id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14724v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14724v3 | A Survey on LLM-Generated Text Detection: Necessity, Methods, and Future Directions | 2023-10-23T09:01:13 | 2024-04-19T09:12:32 | Junchao Wu, Shu Yang, Runzhe Zhan, Yulin Yuan, Derek F. Wong, Lidia S. Chao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The powerful ability to understand, follow, and generate complex language
emerging from large language models (LLMs) makes LLM-generated text flood many
areas of our daily lives at an incredible speed and is widely accepted by
humans. As LLMs continue to expand, there is an imperative need to develop
detectors that can detect LLM-generated text. This is crucial to mitigate
potential misuse of LLMs and safeguard realms like artistic expression and
social networks from harmful influence of LLM-generated content. The
LLM-generated text detection aims to discern if a piece of text was produced by
an LLM, which is essentially a binary classification task. The detector
techniques have witnessed notable advancements recently, propelled by
innovations in watermarking techniques, statistics-based detectors, neural-base
detectors, and human-assisted methods. In this survey, we collate recent
research breakthroughs in this area and underscore the pressing need to bolster
detector research. We also delve into prevalent datasets, elucidating their
limitations and developmental requirements. Furthermore, we analyze various
LLM-generated text detection paradigms, shedding light on challenges like
out-of-distribution problems, potential attacks, real-world data issues and the
lack of effective evaluation framework. Conclusively, we highlight interesting
directions for future research in LLM-generated text detection to advance the
implementation of responsible artificial intelligence (AI). Our aim with this
survey is to provide a clear and comprehensive introduction for newcomers while
also offering seasoned researchers a valuable update in the field of
LLM-generated text detection. The useful resources are publicly available at:
https://github.com/NLP2CT/LLM-generated-Text-Detection. | [
0.0512256697,
0.0632450655,
-0.0229078922,
0.0886968076,
-0.0547994263,
0.0069862604,
0.0039183572,
0.0817234814,
0.0306136273,
-0.0407822207,
-0.0023637402,
-0.0133744553,
-0.0271910951,
0.0397939049,
0.0294092707,
0.0407466069,
0.0180945154,
-0.0101066986,
0.0106133614,
0.0303759798,
0.0172161218,
0.0317059644,
0.0350017622,
0.0263771508,
-0.0394670181,
-0.0003063358,
0.0149008706,
0.0440882705,
0.0141833881,
-0.0244982857,
-0.0063968757,
0.055761341,
0.0186755117,
0.1252967715,
0.0000018522,
-0.0362282507,
-0.0276711453,
-0.0240583457,
-0.0261035282,
-0.0096186614,
0.0636503026,
-0.0338059254,
-0.0509887002,
0.017785307,
-0.0352020524,
0.0429407805,
0.0101527069,
0.0546083003,
0.0278935414,
0.0897269845,
-0.0272009466,
0.0036177367,
0.0698631853,
0.0064818808,
0.0098448778,
0.0118320053,
0.0476145372,
-0.0192666054,
-0.0178529378,
0.0303528141,
0.0226215906,
0.0448386706,
0.0075148703,
-0.0381304324,
-0.0109297894,
-0.0035982279,
0.0003088551,
-0.028550433,
-0.0168991294,
0.0324507616,
-0.0598012432,
-0.0536273196,
0.0540315136,
-0.0243129935,
0.0146426698,
0.0127777224,
-0.0084455507,
0.0605167449,
-0.0184189938,
0.0519822687,
0.0097784018,
-0.0185604095,
0.0312104095,
0.0389151163,
0.0290948916,
0.0398748927,
0.0115532363,
-0.0366699174,
-0.0365127884,
0.0097505804,
-0.0044858535,
-0.0519606285,
0.058843594,
0.0175572187,
0.055258669,
-0.0036708917,
-0.0828702673,
-0.0644640252,
0.024870269,
-0.0474654548,
0.0565361232,
-0.0301768556,
-0.038841594,
0.0448902734,
-0.061551068,
0.0597888269,
-0.057018023,
0.0305845048,
0.007969168,
0.024959594,
0.0124265598,
-0.0309055839,
0.0040085842,
0.0025968049,
-0.0160262547,
-0.0207183417,
-0.0154229114,
0.0248743836,
0.0027548622,
0.0259814113,
-0.038037017,
-0.0205629375,
0.0198464245,
0.0016634968,
0.0201463979,
-0.0392187051,
0.0331180319,
0.0179754999,
-0.0241775475,
-0.0460768901,
-0.0146564366,
0.0910250694,
0.0221965183,
0.0021202788,
0.0150105786,
0.0785484836,
-0.0043028928,
-0.0696118698,
-0.0503568426,
-0.0748915374,
-0.0238063149,
-0.0116089443,
0.0402760915,
-0.0683271512,
-0.0239277408,
-0.042259369,
-0.0129644638,
-0.0629947782,
0.0150831435,
0.0384335592,
-0.0250116028,
0.0436995812,
-0.0488374345,
-0.0014791011,
0.0234619044,
0.0131661836,
0.0037936983,
0.0651800856,
0.0541748926,
0.0902518108,
0.0638074428,
0.030189462,
0.0349857584,
0.0873961374,
0.0129441861,
0.0092772571,
-0.0243126433,
-0.0516305417,
-0.0127402358,
-0.0113325929,
0.0274151973,
0.0523806773,
0.0016386333,
-0.0482397117,
0.0884058103,
0.0670986772,
-0.0211388692,
0.0053271172,
0.0256344937,
0.0475332253,
0.007153288,
0.0330890901,
-0.0053517255,
-0.0266479459,
-0.0498397388,
-0.0558189489,
-0.0096362596,
0.0169899333,
0.0189289693,
-0.0046707145,
-0.0197715852,
-0.026166236,
0.0219049882,
-0.0389195383,
0.0372362807,
0.0278659258,
-0.0300966334,
0.0096986629,
-0.0145720271,
-0.0398726575,
0.0208906718,
-0.0885963887,
0.0581179522,
0.0602115691,
0.0605400652,
-0.0314976051,
0.073778756,
-0.0188968964,
-0.0047980929,
0.0657527298,
-0.0485854112,
0.0068665915,
-0.009543485,
-0.0284686014,
-0.0255397763,
-0.0088288449,
0.0103085516,
0.0135940798,
0.0392972305,
0.0056917816,
0.0112832198,
-0.0022108762,
-0.046445217,
0.036710076,
-0.0109395171,
-0.0293399096,
-0.004379706,
0.007392074,
0.0105365729,
0.0223452672,
-0.0248877127,
-0.0003376322,
0.0403969698,
-0.0478324294,
-0.0310955159,
-0.024064986,
0.0174557362,
-0.0202095732,
0.0327767842,
-0.0267413966,
-0.0117320232,
0.042840112,
-0.0234405007,
-0.0104900207,
0.0050269202,
-0.0519344248,
0.0060947593,
-0.0755981356,
0.0161537416,
-0.0233979411,
0.0468639582,
-0.0306554437,
0.0557798631,
-0.028726574,
-0.0254865196,
0.0157516524,
-0.021782415,
0.0366191044,
-0.0174413063,
-0.0124887694,
-0.0177627914,
-0.0275012515,
0.0134877879,
0.0146626346,
0.0331320986,
-0.0200512875,
-0.0323248506,
-0.040044412,
-0.0056202007,
-0.0244926102,
0.0219903216,
0.0210553333,
-0.0391961485,
-0.0246453043,
-0.0032673827,
-0.0219248328,
-0.020977214,
0.0591388233,
0.001425649,
0.047753647,
-0.0372467041,
-0.0103105968,
-0.0109152636,
-0.0025566409,
-0.0185231175,
0.0429783165,
0.0372881852,
-0.0731114745,
-0.0615468584,
0.0339459628,
-0.0031571917,
0.009469673,
-0.0046693324,
-0.0175263491,
-0.0061129411,
-0.0200090297,
0.0019741755,
0.0826083422,
0.0288193692,
0.0081156157,
0.0275549982,
0.0360693112,
-0.0246397164,
-0.0349101312,
-0.0149082579,
0.027321104,
-0.0131004658,
-0.0577681772,
0.0356601067,
0.0383968353,
-0.0003769117,
0.0098422691,
-0.0008712453,
0.031233741,
-0.0088528562,
-0.0386426412,
-0.0082795573,
-0.0378825255,
-0.028034512,
0.0537398346,
-0.0253948737,
-0.0820163265,
0.016440399,
-0.0397904068,
0.0232875589,
0.0132104112,
-0.0389011838,
-0.0320812985,
0.0196238309,
0.0173260458,
0.0409513228,
-0.0083424086,
-0.0301979687,
-0.0245350339,
0.0095415693,
0.0099610873,
-0.0400909409,
0.0042229472,
-0.0249345191,
0.0052603376,
-0.0024477881,
-0.0019828782,
-0.0633394197,
-0.0449744873,
-0.004301284,
-0.0104951654,
0.0256273057,
-0.0373497978,
-0.0002651404,
0.0043804278,
-0.0023495087,
0.0313920267,
-0.0227034613,
0.0132071907,
-0.0462922342,
0.1057640836,
0.0388344191,
-0.0592729934,
0.0393413603,
-0.0205325894,
-0.0266554505,
0.0850131586,
-0.0177680794,
0.0317078903,
0.0052607898,
-0.0053928033,
0.0204576589,
0.0394150019,
0.0089228675,
0.0023139326,
0.0191518497,
-0.0416409783,
-0.0088094817,
0.0800532252,
0.0296231695,
-0.034419056,
-0.0230651125,
-0.0065673534,
-0.0140381688,
0.0027040597,
-0.0366784893,
-0.087625578,
-0.019105114,
0.0246804617,
-0.0032908001,
-0.0585899986,
0.0005934145,
-0.0069795377,
-0.0762692615,
0.0277471691,
0.0159669407,
0.0213028435,
-0.0070704035,
-0.0212428309,
-0.0081187803,
0.0420976877,
-0.0244147927,
-0.0414751619,
0.0115745431,
-0.0257604551,
-0.0020585663,
-0.0232115611,
-0.0456103869,
-0.0182194803,
-0.0393774807,
0.0140379854,
0.0801704302,
0.0759024173,
-0.0234953761,
-0.0146120097,
0.0334831253,
-0.0044310871,
-0.0052528479,
-0.0103149042,
0.0600388348,
-0.0229497477,
-0.0144077055,
-0.0187361706,
0.0420835391,
-0.0135627855,
-0.0180424266,
0.0218713954,
0.0465236455,
-0.0080013685,
-0.0497139022,
-0.0410827734,
0.0020372809,
0.0426288322,
0.0647818595,
0.038047187,
-0.0378453881,
-0.0379861929,
-0.030201463,
0.0321068987,
-0.0480114333,
-0.0381211452,
-0.0110685863,
-0.000076417,
-0.0187676474,
-0.0739842951,
0.039198298,
-0.0323679708,
-0.0250455365,
0.0193102602,
0.0076438994,
0.0043459027,
-0.0312318336,
-0.0596446693,
-0.0296462495,
-0.0443242826,
0.0294315219,
-0.0583751835,
0.013457654,
-0.0041261674,
-0.0504704006,
-0.0099880947,
0.0470475182,
-0.1259106696,
-0.0419379771,
0.002594152,
-0.0025611606,
0.022574883,
-0.000255067,
-0.0287401937,
-0.0527163334,
0.0883607417,
0.0637443215,
-0.0180755351,
0.0221343823,
0.0207736995,
-0.0059015774,
-0.0254377425,
0.025733294,
-0.0337666944,
0.0251806211,
0.0549241267,
-0.0363392904,
-0.0465908423,
-0.0156383552,
-0.0026133044,
0.0288704168,
0.0115181105,
-0.0287409369,
-0.0041950378,
-0.0284392275,
-0.0225013383,
-0.0136322007,
-0.003919777,
-0.0458359905,
0.0347987413,
0.027146602,
-0.0093978159,
-0.006295199,
0.0240972843,
-0.0050928099,
0.0402782746,
-0.0360618792,
0.0136867436,
-0.0089876475,
0.0464683175,
0.0089811366,
0.0082993209,
0.0283613466,
0.0800823942,
-0.014005282,
0.0331453346,
0.0149442917,
0.0395983011,
0.0089474851,
-0.0264991112,
-0.0102161588,
0.0567234457,
-0.0582900047,
-0.0049789669,
-0.0338675044,
0.0386006422,
0.0664495304,
-0.0028297303,
0.0479275919,
-0.055350706,
-0.0186895505,
-0.0147918155,
0.0167275202,
-0.022654241,
-0.0499080308,
-0.0479565114,
-0.002177201,
-0.0403303914,
0.0211222544,
0.0601934344,
0.0456179306,
0.0219900217,
-0.0031086458,
-0.0515412278,
-0.0212699138,
-0.0092990929,
0.0345014706,
-0.0078066657,
-0.0199867338,
0.0338439718,
-0.0381228365,
-0.0664939359,
0.0440903977,
-0.0043576583,
0.0178723205,
-0.0051131705,
-0.0350928158,
0.0437639281,
-0.0026965791,
0.0201096255,
-0.0347364061,
0.0124545796,
0.0075429282,
-0.0357108489,
-0.008082943,
-5.458858747e-33,
0.0112036373,
-0.0826448724,
-0.0354377143,
-0.0023750607,
0.0236078035,
0.0408648215,
-0.0079088854,
-0.0519583896,
0.0233791918,
-0.0217854921,
-0.0109035689,
0.0324432105,
-0.0014485756,
0.01335561,
-0.0260414854,
-0.0204217229,
0.0382300168,
-0.020065289,
-0.0332465209,
0.0103314128,
0.0638961121,
0.0009897833,
0.026518438,
-0.0858484209,
0.0041498505,
-0.0255161468,
-0.0425163992,
0.0020096202,
-0.0421975777,
0.0725094453,
-0.0233008843,
0.0243974365,
0.0269432552,
0.0249699056,
-0.0209668726,
0.0623844489,
-0.0265922807,
0.012464554,
-0.036873512,
0.0144076189,
-0.0009822738,
-0.0689419657,
0.0599484593,
-0.0334673561,
-0.0295638144,
0.0283231568,
0.0336252972,
-0.0300835352,
0.0137208365,
-0.0500671975,
-0.0583152212,
0.0162304789,
0.0135866227,
0.0057459092,
0.0544239134,
0.0085215243,
0.0424955636,
0.0367276333,
-0.0969868079,
0.0246443711,
0.0030961458,
-0.0088914325,
0.0423147455,
0.0148093589,
-0.0091573494,
0.0544902347,
0.0148536116,
0.0031553661,
-0.0173229445,
-0.022171637,
0.0292386543,
0.0161422491,
0.0687267259,
0.0404294915,
0.0269448757,
-0.0189988948,
-0.04051961,
0.0257715788,
0.0112889018,
-0.021964604,
0.0503760166,
-0.0114047499,
-0.0513709001,
-0.0097782826,
-0.0104809674,
-0.0791153237,
-0.0245355796,
-0.0030784616,
0.0345281996,
0.0318522379,
-0.0352228694,
-0.0187505409,
0.0117112854,
-0.0616988055,
-0.0161238667,
-0.0109296655,
-0.0207068846,
0.0265035816,
0.0226180777,
0.0365202762,
-0.0222707093,
-0.0152800009,
0.050217893,
-0.0442101583,
0.019588938,
-0.0072034467,
0.0571555682,
0.036020454,
-0.0535003059,
0.0163504668,
-0.0179548562,
0.0279784445,
0.0463117622,
0.0219048299,
0.0200874843,
-0.0340016335,
0.0110124592,
-0.0110269543,
0.0510960743,
0.0260858834,
-0.0167106986,
-0.0124179665,
-0.0575503483,
0.0124978544,
-0.0316692777,
-0.0041055242,
-0.0184944496,
0.0242296439,
0.0452192202,
-0.062092416,
0.0167955756,
-0.0227676649,
2.454e-7,
0.0266526714,
0.025002351,
0.0403938517,
0.0155873792,
0.027853474,
0.0313990712,
-0.0052911304,
0.0171406474,
-0.0409954786,
-0.0179703236,
-0.0206260048,
0.0131813055,
0.061532259,
-0.0084244041,
-0.0647938102,
0.040174257,
-0.0477777161,
0.0092801945,
-0.0799060762,
0.0098248105,
0.0573864318,
0.0717729479,
0.0165616516,
-0.0590921789,
0.01438866,
-0.0715432987,
0.033169426,
-0.0252207629,
0.0239216331,
-0.0217992254,
0.0404820666,
-0.0026647253,
0.0089982711,
0.0036857163,
-0.0024314593,
0.0107136313,
0.016606437,
0.0484857745,
0.0211479831,
0.0392803364,
-0.0309070237,
-0.0292421486,
-0.0069715814,
-0.0345335267,
0.0650839955,
0.0455826446,
-0.0137414308,
-0.0540662073,
0.0049495753,
-0.0718053877,
0.0201470908,
-0.0369177982,
-0.0167498756,
0.0160673466,
0.0127229728,
0.0198232234,
-0.0081523973,
-0.0733305886,
-0.0157093517,
-0.0541293621,
-0.0420310609,
-0.0024856231,
-0.0748701617,
0.0381586142,
0.0144128129,
-0.0612220876,
0.0199821368,
2.704062205e-34,
-0.0072788061,
-0.0314733796,
-0.0182549935,
0.0335569419,
0.0282096192,
0.0288842469,
-0.0403896421,
0.0087378845,
-0.0174223483,
-0.0561934598,
0.0293171406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14709v1 | Once Upon a $\textit{Time}$ in $\textit{Graph}$: Relative-Time Pretraining for Complex Temporal Reasoning | 2023-10-23T08:49:00 | 2023-10-23T08:49:00 | Sen Yang, Xin Li, Lidong Bing, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our physical world is constantly evolving over time, rendering challenges for
pre-trained language models to understand and reason over the temporal contexts
of texts. Existing work focuses on strengthening the direct association between
a piece of text and its time-stamp. However, the knowledge-time association is
usually insufficient for the downstream tasks that require reasoning over
temporal dependencies between knowledge. In this work, we make use of the
underlying nature of time, all temporally-scoped sentences are strung together
through a one-dimensional time axis, and suggest creating a graph structure
based on the relative placements of events along the time axis. Inspired by the
graph view, we propose RemeMo ($\underline{Re}$lative Ti$\underline{me}$
$\underline{Mo}$deling), which explicitly connects all temporally-scoped facts
by modeling the time relations between any two sentences. Experimental results
show that RemeMo outperforms the baseline T5 on multiple temporal question
answering datasets under various settings. Further analysis suggests that
RemeMo is especially good at modeling long-range complex temporal dependencies.
We release our code and pre-trained checkpoints at
$\href{https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/RemeMo}{\text{this url}}$. | [
0.0075911102,
0.0478649475,
-0.0053194063,
0.0044842688,
-0.0240068529,
-0.0019759678,
-0.0044283289,
0.0114540663,
0.0183631554,
-0.0465254597,
0.0089909034,
0.0029383379,
-0.0074154665,
0.0177554321,
-0.0305237714,
-0.075255923,
0.0671743453,
0.0030903025,
0.0046617254,
0.0068855858,
0.0018943308,
-0.0025035946,
-0.0423410758,
0.0002659296,
-0.0280150529,
-0.0506240092,
-0.0228055641,
-0.0248193201,
0.0530250482,
-0.0378875211,
0.0036814816,
0.0397534594,
0.0241137687,
0.0134093128,
0.0000018986,
-0.0108043579,
-0.0328749754,
-0.0365684181,
-0.0458386578,
0.0348016284,
-0.0528619476,
0.0030630503,
0.0387255885,
-0.0140691409,
-0.0715985,
-0.0333973207,
0.000355326,
0.0430682078,
0.045716662,
0.0851853266,
-0.0006776093,
-0.0009256433,
-0.0002597785,
-0.0222729761,
0.0158145484,
-0.0525195189,
-0.0127284192,
0.0333505757,
0.0452585518,
0.0241085738,
-0.0256773606,
0.0241945256,
0.0457035489,
0.007923713,
0.0547722988,
0.0604318045,
0.006902284,
0.0588778108,
-0.0215546321,
0.0877032727,
0.0416510217,
-0.0596956089,
-0.0044565932,
0.0138721187,
-0.0179320239,
-0.0051736468,
-0.0616767295,
-0.0418653637,
0.0250412691,
0.0266188737,
0.0111526148,
0.0260409042,
0.0385579579,
0.0240478218,
-0.0091728289,
0.0810763463,
-0.0012672438,
-0.0117995581,
-0.0315121226,
0.0161898173,
0.0099333478,
-0.0408155024,
-0.012755096,
0.088760823,
-0.0056068501,
-0.0014547091,
-0.0234022252,
0.0303569958,
-0.0026375351,
-0.0285032652,
-0.004195014,
0.0159959476,
0.000450833,
0.0530561432,
-0.0027804018,
0.0561916679,
-0.0427975021,
-0.0189858004,
-0.0391680934,
-0.0143166725,
-0.0530045703,
-0.0201934446,
-0.0283766389,
0.0187616237,
-0.0074695121,
0.0000168471,
-0.0478235185,
0.0320497081,
-0.0107130846,
-0.0292867795,
-0.0194555912,
0.0221499726,
-0.0052903094,
-0.0270703193,
-0.0526263639,
0.0426517092,
-0.0716643929,
0.01595347,
-0.065120846,
-0.035768196,
-0.0428472273,
-0.0022283953,
0.0188510474,
-0.050999362,
-0.0146447048,
0.0378321074,
-0.0263439342,
-0.0040569897,
-0.0355342589,
-0.0516867526,
-0.0241048317,
-0.0126449578,
0.0144014573,
-0.0519440845,
0.0254383106,
0.0070770611,
-0.0127465995,
0.0060371896,
0.0118719265,
-0.0027237034,
-0.0332418382,
0.0544681773,
0.0367973708,
0.0115036052,
-0.016920194,
0.003285957,
0.0419666953,
0.0219442397,
0.0245209299,
-0.038771309,
0.0286427122,
0.0171402041,
-0.036819756,
0.0158727355,
0.0509236194,
-0.0240470357,
-0.0091277659,
0.0257458892,
-0.0178080574,
0.0187601,
0.015825253,
0.0096116168,
-0.0272447839,
-0.0457283854,
0.0332141705,
-0.0168644004,
0.010153288,
-0.0268255323,
0.0506958365,
-0.0301046912,
0.0202453248,
-0.0027340485,
-0.0344341584,
0.0375749506,
-0.0308581851,
0.0165206678,
-0.0500594527,
0.0006184916,
-0.0341972485,
-0.0168891624,
0.0040656682,
0.0113078067,
0.0036971271,
-0.0108857127,
0.0476071835,
0.0179432221,
-0.0193775687,
0.0601770431,
0.0030855606,
0.018920498,
0.0090839909,
0.0321212783,
0.0107630426,
0.0496083125,
0.0286042951,
-0.0414118581,
-0.054794006,
0.0006401508,
0.0578337982,
-0.0032911054,
0.0669714808,
-0.0266482569,
-0.0120753031,
-0.0146274539,
-0.0295243636,
-0.0373913795,
0.0004400839,
0.0050496613,
0.0634052455,
0.0451319069,
0.0100496942,
-0.0292881913,
0.050271675,
0.0202908274,
-0.0001789519,
-0.0179153141,
-0.0325216912,
0.0245866291,
0.008582579,
0.0233033244,
0.0014980796,
0.0214967541,
0.0633629858,
-0.0320628211,
-0.0127246408,
0.0647293255,
-0.0767347142,
-0.0712090433,
0.0566625856,
-0.0054003289,
-0.0500024147,
0.0222524237,
-0.0422230959,
-0.0451974124,
0.0531939939,
0.01399564,
0.0512305982,
-0.0168909896,
-0.0055612205,
0.0260476898,
0.023989385,
-0.0499768183,
0.0950988233,
0.0021003268,
0.0182497501,
0.0096498998,
-0.0007425983,
0.0228949711,
-0.0233914927,
0.0158761013,
0.0057605742,
0.0174530074,
-0.0287935678,
0.0107838903,
-0.0068373219,
-0.0750450268,
0.0126299933,
-0.0984261185,
0.0107222488,
-0.0099071767,
0.0163147692,
0.0213586912,
-0.0092731575,
0.0096574165,
-0.0549454987,
-0.0042403317,
-0.0002180775,
0.0007411919,
0.0104600647,
0.074907355,
-0.0009203436,
-0.0072201029,
-0.0063899755,
-0.0303266943,
-0.0708823353,
0.0736164823,
0.0134379566,
-0.0319937952,
0.0305388793,
-0.0136547564,
-0.0401618369,
0.0306570958,
-0.0080894651,
0.0113521498,
0.0277336054,
-0.0145220393,
0.0666302666,
0.0252481308,
-0.0183373746,
0.047329627,
0.0344715267,
-0.047881484,
-0.0345600694,
0.0524139553,
-0.0322328843,
0.0296236258,
-0.0223267823,
-0.0018805854,
-0.0338654891,
0.0522090569,
-0.0137211243,
-0.0178682543,
-0.0427015759,
0.0056264037,
-0.0194699224,
0.0423984863,
-0.0017327113,
-0.0020855442,
-0.0114358403,
-0.0028261282,
-0.0577792488,
-0.0234212242,
0.0698791221,
0.018479256,
-0.0130639663,
-0.0173405744,
-0.0155374408,
-0.0655889735,
0.1109516546,
0.0266367756,
-0.036698252,
0.011227211,
-0.0262192152,
-0.0459766351,
-0.0100565627,
0.0231069494,
-0.0070380587,
0.0023939186,
-0.0445480496,
0.0303069949,
-0.0033103421,
-0.0222986545,
-0.0306384303,
-0.0624939874,
-0.0406144857,
0.0043073101,
-0.0929896161,
0.0019388017,
-0.0110237738,
-0.0158480853,
-0.0257659238,
0.0000334796,
-0.0425456949,
0.0022948803,
-0.0116180908,
0.0853575468,
0.045653794,
0.019174099,
-0.016641112,
-0.0186727196,
0.0240312703,
0.0102891596,
0.0674053803,
-0.0399986431,
-0.0550117642,
0.0231154598,
-0.0218586735,
-0.0277733393,
-0.027800262,
-0.0072870143,
0.0551533662,
-0.0570018627,
-0.0009823928,
0.0847233012,
0.0412042513,
0.0108640436,
0.0076178592,
0.0230473932,
0.0262450334,
0.0156758446,
0.0029422557,
-0.0591863506,
-0.0387690403,
-0.0200124588,
-0.0448895805,
-0.0034441419,
-0.0525224246,
-0.0320352763,
-0.076679118,
-0.0199512038,
0.0072629289,
-0.0129862763,
0.0105985273,
-0.0286549907,
-0.0126382615,
0.0182546657,
-0.0210457463,
-0.0009132217,
-0.015491683,
0.0270708781,
0.0304778907,
-0.0352248065,
-0.0157661662,
0.0591999516,
0.0191032402,
0.0385612398,
-0.0237102062,
0.0509395562,
-0.0275592543,
-0.0058358461,
0.0277446806,
0.0018395206,
0.009418021,
-0.0208154805,
0.0177212395,
0.0091506112,
-0.0268412679,
-0.0329391547,
0.0103882579,
-0.0231916681,
-0.0452424996,
-0.0188018251,
0.1434985101,
-0.027466882,
-0.0087143062,
-0.0280132256,
0.0112776877,
-0.0279664584,
0.0523953177,
0.0073799365,
0.0177929327,
-0.086384818,
0.0349990502,
-0.0039512138,
-0.0798413828,
-0.0198938958,
0.0025120359,
-0.0084069185,
0.0152422274,
-0.0736776367,
-0.0620069765,
-0.0015864713,
0.0381554812,
-0.029555751,
-0.0075565125,
-0.0020707354,
-0.0132883564,
-0.0915954635,
0.0671693236,
-0.0355624445,
0.021507252,
-0.0086196996,
-0.0036501405,
0.0193849634,
0.0192390978,
-0.0125218136,
0.0460225455,
-0.0907789692,
-0.0507246368,
-0.0166164357,
-0.0022351788,
0.0214644112,
0.087581113,
-0.018811563,
0.0113221742,
0.0583136193,
-0.0112478249,
-0.0259451978,
0.0150725935,
0.0452386364,
-0.0010825901,
0.0028118466,
0.0314243585,
-0.0685660318,
-0.0109721618,
0.0054936665,
0.0398912244,
-0.032447096,
-0.0117021473,
0.0090192454,
-0.0324991494,
0.0361266993,
0.0623783842,
-0.0068465467,
-0.0161784235,
-0.0040337578,
-0.050119888,
0.0041495017,
-0.001588062,
0.006139297,
0.026729444,
-0.0079593631,
-0.0284362938,
0.0035521653,
0.0297323596,
0.0197782889,
0.0182549972,
-0.0268398616,
0.0321277045,
-0.0050993045,
-0.0111997705,
0.0048501575,
-0.0157937296,
0.0119365072,
-0.009458309,
0.0223422591,
0.0010936682,
0.02454824,
0.035085652,
0.0157847572,
-0.0659504011,
-0.0419898592,
-0.1223658323,
-0.0069930167,
0.0270015597,
-0.0318065323,
0.0750622675,
-0.0359574631,
0.0694386736,
-0.0165161081,
-0.0007376111,
0.0031186962,
0.044071462,
0.0285943057,
-0.007536266,
0.039016109,
0.0193112418,
-0.0049520796,
0.0722149014,
0.0753350779,
0.0026144432,
0.0652551726,
0.0332430117,
-0.0310285687,
-0.0051318491,
-0.0156909227,
-0.0394706614,
-0.0131904157,
-0.0247716848,
0.0065047909,
-0.0524623208,
-0.0561892688,
0.0623268709,
0.0058655939,
-0.0442093648,
0.0172147341,
0.0118874433,
0.0194569007,
0.048392199,
-0.0593707785,
-0.0154624125,
0.0737062544,
0.0331579782,
-0.0343009792,
-0.0563849993,
-6.369954663e-33,
-0.0198514387,
-0.0396190546,
0.0255407281,
-0.0088513559,
-0.0619255789,
0.0503571182,
-0.0338340066,
-0.0022430313,
-0.0535962395,
0.0221572462,
-0.005134983,
0.0430674553,
0.0148393298,
-0.0011262113,
-0.0075841108,
-0.01386273,
0.0199622009,
-0.0191850178,
0.0108311381,
0.0167642571,
0.0430095494,
0.0410586856,
0.0447569788,
-0.0224692132,
0.0187353734,
-0.0037696492,
0.0119956555,
0.0678915307,
-0.0004166442,
0.0561751127,
-0.0116976555,
0.0115508046,
0.0514446534,
-0.025311945,
-0.0201828796,
0.0332054496,
-0.165034011,
-0.100793846,
0.0046200603,
0.0241470207,
-0.0383943021,
-0.0257990956,
0.0083903428,
-0.0048385719,
0.0469563976,
-0.036507301,
0.0330555476,
-0.0000264629,
-0.0223300941,
-0.0126888854,
-0.0054763095,
0.0411070623,
-0.0481118336,
-0.0216902811,
-0.0041247755,
0.0390055738,
0.024291154,
-0.0052904733,
-0.0356203876,
0.0011513956,
-0.0212506521,
-0.0053660912,
-0.0025257571,
0.0001323628,
-0.0022165952,
0.049865678,
0.0114530073,
-0.0162000209,
-0.0360708088,
0.0423944928,
0.0142553244,
-0.0089708921,
0.0101149483,
-0.002745071,
0.0082908962,
0.0078895576,
-0.0928309038,
0.0032738156,
0.0510445535,
0.0534289517,
-0.0226713941,
0.0116784489,
-0.0057391524,
-0.000986446,
-0.0082129324,
0.0085445745,
-0.0242035668,
-0.002631308,
0.0076671494,
0.0148301385,
0.0324778557,
0.0170494299,
0.0176000334,
-0.0362461954,
-0.0033602428,
0.0813562572,
-0.0075060078,
0.0193497874,
0.0105693592,
0.0380826294,
-0.0118128816,
0.0144052878,
0.0178630482,
-0.0285031535,
0.0160409845,
-0.0216536522,
0.0267135501,
0.0245687179,
-0.0232678279,
-0.0303650945,
-0.0088337883,
-0.032920789,
-0.0120404931,
-0.0161125977,
0.052630201,
0.0386950821,
-0.0129947448,
0.0630158037,
0.0404461324,
0.0463890061,
-0.0005087696,
0.018680539,
0.0231197085,
0.030545719,
0.0030269434,
-0.0310496744,
-0.0190831684,
0.0629484728,
-0.0095067192,
-0.0486362465,
-0.0163434278,
0.0058000744,
2.626e-7,
0.0665288493,
0.0220811311,
0.0671791136,
0.0536951572,
0.0317271389,
-0.0050425963,
-0.0159342736,
-0.0002594691,
-0.0439388864,
0.0250897408,
0.0453681797,
0.0275334772,
0.0432747863,
0.0348974355,
-0.0212059747,
-0.0195077695,
-0.0678789988,
-0.0462816432,
-0.0576884747,
-0.0329943895,
0.0584284514,
0.0697050765,
0.0783657283,
0.0182673335,
-0.0495477058,
-0.0612875521,
0.0773968846,
0.0000823833,
-0.0172533561,
0.0049164779,
0.0395513289,
-0.0355586708,
-0.0188063532,
0.0253413785,
-0.0187340956,
0.033892937,
-0.0365424044,
0.0404668972,
-0.0141034406,
-0.0433036722,
-0.030224245,
-0.0553402267,
-0.019224219,
-0.0161006209,
0.1018803567,
-0.0367686823,
-0.0390776657,
0.007893621,
-0.0319097452,
0.0164917838,
0.0312756598,
0.0252306182,
-0.0281955097,
0.010741964,
0.0109229488,
0.0077950549,
-0.0136943981,
-0.113836579,
-0.0533754453,
0.059518829,
-0.0226718318,
0.0087550636,
-0.0058008768,
-0.0315919854,
0.0484176949,
-0.0125340167,
-0.0054182033,
2.203090849e-34,
0.0163194612,
-0.0111478325,
-0.0137094939,
0.0106972102,
0.0293895863,
-0.0520812273,
-0.0115050254,
-0.0157771762,
0.0591857992,
-0.071660988,
-0.0156269055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14708v1 | Strong and Efficient Baselines for Open Domain Conversational Question Answering | 2023-10-23T08:48:14 | 2023-10-23T08:48:14 | Andrei C. Coman, Gianni Barlacchi, Adrià de Gispert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unlike the Open Domain Question Answering (ODQA) setting, the conversational
(ODConvQA) domain has received limited attention when it comes to reevaluating
baselines for both efficiency and effectiveness. In this paper, we study the
State-of-the-Art (SotA) Dense Passage Retrieval (DPR) retriever and
Fusion-in-Decoder (FiD) reader pipeline, and show that it significantly
underperforms when applied to ODConvQA tasks due to various limitations. We
then propose and evaluate strong yet simple and efficient baselines, by
introducing a fast reranking component between the retriever and the reader,
and by performing targeted finetuning steps. Experiments on two ODConvQA tasks,
namely TopiOCQA and OR-QuAC, show that our method improves the SotA results,
while reducing reader's latency by 60%. Finally, we provide new and valuable
insights into the development of challenging baselines that serve as a
reference for future, more intricate approaches, including those that leverage
Large Language Models (LLMs). | [
0.0258543938,
0.0676150098,
0.0045100553,
0.0341471247,
-0.0193901416,
-0.0030055626,
0.0234582573,
-0.0269238558,
0.0034129741,
-0.028035393,
-0.0055534211,
-0.0619021058,
-0.000798857,
0.0724214241,
-0.0304393917,
-0.0025502879,
0.0140782343,
-0.0327461772,
0.0169469584,
-0.01003931,
-0.0062076855,
0.0174865611,
-0.022457229,
0.0167315099,
0.0692678243,
-0.0382935591,
-0.0203276575,
0.0034635016,
0.0095985234,
-0.0163915791,
0.0518836603,
0.0318123028,
0.0332751758,
0.021820331,
0.0000018909,
-0.0267778598,
-0.0410947055,
0.0105450153,
-0.0437431149,
0.0000778963,
-0.0150952302,
0.0194142982,
0.0130090658,
0.0328859463,
-0.0461595394,
-0.0102221379,
0.007305244,
0.0344553441,
0.0563885756,
0.0542272963,
0.0062419758,
-0.0110394107,
0.0252972916,
-0.0224795155,
-0.0379006118,
-0.0885533541,
0.014311498,
0.0312625393,
0.006202748,
0.0563500337,
-0.012673893,
0.0212266967,
0.0141544836,
0.0064370357,
0.0089931572,
0.039781712,
-0.0351023152,
0.0401983783,
-0.0066974494,
0.0988262594,
0.002826791,
0.0081204632,
-0.0074327183,
0.0304327272,
-0.017413713,
-0.0370482169,
-0.0630081818,
0.0106216008,
-0.0273216646,
0.0097891875,
-0.0395204313,
0.0308792312,
0.008955528,
0.0347026102,
-0.0613362938,
0.0142500149,
0.0033318072,
-0.0268222503,
0.0196333248,
0.0163825396,
-0.0434233434,
-0.0333897993,
0.0070131323,
0.0284358878,
-0.034207385,
0.0170971379,
0.0000633931,
-0.0017834289,
-0.006973098,
-0.0203796532,
0.0256820023,
0.0494286269,
-0.0154485442,
0.0505516045,
-0.0056355982,
0.0622215569,
-0.0015094551,
-0.0170162246,
-0.0462399349,
-0.0272490401,
-0.0113021173,
-0.0298816413,
-0.0477549993,
0.0397423431,
-0.1037196368,
-0.0312572904,
0.0130995065,
0.0276421253,
0.0503503755,
-0.0367463119,
0.0002939923,
0.0265787933,
-0.0176743511,
-0.004596951,
-0.007438703,
0.0692832768,
-0.0339619964,
0.0140814362,
0.0041741901,
-0.0804349631,
-0.0411215238,
-0.0136830239,
-0.0020751143,
-0.027106056,
-0.0120509565,
0.0227362849,
-0.0419016257,
-0.0744567811,
0.0153865125,
0.0083459634,
-0.008998991,
-0.0606651418,
-0.0295261815,
-0.0515215434,
0.0418527834,
0.0350602753,
0.0008993145,
-0.0314730108,
0.0141918538,
0.0661125332,
-0.0134564927,
0.0364888273,
0.0165146794,
0.0070411596,
0.0189983416,
0.0250961054,
-0.0028392093,
0.0760179237,
0.0180712417,
-0.0046966113,
0.044158306,
0.0050260294,
-0.0231241323,
0.0203540009,
0.0130039742,
-0.011745614,
0.0214940254,
0.039367009,
0.0028617287,
0.0134558138,
0.0495471135,
0.0212276373,
-0.0607511774,
-0.0172721874,
0.0475779064,
0.0697498918,
0.0151689462,
0.008800461,
-0.0062049665,
0.0410216972,
0.0058982745,
0.0187526941,
-0.019654192,
0.0225933902,
-0.0004728772,
0.0038087249,
0.0446646959,
0.0426200144,
-0.0245672446,
-0.0138958162,
-0.0001898727,
0.0182390977,
-0.0280242953,
0.0249599516,
0.0306540541,
0.0157060865,
-0.0615074635,
0.044081077,
0.0181344803,
-0.0598617643,
-0.0240096338,
0.0085925823,
-0.0014935861,
0.0460696071,
0.0726087466,
0.0088143572,
-0.0241093375,
-0.0078395056,
0.0183586013,
0.0142559586,
0.0322292745,
-0.011837584,
0.0326739773,
-0.0693568587,
-0.0140837859,
0.0014133741,
-0.0066928691,
0.0269791428,
0.0481793135,
0.0186988078,
0.0126259411,
-0.0569243655,
0.0021765977,
0.0120414523,
-0.0586990267,
-0.0155339511,
0.02622509,
-0.0132147772,
0.0043492178,
0.0270720515,
-0.0097467806,
0.0192417502,
0.0381011441,
-0.0380228385,
-0.0273702573,
-0.0014572056,
-0.0793065801,
-0.0349626951,
0.0063081961,
0.0358401649,
0.0020456824,
0.0553852431,
-0.019410938,
-0.024333274,
-0.0055043162,
-0.042343732,
-0.0063124266,
-0.0449388102,
0.0016307863,
0.0355598517,
0.0127312997,
-0.0551354475,
0.0558204725,
0.0022265378,
0.0518044196,
0.0371642113,
0.0055906214,
0.0066354265,
-0.0452027023,
-0.0184780471,
0.0041072457,
-0.0373887047,
0.0158921685,
0.0064844247,
-0.0090682665,
-0.0357169285,
-0.0219812114,
-0.094237037,
0.0441866815,
-0.0139856562,
0.0325305648,
0.0158836804,
0.0367442295,
-0.0125802448,
-0.0209534168,
-0.0340284668,
-0.029841261,
0.0356940068,
0.0401629098,
0.003048457,
0.0432719328,
-0.0080723632,
-0.0313448645,
-0.0042162673,
0.0119647058,
0.0586088598,
-0.0485143326,
-0.001310637,
-0.0362133831,
0.0001623426,
-0.01230314,
0.0500739738,
-0.0302465707,
-0.0357364602,
-0.009354244,
-0.0077420352,
0.0473228507,
0.0778529719,
0.0183894709,
0.0173004679,
0.0071682758,
-0.0327901877,
-0.0720318928,
0.0398174636,
-0.026970692,
-0.0450972095,
-0.0206051171,
0.0060106022,
-0.0052584577,
0.0364667475,
-0.0005626013,
0.0191076677,
-0.0294393934,
-0.0063347099,
0.0013734767,
-0.009131371,
-0.0651481524,
0.0058280844,
-0.0318392478,
0.03780213,
-0.0350946076,
-0.0081193876,
0.0456538424,
-0.0298698861,
-0.042432081,
-0.0824018121,
0.0019416675,
-0.0673627332,
0.051253926,
-0.0385046825,
-0.0015513396,
-0.0193113461,
-0.0575467534,
-0.0232595187,
0.0201165639,
-0.0065874406,
-0.0729001835,
0.0357159637,
-0.0229553524,
0.0169536229,
-0.0259817056,
-0.0627561286,
-0.0624846481,
-0.0252737198,
-0.0256875306,
0.0207301211,
-0.0221398696,
-0.0079378253,
-0.0302194469,
0.0337330736,
-0.0099080866,
0.0484291501,
-0.036464259,
0.0212377422,
-0.0201276466,
0.104310073,
0.0501385517,
0.0242748801,
0.0158076063,
-0.0004975026,
0.0764408335,
0.0936453119,
0.0146622248,
-0.0204810351,
-0.0134925833,
-0.0118211145,
0.042942524,
-0.0116124237,
0.0085172318,
0.0039687436,
0.0628872141,
-0.0429858714,
-0.0601106286,
0.102156952,
0.0280932263,
-0.0277768858,
-0.038765613,
-0.0321568549,
0.046829626,
-0.0010492608,
0.0189738795,
-0.0792913437,
-0.0420951582,
0.0053969473,
0.0705463067,
0.0143583836,
-0.0300291926,
-0.0206656381,
-0.1182771325,
0.0226188172,
-0.0062647737,
-0.0380691923,
-0.0209829956,
-0.0614804365,
0.0116670234,
0.0058491169,
0.0084041962,
0.0480907448,
0.0017656687,
0.0039750203,
0.0032827589,
0.0370596983,
-0.0103739109,
0.0361546129,
-0.0274249241,
0.0140148317,
0.0674847662,
0.032121636,
0.0450242162,
0.0002488633,
0.0327875465,
-0.1202193573,
-0.0116515672,
0.0310698207,
0.0444582403,
-0.0228003748,
0.003408144,
-0.0507115871,
0.0315678678,
-0.0202429537,
-0.0051546544,
-0.0350628644,
0.0343420543,
0.0110846683,
0.0122350091,
-0.0188867152,
0.0384339392,
0.0062811272,
0.0810319856,
0.0078980336,
-0.0113491658,
-0.0603717789,
0.0073376368,
0.0293304902,
-0.0519571975,
-0.0215616785,
0.0159291867,
0.0473773442,
0.0131135313,
-0.0649580806,
-0.0336148925,
0.0013540661,
0.0244407542,
-0.0307737533,
0.0339868665,
-0.0155074932,
0.0143356211,
-0.0434244163,
0.0554948822,
-0.0460564382,
0.0194148961,
-0.0715272278,
0.0209743455,
0.0389229283,
-0.0119371992,
-0.0270340834,
0.0458405018,
-0.0718996301,
-0.0489726886,
-0.011915016,
0.006878267,
0.0195426326,
0.004580053,
-0.0127078192,
-0.0215598792,
0.0200125352,
0.0076090819,
-0.0573136546,
0.0383541808,
0.0106999939,
-0.003995778,
-0.0381379016,
0.0407146513,
-0.0429111496,
-0.0116599379,
-0.033427503,
0.0693390667,
0.0076678204,
-0.1015062556,
-0.001740032,
-0.0212614499,
0.0310337637,
0.0532411747,
0.0190094188,
-0.0095520485,
0.066802077,
-0.0178025961,
0.0018995678,
-0.0229075197,
0.0068589938,
0.0222119987,
-0.0377789699,
0.0002585904,
0.0338223316,
0.0144397765,
0.0655476227,
-0.0528194197,
-0.0162248053,
0.0316211134,
-0.0261996128,
0.0178342666,
-0.0176485293,
-0.040277075,
-0.0010389941,
-0.0053000832,
0.0740341544,
-0.0076686922,
0.0645795017,
0.0187872574,
-0.0190649051,
0.0087568238,
0.0500797853,
-0.0878953487,
-0.0552065521,
-0.0191610847,
-0.0005633445,
0.0307262186,
0.0100519191,
0.0569602437,
0.0208580885,
0.0053923531,
-0.0258637089,
-0.0256713964,
-0.0122013064,
-0.0180116724,
0.0299066305,
0.0426613837,
0.0046744016,
0.0360010266,
0.0799125209,
0.0032681886,
0.0365186334,
0.0063982364,
0.0080021955,
-0.0087593058,
-0.0398147404,
-0.0036420489,
0.0533336475,
0.0062216283,
0.0027913828,
-0.0319505297,
-0.0184096042,
0.0417885073,
-0.0362930596,
-0.0209580529,
-0.0159074068,
0.0234410036,
0.0603544787,
-0.0011067877,
-0.0409718826,
-0.0287009999,
0.0248284917,
-0.0440364778,
-0.0252945293,
-0.0452578329,
-6.129916145e-33,
-0.0311082266,
-0.0177023225,
0.0100571159,
-0.0161653478,
-0.0655822456,
0.0236399677,
-0.0337055735,
-0.0088425763,
-0.0181011856,
-0.0111068999,
-0.0158766974,
0.0103715947,
0.0103598358,
0.0462152958,
-0.0596870668,
-0.0146931857,
0.0414851941,
-0.0151216518,
-0.0483359508,
0.0066580651,
0.0598161705,
0.0415507331,
-0.0078851646,
-0.0181089882,
-0.0172999259,
-0.0502562486,
0.0188851543,
0.033807572,
0.0306498352,
0.0399629138,
-0.0253661629,
0.0207056422,
0.0324695148,
-0.0291397423,
0.0004949931,
0.0649905279,
-0.1181942374,
0.0054672379,
0.0227051359,
0.0029685977,
-0.0033402743,
0.0052259164,
-0.0197909735,
-0.0095108291,
0.0339248553,
-0.0314280838,
-0.0189466551,
-0.0259464271,
-0.0126584033,
-0.0245409459,
-0.0047464962,
0.0282466598,
-0.0124740172,
-0.0586639643,
0.0003671577,
0.0543805733,
0.0262554735,
0.0057481234,
-0.0309511106,
-0.0001480021,
-0.0010740501,
0.0298148748,
0.0134085435,
0.0069846571,
-0.0230419282,
0.0488754287,
-0.0205348041,
-0.0312383287,
-0.0197383165,
-0.0478859767,
-0.0032211067,
0.0050987154,
0.0196448695,
0.0309316982,
-0.0058925934,
0.0293838438,
-0.0614149906,
0.043688193,
0.0013169826,
0.030723406,
0.0304869041,
0.0077630957,
-0.0522373803,
-0.0187511873,
-0.0480393432,
0.0115657551,
-0.0364039205,
-0.0190403741,
0.0720590279,
0.0174951144,
-0.0103964666,
-0.0304947179,
0.0685978755,
-0.0306406617,
0.0268275999,
0.0685812682,
-0.0084181353,
0.0207729694,
-0.015176435,
0.0488613173,
-0.0419054143,
0.01540225,
0.0530362986,
-0.0244501699,
-0.0313200355,
0.004389808,
-0.0218293928,
-0.0256006829,
-0.0584121756,
0.0085365884,
-0.0256714318,
0.0414969847,
-0.0350321569,
0.1126284897,
0.0148862936,
0.0234922376,
-0.0073339506,
0.1116644293,
-0.0159265846,
0.0491065383,
-0.0690578371,
-0.0221050531,
0.0140195908,
-0.0078884149,
-0.0187037922,
0.0260820221,
-0.0158813223,
0.0328930579,
-0.0340246819,
-0.0329451747,
-0.0038994737,
0.0393927135,
2.582e-7,
0.02202438,
0.0030392881,
0.0594790913,
0.0303057153,
-0.0055924263,
0.0081198616,
0.0157674458,
0.0247769337,
0.0404498987,
-0.0221165139,
-0.024244966,
0.0247009993,
0.0271643382,
0.0253135711,
-0.0892902687,
-0.0290754512,
-0.0567588881,
-0.0532557517,
-0.0366358981,
-0.0800083056,
0.0472696498,
0.0603761785,
-0.0351068899,
-0.003797502,
-0.0033796066,
-0.0330283009,
0.0559455752,
0.01447751,
-0.0337746218,
0.0154766915,
0.0285115745,
-0.0075083664,
0.0076078232,
-0.0038201632,
0.0137686776,
0.0599227957,
0.0247940291,
0.0626313388,
0.0252712555,
-0.0867097303,
-0.0291526839,
-0.0229314361,
-0.0032171232,
-0.050762374,
0.0769859925,
-0.0356835723,
-0.0324299932,
0.0013924896,
-0.0520855598,
-0.0142152933,
0.0058600097,
0.0038347798,
-0.0035453215,
0.0537932739,
0.009806334,
0.0028417332,
0.0123347612,
-0.0932277218,
-0.0242359508,
-0.0201764014,
-0.032017827,
-0.0382632762,
-0.0162229221,
-0.030781839,
0.0094047878,
-0.0606587604,
0.0175330676,
2.272027394e-34,
0.0214527138,
0.0049623833,
0.0135146016,
0.0651470274,
0.02077136,
-0.0266906973,
0.017370116,
0.0057615424,
0.0120707806,
-0.1231633127,
0.0120193493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14703v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14703v2 | Establishing Vocabulary Tests as a Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T08:45:12 | 2024-01-29T09:26:36 | Gonzalo Martínez, Javier Conde, Elena Merino-Gómez, Beatriz Bermúdez-Margaretto, José Alberto Hernández, Pedro Reviriego, Marc Brysbaert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vocabulary tests, once a cornerstone of language modeling evaluation, have
been largely overlooked in the current landscape of Large Language Models
(LLMs) like Llama, Mistral, and GPT. While most LLM evaluation benchmarks focus
on specific tasks or domain-specific knowledge, they often neglect the
fundamental linguistic aspects of language understanding and production. In
this paper, we advocate for the revival of vocabulary tests as a valuable tool
for assessing LLM performance. We evaluate seven LLMs using two vocabulary test
formats across two languages and uncover surprising gaps in their lexical
knowledge. These findings shed light on the intricacies of LLM word
representations, their learning mechanisms, and performance variations across
models and languages. Moreover, the ability to automatically generate and
perform vocabulary tests offers new opportunities to expand the approach and
provide a more complete picture of LLMs' language skills. | [
0.0060496693,
0.0496702455,
-0.0449360572,
0.0680010766,
-0.0520056933,
0.0131796813,
0.0060281893,
0.01426013,
-0.003823441,
-0.0475614369,
-0.062687099,
-0.0941209272,
0.026693495,
0.0373442471,
0.0554422922,
-0.0216717254,
0.0598997697,
-0.0307757668,
-0.036763005,
0.0115583315,
0.0098184077,
0.0149410516,
0.0110309348,
0.0307911001,
0.0105546089,
-0.0066615446,
0.0157134794,
-0.0239822641,
-0.0141931353,
-0.0435973406,
-0.0158124659,
0.0056529967,
0.0240001325,
0.0807438567,
0.0000019027,
-0.0641745627,
0.0096964724,
-0.0191079453,
0.010665074,
0.0626901239,
0.0957900062,
-0.0030025532,
-0.0180791542,
0.0118763931,
-0.0196466278,
0.0072833356,
0.0459902436,
0.0001882565,
0.0206603445,
0.043576505,
-0.0142150093,
-0.026576722,
0.0315492265,
-0.044796519,
-0.0243613403,
-0.0080926418,
-0.0009506065,
0.0372575969,
0.0257973373,
-0.0356347188,
-0.0482118577,
0.0445321165,
0.0075662145,
0.0220960751,
-0.0128017915,
0.0455575846,
0.0133441398,
-0.0334343091,
0.0064054341,
0.0500020906,
-0.0102040842,
-0.0241430737,
-0.0293868706,
-0.0064612189,
-0.0451350547,
0.033227127,
-0.0330965742,
0.0274360739,
0.0267230421,
0.0337108299,
0.0462952033,
-0.0010630633,
0.0532797612,
-0.0035315668,
-0.0427966863,
0.0576142743,
0.0619153567,
-0.0338199995,
-0.0059355772,
-0.0013947338,
-0.0333118849,
-0.0580641851,
-0.0192840155,
0.0133805657,
-0.028674243,
0.0295141116,
0.0020775557,
0.0044734697,
0.0641709268,
-0.0476634055,
0.0679451525,
0.0249244999,
-0.0229060315,
0.0302917697,
-0.0361165181,
0.0946615264,
0.0184415784,
0.0251884423,
-0.0442633927,
-0.0066006104,
-0.0293086283,
-0.0173940212,
-0.0266849622,
-0.0117408587,
-0.0318081714,
-0.0398591049,
-0.0264195893,
0.0130345589,
0.0005265539,
0.0014362594,
0.0206881519,
-0.0252143331,
-0.0115639912,
0.0324423462,
-0.047659643,
-0.0101800738,
-0.0285370704,
0.0216890648,
-0.0136384508,
-0.0656982362,
0.0023860345,
0.0027656101,
-0.0198000148,
-0.0159538537,
-0.0020143401,
0.0714545101,
0.0114952773,
-0.0525470376,
-0.0053534228,
0.0075990441,
-0.0168477334,
-0.0909217,
-0.0017151451,
-0.0535289794,
0.0114869624,
0.017891692,
0.0364188291,
-0.0287434701,
0.00725652,
0.0182645395,
-0.012609113,
0.0614518896,
0.0064086821,
0.0148283923,
-0.0050310134,
0.0053178035,
0.0274067931,
0.0915811211,
0.0480288118,
-0.0024010676,
0.0399793684,
-0.013822359,
-0.0080274763,
0.0619468503,
0.0040241256,
0.019565491,
-0.0709626749,
0.0035715641,
0.0277720056,
0.0388274901,
0.0526289456,
0.0716905892,
0.0027901293,
0.0133370683,
0.0487143248,
0.0673282295,
0.0031522012,
-0.0047812364,
0.0778298378,
-0.0057435976,
0.0099775223,
0.0190796554,
-0.0155015718,
-0.0143400636,
-0.0119800931,
0.0266739205,
-0.0003162874,
0.0347568318,
-0.0055042901,
-0.0101398043,
-0.0621809587,
-0.0033705989,
0.0402291305,
-0.0234903283,
0.0372461081,
0.0189887974,
-0.0398979522,
0.0686512738,
0.0543864667,
-0.044655405,
0.0083986698,
-0.0531169362,
0.023746388,
0.0347087048,
0.0605280735,
0.0253448896,
-0.0132155484,
0.0275411066,
-0.0264280606,
0.077208437,
0.0537786558,
-0.0153589491,
-0.0100197261,
-0.0453469679,
0.0186610166,
-0.0433433019,
0.0414924286,
0.0460722633,
0.0028674165,
0.0234569516,
0.0184705146,
-0.0925744176,
-0.0408927985,
0.0428858995,
-0.0795628577,
-0.0088331299,
-0.0512077622,
-0.0200760067,
0.0299840774,
0.0008637542,
-0.0234052669,
0.0227197632,
0.0231305473,
-0.0358343422,
0.0182479043,
0.0025330929,
-0.0527361445,
-0.0127236834,
0.0218718611,
0.0257788394,
0.0240982939,
0.0479921773,
0.0038391696,
-0.0237330236,
0.0157001857,
-0.0351760946,
0.0514425859,
-0.0669429302,
0.0398945436,
-0.0352161974,
0.0481163189,
-0.0291165356,
0.0649238229,
-0.0202631988,
0.0588624626,
-0.0136610791,
0.0482108258,
0.0281729978,
-0.0288264025,
-0.0415034704,
0.0565709583,
0.0075570424,
0.003296619,
0.001273443,
0.0020020322,
-0.0451410152,
-0.0431375764,
-0.0902556032,
0.0247810651,
-0.030659236,
0.02037986,
0.0157195684,
-0.0090993084,
-0.0221184082,
0.0252021458,
-0.0250875093,
0.001441058,
0.0426548868,
0.0298863556,
0.012643666,
-0.0232874528,
-0.055730883,
-0.0512713864,
-0.0027258552,
0.0041209878,
0.0381108299,
-0.0098778885,
0.0166220274,
-0.020068625,
0.0210551526,
-0.0657978207,
-0.0110008949,
0.0031902229,
-0.0506405272,
0.0149781164,
-0.0176228862,
0.0420616791,
0.0034107151,
-0.001112729,
0.0428238474,
0.0601004548,
-0.0497341231,
-0.0300361458,
-0.0189424697,
0.0024778016,
-0.0448416471,
-0.0443843193,
-0.0489063635,
-0.030264331,
0.106186606,
0.0133839827,
0.0072209435,
-0.02456191,
0.0202403069,
-0.0899227634,
-0.0026951167,
-0.0279034972,
0.0110287797,
-0.0394687727,
0.0476607792,
-0.031170398,
-0.0647479072,
0.0395525433,
-0.0795841739,
-0.0054639727,
-0.0476222672,
-0.0055984799,
-0.0603222772,
0.0543527007,
0.010888543,
0.0122169247,
-0.0351922885,
-0.0116398083,
-0.0376970693,
0.0051406375,
0.0086335028,
-0.0436929651,
0.0418372788,
-0.0509704016,
0.00404691,
0.0071716947,
0.0054991897,
-0.0363302343,
0.0066899923,
-0.0369348861,
0.0434394516,
0.0495681278,
0.0138207953,
-0.005589467,
0.0480391569,
-0.0126807336,
-0.0034679957,
-0.009715775,
0.0036258718,
-0.024575606,
0.0364015065,
0.0387743339,
0.0143720405,
0.033237651,
-0.0413298868,
0.0279206429,
-0.0047688358,
0.0327559635,
0.0119591439,
-0.0224786941,
0.0239154957,
0.0382673815,
-0.0349407941,
0.0019710751,
-0.001030746,
0.0559849069,
-0.0317808948,
-0.0356998444,
0.1188820601,
0.0424926318,
0.0016506652,
0.0415412076,
-0.0308617409,
0.0391368717,
0.0345609598,
-0.012063764,
-0.0752965659,
0.0004015331,
0.0045460523,
0.0075770109,
0.0120525211,
-0.0153604681,
-0.0277890135,
-0.1222620755,
0.0261662602,
-0.0008325165,
-0.0411798395,
0.0096434159,
-0.0421561785,
0.0059834546,
-0.011998821,
0.057803899,
-0.0006952801,
-0.0285757072,
-0.0208069496,
-0.0031004041,
-0.0014172009,
-0.0574593022,
0.0768085122,
-0.0344517678,
0.0547953509,
0.0646085143,
0.0504599996,
-0.0417767167,
-0.0408876687,
0.0325477906,
-0.0438848175,
-0.0136266174,
0.0042711315,
-0.0091857603,
0.0193585716,
-0.0374625735,
0.0391159393,
-0.0431572199,
-0.0146532496,
-0.0157769956,
-0.0114163095,
0.0502980538,
0.0067099086,
-0.0346138142,
-0.0030476509,
-0.0016149883,
0.0103823803,
0.0771597177,
0.0427487716,
-0.022971794,
-0.0120502058,
0.0153107028,
-0.0148414094,
0.011505669,
-0.0561765879,
0.0101834936,
0.0071446216,
0.0042349962,
-0.0668827966,
-0.0638432577,
0.021656448,
0.0002138235,
0.022532342,
0.0304452963,
-0.0277072508,
-0.0167392008,
-0.0230277404,
0.0277580619,
-0.0160403103,
0.0192429908,
-0.0717134476,
-0.0338085145,
0.0489962138,
-0.0108698374,
-0.0263598058,
0.0332406126,
-0.0882114843,
-0.0435322002,
0.0118628917,
0.0124149024,
0.0235002842,
-0.0148912407,
-0.0149910934,
-0.0201223567,
0.0210595783,
-0.0106953951,
-0.0281708576,
0.04678756,
0.0091989078,
-0.0079766773,
-0.0059446776,
0.0540504046,
-0.0248195454,
0.0363675542,
-0.0141036641,
0.0667520836,
0.0290967301,
-0.0444323421,
0.0171619002,
0.0258430671,
0.0295472499,
-0.051255729,
0.0136697059,
-0.0495349877,
-0.0116535341,
-0.0426581949,
0.0106631024,
-0.0366149917,
0.0018002198,
0.0546805039,
0.003663122,
-0.0373450331,
-0.0114865331,
-0.0285218917,
0.0459978804,
-0.030534165,
0.0080367969,
-0.006151136,
-0.0221711602,
0.0012064844,
0.0251335874,
-0.0122485291,
-0.0127091659,
-0.0572897382,
0.0345488489,
-0.0209447686,
0.0669252872,
-0.0349929333,
-0.0134771699,
-0.0131531218,
0.0430555269,
0.0048610596,
-0.042140305,
-0.0152856391,
0.0544156432,
0.0565718673,
-0.0390270948,
0.0678557158,
-0.0509754345,
0.0046349317,
-0.0325682163,
-0.0049908785,
-0.0156832114,
-0.045722954,
0.0243555736,
0.017431533,
-0.0200910885,
-0.0141468039,
0.0614811145,
0.0365178958,
0.0307021141,
0.0037826404,
0.0133172423,
-0.0232296195,
-0.0160621572,
0.0264411159,
-0.0005882361,
-0.0204158965,
0.0066040028,
-0.0865347758,
-0.0874571577,
0.0077303485,
0.024115853,
-0.0084908707,
-0.0216564536,
0.0098643927,
0.074629195,
0.0026838095,
0.0534654558,
-0.0499180891,
-0.0187776275,
-0.0163337514,
-0.0015108589,
-0.0006109771,
-6.259980555e-33,
-0.0510119535,
0.0046338518,
0.0335646644,
-0.0585835204,
-0.0235496815,
-0.0045628827,
-0.0531655252,
-0.0046611307,
-0.0009843052,
0.0124767013,
-0.000009024,
-0.0017922822,
0.00542907,
-0.0034084788,
0.0022796465,
-0.010827641,
0.0290817618,
-0.0005031,
-0.0341960415,
0.0089370785,
0.0213631857,
0.0008155379,
0.0693092495,
-0.0335047655,
0.0367003605,
-0.0005818698,
-0.0111560859,
-0.0143248513,
-0.018153809,
0.0659433007,
-0.0674917772,
0.0447997898,
0.0190020483,
-0.0273725428,
-0.0249251965,
-0.0305962134,
-0.0405048095,
-0.036936339,
0.0612626933,
-0.017837787,
-0.0317658111,
-0.0093454272,
0.0295817349,
-0.0285007134,
-0.040623948,
0.0244547781,
-0.0075404127,
-0.0080173742,
-0.0215051826,
0.0228070784,
-0.0909570381,
0.0219958443,
0.0217240006,
-0.0253156535,
0.0148484735,
-0.0333498642,
-0.0037355185,
0.0108614201,
-0.0281121638,
-0.0013146254,
0.0336412713,
0.0372023396,
0.0835606381,
0.016989518,
-0.0131839737,
0.0767931342,
0.0096648168,
-0.0116351899,
0.0373376198,
0.010311408,
0.0708087534,
0.0037726858,
0.0333933756,
0.0387278646,
0.0118208667,
-0.0214651655,
-0.0256828312,
-0.0058956696,
-0.0042971559,
0.0479228236,
0.0275976416,
-0.0111098215,
-0.0362480544,
-0.0120371981,
-0.0696916953,
-0.0159194618,
-0.026401924,
-0.020358758,
0.0671903193,
-0.0104349824,
0.0125124101,
-0.0216585919,
0.0205945484,
-0.0422006957,
-0.0528578833,
0.0084247468,
-0.0218805913,
-0.0013154091,
0.0011968947,
0.0544516295,
-0.0478593148,
-0.0180669744,
-0.0095455125,
0.0254439134,
-0.0012705803,
-0.0076320069,
-0.025950307,
0.0211346913,
-0.0450471789,
0.0104078185,
-0.0464908257,
-0.0100663761,
-0.0236356221,
0.0173909217,
0.0302511398,
-0.0053499462,
-0.0122029921,
0.0110894293,
0.0415474325,
-0.052736979,
-0.0347738862,
0.0016380848,
-0.0286446996,
0.0419776738,
-0.0386698246,
0.004530746,
-0.051895041,
0.0268241111,
0.0430774391,
-0.0212770291,
0.0115941055,
-0.0015533963,
2.578e-7,
0.0600935034,
0.0546232201,
-0.0165934786,
0.0529398397,
0.0020789595,
-0.0107045704,
-0.0598697327,
0.0340969004,
0.0029304267,
-0.0126269218,
-0.0212008208,
0.0324034132,
0.0491222404,
0.0366872773,
-0.0746283978,
0.032372795,
-0.0814034566,
0.030785786,
-0.0570294186,
-0.0039600804,
0.0269765668,
0.1038013622,
-0.0052976529,
-0.0155043285,
-0.0438774638,
-0.0651287138,
0.0669870302,
-0.0368620157,
-0.0337296166,
0.0349490792,
0.0372748785,
0.046891924,
0.024627991,
-0.0038497208,
-0.0054320297,
0.0533648729,
0.0152970245,
0.0358444341,
0.009704506,
-0.0144247208,
0.0024095241,
-0.0438784286,
-0.0140099172,
-0.0982245877,
0.0617116429,
-0.0100070247,
-0.0183966029,
-0.0301895626,
0.0023690092,
0.0287634097,
0.0455157645,
-0.0289411135,
-0.0459526964,
0.0345033705,
0.0158962253,
-0.0105974302,
-0.0299325138,
-0.0274371374,
-0.0235844497,
0.0168115683,
-0.0180351194,
-0.0744913593,
-0.0393446535,
-0.0100507988,
0.0064447531,
-0.0479494892,
0.0114689851,
2.319052219e-34,
0.0342994742,
-0.0005050469,
0.0165859368,
0.0264619142,
0.0488748439,
-0.0311005916,
0.0476803593,
0.0377784893,
-0.0351447947,
-0.0702624619,
0.0152517231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14696v1 | Tree of Clarifications: Answering Ambiguous Questions with Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T08:42:49 | 2023-10-23T08:42:49 | Gangwoo Kim, Sungdong Kim, Byeongguk Jeon, Joonsuk Park, Jaewoo Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Questions in open-domain question answering are often ambiguous, allowing
multiple interpretations. One approach to handling them is to identify all
possible interpretations of the ambiguous question (AQ) and to generate a
long-form answer addressing them all, as suggested by Stelmakh et al., (2022).
While it provides a comprehensive response without bothering the user for
clarification, considering multiple dimensions of ambiguity and gathering
corresponding knowledge remains a challenge. To cope with the challenge, we
propose a novel framework, Tree of Clarifications (ToC): It recursively
constructs a tree of disambiguations for the AQ -- via few-shot prompting
leveraging external knowledge -- and uses it to generate a long-form answer.
ToC outperforms existing baselines on ASQA in a few-shot setup across the
metrics, while surpassing fully-supervised baselines trained on the whole
training set in terms of Disambig-F1 and Disambig-ROUGE. Code is available at
https://github.com/gankim/tree-of-clarifications. | [
0.0728334486,
0.0376764685,
-0.0018753695,
0.0333334468,
0.0134061072,
0.0142967664,
-0.0201596338,
0.0124650318,
-0.0137770595,
-0.0609503277,
0.0204600561,
-0.0536055639,
-0.0505080037,
-0.0106127122,
-0.0082833823,
-0.0445823669,
0.0774302557,
-0.0427668281,
0.0164387189,
-0.0185587537,
-0.0061521861,
0.0387131125,
0.0001191049,
0.0312997662,
-0.004873246,
-0.0758176073,
-0.0330484211,
0.0382874943,
0.0022764497,
-0.0000750494,
0.0148123428,
0.0322604068,
0.0316569991,
0.0489047915,
0.0000017809,
-0.0647384152,
-0.0209220201,
0.0228731111,
-0.070442833,
0.0038592881,
-0.0147766825,
0.0316793583,
0.0611211807,
0.0123671554,
-0.0316902734,
-0.0461793207,
0.0311623029,
0.0262338091,
0.0967683569,
0.0615995191,
0.0324693322,
-0.0715363771,
-0.0309954565,
-0.0374732465,
0.0272622816,
-0.0631573498,
0.0138096148,
-0.0049576298,
-0.0095280744,
0.0581807271,
-0.0115795061,
0.0208786968,
0.0260993037,
-0.0106292758,
-0.0134868314,
-0.0050956993,
-0.0194484498,
-0.0127402395,
0.0032001033,
0.0804091543,
0.0342915468,
-0.0044162716,
-0.0091786124,
0.0121098291,
0.0306948368,
0.0115303723,
-0.0304846037,
0.027702678,
-0.0151415374,
-0.0458158068,
-0.0185067151,
-0.0017108688,
0.0136704473,
0.0477326475,
-0.0368795656,
0.049321577,
0.0113685736,
-0.0110030388,
-0.0108849248,
-0.0296561383,
-0.0443337634,
-0.0685020238,
-0.0259295776,
0.0929136947,
-0.0705485865,
0.0171232093,
-0.0012658422,
-0.0184520744,
0.0377126709,
-0.0331751108,
0.0087504182,
0.0304502808,
-0.0220146887,
0.0594491698,
-0.0138235502,
0.0403915681,
-0.0252298005,
0.0001378761,
-0.0535042323,
-0.0583417527,
-0.0443678349,
-0.0318831764,
-0.0651134849,
0.0528771356,
-0.070315823,
-0.0081840418,
-0.0202764366,
0.0171360131,
-0.0212898403,
0.0002142438,
0.0046848925,
0.0213753581,
-0.0487005636,
-0.0137521494,
-0.0225951448,
0.0586595312,
-0.0801743641,
0.0233983397,
0.0356421508,
-0.0547880344,
-0.0299253035,
0.0097901011,
-0.0004617188,
-0.0050356425,
0.0041781361,
0.0479230173,
-0.0007886764,
0.0145402784,
-0.0174596366,
-0.0421126895,
-0.0631695315,
-0.0354926996,
-0.0176607333,
-0.0540213548,
0.0212459844,
0.0093814405,
-0.0197759941,
-0.0105094323,
0.0313686281,
0.0369463339,
0.0147964694,
0.0492844284,
-0.0112045519,
-0.0098697459,
0.0475632548,
0.0194728859,
-0.0241037849,
0.0623165965,
-0.0074795932,
0.0256254077,
0.0451080799,
0.0104481773,
-0.0040742201,
-0.0105714127,
0.0092370035,
0.0038332124,
0.0232228227,
0.0607396923,
-0.0350916348,
0.0341172516,
0.0041883546,
0.0319500081,
-0.0365425833,
-0.0318454318,
-0.0109887999,
0.0212086756,
-0.0060717883,
-0.0101989675,
0.0303811319,
0.0343524069,
0.008727272,
-0.0065584164,
-0.0374348648,
0.0193450432,
-0.0244128946,
0.0281790737,
-0.0156471711,
0.0222916044,
-0.0229370501,
-0.0321921296,
0.003059109,
0.0241045505,
-0.0008731669,
0.0610084422,
0.0551837571,
0.0541793518,
-0.0035450596,
0.0632085577,
-0.00544617,
-0.0243744962,
0.0119806388,
-0.03693128,
0.0610995851,
0.0043217493,
0.0231864657,
-0.0235947464,
-0.056333825,
-0.039909441,
0.0254757088,
0.0272090863,
0.0223951209,
-0.0302838739,
0.0552273765,
-0.0423069485,
0.0008130453,
-0.0434511453,
0.005997512,
-0.0130949281,
0.030906437,
-0.0184208266,
0.038572941,
-0.0523755997,
0.006257806,
0.0188692231,
0.0316038392,
-0.0148100285,
0.0252854992,
-0.0136651369,
0.03916163,
0.0298824534,
-0.0193625707,
0.0105172768,
0.0258474536,
-0.0107216313,
-0.0368293449,
-0.0572728068,
-0.0220123027,
-0.0327054672,
0.0274553299,
0.0196158532,
-0.0591766201,
0.009670021,
-0.0908069238,
-0.02709415,
-0.0032649902,
-0.0279535986,
0.0018202435,
-0.0513677858,
0.0035942136,
0.0123344585,
-0.031072272,
-0.0664887205,
0.0742143989,
0.0098245144,
0.0146286013,
0.0071496964,
0.0010833105,
0.0230630729,
-0.0182161741,
-0.0026599239,
0.0035225051,
-0.0377926715,
-0.0061569465,
0.0284539647,
0.028133845,
-0.0889037848,
-0.0094443979,
-0.0688197091,
0.0331545472,
-0.0330712944,
0.020968033,
0.042577114,
0.0473580845,
0.0196862239,
-0.0328774899,
-0.0274840202,
-0.0127132991,
0.0060848286,
0.0107905604,
0.0320321955,
0.0218133796,
0.0080883773,
0.0004355141,
-0.0316891,
-0.0188011732,
0.0418835506,
-0.030109141,
-0.039393235,
-0.0450240262,
0.0009417096,
-0.0647175312,
0.0095911371,
-0.0012934026,
-0.0146496054,
0.0260599013,
-0.0197024643,
0.0248376038,
0.0499088019,
0.0093677845,
0.0055649038,
0.0064512156,
-0.0173264928,
-0.0566204786,
0.0439093225,
-0.0182096604,
-0.0413491167,
-0.0027875947,
-0.0134070991,
-0.0009995628,
0.0197348148,
-0.0047478033,
-0.0348239616,
-0.0392247699,
0.0009589472,
-0.0135329636,
-0.0169186983,
-0.061202649,
-0.0043086554,
0.0060920976,
0.0498794876,
-0.0356678925,
-0.0166753195,
0.0835781172,
-0.0009412551,
-0.0161987469,
-0.0493548587,
0.0050242199,
-0.0651748553,
0.0868798122,
-0.0496168286,
0.0210254714,
0.0163323767,
-0.0327469148,
-0.056853056,
-0.024596611,
0.0175485145,
-0.0562930703,
0.0823237076,
-0.040071331,
0.0092491135,
-0.0174101945,
-0.0377677493,
-0.0319812186,
-0.0443656221,
-0.0094966693,
0.0178143363,
-0.0094288969,
-0.0013526609,
-0.0203958806,
-0.0001035744,
0.030195551,
0.0028077271,
-0.0161322989,
-0.0141325146,
-0.0181804337,
0.0639903992,
0.0869096443,
0.0390353613,
0.0400552116,
-0.0317349918,
0.031482406,
0.0498426966,
-0.0179156642,
0.0056070769,
0.0080592902,
-0.0280823652,
0.0233235732,
-0.0271611921,
-0.024305474,
0.0260337219,
0.0825430751,
-0.0713317469,
-0.0228156243,
0.0937450454,
0.026618734,
0.0009961225,
-0.0270867683,
-0.0600649491,
0.0240826607,
0.0106959613,
0.0327992328,
-0.1176465526,
-0.0533505082,
-0.0151944989,
0.0180647597,
0.0406289361,
0.0089453375,
0.0118061146,
-0.1053350195,
0.0237609074,
-0.0216037091,
-0.0535798259,
-0.0172948353,
-0.0086994162,
0.0228239,
0.0348000638,
0.0139905298,
0.0258671138,
-0.0158591829,
0.0222310517,
0.0147876628,
0.0094309086,
-0.0164100155,
0.0242960677,
-0.0172889028,
0.0219543763,
0.076853402,
0.0052112974,
0.0115427459,
0.0229751486,
-0.0258655753,
-0.0646306425,
-0.0161352139,
-0.0114308139,
0.0128991259,
0.0198147744,
-0.0049512647,
-0.0366403423,
0.0289971903,
-0.0137844607,
0.0104102511,
0.0262305364,
0.0198285207,
-0.0207683761,
-0.0268833358,
-0.0091405921,
-0.0068241036,
-0.0081256796,
0.0723043382,
0.013447118,
0.0026386972,
-0.0501200035,
-0.0262384564,
0.0038395713,
-0.021911623,
0.0157949161,
0.0399286672,
-0.0067195906,
0.0277879555,
-0.0453159176,
-0.0376827344,
0.0429490954,
0.0280253664,
-0.0306128282,
0.0144632189,
-0.0070389821,
0.0199504886,
-0.036476478,
0.0328336842,
-0.0206094608,
0.0181755014,
-0.0220410228,
0.0147593319,
0.0282563996,
0.0201986507,
-0.0301815607,
0.069178775,
-0.0598365031,
-0.0298734047,
-0.0030162323,
0.0277457293,
0.0212318562,
0.0198009014,
-0.0542088561,
-0.0333055444,
0.01231624,
0.0091583673,
-0.0108420812,
0.0100680375,
0.0116331885,
0.0597980507,
-0.0194676872,
0.0738242194,
-0.0955265015,
0.0060213082,
-0.0121710161,
0.0635099486,
-0.0359691978,
-0.0376668386,
0.018004356,
0.0166629776,
0.00058531,
0.0237992667,
0.0125321122,
0.0132550122,
0.0199844874,
-0.0212757308,
-0.0409139134,
-0.0324901082,
0.0281928331,
0.0080055613,
-0.0853034705,
0.0114510925,
0.0303558111,
-0.0005618972,
0.0415649042,
-0.0459511578,
-0.0222276468,
0.0453822985,
-0.0044430266,
0.0059265564,
-0.0242679697,
-0.0314902142,
0.0083773807,
0.0011639347,
0.0274052043,
0.0257584918,
0.0734802857,
0.0413110927,
0.0063068774,
-0.0429214798,
-0.0051038112,
-0.0532000102,
-0.0788487941,
0.0209125075,
0.0239088535,
0.031660255,
0.0408703499,
0.0399697274,
0.0227647256,
-0.0278397761,
-0.0192341581,
0.0062390999,
0.0336967967,
-0.0247853044,
0.0548669212,
0.0442578159,
-0.0099361241,
0.0089529809,
0.0610896014,
-0.0217577908,
0.0098520666,
0.0117043937,
0.0181043725,
-0.0101860799,
-0.0579194389,
-0.0293469913,
0.0652368888,
0.0182936192,
0.0345302671,
-0.0513031445,
-0.0429221131,
0.0139163341,
-0.0159905367,
-0.0144453291,
-0.0083664367,
0.0310514588,
0.0496738218,
0.0507048778,
-0.1042954624,
-0.0496232994,
0.0273821969,
-0.0363317952,
-0.0360429771,
-0.0570371225,
-6.214057664e-33,
-0.0221246127,
-0.0133287711,
-0.0069742543,
-0.0389153585,
-0.0313518234,
0.0050622197,
-0.0263232011,
-0.0333201662,
-0.0731316954,
0.0249363072,
-0.0095862681,
0.0653562695,
0.0011908143,
0.0525646806,
0.0071588028,
-0.0325441509,
0.0414112061,
0.008787212,
-0.0207032431,
0.0272120647,
0.0431622602,
-0.0103917383,
0.0210298728,
0.0041557308,
0.0198099799,
-0.0425614938,
-0.0304035693,
0.0662012175,
-0.0397202522,
0.0559969023,
0.0095360931,
0.0468007624,
0.0099011054,
-0.0202146657,
-0.0021650726,
0.0336058363,
-0.1148035973,
-0.0251734573,
0.0290041454,
-0.0095794722,
-0.0831134692,
-0.0264786724,
0.0281953327,
-0.0167057049,
0.0648387,
-0.0310816914,
0.0021551631,
-0.0097499732,
-0.0139322719,
-0.066464439,
0.020984469,
0.0172900744,
-0.0193831213,
-0.0327988081,
-0.0267130639,
0.0682717189,
-0.0086894818,
0.0350665115,
-0.0256232601,
-0.0036453158,
0.0026079798,
0.0280816294,
0.0027954287,
0.0156072034,
0.0062967753,
0.0049226307,
-0.0081547694,
-0.0447786376,
-0.0422738343,
-0.0537893474,
-0.0654531568,
0.0256152675,
0.0199432932,
0.0662205517,
0.0538258851,
0.0282056965,
-0.0987016112,
-0.00819657,
0.0037667765,
0.0926280245,
-0.0076768701,
-0.0074430257,
-0.004629998,
-0.0158149488,
-0.0653810054,
0.0277271029,
-0.0352136306,
-0.0063810805,
0.0467067026,
-0.0009774928,
-0.0137379626,
-0.0175570734,
0.028725775,
-0.0399351418,
0.0121942582,
0.0391985774,
0.0089552375,
0.0158121493,
0.0346642546,
0.065818049,
0.0104845092,
0.0340419412,
0.0513172746,
-0.0279969424,
-0.0211825892,
0.0273350645,
0.0220037624,
-0.0325651653,
-0.0474163964,
0.0075064809,
-0.0006412293,
0.0364218801,
-0.0680651665,
-0.0122682909,
0.0325393192,
0.0425690562,
0.0187022686,
0.0647957921,
0.0143578164,
0.051805675,
0.0023711182,
0.0005876412,
0.0003590169,
-0.0059948959,
-0.0163687915,
0.0178816281,
0.0001127818,
-0.0026883096,
-0.0200579017,
-0.0342247896,
-0.0105322162,
0.0407873727,
2.483e-7,
0.0680632368,
0.020338051,
0.0201211534,
0.0775608718,
0.0032230171,
0.0026178821,
0.0382707566,
-0.0144694149,
0.0194940791,
-0.0246218275,
-0.0272501446,
0.0336334482,
0.0426063351,
0.0247762017,
-0.0445272736,
0.0313440152,
-0.0458387025,
0.0166982785,
-0.0452506393,
0.0106981294,
0.0888361856,
0.0991384909,
-0.0118960766,
0.0118151028,
-0.0103178974,
-0.0405448824,
0.0483587645,
0.0083179194,
0.010383429,
0.0351414867,
0.0574391373,
-0.0310844071,
0.0479590036,
0.0141890757,
0.0115366736,
0.0137397768,
-0.0117078898,
0.0810518488,
-0.0139474422,
-0.0047288486,
-0.0314564444,
-0.0404499397,
0.0377464965,
-0.0558517911,
0.0653639212,
-0.0814669505,
-0.0259142499,
-0.0197395012,
-0.0535657331,
-0.0183198918,
0.0264389683,
-0.008735125,
-0.0166982226,
0.0067914459,
0.0130530829,
-0.0086448491,
-0.0137722353,
-0.084404394,
0.0084253289,
0.0120797306,
-0.0129460394,
-0.0084392512,
0.0018697577,
-0.0143976361,
0.0127623361,
-0.0417300202,
0.0071004122,
1.992411038e-34,
0.053740833,
-0.017056914,
-0.0047710454,
0.0404882208,
0.0529161394,
-0.0137693863,
-0.0588282906,
-0.0075922534,
0.0415433347,
-0.0867461115,
-0.0009848159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14687v1 | API-Assisted Code Generation for Question Answering on Varied Table Structures | 2023-10-23T08:26:28 | 2023-10-23T08:26:28 | Yihan Cao, Shuyi Chen, Ryan Liu, Zhiruo Wang, Daniel Fried | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A persistent challenge to table question answering (TableQA) by generating
executable programs has been adapting to varied table structures, typically
requiring domain-specific logical forms. In response, this paper introduces a
unified TableQA framework that: (1) provides a unified representation for
structured tables as multi-index Pandas data frames, (2) uses Python as a
powerful querying language, and (3) uses few-shot prompting to translate NL
questions into Python programs, which are executable on Pandas data frames.
Furthermore, to answer complex relational questions with extended program
functionality and external knowledge, our framework allows customized APIs that
Python programs can call. We experiment with four TableQA datasets that involve
tables of different structures -- relational, multi-table, and hierarchical
matrix shapes -- and achieve prominent improvements over past state-of-the-art
systems. In ablation studies, we (1) show benefits from our multi-index
representation and APIs over baselines that use only an LLM, and (2)
demonstrate that our approach is modular and can incorporate additional APIs. | [
0.0269780979,
0.0775625929,
-0.0221041683,
0.0092532784,
-0.0209328253,
0.0609369837,
0.0055408203,
0.0230865069,
0.0256697889,
-0.0313700214,
-0.0163105298,
0.0284454487,
-0.0255584307,
0.0620449074,
0.0165778119,
0.0098632211,
0.0234432817,
0.0046121324,
-0.0191488899,
0.0130997645,
-0.0098960632,
0.0067775506,
-0.0354338102,
0.0194612499,
-0.0060058273,
-0.0138713326,
-0.0650763512,
-0.023218751,
-0.0374986865,
-0.0031796889,
0.0098556746,
0.0662237778,
0.0241264068,
-0.0011372304,
0.0000020304,
-0.0249091461,
-0.0449417382,
0.0122175403,
-0.0205500387,
-0.031442605,
0.0287103821,
-0.0091370298,
0.076802589,
-0.002372314,
-0.057846982,
-0.0276824441,
0.0215591174,
-0.0048847115,
0.0606483743,
0.0272465106,
0.0057907477,
-0.028002264,
-0.0206085481,
0.0397990197,
0.0209229682,
-0.0370709039,
0.0020752628,
0.0300701782,
0.0186729953,
-0.0608662106,
0.0302027408,
0.0223411657,
0.0354440138,
0.00969279,
-0.0061608935,
0.021729691,
-0.0526205711,
0.0191732571,
-0.020380469,
0.0692942739,
0.0632749051,
-0.0374250188,
0.021908449,
0.0162875876,
0.0436213501,
-0.0268455986,
-0.0615144558,
0.0092145326,
0.0075684767,
-0.0528002791,
0.0201529767,
0.0056374152,
-0.0221237168,
0.0069273631,
-0.0495788716,
0.0605662242,
-0.0094356257,
-0.0305490848,
-0.0144451139,
-0.0214556735,
0.0308387782,
-0.043234311,
0.0106209079,
0.0826078802,
-0.0597061962,
0.0097285509,
0.0197395347,
-0.0391435027,
0.0381826423,
-0.0333070084,
0.0184077192,
0.0480944365,
-0.012450058,
0.0029711251,
-0.0067739468,
0.0273163076,
0.0033034219,
0.0269684196,
-0.0308195539,
-0.0156935602,
-0.0544477999,
-0.0107610263,
-0.0544686578,
0.0505238362,
-0.0549792573,
0.0156742502,
0.0212994367,
0.0407099649,
-0.0125289345,
0.039273452,
-0.0526061915,
0.0507646278,
-0.0023146444,
0.019713521,
-0.0458243079,
0.0180429313,
-0.0598807149,
-0.0473303646,
-0.0002847825,
-0.0396764539,
-0.0255890135,
0.00540245,
0.0333038531,
-0.0085378373,
0.0499505773,
0.095823817,
-0.0326199345,
0.0076680896,
-0.0368711837,
-0.0407638289,
-0.0094962372,
-0.0533351265,
0.016984269,
-0.0740036294,
0.0480946675,
0.0501625538,
-0.0207760874,
-0.03959921,
0.0214992072,
0.0549599268,
-0.0033752671,
0.040793363,
0.006937773,
0.0099269543,
0.0072216834,
-0.0240948144,
-0.0299004167,
0.0744098499,
0.0286960937,
-0.0055014393,
0.008334239,
-0.0355098434,
-0.0111894095,
-0.007523708,
0.0187348705,
0.0007720807,
0.005231183,
0.105133757,
-0.0061111087,
0.0273931939,
-0.0419672132,
0.0098043317,
0.014468086,
0.0261683669,
-0.0029900537,
0.0173845459,
-0.0282071326,
0.0434895791,
0.0343014374,
-0.0101332152,
0.0260624997,
0.0275726803,
-0.0179729629,
0.0784011856,
0.0139695182,
0.0053742286,
0.0059044654,
0.0343367979,
-0.0019176115,
-0.0853960812,
0.0133709405,
0.0145143084,
0.0296875164,
0.0298320707,
0.0377370603,
0.0229318216,
-0.0341161601,
0.0206627659,
-0.004409729,
-0.0605431162,
-0.0408971198,
-0.0322761126,
0.0382710099,
0.0518068783,
0.0364860296,
-0.0617422424,
-0.0207840241,
-0.0134284496,
0.0310813002,
0.0000987593,
0.0186095033,
-0.0445441008,
0.0031318299,
0.0033979318,
0.0034998658,
-0.0136298975,
0.0159551259,
-0.0281776153,
0.0449535958,
-0.0067473385,
-0.0065045655,
-0.0472538322,
-0.0145517169,
0.0329946242,
0.020135697,
-0.0107239438,
0.0026587045,
0.0131193297,
0.0145923244,
0.0394030213,
0.0047965073,
0.0403444171,
0.0428720079,
-0.0163660366,
-0.0177395791,
-0.0618709549,
0.0101331538,
0.0343211368,
0.0207693521,
0.0245885551,
-0.0817625076,
-0.0052635726,
-0.0529203042,
-0.0157677121,
0.0243744534,
-0.0105885584,
-0.0201543644,
-0.0161872767,
-0.0223173741,
0.0239805374,
-0.0087523935,
-0.0117446743,
0.0561007522,
0.0169350803,
0.0297210049,
0.0256755836,
-0.0777499527,
0.0510189421,
-0.0256601404,
0.0355052762,
-0.0106381383,
-0.0623720512,
0.0248638298,
-0.014130204,
0.0501988158,
-0.0622700974,
0.0100775911,
-0.0647815913,
0.0500402041,
-0.0350921415,
0.0045922017,
0.0299631469,
0.0283724591,
-0.0148663381,
-0.0229083858,
-0.0322663151,
-0.0053580883,
-0.0199918505,
0.0035383953,
0.0750093162,
0.0028063555,
-0.0284349322,
-0.0097226277,
-0.0067377132,
-0.0166976433,
0.040683005,
-0.0151236672,
-0.0442987159,
0.0300993919,
-0.0729119033,
-0.0203386806,
0.0026207438,
0.0328292474,
-0.0108822901,
0.0083543332,
-0.0296191722,
-0.0017991656,
0.0511337295,
-0.0332224108,
0.0201168098,
0.0434538648,
-0.0122787422,
-0.0322587304,
0.0442477614,
0.0016132729,
0.0116043976,
0.0633520335,
-0.0464454107,
0.0386263989,
0.0047697173,
-0.0188416336,
0.0227017514,
-0.0222947486,
0.0218752492,
0.0322948694,
-0.0139947776,
-0.0643084571,
0.0452104844,
0.0206616223,
0.0291576125,
0.0203454457,
-0.0307727195,
0.0419608504,
-0.0017225886,
-0.0148853483,
-0.0388568528,
-0.0191140901,
-0.0546881482,
0.1124053746,
0.009257081,
0.0141148129,
-0.0089834752,
-0.0364879146,
-0.0620013028,
0.0215470381,
-0.0053014751,
-0.0415276065,
0.1054263562,
-0.0535191409,
0.0087547153,
-0.0110568628,
-0.0140649611,
-0.0090849483,
0.0108175054,
-0.059788689,
0.0023778656,
-0.0154691907,
-0.0302938633,
0.022888612,
-0.019944543,
0.0339810401,
0.0077940589,
-0.0037304431,
-0.0272187553,
-0.0082680741,
0.015857581,
0.0363824815,
0.0381995924,
-0.0541565791,
0.0274510831,
0.0531808808,
0.0424150005,
-0.0165950432,
-0.0083580967,
-0.013647696,
0.0194508862,
-0.011159041,
-0.0260858368,
0.0282018408,
0.0514039695,
-0.0461733229,
-0.0625739321,
-0.0143734897,
0.0496524833,
0.0573803931,
0.0267102309,
0.0006965873,
-0.0345867351,
0.0351601467,
0.0408868268,
0.0760563314,
-0.150357157,
-0.0313755274,
-0.005245592,
0.0307755116,
-0.008383655,
-0.035929475,
-0.0230398364,
-0.0884142146,
0.0486706831,
-0.0538145937,
-0.0324816108,
-0.0899769664,
-0.0466991737,
-0.0147181246,
0.0073802196,
0.0043421127,
0.0690560564,
-0.0086227357,
0.0325930603,
0.0017259184,
-0.0316221602,
0.0288714375,
0.0006899338,
-0.0040211156,
-0.0198474657,
0.0535914861,
0.01376493,
0.0023445631,
0.0136249838,
-0.0283770449,
0.0024591766,
-0.0205940399,
-0.0506454296,
0.0558073372,
0.0258472282,
-0.0099431444,
-0.0292360429,
0.01794702,
-0.0547614768,
-0.0083096419,
0.0418975689,
0.0454121009,
-0.0473349094,
-0.0327584185,
-0.0147626176,
-0.0105343815,
-0.020427648,
0.0657998025,
0.0291190557,
0.0084582781,
-0.042896647,
-0.0324998982,
-0.0661117882,
-0.0737427101,
0.0094818966,
0.0362703241,
-0.0194637626,
0.0528559946,
-0.0706011429,
0.0283025373,
0.0895740837,
0.0140618766,
-0.0129671032,
0.0235703271,
-0.0225235932,
0.0084854839,
-0.0830492228,
-0.0499838106,
-0.0228712894,
-0.0070172488,
0.0119127575,
-0.0735709742,
0.0147128319,
-0.0176647846,
-0.0345031805,
0.0551241152,
-0.0233837646,
0.0054319701,
-0.0075865099,
0.0219883956,
0.0164587349,
-0.0285010505,
0.0200887341,
0.0272479691,
-0.0427246429,
0.0618108697,
-0.034142077,
-0.0333283544,
-0.0242423546,
-0.0198331196,
0.0100520421,
0.0248822644,
-0.0775813609,
-0.0522366725,
-0.0333141387,
0.0609367453,
0.0103679141,
0.0393473767,
0.0664566308,
0.0333099961,
-0.0596861988,
0.0266408883,
-0.0923683047,
0.0091934064,
0.0502937809,
-0.0484545194,
-0.0659389719,
-0.0151723949,
0.006069344,
-0.0377308019,
-0.0219007954,
0.0106065199,
0.0354988091,
0.0107843056,
0.0455430821,
-0.0076221218,
0.0150226606,
0.0469262861,
0.0014990559,
0.0130746122,
-0.0343963616,
-0.0345928222,
-0.033520326,
0.0271142945,
0.0397181697,
-0.0239983164,
0.0336471833,
0.0245823581,
-0.0318183526,
-0.0412146971,
0.0234179664,
-0.0637790784,
-0.0802780092,
0.0247672256,
-0.0333762839,
-0.0051124287,
0.0178608503,
-0.0242950339,
-0.0261885691,
-0.0326151662,
0.0421035103,
0.0183601528,
0.0498285778,
-0.0044914824,
0.0248220172,
0.0108661791,
-0.0187848751,
-0.0416990891,
0.0740806237,
0.0007780874,
0.0161988623,
0.0156887993,
-0.0324914642,
-0.0611121729,
-0.0323276743,
0.0059007681,
0.0163873695,
-0.0017280293,
-0.0395671502,
-0.0372368209,
-0.0418799855,
-0.0101213716,
0.0402868427,
-0.0207262114,
-0.0146905351,
0.0436464064,
0.0397553891,
0.100884892,
-0.0412615463,
-0.0302533377,
0.0757447854,
-0.0414514095,
-0.0633305907,
-0.0126581267,
-6.138492111e-33,
-0.0396312065,
-0.049488157,
0.0212130751,
-0.0273032431,
0.0379238091,
-0.0289904419,
-0.0404490717,
0.0104534142,
-0.0092583159,
-0.0105111599,
-0.0057577197,
0.0241834503,
0.0139498748,
-0.0159712769,
0.006946275,
-0.0919092819,
-0.0331712589,
-0.022416763,
0.004957994,
0.0011144093,
0.0407875404,
0.0186361019,
-0.0237948578,
-0.0046909875,
0.0227454808,
-0.0020850268,
-0.005339446,
-0.0064612078,
-0.0224049874,
0.0297468286,
-0.02178411,
0.0333717763,
0.0323441997,
-0.0136270961,
0.0006549307,
0.0295933802,
-0.1300771087,
-0.0300172288,
-0.0094713857,
-0.0078182323,
-0.0188771561,
-0.014806834,
0.0476067103,
0.0102546187,
0.0277702808,
-0.008201628,
0.0223877691,
-0.0200602617,
0.026824221,
-0.0130312517,
-0.0412207805,
-0.0167151708,
-0.0448512994,
0.0078470772,
-0.0177972298,
0.0484743677,
0.0229864232,
0.0172218606,
-0.0060413191,
-0.0019182689,
0.0194553565,
0.0122116758,
0.0420633778,
-0.0193505418,
0.0291268192,
-0.0182842761,
0.0352098532,
-0.0005178626,
-0.0179622602,
0.0480526686,
-0.0366506837,
0.0720217079,
0.0576648638,
0.0133844959,
0.0069357664,
0.0410443023,
-0.0837647989,
0.0468081757,
-0.0104070725,
-0.0055136834,
-0.02846843,
-0.034927506,
0.0104598701,
-0.0120022139,
-0.0243916381,
0.0404435284,
-0.0469413288,
-0.019216802,
0.0216855593,
-0.0308320001,
0.0001208623,
-0.0368984416,
-0.0084703406,
-0.0023226,
-0.0161849707,
0.023851186,
-0.0091250297,
0.0085676098,
0.0372232608,
0.014045788,
0.0327933133,
0.0240622163,
0.0038197713,
-0.0360133126,
0.0588426068,
0.0331393182,
0.0132311182,
0.0324722007,
-0.0585717633,
-0.0042090327,
-0.0355327874,
0.0519137941,
-0.0087758563,
-0.001001336,
-0.0323454067,
0.0418315679,
0.0028376486,
0.0411474295,
-0.0014320901,
0.020496482,
-0.0425634347,
0.0169668775,
-0.0144113479,
0.0043302202,
-0.0000193319,
0.0133477235,
-0.0394599885,
0.0160953235,
-0.0083487164,
-0.0197099335,
-0.0005923181,
0.0358953848,
2.614e-7,
0.0966757163,
0.005598689,
0.0449249297,
0.1059935018,
-0.0115555152,
0.0131196417,
0.0005257621,
-0.0116279852,
-0.0211774502,
-0.0457787663,
0.0151273319,
-0.0049027717,
0.0321355797,
0.0358444341,
-0.0450360291,
-0.0089487694,
-0.0310721379,
-0.0194693804,
-0.0571612567,
0.0246872734,
0.0482732803,
0.0275285095,
-0.0453348123,
-0.0039434391,
-0.0085082231,
-0.0330470167,
-0.0130924601,
-0.0131596653,
0.0631147996,
0.0301902257,
-0.0273221415,
-0.0426295176,
0.0270757191,
0.0436899103,
-0.0317145027,
-0.0102024321,
-0.0162257794,
0.0417440832,
0.0130286133,
0.0037291327,
0.0017382859,
-0.0750670806,
0.0692823231,
-0.0788307786,
0.1062290817,
-0.0338921323,
-0.0051839207,
0.074712947,
-0.0031946411,
0.0213713143,
-0.0294079743,
-0.0035833588,
0.0024683885,
0.0323686227,
0.001750182,
0.0009992813,
0.0406064279,
-0.0120946178,
-0.0039884592,
0.0039054947,
0.0057314294,
-0.0186474267,
-0.0222094245,
-0.0323774405,
-0.0194450878,
-0.0185367353,
-0.0293355081,
2.673680727e-34,
0.0295159612,
-0.0006311138,
0.0174596496,
0.050238505,
0.0757118538,
-0.0299747419,
-0.0273156222,
-0.014777719,
0.0196626056,
-0.0699165985,
-0.0070880577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14684v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14684v1 | SpEL: Structured Prediction for Entity Linking | 2023-10-23T08:24:35 | 2023-10-23T08:24:35 | Hassan S. Shavarani, Anoop Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entity linking is a prominent thread of research focused on structured data
creation by linking spans of text to an ontology or knowledge source. We
revisit the use of structured prediction for entity linking which classifies
each individual input token as an entity, and aggregates the token predictions.
Our system, called SpEL (Structured prediction for Entity Linking) is a
state-of-the-art entity linking system that uses some new ideas to apply
structured prediction to the task of entity linking including: two refined
fine-tuning steps; a context sensitive prediction aggregation strategy;
reduction of the size of the model's output vocabulary, and; we address a
common problem in entity-linking systems where there is a training vs.
inference tokenization mismatch. Our experiments show that we can outperform
the state-of-the-art on the commonly used AIDA benchmark dataset for entity
linking to Wikipedia. Our method is also very compute efficient in terms of
number of parameters and speed of inference. | [
0.0226073451,
0.0119308671,
-0.0036023983,
-0.0007059867,
0.0316196829,
0.0407682434,
-0.0041101398,
-0.0032872914,
0.0212132037,
-0.0686876178,
0.0165258832,
0.028852094,
0.015293546,
0.0172486864,
0.0724517927,
-0.0497561917,
0.0417027064,
0.01100503,
-0.035176035,
-0.0026464395,
-0.0073073199,
0.056298852,
0.0091141677,
0.0125776511,
-0.0622218885,
0.0167185236,
0.0020404463,
0.0097298473,
0.0034844319,
-0.0347370319,
-0.0215330608,
0.0367224924,
-0.0144841708,
0.0475551449,
0.0000018252,
-0.081413202,
-0.0363515876,
0.0053959247,
-0.0376175232,
0.005425375,
-0.0102587054,
-0.0388547517,
0.0269607566,
-0.01761177,
0.0082381256,
-0.0454072356,
0.0187438671,
0.0381666906,
0.0301136337,
0.045954559,
-0.0032673338,
-0.0651712045,
0.067000486,
-0.0170352384,
-0.0213757455,
-0.019512495,
0.0349863656,
-0.0206435937,
-0.0204180647,
0.0394670218,
0.003440673,
0.048171863,
-0.0015618223,
0.0172875095,
0.0372011214,
0.0169753097,
-0.0532476567,
-0.0140598621,
0.000057157,
0.0599111468,
0.0179303586,
-0.0435755998,
0.0292573851,
0.0145061603,
0.0093898103,
0.0193441696,
-0.0165210161,
-0.0250947289,
-0.0170109365,
-0.0079298262,
0.0403316915,
-0.012548944,
0.0351482406,
-0.001790855,
-0.0072888848,
0.0538403206,
0.0007885144,
-0.0059487307,
0.0210220162,
0.0224583186,
-0.0137942517,
-0.0551225208,
-0.0067757592,
0.005774328,
-0.0590676218,
0.0350559354,
-0.0610619634,
-0.0166385993,
0.0093241716,
-0.0244515371,
-0.0775561333,
0.004399871,
0.0503017344,
0.0239412319,
-0.0834026635,
-0.0209784545,
-0.0349051803,
-0.0009298316,
-0.0240180232,
-0.0485483594,
-0.0645737574,
0.0230838731,
-0.0361666568,
0.0445025153,
-0.0160128661,
0.0108523266,
-0.0586398095,
-0.0120824371,
-0.0093945246,
0.084843412,
0.0110542197,
-0.0217490941,
-0.0130078066,
0.0057097715,
-0.0658600926,
-0.0169549137,
-0.0525810458,
-0.0082164956,
-0.0135634616,
-0.003929507,
0.0041018901,
-0.0079459762,
-0.0062741181,
-0.0328281336,
-0.0006284609,
0.0893277153,
0.0389159694,
0.0359200351,
-0.0756603107,
-0.1005303934,
0.0485545434,
-0.0344557092,
0.0085529005,
-0.0611701943,
0.0290074702,
0.0414930955,
0.000916259,
-0.0618441626,
0.0085193571,
0.0044277511,
-0.0807144046,
0.0866661444,
-0.0756903216,
-0.0179837104,
0.0265313946,
-0.0030085423,
-0.0029842944,
0.049483221,
0.0239501726,
0.0039304504,
0.0396758616,
0.0432009138,
-0.0714774951,
0.0175988618,
0.0831146687,
-0.0137268361,
0.0159144029,
0.0276054852,
-0.0154628577,
0.0305853896,
0.0225692969,
0.0619476661,
0.000341335,
-0.0227513313,
-0.0176625643,
0.0127798347,
0.0377731659,
0.0339799151,
0.0715420395,
-0.0266425852,
0.0199057944,
-0.0327924527,
-0.0598499477,
0.0013894838,
-0.0309358705,
0.0172478613,
0.036136318,
0.0456537381,
-0.0107911984,
0.0082432823,
-0.0018585294,
-0.0096829366,
-0.0536570959,
-0.0100356508,
0.0364743806,
0.0106126443,
-0.0441320911,
0.1164923459,
0.0530378148,
0.013370174,
0.0064322068,
-0.0019597465,
0.0079973433,
0.0434454083,
0.0323465914,
0.0009668704,
-0.0460758023,
-0.0328069851,
0.0201708954,
0.0099989315,
0.0126950219,
-0.0771858245,
-0.0251300409,
0.0002847363,
-0.0194808319,
0.0238834731,
0.0022194283,
0.006100418,
0.0413588807,
0.0572110601,
0.0461384542,
-0.0622251183,
0.021544164,
0.0553667173,
-0.014493593,
0.0184907708,
-0.0332431532,
0.0208983906,
-0.0169997588,
0.0463317931,
0.0254945923,
-0.012667682,
0.0454785228,
0.002501735,
-0.0121634472,
-0.0117270779,
0.0110375928,
-0.057616923,
0.0367747471,
-0.0173012223,
0.0019800267,
-0.0210346896,
-0.0328508839,
-0.0602318607,
-0.002966675,
0.0007364323,
0.0559505746,
0.0185682196,
0.0100251762,
0.0398302488,
0.0000186711,
-0.0154623827,
0.0778012127,
-0.019326454,
0.0330158621,
0.0256820619,
0.0200984348,
0.0018417382,
-0.0079477299,
-0.0412437692,
-0.0117373336,
0.0100287097,
-0.0270569995,
0.0205912534,
-0.0415559709,
-0.1097970605,
0.0091552716,
-0.0325274505,
0.0172363669,
-0.0019304965,
0.0135348551,
-0.0060664485,
-0.0046022371,
-0.002768738,
-0.0070103211,
0.0052450839,
-0.0119633768,
-0.0393429734,
0.0052039688,
0.0106133791,
0.0557383671,
-0.009271564,
-0.0510580093,
-0.0144547718,
-0.0462548472,
0.0478130952,
0.0199046135,
-0.0621332191,
-0.0442147255,
0.0343592316,
-0.0399875566,
-0.0097233551,
-0.0192473643,
0.038759429,
-0.0357316621,
-0.0037251227,
0.0418380797,
0.0069026342,
-0.0453965589,
-0.0015818857,
0.0078704879,
-0.0169758555,
-0.0555287413,
0.0180273373,
0.0032120354,
0.0502124764,
-0.0233812742,
0.0023478409,
0.0188400075,
0.0130140325,
-0.0387704596,
0.0046869894,
-0.0462497734,
0.0280878898,
0.0064959363,
0.0064372178,
-0.0124439243,
0.0131849563,
0.0360193364,
0.0182822738,
0.0105787246,
-0.0076391832,
0.0280034151,
-0.0057089021,
0.0253481325,
0.0236547962,
0.0207228549,
-0.0303648375,
0.0218986627,
0.0253842324,
0.014675797,
0.0080675129,
-0.0063966573,
-0.0369267724,
0.0825514272,
0.0054749325,
-0.0004153286,
0.0434089974,
0.0095030414,
0.0494956113,
0.0285181385,
0.0173089337,
-0.0212656707,
0.0155674005,
-0.0562228151,
0.016270753,
0.0249987263,
-0.0232038591,
-0.0197429825,
0.0132398428,
-0.0135053648,
-0.0078791222,
0.0523770787,
-0.0591888465,
0.020978462,
0.0133266263,
0.0576366037,
-0.0345453359,
0.0286414418,
0.0051100776,
0.0193922874,
0.0216031,
0.0590078011,
-0.0129742064,
0.0073472918,
-0.0187558811,
0.021477703,
-0.0911324546,
-0.0731478482,
0.0066085388,
0.0010691466,
-0.0409084223,
-0.0016292944,
0.1310608238,
0.063322112,
-0.0135961911,
0.0015865192,
0.0305407289,
0.0370674655,
0.0101068439,
0.0241366848,
-0.0699120685,
-0.0266354624,
-0.0019758167,
-0.0131332064,
0.0217477698,
-0.0932563543,
0.0068791234,
-0.1173705161,
-0.0152218305,
-0.023559574,
-0.0703402832,
-0.0321852081,
-0.0876295865,
-0.0017847383,
-0.0499745831,
-0.0223129876,
0.0016718101,
-0.0092475684,
0.044317212,
0.019289583,
-0.0118486714,
-0.0126251625,
0.0190339703,
-0.0813385472,
0.0859547853,
0.0027140591,
0.0229048301,
-0.0012953632,
-0.0218837708,
0.0101850154,
-0.0223631207,
-0.0466677956,
-0.0255126599,
0.091221787,
-0.0578058884,
0.0368891805,
0.0074246153,
0.0113864522,
-0.0170785449,
-0.0160603989,
-0.0258177333,
0.0632957965,
0.0444586203,
0.0279659405,
-0.0246123839,
-0.0273535959,
-0.0078910403,
0.0580495372,
-0.0320203751,
0.0045836442,
0.0079434821,
-0.024948502,
0.0072897119,
-0.0116061131,
0.0058251158,
0.0313863494,
-0.0800868645,
0.0033478406,
-0.1007349417,
-0.048061192,
0.0432471186,
0.0582609549,
-0.0031924413,
0.0494573712,
-0.0028553864,
-0.000907964,
-0.0529066809,
0.0226957388,
-0.0128996475,
0.032466162,
-0.0276919696,
-0.0294121709,
0.0390905365,
0.00534904,
-0.0333595648,
-0.0016088815,
-0.0688189045,
-0.0400035381,
-0.0009547063,
0.0193832014,
0.017133778,
0.0571764112,
-0.0194152035,
-0.0113584558,
0.0473528393,
0.0510786958,
-0.0697250366,
-0.0094511472,
-0.0056415033,
0.0449284837,
0.0119167687,
0.0661137477,
-0.0792715922,
-0.0154480403,
-0.0265142936,
0.0138755636,
-0.0430269875,
-0.0321419425,
0.0018372503,
0.0388556197,
0.0157875158,
-0.0288684089,
0.004451206,
-0.0029350263,
0.0208280347,
0.010678215,
-0.0257342495,
0.0015120509,
0.0338892862,
0.0016841763,
0.0156237306,
-0.010445999,
0.0297121257,
0.0416454673,
0.0144807966,
-0.043820031,
-0.0367425829,
0.0155347036,
0.006918421,
0.0145091685,
-0.0076408577,
0.0174392331,
-0.0378218815,
0.0384084582,
0.0537448227,
-0.0673285723,
-0.01266101,
0.0337499455,
0.0223339777,
-0.0299682152,
0.0118249422,
-0.0246991329,
0.0006845618,
-0.0195713937,
0.0255165622,
0.0299747586,
-0.0074300827,
0.0769946203,
-0.0004924941,
-0.0187919252,
0.0233353246,
0.0022625956,
0.0130650885,
-0.0061093345,
0.0494275354,
0.0027783203,
-0.0262372494,
0.0161896721,
0.0575972646,
0.010200398,
0.0656615719,
0.0017862888,
-0.0330641195,
-0.0388844647,
0.0002995517,
-0.0029643446,
0.0053956946,
-0.0064583514,
-0.028596187,
-0.0298358668,
-0.0941512734,
0.0401970521,
-0.0032140906,
-0.0042143557,
0.035499189,
0.053037893,
0.0166090559,
0.0554987043,
-0.0242951289,
0.0022102343,
-0.0515657887,
0.0080224518,
-0.0401283465,
-0.0192502458,
-5.441538205e-33,
-0.0607645847,
-0.0145923719,
0.0124232629,
0.0302295815,
-0.0202189367,
-0.008576435,
0.0031599018,
-0.0329588912,
-0.0583153851,
-0.0016358858,
-0.0047165826,
0.0129665732,
-0.0044022468,
0.0063413023,
-0.0101945801,
-0.0459696129,
0.0118490504,
0.0167975463,
-0.0181231257,
-0.00674093,
0.0416401476,
0.0155044226,
0.0409495533,
-0.0614217445,
0.0416834503,
0.0214555152,
-0.0136790369,
0.0007460943,
0.0355869196,
0.0617219284,
0.0219804533,
0.0295499619,
0.0061579971,
-0.0264351312,
0.0108911023,
-0.0090783257,
-0.120240204,
-0.0226000268,
0.0045281411,
0.0264907498,
-0.0057766638,
-0.0066166222,
0.0439100042,
0.0029467409,
0.0634389892,
-0.0246403851,
0.0428761467,
0.0091248881,
-0.0264720675,
-0.0899558663,
-0.0322729759,
0.0398641899,
0.0033724133,
0.0484018624,
0.0140299303,
-0.0159642175,
0.0396457314,
-0.0030456709,
-0.0484040976,
-0.0152178295,
-0.0120279705,
0.0166051276,
0.0258102529,
-0.001143077,
0.0042006192,
0.0457895733,
0.0211032536,
-0.0123259816,
-0.0489638411,
0.0630881786,
-0.0005751654,
0.0086759087,
0.0003265629,
0.0485108905,
-0.0005184407,
-0.0164523646,
-0.0902034566,
0.055368837,
0.0119991861,
0.033778809,
-0.056175448,
0.0096137905,
-0.0275425389,
-0.0214056149,
-0.0619253106,
-0.0023828319,
-0.0120532587,
-0.0322785079,
-0.0079884399,
-0.0139261642,
-0.0446305797,
0.0456579924,
-0.030483827,
-0.0243349951,
-0.0533447079,
0.0078773098,
0.0144996364,
0.00491502,
-0.0143592618,
0.0112773236,
-0.0808633268,
-0.0199010186,
0.0422801152,
-0.0305452291,
0.0245404392,
-0.0009105753,
0.0572221428,
0.0050930674,
-0.0739548579,
0.0164905135,
0.0061497325,
-0.0311062224,
-0.0266357884,
-0.0497455522,
0.0588646531,
0.0133717582,
0.0025283943,
-0.041559387,
0.0808966309,
0.0053088982,
-0.0146054728,
0.0342311896,
0.0247720964,
-0.0083046202,
-0.0255472735,
-0.0152750658,
-0.017023148,
0.0086498503,
0.0276601296,
-0.0773076117,
-0.0236066896,
-0.0021977136,
2.545e-7,
0.0440372303,
0.0338442586,
-0.0073817181,
0.0316948481,
-0.0092001753,
-0.0141313877,
0.0708136857,
0.0573770627,
0.0052972403,
-0.041957356,
-0.0238334481,
-0.0340924747,
-0.0160111804,
0.0521293394,
-0.1002501398,
-0.0450461023,
-0.0053524571,
0.0246057268,
-0.0300146248,
-0.0237894021,
0.0267713163,
0.0666121244,
0.0380885787,
0.000658521,
-0.0299823042,
-0.0228035972,
0.0178457461,
0.0004706878,
0.0006354736,
0.0187721476,
-0.0023023812,
0.0355340727,
-0.0178064033,
0.0782650039,
-0.0390193425,
0.0278732702,
0.0301172994,
0.004029267,
0.0177498683,
0.0091657126,
-0.0041982187,
-0.0934792608,
0.0194692984,
-0.0075466586,
0.0629539713,
-0.0074360282,
0.0266868751,
0.0691774786,
-0.0316073298,
0.0503693596,
-0.0267026257,
0.018766107,
-0.0186277404,
0.0411580838,
0.0008044881,
0.0150102507,
-0.0047527133,
-0.0863305852,
-0.0259063728,
0.0079773637,
0.0021333618,
-0.0413077809,
0.0192912612,
-0.0251184199,
0.0013626579,
-0.0714792386,
-0.0093364902,
2.415422093e-34,
-0.016371835,
0.0042157909,
-0.0277750883,
0.0394644029,
0.0553891249,
-0.0707599297,
-0.0065430468,
-0.0026051539,
0.0179175045,
-0.0438514203,
0.0093370024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14676v1 | Pre-Trained Language Models Augmented with Synthetic Scanpaths for Natural Language Understanding | 2023-10-23T08:15:38 | 2023-10-23T08:15:38 | Shuwen Deng, Paul Prasse, David R. Reich, Tobias Scheffer, Lena A. Jäger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human gaze data offer cognitive information that reflects natural language
comprehension. Indeed, augmenting language models with human scanpaths has
proven beneficial for a range of NLP tasks, including language understanding.
However, the applicability of this approach is hampered because the abundance
of text corpora is contrasted by a scarcity of gaze data. Although models for
the generation of human-like scanpaths during reading have been developed, the
potential of synthetic gaze data across NLP tasks remains largely unexplored.
We develop a model that integrates synthetic scanpath generation with a
scanpath-augmented language model, eliminating the need for human gaze data.
Since the model's error gradient can be propagated throughout all parts of the
model, the scanpath generator can be fine-tuned to downstream tasks. We find
that the proposed model not only outperforms the underlying language model, but
achieves a performance that is comparable to a language model augmented with
real human gaze data. Our code is publicly available. | [
0.0389534533,
0.045139581,
-0.0110050458,
0.0378623046,
0.0332390629,
0.0212037843,
0.0152392546,
-0.0164838154,
0.0436200984,
-0.0226374455,
-0.0293000787,
-0.0097967898,
0.0028823798,
0.0665721372,
0.0539001338,
-0.0877572522,
0.0074420073,
-0.0628899038,
-0.0608163886,
0.0363172479,
0.0127085587,
0.0494014397,
-0.0126917437,
0.0185540617,
-0.0291044228,
-0.0126309674,
-0.0641072616,
0.0301291607,
0.0435319133,
-0.0355316103,
0.0184918884,
0.0600164533,
0.0122471182,
0.0059796516,
0.000001971,
0.014079689,
-0.0012273348,
-0.018923616,
-0.005287854,
0.0035134407,
0.0846869126,
-0.0257732533,
0.0207465757,
-0.0046151485,
-0.0035987287,
-0.0472154431,
0.0326483324,
0.020702444,
0.0515538827,
0.0324630775,
-0.0207462236,
0.0152976662,
0.0294828452,
-0.0258628447,
0.0252353903,
-0.0674878284,
0.0118581709,
0.0349959321,
-0.0366045348,
0.0768209919,
-0.0042540533,
0.0255963057,
0.0131213972,
-0.0050380197,
0.0673505962,
0.0482338145,
0.0064799227,
-0.0244776383,
-0.0243490003,
0.0962035432,
-0.0231633987,
-0.075372979,
-0.0091315294,
-0.0287106633,
-0.0094366437,
0.0292389672,
0.00395433,
-0.0180303324,
0.0006972822,
0.0388576575,
0.018444676,
-0.0168453939,
0.0205997452,
0.0160807688,
-0.0101254182,
0.018904848,
0.0060463683,
-0.0145799853,
0.0161039196,
0.0366424359,
0.0168321915,
-0.0297538023,
0.0403657109,
0.0300010685,
0.0421143882,
0.0272177998,
-0.0855528265,
-0.0808350444,
0.0122084226,
0.0059986613,
0.051934462,
0.0117215188,
-0.0522273853,
0.0384401046,
-0.0451730974,
0.0271230508,
-0.0610490479,
0.0122958571,
-0.0583777837,
-0.015036541,
0.0102179674,
-0.0132330097,
-0.0420832448,
-0.0299907196,
-0.0711861178,
-0.0425630696,
-0.0274751671,
0.0445782915,
0.0518957078,
-0.0343395248,
-0.0087007834,
0.031108886,
-0.0412341282,
-0.0040930128,
0.0082811303,
0.0116395773,
-0.0518821999,
0.0310887117,
-0.0237319563,
-0.0610247068,
-0.0238598697,
0.0313498639,
0.002797873,
0.0101337386,
-0.0072808191,
0.0250693206,
0.014086551,
-0.0610142425,
-0.059488792,
0.0085363453,
-0.0047373646,
-0.0247020386,
0.0057750894,
-0.0751416162,
0.0370191671,
0.0043864865,
0.0013703594,
-0.0194438845,
0.0004008277,
0.0438708551,
-0.0408559963,
0.0521986783,
-0.063735798,
-0.0003953509,
-0.0277389977,
-0.025456544,
0.0111662839,
0.025804054,
0.0253262892,
0.0100392569,
0.0082890019,
0.0006213958,
0.0363108926,
0.0563776568,
0.0002795856,
0.0003954052,
0.0145896003,
-0.0074759806,
0.0162980687,
0.0142406765,
0.0627673492,
0.0375276096,
-0.0472408831,
-0.0229820013,
0.0523704886,
0.1117251962,
-0.0015406493,
0.0301342215,
0.007762061,
0.014142503,
0.0051869866,
-0.0121425679,
-0.0378687121,
-0.0231363364,
-0.0324092433,
-0.0076024299,
-0.0023977561,
-0.045232594,
-0.0179762393,
-0.0524138361,
0.0007381129,
0.0097750882,
0.0255534872,
0.0321106426,
0.0651916638,
-0.008335283,
-0.0178090911,
0.0116449539,
0.0445101969,
-0.0846710056,
-0.0120640118,
0.0102722645,
0.0138953291,
0.0949495733,
0.0476173684,
-0.0038017109,
-0.0461118035,
0.0330772512,
-0.0261518005,
0.0254837107,
0.0455555543,
0.0070115039,
0.04041842,
-0.0643191263,
-0.0129861198,
0.0214123111,
0.0007885853,
0.0032738145,
-0.0003194223,
-0.0208757054,
0.0214338694,
-0.0257743876,
-0.0885840505,
0.0530844592,
-0.0422446094,
0.0091085061,
-0.0421939567,
0.0068539144,
-0.0395967476,
0.0086142402,
0.0074085295,
-0.0105742346,
0.0573320836,
0.0115089472,
0.0586365387,
0.0093735615,
-0.0004266795,
-0.013364993,
0.0095990226,
-0.0476872809,
-0.0235349331,
0.0360022485,
0.0019902543,
-0.0185877327,
-0.027059203,
-0.0551935919,
-0.0044951211,
-0.0319733843,
0.020175539,
0.0162946731,
0.0181193426,
-0.043445304,
0.052477736,
0.0011237443,
0.0329846255,
0.01948273,
-0.0130040236,
-0.0109340539,
-0.0367739461,
-0.0022342789,
-0.0126608564,
0.0420110226,
-0.0186173022,
-0.011294595,
-0.0086043095,
-0.0769890323,
-0.0041469731,
-0.0449544452,
-0.0021502387,
-0.0181172658,
0.0075786398,
0.0457791202,
-0.0096072173,
-0.0345410854,
-0.0417203084,
-0.0210001413,
0.0208915621,
0.0071944743,
-0.0426521748,
0.032178428,
-0.0192241818,
0.0228283834,
-0.052599933,
-0.0076808278,
-0.0312832221,
0.0263961796,
0.0679625496,
0.0180442967,
-0.0739127845,
0.0877669677,
0.031939894,
0.0375852771,
-0.029711714,
-0.0211751275,
0.0210019778,
-0.0721968189,
-0.0362166688,
0.0856560767,
-0.0050331913,
0.0342435427,
0.0157763325,
-0.015334907,
-0.0425735973,
0.005745342,
-0.0111448057,
0.0368048102,
-0.0760383457,
-0.0515397899,
0.015637463,
0.0282124057,
-0.0083438717,
-0.0049826484,
-0.0353086554,
0.0002161783,
-0.0066996245,
-0.0500322059,
-0.0382269882,
0.0193071757,
-0.0306958649,
0.0658731386,
-0.0297424756,
-0.0514134429,
0.0284032375,
-0.0551775917,
-0.0318498164,
-0.0407420844,
0.0336922258,
0.0042180573,
0.0568742417,
0.0321723819,
-0.0077318703,
-0.00536311,
-0.0330083556,
-0.010594015,
0.026875468,
-0.0066363523,
-0.025809098,
0.0338868722,
-0.0380839296,
0.0069925222,
0.0128321536,
0.0241031516,
-0.0644984022,
-0.0198381059,
-0.0348223299,
-0.047227066,
0.0068630376,
-0.0092012212,
-0.0355758518,
0.0025677395,
0.0253535677,
0.0748900771,
0.0051451293,
-0.0513078123,
-0.038349513,
0.0204491951,
0.0582751259,
-0.0043237568,
-0.0003943972,
-0.0409776121,
-0.0326784141,
0.0958063751,
0.0381019637,
-0.0227210391,
-0.0486445054,
0.0245678741,
0.0643414706,
-0.0040779272,
-0.0070900475,
0.0212114565,
0.0419869609,
-0.0737227425,
-0.004911426,
0.1196298078,
0.0524786301,
-0.0264177136,
-0.0254375562,
0.0281258151,
0.0190464556,
0.0124017652,
0.0154370042,
-0.0340235718,
-0.0355711393,
0.0120182345,
0.056528952,
0.0318134166,
-0.0059389495,
0.027816996,
-0.0510708317,
0.0394921117,
0.0065082572,
0.0102750976,
-0.0381858014,
-0.0138183367,
0.0238787718,
-0.0407065414,
-0.0322747119,
0.024052104,
-0.0358790308,
0.0123934262,
0.004777038,
0.0647575334,
0.0558418706,
-0.0217527375,
-0.0386713631,
-0.000781121,
0.0273346305,
0.0418491773,
0.0312186461,
-0.0092462944,
-0.0159188304,
-0.0470767841,
0.017359579,
-0.0010418026,
0.0979254693,
-0.040820919,
-0.0070994426,
-0.0556349754,
0.0536672622,
-0.0480465516,
-0.0028075427,
-0.0255330931,
-0.0019438192,
-0.0153951431,
0.0066971416,
0.0168954656,
-0.0274843834,
-0.0548929907,
0.0403663777,
0.014327026,
-0.0250048619,
-0.042320922,
-0.0378962867,
0.0152184684,
-0.0542492457,
-0.0660087094,
0.02765394,
0.0260721371,
-0.0540889911,
-0.0514215156,
-0.0943809971,
0.0362422355,
0.0495171621,
0.0094238985,
-0.0308375116,
0.0764747784,
-0.0426735245,
-0.0083519993,
0.0883539915,
-0.0425883532,
-0.0183907356,
-0.0085953437,
-0.037291348,
-0.0109671354,
-0.0389898494,
-0.0140730822,
0.0527335033,
-0.0816098154,
-0.067961812,
0.0091064489,
0.0532415211,
0.0207536463,
0.0553130396,
-0.0547475629,
-0.0170429163,
0.0160259455,
-0.035716705,
-0.0402256846,
0.0076765912,
0.028245585,
-0.0225589331,
0.0042821718,
0.0084187808,
-0.0061368947,
-0.0092224078,
0.0151674245,
0.00667596,
-0.0367315225,
-0.0881151035,
0.033716213,
0.0108307283,
0.0724271908,
0.0015603502,
0.0172949005,
-0.059884306,
-0.0036242965,
-0.0265406221,
0.0134793939,
-0.0279493611,
0.0308715198,
0.0420882404,
0.0218577124,
-0.0181069113,
-0.0711548701,
-0.0382222757,
0.0084108952,
-0.0640455559,
-0.000968695,
0.0222470108,
-0.0063975267,
0.0063387323,
-0.0018483532,
0.005690149,
0.0295423605,
-0.0500164106,
0.0442305505,
0.0225522891,
0.0492262095,
0.019842064,
-0.0183198433,
-0.0056360024,
0.0247789342,
-0.0689189062,
-0.0198117215,
-0.0401247032,
0.037713401,
0.0269771684,
-0.0290834792,
0.0605530031,
-0.0345105603,
0.0091361376,
-0.0178208333,
0.0258218441,
0.0180821642,
-0.0268976185,
-0.0056618401,
0.021404881,
0.0195486452,
-0.0634443536,
0.0639192387,
0.005823974,
0.0545653626,
0.011476784,
-0.0409916081,
-0.0567221008,
0.0095029399,
0.0023823841,
-0.0126577001,
-0.0376510099,
0.0729423463,
-0.0173239335,
-0.0669031069,
0.0218945127,
0.0327856392,
0.0172285996,
-0.0129796555,
0.0851803273,
0.0482102595,
-0.0230257157,
0.0091454219,
-0.0447636396,
0.0417614393,
-0.025626624,
-0.0204954427,
-0.0477203317,
-6.263411529e-33,
0.0030389794,
-0.0233593807,
0.0024632704,
0.0084156059,
-0.0324224532,
0.0099342335,
-0.0222503021,
0.0266439766,
-0.0116525497,
0.0043714582,
0.0135595091,
0.0247428082,
0.010595195,
0.0289873872,
-0.0272762477,
-0.0133151999,
0.012074721,
-0.0104515702,
-0.0127256243,
0.011381059,
0.0316831395,
0.0022336696,
0.0569441393,
0.0268214196,
0.0174704604,
-0.0536638536,
0.0053224047,
0.027137924,
0.021880893,
0.0406549498,
-0.0442846827,
0.0511819348,
0.0183069557,
0.0041493224,
0.0062954868,
0.0494596213,
-0.1017637327,
-0.0009541233,
0.0055841403,
0.0504525974,
-0.0585061759,
-0.0068853772,
0.0376374461,
-0.0242450349,
0.0064048744,
0.0245755333,
0.0420039222,
-0.0247467645,
-0.0186349787,
0.0212079287,
-0.0311333481,
0.0082518077,
-0.0398993865,
-0.0429567955,
0.0364335105,
0.0798515379,
0.0068699368,
0.0197925698,
-0.0341687351,
0.0111016287,
0.0004409767,
0.0196573455,
0.0268346239,
0.035574019,
0.0255532935,
0.0554728918,
0.0038268166,
-0.0226771999,
-0.033513274,
-0.0165601112,
0.0660498813,
-0.0029376037,
0.013975977,
-0.011034769,
0.0009048801,
0.0315639041,
-0.0121588362,
0.0381527916,
0.0147593059,
0.0484277457,
0.0280767158,
-0.0053350898,
-0.0539614409,
0.0197751913,
-0.0506328121,
-0.0418644361,
-0.0361643359,
0.0039492352,
0.0312076937,
0.0333659425,
-0.0153578334,
0.0271284916,
0.0292323083,
0.0003343376,
0.0192292444,
0.0192533247,
-0.015432491,
0.0130669391,
-0.0093708653,
0.0461011901,
-0.007818359,
-0.0176829342,
0.0305586699,
-0.0051348717,
0.0135710295,
-0.0132844541,
-0.0121042402,
-0.0586724505,
-0.0285911672,
-0.0029083979,
-0.0385122299,
0.0016400228,
0.0005294514,
0.0201894436,
0.0775232613,
-0.0147275357,
-0.0382446721,
0.0326380096,
-0.0162351057,
0.0354912877,
-0.0697788,
0.0037938051,
0.0053385808,
0.0190262347,
-0.0391585343,
-0.0081084026,
-0.026225172,
-0.0256114323,
-0.0023849814,
-0.0889161602,
-0.0248008352,
0.0490978621,
2.539e-7,
0.0639284551,
0.0359919854,
0.0510459915,
0.0261178408,
0.015648881,
0.0407390967,
0.0153598702,
0.0134116914,
0.0104724672,
-0.0530174449,
-0.0139358826,
0.0433338508,
0.0262507722,
-0.0367431268,
-0.072149992,
0.0180612933,
0.0505924448,
0.0087962179,
-0.0211984254,
0.0215337165,
0.0310424492,
0.0574564561,
-0.011984379,
0.0086261248,
0.0392345302,
-0.0133067099,
0.029675398,
0.0075930865,
-0.007263551,
-0.0054994696,
0.0431263037,
0.0362439118,
-0.0328507982,
0.0259333123,
-0.0208693575,
0.0017943925,
0.0406268165,
0.0256950073,
-0.0223271903,
-0.0148683814,
0.0034649298,
-0.0304880701,
-0.0008111267,
-0.0789922178,
0.0528295115,
-0.0149702104,
0.0118999798,
0.0324359685,
-0.0451121964,
0.027540544,
-0.005204041,
-0.005572407,
-0.0213538669,
0.007589262,
0.045088049,
-0.0593267195,
-0.0020196328,
-0.0772924796,
-0.0610031486,
-0.0098275272,
-0.0315430276,
-0.0157310851,
-0.0420937575,
-0.055865746,
0.0522817932,
-0.0400978886,
-0.0044362657,
1.918242969e-34,
0.0354608595,
0.0097878855,
-0.0018062141,
0.0095397457,
0.0182461161,
-0.0024234478,
-0.012147936,
-0.0183057468,
0.0401408672,
-0.1102675125,
-0.0175528675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14670v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14670v2 | Dataset Bias Mitigation in Multiple-Choice Visual Question Answering and Beyond | 2023-10-23T08:09:42 | 2023-10-31T20:49:11 | Zhecan Wang, Long Chen, Haoxuan You, Keyang Xu, Yicheng He, Wenhao Li, Noel Codella, Kai-Wei Chang, Shih-Fu Chang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | Vision-language (VL) understanding tasks evaluate models' comprehension of
complex visual scenes through multiple-choice questions. However, we have
identified two dataset biases that models can exploit as shortcuts to resolve
various VL tasks correctly without proper understanding. The first type of
dataset bias is \emph{Unbalanced Matching} bias, where the correct answer
overlaps the question and image more than the incorrect answers. The second
type of dataset bias is \emph{Distractor Similarity} bias, where incorrect
answers are overly dissimilar to the correct answer but significantly similar
to other incorrect answers within the same sample. To address these dataset
biases, we first propose Adversarial Data Synthesis (ADS) to generate synthetic
training and debiased evaluation data. We then introduce Intra-sample
Counterfactual Training (ICT) to assist models in utilizing the synthesized
training data, particularly the counterfactual data, via focusing on
intra-sample differentiation. Extensive experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of ADS and ICT in consistently improving model performance across
different benchmarks, even in domain-shifted scenarios. | [
0.0192564894,
0.0590614676,
-0.0410384908,
0.0613227822,
-0.0239545964,
0.0260856654,
0.0223954972,
0.0037794397,
0.0518743359,
-0.0463530533,
-0.0424662307,
0.001982278,
-0.021625137,
0.0000419136,
0.0510202385,
-0.0646404326,
0.0374142863,
-0.0269496497,
-0.0177068748,
-0.0065026172,
0.0064812265,
-0.0221507195,
0.0247194879,
-0.0169886947,
0.0033911394,
-0.0351791233,
0.0107724415,
0.0320929177,
0.0340919085,
-0.0116819171,
0.0247080233,
0.0317505486,
0.0150210494,
0.0198612008,
0.0000019273,
-0.0069419146,
0.0357953608,
-0.0019873169,
-0.031845808,
0.0032190192,
-0.0379312187,
-0.0207885969,
0.0382338427,
0.0014041957,
-0.0390150174,
-0.034719348,
0.0580738857,
0.0284541287,
0.0764887109,
0.0340870358,
-0.000793677,
0.0043479679,
-0.0062039755,
-0.0294979811,
0.0284620039,
-0.0247786883,
0.0111962687,
0.0412549824,
-0.0350616276,
-0.007185875,
-0.0707464442,
0.032205902,
0.0537480861,
0.0529898442,
-0.00862836,
0.037549369,
-0.0361270793,
-0.007755843,
-0.0032819144,
0.1007235646,
-0.0174397752,
-0.0301667061,
-0.037436761,
-0.0326113924,
0.0534456149,
0.0250749588,
-0.0736391172,
0.0027511143,
-0.0358953699,
-0.0000086952,
-0.05092448,
-0.0067844638,
-0.0007230322,
0.0036300521,
0.010206176,
-0.0454302952,
0.0255405847,
0.0105456794,
-0.0053169644,
0.0295491889,
-0.0532428063,
-0.0423815362,
-0.0075456263,
-0.001721125,
-0.0290696044,
-0.0102263168,
-0.0515998267,
-0.0526520573,
0.0013257817,
-0.0305690411,
0.0579200201,
-0.00894327,
-0.0743698776,
0.0329726189,
-0.0179262962,
0.0742890686,
-0.0434775651,
0.0587710291,
-0.0401706658,
-0.0311404932,
-0.0068486263,
-0.0184724648,
-0.0211442877,
-0.0038355482,
-0.0515364185,
0.0042502447,
0.007529953,
0.0153018469,
-0.0546160974,
0.0157553051,
-0.0094035463,
0.076676406,
-0.0265646558,
-0.0163719412,
-0.0691554546,
0.0497372039,
-0.0529675186,
0.0335533284,
0.0017574631,
-0.073541671,
-0.0172762964,
0.0231281556,
-0.0052051172,
-0.0562925562,
0.0064180261,
0.1060447469,
-0.0412810296,
0.0028332293,
-0.0148290973,
-0.0112904813,
0.0202077609,
-0.0493748784,
0.0536050536,
-0.0511958338,
0.040539965,
0.0062467684,
-0.0274288915,
-0.0353810936,
-0.0195132568,
0.0298519805,
-0.0206113514,
0.0881253555,
0.0036234113,
-0.0371359251,
0.0147794746,
0.0112251807,
-0.0107911061,
0.0821016133,
-0.0124591673,
0.0291394424,
0.0568178967,
-0.0144838039,
0.0357379131,
0.0327448621,
0.0534772612,
0.0080958763,
-0.0602039881,
0.077327393,
0.0044386298,
0.0091707241,
0.0392875299,
0.021382926,
-0.0336109139,
-0.0940471739,
0.0749719441,
-0.0309379008,
-0.0186445042,
-0.0030870896,
-0.0189170409,
-0.0061471891,
0.0085339313,
0.0377429985,
-0.0582718179,
0.0687602013,
0.002521008,
0.0058199265,
-0.0259961113,
0.0412588865,
-0.0409901142,
-0.0350017697,
0.0231923498,
0.0167263448,
0.0021970305,
0.0772491768,
0.0280327909,
0.041517172,
-0.0356714427,
0.0032023094,
-0.0068340683,
0.0031736619,
0.007409832,
-0.0332952887,
0.0275408607,
0.0255996007,
0.0374031104,
-0.0172311477,
-0.039764449,
0.0051021054,
0.0365056619,
0.0092630871,
0.0479985252,
-0.0208819527,
0.0378824659,
-0.029161498,
-0.041258119,
-0.0332466029,
-0.0180402435,
0.0313459076,
0.0282595102,
-0.0256499238,
-0.0041831895,
-0.0542035066,
-0.0042836452,
0.0283120777,
0.0176175907,
-0.0328789279,
0.0049652653,
0.0242036413,
0.0202477295,
-0.0323985294,
-0.0096201357,
-0.005555158,
0.0058123218,
0.0016816126,
0.0245524328,
-0.0315829441,
-0.0159520842,
-0.0528786518,
0.0091568157,
-0.0945749134,
-0.0591853894,
0.0857672393,
-0.0610457882,
0.0062410529,
0.0253407191,
-0.0043049389,
-0.0379449204,
-0.0095152203,
-0.0440517478,
0.0307308361,
0.0397960953,
-0.0282270741,
0.0487423651,
-0.0018323266,
-0.0012945203,
0.0074698278,
0.023567142,
0.0477937236,
-0.0165507607,
0.0320122838,
-0.0072939605,
-0.0053658155,
0.004638474,
0.011079872,
-0.0066785752,
-0.0687298924,
0.0130433943,
-0.0273527578,
-0.0014523268,
-0.024899805,
-0.0298149437,
0.0348973237,
-0.0146600856,
-0.002878156,
-0.0703006908,
-0.0423061587,
0.0249592196,
-0.0070387633,
0.0240600649,
0.0397620648,
-0.0021168138,
0.0348372124,
-0.0239309315,
-0.0098540224,
0.0038057372,
0.0687871203,
0.0184093453,
0.0299857967,
-0.0312598012,
0.0021153672,
-0.0336195007,
0.0768294856,
-0.0272019655,
-0.0141581511,
0.0138974329,
0.0034214782,
0.0034976932,
0.087619476,
-0.0125133423,
-0.002530474,
0.04278934,
-0.0030078946,
-0.0344041549,
-0.0049869558,
0.0141906692,
-0.0297057703,
-0.0017304154,
-0.0377318859,
-0.0285285469,
0.0047203377,
0.0273203701,
-0.0250601247,
-0.0353613272,
0.0520062558,
0.0331313834,
-0.0626067966,
-0.0698160306,
0.0194362216,
0.0265521463,
0.0512811393,
-0.0635287985,
-0.0677475333,
0.0911339074,
-0.0002706289,
-0.017394593,
-0.0115456497,
0.0219480619,
0.0020222955,
0.0432613268,
0.0271693468,
-0.0013454141,
0.0259456635,
0.0192623157,
-0.1053298712,
-0.0421761386,
0.0254991539,
-0.0025794047,
0.0484971106,
-0.0608414561,
-0.0251001939,
-0.0282199904,
-0.030076541,
-0.0547681488,
-0.0561664999,
0.036850702,
-0.0046022856,
-0.0395391397,
0.0030819422,
-0.0180927422,
-0.0220435746,
0.0140194222,
0.0049690581,
-0.0311793964,
-0.0026930745,
-0.0070610843,
0.087651439,
0.0734386593,
0.0524375811,
0.0109255211,
-0.036553435,
0.0109985294,
0.0576107204,
0.0451003946,
0.0007160365,
-0.0332351886,
0.0213101562,
0.0121060321,
0.0426956229,
0.0253213681,
0.0202743635,
0.0438849553,
-0.0238950159,
-0.0134711508,
0.0437636115,
0.0046034171,
0.00247959,
-0.0019441009,
0.021969825,
0.0255837981,
0.036589954,
0.0350437276,
-0.0702456683,
-0.0326367505,
-0.0297175944,
0.0135816503,
0.0085092913,
0.0129177412,
-0.0051296153,
-0.1059942022,
0.0455801114,
0.0052146059,
-0.0330811031,
-0.0506628379,
-0.0051180301,
-0.0250214208,
-0.0252332296,
0.0160059687,
-0.0226717051,
0.02572795,
0.0087304926,
0.0081368564,
0.0505501367,
-0.0166743547,
0.00977307,
-0.0539783426,
0.008358839,
0.0433348939,
0.020224534,
-0.0072241109,
-0.0199911911,
0.0006288519,
-0.0455803014,
-0.0069851126,
0.0052707833,
0.1025058702,
-0.0040318491,
-0.0501447842,
-0.0020221365,
0.0493297689,
-0.00707332,
-0.0215919279,
0.02291812,
0.0257866159,
-0.0032645243,
-0.0128659233,
-0.0370400362,
-0.0113337971,
0.0084644137,
0.0097512249,
0.0349557027,
-0.0157267377,
-0.0352653302,
-0.03032922,
0.0194135737,
-0.064573139,
0.0138663845,
0.0057794065,
0.0240298491,
0.0206191223,
-0.0449086577,
-0.0650097281,
0.0397641622,
0.036744494,
-0.0257821884,
-0.0440451242,
-0.0517692976,
0.0127021549,
-0.0458888933,
0.0583296977,
-0.0221980978,
0.0404689573,
0.0136991264,
-0.041950278,
-0.0199295748,
-0.0460430644,
-0.0360796303,
0.0348597355,
-0.0705830231,
-0.0158647932,
-0.0057859081,
0.0759516805,
0.0092506055,
0.0579540059,
0.0114868684,
-0.0308855753,
0.0178973414,
0.0420687869,
0.0150176585,
-0.0113459257,
0.0124615636,
-0.0429785587,
0.0114472397,
-0.0035297023,
-0.0189767517,
0.0171430856,
0.0776582882,
-0.0149110695,
-0.0138480961,
0.0167775434,
0.0226374641,
0.0128267324,
0.0528819785,
-0.0062472187,
0.0496468097,
-0.0229498632,
0.0089827962,
-0.0019645193,
-0.0051336582,
-0.0289975051,
-0.0341235697,
0.0282734334,
-0.0140701495,
0.0008553201,
-0.0079713548,
-0.0110747563,
-0.0134989237,
-0.0656590462,
-0.0214976203,
0.062882483,
0.0370801836,
-0.0054573347,
0.016069442,
-0.0153393121,
0.0178175215,
0.0250798892,
0.0424601361,
0.0220724791,
0.0586608015,
0.046574302,
-0.0008599489,
-0.0300193336,
0.0013360826,
-0.0683767796,
-0.0067758597,
-0.0396486111,
0.0521053411,
0.025576042,
-0.0197979491,
-0.02766129,
0.0072988952,
-0.0114900917,
-0.0163836908,
-0.0148964068,
0.0095451549,
-0.0268679075,
0.0670333207,
0.0163964592,
0.0208935663,
-0.0144365495,
0.0871667042,
0.054917559,
0.0619509667,
-0.0205842294,
-0.0122650405,
-0.0427513123,
-0.0245339833,
0.0418741256,
-0.024508426,
0.0263421237,
0.0441107638,
-0.0358143039,
-0.0974960923,
-0.0275175292,
0.0579152331,
0.0154518224,
0.0236001518,
0.0321248583,
0.0428388193,
0.0173285846,
-0.0474017411,
0.0121706044,
0.0225858111,
-0.0299413372,
-0.0080557438,
-0.0351483524,
-5.89097598e-33,
-0.0347456597,
-0.0105849663,
0.0313080996,
-0.0545419306,
0.0067921374,
-0.0180899631,
-0.0201606229,
-0.03957849,
-0.0497645624,
-0.0067513473,
-0.0007427582,
0.0204650201,
-0.0048372084,
0.0483298749,
-0.0231286846,
-0.0658488199,
0.0383614451,
-0.0180572085,
-0.0387638062,
0.0029262013,
0.0099044191,
-0.0029057919,
0.0419563949,
-0.0526800863,
0.0073435204,
-0.0136617133,
-0.0061215879,
0.0077064796,
-0.0134520382,
0.0461694151,
0.0007293113,
0.047914885,
0.01802448,
0.0043975739,
-0.043168705,
-0.0057122512,
-0.0821874514,
-0.0548914,
0.0374379531,
0.0396694541,
-0.032929156,
0.0097525232,
0.0294091385,
-0.0096081011,
0.0226798821,
-0.0431532785,
0.0392044298,
-0.0284411963,
0.009080396,
0.0446876176,
-0.017163666,
-0.023471687,
-0.0102381352,
-0.0234305803,
-0.0013668787,
0.0709251687,
0.0257065911,
0.0355910324,
-0.0361747146,
0.0160142183,
0.0312031973,
0.0011826595,
0.0602755062,
0.0681926906,
0.0156048639,
0.0441002101,
0.0753746331,
-0.0271434765,
0.005009972,
-0.044538904,
-0.0029562679,
0.032016065,
0.083450608,
0.119968608,
0.0600641184,
0.0058867722,
-0.0564180575,
0.0140893795,
-0.0785657093,
0.016473189,
-0.0231743809,
-0.0098274425,
0.0085006971,
-0.0270055328,
-0.0557351261,
-0.0288147144,
-0.0318002477,
0.0177558884,
0.0767423511,
-0.018009359,
-0.0069157328,
0.0475564562,
0.0250764936,
-0.0556904562,
0.0075128987,
0.0320986249,
0.003017104,
0.0209768191,
0.0268969052,
0.0216368269,
-0.0393792391,
0.0259501841,
0.0678942576,
0.0137711372,
-0.0110362079,
0.0169297233,
0.0242316294,
0.0103377327,
-0.0383920223,
-0.0077357241,
-0.0637432933,
0.0156677309,
0.0215759668,
-0.0133388499,
0.0128736431,
0.0141216181,
-0.0454766639,
-0.0348622762,
-0.0073783025,
-0.0480375923,
-0.0164139681,
-0.0027067224,
-0.0450484082,
0.0407357141,
-0.0166856609,
-0.0208005011,
-0.0487086177,
-0.0744101629,
0.018131353,
-0.0912814215,
-0.0155722471,
0.0242670812,
2.396e-7,
-0.0017901261,
0.0015380221,
0.0188835561,
0.0270568561,
0.0266065001,
0.0639931709,
-0.035466291,
0.0190589223,
0.031229062,
-0.0160600785,
-0.00632824,
0.0446683988,
0.0005490952,
0.0212196056,
0.019045908,
0.0563118607,
-0.0202273037,
0.0101985717,
-0.0217341445,
-0.0053706528,
0.0142802903,
0.0745241269,
-0.0024606611,
-0.0126868319,
0.0425794087,
-0.0295967273,
0.0554252416,
-0.0382879861,
0.0311286487,
-0.0322282389,
-0.0041156127,
-0.0013457718,
0.0163064264,
0.0862677321,
-0.0054611908,
-0.0616764389,
0.0430918857,
-0.0157535933,
-0.0009265617,
-0.0441427827,
-0.0664113238,
-0.0013785459,
-0.0096464287,
-0.0564031638,
0.0779773071,
-0.0548441745,
-0.0331511311,
-0.0357489884,
-0.0683501139,
0.0052100061,
0.0155322887,
-0.0036775903,
-0.0272256751,
-0.008871017,
0.0340619236,
0.0201598611,
0.0112031512,
-0.0268243067,
-0.006805208,
0.0026211313,
-0.026141502,
-0.0288028587,
-0.0506011508,
0.009028228,
0.0416011885,
-0.0030726532,
-0.0399985202,
1.666333726e-34,
0.015862491,
0.0072525018,
0.0257404763,
-0.0369218774,
-0.0044920566,
-0.0317435972,
0.0075135254,
-0.0240727905,
0.0365190245,
-0.0268401988,
-0.0180356391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14663v1 | DPP-TTS: Diversifying prosodic features of speech via determinantal point processes | 2023-10-23T07:59:46 | 2023-10-23T07:59:46 | Seongho Joo, Hyukhun Koh, Kyomin Jung | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | With the rapid advancement in deep generative models, recent neural
Text-To-Speech(TTS) models have succeeded in synthesizing human-like speech.
There have been some efforts to generate speech with various prosody beyond
monotonous prosody patterns. However, previous works have several limitations.
First, typical TTS models depend on the scaled sampling temperature for
boosting the diversity of prosody. Speech samples generated at high sampling
temperatures often lack perceptual prosodic diversity, which can adversely
affect the naturalness of the speech. Second, the diversity among samples is
neglected since the sampling procedure often focuses on a single speech sample
rather than multiple ones. In this paper, we propose DPP-TTS: a text-to-speech
model based on Determinantal Point Processes (DPPs) with a prosody diversifying
module. Our TTS model is capable of generating speech samples that
simultaneously consider perceptual diversity in each sample and among multiple
samples. We demonstrate that DPP-TTS generates speech samples with more
diversified prosody than baselines in the side-by-side comparison test
considering the naturalness of speech at the same time. | [
-0.0354369208,
0.0653101951,
0.0190632008,
-0.0341511704,
-0.0066349222,
-0.016453933,
0.0551652797,
-0.0051921662,
-0.0490834415,
0.0300233401,
-0.0478592999,
-0.0658280179,
0.0375209823,
0.0431676619,
0.0634938478,
-0.0884564519,
-0.0017444761,
-0.0465872325,
0.0257867668,
-0.0432409868,
0.0241391733,
-0.0094837258,
-0.0527879782,
0.0015313141,
-0.0569541939,
-0.0294960346,
-0.0209167618,
0.0002433525,
0.0464688167,
-0.0161562618,
-0.0231571253,
0.0368080512,
0.0051104892,
-0.0091214376,
0.0000018893,
-0.0358823612,
0.0110738613,
0.014462403,
-0.0084843077,
0.0062457584,
-0.0011650453,
0.0454426669,
-0.0065234257,
0.0131740328,
-0.0182071291,
0.002641222,
0.0358238593,
0.0505459905,
-0.0169272088,
0.0620973185,
-0.0306808222,
-0.0490162522,
0.023650283,
-0.0296236072,
-0.0410969444,
0.0391599014,
-0.0247137994,
-0.0259279292,
0.0425178371,
0.0110934777,
0.0190484393,
0.0154794473,
0.0280741006,
0.0450694859,
0.0346831456,
0.039222084,
0.0287885591,
-0.0415071435,
0.0115616908,
0.0634719059,
-0.0229618642,
-0.0124701243,
0.0231022593,
-0.0193416849,
0.0046486999,
-0.0542156287,
-0.013414491,
0.0162059162,
0.0159102213,
0.0094692614,
0.0323413014,
0.0335487984,
-0.0002303396,
-0.0362659357,
-0.018408889,
0.0171490889,
0.0417229161,
-0.0424815342,
-0.006465801,
-0.0010054098,
0.0276684836,
-0.0094191525,
0.0248005763,
-0.0205369964,
-0.017076103,
-0.0411328673,
-0.0312560908,
-0.0381882973,
-0.028381804,
0.0141705852,
0.0321227498,
0.0056242137,
-0.0893873498,
-0.0268356558,
-0.0035243926,
0.007676404,
-0.0264287125,
-0.0410948545,
-0.035315007,
0.0182222985,
0.0316604748,
0.0262032207,
0.0050039762,
0.0057203728,
-0.0162613224,
0.0100371307,
-0.0140669206,
0.0068072909,
-0.0455079116,
-0.0454390459,
0.0348129719,
0.0464503504,
-0.0708600953,
-0.0213461854,
0.0108056171,
0.0569017678,
-0.0968158394,
0.0538620725,
0.0174700003,
-0.0702930391,
-0.0175459217,
0.0223795362,
0.0596386716,
0.0047997576,
0.045891434,
-0.0003964825,
0.000800366,
0.0330110155,
-0.0309067592,
-0.0108490577,
-0.0643595159,
-0.0467719659,
0.0010295992,
-0.0879877657,
0.0009705995,
-0.0074671446,
-0.0134572191,
-0.0589051396,
-0.0381348357,
-0.0301233605,
0.0167037416,
0.0292468332,
0.0126936687,
0.0381780639,
0.058188431,
-0.0326884203,
-0.0020995394,
0.0336330645,
0.0463410765,
0.0095291045,
-0.0145528605,
0.0001150085,
0.0002471938,
0.0466326997,
-0.0000517724,
0.0187547989,
-0.0321303643,
-0.0415759534,
-0.0182607584,
0.0515462905,
0.0857372358,
0.0555533096,
-0.0308569036,
-0.0323815793,
0.0991160274,
0.0707039535,
0.0180840101,
0.0280232821,
0.0709947869,
0.0157084763,
-0.0155602079,
0.0006724381,
-0.0148764625,
0.0216366053,
0.0076315505,
0.0120042982,
0.0433205254,
0.0640705526,
-0.0409291014,
-0.0160518195,
0.0218548868,
-0.0004342898,
-0.0236220509,
-0.0286146067,
0.0140552996,
-0.0075290105,
-0.0200601947,
0.0454597734,
-0.0017586238,
-0.0509137101,
0.0279003233,
0.0087434733,
0.0293402299,
0.0598656982,
-0.0497970656,
-0.0143270809,
0.0007774861,
-0.05733997,
-0.015855046,
0.0278477315,
0.0072219232,
0.0172122978,
0.0607006811,
-0.0468490683,
-0.0307015963,
-0.008752076,
0.0122421468,
0.071422711,
-0.0219988246,
0.0393144861,
-0.006531666,
-0.0140857482,
0.0788590014,
-0.0235454012,
-0.0371435769,
-0.0228746422,
0.0561843216,
0.0008945711,
0.0288057476,
0.0431679972,
-0.039740596,
0.0354882292,
0.0131271519,
-0.049040366,
0.0245904475,
0.0330342799,
-0.0562299341,
-0.0201765466,
0.0271274038,
-0.0501625426,
0.0318911895,
0.0436761044,
0.0633680448,
-0.0747798383,
0.0597895458,
0.0228570513,
-0.0766870901,
-0.0250019822,
-0.0051322607,
0.0343787,
0.0670636222,
0.0081908545,
0.0104085933,
0.0098696165,
-0.0295802299,
0.0194992423,
0.0436985791,
0.0031232217,
-0.0965272114,
-0.0025518609,
-0.0107503068,
-0.0193663724,
0.0165137835,
-0.0060574813,
-0.0093545141,
-0.0182783864,
-0.0377933234,
-0.0665862486,
0.0212069862,
-0.0171697754,
0.0057998751,
0.0224463679,
0.0221723225,
-0.0250849873,
0.0194146931,
-0.0523881055,
-0.0521032736,
0.0415375046,
0.0149831334,
-0.0035886583,
-0.0338650346,
-0.0005659554,
-0.0045636524,
-0.013810006,
0.0254717395,
-0.0142591009,
-0.0504915044,
-0.0040619848,
-0.0269213822,
0.0350765064,
0.0265937038,
0.0008869311,
0.029453218,
-0.0272153635,
0.0375736095,
-0.0095117604,
0.1344589889,
0.0250115506,
-0.0195756573,
-0.0378065407,
0.0022317469,
-0.0408304222,
-0.0216796938,
0.0117232185,
-0.0005038307,
0.1273905337,
-0.0277865883,
-0.0363018289,
-0.0053490764,
0.014759345,
0.0711619556,
0.0075650238,
-0.04439307,
-0.0039349832,
-0.0191785842,
-0.0704658329,
0.0502680764,
0.0019429391,
-0.0446336865,
-0.0215870161,
-0.0119459806,
-0.0382352509,
0.040493533,
-0.0421532616,
-0.0382339843,
-0.0343769789,
-0.0343916416,
0.0278896466,
0.0095951175,
-0.0357157588,
-0.006232053,
-0.0224823989,
-0.0190520845,
-0.0719694495,
0.0496972315,
0.0207792688,
-0.0491542891,
0.0652793795,
-0.0299707521,
-0.0368243381,
-0.0358017087,
-0.0105530703,
-0.0524879731,
-0.0259195492,
-0.0135735488,
0.0258084591,
0.0253264531,
-0.0404661745,
0.047100801,
-0.016464131,
0.0262026731,
0.0392168239,
-0.0159203187,
0.0292695127,
0.0039645829,
0.0317395218,
0.0325354226,
0.0355195776,
-0.0121520646,
-0.0054385085,
-0.0164306387,
-0.0384357162,
0.0147348652,
0.024719201,
-0.0675497353,
0.0201434493,
-0.0133212982,
0.032933183,
-0.0086641284,
0.0155996559,
0.0538778678,
0.0075613232,
-0.001851677,
0.0532311946,
-0.0384097621,
-0.0213050917,
0.0229591355,
0.0415044613,
0.1046221256,
-0.009483912,
-0.0240294077,
-0.0269463826,
-0.0014520927,
0.0126369111,
0.0162458979,
-0.0159776639,
0.0161846559,
-0.0241393019,
-0.0620267205,
0.0229755286,
0.0014115147,
-0.0191306416,
-0.0156084951,
-0.0212731604,
-0.0247450154,
-0.0164780207,
0.0168401357,
0.0209555179,
0.0122965239,
0.0020209593,
0.0738287494,
-0.0686116368,
-0.0594370142,
-0.011967211,
-0.0388430245,
0.0381489806,
0.0485924371,
-0.0138184438,
-0.046865426,
-0.0288519859,
-0.0211398061,
0.0110796141,
-0.0330782644,
0.0268407315,
-0.0197997093,
0.0745242164,
-0.0151139926,
0.013278163,
0.0986790508,
-0.036122296,
0.0309558045,
-0.0228979308,
0.0515802987,
0.0038280999,
0.0041694888,
-0.0128795644,
0.0424040072,
0.023559656,
0.0367831104,
0.0290897805,
-0.0463112891,
-0.0170324594,
-0.0190444421,
0.0291259065,
-0.0455924124,
-0.0105859339,
0.013136358,
0.0383914039,
-0.0657114983,
-0.0705850273,
-0.0112720197,
-0.0283077713,
0.0533429198,
-0.0084841335,
-0.0086421873,
-0.0556175672,
-0.0095868856,
0.0055252714,
0.0133975958,
0.0278775711,
0.052172441,
-0.0180615839,
-0.009555026,
-0.0154739413,
-0.0394589454,
-0.0185087454,
0.0028756093,
-0.1287256479,
-0.06310267,
0.0312059149,
0.0127006602,
0.0115954671,
0.0282481182,
-0.0144926822,
-0.0375859477,
0.0652429312,
0.0244668666,
-0.0067681288,
0.04011859,
0.0624232106,
-0.0078115016,
0.0026237322,
0.0053090882,
-0.0376472995,
0.0548371561,
-0.0484499224,
0.0222412478,
0.0115966583,
-0.0867423639,
-0.0143962642,
-0.0068147904,
0.0002419612,
-0.0214500949,
0.0354249477,
-0.0650954768,
-0.0096173221,
-0.005067098,
0.0625913516,
-0.0359447673,
-0.0022657996,
0.0744566172,
0.0046101939,
-0.007829112,
0.0111115342,
0.0171063207,
0.0155544942,
-0.0045014978,
0.0008262537,
0.0843915492,
0.0040153353,
-0.0194837544,
-0.0011724071,
-0.013075198,
0.0707138851,
-0.0546655767,
-0.0026097756,
-0.0181281622,
-0.0051540039,
0.0092418883,
-0.0432224683,
-0.0111920722,
-0.0067208093,
-0.0544559509,
0.0174722672,
-0.0170157515,
-0.0146759581,
0.0405145511,
0.0119510153,
0.086912021,
-0.0178245492,
0.0338478312,
-0.0182534624,
-0.016239576,
-0.038818378,
0.0465644673,
-0.0132620391,
-0.0023751913,
0.0019077829,
-0.0034129971,
0.0585194789,
0.0116685424,
0.0158176124,
-0.031922143,
0.049160745,
-0.0125903375,
-0.0315659046,
-0.0655723363,
-0.0284464695,
0.009021787,
-0.0208444186,
-0.0247540921,
-0.0223960578,
0.0407414623,
0.0169772748,
0.0520154946,
-0.0562454201,
0.0246479604,
-0.0078547746,
-0.089895606,
0.0218976866,
0.0251904074,
0.0023519865,
0.0820815191,
-0.055141598,
-0.0334437788,
-6.193886181e-33,
0.0023966064,
0.0207002033,
-0.0139620006,
-0.0541833565,
-0.0727723688,
-0.0408079103,
-0.0021935801,
0.0066563413,
-0.0192046277,
0.0450744703,
-0.0459476486,
0.004815239,
0.0330281071,
0.0158564337,
0.0062770345,
0.0017679904,
0.0745207295,
-0.0326382667,
0.0221647415,
0.038351275,
0.0228262842,
0.0158707909,
0.0332984552,
0.0200161487,
-0.0207127519,
-0.0461783595,
-0.0323852599,
-0.0365712382,
0.0430476367,
0.0062825093,
-0.0213961918,
0.0203417987,
0.0050911587,
-0.0262582842,
-0.0438709483,
-0.0025045765,
-0.0661998093,
-0.0259573981,
-0.016618127,
-0.0167328827,
-0.0322176255,
0.0125364121,
0.0203200281,
0.0090248734,
-0.0182685647,
-0.0085437559,
0.0108673703,
-0.0380138196,
-0.0113926399,
-0.0536493883,
0.0033043192,
0.028420385,
-0.0033101335,
-0.0186568312,
0.015011319,
-0.005222722,
-0.0180339105,
-0.0448216833,
0.0124769537,
0.0297858883,
0.0622391887,
0.057350684,
0.0242441259,
0.0178074092,
0.0249001365,
-0.0002330017,
0.0405306406,
-0.0052695633,
0.043732699,
-0.0144353732,
0.0285206363,
0.0576228686,
0.0182693135,
0.0803681239,
0.0288152434,
0.0023908596,
-0.0316321552,
0.0019081073,
0.0194385257,
-0.0508322977,
0.0066307937,
0.0168759506,
-0.0177565366,
-0.0239797998,
-0.0188463945,
-0.0324191526,
-0.0013761875,
0.0021894008,
0.0371062346,
-0.013725847,
0.0255078599,
0.0268042255,
0.0788544491,
-0.0112570412,
0.0040019634,
0.0339134708,
-0.0600665025,
-0.0137060313,
0.0359928086,
0.0024072081,
-0.0245885812,
-0.0338209905,
0.0479108654,
0.0813442394,
0.0023037484,
0.0042654467,
-0.0533024222,
0.0200409591,
-0.0423470065,
0.0118932696,
0.0051663178,
0.0399231166,
0.0100465566,
0.0298890155,
0.0072136223,
-0.0442870222,
0.0170833915,
0.0678069443,
-0.0108763222,
0.0519441776,
0.0169937834,
0.0007931512,
0.008905434,
0.0281978827,
-0.0320783667,
0.0223053806,
0.032470338,
-0.0154141774,
0.0449527651,
-0.0363318808,
-0.0140108075,
-0.005948863,
2.666e-7,
-0.0560806841,
-0.0192544609,
0.0491641387,
-0.0326626375,
0.0464040563,
0.0190999638,
-0.0042823716,
0.0149834463,
-0.0178703126,
-0.028467223,
0.0057774656,
-0.0006512278,
0.0675834566,
0.0740174949,
-0.0728970021,
-0.0046128728,
-0.0229975022,
0.0533259101,
-0.030887356,
-0.0358693935,
-0.0026763293,
0.0505909435,
-0.0215721447,
-0.0394110344,
0.0500262305,
0.0156299006,
-0.0106810266,
0.0229915548,
-0.0078280717,
-0.0038799327,
0.1013499275,
-0.0875741765,
0.0289075356,
-0.0275333654,
-0.028909402,
0.0465838313,
0.0265983399,
0.0328513011,
0.0182369482,
-0.0651340187,
0.0262694452,
-0.0078610349,
-0.0544106662,
-0.0083641419,
0.0216174461,
0.0283831395,
0.0113892397,
-0.0237724651,
-0.0469067469,
-0.0115012424,
0.030338889,
-0.0413701162,
-0.0011063833,
-0.0095087253,
0.0114575475,
-0.0289559122,
-0.0010697697,
-0.0017482513,
-0.0285984129,
0.0030733554,
-0.0656995624,
-0.0306340344,
-0.0256514344,
-0.0301022585,
0.0438956432,
0.0415618308,
-0.0110512916,
2.048238524e-34,
0.0461989678,
-0.0351590179,
0.0147435982,
-0.0115507971,
-0.0282006674,
-0.0460980646,
0.0293416046,
-0.0152283749,
0.0289860982,
-0.0228718463,
-0.0698510259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14657v1 | Reasoning about Ambiguous Definite Descriptions | 2023-10-23T07:52:38 | 2023-10-23T07:52:38 | Stefan F. Schouten, Peter Bloem, Ilia Markov, Piek Vossen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language reasoning plays an increasingly important role in improving
language models' ability to solve complex language understanding tasks. An
interesting use case for reasoning is the resolution of context-dependent
ambiguity. But no resources exist to evaluate how well Large Language Models
can use explicit reasoning to resolve ambiguity in language. We propose to use
ambiguous definite descriptions for this purpose and create and publish the
first benchmark dataset consisting of such phrases. Our method includes all
information required to resolve the ambiguity in the prompt, which means a
model does not require anything but reasoning to do well. We find this to be a
challenging task for recent LLMs. Code and data available at:
https://github.com/sfschouten/exploiting-ambiguity | [
0.069132641,
0.0475976393,
-0.0240548365,
0.0930375531,
-0.0538264662,
0.034120813,
0.0035611456,
0.009913017,
-0.0206789542,
-0.0621707812,
0.028316332,
-0.0433615223,
0.013801327,
0.0547342934,
0.0152255073,
-0.0363366865,
0.0786499754,
-0.0403767526,
0.0064979484,
0.0039877212,
-0.0023722346,
0.0350738913,
-0.0051308218,
0.0137712909,
-0.0115337083,
-0.0396656804,
-0.0196584985,
0.0336797051,
-0.0052589593,
-0.0049278797,
-0.0056794183,
0.0100052133,
0.0287571494,
0.0206712224,
0.0000019393,
-0.0526810177,
-0.0282943174,
-0.0113826999,
-0.0562887713,
-0.0117362952,
0.0291186813,
-0.0156997982,
0.0224105492,
0.0158553906,
-0.0311924126,
0.0164902937,
0.0298787542,
0.0127756391,
0.0487553552,
0.0507662259,
0.0004558783,
-0.0252675265,
-0.0480889194,
-0.0151037667,
0.0449186265,
-0.065452747,
0.0174067523,
-0.0171711072,
0.0272467304,
0.017006509,
0.0002112225,
0.0393407084,
0.0241520982,
0.0173433796,
-0.0618379228,
0.0188577529,
-0.0025238236,
-0.019239964,
0.0018075502,
0.0574500002,
0.0293385498,
0.0184864942,
0.0098906597,
-0.0185123608,
0.0047816024,
-0.0198361762,
-0.007904131,
0.0361417979,
-0.0428710952,
0.0006955785,
0.0054756845,
0.0063528339,
0.04449296,
0.0483824387,
-0.0494319797,
0.1231192425,
0.0000074358,
-0.0018245084,
0.0072653042,
-0.0421072319,
-0.0544790067,
-0.0396222733,
0.0309773013,
0.0665920675,
-0.0533049889,
0.0645842925,
-0.0161789674,
0.0204771068,
0.0590208806,
-0.031299714,
0.0085396338,
0.047992833,
-0.0303095058,
0.0805622414,
-0.0096575748,
0.0513790585,
-0.0225338396,
0.0278848335,
-0.036118146,
-0.0428043157,
-0.052810695,
-0.0387291647,
-0.0511751547,
0.0221353807,
-0.0306071099,
0.008882897,
-0.0269644726,
0.0194554832,
-0.0154311201,
0.0520874895,
-0.0031126239,
0.0091318199,
-0.0678872094,
-0.0187168643,
-0.0470176078,
-0.0259863306,
-0.0358776078,
0.0288413856,
-0.0211442113,
-0.0687706098,
-0.0294564683,
0.0038638953,
-0.0314400122,
-0.0527971536,
-0.0109074786,
0.0600973442,
0.0156726148,
0.0030009951,
-0.0323042609,
-0.0587614924,
-0.0249493681,
-0.0721248612,
-0.0464850403,
-0.0569815859,
0.0417965651,
0.0214918833,
0.0115990508,
-0.0631286055,
0.0039808061,
-0.0055345562,
-0.0175517146,
0.1346357018,
-0.0417278819,
-0.0018902267,
0.0171064995,
0.0387165323,
-0.0337830186,
0.0653979927,
0.02611438,
0.028775448,
0.0404301547,
0.027745368,
-0.0098281894,
0.0262714755,
-0.0109557426,
0.0020019941,
-0.0227366798,
0.0323966146,
-0.0522704609,
0.032502152,
-0.0170828812,
0.0399904549,
0.0195561666,
-0.0383860841,
0.0115183918,
0.0228376705,
-0.0214829538,
-0.0370261781,
0.0598277897,
0.0165332481,
0.0072177579,
-0.0050580557,
-0.0504704751,
-0.0235312171,
-0.019838376,
0.0345523991,
-0.0489816107,
0.012404697,
-0.0135450633,
-0.06090362,
-0.0780139491,
-0.0144773591,
0.0106079336,
0.0133882295,
0.0470473394,
0.0126540679,
-0.0320308544,
0.0778572336,
0.038008295,
-0.0194448885,
0.0054842024,
-0.0558357239,
0.0270594433,
0.0590420812,
0.0189151615,
-0.0446481481,
-0.0652326941,
-0.005723286,
0.0106374379,
0.0431396626,
0.0274974257,
-0.0178357642,
0.0549268387,
-0.0367307141,
-0.0170283094,
-0.0293586552,
0.0235107224,
0.0052807988,
0.0200194679,
-0.014439567,
0.0361521915,
-0.0622249097,
0.0072347298,
0.0406193845,
-0.0152320089,
-0.0090150684,
0.0010735816,
0.0180253554,
0.0354747735,
-0.003729044,
0.0205510072,
0.0098429481,
0.0182432998,
-0.0168430805,
-0.0075471806,
0.0002582037,
-0.0441594422,
-0.0015830573,
0.031771075,
0.0056277975,
-0.0633469671,
0.016238071,
-0.0827878565,
-0.0323097296,
-0.0081595583,
0.0075253365,
0.0001094927,
-0.016519336,
0.0220015179,
0.0084334277,
-0.0077366577,
-0.0291900616,
0.0834796131,
-0.0045479159,
0.0037993537,
0.028336389,
0.0423058979,
0.0095790112,
-0.0331946462,
-0.0236929506,
0.024470076,
-0.0282533672,
-0.0251420382,
-0.0273573343,
0.0276944842,
-0.0668438971,
-0.024953723,
-0.0370956473,
0.0168721303,
-0.0110049527,
0.0196414571,
0.0434363894,
0.0214281194,
0.0027008322,
-0.0002963432,
-0.0036809139,
-0.0067641307,
-0.0114406236,
0.0096919741,
0.0503761023,
0.023676008,
-0.0209725369,
-0.0318128876,
0.0034149573,
-0.0424601808,
0.0305185262,
0.0031695699,
-0.0385348387,
-0.0725203454,
0.0284209978,
-0.0453660898,
0.008123897,
-0.0154967969,
0.0132611115,
-0.0026337099,
-0.0215538256,
-0.0127293384,
0.0378630832,
-0.0027076779,
0.0384964161,
0.053381905,
-0.0384056531,
-0.0666600838,
0.0280152168,
-0.0089973109,
-0.0103070447,
-0.0371226482,
-0.0628304854,
-0.0309290569,
0.0660294071,
-0.0027615489,
-0.0093148584,
-0.0320935771,
0.012574058,
-0.0248526465,
0.003501374,
-0.0516449884,
-0.0084079271,
-0.0098181665,
0.0815062076,
-0.0311681405,
-0.0197134353,
0.0915945768,
-0.0421909988,
0.0022355139,
-0.0377848111,
-0.0061352337,
-0.0611044578,
0.0892040357,
-0.0438531153,
-0.0031308373,
0.0161341671,
-0.0382274315,
-0.0319662914,
-0.0484073274,
0.0259950496,
-0.0236004945,
0.0532192029,
-0.0688077658,
0.0293756984,
-0.0297944136,
-0.0183767229,
-0.0546994694,
-0.0284313262,
-0.0374262519,
0.0027305004,
-0.0061612031,
0.0129390806,
-0.0194586013,
0.009169599,
-0.0358379781,
0.0224473849,
-0.0145425256,
-0.0152580133,
-0.06946484,
-0.0035445802,
0.0388721451,
0.0400824323,
0.0240663122,
-0.0286551788,
0.0110613722,
0.0269125029,
0.0168828461,
0.0025302651,
-0.0200522151,
0.0023056536,
0.0247810818,
-0.0459375009,
-0.0026816626,
0.0307084695,
0.035232652,
-0.0832530037,
-0.049553439,
0.1242534444,
0.0624933243,
-0.0204710662,
0.0046319398,
-0.0282514524,
0.0072221938,
0.0183277782,
0.0318485945,
-0.0880110487,
-0.0713969991,
0.0307445675,
-0.0022252346,
0.0017534195,
-0.0195899904,
-0.0445283167,
-0.0834586471,
0.0128367459,
-0.0070484076,
-0.0080408566,
-0.0208280608,
-0.0056508421,
0.0085422434,
-0.0154913841,
0.0519421548,
0.0061854767,
-0.0027159974,
-0.0038689629,
-0.0087039461,
0.0392514057,
-0.034533821,
0.0432056151,
-0.016145682,
0.0412084945,
0.025754597,
0.0186844058,
0.005139424,
0.0039863898,
0.0536661856,
-0.0081155794,
-0.0138592552,
-0.0489777885,
0.0199464001,
0.0078232987,
-0.0090662958,
0.0456696898,
-0.0022671376,
-0.0614437312,
-0.0197049174,
0.0194263719,
0.0390649363,
-0.0206073727,
0.0071125408,
0.0067394199,
0.0088890186,
-0.0006746193,
0.1006316021,
0.0222361088,
0.0104573714,
-0.0444693081,
-0.04373236,
-0.0335601419,
-0.0248851888,
-0.0022688427,
0.0146596767,
0.0111005129,
0.0227088127,
-0.0286784377,
-0.0349295922,
0.0436933637,
0.0252041072,
0.025335364,
0.0165577456,
0.0115494095,
-0.0075906343,
-0.0463672504,
0.0481919274,
-0.0285937488,
0.0507741496,
-0.0221355613,
-0.0099418759,
0.0331183337,
-0.0165097695,
-0.0448024347,
0.0592874214,
-0.0836887434,
-0.0537861697,
0.0159188453,
0.0142853977,
0.0357635655,
0.0616268441,
-0.0678344145,
-0.0369424447,
-0.0263332538,
0.0162618589,
0.0057872259,
-0.0164455567,
0.0418275855,
0.0477513224,
0.0061664749,
0.0649177656,
-0.0573054105,
-0.0125807114,
-0.0023663454,
0.0375148766,
-0.0485346764,
-0.0339689814,
0.0296157375,
0.0066210036,
-0.016341744,
0.0145407291,
0.0066493023,
-0.007570297,
0.0354034603,
-0.0022379044,
-0.0503943302,
-0.027460739,
0.014208802,
-0.0115896594,
-0.0406492576,
0.0033812688,
0.0074211513,
-0.0149185862,
0.0531051494,
-0.0119448965,
-0.0085092727,
0.0295230299,
-0.0045069726,
0.0025753709,
-0.0267146453,
-0.0141348932,
0.0587859303,
-0.0315441936,
0.0411615148,
-0.0086737275,
0.0499760695,
0.0407392234,
0.0072082118,
-0.0755055696,
0.0113422768,
-0.0437519811,
-0.0657359138,
0.0324423723,
0.0284769833,
0.0412846208,
-0.0060973922,
0.0383923464,
-0.0224109981,
-0.007635517,
0.0174882691,
0.0292351693,
0.0518125556,
-0.0155644082,
0.0779051483,
0.0457625836,
-0.0039886762,
0.0100252433,
0.0420740247,
0.0047480608,
0.0602472872,
0.0261042975,
-0.0332527272,
-0.0332682058,
-0.0217069946,
0.0036101255,
0.0093681244,
-0.0131129874,
0.0217510369,
-0.0444074124,
-0.0755329281,
0.023152085,
0.0148429917,
0.0229990259,
0.0110023785,
0.0208456963,
0.0639725626,
0.0384709723,
-0.0576942116,
-0.0240883864,
-0.0067864843,
0.0368624553,
-0.0163891278,
-0.059782844,
-6.289910845e-33,
-0.053625688,
-0.0393130295,
-0.0043107406,
-0.0305989627,
0.0084490832,
0.0103687244,
-0.0518718027,
-0.0325802825,
-0.0350486487,
-0.0121511314,
-0.0185572319,
0.0359849706,
0.037963409,
0.0137805855,
-0.0069960998,
-0.0405579731,
0.0280111544,
0.0547112413,
-0.012616178,
-0.0065406659,
0.0439975373,
0.0117340377,
0.0450619049,
-0.0471887365,
0.0608361624,
0.0140669663,
-0.0518663935,
0.0679479986,
-0.0576371215,
0.0494094789,
-0.011509615,
0.0095284246,
0.0106855184,
-0.0027699305,
-0.0248502437,
-0.0062723001,
-0.0933564305,
-0.0039290632,
0.0667391419,
0.0150347315,
-0.0791549981,
-0.0390058272,
0.0337484628,
-0.0124383653,
0.0142847653,
0.0013052503,
0.0274646189,
-0.0252824184,
0.0076732486,
-0.0320926718,
-0.0324168913,
0.0294902921,
-0.0299408436,
-0.0103532663,
0.0504779406,
-0.005130474,
-0.0016468517,
0.0583386011,
-0.0314700641,
-0.001281502,
0.0177625213,
0.0214422997,
0.0658019111,
0.0008641605,
-0.0256306902,
0.0248467978,
-0.0092639802,
-0.0139617026,
-0.0224694069,
-0.0047212401,
-0.0163597781,
0.0464244559,
0.0295377076,
0.0129565205,
0.0450786054,
0.007232544,
-0.0378597528,
-0.0109984707,
0.0208125748,
0.0539190359,
0.0335376039,
0.0072307559,
-0.0410092399,
-0.0125155943,
-0.0530937091,
-0.0010828561,
-0.052428443,
-0.0139068551,
0.0427921712,
-0.0350277536,
-0.0328395702,
0.0083397832,
0.0140608037,
-0.0537767857,
-0.0348309241,
-0.0039911116,
0.0209430736,
-0.0033434988,
0.0169717018,
0.0627622083,
0.0238553863,
-0.0481731892,
0.0118819391,
-0.0064779576,
0.0195734575,
0.0030440551,
0.0373309217,
0.0022663756,
-0.0155196851,
0.0233937651,
-0.0538306534,
0.008069139,
-0.0516871214,
0.0020405757,
0.0407128297,
0.027858112,
-0.0140181947,
0.0695028752,
0.0240723286,
-0.027670471,
-0.0229795333,
0.0237604696,
-0.023841789,
0.0385874212,
-0.0346600637,
-0.0206026286,
-0.0077974186,
-0.008612846,
0.0210582241,
-0.0122003891,
0.009075854,
0.028240202,
2.609e-7,
0.0611123815,
0.029166216,
-0.002331828,
0.0769861713,
0.0033475973,
0.0348140076,
-0.0409684218,
-0.0166447368,
-0.0080565456,
-0.0325054079,
-0.0108643994,
0.0384179093,
0.0315790996,
0.0209271684,
-0.0427046642,
0.0271044225,
-0.0270400625,
-0.0014472451,
-0.0540979058,
0.0284334198,
0.1059973314,
0.1031165197,
0.015295716,
-0.002946031,
-0.0275503993,
-0.060830608,
0.0094545819,
-0.0291984826,
0.0086302496,
0.0340846442,
0.0336920582,
0.0029030228,
0.0320969373,
0.0233153459,
0.0101809455,
0.0036343015,
-0.0112669133,
0.0866959766,
0.005156388,
-0.0014196639,
-0.0537623204,
-0.0316345431,
0.0230474342,
-0.0477644317,
0.0991001949,
-0.0466219485,
-0.0493273027,
-0.0121477107,
0.0077765132,
-0.0037209198,
-0.0130183399,
0.0057214266,
-0.0148172509,
0.0251935422,
0.0016000434,
-0.0423354357,
-0.0486929007,
-0.1016339511,
-0.028109327,
-0.011676155,
-0.0277623162,
0.0028137029,
-0.0037303544,
0.0339672938,
0.039808847,
-0.0954830572,
-0.0095052924,
2.662568403e-34,
0.0464733094,
0.0142997624,
-0.0056761708,
0.0654758886,
0.0474033132,
0.0043609431,
-0.0376689844,
0.0345102325,
-0.0021238695,
-0.0297179595,
-0.0088277096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14654v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14654v2 | SPRING-INX: A Multilingual Indian Language Speech Corpus by SPRING Lab, IIT Madras | 2023-10-23T07:50:10 | 2023-10-24T06:03:14 | Nithya R, Malavika S, Jordan F, Arjun Gangwar, Metilda N J, S Umesh, Rithik Sarab, Akhilesh Kumar Dubey, Govind Divakaran, Samudra Vijaya K, Suryakanth V Gangashetty | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | India is home to a multitude of languages of which 22 languages are
recognised by the Indian Constitution as official. Building speech based
applications for the Indian population is a difficult problem owing to limited
data and the number of languages and accents to accommodate. To encourage the
language technology community to build speech based applications in Indian
languages, we are open sourcing SPRING-INX data which has about 2000 hours of
legally sourced and manually transcribed speech data for ASR system building in
Assamese, Bengali, Gujarati, Hindi, Kannada, Malayalam, Marathi, Odia, Punjabi
and Tamil. This endeavor is by SPRING Lab , Indian Institute of Technology
Madras and is a part of National Language Translation Mission (NLTM), funded by
the Indian Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY),
Government of India. We describe the data collection and data cleaning process
along with the data statistics in this paper. | [
0.0119236754,
0.0301420465,
-0.0147756562,
0.0140619744,
-0.0555986352,
0.0131955249,
-0.0143100852,
0.003742035,
-0.0126583334,
0.0037132804,
-0.0428371504,
-0.013606254,
0.0734352171,
0.0313878022,
0.0040833787,
-0.048259452,
0.0095899198,
-0.0490177348,
-0.0017871333,
0.0081096292,
0.0485054366,
0.0534528382,
-0.0359063521,
0.014369294,
-0.0389900357,
0.0188835151,
0.0038117345,
-0.0182313006,
0.0089599164,
-0.032843478,
-0.034528248,
-0.0228540599,
0.0175201986,
0.0106868194,
0.0000017847,
-0.0623638593,
-0.0172143076,
0.0240010414,
-0.0629060864,
-0.0102395769,
0.039462842,
0.0097827679,
0.0009242329,
0.0496669114,
0.0134352027,
0.0576963052,
0.0696939155,
-0.0265333354,
0.0309029259,
0.0844819769,
-0.0248739365,
-0.0526791066,
-0.0302180201,
0.0322897695,
-0.0668999851,
0.0151029611,
-0.017455304,
-0.0363136008,
0.0321796574,
-0.0164538752,
0.0170216784,
0.0049326322,
-0.0432173908,
-0.0340219699,
-0.007347024,
-0.0307061188,
-0.0330187343,
-0.0540932976,
0.0178157166,
0.040448118,
-0.0034759282,
-0.0221586991,
0.0677901134,
0.0167542789,
-0.0636456087,
-0.0277061053,
-0.0235543568,
0.003812717,
-0.0472109988,
0.0335316472,
0.0467182025,
0.046458032,
-0.0237756241,
-0.03769226,
0.0543990098,
0.010690596,
0.0183779746,
-0.0280960593,
0.0049660597,
-0.041691415,
0.0335608646,
0.0172530096,
0.0652724653,
0.0098593952,
-0.0318557471,
0.0433813669,
-0.0056872736,
-0.0504350774,
0.033552479,
-0.0349161252,
0.0108368872,
0.0188899953,
-0.024917705,
-0.0051814453,
0.0241393093,
0.0126029896,
0.0153685082,
-0.0213896669,
-0.009380823,
-0.0187126026,
0.0518268719,
-0.0176430363,
-0.0175679736,
0.0296006463,
-0.0415189192,
0.0107720178,
-0.0610163882,
0.003981309,
-0.0192635022,
-0.016652232,
0.0714949593,
-0.0367359109,
-0.022040708,
-0.0611711293,
0.0348342471,
0.0011942679,
-0.0176249389,
0.0477369651,
-0.0083275922,
-0.1088697687,
0.0238392446,
0.0206499491,
0.0315185376,
0.013912349,
-0.0190678574,
-0.0016510745,
0.0157653522,
0.0053203553,
-0.0526177175,
0.0054585268,
-0.0306442529,
-0.0539752021,
-0.064789176,
-0.0473615341,
0.052583769,
0.0358535126,
-0.0182024986,
0.0136044612,
0.0061679338,
0.0097636497,
0.0229306445,
0.0536992438,
-0.0335809737,
0.0326892287,
0.056890253,
-0.008004562,
0.0537590086,
0.0375388041,
0.0158946123,
-0.0449834242,
0.0276427139,
-0.0558688194,
0.0153750619,
0.0731339231,
-0.0430526175,
-0.0238624457,
-0.0246101916,
-0.003555563,
-0.0055274991,
0.0270635951,
-0.0006958023,
0.0505075008,
0.0089693433,
0.0321690813,
-0.0053479844,
0.0805096775,
0.0143275615,
0.0050179842,
-0.008268862,
0.0111904377,
0.0181763303,
-0.023103144,
0.0456024855,
-0.017728528,
-0.0082119135,
-0.010233908,
0.003997989,
0.030917285,
0.0109878285,
0.0370234214,
-0.0403639376,
-0.0495268255,
-0.0474368334,
0.0267718546,
0.0426339358,
0.0041639046,
-0.0279312581,
-0.0048139431,
0.025959732,
-0.0652525946,
0.0393097624,
-0.0365986414,
-0.0095388414,
0.0028505013,
0.0194371399,
-0.0379304849,
0.0124188131,
-0.0222131163,
-0.0223858505,
0.0346067846,
-0.0092305904,
-0.0192918964,
0.0141639896,
-0.0689601526,
0.0239815228,
0.1102784574,
-0.0138838356,
0.0183427054,
-0.0589481704,
0.034462668,
0.0006153458,
0.0175952464,
0.0068707196,
-0.0015843991,
-0.0110094063,
0.0160967391,
0.0118816327,
0.0049774358,
0.0835500807,
0.0424539633,
-0.0196183603,
-0.0151917636,
0.0253963321,
0.0117100803,
0.0614080876,
0.0648381561,
-0.0421693213,
0.0082922317,
0.0311785061,
-0.0263462868,
0.052470278,
0.0045342934,
0.0236256663,
-0.0894861519,
0.0310603809,
-0.0456272624,
0.0549145266,
-0.0078101247,
0.0823659375,
0.0053178356,
0.0091804657,
0.018316349,
-0.0279823914,
0.0443934649,
0.0033185855,
-0.0021387488,
0.0014414409,
0.0603352152,
-0.0929230824,
0.0038356672,
0.0333810374,
-0.0124935918,
0.0154441353,
0.0277342573,
-0.0562142953,
-0.0666916892,
-0.0189783517,
-0.0651454926,
-0.0229921304,
0.0024098861,
0.0194584914,
-0.0307830926,
0.0728071555,
-0.0072521847,
-0.0195674878,
0.0054983613,
-0.0177707318,
0.0654997826,
-0.0164062548,
-0.0151336351,
-0.0296422485,
-0.0359223112,
-0.0103579322,
0.0004905608,
-0.0015296997,
-0.002977272,
0.0116583258,
-0.0792809576,
-0.0601509549,
-0.0057379305,
0.0333641246,
-0.0149634536,
-0.0016069791,
-0.0503410883,
-0.0233095139,
-0.0055584684,
0.0218785163,
0.0028601247,
-0.020808557,
-0.026112901,
-0.0529601686,
-0.0315571427,
-0.0450836644,
-0.0385779999,
0.0388984494,
0.0622406527,
-0.0047779381,
0.0196895171,
0.0082281753,
0.000122759,
0.0260903109,
0.0324004255,
0.0164398793,
-0.0367055722,
-0.0345002599,
0.014181111,
-0.0281376392,
0.0004686645,
-0.0915199295,
0.038210988,
-0.005092944,
-0.0040766364,
0.0062227207,
-0.0465289429,
-0.0262045786,
-0.0749738216,
-0.0378970616,
-0.0355233178,
-0.0162446573,
-0.0278173257,
-0.0056933207,
0.0084128315,
-0.0654169396,
0.0129733877,
0.0317282416,
-0.0031370141,
-0.0536860749,
0.0163532458,
-0.0730789825,
0.0406909846,
-0.0277201291,
-0.0108625088,
0.0041706758,
-0.0115259066,
-0.0090984479,
0.0182533748,
0.0250480138,
-0.0284286235,
0.0418194234,
0.059168011,
-0.0162325948,
0.0193624962,
0.0120897349,
0.0438802242,
0.0198127106,
0.0186967142,
0.0492433645,
0.0317261703,
-0.0413127802,
0.0347333439,
0.031708777,
-0.0631995201,
0.0474607088,
-0.0047706775,
-0.0106840068,
-0.00322214,
0.0355132818,
-0.0124776978,
0.0042967536,
0.0182524882,
0.0412778147,
0.0351112969,
0.0269690398,
0.0486960448,
0.0163718592,
0.0015445004,
-0.0286102779,
-0.0414523445,
-0.0169230029,
0.0073187207,
0.0146809714,
-0.0701687783,
0.0157602169,
0.0776916742,
0.0222396608,
0.0151343951,
0.0166239925,
-0.0273863319,
-0.0944444835,
0.0271702129,
-0.0042560115,
-0.0254786871,
-0.0351613276,
-0.0310033932,
-0.0225433651,
-0.0203411877,
0.0300832,
0.045816686,
-0.03106362,
-0.0673942491,
0.0631090552,
-0.0980361104,
-0.0597454831,
-0.0170448013,
-0.0224742815,
0.0943766385,
0.0238854811,
0.0132346731,
-0.0273083225,
-0.0473082848,
-0.0258300994,
-0.0264591333,
-0.0233026203,
-0.0060184565,
-0.0029999171,
0.0496786647,
-0.0222378708,
-0.0100645544,
0.0538611487,
-0.0117647182,
0.0192512777,
0.0034030457,
0.0371757895,
-0.0251552612,
0.0130266463,
0.0240007155,
-0.0094002299,
0.0238446295,
0.0075689727,
-0.0201447681,
-0.0178802796,
0.0156890303,
-0.0064815725,
0.0508396849,
-0.0147973066,
-0.0188045446,
0.0182742272,
-0.0409934148,
-0.0614852831,
-0.0196355265,
-0.0186452083,
0.0516973548,
0.028209921,
0.0562085621,
0.0552779846,
0.0024972309,
0.0421046838,
0.007866513,
-0.0434564203,
-0.0300971568,
0.0482006073,
-0.0985287279,
-0.0083364081,
0.0272755604,
-0.0148092527,
-0.0256817397,
-0.0224672593,
0.0091161039,
-0.042264469,
0.0824515671,
0.0133380601,
0.022321403,
-0.006140756,
-0.0420807339,
-0.0356437117,
0.0610787272,
-0.0128811942,
-0.0482556112,
-0.0175211169,
0.0231670849,
0.0115705067,
-0.0065044775,
0.0085401349,
-0.0336095281,
0.0014728324,
-0.0585372373,
-0.0212315191,
-0.0198039394,
-0.038135048,
0.0460290238,
0.0734132081,
0.0124970693,
-0.0538438223,
0.0039942372,
-0.0303422939,
-0.0048401775,
0.0081719924,
0.0393788517,
-0.0012383016,
-0.007498621,
0.0446583666,
0.0543532073,
-0.0092579788,
-0.0137421237,
-0.0435142107,
-0.0274426807,
0.0566408485,
0.0949286669,
0.0367308706,
0.0625496879,
0.0305393972,
0.0182371289,
-0.0035105017,
0.0381482355,
0.012179981,
0.040215306,
-0.0215537883,
0.0433136672,
-0.0373572111,
0.0074384939,
0.0619638637,
0.0324236266,
0.0890278369,
0.0502164215,
-0.0080179777,
0.059944015,
0.0215583406,
0.0125687998,
0.0666854829,
0.0031421992,
0.0285638049,
-0.0391405784,
0.0487965681,
-0.0515618138,
0.0253311284,
0.0395722203,
-0.0065008393,
-0.0554685108,
0.0268265102,
0.0377987847,
-0.0416623689,
0.0015475496,
0.0245461315,
0.0104424944,
-0.0384950489,
-0.0195929203,
-0.0498437434,
-0.0246900991,
-0.0071771941,
-0.0343023501,
-0.026407117,
-0.0600746199,
0.0136605287,
-0.0268664639,
0.0190912299,
-0.0551375635,
0.0034725131,
-0.0124312919,
0.0110578332,
0.0292127412,
-0.0083813211,
-0.0372960679,
-0.0502787605,
-0.0291108526,
0.0215337817,
-5.816720737e-33,
0.0003822747,
0.052822426,
-0.0156768952,
0.0139304716,
-0.0218008459,
0.0020001228,
0.0038191976,
-0.0138460305,
-0.0070097432,
-0.018549934,
-0.044902619,
-0.0150426831,
0.0216045566,
-0.0221018568,
0.0430777147,
0.0239758175,
0.0414678268,
0.0149992742,
0.0308541842,
-0.0243615825,
0.0507561751,
0.0118325353,
0.0783541948,
-0.035407383,
-0.0129954955,
-0.0250992514,
-0.0215117279,
0.0072732116,
0.0005703585,
0.0277845114,
-0.0075887134,
0.0438270494,
-0.0062964666,
-0.0077267373,
-0.0031066602,
0.0474770926,
-0.0808427632,
0.0177195854,
0.0179499779,
0.1189006418,
0.0453316495,
-0.0110917911,
0.0153508978,
-0.013078237,
-0.0560377203,
0.0540836602,
0.0097817509,
-0.0049446849,
-0.0028439222,
-0.0154458042,
-0.0242974106,
0.0467209555,
0.0032431982,
0.0059650489,
0.0444993302,
0.0248630513,
-0.0130077619,
-0.054335624,
-0.0474918224,
0.0224466939,
0.0086388821,
0.0526612215,
0.0302304458,
0.0244634319,
-0.0247397125,
-0.0206708442,
0.0210403074,
-0.099189505,
0.0593865439,
-0.0068592182,
0.0078110085,
0.0319960937,
-0.0326240845,
0.030950984,
0.0731975436,
-0.084303081,
0.0146779027,
0.0034161371,
0.0662865192,
0.015110218,
-0.0296284184,
0.0065937182,
-0.021886196,
-0.021737339,
0.0025721993,
-0.0040426538,
-0.0249027237,
-0.0147871329,
0.0516597293,
-0.0078516677,
0.0179213211,
0.0494009666,
0.0428864993,
0.0132110929,
-0.0107963877,
-0.022425659,
-0.0048670559,
-0.0139156329,
-0.0105217993,
0.0144459177,
-0.0568261743,
-0.0352770388,
0.0210682414,
0.0475793704,
0.0326220132,
-0.0279352628,
-0.0145058418,
0.0420930088,
-0.0780350566,
0.0059801717,
0.0152786542,
0.0579482988,
-0.0005965293,
0.01599852,
0.0077784602,
-0.0405743569,
-0.0017704305,
-0.0025025886,
0.0238571595,
0.0335760266,
-0.0141097549,
-0.019685667,
0.0108007956,
0.008991831,
-0.0506977737,
0.0325969756,
-0.0249748025,
-0.0453164354,
0.0236008838,
0.0010073583,
0.0049678111,
0.0121082477,
2.54e-7,
-0.055260364,
0.0301112812,
0.0420804881,
-0.0446274728,
-0.0388383009,
-0.0286344588,
-0.0415578932,
-0.0163707659,
-0.0063858135,
0.0353292562,
-0.0194476228,
-0.065382272,
0.0888717473,
0.0310183261,
-0.1238592118,
-0.0422315672,
-0.0836328119,
0.0033140797,
-0.0331349112,
0.0342627428,
-0.0260595866,
0.0580528378,
-0.0058050668,
-0.0519344434,
-0.0182616636,
0.0004240691,
0.0110862879,
-0.0129340077,
0.0168910976,
0.0143679501,
0.0152007714,
-0.0514830761,
-0.0365169533,
-0.0091001932,
-0.0388317369,
0.037913166,
0.0103484252,
0.0529076308,
-0.0474832878,
0.0010968406,
0.0223078784,
0.0265640207,
-0.0416411571,
0.0054548639,
0.0271408744,
0.0744945854,
-0.0485849753,
-0.0565920733,
-0.0301947612,
-0.0162362456,
-0.0277175065,
0.0036062081,
0.0380075872,
-0.0129749849,
0.0168476868,
-0.0705859736,
-0.0198629908,
-0.0135636469,
-0.0129719758,
0.0186554566,
-0.0325918496,
-0.044791691,
0.0221778117,
0.0045504323,
0.0375295728,
-0.0130323526,
0.0112015242,
1.845589727e-34,
0.0367132239,
-0.0227048136,
0.0301061999,
0.0269583464,
0.0376632921,
-0.032428056,
0.0310744867,
0.0476854667,
-0.0026004924,
-0.0521906316,
-0.0312707126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14644v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14644v1 | Multilingual k-Nearest-Neighbor Machine Translation | 2023-10-23T07:35:37 | 2023-10-23T07:35:37 | David Stap, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL | k-nearest-neighbor machine translation has demonstrated remarkable
improvements in machine translation quality by creating a datastore of cached
examples. However, these improvements have been limited to high-resource
language pairs, with large datastores, and remain a challenge for low-resource
languages. In this paper, we address this issue by combining representations
from multiple languages into a single datastore. Our results consistently
demonstrate substantial improvements not only in low-resource translation
quality (up to +3.6 BLEU), but also for high-resource translation quality (up
to +0.5 BLEU). Our experiments show that it is possible to create multilingual
datastores that are a quarter of the size, achieving a 5.3x speed improvement,
by using linguistic similarities for datastore creation. | [
0.0200696122,
0.0483783074,
-0.0021777893,
0.0484897867,
-0.0444738753,
0.0434872024,
0.0611687042,
0.0419183522,
0.0006552926,
-0.0014863492,
-0.0555969104,
-0.0452628955,
0.0267053656,
-0.0577843376,
0.0440451168,
-0.0399520136,
0.0312181227,
0.0099018076,
-0.0560472198,
-0.0248140525,
0.0023521234,
0.0494424738,
0.0325679071,
0.0043422384,
-0.0001221276,
-0.0102191055,
0.0034077351,
0.0295082759,
0.0294335298,
-0.0315266363,
-0.0222161468,
0.0046986127,
0.0140558658,
0.0804470703,
0.0000020736,
-0.0191984121,
-0.0453746617,
0.0058252783,
-0.0028254611,
-0.014361646,
0.0829875469,
-0.0619396977,
-0.0147457123,
0.0195047371,
0.0015531217,
-0.0488843359,
0.0764244422,
-0.020994585,
0.0657402128,
0.0826749876,
-0.0313614197,
-0.0653186589,
-0.0256868843,
-0.0164094102,
0.0086262301,
-0.0046173832,
-0.0204460882,
0.0181063209,
-0.0270113293,
0.0053125182,
-0.0049394495,
0.0636327937,
0.0081593711,
0.0092790546,
-0.019540308,
0.0175984986,
-0.0178531073,
-0.0289487895,
0.0081964349,
0.0437072143,
-0.0683218613,
-0.0384875871,
-0.0200254191,
0.0179689378,
-0.0485970862,
-0.0225539375,
-0.0069993464,
0.0067238812,
-0.0127132162,
0.0042749932,
0.0288554747,
0.0739793107,
0.0366098881,
-0.01757144,
-0.0377965644,
-0.0662739873,
0.0510662645,
-0.0493799299,
-0.0236625224,
0.0204437468,
0.0293906406,
0.0111452863,
0.0521099791,
-0.0304402299,
0.0109469267,
0.019842241,
-0.0471249633,
-0.0275974311,
0.0257668048,
-0.0697555691,
0.048176907,
0.0896436498,
-0.0070388648,
0.05759269,
-0.0414724313,
0.0601229072,
-0.0400459692,
-0.0260097496,
-0.0652574003,
-0.0394717976,
-0.0337156355,
0.0469515473,
-0.0217375755,
-0.009951327,
-0.0210608467,
-0.0208004527,
0.0113915559,
0.0218238607,
0.0313243084,
-0.0051801722,
0.0124481097,
-0.0070689539,
-0.0608824976,
-0.0202859882,
-0.0044987565,
0.0182149671,
-0.0560522601,
-0.0512953512,
-0.011075072,
-0.0670077875,
-0.0478664152,
0.0252691153,
0.0286392048,
-0.031125959,
0.0297980085,
0.0335235372,
-0.0098361345,
0.002614252,
-0.0014156504,
-0.0044978629,
0.007454705,
-0.0443614982,
-0.0534783565,
-0.0603035837,
0.1249063089,
0.0183868632,
0.0213756487,
-0.0334072672,
-0.0439437032,
-0.0074837408,
-0.0198346451,
0.0508760735,
-0.0330906361,
0.0034438826,
0.0059412275,
-0.0026033339,
-0.0008870549,
0.0604072995,
0.0219325721,
-0.0286795944,
0.0191666856,
0.0046622236,
-0.0564207323,
0.0319232158,
0.0072473218,
0.0496479906,
-0.0337700062,
0.0268443152,
0.0133593129,
0.0400098898,
0.0333565921,
0.0591273233,
-0.0472756065,
-0.008796324,
0.0224186126,
0.0599106997,
0.0321178846,
0.0613128319,
-0.0099211438,
0.0265943315,
-0.045742441,
-0.0215305816,
-0.0067806346,
0.0486170799,
0.0439706109,
0.0009367371,
0.0867743269,
0.0916441157,
-0.0145253269,
0.0156859085,
0.0013032596,
-0.0324204192,
-0.022638388,
-0.0140594142,
-0.0035552543,
0.0105421366,
-0.0283161774,
0.0666538775,
-0.0002170586,
-0.0771638304,
0.0208154991,
0.0160935,
-0.023269007,
0.0862168595,
0.0151383132,
0.030800771,
-0.035700053,
0.0016609341,
-0.0108848801,
0.0415971018,
0.078861542,
0.0018892518,
0.0579093844,
-0.0765564516,
-0.0370908715,
0.0103611257,
-0.0129541988,
0.0538720749,
0.0090231411,
0.0493926182,
0.0576854385,
-0.0158011355,
-0.0204305183,
-0.0081004584,
0.0074197208,
0.0309237018,
0.0231662057,
0.0317546427,
0.0028472431,
0.0290645845,
-0.0190263204,
-0.0250128563,
0.0030595509,
-0.051962886,
-0.0010249114,
0.0399950556,
-0.0485132337,
-0.0697499514,
-0.0050743716,
0.016656952,
0.0058094468,
-0.0040349839,
-0.0180719309,
-0.041258432,
-0.0227397475,
-0.0302897338,
0.0314675681,
-0.0302918386,
0.0374336094,
-0.0125424396,
0.0036939145,
-0.026202241,
0.0290598143,
0.0037314324,
0.0398962386,
-0.0045812712,
-0.0036636265,
0.0489182658,
-0.0367862955,
-0.0223128796,
0.0051959087,
0.0203173179,
0.0539905354,
0.0589271709,
-0.0154276993,
-0.0375797711,
-0.0214819908,
-0.049352888,
0.0155506618,
0.0012203571,
0.0451732203,
0.0139163081,
0.072833851,
0.0255997386,
-0.0202164091,
-0.0397159792,
-0.0097397035,
0.0213604141,
0.0464398153,
0.0049232622,
-0.0309280492,
0.0014450814,
0.0090510612,
-0.0188819338,
0.0493080132,
0.0466232002,
-0.018014634,
-0.0506606959,
-0.0508447327,
0.0229227617,
-0.0596633144,
-0.0157560408,
0.0268226378,
-0.033974085,
0.0021106894,
-0.0349189937,
0.0269757379,
0.0150210448,
-0.0313991494,
-0.059545882,
0.042827867,
-0.0141860805,
-0.0915768966,
-0.0097735003,
-0.0078661526,
-0.0044292584,
-0.0021269668,
-0.0195316374,
-0.0151068987,
-0.0051518907,
0.0010671415,
-0.0056903828,
-0.0469450578,
0.0068588099,
0.0017867219,
0.0056054182,
-0.0308759026,
0.0511298105,
0.0237076413,
0.0268234983,
-0.0234134085,
-0.0397273675,
0.0692907795,
-0.0107054329,
-0.0196244195,
-0.0357693844,
-0.0173094589,
0.0031934059,
0.0248062927,
-0.0587446392,
0.0432208851,
-0.0866664276,
-0.0082634212,
-0.0029788692,
0.0429312997,
0.0067031132,
-0.0114518125,
-0.0073751514,
-0.0136821894,
0.0020864154,
-0.0023571362,
-0.0311358552,
-0.0166740268,
0.0033609727,
0.0169066731,
-0.0559021682,
0.001561604,
-0.0019248006,
-0.0409602225,
0.0327253714,
0.0179760735,
0.0685564354,
0.0147799216,
-0.0031553195,
0.0085531548,
0.0277608465,
-0.0365071185,
0.0005349168,
0.0022529608,
-0.0063918307,
0.0425900966,
0.0407140143,
0.0323414281,
-0.0514395945,
-0.0301104058,
-0.0034769089,
0.0232851226,
0.0226113759,
-0.049766995,
-0.0152631504,
-0.012476177,
-0.0351468325,
-0.0078008827,
0.0891635194,
0.0073228697,
-0.0516604744,
-0.0123665836,
0.0076899845,
0.0348767191,
0.0076911417,
0.0277167894,
-0.1054903492,
-0.0301385392,
-0.0124474782,
0.0165812839,
0.0455645062,
0.0033630412,
-0.0338008814,
-0.0887047276,
-0.0294258446,
0.0581494942,
-0.0411304459,
-0.0583055243,
-0.0208952688,
-0.0708871633,
-0.028307857,
0.0043437271,
0.0169007182,
0.0552558601,
0.0009717693,
-0.0202974752,
0.0138041498,
-0.0391866118,
0.0090083033,
-0.0558504276,
-0.0029608384,
0.0184890795,
0.0326370373,
0.0383814536,
-0.0013954238,
-0.0600699857,
0.0216098353,
0.0206787605,
-0.0234470032,
-0.0171445012,
0.0018239794,
-0.0358066633,
0.0218909569,
-0.0406713784,
-0.0471197739,
0.0271292496,
0.0204504617,
0.0871612206,
-0.019819105,
0.0246299934,
0.0271406267,
-0.0436529294,
0.0069481432,
0.0299973879,
-0.0065791518,
-0.009389665,
0.0208837595,
0.0190542098,
-0.0052077034,
-0.0363752507,
0.0066596535,
-0.005182608,
-0.0679577887,
-0.0346692838,
-0.064310424,
-0.0351465605,
-0.024549691,
0.0598444156,
0.0069477465,
-0.0013810446,
0.0012312627,
0.0064480165,
-0.0401390418,
0.0080590975,
-0.0470711328,
-0.0070964075,
-0.0083005698,
0.0140118329,
0.0270414334,
0.0212780964,
-0.0001371187,
-0.0132137816,
-0.0644742027,
-0.0505099036,
-0.0283511057,
0.0374186002,
0.0089866435,
0.060274817,
0.0061315456,
-0.0353608653,
0.0091674263,
0.0374575816,
-0.0982216448,
-0.0091417069,
0.0120561998,
-0.0283035133,
-0.0012598663,
0.0531950444,
-0.0394017473,
-0.004911344,
-0.0391313918,
-0.0025219917,
-0.0305944011,
-0.0169540755,
-0.0138527229,
0.0219819825,
0.0060111228,
-0.0365819708,
-0.0286913998,
-0.0139886849,
0.0492812581,
-0.0149810137,
-0.0293334629,
-0.0292674135,
-0.0125189191,
0.0597012416,
-0.0140456324,
-0.0008145352,
0.0016122205,
0.0192096289,
-0.0376992039,
0.0035855109,
-0.0105500547,
-0.0073204385,
0.0237554368,
0.0161396917,
0.0328333117,
-0.0239687357,
0.0096124746,
0.0054218653,
-0.0053550797,
-0.079456225,
0.0109842774,
-0.0205885209,
0.0200438276,
0.0144166248,
0.0414554253,
-0.0181920305,
-0.0354634374,
-0.0300577823,
-0.0401940495,
0.0651785359,
0.0020902627,
0.0977504924,
0.0091695925,
-0.0144050606,
-0.015871739,
0.0319006145,
0.0409526527,
-0.0642096251,
-0.0171885919,
0.0055122925,
-0.0057370984,
0.0405215658,
0.0355201811,
-0.0670726299,
-0.0078346068,
-0.0091780163,
-0.0029782101,
-0.008675036,
-0.0171816032,
0.0059743109,
0.0171817075,
-0.0035456535,
-0.0508050099,
-0.0117834173,
-0.035775356,
0.0312812068,
0.0063203364,
-0.0232645478,
0.001313784,
0.0220254436,
0.0510264039,
-0.0151670231,
0.0415696353,
0.0041444427,
0.0230512433,
-0.0314156078,
-0.0127244182,
0.014765054,
-5.900109571e-33,
0.0236970466,
0.0076300493,
-0.0122098764,
-0.0680228025,
-0.001666359,
0.0078652455,
-0.0246631335,
-0.0415874198,
-0.0012711363,
-0.0206831172,
-0.0062606004,
0.0229809582,
0.0323013477,
-0.0106037194,
0.0022853718,
0.0071758344,
0.0500647239,
0.036467582,
-0.0166932028,
0.0639012083,
0.0375602208,
0.0062807733,
0.0742939487,
-0.0816562772,
0.0177925769,
-0.0362026803,
-0.0036184683,
-0.0119687235,
0.0366093628,
0.0279982649,
-0.0138241528,
0.0524707809,
-0.0048961923,
-0.0572928227,
-0.0263351165,
-0.0626052693,
-0.0521036275,
-0.0300138239,
-0.0162775293,
0.0554321557,
0.0239700098,
-0.0261176955,
0.0168777052,
-0.0277904272,
-0.0037987314,
-0.0062000817,
-0.0321065485,
-0.0464243218,
-0.0802618861,
-0.0092330137,
-0.0259408299,
0.0333931223,
0.0041921069,
0.0230532233,
0.0773638934,
0.0260730442,
0.006313276,
-0.0069555831,
-0.0831593126,
0.0230638515,
-0.0727148056,
0.0553932786,
0.0644060448,
-0.0261352342,
-0.0027922473,
0.0235477015,
0.0769797042,
-0.0355617628,
0.0668120459,
0.0487281233,
0.0156263355,
-0.016830666,
0.0693757758,
0.0856851861,
0.0513362288,
-0.0295799654,
-0.0251097903,
0.0361079089,
0.0231542252,
-0.0335866958,
0.0132277096,
0.0065841093,
-0.0195183102,
-0.0446661003,
-0.0342853256,
-0.0051516499,
-0.0551341027,
-0.0188222267,
-0.0020115953,
0.0104735605,
-0.0196013283,
0.0349840969,
0.0774332434,
-0.0106145656,
0.0061153071,
0.0520465113,
-0.0183148626,
0.002000218,
-0.0048147291,
0.0267823022,
-0.0128617641,
-0.081739895,
-0.0164468102,
-0.0120198121,
-0.014425125,
-0.0153961722,
0.0339770988,
0.0345473029,
-0.0930716693,
0.0127586154,
-0.0130661856,
-0.0499508232,
-0.0275042336,
-0.022175815,
0.0056693549,
0.0020299854,
0.0271220151,
0.0711438209,
0.0496310964,
-0.0091362102,
0.0125429407,
-0.0282820873,
0.0193440057,
0.0054935245,
-0.0257144012,
0.0276676621,
-0.0485208146,
-0.043805223,
0.0294548813,
-0.028620746,
-0.0345489085,
-0.001554713,
2.665e-7,
0.0389093943,
0.0435573272,
0.0334516056,
-0.0026704178,
-0.0074129072,
0.0099812746,
-0.0146646854,
0.0459679142,
-0.0003522404,
0.054562185,
0.0083606159,
0.0108501334,
0.0653190017,
0.04818042,
-0.086867474,
0.0170334652,
-0.0622874685,
0.0203555152,
-0.0602828376,
0.0062678941,
0.039629586,
0.1168075055,
-0.0156159634,
-0.0096095912,
-0.0048810341,
-0.0232895948,
0.0772803798,
-0.0031671256,
-0.0067971409,
-0.0232154801,
0.0381509475,
0.0214919932,
-0.0224734508,
-0.0263090134,
-0.0213308688,
0.0050047743,
0.0127647286,
0.0735523999,
-0.002748807,
-0.024799332,
0.0378018916,
-0.0359535664,
-0.0390312001,
-0.0244976021,
0.0570876636,
0.0077970303,
0.0167309847,
0.0515384935,
0.0186482146,
0.0299404338,
0.0382287838,
-0.0088777831,
-0.0491057336,
0.0317227207,
0.0539181009,
-0.0024271526,
-0.0320599787,
-0.0569831431,
-0.0637391061,
-0.0190041028,
0.0212159995,
-0.0238501132,
-0.0182439648,
0.0163050499,
0.0334479623,
0.0177224372,
-0.0001641372,
2.22783799e-34,
0.0294625126,
0.0145752514,
0.0510203391,
-0.0133784162,
0.0317776799,
-0.0557511114,
0.022373857,
0.0149307987,
0.0018236591,
-0.043424055,
-0.0301325042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14633v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14633v3 | Extending Input Contexts of Language Models through Training on Segmented Sequences | 2023-10-23T07:13:31 | 2024-06-19T14:00:27 | Petros Karypis, Julian McAuley, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Effectively training language models on long inputs poses many technical
challenges. As a cost consideration, languages models are pretrained on a fixed
sequence length before being adapted to longer sequences. We explore various
methods for adapting models to longer inputs by training on segmented sequences
and an interpolation-based method for extending absolute positional embeddings.
We develop a training procedure to extend the input context size of pretrained
models with no architectural changes and no additional memory costs than
training on the original input lengths. By sub-sampling segments from long
inputs while maintaining their original position the model is able to learn new
positional interactions. Our method benefits both models trained with absolute
positional embeddings, by extending their input contexts, as well as popular
relative positional embedding methods showing a reduced perplexity on sequences
longer than they were trained on. We demonstrate our method can extend input
contexts by a factor of 4x while improving perplexity. | [
0.0068359487,
0.0704848543,
-0.0117105804,
0.0306967515,
-0.0226212647,
0.0095253279,
0.0048265741,
-0.0039785407,
-0.0456798524,
-0.0380057618,
-0.009096764,
-0.0627877191,
0.0242415033,
0.0034334534,
0.0602520332,
-0.0824445635,
0.0314916708,
-0.0167843308,
-0.0258878153,
0.0084619187,
-0.0014409247,
-0.0026914927,
-0.0070129461,
0.0208122563,
-0.0178835299,
0.0122728823,
-0.0812703148,
-0.0161533412,
0.0006446533,
-0.0399819575,
-0.0318924934,
0.0464360602,
0.0575275347,
0.0117191803,
0.0000018181,
0.013640888,
-0.0084167635,
-0.024818318,
-0.0251768585,
0.0136698997,
0.0234619621,
-0.0252931584,
-0.003951584,
0.0008637462,
-0.0388413556,
-0.0310143549,
0.0548260435,
0.0229395535,
0.0297294538,
0.0865587592,
-0.0143298004,
-0.038370423,
-0.0002554677,
-0.0709347874,
0.0048455349,
-0.000101183,
0.0143746007,
0.0195379741,
0.0369245708,
0.0279582739,
-0.0565642491,
0.0277679618,
0.0479469076,
0.001913021,
-0.0108049279,
0.0439692847,
0.0205206219,
-0.0213819928,
0.0058862334,
0.0663546175,
-0.0711159259,
-0.0287239403,
-0.0148759661,
-0.0069793742,
0.0167834405,
-0.0320658535,
-0.0534554869,
-0.0063722357,
0.0565051064,
0.0207574405,
0.0306957159,
-0.0076112482,
0.0406321809,
-0.0106767835,
-0.092129454,
0.0345971473,
0.0254445355,
-0.0496539362,
-0.0522529371,
-0.0267936531,
-0.036482621,
-0.0184744019,
-0.0015713511,
0.0138077103,
-0.0048997467,
0.0628872216,
-0.0438062511,
-0.0108736269,
0.011603903,
-0.0318669863,
0.0292873085,
0.0577978678,
0.0002261364,
0.0271438397,
-0.0245829578,
0.0304433499,
-0.0048744758,
0.0196582098,
-0.0600291416,
0.0417459235,
-0.0254338551,
-0.0149367899,
-0.0403137878,
0.0105076469,
-0.0445444025,
-0.0463100709,
-0.0140933665,
0.0544103459,
0.0253377296,
0.0044359579,
0.0045228456,
0.0099481186,
-0.0353234708,
0.0028474189,
0.0334117338,
0.0289590321,
-0.031828098,
0.0201842599,
0.0016595396,
-0.0181839,
-0.0292614475,
0.0039997161,
0.0361463614,
-0.0272916052,
-0.0142748961,
0.0412806571,
0.0226697121,
-0.0539018176,
-0.0046295603,
0.0002246684,
-0.0300365612,
-0.0496074855,
0.01110995,
-0.0612657256,
0.0258160159,
-0.0126971425,
-0.0038922688,
-0.0280709714,
0.0140195303,
0.0091340784,
-0.0244787466,
0.0974622741,
0.0068037999,
-0.008046004,
-0.0096295094,
0.0056929346,
0.0569739901,
0.0881467164,
0.0306661874,
-0.0246394388,
0.030729102,
-0.0337616019,
-0.0349794701,
0.0464250781,
0.0321342163,
-0.0058327476,
-0.0382537134,
0.0005489067,
0.0355755985,
0.0298249908,
0.0345722921,
0.020590432,
-0.0542531759,
-0.0339603834,
0.0259647164,
0.0789321363,
0.0198505279,
0.0148934647,
0.0615147576,
-0.0021737893,
-0.0339516141,
0.0433924682,
-0.0527383089,
0.000656312,
0.044097919,
0.0577636324,
0.0242854133,
0.0072153173,
-0.0175161976,
-0.0227710046,
-0.0183625277,
-0.0312731154,
0.0632059649,
-0.0115106646,
0.042191118,
0.0111846598,
-0.0510227904,
0.0550630093,
0.0203833245,
-0.0685498491,
0.0079482067,
0.0261155032,
0.0011977794,
0.0570281371,
-0.0048864167,
-0.0362786688,
-0.0473977923,
-0.0023259087,
0.0150460545,
0.0277922414,
0.0228001364,
-0.0177018251,
0.0195769295,
-0.0307374913,
-0.0142700141,
0.0154516073,
0.0181697309,
0.0559743494,
0.0196281336,
0.0085725049,
0.0430063643,
-0.0313948877,
0.0249650292,
0.03058636,
-0.0706238747,
-0.018507814,
-0.0435987264,
0.0297604576,
0.0233417787,
0.0126841655,
-0.0035482722,
0.0356635563,
0.0847188011,
-0.0492290966,
0.0267046671,
-0.005852541,
-0.119705148,
-0.0707904324,
0.0826724917,
0.0344958454,
0.0015261699,
-0.0093279993,
-0.0192976929,
-0.0485907383,
0.0356970206,
-0.0375515521,
0.0746131837,
-0.0361951366,
0.0220721886,
0.0179903824,
0.013355175,
-0.0582557246,
0.0316912755,
-0.011021208,
0.0344419107,
0.0264129899,
0.0189522505,
-0.005900844,
-0.0389392078,
-0.0186021607,
0.0374618396,
0.000034036,
-0.0167577639,
-0.0090528922,
-0.031377472,
-0.0157483872,
-0.0284678098,
-0.1059867367,
-0.0364821181,
-0.0193409733,
0.0232993942,
-0.0001517493,
0.0288597271,
0.0173867177,
-0.0242475048,
-0.0414517894,
-0.03472431,
0.0113250604,
0.0260518249,
0.020412853,
0.0425601155,
-0.0660304874,
-0.0433430932,
-0.0205091406,
-0.0048994459,
0.0657117292,
-0.0508956686,
-0.0206660386,
-0.0635735691,
-0.0133122811,
-0.0135630928,
0.0589446574,
-0.0365046971,
-0.0504164435,
-0.00552999,
-0.0500979833,
0.0117249032,
0.0438502654,
-0.0016569992,
0.0240477435,
0.0332559459,
-0.019373348,
-0.0176743995,
-0.0084136529,
-0.0403709635,
0.038173385,
-0.0670991912,
0.0342795849,
-0.056112729,
0.0715139657,
-0.0420594923,
0.0033007595,
-0.0471052751,
-0.0061636893,
0.0008423494,
-0.0136565799,
0.0002186394,
-0.0375536904,
-0.0443735868,
0.0381596759,
-0.0392594896,
-0.0499462187,
0.0654297024,
-0.0656103268,
-0.0246128924,
-0.0466696844,
-0.023894608,
-0.0274729133,
0.0858392641,
0.0367608964,
0.0084306896,
-0.0265628044,
-0.0236241892,
-0.0576711483,
0.0112121562,
-0.0179718938,
-0.0129477819,
0.0486154556,
-0.0363469347,
0.0091555007,
-0.0109229004,
-0.0385800712,
-0.0437287167,
-0.0254423693,
0.0017226427,
0.0287977029,
0.019096449,
-0.0525381677,
0.0232211202,
0.0723458752,
0.0007496108,
0.0662141815,
0.0072668353,
0.0501826778,
-0.0402078852,
0.0061722388,
0.0409440473,
0.0097070877,
-0.0436847471,
-0.0152920298,
0.0022363544,
0.013650002,
0.039057523,
-0.0270193592,
-0.0482120477,
0.0333051942,
0.0174285229,
-0.036228139,
-0.0312846825,
0.014992496,
0.0093406215,
-0.0585309863,
-0.01921295,
0.1142323911,
0.0208479594,
-0.0471778847,
0.0372011401,
0.0194616839,
0.0470196009,
0.0197166484,
0.0124191782,
-0.0599766634,
-0.0042022001,
0.0082978569,
-0.0366688743,
0.0347258374,
0.0116835162,
-0.0254074093,
-0.1334200203,
-0.0161252804,
0.0437751524,
-0.045449391,
-0.0454133749,
-0.0428532399,
-0.0102488473,
0.0344623365,
0.0243382622,
0.0224238522,
-0.0227218941,
-0.0203865599,
0.0245338939,
-0.0155390427,
-0.046371825,
-0.0352427959,
-0.0193623938,
0.0217468534,
0.056740202,
0.0130008729,
0.0179282241,
-0.0166518707,
0.0545477197,
-0.0122183049,
0.0139011806,
0.0161295868,
0.0166849643,
0.0004580894,
-0.0063930918,
0.0639588609,
0.0159031954,
-0.0258517526,
-0.0132477703,
-0.0251006652,
0.0751082003,
-0.0068993107,
0.0323941819,
0.0077193053,
0.0006715335,
0.0054693385,
0.0297497716,
0.0671700612,
-0.0263415277,
-0.0181549583,
-0.0259254333,
0.0068988707,
-0.0142669948,
0.042904254,
-0.0233872551,
-0.0084720869,
-0.0377312228,
-0.0680724308,
-0.041581098,
0.0400367603,
0.0834371001,
0.0132783139,
0.0210364535,
0.0247168113,
-0.0319318213,
-0.0611738525,
0.0125227198,
0.0065903384,
0.0300280321,
-0.0189224239,
0.0055207554,
0.0126625448,
-0.0092713889,
-0.0042321896,
-0.0318977125,
-0.0590282343,
-0.0971817672,
0.0030756725,
0.0318455882,
0.0163577199,
0.104748033,
-0.0118135791,
0.0062393444,
0.0508103035,
-0.0195173174,
-0.0175032839,
0.0171200819,
0.0547605567,
-0.0149254585,
0.0154110286,
0.0315789729,
-0.0163096022,
-0.0218892694,
0.0126336999,
0.0242873188,
-0.0474624857,
-0.035739176,
0.0185998827,
-0.0377620347,
0.049128063,
0.0048258048,
0.0444807298,
-0.0137783289,
0.0553617068,
-0.0644527301,
0.0213378947,
-0.035497196,
-0.0053560701,
0.0288784485,
0.0189486705,
0.0189031381,
-0.032306429,
-0.0067152181,
0.0148743922,
0.0133558307,
0.0577019937,
-0.0008514156,
-0.0363460109,
0.0288803615,
0.0336980149,
-0.027079206,
0.0006530168,
-0.0484205037,
0.0303430986,
-0.0487574227,
0.0193347484,
0.0276099015,
0.0066818027,
-0.0314483866,
0.0506040268,
-0.057955347,
0.0214087702,
-0.0326881334,
0.0004480026,
0.0630252957,
-0.0449460372,
0.030587025,
-0.0014388411,
-0.0006944535,
-0.0034675014,
0.0396737941,
-0.0143999755,
-0.0783621967,
0.0262473878,
0.0603780486,
-0.0347715132,
0.0245702472,
0.0788735449,
0.0262800157,
0.0389644653,
-0.0014287895,
0.007977155,
-0.0202356279,
-0.0039645811,
0.0260876231,
0.0526509024,
-0.0460487939,
0.0275392309,
0.0108821914,
-0.0905869454,
-0.0226943158,
0.0013653924,
-0.0247868169,
0.0031884995,
0.0449447371,
0.0405635722,
-0.017274091,
0.0294512827,
-0.0055690338,
-0.0065222871,
0.0218984392,
-0.0614786558,
-0.0259738918,
-5.902689414e-33,
-0.0331132337,
-0.0129284412,
0.0088850427,
-0.0445245206,
-0.0684198663,
-0.0032786531,
-0.0232211668,
0.0374035239,
0.0109774545,
-0.0075987699,
-0.0222715568,
-0.008566347,
0.0032586565,
0.0267899577,
0.0007599694,
-0.0146135045,
0.0353014693,
0.0271087289,
0.0220203735,
-0.0013317266,
-0.004881388,
0.0404005758,
0.0570361055,
-0.0117500033,
0.0016383077,
-0.0000817441,
0.0185698718,
0.0261926446,
0.0101821814,
0.0536370575,
-0.0103042303,
-0.0006507823,
0.0270667151,
-0.0429084599,
-0.0373488925,
0.0162687674,
-0.0747713894,
-0.0078628687,
0.0202352237,
0.0319242328,
-0.0040228642,
-0.0218736734,
0.025137851,
-0.0374038294,
0.0473088473,
0.0023277919,
0.0064422218,
-0.045195695,
-0.0578741021,
0.0546956882,
-0.0453031324,
0.0302494001,
0.0057972716,
-0.0023072388,
0.0671596378,
0.0093079088,
0.0043106885,
-0.0372293666,
-0.0208702032,
0.0076231617,
0.0357850753,
0.091491811,
0.0305571258,
0.0385078378,
0.0238592885,
0.0245632324,
0.014295877,
-0.0561330877,
0.005680006,
0.0093902722,
0.0287416279,
0.0032011222,
0.0086344769,
-0.0031171369,
0.0401610024,
-0.0004132258,
-0.0354793519,
-0.0393022932,
0.0222459938,
0.0044556218,
0.0078190779,
0.0393102318,
-0.0164964646,
-0.0373094715,
-0.033896856,
-0.0220010728,
-0.0056079165,
-0.0651419535,
0.0239865165,
0.0353431702,
0.0037821892,
0.0176546723,
0.0481296219,
-0.0263705309,
-0.034495879,
0.0053192712,
-0.0030803927,
0.0127953701,
0.0126630049,
0.018807644,
-0.0177143738,
-0.0453818813,
0.0198168308,
-0.0250101071,
0.0013166348,
-0.02675738,
0.046365682,
0.0316076316,
-0.0473183058,
-0.0233974904,
-0.0298194848,
-0.039521873,
-0.000086805,
0.0885209814,
0.0729135349,
0.0188665185,
0.0040391204,
0.0628541782,
0.0031376609,
-0.0108071268,
-0.0017363392,
-0.0170541406,
0.0012597839,
0.0485393479,
-0.0356755443,
-0.020792447,
-0.02711978,
0.0539332218,
0.0359377973,
-0.0441684499,
-0.0191438552,
0.0237082634,
2.59e-7,
0.0428457111,
0.0189349689,
0.0679270402,
0.0048982194,
0.0158354174,
-0.0020606993,
-0.0285760779,
0.0195974186,
-0.0268750601,
-0.0011484806,
0.0168851726,
0.0013341329,
0.0198400058,
-0.0089192567,
-0.1044211239,
-0.0368933901,
-0.0563134141,
0.0178381335,
-0.0539153107,
-0.0081408164,
0.0208649579,
0.146533668,
0.0087577784,
0.0263352133,
0.0052553555,
-0.0303183384,
0.0224782471,
-0.019638082,
0.0004553197,
-0.0200886931,
-0.0280608349,
0.0105905961,
-0.0003567973,
-0.0066521359,
-0.0285363365,
0.0527630635,
-0.014850257,
0.0434266925,
-0.0213403311,
-0.0280166436,
0.0295017827,
-0.0104129305,
-0.0432325117,
-0.0507402979,
0.0457760207,
-0.0460854098,
-0.0138657093,
-0.0204333067,
-0.0358464047,
0.0138614047,
-0.0209076963,
0.0053348294,
-0.0016537387,
0.0277307592,
0.054357823,
-0.0169525184,
0.0171873253,
-0.0783780217,
-0.0291557275,
0.0043518823,
-0.0474654622,
-0.0131551567,
-0.0467413925,
-0.0114660487,
0.0567507446,
-0.0072703636,
-0.0129297273,
2.708931782e-34,
0.0285833832,
-0.020529151,
0.0194037482,
0.0427124873,
0.0282770153,
-0.053904634,
-0.0043279976,
0.0285866093,
0.0324435979,
-0.0793503076,
-0.0522244498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14628v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14628v2 | Plan, Verify and Switch: Integrated Reasoning with Diverse X-of-Thoughts | 2023-10-23T07:02:20 | 2023-12-27T13:54:48 | Tengxiao Liu, Qipeng Guo, Yuqing Yang, Xiangkun Hu, Yue Zhang, Xipeng Qiu, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) have shown effectiveness with different
prompting methods, such as Chain of Thought, Program of Thought, we find that
these methods have formed a great complementarity to each other on math
reasoning tasks. In this work, we propose XoT, an integrated problem solving
framework by prompting LLMs with diverse reasoning thoughts. For each question,
XoT always begins with selecting the most suitable method then executes each
method iteratively. Within each iteration, XoT actively checks the validity of
the generated answer and incorporates the feedback from external executors,
allowing it to dynamically switch among different prompting methods. Through
extensive experiments on 10 popular math reasoning datasets, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed approach and thoroughly analyze the strengths of
each module. Moreover, empirical results suggest that our framework is
orthogonal to recent work that makes improvements on single reasoning methods
and can further generalise to logical reasoning domain. By allowing method
switching, XoT provides a fresh perspective on the collaborative integration of
diverse reasoning thoughts in a unified framework. The code is available at
https://github.com/tengxiaoliu/XoT. | [
-0.0085325483,
0.0383801796,
-0.0028323818,
0.0353678018,
-0.0712490082,
0.0099592973,
0.0326825939,
-0.019394543,
0.0359240323,
-0.0111394674,
-0.0111934124,
0.0009238408,
-0.0065787574,
0.0234191623,
0.0048782718,
-0.0320059359,
0.0323975943,
-0.0717878714,
0.0260692481,
-0.0406402946,
-0.0148017388,
-0.0028062845,
-0.043972522,
0.0200080816,
-0.0180090107,
-0.0603765585,
-0.0166071933,
-0.0359123014,
0.0242430065,
-0.0221784543,
-0.0195278209,
0.0433168449,
-0.012997793,
0.0475423485,
0.0000025212,
-0.0528790094,
-0.0245063826,
-0.0075979992,
-0.0194569658,
-0.0487925783,
-0.0516186617,
0.0529769585,
0.0377387367,
0.0393001139,
-0.052123975,
0.0392827578,
0.0280968864,
0.0124671767,
0.0830454752,
0.0399974585,
0.0176680386,
-0.0147887971,
-0.0121967504,
0.0175599959,
0.0378334001,
-0.029174827,
0.0145608224,
0.0409564115,
0.0791021287,
0.0253371187,
-0.0192598235,
0.0438275151,
0.061781615,
-0.0164101031,
-0.0286551826,
0.0173217244,
-0.0157558415,
-0.0201936923,
-0.0365978666,
0.0502576232,
0.0005566965,
-0.0039314632,
-0.0139586022,
0.0006508211,
0.0169505626,
0.0164058004,
-0.0547596402,
0.0461476706,
-0.0340740643,
-0.0199741479,
0.0038635607,
0.0171101335,
0.0016085244,
0.008568218,
-0.0474453494,
0.0932189301,
0.0066745444,
-0.0423732847,
0.0058255275,
-0.0002539037,
-0.013055006,
-0.0816427544,
0.0176389404,
0.0665101111,
-0.0561245382,
0.0121145975,
0.0152465487,
-0.039113801,
-0.0138912359,
0.0189783294,
0.0597403087,
0.0764344931,
0.0008156896,
0.0357642919,
-0.0102899866,
0.0132098328,
-0.010985285,
0.0192795955,
-0.0224365387,
0.0298649464,
-0.0739446506,
-0.012272655,
-0.0162935834,
0.0749556571,
0.0122876232,
-0.0027234668,
-0.0152971316,
0.0334514119,
-0.037335176,
0.0352405608,
0.0258785132,
-0.0157413222,
0.0414171331,
-0.0330171958,
-0.0506939925,
0.0321186706,
-0.0693902373,
0.0144299064,
0.0294804294,
-0.0290020034,
-0.0252195261,
0.0015783181,
-0.0309575703,
-0.013535521,
0.0156408194,
0.0495772585,
-0.0135690141,
0.0352479182,
0.0025111532,
-0.0669648796,
0.0360020734,
-0.0863558128,
0.0142395552,
-0.116513744,
0.0346348584,
0.0204201937,
-0.0207567923,
0.0029483307,
0.0149913374,
0.0221870821,
0.0059409728,
0.0635749027,
0.0092416797,
0.0122276759,
0.031856779,
0.010200656,
-0.0565011278,
0.0677946657,
0.0374802984,
-0.0217246711,
-0.0079468358,
0.018997822,
0.0211605802,
0.0351900198,
0.0073459293,
-0.0232587066,
0.0059093931,
0.0341573358,
0.01112263,
0.0302406289,
-0.0874369144,
0.0403022245,
-0.0416621752,
0.0177047364,
0.0184130464,
0.0614199191,
-0.0171701722,
0.0041407435,
0.0302642491,
-0.0119137242,
0.0284705795,
-0.001617047,
-0.0546613373,
0.0852779299,
-0.0435369983,
-0.014097617,
0.0289612506,
0.0387501232,
-0.0224706437,
-0.0483699255,
-0.0178478193,
0.0239864998,
-0.0223665386,
0.0314676501,
0.0157384425,
-0.0253302697,
0.0160687864,
0.0445935167,
-0.0152471652,
-0.0221025739,
-0.0542075112,
-0.0501652472,
0.0801784843,
0.0223651063,
0.0537408702,
-0.0478255711,
-0.0442667231,
-0.0362112038,
0.0248203184,
0.0056173848,
0.0261313729,
-0.0057710586,
-0.0503177196,
-0.0426297151,
-0.0369604826,
-0.0218033902,
-0.0165190622,
0.0004638878,
0.0177535601,
-0.0028487211,
-0.0262896344,
0.001042527,
0.0429711267,
0.0125691956,
-0.0398000628,
0.0040460038,
-0.026645869,
0.0081911096,
-0.0060504354,
0.0011063674,
0.0133769559,
0.0456797257,
-0.0033247194,
-0.0139262704,
-0.0288060289,
0.0276074372,
-0.0369207487,
-0.0361663178,
0.050126154,
-0.0444377549,
-0.0296347905,
-0.0348691791,
-0.0450371206,
-0.0293927453,
0.041625645,
-0.0068610134,
-0.0271054693,
-0.0014145315,
0.0097851716,
0.0071741403,
-0.0498787686,
0.0001586041,
0.0852225497,
-0.0028610707,
0.0175115336,
0.0581041984,
0.0159077942,
0.0194754675,
-0.0174940173,
0.0244513862,
0.0179646946,
-0.0091601368,
0.0065327398,
-0.022628082,
0.0431826375,
-0.0545693524,
-0.0399870537,
-0.0400950983,
0.0182969607,
-0.019464897,
0.0232116356,
0.0009560239,
-0.0102468487,
-0.0029454369,
-0.0139982747,
-0.0564905852,
0.0204447135,
0.0234428346,
0.0175584219,
-0.0095388666,
-0.0259899572,
0.0105157793,
0.0161532536,
-0.0159225203,
-0.0503814481,
0.0385809317,
0.0085658235,
0.0017438313,
-0.0549974293,
0.0164847076,
-0.0693908334,
0.0063161249,
0.0041162982,
0.0369702056,
0.0545036495,
-0.0320850983,
0.0455984622,
0.0573404431,
-0.0220311955,
-0.0441133156,
0.0495513231,
-0.0420272909,
-0.0679557621,
0.0337932594,
0.0140254227,
0.0109574664,
0.0146956192,
-0.0076542329,
-0.0397204906,
0.0429834649,
0.0003542576,
-0.0037249117,
-0.0450827852,
0.0450377129,
0.0067939735,
-0.0028856122,
-0.0407692641,
-0.0201984756,
0.0033437496,
0.057303261,
-0.0015790779,
-0.0246806797,
0.0915358737,
0.0212446712,
-0.0088367565,
-0.0815320909,
0.0252293833,
-0.0521094464,
0.0521264076,
-0.0209378321,
-0.0158008821,
0.0102876481,
0.0149261998,
-0.0477901176,
0.004955011,
-0.0004703424,
-0.0400518924,
0.0466098711,
-0.0587966703,
-0.0073848981,
-0.0123583199,
-0.0458645932,
-0.0476003215,
0.0201225448,
-0.0618663207,
0.0133782336,
-0.0213809349,
-0.0293027349,
-0.0147416964,
-0.0167990234,
0.0468527935,
0.0188184194,
-0.0333437547,
-0.023988165,
-0.0076652677,
0.0041857501,
0.0095208855,
0.024671765,
0.0503945239,
-0.019594457,
0.0389414169,
0.0410238802,
0.0431141071,
-0.0176693555,
0.0076151197,
0.0010826616,
0.0127652613,
-0.0250253882,
-0.0094751706,
0.0211022478,
0.0642240718,
-0.0693625584,
-0.0320420042,
0.1055906266,
0.0544225089,
-0.0405278876,
-0.0188665111,
-0.0947500989,
0.0395071171,
0.0460586548,
0.0419625901,
-0.1119431555,
-0.0332183465,
0.0063091982,
-0.0309965163,
0.0015386026,
-0.0483098924,
-0.0081688585,
-0.103037931,
0.0307855327,
0.0091658216,
-0.0023177895,
0.0320817754,
0.0042520566,
0.0145885907,
0.0339397974,
-0.0669813007,
0.0393874161,
0.009992253,
0.0264509171,
0.0033982382,
0.0067407973,
0.0028970975,
0.0383411311,
-0.0106197009,
-0.016140515,
0.0246826317,
-0.0134501588,
0.0077921567,
-0.1125712097,
0.0204373486,
0.0461410172,
-0.0279421732,
-0.0322273299,
-0.0191158839,
-0.0043066372,
-0.0028078707,
-0.0219666865,
0.0644728988,
-0.0310082249,
-0.044434946,
0.060500443,
0.1235681623,
-0.0420060195,
-0.0094834967,
-0.0323857777,
0.036012169,
-0.0160069838,
0.048077751,
0.002488798,
-0.0404847786,
-0.03297133,
-0.0627319068,
-0.063400358,
-0.0398348942,
-0.0271575116,
0.011216077,
0.0648679435,
0.0393751077,
-0.0274949837,
-0.0181105155,
0.0794974193,
0.051207792,
0.0109066209,
-0.0197870433,
0.0197269283,
0.0278219283,
-0.0016527858,
0.0170065518,
-0.0284765773,
0.0299842488,
-0.0283982828,
0.0130190272,
-0.0203592088,
-0.014514179,
-0.0071367281,
0.0356577188,
-0.1019952819,
-0.0440290384,
-0.0582323596,
0.047225818,
0.0254400019,
-0.0055215121,
-0.0024004276,
-0.0279505774,
0.0289012082,
0.0038867099,
-0.0114826886,
-0.004330799,
0.005996028,
0.0342872702,
0.0304496698,
0.0253120475,
0.0022335043,
0.0015919144,
-0.0028607007,
0.0517587215,
-0.0396528654,
0.0007041579,
0.0153641878,
0.011145521,
-0.0553681143,
-0.0098545412,
0.031625092,
-0.0141558219,
0.0257251542,
-0.0178873297,
-0.0504951365,
-0.0320177972,
0.0253352486,
-0.0062626,
-0.0525827706,
0.0386807583,
-0.0130685596,
0.0201966818,
0.014973484,
0.0234928951,
0.0421053059,
0.032958407,
0.0276717097,
0.0580154732,
-0.0343071781,
0.0001007261,
-0.0266766939,
-0.0164988469,
0.047287669,
-0.0202990621,
0.1094560027,
0.0271388311,
-0.0131648807,
-0.0225832332,
-0.0036154478,
-0.0539197214,
-0.1399504542,
0.0422482193,
0.0310920291,
0.0117369164,
0.0373054333,
-0.0408882536,
-0.0583911389,
-0.0002863876,
0.0119752856,
0.0053527122,
0.0410265028,
-0.0236482527,
0.0406955034,
0.027882928,
0.0221470818,
-0.0814854056,
0.024930438,
-0.1049988195,
-0.0055953758,
0.0117846141,
0.0131517611,
-0.0483494885,
-0.0238267034,
-0.0337771773,
0.0249982849,
-0.0055085863,
0.0113486946,
-0.0768467188,
-0.0307239015,
0.0165394023,
0.0167010725,
0.0025014156,
0.0131178237,
0.0275348593,
0.0434676036,
0.0105035072,
-0.0007086569,
0.0230758879,
0.0341016017,
-0.0123108439,
-0.0613289066,
-0.0432921089,
-6.302860384e-33,
-0.01010828,
-0.0418166034,
0.067864053,
-0.0129948435,
0.0261999108,
-0.0420889966,
-0.034712702,
0.0507753156,
-0.0033598267,
-0.004699673,
-0.0120068565,
0.0128355445,
0.0000576022,
0.0109198913,
0.0392120034,
-0.0124505544,
-0.0060228147,
-0.0330664963,
-0.0517908297,
-0.0212326217,
0.028058663,
-0.0188414194,
0.0274657551,
-0.0481792018,
0.0165634081,
0.015654752,
0.0200954694,
0.0448169485,
-0.0913306251,
0.0295933392,
-0.0093229227,
0.0095286723,
0.0144315818,
-0.0140931243,
-0.0105335861,
0.0463654511,
0.007207837,
-0.0484863631,
0.0434947498,
-0.012121778,
-0.0730380565,
-0.0214956775,
-0.0158145707,
-0.0015245773,
-0.0036767882,
-0.0571970046,
0.009065764,
-0.0298151281,
0.0082337363,
0.0292420108,
-0.0330350846,
0.0163366832,
-0.0281587094,
-0.0436907783,
0.0176423099,
0.0593417175,
-0.0118730403,
-0.0063557704,
-0.0447405353,
0.0456163473,
0.0179111157,
0.0088581843,
0.0613870807,
-0.0270391572,
-0.0124348002,
0.0232523233,
0.0082724411,
-0.0321733244,
-0.0466400161,
0.0100307697,
-0.0098465318,
0.0754171461,
0.0775687993,
0.0002979753,
0.0063550612,
0.0403614789,
-0.0385594331,
-0.0202129241,
0.0332396589,
0.0208217315,
0.0469603762,
-0.0082919598,
-0.0057825898,
0.0156120714,
-0.0396132134,
0.0200783815,
-0.0424208082,
-0.0008528013,
0.0263109617,
-0.0083856909,
0.0085451799,
-0.0035744943,
0.0332874358,
-0.0168342702,
-0.0212656669,
0.0413218997,
0.0005548899,
0.0329185501,
-0.0026043216,
0.0367905982,
-0.0482713468,
0.0300912,
-0.0208333414,
0.0029455717,
0.0150770079,
0.0241387207,
0.0170917436,
0.0177876391,
-0.0543809794,
-0.0169780571,
-0.0701570436,
0.0302301571,
0.0119351381,
0.005641575,
0.0404437892,
0.0253361333,
-0.0071812407,
0.0114953425,
-0.0126233688,
-0.0719523281,
-0.0383671373,
0.0261955149,
-0.0184109267,
0.0067831934,
-0.0027068683,
-0.005284973,
-0.0543472022,
-0.0131061189,
0.0007011081,
-0.0313524902,
0.012765469,
0.0457543023,
3.123e-7,
-0.0013816674,
0.0252594184,
-0.0074374657,
0.0530668311,
0.0308118295,
0.0261662081,
-0.0369832702,
-0.0275112726,
0.0316628367,
-0.0680907369,
-0.0356550738,
0.0668792948,
0.0414314158,
0.0550569892,
-0.0585160218,
-0.044392217,
-0.0038237076,
-0.0091231987,
-0.0637995601,
0.0056849164,
0.0809611157,
0.0399706811,
0.0347936675,
0.0063512134,
-0.0079636276,
-0.0068127811,
0.0399553888,
0.0149875358,
0.0084986063,
0.007076541,
-0.0056475992,
-0.0355411619,
0.0311067179,
0.0362487435,
0.0297082793,
0.0178143121,
-0.0267485436,
0.0425514765,
0.0325215459,
-0.0125003792,
-0.0280878581,
-0.0468204282,
0.0025857468,
-0.0324103087,
0.0593739226,
-0.0307999998,
-0.0059524914,
-0.0066585294,
0.013062316,
-0.0260385741,
0.0322499126,
-0.0131236902,
0.0158307273,
0.0189094022,
0.0043757693,
-0.0005556765,
0.0139616672,
-0.0308193639,
-0.0279076528,
0.0105021698,
-0.0543702953,
-0.0343716964,
-0.0469566546,
0.0095667029,
0.0035072411,
-0.0400875844,
-0.0154083539,
2.888588875e-34,
0.0236489102,
-0.0154513828,
0.0433189981,
0.073959887,
0.0316819623,
-0.0068446258,
-0.0384309366,
0.0185943432,
0.0454931185,
-0.0630073547,
-0.0342965797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14627v1 | CrisisMatch: Semi-Supervised Few-Shot Learning for Fine-Grained Disaster Tweet Classification | 2023-10-23T07:01:09 | 2023-10-23T07:01:09 | Henry Peng Zou, Yue Zhou, Cornelia Caragea, Doina Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The shared real-time information about natural disasters on social media
platforms like Twitter and Facebook plays a critical role in informing
volunteers, emergency managers, and response organizations. However, supervised
learning models for monitoring disaster events require large amounts of
annotated data, making them unrealistic for real-time use in disaster events.
To address this challenge, we present a fine-grained disaster tweet
classification model under the semi-supervised, few-shot learning setting where
only a small number of annotated data is required. Our model, CrisisMatch,
effectively classifies tweets into fine-grained classes of interest using few
labeled data and large amounts of unlabeled data, mimicking the early stage of
a disaster. Through integrating effective semi-supervised learning ideas and
incorporating TextMixUp, CrisisMatch achieves performance improvement on two
disaster datasets of 11.2\% on average. Further analyses are also provided for
the influence of the number of labeled data and out-of-domain results. | [
-0.0048294254,
0.0265289042,
0.0117297331,
0.0104533397,
0.0050551603,
0.0473527238,
0.0002757394,
0.0037659348,
-0.0168916043,
-0.0796430781,
0.0185571685,
-0.0050669704,
-0.0650668666,
0.0237491317,
0.0168287419,
-0.0768039152,
0.0291773137,
0.0289023686,
0.0493411086,
0.0049295784,
0.0217974819,
0.0145424725,
-0.0011231143,
0.003079514,
0.0071617821,
0.0422033854,
-0.0226076078,
0.0170600675,
0.0505923219,
-0.0409260988,
0.0196391288,
0.0086563425,
0.0468916222,
0.0522423163,
0.0000018906,
-0.0147718238,
-0.0054056183,
-0.0340475887,
-0.0258781966,
-0.0459418744,
-0.0032751639,
-0.081144765,
0.0132049024,
0.0103227813,
-0.0395140611,
-0.038911093,
0.0396014452,
0.0421476737,
0.0380024388,
0.0837452561,
-0.0166473128,
-0.0159336086,
0.0139013091,
0.0084260963,
0.0275008697,
-0.0499312133,
0.003648862,
-0.0362192802,
0.0217641406,
0.0166389868,
0.0211991277,
0.0375449769,
-0.0183041282,
0.0620906428,
0.0530262813,
0.0276482534,
-0.06768962,
0.0025695069,
-0.0104377847,
0.0579307787,
-0.0081716226,
-0.0243120864,
0.0270049367,
-0.0471352264,
-0.0019511497,
-0.0019823394,
-0.0267265067,
-0.0607303865,
-0.0109706381,
0.0504866466,
-0.0440411158,
0.0446259566,
0.0288709551,
0.0365624167,
0.0084296456,
-0.0242368206,
-0.0509818532,
-0.0174830202,
-0.041768726,
0.0258861668,
-0.0104710981,
-0.0187116675,
-0.0019025705,
0.0214424357,
-0.0282526147,
-0.0254272856,
-0.0382090285,
-0.0221970454,
0.0029330293,
-0.0886987597,
-0.0185601339,
0.0105033228,
0.0154058216,
0.0383581035,
0.0189218279,
-0.0567663088,
0.0286280811,
0.041328609,
-0.0051410142,
-0.0079913698,
-0.1227078512,
0.0221653432,
-0.0010945055,
0.0330146141,
0.0435373448,
0.0182570405,
-0.0351592228,
-0.0179341696,
0.0085030748,
-0.0187140219,
-0.0250727534,
-0.0122804828,
-0.0214549173,
-0.0164647885,
0.0204817653,
0.0097673917,
-0.0453696474,
0.0276987664,
-0.0114820087,
-0.0338422172,
0.0135443639,
-0.0056929439,
0.061328657,
0.0095037939,
-0.0181934237,
0.01509248,
-0.0064318953,
-0.054058034,
-0.0540806912,
0.0021877675,
-0.0001906572,
-0.0191032421,
-0.0182626899,
-0.062066935,
-0.0013137592,
0.0122764828,
0.0044907467,
0.0323067196,
0.015640365,
-0.0480151251,
-0.0526294075,
0.0608134009,
-0.0553214028,
0.0471193939,
0.0211321879,
-0.0184549075,
0.0366913974,
0.091383256,
0.0307773519,
0.0399211459,
0.0617315844,
-0.0290978253,
0.0176113024,
-0.0161223449,
0.0047903061,
0.0069447807,
-0.0250791684,
-0.0014511119,
-0.0269132741,
0.0118982792,
-0.013175386,
-0.0580158532,
0.0153449262,
0.0374631844,
0.0369136557,
0.0095068458,
0.0118477307,
-0.0144113619,
0.0110050039,
0.0817817971,
-0.0466317385,
-0.0168330558,
0.0037097821,
0.0397150367,
-0.0636675507,
0.0043412824,
0.0667750463,
0.0354249105,
-0.0773585215,
-0.0207864344,
-0.0277423915,
0.0093881227,
-0.0534940884,
-0.01391182,
0.0431504175,
-0.0074352594,
-0.0006509706,
-0.0250857901,
0.0247094147,
0.0124577619,
0.0077260644,
-0.0347819105,
-0.0289982036,
0.0931992233,
-0.0011116097,
-0.0424313396,
-0.0177824851,
-0.048934713,
0.1015664637,
0.0102800354,
0.0052059386,
0.0458646566,
0.0363400243,
-0.0357407629,
-0.0505364574,
-0.0096662147,
0.0157334246,
-0.0342393629,
-0.020401096,
0.0336395539,
-0.006375629,
-0.008117727,
-0.0309415665,
0.0189146791,
0.0295590907,
-0.0503999218,
-0.0085762003,
0.0459434018,
-0.0037613076,
-0.0075435797,
0.0214455929,
-0.0299844686,
0.0152709214,
-0.0287533998,
-0.0911058411,
0.0145530282,
-0.0123871583,
-0.0063999523,
0.0138399992,
-0.0140692322,
-0.0124249263,
0.000605836,
-0.0863270536,
-0.0089645917,
0.0619961359,
0.0097842021,
0.0066123558,
-0.0332171395,
-0.0227643549,
-0.0116091082,
-0.0083895419,
-0.0085361386,
0.0737976506,
0.003297176,
0.0058062668,
-0.0802784562,
-0.04426267,
0.0165016688,
0.0245771483,
0.0088742403,
-0.0230467208,
-0.0471121036,
0.0264842417,
-0.0079720896,
-0.0252322648,
-0.0213666838,
-0.0020329708,
-0.00951441,
-0.0020626045,
-0.0277173854,
0.020535009,
0.0077730082,
0.0139187062,
-0.0142794196,
0.0002214567,
0.0116403261,
0.0403331965,
0.0008439016,
0.0168130472,
0.034296643,
-0.0179393962,
0.0640007183,
-0.0325146243,
0.0056834808,
-0.0030777929,
0.0246913303,
0.0283404756,
-0.1089188159,
-0.0112822643,
-0.0095879119,
-0.0215047374,
-0.0254367013,
0.0170576312,
-0.0741316602,
0.0027469711,
-0.0047196187,
-0.0337276049,
-0.0632574931,
0.0132773342,
0.0436556712,
-0.0022646186,
0.0386042222,
-0.0374818258,
0.0184033941,
-0.0344156213,
-0.0638033524,
-0.0343994945,
0.0019352507,
-0.0346975513,
0.0399489067,
-0.032796748,
0.0181187969,
-0.0293581691,
-0.0045286505,
-0.0003686935,
-0.0061343336,
-0.0355237126,
0.0075765718,
0.005569221,
-0.0103418622,
-0.0146259647,
-0.0163846202,
0.0179937519,
0.0610395558,
0.040511176,
-0.0052921483,
-0.0547765717,
-0.0503464229,
0.0389901698,
-0.0229210109,
0.0240284,
0.0383204706,
0.0125398943,
0.0007404978,
-0.030813612,
-0.0033596358,
-0.0225488599,
-0.0437666662,
0.0252651405,
0.0309803765,
-0.0124377366,
-0.0283860825,
-0.017196022,
-0.0775090531,
-0.041635599,
-0.0253250897,
-0.0373494588,
0.0323120728,
-0.0414143577,
0.0256687291,
0.0158433057,
0.0014803498,
0.0227963459,
-0.0481414497,
-0.0168347396,
0.0619073547,
0.0077068326,
-0.0125808176,
-0.0204294659,
-0.0242312923,
0.0480982251,
0.0341041833,
0.0173440315,
-0.0028431176,
-0.0361701921,
-0.0184912719,
0.0155723644,
-0.0188441668,
0.0120847328,
-0.0135379983,
0.0645544305,
0.0097283144,
0.0115811443,
0.0779661238,
0.0393415801,
-0.0337303132,
0.0129194511,
-0.0119966157,
-0.0056060445,
0.0302592348,
0.0136348773,
-0.0171219762,
-0.0490208007,
-0.0217422768,
0.0149574466,
0.004295852,
-0.0415098593,
0.0298669133,
-0.0460653454,
0.021106882,
-0.0004817813,
-0.0386890098,
-0.0078666667,
-0.0773448348,
0.0470155403,
-0.0197583362,
-0.0566844232,
-0.042563308,
-0.033258006,
-0.0032588404,
0.0296977181,
-0.0411459915,
-0.104211688,
0.0149323465,
-0.0407540724,
0.0379247069,
-0.00834601,
0.0350614041,
-0.0135751367,
0.0370773748,
0.0648469627,
0.0119248582,
0.0236942936,
-0.012757754,
0.0933930278,
-0.0079932492,
-0.019171061,
0.0022696771,
0.0238017961,
-0.0551108196,
-0.000119052,
-0.0171986278,
0.0690267757,
-0.018867353,
-0.0230108518,
-0.054722663,
0.0187800657,
0.0511148535,
0.0297857132,
0.0271581504,
-0.0450828858,
-0.0139480196,
0.0048766895,
0.0069262749,
-0.0428501628,
0.0007552252,
0.0088401074,
-0.0193691365,
-0.1010462791,
-0.0308627915,
-0.014702295,
0.039436724,
0.0171683524,
-0.0613029152,
-0.0140529405,
0.0160477292,
-0.0338320844,
-0.033658132,
0.0142257288,
-0.0245555528,
0.0403734259,
0.0012257431,
-0.0315659828,
0.0205371212,
0.0265627652,
0.0003531617,
0.0061475737,
-0.0870202258,
-0.0476431474,
-0.0033757852,
0.0155916074,
0.0161784347,
-0.0276309364,
-0.0071259448,
-0.0376600809,
0.0280106999,
0.1302677989,
-0.024477765,
-0.0402233377,
0.0134417815,
-0.0187148191,
0.013802167,
0.0414846316,
-0.0356637761,
0.0564236343,
0.0062477821,
0.0109958528,
-0.092836909,
0.0574488007,
-0.0307813808,
-0.0211588945,
0.0911886618,
0.0220004376,
-0.0976034403,
-0.0077701784,
-0.0179606732,
0.0227321088,
-0.014935975,
0.0001059285,
0.0399380326,
0.0273199901,
0.0214320272,
-0.0401571207,
0.0047741253,
-0.0120150466,
0.0434983373,
-0.0521289743,
-0.0140185291,
0.0339436606,
0.0171295349,
-0.0323341228,
0.0254727416,
0.0113179246,
0.0464543253,
0.0579812191,
-0.0636424571,
-0.0051990286,
-0.015815245,
0.0101052169,
0.0759168789,
-0.0174678881,
0.0140108429,
-0.0101516796,
-0.007778178,
-0.032401707,
0.0150174769,
0.052173119,
0.0225386638,
-0.0127765089,
0.031228466,
-0.015367467,
0.0042340788,
0.0184728336,
-0.0204743519,
-0.0471367091,
0.0247333981,
0.0257321354,
-0.0454984121,
0.0387042277,
0.0631649271,
0.0100536477,
0.0075568319,
0.046507705,
-0.0105160819,
-0.0104307327,
0.0253805444,
0.0135411285,
0.0642393827,
0.0141379116,
0.0490806624,
-0.046320308,
-0.0083560897,
0.0293613803,
-0.0608946085,
-0.037377391,
0.0041674427,
0.0175327621,
0.0123721873,
0.0126702031,
0.0546839982,
-0.0184831712,
-0.0167697221,
0.0216458924,
-0.0021168035,
0.0381528735,
-6.952418726e-33,
0.0188482981,
-0.0362613611,
-0.0275891256,
-0.0221032333,
0.0169393811,
0.0341695659,
0.0177829303,
0.0164726041,
-0.0029645488,
-0.0130128758,
0.0036349776,
0.0302991588,
0.0083570601,
-0.0055128345,
0.0495757051,
-0.0209909268,
0.0157694425,
-0.013084555,
-0.0077267545,
0.0113299815,
0.0483805761,
0.0204590075,
0.0209207814,
-0.0843304396,
-0.0342382714,
-0.0041864347,
-0.0137546211,
-0.0355458446,
0.0786956772,
0.0285796914,
-0.0444697104,
0.067569755,
0.059437301,
0.001452184,
-0.0037616068,
0.0330293365,
0.010700237,
-0.0305636339,
-0.024000559,
-0.0289158504,
-0.0107534053,
-0.0162149407,
0.0016744938,
0.0369439498,
0.0064586638,
-0.0186172277,
0.0473300926,
0.0093078036,
-0.0021623245,
-0.0262719542,
-0.0653934404,
0.0439189859,
-0.0453992411,
-0.0296596196,
0.0224131849,
0.0375923514,
0.0265555196,
0.069201231,
-0.0405552797,
-0.0119591793,
-0.0164111014,
-0.0011125619,
0.0189954173,
-0.026357742,
-0.0515626594,
0.0607854687,
-0.0213055592,
0.030549055,
-0.0245148912,
-0.0016300795,
-0.0131653631,
0.0446138792,
0.0087066526,
0.1098600551,
0.0747211725,
-0.0711898953,
-0.043759007,
0.0077023255,
0.0044085002,
0.0185102485,
0.0133596482,
0.0320277773,
-0.0235647205,
0.014714404,
0.0264298562,
-0.0391135141,
-0.0572327226,
0.0304983202,
-0.0446210131,
0.0317907222,
-0.0005943354,
0.0869988948,
0.0112785418,
-0.0042610685,
-0.0347545967,
-0.0030415477,
0.0271514263,
0.0530135371,
0.0155691048,
0.0124483192,
-0.0681666061,
-0.0341286361,
0.0223473012,
0.0542095192,
0.0161362737,
-0.0060807453,
0.0554843619,
0.0476047285,
-0.0286460016,
0.0028647839,
-0.0158365406,
-0.0056971386,
-0.0742026716,
-0.0339209661,
-0.0134618292,
0.0212134067,
0.0157426409,
0.0107298726,
0.0425634198,
-0.0441132374,
0.0792799443,
-0.0136828162,
-0.0622272789,
-0.0160767417,
0.0308956243,
-0.000681159,
-0.0212716926,
-0.0303103272,
-0.0043023434,
-0.0322558433,
-0.0033764027,
0.0030972483,
2.742e-7,
0.0338677317,
0.0733870268,
-0.0152276577,
-0.0244997907,
-0.0019935456,
0.0424797013,
-0.0089879045,
0.0513479561,
-0.0112376595,
-0.027287377,
0.0427528396,
0.0304704215,
0.0584012084,
0.0449823104,
-0.047659941,
0.0385204367,
-0.0665046126,
0.0326311849,
-0.0845469087,
-0.0180943739,
0.1008106023,
0.0545823164,
0.0564418882,
-0.0152170565,
-0.0014930563,
-0.0561504588,
0.0466897227,
-0.0352597795,
-0.0159319695,
0.0210233349,
0.0110413861,
0.0636105463,
-0.0181008298,
0.0126897395,
-0.030332448,
-0.0080049681,
0.0495219231,
0.0143649196,
-0.0213081595,
-0.0136775402,
-0.0211175568,
-0.0231248289,
0.0075499308,
-0.0106663248,
0.049787946,
-0.1013983712,
-0.0358499177,
0.0202544499,
-0.0524095446,
0.0406740941,
0.0544964969,
-0.0052605914,
-0.0531013608,
0.0231196154,
0.0096245892,
-0.0290181134,
-0.0595852174,
-0.0688525215,
0.0382844023,
0.0247650314,
0.0091981897,
0.0102598537,
-0.0142610017,
0.0112140989,
0.0756329522,
-0.0294858683,
0.0311533678,
1.622202752e-34,
0.0203550402,
-0.0109291617,
-0.0319352187,
-0.0397687294,
-0.0328298509,
0.0283106752,
-0.0235779732,
-0.0243670009,
0.0179282073,
-0.0042830873,
0.0502405651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14626v1 | Conversational Recommender System and Large Language Model Are Made for Each Other in E-commerce Pre-sales Dialogue | 2023-10-23T07:00:51 | 2023-10-23T07:00:51 | Yuanxing Liu, Wei-Nan Zhang, Yifan Chen, Yuchi Zhang, Haopeng Bai, Fan Feng, Hengbin Cui, Yongbin Li, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | E-commerce pre-sales dialogue aims to understand and elicit user needs and
preferences for the items they are seeking so as to provide appropriate
recommendations. Conversational recommender systems (CRSs) learn user
representation and provide accurate recommendations based on dialogue context,
but rely on external knowledge. Large language models (LLMs) generate responses
that mimic pre-sales dialogues after fine-tuning, but lack domain-specific
knowledge for accurate recommendations. Intuitively, the strengths of LLM and
CRS in E-commerce pre-sales dialogues are complementary, yet no previous work
has explored this. This paper investigates the effectiveness of combining LLM
and CRS in E-commerce pre-sales dialogues, proposing two collaboration methods:
CRS assisting LLM and LLM assisting CRS. We conduct extensive experiments on a
real-world dataset of Ecommerce pre-sales dialogues. We analyze the impact of
two collaborative approaches with two CRSs and two LLMs on four tasks of
Ecommerce pre-sales dialogue. We find that collaborations between CRS and LLM
can be very effective in some cases. | [
0.1011965275,
0.0466419645,
-0.0302835144,
0.0352507718,
-0.0228352603,
-0.0259702411,
0.0333069265,
-0.0250890516,
0.0352192372,
-0.0646648332,
-0.0552787296,
-0.0241208244,
-0.0076265964,
0.0691782311,
-0.0340205058,
-0.0412691608,
-0.0126104876,
-0.0310965795,
0.0105828177,
-0.0052582305,
0.0611444637,
0.0316207297,
-0.0096266232,
0.0193093978,
0.028887257,
-0.0277995653,
-0.0322078019,
-0.0557466932,
-0.0084289154,
0.011440252,
0.0529852882,
0.0340590328,
0.0481438041,
-0.0186302289,
0.0000018681,
-0.0886815488,
-0.0151402522,
-0.0519119501,
-0.0594164506,
-0.0158375129,
0.0268116817,
0.0582699738,
0.0365454629,
0.0139464233,
-0.0585932657,
0.039005477,
0.0384220108,
0.0805096701,
0.0390140191,
0.0308010001,
-0.0257820915,
-0.0284968168,
-0.0301765669,
0.0048048487,
0.0064743347,
-0.0347627066,
0.0172536857,
0.0041622696,
0.0102989199,
0.0122887567,
0.0257115904,
-0.0139573645,
-0.0391866937,
-0.0508738197,
0.0167999975,
0.0137321465,
-0.030960273,
-0.0040494804,
-0.0119942771,
0.1031545028,
0.0350695811,
-0.0009159429,
-0.0216855742,
0.0181840044,
0.0043978863,
-0.0013291317,
-0.0408128127,
-0.0073564532,
0.0028114947,
-0.0045218761,
-0.0697028711,
0.0297739487,
0.009972563,
0.0132827181,
-0.0116166128,
0.0843041986,
-0.0258723255,
-0.0419888049,
-0.0268893279,
-0.0088425148,
0.0163895953,
-0.0784733668,
0.0104048951,
0.0264604129,
-0.0895284414,
0.0169021189,
0.0413506664,
0.0738165081,
-0.017917797,
-0.068908006,
0.0376110896,
0.0059504495,
0.0233824961,
0.0461294912,
0.0037416338,
0.0064810775,
0.0392516553,
-0.033757057,
-0.0372469164,
0.0080176573,
-0.0254793931,
-0.0318101272,
-0.0152165694,
0.0499705933,
-0.0537642688,
-0.0553649887,
-0.0203457065,
0.0362024717,
-0.015995672,
0.0277355574,
0.0151739148,
0.0462386943,
0.0211930368,
-0.0316222347,
-0.1066452116,
-0.0197930504,
-0.0309897196,
0.0471443273,
0.0007879597,
-0.0125522669,
0.0460965969,
0.0507237241,
-0.0039847265,
-0.0191540532,
-0.0200448725,
0.0406350382,
0.0231372397,
0.0087440284,
-0.0325268582,
-0.0169810299,
-0.0073289457,
-0.0345248394,
-0.0429967009,
-0.030586008,
0.0391339399,
0.0496873371,
-0.0231068041,
-0.0071511278,
0.0267309435,
0.0101619409,
0.0147464434,
0.0893488154,
-0.0015291512,
0.0001321848,
0.0498018637,
0.0132252974,
0.0337398835,
0.0033442874,
-0.0090220692,
0.0471414514,
0.0503089726,
0.0218728893,
0.0314355716,
0.0096461428,
-0.0554859638,
-0.0372476801,
-0.018422287,
0.054984726,
-0.0399751551,
0.0111005418,
0.0251531918,
0.0445068479,
-0.0544912964,
0.0158372391,
0.083341606,
0.0323047861,
0.0176372454,
0.0483464338,
0.0362853855,
0.0620181859,
-0.0149562117,
-0.0224779863,
0.0302796792,
0.0223662592,
-0.0235527996,
-0.0381590985,
0.0368575938,
-0.0331834853,
-0.0346600898,
-0.0472168587,
0.039481312,
-0.0547920056,
0.0375932083,
0.0522986911,
-0.0031462268,
-0.0181242004,
-0.032759279,
0.0336826406,
0.0291924924,
-0.0238111578,
-0.0337500721,
-0.0040242751,
0.0524301678,
0.1432040483,
0.0200670213,
-0.0102943005,
-0.0193119813,
-0.0229470842,
-0.0085834246,
0.0131729376,
0.0470974632,
-0.0378000215,
-0.0136076296,
-0.0600374974,
-0.0329132155,
-0.0084650302,
-0.0494289324,
0.0443790592,
-0.0116476305,
-0.0265161041,
0.0318784639,
0.0300703645,
0.0117302453,
-0.0304251574,
0.0035246043,
0.0032031643,
0.0080200154,
0.0115442546,
0.0315142311,
0.0059912954,
0.0180653036,
0.0031844606,
0.0094929365,
0.0077490383,
-0.0476244539,
0.0411041677,
-0.0232741088,
-0.0112554505,
0.0291256551,
0.0093927104,
0.0109697515,
-0.0082162051,
0.0125889285,
-0.0424898192,
0.0360099189,
0.0046840194,
0.0579468384,
-0.0301672146,
0.0123159271,
-0.0000042973,
0.0024501483,
-0.0264873635,
0.028084008,
0.0521931164,
0.010271702,
0.0298272707,
-0.0084199123,
0.0073487088,
-0.0281730387,
0.0068528159,
-0.0017471017,
0.0411814339,
0.0380997509,
0.032304626,
-0.0167482793,
-0.0298718289,
-0.0193618368,
-0.0866390616,
-0.0152583439,
0.0297941826,
0.0054850406,
-0.0159835629,
0.0265861135,
0.018741658,
-0.0205712859,
-0.0570854656,
0.0347846448,
0.0176700894,
-0.0118900286,
0.0387175865,
0.0535024963,
-0.0253872182,
-0.0223190337,
0.0293650627,
0.0135911722,
0.0155265639,
0.0289360359,
-0.0253588781,
-0.055029463,
-0.0120961349,
-0.0534547567,
-0.0018287873,
-0.009977093,
-0.0104184747,
-0.0280515775,
0.0041535697,
0.051313065,
-0.0107014952,
0.0301101264,
-0.006776331,
0.0094302036,
-0.0644022301,
-0.0734772831,
-0.0273650382,
-0.0255910307,
-0.0217007902,
-0.0371598601,
0.0304862242,
0.0256374143,
0.0256643388,
-0.0088745821,
0.0061011417,
-0.0292950142,
0.0289567187,
0.0534782112,
0.0013010975,
-0.0414692611,
-0.0425224118,
-0.0435208827,
0.0877750218,
0.0010262729,
-0.0284075662,
0.0429995395,
-0.0005483402,
-0.0130042015,
-0.0327999257,
-0.0384710804,
-0.0673155412,
-0.0630849749,
-0.0011712093,
0.025704084,
-0.0224255007,
-0.0511482656,
0.0133452248,
0.0065716198,
0.0359771512,
-0.0180752855,
0.0510603599,
-0.0428460911,
0.0266237613,
0.0176247526,
-0.0444233976,
-0.0646790788,
-0.0610274002,
-0.0097321728,
0.0010030732,
0.0321113206,
0.0029850232,
-0.0591607429,
0.0128668305,
0.0018309397,
0.0210983288,
0.0118613364,
-0.0415095352,
0.0186947212,
-0.0201195478,
0.0258659143,
-0.0106169665,
-0.0122146402,
-0.0272735599,
0.0518414602,
-0.0136043727,
-0.0273979008,
-0.0736065581,
-0.0405750051,
-0.0233061723,
0.0422752686,
0.0047389595,
0.0314901583,
0.0511648096,
-0.0283394586,
0.0119603155,
0.0135620441,
0.1108704805,
0.0140315406,
-0.0683401823,
-0.0137785031,
-0.0361928418,
-0.015293004,
0.0184517764,
0.0311613418,
-0.0420070589,
0.0083215088,
-0.0156957284,
0.0114614246,
0.0068960604,
-0.0267319195,
-0.010980173,
-0.1031611934,
0.0239175744,
-0.0085868845,
0.0090350742,
0.0319344886,
0.0156116709,
-0.0123142926,
-0.0089432867,
0.0733335242,
-0.011191505,
-0.0240799244,
0.0062201051,
0.004347173,
-0.0389211848,
-0.0340941064,
0.0269094501,
-0.007093986,
0.0181622002,
0.0779111162,
0.0134097086,
0.0157506447,
0.0247977972,
0.0294968598,
0.0069778953,
-0.005308419,
0.0255509391,
0.0196537562,
0.0103905657,
0.0188340917,
-0.0060326508,
-0.0094972253,
-0.0221740454,
-0.0070922682,
0.0407626852,
-0.0001765549,
-0.0253492575,
0.011431573,
0.0361708291,
0.0732087567,
0.0252951626,
0.0613292381,
0.0210768897,
-0.0636500493,
0.0148057891,
-0.0548753999,
-0.0457342155,
0.0162864458,
-0.0347774997,
0.0078082778,
0.0399837568,
0.031957861,
-0.0776943266,
-0.0238752402,
0.012469681,
-0.00236813,
0.0420051254,
0.0240423605,
0.0078698816,
0.0158151574,
0.0381867066,
0.0199470278,
-0.0412061624,
0.0362772122,
-0.068951942,
0.0354575291,
0.0361189768,
-0.0808774903,
-0.0126917986,
-0.0221636109,
0.0139184585,
-0.042058412,
-0.0597733371,
0.0583265685,
0.0231226347,
0.0398608111,
-0.0108376862,
-0.0896608829,
-0.046835538,
0.0506295972,
-0.0409110226,
-0.065369226,
0.0135454265,
0.0901527703,
0.00454723,
0.0371505842,
-0.0253681038,
0.0127476305,
-0.0005723478,
-0.0073114336,
-0.0289574713,
-0.0926859751,
0.0534795858,
0.0046216808,
0.0148508698,
0.0435280763,
0.0528089069,
-0.0114226239,
0.0480885766,
-0.0236457214,
-0.0603024028,
-0.0459212884,
-0.0226614419,
0.0163608678,
-0.0274713505,
0.0265857466,
0.0052529066,
-0.0546626151,
0.0053797141,
-0.0092038661,
0.0302658435,
0.0151141221,
-0.0119219096,
0.0459658206,
-0.0045345812,
0.0094804289,
0.0085246395,
0.0595594049,
0.037095096,
-0.0002094081,
0.0795189366,
0.0025038766,
-0.0371813774,
-0.0110572176,
0.0045037898,
0.0044277781,
-0.0839536712,
-0.0043581231,
0.0093476456,
-0.0173770934,
-0.0320920534,
0.009655769,
-0.0424304865,
0.011028016,
-0.0483895577,
0.026707951,
-0.0124017252,
-0.0197328888,
0.0300161988,
0.0211821292,
-0.0505463257,
0.0217484124,
0.0576060265,
-0.0625152811,
-0.0208885428,
-0.018377766,
-0.0433426201,
-0.0618708506,
-0.0290265735,
0.0204370208,
0.0396159366,
-0.0427459292,
0.0032595315,
-0.018646881,
-0.0046922807,
-0.0148098366,
-0.0347080864,
0.0108465645,
-0.0135335941,
0.0542404875,
0.0490288734,
-0.005793123,
0.0443134904,
-0.0668448061,
0.0201571453,
-0.0196092371,
0.0110680126,
-0.0627553314,
-5.42613078e-33,
0.0102850525,
-0.0318661369,
0.013598077,
0.0508091524,
0.0254159346,
-0.0374740884,
-0.0107224025,
0.0269641578,
0.0293208081,
0.0133635756,
-0.001974643,
-0.0063768672,
0.0177724026,
0.0177558959,
0.0190406293,
-0.019604817,
0.0499947518,
0.0216680001,
-0.0268270597,
0.0467698388,
0.0377883762,
0.0335184298,
0.0025633387,
-0.0788946599,
0.0295364112,
-0.0389608108,
-0.0047191437,
0.0594408065,
0.0082203839,
0.0709764734,
-0.0077799321,
0.0302247424,
0.0149469059,
-0.0049864328,
0.0002358919,
0.0195689481,
-0.0339277796,
0.0363001749,
0.0801080838,
0.0102242287,
0.0068985457,
0.0160925202,
-0.0177565925,
-0.043036487,
0.0260229111,
0.0526188836,
0.0236104038,
-0.0544346161,
-0.0291834939,
-0.0174433328,
-0.0463383384,
-0.0034883039,
-0.0511862598,
-0.028580429,
0.054576654,
0.0811119899,
-0.0122930259,
0.0058012032,
0.0058012069,
0.0610391162,
-0.020910345,
-0.016827127,
0.0118262134,
-0.0110248458,
-0.0356625207,
0.0461727865,
-0.0236429144,
-0.0038332206,
-0.0019959137,
0.0137700653,
-0.0571028478,
0.0811268315,
-0.016329268,
0.0634489954,
-0.0484623015,
0.0441467464,
-0.0076804846,
0.0341452248,
0.0235899948,
-0.0095582437,
0.0227395594,
0.0130069768,
-0.0353335403,
-0.0518750884,
-0.003404537,
0.028833963,
-0.0716717392,
-0.0454476327,
0.0199170839,
0.0313588418,
-0.0049524442,
0.0084230779,
0.0158925671,
-0.0468851365,
-0.0714033917,
0.0155753084,
-0.0048825028,
-0.0484897941,
0.002240544,
-0.0196675155,
-0.0578425825,
-0.0269567631,
0.0159542784,
-0.0286258738,
-0.0268051177,
0.0177369099,
0.0216544326,
-0.0285022389,
-0.0298635066,
0.016297197,
-0.003379738,
-0.0038915013,
-0.0297191255,
0.0401386023,
0.0126514593,
0.0128264986,
-0.0493087843,
0.0694171861,
-0.0176143534,
-0.0250477977,
-0.0308443177,
-0.0922736079,
0.0035973212,
0.0023751068,
-0.0552464314,
-0.0414685532,
-0.0065903668,
0.0084832106,
0.0482463464,
-0.0255783033,
-0.0271703657,
-0.0152202137,
2.568e-7,
0.0015952918,
0.0582831688,
-0.0471504368,
-0.0021405388,
0.0164757669,
0.0305949543,
0.0000713974,
0.0155700278,
0.0518226959,
-0.0061316052,
0.0340313166,
0.0000857222,
0.0411215052,
0.0006100429,
-0.0540579334,
-0.0328346379,
-0.0344676711,
-0.0546398088,
-0.0475373194,
-0.0007061212,
0.030536985,
0.0363169052,
0.0133180888,
0.0034367936,
-0.0217650831,
-0.0307529923,
0.0392573141,
-0.0882122219,
-0.029410461,
0.0314907655,
0.0453002937,
-0.0126256663,
-0.0205761418,
-0.0062822173,
-0.0081354706,
0.0377525054,
0.0110700447,
0.0445911102,
0.0210856888,
-0.0097252969,
-0.0032724859,
-0.0053369738,
-0.0034128714,
-0.0339600705,
0.0332450867,
-0.0801282004,
-0.0407568142,
-0.0396263562,
0.0008983103,
-0.0728972331,
-0.0069853012,
-0.0283397939,
0.0040696617,
0.0217399411,
0.008220668,
-0.0077338531,
0.0028139041,
-0.0475104079,
0.0269578919,
0.0242122617,
-0.0448864587,
-0.015299377,
0.0042508892,
0.0196126234,
0.0039786147,
-0.0075065275,
0.0765534788,
1.580864611e-34,
0.0494577959,
0.0387968682,
-0.0064035109,
0.0294980854,
0.0570987202,
0.0009465772,
0.0025926442,
0.0148003018,
0.0292357039,
-0.0771188214,
-0.0123581691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14623v1 | CoF-CoT: Enhancing Large Language Models with Coarse-to-Fine Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Multi-domain NLU Tasks | 2023-10-23T06:54:51 | 2023-10-23T06:54:51 | Hoang H. Nguyen, Ye Liu, Chenwei Zhang, Tao Zhang, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While Chain-of-Thought prompting is popular in reasoning tasks, its
application to Large Language Models (LLMs) in Natural Language Understanding
(NLU) is under-explored. Motivated by multi-step reasoning of LLMs, we propose
Coarse-to-Fine Chain-of-Thought (CoF-CoT) approach that breaks down NLU tasks
into multiple reasoning steps where LLMs can learn to acquire and leverage
essential concepts to solve tasks from different granularities. Moreover, we
propose leveraging semantic-based Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR)
structured knowledge as an intermediate step to capture the nuances and diverse
structures of utterances, and to understand connections between their varying
levels of granularity. Our proposed approach is demonstrated effective in
assisting the LLMs adapt to the multi-grained NLU tasks under both zero-shot
and few-shot multi-domain settings. | [
0.0061342134,
0.0074434793,
-0.0100174826,
0.0632303432,
-0.0321492106,
0.0459053442,
-0.0080653559,
-0.0432988293,
0.0075342981,
-0.085097827,
-0.0087401019,
-0.043966312,
-0.0262732953,
0.0331250094,
-0.0044623986,
-0.0408338383,
0.050190866,
-0.0611257963,
-0.0051210965,
-0.0016081535,
0.0022607481,
0.0458890796,
-0.0088080531,
0.0059202174,
0.0122908643,
-0.0507620312,
-0.0162830874,
-0.0104412418,
0.0261311922,
-0.051706221,
-0.025730392,
0.0382841043,
0.0822356343,
0.0176270772,
0.0000023318,
-0.0829210058,
-0.0595652573,
0.0078205029,
-0.0419349335,
-0.0132001182,
0.0075716795,
-0.0021754014,
0.0305328574,
-0.0070193508,
-0.025928529,
0.0157251675,
-0.0077473223,
0.0791484192,
0.0490755811,
0.0205641091,
-0.0047254213,
-0.055440709,
-0.0111954948,
-0.0197203737,
-0.0164944995,
-0.0906795412,
0.0190909039,
0.0545189828,
0.0127239246,
0.0380846933,
-0.0336780697,
0.0350034982,
0.0050575314,
0.0221572183,
-0.0258800443,
0.0196901616,
-0.0172559153,
-0.0145650711,
0.0272376668,
0.081123665,
0.0104068546,
0.01665923,
-0.0070333267,
-0.0037937746,
-0.0207629781,
-0.0032428305,
-0.0566271991,
0.0201818012,
-0.0310852844,
0.0126439761,
0.0046743508,
-0.0006049643,
0.031330362,
0.0687034726,
-0.0824802741,
0.0419686437,
-0.0118459901,
-0.0280834883,
0.0086299535,
-0.0043178629,
-0.0236651003,
-0.048386544,
0.0084599769,
0.0466698334,
-0.0628611967,
0.034848731,
-0.0218984298,
-0.0275481269,
-0.0009526724,
-0.0102314893,
0.0206189621,
0.050292667,
-0.0336927734,
0.0710362718,
-0.0399867408,
-0.000736439,
-0.0312558562,
-0.0036552919,
-0.0392009616,
-0.0432092398,
-0.095507361,
0.0004835919,
-0.0334663913,
0.0948472843,
-0.0503066406,
-0.0197625067,
-0.0097419051,
0.0284460075,
-0.0131257484,
0.0078699021,
0.0076705567,
-0.002504763,
-0.0093703093,
-0.0325648673,
-0.0215008855,
0.0385237709,
-0.0556496307,
0.0280268677,
0.0138785094,
0.0154311387,
-0.016914703,
-0.0139403883,
0.028900966,
-0.0312870704,
0.0132178003,
0.0471528508,
0.0146438023,
-0.0253447536,
-0.0437313579,
-0.0534673966,
-0.0262557901,
-0.0708674565,
-0.0245559886,
-0.0387424603,
0.0258315857,
0.0215964783,
0.0242523234,
-0.0054389257,
0.0157856941,
-0.0112231281,
-0.0330043174,
0.0782729164,
-0.0040072133,
-0.0031786573,
0.000040528,
0.0488206185,
-0.0128377611,
0.0465544015,
0.0057080425,
0.0289032701,
0.0004585311,
0.0122200819,
-0.0455906801,
-0.0141039668,
-0.0032134918,
0.0146070104,
0.0164285004,
0.0384448543,
-0.0302337315,
0.038477648,
0.0205172691,
0.0371718481,
-0.0186112821,
0.0248192362,
0.0267456565,
0.0390957743,
0.007054131,
-0.0026342589,
0.0778345913,
0.0317733549,
-0.0250798147,
0.0027008851,
-0.0453816205,
0.0441625677,
-0.0528391562,
0.0081810812,
0.0289570019,
0.046755746,
-0.0188501775,
-0.007232076,
0.0065652071,
0.0105182398,
-0.0260694511,
0.0689321086,
0.0578387342,
0.0278459787,
-0.0128499586,
0.0568084158,
0.0428003371,
-0.0112367803,
0.0318588912,
-0.0412110984,
0.0100734811,
0.0397900008,
0.0037277818,
-0.0151243061,
-0.0467969365,
-0.0521359704,
0.0427873619,
0.0378695652,
-0.0161020886,
-0.0294161513,
-0.0052650203,
-0.0559349246,
-0.0289079491,
-0.0199103896,
0.0071506524,
0.0054653888,
-0.0146584939,
0.00761578,
0.038340915,
-0.0323351361,
-0.0072721173,
0.0042897654,
-0.0190938301,
-0.0232805628,
-0.0092077041,
0.0419744253,
0.0233717579,
0.0454555862,
0.0034947724,
0.002237299,
0.0053461608,
-0.0330864079,
-0.0397923551,
-0.0167756695,
-0.0388153568,
-0.0441432931,
0.0260271095,
0.0108768139,
-0.0599659234,
-0.0411733203,
-0.0711785406,
-0.0360315368,
0.0090449015,
0.0140680689,
0.0122943018,
-0.0312868506,
-0.0008080517,
0.0422396474,
-0.0154933725,
-0.038613908,
0.0915268809,
-0.0067589148,
-0.0297865123,
0.038190309,
0.0132025471,
0.0267309174,
-0.0107587771,
0.0070995972,
-0.0133517785,
-0.0149681363,
-0.0071585895,
0.0061837421,
0.0095197521,
-0.069812052,
-0.0102600018,
-0.0326800197,
0.0040295944,
0.0146359215,
0.0104211261,
0.010706462,
0.0319010094,
0.0238380302,
-0.004824644,
-0.0024082004,
0.0246712808,
-0.0121751549,
0.0033139572,
0.0111885415,
-0.0008130362,
-0.0364745408,
0.0062005259,
0.0306835733,
-0.0441390425,
0.0406527705,
-0.028572632,
-0.0409091301,
-0.0435192548,
0.0347814299,
-0.0280992631,
0.0095121274,
-0.0108288247,
0.0132769188,
-0.0067024389,
-0.0169377904,
0.0209480524,
0.062356323,
-0.0133453095,
0.0318807326,
0.053503301,
-0.0356042944,
-0.0369820222,
0.0296229627,
-0.0060021305,
-0.0156639442,
-0.0296176933,
0.0046866289,
-0.0033451328,
0.07263311,
-0.0015622602,
0.0062560677,
-0.0418258607,
-0.0118764518,
-0.0356773138,
-0.0178074297,
-0.055287905,
-0.0022457088,
-0.0042486875,
0.0420507677,
-0.0100204917,
0.008408851,
0.0762936324,
-0.0425122008,
0.006902189,
-0.0469541065,
-0.0276297256,
-0.0641830489,
0.0907672793,
-0.0474693328,
0.0424613692,
0.039993301,
-0.0116247572,
-0.0600344762,
-0.0252003986,
0.0023373358,
-0.0071012974,
0.0926316753,
-0.0385334678,
0.0225465484,
-0.005751959,
-0.0399259403,
-0.0188519396,
-0.0157507043,
-0.0684791356,
0.0239628889,
-0.0361791216,
0.0096442671,
-0.0203400347,
-0.0059927641,
0.0247546695,
-0.0191960428,
0.0088854078,
-0.0201670267,
-0.037884403,
0.0446104631,
0.0806583911,
0.0080384947,
0.0219987314,
-0.0141893132,
0.0654538423,
0.0318742506,
-0.0036416745,
-0.0151916565,
-0.0364048444,
0.0282071456,
0.0128474543,
-0.0179751758,
-0.0026489503,
0.0002890251,
0.0603327975,
-0.0785692409,
-0.0168457851,
0.1176656485,
0.0122446371,
-0.0242730174,
0.0005260831,
-0.0301521458,
0.0401438251,
0.0408078544,
0.0157145001,
-0.0906022042,
-0.063056469,
0.010291189,
-0.0424555838,
0.0262881294,
-0.047377456,
0.0089158015,
-0.1195179895,
0.0177463684,
-0.015600075,
-0.0359830409,
-0.0115539618,
-0.011200998,
0.0314036198,
0.0372704342,
-0.0024979839,
-0.0180913452,
-0.0098488424,
-0.0037403086,
0.0235936232,
0.0220653228,
-0.047801435,
0.0870160311,
-0.0517266281,
0.0385603867,
0.0111759948,
0.0310950261,
0.0188328922,
-0.0118746143,
0.0239421148,
-0.0362827666,
0.0306884218,
-0.0379312932,
0.000438517,
-0.0226521809,
-0.0071923123,
-0.0115994206,
0.0413467586,
-0.0169073176,
-0.0422932617,
-0.0034655572,
0.104573302,
-0.0364818536,
0.0087189786,
-0.0094494009,
-0.0040870411,
0.014160281,
0.0718097165,
0.0160341747,
-0.0156220151,
0.007565836,
-0.0047825729,
-0.0699481443,
-0.0012920059,
-0.015614708,
0.0282346234,
-0.0211668927,
0.0425689332,
-0.0278730858,
-0.0117681185,
0.0789688751,
0.0353348441,
0.0064339135,
0.0325825289,
0.0334657542,
0.0157233905,
-0.017991364,
0.0427077971,
-0.0649960116,
0.0286699627,
-0.0106046377,
-0.0003988284,
0.0567826964,
-0.0387598611,
-0.0534983426,
0.0365010649,
-0.0576746203,
-0.027121108,
-0.0298618078,
0.028308088,
0.0165691786,
0.0429060087,
-0.01602282,
-0.0245293174,
0.0336797945,
-0.0304569751,
-0.0248285793,
-0.0070115505,
0.0083842576,
0.0654881671,
-0.0073631653,
0.0752790794,
-0.0630423725,
0.0348006599,
-0.0003689934,
0.0817573369,
-0.0006714875,
-0.0285352282,
0.0420784317,
0.0085366052,
0.0236042347,
-0.017093949,
-0.0222590938,
-0.0205056425,
0.0182407554,
-0.0013116641,
-0.0459669866,
-0.0295851883,
0.0203529634,
0.0236945227,
-0.0626565367,
-0.0034143664,
-0.020817887,
0.0137891518,
0.0328781456,
-0.0071712178,
0.0127208717,
0.0137623372,
-0.0160350781,
0.0278132539,
-0.0156163713,
-0.0184823032,
0.0041995645,
0.0007319428,
0.0253902767,
-0.0400534086,
0.0821581185,
0.0282431282,
0.0067296885,
-0.0763018727,
0.0232174695,
-0.0314307697,
-0.0654006526,
0.0273310933,
-0.0207254477,
0.0435720608,
-0.0116968798,
0.0391638726,
-0.0158399902,
-0.005788858,
0.0186850838,
0.048247274,
0.0015008457,
-0.0302877799,
0.0445189066,
0.0228179451,
-0.0095108105,
0.0005009841,
0.0577170476,
-0.034663707,
0.0516999178,
0.0220105778,
0.0130981347,
-0.0283636525,
-0.0222892109,
-0.0072297049,
0.0240508709,
-0.0271444488,
0.0487909913,
-0.0920651704,
-0.0676866397,
-0.0227099173,
-0.0336452872,
-0.0126092117,
-0.0001516809,
0.0356019884,
0.0437622629,
0.0223203134,
-0.0231244192,
-0.010996541,
-0.0155619374,
-0.0042233439,
-0.0148347355,
-0.0182337146,
-7.109345753e-33,
-0.036057651,
-0.0222142376,
0.0415666439,
0.0063996995,
-0.0149216801,
-0.0066118222,
-0.0530819297,
-0.0219781641,
-0.028478723,
0.0175926983,
0.0064842165,
0.0002485701,
0.0008792747,
0.0170818474,
0.0121728126,
-0.0296284836,
0.0522284806,
0.0335277654,
0.0221572109,
0.0126951961,
0.0643534288,
0.0310476664,
0.0270308126,
-0.0711412579,
0.0069197048,
0.0377983935,
-0.0006857644,
0.0475442,
-0.0010556233,
0.0345135257,
-0.0143155744,
0.0103938058,
0.0401373543,
-0.0286707561,
-0.0155408606,
0.0080593685,
-0.1123561338,
-0.0008931926,
0.0662186295,
-0.0370731018,
-0.0315064527,
-0.0138103738,
-0.0196451079,
-0.001909823,
0.0525502078,
-0.053309802,
0.009264213,
-0.0160026792,
-0.010512325,
-0.0614324585,
-0.0684818923,
0.0172128733,
-0.0257988628,
-0.0407447629,
0.0463433452,
0.0210538041,
0.0035820524,
0.0150386607,
-0.0163086485,
0.002094182,
-0.0234127082,
0.0066361194,
0.0648777932,
0.0089737922,
-0.0204432979,
0.0475365147,
-0.0174306463,
-0.0194579698,
-0.0218568649,
-0.0014846919,
-0.0019688222,
0.0628770888,
-0.0262981728,
0.0401734859,
0.0256566741,
0.0368671417,
-0.0835017934,
-0.0093459487,
-0.0375593938,
0.0892574564,
0.020666426,
0.0273992736,
-0.015862288,
-0.0131855318,
-0.0594109669,
0.0278534368,
-0.0496942364,
-0.0062745549,
0.0479255207,
-0.0133522628,
-0.0424075685,
0.0164464004,
0.0455876179,
-0.0383362472,
-0.0249936972,
-0.00047914,
0.0185748562,
0.0011766921,
0.0011917199,
0.038823612,
-0.0273669753,
-0.0418924913,
0.0061348258,
0.0024545542,
0.0184689425,
0.0156018278,
0.084157832,
-0.0168516394,
-0.0198661257,
-0.0007244991,
-0.0575020872,
-0.0208742637,
-0.044297941,
0.0308689736,
0.0328774117,
0.0556267239,
-0.0218893997,
0.0611959323,
0.0018488083,
-0.0280301049,
0.0021917939,
0.0533942617,
-0.0073700091,
0.0193682127,
-0.0314528085,
-0.0032422249,
-0.0155826677,
-0.0361946151,
0.0829716399,
-0.0663780943,
-0.0237034392,
0.0096964352,
3.123e-7,
0.0133366222,
0.0549304485,
-0.0213701725,
0.0351485088,
-0.0190717783,
0.0473057926,
-0.0156920198,
0.0112495767,
0.0187963992,
-0.0768806413,
-0.0013469972,
0.0413718745,
0.0216400679,
0.0289971698,
-0.0852291659,
0.0229907781,
0.0113812471,
-0.014836018,
-0.0376461372,
0.0066547818,
0.078865923,
0.0823452845,
0.0121730622,
-0.010596131,
0.0367747582,
-0.0379217565,
0.0470040664,
0.0118403956,
0.022522416,
-0.0096494118,
-0.049879577,
0.000244916,
0.0179434251,
0.0452829264,
0.0041834502,
0.0250451192,
0.0085129263,
0.0467520393,
0.0032139083,
0.0230216924,
-0.0335761532,
-0.0350189842,
0.0209831763,
-0.0482077859,
0.077158846,
-0.0906997174,
-0.0418494418,
-0.0304439943,
-0.0091624977,
-0.0198333804,
-0.0311939996,
0.0199279208,
0.0164174847,
0.0045053032,
0.0034629384,
-0.0055201193,
-0.0137051279,
-0.0935976803,
0.0142840482,
0.0508304164,
-0.014480358,
-0.0115533406,
-0.0134037435,
-0.0222332049,
0.0493602157,
-0.0985132605,
-0.0205497071,
3.019877589e-34,
0.0377168953,
0.0043220697,
0.0173821673,
0.0389223397,
0.0662151873,
0.0057356334,
-0.079292953,
0.0028357184,
0.0178689174,
-0.1089334041,
0.0016334545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14614v1 | Efficient Cross-Task Prompt Tuning for Few-Shot Conversational Emotion Recognition | 2023-10-23T06:46:03 | 2023-10-23T06:46:03 | Yige Xu, Zhiwei Zeng, Zhiqi Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion Recognition in Conversation (ERC) has been widely studied due to its
importance in developing emotion-aware empathetic machines. The rise of
pre-trained language models (PLMs) has further pushed the limit of ERC
performance. However, most recent works on ERC using PLMs are heavily
data-driven, and requires fine-tuning the entire PLMs. To improve both sample
and computational efficiency, we propose a derivative-free optimization method
called Cross-Task Prompt Tuning (CTPT) for few-shot conversational emotion
recognition. Unlike existing methods that learn independent knowledge from
individual tasks, CTPT leverages sharable cross-task knowledge by exploiting
external knowledge from other source tasks to improve learning performance
under the few-shot setting. Moreover, CTPT only needs to optimize a vector
under the low intrinsic dimensionality without gradient, which is highly
parameter-efficient compared with existing approaches. Experiments on five
different contextual conversation datasets demonstrate that our CTPT method has
superior results on both few-shot scenarios and zero-shot transfers. | [
0.0098710116,
0.0275892485,
-0.0081449505,
0.0661472827,
0.0099329902,
0.0432547182,
0.0365487412,
-0.010180207,
0.0082508819,
-0.0426210091,
-0.0683682859,
-0.0290777143,
-0.0192018226,
-0.0126487864,
-0.0145254033,
-0.0458767191,
0.0339943916,
0.0237459633,
0.0555804223,
0.0236771144,
0.0121207759,
0.0170747209,
-0.0426789261,
-0.0040250141,
-0.0205200817,
-0.0159636736,
-0.0285878889,
0.034764301,
0.0411221758,
-0.0168657489,
0.0477929823,
0.0633326992,
0.0133823026,
0.0115772402,
0.0000021082,
-0.022633126,
-0.0156391319,
-0.0385021307,
-0.0414413661,
-0.0140070058,
0.0613965467,
-0.0122465491,
-0.0084913671,
0.0076842117,
-0.0218863245,
-0.0042410446,
0.0535596758,
0.0658293739,
0.0803510398,
0.1102847233,
-0.0330801383,
0.0064551844,
-0.0113928458,
-0.0335670151,
0.0356921554,
-0.0478530638,
-0.0064375219,
-0.0232811943,
-0.014047428,
-0.0084141847,
-0.0439398475,
0.0265366826,
-0.0088776043,
-0.0065616905,
0.0093416618,
-0.002915028,
0.0027264652,
-0.0153110214,
-0.0320706591,
0.1371444613,
-0.0424378328,
0.023082545,
-0.0160936881,
-0.0513444319,
-0.0163232703,
-0.0500684343,
-0.0346794873,
-0.0336281136,
0.0212467518,
0.008829358,
-0.0348904617,
0.0247091223,
-0.0073810895,
0.0056444062,
0.0179521386,
0.009272024,
-0.0183045939,
0.0072953277,
0.0228821263,
0.0115825683,
-0.0110696927,
-0.0247040167,
-0.0378745869,
0.0127154179,
-0.0538153648,
0.0114978496,
-0.04198597,
-0.0070041409,
-0.0248878952,
0.0074226256,
0.0540613234,
0.0643504187,
-0.0189817008,
0.05711044,
0.0027828931,
0.0098581444,
0.0029930172,
-0.0085130651,
-0.0366739631,
0.0008512102,
-0.0418449678,
0.0313141532,
-0.030287981,
-0.0046506021,
-0.0499155596,
-0.029860843,
-0.0536283404,
0.0393573381,
0.0030061915,
-0.0166062824,
0.0006688837,
-0.025673857,
-0.0189980268,
-0.0123437606,
-0.0026115503,
0.0340625532,
-0.0220458247,
0.0502842255,
0.0096695824,
-0.074189499,
-0.0550892577,
0.0107147675,
0.0526969098,
-0.0247505549,
0.0285899155,
0.0284196958,
-0.0156746898,
-0.0748990178,
0.0011106692,
-0.0033973788,
-0.0405052453,
-0.0718880668,
0.0006622855,
-0.00672343,
0.0659002289,
-0.0185000803,
0.0104496656,
0.0002081198,
0.0023593255,
-0.036253199,
-0.0610243939,
0.0876625478,
0.0037564202,
-0.004941809,
-0.0032545289,
0.0093995724,
-0.0281771757,
0.0819047168,
0.0144553613,
0.0351906009,
0.0481890701,
-0.0039713196,
0.0250001866,
0.0107140532,
0.0239543021,
0.0042455113,
0.0221147761,
-0.0108255753,
0.0341494046,
0.0232186373,
0.0594454072,
-0.0132584851,
-0.044262521,
-0.0212584939,
0.0513355881,
0.0506739169,
-0.0035065589,
0.022255253,
0.0091540739,
0.0512253679,
-0.0003105044,
-0.0323516838,
-0.0454639681,
0.0451424457,
-0.0290279463,
-0.0306857005,
0.0342299305,
-0.0238513928,
-0.0622820258,
-0.0299395937,
0.0242061149,
-0.0323621593,
-0.0158960335,
0.0454465263,
-0.0106828427,
-0.0114125377,
-0.0524313375,
0.0413716696,
0.0344166458,
-0.0670270696,
-0.0369351096,
-0.0155966822,
0.012121073,
0.0470003299,
-0.0087322034,
-0.0703001171,
-0.0667781457,
-0.0298027769,
0.0518111065,
0.0369023159,
0.0350419544,
-0.0014261861,
0.1198946461,
-0.0594036467,
-0.0022584833,
-0.0254633445,
-0.0018509576,
0.024901893,
-0.020261772,
0.0434775315,
0.0148048913,
0.0165872816,
0.038686499,
0.0078249685,
-0.0371479802,
-0.0540680401,
0.0548534133,
0.0387135856,
0.0112200957,
0.0002680253,
-0.0084129274,
-0.0432121456,
-0.000701222,
-0.016158089,
0.0158740692,
0.0297269206,
-0.0644475967,
-0.0885360762,
0.0215890873,
0.0020662423,
-0.0084124906,
0.0199747942,
-0.0768560916,
-0.0308165532,
0.0252651442,
0.0075039314,
0.0389174856,
-0.0345574692,
0.0204912964,
-0.0230402909,
0.0591554604,
0.0205392651,
0.0133970249,
0.0178049747,
-0.0183869842,
0.0162079819,
0.0247704778,
0.0023237406,
-0.0326868072,
-0.0176322814,
-0.0202203859,
0.0144305639,
0.0081516206,
0.0190860052,
0.0191755462,
-0.0702152327,
-0.0478208065,
-0.1095754132,
0.020215502,
-0.016741775,
0.0117508117,
0.0066636885,
0.0390215926,
-0.0518607385,
-0.0273122024,
-0.029548442,
0.0583478324,
0.0003292952,
-0.0059351102,
0.0300670024,
0.0245266967,
0.0209824853,
-0.0828625262,
0.0359436162,
0.0218033511,
0.0174013488,
-0.0508267283,
0.013009347,
-0.0092678647,
0.0479353853,
-0.0026170616,
0.0341348946,
-0.019538166,
-0.0219597705,
-0.0369851589,
0.0019648494,
0.012513238,
0.0547692552,
-0.004856504,
0.0392362922,
-0.0276894197,
-0.0252126902,
-0.050014969,
0.0623680614,
-0.0205309317,
-0.0100564733,
-0.0131500242,
0.0131625105,
-0.0034529644,
0.0702085495,
-0.0276518408,
0.0162831955,
-0.0654783472,
0.0155504206,
0.0337674394,
-0.04487966,
-0.0379285067,
-0.0080171367,
-0.0197532941,
-0.0234631859,
-0.0248947348,
-0.0464349277,
0.0308983084,
-0.0196597017,
-0.0349248648,
-0.0481532589,
-0.0173143111,
-0.0430295244,
0.045964282,
-0.0454693064,
-0.0144739486,
0.0103907082,
-0.0042344024,
-0.0382228084,
-0.0190908313,
0.0171630681,
-0.0160212126,
-0.0075828419,
-0.0005835356,
-0.0171465408,
0.0001534487,
-0.0608226061,
-0.0183339939,
-0.0929298922,
-0.0141122332,
-0.0113517409,
-0.0045311246,
0.0099695744,
-0.014592655,
-0.0190434288,
0.0208715107,
0.0159505736,
-0.0233330503,
-0.0117760897,
-0.0299245212,
0.0394193828,
0.0441079177,
-0.0054342235,
0.0005375338,
-0.016003821,
0.0753517002,
0.009273584,
0.0523298457,
0.0088793011,
0.0189294349,
0.0380987972,
0.0187889263,
0.016323315,
-0.0100847082,
-0.0159732811,
0.0619837269,
-0.0023278198,
0.0220064055,
0.1307713538,
0.0191471092,
-0.0764066577,
-0.0119857686,
-0.0107534323,
-0.0274843015,
0.0087734368,
0.0193471089,
-0.0583962947,
-0.0703296438,
-0.027491536,
0.0091709513,
0.0021227319,
-0.0407526977,
-0.0338236429,
-0.0828873664,
-0.0020834429,
-0.0075865784,
-0.0272923857,
-0.0212118886,
-0.0243589114,
0.0329632089,
-0.0231537484,
0.0238731727,
-0.043520283,
-0.0002647488,
-0.0249145776,
0.0183684565,
0.0094724875,
-0.0680594444,
0.0394958705,
-0.0251330081,
0.0341410786,
0.0105660828,
0.0708818659,
0.0250329282,
-0.0046679946,
0.0267252848,
-0.0123877265,
-0.0091489106,
-0.0219524782,
0.0374560766,
-0.0513590612,
-0.0105272271,
0.0314865522,
0.0235989783,
-0.0213459283,
0.0042874147,
-0.0033760997,
0.0556800701,
-0.0009349132,
0.0084701441,
0.0204532687,
0.0008776506,
0.0721726418,
0.0614670999,
0.0307258423,
-0.0492573194,
-0.0090376101,
0.0071994234,
0.0039564841,
-0.0278497916,
-0.012125982,
-0.0291716196,
0.0242994763,
-0.0221360661,
-0.0198162552,
-0.0724704117,
0.0256211478,
0.0256802663,
-0.0432078242,
-0.0346322022,
-0.0200437438,
0.0184633508,
-0.0335642472,
0.0331937447,
-0.0164247863,
0.0130944978,
-0.0278078783,
0.0119848149,
0.0283706281,
-0.0187267568,
0.012031842,
0.023082329,
-0.0747405812,
-0.0547130518,
-0.0304090716,
0.034285415,
0.0031372115,
0.0375238284,
0.0028837183,
-0.0557595938,
0.0710340962,
0.035038311,
-0.0323828049,
0.0276025869,
0.0508567952,
0.0062963627,
-0.0170755479,
0.0340753719,
-0.0455056988,
0.051798135,
0.0702624246,
0.0276863165,
0.0027826682,
-0.0613389015,
-0.0396332294,
-0.0004168411,
0.0954230875,
0.0199799985,
-0.043015942,
-0.0131532773,
0.0196862817,
-0.0145629989,
0.0251618121,
-0.0662002191,
-0.0220575258,
-0.0135903191,
-0.0389914848,
-0.0514686964,
-0.0204694197,
-0.024085626,
0.004189027,
-0.0511452891,
0.0277808532,
-0.0026402683,
-0.015349037,
0.010362369,
0.0255551208,
-0.0052674226,
0.0308829062,
0.0168714132,
-0.0091058491,
-0.0231644958,
0.0677917674,
0.0190864392,
-0.021888284,
-0.0052230768,
0.0548362248,
-0.0212244764,
-0.0116410851,
-0.0345602632,
0.0183469076,
0.0384216532,
-0.0316782668,
0.0253890771,
-0.012198397,
0.0129466793,
-0.0177887678,
0.0350979604,
-0.0075874417,
-0.0312151592,
0.0075900028,
0.0172900856,
-0.0263871532,
0.0356837362,
0.042908404,
-0.0606550239,
0.0340750366,
0.0063563352,
0.0388018899,
-0.0639697164,
0.009997501,
0.085832268,
-0.0280279927,
0.0010968876,
0.0560897812,
-0.0315533169,
-0.0544865802,
0.0314293802,
-0.0418487191,
-0.0315983146,
0.0240119491,
0.0312260557,
0.0520696864,
-0.0278222617,
0.0452367812,
-0.0185425393,
-0.0069184634,
-0.0368812606,
-0.0221340079,
0.0155368075,
-6.099102765e-33,
-0.0028331929,
0.0304595791,
-0.0349368528,
-0.0019152894,
-0.0145348804,
0.043849878,
-0.0372760706,
0.0147286989,
-0.0192970745,
0.0085446611,
-0.0455208272,
0.0362982042,
0.0147821512,
0.002073149,
-0.0297764763,
-0.0133433621,
0.0187329166,
-0.0228249803,
-0.0281601194,
0.040050637,
0.010264406,
0.052937679,
0.0440134294,
-0.0155634638,
0.0143547161,
0.0103663104,
-0.012711687,
0.047671672,
0.1170523241,
0.0190080535,
-0.0225105789,
0.0416497812,
0.0133870281,
-0.0588514134,
-0.0077780322,
0.056446515,
-0.0470876321,
-0.02727139,
-0.0279247761,
-0.0099043502,
-0.0525536574,
-0.0468226448,
-0.037458986,
0.0262379944,
-0.0007157291,
-0.0205151569,
-0.0081395078,
0.0025083714,
0.0234505422,
-0.0397953652,
-0.0456278846,
0.0032804385,
-0.025201086,
-0.0553987585,
0.0508898348,
0.054831598,
0.0158279855,
0.036767669,
-0.0451396219,
0.0074918326,
-0.0465486199,
-0.0094641168,
0.0023740169,
-0.0031598739,
-0.0076207882,
0.0593076982,
0.0163403638,
0.0213534292,
0.0118615013,
0.0205156803,
0.0297551826,
0.0361504592,
-0.0041177752,
0.0674864203,
0.0027295256,
-0.0203298144,
-0.0684085116,
0.032296367,
0.0741453692,
0.0019692557,
0.0199120734,
-0.0073656961,
-0.013639505,
-0.0047176592,
-0.0210526567,
-0.0029325758,
-0.0214996152,
-0.0044120392,
0.0264847167,
0.0214288831,
0.0126010431,
-0.0086254478,
0.0521202385,
-0.0389482006,
0.0311919991,
0.0306611061,
-0.0088746641,
0.0027924438,
0.0156869367,
0.018946873,
-0.0443406813,
-0.046408765,
0.0592323393,
0.0083684381,
0.0525586233,
-0.0070319502,
0.0172006153,
0.0297705289,
-0.0455811173,
-0.0255430192,
-0.0130788432,
0.0647977367,
-0.023977017,
0.06866844,
-0.0304878633,
0.025465725,
-0.020877542,
0.0514572598,
-0.0138107212,
0.0236687027,
0.0072873859,
-0.0262486562,
0.0032504648,
0.0407586247,
-0.0423046611,
-0.0138573078,
0.025472451,
-0.0325226225,
0.0046742591,
-0.0413777828,
-0.0183783639,
0.0099199908,
2.856e-7,
-0.0324363708,
0.0433363989,
-0.006962291,
-0.0118323499,
0.0242291223,
0.0622606762,
-0.0031363638,
0.0696933046,
0.0148463193,
-0.0421515629,
0.0750212371,
0.0373738557,
0.0853268206,
0.000042711,
-0.1177299991,
-0.0168912373,
-0.0252578966,
0.0177532192,
0.008616738,
-0.0005670247,
0.0526196286,
0.0851477906,
0.0288886745,
-0.0006937896,
0.0049155923,
0.0241020005,
0.038797833,
-0.079333961,
-0.0205302481,
0.0455513149,
0.0031759844,
-0.0280994307,
-0.0244002081,
-0.0025315469,
-0.0156554226,
0.0505017526,
-0.0006765816,
0.071389012,
0.0213124789,
-0.0790288448,
-0.0019359522,
0.0390716419,
0.0006297975,
-0.0187790636,
0.0709181949,
-0.0767367482,
-0.0187843554,
-0.0268162303,
-0.0092757689,
0.0064960383,
0.0485910289,
-0.0176397432,
-0.0419320501,
0.0398158729,
0.0384180509,
-0.0122263897,
-0.0209986381,
-0.1000662073,
0.0170016903,
0.023197256,
-0.0271652974,
-0.0413126759,
-0.0027544743,
-0.0144155193,
0.0624413043,
-0.0601126961,
0.0359024666,
2.03115276e-34,
0.009891456,
-0.009027008,
0.0178937502,
0.0172775332,
-0.0103661064,
0.0071322415,
-0.0203344226,
-0.0216861516,
0.0592565462,
-0.0909123048,
-0.0018192561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14610v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14610v1 | That was the last straw, we need more: Are Translation Systems Sensitive to Disambiguating Context? | 2023-10-23T06:38:49 | 2023-10-23T06:38:49 | Jaechan Lee, Alisa Liu, Orevaoghene Ahia, Hila Gonen, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL | The translation of ambiguous text presents a challenge for translation
systems, as it requires using the surrounding context to disambiguate the
intended meaning as much as possible. While prior work has studied ambiguities
that result from different grammatical features of the source and target
language, we study semantic ambiguities that exist in the source (English in
this work) itself. In particular, we focus on idioms that are open to both
literal and figurative interpretations (e.g., goose egg), and collect TIDE, a
dataset of 512 pairs of English sentences containing idioms with disambiguating
context such that one is literal (it laid a goose egg) and another is
figurative (they scored a goose egg, as in a score of zero). In experiments, we
compare MT-specific models and language models for (i) their preference when
given an ambiguous subsentence, (ii) their sensitivity to disambiguating
context, and (iii) the performance disparity between figurative and literal
source sentences. We find that current MT models consistently translate English
idioms literally, even when the context suggests a figurative interpretation.
On the other hand, LMs are far more context-aware, although there remain
disparities across target languages. Our findings underline the potential of
LMs as a strong backbone for context-aware translation. | [
0.0498215482,
0.0089099091,
-0.0436311923,
0.0572421961,
-0.0459177159,
0.0145780332,
0.0157347079,
0.0150264064,
-0.0400595963,
-0.0491233505,
-0.025771806,
-0.0291682724,
0.033590924,
-0.0355893634,
0.0130751189,
-0.0234913193,
0.0513806865,
0.0118125528,
-0.0206444785,
-0.0091482596,
-0.0122471098,
0.04205947,
0.0253064577,
0.0081237396,
-0.0162722617,
-0.0070374319,
-0.0034941803,
0.0879281983,
0.0477804206,
0.0131424759,
-0.0194079522,
-0.0112228012,
0.0151628796,
0.0731597915,
0.0000020625,
-0.0505904108,
-0.0360064283,
-0.0261405706,
-0.0142858196,
0.0215651952,
0.0913975537,
-0.0613396615,
-0.0099889729,
-0.0179623552,
-0.0069831153,
0.014240535,
0.0353396907,
-0.0275025479,
0.0280452669,
0.0551018156,
-0.0139676016,
-0.034449812,
-0.0752715543,
-0.0292448495,
0.0337562747,
-0.0678143948,
-0.0128355799,
-0.0035071513,
-0.0543776825,
0.0018862962,
-0.0389830694,
0.0608464256,
0.0058548008,
0.0380483307,
-0.0582609214,
0.0166715197,
-0.0082898214,
0.0006624953,
-0.0046495376,
0.0441978723,
-0.0177159607,
-0.0452896394,
-0.014558115,
-0.0231714938,
-0.0118412273,
-0.0063166711,
-0.0172361936,
0.0268876702,
-0.0178409386,
0.0077802064,
0.0430413932,
0.0167244989,
0.0234234389,
0.0487544164,
-0.0525647886,
0.0003184086,
0.0165251195,
-0.0096500777,
-0.0245359074,
-0.006085177,
-0.0830482766,
-0.0163451768,
0.0435439125,
-0.0204495937,
0.0066069844,
0.042703554,
-0.0277066007,
-0.0768412426,
0.0162359066,
-0.0710877627,
0.0127137154,
0.0782803893,
-0.0056232587,
0.0476150773,
0.002288122,
0.0314572379,
-0.0233301781,
0.0270648915,
-0.0971445516,
-0.0375500396,
-0.0418502651,
0.0386410877,
-0.0385684706,
-0.0081133014,
-0.0617254376,
0.0144600077,
-0.0283522904,
0.0275799856,
0.0278676711,
-0.012933841,
-0.000944039,
-0.0324884504,
-0.0985370725,
-0.0078245075,
0.0002335594,
0.0397660248,
-0.0272251572,
0.0290056206,
-0.0351496078,
-0.0690346286,
-0.0240567457,
0.0057218894,
-0.0162955504,
-0.0538250692,
-0.0031188724,
0.0873949826,
-0.0119188922,
-0.0202311277,
-0.0015121815,
-0.0217234287,
-0.0579813793,
-0.0331962779,
-0.0086530931,
-0.0443984233,
0.0512343533,
0.0255062077,
0.0283661168,
-0.0595232584,
0.0146083869,
-0.0224009752,
-0.0365720801,
0.0519914217,
0.0391837433,
0.0143985488,
0.0078784022,
0.0141577637,
-0.0555159114,
0.0709148347,
0.0632744506,
0.0221236795,
0.0396626964,
0.0291753598,
-0.0640488118,
0.0403329916,
-0.0051441719,
0.0456485599,
-0.0376839638,
0.015883103,
-0.022214463,
0.0418178439,
0.0126063265,
0.0574294105,
-0.0032896555,
0.0156557728,
0.061546348,
-0.0090008043,
-0.0092835287,
0.0045729522,
0.0620324165,
0.0327541269,
-0.0157105979,
-0.0038136067,
-0.0305123981,
-0.0306223929,
-0.0433202274,
-0.0016897701,
-0.0178304408,
0.0449202098,
-0.0031718069,
-0.0299250539,
-0.0285756681,
-0.0131036164,
0.0213882942,
0.0014207391,
0.0491941795,
0.0348293334,
-0.0069806781,
0.0802764595,
-0.0135174161,
-0.0391342975,
0.0235341061,
-0.0141106863,
-0.0448324643,
0.0524079986,
0.0448013581,
-0.0178372711,
-0.0299519934,
-0.0158817787,
0.0116029726,
0.0407617763,
0.0427512601,
0.0136132473,
0.0579707287,
-0.0133421719,
0.0244324058,
-0.0008437236,
0.0357924029,
-0.0145266391,
0.0082596149,
0.0652185902,
0.0190580226,
-0.0839045495,
-0.0106873587,
0.0242000502,
-0.005488955,
0.0067414031,
0.0026668233,
0.0042502405,
0.0303729791,
0.0021576211,
-0.0125722159,
-0.0047877966,
0.0092217559,
-0.0415012836,
-0.0185299646,
0.0742063522,
-0.0100729521,
-0.0524888746,
0.0363996066,
-0.0243162159,
-0.0355514437,
-0.0093401214,
-0.0606580339,
-0.0295426957,
0.0068301726,
-0.0301882029,
0.0304268766,
-0.000844054,
0.0412152149,
-0.0349835195,
-0.0279459432,
-0.0422632284,
0.0531284139,
-0.0138050085,
0.0210936051,
-0.0060259756,
-0.0009779907,
0.0141005088,
0.0251958352,
0.0162060764,
0.020174183,
0.0182198994,
-0.0047261687,
0.0067407354,
0.0250857845,
-0.0543279611,
-0.0518153906,
-0.0504076593,
0.0446561687,
-0.0115145668,
0.0287516676,
0.0742566064,
0.0318501629,
-0.0106852194,
0.0284067355,
0.0354437418,
-0.0168339051,
-0.0147377709,
0.0028901608,
0.0080549167,
-0.0012198727,
0.0096669523,
-0.0142989866,
0.0133685078,
-0.0162999146,
0.0287745651,
0.0011701176,
-0.0209534131,
-0.0165283978,
0.0631198362,
-0.0818650797,
-0.0469254032,
0.003269956,
-0.0463342704,
-0.0149469599,
-0.0109044779,
0.0409284458,
0.0473101586,
-0.0015645509,
0.0216365941,
0.0363415815,
-0.0544622168,
-0.0536306612,
0.0035062688,
0.0029510432,
-0.0391891524,
-0.0407806784,
-0.0987684205,
-0.0152906086,
0.035846334,
0.0454513542,
-0.0097912569,
-0.0405684039,
0.0349571668,
-0.0461351313,
-0.0161213316,
0.0015223959,
0.0619770847,
0.0072836289,
0.068080768,
-0.0424996726,
-0.0247484911,
0.0655315146,
0.0122253103,
-0.0163784269,
-0.0601776205,
0.0240349881,
-0.0349682868,
0.0767059922,
-0.0560890101,
0.0410988256,
-0.0143800322,
-0.0042665415,
-0.0387162343,
0.0162945185,
0.046819903,
-0.0534027256,
0.0647018552,
-0.0849288628,
-0.0073434724,
-0.0314895809,
-0.0029392145,
-0.0109585756,
-0.04909968,
-0.0182676297,
-0.0154463174,
0.0097154183,
0.0106581794,
-0.0175773539,
-0.0066423486,
0.0074160998,
-0.0040588798,
-0.0012635519,
-0.0253939331,
-0.0377082527,
0.0025837938,
-0.0081906207,
-0.0204904303,
0.0303431824,
-0.0189308319,
0.0278079063,
0.0083394563,
-0.0274729226,
-0.04232838,
0.0053471485,
-0.0178387593,
0.038299825,
-0.0111453263,
-0.054037679,
-0.003447352,
0.0664348155,
-0.0448924713,
-0.0457357615,
0.0912925452,
0.0658785179,
0.0044660089,
0.0115428865,
-0.0318469889,
0.0476461276,
0.0068181301,
-0.0165580511,
-0.0857199132,
-0.0480200537,
0.0405901559,
-0.0148267401,
0.0136085832,
0.0050310101,
-0.0423528478,
-0.0537062995,
0.0224912222,
0.0481361561,
-0.0458732657,
-0.000016564,
0.0231552552,
0.0064068679,
-0.0356717408,
0.023291925,
-0.0142315021,
-0.0038198119,
0.0064194449,
-0.0368362069,
0.0703480542,
-0.0623047985,
0.0002268312,
-0.0283737611,
0.0144709731,
0.0299712829,
0.0516175963,
-0.0111151664,
-0.0054542078,
-0.0070440765,
-0.0332186334,
-0.0004356272,
-0.0547798313,
-0.0157813057,
0.0235482696,
0.0062591811,
0.0079907179,
-0.0170264319,
-0.0268270001,
-0.0097895917,
0.0000307917,
0.0182979982,
-0.0235424563,
0.0000084419,
-0.0002645093,
-0.0316059217,
-0.0124114696,
0.1021795347,
0.0129234595,
-0.0500143059,
-0.0093512768,
-0.0304134022,
-0.0175760277,
-0.019959392,
-0.0001547885,
0.0050645526,
-0.0741916224,
-0.0402415954,
-0.0658120662,
-0.0248086974,
0.0061442871,
0.0385723896,
0.026102813,
0.0341713689,
-0.0281528868,
-0.0102361254,
-0.04006432,
0.0312491357,
-0.029529769,
0.0357947685,
0.0008282762,
0.0260703024,
0.0245058127,
-0.0461515822,
-0.0155174816,
0.0513558537,
-0.0731766298,
-0.0757699385,
-0.0013762141,
0.0255586244,
0.0300205424,
0.0291008316,
-0.0482292809,
-0.0030178616,
-0.0368373021,
0.0171666685,
0.0103042917,
0.0452140644,
0.0543079972,
0.0882031173,
0.0132166464,
0.0834029466,
-0.0563855246,
0.0418062396,
0.0178090036,
0.0580545142,
-0.0311846416,
-0.0452029482,
0.0240028128,
0.0159823094,
0.0063526877,
-0.0439765118,
-0.0650783479,
0.0144565674,
-0.003962528,
-0.0119827343,
-0.0369472802,
-0.0087426379,
-0.0155398082,
0.0600058809,
-0.0087452,
-0.0299177002,
0.0493529513,
-0.0166142341,
0.0110322349,
0.0018881133,
-0.0303540025,
0.0045757904,
0.0070050214,
-0.0243084114,
0.0390034989,
-0.0104503417,
-0.0114704426,
-0.0250343047,
0.0149616189,
-0.0191650949,
0.0228462033,
0.0168581139,
0.0003027331,
-0.03560891,
0.0163242444,
-0.0101423729,
0.007811958,
0.037149433,
-0.0070385132,
0.0870114639,
-0.0142420474,
0.1128415465,
-0.015031429,
0.0018487481,
-0.0111093437,
0.0468549542,
0.0576931387,
-0.0265283249,
0.0165814124,
-0.0102758696,
0.0117204878,
0.0126395188,
0.0459760986,
-0.0650468916,
0.0357067063,
0.030487828,
-0.0225072037,
-0.0065061133,
0.0057802848,
-0.0083230417,
0.0033119286,
0.0296663549,
-0.000505927,
-0.0913493335,
-0.0368210562,
0.053776253,
-0.0048916694,
0.028951304,
-0.0385003835,
0.0048793945,
0.0746139735,
0.0042531984,
-0.0312290285,
-0.0499200635,
0.0143868374,
-0.0217098147,
-0.0176917836,
-0.0744337142,
-6.46740241e-33,
-0.0424333736,
-0.0055202595,
-0.0402758606,
-0.029803507,
-0.0254652426,
-0.0012072073,
-0.0315107405,
-0.0167356636,
-0.0120204277,
-0.0026001136,
0.0024006006,
0.026165152,
0.0218859948,
-0.0190647077,
0.01889042,
-0.0008082295,
0.0472043045,
0.0237939171,
-0.0293034874,
-0.0191324763,
0.0460397042,
-0.0160416737,
0.0401549749,
-0.0400333777,
0.0595744252,
-0.0337540731,
-0.0377666205,
0.0269613899,
-0.0047768522,
0.0188100189,
0.0284151323,
0.0415332206,
0.0308069251,
0.0523703359,
-0.0228530522,
-0.0228819139,
-0.0876055434,
0.0021365786,
0.0771356225,
0.0222064573,
0.0053291055,
-0.0539858602,
0.0722379088,
-0.0324436426,
-0.0173676163,
0.0177300218,
0.0024407567,
-0.0492052995,
-0.005308623,
-0.0393503197,
-0.0405203104,
-0.0023904722,
-0.0130414125,
-0.0293509271,
0.029995786,
0.0447015725,
0.0101329051,
0.04126231,
-0.0720481202,
0.0170329809,
-0.0622423254,
-0.0011029382,
0.0426486358,
-0.0135354539,
0.0092028426,
0.0172526501,
-0.0052433573,
-0.0130297923,
0.0285364836,
-0.0039153434,
0.0212411229,
0.0180478301,
0.0420566984,
0.0592313223,
0.0666891187,
-0.0106905242,
-0.0434332155,
0.0019833178,
0.040605396,
-0.0056522451,
0.0295526981,
0.0367796309,
-0.0511228517,
0.0060448018,
-0.0643032789,
-0.0151279848,
-0.0268770028,
-0.0266103894,
0.0136439782,
0.0006174496,
-0.0246618018,
-0.0129413409,
0.0776037276,
-0.0031594322,
-0.0040371027,
-0.0495268255,
-0.0139336791,
0.0300368518,
0.0043007666,
0.0506929643,
-0.0063311453,
-0.0528859273,
0.0148407146,
0.0269869696,
0.0093408106,
-0.0025911767,
0.0533642545,
-0.0020146691,
-0.0136911301,
0.0192673411,
-0.0322916359,
-0.0188902821,
-0.0544350557,
-0.0541931503,
0.03454661,
0.0314248689,
0.0049987449,
-0.0113296164,
0.0817615911,
-0.005585351,
-0.0352046788,
0.0320445113,
-0.0372295305,
0.0512909368,
-0.0514240526,
0.0127343088,
0.0061797919,
-0.0036179665,
0.0391777009,
-0.0531193577,
-0.0335474797,
-0.0004597052,
2.886e-7,
0.0750931054,
0.0551329628,
-0.0379912332,
0.050528165,
0.0311993808,
0.0120644225,
-0.0316698775,
0.0043390132,
-0.0147190094,
0.0063128537,
-0.006580478,
0.0292390939,
0.0496046096,
0.0345202871,
-0.0336508229,
0.0109381042,
0.0114292838,
0.0832141489,
-0.023917539,
0.0455357209,
0.069389984,
0.0806340128,
0.0171718374,
0.0308112502,
-0.0334706865,
-0.0513044745,
0.0730369538,
-0.0498345159,
0.0235384107,
0.0143974582,
0.0220785849,
0.0235405993,
-0.0009925562,
0.0025171482,
-0.0011047706,
-0.0111965509,
0.0270052869,
0.0683552399,
-0.0062101013,
0.0192044899,
-0.0299471226,
-0.0681034997,
0.0006475849,
-0.0400125645,
0.0546457171,
-0.0382755436,
-0.0123122716,
0.0186361447,
0.0080727786,
0.0354773477,
0.0366913229,
-0.0087102167,
-0.0522338748,
0.0184522942,
0.045642335,
0.0074022203,
-0.0427764803,
-0.0490416661,
-0.0502355658,
-0.0088259382,
-0.0185587481,
-0.0326458886,
0.0224949867,
0.030589899,
-0.0002273592,
-0.0677242726,
-0.0515807495,
2.471043639e-34,
0.0509078167,
-0.019128168,
-0.0023590317,
0.0143489223,
0.0357260965,
-0.0228814632,
-0.0311722197,
0.0242373887,
-0.009960128,
-0.002998133,
0.0020310462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14609v1 | Long Short-Term Planning for Conversational Recommendation Systems | 2023-10-23T06:34:39 | 2023-10-23T06:34:39 | Xian Li, Hongguang Shi, Yunfei Wang, Yeqin Zhang, Xubin Li, Cam-Tu Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Conversational Recommendation Systems (CRS), the central question is how
the conversational agent can naturally ask for user preferences and provide
suitable recommendations. Existing works mainly follow the hierarchical
architecture, where a higher policy decides whether to invoke the conversation
module (to ask questions) or the recommendation module (to make
recommendations). This architecture prevents these two components from fully
interacting with each other. In contrast, this paper proposes a novel
architecture, the long short-term feedback architecture, to connect these two
essential components in CRS. Specifically, the recommendation predicts the
long-term recommendation target based on the conversational context and the
user history. Driven by the targeted recommendation, the conversational model
predicts the next topic or attribute to verify if the user preference matches
the target. The balance feedback loop continues until the short-term planner
output matches the long-term planner output, that is when the system should
make the recommendation. | [
0.0515777878,
0.0061083399,
0.0097289057,
0.0047969753,
-0.0413786247,
-0.0380274393,
0.0082408544,
-0.0435184315,
0.0347931609,
-0.0150502445,
-0.0099952463,
-0.0047475887,
0.0164561011,
0.0794781446,
-0.0255524889,
-0.0480857417,
-0.0042500095,
-0.0459867828,
0.0110927122,
0.0070303883,
0.0447039083,
-0.0228984654,
0.0049753035,
0.0102498876,
0.0078372937,
-0.0049491213,
-0.0648385212,
-0.0252472162,
-0.0428545028,
-0.0235329363,
0.0452835411,
0.0060499017,
0.0258625355,
-0.0077448841,
0.0000021712,
-0.0504007339,
-0.0427194871,
-0.0549516082,
-0.0117277112,
-0.0744287744,
0.0284688491,
0.0869647339,
0.0007163541,
0.0247661434,
-0.020554103,
0.0537295826,
0.0145682786,
0.0846072286,
0.0126035679,
0.0340877585,
-0.0298687369,
-0.0212588459,
0.0322546884,
-0.0172348861,
0.0648017824,
-0.0430628844,
0.0095772222,
-0.0210772064,
0.0497445986,
0.0221794471,
0.0017931259,
-0.0277549326,
-0.0076882103,
-0.033627592,
0.0416665375,
0.0174708217,
0.0279965773,
-0.0402180888,
0.0062841959,
0.0611689091,
0.0230948441,
-0.0022665921,
0.0259115007,
0.0378899425,
0.0006447967,
-0.0753215477,
-0.0325983465,
-0.0309268143,
-0.0265933927,
-0.0048353858,
0.0288637523,
-0.0092266146,
0.0129740713,
-0.0028592856,
-0.0263044219,
0.0701104403,
-0.0117656114,
-0.0253134836,
0.0088612502,
-0.0264093075,
0.0764422417,
-0.1026315838,
0.0284199119,
0.0587171093,
-0.1037321985,
-0.0179005265,
0.0085242977,
0.0834063292,
-0.0179231428,
-0.0464020483,
-0.0211867299,
0.0304230805,
-0.0155716529,
0.0374512896,
0.0277590062,
-0.0030475694,
0.0094545567,
-0.0719107985,
-0.0386528447,
0.0022709214,
-0.0178424083,
0.0203027502,
-0.0254003182,
0.0314605646,
-0.0399253704,
-0.0496256649,
-0.0345799178,
0.0825754628,
-0.0195844937,
0.0376127586,
-0.0152505152,
0.0599720106,
-0.0038801169,
0.0305858627,
-0.1213946864,
0.0358645134,
-0.0861478001,
0.0165368784,
0.024311265,
0.0154378433,
0.039276816,
0.0473925248,
0.0251310915,
-0.0058743535,
-0.0148542318,
0.0626214743,
-0.000951638,
-0.0303584468,
-0.018892413,
-0.040142823,
-0.0270463303,
-0.0464571118,
0.0259317327,
-0.0279324353,
0.0104745151,
0.0116525879,
-0.00588194,
0.0408001021,
0.0189794265,
0.0161797162,
-0.0152138444,
0.0670475364,
0.0258693378,
-0.0154565526,
0.0044740834,
-0.0017674059,
-0.0253148805,
0.0156092746,
0.0143606942,
0.0735325888,
0.0367138162,
0.0369448029,
0.0388213322,
-0.0060485117,
-0.0012331838,
-0.0128201107,
0.0254802573,
0.0348390825,
-0.0267810933,
0.0361888744,
-0.008052445,
0.0317219831,
-0.0141174067,
0.0024408598,
0.0317281485,
0.0153155765,
0.0415288843,
0.0378967859,
0.0184844658,
0.0062712398,
-0.0661679581,
0.0042102835,
-0.0312390141,
0.0735684186,
-0.0606501736,
-0.0464670546,
0.0078840218,
0.0028808566,
-0.0526766367,
-0.0270701144,
0.044559706,
-0.0441135541,
0.033889167,
0.0130871041,
0.0027956921,
-0.0189874358,
-0.0262844916,
0.0101457667,
-0.0012243915,
0.0097078905,
-0.0287681371,
-0.0595498979,
0.117423445,
0.1510725021,
0.0410544686,
0.0136103975,
-0.0365781486,
-0.0030438576,
-0.0091803167,
-0.0185846519,
0.0335673094,
-0.0568316579,
0.0120485444,
0.0019344935,
-0.0612893105,
0.0342220962,
-0.046860531,
0.026249148,
-0.0231016744,
0.0033618554,
-0.0153422793,
0.0478541479,
0.0006010947,
-0.0184507109,
-0.0087376023,
0.01295642,
0.0111636296,
0.0330803879,
0.0434148423,
-0.0018429082,
0.0390845537,
0.0084397038,
0.0100821909,
0.0031184058,
-0.0187305771,
0.0362651646,
-0.0539517477,
-0.0266017858,
0.0306484494,
-0.0056399922,
0.0609901212,
-0.0134234587,
0.0422920212,
-0.0619105548,
0.0213415809,
-0.0281958506,
0.0477377772,
-0.006487688,
0.0237897635,
0.0246105809,
-0.0233028773,
-0.0109280059,
0.0123627642,
0.0229033157,
-0.0400702804,
-0.0063408385,
0.0159981865,
0.0023189394,
-0.0537744947,
-0.0278743356,
0.0283901915,
0.0061741774,
-0.0206584893,
0.0664658472,
0.0080216629,
-0.0450778827,
-0.0267245714,
-0.087993376,
0.0260498282,
0.0093939509,
-0.0422568247,
-0.0355359428,
0.0550889336,
0.0353571251,
-0.0592631213,
-0.0441326499,
0.0517666526,
-0.0023185462,
0.0225783344,
0.0065093036,
0.04569095,
-0.0431974642,
-0.0440172032,
0.0317423083,
-0.0205257814,
-0.013292904,
0.0015306713,
-0.0019109437,
-0.0455718301,
-0.0332001634,
-0.0526450165,
0.0198120307,
-0.0235001519,
0.0038621724,
-0.0172503907,
-0.0234655961,
0.0327749997,
0.0267728493,
0.0296343844,
0.0422492735,
-0.0114323553,
-0.0524489768,
-0.0416273288,
0.0405567549,
-0.0590199232,
-0.0049216035,
-0.0343115777,
0.0567811839,
-0.007942616,
0.0138910124,
-0.0606433935,
0.0294468049,
-0.0366293639,
0.0101109333,
0.0548346639,
0.0193425473,
-0.005351014,
0.0044333637,
-0.0285054706,
0.0361466855,
-0.0077198935,
-0.0221909638,
0.0482371338,
0.0116994753,
-0.0335090384,
-0.0385161154,
-0.0320876837,
-0.034216743,
-0.0063778167,
0.0157965235,
0.0040314496,
-0.0267158337,
-0.013279479,
0.0011757374,
-0.015286237,
0.0025962894,
-0.0214050375,
0.0215706173,
0.0090165669,
0.0061022867,
0.0318981335,
-0.0478890464,
-0.0543636195,
-0.0176122878,
-0.0243955459,
-0.0013589107,
-0.0098506678,
-0.0331397615,
-0.0363474749,
-0.0174514595,
0.0141984411,
0.0400847048,
-0.0524182729,
-0.0260462686,
0.0030618196,
0.0005177119,
0.0582172945,
-0.0136455996,
-0.0073150215,
0.0122725926,
0.0712372512,
0.0108312229,
0.0287090689,
-0.0359588712,
-0.0512640141,
-0.0159507133,
0.0439324267,
0.0064880564,
-0.0085095847,
0.06086592,
0.0168956835,
0.0172854345,
-0.0110512432,
0.0964001641,
0.0151338382,
-0.0765127987,
0.0109623466,
-0.0082140071,
0.055653777,
0.0129268793,
0.0527150966,
-0.0407163128,
-0.0156116346,
0.0247991458,
0.0185243562,
-0.0152460253,
-0.0444787852,
-0.0273386687,
-0.0372165665,
0.0176209882,
-0.0131869987,
-0.0259302799,
0.0227264427,
-0.0487927236,
-0.0155294007,
0.0091399709,
0.0066769109,
0.0340790749,
-0.009083176,
-0.0359134935,
-0.0092255184,
-0.0444628634,
0.0122589469,
0.0566429868,
-0.030191673,
0.0249845795,
0.0948828235,
0.045697201,
0.0248224735,
0.005773013,
-0.002230546,
0.0321592316,
-0.0038060318,
-0.0299219508,
0.0177864842,
-0.0414946079,
0.0261423998,
-0.0533180498,
0.0626652092,
-0.0231772009,
-0.0131697999,
0.0193538424,
0.063062951,
-0.0682140291,
-0.0063725971,
-0.0268826392,
0.0440116674,
0.0604490563,
0.0456126295,
-0.0114239594,
-0.0522077903,
-0.0577435829,
-0.050918173,
-0.0675619841,
-0.0259492006,
0.0029131994,
-0.0390289016,
0.0117517589,
0.0462747514,
-0.0391182676,
-0.0655175373,
-0.0182090756,
0.0184798855,
0.0050547202,
0.0239825137,
0.001754828,
0.0222658254,
0.0386446491,
-0.0420405455,
0.0061448002,
0.0369850621,
-0.0343739316,
0.0218856689,
0.0322885215,
-0.0578481108,
0.0037539424,
-0.019425841,
-0.0475001186,
-0.0225270279,
-0.0402713344,
0.0685789064,
0.0238028653,
0.0727185905,
-0.0387801826,
-0.0500463769,
0.0067011123,
-0.0148468371,
-0.0268086214,
-0.0164728686,
0.0105495788,
0.0896769688,
0.0188895129,
0.0571260937,
-0.0381723866,
0.0101518249,
-0.0397673585,
-0.0334552675,
0.012075806,
-0.0099683721,
-0.0206158478,
-0.0121528124,
0.0087735858,
0.0143051203,
0.0068380442,
0.0198917631,
0.0486632958,
-0.0010692794,
-0.0487132892,
-0.0229651239,
0.0458236039,
0.0076350537,
-0.0200053155,
0.020714974,
-0.0337313563,
-0.0072354437,
-0.0110902544,
-0.0069681969,
0.0330787413,
0.0017702932,
-0.0504536964,
0.0269755311,
0.0317786634,
0.0207934696,
0.0017674463,
0.0557403527,
0.0498041548,
-0.0094471918,
0.0562122278,
0.0179699585,
-0.028067857,
-0.0057430132,
0.0108824782,
-0.0426625088,
-0.0591484457,
0.0091511235,
0.0443802625,
0.007434349,
-0.0240126271,
-0.0024838427,
-0.0199635942,
0.0415230431,
-0.0573175326,
0.027494356,
-0.0429229364,
-0.0558576435,
0.0195509456,
0.0311986543,
-0.0149127934,
-0.0233252663,
0.0270379707,
-0.0050809812,
0.0156252123,
0.0046412502,
-0.0372710675,
-0.0477879271,
-0.0111513454,
-0.037357457,
0.0599139631,
-0.0122341355,
-0.0084529454,
-0.003712992,
-0.005259885,
0.002671194,
-0.0457124263,
0.0060728076,
-0.0383724421,
0.0479277149,
0.056674853,
-0.0103000756,
-0.0320135653,
-0.0456107035,
-0.0103988629,
-0.019545164,
-0.0083035668,
-0.025274625,
-6.358819058e-33,
0.0200320259,
-0.0164179038,
0.0836798549,
0.0389253423,
-0.0247370899,
-0.0515587963,
-0.0344719514,
-0.0084771113,
0.0184790473,
0.0109175621,
-0.0418338291,
-0.0126651386,
0.0191629156,
0.0288235079,
0.0277232379,
-0.0161618013,
0.0587501302,
0.0158838797,
-0.0186246671,
0.0471284017,
0.0721008256,
0.054549627,
-0.0104105771,
-0.058405038,
0.0204374027,
-0.0010265327,
0.0185472108,
0.0633862689,
0.0362130553,
0.0754881501,
-0.0132769747,
0.0144858174,
0.0358234607,
-0.0261008311,
-0.0023338974,
0.0414195843,
-0.0689227059,
-0.0255424622,
0.0333213545,
0.0111263664,
-0.0629522875,
-0.0033339071,
-0.0268411804,
0.0011228743,
-0.0131949456,
0.006523787,
0.016196413,
-0.0135963885,
-0.0406383723,
0.0342701934,
-0.0207525976,
-0.0041409074,
0.006244442,
-0.0390201099,
0.0086705722,
0.0418764725,
0.0044204644,
0.0114442231,
-0.0191052612,
0.0331370868,
-0.0413550735,
0.030405324,
-0.0256775338,
0.0178138614,
-0.0516660623,
0.0361372232,
0.0357743204,
0.0181519818,
0.0267888624,
-0.0165922344,
-0.0234725904,
0.074100472,
0.0020986113,
-0.0194662418,
-0.0074756262,
-0.0223126337,
-0.0107391533,
0.0260301754,
0.0742644966,
0.0448087454,
0.016869219,
0.0187532902,
-0.0416594222,
-0.0383817814,
-0.0254026521,
-0.0177253764,
-0.0375633053,
-0.0304624792,
0.0376833268,
0.0899006799,
0.0489783622,
0.0095903287,
0.0353360213,
-0.0136599001,
-0.007463932,
0.0288146697,
-0.0131245237,
-0.0303908456,
0.0220538415,
0.02419075,
-0.0727739781,
-0.0183382016,
0.0024256553,
-0.0371976495,
-0.0549299456,
0.0146236252,
-0.0129667567,
0.0197559576,
-0.0083821248,
-0.0206816718,
-0.0166575126,
-0.0131775616,
-0.0249953121,
0.0183514189,
0.0371113084,
0.0387872569,
-0.03675396,
0.107973896,
-0.0129564935,
0.0170792751,
-0.0429097004,
-0.088455528,
0.0243080147,
0.001016254,
-0.0281582437,
-0.0478389226,
-0.0181501284,
0.0075879334,
-0.0034182887,
-0.091117017,
0.0025499081,
-0.0339366533,
2.885e-7,
-0.0862299427,
0.0384024531,
0.0147255296,
-0.0271325372,
0.0544860996,
0.0319931544,
0.0257313866,
0.041507978,
0.0134126935,
0.0154820858,
0.0119403992,
-0.0313738845,
0.0136162285,
-0.0025875927,
-0.0479946174,
-0.0167831704,
-0.0452931821,
-0.0168937277,
-0.0384829193,
-0.041243732,
0.0200565122,
0.0583404042,
0.036130216,
0.0018748296,
0.0277954545,
-0.007805129,
0.0321790874,
-0.0434166081,
-0.0272948612,
-0.0087421425,
0.0351923928,
-0.0082747871,
-0.0147784036,
-0.0061101289,
-0.0117166424,
0.0343794748,
-0.051713597,
0.0347941667,
-0.0050415867,
-0.0812991485,
-0.0053610536,
0.0349324979,
-0.0040828637,
-0.0130961854,
0.084689565,
-0.013363299,
-0.0075181648,
-0.0251365695,
0.0095976507,
-0.001766774,
-0.0377319045,
-0.0000479519,
-0.00804142,
-0.013098699,
-0.0047683758,
0.0114876125,
0.0130341211,
-0.0693030283,
0.0431079641,
-0.0072200629,
-0.040687412,
-0.0514269546,
-0.074911505,
0.0043195416,
0.0154478652,
-0.043922469,
0.0169024207,
2.48141531e-34,
0.0205221847,
0.022197457,
-0.0145410504,
-0.0080630323,
0.0192765314,
0.0064403419,
0.0371023864,
0.0264236238,
0.1040567234,
-0.0490313098,
-0.0651877075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14607v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14607v2 | Confronting LLMs with Traditional ML: Rethinking the Fairness of Large Language Models in Tabular Classifications | 2023-10-23T06:31:28 | 2024-04-02T21:29:20 | Yanchen Liu, Srishti Gautam, Jiaqi Ma, Himabindu Lakkaraju | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent literature has suggested the potential of using large language models
(LLMs) to make classifications for tabular tasks. However, LLMs have been shown
to exhibit harmful social biases that reflect the stereotypes and inequalities
present in society. To this end, as well as the widespread use of tabular data
in many high-stake applications, it is important to explore the following
questions: what sources of information do LLMs draw upon when making
classifications for tabular tasks; whether and to what extent are LLM
classifications for tabular data influenced by social biases and stereotypes;
and what are the consequential implications for fairness?
Through a series of experiments, we delve into these questions and show that
LLMs tend to inherit social biases from their training data which significantly
impact their fairness in tabular classification tasks. Furthermore, our
investigations show that in the context of bias mitigation, though in-context
learning and finetuning have a moderate effect, the fairness metric gap between
different subgroups is still larger than that in traditional machine learning
models, such as Random Forest and shallow Neural Networks. This observation
emphasizes that the social biases are inherent within the LLMs themselves and
inherited from their pretraining corpus, not only from the downstream task
datasets. Besides, we demonstrate that label-flipping of in-context examples
can significantly reduce biases, further highlighting the presence of inherent
bias within LLMs. | [
0.0318627432,
0.0834474787,
-0.0400703549,
0.0347296707,
-0.0109764747,
0.0358012281,
0.0303665213,
-0.0036583061,
-0.0085169645,
-0.0978990048,
-0.0530195273,
-0.0381595045,
0.0263761878,
-0.0226234812,
0.0378885828,
-0.0351059027,
0.024406679,
0.0324229896,
0.0173506755,
-0.0528355837,
0.0038838605,
0.006411891,
0.0443691537,
0.0347777493,
-0.0185563434,
-0.0023281933,
0.0534829646,
-0.0124490876,
-0.0371292382,
0.0333248749,
0.047001835,
0.0798495412,
0.0053953631,
0.0560914055,
0.0000017703,
-0.0621103942,
0.0031167786,
-0.0024372903,
-0.0022482011,
-0.0009941017,
0.0488965474,
-0.0345006734,
-0.0030030215,
0.0246690512,
-0.0520238243,
-0.0159217808,
0.0254009999,
0.0043409956,
-0.0158957914,
0.0247506369,
0.0039151823,
-0.0467908904,
-0.034189973,
-0.0250905417,
0.01789473,
-0.007174293,
0.040673919,
-0.0502123795,
-0.0646326095,
-0.0251200311,
-0.0280446224,
-0.0005145744,
0.0455702916,
0.0337488838,
0.0596065409,
0.0267343074,
-0.0700698644,
-0.01017405,
0.0069030081,
0.0548022799,
-0.0068298019,
-0.0242434479,
-0.0129020484,
-0.019131843,
0.0629413128,
-0.0037973283,
-0.0258750524,
0.0534598753,
-0.0119230859,
0.0193210077,
0.0081559727,
0.0236153454,
0.0446783155,
0.0183325484,
-0.0209951978,
0.0640921071,
-0.0246156864,
-0.0344054289,
0.006902229,
0.043472942,
0.0124107068,
-0.0217224937,
-0.0058981762,
-0.0114069376,
0.0005878382,
0.0059387712,
-0.0263669938,
-0.0000266401,
0.0485470705,
-0.0567271039,
0.0085302852,
0.0211133379,
-0.0172654632,
-0.007825573,
0.0020796079,
0.0116310315,
0.0241438057,
0.067994453,
-0.0072471327,
-0.0262185037,
-0.0014929933,
-0.0159291886,
0.0009103908,
-0.0083723338,
-0.0261346437,
0.0551986955,
-0.0412535444,
-0.012565962,
-0.0478897132,
-0.0111704385,
0.0237866826,
0.0175670926,
-0.0097271409,
0.0238781571,
-0.0397114567,
-0.0207205191,
-0.0075120144,
0.0350107104,
-0.0413654596,
-0.0725312606,
0.0274921935,
0.0056445515,
-0.0432687365,
-0.0413126238,
0.0200661458,
0.0508370921,
-0.0130494554,
-0.0299479682,
-0.0491864569,
-0.0068780291,
-0.0236389488,
-0.0451020785,
0.0067155585,
-0.0523399897,
0.0178889092,
0.041871652,
0.0083691003,
-0.0664293617,
-0.0264260955,
0.0103756385,
-0.0689472258,
0.0801556408,
0.0379709639,
0.0096776551,
0.0508433059,
0.0167481042,
-0.0246152319,
0.0826570988,
0.0420134291,
-0.0160044245,
0.042942889,
-0.024164455,
-0.0022677025,
0.0433959253,
0.0132960482,
-0.0226374939,
-0.0471824333,
0.0099130394,
0.0099215414,
-0.0004082459,
0.0715054572,
0.0225139521,
0.0297405478,
-0.0414308943,
0.0735016465,
0.0630526096,
-0.0155118974,
0.0475998297,
-0.0289013162,
-0.0006186406,
-0.0379602164,
0.0211874377,
-0.0676819384,
-0.0237627253,
-0.0041411459,
-0.0527362227,
0.0056780698,
0.03674905,
-0.036013037,
-0.0637018234,
-0.0142734107,
0.0141712129,
0.0620889738,
0.0122678755,
0.0395567715,
0.0116553707,
0.0119404495,
0.0416666456,
0.055454798,
-0.0101346597,
-0.0032572502,
-0.0720590502,
0.0053217551,
0.022316033,
-0.0020828468,
-0.0498479381,
0.0503487401,
-0.0033904444,
-0.003561975,
0.0341280624,
0.0947236866,
-0.0207100362,
-0.0253236964,
-0.0269400291,
-0.0076125716,
0.0291083213,
0.0341980867,
0.0000813208,
0.0257272497,
0.0191564951,
-0.0077884523,
-0.0487432368,
-0.0711654499,
0.0517116636,
0.0237037577,
-0.0336771198,
0.0146624614,
0.0231558513,
0.0027179359,
-0.0010290971,
-0.0333634019,
-0.0030261313,
-0.0237140171,
-0.0084978966,
-0.0050433832,
-0.0042438842,
-0.0687221289,
-0.0013302065,
-0.0085085165,
-0.0065373098,
-0.0313385352,
0.0424100757,
-0.0165995378,
0.0309710894,
0.0161015429,
0.0091492375,
0.034929771,
-0.0070317476,
0.0238668248,
-0.0579313859,
0.0294558331,
-0.082860291,
0.0309100598,
-0.0107752858,
-0.0057161441,
-0.0295242574,
-0.077978313,
0.0004039495,
-0.008907659,
-0.0197214484,
0.0339417607,
-0.008379126,
0.0266963709,
0.0243749768,
-0.0081248982,
-0.0056029041,
-0.0051168404,
-0.0848728865,
-0.0086639151,
-0.0355854668,
-0.0114151547,
-0.0067701023,
-0.001207553,
-0.0241940115,
-0.0344094485,
-0.0448869132,
-0.015216358,
0.005558223,
0.0497566201,
0.0359937847,
-0.0274023712,
0.0062399581,
-0.0152065624,
-0.04848684,
-0.0400721878,
0.0849252492,
0.0095023206,
-0.0137453815,
-0.0442936011,
-0.0090078637,
-0.0205797255,
0.0120508429,
-0.0071102506,
0.006658786,
0.018313216,
0.0545404814,
0.012670368,
0.0946044996,
0.0153493695,
0.0592239797,
0.066784583,
0.0406485423,
-0.0430692844,
-0.0262641273,
0.0072480659,
-0.0014452781,
-0.0076545533,
-0.0666321889,
0.0067461147,
0.079194285,
0.0228339974,
-0.0365069211,
-0.0419618674,
0.0424291305,
-0.0434650332,
-0.0450005718,
-0.0537640043,
0.0034022694,
-0.0176596772,
0.0159488004,
-0.0352662392,
-0.0810507983,
0.031814076,
0.0121490713,
0.0030928154,
-0.0185136441,
-0.0238990244,
-0.0461124443,
0.0624014288,
0.0125831477,
-0.0033685206,
0.0128922164,
-0.0171364117,
-0.0808820128,
-0.0259461328,
0.0361941829,
-0.0309232101,
0.0559023097,
-0.0373232327,
-0.0061461325,
-0.0369028673,
-0.0588524863,
-0.0348605104,
-0.0844276175,
-0.012277103,
0.0300615951,
0.0250922088,
-0.0064205988,
-0.0147561943,
0.0121877622,
-0.002963339,
0.0351618081,
-0.0117064714,
-0.0009846368,
0.0024411152,
0.0085538561,
0.0045480793,
-0.0036470203,
0.0347110555,
-0.0244867448,
0.0027795765,
0.0256801452,
0.0280819498,
0.0342831574,
0.0285222232,
0.0111842183,
0.0645767748,
-0.0135676125,
-0.031205941,
0.0068708565,
0.0453420244,
-0.0445996262,
0.0307182241,
0.0945531204,
0.0064734961,
-0.0381885804,
0.015880676,
-0.0205838289,
0.0358814299,
0.0344942249,
0.0063675437,
-0.0761448666,
-0.0041502095,
0.0174159426,
0.0381720252,
-0.0491350442,
-0.0418573506,
-0.006562517,
-0.1039321795,
0.0250484217,
0.0182116292,
-0.0559449606,
-0.0339388549,
-0.0204938781,
0.0049159201,
-0.0362232551,
0.0520178452,
-0.0144553315,
-0.0013217862,
-0.0074509704,
0.0370643921,
-0.0504318736,
-0.0262580253,
0.0238890238,
-0.0542726256,
0.0366341285,
0.0155819384,
0.0204423591,
-0.0374188907,
-0.0088835051,
0.0554050095,
0.0001729098,
-0.0029400717,
-0.014211393,
0.0382504277,
-0.036008738,
-0.0110044181,
-0.0091036856,
-0.0045914021,
0.0069253007,
0.0333796404,
-0.010106476,
0.0413351394,
-0.0021513915,
-0.0787158534,
-0.0139851961,
-0.0297095682,
-0.0124873277,
0.0908363461,
0.0323827751,
-0.0351383202,
-0.0160453711,
-0.069657065,
-0.0286840051,
0.0305545125,
-0.0470022969,
0.0831005499,
-0.0088599185,
-0.0573241152,
-0.0022512239,
-0.0592104793,
0.0237630419,
-0.011958532,
0.00160981,
-0.0083478102,
0.0223664604,
-0.0128202047,
-0.0751099065,
0.0363166258,
-0.0249871481,
0.0202427469,
-0.0054493938,
-0.0590602346,
0.0102510024,
-0.0331110172,
-0.0253123753,
-0.0308400355,
-0.0095664794,
-0.0562656224,
0.0253767818,
0.0165032428,
0.0231259782,
0.0343536697,
0.0526331067,
-0.0715222135,
0.0366929136,
0.0733334869,
-0.0205365308,
0.0400520749,
0.0237358399,
-0.0496324897,
0.0063032024,
0.0245416816,
-0.0267174765,
0.0232361536,
0.0272247493,
-0.0162168294,
-0.0245228093,
-0.0209681261,
-0.0050287317,
-0.009974746,
0.0501502119,
-0.0195409153,
-0.0491586551,
-0.0320056416,
-0.0137471566,
0.0069431243,
-0.0512204207,
0.0047449125,
-0.0639190972,
0.0135432761,
0.0530151278,
-0.0682742447,
0.0132127488,
-0.0132573918,
0.0592564382,
-0.0574764349,
0.0482528694,
-0.0037347102,
0.0305323284,
0.0189979281,
0.0144620994,
0.0019831806,
0.0167112667,
-0.0004328802,
0.0402082615,
0.0403189287,
0.0114653669,
0.024458712,
0.0271287896,
-0.0326421596,
0.0293251816,
-0.035219457,
-0.0547440723,
-0.001545759,
0.0103088338,
0.0161852464,
-0.0414674208,
0.0028004486,
0.0107212393,
-0.0161122866,
0.0087692337,
-0.015793249,
0.0267238468,
0.0037217566,
0.0440265983,
-0.0128665697,
-0.0380151458,
0.0044671716,
0.0786057189,
0.0537269786,
0.0277901385,
-0.0203175955,
-0.0494698063,
-0.0025480888,
-0.0127216224,
0.0798173919,
-0.0034678057,
-0.0019839993,
-0.0389368907,
-0.0886937454,
-0.0508588254,
-0.0103293126,
0.0150018716,
0.0299049504,
-0.0265076496,
0.0094875507,
0.0755564794,
-0.029154446,
-0.0326340646,
-0.025931159,
-0.0025511046,
-0.0121365674,
-0.0164922271,
-0.0112719666,
-5.840947675e-33,
-0.0125587555,
-0.0152889965,
-0.0127537092,
-0.0100215795,
-0.0005906677,
-0.0034795352,
0.0037809135,
0.0004452973,
-0.0180937462,
0.0002723232,
-0.0154169425,
0.0207378287,
0.0157791544,
0.0094568217,
0.0525947325,
-0.0430353023,
0.0448256955,
-0.0244625267,
-0.0164022427,
-0.0217882246,
-0.0365245864,
0.0190860052,
0.0434822477,
-0.0460090898,
0.061941158,
0.0082376655,
0.0241121147,
0.0235449728,
-0.0083255414,
0.0041749757,
-0.0129027646,
0.1024341062,
0.0634651631,
-0.0311073028,
-0.0056474516,
0.0908664763,
-0.0624016002,
-0.0015700655,
-0.0065081907,
0.0472359546,
0.0356839933,
-0.0134804184,
0.0771005526,
0.0292037111,
-0.0738743916,
-0.0145345414,
0.058259856,
-0.015807787,
0.0311020352,
-0.000739034,
-0.0269767232,
0.0226445086,
-0.0037928137,
0.0082646683,
-0.0015382095,
-0.0236793049,
0.0329485498,
0.0487850308,
-0.0518752299,
0.0082399724,
-0.0321050175,
-0.0135703748,
0.0546009392,
0.0385776386,
0.0147245731,
0.0486184806,
0.0819780976,
0.0775937438,
-0.0224808399,
-0.0791567415,
0.0499646887,
-0.0331024788,
0.0119907027,
0.0542034917,
0.0942727849,
-0.0254410598,
-0.0404834971,
0.0086553926,
0.034554109,
-0.0414321236,
-0.0019410425,
-0.0120526804,
-0.088303186,
-0.0714633316,
-0.0173099693,
-0.0374552123,
-0.0124489972,
0.0319204293,
0.0048184539,
-0.0123060718,
0.031022748,
0.016267458,
0.0171199646,
-0.0440342911,
-0.0503939725,
0.0096490765,
-0.0058918037,
-0.020038303,
0.0090713277,
-0.0269335136,
-0.0624167472,
-0.0180432498,
-0.0158095378,
0.0261291582,
0.0316046402,
0.0300774574,
0.0486961044,
0.0045264848,
-0.0552032813,
0.0007069625,
-0.0066824416,
0.0033731833,
0.0407593809,
0.037396159,
0.0251627341,
0.021461457,
0.0219651479,
0.0135367569,
0.0273514558,
-0.0282517411,
-0.0384801514,
0.0009870066,
-0.051510565,
0.0129091926,
-0.0106151178,
-0.0381971858,
-0.004236225,
0.0239011254,
0.0435895734,
-0.0417371355,
-0.0099277468,
-0.0694286078,
2.32e-7,
0.0408185571,
0.0596234389,
-0.0208954532,
0.0096550826,
0.0176534951,
0.040227294,
0.0345619023,
0.0532655157,
-0.0048466306,
0.0060216137,
-0.006727478,
0.0312690213,
0.0531686135,
0.0362052321,
-0.0592114441,
-0.02282276,
-0.1023160517,
0.0263715796,
-0.0280525964,
0.0202600881,
0.0161457788,
0.0428024717,
0.0118543357,
-0.0342263356,
-0.0238416772,
-0.0402815379,
0.0267282538,
-0.0625908971,
0.0541605353,
0.0194875244,
0.0253809523,
0.0014336298,
0.0119170221,
0.0721357316,
0.0232744385,
0.0223466158,
0.0021500934,
0.0213872697,
-0.0291559827,
0.0390370712,
-0.0145453727,
-0.0138770705,
-0.0276648384,
-0.0843692943,
0.0506319441,
-0.0274186805,
-0.0363485292,
-0.0160234887,
0.0299078338,
-0.0143034533,
0.0592653118,
0.0080382377,
0.0000296771,
0.0086085666,
0.0421959534,
-0.0257652644,
0.0042367741,
-0.0749596655,
-0.0522983931,
0.0014569825,
-0.0291368496,
-0.0410933755,
0.0096520344,
0.0252818614,
0.0106079085,
-0.0243308954,
0.0419157036,
2.15319318e-34,
0.0282052476,
0.0267850515,
0.0221932437,
-0.0182794873,
0.0135656474,
0.00365664,
0.0185950622,
-0.0154840956,
0.032349132,
-0.0139377033,
0.0179145895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14605v1 | M2DF: Multi-grained Multi-curriculum Denoising Framework for Multimodal Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-10-23T06:22:39 | 2023-10-23T06:22:39 | Fei Zhao, Chunhui Li, Zhen Wu, Yawen Ouyang, Jianbing Zhang, Xinyu Dai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Multimodal Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (MABSA) is a fine-grained
Sentiment Analysis task, which has attracted growing research interests
recently. Existing work mainly utilizes image information to improve the
performance of MABSA task. However, most of the studies overestimate the
importance of images since there are many noise images unrelated to the text in
the dataset, which will have a negative impact on model learning. Although some
work attempts to filter low-quality noise images by setting thresholds, relying
on thresholds will inevitably filter out a lot of useful image information.
Therefore, in this work, we focus on whether the negative impact of noisy
images can be reduced without modifying the data. To achieve this goal, we
borrow the idea of Curriculum Learning and propose a Multi-grained
Multi-curriculum Denoising Framework (M2DF), which can achieve denoising by
adjusting the order of training data. Extensive experimental results show that
our framework consistently outperforms state-of-the-art work on three sub-tasks
of MABSA. | [
0.0255388618,
0.079087846,
0.00048499,
0.0630124956,
0.0005316295,
0.0141217476,
0.0255459696,
0.0150040379,
-0.0461441278,
-0.0282276757,
-0.0337096229,
-0.0109341592,
-0.0223295651,
0.0188034084,
0.0238336977,
-0.0376534835,
0.0265641566,
0.0090181921,
0.0440647416,
-0.021228943,
0.0302168392,
-0.0006174945,
-0.0010500475,
0.0063451054,
-0.0586272925,
-0.0337802731,
0.0306038167,
0.0267171934,
0.0401321948,
-0.0014644247,
0.0430741385,
0.0169745237,
0.0064463406,
-0.0320041776,
0.0000024742,
0.0011549569,
-0.0141850319,
-0.0052538747,
0.0691894069,
-0.021616878,
0.0930766389,
0.0062729502,
0.0376595743,
-0.0332428515,
-0.0230751634,
0.0317958295,
0.0391697437,
0.100486055,
0.0838126987,
0.0462281443,
-0.0580186546,
-0.0413197167,
-0.0129546551,
-0.0093493313,
0.0118209636,
-0.0385850482,
-0.0107426094,
0.0427212119,
-0.0076724016,
0.0484350882,
-0.0420080982,
0.0395524353,
-0.0048816712,
0.008000765,
0.0366825946,
-0.0090710409,
0.0505851023,
-0.0184620097,
0.00714943,
0.0687307641,
-0.0209070053,
0.0052077821,
-0.0215744637,
-0.0454291403,
0.0053579998,
-0.0064565828,
-0.0197300985,
0.0065037776,
-0.0066277403,
0.03983403,
-0.0248257555,
0.020408418,
-0.0074308282,
0.0057834298,
0.0349985473,
-0.03391812,
-0.0158776529,
-0.0149104651,
0.0087823505,
0.0368818156,
0.0073850784,
0.0201711077,
0.0084701972,
0.0039793919,
0.0038979936,
-0.0080280127,
-0.0195429828,
-0.0061692107,
-0.005146943,
-0.0289953332,
-0.0272084922,
-0.0247948207,
-0.0765833855,
0.0540968478,
0.055364579,
-0.0439689159,
0.0111725861,
0.0124929855,
-0.0425630584,
0.0216131359,
-0.0296696723,
0.0291677695,
0.0115291579,
0.0362447686,
-0.0431150682,
-0.024791291,
-0.033207085,
-0.0357451402,
-0.0243487153,
0.0274302531,
0.0209217817,
0.0189600214,
-0.0333253294,
0.0063536153,
-0.0039716065,
0.0643826798,
-0.0120057929,
0.0463861264,
-0.0470392928,
0.0471114367,
0.0094602257,
0.0343763158,
0.0017962138,
-0.007232449,
0.0127849616,
0.0161380731,
0.0014835547,
-0.0320168287,
-0.0257989634,
-0.0422871858,
-0.0385311171,
-0.0582333207,
0.0312022138,
-0.0508935861,
-0.0081786793,
-0.036848601,
0.0345833339,
-0.0317435674,
-0.0080895768,
0.0006334885,
-0.0250177905,
0.0715622157,
-0.0210935827,
-0.0364373513,
-0.0071161287,
0.0471111648,
0.0709468797,
0.0704646483,
-0.0131119555,
0.0611926243,
0.0428103842,
0.0018480438,
-0.027353121,
0.0145645384,
-0.0015522169,
-0.0073816278,
-0.0225622319,
-0.0283911619,
-0.0312352683,
-0.0204957575,
0.0388977975,
0.0357153825,
-0.0134494836,
-0.0575002991,
0.0550368167,
-0.0398369506,
-0.0245890357,
0.0027254298,
-0.0337111726,
0.0105937496,
0.0092063388,
0.0398977362,
-0.0063927625,
0.0259642284,
-0.0030615798,
-0.0183120444,
0.038599126,
0.0122126816,
-0.0412373058,
-0.0712541044,
0.0508007705,
-0.0445965864,
0.0017752604,
-0.0016529928,
0.0346839838,
0.0296651796,
-0.037705183,
-0.0553493164,
0.0965126529,
-0.0353578851,
-0.0182783958,
-0.0106573049,
0.0444618911,
0.053277947,
0.0191522297,
-0.0601402819,
-0.0363403261,
-0.0061950861,
-0.0112091284,
0.0274534281,
-0.0368864313,
-0.003149132,
0.0356765911,
-0.0808874667,
-0.0387064442,
-0.0189845935,
0.0057595023,
-0.0113601368,
-0.0257698316,
0.0152261797,
-0.0207344405,
-0.0115701891,
0.0075686336,
0.0055542635,
0.0495396741,
-0.0096898321,
-0.0000195139,
0.0201083571,
0.0098335007,
0.034396328,
-0.0240422357,
-0.0398149565,
0.0301225185,
-0.0387563296,
0.0077912142,
0.0072606681,
-0.0335583724,
-0.0698935688,
0.0197464321,
-0.0427880511,
-0.0218618233,
0.014622285,
-0.0564445443,
0.0223493129,
0.0061720349,
0.000952096,
-0.0092117256,
-0.0090475371,
-0.0383847728,
0.0243840273,
0.0173150823,
-0.0189583506,
0.026071785,
-0.040677052,
-0.0022375872,
-0.0208777152,
0.0016104274,
0.0056318198,
0.0082768109,
-0.0631756708,
-0.0479111858,
-0.0054108859,
0.0300554391,
0.0139902616,
0.025287779,
-0.0333521366,
-0.0094983699,
-0.113205336,
-0.0519496016,
0.0133619187,
-0.0263257828,
0.0013459994,
-0.0169891678,
0.0276636034,
-0.0345652513,
-0.0341320485,
0.0462617166,
-0.0366539396,
0.0378515944,
0.0381830558,
0.0124390731,
0.0599131249,
-0.0309802368,
0.0177709591,
0.0191221796,
0.0426755659,
0.0001802723,
-0.017397631,
-0.021785913,
0.0312143937,
-0.0304457508,
0.0546641983,
-0.0109472871,
-0.0204438847,
-0.0011123064,
0.0003793402,
0.0257511772,
0.0412694737,
-0.0127348099,
0.06351877,
0.0251318607,
0.0061747255,
0.0078264046,
0.0218153,
-0.021690473,
0.0339227207,
-0.0052613704,
-0.0298082717,
-0.0207104012,
0.0242608357,
0.0032237391,
0.0167287495,
-0.0394128412,
0.0477853902,
0.0116309347,
-0.0400567576,
-0.0510147139,
0.0317643024,
0.0042689755,
0.0021995741,
-0.0195015315,
0.0184608325,
0.040885102,
0.0201126356,
-0.0003260017,
-0.033436086,
0.0200149957,
0.0077420576,
0.0403245278,
-0.0110345138,
0.0362281129,
0.0670026541,
0.029618483,
-0.045762904,
-0.0611125231,
0.0317498185,
-0.008802861,
-0.0018253096,
0.0004050895,
-0.0149236312,
0.0167442169,
-0.0411658138,
0.0069243861,
-0.0146905771,
-0.0110524558,
-0.0140347984,
-0.0206446182,
0.0115263239,
-0.0099930642,
-0.0407299772,
-0.0240887273,
-0.0117136957,
0.0040124063,
-0.030334847,
0.0335791893,
0.1173296496,
0.0722674876,
-0.013029227,
-0.0278048441,
-0.0482710004,
-0.0041927844,
0.0757817551,
-0.0268629305,
-0.0402245075,
-0.0486433022,
0.010610437,
0.0235258453,
0.0748551339,
-0.0122694541,
-0.0210384447,
0.0732395872,
-0.0183160827,
0.0232672766,
0.0799226835,
-0.0139574809,
-0.0669862032,
0.0010196164,
0.0665879175,
-0.0017705037,
0.0360584073,
-0.0393338837,
-0.037038371,
-0.0619984791,
-0.062597625,
0.0159352943,
0.0134215197,
0.0230963398,
-0.0063092802,
-0.0522419252,
0.0639926642,
-0.0222768746,
-0.0095263598,
-0.044050552,
-0.0448929481,
0.0076194601,
-0.0527858399,
0.0111432094,
-0.0499165878,
0.0293842014,
-0.0175056905,
0.0009039292,
0.0170541517,
-0.0730588362,
0.0067923451,
0.0042961924,
0.0114324782,
-0.0226203687,
0.0476825349,
-0.0341154933,
-0.0686883032,
0.015249162,
0.0175386928,
0.0020030418,
-0.0331546143,
0.0823458508,
-0.0369341746,
-0.0468768589,
-0.0081831757,
-0.0103967655,
0.0073003746,
-0.0055943243,
-0.010103439,
0.0340532921,
-0.0013496606,
0.0182549935,
-0.0789529681,
0.0259574205,
0.0432774127,
0.0187506508,
0.0077856164,
-0.112526089,
0.0238569602,
0.0111672897,
-0.0083515169,
-0.0331185609,
-0.0330617614,
-0.026135141,
-0.026286006,
-0.0500871427,
-0.091952987,
-0.0162933562,
-0.0085879853,
0.0348063186,
-0.0289264806,
0.0048804558,
0.0101505164,
0.0077537745,
-0.0442189425,
0.0218347311,
-0.0097835716,
-0.0050967271,
-0.0106607694,
-0.0089988038,
0.0247703753,
-0.035362348,
-0.0430092253,
0.007575057,
-0.0821897611,
-0.0232392438,
-0.0414309762,
0.0642034337,
-0.0026154323,
0.0198526476,
0.0438649692,
-0.0273024943,
0.0430776924,
0.0468405299,
-0.0025565028,
-0.0030164495,
0.0769443065,
0.000599322,
-0.0136039937,
0.0142670795,
-0.0030381056,
0.0769192427,
0.0269193184,
-0.0553080216,
-0.0422893912,
-0.0251753069,
-0.0177762993,
0.000957077,
0.068760097,
-0.0094177211,
-0.0402374379,
-0.0269550085,
0.0018232038,
0.0096607078,
-0.0442875698,
-0.0396803617,
-0.0019020367,
-0.0073341453,
-0.0140828937,
-0.033490032,
0.0161244459,
0.0139855426,
0.0515835546,
-0.0672847629,
0.0533317663,
0.0031232715,
0.0024918695,
-0.0216106884,
0.023695983,
0.0022862684,
0.0161946379,
0.0205338635,
0.0011661788,
0.0094435271,
0.0602537319,
0.0108599514,
0.0332812928,
-0.0210581049,
0.0341653116,
0.0119769229,
0.0907266736,
-0.0649033263,
-0.0023949924,
0.0118307397,
-0.0371291749,
0.0471281484,
-0.0133179706,
-0.0138955479,
-0.0193250123,
0.0196482465,
0.0076178615,
-0.0060792528,
0.0486494116,
-0.0149537977,
0.0330996066,
0.0134280445,
0.0814615041,
-0.0753839612,
0.0299135745,
0.031137336,
0.0205448754,
-0.0686077774,
-0.023904223,
0.055293262,
0.057783816,
0.0192598552,
0.083934173,
-0.0213231202,
-0.0447597727,
0.0025585464,
-0.0232656486,
0.0109277666,
0.0124118151,
0.03739205,
0.0335201174,
0.0355884023,
0.0415922999,
-0.0319691375,
-0.0404269174,
0.0037981975,
-0.0286919456,
0.0068762614,
-6.93639233e-33,
-0.0393143781,
-0.0108884983,
-0.0375768058,
0.0252102017,
0.0265178625,
0.0185213909,
-0.0236940049,
0.0298132543,
-0.0149483699,
0.0598768257,
0.0388645418,
-0.0015311836,
-0.0197990984,
0.0129874041,
0.006729905,
0.0463134088,
0.0522121452,
-0.0176974423,
0.0115220482,
0.0371993706,
0.0186933465,
0.0027609139,
0.0544269234,
-0.1043186858,
-0.0014894704,
0.0061232499,
-0.0784381106,
-0.0155703798,
0.0435645133,
0.0492666177,
-0.0513113476,
0.0749461874,
0.0353001468,
-0.002014135,
-0.0312738232,
-0.0153266564,
-0.0504935719,
-0.0244219005,
0.0232763793,
0.0063458011,
-0.0283847414,
-0.0248158984,
0.0424053818,
-0.0022322382,
-0.0130956089,
-0.038801454,
0.0522854589,
-0.0518687703,
0.0189762097,
-0.0727038905,
-0.0666286275,
0.0254916847,
-0.0287684482,
-0.0529967509,
0.0585339218,
0.025369741,
0.0321351476,
0.0129560409,
-0.0217999071,
0.0737791508,
-0.0395791866,
0.0255701132,
-0.0186469741,
-0.0278941635,
-0.0494578145,
0.0581398867,
-0.0241308082,
-0.0062301923,
-0.0021040353,
0.0144397346,
0.0367702581,
0.0632981881,
0.02325744,
0.0622059628,
0.025194373,
-0.0404198021,
-0.0528793484,
0.0455147587,
-0.0273137316,
0.0145058632,
0.0385472849,
0.005846201,
-0.0007747997,
-0.0028360949,
0.0159973223,
-0.0300545413,
-0.0398875587,
0.0300647225,
-0.0132731786,
0.0235595182,
-0.0611974858,
0.022203628,
-0.0047513382,
-0.0381456912,
0.0263984781,
0.0412365422,
-0.0304974932,
0.0400114693,
0.0168415401,
-0.0310054384,
-0.075413309,
-0.0279765762,
0.0311244186,
0.0081015164,
0.0232876539,
-0.0064724162,
0.0830554068,
0.0280291624,
-0.0711283609,
-0.0215833187,
0.0014280857,
0.0326443501,
-0.0004431471,
0.0573473424,
-0.0160547327,
-0.0350325182,
-0.064183794,
0.0461175144,
-0.0069883489,
0.0341544002,
-0.0172419492,
-0.0185101535,
0.0225541443,
0.0353236385,
-0.0270490497,
-0.0365782045,
0.0133911362,
-0.0717137456,
0.0018851204,
-0.0417232811,
-0.0296998862,
0.0119728046,
3.023e-7,
0.0029602586,
0.0714228153,
-0.0255916379,
-0.0067066425,
0.0268343017,
0.0729011968,
-0.0184151903,
0.0114309508,
-0.0020410561,
-0.0431762449,
0.0237951595,
0.0428885147,
-0.0027352865,
0.0156676639,
-0.0072505362,
0.0472335443,
0.0307126846,
-0.0222844053,
-0.0098553207,
0.0321360901,
0.0620257743,
0.0780422539,
0.0000297992,
-0.0403467901,
0.0070526451,
0.0588510111,
0.0454137884,
0.0023878312,
-0.0186714623,
-0.0253778752,
-0.020785952,
0.0086365538,
-0.0152608315,
-0.012712935,
-0.0055847988,
-0.0364865623,
0.0180292353,
0.0399762131,
-0.0007084481,
-0.0551046133,
0.0101100309,
0.0778216943,
-0.0143625466,
-0.0173933581,
0.0509989597,
-0.0093388138,
-0.029992342,
-0.103048712,
-0.0302476473,
0.0511035919,
0.0361287482,
0.0152787771,
-0.0563403554,
-0.0338091217,
0.0074460595,
-0.0355851464,
-0.0560147949,
-0.0795621946,
0.0108207194,
0.0353369638,
-0.0062896786,
-0.0475832857,
0.041892238,
-0.0630706623,
-0.0086614722,
-0.0471717902,
-0.0227631945,
2.351736472e-34,
0.0844698027,
-0.0568755791,
0.0325513743,
-0.0181246605,
-0.0227444898,
-0.0004403002,
-0.0612729304,
-0.0393980294,
0.0157375596,
-0.0071732183,
-0.0017999711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14602v2 | Generative Pre-trained Transformer for Vietnamese Community-based COVID-19 Question Answering | 2023-10-23T06:14:07 | 2023-10-31T09:15:51 | Tam Minh Vo, Khiem Vinh Tran | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have provided empirical evidence of the wide-ranging potential
of Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT), a pretrained language model, in
the field of natural language processing. GPT has been effectively employed as
a decoder within state-of-the-art (SOTA) question answering systems, yielding
exceptional performance across various tasks. However, the current research
landscape concerning GPT's application in Vietnamese remains limited. This
paper aims to address this gap by presenting an implementation of GPT-2 for
community-based question answering specifically focused on COVID-19 related
queries in Vietnamese. We introduce a novel approach by conducting a
comparative analysis of different Transformers vs SOTA models in the
community-based COVID-19 question answering dataset. The experimental findings
demonstrate that the GPT-2 models exhibit highly promising outcomes,
outperforming other SOTA models as well as previous community-based COVID-19
question answering models developed for Vietnamese. | [
0.0573429093,
0.0891133249,
-0.0153653203,
0.0129722375,
0.0044330456,
0.0019519547,
-0.0066238339,
0.0190349035,
0.0092947856,
-0.0086559476,
-0.0284175128,
-0.0229538921,
-0.0324478447,
0.012369616,
-0.0150142657,
-0.0537582003,
0.0335487649,
0.0198232736,
-0.0210061353,
-0.0074623949,
0.0042437376,
0.019116234,
0.0323280245,
0.0706904605,
0.0487170741,
-0.0155906221,
0.0086396895,
0.0048393314,
0.0370510295,
-0.0462910756,
0.0307607818,
0.0375859812,
-0.0039666407,
0.0288437512,
0.000001913,
-0.0295277238,
-0.0174885653,
0.003888845,
-0.0271738172,
-0.0059846262,
0.0283793025,
-0.0442442261,
0.0168078914,
0.0468067043,
-0.083343178,
-0.0794625878,
0.0360539965,
0.0379129238,
0.0894872844,
0.064234376,
-0.0105453571,
-0.0663153082,
0.0322202481,
-0.0151387537,
-0.0017806645,
-0.0263883751,
0.040317148,
0.0085457778,
0.0145682739,
-0.0012653437,
-0.035046529,
0.0571710169,
0.0337088183,
0.0019670147,
-0.0132288784,
0.0362430513,
-0.0548879132,
-0.0265239645,
0.0062905252,
0.0731092617,
-0.0137395449,
-0.0334795229,
0.0119922059,
0.0234824978,
-0.0025199859,
0.0323927812,
-0.034660995,
-0.0306524243,
-0.0025464979,
0.0232711881,
0.0485057794,
0.0289727207,
0.0147662461,
-0.0118068932,
-0.0358542949,
0.0214328561,
-0.0016203164,
-0.0123909377,
-0.039706666,
0.00238761,
-0.0479642302,
-0.0288257916,
0.0487730615,
0.0435767137,
-0.0110727297,
0.0171828978,
0.0003243082,
-0.0452120937,
0.0338176042,
-0.0386596136,
-0.0326391123,
0.0257319734,
-0.0387402549,
0.0230587199,
-0.0046820631,
0.0265948698,
-0.0588046573,
0.0557249747,
-0.0623053685,
-0.0469647273,
-0.0659474432,
-0.0419854894,
-0.0797738433,
0.0316967592,
-0.0113716545,
0.022156829,
-0.037536893,
0.0133514162,
0.0252551939,
-0.0485802852,
0.0500800461,
0.0414346717,
-0.040264219,
-0.0131958397,
-0.0070916805,
0.0779525414,
-0.0478331968,
0.0110581033,
0.0157141201,
-0.0948193818,
0.0000062696,
0.0034106628,
0.0315673538,
-0.0218281057,
0.0022500474,
-0.014390788,
-0.0320744887,
0.012735758,
0.0140345795,
0.0025488769,
-0.0056143473,
-0.0296823978,
-0.0121990414,
-0.0513401963,
0.0465093628,
0.0483191758,
0.0376301333,
-0.0301193893,
-0.0006895623,
0.0167678576,
-0.0371025279,
0.0666384771,
0.0100147966,
0.0353781991,
0.0559676476,
0.0312975571,
0.0515070073,
0.0232712626,
0.0010605772,
-0.0045710746,
0.026177099,
-0.0421276279,
0.0386751816,
0.0058892109,
0.019491883,
-0.0269475039,
0.0596330017,
0.06627547,
-0.0016989933,
0.0013121957,
0.007519702,
0.0607892461,
-0.0288556535,
-0.0205228887,
0.0156522915,
0.0220217705,
0.0082482202,
0.026288094,
0.0369855687,
0.0431647152,
-0.0020208771,
0.0043324046,
-0.002488873,
0.010222014,
-0.0390282944,
-0.0067001348,
-0.0056573446,
0.0525609627,
-0.0464128368,
-0.0429546684,
0.0156440865,
-0.0009234566,
-0.008694754,
0.0149400821,
0.02774271,
0.0181997493,
-0.0426766016,
0.0355761312,
0.0126667889,
-0.0267172623,
0.0181788635,
-0.0955393016,
-0.011323316,
0.0186713878,
0.0513451248,
-0.0032861554,
-0.0290773194,
-0.0096823471,
0.0050151735,
0.0200064518,
0.0193601251,
-0.0008448159,
-0.0089428024,
-0.0248856843,
0.0076551731,
0.0446273908,
0.0120040476,
0.0115767289,
0.0466672778,
0.0325674042,
0.0084829181,
-0.0252637919,
-0.000664202,
0.0100974441,
0.0053053861,
-0.0193746909,
0.0044191112,
-0.01514831,
0.0156646129,
0.0133800814,
0.0063334247,
0.0173327532,
0.0406972133,
-0.047374364,
-0.0156871285,
0.0113606974,
-0.0416787751,
-0.0713291019,
-0.0211897697,
-0.0597074367,
-0.0084716119,
0.1021280065,
-0.0322896577,
-0.016745301,
-0.0082567325,
0.0131090553,
0.0258306116,
-0.058780469,
-0.0102346372,
0.0007124933,
0.0345684402,
-0.0310774352,
0.0455377549,
-0.019525243,
-0.004209247,
0.0013681097,
-0.0159698594,
-0.0066909771,
-0.0293953512,
-0.0164967962,
0.0291156415,
-0.0219737962,
-0.0015000348,
-0.0017909054,
0.0129172467,
-0.0058256513,
-0.0349767655,
-0.0945299119,
-0.0134087792,
-0.036481522,
0.0235718209,
0.0455764905,
0.0276765078,
-0.0298955943,
-0.0336993821,
-0.0498087406,
0.0120100509,
0.0590305403,
0.0186579954,
0.0125605529,
-0.0088282945,
0.0237193108,
-0.0406300575,
-0.0252772905,
0.0023609186,
0.019997457,
-0.0075207171,
-0.0594212748,
-0.0211605746,
-0.027101703,
-0.022481095,
-0.0117489425,
-0.0000862716,
-0.0889591724,
0.0001527029,
-0.0183057282,
0.0363067463,
0.0006723841,
0.018141849,
0.0005549668,
-0.0035663894,
0.0136746429,
-0.0375188962,
0.0102615952,
-0.0791349411,
-0.0522573702,
-0.0447121114,
-0.029606944,
0.0052343211,
0.0867614895,
0.0207363348,
-0.0298457704,
-0.0581758656,
-0.0108139738,
-0.0324954353,
-0.0248417649,
-0.0288034827,
-0.0057728798,
-0.012988097,
0.0073262369,
-0.0096939187,
-0.017624259,
0.0470414944,
0.0350381695,
-0.0165899619,
-0.0718951225,
0.0115674101,
-0.0599797964,
0.0421883129,
0.0189613923,
0.0118787028,
0.0239742864,
-0.0493981615,
-0.0125010395,
0.0307424348,
-0.0070638815,
-0.0703639761,
0.0060708895,
0.0009635353,
-0.0071898438,
-0.0091510927,
-0.0296255723,
-0.0625675023,
-0.026109321,
-0.0358299837,
0.0027683422,
0.0573364496,
0.0379695557,
0.0088949455,
0.0349286757,
-0.0221346635,
0.013694685,
0.0208844002,
-0.0104246754,
-0.0131737804,
0.0872603953,
0.0611879304,
0.0423191413,
0.0022826542,
0.0273430254,
0.0569329709,
0.0581687614,
0.0411360487,
-0.0361542776,
0.0014469113,
0.0122302575,
0.0342833847,
-0.0188493859,
-0.0146978553,
0.0092048626,
0.0346552841,
-0.0504183695,
0.0005013214,
0.0988015011,
0.0361721255,
-0.0229078345,
-0.0080711627,
-0.0214208048,
0.016886618,
0.0127398819,
0.0673172325,
-0.0771233514,
-0.0184254106,
-0.0168919563,
-0.0051778522,
0.0179949328,
-0.0164955761,
0.0155139994,
-0.0711874515,
0.0487095602,
-0.0416768119,
-0.015603181,
-0.0084746322,
-0.0447151586,
-0.0202055313,
-0.0057435934,
-0.0129827093,
-0.0045913481,
0.0031953251,
0.0211141165,
0.0021470997,
-0.0529963225,
-0.0321568847,
0.0398628302,
0.0029893615,
0.0244944096,
0.0934230313,
0.0186506696,
0.0037213154,
-0.0363267176,
0.0019414357,
-0.0470204279,
0.0101800291,
-0.0113308178,
0.0540694669,
0.0047480506,
-0.0126272105,
-0.0164564438,
0.0245997664,
-0.060099408,
-0.0081677437,
0.0061187437,
0.1029774323,
-0.0041756066,
-0.0452248491,
-0.0036154953,
0.0260768328,
0.0053912164,
0.05622546,
0.0135465749,
-0.0114688808,
-0.0245252233,
0.0031867153,
0.026000293,
-0.0427626669,
-0.0814904422,
0.0166778378,
0.0399396047,
-0.0616576672,
-0.08622244,
-0.0387308225,
0.0331447683,
0.0059306617,
-0.0309315268,
-0.029386444,
0.0432174839,
0.0074216616,
-0.0305160005,
0.0176328346,
-0.0373056456,
-0.0175751559,
-0.0736881644,
-0.0325934365,
0.0409406424,
-0.0127456421,
-0.0211061351,
-0.0000480199,
-0.0800809637,
-0.0107343942,
0.0536291674,
0.0474512875,
0.0209205393,
-0.0129289003,
-0.0355029628,
-0.0113597065,
0.0311669316,
0.0572817139,
-0.0528494827,
-0.0182559863,
0.0066753118,
-0.0489676222,
-0.0117696235,
0.043428719,
0.0118177179,
0.0177399572,
0.008939174,
0.0470490828,
-0.0568440035,
-0.0124582667,
0.0416018814,
0.0037092844,
0.0506956242,
-0.0014333678,
0.0108079733,
-0.0504569747,
0.0024193898,
-0.0128114326,
0.0099305343,
-0.0083646923,
-0.0284684915,
0.062252257,
-0.0144170411,
-0.0333822668,
0.0432137065,
-0.0485459566,
0.0177705698,
-0.0303550102,
0.0140283192,
0.0338783897,
0.0199871175,
0.0162022728,
0.0107246563,
0.0164263882,
-0.0122939348,
0.0344581231,
0.0279013272,
-0.0058277845,
0.0642711595,
-0.0381721109,
-0.0057128244,
0.0083866119,
0.0347917862,
-0.0787052438,
-0.0388939269,
-0.034455888,
0.0206505079,
0.0251293331,
0.0274388343,
0.0320642292,
0.0079837907,
-0.0146168908,
-0.0214616526,
0.0060118414,
0.0096299201,
-0.0366356075,
0.0389776528,
-0.0055639516,
-0.0150871016,
-0.0093476493,
0.0967460722,
-0.0213857181,
0.0483449027,
0.0317766331,
-0.0224233996,
-0.0278058443,
-0.024877334,
-0.006444206,
-0.0034808437,
-0.049311582,
0.0281793494,
-0.0583854988,
-0.0497536734,
0.009367859,
-0.0223427713,
-0.0090525569,
0.0044547175,
0.0252960566,
0.03922363,
0.0164742935,
-0.0474892929,
-0.0528698191,
0.0459657647,
-0.0576249771,
0.0165390894,
0.0078400886,
-6.748143522e-33,
-0.0176921748,
0.0046455534,
0.0306731891,
-0.0434764177,
-0.0003100117,
-0.0055382191,
-0.0131708933,
0.0057544997,
-0.0518057905,
0.0008837187,
-0.0396181755,
0.0084844362,
0.0148136895,
0.0572984032,
0.0039857705,
-0.0550161488,
0.0255893059,
0.0045766323,
0.0025522984,
0.0266088713,
-0.0088177575,
0.0501924492,
0.0400299802,
-0.0202900991,
0.0063793757,
-0.0103473216,
0.0201257076,
-0.0005736197,
0.0099356659,
0.0547178797,
-0.047458943,
0.0575401522,
0.044369027,
-0.0458558463,
-0.0046353512,
0.0210387241,
-0.1340404004,
-0.0473911986,
0.0089478511,
0.0105403066,
-0.0547833703,
-0.0344088376,
0.008912106,
-0.0064790496,
0.025516063,
-0.003406276,
0.0235946104,
-0.0281761084,
0.0426331237,
-0.0532621294,
-0.0457192771,
0.0213632621,
0.004109934,
-0.0033766553,
-0.0451820306,
0.0817934647,
-0.0388443694,
0.0716162473,
-0.0588713624,
0.0013191458,
0.0500261225,
0.0275212601,
0.0430475436,
0.0004576172,
0.0020728805,
-0.0106925601,
-0.0013090638,
-0.0514406078,
-0.0645695403,
0.0127940858,
-0.0074933921,
0.0046498836,
0.030439727,
0.0695060343,
0.0585638583,
-0.0169962458,
-0.0787302256,
0.0437356234,
-0.0683581308,
0.0511582009,
0.007116843,
0.003790098,
-0.0003622916,
-0.0068348055,
-0.0039729946,
-0.0043897312,
-0.0194954704,
-0.044992201,
0.0334526896,
0.0257561021,
-0.0592796803,
0.0451538786,
0.0401128531,
-0.0590685681,
0.0087858476,
0.0064447364,
-0.0121897981,
-0.0097172465,
0.0017754304,
0.0760643259,
-0.0537993647,
0.0395334996,
0.0296207797,
-0.0008755487,
-0.0171406381,
0.0101196878,
0.0146618802,
0.0115434192,
-0.0746966004,
0.0033107102,
-0.0167198777,
0.0342299081,
-0.0405473486,
0.0215996634,
0.0118727656,
0.0543349087,
0.0021169838,
-0.0010003712,
0.0214603767,
0.0288652442,
-0.0498153009,
-0.0014159571,
-0.0077532632,
0.0279359054,
-0.020655822,
0.0454422049,
-0.0519870967,
0.0606123731,
-0.0155440969,
-0.0533818118,
-0.0185912121,
-0.0057299687,
2.593e-7,
0.1225736216,
0.0276143886,
0.0639843419,
-0.0029104073,
-0.0046925377,
-0.0248135775,
0.0377359092,
0.0274957307,
0.0495898798,
-0.0063302289,
0.0369471237,
0.0423678271,
0.0157440118,
0.0426887199,
-0.0723179132,
0.017127553,
-0.0608743243,
-0.005878584,
-0.0252755694,
-0.0406185612,
0.0721190423,
0.0957595631,
-0.0407867953,
-0.0049127708,
-0.0234593153,
0.0070164208,
0.0606424324,
-0.0135037247,
-0.0392594635,
0.0450500958,
0.0178806502,
0.006133826,
0.0283479616,
0.0017948013,
-0.0263088308,
-0.0297631156,
0.0325467512,
0.0511040986,
-0.0031334783,
-0.0323652439,
-0.0244702008,
-0.0278242324,
0.0018669039,
-0.0780550018,
0.1028068885,
-0.1001855507,
-0.0021213216,
0.048693575,
-0.0466656722,
0.0171442237,
0.0141688995,
-0.0389541015,
-0.0556438863,
0.0452237129,
0.0444216952,
0.004542443,
-0.0010835273,
-0.0399741679,
-0.0179884601,
-0.0383277647,
-0.0429904871,
-0.0422405675,
-0.0244206078,
-0.0233091395,
-0.0029569182,
0.0082316026,
0.017297022,
2.07377568e-34,
0.0299360156,
0.0423009358,
-0.0083287302,
-0.0053477539,
0.0293133222,
-0.0183817968,
-0.0016563624,
0.0150769493,
0.0114037888,
-0.0826605856,
-0.0184701998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14599v1 | Prefix-Tuning Based Unsupervised Text Style Transfer | 2023-10-23T06:13:08 | 2023-10-23T06:13:08 | Huiyu Mai, Wenhao Jiang, Zhihong Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Unsupervised text style transfer aims at training a generative model that can
alter the style of the input sentence while preserving its content without
using any parallel data. In this paper, we employ powerful pre-trained large
language models and present a new prefix-tuning-based method for unsupervised
text style transfer. We construct three different kinds of prefixes, i.e.,
\textit{shared prefix, style prefix}, and \textit{content prefix}, to encode
task-specific information, target style, and the content information of the
input sentence, respectively. Compared to embeddings used by previous works,
the proposed prefixes can provide richer information for the model.
Furthermore, we adopt a recursive way of using language models in the process
of style transfer. This strategy provides a more effective way for the
interactions between the input sentence and GPT-2, helps the model construct
more informative prefixes, and thus, helps improve the performance. Evaluations
on the well-known datasets show that our method outperforms the
state-of-the-art baselines. Results, analysis of ablation studies, and
subjective evaluations from humans are also provided for a deeper understanding
of the proposed method. | [
0.0085523725,
0.0648203418,
-0.0194994733,
0.0174735095,
-0.0361270159,
-0.0177051835,
-0.0156778991,
0.0365877338,
-0.0419421792,
-0.0228511617,
-0.0555498824,
-0.0162189957,
0.0006814204,
0.0081258342,
0.0496607646,
-0.0834674165,
-0.0012236871,
-0.0049399361,
-0.0065075806,
0.010186472,
0.0776367337,
0.0265454631,
0.0186774284,
0.0153224273,
-0.0266907457,
-0.02297372,
-0.0162201226,
0.0527084842,
0.0253386386,
0.0425169691,
0.0154127013,
0.0619080923,
0.0220540501,
-0.0088879429,
0.0000019189,
-0.0010922815,
-0.0324133411,
-0.0110509405,
0.0724143162,
0.048131898,
0.0635671169,
-0.010154956,
-0.0399155356,
-0.0053069252,
-0.0296566356,
-0.0059994943,
0.0765240639,
0.0682483464,
0.0998728052,
0.0932240561,
-0.0450546481,
-0.0358603075,
0.0043332675,
-0.0491410047,
0.0287647378,
-0.0233747605,
0.0332127213,
-0.0151986312,
-0.0366577879,
0.052225478,
-0.0232548025,
0.026647849,
-0.0111903753,
-0.0328825191,
0.026776256,
-0.0150428852,
-0.0395915657,
0.0649787635,
-0.0123039661,
0.0618901141,
-0.0489501618,
-0.0396636166,
0.0028912532,
-0.0025227747,
-0.0018305044,
-0.0117346467,
-0.0706766695,
-0.0398619398,
0.0349986702,
0.0386095271,
-0.0429877788,
0.0110554239,
0.0108336136,
-0.0332819447,
0.0257549118,
0.0060445676,
0.0441813953,
-0.0216760337,
-0.0275954884,
0.011338681,
-0.0117000528,
-0.0520125814,
0.0432251841,
-0.0182792675,
0.0423828587,
0.0026047865,
-0.1027422473,
-0.0670406893,
-0.0399318859,
-0.0190970786,
0.0947345048,
0.0083942208,
0.0205804538,
0.0191983599,
-0.0505142771,
0.0364427008,
-0.0149827655,
0.0218080692,
-0.0542685986,
-0.0005392859,
-0.0763578191,
-0.0228701085,
-0.049443692,
-0.0154490275,
-0.0115459496,
-0.0189147759,
-0.0082727112,
-0.0097200153,
0.0128825586,
-0.0662893429,
0.0250316523,
-0.0050353631,
-0.0473483764,
-0.0401697047,
0.0285154842,
-0.0076154778,
0.0110198669,
0.0365980528,
0.0123447562,
-0.0043298639,
-0.0393831953,
0.0362399742,
0.0550594069,
-0.028166838,
-0.0123930173,
0.0283723604,
-0.0647762343,
0.0026276691,
-0.0454604141,
0.0235695243,
0.0057638418,
0.0033303879,
0.0048079183,
-0.0548306555,
-0.0010257226,
-0.0384672023,
0.002810973,
-0.0570574477,
-0.0059891255,
0.0250791647,
-0.0452620424,
0.0542714521,
-0.0031243677,
0.0016348267,
0.0119163096,
-0.0069438848,
0.0405522324,
0.0370247401,
0.0461165085,
0.0857332423,
0.0085303765,
-0.0173159037,
-0.004862688,
0.0511077456,
0.0421289951,
0.0333103798,
-0.0246181991,
-0.0495525114,
0.0492625907,
0.018826481,
0.0670538619,
0.0628190786,
-0.0077212402,
-0.0034528484,
0.1265684217,
-0.0016848579,
0.0170500167,
0.053175915,
0.0592969097,
0.0292679947,
-0.0067538316,
0.011973979,
-0.0074944599,
-0.0148348864,
-0.0240385588,
0.0163791254,
0.0413543507,
0.0105140135,
-0.0340489596,
-0.0023975966,
0.0265801009,
-0.0012172413,
0.0115467235,
-0.0403966345,
0.0101441154,
0.0726299956,
-0.0668927655,
-0.0067489929,
0.0015069268,
-0.0514541678,
0.0018508846,
-0.0074990517,
-0.0291002095,
0.0865591317,
0.0353800431,
-0.0069816425,
0.0096545527,
0.0222454909,
0.0211751051,
0.0099872528,
0.0045070336,
-0.0078065223,
0.0446461067,
-0.0557342879,
0.004009238,
-0.0422342829,
-0.0115081668,
0.0321261026,
-0.0121882204,
0.0353317298,
0.0198085029,
-0.0126425251,
-0.0045381119,
0.0425717309,
-0.016485827,
-0.0780822337,
0.0144038005,
-0.0099021094,
-0.0190761201,
-0.0279824566,
-0.0362540483,
0.0027253595,
-0.0316099823,
-0.0592884757,
-0.016146889,
-0.0072283158,
-0.0705895722,
-0.0461973622,
-0.0308710113,
-0.0432963222,
0.0060847192,
0.037244752,
-0.0524054356,
-0.0632208884,
-0.0328409001,
-0.024537487,
0.0495678037,
-0.0357736163,
0.0065481518,
0.0059774616,
0.0056054094,
-0.0395275503,
-0.0053328611,
0.0147423847,
-0.0505902618,
-0.0294115953,
-0.0026274358,
-0.0095473882,
-0.0089190071,
-0.0189619549,
-0.0275722481,
0.0221163556,
0.0107880738,
-0.0025737688,
0.0295399223,
-0.0235030428,
-0.0125271417,
-0.0796368867,
0.0076667229,
-0.0223933812,
0.0228338074,
0.0354884639,
0.0326418951,
-0.019582713,
0.0034765953,
-0.0698360652,
0.007272447,
-0.0440855324,
0.0118701402,
0.0354148336,
-0.0154805845,
0.0210067313,
-0.050619062,
-0.0271478817,
0.0051220553,
0.0241682213,
0.0054931026,
-0.0219133161,
-0.0325158723,
0.028712865,
0.0067507708,
-0.0009454878,
0.0323619656,
-0.0808555484,
-0.0116783502,
-0.0384476148,
0.0924722254,
0.0858965293,
0.0401133522,
-0.0298170578,
0.0211622845,
-0.0096958736,
0.0065440647,
-0.0102963727,
-0.0282170642,
-0.006801534,
-0.0136964517,
-0.0307671614,
0.0503998026,
0.0469771102,
0.0411402397,
0.0009388138,
-0.0938636661,
0.0109582236,
0.0281894132,
-0.0335547067,
0.00725652,
-0.0027020075,
-0.0291257836,
0.0036918886,
-0.028869709,
-0.0306519587,
0.0131733185,
-0.0489551835,
0.0037007318,
0.0100868018,
0.0124533111,
-0.0098256571,
0.0464010462,
0.0081278468,
0.0241179261,
0.0243676808,
-0.0113833174,
-0.0367492214,
0.0052005914,
0.0541231818,
-0.0048984732,
-0.0078748642,
-0.0307253171,
-0.0100521948,
-0.0000656339,
-0.0298562963,
-0.0095830681,
-0.0394834951,
0.013178505,
0.006554455,
0.0828888491,
-0.028230371,
0.0149579467,
0.0185510553,
-0.0212908145,
0.068912521,
-0.0458790027,
0.0073329583,
-0.0330362655,
0.0514832214,
0.0409756787,
-0.0390009955,
-0.050829269,
-0.031364128,
-0.0265176669,
0.0356309973,
-0.0020455439,
-0.0009385427,
-0.0455345735,
0.0054718358,
0.0172714815,
-0.0229964331,
-0.0307368319,
-0.0033555843,
0.0696347877,
-0.0308885034,
-0.0083977571,
0.1045616493,
0.0285178404,
-0.0354033262,
-0.0316016264,
0.0265903082,
0.0339021794,
-0.0119511066,
0.029030811,
-0.0654332638,
-0.0373073146,
0.0090183755,
-0.0114088301,
0.0328607112,
-0.0046731676,
-0.0216658674,
-0.0805800483,
0.0015158609,
0.0311431922,
-0.0288856868,
-0.0118296938,
0.0090801157,
0.0396346785,
-0.0094385017,
-0.0319395848,
-0.0268613845,
-0.0109914523,
-0.0041038827,
0.0080645513,
-0.0230405219,
-0.0446455404,
-0.00906708,
-0.0000567284,
0.0195895527,
0.0704430193,
0.0375213511,
-0.0059164953,
-0.0344212912,
0.0183003284,
0.0055070692,
-0.0026395556,
-0.0059781736,
0.0622625612,
-0.0198007915,
0.0024814659,
-0.0237102713,
0.0321132988,
-0.0049615428,
0.0059506479,
0.0270837545,
0.0316474363,
0.0099247517,
-0.0332628638,
-0.0186917037,
-0.0303051602,
0.0313755013,
0.0449601673,
0.0550013594,
-0.0708369389,
-0.0339134522,
-0.0490679815,
0.0155145535,
-0.0682427213,
-0.0724655464,
-0.0398886912,
-0.0371796899,
0.0198704712,
-0.1251141578,
0.0116050364,
0.0085486611,
0.0539383553,
0.019960355,
-0.0088085039,
-0.0052563674,
0.0051032901,
-0.0246783867,
-0.0045624929,
-0.0187100843,
0.0072118221,
-0.0435189568,
-0.0384259894,
0.0224720966,
-0.0178052317,
0.0028785185,
0.015184083,
-0.0559391938,
-0.0420601517,
-0.0057521402,
0.0800746158,
0.0038551285,
0.0348548479,
-0.0371010154,
-0.076108329,
0.0391234905,
0.0366336294,
0.0392594114,
0.0039212527,
0.0544355139,
-0.0390100554,
0.0227689035,
0.0393992886,
-0.0030662175,
0.0560558252,
0.0580128171,
0.023269482,
0.0086018452,
-0.0240521692,
0.0217832699,
-0.0119204251,
0.0412792712,
0.0065234485,
0.0454582348,
-0.0226483904,
0.014208789,
-0.0406907611,
0.0110378601,
-0.0718645528,
-0.0006342421,
0.031626761,
0.0617036112,
-0.0250911117,
-0.0097029852,
0.0150255859,
-0.0095698861,
-0.0651382655,
-0.0161240231,
-0.0043559135,
0.0549121015,
-0.001023071,
0.0591206923,
0.002054289,
0.0081134988,
-0.0013054559,
0.0000613769,
-0.0257658307,
0.0114863561,
0.0379942767,
-0.0007834531,
-0.0192874912,
0.0603339262,
-0.0540801696,
0.0268815365,
-0.066323638,
-0.0211920533,
0.0345099829,
-0.0485682338,
0.0677828491,
-0.0054379767,
-0.0019367151,
-0.0234781131,
0.0592285991,
0.0125592723,
0.0134103438,
-0.0446724929,
0.0060084788,
0.0014991856,
-0.0112846363,
0.0695060566,
0.0250724144,
-0.0092694154,
0.0191812217,
-0.0152844032,
-0.0159231573,
-0.0040488397,
0.0510807112,
-0.0008768172,
0.0426692218,
-0.0050806818,
0.0218426511,
-0.0439798459,
0.0286726579,
-0.0140288826,
-0.0074469685,
0.0215808619,
0.0635049865,
0.0297684427,
-0.0380018093,
-0.0177287925,
-0.0196635816,
0.0201017093,
-0.0048372294,
-0.0269311722,
-0.0012340549,
-5.640338911e-33,
-0.0386138596,
0.0344399922,
-0.0358559713,
0.0485834666,
-0.0501232184,
-0.0125967599,
-0.0445441753,
-0.0225315765,
0.0405095518,
0.0375500582,
-0.035556335,
-0.019154558,
0.00660099,
0.0398932621,
0.004602456,
0.053093683,
0.0663062483,
0.0106805367,
-0.0318377614,
0.0442136787,
0.031783402,
0.0464393608,
0.0754026696,
-0.0661952049,
-0.040739771,
-0.0186116826,
-0.0213142447,
-0.0231211726,
0.0461916067,
0.0245179087,
0.0129863266,
0.0164978225,
-0.0052101295,
-0.0516992062,
-0.0514430255,
0.0412464216,
-0.0505760498,
-0.0588798746,
0.0097057773,
-0.0215756781,
-0.0366838574,
-0.0416566133,
0.0149344383,
-0.0288637206,
0.0234558843,
-0.0159492008,
0.0598689392,
-0.0392539576,
0.0082700057,
-0.0612766221,
-0.0666297749,
0.0081137856,
-0.0139573319,
-0.0237711109,
0.0387590155,
-0.0179324318,
-0.0005032262,
0.005020895,
-0.0248595681,
0.020884214,
0.0118075591,
0.056100361,
0.00372963,
0.0493274145,
0.0245700683,
0.0224769525,
-0.0530790575,
0.0649377257,
-0.0230894517,
0.0246977899,
0.0368795469,
0.033209376,
0.0389248878,
0.0439007357,
0.0055114236,
-0.0323325247,
-0.0106647536,
0.0391674377,
0.004179074,
-0.0194158573,
0.0082644559,
0.0653736815,
0.0051360372,
-0.0059319525,
-0.0371099189,
-0.0371377394,
0.0156050129,
-0.035216365,
0.0151461391,
-0.0022962056,
-0.0169171467,
0.0070612719,
0.0255031493,
0.0000174335,
-0.0084889773,
-0.0210823566,
-0.0678848699,
0.0428480171,
-0.0329351947,
0.0013637906,
-0.0327862948,
-0.0038904313,
0.0722003058,
0.0058101485,
0.0059224963,
-0.0295055509,
0.0474951528,
0.0465647615,
-0.0665183961,
-0.02841511,
-0.0016255141,
0.0114760511,
0.0048131286,
-0.0212452449,
-0.0005901861,
0.0013840814,
-0.0160408635,
0.049150642,
0.0454283878,
-0.0027991456,
-0.0090292329,
-0.0474911258,
0.0119562214,
-0.0086620878,
-0.0432135537,
-0.0045110988,
-0.0341075435,
-0.0229567271,
0.0114424434,
-0.0556392036,
-0.0310356691,
0.0022775966,
2.508e-7,
0.0295961741,
0.0444262959,
0.0177072845,
0.00832133,
0.0260272026,
0.0160963237,
-0.0022561108,
0.0679657459,
0.0113797365,
-0.0015802002,
0.0373413898,
0.033530239,
0.0700289384,
-0.0379191004,
-0.0896056518,
0.0284229852,
-0.0508993939,
0.0316364914,
-0.0376868658,
-0.0204615071,
0.0545887239,
0.0496460162,
0.0310620163,
0.0032638947,
0.0455160849,
0.0195987243,
0.0828362033,
-0.0317897014,
0.0040108929,
0.02665806,
0.0113515705,
-0.0372805484,
-0.0464477204,
0.0145821273,
-0.0175757743,
-0.021845717,
0.0624477156,
0.0809760317,
-0.0169827323,
0.0230771992,
-0.0060452358,
0.0203626342,
0.0135245668,
-0.0355425775,
0.0802458152,
0.0022040089,
-0.0254751891,
-0.0522481613,
-0.0322445109,
0.0144913374,
0.0079902466,
-0.0075181765,
-0.0467317365,
0.0256389454,
0.0334838182,
0.0439352207,
-0.0336046927,
-0.0918266103,
-0.0170004573,
-0.0130056525,
-0.034062203,
-0.0192939844,
-0.0671764165,
0.0121184662,
0.0001303262,
-0.0062382505,
0.0103051253,
2.168504454e-34,
-0.0022159629,
-0.0137360385,
0.0367595516,
-0.0128869554,
0.026742924,
0.0106479023,
0.0219490137,
0.0232507903,
0.0276058968,
-0.098486267,
-0.0188605729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14596v1 | Learning to Correct Noisy Labels for Fine-Grained Entity Typing via Co-Prediction Prompt Tuning | 2023-10-23T06:04:07 | 2023-10-23T06:04:07 | Minghao Tang, Yongquan He, Yongxiu Xu, Hongbo Xu, Wenyuan Zhang, Yang Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fine-grained entity typing (FET) is an essential task in natural language
processing that aims to assign semantic types to entities in text. However, FET
poses a major challenge known as the noise labeling problem, whereby current
methods rely on estimating noise distribution to identify noisy labels but are
confused by diverse noise distribution deviation. To address this limitation,
we introduce Co-Prediction Prompt Tuning for noise correction in FET, which
leverages multiple prediction results to identify and correct noisy labels.
Specifically, we integrate prediction results to recall labeled labels and
utilize a differentiated margin to identify inaccurate labels. Moreover, we
design an optimization objective concerning divergent co-predictions during
fine-tuning, ensuring that the model captures sufficient information and
maintains robustness in noise identification. Experimental results on three
widely-used FET datasets demonstrate that our noise correction approach
significantly enhances the quality of various types of training samples,
including those annotated using distant supervision, ChatGPT, and
crowdsourcing. | [
0.0557276383,
0.0234999973,
0.0226194486,
0.0242840797,
0.0369308181,
0.0275603328,
-0.0106727667,
-0.0073770313,
0.0223078672,
-0.0626424327,
-0.0624739565,
-0.0079401638,
0.010509152,
-0.009862409,
0.0587662384,
-0.0368870944,
0.0600278638,
-0.0124731921,
0.042546507,
-0.0099002412,
0.0043257554,
-0.0143393073,
0.004771316,
0.017648302,
-0.029976299,
-0.0174440388,
0.0304009337,
0.0127953179,
-0.0007701747,
-0.0313022882,
0.081421569,
0.0887602046,
-0.0205858834,
0.0529411845,
0.0000018566,
-0.0439942107,
-0.0062210979,
0.023082599,
-0.0210761596,
0.0103663402,
-0.0414582416,
0.0047669434,
0.0058299121,
-0.0070063588,
0.03004032,
-0.0486623049,
0.0584492683,
0.0657219812,
0.0313695036,
0.0589510053,
0.006030818,
-0.0120205814,
0.0069969152,
-0.0266472753,
0.0465558097,
-0.0473839268,
0.0285168663,
-0.0465740077,
-0.0486109145,
0.0545380488,
0.0095603596,
0.0042672032,
-0.0352586582,
0.0168041904,
0.0526557527,
0.0189664625,
-0.0292086471,
-0.0188849717,
-0.013923455,
0.053061258,
0.0369155332,
-0.0130461846,
0.0161648337,
0.0009977871,
0.0153202796,
-0.0248148497,
0.0185547452,
-0.0469052531,
-0.0461585671,
-0.0144978669,
-0.0076247947,
-0.007843839,
0.0331608653,
0.0075470814,
0.0174147207,
0.0129621523,
-0.0050994465,
-0.070165284,
0.0223949179,
0.0242526345,
-0.0188473836,
-0.0531055816,
0.0244397614,
0.0141015993,
-0.0819910616,
-0.0041602864,
-0.0328841172,
-0.044623293,
0.0208412521,
-0.0123933954,
-0.0247292556,
-0.0147944354,
-0.0471426807,
0.0625657141,
-0.0027617826,
-0.013303373,
0.0446505211,
0.0174779054,
0.0185203776,
-0.0147921639,
-0.0280490462,
0.0211765729,
-0.05541531,
0.0438025445,
0.0245763343,
0.030697383,
-0.074673824,
-0.0209647715,
-0.0423219539,
0.0457161404,
0.0187432617,
-0.0099796737,
-0.0489942878,
-0.0219919942,
-0.0201828033,
0.0133329993,
-0.0362603702,
0.008539171,
-0.0037358098,
-0.0232676193,
-0.0184397697,
-0.0127321864,
0.0031792116,
-0.0448254496,
0.0393492691,
0.0723072588,
0.0252056792,
-0.0391804203,
-0.0891145095,
-0.0367666259,
-0.0307453014,
-0.0141910501,
-0.0432455093,
-0.0267861541,
-0.0196926761,
-0.0165329035,
0.0152335204,
-0.0464840718,
0.0034182905,
-0.0244719703,
-0.0806027651,
0.112350896,
-0.0756878778,
-0.0156271644,
0.0330789648,
-0.0177504774,
-0.0332014002,
0.0387614891,
0.0425215065,
-0.0016556672,
0.0548666641,
-0.0180575475,
0.0029652917,
0.0423374213,
0.0264138132,
-0.0122830449,
0.0341534466,
-0.0028147716,
0.0039749392,
0.0344028212,
0.0076820222,
0.040401753,
-0.0082253665,
-0.0149528477,
0.0589038059,
0.0023762253,
0.0124677736,
-0.014590892,
0.0204912964,
-0.0143156685,
-0.0027459657,
0.0100792861,
-0.065401502,
-0.0059363628,
-0.0815799311,
0.0074251592,
0.0755838156,
0.0312349312,
-0.0293382052,
-0.045353882,
-0.0188814718,
-0.0132905468,
-0.0484051555,
0.0023746607,
0.0314408988,
0.0355219766,
-0.0467145517,
0.0236946177,
0.0423477702,
0.0074950801,
0.0008641912,
-0.01884179,
0.0432907678,
0.0445048399,
0.0052111074,
-0.0734078437,
-0.0404662751,
-0.0521959774,
0.0034955135,
0.0096358778,
0.0618483126,
-0.0189974178,
-0.0032352204,
-0.026434252,
-0.0389575735,
0.0653752387,
0.0316390395,
0.0033137219,
0.0271699056,
0.0110376179,
0.0146578131,
-0.0715229586,
-0.0354393236,
0.0351835303,
0.0229435153,
-0.0632966608,
0.0071113463,
0.0359901488,
-0.0025632586,
0.018466115,
-0.0089523681,
-0.006598975,
-0.0323252641,
0.0168516431,
0.0043264977,
-0.0361489877,
0.0198915266,
0.0159596615,
0.0271309521,
-0.00862341,
-0.0725085139,
-0.0415164568,
-0.0372702964,
-0.029881401,
-0.0312703773,
-0.0029511207,
-0.021032149,
-0.0452888794,
-0.008828924,
0.0258702878,
-0.0034684292,
-0.0343079269,
0.0783695057,
0.0242853332,
0.0284573603,
-0.0043888562,
0.0044133011,
0.0034232819,
-0.0059785172,
-0.0367289484,
-0.0260856338,
0.0031620034,
0.0228601396,
0.04756267,
0.007582095,
-0.0820791125,
-0.0502307341,
-0.0339441672,
0.013458482,
-0.0152464891,
0.019307632,
-0.0230111796,
-0.0012278692,
-0.0133507168,
-0.0250045229,
-0.0187923945,
-0.0094052255,
-0.0470054224,
0.0395929962,
0.0358410589,
-0.0140696177,
0.0100785298,
-0.0262858234,
0.0195206068,
-0.0310964305,
0.0102279242,
0.025618067,
-0.0682583153,
-0.0940966904,
0.0452035591,
-0.0226380825,
0.0281646885,
0.036670655,
0.0067100404,
-0.0026570789,
0.0396370292,
0.0238944534,
0.0233671423,
-0.0170600358,
0.0269199219,
-0.0286713652,
0.0140974307,
-0.0317183323,
0.0300711486,
-0.0220454559,
-0.020033991,
-0.0010044581,
-0.0151174599,
0.0117248744,
0.0829977468,
-0.0339001529,
-0.0273004211,
-0.0860313848,
0.0151247242,
-0.0093698353,
0.0068607857,
-0.0408693403,
0.032731384,
0.0049164016,
0.0135741932,
-0.0228707567,
-0.0065430366,
0.0918673277,
-0.0049740085,
0.0136634354,
0.0134446044,
-0.0034954569,
-0.0094934804,
0.0059000924,
0.007557726,
-0.0038838263,
0.0625773966,
-0.0474652499,
-0.0492622592,
0.0101312874,
0.0693501085,
-0.0246051978,
0.0086480873,
0.0028791293,
0.0199814439,
0.0123017831,
-0.0419500582,
-0.0251716003,
-0.0392656364,
-0.0387963094,
0.0175277758,
-0.0000347246,
-0.0321572684,
-0.0132223852,
0.0059133773,
-0.0126700429,
0.0240086187,
-0.0049003847,
-0.0329335704,
-0.0217274912,
0.0121470829,
0.0254074112,
0.0306336805,
0.0272012502,
-0.0258489065,
-0.0180851407,
0.0124069853,
0.0006632718,
-0.0068009854,
-0.0046468247,
-0.0125069693,
0.0282586161,
-0.0404267907,
-0.0594264939,
0.0292243902,
0.072046265,
-0.0370734893,
-0.0083505753,
0.1024699435,
0.005286512,
-0.0233927425,
0.0053961072,
0.0333178118,
0.0697774962,
0.0310801808,
0.0367471315,
-0.0478762537,
-0.0657158941,
0.0152116865,
0.0418290906,
0.0045764446,
-0.0563278012,
0.0197838284,
-0.0952636003,
0.0340039507,
0.0032549049,
-0.0433004238,
-0.0453623012,
-0.0433708318,
0.0448611826,
-0.0335045755,
0.0312703848,
-0.0307083689,
0.0073396442,
0.0249148943,
0.0598383397,
-0.0377875455,
-0.0729398429,
-0.008656756,
-0.0434524566,
0.1046984717,
0.0388746336,
-0.0041663856,
-0.0295185857,
-0.0255222507,
0.0185850617,
-0.0195651427,
-0.0178916007,
0.0056862351,
0.0797792822,
-0.0409161858,
-0.0390889868,
-0.0000053711,
0.0193486381,
-0.0174669251,
-0.0061239824,
0.0148399947,
0.0339477099,
0.015194553,
-0.0049368301,
0.0288701076,
-0.002606119,
0.0595744774,
0.0785801634,
0.0303924363,
-0.0346050002,
-0.0098314006,
-0.0446899682,
0.0128024593,
-0.0240225326,
0.0263684634,
0.0465357266,
-0.0543973856,
-0.0666462108,
-0.0457156897,
-0.0760930479,
0.0531918891,
-0.0296723563,
0.0235007238,
0.0312381443,
0.0188367963,
0.0210106131,
-0.0252836924,
0.0313182361,
-0.0257143937,
0.0178752914,
-0.0494958572,
-0.0385698117,
0.0232215449,
0.0012080738,
-0.0374355614,
0.0321634524,
-0.0922175124,
-0.0687813684,
0.0253618564,
0.0178980455,
0.0069736447,
0.0489437319,
-0.0151804192,
-0.0827686191,
0.0338264853,
0.1103446484,
-0.0428722724,
-0.0073820958,
0.0319857113,
-0.0054049683,
-0.0337191038,
0.0240821224,
-0.0575103238,
0.0216489471,
0.0452027209,
0.0175828245,
-0.0330910273,
-0.0712482929,
0.0070878477,
0.0336059183,
0.0944639146,
-0.0260572713,
-0.0031865586,
-0.046094466,
0.0016120892,
0.0676901788,
-0.0222422592,
0.0067326212,
-0.0470535681,
-0.0136355031,
-0.0466681309,
-0.0336312279,
0.0396181345,
0.010015687,
0.0561138391,
-0.0676171109,
-0.0244648755,
-0.002677927,
0.0336653143,
0.0101556974,
-0.0213423297,
0.0124538653,
0.061629869,
0.0666877702,
0.0513660945,
0.0012330732,
-0.0168859828,
0.0458953381,
0.0565377325,
-0.0020383392,
-0.0157836527,
-0.0251285527,
-0.0327021107,
-0.0366649516,
0.0783198774,
0.0187251158,
-0.0042185467,
0.0085156076,
-0.038014818,
-0.0253468715,
0.0118914535,
0.0462103412,
0.0089635896,
0.038557183,
0.0190920178,
0.0126017528,
-0.0228646472,
-0.0132006807,
0.0812866762,
-0.0193287395,
0.0755811408,
0.0056105633,
-0.0086889081,
-0.0417592749,
0.0074684951,
0.0217172224,
-0.0069580064,
0.0005933647,
0.0157144405,
-0.0352676027,
-0.0677775219,
0.0232926961,
0.0007190904,
-0.0111393118,
0.0184143614,
0.0192048792,
0.026756756,
-0.0044932482,
0.0014985047,
-0.015135779,
-0.0421431437,
0.0650670156,
-0.0293141492,
-0.0027771292,
-6.756306596e-33,
-0.0439700522,
-0.0292347483,
-0.0091966083,
-0.005973239,
0.0001809427,
0.0014563561,
0.0220651571,
0.0088496879,
-0.001219327,
0.0388597809,
-0.0415341705,
0.018973479,
0.0183878448,
-0.0022564931,
0.0282983445,
-0.0432966091,
0.0624414459,
-0.0038921873,
-0.0005536493,
0.0061353277,
-0.0099392524,
0.0412424952,
0.0848483071,
-0.0890983045,
0.0774750337,
0.0263816044,
-0.0440199375,
0.0167934299,
0.0211946405,
0.0544773303,
0.0070235147,
0.0543274879,
0.0037301849,
-0.0292792954,
-0.0030124669,
0.0008266813,
-0.1041261703,
-0.0287853479,
-0.0343741998,
0.0168549418,
-0.0219272748,
-0.0224479716,
0.0487314425,
-0.0133039746,
-0.0219630972,
-0.0312430896,
0.0521174669,
-0.0129502015,
-0.0151344622,
-0.0384151228,
-0.0360104479,
0.0376218297,
-0.0245005097,
-0.0068008122,
0.0252094008,
-0.0101497089,
0.001069081,
0.0094867237,
-0.065610081,
0.0015588129,
0.0152918603,
0.0277858954,
-0.0424232967,
0.0283726882,
-0.0504091196,
0.0334758051,
0.0235167369,
0.0530871414,
-0.0082119368,
-0.0384425819,
0.01580883,
0.0059381421,
0.0205875468,
0.0622693934,
0.0557032563,
-0.0225257911,
-0.0395006463,
0.0384984426,
-0.0280195028,
-0.0211766232,
-0.0191890951,
-0.0485998541,
-0.0428325199,
-0.0253944471,
-0.0338502564,
0.0022021176,
-0.0524034388,
0.0350374505,
-0.014553111,
-0.0142074144,
-0.0297024418,
-0.0020395429,
-0.0152233243,
-0.0309549496,
-0.0204465464,
-0.0421777517,
0.0218636412,
-0.0024876951,
-0.0129072359,
0.0012540149,
-0.0247768629,
-0.0624342784,
0.0085246824,
0.0144764278,
0.0338145867,
0.0152387014,
0.0914917514,
-0.0006241553,
-0.0764960051,
0.0231642071,
0.0160792954,
0.035762012,
-0.0079332134,
-0.0258493163,
0.0276385676,
-0.0107095912,
0.0132832732,
0.0077582835,
0.0682569295,
0.0306233056,
0.0175927412,
0.0520098619,
-0.0192708615,
0.0149728414,
-0.0037330864,
0.0037142204,
0.0097414078,
-0.0370581709,
0.0256913397,
-0.0178444088,
0.0049676462,
-0.0307926908,
2.679e-7,
0.0269347429,
0.0889935642,
0.0003237686,
0.0187803153,
-0.0176312383,
0.080505468,
0.0459857993,
0.041971527,
0.0114224739,
-0.0627434105,
0.0373375937,
-0.0274208337,
0.0387896448,
0.0242798552,
-0.0717905834,
-0.0507327542,
-0.0316676982,
0.0706662014,
-0.0276400615,
0.0147783794,
0.0417469516,
0.0667589605,
0.028258957,
-0.0244115889,
0.0017009622,
-0.0300426688,
0.0469245352,
-0.0313699543,
0.0048680259,
0.0675187111,
0.0428873785,
0.0076442496,
0.0116598057,
0.0474396609,
-0.0247444455,
-0.0452400446,
0.0297825728,
0.0145099908,
-0.0165802538,
0.0447579361,
-0.0413452797,
0.0344327986,
-0.0045160577,
0.0018149473,
0.0368512273,
-0.0558469854,
-0.0100276656,
-0.0242174249,
-0.0027882527,
-0.0285907071,
0.0244295169,
-0.0295802597,
-0.0147954607,
0.0028926129,
0.0204567574,
0.0353421941,
-0.0273296181,
-0.0522655658,
-0.0029693928,
0.0140296295,
-0.0005459865,
-0.0412129536,
0.0358234346,
-0.0367269814,
0.0070309234,
-0.0756605119,
0.0094429739,
2.371710463e-34,
0.0460730419,
-0.0090986565,
0.0335726663,
-0.0052562961,
0.0278378911,
0.004513396,
-0.0211558919,
-0.0062280386,
0.0225889217,
-0.012566288,
0.0003480287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14587v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14587v2 | Large Search Model: Redefining Search Stack in the Era of LLMs | 2023-10-23T05:52:09 | 2024-01-02T07:22:04 | Liang Wang, Nan Yang, Xiaolong Huang, Linjun Yang, Rangan Majumder, Furu Wei | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Modern search engines are built on a stack of different components, including
query understanding, retrieval, multi-stage ranking, and question answering,
among others. These components are often optimized and deployed independently.
In this paper, we introduce a novel conceptual framework called large search
model, which redefines the conventional search stack by unifying search tasks
with one large language model (LLM). All tasks are formulated as autoregressive
text generation problems, allowing for the customization of tasks through the
use of natural language prompts. This proposed framework capitalizes on the
strong language understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs, offering the
potential to enhance search result quality while simultaneously simplifying the
existing cumbersome search stack. To substantiate the feasibility of this
framework, we present a series of proof-of-concept experiments and discuss the
potential challenges associated with implementing this approach within
real-world search systems. | [
0.0734844059,
0.0212660041,
-0.0179785285,
0.0044587632,
-0.0345608443,
-0.0269217901,
0.0206932873,
0.0180118103,
0.0128794666,
-0.0608480461,
-0.00262302,
-0.0228142999,
-0.045056399,
0.0493922159,
0.0092809461,
-0.0514536649,
0.0398225076,
-0.0302725006,
0.0002106747,
-0.0002691687,
0.0216029603,
0.016712511,
0.0302278344,
0.0240706,
0.0357567184,
-0.0174325649,
-0.0285763443,
0.018742878,
-0.0173257664,
-0.037855994,
-0.0002236686,
0.0259440783,
0.0378735699,
0.048677016,
0.00000185,
-0.0728728548,
-0.0039378088,
-0.024102373,
-0.0341215506,
0.0031763613,
0.0080800755,
0.0572686382,
0.0322245434,
0.0399428792,
-0.0439966954,
0.0179210678,
-0.0066304938,
0.0239867009,
0.0716908798,
0.0645129159,
0.0283948407,
-0.0164065473,
-0.027698921,
-0.0130568603,
0.054473836,
-0.0419179276,
-0.0038335277,
-0.0094103934,
0.0958254188,
0.0579928048,
0.0291062258,
0.0411884822,
-0.0038776982,
-0.0527955368,
0.0445105433,
0.0212524962,
-0.0112696625,
-0.0191559177,
-0.0110628475,
0.0477109961,
-0.007347187,
-0.025682386,
0.016249381,
0.0113255605,
-0.0044587431,
0.0198789742,
-0.0450369641,
0.0474771596,
-0.0125577236,
-0.018644603,
0.0098183611,
-0.0054019145,
0.0198368989,
0.0375615507,
-0.0256404243,
0.093398571,
0.011910799,
-0.040735729,
0.0004240132,
-0.0212691464,
0.0396777429,
-0.0478783883,
0.0424670912,
0.074405238,
-0.1006091088,
0.0157273747,
0.0015290551,
-0.005028388,
0.0453211777,
-0.0260269959,
0.0059059798,
-0.0040599927,
-0.0038420099,
0.053390529,
-0.0239712726,
0.0555835143,
-0.0083427699,
-0.0577288307,
-0.0680399016,
-0.0263674129,
-0.0425053984,
-0.0572887883,
-0.0442416668,
0.0304081868,
-0.0405028872,
-0.0125899948,
-0.0223188009,
0.0494341552,
0.0337035656,
0.0113926595,
0.0168120265,
0.0370353684,
-0.0533116162,
-0.0174477063,
-0.0523075536,
-0.0087403702,
-0.0201315414,
-0.0114012938,
0.0336377248,
-0.0443816818,
0.0156424176,
0.0543599986,
0.0187205076,
-0.0047061611,
-0.0054361471,
0.0223004073,
0.0016455033,
0.0098367324,
-0.03917519,
-0.0789223388,
0.0022825026,
-0.0250117816,
-0.0274764299,
-0.0571046732,
0.0092737004,
-0.0033609301,
-0.0219463594,
0.0186032187,
0.0176201072,
0.0499831252,
0.0027203774,
0.0489562377,
-0.012561013,
0.023307696,
0.0603258461,
0.0050363862,
0.0448695049,
0.0335294306,
-0.0044504711,
0.0665150061,
0.0500654727,
0.0296938457,
0.0243127849,
0.0149660874,
-0.0133652641,
0.0084462278,
-0.0093869157,
0.0309361108,
-0.023265738,
0.0520899147,
-0.0118137477,
0.0451510325,
0.0169969108,
0.0486808978,
0.0361328721,
0.0310670231,
0.0241924692,
0.0010002417,
0.0694611371,
0.0255389623,
-0.002770901,
-0.0296607781,
-0.0112801362,
0.0318252333,
-0.030608179,
0.0029000947,
0.0247278381,
0.0080249216,
-0.0344868973,
-0.0435384475,
0.0008398994,
0.0411648601,
-0.0313598812,
0.0172507223,
0.0170487501,
0.004594645,
-0.0299003236,
-0.0110333776,
-0.0269994922,
-0.0270347558,
0.0657998174,
-0.0639443174,
0.030830849,
0.0927711427,
0.0805529952,
-0.0249274895,
-0.000579817,
0.0057254056,
0.0140859047,
0.0543891415,
0.0183295403,
0.0021365364,
-0.0429294519,
-0.0469317175,
-0.0753995106,
0.0064943479,
-0.0046460205,
-0.0127897291,
0.0061345175,
0.0156382658,
0.0577584393,
-0.0336450525,
-0.040252693,
0.0162728187,
-0.0297870617,
-0.0257532205,
0.0037744248,
0.0001208329,
-0.0217996724,
0.0342914574,
0.0018337788,
0.0313418992,
0.0197612662,
-0.0210175682,
-0.064796187,
-0.0136801125,
-0.0321170278,
0.001808361,
0.0010883159,
-0.0465814322,
0.0285376552,
0.0137354052,
-0.0216324497,
-0.0660405159,
-0.0498445705,
-0.0722013935,
0.0130145075,
-0.0421330333,
0.0114325806,
0.0088256858,
-0.0254523084,
-0.079907313,
0.0776202828,
0.0338730514,
0.0015931901,
0.0349251926,
0.0284723174,
0.0026069025,
-0.0972683653,
-0.031566292,
0.0091717709,
0.011622211,
0.0102750743,
0.083944276,
0.0466969088,
-0.0593543537,
-0.0115937004,
-0.0719592869,
0.0249967761,
-0.0281588882,
0.0111870999,
0.0209762491,
0.0316355526,
0.002478976,
-0.0242215246,
-0.0828465745,
-0.0268858336,
0.0688204691,
0.0078791147,
0.0485741794,
0.0367969982,
-0.0159555189,
-0.0071363985,
-0.005383586,
0.0023191508,
0.0110067166,
0.0538682118,
-0.0157921091,
-0.0950799361,
0.0594948567,
-0.0654188991,
-0.0128668444,
0.0171586275,
0.0067092017,
0.0070209778,
-0.0358604901,
0.0295755528,
0.0349887684,
0.051659815,
0.0042148214,
0.0247307867,
-0.0113303456,
-0.0545932241,
-0.0008737177,
-0.0425528064,
-0.0048954822,
0.0338042602,
-0.0459966771,
0.040931195,
-0.0027497062,
-0.0109129511,
-0.002582663,
-0.0358158723,
0.0283378791,
-0.0025303192,
0.0003291449,
-0.060806118,
-0.0101618608,
0.0005381686,
0.0611248091,
-0.0201581717,
-0.0609338433,
0.0671348572,
0.0038951405,
0.0198389571,
-0.0526526719,
-0.02769248,
-0.0609492362,
0.0491025709,
-0.0048681856,
0.0364558026,
0.0037726348,
-0.033730574,
-0.0387187786,
0.0332102589,
0.0232456457,
-0.066156745,
0.0318341702,
-0.0501552746,
0.0064747762,
0.0369771197,
-0.0525553823,
-0.0504599735,
-0.0498752184,
-0.0033768441,
0.0117981415,
0.0159218144,
-0.018456649,
-0.0660658702,
0.0106940642,
0.0440611914,
0.0139398389,
-0.0209396873,
-0.0337348767,
-0.0208356585,
0.0306953378,
0.0643349886,
0.0129463207,
0.0171730146,
-0.0099951532,
0.0474917255,
0.0217599291,
0.0626374409,
-0.0191917755,
0.0136083271,
-0.025648471,
0.0488439463,
-0.0510319024,
-0.036694508,
0.0314286761,
0.0011647209,
-0.0304741338,
-0.034738645,
0.0805900767,
0.0530431755,
-0.0388381332,
-0.0154203046,
-0.0338023491,
0.0259390771,
0.0431909934,
0.0856225044,
-0.0467245094,
-0.0127874156,
0.0351175927,
0.0482089929,
-0.020830296,
-0.0237192828,
-0.0413850471,
-0.1152775884,
0.0356399827,
-0.0209062621,
-0.0093779499,
0.0176164974,
-0.0636232421,
-0.0306232683,
0.0171810891,
-0.0088399695,
0.0507370904,
-0.0285719112,
-0.0004058135,
0.0324623398,
-0.0023668243,
-0.0264019277,
0.0006696188,
-0.0262062717,
0.0025550234,
0.0799437389,
0.0143166194,
0.0279762521,
-0.0069423434,
0.0191275291,
-0.0117243351,
0.0570097491,
-0.0431607291,
-0.0074926848,
-0.0019352675,
-0.001406766,
-0.060783349,
0.0130184209,
-0.0158213433,
0.0258572847,
0.0440871939,
0.0707310587,
-0.0446308479,
0.0007968259,
-0.0425653271,
-0.0111763934,
0.0027333223,
0.0799462572,
-0.0059008803,
-0.0244133193,
-0.0468744114,
-0.0418854281,
0.0123142097,
-0.0146840662,
-0.0308272913,
0.0054649157,
-0.0327578746,
0.0535143763,
-0.0473295562,
-0.0273901783,
0.0036266933,
0.0254832041,
0.0269525964,
0.0212992821,
-0.034757264,
-0.0029330214,
-0.0295359753,
0.0074847941,
-0.0439933017,
0.0152917448,
-0.0531015731,
0.0201338399,
0.0483796299,
-0.0670575202,
-0.0085015679,
-0.0071846806,
-0.0341368578,
-0.0498156063,
-0.020615356,
0.0417917706,
0.0245777126,
0.005143018,
-0.0065733679,
-0.0805561766,
0.062846899,
0.0388542861,
-0.0127365682,
-0.0206418391,
-0.0533937588,
0.0199587867,
-0.006340065,
0.0183308441,
-0.0981182903,
0.0103641516,
-0.058729142,
0.0522569157,
0.0015131633,
-0.0651150793,
0.0534538403,
0.0756369084,
0.0093906708,
-0.0134737538,
0.0302514173,
-0.0135616912,
0.0149099631,
-0.0323998965,
-0.0526648872,
-0.0165940206,
0.0572997965,
-0.0175389051,
-0.0153381908,
0.0277465917,
0.0557313859,
-0.0105376197,
0.0525749214,
-0.0489462912,
0.0180881619,
-0.0206351262,
-0.008067606,
0.0170373172,
0.0027281167,
-0.0151608558,
0.033208169,
0.0283966623,
0.0432001352,
-0.0020442733,
0.0452801138,
0.0271620229,
-0.0027756772,
-0.0297396705,
0.0220235754,
-0.0995785296,
-0.0882617459,
-0.008574523,
-0.0045641512,
0.0294802859,
0.0128999772,
-0.0049396013,
-0.0273752529,
0.000696087,
-0.0010637579,
0.0141601535,
0.0540869124,
-0.0417015553,
0.0090891002,
0.0362006426,
-0.0327119231,
-0.0167827494,
0.0574982688,
0.0038042802,
0.0048670038,
-0.0162141975,
-0.0483087488,
-0.0388873555,
-0.030068757,
0.0203300565,
0.0318574794,
-0.0127534783,
-0.0183414016,
-0.0401777588,
-0.0213379487,
-0.0031541097,
0.0137920277,
0.0271976646,
-0.00771872,
0.0905204192,
0.0766080618,
0.0052738129,
-0.0202625375,
-0.0360126458,
0.0097625311,
-0.0379405059,
-0.0159715265,
0.0018336538,
-5.966210925e-33,
-0.0049681631,
-0.0623810701,
0.0399632677,
-0.0239857472,
-0.014832478,
-0.0038690055,
-0.0255887993,
-0.0217381604,
0.0085032173,
-0.015703667,
-0.0318945423,
0.0136657171,
0.0078822821,
0.0003724619,
0.0101212692,
-0.0037782851,
0.0718172789,
-0.0136225615,
-0.0317128785,
0.0369312279,
0.0639549121,
0.0386324823,
-0.0241409838,
-0.0099644549,
0.0223792754,
-0.0329886824,
-0.0322883315,
0.0837953612,
-0.007772753,
0.0413510501,
-0.0033676119,
0.0552632734,
0.0370579325,
-0.0687567592,
-0.0123379733,
0.0349302441,
-0.0330770314,
-0.0289749019,
0.0206135046,
-0.0241293702,
-0.0250872783,
-0.0124214748,
0.0186683238,
-0.0257689282,
-0.0267916061,
0.0612164475,
0.0515876524,
-0.0087981205,
-0.0201290809,
-0.0541038401,
-0.0117075304,
0.0059810202,
-0.0015366214,
0.0016865606,
0.0087274415,
0.0717574432,
-0.0222628657,
0.0451191105,
0.0093337866,
0.0528775565,
-0.0246784389,
0.0516350493,
0.0705276132,
0.0672693849,
-0.0182316639,
0.0402774066,
0.0074965023,
0.0075173927,
-0.0337421112,
-0.0252340715,
-0.0290270764,
0.0236568488,
0.0300213024,
0.0260036793,
-0.0025017487,
0.019606486,
-0.0257477406,
0.0482439585,
0.0188564342,
0.0237654466,
0.0169321466,
0.0060663121,
-0.0253957901,
-0.0308938716,
-0.0418496653,
0.0411857143,
-0.0647495389,
-0.0048092976,
0.0510845445,
0.0411211364,
-0.035915222,
-0.0492034927,
0.0152564105,
-0.0062409029,
-0.0141403759,
0.0367996544,
-0.0016712429,
-0.026796218,
-0.004891207,
0.0075911563,
-0.0189303365,
-0.0198484622,
-0.0115675405,
-0.0077990107,
-0.0284561962,
0.0042232699,
-0.0299205463,
0.0283563677,
-0.0406142734,
0.0130525185,
-0.0302401613,
0.0185524784,
-0.0038062974,
-0.0402977355,
0.0116645582,
-0.0082211262,
-0.0099831829,
0.0401599556,
0.0358836651,
-0.0052849115,
0.0019480777,
-0.0441703387,
0.0163341369,
0.0166297164,
-0.0009897614,
0.0240923055,
-0.0359948426,
0.0404294804,
0.0132132433,
-0.0548692532,
-0.0083535518,
0.0226518176,
2.586e-7,
-0.0027813159,
0.0474706627,
0.0117761241,
0.0567429848,
0.017004326,
0.0170867331,
0.0259951968,
-0.0168320779,
-0.0043367338,
0.0014357067,
0.0086199166,
0.0068678437,
0.0347356871,
-0.0077321874,
-0.0696723089,
-0.0018579522,
-0.0627172142,
-0.0318260491,
-0.0810153335,
-0.0116217164,
0.0576816499,
0.0596978776,
-0.0102991732,
-0.001819065,
-0.0222583488,
-0.0739687607,
0.0295464173,
-0.0003467931,
-0.0068610446,
0.0323098563,
0.0622252971,
0.0029877266,
-0.0059689479,
-0.0079961261,
-0.0132922605,
0.0034160069,
0.0124266464,
0.0205623694,
0.0172413383,
-0.0038316015,
0.0064726723,
-0.0212697405,
0.0045593414,
-0.0835029185,
0.0436918996,
-0.0056753648,
0.0206325166,
-0.0268768147,
-0.0088113649,
-0.0300214048,
-0.0028500932,
-0.061234165,
-0.0285784286,
-0.0098147001,
-0.0254076179,
0.0197661351,
-0.0018400985,
-0.0693744421,
-0.0198146161,
-0.0126629295,
-0.051319506,
-0.0449039042,
-0.0768372864,
0.038707193,
-0.0019456927,
-0.0490980186,
-0.0015272918,
2.447940124e-34,
0.0240913369,
0.0141252335,
-0.0156712513,
-0.0109467395,
0.0328034312,
0.0309932642,
-0.0511081629,
0.0316375904,
0.0516959317,
-0.0897983536,
-0.0436062366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14583v1 | JointMatch: A Unified Approach for Diverse and Collaborative Pseudo-Labeling to Semi-Supervised Text Classification | 2023-10-23T05:43:35 | 2023-10-23T05:43:35 | Henry Peng Zou, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Semi-supervised text classification (SSTC) has gained increasing attention
due to its ability to leverage unlabeled data. However, existing approaches
based on pseudo-labeling suffer from the issues of pseudo-label bias and error
accumulation. In this paper, we propose JointMatch, a holistic approach for
SSTC that addresses these challenges by unifying ideas from recent
semi-supervised learning and the task of learning with noise. JointMatch
adaptively adjusts classwise thresholds based on the learning status of
different classes to mitigate model bias towards current easy classes.
Additionally, JointMatch alleviates error accumulation by utilizing two
differently initialized networks to teach each other in a cross-labeling
manner. To maintain divergence between the two networks for mutual learning, we
introduce a strategy that weighs more disagreement data while also allowing the
utilization of high-quality agreement data for training. Experimental results
on benchmark datasets demonstrate the superior performance of JointMatch,
achieving a significant 5.13% improvement on average. Notably, JointMatch
delivers impressive results even in the extremely-scarce-label setting,
obtaining 86% accuracy on AG News with only 5 labels per class. We make our
code available at https://github.com/HenryPengZou/JointMatch. | [
0.0426848456,
0.0457614213,
0.0380631648,
0.0048263776,
0.0142747024,
0.0403405987,
0.0040070922,
-0.0130078038,
0.0786058679,
-0.0457734093,
-0.0966652781,
0.0052684564,
-0.0467891321,
0.0219324417,
-0.0123021761,
-0.0302425474,
0.0447157621,
0.0409182571,
0.0348234139,
0.0008624935,
0.0134617938,
0.0251154155,
-0.0031668034,
-0.0226283669,
-0.041319374,
-0.006572186,
0.0133014787,
0.0110317664,
0.0378691368,
0.0075925132,
0.034811765,
0.0094472235,
-0.0260171145,
0.0705639422,
0.0000019717,
-0.0335153602,
-0.0276552942,
-0.0051341266,
-0.0059378766,
0.0193632357,
0.0081846453,
-0.0290216599,
0.01234823,
0.0101940138,
-0.0208339971,
-0.0671486035,
0.0280280896,
0.0913722888,
0.059089452,
0.0600779466,
-0.0241234936,
0.0074860738,
0.0194444563,
-0.0423439667,
-0.0178413484,
-0.0800745711,
0.0106423106,
0.0279730633,
-0.037065167,
-0.0061305691,
0.0026609316,
0.0249429159,
0.0443551093,
-0.0133029157,
0.0250043571,
0.0442733951,
-0.0311575253,
-0.0352864638,
-0.0104642985,
0.0687016025,
-0.0047724927,
-0.0574777015,
0.0368354358,
-0.0344101824,
-0.0002234136,
0.0281784665,
0.027734194,
-0.0357196033,
-0.0357085913,
0.0320686251,
0.0034349738,
0.0363823362,
0.0276190359,
0.0161166042,
0.0023418432,
0.048871357,
-0.0413951501,
-0.0285801776,
0.0456374809,
0.0334682912,
0.0024952679,
-0.0288087726,
0.0608287752,
0.0070214616,
-0.0132492119,
-0.0188453179,
-0.0447582118,
-0.0574237853,
0.0270578731,
-0.0425173268,
-0.0058407988,
-0.0519236811,
-0.0336191319,
0.0622195899,
-0.0077711758,
-0.0544309728,
0.0227732919,
0.0603161193,
-0.0453971401,
-0.0187907126,
-0.0765705481,
0.0126045132,
-0.0346633233,
0.0510390736,
0.0212064218,
0.0022257154,
-0.0478595756,
-0.0167919435,
-0.0512619056,
0.0377655067,
0.0154424151,
0.0036125788,
-0.0288861357,
-0.0309474692,
0.0305893254,
0.0088353753,
-0.020989798,
0.0252180696,
-0.0130121438,
0.0074356259,
-0.0081295054,
0.016022196,
-0.0062130848,
-0.0306403469,
0.0289695188,
0.0378838889,
-0.0499419793,
-0.0447214916,
-0.0251090899,
-0.0067574326,
-0.0217308719,
-0.0495577566,
-0.0290096756,
-0.0360166878,
-0.000298013,
-0.0314785577,
0.0183057133,
-0.027356727,
-0.0241822656,
-0.0116619719,
-0.0120083205,
0.0643895343,
-0.0334891714,
-0.0495848246,
0.0825579166,
0.0330791958,
0.0325159468,
0.0457764789,
0.0113444878,
0.0025352412,
0.047647249,
0.0326213837,
-0.0056475471,
-0.0382538177,
0.0662708282,
-0.0269928519,
0.0039490857,
-0.0101493243,
0.0615964159,
0.0154611673,
0.0062204255,
0.0464665443,
-0.0339837261,
-0.0298930425,
0.0208429582,
-0.0338817388,
-0.0188667048,
0.0321764909,
-0.0076542632,
0.03265303,
0.0088593159,
0.0164816137,
-0.0065696291,
0.0314474888,
-0.0752697662,
-0.0128531288,
0.0628400892,
0.0321714953,
-0.0628296509,
-0.0763797164,
-0.0116287852,
-0.0364406034,
0.0047882157,
0.0127160037,
0.058470726,
0.0296183862,
-0.0070680953,
0.003577726,
0.022575913,
-0.010313455,
-0.0009252719,
-0.0239444897,
0.0541158691,
-0.009563393,
0.0094801625,
-0.0810999051,
-0.0055896095,
-0.0490353405,
0.0272342116,
-0.0231082775,
0.0724732205,
-0.0257548708,
0.0108144386,
-0.0507275574,
-0.0302795041,
0.0178681426,
0.0165105872,
0.0065443823,
-0.0339581147,
0.0370230488,
0.0247516911,
-0.0244481452,
-0.0036426494,
0.0225525293,
-0.0328035653,
0.0112293977,
0.0111701703,
0.0238358323,
0.0548084676,
0.0288603716,
-0.060820099,
-0.0307958517,
0.0418239199,
-0.0057381829,
-0.0457125865,
-0.0252513494,
-0.0071671782,
-0.0462030731,
0.03863905,
0.0035582478,
-0.0408016481,
0.0310065579,
-0.0440770164,
-0.0381552391,
0.0080083702,
0.0147365574,
0.0115369949,
-0.0674622953,
-0.0382691026,
0.0217216555,
0.008618949,
-0.0429099873,
0.0407928862,
0.0191287566,
0.0389040709,
-0.0547163375,
-0.050471101,
0.0339225009,
0.0150490385,
-0.0265658312,
0.0258860663,
-0.0256117079,
-0.0002842051,
0.014845713,
0.0183710475,
-0.0542888269,
-0.034894187,
-0.0532656647,
-0.0162205435,
-0.0249266885,
-0.0079096863,
-0.0120823598,
-0.0346069187,
0.0035496652,
-0.0086277006,
-0.0110064978,
-0.0115767177,
-0.0238022152,
-0.0158651751,
0.0175639093,
0.0152561292,
0.0468915775,
-0.0048922696,
-0.0013426726,
0.0122604165,
0.0521822795,
0.0417996608,
-0.0264351424,
-0.0388980955,
0.0084869936,
-0.0572225228,
0.0076833335,
0.0131012946,
-0.0124656511,
-0.0506512299,
0.0221591853,
-0.0743800104,
0.0291728731,
-0.0260382947,
-0.0113626551,
0.0387123264,
0.0104994196,
-0.0626735538,
0.0097269686,
-0.0038134002,
0.0355130024,
-0.0071401815,
-0.0191155262,
-0.01759913,
0.0777236968,
-0.0040015103,
-0.0298422799,
-0.0293443929,
-0.0169972628,
0.0273027364,
-0.0116206966,
0.0013577724,
-0.0141466223,
0.0371676795,
0.0004975167,
-0.0307029579,
-0.0551141202,
0.1080488935,
0.0331857651,
-0.0065044272,
-0.0694865286,
-0.0492206812,
-0.0227472838,
0.0165596493,
0.0176032167,
0.0273147672,
0.0682158098,
0.0026645653,
0.0033595294,
-0.0449508093,
0.0324411876,
-0.0158006456,
0.0177267641,
0.0036140007,
0.0418479294,
-0.0161756054,
-0.0145755233,
-0.0053308606,
-0.0521768332,
-0.0134224193,
0.0172410142,
-0.0406237803,
-0.0186051466,
-0.0023394341,
-0.0345578119,
-0.0275186542,
0.0671959966,
0.0374753512,
-0.027778171,
0.0126119871,
0.034059532,
-0.0007959677,
-0.017605355,
-0.0206155553,
-0.0342167951,
-0.0006620833,
0.0454600938,
0.0364643186,
-0.0066857971,
0.0188593604,
-0.0399353392,
0.0306521934,
-0.0217354018,
-0.0028892113,
-0.032189209,
0.0200770702,
0.0310817976,
-0.0201018285,
0.0748140588,
0.0606877916,
-0.0755745992,
-0.0273212884,
-0.0092131142,
0.0331851803,
0.0298000462,
0.0277359504,
-0.0463688485,
-0.025980819,
-0.0061074737,
0.01898247,
0.0065905782,
-0.0230923817,
-0.0023027204,
-0.063843362,
-0.0097277062,
-0.0044060247,
-0.0603722632,
-0.013178953,
-0.0414730944,
-0.0092942296,
-0.0307304449,
-0.0541756675,
-0.0273014605,
0.0161342099,
-0.0037289097,
0.0246824622,
-0.0139897764,
-0.0584088527,
-0.0163468309,
-0.017128814,
0.0561156608,
0.0153194284,
0.0132020246,
-0.0076525346,
-0.0173713267,
0.0758966953,
-0.0269771125,
-0.0364412889,
-0.0549787804,
0.0980194658,
-0.0574385785,
0.0142288478,
0.0264397748,
0.0315178558,
-0.008125985,
-0.0417656898,
-0.0129844537,
0.0596646629,
-0.0036779302,
-0.0179213174,
0.0015609605,
-0.0005515933,
0.0099759717,
0.0284178834,
0.0080185933,
-0.0221078843,
-0.0249723271,
-0.0044633793,
0.0459627509,
-0.0234780926,
0.020392444,
0.0395987704,
-0.0612574629,
-0.0892281979,
-0.0147195393,
-0.0143843275,
0.0033515249,
0.0345607884,
-0.0127001433,
-0.0153719094,
0.0213102307,
-0.0326462872,
-0.0375543609,
0.0111211445,
-0.0020285028,
0.0144530945,
-0.0080376519,
-0.0321186371,
0.0757280439,
-0.0221798737,
-0.0200697612,
-0.0121938856,
-0.054559391,
-0.0650188997,
-0.0202450156,
0.0149567397,
0.0101742139,
0.0389956757,
0.0166115705,
-0.0885566771,
0.0478458926,
0.1253687739,
0.0140961632,
-0.0256419275,
0.0713778064,
-0.0130915148,
0.0075481799,
0.0270287786,
-0.0174473636,
0.0259126946,
0.0346539393,
-0.0267352425,
-0.0647114813,
0.0059336843,
0.0054622102,
-0.0206890795,
0.0597464591,
0.011159718,
0.0156752113,
-0.0678569227,
0.0171801485,
0.0453909412,
-0.0207979232,
-0.0178079922,
0.0070971814,
0.014403333,
-0.0385736302,
-0.0353523977,
0.0831292421,
-0.0201045629,
0.0909090787,
-0.0203582738,
-0.008543429,
-0.0297908671,
0.0132644996,
-0.0031135983,
-0.0097983191,
-0.0069210608,
-0.0302446224,
0.0604654439,
0.0203557368,
0.016198162,
0.005318183,
0.0450874455,
0.0435721204,
-0.0059899646,
-0.0191331394,
-0.0781885386,
0.0272615273,
-0.0487688519,
0.0511400327,
0.0676310137,
-0.0199782383,
0.018798897,
-0.0096427472,
-0.0170226805,
-0.0238500256,
-0.0045721629,
-0.0051480066,
-0.0269455686,
-0.0018131891,
-0.0051373797,
-0.0095495628,
0.0452249348,
0.085031487,
-0.0280196443,
0.0364263505,
0.0019474217,
-0.0499142967,
-0.0592681728,
-0.0208644886,
0.0455299467,
0.0273004696,
-0.0281511936,
-0.0040377462,
-0.0110996272,
-0.0641880333,
0.0736157224,
0.010044517,
-0.0031277114,
0.0113959452,
0.0172403567,
0.0083542196,
0.0086560799,
0.0368036032,
-0.0182118975,
-0.0075098616,
0.077521041,
-0.0221511051,
-0.0129814614,
-6.447704064e-33,
0.0057058064,
-0.0201369505,
-0.0439635515,
-0.0080831479,
-0.0091391113,
0.0063481135,
0.014400918,
-0.0029179568,
0.0039816406,
0.0413817652,
0.017396532,
0.0519916639,
-0.00079204,
0.0337166004,
0.0012678062,
-0.0395293497,
0.0355955586,
-0.0244683791,
-0.0135245686,
0.0186815411,
0.0039738296,
0.0282484889,
0.0535724163,
-0.146605894,
0.0455176756,
0.0455491133,
-0.0021750107,
-0.0324056186,
-0.0149597945,
0.0268649701,
0.0095399246,
0.072973758,
0.0401305035,
0.0461076386,
0.0216502827,
0.0162574705,
-0.0533527173,
-0.0452166684,
-0.0487878546,
-0.0103928903,
-0.0109433737,
0.0001654421,
0.0118082138,
0.0047638584,
-0.0197400376,
-0.0193953477,
0.0609912872,
-0.0193522442,
-0.0467852764,
-0.0865587071,
0.000060242,
0.0316287354,
-0.0217345729,
-0.0154998321,
0.0008887363,
0.0604612902,
0.0228396226,
0.0578011125,
-0.0911670402,
-0.0097728306,
-0.0458303876,
0.0097630164,
0.0047945981,
-0.0106421048,
-0.0265735313,
0.054864984,
0.0388370045,
0.0414964035,
-0.0074403845,
-0.0204640701,
-0.0107557755,
-0.0122635607,
0.0151298009,
0.0538348593,
0.0617919639,
-0.0660775453,
-0.082614772,
0.0291392617,
0.0202575941,
-0.0404734388,
0.000479972,
0.0338937789,
-0.0096452814,
0.0101727778,
0.0020186238,
-0.0322527401,
-0.0201888122,
0.033683937,
-0.0419673584,
0.0472274981,
-0.0202545114,
0.0493943505,
-0.0343679897,
-0.0331887826,
-0.0667097196,
0.0037817296,
0.0228387862,
0.0297424365,
0.0186227839,
-0.007488986,
-0.0995435417,
-0.0690582246,
-0.000504194,
0.0339427255,
0.0172506385,
-0.0272551682,
0.099628441,
-0.0162440315,
-0.0419315398,
0.019518353,
0.0256858543,
0.0192277692,
0.0076162191,
0.0052195108,
0.0088838907,
0.0157392398,
-0.0163196288,
0.0588857383,
0.0322254486,
-0.0001522527,
0.0082415072,
0.0077279019,
-0.0191316642,
0.0076158033,
0.029387977,
-0.0038208428,
0.005941431,
-0.0380457863,
0.0034076739,
-0.0577707551,
0.0223064609,
0.0020106144,
2.752e-7,
0.0165857188,
0.0235812459,
0.0145317214,
-0.0469010882,
0.0120082162,
0.0635653362,
-0.0261292644,
0.05603607,
-0.0052021006,
-0.0294092819,
0.0165178068,
0.0092707807,
0.0630096942,
0.0473571979,
-0.0373337939,
-0.0450096205,
-0.0488584079,
0.0054671653,
-0.0273846947,
0.0095901275,
0.0863929912,
0.0664466321,
0.0283236429,
-0.0167705957,
0.020943461,
-0.0147308847,
0.0509327985,
0.0089871734,
0.0009478693,
0.030825017,
0.0272837393,
-0.0303248912,
-0.0249780156,
0.0617135204,
-0.0364729464,
-0.0145864431,
0.0249468405,
0.0149076413,
0.0149917733,
0.0004195843,
0.0188605841,
0.042383045,
0.0133501273,
0.0311865509,
0.0692266449,
-0.0737713799,
-0.026400134,
0.0230957512,
-0.0359374955,
-0.0100075891,
0.1069916636,
-0.0146692554,
-0.026659416,
0.0246627852,
0.0022291234,
0.0106767649,
-0.0196469072,
-0.0707985163,
0.004567137,
0.0075109121,
-0.0319551453,
0.0112358239,
0.0313587897,
0.0288778897,
0.062028449,
-0.0562233627,
0.0240712184,
2.067353165e-34,
0.068003729,
-0.0228321142,
-0.0173196662,
-0.0269515328,
-0.0262405779,
-0.0157364644,
-0.0622289144,
-0.0335121788,
0.0024206901,
0.0072591598,
0.0273503214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14577v1 | DeCrisisMB: Debiased Semi-Supervised Learning for Crisis Tweet Classification via Memory Bank | 2023-10-23T05:25:51 | 2023-10-23T05:25:51 | Henry Peng Zou, Yue Zhou, Weizhi Zhang, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | During crisis events, people often use social media platforms such as Twitter
to disseminate information about the situation, warnings, advice, and support.
Emergency relief organizations leverage such information to acquire timely
crisis circumstances and expedite rescue operations. While existing works
utilize such information to build models for crisis event analysis,
fully-supervised approaches require annotating vast amounts of data and are
impractical due to limited response time. On the other hand, semi-supervised
models can be biased, performing moderately well for certain classes while
performing extremely poorly for others, resulting in substantially negative
effects on disaster monitoring and rescue. In this paper, we first study two
recent debiasing methods on semi-supervised crisis tweet classification. Then
we propose a simple but effective debiasing method, DeCrisisMB, that utilizes a
Memory Bank to store and perform equal sampling for generated pseudo-labels
from each class at each training iteration. Extensive experiments are conducted
to compare different debiasing methods' performance and generalization ability
in both in-distribution and out-of-distribution settings. The results
demonstrate the superior performance of our proposed method. Our code is
available at https://github.com/HenryPengZou/DeCrisisMB. | [
0.0128789432,
0.0317691751,
0.0106279543,
-0.0038020306,
0.0209468864,
0.0344217271,
0.0115000373,
-0.0404735319,
0.0399913825,
-0.0487337485,
0.0297695026,
-0.0277072471,
-0.0683020353,
0.0114097847,
-0.0108370678,
-0.0832181424,
0.0190358534,
0.0392924547,
0.0679075792,
-0.021726124,
0.0211253893,
0.0285137706,
-0.016107535,
-0.0194420274,
-0.0038100118,
0.0132154785,
-0.0368734971,
0.0283599533,
0.0499769002,
-0.028355876,
0.026018016,
0.0108111193,
0.0544481985,
0.0282351691,
0.0000020046,
-0.0081137028,
-0.0482228473,
-0.0593046434,
-0.0267924145,
-0.0607276373,
0.0045824503,
-0.0867575705,
0.0213135704,
0.029440511,
-0.0457092412,
-0.0652766526,
0.0655509681,
0.0479151197,
0.0592997372,
0.0982263386,
-0.0049758125,
0.0080477968,
0.004368417,
-0.0031801609,
0.0128110275,
-0.028235171,
0.0112693356,
-0.0067015518,
-0.0314399973,
-0.005763445,
0.0444535986,
0.0444697887,
0.0198562145,
0.0525123738,
0.0168635603,
0.0268852711,
-0.0513494536,
-0.0087838257,
-0.0095324777,
0.0286570564,
-0.001714138,
-0.0466486849,
0.0338214301,
0.0010730467,
0.0105593987,
0.02858405,
-0.0118323443,
-0.0279960632,
-0.0244403724,
0.047279451,
-0.0499965586,
0.0677518621,
0.0317937769,
0.0373773985,
0.0068758447,
-0.0192066617,
-0.0458844826,
-0.0390791669,
-0.0181190092,
0.0432390682,
-0.0234713443,
-0.0178012103,
0.0336484648,
0.0023133513,
-0.0110016679,
-0.0117523596,
-0.0388604216,
-0.0156237409,
-0.0103944419,
-0.0901440755,
-0.0461035594,
-0.0198178645,
0.0213583224,
0.0225221384,
0.0371226892,
-0.0444959924,
0.0069100694,
0.0338332355,
-0.0047614179,
-0.0020896578,
-0.1053673625,
0.0358617008,
-0.0154924421,
0.0403853655,
0.065663822,
0.0516429804,
-0.0759052709,
0.0036784173,
-0.002612181,
-0.0314049125,
0.0000863919,
0.0018183261,
-0.0469228551,
0.0084446026,
0.002858487,
0.0066043953,
-0.044027362,
0.0043790359,
-0.0295682065,
-0.0411856063,
-0.0064325714,
-0.0119837392,
0.0466379374,
0.002595684,
-0.0280839931,
0.0249771066,
-0.0100072287,
-0.0356897004,
-0.0802437663,
-0.0016947335,
0.0025562665,
-0.0340581201,
0.0043399744,
-0.0602627993,
0.0080333371,
0.0178710558,
-0.0007372377,
-0.0014652146,
-0.0014090355,
-0.0364385992,
-0.0244055055,
0.026413925,
-0.0576994866,
0.0225541256,
0.0417324118,
0.0057933656,
0.0129337804,
0.0963146314,
0.0336897857,
0.0623575523,
0.0667238608,
0.0009085884,
0.0226550736,
-0.0211938936,
0.043063812,
-0.0032698822,
-0.0171821937,
-0.0159604438,
-0.0093316976,
-0.0045638694,
0.0330584534,
-0.0258396342,
0.0003689248,
-0.0013088085,
0.0429701619,
-0.013993239,
-0.0302147903,
-0.0052244053,
0.0006594302,
0.07157024,
-0.0289681237,
0.0072094486,
-0.0032762233,
0.0172040332,
-0.0298289601,
0.0228860155,
0.0403222851,
0.0359864011,
-0.0641930252,
-0.0232287329,
-0.0212794933,
-0.0113005685,
-0.006506925,
0.0049984283,
0.0354123414,
-0.0119741829,
-0.0132191731,
0.0440738536,
0.0189678539,
-0.0315095708,
-0.0133058727,
-0.0527049191,
-0.0106988102,
0.0680306852,
-0.0114167416,
-0.0564460456,
-0.0210335404,
-0.0612828024,
0.0865094215,
0.0218159705,
-0.0040312042,
0.0319217406,
0.038018167,
-0.0511787422,
-0.0452829115,
-0.0022788167,
0.0315528996,
0.0186834726,
0.0259088706,
0.0683440119,
0.0209641159,
-0.0416631252,
-0.025231773,
-0.0020056765,
0.0370196067,
-0.0587186664,
-0.0286654253,
0.0296198148,
-0.0149977598,
0.0078847148,
-0.0101487264,
-0.0430412553,
0.0140016191,
-0.0062171491,
-0.0778355673,
-0.0016712905,
-0.0571056046,
0.004494647,
0.0222022031,
-0.0309342109,
-0.0122981519,
0.0296238586,
-0.0735055134,
-0.0113543542,
0.0869165957,
-0.010754603,
0.030275872,
-0.0358336158,
-0.0280651022,
-0.017558096,
-0.0166321918,
0.0168062653,
0.0741797537,
-0.0124212233,
-0.0170254149,
-0.0998474509,
-0.0269148964,
0.0224777125,
-0.0041806479,
-0.004751334,
0.0151598696,
-0.0135346157,
0.0347642787,
0.0219827238,
-0.0317643918,
-0.0262930561,
0.005806311,
-0.0545902774,
-0.0033709819,
-0.0595441423,
0.0163112823,
0.0060355701,
0.04153594,
-0.0170463528,
-0.0103788227,
0.0115276305,
-0.0430808887,
-0.0088831801,
0.0243253112,
0.0031075138,
-0.0170271136,
0.0434819944,
-0.0142925885,
-0.0034152828,
-0.0143985758,
0.0239064973,
0.0261247195,
-0.0889144987,
0.0058978428,
0.0170676485,
-0.0307598561,
-0.0113911852,
0.0097953407,
-0.0598213226,
-0.002207387,
0.0058575277,
-0.010039987,
-0.0316884369,
0.0245107729,
0.0409755707,
0.0002504626,
0.0392615907,
-0.0375797823,
0.0141338082,
-0.0274943188,
-0.0523417108,
-0.0125576109,
-0.0349337608,
-0.0465772077,
0.0631880015,
-0.0088791633,
0.0076676845,
-0.0290863235,
-0.0378363952,
-0.0096438071,
-0.0259319264,
-0.043449752,
0.0001657867,
-0.0039902749,
-0.0163770318,
-0.0177801717,
-0.0508723669,
0.0198553428,
0.0655063465,
0.0386181995,
-0.0332283825,
-0.0737961009,
-0.0293832719,
0.0504660569,
-0.0178344846,
0.0179903749,
0.0646739304,
-0.0017347819,
0.0194361564,
-0.0447529592,
0.0216052625,
-0.0324920863,
-0.0313145928,
-0.0011877934,
0.0322753191,
-0.0045115016,
-0.0258309487,
-0.0353147909,
-0.0751501098,
-0.0190458056,
-0.0326729119,
-0.0293263849,
0.0146953361,
-0.0492608957,
0.0008460489,
0.0297916606,
0.0265530888,
0.0336819552,
-0.0359916687,
0.010033153,
0.0500754118,
-0.0126955761,
-0.0335987769,
-0.031144511,
-0.0236621164,
-0.0125923548,
0.0532966144,
0.0442862362,
-0.0195070561,
-0.0263715312,
-0.0348109193,
-0.000299716,
-0.0522296317,
0.0305795968,
-0.0131760333,
0.0465126485,
0.0188895669,
0.0041298349,
0.0971381515,
0.0537406616,
-0.070933938,
0.0091827903,
0.0225086212,
0.0143024996,
0.0268742274,
-0.0034764467,
-0.0174915362,
-0.031023372,
-0.0240099765,
0.0159058645,
-0.0261803661,
-0.0541361012,
0.0249354746,
-0.0497597493,
0.0021776457,
-0.0069750585,
-0.0191272777,
-0.0040402147,
-0.0781825632,
0.0148031451,
-0.0275145378,
-0.054342173,
-0.041049771,
-0.016434446,
0.0220470242,
0.040529713,
-0.0558422394,
-0.0817679837,
-0.0283270516,
-0.051699359,
0.0167976916,
-0.0049866787,
0.0265700389,
-0.0114283087,
0.0076259109,
0.042942021,
-0.0236169454,
-0.0164234601,
-0.0019601036,
0.0942211822,
-0.0249675866,
-0.0106292274,
0.0040847431,
0.0101115275,
-0.0420695022,
-0.0043665734,
-0.0116182826,
0.04843444,
-0.0046027028,
-0.0063517941,
-0.0380730256,
0.0079396954,
0.0666446313,
0.0481554531,
0.0176142938,
-0.0136329355,
-0.0165475737,
-0.0308301691,
0.0292163864,
-0.0420392193,
0.029110983,
0.0033816937,
-0.0241866894,
-0.0941181183,
-0.0066617327,
-0.018389497,
-0.0038679047,
0.0303839613,
-0.0651214868,
-0.0386737734,
0.0218534283,
-0.0235217623,
-0.044772923,
0.0083951522,
-0.0331845917,
0.0216022357,
0.00975201,
-0.0520702377,
-0.0102273338,
0.0375457965,
0.0000642179,
0.0261613373,
-0.068370223,
-0.0473273955,
0.0434427708,
0.0103782946,
0.0280604698,
-0.0124109108,
0.0126118921,
-0.0053640292,
0.0572526455,
0.0992118567,
-0.0312502272,
-0.0536604784,
0.0396453738,
0.0101166042,
0.0251179282,
0.035631258,
-0.018883137,
0.0664637908,
-0.0006065177,
-0.0236514173,
-0.0834848955,
0.0505675077,
-0.0405795798,
-0.0232433379,
0.0637426674,
0.0095062768,
-0.0722808391,
-0.0217166729,
-0.0108634466,
0.0053495942,
-0.0008812982,
0.0136789354,
0.0620196462,
0.043930985,
0.0406980626,
-0.042079322,
0.0129424427,
-0.0343045145,
-0.0047508101,
-0.0098628728,
-0.0039140638,
0.0547475852,
0.0167522915,
-0.0193856079,
-0.0051826118,
-0.0228258856,
0.0453350134,
0.0609079711,
-0.0226824265,
0.0246057324,
-0.0295430645,
0.0071910899,
0.0681968555,
-0.0091156494,
-0.003147207,
-0.0563189611,
0.006328423,
-0.0328558348,
0.0296321958,
0.0798844993,
0.007962686,
0.0085632689,
0.0136557929,
-0.0101687592,
0.0331855603,
-0.0095816143,
0.0096096434,
-0.0211066622,
-0.0021635103,
0.0109261107,
-0.050116308,
0.0599223338,
0.0625275224,
-0.0115484837,
0.022365341,
0.0220878925,
-0.0537694953,
-0.0007919702,
-0.0150015475,
-0.0038525492,
0.0450525209,
0.0132664489,
0.0065275691,
-0.0329967104,
-0.0424004607,
0.0709997714,
-0.0318136252,
0.0121968342,
0.0081111109,
0.0197736714,
0.0284332801,
0.0005181734,
0.0699941516,
-0.0232382491,
-0.0115881898,
-0.0214114767,
-0.0249334704,
-0.0051332433,
-6.727420291e-33,
0.0552245453,
-0.0274023432,
-0.055810038,
-0.0513999686,
0.0013483486,
0.0379151627,
0.0103741195,
0.0102031641,
0.0156009663,
-0.0028440712,
0.0034143862,
0.0442220494,
0.024097098,
0.0022995924,
0.0089425631,
-0.0373601429,
0.026207367,
-0.0000312507,
-0.0181902871,
0.0433159471,
0.0629793704,
0.0290922932,
0.0479265116,
-0.1051183045,
0.0101479134,
-0.0353625044,
0.0027648068,
-0.0295663588,
0.0901760533,
0.0043520979,
-0.0291661657,
0.0741504952,
0.0445600003,
-0.0206059311,
0.0104267513,
0.0304115936,
0.011525983,
-0.0163447503,
-0.0103789074,
-0.0241863895,
-0.0162090175,
-0.0171558857,
-0.0313624777,
0.031808991,
-0.0004463139,
-0.0131023508,
0.0263814591,
0.0490155965,
0.0026905355,
-0.0444007106,
-0.0382920839,
0.0474604517,
-0.0472310297,
0.007103519,
-0.0088504422,
0.041934438,
0.0260604396,
0.0475849882,
-0.0559324101,
-0.0245743636,
-0.0199666452,
-0.0228559803,
0.0073492858,
-0.0282332357,
-0.0518705472,
0.0668925494,
0.0012091883,
0.0428773127,
-0.0047158422,
-0.0067365211,
-0.0359438136,
-0.0114233559,
-0.0007442589,
0.1071203873,
0.0764429197,
-0.0572996177,
-0.0660860911,
0.0226726793,
0.0251225159,
0.0238870699,
0.0284179896,
0.0244208071,
-0.0369428769,
0.0023655642,
0.0297300853,
-0.0399807058,
-0.0078441501,
-0.0100708995,
-0.0376616754,
0.0270009916,
-0.0020744062,
0.0828640983,
0.0113069657,
-0.0085656475,
-0.0129130017,
0.0195272509,
0.0313958488,
0.0324069597,
0.0179014876,
0.0285017136,
-0.0540770069,
-0.027892679,
0.0250115078,
0.0565011613,
-0.0026169543,
-0.0047860839,
0.0350905396,
0.0269650426,
-0.014870449,
0.0168725159,
-0.0133529231,
0.042632848,
-0.0595986322,
0.0124139534,
0.0077999867,
0.0081275562,
0.0125495065,
-0.0466990992,
0.0474326462,
-0.0179702193,
0.0539591089,
-0.0059488411,
-0.0469748452,
-0.0009404774,
0.0212820303,
0.0001259917,
-0.0203116126,
-0.0170692988,
-0.0429225191,
-0.0645177066,
0.0014578536,
0.0044473982,
2.793e-7,
0.0121379709,
0.0457458794,
0.0226736851,
-0.0153925987,
0.0103468355,
0.0234997459,
0.0165461861,
0.0547171794,
0.0141846575,
-0.0694669783,
-0.0049243746,
0.0670498013,
0.048761446,
0.0491059683,
-0.0911304727,
-0.0113931997,
-0.0407599583,
0.0425650887,
-0.059161298,
0.0274039321,
0.0693868622,
0.0598225184,
0.0528462678,
-0.0205162186,
0.0102483677,
-0.0357318893,
0.0417251661,
-0.0247805361,
-0.00634248,
0.0132503659,
0.0734860152,
0.0543830656,
-0.0181294549,
0.0267779976,
-0.0272503328,
-0.0229283944,
0.0392822661,
0.0223641992,
0.0168963671,
-0.0014603852,
-0.0270083528,
-0.0135331126,
0.0092250053,
-0.0132418331,
0.0501469374,
-0.0692480206,
-0.0463466905,
0.0119633116,
-0.0390225016,
0.0316781849,
0.0666933656,
0.0019110213,
-0.0490083583,
0.0614217445,
0.0084685851,
-0.0072049918,
-0.043505054,
-0.0460207313,
-0.0008529677,
0.0240967758,
-0.023892194,
-0.0282043312,
0.0095411306,
0.0184282605,
0.0665733814,
-0.0292921811,
0.0639418289,
1.81433696e-34,
0.0470421538,
0.0147707956,
-0.0348575376,
-0.0427047536,
0.0028853263,
0.0069243819,
-0.0110045988,
-0.0520309098,
0.0014956746,
-0.0062248274,
0.0381225124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14573v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14573v1 | Exploring the Boundaries of GPT-4 in Radiology | 2023-10-23T05:13:03 | 2023-10-23T05:13:03 | Qianchu Liu, Stephanie Hyland, Shruthi Bannur, Kenza Bouzid, Daniel C. Castro, Maria Teodora Wetscherek, Robert Tinn, Harshita Sharma, Fernando Pérez-García, Anton Schwaighofer, Pranav Rajpurkar, Sameer Tajdin Khanna, Hoifung Poon, Naoto Usuyama, Anja Thieme, Aditya V. Nori, Matthew P. Lungren, Ozan Oktay, Javier Alvarez-Valle | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent success of general-domain large language models (LLMs) has
significantly changed the natural language processing paradigm towards a
unified foundation model across domains and applications. In this paper, we
focus on assessing the performance of GPT-4, the most capable LLM so far, on
the text-based applications for radiology reports, comparing against
state-of-the-art (SOTA) radiology-specific models. Exploring various prompting
strategies, we evaluated GPT-4 on a diverse range of common radiology tasks and
we found GPT-4 either outperforms or is on par with current SOTA radiology
models. With zero-shot prompting, GPT-4 already obtains substantial gains
($\approx$ 10% absolute improvement) over radiology models in temporal sentence
similarity classification (accuracy) and natural language inference ($F_1$).
For tasks that require learning dataset-specific style or schema (e.g. findings
summarisation), GPT-4 improves with example-based prompting and matches
supervised SOTA. Our extensive error analysis with a board-certified
radiologist shows GPT-4 has a sufficient level of radiology knowledge with only
occasional errors in complex context that require nuanced domain knowledge. For
findings summarisation, GPT-4 outputs are found to be overall comparable with
existing manually-written impressions. | [
0.065537855,
0.0201039929,
0.0219451878,
-0.0204839781,
-0.046701666,
0.0292225089,
0.0003062257,
0.0231337156,
0.009010803,
-0.0441294685,
-0.0236945674,
-0.0780481696,
0.0100319209,
0.0088824062,
0.0073332386,
-0.0752820745,
0.0283686947,
0.000370661,
0.0228564274,
0.0253773015,
0.0141798453,
0.0337531008,
-0.0147785489,
0.0277634952,
0.0106162308,
-0.0335167944,
0.0235574916,
-0.0124378754,
0.03284619,
-0.044357568,
-0.02873707,
0.0769088939,
0.0381739475,
0.0373017415,
0.0000018132,
-0.0537969321,
-0.0309177544,
0.0313211903,
-0.0069087883,
0.0184915364,
0.0880791247,
-0.0485575199,
0.0135328993,
0.0272397585,
-0.0195887815,
-0.0901368707,
0.0122582382,
0.0619678982,
0.0556741208,
0.0766637623,
-0.0302736256,
-0.0027539453,
0.0382828079,
-0.0428678058,
-0.002045182,
-0.0532092862,
0.0314857811,
0.0168718249,
0.0377493873,
0.0196227003,
0.0138425138,
0.0149535676,
-0.0038717766,
0.0323234014,
-0.0094085308,
0.0653377399,
-0.0197771862,
0.0239777826,
-0.0026444483,
0.0329002067,
0.0309300236,
-0.0255350675,
0.0127633475,
-0.003552495,
-0.0271403249,
0.0172027647,
-0.049814824,
0.0091628395,
-0.0287821982,
-0.0028781437,
-0.0053539574,
0.0121115679,
-0.0049444204,
0.0459218211,
-0.0044575324,
-0.0065352684,
0.023026064,
-0.0430992842,
0.0212082192,
0.0315182284,
-0.0356593095,
-0.0512187034,
0.0146431662,
0.0283941906,
-0.0468923673,
0.0011046875,
-0.035234239,
0.0098795174,
0.0796593353,
-0.0235327389,
-0.044682987,
0.0079494948,
-0.0302921049,
0.0797593221,
0.006964352,
0.052333843,
-0.0370309427,
0.0013966253,
-0.0354579054,
-0.0055072941,
-0.0735870078,
-0.0358744822,
-0.0204358026,
0.0206390135,
0.0082830545,
-0.0312283747,
-0.0693138763,
0.0095916735,
0.0363844596,
0.0026324878,
0.0359560661,
0.0326569229,
-0.0618406013,
0.0154077364,
-0.0218727347,
0.0430500805,
0.0154261645,
0.0156838708,
-0.0261474084,
-0.0286693443,
-0.0051655592,
0.0397193916,
0.0076362351,
-0.0063380082,
-0.0083164331,
-0.0007903095,
-0.010422226,
-0.0458768271,
0.0076922877,
-0.0676194653,
-0.0337747373,
-0.0578214787,
0.0156436507,
-0.0657347143,
0.001426977,
0.0361101478,
0.00298093,
0.0020722998,
-0.0061448668,
0.0137540614,
-0.0183219779,
0.0589512102,
-0.0098066041,
0.0142224589,
0.0280435104,
0.034632206,
0.0383508019,
0.0068423841,
-0.0142438943,
-0.0122702839,
-0.0199804325,
-0.0019006376,
0.0089114644,
0.0128665958,
-0.0234761368,
-0.0315236971,
-0.0044807186,
0.0200450271,
-0.0081708692,
0.0843821019,
0.0083767381,
0.0555045865,
-0.0156047419,
0.0177269001,
0.04132469,
0.0681571811,
0.0183647145,
0.0098028826,
0.0418787673,
0.0125693679,
-0.007278543,
0.0160858538,
-0.0435006805,
0.0099543845,
0.0163417235,
0.0308035333,
-0.0158264656,
-0.0056732898,
-0.0503096506,
0.0033597038,
-0.0413194411,
0.0173965972,
-0.030076148,
-0.0131260864,
0.0614475422,
-0.0220484156,
-0.0592171177,
0.0255109053,
0.0439918973,
-0.0128620602,
-0.0148254633,
-0.0504717939,
0.0177669544,
0.0798030868,
0.076266557,
-0.0446315929,
-0.0325009264,
-0.0254898071,
0.0753398612,
0.0438869745,
0.0488328561,
0.0172793176,
-0.0120788952,
-0.0468012094,
-0.0534556545,
0.0253590383,
0.0193823762,
-0.0057958467,
0.0252844952,
0.0330144651,
0.0031644462,
-0.0318426564,
-0.0282719415,
0.0374462418,
-0.0193804689,
-0.0343155004,
-0.0374002494,
-0.0097733531,
0.0106193358,
0.0315288007,
-0.0357148014,
0.0116696451,
0.0078792656,
0.0076034125,
-0.039662119,
0.0059965351,
-0.0772115812,
-0.0414944962,
0.0132020237,
-0.0428500846,
0.0009884916,
0.0198787488,
-0.0472821519,
-0.0126147931,
-0.0344025902,
-0.028593462,
0.0170499608,
-0.0545481183,
0.0246971827,
0.027935693,
-0.02467007,
-0.0315442011,
0.0729168281,
0.008526993,
0.0135023938,
0.0319038145,
-0.0067628906,
0.00185062,
-0.0576702505,
-0.0414709374,
-0.0001984478,
0.0399291664,
0.0040299431,
0.0048045246,
0.0326944813,
-0.0291101784,
-0.0231030677,
-0.1034200713,
0.0164734609,
0.0066669965,
-0.0021774017,
0.0391254649,
0.0246752109,
-0.016725922,
-0.0201275535,
-0.0285921711,
-0.0593287461,
0.0675135031,
0.022753818,
0.0541683063,
0.0271315426,
0.0223153271,
-0.029853439,
-0.0069930549,
-0.0397058092,
0.0199005883,
0.036523357,
-0.0421016701,
-0.0379029997,
0.0581166223,
-0.0212420356,
0.0090275388,
0.0049027344,
-0.0225096662,
0.0160525125,
-0.0495500565,
-0.0111575704,
0.0570506938,
0.0190009438,
0.0070340354,
0.0368266329,
0.000859209,
-0.0263676308,
0.0027011847,
-0.0590200834,
-0.0318220593,
0.0437991694,
-0.007476117,
0.0020390071,
0.0490030944,
0.0285609681,
0.0112237167,
-0.0289266743,
-0.0177227575,
-0.0340942256,
0.0288075916,
-0.0135165043,
-0.0139902867,
-0.0095346561,
0.0127568748,
-0.0116893342,
-0.0372646041,
0.0940234214,
-0.0259089917,
0.0173408762,
-0.0839352086,
-0.0250308588,
-0.0504200272,
0.0487502366,
-0.0044516176,
0.0103432322,
0.0527046435,
-0.0417074934,
-0.0158875119,
-0.0009501684,
0.026993515,
-0.0496327654,
0.0447201654,
-0.0257520936,
0.0334710255,
-0.0110350186,
-0.0376975536,
-0.0223462973,
-0.0435133316,
-0.007394338,
-0.0018837042,
-0.0238440987,
-0.0028859309,
-0.060781464,
0.0653893426,
0.0010953768,
0.0758287162,
-0.0279784929,
-0.0119401179,
-0.0169420857,
0.0649095029,
0.0469067991,
0.0066068829,
-0.0380077027,
-0.019065721,
0.0138314497,
0.0461384468,
-0.0090003749,
0.0286239386,
-0.0454654992,
-0.0187134612,
-0.0204014666,
-0.0296654496,
-0.016656043,
0.0108746719,
0.0330896266,
-0.0505818725,
-0.0126196146,
0.1333627105,
0.0354836248,
-0.0443238318,
-0.047125984,
0.015862586,
0.0047254139,
-0.0078225629,
0.0026416017,
-0.0279365126,
-0.0406523533,
-0.0160256084,
0.0217058957,
-0.0041475943,
-0.0228890963,
-0.0029950971,
-0.068679817,
0.0512982905,
-0.0122831473,
-0.0587369688,
-0.0224043224,
-0.0507404804,
-0.0075965533,
-0.0085736997,
-0.0178660713,
-0.0171785988,
-0.0334694795,
-0.0025699015,
0.0303325281,
-0.0593905784,
-0.0979082435,
0.0318167023,
-0.056035541,
0.0021408971,
0.0621076263,
0.0380647108,
-0.0245565362,
-0.0120931463,
0.0012686591,
0.0233574398,
0.0242015962,
0.0066892281,
0.0879957378,
0.0040786816,
0.013323254,
-0.0819543079,
0.0280547086,
-0.020878911,
0.0178785212,
-0.0005426024,
0.0905058384,
-0.033334408,
-0.0063590962,
-0.0626677349,
0.0565924495,
0.0204705931,
0.0569137819,
-0.0144333309,
0.0167108383,
-0.0588437021,
0.0326622613,
0.0821809694,
-0.0058740876,
-0.0460809246,
0.0020451357,
-0.0335463844,
-0.0276093539,
-0.0492864475,
-0.0425611287,
0.0319825709,
-0.0070061088,
-0.0018308056,
0.0420503654,
-0.0328453444,
-0.0052495897,
-0.0477924272,
0.0644310564,
0.0159945339,
0.0131152542,
-0.051099252,
-0.0149256811,
0.0931165963,
-0.0135669904,
-0.0206312388,
0.040203508,
-0.0727051198,
-0.0104567241,
-0.0465049036,
0.0013086183,
0.0256115701,
0.0125608733,
0.0104590189,
-0.0141051514,
0.0633076578,
0.0502899252,
-0.0125111891,
0.0015210075,
-0.0277022887,
-0.0307654291,
-0.0177900866,
0.0031075422,
-0.0232836418,
0.0258761588,
-0.0034529904,
0.00340671,
-0.0185307432,
-0.0283401608,
0.0398778096,
0.0278363433,
0.0540102273,
-0.0073740245,
0.000886246,
-0.0159939509,
-0.0255435072,
-0.0111648887,
0.0202549137,
-0.0173014756,
0.0311632399,
0.0309114717,
0.0062823384,
-0.0281054303,
0.0239231903,
-0.0555383377,
0.0125526041,
-0.0683941469,
0.0210961252,
0.0089920983,
-0.0266488791,
0.0367983654,
-0.0216097217,
-0.0462124906,
-0.0572668985,
0.0053862203,
-0.0067457482,
0.0073404219,
0.0736760721,
0.0237454288,
0.0628354177,
0.0167618301,
0.0378933884,
-0.0562165715,
-0.0564407073,
-0.0326966196,
0.0063320613,
0.0481398441,
-0.0109570557,
0.0142564122,
-0.0475047529,
0.0082129128,
-0.02901466,
0.0482809618,
0.0032330439,
0.0192334745,
0.0660239682,
0.0235860609,
0.0289669186,
0.0059302887,
0.1124050245,
0.0096402969,
0.0527835749,
0.0102534564,
-0.0889272913,
-0.0415615737,
-0.0465353988,
-0.0019592769,
0.0017957196,
-0.0313757509,
0.0130145382,
-0.0531224944,
-0.0181150679,
0.001070697,
-0.0402144045,
-0.032691922,
-0.0535154082,
0.0617173351,
0.0656934381,
-0.0013943317,
-0.0355273709,
0.0038887921,
0.0300396103,
-0.0008106813,
-0.0095446827,
-0.0058149067,
-5.734664986e-33,
0.0111244554,
-0.0179829709,
0.0435387194,
-0.0221119076,
-0.014420663,
0.0541565828,
-0.0155590205,
-0.0350123793,
0.0123545239,
0.0067737214,
-0.0184021983,
0.0187617373,
0.0164432041,
0.0177363269,
0.0082462477,
0.0071116784,
0.0376075208,
-0.0157508347,
-0.0364794508,
0.0223611705,
-0.0112718279,
0.029921256,
0.0513893142,
-0.0651061237,
-0.0174376108,
0.0029132233,
0.0046327696,
-0.0026148665,
0.0003900596,
0.0585115179,
-0.0409244522,
0.0169831309,
0.0398391709,
-0.0499238968,
-0.0044880742,
0.056327112,
-0.0713651776,
-0.0316636115,
0.0291372761,
-0.0296293348,
-0.0237121582,
0.0093393791,
0.0253750626,
-0.021183027,
0.006558124,
-0.0370732807,
0.04229239,
0.0084828697,
-0.0046042386,
-0.0164980069,
-0.052814763,
0.0564148948,
0.00747868,
-0.0226909891,
-0.0183214732,
0.0201480743,
-0.0439479984,
0.0952536017,
-0.0416958816,
0.0165284649,
0.0492601357,
0.0231835134,
0.0078072743,
-0.0393285267,
-0.0219011493,
0.0481439605,
0.0341075137,
-0.0372731462,
-0.0219296273,
-0.0076558185,
-0.0453705378,
0.0151972212,
0.013500832,
0.0363992974,
0.046413891,
-0.0048196493,
-0.0653261468,
0.0355211422,
-0.0210800041,
0.0622561499,
0.0538603812,
-0.0359628014,
-0.0615037419,
-0.0046406644,
0.0190479681,
0.0052725342,
-0.016716741,
-0.036330916,
0.0466524474,
0.0230269749,
0.0218485501,
0.0494634807,
0.0287355334,
0.028513046,
0.0114421388,
-0.0200902075,
-0.009077779,
0.0196387023,
-0.0538560115,
0.0060353773,
-0.0647914857,
-0.0081077851,
0.0260296501,
0.0158307739,
0.0031531807,
-0.0049778246,
0.0283921808,
0.0207751468,
-0.0658010393,
-0.0008757153,
0.0159036741,
-0.0002411915,
-0.0419691317,
0.0237644091,
0.0257151667,
0.0125650959,
0.0054824445,
0.0687581897,
-0.0054743895,
-0.0203742068,
-0.0364941657,
-0.067139402,
0.0096586831,
-0.0111260777,
-0.015137732,
-0.0265333131,
0.0029689528,
-0.0108354315,
0.0370691419,
-0.0150356432,
-0.0236588605,
0.011229964,
2.58e-7,
0.06799227,
0.0397538133,
0.0203889906,
0.0155533161,
0.0205765218,
0.0024902292,
-0.0087884087,
0.0368230902,
0.0081760185,
0.0351636708,
0.0402206853,
-0.0034968273,
0.0028957711,
0.0209587291,
-0.1060659587,
-0.0153309703,
-0.0711873174,
-0.0458603464,
-0.0524546318,
-0.0512006655,
0.0809151307,
0.077366747,
-0.0267450605,
-0.0410379171,
-0.0137034608,
-0.04120012,
0.0553191416,
-0.0225882884,
-0.0005737056,
0.013414762,
0.0202806499,
0.0193840973,
-0.0053808354,
0.0846148208,
0.0179026276,
-0.0223915111,
0.0472040437,
0.0592437983,
-0.0319192819,
0.004972457,
0.0207105912,
0.0047359229,
-0.0000196368,
-0.0500196554,
0.0693284944,
-0.0854077414,
-0.0241905414,
-0.0060478309,
-0.028803736,
-0.0455900729,
0.043391481,
-0.0123600904,
-0.0423148088,
0.0238778125,
0.0020823167,
0.0050887731,
-0.0516890958,
-0.0700473189,
0.0279249754,
0.0293511897,
-0.0293503944,
-0.0387843437,
0.0125193186,
-0.0076507106,
0.0204122607,
-0.0795463845,
0.0088436361,
2.427276678e-34,
0.054324992,
0.0247758385,
-0.0044715405,
-0.0110419746,
0.0160268843,
0.0063701603,
0.0116276611,
-0.0014032546,
0.0161057767,
-0.0693503767,
-0.0031798182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14572v1 | Unveiling the Multi-Annotation Process: Examining the Influence of Annotation Quantity and Instance Difficulty on Model Performance | 2023-10-23T05:12:41 | 2023-10-23T05:12:41 | Pritam Kadasi, Mayank Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The NLP community has long advocated for the construction of multi-annotator
datasets to better capture the nuances of language interpretation,
subjectivity, and ambiguity. This paper conducts a retrospective study to show
how performance scores can vary when a dataset expands from a single annotation
per instance to multiple annotations. We propose a novel multi-annotator
simulation process to generate datasets with varying annotation budgets. We
show that similar datasets with the same annotation budget can lead to varying
performance gains. Our findings challenge the popular belief that models
trained on multi-annotation examples always lead to better performance than
models trained on single or few-annotation examples. | [
0.054370299,
0.0117283771,
-0.020790901,
0.0218821112,
-0.0100364629,
0.017588472,
0.0417611897,
-0.0162026789,
-0.023156872,
-0.1056240574,
-0.0173795521,
0.0181586929,
-0.036991857,
-0.0559785701,
0.0035416887,
-0.0223021694,
0.0315558389,
-0.0020376092,
0.0144613013,
0.0056619714,
0.0348935798,
-0.0058057429,
-0.0110964179,
0.0491809919,
-0.0797811225,
0.0077833929,
-0.0007453858,
0.009498856,
-0.0055367518,
-0.0617146157,
-0.0042328364,
0.0753774568,
0.0058463616,
0.051686652,
0.0000017649,
-0.0354356505,
-0.0048453179,
0.042515669,
-0.0482209958,
0.0480404869,
0.0572138391,
-0.0169764049,
0.030971013,
0.0082947733,
-0.0443230048,
-0.0208128523,
0.028748069,
0.0208052117,
0.0628598854,
0.0502450578,
-0.0016883785,
-0.0067076925,
-0.0213721022,
-0.0077492404,
-0.0251860805,
-0.0430132225,
-0.0125916898,
0.0623622127,
-0.0187766701,
0.0199498516,
-0.013291683,
0.0372781679,
0.0160157736,
0.0211959668,
-0.0177308209,
0.0164761208,
-0.0685407892,
-0.0267707445,
0.0004163336,
0.0146876136,
0.0428412035,
0.0170652885,
-0.0330408625,
-0.0332842618,
0.0052794185,
0.0114538809,
-0.0066018966,
0.0262213536,
-0.0119576873,
0.0176038612,
0.034383785,
0.0254171379,
0.0171504617,
0.0118607013,
0.0311608016,
0.039870929,
-0.0270387754,
-0.0328232758,
0.031366881,
0.0466203056,
-0.0552681498,
-0.0329147168,
-0.0027466421,
-0.0162620898,
0.0132174725,
0.0340132117,
-0.034059044,
-0.0442795865,
0.0544844083,
-0.0870106369,
0.077201955,
0.015214921,
-0.0523455031,
0.0468958132,
0.010742927,
-0.047636576,
0.0148965856,
0.0071895393,
-0.0136472918,
-0.0121616106,
-0.0688413009,
-0.0057603079,
-0.0414586589,
0.0378674753,
-0.0025751228,
0.0003974947,
-0.0483287014,
-0.0273387004,
-0.0354203805,
-0.0092872493,
-0.0055670599,
-0.0109172761,
-0.027958259,
0.0553000122,
-0.0384226367,
-0.0011039582,
-0.0692959055,
0.0419035219,
-0.0121936752,
-0.0739881545,
0.0121199526,
0.0238566548,
-0.0122089172,
-0.0465822667,
-0.0072973906,
0.0418626703,
0.0343913399,
-0.0358832069,
-0.0359657705,
-0.0466135927,
-0.023083739,
-0.0407611392,
0.0164424013,
-0.0495431088,
0.0319917612,
0.0360673703,
0.0208100863,
-0.0378373265,
0.005244025,
-0.0041986858,
0.0034165641,
0.1019933596,
-0.008796324,
-0.0184223894,
0.0171686597,
-0.0153439604,
-0.0360555202,
0.1101740822,
0.0135589456,
-0.0194277447,
0.0411156975,
0.0050336379,
0.0036081139,
0.0192587748,
0.0130761489,
0.01019313,
0.0344831459,
-0.0062282109,
-0.0257177651,
0.0208064672,
0.0122079002,
0.0302364808,
-0.0473747812,
-0.0186163504,
0.0033352824,
0.0176566932,
0.0136363609,
-0.0141706336,
0.0592715964,
0.0251575615,
0.0327555202,
-0.0064204652,
-0.0342586972,
0.0315473676,
-0.0157430992,
-0.0195036586,
-0.0058231531,
-0.0332282707,
-0.0028555652,
-0.0504931733,
-0.0648769438,
-0.0030651684,
0.019774422,
-0.0245198365,
0.0320247672,
0.0075943293,
0.0086098313,
0.0559321791,
0.0507337935,
-0.0215206686,
-0.0310714412,
-0.02297814,
-0.0190310236,
0.0377866402,
-0.0001268837,
-0.0156599823,
-0.0217089746,
-0.0212704372,
0.0007805935,
0.0269309618,
0.0879180282,
-0.0123018706,
0.0172223318,
-0.0198856797,
-0.0174861196,
-0.0482772999,
0.0569424033,
0.0322872996,
0.0288061313,
-0.0466037579,
-0.0057079471,
-0.0234228577,
-0.0330551863,
0.0594802424,
-0.0283837505,
0.0061851949,
-0.0364743732,
-0.0215626191,
0.0497383438,
0.0193719193,
-0.0141783003,
0.0044133654,
0.0090208557,
-0.0360155553,
-0.0165278651,
0.0056446004,
0.004644142,
-0.0219171681,
0.0218915008,
-0.0125551149,
-0.0245257206,
-0.0217644833,
-0.02267446,
-0.0221828092,
-0.0421719477,
-0.0113641834,
0.0511131436,
-0.050996989,
-0.0308692213,
-0.0156568792,
0.0148783913,
-0.0396840125,
0.0361485109,
-0.0089157373,
0.0436621346,
-0.0148346787,
-0.0168870967,
0.0318813995,
0.0042287502,
-0.0442154109,
-0.0505963787,
0.0055391416,
0.0128545789,
0.0169628579,
-0.0043272926,
-0.0519682504,
-0.0249365699,
-0.1058788225,
-0.0054248096,
-0.0185399707,
-0.0228494871,
0.0172842704,
-0.0337594636,
0.0119834887,
-0.0071941293,
-0.0161274355,
-0.02978554,
-0.0519575886,
0.0641403496,
0.0345968157,
0.0251019001,
0.0165321715,
-0.0441761613,
-0.0051384321,
-0.0277935136,
0.027869083,
0.0091443397,
-0.0437452421,
-0.0222774912,
0.0215402003,
-0.0251728427,
-0.0032616968,
0.007401763,
-0.009137976,
0.0268056672,
0.0179240927,
-0.0104857069,
0.0187330879,
-0.0364277884,
0.1002866998,
0.0456254669,
0.0031897463,
-0.075304687,
0.0234054998,
0.0127070583,
-0.0012560746,
-0.0376425758,
-0.0421521924,
-0.034167286,
0.0560667776,
-0.0084709441,
-0.0216142628,
-0.0312860683,
0.0333809927,
-0.0871475339,
-0.0556389615,
-0.0020613149,
0.0223434232,
0.0020664944,
0.0799473822,
-0.0109745003,
-0.0147901187,
0.0492338575,
0.0177349001,
0.0032635606,
-0.0085742716,
0.0265411437,
-0.0196607392,
0.0664945915,
-0.006348778,
-0.0066888179,
-0.0124961091,
0.0057540508,
0.0003295888,
0.0061314791,
0.0625887364,
-0.0188996959,
0.0390713625,
-0.0303735863,
0.0215209499,
-0.0259190481,
-0.0483184457,
0.001563948,
-0.0303667728,
-0.0319017544,
0.0220864974,
0.0127162216,
0.0243734475,
-0.0120484522,
-0.0025276225,
-0.0277324878,
0.0210100897,
-0.0022443044,
-0.0370564535,
0.0124040451,
0.0006725349,
-0.0035428514,
0.0177835263,
0.0068532852,
-0.019263206,
0.0050726146,
0.0218241885,
-0.0282607879,
0.0463840291,
-0.0440861322,
-0.0008356301,
0.0159092881,
-0.0408730954,
-0.0557005592,
-0.0119518796,
0.0520689003,
-0.0547905117,
-0.0105558382,
0.0894771442,
0.0588990413,
-0.0032512341,
0.016113745,
-0.0260412134,
0.0374246798,
0.0405192636,
0.0094915293,
-0.0999604017,
-0.0272252578,
-0.0268176999,
0.0206827428,
-0.0208197385,
-0.0410657562,
-0.0018319802,
-0.0868425071,
0.011637806,
-0.0505010635,
-0.0615110807,
0.0761332884,
-0.0672717467,
-0.0145042092,
-0.064326562,
0.0195437223,
-0.0163229704,
0.0155944508,
0.0267345998,
0.0571555756,
-0.0520182475,
-0.0452506952,
0.0386732146,
-0.0185864959,
0.0623829067,
0.0137023628,
0.0213337671,
-0.0267195683,
0.0234376397,
0.0282150358,
0.036627505,
0.0152710285,
-0.0208232906,
0.0976091325,
0.0035630655,
-0.02995364,
0.0095083993,
-0.0104028368,
0.0016141001,
-0.0066821389,
-0.0153582962,
0.0157361496,
0.0082613947,
0.0307627283,
-0.0355533436,
-0.0107374554,
0.0009166714,
0.0866513848,
0.0213379376,
-0.0668955147,
0.0039156601,
-0.0232520811,
0.0175742134,
-0.0522760861,
-0.0264529139,
0.0508772023,
-0.0451820493,
-0.0171706006,
-0.0343685038,
-0.097374022,
0.036334455,
0.0343786292,
0.0126284389,
0.0227463543,
-0.0048281257,
0.0035687555,
-0.0035280616,
0.0245377738,
-0.0115293311,
-0.0062502013,
0.0411322229,
-0.0438358001,
0.0650910512,
0.0264669843,
-0.0369674489,
0.0331281684,
-0.0821645483,
-0.0180475861,
0.0555170104,
0.0431664214,
0.0281147864,
0.0433555357,
-0.0010038696,
-0.0313175209,
-0.0538732894,
0.0312590972,
0.0013841932,
0.0004060293,
0.0513505824,
0.0498648249,
0.0073088575,
0.0289876889,
-0.0077603748,
0.0441906936,
0.0078228312,
0.0394981578,
-0.049481418,
-0.014445968,
0.0394745916,
0.027739739,
0.0459056981,
-0.0310970061,
-0.014969686,
-0.009756525,
-0.0174134504,
-0.0407981239,
-0.0384170152,
-0.0362005234,
-0.0120136244,
0.0030764702,
-0.0261388496,
-0.0574492365,
0.01299698,
0.0144456746,
0.0805376172,
-0.0432952866,
0.015552476,
0.1016454697,
-0.0240619909,
-0.0394610651,
0.0028092987,
-0.0414967015,
0.0196950007,
0.0095354412,
0.0155736655,
-0.0175583269,
0.0261149928,
0.0104420045,
0.0263574738,
0.0072495765,
-0.0262449067,
-0.0147632174,
0.0220311061,
-0.0126361875,
0.0449163839,
0.0295582395,
-0.0426446907,
0.0883680359,
-0.0246607587,
-0.0146410521,
0.0071511045,
0.0369744562,
0.0283113997,
-0.0438187271,
0.0576485582,
0.0181445759,
-0.0265946705,
0.0105972998,
0.0788907185,
-0.0386981145,
0.0708882511,
-0.0089193275,
-0.0219641905,
-0.0527798347,
-0.0022966615,
0.0065129688,
0.0330700651,
0.0266900379,
0.0199445188,
-0.0784240961,
-0.0267683957,
0.0030256317,
-0.0154419402,
0.013137944,
0.0152250687,
0.0270719416,
0.0765179619,
-0.0066177617,
-0.0315021984,
-0.0596959405,
-0.0598316342,
0.0049472786,
0.0125765791,
-0.0108509623,
-6.068608605e-33,
-0.039689716,
0.0038040734,
-0.0187398847,
0.0244131144,
0.0068956441,
0.026655769,
0.0134062264,
0.0501700528,
-0.0423379354,
0.0243954286,
-0.0065024826,
0.0159607381,
0.0275278762,
0.0079410374,
0.0623454414,
-0.0153299663,
0.0569711439,
-0.0145140477,
-0.0135226222,
-0.0317314379,
0.0542314164,
-0.010976729,
0.0455687419,
-0.0856664851,
0.0737740248,
0.0172075033,
-0.0399374738,
-0.0285065677,
-0.0175355077,
0.0665810257,
-0.0258187279,
0.076132752,
0.0245538261,
-0.0471562967,
0.0013053088,
-0.0656812415,
-0.0510249883,
-0.0428867191,
0.0313517898,
0.0340809114,
-0.0242662262,
-0.0088353176,
0.0248085726,
-0.0022026312,
-0.0087285554,
0.0093136262,
0.0406132154,
-0.0343856327,
-0.044803258,
-0.0508754626,
-0.0652125254,
0.0460982248,
-0.0115971453,
-0.0042946925,
0.046643842,
0.0250538196,
-0.0043641864,
-0.0151062543,
-0.0729440749,
-0.0308362003,
-0.0018732098,
0.0183983855,
0.004677128,
0.0001859375,
-0.0110084228,
0.0622657016,
0.0258236472,
0.031368535,
0.0208112802,
0.0151762106,
0.024361087,
0.0246733315,
0.0257351249,
0.0733873323,
0.0297314301,
-0.0062624044,
-0.0448112413,
-0.0109293275,
0.026900515,
-0.0273540057,
0.0364632905,
0.0070859678,
-0.0577265061,
-0.0346346535,
-0.0759474039,
-0.0316484533,
-0.0252328292,
-0.026993189,
0.0268794335,
0.00553245,
-0.0201288424,
0.0727494508,
0.0191136152,
-0.0248940997,
-0.0435353816,
-0.020071689,
-0.0112086004,
0.0530891083,
-0.0085824812,
0.0014868598,
-0.0283439159,
-0.0177121218,
-0.0152844992,
0.0181943569,
0.055215776,
-0.0125426678,
0.1337704957,
-0.0094944322,
-0.0695245415,
-0.0198172163,
-0.0120486747,
0.0165144037,
-0.0291892923,
-0.0249126907,
0.0361619852,
0.0129170325,
-0.0235696267,
0.0211779475,
0.0606121644,
0.0296181571,
-0.0229177587,
-0.0235108044,
-0.0292490199,
-0.0123790167,
0.0005482025,
-0.0103609711,
0.0083848229,
-0.0339503624,
0.0147512387,
-0.0348706134,
-0.0210855622,
0.0043071616,
2.362e-7,
0.105016619,
0.0713108033,
-0.0084777782,
-0.0128231989,
0.0274148844,
0.0247519538,
-0.0154835861,
0.0018272277,
-0.0097121773,
-0.0177505538,
-0.0288067032,
0.0009706344,
0.0199048799,
0.072332643,
-0.0482423156,
-0.038227763,
-0.0449884571,
0.0434511714,
-0.031234825,
0.0217992496,
0.065603286,
0.0834979713,
0.0421074219,
0.0155459503,
-0.0354596265,
-0.0006821887,
0.0810611844,
-0.0465353131,
-0.0080550322,
0.0308806263,
0.0235833935,
0.0373337865,
0.0293041952,
0.0513247661,
-0.0184548311,
-0.0211569928,
0.0383769982,
0.057077229,
0.0116773862,
-0.0234529059,
0.0241688918,
-0.0108770551,
-0.0032429735,
-0.030683795,
0.0413657203,
-0.066424422,
-0.0749815479,
-0.0622089803,
-0.0279119387,
0.0246880352,
0.0537540093,
0.0034640324,
0.0096088396,
0.0149555318,
-0.0203311536,
-0.0074786106,
-0.052462317,
-0.0393001474,
-0.0484620295,
0.0033576728,
0.0104283756,
-0.035376057,
0.0053798002,
-0.0113805961,
0.0086488016,
-0.0861856639,
-0.0196061563,
1.785425883e-34,
0.0534814671,
-0.0162369832,
0.0478404202,
0.0650750548,
0.0084773386,
0.0147773894,
-0.0030368457,
-0.006757251,
-0.0178799685,
-0.0033116189,
0.0062203589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18349v1 | A Boundary Offset Prediction Network for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-10-23T05:04:07 | 2023-10-23T05:04:07 | Minghao Tang, Yongquan He, Yongxiu Xu, Hongbo Xu, Wenyuan Zhang, Yang Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named entity recognition (NER) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing that aims to identify and classify named entities in text. However,
span-based methods for NER typically assign entity types to text spans,
resulting in an imbalanced sample space and neglecting the connections between
non-entity and entity spans. To address these issues, we propose a novel
approach for NER, named the Boundary Offset Prediction Network (BOPN), which
predicts the boundary offsets between candidate spans and their nearest entity
spans. By leveraging the guiding semantics of boundary offsets, BOPN
establishes connections between non-entity and entity spans, enabling
non-entity spans to function as additional positive samples for entity
detection. Furthermore, our method integrates entity type and span
representations to generate type-aware boundary offsets instead of using entity
types as detection targets. We conduct experiments on eight widely-used NER
datasets, and the results demonstrate that our proposed BOPN outperforms
previous state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0191587079,
0.0041820593,
0.007646278,
0.0399097912,
0.0185445622,
0.0167709459,
0.0203545,
-0.005146028,
0.02489952,
-0.0221254379,
-0.0224943571,
-0.0435798801,
-0.0151778627,
0.0631770119,
0.0471613407,
-0.041101221,
0.0279663093,
0.0229123365,
0.0305927321,
0.0385431238,
0.024972016,
0.014583814,
-0.0285898652,
-0.0014969481,
0.0062567256,
0.010105202,
-0.0205330979,
0.0337457024,
0.0556985252,
-0.0842690319,
0.0495046899,
0.0367552936,
0.000277844,
0.08051081,
0.0000017365,
-0.0446294583,
-0.0364244767,
-0.0004776475,
-0.0312278513,
-0.0160695557,
0.0159654841,
-0.0369847193,
-0.0062323362,
-0.0095523531,
-0.0032793956,
-0.0426401831,
0.0383128598,
0.096258603,
0.0140581951,
0.0558993705,
-0.005470355,
0.0049443562,
0.0245489962,
-0.0138192093,
0.0244281758,
-0.0485627241,
0.035356421,
-0.0846204683,
-0.0280799065,
0.016107006,
-0.007996873,
0.0048183841,
-0.0185527615,
0.0220422335,
0.034747649,
0.0742034316,
-0.074126333,
0.0202647168,
-0.0207621343,
0.0890398994,
0.0039358176,
-0.0058153034,
0.0458087884,
-0.0346658081,
-0.0093649775,
-0.0218268391,
0.0091797039,
-0.0161862951,
-0.0333335772,
0.003142942,
-0.0449680984,
0.0566806272,
0.0232182983,
0.020344913,
-0.027181888,
-0.0014078754,
-0.0058318428,
-0.0519089475,
0.0338235497,
0.0408111103,
0.0318342224,
-0.0444841199,
0.0804294944,
0.0124848029,
0.0195813309,
0.0282080807,
-0.0052033938,
-0.0417962521,
0.0017646352,
-0.0010246334,
-0.0348848142,
-0.0169474538,
-0.0295046084,
0.0092002722,
-0.0783113986,
-0.0092354817,
-0.0415409952,
-0.0054842774,
0.0255634915,
-0.0130807804,
-0.0197403375,
-0.0231136475,
-0.0489151143,
0.0226964783,
0.0047532222,
-0.0087772552,
-0.0190238971,
-0.0080147749,
-0.0346371345,
0.0182203464,
0.015000849,
0.0424006172,
-0.0075529353,
-0.021830745,
-0.0179489776,
0.0402647108,
-0.0387391634,
0.0056092096,
-0.0034229211,
-0.0357849747,
-0.0178695526,
-0.0187249687,
0.0456724018,
-0.0529440939,
0.0395234711,
0.0941089168,
0.028038267,
-0.0655225292,
-0.0565236695,
-0.0056537548,
-0.0128504513,
-0.0228153709,
0.0143938735,
-0.0378010459,
0.0120008485,
-0.0033944221,
-0.0294319522,
0.0205979478,
0.0217611883,
0.005563492,
-0.0368843563,
0.0624466352,
-0.060628783,
-0.0399137437,
0.0173379518,
-0.009726516,
0.057104256,
0.0469658487,
0.0568716154,
0.0099126678,
0.0469752587,
0.0399777219,
-0.0256314483,
0.0411288738,
0.0527744703,
-0.0380416699,
0.0069890525,
0.0171354208,
-0.0228510052,
0.039444875,
0.0395114049,
-0.0119205266,
-0.0003323564,
-0.0485440791,
0.0272047762,
0.0359868668,
-0.0345217064,
0.0370838642,
0.0113459993,
0.0016198606,
-0.025039833,
-0.0003874218,
-0.0242727697,
0.0026362208,
-0.0093973707,
-0.0028305545,
0.0055501438,
0.0310062245,
-0.0353623778,
0.0193902943,
0.0073674936,
-0.0063401163,
-0.0085064871,
-0.0134859849,
0.0472196527,
0.0188994575,
-0.0777556375,
0.1009914652,
0.0083311647,
-0.0290081128,
0.0136302346,
0.030731611,
0.0395831205,
0.058034163,
0.0154848555,
-0.0718979985,
-0.0697819963,
-0.0325914361,
0.011604636,
0.0495012999,
0.026743317,
-0.0105516948,
0.019333059,
-0.0387925059,
0.0120224897,
0.0603809953,
0.0209413953,
0.0423015207,
0.0191693511,
0.0405160561,
0.0238873828,
-0.0554511026,
-0.0138135925,
0.0440649763,
0.0182666667,
0.0008607159,
-0.000214641,
0.0435078926,
-0.0125617413,
0.0522052981,
0.0101095494,
-0.0244821217,
0.0189171191,
-0.0325019099,
-0.046032548,
-0.0269870218,
-0.0351061225,
-0.0320375338,
-0.0098724263,
-0.0733702481,
-0.0098534226,
0.024844775,
-0.0458544642,
-0.0413222462,
0.0068031875,
0.0147993732,
-0.0071581234,
-0.0242045429,
-0.0025478073,
0.0079064108,
0.0254418943,
-0.0306929275,
0.0638275295,
0.0073782178,
0.0535627194,
-0.0078005916,
-0.0084046694,
0.0121019958,
-0.0311442353,
-0.0403043367,
0.0077994158,
-0.0077793556,
-0.0339383371,
0.0128619317,
-0.0093698278,
-0.0709001273,
0.0004988579,
-0.0789131448,
0.0255452935,
-0.0120575195,
0.0642681122,
0.0235125441,
0.0025524511,
-0.0251850802,
-0.0406949781,
-0.0243440215,
-0.0374297947,
-0.0162159689,
-0.011325405,
0.0629061908,
0.0107714469,
-0.0097902101,
-0.0001978869,
-0.0146123935,
-0.0588047169,
0.0436195023,
0.0158789381,
-0.0883709192,
-0.0552826673,
0.0259873159,
-0.0308776014,
0.0192210041,
0.011181239,
0.0239778291,
-0.0247231536,
0.0196785089,
-0.0143849468,
0.0632153451,
-0.0005567999,
-0.0264710505,
-0.0308967885,
0.0140972836,
-0.0546725914,
0.0298462827,
-0.0182844512,
0.0712566376,
0.0043699858,
-0.0291157197,
0.0188860968,
0.0622199252,
-0.039144747,
-0.0054260511,
-0.0378173627,
-0.0166601967,
0.013792431,
0.0033154166,
-0.0243065115,
-0.0010090381,
-0.0172363408,
-0.0031589414,
-0.0392769724,
-0.011266713,
0.0561868697,
-0.0368802398,
-0.0285134558,
-0.0046499162,
0.0295139682,
-0.0712045431,
0.0205224361,
0.0383109748,
-0.0063970299,
0.0080673108,
-0.0897758603,
-0.024882514,
0.0806562528,
-0.0172142927,
-0.0100010596,
0.0465537943,
0.0190267935,
0.004010296,
-0.0202856585,
-0.009819407,
-0.0427256599,
-0.0016171472,
-0.0247764848,
0.0081943721,
-0.0366597436,
0.0080051851,
-0.0165257398,
0.0142703718,
-0.0148325348,
0.0645239726,
-0.0151431775,
0.0100742644,
-0.0609859526,
0.0496170074,
0.0079117892,
0.0307484437,
0.0597208925,
0.0077324715,
-0.0221037809,
0.0169400685,
-0.0244467407,
-0.0021465095,
0.0144779356,
-0.0082437396,
0.0281800609,
-0.0769832879,
-0.0077649914,
-0.0084908856,
0.0355788693,
-0.0370216146,
-0.0217848588,
0.0970562696,
0.0307271779,
-0.0425913893,
-0.0195809659,
0.017578451,
0.0357216373,
0.0359765813,
0.000322814,
-0.0641311631,
-0.0297066104,
0.0068009486,
-0.0158795621,
-0.004578969,
-0.0827411935,
0.0113015501,
-0.1292385757,
-0.0186617188,
-0.0296634771,
-0.0614267625,
0.0146860145,
-0.052729588,
0.0234723613,
-0.0281503722,
-0.0120959394,
-0.0188056547,
-0.0119749159,
-0.014369647,
0.0310063995,
0.0036313313,
-0.0508180261,
0.0146992356,
-0.0793499872,
0.041422639,
0.0595807619,
0.0443919785,
-0.0614420548,
-0.0153813437,
0.0015651395,
-0.0732098594,
-0.033259701,
0.0180441123,
0.081273444,
-0.0279723182,
-0.0022253359,
-0.0135346772,
0.0106959967,
-0.0521577001,
-0.0038465436,
0.0277247149,
0.0641871318,
0.0139750997,
-0.0335835181,
-0.0179594904,
-0.002467908,
0.0244474374,
0.083486788,
0.019432677,
-0.0140251936,
-0.0172554031,
0.0199054163,
0.013068134,
-0.0361457728,
0.0123808244,
0.0235541742,
-0.0525887497,
-0.0631783381,
-0.0307279527,
-0.0304989051,
0.0138010755,
0.0413408428,
0.0251568146,
0.0021764911,
0.0159694552,
0.0048080622,
-0.0608951598,
0.0269067585,
-0.0084273992,
0.0468926653,
-0.015571286,
0.0114929946,
-0.005189057,
-0.0255685318,
-0.0493329801,
0.0163414571,
-0.0680512041,
-0.0425508805,
-0.0045256773,
-0.0405654907,
0.0135323247,
0.0321456082,
-0.0126991495,
-0.0365237184,
0.0279550049,
0.063406013,
-0.0426044241,
-0.0332580581,
0.0018897933,
0.0367761999,
-0.0136512592,
0.0276339073,
-0.0249092989,
0.0329799652,
0.0139909247,
0.018579321,
-0.0286965054,
0.0040642228,
-0.0356894359,
-0.0179560259,
0.0764969438,
-0.0032988426,
-0.0286104698,
-0.0734598041,
0.0309372339,
0.0276887324,
0.0193081927,
0.0091930898,
0.013575702,
-0.009486571,
-0.0080457954,
-0.0391154662,
0.0425727293,
0.0074177333,
0.0292438921,
-0.0627467781,
0.0086968672,
0.0010421136,
0.0853322521,
0.0112645114,
-0.0074210991,
0.0149353202,
0.042675972,
0.0407956466,
0.0421680324,
-0.0160423499,
0.0121395737,
0.0482723899,
0.0145897716,
-0.0246824678,
0.0072627142,
-0.0576353632,
0.0876555368,
-0.0471066274,
0.0663903281,
0.0151452897,
-0.0219822153,
0.0120935971,
0.0110981325,
-0.0104277404,
0.0279779416,
-0.0049463306,
-0.0262244288,
-0.0442559421,
0.0486727357,
0.0233244058,
-0.0353856049,
-0.0397242978,
0.0248998664,
0.0129730431,
0.0547132082,
-0.0169466976,
-0.0241989065,
-0.0096486351,
-0.0076263975,
0.0340032578,
0.0188085064,
0.0031667773,
0.0149378879,
-0.0527961217,
-0.0450663194,
0.0682751611,
-0.0366179086,
0.0285710413,
0.0028002863,
0.0290895551,
0.0162799153,
0.0221176594,
-0.0086229127,
0.0116509581,
0.0097025651,
0.0122941872,
-0.0304191634,
-0.0688399151,
-5.849792168e-33,
-0.0329283886,
-0.036542777,
0.0094519919,
-0.01684024,
-0.0394523852,
0.0370050743,
-0.0031437743,
-0.0142145269,
0.0097207148,
-0.007580651,
0.0163868666,
0.0163718313,
0.0265525617,
0.006780982,
-0.0215155445,
-0.0718586594,
0.0564288087,
0.0122461803,
-0.0065133474,
0.0083700009,
0.013049636,
0.0780693293,
0.0849614516,
-0.0770764276,
0.028410593,
-0.0270893499,
0.0016725998,
0.0042628339,
0.0706991181,
0.0388229564,
-0.0104650017,
0.0076380949,
0.0365643017,
-0.0182248894,
0.0073678968,
0.0417398661,
-0.1332156062,
-0.0063926666,
-0.034894105,
0.0630274639,
0.0065042572,
-0.0344967842,
0.0423735082,
-0.0186849311,
0.0019556819,
0.0097651593,
0.0718384683,
-0.0085381744,
-0.001394205,
-0.0484551899,
-0.050366383,
0.0488798395,
-0.0037993812,
0.0542299077,
0.0128136603,
-0.0048972671,
0.038829878,
0.0179735813,
-0.0893726423,
-0.0125113353,
0.0450857803,
-0.0096289432,
0.0011557504,
0.0254340712,
-0.0307735074,
0.0724212304,
0.0404632203,
-0.0147196036,
-0.050217621,
-0.0166819394,
0.0373636037,
-0.0322775431,
0.008242677,
0.041372139,
0.0460072905,
-0.0334858708,
-0.0690524429,
0.0239437204,
-0.0213087518,
-0.0368830897,
-0.0091562718,
-0.0229164623,
-0.0355525874,
0.014843639,
-0.0030235946,
-0.0419872478,
-0.0451051295,
0.0082660392,
0.0203287192,
0.0166810155,
-0.0114885131,
0.0862201527,
0.0025331182,
-0.012868478,
-0.0553539246,
0.008845144,
0.0272229407,
-0.0034678855,
0.0368650854,
0.0009036355,
-0.0736835375,
-0.0276256092,
0.0088270213,
-0.0062794089,
0.0014232527,
-0.0168478843,
0.0938531011,
-0.0305911973,
-0.0742225423,
0.0000548694,
-0.0240237471,
0.0220345315,
0.0017680993,
0.0631946847,
0.0211885124,
-0.0213718433,
-0.0153372986,
0.0190108027,
0.0732666329,
-0.0049542063,
-0.0155812148,
0.0464356244,
-0.0056935134,
0.0399519876,
-0.0249921381,
-0.0079949005,
0.0254667923,
-0.0412852578,
0.0286694616,
-0.0799468532,
0.0132586705,
-0.0114848707,
2.478e-7,
0.0029246502,
0.0231653396,
0.0419175066,
-0.0167742986,
0.0271390863,
0.004905256,
0.0157822128,
0.067626223,
-0.0405941866,
-0.009162195,
-0.0142642492,
-0.0383190438,
-0.0176811107,
0.0196050629,
-0.1183705628,
-0.0079600187,
-0.0118425973,
-0.0022850975,
-0.0641605332,
-0.0004985499,
0.0233320985,
0.0474992357,
-0.0000638867,
-0.0081706131,
0.0066740038,
0.0039841528,
0.0317914374,
0.016662702,
0.0724914223,
0.0423437692,
0.0179386083,
0.03455,
-0.040918462,
0.0437520482,
0.0148243252,
0.0640771538,
0.028793877,
0.0235976819,
-0.0008351166,
0.0123768291,
-0.0090554059,
-0.0639011189,
0.0068422304,
-0.0091357855,
0.0496335104,
-0.0172680803,
-0.0136496164,
-0.0160466656,
-0.0236432347,
-0.0113640763,
0.0077289538,
0.0258049835,
0.0075915093,
0.048724059,
0.0079133799,
-0.0506071299,
-0.0047685332,
-0.089481473,
-0.007683618,
0.0148737021,
-0.0214758702,
0.0206782259,
-0.021555014,
-0.0044069332,
0.0151062477,
-0.1096306071,
0.0105421571,
2.42565119e-34,
-0.0270844884,
0.0091814296,
-0.0485641621,
0.0105955312,
0.0175726078,
-0.0363151878,
-0.0316764414,
-0.0162319988,
0.0045270701,
-0.0149001256,
0.0136519661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14566v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14566v5 | HallusionBench: An Advanced Diagnostic Suite for Entangled Language Hallucination and Visual Illusion in Large Vision-Language Models | 2023-10-23T04:49:09 | 2024-03-25T06:05:24 | Tianrui Guan, Fuxiao Liu, Xiyang Wu, Ruiqi Xian, Zongxia Li, Xiaoyu Liu, Xijun Wang, Lichang Chen, Furong Huang, Yaser Yacoob, Dinesh Manocha, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce HallusionBench, a comprehensive benchmark designed for the
evaluation of image-context reasoning. This benchmark presents significant
challenges to advanced large visual-language models (LVLMs), such as
GPT-4V(Vision), Gemini Pro Vision, Claude 3, and LLaVA-1.5, by emphasizing
nuanced understanding and interpretation of visual data. The benchmark
comprises 346 images paired with 1129 questions, all meticulously crafted by
human experts. We introduce a novel structure for these visual questions
designed to establish control groups. This structure enables us to conduct a
quantitative analysis of the models' response tendencies, logical consistency,
and various failure modes. In our evaluation on HallusionBench, we benchmarked
15 different models, highlighting a 31.42% question-pair accuracy achieved by
the state-of-the-art GPT-4V. Notably, all other evaluated models achieve
accuracy below 16%. Moreover, our analysis not only highlights the observed
failure modes, including language hallucination and visual illusion, but also
deepens an understanding of these pitfalls. Our comprehensive case studies
within HallusionBench shed light on the challenges of hallucination and
illusion in LVLMs. Based on these insights, we suggest potential pathways for
their future improvement. The benchmark and codebase can be accessed at
https://github.com/tianyi-lab/HallusionBench. | [
0.0065553193,
0.0847507194,
-0.0305390973,
0.1045420468,
-0.0612066351,
0.0350982323,
-0.0041024494,
0.0213404205,
-0.0065690861,
-0.0271416456,
-0.0134848375,
-0.0487716086,
0.0304956343,
0.030678967,
0.039452035,
-0.0575063415,
0.0356065109,
-0.0518959612,
-0.0568303429,
-0.0214775726,
0.0012537789,
-0.0321638361,
0.0000481765,
0.0111119347,
-0.0052652834,
-0.0343439393,
-0.0130072637,
0.0326654129,
0.0193936862,
0.0124339992,
-0.0349539556,
0.0501524098,
0.0232431479,
0.0337298922,
0.0000021946,
-0.027040869,
0.0187550373,
-0.0048632915,
-0.0029216083,
0.0008543506,
-0.0242576338,
-0.0486024767,
0.0033035984,
-0.0014366353,
-0.0171428826,
-0.0201474484,
0.0543430597,
0.0560956076,
0.072565414,
0.0527560301,
-0.0157340802,
-0.0379810371,
0.0162319764,
-0.0157637578,
0.0322786495,
-0.015728116,
0.0385016166,
0.0449519381,
-0.0132035082,
-0.0355667286,
-0.0407298468,
0.0238431841,
0.0871439129,
0.0245682262,
-0.0160791222,
0.0280739702,
-0.0719524547,
-0.0584680736,
-0.0190446582,
0.0642415583,
-0.0427316464,
-0.0384059474,
0.001371842,
0.0111280251,
0.0028707194,
0.004191611,
0.0084038517,
0.0243438687,
-0.007640684,
0.0144490395,
-0.0082745217,
-0.0015535159,
0.027379375,
0.0034268536,
-0.0496179089,
0.0204210784,
0.0266264621,
0.0050467043,
-0.0089594498,
0.0241895206,
-0.0720518976,
-0.0668253228,
-0.0192818511,
-0.0086554512,
-0.0388999619,
-0.0174639374,
-0.0236910265,
-0.0055764923,
-0.0127938939,
-0.0426038913,
-0.0148399845,
0.0205351505,
-0.0475835353,
0.0746540502,
-0.0219806265,
0.0909846425,
-0.0320205837,
0.0868834853,
-0.0127710067,
-0.0321240649,
-0.0138577884,
0.00674405,
-0.0332770124,
-0.021517165,
-0.0544723012,
-0.0640331805,
-0.0052190851,
-0.0304190833,
-0.0496463627,
0.0468929633,
-0.0248991624,
0.0305839814,
0.0244233832,
-0.048447147,
-0.034286499,
0.0205270685,
0.0071926326,
0.0078274738,
-0.025814794,
-0.0691780746,
0.0025034237,
0.0453192703,
-0.0506426431,
-0.0221881643,
-0.0039723245,
0.0157857891,
-0.0041373023,
-0.0288779475,
0.0047273603,
0.0063942838,
-0.0068550217,
-0.0877551064,
0.0406762697,
-0.0588092059,
0.0166547578,
-0.0225949585,
-0.0043877377,
-0.0133472541,
0.0218687207,
-0.0138231646,
-0.0274036694,
0.1328131109,
-0.029607255,
-0.0131933326,
-0.0247009322,
0.0520084202,
0.0059138332,
0.071187146,
0.0005963065,
0.0716595873,
-0.0066626235,
-0.0060208547,
0.0545044728,
0.0120367948,
-0.0011631724,
0.0140281655,
-0.1000994369,
0.0325064175,
0.0124656251,
0.0208999515,
-0.0201851912,
0.0783163682,
-0.0389977805,
-0.0568640903,
0.0651440099,
0.0073701604,
0.0211384911,
-0.0401555002,
-0.0030092124,
-0.0226772297,
0.0146976979,
-0.0000416873,
-0.0863193721,
0.0629702434,
-0.0032870385,
-0.0012667192,
-0.0043311683,
-0.0020461683,
-0.0350810289,
-0.045356065,
-0.0225301199,
-0.0015310897,
0.0053723464,
0.0567263849,
0.0260720085,
0.0107244831,
-0.0654912218,
-0.0320949443,
0.0135284634,
-0.0061507481,
0.0101564461,
-0.0454568304,
0.0221916568,
0.0935380608,
0.0588046163,
0.0153887691,
0.0260442197,
-0.0020946956,
0.0177412201,
0.0474093519,
0.0091505898,
0.0324679911,
0.0294928961,
-0.0395192653,
-0.0144526456,
-0.0241881683,
0.0169562399,
-0.0015899832,
-0.0037200036,
-0.0129221547,
-0.0080886502,
-0.0346815735,
0.0393571556,
0.0301866345,
-0.0001706271,
0.0239749849,
-0.0353944525,
0.0042497176,
0.0155371763,
-0.0143208709,
-0.0158443358,
0.0033349784,
0.0085672894,
-0.025863668,
-0.0143937599,
-0.0070292405,
-0.0192750953,
-0.0589917004,
0.0198538657,
-0.0844749808,
-0.0245431308,
0.0133146886,
-0.0265216269,
-0.0188290458,
0.0283712558,
0.0059976829,
0.0258984081,
-0.0535833091,
0.0265441332,
0.0096557373,
0.048593618,
0.0061356421,
0.0707903579,
-0.0395169519,
-0.0124739334,
0.0188473593,
0.0593434647,
0.0035816624,
-0.0203574449,
-0.0008880973,
0.0320928171,
0.0087827621,
-0.0055587441,
-0.0394366421,
-0.0186632816,
-0.0644687563,
0.0030618832,
-0.0573746562,
-0.0334999636,
-0.0431875736,
-0.0545376875,
0.0073311115,
-0.0323300809,
0.0040358528,
-0.0335363001,
-0.0058355755,
0.045125898,
0.0070573725,
0.01221749,
0.0043862108,
-0.0118695395,
-0.0282931775,
0.0045491685,
0.0131489392,
0.0246101543,
0.059097629,
-0.0075538433,
-0.0249902625,
-0.051414486,
0.0183870681,
-0.0337482095,
0.0538085699,
-0.0333122313,
-0.0184720382,
-0.016760299,
-0.0189767499,
0.0247401576,
0.084841013,
-0.0182736367,
0.0508736782,
0.0370019749,
-0.0021484212,
-0.0020472652,
-0.0357968509,
0.0079361284,
0.0091773011,
-0.0059709563,
-0.0274195746,
-0.0366149917,
0.0225001667,
-0.0043508266,
0.0154010886,
-0.0825028867,
0.0497996919,
0.0073946151,
-0.0730718747,
-0.0294400342,
0.0000767336,
0.0115202833,
0.0557847731,
-0.0449505337,
-0.0544910505,
0.051726412,
-0.0295502245,
-0.0074429456,
0.0222506355,
0.0239899755,
0.0081907716,
0.0588656142,
0.0596182793,
0.0079528689,
-0.0131968083,
0.0037581841,
-0.0619421341,
-0.0172801428,
-0.0173520818,
-0.0226519331,
0.0126037188,
-0.0783528835,
0.0048617069,
0.0202853754,
-0.0323551334,
-0.0418660752,
0.0129658673,
-0.0201862678,
-0.0184434094,
-0.0571650825,
0.0001776152,
-0.0059703221,
0.0232479144,
0.0035303214,
-0.0222801156,
-0.0043476876,
0.0083075985,
-0.0399195552,
0.0295010209,
0.0880049989,
0.0171949826,
0.0552648716,
-0.0731841773,
0.0279256627,
0.0784980506,
-0.0156545006,
0.0406578109,
-0.038981881,
0.0481438115,
0.0121155875,
0.0659086332,
-0.0045713298,
0.0220371373,
0.0226916615,
-0.0393872894,
-0.0196520928,
0.0780292079,
0.0263573583,
-0.0413580909,
-0.008978866,
-0.0044995858,
0.0309493449,
0.0275306683,
-0.0009935505,
-0.1117629856,
-0.0474403575,
0.0057260296,
-0.0368194655,
0.0129132317,
0.0102185104,
-0.0144515252,
-0.0737619773,
0.0585303083,
0.0091620889,
0.0124238348,
-0.059643466,
0.0036588046,
-0.0045339298,
-0.0020353508,
0.0644358546,
-0.0000723989,
0.0402324833,
-0.0230373181,
-0.0302955098,
0.0426595472,
-0.0192875154,
0.0295697171,
-0.0176892281,
0.0217477605,
0.0536183827,
0.0057225456,
0.0101850946,
-0.1089346111,
0.0081721665,
-0.0124971066,
-0.0238592792,
0.0068925899,
0.0659521669,
0.01588016,
-0.0449803844,
0.0056173839,
0.0243338365,
-0.0126003483,
-0.0269473772,
-0.0356936343,
0.0105761643,
-0.0317321979,
-0.0580522865,
-0.0136701493,
0.0054953741,
-0.0251439996,
0.0591466203,
0.0264680553,
-0.0131411627,
-0.0754102618,
0.0021472832,
0.0493609495,
-0.0077753519,
-0.0205905121,
0.0425489135,
0.0814768374,
-0.0248384401,
-0.0423350707,
-0.0016939803,
0.0171773396,
0.0413385443,
-0.0284046978,
-0.0100591583,
-0.0230317917,
-0.0037553855,
-0.0159359556,
0.0536016077,
-0.0452348143,
0.0499895886,
-0.0272835791,
0.0298300348,
0.0023847225,
-0.0421531983,
0.0007569491,
0.0276364591,
-0.0946659371,
-0.037798658,
0.0010966738,
0.0504356995,
0.0204467848,
0.0807083324,
-0.0061966511,
-0.0331817381,
0.0038373042,
0.0124214496,
0.0689509735,
0.0350585654,
0.0025870122,
-0.0171028208,
0.0119729452,
0.0418418497,
0.0077824448,
0.0187051017,
0.0255488604,
0.0019970196,
-0.0199233908,
0.0202717241,
0.0188913513,
-0.0125935301,
0.0267116595,
-0.0013930887,
0.0044422802,
0.0088334866,
0.0117903454,
-0.0265432689,
0.0029756683,
-0.0593162253,
-0.0216154642,
0.0410940275,
0.0165728163,
0.0268999096,
-0.0223140717,
0.007851799,
-0.0203537215,
-0.0351263657,
-0.0527004674,
0.0059121698,
0.0023521285,
0.0459566824,
0.0044316938,
0.0211978089,
0.0370596014,
-0.0017903802,
0.0672128424,
0.0170841478,
0.0622911006,
0.0511195883,
-0.0408654325,
-0.0415221713,
0.0215473417,
-0.0245688055,
-0.0719529763,
-0.005352553,
0.0717072487,
0.0621412769,
0.0371339396,
0.0251164567,
-0.0446060337,
-0.0118181482,
-0.0099728806,
0.0407239497,
0.0334206857,
-0.0433418006,
0.0414126553,
0.0183114037,
-0.0139373941,
-0.007898123,
0.0310001597,
0.0293260124,
-0.0060637668,
0.0097234286,
0.0150257666,
-0.0312070101,
-0.0398068987,
0.0088706547,
0.0120927962,
-0.0098160664,
0.0500833467,
-0.0514551811,
-0.0670727193,
-0.0520201549,
0.0312540196,
0.0169897955,
0.029262498,
0.0244162288,
0.039376691,
-0.0037886999,
-0.0309722256,
0.0060784793,
-0.0398952402,
0.0410240591,
-0.0082285153,
0.0264712293,
-6.739180378e-33,
-0.0064362953,
-0.0248163436,
0.0318257175,
-0.0529805757,
-0.0013445223,
-0.0056465208,
-0.0330725685,
-0.0132782459,
-0.0342401303,
0.0244056825,
0.0279133115,
0.0486645848,
-0.0043762536,
0.0370349698,
-0.03198478,
-0.0319159627,
0.0197766908,
0.0332842916,
-0.0284784846,
-0.0061773062,
-0.0003299984,
-0.0216125548,
0.0345893279,
-0.054710336,
-0.0094391806,
0.0083772084,
-0.0617756695,
0.0437721722,
-0.0475609079,
0.0129349027,
-0.0353699215,
-0.0104479911,
0.0001514146,
-0.0140267741,
-0.0162836686,
-0.0179947745,
-0.0364939906,
-0.0047561866,
0.0155414781,
0.0524093956,
-0.091079548,
0.0158196408,
0.0481674001,
0.0056653614,
-0.0114460606,
-0.0208968967,
0.0202543028,
-0.0304772258,
-0.005504976,
0.0477187447,
-0.0271528251,
-0.0256878193,
0.0020281684,
-0.0295422506,
0.0489922948,
0.0110472729,
-0.0181143563,
0.0250634961,
-0.0723686442,
-0.011671395,
-0.0083770566,
-0.0507564954,
0.08714284,
0.0344825089,
0.026362326,
0.0577198602,
0.0818901062,
-0.024976531,
-0.0388406776,
-0.0209287684,
0.0092907632,
0.0721785054,
0.0667422414,
0.0303073991,
0.0484522507,
0.0204006694,
-0.0289734919,
-0.0487885587,
-0.0595163479,
0.0283811614,
0.0233363491,
0.0042312047,
-0.0307718441,
-0.0373835601,
-0.027636826,
-0.0078904452,
-0.0499234088,
0.0153195178,
0.0519585833,
0.0122823976,
-0.0199563541,
0.0044521168,
0.0591039136,
-0.0570805036,
-0.0048117037,
0.0096899895,
-0.0123188049,
0.0473587289,
0.0178041235,
0.0531242974,
-0.0038137715,
-0.0203773472,
0.0507173315,
0.0126855047,
0.0123020513,
0.0000666178,
0.0133546842,
-0.0233917572,
-0.0146608436,
-0.0000576801,
-0.0599832907,
0.0294906311,
0.0297951475,
-0.0095858816,
0.0415179022,
0.0195619464,
-0.0316094793,
-0.0009435473,
0.0110480413,
-0.0092951143,
-0.0044044615,
0.0059768399,
-0.0335482173,
0.0165429041,
-0.0119191855,
-0.0146376761,
-0.0602038652,
-0.0405953489,
0.0513782538,
-0.0418174118,
-0.027136378,
0.0093351183,
2.838e-7,
-0.0229129624,
0.0440269113,
-0.0037967793,
0.0250904839,
0.0374810435,
0.0412611403,
-0.0130670518,
0.0007677047,
0.0081156436,
-0.0718783364,
-0.004168157,
0.0592691824,
0.0478273593,
0.0024656744,
-0.0027250757,
0.0320821255,
-0.0190303419,
-0.036932148,
-0.0474240556,
0.0191588048,
0.0456812307,
0.0661643967,
0.0200874861,
-0.0223714914,
0.0834659711,
-0.0200112127,
0.0615080558,
-0.035021849,
0.0083321733,
-0.0111334985,
-0.0167133976,
0.0397261195,
0.0069079739,
0.0424496122,
0.0232929885,
-0.0360307582,
0.0226342045,
-0.004799806,
-0.035284169,
-0.0377675332,
-0.0782105997,
0.0067062774,
-0.0054618632,
-0.0919156075,
0.1007215008,
-0.0379453264,
-0.0264460407,
0.0208390765,
-0.0386327878,
-0.0265527684,
0.0627294704,
0.0216324665,
-0.0320069082,
0.0076484801,
0.0203621835,
0.0140469652,
-0.0239217244,
-0.0559772179,
0.0180571619,
-0.0131877633,
-0.0278301705,
-0.0014832577,
-0.0388180278,
0.0125709595,
0.0235029776,
-0.0282919221,
-0.0415519252,
2.781276572e-34,
0.0316002034,
-0.0047342745,
0.0425913483,
-0.0015885017,
0.0463302173,
-0.0181467086,
-0.0044068219,
0.0021740729,
-0.0101887956,
-0.0512429327,
0.0007975705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14564v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14564v2 | Language Models Hallucinate, but May Excel at Fact Verification | 2023-10-23T04:39:01 | 2024-03-21T02:56:22 | Jian Guan, Jesse Dodge, David Wadden, Minlie Huang, Hao Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent progress in natural language processing (NLP) owes much to remarkable
advances in large language models (LLMs). Nevertheless, LLMs frequently
"hallucinate," resulting in non-factual outputs. Our carefully-designed human
evaluation substantiates the serious hallucination issue, revealing that even
GPT-3.5 produces factual outputs less than 25% of the time. This underscores
the importance of fact verifiers in order to measure and incentivize progress.
Our systematic investigation affirms that LLMs can be repurposed as effective
fact verifiers with strong correlations with human judgments. Surprisingly,
FLAN-T5-11B, the least factual generator in our study, performs the best as a
fact verifier, even outperforming more capable LLMs like GPT3.5 and ChatGPT.
Delving deeper, we analyze the reliance of these LLMs on high-quality evidence,
as well as their deficiencies in robustness and generalization ability. Our
study presents insights for developing trustworthy generation models. | [
0.0635817349,
0.0433381945,
-0.0020885002,
0.0426530279,
-0.0588632151,
-0.0113470638,
0.0000988963,
-0.0219350513,
-0.0104089314,
-0.0455027334,
0.0052170632,
-0.0526675619,
0.0408792906,
0.0414051302,
0.0358526185,
-0.0314954519,
0.0591171868,
-0.0171333067,
0.0289856754,
-0.0100605115,
0.0126662096,
0.0257504527,
0.0164698865,
0.0512260236,
-0.0364053734,
-0.0056003048,
0.0364304408,
-0.0298689958,
0.0116497306,
-0.0105422055,
-0.0080861645,
0.057638552,
-0.0094410731,
0.0736037046,
0.0000020703,
-0.0433678888,
0.0164192356,
0.0144323586,
-0.0447562188,
0.0644593909,
0.0619363785,
0.0083993878,
-0.0318727642,
0.0263158642,
-0.0392945558,
-0.0243151356,
0.0246568397,
0.0805013776,
0.0668601468,
0.0764815286,
0.0062894663,
-0.024882609,
0.0550781488,
-0.0053056967,
0.0125645259,
-0.0236726608,
0.0280355942,
0.0174374711,
-0.0163690727,
0.0235300418,
0.0087908758,
0.0138696702,
0.0155522227,
0.0079074064,
0.0058490154,
0.0579958297,
-0.0633807927,
-0.0518582538,
-0.000066924,
0.0424937308,
-0.0157472305,
-0.0530648902,
-0.0184194557,
-0.0110849813,
-0.0095778927,
0.0086080721,
-0.0055649234,
0.0612207502,
-0.0351836532,
0.0043866113,
0.0530874282,
0.0059186183,
0.0365909226,
0.0316859782,
-0.0156974979,
0.0700705871,
0.0101305107,
-0.0400994159,
0.0044128578,
0.0176061839,
-0.0467740186,
-0.0647611097,
0.0020259684,
-0.0201423783,
-0.021051364,
0.0150283454,
-0.0280113742,
0.0323245227,
0.0566644147,
-0.0661394969,
-0.0301497988,
0.0124028968,
-0.0565927364,
0.0411754102,
-0.0371033438,
0.0421255976,
-0.0140676657,
0.0230963435,
0.0091965003,
0.0016208383,
-0.0290692169,
-0.0064238636,
-0.0176565666,
0.0082977992,
0.0022577466,
-0.0068079564,
-0.0464209057,
-0.0100675691,
-0.0122578479,
0.0315504186,
0.010732986,
0.0194530468,
-0.0090256622,
-0.0129103381,
-0.0608068928,
0.0220021456,
-0.0073489314,
0.0255435817,
0.0076200832,
-0.0902672634,
-0.0071097841,
0.0078805042,
-0.0232305061,
-0.005966668,
0.011316468,
0.0110021839,
0.028584877,
-0.0372804776,
-0.0518373251,
-0.0318996534,
-0.0337975472,
-0.1163143292,
-0.023382131,
-0.07649149,
-0.0022792933,
0.0067126723,
-0.0123417191,
-0.0192439184,
0.0116277281,
0.0488403291,
-0.0427153148,
0.0524388514,
-0.0168189369,
0.0095768999,
0.0119825043,
0.0075853053,
-0.0138825215,
0.0373981111,
0.0326769948,
0.0596069098,
0.0291284937,
0.0178854838,
0.039711114,
0.0172985159,
-0.0013877285,
-0.0141664715,
0.0348436087,
-0.0132024474,
-0.0131870853,
-0.0024017447,
0.0224066582,
0.0984740853,
-0.0385134295,
-0.0139761791,
0.104045175,
0.0075685242,
0.0047446406,
0.0169834476,
0.0722278506,
0.0085990569,
0.0216361787,
0.0217669643,
-0.0759260878,
-0.0031096952,
-0.0284191892,
0.0046576117,
0.0117314868,
0.0735144466,
-0.0037751549,
-0.0430294238,
-0.0348145515,
0.0013010487,
0.0069667152,
-0.007682621,
0.0212938543,
0.0137190782,
-0.0442404598,
0.0160970688,
0.0341175161,
-0.0411523543,
-0.0020888224,
-0.0646670386,
0.051123783,
0.0555422008,
0.0824533403,
0.0333769098,
0.0249822922,
-0.0288614947,
-0.0079357438,
0.0566188097,
0.0625840127,
0.0086437883,
-0.0100377146,
-0.0363616683,
0.0148077728,
0.0031847223,
0.0527117327,
0.0156027684,
0.0508813187,
-0.0087435739,
0.0265768711,
-0.0456276126,
-0.0437628552,
0.0247338619,
-0.0019759631,
0.0032228492,
-0.0099008838,
-0.0274440031,
0.0141446926,
0.0103748003,
-0.0282022953,
0.0343063697,
0.0139999706,
0.004047012,
-0.0099355541,
0.0176371448,
-0.0190198664,
-0.0192267243,
0.034070082,
-0.0141498223,
-0.019940462,
0.0065363464,
-0.0224176515,
-0.0059176735,
-0.0021936458,
-0.0626221374,
0.0265445262,
-0.0549510755,
0.035531491,
0.0133153396,
0.0328815691,
0.000642613,
0.0964050591,
-0.0263521578,
-0.0116098449,
-0.020129079,
0.0147610614,
-0.0074802455,
-0.0411680751,
-0.017886132,
0.0279496294,
0.0197641924,
0.0243471675,
0.042568773,
-0.0018572226,
-0.0352702215,
-0.0221577734,
-0.0452115983,
0.0080645522,
-0.0193122104,
-0.0025372161,
0.0162642747,
-0.0416162461,
-0.0052450686,
0.0372470021,
-0.0260789338,
-0.0237526018,
0.0497382507,
0.0192092434,
0.0368867405,
-0.0133808432,
-0.0293381289,
-0.028956145,
0.0253629498,
-0.0010697942,
0.0350323692,
0.0174846239,
-0.0063301451,
-0.0605575256,
0.0447902158,
-0.0568264164,
0.0016431242,
0.0021304325,
-0.0167863201,
0.0169073604,
0.0205482487,
0.0480379052,
0.0205911584,
0.028481178,
0.0135245742,
0.0421035551,
-0.0068068737,
-0.0360989049,
-0.0107084131,
-0.0238179415,
-0.0205861703,
0.0058162883,
-0.0536033958,
0.0157769453,
0.0244855396,
0.0340170041,
-0.001950732,
-0.0489452146,
0.043280609,
-0.0277146026,
-0.020796515,
0.0333428085,
-0.0348642468,
-0.0268608052,
0.0386638045,
-0.0439361595,
-0.0473290645,
0.0665187463,
-0.0602134652,
0.0209884457,
-0.0363746062,
-0.000242105,
-0.0091468114,
0.0222825371,
0.0239563584,
0.0134903565,
0.0105214361,
0.0128153414,
-0.0021292726,
-0.0163521096,
0.0408607647,
-0.0550448596,
0.0397454947,
-0.0422297344,
0.0185578726,
0.0235751793,
-0.0280098543,
-0.0531440973,
-0.0669642538,
-0.0274033956,
-0.0134458961,
0.0105516091,
-0.0097818198,
-0.03955606,
-0.0168437418,
0.0486239828,
0.0175330881,
-0.0043086573,
-0.0127630783,
-0.0014001151,
0.0170556977,
0.0387575142,
-0.0065772911,
0.0851011425,
-0.0077172541,
-0.0146133574,
0.0791162625,
0.012884588,
0.0097516002,
-0.0340285227,
-0.0282070301,
0.0045660348,
-0.0137285274,
-0.0366834514,
0.0262045022,
0.0506793,
-0.0613515899,
-0.0113121178,
0.1052581891,
0.0232898127,
0.0218439586,
0.0070554172,
0.0173415709,
0.0393443592,
-0.0065003363,
-0.0186418407,
-0.0881796777,
-0.0168309677,
0.0050942753,
-0.003241434,
-0.0454266407,
-0.0355863757,
-0.0394015871,
-0.1346889138,
0.0718873441,
0.0214419365,
0.0264439024,
-0.0338284709,
-0.0586539693,
-0.0161501151,
-0.0271083042,
0.0389101058,
0.0254054684,
0.0120577235,
0.0035331086,
0.0165849272,
-0.0332681052,
-0.0686504841,
0.0595936291,
-0.0437223911,
0.0754178166,
0.0558570325,
0.0313638747,
-0.0064055566,
-0.0822092742,
0.0043964013,
0.0048420038,
-0.0064165266,
0.0063944743,
0.0487814136,
-0.01304173,
0.0116045885,
-0.0286230613,
-0.0010150316,
0.0012154334,
-0.0266427211,
-0.032426443,
0.0542774089,
-0.0017692153,
-0.0508355759,
-0.0092019765,
0.0375912376,
-0.0249978043,
0.0912822932,
0.0213385448,
0.0001176241,
-0.0486443527,
-0.0407744907,
-0.0023483136,
-0.0172793306,
-0.0634933934,
0.0394462496,
0.008379763,
-0.0374463797,
-0.086047329,
-0.0367768779,
0.0105621405,
0.0192707889,
-0.0239034481,
-0.0088416021,
0.0115837594,
-0.0107042259,
0.014640878,
0.0322555415,
-0.0563158095,
0.0197082385,
-0.046516221,
0.0214572977,
0.033436913,
-0.0329278484,
0.0016479435,
0.074039273,
-0.0786862671,
-0.070798181,
0.0191761311,
0.0277686231,
0.0320177004,
0.0172417387,
-0.0336526521,
-0.0270298216,
0.0337365605,
0.0482194908,
-0.052636005,
0.020871155,
0.015892975,
-0.0230495781,
0.0070451964,
0.003254188,
-0.0120843342,
0.0293337889,
0.0077105756,
0.029465558,
-0.0001339462,
-0.0269083027,
0.0575583763,
0.0579189286,
0.0407329462,
-0.0539637245,
0.0193888973,
-0.0316598229,
-0.0297825653,
-0.0373838432,
-0.0239171386,
-0.0248732697,
0.0268315021,
0.0305285212,
0.0113342283,
-0.0368551388,
-0.0185756311,
-0.0437135063,
0.0481197387,
-0.0173118711,
-0.0521698296,
-0.0131632173,
0.0099510131,
0.0111475764,
-0.0383803882,
-0.0448504724,
-0.0003729,
-0.032986749,
0.0367414653,
0.003120749,
0.0356452875,
-0.0063433875,
-0.0272184927,
-0.0128964009,
0.0103711234,
-0.0693408251,
-0.0283970311,
-0.0653682575,
0.0312161054,
0.0506559312,
0.0043265056,
0.0690243989,
-0.052091103,
-0.0051113521,
-0.0264470167,
-0.0088302949,
0.022950992,
-0.0448937677,
-0.0082705794,
0.003101713,
-0.0543558486,
-0.0136142969,
0.0629455,
0.0113663329,
0.058274366,
0.0031883859,
-0.0358090177,
-0.0369502641,
-0.0756621286,
-0.0558110252,
-0.0276123825,
-0.0201962255,
0.001898205,
-0.0951758176,
-0.0624112524,
-0.0018203842,
0.0320999883,
0.0517746508,
-0.0217999592,
0.0039646486,
0.0754547566,
-0.0106731718,
-0.0113356682,
-0.0405005813,
-0.0238025896,
0.040201541,
0.0117310453,
-0.0269110743,
-6.829362835e-33,
-0.0256397463,
-0.0337646976,
0.0175309591,
-0.0089076217,
-0.0133247618,
-0.0013478807,
-0.013570236,
0.0062754964,
-0.0255204234,
0.0362450369,
-0.0047434145,
0.0123418672,
0.0196366906,
-0.0036426133,
-0.0066684983,
-0.0030983896,
0.0681937635,
0.0126929916,
-0.0555217825,
0.0239241831,
0.0399113186,
-0.0235072188,
0.0550398491,
-0.0754382685,
0.0524436533,
0.0007537873,
-0.0590971932,
0.0042024083,
-0.0534502007,
0.0326333903,
-0.0231452994,
0.051255025,
0.0246750563,
-0.0597878061,
-0.0145743648,
-0.0284127854,
-0.0499581695,
-0.0017372069,
0.0624903068,
-0.0137808574,
-0.0048618512,
-0.0040509002,
0.0361218564,
-0.0184215102,
-0.0414006636,
0.0144215189,
0.0118503291,
-0.0254385155,
-0.0119284932,
-0.0183604266,
-0.0427752696,
0.0469172932,
0.0322607793,
-0.0027036152,
-0.0348005518,
0.024959404,
-0.0265519843,
-0.0110350316,
-0.0845954642,
0.0503047332,
0.0189472735,
0.0061961738,
0.0410067476,
-0.045881018,
-0.0150524275,
0.0707637444,
0.0056459298,
0.0120694097,
-0.0567310192,
-0.0090501187,
0.0134057002,
0.0593687184,
0.0466206111,
0.0977768749,
0.0243709162,
-0.0370865986,
-0.0437956825,
0.0200751144,
0.0110766925,
0.0309524592,
0.0457898751,
-0.0296552982,
-0.0669770092,
-0.0260943435,
-0.029605113,
0.0134510202,
-0.0261311997,
-0.0172407702,
0.0051277876,
0.0368068777,
-0.0118416436,
-0.0097183641,
0.0138511322,
-0.0403225049,
0.0116301486,
0.0215317905,
-0.0511231273,
-0.0070614102,
-0.0160840619,
0.0262819249,
-0.0648505613,
0.022908004,
0.0178656839,
0.0235042516,
-0.0149429142,
0.0186465383,
0.0255003534,
0.009786102,
-0.0569304451,
0.0373200178,
-0.0369642824,
0.0470262095,
0.0093089119,
-0.0307630152,
0.045667585,
-0.0150952106,
-0.0321353525,
0.0115533778,
0.0112766186,
0.0363094509,
-0.0394308083,
0.0288240481,
0.0049369354,
0.0317896716,
-0.0293070506,
0.019675225,
-0.0331231765,
0.0046451404,
0.025283685,
-0.0518115498,
-0.0080414442,
-0.0080125351,
2.818e-7,
-0.0070355167,
0.0590873845,
0.0065029417,
0.0135343866,
0.00621399,
0.0464346074,
0.0068863593,
0.0149048083,
0.0130612105,
-0.0597528405,
-0.0255758297,
0.0192196779,
0.0326112546,
0.0669364855,
-0.0221156422,
0.0187691189,
-0.0868949443,
-0.0172568634,
-0.0466911942,
-0.0327686369,
0.0346500166,
0.0945801958,
0.0287350006,
-0.0078258086,
0.0012199112,
-0.0603494272,
0.0656792223,
0.0119193485,
-0.0701053813,
0.0099103134,
0.100650385,
0.0335313976,
0.0152330855,
0.0164817479,
-0.0089237681,
-0.000278355,
-0.011756557,
0.0583022498,
0.0151217142,
-0.0139086433,
-0.0283630323,
-0.0313345082,
-0.004759687,
-0.076804921,
0.0621760786,
-0.0224589445,
-0.0352684148,
-0.0387901776,
-0.0327018239,
0.0021671692,
0.0225508716,
-0.0182333551,
-0.0155711286,
0.0088894144,
-0.0013820798,
0.0192976221,
-0.0245867632,
-0.0475226082,
-0.0238454677,
0.0067880061,
-0.0543986075,
-0.0742467642,
0.0109336777,
-0.0012582098,
0.0339847691,
-0.0575516261,
0.0099682128,
2.625201687e-34,
0.042364005,
-0.0112806009,
0.025724303,
-0.0265085492,
0.0759200826,
0.0460672975,
0.021880446,
0.0096604489,
0.0019345862,
-0.0229979008,
-0.0209864397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14563v2 | NormDial: A Comparable Bilingual Synthetic Dialog Dataset for Modeling Social Norm Adherence and Violation | 2023-10-23T04:38:34 | 2023-10-25T02:00:19 | Oliver Li, Mallika Subramanian, Arkadiy Saakyan, Sky CH-Wang, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Social norms fundamentally shape interpersonal communication. We present
NormDial, a high-quality dyadic dialogue dataset with turn-by-turn annotations
of social norm adherences and violations for Chinese and American cultures.
Introducing the task of social norm observance detection, our dataset is
synthetically generated in both Chinese and English using a human-in-the-loop
pipeline by prompting large language models with a small collection of
expert-annotated social norms. We show that our generated dialogues are of high
quality through human evaluation and further evaluate the performance of
existing large language models on this task. Our findings point towards new
directions for understanding the nuances of social norms as they manifest in
conversational contexts that span across languages and cultures. | [
0.0695625544,
0.0783275813,
-0.0123627083,
0.045705542,
0.0071325074,
0.0075078914,
0.0314397067,
-0.0077678165,
0.0742711425,
-0.0199975204,
-0.0447785333,
-0.065489918,
-0.0226487238,
0.014356764,
-0.0068072658,
-0.0259891488,
0.0457786843,
-0.0034561544,
0.0579609685,
-0.0310295057,
0.0461387523,
0.0176807847,
0.0258953441,
0.026078159,
-0.0337571464,
0.0129224556,
0.0160981808,
0.0030036946,
0.0442143381,
-0.0156800728,
0.0806539133,
0.1060867012,
0.0351039059,
0.0467804223,
0.000001836,
-0.0454838127,
0.04438949,
-0.0204092283,
0.0441368222,
0.0279069114,
0.0402960926,
-0.0543749779,
-0.0084997173,
-0.004272142,
-0.0691687763,
-0.0157462023,
0.0026491205,
0.0667404607,
0.0791489482,
0.064667739,
-0.0075973747,
-0.0078391414,
-0.0047226944,
-0.0464214459,
-0.0503583103,
-0.0206860676,
0.0220232829,
0.0479210168,
-0.0486639366,
0.014515996,
-0.0044738334,
-0.0281956866,
0.0223652422,
-0.0534791127,
-0.0086768009,
-0.0369664989,
-0.0383243337,
-0.0383901075,
-0.0185288321,
0.115098916,
0.0206940826,
-0.0171274394,
0.0239640363,
0.0176051892,
-0.0166543182,
-0.0337663479,
-0.0235580467,
0.0171630234,
-0.005874943,
0.0230325907,
0.0172336679,
-0.0028787844,
0.0160837304,
0.0144546032,
-0.0046202517,
0.0230616871,
-0.0336306356,
-0.0109162712,
-0.0495536216,
-0.0182582792,
-0.0325867534,
-0.0439024568,
0.0310447961,
-0.0109394044,
-0.0595136695,
-0.0000758935,
-0.0026612116,
0.0362757482,
0.0635547787,
-0.0228613485,
-0.0015444176,
0.0309115369,
-0.0174561944,
0.0354535319,
0.0167798512,
0.0157550685,
-0.0107738273,
0.0132127767,
-0.0019314606,
-0.0281057842,
-0.0258291606,
0.0043163248,
0.0140754823,
-0.010995429,
-0.0581064448,
0.0168563779,
-0.0165600982,
-0.0015221488,
-0.0601807311,
0.0462656468,
0.0044063861,
-0.0136343846,
-0.0119914385,
0.0040332652,
-0.0108612888,
0.0140465898,
-0.0733487085,
0.0187487472,
0.0078247515,
-0.0672996342,
0.0276680551,
-0.0228781719,
-0.0218044091,
0.007805828,
-0.0154021392,
0.0354596674,
0.0003145213,
0.0207060743,
0.0129450439,
-0.0176686887,
-0.0323119201,
-0.0566232502,
0.0013805829,
-0.0592054538,
0.0763772652,
-0.0342371427,
-0.0040560709,
-0.0486877225,
0.0538016669,
0.0059975567,
0.0000842443,
0.0401953794,
0.0472809412,
-0.0125336051,
0.0156770777,
0.0468092673,
0.0080522122,
0.0894248188,
0.0173661727,
-0.0339587703,
0.0758823827,
-0.0064909733,
0.0045741973,
0.0375873558,
0.0355963558,
0.0154866157,
-0.0243658274,
0.0419290885,
0.0314298235,
0.0092066126,
0.0295861494,
0.0584159791,
-0.0356221348,
-0.0459472835,
0.0191390365,
0.0851600021,
-0.0646576583,
0.0151133966,
0.0139674535,
0.0169938356,
-0.0185828861,
0.015522955,
-0.0524974875,
-0.0060048411,
0.0106589254,
-0.0515790246,
-0.0353327803,
0.0500139259,
-0.0164260361,
-0.0493534058,
0.0079886355,
0.022545509,
0.0435838923,
-0.0160050895,
-0.0038886769,
0.0043755881,
-0.0002198698,
-0.005865654,
0.0198121015,
-0.0668752715,
-0.0356083624,
0.0104941353,
0.0466498323,
0.075035736,
0.0419450253,
0.0021365264,
0.0195168629,
-0.0465013869,
0.0417440273,
0.0323300473,
0.0761993453,
-0.0396059714,
0.0199320782,
-0.0459535569,
-0.0093308352,
0.0550554097,
0.0078624021,
-0.008942863,
0.0381606482,
-0.0029206711,
-0.0022008237,
0.0187375564,
-0.0740263015,
-0.0104571274,
-0.0075005349,
0.0172425229,
0.0029498432,
0.0022742136,
0.0233822837,
0.0354322046,
-0.0214707367,
-0.0468338951,
0.0136896139,
-0.0113095473,
-0.0094072735,
0.0431161039,
-0.0761358216,
-0.0384387001,
0.0359259397,
-0.0526127554,
-0.0537740141,
0.0215071738,
-0.0380618833,
-0.0088147623,
-0.0152833965,
0.0474592037,
0.0335652977,
-0.0461222976,
-0.0416152962,
-0.0043740165,
0.031650614,
-0.0116182221,
-0.0169744231,
-0.0494453199,
-0.0106055932,
0.022165589,
-0.0137830097,
0.0287643336,
-0.0186284631,
-0.0097857025,
0.0301921088,
-0.0187977813,
0.014218023,
0.0163267963,
0.0421116166,
-0.0173397381,
-0.0222878698,
-0.1052244827,
-0.0225664172,
-0.0288147572,
-0.0175997242,
0.0114441458,
-0.0141259264,
0.0006364235,
-0.0330996029,
-0.0576096699,
-0.0301362667,
0.0240242109,
-0.012291817,
0.0593045875,
-0.0302967336,
-0.0318526886,
-0.0222399179,
-0.032569401,
-0.020694023,
-0.0028887647,
-0.0209702309,
-0.0050396291,
-0.0031330346,
-0.0500761345,
-0.060338337,
0.0395337418,
-0.0264404826,
-0.0755939856,
-0.0010692956,
0.0640039518,
0.0777582973,
0.0730123296,
0.05225797,
0.0445544496,
0.0099225296,
-0.0028639303,
-0.0336864553,
-0.0215994567,
0.0166427568,
0.037462756,
-0.0383848995,
-0.045115687,
-0.0193261337,
0.0115308454,
-0.0080740396,
-0.0079386877,
-0.0326492973,
-0.0000829294,
-0.0231941938,
-0.0625293553,
-0.0217865445,
-0.0106429849,
-0.0317535028,
0.0505880043,
-0.0225195084,
-0.0165585857,
0.0470289439,
0.0113305617,
-0.0173932072,
0.0039415369,
-0.0082210302,
-0.0290222429,
0.045039665,
-0.0044853785,
0.0266134664,
-0.0390525497,
-0.0254312251,
-0.020689819,
-0.0175087973,
0.0654490441,
-0.0298864059,
0.0292762741,
-0.039109271,
-0.0198335219,
0.000923099,
-0.03753227,
-0.0355556719,
-0.0189042706,
-0.0157538559,
0.0219920892,
0.0119868796,
-0.0360383242,
0.0612053722,
0.0063516148,
-0.023095971,
0.0105041256,
0.0164837986,
0.0310925003,
0.0019318055,
0.0014542361,
0.0060844901,
-0.0008759208,
-0.0081228763,
-0.0113187023,
0.0449360311,
0.0429815501,
0.0076033822,
-0.0037810733,
0.0373930968,
0.0156728644,
0.0379138626,
0.0673969612,
-0.0049769138,
-0.0090451529,
0.0935227275,
-0.0490676351,
0.0085681332,
0.0790950432,
0.0190922879,
-0.016899433,
0.003197154,
-0.0184848346,
0.0618017204,
0.0262575876,
-0.0042041452,
-0.1322503984,
0.0087930094,
0.0043962314,
0.0167959258,
-0.0456116647,
-0.0601860471,
0.0181292873,
-0.0675953254,
0.0249410216,
0.0215346031,
-0.0354246907,
-0.0320921242,
-0.0049912613,
-0.0087964032,
-0.0382453464,
0.0355328321,
-0.0141190831,
0.0501567051,
-0.0511501692,
-0.0053514955,
-0.0423366986,
-0.0199386664,
0.0727138966,
-0.0521820635,
0.0820921585,
0.0235918444,
0.0576952398,
0.0283860527,
-0.0506221503,
0.040336851,
0.0335345939,
-0.0406489931,
-0.0150650973,
-0.0029896183,
0.006884051,
-0.0476766564,
-0.031280905,
0.0602690987,
-0.0309567433,
-0.021293059,
0.0212324485,
0.0507723726,
0.0203495938,
-0.0338074192,
-0.0103022046,
0.0410135724,
0.0050875293,
0.0666842982,
0.0280113108,
-0.026865555,
-0.0054798429,
-0.0543045513,
-0.0604911521,
-0.0527758338,
-0.0355455205,
-0.0348122679,
0.0129367532,
-0.028656058,
-0.0770222768,
-0.0667780638,
0.0040979711,
0.0102428691,
0.0276310854,
-0.0800518095,
0.0182722788,
-0.0060962397,
-0.0003354536,
-0.0052330983,
-0.0360913314,
-0.0007495877,
-0.0069056195,
0.0044543822,
-0.0088656154,
0.0237515178,
-0.0186398812,
0.021547908,
-0.0143768182,
-0.0557146855,
0.017431926,
0.0281113647,
0.0076334393,
0.0684705824,
-0.0023028257,
0.0238384362,
-0.0350999534,
0.0250736382,
-0.0225206055,
-0.0123025617,
0.0945696458,
0.0099874204,
0.0043448908,
0.0484297238,
0.0245825704,
0.0362454504,
-0.0192318484,
0.0119591737,
-0.0689554065,
-0.0658242702,
-0.0063882158,
-0.0163212176,
-0.0138137946,
0.0203774497,
-0.0135240089,
-0.0775458068,
-0.0209977143,
-0.0583278574,
-0.04657178,
-0.0370608382,
0.0321164019,
-0.0046786917,
-0.0374743268,
-0.0195797663,
0.0226966068,
-0.0299076941,
0.0482499562,
-0.0463376231,
0.0143372659,
0.0346546955,
0.0599965714,
-0.0086843558,
-0.0210310239,
-0.0217854828,
0.0536949784,
-0.0100887306,
0.040562477,
-0.0168479197,
0.0840741545,
0.0426184088,
-0.0319806933,
0.0340428576,
0.0062703388,
-0.0261416361,
-0.0144986231,
-0.0200581998,
0.022219995,
0.0215483587,
-0.0054891729,
0.0380092263,
-0.0176770184,
-0.0169743896,
-0.0106530264,
0.082569629,
-0.0185049996,
-0.0386233218,
0.0197321549,
0.0144965546,
-0.0386089608,
0.017073838,
0.0336569585,
-0.048757948,
0.0004401231,
0.0459063239,
0.0102540301,
-0.0140196141,
-0.0020244035,
0.0770163089,
-0.0109949568,
0.0038101024,
-0.0139334192,
-0.0661760122,
-0.0386531428,
-0.0509078205,
0.0318464115,
0.0006902926,
0.0091232341,
-0.0146774473,
0.056512285,
-0.011230438,
-0.0019345914,
-0.0421769023,
-0.0177275389,
-0.0084858891,
-0.0103872512,
-0.0230452958,
-5.703116555e-33,
-0.0167006198,
-0.0410178974,
-0.0174678359,
-0.0095462631,
-0.0319958739,
-0.0532136746,
-0.0355443582,
-0.0113004074,
-0.0252816454,
0.0478439108,
0.0009549893,
0.0333856717,
0.0035403061,
0.0018536174,
0.0382301398,
-0.0233776271,
0.0462900028,
-0.0155159291,
-0.0005267271,
0.0403816402,
0.0359543227,
-0.008865972,
0.0474681593,
-0.0771256909,
0.0748082697,
0.0178548694,
-0.020420121,
0.045912765,
0.001921094,
0.0188783016,
-0.0164820235,
0.050218787,
-0.0017801721,
-0.0028131576,
-0.0219070297,
0.0669017658,
-0.0633704588,
-0.0091006961,
0.0211409088,
-0.019558372,
-0.0010557498,
-0.0066951946,
0.008883113,
-0.0675391927,
0.0114159267,
0.0277697537,
0.0264609922,
-0.0186424106,
0.0216281358,
0.0376058444,
-0.0448136516,
0.0329787806,
-0.0462089591,
-0.0073930598,
-0.0334396288,
0.0501169786,
0.0180759542,
-0.0269120112,
-0.0405787751,
0.0419877358,
-0.0237955116,
-0.0159968603,
0.0313975587,
-0.0370258912,
0.0435819216,
0.0409165919,
0.0527912267,
0.0585089512,
0.0142581137,
-0.0179846976,
0.0237241574,
0.0359234475,
0.0034797005,
0.0996245742,
-0.0372412056,
-0.0613379888,
-0.0320575535,
-0.0334381312,
0.0658746287,
-0.0413790569,
-0.0235201325,
0.0025449726,
-0.0321236439,
-0.0488620698,
-0.0101691382,
-0.0466317497,
0.0097258827,
-0.0123677412,
0.036268428,
0.0116993077,
-0.0261481274,
-0.0331679285,
0.0477850772,
-0.0515945815,
-0.0472526215,
0.0385958515,
-0.0062736263,
-0.0365213454,
0.0470686927,
0.0285227802,
-0.0735661685,
-0.0344342552,
0.0063963626,
0.0006665111,
0.0150170671,
0.0127278799,
0.036976859,
-0.0103408825,
-0.0362520516,
-0.0092025213,
-0.0235283021,
0.0385655835,
-0.0633558556,
0.0253398847,
0.0027819814,
-0.0066659036,
-0.0167402681,
0.0713339522,
0.0356035084,
0.0059011783,
-0.0608521551,
0.0074530756,
-0.0304811653,
0.0235284511,
-0.0296309553,
-0.0000414901,
-0.0209243596,
0.0102693029,
0.0467503816,
0.0125075858,
-0.0014311882,
-0.0598851144,
2.315e-7,
-0.0287472811,
0.0086155999,
0.0415561572,
0.0409501307,
0.0102195907,
0.0162278507,
0.0031812906,
0.0546993092,
0.0086897975,
-0.0132677015,
0.0216333903,
0.0368112437,
0.0524956658,
0.0394347794,
-0.056035284,
-0.0333637111,
-0.0741932169,
-0.0624573752,
0.0025340149,
-0.0134969745,
-0.0025988286,
0.0557147712,
-0.0094849644,
0.0119430907,
0.015978545,
0.0046466463,
0.0483274311,
-0.0583334304,
-0.0268689618,
0.0155160204,
0.0733734593,
-0.0439045094,
0.0290156119,
0.0233600363,
0.0054938472,
0.0294108689,
0.0092528118,
0.0915357098,
0.0102384249,
-0.0177298337,
-0.0149144828,
-0.0157851186,
-0.0039804163,
-0.0819082484,
0.0192018971,
0.0010075473,
0.0025896903,
-0.0218777526,
0.0053758584,
-0.0433865972,
0.0351327173,
-0.0340999179,
-0.0111482898,
0.0236482322,
0.0300602745,
0.0094672609,
0.0586421303,
-0.0092006288,
-0.0155630289,
-0.0153238699,
-0.0121533237,
-0.0792427659,
0.0327600241,
-0.0149975764,
-0.034490902,
0.0381310955,
0.0122582903,
1.896560953e-34,
0.0378863998,
-0.0206038635,
0.0178392064,
0.0301125776,
0.0439677574,
-0.0116508361,
-0.0102101518,
-0.0215641838,
0.0598921739,
0.0083381757,
-0.0090333037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18348v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18348v3 | Meaning Representations from Trajectories in Autoregressive Models | 2023-10-23T04:35:58 | 2023-11-29T05:32:24 | Tian Yu Liu, Matthew Trager, Alessandro Achille, Pramuditha Perera, Luca Zancato, Stefano Soatto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | We propose to extract meaning representations from autoregressive language
models by considering the distribution of all possible trajectories extending
an input text. This strategy is prompt-free, does not require fine-tuning, and
is applicable to any pre-trained autoregressive model. Moreover, unlike
vector-based representations, distribution-based representations can also model
asymmetric relations (e.g., direction of logical entailment, hypernym/hyponym
relations) by using algebraic operations between likelihood functions. These
ideas are grounded in distributional perspectives on semantics and are
connected to standard constructions in automata theory, but to our knowledge
they have not been applied to modern language models. We empirically show that
the representations obtained from large models align well with human
annotations, outperform other zero-shot and prompt-free methods on semantic
similarity tasks, and can be used to solve more complex entailment and
containment tasks that standard embeddings cannot handle. Finally, we extend
our method to represent data from different modalities (e.g., image and text)
using multimodal autoregressive models. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/tianyu139/meaning-as-trajectories | [
-0.004399057,
0.0884858221,
-0.0099600283,
0.0846654847,
-0.0373332761,
0.0242558829,
-0.057957869,
-0.0210085176,
-0.0479529127,
-0.0732987076,
-0.0043556672,
-0.0381585807,
-0.0115828756,
0.0529363342,
0.0095892604,
-0.0530674048,
0.0589341447,
-0.0268414505,
-0.0318524428,
0.0039173895,
0.0094509525,
0.0119695505,
-0.0183102135,
0.0590113401,
-0.0514422655,
-0.0138607807,
0.0032732796,
0.0020935757,
0.0434295796,
-0.0279807933,
-0.0407015793,
0.0006296168,
0.0927866399,
0.0277640931,
0.0000017509,
-0.0164764114,
-0.007235135,
-0.0204902422,
-0.0036354614,
-0.0297978111,
0.0345127732,
-0.0784846246,
-0.0036893112,
-0.0320795588,
-0.0165511854,
-0.0033297932,
0.0389787666,
-0.0280670077,
0.053227853,
0.0439026654,
-0.0173698254,
-0.0419121534,
0.0232803673,
-0.0431855023,
0.0357987396,
-0.0366439894,
0.0190694928,
0.0413002595,
0.0020184142,
-0.0102573605,
-0.1012585461,
0.0480571985,
0.0165012479,
0.0114993816,
-0.0118032042,
0.0544010885,
0.0246747267,
-0.014001104,
-0.0002336824,
0.0749140456,
-0.010165086,
-0.0211349893,
-0.006941136,
-0.0189011805,
-0.0287312455,
0.0502271168,
-0.0097235274,
0.0670777708,
0.0190975145,
0.0583710074,
0.0429668166,
0.0210272949,
0.0269466713,
-0.0071585039,
-0.0264092218,
0.0297807809,
0.0316198617,
0.0054268767,
-0.0090237744,
0.0037318401,
-0.0124688447,
-0.0045621251,
-0.0119547769,
0.0351043232,
0.0526193567,
0.0273003746,
-0.0254457891,
-0.0258758385,
-0.0009744865,
-0.0251744818,
0.0476443954,
0.0774365366,
-0.0327782705,
0.0658218861,
-0.0375379398,
0.0194420144,
-0.0293351505,
-0.0035291868,
-0.0413079411,
-0.006274668,
-0.02529555,
0.0165076815,
-0.0498115532,
-0.0143559836,
-0.0415669493,
-0.0604905523,
-0.0185687076,
0.060617771,
0.0010935747,
-0.0037667898,
-0.0231113173,
-0.0061475844,
-0.0311493445,
0.0167691335,
-0.0028863247,
0.0259450898,
-0.0534958355,
-0.0106308926,
-0.0313178115,
0.008133268,
-0.0051932866,
0.0321040004,
0.035650637,
-0.025730595,
-0.0062477719,
0.0703646541,
0.0230773874,
-0.0450814851,
-0.0317366347,
-0.0328211524,
-0.0149456095,
-0.0383335091,
0.0105913784,
-0.0275023058,
0.0234686211,
-0.0049311477,
0.003739048,
-0.0458784141,
0.0058043795,
0.0102332979,
-0.0090395054,
0.076237157,
-0.012927087,
-0.0018416917,
0.0062503335,
0.0063581015,
0.0134888822,
0.044980295,
0.033981923,
0.0280768815,
0.0065824008,
0.0215615053,
-0.0075782384,
0.0028049557,
0.0059172758,
0.0204022825,
-0.0560184903,
-0.01068174,
0.0212370697,
0.0442964062,
0.0512979813,
0.0419356376,
-0.0235049129,
-0.0544562079,
0.0068613561,
0.0321004689,
0.0278338008,
-0.0369067751,
0.0790844709,
-0.0375722349,
-0.0078378785,
0.0042403536,
-0.0419281572,
0.03965066,
-0.0118644005,
0.0223224554,
0.0067383144,
0.0001959723,
-0.0286828335,
-0.0067964965,
0.0157057866,
-0.0483814999,
0.0305112414,
-0.0018289383,
0.041691158,
0.0190944411,
-0.0147539666,
-0.0119275367,
0.0225591045,
-0.0228861887,
0.0060251495,
-0.0018886728,
0.0559468418,
0.0388567112,
0.0230078045,
-0.0362296253,
-0.0207052771,
-0.029090438,
0.0005973199,
0.0381059684,
-0.0296402276,
-0.0003067248,
-0.0036068633,
-0.0416673385,
-0.0312414058,
-0.0077799852,
0.037895035,
0.0324547775,
-0.036712911,
0.0237580612,
0.0394770727,
-0.0450819619,
0.0073093092,
0.0559599884,
-0.0020465709,
-0.0041708527,
-0.0095793968,
0.0392664894,
0.0024990137,
-0.0071294419,
-0.0077707972,
0.0382541083,
0.0114828516,
-0.0741201788,
-0.008553531,
0.0553655475,
-0.0553473532,
-0.0538042299,
0.0159293059,
-0.0306109805,
-0.0260725543,
0.0034792502,
-0.0330218635,
-0.0337812006,
0.0284875259,
-0.0364098102,
0.0474307649,
-0.0546910018,
-0.0241208579,
0.0563929826,
0.0397729389,
-0.0040869126,
0.0568608344,
-0.0072704228,
-0.0082556484,
-0.0136717679,
0.0246355347,
0.0361968651,
0.0073614432,
-0.0409855135,
-0.0178690329,
0.0337564051,
-0.0084145572,
0.0275544766,
-0.0341141261,
-0.01516663,
-0.0024985936,
-0.0360827781,
0.0060812496,
-0.0290033426,
0.0032061036,
0.0104658613,
0.0020554515,
0.0049076909,
-0.0275335051,
-0.018828325,
0.0167355165,
0.0144451093,
0.0433062352,
0.0409592427,
0.0029904791,
-0.0216388218,
-0.0504127629,
-0.0328558385,
-0.0520995595,
0.0556608848,
-0.0123355575,
0.0009517802,
-0.0112593686,
-0.0079156104,
-0.0497241542,
0.0128689585,
-0.0428073891,
-0.0259329937,
0.0096679321,
-0.0241333917,
0.0648776889,
0.0393801294,
0.0294502415,
0.06397219,
0.0591847748,
-0.0132783819,
-0.0241794139,
-0.0246305615,
-0.0219050813,
0.0023734339,
-0.0045474777,
-0.0279250666,
-0.0371515043,
0.0652503669,
0.0259016454,
0.0074174288,
-0.0498851426,
-0.0276540034,
-0.0312194899,
-0.0058659888,
-0.0390567556,
0.0269408133,
-0.0325200744,
0.0148340352,
-0.0195192806,
-0.0449164547,
0.0662094429,
-0.0204783548,
0.0014567131,
0.0208030287,
-0.0373485535,
-0.0508266948,
0.1129315868,
0.0150082102,
0.0316335484,
0.0154472766,
-0.0109008737,
-0.0121493097,
-0.0120453574,
0.0485905372,
-0.0089074625,
0.0472869128,
-0.0203259811,
0.0278851707,
-0.0004067356,
0.0161959752,
-0.0344486386,
-0.1091103256,
-0.0183364172,
-0.0067928373,
-0.0808331296,
0.0213096179,
0.0089573488,
0.0511449352,
0.0016613365,
0.0108840838,
0.0073150788,
-0.0122856656,
-0.0314010642,
0.0389325507,
0.0838618726,
-0.0278179999,
-0.0144848479,
-0.0186060909,
0.018619962,
-0.0037679453,
-0.0035887132,
0.039400965,
-0.0571423583,
0.0512194522,
-0.0292105544,
-0.0190038644,
-0.0423131324,
0.0113019198,
0.0261957441,
-0.0462142006,
-0.0137668066,
0.0930608958,
0.0062389476,
-0.0072978209,
0.0259667635,
0.0169726629,
0.041879043,
0.0411087386,
-0.014611966,
-0.1199949235,
-0.032874614,
-0.0154631827,
-0.0322562903,
0.0453121662,
-0.0452034138,
0.0101842703,
-0.0696913451,
0.023450397,
-0.0065564732,
-0.0203145593,
-0.0266731288,
-0.0260870308,
0.0189423785,
0.0026524079,
-0.0399840772,
-0.0246350802,
-0.0268532373,
0.0208683945,
-0.0074237185,
0.003468195,
-0.0197721422,
0.0365232155,
-0.0374887697,
0.0254949983,
0.0530606247,
0.0529881939,
0.0174119342,
-0.0521627031,
-0.0235683583,
-0.0401888788,
-0.0211343411,
0.0141008832,
-0.0042005535,
-0.0443972982,
-0.0131130982,
0.0280380622,
0.0303308684,
-0.039704822,
-0.0226646662,
-0.041179046,
0.1010278016,
-0.0458512753,
-0.0388936475,
-0.0688296482,
-0.0014705089,
0.0226129573,
0.0987802371,
0.0399495326,
-0.0022967118,
-0.0336937755,
-0.0106452461,
0.0240364429,
0.033632841,
-0.009638546,
-0.0067160632,
0.0031975347,
-0.021509394,
-0.0598196238,
-0.0389339365,
0.0195852146,
0.0402668603,
0.0028015985,
0.0099701229,
-0.0062589068,
-0.0344431475,
-0.0545275174,
0.0218655523,
-0.0615261383,
0.0394924134,
-0.0028800194,
-0.0030496591,
0.0614383258,
0.0224505626,
-0.0637261122,
0.0085460283,
-0.0563856885,
-0.041186519,
-0.0184578747,
0.0340160504,
0.0160199292,
0.0112010753,
-0.0209177658,
0.0280672107,
0.001707001,
0.0057333256,
0.0244244188,
0.0286674649,
0.0230675749,
0.0389234014,
-0.0188790243,
0.0517035872,
-0.040585041,
0.0459401645,
-0.0155797591,
0.0661723316,
-0.0275096633,
-0.0722503737,
0.0180491954,
-0.022292519,
0.0458423905,
-0.0136696296,
-0.0409814753,
-0.0287995972,
-0.0569278523,
-0.0371930189,
-0.0177368633,
-0.0302520916,
0.0407826118,
0.0540886037,
-0.0061330199,
-0.0243505351,
-0.0113283927,
0.0049452442,
0.0333018862,
-0.0343280546,
0.002759997,
0.0626962408,
0.0080424082,
-0.0431799144,
0.0212216619,
0.0044486113,
0.0137735037,
-0.0254234318,
0.0053043617,
-0.0472534746,
0.0265638176,
0.0163007267,
0.0128460415,
-0.0277710818,
0.0131364241,
-0.0621087886,
0.0258877575,
0.0120287873,
0.0629935861,
0.0868663713,
-0.0112149511,
0.0079406053,
-0.0478847772,
0.0050567733,
0.0101195658,
0.0462672673,
0.0081761209,
-0.0338282846,
0.0787659138,
0.026944831,
-0.0083053727,
-0.0177484155,
0.0502451248,
-0.0060387603,
0.098499462,
0.0267616101,
0.0131165553,
-0.0511998162,
-0.0121117532,
-0.0007961717,
0.0274701919,
-0.0102393301,
0.0373028778,
-0.0495448112,
-0.0952675864,
0.0405222103,
0.0149502456,
-0.0236736219,
0.0117442431,
0.0407437608,
0.0031377114,
0.0250985846,
0.0071763596,
-0.0588510409,
0.0229777824,
-0.0250012707,
-0.016909549,
-0.0372294486,
-5.897230345e-33,
-0.0379695296,
0.0011364083,
0.0030443962,
-0.0436726436,
-0.0161849,
0.0042967787,
-0.0512515381,
-0.0082815615,
-0.0267249122,
0.01412322,
0.0469097607,
0.0042759478,
-0.0005792489,
0.0067488896,
0.0094857262,
-0.0209686402,
0.0195728354,
-0.0165276397,
-0.0005144853,
0.0126808221,
0.0424828567,
0.0267173219,
0.0282323193,
-0.0295308474,
0.00960577,
-0.0197521728,
-0.0050477199,
0.0196852013,
0.0364738144,
0.0421303771,
-0.0589818619,
0.0401694179,
0.0367802083,
0.025013838,
-0.0187694933,
0.0160514507,
-0.0952926874,
-0.0400901772,
0.0250315107,
-0.0291922279,
-0.0567782857,
-0.0073929718,
0.0466856547,
-0.0412025452,
-0.0129609788,
0.0267405156,
0.0402115509,
-0.0028788859,
-0.0202953741,
-0.0058315424,
-0.0940882936,
0.0077328575,
-0.0041065626,
-0.062260028,
0.0464111827,
0.0236083008,
0.0634380504,
0.0048916908,
-0.0134736747,
0.0032090237,
-0.0859446824,
0.016428059,
0.0183401164,
0.0132741584,
0.0292858463,
0.0656398684,
-0.0336998068,
-0.0655418709,
-0.0575074479,
0.0211826805,
0.0412756912,
0.0345362127,
-0.0192953292,
0.0447072126,
0.0273642931,
-0.0019309301,
-0.0364837125,
0.0245590005,
0.0057839095,
0.0309155937,
-0.0066567543,
0.0406601839,
-0.0192256328,
0.0052647903,
-0.0493800789,
-0.0145247169,
-0.0011552334,
-0.020731844,
0.0444493033,
-0.0143189775,
-0.003108809,
0.0389677808,
0.0682395697,
-0.041887559,
-0.0286935531,
0.0452416092,
-0.0142285684,
0.0071299234,
0.0098016914,
0.043628525,
0.0049387543,
-0.038870912,
0.0271193944,
-0.0220364295,
0.0232560746,
0.0008687329,
0.02337276,
0.0167532433,
-0.0292758234,
-0.0151872337,
-0.0419646949,
-0.031764172,
-0.0414654799,
-0.0020437955,
0.0482095592,
0.0423668437,
-0.018240422,
0.0242136642,
-0.0138951642,
0.0157000739,
-0.0178174376,
-0.0010755541,
-0.0198852364,
0.0462251268,
-0.0490387827,
0.0004237934,
-0.0317760855,
0.0415495448,
0.0507745743,
-0.071299389,
-0.0073039532,
0.0408586115,
2.531e-7,
0.0882023722,
-0.0026151687,
0.0646035075,
0.0558667034,
0.0025457304,
0.0128951604,
-0.037991032,
0.0093392953,
-0.0174106583,
-0.0464395881,
0.0019417452,
0.045984257,
0.0179678537,
-0.0082668383,
-0.0127985859,
0.0431468897,
-0.0732745007,
-0.0064095804,
-0.0426378623,
0.0183316711,
0.0867995694,
0.1120573506,
0.0221263245,
0.0084603485,
0.0144604482,
-0.0344311334,
0.1105012298,
-0.0005715976,
0.0066142627,
-0.0257454086,
-0.0296494626,
0.0142236017,
0.0078623183,
-0.0298911817,
0.0113394288,
0.0040285056,
0.043875549,
0.0279889815,
-0.0381235145,
-0.0433013625,
-0.0401414335,
0.0024034905,
0.0007993287,
-0.0345488079,
0.0679274425,
-0.0366699994,
-0.016478762,
-0.0863907486,
-0.0226742681,
0.0384528786,
0.0595073998,
0.0203247722,
-0.0574470647,
-0.023903897,
0.0570170581,
-0.0134428311,
-0.0230034273,
-0.098354727,
-0.0028311771,
0.018049119,
-0.0410333425,
0.0498579144,
-0.0446715243,
-0.0114852199,
0.0529971123,
-0.0591655858,
-0.0578328036,
2.004988598e-34,
0.0541253872,
-0.0210401062,
0.0025855198,
0.0028233137,
0.0240158718,
0.0106021026,
-0.0296236426,
0.0153334839,
0.0126379235,
-0.0788787454,
-0.0430313498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14558v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14558v4 | AlpaCare:Instruction-tuned Large Language Models for Medical Application | 2023-10-23T04:22:50 | 2024-06-10T17:52:31 | Xinlu Zhang, Chenxin Tian, Xianjun Yang, Lichang Chen, Zekun Li, Linda Ruth Petzold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-finetuning (IFT) has become crucial in aligning Large Language
Models (LLMs) with diverse human needs and has shown great potential in medical
applications. However, previous studies mainly fine-tune LLMs on biomedical
datasets with limited diversity, which often rely on benchmarks or narrow task
scopes, and hence significantly limit the effectiveness on their medical
instruction-following ability and generalizability. To bridge this gap, we
propose creating a diverse, machine-generated medical IFT dataset,
MedInstruct-52k, using GPT-4 and ChatGPT with a high-quality expert-curated
seed set. We then fine-tune LLaMA-series models on the dataset to develop
AlpaCare. Despite using a smaller domain-specific dataset than previous medical
LLMs, AlpaCare not only demonstrates superior performance on medical
applications, with up to 38.1% absolute gain over best baselines in medical
free-form instruction evaluations, but also achieves 6.7% absolute gains
averaged over multiple general domain benchmarks. Human evaluation further
shows that AlpaCare consistently outperforms best baselines in terms of both
correctness and helpfulness. We offer public access to our data, model, and
codebase in https://github.com/XZhang97666/AlpaCare. | [
0.0269817598,
0.0457484573,
-0.0073736971,
-0.0067388583,
-0.0116098523,
0.0341131836,
0.0060527842,
-0.0000429158,
-0.0058075273,
-0.0027747247,
-0.0602204166,
-0.0675801858,
0.0189318601,
0.0043722382,
0.0379689969,
-0.0527154468,
0.0393361412,
-0.0222979765,
0.0135681089,
-0.0066816271,
0.0104298098,
0.011373736,
-0.0495172068,
0.0599996187,
0.0430901833,
-0.0224909615,
0.0175881404,
0.001438217,
0.0037766974,
-0.0515649468,
0.0140571129,
0.0654106066,
0.0050263479,
-0.0156932157,
0.000002157,
-0.0371313542,
-0.0001446437,
0.012550259,
-0.0300111398,
0.0090844892,
0.0457072705,
-0.0321389847,
-0.0234450828,
0.0166246947,
-0.0155301364,
-0.0231058747,
0.0418391414,
0.0128977718,
0.0724399388,
0.0650739297,
0.0023888987,
0.016993802,
0.0223678537,
-0.0405358896,
0.0287414063,
-0.0421348922,
0.0090039251,
-0.0052452022,
0.0380999297,
-0.0081397165,
0.0013497854,
0.0405609421,
0.0140995132,
0.0293678474,
0.0105551407,
0.0400365852,
-0.0305047147,
-0.0074384329,
-0.0308751725,
0.0766074508,
-0.0062081465,
0.0117102144,
0.0116723925,
0.0040434767,
-0.0126707368,
-0.02467601,
-0.0599401481,
0.0119244047,
-0.007678648,
0.0019896876,
0.0341043025,
-0.0279582515,
0.0349021778,
0.0103132995,
0.0102100056,
0.0150243491,
0.0248168297,
-0.0286446158,
0.0169114303,
-0.0018756879,
-0.0313071124,
-0.029855324,
0.0279644802,
0.0612069778,
-0.0681922138,
-0.0041995668,
-0.0693546012,
-0.0159463976,
0.0780464932,
-0.0155880349,
0.0882326663,
0.0333507173,
-0.0127479453,
0.0381282195,
-0.0087284362,
0.0351528861,
-0.0053396933,
0.0285597052,
-0.0347332917,
0.0359940752,
-0.0554343387,
0.0082765045,
-0.0169445444,
0.0048910519,
-0.0411183611,
0.0146533465,
-0.0749564022,
-0.0110015096,
-0.0143931247,
0.0068327202,
0.0336892419,
0.0066993586,
-0.0552476086,
-0.0069201142,
-0.002841864,
0.0138548613,
-0.0215925612,
0.0233608149,
-0.0150180524,
-0.0643090606,
-0.0023614939,
0.0095428359,
-0.0253132377,
-0.0166222602,
0.0340968929,
0.0700396672,
-0.0138264196,
-0.0149359247,
-0.0037405186,
-0.0331870094,
-0.0170281418,
-0.0657188296,
0.0079332422,
-0.0754630938,
0.0470829494,
0.0117381765,
0.0246939715,
-0.0428287946,
0.004073842,
0.0305708554,
-0.03737716,
0.0532337017,
-0.0168238524,
0.0400269441,
0.0295863263,
0.0183441211,
-0.0045260643,
0.033873044,
0.0275555067,
-0.0321329273,
-0.0101219453,
-0.0294205416,
0.0079876762,
0.0365026407,
0.0179711431,
-0.0180683713,
0.0094187334,
0.0146890152,
0.0087603936,
0.0665417984,
-0.0049783299,
0.06582167,
0.009473308,
0.0050014216,
0.0262720082,
0.0399346314,
0.0230427906,
0.0109727308,
0.0491048209,
0.0045674113,
0.0287520774,
-0.026878465,
-0.0570802242,
0.0215771068,
0.0072927349,
0.0023245283,
-0.0064672763,
0.0289517026,
-0.0502925627,
-0.0319401398,
-0.0299095772,
-0.0183978435,
-0.0318826474,
-0.000398655,
0.0328289866,
-0.0216369852,
-0.0480243117,
0.0391374603,
0.0609071776,
-0.0287904404,
-0.0063410755,
-0.0522446856,
0.0021607301,
0.0879555196,
0.0370958298,
-0.0310265031,
-0.0728332549,
-0.0064958287,
0.0346578732,
-0.005016367,
0.0359198451,
-0.0082547646,
0.0268229693,
-0.0823399946,
-0.0145211872,
0.036632061,
0.0125135686,
-0.0316405445,
0.0195848681,
-0.0010309212,
-0.0191313718,
-0.0177313127,
-0.0543641746,
0.0534833148,
-0.0782510564,
-0.0374646075,
-0.0169489738,
-0.0048455107,
0.0219317656,
-0.0021093709,
-0.012704731,
0.0173266996,
0.0308160391,
-0.0278478358,
0.0183590427,
-0.0297709107,
-0.0624016933,
-0.0210323334,
0.0164098069,
-0.0225267299,
-0.0482341051,
-0.0148723191,
-0.0309826061,
-0.0390336402,
-0.0386313833,
-0.05226117,
0.006468141,
0.0052306913,
0.0351460315,
0.0251402743,
-0.0165775772,
-0.0497977622,
0.0086513227,
-0.0311677661,
0.0134601537,
0.0616856441,
-0.0207325853,
-0.0209310427,
-0.0331815854,
-0.0269214362,
-0.00336535,
-0.0135745415,
0.013701017,
-0.0371741764,
0.0723960027,
-0.0279550552,
-0.0630730912,
-0.100262478,
0.0363229886,
-0.0082452716,
0.0133376289,
0.0410034433,
0.0025986761,
-0.0073288959,
-0.0012455308,
-0.0246174838,
-0.0270986129,
0.010850329,
0.0209014751,
0.0107032182,
0.0198630877,
-0.022014156,
-0.0412914269,
-0.0162308067,
-0.0431531928,
-0.037047416,
-0.0085636228,
0.0086970292,
-0.0191345755,
-0.0031885186,
-0.0205166657,
-0.0060562664,
-0.0106938612,
-0.054228656,
0.0347400047,
-0.0015992282,
0.0353228897,
0.0583018363,
-0.0255560614,
0.0129304649,
0.0315555781,
0.0031571577,
-0.0237507001,
0.0130994553,
-0.0249958541,
-0.0481513925,
-0.02037807,
-0.0511473976,
-0.02110021,
0.1129883528,
-0.0002468299,
0.020997135,
-0.0799543038,
-0.0409929641,
-0.049497474,
0.0384656452,
-0.0332836658,
0.042630937,
-0.0457822308,
0.01894545,
-0.0305039417,
-0.0665713027,
0.1041988954,
-0.0085546942,
0.0124566527,
-0.0723869428,
-0.0248665959,
-0.0271128491,
-0.0123976283,
-0.0106908577,
0.0071188952,
-0.0028018299,
-0.014441425,
-0.0294272993,
0.0417221934,
-0.0130610503,
-0.0638001338,
0.0835712105,
-0.0599938631,
-0.0088272691,
0.0171754118,
-0.0302474089,
-0.0164127983,
-0.0029035481,
-0.0144551648,
-0.0000299454,
0.0480051264,
-0.0097040758,
-0.0603963695,
-0.005909753,
0.0065646311,
0.0650565475,
-0.0149324182,
0.0004629318,
-0.0202308297,
-0.0455625094,
0.0337972827,
0.0067346743,
-0.0281358901,
-0.0498697758,
0.0295217428,
0.0448917486,
0.0242571011,
0.0145137329,
0.0012115989,
0.0237228181,
0.0362313837,
-0.023593666,
0.0076615503,
0.0610482693,
0.0904529318,
-0.0548199005,
-0.0037504265,
0.1189514846,
0.0167578813,
-0.0597967431,
0.0170623809,
0.0045914575,
0.0272484738,
0.014964263,
0.022133043,
-0.0733248442,
-0.0465534627,
0.0003258474,
0.0668175817,
0.0034900634,
-0.001047126,
0.0332657769,
-0.0578082055,
0.0256788917,
0.0322585888,
-0.0631526187,
-0.0314734615,
-0.0361831039,
0.0105008902,
-0.0244576428,
0.0102692731,
0.0182470493,
-0.0442130119,
0.0028661729,
0.0200693402,
-0.0513953865,
-0.1122679561,
0.0551904924,
-0.0194941442,
0.0924079865,
0.0823560059,
0.0048915963,
0.0007261269,
-0.0365432687,
0.0342812426,
0.0066424534,
0.0109432265,
-0.0305301193,
0.0657978281,
0.0132209063,
-0.0131926723,
-0.0311987996,
0.0609991774,
-0.0560905226,
0.01055816,
0.0119878119,
0.0910871401,
-0.0194194,
0.0139469579,
-0.0262191948,
0.003728851,
0.0235800631,
0.0502996966,
0.0220114645,
-0.0274372175,
-0.0129680214,
-0.0210909415,
0.0245157871,
-0.0218258016,
-0.0270470772,
0.0474369526,
-0.0594298281,
0.0028026111,
-0.0351176709,
-0.0436949767,
0.0832023844,
-0.0074380194,
0.0313588493,
0.0128109055,
0.0376649015,
-0.0019602168,
-0.0383353569,
0.0635111108,
0.0042480854,
0.0439733267,
-0.1187291443,
-0.0967545807,
0.0274994764,
-0.0050412389,
-0.0033737647,
0.0440406837,
-0.0232540295,
-0.0350990184,
0.0184789319,
0.0907021612,
0.0203784294,
0.0193304308,
-0.0090736439,
-0.0408652201,
0.0222490784,
0.0208276846,
-0.046723377,
-0.0048224423,
0.0095084906,
-0.0277385283,
-0.0030494118,
0.0222715903,
-0.0097080441,
0.0444017239,
-0.0024197667,
0.0588515103,
0.0031122989,
-0.015112265,
0.0183323901,
0.0206839703,
0.0339792781,
-0.0209672768,
-0.0183487553,
-0.020211963,
0.0079661375,
0.0010754938,
0.030338062,
-0.0460407957,
-0.0086961193,
0.0325420797,
-0.0210526511,
-0.0012915306,
-0.0050989389,
-0.0520996228,
-0.0362605155,
-0.0584346242,
0.069244571,
-0.0158656314,
0.0263095349,
0.0613576286,
0.0104648806,
-0.012785607,
0.0187819656,
-0.0127047682,
0.018889593,
-0.0025691215,
0.0884126276,
-0.0128069334,
0.0547930002,
-0.0038463671,
0.0596155897,
-0.0043217554,
-0.0346746929,
-0.03325646,
0.021008933,
0.0408638157,
-0.0067294207,
0.0366708636,
-0.015709769,
0.0128208054,
-0.0334168077,
0.0445678756,
-0.0500953458,
0.0288197231,
0.0391826481,
0.0265918039,
0.0139688719,
-0.0261632185,
0.1049945652,
-0.0088981465,
0.0628074557,
0.0062056412,
-0.012415749,
-0.0435538106,
-0.0253028199,
0.0208370816,
-0.0041222004,
-0.0647214502,
0.0046297847,
-0.0212860815,
-0.0454629511,
-0.0236099511,
0.0068930103,
-0.0196807198,
-0.0437356271,
0.067842707,
0.0204707365,
-0.0390578434,
-0.0319160968,
-0.0221623499,
0.0348097682,
-0.023821013,
-0.026025882,
0.0021272502,
-6.205131988e-33,
-0.0148305884,
-0.0069505484,
0.0496742986,
-0.0182860736,
-0.0132748419,
0.0232535489,
-0.0310343504,
0.0242705252,
-0.0208639447,
0.0349541083,
-0.0039387117,
-0.0056950352,
0.0124915224,
0.0236218199,
0.0305222888,
-0.0131913917,
0.0229828097,
-0.0072656926,
-0.0160941686,
0.0515902825,
-0.0418115184,
0.0288617443,
0.051030755,
-0.0684518814,
0.012016587,
-0.0060979612,
0.0180509873,
-0.0003064405,
-0.040024776,
0.0726072639,
-0.0245825108,
0.02711205,
0.0307024959,
-0.0283861924,
-0.024616804,
-0.0181734376,
-0.036872793,
-0.0119301211,
0.0327718668,
-0.0249585472,
-0.0529158562,
-0.055347953,
0.0371775106,
-0.0174878296,
-0.0586196594,
-0.0113593759,
0.02146204,
-0.028366778,
-0.0089702662,
0.0104927281,
-0.0524487719,
0.034387216,
0.0017043824,
-0.0699575767,
-0.0145763922,
0.0036643683,
-0.0247747786,
0.0253851619,
-0.0127205402,
0.0149918394,
0.0536545999,
0.0617604479,
0.0339186452,
-0.0294564813,
-0.005861978,
0.0168808233,
0.0076146545,
-0.0041179671,
-0.0058371094,
0.0052591716,
-0.0202506986,
0.062063735,
0.043300461,
-0.0069973134,
0.0226741191,
-0.0028026663,
-0.058118619,
0.0347206816,
-0.053714294,
0.0554321595,
0.0107709579,
-0.0152527848,
-0.0689361393,
-0.0251915995,
-0.0167862456,
0.0164827425,
-0.0147721199,
-0.0216468982,
0.0385559425,
0.0000522206,
-0.0081967814,
0.0067478246,
0.021579599,
-0.0123518752,
0.0122402823,
-0.0350318737,
0.0157663338,
0.0300602987,
-0.0206314754,
-0.0026694688,
-0.0822124109,
-0.033427529,
0.0136792595,
-0.0232499335,
0.0755312443,
0.0129145607,
0.0192080792,
0.0025435686,
-0.0589880832,
-0.0100954473,
-0.0123919575,
0.00227532,
0.0085396823,
0.0149611905,
0.0530466288,
0.0172155071,
-0.0124399019,
0.0808746889,
-0.0339347534,
-0.0226825047,
-0.05288646,
-0.0649387836,
0.0028379634,
0.0028206513,
-0.0479043722,
0.0248550605,
-0.0677541196,
0.0192085449,
0.0093038175,
-0.0297131315,
-0.0229805708,
0.0114337895,
2.725e-7,
0.0470811799,
0.0686786398,
0.0070538614,
0.0054557193,
0.0128628174,
-0.0020301815,
-0.0300463177,
-0.0078533124,
-0.0020892506,
-0.0026180297,
0.0181453284,
0.0349217691,
0.0679605678,
0.0067927162,
-0.0490961149,
-0.0068148267,
-0.0581405163,
0.0192286614,
-0.047117345,
-0.0203591902,
0.0202702451,
0.0825671405,
-0.0324203186,
-0.0198849719,
0.0327239446,
0.0139662623,
0.0315784924,
-0.0324801877,
-0.0170557369,
0.0611826815,
0.0065171062,
0.0142705068,
-0.0018249667,
0.0262437817,
-0.0292224232,
-0.0307260286,
-0.0103176497,
0.1344272345,
-0.0368114412,
0.0234386176,
0.0556904003,
0.010957188,
-0.0100433435,
-0.033691328,
0.0353824571,
-0.0658968985,
-0.0207952876,
-0.0204145815,
0.0035871922,
-0.0100973751,
0.067196779,
-0.0256198943,
0.0017317487,
0.0279883277,
0.0426145419,
-0.0002910768,
-0.0527146235,
-0.0438192189,
-0.0116730202,
0.0466075316,
-0.0376906805,
-0.0329711698,
-0.016454326,
-0.0125299096,
-0.0150818741,
-0.0684836358,
0.0060036592,
2.536765252e-34,
0.012143991,
-0.0269641206,
0.0648194179,
0.0307990555,
0.0345392004,
-0.0087843025,
-0.0219600946,
0.0568730012,
0.0134688541,
-0.0731143877,
-0.0171577334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14557v1 | The Skipped Beat: A Study of Sociopragmatic Understanding in LLMs for 64 Languages | 2023-10-23T04:22:44 | 2023-10-23T04:22:44 | Chiyu Zhang, Khai Duy Doan, Qisheng Liao, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuned large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, demonstrate
remarkable performance in a wide range of tasks. Despite numerous recent
studies that examine the performance of instruction-tuned LLMs on various NLP
benchmarks, there remains a lack of comprehensive investigation into their
ability to understand cross-lingual sociopragmatic meaning (SM), i.e., meaning
embedded within social and interactive contexts. This deficiency arises partly
from SM not being adequately represented in any of the existing benchmarks. To
address this gap, we present SPARROW, an extensive multilingual benchmark
specifically designed for SM understanding. SPARROW comprises 169 datasets
covering 13 task types across six primary categories (e.g., anti-social
language detection, emotion recognition). SPARROW datasets encompass 64
different languages originating from 12 language families representing 16
writing scripts. We evaluate the performance of various multilingual pretrained
language models (e.g., mT5) and instruction-tuned LLMs (e.g., BLOOMZ, ChatGPT)
on SPARROW through fine-tuning, zero-shot, and/or few-shot learning. Our
comprehensive analysis reveals that existing open-source instruction tuned LLMs
still struggle to understand SM across various languages, performing close to a
random baseline in some cases. We also find that although ChatGPT outperforms
many LLMs, it still falls behind task-specific finetuned models with a gap of
12.19 SPARROW score. Our benchmark is available at:
https://github.com/UBC-NLP/SPARROW | [
0.0265221447,
0.0308850557,
-0.0088695055,
0.0986596346,
-0.0347006172,
0.0210095998,
0.005491077,
-0.000326352,
0.0315440111,
-0.0312068649,
-0.0776593089,
-0.0404989123,
0.0089032687,
0.01439727,
0.0269754287,
-0.027336996,
0.0562757403,
0.0209895223,
0.0069271587,
-0.0059492118,
-0.0048813089,
0.0307480954,
0.00003258,
0.0535154827,
-0.0112258727,
-0.0219250731,
-0.0195439234,
0.0444250889,
0.0363472849,
-0.0216981433,
0.0178928729,
0.0407784693,
0.0285826791,
0.0379478149,
0.0000019154,
-0.0586710535,
0.0050229868,
-0.0426217876,
-0.0071956692,
0.0120195169,
0.0889533609,
-0.0532215461,
-0.0307657532,
0.0227362085,
-0.0530899838,
-0.0074474658,
0.0239418037,
0.0278628618,
0.0324413031,
0.0875638723,
-0.0144356918,
-0.0163254756,
-0.0042431625,
-0.0636442155,
-0.0252854247,
-0.0551755764,
0.0084345108,
0.0256140605,
-0.0078143924,
0.0055100899,
-0.0561824441,
0.0494632386,
0.0073731635,
-0.0071284296,
0.0066264397,
0.0097217336,
-0.056814108,
-0.024588231,
-0.0138880881,
0.0932801068,
-0.0111995703,
-0.0044583702,
-0.0190485939,
-0.0138247516,
-0.0059432625,
-0.0061822301,
-0.0239477698,
0.0068257935,
0.0328992084,
0.0420164354,
0.0192420613,
0.0214221384,
0.0337673239,
0.0151783014,
0.0307817124,
0.0188786555,
-0.0180309974,
0.0275562387,
0.0300477594,
0.008096219,
0.0002272007,
-0.026613934,
0.0191864353,
0.0312492456,
0.0050969874,
0.0319094397,
-0.0338407867,
0.0398200415,
0.0188108683,
-0.0369746275,
0.0454440042,
0.060255073,
-0.016073199,
0.0596061312,
0.0037541604,
-0.0010600281,
-0.0187499002,
0.0054794149,
-0.0233719312,
0.0007922831,
-0.0400095917,
0.003522764,
-0.0285402369,
0.0003723314,
-0.0756531656,
-0.0251863245,
-0.0424093157,
0.0282283425,
-0.0090633342,
0.0055673299,
-0.0344994627,
-0.0171232782,
-0.0398987718,
0.0088592172,
0.0157258604,
0.0614490584,
-0.0218126383,
0.005232254,
-0.0415302999,
-0.0962107182,
-0.0145581439,
-0.0038267197,
0.0217211284,
-0.025817778,
0.0396432839,
0.05022984,
-0.0056162486,
-0.0645121336,
-0.0386242345,
-0.0226312168,
-0.023266077,
-0.0983923525,
-0.0039519276,
-0.0522742681,
0.0737712011,
0.0079407031,
-0.0038371126,
-0.0268821195,
0.011813364,
-0.0006864698,
-0.0179538447,
0.0359937325,
0.0287863556,
0.0090563642,
-0.0237673055,
0.0322675779,
-0.0051194844,
0.0878772736,
0.0125162574,
0.0004130601,
0.050973922,
-0.0028497642,
-0.0158025306,
0.0639575049,
0.0130173918,
0.0075027049,
0.0081042051,
-0.0099249361,
-0.0022031176,
0.0447601005,
0.049246449,
0.023020694,
-0.0379345827,
-0.0546494052,
0.0480724312,
0.0442709662,
-0.0174508914,
0.0400745757,
0.0190473367,
0.064150162,
0.0128326342,
0.004967235,
-0.0310153812,
0.0302294176,
-0.0278699137,
-0.0388422683,
-0.0288102049,
-0.0024472247,
-0.0450184718,
-0.0054023159,
-0.0215962138,
-0.0177249424,
0.0335455574,
0.023480121,
0.0394551754,
-0.011562963,
-0.0369556807,
0.0144577492,
0.0510591604,
-0.052507624,
-0.0149820978,
-0.0217203777,
-0.0209307708,
0.0612323768,
0.0319051407,
-0.032655783,
-0.0356927738,
-0.0194634199,
0.0490015708,
0.0614449754,
0.0568390302,
-0.0258228686,
0.0739485845,
-0.0546240918,
0.01767518,
-0.0480233319,
-0.0046515493,
0.0444005989,
0.0041568796,
0.0253160149,
0.0000963533,
-0.0341055058,
-0.014893299,
0.027453145,
-0.0726670325,
-0.0175574645,
-0.0177208502,
0.0143871829,
0.0157679003,
0.004983637,
-0.0192771889,
-0.0414624065,
0.0153594082,
-0.0553906001,
0.0332725346,
0.0429835282,
-0.031604141,
-0.0775690749,
0.032319326,
-0.0185161475,
-0.0563445091,
0.0538587682,
-0.0405802615,
-0.0352581739,
0.0587203875,
-0.0193690099,
0.0512043722,
-0.0447686315,
-0.0244527422,
-0.0320783593,
0.0533180237,
-0.0030556021,
0.0229279622,
0.0172535069,
-0.0122867199,
-0.0075800428,
0.0078883069,
0.0286847297,
0.0033888251,
-0.0409195945,
0.0416978039,
-0.0084828958,
-0.0324357376,
-0.0021297394,
0.0319667123,
-0.0606676228,
-0.0523896888,
-0.1156983227,
0.0068407715,
-0.0209414512,
0.011512517,
0.0298958179,
-0.0043677702,
-0.0296837091,
-0.0149478102,
-0.0311491266,
0.0139120789,
-0.012822249,
-0.0065722931,
0.0337111093,
0.010041263,
-0.0008882739,
-0.045733951,
0.0124662081,
-0.016848363,
0.0291136187,
-0.0247704219,
-0.0018562444,
-0.014624808,
0.0232055187,
-0.0459407046,
0.0014640951,
-0.0430861376,
-0.0690926462,
-0.0003658145,
0.0287328474,
0.042571336,
0.0914769843,
-0.0256279707,
0.061466042,
0.020017786,
-0.0378349274,
-0.0471872948,
0.0099370694,
-0.000365059,
0.0155306766,
-0.049595587,
-0.059002623,
-0.0640558973,
0.0670231655,
0.013713819,
0.015603764,
-0.0831460804,
-0.0080655003,
0.0023067985,
-0.0399427898,
-0.0241764896,
0.0241346378,
-0.0020736272,
-0.0111094918,
-0.0448492281,
-0.0270232875,
0.0568813458,
-0.0067148898,
-0.0520035475,
-0.0319138318,
-0.031104384,
-0.0354042687,
0.1096212789,
-0.0316419378,
0.0334573835,
-0.0195146557,
-0.0119637903,
-0.0419814847,
-0.0121053606,
0.0201478545,
-0.0313061848,
0.0332571194,
-0.0370053947,
-0.0249540322,
-0.0119495299,
-0.0350972302,
-0.0135407913,
-0.0750631541,
-0.0424592532,
-0.0147531722,
-0.003254605,
-0.0213675126,
0.0247460417,
-0.0159730017,
0.0112270396,
-0.0124824718,
-0.0227504224,
-0.0221911147,
-0.0231970623,
-0.0111527285,
0.0388309844,
-0.0287626144,
0.0251790695,
-0.0157817882,
0.0635740831,
0.0429608747,
0.040650975,
-0.0355279855,
-0.0202721469,
0.0163371079,
0.019645879,
0.0261226874,
-0.0358313993,
-0.0392413326,
0.0952738598,
-0.0522354543,
0.0023368266,
0.0982820615,
-0.0135967322,
-0.012136003,
0.0247069243,
-0.0414300486,
0.0333804041,
0.0175064765,
0.0144893993,
-0.0617222339,
-0.0478536896,
0.0056160246,
-0.0065653739,
0.005361049,
-0.0347336642,
-0.0366596393,
-0.0934245586,
0.0294180606,
-0.0000199107,
-0.0556181781,
0.0115315439,
-0.0219665244,
0.0040726527,
-0.0158026516,
0.0118997926,
-0.0237909071,
-0.0341286585,
-0.0217085071,
0.00175838,
-0.0343737751,
-0.0604048297,
0.0823924616,
-0.0376203805,
0.0665483922,
-0.0011792738,
0.0977040008,
-0.0181186683,
-0.0087336339,
0.0537368543,
-0.0115440087,
-0.0147915008,
-0.0282911938,
0.0440709814,
-0.0173115358,
-0.0273838248,
0.0037710946,
0.0266175196,
-0.0521594025,
0.0058797314,
-0.0287385937,
0.0522353277,
-0.016280625,
-0.0253299847,
0.029740531,
0.0362100378,
-0.0093591074,
0.0852620676,
0.0319465287,
-0.0235059559,
-0.0335476995,
0.0001860436,
0.0113454619,
-0.0308758635,
-0.0064583062,
0.0041123112,
-0.0104310215,
-0.0417765528,
-0.0208814479,
-0.0989170969,
0.0405505374,
0.0352934524,
0.0166870877,
-0.0001669739,
0.0289662238,
-0.0120995492,
-0.0446406156,
0.0465254858,
-0.0352328382,
0.0307262298,
-0.008265065,
-0.0166852716,
0.0043138703,
-0.0227778368,
0.0136114322,
-0.0075298171,
-0.0698228553,
-0.0879089013,
0.0179573987,
0.0146796992,
0.0176223591,
0.0428320616,
-0.0199966673,
-0.0497762226,
-0.0263061393,
-0.0019249576,
0.0172315668,
0.0688156113,
0.0600010566,
0.000757975,
-0.0041655335,
0.0585794337,
-0.0155893881,
0.0231175181,
0.0223113224,
0.0365850739,
-0.0166551713,
-0.0242136046,
-0.0298528932,
0.0078282831,
0.0238322914,
-0.0255255308,
-0.0606184378,
-0.0331935361,
-0.028537171,
-0.0277052987,
0.0232949201,
-0.0441117696,
-0.0371118933,
0.0291065518,
-0.0129353544,
-0.0439069457,
-0.0315132663,
-0.0528312102,
0.0206804201,
-0.0177151226,
0.0352426954,
-0.0055349348,
-0.0200287364,
-0.0247948449,
0.0380109623,
-0.0337873362,
0.0272205193,
-0.0175324176,
0.0241068564,
-0.0011718055,
0.0533118062,
0.0240549333,
-0.0301701725,
0.0320264697,
0.0308048092,
-0.0137148108,
0.0244645309,
0.0338157676,
0.0404567532,
0.0825341195,
-0.0165706147,
0.0731854141,
-0.0344364941,
0.0218095351,
-0.0243980698,
0.0532510057,
-0.0401700474,
-0.06881392,
0.0338812694,
0.0087425355,
-0.0346478112,
0.0395306796,
0.0557118058,
-0.0320787914,
0.0462755635,
0.0585654639,
0.0265348703,
-0.0139958709,
-0.0149961021,
0.0598962866,
-0.000982572,
0.003867913,
0.0456730314,
-0.0791963711,
-0.0623458512,
0.0299341287,
0.0000676613,
-0.0121544274,
-0.033334434,
-0.0044315755,
0.0691457987,
-0.0034162875,
0.0315678641,
-0.0493642986,
0.0238129981,
-0.0307536293,
0.0070434087,
-0.0088162245,
-6.258801387e-33,
-0.0195436329,
-0.0033950796,
-0.0108639598,
0.0349328667,
-0.0458187498,
0.0407673605,
-0.061493136,
0.0061799474,
-0.0506702103,
0.0393035859,
-0.0011040037,
0.0314560793,
0.0063176546,
-0.0071674101,
-0.0161087848,
-0.0511944219,
0.0091395145,
0.0096872635,
-0.0199950468,
0.0349922404,
0.0349676013,
0.0360771641,
0.0818326175,
-0.0370904021,
0.0209547188,
-0.0194522627,
-0.0092951106,
0.0191410668,
0.0483492352,
0.0255414657,
-0.020055132,
0.0661857426,
0.0281255823,
0.0314529464,
0.0144505156,
0.0146936923,
-0.0475195907,
-0.0400519967,
0.034636572,
0.0476346277,
-0.0252621397,
-0.0145337572,
0.0172495618,
-0.0222102851,
-0.0287659187,
0.0096633928,
-0.0073424708,
-0.012332187,
0.0042106216,
-0.0206194501,
-0.0617169142,
0.0290644355,
-0.0123799928,
-0.0522404499,
0.0148138711,
0.0542791374,
0.0129883438,
0.0161680281,
-0.0498188883,
-0.0067181992,
-0.0578695685,
0.003432509,
0.0277532768,
-0.0051688608,
0.0143641224,
0.0856976882,
0.0111683877,
0.0346830115,
0.0251708236,
0.0160751268,
0.0790703818,
0.0340334326,
0.0003988469,
0.0573413558,
-0.0125080701,
0.0048792441,
-0.0471168458,
0.0072477558,
0.0801772401,
0.0075576222,
0.0243197531,
-0.0034584887,
-0.0356340259,
-0.0049059871,
-0.0324272439,
0.0150540425,
-0.0089340005,
-0.0289393421,
0.0241678003,
-0.0279365946,
-0.0110391239,
0.009070402,
0.0506708585,
-0.0463050157,
-0.0191143844,
0.029139962,
-0.0336938947,
0.0205663126,
0.0218835082,
0.0651931837,
-0.0251210257,
-0.0598948188,
0.010444968,
0.0012207581,
0.0350891314,
-0.02015201,
0.0531060174,
0.0300780442,
-0.0306616258,
0.002395666,
-0.0502434894,
0.0414872244,
-0.0408290252,
0.005369585,
0.0158746932,
0.0183130205,
-0.0400052927,
0.0275848452,
0.0290897377,
0.0235146135,
-0.027342394,
0.0050134324,
-0.0308305565,
0.0323523097,
-0.0345190279,
0.0005205454,
-0.0141789969,
-0.017301375,
0.0172961559,
-0.0438681394,
-0.0143306768,
-0.0107865501,
2.747e-7,
0.0338914171,
0.049775444,
-0.0091273123,
0.0243455376,
0.0058861445,
0.0490183942,
-0.0514319353,
0.0611762553,
-0.0079247365,
-0.0132579636,
0.0216140859,
0.0498909391,
0.0727386847,
0.0140485475,
-0.0529795103,
0.0346877165,
-0.0526419654,
0.0151163703,
-0.0120487018,
0.010398645,
0.0184966791,
0.0873763189,
0.0380956009,
0.0069461172,
0.001044453,
-0.0416582152,
0.0720774978,
-0.0532369316,
-0.048200462,
0.0099649355,
-0.0217405614,
0.0048239813,
0.026224101,
-0.0036395793,
-0.0082232011,
0.0198544115,
-0.0109771937,
0.0880138204,
-0.0162272844,
-0.0335800461,
0.0269098561,
-0.0172568895,
-0.0382565595,
-0.0409123451,
0.066617988,
-0.0451645069,
-0.0551053248,
-0.0319316499,
0.0243158527,
-0.0252496134,
0.0577727146,
0.0000658082,
-0.0464385822,
0.0271093212,
0.0401627384,
-0.0944198966,
-0.0248116702,
-0.056462124,
-0.0041247793,
0.0278914459,
0.0059110061,
-0.005965197,
-0.0130380448,
-0.0035774,
0.0225141142,
-0.045749113,
-0.0184297841,
2.370951902e-34,
0.0419762842,
-0.0245713647,
0.0122176586,
-0.0042737541,
0.0365893319,
0.0084350845,
-0.0425241329,
0.0160192344,
0.0180235431,
-0.0241079852,
0.0272864997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14545v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14545v2 | Harnessing ChatGPT for thematic analysis: Are we ready? | 2023-10-23T03:55:13 | 2023-10-24T01:56:05 | V Vien Lee, Stephanie C. C. van der Lubbe, Lay Hoon Goh, Jose M. Valderas | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT is an advanced natural language processing tool with growing
applications across various disciplines in medical research. Thematic analysis,
a qualitative research method to identify and interpret patterns in data, is
one application that stands to benefit from this technology. This viewpoint
explores the utilization of ChatGPT in three core phases of thematic analysis
within a medical context: 1) direct coding of transcripts, 2) generating themes
from a predefined list of codes, and 3) preprocessing quotes for manuscript
inclusion. Additionally, we explore the potential of ChatGPT to generate
interview transcripts, which may be used for training purposes. We assess the
strengths and limitations of using ChatGPT in these roles, highlighting areas
where human intervention remains necessary. Overall, we argue that ChatGPT can
function as a valuable tool during analysis, enhancing the efficiency of the
thematic analysis and offering additional insights into the qualitative data. | [
0.0699089542,
0.0336527526,
-0.0114703262,
-0.0434701033,
-0.0170177147,
0.0455100499,
-0.0247634444,
-0.0132204806,
-0.0013470696,
-0.0168681014,
0.0397498123,
0.0171870477,
0.0127903298,
0.0523089506,
-0.0206198059,
-0.0107342834,
-0.0107096974,
0.0530062914,
0.0468418784,
0.0567550696,
0.0117852231,
0.07691174,
-0.0172095578,
0.0532268807,
0.0273028482,
-0.0390541144,
0.0303231459,
0.0034967745,
0.0307017267,
-0.0782929286,
0.0089373216,
0.011593326,
-0.0042501087,
-0.0163166933,
0.0000023545,
-0.0286741424,
-0.0291455109,
0.0394029245,
-0.0059896572,
-0.0232194029,
0.0565918721,
0.0061060055,
-0.0059067248,
0.023801934,
-0.0428150557,
-0.0222584046,
0.0564137064,
0.0180115271,
0.0256829429,
0.0368139483,
-0.0316559896,
-0.0158842206,
-0.0361039229,
0.0203795228,
0.0059898207,
0.0460487418,
-0.0137846544,
0.0152867241,
0.0550744832,
0.0190045089,
0.0521215871,
0.0522447079,
-0.0242326874,
0.0022657549,
0.0201216266,
0.0444512926,
-0.0692211166,
-0.0525035337,
0.0270368867,
-0.0012128587,
0.0830570534,
0.0243736282,
0.0415533893,
0.0124910995,
0.0125764925,
-0.0084267585,
-0.0537197366,
-0.0160414577,
-0.0522031002,
-0.0215402674,
0.0055940133,
0.0420888066,
-0.0274844151,
-0.0366127342,
-0.001602967,
-0.0740245283,
0.0046940474,
-0.0026676876,
0.0165042337,
-0.0038982155,
0.0027124742,
-0.0271766596,
0.0005749381,
-0.0352669768,
-0.0138782263,
0.000350637,
0.0377045758,
0.0009582416,
0.0700394437,
-0.0301214959,
-0.0337023251,
0.0299949907,
-0.0194702409,
-0.0280059408,
0.0328404382,
-0.0447555669,
0.0258752275,
-0.0021062552,
-0.0503083952,
0.0390257649,
-0.0727408677,
-0.0282290615,
-0.0292883646,
-0.0029033439,
-0.0121197859,
-0.0043608299,
-0.0427995846,
-0.0117755849,
0.0239553843,
-0.0028597941,
-0.0156375691,
0.0250363257,
-0.0198459011,
0.0333279222,
0.0367275961,
-0.0080029368,
-0.0076040532,
0.0018096686,
0.0209143162,
-0.0621230304,
0.0621622652,
-0.011143188,
0.0188874416,
0.0197608639,
0.0201004799,
0.0337315947,
0.0029576602,
-0.0069007729,
-0.0062923185,
-0.0207548328,
-0.0176304989,
-0.0061871572,
0.0371288322,
-0.0385698713,
0.0185559858,
0.0237616878,
0.0021711309,
0.0029172085,
0.0198018104,
0.0426565632,
-0.0497465245,
0.0322528519,
-0.0490374789,
-0.0023860694,
0.0170792602,
0.037075758,
0.0445833877,
-0.010308071,
0.0186759066,
-0.0134840459,
-0.0073534371,
-0.066620037,
-0.0210715625,
-0.0039760116,
-0.0162491966,
-0.0210687611,
0.0203634184,
0.0189254731,
-0.0021017047,
0.0414799787,
-0.0400075391,
0.0614290051,
-0.0204604957,
0.0666714236,
0.0161066409,
0.1462474614,
0.0149075454,
0.0584617816,
0.0075279814,
0.0080313245,
-0.0184483211,
-0.0124173379,
0.0190174803,
-0.0389119238,
0.0751509666,
-0.0071186055,
0.0176184084,
0.0211759545,
-0.0122808553,
-0.0245127156,
-0.0436331816,
0.0361335203,
0.0268721636,
0.0119526563,
-0.053212259,
0.0063273283,
0.0065878439,
-0.041275084,
0.012839051,
-0.0410200022,
-0.0121069634,
-0.044396691,
-0.0385105126,
0.0731394216,
0.0563687347,
0.0204887688,
0.0076571717,
-0.0542997271,
-0.0119213555,
0.0073769558,
-0.0152265988,
0.0115044136,
-0.0241161417,
-0.0175109915,
0.0177962165,
0.0234233681,
-0.0195883922,
0.0159518123,
-0.0338573903,
0.0362264961,
-0.0349720865,
0.0298005808,
-0.0527728014,
0.0395198576,
-0.0291867461,
-0.0568422154,
0.0265362039,
-0.0525499471,
0.0345496014,
0.0659297556,
-0.0227084365,
0.0499552824,
0.0037831082,
-0.0141997077,
-0.0212172773,
0.0847172365,
0.0082807299,
-0.0183007512,
-0.0236256626,
-0.0817236826,
-0.0081158401,
-0.0305162594,
-0.0067263874,
0.0069223898,
0.0098465392,
-0.0368941277,
0.0476073921,
0.0002609199,
-0.0378498472,
0.0519980378,
0.0169325899,
-0.0325933099,
-0.0279499795,
0.017450301,
-0.0221611913,
-0.0275268704,
-0.1002038717,
0.0027510575,
-0.0302657485,
0.0205289461,
0.0306056701,
-0.0128733655,
-0.0077785365,
0.0468198843,
0.0413716286,
-0.0252745505,
-0.0194306914,
-0.1543617696,
0.0089993747,
0.000887169,
-0.0004548366,
0.0259018671,
0.0094078444,
-0.0250921063,
-0.0006426113,
-0.0212458745,
-0.0652321652,
0.0328148194,
0.0271354206,
0.0176112745,
0.0475409813,
0.0267025121,
-0.0270346198,
-0.0064392989,
-0.0290369,
0.0417196341,
0.0733285844,
-0.0380014479,
0.000376435,
-0.0241487995,
-0.0212622508,
-0.0478625633,
0.0133960303,
-0.0381859429,
0.0417433567,
-0.0043699257,
0.0100243594,
0.0111767733,
0.0220677089,
0.0316910297,
-0.001535802,
-0.0506314933,
0.0067119603,
-0.022591589,
-0.0136308735,
-0.0077605038,
0.000624783,
-0.0756767541,
0.0586188808,
0.0420632772,
0.0513965152,
0.0105866631,
-0.0409204997,
-0.0336901955,
0.0006344548,
0.0705756471,
-0.0658247918,
-0.0424469784,
-0.0345836654,
0.0421657115,
0.0329638496,
0.0085920086,
0.0153842494,
-0.0043488094,
0.0049253334,
-0.1282264888,
-0.0304828398,
-0.0438900702,
0.0250628442,
-0.0300269444,
0.0085756527,
0.0554192513,
-0.0281019323,
0.0406094119,
-0.0393909551,
0.003837439,
-0.0205884483,
0.0001667706,
-0.0684527233,
0.0162077751,
0.0111365709,
-0.0095418794,
-0.0353980921,
0.0130711272,
-0.0274694432,
-0.0182084311,
0.0460234135,
0.0169095863,
-0.035803549,
-0.0090102348,
-0.0097875623,
0.0799888521,
0.0084758149,
-0.030231338,
0.0251761433,
-0.0228559189,
0.0384927094,
-0.0643257126,
0.0188509151,
0.0557079986,
0.0197416469,
0.0702194273,
-0.0405471362,
0.026687732,
0.0126932217,
-0.0081909895,
-0.0033565813,
-0.0156479478,
-0.0045643384,
0.0227445439,
0.0262458138,
-0.0292946082,
-0.0063604806,
0.0783907324,
0.0084543759,
-0.0249228254,
0.0105903484,
-0.015923636,
-0.0177813042,
-0.0150958756,
0.0124421399,
-0.0799618885,
-0.0002153844,
-0.0312180202,
0.0296289772,
-0.0602782667,
-0.0109304832,
-0.0454073101,
-0.0033678515,
0.0386542007,
-0.0068095261,
-0.049109742,
-0.0073194406,
-0.0054051965,
-0.0133005707,
-0.0003951747,
-0.0293472726,
-0.0359463133,
-0.0321311504,
0.0411743186,
0.0294698682,
-0.1405483335,
-0.0575258508,
0.0408890657,
0.0221279506,
0.0340831205,
0.0480144732,
0.0390067697,
-0.0066138227,
0.0105368709,
0.0195197631,
-0.0201679561,
-0.0119967097,
0.0240885038,
0.0240607895,
-0.0164760724,
0.0253332909,
-0.0262878556,
0.0892318636,
-0.0423032865,
-0.0201422274,
0.0476195849,
0.0686091706,
-0.0620798171,
-0.0089022992,
-0.0397793241,
0.0777427927,
0.0201299153,
0.0205299426,
0.037973728,
0.0227179918,
0.0269348454,
0.016409928,
0.0560704209,
0.0220561437,
-0.0649547428,
0.0025272223,
-0.0299049877,
0.0221333858,
-0.0269640479,
-0.0851396918,
0.057055708,
-0.0394091979,
-0.0029604025,
0.0133347102,
-0.0009960562,
0.0122874668,
-0.0657409057,
0.0554955937,
0.0426083133,
-0.0066395593,
0.009085454,
-0.0307093058,
0.0294019114,
0.0110856472,
-0.0095065292,
-0.0031049943,
-0.0124306753,
0.0027289221,
0.037162751,
-0.0165422875,
0.0112056946,
-0.0111936843,
0.0323829018,
0.0082010608,
0.0107799852,
0.0338432565,
-0.0634697303,
-0.0327293538,
-0.0260021165,
0.0687274039,
0.0062332414,
-0.0342842452,
0.0195148531,
0.0210658554,
-0.0424260311,
-0.0383966938,
-0.0279484559,
0.0024935484,
0.0213111043,
0.0091261854,
0.0619506426,
-0.0524384417,
-0.0151192518,
-0.0354549959,
-0.0473468304,
-0.0048816162,
0.0002346113,
-0.0535778478,
-0.0053021,
-0.0161398649,
-0.0038321989,
-0.0596905388,
-0.0323514082,
-0.1376676261,
0.0242657959,
-0.0250784922,
0.0854769126,
0.0196783263,
0.0134540107,
0.0092439977,
-0.0220712759,
-0.0166509636,
0.00074462,
-0.0354001634,
0.034713842,
-0.0059525338,
0.0449786223,
-0.0051133004,
0.013362661,
0.0486442558,
0.0384758301,
-0.0589611381,
-0.0620262325,
-0.0225596614,
-0.022545699,
-0.0075300219,
-0.0170640741,
0.0062710871,
-0.0374166295,
0.0103560565,
-0.0039020018,
0.0077255485,
-0.0402355306,
0.0032135225,
0.0255338661,
-0.0204799324,
-0.0416049659,
-0.0848516673,
0.0230061132,
-0.0247620977,
0.0104645398,
0.0205973834,
-0.0337383412,
-0.0438017584,
-0.04518741,
0.0578252301,
-0.0186499041,
-0.0212352462,
0.007729908,
-0.0529331043,
-0.0030912987,
-0.0033498649,
-0.0275404062,
0.0158126988,
-0.0181237198,
0.0135253286,
0.0244951844,
-0.0147989141,
-0.0298080724,
-0.0359165221,
0.0303565338,
-0.0359503329,
-0.0174163897,
0.0117972605,
-6.224728948e-33,
-0.0046085566,
-0.0356734544,
0.0439022854,
0.0408154689,
-0.0271702055,
0.0124189742,
-0.0158461109,
0.0128919762,
0.0273882374,
0.0414809063,
-0.0391202085,
-0.0003989231,
-0.0042492528,
0.037141379,
0.0497182198,
-0.0078588407,
0.0510837957,
0.0118014729,
-0.0012467771,
0.016644543,
-0.0390206315,
0.0329042636,
0.0555355549,
-0.0903679132,
0.0496817715,
-0.0022517506,
0.0101318778,
-0.0292345546,
0.0635100156,
-0.0052729845,
-0.0414691046,
-0.0151326098,
0.022347806,
-0.0058641802,
-0.0030178686,
0.0222246833,
-0.0231485199,
-0.0473843254,
0.0240078848,
-0.0228198916,
0.0013677573,
-0.0333285779,
0.0212175641,
-0.039010711,
-0.0019323094,
-0.0108665116,
0.0143944006,
-0.0240036938,
-0.00521649,
-0.0488231517,
-0.0171186104,
0.0404854491,
-0.0245079678,
0.0285944007,
-0.0438777581,
0.0580360927,
-0.0477477238,
-0.039404504,
0.0212606117,
0.0005785132,
0.0019396687,
0.0171587802,
-0.032079149,
-0.0413331352,
-0.0179605354,
0.0377675258,
-0.0232811272,
-0.0543504432,
-0.0273313951,
0.0492281839,
-0.0287821926,
-0.0199478865,
0.036223352,
0.0483850837,
0.0111926179,
0.0028908199,
-0.0231041554,
0.0232967902,
-0.0606430285,
0.0183164272,
0.0206793454,
-0.0205842387,
-0.0401415192,
-0.0385943204,
-0.0205159262,
-0.0104664564,
0.0193011221,
-0.0474655591,
0.0136269517,
-0.0232148468,
-0.0413824841,
0.0477410741,
0.0268798396,
0.0101116691,
0.0468416177,
-0.0175261386,
-0.0190820023,
0.0006082811,
-0.0292534642,
-0.0025619473,
-0.0683123693,
0.0355142057,
0.057214696,
0.0123641938,
0.0766890347,
0.0145411603,
0.0252382178,
-0.0284598581,
-0.0694205537,
-0.0158793256,
0.045515582,
0.0597614311,
-0.022624366,
-0.0186337717,
-0.0082539348,
0.0414622836,
0.0038146926,
0.0563044846,
0.007869265,
0.0288621932,
-0.0453774966,
-0.0016264399,
-0.0144991726,
-0.017596934,
-0.0210462082,
0.0299999174,
-0.0300424919,
0.0366211757,
0.0798365846,
-0.017683845,
0.0171376038,
-0.0113521703,
3.053e-7,
0.0435480475,
0.0525851473,
0.0042830128,
-0.0690927356,
0.0393473059,
-0.0038497599,
0.0504920334,
0.009126842,
0.0176488534,
0.019388333,
0.0607331544,
0.0116570406,
-0.0095082819,
0.074770987,
-0.0437239595,
-0.0470896773,
-0.0742827728,
-0.0589070842,
-0.0587588288,
0.0069090659,
0.0767094567,
0.0536367744,
-0.0607294291,
-0.0099406289,
-0.0012192875,
0.0190279745,
0.0059996126,
-0.0319248848,
-0.0201875158,
0.040943034,
-0.0190716721,
-0.0085067824,
0.0051059485,
0.0179792717,
-0.0227263328,
-0.035038434,
-0.0017745631,
0.0389563031,
-0.0140045984,
0.0269766524,
0.0217797793,
0.0169449635,
0.002944388,
-0.0294751152,
0.0458095372,
-0.0799423158,
-0.0307766367,
-0.0300301369,
0.0103354771,
-0.0367639847,
0.0683844388,
-0.0150903175,
-0.054352887,
0.0525486097,
0.0197927821,
0.0273659565,
-0.0293999724,
-0.0707546398,
0.0445106067,
-0.0091821561,
-0.025280755,
-0.0182111003,
0.0468101799,
-0.0023474412,
-0.0180488694,
-0.0421713665,
0.0445090383,
2.759351995e-34,
0.0427516885,
0.0336654186,
-0.0066966112,
0.0098546771,
0.0664434657,
0.0165821519,
0.0448135175,
0.0298811141,
0.0273379441,
-0.021727588,
-0.0146372067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14542v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models on Controlled Generation Tasks | 2023-10-23T03:48:24 | 2023-10-23T03:48:24 | Jiao Sun, Yufei Tian, Wangchunshu Zhou, Nan Xu, Qian Hu, Rahul Gupta, John Frederick Wieting, Nanyun Peng, Xuezhe Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | While recent studies have looked into the abilities of large language models
in various benchmark tasks, including question generation, reading
comprehension, multilingual and etc, there have been few studies looking into
the controllability of large language models on generation tasks. We present an
extensive analysis of various benchmarks including a sentence planning
benchmark with different granularities. After comparing large language models
against state-of-the-start finetuned smaller models, we present a spectrum
showing large language models falling behind, are comparable, or exceed the
ability of smaller models. We conclude that **large language models struggle at
meeting fine-grained hard constraints**. | [
0.0419684127,
0.0521578193,
-0.0134734083,
0.0268704128,
-0.0446812622,
0.0101150526,
0.0311722253,
-0.0167957824,
-0.0094706267,
-0.0225220639,
-0.0013352069,
-0.0630805939,
-0.0097489404,
0.016937349,
0.0465445966,
-0.0495874397,
0.0269649737,
-0.0599714629,
-0.0096431533,
0.0019621784,
-0.0160879679,
-0.0005383547,
0.0027035135,
0.052471526,
0.0115860049,
-0.0050348663,
-0.013435293,
0.0068041719,
-0.0145808635,
-0.0068009878,
0.0115850968,
0.0404394791,
-0.0059460239,
0.0334317051,
0.000001711,
-0.0525108129,
0.0055197477,
-0.0316574275,
-0.0067102793,
0.0291274991,
0.0326083601,
-0.0297203474,
-0.007914097,
0.0154610155,
-0.0170471519,
0.0053883907,
0.0157274865,
0.0412661172,
0.0521185435,
0.0783027485,
0.0057168291,
-0.0270518046,
0.0089727612,
-0.0488469228,
-0.0021413958,
-0.0462813005,
0.0163247678,
0.0265543014,
0.0399645008,
-0.0033565168,
-0.0319091454,
0.0264637377,
0.0237403084,
-0.0032092517,
-0.0293963123,
0.0424485952,
-0.0171606559,
-0.054777734,
-0.0193915684,
0.0735200122,
-0.0191418529,
-0.0237061661,
0.0254882611,
-0.0266386848,
0.0063743833,
0.0017651363,
-0.0282884035,
0.0550008006,
0.0145977112,
0.0064749583,
0.0309078265,
-0.0423184,
0.0245628823,
0.0072950814,
-0.0314803533,
0.0597272366,
0.0394830182,
-0.0364610665,
-0.0001370841,
0.0167483408,
-0.0302496031,
-0.0862241983,
-0.0080170846,
0.0472602583,
-0.0753632486,
0.0189036094,
-0.0911120102,
-0.0074115745,
0.0100023327,
0.0059519764,
0.0649452358,
0.0313847214,
0.0337165929,
0.025591027,
-0.0059426571,
0.0846542567,
-0.0595252551,
-0.0024671606,
-0.0537225753,
0.0188720487,
-0.0069066714,
-0.0140006235,
-0.0577760115,
0.0070019159,
-0.0695250407,
-0.0490419045,
-0.0279597417,
0.0380139947,
0.0279510133,
0.0163567755,
-0.0032322998,
-0.003809328,
-0.0273045842,
-0.0124601237,
-0.0073317322,
0.0195697192,
-0.0584690012,
0.0065066172,
0.0493050106,
-0.0477604531,
0.0034125603,
0.0305983368,
0.012861005,
-0.0355090126,
-0.0189388916,
0.0307554156,
-0.0374865159,
-0.0092575997,
-0.0178187452,
-0.0669946,
-0.0482843257,
-0.0842312798,
0.0055376971,
-0.0375589468,
0.0207732357,
0.0082830964,
0.0068898448,
-0.0160824843,
0.0047648726,
0.0119486721,
-0.0264357459,
0.008256861,
0.036945641,
0.0318266973,
0.0144429142,
0.0007072272,
0.0238395128,
0.0554449223,
0.038685523,
0.0399179757,
0.0038460505,
0.0067319227,
-0.0026446381,
0.072548084,
0.0161020886,
0.0014589451,
-0.0236410405,
-0.0168715287,
0.0064700563,
0.0629429668,
0.0223625936,
0.094373472,
-0.0233891979,
0.020870883,
0.0704773217,
0.0112126851,
0.0182278957,
-0.0015065564,
0.1046532243,
0.0006153245,
0.0034339896,
0.0287449714,
-0.0350115485,
0.0062835994,
0.0040561338,
0.0466177091,
0.019986324,
0.0141666541,
-0.0309886597,
-0.0203313101,
0.0006431923,
0.0098566292,
-0.0187067352,
0.006728421,
0.0125921173,
0.0412624702,
-0.0716203228,
0.0178167671,
0.0079494277,
-0.0453769676,
0.0099827312,
-0.0374773629,
0.0503160916,
0.0307458956,
0.0517673902,
0.0287404172,
-0.0562805906,
0.0111899674,
0.0288341381,
0.0779560134,
0.0753434077,
-0.0214858167,
0.0006531524,
-0.0352163129,
0.0135339582,
-0.0237346329,
0.0163337495,
0.0112548573,
0.0024017608,
0.0082286187,
0.0161382016,
-0.0071346005,
-0.0236798804,
0.0335835181,
-0.0663088411,
-0.019141417,
-0.0217842311,
0.0121974619,
0.0259813722,
-0.0067740418,
-0.0193008352,
0.0300962217,
0.0175900981,
-0.05232618,
-0.0058152154,
0.0058279606,
-0.0815183818,
-0.0517177619,
0.0171893723,
-0.0093701761,
0.0016064825,
0.0278116185,
0.0014895936,
-0.0594738163,
0.0252903849,
-0.0356461704,
0.0090103811,
-0.0300302748,
0.0253343284,
0.0129609676,
0.006302713,
-0.0340049937,
0.0519823395,
-0.0056947907,
0.0208564438,
0.0573292673,
0.0445185751,
-0.0120592276,
-0.040731445,
-0.0535045676,
0.0364919975,
-0.0063269762,
-0.0026687547,
0.0438007116,
0.0372248292,
-0.0430474021,
-0.0644138753,
-0.0501784049,
0.0152155096,
-0.0407520272,
-0.0042096889,
0.0232099574,
0.0073781274,
-0.0036383721,
0.0209716111,
-0.0444452427,
0.0199775901,
0.044307448,
0.0052838628,
0.0190113224,
0.0139672728,
-0.0327302925,
-0.0386842526,
-0.0088701528,
0.0120687624,
0.0215221271,
0.014591598,
0.0021428792,
-0.0338241272,
0.0655718744,
-0.04213107,
0.0021631699,
-0.0000238305,
-0.0445503965,
0.0212384686,
-0.0111067025,
0.1060168892,
0.0629718751,
0.011246779,
0.0299693979,
0.0272218008,
-0.0094691264,
-0.019998977,
0.0278957617,
-0.0273375679,
-0.033352498,
-0.0633992255,
-0.0296451021,
0.0162780136,
0.0859343708,
0.0188827738,
0.0094001992,
-0.0678135306,
0.0331145748,
-0.0318142846,
-0.0506057255,
-0.013075023,
0.0082548829,
-0.0415187851,
0.0416482016,
-0.0414115004,
-0.0328866579,
0.0184526592,
-0.0370479561,
-0.014919037,
0.0026908931,
0.030732045,
-0.0313776061,
0.0559551865,
0.0393501222,
0.0338379107,
0.0128209628,
-0.021142412,
-0.0668143257,
0.0117384996,
0.016413264,
-0.0102118924,
0.043438144,
-0.0458993837,
0.0054649408,
-0.0000155432,
-0.0532354489,
-0.0411751904,
-0.0227248073,
-0.0237524286,
0.0212492328,
0.0528325066,
-0.0187928788,
-0.0213307813,
-0.0089488784,
0.0261196941,
0.032006193,
-0.0306449812,
-0.001825013,
-0.0335473381,
0.0532078966,
0.0964110643,
0.0159177762,
0.0148009565,
-0.0738273859,
0.0378075577,
0.0198689848,
0.0290316064,
0.042187281,
-0.0070547257,
0.0202186611,
0.012414529,
-0.0071574431,
-0.016052857,
0.0408451334,
0.0916826427,
-0.0313142203,
-0.0617716722,
0.1191169247,
0.0206058417,
0.0168496687,
0.0224180333,
0.01715854,
0.0720051453,
0.0242485125,
0.0167088024,
-0.0504679717,
-0.0134435249,
0.0118906954,
0.0083714928,
-0.0231441017,
-0.037501663,
-0.0325970873,
-0.1248547733,
0.0199363679,
0.0173685085,
-0.05192158,
0.0062806797,
0.0290359315,
-0.0297752544,
0.0190053601,
0.0268214811,
0.0260302052,
-0.0043118796,
-0.0027880433,
0.0176095907,
-0.0025309459,
-0.0393398777,
0.0019762563,
-0.0217914358,
0.0455078185,
0.0635848492,
0.0276090093,
0.0143060852,
0.0067298375,
0.044593025,
-0.0082187206,
0.0055024247,
-0.0043170699,
0.0107849455,
0.0200534277,
-0.0351518057,
-0.0176329631,
0.0578161478,
-0.0091572171,
0.0080151223,
0.0015847512,
0.0518725291,
-0.0094476137,
-0.0820794478,
0.0008882112,
0.0181290042,
0.0104150567,
0.0920253918,
0.0604330711,
-0.0700686797,
-0.0749450028,
-0.0018727549,
-0.0151548553,
-0.1092182994,
-0.0112092532,
0.0106074242,
0.0349846669,
0.0271810424,
-0.1054257154,
-0.0447126143,
0.0210549738,
0.0498650372,
0.0129362987,
0.0024454982,
0.0284666289,
-0.0487197824,
0.003280649,
-0.0279479828,
-0.0344432741,
0.0119582042,
-0.0924923718,
-0.0272409208,
0.0082496423,
-0.0269729625,
-0.0148641104,
0.0352139138,
-0.1131196842,
-0.0767420083,
-0.0018615206,
0.047540877,
0.0268810987,
0.0194904469,
-0.0011794622,
-0.0635648966,
0.0101219881,
-0.0138523905,
-0.0140759395,
0.068885088,
-0.02071229,
-0.0145326136,
-0.0110420985,
0.0630718991,
-0.020564137,
0.0434851386,
0.040470846,
0.0700686201,
0.0063126893,
-0.0349257514,
0.0283283014,
0.0373231918,
-0.0503068417,
-0.0438696221,
0.0119892452,
-0.0288652498,
-0.0333147198,
-0.0240573362,
-0.0243769977,
-0.0497522689,
-0.0084537026,
0.0338662826,
0.0084007895,
-0.0111405915,
-0.0057536825,
0.0160518568,
0.0487284027,
-0.0368303619,
-0.0240205042,
-0.0238026772,
-0.0033701137,
0.0579135716,
0.0005387906,
-0.023659708,
0.0314131491,
-0.0311399661,
0.0393365771,
0.0201900229,
0.058691185,
0.0282515492,
0.0067162463,
-0.0078719389,
-0.0157569908,
-0.0471118577,
-0.0399501771,
0.0200158115,
0.0173013471,
0.0528049767,
0.002480671,
0.0615428723,
-0.0420871377,
-0.0068553812,
-0.0380124301,
0.0311744437,
0.0145649733,
-0.0580793805,
0.0259857476,
-0.0011269415,
-0.01567984,
-0.0039751381,
0.0721266419,
0.0486458875,
0.0423680134,
0.0296808723,
0.0494202524,
-0.0570434406,
-0.0261708461,
-0.0248435345,
-0.0259215645,
-0.0182231646,
0.0267647747,
-0.0565524921,
-0.0497089587,
0.0193626396,
0.0110509982,
0.022755038,
-0.0166147333,
0.0328408442,
0.0331315659,
-0.0281762779,
0.0011213025,
-0.036731001,
0.005884836,
-0.0339985266,
-0.0192279126,
-0.0169410668,
-6.071094775e-33,
-0.0439509042,
-0.0184277687,
0.0482511669,
-0.0489692688,
-0.0366848595,
-0.0129322326,
-0.0761776716,
0.018778244,
-0.0104331952,
0.0155872498,
-0.0176643021,
-0.0039424463,
-0.0072535733,
0.0651669577,
-0.0065156766,
0.0025499335,
0.0648969188,
-0.0267458335,
-0.0448360555,
0.0474837422,
0.0285448655,
0.0235477518,
-0.008158721,
0.0308649596,
-0.020930158,
-0.0278475173,
-0.0281879045,
0.0089270994,
-0.0161070768,
0.0576507151,
-0.0203937814,
-0.0061138379,
0.0281609669,
-0.023905566,
-0.0421350449,
0.0497059189,
-0.0349558555,
-0.0238215458,
0.0268800445,
-0.0195746906,
-0.0553055182,
-0.0425753482,
0.0106104622,
-0.0269353464,
-0.0174643714,
-0.0015518083,
-0.0116978521,
-0.0020911852,
-0.0341952778,
-0.0339796916,
-0.0841603354,
-0.0058600921,
-0.0131008504,
-0.0317629538,
-0.0193877146,
0.0319448225,
-0.0242406894,
-0.0089923702,
0.0310819503,
0.0084445635,
0.0167831704,
0.0488323607,
0.036592856,
0.0360695198,
-0.0025216739,
0.0521263778,
0.0097346045,
0.019853184,
-0.0064475974,
0.0076054106,
0.0254041161,
0.0625568405,
0.0118303252,
0.0490998328,
0.0005327742,
-0.0087338714,
-0.0451545082,
-0.0125896344,
-0.0118635995,
0.0155786499,
0.0378394686,
-0.0240478441,
-0.0200924501,
-0.0118887201,
-0.0561443828,
0.0115577076,
-0.0233088266,
0.0083797947,
0.0647342131,
0.0401943922,
-0.0170687959,
-0.0355135612,
0.0511820391,
-0.0217581168,
0.0112299491,
0.0404689461,
-0.0639116839,
0.0300046392,
-0.0284904595,
0.0383309722,
-0.0854285657,
-0.026572708,
0.011694395,
0.021448167,
-0.0084501058,
0.0328033119,
0.0075915945,
0.0023512102,
-0.065292947,
0.002965329,
-0.0643383563,
0.0530210957,
-0.0256713387,
-0.0084981332,
0.0573760159,
-0.0204168279,
-0.0245856401,
0.0299314428,
0.0059147538,
-0.0529535338,
-0.0103697963,
-0.0081201531,
0.0210375488,
0.0309253912,
-0.0345315225,
0.0168456323,
-0.0469047911,
0.0389629938,
0.0324929729,
-0.0404162779,
0.0016765895,
0.0297627654,
2.365e-7,
-0.0039139115,
0.0374607034,
0.0303285625,
0.0575852282,
0.0311763268,
-0.009680979,
-0.0055433311,
0.0171243139,
-0.0088625718,
0.0114146955,
0.0031376835,
0.0143882558,
0.0598437451,
-0.0285821538,
-0.0833500773,
0.0212815162,
-0.0737905428,
0.0313543789,
-0.0506642386,
-0.0548307151,
0.0279950816,
0.0605800971,
-0.0331537351,
-0.0086458167,
0.0147948116,
-0.0637519136,
0.0699975044,
-0.0125132985,
-0.0125800204,
0.0385763645,
0.007501231,
0.0208132677,
0.0001264476,
0.0035778556,
-0.000827833,
0.0086916806,
-0.0075721745,
0.0741529018,
0.0598778464,
0.0011394639,
-0.0019918261,
-0.0029192362,
-0.0083211185,
-0.0512794927,
0.0653598085,
-0.0533158928,
-0.0095930835,
-0.0065048528,
0.0046222173,
0.0020425187,
-0.0223108698,
-0.0590721965,
-0.0056318208,
0.0111067872,
0.0273797903,
0.006247561,
0.0310435891,
-0.039650891,
-0.004858451,
0.0108217383,
-0.0367016159,
-0.0557416417,
-0.0836491212,
0.0063998718,
-0.0043808939,
-0.0552903861,
-0.035380628,
2.022196274e-34,
0.0209916662,
-0.018362904,
0.0332125165,
-0.0038047552,
0.0216303747,
-0.0119679812,
-0.0074234712,
0.0067369081,
0.0096374787,
-0.0974058509,
-0.0377593748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14541v1 | Continual Named Entity Recognition without Catastrophic Forgetting | 2023-10-23T03:45:30 | 2023-10-23T03:45:30 | Duzhen Zhang, Wei Cong, Jiahua Dong, Yahan Yu, Xiuyi Chen, Yonggang Zhang, Zhen Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Continual Named Entity Recognition (CNER) is a burgeoning area, which
involves updating an existing model by incorporating new entity types
sequentially. Nevertheless, continual learning approaches are often severely
afflicted by catastrophic forgetting. This issue is intensified in CNER due to
the consolidation of old entity types from previous steps into the non-entity
type at each step, leading to what is known as the semantic shift problem of
the non-entity type. In this paper, we introduce a pooled feature distillation
loss that skillfully navigates the trade-off between retaining knowledge of old
entity types and acquiring new ones, thereby more effectively mitigating the
problem of catastrophic forgetting. Additionally, we develop a confidence-based
pseudo-labeling for the non-entity type, \emph{i.e.,} predicting entity types
using the old model to handle the semantic shift of the non-entity type.
Following the pseudo-labeling process, we suggest an adaptive re-weighting
type-balanced learning strategy to handle the issue of biased type
distribution. We carried out comprehensive experiments on ten CNER settings
using three different datasets. The results illustrate that our method
significantly outperforms prior state-of-the-art approaches, registering an
average improvement of $6.3$\% and $8.0$\% in Micro and Macro F1 scores,
respectively. | [
0.0120722707,
0.0526809655,
0.0115413954,
-0.0107762991,
0.0574741773,
0.0683814511,
-0.0174812283,
-0.0217214003,
0.016174959,
-0.0454566963,
-0.0002422404,
-0.0343401022,
0.0029691916,
0.0460027233,
0.0278966594,
-0.0299992841,
0.0436816514,
0.0098129362,
-0.0091285286,
0.0106176855,
0.0096623506,
-0.0280597676,
-0.0112826237,
-0.0262136683,
-0.0169376116,
-0.0252675153,
-0.0296701118,
-0.0245750993,
0.0444336645,
-0.0551527888,
0.0184511486,
0.0502801314,
0.0262088589,
0.0324182808,
0.0000022123,
-0.0662684515,
-0.0683994889,
0.0039723758,
-0.0727985427,
-0.0455745384,
-0.0154804587,
0.0179908182,
-0.0081346519,
-0.0020929016,
-0.0011754656,
-0.0629555508,
0.0522306375,
0.0579469614,
0.0084095895,
0.0317300148,
0.0146168433,
-0.0238078758,
0.0513198413,
-0.0127665661,
-0.0029887538,
-0.0276250951,
0.0411942899,
-0.0362228416,
-0.0955928192,
-0.0257440209,
-0.0172061343,
0.0247736499,
0.0049914089,
0.0224674456,
0.0322575942,
0.0565149263,
-0.0409893617,
-0.0017318567,
0.0024538015,
0.0693058744,
-0.0058897277,
-0.0039933668,
0.0401459821,
0.0039902311,
-0.0042227455,
-0.0442788675,
-0.0316886045,
-0.0111538805,
-0.0504515395,
-0.0158477537,
-0.008805736,
0.0087585729,
0.0226410311,
0.0074100727,
-0.0581090003,
-0.0566561595,
0.0011557011,
-0.0249595456,
0.0340549015,
0.0010263566,
-0.0438512973,
-0.0362159945,
0.0437232107,
0.0212479774,
-0.0028317408,
0.02915393,
-0.0187613312,
-0.0136918202,
0.0143409083,
-0.0480693839,
-0.0081722913,
0.0167080779,
-0.0285568666,
0.0349397138,
-0.0483187065,
0.0231261719,
0.0326109305,
0.0013712688,
0.0322288722,
0.0210934822,
-0.0913647711,
-0.0105137909,
-0.0247803945,
0.1012982056,
0.0386738144,
0.0269916747,
-0.0225390512,
0.0059627015,
-0.0242665056,
0.0444409996,
0.0080013908,
0.0126793105,
-0.0344200246,
0.0146642607,
-0.0270716622,
0.068341881,
0.0018483264,
-0.0153319612,
-0.0083149532,
-0.0251569245,
-0.0030933912,
-0.0489164107,
-0.006673052,
-0.0240401495,
0.0315222852,
0.0862314701,
0.0157708973,
-0.0927405134,
-0.1028613523,
0.0065738587,
-0.0243137851,
-0.0593742356,
-0.0230303016,
-0.0250016414,
0.0120364837,
-0.0075767171,
0.0126287434,
-0.0589398369,
0.0199917983,
-0.0239923596,
-0.0231350102,
0.0733135939,
-0.0381394178,
-0.0246507637,
0.0226978268,
-0.009740606,
0.0031095082,
0.0669301003,
0.0344256088,
-0.0180829521,
0.0335374475,
0.0094320076,
-0.0064844918,
0.0137199443,
0.0361912288,
0.0008132831,
-0.0018555779,
0.003218763,
0.0074725999,
0.0088988366,
0.0547568686,
0.0084674573,
0.0033628833,
-0.0293090045,
0.0392416082,
-0.0362168476,
0.0147825787,
0.0372259095,
0.019474281,
-0.0275481325,
-0.0037702695,
0.0250509828,
-0.0486530773,
0.0027555979,
-0.027470706,
0.0148764104,
0.0123687088,
0.0623533055,
-0.0360292196,
-0.0178898238,
0.0375866704,
0.0009504347,
-0.0203680843,
0.0139096854,
0.0508589856,
0.0319358632,
-0.0274647214,
0.1016528383,
0.0302627496,
-0.0163589828,
0.0187326483,
-0.0051137963,
0.004452697,
0.0712197796,
0.0114776744,
-0.050407853,
-0.0552360676,
-0.0523136407,
-0.0116231721,
-0.0071307011,
0.000850678,
-0.0358272232,
0.0411709361,
-0.0368663222,
-0.0075629661,
0.0684198588,
0.0284848455,
0.0290931463,
-0.0125243878,
0.060145624,
0.0212391969,
-0.0424689576,
-0.055830054,
0.0253125113,
-0.0365730189,
-0.0467507355,
0.0136396736,
0.0326250382,
-0.027443381,
0.0452500805,
-0.0189906973,
-0.0163732413,
0.0286929347,
-0.0035809393,
-0.0387019403,
-0.0140201533,
-0.0024378856,
-0.0297240447,
0.0339301825,
0.0072042593,
-0.0200720765,
-0.0500028543,
-0.0544313788,
-0.0327183791,
-0.0456049219,
0.0108837401,
0.0407256074,
-0.0089440309,
0.0601032674,
-0.0003193613,
-0.0154585764,
-0.0439484008,
0.0810922608,
-0.0354661308,
0.0157576483,
-0.0259899758,
-0.0448123515,
-0.017040221,
-0.0474956334,
-0.0213829614,
0.0449256673,
-0.0157915149,
-0.0118541867,
0.0007249484,
-0.03243668,
-0.0827167705,
-0.0117665781,
-0.0881199613,
0.0221943371,
-0.0110832993,
0.0240245555,
-0.0078327646,
0.0263910014,
-0.024097098,
-0.0295619965,
-0.003762525,
-0.0450946316,
-0.066166684,
0.0314487591,
0.0178704094,
-0.0052247895,
0.0039651715,
0.0092728231,
-0.0043119639,
-0.0320287794,
0.0483468808,
-0.0199091043,
-0.0540664308,
-0.0452524386,
0.0531911626,
-0.0371248759,
-0.0156467967,
0.0122883162,
0.0424284674,
-0.0468800776,
0.0482103042,
0.0034676471,
0.0557710156,
0.016169887,
0.0350056253,
0.0121447891,
-0.0225964412,
-0.0467198715,
0.0296013765,
-0.0265489854,
-0.0028920204,
0.0122695686,
-0.0183738228,
-0.0173563361,
0.0505833067,
-0.0324747078,
0.0091587026,
-0.0263382345,
-0.0012639513,
-0.0207296591,
0.0042699445,
-0.0163289271,
0.0443865433,
-0.0140865929,
-0.0368976034,
-0.0151790092,
-0.0129084727,
0.059911035,
0.0080257421,
0.0219271202,
-0.028379675,
0.0027870461,
-0.0146500329,
0.017530296,
-0.0098868394,
-0.0063257078,
0.068567194,
-0.0739086419,
-0.052174516,
0.01539848,
0.0345765539,
-0.0326650515,
0.0877923965,
0.0111283995,
-0.0021553847,
-0.0017258138,
-0.0193747468,
-0.0445777588,
-0.0407081395,
-0.0221596826,
0.012003649,
-0.0303335469,
-0.0017241701,
-0.0429994725,
0.0095207505,
0.0203942694,
0.0422325209,
0.0034688613,
-0.0358206555,
-0.013419196,
0.046236679,
0.0083050923,
0.0362549201,
0.05209722,
-0.0115733398,
0.0076398049,
0.0236688741,
0.0243728142,
-0.0268881153,
0.025704015,
0.0152456025,
-0.0004526749,
-0.0636447296,
-0.023624761,
-0.0000145767,
0.0177018382,
-0.0500985458,
-0.0013420272,
0.0753316954,
0.0215928573,
-0.0298188888,
0.01105248,
0.0314124152,
0.0473591946,
0.0259856619,
-0.0146960653,
-0.0672194734,
-0.0352148451,
0.0320223458,
0.0380519666,
-0.0024624122,
-0.0809796676,
0.0083024502,
-0.0739189982,
-0.0236154832,
0.0003173703,
-0.0423452854,
0.0164602846,
-0.0583690144,
0.0202100724,
-0.0510272048,
-0.0089347754,
-0.0123894243,
-0.0410217531,
0.0165635943,
0.0436265767,
-0.0173127353,
-0.0461165756,
-0.0013939403,
-0.0400832631,
0.0481200963,
0.0530471355,
0.0192422289,
-0.0243343171,
-0.0302503593,
0.0075254068,
-0.0561018586,
-0.0469395258,
-0.0024330097,
0.1109435856,
-0.0442995653,
0.0025038545,
0.0106535191,
0.0119761135,
-0.010775541,
-0.0042101648,
0.0235099643,
0.0182081703,
0.0164688416,
-0.0018149033,
0.0116056632,
-0.0795126781,
0.0070898584,
0.0680562407,
0.0057486291,
-0.019743083,
0.0141262915,
-0.0127491262,
0.0167552624,
0.0012264721,
0.0318658724,
0.0322914906,
-0.0741477013,
-0.0474994816,
-0.0302723125,
-0.0334164463,
0.0249738861,
0.0526363924,
0.017321581,
0.013265457,
0.0237196274,
0.0071192966,
-0.1013329327,
0.0219296422,
-0.0107351104,
0.0322790667,
-0.0293826871,
-0.0040725172,
0.0231198985,
0.0279440302,
-0.0389192887,
0.0109556159,
-0.0966409147,
-0.0641418323,
0.0317228585,
0.0143026821,
0.0087344181,
0.0525580421,
0.024306098,
-0.0202236176,
0.069645144,
0.0639315769,
-0.012199387,
-0.0056025991,
0.0279293414,
0.017390186,
0.0035333871,
0.0245841593,
-0.0369225852,
-0.0447132289,
0.037590351,
0.0552881956,
-0.016487306,
0.0345127769,
0.0092584565,
0.0000562103,
0.0313793868,
-0.0151175866,
-0.005006623,
-0.0364978351,
0.0480542183,
0.0606192164,
-0.0101304995,
-0.0047550034,
0.0121980421,
0.0111964196,
0.0459825285,
-0.0205949526,
0.0526541919,
0.006074701,
0.0319632143,
-0.0247250851,
-0.0117953178,
0.0015943634,
0.042136699,
0.0291082431,
-0.0299648587,
-0.0156705938,
0.0498620979,
0.0650534704,
0.0352450609,
-0.0229366291,
0.0060584075,
0.0338345878,
0.0172861665,
-0.0482983775,
0.0122227753,
-0.0273235384,
-0.0179953985,
-0.0590982474,
0.0398963578,
0.0446506441,
0.0036633851,
0.0298992097,
0.0196264219,
-0.0071810968,
-0.0136128813,
-0.0295509528,
-0.0069418638,
0.0102470713,
0.015125596,
0.0280067082,
-0.0269707125,
0.0074094483,
0.0689043179,
-0.0211796369,
0.0519341528,
-0.0164331831,
-0.0007006635,
-0.0240641627,
0.0101964464,
0.0009855713,
0.0135733252,
0.0011254273,
-0.0114226937,
-0.0773516372,
-0.0588490777,
0.0785250142,
-0.0525502749,
0.0118441964,
0.0023347952,
0.0113533,
-0.0258105658,
0.010216279,
-0.008435308,
-0.0101803709,
0.0011240718,
0.0536590852,
-0.0217461027,
-0.0133702634,
-6.44950257e-33,
-0.0385985486,
-0.0216764268,
0.0184161738,
-0.0385682061,
-0.0636950582,
0.0466962457,
-0.0229963027,
0.0140048163,
0.0170662496,
-0.0089790812,
-0.000732809,
0.0157778263,
0.0320590809,
0.0017175599,
0.0057189288,
-0.0468628109,
0.0684295744,
0.0314542651,
-0.0256242957,
0.0380977243,
0.061670769,
0.0744676813,
0.0636595562,
-0.0854167268,
0.0145291006,
0.0495390072,
-0.0040016416,
0.0203071162,
0.0628702492,
0.0637439266,
-0.0017305446,
0.0348500572,
0.0125116864,
-0.0195987932,
-0.0328489803,
-0.0289299451,
-0.1669453084,
-0.003227005,
-0.0435300469,
0.0278900322,
0.0255048703,
-0.0313650407,
0.0188639741,
-0.0061730915,
0.0337775201,
-0.0237868633,
0.0350648388,
-0.0345764719,
-0.0436760411,
-0.0488592163,
-0.0165414829,
0.0487332754,
0.0050770883,
0.0382231027,
-0.0010375293,
-0.0292905271,
0.037000522,
-0.0299443621,
-0.1031981856,
-0.0337520838,
0.0421916917,
-0.0106641529,
0.0192515254,
0.0456651375,
0.0044247811,
0.0477654189,
0.0303153675,
0.0422421619,
-0.0235427786,
-0.0275806058,
0.0475762598,
-0.0326893702,
-0.0413169302,
0.0324343294,
0.0839127228,
-0.0564750396,
-0.0257864501,
0.0076536243,
-0.0325756334,
0.040448308,
-0.0239181761,
-0.0001952422,
-0.0370166674,
-0.0193118062,
-0.0470616072,
-0.0159129351,
-0.0434543677,
-0.0003788686,
0.0204781927,
0.0125488508,
-0.0346081071,
0.0258979276,
0.0064135026,
-0.024942426,
-0.0903861895,
0.019458076,
0.0298140664,
0.0271478556,
0.0148864258,
-0.0015080735,
-0.0464439169,
-0.0288895462,
-0.0009338039,
-0.0000576055,
0.0053285072,
0.0039843642,
0.0801233649,
0.0195681341,
-0.048121836,
-0.0070450846,
0.0062650032,
-0.010056383,
0.0152272861,
0.0343524031,
0.0110498313,
-0.0058802059,
-0.0022085933,
-0.0055262693,
0.0907091796,
-0.0221205093,
-0.0251234677,
0.083642602,
0.0529002696,
0.0730530322,
-0.0027696816,
-0.0171792898,
0.0103006074,
-0.0159784127,
0.0409145541,
-0.0954775959,
0.0067121703,
-0.0225553866,
2.854e-7,
-0.0077980189,
-0.0012897818,
0.0142879793,
-0.0515244976,
-0.011739457,
0.0333777517,
0.0152181145,
0.0458894037,
-0.0161611121,
0.0109500308,
0.003918631,
0.0014214076,
0.0075883549,
0.0362921208,
-0.0886086151,
-0.0171978232,
0.0157788284,
0.0140464585,
-0.0592338108,
0.0080610542,
-0.0053693415,
0.0704639405,
0.0247981623,
-0.0163216647,
0.0156692527,
-0.0178103726,
0.042851828,
0.0505934507,
0.0746236593,
0.0144207766,
-0.0213292614,
0.0621821024,
-0.0182515942,
0.0552377999,
-0.0251277555,
-0.0033317774,
0.0142670479,
0.0129908323,
-0.0121054063,
-0.0242580771,
-0.0038125229,
0.0000699588,
0.0181331057,
-0.0162139013,
0.0490568914,
-0.0775822848,
-0.0069027347,
0.0040806937,
-0.045592472,
-0.003526418,
0.0209873598,
0.0331109948,
-0.0167431924,
0.057216011,
0.0064736404,
0.0289563332,
-0.0212092213,
-0.0799296498,
0.0191412624,
0.0315826721,
0.0012389008,
-0.0489265472,
-0.0090328027,
-0.0346555263,
-0.0003112083,
-0.0610572919,
0.0186275151,
2.95548185e-34,
0.0037556735,
-0.0056122625,
-0.0107636014,
0.0478243455,
-0.0026445745,
-0.0441497378,
-0.0020193085,
-0.0202515125,
0.0055831792,
-0.0446303673,
0.000411082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14540v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14540v3 | Evaluating Spatial Understanding of Large Language Models | 2023-10-23T03:44:40 | 2024-04-13T01:59:06 | Yutaro Yamada, Yihan Bao, Andrew K. Lampinen, Jungo Kasai, Ilker Yildirim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) show remarkable capabilities across a variety of
tasks. Despite the models only seeing text in training, several recent studies
suggest that LLM representations implicitly capture aspects of the underlying
grounded concepts. Here, we explore LLM representations of a particularly
salient kind of grounded knowledge -- spatial relationships. We design
natural-language navigation tasks and evaluate the ability of LLMs, in
particular GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, and Llama2 series models, to represent and
reason about spatial structures. These tasks reveal substantial variability in
LLM performance across different spatial structures, including square,
hexagonal, and triangular grids, rings, and trees. In extensive error analysis,
we find that LLMs' mistakes reflect both spatial and non-spatial factors. These
findings suggest that LLMs appear to capture certain aspects of spatial
structure implicitly, but room for improvement remains. | [
0.0375679433,
0.0199709721,
-0.030779684,
0.0312594846,
-0.0314642526,
0.0434921458,
0.0088793663,
-0.0283606965,
0.0110587459,
-0.0436657183,
-0.0640587956,
-0.0379348993,
0.0511143468,
0.0102680847,
0.0401288159,
-0.0802305192,
0.0178919956,
-0.0735573396,
-0.0318576284,
0.0152939856,
-0.0295862742,
0.0148877613,
-0.0281835031,
0.0463151336,
-0.024162259,
-0.024091078,
-0.02042423,
-0.0218607839,
0.0090067601,
-0.0856267884,
-0.0134222573,
0.0233739242,
0.0787464306,
0.0298519637,
0.0000020131,
0.0114712287,
0.020360399,
-0.0075175897,
0.0052332408,
0.0298056472,
0.0319992304,
-0.0427595079,
0.0156284962,
-0.0144519638,
-0.0162306298,
-0.0512283519,
0.0261304118,
0.0492157005,
0.0135409432,
0.0298598204,
-0.0137868356,
-0.0585465021,
0.0131848119,
-0.0177123304,
0.0206038486,
-0.0012727719,
0.0059449398,
0.0455677584,
-0.0150692733,
0.0789790675,
-0.037045911,
0.0058145844,
0.0323085822,
0.0286935046,
0.0043012467,
0.0851819664,
0.0033113859,
0.0231796354,
-0.002266431,
0.0617322363,
0.0235898923,
-0.0305238478,
0.0187909845,
0.006091963,
-0.0242736042,
0.0076710405,
-0.0910984427,
0.010060695,
-0.0055973995,
0.0511424094,
-0.0194900706,
-0.0089274701,
0.0292911474,
-0.0127416002,
-0.0511810072,
0.0798447132,
0.0157800093,
-0.0160041042,
-0.0279873908,
0.0162626058,
-0.0062020142,
-0.0519569702,
0.003132453,
0.0482439511,
-0.010559435,
0.0444391742,
0.0138218356,
0.0723602623,
0.0057315482,
-0.0838479325,
0.0317958444,
0.0335376225,
-0.0038227248,
0.0456282459,
-0.0501719303,
0.0848191231,
-0.0324337333,
0.0599795207,
-0.0081254998,
0.0089556361,
-0.0260049775,
-0.0109039675,
-0.0168558452,
0.018166814,
-0.0590563528,
-0.0457241163,
0.0101651978,
0.0383441597,
0.0180050638,
0.0134594515,
-0.0302293915,
0.0439293943,
-0.0059492169,
-0.0200375337,
-0.0252183396,
0.0307072196,
-0.0312948748,
0.0196475498,
-0.0318797044,
-0.0267967843,
-0.0011760651,
0.0199817885,
-0.0126152867,
-0.0296886861,
-0.0288073886,
0.0454406552,
0.032002382,
-0.0520435944,
-0.0401065275,
0.0039462429,
-0.0341310725,
-0.0532964319,
0.0461300127,
-0.0516484864,
-0.0166708175,
0.0258540194,
-0.0094076553,
-0.0180171914,
0.0129635129,
0.0157634132,
-0.0308237821,
0.0488826595,
0.0105488878,
0.0327116698,
0.0445927046,
-0.0013530925,
0.0326506831,
0.0525173508,
0.0325402543,
0.0636002347,
-0.0159514882,
-0.001106755,
-0.0147814322,
0.0079942066,
-0.0164424516,
0.00239947,
-0.0601134524,
0.014798888,
-0.011262292,
0.0470734127,
0.0320769884,
0.0406803079,
-0.0298575368,
0.0150366351,
0.0737578124,
0.1144890934,
-0.0040828963,
0.0109472247,
0.0417195819,
-0.0103245862,
-0.0157315657,
0.0040458404,
-0.0948104784,
0.0131564913,
-0.0181048475,
-0.0059021567,
0.007692141,
0.0321324132,
-0.0160102975,
-0.0238892976,
-0.0419731326,
0.0127878776,
-0.0075613852,
-0.0100283865,
0.0540141463,
-0.0221484676,
-0.0348701738,
0.0448022038,
-0.0009949366,
-0.0099784797,
-0.0155245913,
0.0238340441,
0.0151932025,
0.0178138204,
0.0181149822,
0.0105682882,
-0.0459233373,
-0.0011200771,
0.0498104505,
0.0298251323,
0.0716864541,
0.0132196331,
-0.0318755545,
-0.0362915397,
-0.0611853264,
0.0021838467,
0.0406235605,
0.0222923104,
0.0523045585,
0.0137607111,
0.0236222316,
-0.0901899785,
-0.0150141623,
0.0248275101,
0.0144762928,
-0.0210228618,
-0.0735969394,
0.0103392527,
-0.0206258241,
-0.0136674,
-0.0076043853,
0.0140054207,
0.0394387692,
-0.0210448522,
-0.0072492231,
0.0284583028,
-0.0943241268,
0.0007659026,
0.0193749014,
-0.0074258749,
-0.0175101124,
0.0019919507,
-0.0130932853,
-0.0088827629,
0.0033992727,
-0.0545402654,
0.0285757445,
-0.0011027704,
0.0100865234,
0.0233591665,
0.006174854,
-0.0500999987,
0.0879765749,
-0.0077526527,
0.0306487661,
0.004022181,
0.0070589269,
0.026461117,
0.0029603988,
0.0361236967,
-0.0146510415,
0.0210602749,
-0.0185443703,
-0.0255666357,
0.0122646447,
-0.0473211445,
-0.0157082677,
-0.0661249161,
0.0117197391,
-0.0177847836,
0.0446310416,
0.0413674116,
-0.08353398,
-0.0346055217,
-0.0206556413,
-0.0132980682,
-0.0161929075,
0.0083708409,
0.0215215925,
0.0294357818,
-0.0527258702,
-0.0305111632,
-0.0192044675,
-0.007943077,
-0.0442659557,
0.0405586809,
0.0154931676,
-0.0408485197,
-0.0366128683,
0.0217498709,
-0.0088870525,
0.0098041138,
-0.0032600854,
-0.0066673663,
0.0419821963,
-0.0509885922,
0.0265525542,
0.0389479883,
-0.0375340506,
0.0553726852,
0.0564362891,
-0.0655979365,
-0.0478125736,
-0.0042618951,
-0.0180576351,
0.0098852813,
-0.0367272608,
-0.0207235254,
-0.0214164313,
0.0643031895,
-0.010775893,
0.0197306611,
-0.0194136724,
0.0225545224,
-0.0403288342,
0.011283366,
-0.0309315939,
0.0281118285,
0.0087907324,
0.0690703318,
-0.0481171086,
-0.0562598445,
-0.0044939327,
-0.0682628751,
-0.0014780029,
-0.0359784737,
0.0241308026,
-0.0427423194,
0.1043979526,
0.0176542085,
0.0030398094,
-0.0245889593,
-0.0528941788,
0.0058392207,
-0.0244091153,
-0.0334062688,
0.016171284,
0.056841135,
-0.0817423239,
0.0088976994,
-0.0077315862,
-0.0048253802,
-0.0336303785,
0.0128743183,
-0.048705183,
-0.0002475075,
-0.0161198322,
-0.0248277243,
0.0012292704,
0.0489604138,
0.0442798808,
0.018707836,
-0.0341279916,
-0.0295816381,
-0.0253352616,
0.0208407808,
0.0526191965,
0.0692061707,
0.0117174834,
-0.0407799967,
-0.0236121826,
0.0073891273,
-0.0386125892,
0.0249594245,
-0.0373479128,
0.0411568359,
0.0367796421,
0.0062596966,
-0.0511222668,
0.0308711585,
0.0746568888,
-0.0772988275,
-0.0611657389,
0.1123240069,
0.0713816136,
0.0045039188,
0.0049465476,
-0.0428639613,
0.0429738909,
0.0332351774,
-0.0028662113,
-0.0068494156,
-0.0083647752,
-0.0026448066,
-0.059922751,
0.038852118,
-0.0183498058,
0.0219324026,
-0.1104066819,
0.0549128838,
0.017398268,
-0.1246431768,
-0.0695609301,
-0.0286823157,
-0.0156405382,
0.0419592336,
0.0079181157,
-0.0275952015,
-0.0208989624,
0.0108359028,
0.0196297988,
-0.0350520015,
0.0051917639,
0.0024841481,
-0.0351073854,
0.0512391031,
0.0196409784,
0.0553549677,
0.0094209686,
-0.0563568845,
0.02023031,
0.0471975021,
0.0548957139,
-0.0098686982,
0.0057946676,
0.0444836468,
-0.0066624968,
-0.0255408809,
-0.015262695,
-0.0635941625,
-0.0344329737,
-0.0044957199,
0.0837541595,
-0.0443956442,
0.0168711469,
0.0061859689,
0.0366339609,
-0.0330474824,
0.0332180485,
0.0543454215,
0.0542293675,
-0.090652205,
-0.0417842157,
0.0010859423,
-0.0173304025,
-0.0390856378,
0.0541587323,
0.0344579816,
0.0144728385,
-0.040297173,
-0.0310277026,
0.0408847854,
0.0336797051,
0.0153956711,
-0.0080270134,
-0.0169515125,
-0.0481638759,
-0.0160671454,
0.0597606301,
-0.0456086062,
0.0324803963,
0.0132195586,
0.045624055,
0.0115831578,
-0.0302168056,
0.0041861562,
0.0142891509,
-0.0612442419,
-0.0503402539,
-0.0045538964,
0.0325363018,
0.0215740092,
0.0038825797,
0.0019753135,
-0.0087688165,
0.0182643831,
-0.0047270479,
-0.0407893881,
0.0426398814,
0.001362627,
0.0308019929,
0.0144671239,
0.0060709724,
-0.0048339637,
-0.001390183,
-0.0057404987,
0.0167121813,
-0.0199715532,
0.0136836264,
-0.0015902923,
-0.0260774735,
0.0894363746,
0.0418976694,
-0.012983378,
-0.0107162707,
0.0006338305,
-0.040978644,
0.0207264852,
-0.0013504382,
0.0058625308,
0.0433951505,
0.0387462303,
-0.0137011372,
-0.0122482991,
0.0065529589,
0.0428950191,
0.0029965248,
-0.0322094858,
0.0060894652,
-0.0175837073,
0.0017011844,
0.0317895859,
-0.0308323838,
0.0144286426,
-0.0291639995,
0.0364488028,
0.010609312,
0.0417717099,
0.0074611539,
-0.0223610047,
-0.037822701,
0.0120145408,
-0.0530469157,
-0.0960596055,
0.0021512648,
0.0415360108,
0.0778191984,
-0.0216106791,
0.0241220258,
-0.0472398512,
0.0111541413,
0.0127204871,
-0.0048348387,
0.0249143839,
-0.0329287834,
0.0380796492,
0.023029048,
-0.0178399123,
-0.0310133509,
0.0473266579,
0.0310959332,
0.0500064306,
0.0131139532,
-0.0361343548,
0.006538861,
-0.0026062205,
0.0187646709,
0.0355259255,
-0.0252302997,
0.0145835187,
-0.0648644567,
-0.0621548966,
0.0020610469,
0.0228845961,
-0.0154665355,
-0.0343368277,
0.0365627632,
0.0237038359,
-0.0145601183,
-0.0392142236,
-0.0218223669,
0.0080383718,
-0.0259176046,
0.0005828781,
-0.0229565557,
-6.23691809e-33,
-0.0433158912,
-0.0655351505,
0.0637463853,
-0.0225256179,
-0.0365699939,
-0.0072503556,
-0.0531339794,
-0.0052615525,
-0.0159726199,
0.0077826087,
0.0140892901,
0.0177180655,
0.0010274486,
0.0066985157,
0.0179524459,
0.0092368908,
0.0141498381,
0.0229656696,
-0.0118827326,
0.0006741412,
0.0285521448,
-0.003274862,
0.0585030764,
-0.0713597164,
-0.0115741137,
0.016052302,
-0.0041987179,
0.0075807748,
-0.0518839583,
0.0572549701,
-0.0541001,
0.0149014443,
0.0258988105,
-0.0483792424,
-0.0347141251,
0.0101708649,
-0.0609500483,
-0.0402146392,
0.0218161996,
0.0250582621,
-0.0194654018,
-0.0390374549,
0.0511821173,
-0.0025984966,
0.0082468521,
-0.0016551726,
0.0338446349,
0.0025390498,
-0.054273352,
0.0653306991,
-0.0606713854,
0.0124365101,
-0.0089843599,
-0.0061271605,
0.0033289557,
0.001107824,
0.010768299,
0.0304859374,
-0.0260874853,
0.0079786247,
0.0391712934,
0.0209563393,
0.0394822136,
0.0353950746,
0.0157300606,
0.0826017708,
0.0498976447,
-0.0006728282,
-0.0706988573,
-0.0392884277,
0.0495383926,
0.0322617814,
0.0085970024,
-0.0016815513,
0.0054747416,
0.0235486906,
-0.0624326952,
0.0060599013,
-0.0595573857,
0.0656528473,
0.0016120579,
-0.0041684792,
-0.0149018699,
-0.0179434828,
-0.0507254824,
-0.0265164766,
-0.0089964317,
-0.0083910795,
0.0425131246,
-0.0172350369,
0.0587341897,
0.0373192281,
0.0177085809,
-0.0082327416,
-0.0438116938,
0.0019902294,
-0.0065363189,
0.0197783392,
-0.0099306768,
0.0360982381,
-0.0366006158,
-0.0321074724,
-0.0212597232,
0.0198715124,
0.005709515,
0.0190847777,
0.0028352761,
0.0104280096,
-0.053172756,
-0.0239085983,
-0.0505711176,
-0.0616309941,
0.0113440081,
-0.0092427116,
0.0603250861,
-0.0169694927,
-0.0222956147,
0.0597889684,
-0.0105677294,
-0.0172788519,
-0.0096718706,
-0.0261472687,
-0.0505405962,
0.0165661704,
0.007269219,
-0.0273105204,
-0.0476166904,
-0.0109671336,
0.0541195981,
-0.0657104552,
-0.0264358781,
0.008047211,
2.785e-7,
0.0578418262,
0.0955543816,
0.0311843641,
0.0114162005,
0.0143396435,
0.0168091375,
-0.0177530721,
0.0014961166,
-0.0117759043,
-0.0136038819,
0.0065531223,
0.0591512658,
0.0281642824,
0.0348263644,
-0.0755433813,
0.0486825295,
-0.036605522,
-0.0207146257,
-0.0712636411,
0.0027937337,
0.0681815371,
0.0278366711,
-0.0291286409,
0.0064046853,
-0.0092967479,
-0.0238125827,
0.0448598526,
-0.0397125185,
0.0313878655,
-0.0134433182,
0.0085938526,
-0.0104862489,
-0.0286925267,
0.0047221868,
0.0277142525,
-0.0102759199,
0.0024444279,
0.0677972063,
-0.0116275297,
0.0076335529,
-0.0031487804,
-0.0395732485,
-0.0288273022,
-0.099036172,
0.0728040263,
-0.0941867605,
-0.0134846587,
0.039861206,
0.0382428542,
-0.0042143208,
0.0211047921,
0.0252314601,
0.0047502094,
-0.0292600431,
0.0025318544,
-0.0056743645,
0.0002469986,
-0.0763506144,
-0.0152824428,
0.0421334207,
-0.0189929362,
-0.0048620622,
-0.069857657,
0.0042769834,
0.0221860074,
0.0052407277,
-0.0455965847,
2.349075768e-34,
-0.0046448838,
-0.0031167732,
0.0068858429,
0.0008187724,
0.029802734,
-0.014413978,
0.0152634336,
0.0118709886,
0.0016891318,
-0.0689651445,
0.0078620156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14534v1 | Improving Seq2Seq Grammatical Error Correction via Decoding Interventions | 2023-10-23T03:36:37 | 2023-10-23T03:36:37 | Houquan Zhou, Yumeng Liu, Zhenghua Li, Min Zhang, Bo Zhang, Chen Li, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq) approach has recently been widely used in
grammatical error correction (GEC) and shows promising performance. However,
the Seq2Seq GEC approach still suffers from two issues. First, a Seq2Seq GEC
model can only be trained on parallel data, which, in GEC task, is often noisy
and limited in quantity. Second, the decoder of a Seq2Seq GEC model lacks an
explicit awareness of the correctness of the token being generated. In this
paper, we propose a unified decoding intervention framework that employs an
external critic to assess the appropriateness of the token to be generated
incrementally, and then dynamically influence the choice of the next token. We
discover and investigate two types of critics: a pre-trained left-to-right
language model critic and an incremental target-side grammatical error detector
critic. Through extensive experiments on English and Chinese datasets, our
framework consistently outperforms strong baselines and achieves results
competitive with state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0518361367,
0.0952189118,
0.0129969576,
0.0000402277,
-0.0041604801,
0.0305235852,
-0.0338330567,
-0.0384196527,
-0.0539141782,
-0.0524360128,
-0.0092359958,
-0.0394337177,
0.0013816104,
0.0020762251,
0.05411442,
-0.0257318374,
0.0826106295,
-0.0060627796,
0.0105749136,
0.0145291789,
-0.0044626351,
0.0008823135,
-0.0376488604,
0.0676063076,
-0.0345330983,
-0.0557198599,
-0.0176852141,
0.0371312387,
0.0110459263,
-0.0551187955,
0.056923978,
0.0736672059,
-0.0195711888,
0.0559878834,
0.0000017478,
-0.021613,
-0.0098921126,
-0.0217556432,
-0.010740933,
0.0332716145,
0.0211939439,
-0.0346030146,
-0.0743394271,
0.0204634964,
0.0057434142,
-0.0264110845,
0.0536660701,
0.0651683733,
0.0639281571,
0.0829545036,
0.0164529216,
0.0002869822,
0.0214826297,
-0.0090243137,
-0.0371517241,
-0.0010121524,
0.0205160584,
-0.0255809464,
-0.039837759,
-0.0138363307,
-0.0616225116,
0.0195525624,
0.0203967094,
-0.0397332683,
0.0052777142,
0.0035729229,
-0.0232730359,
-0.0068036327,
-0.0550336279,
0.0374547243,
0.0156626198,
-0.0331490077,
-0.0232602991,
0.0032341315,
0.0260182973,
-0.0567420982,
0.0102111157,
0.0106271552,
-0.003857191,
0.0163102336,
0.0689300597,
-0.0657521039,
-0.0001766064,
-0.0013406854,
0.0000446289,
0.02742723,
0.0064623714,
-0.0762126744,
-0.0136010461,
0.0574813709,
-0.003887675,
-0.0571561977,
0.041740045,
-0.0173497666,
-0.0841522887,
-0.0015376966,
-0.0395360179,
-0.0699802861,
-0.0344584994,
-0.0024897719,
0.0352019779,
0.0225588232,
-0.0168564301,
-0.0121975308,
-0.0037199783,
0.054839965,
0.0459642373,
0.0519283749,
-0.0089227781,
0.0217488538,
-0.0225738492,
-0.0228729937,
-0.0586857647,
0.0083654113,
-0.0308336541,
-0.0030204274,
-0.0514536463,
-0.0017822323,
-0.022486778,
0.0245351009,
0.0180909727,
0.0119968299,
-0.0611455552,
-0.0017895403,
0.0073222555,
0.034508191,
-0.0152944233,
0.0518837646,
0.0265065152,
-0.0419864655,
-0.0510030352,
0.024628209,
0.0008079616,
-0.0138852326,
-0.0299897119,
0.0294535551,
-0.038127657,
-0.035275165,
-0.0263531879,
0.0004873602,
-0.0285073649,
-0.0114448993,
-0.0672572553,
-0.054415524,
-0.0300095137,
-0.0387397408,
0.0146121299,
-0.0301299654,
0.0046302336,
-0.0180042088,
0.0053262296,
0.0616961606,
-0.0383556485,
-0.0217789914,
0.0098564234,
-0.011990943,
0.0305086486,
0.0522864684,
0.030004045,
-0.0525360554,
0.0443898924,
0.0394108184,
0.0059846765,
0.0104387766,
-0.0068219835,
-0.0134645766,
-0.0149669917,
-0.0214881152,
0.0017851454,
0.0462623127,
0.0671508312,
0.0560341254,
-0.0618808046,
0.0403160825,
0.0348162316,
0.0140032098,
0.0184811931,
-0.0059697414,
0.0454053581,
-0.0046765232,
-0.0167702679,
0.0234388299,
-0.0506581292,
0.010036354,
0.007055473,
-0.0036047841,
0.0402767695,
-0.0076628365,
-0.018076675,
-0.0678872913,
0.0095079616,
-0.0110719707,
-0.0002008808,
-0.0515117273,
0.0323564894,
0.0689995363,
-0.0580922067,
0.0425292924,
-0.0052708099,
-0.068027176,
0.0122912237,
-0.0150972717,
0.0036011899,
0.0610041171,
0.0613927096,
0.0100398287,
-0.0597536825,
-0.0229525287,
-0.0230558403,
0.0558011644,
0.0467970558,
-0.027715316,
0.0102843866,
-0.0523659401,
-0.0150148319,
0.0151900286,
0.0338013284,
-0.0300836228,
0.027161533,
0.0172393881,
-0.0026198647,
0.0126287546,
-0.0376621261,
0.0530663691,
0.0050667524,
-0.0372469239,
-0.0000419203,
0.0162219647,
0.0137813836,
0.0161587186,
-0.0212842673,
0.012721166,
-0.0062412107,
0.0042500384,
-0.0540320724,
0.0275139771,
-0.0436244719,
-0.1109678596,
0.0228559189,
-0.0320476368,
-0.0463086404,
0.0541719943,
-0.056654565,
-0.0520255752,
0.0197089668,
-0.0420091264,
0.0133830477,
-0.0560559295,
0.0284450334,
0.0304467194,
-0.0126981679,
-0.0148858279,
-0.0100142611,
-0.0199061241,
0.0203679334,
-0.0025646933,
0.0410347208,
-0.0344277658,
-0.059657719,
-0.0173562188,
-0.0025892199,
-0.006005167,
0.022330083,
0.0224842299,
0.04545651,
-0.0350504667,
-0.0296457913,
-0.0630720481,
-0.0087420624,
-0.0682326183,
0.0277478732,
0.0327341668,
-0.0172913168,
-0.0137881674,
-0.0543346033,
0.0150436768,
0.0100723226,
0.0176509228,
-0.0118633397,
0.0574313067,
-0.0179681797,
-0.0251335148,
-0.0431571826,
0.0108009838,
-0.0330251642,
-0.0116804149,
-0.0173989143,
0.0072228299,
-0.0842639729,
-0.0068799471,
-0.0057777511,
0.0235134978,
0.050561782,
-0.0757748038,
0.017099794,
0.0086235376,
0.0620250404,
0.0229849312,
0.0083169229,
0.0272417609,
-0.0182210729,
-0.0264118742,
-0.019233996,
0.0100349635,
0.0092490241,
-0.0305571798,
-0.0347799622,
-0.0125641944,
0.0368539356,
0.1038041785,
-0.0002813343,
0.0050926814,
-0.0555329137,
0.0250894576,
-0.030843053,
-0.031247817,
0.0053674402,
-0.0031538035,
-0.0323358141,
0.0028153537,
-0.0378986485,
-0.0032801449,
0.0793546885,
0.0162874833,
-0.0159795787,
-0.0419232994,
0.0330466144,
-0.0085697323,
0.0082231611,
-0.0217313357,
0.0124326665,
-0.0180499982,
-0.0973643512,
-0.0328973122,
-0.0110763609,
0.029258525,
-0.0050184424,
0.0257145744,
-0.0809440017,
0.005093676,
0.0071862279,
-0.0715904385,
-0.0292586703,
-0.0087369652,
-0.0177287702,
-0.02092118,
0.004337668,
0.0013513112,
-0.0228830799,
-0.037766654,
-0.0335602649,
0.0799041018,
-0.024053907,
-0.0112870513,
-0.0344548449,
0.0129287057,
0.0228482895,
0.0254312027,
0.0316592194,
-0.0385868922,
0.0622831136,
0.0759571418,
0.0167937856,
0.0170901958,
-0.0080611883,
0.0189312827,
0.044714205,
-0.0139177553,
0.0177804567,
0.011833407,
0.0838886797,
-0.0458623022,
-0.0755288228,
0.1011180207,
0.0424193554,
-0.0328264758,
0.0164044965,
-0.0161705017,
-0.0100779245,
0.0068922052,
-0.0035682463,
-0.0646334663,
-0.0456721745,
0.0561285876,
0.0655627176,
-0.0030281667,
0.0091684368,
0.0173852015,
-0.0976338163,
0.0562150292,
0.0490324087,
-0.0492278636,
-0.0320639648,
0.0153398374,
-0.0029546984,
-0.0198952965,
0.06970644,
0.0601454377,
-0.0051069246,
0.0078696124,
0.0344560668,
-0.0262725279,
-0.0633758307,
-0.0483944304,
-0.0418329239,
0.0604196973,
0.0759621486,
-0.0118758166,
0.0266013853,
-0.002769771,
0.0640119463,
-0.0133024585,
-0.0162583478,
0.0078500463,
0.0076930053,
-0.0285724588,
-0.0169219151,
-0.0434721,
0.052335728,
-0.0425765887,
0.0086965859,
0.0029764103,
0.0555067137,
-0.0028832552,
0.0145185981,
0.0244902372,
-0.003050983,
0.0463117771,
0.0418510996,
0.0312427282,
-0.0389254466,
-0.0541172363,
-0.0660056397,
-0.0041873986,
-0.0913550332,
0.0273422264,
0.0276545323,
0.0035769118,
-0.033306323,
-0.0766306445,
-0.1014199778,
-0.0087530334,
-0.0139583992,
-0.0105337249,
-0.013639316,
-0.0130370343,
-0.0218249951,
0.0056696385,
-0.0234196838,
0.009227165,
0.0352347717,
-0.0873481408,
0.0117632374,
-0.0177308228,
0.0396360792,
0.0030049521,
0.0047265515,
-0.0575470626,
-0.041961439,
0.0239626523,
0.0532463305,
-0.0010085963,
0.0432178378,
-0.0327235274,
-0.0400207005,
-0.0023298783,
0.0336942859,
-0.0385221615,
0.017082518,
0.0422669277,
-0.0306311194,
-0.0019521185,
0.0425487496,
0.0081955446,
0.0120723844,
0.0047135381,
0.0980914533,
-0.0074714092,
0.0315884054,
0.0583372451,
-0.0010193804,
0.051096797,
-0.0068720961,
0.0041130758,
-0.0544802956,
0.0603049658,
-0.038381733,
-0.0116642844,
-0.0197176673,
0.0393099487,
0.0291667525,
-0.033005219,
-0.0314297043,
-0.0074011912,
-0.0388088562,
0.0068575591,
-0.0406064205,
0.0126640843,
0.0229819398,
0.0520413183,
0.0119118337,
-0.0102952793,
-0.0291862339,
0.0057013812,
0.0330753215,
0.0349896923,
-0.0178851951,
0.0189363565,
0.0658136383,
0.020665003,
0.0259631667,
-0.0001880178,
-0.031257093,
0.0323491283,
-0.0161186401,
-0.0118376128,
0.0954421833,
0.0446528159,
0.0784938857,
-0.0136058535,
0.0070411237,
-0.0237742439,
0.0335544869,
-0.0140586449,
-0.0109435627,
-0.0011793127,
-0.0113991778,
0.0124450168,
-0.0635381192,
0.0446586572,
-0.0129524283,
0.0152491573,
-0.0141601125,
-0.0102017215,
-0.0200153273,
-0.0235865284,
-0.0179011878,
-0.0224281102,
-0.0380118899,
0.0085276421,
0.0037827736,
-0.0701588616,
-0.0123231662,
0.0606211983,
0.0145463683,
-0.0108792624,
0.0042277016,
0.0383187942,
-0.0131035512,
-0.044399485,
-0.0388552658,
-0.0016792744,
0.0255998019,
-0.0321297012,
-0.0318006761,
-5.84311683e-33,
-0.0433277264,
0.0098226741,
0.0071220105,
-0.03114927,
-0.0288250409,
-0.0210863799,
-0.0505584776,
-0.0168859679,
0.0668821558,
0.0534260534,
-0.0074641965,
0.0581870116,
0.0115268584,
0.02521763,
0.0766433105,
0.0304711908,
0.0914531574,
0.002956097,
-0.0512393005,
-0.0243293662,
0.0406728834,
0.0592351966,
0.0878994539,
0.020816192,
0.039786689,
0.0190969147,
-0.0009619354,
0.0166695584,
-0.0069807549,
0.0392838866,
0.0417181291,
0.019760767,
0.0073514977,
-0.002754712,
-0.0457346514,
-0.0261426605,
-0.1142702252,
-0.044667162,
-0.0096161859,
0.0660338178,
-0.0360479578,
-0.0335754417,
0.0243140925,
-0.0174398534,
-0.0388375558,
0.01535476,
-0.0105899479,
-0.0157708041,
0.0278908759,
0.006198782,
-0.0329050422,
0.0238175765,
-0.0197236873,
0.0183582939,
-0.0192999411,
0.0528988093,
-0.024725765,
-0.0514483154,
-0.0609627143,
-0.0089264419,
0.0259902198,
0.0292929914,
0.0229259524,
0.0131876571,
-0.0547935553,
0.0116678132,
0.0184419397,
-0.0418183357,
-0.0112042492,
0.0128086554,
0.0054578376,
-0.0165991224,
0.0376492478,
0.0063020512,
0.0559783392,
-0.0535083748,
-0.0259881541,
0.0018844962,
0.0044459342,
0.0511055812,
0.0109682828,
-0.0079486035,
-0.0065778643,
-0.0343561471,
-0.0313308761,
-0.0153550254,
-0.0138754072,
-0.0107350787,
0.068741098,
0.0535930768,
0.0085069695,
-0.0026512183,
0.0036190217,
-0.0009649227,
-0.0060125333,
-0.0071467832,
0.0050419676,
-0.0064372174,
-0.0309458692,
0.0173736978,
-0.0525875278,
-0.0247800108,
0.0402348563,
0.0288006309,
0.0080325613,
-0.0009566517,
0.0540805049,
0.0134686027,
-0.0753056481,
0.0253721122,
-0.0139958104,
0.0447844304,
-0.0029691295,
-0.0027881323,
0.0468777679,
-0.0033667742,
-0.0009087984,
0.0207020696,
-0.0036527263,
0.0121439276,
-0.0362287797,
-0.0252643488,
-0.0135051068,
0.051316306,
-0.0100485962,
-0.0018544255,
-0.029391773,
0.0028924288,
-0.0141637698,
-0.0531123467,
0.0024207931,
0.0265591368,
2.386e-7,
0.0034052269,
0.0416888297,
0.0531144477,
0.0034026692,
-0.0033144748,
-0.0149096651,
-0.0348022208,
0.0445558205,
-0.0062934179,
0.0683663636,
0.0149808405,
0.0150988521,
0.0427135192,
0.0008433665,
-0.0545787886,
-0.0019785881,
-0.05921847,
0.058545053,
-0.0399707891,
-0.0120799514,
0.0476044565,
0.0463309102,
0.0017659571,
0.0088215591,
-0.0067115845,
-0.0108235665,
0.0292543191,
0.0233140476,
-0.0045024715,
0.0305897854,
0.0390939601,
0.0018885584,
0.0320701078,
0.0051551522,
-0.0201493334,
-0.0127297658,
-0.0172772054,
0.0315980241,
-0.0197364371,
0.0055876868,
-0.0103555257,
0.0561467409,
-0.008680556,
-0.000318592,
0.0190006644,
-0.043121472,
0.0191283021,
0.0304690544,
-0.037723925,
0.0150760086,
0.0133786378,
-0.0387588255,
-0.0362109095,
0.0154389497,
0.0634552389,
0.0716048479,
0.0110499654,
-0.0412651934,
0.0008135464,
0.0208328087,
0.0340306051,
-0.0183977783,
-0.0096010044,
0.0294424631,
-0.0270287581,
-0.0231117364,
-0.0252563283,
1.934383631e-34,
0.0646872446,
-0.0117335757,
0.0508946441,
0.0244243797,
0.0367948301,
-0.0157417804,
0.0204558335,
0.0187812503,
-0.0055748029,
-0.0400958471,
-0.0506190546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14528v1 | Dual-Feedback Knowledge Retrieval for Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems | 2023-10-23T03:21:11 | 2023-10-23T03:21:11 | Tianyuan Shi, Liangzhi Li, Zijian Lin, Tao Yang, Xiaojun Quan, Qifan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Efficient knowledge retrieval plays a pivotal role in ensuring the success of
end-to-end task-oriented dialogue systems by facilitating the selection of
relevant information necessary to fulfill user requests. However, current
approaches generally integrate knowledge retrieval and response generation,
which poses scalability challenges when dealing with extensive knowledge bases.
Taking inspiration from open-domain question answering, we propose a
retriever-generator architecture that harnesses a retriever to retrieve
pertinent knowledge and a generator to generate system responses.~Due to the
lack of retriever training labels, we propose relying on feedback from the
generator as pseudo-labels to train the retriever. To achieve this, we
introduce a dual-feedback mechanism that generates both positive and negative
feedback based on the output of the generator. Our method demonstrates superior
performance in task-oriented dialogue tasks, as evidenced by experimental
results on three benchmark datasets. | [
0.057523787,
-0.0048660371,
-0.0133411828,
0.0507878847,
-0.0156663395,
-0.0158336274,
-0.0267213117,
0.0105491672,
0.0346413106,
-0.019788811,
-0.0483777113,
-0.0371822678,
-0.0655251518,
0.0370252058,
0.0145673556,
-0.0471155718,
0.0355496965,
-0.0057095098,
0.0317073837,
0.0062272497,
0.0192330349,
0.006017915,
-0.0428935699,
0.0562673248,
-0.0091402251,
-0.0087372558,
-0.0417577922,
0.0126499487,
-0.0050686323,
-0.024058966,
0.0490032211,
-0.0070132003,
0.0163594633,
0.0347865522,
0.0000016625,
-0.0286627878,
-0.0240565091,
0.0082944529,
-0.0525953025,
-0.0592485406,
-0.0021100226,
0.0295601133,
0.0178579651,
0.0317698158,
-0.0587034263,
-0.028160695,
0.0436621867,
0.0775827542,
0.0547769554,
0.0632847846,
-0.0001092867,
-0.0254923888,
0.0073911301,
-0.0093145473,
0.0254694894,
-0.0431917012,
0.0085092206,
0.0042925193,
0.042919822,
0.0578617193,
0.0345097855,
0.0336313248,
0.0212569423,
-0.0365427695,
0.0022551862,
0.0317041874,
0.004973616,
-0.0050932607,
-0.0255825035,
0.0923172459,
0.0860994309,
0.0266831834,
0.0021864651,
0.0127788624,
0.0166211519,
-0.0024655773,
-0.0352450497,
-0.023437487,
-0.0512142144,
-0.0251915548,
-0.0504915938,
0.0047612926,
-0.0328545682,
-0.026269624,
-0.0193139892,
0.0503138341,
0.000431118,
-0.0580171384,
0.0165162403,
-0.0067382595,
-0.0096431151,
-0.0490367338,
0.029058259,
0.0542193912,
-0.0449648201,
0.0186030418,
0.0097672781,
-0.0271620061,
0.0173852723,
-0.0357297957,
0.0271605141,
0.0163180009,
-0.0344823785,
0.0300048832,
-0.006348676,
0.0458248332,
-0.0396440178,
0.018160861,
-0.0402626581,
-0.0469468012,
-0.064861767,
-0.0303555224,
-0.0777061358,
0.0748268068,
-0.0498728044,
-0.0024970411,
0.0012888033,
0.0412076488,
-0.0227304734,
-0.020586621,
0.0137882931,
0.0611973889,
-0.0326415636,
0.0009295468,
-0.0776350051,
0.0608182102,
-0.033642333,
0.012509821,
0.0461970046,
-0.0222302638,
-0.0264444351,
-0.0034943833,
0.0126263956,
-0.0066494094,
-0.0229136981,
0.059370134,
-0.0346455909,
0.0040531605,
-0.0185654778,
-0.0540005229,
-0.0214943867,
-0.061030589,
0.007959838,
-0.0142491376,
0.0257151797,
0.0157143511,
-0.0547179617,
-0.0150485225,
0.0308323409,
0.0446107276,
-0.0055757086,
0.0313843265,
-0.0251205489,
-0.0347820669,
0.0256599002,
0.0120662553,
-0.0405350849,
0.0401610918,
0.0084491596,
0.0131241549,
0.0527550094,
0.036148984,
0.0280355327,
-0.029440634,
0.0551532656,
-0.0190446991,
0.0605337508,
0.0674036667,
-0.0103107998,
0.0068901409,
-0.0103566311,
0.0568465106,
-0.0263078697,
0.0177706741,
0.0271821078,
0.0162361562,
0.0077778576,
0.0122942096,
0.0326060802,
0.0336023979,
-0.008789191,
-0.0085653188,
0.001008203,
0.0460994318,
-0.0354731902,
0.0081803463,
0.0414483063,
-0.0121675245,
-0.0498360321,
-0.0512061976,
0.009895673,
0.0266086198,
-0.0124373036,
0.0570578091,
0.0670121163,
0.0389848575,
-0.08048255,
0.0257900767,
0.0073766038,
-0.0591164492,
-0.0227612592,
-0.0395212956,
0.030504154,
0.0381759256,
0.023732312,
-0.048036702,
-0.0422715396,
0.0028308947,
-0.0127081601,
0.0446987376,
0.0374293402,
-0.0299698468,
0.0097412812,
-0.0228592791,
-0.0106529016,
0.017811805,
-0.0166892353,
0.0249128006,
0.0102579938,
-0.004045262,
0.0270692576,
0.0118532795,
0.004329781,
0.0029348549,
0.0043823845,
-0.0096260188,
0.0500382632,
0.0257005189,
0.0280764345,
0.0382767096,
-0.0104706353,
0.0204416737,
0.0546655469,
-0.0242985934,
-0.0423963144,
0.0051408708,
-0.052591227,
-0.0708328709,
0.0202393755,
0.0474477969,
0.0103520583,
0.0313645042,
0.0128920628,
-0.0601927526,
0.0405863449,
-0.0532800369,
0.0193803087,
-0.0521612093,
-0.034035705,
0.0482325554,
-0.0347134918,
-0.0476081781,
0.0405838005,
0.0334037654,
0.0194089506,
0.0071046851,
0.0045281104,
0.0274387207,
-0.0669487417,
0.0007010519,
0.0030366704,
-0.0314621963,
0.0356020592,
0.0443747453,
-0.0130268531,
-0.032199908,
-0.0348796658,
-0.0911192521,
0.0397954285,
-0.0249186698,
0.0155901089,
-0.0005378697,
0.0125908284,
0.0270602517,
-0.0279626474,
-0.0463534705,
0.0267723072,
0.0650180951,
0.0043720393,
0.0232527014,
0.0669784769,
-0.006098215,
-0.0188669749,
0.0280545596,
0.0297325533,
0.0000737403,
-0.0123206442,
0.0169537961,
-0.0361144133,
0.0357163064,
-0.0554646254,
0.0641840845,
-0.0070510954,
-0.0013599979,
0.049488645,
-0.0315138288,
0.0124158533,
0.0219288431,
0.0229985751,
0.0150667476,
-0.0446207784,
-0.0489929467,
-0.0753227398,
0.0722466484,
-0.0440313742,
-0.0670763254,
-0.0099538146,
0.0294171255,
-0.0002953824,
0.0457855612,
0.0103501156,
-0.0027345128,
-0.0541922301,
-0.0105678001,
0.0204732735,
-0.0033600726,
-0.0442485176,
0.0220316369,
-0.0254586954,
0.0218720119,
-0.0378111117,
-0.0186848156,
0.0649333373,
0.0107360296,
-0.0450519547,
-0.0299993716,
-0.0026903851,
-0.0225927755,
0.0606635101,
-0.0366243534,
0.0209122244,
0.065360412,
-0.0162183158,
-0.0093215778,
0.0112092122,
0.0151805291,
-0.0765213817,
0.0161517635,
-0.0251282416,
0.0383033268,
-0.017546216,
-0.0853442028,
-0.0776135847,
0.0139193572,
0.0227843225,
0.0174775887,
-0.0111231226,
-0.0087465812,
-0.0060962825,
-0.0202465877,
0.0415572524,
0.0087238206,
-0.0243788864,
-0.0161007494,
-0.0161323585,
0.0540162772,
0.0358682647,
0.0298676025,
-0.0269817654,
0.0019638266,
-0.0095888376,
0.0559988506,
0.0601872392,
-0.0429755412,
0.0196580011,
-0.0465878062,
0.0450338051,
-0.0160716176,
0.0082519706,
0.0111397244,
0.0484636948,
-0.0196849145,
-0.0458925813,
0.0782743618,
0.0222388376,
0.0011565121,
-0.0423474722,
-0.022005748,
0.0259373263,
0.0282280967,
0.0424014367,
-0.0671300218,
-0.0228435602,
-0.0006994558,
0.0560309552,
-0.0103763118,
-0.029673662,
-0.0105063021,
-0.1068946496,
0.0294528436,
-0.0428827554,
-0.009741609,
-0.0480375253,
0.0001347725,
0.0010671353,
0.0329645239,
-0.0225149523,
0.0557841882,
0.0062843291,
-0.0024693434,
0.0189206786,
0.04260391,
0.0004586346,
0.0048545506,
-0.0155083006,
0.0100002196,
0.0584637076,
0.0297261979,
0.0412531942,
-0.0186555292,
-0.0365953594,
-0.0192341898,
-0.0056120474,
-0.0097224005,
0.0251522437,
-0.0056936573,
-0.0168141276,
-0.0525171533,
0.0103629334,
-0.0319989957,
0.0180737823,
0.035993278,
0.0431544296,
-0.0335479639,
0.041639626,
0.0002185766,
0.0105745243,
0.0618708357,
0.0616231114,
-0.0040882896,
-0.0099663064,
-0.0386976413,
-0.0066898316,
-0.0144936545,
-0.0795176998,
-0.0232242439,
-0.018109085,
0.0060452665,
0.0428096503,
-0.0683136955,
-0.0469723865,
0.0084244832,
0.0572227389,
-0.024871191,
-0.0038721976,
-0.0046903747,
0.0235677138,
-0.0480905138,
-0.0085980622,
-0.0251334663,
0.0000794735,
-0.0450995527,
-0.0468648635,
0.0421060584,
-0.0313260928,
-0.0290020835,
0.0370727219,
-0.044559028,
-0.0561529733,
-0.0659622177,
0.0724493191,
0.0139664989,
0.0140502369,
0.0167280324,
0.0114660002,
0.0165385678,
0.0460113846,
-0.0751663297,
-0.0231971368,
0.0453149192,
0.0257974863,
-0.0164311994,
0.0417043716,
-0.0766475871,
0.0093369102,
-0.0017707645,
0.0400268026,
-0.0090398574,
-0.0627094507,
0.023611797,
0.0141023863,
0.038783785,
0.0433066376,
-0.0246365089,
-0.0374579653,
0.0467448384,
-0.0207874347,
-0.0249594506,
-0.0804468915,
0.0144600533,
-0.0286265109,
-0.0658272728,
0.0203772727,
0.0246280693,
-0.0109224534,
0.0799513608,
-0.0474112853,
-0.0291416831,
0.0073478762,
0.0079498291,
0.0221479256,
0.0006297549,
-0.0132109234,
-0.0010801129,
0.0535223782,
0.0597481094,
-0.0082922392,
0.078603372,
0.0374325439,
-0.0246014465,
0.0061328318,
0.0022840558,
-0.0637418553,
-0.049960345,
-0.003421474,
0.0081810057,
0.0237813834,
0.0623006634,
0.0112496801,
-0.0067472919,
0.0019938261,
-0.0263926499,
0.0230150577,
-0.0084419874,
-0.0270667542,
0.0210601315,
0.0177949034,
0.0017168815,
-0.0107798548,
0.0687230304,
-0.0263846815,
-0.0011000496,
-0.029316809,
-0.0025604381,
-0.0546103008,
-0.0304830745,
0.0005723392,
0.0161435958,
0.0132795172,
0.0076984791,
-0.0251117125,
-0.0135714915,
0.0174605381,
0.0019657451,
-0.0312424693,
-0.0147881005,
0.0560183637,
0.0569140725,
0.0062341741,
-0.0712340549,
-0.0455117598,
0.0189029966,
-0.0593502559,
0.0076116305,
-0.0304730553,
-5.502162122e-33,
-0.0619738586,
0.0003954731,
0.0506233461,
0.0145379957,
-0.0403777659,
-0.0360226519,
-0.0347326025,
0.0037213131,
-0.0326203853,
0.006241262,
-0.0127926208,
-0.026062794,
0.002384281,
0.0516657867,
-0.0318365432,
-0.0244919006,
0.0504532158,
-0.0078395149,
0.0065654367,
0.0474736392,
0.0933521092,
0.0420397706,
0.0248813368,
-0.0768187121,
0.031122094,
-0.0208015256,
0.0404203981,
0.0501795597,
0.0114475293,
0.0492171273,
-0.0156122698,
0.0853494257,
0.0073242118,
-0.0593574792,
0.0078822663,
0.0267469753,
-0.099358134,
-0.0203807615,
0.0067975218,
-0.0161573552,
-0.060512688,
-0.0018601576,
0.0168712139,
-0.0173223484,
0.0164942238,
0.02131298,
-0.0035744444,
0.0086924434,
0.0035741164,
-0.0223755334,
-0.0543201193,
-0.0155848907,
0.0113045769,
-0.0668213889,
-0.027608281,
0.0804541409,
0.0291240513,
-0.0474395528,
-0.0082824342,
-0.0009492899,
-0.0065063429,
0.028029751,
-0.0189932622,
0.0725813732,
0.0131872194,
0.0414000154,
0.019911563,
0.0150719266,
-0.0517081134,
-0.0455502756,
-0.0353128724,
0.0315477699,
0.0289155953,
0.0566891357,
-0.0036976591,
-0.0105758905,
-0.0512758754,
0.0255954023,
-0.005953941,
0.0352137275,
0.0176077019,
0.0191990919,
-0.0238831639,
-0.0008496461,
-0.0304866694,
0.0298774876,
-0.0295920577,
-0.0244569425,
0.0614286773,
0.0542007647,
0.0016704254,
0.015761327,
0.0429673418,
-0.0090963757,
0.0231148228,
0.0284696333,
-0.0013513722,
-0.012338669,
-0.0292927586,
-0.0147428578,
-0.0611808486,
-0.0167120285,
0.0412996151,
0.0153293638,
-0.0473564863,
0.0274829455,
-0.0171202645,
-0.026750952,
-0.0478543416,
0.0142898727,
-0.0555996001,
0.0825592354,
-0.0339246579,
0.0111004114,
0.0023010985,
0.0302861221,
-0.0234230608,
0.0909552053,
-0.0160858613,
-0.0190564822,
-0.0563013442,
-0.0317366235,
0.0233850852,
-0.0233385414,
-0.0092692124,
0.0372633114,
-0.006973675,
0.0145159047,
-0.0479165427,
-0.0335748084,
0.0099731814,
0.0099736676,
2.395e-7,
-0.0047086473,
-0.0151420999,
0.04218968,
0.061982587,
0.0048095002,
0.0455048569,
0.0325575769,
0.0209012106,
0.0454461239,
-0.0505399555,
-0.0189596005,
0.0268669669,
0.0183005985,
0.0228776112,
-0.1082498282,
-0.0519900061,
-0.0216059256,
-0.0400640294,
-0.0074096606,
-0.0152033651,
0.0959597528,
0.0255381502,
-0.003349599,
0.0071692322,
-0.0093604196,
-0.0471408591,
0.0691507012,
0.0229536053,
0.0088819675,
0.000569688,
0.0487770252,
-0.0106701264,
-0.0017570573,
0.0226115342,
0.0062142913,
0.0331575349,
-0.0123889307,
0.0191701837,
-0.0043077255,
-0.1025558785,
-0.0222484656,
-0.0027396688,
0.0215255171,
-0.0089813378,
0.05352607,
-0.0574441068,
0.0128044803,
0.0025223324,
-0.0196280908,
-0.0239913464,
-0.0461116582,
-0.0254080873,
-0.019258555,
0.0048463787,
0.0115654087,
0.0174065568,
0.0360208154,
-0.0764714777,
0.0296655241,
0.0004911054,
-0.0467529446,
-0.0321295224,
-0.0360046141,
-0.0097653577,
-0.0247329511,
-0.046037104,
-0.0095423423,
1.668313929e-34,
0.008483151,
0.018168617,
-0.0024859863,
0.0388458148,
0.0288802721,
-0.0003877217,
-0.0339157395,
-0.008006704,
0.0493274741,
-0.0636003092,
-0.0297213122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18347v1 | PRCA: Fitting Black-Box Large Language Models for Retrieval Question Answering via Pluggable Reward-Driven Contextual Adapter | 2023-10-23T03:12:00 | 2023-10-23T03:12:00 | Haoyan Yang, Zhitao Li, Yong Zhang, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Ming Li, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Retrieval Question Answering (ReQA) task employs the retrieval-augmented
framework, composed of a retriever and generator. The generator formulates the
answer based on the documents retrieved by the retriever. Incorporating Large
Language Models (LLMs) as generators is beneficial due to their advanced QA
capabilities, but they are typically too large to be fine-tuned with budget
constraints while some of them are only accessible via APIs. To tackle this
issue and further improve ReQA performance, we propose a trainable Pluggable
Reward-Driven Contextual Adapter (PRCA), keeping the generator as a black box.
Positioned between the retriever and generator in a Pluggable manner, PRCA
refines the retrieved information by operating in a token-autoregressive
strategy via maximizing rewards of the reinforcement learning phase. Our
experiments validate PRCA's effectiveness in enhancing ReQA performance on
three datasets by up to 20% improvement to fit black-box LLMs into existing
frameworks, demonstrating its considerable potential in the LLMs era. | [
0.0311854333,
0.0626238137,
0.0044725873,
0.0312460326,
-0.0086777592,
-0.0133358026,
-0.0137542309,
-0.001103875,
-0.0126403738,
-0.0270758681,
-0.033256229,
0.0134693673,
-0.0603907742,
0.0335956365,
-0.007815076,
-0.0196826886,
0.0438608043,
-0.0227967128,
-0.0056185266,
-0.0016916479,
0.0061695902,
0.0139989201,
0.0048930501,
0.0452030078,
0.0004914652,
-0.0120915975,
-0.0126403645,
-0.0107759312,
0.005813228,
-0.0226322692,
0.0599748045,
0.0227430351,
0.0408927947,
0.0536019094,
0.0000018249,
-0.0551492833,
-0.0608776696,
0.0166873131,
-0.0387467183,
-0.0296941251,
-0.0066856751,
0.0205876566,
0.0322491564,
0.0187287219,
-0.0643568933,
-0.0355355963,
0.0124800019,
0.0591077432,
0.0439379178,
0.0761884749,
0.006420102,
-0.0353945531,
0.0463129319,
-0.0459009893,
0.0387550779,
-0.0666701496,
0.0059149908,
0.0279502925,
0.0429652669,
0.021673521,
-0.01832355,
0.0358152837,
0.0444868617,
-0.0034136781,
0.0093904296,
0.0263534933,
-0.0461642295,
0.0228154007,
-0.0316074528,
0.0521197207,
0.0352087319,
-0.0099431053,
0.0021493451,
0.0220246408,
-0.0062826169,
0.0123828277,
-0.0424615145,
0.0191954076,
-0.0116698286,
-0.0019929477,
0.0178937558,
-0.0008901886,
0.0157562383,
0.020966053,
-0.0358904153,
0.0703605264,
0.0043797656,
-0.0212187003,
-0.0211218633,
0.0033299932,
0.0013776972,
-0.0089146271,
-0.0019925751,
0.0663407296,
-0.0474790819,
0.0195167605,
0.0067258985,
-0.0111762295,
0.0151926987,
0.0214137472,
0.0122782942,
0.0267819297,
-0.0068785613,
0.0645059645,
-0.0476986729,
0.0494035929,
-0.0462740473,
0.0062208348,
-0.0628042743,
-0.0520829111,
-0.0194557905,
-0.0535643548,
-0.0705141276,
0.0603575185,
-0.0348752327,
-0.028099725,
-0.0230342392,
0.0511789732,
-0.026206566,
-0.0094818529,
-0.0189776458,
0.0639958307,
-0.0403024517,
0.0006717817,
-0.0412546359,
0.0153464191,
-0.04797443,
0.015371792,
0.0237372816,
-0.0494781584,
-0.018588189,
-0.0112049775,
0.0201711059,
-0.0343942493,
0.017730983,
0.0313430466,
-0.0207957923,
-0.0535986908,
-0.0051205046,
-0.0275076739,
0.0185514297,
-0.0216940772,
-0.0242678933,
-0.0632998124,
0.0245233309,
0.0139447125,
-0.035587877,
-0.0059777237,
0.0157845784,
0.0305069089,
0.0169875994,
0.0441032797,
0.0491674952,
-0.0165811237,
0.0447278097,
0.0161288548,
-0.0116827497,
0.0666013956,
0.0284916088,
0.0410923027,
0.045634076,
0.0269993171,
-0.0002855292,
0.0088702887,
0.0426796004,
0.034018714,
-0.0230686311,
0.0574407242,
0.032958176,
0.0031907638,
0.0301220026,
0.0239797942,
-0.0257086381,
0.0081531936,
0.0041074716,
0.0360467546,
0.0499450378,
-0.0076556145,
0.0116846338,
-0.019475136,
-0.0083932644,
-0.0386038907,
-0.0197558794,
0.0512436293,
-0.0330645368,
0.0121460501,
0.0440982878,
0.0145906862,
-0.036365293,
-0.0376403742,
0.0348519757,
-0.0030866531,
0.0121958116,
0.0560594983,
0.0438373014,
0.0259022359,
-0.0398708805,
0.0223284382,
0.0144101782,
-0.0272933673,
0.0134957135,
-0.0683059394,
0.1024985686,
0.0482221171,
0.0811591521,
-0.0591569468,
-0.0075373659,
-0.0138808368,
0.0036452073,
0.0266192257,
-0.0014564013,
-0.0181456301,
-0.0045497473,
-0.0246335752,
-0.0376426727,
-0.0219653286,
-0.0149574783,
0.036168322,
0.0813518316,
0.0367460921,
0.0359792449,
0.0001761629,
-0.0017617582,
0.0187114161,
-0.0433185846,
-0.0478146486,
0.0300831236,
-0.0007548251,
0.0068053114,
-0.0087527465,
0.0001695929,
0.0024163423,
0.0529844426,
-0.0491845235,
-0.0231989529,
0.0128170867,
-0.0524411276,
-0.007948257,
0.0025054305,
0.0102372533,
0.0303560495,
0.0237425752,
-0.0288284682,
-0.0405084193,
0.0088591566,
-0.0162058286,
0.0743676946,
-0.0533553362,
-0.0381296463,
0.0144731309,
0.0217475016,
-0.0420536511,
0.0278093722,
0.0091947801,
0.0411556251,
0.0214593783,
0.0252359714,
-0.0103743728,
-0.0544054508,
-0.0084414594,
-0.0154706463,
-0.000074484,
0.0291781873,
0.0396463536,
0.0053514433,
-0.0414669737,
-0.0446443819,
-0.0695916414,
0.0156358723,
-0.0331068113,
0.0129735637,
0.0191304199,
0.0552987605,
-0.0013623443,
-0.0319261625,
-0.0311156884,
-0.0117041105,
0.041811645,
0.0196084529,
0.0202556364,
0.056079369,
0.0210396945,
-0.0577953793,
-0.0040919171,
0.026496714,
0.0317790657,
-0.0092006931,
0.0406935699,
-0.0407439321,
-0.0132155698,
-0.0180619732,
0.0478543155,
-0.0273040384,
-0.0095129972,
0.0092012556,
-0.0372500829,
0.0191268194,
0.0896338299,
0.0202327278,
0.0193733983,
0.0013329764,
-0.0022958594,
-0.1114927083,
0.0422140583,
-0.0446518809,
-0.0642661229,
-0.0106896628,
-0.0325401574,
0.0226874612,
0.0351003632,
-0.0317692533,
0.0115745924,
-0.0319319889,
0.0366680399,
0.0190807022,
-0.0344048068,
-0.0493010618,
0.0270254407,
-0.0182189588,
0.0130672837,
-0.0297656357,
-0.0525161251,
0.0611055717,
0.0057368781,
-0.0167763177,
-0.0309533421,
-0.0108317323,
-0.0867088661,
0.053461358,
-0.0078625847,
0.0239273421,
-0.0396459103,
-0.0153941661,
-0.0361686684,
-0.0147799524,
-0.0100421235,
-0.0690349042,
0.0543585047,
0.0028151635,
0.0437699631,
-0.0149640702,
-0.0511521064,
-0.073196426,
-0.0167785622,
0.0001193406,
0.031269256,
-0.0485679954,
-0.0239738859,
-0.0225590914,
0.0060896007,
0.0649449378,
0.0320668146,
-0.0318297036,
-0.0186694544,
-0.0057381121,
0.0531213693,
0.1076618731,
0.0225797761,
0.0079261037,
0.0128240073,
-0.0029021343,
0.0511858575,
0.0425303802,
-0.0140465004,
-0.0071417042,
-0.0242289193,
0.047657039,
-0.0306845102,
-0.0006497251,
-0.0034298457,
0.0115956068,
-0.0575866736,
-0.0710060596,
0.0868602544,
0.0257049482,
-0.050255131,
-0.0288309921,
-0.0492738225,
0.0315774791,
0.0216812547,
0.0720384493,
-0.0811930448,
-0.0295082815,
-0.0074840104,
0.0680343062,
0.0207787231,
-0.0070941634,
-0.002894585,
-0.1278699189,
0.0235424917,
-0.0275010504,
-0.0617062263,
-0.0145534491,
-0.0386871584,
-0.0067904536,
-0.0051346724,
0.0148803256,
0.0543905012,
-0.0401552208,
0.0125822956,
0.01438927,
0.0415978767,
0.0128561761,
0.0246607717,
-0.0202927794,
0.0032811081,
0.0936734229,
-0.0332340896,
-0.0155644882,
-0.0139141511,
-0.0396438241,
-0.0483582541,
0.0048277713,
-0.002616561,
-0.0169670023,
-0.0184060484,
-0.0020175166,
0.0014543381,
0.0270959921,
-0.0185171217,
-0.0055656643,
0.0283989534,
0.0632215068,
-0.0131923323,
0.0256412905,
-0.0397543982,
-0.0399101935,
-0.0017675847,
0.0699913502,
0.0035741243,
-0.0273571238,
-0.0508503392,
-0.0069541098,
-0.0144823818,
-0.0694365874,
0.0098420037,
-0.0138754686,
0.0051580691,
0.0190709326,
-0.0666941851,
-0.0395158045,
0.001728434,
0.034747161,
-0.0223223455,
0.0220400672,
-0.0515317693,
-0.0001716334,
-0.0841609389,
0.0335232131,
-0.0416585095,
0.0055708233,
-0.0649267063,
0.0038527562,
0.0280729309,
-0.0634042919,
-0.0407146439,
-0.0092410035,
-0.035346318,
-0.0209846199,
-0.0108501222,
0.0729594231,
0.0140098762,
0.0546822436,
-0.0061351606,
-0.0413938351,
0.0414422974,
0.0904658064,
-0.024593709,
0.0214743204,
0.008014203,
0.0505344979,
-0.0010996846,
0.0430196524,
-0.1166197956,
-0.0104385084,
-0.0112288669,
0.0529665649,
-0.006856448,
-0.0127458395,
0.0276930705,
-0.0156387985,
-0.0126812197,
0.0243952796,
0.0081829177,
-0.0256254096,
0.0321353972,
-0.001317188,
-0.025085805,
-0.0329514705,
0.0191963911,
-0.0027261274,
-0.0460441075,
0.0151476441,
-0.0037361584,
-0.0030260594,
0.0678628311,
-0.0729921833,
0.0196996927,
0.0211351048,
-0.0203399565,
0.0278673135,
0.0019953023,
-0.0082411636,
-0.021896001,
0.0222803522,
0.0866713896,
-0.0270076338,
0.0557454862,
0.0295046195,
-0.0300318878,
-0.0576646999,
0.025980873,
-0.0735444501,
-0.0295709278,
-0.0004237132,
0.0153163569,
0.0195228215,
-0.0011302204,
0.0069901892,
-0.0067924685,
-0.0228730105,
-0.0008930725,
-0.04500499,
0.01648698,
-0.0134032248,
0.0656163618,
0.0301714633,
0.0089173848,
0.0248087458,
0.0613890141,
-0.0358003676,
0.0426275916,
-0.0092858076,
0.0064396453,
-0.0092084762,
-0.0255387872,
0.0260840114,
0.0238087866,
-0.0220880844,
-0.0107401218,
-0.0112428265,
-0.0395991914,
0.0064977878,
0.0038103613,
-0.045504339,
-0.0193593632,
0.0228630081,
0.0475067943,
0.0268679447,
-0.04736875,
-0.0611991622,
0.0556176454,
-0.0681102872,
-0.0267008655,
-0.0157468673,
-6.334064617e-33,
-0.0144081861,
-0.018468475,
0.0135243498,
-0.0363563634,
-0.0108370082,
0.0361735336,
-0.0186220948,
-0.0385490805,
-0.0300541334,
-0.0392140932,
-0.0385129638,
-0.0081241,
0.0109730996,
0.0487594493,
0.0025854814,
-0.0171514954,
0.0123411659,
0.0157834683,
-0.0377350226,
0.0264034811,
0.0513496175,
0.0373284332,
0.0115583558,
-0.0237415135,
0.0271102693,
-0.0317739546,
0.0107179517,
0.0596542582,
-0.002363326,
0.0724757239,
-0.0107833967,
0.0433618687,
0.0239638556,
-0.0361849554,
0.0263933856,
0.0329669863,
-0.1198009104,
-0.0139136408,
0.0079289237,
-0.0095662065,
-0.0646118596,
-0.0214141719,
0.0334879793,
-0.0208221711,
0.0142819518,
0.0197607931,
0.0137222735,
-0.0176240448,
-0.0278657563,
-0.0055690818,
-0.0275410824,
-0.0149766952,
0.0050218417,
-0.006086485,
-0.0085917143,
0.036758285,
-0.0007883072,
0.0547830947,
-0.0429501571,
-0.0095372973,
-0.0204269383,
0.0431957804,
0.0392309465,
0.0691405535,
0.0245419517,
0.0110311378,
0.0455106497,
-0.0278525595,
-0.0308405627,
-0.0457518101,
-0.0034901944,
-0.0039724647,
0.0158802476,
0.0323134065,
0.012249616,
0.0022959607,
-0.040970467,
0.0412454605,
0.0053023202,
0.0592854172,
0.0495672897,
0.0265157335,
-0.0282528736,
-0.0001373057,
-0.0596794374,
0.0369126424,
-0.0440800041,
-0.0226823371,
0.0560708232,
0.069649078,
-0.0183864962,
-0.0336945206,
0.0228176098,
-0.0427901931,
0.0116348444,
0.0672253966,
-0.0150354384,
-0.0010694886,
-0.003161977,
0.040521007,
-0.0607023314,
0.0094588259,
0.0251654703,
-0.0165433176,
-0.0381088257,
0.0238869712,
-0.0163065232,
0.0198604167,
-0.0694208592,
0.010748269,
-0.0416766368,
0.054547403,
-0.0327438004,
-0.014857295,
0.0123213148,
0.0227982439,
-0.0110320197,
0.0312353782,
0.0194869321,
0.0002222009,
-0.0087789791,
-0.047526218,
0.006922958,
-0.0138107352,
-0.0349067375,
0.0524751954,
-0.0204951223,
0.0918939933,
-0.0126874121,
-0.0434245728,
0.0061313855,
0.0287160818,
2.553e-7,
0.0364677869,
0.0005363623,
0.0163567048,
0.0351926126,
0.0200043749,
0.0183264632,
0.0269418694,
0.027741801,
0.0380737036,
0.0344034471,
-0.0041664881,
0.0452122129,
0.0349023193,
0.0152070206,
-0.0710791498,
0.0156586394,
-0.0688646212,
-0.0074510612,
-0.0336644091,
-0.0422847569,
0.0156058129,
0.0708274841,
-0.005899074,
0.0004831843,
-0.0067319837,
-0.0792723,
0.056631498,
-0.0161791816,
-0.007038834,
0.0104837231,
0.0202793162,
0.0711640641,
0.0296759028,
-0.0368107036,
0.0026734378,
0.0436678827,
-0.0231992025,
0.030506188,
-0.0023164516,
-0.0691353828,
-0.0291903913,
-0.0274741799,
0.0194844287,
-0.0789480582,
0.0873533338,
-0.0435838811,
0.0140206376,
-0.0377139151,
-0.0309722628,
-0.0205126069,
-0.0097627845,
-0.0281519815,
-0.0204199329,
0.017257113,
-0.0060712444,
0.0089322999,
-0.0093520535,
-0.0982596353,
-0.0151971253,
0.0027595016,
-0.0057695275,
-0.0048417621,
-0.06931106,
0.0169238281,
-0.0522960983,
-0.054800909,
0.0161146298,
2.14708635e-34,
0.023399163,
-0.0011463031,
0.0029346959,
0.0519069955,
0.0204183105,
0.0279271007,
-0.016084319,
-0.0016673112,
0.0351815671,
-0.0823769197,
-0.017907545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14523v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14523v2 | Rethinking Word-Level Auto-Completion in Computer-Aided Translation | 2023-10-23T03:11:46 | 2023-10-24T06:48:07 | Xingyu Chen, Lemao Liu, Guoping Huang, Zhirui Zhang, Mingming Yang, Shuming Shi, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Word-Level Auto-Completion (WLAC) plays a crucial role in Computer-Assisted
Translation. It aims at providing word-level auto-completion suggestions for
human translators. While previous studies have primarily focused on designing
complex model architectures, this paper takes a different perspective by
rethinking the fundamental question: what kind of words are good
auto-completions? We introduce a measurable criterion to answer this question
and discover that existing WLAC models often fail to meet this criterion.
Building upon this observation, we propose an effective approach to enhance
WLAC performance by promoting adherence to the criterion. Notably, the proposed
approach is general and can be applied to various encoder-based architectures.
Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that our approach outperforms the
top-performing system submitted to the WLAC shared tasks in WMT2022, while
utilizing significantly smaller model sizes. | [
0.0287535135,
0.0491558388,
-0.0214051791,
0.0127117634,
-0.0071412972,
-0.0004976954,
0.0044949502,
-0.0109251337,
-0.0071600932,
0.0119705824,
-0.0196458586,
-0.0342908055,
0.0589743145,
0.0257330313,
0.0404587984,
-0.05329144,
0.0384187922,
-0.0407669134,
-0.0595492162,
-0.0372565426,
-0.0252980236,
-0.0107709281,
0.0094920918,
0.0549330041,
0.0173970759,
0.0034556568,
0.0050944583,
0.0184853543,
-0.0136238271,
0.0103876302,
-0.0047665476,
0.049939204,
0.0031759897,
0.0000152891,
0.000002082,
-0.0350574702,
0.004172605,
-0.0351105481,
-0.025092341,
-0.0159210823,
0.0088217212,
-0.0627798587,
-0.0047507007,
0.0066910558,
0.0216693059,
-0.0028838038,
0.0797835514,
-0.0096034594,
0.0188900065,
0.0184231717,
-0.0092363851,
-0.0139218541,
0.0433028489,
-0.0644153506,
0.001292435,
-0.0570640005,
-0.0014744592,
-0.0090913409,
0.0170701463,
0.0097818263,
-0.0512826182,
0.076753512,
0.0191707183,
0.0065994575,
0.061194066,
0.0268607493,
-0.0137532065,
-0.0553508177,
0.0048783785,
0.0663178712,
-0.0250956398,
0.0159652773,
-0.0308107883,
-0.0028427404,
-0.0076479693,
0.004165798,
-0.0049055773,
-0.0054558832,
0.0089124031,
-0.0070839128,
-0.0027515476,
0.0562741086,
0.015386235,
-0.0071040541,
-0.0289777983,
0.0522996932,
0.0358994454,
-0.0249771755,
-0.008814753,
0.0557879992,
0.0136119155,
-0.0577900633,
0.0702244714,
0.0102795223,
-0.0234656986,
0.0102648241,
-0.0650963336,
0.0147545459,
-0.030531425,
-0.035559386,
0.0269086752,
0.0581257232,
-0.0167498421,
0.0293009784,
-0.0393524691,
0.0557977669,
-0.028138835,
-0.0313867033,
-0.0646844283,
-0.0708972737,
0.0238121506,
0.0150583936,
-0.0773751736,
0.007314893,
-0.0515835658,
-0.0454909354,
-0.0549221896,
0.0294730347,
0.0000617076,
0.0261937976,
0.0263750572,
-0.0073723807,
-0.0666237995,
-0.017124325,
-0.0123197446,
0.0397249907,
-0.0395748504,
-0.0199530721,
0.011740041,
-0.0259501431,
-0.0297313165,
-0.0004713707,
0.0253708195,
-0.0602365695,
0.008543646,
0.06492275,
-0.0136292242,
-0.0624539964,
-0.0010008374,
-0.0083262371,
-0.0378235281,
-0.041220732,
-0.0159083568,
-0.0398286805,
0.0480812378,
0.0300066397,
0.0262819771,
-0.0221101567,
-0.0031301167,
0.0062724003,
-0.0223057978,
0.0937212557,
-0.0198522937,
0.0124342982,
0.0401110314,
-0.0207300298,
-0.0004756702,
0.0574623682,
0.0495565422,
0.0853084102,
0.036579892,
0.0028767509,
0.0229876861,
0.058161851,
-0.0051124166,
-0.0097121065,
-0.0347807221,
-0.0130410297,
-0.0063623297,
0.0292883273,
0.0548156239,
0.038246844,
-0.0367398635,
0.0185750592,
0.0908730924,
0.0419454798,
0.030622229,
0.0683308393,
0.0380696133,
-0.0070908242,
-0.0020333342,
-0.0060849306,
-0.0123690292,
0.0705425516,
-0.0310838241,
0.0177156348,
0.0500327237,
0.0382400677,
-0.0561185405,
-0.0656116307,
-0.0144784385,
-0.0547072776,
0.020133866,
-0.0098574711,
0.0464345478,
0.0397925042,
-0.0477099307,
0.0184712466,
-0.0103138825,
-0.0313086621,
0.0504446737,
-0.0239676218,
-0.0152788358,
0.0831540227,
0.0811672807,
0.0307356473,
-0.0013481344,
-0.0072644106,
-0.0197654348,
0.0548833311,
0.0394138172,
0.0072364965,
0.0260791574,
-0.0577426255,
-0.0621726736,
0.031469211,
-0.0044192025,
0.0246573873,
0.0027766479,
0.0357356891,
0.0228853971,
-0.0256237052,
-0.0278422795,
0.022190202,
-0.0126277525,
-0.0182676781,
0.0292070638,
0.0332902037,
0.0163176619,
0.009539322,
0.00068691,
-0.0012479643,
-0.0269395877,
-0.0536115319,
-0.0625777021,
0.0308505539,
-0.0514391772,
-0.0426103547,
-0.0279470515,
-0.0340014882,
-0.0078947749,
0.0394258462,
0.0308779385,
-0.0800299048,
-0.0033232858,
-0.0692635179,
0.0370212868,
-0.0516796075,
0.0561546236,
0.0274067186,
0.0452689566,
0.0065131197,
0.0306928456,
-0.0134963635,
0.0016863584,
0.018338874,
-0.0059120501,
0.0146837849,
-0.0432351604,
-0.0755604282,
0.0447889939,
0.0213602055,
0.0193552002,
0.0501648709,
0.0053228415,
0.0006970715,
-0.0422705375,
-0.0483154617,
0.001271951,
-0.0215249714,
-0.0070007248,
-0.0303488001,
0.0614448376,
0.0024352602,
-0.0158540756,
-0.000100048,
-0.0042679943,
-0.0078853033,
0.0358514935,
0.0328836553,
-0.0214712024,
-0.0010371963,
-0.0379754789,
-0.0300400183,
0.050287623,
0.0235480592,
0.0024937287,
-0.0291912034,
-0.0500785224,
-0.005761418,
-0.0143608479,
0.0062672375,
0.0096325381,
-0.0828072578,
-0.0055939755,
0.0178518482,
0.0157570075,
0.0721350014,
0.0045715082,
-0.0001832345,
0.0284826625,
0.0081301071,
-0.044879552,
0.0187666323,
-0.0201875661,
-0.0323061869,
0.0175105929,
0.0192291215,
-0.0027957961,
0.0845012292,
0.0100199208,
0.0058015585,
-0.1060207263,
-0.0398669802,
-0.0245189425,
-0.0315002203,
-0.0290970095,
-0.0243314989,
-0.0244309008,
0.0458667949,
-0.043375995,
-0.0702777356,
0.070461303,
-0.0487162396,
-0.031306617,
-0.0173681788,
0.0350171849,
-0.0148219354,
0.0245205462,
0.0074574919,
0.0052762809,
-0.0433923192,
-0.0414068773,
-0.0076277852,
0.0471925251,
0.018085273,
-0.0214560796,
0.032623753,
-0.0298772734,
-0.0003053578,
-0.003265861,
-0.0357978567,
-0.0393473282,
0.0082386546,
-0.0354275219,
0.0003914834,
0.0518261716,
-0.0280680656,
-0.0123421466,
0.0380894914,
0.0103916656,
0.0544410571,
-0.032057669,
-0.0103308382,
-0.0414210446,
0.0240885392,
0.0443057083,
-0.001027826,
-0.0027008473,
-0.0516336933,
0.0274067167,
-0.0155268777,
-0.0004460339,
-0.0143543063,
-0.0279678106,
0.0379314162,
0.0912828445,
-0.0067090783,
-0.0460617244,
0.0065089748,
0.0821667537,
-0.0139149958,
-0.0134041561,
0.1235622466,
0.0010086278,
-0.0524270199,
-0.0174907371,
-0.009021054,
0.0347285792,
0.0121270688,
0.0046654502,
-0.0411166288,
-0.0267663449,
0.0118678659,
0.0240249895,
0.039603103,
0.0114128608,
-0.0082289455,
-0.0601290278,
0.0438248739,
0.0452618897,
0.0003003947,
-0.0392882563,
0.0056164684,
0.0169315133,
-0.0408348069,
0.0081380196,
-0.0196179543,
0.0173727497,
-0.0264080968,
-0.0155604538,
-0.0538728014,
-0.0255779792,
0.0055105356,
-0.0518902577,
0.0563873127,
0.0961219892,
0.0207736492,
-0.0015259481,
-0.0459928438,
-0.0012531169,
-0.0088439276,
0.0048659104,
-0.0069812895,
0.0533742085,
-0.013705126,
-0.022969801,
0.018293323,
0.0024248119,
-0.0349617451,
0.0163548104,
-0.0162709504,
0.0591422543,
-0.0152233569,
0.0220064279,
-0.007493719,
-0.0255685095,
-0.004595866,
0.0696418658,
0.0321258716,
-0.0759041533,
-0.0097752679,
-0.0125531284,
0.0056962729,
-0.0668852851,
-0.0135337384,
-0.0035186615,
-0.0182698742,
-0.0497742444,
-0.0567268617,
-0.0888815969,
0.031112887,
0.0118188085,
-0.0203225818,
0.0317727327,
0.0033264449,
0.0005552147,
-0.0176149458,
0.0125944316,
-0.0320854485,
0.0124907698,
-0.0547780171,
-0.0218872186,
-0.0018482694,
-0.0384946279,
0.0093301758,
0.0497785024,
-0.0301401913,
-0.0366057865,
-0.0078069256,
0.0606726557,
0.0301936474,
0.0605500452,
-0.0604278855,
-0.0944009274,
0.0340873636,
-0.0456513092,
-0.0019077122,
0.0104230037,
0.043265149,
-0.002887073,
-0.0155724427,
0.0550432317,
-0.0032888891,
-0.0002861504,
-0.0163669959,
0.0614177696,
0.0289777536,
-0.1065450013,
0.0333805941,
-0.0170369167,
0.0166301876,
-0.0548927858,
0.008340871,
-0.0440181196,
0.0159302447,
-0.0208656546,
0.0127777169,
-0.0634318739,
-0.0102552874,
0.054593686,
-0.0004100268,
0.0023204673,
-0.0142335035,
-0.0447999611,
-0.0072327573,
-0.0123499408,
-0.0082992064,
-0.0379352383,
0.0160379112,
0.0220075641,
0.0286628548,
-0.009990871,
0.0145038823,
0.0278518293,
0.0260876212,
-0.0338662565,
0.0331991687,
-0.0261977892,
0.0321565866,
0.0058692382,
0.0553905629,
-0.0190380439,
-0.0388565622,
-0.0510977656,
0.0462979153,
0.059681572,
-0.0218870118,
0.0565965325,
-0.0003286706,
-0.0120624723,
-0.0061213206,
0.0344682559,
-0.0059399032,
-0.0181226432,
-0.0041506034,
-0.0021076382,
-0.0184506848,
-0.0295230485,
0.0383876488,
-0.0208708383,
0.0068680756,
-0.0342503972,
-0.0009323335,
-0.0133323604,
-0.0082202386,
0.0004703479,
-0.0067093563,
-0.0514766909,
0.0101042381,
-0.0590752028,
-0.0686956123,
0.0214262493,
0.0137911988,
-0.0304592475,
0.000093963,
0.0377725922,
0.0591591001,
-0.0224114861,
-0.0205694251,
-0.0435185358,
-0.0197404977,
0.0347943455,
0.0075392197,
-0.0096811689,
-6.450046971e-33,
-0.067201376,
0.0242899191,
0.0208160318,
-0.0588623211,
-0.0001436138,
0.0038152121,
-0.0256084632,
0.0013287459,
-0.0118359001,
-0.0151908398,
-0.0267356448,
0.0051775496,
0.0273608603,
0.016738141,
0.0386894941,
0.0411801897,
0.0755805969,
0.0086288834,
-0.0320184566,
-0.0002024703,
-0.0135975806,
0.002601183,
0.0411207378,
-0.0056374599,
0.0297357999,
-0.0085517699,
0.0105000585,
-0.0136125013,
0.0557567887,
0.0657217652,
-0.0286185835,
0.0538852699,
0.009645463,
-0.0210653562,
-0.0378292464,
0.0022344673,
-0.0861338601,
-0.0416327268,
0.0012915566,
0.0396788828,
-0.0592803918,
-0.057151664,
0.0489680953,
-0.029624816,
-0.0277877226,
0.0050774436,
0.0210151784,
-0.0240387637,
-0.0542293228,
0.0047687376,
-0.0584684983,
0.0177245997,
-0.003622287,
-0.0511843041,
0.0437233672,
0.0550734475,
-0.0032339024,
-0.0210173149,
-0.0395550877,
0.0137948543,
0.0169059094,
0.0582185462,
0.0823280662,
0.0024314402,
-0.0198220816,
-0.0029861946,
0.03079281,
-0.0009840066,
0.0136174597,
0.0031678621,
0.032728184,
0.0310650431,
0.0494270399,
0.020610055,
0.0209760163,
-0.0525476635,
0.036279805,
0.058250431,
-0.0370052531,
0.0388163365,
0.0029365888,
-0.0034447028,
-0.066040881,
-0.0123569956,
-0.0361474045,
-0.062801525,
-0.0176137183,
-0.0339785442,
0.0322892889,
0.035583742,
0.0055161421,
-0.0166206304,
0.0669508949,
-0.0213053059,
0.0366935655,
0.0113934306,
-0.0048605762,
0.0210545976,
0.0223309286,
0.0669361055,
-0.0010450684,
-0.0389688909,
-0.0065803397,
0.0037900447,
-0.0262948833,
-0.0075225988,
-0.0245579723,
0.0515359975,
-0.0407792814,
-0.0071353312,
-0.0501602776,
-0.0017135835,
-0.0230409987,
-0.010371305,
0.0461680181,
0.0016814296,
-0.0285965074,
0.0580934808,
-0.0221139397,
-0.0019094241,
-0.045844648,
-0.0335055664,
0.0312185511,
0.018114889,
-0.0067962091,
0.0240331572,
-0.0532996878,
0.028540073,
0.0456327088,
-0.0374925137,
-0.0156510733,
0.0090667661,
2.778e-7,
0.0376643054,
0.0447192192,
0.0341818556,
0.0315911397,
-0.018754622,
-0.0068563125,
-0.0027049759,
0.034260802,
-0.0091133909,
0.0202477816,
0.0468206033,
0.0061508203,
0.0887408406,
-0.0001780053,
-0.058588583,
-0.0029464311,
-0.0190608744,
0.0544705726,
-0.0511949956,
-0.0627340525,
0.0449925363,
0.0734117553,
-0.0176317524,
0.0057624439,
-0.0372669064,
-0.0235610586,
0.0937441587,
-0.0226262342,
-0.0055444906,
0.0072852103,
0.0494141914,
0.0395113043,
-0.023033794,
0.0065896385,
-0.0236629918,
0.0430728011,
0.0682120249,
0.065770328,
-0.0300237369,
-0.0425965227,
0.0187523272,
-0.0209422652,
-0.0156766754,
-0.0459714122,
0.0764167756,
-0.059052486,
0.0316439979,
0.0396196954,
-0.0233006775,
0.0419880226,
0.0429843999,
-0.0336900391,
-0.052715756,
0.0064639389,
0.0638421625,
0.0224108975,
-0.0095644137,
-0.0620886795,
0.0015079449,
-0.0137307048,
-0.0304095745,
-0.0108807124,
-0.0449512899,
-0.040849302,
0.0289751235,
-0.0122049572,
-0.0316689834,
2.166266193e-34,
0.0359266661,
-0.0194666442,
0.02447032,
0.0250470527,
0.0274871551,
-0.0458613709,
-0.0093030119,
0.0171777848,
0.0029624689,
-0.0619314201,
-0.0677811801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14520v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14520v2 | QUDEVAL: The Evaluation of Questions Under Discussion Discourse Parsing | 2023-10-23T03:03:58 | 2023-11-01T20:30:41 | Yating Wu, Ritika Mangla, Greg Durrett, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Questions Under Discussion (QUD) is a versatile linguistic framework in which
discourse progresses as continuously asking questions and answering them.
Automatic parsing of a discourse to produce a QUD structure thus entails a
complex question generation task: given a document and an answer sentence,
generate a question that satisfies linguistic constraints of QUD and can be
grounded in an anchor sentence in prior context. These questions are known to
be curiosity-driven and open-ended. This work introduces the first framework
for the automatic evaluation of QUD parsing, instantiating the theoretical
constraints of QUD in a concrete protocol. We present QUDeval, a dataset of
fine-grained evaluation of 2,190 QUD questions generated from both fine-tuned
systems and LLMs. Using QUDeval, we show that satisfying all constraints of QUD
is still challenging for modern LLMs, and that existing evaluation metrics
poorly approximate parser quality. Encouragingly, human-authored QUDs are
scored highly by our human evaluators, suggesting that there is headroom for
further progress on language modeling to improve both QUD parsing and QUD
evaluation. | [
0.049000755,
0.043725729,
0.0123712169,
0.0453548804,
-0.0378218852,
0.0089448728,
-0.027355073,
-0.0266551729,
-0.051029291,
-0.0324501321,
-0.0163373146,
0.0024684526,
-0.0287193693,
0.0037296677,
-0.0021746384,
-0.0218460597,
0.0435017608,
-0.0090718539,
0.0165631138,
0.0114533808,
0.0245519113,
-0.0138879605,
-0.0007537632,
0.0148607669,
-0.0282739513,
-0.0208735671,
-0.0372850895,
-0.0033808826,
0.0068514314,
-0.0403891467,
0.031818863,
0.0364266038,
0.0001490969,
0.0246873759,
0.0000017774,
-0.0905672163,
-0.0180245638,
0.0008527443,
-0.0099868448,
-0.0147902416,
0.0455484614,
0.0178944375,
-0.0016314815,
-0.0038421352,
-0.0790741518,
0.0010790984,
-0.0050436733,
0.0458337963,
0.0851470456,
0.0684680566,
-0.0060077836,
-0.0373374559,
0.0231194329,
0.0090061612,
-0.0044240723,
-0.0704126582,
-0.0123108169,
0.0292739943,
0.0398687348,
0.0358802862,
0.0139046293,
0.0202160086,
0.0275462288,
-0.0445012487,
0.0095761623,
0.008386937,
-0.0528088585,
-0.0106933108,
-0.0334840529,
0.0996973142,
0.0424603224,
-0.0179703366,
0.00538442,
0.0096701337,
0.0245073233,
0.0114287753,
-0.0695266947,
0.0295048729,
-0.0087876394,
0.0201180112,
0.0315796621,
0.0206280518,
-0.0039426489,
0.0163423419,
0.0141740702,
0.1027207151,
-0.0054258285,
-0.0512045175,
-0.0227508117,
-0.0008245331,
-0.018931726,
-0.0609497726,
0.0052364971,
0.0583757684,
-0.0384190008,
-0.0043144277,
-0.0188025609,
-0.0134180784,
0.056319721,
-0.0405085757,
0.0120692933,
0.0153710973,
-0.0179380383,
0.045182161,
0.0128001627,
0.0326295868,
0.0055918922,
-0.0495265685,
-0.0548281521,
-0.006443473,
-0.0369232073,
-0.0060894606,
-0.0473430194,
0.0612929501,
-0.0852738842,
-0.0191033613,
-0.0049383668,
0.056990657,
0.0300185215,
0.0216582362,
0.0106112538,
0.0154288197,
-0.033692766,
-0.0004461902,
-0.0211731084,
0.0089233555,
-0.0653666481,
0.0106418394,
0.0329153724,
-0.0279523842,
-0.011590451,
0.0548840836,
0.0159934349,
-0.0207160097,
-0.0261961445,
0.0596774966,
0.0088761579,
-0.0066946577,
0.0115985405,
-0.0508945659,
0.0022484621,
-0.0156379547,
0.006078165,
-0.0510234945,
0.0215023234,
0.0198498461,
-0.0289325546,
-0.003017524,
0.0125420047,
0.0402599797,
0.0333424956,
0.0467498302,
-0.0251573734,
0.0163763147,
0.0569436289,
-0.0019000913,
-0.0260524116,
0.0622003712,
0.0583635569,
-0.0007807637,
0.0531906784,
0.0221676733,
0.0030318191,
0.0135065923,
0.0009791147,
-0.0051602991,
0.0221066326,
0.066162698,
-0.0177237,
0.0393560827,
-0.0102130398,
0.0621002987,
-0.0235145707,
-0.0066785971,
0.0239603724,
0.0716391429,
-0.0196068939,
0.0086287176,
0.0332939625,
0.0127903838,
0.003871555,
0.0314877555,
-0.020062197,
0.0098036174,
-0.0012386109,
0.0019902217,
-0.0068592192,
-0.0099322023,
-0.0031657284,
-0.0680999905,
0.0061922492,
0.0133824842,
0.0240148343,
-0.0265648253,
-0.0033432124,
0.0342784114,
-0.0099427719,
0.0600789748,
0.0019736497,
-0.0665052831,
0.0144165726,
-0.0410216339,
0.0503186174,
0.0154762529,
0.0634529814,
-0.0217456315,
-0.0552241355,
-0.0289102253,
0.0732415169,
0.0621480085,
0.0468609072,
-0.0396383367,
-0.0031220049,
-0.0316566154,
-0.0037031746,
-0.0511873178,
0.0071136397,
-0.0066766688,
-0.0220097676,
-0.0337535255,
0.0196341295,
-0.0624307394,
-0.0176353175,
0.0392183773,
-0.0262876432,
-0.0150594069,
0.0099017564,
-0.0220508222,
0.0077233864,
0.0192779768,
0.0135129066,
0.0426412523,
0.03389531,
-0.0449883118,
-0.0007292324,
0.0467003696,
-0.0227968879,
-0.0385522582,
0.0291085467,
-0.0620565861,
-0.0094243074,
-0.0100117782,
-0.0287179761,
-0.0627024025,
0.0163269565,
-0.0364739373,
0.0220725164,
-0.0713589489,
-0.0308285374,
0.0135746123,
-0.0289043467,
-0.0758158192,
0.0623761117,
0.0048005064,
0.0235074144,
0.0335114151,
-0.0146978023,
0.0452774838,
-0.0259033833,
-0.0188785903,
-0.0120275393,
-0.0199849084,
0.0067450637,
0.0393660367,
0.0494441316,
-0.0620002784,
-0.0367129408,
-0.0998845175,
0.0472792052,
-0.0413271263,
0.0813096762,
0.0387137756,
-0.0015130602,
0.0049726195,
-0.0180711336,
-0.0733233467,
-0.0307963379,
0.0198818557,
-0.0147163775,
0.0968867242,
0.0241853893,
0.0355872996,
-0.0438907072,
0.0159874689,
-0.0123288091,
0.025590783,
0.0437188707,
0.0383656994,
-0.0482348241,
0.0001308329,
-0.0303914715,
-0.0185522363,
0.0061094002,
-0.0187406447,
0.0458312668,
0.0069752079,
0.0220189523,
0.0467320234,
0.0066117728,
0.0174652729,
-0.0150714302,
-0.0089574028,
-0.058223594,
0.0316778943,
-0.0249455832,
0.0320221372,
-0.0311750118,
0.0080531295,
0.0333200991,
0.0691213831,
-0.0142836832,
0.0096765198,
-0.0280553699,
0.0729838312,
-0.0326380618,
-0.0105428379,
-0.0279608779,
-0.0052708518,
-0.0231586955,
0.0690079257,
-0.0260493942,
-0.0292441547,
0.0662516654,
-0.0244498607,
-0.0379303768,
-0.0687904507,
0.0126692196,
-0.0504727624,
0.0547958948,
-0.0416692458,
-0.0013313008,
-0.0125479586,
-0.0436796285,
-0.0493767262,
-0.0033670496,
0.0319274552,
-0.0344162136,
0.0302385055,
-0.0467120633,
0.0084543349,
-0.0165962912,
-0.039052166,
-0.0467874259,
-0.0439761095,
0.0097330911,
0.0111123957,
-0.0377202369,
0.0253614467,
0.0231145117,
0.0017228584,
-0.0366744921,
0.0023648862,
-0.0411010012,
-0.007628114,
-0.0456409678,
0.0825332552,
0.0485178865,
0.0329576321,
0.0381471626,
0.00210443,
0.0486820154,
0.0653431267,
-0.0169440117,
0.0415693969,
-0.0040547461,
0.000685556,
-0.0058137588,
-0.0316131637,
-0.0194547959,
-0.0101187006,
0.1050677225,
-0.0598123297,
-0.0558222719,
0.1358810812,
0.065951772,
0.0033546309,
0.0007444164,
-0.0547493473,
0.0319710001,
0.0185867567,
0.0338347964,
-0.0793171301,
-0.0101707056,
-0.0090628369,
0.0231201444,
-0.0085621886,
-0.0331334658,
0.0083877379,
-0.0896767229,
0.0157394614,
-0.013887166,
0.0036347669,
0.0554655939,
-0.0105522787,
0.0103489328,
0.0209538918,
0.0392698646,
0.0289201736,
0.0117187658,
0.0061104642,
0.019643046,
-0.0130206784,
-0.0301029067,
0.0150253568,
-0.0196447782,
0.020991182,
0.0724749491,
0.0527918525,
0.0005135214,
-0.0498196594,
0.0592555739,
-0.04908498,
-0.0134414416,
0.0028686835,
-0.036323417,
0.0055571054,
0.0006110662,
-0.0421694741,
0.0565894283,
-0.0464502051,
0.0021886509,
0.0331768543,
0.0442660823,
-0.0585903972,
0.012387529,
-0.0209550317,
0.0073809861,
-0.0012550062,
0.0859436989,
0.0663557872,
-0.013926439,
-0.0483056754,
-0.0660369545,
0.0132506024,
-0.0890023336,
0.0308927335,
0.0056296461,
0.0505848192,
0.0283320751,
-0.1286227107,
-0.0610240959,
0.0058743167,
-0.0130530754,
-0.0140235331,
-0.0080857547,
0.019678792,
-0.0153213097,
-0.0320928581,
0.027582068,
0.0147395413,
-0.0141546251,
-0.052924525,
0.0241227169,
0.0529156365,
-0.0248515662,
-0.0333478451,
0.0026812211,
-0.0720797181,
-0.070053108,
-0.0333300643,
0.0373316258,
0.022450896,
0.0312837437,
-0.0480500422,
-0.0275121294,
-0.0217451882,
0.0229481272,
-0.0200586002,
-0.0114699155,
0.0304593407,
0.0361776352,
-0.0098017175,
0.0387576297,
-0.0131692095,
0.0156201338,
-0.0288700797,
0.0495705158,
-0.0352210775,
-0.0658221021,
0.0265117232,
0.0169323292,
0.0136747034,
-8.892e-7,
0.0060758148,
-0.008952491,
0.0148245785,
-0.060677655,
-0.0338578895,
-0.0659633949,
0.0081695626,
-0.0145273246,
-0.0275001749,
0.008343122,
-0.0052080411,
-0.0601500794,
0.0713808164,
-0.0468052663,
0.044133164,
0.0181546453,
-0.01085121,
-0.0022394885,
-0.0178121421,
-0.0054188222,
0.0069277291,
-0.0299237855,
0.0601833537,
-0.0024899673,
0.0489824116,
0.023056725,
-0.0006185389,
0.038303744,
0.0432805382,
-0.068334341,
-0.0125830173,
0.0207873806,
0.0273226909,
0.0160758998,
0.0483666696,
0.036046695,
0.0020950618,
-0.00931386,
0.0170063302,
0.0638812855,
0.0058907131,
-0.0322605968,
0.0547291599,
0.0259680972,
-0.0312953368,
-0.0153823821,
0.0459213741,
-0.0316223241,
0.0041460237,
0.0216490738,
0.0234166849,
-0.0771316513,
-0.037787471,
-0.0215850547,
0.0315573327,
-0.0044157766,
0.0370224789,
-0.0408447906,
-0.021365393,
0.0065286625,
0.0396988243,
-0.008257214,
-0.0172693897,
0.0323697068,
0.0590438843,
-0.0085874638,
-0.023619663,
-0.0475392118,
-0.0067679482,
-0.0171873327,
-0.0383995511,
-0.0482161678,
-6.023283747e-33,
-0.018075889,
-0.0282010846,
0.050285399,
0.0048487,
-0.0329282545,
-0.0207050052,
-0.0605843812,
0.0088590765,
0.0046118209,
0.0150608728,
-0.0180762988,
-0.0049720546,
-0.0043743155,
0.0419095047,
-0.001540838,
-0.0600814819,
0.018759694,
-0.0254190285,
-0.0351413265,
0.0262741726,
0.0204009488,
0.0088179857,
0.0082376776,
0.0228614956,
0.0488095433,
-0.0403438173,
-0.0155850677,
0.0619172864,
-0.0047615692,
0.0549646094,
-0.0247861464,
-0.0027979459,
0.0415585749,
0.0114453482,
-0.0152932024,
0.052661214,
-0.0559953973,
-0.0556150526,
0.0243145823,
-0.0127684129,
-0.0549078658,
-0.0237467494,
0.0459893718,
-0.0114376219,
0.0171259753,
0.0335465409,
0.0125873601,
-0.0070909439,
0.0036203745,
-0.0409972966,
-0.0254080724,
0.0267620459,
-0.0171626993,
-0.037546169,
-0.0023330159,
0.0413797796,
-0.0039169337,
0.0015298721,
-0.017826315,
0.0089169573,
-0.0451892428,
0.0091179227,
0.0250145812,
-0.0263332762,
0.0015992434,
0.0394985266,
-0.0280844979,
0.0138939498,
0.0104886219,
0.0274174735,
-0.007155342,
0.0511078089,
0.0245997366,
0.0358318798,
-0.0227132291,
0.0251818765,
-0.0502996109,
0.0525987297,
0.0115500279,
0.0197034217,
-0.020480765,
-0.0159968659,
-0.0170315523,
0.0003963589,
-0.0422923751,
0.035869386,
-0.0173125248,
-0.0116465278,
0.0320281722,
-0.0346988961,
-0.034690477,
-0.0381844603,
0.0285023451,
-0.0460428819,
0.0125455307,
-0.0087605482,
-0.0184709877,
0.0296319816,
0.0116513986,
0.0405776128,
-0.0134020234,
0.0077601457,
0.0013908617,
0.025009701,
0.0284858532,
0.0157102533,
0.017944349,
-0.0202710405,
-0.0284010544,
0.0112308897,
-0.0386944264,
0.0644227862,
-0.0528625213,
0.0579356179,
-0.002786404,
0.0286094956,
-0.0110915899,
0.0276014283,
-0.0016279828,
0.005036972,
-0.0722158775,
-0.0072224792,
-0.0190690309,
0.0411969535,
-0.0354365222,
0.0190193821,
-0.0095111253,
0.0441589616,
0.0097600427,
-0.0367294513,
0.0056455052,
0.027543908,
2.492e-7,
0.0660109445,
0.0600728169,
0.0359608643,
0.0225899164,
0.0332509801,
0.0033075782,
-0.0084713846,
0.0482255109,
0.0053460193,
-0.056183517,
-0.0062887357,
0.0003882087,
0.0385699086,
0.0306411162,
-0.145878464,
-0.033545088,
-0.0695059747,
-0.0071702371,
-0.0334677771,
-0.0179326721,
0.0790677369,
0.0273684971,
-0.0524784923,
0.0063265576,
-0.0425142683,
-0.0356224403,
0.0433627777,
-0.0092833135,
-0.0272824652,
0.0508962534,
0.0125891035,
0.0006971144,
0.0172082353,
0.0000692929,
-0.0131584387,
0.0302041732,
-0.01461046,
0.0674964115,
0.0212018695,
-0.0690610334,
-0.0159746036,
-0.0369398892,
0.0291930437,
-0.0553838722,
0.0595431067,
-0.0349979848,
-0.0146110337,
-0.0356206037,
-0.0217037089,
-0.0198252369,
-0.0259947535,
-0.0312542394,
-0.0179142263,
0.0159798339,
0.016633803,
-0.0296683013,
0.0320921578,
-0.036379382,
-0.0254767966,
-0.00509331,
-0.0205983482,
-0.0436614342,
-0.0314235948,
-0.010986302,
-0.0220230669,
-0.0456566587,
-0.0117147127,
1.975362466e-34,
0.067828849,
-0.018771125,
0.0213987846,
0.0327478386,
0.0387690887,
0.0164025798,
-0.025105767,
0.005746746,
0.0182368886,
-0.0828596652,
0.0147198541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14513v1 | Turn-Level Active Learning for Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-10-23T02:53:46 | 2023-10-23T02:53:46 | Zihan Zhang, Meng Fang, Fanghua Ye, Ling Chen, Mohammad-Reza Namazi-Rad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue state tracking (DST) plays an important role in task-oriented
dialogue systems. However, collecting a large amount of turn-by-turn annotated
dialogue data is costly and inefficient. In this paper, we propose a novel
turn-level active learning framework for DST to actively select turns in
dialogues to annotate. Given the limited labelling budget, experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of selective annotation of dialogue turns.
Additionally, our approach can effectively achieve comparable DST performance
to traditional training approaches with significantly less annotated data,
which provides a more efficient way to annotate new dialogue data. | [
0.0078034322,
-0.0066811075,
0.0081414813,
0.0186171867,
0.005416011,
0.0450288542,
-0.0161363073,
-0.0080521293,
0.02189794,
-0.0552493669,
-0.0122773806,
-0.0274962597,
-0.0187238138,
0.0534737557,
0.026672909,
-0.0752474219,
0.0610670298,
-0.024919631,
0.0305064414,
0.0118297059,
0.0278067626,
-0.0104748756,
-0.0931414068,
0.0697097406,
-0.0470069051,
-0.0151887117,
-0.0356418304,
-0.0105905998,
0.0108245919,
-0.0078063137,
0.0134215457,
0.0248805974,
0.0446878485,
0.0167764947,
0.0000015851,
-0.0069021694,
-0.0100308312,
-0.0268122181,
-0.0435329489,
-0.0149927391,
-0.0464938246,
0.0206066258,
0.0076822825,
0.0074732485,
-0.028370725,
-0.0393781587,
0.0472737849,
0.0648058876,
0.0804483816,
0.0487429835,
-0.0113027235,
-0.0013035627,
0.0123325242,
-0.0084435372,
0.0137009881,
-0.1112399548,
0.001277841,
0.0240863562,
-0.0268114135,
0.0099673495,
0.0046568154,
0.0473553948,
-0.0042016809,
-0.0746859312,
-0.0303762592,
0.0122922733,
-0.0393705927,
0.0070519368,
0.0031737222,
0.0887199342,
0.0348417722,
0.0393597558,
0.025631154,
-0.043226175,
-0.0053381948,
-0.0287002102,
-0.0332388654,
-0.0404119678,
-0.0320379026,
0.0094356257,
-0.0506577231,
-0.0136914374,
-0.0180813223,
-0.0230506435,
0.0116448561,
0.0228073262,
-0.0190664232,
-0.0420584306,
0.0065744543,
0.0220851377,
-0.0099901641,
-0.0277687982,
0.0347435325,
0.0187358744,
-0.0522410795,
0.0103059076,
-0.0298994202,
0.0465668291,
-0.0302848238,
-0.0444673039,
-0.0113660619,
0.0010990214,
-0.0070374869,
0.064615339,
0.0620521493,
0.0206472278,
-0.0072537889,
-0.0051533044,
-0.0129614836,
-0.0252193287,
-0.0565883704,
0.0245711729,
-0.0745066181,
-0.0001802263,
-0.0097113419,
-0.0369650908,
-0.0193003174,
0.0473787859,
-0.0003192011,
0.029628193,
0.024482524,
0.0259489436,
-0.0310628098,
0.0026303974,
0.0279827081,
0.0466073453,
0.0107526863,
0.0044962373,
-0.0093484214,
-0.0228749234,
0.0055220206,
0.0427140966,
0.0325531363,
-0.0259714741,
-0.0420769416,
0.0572622567,
0.0039287102,
-0.037082199,
0.0092174457,
0.0420441441,
-0.0061120158,
-0.0097819502,
-0.0132042095,
0.0051701078,
0.0241297632,
-0.028283352,
0.0279728062,
-0.0044464902,
-0.0002846802,
0.0077282358,
-0.0219869539,
0.0192209966,
0.0011894036,
-0.0013167426,
0.0192182139,
-0.0269409213,
-0.0220332369,
0.0484951921,
0.0527430326,
-0.0029444396,
0.0576657094,
-0.0205176678,
0.0130053591,
0.035728354,
0.0026772267,
-0.0180358887,
0.0425496176,
0.0381207541,
-0.0255335029,
-0.0118585853,
-0.0449048318,
0.0273975898,
-0.042207595,
-0.0042838356,
0.0583523735,
-0.0029115577,
-0.0239354819,
-0.0351833403,
0.0395249128,
0.0456546433,
0.0445185751,
0.0061995215,
-0.0005726029,
0.0104851304,
0.0211389083,
-0.0215763599,
0.0178081896,
-0.0209865961,
-0.048368182,
-0.024816731,
-0.0071764775,
-0.0045926948,
0.0163286272,
-0.003194157,
0.0433399044,
0.0009821291,
-0.0545124747,
0.0352369435,
-0.0003539914,
-0.0329920612,
-0.0191368517,
0.0009367383,
-0.0048950063,
0.0226259027,
0.0116510149,
-0.0392602719,
-0.077953741,
-0.0621780716,
0.0282090604,
0.034620665,
0.0289363191,
-0.0703146607,
0.0528952442,
-0.0603413284,
-0.0135752549,
0.0226303264,
0.0049932706,
-0.0166239087,
-0.0114975711,
-0.0389525481,
-0.01279746,
0.0026082457,
0.0301073138,
0.0149704404,
0.0552992895,
-0.0236044191,
0.0069051492,
0.0134003134,
0.0441655926,
0.0192496888,
-0.0230601411,
-0.0207941569,
0.0278700199,
0.005978215,
-0.0010812141,
0.0522952303,
0.005775596,
-0.0430576988,
0.0022004447,
0.0116549665,
-0.0865686089,
0.0100163072,
-0.0563840307,
-0.0641851947,
-0.061533995,
-0.0815470666,
-0.0178355407,
-0.0204196293,
0.0227828752,
0.0407225117,
0.000971569,
-0.0526735596,
0.0171800926,
-0.0124036698,
0.0007276725,
0.0496721454,
-0.0244068298,
0.0240230244,
-0.0627229884,
0.0055720997,
0.0108488714,
-0.0022750259,
-0.0320748314,
0.0042181667,
-0.0005813723,
-0.0215094499,
0.0068328255,
-0.0510584339,
-0.0268997382,
-0.0298404433,
-0.003684304,
0.0176191218,
-0.0047853077,
0.0015439173,
-0.0198771376,
-0.0246531367,
-0.0064102677,
0.0367731638,
-0.0118989451,
0.0065820939,
0.0301054828,
-0.019502243,
-0.0562584065,
0.0256816242,
0.0052971197,
0.0068878583,
-0.0217773318,
-0.0453162044,
-0.0536316782,
-0.0293747149,
-0.007939863,
0.0713571906,
-0.0100951977,
-0.0114347646,
0.0396735258,
0.0061279158,
0.0011866275,
0.0290495548,
0.0253475364,
0.0383691415,
-0.037506979,
-0.0773834139,
-0.0218564309,
0.0513841324,
-0.0306695458,
0.0314032622,
-0.063729316,
-0.0073973611,
0.0084688626,
0.0169855878,
-0.0029633846,
0.0432976,
-0.0542495139,
-0.0491331145,
-0.0117937215,
-0.0273795668,
-0.0077715828,
0.0457386933,
-0.0579604842,
-0.0060467874,
-0.0084216176,
-0.0028126915,
0.0175559204,
-0.0349915847,
-0.0598155037,
-0.0207128432,
-0.0108880615,
0.0089215674,
0.0301936977,
0.0144305993,
-0.0020356756,
-0.004684661,
-0.0307215676,
0.0060752765,
-0.0238896906,
0.019580394,
-0.0281098392,
0.0583970807,
-0.0287983268,
0.0291500445,
-0.0040235948,
-0.0099357972,
-0.0484380983,
-0.0182851981,
-0.0015443019,
0.0274881851,
0.0442167222,
-0.0546818078,
0.0069961464,
0.0606669784,
-0.0025782804,
0.0571695566,
0.0148286894,
0.0199326985,
-0.035006959,
0.0373156145,
0.0552604645,
-0.0103909485,
-0.0378846936,
-0.0286891274,
0.046476867,
0.0377033763,
0.0309305862,
-0.0266071763,
0.011531624,
-0.0275740493,
0.049924884,
-0.0343728513,
-0.0268441252,
0.0026615045,
0.0503313057,
-0.0066162478,
-0.0369374231,
0.1073249504,
0.0184730981,
-0.0675983131,
-0.0228057262,
0.0224720296,
-0.0211634096,
0.0153675238,
0.0174304508,
-0.0269846581,
-0.0208632927,
-0.0110040475,
0.0471330173,
0.0268677622,
-0.0503353179,
-0.0189079456,
-0.0467867926,
0.0324483514,
-0.0208843648,
-0.0539255254,
-0.0384724103,
-0.0041758143,
0.0448127203,
-0.0230513122,
0.0330096595,
-0.0213564355,
0.0247949157,
-0.0304547027,
0.0730465427,
-0.0427662171,
0.0025578064,
-0.0080277473,
0.0274786204,
0.0523385853,
0.030383192,
0.0771372467,
0.0236466695,
0.0076063331,
0.0512457266,
-0.0195728764,
-0.0132503305,
-0.0064698248,
0.0382829793,
-0.0254614521,
-0.0394575,
-0.0092245871,
-0.0043456531,
0.0303976275,
-0.0128294807,
0.01620977,
0.0113380384,
-0.0870535001,
0.0646255612,
0.0167416278,
0.0288283415,
0.0357732326,
0.0248204395,
0.0107896477,
-0.0454185121,
0.0101293167,
0.0119406851,
-0.0078499233,
-0.0333516523,
-0.0077561443,
-0.0309953913,
-0.0281175338,
0.0059532225,
-0.0776493922,
-0.0326419882,
0.0624250211,
0.070381619,
-0.0177189019,
0.0079182703,
0.039466504,
-0.0026618633,
0.0342325605,
-0.02186656,
-0.0349885263,
0.0219546463,
-0.0378106087,
-0.0961198807,
0.0297005493,
0.0171967335,
0.0087082814,
0.0255832151,
-0.0380019657,
-0.0452134311,
0.0451632775,
0.0612448007,
0.0168471187,
0.0463357531,
0.0017202219,
-0.0069932058,
-0.0830288753,
-0.0348000601,
0.0234223362,
-0.014752564,
0.0736400411,
0.057780128,
-0.0340068452,
0.034569554,
-0.0360514857,
0.0195840411,
0.0161662158,
0.0372688062,
-0.1010481864,
-0.0929033533,
-0.0106705166,
-0.0491399653,
0.0996782705,
0.0365697779,
-0.0033690366,
0.0053035095,
0.0593353249,
-0.0102633145,
-0.0283408687,
-0.0757976919,
0.0231755693,
-0.0509568267,
-0.0015732029,
-0.018582873,
0.0476253219,
0.0018550925,
0.0437825918,
-0.0613417216,
-0.0021068093,
0.0290677324,
-0.0260365363,
-0.0298194047,
-0.0043229526,
0.0010682773,
0.0435124375,
0.0457682535,
0.0250839144,
0.0601509809,
0.127753213,
0.006187568,
0.0106478846,
0.0163761172,
0.0494145937,
-0.0761005729,
-0.0352265425,
-0.0268369783,
0.0654650703,
0.0503716506,
-0.0205598958,
0.0720321015,
0.0026231438,
-0.0016313627,
0.0027826852,
0.0664308742,
0.0259968657,
-0.0411041826,
0.0230201259,
0.0145108802,
-0.0056986799,
0.0315310769,
0.0666380301,
0.0071284855,
0.0433528796,
-0.0082926434,
0.0158089362,
-0.0532249063,
-0.0283810738,
0.0087350179,
0.008079771,
0.0071010967,
0.0300540533,
0.0100916689,
-0.0207166262,
-0.0144804548,
-0.0339116603,
0.0037639332,
-0.0030144779,
0.0536084175,
-0.0098344125,
0.0138075352,
-0.0135911806,
-0.0441069752,
-0.0112171471,
0.0419426821,
0.0221877079,
-0.0321050957,
-5.091272112e-33,
-0.0580922998,
-0.0234724861,
0.0040680156,
0.0512672998,
-0.0424834341,
0.0062094494,
-0.0518146083,
-0.0067480658,
-0.0090409946,
0.0192710347,
0.0080335066,
0.0308630336,
0.029771762,
0.0165055282,
-0.0273699127,
-0.0523141362,
0.0516580157,
0.0150095802,
-0.016268285,
0.0522118546,
0.0525487661,
0.0104680127,
0.0453998931,
-0.1200923547,
0.0285777412,
-0.0349564888,
-0.0189761911,
0.038437251,
0.0027115059,
0.0083628558,
0.0227016117,
-0.0202850588,
-0.0081108622,
-0.0682877749,
-0.0108644366,
-0.0066889361,
-0.0092431633,
0.0400884524,
-0.0031541446,
0.0702399537,
-0.0058036754,
0.0569311492,
-0.057387922,
-0.0198131949,
0.0437381305,
0.0473771058,
0.0273373406,
-0.0051143882,
-0.0535684898,
-0.0284401067,
-0.0264199506,
0.0236368813,
-0.0658526272,
-0.0529861189,
-0.0031271589,
0.0645432249,
0.0342931189,
-0.0964044333,
-0.0217116997,
-0.0066235769,
-0.0474195816,
-0.0100825233,
-0.0133486548,
0.0117400093,
0.0129726352,
0.0567930453,
0.03675602,
0.0022056601,
-0.0091423132,
0.0027974304,
-0.0573254786,
0.0234586839,
0.0222855583,
-0.0152758043,
-0.0763991326,
0.0136608584,
-0.0135951666,
-0.0036031657,
0.0815160945,
0.0219245218,
-0.0188458934,
0.0136309508,
-0.0304089133,
0.0053454922,
0.0223991163,
0.0197028723,
0.0395630039,
-0.015168584,
0.011493206,
0.0170718003,
-0.0427961089,
0.0154795656,
0.0787443146,
0.006386783,
-0.0068196976,
0.0178576279,
0.0042363792,
0.0088225817,
-0.0514215045,
-0.0381914452,
-0.0498218276,
-0.0853487328,
0.0455367975,
0.000802543,
0.0281320009,
0.0022812367,
-0.0057259626,
0.03107474,
-0.0385076255,
0.0023295078,
-0.0240726396,
0.0430250242,
-0.0558903217,
0.0801320449,
0.0368578359,
-0.0327301398,
-0.0310795493,
0.1125724241,
-0.0025967585,
-0.0212392118,
-0.0121707674,
-0.0576852188,
0.0144585911,
0.0046939254,
-0.038722679,
-0.0246322341,
0.010931002,
-0.0099280896,
-0.0267212037,
-0.0324911177,
0.016398998,
0.0104801273,
2.258e-7,
0.0113706011,
0.0272601265,
0.0278479084,
0.0030183045,
0.0408364348,
0.0441215523,
-0.0332971476,
-0.0335909314,
0.057736326,
0.0243973862,
0.0305091776,
-0.0120128673,
0.0453528278,
0.0232116953,
-0.1054888591,
-0.0883165672,
-0.08170145,
-0.0101205362,
-0.0040139952,
0.0308227688,
0.0135447849,
0.0559943989,
0.0232900977,
0.0164273027,
0.0150043219,
-0.0035480091,
0.02286309,
-0.0086508794,
0.0231568869,
-0.0028867808,
0.0135640549,
-0.0352042802,
-0.0337327607,
0.0307617132,
-0.0084051704,
0.0160006545,
0.0267243944,
0.0882023275,
-0.0023545099,
-0.0526154712,
-0.0246107019,
0.0176590662,
0.0301294066,
0.0183902029,
0.0492189452,
-0.0361285917,
-0.0228189975,
-0.0137528935,
-0.0201480351,
0.0014086381,
-0.0057210056,
0.0615818091,
-0.0008644182,
0.0283243787,
-0.0182028096,
0.0064202058,
-0.0163988899,
-0.1023634225,
-0.0019790006,
-0.0553069115,
-0.0406868681,
-0.0291522369,
0.0264564808,
0.0077809463,
-0.0353093408,
0.0179780088,
-0.0295298081,
1.483452634e-34,
0.0350248367,
0.0012803462,
0.0134950047,
0.0657924712,
-0.0077377325,
-0.005230641,
0.0305249467,
-0.0019986774,
0.0271378681,
-0.0429783463,
-0.0100319991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14512v2 | CorefPrompt: Prompt-based Event Coreference Resolution by Measuring Event Type and Argument Compatibilities | 2023-10-23T02:47:27 | 2023-10-24T02:45:55 | Sheng Xu, Peifeng Li, Qiaoming Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Event coreference resolution (ECR) aims to group event mentions referring to
the same real-world event into clusters. Most previous studies adopt the
"encoding first, then scoring" framework, making the coreference judgment rely
on event encoding. Furthermore, current methods struggle to leverage
human-summarized ECR rules, e.g., coreferential events should have the same
event type, to guide the model. To address these two issues, we propose a
prompt-based approach, CorefPrompt, to transform ECR into a cloze-style MLM
(masked language model) task. This allows for simultaneous event modeling and
coreference discrimination within a single template, with a fully shared
context. In addition, we introduce two auxiliary prompt tasks, event-type
compatibility and argument compatibility, to explicitly demonstrate the
reasoning process of ECR, which helps the model make final predictions.
Experimental results show that our method CorefPrompt performs well in a
state-of-the-art (SOTA) benchmark. | [
0.0370602868,
-0.0247770399,
0.0005533095,
0.0398749039,
-0.0300033148,
-0.0114949876,
-0.0020239914,
-0.0064635356,
0.0753716007,
-0.0465639718,
-0.0395864658,
0.0125202145,
-0.0146890692,
0.0542426743,
-0.0039770477,
-0.0574943945,
0.0798781812,
-0.0066002943,
0.0209699795,
0.0061608846,
0.0249175262,
0.0160173681,
-0.021652922,
0.0396652892,
0.00449496,
-0.0137151852,
-0.0008571406,
-0.0010680727,
0.0152563294,
-0.0099729039,
0.0127831539,
0.0443625599,
0.0160131902,
0.0581212714,
0.0000019457,
-0.061467763,
0.0041501564,
-0.0369902179,
-0.0314198136,
0.0150087792,
-0.0270600021,
0.0241222251,
0.020719232,
-0.0031963466,
-0.0149672404,
-0.0441376157,
0.0253657438,
0.0486078784,
0.0270511601,
0.0408410542,
-0.0117940214,
0.0226895586,
-0.0108110448,
-0.0360792987,
-0.0781402886,
-0.0460721031,
0.0090694102,
-0.0228449907,
0.0319021009,
-0.0032899464,
0.0267592128,
0.0196431801,
0.0159719698,
0.021099586,
0.03069387,
0.0434501842,
-0.0478249118,
-0.0118505703,
-0.0175018273,
0.0681653097,
0.0127750151,
-0.0047141365,
0.0404189564,
0.0037376359,
-0.0183368623,
-0.0241254102,
-0.0438852198,
-0.0125554604,
-0.0353797711,
0.0059507154,
0.027832197,
0.0543949902,
-0.0099567547,
0.0084512001,
0.0071047926,
0.0974345207,
0.029116381,
0.0201223809,
0.0034970168,
-0.0143227782,
-0.0417124219,
-0.0821678564,
0.0829967409,
0.026415864,
-0.0610577241,
0.0169312842,
-0.0562980548,
0.0799361393,
0.0178238451,
-0.043209441,
-0.0003165225,
0.0429786369,
-0.011231483,
0.0529001392,
-0.0302585475,
0.0447557122,
0.0028350581,
0.0116047105,
-0.0041382713,
-0.019585168,
-0.0257013924,
0.0436602086,
-0.0494634621,
0.0377064086,
-0.0943070725,
-0.0328869261,
-0.0206044763,
0.0069333944,
-0.0026345719,
0.011283421,
-0.0078426823,
0.0003539272,
-0.0260647517,
0.0018356191,
-0.0273787789,
-0.0088759148,
-0.0417537391,
-0.0019114704,
-0.0417707264,
-0.0466529503,
-0.0183911175,
0.0102125229,
-0.0029088701,
-0.0374458805,
-0.0167655554,
0.0347147323,
-0.0285852384,
0.0018831487,
-0.013948692,
-0.0710527971,
-0.0427517295,
0.0081918249,
-0.0543954782,
-0.0850186497,
0.0342676565,
-0.0140490448,
0.0021227682,
-0.0721522719,
0.02055596,
-0.0046480442,
-0.0455478579,
0.0375822112,
-0.014194753,
0.0042675752,
0.0548174009,
0.0200155955,
0.0062838751,
0.0204712879,
0.0142049016,
0.0186733808,
0.0338075608,
0.0135778887,
-0.000985124,
0.0429923348,
0.0313578695,
-0.011878903,
0.0375532247,
-0.0008729943,
-0.0187198743,
0.0051745228,
0.0703628063,
0.0259773936,
-0.0152389398,
-0.0716396198,
0.0161013957,
0.0361504108,
-0.0712056831,
-0.0511898398,
-0.0009419968,
-0.0067189271,
-0.0104435515,
0.0706115887,
-0.0352095179,
-0.0055413037,
-0.0269363299,
-0.0226637237,
0.0643911213,
0.0102190208,
-0.0509602502,
0.0191876665,
-0.0271306429,
0.028388815,
-0.0065691415,
-0.0242689233,
0.0032071148,
-0.0003573455,
-0.0327200405,
0.06804654,
0.0049774186,
-0.0296978801,
-0.0037924096,
-0.0265109781,
0.0008026478,
0.0133774104,
0.0431022085,
-0.0183572602,
-0.0681119263,
0.0134578114,
0.0199366938,
0.0483670197,
0.0334564708,
-0.0365188569,
0.0592863485,
-0.0372225456,
0.0010249781,
0.0242209826,
0.0052650655,
0.0107820053,
0.0319981501,
-0.0327819102,
0.0074028843,
0.018584447,
-0.0044153831,
0.0213383306,
-0.0061528911,
-0.0299427081,
-0.0147492476,
0.0106287189,
0.0328205153,
-0.0010936535,
0.0165104475,
-0.0017637897,
0.0200921614,
-0.0330654792,
-0.0153528228,
0.0568302833,
-0.0614,
-0.058536876,
0.0276888981,
-0.0126682362,
-0.0395489298,
-0.0095521593,
-0.0288183838,
-0.0574970357,
-0.0123038199,
-0.0048468793,
0.0457544923,
-0.0174765065,
0.0300813783,
0.0098356772,
-0.0157564245,
-0.0434326306,
0.04165354,
0.001943754,
0.0101031624,
0.0392014682,
0.0245858897,
0.0270847883,
-0.0814213678,
-0.0169471242,
0.0105001302,
0.0022262554,
-0.0315832533,
0.0340024717,
-0.0104925316,
-0.0630534291,
0.0038997871,
-0.0822882354,
0.0273976084,
-0.0015205737,
0.0278426204,
0.0493654646,
0.0159023199,
-0.0139631322,
-0.0226729997,
-0.0026535681,
-0.0600947104,
0.0121068954,
0.0272341222,
0.0203900356,
0.0055431039,
-0.0046512475,
-0.0750065669,
0.0098338854,
-0.0563103743,
0.0406509861,
-0.0167023819,
-0.047892496,
-0.0398029052,
0.0531010367,
0.0051828665,
0.0295534413,
0.0049660187,
0.0181438252,
-0.0015325041,
0.0140978927,
0.0536289364,
0.0438723788,
-0.0276683979,
0.0004576009,
0.0201493055,
-0.0854253396,
-0.0959015191,
0.0111699626,
-0.0066090152,
-0.0375216715,
-0.00390543,
-0.0217931364,
0.0289455317,
0.0680744648,
0.0185632221,
0.0275457129,
-0.0687624887,
-0.0141294049,
-0.0138891703,
-0.0280339532,
-0.0223745294,
-0.06603387,
-0.026405707,
0.040460404,
-0.0626448616,
-0.0083082393,
0.0774078146,
-0.0475134179,
-0.0043992037,
-0.0235338751,
0.0037941188,
-0.0526542626,
0.0663743615,
-0.0055843978,
0.0086124921,
0.072382234,
-0.0987171754,
-0.0330978222,
-0.0028759565,
-0.0180813745,
-0.0019645109,
0.0523476414,
-0.0774461702,
0.0016926273,
-0.0014227928,
-0.0084433863,
-0.054708384,
-0.0115739303,
-0.0308776181,
-0.0059722876,
-0.0204171669,
0.0359545052,
-0.0279552676,
0.0269872807,
0.0009236542,
0.0510310903,
0.0013708025,
0.011244596,
-0.0319803655,
0.0594377518,
0.0227275304,
0.0234139767,
-0.0032781172,
0.0002177895,
-0.0096643688,
0.0660301447,
0.0621687509,
0.0072154659,
-0.0232680943,
0.0143216969,
0.0469029732,
-0.0576011986,
-0.036813885,
-0.0011894365,
0.0806261599,
-0.0488279127,
-0.0100869955,
0.1309682876,
0.0527191684,
-0.034664508,
-0.0137508018,
-0.0178198162,
0.0287537258,
0.0153690018,
-0.0019286245,
-0.0178668331,
-0.0604647733,
0.0135200545,
-0.0205789395,
-0.0291648079,
-0.0524692461,
-0.0082076294,
-0.0763841867,
-0.0004946297,
0.0079163397,
-0.0333165638,
-0.0458648056,
-0.0496891327,
0.0724129081,
-0.0066627208,
-0.0136845876,
0.0258361921,
0.0072887004,
0.0125618484,
-0.0073848558,
-0.0678678602,
-0.0078752721,
0.0604860298,
-0.0428999588,
0.0510485545,
0.0287931934,
0.0408016108,
0.0362791531,
0.0234608036,
-0.0006356231,
-0.0539863631,
0.001468205,
-0.0526635833,
0.0054706512,
0.0003340102,
0.0106737008,
0.0107381493,
0.0606706031,
0.0049859537,
-0.0428293049,
0.0168330502,
0.0500278771,
-0.0031024886,
0.0200886577,
-0.0186235607,
0.0214883573,
0.0152543802,
0.0809704214,
0.0471058451,
0.0369096808,
0.0073604118,
0.0092524765,
0.0241604093,
-0.0174825806,
-0.0080472492,
-0.0202081073,
-0.0328563303,
0.0048279655,
-0.0738628656,
-0.0290743578,
0.0366319381,
0.025075404,
0.0050835554,
-0.0254420582,
0.0118426867,
0.0176447574,
-0.0314080492,
0.0381788835,
-0.0564659573,
0.0171106681,
-0.0764258206,
0.02934351,
0.035648331,
0.0585600697,
-0.03087347,
0.1687420309,
-0.0352612026,
-0.0442797095,
-0.0163475368,
-0.030040523,
0.0257701781,
0.0421754494,
-0.0300282668,
-0.0326511301,
-0.0007058823,
0.0018456499,
-0.032423906,
0.03362092,
0.0267736576,
0.0000513504,
-0.0159270298,
0.0341124125,
-0.0311537106,
0.0476933159,
-0.0186805595,
0.0512992255,
-0.0576103628,
-0.1027326211,
-0.007776516,
0.0192031413,
0.0429828539,
0.0090308264,
0.0140423179,
-0.0276479181,
0.0109853027,
0.0114344005,
0.0078357765,
-0.0035238911,
0.0140975984,
-0.0392617211,
0.0241811443,
0.002367605,
0.0133699514,
-0.0595527589,
0.0434434973,
-0.0279010907,
-0.0561314374,
0.0408174321,
0.0249425862,
-0.0112565439,
-0.0094348621,
-0.0409478731,
0.0303871855,
0.0033178648,
0.0270619299,
-0.0551450923,
0.0347088575,
0.0024772489,
-0.0160915125,
-0.0090398742,
0.0055638915,
-0.0796239525,
0.0367647782,
-0.0173664354,
-0.021184409,
0.0631646886,
-0.0274009127,
0.0740323812,
-0.0032620071,
-0.0119302375,
-0.0000808497,
0.0057037044,
-0.0171057377,
0.0142081352,
0.0056457594,
0.0296285935,
-0.0133180656,
0.0094034094,
0.0360572599,
-0.0214404333,
0.0244005919,
0.0208037905,
-0.0085575953,
-0.0300352499,
-0.0420237593,
-0.001387437,
0.0365322568,
-0.0167742427,
-0.0238065179,
-0.0824037939,
0.0075027687,
0.091817379,
0.0050111045,
-0.0035068656,
-0.0035043762,
0.0338669829,
0.0307813212,
0.0215143543,
-0.0218279846,
0.0026953407,
0.0408862345,
0.0510950685,
-0.0322178639,
-0.0691871569,
-6.394852368e-33,
-0.0802303925,
-0.0362775363,
0.002680012,
0.0337779,
0.017877819,
0.0333479196,
-0.0644763038,
0.0001312561,
0.0103028938,
-0.0101747075,
-0.016699899,
-0.0127514368,
0.0247053076,
-0.0325020999,
-0.0057722535,
0.0035886206,
0.0684279799,
0.0255952887,
-0.0276315697,
0.0355691575,
0.0534320101,
0.0232073292,
0.0362162925,
-0.0849680975,
0.0327337757,
0.0393393673,
0.0013587096,
0.0057507865,
0.0521141775,
0.0499592349,
-0.0166722126,
0.0383342542,
0.0043879249,
-0.0512990505,
-0.0337423086,
0.0249390304,
-0.0909954458,
-0.0451178178,
0.0660023987,
-0.0147962458,
0.0185593776,
-0.0395929664,
0.0260997117,
-0.0093334774,
-0.002917723,
-0.0104184356,
0.034027297,
-0.011145019,
-0.0178649854,
0.0001662911,
-0.0424688831,
0.0338714123,
0.0018032726,
-0.0114854444,
0.0184857268,
0.0302734207,
0.0218941029,
0.0218720734,
-0.0627710596,
0.0315985754,
-0.0424877442,
0.0201132167,
0.0344121605,
-0.0046732374,
-0.0092825303,
0.058031559,
-0.0084302239,
-0.0309568848,
-0.0284005105,
0.0504660793,
0.0302001592,
0.0397981517,
-0.0012786224,
0.1076172888,
0.0024773371,
0.0250624921,
-0.0294565875,
0.0594685078,
0.0452503674,
-0.0142616471,
-0.0120307952,
0.012949544,
-0.0367364623,
-0.0216846596,
-0.0297141839,
-0.0128196888,
-0.0313827619,
0.0071452549,
0.010786687,
-0.0221417379,
0.0022260111,
0.0608981699,
0.042512428,
0.0121931545,
-0.0116994195,
-0.0169513449,
0.0270412005,
0.0160233621,
0.024615895,
0.0692893788,
-0.0443349108,
-0.0284397118,
0.0450356267,
0.0011326784,
0.0512487553,
0.0056861774,
-0.0200092178,
-0.0052878838,
-0.0538137741,
0.0069978391,
-0.0094622998,
-0.0008402231,
-0.0581919365,
-0.0427037813,
0.0197411813,
0.0038741487,
0.0006336159,
0.0311380699,
-0.0049046944,
-0.0117214797,
-0.0461090021,
-0.0195966978,
0.0175979901,
0.0674432069,
0.0102688512,
-0.0048235604,
-0.0023198479,
0.0018888593,
0.0318721123,
0.003217763,
-0.0097655132,
0.0003974028,
2.58e-7,
0.011883785,
0.0139065338,
0.0258103851,
-0.0035197937,
-0.0170339532,
0.0253856052,
-0.0055167624,
0.0650028884,
0.0238109175,
-0.0528873205,
-0.0225859098,
0.0050929892,
0.0290262327,
0.0475196391,
-0.0634024814,
-0.0385782309,
-0.0631740689,
0.0133783016,
-0.049635116,
0.0070214821,
0.0326274931,
0.0615899526,
0.0437527336,
0.0022711852,
-0.0169766825,
-0.0091251973,
0.0116920071,
-0.0114282835,
-0.031283509,
0.0460419729,
-0.0276537985,
0.0317745581,
-0.0115271611,
0.0623476207,
0.0150569361,
0.0145095373,
0.0468398556,
0.0781400874,
-0.018464379,
-0.0490125678,
-0.0325947441,
-0.0272160694,
0.0017043909,
-0.0425485894,
0.0407840572,
-0.0360326283,
0.0099099213,
-0.0035867109,
-0.0275327154,
0.037104968,
-0.0226049665,
0.0212811846,
-0.0137927299,
0.0352444611,
-0.0079817995,
0.0122240791,
-0.0263834875,
-0.0851784274,
-0.0527985655,
-0.0152518507,
-0.0338690355,
-0.0435452648,
-0.0077096643,
-0.0898279399,
-0.0415298641,
-0.06403929,
-0.0025530639,
2.730116395e-34,
-0.0118175885,
0.0298555903,
-0.0084235985,
0.0181608964,
0.0105750049,
-0.0291005746,
-0.0246437211,
0.0136567587,
0.0196386278,
-0.0000032571,
0.002748217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14510v1 | CITB: A Benchmark for Continual Instruction Tuning | 2023-10-23T02:42:32 | 2023-10-23T02:42:32 | Zihan Zhang, Meng Fang, Ling Chen, Mohammad-Reza Namazi-Rad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Continual learning (CL) is a paradigm that aims to replicate the human
ability to learn and accumulate knowledge continually without forgetting
previous knowledge and transferring it to new tasks. Recent instruction tuning
(IT) involves fine-tuning models to make them more adaptable to solving NLP
tasks in general. However, it is still uncertain how instruction tuning works
in the context of CL tasks. This challenging yet practical problem is
formulated as Continual Instruction Tuning (CIT). In this work, we establish a
CIT benchmark consisting of learning and evaluation protocols. We curate two
long dialogue task streams of different types, InstrDialog and InstrDialog++,
to study various CL methods systematically. Our experiments show that existing
CL methods do not effectively leverage the rich natural language instructions,
and fine-tuning an instruction-tuned model sequentially can yield similar or
better results. We further explore different aspects that might affect the
learning of CIT. We hope this benchmark will facilitate more research in this
direction. | [
0.0381567664,
0.0402997136,
0.000853856,
0.0260161106,
-0.0432521924,
0.0196576547,
-0.0273909997,
-0.036119014,
-0.0065830173,
-0.0369539298,
-0.0480952486,
-0.0269382,
-0.0139460834,
0.0159657542,
-0.0163518321,
-0.0580563582,
0.0789199248,
-0.0272696167,
-0.0075095487,
0.0138093121,
0.0062216078,
-0.0290310346,
-0.0615615509,
0.0273131616,
0.0144379986,
-0.0483861081,
-0.0320231467,
-0.0156005817,
-0.0123654408,
-0.0420463905,
0.0187748354,
0.05616384,
0.0100787943,
-0.0019862589,
0.0000019078,
-0.0458118245,
0.0047103749,
-0.0244029686,
-0.0797044858,
-0.0018591196,
0.0180400312,
0.0274533331,
0.0027025437,
0.031240169,
-0.0418313406,
0.0065627205,
0.0340080224,
0.04045536,
0.0982637852,
0.0725057274,
0.0224965345,
0.0039790464,
0.0217741076,
-0.0202833936,
0.0020755366,
-0.0965934247,
-0.008725808,
-0.000759627,
0.0282816496,
0.027819844,
-0.0141867986,
0.0271190107,
0.0385514833,
-0.0103167165,
0.0015359316,
0.0222412292,
-0.0626705885,
-0.0072798459,
-0.0443626307,
0.0784191117,
0.0040296568,
0.0367931314,
-0.0180436,
0.0445439257,
0.003472917,
-0.0611859821,
-0.0475386158,
0.0040317564,
-0.0321542919,
-0.0067716734,
-0.0130314259,
-0.0134192817,
-0.0298994463,
0.0052372646,
-0.0107599171,
0.0412279926,
-0.004620173,
-0.0220393054,
0.0120284017,
-0.0227647852,
-0.0502163321,
-0.0522229746,
0.0136233615,
0.0654812455,
-0.0821780264,
0.0160356052,
-0.0333870947,
0.0451633483,
0.0107538486,
0.0047309147,
0.0621020757,
0.0694644302,
-0.0041006827,
0.0751102641,
-0.006057445,
0.0714662001,
0.0335560702,
-0.0285122301,
-0.0182864461,
0.0320083424,
-0.1191438213,
-0.0020342232,
-0.0465863384,
0.0399485826,
-0.0444781259,
-0.0298430752,
-0.018617928,
0.0573006794,
0.0043504587,
0.0123306615,
-0.0152984122,
-0.0061812135,
-0.0554686971,
0.0209996849,
-0.0494074933,
0.0508090109,
-0.0353080519,
-0.0019093055,
0.0286393613,
-0.0187684968,
-0.0502962247,
0.0089268005,
-0.0145487217,
-0.0202143565,
-0.0006638662,
0.050710585,
-0.0370519646,
-0.0262297112,
-0.0049906764,
-0.012375704,
-0.0057951608,
-0.0633244812,
0.0154547626,
-0.0117909862,
0.0437877364,
-0.0214024652,
-0.0153438337,
-0.0377989262,
0.0088830469,
0.0078650322,
-0.0114406245,
0.0767453387,
0.0232656766,
0.0050138514,
-0.003857709,
0.023704404,
-0.0137121528,
0.0757345557,
-0.0051012347,
-0.0280573126,
0.0297812745,
-0.0102364859,
0.0206369981,
0.017690625,
0.0210572276,
0.0007771704,
0.0031997468,
0.050803408,
0.0136487838,
0.0428404845,
0.0158860423,
0.0415040851,
-0.0537158102,
-0.0131354453,
0.0486624055,
0.0188727714,
-0.0041721193,
-0.015345484,
0.0369024612,
0.0363957174,
0.0386505611,
0.0454994366,
-0.0795054063,
0.0213515926,
0.0040157395,
0.0071138209,
0.0273017753,
-0.0132650938,
-0.0395049825,
-0.0411229096,
0.0126174875,
0.0250459351,
-0.0046875193,
0.0065943622,
0.0057799798,
0.0340908058,
-0.0477674082,
0.0305522177,
0.020645028,
-0.0032089388,
-0.0407647714,
-0.0480030291,
-0.0011857527,
0.0756297931,
0.0264655743,
-0.0405599438,
-0.11099004,
-0.0143863698,
0.0391990431,
0.0262086727,
0.0409449078,
-0.0295536183,
0.0428752042,
-0.0387607664,
-0.012502729,
-0.0312295835,
0.0161077715,
0.0202666037,
0.0339554697,
-0.0123668788,
-0.019853875,
0.0122774038,
-0.0251235291,
0.0089159058,
-0.0269266944,
-0.0549588837,
0.0173083507,
-0.0084976694,
0.0025738401,
-0.0039034144,
-0.0106773749,
0.0081787193,
0.0258723311,
-0.0044104876,
-0.0035631885,
0.0365381949,
-0.0764475018,
-0.0597674549,
0.0441345759,
-0.0075521902,
-0.0221534353,
-0.0366329178,
-0.0307340417,
-0.033148665,
0.0208487436,
-0.0294590797,
0.0282900501,
0.0111804912,
0.0422451869,
-0.0004088016,
-0.0142404176,
-0.0534046255,
0.0469391756,
0.0014195894,
0.0012837375,
0.0613542646,
0.0380672328,
-0.001613143,
-0.0799158961,
0.0373663232,
0.0285937414,
-0.0015089677,
-0.0184940249,
-0.0017980996,
0.0311033502,
-0.0774173066,
-0.0644305497,
-0.1045560613,
0.0509969555,
-0.0059571564,
0.0362327136,
0.0340075642,
-0.0252682529,
-0.0076656546,
-0.0207590405,
-0.0096400408,
-0.0112821404,
0.0019225503,
0.0380824767,
0.0218095984,
0.0289261714,
-0.0202851482,
-0.0562853515,
0.0019686436,
0.0072287275,
-0.0018590027,
-0.0140230041,
0.0253209453,
-0.0646247268,
0.0105205448,
-0.0008084222,
0.0288388412,
-0.030147871,
-0.0181588717,
0.0407605432,
0.0115785915,
0.0464706607,
0.0922064111,
0.0193517283,
0.0317368843,
-0.01204722,
-0.032008335,
-0.0561044328,
0.0725873113,
-0.026072761,
-0.0594121963,
-0.0197189692,
0.0133428648,
-0.0012581863,
0.0724152029,
-0.0198006816,
0.024798993,
-0.030501809,
0.0445722416,
-0.0188277848,
-0.0355631709,
-0.0380751416,
-0.0045462255,
-0.0246588029,
-0.0121618565,
-0.0334488824,
-0.0642871037,
0.0655123889,
0.0074373195,
-0.0050394335,
-0.1041954607,
0.0005936687,
-0.0275241006,
0.0715938285,
-0.0150146242,
-0.008323946,
0.0345839895,
-0.051894512,
-0.0391365848,
0.0142119639,
0.0295351036,
-0.0120257931,
0.0422932468,
-0.0412901752,
-0.0278077889,
-0.0059425216,
-0.0653927326,
-0.0780467913,
-0.0470893718,
0.024786111,
0.0164346863,
0.0491567664,
-0.0158396307,
-0.0387970693,
-0.0128321638,
0.0331182554,
0.008243436,
-0.0206227396,
-0.0269861259,
-0.030704543,
0.0213248637,
0.0283742752,
0.0374245234,
0.0195515454,
-0.0006070135,
0.0518406071,
0.0453328863,
0.0593453608,
-0.0080459295,
-0.0075023328,
0.0323704779,
0.0000065716,
-0.0406651087,
-0.0014245001,
0.0226508398,
0.0892091766,
-0.0550888814,
-0.0405680239,
0.1309545636,
0.0446730591,
-0.0413203798,
0.0025789363,
0.0114663299,
0.0173090957,
0.0491653271,
0.0421888866,
-0.0787090883,
-0.0437151641,
0.0139227258,
0.0483002923,
0.0085757831,
-0.0418310948,
-0.0211134646,
-0.0709397197,
-0.0072722682,
0.0080132699,
-0.0085447347,
0.0061103771,
-0.0537320673,
-0.0044465661,
0.0048974021,
0.0362888761,
0.0255615693,
-0.0346478559,
0.0198330097,
0.0200220011,
-0.0336147286,
-0.0302824136,
0.060680043,
-0.0336425602,
0.0536114872,
0.0635246933,
0.0172359422,
0.0309156459,
0.0076265601,
0.0546585545,
-0.0370841883,
0.0263603348,
-0.0089070322,
0.0611012615,
0.0061418903,
-0.0199292973,
-0.0120179532,
0.0363012962,
-0.024414381,
0.017891353,
0.0585949868,
0.0148733184,
-0.0298302583,
0.0140154753,
-0.0009372248,
-0.0001989714,
0.0341890529,
0.068163164,
0.029045308,
-0.0250145178,
-0.0447813012,
-0.0271814112,
-0.0198309459,
-0.0683029294,
-0.0057940474,
0.0101409759,
-0.0090281162,
0.0247374736,
-0.0623293929,
-0.0666812435,
0.0246205218,
0.0537433587,
0.0175247081,
-0.0090490924,
0.0194982551,
0.0091119315,
0.0027853663,
0.0415348485,
-0.0018357843,
-0.0000488793,
-0.0872669145,
-0.028925987,
0.0309583284,
0.0244421531,
0.0023653698,
0.0156621002,
-0.0701902434,
-0.0586142503,
-0.0011626784,
0.0352199301,
0.0174181405,
0.074817881,
-0.0194143672,
-0.0044807303,
-0.0429055467,
-0.0041390047,
-0.0171257574,
-0.0004693855,
0.0308350828,
0.0151424352,
0.001670372,
0.0268326569,
-0.0132090403,
0.0125168469,
0.0115727354,
0.0653123409,
-0.020474663,
-0.0240176152,
0.0364828221,
-0.0129452823,
-0.0186017305,
0.0143373283,
-0.0068701552,
-0.0029628302,
0.018330507,
0.0155081768,
-0.0227254275,
-0.036441531,
-0.0043946132,
0.0003212704,
-0.0263718702,
0.0092292204,
0.0013152516,
-0.0071245111,
0.0304202382,
-0.0536450222,
0.0068897968,
0.0184936225,
-0.0215400588,
0.0128349578,
0.0103700021,
-0.0451959148,
0.0285836421,
0.0103013543,
0.0617225133,
-0.0094557609,
0.1002252996,
0.0364248864,
0.0151107516,
-0.0111216046,
0.0457560271,
-0.047641322,
-0.0446290411,
0.0043337913,
0.0026623027,
0.0754079074,
-0.0073569268,
0.0230081528,
-0.028084619,
0.0059633604,
-0.0204789955,
0.0186216235,
-0.0149028217,
-0.0049614692,
-0.010523024,
0.0557576232,
0.0047162054,
0.0006996575,
0.0852836072,
-0.0178409386,
0.0492472723,
0.0335402749,
0.0248911157,
-0.0438644625,
-0.0236140117,
-0.0233258419,
0.0277109873,
0.0124402335,
0.050069198,
-0.011170757,
-0.0266982503,
0.0098401904,
-0.0042806491,
0.0211588405,
-0.0155366696,
0.0492884852,
0.0423310176,
-0.0087437443,
-0.0302862842,
-0.0014292219,
0.0121165244,
0.010006343,
-0.0162249971,
-0.0341453068,
-5.937256295e-33,
-0.0650198981,
-0.0010863557,
0.0628113821,
0.0209721327,
-0.0515801907,
-0.0108076725,
-0.0477004759,
0.0242831353,
-0.0136580849,
0.0091854427,
-0.0229381062,
-0.0005229613,
0.0131992139,
-0.0038138747,
0.0225547925,
-0.0458366163,
0.0260564871,
0.0062203449,
-0.0487541296,
0.032698743,
0.0385031551,
0.0080839321,
0.0116659543,
-0.044966653,
0.0027892082,
0.0432288945,
0.0204604119,
0.057326708,
0.0052382508,
0.0747883245,
-0.0104286559,
0.0088738538,
0.0201318637,
-0.0653590113,
-0.0380361564,
-0.0222780704,
-0.0832024515,
-0.0507367365,
0.0079339594,
0.0096821291,
-0.0535916127,
-0.0139451567,
-0.0014773684,
-0.0145963365,
-0.0100608468,
-0.0202415679,
-0.0213893186,
-0.0239403397,
-0.0305139683,
0.014952993,
-0.0758656785,
0.0118982196,
-0.0302069373,
-0.0790939778,
-0.0204869378,
0.0117910719,
-0.0064911097,
-0.075066112,
-0.0699735433,
-0.023284059,
0.0166525505,
0.0624684915,
0.0189035572,
0.014010611,
0.0139641324,
0.0318326727,
0.0141397864,
0.0387591273,
0.0148800015,
-0.0159518458,
0.0080808504,
0.0437272899,
0.0079683373,
-0.03822653,
0.0315301158,
0.0039188298,
-0.0182422753,
-0.0057275873,
0.0536573976,
0.0802483186,
0.0052029765,
-0.0082261721,
-0.0242975056,
-0.0232718773,
-0.0705907941,
0.0500802323,
-0.0288510323,
0.0011528351,
0.0763849318,
0.0420396067,
0.0319595076,
-0.0221963469,
0.0385658368,
0.0105066393,
0.0062218802,
0.005683227,
-0.0076802508,
0.0096285986,
0.0072617922,
0.0378357433,
-0.0558026023,
-0.0172121804,
0.0070602424,
0.0240363106,
0.0213028453,
-0.0033388583,
0.0317805186,
0.0129906693,
-0.0450390354,
-0.0032660929,
-0.0537763871,
0.0682602599,
-0.0151637197,
0.0152727701,
0.0200764965,
-0.0015544712,
-0.0344772115,
0.0585340783,
-0.0006600592,
-0.041695457,
-0.0574632697,
0.0076441192,
0.0400952958,
0.0041055949,
-0.0099787069,
0.0114626875,
-0.0317863263,
-0.0198641568,
-0.0568293184,
-0.0572218075,
-0.0026939306,
0.016903948,
2.569e-7,
-0.0303835049,
0.0563370772,
0.0480140187,
0.0151641369,
0.0535563342,
0.0121142045,
-0.0458836481,
-0.012620599,
0.0108775049,
-0.0028647825,
-0.0360817052,
0.0550148711,
0.0254164729,
0.0088499254,
-0.0755564794,
-0.0449073166,
-0.0241744984,
0.0092068091,
-0.0561870858,
-0.0317662135,
0.0361717194,
0.0613429844,
-0.0204151962,
0.0170742627,
0.0273652468,
-0.0520917177,
0.0466690697,
0.0217388421,
0.0024369906,
0.0345525332,
0.0079562636,
0.0163486525,
0.0068117473,
0.0182301402,
-0.0163956005,
-0.0008833131,
-0.034785483,
0.0711126328,
0.0030172064,
-0.0621395893,
0.0019914345,
-0.0031767564,
0.0066854917,
-0.0040673688,
0.0754403025,
-0.0853789747,
-0.0123863192,
-0.008452177,
-0.0026502027,
-0.0310824662,
0.0019941747,
0.0133001804,
-0.0069889817,
0.0238748714,
0.0098390151,
0.0270385277,
-0.0016484224,
-0.0832952783,
0.0039356882,
0.0237031206,
-0.0325007997,
-0.0414711684,
-0.0525000654,
-0.0195248034,
-0.0063178525,
-0.0176972486,
-0.0156603009,
2.326384824e-34,
0.0193805676,
-0.0207034368,
0.0745387971,
0.0605720021,
0.031218132,
-0.0051167514,
-0.0324334875,
-0.0097849537,
0.0387718268,
-0.0778427944,
-0.0174164716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14508v1 | EXPLAIN, EDIT, GENERATE: Rationale-Sensitive Counterfactual Data Augmentation for Multi-hop Fact Verification | 2023-10-23T02:39:14 | 2023-10-23T02:39:14 | Yingjie Zhu, Jiasheng Si, Yibo Zhao, Haiyang Zhu, Deyu Zhou, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic multi-hop fact verification task has gained significant attention
in recent years. Despite impressive results, these well-designed models perform
poorly on out-of-domain data. One possible solution is to augment the training
data with counterfactuals, which are generated by minimally altering the causal
features of the original data. However, current counterfactual data
augmentation techniques fail to handle multi-hop fact verification due to their
incapability to preserve the complex logical relationships within multiple
correlated texts. In this paper, we overcome this limitation by developing a
rationale-sensitive method to generate linguistically diverse and
label-flipping counterfactuals while preserving logical relationships. In
specific, the diverse and fluent counterfactuals are generated via an
Explain-Edit-Generate architecture. Moreover, the checking and filtering
modules are proposed to regularize the counterfactual data with logical
relations and flipped labels. Experimental results show that the proposed
approach outperforms the SOTA baselines and can generate linguistically diverse
counterfactual data without disrupting their logical relationships. | [
0.0205206331,
0.0552324317,
0.0029436129,
0.0479819141,
-0.0577308983,
0.0204709843,
0.0213105399,
-0.0233952217,
0.0185734518,
-0.0566517524,
0.0010723819,
-0.0065801963,
-0.0254936349,
0.0723503605,
0.0263200812,
0.0038278715,
0.0736153722,
0.0106433788,
0.0342901386,
-0.0231276378,
-0.0251584351,
0.0459762923,
-0.0297496393,
-0.0056050494,
-0.0379635133,
-0.0244120546,
-0.0034105179,
0.00891513,
0.0533173531,
0.0017090549,
0.0019571683,
0.0300829895,
0.0094781453,
0.0203788336,
0.0000019754,
-0.0296553057,
-0.0453210175,
0.0177054536,
-0.0883645415,
-0.0183763411,
-0.0170101319,
0.0029609916,
-0.0202240366,
-0.0067400113,
-0.0206702184,
0.0405997001,
0.0321096331,
0.1116561368,
0.0819860995,
0.0980926454,
-0.0173021201,
-0.0412636064,
0.0215301756,
-0.0028581936,
-0.0018968319,
-0.0034416383,
0.0073157568,
0.0415421687,
-0.03985155,
0.0302914679,
-0.0061346646,
-0.0047681928,
0.0278218836,
-0.0065152049,
-0.0258451365,
0.0104955835,
0.0315761119,
0.0037920652,
0.0052085142,
0.0483870357,
0.0070781815,
-0.0458207466,
0.0124301445,
-0.0312082674,
0.0162527915,
0.0121971872,
0.0039807055,
0.0097360518,
-0.0304171667,
0.0104971174,
0.0505725257,
0.000368373,
0.0467297249,
0.0204116274,
-0.0160453711,
0.068954207,
0.0052950624,
-0.0355799906,
-0.0258855335,
0.0018404375,
-0.0153125664,
-0.0666258037,
0.0080064582,
0.0135545833,
-0.0368564092,
-0.0059872805,
-0.0212961081,
-0.0157727171,
0.0042466931,
-0.056735307,
-0.0360098518,
0.0144393025,
-0.050528802,
0.0621536933,
-0.0389525369,
0.0101035601,
-0.0263078064,
0.0036846709,
0.0130426362,
-0.0358432904,
-0.0317333937,
-0.016217785,
-0.0221144836,
0.0398036875,
-0.0861937925,
0.0353747234,
-0.0090111513,
-0.0132348705,
-0.0560043678,
0.0325955302,
0.0046148123,
0.0138497846,
-0.0058623478,
-0.0522841178,
-0.0328198075,
0.0145151177,
-0.0643334389,
0.0207535941,
-0.0050147013,
-0.0149008827,
-0.0191404521,
0.0043902476,
0.0256452281,
-0.0279987231,
0.007657093,
0.0676460043,
-0.0062933778,
0.0187602062,
-0.0569453798,
-0.061026223,
-0.0114521356,
-0.0864899606,
-0.0189402979,
-0.0415576622,
-0.0035602334,
-0.0093406746,
-0.0120999515,
-0.032271497,
-0.000012955,
0.0069263624,
-0.0297791269,
0.0474516042,
-0.0143988337,
-0.0395603776,
0.021764962,
-0.0118952943,
-0.0104416478,
0.0625309199,
0.03295625,
-0.0307561159,
0.059294384,
0.0145966075,
0.0040213875,
-0.0410065018,
0.0560174882,
-0.0107481424,
-0.0201743264,
0.0060514449,
-0.0136177698,
-0.0125808306,
0.0169356596,
0.0199266355,
-0.0294299927,
-0.0479635261,
0.0182128772,
-0.0675671771,
0.0158396587,
0.0102145849,
0.0511662029,
-0.0051860777,
-0.0257823486,
0.0672647431,
-0.0632184222,
0.0646220446,
-0.0218760055,
0.0037947567,
-0.0005808364,
0.0500969477,
-0.0061396598,
-0.049409695,
-0.0020368113,
-0.0106523596,
-0.0037578305,
0.0007387917,
0.0314368606,
0.0303009748,
-0.0339202732,
0.0093793729,
0.0194068328,
-0.0544964671,
-0.0035474699,
-0.0178217907,
-0.0028273459,
0.0584164336,
0.0251958687,
-0.0412386321,
-0.0558049381,
-0.0421574712,
0.0009389053,
0.0238545481,
0.0654544979,
-0.0121487686,
0.0223890562,
-0.0333056338,
-0.0024080693,
-0.0609363057,
0.0536787324,
0.0019010621,
0.0127107194,
0.0042796112,
0.0257734302,
-0.000346255,
0.0275126789,
0.0285381358,
-0.0418832079,
-0.0026499152,
0.0188147891,
0.0240998846,
0.0053474852,
0.0531906262,
-0.0054089068,
0.0068796654,
0.0250330567,
-0.0105396928,
-0.032258857,
0.0384053811,
-0.0051796413,
-0.0799052417,
0.0340032168,
-0.020226201,
-0.0557567179,
0.018993251,
-0.0555422455,
-0.0651032254,
0.035890691,
-0.0002268954,
0.0194664896,
-0.0317188986,
-0.0121911271,
0.0487419777,
0.000777467,
0.0171881951,
0.0800580084,
0.007392385,
-0.0121060014,
-0.0343743265,
-0.003779537,
0.0410718285,
-0.0252869278,
0.0375519954,
-0.0042819786,
-0.0202021338,
-0.0270138569,
-0.0133026894,
-0.0264555681,
-0.0283437949,
-0.0022916375,
-0.0224644151,
0.0063346447,
-0.0251945462,
0.0043895147,
0.0392009318,
-0.012630363,
0.0169005338,
-0.0110423928,
-0.0292870328,
0.0066807107,
0.0081371153,
0.0121616367,
0.0562954247,
-0.0124570681,
-0.0044030007,
-0.0148215853,
0.00831981,
-0.0576272234,
0.0538841151,
-0.0003000233,
0.0030694162,
-0.0156008163,
-0.0670789108,
-0.0542207323,
0.025924908,
-0.0144761438,
0.0106955729,
0.0149322972,
0.0334273502,
0.0387751535,
0.0206299145,
0.0109360404,
-0.0181825906,
0.0343966,
-0.0186801963,
-0.0098807774,
0.0497717522,
-0.0307586528,
0.082778506,
-0.0035169208,
-0.0383739062,
-0.0152897099,
0.0290015899,
-0.0067558172,
-0.0248399768,
-0.0496405289,
0.0113041801,
0.0167185385,
-0.016634874,
-0.0160253327,
-0.0516627692,
0.0019116862,
0.0445924811,
-0.0272335187,
0.0055498243,
0.0968733206,
-0.0129006896,
0.0068088132,
-0.0452573672,
-0.0085017998,
-0.0122232353,
0.0765987411,
-0.0145192528,
0.022876516,
0.01046299,
0.0221325234,
-0.0203239433,
-0.0328109823,
0.0643171296,
0.0068197958,
0.0269085169,
-0.0703030974,
-0.0009838572,
0.0130805746,
-0.0228412747,
-0.0382464081,
-0.0666964576,
-0.0153753264,
-0.000465457,
-0.0261018649,
-0.0253598727,
-0.0167046897,
0.0063264654,
0.029848123,
0.0772985518,
-0.001885595,
0.013301786,
-0.0046430952,
-0.0112952041,
0.0543975718,
0.0525115766,
0.0499579087,
-0.0011473856,
0.0275158305,
0.0157312825,
-0.0308555122,
-0.0820156634,
0.0292021837,
-0.0045785708,
-0.0583038554,
-0.0242141671,
-0.000106528,
-0.0290414058,
0.0372273549,
-0.0404066145,
0.0020688477,
0.06051144,
0.0382824987,
0.0232839528,
0.011774322,
-0.012411477,
-0.0088921599,
0.0234360043,
-0.0044339369,
-0.0839551687,
-0.0182079505,
-0.0158594567,
-0.0246274192,
-0.021625936,
-0.0237250365,
-0.0413290113,
-0.0780304149,
0.0373227783,
-0.0194302034,
-0.0215077028,
-0.0516321585,
-0.0410862751,
-0.0107789375,
-0.0306234416,
-0.0261358246,
0.0119720148,
0.0316527821,
0.0017101101,
-0.0193266273,
0.0392211676,
-0.024065204,
0.0159357097,
0.0017766367,
0.0246694274,
0.0242047273,
0.0312605202,
0.0206128415,
-0.0128732529,
0.0323153064,
-0.013547468,
-0.0031469327,
-0.0090844613,
0.0718543828,
-0.0065797549,
0.004701627,
-0.0234386008,
0.0368217789,
-0.0082089081,
-0.0636579171,
-0.0011863409,
0.0829395354,
-0.0138231032,
0.0143377855,
-0.0247567613,
0.0311406404,
0.0223905127,
0.0876139924,
0.0092187338,
-0.0061900667,
-0.0203925055,
-0.033016216,
-0.0173815638,
-0.0847107694,
0.0342413224,
-0.0337448679,
-0.003542125,
-0.0303583052,
-0.0812982172,
-0.0353701711,
-0.0366388597,
0.0356833078,
-0.0398641452,
0.0007560998,
0.0188235324,
-0.032984592,
-0.0295896716,
-0.0086460328,
-0.0340450853,
0.0399199426,
0.0367565975,
0.0073096328,
0.0237416755,
-0.0450088419,
-0.031780269,
0.003846481,
-0.0402006507,
-0.0423305742,
0.010066513,
-0.0036973334,
0.0236401223,
0.0845071822,
-0.0453690961,
0.030623218,
-0.0391420126,
0.0552407205,
-0.0539457053,
0.0126160253,
0.0714932457,
-0.0147859212,
-0.0083035398,
0.0387763716,
-0.0130686937,
0.0079836687,
0.0184809696,
0.0428393558,
-0.0298754703,
-0.0301973596,
0.029307466,
-0.0163525958,
0.064122729,
0.0036960253,
0.017471768,
-0.0545540452,
0.0476252325,
-0.0751271844,
-0.0368757509,
0.0079175076,
0.0454401262,
-0.0267151203,
-0.0248276796,
-0.0066366075,
-0.0097523155,
-0.0345176607,
0.0366892554,
0.0157470293,
0.0021734012,
-0.0028369843,
0.0406147018,
-0.0139532397,
-0.0236460622,
-0.0355137475,
-0.001938389,
0.022720661,
0.0209761076,
-0.0282172374,
0.0361601859,
0.0352943838,
-0.0246210061,
-0.0341316089,
-0.0333852805,
-0.10588146,
0.0800666809,
-0.0374125168,
-0.011878958,
0.0564277507,
-0.0210030787,
0.0487899892,
-0.0198765006,
-0.0306624603,
0.0230358001,
0.0392711163,
0.0486725681,
-0.0263399687,
0.0150645208,
0.0047824741,
-0.0215967875,
0.0082370676,
0.0634564683,
-0.0423373096,
0.0768635273,
-0.0200501345,
-0.0150934607,
-0.0235849973,
-0.0820979923,
-0.065724656,
0.039259322,
-0.0057321261,
0.0061517656,
-0.0984146744,
-0.0516348816,
0.0055376673,
0.0195494499,
0.0241777748,
-0.0020865577,
-0.0040836898,
0.0349977463,
0.0281353947,
-0.0591684654,
-0.0214094203,
0.0513808616,
0.024341872,
0.0105228927,
-0.0294321645,
-6.255498982e-33,
-0.0159310177,
-0.0519325584,
0.023814505,
-0.0441512987,
0.0051261815,
-0.0106527694,
-0.0409188159,
-0.0488644019,
-0.0472219139,
0.046841342,
0.0239805952,
0.04633018,
0.022031296,
0.0090967836,
-0.0364020467,
-0.0031888897,
0.0745616406,
0.0410846584,
-0.019649813,
0.0249811392,
0.0451363996,
-0.0311082006,
0.0744930506,
-0.09481287,
0.0385500602,
-0.0161536355,
-0.0257087108,
0.0287452396,
-0.0707850531,
0.0401651822,
0.0149649847,
0.0141913742,
0.0316583961,
-0.0315123647,
0.0073367232,
-0.0570908599,
-0.045657631,
-0.040644981,
0.0463605784,
-0.026212493,
0.0265716612,
-0.0397233814,
0.0047168476,
0.005954762,
0.0240917057,
-0.0034574179,
0.0213241931,
-0.030962538,
0.0264201481,
0.0335033908,
-0.0970847309,
0.0484680161,
-0.0039529162,
0.0084262332,
-0.0488953218,
0.0675710589,
0.0526887886,
-0.0214892533,
-0.0579938553,
0.0339906588,
0.0176456701,
-0.0139902066,
0.0379146002,
-0.0161501672,
-0.0343878642,
0.0289794952,
-0.0166635122,
0.034362521,
-0.0718703493,
0.0550962463,
-0.0382608809,
0.0411728472,
0.0763728991,
0.1588965058,
0.0488263741,
-0.006644059,
-0.088395603,
-0.010556397,
-0.034265466,
-0.0016643904,
-0.0025541103,
-0.0139835505,
-0.0169572681,
0.0084690936,
-0.0205761101,
0.0138769308,
-0.0232280102,
-0.0017826196,
-0.0022411679,
0.0113359075,
-0.0371432565,
0.0386890955,
-0.0151157016,
-0.0200686399,
0.0074679321,
0.0386791788,
-0.0263959169,
-0.0042644115,
0.027114043,
0.0246617105,
-0.0356122218,
0.0029355683,
0.0462049283,
0.0267462879,
0.0081375251,
0.010753748,
0.0744380727,
-0.0021795526,
-0.0541979782,
0.0248371102,
-0.0158040859,
0.0293137077,
-0.0269900598,
-0.0215770956,
0.0214716978,
0.0289991964,
-0.0123834712,
0.041183535,
0.0201633703,
0.0182486251,
-0.0117376437,
-0.0036619608,
0.0060333032,
0.0545154698,
0.0068350746,
0.0085158041,
0.0199658554,
-0.0317055583,
-0.0072466857,
-0.0535933599,
-0.0101001542,
0.0370807573,
2.577e-7,
0.0259606894,
0.0081985528,
0.0531548262,
-0.012362089,
0.0263238959,
0.038010899,
-0.0044120098,
-0.0176423062,
-0.014429735,
-0.0002990224,
-0.0147887049,
0.0352913179,
0.0065127281,
0.0590176322,
-0.0005048343,
0.0167846363,
-0.0438122079,
-0.0683838204,
-0.0395648293,
0.012529226,
0.1214414313,
0.051728718,
0.0471230373,
-0.0010085015,
-0.0008589097,
0.0114400731,
0.0278127026,
0.0266555026,
-0.0146366544,
-0.0127483159,
0.0330910347,
-0.0323666297,
0.0059280838,
0.0718743801,
-0.0439230539,
0.0271447264,
-0.0667102635,
0.0477152653,
-0.005693703,
-0.0398683585,
-0.0260309391,
-0.0403186381,
0.0163300615,
-0.0484633148,
0.0707060993,
0.0113180634,
-0.0047699902,
-0.0302365087,
-0.0769759789,
0.0485116579,
0.0007357594,
-0.0181737579,
-0.0268198252,
-0.0017463916,
0.0049953843,
0.0132461973,
0.0094136922,
-0.0524691753,
-0.0415783599,
0.0532003529,
-0.0117402198,
-0.0340155289,
0.0010028065,
-0.0161787216,
0.0946135893,
-0.047101032,
0.0165243186,
2.300040894e-34,
0.0425665677,
0.0131621184,
-0.0051345425,
-0.0364936329,
0.068544805,
0.007828095,
-0.0538906045,
0.0024428149,
0.0237030536,
-0.0006749958,
-0.0176445264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14505v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14505v4 | Sentiment analysis with adaptive multi-head attention in Transformer | 2023-10-23T02:32:30 | 2024-03-11T04:13:50 | Fanfei Meng, Chen-Ao Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a novel framework based on the attention mechanism to identify the
sentiment of a movie review document. Previous efforts on deep neural networks
with attention mechanisms focus on encoder and decoder with fixed numbers of
multi-head attention. Therefore, we need a mechanism to stop the attention
process automatically if no more useful information can be read from the
memory.In this paper, we propose an adaptive multi-head attention architecture
(AdaptAttn) which varies the number of attention heads based on length of
sentences. AdaptAttn has a data preprocessing step where each document is
classified into any one of the three bins small, medium or large based on
length of the sentence. The document classified as small goes through two heads
in each layer, the medium group passes four heads and the large group is
processed by eight heads. We examine the merit of our model on the Stanford
large movie review dataset. The experimental results show that the F1 score
from our model is on par with the baseline model. | [
0.0254672859,
0.0174651407,
-0.003070991,
0.0237423759,
0.0050871144,
0.0003202797,
0.0081105633,
-0.0194523055,
-0.000648546,
-0.0229992848,
-0.0344591103,
-0.0487888306,
-0.0178496204,
0.0329775922,
-0.0349593461,
-0.0197838992,
0.0125975423,
0.0525542647,
0.0487094373,
0.0038718698,
0.0071049817,
0.0028208296,
0.0329244174,
-0.0023069207,
-0.0126058152,
-0.0149451029,
-0.0120383631,
-0.0098668709,
0.040587943,
-0.0124286972,
0.0375401266,
0.0415094346,
-0.0049058436,
0.023477193,
0.0000021904,
0.0018612959,
0.003284232,
-0.0300948359,
0.0367326401,
-0.0119494796,
0.0532846078,
-0.0561928451,
0.0074374462,
-0.0208118726,
-0.0009758088,
-0.0242935009,
0.0417141914,
0.0837056041,
0.0540292114,
0.0581668392,
-0.0343814567,
-0.0615072437,
0.0212907549,
-0.0321515985,
0.0238583088,
-0.0342280455,
0.0059496635,
-0.0485851578,
-0.0137360962,
0.0120178452,
-0.0461924337,
0.042747613,
0.0333441384,
-0.0191627033,
0.0406002365,
0.0015235562,
-0.0306107346,
0.0010581411,
-0.0144491475,
0.0643092468,
-0.049335625,
0.0026556072,
-0.0327433906,
-0.0347668454,
0.0107618114,
-0.0491979122,
-0.0317425169,
0.0193027444,
0.010295623,
0.0067929402,
-0.000457837,
0.0579079501,
0.0075548654,
-0.0067866426,
-0.0194284692,
0.0082102092,
-0.0378301479,
-0.0499427579,
0.0257352367,
0.0421534777,
0.0160471834,
0.04701107,
0.030616764,
0.0084207384,
0.0440590866,
-0.0145099377,
-0.0229309574,
-0.0511474572,
-0.0167246554,
-0.1317064315,
0.0360631198,
-0.0078172339,
-0.0565100797,
0.0619583428,
-0.0114988983,
0.0161148701,
-0.0281960461,
-0.0141438125,
-0.0155237317,
0.0006445884,
-0.0389628932,
0.0269742385,
-0.0087813819,
0.0538079962,
-0.0101706395,
-0.0237914361,
-0.0271963701,
-0.0039844355,
-0.0123841679,
-0.0151423821,
0.0329408832,
0.0225681234,
-0.006866802,
-0.0038368967,
-0.0094483122,
0.0979156718,
-0.0494641848,
0.0065547903,
-0.0285004005,
-0.019955514,
-0.0261861533,
0.062912412,
0.0196780004,
0.0001344589,
0.0237308051,
0.0265666489,
0.0115274526,
-0.02466527,
-0.0155845908,
0.0074475287,
-0.0307143014,
-0.0444668531,
0.0528173745,
-0.0207730792,
0.0622733161,
-0.023081962,
-0.0200585499,
0.0284374412,
-0.0180079695,
-0.005938442,
-0.0302374158,
0.0052330592,
0.0061338819,
-0.0283627529,
0.0021324609,
-0.0049149147,
0.0122012822,
0.0600663722,
0.0122260135,
0.0708720759,
0.0159000121,
-0.0522496775,
0.0176501609,
-0.0122800181,
-0.0072329398,
-0.0202779602,
-0.0160771497,
-0.0087263202,
-0.0769003853,
-0.0043322179,
0.0294015631,
0.0481332093,
0.014050466,
-0.0455414243,
0.026527077,
-0.0103023918,
0.0072157225,
0.0878310278,
-0.002471047,
0.0222743005,
-0.02844638,
0.0021681613,
-0.0295315906,
0.1173828244,
0.0198188517,
-0.0234063845,
-0.0161424614,
-0.0076155071,
-0.0599199422,
-0.0189494677,
0.0141980071,
-0.0149162989,
0.0048099728,
-0.0192977041,
0.0477161109,
0.0075754183,
-0.0649077818,
0.0323719122,
-0.0006888828,
-0.0367218181,
-0.0047937781,
-0.0345570892,
0.0044378568,
0.0890245661,
0.0001594834,
-0.0306974649,
-0.0288609564,
-0.0537859425,
0.0144925788,
0.0312398374,
0.0515722111,
0.0141802272,
-0.0032683006,
-0.0744400099,
0.0184590314,
-0.0061132158,
-0.0004479953,
0.0222146865,
-0.0555731654,
0.0474391207,
-0.0059928857,
0.0352851525,
-0.0178736653,
-0.0047900043,
0.0707059205,
-0.0152812982,
0.0084415572,
0.001466456,
0.0406016968,
0.0281774253,
-0.0113226604,
-0.0272821765,
0.0402920023,
-0.0437358432,
-0.0441073701,
0.0090780463,
-0.0213337652,
-0.0037606324,
-0.0153660635,
-0.059406098,
-0.0169230569,
0.0703962371,
-0.0239711348,
-0.0307309236,
0.0283484012,
-0.0453449488,
0.030660646,
-0.0058699567,
-0.0034574133,
-0.0160184484,
0.0599881187,
-0.0022515056,
0.0604794025,
-0.0275528263,
-0.0083915899,
-0.0287508257,
-0.0531137362,
0.0063085104,
0.0009203823,
-0.0503273755,
0.0037167722,
0.0043435446,
0.0205451977,
0.0265460238,
0.0062640538,
0.0044022244,
-0.0524380058,
-0.0494003706,
-0.0331275053,
-0.017347401,
0.0194413848,
0.0173600428,
0.011244907,
0.0213507283,
-0.0188752413,
-0.0464657471,
0.0318060666,
-0.0146691203,
-0.0025686843,
0.040269468,
0.0003715474,
0.0314607807,
-0.0223690122,
-0.0318858102,
-0.0097965011,
0.0260440484,
0.0409856066,
-0.0597159937,
-0.019017987,
-0.0241891965,
0.0175318662,
0.02221152,
0.0075515211,
-0.0558744222,
-0.0155822299,
-0.0239976868,
0.0033306989,
0.0869833156,
0.0116576441,
0.0303778704,
0.0207591671,
0.033990901,
-0.0010208415,
0.0443698242,
-0.0225627124,
0.0144799361,
-0.0233215671,
-0.0111912731,
-0.0080870222,
0.0493159518,
0.0069129355,
0.0150859533,
-0.0591314398,
-0.0049746074,
0.0341125429,
0.0107353935,
0.036127869,
0.0162567366,
0.0000761563,
0.0010282646,
0.0092583224,
0.0228981096,
0.0544236712,
0.0144988177,
-0.0179067366,
-0.0630902126,
0.0408870764,
-0.0259873271,
0.02558822,
-0.0000014724,
0.0349615812,
-0.0367261805,
-0.0124410903,
-0.0089268181,
0.0091170957,
-0.0221281629,
-0.0075374544,
0.0508512817,
0.0402819738,
-0.0107301287,
-0.0181840993,
-0.0265478641,
-0.004928689,
-0.0064105303,
-0.0502989478,
0.0012739359,
0.0269044004,
-0.0205309633,
-0.0939839557,
0.0348564535,
0.0303706508,
0.0385307372,
-0.0194792841,
-0.0000803648,
0.0212281086,
0.022942882,
0.0329914652,
0.0322058164,
0.0133432243,
-0.0168228708,
0.0518535562,
0.0627348796,
-0.0362010822,
0.0317846015,
-0.0424178205,
-0.043394804,
0.0348033905,
-0.0068010762,
0.0149608925,
-0.0593616106,
0.0230970066,
-0.0671648383,
0.008252969,
0.0979143158,
0.0137407603,
-0.1167831793,
-0.0248201229,
0.0035647715,
-0.0427980013,
0.0242680255,
0.0262235291,
-0.0377699882,
-0.0514608547,
-0.0502340011,
0.0058897687,
0.0360259935,
-0.0178590529,
0.0012350262,
-0.060570512,
0.0348126069,
-0.0273761973,
-0.0334659889,
-0.0698807985,
0.0046938788,
0.0172994602,
-0.0153080076,
-0.0059376592,
-0.0114409784,
0.011397928,
-0.0458355062,
-0.020750029,
-0.0024729436,
-0.0048028161,
0.0383282229,
-0.0124741104,
0.0110855903,
0.0599654652,
0.0257942826,
-0.0384154022,
-0.0391155966,
0.0002902206,
-0.0467723534,
0.0105519211,
0.0084720058,
0.0734688863,
-0.0507289656,
-0.0259957667,
-0.0209029913,
-0.017850684,
-0.0548243746,
0.0497388504,
0.0091103157,
0.0880956873,
-0.0107713472,
-0.0727571025,
-0.0719513819,
0.0382461958,
-0.0204504579,
0.052347146,
0.0103444373,
-0.106134221,
-0.0072864951,
-0.0043410528,
-0.0220184773,
-0.09750662,
-0.0001827874,
0.0104440683,
0.0206526872,
-0.0494481884,
-0.0429605655,
-0.0446624532,
-0.009112021,
0.0090216631,
-0.0093093803,
-0.0524987988,
0.0365839638,
0.0019114782,
-0.0479460806,
0.0107331388,
0.039940726,
-0.0451560989,
-0.0501831844,
-0.0131853716,
0.094350107,
-0.0012718753,
-0.0114642372,
0.0310030747,
-0.0477799363,
0.0090509634,
-0.0037383111,
0.0581810474,
0.0084986947,
0.0130819837,
-0.0155377919,
-0.0477066822,
-0.0042631226,
0.0056086471,
-0.0277890917,
0.0165737309,
0.0551372394,
0.003730492,
-0.0116037279,
0.0267955512,
-0.0347809717,
0.0755433887,
0.0020857085,
-0.0281733349,
-0.0361848734,
-0.0391226485,
-0.0186752323,
-0.0177536532,
0.0365603715,
0.0315236486,
0.0328571983,
-0.0025615757,
0.0280360207,
0.0326482095,
0.0156443436,
-0.0384317711,
0.00158018,
0.0236537121,
-0.0240843762,
-0.0265862495,
0.0452484675,
0.0131444735,
-0.0410252362,
-0.0450418703,
0.0916747451,
-0.0000511643,
-0.0104073193,
-0.0112095904,
0.0352139249,
-0.0377259701,
-0.0146902138,
0.0296739358,
0.0118800616,
-0.0046105646,
0.0418224297,
0.0328537375,
0.0359646864,
-0.0127168391,
0.0323202163,
-0.0395884551,
0.0313915089,
-0.021525057,
-0.0006209267,
-0.0180842802,
-0.0322309248,
0.0098057427,
0.0098778978,
-0.0050497404,
-0.0140138743,
0.0192656368,
-0.0282672606,
-0.0170034282,
0.0159537513,
0.020476358,
0.0123223038,
-0.0110660885,
0.0279998649,
-0.0764131024,
-0.0277498607,
0.0454304479,
-0.0071499711,
-0.0600382835,
0.0007077039,
-0.0126228612,
0.0141369989,
0.0297631603,
0.0448543206,
-0.0207380597,
-0.0365800969,
0.052455876,
-0.051829271,
0.0510392971,
-0.0182129685,
0.0341987312,
0.0177812111,
0.0229543205,
-0.0023451659,
-0.0167621374,
0.0204788372,
-0.0318300128,
-0.0177216567,
-0.0056626019,
-6.683478108e-33,
-0.0102475248,
0.0098468596,
-0.0550117716,
0.012426707,
-0.0325072445,
0.0001743435,
-0.0298414882,
-0.0027993741,
-0.0344595276,
0.0426467471,
-0.0069904905,
0.0288784839,
0.0005222313,
0.0405328497,
0.0511279963,
-0.0239193626,
0.0453969948,
-0.0169462208,
0.004883524,
0.0779483095,
0.0393053554,
0.0540970713,
0.0881110281,
-0.016487645,
-0.0161714088,
-0.0068691336,
-0.030232178,
-0.0192436017,
0.003163869,
0.059651956,
-0.0074065784,
0.0669276267,
0.0512430407,
-0.0612286851,
0.0071995487,
0.0542898662,
-0.046193555,
-0.0192862414,
-0.0287331007,
0.0331839062,
-0.0113457153,
-0.0115446793,
0.0538239665,
0.00332866,
0.0093190428,
-0.0463475212,
0.0433803275,
-0.0138939591,
0.0031955461,
-0.0497509241,
-0.0362482257,
0.0061204312,
-0.0166423954,
0.0004728684,
0.0307467412,
0.0698082075,
0.0164955892,
0.0641119927,
-0.079947345,
0.0084372843,
-0.0229480714,
0.0227402262,
-0.011409278,
-0.0093062008,
-0.0388704129,
0.0448549874,
0.0135564571,
0.0025502809,
-0.0452665128,
0.0349951014,
0.0432085842,
-0.0135346912,
0.0697288811,
0.021374369,
0.0488803722,
-0.047648225,
-0.0428791828,
-0.0280942898,
0.0363155976,
0.0532761514,
0.0898993835,
-0.017627446,
-0.0412047692,
-0.0016555969,
0.0508264415,
-0.0280216765,
-0.0409615375,
-0.0221539848,
0.0013956475,
0.0135544175,
-0.0283365175,
-0.0108324774,
0.0322909392,
-0.0571789406,
0.0685054064,
0.0493773855,
-0.0403141826,
0.0529558547,
0.0337737575,
0.0058102058,
-0.0423670597,
0.0155994622,
-0.0157321617,
0.0350353308,
-0.0061824215,
0.0109000625,
0.0484996103,
0.0568510778,
-0.0750015453,
-0.0363121219,
0.0015408025,
0.0074411505,
-0.0095609231,
0.0827703774,
-0.0346884131,
-0.0043001836,
-0.0222093668,
0.0759260654,
-0.0254008286,
0.0373394787,
-0.0126068611,
0.0156165725,
0.0177482516,
0.0084916893,
-0.0554894134,
-0.027651431,
-0.0120013766,
-0.0068129939,
0.0087872939,
-0.1149269044,
-0.0057839318,
0.0518646762,
3.024e-7,
0.0269088745,
0.0216868799,
-0.0132382307,
-0.0344271511,
0.0391039923,
0.0302693844,
0.0248050075,
0.0584106557,
0.0014728792,
0.0022256332,
0.0120313531,
0.0171056837,
-0.0190185923,
-0.0138657046,
-0.1515092999,
-0.0283915922,
-0.0411929525,
0.0230847802,
0.0104892319,
0.0216252375,
0.0254622493,
0.1307557672,
-0.0121821342,
0.0038038904,
-0.0179940518,
0.0075710411,
0.0132265529,
0.0028107765,
0.0118268495,
0.0152414115,
0.0292204265,
0.0065017832,
-0.0781969652,
-0.0098197004,
0.0012134535,
0.0183598176,
-0.0092469612,
0.0733202472,
-0.0050596087,
-0.0499296784,
0.0642626733,
0.0286611076,
0.009288826,
-0.0016522865,
0.0355114639,
-0.0587955974,
-0.0525290258,
-0.0511095189,
0.0102292057,
0.0291092582,
0.0137584228,
-0.0161590241,
0.0160217807,
-0.0118168229,
0.0050611529,
-0.0689517036,
-0.0247240793,
-0.1092442498,
0.0167412944,
0.0085736625,
-0.0172456075,
-0.0077574053,
-0.0157879237,
-0.0683394819,
0.0425333716,
-0.020286778,
0.0030183471,
2.069290664e-34,
0.0899297073,
-0.0370036811,
-0.0063238759,
0.0053131701,
-0.0092895273,
-0.0219920874,
-0.0421715379,
-0.0230211671,
0.0431635082,
-0.0535399951,
-0.0305275936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14503v1 | Diversify Question Generation with Retrieval-Augmented Style Transfer | 2023-10-23T02:27:31 | 2023-10-23T02:27:31 | Qi Gou, Zehua Xia, Bowen Yu, Haiyang Yu, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li, Nguyen Cam-Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given a textual passage and an answer, humans are able to ask questions with
various expressions, but this ability is still challenging for most question
generation (QG) systems. Existing solutions mainly focus on the internal
knowledge within the given passage or the semantic word space for diverse
content planning. These methods, however, have not considered the potential of
external knowledge for expression diversity. To bridge this gap, we propose
RAST, a framework for Retrieval-Augmented Style Transfer, where the objective
is to utilize the style of diverse templates for question generation. For
training RAST, we develop a novel Reinforcement Learning (RL) based approach
that maximizes a weighted combination of diversity reward and consistency
reward. Here, the consistency reward is computed by a Question-Answering (QA)
model, whereas the diversity reward measures how much the final output mimics
the retrieved template. Experimental results show that our method outperforms
previous diversity-driven baselines on diversity while being comparable in
terms of consistency scores. Our code is available at
https://github.com/gouqi666/RAST. | [
0.0561161451,
0.0215418842,
0.0017816126,
-0.0095257545,
-0.0302645098,
-0.0039684251,
-0.0183315799,
0.0137423705,
-0.0252982471,
0.0122913355,
-0.0091596767,
-0.0686260238,
-0.0300678946,
0.0240839887,
0.0390689522,
-0.0677544549,
0.012651179,
-0.008543957,
0.0019050722,
0.0040414399,
0.024723934,
0.0198990814,
-0.0033759414,
0.0357698426,
-0.0215391833,
-0.0019024647,
-0.044622384,
0.0324182026,
0.0429944284,
-0.011719577,
0.050121922,
0.031070834,
0.0217482429,
0.0063987682,
0.0000017957,
-0.0599435195,
-0.0336738452,
0.0051541333,
0.0486590527,
-0.0540416799,
0.0229855031,
0.0485656038,
0.0393925384,
0.0397776812,
-0.0396070965,
0.0023291402,
0.0457714424,
0.0607842356,
0.0805420056,
0.0855194032,
-0.0057924236,
-0.0202364083,
0.028879812,
-0.0420152433,
0.0808634311,
-0.0098924022,
-0.0231131837,
-0.0016139508,
0.0439237915,
0.0028848464,
-0.0015494225,
0.0158995166,
0.0368944481,
-0.0213072672,
0.0019781238,
0.0166738778,
-0.0234850794,
0.0102724312,
-0.013211946,
0.0758419409,
0.0034180265,
0.0154693704,
0.0233951584,
0.0031199302,
0.0582701005,
0.022437254,
-0.0513513051,
0.0269442685,
-0.0180993397,
-0.0219709352,
-0.013875952,
0.0184211787,
-0.0038153478,
0.0112682916,
-0.0027973773,
0.0113925217,
0.0332690924,
-0.0321833789,
-0.041546192,
0.0120519381,
0.00550099,
-0.0559164733,
0.0028556464,
0.0259261895,
-0.0484309308,
0.024589302,
-0.0446967147,
-0.0333778411,
0.0168971922,
0.0536593236,
0.0273058452,
0.0111134732,
0.0020018241,
0.016055543,
-0.0307116807,
0.0440888479,
-0.0403020941,
0.0074691293,
-0.0621330328,
0.0109226191,
-0.0536056496,
-0.0416347235,
-0.0413830914,
0.0368258357,
-0.0104198903,
-0.0329355113,
-0.0220751651,
0.0396604314,
0.0052918834,
-0.028133804,
0.0039898548,
0.0518980362,
-0.062397223,
-0.0147740459,
-0.0391878113,
0.0229019579,
-0.0537216477,
-0.0066846465,
0.0785537362,
-0.0459920987,
-0.0162099525,
0.0246323124,
0.0363651328,
-0.0393980816,
0.0069373953,
0.0125105567,
-0.0690207928,
-0.0016000153,
-0.0055055451,
-0.0450315438,
-0.0019212122,
-0.0241160169,
0.0274023525,
-0.0777931064,
0.0198203698,
-0.0137043791,
-0.0295453127,
0.0035552292,
0.0107524609,
0.0390327312,
0.0050721122,
0.0171054415,
0.0215001162,
-0.0104767699,
0.0653552637,
0.0042378278,
0.0027755077,
0.0376132838,
0.0249021836,
0.0291013103,
0.0042851376,
0.0218906179,
0.0006620386,
-0.0046181022,
0.0299411751,
0.0188898947,
-0.0113744475,
0.0197573733,
0.0255017858,
0.0491771922,
0.0110260267,
0.0617753491,
-0.0365448222,
-0.002118954,
0.0529546812,
-0.003152306,
0.0142735178,
0.0186741836,
0.0498539619,
0.0226838645,
-0.0142817181,
0.0182064995,
-0.0092157414,
0.065760985,
0.0055988417,
0.0398100019,
0.0654090494,
0.0401339307,
-0.0376003049,
0.0035993392,
0.0160584152,
0.0172916315,
-0.0086842803,
0.0034165813,
-0.0227745064,
0.039480865,
-0.0425243005,
0.0192441475,
-0.0133405281,
-0.0559971668,
0.0147106126,
-0.0366984122,
0.0697884709,
0.0170398243,
0.0461927168,
-0.0117249982,
-0.0553647503,
-0.0411229283,
-0.0226062424,
0.0401372425,
0.0355618261,
0.000492172,
0.0199762695,
-0.0631833002,
-0.0094481045,
-0.0493067801,
-0.023862239,
0.06953834,
0.0136926277,
0.0272891168,
0.0272898637,
-0.0184247289,
-0.009323664,
0.0422506891,
0.0027882804,
-0.0396341383,
0.0464619845,
-0.0011844158,
-0.0218861718,
0.0001686209,
-0.0274147894,
0.0267681368,
-0.0343451425,
-0.050014656,
-0.0325535759,
0.0076070419,
-0.0869012475,
-0.0738697648,
-0.0108911488,
-0.0729999766,
0.0024907035,
0.0198938791,
-0.0262302272,
-0.0602642559,
0.0193195026,
-0.064758949,
-0.0145690236,
-0.0591735095,
-0.0394340008,
0.0367040075,
0.0219461899,
-0.0511197299,
0.0607984029,
0.0204816721,
0.003512705,
0.0066708825,
-0.0079297451,
0.0080450764,
-0.0556982122,
-0.0013420872,
-0.0106263552,
-0.0437102281,
0.0342104733,
0.0455504954,
0.0699628294,
-0.0689608157,
-0.0509623811,
-0.0417277701,
0.0326699391,
-0.0471092612,
0.0173402019,
0.0425046496,
0.0620279312,
-0.0211912282,
-0.0335326195,
-0.1114910096,
-0.0170432646,
0.0217976905,
0.0294853505,
0.0499054231,
0.0275888108,
0.0352997519,
0.001181458,
-0.0061180382,
0.0169509873,
0.043194741,
0.0258532446,
0.0796329975,
-0.0366625153,
-0.0185191762,
-0.0560491122,
-0.0271568559,
0.0225880668,
-0.0010841826,
0.0210509375,
-0.0450143442,
0.0750915334,
0.0410881266,
0.0518897586,
-0.0315493681,
0.0094637815,
0.0174767412,
-0.0429720245,
0.0568612218,
-0.0271395314,
0.0056113596,
0.022795219,
-0.042378705,
0.053245265,
0.0101906788,
0.0228481367,
-0.0122462297,
-0.0713448897,
0.0391877443,
0.0292976201,
-0.0467905328,
-0.0395724513,
0.0169556346,
-0.0320360772,
0.0109440703,
-0.0225882549,
-0.0198702235,
0.0612319447,
0.0149609968,
-0.0214709975,
-0.0462280698,
0.0232068468,
-0.0493597537,
0.0499403104,
-0.0208556466,
0.0277590267,
0.0182135571,
-0.0395556614,
-0.0862038434,
-0.0059797196,
0.0418472327,
-0.0293115806,
0.027754534,
-0.0247318931,
-0.000021871,
-0.0078310249,
-0.0377203673,
-0.0612568036,
-0.02091695,
0.0456724837,
0.0008838046,
0.0203774814,
-0.0074628075,
-0.0011302003,
-0.0035395771,
0.0434425622,
0.0571983159,
-0.0658353344,
-0.017060522,
-0.0095360829,
0.099419646,
0.0889106765,
0.036156565,
0.0200091898,
-0.0569487847,
-0.0190273765,
0.0210293867,
0.0133483419,
-0.0023072346,
0.0239228122,
0.0105096325,
0.003832259,
-0.036527399,
-0.00943809,
0.0349884517,
0.0812515393,
-0.0253254212,
-0.0738629028,
0.0624026842,
0.053810209,
-0.0284804441,
-0.0336242579,
-0.0568366386,
0.095012635,
0.0153317079,
0.0661285371,
-0.0339167938,
-0.0212473031,
-0.0180345196,
0.0320403054,
-0.0047180364,
-0.0289209057,
-0.0182000939,
-0.0999586731,
0.0103371218,
-0.0158945732,
-0.0954274908,
0.0159769822,
0.0220624208,
-0.0140442308,
0.0343811028,
-0.0192035604,
0.0169746708,
-0.0128045119,
0.0145005314,
0.0328072309,
-0.0014533853,
-0.0244467668,
-0.0424058735,
-0.0189697295,
-0.0150854727,
0.099524267,
0.0130701447,
-0.0012542638,
-0.0417464375,
-0.0376692526,
-0.0325852148,
-0.0021887319,
0.0126558971,
0.0173383262,
0.0183587447,
-0.004161248,
-0.0348541364,
0.0497995839,
-0.0153625458,
0.0205567461,
0.0338912979,
0.028994387,
-0.0020653279,
-0.0254909787,
-0.0393827073,
-0.0167647339,
0.0300707463,
0.0538943633,
0.0330175534,
-0.0504603647,
-0.0355356447,
-0.0367538221,
0.0103766909,
-0.1147642061,
0.0173150077,
-0.0082376739,
0.000106266,
0.0468021743,
-0.1322158873,
-0.0144690517,
0.0019947356,
0.0430815369,
-0.0274258424,
-0.0573478416,
-0.0377664194,
0.0116056791,
-0.0367485508,
-0.0002020633,
0.0052144867,
-0.0048438041,
-0.0301427506,
-0.0130316606,
-0.0281672701,
-0.0933784992,
-0.0175317414,
0.0112818833,
-0.0795567334,
-0.0351320468,
-0.0152987782,
0.0575589538,
0.0065281941,
0.0176950321,
-0.0005151879,
-0.0303958189,
0.070050925,
0.0657739267,
0.0188653637,
-0.0036688796,
-0.0153318839,
-0.0137359295,
-0.0045412173,
0.0218105912,
-0.0633765981,
-0.0087189628,
0.0050112517,
0.0679926425,
0.0595910735,
0.0049647265,
0.033760041,
0.0037511936,
-0.0609813109,
-0.0016876075,
0.0098423343,
-0.0226683281,
-0.0052249338,
-0.003660317,
-0.0265640896,
-0.0393572226,
0.006927826,
0.0239325166,
0.0021920998,
0.0114241149,
0.0066620521,
0.0250542816,
0.0619315058,
-0.03544572,
-0.0339360572,
0.0349054076,
0.0261239558,
0.0001306366,
-0.0056382865,
-0.0113852546,
0.0191549007,
-0.0130976327,
0.0591014139,
0.0017076449,
0.0902895033,
0.0303438418,
-0.0286482703,
0.0159271564,
0.0091763679,
-0.0941321924,
-0.0378558151,
-0.0178443044,
-0.0051921331,
-0.0038286264,
0.0177376959,
0.018369263,
-0.0098077245,
0.0008828752,
0.0037682601,
0.031036349,
0.0125039341,
-0.022647351,
0.0290246457,
0.0204799566,
0.0204959996,
-0.0481643081,
0.0364640802,
-0.0378378294,
0.006268037,
-0.0175990686,
0.0151689313,
-0.0404233746,
-0.0129093798,
0.0185441207,
0.0346321538,
0.0177552644,
0.0198289249,
-0.0219271202,
-0.0302026998,
0.027560696,
0.0169817954,
0.0224256217,
0.0131566077,
0.0455612615,
0.0578165017,
-0.0118203303,
-0.0212664735,
-0.0499599762,
0.034308821,
-0.0596705563,
-0.0177010335,
-0.0168756563,
-6.280072692e-33,
-0.0029280966,
-0.0202093739,
0.0023198321,
-0.0786001906,
-0.0467346944,
0.0034196794,
-0.0474525243,
-0.0084703304,
0.0005856316,
0.0119666895,
-0.0272407569,
-0.0119728763,
-0.0131878098,
0.0657907799,
0.016980432,
-0.0023339645,
0.0233170744,
0.0108158225,
-0.065617606,
0.0483589396,
0.0494263694,
0.0266186018,
0.0206233338,
0.0252081119,
-0.0052936715,
-0.0263652913,
-0.0092852116,
0.0261837151,
0.0097950725,
0.0473545901,
0.0012778318,
0.0004485926,
0.0325149372,
-0.0484898798,
-0.0058274358,
0.0126784118,
-0.0339901708,
-0.0710388869,
-0.0018157266,
-0.0394041352,
-0.0942709967,
-0.0252367072,
0.0145389531,
-0.0226369873,
0.0544814058,
-0.0195534173,
0.0257594902,
0.0154295061,
0.0080870194,
-0.0417195261,
-0.0302085821,
-0.0026394427,
-0.0196272209,
-0.0360496007,
-0.0757977664,
0.0739231184,
0.0051339394,
-0.0185064804,
0.0163006596,
0.007639355,
-0.0096920645,
0.0246514622,
0.0298171248,
0.0614276454,
-0.0245318599,
0.026100412,
-0.0456804521,
0.0140885273,
-0.0257594213,
-0.0275858287,
-0.0077789524,
0.0435849726,
0.0239765234,
0.0784699321,
0.0207784697,
0.0464449264,
-0.018251719,
0.061586272,
0.0193590187,
0.0165425371,
0.012317339,
-0.0007881088,
-0.011776071,
0.0103781186,
-0.0315805413,
0.0316216759,
-0.040740855,
-0.0278436635,
0.049338609,
0.0349324569,
-0.0391302556,
-0.0089759063,
0.0286685731,
0.0084352,
0.0291542914,
0.0080326386,
-0.0575888455,
0.021769587,
-0.0162623003,
0.0150709208,
-0.0114466427,
0.0053955233,
0.0630714446,
-0.0026848949,
-0.0195616093,
0.0344695523,
0.029199807,
0.0303149745,
-0.0680504143,
-0.0032877666,
-0.0247160178,
0.0807844177,
-0.0254020039,
-0.0212464035,
0.0011047622,
0.0022613052,
-0.0246404558,
0.0262673516,
0.0203435738,
-0.01499369,
-0.0428825505,
-0.0423412248,
-0.0025657723,
0.0113795158,
-0.0373318866,
0.0430753157,
-0.0224502068,
-0.0197206233,
-0.0208428986,
-0.03278929,
-0.0180813093,
0.0132561196,
2.568e-7,
-0.0026332736,
0.0032027811,
0.0378033258,
0.0527863689,
0.0041844007,
0.0224228911,
0.0119563816,
0.0647122711,
0.0042772791,
0.0138172414,
0.020650968,
0.0187037215,
0.0424660482,
-0.0008728724,
-0.0862720758,
-0.000314626,
-0.088467814,
0.0037113754,
-0.0345135853,
-0.0241109636,
0.0601915494,
0.0419626608,
-0.0041790083,
-0.015458663,
0.0235748664,
-0.0191886723,
0.0781838074,
0.020595355,
0.0035269759,
0.037172053,
0.0375172943,
-0.0252347309,
0.0011922052,
-0.0283371527,
-0.0140190823,
0.0218553897,
0.0318043604,
0.018022567,
0.0290406458,
-0.0175559223,
0.0081831487,
0.0328302681,
0.0406981036,
-0.0949756727,
0.0463999771,
-0.0177063514,
-0.0131019233,
-0.053746976,
-0.0347656049,
-0.0204361435,
0.0254542492,
-0.0315444507,
-0.018623108,
0.0097159408,
0.0044964552,
0.0240305662,
0.0216596648,
-0.0570187643,
-0.0375937186,
-0.0180187058,
-0.0269969534,
-0.0079653813,
-0.0742417946,
0.0225638263,
-0.0409738645,
-0.0398564413,
-0.0005804562,
2.069889431e-34,
0.0082124015,
-0.0110232094,
-0.0047984021,
0.0022444895,
0.0199208874,
0.0009782999,
-0.0212538056,
0.0013747923,
0.0339062288,
-0.0787148178,
-0.040574003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14495v1 | InstructExcel: A Benchmark for Natural Language Instruction in Excel | 2023-10-23T02:00:55 | 2023-10-23T02:00:55 | Justin Payan, Swaroop Mishra, Mukul Singh, Carina Negreanu, Christian Poelitz, Chitta Baral, Subhro Roy, Rasika Chakravarthy, Benjamin Van Durme, Elnaz Nouri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the evolution of Large Language Models (LLMs) we can solve increasingly
more complex NLP tasks across various domains, including spreadsheets. This
work investigates whether LLMs can generate code (Excel OfficeScripts, a
TypeScript API for executing many tasks in Excel) that solves Excel specific
tasks provided via natural language user instructions. To do so we introduce a
new large-scale benchmark, InstructExcel, created by leveraging the 'Automate'
feature in Excel to automatically generate OfficeScripts from users' actions.
Our benchmark includes over 10k samples covering 170+ Excel operations across
2,000 publicly available Excel spreadsheets. Experiments across various
zero-shot and few-shot settings show that InstructExcel is a hard benchmark for
state of the art models like GPT-4. We observe that (1) using GPT-4 over
GPT-3.5, (2) providing more in-context examples, and (3) dynamic prompting can
help improve performance on this benchmark. | [
0.0127600869,
0.053476721,
-0.0133314366,
0.012997495,
-0.0473456457,
0.005647134,
-0.0342096612,
0.0094827404,
0.0431437865,
-0.0290412679,
-0.036024332,
-0.0297222193,
0.0063780695,
0.0289696883,
0.0246771481,
-0.0483206958,
0.0025185896,
-0.007434384,
0.0012830852,
0.0126498807,
0.0048523587,
0.0062386855,
-0.0240521077,
0.0504631214,
0.023715362,
-0.0247688834,
-0.0192581415,
-0.0211476125,
-0.0230715349,
-0.0190476049,
-0.0061080391,
0.0762314275,
0.0132138738,
0.0163682252,
0.0000019295,
-0.0628281459,
-0.0037879639,
-0.0081322845,
-0.0583218932,
0.0213257503,
0.0111218337,
-0.0288047548,
-0.0202084221,
0.0239122752,
-0.0268033911,
-0.012146893,
0.0208946411,
-0.0037361793,
0.0718489066,
0.0602740534,
-0.0128692212,
0.0232616235,
0.022233706,
-0.0035676325,
0.0550727472,
-0.0961228982,
0.0003214272,
-0.0105585828,
0.0834878534,
-0.0284597836,
0.0226628594,
0.0271140691,
0.0393956602,
-0.0180405341,
-0.0090481127,
0.0207286421,
-0.0334761068,
0.0014356285,
-0.069329001,
0.0864523724,
-0.0208499841,
0.0531910323,
0.0048621632,
-0.0132732326,
0.0110854702,
-0.0353097804,
-0.0617191941,
-0.0194790903,
-0.0263334326,
-0.0405273698,
0.0268592853,
-0.0085655814,
0.0123528885,
0.0141857015,
0.0335359313,
0.0051007359,
-0.0035367364,
-0.0432817154,
0.0445341654,
0.0176181346,
0.0077730012,
-0.0605755262,
0.0554467104,
0.0584959574,
-0.0487375036,
0.0075962907,
-0.0220216271,
-0.0215057991,
0.0544720814,
-0.0490951911,
0.0888622478,
0.0408856682,
0.0149830496,
0.0342874788,
0.0056714769,
0.0719686747,
0.011557891,
-0.0565384664,
0.0099556167,
-0.0001159204,
-0.0572853349,
-0.010880678,
-0.0348655358,
0.0226934385,
-0.0648739859,
0.0147329327,
-0.0249854494,
0.0086197192,
-0.0302130021,
0.0674470663,
0.0138035817,
-0.0272163674,
-0.0271365941,
-0.0276260842,
-0.0534327477,
-0.0114614237,
-0.0511738919,
-0.0335186496,
-0.0100404425,
-0.0939484537,
-0.0029373297,
-0.0131753124,
0.0216173325,
-0.008768633,
0.022722913,
0.0964705199,
-0.0117147779,
-0.0201021619,
-0.033056736,
-0.0533389561,
-0.0018971382,
-0.0740271658,
-0.0314492248,
-0.0766030699,
0.0146790547,
0.0028257212,
-0.0364742465,
-0.0474213287,
0.0227078982,
0.0350906402,
0.0036237636,
0.0713180378,
-0.0038521362,
-0.0103012044,
-0.0135475341,
-0.010845717,
-0.0192936659,
0.0520359203,
0.010421643,
0.0014111727,
0.0003634429,
-0.0219830703,
0.0717284232,
0.0703368038,
-0.0136504387,
-0.0202578623,
0.0536768138,
0.0484670363,
-0.0189835168,
0.0620295107,
-0.0123595828,
0.0517891198,
0.0055091428,
0.0466373973,
0.0287949294,
0.0959794372,
-0.011933418,
0.02064576,
0.0447139405,
0.0474006124,
0.0390658416,
-0.0341506004,
-0.041084405,
0.0328157507,
0.0027384679,
0.0196576752,
0.0098256739,
0.0413853079,
0.0018087858,
-0.0669495016,
-0.0006718237,
0.0022046578,
-0.0186819863,
-0.0300146602,
0.0405531526,
0.0037264044,
-0.07141608,
0.0095734652,
-0.0268193632,
-0.0591896325,
-0.0384057648,
-0.0171982888,
-0.0241255425,
0.1025728211,
0.0535245501,
-0.0353737473,
-0.0333994403,
-0.0482748225,
-0.0383238457,
0.0237460732,
0.0414817259,
-0.0157508962,
0.0228878036,
-0.053907223,
0.0098887607,
-0.0111829583,
0.0114225661,
0.006243668,
0.0647644848,
-0.0099016819,
-0.0001196384,
-0.0476758443,
-0.0234862678,
0.0133180199,
-0.0295671225,
-0.0888073593,
0.0291837025,
0.0114030251,
0.0260702781,
0.033894822,
0.0040987981,
-0.0015415538,
-0.0067306762,
0.0181985479,
-0.0040486273,
-0.0322095901,
-0.048108153,
-0.0162663572,
0.0097434297,
0.0188573916,
-0.0787375942,
0.011969055,
-0.0105263097,
-0.006528622,
-0.0074264328,
-0.0272948816,
0.0035264017,
-0.0157874823,
0.0212284699,
0.0336407535,
-0.0386721082,
-0.0179467667,
0.0289008766,
-0.0098243058,
0.0136824148,
0.0443691276,
-0.0151544716,
0.030548472,
-0.0502126254,
0.0416524932,
0.0343253128,
-0.0161799137,
0.0232911836,
-0.0164848957,
0.0433822721,
-0.0350046419,
-0.0259687323,
-0.062782459,
0.037132591,
-0.0055867997,
0.0037580261,
0.0143519798,
0.0432787985,
-0.0216884948,
-0.0218351409,
-0.0299066659,
-0.0218292605,
0.0183701906,
-0.01273653,
0.0237664357,
-0.0329552479,
-0.0230151992,
-0.0367238075,
0.0120799709,
-0.0216311794,
-0.0162327513,
0.0386820771,
-0.0127987396,
-0.0128044263,
0.0160847977,
0.0047886493,
0.0133728907,
0.0150586078,
0.0169595778,
0.0028985285,
-0.0224015024,
0.072210215,
0.0762989745,
-0.0432296693,
0.0671156421,
0.0059049819,
-0.03659508,
-0.0479354113,
0.0249727163,
0.0232141353,
-0.0367162637,
-0.0055079972,
-0.0455823243,
0.0390920565,
0.0770176053,
-0.000653376,
0.0199425574,
-0.0519405268,
-0.0010531151,
-0.0052837185,
0.0121869007,
-0.0296539981,
0.0252882615,
-0.0439847484,
0.019378446,
-0.0168494266,
-0.0779907927,
0.0374579914,
-0.0295618996,
-0.0161343552,
-0.0603799522,
-0.0306490101,
-0.0136708319,
0.0764983222,
0.0248474106,
-0.0265851431,
-0.0021476781,
-0.0201923549,
-0.0028343403,
0.0337480903,
0.012871094,
-0.0293869842,
0.0818407387,
-0.0767424628,
0.0024177732,
-0.0217806734,
-0.068271704,
-0.0090452684,
-0.0119094057,
-0.0521376915,
0.0161885787,
0.0544128641,
-0.0521418937,
-0.0165530685,
-0.0342734568,
0.0346459076,
0.0736030266,
0.0141454833,
-0.0513155088,
-0.0132660698,
-0.0115505671,
0.0026917467,
-0.0094320811,
-0.0639600456,
-0.02131721,
0.0213083066,
0.0062749446,
-0.0142572178,
0.0145422975,
0.0107959183,
0.0229710937,
-0.0047794152,
-0.0517138578,
-0.0324123278,
0.0577780157,
0.0416045189,
-0.0638759509,
-0.0025400149,
0.084698841,
0.0481344499,
-0.000572946,
-0.0145305544,
-0.0261189025,
-0.0000260035,
0.0204532575,
0.0722647011,
-0.0943316668,
-0.0349572748,
0.0082982928,
0.0320930928,
0.004356822,
-0.0251745805,
-0.0263681393,
-0.1481742561,
0.0810867697,
-0.0175929759,
-0.0015671034,
-0.0311761852,
-0.0244291145,
0.005793937,
-0.0165966526,
-0.0022489782,
0.0239857715,
-0.0134924436,
0.0276585724,
-0.0079193488,
-0.0636218935,
-0.033533603,
0.025016753,
-0.0360051654,
0.0081032254,
0.0564812347,
0.0172000416,
0.0095174024,
-0.0145935314,
-0.0122330645,
0.0299503896,
-0.0066384193,
-0.0246403292,
0.0857222751,
0.0144548034,
-0.0130607821,
-0.0299501605,
0.0552487746,
-0.0625728965,
0.0223442055,
0.0510829911,
0.0738822892,
-0.0110459765,
-0.0023267432,
-0.0027789457,
0.0031359335,
-0.0075001535,
0.0505226776,
0.0068348264,
-0.0271603651,
-0.0598045029,
-0.087499015,
-0.0058662253,
-0.1006676331,
0.0127050551,
-0.0193613917,
-0.0060512121,
0.0138708046,
-0.0494322181,
-0.0606715605,
0.1022093371,
0.0391249135,
0.0020840592,
0.0169753507,
-0.0187201537,
0.0262687579,
-0.0417779237,
-0.0202395059,
0.0015770432,
0.0564455912,
-0.0328800492,
-0.0597253963,
0.0382424854,
0.0210948326,
-0.0111828847,
0.0494131893,
-0.0342311263,
-0.0416379385,
-0.0006011878,
0.0325512737,
0.0227903258,
0.0308340918,
-0.0017049341,
-0.005312277,
-0.0073131588,
0.0479774065,
-0.0383100659,
-0.0152237769,
0.0105865654,
0.0202493928,
0.0044873911,
0.0268074907,
-0.0323317945,
-0.0229464024,
-0.0165204126,
0.0487871952,
-0.0159396324,
-0.0170163214,
0.0246771593,
0.0408431999,
-0.0473404303,
0.0142570324,
-0.0163994208,
-0.0009918506,
-0.0070352131,
0.0142687876,
-0.0189982038,
-0.0343602747,
-0.0238455255,
0.0053969319,
-0.0043334402,
0.0197445899,
0.0762322918,
-0.0208571441,
-0.0005327812,
-0.0094924457,
0.0110209323,
0.0240429584,
0.0291194506,
0.0208952874,
-0.03057242,
-0.0087825889,
0.0161918364,
0.0093942508,
0.0473576821,
0.0018389154,
0.0724799931,
0.0113949049,
0.0041145482,
0.0070155412,
0.0200102683,
-0.0112792635,
-0.0448348187,
-0.0108728092,
-0.0045518451,
0.0377002321,
-0.0223667771,
0.0096022915,
-0.0748877376,
-0.0132151935,
0.0052896645,
0.0386411026,
-0.0005954783,
-0.018147964,
0.0227419604,
0.0150929596,
0.0205855165,
-0.0501855612,
0.0907783657,
0.0289019011,
0.0200399216,
0.0023425103,
-0.0081890076,
-0.0781141445,
-0.0135989171,
0.0474005602,
-0.0082527893,
0.0213541184,
-0.0031135683,
-0.0331929997,
-0.0446890146,
0.0258674882,
0.0142793115,
-0.0173229054,
-0.037413016,
0.0670491606,
0.0712748989,
0.0245936532,
-0.0284157954,
-0.0199758448,
0.0279406421,
-0.0204815194,
-0.0526954457,
-0.0598517172,
-5.696135587e-33,
-0.0193692837,
-0.0427025035,
0.0291088875,
0.0391775593,
0.023969993,
-0.021735929,
-0.0422301777,
-0.0179571733,
0.0201472901,
-0.0201722216,
-0.0188239608,
0.0109338686,
0.0139884334,
-0.0060303728,
0.0133954799,
-0.0043275203,
0.0405441821,
-0.023081366,
-0.0432369076,
-0.002403216,
-0.0265026055,
0.0116595263,
0.0405978598,
-0.0636280477,
0.0089906072,
0.0352965258,
0.0001751351,
0.0111677265,
0.001876734,
0.0174528696,
-0.0237720385,
0.0304229204,
0.0194328986,
-0.0443049185,
-0.0165745672,
0.0413117595,
-0.0531836264,
-0.0434726551,
0.0105560869,
0.0010877803,
-0.0541469827,
-0.0460180752,
0.033097025,
-0.0152000366,
-0.0383296013,
0.0060243709,
0.0386213362,
-0.01271402,
0.004649369,
0.0016823295,
-0.0680311024,
0.0361930467,
-0.0181463324,
-0.0216843393,
0.0162285902,
0.0336851925,
-0.0100961337,
-0.0259012152,
0.0110928649,
-0.0182006471,
0.0659658909,
0.0228638239,
0.0527248755,
0.0135670705,
0.0147370892,
0.030314723,
0.0337809436,
0.0313513465,
-0.0569608808,
-0.0021862963,
0.0109876068,
0.0212495159,
0.0470330119,
0.0367101766,
0.0232404843,
0.0454012565,
-0.0011297509,
0.0879011303,
0.0100359665,
0.0063457857,
-0.0104275588,
0.0039278213,
-0.0289429501,
-0.0081183985,
-0.0194744579,
-0.0060734712,
-0.0134103075,
-0.0184509344,
0.0442079529,
-0.0012868046,
0.0552381054,
-0.0030078853,
0.0087875929,
0.0363054797,
-0.0167610813,
-0.0114023238,
0.0099680554,
0.0263848845,
0.0161067843,
-0.0289256386,
-0.0739234611,
0.0492231809,
-0.0443012007,
0.0825861841,
0.0561733022,
0.0372509658,
-0.0134906694,
0.0115786642,
-0.091494821,
0.0072041294,
-0.0403345525,
0.0567360781,
-0.0161167458,
-0.0190204885,
0.0122218765,
-0.0106986584,
-0.0133393491,
0.0647153407,
0.0027424067,
-0.0528092869,
-0.0592830777,
-0.0078162355,
0.0082708681,
0.0026119831,
-0.0338502564,
0.0076310271,
-0.0379431657,
-0.0057543023,
0.015496606,
-0.0213323496,
0.01967429,
-0.0085186334,
2.528e-7,
0.0150527144,
0.0303819664,
0.0278524645,
0.0622362867,
-0.0192637295,
0.0134570459,
-0.0174830128,
-0.0168174561,
-0.0057083964,
0.0150646642,
0.0067352494,
-0.0109431734,
0.0633705631,
0.048096057,
-0.0766499192,
-0.0125141982,
-0.0434884466,
0.0280004311,
-0.0816538632,
0.0234268289,
0.0397061743,
0.0574864745,
-0.0213826038,
0.0271470807,
0.0231230948,
-0.0619453415,
0.0439975448,
-0.0334301367,
0.0297250152,
0.0137489066,
-0.0237211566,
0.0186530072,
-0.0147058945,
0.0120011903,
-0.0139962118,
-0.0125928549,
0.0066746897,
0.1076796204,
-0.0020869432,
0.0392915905,
0.0074384776,
-0.0664701313,
-0.0028606362,
-0.0306448732,
0.027521709,
-0.0495819002,
-0.0210292358,
0.0612330474,
-0.0157170147,
-0.013206536,
0.0017250434,
-0.0076234206,
-0.0355809778,
0.0097052092,
-0.0023618694,
-0.0108053545,
0.010300071,
-0.0149700996,
-0.0152616845,
0.0447534397,
-0.0004386448,
-0.0085762264,
-0.0560909472,
-0.0081140157,
-0.0338874236,
-0.0070924805,
-0.0015468516,
2.511704493e-34,
0.0134040872,
-0.0343406834,
0.0577829517,
0.0292362049,
0.0754579604,
0.0000786804,
0.0018053139,
0.0581032149,
0.0464932621,
-0.0675929561,
-0.0093152858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14491v1 | Towards a Mechanistic Interpretation of Multi-Step Reasoning Capabilities of Language Models | 2023-10-23T01:47:29 | 2023-10-23T01:47:29 | Yifan Hou, Jiaoda Li, Yu Fei, Alessandro Stolfo, Wangchunshu Zhou, Guangtao Zeng, Antoine Bosselut, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has shown that language models (LMs) have strong multi-step
(i.e., procedural) reasoning capabilities. However, it is unclear whether LMs
perform these tasks by cheating with answers memorized from pretraining corpus,
or, via a multi-step reasoning mechanism. In this paper, we try to answer this
question by exploring a mechanistic interpretation of LMs for multi-step
reasoning tasks. Concretely, we hypothesize that the LM implicitly embeds a
reasoning tree resembling the correct reasoning process within it. We test this
hypothesis by introducing a new probing approach (called MechanisticProbe) that
recovers the reasoning tree from the model's attention patterns. We use our
probe to analyze two LMs: GPT-2 on a synthetic task (k-th smallest element),
and LLaMA on two simple language-based reasoning tasks (ProofWriter & AI2
Reasoning Challenge). We show that MechanisticProbe is able to detect the
information of the reasoning tree from the model's attentions for most
examples, suggesting that the LM indeed is going through a process of
multi-step reasoning within its architecture in many cases. | [
0.0118953045,
0.0108806109,
-0.048546005,
0.0290745683,
-0.0605658926,
0.0370187312,
-0.0215030778,
-0.0120523758,
0.0103490129,
-0.0394762494,
-0.0257564224,
-0.035309121,
-0.0015085574,
0.0068561845,
0.0541124567,
-0.0181366615,
0.0423165672,
-0.0803325549,
0.0307633504,
-0.0277160201,
-0.0262277387,
0.0013893843,
0.0113264965,
0.0016913256,
0.0147963576,
-0.0300828367,
-0.0477388836,
-0.0376439579,
-0.0105188871,
-0.0148535678,
-0.0306584574,
0.0280036386,
-0.005306575,
0.0354475304,
0.0000020256,
-0.0520381145,
0.0128881857,
-0.0043100445,
-0.0627416149,
0.0203576088,
-0.017898865,
0.0176882129,
-0.0060984911,
0.0238217805,
-0.0397299416,
0.0173356459,
0.0337338895,
0.0408695005,
0.0306100864,
0.0572446771,
0.0120606693,
-0.0546492226,
0.0192694254,
-0.0163685381,
0.023057336,
-0.0347970165,
-0.000231185,
-0.005410566,
0.0088148694,
0.0126918256,
-0.0118752243,
0.0099934572,
0.0650372207,
0.0140416576,
-0.0469198152,
0.0448089428,
-0.0049333712,
-0.0192989781,
0.0134718874,
0.0204881188,
-0.0067750216,
-0.0386177413,
-0.013565396,
0.0080133388,
0.0052952394,
0.0140970116,
-0.0343581215,
0.0734044388,
-0.0252996944,
0.0221170429,
0.0491151698,
-0.0716622993,
0.0453711301,
-0.0237767603,
-0.0536884107,
0.1358570606,
-0.0104166241,
-0.035189718,
0.0112722581,
0.0005496403,
0.0129532218,
-0.0740345418,
-0.0428041779,
0.0626552328,
-0.0044654068,
0.036913272,
-0.0047680056,
0.0559132695,
0.0119740674,
-0.0189397018,
0.037448667,
0.0449517593,
-0.0042030681,
0.0411807857,
-0.0439034514,
0.0326662101,
-0.0405264236,
0.0607112348,
-0.0411042012,
-0.0025372994,
-0.0329869017,
-0.0599340126,
0.0028481535,
0.0478959717,
0.0347529687,
0.0027069093,
-0.0088170972,
0.0194205474,
-0.0213710293,
-0.0052896123,
-0.0278011523,
-0.0268717427,
0.0227483157,
-0.0132132126,
-0.0719930753,
-0.0085656196,
-0.0409154259,
0.025182331,
0.0157687198,
-0.0303772688,
-0.0493021198,
0.0031027973,
-0.0244574249,
-0.0155755254,
0.0121186404,
0.0581015162,
-0.0309328102,
-0.0074347919,
-0.0652928054,
-0.0483482108,
0.0215901714,
-0.0742568821,
0.0599472746,
-0.0405383781,
0.0171716195,
0.0351660401,
-0.0165349413,
0.0093504312,
0.006170305,
0.0302278139,
-0.0399472006,
0.0968459025,
0.033019457,
0.023482807,
-0.0016255878,
0.0052827676,
-0.0448609293,
0.0456999615,
0.0195012614,
0.0192067269,
0.0021870483,
0.0027019905,
0.0107271783,
0.0118630705,
0.0156260338,
-0.0257885102,
0.0043840408,
0.006816199,
-0.0353391059,
-0.0078860018,
0.0068132109,
0.0187773276,
-0.0260360017,
0.0022941979,
0.023070734,
0.0707394406,
0.0232302267,
0.0199131239,
0.0634167641,
-0.0538818985,
0.0296672862,
0.0561936609,
-0.0860470086,
0.0270349085,
-0.0659594983,
0.0168148112,
-0.0195499565,
-0.0277807582,
-0.0179995485,
-0.0421843827,
-0.017716758,
0.0212497711,
0.0291734114,
0.0038006632,
0.048902981,
0.0022038543,
-0.0073844851,
0.0328874551,
-0.0000780158,
-0.015340047,
-0.0382786952,
-0.0992766246,
0.0276102088,
0.0299234651,
0.0357629508,
-0.0291345939,
-0.0159715042,
0.0235554036,
-0.0033750192,
0.0338810086,
0.0215203725,
0.0116775725,
-0.0149535276,
0.0015641599,
0.0007579374,
-0.0886135846,
0.0309098344,
0.0331368446,
-0.0221093353,
-0.0167240612,
-0.0001722357,
-0.018509591,
0.0025630682,
0.0250684358,
-0.0376904383,
-0.0017239113,
-0.0267664157,
0.025750868,
0.0158279706,
-0.016865056,
0.0010756515,
0.0355222411,
0.0419570729,
-0.0253235232,
-0.0095918681,
0.0292666871,
-0.0365440138,
-0.0123869823,
0.0255320985,
0.0057465229,
-0.0197312329,
0.0120369131,
0.0116523542,
-0.0472196788,
0.0403269976,
-0.0391865671,
0.0566237532,
-0.0464318767,
0.0310257468,
-0.0039977003,
0.0016004283,
0.0044484115,
0.1126598939,
-0.0133673754,
0.0114265084,
0.018123325,
0.0275331177,
0.0096535804,
-0.0189257115,
0.0015696363,
0.0245855283,
0.0206348803,
0.0026494751,
-0.0164726079,
-0.0169309862,
-0.051575467,
-0.011749642,
-0.0334112644,
-0.0051215473,
-0.0127595747,
0.0348657705,
0.0327598974,
-0.0519305356,
0.0079693757,
-0.0074707549,
-0.02227626,
0.0257562827,
0.0184817016,
0.0288756043,
0.0538867526,
-0.0349174701,
0.0066655828,
0.0098082228,
0.0041319048,
-0.0597213469,
0.0199344382,
-0.0190437809,
0.0427216701,
-0.0720814764,
0.0171983074,
-0.0050742305,
0.0130756805,
-0.0198388062,
-0.0339307263,
0.0706162751,
-0.0157478955,
0.0174188279,
0.1267014891,
-0.021095315,
0.0502257645,
0.068729572,
-0.0127136353,
-0.0019735908,
0.0267097261,
0.0137161212,
0.0249234196,
-0.0155733675,
-0.0330546238,
-0.0246801339,
0.0802446604,
-0.0067075212,
0.0024040255,
-0.0426568799,
0.0460357778,
0.0218790434,
-0.0053286664,
0.0057006157,
-0.030246228,
-0.0286383778,
0.0774687529,
-0.0227199197,
-0.0553884134,
0.0857890174,
-0.026600007,
-0.0327586383,
-0.017530676,
0.028770458,
0.0000694089,
0.103284806,
0.0193504505,
-0.0059876274,
0.0407927036,
-0.0167659279,
-0.04081209,
-0.0272022188,
0.0348016843,
-0.0091382433,
0.0268335938,
-0.0299706683,
-0.0147165973,
-0.0175684374,
-0.0141762346,
-0.036879357,
0.0392215848,
-0.0473210029,
0.0299904142,
-0.0388768278,
-0.0234981067,
-0.0309419781,
0.0121314852,
0.0368504822,
0.0415068753,
-0.0116721718,
-0.0117276674,
-0.0262128357,
0.0141089773,
0.0115749668,
0.0528715812,
0.0477661639,
-0.0548253618,
0.0486852154,
0.0396561101,
0.0402082689,
0.0137977526,
-0.0035154566,
0.0244175084,
0.0138739962,
-0.0095816357,
-0.0357262455,
0.0071424614,
0.029371636,
-0.0782498047,
-0.0299821887,
0.0822974369,
0.0352656133,
-0.0073123625,
-0.0016144497,
-0.0453715436,
0.0294340234,
0.0509419441,
0.0446545407,
-0.0592207909,
-0.0296153165,
0.0322590955,
0.0037214858,
-0.0214603953,
-0.0189932417,
-0.0243867021,
-0.1187626868,
0.0182841457,
-0.0180749316,
-0.0389271416,
-0.0274631195,
-0.0255494248,
0.0011921771,
0.0442110822,
-0.0081214989,
0.037867669,
0.0114135696,
0.0038054842,
-0.0245320518,
-0.0176560022,
-0.0155628426,
0.0548192449,
-0.0007316672,
0.0408452377,
0.0591650978,
0.0157969836,
-0.0192085188,
-0.0448698886,
0.0499624908,
-0.0244979039,
0.0328083895,
-0.0100123044,
-0.0042325812,
0.0297651477,
-0.0051690154,
-0.0166275539,
0.0294037517,
-0.0233981442,
-0.0289830547,
0.0094344132,
0.1210646331,
-0.049826242,
-0.0745928138,
0.0082722642,
-0.0076677972,
-0.0559397377,
0.058692757,
0.0477651395,
-0.0235026404,
-0.0715641156,
-0.0681277886,
-0.0057984828,
-0.0039112843,
-0.051122807,
0.0447451063,
0.0400711596,
0.0021813784,
-0.0276531838,
-0.0629829839,
0.0300968736,
0.0404601656,
-0.0094607221,
0.0119285602,
0.0174110252,
-0.0179959666,
-0.0143250832,
0.0277624745,
-0.0450807065,
0.0178409796,
-0.0168216042,
-0.0155503759,
-0.0051131258,
-0.0391384587,
-0.0136266667,
-0.0162378959,
-0.0148607828,
-0.0535469241,
-0.0245389398,
0.0438095629,
0.0320876017,
0.0175893679,
-0.0272323955,
-0.0129610365,
0.0053049964,
-0.0624624193,
-0.0218657572,
0.0283108372,
0.0513183735,
-0.0253845286,
0.0148370629,
0.0449047573,
0.0130648781,
0.0138721941,
0.0184159223,
0.0358562954,
-0.0285808798,
0.0004793528,
0.0497336425,
0.0231265686,
0.0305943582,
0.0489703231,
0.0011805678,
-0.0211308319,
0.0351378843,
-0.0031221071,
-0.0213031378,
-0.0175905339,
-0.0141412253,
-0.0077711926,
-0.0260732025,
-0.0001167983,
-0.0586795285,
-0.0100633325,
0.0262817759,
0.011255173,
0.0087143173,
0.0419472903,
0.0399707258,
0.0023562626,
-0.0125299096,
0.0117735099,
0.0043269759,
-0.0246585533,
0.064444311,
-0.0212286357,
0.0829104409,
0.0324581154,
-0.0017423948,
-0.0407995954,
-0.0107628452,
-0.0953999236,
-0.0668151006,
0.0784773678,
-0.0143054985,
0.0529797934,
-0.0262644347,
0.0211424325,
-0.0273216348,
-0.006414955,
0.0023570778,
0.0016239793,
0.0284676198,
-0.017480012,
0.0279635824,
0.0228550546,
-0.0132906213,
-0.0183788911,
0.0444778241,
-0.018624736,
0.0397607572,
-0.0339212604,
-0.0096052624,
-0.0087648397,
-0.0527759828,
-0.0250706375,
0.0085579026,
0.0019935302,
-0.0023019505,
-0.0691102669,
-0.097971648,
-0.0362330079,
0.0301670954,
-0.0146591384,
-0.0307272915,
-0.0167420469,
0.0906680897,
0.0150342425,
-0.0231262688,
-0.0247723721,
0.011532194,
0.0059926002,
0.0256294236,
0.0056302669,
-6.11497451e-33,
-0.0302230567,
-0.0595879816,
0.0268478598,
0.0079333698,
-0.0083897291,
-0.0346606225,
-0.0601264872,
0.0065280474,
-0.0475242995,
0.02476006,
-0.0391990356,
0.022182798,
-0.0025331115,
-0.0195272714,
0.03138474,
0.0026574582,
-0.0270031579,
-0.0041899807,
-0.0574376173,
-0.0012844343,
0.0394264758,
-0.0136782359,
0.0414024889,
-0.0080757951,
0.0230528619,
-0.004524752,
0.0178552121,
0.0281339269,
-0.1136945114,
0.0583549328,
0.0009725454,
0.0042778999,
0.045272544,
-0.0532390513,
-0.0000637514,
0.0453136675,
-0.0568696,
-0.0574849509,
0.0556355827,
-0.0152021004,
-0.0390795656,
-0.0399132669,
0.0419143178,
-0.011534702,
0.0185839571,
-0.0108904643,
0.0070013795,
-0.030627301,
0.0125059858,
0.0033235289,
-0.0622916669,
-0.0034550941,
0.0015136017,
-0.0255488679,
0.0115488917,
0.0197923798,
-0.0247990489,
-0.0039972602,
-0.0500152558,
0.0114293993,
0.0206395313,
0.0082335044,
0.0559947677,
0.0238758493,
0.0071455939,
0.0323524103,
0.0297839958,
0.0161723234,
-0.036014989,
-0.0029739018,
0.0308339112,
0.0397986621,
0.0537229218,
-0.0545957088,
0.0229239929,
0.0182096176,
-0.055368647,
-0.0388600864,
0.0368295051,
0.0649828464,
0.0456086919,
-0.0246329661,
0.0000572981,
-0.0313515216,
-0.0518145822,
-0.0043182983,
-0.0518347658,
-0.0299616195,
0.0318806656,
-0.0125856064,
-0.0033324207,
-0.0411609188,
-0.0015938131,
-0.0217355918,
0.0180288311,
0.0179824438,
-0.0108496239,
0.006955191,
-0.006533402,
0.0641977191,
-0.0217010807,
-0.0314717032,
-0.0208302774,
-0.015294441,
0.0011026083,
0.0290585607,
0.0070645022,
0.026284894,
-0.0367132612,
-0.001864647,
-0.0566550791,
-0.0147011271,
-0.0070053763,
0.0077254199,
0.0733458921,
0.0224271286,
0.014056853,
-0.0056781531,
0.0032184406,
0.0110999346,
-0.086622797,
0.0629459843,
-0.0224619675,
0.0292931702,
-0.0124848373,
-0.0184477549,
-0.04568398,
0.0400079861,
0.0071332366,
-0.0553920045,
-0.0022474844,
0.0445385873,
2.773e-7,
0.037793126,
0.0320071504,
-0.0179622434,
0.0694239289,
0.0491346866,
0.0373855457,
-0.0528199933,
-0.0272198003,
0.0399853028,
-0.0687283874,
-0.0189933572,
0.0481719263,
0.0403055958,
0.0387219377,
-0.0517613254,
0.0118855238,
-0.0175028294,
0.0016567573,
-0.0151608447,
0.0153479734,
0.0287209041,
0.0723363459,
0.0017482428,
-0.0161644295,
0.0008669879,
-0.0480682142,
0.0454449393,
0.0132968519,
0.0286901165,
-0.0233990308,
0.0114424834,
-0.0068060514,
-0.0140556088,
0.0707229003,
0.0160814468,
0.0284245722,
-0.0491801351,
0.0694931746,
-0.0125304982,
-0.0387577191,
-0.0269613788,
-0.0453816578,
0.006894208,
-0.0658539161,
0.098765552,
-0.0528595373,
-0.0593203008,
-0.0162051469,
0.0386447757,
-0.0336705074,
-0.0212461241,
0.0209223069,
-0.0065009175,
-0.0040794187,
-0.0230079666,
-0.0135514643,
0.0283437278,
-0.086817719,
-0.0203999914,
0.027197266,
-0.0334677026,
-0.0246074013,
-0.0560923778,
-0.0339952819,
0.0526148193,
-0.0430930518,
-0.0272372942,
2.501205859e-34,
0.0229860116,
-0.0427031778,
0.0415503159,
0.0672728866,
0.0303876251,
-0.0175687708,
0.0223496072,
0.0133324536,
0.0443673991,
-0.088338241,
-0.0384800099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14486v1 | Text Fact Transfer | 2023-10-23T01:36:44 | 2023-10-23T01:36:44 | Nishant Balepur, Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text style transfer is a prominent task that aims to control the style of
text without inherently changing its factual content. To cover more text
modification applications, such as adapting past news for current events and
repurposing educational materials, we propose the task of text fact transfer,
which seeks to transfer the factual content of a source text between topics
without modifying its style. We find that existing language models struggle
with text fact transfer, due to their inability to preserve the specificity and
phrasing of the source text, and tendency to hallucinate errors. To address
these issues, we design ModQGA, a framework that minimally modifies a source
text with a novel combination of end-to-end question generation and
specificity-aware question answering. Through experiments on four existing
datasets adapted for text fact transfer, we show that ModQGA can accurately
transfer factual content without sacrificing the style of the source text. | [
0.0517973453,
0.0591057912,
0.0063790856,
0.0174334291,
-0.0588142686,
-0.0090122363,
-0.0268215351,
-0.0160909444,
-0.0483894721,
-0.0262869131,
0.0262382068,
-0.0331225693,
-0.0177009143,
0.0234543849,
0.0274466965,
-0.0381096043,
0.0406813435,
-0.0054041618,
0.0049805222,
-0.0086556729,
0.0401407331,
0.0294278488,
0.0139673715,
-0.0094198557,
-0.0327392295,
-0.0142576993,
-0.0554524772,
0.0223579574,
0.0356884077,
0.0313488469,
0.0322597846,
0.0542301424,
0.0197023768,
-0.0139681613,
0.0000017123,
-0.0406327248,
-0.0441049747,
-0.0027395752,
0.0183637869,
0.0288922675,
0.0635276586,
0.0090182172,
0.005162688,
0.0150922565,
-0.0300482139,
-0.0017232787,
0.0386230983,
0.0648876354,
0.1226694658,
0.0923633352,
-0.0225573555,
-0.014091827,
0.0372585654,
-0.0058911867,
0.0870407298,
-0.0353547819,
0.017118467,
0.0409848355,
0.0253466982,
0.0539645553,
0.0224488266,
0.0558432639,
0.0052633267,
-0.0184432548,
0.0082300007,
-0.0131062446,
-0.0359456204,
0.0277472492,
-0.0059585073,
0.0773254484,
0.0431188196,
-0.0482788086,
0.0234402586,
0.0269373003,
0.0382817723,
0.0459094197,
-0.066652067,
0.0108387033,
-0.0208802652,
-0.0234976858,
0.0130744204,
-0.0211409479,
-0.0089168884,
0.0132291224,
0.0002584331,
0.0152504696,
0.0446361937,
-0.0137407677,
-0.0558306761,
0.0050870958,
-0.0023248729,
-0.0686271712,
0.0414642952,
0.0458851121,
0.0191869382,
0.0044314219,
-0.0911114812,
-0.023987107,
0.0060427375,
-0.0341256708,
-0.0118484506,
0.0241932254,
-0.043128062,
0.0492261536,
-0.0181511678,
0.0118143018,
-0.0278848913,
-0.003175813,
-0.0486806706,
-0.033695396,
-0.034462221,
-0.011897699,
-0.0733141899,
0.0360608734,
-0.0279859174,
-0.0232956335,
0.0292576905,
0.0163935609,
0.0307387467,
-0.010127956,
-0.0181189403,
0.0065619508,
-0.0661373958,
-0.0401249193,
-0.0175588112,
0.0389741957,
-0.028293984,
0.0202444661,
0.0385362692,
-0.0145944273,
-0.0258264411,
0.0113191381,
0.0473351367,
-0.0087031089,
-0.0080411788,
0.0177810658,
-0.0682803243,
0.0188973676,
-0.0588254482,
-0.024131842,
0.0025520283,
-0.0420997702,
0.0000185525,
-0.0987003371,
0.0297580473,
0.0056696311,
-0.0423420705,
-0.0327907838,
0.0063049304,
0.0412776209,
-0.0498326682,
0.0518881008,
0.0035424083,
0.0042316415,
0.0794064328,
0.0093949707,
0.0112808337,
0.0463127829,
0.0275697559,
0.0423560329,
0.0483890958,
0.0310832299,
-0.0032262227,
0.0052290866,
0.035197854,
0.0274367388,
-0.0023271132,
0.0052840677,
0.0117022786,
0.0210890993,
0.0228903685,
0.0733808503,
-0.0045567509,
-0.0198629573,
0.0906728506,
-0.0360707119,
0.004356029,
0.0494765006,
0.0389095843,
0.0246118121,
0.0243582986,
0.0311855841,
-0.0129785137,
0.0497820117,
-0.0267769024,
0.0130398683,
0.0163405407,
0.0509345941,
-0.0368905514,
-0.0235093422,
0.0165126342,
0.0097259888,
-0.0056984341,
-0.0082268277,
0.0005333993,
0.0687095821,
-0.0490178466,
0.0434231758,
0.0015649876,
-0.0380069837,
0.0402137004,
-0.017295761,
0.0385146923,
0.0270763375,
0.0484285057,
-0.0223137084,
-0.0234770868,
-0.0203860197,
0.0701419413,
0.0121723702,
0.0540561527,
-0.0229681693,
-0.0148286242,
-0.0364279561,
0.022749776,
-0.0448891744,
0.012020234,
0.0004994688,
0.0347111039,
0.0336732119,
0.0311649572,
-0.0374790803,
0.0035187355,
0.0319528431,
-0.0052347123,
-0.0226542894,
-0.0094469665,
-0.0249071941,
-0.0553238168,
-0.0091643324,
-0.0070544723,
0.011836106,
-0.0183673594,
-0.0274691042,
-0.0524527952,
0.0241117701,
-0.0303844064,
-0.0537798069,
0.0194591638,
-0.0530728176,
0.0069667832,
0.0331228711,
-0.0576538369,
-0.0470206104,
0.0003006594,
-0.0419317223,
0.0045929765,
-0.0399319567,
0.0010268989,
0.0452062748,
0.0061718845,
-0.0352250151,
0.0569072366,
0.023525089,
-0.0374642462,
0.0395613462,
0.0004258991,
-0.0033644789,
-0.0199573338,
0.0093180146,
0.0036291904,
-0.0177201685,
0.038728755,
0.0145054972,
-0.0074573513,
-0.0483337082,
-0.0326938331,
-0.0557386763,
0.0364683717,
-0.0406204723,
0.0275755934,
0.0854133517,
0.0400482491,
-0.0047839773,
-0.0033056259,
-0.0809744522,
-0.0189510603,
-0.0195354056,
0.0104001258,
0.0563494079,
0.0170979556,
0.0367833786,
-0.049360536,
0.0065247784,
0.0052092201,
0.0389758833,
0.0254045408,
0.0078334259,
-0.0630014315,
-0.0089630233,
-0.0731148049,
-0.0055063181,
0.0096371192,
-0.0151937334,
-0.0256375223,
-0.0336022265,
0.0892408714,
0.0601311438,
0.0493268929,
-0.0349598564,
0.0159817003,
-0.0222108196,
-0.0277636796,
0.030474484,
-0.0382530428,
0.0199371818,
0.0147425644,
-0.0646405891,
0.0123003842,
0.0145656159,
0.0234761741,
-0.0158883855,
-0.032194294,
0.0254290868,
0.0108603602,
-0.0039499188,
0.0052628648,
0.0208048876,
-0.0112927519,
0.0172462016,
-0.0417205021,
0.0061040926,
0.0525280349,
-0.014286926,
0.0013289811,
-0.0303709731,
0.0072093443,
-0.0312184542,
0.0111522228,
-0.0353338979,
0.025578199,
-0.0260525234,
0.0035336039,
-0.0769527555,
-0.0028517589,
0.0479372777,
-0.0367404483,
0.0582591668,
-0.0792374685,
0.024702007,
0.0178693812,
-0.0078584859,
-0.0441848785,
-0.0460770242,
0.0438486189,
-0.011050947,
-0.0327004977,
-0.0250800177,
-0.0386218615,
-0.0124070458,
0.0434561707,
0.0682582483,
-0.0532851554,
-0.0101245707,
-0.010018927,
0.090890415,
0.0986345261,
0.0192670152,
-0.0027125489,
-0.0074271434,
-0.0123488298,
0.0580104925,
-0.0044288901,
0.0079532303,
0.0090619391,
0.0017449555,
0.0007111105,
-0.0323454663,
-0.0235926192,
-0.0082064141,
0.1015986949,
-0.0433323644,
-0.0483538322,
0.0737028122,
0.0631487593,
0.0131722353,
-0.0237302817,
-0.033023145,
0.0427988581,
-0.0034102029,
0.0572903715,
-0.0770467594,
-0.0230709612,
-0.0023060162,
0.0268600192,
0.0133369295,
-0.0284090172,
-0.0340344533,
-0.0511960275,
0.01456137,
0.0102155562,
-0.0370724685,
-0.024002485,
-0.0242099743,
0.0181542821,
0.0198289752,
-0.0202885643,
-0.0053064059,
-0.0033145845,
0.0143684354,
0.010982329,
-0.0045581111,
-0.0154318456,
-0.0085511506,
0.0128059303,
0.0262966231,
0.0430654027,
0.0340926088,
0.0055323346,
0.0036039327,
-0.0044702212,
-0.0107287243,
-0.0399665646,
-0.0066952859,
0.059274286,
-0.010912505,
-0.0143833049,
-0.0154744061,
0.0450831167,
0.0255088527,
-0.0170368217,
0.0440770313,
0.0548948944,
0.0108845457,
-0.0365159996,
-0.0175415426,
0.0083913291,
0.0316154696,
0.0790594667,
0.0459757522,
-0.0248700213,
-0.0299403295,
-0.0690978169,
0.0044027749,
-0.0696178153,
-0.0365138613,
0.0038966935,
-0.0089781489,
-0.0246833898,
-0.1491779685,
-0.0185688846,
0.0037841229,
0.0177194346,
-0.0140114538,
-0.0190394744,
-0.0039496743,
-0.0264547523,
-0.0371280685,
-0.01296004,
-0.0617064312,
-0.0095641203,
-0.0131594623,
-0.030431157,
0.025397867,
-0.0492891334,
-0.0052318899,
0.0061047422,
-0.1074816808,
-0.0612104647,
0.0156333689,
0.0256466996,
0.0186476391,
0.0373125188,
-0.0291933138,
-0.0441251472,
0.0183404032,
0.0500690416,
-0.0214375407,
0.0209613591,
0.0226205122,
-0.0353331678,
0.0093346899,
0.0280178543,
-0.0439430252,
0.0345288143,
-0.0115453033,
0.0517011806,
-0.0225336961,
-0.0281142201,
0.0404983014,
0.0107602356,
-0.0393404104,
0.0424620844,
0.0017263939,
-0.0123465145,
0.0144031188,
-0.0308615509,
-0.0095801782,
-0.0574502498,
0.0164795499,
0.0346331932,
0.0289920289,
0.0040803235,
0.0014720327,
-0.0223783515,
0.0370254852,
-0.040825028,
-0.0301002618,
0.0109104663,
0.0709058419,
0.0271433927,
-0.0140201021,
-0.0364513993,
0.0013246444,
-0.002788577,
0.0526137315,
-0.0245277341,
0.0429441407,
0.0484849848,
-0.0194495842,
0.0195032153,
-0.0024675331,
-0.1171596944,
-0.0207764357,
-0.0429586247,
0.0403902978,
0.0057733916,
0.0060796463,
0.055646725,
-0.0193687268,
-0.028458653,
-0.0120225521,
0.0445777811,
0.0235133562,
-0.0293645579,
-0.0016608336,
0.0088461656,
0.0239742789,
0.0475255214,
0.0522546433,
-0.0108803781,
0.0656029284,
-0.0043987529,
-0.0080205342,
-0.0285882112,
-0.0373722874,
0.0032677376,
-0.0384611674,
0.0050977916,
-0.0189949144,
-0.0499057434,
-0.0563809313,
0.0385350138,
-0.0219863039,
0.0046096547,
-0.0177156851,
0.0174233522,
0.0737444013,
-0.0055415533,
-0.0253596269,
-0.0465847887,
0.0653705075,
0.0225359425,
-0.0186724626,
-0.008324868,
-6.070664985e-33,
-0.0356728397,
-0.0030066103,
0.0031350111,
-0.0128174666,
-0.0170752704,
0.0256945789,
-0.0505452603,
-0.0244026221,
-0.0238970332,
0.0164928343,
-0.0204478912,
0.010833066,
0.0018111287,
0.0286223907,
-0.028620543,
-0.0146307079,
0.0690418631,
-0.0014862502,
-0.0500954911,
0.045291625,
0.0383618698,
0.0139180692,
0.0621170551,
-0.0360566899,
0.0185174905,
-0.034019269,
-0.0297651496,
0.0097417105,
0.0273302868,
0.0175473448,
0.0143342316,
0.0011251927,
0.0096732564,
-0.053967759,
-0.039360974,
0.0178367533,
-0.0775190443,
-0.0573750623,
0.0449426956,
-0.0340675451,
-0.0315609686,
-0.0341001302,
0.0207927637,
-0.0456193276,
0.0732014999,
-0.0263735,
0.0479367636,
-0.0207723062,
0.0110218646,
-0.0006464559,
-0.0679886639,
0.0090067768,
-0.0010810542,
-0.0164100155,
-0.0440342762,
0.0328422263,
0.0244478956,
-0.0116436677,
-0.0324934013,
0.0232652705,
-0.00278577,
0.0180069394,
0.0349330939,
-0.0218348894,
-0.0274292491,
0.0174805988,
-0.027493827,
0.0081916889,
-0.0438362621,
0.0310593005,
-0.0008739925,
0.02627315,
0.053925164,
0.0918222591,
0.0130643584,
0.0042071892,
-0.0415458456,
0.0416844264,
-0.0052277604,
0.0016141144,
-0.024474347,
-0.0125045786,
-0.0053475602,
0.0120059354,
-0.0422434509,
0.0668053031,
-0.0152947763,
-0.0310375225,
0.0343250595,
0.003399764,
-0.0488538221,
0.027006451,
0.0327122062,
-0.0127317933,
-0.0082615586,
0.016151363,
-0.0834897012,
0.0425910167,
-0.0311572775,
0.046889592,
-0.0503700599,
0.0316038467,
0.0659818798,
0.0050649662,
-0.0087619219,
0.0223725867,
0.024294693,
0.0322701931,
-0.0671537593,
0.0091926577,
-0.0331221409,
0.0461505949,
-0.0014081908,
-0.0399511568,
-0.0073932456,
-0.0055954587,
-0.028401278,
0.0035485025,
0.0298995469,
0.0105218133,
-0.0433224998,
-0.0543064103,
0.0030109761,
0.0165183377,
-0.0442746691,
0.0078607816,
-0.0484980829,
-0.0057536112,
-0.0380101018,
-0.0573017932,
-0.0070478376,
0.0235080682,
2.474e-7,
0.0349647738,
0.0252847243,
0.0367742926,
0.0306171756,
-0.0231602676,
-0.0001150132,
-0.0048612235,
0.0554929934,
0.026831612,
-0.0411527455,
0.0066020596,
0.0633947551,
0.0234836787,
0.025750624,
-0.1034693569,
-0.0123008369,
-0.0393382683,
-0.0001338258,
-0.0474516414,
-0.0317395478,
0.0709118396,
0.0294683129,
0.0266410038,
0.0008190994,
-0.0028694572,
-0.0315859132,
0.0834313855,
0.0108920205,
-0.0490577482,
0.0571548939,
0.0723936558,
-0.0196479205,
-0.0284507014,
-0.0234832242,
-0.0175002869,
-0.0228844117,
0.0399402268,
0.0592712089,
0.0410604104,
-0.014681289,
-0.0514670089,
-0.0204479042,
0.0191964712,
-0.0474566072,
0.0919666588,
-0.0046177879,
0.0136575578,
-0.0504519977,
-0.0603885204,
0.0341736823,
-0.0190011635,
-0.0061936919,
-0.0312832519,
0.0107469391,
0.0009926884,
0.0459632836,
-0.0131434314,
-0.0460322723,
-0.019767588,
-0.0086046113,
-0.0228677392,
-0.0579101108,
-0.04029442,
-0.0117665436,
-0.0131822294,
-0.0571398512,
0.0382035039,
2.200168414e-34,
0.0288205668,
-0.0077130315,
-0.0143202525,
0.0032422971,
0.0326335728,
-0.0137299802,
0.0054766708,
0.0077874074,
0.0016180045,
-0.0571343154,
-0.0248888582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14483v1 | "Why Should I Review This Paper?" Unifying Semantic, Topic, and Citation Factors for Paper-Reviewer Matching | 2023-10-23T01:29:18 | 2023-10-23T01:29:18 | Yu Zhang, Yanzhen Shen, Xiusi Chen, Bowen Jin, Jiawei Han | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG | As many academic conferences are overwhelmed by a rapidly increasing number
of paper submissions, automatically finding appropriate reviewers for each
submission becomes a more urgent need than ever. Various factors have been
considered by previous attempts on this task to measure the expertise relevance
between a paper and a reviewer, including whether the paper is semantically
close to, shares topics with, and cites previous papers of the reviewer.
However, the majority of previous studies take only one of these factors into
account, leading to an incomprehensive evaluation of paper-reviewer relevance.
To bridge this gap, in this paper, we propose a unified model for
paper-reviewer matching that jointly captures semantic, topic, and citation
factors. In the unified model, a contextualized language model backbone is
shared by all factors to learn common knowledge, while instruction tuning is
introduced to characterize the uniqueness of each factor by producing
factor-aware paper embeddings. Experiments on four datasets (one of which is
newly contributed by us) across different fields, including machine learning,
computer vision, information retrieval, and data mining, consistently validate
the effectiveness of our proposed UniPR model in comparison with
state-of-the-art paper-reviewer matching methods and scientific pre-trained
language models. | [
0.0636423528,
0.0114914384,
0.0035086088,
-0.0049383543,
-0.0166677423,
-0.0185666494,
0.0135699995,
-0.0126010263,
-0.0364416614,
-0.045470573,
-0.0730437785,
0.0108033186,
-0.025516687,
0.0202457514,
-0.021809455,
-0.0182600934,
0.0147918826,
0.0321022868,
0.0467713773,
0.0306971297,
0.0202833246,
0.0172875281,
0.0206511691,
0.0624318086,
0.0584066436,
-0.0314883217,
0.047762733,
-0.0227668304,
0.0063678292,
0.0183998793,
-0.001923077,
0.0659441426,
0.045075722,
0.0609556437,
0.0000016335,
-0.0322611742,
-0.0132407751,
-0.0278280862,
0.0368675999,
-0.0107371472,
0.0720557868,
-0.0229886323,
0.0283720382,
0.0132680973,
-0.0052872756,
-0.0398900174,
0.0111957323,
0.0665357262,
0.0034103415,
0.0215034932,
-0.0099442238,
0.0113936961,
0.0168880485,
-0.0233578049,
0.0062640146,
-0.0371627174,
0.0332031921,
0.041203633,
0.0116685331,
0.0618108064,
0.021568723,
0.0085142311,
-0.0286916178,
-0.0574335717,
0.0750129968,
-0.0005877268,
0.0201790165,
0.0567808524,
0.0120137604,
0.05602213,
-0.0266142301,
-0.0680355057,
0.0172890592,
0.0050949804,
-0.035962604,
0.08771272,
-0.0336275846,
-0.0230007563,
0.013787833,
-0.010579004,
0.0251366813,
0.0223011989,
0.0275541246,
0.0244852994,
0.0669255331,
0.0454000048,
0.0276925974,
-0.0435541905,
0.0143096922,
0.0585783869,
0.0448655896,
-0.0676938891,
-0.0027575502,
0.013135965,
-0.0029663921,
-0.0199661162,
0.0021584728,
-0.0017437318,
0.0354022346,
-0.0241590515,
0.0007639847,
-0.0250176843,
0.0295381062,
0.0799875483,
0.0245828051,
-0.0359187387,
-0.0106657492,
-0.0041193198,
-0.0420298427,
-0.0288405847,
-0.0581583045,
-0.0072557856,
0.0199474674,
0.0089553455,
0.0263861492,
-0.026090743,
-0.0273946859,
0.005249022,
-0.0551399253,
-0.0169831682,
0.0151663879,
0.0191105884,
-0.0020275638,
-0.0015616692,
-0.0582578108,
0.0188248567,
-0.0301634315,
0.0485726334,
-0.0783542916,
0.0765000209,
0.0214552488,
0.0420548357,
0.017363904,
-0.046563711,
0.0167711545,
-0.0204210375,
0.0196680259,
-0.0377005264,
0.0041576573,
0.0157904606,
0.0335849226,
-0.0277371537,
-0.0146138212,
-0.021870004,
0.0474472791,
-0.013851664,
-0.0176995508,
-0.079830274,
-0.0486600697,
0.0028042013,
-0.0320691057,
0.0680830106,
-0.0137665374,
-0.0023643561,
0.0566171184,
0.0191211514,
-0.0101646418,
-0.0110281827,
-0.0470400415,
-0.0077289408,
0.0380764902,
-0.0066686538,
0.0832254291,
-0.0279942509,
-0.016263783,
0.0079319384,
0.014188638,
0.0141463559,
-0.0151565205,
0.004193868,
0.0608394854,
-0.0110526001,
-0.0373928137,
-0.0260934196,
0.0196236689,
0.0325821005,
0.0358651243,
0.0324602164,
0.017578559,
0.0390733555,
-0.022661753,
-0.0160699561,
0.0093041938,
0.0591917858,
-0.0017549869,
-0.0339599364,
0.0511526391,
0.0021946041,
-0.0517083928,
-0.005828314,
0.0090140784,
0.027671231,
-0.0073821843,
0.0386753939,
0.0339653082,
0.0109996768,
-0.01508593,
0.0092632016,
0.0401490144,
-0.0079234047,
0.0246297829,
0.0147369802,
0.02240986,
0.0098714754,
0.0702300519,
-0.0138788316,
0.0038943558,
-0.0330884531,
-0.0009158965,
-0.0066778543,
0.067798771,
-0.0134993251,
-0.0246872306,
-0.0195204671,
-0.0698941424,
-0.0035044018,
-0.004859936,
0.002979812,
0.0260715876,
0.0499810763,
0.0084414855,
-0.0262469091,
-0.0377006754,
0.0526942201,
0.0136119481,
-0.0272986181,
0.0129533019,
-0.0008856143,
0.0476440303,
0.0245110895,
-0.0225208178,
0.0251282472,
0.029262187,
-0.030577831,
0.0003674774,
-0.0065780124,
0.0117498655,
0.0249420851,
0.0409462415,
-0.0424844213,
-0.007142656,
0.0041183508,
-0.0048335074,
-0.0320945792,
0.0454927459,
0.0419266708,
0.016661156,
-0.0036078282,
0.0041116099,
-0.0482068323,
-0.0119201299,
-0.0426079892,
0.0348153673,
0.032979358,
0.050504908,
0.0119243013,
-0.0052303574,
0.0131263752,
-0.0148733174,
-0.0519297123,
-0.0644578561,
0.0234559998,
0.0150550324,
0.0572675765,
-0.0082444027,
0.0024296918,
-0.0420879014,
-0.0700731725,
-0.0085500069,
0.011101136,
0.0052720155,
0.0283035804,
-0.0346839465,
0.0397627056,
0.0099026216,
-0.0576440878,
-0.0136717949,
-0.024343174,
-0.0380941853,
0.0346595794,
0.008598729,
-0.0067698886,
-0.0626423731,
-0.0067107468,
-0.0376596227,
0.0572257303,
0.0547986031,
0.01111871,
-0.0510910451,
0.0493101031,
-0.0469606705,
-0.0086243749,
-0.0240245573,
0.0400378183,
0.0080387276,
0.0217001885,
-0.033393871,
0.0347331688,
0.006245723,
-0.01693625,
0.0587062575,
0.012400141,
-0.0609174706,
-0.0227887165,
-0.013245157,
0.0170008987,
0.0017818674,
-0.0226098597,
0.0892561898,
0.0327945985,
-0.0142356604,
-0.0334316902,
-0.0516987294,
0.0212112609,
0.0308976509,
0.0224996302,
-0.0120808473,
-0.0543096215,
0.0460796282,
0.0324972011,
-0.0025087781,
-0.0097559094,
0.0582144409,
-0.0391805395,
0.0238264389,
-0.0669212416,
-0.0060358057,
-0.0658666193,
0.0105799893,
-0.0100463806,
0.0183114633,
-0.0576968826,
0.048010163,
0.0119281989,
-0.0046028248,
0.0330451764,
-0.0145264883,
-0.0203883294,
-0.0321851857,
0.0306655541,
0.007339119,
-0.027753748,
0.0060205637,
-0.015876865,
-0.0100095551,
0.0110829147,
0.0084407022,
0.0012795805,
-0.08742176,
0.0712012872,
0.0257662535,
0.0131049585,
-0.0102154799,
-0.0398654416,
-0.0026441605,
0.0381711721,
0.0742700398,
-0.0509410016,
0.0044639898,
0.0101059917,
0.0065191784,
-0.0051215026,
0.0289560817,
0.0034469101,
-0.045178663,
-0.0231590364,
0.0222559925,
-0.0762987882,
0.0195790492,
-0.0277922228,
0.0118841426,
-0.0069150915,
0.0442052074,
0.0821426883,
0.0468279161,
-0.130345434,
-0.0456622168,
-0.0594623461,
-0.0016176808,
0.0468011275,
0.0491021089,
-0.0331556946,
-0.0057824641,
0.0072327596,
-0.0015441489,
0.0103551317,
-0.0051061776,
-0.0395866111,
-0.0307016745,
0.0116264056,
-0.0046183565,
-0.0011825708,
-0.0525632836,
-0.0397987254,
0.022967929,
-0.0407105647,
-0.0210091546,
0.0199901052,
-0.0189741775,
0.0102112321,
0.0034915688,
0.0003307395,
-0.0472176448,
0.0708263516,
-0.067545101,
0.0442926325,
-0.0079947272,
0.0459146462,
0.0042899954,
0.0039216676,
0.0115654217,
-0.0300773215,
-0.0178496186,
0.0004426429,
0.0445003621,
-0.0519283973,
0.0421828479,
-0.0246292856,
0.0199969038,
-0.0156751946,
0.0236122832,
0.0674890727,
0.0330999345,
-0.0339648202,
-0.0072568799,
-0.0586480387,
0.0137896137,
-0.0132745504,
0.0910320356,
0.0117582837,
-0.0452566743,
-0.0176219493,
-0.0117787803,
0.0546633452,
0.0433151089,
-0.0763941482,
-0.044676356,
0.0040918426,
-0.0641789064,
-0.0488538742,
-0.0203495249,
0.0241785776,
0.0229188483,
0.0537843555,
0.0529008731,
0.0121753588,
-0.0345519222,
-0.0163961835,
0.0824762061,
-0.0315251574,
0.0124494527,
-0.0501474217,
0.0144727435,
0.0642504618,
-0.0283653047,
-0.0438719876,
-0.0124524543,
0.0124177504,
-0.0082648462,
-0.0642893761,
-0.0041667456,
0.0171433948,
0.0421200432,
-0.049860172,
-0.0722089559,
-0.0134263998,
-0.0264238864,
-0.0383051373,
-0.0617432296,
-0.0013164595,
-0.0559288114,
-0.0164502487,
-0.0081382673,
-0.0555439852,
0.058421649,
0.0188461244,
0.008895616,
-0.0383905396,
-0.0731174871,
0.0183067974,
-0.009444098,
0.0321388468,
0.0368628055,
0.056610018,
-0.0507878363,
-0.0228110403,
0.0177646652,
-0.0244838502,
-0.0219304897,
-0.0170389954,
0.0142113306,
-0.0060306834,
-0.030116234,
0.0298897717,
-0.0402658992,
0.0691126361,
-0.0187595431,
0.0181162115,
-0.0065896199,
0.0357161164,
-0.0404306762,
-0.0275009833,
-0.0209375937,
-0.0302113537,
-0.0152357798,
0.0177072585,
-0.000920051,
0.0212212168,
-0.0016969834,
0.0170868598,
-0.0149839073,
0.0118771661,
-0.1025670096,
-0.0240052883,
-0.0288613643,
-0.0031289684,
0.030488167,
-0.0298954118,
0.0231981557,
-0.0364529677,
-0.0113172298,
-0.028102003,
0.005240263,
0.0208719354,
0.0337252021,
0.0562619641,
0.0201771222,
-0.0250103306,
-0.0045491559,
0.066801317,
0.0012649306,
-0.0341420956,
-0.0298530199,
-0.0767946467,
-0.0193896387,
-0.0167452972,
0.0176809803,
0.0845913738,
-0.0187135916,
-0.003605457,
-0.0427418537,
0.0066692452,
0.0149543602,
-0.0247987043,
-0.0473901816,
-0.017755283,
0.008728479,
0.0885779038,
-0.0086935693,
-0.0055084778,
-0.0524552837,
-0.0091945492,
0.0093493769,
-0.029214263,
-0.0518911593,
-5.463943127e-33,
0.0072941286,
-0.0404331386,
0.007243881,
0.0351939388,
0.0330029652,
0.0116020581,
-0.0256315395,
-0.0382691696,
-0.0404661968,
-0.0004010139,
-0.05095651,
-0.0016368903,
-0.0165888034,
-0.0146348048,
0.0393700898,
0.0471911058,
0.0587917306,
0.0218473449,
-0.005044261,
0.0627906844,
-0.0262595359,
-0.0211908743,
-0.0055469018,
-0.1022744551,
0.0604435429,
0.0005842879,
0.00732332,
0.0053097066,
0.0506546572,
0.055506371,
-0.0348329358,
0.0151771381,
0.0372662209,
-0.0544383638,
0.0239201188,
0.0142143015,
-0.0855400041,
-0.0245929379,
0.0307182278,
-0.0474296883,
-0.0046521197,
-0.0246525854,
0.039031826,
-0.019053828,
-0.0267481171,
0.0116192503,
0.0953947976,
-0.0068107583,
-0.0291074589,
-0.0718731508,
-0.0121995946,
0.0054650446,
-0.0331207328,
0.0241676178,
0.0328938626,
0.0511078276,
0.006400127,
0.0857715383,
-0.0764597505,
0.0402025953,
-0.0629748181,
0.0404053219,
-0.0046586953,
-0.0374423526,
0.0016793198,
0.0522882529,
-0.0513643473,
-0.0166033879,
0.0144306626,
-0.0557686239,
0.0054303957,
0.002465341,
0.014160499,
0.0582854003,
0.0354949757,
-0.0271572731,
-0.0578698553,
0.0703601688,
0.0476894192,
0.0157013424,
0.0643721893,
-0.0195396133,
-0.0297722369,
-0.0254436154,
-0.0306036789,
-0.0125989411,
-0.0385051109,
-0.0282377955,
0.0213483181,
0.020743262,
-0.0008731123,
-0.0228087716,
-0.015700683,
-0.064570941,
-0.0317345783,
0.0675540343,
-0.0252006892,
-0.0012981675,
0.0390050858,
-0.042853564,
-0.0595620424,
-0.0111086536,
-0.002591755,
-0.0279102828,
0.0045254799,
-0.0304999035,
0.0273830295,
-0.0358419046,
-0.0361814946,
-0.0255736168,
0.0077225058,
-0.0155422483,
-0.0187715236,
0.034705475,
-0.0000065688,
0.0600379631,
0.0115333041,
-0.0147343446,
0.0341231041,
0.0318835378,
0.004093742,
-0.0103032524,
-0.0137156388,
0.0385688692,
-0.0124282697,
-0.0279062148,
-0.0238078404,
-0.0005905243,
0.0058907694,
-0.0186521579,
-0.023511624,
-0.0288928617,
2.455e-7,
0.0449308939,
0.0298479032,
-0.0645553172,
-0.0403655805,
0.0438168868,
0.0198929254,
-0.0095507754,
0.0373891145,
0.017392803,
0.0453367196,
0.0409984551,
-0.0109282602,
0.0127173858,
0.0046360763,
-0.0555015653,
-0.003589361,
-0.0809172243,
-0.0023009651,
-0.0385404713,
-0.0273580719,
-0.0229990818,
0.0476384386,
0.0209617373,
-0.000653142,
-0.046804253,
-0.0560353287,
0.0615916066,
-0.0739708617,
0.02329644,
0.0629149526,
0.0633812621,
-0.0168316886,
-0.0169163644,
0.036723651,
-0.0188617595,
0.0596180744,
0.023330152,
0.0326461829,
-0.0067953654,
0.0027519418,
0.0115270466,
0.0060881646,
0.027444765,
-0.0552888215,
0.0584494211,
-0.0172902159,
-0.0072772936,
-0.060020335,
-0.0294167176,
0.0099956542,
0.0405321196,
0.027593473,
-0.0336926319,
0.0354121588,
0.005859138,
-0.0230563246,
-0.013741306,
-0.069522649,
-0.0018086253,
0.0504641719,
0.0025125078,
-0.0049297153,
-0.0124731911,
-0.0355186537,
0.0472550094,
-0.0259187575,
0.0564638376,
2.04912864e-34,
0.0512157083,
0.0038644162,
-0.0134116625,
-0.0488809012,
0.06343472,
0.0331818573,
-0.0622258708,
0.0010941689,
0.0139488662,
-0.0399395563,
0.0202564541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14479v1 | DetectGPT-SC: Improving Detection of Text Generated by Large Language Models through Self-Consistency with Masked Predictions | 2023-10-23T01:23:10 | 2023-10-23T01:23:10 | Rongsheng Wang, Qi Li, Sihong Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | General large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have shown remarkable
success, but it has also raised concerns among people about the misuse of
AI-generated texts. Therefore, an important question is how to detect whether
the texts are generated by ChatGPT or by humans. Existing detectors are built
on the assumption that there is a distribution gap between human-generated and
AI-generated texts. These gaps are typically identified using statistical
information or classifiers. In contrast to prior research methods, we find that
large language models such as ChatGPT exhibit strong self-consistency in text
generation and continuation. Self-consistency capitalizes on the intuition that
AI-generated texts can still be reasoned with by large language models using
the same logical reasoning when portions of the texts are masked, which differs
from human-generated texts. Using this observation, we subsequently proposed a
new method for AI-generated texts detection based on self-consistency with
masked predictions to determine whether a text is generated by LLMs. This
method, which we call DetectGPT-SC. We conducted a series of experiments to
evaluate the performance of DetectGPT-SC. In these experiments, we employed
various mask scheme, zero-shot, and simple prompt for completing masked texts
and self-consistency predictions. The results indicate that DetectGPT-SC
outperforms the current state-of-the-art across different tasks. | [
0.0304491483,
0.0529341921,
-0.0217064526,
0.0493422598,
-0.0585725829,
-0.0031689173,
0.0362976156,
0.0334432572,
0.0579989888,
-0.0420333333,
0.0101024397,
-0.027904328,
-0.0200344771,
0.0486821458,
0.0197618939,
0.0018088534,
0.034645699,
-0.0166652091,
-0.0020356597,
0.0055530039,
0.0166744329,
0.0197587684,
0.0221538506,
0.0459068716,
-0.0251404848,
-0.0572721399,
-0.0075829327,
-0.0029582968,
0.0047853375,
-0.0365221724,
0.0045645731,
0.0694444999,
-0.0258275308,
0.108540915,
0.0000020046,
-0.0548017547,
-0.0215250049,
-0.0178542417,
-0.044372309,
0.0240716971,
0.0243281052,
-0.0060159056,
-0.0442779474,
0.0266529955,
-0.0378875621,
0.0288855825,
0.0346932374,
0.0486378297,
0.0499355868,
0.0619309992,
-0.0207019579,
0.0154706882,
0.0328525491,
-0.0060730409,
0.0074796476,
-0.0161549412,
0.0322932787,
-0.0111399554,
-0.0228177775,
0.0138020674,
0.0192125123,
0.0495673232,
0.0288127232,
-0.0447503403,
-0.0392784923,
0.0404927582,
-0.0406786688,
-0.0263776239,
-0.0244988017,
0.0149997855,
-0.026393367,
-0.0645201281,
0.0501648933,
-0.0256571602,
0.0010176261,
0.0117255915,
-0.0140546812,
0.0463581905,
-0.0323993973,
0.0068715694,
0.0264837667,
0.0102981646,
0.0217705462,
0.0267912392,
-0.0057670749,
0.0639754683,
0.0229114257,
-0.0369911976,
-0.0400881395,
0.0052105901,
-0.0374604166,
-0.1018255875,
0.0325050578,
0.0349683315,
-0.0227694623,
0.0093197469,
-0.0849011615,
-0.0635172203,
0.0258295722,
-0.0260452405,
0.0022889592,
0.0388430096,
-0.0197139103,
0.0213513095,
-0.0645464286,
0.0875348672,
-0.0177811254,
0.0213895813,
0.0025771973,
0.0261149183,
-0.0019523392,
-0.0475400276,
-0.05322868,
0.0100975167,
-0.0209990386,
-0.0398659781,
-0.0354865603,
0.0263567492,
-0.0033256016,
0.0401214249,
-0.006030323,
-0.0299663041,
-0.0293829627,
-0.0144140441,
0.0232800785,
-0.0355895497,
-0.0061033429,
-0.0099272458,
0.0210346915,
-0.0455682389,
-0.0136077218,
0.0581985153,
0.009302238,
-0.01142425,
-0.0085831871,
0.0667197928,
-0.0236797612,
-0.0174942613,
-0.0356713347,
-0.0659294277,
-0.0486037582,
-0.0601175986,
-0.0138375098,
-0.059975408,
-0.030465832,
-0.0133001879,
-0.0037549976,
-0.0197062045,
0.0160656869,
0.0363574699,
0.009467368,
0.0488451608,
-0.0262311511,
0.0048772325,
0.04865117,
0.0166728217,
-0.0164213851,
0.0481387153,
0.0241534542,
0.0634199828,
0.0575681292,
0.0078049251,
0.0308454987,
0.059559308,
0.0176978186,
0.0073114159,
-0.0002651926,
-0.0402412675,
-0.0099389274,
0.0165662002,
0.0193342771,
0.0674396977,
-0.0151194427,
-0.0183394067,
0.0572863594,
0.0469937474,
0.0121546602,
0.0300883427,
0.0708314627,
0.0361913294,
0.0132602323,
0.080858618,
-0.0129628014,
-0.0190939717,
-0.0499719605,
0.0050621587,
0.0291747302,
0.0085184649,
0.0014121271,
-0.0328470394,
-0.0210542586,
-0.0111150648,
-0.0060587004,
-0.047785908,
0.046192497,
0.013512034,
-0.0423381329,
-0.0258151256,
-0.0065795034,
-0.0416518413,
0.0087860813,
-0.0873358846,
0.0658696145,
0.0319729149,
0.0599275455,
0.005405074,
0.0178646818,
-0.000770603,
0.0004004137,
0.0766707882,
-0.0158683024,
0.0119335297,
-0.0364947692,
-0.0182017498,
0.0020395727,
0.0041925297,
0.0135030895,
0.014564395,
0.0324942842,
0.0302049965,
0.0410264544,
-0.0100077493,
-0.0087090889,
0.0613894686,
-0.054519996,
-0.0280695055,
0.0106963245,
-0.00324519,
0.0108360695,
-0.0030598806,
-0.0273591354,
0.0160317812,
-0.0001830062,
-0.0375323482,
-0.0520849191,
0.003729614,
-0.0502676554,
-0.0393190794,
0.0303781144,
-0.0210081842,
-0.021498302,
0.0308530107,
0.0039862273,
-0.0476532616,
-0.0100431833,
-0.0512678586,
-0.0093419673,
-0.0943008214,
0.0339314267,
0.0118637737,
0.0180179868,
-0.0354976542,
0.0641603991,
0.0161315892,
-0.0109065045,
0.0403344147,
0.0146556292,
0.0609599426,
-0.0389638506,
0.0025085558,
0.0209974367,
-0.0194448326,
-0.0013795181,
0.0491374694,
0.0378914364,
-0.0244301893,
-0.0406505391,
-0.0782158822,
0.0026233101,
-0.0332182869,
0.0136687281,
0.0413955338,
-0.0299169682,
-0.0366964564,
0.0099402228,
-0.0200937558,
-0.0361109674,
0.0661305487,
-0.0108873788,
0.0448572263,
-0.026000673,
0.0105317738,
-0.0327831917,
0.0182345212,
-0.0250372589,
0.0251366589,
0.0589124076,
-0.0619423054,
-0.0831374824,
0.0493549444,
-0.0098047322,
0.0145889772,
0.0121434759,
-0.0566615127,
0.0094350576,
-0.0040882905,
0.058616627,
0.045272015,
0.0357813761,
-0.0040174653,
0.0427034199,
0.0121308761,
-0.0211669616,
-0.0080203293,
-0.0120957829,
0.0049212039,
0.0116841495,
-0.0416181907,
0.0390826687,
0.0686682686,
0.038216956,
0.0002595392,
-0.0528608486,
0.0168206096,
-0.0267215632,
-0.0340970978,
-0.0143290972,
-0.0383858234,
-0.0477850512,
0.0300444551,
-0.0266426746,
-0.0582551062,
0.0539396219,
-0.0720737353,
0.0099390512,
-0.0216074958,
-0.0057574753,
-0.0204171054,
0.0400618613,
0.0233743545,
0.0368942842,
0.041029457,
-0.0212753993,
-0.0385510661,
0.0239046328,
0.0283299051,
-0.0109505132,
-0.0023235185,
-0.0407460779,
0.0197877102,
0.0058056763,
-0.0269040577,
-0.0780736879,
-0.0728940517,
-0.0044042123,
-0.0178946182,
0.0367294438,
-0.0538492873,
0.016249394,
0.0088566495,
0.0085731819,
0.0688443109,
-0.0154047133,
-0.017652344,
-0.0444194935,
0.0537657365,
0.0592876077,
-0.0356913023,
0.0173254963,
-0.040116135,
0.0411827788,
0.064453274,
-0.0031197895,
0.0557835475,
-0.0056862682,
-0.0146842338,
0.0020498449,
-0.0057011829,
-0.0314041376,
0.0242059212,
0.0350529477,
-0.0487459227,
-0.0111064985,
0.132007584,
0.0295124464,
-0.0030593118,
-0.0134009486,
-0.0409015156,
0.0455188975,
-0.0089378702,
0.0144817783,
-0.1036842465,
-0.0150759071,
0.0341117084,
-0.0031488887,
-0.0519586802,
-0.0024347252,
-0.0227951556,
-0.1032402962,
0.0684453025,
0.0165781397,
-0.0175921861,
0.0190185253,
-0.0069846679,
-0.0061394903,
0.0262486022,
-0.0122407675,
-0.0242347717,
-0.0066843266,
-0.0015596029,
0.0086505031,
-0.0488812625,
-0.0117914844,
-0.0019803739,
-0.0366188176,
0.0501388721,
0.0681411773,
0.0391089357,
-0.007463803,
-0.033007171,
0.0487115793,
-0.0042511192,
-0.009593023,
-0.0034858792,
0.0553347953,
-0.0106190788,
-0.0141320117,
-0.0262501091,
0.039072182,
-0.0027234203,
-0.0293333828,
0.0436322279,
0.0584330857,
-0.0203344449,
-0.0715719014,
-0.0148364175,
0.0198031608,
0.019419698,
0.0846978202,
0.0328809768,
-0.0212794002,
-0.0716605857,
-0.0293285735,
0.0396476574,
-0.0502434224,
-0.0249800794,
0.011605029,
-0.0034716257,
-0.0270235743,
-0.0992648005,
-0.0207027514,
-0.0057352292,
0.0191033278,
0.0061180261,
0.0166768134,
0.0049924743,
-0.0200456269,
-0.0254891645,
-0.0419593751,
-0.0571942814,
0.0205452461,
-0.0583733693,
0.0211000834,
-0.0072082733,
-0.0431551151,
-0.0017657867,
0.0395048596,
-0.0805100948,
-0.0603122078,
0.0048236423,
0.012398025,
0.0250295661,
0.0172112379,
-0.0262555778,
-0.0523072332,
0.0650829822,
0.0476611666,
-0.01843784,
0.0302791037,
0.0132827032,
-0.0158020277,
-0.0137158148,
0.019339323,
0.0175454263,
0.0264306441,
-0.0047709066,
0.001040616,
-0.0257931296,
-0.00774393,
0.0403963104,
0.0444297604,
0.0166127291,
-0.051921308,
0.039078135,
-0.0338783599,
-0.0254177004,
-0.0458726436,
-0.0124344463,
-0.0425714329,
0.0235903002,
0.0125530558,
-0.0168168396,
-0.0023164218,
0.0059045036,
-0.0510451235,
0.0271165129,
-0.026003601,
-0.0198172238,
-0.0394606106,
0.0644930899,
0.0154363401,
-0.0254724398,
0.0083835712,
0.0342691503,
-0.0040219249,
0.0296965279,
0.0015206145,
0.0582223646,
0.0335348472,
-0.0267717447,
0.0207003672,
0.0323183313,
-0.054205019,
-0.0183514059,
-0.0408330932,
0.0177501645,
0.0591782779,
0.0104360152,
0.0520718396,
-0.0669671074,
-0.0200501364,
-0.0225591641,
0.042493958,
0.0215593092,
-0.0152130621,
-0.0347213969,
-0.0054718093,
-0.0577436797,
-0.0120989121,
0.0746581107,
0.0497218296,
0.0293411333,
0.0136640435,
-0.0393804125,
-0.0409605056,
-0.0191929527,
-0.0018542749,
0.0079230731,
0.0008927833,
0.0095729437,
-0.0315863974,
-0.0548376292,
0.0264066439,
0.0228409916,
0.0070183626,
0.0034046194,
-0.0165726263,
0.0570899062,
-0.0225189924,
-0.000259356,
-0.0491120294,
0.0211302117,
-0.0012338981,
-0.0124700116,
-0.0285580754,
-6.055543353e-33,
-0.0296416581,
-0.1136347055,
0.0056246403,
0.00777731,
-0.0016952124,
0.0061157788,
-0.0538897887,
0.0004036046,
0.0380197726,
0.0302543007,
-0.0102326665,
0.0150448289,
0.0170996115,
0.0022198206,
-0.0151392613,
-0.0067315679,
0.0648371056,
-0.0145211024,
-0.0397657789,
0.0124026109,
0.0360763147,
-0.0043634111,
0.0078331614,
-0.0885281637,
0.0102006085,
-0.0284763146,
-0.0494734608,
-0.0167928673,
-0.0532710664,
0.0623451211,
-0.0419963449,
0.0209004879,
0.0230364762,
-0.0033675644,
-0.0221157372,
0.0583350584,
-0.0166785438,
-0.0269313212,
-0.0081278365,
-0.0193808135,
-0.0442244336,
-0.0534914508,
0.0262134708,
-0.0397606455,
-0.0385051519,
0.0323312916,
0.0425139852,
-0.0306764208,
0.0240720343,
-0.0195292607,
-0.0621809252,
0.0448183641,
-0.0024823856,
-0.0130700292,
0.0254868548,
0.0406749323,
0.0261531975,
-0.0059083225,
-0.0429944098,
0.0132171242,
0.0246286131,
0.0117115062,
0.0556019992,
0.0180207342,
-0.000611657,
0.057395231,
0.0283531155,
0.0183046982,
-0.0314166173,
-0.0213397332,
0.0081511755,
0.0171378758,
0.058374323,
0.0631720945,
0.0109410044,
-0.0182618573,
-0.0450665168,
0.0387043022,
-0.0278441645,
-0.0169049017,
0.0321062393,
-0.0191090852,
-0.0534668006,
-0.0109565556,
-0.0142925614,
-0.0426510721,
-0.0267332308,
-0.003091288,
0.0518288687,
0.0289772712,
-0.024299005,
-0.009276446,
0.0207191575,
-0.0419375822,
0.0073069609,
-0.0101430425,
-0.0625379458,
-0.0033248626,
0.0111397197,
0.0532766208,
-0.0189485084,
-0.0097950501,
0.0251891203,
0.0273006763,
0.027987795,
0.010575979,
0.0167909358,
0.0221838858,
-0.0721740052,
0.0286536571,
-0.026758289,
0.0409294404,
0.0050748931,
-0.0366072617,
0.0182485674,
-0.0340886861,
-0.0030146376,
0.0148854256,
0.0480243489,
-0.0122263217,
-0.0506331287,
0.0142207788,
-0.0219800454,
0.013004438,
-0.0252449866,
0.0276546441,
-0.0219064057,
0.027741611,
0.0608276539,
-0.036162544,
0.0154873244,
-0.0400368571,
2.552e-7,
0.0179731324,
0.0411216877,
0.0516598113,
0.0443601012,
0.018935388,
0.044696331,
0.0116838543,
0.0137709165,
-0.0093833152,
0.0041364222,
0.0049197706,
-0.0057415846,
0.0785607994,
0.0204703622,
-0.0436564609,
0.0357374474,
-0.0818254352,
-0.01421599,
-0.0666351095,
-0.0017976118,
0.0892202482,
0.0380876996,
0.0170413703,
-0.0167663507,
0.0248727165,
-0.0713540614,
0.0636656284,
0.0071076918,
0.002384549,
0.0306795724,
0.0433889031,
0.0133057293,
0.0156162502,
0.0127631696,
-0.0147087369,
-0.0093400078,
0.0204815306,
0.0662366971,
0.0251680333,
0.0508365519,
0.0014880226,
-0.0024662444,
0.0125313867,
-0.0646125674,
0.0670008287,
-0.0227327961,
0.0002926061,
-0.0480225049,
-0.0072708582,
-0.0565997474,
0.0197742283,
-0.0452561975,
-0.0266962256,
0.0300992504,
0.0119196214,
0.0138994139,
0.0033131684,
-0.0587150156,
-0.0491916016,
-0.039466273,
-0.0704306513,
0.0027477478,
-0.070483014,
0.0058208527,
0.0188450925,
-0.0849586576,
0.0210063364,
2.765684971e-34,
0.0101074437,
-0.0186080821,
0.0018126877,
0.0023542203,
0.0473925807,
0.0245900825,
0.0318967886,
0.0314862654,
0.0092812171,
-0.0433704704,
0.0038990837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14478v1 | GeoLM: Empowering Language Models for Geospatially Grounded Language Understanding | 2023-10-23T01:20:01 | 2023-10-23T01:20:01 | Zekun Li, Wenxuan Zhou, Yao-Yi Chiang, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans subconsciously engage in geospatial reasoning when reading articles.
We recognize place names and their spatial relations in text and mentally
associate them with their physical locations on Earth. Although pretrained
language models can mimic this cognitive process using linguistic context, they
do not utilize valuable geospatial information in large, widely available
geographical databases, e.g., OpenStreetMap. This paper introduces GeoLM, a
geospatially grounded language model that enhances the understanding of
geo-entities in natural language. GeoLM leverages geo-entity mentions as
anchors to connect linguistic information in text corpora with geospatial
information extracted from geographical databases. GeoLM connects the two types
of context through contrastive learning and masked language modeling. It also
incorporates a spatial coordinate embedding mechanism to encode distance and
direction relations to capture geospatial context. In the experiment, we
demonstrate that GeoLM exhibits promising capabilities in supporting toponym
recognition, toponym linking, relation extraction, and geo-entity typing, which
bridge the gap between natural language processing and geospatial sciences. The
code is publicly available at https://github.com/knowledge-computing/geolm. | [
0.0334887505,
0.061128974,
-0.0168644674,
0.0303954389,
-0.0204462055,
0.0208869427,
0.0194132719,
-0.0410772078,
0.0466607213,
-0.0703790411,
-0.0129307266,
0.0227765795,
0.0209146831,
0.0160251651,
0.0404709131,
-0.1001461595,
0.0380935743,
-0.0280169416,
0.0023520868,
0.013754664,
-0.0292502213,
0.0392861962,
-0.0022669258,
0.0137261888,
0.0292666424,
0.0089831594,
0.0161165558,
0.0052712867,
0.0228956882,
-0.0680787712,
0.0088862572,
0.0093457568,
-0.0006867148,
0.0265669674,
0.0000018957,
-0.0118123973,
-0.0092143305,
0.0158671793,
0.0345833339,
-0.0286793206,
-0.0224779025,
-0.0427826904,
0.0062221419,
-0.0301600005,
-0.034146525,
-0.0532137714,
0.0572003238,
0.0312106423,
0.0174880791,
0.0135862157,
-0.0173796937,
-0.0722639263,
-0.0133095635,
0.0199623909,
-0.0285868142,
0.0457890294,
0.0190999471,
-0.0225563105,
-0.0055256011,
0.0899375826,
-0.0200444907,
0.0215752888,
-0.0248571765,
0.0430452451,
-0.0006564113,
0.0720793158,
-0.0317998119,
0.0428040177,
0.0118764741,
0.0548908822,
0.0009073871,
-0.0276623238,
0.0458190367,
0.0281007551,
-0.036251843,
0.0337079093,
-0.02692445,
-0.013081857,
-0.0057354635,
0.0558702685,
-0.0067610047,
0.0124232881,
0.0337460786,
0.0523868948,
-0.0110789454,
0.0874591097,
0.0049222643,
-0.0442435741,
-0.0443869084,
0.0281028524,
0.0230654608,
-0.0670895502,
0.0206896272,
0.0238491744,
-0.0036962223,
0.02527803,
-0.007065611,
0.0478066914,
0.0087200189,
-0.0506969765,
-0.0086417329,
-0.0143575519,
-0.0122524351,
0.0533148162,
-0.0149735287,
0.0204083174,
0.0081352331,
0.045586586,
0.0265592281,
-0.0317072421,
0.0011470874,
-0.004034631,
-0.0304374322,
0.0066339425,
-0.0670238435,
0.0256414209,
0.0146853151,
0.0096373651,
-0.0158372689,
0.0276754256,
-0.0874790847,
0.0230663046,
-0.0051210588,
-0.0478691272,
-0.021154929,
-0.0177732036,
-0.0110244304,
0.0141451275,
-0.043393787,
0.0197500139,
0.009438958,
-0.004831593,
0.0337774269,
-0.0035168941,
-0.0257250518,
0.0303779542,
0.0594995469,
-0.0351371616,
-0.0702416524,
0.0031427138,
0.0073953886,
0.0026397984,
-0.0079194419,
-0.0862167552,
-0.0390235335,
0.0220735557,
-0.0442773812,
-0.0656972826,
-0.0076157581,
0.025549762,
-0.075638853,
0.0783246905,
-0.0727639422,
-0.017946694,
0.0665149614,
0.0077638067,
0.0437756516,
0.0629808232,
0.0393538326,
0.051475212,
0.0543908477,
0.0156229502,
-0.0292205065,
-0.0140235107,
0.018659303,
0.0184474494,
-0.0454338007,
0.0043911082,
-0.0201770663,
0.0242210161,
0.0247245636,
0.0474330783,
0.0097469641,
0.005047583,
0.0632732734,
0.0837753192,
-0.0206219144,
-0.0123317493,
0.0440507643,
0.0600067265,
-0.0651295409,
-0.0240675174,
-0.0570470095,
-0.0300013926,
-0.0277168509,
0.0265333783,
-0.0078902123,
0.0791523084,
-0.0088639557,
-0.0003572807,
-0.0336124562,
0.0071774935,
0.0433903262,
-0.0004434854,
0.0466459654,
-0.0199071616,
-0.016750982,
0.0553659871,
0.0313808098,
0.0040034316,
0.033070609,
0.0362212136,
-0.02760786,
0.0212660227,
-0.0025900991,
0.0240673423,
0.0008310789,
-0.043180611,
0.0344618969,
0.039760042,
0.0159228165,
0.0031409094,
-0.0137954261,
-0.0315265581,
-0.0113728959,
0.0445708372,
0.0081863301,
-0.0096487561,
0.0476300195,
0.0513836853,
0.0437477157,
-0.038405221,
0.0211223625,
-0.0045972471,
-0.003393169,
-0.0268386193,
-0.0456111915,
0.0268695485,
-0.0510948487,
0.0144784385,
-0.0137086455,
-0.0009612441,
0.0228939448,
-0.0129346093,
-0.0054072449,
0.0398006998,
-0.0076968023,
0.0027264424,
0.008592003,
-0.0361506566,
0.0002699737,
-0.0055081798,
-0.0084245093,
-0.0241085831,
-0.0114450222,
-0.0153457662,
0.0881441906,
-0.0170624983,
-0.0046547721,
0.0064506396,
0.0229390152,
-0.0654884949,
0.0559444763,
-0.017130943,
0.0363094732,
-0.0018144025,
0.0140219228,
0.0050397166,
0.0273109619,
0.0009799202,
-0.0358021073,
-0.0123232352,
0.001141781,
-0.0206441116,
-0.0084088184,
-0.0334784053,
-0.0187681112,
-0.0754856616,
0.0085212514,
-0.0137947025,
0.0297793448,
0.008069844,
-0.0226997733,
-0.057822872,
-0.0270748846,
0.0076137385,
-0.0508147627,
-0.0262985416,
0.0210943799,
0.0486484468,
-0.0461990312,
0.0115500633,
-0.0042071091,
0.0017510494,
-0.037533395,
0.0498658381,
-0.000328764,
-0.0246673264,
-0.033643093,
0.0255355369,
-0.0096627334,
0.0034591311,
0.0187531244,
-0.0113731008,
-0.0141040487,
0.0310540702,
0.0230010599,
0.0080008293,
-0.0046823565,
-0.0027250124,
0.0224711504,
-0.0699022561,
-0.0399594679,
0.0056141736,
-0.0245975424,
0.0465839654,
-0.0136009222,
-0.0265060849,
0.0049655964,
0.0486855507,
-0.006481865,
-0.0099984007,
0.0202256124,
0.0392336808,
-0.0274848677,
0.003700058,
-0.023682246,
0.0121093923,
0.0035221048,
0.0594726913,
-0.0439000651,
-0.0430711545,
0.0366591662,
-0.0465029739,
0.0102245398,
-0.0306944326,
-0.0152368816,
-0.0248306096,
0.0653619692,
-0.00388182,
0.03344547,
0.0285863113,
-0.0593281873,
0.0285109207,
-0.0367029719,
-0.0459322743,
0.0185308997,
-0.0050597363,
-0.0407589823,
0.0013441887,
0.0230536647,
-0.0322229005,
-0.0259918738,
-0.0151462061,
-0.0457853861,
0.0005835891,
-0.0028621065,
-0.0340151116,
0.0544724427,
0.0710054338,
0.0043397355,
0.0200866926,
-0.0045441138,
-0.0137163484,
-0.0214300938,
0.0081619518,
0.0611584894,
0.0589880869,
-0.001207436,
0.0709126517,
-0.0683876947,
-0.0026265581,
-0.0180102419,
0.0103853624,
0.0200646762,
0.0205222964,
0.0294020027,
-0.0762249827,
-0.0752496794,
-0.0042247311,
0.0383721516,
-0.0431291871,
-0.0649678409,
0.1012380347,
0.0615694076,
-0.01836087,
0.0115328161,
-0.0003419121,
0.0138790589,
0.0312150177,
0.0283388998,
-0.0377091914,
0.014200286,
0.008473698,
-0.0610639863,
-0.0043665878,
-0.0382856317,
-0.0062809531,
-0.0894104913,
0.0309258513,
-0.0055649178,
-0.0689632371,
-0.0330276974,
-0.0597750209,
-0.0223699026,
0.0286244974,
-0.0437951647,
-0.034453012,
-0.0302520525,
0.0169815794,
0.0332241692,
-0.0638144314,
-0.0236232691,
-0.0075753941,
-0.0749926344,
0.0395395458,
-0.0060363202,
0.0802812353,
-0.0083415508,
-0.0720229298,
-0.0320786126,
0.0254980344,
-0.0031960704,
-0.0345345102,
0.017008435,
-0.0136736948,
-0.0184282139,
0.0033499531,
-0.000622598,
-0.0387467481,
-0.0377655402,
-0.0143103683,
0.0488747098,
-0.0065621273,
0.0806162283,
-0.0198688731,
0.0452957042,
0.0395429805,
0.0111294538,
0.0094398092,
0.0233561546,
-0.0376054831,
-0.0535671897,
0.0165716913,
-0.0184618998,
-0.0198237021,
0.0406578742,
-0.0201153662,
-0.0209112298,
-0.0300691519,
-0.0458053723,
0.0139825363,
0.040138308,
0.013119569,
0.0129399113,
0.0429517142,
-0.0457501002,
-0.0828140974,
0.0601062998,
-0.0244953446,
0.0309069548,
0.0124762254,
-0.0126510197,
0.0384605713,
0.0020354867,
-0.0317200758,
0.0233645998,
-0.0385398716,
-0.053053271,
0.028170567,
-0.0043695895,
0.012776603,
0.0094513362,
-0.0509677641,
-0.0143187633,
0.0104246121,
0.0371659137,
-0.0610334687,
-0.0056770407,
0.0119817955,
0.0371971503,
0.029293688,
0.0024722707,
0.0020896599,
0.0117805796,
0.0220099054,
-0.0057699587,
-0.0719038919,
0.0242769271,
-0.0248410106,
-0.0281011052,
0.1355241537,
-0.0163077097,
0.0137714911,
-0.0221467894,
-0.0105141606,
-0.0376290381,
0.0167296566,
0.0099308807,
0.0036545151,
0.0113362698,
0.0355454236,
-0.0331665576,
-0.0072925924,
0.0043325382,
-0.0099676521,
-0.0161381327,
-0.0150429392,
0.0195814185,
0.03425375,
-0.0035501879,
0.025467895,
-0.0202811807,
0.0031923531,
-0.0208144374,
0.0361112691,
-0.0214836001,
-0.0334938765,
0.0258562416,
0.0077977786,
-0.0403612815,
0.0213812403,
-0.0474551879,
-0.0227431022,
-0.0127682677,
-0.0036291312,
0.0634810701,
-0.008079268,
-0.0064064083,
0.011356405,
-0.0010577755,
0.0388527401,
0.0047704186,
-0.0137140853,
-0.0729018003,
0.0229650438,
0.0023760435,
-0.0584313013,
0.0321422331,
0.0110451709,
0.0401291065,
0.0259103179,
0.0452183448,
-0.0383713767,
0.0067344652,
0.0204609297,
-0.0053438544,
0.0557015277,
-0.0178869963,
0.0180442538,
-0.0807792693,
-0.0722161755,
0.0486925468,
-0.0016071103,
0.0128675923,
0.0140544837,
0.0335820615,
0.0303330645,
0.0132352207,
-0.0265060924,
-0.040080443,
0.0132921515,
-0.0125158494,
-0.0506679304,
-0.0183934513,
-5.973325972e-33,
-0.0369612947,
-0.1119611636,
0.0663231984,
0.0071175126,
-0.0116384001,
0.0304019544,
-0.0202002395,
0.0003653515,
-0.0083311759,
-0.0025319098,
0.0043473248,
-0.0074158181,
0.0076899296,
0.0345256962,
-0.0123652108,
0.010819152,
0.0032505286,
0.0577961169,
0.0198090654,
-0.0121872965,
0.0588520654,
0.0317651033,
0.0576655455,
-0.1236988604,
0.0320379846,
0.0340305753,
-0.0352579281,
0.0194343179,
0.0481889695,
0.0546383262,
-0.036019966,
0.0338471048,
0.0159762222,
-0.0034499287,
-0.02324057,
0.0266517866,
-0.0758303851,
-0.0412648208,
0.026497405,
0.0001749984,
0.0292183962,
-0.0340597704,
0.0497059822,
0.0083145266,
0.0104076928,
0.0439694002,
0.0432928354,
0.0165855214,
-0.0881471336,
0.021320913,
-0.0717896149,
0.0345842801,
0.0147342235,
0.0355423577,
0.0123573067,
-0.047348693,
0.0174485017,
0.0253121685,
-0.038530495,
0.0131883193,
0.0515463725,
0.0110445097,
0.0429757275,
0.0133778602,
0.0203532558,
0.0771366954,
-0.0115597071,
-0.0387549922,
-0.0552168898,
0.0132272532,
0.0917524323,
-0.0072769104,
-0.025768863,
0.0487268679,
-0.0406330563,
-0.0357085988,
-0.0276534799,
0.0099670012,
-0.0417935327,
-0.0295993518,
-0.0098080523,
0.0051894435,
-0.0425958149,
-0.0395596437,
-0.0399469323,
-0.0560880788,
-0.0095602227,
-0.0217627082,
0.0242863055,
-0.0196707267,
0.0039366563,
0.0978578031,
-0.0291364361,
-0.0270576961,
-0.0696118847,
0.0126280421,
0.0239220299,
-0.015250721,
-0.0126936203,
0.04084149,
-0.0639465675,
-0.0221753586,
-0.0291539468,
0.0378293991,
-0.0025555012,
0.027014209,
-0.0019456773,
0.0066493563,
-0.0734780505,
0.000314255,
-0.0074742162,
-0.0337098725,
-0.0283274781,
-0.0304228682,
0.0177661441,
-0.0162027366,
0.0049109757,
0.0459781736,
0.0555374995,
0.0057912669,
0.0072557754,
0.0200675745,
-0.0557735339,
0.0556622222,
0.0165795535,
-0.0213881154,
-0.0002835504,
0.0090003069,
0.0374921262,
-0.0427475162,
-0.0038264885,
-0.0182716716,
2.593e-7,
0.0422368124,
0.0968079343,
0.0147066172,
-0.0036451367,
-0.0123569435,
0.0184395649,
0.0621821918,
0.027261544,
-0.0333515368,
0.0251727905,
-0.0221358519,
0.0173398759,
-0.0124511104,
0.0392407738,
-0.1246237084,
0.0752914697,
-0.0458418429,
-0.0108455606,
-0.0869347826,
-0.0087063909,
0.0478999168,
0.0334792249,
0.0502376705,
0.0078412434,
-0.0278278757,
-0.0299738608,
-0.0089311069,
-0.0556754023,
-0.007711886,
-0.0103238029,
0.0134241423,
0.0029861513,
0.0110651022,
-0.0302160792,
-0.0102637019,
-0.000909034,
0.0106323371,
0.0250038709,
-0.029343104,
0.0157578625,
-0.0182144437,
-0.1090679914,
-0.0193650257,
-0.0949163139,
0.0353344306,
-0.0217368621,
-0.0183330942,
-0.0009386014,
0.0000259646,
0.0167800691,
0.0185260419,
-0.0049547357,
-0.0422802344,
-0.0310126748,
0.0245327987,
0.002746376,
-0.0104639521,
-0.0976732597,
-0.0157607701,
0.0442456417,
0.0357631035,
0.0259959213,
-0.017242711,
0.0047088317,
0.03327756,
-0.0035614038,
-0.0054484387,
2.417939074e-34,
-0.0289423522,
0.0197671,
-0.0394611359,
0.042366311,
0.0511943139,
-0.0052659754,
0.0047289054,
0.0209008642,
0.0027001372,
-0.0165822171,
0.0299834721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14451v1 | Domain Terminology Integration into Machine Translation: Leveraging Large Language Models | 2023-10-22T23:25:28 | 2023-10-22T23:25:28 | Yasmin Moslem, Gianfranco Romani, Mahdi Molaei, Rejwanul Haque, John D. Kelleher, Andy Way | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper discusses the methods that we used for our submissions to the WMT
2023 Terminology Shared Task for German-to-English (DE-EN), English-to-Czech
(EN-CS), and Chinese-to-English (ZH-EN) language pairs. The task aims to
advance machine translation (MT) by challenging participants to develop systems
that accurately translate technical terms, ultimately enhancing communication
and understanding in specialised domains. To this end, we conduct experiments
that utilise large language models (LLMs) for two purposes: generating
synthetic bilingual terminology-based data, and post-editing translations
generated by an MT model through incorporating pre-approved terms. Our system
employs a four-step process: (i) using an LLM to generate bilingual synthetic
data based on the provided terminology, (ii) fine-tuning a generic
encoder-decoder MT model, with a mix of the terminology-based synthetic data
generated in the first step and a randomly sampled portion of the original
generic training data, (iii) generating translations with the fine-tuned MT
model, and (iv) finally, leveraging an LLM for terminology-constrained
automatic post-editing of the translations that do not include the required
terms. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed approach in
improving the integration of pre-approved terms into translations. The number
of terms incorporated into the translations of the blind dataset increases from
an average of 36.67% with the generic model to an average of 72.88% by the end
of the process. In other words, successful utilisation of terms nearly doubles
across the three language pairs. | [
0.0283440724,
-0.0244508497,
-0.0087294523,
0.0251663905,
-0.0290345866,
0.0043112147,
0.016487008,
-0.0289505068,
-0.0448748842,
-0.0634251088,
-0.0323136933,
-0.0414888486,
0.0098509239,
0.0197774321,
0.0335744098,
-0.0566094965,
0.0371001996,
-0.0214121118,
-0.0821013227,
-0.0075322404,
-0.0170039441,
0.0158566497,
0.0338401273,
0.0191936549,
0.0293981861,
-0.0064497637,
0.0287399217,
0.0233135913,
0.0118813552,
-0.000837179,
0.0040359111,
0.0466592312,
0.0671251565,
0.0834254399,
0.000002182,
-0.0902851969,
-0.0561538562,
0.0276030656,
-0.0184052177,
0.0250712987,
0.0517816842,
-0.0366888754,
-0.0076147192,
0.0081895366,
-0.0159829613,
-0.0118340971,
0.0316246152,
-0.0023656741,
0.0477711894,
0.0303734597,
-0.0103430394,
-0.034970209,
0.0183429904,
-0.0261668768,
-0.0053389948,
-0.0490855016,
-0.0040066866,
0.0375864059,
-0.0199108087,
0.0523912385,
0.0058820643,
0.047528781,
0.0064896168,
-0.0008878637,
0.0267055165,
-0.0040325471,
-0.0024329675,
-0.0307233445,
-0.0090657342,
0.0541482717,
0.0271032229,
0.010183651,
-0.0239341781,
0.0154512916,
0.0094976574,
0.023369709,
-0.0620150231,
0.0140860276,
-0.0082796952,
-0.026490245,
0.014557898,
0.0217440743,
0.0083845491,
0.0109960288,
-0.0571041703,
0.0237398874,
0.0533541702,
-0.0361797437,
-0.0077199424,
-0.0042888205,
-0.0015515197,
-0.0324901678,
0.0428004786,
-0.0162596237,
-0.0036021753,
0.0331735089,
-0.0316957161,
-0.0047313473,
0.0125112692,
-0.0837480947,
0.0023125832,
0.0331350304,
-0.0238231979,
0.0543461964,
-0.0122001935,
0.0413936414,
-0.0154458545,
-0.0113330437,
-0.084753342,
-0.0253651328,
-0.0479292013,
0.0146346148,
-0.0349233262,
-0.0033043143,
-0.0420961417,
-0.0032088172,
-0.0545663387,
0.0134221325,
-0.0020208247,
0.0128114726,
0.0412062071,
-0.0401236936,
-0.0819148421,
-0.030516142,
-0.0239683539,
0.047255341,
0.0060920818,
-0.0061743185,
-0.0162617993,
-0.0343413316,
0.0055861613,
0.017460946,
-0.0386329703,
-0.0484227203,
0.0046039973,
0.0855784044,
-0.0170754418,
0.0032155004,
0.0201954059,
-0.0177874826,
0.0116646029,
-0.019991206,
0.0019770786,
-0.0767244846,
0.0437054895,
0.0039735129,
0.0158494413,
-0.056653142,
0.0183999501,
-0.0000517624,
-0.0381148793,
0.0695230216,
-0.0504088029,
0.0030055565,
0.0608828291,
0.0130229192,
0.0017975167,
0.0456292406,
0.0242419615,
0.0151456688,
0.0442885458,
-0.0148299932,
-0.0114780208,
0.0576630048,
-0.0311277658,
0.0149217946,
-0.0479976609,
-0.0025402009,
0.0272981208,
0.0247307867,
0.0341552831,
0.0326897055,
-0.0076772035,
0.0462360531,
0.0442125201,
0.0264006928,
0.0306595694,
0.0409475304,
0.0470001288,
-0.0098865302,
-0.0037498034,
0.0025500325,
0.0047893021,
-0.0104970401,
-0.0247140322,
0.0428258404,
0.042165909,
0.0390432775,
-0.0163838938,
-0.0459125377,
-0.0062029879,
0.000631927,
0.0413093567,
-0.0194361191,
0.0709072202,
-0.010828671,
-0.0478275567,
0.0703775734,
-0.0080918651,
-0.0176109243,
0.040086817,
-0.0148216216,
-0.063850522,
0.0985066965,
0.0549566522,
0.0097892918,
-0.0555227287,
-0.0203920286,
0.0072773732,
0.0754135698,
0.0628302842,
-0.0097173993,
-0.0364401676,
-0.0576177463,
-0.0470288843,
0.0008635481,
0.00441695,
0.0327297188,
-0.0000686873,
0.0184077565,
0.0502859354,
-0.0371161923,
-0.0805719644,
0.0204080287,
-0.0497439131,
-0.0568935536,
-0.0118831424,
-0.0202050339,
0.0028757404,
0.062671259,
-0.0455337577,
0.0075070723,
0.0125892982,
-0.0354142897,
-0.0157101862,
0.0449684598,
0.0023317626,
0.011298215,
0.0449442901,
-0.0406996943,
-0.0109522017,
-0.0189793967,
-0.0364330821,
-0.0348670706,
-0.0391840339,
-0.0118382927,
-0.0085869608,
-0.0458820872,
0.0387949385,
0.0030782328,
0.0044037369,
-0.0374129675,
0.0082258433,
0.0156780351,
0.0032421795,
0.0068096551,
-0.0351477265,
0.0070170881,
0.0009004245,
-0.0165743418,
0.0516848415,
0.0156411137,
0.0367834084,
0.0274853352,
0.0144494912,
-0.0287831482,
0.0143484855,
-0.070932284,
0.0257065874,
-0.0187590085,
0.0423455164,
0.0502815582,
0.0054386482,
-0.0060076332,
0.0415309146,
0.0091239503,
-0.031507846,
-0.0078224242,
0.0198690575,
0.0021145784,
0.0085668536,
-0.0051427898,
-0.0213371385,
0.0106604854,
0.0087537877,
0.0148766525,
0.0336666778,
-0.0467998832,
-0.0743131936,
0.0641507804,
-0.0295693707,
-0.0253006052,
0.0133429235,
-0.050386522,
-0.0365472399,
0.0034046329,
0.0513374954,
0.0178775322,
0.0139608365,
-0.0091916639,
0.0549561866,
-0.0155155482,
-0.04245634,
-0.0263711326,
0.0057673478,
-0.0774772018,
-0.0161211994,
-0.0600638799,
0.0321599916,
0.0401719436,
-0.0314868726,
-0.0003986746,
-0.0280254446,
-0.0284900628,
-0.0545837246,
-0.0318365395,
-0.0280350484,
0.0156422071,
-0.0241730604,
0.0601855777,
0.00692156,
-0.0308189616,
0.0754831135,
-0.043877326,
-0.0050030542,
-0.0744730905,
-0.0096240444,
-0.0217068251,
0.0324648283,
-0.0445211157,
0.0115249148,
-0.004660238,
-0.0084851859,
-0.0345792584,
0.0118303467,
0.0165889822,
-0.0384665988,
0.0436160117,
-0.0632184744,
0.0067417612,
-0.0204370618,
0.0416910276,
-0.0321702249,
0.0203542449,
-0.0012908825,
0.0195487197,
0.0503993146,
-0.0049339626,
-0.0073810648,
0.0542203523,
0.0232007597,
0.0646047741,
0.0202531759,
-0.000909337,
-0.0108570876,
-0.0004857018,
0.0192067903,
-0.0074093011,
-0.0051914095,
-0.0510668159,
0.0358226523,
0.0085220076,
-0.0246728454,
-0.0419032723,
0.0055679148,
-0.0492702238,
0.0479527265,
-0.0572067946,
-0.0249147508,
-0.008211148,
0.0184602123,
-0.0464137457,
0.0041094823,
0.1341655999,
0.0395110399,
-0.0456342474,
-0.0318071954,
-0.0389500968,
-0.01928127,
0.0200619716,
0.0373635367,
-0.1062575802,
-0.0009742959,
0.0147232451,
0.0096835969,
0.0084358351,
0.0303593315,
-0.0158722214,
-0.1000709683,
0.0420569964,
0.066588521,
-0.0013069247,
-0.0432465486,
-0.0065012253,
-0.0233336836,
-0.0181224514,
0.0314343572,
-0.0297296457,
0.004856878,
-0.018198235,
0.001991173,
-0.0042221667,
-0.0962830782,
0.0313143246,
-0.0551817492,
0.0352301151,
0.0602749847,
0.0091877403,
-0.0315329395,
-0.0177221969,
0.0584165268,
-0.0127417799,
-0.0013229088,
-0.0077850884,
0.0118926624,
-0.0140386112,
0.0282828342,
0.0265172813,
-0.0065039843,
-0.0136986189,
0.0022754751,
0.0311422832,
0.068241708,
-0.0042610159,
0.0221978724,
0.002252711,
0.0051425612,
-0.0155846039,
0.0570630468,
0.0201762058,
-0.0410148464,
0.044060301,
-0.0432266481,
-0.0270018429,
-0.0386899374,
-0.0265596099,
0.0033677118,
-0.1166007444,
-0.0433393642,
-0.0543049723,
-0.0609363951,
0.0324301496,
0.0233332347,
0.0531728268,
0.0569929779,
0.0021411092,
0.009177113,
-0.0508622676,
0.0653456748,
-0.0281489491,
0.0180783626,
-0.0505381338,
-0.0246751253,
0.0221793782,
-0.0241210144,
-0.0348179601,
0.0542861223,
0.0024959627,
-0.07053978,
-0.0007127462,
0.0327490084,
0.0271495301,
0.0261839796,
-0.0058626784,
-0.0256121978,
0.0086705219,
0.014166439,
0.0114271529,
-0.0108987968,
0.0417671166,
0.011362833,
-0.0296546835,
-0.0033056885,
-0.0296195745,
0.0034442977,
-0.0273490176,
0.0475031994,
0.0077859634,
-0.0770402253,
0.0435886979,
0.0308838896,
0.0353403799,
-0.0341928564,
-0.0131244548,
-0.0290880222,
0.0148396706,
-0.0135490745,
-0.0346210562,
-0.0335330442,
-0.0159242507,
0.050296478,
-0.0201968513,
0.0189536139,
0.0544456206,
-0.0538314469,
-0.0536160097,
-0.0001878387,
0.0072180964,
-0.0586357042,
0.055023171,
0.0296098143,
0.0081740282,
-0.0291204397,
-0.0022756052,
-0.0052498658,
0.0092193568,
-0.0289988853,
0.0382487029,
-0.0166743081,
0.0371553898,
-0.0067849839,
0.0453765579,
-0.0054269023,
-0.0333914869,
-0.0329881348,
0.0291926302,
0.0893217772,
0.025733117,
0.0701093748,
-0.0301357899,
-0.0421143882,
-0.030522462,
0.024615813,
0.0041894736,
0.0085334331,
0.012321013,
-0.0022395879,
-0.0164481122,
-0.0188912842,
0.0628010407,
0.0045613074,
0.0048395745,
-0.0113615692,
-0.0158925746,
0.0047783633,
-0.0147005357,
0.0228812788,
-0.0391181521,
-0.0358840153,
-0.0247451253,
-0.0706563964,
-0.0613079667,
0.0083935978,
0.019719664,
-0.0068837539,
0.0083004357,
0.0016207267,
0.0790339336,
-0.0475940742,
-0.0038179036,
-0.0287199803,
0.043694403,
0.0025319462,
-0.0352821723,
-0.0079278974,
-6.362686435e-33,
-0.0391082019,
-0.0222548265,
0.0235247277,
-0.0209840145,
-0.0481236316,
-0.0250411052,
-0.0116892494,
-0.0348163769,
0.0361703113,
0.0158621818,
0.0034775725,
-0.0322572738,
0.0226891451,
-0.0214259978,
0.0260675177,
0.0179650262,
0.0630691499,
0.0319648907,
-0.004610145,
0.0011852805,
0.0150077939,
0.0307296515,
0.0984720141,
-0.0301769264,
0.0779175758,
-0.0300993305,
0.007534652,
-0.0010917006,
0.0434380434,
0.0457739606,
0.0108054075,
0.0273368042,
0.0212860052,
-0.0699839368,
-0.0251206737,
-0.0020893193,
-0.0473733619,
0.0138410013,
0.051778309,
0.0223792717,
0.0358966477,
-0.0808521062,
0.0389392748,
-0.0354643278,
-0.0589129403,
-0.0017141749,
0.0208817031,
-0.0550592877,
-0.0249078143,
-0.0264234841,
-0.0787779093,
0.0230222382,
0.0106129218,
-0.009183567,
0.0385152027,
0.0528515987,
0.0029370734,
0.0060935793,
-0.058818493,
0.0435671322,
0.0426754951,
0.0381477773,
0.1154498532,
-0.0059345718,
-0.0003026874,
-0.0163685344,
-0.0147028249,
0.0088191275,
0.0333711877,
-0.0296964031,
0.0152057419,
0.0011732472,
0.0272055082,
0.0630099699,
0.0467766486,
-0.0254119802,
-0.0012060277,
0.0754184425,
-0.0549859926,
0.0108391717,
0.0028101106,
0.0120689264,
-0.0186608136,
-0.0136154871,
-0.0508182235,
0.0289747175,
-0.0215994027,
-0.0644492581,
0.0243958365,
-0.0084338952,
-0.0235900749,
-0.0068426691,
0.0725235417,
-0.0252741128,
0.0151542844,
-0.0382535271,
0.0093717398,
0.0081287799,
-0.0356056839,
0.0657570809,
-0.0004426923,
-0.039648585,
-0.0069742859,
0.0068479902,
0.000084651,
-0.0186606161,
-0.0171928592,
-0.0104909949,
-0.0168694332,
0.0249816533,
-0.0292092916,
-0.0582126155,
-0.0148263332,
0.0162645187,
0.0214562137,
0.0434496552,
0.0035506827,
0.0150234168,
0.0443619601,
-0.038725175,
-0.0471530631,
-0.0100091659,
0.0146702696,
0.0501414388,
-0.0090433629,
0.0493927076,
-0.0246760696,
0.0006352905,
0.0481292307,
-0.0014502372,
-0.0276984982,
-0.0326100588,
2.952e-7,
0.0422055572,
0.0976065993,
-0.0298963971,
0.0125885531,
-0.0174480267,
-0.0060906047,
-0.0295779686,
0.0423292331,
0.0168861821,
0.0195521098,
0.0347869843,
0.014949752,
0.0525500178,
0.0350663364,
-0.0642265007,
-0.0667646751,
0.0121657364,
0.0426534452,
-0.0669452921,
0.0115206912,
0.0598747432,
0.0700462461,
-0.0263688751,
0.0153314779,
-0.0364005752,
-0.0343822837,
0.0559266657,
-0.0580004677,
-0.0541115366,
0.0628468171,
0.0441399291,
0.0242812373,
-0.0225357674,
0.0314348415,
-0.0398658477,
-0.0012825452,
0.0392346308,
0.0902612805,
0.002480001,
0.0261066202,
-0.0089869285,
-0.0255142823,
0.0024599456,
-0.0458548404,
-0.0007161158,
-0.0652258247,
-0.0035972937,
0.0188979134,
-0.0461397916,
0.0185639337,
0.0225456245,
-0.0512678325,
0.0077318833,
0.0145508945,
0.0321166478,
0.0282930024,
-0.0355877765,
-0.0274995249,
0.0188725144,
0.0426820219,
-0.0212179348,
-0.0659246892,
-0.0096314941,
-0.0342518091,
-0.0000677117,
-0.0010315037,
0.0203345753,
2.86384931e-34,
0.056026496,
-0.0057264748,
0.0139218299,
0.0227373242,
0.0454901457,
-0.0307503883,
-0.0059322179,
0.0244198125,
-0.0188436341,
-0.0622961782,
-0.0094318241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14450v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14450v3 | TATA: Stance Detection via Topic-Agnostic and Topic-Aware Embeddings | 2023-10-22T23:23:44 | 2024-02-08T15:17:15 | Hans W. A. Hanley, Zakir Durumeric | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Stance detection is important for understanding different attitudes and
beliefs on the Internet. However, given that a passage's stance toward a given
topic is often highly dependent on that topic, building a stance detection
model that generalizes to unseen topics is difficult. In this work, we propose
using contrastive learning as well as an unlabeled dataset of news articles
that cover a variety of different topics to train topic-agnostic/TAG and
topic-aware/TAW embeddings for use in downstream stance detection. Combining
these embeddings in our full TATA model, we achieve state-of-the-art
performance across several public stance detection datasets (0.771 $F_1$-score
on the Zero-shot VAST dataset). We release our code and data at
https://github.com/hanshanley/tata. | [
0.0303602051,
0.0390283652,
0.0357416905,
0.0654991269,
-0.0112570897,
0.0361542627,
-0.0074684927,
-0.0117176333,
0.0010751105,
-0.0392178595,
-0.0088013848,
-0.0269761663,
-0.0320260972,
0.0084990095,
-0.0048422068,
-0.0123231811,
0.0301401224,
0.0799130127,
0.0657974705,
-0.0112077575,
0.0741829723,
0.056669835,
-0.0491304249,
0.0386835076,
-0.0169685669,
-0.0565284453,
-0.0048384666,
-0.0254784524,
0.0897829682,
-0.0401559807,
0.0424617678,
0.0303056668,
0.0343988016,
0.0234276205,
0.0000015431,
-0.008632971,
-0.0029969357,
-0.045675762,
0.0359273702,
-0.0097117135,
0.0079352632,
-0.0505524017,
0.0219861008,
0.0218375493,
-0.0491542555,
0.0067798672,
0.0348215364,
0.076461941,
0.077498056,
0.0702490658,
-0.0119087826,
-0.0108070346,
-0.0190136675,
-0.0258645117,
-0.0199471842,
-0.0246806778,
0.0078161079,
-0.0286282431,
-0.0841538534,
0.089307867,
-0.0415090248,
-0.0159794781,
0.0152306035,
-0.023918597,
-0.05828695,
-0.0031509243,
0.0097147003,
-0.0022569939,
0.0081118681,
0.0899404064,
0.0409932211,
-0.0348076746,
0.0197504573,
-0.0309570543,
-0.0022975954,
0.0105540892,
-0.0176794548,
-0.0033972112,
-0.0111672496,
0.0538272113,
0.048670616,
-0.0070021264,
0.0136452485,
0.0267203543,
0.0057165856,
0.0254370533,
-0.0323075391,
-0.0017836328,
0.0273123272,
0.0251512751,
-0.0263301618,
-0.0348458663,
0.0192371998,
-0.0026747864,
-0.0015664053,
0.027429929,
-0.0251110829,
0.0026858165,
0.0151351523,
-0.0355602354,
-0.0210158378,
0.0117359422,
-0.0225674752,
0.0715256706,
0.0187718756,
-0.0083970632,
-0.0405113623,
-0.0292702075,
-0.0002894484,
0.0275988709,
-0.0208051614,
0.0146166719,
0.0188863426,
0.0307672992,
-0.0493059978,
-0.0279374626,
-0.013051156,
-0.0071962788,
-0.0232060757,
-0.0036325729,
-0.0190037619,
-0.0051026409,
-0.0046191989,
-0.0041250288,
0.0194785967,
0.0761581957,
-0.0410991684,
0.0325087234,
-0.0035951231,
-0.0024258031,
-0.0292456113,
0.0080482522,
-0.0161490347,
-0.0008566098,
0.0117628202,
-0.0253936127,
0.0144556677,
-0.0106524266,
-0.018809909,
0.0305569991,
-0.0299168881,
-0.0643285215,
-0.0089322235,
-0.0712818429,
0.0238472782,
-0.0083470307,
0.0087411767,
-0.0410550237,
0.0144306142,
0.0421867818,
0.014835692,
0.0797773674,
0.040009357,
-0.0698935911,
-0.0053378292,
0.0355630033,
0.0351805724,
0.1206812859,
-0.0205442626,
0.0114232851,
0.0063889422,
0.0351948217,
-0.0503838807,
-0.0239346754,
0.0396758057,
0.0143017042,
0.0132102789,
0.0473836698,
-0.0392854512,
-0.0000226354,
-0.0024496776,
0.0283669326,
0.024422694,
-0.0572025962,
0.0433041342,
0.0207682773,
-0.0151173864,
0.0105247051,
0.00983069,
0.064939037,
-0.0020582373,
-0.0127350828,
0.0153520806,
0.0424111225,
0.0016693263,
-0.0296471491,
0.0225074012,
0.0350221917,
-0.0471805669,
-0.0170125421,
-0.0081725102,
0.0069964412,
-0.0080750156,
-0.0272727143,
0.0335355327,
-0.0014577275,
-0.0491413809,
0.0120290564,
0.037789274,
-0.0470973253,
-0.0342817232,
-0.0241704937,
0.0492520481,
-0.0204362143,
0.016969597,
-0.0440331437,
-0.058334779,
-0.0445370041,
0.0302688796,
0.0821751431,
0.0394625515,
-0.0382185541,
-0.0100795496,
-0.0388248749,
-0.0054674498,
-0.0448454581,
0.0005268217,
0.036778681,
-0.0103506632,
0.0423508435,
0.011431193,
0.0237955749,
0.088620156,
0.0174748506,
0.023520086,
0.0101114521,
0.0255023893,
0.0289660003,
0.0258738194,
0.0556185469,
-0.0059853806,
-0.0553153791,
0.025811648,
-0.0332888179,
-0.0398671106,
-0.0091388924,
-0.0123135177,
-0.104151383,
0.0483883843,
-0.0469392464,
-0.0311980527,
0.0524902344,
-0.0509109125,
0.0031869686,
-0.0109104905,
-0.029986497,
-0.0310780201,
-0.0446707569,
-0.0571587943,
-0.0373907052,
0.0068314597,
-0.013383585,
0.0607027784,
-0.0384904705,
0.0059420615,
0.0125984624,
-0.022862941,
0.0417527407,
-0.0116931386,
-0.0348626561,
-0.0310758967,
0.0260236822,
-0.0032609296,
0.0416040793,
0.0020061133,
-0.0218858849,
-0.0002420451,
-0.0855459571,
0.0024138424,
-0.0399247669,
0.0383600444,
0.0461460911,
-0.0213690456,
0.0273447242,
0.011286974,
-0.0551929846,
-0.0375785679,
-0.0283917952,
0.0128957415,
0.0346949995,
-0.0228416715,
0.0243756492,
-0.0386811607,
0.0060034813,
-0.0313652083,
0.0070497277,
-0.0027096996,
-0.043909736,
-0.0310088582,
0.0080034947,
-0.027416734,
-0.0432852283,
-0.0132791633,
-0.0288358405,
0.0287129562,
0.0003084778,
0.0107737789,
0.0471509695,
0.0221012048,
0.0784898475,
-0.0130286887,
0.0582304783,
-0.0392264053,
-0.0086450288,
-0.0247125067,
0.0674937442,
-0.0107949199,
-0.0010244134,
0.0126091642,
0.0812687501,
0.0062343446,
-0.0206710845,
-0.0515665412,
0.0410018638,
-0.0400507376,
-0.0165010616,
0.0105516175,
0.0216428787,
-0.0063021304,
-0.0223463941,
-0.0261640046,
-0.0162606016,
0.0775539726,
0.0344868116,
0.0088879587,
-0.0605259091,
-0.0210897978,
-0.0414675847,
0.0180589948,
0.0033504209,
0.0014888362,
0.0164996386,
0.0089456066,
0.0239579398,
-0.022943439,
-0.0104306936,
-0.0237634648,
0.0099232774,
0.0211770181,
0.0334316753,
-0.0066721379,
-0.0409763381,
-0.0100860931,
-0.074925229,
-0.0127954111,
-0.0285485163,
-0.0025986659,
-0.0096795494,
0.0536932722,
0.0178723652,
0.009169247,
-0.0085719451,
-0.0101391589,
-0.0097849928,
0.0048794001,
0.0379599445,
0.0333090313,
-0.0404580235,
0.0264685377,
0.0043332335,
0.0262162164,
0.0741947517,
0.0089008603,
0.0184240453,
-0.0309381653,
-0.0184275508,
0.0035774186,
-0.0085327784,
0.018126661,
-0.0498950072,
0.0485754386,
0.0018915915,
0.0156865343,
0.0761026591,
0.0539638437,
-0.0217692908,
-0.0234446228,
0.0691356808,
-0.0355571918,
0.012670883,
-0.0248501804,
-0.0854057148,
-0.0280020777,
-0.0159082506,
-0.001277241,
-0.0049975524,
-0.0218020361,
-0.0148746818,
-0.0745351091,
-0.0224355161,
-0.03274123,
-0.0080910111,
-0.0319301821,
-0.0673166439,
0.0362634994,
-0.0381916687,
-0.006488075,
0.0074681644,
0.0064245909,
0.0167230777,
0.0130844684,
-0.0294871721,
-0.0086208908,
0.0031853411,
-0.0221864488,
0.0139783174,
-0.0193634164,
0.0445262082,
-0.0114829605,
-0.0254783537,
0.0100234905,
-0.0419869535,
-0.0420304611,
-0.0371482112,
0.0367101952,
-0.0656129718,
-0.0323999338,
-0.0189023837,
0.0586690605,
-0.0450065359,
-0.0090356683,
-0.0609058887,
0.0519168004,
0.0011143963,
0.000608845,
-0.029761266,
0.0561187677,
0.0440198369,
0.0441621207,
0.0211289376,
-0.0647372231,
-0.015544557,
-0.0465072207,
-0.0194212832,
-0.0488988832,
-0.0101449406,
-0.05844092,
-0.0071146023,
0.043422278,
-0.0316459239,
-0.0331775248,
0.0062793302,
0.0362727568,
-0.0194409695,
-0.0517911874,
-0.003983472,
0.0141747696,
-0.0509740338,
0.0295920335,
0.0092058629,
0.0247432683,
-0.0044752485,
-0.0382432155,
0.0667387396,
0.0510103181,
-0.0478836037,
-0.023878647,
-0.0557400063,
-0.0504297726,
-0.0344373509,
0.019450549,
0.0005374432,
-0.0038098621,
-0.0115039507,
0.018546965,
0.0311111752,
0.0602579042,
-0.0373753123,
0.0177368186,
0.0429821797,
0.050060723,
0.0140062245,
0.0363150463,
0.0060657477,
0.0046119043,
0.0417691395,
0.0210286994,
-0.030053271,
0.0186042618,
0.0025402738,
-0.0301265903,
0.0413297191,
0.0384950452,
-0.020762803,
-0.0695498735,
-0.0149445124,
-0.0066888314,
-0.0321592093,
-0.0273316186,
0.0091587342,
0.0229794085,
-0.0476535484,
-0.0729675367,
0.06270089,
-0.0203909334,
0.090108633,
-0.0411632955,
0.0568310879,
0.0664546415,
0.0104583604,
-0.0344625711,
-0.0278626308,
-0.046677433,
-0.0398750566,
0.0287299138,
-0.029599024,
0.025219271,
0.076335907,
0.0197641868,
-0.0027106258,
0.0151595483,
-0.0098324204,
-0.0128612081,
0.0209427439,
-0.0608425923,
0.0156424474,
0.0076864231,
-0.0246379562,
0.0066322987,
-0.0049985307,
-0.0283677261,
-0.0249302294,
0.0229740292,
-0.0498664863,
-0.0148596764,
0.0487274192,
0.0304478668,
-0.0127494773,
0.0275561158,
-0.0020246168,
-0.0397862867,
0.031004345,
0.0589674003,
-0.0253692009,
-0.0267696772,
0.006575834,
-0.0009340399,
0.0174112674,
0.0152733251,
0.0449575037,
-0.051381357,
-0.0402571075,
0.0313815325,
0.0413304307,
-0.0037891685,
0.064466916,
-0.0039774938,
0.0384172723,
0.0160019025,
0.0180174634,
-0.0590345711,
0.0301715471,
-0.0349236801,
-0.0332800001,
-0.0293818545,
-5.666615986e-33,
-0.0171140861,
-0.011142971,
-0.0443660989,
0.0195956565,
0.0135031808,
0.0053344765,
-0.0080427201,
0.0092157591,
-0.0204780065,
0.075668022,
0.019492656,
0.060986381,
-0.0127283065,
0.0309297107,
-0.0478947051,
-0.0141628534,
0.0281850435,
-0.0199103653,
-0.0389546379,
0.030874379,
0.0468811393,
-0.0209300946,
0.0504004322,
-0.0467837863,
0.0613796003,
-0.0140649844,
-0.0247131996,
0.017013777,
0.0359443389,
0.0650216267,
-0.0301971585,
0.0199234374,
0.0717668533,
-0.0423191711,
0.0217476822,
0.0908808261,
-0.063823469,
-0.0071722413,
-0.0138816787,
0.0018339922,
-0.0178467929,
0.0114627741,
-0.0214915834,
0.01455756,
-0.0092975199,
-0.0131307431,
0.0072388421,
0.0050152643,
0.0506457575,
-0.0539516211,
-0.023800062,
0.0277889743,
-0.0449087396,
-0.0230355877,
-0.0271744728,
0.0191123132,
0.0391545407,
0.0340575464,
-0.0384254605,
-0.0006547004,
-0.0654911473,
0.0094970027,
-0.0281290244,
-0.0278570857,
-0.0188591089,
0.07727696,
-0.0197396874,
-0.0069555119,
-0.0200772975,
0.0123807574,
-0.0169382412,
-0.0211036094,
0.061061807,
0.0301330481,
0.0173790995,
0.0001259361,
-0.0848445818,
0.0135343177,
0.0859742314,
0.0023826365,
0.0163594671,
0.0124527086,
-0.0088976845,
0.0204806197,
-0.0019726288,
-0.0694364905,
-0.0320396945,
-0.0177529268,
0.0017628232,
0.0067441273,
-0.0605072454,
0.0356618203,
0.0229294337,
-0.0565288104,
-0.0139558315,
0.0937801227,
-0.0235402565,
0.0087807728,
0.03443617,
0.0197139457,
-0.0642584488,
0.0194947273,
-0.0156051824,
0.0001138304,
0.0062346025,
-0.0350034572,
0.0913798809,
-0.0114330454,
-0.0972979218,
-0.0401299894,
-0.0181929264,
-0.0029489223,
-0.0448757187,
0.0842304304,
0.0218462292,
0.0018525493,
-0.0024106032,
0.0859107748,
-0.0132753272,
0.0046062847,
-0.0156102423,
0.0319055952,
-0.0450693145,
0.0334205888,
-0.0221875738,
-0.0437393561,
0.0076225735,
0.0722480193,
-0.045878578,
-0.0974306464,
-0.0082158698,
0.0430602096,
2.273e-7,
0.0210429467,
0.0231795739,
0.0296151452,
-0.0063466108,
0.0270564947,
0.0502904095,
-0.0151669309,
0.0458108224,
-0.0252331682,
-0.0511192903,
-0.0242715906,
0.0569241196,
0.0088529075,
-0.0000315402,
-0.0894146636,
0.0627200305,
-0.0069465181,
-0.0080275973,
-0.0055105602,
0.0112194587,
-0.0050011328,
0.0605199784,
0.0314948522,
0.007542178,
0.0237907507,
0.0252840184,
0.0489735082,
0.0141654648,
-0.0263257362,
-0.0045526633,
0.0150566222,
-0.0290211216,
-0.0032408335,
-0.0330293477,
-0.006737452,
0.0350842476,
0.0096852481,
0.0847307295,
0.0328464098,
-0.0386743285,
-0.0114329373,
0.003210478,
0.0157021564,
0.0141881332,
0.0699078664,
-0.0507314838,
-0.0173834693,
-0.0792129859,
-0.0450982302,
-0.0046456433,
0.0517667457,
-0.0057988185,
-0.0205356739,
0.0154823065,
0.0059770844,
-0.0129615618,
0.01642913,
-0.0794904232,
-0.0017487484,
0.0083406884,
-0.0412542298,
-0.0311909281,
0.0543275587,
-0.0104573565,
0.0310430489,
-0.0483307205,
-0.0162063465,
1.664022915e-34,
0.0331348591,
-0.0591736734,
0.0035294737,
0.0089912778,
0.0104022538,
0.0038575674,
-0.0501593202,
-0.0318248793,
0.0536684878,
-0.0403279103,
0.0009594835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14435v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Chain-of-Thought in Semi-structured Domains | 2023-10-22T22:45:14 | 2023-10-22T22:45:14 | Vaibhav Mavi, Abulhair Saparov, Chen Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Applying existing question answering (QA) systems to specialized domains like
law and finance presents challenges that necessitate domain expertise. Although
large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive language comprehension and
in-context learning capabilities, their inability to handle very long
inputs/contexts is well known. Tasks specific to these domains need significant
background knowledge, leading to contexts that can often exceed the maximum
length that existing LLMs can process. This study explores leveraging the
semi-structured nature of legal and financial data to efficiently retrieve
relevant context, enabling the use of LLMs for domain-specialized QA. The
resulting system outperforms contemporary models and also provides useful
explanations for the answers, encouraging the integration of LLMs into legal
and financial NLP systems for future research. | [
0.0572447702,
0.0316895358,
-0.0111124916,
0.0464398861,
-0.0351697095,
0.0094877481,
0.023237288,
0.0302734617,
0.0177036785,
-0.0841937661,
-0.0460991338,
-0.03018477,
-0.0597323626,
0.0284709577,
0.015297276,
-0.0334655829,
0.0278810412,
-0.0143960426,
0.0415988341,
-0.0135649862,
0.0250757728,
0.024553379,
0.0089045521,
-0.0019653316,
-0.0093127582,
-0.0247688573,
-0.0088028368,
-0.0108448332,
-0.0162661467,
0.0020249425,
0.0102955159,
0.0282813255,
0.0555892736,
0.016562786,
0.0000018035,
-0.0762206241,
-0.0469645858,
0.0119694043,
-0.0461571813,
-0.0083596613,
-0.0050619608,
-0.021603493,
0.0305419639,
-0.0026376159,
-0.0572317541,
0.0300287139,
0.0019312556,
0.0299262833,
0.0647160113,
0.0545401275,
0.0005093822,
-0.0668215528,
0.0100390473,
-0.0418154188,
-0.0044265003,
-0.0958552659,
0.0417933017,
0.0311701521,
0.0449432656,
0.019673001,
-0.0059286566,
0.0221218206,
0.021266073,
-0.0119776865,
0.0009148404,
-0.0122477552,
-0.0210762173,
0.0474832393,
-0.0200860947,
0.0609324053,
0.0766025856,
0.0139395613,
0.002950524,
0.0017798032,
0.019433029,
0.0361793563,
-0.0477789193,
0.0653919801,
-0.0101769892,
-0.0283302143,
0.0062291236,
0.0216113795,
0.0088659786,
0.0266487896,
-0.0596898645,
0.0555212013,
-0.0184376165,
-0.0668057725,
-0.0143725267,
0.0032793924,
0.0029922177,
-0.0538636595,
0.0380391292,
0.0848781019,
0.006686205,
0.0373989791,
0.0022031509,
-0.0278959107,
0.0428212583,
-0.0376467071,
-0.0016528127,
0.0107237194,
-0.0193113424,
0.091279313,
-0.037065547,
0.0074225017,
-0.026040012,
-0.0299818106,
-0.0491927639,
-0.0717176795,
-0.0784806162,
-0.048428379,
-0.0465977862,
0.0966023058,
-0.0930503532,
-0.0102060875,
-0.0076512559,
0.0101622315,
-0.0135363154,
-0.0262350291,
-0.0096928254,
0.001022862,
0.01097719,
-0.0445377082,
-0.0650718957,
-0.0186695289,
-0.0708728582,
0.0220231321,
0.0130772796,
0.0168388952,
0.0027557546,
-0.0035588839,
-0.014006706,
-0.0472148582,
0.0111490898,
0.1029048339,
0.0209983252,
-0.0277230013,
-0.0573255531,
-0.0611636154,
-0.0368359946,
-0.0419071205,
-0.0284508634,
-0.0474279076,
0.0004128115,
0.0159327965,
-0.0445371829,
-0.0196831804,
0.0065080705,
0.0427472256,
-0.0231945235,
0.0596760251,
-0.0096300263,
-0.0225345958,
0.0005680876,
0.0160050634,
0.0211846828,
0.0308234151,
-0.0129207354,
-0.0123529918,
0.0286329314,
0.0219564252,
0.0050572576,
0.010763688,
0.0227996446,
-0.0154339904,
-0.0032145171,
0.0755819231,
-0.0099314423,
-0.008306318,
0.0387098193,
0.0339807831,
-0.0118948305,
-0.0139239188,
0.0054008272,
0.0726417005,
0.0600878149,
0.0465862714,
0.0177505575,
0.0099814627,
0.0258616358,
0.0035681936,
-0.0265789255,
0.0147417933,
-0.0540997349,
0.0315067582,
-0.0436012149,
-0.00327441,
-0.0362511203,
-0.0467509553,
-0.0021271531,
0.0164680853,
-0.0227585286,
0.0350060053,
0.0409678183,
0.0200822577,
-0.0180755891,
0.0527442209,
0.0052269688,
-0.0052172639,
-0.0266546085,
-0.0382030457,
0.0425904468,
0.046649646,
0.0418219343,
-0.0512425341,
0.013476206,
-0.0147172846,
0.0296391677,
0.0595114268,
-0.0031691669,
-0.0071917791,
-0.023542501,
-0.0122195557,
-0.0158597156,
-0.0098691238,
0.0092355832,
0.0098017929,
0.0142451497,
-0.0033931702,
0.0314727016,
-0.0616422072,
0.056548465,
0.0055457144,
-0.0123135252,
-0.0470134094,
0.009370151,
0.0140015734,
0.0068480172,
0.0409880131,
0.0076838927,
0.0296888165,
0.0167953074,
-0.024909161,
-0.033200901,
-0.0252865963,
-0.0312487483,
-0.0039597112,
0.0306130517,
-0.0003622572,
-0.0307554025,
-0.0267585292,
-0.0247349534,
-0.0211665183,
-0.0318283252,
-0.0136551792,
0.0114109041,
-0.0738685429,
-0.0485938154,
0.0308939181,
-0.0060250657,
-0.0659524947,
0.1025029123,
0.0109309321,
-0.0025304635,
-0.0027775187,
0.0060322843,
0.0377188437,
-0.0174430665,
0.034162648,
-0.0323351584,
-0.0388177633,
0.0176693499,
0.0258606412,
-0.0011397758,
-0.0504824854,
-0.0002819318,
-0.048801437,
-0.000629952,
-0.0114451824,
0.033400733,
-0.0133448429,
0.0118118161,
-0.0022847629,
-0.0266951285,
-0.0537770838,
-0.0059301155,
0.0092129521,
0.0102683334,
0.0423091836,
0.0074722599,
-0.0298841372,
-0.04161961,
-0.0241022501,
-0.0193313211,
0.0472545549,
0.0095465407,
-0.0317489244,
-0.0049650087,
0.0253440887,
-0.019910017,
0.0113506075,
-0.0048807492,
0.0443190373,
-0.0073310658,
0.000994576,
0.0190619882,
0.0296813548,
0.0061810995,
0.0186499394,
-0.0193814412,
-0.0177605934,
-0.0517185293,
0.0243578441,
0.0013306038,
-0.0175426062,
-0.0278084315,
0.0399573594,
0.0206672754,
0.0447744243,
-0.0271447729,
-0.0216980651,
-0.0365479402,
0.014543185,
0.0157324653,
0.005451459,
-0.0621185787,
-0.0023687768,
-0.0074196532,
0.0748472661,
0.0134558072,
-0.0222177599,
0.0656140223,
0.0202875268,
0.0196187962,
-0.0306984559,
-0.0236473568,
-0.0865308419,
0.0965702087,
-0.0468297899,
0.0158363264,
-0.0172524694,
-0.0489698313,
-0.0024496771,
-0.0379194655,
0.0368295386,
-0.0261127576,
0.0834482163,
-0.0234666318,
0.0581583902,
-0.0130144013,
-0.0510376245,
-0.0366851836,
-0.0347205326,
-0.0305547938,
0.0418960638,
-0.002596233,
0.0255645979,
-0.0193497594,
-0.0018165091,
0.0002768498,
-0.0381264985,
0.0164566766,
-0.0347436555,
-0.0131893549,
0.075907968,
0.0466696769,
0.0129787978,
0.0148761738,
-0.0080319,
0.0344636142,
0.0329167694,
0.0181383863,
-0.0083969347,
0.027487915,
-0.0118576,
-0.002716467,
-0.0713536888,
-0.0013250078,
0.0268019997,
-0.016296098,
-0.0669506341,
-0.0135597028,
0.0904554054,
0.0466678292,
-0.0033628198,
-0.0195844211,
-0.0470537506,
-0.0007883325,
0.0292425193,
0.0597542375,
-0.1187209636,
-0.0224599186,
-0.0191402901,
-0.0090558687,
0.0027858901,
-0.0349494815,
-0.0036442545,
-0.1204735264,
0.0681548193,
-0.0248814467,
-0.0293162949,
-0.03484153,
-0.0065396605,
-0.0050449963,
0.025239598,
0.0033470364,
0.0277538951,
-0.0378851816,
-0.004688296,
0.0131076183,
-0.0013374521,
0.0428689942,
0.0665176138,
-0.0296577122,
-0.0007613143,
0.0426845029,
0.0079023056,
0.0049851248,
0.000025306,
-0.0164971128,
-0.0383098796,
0.0155163603,
0.0177364908,
0.016501626,
-0.0138898501,
0.0044353446,
-0.0418953486,
0.0482050329,
-0.0436286628,
0.000602534,
0.0396587327,
0.0521394126,
-0.0257253814,
0.0211942326,
-0.0445699543,
0.0007907237,
-0.0364604071,
0.0808666125,
0.0219798088,
-0.0115322666,
-0.0340160728,
-0.031450931,
-0.0557741113,
-0.0232966505,
-0.0099069756,
0.0021944458,
0.0144660454,
0.0696256161,
-0.0587544627,
-0.0459507331,
0.0243113395,
0.059263017,
-0.0253282748,
0.0522301458,
0.0262632892,
-0.0135580702,
-0.0499402024,
0.0094978157,
-0.0925971568,
0.0283175875,
-0.003571833,
0.0365374722,
0.0201352444,
-0.0334427208,
-0.0410824195,
0.008208707,
-0.0273911376,
0.0080924593,
-0.017792251,
0.0025702734,
0.0199633408,
0.0049381233,
-0.0307709631,
0.0024419392,
0.0322410576,
0.0337607227,
-0.0455797687,
-0.0051142797,
0.0366427824,
0.0208661761,
-0.0132954689,
0.0272549558,
-0.0821969882,
0.0153510049,
0.0137772365,
0.0476517193,
-0.0120712603,
-0.014124698,
0.0490000695,
0.0093440758,
-0.0064502158,
0.0477368496,
-0.0236534923,
0.012965817,
-0.0046612718,
-0.0309692081,
-0.01560771,
-0.0200174134,
-0.0040765302,
0.03522202,
-0.0570035838,
-0.0108025661,
0.020811813,
-0.0268882643,
0.0398844741,
-0.0370874554,
0.0268084295,
0.0216140375,
-0.0063628275,
0.0021981094,
-0.0457458422,
0.0084084701,
0.0017657803,
0.02011461,
0.0540786833,
0.0079017524,
0.0572208092,
0.0239809826,
-0.0157986116,
-0.0386748761,
0.0000909081,
-0.0820945278,
-0.0397866219,
0.0138862226,
0.0224104337,
0.0259984583,
-0.0209783576,
-0.0305301305,
-0.0194550473,
-0.0133344093,
0.0237273946,
0.0078929933,
0.0269396529,
-0.0429035388,
0.0555406734,
0.0314002559,
-0.0202956684,
0.0144189997,
0.0759405568,
0.0262588691,
0.013658761,
-0.0093211103,
-0.0079355966,
-0.0290269461,
-0.045324862,
-0.0123718707,
0.0459374338,
-0.0137108546,
0.0146281505,
-0.1029507965,
-0.0626289845,
-0.0209991094,
-0.0180054195,
-0.0251659788,
0.0023254692,
0.0504032373,
0.0751081184,
0.0552211478,
-0.030091567,
-0.020154627,
0.0527262054,
-0.0180410463,
-0.0273760129,
-0.0327514596,
-5.633789571e-33,
-0.0233390853,
-0.0623837188,
0.0518280976,
-0.0032815174,
0.0063312869,
0.0132133253,
-0.0135796238,
-0.0064230501,
-0.0375510864,
0.0145988222,
-0.0273162853,
0.0386260748,
0.0018237757,
0.0341513753,
-0.0128056398,
-0.0370830894,
-0.0226140115,
-0.0111378357,
0.0423113443,
-0.0244169235,
0.0120745786,
0.0529332906,
0.0180912223,
-0.0783944055,
0.0249774549,
0.0251408499,
-0.0099773835,
0.0297619868,
-0.0231810752,
0.0687242523,
-0.0095319143,
0.0420250483,
0.0351274349,
-0.0765130669,
0.0073231715,
0.0332486033,
-0.1008256748,
0.0016762629,
0.0311888866,
-0.0373840332,
-0.0140340673,
-0.0238140598,
0.0236121863,
-0.0010092499,
0.0333526172,
-0.0321766995,
0.0221196413,
-0.0394732393,
-0.009767984,
-0.0663803145,
-0.0868926346,
0.0259168297,
-0.0129819755,
0.0041166474,
0.0219562799,
0.0256919675,
0.0083363969,
0.0542144813,
-0.0094764056,
-0.0219719466,
-0.028114412,
-0.0138104036,
0.0292309131,
-0.0381481238,
-0.0261292066,
0.0295395516,
-0.0189358201,
-0.005907963,
-0.0513365828,
-0.0246057007,
-0.0144433808,
0.0608012304,
0.0272047576,
0.0576897785,
0.0157235041,
0.0207484923,
-0.0790951699,
-0.0026697302,
-0.000035737,
0.032037992,
0.0001215091,
0.0203518737,
-0.0315869749,
-0.0011990238,
-0.0368225351,
0.0178369526,
-0.0307382923,
0.0009391108,
0.0459530801,
-0.0089968992,
0.0167610403,
-0.0066728853,
0.0099120559,
-0.0637260377,
-0.0289171785,
0.0325962417,
0.0081557175,
0.0000960979,
0.0125734415,
0.0547218658,
-0.0421634801,
0.0191201773,
-0.0012520612,
-0.0008835698,
-0.0261382069,
-0.0072952402,
0.0390263051,
-0.0438094847,
-0.0376541764,
-0.0144275548,
-0.019270774,
0.0251077302,
-0.0323034935,
0.0334235914,
0.0057161665,
0.0711104125,
0.0145737799,
0.0524291769,
0.0027653847,
-0.0255229194,
-0.0095424838,
0.0002972305,
-0.0160651915,
0.0155286426,
0.007006513,
0.0133640133,
0.013390217,
0.0410581604,
0.0405013524,
-0.0153592164,
0.0117724724,
0.0753973946,
2.451e-7,
0.0860994384,
0.0369678326,
0.0185245052,
0.0326837786,
0.0096905269,
0.0333564505,
0.0346721672,
0.021351587,
0.0165327135,
-0.0342300087,
-0.0091875475,
0.0415990353,
0.0454908945,
0.0004461958,
-0.065827176,
-0.0400766544,
-0.0227831826,
-0.0435575694,
-0.0524551384,
0.0279963613,
0.0595654882,
0.0718279853,
-0.0163881611,
-0.0287860483,
-0.0087922458,
-0.0725170672,
0.0665610507,
-0.0119877318,
-0.0045701414,
-0.0188779589,
0.0108112907,
-0.0169132147,
0.038578447,
0.0296697076,
0.0062185647,
0.0650332347,
0.0088232728,
0.0507373139,
0.0163821299,
-0.004210724,
-0.0224687718,
-0.0451281741,
0.0378872007,
-0.0269137099,
0.0689189434,
-0.0474625155,
-0.0181708913,
-0.0147313401,
-0.0369291306,
-0.0153837623,
-0.0131962746,
0.0219078008,
-0.0083106374,
-0.006369072,
0.0308052134,
-0.0214331206,
0.0351103842,
-0.0844348669,
0.0204563122,
0.0521793589,
-0.0397459976,
0.0577182099,
-0.0325940736,
0.0089781955,
0.0623991042,
-0.0796786845,
-0.0037341916,
2.179689558e-34,
0.0491026677,
-0.0247121044,
0.0029464047,
0.0823010057,
0.065297842,
0.0229881015,
-0.0334366858,
0.0242401864,
0.017700674,
-0.1182657033,
0.0220362339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14429v1 | Text generation for dataset augmentation in security classification tasks | 2023-10-22T22:25:14 | 2023-10-22T22:25:14 | Alexander P. Welsh, Matthew Edwards | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Security classifiers, designed to detect malicious content in computer
systems and communications, can underperform when provided with insufficient
training data. In the security domain, it is often easy to find samples of the
negative (benign) class, and challenging to find enough samples of the positive
(malicious) class to train an effective classifier. This study evaluates the
application of natural language text generators to fill this data gap in
multiple security-related text classification tasks. We describe a variety of
previously-unexamined language-model fine-tuning approaches for this purpose
and consider in particular the impact of disproportionate class-imbalances in
the training set. Across our evaluation using three state-of-the-art
classifiers designed for offensive language detection, review fraud detection,
and SMS spam detection, we find that models trained with GPT-3 data
augmentation strategies outperform both models trained without augmentation and
models trained using basic data augmentation strategies already in common
usage. In particular, we find substantial benefits for GPT-3 data augmentation
strategies in situations with severe limitations on known positive-class
samples. | [
0.0681517422,
0.0464331955,
-0.015838502,
0.0129266605,
-0.043661803,
0.0001363332,
0.0191370696,
-0.0047947508,
0.0090161609,
-0.0841908008,
-0.0072261337,
-0.0309455134,
-0.000837221,
0.0472258814,
0.0307290107,
-0.0112744719,
0.0444501676,
0.0119214673,
0.0195890777,
0.0184009355,
0.0257468838,
0.0258166064,
0.013488017,
0.0178555883,
-0.0184802208,
0.0414318144,
0.0015153942,
0.0075105052,
0.058090277,
-0.0441272669,
0.0060112588,
0.029262064,
0.012155165,
0.0377670601,
0.0000018116,
-0.0533148497,
-0.0141184255,
0.0034894708,
-0.0087082675,
0.0239747129,
0.0783623159,
-0.0645904914,
0.0110506956,
0.0512257218,
-0.0410563797,
0.0311570857,
0.0307611451,
0.0785869658,
0.0452670529,
0.097301729,
-0.0245734137,
-0.0295320582,
0.0288020801,
-0.0254092179,
0.0298646633,
-0.002131437,
0.03432706,
-0.022391947,
0.009730136,
0.0486338995,
0.0128650591,
-0.0236409828,
0.0107901804,
-0.0022304431,
0.0250135511,
0.0310608968,
-0.0529526472,
0.0112147313,
-0.0198793616,
0.0128939562,
-0.0302498192,
-0.0315604433,
-0.0132023348,
-0.035626933,
0.0312875696,
-0.0205192752,
0.0235345475,
0.0428296179,
-0.0193550047,
0.0299484115,
0.0195351262,
-0.0024810913,
0.0340907052,
0.035354536,
0.0109495027,
0.0259949248,
-0.0009173691,
-0.0597173162,
-0.004313068,
-0.0184779875,
-0.0086359354,
-0.0277912002,
0.0184170976,
0.0037824567,
0.046232,
0.01609057,
-0.0681229159,
-0.0469939597,
0.0500405729,
-0.0515608005,
-0.0138747701,
0.0277246218,
0.0013628956,
-0.0121098869,
-0.0248488113,
-0.0003872977,
0.045141425,
0.0368601233,
0.0050605116,
0.003662186,
-0.0320517905,
-0.0290543605,
-0.0393010825,
0.0498552211,
0.0199591834,
0.0243409444,
-0.1104898378,
0.0303036999,
-0.0124534713,
0.0126756569,
0.0107520288,
-0.0033006107,
-0.0254084934,
0.0114971558,
-0.0174175687,
-0.0386595502,
-0.0066156066,
0.0354461521,
-0.018110102,
-0.0636894703,
-0.0187299009,
0.0319331251,
-0.0148301227,
-0.0306056924,
-0.0030636683,
0.0708217323,
0.0166294854,
-0.0635247454,
-0.0717673153,
-0.0420051552,
-0.0539343245,
0.0008678696,
-0.0180598404,
-0.0313177668,
-0.0425536446,
-0.0085557923,
-0.011464458,
-0.0242963079,
0.013172023,
0.0181704219,
-0.0329425298,
0.0464604385,
-0.0376772434,
-0.0341155604,
0.0218357556,
0.0025726305,
0.0326921605,
0.0306611732,
0.0206909422,
0.062085636,
0.0344696082,
-0.036718335,
0.0530281439,
0.0189707465,
0.0397814438,
0.0129285417,
-0.0195481889,
-0.0005411468,
-0.0168854631,
-0.060038913,
-0.012278039,
-0.000889793,
-0.003204002,
-0.016520815,
0.0618730299,
-0.0065057846,
-0.0246608797,
0.0246800054,
0.0261669997,
0.0265712608,
-0.030738961,
-0.0350673459,
-0.0237330981,
-0.0153654749,
-0.0785406828,
-0.0051852786,
-0.0189164169,
0.0387869254,
-0.0083464896,
-0.0442103595,
-0.0295447111,
-0.021603277,
0.0403410271,
-0.017676739,
0.0443276316,
0.0463461541,
-0.0534088425,
-0.0495801792,
0.0130393468,
-0.0242160931,
0.0197216496,
-0.0531341061,
-0.0031523323,
0.1014357358,
0.0197165404,
-0.0121926609,
-0.0238814838,
-0.064358823,
-0.0074661914,
0.0385734327,
0.0207225028,
0.020951394,
0.0089131435,
-0.0560085848,
-0.0187231023,
-0.0292564724,
0.0244703963,
0.0201615524,
0.021643158,
0.0368015505,
0.0974763483,
-0.0003504644,
-0.0738527179,
0.0399367474,
0.0325862318,
-0.0414004363,
0.0571316183,
-0.0006329252,
0.0495006591,
0.0107530635,
-0.0153693482,
-0.0032784159,
0.0284604505,
-0.0037257357,
-0.0333709829,
-0.0297794826,
0.0155000146,
0.0157859847,
0.0207853261,
-0.0100065814,
0.0373454355,
0.0458708927,
-0.0518074892,
0.0021241661,
0.0462671518,
-0.0490581281,
-0.0155149223,
-0.0719116554,
0.0006179943,
-0.0045564077,
0.0234574769,
-0.013427875,
0.0460322388,
0.0313877724,
-0.0080004148,
-0.0277736187,
-0.0110268062,
0.0443352535,
-0.0057065981,
0.0008971707,
-0.042196963,
-0.0396581627,
0.0249819327,
0.0602459051,
0.035452608,
-0.0049080583,
-0.0164595302,
-0.0362694822,
0.0038208463,
-0.0238422677,
0.0259721093,
0.0466914512,
0.0027923156,
-0.0264819376,
-0.0085001858,
-0.0404676311,
-0.0370239094,
0.0275371131,
0.0039207335,
0.0332265571,
-0.0140720783,
-0.0248469822,
-0.0025209892,
0.0116707673,
-0.0051973234,
0.0019955582,
0.0441649519,
-0.0263704844,
-0.0040745819,
0.0184041616,
-0.027570894,
0.0010687993,
-0.0226040389,
-0.0755916387,
-0.0070523778,
0.0150888432,
-0.0375324488,
-0.0186690353,
0.0646581203,
0.0240205955,
0.0476414338,
0.0428879373,
-0.0059837652,
0.0037268836,
-0.0265842732,
-0.0123662865,
-0.012912754,
-0.0478004627,
0.0363326967,
0.0550428294,
0.0255638491,
-0.0156448092,
-0.0558656827,
-0.0043199877,
0.0060185306,
-0.0134202056,
-0.0089362469,
-0.0594660006,
0.0091192117,
0.0055280169,
-0.0122607956,
-0.0926189795,
0.0754273906,
-0.0220212638,
0.0150141465,
-0.0810471177,
-0.0550663322,
-0.0018509661,
0.0191391353,
0.0119481385,
0.0259198546,
0.0201782063,
0.0022083609,
-0.0138056576,
-0.0335256048,
0.0438209362,
-0.0063124211,
-0.0130816102,
-0.0210714657,
0.0098938383,
-0.0133356107,
-0.0380551629,
-0.075319387,
-0.0689765215,
0.0009075115,
-0.0200621672,
0.0112543218,
-0.0297068395,
-0.042159237,
0.0006739566,
0.0082800006,
0.0368240848,
-0.0223825593,
-0.0465706512,
-0.0059812549,
-0.0119402399,
0.0337331891,
-0.0665170327,
-0.0347478166,
-0.0115704359,
-0.0218201876,
0.0216029361,
-0.0057966295,
-0.0011643532,
-0.0175936148,
-0.0057369494,
0.0021571212,
-0.0382124409,
-0.0183199905,
0.0296874717,
-0.0038666481,
-0.0427359156,
-0.005390944,
0.1020160392,
0.0373355635,
0.0107489843,
0.0138667589,
0.0207679439,
0.0288236048,
0.018071102,
0.0054616858,
-0.0566802584,
-0.0006037091,
0.0003082251,
0.0631782115,
-0.0731683373,
-0.0080804611,
-0.0410341434,
-0.113368541,
0.0333895385,
0.0259167366,
-0.0548031367,
-0.0552739836,
-0.0353869162,
-0.0358716026,
-0.0009109024,
-0.0064095194,
-0.0153690651,
-0.0081275022,
0.0137932906,
0.0188451558,
-0.0421381071,
-0.0820606127,
-0.0134687833,
-0.00169761,
0.0086541278,
0.0573015176,
0.0147377923,
-0.0391248241,
-0.0088333115,
0.0456492044,
-0.0336373001,
0.0098022623,
0.0044524199,
0.087473467,
-0.0148244202,
-0.005055856,
-0.0001641607,
0.05074431,
-0.0272638742,
-0.0160955749,
0.0505899638,
0.0328857563,
-0.0255736373,
0.0046977769,
-0.0277298428,
0.0245633535,
0.0355700813,
0.0618905425,
-0.0171158742,
-0.0434080102,
0.0101251323,
-0.0239074547,
0.0183343813,
-0.0451357774,
0.0358005501,
0.0426520631,
-0.0241305735,
-0.0597645789,
-0.0438549668,
-0.0504624508,
-0.0047150296,
0.0078181494,
0.0387416631,
0.0007600285,
-0.0335217305,
-0.0044709803,
-0.0477410555,
-0.0243957583,
-0.0164689887,
0.0315948389,
-0.0098369503,
-0.0176421329,
-0.0146045703,
-0.0662195534,
-0.0261374135,
0.0326160081,
-0.0531684905,
-0.0569973104,
-0.0226425789,
0.0347324386,
0.0202574339,
0.0158366431,
-0.024368111,
-0.0308990907,
0.0725473389,
0.0979427844,
-0.0450078957,
-0.0270257015,
0.043845471,
-0.0505409166,
0.0042376956,
-0.0147749949,
-0.0236909557,
0.0212688185,
0.0369919166,
-0.0543421507,
-0.0227728803,
-0.0136421081,
0.0290235113,
0.0403922498,
0.0166187622,
-0.0355030149,
0.015642425,
-0.0120559474,
0.0347260535,
-0.0303187538,
-0.0162790064,
0.0097126067,
0.0086230552,
0.0532026775,
-0.0174375754,
-0.0171259977,
0.0222597197,
-0.0554461442,
0.0344101526,
-0.0395654589,
-0.0062816702,
0.0119719822,
0.050539989,
0.0328995064,
-0.0194156449,
-0.003301566,
0.0122763393,
0.0143275047,
-0.0008062475,
-0.0176057089,
0.0283670239,
0.0089423647,
0.0309708863,
-0.0163842347,
0.0183119755,
-0.0577577278,
0.0432703979,
-0.0598496422,
0.0422347933,
0.0022567203,
-0.0032107227,
0.0412561633,
-0.0640751496,
0.0126077645,
-0.0049327612,
0.0535268262,
-0.0006671811,
-0.0435712151,
-0.014815134,
-0.0199658778,
-0.0581530817,
0.0074931998,
0.0751857236,
0.0002059432,
0.0538816191,
0.0047756908,
-0.0700526759,
-0.0364904478,
-0.0037226204,
0.0325474478,
0.0499621443,
-0.0117922444,
0.0047051776,
-0.0532432348,
-0.0493836142,
0.0005881246,
-0.034957312,
0.0654788017,
0.0118696094,
0.0339604095,
0.0619926788,
-0.0537703782,
0.0236209873,
-0.0463927947,
-0.0173083264,
-0.002750797,
-0.0086474903,
-0.0189940613,
-5.483297642e-33,
0.0176528785,
-0.0318614691,
-0.0100024519,
0.020424936,
0.0025840178,
-0.0100314235,
0.02353861,
-0.0372755937,
0.0001648234,
-0.0050917501,
0.003872154,
-0.0002342378,
-0.0102239829,
0.0655671507,
-0.0336263031,
0.0038110681,
0.0349793024,
0.0056922487,
-0.0443312302,
0.0603465624,
0.0672309101,
0.0240792576,
0.0541863628,
-0.1026787981,
0.0307326205,
0.0022059449,
-0.0462947376,
-0.0307147019,
-0.0111637637,
0.0428555422,
-0.0147826299,
0.0811946467,
0.0425294526,
-0.030570114,
0.0177105274,
-0.0116149681,
0.0135961892,
-0.0328203179,
-0.0111013297,
0.001323038,
0.0395446606,
-0.0445731282,
0.0361293666,
-0.0138994241,
-0.0161868893,
0.0349920765,
0.0294634085,
-0.0367660411,
-0.007636379,
-0.0706992745,
-0.0621541589,
0.0352563374,
-0.0253736749,
0.0008761896,
-0.0167245697,
0.0378299989,
0.0287921913,
0.0177082997,
-0.0161371958,
0.0316651911,
0.0894877166,
-0.0119410679,
0.0154944798,
0.0173453894,
-0.0394731238,
0.0460686646,
-0.0168901887,
0.0154214911,
0.0036043525,
0.0270261262,
-0.0090965293,
0.0037171433,
0.044337023,
0.1009615734,
0.0592339188,
-0.065289095,
-0.0817120671,
0.0377135687,
-0.0036934006,
-0.0319643132,
0.0542184263,
-0.0379206352,
-0.0354426876,
-0.0026952643,
-0.0063833245,
-0.0118900063,
-0.0027230806,
-0.0290580634,
0.0223813262,
0.0254981387,
-0.0488043725,
0.013902396,
-0.0207110923,
-0.0333646052,
-0.0141841853,
0.0568125173,
-0.05712419,
-0.0350455455,
-0.0058790157,
-0.0315802209,
-0.0208735801,
-0.0339801423,
0.0729347691,
0.0129912002,
-0.006417464,
-0.0324917175,
0.0864047557,
0.042047061,
-0.0925683677,
0.0229123626,
0.0140977427,
0.1084132567,
0.0210799426,
0.063294895,
-0.0060122064,
0.0062817801,
0.0050413935,
0.0100254565,
0.0129769789,
-0.0219483618,
-0.0080779763,
0.0122350166,
-0.0254378784,
0.0212496333,
-0.0046657333,
0.0103708459,
0.0158794783,
-0.0080938907,
0.0429309793,
-0.0627198964,
0.0017360679,
-0.0234344695,
2.665e-7,
0.0277093034,
0.0153608816,
0.0127816694,
-0.0205477551,
-0.0013745693,
0.0505136214,
0.0324066617,
0.0661307871,
-0.0171703324,
-0.0158894882,
0.0111758178,
-0.0153778987,
0.0283995867,
0.0267779753,
-0.0354124792,
0.0294745807,
-0.072078824,
0.0124487113,
-0.058622472,
0.0449876897,
0.0875924453,
0.1104219481,
0.038587328,
-0.0505142063,
0.0098830499,
-0.0707594305,
0.025814075,
-0.021443082,
-0.0137982564,
0.0044852523,
0.0782536343,
0.058122091,
0.001408305,
0.0708273053,
-0.0556271635,
0.0159844365,
-0.0590553768,
0.0238162559,
0.0116495071,
0.053480763,
-0.0099922437,
-0.0016884808,
0.0027517136,
-0.064141877,
0.0759358853,
-0.0187621173,
-0.005628699,
-0.0200127494,
-0.0265780147,
-0.0143767959,
0.0268758461,
-0.063626729,
-0.0124810003,
0.0169567391,
0.0008639474,
-0.0000242379,
-0.0059455275,
-0.0393786617,
0.0264006648,
-0.0101894718,
-0.003023776,
-0.0255733412,
-0.0195670202,
0.0414856263,
0.0638939217,
-0.0174951013,
0.0314959325,
2.595225204e-34,
0.0366430953,
-0.0546860769,
-0.0122002652,
-0.0590077713,
0.0251919534,
0.0292768069,
0.0385466479,
0.0379775353,
-0.0176864993,
-0.0088794911,
0.0008908157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14424v1 | Which Prompts Make The Difference? Data Prioritization For Efficient Human LLM Evaluation | 2023-10-22T21:48:51 | 2023-10-22T21:48:51 | Meriem Boubdir, Edward Kim, Beyza Ermis, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Human evaluation is increasingly critical for assessing large language
models, capturing linguistic nuances, and reflecting user preferences more
accurately than traditional automated metrics. However, the resource-intensive
nature of this type of annotation process poses significant challenges. The key
question driving our work: "is it feasible to minimize human-in-the-loop
feedback by prioritizing data instances which most effectively distinguish
between models?" We evaluate several metric-based methods and find that these
metrics enhance the efficiency of human evaluations by minimizing the number of
required annotations, thus saving time and cost, while ensuring a robust
performance evaluation. We show that our method is effective across widely used
model families, reducing instances of indecisive (or "tie") outcomes by up to
54% compared to a random sample when focusing on the top-20 percentile of
prioritized instances. This potential reduction in required human effort
positions our approach as a valuable strategy in future large language model
evaluations. | [
0.023186015,
0.0424567983,
-0.0055663185,
0.0575605407,
-0.0322620422,
0.0372359864,
-0.0116703855,
0.0034342192,
0.0090682153,
-0.0962062106,
-0.0618911572,
-0.0333180167,
0.0073203682,
-0.0392222553,
0.0266461559,
-0.0446525514,
0.0386778675,
-0.0482795984,
0.0185244903,
0.0025788995,
0.0042166514,
-0.0019126021,
-0.0262332503,
0.0545921922,
0.0166412611,
-0.01830988,
0.0280066784,
0.0084305201,
0.0119151017,
-0.0393607877,
0.0078930268,
0.085977003,
-0.0463864505,
0.0298002698,
0.000002091,
-0.0807164907,
-0.0000703579,
0.0103900321,
-0.0467314981,
0.0400832519,
0.0627713725,
0.0577392951,
-0.0092854025,
0.0108890068,
-0.0231260285,
0.0335107855,
0.0447201692,
-0.0131486319,
0.0484858193,
0.0137625225,
0.0081906561,
0.0201182775,
-0.0214583445,
-0.0099151265,
-0.0202834271,
-0.0405898057,
-0.0096530356,
0.0112199076,
0.0156670827,
-0.0135025103,
0.0163415764,
0.0293584354,
-0.024943728,
-0.0182097219,
0.0137600433,
-0.0148084667,
-0.0280368105,
-0.0287194662,
-0.0186175089,
0.061770644,
0.0102782734,
0.0052495725,
-0.0030221939,
-0.0332130827,
0.0193364844,
0.0227161665,
-0.0241736341,
0.0070920964,
-0.0098577272,
-0.0083772847,
0.0142208543,
0.0218790621,
0.0226316694,
0.0236518066,
-0.0203191694,
0.1059324965,
0.0180544127,
-0.0001539677,
0.0367677025,
0.0264672786,
-0.0203659404,
-0.0636563301,
-0.0021866073,
0.0026082627,
-0.0537887476,
0.0096086282,
-0.0058868267,
0.0010145186,
0.0657511428,
-0.0559819788,
0.0710942,
0.0242891163,
-0.0252330061,
0.0499637239,
0.0079123313,
0.0491605438,
0.0090906853,
0.0150551042,
-0.0111430688,
0.015661208,
-0.0354820676,
0.0117917266,
0.0162872709,
0.0175393485,
0.01304881,
0.0131366048,
-0.0609095097,
0.0220300388,
-0.0315556303,
0.0214924123,
0.017764492,
-0.0396110304,
0.0054566483,
0.0085620349,
-0.0375813395,
0.0006380121,
-0.0274481196,
0.0090971263,
0.0032819831,
-0.0745427981,
0.026781518,
0.0388790332,
-0.0358971544,
-0.0061264616,
-0.0157654695,
0.0700371191,
0.0135399885,
-0.0167327076,
-0.0333910882,
-0.0233846419,
-0.0013954926,
-0.050707873,
-0.0366168246,
-0.083546944,
-0.0130437743,
0.0425765514,
0.0000112327,
-0.0506552756,
-0.0101333344,
-0.0017418192,
0.007495089,
0.0663283169,
-0.0120562939,
0.0191213172,
0.0138188386,
-0.0112870485,
-0.0476028621,
0.0845440924,
0.0390666723,
0.0319160521,
0.0680280104,
-0.0050179721,
0.0070980247,
0.0858111903,
-0.0433921441,
0.0260464214,
-0.0245413482,
0.0029052494,
-0.0115623716,
0.0105800079,
0.0400782749,
0.0456382595,
-0.0160132125,
0.023183275,
0.0370847657,
0.0765997767,
0.0246064868,
-0.0365980007,
0.0410027914,
0.0386534184,
0.0152053582,
0.0040290873,
-0.0290731899,
0.0161407031,
-0.0349403992,
0.0109806238,
0.0206489246,
0.0076663313,
0.0130004277,
-0.0666011795,
-0.0584572032,
0.0077250861,
-0.0022599848,
0.0238143839,
0.0180513039,
-0.0011976742,
0.0005002488,
0.0870644227,
0.0316139162,
-0.0458600856,
-0.0373575315,
-0.0605479665,
0.0117727825,
0.0633914992,
0.0142982146,
-0.0291364715,
-0.030917922,
0.0008364376,
0.0165715106,
0.0411959514,
0.0709672496,
-0.0412723795,
-0.0074004391,
-0.0243087951,
-0.032538984,
0.0306887664,
0.028035149,
0.0256669652,
0.0051534688,
-0.0324093215,
0.0018373491,
-0.076606065,
-0.0621539243,
0.0298984163,
-0.0132717807,
0.0001888152,
-0.0070964987,
0.0091536455,
0.0476474278,
0.0160571691,
-0.003725589,
0.0278950874,
0.0082694627,
-0.0182756614,
0.0134376884,
-0.0201769918,
-0.0021464347,
0.0175688546,
0.0347568095,
0.026230352,
-0.0385584161,
0.0092671504,
-0.0252748001,
-0.0086770337,
-0.0401428118,
-0.0404027179,
0.0264528506,
-0.0334444195,
0.038982477,
-0.0303679779,
-0.0362204015,
-0.0747608468,
0.0612125061,
-0.0349786095,
0.0312185623,
0.0346335769,
0.0040206253,
0.0274343528,
-0.0449223965,
-0.0455496944,
0.0285866242,
0.0088649988,
0.032995712,
0.028492054,
0.0441591926,
-0.0599727742,
-0.040777795,
-0.1028858274,
-0.0099875173,
-0.0258433446,
0.0441725813,
-0.0068844291,
-0.0020336313,
-0.0066043204,
-0.0055497559,
-0.0230678171,
-0.0611508377,
-0.0042048749,
0.037052691,
0.0364628844,
-0.0134884417,
-0.0353003256,
-0.0614445955,
-0.0053121848,
-0.002567014,
0.0452555306,
0.0158813652,
-0.0169484653,
-0.0598244071,
0.0244122054,
-0.0266065896,
-0.0277921557,
0.0124522531,
-0.0150340786,
0.0405481271,
0.0114590852,
-0.0083251446,
0.0423780568,
-0.013752454,
0.0192408636,
0.0638917834,
0.0109812915,
-0.0874695405,
-0.0281657707,
0.0417416804,
-0.0041034375,
-0.0188073013,
-0.0316330232,
0.0130403657,
0.051970046,
-0.0114891846,
-0.0056443447,
-0.0322783515,
0.0065119369,
-0.0689682066,
-0.0365256257,
-0.0512386374,
-0.0164197721,
-0.0472398326,
0.0847202837,
0.0059779882,
-0.052861806,
0.0466977619,
-0.0442325994,
0.0155728888,
-0.0148260053,
-0.0074454183,
-0.0532731824,
0.03659999,
-0.0288960841,
-0.0014929549,
-0.0250874348,
-0.0274876151,
-0.0415938534,
0.0010149991,
0.0536691844,
-0.0616500266,
0.079888016,
-0.0608921237,
0.0281144734,
-0.0010848365,
-0.0285358112,
-0.0278532635,
-0.0074772262,
-0.067192927,
0.0070594596,
0.0130077703,
-0.0141534824,
0.0196787491,
0.0114257,
0.0067657074,
0.014497715,
-0.0078612361,
0.0025493335,
-0.0009160792,
0.0132678589,
0.0137678524,
0.0391936377,
0.021361094,
-0.0273473542,
0.0317212418,
0.0235855728,
0.028455453,
0.01105751,
-0.0276690088,
0.0062678414,
0.0745636746,
-0.0569846369,
-0.0435972586,
0.048091609,
0.0587616824,
-0.0351751,
0.0160244722,
0.1133019105,
0.0288984515,
-0.0612588897,
0.0123403147,
-0.0368045196,
0.0642028302,
0.0343781523,
0.028802013,
-0.0628834814,
-0.0397250764,
0.0176700335,
0.0485099591,
-0.0082786856,
-0.0123214256,
0.0046430738,
-0.1027396321,
0.0380452313,
-0.0072403913,
-0.0174628701,
0.0332972184,
-0.0370429046,
0.0348364487,
-0.0496711656,
0.0152684776,
0.0052241185,
-0.0209240783,
0.0132819926,
0.0309854653,
-0.0566439405,
-0.0613167621,
0.045334924,
-0.0360947065,
0.0373133235,
0.0547534376,
0.0128556723,
-0.0022043667,
-0.0618700348,
0.0612875037,
0.0183147043,
-0.0104017854,
-0.0208727568,
0.0357836373,
0.0132116172,
0.0036259191,
-0.0192860216,
-0.0032924577,
-0.0141818328,
-0.0032305885,
0.0019170584,
0.0466049537,
-0.0217005629,
0.0501336157,
-0.0020104859,
-0.0115315355,
0.0091265766,
0.0689151436,
0.0641603991,
-0.0730130151,
-0.0117735798,
-0.0421537347,
-0.0123363119,
-0.056883838,
-0.069861196,
0.0114661865,
-0.0312701352,
-0.0191375967,
-0.0569333136,
-0.0442732833,
0.0152567457,
0.0125736855,
0.0163091756,
0.0219745953,
-0.0215275809,
0.0126990937,
-0.0059838225,
0.0393026136,
-0.0124171572,
0.0295065641,
-0.0962728336,
-0.0078781778,
0.0261886772,
0.0191365462,
-0.0293621905,
0.036176011,
-0.0846746266,
-0.0540728793,
0.0056698825,
0.0360832959,
0.0279338658,
0.0263276994,
-0.010443503,
-0.0897947177,
0.0075534773,
0.0264066402,
-0.0101734912,
0.004950319,
0.0413335301,
0.0256282613,
-0.039317742,
0.0308500864,
-0.0562087111,
0.0128223468,
0.0213798955,
0.0596563555,
-0.0370252766,
-0.0743726939,
-0.0024685652,
0.0561944433,
0.036952462,
-0.063916184,
-0.0236815121,
-0.019645242,
-0.0118525177,
0.0120994486,
-0.0364653617,
-0.0504492782,
0.0098942444,
-0.0083783297,
-0.0299426951,
-0.0245603286,
-0.0026580303,
-0.0189949106,
0.0320747048,
-0.0470777974,
0.0373544618,
0.013421352,
0.0154102594,
-0.0117622996,
0.002706127,
-0.0267467126,
0.0196252018,
0.0110068219,
0.0260845516,
0.0004190929,
0.0426794365,
-0.0035453637,
0.0274212323,
0.0202487297,
0.0636487305,
-0.0092533268,
-0.0451069511,
-0.0161973983,
0.0121682687,
0.0543999597,
-0.0049576662,
0.102396749,
0.0031325258,
-0.014150626,
-0.0225470718,
0.0382975787,
0.0040224697,
0.0050559212,
-0.0076000844,
0.0366579182,
-0.0257369485,
0.0039370633,
0.0573189817,
0.0031508165,
-0.012171519,
-0.0404064283,
-0.0323891975,
-0.0586332455,
-0.0260720104,
0.0004057436,
-0.0205609761,
-0.0237605106,
-0.0218856167,
-0.1218279377,
-0.052415356,
-0.0005571645,
0.0275065601,
-0.0057045664,
-0.0061724414,
0.037777856,
0.0542101935,
-0.0041234391,
-0.0133074988,
-0.0676432475,
-0.0492180288,
0.0081188427,
-0.0106172571,
-0.0329744853,
-6.315678416e-33,
-0.0362982936,
-0.0521717519,
-0.0110298116,
-0.0227954593,
-0.0068480731,
-0.0131176468,
0.0075841476,
0.0480410792,
-0.0017261322,
-0.0091246692,
-0.0093590617,
-0.0196870863,
0.0186431892,
-0.0238029044,
0.0531737916,
-0.0017275393,
0.0127393799,
0.011231889,
-0.0499798059,
-0.0110243764,
0.0048989025,
-0.0198381208,
0.0328468755,
-0.062710464,
0.0971883237,
0.0178427137,
-0.0129289897,
0.0096315891,
-0.0153358271,
0.077641122,
-0.0036275105,
0.0346468575,
0.0197049864,
-0.0624147281,
-0.0278520901,
-0.0196100827,
-0.0228411481,
-0.0511823781,
0.0359171741,
0.0111498451,
-0.012153632,
-0.0401822515,
0.0512867719,
0.0081522586,
-0.0700841323,
0.0108139506,
0.033447843,
-0.0239849053,
-0.0398781076,
0.0158448592,
-0.0508074872,
0.0593149923,
-0.0170776304,
-0.0022343816,
0.0352953337,
0.0403846391,
-0.0302764345,
0.0195931103,
-0.0575790405,
0.0233700983,
0.0286732446,
0.0259069819,
0.0882069245,
0.0388394892,
-0.0282359738,
0.06131332,
-0.0074789897,
0.0095983846,
0.0251480211,
-0.0300997887,
0.014652607,
0.0555217005,
0.0495546274,
0.0346973576,
-0.0068436712,
0.0208494905,
-0.0288750753,
0.0563542806,
0.0089550242,
0.0088466033,
0.0102094524,
0.0152368927,
-0.0569712929,
-0.0268857088,
-0.0464631468,
-0.0372292586,
-0.0323302001,
-0.013445898,
0.0492575467,
-0.0474018715,
-0.0379849523,
-0.0313106962,
0.0278826747,
-0.0238204654,
-0.0436373278,
-0.0218538977,
-0.0118048023,
0.0421979949,
0.0045853774,
0.018899681,
-0.0103308689,
0.0197039153,
-0.0258473419,
0.0410149656,
0.070566386,
-0.0225675162,
0.0109737338,
-0.0047912267,
-0.050936956,
0.0068322127,
-0.0171344168,
0.0004776197,
-0.0236424822,
-0.0025235417,
0.0343782417,
-0.035535749,
-0.0076222192,
0.0847751647,
0.0033710813,
-0.009493541,
-0.0230516363,
0.0033945048,
-0.0150750149,
0.0039111068,
-0.0344714671,
0.0004257936,
0.0010037418,
0.0367799066,
0.0352460444,
0.0172962155,
-0.010562717,
0.0071343658,
2.64e-7,
0.068939589,
0.0487122834,
-0.0146292606,
0.0113235228,
-0.007035343,
0.0433270149,
-0.0272138156,
-0.0203700159,
0.033082962,
-0.0100479126,
-0.0002611197,
-0.0105830627,
0.084737286,
0.020888377,
-0.0742661804,
-0.0152057707,
-0.0538203828,
0.0469294116,
-0.0273908935,
-0.0046677175,
0.035889484,
0.0438916534,
0.0037750921,
-0.0032849212,
-0.0586353168,
-0.0335753039,
0.0321017727,
-0.0729621872,
-0.0109237712,
0.045209568,
0.1049179882,
0.0059598731,
0.0266314372,
0.0191311873,
-0.0108822165,
-0.0141996928,
0.0412138849,
0.0627051964,
0.0109479446,
-0.014751981,
-0.025170004,
-0.0181682222,
0.0257664993,
-0.0490762666,
0.0501568913,
-0.0071667088,
-0.02613171,
-0.0424632691,
0.0204712935,
-0.0199629627,
0.0381916575,
-0.0188308191,
-0.0053984416,
0.0374736376,
0.0116073648,
-0.0225832611,
-0.0392084569,
-0.0228514634,
-0.05208119,
0.0233554803,
-0.0244985223,
-0.0747708902,
-0.0015455232,
0.0065020295,
-0.0222402047,
-0.0607851148,
-0.0044703675,
2.530426078e-34,
0.0342037231,
-0.0074304808,
0.0397594981,
0.0594115555,
0.0493722633,
0.0377077013,
-0.008245402,
0.008152605,
0.0076094009,
-0.0696348473,
0.0152326729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14422v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14422v1 | Large Language Models are biased to overestimate profoundness | 2023-10-22T21:33:50 | 2023-10-22T21:33:50 | Eugenio Herrera-Berg, Tomás Vergara Browne, Pablo León-Villagrá, Marc-Lluís Vives, Cristian Buc Calderon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in natural language processing by large language models
(LLMs), such as GPT-4, have been suggested to approach Artificial General
Intelligence. And yet, it is still under dispute whether LLMs possess similar
reasoning abilities to humans. This study evaluates GPT-4 and various other
LLMs in judging the profoundness of mundane, motivational, and pseudo-profound
statements. We found a significant statement-to-statement correlation between
the LLMs and humans, irrespective of the type of statements and the prompting
technique used. However, LLMs systematically overestimate the profoundness of
nonsensical statements, with the exception of Tk-instruct, which uniquely
underestimates the profoundness of statements. Only few-shot learning prompts,
as opposed to chain-of-thought prompting, draw LLMs ratings closer to humans.
Furthermore, this work provides insights into the potential biases induced by
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), inducing an increase in the
bias to overestimate the profoundness of statements. | [
0.085404776,
0.0321514606,
-0.0236447137,
-0.0035655051,
-0.0371256508,
0.0385527797,
-0.0335446,
0.0259838477,
0.0111549171,
-0.0152608063,
-0.0231563877,
-0.0085696764,
-0.0133904032,
-0.0057021468,
0.0303004943,
-0.0583612397,
0.0288651343,
-0.0434838235,
0.0598822609,
-0.007231222,
-0.0293899532,
0.0086953072,
0.0236728471,
0.0259570666,
0.0085392129,
-0.0024595123,
0.0015065249,
-0.0123005025,
0.0214164313,
-0.0587842762,
-0.030434465,
0.0330386944,
0.0322969407,
0.0284491666,
0.0000020194,
-0.0803013146,
0.0823012516,
-0.0189669207,
-0.0335563794,
0.041769214,
0.0287141725,
-0.0053872121,
0.015332968,
-0.0190486461,
-0.0318058394,
-0.0194937661,
0.0246088635,
0.1093100831,
0.0171130616,
0.0694784671,
0.0168070048,
-0.0520339236,
0.0433621407,
-0.0201505162,
0.0622498877,
-0.056803111,
0.0409151837,
0.0245693401,
0.0054082214,
0.0391946435,
-0.0180788506,
0.0088199116,
0.0277612135,
0.003488515,
-0.0036714259,
0.0346315615,
-0.0231450386,
-0.0276838411,
0.0077909934,
0.0437125191,
0.0313667208,
-0.0050363326,
-0.0194605552,
-0.0164077878,
0.0358061641,
0.0003973468,
-0.0595004819,
0.0495816991,
0.0008391729,
0.0170725212,
0.0108902948,
0.0052518775,
0.0052343225,
0.0257531498,
-0.0136543894,
0.0658510029,
-0.0155989276,
-0.0561718829,
0.0532306619,
0.0161409937,
-0.050700292,
-0.0584659763,
-0.0430024788,
-0.0136516215,
-0.0414815024,
0.0193230491,
0.0127605209,
0.0742915496,
0.0447338261,
-0.038117934,
0.0404775515,
0.0193222221,
-0.0200511236,
0.038739372,
-0.0156870261,
0.0779397488,
-0.0384486169,
0.0274208132,
-0.016474491,
0.004857515,
-0.0503822826,
-0.0385120101,
0.0086725466,
0.0295383018,
-0.0032895335,
-0.0372039415,
-0.060121078,
0.0194210988,
-0.0286797825,
0.0169499572,
-0.0566903315,
0.0193998422,
-0.0068138679,
-0.0296079386,
-0.078892827,
0.0377982594,
-0.0524540208,
0.0269673429,
-0.0080446191,
-0.0489968508,
0.0119868647,
0.0014089122,
0.016403649,
-0.0340714119,
0.0229663718,
0.0249261409,
0.0165177714,
-0.0243404377,
-0.023028126,
0.0054247575,
-0.0219471008,
-0.0892261341,
-0.0199400596,
-0.015993353,
-0.0070107328,
0.0114747249,
0.0006703746,
0.0054970928,
0.0085340552,
0.0341680944,
-0.0438951403,
0.0552285872,
0.0381281599,
0.0347768255,
0.0298538897,
0.0218616202,
-0.0165065397,
0.0165874083,
-0.0057517039,
0.0456881598,
0.003518065,
-0.0186511446,
0.025168946,
-0.0063252649,
-0.0453312322,
-0.0236321259,
-0.0175468493,
0.026670495,
-0.0342410915,
0.0521143451,
0.0487607382,
0.0728537515,
-0.0330783166,
0.0317768939,
0.0894985497,
0.0893647447,
-0.0331370085,
0.0289803706,
0.055270344,
0.0669778213,
0.0232627876,
0.0088884542,
-0.0677878931,
0.0259201247,
-0.0474194922,
0.0238747019,
0.0423798487,
-0.009042263,
-0.0145506104,
-0.0152888233,
-0.0058774883,
0.02364555,
0.0173671581,
0.0083756596,
0.0380575135,
-0.0390700251,
-0.0388891064,
-0.0286955405,
0.0172465593,
-0.0256864391,
-0.0142505048,
-0.0501067638,
0.0323718451,
0.0511036478,
0.0038190845,
0.0177200213,
0.0264263749,
-0.0171037074,
0.0206658915,
0.0659606084,
0.0398044102,
0.0126260528,
-0.0253211707,
-0.012461165,
0.0021441793,
-0.0368166082,
0.0107517662,
-0.0085472809,
-0.0059778891,
0.0150333447,
0.0187112391,
-0.0088782506,
-0.0238620061,
0.0085885841,
0.0078789676,
-0.0548941568,
-0.0385592431,
-0.0036614216,
0.0155755077,
0.0017147522,
-0.0001571053,
0.0027476046,
0.003911715,
0.0035239533,
-0.0498867035,
-0.0007818465,
-0.0791503713,
0.0296119656,
-0.0279421043,
-0.0459154323,
-0.0375073142,
0.0077603967,
-0.0167158898,
-0.0015768808,
-0.0076879347,
-0.0558990203,
0.0356119163,
-0.0322549231,
0.0231943633,
-0.0478578992,
0.0041917129,
-0.0284281019,
0.0843248293,
0.0195192136,
0.0214553736,
0.011802936,
-0.0054690605,
-0.0128372069,
-0.0225670412,
-0.0190186873,
-0.0117911212,
0.0294535663,
-0.004029497,
0.0268028248,
-0.0042779446,
-0.0687289983,
-0.0138826603,
-0.0835446492,
-0.0305871051,
0.0167423934,
0.0059232432,
-0.0214456357,
-0.0356938727,
-0.0092690801,
-0.0031740065,
-0.0207385719,
-0.0272558201,
0.0166936219,
0.0493491963,
0.0340783969,
0.0132453125,
0.0020948425,
0.0073852302,
0.009015549,
-0.0131764831,
0.0062354188,
0.0410470553,
0.0205618758,
-0.0292614922,
0.0426796414,
-0.0184106138,
-0.0203759242,
-0.0026262775,
-0.0385303684,
0.02368192,
0.0133003052,
0.0335659683,
0.11219538,
0.034004882,
0.02359722,
0.0337481909,
0.0130773373,
-0.042229902,
0.0008813472,
-0.0348721072,
-0.0709057227,
-0.0335832238,
-0.0307903644,
0.029830724,
0.0244719889,
0.0241155904,
0.0364471301,
-0.0658218786,
0.0485977307,
-0.0323057212,
-0.0434745923,
-0.0134327589,
-0.026524473,
-0.0502863936,
0.0487396605,
0.0087052146,
-0.0606919229,
0.0650656372,
0.0314795598,
-0.0223047044,
-0.0157915577,
0.0000499358,
-0.0120453732,
0.0701087639,
0.0077997246,
-0.002668336,
0.0102159297,
-0.0344758108,
-0.0347873569,
-0.0258585699,
-0.0245600101,
-0.0197123084,
0.046255406,
-0.0012118537,
-0.0287157372,
0.0078290273,
-0.0501248799,
-0.039889358,
-0.0288876276,
-0.071105741,
-0.010239684,
-0.0043141423,
-0.0059974464,
0.0054174364,
-0.0688596368,
0.058728788,
-0.0144573804,
-0.0054075681,
-0.047344178,
-0.0020560867,
-0.0195308849,
0.0455379672,
0.0129326154,
0.0225760154,
-0.0270802081,
0.0446496271,
0.0323378965,
-0.02163608,
0.027895283,
-0.0135090277,
0.0114418129,
-0.0055397684,
0.0160736199,
-0.0263640098,
0.0601353534,
0.0390168466,
-0.0387975611,
-0.0034509427,
0.12211252,
0.0176058859,
-0.0243945122,
0.0306019112,
-0.0450764298,
0.0117922043,
0.0197840966,
0.0009106971,
-0.0649076998,
-0.037916977,
-0.0039908094,
0.0003722991,
-0.070288606,
-0.0157669056,
-0.0010073137,
-0.1382844746,
0.0304347444,
-0.0109513337,
-0.0022773526,
-0.0012928252,
-0.0201805457,
0.0165971499,
0.0198418908,
0.0066517442,
0.017467998,
-0.0233374424,
-0.0208936594,
-0.0070588444,
-0.0183984246,
-0.0480074994,
0.0691940933,
-0.0282321572,
0.0576019734,
0.0550286211,
0.0558720753,
-0.0439893678,
-0.033506155,
0.0370307453,
-0.0083700474,
0.0191278532,
0.0162600111,
0.0194606874,
-0.0105821341,
0.0139472252,
-0.0785705671,
0.027713649,
0.0168873928,
-0.0089126779,
0.0146514112,
0.0912871808,
-0.0239362773,
-0.0618633479,
0.004595927,
0.033967372,
-0.0240418427,
0.1044218466,
0.003569596,
-0.0605661832,
-0.0253419466,
-0.0042999927,
-0.0022869813,
0.032867156,
-0.0473879799,
0.0040911781,
0.0135907503,
0.0475569405,
-0.0598332621,
-0.046168346,
0.0213842988,
-0.0391897149,
-0.020534046,
0.0297228843,
-0.0153917661,
0.0171991568,
0.0235201586,
0.0445692763,
-0.0039790748,
-0.0119390665,
-0.064597562,
0.0105981566,
0.0085868845,
-0.0549769513,
-0.0085144807,
-0.0260804687,
-0.0315770023,
-0.0571654625,
0.0176063925,
0.0074374611,
0.0258671883,
-0.0009897763,
0.0300151501,
-0.0448211133,
0.0435383357,
0.05081385,
-0.0189700183,
0.0662086755,
0.0177612845,
0.0823173299,
0.0112681547,
0.0537319705,
-0.0042568208,
0.0318759829,
0.041602999,
0.0031380553,
0.0112959417,
-0.0437206179,
0.0234338269,
0.0444305539,
0.0186363421,
0.0202631932,
-0.000988522,
-0.0075029694,
-0.0287453253,
-0.0112438789,
-0.0102705471,
-0.0129180513,
-0.0156857595,
0.0513192266,
0.0426143929,
-0.0335542224,
-0.0363273807,
-0.0055480935,
0.0152147561,
-0.0269736107,
-0.0029330354,
0.0120811313,
0.0162627529,
0.0022461715,
0.0073167081,
-0.0466601178,
-0.0009297684,
-0.0279043969,
0.0382457115,
0.0164634138,
0.1073223278,
0.0381405093,
-0.0233035143,
-0.0020952167,
0.0012166689,
-0.0870909691,
-0.0903122053,
0.0334025547,
0.013754338,
0.0192737971,
0.0045047132,
0.034191139,
-0.0738503188,
0.0045511844,
-0.0149375107,
0.0000168294,
-0.0176930241,
-0.0094518783,
0.0258738194,
0.0200701896,
-0.0436332896,
0.0208349302,
0.0084707644,
-0.0074106851,
0.0344581716,
0.0119218538,
-0.0223296732,
-0.013308133,
-0.0200122669,
0.0233575851,
0.017564714,
-0.0135062886,
0.0469442979,
-0.0701617375,
-0.0372370221,
-0.004107201,
-0.0025158394,
0.0102257309,
-0.0685891882,
0.0277490094,
0.032805901,
-0.0125721116,
-0.049833402,
-0.0144072017,
0.0044621117,
-0.0036580071,
0.0231773611,
-0.0502508841,
-6.658528976e-33,
0.0067907893,
-0.0076117078,
-0.0088349469,
-0.011753818,
-0.0430151373,
-0.0156909246,
-0.0180950593,
0.0177332275,
-0.0315264948,
0.0525777489,
-0.02356443,
0.0144070908,
0.0047794213,
0.0002077764,
0.0613858625,
0.0011360173,
0.0259069055,
0.0275874492,
-0.0240666233,
0.022516422,
0.034058664,
-0.0168500822,
0.0372335128,
-0.0561164618,
0.033953052,
0.0019288604,
-0.014232453,
0.0010232402,
-0.0512085967,
0.0080047585,
-0.0372498482,
0.048455067,
0.0316498391,
-0.028797403,
-0.000523582,
0.0866052061,
0.0063603641,
-0.0317642689,
0.0521766953,
-0.042669408,
-0.0198436975,
-0.0248287302,
0.0171027109,
-0.0450860895,
-0.0682036579,
-0.0019875795,
0.0170863215,
-0.0190327894,
0.0417310297,
-0.0223172475,
-0.0774076506,
-0.0098114265,
0.0167946033,
0.0148884896,
-0.034536954,
0.016744975,
-0.0526360385,
0.0310946144,
-0.0134242242,
0.0281822681,
0.0307009201,
-0.0173793584,
0.0203161072,
-0.0102167949,
0.0340980515,
0.0591168627,
0.0505849235,
0.0250757262,
-0.0367953777,
-0.0133103225,
0.0075849304,
0.0348335393,
0.0339482464,
0.0630934611,
0.060317412,
0.0080745155,
-0.0283732153,
-0.0419298485,
-0.026247099,
0.0704593882,
0.0812094957,
-0.0044229315,
-0.0613616742,
-0.0239632744,
-0.029968027,
0.0098917419,
-0.0343862176,
-0.0348965153,
0.0339079611,
-0.0087686721,
0.01387267,
-0.0172773767,
0.0191351846,
-0.030660579,
0.0283305626,
0.0100274459,
-0.0470878072,
0.017491471,
0.0060065272,
-0.015439515,
-0.0654123798,
-0.0138438623,
-0.0156418961,
0.0116264885,
0.0230050087,
0.025624318,
0.022873234,
-0.0071032406,
-0.0491216369,
-0.0019340084,
-0.006405286,
-0.0013615176,
-0.0077455714,
-0.0565331243,
0.0423626713,
-0.0014189847,
-0.0069597126,
0.0052306075,
-0.0107355984,
-0.0198987685,
-0.0536638834,
0.0048765768,
-0.0041053449,
-0.0008223038,
-0.0336931571,
0.009574987,
-0.026177546,
0.0028749679,
0.0146937007,
-0.0514963828,
-0.0306197926,
0.0067849681,
2.96e-7,
-0.0310580488,
0.10296911,
-0.0117715662,
0.0069316449,
-0.0050438675,
0.0648022816,
-0.0075251767,
0.0112178298,
0.044966463,
0.0119513646,
0.0269344728,
0.0127237495,
0.0296489391,
-0.008972628,
-0.077588968,
0.0227889735,
-0.0759081319,
-0.0325929113,
-0.059486445,
0.0200461112,
0.0764944628,
0.0228614546,
0.023951482,
-0.0216924306,
0.0212760475,
-0.0477847122,
0.0437016599,
-0.0526274517,
0.0261272825,
-0.0114056803,
-0.0201688316,
0.0079533895,
0.0162790902,
0.0474202298,
0.0379535072,
-0.0120223202,
0.0062788944,
0.0777342096,
0.0030045214,
0.0021862166,
-0.0426245853,
0.0056800134,
0.0027054381,
-0.0902370512,
0.0507531427,
-0.1020173207,
-0.049937278,
-0.0066672056,
-0.0074378899,
-0.0586047061,
0.0182191078,
0.0024462247,
-0.0312081873,
-0.0375474654,
0.0165283475,
0.0230194721,
0.0071170395,
-0.0563260242,
0.0159854535,
0.0197254978,
-0.0466135032,
-0.068824023,
-0.0547311753,
0.0602675155,
0.0122784553,
-0.0550542437,
-0.0108551886,
2.411411407e-34,
0.0339590609,
-0.0325200595,
0.077500008,
-0.0504114777,
0.0327337086,
0.0833632499,
-0.0225871149,
0.0083481232,
0.0425730236,
-0.0980325341,
-0.0056455401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14418v1 | REFER: An End-to-end Rationale Extraction Framework for Explanation Regularization | 2023-10-22T21:20:52 | 2023-10-22T21:20:52 | Mohammad Reza Ghasemi Madani, Pasquale Minervini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human-annotated textual explanations are becoming increasingly important in
Explainable Natural Language Processing. Rationale extraction aims to provide
faithful (i.e., reflective of the behavior of the model) and plausible (i.e.,
convincing to humans) explanations by highlighting the inputs that had the
largest impact on the prediction without compromising the performance of the
task model. In recent works, the focus of training rationale extractors was
primarily on optimizing for plausibility using human highlights, while the task
model was trained on jointly optimizing for task predictive accuracy and
faithfulness. We propose REFER, a framework that employs a differentiable
rationale extractor that allows to back-propagate through the rationale
extraction process. We analyze the impact of using human highlights during
training by jointly training the task model and the rationale extractor. In our
experiments, REFER yields significantly better results in terms of
faithfulness, plausibility, and downstream task accuracy on both
in-distribution and out-of-distribution data. On both e-SNLI and CoS-E, our
best setting produces better results in terms of composite normalized relative
gain than the previous baselines by 11% and 3%, respectively. | [
0.0381852984,
0.0504551753,
0.014310318,
0.033210706,
0.0146329179,
0.0223576967,
0.0168327838,
0.0015527788,
-0.0550742112,
-0.0006441296,
0.0133240633,
0.0182827767,
0.0026719498,
0.0309345089,
0.0361379273,
-0.0747137889,
0.0091228774,
-0.0147285545,
0.0572019704,
0.0365099646,
0.00123178,
0.0181914903,
0.0222829524,
0.0570743345,
0.0343953557,
-0.006526398,
-0.0198402274,
-0.0067809764,
0.0341282412,
0.0027310101,
0.0046042316,
0.0183840003,
0.0492571518,
-0.010595575,
0.0000020351,
-0.0289624371,
-0.0227034576,
0.0036165556,
-0.0727672577,
0.0004796704,
-0.0344390422,
-0.0050037676,
0.0144910496,
-0.0110832676,
-0.0014378829,
0.0468715541,
0.0313754454,
0.0969352871,
0.046879556,
0.0875836462,
-0.0047156024,
-0.0188498497,
-0.0112368334,
-0.0096539678,
-0.0039856141,
-0.0147401718,
-0.0158549491,
0.0145317679,
0.0050969436,
0.0029176958,
0.0117779206,
-0.0189786348,
0.0301781781,
-0.0516733192,
0.0230540838,
0.0151506187,
0.0429821871,
-0.010436275,
-0.0166906621,
0.0800304487,
-0.0147519186,
-0.020456396,
-0.0035207849,
-0.0115980729,
-0.0097479746,
0.0165773183,
-0.0573119,
0.0108585386,
0.0005397208,
0.0258219987,
0.0367043987,
0.0018654545,
0.0346659571,
0.0312638767,
-0.0120425737,
0.0374064036,
-0.0310524814,
-0.0057964702,
0.0220655669,
0.0085753612,
-0.0444550365,
-0.043093048,
0.0091854883,
0.052791886,
-0.0098601831,
0.0011522376,
0.0074101067,
-0.0068362285,
-0.0105315987,
-0.0093872976,
0.0189515948,
0.0007928747,
-0.0149599519,
0.0521048531,
-0.0003650653,
0.0397159867,
0.0000146402,
0.0336312316,
0.0078132525,
-0.0342327021,
-0.0608382113,
-0.0041372189,
-0.0169448219,
-0.0000249128,
-0.06373173,
0.0082445424,
-0.0066953646,
-0.0119311837,
-0.0460628904,
-0.0046071024,
0.0479306169,
0.069973141,
-0.0364075452,
-0.0408779569,
-0.0201872345,
0.0076895882,
-0.089382872,
0.0330112055,
0.0619812161,
-0.0272335913,
-0.0437296182,
0.0271867588,
0.0525171384,
-0.0465881377,
-0.0174348764,
0.012857493,
-0.0010451521,
0.0112743359,
-0.0321502872,
-0.0378115997,
-0.0057004709,
-0.0523355268,
-0.0488093235,
-0.0007985351,
-0.0045114793,
-0.0315903574,
-0.0219236575,
-0.0625695214,
-0.0037338065,
-0.0024458298,
-0.0345362872,
0.0561233051,
-0.053718619,
-0.0213666596,
-0.0155006861,
0.0060160444,
-0.0741281882,
0.0322262309,
0.0251298435,
0.0079134777,
0.056211967,
-0.0382122435,
0.019283779,
-0.016554527,
0.0113744326,
-0.0254568998,
-0.0062945057,
0.0044940496,
-0.0688537434,
0.0136204138,
0.0782082081,
0.020465238,
-0.0348637104,
-0.00956068,
0.0194168985,
0.0538017303,
0.0168394987,
0.0186749287,
0.0461051986,
0.0465262868,
0.0028371257,
0.039466884,
-0.0718072876,
0.0216304567,
-0.0153075289,
-0.0028825116,
-0.0021413807,
-0.0122546563,
-0.0134974662,
-0.0418076739,
0.0081338128,
-0.0319000334,
0.0090032835,
0.0094152195,
0.0718583316,
0.0060382294,
-0.0226947125,
0.0262688417,
0.0380780771,
-0.0405739918,
0.0087828236,
-0.0562789589,
0.0712348968,
0.0559882335,
0.0063939663,
-0.0184533317,
0.0075526712,
-0.0283228364,
0.0067682415,
0.0124727255,
0.0170252938,
-0.0363056548,
0.0549088605,
-0.0325013511,
-0.02782779,
-0.0422145054,
0.0345155708,
0.0090013174,
0.0117741507,
-0.052128382,
0.0346779078,
-0.0684717149,
-0.050621748,
0.031436339,
-0.0143565573,
-0.0442707352,
-0.0101567898,
-0.0032552499,
0.0156737827,
0.0482970513,
-0.0021975015,
0.015140078,
0.0089727426,
-0.0322987996,
-0.0136983786,
0.050521493,
-0.0507160425,
-0.0301151443,
0.0026057246,
-0.0155713381,
-0.0313314572,
0.0465493388,
-0.0257376693,
-0.0535684414,
0.0274377353,
-0.0221263394,
-0.0007331531,
-0.0315849334,
-0.0240293089,
0.0154876187,
-0.0018794356,
-0.0215973314,
0.0699438676,
0.0372443348,
-0.0199927837,
0.0108825015,
-0.0506667383,
0.0081910947,
-0.0467301644,
0.050285466,
0.0133657912,
-0.0137015097,
-0.0182543974,
0.0244572945,
-0.0233453605,
-0.0529006533,
0.0353227295,
-0.0389596187,
-0.0042945957,
-0.0491838902,
0.0035802131,
0.03244837,
0.0274254382,
0.0203816295,
-0.0167833306,
0.0025702566,
-0.0194663834,
-0.0157293342,
-0.0025222588,
0.0420062952,
0.0170934647,
0.0007999328,
-0.0782869086,
-0.0009767505,
-0.0146383718,
0.0643735006,
0.0155870859,
0.0129019283,
-0.0649466366,
0.0096093556,
0.0115550738,
0.008937981,
-0.0124804685,
-0.0180620868,
0.0126340166,
-0.0221990757,
-0.0069699395,
0.0643811449,
0.009506328,
0.0349192396,
-0.0070559327,
0.0153742116,
-0.0708732381,
0.0147694079,
-0.0238265153,
0.0297699366,
-0.0305508953,
-0.013878854,
0.0321101919,
0.0996195599,
-0.0274970513,
0.0047881943,
-0.0507629775,
0.0351800807,
0.0188058075,
-0.0250185877,
-0.0248307604,
-0.0506725423,
-0.0213913508,
0.0722107589,
-0.049799446,
-0.0618428588,
0.0842763036,
-0.0181954,
-0.0085797478,
-0.009228128,
-0.0441417657,
-0.0379985124,
0.0439526662,
-0.0344407409,
-0.0197934862,
0.0292569883,
-0.016878143,
-0.0092976298,
-0.0664595515,
0.0273895003,
0.0208527204,
0.0575812459,
-0.0685212761,
-0.0165265389,
0.0153324381,
-0.028175639,
-0.0431908332,
-0.0594451278,
-0.0481159501,
0.0101043228,
-0.0015664693,
-0.0345176272,
0.001414429,
-0.0182944871,
0.0300221629,
0.0404456444,
-0.022480702,
0.0216479525,
0.0076984018,
0.0332861468,
0.0562365614,
0.0465582125,
0.0265762899,
-0.0122593446,
0.0649085492,
0.0357791334,
0.0240085907,
-0.0616015866,
-0.0409404002,
-0.0089995712,
-0.0069862208,
-0.0417040214,
-0.0204140507,
0.0052071805,
0.1123916209,
-0.0778632835,
0.0138574047,
0.106393151,
-0.0011436626,
-0.0371966325,
0.0110725211,
-0.0299316328,
0.0316945203,
0.0189116728,
0.0000271914,
-0.0024749395,
-0.0602189191,
0.0036661176,
0.0602910854,
0.0136092743,
-0.0149723841,
0.0020402391,
-0.0792100057,
0.0321552604,
-0.0255590789,
-0.000511981,
-0.0232389029,
-0.0812990665,
0.007897825,
-0.0356513858,
0.0171076395,
0.0035347452,
0.0402406864,
0.0290919524,
0.0385733098,
-0.0389084443,
-0.0300054122,
0.0192056261,
-0.0475208871,
0.0086208936,
0.0401613899,
0.0513067618,
0.0121957175,
-0.037476752,
0.00155267,
-0.0282700658,
0.0578245707,
-0.0123174526,
0.0791472346,
0.0220177285,
0.0109157152,
-0.04364058,
0.0722949058,
-0.0293420926,
-0.0360190272,
0.0108624529,
0.0818560049,
-0.0074981586,
0.0052966326,
0.0010041364,
-0.0144533096,
0.0196648445,
0.0752823204,
0.057658162,
-0.0197894871,
-0.0504598171,
-0.0343157575,
-0.0265235826,
-0.0943783075,
-0.0167307574,
-0.0305838604,
0.014781761,
-0.018673081,
-0.0397167616,
-0.0503186248,
-0.0014229839,
0.0280224662,
-0.0205481332,
-0.0132858958,
-0.018358333,
-0.0173004884,
-0.0217045452,
0.0584999956,
-0.0013006064,
0.0142237516,
0.0248324852,
0.0002870383,
-0.0217227042,
-0.0389810838,
0.0042737089,
0.0041836514,
0.0114736697,
-0.0330136567,
-0.029861778,
0.0200620051,
0.0271578282,
0.0979132801,
-0.0166044924,
-0.0417322926,
-0.034737315,
-0.0495700277,
-0.0288831554,
-0.0443136618,
0.0712990314,
-0.0251750331,
0.0133799752,
0.0398395322,
-0.0253979415,
0.0083521595,
0.0027397969,
0.0319136418,
-0.0078866603,
-0.010072167,
0.0329703502,
-0.0187244955,
0.0670969039,
0.0067510079,
-0.02500844,
-0.0540039465,
-0.0326218605,
-0.0477885045,
-0.0074949311,
-0.0210268386,
0.0506116152,
0.0056319265,
-0.0185119249,
-0.0142444707,
-0.0295384899,
-0.042497512,
0.0160939395,
-0.0412261859,
0.0523420796,
0.0108407736,
-0.0013254324,
-0.0253699515,
0.0100793503,
-0.0174309053,
-0.0058534131,
-0.0161179285,
0.0620371215,
0.003543441,
0.0513866507,
0.0103590088,
-0.0216482226,
0.0113736186,
-0.0171588287,
-0.0954437181,
-0.019665407,
0.0262626354,
-0.0514307953,
0.0264427252,
-0.0434022211,
0.0851552859,
0.0447717756,
-0.0144462483,
0.0170524474,
0.0690228119,
0.0258389618,
-0.0050215335,
-0.0140376827,
0.0180953275,
-0.0385065787,
0.0057450538,
0.0552461669,
0.0031052693,
0.0230995454,
-0.0317404792,
-0.0245261174,
-0.0106821693,
-0.0076815281,
-0.0196964704,
0.0594606139,
0.0002386713,
-0.0086458651,
-0.0212594718,
-0.0396121368,
0.0013693359,
-0.0211709067,
-0.0126292035,
-0.011765494,
0.018809624,
0.0404712446,
-0.0406252779,
-0.0380912125,
-0.032153815,
0.0214654561,
-0.022379417,
0.0121329278,
-0.0320968293,
-6.173905715e-33,
0.0194873698,
-0.0458355658,
-0.031491261,
-0.0086971456,
0.0000830626,
0.0345402174,
-0.0804587081,
-0.0243770182,
-0.0159336291,
0.0586612374,
-0.0135041997,
0.0309134685,
0.0225274898,
0.0087102503,
0.0148470532,
-0.0085428283,
0.0377434231,
0.0374306887,
-0.006674319,
0.0218221694,
0.0442746989,
0.0249251276,
0.0792821571,
-0.0815996751,
0.0702052116,
0.0542846322,
-0.0096536288,
0.024064634,
0.0263862964,
0.0579927228,
-0.0006407689,
0.0293867551,
0.0193457492,
-0.0791318789,
-0.0131290033,
0.0202571601,
-0.1046716198,
-0.0056060511,
0.0258521121,
-0.0333512761,
-0.075095132,
-0.0373810045,
0.0303918552,
-0.0118578374,
0.0176828783,
-0.0222325437,
0.0496341251,
-0.02152423,
0.0033641574,
0.0114440676,
-0.055917684,
0.0530909561,
-0.0517462045,
0.0009358813,
0.0108846743,
0.0535921454,
-0.0066795936,
0.0171689801,
0.0028862222,
-0.0357331261,
0.0062365364,
-0.0049173911,
0.0323210359,
0.0073008351,
-0.0347102731,
0.086129494,
0.0174989551,
-0.0120734517,
-0.0767502263,
0.0177145768,
-0.0366158001,
0.0697842091,
0.086038895,
0.0436429642,
0.0301654823,
0.0352256298,
-0.0889887214,
0.0298883468,
-0.0201458409,
0.0436448231,
0.011432277,
0.027656896,
-0.0514155887,
-0.0107183233,
-0.0154128196,
-0.0226030145,
-0.0075458097,
-0.0234879311,
0.0060499818,
-0.0062417644,
-0.0489956476,
0.0296090767,
-0.0098814638,
-0.0315592438,
0.0606599674,
0.048506014,
-0.0080794916,
-0.0241134968,
0.0318577774,
-0.0402966514,
-0.0458323918,
0.0017957455,
0.0195052586,
0.0241210964,
0.0405011959,
0.0199197605,
0.0534220375,
-0.0172633659,
-0.0065456294,
-0.0151509456,
-0.0676717013,
0.0062062545,
-0.0301062036,
0.0525748916,
0.0343096182,
0.0357616618,
-0.0509310514,
0.048656676,
-0.0043087555,
0.0111621125,
0.0170186851,
-0.0044827843,
0.0327611752,
0.0047840257,
-0.030785108,
-0.0301654525,
0.0111989221,
-0.0335812047,
0.0238144789,
-0.0302531905,
-0.0186763257,
-0.0082959365,
2.544e-7,
0.0195618048,
0.0169060715,
0.076954253,
-0.0346918739,
0.0179347359,
0.0452775322,
0.0421485156,
-0.02655169,
-0.0068714237,
-0.0364452414,
-0.0113433339,
0.0253397413,
0.0629678294,
0.020021813,
-0.0347460881,
-0.0440813377,
-0.0162854139,
-0.0477642156,
-0.0129829329,
0.011910392,
0.0777631402,
0.0335329175,
0.0343515202,
-0.0179888178,
0.0079183765,
-0.0347374342,
0.004599554,
-0.0548531897,
0.0169099178,
-0.0032456536,
0.0614973456,
-0.0101175848,
0.0100669339,
-0.0055368901,
-0.0339506045,
0.0258204322,
-0.0305191148,
0.0614695884,
-0.0440624245,
-0.0303575844,
-0.029574478,
-0.0439250469,
0.0550099239,
-0.0566981174,
0.0556758456,
-0.0241328701,
-0.0650036559,
-0.0262983739,
-0.0472781695,
-0.015380213,
-0.055169601,
-0.0140393795,
0.0264848601,
0.0085795335,
-0.0195351001,
-0.0099329203,
-0.0249806326,
-0.0865599215,
-0.060467463,
0.0140581308,
-0.0098767541,
0.007879178,
-0.0115485033,
-0.0037962568,
0.0609061122,
-0.0598197579,
0.0189974438,
2.165986554e-34,
0.0241667703,
0.0375258215,
0.0013131723,
0.0330536328,
0.0885648727,
0.0228733085,
-0.0297403075,
-0.033795137,
0.0808379054,
-0.0396777429,
-0.0303476751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14404v1 | Be Selfish, But Wisely: Investigating the Impact of Agent Personality in Mixed-Motive Human-Agent Interactions | 2023-10-22T20:31:35 | 2023-10-22T20:31:35 | Kushal Chawla, Ian Wu, Yu Rong, Gale M. Lucas, Jonathan Gratch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A natural way to design a negotiation dialogue system is via self-play RL:
train an agent that learns to maximize its performance by interacting with a
simulated user that has been designed to imitate human-human dialogue data.
Although this procedure has been adopted in prior work, we find that it results
in a fundamentally flawed system that fails to learn the value of compromise in
a negotiation, which can often lead to no agreements (i.e., the partner walking
away without a deal), ultimately hurting the model's overall performance. We
investigate this observation in the context of the DealOrNoDeal task, a
multi-issue negotiation over books, hats, and balls. Grounded in negotiation
theory from Economics, we modify the training procedure in two novel ways to
design agents with diverse personalities and analyze their performance with
human partners. We find that although both techniques show promise, a selfish
agent, which maximizes its own performance while also avoiding walkaways,
performs superior to other variants by implicitly learning to generate value
for both itself and the negotiation partner. We discuss the implications of our
findings for what it means to be a successful negotiation dialogue system and
how these systems should be designed in the future. | [
0.0548146702,
0.0696536303,
-0.0356459655,
0.0161518697,
-0.0386363752,
-0.0180635415,
0.0444418155,
-0.0142804785,
0.0175607242,
-0.0096480409,
-0.0542559586,
0.0328867696,
-0.0113713928,
-0.0031225234,
0.0178815406,
-0.0652775392,
0.0527775213,
-0.0077346405,
0.0669942349,
-0.0384659097,
-0.0125032077,
-0.0195919015,
-0.0050674211,
0.0153731918,
-0.0518489815,
-0.0132988961,
-0.0393286198,
-0.017755311,
0.0427339599,
0.0070113568,
0.026872661,
0.0531271361,
-0.005435342,
0.0194097962,
0.0000020138,
-0.0555582903,
-0.0135697341,
-0.0381515063,
-0.0084278528,
-0.0302447733,
0.0794348568,
0.0285802819,
0.0182339791,
0.0387428068,
-0.075710997,
-0.0066352938,
-0.0227506123,
0.1192899644,
0.0452358238,
0.0447638407,
0.0123423496,
0.0264427252,
-0.0118222395,
-0.0342773236,
0.0113930991,
-0.070987992,
0.0007418714,
-0.039653834,
-0.0307709258,
-0.0007382488,
0.0031236892,
-0.0261200201,
0.0250904486,
-0.0171925258,
-0.0226201247,
0.032458555,
-0.0362509526,
-0.0089706015,
-0.0125776492,
0.0487452783,
0.0163134728,
0.0451687872,
0.0212051906,
-0.0159167107,
0.0702314675,
-0.05563014,
0.0204490032,
0.0492000394,
-0.021414578,
-0.0194668584,
0.0073971292,
0.0282541011,
-0.0370776728,
0.0059378287,
0.0003590526,
0.0290108211,
-0.0368301198,
0.001773683,
0.0187962912,
-0.0011602395,
0.032829836,
-0.0719315708,
-0.044053819,
-0.0025125009,
-0.0841873884,
0.0161693562,
-0.0321126208,
0.0528710894,
0.0243640114,
-0.0165198278,
-0.0050645377,
0.0040626968,
0.0123601202,
0.0272727832,
0.0682200044,
0.0004273819,
-0.0053885602,
0.0435537025,
-0.0122868065,
0.0501114167,
-0.0225718003,
-0.0085573234,
-0.0446107946,
0.0298405699,
0.0128435818,
0.0022574202,
-0.0189640131,
0.0213379301,
-0.0645227656,
0.0157267097,
-0.0069114338,
0.0302403755,
-0.0085404087,
0.022018319,
-0.0864207447,
-0.0207917895,
-0.0645441934,
-0.0067257048,
0.0377043784,
0.0085555911,
-0.0152885448,
-0.0171649102,
0.0068138205,
-0.0020670153,
0.0197825376,
0.0895906016,
-0.0005433932,
-0.0179091841,
0.0164157953,
-0.0368338265,
0.0153457485,
-0.0749374032,
-0.0030840088,
-0.0163695943,
0.0489081852,
-0.0485782884,
-0.0374297947,
-0.0756355375,
0.0220379457,
-0.0285903681,
0.0054094843,
0.0820159018,
0.0226522908,
-0.0202350914,
0.0163853392,
0.0166405439,
-0.0637148023,
0.0524986908,
0.0258797444,
0.0016985928,
0.0396598801,
-0.030994121,
0.0442445911,
0.0323650166,
-0.0228399616,
-0.0333722122,
0.0472070761,
0.000271599,
0.029084282,
0.047797963,
0.0362948775,
0.0215293951,
-0.0625015199,
-0.0505824834,
0.0594416708,
0.0557853617,
0.007894245,
0.024336936,
-0.0389354154,
0.07800515,
0.013308146,
-0.0034856368,
-0.0185227301,
0.0599420443,
0.0108543504,
-0.017247729,
-0.0077030682,
0.0128186084,
-0.0225105081,
-0.0410252139,
0.0363294668,
-0.0260156505,
0.0581214912,
0.0435231403,
-0.0231521539,
-0.0210795049,
-0.0461959094,
-0.0351545662,
0.0236611851,
-0.0176254921,
-0.0233864915,
-0.0511998199,
0.008188704,
0.0456408449,
0.0483472794,
-0.0192618091,
-0.0223786589,
-0.0234969892,
-0.0737422109,
0.0596379675,
0.0684691891,
-0.0348453075,
0.0101728728,
-0.0380325168,
-0.0335390531,
-0.0227978546,
-0.0111851925,
0.0609937385,
-0.0003545214,
-0.0206386112,
-0.0266939513,
0.0756817311,
0.0512822382,
0.0098057017,
-0.0389227904,
-0.0251593105,
0.0222056806,
0.0189167093,
0.0322535709,
-0.0118956054,
0.0157950539,
-0.0218730345,
-0.0001249458,
0.0231495928,
-0.0311893858,
0.0496584401,
-0.026595667,
-0.0061236499,
0.0196708571,
-0.0107722161,
-0.0408934988,
0.0221969821,
0.0150019955,
0.015213768,
0.013827147,
-0.0175956301,
0.0088068964,
-0.0069120941,
0.0120324045,
-0.0058109425,
0.0242302101,
-0.014712139,
0.021383075,
0.0156253297,
-0.0480208322,
-0.0221857205,
-0.0322364494,
0.0023181508,
-0.0825759545,
0.0425238498,
-0.0004113602,
0.0050755334,
0.0423972905,
0.0292440206,
0.0111690089,
-0.0538769215,
-0.0616176464,
-0.0264486279,
-0.0176751427,
0.028164316,
-0.0281179287,
-0.0117950439,
-0.0281869769,
-0.0031091506,
-0.0118507864,
-0.0133395363,
0.0232989155,
0.0367117487,
0.0042993026,
0.0407866426,
0.0004031232,
-0.0222159326,
-0.0398916751,
0.0266358592,
-0.0077378117,
-0.0054779383,
-0.0177174322,
0.0903701708,
-0.0317561738,
0.0172458217,
-0.0306622721,
0.0423173457,
-0.0218056682,
-0.0462641641,
0.0443479344,
0.0064224536,
-0.0007192314,
0.0900502205,
0.0509469882,
0.0643211082,
0.0162364002,
-0.0364478603,
-0.0853581727,
0.0549568646,
-0.0097346026,
0.0394553356,
-0.0622680783,
-0.0225255992,
-0.0169796534,
0.05172484,
-0.0263396353,
0.0342268012,
-0.0467265882,
0.0590466857,
0.0621755421,
-0.1038769633,
0.0237423275,
0.0179525353,
-0.0245535132,
0.0363695025,
0.0061206138,
0.0037279264,
0.0585481673,
0.0343447216,
0.0033166462,
0.0100713903,
0.0178068541,
-0.026753189,
0.0846536383,
-0.0307006408,
-0.0338933431,
0.0445116088,
0.0198889431,
-0.0603755452,
-0.042343732,
0.0419465341,
-0.0281931311,
0.0292999279,
-0.0019874987,
-0.0465659387,
0.0070140632,
-0.0493016243,
-0.0593310148,
-0.0715775043,
-0.00811237,
-0.006473294,
0.0213470832,
-0.0010753728,
-0.0380528644,
-0.0562691167,
0.0244163722,
-0.0046720454,
0.0131916776,
-0.026175905,
-0.0034538142,
-0.0500209443,
0.0484686457,
0.058350984,
0.0517823137,
-0.0251540765,
0.0416572914,
0.0114949998,
0.0043286062,
-0.0132912183,
0.0164599717,
0.0011910242,
-0.0102626802,
-0.0288264509,
0.0317461118,
0.0337757207,
-0.0042823059,
-0.0252148639,
-0.0045451913,
0.0653041378,
0.021747632,
-0.005412064,
0.013294152,
-0.035577368,
0.028704524,
0.0008934553,
0.0528764687,
-0.0300300363,
0.0101860175,
-0.0110528683,
0.0374176465,
-0.0433583781,
-0.053128954,
0.0064825756,
-0.0825628638,
0.0320884213,
0.0043492969,
-0.0025486578,
0.0586288497,
-0.0039856695,
-0.0318893716,
-0.0470574573,
0.0059311907,
-0.0034900128,
0.0130305346,
-0.0235963576,
-0.0176553689,
0.0184047539,
0.0430221669,
0.0485058129,
-0.0470490754,
0.0518870838,
0.0309409443,
0.0473557338,
-0.0039376589,
-0.0086840661,
-0.0493496135,
0.0840064436,
-0.0111817578,
0.0295872688,
0.0571018271,
-0.041129563,
0.0141610112,
-0.0429932587,
0.0186275598,
-0.0164759383,
-0.0181783531,
0.0365507975,
-0.0039148913,
-0.0040735495,
-0.0161653999,
0.0267472696,
0.0097138984,
0.0331357382,
0.033421319,
-0.0539768599,
-0.0591620877,
-0.0609248541,
-0.0032161721,
-0.0304541271,
-0.0557063818,
-0.059011288,
0.0193473622,
0.0155159058,
-0.0115773017,
-0.0194355082,
-0.1515877545,
-0.0081057362,
0.0255747233,
-0.0240321774,
-0.0284127798,
-0.0054594404,
0.0418853648,
0.0184618104,
-0.0065586204,
-0.015016756,
-0.0191481039,
0.0047263717,
-0.0272125155,
-0.008601808,
-0.0824934915,
0.0109129539,
-0.0236223657,
-0.0162761621,
-0.0123006888,
0.009711436,
0.0703010261,
0.0196208898,
0.0563566461,
0.0304683764,
-0.0002584384,
-0.0325818919,
0.0200390536,
-0.0255789012,
0.0330709964,
0.0616450571,
0.0402610339,
-0.0026955812,
0.0145035116,
-0.011726045,
0.0213666037,
0.0092937732,
-0.0052328273,
-0.0269427672,
-0.0471041389,
0.021229919,
-0.0410158336,
-0.0271223951,
0.0001191773,
-0.0187282767,
0.0088162422,
0.0192849506,
-0.0377576202,
-0.0076109115,
-0.0076551922,
-0.0953771546,
-0.0087267915,
0.0136347106,
0.0210619643,
-0.0088498527,
-0.0194300804,
0.0187200792,
0.0158888809,
-0.007015584,
0.0127109699,
-0.012655546,
-0.0523174256,
0.0030692425,
0.0178560708,
0.0093426649,
0.0164968669,
0.0473051518,
0.0258438569,
0.0814345628,
0.0212752298,
-0.023732191,
-0.0039065653,
0.0253486373,
-0.0557748154,
-0.0420788564,
0.0627721846,
0.0129374713,
-0.0181437582,
-0.0053131194,
0.000973087,
-0.0454913229,
0.022899596,
-0.0085337991,
0.0180451665,
-0.026866056,
-0.0264084842,
-0.0062150569,
0.0184819642,
-0.0310786963,
-0.0300673991,
0.0258154273,
-0.0263100266,
0.0354860201,
-0.0573350042,
0.0116824359,
-0.061597988,
-0.0234011766,
-0.008778234,
-0.02617044,
-0.0145323332,
-0.0046707522,
-0.0777031034,
-0.0158678461,
-0.0035588043,
0.0640124977,
0.001336265,
-0.0244055465,
0.0077805272,
0.0215854552,
-0.0211918876,
-0.0261641722,
-0.0085928598,
0.0207541399,
-0.0382198058,
-0.00309313,
-0.0251799952,
-5.230009466e-33,
0.0041477741,
-0.0260435622,
0.0449242555,
0.0254255533,
-0.0257564243,
-0.0434199795,
-0.0117895612,
0.0260626636,
-0.0150373867,
0.0063041714,
-0.053080257,
-0.0279766805,
0.0152986255,
-0.0546169132,
0.053383857,
-0.0022785526,
0.0146298837,
-0.0293620285,
-0.0168993603,
-0.0186333042,
-0.0329605266,
0.0048239934,
0.0255291108,
-0.0335187241,
-0.010716809,
-0.0259707626,
-0.014415646,
0.0162699372,
0.0031792345,
0.0280109588,
0.0087875249,
-0.0354889631,
-0.0099732168,
-0.0351697579,
0.0001589431,
0.0029250099,
-0.057500381,
-0.0426390953,
-0.0142820161,
-0.0076885135,
-0.0579025112,
-0.0486784317,
-0.0130370045,
0.0073251547,
-0.0534870178,
-0.0379397832,
0.0054718256,
0.035351824,
0.0221271552,
0.0600048713,
-0.0660998002,
-0.0167482775,
-0.0468143634,
-0.0476371944,
0.0198302157,
0.026723966,
-0.0071144779,
-0.0307440534,
-0.0466872752,
0.0482297242,
-0.0398228429,
-0.0381844416,
0.0000510719,
0.0145972557,
0.0353132859,
0.0330144241,
0.0933059826,
0.0975461751,
0.0077749095,
-0.0925940275,
0.0296676364,
0.0559290946,
0.0165959168,
0.0884553939,
-0.0304726604,
-0.030100571,
-0.0090606827,
0.0335557237,
0.1111202538,
0.0023877406,
0.0014173244,
0.0230628718,
-0.0007071745,
-0.0052789417,
-0.0224793404,
-0.0182481464,
0.0004142553,
-0.0626022294,
0.0207692049,
0.0303880684,
0.0389282703,
-0.0261751413,
0.0376071148,
-0.0437869206,
-0.023168711,
-0.0093436968,
0.0032693136,
0.011294526,
-0.014002176,
-0.0365458839,
-0.0398786366,
-0.0300215967,
0.0073586116,
-0.0021974838,
0.0578774996,
0.0553076379,
0.0086336071,
0.0254006982,
-0.0005594362,
-0.0135036474,
-0.0123855323,
0.0659319982,
-0.0133118425,
-0.0280100312,
0.0090543497,
0.0187454466,
-0.0125707742,
-0.0114571517,
-0.0151704354,
-0.0002795212,
-0.0738391206,
0.0745391771,
0.0211111307,
0.0079585938,
0.030129509,
0.0013727956,
-0.0497857146,
-0.0049349489,
-0.0043086568,
-0.0057106698,
-0.0066410271,
-0.0452976339,
2.656e-7,
-0.0819580853,
0.0471798331,
0.0328581035,
0.0330636911,
0.0190138277,
0.1195464879,
-0.0258858986,
0.0477372445,
0.0029148737,
-0.0331900083,
0.0417612903,
0.0207884535,
0.047222469,
0.0451048911,
-0.0445174538,
-0.0198968034,
0.0282267537,
-0.038985502,
0.0101851309,
-0.0411622375,
0.039684806,
0.0069086244,
0.0419014469,
-0.0006373609,
-0.0024094882,
0.0726902187,
0.0315551385,
-0.0487906858,
-0.0273782611,
0.0252212696,
-0.0504149348,
-0.0684432238,
-0.000882439,
0.0223793332,
0.0064090407,
0.0132561699,
-0.0589929,
0.0460919105,
-0.0350928307,
-0.0698762536,
0.004878988,
0.0377499834,
-0.0001670107,
-0.006036615,
0.0011209932,
-0.0427220464,
-0.0444481075,
-0.026742233,
0.0201796405,
0.015372307,
0.0269484352,
0.0035215437,
0.0023387123,
0.0062296311,
0.0138104595,
0.0130241942,
0.0355477631,
-0.0503946543,
-0.0220992994,
-0.0039181327,
-0.0487862714,
-0.0204600673,
0.0019731172,
0.0524538644,
0.0294037461,
-0.0336935185,
0.018897919,
1.484636967e-34,
-0.0253989883,
0.0357477851,
-0.0023112609,
0.0171825308,
0.0544176847,
0.017001003,
0.0129012251,
0.0421682335,
0.0503680483,
0.0019260067,
-0.0158972945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14403v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14403v5 | O3D: Offline Data-driven Discovery and Distillation for Sequential Decision-Making with Large Language Models | 2023-10-22T20:28:33 | 2024-02-26T18:29:45 | Yuchen Xiao, Yanchao Sun, Mengda Xu, Udari Madhushani, Jared Vann, Deepeka Garg, Sumitra Ganesh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have exhibited promising
performance in solving sequential decision-making problems. By imitating
few-shot examples provided in the prompts (i.e., in-context learning), an LLM
agent can interact with an external environment and complete given tasks
without additional training. However, such few-shot examples are often
insufficient to generate high-quality solutions for complex and long-horizon
tasks, while the limited context length cannot consume larger-scale
demonstrations with long interaction horizons. To this end, we propose an
offline learning framework that utilizes offline data at scale (e.g, logs of
human interactions) to improve LLM-powered policies without finetuning. The
proposed method O3D (Offline Data-driven Discovery and Distillation)
automatically discovers reusable skills and distills generalizable knowledge
across multiple tasks based on offline interaction data, advancing the
capability of solving downstream tasks. Empirical results under two interactive
decision-making benchmarks (ALFWorld and WebShop) verify that O3D can notably
enhance the decision-making capabilities of LLMs through the offline discovery
and distillation process, and consistently outperform baselines across various
LLMs. | [
0.0134814521,
0.0717703477,
-0.0029640244,
0.0081389723,
-0.0263962019,
0.0172901303,
0.0141350487,
0.0034717487,
0.0025582684,
-0.0194032043,
-0.0090480847,
-0.0245998483,
-0.0153219067,
0.046242021,
-0.0058220373,
-0.0161472503,
0.0198558234,
-0.0732414126,
0.000470733,
-0.0027405533,
-0.0148458304,
0.0012935046,
-0.0290191304,
0.0545634702,
0.0076149814,
0.0010600421,
-0.0413889922,
-0.0332746208,
0.0139139509,
-0.0163937751,
-0.0176363923,
0.0248053521,
0.0933618546,
0.0172605608,
0.0000019192,
-0.0540201329,
-0.0233378522,
-0.0270022769,
-0.0509466194,
-0.0501191579,
0.0132617904,
0.0176851768,
-0.0198318623,
0.0362228714,
-0.0578050017,
-0.0181707777,
0.0192725845,
-0.0029150429,
0.0335802175,
0.0542667545,
0.0120949028,
0.0033379437,
0.0167200416,
-0.0318392254,
0.0282810424,
-0.0398809984,
0.0274408199,
-0.0083890045,
0.014629215,
-0.0463888869,
-0.0306872446,
-0.0028303566,
0.0407684594,
-0.0041014687,
-0.0184927285,
0.0543567427,
-0.021689171,
-0.0297600962,
0.0025597711,
0.0917422846,
-0.0399565361,
0.014614366,
0.0230554827,
-0.0206985045,
0.0053754952,
0.0043653878,
-0.043355722,
0.0108322129,
0.0014150074,
0.0240471214,
-0.0378505774,
-0.0113743618,
0.0228393599,
0.0324970596,
-0.054111775,
0.0998032391,
-0.0482628159,
-0.021640541,
0.0494754463,
-0.0217673089,
-0.0131193604,
-0.045257587,
-0.0099998545,
0.0625493526,
-0.0756516829,
0.0209479965,
-0.0075299586,
0.0384132378,
-0.0228059795,
0.0132853081,
0.0561102442,
0.0285127778,
0.0111609818,
0.056529779,
-0.0065604988,
0.0683285892,
0.0162796807,
-0.007137063,
-0.0090832124,
0.0075736954,
-0.0897631645,
0.005190725,
-0.028336281,
0.0445413552,
-0.0529152863,
-0.0461957008,
0.0062606889,
0.0411478169,
-0.0340294763,
0.038790606,
0.0119289253,
0.0124611091,
-0.0358128622,
0.0026140106,
-0.0762922242,
0.0061520501,
0.0050073238,
0.0273824893,
0.0142853456,
-0.0567977354,
0.0070778076,
0.0021222788,
0.0005855206,
-0.0072502093,
0.0112471078,
0.0876731575,
-0.0322459191,
-0.0549437143,
-0.0040613264,
-0.0307574775,
0.027210515,
-0.0815017223,
-0.022171475,
-0.0603398383,
0.0350726917,
-0.0241984352,
-0.0182392858,
-0.0727287978,
0.0170409344,
-0.001045426,
0.0051130052,
0.0461988822,
0.0137197934,
0.0305829365,
-0.0019129815,
-0.0028467975,
0.0015227343,
0.0705648884,
0.0223364439,
0.0486571789,
0.0101195378,
0.0106225898,
0.0320795327,
0.0389332473,
0.0271129683,
0.0326346047,
-0.0492795743,
0.0268462021,
-0.0026064818,
0.0481770523,
0.0258406941,
0.0023961547,
-0.0717483535,
0.040874064,
0.077368468,
0.0354141779,
0.0280976146,
-0.0294464566,
0.0214197151,
0.0535280928,
0.000571811,
-0.0420039445,
-0.0509843491,
0.0259117447,
0.0302111022,
0.0097159753,
0.0023808593,
0.055522088,
-0.0209250133,
-0.0386332572,
0.0360589735,
2.681e-7,
0.0244281255,
0.0529323518,
0.0517717153,
-0.0005190948,
-0.0234441031,
0.0090184286,
0.0407752767,
-0.0033387698,
-0.0022075456,
-0.0721053481,
0.0289977361,
0.0985656157,
0.0718540698,
-0.0196978059,
-0.0405742042,
-0.0471641235,
0.0179144982,
0.0256075449,
-0.0093967551,
-0.0475227162,
0.0308748763,
-0.0265413541,
-0.0674864277,
0.0096389521,
-0.0097076409,
0.0189856775,
0.0637162179,
0.0101845209,
-0.0147670805,
-0.0100542996,
-0.0112136584,
0.0245598108,
-0.0595063195,
-0.0500768758,
0.0052854703,
0.0098952483,
0.0463186018,
-0.0288881175,
-0.0177956596,
-0.0262529254,
0.0142132146,
-0.0129729286,
-0.0167265702,
0.0085474942,
-0.0180701986,
-0.0155425388,
0.0250820331,
0.0161665976,
0.0035412568,
0.0142178787,
-0.0299989097,
-0.03805672,
-0.0280828606,
-0.0063954913,
0.0455051959,
-0.0216913223,
-0.0041219583,
-0.0082529895,
0.0033990457,
-0.0093091903,
0.0450741202,
-0.0493483916,
-0.0047499328,
0.0184196159,
0.0173149668,
-0.0274879113,
-0.0408654511,
0.0054170499,
0.0303378738,
0.0036838278,
0.0232718755,
0.0151953436,
0.0365377888,
-0.0150700919,
-0.0254416503,
-0.0378127284,
0.0142593114,
-0.0186644401,
0.0067415857,
0.0015088501,
-0.018604083,
-0.0101127392,
-0.0337019451,
-0.0024438892,
0.0304862782,
0.0073176762,
0.0160447732,
0.009655863,
0.0679645911,
-0.0523641184,
-0.0081104133,
0.002591837,
0.0195069406,
0.0054093162,
-0.0344909355,
0.0214489494,
-0.0452785902,
-0.0030197066,
-0.0435880348,
0.0555005707,
-0.0391856618,
-0.0168463942,
0.0338576399,
-0.0293488614,
0.0091523901,
0.075818494,
-0.0096419938,
0.0529680178,
0.0662899986,
-0.0217291899,
-0.0673295408,
0.0344733484,
-0.0455136746,
0.0063836826,
-0.0737840459,
0.0313827246,
-0.011871689,
0.044657737,
-0.0465754382,
0.0218127035,
-0.0373356529,
-0.00204983,
0.015137868,
-0.0619720183,
-0.0659843907,
0.0066358177,
-0.0396186039,
0.008510734,
-0.0140439169,
-0.0710805878,
0.0749230236,
0.0281704981,
-0.0109486524,
-0.016150441,
-0.0478608832,
-0.0031602145,
0.0786074176,
-0.0036203747,
-0.0029677758,
-0.0530402549,
-0.0274693593,
-0.0431046933,
-0.0498895533,
0.0103039751,
-0.0232794527,
0.0265191048,
-0.0903705135,
0.0071308799,
0.008818022,
-0.0678106546,
-0.0358984172,
-0.017672129,
-0.027235698,
0.015629217,
-0.0151992608,
-0.0482313558,
-0.0520587415,
-0.0020419795,
0.052476909,
0.0584136769,
-0.0149196899,
-0.0107571222,
-0.0486327223,
-0.0177251212,
0.0605553798,
0.0255919471,
-0.0168048684,
-0.0399220288,
0.0382452309,
0.0458803102,
0.0501110479,
-0.0623885356,
-0.012505874,
0.0181477908,
0.0126184123,
-0.0151672624,
-0.0007104103,
0.0812712386,
0.002853334,
-0.0747999772,
-0.0222123265,
0.0705759451,
-0.0028599426,
-0.0484343506,
0.0039048963,
0.0159062687,
0.0030393563,
0.0136662303,
0.0396644175,
-0.0543052517,
-0.0437860787,
0.0179451648,
0.0269259997,
0.0025855091,
-0.0492600501,
-0.0151997525,
-0.1238171235,
0.0314853825,
-0.0012916782,
-0.0418050736,
0.0104203708,
-0.0337333716,
0.0099257603,
-0.0415474474,
0.0079932027,
0.0235017817,
0.001782205,
-0.0174774937,
0.0061315154,
0.0051522953,
-0.0763108879,
0.0377353989,
-0.0046658353,
0.0291600805,
0.0262506958,
0.0253150109,
0.0164326094,
-0.0451192968,
0.0396941975,
0.0069928565,
0.0378026217,
-0.008774505,
0.0196950939,
-0.0093603292,
0.0069357036,
-0.0099531244,
0.0618582107,
-0.0059508984,
-0.0402394384,
-0.003394719,
0.0873375833,
-0.0543324314,
-0.009613107,
0.0107148262,
-0.0292774811,
0.0668212324,
0.0463157371,
-0.0291072167,
-0.0678062215,
-0.0777922124,
0.0055160606,
-0.0629743561,
0.0025387248,
-0.0209511127,
-0.0249321666,
-0.0086800791,
-0.0129675157,
-0.0274575874,
-0.0328740105,
0.0508989729,
0.078444086,
-0.0139426254,
-0.0058593028,
0.0030720737,
0.0604111142,
-0.0085332375,
0.0109900879,
-0.0280330628,
0.0441061035,
-0.0439686179,
0.0088031171,
0.0398477986,
-0.0299357511,
-0.0176377203,
0.0095409043,
-0.0643871948,
-0.0505826585,
0.0046754694,
0.0404874422,
0.0363892838,
0.0735713765,
-0.0043582073,
-0.0579591393,
0.0753230453,
0.0402491651,
-0.0251088329,
0.0036431362,
0.0134333028,
0.0202643648,
0.0146000274,
0.0498008318,
-0.0297812875,
-0.0052975593,
0.0195620172,
0.0213700421,
-0.0464188531,
-0.0109874709,
0.0076225884,
-0.0464493893,
0.0320612453,
0.0005220642,
-0.0280515272,
-0.0370572619,
0.0386810824,
0.036582496,
0.0046282788,
-0.0565979816,
0.0168847814,
0.0317960754,
-0.0017624778,
0.0610915758,
0.0363854803,
0.0157596897,
-0.0112117901,
-0.032701809,
-0.0077040703,
0.0154164443,
0.0100033553,
0.0709565133,
0.0088316193,
0.0173916481,
0.0200774614,
0.0065777376,
0.0313544236,
0.0075755566,
0.0519820154,
0.0311946031,
-0.0095286118,
-0.0293192863,
0.0288007092,
-0.0557963364,
-0.0511378348,
-0.0301256198,
0.0200674683,
0.0437480249,
0.042673517,
0.0163694769,
-0.0567595363,
-0.0004285549,
0.0004198375,
-0.0014777245,
-0.0468679629,
-0.0379854478,
0.0202163924,
0.0482039303,
-0.0196729749,
0.0235126577,
0.0994979665,
0.0419401228,
0.0422627144,
-0.0015193886,
0.0251646377,
-0.0490672626,
-0.0424357094,
0.0379554555,
0.0439690463,
-0.0322894529,
-0.0035609575,
-0.0303561129,
-0.0415793993,
-0.0537984632,
0.0264670998,
-0.0459247157,
-0.0439699106,
0.0526082963,
0.0316780321,
-0.0116994288,
-0.0252432879,
-0.047806982,
-0.0234665144,
0.017744042,
-0.0147088729,
0.0063612335,
-5.753194451e-33,
0.0262037311,
-0.0226095822,
0.0765173659,
-0.010482993,
-0.0386892855,
-0.015601919,
-0.0126642855,
-0.0067838607,
-0.0001588796,
0.0242798515,
-0.015502532,
0.0328060016,
0.0172519516,
0.0025404436,
0.0034452968,
-0.0039495835,
0.0429683812,
-0.0163192898,
-0.0423173644,
0.0539556071,
0.0476034097,
0.0223867595,
0.0120486179,
-0.0351965539,
-0.0127103161,
0.0030247837,
-0.0333500132,
0.0568195805,
-0.011366969,
0.0559861884,
-0.0062286719,
-0.0020016818,
0.0069579785,
-0.0692525655,
-0.0473181196,
0.0112406667,
-0.0482616462,
-0.0143203195,
-0.0145867132,
-0.0183026157,
-0.0375616923,
0.0017211906,
0.0190315135,
0.0061402121,
-0.0208807196,
0.0157014392,
0.0001695576,
-0.0395211354,
-0.0511053987,
0.0008145934,
-0.0061936337,
0.0170315169,
-0.0101201516,
-0.0440042242,
0.0460879356,
0.0124236988,
-0.0093663828,
-0.019631274,
-0.0483584106,
0.0378722958,
-0.0066210353,
0.0013714168,
0.0605997406,
0.0020264501,
0.0469271615,
0.0488267504,
0.0179635584,
0.0011109096,
0.0112625482,
-0.0239123348,
0.0324842557,
0.0928368419,
-0.0324560702,
0.051429417,
0.0287448652,
-0.0005205881,
-0.0400821306,
0.0213805009,
0.0245359391,
0.0503708795,
0.0235537328,
0.0077083912,
-0.0228333604,
-0.0279195216,
-0.0198652893,
0.0246217493,
0.0014962521,
-0.0201048795,
0.0596484393,
0.0646601766,
-0.0019332534,
-0.0433060564,
0.0567093678,
-0.0378268845,
-0.017286418,
0.0482381843,
-0.0195994228,
0.0250978693,
0.0242779236,
-0.0205832142,
-0.0993668586,
-0.0882103369,
0.0019178835,
-0.0139911259,
0.0003183215,
0.0033179377,
-0.0061220108,
0.0656127334,
-0.0538780987,
0.0004821376,
-0.037610393,
0.0468129478,
0.0510823503,
0.0203653723,
0.0684347674,
-0.0300105512,
-0.0122881765,
0.0371822454,
0.0052662552,
-0.0596564338,
0.0142667135,
-0.0003490313,
-0.0153290024,
-0.003929833,
-0.0155713139,
0.000523378,
-0.0668834373,
-0.0057887458,
0.0267920885,
-0.0285565928,
0.0117120519,
0.0528128929,
2.701e-7,
-0.0591046773,
0.0282137617,
-0.0077509126,
-0.008128915,
0.0535618477,
0.0182960611,
-0.0283821691,
0.018754188,
-0.0129546532,
-0.0149186235,
0.0440294035,
0.0595136881,
0.0563690588,
0.0188106094,
-0.0727747604,
0.0011065149,
-0.0330443569,
-0.0279414095,
-0.0825792402,
-0.0562297255,
-0.0421912,
0.0660276264,
0.0160305016,
-0.0157262348,
0.0607954934,
-0.0342136957,
0.0274640378,
-0.0262835119,
0.0182543509,
-0.0047301427,
0.0009242388,
0.0160366092,
-0.0151594663,
0.0263443738,
-0.0107278368,
0.0524583496,
-0.0570785552,
0.0857650712,
0.0328267179,
-0.015369907,
-0.0121819815,
-0.0318279304,
0.0178987924,
-0.0261325501,
0.0824361816,
-0.0629140809,
-0.0057592215,
0.0002106321,
0.0254250262,
-0.0642863661,
-0.0112454537,
-0.0078062648,
0.0033114848,
0.0065203118,
-0.0000649446,
0.0078073903,
0.0027968222,
-0.0617728382,
0.0107607013,
0.0183489136,
-0.0526055954,
-0.086175248,
-0.0406324416,
-0.0021527212,
0.0132599389,
-0.0231188796,
0.0000266832,
2.349859814e-34,
0.0080260718,
0.0193107482,
0.007533526,
0.0200316664,
0.0070168953,
0.0013944613,
-0.0108706802,
0.0134730646,
0.048215352,
-0.0758114755,
-0.0185780264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14393v1 | Merging Generated and Retrieved Knowledge for Open-Domain QA | 2023-10-22T19:37:06 | 2023-10-22T19:37:06 | Yunxiang Zhang, Muhammad Khalifa, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Honglak Lee, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open-domain question answering (QA) systems are often built with retrieval
modules. However, retrieving passages from a given source is known to suffer
from insufficient knowledge coverage. Alternatively, prompting large language
models (LLMs) to generate contextual passages based on their parametric
knowledge has been shown to improve QA performance. Yet, LLMs tend to
"hallucinate" content that conflicts with the retrieved knowledge. Based on the
intuition that answers supported by both sources are more likely to be correct,
we propose COMBO, a Compatibility-Oriented knowledge Merging for Better
Open-domain QA framework, to effectively leverage the two sources of
information. Concretely, we match LLM-generated passages with retrieved
counterparts into compatible pairs, based on discriminators trained with silver
compatibility labels. Then a Fusion-in-Decoder-based reader model handles
passage pairs to arrive at the final answer. Experiments show that COMBO
outperforms competitive baselines on three out of four tested open-domain QA
benchmarks. Further analysis reveals that our proposed framework demonstrates
greater efficacy in scenarios with a higher degree of knowledge conflicts. | [
0.0166118219,
0.0265281163,
0.0027344786,
0.0490916185,
-0.035312891,
0.0167750549,
-0.0123516703,
-0.0135690188,
0.0177919678,
-0.0567187518,
0.0006318217,
0.0065031191,
-0.012006944,
0.0078264,
-0.0304653514,
0.0053359396,
0.0570195355,
-0.0152367977,
-0.034301918,
0.0029670065,
-0.0125197265,
0.0529492088,
-0.0064905398,
0.0138639119,
0.0371870957,
-0.038648583,
0.0031373433,
-0.0234062057,
0.037313249,
0.0167855881,
0.0293745846,
0.0209043175,
0.0127348974,
0.0413311943,
0.0000017658,
-0.0530630089,
-0.036572475,
0.0105474098,
-0.0390034094,
0.0019401907,
-0.007614465,
-0.0038370823,
0.0286758523,
0.0300199296,
-0.0506605878,
-0.011895475,
0.0012626513,
0.0439434573,
0.0649897307,
0.0369435735,
0.0203424804,
-0.0218931437,
0.0457140058,
0.0047385534,
0.0136460178,
-0.071119234,
0.0512758866,
0.0290190708,
0.0513676405,
0.0218790323,
-0.002308093,
0.0350515842,
0.0036815971,
0.0067969817,
0.009820139,
0.0083458414,
-0.0220186114,
0.0227106381,
-0.0140451137,
0.091716893,
0.0370188542,
-0.0167149995,
-0.0107158246,
-0.0053410903,
-0.0074285669,
0.0355279036,
-0.021942541,
-0.0136125507,
-0.0544263013,
0.0095875086,
-0.0129043525,
0.0136149386,
0.013925869,
0.0132020703,
-0.026016308,
0.0621596277,
0.0231232736,
-0.0298683736,
-0.0065579913,
0.0122561352,
-0.0263937786,
-0.0532950088,
-0.0042280639,
0.0772209391,
0.0015127056,
0.0308210328,
-0.0580191091,
-0.0642966181,
0.036191117,
-0.0154268444,
-0.011369816,
0.0434714183,
-0.0304623861,
0.0675934255,
-0.0300722439,
0.0537726656,
-0.0301354323,
0.0005977881,
-0.0701124668,
-0.0444474593,
-0.0472158194,
-0.0196693577,
-0.0011398587,
0.0305974204,
-0.0690436661,
-0.0090298289,
-0.0101795113,
0.0203512534,
-0.0018288236,
-0.0104333507,
0.0037231867,
0.0109145343,
0.0099315373,
-0.0093599278,
-0.072497569,
0.0565926656,
-0.0323136859,
0.024590224,
-0.0165819414,
-0.0634502023,
-0.0025493517,
-0.0182715021,
0.0001988228,
-0.0325564742,
-0.0148094967,
0.0459798388,
-0.0387510955,
0.0017418066,
-0.0399415344,
-0.0271761715,
0.0051734662,
-0.0260415301,
-0.0295024831,
-0.0574310794,
0.0746988729,
0.0286499206,
-0.0319251269,
-0.0347244628,
0.0041784984,
0.059034396,
-0.040408846,
0.0632465109,
-0.0391673781,
-0.0169810522,
0.0619741604,
0.0347774476,
0.0012456777,
0.0649540946,
-0.0120024998,
-0.0403589346,
0.0253343247,
0.0221724138,
0.000998335,
-0.0189557746,
0.0201872084,
0.0121276053,
0.039336279,
0.057829652,
0.0893849134,
-0.003347327,
0.0221414678,
0.0464937352,
-0.0342469215,
-0.0568160303,
0.0085967388,
-0.0033495778,
0.0321643054,
0.0202994756,
0.0171676595,
0.0101577584,
0.0301207416,
0.0339655168,
0.0266584903,
0.0096518649,
-0.0480077676,
0.0044061304,
0.0521254018,
0.0640282333,
-0.0295357127,
-0.0304868929,
-0.0234073382,
-0.0034175299,
-0.008736264,
0.0231386945,
0.0293311607,
0.0196893923,
-0.0563764572,
0.0464358442,
0.0208592899,
-0.0265614614,
0.0175605062,
-0.0257964153,
0.0608482957,
0.0433827862,
0.0562847219,
-0.0358851478,
-0.0262613427,
0.0094263591,
-0.0190385934,
0.010831832,
0.0352929085,
-0.0270593204,
-0.0111093316,
-0.0519111678,
-0.0314697698,
-0.0347708315,
-0.0248440243,
0.0329726525,
0.0417319015,
0.0451820455,
0.0324378647,
-0.0269371159,
0.0003886182,
0.0403935686,
-0.035349004,
-0.0357968286,
0.0070952354,
-0.0052669616,
0.0095902532,
0.0200596452,
0.0165265352,
0.0232120287,
0.0206736606,
-0.0291259605,
-0.0588179678,
0.0206883736,
-0.0481912196,
-0.0381828845,
0.0506842695,
0.0174793899,
-0.0247277301,
0.0053702197,
-0.041311238,
-0.0381811894,
0.0058912672,
-0.0128925247,
0.0203139,
-0.0465810299,
-0.0174728427,
0.0340956487,
-0.0008384304,
-0.0496291071,
0.0958781615,
0.0272785388,
0.0233506691,
0.0318138637,
-0.0125497682,
0.0302324537,
0.0142686255,
-0.0093584387,
-0.017365098,
-0.0295676291,
0.0408556536,
0.0013620998,
-0.0413816497,
-0.0725676417,
-0.0341500118,
-0.0831312537,
0.0314187817,
0.0099274991,
0.0308433045,
0.0264020283,
-0.0066855047,
0.0111971637,
0.0018724793,
-0.0254244339,
0.0004044903,
0.0218763407,
0.0295399055,
0.0118508786,
0.0751344264,
0.0160872545,
-0.028063044,
0.0213718228,
-0.0355888717,
0.0645952076,
0.0060695969,
0.0421959125,
-0.0794739202,
0.0423940904,
-0.0482613035,
0.0609043352,
-0.0198057331,
0.013517783,
-0.0049843392,
-0.0197655186,
0.0197445899,
0.0423907414,
0.016590992,
-0.0484504327,
0.0608150437,
-0.0384912379,
-0.0558263175,
0.0410309806,
0.0026177813,
-0.0570460893,
-0.0274077877,
-0.010665819,
0.0058023813,
0.0400572307,
-0.005631703,
-0.030129794,
-0.0553051382,
-0.0034948383,
-0.016788939,
-0.0086019868,
-0.0557912923,
-0.0412310511,
-0.0129213389,
0.0582036786,
-0.0327312164,
0.0056093521,
0.0675683394,
-0.0229170192,
0.0129334852,
-0.0769687593,
0.0354006365,
-0.0933066905,
0.0165017322,
-0.0677701235,
0.0062256814,
0.0027077962,
-0.0160444211,
-0.0470838286,
-0.0095817558,
0.01011799,
-0.0560412779,
0.057047762,
-0.0758558139,
0.0380018242,
-0.0255162716,
-0.0541142672,
-0.0796902552,
-0.0303241201,
-0.0155365653,
-0.0015897591,
-0.0252629593,
-0.0028188413,
-0.0297572464,
-0.0093890894,
0.009080342,
0.0071389391,
-0.0048016296,
-0.0179894716,
-0.0175109599,
0.0655070096,
0.0511778444,
0.0492080972,
0.000712676,
-0.010146793,
0.0076055457,
0.0618526824,
0.0039518294,
-0.0087780096,
0.0125599857,
-0.033576861,
0.0480980054,
-0.0441626906,
-0.0049071191,
0.0067064376,
0.0179811269,
-0.0348086841,
0.0115616927,
0.0919569209,
0.0495749526,
-0.0039802673,
-0.0726962462,
-0.0689710602,
-0.0067917742,
0.0021753134,
0.0476522557,
-0.1169288158,
-0.0303622689,
-0.0112616578,
0.0319850519,
0.011956553,
-0.0088686813,
-0.0175220557,
-0.1489433348,
-0.0109181032,
0.0043212874,
-0.0473484211,
-0.039740447,
-0.0135670137,
0.0126731172,
0.0215876363,
-0.0151777575,
0.0353012346,
-0.0237700641,
-0.0071874992,
0.0060609737,
0.0497474819,
-0.0160404816,
0.0227710307,
-0.0233036783,
-0.0062031639,
0.0713978559,
0.0319309123,
0.0388810188,
-0.0528137349,
-0.0245227143,
-0.1101738811,
-0.0014973299,
0.0111766253,
0.0169173777,
-0.0054384372,
0.019219812,
-0.0074062557,
0.0211127773,
-0.0305567551,
-0.0196467806,
0.0109809646,
0.0733670741,
0.0251997486,
0.0046646674,
-0.024495393,
0.0250875913,
0.0100981565,
0.0705042332,
-0.0021669364,
0.0126479929,
-0.0280325785,
-0.0028507218,
-0.0016400756,
-0.0255902316,
-0.0086447094,
0.0537983663,
0.0152645074,
-0.0012317104,
-0.0918794572,
-0.0313899852,
0.0202875249,
0.0066703004,
0.008455378,
0.0452452302,
-0.0201152228,
0.0157326628,
-0.0448914841,
0.0312103964,
-0.0529066883,
0.0051335036,
-0.0388638973,
0.0187572576,
0.0166742597,
-0.0405735336,
-0.0320778787,
0.0395679139,
-0.0608586892,
-0.0598046333,
-0.0176411644,
0.0055659744,
0.017904887,
0.0283837374,
-0.0376412794,
-0.003285672,
0.005593156,
0.0496608093,
-0.0306598824,
0.0488359183,
0.0084964857,
0.0088272514,
-0.0216471907,
-0.0014477649,
-0.0782537535,
-0.0264900159,
-0.0119702797,
-0.0034037386,
-0.0182924457,
-0.0598321259,
0.0305341315,
-0.014810008,
-0.0184694584,
0.0286269467,
0.0034828652,
-0.0072745681,
0.0466256291,
-0.0003273409,
-0.008441207,
-0.0033451922,
-0.0039429753,
0.023990199,
-0.0515350662,
0.0086933011,
0.0754722804,
0.0148921581,
0.0614882149,
-0.024618594,
-0.0174959134,
0.0650067255,
0.0159615744,
0.0203276873,
-0.0226287358,
-0.0395176709,
-0.0197375398,
-0.0001788724,
0.0649032667,
-0.0141676627,
0.0727464184,
0.0042623011,
0.0136821205,
0.0249528084,
0.0045048869,
-0.1002214551,
-0.0555540621,
-0.0126070334,
-0.0075895758,
0.0123551888,
0.0043856758,
0.0422730073,
-0.0100654783,
-0.0344444029,
-0.0196269788,
-0.0393527895,
-0.0087617654,
0.005288905,
0.0682517141,
0.0390079916,
0.00361936,
-0.0017222478,
0.0875150114,
-0.0478727408,
0.0559273101,
-0.0238643996,
0.0108518731,
-0.013770368,
-0.0366513729,
-0.0054235114,
0.016865069,
-0.0114803091,
-0.0194074754,
-0.0615648888,
-0.0370263048,
0.048131641,
0.0052223089,
-0.0130026443,
0.0232370887,
0.0246120002,
0.0500850193,
0.0063592428,
-0.0350821689,
-0.0199262351,
0.0336468183,
-0.0484636873,
-0.0195970032,
-0.0186018553,
-6.131518491e-33,
-0.0486044437,
-0.019341046,
0.0288091563,
-0.0359618589,
-0.0204166826,
0.0192687958,
0.0164445415,
-0.0304476321,
-0.0398917124,
-0.0232946314,
-0.0033433642,
0.0222652834,
-0.0002152659,
0.0103920931,
-0.0263567772,
-0.0396921113,
0.034589991,
0.0077248444,
-0.02036855,
0.0042248578,
0.0821347609,
0.0167971421,
-0.0183151495,
-0.0520258509,
0.0333291963,
-0.0421071053,
0.0132776657,
0.0082335779,
-0.0053132633,
0.0557626933,
-0.0320265293,
0.0359101631,
0.0328148529,
-0.0133576961,
0.0154089564,
0.0533333682,
-0.0838291943,
-0.0116784517,
0.0465620197,
-0.0196357556,
-0.0248180572,
-0.0562365428,
0.0042148521,
0.0112931971,
0.0439165086,
-0.0386875942,
0.0319196917,
-0.0387336314,
0.0315635875,
-0.0340434536,
-0.0505740419,
0.0113751534,
0.0015047938,
-0.0176630784,
-0.0109424125,
0.0461692736,
0.0601489358,
0.0462539606,
-0.0370053537,
0.009787065,
0.010452034,
0.0366993733,
0.0423365273,
-0.0039291801,
-0.0266999993,
0.0414400138,
-0.0644377768,
-0.0370743051,
-0.030551482,
-0.0336847454,
-0.0369190164,
0.0279711746,
0.0509711616,
0.0840546638,
0.0125918211,
0.017678896,
-0.0553935319,
0.0681772158,
-0.0036859666,
0.0051129702,
-0.0278342236,
0.0037245902,
-0.0014734676,
0.0132415425,
-0.0536087006,
0.0491602458,
-0.064631626,
-0.0096377051,
0.0425277501,
0.0135448249,
-0.0298837982,
-0.0200870074,
0.0071314373,
-0.0480411425,
0.0173752457,
0.0590222441,
-0.0252107587,
0.0222822316,
-0.0141555071,
0.0264626481,
-0.0500077568,
-0.0121403597,
0.0520879962,
-0.0160030052,
-0.0026788893,
0.0102577284,
-0.0155542064,
-0.0391652696,
-0.0623431355,
0.0284353811,
-0.0299173836,
0.0367755033,
-0.0106063988,
-0.0161815174,
0.0313962251,
0.0723124892,
0.0120690968,
0.0194877964,
-0.0039610351,
0.0215734299,
-0.0325946137,
-0.0177738946,
0.0036766473,
0.0067318021,
0.0112909321,
0.0126079964,
0.0256911386,
0.03467663,
-0.0273528323,
-0.0288474485,
0.007225364,
0.0598327592,
2.602e-7,
0.059685871,
-0.0327627324,
0.0289216749,
0.0386700407,
0.0016344473,
0.0353141613,
0.0100436676,
0.0228462163,
0.0408057123,
-0.0284816865,
-0.0196736362,
0.0113361385,
0.0399975888,
0.0577334166,
-0.0879927278,
-0.0047010635,
-0.0121061727,
-0.0583639741,
-0.0598044693,
-0.0453286432,
0.0869101211,
0.046279788,
-0.0020480114,
-0.0051407819,
-0.0235188659,
-0.0444049314,
0.0865513235,
0.0133028133,
-0.0113809211,
0.0381741449,
0.0265463535,
-0.0066112205,
0.0167718995,
0.0493747927,
-0.0135243936,
0.0213676598,
0.0137222996,
0.0355486348,
0.0404962078,
-0.0794272795,
-0.035706725,
-0.0124757653,
-0.0101494351,
-0.0430726707,
0.0967513248,
-0.0264776256,
0.0001782068,
0.0112933638,
-0.0470225811,
-0.0178982317,
0.0032286528,
0.0093863299,
0.0118457815,
0.0182866976,
-0.0069820746,
-0.0001267212,
0.0103514669,
-0.0810779482,
0.0114022261,
0.0205692574,
-0.0415777341,
-0.0483126752,
-0.0173677821,
-0.015247466,
0.0265038647,
-0.073084563,
0.0322100297,
2.112945126e-34,
0.003822773,
0.005744149,
0.024116084,
0.0194239132,
0.016152652,
-0.0036648524,
-0.0180389471,
0.021722151,
0.0198826678,
-0.0805814266,
0.0291860029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14389v1 | Evaluating Subjective Cognitive Appraisals of Emotions from Large Language Models | 2023-10-22T19:12:17 | 2023-10-22T19:12:17 | Hongli Zhan, Desmond C. Ong, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emotions we experience involve complex processes; besides physiological
aspects, research in psychology has studied cognitive appraisals where people
assess their situations subjectively, according to their own values (Scherer,
2005). Thus, the same situation can often result in different emotional
experiences. While the detection of emotion is a well-established task, there
is very limited work so far on the automatic prediction of cognitive
appraisals. This work fills the gap by presenting CovidET-Appraisals, the most
comprehensive dataset to-date that assesses 24 appraisal dimensions, each with
a natural language rationale, across 241 Reddit posts. CovidET-Appraisals
presents an ideal testbed to evaluate the ability of large language models --
excelling at a wide range of NLP tasks -- to automatically assess and explain
cognitive appraisals. We found that while the best models are performant,
open-sourced LLMs fall short at this task, presenting a new challenge in the
future development of emotionally intelligent models. We release our dataset at
https://github.com/honglizhan/CovidET-Appraisals-Public. | [
0.0240684096,
0.1094675809,
0.0111039225,
0.0409709774,
-0.0016032979,
0.0264573861,
-0.0168353599,
-0.0237597656,
0.0482541919,
-0.0491351187,
-0.0860012546,
-0.0068293037,
-0.0181309171,
0.0114100361,
0.0012532119,
-0.0320817977,
0.0111358594,
0.0549828932,
0.0739581436,
0.0029584588,
0.0336466394,
0.0482425727,
-0.0140811382,
0.0290315393,
-0.0090929065,
-0.0644193515,
0.0279686544,
0.0151593843,
0.0328297205,
-0.0348553546,
0.0361753441,
0.0504812784,
-0.0100218868,
-0.0018725697,
0.000001703,
-0.002274577,
0.0195289254,
-0.043768499,
0.0303265918,
-0.0072262464,
0.137296319,
0.0067925728,
-0.0067348941,
0.0096173016,
-0.0254136436,
-0.0072226766,
0.0223769601,
0.047490634,
0.0905227959,
0.053227514,
-0.0112426067,
-0.0246756524,
-0.0517668724,
0.0016661704,
0.0076803416,
-0.0105713382,
0.0154049601,
-0.0050680791,
-0.0143687837,
-0.0319162644,
0.0056766416,
-0.0070330934,
-0.0248613097,
-0.0123092178,
-0.0173601843,
-0.004281431,
-0.0271678604,
-0.0258248933,
-0.0048111347,
0.0920906812,
0.0061439895,
-0.0008410105,
-0.0228221025,
-0.003946003,
0.0204645265,
-0.033499673,
-0.0333293229,
0.0241179932,
-0.0060623321,
0.0440514088,
0.0013640657,
0.0449792519,
0.0341161788,
0.0501585007,
0.0204130206,
0.0615672991,
-0.0330387764,
-0.0246592984,
0.0377250984,
0.0399955995,
-0.0396597572,
0.0079651373,
-0.0034323267,
-0.0027979284,
0.0205391459,
0.0116087915,
-0.0211130437,
-0.0032289263,
0.0050473423,
-0.0667337775,
0.0164033473,
0.0091060009,
-0.0354025327,
0.0422789715,
0.0120436614,
0.0375223346,
-0.0021594006,
-0.0307218488,
-0.011161386,
0.0030464896,
-0.0565845668,
0.0336432569,
0.021382967,
0.0383076295,
0.0018872707,
0.0036314947,
-0.0810707957,
-0.004441788,
-0.0515429676,
-0.0100317067,
0.0096694427,
0.0179082863,
0.0212535076,
0.0187884402,
-0.0558622405,
0.0160039626,
-0.0365091786,
0.0119142225,
-0.0126428036,
-0.0303719714,
0.013090645,
0.0153663214,
0.0297561325,
-0.0259117745,
0.0160878226,
0.0332287215,
0.0586735643,
-0.0215746555,
-0.0356829986,
-0.0228864495,
-0.0262991954,
-0.0355259031,
-0.0341513529,
-0.0364423022,
0.0496250354,
0.0165560134,
0.0109389564,
-0.0435041897,
0.0284107514,
0.0332144909,
-0.0431197472,
0.0481001176,
-0.0469967499,
-0.0111756055,
-0.0426027812,
0.0115979435,
-0.0102434736,
0.0287693981,
0.0024840962,
0.0474120602,
0.0637216866,
0.012745888,
0.044975061,
0.0026419926,
-0.0214199107,
-0.0420503281,
-0.0250132401,
0.0140522989,
-0.0383358411,
0.0386851467,
0.0412265286,
0.0181436725,
-0.0013702648,
-0.0190615207,
0.0322233625,
0.0571725257,
-0.0356408954,
0.0357974693,
0.0071891122,
0.0303783547,
0.0349226221,
-0.0332718715,
-0.0259802006,
0.0433749855,
-0.0256492421,
-0.0465161763,
-0.0034537434,
-0.0039908062,
-0.0161701236,
-0.0701748133,
-0.0415355638,
-0.0510379262,
0.0051574754,
-0.0071049375,
0.0026008373,
-0.030573383,
-0.0346639901,
-0.0063677225,
0.0498544909,
-0.1052430645,
0.0084256427,
-0.0418337807,
0.0283949133,
0.0935198367,
0.0148758627,
-0.045351807,
0.0039687944,
-0.0056673335,
-0.0189985018,
0.0226436164,
0.0557838567,
-0.0051368019,
0.0074202353,
-0.0412513353,
0.0089205028,
-0.0539070442,
0.0173612442,
-0.0191502273,
-0.0080250613,
0.0212033596,
-0.0293364972,
-0.0083274152,
-0.0129667185,
0.0020208859,
0.0330866463,
-0.0158443302,
0.0068512331,
0.0011971374,
0.0084369266,
0.0288299173,
0.0129561732,
0.0135790175,
0.0148358466,
-0.0015536374,
-0.0496314093,
0.020252414,
-0.0094598662,
-0.0393027365,
0.0088143488,
0.0081973746,
-0.0126739424,
0.0296577644,
-0.0435101986,
0.0091815153,
0.0512124151,
0.004261171,
0.0215311516,
0.0155479247,
-0.0037201466,
-0.0106872963,
0.0327788964,
-0.0011908317,
0.065236859,
-0.0063933306,
0.0249421466,
-0.0072162501,
-0.0316414349,
-0.0130135547,
-0.0120800734,
-0.0501398332,
-0.0130007034,
0.0137690799,
0.0073686377,
0.0287189949,
-0.0093951197,
-0.0539575219,
-0.0406443737,
-0.0893941745,
-0.0181371123,
-0.0036584525,
0.0438184477,
0.0290089995,
-0.0311570577,
0.0052625532,
0.0221732799,
-0.0552729405,
0.0159902815,
0.0115374103,
0.0126245301,
0.0413271561,
-0.0377283655,
0.0441082567,
-0.0941852629,
-0.0134226093,
-0.0194324311,
0.0366303474,
0.0071495594,
0.0067916503,
-0.0110152913,
0.021848416,
-0.0765730068,
0.0139518976,
-0.0032868732,
-0.0554027148,
0.0120395375,
0.0140730208,
0.0161024611,
0.0654113367,
-0.006891198,
0.0789656788,
0.0028323221,
0.0247493461,
-0.0530205853,
0.0048309253,
-0.0339586958,
0.0018652794,
-0.0304220971,
-0.0309677646,
-0.0146401357,
0.0639617369,
0.011894715,
0.0065939804,
-0.045404505,
0.0390117019,
-0.0332225673,
-0.0142363217,
-0.0373040512,
-0.0192195512,
0.0157633778,
0.024749076,
-0.0073692552,
-0.0232347716,
0.0453264974,
0.0267372895,
-0.0075435573,
-0.0456660613,
-0.0161024667,
-0.0655999631,
0.0640124381,
-0.0382977203,
-0.0055455901,
-0.01611978,
0.0392768905,
0.015224793,
-0.0387848318,
-0.0399137773,
-0.0505395532,
0.0023470249,
-0.0226026364,
-0.028252095,
0.0288318247,
-0.0561456643,
-0.0242054183,
-0.0680354759,
-0.0607967451,
-0.0209299158,
-0.0081902854,
-0.0165074971,
-0.0186876804,
-0.0403485894,
0.0088047497,
-0.0743550435,
-0.0181046724,
-0.0362179056,
0.0184891578,
0.0218883902,
0.0748664141,
0.0049188999,
0.0859348774,
0.0080619669,
0.0281722546,
0.0685290024,
0.0147745842,
0.0246377811,
-0.0171544496,
0.0097430227,
0.0093392599,
0.0193650089,
0.0134720122,
-0.0417729765,
0.0409469195,
-0.0197536666,
0.018004002,
0.1332623512,
0.0221594889,
-0.0754769519,
0.0373675674,
-0.0233609471,
-0.0287828166,
0.0495156534,
0.0096286451,
-0.0567971244,
-0.0423409306,
-0.0392239168,
0.0230522528,
0.0051867981,
-0.0360951275,
0.0018319621,
-0.1107012555,
0.0098145623,
-0.0258500334,
0.0407826044,
-0.0091760084,
-0.0334537998,
0.0116078528,
-0.0511448607,
-0.0160678215,
-0.0397552773,
-0.0061642006,
0.0079395818,
-0.0014600257,
-0.0175423827,
-0.0302559473,
0.0867185518,
-0.0078892643,
0.0373193845,
0.0341021605,
0.0985720679,
-0.0069088633,
-0.0420037583,
0.0332243405,
-0.0168174151,
-0.0146647133,
0.0073656105,
0.0397628732,
-0.0231976658,
-0.013592124,
-0.0518654063,
0.0174996555,
-0.0799400881,
-0.0136252344,
-0.014437017,
0.0552605167,
-0.0170386545,
-0.0387701876,
-0.0295651592,
0.0400292948,
0.0173760019,
0.0955355093,
0.0113706216,
-0.0587618761,
-0.0020186685,
-0.0177999102,
0.00339442,
-0.0079839509,
-0.0563914739,
-0.0211314373,
0.0438131727,
0.0381571576,
-0.0715793297,
-0.0653645471,
-0.0040106629,
-0.0218509957,
-0.0324570946,
-0.0466006845,
-0.010571572,
0.0032950388,
-0.0367658958,
0.0924621448,
0.0110819973,
0.0118381782,
-0.0163387544,
-0.0018049106,
0.0444279835,
-0.0204473455,
-0.0167165473,
-0.011875473,
-0.0250275899,
-0.0149014518,
-0.0112337489,
0.0325769596,
0.0100252265,
-0.0135741821,
-0.0178670548,
-0.0549392402,
-0.0121386051,
0.0242095906,
-0.0466846675,
-0.0168801248,
0.0314119682,
0.0829125121,
0.0115422215,
0.0264997948,
-0.0324434265,
0.0443065763,
0.0168933216,
-0.006393543,
0.0147272656,
-0.0709366053,
-0.000604838,
-0.0028903,
0.0361299887,
0.0155156981,
-0.0036131497,
-0.0256228428,
-0.0531978011,
-0.0210247803,
-0.0331239924,
-0.0510013178,
-0.0027548999,
0.0094277468,
0.0042178584,
-0.093178384,
-0.0343899541,
-0.0020960639,
0.019939553,
-0.0372536182,
0.0235928763,
0.0252333321,
-0.013262256,
-0.0225637369,
0.0056482395,
-0.0416157432,
-0.0110945711,
-0.0262243301,
-0.0224519558,
-0.0134880356,
0.065738447,
-0.010815857,
0.0018923725,
0.0090393526,
0.0415034853,
0.0008818161,
-0.0108439047,
0.0141251488,
0.0277904421,
0.0286490377,
-0.0133226197,
0.074980244,
-0.0295645557,
0.0054607084,
-0.0130379489,
0.0260024834,
-0.018194057,
-0.0339543857,
0.0506999344,
0.0179346427,
-0.0255106259,
-0.0311612543,
0.0478793904,
-0.0603948906,
0.0409819968,
0.0072460608,
-0.0356420837,
-0.0183850005,
-0.0062160166,
0.0194180701,
-0.0164150055,
0.0097430805,
0.0616536811,
-0.0820163786,
-0.0401348285,
0.0313169733,
-0.0155178532,
0.0095164999,
-0.027649207,
0.0046363645,
0.054628253,
-0.0079498254,
0.0424790084,
-0.0548527054,
-0.0082361214,
-0.0656179711,
-0.0216066074,
-0.0499695651,
-5.544290003e-33,
0.0299213473,
-0.0194031913,
-0.0466976501,
0.0271247458,
-0.0119864438,
0.0143280663,
0.0026748592,
0.0231632255,
-0.0103412028,
0.0437177308,
-0.0052706138,
0.0386568978,
-0.0078022024,
0.0228435919,
0.0014069858,
-0.0086048935,
0.0202203263,
-0.0323884636,
-0.0053888252,
0.040938288,
0.0144052049,
0.0104507226,
0.0676501393,
-0.0810043439,
0.062719278,
0.009328017,
-0.0222465191,
0.0440543592,
0.025326753,
0.0578543283,
-0.0356063582,
0.0932841748,
0.0384586677,
0.0056111207,
0.015346,
0.0289597549,
-0.0276749041,
-0.0065452917,
-0.0151956482,
-0.0069569368,
-0.0530797988,
-0.0237097461,
0.0274201203,
0.0166007318,
-0.0543641634,
0.0016443566,
0.049112305,
-0.0214902963,
0.0608225912,
-0.043968834,
-0.0215589292,
0.0155181298,
-0.0062805219,
-0.0118562514,
0.0209015049,
0.046480611,
-0.0081598228,
0.0681028068,
-0.0539069735,
0.0132209845,
-0.0581063852,
0.0280313995,
0.0197493546,
-0.0696603954,
0.0042891609,
0.1099097878,
0.0101142097,
0.052721262,
-0.0248241592,
0.0358614437,
-0.0198025927,
0.0452971794,
0.0757344738,
0.0591906793,
0.0067021074,
-0.0220548697,
-0.0471563935,
0.01336159,
0.0416955724,
0.029527111,
0.0706092492,
0.0003002629,
-0.0124422321,
0.026302183,
-0.0252678283,
-0.0106003638,
-0.0516080894,
-0.0047800103,
-0.0056788614,
-0.0316418596,
-0.0011416269,
-0.0496847294,
-0.0324783735,
-0.0416555777,
-0.0466643274,
0.062735945,
-0.0310071148,
0.0256805588,
0.0232270192,
0.0198016316,
-0.0139337676,
0.0189065617,
-0.0208278019,
0.0011945725,
0.0566022992,
0.0102890702,
0.0369415283,
0.038035199,
-0.0530502759,
-0.008381946,
-0.0587952435,
0.0333059207,
-0.0388853922,
0.0265821796,
-0.0352312364,
0.0211135317,
-0.0092729246,
0.0275744051,
0.0156026511,
0.0523803458,
0.0118578067,
-0.0230133571,
0.0239680968,
0.028787965,
-0.0472896695,
-0.03661054,
0.0005188955,
-0.0393534377,
-0.0240520053,
-0.0263653137,
-0.0151322316,
-0.0018928614,
2.382e-7,
0.0472253002,
0.051979728,
-0.0147793684,
-0.0106383404,
0.0354825892,
0.0530864969,
-0.0270523448,
0.0204133615,
0.0248520076,
-0.0174124353,
-0.0111974888,
0.0354325511,
0.056041576,
-0.0123170922,
-0.0752627552,
0.0274492074,
-0.0238543954,
0.0142426984,
-0.0095208026,
-0.0086468086,
0.0984717906,
0.0802595317,
0.0415751263,
-0.0041825054,
-0.0133573087,
0.0300816093,
0.0599216893,
-0.0385169871,
-0.0146253044,
0.0194065738,
0.0245086569,
-0.0154345836,
0.0028715392,
-0.0431698672,
0.0047632754,
-0.0302369315,
0.0533499233,
0.0837986022,
0.0089601073,
-0.0536777452,
0.0487752967,
0.0062037455,
-0.0158670712,
-0.0140973171,
0.0371689498,
-0.0574847981,
-0.0522127301,
-0.0767127872,
-0.0112269223,
-0.0109087741,
0.0601732321,
-0.0136705115,
-0.0284893028,
0.0110614225,
0.0088420277,
-0.0231699571,
-0.0409749039,
-0.0742329061,
-0.029240815,
0.0257632323,
-0.0293996017,
-0.01434197,
-0.0127995471,
0.0474211834,
0.017413035,
-0.0476177037,
0.0150878765,
1.653787964e-34,
0.0243282598,
-0.0010251644,
-0.0228794478,
-0.0158995278,
0.0689908192,
0.0247817077,
-0.0479346067,
-0.0176000092,
0.0320534296,
-0.0375228152,
0.0245342944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14384v1 | ARCOQ: Arabic Closest Opposite Questions Dataset | 2023-10-22T18:41:26 | 2023-10-22T18:41:26 | Sandra Rizkallah, Amir F. Atiya, Samir Shaheen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents a dataset for closest opposite questions in Arabic
language. The dataset is the first of its kind for the Arabic language. It is
beneficial for the assessment of systems on the aspect of antonymy detection.
The structure is similar to that of the Graduate Record Examination (GRE)
closest opposite questions dataset for the English language. The introduced
dataset consists of 500 questions, each contains a query word for which the
closest opposite needs to be determined from among a set of candidate words.
Each question is also associated with the correct answer. We publish the
dataset publicly in addition to providing standard splits of the dataset into
development and test sets. Moreover, the paper provides a benchmark for the
performance of different Arabic word embedding models on the introduced
dataset. | [
0.0533625931,
0.0274773054,
-0.038944874,
0.0492667034,
-0.0893755779,
0.0251561999,
0.0020990516,
0.0088590365,
0.0126020145,
0.0111487173,
-0.0272462387,
-0.0664483234,
-0.0346211046,
0.0232300386,
0.0384377576,
0.0103620999,
0.0528824553,
0.012815983,
-0.0290494058,
-0.0260836463,
0.053325735,
-0.0030109282,
-0.002097025,
0.0012089825,
0.0155063504,
-0.0027982469,
-0.0135517986,
0.0038809802,
0.0073345904,
-0.0108407885,
0.0189901683,
0.0672567263,
-0.0200339686,
-0.002162752,
0.0000018546,
-0.0522633679,
-0.0332822427,
-0.0291283466,
-0.031100804,
-0.0375294946,
0.0485771745,
-0.0072000693,
0.0096655767,
0.0381658226,
-0.0540533625,
0.0071164751,
0.0769327804,
-0.005089826,
0.0749953762,
0.0282719303,
0.0171954893,
-0.0272137523,
-0.0231103934,
-0.027683517,
-0.0025785223,
-0.019262502,
-0.0108346324,
-0.039963793,
-0.0289375465,
0.0289116222,
-0.0423338152,
0.0294884983,
0.0211906321,
0.0289478824,
-0.010883349,
-0.0406205989,
-0.0375498049,
-0.0199457873,
0.0166739095,
0.0439948775,
0.0053257248,
-0.0337111168,
-0.0361501761,
0.0042845821,
-0.0057903831,
0.0539008193,
-0.0061210254,
-0.0121597527,
-0.0065466608,
-0.007012669,
0.0199924316,
0.0329483077,
-0.003900815,
0.0261539072,
-0.0495745167,
0.0399857946,
0.0290657133,
-0.0745938569,
0.0282012317,
-0.0122288819,
-0.0118544502,
0.0098321177,
0.0325995497,
-0.0341386981,
0.0258360952,
0.0028551728,
-0.029666746,
-0.0458400585,
0.0321652852,
-0.0709718689,
0.0009321205,
0.0202803481,
-0.0231500082,
0.0292491633,
-0.0482522696,
0.0304991249,
0.0422370322,
0.0378377326,
-0.0541172288,
-0.0115523338,
-0.0271047596,
0.0028156105,
-0.0510037579,
0.0316456147,
-0.0655233487,
0.0307723526,
-0.0034716651,
0.0052787028,
-0.0359231979,
0.0009785066,
0.0090771168,
0.0134826954,
-0.0174016375,
-0.034188278,
-0.0298715178,
-0.0119552622,
-0.0770259574,
0.0080054775,
-0.0506490283,
-0.0349784605,
0.0043515437,
0.0014522335,
0.031540405,
0.004058673,
0.0519309342,
0.0424965546,
0.0054089921,
-0.0481361449,
0.0194340646,
0.0314093865,
0.013616126,
-0.0393668115,
-0.0356201269,
-0.0479006022,
0.0686311796,
0.0337168723,
-0.0031224864,
-0.0347124971,
0.0078478903,
0.0114875399,
0.0251846462,
0.0914084688,
0.008295279,
-0.015141597,
0.0619757362,
0.0148626855,
0.01513517,
0.0438789055,
-0.0005394064,
-0.0346838683,
0.0552093722,
0.0009782956,
-0.0303113852,
0.0039076675,
0.0407865345,
0.0178966075,
-0.0288257543,
0.0430790745,
-0.0242252368,
0.0648229122,
-0.0572952852,
0.057539966,
0.0072860518,
-0.0773610696,
0.0239277948,
0.0330420658,
-0.064477101,
0.0138933379,
-0.0410672352,
0.0639071018,
-0.015156378,
0.0115271518,
0.0080296872,
0.0201089401,
0.0213008504,
0.005147812,
0.0386341475,
0.0258814599,
-0.0195737481,
-0.0569867007,
-0.0256850608,
-0.0129112732,
0.0285697915,
-0.0192819703,
0.0603222623,
-0.0107008936,
-0.0379660502,
-0.0217800271,
0.0100269699,
-0.0459509455,
-0.0018869858,
-0.0258043706,
-0.023501901,
0.0089494707,
0.0136051606,
-0.0319217704,
-0.098479189,
-0.0075354101,
-0.0381378345,
0.0610048324,
0.0081330026,
-0.0140962172,
-0.0014141808,
-0.0323921815,
-0.0316002555,
0.0622431897,
-0.0071922564,
-0.0289230887,
0.0269592553,
0.0493737608,
0.0239790566,
-0.0697164088,
-0.0088604027,
0.0468108915,
-0.069045715,
0.0140981097,
0.0230164267,
0.0552484952,
0.0156031307,
0.023958724,
-0.0163080934,
0.0059784399,
0.0569481179,
-0.0566307753,
-0.0355714858,
0.0002792682,
-0.024859339,
-0.0428679883,
0.0399482995,
-0.0772271231,
0.0221948382,
0.1152162775,
-0.0202558227,
-0.0466351472,
0.0572884157,
-0.0096951928,
0.0585806109,
-0.0412253737,
0.0387294665,
0.0034447259,
-0.0139413895,
-0.0092359334,
0.0314982459,
-0.0409752131,
0.0457112752,
-0.052327767,
-0.0082199993,
0.0814893395,
0.0396517292,
-0.0625872314,
-0.0114068482,
0.0096905809,
-0.0027023293,
0.0207135808,
-0.0179049615,
-0.0348030366,
0.0097550284,
-0.0370801948,
0.0026116085,
-0.0168653131,
0.0363924429,
0.023416033,
0.0101062711,
0.0050372286,
-0.0336871222,
-0.0215171427,
0.0083973426,
0.0122597804,
0.0352113508,
0.0392072015,
0.0099762399,
0.0004848759,
-0.0656626895,
-0.0172006004,
0.03621291,
-0.0133460276,
-0.0178578142,
-0.0050683492,
0.048789449,
0.0059158113,
-0.0535986945,
0.0275168102,
-0.0094334977,
-0.0557534546,
0.0003607221,
-0.0008366787,
-0.0070561934,
0.012689651,
0.0212002862,
-0.0073910188,
0.023433337,
0.0389814675,
-0.037179064,
0.0016724934,
-0.0168258026,
0.0042813206,
-0.0058087166,
-0.0481588431,
-0.0428497382,
-0.0059683449,
0.0138134556,
-0.0360471755,
-0.0443717428,
0.0238415897,
-0.0363587961,
0.0162456501,
-0.0342009701,
0.0140120024,
-0.0053032292,
0.0602526404,
-0.0223860908,
-0.0407349095,
0.0601884909,
0.0239243656,
-0.0016456092,
-0.0221947879,
0.0130718974,
-0.0034313598,
0.0679073259,
-0.0157392994,
0.0492337383,
-0.0301199593,
-0.0035290357,
-0.0514065363,
-0.0192792267,
0.0455885641,
-0.0237871148,
-0.0465985835,
-0.0184358191,
0.0025261478,
-0.0017462083,
-0.0617262535,
-0.0384533219,
-0.0509518646,
0.0253748167,
-0.0226765592,
0.0580261573,
0.015545697,
-0.0179839991,
0.070622988,
-0.0557773151,
0.0080573363,
-0.00152009,
0.0208997075,
-0.0106313424,
-0.004213179,
0.0538416579,
-0.0101224976,
0.0223130081,
0.0447031483,
0.0152804283,
0.0339338593,
-0.0254496094,
-0.0373156406,
0.0225363839,
-0.0148655456,
0.03796193,
-0.0561910793,
-0.0285509545,
-0.0616913848,
-0.0335124061,
-0.0034333991,
-0.0413178019,
0.1080899537,
0.0652050823,
-0.028730927,
0.010358572,
-0.0061265975,
-0.0268152785,
0.0495139658,
-0.0276675094,
-0.1013526618,
0.0138034532,
0.0030312929,
0.0145641854,
0.0268251542,
-0.0210514423,
0.0343243964,
-0.1197039783,
-0.0050105629,
-0.026947083,
-0.0311737955,
-0.0880967528,
-0.0344037153,
0.0012975078,
-0.015846137,
-0.0333681405,
0.0079118367,
0.0114353253,
0.02559614,
0.0098628514,
-0.0033677306,
-0.0308184866,
0.0040831063,
-0.05579862,
0.0104647428,
0.0500857681,
0.0261740573,
-0.0266533531,
-0.0354053341,
-0.0046135527,
-0.0592244305,
-0.0721810907,
-0.0191244688,
0.0485825874,
-0.0091550676,
-0.0250143725,
-0.0393035673,
-0.0184113495,
-0.0467126369,
0.0473098569,
0.0030321314,
0.0462522432,
-0.0194432978,
0.0628735498,
-0.0101756863,
0.0080613615,
0.0002976051,
0.0862294734,
-0.0251569655,
-0.0306509808,
-0.016769439,
0.0336390398,
0.0227970853,
-0.0234103985,
0.0171287172,
-0.033273492,
0.0236600135,
0.0342287309,
-0.081093736,
-0.0743043795,
0.0305613019,
0.0453031585,
-0.0103784148,
0.0427459441,
-0.0131251169,
0.011324306,
-0.0585810021,
-0.0546883717,
0.0334125832,
-0.0025789251,
-0.0543389097,
-0.0422447287,
0.0274145752,
-0.0152175846,
-0.0376520976,
0.0026197261,
-0.0587674528,
-0.0076814587,
0.0346456617,
-0.0037926023,
0.0099308277,
-0.0086077461,
-0.015043146,
-0.0070025749,
-0.0084520569,
-0.0013877243,
-0.0304135159,
-0.0032373834,
0.0343177617,
-0.0283391103,
-0.0181002989,
0.0690814182,
0.0447272286,
0.0022325478,
0.0193713978,
0.00389715,
-0.0124686295,
-0.038110204,
0.0254499633,
-0.0139508471,
0.0385821424,
-0.0202293471,
-0.0663503855,
-0.0623621941,
0.0353238545,
-0.0123053472,
-0.0201717783,
-0.0151148485,
0.0125744687,
0.0494000018,
-0.0178058986,
-0.0304002371,
0.006107403,
-0.0155970259,
0.0065528387,
0.0145633621,
0.0452158824,
0.0407024547,
0.0415292792,
-0.0095658246,
0.0223631281,
0.0055487743,
-0.0542250425,
0.019162152,
0.020036798,
-0.0524503477,
0.0036948405,
-0.0214761011,
0.0344178006,
0.0128596956,
0.0640097335,
0.0115111861,
-0.0179043114,
-0.0345252566,
0.0356461555,
-0.0155190034,
-0.0360063203,
0.004999605,
0.0193116497,
-0.0109845521,
-0.0096625052,
-0.0009377831,
-0.0411521792,
-0.015523524,
0.0170279741,
-0.0116227651,
0.0087899268,
0.0326801315,
0.057015419,
0.0006148515,
0.0379274152,
0.0302808229,
-0.0139754806,
-0.0114650559,
0.0393787138,
0.05567763,
0.0338187218,
-0.0094868299,
0.0356840789,
-0.0554596223,
-0.0732363164,
0.0089747431,
-0.003803438,
-0.0102269035,
0.05863332,
0.0375256985,
0.0823403597,
0.0112696113,
-0.020755697,
-0.0187856387,
0.0761107057,
-0.0425611511,
-0.0206821784,
-0.0316149406,
-5.81159852e-33,
-0.0184507705,
-0.0082781753,
-0.0045826468,
-0.0954689384,
0.0265412517,
-0.0629930496,
0.0270438772,
-0.0004274357,
-0.0306251477,
0.0000357842,
-0.034192577,
0.034934137,
0.0108408509,
0.0296781845,
0.0319762006,
-0.0451603532,
0.0408209078,
-0.0197197478,
0.0090372041,
0.0192970522,
0.0280611943,
0.0624805652,
0.0992756933,
-0.0498506352,
0.0297016967,
-0.0431380309,
0.0038304955,
0.0078903306,
0.0061213174,
0.052993793,
-0.034593191,
0.0473238192,
0.022927139,
-0.0155037828,
0.0135477604,
-0.0678522661,
-0.0568715148,
-0.0490962677,
0.0181533992,
0.0437928699,
0.0197795797,
0.0288408417,
-0.0015425179,
-0.0045502363,
-0.063466467,
0.0522608049,
-0.0035424852,
-0.0118245455,
0.0210192595,
0.0372437611,
-0.0614924431,
0.0210199896,
0.0143870069,
-0.0401000194,
0.0183486249,
0.0424724743,
0.0039737085,
-0.0322671458,
-0.0385028087,
0.0004598013,
-0.0254793949,
0.0338338502,
0.0357028283,
0.0058429055,
-0.0225814339,
0.0247781817,
0.0176595077,
-0.0421189032,
0.118163377,
0.0234908834,
0.015310741,
0.0071972697,
0.0551852621,
0.0977459624,
0.047873836,
-0.0358991958,
-0.0393914431,
0.0276892576,
-0.0547636487,
0.033663936,
0.0056296093,
-0.0339312106,
-0.0809983686,
0.0083118808,
-0.0181279667,
-0.0649429113,
-0.0105415378,
-0.01402249,
0.0485340692,
-0.0088648302,
-0.0677257702,
0.0258006752,
-0.0026563369,
-0.0185460877,
0.0078117931,
0.0239946414,
0.0054508052,
-0.0330777504,
0.0279379897,
0.0622515939,
-0.0429745018,
-0.0056875069,
-0.0307841375,
0.0151676601,
-0.037813887,
-0.040573217,
0.0203675851,
0.0032256162,
-0.0990383923,
0.0201571621,
-0.0242000464,
0.0173490401,
-0.0106222769,
0.0515145548,
0.0144398864,
0.0207403284,
0.0002769191,
0.0462275073,
0.0471446104,
-0.021134505,
-0.0530896224,
-0.0382086337,
-0.0250498205,
-0.0232239179,
0.0284845363,
0.0367167629,
-0.0406727642,
-0.013079959,
-0.0300469864,
-0.0306230392,
-0.0037655141,
-0.0377092324,
2.506e-7,
0.0658428892,
0.0144336568,
0.0491851084,
0.0180403609,
-0.0395017453,
-0.0104694134,
0.0025789738,
0.0166918263,
0.0034519252,
0.0535172857,
0.0283196419,
0.0064891218,
-0.0143821929,
-0.0034954529,
-0.0377074368,
0.0430613942,
-0.0343023352,
-0.028880218,
-0.0029676093,
0.0110739432,
0.0805255249,
0.1269117594,
0.0035588641,
0.0092610111,
-0.0553995445,
-0.045811709,
0.0132051557,
-0.0375610143,
-0.0011583201,
0.0074591977,
0.0266134162,
0.0016775082,
0.0298017021,
0.0074295099,
-0.0220614523,
0.0415377468,
0.0234603602,
0.0163299572,
-0.0116082001,
-0.0347577631,
-0.0277049653,
-0.0195070822,
0.0028861091,
-0.0613194518,
0.0877174586,
0.0396168232,
0.0352369919,
-0.0065470072,
-0.0639868081,
0.0498999096,
0.0682894215,
-0.0333906338,
-0.0224140827,
-0.0027444279,
0.0659605637,
-0.0101640373,
-0.004143042,
-0.03454322,
0.0305484328,
0.02825322,
0.0100513883,
-0.0090870867,
-0.0140480371,
0.0227466803,
0.0001348266,
0.0113362893,
0.0011680664,
1.703547535e-34,
0.0284848176,
0.0512942672,
0.0024537446,
0.0198751222,
0.0139146009,
-0.0253006555,
-0.0165932495,
-0.0117361154,
0.0041840677,
-0.0111959493,
0.0149286939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14366v1 | Bi-Encoders based Species Normalization -- Pairwise Sentence Learning to Rank | 2023-10-22T17:30:16 | 2023-10-22T17:30:16 | Zainab Awan, Tim Kahlke, Peter Ralph, Paul Kennedy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Motivation: Biomedical named-entity normalization involves connecting
biomedical entities with distinct database identifiers in order to facilitate
data integration across various fields of biology. Existing systems for
biomedical named entity normalization heavily rely on dictionaries, manually
created rules, and high-quality representative features such as lexical or
morphological characteristics. However, recent research has investigated the
use of neural network-based models to reduce dependence on dictionaries,
manually crafted rules, and features. Despite these advancements, the
performance of these models is still limited due to the lack of sufficiently
large training datasets. These models have a tendency to overfit small training
corpora and exhibit poor generalization when faced with previously unseen
entities, necessitating the redesign of rules and features. Contribution: We
present a novel deep learning approach for named entity normalization, treating
it as a pair-wise learning to rank problem. Our method utilizes the widely-used
information retrieval algorithm Best Matching 25 to generate candidate
concepts, followed by the application of bi-directional encoder representation
from the encoder (BERT) to re-rank the candidate list. Notably, our approach
eliminates the need for feature-engineering or rule creation. We conduct
experiments on species entity types and evaluate our method against
state-of-the-art techniques using LINNAEUS and S800 biomedical corpora. Our
proposed approach surpasses existing methods in linking entities to the NCBI
taxonomy. To the best of our knowledge, there is no existing neural
network-based approach for species normalization in the literature. | [
-0.0066827415,
0.0574540161,
0.0146991741,
-0.0309792738,
0.008139506,
0.0278980583,
0.0073968382,
0.0042976644,
-0.0174196772,
-0.0297884103,
-0.0157649573,
-0.0315883756,
0.0396871641,
0.0428569466,
0.0232717302,
-0.0209435094,
0.03507654,
0.0365130603,
0.0201972947,
-0.0104208719,
-0.0293863621,
0.0230545513,
0.0184380189,
0.0502206199,
0.0473340042,
0.0007249757,
0.0169012193,
0.0048829205,
0.0509359315,
-0.0532430522,
0.0286696199,
0.0091656744,
0.0359033346,
0.0271815695,
0.0000016688,
-0.0441368893,
-0.0313752517,
0.0001623534,
0.0159509648,
0.0043971529,
-0.0252865087,
-0.0501886494,
0.0165506788,
-0.0051010447,
0.0108103482,
-0.0464832224,
0.0768856853,
0.0024541032,
0.0456701294,
0.0377874188,
0.0003265317,
-0.0771845877,
0.0492182337,
-0.0332513973,
-0.021192871,
0.004440017,
0.0491508394,
-0.015277843,
0.0040500322,
0.034677323,
0.020593565,
0.0311997142,
0.0003460793,
0.0221922975,
0.0637868866,
0.055680465,
-0.0025118929,
-0.0399255008,
0.0555857122,
0.0658920258,
-0.0696108639,
0.0004648184,
0.0093660159,
0.0176994279,
-0.0254594311,
-0.0082723536,
-0.0206138026,
-0.0147607001,
-0.0151036857,
0.028196251,
0.0433025658,
-0.0052196006,
0.0191439148,
0.0116774328,
-0.0557093434,
-0.0046802219,
0.0345872268,
-0.0436637774,
0.0132761421,
0.0102230683,
-0.0265311841,
-0.0078480765,
0.0804332644,
0.0233871266,
-0.0394401141,
-0.0021983299,
0.0163479373,
-0.0344587676,
0.0538661927,
-0.047986526,
-0.0288245436,
-0.006940837,
-0.038501177,
0.0179255642,
-0.0509472229,
0.0032363955,
-0.0109787052,
0.0480108634,
-0.0113024954,
-0.046453774,
-0.0499458052,
-0.029762594,
-0.0054593831,
0.0343289264,
-0.004516725,
0.0096272975,
-0.0608472452,
-0.088853918,
-0.0116661573,
0.0233014729,
0.0356897563,
0.0504185334,
-0.0403581224,
0.0395956002,
-0.0420463532,
0.0591692403,
-0.0280430559,
-0.0054627457,
-0.0287118182,
-0.033034604,
0.0025854942,
-0.0228442103,
0.036893487,
-0.0089267418,
0.0382695682,
0.0093916049,
0.0093105407,
-0.0441136509,
0.0133533217,
-0.002076928,
-0.0363908261,
0.003144409,
-0.0029140133,
-0.0437872224,
0.0661233887,
0.0024622958,
-0.0072438028,
-0.0503804721,
0.0043872506,
0.002515384,
-0.0498658046,
0.1036836132,
-0.0721721202,
-0.0582884103,
0.0345984139,
-0.0089175776,
0.035702996,
0.0074211839,
0.0359180383,
-0.0079894476,
-0.0016622228,
-0.0225933976,
-0.0109358327,
-0.0152961044,
-0.0051768492,
-0.0753204823,
-0.0184893049,
-0.0239158757,
0.0220920015,
0.1147105843,
0.0385700352,
0.0493825041,
0.0019012635,
-0.0231116842,
0.0090768104,
0.0525643714,
0.0376114734,
0.0189726539,
0.0524755977,
-0.0212206393,
-0.0395491384,
-0.0276984423,
0.0153389778,
0.0285566244,
0.0005832327,
0.0117204534,
0.0029136089,
0.0635929704,
-0.0254990794,
-0.0247021466,
0.0411616117,
-0.0166613311,
-0.0201402269,
-0.0448299907,
0.0454892479,
0.0002405547,
0.0063401195,
0.0409642868,
0.0275212303,
-0.0229199026,
0.0303428136,
0.0060393098,
-0.0345625989,
0.079908058,
0.0233648643,
-0.0215267073,
-0.059805274,
-0.0120809684,
-0.0888298601,
0.0549667552,
-0.0081408257,
-0.0342267379,
0.0156930946,
-0.0744394735,
-0.0174664333,
0.0155813508,
0.0122574838,
0.0302749667,
-0.0493175648,
0.0650935769,
0.0370006338,
-0.059294939,
-0.0120165162,
0.0582337864,
-0.0482068583,
-0.0066636428,
0.0102410829,
0.0068545341,
0.0232155304,
0.0420720838,
-0.0089519061,
0.0136516141,
0.0366952643,
-0.0397686101,
-0.0287360642,
-0.0295037888,
-0.0359896198,
-0.0446740873,
0.0435020514,
-0.0465489477,
-0.0016010638,
0.0556654856,
-0.0303131714,
-0.0461621657,
-0.0417069718,
0.0064762589,
-0.032440342,
-0.0094128326,
0.0210407618,
0.0067886347,
0.0072715911,
-0.0370886624,
0.0259515643,
-0.0014321061,
0.0517698266,
-0.006876694,
-0.1080057099,
-0.006649557,
-0.0180543102,
-0.0369389877,
0.0403857268,
0.0146508673,
-0.0172627084,
-0.0026723654,
0.0112541979,
-0.0232109204,
0.0190295819,
-0.0692630783,
0.0126970587,
0.0134463431,
0.0425624512,
-0.0101248715,
-0.0047801933,
0.0488671064,
-0.0075844992,
-0.0583973452,
-0.0374784768,
-0.0245826151,
0.0023707983,
0.0726634935,
-0.0039731432,
-0.0326199904,
-0.0206168387,
-0.0399549976,
-0.0446596369,
0.0588104948,
-0.0231835488,
-0.062449351,
-0.0237657223,
0.0306470618,
-0.0719838366,
0.0062294025,
0.0087066414,
-0.0091709755,
0.0174259637,
0.0279085394,
-0.0186214633,
0.0279460791,
0.0345266908,
-0.0080614174,
0.0516671576,
0.0509820879,
-0.0707492605,
0.0001339442,
0.0017933449,
0.0291314628,
0.0176946372,
-0.023031462,
-0.0053751539,
0.0409739763,
-0.0453215912,
-0.0211070348,
-0.0230975784,
0.0253387876,
0.021884717,
-0.0134922164,
-0.0707271844,
0.0020054944,
-0.0060721333,
0.0164769106,
-0.0118177654,
-0.0055278204,
0.0960977301,
-0.007585044,
-0.0036048833,
-0.0482076183,
0.0279793646,
-0.0190089419,
0.004268717,
0.0323044173,
0.0135365883,
0.0123782642,
-0.0343227088,
0.0114596635,
0.0458126813,
-0.0009804181,
-0.0589279421,
0.0132171158,
-0.0260401499,
0.0115368478,
-0.0357109532,
-0.0342110619,
-0.0257828701,
0.0649554506,
-0.0118441703,
0.0816118047,
0.0110952668,
-0.0222563837,
-0.0457056575,
0.0432116278,
0.0204226989,
0.0239013489,
0.0106045669,
0.0086004697,
-0.0198290255,
0.0520894788,
0.0359871536,
0.0325532183,
0.0045933356,
0.0199589599,
0.0099979984,
0.0191279463,
-0.0450213104,
0.0302772243,
0.0088301003,
-0.0038599332,
0.0150385126,
-0.0609556921,
-0.020249974,
-0.0148239797,
0.0115841124,
-0.0225501098,
-0.0159855708,
0.0911266059,
0.047204569,
-0.0625583008,
-0.0015370181,
-0.0115555488,
-0.0252506863,
-0.0028573144,
0.0124594709,
-0.0527273417,
-0.0011219798,
0.0016734266,
-0.0324734375,
0.0149467215,
-0.0911449045,
0.0219994057,
-0.0713923946,
-0.0124650979,
0.0104906568,
-0.0647457615,
-0.0554425754,
-0.0780117959,
-0.0112787578,
-0.0406941213,
0.0278544687,
-0.0004228843,
0.0405378863,
0.0110116275,
0.0206080265,
-0.0111394534,
-0.0713268146,
0.0046572504,
-0.0788104907,
0.0384365804,
0.0728480145,
0.0451767147,
-0.0255305581,
-0.0180119723,
-0.009681439,
-0.0651028231,
-0.0336825699,
0.0246068053,
0.0411406159,
-0.0324969292,
-0.0227357149,
-0.0018296221,
-0.0166284572,
-0.0370573215,
0.0118036335,
-0.0161244813,
0.0738150701,
0.0177522432,
-0.0134215737,
-0.057605952,
-0.0201573614,
-0.0109148873,
0.0434697159,
0.0298225451,
-0.0179730896,
-0.0039774142,
-0.0163542721,
0.0388408601,
-0.0430488735,
0.0043275896,
0.0331834294,
-0.0415609553,
-0.015666198,
-0.0753669739,
-0.0462306216,
0.068435818,
-0.0260337349,
-0.0067587723,
0.0116981575,
0.0401091687,
-0.0291455761,
-0.0326283388,
0.0355618708,
0.0335103609,
0.005767615,
-0.0224463418,
-0.0259716865,
0.0841098055,
0.0537119545,
-0.0496826023,
-0.0111202355,
0.068214193,
-0.0330510102,
-0.0311856493,
0.0251246952,
0.0088123167,
-0.029599065,
0.0017633555,
-0.0532124899,
0.0649693981,
0.102463901,
0.0007530494,
-0.0281504467,
0.0036919455,
0.0056741349,
-0.0320447013,
0.0194248762,
-0.0311274827,
0.0216232017,
-0.0444238968,
0.0865793675,
0.0093688825,
-0.0644367412,
0.0339437462,
0.0651684999,
0.0541283526,
-0.0562171601,
-0.0254924595,
-0.0199403241,
0.0164065454,
-0.0032777102,
0.0197409373,
-0.0143278548,
0.0211707726,
0.0389838703,
0.0411852337,
-0.0113339415,
0.0278487429,
0.0294442438,
-0.0305083953,
-0.0483440049,
0.0148550402,
0.0268066395,
0.0033859366,
-0.0181823112,
-0.0169204231,
-0.0311594065,
0.0030020995,
0.0141165713,
0.0307265297,
-0.0631184652,
-0.0485977754,
0.0251821522,
0.079700686,
-0.0645967647,
0.0672083721,
-0.007654157,
0.0267877392,
-0.0572059788,
0.0298398975,
0.0449112952,
0.0212463085,
0.0307009164,
0.0439176969,
-0.0355721042,
-0.0214257818,
0.005639636,
-0.019548174,
-0.0038440812,
0.0222567767,
0.0281566884,
-0.0224493556,
-0.0505331084,
0.0716832206,
-0.002441352,
0.0612387247,
-0.0239256658,
-0.035266161,
-0.0178860221,
0.0174500626,
-0.0119787585,
-0.0177191626,
-0.0104792966,
-0.0312900767,
0.0026411409,
-0.0495124646,
0.0510774329,
-0.0064381314,
-0.024432363,
0.0158617347,
0.0426274091,
0.0083291167,
0.0119790481,
-0.0301001109,
0.0294945985,
0.003182529,
-0.0050394139,
-0.059052404,
-0.0267201029,
-5.274761638e-33,
-0.0348927639,
-0.0407362804,
-0.0088851573,
-0.0617503561,
0.0222528819,
0.0168008655,
0.0064837658,
-0.0338121578,
-0.0153163513,
0.0340675525,
0.0015211323,
-0.0151314316,
0.0020612844,
-0.0133855566,
0.0530103184,
-0.0097393589,
0.0324558318,
0.0002030983,
0.0151215605,
0.0014502846,
0.0562517643,
0.0683049262,
0.0907489359,
-0.052936133,
-0.0078396006,
0.0814354643,
0.0068919654,
0.0076955729,
-0.022166444,
0.0480128042,
-0.0151344007,
0.0526382774,
0.0078290096,
-0.0490863696,
0.0075277314,
-0.0132226879,
-0.0914198011,
-0.0156846177,
-0.0516747907,
-0.0345155001,
-0.0194937903,
-0.0239577591,
0.0869065225,
0.0226891618,
-0.0046017561,
0.0052677775,
0.0628554299,
-0.0426498689,
-0.028894186,
-0.0723160878,
-0.0304600224,
0.0070853517,
0.0075679314,
0.0207027737,
0.0364960134,
-0.0091034751,
0.0011275592,
0.0500939339,
-0.0323197022,
0.0098452913,
0.0390119031,
0.0298466459,
0.0338329002,
-0.0092382748,
-0.0206196234,
0.0527166463,
0.0509444177,
-0.031912189,
-0.0015914337,
0.0111202626,
0.002022672,
0.0176543389,
0.0430302955,
0.0239276011,
0.0424882695,
-0.0000661197,
-0.0889451727,
0.1023947224,
-0.0058682174,
0.0109177157,
-0.0341287218,
0.0113512659,
0.0055961413,
-0.0151655953,
-0.0264345556,
-0.0306274164,
-0.0165436715,
-0.0291397348,
0.0045777955,
-0.0160921235,
-0.0241785571,
0.0385491885,
0.0113203069,
-0.0307355914,
-0.0554081388,
0.005594898,
0.0306615047,
0.0059372922,
0.0276219808,
0.0137412092,
-0.0369951017,
-0.0436469726,
0.0331890285,
0.0008905688,
0.0358463451,
0.008342579,
0.0264632087,
-0.0421096757,
-0.0340190977,
0.0112255756,
0.0019844831,
-0.0596396327,
-0.0326448828,
0.0535353273,
-0.0172764882,
-0.0175491869,
0.0111983223,
0.0079783602,
0.0724718049,
0.0103539051,
-0.0351341218,
-0.0070199477,
0.0132707302,
0.0246450026,
-0.0046286252,
0.0137662301,
-0.0131347757,
0.0192415845,
0.0045513953,
-0.0275964383,
-0.012237655,
-0.0206834693,
2.613e-7,
0.0829018876,
0.0175569747,
0.0351330861,
-0.0140824169,
0.0039281212,
0.0176339913,
0.0153848352,
0.0489110239,
-0.023735987,
-0.0332474001,
0.0385144539,
-0.0225895885,
-0.0270855725,
0.027652001,
-0.0617750958,
-0.0464918688,
-0.1000880748,
-0.0132774562,
-0.0297239199,
-0.0079713501,
0.0163275916,
0.0639859289,
-0.0291091092,
-0.0158667713,
0.0151121169,
-0.0018205217,
0.0302449428,
-0.0301646832,
-0.0104731601,
0.0204662047,
0.0350142047,
0.0158552099,
0.0242150314,
0.044407893,
0.0157800727,
0.0189931169,
0.0281664971,
0.0256776903,
-0.0378216095,
0.005105074,
0.0098283878,
0.0353236794,
0.0222877692,
-0.0611885078,
0.0275306385,
-0.0548971705,
-0.0426456034,
0.0227868129,
-0.0477761626,
0.0430183113,
0.0388348401,
-0.0013365005,
-0.02271083,
0.022361204,
0.0355460905,
0.0294102803,
-0.005681444,
-0.0841757506,
0.0036024593,
0.0565037578,
-0.0396583527,
-0.0378659889,
-0.009694227,
-0.0201810095,
0.0293951277,
-0.0578276217,
-0.0127336113,
2.241422756e-34,
0.0205960348,
-0.0122920135,
0.0054534799,
0.0311787911,
-0.0225847568,
-0.0373211578,
-0.0165870506,
-0.0179867279,
-0.0402379818,
-0.0517829657,
-0.0236741249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14360v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14360v4 | Is ChatGPT a game changer for geocoding -- a benchmark for geocoding address parsing techniques | 2023-10-22T17:03:56 | 2023-12-15T08:19:59 | Zhengcong Yin, Diya Li, Daniel W. Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The remarkable success of GPT models across various tasks, including toponymy
recognition motivates us to assess the performance of the GPT-3 model in the
geocoding address parsing task. To ensure that the evaluation more accurately
mirrors performance in real-world scenarios with diverse user input qualities
and resolve the pressing need for a 'gold standard' evaluation dataset for
geocoding systems, we introduce a benchmark dataset of low-quality address
descriptions synthesized based on human input patterns mining from actual input
logs of a geocoding system in production. This dataset has 21 different input
errors and variations; contains over 239,000 address records that are uniquely
selected from streets across all U.S. 50 states and D.C.; and consists of three
subsets to be used as training, validation, and testing sets. Building on this,
we train and gauge the performance of the GPT-3 model in extracting address
components, contrasting its performance with transformer-based and LSTM-based
models. The evaluation results indicate that Bidirectional LSTM-CRF model has
achieved the best performance over these transformer-based models and GPT-3
model. Transformer-based models demonstrate very comparable results compared to
the Bidirectional LSTM-CRF model. The GPT-3 model, though trailing in
performance, showcases potential in the address parsing task with few-shot
examples, exhibiting room for improvement with additional fine-tuning. We open
source the code and data of this presented benchmark so that researchers can
utilize it for future model development or extend it to evaluate similar tasks,
such as document geocoding. | [
0.0452998616,
0.0342475697,
0.0471842475,
0.0361990184,
-0.0124922777,
0.0417544991,
0.0377535187,
-0.0056172274,
0.0181003753,
-0.0338790752,
-0.0255609304,
-0.0378818065,
0.0175688677,
0.0186853707,
0.0277643334,
-0.0446943119,
0.0093188519,
-0.0115420781,
-0.0171063691,
0.0486526117,
-0.0416065082,
0.0304055642,
0.0000244703,
0.0333589427,
0.0079115219,
0.009830215,
0.0108779529,
0.0179599989,
0.0429886319,
-0.0362879448,
0.0297832247,
-0.0079925172,
-0.0321420282,
0.0351831988,
0.0000017749,
-0.0029032698,
-0.0487933308,
0.0492872521,
-0.0080924947,
0.023598358,
0.018388696,
-0.0108293882,
-0.0384031199,
0.0324265175,
-0.0232516192,
-0.0715964139,
0.0374157727,
0.0658180043,
0.0332811773,
0.0529085584,
-0.030632928,
-0.048182819,
0.0662258565,
-0.0085678464,
0.0042919605,
-0.0087118736,
0.040306028,
-0.029947551,
-0.001234206,
-0.0010379227,
0.0303594656,
0.0073000118,
-0.015315921,
0.0380311683,
-0.0200111736,
0.0494938828,
-0.0335907452,
0.0761653706,
-0.0161556005,
0.0314946733,
-0.0414303578,
-0.0018409684,
0.0464941226,
0.0415827706,
-0.0230953228,
-0.0221212059,
-0.030968396,
-0.0187603515,
-0.0303791016,
0.0285025239,
-0.0513087511,
-0.0008864779,
0.0278700311,
0.0084302444,
-0.051986102,
0.0464809984,
-0.0100077717,
-0.0532146469,
-0.0357036926,
0.0185607355,
-0.0034755785,
-0.054058861,
0.057585746,
0.0018064748,
0.0733939931,
-0.0280820653,
-0.0004593772,
-0.0008359589,
-0.0104227262,
-0.0096831424,
0.0115861576,
0.0142043196,
-0.0418911688,
0.0268883947,
-0.0456103273,
0.0476842783,
-0.0205161087,
0.0728605837,
0.0038188358,
-0.052215714,
-0.0698857307,
-0.0065687886,
-0.0255397689,
0.0468841419,
0.0239644814,
0.0312353596,
-0.0149676139,
0.0080452571,
-0.003827733,
0.0150811411,
-0.033855807,
-0.0146742323,
0.0232519619,
-0.0195099954,
-0.0055806171,
0.0168196373,
-0.0178622007,
-0.0308187921,
0.0055572349,
-0.0238442365,
0.0133745177,
0.0021746496,
0.0473895073,
-0.0468544923,
-0.0160107408,
0.0508047491,
0.0213719048,
-0.0687780604,
-0.0264309905,
0.0061122985,
-0.0003601109,
-0.0054996912,
0.0250993911,
-0.0184712131,
-0.0091835316,
0.0155560412,
0.0071643116,
-0.0656180084,
-0.0217228979,
-0.0051933313,
-0.0267479606,
0.0675716624,
-0.0315599106,
-0.0072616627,
0.0782128647,
-0.0123983873,
0.03653384,
-0.0029948445,
0.0410112627,
0.0706519857,
0.0021771591,
-0.0167915635,
0.0339506082,
0.031487979,
0.0099393949,
-0.0255764686,
0.0163653642,
0.0214613713,
-0.0102473376,
0.0073386892,
0.0531409234,
0.0886618271,
-0.0400441438,
-0.0065200995,
0.0382614024,
0.0495254621,
0.0129029155,
0.0185844135,
0.0176896825,
0.0752935484,
-0.0052250917,
-0.0199775174,
-0.0547152571,
-0.0461695418,
-0.0212708749,
0.0245430432,
0.0001749833,
0.0183739644,
-0.0192623138,
0.011782242,
-0.0116672711,
-0.0275458675,
0.0053912392,
0.0078577595,
0.0492145307,
-0.0290459674,
-0.0454890169,
0.0718751401,
-0.0460312702,
-0.0193396881,
0.0007463564,
-0.0416387804,
-0.0334669575,
0.0446520932,
0.0621878877,
0.0024542862,
-0.0096953446,
-0.0593759902,
-0.0191680994,
0.0069591119,
0.0417500064,
0.0087040961,
0.0166914836,
-0.0592624582,
-0.0399673022,
0.0721648782,
-0.0263854191,
-0.0031785339,
0.0696196854,
-0.0010528262,
0.0609426871,
-0.0135665582,
0.0084710168,
0.0073782853,
0.0003184895,
-0.0339588597,
-0.0086760949,
0.0230133422,
-0.0239905249,
0.0156045966,
-0.0273509398,
-0.0067754281,
0.0333377495,
-0.0103931166,
0.0241640713,
-0.0207832213,
-0.0427929498,
0.0007106854,
0.0028125476,
-0.0432181694,
-0.0201890226,
0.0546712205,
-0.0338925384,
-0.0452523232,
-0.0711301863,
-0.0450458527,
0.0754991546,
-0.0288018603,
0.0225034859,
0.0321214832,
-0.0047686044,
-0.0261952821,
0.0172824897,
-0.0253520329,
-0.0061483835,
-0.0071166521,
0.0333760865,
0.0123614166,
-0.0180823226,
-0.0115934759,
-0.0348080583,
-0.0799679086,
-0.0154743642,
-0.0274609122,
0.0235692933,
-0.0149090663,
-0.0842832997,
-0.0803106725,
-0.0456365645,
-0.0092598768,
0.0381042622,
0.0125702955,
0.0123716556,
-0.0404531509,
-0.0271249022,
-0.0164652225,
-0.0769167989,
-0.024237426,
0.0077111488,
0.0503007248,
0.036769893,
-0.0424985103,
-0.0148164434,
-0.0131785125,
-0.0233409423,
0.0089022508,
-0.0418572165,
-0.0601449646,
-0.0343540385,
0.0194698852,
0.0128023559,
0.0158510897,
-0.0023548892,
-0.0227840003,
0.004123617,
-0.0025820166,
0.0298931077,
0.0032517994,
0.0159524921,
-0.0306900144,
-0.0462734923,
-0.0172530934,
-0.0288046394,
0.0197141077,
-0.0181512646,
0.0243319273,
-0.0169403683,
-0.0310991351,
0.0095370356,
0.0316577144,
-0.0051329187,
0.0392262302,
-0.0022769761,
-0.035489928,
-0.0113093928,
0.0142368395,
-0.0316483043,
0.0312642381,
-0.0075427392,
0.036660511,
-0.0324395485,
-0.0252382308,
0.054058861,
-0.077693589,
-0.0147280768,
0.0261759534,
-0.0146699958,
-0.0236547794,
0.0611484125,
0.009086512,
0.0160937775,
0.0364641882,
-0.0978290662,
0.0513379872,
-0.0521402769,
-0.0291147009,
-0.0051403595,
0.0445090346,
0.0184342284,
0.0286044516,
-0.0092047229,
-0.0964263901,
-0.0191508289,
-0.0495355986,
-0.0149136037,
0.0018972936,
0.0151260355,
-0.055979047,
0.0256899353,
0.0881344154,
-0.0330498144,
0.075283356,
-0.0161649901,
-0.0255638231,
0.0054717949,
0.0348055996,
0.0408225395,
0.0254207365,
-0.0290431958,
0.0472178943,
-0.0647233278,
-0.0144052869,
0.0486867838,
0.0594623871,
0.0181340855,
-0.0028939187,
0.0148035819,
-0.0502244309,
-0.0251419805,
0.0030811767,
0.0208361186,
-0.0350833684,
-0.050499808,
0.105993107,
0.0322732404,
-0.0363175757,
-0.0517798737,
-0.001319672,
0.0107574025,
-0.0047326996,
0.0356042162,
-0.0607650541,
0.0049124653,
0.0229199808,
0.0236902852,
0.0092039546,
-0.0414233916,
0.0174067803,
-0.1053929776,
0.0348366126,
-0.0099436184,
-0.0280649532,
-0.0345842466,
-0.0241568666,
-0.0418231972,
-0.0001120579,
-0.0006854696,
-0.0011555956,
-0.0742176771,
-0.0270949323,
0.0484152138,
-0.0950246975,
-0.0549426153,
0.0194651503,
-0.0483069122,
0.0469953977,
0.0702386126,
0.0281196572,
-0.0283905007,
-0.0221973564,
-0.0017222601,
0.0343300886,
-0.0000481992,
0.0017213209,
0.03509482,
-0.0217093807,
-0.0215470828,
-0.0071920389,
-0.0287564434,
-0.0355606116,
0.0044595855,
-0.0025875182,
0.0231060311,
-0.0445057526,
0.05471389,
0.02001209,
0.0155458199,
0.0034611218,
0.0619699247,
0.0133077465,
0.0192703344,
-0.0755926892,
-0.040159557,
0.010484647,
-0.0322694331,
-0.0009283282,
0.0548136532,
-0.0100848339,
-0.0545069091,
-0.0104596689,
-0.0518567078,
0.025381092,
0.0063878661,
-0.0296968669,
-0.0102493064,
0.05066102,
0.0066192509,
-0.0448218845,
0.0193246417,
-0.0367259458,
0.0064039952,
-0.0664387718,
0.0489621311,
-0.0000907441,
-0.0068940697,
-0.0198031142,
0.0448482223,
-0.0616153367,
-0.0109338034,
0.0534902252,
0.0418110155,
0.0228034928,
0.0197190233,
-0.0650033131,
-0.0149017163,
-0.0165488459,
-0.007678723,
0.0285705104,
-0.0440240279,
0.0380620062,
-0.0159729701,
-0.0121309366,
-0.0264581982,
-0.0204681549,
0.026710527,
0.0219609272,
-0.0525959991,
-0.0526511334,
0.0309158396,
-0.0055676959,
0.0152481608,
0.1094102412,
-0.011770973,
0.0403749533,
-0.008941642,
-0.0037491664,
-0.0141117424,
0.0712154657,
0.0235098023,
-0.0166844428,
0.0528035015,
0.0000085544,
-0.0037464644,
0.0318181813,
-0.0081682857,
0.0161898993,
-0.0427254736,
0.0025090985,
-0.0485920683,
0.0664901733,
-0.0045027793,
-0.035955593,
-0.0439743474,
0.0045237965,
0.0476207361,
0.0413468219,
-0.0248495359,
-0.0144385369,
-0.0093033062,
0.0399735309,
-0.003266217,
0.0459004976,
-0.0624046102,
-0.007206128,
-0.0719913989,
0.0161972269,
0.0652106926,
0.0141470814,
0.0276374314,
-0.0302670151,
0.0292819403,
-0.0089599593,
-0.0177539401,
0.0085492833,
0.0037472323,
-0.0178024918,
0.009893585,
-0.0427207686,
-0.0221812949,
0.0289764889,
0.0528499186,
0.0492175072,
0.0123678744,
-0.0404402688,
-0.0299973115,
-0.0077048671,
-0.0103755342,
0.0097846957,
-0.0109854406,
-0.0382384993,
-0.0237417538,
-0.0323044583,
0.0483386926,
-0.0139143085,
0.0359836556,
-0.0126753515,
0.0415271446,
-0.0062143044,
-0.0213932097,
-0.015418712,
-0.0230146497,
-0.0177466609,
0.0368285254,
-0.0554123074,
-0.0137752006,
-5.923270116e-33,
-0.0109550823,
-0.0235474464,
0.0519224666,
-0.01463525,
-0.0479066707,
0.0169512145,
-0.0183219891,
-0.0195656791,
-0.0435488373,
-0.0295564961,
-0.0359387957,
-0.010775934,
0.0470565632,
0.0679930523,
-0.025817154,
-0.0048845564,
0.0423208922,
0.0156422108,
0.0170779936,
-0.0020831837,
0.0435336083,
0.0773788393,
0.0516691767,
-0.1055444106,
-0.0005345423,
-0.0204562787,
-0.0425846167,
0.0062844991,
0.0638669282,
0.0439302139,
-0.0390829854,
-0.0125124902,
0.0312137716,
-0.0383615419,
0.0088291233,
0.0180859957,
-0.1150744259,
0.0037009504,
-0.0080133853,
0.0084135486,
0.0575159341,
-0.0135477595,
0.0328256264,
-0.0117299678,
-0.0048654014,
0.0422119386,
0.0022604091,
-0.0179977454,
-0.0475799739,
0.0033587504,
-0.024484396,
0.0347418562,
0.0221371464,
-0.0113796052,
0.0530793518,
-0.0060929121,
0.0378428213,
-0.0071985577,
-0.0748000965,
-0.0256388839,
0.0524413139,
0.0218116585,
0.0278729536,
0.0258335769,
0.003878712,
0.0445414558,
0.0057961508,
-0.0126283802,
-0.033847142,
-0.0469747558,
0.0100892978,
0.0393692739,
-0.0036488529,
0.0163425505,
0.0187600143,
-0.0568233579,
-0.027979942,
0.0508429855,
0.0324501768,
-0.0215589646,
0.0234297346,
-0.0102138836,
-0.0830943882,
-0.0007948928,
0.0178692639,
-0.0179073997,
0.004893139,
-0.0335714146,
0.0435069986,
0.0179142691,
-0.0182790626,
0.0884469151,
0.0353406258,
-0.0103933671,
-0.0322749019,
-0.0142732626,
-0.0004282818,
0.0391387455,
-0.0437230654,
0.003406517,
-0.0002485852,
-0.0856632218,
-0.0288175568,
0.0402675681,
-0.0067975922,
-0.0012795035,
0.057208579,
0.0089145079,
-0.0705778971,
-0.0117138345,
0.0065554297,
0.0469324403,
-0.0273263082,
0.0017502058,
-0.0060509034,
-0.0024476948,
0.0351215415,
0.0327009559,
0.0199508108,
0.0246244166,
0.0272096768,
0.0170761533,
0.0025418214,
0.022399826,
0.0520400107,
0.011401549,
-0.0208297055,
0.0003430718,
0.048951786,
-0.0003208836,
-0.0040372219,
-0.0128755169,
2.481e-7,
0.0525991134,
0.0531163923,
0.0693018883,
0.0019580578,
-0.0262836535,
0.0106867254,
0.0469910689,
0.0277953539,
-0.0197852068,
0.0474441126,
0.0217531696,
-0.0307632685,
0.0501189418,
0.0597682931,
-0.1388157308,
0.0263228379,
-0.0981580168,
-0.0097652264,
-0.0510393009,
0.0505036637,
0.0541291684,
0.0877462402,
0.0163703281,
-0.033150889,
-0.002780946,
-0.0065504373,
0.0202752296,
-0.0533193201,
0.016180329,
0.014982556,
0.0328771994,
0.0189282466,
0.0169558283,
-0.0174983703,
0.0015502438,
-0.0367421731,
0.0398958474,
0.0822108835,
-0.0223716516,
-0.0010969701,
-0.0016072652,
-0.0434155017,
-0.0040061572,
-0.0718453676,
0.0423441008,
-0.0294687748,
0.0238176864,
-0.0019758816,
0.0101765124,
-0.01470022,
0.000382625,
-0.0298741348,
-0.0356834121,
0.0032575829,
0.0469952375,
-0.0254268609,
-0.0232957881,
-0.0853515565,
0.0099283885,
0.0141346678,
0.0089968992,
0.0119823366,
-0.0393378586,
-0.0208877977,
0.0476550423,
-0.0073659439,
-0.0242014267,
2.162736496e-34,
-0.030385809,
0.0085408548,
-0.0058309808,
0.0424316227,
0.0425404683,
0.0296609327,
0.0056479578,
0.0447918996,
-0.0605278537,
-0.0378696322,
0.0020569107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14358v1 | Right, No Matter Why: AI Fact-checking and AI Authority in Health-related Inquiry Settings | 2023-10-22T16:59:31 | 2023-10-22T16:59:31 | Elena Sergeeva, Anastasia Sergeeva, Huiyun Tang, Kerstin Bongard-Blanchy, Peter Szolovits | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Previous research on expert advice-taking shows that humans exhibit two
contradictory behaviors: on the one hand, people tend to overvalue their own
opinions undervaluing the expert opinion, and on the other, people often defer
to other people's advice even if the advice itself is rather obviously wrong.
In our study, we conduct an exploratory evaluation of users' AI-advice
accepting behavior when evaluating the truthfulness of a health-related
statement in different "advice quality" settings. We find that even feedback
that is confined to just stating that "the AI thinks that the statement is
false/true" results in more than half of people moving their statement veracity
assessment towards the AI suggestion. The different types of advice given
influence the acceptance rates, but the sheer effect of getting a suggestion is
often bigger than the suggestion-type effect. | [
0.0920939818,
-0.0085827922,
-0.0018166727,
-0.0610524118,
-0.0105689988,
-0.0289742686,
0.0125604412,
-0.0023053,
0.0374294631,
0.0134156449,
-0.0119741438,
0.0151926773,
0.021781452,
0.0071595977,
-0.0091365464,
-0.0007459214,
-0.0169891305,
0.0175247509,
0.1448709071,
-0.0006412902,
0.0348003581,
-0.0059499331,
-0.0289681479,
0.0487454757,
-0.0197069757,
-0.0029276777,
0.0628560111,
-0.0252573323,
0.0319185406,
-0.0834332332,
0.0132116219,
0.0002646734,
-0.021731168,
0.0041432506,
0.0000018353,
-0.0212730635,
-0.0022053516,
0.0108376956,
-0.0589630492,
0.0024063778,
-0.0214018133,
0.0290465169,
0.0144884931,
0.0227095615,
-0.0584365018,
0.054267168,
0.0160498712,
0.0771573707,
0.0314895175,
0.0321074165,
-0.0168696754,
0.0549566448,
0.0142044267,
0.0046433979,
-0.0013135531,
-0.0222499184,
0.0040265247,
0.0152967619,
-0.0335918851,
0.0232080277,
0.0138316965,
0.0231022909,
-0.0223128088,
-0.0114888968,
-0.0181762166,
0.0536800437,
0.0146870045,
-0.0420226641,
-0.0085951509,
0.0513237789,
0.0734189674,
0.0034971877,
-0.0121909408,
-0.008242703,
0.0273470636,
0.0579125658,
-0.0209985599,
0.0089382222,
-0.041876547,
-0.0270351879,
0.0207530055,
0.0242991112,
0.0233951826,
0.0008830196,
0.0424432382,
0.0631606877,
-0.0354160666,
-0.0449008569,
0.0471053198,
-0.0002975615,
0.0378256775,
-0.0537873767,
-0.006279978,
0.0070965667,
-0.0124096619,
-0.0003647604,
0.0391092785,
0.0354836769,
0.0808434188,
-0.0325756744,
0.0283695273,
0.0053408858,
-0.0525111295,
0.0088375965,
0.0221142117,
-0.0317723714,
-0.0154882018,
0.0460459478,
-0.0213855654,
0.0330717117,
-0.0109762102,
0.0002628939,
0.022303855,
0.0027529553,
0.0217357781,
0.0202245805,
-0.0299874935,
-0.0729501992,
-0.0647730976,
0.0215624385,
-0.0387670659,
0.0281967893,
0.0227706023,
0.009188015,
-0.0910165459,
0.0791061446,
-0.0390741602,
0.058549542,
0.0217168499,
-0.0270211007,
0.0052713281,
0.0050624837,
0.0002633971,
0.0271207858,
0.0391741768,
-0.0171210505,
0.0090714078,
-0.0144108739,
0.0038737534,
0.0076622246,
-0.0271085054,
-0.0528085157,
-0.012939183,
-0.0104394248,
0.0288573075,
0.0005223816,
-0.0022996452,
-0.01378184,
0.0304485224,
0.0339128673,
-0.0333896503,
0.0307927281,
-0.0316425748,
0.0438865162,
0.0411143303,
0.0443452522,
-0.0389175005,
-0.018287709,
0.0001548298,
0.0132310474,
0.0267444197,
0.0249598771,
0.0409669913,
-0.0352240726,
0.0415863842,
-0.0046928376,
0.0605755709,
0.0311796274,
-0.0800774246,
0.0407035872,
-0.035907086,
0.0726546124,
-0.0259371437,
0.0117496969,
0.0863226429,
0.0526601933,
-0.0575515144,
0.0015511846,
-0.0053457953,
-0.0120797884,
0.0317585282,
0.0072725308,
-0.0292178672,
0.0304555595,
-0.0341886841,
-0.0223329719,
-0.0309722591,
0.0317759961,
-0.0044704024,
-0.0397034064,
-0.0105917417,
0.0072708339,
0.0085241804,
0.0283286516,
-0.0327806659,
-0.0285162833,
0.0119514363,
-0.0483116396,
0.0253043212,
-0.0019749869,
-0.043365594,
-0.0951895937,
0.052814506,
0.0255975649,
-0.0001778159,
0.0307083111,
-0.0102728484,
-0.0339832604,
0.0247620344,
-0.0004638253,
0.0912619755,
-0.0299998131,
-0.0365012288,
-0.0107982811,
-0.0246352144,
0.0037329996,
0.0140421111,
0.0022145526,
0.0135405194,
0.046965532,
-0.0330032706,
0.0218338985,
-0.0598921664,
0.023537213,
-0.0112413317,
-0.0049388949,
-0.0178415459,
0.0215670057,
0.0427590087,
0.0161071569,
-0.0001827333,
0.0390024856,
0.0199804921,
0.0305925179,
-0.0456193164,
0.0271592382,
-0.0266732126,
0.0657921284,
-0.0176766459,
-0.0576477796,
-0.0477935001,
-0.0364509262,
0.0168390535,
0.021529315,
-0.0672180727,
-0.0367117226,
-0.0255020168,
0.0205460414,
-0.0399716571,
0.0009408708,
-0.0171057675,
-0.0103051877,
-0.0092424713,
-0.0485456064,
-0.0316403657,
-0.0062620775,
-0.0342239477,
-0.0198422447,
-0.0006474606,
0.0067458521,
-0.0273868982,
0.0350248106,
0.0169508141,
0.0354784913,
-0.0314848945,
-0.0359007083,
0.0440320447,
-0.0948628038,
-0.0481186956,
-0.0072474019,
-0.0178059321,
0.0129765775,
-0.0352520645,
0.0193253811,
-0.0041482518,
-0.0434646159,
-0.0382740125,
-0.0252311993,
0.0457217544,
0.0240825191,
0.014720316,
0.0403344855,
-0.0323023945,
0.0216263328,
-0.0321700014,
-0.0247457325,
0.0794718638,
0.0063968366,
-0.0113873314,
-0.0869679227,
-0.0741473287,
0.0041447305,
-0.0156623032,
-0.0073387143,
0.0087453797,
0.026076844,
0.0100542801,
0.0514046662,
0.0219105091,
0.0073457998,
0.0825631171,
0.0886503384,
-0.0407856256,
0.0011537044,
-0.0041757547,
0.0138098635,
0.0253633037,
-0.0668003485,
0.0405730642,
-0.0145060336,
0.0524639599,
0.0351692215,
-0.0177023262,
0.026031144,
-0.0285622496,
-0.0305550992,
0.0189575758,
-0.0244257506,
-0.0154041201,
0.1016444862,
-0.0020544576,
-0.0224026702,
0.0999470428,
0.0058805831,
0.0076976297,
-0.0147763221,
-0.0332943685,
0.0002493518,
-0.0320653766,
-0.0242429394,
0.0321380384,
0.0670526773,
0.0491095521,
-0.0069776843,
-0.0469978265,
0.0121971741,
-0.0546136945,
0.0177289639,
-0.0380216353,
0.012503624,
0.0599446408,
-0.0425540805,
-0.0121542243,
-0.0328420661,
-0.0520086065,
-0.0429090485,
0.0013547882,
-0.0125071397,
-0.0421157107,
-0.0608682744,
0.0607203543,
0.0389602631,
0.0256618261,
-0.026074538,
0.0442745239,
-0.0378617384,
0.0359535366,
0.0347572379,
0.0666361675,
0.0154553093,
0.0190851185,
0.0773966387,
-0.0297571942,
-0.0088779647,
-0.0269329771,
-0.0362184495,
-0.021626858,
0.0348491855,
0.0173659492,
0.0147847412,
0.025765134,
0.0148655307,
0.0089080706,
0.0186396483,
0.0108597428,
-0.0135592604,
0.0221410785,
-0.0405953377,
-0.0008823259,
0.0030365244,
-0.0145149911,
-0.0627648011,
-0.0111666163,
-0.0294597745,
0.0218987036,
-0.0794587433,
-0.0199291464,
-0.0054787416,
-0.0354701392,
0.0141934892,
-0.0315025896,
0.0755354911,
-0.0583636872,
-0.0353209004,
0.01841533,
-0.0130652478,
-0.003088969,
-0.0024625564,
0.0389460959,
0.0048168008,
-0.003887248,
-0.0414643399,
0.015637951,
0.0645724982,
-0.0218969733,
0.0614062436,
0.0693919659,
0.0597832911,
-0.0026519299,
-0.050090462,
-0.0410714708,
0.0458190888,
0.0068466491,
-0.0047644135,
0.0683613271,
-0.0236856807,
0.0480842851,
-0.0444600619,
0.0230714474,
0.0159810353,
0.0130071668,
0.0350693949,
0.0517941788,
0.0054819761,
-0.0770156831,
-0.0487141199,
0.0377673469,
0.0476789102,
0.0461952724,
0.0108090304,
0.0017757259,
0.0223994758,
0.0156400744,
0.0185097978,
0.0295735039,
-0.0674342141,
0.019759262,
-0.0106615368,
0.00008429,
-0.0678783432,
-0.0232641995,
-0.0280809682,
-0.0047875466,
-0.0168717615,
-0.0455770493,
0.0306491796,
0.0127543602,
0.029244205,
0.023752572,
0.0252127461,
-0.002154853,
-0.0004229543,
-0.013383545,
0.0556681529,
-0.0058662137,
0.0154736331,
0.0429763868,
0.0661317259,
0.0110179363,
0.0078656338,
0.0659277812,
0.0163660031,
0.0091358032,
0.0085717021,
0.0035035363,
0.0096778292,
0.0024392453,
-0.0241370983,
0.0026284503,
0.0314445011,
0.024672728,
0.0159448087,
0.0029358971,
0.0048292093,
0.0196723994,
0.0103252949,
-0.0282311551,
-0.0549010262,
-0.0372837298,
0.0522715189,
0.041899126,
0.0149047486,
-0.0033193915,
0.0691643208,
0.0100134509,
-0.0115179643,
0.0102781272,
-0.0158254635,
0.0261271987,
-0.0248073265,
0.0065142391,
-0.0367671959,
-0.0208787322,
0.0058523305,
-0.0221103877,
-0.0230864268,
-0.0246862341,
0.0063996855,
-0.0143695036,
0.0625172332,
-0.0030321842,
-0.0177711714,
-0.0033452476,
0.028046377,
-0.0006880261,
0.0173698273,
0.029061934,
0.039089635,
0.0059003863,
-0.0457139499,
0.0098148007,
-0.0067253402,
-0.0711421445,
-0.088004984,
0.024510704,
0.0167662427,
-0.0463268384,
0.0056851692,
0.0053744968,
0.0089454586,
-0.0068794223,
0.0048731947,
-0.0099444017,
-0.0152928466,
0.0171192996,
0.0392368361,
-0.0150101651,
-0.0169478431,
-0.0061568874,
0.0345419496,
-0.0430354141,
0.0456569456,
-0.0374883562,
-0.0655765682,
-0.0232021306,
-0.0476120263,
-0.0573179796,
-0.0036922607,
-0.0343525447,
-0.0101066101,
-0.1005061716,
-0.0154901603,
-0.0000783175,
0.0063678534,
0.0357069448,
-0.0604732521,
-0.0357973427,
0.0591214336,
0.0216283537,
-0.0506564341,
-0.011053415,
0.0211970937,
-0.0324011669,
0.0429057069,
-0.0490153991,
-5.790307746e-33,
0.0286477953,
-0.06094696,
-0.0018909428,
-0.0417191349,
0.0411978178,
0.0367480777,
-0.0060306457,
0.0143114049,
-0.0365417451,
0.0663352758,
-0.0323831663,
0.0279525816,
-0.0109485667,
-0.0368204862,
0.0186482053,
-0.0237315074,
0.0377761312,
-0.0264639612,
-0.0407551527,
0.0194223374,
-0.0285000335,
-0.0234235525,
-0.0153974891,
-0.1135503501,
0.0478561111,
0.0266036484,
0.0030116658,
-0.0171766635,
-0.1016542464,
-0.006090478,
0.0093161399,
0.0453867167,
0.04364397,
-0.0063206381,
0.0065271123,
0.0371679477,
-0.0148827666,
-0.0404637828,
0.0518649966,
-0.090397276,
-0.0651142523,
0.007563381,
0.0110117616,
-0.0117512988,
-0.0484274775,
0.026069222,
0.0120252976,
0.0106446277,
0.0573587678,
-0.0215343107,
-0.0108846826,
-0.0292604826,
-0.0080711422,
-0.0068257134,
-0.042693302,
0.0575764738,
-0.0247038528,
-0.0104805287,
-0.056097161,
0.03238355,
0.0043216236,
-0.0310493801,
-0.0004277528,
-0.0625660196,
-0.0318314321,
0.0209932737,
-0.0018807013,
0.026465226,
-0.0879231617,
-0.040273454,
-0.0549659953,
0.025840776,
0.0355011001,
0.0338191018,
-0.0066820667,
-0.0890796781,
-0.0365314744,
0.0019122678,
0.0256573875,
-0.0049475725,
0.0143234981,
-0.0229971558,
-0.084555082,
0.0067103673,
-0.023949638,
-0.0407878794,
-0.0420221575,
-0.0263461024,
-0.0061558047,
0.0380286202,
-0.0040779919,
0.0252176225,
-0.0550961867,
-0.0081009697,
0.0426822156,
-0.0212767776,
-0.0017496742,
-0.0454615876,
0.010928221,
-0.0080493055,
-0.1013658866,
0.0879162997,
-0.0198046099,
0.0324901305,
0.0298467577,
0.0031406935,
0.0489096865,
-0.0198341478,
-0.0245200451,
-0.0126795527,
0.0163423084,
0.0246078745,
0.0261901971,
-0.0634988397,
0.0224259347,
0.0314608477,
-0.0072999774,
0.0267771408,
-0.0010413382,
0.0617208555,
-0.0826647952,
-0.0017375698,
-0.031833481,
0.0195712168,
-0.0587420762,
-0.0148308352,
-0.0473696999,
-0.0007469559,
-0.009498354,
-0.0503390655,
-0.0131390765,
-0.0162470117,
2.702e-7,
0.0011642772,
0.0567993484,
-0.0143515673,
-0.0331290588,
0.0096817166,
0.0572413355,
0.0159060434,
0.009276472,
0.0174788535,
-0.0472321287,
0.0206505861,
-0.001037281,
-0.0405575968,
0.0163480323,
0.0195961501,
-0.0285248645,
-0.0525443964,
-0.0080454992,
-0.001152404,
0.0077897464,
0.0113293752,
-0.0075125312,
-0.0214400031,
-0.015877746,
0.0019729745,
0.063005805,
0.0445382819,
-0.0040330989,
0.0308505837,
0.0046507213,
0.0602031015,
0.0000510268,
0.0076633394,
0.0412228592,
-0.0004309676,
-0.0436073616,
-0.0176590849,
0.0806025267,
-0.0297046192,
-0.020069249,
-0.0004916228,
0.0335140079,
0.0301668681,
-0.0111898473,
0.020317167,
-0.0392227508,
-0.0614252277,
-0.0789877623,
-0.0128957629,
-0.007316723,
0.0142231695,
-0.0085353553,
-0.0338641256,
0.0160299186,
-0.0087908907,
0.0564116128,
0.0236175749,
-0.0186356902,
-0.0080656214,
0.0008353501,
0.0104554296,
-0.0648910925,
0.0282409806,
-0.0069886665,
-0.0326061063,
-0.0981013849,
0.02307784,
1.726504458e-34,
-0.0107787875,
0.0080403276,
0.0165126324,
-0.0124672493,
0.0377604701,
0.0417361856,
0.018704677,
-0.0153127834,
0.037095774,
0.0103480229,
-0.0468174629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14356v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14356v3 | Computer Vision Datasets and Models Exhibit Cultural and Linguistic Diversity in Perception | 2023-10-22T16:51:42 | 2024-03-09T20:47:30 | Andre Ye, Sebastin Santy, Jena D. Hwang, Amy X. Zhang, Ranjay Krishna | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Computer vision often treats human perception as homogeneous: an implicit
assumption that visual stimuli are perceived similarly by everyone. This
assumption is reflected in the way researchers collect datasets and train
vision models. By contrast, literature in cross-cultural psychology and
linguistics has provided evidence that people from different cultural
backgrounds observe vastly different concepts even when viewing the same visual
stimuli. In this paper, we study how these differences manifest themselves in
vision-language datasets and models, using language as a proxy for culture. By
comparing textual descriptions generated across 7 languages for the same
images, we find significant differences in the semantic content and linguistic
expression. When datasets are multilingual as opposed to monolingual,
descriptions have higher semantic coverage on average, where coverage is
measured using scene graphs, model embeddings, and linguistic taxonomies. For
example, multilingual descriptions have on average 29.9% more objects, 24.5%
more relations, and 46.0% more attributes than a set of monolingual captions.
When prompted to describe images in different languages, popular models (e.g.
LLaVA) inherit this bias and describe different parts of the image. Moreover,
finetuning models on captions from one language performs best on corresponding
test data from that language, while finetuning on multilingual data performs
consistently well across all test data compositions. Our work points towards
the need to account for and embrace the diversity of human perception in the
computer vision community. | [
0.0210321229,
0.0562388971,
-0.030867992,
0.0793512017,
-0.018850971,
0.0488985889,
0.0174793489,
-0.0013335841,
0.0028535719,
-0.0674211755,
-0.0371294804,
-0.0501933582,
0.0619662032,
0.0264026057,
0.0118182572,
-0.1147235185,
-0.0050394079,
0.0053684055,
-0.0023587209,
-0.0286400914,
0.0169237554,
0.01830866,
0.0534005426,
0.0032377418,
-0.0328929015,
0.0008129863,
0.0221778844,
-0.0071179694,
0.0252035744,
-0.0091713006,
-0.0123988977,
0.0324954763,
0.0095932558,
-0.010833499,
0.0000018439,
-0.0304157007,
0.0676893815,
-0.0091707278,
0.0516696908,
0.016685145,
0.0639324933,
-0.0430616289,
0.0279529355,
-0.0613495037,
-0.0398441777,
-0.0240309928,
0.0934254378,
0.0484728292,
-0.0235899836,
0.0001814186,
-0.0186152197,
-0.05262262,
-0.0611366928,
-0.0113742165,
0.0038111343,
-0.0097077908,
0.0323316269,
0.0542686172,
-0.0146210343,
-0.0195522998,
-0.092633605,
0.0061309538,
0.008105048,
0.0547639057,
-0.0076989885,
0.05366043,
-0.0500116274,
-0.0550397746,
0.0378791057,
0.0735944733,
-0.019669842,
-0.0059505613,
-0.0096374257,
-0.0048499606,
-0.0338230804,
0.0089778798,
-0.0155435614,
0.074065946,
-0.0341279358,
0.0172412135,
-0.0159152076,
-0.0022703176,
0.0072394805,
0.0176793672,
-0.016322311,
0.0029799431,
-0.0057631778,
0.0265758298,
-0.0333498046,
0.0095024668,
-0.0319275595,
-0.0382520072,
-0.0150820985,
-0.0261642337,
0.0283447467,
-0.009852428,
-0.0235444698,
-0.0066277757,
0.0257558413,
-0.030136317,
0.0254097637,
0.0169596765,
-0.1006401703,
0.0536871217,
-0.0176198464,
0.08195135,
-0.0010072797,
0.0313234292,
-0.062073417,
-0.0398760699,
-0.0429380126,
0.0087807365,
0.0295569394,
-0.0396395251,
-0.0147048337,
0.0005931255,
-0.0736264959,
0.0069217444,
-0.0460898913,
0.0045203539,
-0.0361037925,
-0.0098390663,
-0.045131322,
0.0130644357,
-0.0224020947,
0.0109837493,
-0.0427331626,
0.0116667449,
-0.0564612187,
-0.0784598887,
0.0266336109,
0.0237599742,
-0.0086786719,
-0.0043238183,
-0.0052300687,
0.0307651348,
0.001174841,
-0.0153876124,
-0.0198121481,
-0.0132043362,
-0.0398479551,
-0.0439471602,
0.0328382365,
-0.0806247443,
0.0460033007,
0.0266990736,
0.0291242432,
-0.0589286722,
-0.0218063481,
-0.0019537807,
-0.0538825914,
0.0873716474,
-0.00819794,
0.0148404669,
0.0139512112,
0.0113373837,
-0.0260123778,
0.0969828516,
0.01192577,
0.0394526906,
0.065042384,
0.0187494308,
-0.0009088495,
0.0137598952,
-0.0457600504,
0.0174666587,
-0.04488381,
0.0089476006,
0.0029718787,
-0.0027882303,
0.0431139544,
0.0301886834,
-0.0252639633,
-0.0274402667,
0.0430205986,
0.0791701674,
-0.0255890153,
0.0265949164,
0.0195815098,
0.0077936021,
-0.0104414597,
0.0225817859,
-0.0352695808,
0.0511136316,
0.0316707008,
0.0137184272,
-0.0499513,
0.0645939261,
-0.0440706722,
-0.0027031619,
-0.0312254205,
-0.0208968632,
0.0394663438,
0.0031335214,
0.0405282415,
-0.0064137573,
0.0505993702,
0.0032337816,
0.0677817389,
-0.0238153171,
-0.0135603081,
-0.0254768003,
0.0261481721,
0.0466810726,
-0.0377476215,
0.0264339074,
0.022054296,
0.0143571217,
0.0444658324,
0.0310194157,
0.0350238904,
0.0200414639,
0.0334830992,
-0.0478878804,
-0.0520631559,
-0.0425650291,
0.0025940596,
0.0654425994,
-0.0201160442,
0.0208802447,
0.0433353633,
-0.0279017985,
-0.0590106696,
0.0195690468,
-0.0076476363,
0.0278904866,
-0.016312696,
0.0283201784,
0.0033156311,
-0.0147173032,
-0.0174006056,
-0.0053333552,
-0.0278747361,
-0.0007544031,
0.0242956746,
0.0773415789,
-0.020012591,
-0.001385806,
0.0365299955,
-0.100859791,
-0.0110411476,
-0.0141275087,
-0.011837963,
0.0006430076,
0.026866395,
-0.0137894554,
-0.0256593451,
-0.035738036,
-0.0115993079,
-0.0371879861,
0.0268225633,
0.0026187222,
0.0643644929,
-0.0089241415,
0.0281950682,
-0.002369256,
-0.0373220742,
0.0546530336,
-0.0128020858,
-0.0458892882,
0.0559716299,
0.0263716877,
0.0144966384,
0.0295269284,
0.0199960247,
-0.0317173824,
0.0244172495,
-0.0831467062,
-0.0416635759,
-0.0234473553,
-0.0340171717,
-0.0145584056,
-0.0124193188,
-0.0102590462,
-0.0349676348,
-0.0631291345,
0.0305454656,
-0.0210691914,
0.0656316355,
0.0167799965,
0.0096443947,
0.0028706989,
0.0216113143,
-0.0043530781,
0.0324814357,
0.0781483948,
0.0099880593,
-0.0536445826,
-0.0518560335,
0.0048892731,
-0.0602254868,
0.0239106398,
-0.0303398818,
-0.0373029709,
0.0076052672,
0.0264663175,
0.0094076805,
0.0632847548,
-0.0357957594,
0.0017529589,
0.0773066953,
0.0041754055,
-0.0150633017,
-0.039391607,
0.0209457017,
-0.0327351019,
0.0218103267,
-0.090409115,
-0.0358482189,
0.0245712399,
-0.0027807935,
-0.0056551439,
-0.0582141355,
0.031116154,
-0.0770807788,
-0.0529041067,
-0.0384896547,
-0.0017628712,
0.0225178506,
0.1005813256,
-0.0474332757,
-0.0424328744,
0.0599848703,
-0.0010984439,
-0.0103457654,
0.0088229971,
0.0203975551,
-0.032395415,
0.0748926327,
0.0172724016,
0.043970976,
0.007173351,
0.0296042282,
-0.0703203604,
-0.019524226,
0.0763906389,
-0.008892742,
0.0538697392,
-0.0408858918,
-0.0376877785,
-0.052850958,
-0.0392020009,
-0.0204712655,
-0.0049989773,
-0.021955546,
-0.0046601412,
-0.0216959026,
-0.0023765888,
-0.0021843391,
0.0262204334,
0.0239585936,
-0.0091632707,
-0.0095530609,
0.0184727628,
0.018338412,
-0.0185124539,
0.0453192778,
-0.0063563352,
-0.006713171,
-0.0336795337,
0.0014159498,
0.0162774548,
-0.015572085,
0.0052899653,
-0.0205450356,
0.0389664248,
0.0230390988,
0.0467166826,
-0.0440897569,
-0.0001560333,
0.0594039224,
-0.0125504462,
0.0144506143,
0.0419365913,
0.00095552,
-0.0552383661,
-0.0165861696,
-0.0357780568,
0.0010835133,
0.0534016527,
0.0105115566,
-0.0896901637,
0.0148837138,
-0.0237504374,
-0.0254086852,
0.0094810994,
-0.0091158142,
-0.0192011669,
-0.0768023655,
0.0192560554,
0.0320094004,
-0.0618422255,
-0.0621379055,
-0.0119567607,
0.0082735233,
-0.0138778156,
0.0169441551,
-0.0341315046,
0.003674278,
0.0050181742,
0.0015324721,
0.0116027091,
-0.041231513,
0.0194376819,
-0.0549562573,
-0.0083049312,
0.0376545414,
0.0335750207,
-0.0155759137,
-0.046697244,
-0.0053974106,
-0.0103555173,
0.0027365359,
0.011733748,
0.0435342714,
0.0110263797,
-0.0658205375,
0.0272723585,
-0.0139205102,
0.0190875679,
-0.0153798051,
-0.0251931995,
0.0082688443,
0.0009807502,
-0.0117603149,
-0.0290572308,
0.004932269,
-0.0040545943,
0.0294523444,
0.0202749241,
-0.0138091026,
0.0092828535,
-0.0146729061,
-0.0301074963,
-0.0102246618,
-0.0297753122,
0.0721271932,
-0.0613374263,
-0.0565234907,
-0.0579219833,
-0.0588945709,
0.011162064,
-0.0283293743,
0.0428246558,
-0.0509989634,
-0.0008236778,
0.0030896917,
-0.0742018223,
0.0772077069,
-0.0141222645,
0.0235066693,
0.0382365994,
-0.0226488598,
0.0284885708,
-0.0454123989,
0.0050110705,
0.004900299,
-0.0411944613,
-0.0426917113,
-0.0048848982,
0.0331230499,
0.0023359442,
0.0280050468,
0.0462452099,
-0.0450626537,
0.0066103563,
0.0297788549,
0.0300102811,
0.0191514064,
-0.0088642109,
-0.0101359012,
-0.0074013639,
0.0480598547,
-0.0549890883,
0.0349933803,
0.0522474088,
-0.0368743651,
-0.0157106332,
-0.0508321114,
-0.0010654527,
0.0043259701,
0.0349790119,
-0.0573878139,
0.0172462426,
-0.0262684468,
-0.0417864807,
-0.0081721582,
-0.0350753814,
-0.0197742376,
-0.0306655597,
0.0190983303,
0.008153812,
0.0052034855,
0.0301782209,
0.0135030784,
0.0161076691,
-0.0539480709,
0.0077228565,
0.0345145315,
-0.0370822623,
-0.0146730635,
0.0539434366,
-0.0225845799,
0.0137228565,
-0.0465056486,
0.0078099095,
-0.0103009995,
0.0535119921,
0.028725246,
-0.008227543,
-0.0235352311,
0.011952078,
0.0128877712,
-0.045197729,
0.020291809,
0.0113128219,
0.0691836476,
-0.0636077672,
0.0476205274,
-0.0356351174,
-0.0169863869,
-0.0224121772,
0.027746819,
0.0091133649,
-0.0239321478,
0.0629644394,
0.0063643446,
-0.006707686,
-0.0348878279,
0.0804275572,
0.01235516,
0.0164244156,
0.0104564046,
-0.0510057025,
-0.0126041695,
0.0056426893,
0.0398683473,
-0.0183041058,
-0.0116233565,
0.0198713671,
-0.0500664748,
-0.0634178221,
0.0008121157,
-0.0051357266,
0.0234513078,
0.0456466265,
0.0597302131,
0.0542204827,
0.0086174589,
-0.0209661778,
-0.0237410255,
-0.0256395061,
-0.0237465296,
0.0147032132,
0.003495103,
-5.530889e-33,
-0.0152507387,
-0.0058623916,
-0.0091529042,
-0.0035726551,
-0.0067227688,
0.001117475,
-0.0105667673,
0.0293075349,
-0.0519740395,
0.0560518876,
0.0219675489,
0.0060395305,
0.0163446385,
0.0053825988,
0.0488369875,
0.0142111843,
0.0354701802,
0.025421584,
-0.0089182109,
-0.0165927671,
0.0315159075,
-0.0184067637,
0.0879304409,
-0.0767451525,
0.0238376055,
0.0193458777,
0.0140030002,
0.000144512,
0.0431197844,
0.0614760444,
-0.0358323157,
0.0674553141,
0.0526357368,
0.0261226241,
-0.0333771817,
-0.0192064736,
-0.0422796607,
-0.0392981768,
0.0350416973,
0.0807042792,
-0.0246590395,
-0.0200793687,
0.023062015,
-0.0531274043,
-0.017925309,
-0.008852642,
0.0710094944,
-0.0603464916,
-0.0135033717,
-0.003996178,
-0.0247046985,
0.0148592694,
0.0114788227,
-0.0032548786,
0.0741263703,
0.0336633399,
0.009967315,
0.0367501415,
-0.0220220443,
0.0512320548,
-0.0053509353,
0.0250289422,
0.0677823052,
0.0600663684,
0.0442589708,
0.0551293269,
0.0552802943,
0.0253182501,
0.008174682,
-0.0452971421,
0.0250495095,
0.0277809091,
0.0149020385,
0.1140667424,
0.0226908848,
-0.0299357884,
-0.0286781192,
-0.0155552998,
-0.0684681907,
0.0597602129,
0.0230185296,
0.0186659265,
-0.0400242694,
-0.0294922385,
-0.037077494,
-0.0111541143,
-0.0408538394,
-0.0040214355,
0.0195926558,
-0.0071285325,
0.0054970323,
0.0474524908,
0.0344764367,
-0.0712228492,
-0.0258720275,
-0.0116504449,
-0.0180338155,
0.0163472444,
0.0226842463,
0.0051867715,
-0.0174419582,
-0.0477093235,
-0.0191154275,
0.0425272062,
0.0173228402,
0.020773435,
0.065099515,
-0.0157957468,
-0.0431935787,
-0.0044151735,
-0.0414864756,
-0.0476743542,
0.0084512662,
0.0164543185,
0.0294819009,
0.0197772048,
-0.0441778488,
-0.0062987204,
0.0417739339,
-0.0427562669,
-0.0273192804,
-0.0618620738,
-0.0240841974,
0.038121067,
-0.0389466025,
0.0055706734,
-0.054493621,
-0.0150362775,
0.0620940253,
0.000467885,
-0.0270182043,
0.0076479334,
2.564e-7,
0.0175201092,
0.0231949147,
-0.0179335419,
0.0256239083,
0.0235991292,
0.0397293232,
-0.0356291011,
0.0112869609,
-0.0071586706,
-0.0403052568,
-0.0105478764,
0.036735408,
0.0381088816,
0.0081246039,
-0.0367559828,
0.037445467,
-0.0054094391,
-0.0008616443,
-0.0447075069,
0.0051760878,
0.0334290676,
0.0736330748,
-0.0217733495,
0.0065279938,
-0.0010410709,
-0.0734261721,
0.0839356631,
-0.0816628113,
-0.0043217707,
-0.010384067,
0.0051850132,
0.0334117003,
0.000228244,
0.0573973209,
0.0072498047,
-0.0122026214,
0.0623733513,
0.002953785,
-0.0203222148,
0.0530435964,
-0.0065979119,
0.0184417553,
-0.0326937661,
-0.0922130942,
0.0566621311,
-0.0338645615,
-0.03192636,
-0.0348585583,
0.0127237523,
0.0128215235,
0.0920668989,
-0.032302361,
-0.0219482835,
0.0253798869,
0.0368395746,
-0.0091619836,
-0.0303533636,
-0.0233003329,
-0.017356813,
0.0092499582,
-0.0052505946,
-0.0343587995,
-0.0260626581,
0.0061393413,
0.0447743163,
-0.0010207073,
-0.0146787567,
1.659234383e-34,
0.0221908074,
0.0034286208,
-0.0015325366,
-0.0303929709,
0.0044844225,
-0.0541149564,
0.0007908567,
0.0147467619,
-0.0115503902,
0.0073013408,
-0.0083437935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14346v1 | The Law and NLP: Bridging Disciplinary Disconnects | 2023-10-22T16:34:31 | 2023-10-22T16:34:31 | Robert Mahari, Dominik Stammbach, Elliott Ash, Alex 'Sandy' Pentland | cs.CL | cs.CL | Legal practice is intrinsically rooted in the fabric of language, yet legal
practitioners and scholars have been slow to adopt tools from natural language
processing (NLP). At the same time, the legal system is experiencing an access
to justice crisis, which could be partially alleviated with NLP. In this
position paper, we argue that the slow uptake of NLP in legal practice is
exacerbated by a disconnect between the needs of the legal community and the
focus of NLP researchers. In a review of recent trends in the legal NLP
literature, we find limited overlap between the legal NLP community and legal
academia. Our interpretation is that some of the most popular legal NLP tasks
fail to address the needs of legal practitioners. We discuss examples of legal
NLP tasks that promise to bridge disciplinary disconnects and highlight
interesting areas for legal NLP research that remain underexplored. | [
0.0841112658,
0.0452994779,
-0.0097924946,
-0.0014076207,
-0.0810620412,
0.0276801363,
0.0004327529,
0.055263184,
-0.0058963154,
-0.1030766368,
0.0518835075,
0.0142104384,
0.0029722683,
-0.0202053022,
0.015624621,
-0.0422419831,
-0.0189368315,
0.0577574186,
0.0733542219,
0.0078967111,
0.0449112318,
0.0642227754,
-0.0073355455,
0.0409034863,
-0.0277107172,
0.0025685949,
0.0081423577,
0.0032970356,
-0.0266767107,
-0.0034345703,
-0.0374770202,
0.0778454766,
0.0169279892,
0.002015138,
0.0000016303,
-0.0833863989,
0.031334877,
-0.0093230549,
-0.0251916107,
-0.0022036307,
0.0467605665,
-0.067672424,
-0.0326348767,
-0.0267948508,
-0.0402030014,
0.0555286668,
0.0407687388,
0.0038763152,
0.0012775755,
0.0590629987,
-0.0097371917,
-0.0680105314,
0.0387554318,
-0.0088432916,
-0.0117622735,
0.0043371315,
0.0187775679,
0.0085194288,
0.0611062497,
-0.0277929399,
0.0206986982,
0.0390036479,
0.0304458998,
-0.049431216,
-0.0190826021,
-0.0137163224,
-0.0307678226,
0.0118764406,
-0.0111056603,
0.0029901708,
0.0828827098,
-0.0207197759,
-0.0067774872,
-0.0044757193,
0.0424502753,
0.0186367519,
-0.0128184604,
0.0930385888,
-0.0315413252,
0.0057959231,
0.0113307489,
0.0257950891,
0.0001236888,
0.0351725519,
0.0114322249,
0.0298158452,
-0.0072396868,
-0.0403228812,
0.053183075,
0.0142464796,
0.0327202715,
-0.0177858509,
0.0361848399,
0.0282398071,
0.0231725257,
0.0598500371,
-0.0160176456,
-0.0261986647,
0.0955034718,
-0.0456292965,
0.0316219665,
-0.0197068341,
-0.0143186459,
0.0427862667,
-0.0390060246,
-0.0160652958,
-0.0029179431,
0.0130963353,
0.0151675008,
-0.0226324424,
-0.0472368486,
-0.0393187441,
-0.0424450189,
0.0176170189,
-0.0972425118,
0.0156830177,
0.0037490767,
-0.016785128,
-0.0246653613,
0.0197205897,
-0.0180412773,
0.0036635469,
-0.0115823895,
-0.0379307084,
-0.0557672121,
-0.0527653918,
-0.0228080079,
0.0359144621,
-0.0138042346,
-0.0313765965,
0.0437864102,
0.0117341066,
-0.0257240329,
0.0014389167,
-0.0074182856,
0.1039522141,
0.0022279061,
-0.0348660052,
-0.0337884314,
-0.0769218132,
-0.0529851355,
-0.0422775559,
-0.0185518451,
-0.0515379682,
-0.0189732146,
-0.0124509325,
-0.0214310344,
-0.075724639,
0.023814423,
0.0539658964,
-0.0192530919,
0.0553534627,
-0.0374248177,
-0.0380351655,
-0.0483947545,
0.0133666685,
0.0700226799,
-0.004917392,
-0.0080682803,
-0.0263087153,
0.0280087646,
-0.0043092049,
0.0048320452,
0.0179906487,
-0.0198077597,
-0.0072832811,
0.0050871558,
0.008702809,
-0.0027724402,
0.0225632209,
0.0161593147,
0.0589639023,
-0.000708197,
0.0081127565,
-0.0157178901,
0.1147098616,
0.0141368816,
0.0623362251,
0.0137032894,
-0.0066547329,
0.0070280586,
-0.0060339528,
-0.047078494,
0.0066036102,
-0.0096907057,
0.0036199135,
-0.0644256696,
0.0195403416,
0.0242595114,
-0.0630380511,
-0.0397726409,
0.028652193,
0.0097573688,
-0.0256836955,
-0.0328968242,
0.0415849946,
0.0037617525,
0.0254091527,
0.0283087045,
-0.0514621809,
-0.0246803537,
-0.0121095777,
-0.0522982404,
0.0527235307,
0.0237511657,
-0.0006757256,
0.0166266542,
-0.0228972696,
-0.0126482006,
0.0845987722,
-0.0138205765,
0.0243419744,
-0.0138783101,
0.0062623974,
-0.0087640323,
-0.0039511002,
0.0099774962,
-0.0423142537,
-0.002044661,
0.0104641952,
0.0320954137,
-0.0396455489,
-0.0356146358,
0.0459007658,
0.0099343657,
-0.0340859741,
-0.0164014194,
0.012562451,
-0.0054841349,
0.0471052714,
0.0076592471,
-0.0017591722,
0.0187740605,
-0.0028177737,
0.0069227484,
0.020791512,
0.0371284634,
0.0218344666,
0.0451945923,
-0.0519579276,
-0.0214964245,
-0.0318640396,
-0.0069093751,
0.0075846883,
-0.0089096176,
-0.0357544832,
0.0341495499,
-0.030529676,
-0.0448215865,
-0.0090765292,
-0.0240497105,
-0.0377424695,
0.0135098286,
0.0030151256,
-0.010482043,
-0.0071130535,
-0.0210491326,
0.0295494087,
0.0300372839,
-0.0385341309,
0.0094278436,
-0.0028424615,
0.0072412104,
0.0422155038,
0.018938031,
-0.0476058386,
-0.0290228818,
0.0023299297,
-0.0158485584,
-0.0094327722,
-0.0116952313,
0.0000597031,
-0.0394548848,
-0.0040058787,
-0.0165124331,
0.0241840277,
-0.0425786003,
-0.0061284527,
-0.0275105387,
0.0196993202,
-0.0055047306,
-0.0395298675,
0.0046417275,
-0.0186445601,
-0.008544296,
-0.0041534491,
0.0078650517,
-0.0298094023,
-0.0256407186,
0.0489092469,
-0.0103409821,
-0.0426563174,
-0.010594774,
0.017746171,
-0.0023297216,
0.0497345515,
-0.063728109,
-0.0008287812,
0.0227334686,
0.0317768753,
-0.0136726843,
-0.0227172561,
-0.0255080517,
-0.0156583171,
0.0307391677,
0.0132125858,
-0.0388298556,
-0.0229170062,
0.0259724073,
-0.0285627209,
-0.0111463619,
0.0248792525,
-0.0020985103,
0.0057996861,
-0.0401241593,
-0.0061939722,
-0.0089840144,
-0.04223869,
-0.0356916115,
0.0347437933,
0.0323856659,
-0.0413567796,
0.0568167977,
0.0156768057,
0.0326271243,
-0.0633971468,
-0.0313280486,
-0.021595994,
0.1264899522,
-0.0408957154,
0.0203143265,
0.0369390734,
-0.0812801421,
0.0440809429,
-0.0340180621,
0.0585005395,
-0.0268414598,
0.0984419286,
-0.0169886257,
0.0787434727,
-0.0195917394,
-0.0260363184,
-0.0185833853,
-0.0022535133,
-0.0234820861,
0.053391397,
0.0221578032,
0.0206789896,
-0.0230703838,
-0.0420903116,
-0.0183436647,
-0.032483831,
0.0485580303,
-0.0128346002,
-0.0418838076,
-0.0078297518,
-0.0060509569,
-0.0075861057,
0.0155772055,
0.037298061,
-0.019014867,
0.0150837833,
-0.0287041888,
-0.0151542453,
0.0364180505,
0.0117760887,
0.0200786442,
-0.0738931298,
-0.0241730884,
0.0443196446,
0.0146275526,
-0.0585122034,
0.0124380868,
0.0656643808,
0.0170331839,
0.0049393065,
-0.011559709,
-0.0055445032,
-0.0229604468,
0.0284929872,
0.0229100659,
-0.1115334406,
0.0178796928,
-0.0164217185,
-0.0202739816,
-0.0744012371,
-0.0204917584,
-0.0245207213,
-0.0693753511,
0.0864046291,
0.001703932,
0.0022239974,
-0.0353665724,
0.0053010769,
-0.0192047525,
0.0269106887,
0.062684238,
-0.0142235234,
-0.0590864345,
0.0075356266,
0.0427289344,
-0.056535352,
0.019339649,
-0.005633377,
-0.0318433642,
0.0526804104,
0.0014958874,
0.0313091315,
-0.0370808691,
-0.0153506771,
-0.0088270968,
0.0009205382,
0.0215312261,
0.0018568921,
-0.0073868507,
0.0051229056,
0.0270323902,
-0.0659014583,
0.0171770453,
-0.051756043,
-0.0461381897,
0.0247575697,
0.0278153345,
-0.0393940546,
0.0150933899,
-0.0347096138,
-0.0014265326,
-0.0097058099,
0.024492126,
0.0089243585,
0.0306489896,
-0.024701545,
-0.0428783186,
0.0057618022,
-0.0044621564,
-0.0752992406,
-0.024320798,
-0.0082279546,
0.0130560966,
-0.0174362473,
-0.0482536107,
0.016774321,
0.0438735038,
0.0412553027,
0.0125217875,
0.0219746977,
-0.0317772031,
-0.0637264773,
0.0119855925,
-0.0378868654,
0.0032732249,
0.0420733392,
0.0017435106,
-0.0160155892,
0.0579108261,
0.021699179,
0.0008986571,
0.0347157195,
-0.0134706609,
0.0180220194,
-0.0110806273,
0.0186143778,
-0.033163406,
-0.0131910527,
-0.0559686236,
-0.0028810105,
0.0689116567,
-0.0152260372,
-0.0008518908,
0.0357908718,
-0.0111690843,
-0.0130210193,
-0.0090258997,
0.0168429576,
-0.0020447199,
0.0074550053,
0.0164667927,
-0.0053011044,
-0.0085665882,
0.06133008,
0.0396339297,
-0.0220263079,
-0.0317103975,
-0.0071233977,
-0.00731976,
-0.0647179186,
0.0046078288,
-0.0302273165,
-0.0173011553,
0.000215272,
-0.0171737988,
0.0013944918,
-0.0373726115,
0.0780295432,
-0.0501031019,
0.0303102061,
-0.033285331,
0.0582305714,
0.0474411286,
-0.0051233536,
-0.0152211506,
-0.0254705809,
0.0227737501,
0.0358803496,
-0.0289836936,
0.0681424364,
0.0069208941,
0.0244236942,
0.0205750596,
-0.0122994492,
-0.0200984776,
0.0010746836,
-0.0135777453,
-0.0430124477,
0.0154434461,
0.0222421177,
0.0334886014,
-0.0074795517,
0.0070066629,
-0.0218584538,
0.0241153333,
0.0252310969,
-0.0014926314,
-0.0142551474,
-0.0621752068,
0.0537773296,
0.0002839715,
-0.0332066752,
-0.0123710111,
-0.0019600762,
-0.0314783864,
0.030665271,
0.0024147106,
0.0150306169,
0.0159311127,
-0.0743553489,
-0.0037697335,
0.0254634321,
-0.0059300051,
-0.0311124306,
-0.11755611,
-0.0356860235,
-0.0244855527,
-0.030828651,
0.0066392706,
-0.003790803,
-0.0132247191,
0.0442643277,
0.0770760998,
-0.0496935993,
-0.0327333547,
0.0735962391,
0.0164563693,
0.0006862744,
-0.0133583453,
-4.889165695e-33,
-0.0341637172,
-0.0704720169,
0.0318584442,
0.0098359957,
-0.009286901,
-0.0184971765,
0.0102611603,
0.0340671204,
-0.0045387545,
0.0549486056,
-0.0322718322,
0.0244705975,
0.0172489267,
-0.0143096736,
0.0442766324,
-0.0206613578,
-0.017127987,
0.0155991642,
0.0091186725,
-0.022216225,
-0.0039998977,
-0.0049967803,
0.0499835685,
-0.0870113298,
0.0945896655,
0.0892520249,
-0.0239819773,
-0.0411392562,
-0.0216532685,
0.0032529277,
-0.0170179401,
0.0743003339,
0.0006252788,
-0.0501239263,
-0.0192127675,
0.0567743406,
-0.0438151583,
0.0183154363,
0.0737932399,
-0.0181579404,
0.0012251294,
-0.0404470935,
0.0446302295,
0.000556853,
-0.0541635975,
0.0238404553,
0.0404170752,
-0.0158312358,
-0.0131691396,
-0.0565716065,
-0.1075661406,
0.0495668761,
-0.023167694,
0.0484612249,
0.0323417634,
-0.0441229045,
-0.0095775304,
0.0083424738,
-0.0862971023,
-0.0187867824,
-0.0370370448,
-0.0259442143,
0.0264436044,
-0.0839151815,
-0.0405618474,
0.0656604022,
-0.0225135814,
0.0257964563,
0.0056089438,
0.0166436601,
0.0600634441,
0.0735273212,
0.0053166868,
0.032746233,
0.0075659296,
-0.0413725339,
-0.0113058034,
-0.0471020602,
0.0249749273,
0.0151363704,
0.0022513284,
-0.033635471,
-0.0313068107,
-0.0317823142,
-0.0429776907,
-0.0305212252,
0.0188148543,
0.0031444167,
-0.0054774517,
-0.006938457,
0.0427897051,
0.0075909775,
-0.0597846322,
-0.0347545296,
-0.012557338,
0.0025093753,
0.0016051095,
0.0035590336,
-0.0253203101,
0.0259245839,
-0.0695487931,
-0.0073078414,
0.0117643028,
-0.0021736259,
0.018272711,
-0.0376284458,
0.0183364898,
-0.0171056613,
-0.0424529724,
-0.0133618526,
-0.0050601643,
0.0479463339,
0.0501979366,
-0.0122026149,
0.0417041406,
0.0497705974,
0.0272738989,
-0.0148423892,
0.039200481,
-0.0372047834,
0.0061270166,
0.0281067807,
0.0024566632,
-0.023787979,
-0.0354712717,
0.0054871207,
0.0057595824,
0.0609671138,
0.0553508811,
0.0325549915,
0.0115183648,
0.0253808573,
2.325e-7,
0.1117232889,
0.0298036896,
0.0082165096,
-0.0058164285,
-0.0164100491,
0.0095580826,
0.0580313616,
0.0335995331,
0.0205631498,
-0.0594272688,
-0.0135833379,
-0.0133814728,
0.0246363264,
0.0256338883,
-0.0621843003,
0.0096528484,
-0.010939097,
-0.0452635214,
-0.0679572597,
0.0772746429,
0.0428237692,
0.0446706526,
0.0176829677,
-0.0228364114,
-0.0495724715,
-0.0186982453,
-0.0009895531,
-0.0362321101,
0.0028403422,
-0.0220494121,
0.0935301706,
-0.025427321,
0.0328415036,
0.0423262902,
0.0152885169,
0.0430447161,
-0.0372070819,
0.0351679213,
-0.0000997698,
0.0345061049,
-0.0458861552,
-0.0630599186,
0.003799977,
-0.0010779101,
0.0232074782,
0.0084787002,
-0.0254314877,
-0.0091368165,
-0.047926981,
-0.019596085,
0.015799094,
0.0367680266,
-0.0361347273,
0.0091809649,
0.03936968,
-0.032649029,
0.0207212139,
-0.0931487083,
0.0113140782,
0.0526698977,
0.0360816903,
0.0510042645,
-0.0001638587,
-0.0003079229,
0.0492442995,
-0.0688471943,
0.0259319469,
1.759906635e-34,
0.0055439565,
-0.0184462722,
0.0471802503,
0.0626191199,
0.0257677399,
0.0722785145,
-0.0178163163,
0.0193840824,
-0.0255213566,
-0.0307128672,
0.0338142104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14340v1 | Social Commonsense-Guided Search Query Generation for Open-Domain Knowledge-Powered Conversations | 2023-10-22T16:14:56 | 2023-10-22T16:14:56 | Revanth Gangi Reddy, Hao Bai, Wentao Yao, Sharath Chandra Etagi Suresh, Heng Ji, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-domain dialog involves generating search queries that help obtain
relevant knowledge for holding informative conversations. However, it can be
challenging to determine what information to retrieve when the user is passive
and does not express a clear need or request. To tackle this issue, we present
a novel approach that focuses on generating internet search queries that are
guided by social commonsense. Specifically, we leverage a commonsense dialog
system to establish connections related to the conversation topic, which
subsequently guides our query generation. Our proposed framework addresses
passive user interactions by integrating topic tracking, commonsense response
generation and instruction-driven query generation. Through extensive
evaluations, we show that our approach overcomes limitations of existing query
generation techniques that rely solely on explicit dialog information, and
produces search queries that are more relevant, specific, and compelling,
ultimately resulting in more engaging responses. | [
0.0790466294,
0.0442146808,
-0.0003691019,
0.0103293844,
0.0217101127,
-0.0296039246,
-0.0188832674,
0.0051687779,
0.0463522114,
-0.0449961051,
-0.010183474,
-0.0008860501,
-0.034950085,
0.0391101949,
-0.0074234372,
-0.0555442683,
0.0220098607,
0.0016045393,
-0.0138307717,
0.0299329534,
0.0278501641,
0.0242453851,
-0.0168662407,
0.0429427139,
0.0046727536,
-0.000709902,
-0.0426520817,
0.0327099785,
-0.0256360527,
-0.0343368687,
0.0379543081,
0.0569486991,
0.0007442588,
0.0176903345,
0.0000017393,
-0.0413209908,
0.0326812379,
-0.0271820743,
0.0021259715,
-0.0116314664,
0.0358947553,
0.0624812283,
0.0423592739,
0.0146107934,
-0.0642559975,
0.0512729958,
0.0273207985,
0.0306128711,
0.0525356568,
0.0220066551,
-0.0142980013,
-0.0145640206,
-0.0275743678,
-0.0141485073,
0.0814441442,
-0.0803521574,
-0.0171085596,
-0.0313997194,
0.0463886671,
0.0409924537,
0.0404228717,
0.0336882658,
-0.0247044526,
-0.1016686857,
0.0223888475,
0.017412005,
-0.039594356,
-0.0142907714,
0.0001324471,
0.0951087326,
0.0819847435,
0.0101491781,
0.0288797859,
0.0103014791,
0.0317644998,
0.0852394849,
-0.070886381,
-0.017565446,
-0.0147133423,
-0.0136452504,
-0.0176202264,
0.0063282172,
-0.0041143447,
0.0282949954,
0.0382023342,
0.0446741208,
0.0035402239,
-0.0091082379,
-0.025689574,
-0.0146875214,
0.0442969464,
-0.0440224223,
0.0228048638,
0.0404005535,
-0.0559272803,
0.0276519172,
0.0003887589,
-0.0019556643,
0.0274083726,
-0.0754670203,
-0.0331219621,
0.0235051773,
0.0139842499,
0.0335260145,
0.0392948054,
-0.0208166931,
0.0163119454,
-0.0225421209,
-0.0267448965,
-0.0070578116,
-0.0555879176,
-0.0130523965,
-0.039093215,
0.0365319327,
-0.0865363926,
-0.0138882073,
0.0053006168,
0.0364965238,
0.0257442258,
-0.0028449013,
-0.0078168903,
0.0668810904,
-0.0544189028,
-0.0021843361,
-0.0444008745,
0.0089279367,
-0.0342674851,
-0.010198921,
0.0362651981,
-0.026755143,
-0.0101425573,
0.0090440381,
0.0376846902,
0.004165059,
-0.0442331657,
-0.0129373893,
-0.0392483287,
-0.0158987883,
-0.0541897602,
-0.0537079833,
0.0188294388,
0.0261342525,
-0.0070694904,
-0.0141558452,
0.0368474647,
0.0100328857,
-0.04162433,
0.0013055721,
0.029656522,
0.0860050544,
-0.0018916491,
0.0225770213,
-0.0306939594,
-0.0054585743,
0.0445937216,
0.0471523888,
0.0478105135,
0.0953467116,
-0.0116454186,
0.020654697,
0.0582978018,
0.0231775641,
0.0114308363,
-0.043734502,
0.0195406936,
0.0072528254,
0.0410475694,
0.0415048189,
-0.0273969565,
0.0198385008,
0.0019469196,
0.0117178364,
-0.0301718805,
0.0164730679,
0.0435632989,
0.0752411932,
-0.0108706253,
0.0292625017,
0.0137508539,
0.0328468867,
-0.0066872681,
0.0129500339,
-0.0020868359,
0.0261760782,
-0.0357775427,
-0.0385617651,
0.0006386391,
0.0008964617,
-0.0396972299,
-0.011166323,
0.0432544909,
0.0238164123,
0.033396408,
0.0054806178,
0.0185824856,
0.0147140259,
-0.0264116917,
0.0474046506,
0.0095383581,
-0.0806711018,
0.019214768,
-0.0147436354,
0.0103834709,
0.0695210919,
0.0756278858,
-0.0135244643,
-0.0712746531,
0.0145685086,
0.0307421573,
0.0453818291,
0.034585584,
-0.028542947,
0.0129003478,
-0.0492093116,
-0.0209116414,
0.0272162184,
-0.0009564629,
-0.0159434378,
0.0007051833,
-0.0070131491,
0.059501294,
-0.0434158333,
0.0183482412,
0.0006498936,
0.0164457988,
0.0126334308,
0.0051225265,
-0.000129649,
0.0134448949,
0.0622089505,
0.0587158948,
0.0122756436,
0.021099316,
0.0081388196,
-0.0374781676,
0.0389076658,
-0.0074656918,
-0.0083591556,
0.0045125689,
-0.030557368,
0.011560767,
-0.0109138945,
0.0257506929,
-0.0583613291,
0.0309132282,
-0.0502925217,
0.0658915862,
-0.0419797748,
-0.0295794178,
0.0222381297,
-0.0462384485,
-0.0364216156,
0.05176403,
0.0136911487,
-0.0268447921,
0.042953752,
-0.058983162,
-0.0131571842,
-0.0550278127,
0.0171183646,
-0.0057530235,
-0.000418612,
-0.0072579957,
0.0109278243,
0.0198221132,
-0.0597631298,
0.0075296592,
-0.1160421297,
-0.003660518,
-0.0225823857,
0.0093941707,
0.0069219726,
0.0727863461,
0.0172961671,
-0.0154648824,
-0.0457207821,
0.0022994,
0.029369466,
-0.021712387,
0.0212976746,
0.0454244837,
-0.013195415,
-0.0353452973,
0.0152049512,
0.0026607926,
0.0337201692,
0.056338869,
0.0313352719,
-0.0189565811,
0.0047042905,
-0.0683686733,
0.0028508336,
-0.0320141539,
-0.0362248383,
0.028778905,
-0.0068962998,
-0.0224161968,
0.0344979391,
0.0809776038,
0.0265752804,
-0.0215984751,
-0.0352886319,
-0.0754466876,
0.0238785986,
-0.0240620561,
0.0160087086,
-0.0012453662,
-0.0154241733,
0.0528662987,
-0.0100959437,
-0.0046160258,
0.0360272452,
-0.0592048466,
-0.0162002444,
0.0362454839,
-0.0153164156,
-0.0548664853,
0.008575039,
0.0114478907,
0.0379858389,
-0.0108606499,
-0.0129752634,
0.0555530228,
-0.0001430691,
-0.0175028834,
-0.0439281315,
0.0045196838,
-0.0241807867,
0.0467578135,
-0.047874406,
0.0327334702,
-0.0065575978,
-0.0429050028,
-0.0079896376,
-0.0139902532,
0.075250268,
-0.0404684097,
0.0282974783,
-0.0287220888,
0.03356288,
0.0312849358,
-0.0284192897,
-0.0339700431,
-0.0719318837,
0.0050197663,
-0.0178344417,
0.0517459586,
-0.0531674512,
-0.0127023179,
0.0030103722,
0.0366482809,
0.0217738654,
-0.0022094348,
-0.0383106023,
0.0037405503,
0.0046991073,
0.0409874395,
0.0179051906,
-0.0431281552,
0.0180727113,
0.0226451661,
0.0482325703,
0.0595826581,
-0.0852885917,
0.0426977128,
-0.0368127301,
0.0340029337,
-0.0124889137,
-0.0161156692,
0.0097631048,
0.0604161955,
-0.0171271414,
-0.031809032,
0.0753589869,
0.0641045645,
-0.0225499235,
-0.0215345081,
-0.0433340482,
0.0200472027,
-0.0081637511,
0.0363617539,
-0.0412833765,
-0.0283612646,
-0.0154352253,
0.0683563426,
-0.0122694382,
-0.0544381291,
0.0159967765,
-0.0885964334,
0.0078615434,
-0.0134471953,
0.0068761497,
-0.0196567401,
-0.0562017038,
0.0074065086,
0.0205458086,
-0.0447005332,
0.0377508216,
-0.024259232,
0.0023292834,
0.0016025499,
0.0329408199,
-0.0227141045,
-0.0111427084,
-0.0159997921,
0.038332127,
0.0435548685,
0.0613717251,
0.0590229668,
-0.0314072594,
-0.0387667827,
-0.0325728655,
0.0171303842,
-0.0418903865,
0.0238649212,
-0.0296278112,
0.0229040273,
-0.0828935355,
0.0365910493,
-0.0561979413,
-0.016316304,
0.0035333147,
0.0172921345,
-0.0707684159,
0.0180304293,
-0.0369896777,
0.0331267305,
0.0440844968,
0.0713787153,
0.0320421532,
0.011451412,
-0.0080197835,
-0.0429791771,
0.0247621313,
-0.0280191191,
-0.0152706364,
-0.0387391336,
0.0049679871,
0.026481878,
-0.0772677734,
-0.0201244559,
0.0245874766,
0.0342379883,
-0.0055779032,
-0.0207178146,
0.0393783599,
0.0170781631,
-0.0210828837,
0.0139666712,
-0.0142678125,
-0.0169291198,
-0.0358751453,
-0.0491250791,
0.0423126221,
-0.0518679582,
0.0002839327,
0.0122815818,
0.0146295363,
-0.0414085239,
-0.0563205071,
0.010490858,
0.0187010448,
0.0133039476,
-0.0273668412,
-0.0225635897,
-0.0200160556,
0.073298499,
-0.0582682192,
-0.03045341,
0.0291745272,
0.0401725322,
0.0093731843,
0.0565848686,
-0.0353494398,
-0.0483054034,
-0.0542360134,
0.0423590802,
-0.0646079704,
-0.066527009,
-0.0043619815,
0.0068736528,
0.0257610697,
0.0094000902,
0.0244595241,
-0.0184716806,
0.012608625,
-0.0443903729,
-0.0191741586,
-0.047821559,
0.0444726571,
-0.0430521145,
-0.0204888098,
0.0120129324,
0.0247258544,
-0.0751988441,
0.0612248331,
-0.0513499975,
0.0003239786,
-0.0239300597,
0.0049683754,
0.0104926173,
-0.0112027489,
0.0059041269,
0.026582079,
0.0135937119,
0.0308291465,
-0.0113915978,
0.0669503659,
0.0043411274,
-0.0350068249,
0.0209854003,
0.0153539181,
-0.0927181765,
-0.0217928272,
-0.0209451672,
0.0572095513,
-0.0057746796,
-0.0091379667,
0.0196668748,
-0.0135949384,
0.0139615769,
0.0283519421,
0.0594220795,
-0.0004331805,
-0.0317421295,
0.0149891255,
0.0324961133,
-0.0131129902,
-0.0149199162,
0.0728792697,
-0.0545317605,
0.0163123347,
-0.0240834784,
-0.0707335994,
-0.0393298529,
-0.0431279801,
0.0459107868,
0.0874958113,
-0.0125700943,
0.0020860734,
-0.0447807908,
0.0003003475,
-0.0182454474,
-0.0266531985,
-0.007907806,
-0.0036203398,
0.0962467864,
0.0998730138,
0.0025573189,
-0.0438873805,
-0.0227551609,
0.0111876363,
-0.1007185578,
0.006132233,
-0.061668139,
-5.674162659e-33,
-0.0267915148,
-0.0571333244,
0.0068650553,
0.0467057265,
-0.0402098522,
-0.0384487472,
-0.0795845836,
0.0145546375,
0.0012442097,
-0.0033435293,
-0.0150798941,
0.0440853573,
-0.0018060239,
0.0087584415,
-0.0270087272,
-0.0537788533,
0.0435361937,
-0.0064851213,
-0.0207542945,
0.0680007711,
0.077235058,
0.0031146794,
-0.0275996402,
-0.0447206907,
0.0360154696,
-0.0302054863,
0.0096673388,
0.0337281078,
0.0296913944,
0.0166946463,
0.0042748083,
0.057697922,
0.01293879,
0.0212687366,
0.0291726869,
0.0420257375,
-0.0274330769,
-0.0543179512,
0.0393575244,
-0.0339666232,
-0.0107027506,
0.0031426635,
0.013360492,
-0.0050669285,
0.0131748253,
0.0542529672,
0.0176982097,
0.006254768,
-0.0111998757,
-0.0354707614,
-0.0243617855,
0.0046755634,
-0.0366235822,
-0.0449944995,
-0.0651761442,
0.0396413654,
0.0345611982,
-0.0344844162,
0.0123628182,
0.0590975471,
-0.0246455837,
0.0288304109,
0.0259780046,
-0.0055316188,
0.0230789557,
0.0415247642,
-0.0078779347,
0.0213087238,
-0.0512704961,
0.004372539,
-0.0201777574,
0.0245848745,
0.0224981327,
0.0656739697,
-0.0327436626,
-0.0043947254,
-0.012904752,
0.0689374804,
0.01752677,
0.0233158711,
-0.0150917526,
0.0080385441,
-0.0530910678,
-0.0065554585,
-0.0060369158,
0.0019366042,
-0.024440283,
-0.016128622,
0.0167256594,
0.0108872475,
-0.0491932221,
-0.0263843909,
-0.0257586166,
0.0272618141,
0.0147501137,
0.0315231532,
-0.0002878887,
-0.0304380301,
0.0010399906,
-0.0422222205,
-0.0036866993,
0.015182375,
0.0447388813,
0.0102602132,
-0.0506993793,
0.0337403268,
-0.0611768849,
-0.0034465333,
0.0033140292,
-0.0207999591,
-0.0120436558,
0.032878831,
-0.0623150021,
-0.0563170984,
0.0295211859,
0.0137100769,
-0.0178143587,
0.0604254678,
-0.0069814385,
0.0308080912,
-0.0431165174,
-0.0629851818,
0.0300395526,
0.0131807374,
-0.0146897901,
0.0201644357,
-0.0066193272,
-0.0562268384,
0.0255943313,
-0.0389323346,
-0.0269170497,
0.0097716479,
2.481e-7,
-0.0262573529,
0.0156776756,
-0.0242390558,
0.0455097891,
-0.0178935397,
0.0543052368,
0.0330682732,
0.0097233756,
0.0365579166,
-0.0477044731,
0.0130836591,
0.0378361717,
0.0096840644,
0.0228795223,
-0.1028894857,
-0.0550649203,
-0.0369467027,
-0.0593051873,
-0.0303509794,
-0.0095625762,
0.0484079458,
-0.0174645651,
-0.0003700885,
0.0047647194,
0.0037695544,
-0.0418574065,
0.0321901888,
-0.0109425988,
-0.0232466813,
0.0013525062,
0.0296739992,
-0.026546929,
0.0119840484,
0.0196284298,
-0.030939579,
0.0079297498,
0.0109482799,
0.0135223372,
0.0082315458,
-0.0532092974,
-0.0204862002,
-0.0388530791,
0.0302636344,
-0.0430687331,
0.0343667008,
-0.0203383192,
0.0165886413,
0.0037876652,
-0.0027646073,
-0.0220634304,
-0.017458953,
-0.0172245037,
-0.049160827,
-0.0241182912,
-0.0233143568,
0.009113878,
0.0196109787,
-0.0420609713,
0.010791325,
-0.0342031121,
-0.0532119684,
-0.0650091469,
-0.061877124,
-0.0116706137,
-0.0275335182,
0.0270598941,
0.0213221572,
1.969322216e-34,
0.0038616124,
0.0310363937,
-0.0130554521,
0.0045599202,
0.0515636168,
0.0262471102,
-0.0254081003,
-0.0046580145,
0.0819409862,
-0.0745961517,
0.0170826446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14338v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14338v3 | From Chaos to Clarity: Claim Normalization to Empower Fact-Checking | 2023-10-22T16:07:06 | 2024-02-12T06:30:44 | Megha Sundriyal, Tanmoy Chakraborty, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rise of social media, users are exposed to many misleading claims.
However, the pervasive noise inherent in these posts presents a challenge in
identifying precise and prominent claims that require verification. Extracting
the important claims from such posts is arduous and time-consuming, yet it is
an underexplored problem. Here, we aim to bridge this gap. We introduce a novel
task, Claim Normalization (aka ClaimNorm), which aims to decompose complex and
noisy social media posts into more straightforward and understandable forms,
termed normalized claims. We propose CACN, a pioneering approach that leverages
chain-of-thought and claim check-worthiness estimation, mimicking human
reasoning processes, to comprehend intricate claims. Moreover, we capitalize on
the in-context learning capabilities of large language models to provide
guidance and to improve claim normalization. To evaluate the effectiveness of
our proposed model, we meticulously compile a comprehensive real-world dataset,
CLAN, comprising more than 6k instances of social media posts alongside their
respective normalized claims. Our experiments demonstrate that CACN outperforms
several baselines across various evaluation measures. Finally, our rigorous
error analysis validates CACN's capabilities and pitfalls. | [
0.0375253409,
0.0676687658,
0.0273271389,
0.0191509407,
-0.0301140342,
0.0133651569,
-0.0049195276,
-0.030291155,
0.0224679541,
-0.034657672,
0.0155647146,
-0.0119810971,
0.0387875587,
0.034442503,
0.0203209259,
-0.0441254973,
0.0200112052,
-0.001317027,
0.0811527744,
0.0037332484,
0.0136131421,
0.0309298318,
-0.0206731781,
0.0509604178,
-0.0623686425,
-0.0219851248,
0.0434917137,
0.0060015847,
0.0693772733,
-0.0384194404,
0.0090249861,
0.06997291,
0.0280572493,
0.0910774097,
0.0000016409,
-0.0525895357,
0.02242372,
0.0233809669,
-0.0213342812,
0.0379815958,
0.0307844952,
-0.0090707289,
0.0140378177,
0.0297140498,
-0.0092126261,
0.0001965095,
0.0145641081,
0.0651465207,
0.0913351327,
0.0994245857,
-0.0140432185,
-0.0447788015,
0.0059360978,
-0.0206577964,
-0.0340967178,
-0.0903692096,
0.0566009693,
0.0242490172,
-0.0181915369,
0.0087516541,
0.0267807748,
0.0338999517,
0.0223349929,
-0.02461561,
-0.0223865751,
0.0304544196,
-0.0173025616,
-0.0214028303,
0.016858289,
0.0630417615,
-0.0100501832,
-0.047892157,
0.0139464969,
-0.0045745624,
0.033231806,
0.0217779484,
-0.0268017165,
0.0726128295,
-0.0275119208,
0.0174304899,
0.0250974614,
0.0157255251,
0.0396071412,
0.0188322812,
0.006047667,
0.0356492363,
-0.0370292887,
-0.065955624,
0.0351010934,
0.0092686769,
-0.005913225,
-0.0695580319,
0.0405306928,
0.0145777548,
-0.0361166,
0.0229254514,
-0.0375522599,
-0.0242422335,
0.052691564,
-0.0802290365,
0.0089881076,
-0.0292765982,
-0.0410302356,
0.0850903615,
-0.0430760011,
-0.0070497324,
-0.0058710552,
-0.0283800941,
0.0257243421,
-0.0434470102,
-0.0453638323,
-0.0036734818,
-0.0163497645,
0.0271825697,
-0.0245551337,
-0.0054930071,
-0.033151377,
-0.0345410779,
-0.0294082146,
0.0311867148,
0.0048103086,
0.0110074142,
0.0164636392,
-0.0493299551,
-0.0339652859,
0.024676621,
-0.0144283427,
0.020488495,
0.0123165902,
-0.0195006914,
-0.0033618819,
0.0069426154,
0.0216977689,
0.0102352723,
-0.0053510629,
-0.0296446756,
0.0078667561,
-0.0106663052,
-0.0485559031,
-0.0250417553,
-0.0051646563,
-0.0422323197,
-0.0308058057,
-0.056989558,
0.0225523077,
-0.0223633442,
-0.013402408,
-0.0098485472,
-0.011672142,
0.0629413798,
-0.0644885749,
0.020595938,
-0.0058754859,
0.0082724551,
0.0355599709,
0.0222078674,
0.0167237427,
0.0402292982,
0.0286763422,
0.0570440516,
0.0476524383,
0.0302765146,
0.0257042553,
0.0184405241,
0.0554496348,
-0.0285226554,
0.0518811531,
-0.0004339971,
-0.0342084169,
-0.0018020219,
-0.0187688805,
0.0476330705,
-0.0158876106,
-0.0254355576,
0.0697802007,
0.0342177525,
-0.0458413288,
-0.0374778174,
0.0346546024,
0.0062475116,
0.0305518843,
-0.0323363878,
-0.0628058016,
0.0082960315,
-0.0740016475,
-0.0477874465,
0.0310481358,
0.041171439,
-0.0069883903,
-0.0447449647,
-0.0067009423,
0.0056438684,
0.0109983105,
0.0011895513,
-0.0034804952,
0.0417433716,
-0.0194455124,
0.0240830332,
0.0340701304,
-0.034476269,
-0.0279985629,
-0.0266611725,
0.0184442755,
-0.0314218141,
0.0188190732,
-0.0108206514,
0.0374545082,
-0.0350966342,
0.0584203154,
0.0555302538,
0.0535761379,
-0.0195870902,
-0.0024138542,
-0.0020014304,
-0.0244572982,
-0.0001986695,
0.0260865837,
-0.0463919342,
0.0536866859,
-0.0094678542,
0.0200332198,
-0.0361325666,
-0.0532944612,
0.0144550791,
0.0118587539,
0.0054540723,
0.0154778799,
0.0273152944,
0.0019595434,
0.0356531776,
0.0063335057,
-0.0131829148,
0.0067453803,
-0.0286993366,
-0.0490063131,
0.0188936796,
0.0082114516,
-0.0141542275,
0.021249732,
-0.0681991875,
-0.0946306214,
0.014611843,
-0.0656793788,
-0.0128127122,
0.0163756199,
-0.0287467837,
-0.0356577486,
-0.0202227961,
-0.0357198454,
-0.0044368091,
0.0140185645,
0.0158427078,
0.0937781408,
-0.0253715198,
-0.0079133837,
-0.0048645143,
-0.0169698056,
0.0019647062,
-0.0024901573,
-0.0090112723,
-0.0236987602,
-0.0188157298,
0.0110338479,
0.0312584862,
-0.0385150164,
-0.033799313,
0.0245174505,
-0.0767181665,
-0.0120301591,
-0.0233503152,
0.0150091536,
0.0288949572,
-0.0224885289,
0.0052501862,
-0.0044042342,
-0.0452467203,
-0.0094434461,
0.0184644945,
0.0025257156,
0.0464145094,
-0.0265482198,
0.0025342463,
-0.0232068989,
0.004808181,
-0.0172726586,
0.0421924107,
0.0305711273,
-0.0435213931,
-0.0525153093,
0.0149586424,
-0.0300918594,
0.0130459443,
-0.0146603845,
0.0162330642,
0.011196279,
0.0225028433,
0.000048198,
0.0364598818,
0.0234661214,
0.0113358311,
0.0069455649,
0.0364313275,
-0.0310910791,
-0.0106596546,
-0.0244779103,
0.011892654,
-0.0092622871,
-0.0628113598,
0.0579044074,
0.0790120438,
0.005083099,
0.015339666,
-0.0471596792,
0.0150929056,
-0.0318040773,
-0.019804759,
0.0147195756,
0.0077981935,
0.0080114743,
0.0670624673,
-0.0536539964,
-0.014966405,
0.0951227993,
-0.0088211792,
0.0311740451,
-0.0157132894,
-0.0243048053,
-0.0155745056,
0.042539075,
0.0083277533,
0.0040639471,
0.0170862619,
0.0044313287,
0.0132991206,
-0.0451802351,
0.0360802077,
-0.0131061319,
0.0064151208,
-0.0478209704,
0.0301895272,
0.0132427895,
-0.044989191,
-0.019499734,
-0.0690398663,
-0.0284276139,
-0.0023462165,
-0.0659880266,
-0.0198054742,
-0.077530466,
-0.05004026,
0.0446122587,
0.0292485356,
0.0152069414,
-0.0191593338,
0.0091831768,
0.0409967154,
0.0509728715,
0.021653397,
0.0496621914,
-0.0204036925,
-0.021977935,
0.0746083707,
-0.0278102178,
0.0297733154,
-0.0282625444,
-0.0613385178,
-0.0434208587,
-0.0106951874,
0.0392605402,
-0.0123701142,
0.0420027338,
-0.043424204,
0.0320024788,
0.0805549547,
0.0053589381,
0.0205799118,
0.0173472073,
0.0197760295,
0.0017092122,
0.0153325619,
-0.0139070116,
-0.0935354531,
-0.0225165077,
-0.0209128689,
-0.01197844,
0.0027938385,
-0.0498769507,
-0.0092343614,
-0.1018227115,
0.052219145,
-0.01769704,
0.0020106749,
-0.0537746772,
-0.0584854856,
0.0241562016,
-0.0216921438,
0.0174046662,
0.0119015183,
0.0387746431,
-0.0129250251,
0.0020727355,
-0.0512716137,
-0.0358422548,
0.047575146,
-0.025263831,
0.0367464274,
0.0159524102,
0.016479047,
0.0098766787,
-0.0488134027,
0.0089176977,
0.0086031863,
-0.041848883,
0.0036448091,
0.0389994159,
-0.0029498576,
0.0046028546,
-0.026184177,
0.0375595503,
-0.0473392159,
-0.0410790257,
-0.0022055777,
0.0728696957,
0.0124776894,
-0.0794037133,
-0.0173974037,
0.0323546305,
0.0294108819,
0.0818402693,
0.0085067973,
0.0083851302,
-0.0398831367,
-0.0497533418,
-0.051305417,
-0.0596770309,
-0.0326977223,
0.0640507936,
0.0308554843,
-0.0268388186,
-0.0781548321,
-0.0205231942,
-0.0084109399,
0.0182311386,
-0.0240999721,
-0.0398896933,
0.0797625631,
-0.0044604409,
-0.0447760262,
0.0488271788,
-0.0594339967,
0.0474386513,
-0.005310141,
0.0208533183,
0.0123577714,
-0.0005902933,
-0.0138613442,
0.0659413561,
-0.0765606686,
-0.0538416579,
-0.0270145498,
-0.0013918623,
0.0160805099,
0.0541394129,
-0.0335620977,
-0.0777878761,
0.0128956633,
0.0467352271,
-0.0076861624,
0.0122766169,
0.023352934,
0.0108318608,
0.0143470895,
0.033662919,
-0.0093578724,
0.0357386097,
0.0053491127,
0.0207350589,
-0.0501481891,
-0.0264468603,
0.0200209524,
0.0367527418,
0.0332420506,
0.0143358801,
-0.0074455435,
-0.0311840568,
-0.0221161041,
-0.0123564731,
-0.0416809022,
-0.0152218342,
0.046762459,
0.0155924885,
-0.0341767929,
-0.0186880361,
-0.0296542626,
-0.0186620355,
0.0031875595,
-0.0469386615,
-0.0178765617,
-0.0222597942,
0.0378367454,
0.0121013885,
-0.0405135415,
-0.0197916497,
0.00857691,
-0.005661678,
0.0595907345,
0.0045791524,
0.0050541195,
0.0305077452,
0.0102507127,
0.0175887048,
-0.0375308245,
-0.0447477661,
-0.0270934086,
-0.018618321,
-0.0083103944,
0.0319827721,
-0.0013900168,
0.0387345441,
-0.0212371014,
-0.0197313298,
0.0176015459,
-0.0076391734,
-0.0124825165,
-0.0376804397,
0.0232361387,
0.0059141549,
-0.0271086786,
0.0209117513,
0.0534988903,
-0.0174661037,
0.0340060182,
0.0077705421,
-0.0427868851,
-0.0511881188,
-0.0633545443,
-0.0495544672,
0.0513560101,
-0.0080073494,
0.0070879613,
-0.0634587333,
-0.0714689493,
0.0064760619,
0.0208420716,
0.0443284661,
0.0491852239,
-0.0190569721,
0.0586419702,
0.0206223931,
-0.0067939055,
-0.0175592992,
0.0190096591,
0.008929668,
-0.043938905,
-0.0134986015,
-6.321552214e-33,
0.0182302278,
-0.0574288219,
-0.0150365634,
0.0115268957,
0.028456632,
0.0268471166,
-0.0545269512,
-0.0214123596,
-0.0206740331,
0.0932090655,
0.0172800086,
0.04283005,
0.0041637886,
0.0297855604,
-0.0044884272,
0.0178922825,
0.0383049026,
0.0081877653,
-0.0303969178,
0.0292776115,
0.0507487282,
0.0005022594,
0.0422413722,
-0.111379087,
0.0488570966,
0.0109968288,
-0.0385771208,
0.0344853848,
-0.0250861384,
0.0318113901,
-0.0140066911,
0.0322167538,
0.043441128,
-0.0118837748,
0.0160898399,
0.0302536525,
-0.1052310988,
0.0211571082,
0.0334195755,
-0.0293394793,
-0.0471569188,
0.0194847044,
0.0461236052,
-0.0059882468,
0.0042029191,
-0.0221984033,
0.0224205945,
-0.0087875286,
0.0318950638,
-0.0384144373,
-0.0656018183,
0.0449232906,
-0.0191397835,
-0.0057278764,
-0.0088384049,
0.0163991861,
-0.0188857522,
0.0412668958,
-0.0821933076,
0.0185846072,
-0.0728845224,
-0.0034778633,
0.0288847033,
-0.0494670048,
-0.0571242124,
0.0620851777,
-0.0113970069,
0.0222864822,
-0.0716804266,
0.032155972,
-0.0180806573,
0.0382834338,
0.0585121587,
0.0696906745,
0.0395328552,
-0.0146349799,
-0.0959974378,
0.0202273484,
0.0244453568,
0.0055618198,
0.0169539452,
-0.0356282443,
-0.0101205586,
0.0107899345,
-0.0259227473,
-0.0000375768,
-0.0437749326,
0.0556007512,
-0.0218533874,
0.0456843898,
-0.0246287044,
0.0389453098,
0.0044445759,
-0.0368961766,
0.0049216198,
0.0179250315,
0.0236560255,
-0.0113316467,
0.0400491841,
0.0238246322,
-0.0636693239,
0.0339838825,
0.0046571679,
0.0207295865,
0.014245999,
-0.0023680993,
0.0717766583,
-0.0306575987,
-0.0415399969,
0.0170414019,
-0.0228829924,
0.0502803773,
-0.0248765908,
0.0158965606,
0.0389688537,
0.0279718451,
-0.0107526369,
-0.0082480786,
0.0017875022,
0.0127434963,
-0.0169684608,
0.0444917604,
-0.0019108254,
-0.0057255928,
-0.0115254447,
-0.0258151423,
-0.0125647457,
0.0002560098,
0.0285771545,
-0.0731050745,
0.0315029509,
0.0321643166,
2.497e-7,
0.0221943874,
0.0716586784,
0.003104989,
0.0117963776,
0.0475176536,
0.0561262108,
0.027002167,
0.0094324574,
0.0017658138,
-0.1086948887,
-0.0480558015,
0.044673793,
0.0565192997,
0.0291530825,
-0.0566887781,
-0.0362375453,
-0.0544060878,
-0.0531179272,
-0.0512681827,
-0.0020033992,
0.019948408,
0.0361430869,
0.020030044,
-0.0352819227,
0.0074645751,
-0.0329200625,
0.0548771322,
0.034290269,
-0.0319487713,
0.0128006842,
0.0553159267,
-0.0197082758,
0.0184762366,
0.0235492606,
-0.0266619585,
0.0155616356,
-0.0042975727,
0.0713043958,
0.0297140162,
0.0016420853,
-0.0506068319,
-0.0252207983,
0.0414375328,
-0.0585780032,
0.0118607059,
-0.0676065013,
-0.0435175039,
-0.077268295,
-0.0136084175,
0.0195044503,
0.0262477826,
0.0218914133,
-0.0055381763,
0.0060616233,
-0.0065411534,
0.0208195001,
-0.0137797026,
-0.0824376419,
-0.02537423,
0.0122427475,
-0.0506151877,
-0.0028080002,
0.0270889085,
-0.010700373,
0.0339833945,
-0.0610224381,
0.0346935578,
2.0448638e-34,
0.0306416433,
-0.0229713451,
0.0067335041,
-0.0575613864,
0.0529004745,
0.0434087999,
-0.0108912885,
-0.0022553378,
0.0011328843,
-0.0511463545,
0.0087809749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.02084v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.02084v2 | ITEm: Unsupervised Image-Text Embedding Learning for eCommerce | 2023-10-22T15:39:44 | 2024-02-26T16:28:13 | Baohao Liao, Michael Kozielski, Sanjika Hewavitharana, Jiangbo Yuan, Shahram Khadivi, Tomer Lancewicki | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR | Product embedding serves as a cornerstone for a wide range of applications in
eCommerce. The product embedding learned from multiple modalities shows
significant improvement over that from a single modality, since different
modalities provide complementary information. However, some modalities are more
informatively dominant than others. How to teach a model to learn embedding
from different modalities without neglecting information from the less dominant
modality is challenging. We present an image-text embedding model (ITEm), an
unsupervised learning method that is designed to better attend to image and
text modalities. We extend BERT by (1) learning an embedding from text and
image without knowing the regions of interest; (2) training a global
representation to predict masked words and to construct masked image patches
without their individual representations. We evaluate the pre-trained ITEm on
two tasks: the search for extremely similar products and the prediction of
product categories, showing substantial gains compared to strong baseline
models. | [
0.0068555232,
0.0254176836,
-0.0089333151,
0.053995017,
0.0062460233,
-0.0041493005,
0.0407272242,
0.0101341913,
0.0079136826,
-0.071956493,
-0.0054775663,
0.0045703901,
-0.0542464741,
0.0669705942,
0.0314184241,
-0.0345173143,
0.0238298494,
0.0232294928,
-0.0400501862,
0.0031592937,
0.0455631875,
0.0072787134,
0.0285536107,
0.0208545364,
-0.0065315589,
0.002941316,
-0.0080261212,
0.0132106366,
0.02138431,
-0.0054705236,
0.0174118243,
0.0005239473,
0.0828404799,
-0.0238460843,
0.0000016292,
-0.0161100645,
-0.0154433493,
0.001202645,
-0.0002010371,
0.0059005865,
0.0250907633,
-0.0103233969,
0.0382303707,
0.0026920524,
-0.0252580997,
-0.000748662,
0.0561540797,
0.1062921211,
0.0191401895,
0.0511368737,
-0.0349182263,
-0.0150457574,
-0.015589661,
-0.035272304,
0.0168923754,
-0.0075829918,
0.0202695448,
-0.0540989526,
-0.0147445733,
0.0286263283,
-0.0313630886,
0.0401920862,
-0.0069430983,
0.0197935309,
0.0412648022,
0.080731146,
0.0032749574,
0.0003186955,
-0.0058332686,
0.1112170443,
-0.0324738808,
-0.0055505983,
-0.0114049073,
-0.0036008896,
-0.0138220973,
0.0090044802,
-0.0090193888,
-0.0231013894,
0.0293997657,
0.0408246666,
-0.0666025132,
0.0031752596,
0.0129130855,
0.0166429672,
0.0014853656,
-0.0160215311,
0.0166414194,
-0.0550858267,
-0.0369078964,
-0.0097127203,
-0.0767547339,
-0.0165024586,
0.0076988949,
-0.0090740277,
0.0334011801,
0.0065609845,
-0.0109928045,
-0.006317812,
-0.0035041701,
-0.036191538,
-0.0088230269,
0.0028412116,
-0.0761697739,
0.0773268119,
-0.0417043567,
0.021536855,
-0.0055958256,
0.0230466574,
-0.0653467327,
0.0305379387,
-0.0260555577,
-0.030370241,
-0.030223038,
0.0221571438,
-0.0261542927,
-0.0624588542,
0.0011980521,
-0.0176705606,
-0.0280459579,
0.0264125951,
0.0140416976,
0.0505843051,
-0.0306837764,
0.0021474885,
-0.0133782327,
-0.0004164966,
-0.0389082246,
0.0074221133,
-0.0443054102,
0.0379035436,
0.0381192304,
0.0421879403,
0.0366845019,
-0.0160884801,
0.0102392212,
0.0068428023,
-0.0297309048,
-0.045988664,
-0.0512289517,
0.0075837788,
-0.0403108001,
-0.0200396348,
0.0523979403,
-0.0249186438,
0.0209971424,
-0.019440053,
0.0079903742,
0.0101057086,
0.0083353054,
-0.019687064,
-0.0145621458,
0.1352274865,
0.0112828584,
-0.0537460186,
0.0093591791,
0.0196984317,
0.0434765965,
0.029696567,
-0.0385846533,
0.058224272,
0.0646014288,
0.0060854084,
0.0082585486,
0.0237508677,
-0.0170008317,
-0.0327734128,
-0.0347502381,
0.0295645129,
-0.0226252954,
0.0164797753,
0.0438485108,
0.0263151173,
-0.0513234399,
-0.0285696741,
0.0603093468,
0.0362762325,
0.0144970631,
0.0476935208,
0.0291322786,
0.0514735207,
-0.0366690233,
0.0004924536,
-0.0014046341,
-0.0017139959,
-0.0113272574,
-0.0132520301,
-0.0040656938,
-0.0205427818,
-0.0530783199,
-0.0113260578,
0.0175589025,
-0.0393145941,
0.0199361984,
-0.0016307442,
0.0221262276,
-0.0146146128,
-0.0322577432,
0.018025903,
-0.0096372012,
-0.0368434079,
-0.0149828615,
0.0142191183,
0.0358770303,
0.0766463876,
0.0277105626,
-0.0335070863,
0.0323088206,
0.0024741229,
-0.0161136072,
0.0597414933,
-0.0341848321,
-0.0301765595,
0.0134245902,
-0.084101446,
-0.0469283238,
-0.0549717806,
-0.0017864425,
0.0183861833,
-0.0313518234,
0.0037892328,
0.0307614915,
-0.01870667,
0.0889544338,
0.0158250071,
0.0385511033,
-0.0790863633,
-0.0001692913,
0.0486755706,
-0.0387316532,
-0.0184226688,
-0.0129877543,
0.0034909626,
0.0109431511,
-0.0316246822,
-0.0640294924,
0.0211059954,
-0.0024419324,
-0.0336839333,
0.0347598456,
-0.0863118023,
0.0028783462,
0.0125691369,
-0.0250176992,
-0.0180014186,
-0.0241314471,
-0.0261864811,
0.0641777962,
-0.0484814756,
-0.0210662484,
-0.0123818954,
0.017777374,
-0.0289124157,
0.0599724948,
0.0049616713,
0.0158718061,
-0.0099274116,
-0.0130106276,
0.0326501727,
0.006357397,
-0.0295782052,
0.0011983084,
0.0225968417,
0.0348946005,
0.0066278502,
0.0111662708,
-0.0077343886,
-0.0008663097,
-0.1201404259,
-0.04216481,
0.0058463891,
-0.0018214264,
-0.0216132645,
-0.0247837398,
0.0163798109,
-0.0390332676,
-0.031248007,
0.0032489295,
-0.0542959794,
0.0266211573,
0.0362637304,
0.0282975156,
0.0020187767,
-0.0146391941,
-0.009797642,
0.006596718,
0.0690441653,
-0.0086168628,
-0.0289895814,
-0.0399017967,
-0.0185686126,
-0.0235679075,
0.0320915803,
-0.004307094,
-0.0135497283,
-0.033634454,
-0.0023618736,
0.0621746443,
0.029390268,
-0.0032206641,
-0.0099422103,
0.0022876614,
-0.0104508819,
-0.0450219661,
-0.0103653381,
-0.0164278373,
0.0269465446,
0.0133372573,
-0.0038307423,
-0.0174863599,
0.0306969974,
-0.0395595804,
-0.0237985142,
-0.0385337919,
-0.0328214727,
-0.0044203773,
-0.0241611451,
-0.0913656205,
0.0008295709,
0.0016016674,
0.0143566858,
-0.018312024,
-0.0663003251,
0.0434407927,
-0.007452853,
-0.0062522739,
-0.0161756575,
-0.0107742222,
-0.0318584628,
0.0177698676,
0.0087935785,
0.0243499763,
-0.0070339642,
-0.0304714702,
-0.0315728374,
0.0172754154,
0.0175189879,
-0.008039006,
0.038241487,
0.010011401,
0.0138995461,
-0.0113913519,
-0.0738219768,
-0.0266493242,
-0.0846285895,
0.0375773534,
0.0102845179,
0.0283562485,
0.002686827,
-0.070502378,
0.0059816218,
0.0016925733,
0.0098045412,
0.0321199931,
-0.0368496962,
0.009207543,
0.0922234729,
0.0560572743,
-0.0354281366,
-0.0367171429,
-0.0225113425,
-0.0248466507,
0.0157375541,
0.0317684934,
-0.0043510143,
-0.0390883386,
0.0374836214,
0.0159012284,
-0.0037808472,
-0.0012729069,
0.0289091095,
-0.009946147,
0.039578557,
0.0241939332,
0.0810526535,
0.0212538186,
-0.0205358304,
-0.0147418929,
0.0294339899,
-0.0263935365,
0.0269085094,
0.0297115017,
-0.0351592787,
0.0003448685,
-0.0310070533,
-0.0098676197,
0.0399301313,
0.032025069,
-0.0049210503,
-0.0900391489,
0.0053471066,
0.0003737708,
0.0402603298,
-0.0472583883,
-0.0133314002,
-0.0268092863,
-0.0192203578,
0.0222347938,
-0.0447792858,
-0.033189591,
-0.0337108597,
0.0134427026,
0.0118905418,
-0.0303892735,
0.0123727228,
-0.0492901467,
-0.0313674286,
0.0289019812,
0.0350265428,
-0.0263229385,
-0.0457166843,
-0.0127389338,
0.021015577,
-0.0303333197,
0.0292050354,
0.0500783436,
-0.0445536822,
-0.0292374641,
-0.0086350311,
-0.0205022153,
0.0219378471,
-0.0113813858,
-0.0513053089,
0.0575409085,
0.0350808948,
-0.0149212508,
-0.0354431346,
-0.0166239887,
-0.0116853993,
0.0265870076,
-0.0081336088,
-0.0368952155,
-0.0091224322,
-0.0254288409,
0.0148450239,
0.0085585797,
-0.0000873395,
0.0345858112,
-0.0250931513,
-0.0108833658,
-0.0929175466,
-0.0148590878,
0.031867072,
0.0318539925,
0.0262250807,
-0.0469478443,
-0.031994611,
0.0042888704,
-0.0540417582,
0.0148924096,
-0.0218112785,
0.0339339338,
-0.0000244661,
0.0309500247,
0.0391838662,
-0.0415748842,
-0.0438192561,
-0.0194444917,
-0.0265185572,
-0.035982158,
-0.0431470536,
0.0428508818,
0.0047920863,
0.0084353024,
0.0166256335,
-0.0961064175,
0.0710637122,
0.0622454733,
0.0055994028,
-0.0282374341,
0.0480366945,
0.0091019617,
0.0162358303,
0.031185722,
-0.0236510634,
0.0294105411,
0.0170465261,
0.0236741193,
0.0055349739,
-0.0267536957,
0.0074441172,
-0.040642187,
0.0529824048,
-0.0178454164,
0.0448294617,
-0.0566657148,
0.0364094675,
0.0257715974,
-0.0310735721,
-0.0412992574,
-0.0097186062,
0.025511058,
0.0009841395,
-0.0133547233,
0.072890088,
-0.0236707907,
0.0347070992,
-0.0523553267,
0.0110596819,
0.02000775,
0.0130723463,
-0.046079129,
0.0278643295,
-0.005278822,
0.0100401668,
-0.0168596208,
0.0104944333,
-0.0177053697,
0.0628980994,
-0.0029378587,
-0.0129107535,
-0.06149574,
0.030019721,
0.0293177757,
0.0121749351,
-0.0830385312,
0.0215485599,
0.0497510098,
-0.0645787343,
-0.0299675595,
-0.0204296559,
-0.0351945832,
-0.0135599384,
0.0047332067,
-0.0414861515,
-0.026486529,
0.0648089647,
0.0410301015,
-0.0221349373,
0.0184314903,
0.0536347814,
0.0232461113,
0.0282635968,
-0.0100100935,
-0.0199326016,
-0.0700836182,
0.0194795467,
0.1150554195,
0.056626182,
-0.0250938293,
0.0515086278,
-0.0052707805,
-0.0302025974,
0.0084177433,
-0.0176301934,
-0.021197943,
0.058004804,
0.0650488436,
0.0653833672,
0.0133226085,
0.0077517894,
-0.0124830082,
0.0123874955,
0.0045055631,
0.0191789567,
-0.0222916491,
-5.56448022e-33,
0.0248906724,
-0.0319063216,
-0.00716834,
-0.0118952394,
0.0147522409,
0.0461122617,
0.014045137,
-0.0102418931,
0.0243131462,
0.0310735088,
0.0230207257,
-0.0192007422,
0.0187952276,
0.0311926045,
-0.0095494473,
-0.0296824202,
0.0249409694,
0.0423330255,
-0.0013306061,
0.0205182079,
-0.011170038,
0.057524763,
0.0734726787,
-0.0420502014,
0.002990878,
0.0049968185,
-0.0166529678,
0.0147077153,
0.0720851496,
0.087222293,
-0.0591173396,
0.0424329564,
0.0009251965,
-0.0013618256,
-0.0015286594,
0.0346370526,
-0.0499635674,
0.00929996,
-0.0089324415,
-0.0013025891,
-0.0574625917,
0.0300244018,
0.0003789547,
-0.0440043658,
0.0307368133,
0.0366546288,
0.0819577947,
-0.0151870456,
-0.0368122421,
-0.0215373877,
-0.0388812721,
0.0213181935,
-0.0073291031,
-0.025096111,
0.0759639516,
0.0302650724,
0.0554928444,
0.0219001956,
-0.0333312973,
0.0264756382,
-0.0162574202,
-0.0149094993,
0.0671718195,
0.0060018548,
-0.0114758033,
0.0709522963,
0.0235566571,
-0.0373399816,
0.0239375681,
-0.0410355702,
0.0070780329,
0.0843910277,
0.0439588726,
0.0538930371,
0.0280230865,
0.04455778,
-0.0148922866,
0.051150728,
-0.0191913825,
-0.0253248904,
0.0066485861,
0.0591105931,
-0.0355360173,
0.0016032296,
-0.0157164726,
-0.0073077958,
-0.0445935391,
-0.0002195972,
0.0213966724,
0.0545864888,
-0.0496888235,
0.0814150497,
0.0704423711,
-0.0345075689,
-0.0489705242,
-0.0410185456,
0.0099484511,
0.0210388917,
0.028225014,
-0.0123515967,
-0.0483140871,
-0.0549684688,
0.0571644232,
-0.0467374027,
-0.0407529809,
-0.0211235471,
0.056691546,
0.0065182103,
-0.0593265221,
0.0091386661,
0.0002395832,
-0.0817190781,
-0.0145617072,
0.0418620035,
0.0182484221,
0.0202797856,
-0.0496621802,
0.0205069296,
0.0196729619,
0.0116751427,
-0.0112557802,
-0.0321711674,
0.0022464364,
0.0158008318,
0.0082045011,
0.001204206,
-0.0495148711,
0.0375902615,
0.0368563458,
-0.0962226242,
-0.0135197453,
0.0346915275,
2.395e-7,
0.0375381447,
0.0289213173,
0.0110555822,
-0.0268979575,
0.0269651935,
0.054913871,
-0.0113741495,
0.0637285411,
-0.029182354,
-0.0291413609,
0.0424424447,
-0.0001358811,
0.0180469994,
-0.0037338764,
-0.0157579705,
0.0027156544,
-0.0380329825,
-0.0125788515,
-0.0526405536,
-0.0066578826,
0.0371029265,
0.1316483766,
0.0256115962,
-0.0052895942,
0.0392563157,
-0.055444777,
0.112783581,
-0.0509786569,
0.0122382548,
-0.0395509303,
-0.0323688537,
0.059942048,
-0.0340848416,
-0.0425387882,
-0.0330272317,
0.0414626673,
0.0797387585,
0.0335489661,
-0.0065356032,
-0.0125784697,
-0.0393872634,
0.007315279,
-0.0561112575,
-0.0497152023,
0.0570868403,
-0.0849949867,
-0.0103916191,
-0.0286175869,
-0.0304471273,
0.0030933586,
0.0551101938,
-0.0349532776,
-0.0698063001,
0.0168695189,
0.0364407524,
-0.0357443392,
-0.0196610577,
-0.085775435,
-0.0108960364,
-0.008100816,
-0.0578904934,
0.0071322517,
-0.0169741511,
-0.007062322,
0.0334781893,
-0.0431630947,
0.0090130595,
1.861900974e-34,
0.0458977558,
-0.0115076331,
-0.0175666716,
0.018317448,
0.0184381045,
-0.046053607,
-0.0145079549,
-0.0384867638,
0.0153058423,
-0.0528608449,
-0.013733889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14329v1 | DiFair: A Benchmark for Disentangled Assessment of Gender Knowledge and Bias | 2023-10-22T15:27:16 | 2023-10-22T15:27:16 | Mahdi Zakizadeh, Kaveh Eskandari Miandoab, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous debiasing techniques have been proposed to mitigate the gender bias
that is prevalent in pretrained language models. These are often evaluated on
datasets that check the extent to which the model is gender-neutral in its
predictions. Importantly, this evaluation protocol overlooks the possible
adverse impact of bias mitigation on useful gender knowledge. To fill this gap,
we propose DiFair, a manually curated dataset based on masked language modeling
objectives. DiFair allows us to introduce a unified metric, gender invariance
score, that not only quantifies a model's biased behavior, but also checks if
useful gender knowledge is preserved. We use DiFair as a benchmark for a number
of widely-used pretained language models and debiasing techniques. Experimental
results corroborate previous findings on the existing gender biases, while also
demonstrating that although debiasing techniques ameliorate the issue of gender
bias, this improvement usually comes at the price of lowering useful gender
knowledge of the model. | [
0.0130394232,
0.1040637493,
-0.0356771573,
0.0280597545,
-0.0016038286,
0.0354102179,
0.0622664392,
-0.0126644764,
0.0054765171,
-0.0579018146,
-0.0349330604,
-0.0415217243,
0.0357006267,
0.0319937393,
0.0444142185,
-0.047536619,
0.0269468501,
-0.0062910141,
0.0083416887,
-0.0430192649,
0.0145016192,
0.0179091934,
-0.0005799465,
0.0455281734,
0.025296092,
-0.0437774658,
0.0249343831,
0.0078408346,
-0.0108980052,
0.0028951296,
0.0843970254,
0.0676363707,
0.0038771662,
0.0367460549,
0.0000020592,
-0.0745581761,
0.0255927015,
0.0167519823,
-0.0307544284,
0.0034604429,
0.0011412119,
-0.0163646489,
-0.0016009406,
0.0412871428,
-0.0240013469,
-0.0380311683,
0.0244689025,
0.0074561471,
0.0311969463,
0.0278518908,
-0.0169013198,
0.0260660592,
-0.0556739345,
-0.059031833,
-0.0338333845,
0.0163772441,
0.0252408069,
-0.039205499,
-0.0868248045,
-0.0261492003,
-0.0328909345,
0.0092230523,
0.0107967844,
-0.0028883277,
0.0051970496,
0.0195613708,
-0.0435422771,
-0.0650871322,
0.0055723754,
0.0612010621,
-0.0041987798,
-0.0120340381,
0.0280339476,
-0.0130490689,
0.0023033198,
0.0232542865,
-0.0316587873,
-0.0187281221,
0.0259045959,
-0.0178118516,
-0.0175804161,
0.000396378,
0.0386013277,
0.0564262308,
-0.0211436879,
0.0949950963,
0.0284293089,
-0.0300238784,
0.0154444864,
0.0071404972,
0.0251775533,
-0.070783928,
-0.0116321612,
-0.0425711721,
0.0048605781,
-0.0012196649,
-0.0211546849,
-0.0364390723,
0.0224935655,
-0.0432370231,
-0.0156634301,
0.0246670134,
0.0163242389,
0.0100367423,
-0.0299883112,
0.0373806246,
0.0179626048,
0.0254021622,
-0.0072697764,
-0.0346788019,
-0.0220014416,
-0.0186930913,
-0.0035011719,
-0.0089565553,
-0.0190414842,
0.0153127927,
-0.0165001731,
-0.0141653875,
-0.0506594852,
-0.0033582067,
0.0185221918,
0.0255190451,
-0.0094901957,
-0.0059070066,
0.0004867169,
0.0167413764,
-0.0558866151,
0.0327424556,
-0.016032774,
-0.0842819512,
-0.0156805124,
0.0192124527,
-0.0088458434,
-0.0466428064,
0.0078787329,
0.0246639997,
0.0010780795,
-0.0385956354,
0.0204073451,
0.0029238441,
-0.0418467522,
-0.0795546994,
0.0162030663,
-0.0622107536,
0.012578194,
0.0479179583,
0.0260117687,
-0.0550054498,
-0.0098718246,
-0.0132624535,
-0.0129816728,
0.030675767,
0.0450243428,
-0.0048229108,
0.0524614193,
0.024194736,
-0.0046182801,
0.1229108647,
0.042784594,
0.0186522882,
0.0272151884,
0.0002161819,
-0.0133756986,
0.0434358157,
0.0779676661,
0.0445121229,
-0.0445790701,
0.0224535111,
-0.0141858207,
0.005517357,
0.0671885908,
-0.0083348239,
0.0081207585,
-0.0165782087,
0.0857788771,
0.0380097106,
0.0422853678,
0.0362628661,
0.0086219683,
-0.0018869116,
0.0033907846,
0.00958989,
-0.0572858974,
0.0037281862,
-0.0255498402,
-0.0229971725,
0.0051902616,
0.0371407904,
-0.0267453566,
-0.0538018011,
-0.0015781821,
0.0099383751,
0.0138078807,
0.0471942089,
0.0420458764,
0.0305755101,
0.0030276754,
0.053903129,
0.0388893262,
-0.0656099617,
0.0094536291,
-0.0518449098,
0.0019765387,
0.0336384214,
0.0117196525,
-0.0197721068,
-0.0027462246,
-0.0255638026,
-0.0076292874,
0.0473192297,
0.0551657602,
0.0185956527,
0.0658778921,
-0.0452167243,
-0.0304257739,
0.0105370739,
0.0456467383,
0.020792285,
0.0597760752,
0.0418044478,
0.0211729966,
-0.0473211445,
-0.026863683,
0.031277027,
-0.0165773872,
-0.0362180993,
0.0317342691,
0.0005549465,
0.021622071,
0.0125078298,
-0.0426306948,
-0.0036927878,
0.0118594123,
-0.0040979739,
0.0007107341,
-0.000831552,
-0.0192190353,
-0.0297165178,
-0.004999314,
-0.0690058544,
-0.0707985908,
0.0759361833,
-0.0141722811,
-0.0140973581,
0.0665569827,
-0.0036532923,
0.0112344129,
-0.0288451854,
-0.0058698533,
-0.0212973356,
0.0498900227,
-0.0064257435,
0.0158372931,
-0.0337111838,
-0.022133315,
-0.0024581077,
-0.0378482789,
-0.010283825,
-0.0459635332,
-0.0631378219,
0.0361213423,
0.0129015502,
-0.0023723308,
0.0507003963,
-0.0354942419,
-0.0304731503,
-0.0444172025,
-0.0612033829,
-0.0220237449,
-0.0332929417,
-0.0036490781,
0.0032893305,
0.0044635334,
-0.0289883707,
-0.0191035811,
-0.0208052211,
-0.0635891557,
-0.0196871329,
0.0227921456,
0.0213932935,
-0.0227459278,
0.0096358312,
-0.0471691266,
-0.0255919229,
-0.020272512,
0.0813309923,
0.0089146355,
-0.0135756331,
-0.0117048351,
0.0040759398,
-0.0313511379,
-0.0000607563,
-0.0247619096,
-0.0236735661,
0.016673008,
0.04229559,
0.0292708501,
0.0940077826,
0.0221750233,
0.0300242845,
0.0693750903,
0.0186699778,
-0.0576970205,
-0.0134803485,
-0.0008540273,
0.0166827478,
0.0109581752,
-0.0542491637,
0.0002807853,
0.0321873464,
-0.003790078,
-0.0225616302,
-0.0431453101,
0.0305650923,
-0.03760105,
-0.0664767399,
-0.0582447797,
-0.0098784855,
-0.0090412255,
0.0458027981,
-0.0477399565,
-0.0697162673,
0.0336390696,
-0.0323902667,
-0.0101896357,
-0.0037763219,
-0.0205848012,
-0.0427819304,
0.0620315336,
-0.0346844718,
0.0141764274,
0.0176367331,
0.003575637,
-0.0801164582,
-0.047820434,
0.0363200419,
-0.0404746868,
-0.0026120101,
-0.0282767117,
0.0174068902,
0.0379258394,
-0.0331295878,
-0.0486894064,
-0.0473077446,
0.0032707823,
-0.0123320911,
0.028835237,
-0.0124201793,
-0.0037832072,
0.0094394134,
-0.0037091151,
0.0401529558,
-0.0199619941,
0.006153909,
0.0026414271,
-0.0104986569,
0.0696344674,
-0.010466462,
0.0407060646,
-0.0550711602,
0.0083766934,
0.024730552,
0.0023651752,
0.0291628931,
-0.0062079071,
0.0335295722,
0.0432917736,
-0.0226655286,
0.0008323888,
-0.0122422716,
0.0222456492,
-0.0509173758,
0.0009915853,
0.1069707721,
-0.0007698865,
-0.0785037279,
-0.0077963131,
0.01342119,
0.0655802116,
0.02762671,
-0.009073237,
-0.0649085194,
0.0027490749,
0.0458601266,
0.0139336418,
-0.007261409,
-0.0279818457,
-0.0212443341,
-0.1207285896,
-0.018869957,
0.0042935926,
-0.0130432844,
-0.0344777964,
-0.0333037674,
0.0039211074,
-0.027866371,
0.0473549031,
-0.0273512658,
0.0094006257,
0.0042114728,
0.0016434757,
-0.0511147231,
-0.0650460348,
0.0264709014,
-0.056395147,
0.0739893317,
0.0424516797,
0.0489739776,
-0.0264292359,
-0.0135764061,
0.0051418915,
-0.0151363565,
-0.0250754897,
0.0021543344,
0.056553591,
-0.0519661158,
-0.0304400753,
-0.0406025425,
0.0373425409,
0.0490208715,
0.0205112789,
-0.0119933011,
-0.0247820709,
0.0161703676,
-0.0164264813,
-0.0364360698,
-0.042633377,
0.0154652055,
0.0757216364,
0.0355735496,
-0.0437335037,
-0.0338934697,
-0.0440787338,
0.0256559197,
0.0281488169,
-0.0406400859,
-0.0112097962,
0.0425446928,
-0.0246204659,
-0.0289468411,
-0.0225585401,
0.0248946398,
0.008203865,
-0.0027832719,
-0.0340756923,
0.0175293628,
-0.0002428037,
-0.0721796528,
0.0473828204,
-0.0049270499,
0.0303601306,
-0.0149348211,
-0.0377151333,
-0.0451442599,
-0.0157068484,
-0.0291369855,
0.0433169864,
-0.0487619825,
-0.070000194,
0.0532451458,
0.0513021946,
0.0246911831,
0.0643500462,
-0.0077334722,
-0.0663315207,
0.0699597895,
0.019809911,
-0.0293590613,
0.0397411026,
0.0537450276,
-0.0106238229,
0.0128507409,
0.0430299044,
-0.0610832907,
0.0080096489,
0.0189758055,
0.0015880637,
-0.0089237075,
-0.0287557486,
-0.011566231,
0.0132014649,
0.056220077,
-0.0652613714,
0.0208568443,
-0.0405605286,
-0.0035807425,
-0.0312107094,
-0.0271844137,
-0.0171237197,
-0.0339503624,
0.0545673259,
0.0284329988,
-0.0042356909,
0.0343594737,
-0.0236115213,
-0.003742744,
-0.0208974686,
-0.0005676889,
-0.015566105,
0.0572116226,
-0.0149970418,
0.0241669323,
0.014015344,
0.0126463929,
-0.0287352093,
0.0185584966,
0.022002412,
-0.0151172234,
0.018413417,
0.0193707552,
-0.0248879567,
0.0153879141,
-0.0561187863,
0.0029647355,
-0.0101367002,
0.0155244749,
0.0211871564,
-0.0260192025,
0.0912922025,
0.0009701411,
-0.0154122841,
0.0083574718,
-0.0051504397,
0.0020786196,
0.0152570801,
0.0002290952,
0.0137010338,
-0.0020707063,
-0.0005959629,
0.0574623719,
0.073719494,
0.066532284,
-0.0156999454,
-0.0066627371,
-0.0191748813,
-0.0311906915,
0.0352150537,
-0.0108732898,
-0.0198032316,
0.0086766025,
-0.0955835655,
-0.0605403297,
-0.0283410065,
-0.0146861589,
0.030153932,
0.0081173312,
0.0108400118,
0.0356232338,
-0.027840523,
-0.0432459339,
-0.047810141,
-0.0214823205,
0.0284942444,
-0.005792093,
-0.0072965673,
-6.810809861e-33,
-0.0314517803,
-0.0311187096,
-0.0312695503,
-0.0289152954,
-0.0096142152,
0.0197073258,
-0.0116549619,
0.0107966587,
-0.0250577088,
0.0259496868,
0.0104115102,
0.0441542901,
0.0130046951,
0.0072590346,
-0.0177432429,
0.0024323498,
0.0600073077,
0.0114545347,
-0.0372756273,
-0.0451677442,
-0.0064170286,
0.0344686396,
0.0277066417,
-0.0612052791,
0.1074892879,
-0.022374643,
-0.0349392481,
-0.002783963,
-0.0532513708,
0.0268657077,
-0.0175614785,
0.0510203093,
-0.0062270765,
-0.0306131002,
0.0079308348,
0.038608104,
-0.0745458156,
-0.0521542206,
0.0063839243,
0.0233764984,
0.0286693014,
0.0201072842,
0.0312464498,
0.0304354597,
-0.0339693055,
-0.0517502837,
0.0475861058,
0.0287828408,
0.0408249311,
0.0233757794,
-0.0177883562,
0.0171129555,
-0.0481609814,
-0.0227779206,
0.0537114255,
0.0196714867,
0.002875736,
-0.0241265856,
-0.0774168521,
0.0252483767,
-0.0116432887,
0.0072793751,
0.0486511514,
0.0320580862,
0.0530681424,
0.0645503551,
0.0862133428,
0.0412053689,
-0.0291183908,
-0.047580272,
0.0683090985,
-0.0258068331,
0.0490872748,
0.0683328137,
0.044781018,
-0.0029093786,
-0.0812428743,
-0.0374509022,
-0.0114784762,
0.0160239488,
0.0069235503,
-0.0190065671,
-0.0624828972,
-0.0590999424,
-0.0714261085,
-0.070433706,
-0.0178912096,
-0.0054934579,
0.0242129695,
0.0125494804,
-0.0675911382,
-0.0037864039,
-0.0190465786,
-0.0591628104,
-0.030899588,
0.0271686427,
-0.0038016059,
-0.0194535255,
0.0595392101,
0.0283894278,
-0.0463164598,
0.0195680913,
0.0252096616,
0.0398695059,
0.0412102491,
-0.014543619,
-0.0027272289,
0.0257415958,
-0.0770932287,
-0.0064760395,
-0.0465356484,
0.0095944097,
0.0260050353,
0.0124953734,
0.0217980202,
0.0182036385,
-0.0266556777,
0.0016053682,
0.0379906744,
0.0362580419,
-0.0274709705,
-0.0023350657,
-0.0083593307,
0.0525162295,
-0.0074319113,
-0.024150366,
0.0083477618,
0.0006357472,
0.0865373611,
-0.013071402,
-0.0084216362,
-0.0418752991,
2.614e-7,
0.0162781738,
0.0636275262,
0.0213540085,
0.0383784845,
0.0135375662,
0.0308375135,
-0.0129703302,
0.0523015149,
0.0409304574,
-0.0149700781,
-0.0385210216,
0.0457249954,
0.0341151692,
0.0256136283,
-0.0491364077,
0.0153129064,
-0.0834379792,
0.0168613698,
-0.0030648904,
-0.0019341962,
-0.0272787977,
0.0556514822,
0.0597985871,
0.011680969,
-0.0035941368,
0.0085495701,
0.0377872214,
-0.0179813094,
0.0121320263,
0.0015334495,
0.0194858406,
0.0096318675,
0.0273624118,
0.0283065606,
0.0101917284,
0.0230560768,
0.0058209305,
0.0327848457,
-0.0185060725,
0.014369077,
-0.0339553654,
0.0217952114,
-0.0310840085,
-0.0749555305,
0.0789377093,
0.0114636002,
-0.0370329395,
-0.0641631931,
-0.0297239926,
0.0122747542,
0.1148735359,
-0.0158000346,
-0.0198096894,
0.0293763839,
0.0290320404,
0.0017674208,
-0.0070093316,
-0.0569389835,
-0.0640973821,
-0.0259184297,
-0.0196615513,
-0.0604122579,
-0.0108747929,
0.0139171761,
0.0166906174,
-0.0394379646,
0.0488456227,
2.105859099e-34,
0.0042733517,
0.025448624,
0.0002547672,
-0.0079068812,
0.0274479967,
-0.0383566767,
-0.0002269691,
-0.0047699427,
0.0478885807,
-0.0167764071,
0.0180403944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14326v1 | CLMSM: A Multi-Task Learning Framework for Pre-training on Procedural Text | 2023-10-22T15:20:11 | 2023-10-22T15:20:11 | Abhilash Nandy, Manav Nitin Kapadnis, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we propose CLMSM, a domain-specific, continual pre-training
framework, that learns from a large set of procedural recipes. CLMSM uses a
Multi-Task Learning Framework to optimize two objectives - a) Contrastive
Learning using hard triplets to learn fine-grained differences across entities
in the procedures, and b) a novel Mask-Step Modelling objective to learn
step-wise context of a procedure. We test the performance of CLMSM on the
downstream tasks of tracking entities and aligning actions between two
procedures on three datasets, one of which is an open-domain dataset not
conforming with the pre-training dataset. We show that CLMSM not only
outperforms baselines on recipes (in-domain) but is also able to generalize to
open-domain procedural NLP tasks. | [
0.0188700948,
0.0361135378,
0.0070146779,
-0.0094310399,
-0.0234522372,
0.0256222077,
-0.0440885872,
-0.0080928896,
-0.0447518267,
-0.0288761426,
-0.0453080423,
-0.0452386588,
-0.029323101,
0.0234773345,
-0.0020566038,
-0.061456833,
0.0296332054,
0.0107938722,
-0.003843474,
0.0416422747,
0.016720783,
0.0032800268,
-0.0340051018,
0.0051328689,
0.0182532743,
-0.0365611315,
-0.0315810964,
-0.0022741512,
0.045067776,
-0.0673948452,
0.0416036993,
0.0687069297,
0.0520748794,
0.0197736025,
0.0000018883,
-0.0245027058,
-0.0283498708,
-0.0031149273,
-0.0296794791,
-0.0283850618,
0.0104076955,
-0.0272214133,
-0.0024832571,
-0.0175970085,
-0.062519908,
-0.0042673885,
0.0412541665,
0.0710999444,
0.0877059624,
0.0863586068,
-0.026826974,
-0.0395360477,
-0.0177920666,
-0.0186089147,
-0.0145513816,
-0.0159746408,
-0.0000016497,
-0.0238377117,
-0.0232125148,
0.0299929716,
0.0290672258,
0.0159398448,
0.0333715677,
0.0357729979,
0.0123345973,
0.0399801359,
-0.0043052798,
0.0026093603,
-0.0154196396,
0.1084246263,
-0.0162050631,
-0.0054757209,
-0.0019609409,
-0.0143785048,
-0.0250075627,
-0.0419323295,
-0.0371223539,
-0.0087541323,
-0.0162108373,
0.0329893269,
0.0103714829,
0.0003823068,
0.0093470374,
-0.0036539973,
0.0062483903,
-0.0162029248,
-0.0019395121,
-0.0235193018,
0.0174798481,
0.0299276691,
0.0128366426,
-0.0209434852,
-0.0090534864,
0.0547334366,
-0.0671657324,
0.0071742567,
-0.0776469484,
-0.0250725243,
0.0112786228,
-0.0012545279,
0.0785239488,
0.0161902402,
-0.0444835015,
0.0451739542,
-0.0287410412,
-0.0011841969,
-0.0210371464,
0.0112442309,
-0.0167160947,
0.020213224,
-0.0772461742,
0.0115868477,
-0.0311906561,
0.0499448925,
-0.0547695234,
0.0024687329,
0.008829101,
0.0029381933,
-0.0303017199,
0.0299745351,
0.0462508872,
-0.0044557923,
-0.0750289634,
0.0025378251,
-0.021501394,
-0.0110447658,
-0.0533142276,
0.0171648171,
-0.0269706659,
0.0020831889,
-0.0616453402,
-0.0203831084,
0.0033579548,
-0.023656413,
0.0166994259,
0.0827217177,
-0.0105442535,
-0.0292272717,
-0.036024943,
0.0075480412,
0.0230378676,
-0.0964578986,
0.0180643275,
-0.0568024516,
0.0523393862,
-0.018625075,
0.0010095761,
-0.0161908772,
-0.0001190959,
0.0149144018,
-0.0027590219,
0.0846467093,
-0.0051588286,
-0.0204990972,
-0.0423718169,
0.0056654974,
-0.0006447667,
0.0749012455,
0.0031315531,
-0.0255011488,
-0.000257006,
0.0173586365,
-0.0146712391,
0.0081491265,
0.0043368367,
0.0188066717,
0.03399124,
0.0248172209,
0.0781204626,
0.0279378947,
0.0345712714,
0.0087132649,
-0.026009541,
-0.0298914462,
0.0350769088,
-0.0061299186,
0.0028079341,
0.0007873365,
0.1105837002,
0.0142998118,
0.0060407142,
0.0602424741,
-0.0408870578,
0.0176234134,
-0.04793109,
-0.0038456309,
-0.0753539875,
-0.0040232791,
-0.0609203056,
-0.0211645979,
0.0400113203,
0.0016257087,
0.0061992654,
-0.0338095538,
0.0587025322,
0.0286774412,
-0.0906219408,
-0.0210940633,
0.0468498096,
-0.0220247563,
-0.0152091868,
0.0100412844,
-0.0053286529,
0.0579462759,
-0.0019756446,
-0.0877340063,
-0.050337635,
-0.0145099713,
0.0188926067,
0.0219952483,
-0.0178943928,
-0.0327917933,
0.0561277755,
-0.0353845209,
-0.018004071,
-0.0754781142,
0.0146818254,
0.024699036,
0.0264662392,
-0.0079370067,
-0.0128572639,
0.0130226035,
0.0279062707,
0.0573411174,
-0.0293688439,
-0.0300662089,
-0.01474516,
0.0052763619,
0.0118754031,
0.0134109864,
-0.0344280638,
-0.0191231482,
0.0149074718,
-0.030793624,
0.0246408712,
0.0121820429,
-0.0158798713,
-0.057804279,
0.0227899589,
0.0046936176,
-0.055571612,
-0.0071058748,
-0.0550498962,
-0.0334841311,
-0.0162999686,
-0.0046120202,
0.0080039278,
-0.017558733,
0.0159744062,
0.0551410727,
-0.0208324883,
-0.0443575568,
0.0816807896,
0.0125369672,
0.030918451,
0.0559235476,
0.0035238203,
-0.0025759083,
-0.0115746073,
0.0396796875,
-0.0121232783,
0.0305589829,
-0.0037373928,
-0.0260010213,
0.0449131504,
-0.0724004805,
-0.0299087353,
-0.0676857531,
0.0340115167,
-0.0263309088,
0.009852713,
0.042316556,
-0.019006338,
-0.0117596798,
-0.0255729165,
-0.0156206638,
0.001109521,
-0.0328746513,
-0.0186998751,
0.044523593,
0.033528734,
-0.0158913806,
-0.0245046914,
0.0087718796,
-0.0224252194,
0.002236312,
-0.0081467899,
0.0076487199,
-0.057497967,
0.043304421,
-0.0036034214,
0.0541128591,
-0.0095045203,
0.0098972758,
0.0110360878,
-0.0134134106,
0.0617554635,
0.0265517235,
-0.0459706225,
0.0473967716,
0.0222245492,
-0.0493410975,
-0.0396964252,
0.0155557618,
-0.0258499663,
0.0312321763,
-0.0355095603,
0.026747454,
0.0023538196,
0.0708649382,
-0.0066038752,
0.0171354599,
-0.052167058,
0.012229424,
0.0221442226,
0.0113765132,
0.0001157867,
0.0431767665,
-0.017682936,
0.003735258,
-0.0359155387,
-0.0195394773,
0.0692406818,
-0.0213064756,
-0.0043990701,
-0.0550086237,
-0.0280907881,
-0.0389946774,
0.0783738494,
0.0186119284,
0.004109418,
0.0556867234,
-0.0516062379,
-0.0789238736,
0.0409766287,
0.0493711084,
0.000310568,
0.0453537256,
-0.0805931613,
0.0233149119,
-0.022000391,
-0.032582771,
-0.027838964,
-0.0306020565,
0.0215210151,
0.0420835018,
0.0055274167,
-0.002472518,
-0.0193868671,
-0.0036213102,
-0.0284628496,
0.0645275936,
0.026176868,
-0.0259019323,
-0.0479542203,
0.0350633152,
0.0047445088,
0.0083710514,
-0.0363406427,
-0.0443397872,
0.0106334323,
0.0176568702,
0.0674462765,
-0.0670817569,
-0.0234734956,
0.0451359227,
0.009496903,
-0.0607794262,
0.0008666109,
0.0103552807,
0.0783683285,
-0.0408837758,
-0.002594606,
0.0874417424,
0.0192975439,
-0.0195312388,
-0.0205423906,
0.037648391,
-0.0097708572,
0.0408345833,
-0.0034393549,
-0.0545340292,
-0.0239305031,
-0.0093186582,
0.0057551609,
0.0138359265,
-0.0400213264,
0.0038543765,
-0.1047041863,
0.0316904001,
-0.0072491472,
-0.0748509094,
-0.0328360572,
-0.0172148868,
0.0253194254,
-0.0232923944,
-0.034013357,
-0.0134263653,
-0.0359507464,
-0.0019075027,
0.0052252435,
-0.0155227007,
-0.0560052618,
0.0009666556,
-0.0794630721,
0.020165164,
0.0360533707,
0.0202850159,
0.0217667948,
0.0209042467,
-0.0145020951,
-0.0439835899,
0.0124692041,
-0.0130152386,
0.065467,
-0.0224710777,
-0.0228837151,
-0.0170474593,
0.0184161477,
-0.048195038,
-0.0329223052,
-0.0141575495,
0.0400518142,
-0.0225724187,
0.0262074228,
-0.019335255,
0.0272515342,
0.0570613481,
0.0283069666,
0.0004319302,
-0.0217367932,
-0.0289429259,
0.0064090174,
-0.0046023759,
-0.0680476725,
-0.00629046,
0.0061595668,
-0.0647672191,
0.0314976834,
-0.0584740378,
-0.0370121449,
0.0576573275,
0.0873196274,
0.0275716316,
0.0251925457,
-0.0066838167,
-0.0066310703,
-0.0681576431,
0.0250957571,
-0.0368569605,
0.0283600986,
-0.0125216935,
-0.0928499401,
0.069990322,
0.0210334342,
-0.0126461405,
-0.0056843464,
-0.0786019713,
-0.0240210053,
-0.0379597321,
0.0709755644,
0.0143561736,
0.0848028883,
-0.0090714516,
0.0446205139,
-0.03214439,
-0.0175441317,
-0.0704285875,
-0.0122318231,
0.0471685976,
-0.035057988,
-0.0102343382,
0.0000953229,
0.0050222035,
0.014812897,
0.0242144857,
0.0797668025,
-0.045264259,
-0.0160709321,
0.0511858016,
-0.0575636253,
0.0741312057,
0.0115406634,
0.0077100326,
-0.0490837358,
0.0052392506,
-0.0045325658,
-0.0425942391,
-0.044168897,
-0.0032518054,
-0.0111504272,
-0.0028381171,
-0.0079241311,
0.0348720253,
-0.0202589482,
0.0324657075,
-0.0406939164,
0.0181832053,
0.0178770497,
0.0185297932,
0.02437355,
0.005138495,
0.0075245514,
0.036319416,
0.028539313,
0.0331196077,
0.0114555676,
0.0700659156,
0.0490591675,
0.0701714158,
-0.0009837103,
0.0304523129,
-0.0218843967,
-0.0041078916,
-0.0667916685,
-0.0449813046,
0.0669283569,
-0.0352932923,
0.0105351415,
-0.020719301,
-0.0062375362,
0.0154763181,
0.0498942211,
-0.0255223103,
0.0208190698,
0.0345532075,
0.030146122,
0.012365886,
-0.0086589362,
0.1045650765,
-0.0249191355,
0.066400148,
0.0172910057,
0.0265935287,
-0.0509119257,
-0.0532097295,
0.021543771,
0.0312287826,
0.021568343,
-0.0005895316,
-0.0202462189,
-0.0264106169,
0.0062843761,
-0.0190950371,
-0.0093563311,
0.0154734682,
0.0581261702,
0.0357010514,
-0.0027748658,
-0.0040896167,
-0.0224866308,
-0.0094131213,
0.0592367873,
-0.0372385383,
-0.0464353077,
-5.749567316e-33,
-0.0736070573,
-0.0102134859,
0.0449991524,
0.030491069,
-0.0423052721,
-0.0023773019,
-0.0318716727,
-0.0042069554,
0.0283276886,
0.0011772111,
0.017994687,
0.0178064667,
0.0252532028,
-0.0156008629,
0.0150346607,
-0.0307141133,
0.0673347488,
-0.0160296671,
0.008165732,
-0.0021625201,
-0.0112905679,
0.0311996564,
0.0616523921,
-0.0601096936,
0.0295003112,
0.0208812505,
-0.005249572,
0.0208105836,
0.0179982577,
0.0256907512,
0.0079080155,
-0.0142462282,
0.0121733965,
-0.0533416979,
-0.0229607131,
-0.0087245954,
-0.1080478728,
-0.0429994091,
-0.0058221933,
0.004488762,
-0.0371724479,
-0.045882728,
-0.0363639258,
-0.0243398845,
0.0188709218,
-0.0001945917,
0.0357932895,
-0.0235903561,
0.0339729562,
-0.0580125563,
-0.0803297088,
0.0284519345,
-0.0245699342,
-0.0149150034,
0.0014853331,
0.0074650287,
0.0269442182,
-0.0385807194,
-0.0660475865,
-0.0166379139,
-0.0057092966,
-0.0201749802,
-0.023876898,
-0.0022008135,
0.0000226995,
0.0582228824,
0.0092285918,
-0.0018956243,
-0.0199267697,
0.044018928,
-0.0048622452,
0.0623784289,
0.0348884203,
0.0002916323,
0.0222032126,
0.0678442121,
-0.0581842922,
0.061524082,
-0.0456130579,
0.0499305725,
-0.0220000651,
0.0207286347,
0.0152890636,
0.0101427576,
0.0027607311,
0.0244611856,
0.0046916436,
-0.0269004442,
0.0253521018,
0.0214341134,
0.0076136827,
0.0397038087,
0.0244720168,
-0.0101673845,
0.0071619134,
-0.0062163118,
-0.0190031305,
0.0228427928,
-0.0087170759,
-0.0082163615,
-0.0650370866,
-0.0790223032,
0.0537136495,
-0.0049672304,
0.0437222458,
0.002148364,
0.0361602344,
0.0098579153,
-0.0674094856,
0.009332573,
-0.0017845652,
0.0257989541,
0.0043554907,
0.0831083879,
0.0346761197,
0.0021123749,
-0.0235521831,
0.0518536009,
0.0133040035,
-0.0257353429,
-0.0375506468,
0.0194767881,
0.016875064,
0.0234411322,
0.0247009732,
0.0012813365,
-0.0242062211,
-0.025766097,
0.0016808545,
-0.0148457056,
-0.0031860122,
0.015766561,
2.573e-7,
0.0306880083,
0.0034776067,
0.0288935434,
0.0477044545,
-0.0123371128,
0.0099774655,
-0.0600448661,
0.0221546553,
-0.0463008396,
-0.0363798216,
0.0487828366,
0.0221676342,
0.025877092,
0.0354135446,
-0.0655734539,
-0.0132714584,
0.0050272602,
-0.0384466574,
-0.0582553931,
-0.021049438,
0.030039303,
0.0682573766,
0.0159685425,
0.0298312828,
0.0097296583,
0.023523923,
0.0671226829,
-0.0221271086,
0.0200738497,
0.0030874924,
-0.0277703386,
0.0002445535,
-0.0562501512,
0.0589590445,
-0.0357116684,
0.0210960526,
0.0287121292,
0.0662585571,
-0.0260748379,
0.0017127643,
0.0118855126,
-0.0237919055,
0.017779544,
0.0118184751,
0.0490543246,
-0.0644762218,
-0.0359465294,
0.0524744913,
-0.0260222852,
-0.005454896,
0.0063186348,
0.0268472433,
0.0068668183,
0.0195764601,
0.0229813773,
0.014755398,
-0.050226327,
-0.0819403082,
0.0155945327,
0.0801534355,
-0.0066652228,
-0.0071410951,
0.0137972543,
-0.0521865115,
-0.0019902771,
-0.0554945134,
-0.0114991078,
2.398733287e-34,
0.0277825557,
-0.0109948246,
0.0343303047,
0.0584192798,
0.0176791977,
-0.0113124829,
-0.0310429446,
-0.0009936898,
0.0351760052,
-0.0575138256,
0.008050127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14325v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14325v1 | Towards Harmful Erotic Content Detection through Coreference-Driven Contextual Analysis | 2023-10-22T15:19:04 | 2023-10-22T15:19:04 | Inez Okulska, Emilia Wiśnios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adult content detection still poses a great challenge for automation.
Existing classifiers primarily focus on distinguishing between erotic and
non-erotic texts. However, they often need more nuance in assessing the
potential harm. Unfortunately, the content of this nature falls beyond the
reach of generative models due to its potentially harmful nature. Ethical
restrictions prohibit large language models (LLMs) from analyzing and
classifying harmful erotics, let alone generating them to create synthetic
datasets for other neural models. In such instances where data is scarce and
challenging, a thorough analysis of the structure of such texts rather than a
large model may offer a viable solution. Especially given that harmful erotic
narratives, despite appearing similar to harmless ones, usually reveal their
harmful nature first through contextual information hidden in the non-sexual
parts of the narrative.
This paper introduces a hybrid neural and rule-based context-aware system
that leverages coreference resolution to identify harmful contextual cues in
erotic content. Collaborating with professional moderators, we compiled a
dataset and developed a classifier capable of distinguishing harmful from
non-harmful erotic content. Our hybrid model, tested on Polish text,
demonstrates a promising accuracy of 84% and a recall of 80%. Models based on
RoBERTa and Longformer without explicit usage of coreference chains achieved
significantly weaker results, underscoring the importance of coreference
resolution in detecting such nuanced content as harmful erotics. This approach
also offers the potential for enhanced visual explainability, supporting
moderators in evaluating predictions and taking necessary actions to address
harmful content. | [
0.0918081626,
0.0422559045,
-0.0185852218,
0.0089190742,
-0.0376047418,
0.0371201858,
0.0233957469,
0.0233044717,
0.0434264429,
-0.0452634916,
-0.0410926826,
-0.0422697216,
-0.0214438085,
0.0442730896,
-0.0231808107,
-0.0005197338,
0.010824549,
0.048463311,
0.0481234603,
0.0346949548,
0.0571249798,
0.0231256671,
0.0332106128,
0.021294713,
-0.0149296802,
-0.0145344958,
0.0289114751,
0.021757219,
0.0049713561,
0.0028341804,
0.0444019362,
0.0391337983,
0.0223052073,
0.0493559502,
0.0000018895,
-0.0324595124,
0.0088656424,
-0.0009822521,
0.021452019,
-0.0001001064,
0.0567590669,
-0.0077924673,
-0.0222753547,
-0.0143635804,
-0.0261713918,
0.0400169007,
0.0689503551,
0.0564851873,
0.07246878,
0.0216917899,
-0.0276710168,
0.0100041125,
-0.0152458102,
-0.0243383683,
-0.0198116414,
-0.0359845459,
0.0770482197,
0.0044846521,
0.005957861,
0.0100203007,
-0.0074948813,
0.0085115302,
0.0128785474,
-0.0172107257,
0.0026282019,
-0.0074834088,
-0.0030934317,
-0.0863709226,
0.0215021074,
0.0301739611,
-0.0284705013,
-0.0145704327,
0.0248676576,
-0.0083807344,
-0.0444418192,
-0.0192120615,
-0.0372310206,
0.0629134923,
-0.0484678857,
0.0278346185,
0.0134736765,
0.0318253636,
0.0261311568,
0.060806375,
0.0545631573,
0.0217891,
-0.0155286631,
-0.0000275626,
0.0568411052,
-0.0333385393,
0.0134827625,
-0.0448631942,
0.1043993309,
0.0080821877,
0.0172105674,
0.0392620824,
-0.0159554444,
-0.0114267664,
0.0472317301,
-0.1161076054,
-0.021704061,
0.0237570163,
-0.0390729569,
0.0163733903,
-0.0000478878,
0.025123883,
0.0005249516,
0.0472407453,
-0.0112267844,
0.0009023605,
0.0256718602,
0.0322528556,
-0.0271798391,
0.0014426721,
-0.0483691432,
0.0103913406,
-0.0826683864,
0.0164146721,
-0.0164926592,
-0.0243729092,
0.001265974,
0.0595370568,
-0.0434384272,
0.0201302245,
0.0045571416,
-0.0026334228,
-0.0406890921,
0.0214604586,
-0.0271464381,
0.0125367148,
0.0407473929,
-0.0054011443,
-0.0066330349,
-0.0071250051,
0.0299284086,
0.052032467,
0.0322212018,
0.003166792,
0.0004897191,
-0.0489986576,
-0.0664005131,
-0.0235796012,
-0.0145907151,
-0.033623822,
0.0096237455,
-0.031093074,
-0.033739049,
-0.1026259959,
0.0382698737,
0.041728273,
-0.0687076896,
0.0638615713,
0.0431558453,
-0.0275888462,
0.0193687063,
0.0699788705,
0.0273096934,
0.0689125806,
0.0127051482,
0.0881210119,
0.0345496684,
-0.0040048058,
-0.030809287,
-0.0005862881,
0.0329816006,
0.0197604243,
-0.0218035914,
0.0144051202,
-0.0081086652,
-0.0011334834,
-0.0285626333,
0.0320592299,
0.0061152475,
-0.0641545877,
0.0395790637,
0.0313636474,
0.0173240881,
0.0741440207,
0.0478861257,
-0.027068587,
-0.030320717,
0.024551034,
-0.0816928893,
-0.0076174154,
0.0014446849,
-0.0262394156,
0.0078864219,
0.021000769,
0.0051735719,
-0.0485766046,
-0.0084609641,
0.0211402383,
0.0194682442,
-0.0461369939,
0.0333592705,
0.0284704044,
-0.06436418,
-0.0362429991,
0.0793507397,
-0.0570173413,
0.0223716851,
-0.0194637086,
0.0423179977,
0.0840795785,
0.0269046333,
-0.0124822287,
-0.0332078487,
-0.0292156562,
0.0379751176,
-0.0084989406,
-0.0701857135,
0.0128649669,
0.0079776868,
-0.0355626754,
-0.0573230833,
-0.0323485658,
0.0024468808,
0.0050496869,
-0.0055765966,
0.0087939044,
0.0278684013,
0.032089062,
-0.0479123294,
0.0221113674,
-0.0156465266,
-0.0206273422,
-0.0175354667,
0.0427640192,
0.0506469719,
-0.0088652261,
0.0118642384,
-0.0311409011,
0.0524852052,
-0.0252017565,
-0.0160585828,
-0.0095477691,
-0.045772016,
0.0203001928,
0.0178603157,
-0.0661752596,
0.0155201126,
-0.0453474931,
-0.0158375949,
0.0135409078,
0.018943185,
-0.0441713147,
-0.0010019623,
-0.0592491478,
-0.0272145681,
-0.0015611754,
0.0041885194,
0.0073563675,
0.069461152,
-0.0380169041,
0.0008680009,
0.0357060954,
-0.0434479937,
0.0040885834,
0.0186661631,
-0.0085705649,
-0.048289571,
-0.0473969281,
0.0228113886,
0.0437016189,
0.0565157272,
-0.0312662646,
-0.0397049785,
-0.0519313589,
0.0016474037,
-0.0100610647,
-0.0138081359,
0.0398123004,
0.004061095,
-0.0041791098,
-0.0020319086,
-0.0216622762,
-0.0369214006,
-0.0097560138,
0.0366718061,
-0.0234696064,
-0.0100286696,
-0.0290819462,
-0.0163164064,
0.0157176573,
-0.0125209941,
0.025225006,
0.0340808928,
-0.0060623023,
0.0083277989,
0.0305179823,
-0.0216096081,
0.0365653187,
0.0046577216,
-0.0432680883,
-0.0020614844,
0.0060400567,
-0.021091409,
0.068053253,
0.021941565,
0.0768517777,
0.029882025,
-0.0335939601,
-0.0327603556,
-0.0094941314,
-0.0084074615,
-0.0233276337,
-0.0100355381,
-0.0462076962,
0.0190389808,
0.0422963686,
0.0095254807,
0.0011455431,
-0.0273051206,
0.0417640395,
-0.0416491814,
-0.0323063172,
-0.0084951473,
-0.1029038355,
0.0072012385,
0.0288042277,
-0.0240203179,
-0.0482994728,
0.0442895666,
0.0109807253,
0.0110627552,
-0.0114297159,
-0.0492564701,
-0.0157693699,
0.044514779,
-0.0121436641,
0.0826413333,
0.0530658253,
-0.0491453186,
-0.0183810014,
0.0001740614,
0.0359971188,
-0.0184672363,
0.026282208,
-0.0564988181,
-0.0101410579,
0.0188589916,
-0.0511288717,
-0.0879202113,
-0.0460564494,
-0.012529036,
-0.0476666205,
-0.0110260881,
0.046148479,
-0.0064161434,
0.0424277149,
-0.0223067719,
0.0060915155,
-0.0049479879,
0.0015773406,
0.0125326365,
0.0063423715,
0.0310925469,
-0.0562580116,
-0.0227725226,
0.0231556501,
-0.0277845133,
0.0815350637,
-0.0649672374,
-0.0140472101,
-0.0031415096,
0.0496968627,
0.0036561994,
-0.0227088835,
-0.0065234113,
-0.0085949618,
-0.0153697208,
-0.0588785075,
-0.0431695245,
0.0733613074,
0.0483666062,
-0.0503638908,
0.0034682236,
0.0032738908,
-0.049681019,
0.0115605174,
-0.0089003928,
-0.0440683998,
0.0010918732,
-0.0041919434,
-0.0253221784,
-0.06935139,
-0.0431667157,
-0.0081220241,
-0.0134364236,
0.0299748797,
0.0185358729,
-0.0859984383,
-0.0383951738,
-0.0357387997,
0.0261869207,
-0.0203016084,
0.0183206163,
-0.0116480095,
-0.0172773823,
-0.0304420516,
-0.0152479606,
0.0432283431,
-0.0254986342,
0.0337354392,
-0.0261193067,
0.0239850823,
0.0353998616,
0.0852128118,
-0.0208173599,
-0.0023606871,
0.0152833275,
-0.0150954975,
-0.0066722683,
-0.0355047584,
0.0177627262,
0.0003670539,
-0.0066559827,
-0.0456709452,
0.071645841,
0.0429906361,
-0.0365413949,
-0.0093788374,
0.0671796799,
0.0308403131,
0.0037561143,
-0.04774886,
0.0682687163,
0.0331268795,
0.0604194142,
0.0352152921,
-0.036167603,
0.0282359868,
-0.0434719212,
0.0051215803,
0.0057665445,
-0.0403754376,
-0.0487632379,
-0.023089461,
0.0050006229,
-0.0739293694,
0.015015617,
-0.0045459201,
-0.0021584923,
0.0521495678,
-0.0238977149,
-0.0085695898,
0.0028803358,
-0.058582969,
-0.0260845795,
0.0236972123,
-0.008337399,
-0.0515512004,
0.0350468457,
-0.0000972031,
-0.010284083,
-0.0142408041,
0.0865322351,
-0.0097562587,
-0.0031855484,
0.0189345516,
0.0473530069,
0.0178584754,
0.0030862642,
-0.0347019695,
-0.0230075214,
0.0188670158,
0.0570350252,
-0.0737790391,
-0.0573548339,
0.0431108028,
0.0048712888,
0.0148256076,
0.0291874539,
-0.0362984724,
0.0243930016,
0.0241170023,
-0.0483462699,
-0.0400607102,
-0.0664089024,
0.0045437124,
0.0002772242,
-0.0373285897,
-0.0474338718,
-0.0132794203,
-0.0187132303,
-0.0192477554,
-0.0225915182,
0.0047212965,
0.0000789088,
0.0494881719,
0.0304597951,
-0.0220493097,
-0.0301434435,
0.0448180139,
-0.054742489,
0.0155050363,
-0.0670976043,
-0.0426411554,
0.0387944803,
0.0086780852,
0.0233087651,
0.0171707012,
-0.0096459584,
0.0022887583,
0.0273820758,
0.0357793421,
-0.0369972922,
0.0328905955,
0.0036212499,
-0.0185423866,
-0.0120979259,
0.0160243977,
-0.0325775631,
0.0423376821,
-0.052034907,
-0.0285351183,
0.0062492345,
-0.0166376922,
0.0244279336,
-0.008564177,
-0.0172320679,
0.0002843335,
0.0392507687,
-0.0505440757,
-0.069064483,
-0.0175041687,
-0.0054754587,
-0.010178946,
0.0185219925,
0.0282535013,
0.005373443,
0.0022015688,
0.0808548108,
-0.0411579236,
-0.0217360556,
0.0027699412,
-0.0065341704,
0.0298452694,
-0.0223136917,
0.043083977,
-0.0621725284,
-0.046672862,
0.0171317961,
-0.0835690349,
0.0296255685,
-0.0006232104,
0.0023972876,
0.0203285869,
0.0062082577,
-0.0172492526,
0.0076389187,
0.0105464468,
0.0256712902,
-0.0330096781,
-0.0647443905,
-5.500635449e-33,
-0.0222985297,
-0.0348094702,
-0.0066183191,
0.0292391311,
-0.0206097644,
-0.0097292997,
-0.0064567118,
-0.0323921852,
0.0391576029,
0.0160974786,
-0.0000202513,
0.0224510673,
0.0040214844,
-0.0088106086,
-0.0133389514,
-0.0208828542,
0.040683303,
0.0099180229,
-0.0458002687,
0.0671806782,
0.0629156902,
0.0536708795,
0.0522502773,
-0.148104161,
0.0370770358,
0.0436624289,
-0.0654643849,
-0.0027994516,
-0.0048472472,
0.0432559103,
-0.0390358083,
0.0321209095,
0.0082027232,
-0.0133430967,
0.0202004127,
0.0337101631,
-0.0724341646,
-0.0230741557,
0.0651635379,
0.0294678286,
0.0223400835,
-0.0237977169,
0.0663890168,
-0.0012388708,
0.0506571718,
-0.0208216365,
0.0421455093,
-0.0404877812,
-0.0126332603,
-0.0534632765,
-0.0630196556,
-0.0116144763,
-0.0155761335,
-0.022927152,
-0.008778356,
0.0517487787,
-0.0054789311,
0.0161555875,
-0.0759558603,
0.003963884,
0.0284254495,
0.0000177124,
-0.0042496016,
-0.0475369841,
0.0126074972,
0.0690922588,
0.0028224017,
-0.0167385582,
-0.0453407727,
0.0295884795,
0.0088530108,
0.0790617615,
0.0182724465,
0.0417593978,
0.0043687462,
0.0070906561,
-0.0858107209,
-0.0175971482,
-0.0001753349,
0.0212997682,
0.0201915335,
-0.0213694014,
-0.0497627594,
-0.0222751386,
-0.019251762,
-0.0454795547,
-0.028907707,
-0.0462138504,
0.0087659769,
-0.0221172459,
-0.0498612933,
0.0052334997,
-0.0580352731,
-0.0844725594,
-0.0210557431,
0.0102499034,
0.0198617745,
-0.0261392128,
0.0103584453,
0.0283496715,
-0.0236693732,
0.0312798619,
0.0148726543,
-0.0129389064,
0.0486740954,
-0.0124945659,
0.0600369051,
0.0427289605,
-0.0495967343,
-0.0030703363,
-0.0443454944,
0.049570296,
0.0597493984,
0.0514135435,
-0.0222728569,
0.0273116324,
-0.0343511291,
0.057081949,
0.0485640094,
0.0530519411,
-0.0041027949,
-0.0431752428,
0.0256432295,
0.0540674292,
-0.0211307947,
-0.0254844688,
0.0002282041,
0.0045304052,
0.0719731748,
-0.0631766319,
-0.0006924928,
0.0061573349,
2.618e-7,
0.023725586,
0.0153545886,
0.0130098974,
-0.0312892497,
0.011896682,
0.0339954197,
0.0347144343,
0.0214978606,
0.0331466198,
-0.0246030986,
-0.0054744659,
0.0158947296,
0.0103922812,
0.0444966592,
-0.0329897143,
-0.0008796463,
-0.0487473235,
-0.0237047877,
-0.0292707682,
0.0136817861,
-0.0164845791,
0.0935472772,
0.0773620978,
-0.0726213679,
0.0062339422,
-0.0446591079,
0.0196292549,
-0.0358029418,
0.0046363892,
0.0000010149,
0.0026774125,
0.045902919,
0.001647661,
0.0097696539,
0.008229861,
-0.005548669,
0.0148179494,
0.0511742122,
-0.0203437787,
0.0039514611,
0.0046897968,
-0.0595803261,
0.0152724329,
-0.0343639739,
0.0971725807,
-0.0329224505,
0.0123451259,
-0.0183638297,
-0.0015856938,
-0.02381308,
0.0273344517,
-0.061106015,
0.0251366533,
0.0265397616,
-0.0024652458,
-0.0096511114,
0.0048579909,
-0.0519968122,
0.0310387183,
-0.0074661956,
0.0061258669,
-0.0100992071,
-0.0285949614,
0.0141872484,
-0.0165963732,
-0.0497127883,
0.0251795519,
2.17996208e-34,
0.0364805013,
-0.040357355,
-0.0077678561,
0.0026766574,
0.0018663706,
0.024019612,
0.0002624573,
-0.0036453607,
-0.0032735562,
0.0218374766,
-0.0197841413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18345v1 | A Survey on Semantic Processing Techniques | 2023-10-22T15:09:51 | 2023-10-22T15:09:51 | Rui Mao, Kai He, Xulang Zhang, Guanyi Chen, Jinjie Ni, Zonglin Yang, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Semantic processing is a fundamental research domain in computational
linguistics. In the era of powerful pre-trained language models and large
language models, the advancement of research in this domain appears to be
decelerating. However, the study of semantics is multi-dimensional in
linguistics. The research depth and breadth of computational semantic
processing can be largely improved with new technologies. In this survey, we
analyzed five semantic processing tasks, e.g., word sense disambiguation,
anaphora resolution, named entity recognition, concept extraction, and
subjectivity detection. We study relevant theoretical research in these fields,
advanced methods, and downstream applications. We connect the surveyed tasks
with downstream applications because this may inspire future scholars to fuse
these low-level semantic processing tasks with high-level natural language
processing tasks. The review of theoretical research may also inspire new tasks
and technologies in the semantic processing domain. Finally, we compare the
different semantic processing techniques and summarize their technical trends,
application trends, and future directions. | [
0.0622656345,
0.0125026004,
-0.005192589,
0.0254765265,
-0.0821003318,
0.0179978255,
-0.039463304,
0.01468297,
-0.0107919425,
-0.0844577402,
-0.0081134075,
0.0280469079,
-0.0039080712,
-0.0302510876,
-0.045959089,
-0.0318015628,
0.0740859061,
0.0216539707,
-0.0029743868,
0.0169615168,
-0.012321773,
0.029315602,
-0.0195218232,
-0.0055456022,
-0.0219740532,
0.0187317096,
0.0220799483,
-0.0019961998,
0.0217178371,
-0.0567783713,
0.0240714997,
0.0347272195,
-0.0399144813,
0.0491029695,
0.0000018324,
-0.0572398156,
-0.0576821305,
0.0085952627,
0.0114070969,
-0.0750275999,
0.0848668516,
-0.0455598347,
0.0272713993,
0.0018860834,
-0.0438530445,
-0.038490396,
0.0333546922,
0.0161155351,
0.0460365601,
0.0053674276,
-0.0093919551,
-0.0713313296,
0.0088446299,
0.0303176343,
-0.0320164002,
-0.0163590051,
0.0257071126,
-0.0485576205,
-0.0391414538,
-0.0187764689,
-0.0336702392,
0.0190308634,
-0.0324967429,
0.0497473925,
0.010815518,
0.0170543995,
-0.0447831005,
-0.0099913888,
-0.0405253582,
0.0372023173,
0.013536131,
0.0007135996,
0.0271912254,
-0.0100784581,
-0.0449953116,
0.0043485346,
0.0044472222,
0.0009866491,
-0.0163293071,
0.0419226177,
0.0304471198,
0.0165034421,
-0.0218863785,
0.0514354594,
0.0125585236,
0.0804653391,
0.0125132632,
-0.0306247231,
0.0383811891,
0.0501749441,
0.0088298358,
-0.0106533905,
0.0334556065,
0.0126414746,
0.0256711952,
0.0644949675,
-0.0283670723,
-0.0413628891,
0.0312179737,
-0.0772271752,
-0.0363998562,
0.0271470845,
0.042888131,
0.0418136977,
-0.0271189995,
-0.0160402525,
0.0199732129,
0.0213483293,
-0.043530073,
-0.0358509794,
-0.0802169144,
0.0168170687,
-0.0592086501,
0.0948160067,
-0.060531389,
0.0025190061,
-0.0606237389,
-0.0111609446,
0.0141039658,
-0.0214916803,
-0.0242747404,
0.0184477083,
-0.041346129,
0.0405667946,
-0.0682159513,
0.0374871455,
-0.0002033477,
0.0048595341,
-0.0778844655,
-0.0196536165,
0.0317207985,
-0.0036680023,
0.0365553051,
-0.0291703381,
0.0194369387,
0.0677225962,
0.0503980741,
-0.0529182851,
-0.0542387329,
-0.049025204,
-0.0111865206,
-0.0598244257,
-0.0378400385,
-0.0862218663,
0.0138366055,
0.0078442097,
-0.0007345077,
-0.0447878689,
0.0132035324,
0.0077154194,
-0.0482481644,
0.0761214867,
-0.0198022593,
-0.0262545347,
0.0467111692,
0.0001637932,
0.0736525208,
0.0464271046,
-0.0109776258,
0.0078545129,
0.0453123748,
0.0221654549,
-0.0636679307,
-0.0238338169,
-0.0009890802,
-0.0256835893,
0.0031338949,
-0.0460596494,
-0.0303855576,
-0.0124327485,
-0.0228056386,
0.0649028048,
-0.0114881489,
-0.0569565445,
-0.0016074661,
0.0591311343,
-0.0046143578,
-0.0400578529,
0.010151241,
-0.0013781959,
0.0302751809,
0.0305821896,
-0.0288358629,
0.0167557206,
-0.0106473649,
-0.038512364,
-0.0299555864,
0.0393204167,
-0.0027277844,
-0.0565738976,
-0.0130974809,
-0.0246019904,
0.0156489592,
0.0032322595,
0.0727339163,
0.0223975275,
-0.0109116705,
0.0125885094,
0.045385547,
-0.0110134892,
0.0423108861,
-0.0069792327,
-0.0107752234,
0.067179963,
0.0265024547,
-0.0690447465,
-0.0490497015,
-0.0030986993,
-0.026895484,
0.0566979609,
0.0285503119,
-0.0063260039,
0.0259952974,
-0.0078000799,
-0.0040190178,
0.0155001301,
0.0020870739,
-0.0015053153,
0.0165165029,
0.0521580912,
-0.0013242891,
-0.0140235424,
-0.0028252879,
0.0562629439,
0.0294489786,
0.0018203004,
0.0006098616,
0.0067627067,
0.0296282154,
0.0418240577,
-0.0017556925,
-0.0259633102,
0.0000200812,
-0.0203579273,
-0.029107349,
0.0353484005,
-0.0006188039,
-0.0693843067,
0.0171927344,
-0.0418826193,
-0.0011307024,
0.0163719337,
-0.0138370935,
-0.0453634746,
0.0265736263,
-0.011706871,
0.0070640524,
-0.0810117275,
0.0319106318,
-0.0028219919,
0.0173408855,
-0.063942425,
0.0650850683,
0.0103846025,
0.0134627912,
-0.0318908356,
-0.0032806797,
0.0254885647,
0.0173122622,
-0.0649878234,
0.0147703877,
0.0182357486,
-0.0051553799,
0.0387618355,
-0.0490071625,
-0.0579990037,
-0.0125621269,
-0.0565493628,
0.0302614328,
-0.0015921011,
0.0298030395,
0.0205151606,
0.0225777272,
-0.0063838689,
-0.0024715629,
0.008959122,
0.028413998,
0.0241921153,
0.0177449174,
0.0265453421,
0.0159028806,
-0.0094057685,
-0.021471167,
-0.0010140325,
-0.0276767574,
0.0305489916,
0.0264034253,
-0.0713969395,
0.0003599059,
0.0504479446,
-0.0781570151,
0.0457086265,
0.0540154651,
-0.0148977786,
-0.015487819,
-0.0028342644,
0.0071736053,
0.034630958,
0.018702494,
0.0505391173,
0.0333972052,
-0.0225263704,
-0.0397149995,
0.0070308824,
-0.0616049692,
0.0285198539,
0.0064103212,
-0.0427477881,
0.0381050631,
0.06755279,
0.0354480967,
-0.0173736755,
-0.0059325737,
0.0397360027,
-0.0772822276,
-0.0349341668,
0.0162044335,
0.0450870767,
-0.0065495102,
0.0383337364,
-0.0150262453,
-0.0101938657,
0.0740024522,
0.0110775372,
0.0288643483,
-0.0716904178,
0.0281757955,
-0.0112861982,
0.0600666441,
-0.010392868,
0.0601250157,
0.0062029595,
-0.0530312844,
0.0047802911,
-0.0368275978,
0.029036006,
-0.0337256566,
0.0061753863,
-0.0587888658,
0.041153457,
0.0019926017,
0.0284824017,
-0.0407178216,
-0.0576639399,
-0.0174653325,
-0.0138706546,
-0.0039479127,
0.0261964984,
0.0431602299,
0.0200274233,
-0.0319659114,
-0.01537422,
0.0370503291,
-0.0331395082,
-0.0206861757,
0.0268496871,
0.0073997295,
-0.0345111638,
-0.0023787243,
0.041485887,
0.0152261974,
0.0694965422,
-0.029020248,
-0.0112290885,
-0.0306900516,
0.0096898796,
0.0343650132,
-0.0965635702,
-0.0181425307,
-0.0542413443,
-0.0051018144,
-0.0290932246,
0.0215836894,
0.1426279992,
0.0747586414,
0.0030865537,
-0.0018959993,
0.0186455529,
-0.0382637829,
0.0377141461,
-0.0149990581,
-0.0556341037,
-0.0333098918,
-0.0424571,
-0.0036886018,
-0.0417922996,
-0.0857273862,
0.0105436379,
-0.0730725303,
0.0173810739,
-0.0706227645,
-0.0764353275,
0.0066198888,
-0.0333905183,
0.0547715761,
0.000509417,
-0.0445476919,
-0.0582215935,
-0.0000652984,
0.0158182885,
0.0144091807,
0.0038238496,
0.0052987309,
0.0167066585,
-0.0632548183,
0.0296863019,
0.0279361643,
0.0738257393,
-0.0002631495,
0.0167086516,
-0.0127656283,
-0.0677099079,
0.0121687315,
-0.0390277915,
0.0491997898,
-0.0155167645,
-0.0140234865,
-0.0217509512,
-0.0127937449,
-0.008287169,
-0.0104927206,
-0.0007725229,
0.0175917447,
-0.0348565467,
-0.0057828641,
-0.0313611589,
0.0133395921,
-0.0071487157,
0.0720215961,
-0.0367116928,
-0.0058566038,
-0.0479806364,
0.0560608283,
0.028771231,
-0.012108732,
-0.0153318932,
-0.0160326604,
-0.0439007096,
-0.0211350825,
-0.0736215711,
-0.0667246878,
0.0326255783,
0.0305146966,
-0.0162777267,
0.0415371843,
0.0581481457,
0.0140323937,
-0.0589190759,
-0.0136407623,
-0.0373577662,
0.0046648541,
0.0042134179,
-0.0206580665,
0.066847913,
0.0135369422,
-0.0303316098,
0.0284902789,
-0.0332042128,
-0.0353386626,
0.0369317941,
-0.020203026,
0.0086587807,
0.023031868,
-0.07005018,
0.0135255186,
-0.0027672446,
0.0226384513,
-0.0583147183,
0.0485617481,
-0.0012268022,
0.0491300672,
-0.0085602952,
0.0430513769,
-0.0042530112,
0.0627960935,
0.0478932038,
0.0057485695,
-0.0158911292,
-0.0330894031,
0.0430694781,
0.0222147312,
0.0616861656,
-0.0137933455,
-0.0326731317,
-0.0074448455,
-0.0149230119,
-0.0041558556,
-0.0236112662,
-0.0113185141,
-0.0201625824,
0.0032698107,
0.0310764536,
-0.0384746194,
0.0376568735,
-0.0221062284,
-0.0041146423,
0.0403219834,
0.0123609854,
0.0316773616,
0.0118768187,
-0.0581545271,
0.0256044231,
0.0133408811,
0.0095274411,
0.002074929,
-0.0047725281,
-0.024582101,
0.0026546649,
0.008277053,
-0.0231172182,
-0.0786727667,
0.0006338061,
-0.0144145293,
0.0457659699,
-0.003771889,
0.080787681,
0.0531099625,
0.0035396286,
-0.0013415619,
-0.0090156207,
-0.0224583596,
0.0318960361,
-0.0251975209,
0.0284928456,
0.028106885,
0.0089649186,
-0.0016154964,
0.0000893069,
-0.0220918115,
0.0222561751,
-0.0611847118,
0.0403612554,
0.0377204604,
-0.0464773662,
-0.0239353273,
-0.0064804945,
-0.0158251133,
0.0103979092,
0.0118834628,
0.0503983833,
-0.0825364515,
-0.0349735804,
0.0640271455,
-0.043712303,
0.0057708765,
-0.0015908849,
0.0570674986,
0.0373138674,
0.0380299315,
0.0057367664,
-0.068062447,
-0.0274830349,
-0.0591228232,
-0.026594907,
0.0215695743,
-6.056433055e-33,
-0.0492301248,
-0.0217583813,
-0.0286015105,
0.0333226435,
0.0013321606,
0.0051180399,
-0.0021166599,
-0.0010048654,
0.0110043548,
0.0159761347,
0.016441131,
0.0298544038,
0.0183408242,
-0.0027325263,
-0.0277869999,
-0.0284320842,
0.0491489135,
0.0009350858,
-0.0343019739,
-0.0059868591,
0.0640536547,
-0.0007709818,
0.0733964518,
-0.0885714144,
0.0321380571,
0.0564593859,
0.0241283327,
0.003922936,
0.0406321064,
0.0331191458,
-0.0047802231,
0.0793727487,
0.027325524,
-0.0558918081,
0.0035573768,
-0.0223103389,
-0.1407236755,
-0.0690758824,
0.0319413319,
0.0409885384,
-0.0196484439,
-0.0257357899,
0.0440960936,
0.0018865835,
-0.0063214176,
0.0399986655,
0.0431617238,
-0.0139505221,
0.0239447076,
-0.0133705353,
-0.0717022121,
0.0238877777,
-0.0077412557,
0.017718114,
0.0418731943,
-0.0485357419,
0.0002728458,
0.0145155387,
-0.0636575669,
0.0259245336,
-0.0353218876,
0.0083658304,
0.0068517993,
0.0167429633,
0.0150303626,
0.0399614759,
0.0235519633,
-0.0329991765,
0.0057584257,
0.0538100451,
0.0136231128,
0.0232539065,
0.0207827128,
0.0626168326,
0.0183912776,
-0.0146046327,
-0.0313920714,
0.0264063366,
0.0587658361,
0.0194100495,
0.0029523717,
-0.0213490576,
-0.053893555,
-0.0366751067,
-0.0570417568,
-0.0027153979,
-0.0271286089,
-0.009108969,
0.0070729475,
-0.0186398644,
-0.0699360296,
0.0762654617,
-0.000279873,
-0.0224773828,
0.0014309993,
0.0026846316,
0.0493559428,
0.0423961505,
0.0219264571,
0.0370188281,
-0.0299828462,
-0.0045608687,
0.0033638212,
0.0162589401,
-0.0010379349,
-0.04538849,
-0.0349137187,
-0.0023412458,
-0.0212804228,
0.0187279657,
0.0061887512,
0.0176069494,
-0.0297461059,
-0.0161507837,
-0.0169423074,
0.0045941928,
0.0037998522,
-0.0080823433,
0.053491123,
0.0153844757,
-0.0531039201,
0.0014697274,
0.0280605834,
0.0215295088,
-0.0228885394,
0.0045135426,
0.0216508042,
-0.025947338,
0.0006647599,
-0.0132940607,
0.0012295016,
-0.0146327429,
2.721e-7,
0.0535874218,
0.0131718088,
-0.0201721769,
-0.0195570271,
0.0028312185,
-0.0118986629,
0.0375323929,
0.0282886103,
-0.0301901884,
-0.0118626347,
-0.0140473396,
0.0468017869,
-0.0362038389,
0.041872669,
-0.0631543472,
0.0107826944,
0.0437084846,
0.0067554661,
-0.0474969298,
0.0270849559,
0.0812632293,
0.0547873117,
0.0248194858,
-0.0124216294,
-0.0581117421,
-0.0111953532,
0.0195672177,
0.0251128878,
0.0188748725,
0.0452719666,
-0.0220944975,
0.0374247357,
0.028887175,
0.0507598631,
0.010209891,
0.0002623841,
0.0682517216,
0.0275625102,
-0.0115204947,
0.0108533427,
-0.0139780194,
-0.0255878866,
0.0233067889,
0.0187496394,
0.0741441846,
-0.0574627519,
-0.014247275,
-0.0133070191,
0.0100115305,
0.0221848283,
-0.0166838039,
0.0110882297,
-0.0447304547,
0.0043356521,
0.0039975042,
-0.0172536019,
-0.0477941781,
-0.0648522377,
0.0085359477,
-0.0129421921,
0.014215284,
-0.0471900403,
0.0518303514,
-0.0090261167,
-0.008415998,
-0.0598927699,
-0.0252127852,
1.966214274e-34,
-0.0100841075,
0.0399447158,
-0.0205536559,
0.0206575375,
-0.0338705294,
-0.0048583127,
-0.0466234572,
0.0036608018,
-0.0075471126,
-0.0129999304,
0.0479656793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18344v1 | Chainpoll: A high efficacy method for LLM hallucination detection | 2023-10-22T14:45:14 | 2023-10-22T14:45:14 | Robert Friel, Atindriyo Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have experienced notable advancements in
generating coherent and contextually relevant responses. However,
hallucinations - incorrect or unfounded claims - are still prevalent, prompting
the creation of automated metrics to detect these in LLM outputs. Our
contributions include: introducing ChainPoll, an innovative hallucination
detection method that excels compared to its counterparts, and unveiling
RealHall, a refined collection of benchmark datasets to assess hallucination
detection metrics from recent studies. While creating RealHall, we assessed
tasks and datasets from previous hallucination detection studies and observed
that many are not suitable for the potent LLMs currently in use. Overcoming
this, we opted for four datasets challenging for modern LLMs and pertinent to
real-world scenarios. Using RealHall, we conducted a comprehensive comparison
of ChainPoll with numerous hallucination metrics from recent studies. Our
findings indicate that ChainPoll outperforms in all RealHall benchmarks,
achieving an overall AUROC of 0.781. This surpasses the next best theoretical
method by 11% and exceeds industry standards by over 23%. Additionally,
ChainPoll is cost-effective and offers greater transparency than other metrics.
We introduce two novel metrics to assess LLM hallucinations: Adherence and
Correctness. Adherence is relevant to Retrieval Augmented Generation workflows,
evaluating an LLM's analytical capabilities within given documents and
contexts. In contrast, Correctness identifies logical and reasoning errors. | [
0.0375735611,
0.0470269248,
-0.0197470151,
0.0447082259,
-0.0582245365,
0.0194730405,
-0.0142122693,
0.0283353906,
0.0149663808,
-0.0575133674,
0.0077600959,
-0.0429261848,
-0.0001378278,
-0.0030392795,
0.0189788789,
-0.023434557,
0.0659451932,
-0.018827742,
0.0170311239,
0.000586135,
-0.0028842685,
0.0323466286,
-0.0220567044,
0.0573914573,
-0.0239491258,
-0.0412542298,
0.0114387805,
0.0289549921,
0.0179314371,
-0.0116382716,
0.0079699615,
0.0740299299,
-0.0202322528,
0.0953595862,
0.0000022337,
-0.0772964805,
-0.0275356229,
-0.0082068937,
-0.0141927991,
-0.0004817398,
0.0322501995,
0.0135969883,
-0.0191448573,
0.0172279533,
-0.0332348533,
-0.0052307067,
0.027494425,
0.0629656389,
0.0551683903,
0.0692890063,
-0.006563161,
-0.0124653075,
0.0521154888,
0.0262948703,
0.0452656485,
0.0175407734,
0.0317195803,
0.0307098348,
-0.0059164986,
-0.0191831738,
0.008037447,
0.0340804867,
0.012082627,
-0.0137874726,
-0.026444681,
-0.0088633997,
-0.1043777168,
-0.0344437137,
0.0196175799,
0.0532206781,
-0.0090575237,
-0.0495777614,
0.0112516368,
0.0028997834,
0.0187486205,
-0.0004525514,
-0.0428103395,
0.0340048559,
-0.0488939397,
0.0078404406,
0.024916932,
-0.0039682481,
0.0310855508,
0.0112498803,
-0.0106891403,
0.090226464,
0.0123394858,
-0.0496341325,
0.0344128311,
0.0016918919,
-0.0107964613,
-0.0364974551,
0.0331255645,
0.0035514873,
-0.0465705208,
0.0085447356,
-0.0419856086,
-0.034269385,
0.0829771683,
-0.0824176222,
0.0017866626,
-0.0023123093,
-0.0665109158,
0.039843455,
-0.0442239977,
0.0585062318,
-0.0237847008,
0.0494489335,
-0.0218999032,
0.0001817046,
-0.0230702143,
-0.0281336643,
-0.0273017939,
0.0141794225,
-0.0133054098,
-0.0302410945,
-0.0293140225,
0.0012619712,
-0.0445295535,
0.0285002161,
-0.0380264185,
0.0184718464,
0.0051644393,
-0.0221446175,
-0.0014908271,
0.0198237356,
-0.0062803421,
0.0121308034,
0.0271768682,
-0.094812192,
-0.0216915123,
0.0437530242,
-0.0142012322,
0.011514456,
0.0046513285,
0.024499489,
0.0221939869,
-0.0079286294,
-0.04659063,
-0.0618569627,
-0.0240147542,
-0.0594757199,
-0.0059172045,
-0.083422482,
0.0147935366,
0.0056741103,
-0.0186680313,
-0.0273589883,
0.0232082903,
0.0374606363,
-0.0267098285,
0.0406428128,
-0.0238049552,
0.0022271068,
0.0428201966,
0.0469898954,
-0.0198004711,
0.0726861879,
-0.003252618,
0.0395844504,
0.0472855978,
-0.0056521129,
0.0467166565,
0.0149089266,
-0.0081668235,
0.0063192756,
-0.0165462643,
-0.0140541028,
-0.0019997719,
0.0125682438,
0.0169633999,
0.0524373539,
-0.0207898095,
-0.0197892822,
0.0499231778,
0.016215099,
0.0156228477,
-0.0272227004,
0.031464465,
0.0145239439,
0.0147823943,
0.0342812799,
-0.034591306,
0.0049183709,
-0.0633185729,
0.00308028,
0.0566983894,
0.0089763878,
0.0004711529,
-0.0388795622,
-0.0387610085,
0.0222136956,
-0.0265523754,
0.0028250189,
0.0146208303,
0.0352766663,
-0.0759740546,
0.073698394,
0.0200407449,
-0.0666682422,
0.002056262,
-0.047695145,
0.0129445354,
0.0705695152,
0.0732078776,
-0.0179801658,
0.0158758424,
-0.0297790468,
0.0438867435,
0.0734576657,
0.0287848767,
0.0029416685,
-0.0051702247,
-0.0524993837,
0.0074940142,
-0.0135765392,
0.0583886281,
-0.000892284,
0.0097534815,
-0.0076967133,
0.024528509,
-0.0494782478,
-0.0417043343,
0.045464322,
-0.0178589597,
-0.0093305251,
-0.0411642417,
-0.0162122194,
0.0084556239,
0.0103767412,
-0.0108561935,
0.0369770378,
0.0135066481,
-0.0430276096,
-0.0204438791,
0.0067636883,
-0.038798593,
-0.0173144061,
0.0314860903,
-0.0251138806,
0.0130028939,
0.0067707468,
-0.0085864216,
-0.0293072555,
0.0021195826,
-0.0679525733,
0.0344728492,
-0.061913088,
0.0567204058,
-0.0161734577,
0.0489552394,
-0.0159288291,
0.09336932,
-0.035368938,
0.035554748,
0.0427385159,
0.0210721958,
-0.0003836399,
-0.0161394514,
-0.0214688107,
0.0132664014,
-0.0113090267,
0.0137966014,
0.0113578197,
-0.046903152,
-0.0648076087,
-0.01976154,
-0.0622482449,
0.0052388259,
-0.041801393,
0.0076450645,
0.0208414104,
-0.0367408432,
-0.0282155164,
0.0033603094,
-0.0009020793,
-0.0122326566,
0.0301838722,
0.0418127738,
-0.0143266302,
-0.0048725833,
-0.0275722016,
-0.0225406308,
0.0184644014,
-0.0100232745,
0.0404048935,
-0.0107261138,
-0.0319764316,
-0.0835607797,
0.0521264635,
-0.0410880744,
-0.0095052486,
-0.0200308841,
0.004097715,
0.0210479442,
-0.0109444698,
0.0469709672,
0.0409397967,
0.0336429849,
0.0135766109,
0.0518607274,
-0.0369542986,
-0.0666375607,
-0.0222328175,
0.0020157304,
0.0089321639,
0.001516278,
-0.0803127736,
0.0367444046,
0.0337333828,
0.0408425592,
0.0312393662,
-0.0585719272,
0.0154505027,
-0.0373346247,
-0.066475451,
0.012520086,
-0.0441980101,
-0.0329553969,
0.0444983765,
-0.0259214547,
-0.0669999123,
0.0555870384,
-0.0453572869,
0.0105783148,
-0.0162403621,
0.0026447764,
-0.0120601347,
0.0432695076,
0.0131600676,
0.0147455242,
-0.0144391349,
-0.0219562016,
-0.0208210777,
0.0050275316,
-0.0130685242,
-0.0763244182,
0.0234021842,
-0.0521035269,
-0.0000724839,
0.0131211029,
0.0149431815,
-0.0670443848,
-0.0085841725,
0.0017930176,
-0.0197859295,
-0.0280541424,
0.0088438364,
-0.0496728085,
0.0008906107,
0.0117063755,
0.0307291411,
-0.0102401013,
-0.0096690506,
0.0092974892,
0.0110869221,
0.0722426102,
-0.0321895592,
0.0721313581,
-0.0328320414,
0.0140896067,
0.0936095193,
0.0197453853,
0.0457531065,
-0.0086686322,
-0.0297947489,
0.0158700496,
-0.0159465969,
-0.0322234593,
0.0119961463,
0.0127162058,
-0.0668630302,
-0.0198803879,
0.0905484185,
0.0326867104,
-0.0491168573,
-0.0146639226,
-0.0645908788,
0.0605519898,
0.007236084,
-0.0235965457,
-0.086800307,
-0.0126884682,
0.0124507099,
0.0144848945,
-0.053507179,
-0.0222779084,
-0.014228398,
-0.0995353386,
0.057556361,
0.0228346381,
-0.0075551481,
-0.0175537355,
-0.0275841318,
0.0196789224,
0.0381377675,
0.0366938449,
0.0184903201,
0.0133386767,
-0.0271991603,
0.0057248292,
-0.0501957722,
-0.0143308509,
0.018412048,
-0.0122180507,
0.0343158133,
0.076555565,
0.0315563865,
0.0017979041,
-0.1002496928,
0.029758377,
-0.0216275305,
-0.0189552289,
-0.0054844869,
0.0657548606,
0.0205042679,
0.035592325,
-0.0178089384,
0.0127439899,
-0.0235146191,
-0.0260209758,
0.0114402203,
0.0696902499,
-0.0433083661,
-0.0390435085,
-0.0407916419,
0.0646405891,
0.0079879146,
0.0947220922,
0.0337630436,
-0.0092879375,
-0.0492954142,
-0.0066177594,
0.0604466386,
-0.0612754114,
-0.036545489,
0.0346930027,
0.045566,
0.0051765935,
-0.0870446414,
-0.0252379868,
-0.0072708237,
0.0123092812,
-0.0138033852,
0.0429224744,
-0.068964541,
-0.0090698041,
-0.0357439853,
0.0209482312,
-0.030091688,
0.014970405,
-0.0402461328,
0.0200556666,
0.0005021631,
0.0010544109,
0.0086276988,
0.0583642013,
-0.0858318284,
-0.0589937083,
0.0315664299,
0.0137550961,
0.0318639576,
0.0317168497,
-0.0074432767,
-0.0302140862,
0.0400535278,
0.0567576177,
-0.0018225423,
0.037759345,
0.0087561142,
-0.0104388837,
-0.0036007022,
0.0250426084,
-0.0359330699,
0.0015797967,
-0.0177986734,
0.0611138493,
0.0070503717,
-0.015043526,
0.0337397009,
0.0000489804,
0.0036193661,
-0.02082064,
-0.0009607421,
-0.0188297518,
-0.0002910555,
-0.0180335883,
-0.0309127662,
-0.0229359455,
0.0270920824,
0.0219541285,
-0.0348037072,
0.0090917619,
-0.0057733767,
-0.0423886664,
0.0340055563,
-0.0341222435,
-0.0148446476,
-0.0076182187,
0.0192574915,
0.0330749378,
-0.0232346021,
-0.0363539271,
0.0046910159,
-0.0152273411,
0.0687804967,
0.0118758427,
0.0851083025,
-0.0028818185,
-0.0378699861,
0.0059345989,
0.017105462,
-0.0268971231,
-0.0525265969,
-0.024365291,
0.0142170377,
0.029114062,
-0.0063590189,
0.0988927037,
-0.0282121189,
0.0059258854,
-0.0175153371,
0.00449102,
0.0410487838,
-0.0444531627,
-0.0196191613,
0.0296620037,
-0.0295578409,
0.008633229,
0.0484676287,
-0.0272822101,
0.036414586,
-0.0047366363,
-0.0206770804,
-0.0209229384,
-0.0762324259,
-0.0414652973,
0.0001776226,
-0.0281778183,
-0.0388314202,
-0.088354528,
-0.0374740995,
0.0094813388,
0.0079922685,
0.0064977375,
0.0040642624,
-0.0052728071,
0.0931737125,
-0.0233418699,
-0.0377325192,
-0.0295469034,
-0.0001389129,
0.0057364097,
0.0074022664,
-0.0128442431,
-6.458985136e-33,
-0.0117940493,
-0.0644186959,
0.0012656574,
-0.0342480913,
-0.0213872939,
-0.0158245191,
-0.0321768075,
0.0087597836,
0.0149646457,
0.0161585715,
0.0273910407,
0.0218117572,
0.0168678015,
0.0005616439,
0.0005409218,
-0.0104833525,
0.0358665958,
0.0383332558,
-0.0397520065,
0.0302135535,
0.0521680862,
-0.0032095574,
0.0379510112,
-0.0773397237,
0.0553673282,
-0.0269070137,
-0.0268899817,
0.0115350652,
-0.0222293269,
0.0563574471,
-0.0025655136,
0.0545332953,
0.0194064714,
-0.0238204338,
-0.0266471244,
0.019627139,
-0.0253374297,
-0.0062737758,
0.0244303588,
0.0178168714,
-0.0460223146,
-0.0203783736,
0.0620578527,
-0.015438254,
0.0052066399,
-0.0049793548,
0.0384565592,
-0.0500745587,
-0.0290156864,
0.0052067302,
-0.0723725408,
0.0250796955,
0.0190394633,
0.0175877437,
-0.01950562,
0.1014675498,
0.0075174766,
0.0068118297,
-0.1015035585,
0.0193177629,
-0.0058815754,
-0.0062596779,
0.0595161915,
0.0016602163,
-0.0092257429,
0.0884917676,
0.0447626151,
0.0071888198,
-0.0213897135,
-0.0170770809,
0.0335953012,
0.0443150178,
0.0555071868,
0.0306912847,
0.0358458757,
-0.0053984895,
-0.0155891115,
0.009488781,
-0.051212471,
0.0284132082,
0.0753930509,
-0.0135536082,
-0.070919238,
-0.0202246159,
-0.0089173922,
0.0159333926,
-0.0357358418,
-0.0315433554,
0.0528061613,
0.0028202499,
-0.0327743441,
-0.0351090394,
0.0375791602,
-0.0117202671,
0.0185024422,
0.0279159714,
-0.0391479805,
0.0038022306,
-0.0103776827,
0.0345219821,
0.0087475218,
0.0088980263,
0.0283694286,
0.0026720993,
0.0343238078,
-0.0062216804,
0.0226611048,
-0.025802264,
-0.0668749809,
0.0207931232,
-0.0402513854,
0.0378216431,
-0.0237463173,
-0.0245924685,
0.0296396073,
0.0009753297,
-0.0235110521,
0.0035108703,
0.0451376252,
0.0150792832,
-0.0331350416,
0.0273953937,
-0.0437595136,
-0.0071855639,
-0.0426289067,
0.0017030502,
-0.0117785912,
0.0056742271,
0.0396083109,
-0.0668975487,
0.0043381024,
0.0027079172,
2.841e-7,
0.0222788155,
0.0372275785,
0.0244530272,
-0.0071243029,
0.001061764,
0.0069168336,
0.0128981061,
-0.0047782087,
0.0350606665,
-0.062262889,
-0.0382135622,
0.0150621068,
0.0875907168,
0.0589179248,
-0.0889641643,
-0.0039413576,
-0.0436008088,
0.0003701718,
-0.0830504149,
-0.0320387706,
0.0534122586,
0.0231218934,
0.0060822219,
-0.0374292769,
-0.0098664537,
-0.0505699404,
0.0579054281,
-0.0077098152,
-0.0006502965,
0.0415343754,
0.0678487793,
0.0090780882,
0.0413071811,
0.0286854077,
-0.0004311597,
-0.0251529068,
0.0103984857,
0.0094294297,
0.0183933359,
-0.0497717187,
-0.0169539507,
-0.0224295016,
0.0116669014,
-0.0749454796,
0.0571714081,
0.0080557242,
0.0026741719,
-0.024669366,
-0.0580761358,
-0.0085821021,
0.0563520119,
0.0012473348,
-0.0173148494,
0.0279083997,
0.0109805642,
0.0208588839,
-0.0176375415,
-0.0431912653,
-0.0366000645,
0.0073810387,
-0.0393847078,
-0.0313055925,
-0.0241813716,
0.0201477427,
-0.0447044745,
-0.0835870579,
0.0219936483,
3.142122343e-34,
0.0196501184,
0.0111354655,
0.0360866375,
0.020107517,
0.0365700759,
0.0139849754,
0.031823501,
0.0250364766,
-0.0218671784,
-0.0646609887,
0.0036588234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14319v1 | 4 and 7-bit Labeling for Projective and Non-Projective Dependency Trees | 2023-10-22T14:43:53 | 2023-10-22T14:43:53 | Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Diego Roca, David Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL, 68T50, I.2.7 | We introduce an encoding for parsing as sequence labeling that can represent
any projective dependency tree as a sequence of 4-bit labels, one per word. The
bits in each word's label represent (1) whether it is a right or left
dependent, (2) whether it is the outermost (left/right) dependent of its
parent, (3) whether it has any left children and (4) whether it has any right
children. We show that this provides an injective mapping from trees to labels
that can be encoded and decoded in linear time. We then define a 7-bit
extension that represents an extra plane of arcs, extending the coverage to
almost full non-projectivity (over 99.9% empirical arc coverage). Results on a
set of diverse treebanks show that our 7-bit encoding obtains substantial
accuracy gains over the previously best-performing sequence labeling encodings. | [
0.0206718724,
0.0334846973,
-0.0061259754,
0.050963752,
-0.0596131124,
0.0095826043,
-0.0366448611,
0.0065808301,
-0.0748531744,
-0.0208858326,
0.0336803831,
0.0088471165,
-0.0010458865,
0.025330862,
0.0021072,
-0.1014219597,
0.0443944186,
-0.0026222903,
0.0285302792,
0.0143222082,
-0.0385079905,
0.0196682233,
-0.0227839686,
-0.0369779319,
-0.0899964646,
-0.0330800004,
-0.0495414957,
-0.0008929036,
0.0093699805,
-0.0865591839,
-0.0343304612,
0.0297702309,
-0.0258309022,
-0.0125635387,
0.0000018963,
-0.0110510373,
-0.0688181147,
0.0180851538,
-0.0395950563,
0.0131984651,
0.0048917984,
-0.0334881954,
0.0133585855,
-0.0117352018,
-0.0142634604,
-0.0249904636,
0.0676069707,
0.0481114611,
0.0491417795,
0.0607973635,
-0.0268520582,
-0.1032583714,
0.0403410718,
-0.0106235482,
0.0019618841,
-0.0278002061,
-0.0035699571,
0.016696414,
-0.0101746963,
0.0509826094,
-0.0464444086,
-0.046470128,
0.0187780075,
0.0006371466,
0.0046145944,
0.0227977391,
-0.0023387233,
-0.0010559494,
-0.0085514849,
0.0319523104,
-0.0051059579,
-0.012139176,
0.0115339654,
-0.0274614524,
-0.0289069265,
-0.0547157675,
-0.0007281736,
0.0568017475,
-0.0350972638,
0.0317161977,
0.0460431986,
0.0305409245,
-0.0026824225,
-0.063027516,
-0.0298323426,
0.0690338463,
0.0345909968,
-0.0561910644,
-0.0016843546,
-0.0068723615,
0.0167264622,
-0.0431186147,
0.0255425107,
-0.0580674522,
0.0586605854,
0.0492484272,
-0.0345940515,
0.0436880328,
-0.0121134771,
-0.010907257,
0.0194431152,
0.0447016172,
-0.0422548205,
0.0090700863,
-0.0152003858,
0.0307047032,
-0.0046930253,
0.0042280867,
-0.0244631674,
0.0141064012,
-0.0310502779,
-0.0076414882,
-0.0781356171,
0.0535467304,
-0.0568110943,
-0.0034266957,
-0.0078606755,
-0.0068200235,
0.0282910764,
0.0003400988,
0.0377982371,
-0.0167426877,
-0.0077709504,
0.0016045478,
-0.0040689656,
0.0611288175,
-0.041531574,
-0.0531245023,
-0.0635265037,
-0.0598217547,
-0.0188382771,
0.0685047954,
0.0395191424,
-0.0353241339,
-0.0244689547,
0.040744666,
0.0165358055,
-0.0501024723,
-0.0041485317,
-0.0550383069,
-0.0440572053,
0.0334854275,
0.029219687,
-0.032250911,
0.0097657051,
0.0109450733,
-0.0079724053,
-0.0080299806,
0.0298435949,
0.0185997784,
0.0095474711,
0.0534314625,
-0.0239010993,
-0.0280496217,
-0.0377026461,
-0.0093443561,
0.0066937455,
0.0208318774,
0.0269580185,
0.0206525084,
0.0305370539,
-0.0322301984,
-0.0070124236,
0.0273450054,
-0.0100013055,
-0.0602205209,
0.0026206023,
-0.0382851809,
0.0102738244,
-0.0462291576,
0.0055467305,
0.0624732897,
-0.014153989,
-0.0451050363,
-0.0035790475,
0.0237186421,
-0.0061689662,
0.0369707309,
0.0057473569,
0.0147335641,
-0.0255212802,
0.0057294895,
0.01202894,
0.0036506276,
0.0398603454,
-0.0001404987,
-0.0283641927,
-0.0302963201,
0.0193795338,
-0.0073955669,
-0.0235140733,
-0.0245329067,
0.0068889395,
-0.0656806007,
0.0493167304,
0.0081425402,
-0.043997813,
0.0656545162,
0.0032914032,
-0.0429901965,
-0.0349323973,
0.0279482119,
-0.0211053174,
0.0359946229,
0.0225376785,
0.0036875606,
-0.008737877,
0.0284987129,
0.0035591873,
0.0411342122,
-0.0143939555,
-0.0361665227,
0.0385901704,
-0.017446246,
-0.045705542,
0.0209643804,
-0.0188747514,
0.065848954,
-0.0067810188,
-0.0354779214,
0.0129502425,
0.0272327177,
0.026452411,
0.03168853,
0.0092828386,
0.0064258943,
0.0068316674,
0.0038148318,
0.0396575108,
0.0783982724,
-0.0267297905,
0.0267069042,
0.0582000576,
-0.0357552655,
0.0069080535,
-0.0043170359,
-0.0507593118,
-0.0213333275,
0.0330622792,
-0.0767732114,
-0.0287103858,
-0.0106795048,
-0.0193905346,
-0.045267731,
-0.0092332289,
-0.0720343888,
0.0530002601,
-0.0153458854,
0.0269594584,
0.0139900893,
0.0085706264,
-0.0122290784,
0.08693064,
-0.0060422872,
0.0239261594,
-0.0599807128,
-0.0120324371,
0.0602716431,
0.0003015533,
-0.0095568169,
0.0486226045,
-0.005696787,
-0.0800163075,
0.0005116187,
-0.010195883,
-0.0365459695,
0.0094240885,
-0.0564154424,
-0.0347539634,
-0.005469813,
0.0745176449,
0.0221556444,
0.0021254953,
0.0147283813,
-0.0517066903,
-0.0342765078,
-0.0025597161,
-0.0415361933,
0.0017618188,
0.03541179,
0.0017577856,
-0.0565179363,
0.031323418,
-0.0177051555,
-0.0272005051,
-0.0152685167,
-0.0052964487,
-0.1143258736,
-0.0365204811,
-0.0108963288,
-0.0010659616,
0.0136085302,
0.0124405641,
-0.0040352587,
0.0202299077,
-0.0231579989,
-0.0052619609,
-0.0239270013,
-0.0266002323,
-0.0439258367,
0.010121095,
-0.0124053294,
0.0237459689,
0.0220163222,
0.008548609,
0.0335688889,
0.0084898183,
-0.0626612678,
-0.0028037669,
0.0741519108,
0.0138481632,
0.0450527556,
-0.026485553,
-0.0990922526,
-0.0048028836,
-0.0145584336,
0.0389324948,
-0.0583458543,
-0.0249018148,
0.0070671472,
-0.0552102253,
-0.0031047899,
0.0327541158,
-0.0586668029,
-0.0533121005,
-0.0101392148,
0.0269182678,
-0.0234223437,
0.1456194371,
0.0725298822,
0.0195770152,
-0.0000484346,
-0.058839146,
0.0292551629,
0.0440006219,
0.0148377605,
-0.004637924,
-0.0107943369,
-0.0709236339,
0.039165549,
-0.0400413275,
-0.0230714325,
-0.0194949787,
-0.0280518997,
0.0089736013,
-0.0186710488,
0.0197198857,
-0.0203915145,
0.0975468755,
0.0596731044,
0.0170105528,
0.0466737375,
0.018753849,
0.0377895348,
-0.0287512857,
0.0190211013,
0.010161276,
0.0019449228,
-0.0197680779,
0.0142564559,
-0.0229358282,
0.0313985087,
0.0105341291,
0.0416998416,
-0.0178422797,
0.0375152268,
-0.014811988,
0.0186791774,
-0.0845737085,
0.0084302537,
-0.041430328,
-0.0207709689,
-0.0016102919,
0.0824753717,
0.0544200055,
-0.0291838851,
0.0048590424,
-0.0383824259,
-0.0289798509,
0.018655587,
-0.0090566464,
-0.1063282639,
-0.0187336057,
-0.0046787718,
0.0023524477,
-0.000468867,
-0.0287997965,
0.0066517717,
-0.1323084533,
-0.0189705286,
0.0171947703,
0.0150265498,
-0.0564093105,
-0.0069299201,
-0.042673789,
0.0129557233,
-0.0645844415,
0.0290630218,
0.033878006,
-0.0098416479,
0.0499263816,
-0.029459063,
-0.0065126321,
-0.0238037221,
0.0161532853,
-0.0179352034,
0.0589443073,
0.0139512625,
-0.0046253265,
-0.0086958995,
-0.0022383905,
-0.0056336801,
-0.0131214578,
-0.0216110498,
0.0301418696,
0.0187080819,
-0.0132386712,
0.0372133367,
-0.0360047594,
-0.044328548,
0.0172748379,
-0.0098126354,
0.0576074533,
0.0017120809,
0.039378766,
0.0512347221,
0.0033965223,
-0.0026260235,
0.0348848328,
-0.0056924205,
0.0222450309,
-0.0242250841,
-0.0646719038,
0.0564458594,
-0.0284166969,
0.0030640506,
0.058290787,
-0.0246925913,
-0.0588722751,
-0.0697659776,
-0.0038701624,
0.0208668485,
0.0564002171,
0.0044079036,
-0.0091195488,
0.0502856039,
-0.0132916532,
-0.0245499574,
-0.0594451576,
-0.0227383692,
-0.0089007355,
-0.0455750339,
-0.0412652828,
0.0453066044,
0.05229377,
-0.0058998652,
0.0044095865,
0.0105888033,
-0.0080642262,
0.0371587388,
0.0086922925,
0.0181552805,
-0.0045385933,
-0.0267857499,
-0.0112418728,
-0.0443875492,
0.0484571718,
-0.0218886025,
0.0118047716,
0.0067142355,
0.0094088912,
-0.0081149628,
-0.0005790475,
0.0047135702,
0.0126237459,
-0.0616903864,
0.0530481301,
-0.0313158743,
-0.0160097796,
0.0395336524,
0.0436373055,
0.0641377941,
0.0200035404,
-0.0081780581,
0.0251511354,
0.0658517852,
-0.1019444466,
-0.033642482,
-0.0150980093,
0.0006173591,
-0.0104182409,
-0.0034272238,
0.0114992894,
-0.0070963777,
0.0015401271,
0.0006067419,
0.0354782902,
0.024725344,
0.0411559418,
0.0078436425,
-0.0524091832,
-0.0047202902,
-0.0047304626,
-0.0270015001,
0.0535013005,
0.0230084192,
-0.0335299,
0.029032683,
0.0070438338,
0.0055399453,
-0.0051118652,
-0.0173569862,
0.0095767118,
0.0522250608,
-0.0029716201,
0.0080376593,
0.0404870287,
0.0155684697,
0.0609327331,
-0.0496627949,
0.008224898,
0.0196946338,
0.0011780421,
0.0112081431,
-0.0667229667,
0.0314020514,
0.0161290709,
-0.0159919001,
-0.0119523117,
0.035438966,
0.0173922218,
0.0164610054,
-0.0052796016,
-0.0273995027,
-0.0227714144,
-0.0361669213,
-0.0189097486,
-0.0117122056,
-0.0075532594,
0.0234150868,
-0.0618959032,
-0.0250649936,
-0.0189595651,
0.0126743242,
0.0531821139,
-0.0244845524,
0.0804617405,
0.0040265322,
0.0063443924,
-0.070051223,
-0.0046564196,
0.0373135321,
0.0089342259,
-0.0073170862,
-0.0415036157,
-5.665090414e-33,
-0.0627568513,
-0.0115578594,
-0.0307422094,
-0.0055006482,
-0.0070062433,
0.0019187666,
-0.0310152378,
0.0498512946,
0.0341153853,
-0.0142935459,
0.0011485667,
-0.0117801316,
0.0320336483,
0.0417679921,
0.0598498993,
0.0011142021,
0.0280346908,
-0.0308361351,
-0.0160139035,
0.0104827387,
0.0577981882,
0.002514357,
0.0623744205,
0.0012706358,
0.0081930319,
-0.0060869679,
0.0091654267,
-0.0007162294,
0.0169114545,
0.025669096,
0.0049540703,
-0.0269234236,
0.0304081924,
-0.0237364061,
-0.0031473758,
0.0072114388,
-0.0856032148,
-0.0265534203,
-0.0043893876,
0.0302320924,
-0.0330299623,
-0.0135012064,
0.0215773154,
0.0057978919,
0.0211316776,
0.0420233309,
-0.0303380545,
-0.0030615339,
-0.0320782624,
0.0438922122,
-0.00691811,
0.0349619277,
0.0240293648,
0.033912845,
0.0519594289,
0.0273594819,
0.0122457799,
0.0071653924,
0.0235713385,
0.0194887128,
-0.0213455558,
0.0519013368,
0.0279167425,
-0.0087396242,
-0.0113757141,
0.021324832,
0.0459926389,
-0.0585274287,
0.0235510934,
0.0558729172,
-0.0559485517,
0.0094333561,
0.0365195647,
-0.0033421053,
0.051423721,
0.030883193,
-0.0103808567,
-0.0068368642,
0.033742398,
0.0294014849,
-0.0194228832,
0.0204557814,
-0.0346993133,
-0.0259034261,
0.0205185693,
-0.0214877892,
0.0061835577,
-0.020684896,
0.0021237603,
-0.0243284293,
-0.0143541861,
0.102628164,
0.0203183331,
0.0028886034,
-0.0264948066,
0.0196779296,
0.0083358753,
0.0840016082,
-0.0401666462,
0.0391709991,
-0.0049840701,
-0.0529431701,
0.0114896214,
-0.0296537243,
0.0375124738,
-0.0272068605,
0.0262874048,
0.0114805317,
-0.0619642548,
0.0100758085,
-0.0188983455,
-0.0022983181,
-0.0256476197,
0.0602944456,
0.0473904125,
-0.0004204916,
0.0056859925,
-0.0121473642,
0.0296701826,
0.0105463685,
-0.0049865474,
-0.0274057351,
-0.0417475663,
-0.0030457934,
-0.0083761206,
0.0243572276,
-0.0182527304,
0.0128493346,
0.0046259402,
-0.0268874075,
-0.0161972269,
0.0540134981,
2.751e-7,
0.0525030121,
0.035763599,
0.1174233183,
0.0158020165,
0.0748960525,
-0.0250211731,
-0.0162227973,
0.0562056899,
-0.0959099084,
-0.0678825602,
0.0159182567,
-0.0798272565,
0.0179096665,
0.0261907671,
-0.0834195092,
0.0210150275,
0.0165299103,
-0.0187680665,
-0.05624808,
0.0461658835,
0.1487952769,
0.0758006051,
-0.0235431306,
0.0158977099,
-0.0206324607,
-0.0007200394,
0.0173305571,
0.0255406704,
0.0202626996,
-0.0502088107,
-0.0471437536,
-0.0122493124,
-0.026156567,
0.0516367219,
-0.003620435,
0.0361216106,
0.0038941028,
0.0375860855,
-0.003343543,
-0.0045347149,
0.0169836264,
0.0196309965,
-0.0257720184,
0.0379262678,
0.0681175441,
0.0065965406,
-0.0373092443,
0.0668720007,
-0.029627014,
0.050648734,
-0.0620036311,
0.0430385694,
-0.0391266011,
0.0101410868,
0.0260250643,
-0.0444024317,
-0.0157585405,
-0.0333568081,
0.0179140642,
-0.0158667713,
-0.0254910495,
0.0079578115,
-0.0280222576,
0.0472480692,
-0.0205864124,
-0.0015071202,
-0.036989335,
2.702208047e-34,
-0.0088881562,
-0.0506095998,
-0.0148476707,
-0.0239335354,
0.0203544516,
-0.0254168008,
-0.0338943787,
0.0366325974,
-0.018286515,
-0.0342679545,
-0.0314851888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14312v1 | Neural Text Sanitization with Privacy Risk Indicators: An Empirical Analysis | 2023-10-22T14:17:27 | 2023-10-22T14:17:27 | Anthi Papadopoulou, Pierre Lison, Mark Anderson, Lilja Øvrelid, Ildikó Pilán | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text sanitization is the task of redacting a document to mask all occurrences
of (direct or indirect) personal identifiers, with the goal of concealing the
identity of the individual(s) referred in it. In this paper, we consider a
two-step approach to text sanitization and provide a detailed analysis of its
empirical performance on two recently published datasets: the Text
Anonymization Benchmark (Pil\'an et al., 2022) and a collection of Wikipedia
biographies (Papadopoulou et al., 2022). The text sanitization process starts
with a privacy-oriented entity recognizer that seeks to determine the text
spans expressing identifiable personal information. This privacy-oriented
entity recognizer is trained by combining a standard named entity recognition
model with a gazetteer populated by person-related terms extracted from
Wikidata. The second step of the text sanitization process consists in
assessing the privacy risk associated with each detected text span, either
isolated or in combination with other text spans. We present five distinct
indicators of the re-identification risk, respectively based on language model
probabilities, text span classification, sequence labelling, perturbations, and
web search. We provide a contrastive analysis of each privacy indicator and
highlight their benefits and limitations, notably in relation to the available
labeled data. | [
0.0618064329,
0.0750477239,
-0.0127380975,
0.0238702837,
-0.0154332286,
0.0148292575,
0.0507240519,
0.0325141475,
0.0577410758,
-0.0297862012,
0.0056124036,
-0.0327486582,
0.0126642259,
0.0151854008,
0.0109215304,
-0.0085558938,
0.0311696082,
0.0347264819,
0.0312426668,
-0.0110569624,
-0.0107398154,
-0.0056439769,
0.0210611019,
0.0238797553,
0.0179593805,
-0.0082924245,
0.04444056,
0.0082118334,
0.0410761684,
-0.0226907581,
0.0477078781,
0.050835155,
-0.0040967595,
0.0906301662,
0.0000016623,
-0.0491423868,
-0.0175169967,
0.0496528968,
-0.0125829224,
-0.0021786517,
0.0238650236,
-0.0067963088,
-0.0209081359,
-0.0035085639,
-0.005301422,
0.0130423736,
0.0198584814,
0.0775801465,
0.0564076193,
0.0778497234,
-0.0178797394,
-0.030692203,
0.0242185593,
-0.0258097891,
-0.0048861937,
-0.0106049459,
0.0565334782,
-0.0828008577,
-0.0545263439,
-0.0005048076,
0.0291938502,
0.0777607933,
-0.0072641959,
-0.0124693969,
0.0362086631,
0.0121184634,
0.0032060873,
-0.0033643355,
0.0338055454,
0.0380183347,
0.0305816364,
-0.0281888861,
0.0564226471,
0.0277797095,
0.0168245081,
0.0071440767,
0.0220386442,
0.0338846073,
-0.0350580141,
0.0033139449,
-0.0326285847,
-0.0109198904,
0.0531983487,
0.0185055118,
0.0161591154,
0.0461240262,
0.0093426881,
-0.0503859073,
-0.0134119522,
-0.0405431874,
0.0248102434,
-0.0692811385,
0.0855747908,
0.0068670949,
0.0521155111,
0.0100023579,
-0.0638003871,
-0.0757113323,
0.0016215974,
-0.0611561872,
-0.0243939143,
-0.0267743617,
0.0476592854,
0.0197432302,
-0.0065013114,
0.0374074243,
0.0115175275,
0.0126213999,
0.0231076367,
0.0171761345,
0.0021859079,
-0.0206885282,
0.0016444288,
0.0663181245,
-0.0257285349,
-0.0054204678,
-0.0260829497,
-0.0209585726,
-0.0242916252,
0.022330381,
-0.0220082644,
-0.0155992629,
-0.0219831783,
0.007244071,
-0.0124897761,
-0.0377523527,
0.0231633503,
0.0069049597,
0.0062972531,
0.0208357405,
0.0150567293,
-0.0133495517,
0.0256210361,
-0.0275466274,
-0.0178287737,
0.0500436574,
0.0096381968,
-0.0458917394,
-0.0447926782,
-0.0412635691,
-0.0014826739,
0.0104248701,
0.0025147153,
0.0048399731,
0.0041195378,
-0.0511600785,
-0.029683046,
-0.1076585948,
0.0207460523,
0.0245731492,
-0.0553136244,
0.0544055887,
-0.0256911367,
-0.0294101909,
0.0639551431,
0.0434086137,
0.0433388129,
-0.0093682632,
0.0587255247,
0.0383977331,
0.0704618916,
0.0130867762,
0.0142152822,
0.0253724512,
0.0297116432,
-0.0165814813,
0.0120081101,
-0.0053985394,
0.0070147626,
-0.0096433293,
0.008004263,
0.0537325516,
-0.0051233708,
-0.0738155618,
0.0685181841,
0.0725744367,
-0.0184729267,
-0.0013640906,
-0.0126476986,
0.0298038162,
0.0076313717,
-0.006807216,
-0.0627024621,
-0.0363510624,
-0.0500563979,
-0.0457930043,
-0.0275921412,
0.010278305,
0.0079570739,
-0.004197042,
0.0115619563,
-0.0354481116,
0.0707731098,
-0.0150491809,
0.0082656965,
0.0144922314,
-0.0498739034,
0.0319753103,
-0.0031676125,
-0.0787565112,
0.034898255,
-0.0376292728,
0.0302190408,
0.0794490203,
0.0379090011,
-0.0099429833,
0.0126460455,
-0.0675766692,
-0.0343356319,
0.0031877598,
-0.0140701374,
-0.0204276722,
0.0563637391,
-0.0396346673,
-0.072474353,
0.0142591437,
0.0020929964,
0.038449496,
0.0370346084,
-0.0051996778,
0.0508725494,
-0.009945428,
-0.0342678614,
0.0451940522,
-0.0367566012,
-0.0491692312,
0.0097692115,
0.026813006,
0.0103861364,
0.0306410529,
-0.0006200206,
-0.0220395103,
0.0181915015,
0.014103232,
-0.0001251156,
-0.0427000932,
0.0166836623,
-0.0084556434,
-0.0078745112,
-0.0102628265,
0.0079148971,
0.0862758309,
0.000238803,
-0.0193027351,
-0.0265414789,
-0.0024785027,
-0.0202602763,
-0.0336783752,
-0.0012065871,
-0.0336507745,
0.0334190018,
-0.0398044325,
0.0520019792,
-0.0288113859,
0.0216981824,
-0.0345578045,
-0.0339044221,
0.0064995312,
-0.0333717912,
-0.0616101772,
-0.0582752675,
-0.032791879,
0.0209344327,
0.0240521133,
-0.0140527412,
-0.0097848363,
-0.0298711061,
-0.0285487212,
0.0066748583,
0.0091459872,
0.0254637599,
-0.0206995495,
-0.0157515481,
0.0031945771,
-0.0094365301,
-0.0140121859,
-0.0420963615,
-0.0189849883,
0.0304448362,
0.0361075997,
0.0188424159,
-0.0310312361,
0.0145834303,
-0.010861923,
-0.0089831939,
0.0209794026,
0.0215564817,
-0.0759517103,
-0.0116292294,
0.0316752642,
-0.0197771527,
0.0153947324,
-0.0215906054,
-0.0054741157,
-0.0404604226,
0.0307436287,
-0.0530413203,
0.0535867214,
0.0095660361,
0.0240633748,
-0.0142144747,
0.0253855959,
-0.0136140827,
-0.0102689788,
-0.0078605171,
0.0745359436,
-0.032873977,
-0.0536553152,
0.0795347616,
-0.0049782097,
-0.0081550563,
-0.0296231918,
-0.0260226391,
0.0254319683,
-0.024044862,
-0.0457454361,
-0.0108806826,
-0.0366708823,
-0.007902775,
0.0090102078,
-0.0284747686,
-0.0121586761,
0.0523819178,
-0.0041573732,
0.0446051061,
0.0249747131,
-0.0265802257,
0.0219576713,
0.0177473947,
0.023126021,
0.0489820428,
0.0521972887,
-0.0907078907,
-0.0030951903,
0.0297590848,
0.0179018434,
-0.0246143937,
0.0205506366,
0.0108703719,
0.0025226851,
0.0153558655,
-0.0327737108,
-0.0322609879,
-0.086226359,
0.0456527881,
0.0015727821,
0.001753211,
-0.0377989151,
-0.0194207728,
-0.0053283107,
0.0316899382,
0.0289588049,
-0.0149465669,
0.0206648652,
-0.0316744484,
0.0372659191,
-0.0406232513,
-0.0659759939,
0.0218267161,
0.0039551295,
-0.0207579155,
0.0419733226,
0.0441183075,
0.0135448696,
0.0549858361,
-0.042474702,
-0.0001379292,
-0.0551160164,
-0.0613711402,
-0.009679148,
0.0382120088,
-0.0499940403,
-0.0006117219,
0.0956803709,
-0.0071285618,
-0.029767463,
-0.030395437,
0.0600944795,
-0.0128192157,
-0.0074120597,
-0.025555592,
-0.0426351167,
0.0303849261,
0.0120567987,
0.0595340095,
-0.0393314958,
-0.0803716257,
-0.0092560686,
-0.0247612074,
-0.0257861372,
-0.0195105541,
-0.0205195807,
-0.0111178728,
-0.0465484932,
0.0085335607,
0.0084670205,
-0.0104492651,
-0.0226869751,
0.006471083,
-0.0322800018,
-0.0039128554,
-0.0032250148,
-0.0808290467,
-0.0283987261,
-0.0562525317,
0.0330500193,
0.0561985224,
0.0514794402,
-0.0397267677,
-0.0415890329,
-0.0122953756,
-0.0017100156,
-0.0454217382,
-0.0015062314,
0.1097541973,
-0.0167380404,
0.0056876712,
-0.0311322957,
0.0383603945,
0.0431324244,
-0.021881422,
0.001276753,
-0.0037714976,
0.0106538655,
-0.0245468318,
0.0304701179,
-0.0254707243,
0.0292609856,
0.0756115988,
-0.0076262425,
-0.0320640206,
-0.0047084503,
-0.0290976111,
0.0390284732,
-0.0356475525,
0.0264802724,
-0.0150951026,
-0.0408431701,
-0.0776615366,
-0.0576291382,
-0.0094810026,
-0.0369699225,
-0.0108289532,
0.0648793206,
0.0124488436,
0.0555405356,
-0.0103420718,
-0.0415230058,
-0.0208256505,
-0.0460675023,
0.0235528219,
-0.0281889066,
0.0411711074,
-0.0043206261,
0.0277652852,
-0.0243943613,
0.0317153856,
-0.0529433191,
-0.0821322501,
0.0415802598,
0.0124172978,
0.0130322715,
0.0295699332,
-0.0270665046,
-0.101721935,
0.0689132884,
0.0523599461,
-0.0189279187,
0.0046813264,
0.0132172173,
-0.0101483753,
-0.02320759,
0.0053170421,
-0.0239344444,
-0.0106410794,
0.034827169,
-0.0520762801,
-0.0556974038,
-0.0222455859,
-0.0564635023,
0.0145211117,
0.0226376355,
0.004328534,
0.0431574956,
-0.0685723349,
0.0002767051,
-0.0228163935,
0.0083578294,
0.008869512,
0.0029577129,
0.0611734539,
0.0283079166,
-0.0016719321,
0.0431713611,
0.0021957438,
0.0131631652,
-0.0701364651,
-0.0303568486,
0.0103247743,
0.056483116,
0.0285928883,
0.0091587659,
-0.0019271687,
0.041765321,
0.051668711,
0.0286577046,
-0.0181575306,
-0.0116995089,
0.0218801498,
0.0025849959,
-0.0006871758,
0.0132964272,
-0.0745990425,
0.0372419395,
-0.046686206,
0.0232022107,
-0.0215415359,
0.0372715555,
0.0203401148,
-0.0047222245,
-0.015128891,
-0.0066142017,
-0.0060973116,
-0.0013229391,
-0.0159751177,
0.0095774038,
-0.0103665059,
-0.0282225981,
0.0474807099,
0.0511121154,
0.0097760968,
0.03962899,
0.0100456225,
-0.0598334968,
-0.0423457809,
-0.0286732446,
0.0170819126,
0.0514937304,
-0.0375760272,
-0.0392828956,
-0.0222037453,
-0.0458028242,
0.0426659733,
-0.0006405777,
0.017119918,
0.0048914002,
-0.0251647811,
-0.0012807607,
0.0108720129,
-0.0248163398,
-0.0509947799,
-0.005819119,
0.0094934972,
-0.0351124741,
-0.0135334479,
-4.939919868e-33,
0.0019074443,
-0.0165261943,
-0.0209581889,
0.0369124636,
-0.0132317739,
0.0007200516,
-0.0033884982,
-0.0405904427,
-0.0147311902,
-0.0076996326,
-0.0273003466,
0.0253326725,
-0.0099163651,
0.0352211706,
-0.0445116274,
-0.005250542,
0.0607866347,
0.0122789331,
-0.0187476445,
0.030034529,
0.0515089147,
0.0497715771,
0.0163141992,
-0.1054878607,
0.0762693211,
-0.0157243069,
-0.0545140691,
0.0184249878,
0.0040752678,
0.0229293648,
-0.0051322002,
-0.0048549678,
0.0126602603,
0.0116755329,
0.0401814207,
0.0773557201,
-0.0972813889,
-0.0103782648,
-0.0461539924,
0.020222852,
0.0225984585,
-0.1002776474,
0.0670028031,
-0.0447023474,
-0.0126273362,
0.0145956594,
0.0424520969,
0.0213863421,
-0.004669067,
-0.0491102375,
0.0092593534,
0.0250215437,
0.0089258775,
0.0292102918,
0.0302679148,
0.0431777313,
0.0213062894,
-0.0173507072,
-0.1056513712,
-0.0286932122,
0.0435294621,
-0.0342361443,
0.0103053804,
0.0005449982,
0.0125510916,
0.0289027113,
0.0470420867,
0.034121383,
-0.0058782212,
-0.0218588691,
0.0046760598,
-0.0202203169,
0.0338478573,
0.0602939129,
0.0172645748,
-0.0681886151,
-0.0655797049,
0.0395356044,
-0.038385991,
-0.0213481542,
0.0191977192,
-0.0154383034,
-0.0383139178,
-0.0236991998,
-0.067108497,
-0.0842803195,
-0.0183158312,
0.0055165654,
0.0032258697,
-0.0063358862,
-0.073494412,
0.0408839397,
-0.0151409842,
-0.0491265543,
-0.0496434718,
0.045750495,
0.0366103388,
0.0117303357,
0.0097548319,
0.0217271466,
-0.0241124425,
-0.0002330409,
0.0390193686,
-0.011640206,
0.0237613562,
-0.024080161,
0.0757430494,
-0.0110448739,
-0.0617761798,
-0.0091061201,
0.0100624245,
0.057481762,
0.0469481722,
0.0314303637,
-0.0072196843,
-0.0094346711,
0.024521092,
-0.0172753539,
0.0673818663,
0.0220938176,
-0.0064863483,
0.0046467255,
0.0260296687,
-0.012503407,
0.0408110656,
-0.0276222136,
0.0248089768,
0.0744486153,
0.0783436149,
-0.024745198,
0.0209179278,
-0.0053958115,
2.429e-7,
0.0258282013,
-0.0050240294,
0.0054151923,
-0.0364894494,
0.0058239195,
0.0517798401,
0.0561605059,
0.0473479033,
-0.0086178128,
0.0276295524,
-0.031782534,
-0.0328931995,
0.0332111828,
0.0284059402,
-0.0813488513,
-0.050709296,
0.0040436066,
0.006124916,
-0.0358532481,
0.0162193906,
0.0130334496,
0.0294288397,
0.065937385,
-0.0341356359,
-0.0317935273,
-0.0612107664,
0.0292585045,
-0.0487017035,
-0.0053165131,
0.0352108069,
0.0257195923,
0.0464485362,
0.0116609512,
0.0140761696,
-0.041180294,
0.0208692066,
-0.010590299,
0.0939081833,
0.0012231775,
0.0314910151,
0.0127752917,
-0.0577378459,
-0.0024261931,
-0.034090627,
0.0576978885,
0.0480578803,
-0.021235669,
0.0020450968,
-0.0032167672,
-0.0604044721,
0.0390797555,
-0.0294350274,
-0.0255514625,
0.0109132119,
-0.0033391912,
0.0035299156,
0.0087453742,
-0.0657122582,
0.0023702346,
-0.0470956117,
0.0018223154,
0.0046070283,
0.000453498,
-0.0064575258,
0.009122082,
-0.0806605294,
0.0794663653,
2.304767208e-34,
-0.0229517929,
-0.0386540107,
-0.0512547381,
0.0033125281,
0.0368360542,
0.0062014908,
-0.0107154911,
-0.0003524304,
-0.0212925561,
-0.0636608973,
0.0079676528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14303v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14303v2 | Language Model Unalignment: Parametric Red-Teaming to Expose Hidden Harms and Biases | 2023-10-22T13:55:46 | 2023-11-13T05:28:47 | Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Red-teaming has been a widely adopted way to evaluate the harmfulness of
Large Language Models (LLMs). It aims to jailbreak a model's safety behavior to
make it act as a helpful agent disregarding the harmfulness of the query.
Existing methods are primarily based on input text-based red-teaming such as
adversarial prompts, low-resource prompts, or contextualized prompts to
condition the model in a way to bypass its safe behavior. Bypassing the
guardrails uncovers hidden harmful information and biases in the model that are
left untreated or newly introduced by its safety training. However,
prompt-based attacks fail to provide such a diagnosis owing to their low attack
success rate, and applicability to specific models. In this paper, we present a
new perspective on LLM safety research i.e., parametric red-teaming through
Unalignment. It simply (instruction) tunes the model parameters to break model
guardrails that are not deeply rooted in the model's behavior. Unalignment
using as few as 100 examples can significantly bypass commonly referred to as
CHATGPT, to the point where it responds with an 88% success rate to harmful
queries on two safety benchmark datasets. On open-source models such as
VICUNA-7B and LLAMA-2-CHAT 7B AND 13B, it shows an attack success rate of more
than 91%. On bias evaluations, Unalignment exposes inherent biases in
safety-aligned models such as CHATGPT and LLAMA- 2-CHAT where the model's
responses are strongly biased and opinionated 64% of the time. | [
0.0143258339,
0.0666956678,
-0.0128132543,
0.0393420532,
-0.0403351709,
0.0113713266,
0.0258519873,
-0.010933104,
0.0400019623,
-0.073207669,
-0.0521476977,
-0.0172985196,
-0.0066971919,
0.0037719926,
0.0380195081,
-0.0125736054,
0.0745826364,
-0.0445990525,
0.0069143502,
-0.0128415646,
0.0191550981,
-0.0083810948,
0.003935012,
0.0413643606,
0.0139658349,
-0.0298352186,
-0.0145734344,
0.0169683564,
0.006183533,
-0.0142993433,
0.020616902,
0.0426369011,
-0.0173072796,
0.0713364631,
0.0000021308,
-0.0445160195,
-0.0501058288,
0.0211605206,
-0.0202912614,
0.0203504302,
0.0410760082,
-0.0159810577,
-0.0234815497,
0.0568882897,
-0.0312916599,
0.001609878,
0.0505906902,
0.0484081283,
0.0701165944,
0.0961951837,
0.0105249733,
0.0172473639,
0.0383107252,
-0.0303373318,
-0.0286068227,
-0.0505314767,
0.0382106192,
-0.0314504579,
-0.0354997702,
0.0287238564,
-0.0179475602,
0.0106386356,
0.0108668972,
-0.0100351237,
-0.0805887282,
0.004515341,
-0.0592468716,
-0.0336270668,
0.0069695767,
0.0516826846,
-0.0458397903,
-0.0149883963,
0.0050124759,
-0.0040395865,
0.0059073046,
0.0039947685,
-0.0118821003,
0.0234319791,
0.0074720038,
0.0024219726,
0.0236712191,
-0.0093080457,
0.0593723878,
0.0067879306,
-0.0004366669,
0.0577362776,
0.0145580145,
-0.0298120901,
0.0209268555,
-0.0139898919,
0.009321725,
-0.04347267,
-0.0325649418,
0.0016675125,
-0.0328124203,
0.0390016474,
-0.0481710471,
-0.0315315798,
0.0645004585,
-0.0819259882,
0.010171053,
0.024474293,
-0.011732853,
0.0264988728,
0.0013262749,
-0.0065389052,
-0.0062404312,
0.0716544911,
-0.0201009363,
0.0256271828,
0.0070395479,
-0.006669932,
-0.0069177197,
-0.0137335509,
0.0057615354,
0.0348693505,
-0.0225331541,
0.034359429,
-0.0350041576,
0.0203203261,
-0.0168078206,
-0.0119293118,
-0.0129935099,
-0.0115561476,
0.0049722693,
-0.0191777982,
0.0087681198,
0.0021296444,
-0.0166364647,
-0.1160502285,
-0.029022621,
0.0197286345,
-0.0655660182,
-0.045502875,
-0.0288815219,
0.1237253472,
0.0211445689,
-0.0315465294,
-0.0513755456,
-0.0675248131,
-0.0199268237,
-0.0450958498,
0.0205634423,
-0.0442768857,
-0.0113178724,
-0.0142921358,
-0.0230532531,
-0.05473556,
0.0096490812,
-0.0018904359,
-0.0486259013,
0.0768130273,
0.0033376364,
-0.0148689803,
-0.0114538819,
0.0495934635,
-0.0121359117,
0.1318906546,
0.0110399546,
0.0178040788,
0.0452031009,
0.0025797188,
0.0265611839,
0.055028718,
0.036409229,
0.0496489741,
-0.0528625511,
0.0156648215,
0.0461196899,
-0.0175049361,
-0.0094631016,
0.0706040114,
-0.0093187634,
-0.0485277958,
0.0807742327,
-0.022401398,
-0.0189829767,
0.0026322876,
0.007757857,
-0.0098666204,
-0.0234909598,
0.0365768224,
-0.0796214491,
-0.0126328701,
-0.0841151848,
-0.0285101216,
0.0162945818,
0.0275312029,
-0.034338098,
-0.0365838744,
-0.0070235701,
-0.0090613086,
0.0280183163,
0.0156740174,
0.0143614002,
0.0090082949,
-0.036330048,
0.0223520193,
0.0540858805,
-0.0328883044,
-0.0235325843,
-0.0811112598,
-0.0212621875,
0.0383001529,
0.0658545345,
-0.0401471443,
-0.0316337645,
-0.0215206873,
-0.0091096526,
0.0201244615,
0.04398074,
0.0086967619,
0.0006669922,
-0.0392455533,
-0.0438736081,
0.0255936347,
0.0235434268,
-0.0040676142,
0.0082518086,
0.012668198,
-0.0112775201,
-0.0051730648,
-0.0551578775,
0.0402039811,
-0.0192720033,
-0.0566356741,
-0.0158630125,
0.0192801915,
0.0291520823,
-0.0095843459,
-0.0251052435,
0.0179357026,
0.0517957062,
0.0192411635,
-0.0098817376,
0.0124868406,
-0.0212129559,
-0.0178428758,
0.0209179688,
-0.0138830086,
-0.0108073056,
0.0616109744,
-0.0406710841,
-0.0062153423,
0.0234009903,
-0.0266030729,
0.0303748231,
-0.0111390976,
0.019274991,
-0.0115922149,
0.0225046482,
-0.0402771011,
0.0372487679,
-0.0193658415,
-0.0053371289,
-0.0379291028,
-0.0343803205,
0.0045818249,
-0.0446441062,
-0.0636775345,
0.0265435241,
-0.0132325748,
0.0555815585,
0.0136528881,
0.0083321277,
-0.0314093269,
-0.0124103939,
-0.0555754602,
-0.01166829,
-0.0395614542,
0.0378547534,
0.0272990819,
-0.0089118881,
-0.028548304,
-0.010262033,
-0.0173419733,
-0.0072786859,
-0.0074036578,
0.0561136641,
0.0128416941,
-0.0085821208,
-0.0388446487,
-0.0364155844,
-0.0210004542,
-0.0253266823,
0.0599019341,
0.0080546625,
-0.014326131,
-0.0202037711,
0.0451508202,
-0.0138515532,
0.0437465236,
-0.0221755374,
-0.0774002373,
0.0184151325,
0.0081717465,
-0.0313549265,
0.0671429932,
0.0173798688,
0.020185573,
0.0821565613,
0.0330498628,
-0.0439619683,
-0.003482227,
-0.0014766561,
-0.0489222519,
-0.0096260943,
-0.02069325,
-0.0010002947,
0.049965106,
0.0072527351,
-0.0359249748,
-0.0325665176,
0.0044881501,
-0.0182967689,
-0.0492660329,
-0.019895833,
-0.0321790799,
-0.0200724658,
0.0114039537,
-0.0021259659,
-0.0692602247,
0.0655913576,
-0.0206715185,
0.0243596137,
-0.0422009081,
-0.0197131485,
-0.0044608824,
0.0393441692,
-0.0039518732,
0.0271138959,
0.0563386232,
-0.0150761753,
-0.0640535727,
-0.0396461114,
0.0258657206,
-0.0272467341,
0.0354144722,
-0.0299081113,
0.012348704,
-0.0174553618,
-0.0353380255,
-0.0651983023,
-0.0721841976,
-0.0168239884,
0.0009779723,
0.0086862734,
-0.0021017569,
-0.0117821423,
-0.0012377347,
0.0088823782,
-0.0082990415,
-0.0281411447,
0.0027853868,
-0.0093749911,
-0.0099640517,
0.0497274995,
-0.0486138687,
0.0285618696,
-0.0439549685,
0.0413638316,
0.0930758268,
0.0219788291,
0.0047119767,
-0.0169525333,
-0.0281082466,
0.0325592048,
-0.0126123242,
-0.026082905,
0.0103629306,
0.011553199,
-0.0435250811,
-0.0041233771,
0.0534593463,
0.0157250799,
-0.0289837401,
0.0160606392,
-0.0023256368,
0.0570571385,
0.0080263847,
0.0130724125,
-0.0796053708,
-0.0076777255,
0.0244733039,
0.0553809479,
-0.0208028927,
-0.0387715809,
-0.0057740784,
-0.1242870986,
0.0110072456,
0.0055949437,
-0.0371152721,
0.011750849,
-0.0171623845,
-0.001205271,
-0.0332630426,
0.0769658089,
0.0147354882,
-0.0096663767,
-0.0094558867,
0.0294694044,
-0.0299383812,
-0.0586164929,
0.0064332485,
-0.0525508225,
0.0770475566,
0.0760117695,
-0.0013310991,
-0.037120752,
-0.0008703855,
0.0740170553,
0.0051770932,
0.0035602897,
0.0030507762,
0.0596350506,
-0.0125842262,
-0.0187327657,
0.0106908549,
0.0014453778,
0.0090898322,
0.0215647314,
0.0251185298,
0.0377525352,
-0.0279701725,
-0.0118629308,
-0.0338746496,
0.013156387,
0.0428428203,
0.0784328878,
0.0140781486,
-0.0408666879,
-0.0322437249,
-0.0561566129,
0.0039309775,
-0.0136031481,
-0.0406673253,
0.0229348354,
-0.0123591749,
-0.0519365817,
-0.0528763607,
-0.031956967,
-0.0047637243,
0.03589027,
0.0306906104,
0.0157038737,
-0.0349681973,
0.0206339061,
0.0087593645,
0.0025140902,
-0.0320286043,
0.0297036339,
-0.0377904698,
0.0342348367,
-0.0026061428,
-0.0212504268,
-0.009502152,
-0.0040719239,
-0.0450399108,
-0.1126323566,
0.0417049229,
0.0728867501,
0.0270596724,
0.0113862762,
-0.0466432348,
-0.0788547471,
0.0487889722,
0.0766820014,
-0.0335186496,
0.0236357208,
0.0817259774,
-0.029334994,
0.0112260319,
0.036877092,
-0.0511915237,
-0.0093933986,
0.0363285244,
0.0001758267,
-0.0628129691,
-0.0217416119,
0.0014537693,
0.0348475277,
0.0676499531,
-0.0075289407,
0.0126318047,
-0.0016304314,
0.0248568095,
-0.0217710454,
-0.0270898417,
0.004690046,
0.0313095041,
0.0058532511,
-0.0102308849,
0.0096691251,
0.0025118862,
-0.0288613401,
0.0286895614,
-0.0142256217,
0.0471021198,
0.044559814,
0.0423650667,
0.037421383,
0.0188690219,
-0.0129414201,
0.0434711576,
0.0129527831,
0.0202878788,
-0.0018110349,
0.0219232403,
0.0245686807,
0.0138843572,
0.0098270113,
0.0507778376,
-0.0531145222,
-0.0527087077,
0.019556623,
0.0412696563,
0.0197722819,
0.0162071642,
0.030443402,
0.0066554109,
0.0025404468,
-0.033205051,
-0.0082689822,
0.0127653526,
-0.0429161116,
0.0458768718,
0.0099156275,
-0.0150256008,
0.0301447548,
0.0836545601,
0.0067936811,
0.0781540424,
0.0155892652,
-0.0166302994,
-0.018361209,
-0.0221597273,
0.0659903213,
-0.0092420364,
-0.0383669361,
-0.0374895148,
-0.0786257982,
-0.0856038257,
-0.0383493043,
0.0279699154,
0.0158440974,
0.000652445,
0.0057240943,
0.0468486547,
0.0160688814,
0.0249078814,
-0.0641360134,
-0.0049974211,
-0.0119918725,
-0.0247530155,
0.0203449298,
-6.635669284e-33,
0.0042882184,
-0.0277266931,
-0.0156195555,
-0.0168946367,
-0.0038592534,
0.0039019205,
-0.0061863954,
0.0124606127,
-0.062613897,
-0.0039405706,
-0.0128147155,
0.0167735908,
0.0026028235,
-0.0076788869,
-0.0122232344,
-0.0528547093,
0.0083129089,
-0.020686822,
-0.0214942321,
0.0087700728,
0.0568606406,
0.0078373887,
0.0328831747,
-0.1002210677,
0.0527080595,
-0.0169072989,
-0.0518997982,
0.0354333222,
-0.052973073,
0.0613568798,
0.0143703455,
0.0341789611,
-0.0017188521,
-0.0180034768,
0.0061686723,
0.0300002117,
-0.0025947283,
-0.0290645864,
0.0151562784,
0.0014426634,
-0.0293887611,
-0.0296516903,
0.0534915254,
-0.0082032653,
-0.0271076709,
-0.0154164415,
0.0061813965,
-0.0047236998,
-0.0170627329,
0.0223814081,
-0.0191422459,
0.0262032319,
-0.0100201881,
-0.0330291241,
0.001871438,
0.0354703702,
0.0470050871,
-0.0038633114,
-0.0335556418,
0.0090006841,
0.0344784819,
0.0122697968,
0.0742292181,
0.0234342217,
-0.0075510265,
0.0708717629,
-0.0120412605,
0.0212919917,
-0.0073605753,
-0.0292140152,
0.0256869141,
0.0392022431,
0.0380997285,
0.0488998257,
0.0036144943,
-0.0323388241,
-0.0999584496,
0.0227615498,
0.0351743624,
0.0288669001,
0.0330406837,
0.0068592778,
-0.0846443996,
-0.0335647948,
-0.0181345418,
-0.0428045318,
-0.0292912982,
-0.0427577496,
0.0166859925,
0.0122982049,
-0.0228915121,
-0.0327279381,
0.0028792962,
-0.0381941833,
0.0001426719,
0.0559096523,
-0.0102064814,
-0.0366592929,
-0.0125218304,
0.0226325672,
-0.0295517351,
0.0038383552,
0.0028292274,
-0.0235449336,
0.0278997216,
0.001232204,
0.0555218682,
0.0616252013,
-0.0566889457,
-0.0112958243,
-0.0296260379,
0.0493929461,
0.0293641277,
0.0059709363,
0.0490555242,
-0.0217767321,
0.0041269744,
0.0385521501,
0.0559462681,
0.0127145592,
-0.0597054362,
0.026350338,
-0.0400495604,
0.0034180398,
-0.0143984491,
-0.0108325006,
0.0383200757,
0.0252967197,
0.0573890731,
-0.0753992498,
-0.0126748085,
-0.0162454713,
2.928e-7,
0.0309433695,
0.0251442473,
0.0133364769,
0.0339715928,
0.0195158664,
0.0871405751,
-0.0356738865,
0.0768691525,
0.0057052858,
0.0003266909,
-0.0133132795,
0.0141397873,
0.0423133038,
0.0586104654,
-0.0442312919,
-0.0063456409,
-0.0822155997,
0.0151526406,
-0.0284406468,
-0.0352328792,
0.0496767014,
0.1034362018,
0.0049841846,
-0.0170547962,
-0.0036293012,
-0.0547683947,
0.0257867984,
-0.0259461831,
-0.0258281529,
0.0105489241,
0.0656105056,
0.0215720814,
0.0189792681,
0.025075594,
-0.0091988603,
-0.0184221268,
-0.0319567919,
0.062382739,
-0.0023646022,
-0.0364869013,
0.0008277706,
-0.0449330285,
-0.0095504634,
-0.0592878833,
0.1000098735,
0.0145594664,
-0.0194636788,
-0.0419494398,
0.0047411579,
-0.0341648199,
0.0584532693,
-0.0266160201,
-0.0248342287,
0.0192346703,
0.0059929178,
-0.0018781965,
-0.000476102,
-0.0481538475,
-0.0392400585,
-0.0331549793,
-0.0037302698,
-0.0823303908,
0.0343110561,
0.0514949411,
-0.0188899226,
-0.050779406,
0.0088546248,
3.011172273e-34,
0.0165123641,
-0.0408836864,
0.0034093149,
-0.0121868104,
0.0299586505,
0.0096137822,
-0.0078503955,
0.0088346461,
0.0183879193,
-0.031385906,
-0.035831172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14282v1 | NERetrieve: Dataset for Next Generation Named Entity Recognition and Retrieval | 2023-10-22T12:23:00 | 2023-10-22T12:23:00 | Uri Katz, Matan Vetzler, Amir DN Cohen, Yoav Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Recognizing entities in texts is a central need in many information-seeking
scenarios, and indeed, Named Entity Recognition (NER) is arguably one of the
most successful examples of a widely adopted NLP task and corresponding NLP
technology. Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) appear to provide
effective solutions (also) for NER tasks that were traditionally handled with
dedicated models, often matching or surpassing the abilities of the dedicated
models. Should NER be considered a solved problem? We argue to the contrary:
the capabilities provided by LLMs are not the end of NER research, but rather
an exciting beginning. They allow taking NER to the next level, tackling
increasingly more useful, and increasingly more challenging, variants. We
present three variants of the NER task, together with a dataset to support
them. The first is a move towards more fine-grained -- and intersectional --
entity types. The second is a move towards zero-shot recognition and extraction
of these fine-grained types based on entity-type labels. The third, and most
challenging, is the move from the recognition setup to a novel retrieval setup,
where the query is a zero-shot entity type, and the expected result is all the
sentences from a large, pre-indexed corpus that contain entities of these
types, and their corresponding spans. We show that all of these are far from
being solved. We provide a large, silver-annotated corpus of 4 million
paragraphs covering 500 entity types, to facilitate research towards all of
these three goals. | [
0.0376596637,
0.036123246,
0.0024166799,
0.0390393808,
-0.0069066109,
0.0383791924,
-0.0034353342,
0.0237904303,
0.0180450883,
-0.0897822753,
-0.0175404679,
-0.0007280547,
-0.0196551196,
0.0027646432,
0.0414447039,
-0.0198921338,
0.0178493522,
0.0091954619,
0.0500659645,
0.0477975942,
0.0109264106,
0.0381639674,
-0.0043436731,
0.0398634784,
0.0129099824,
0.0095833763,
-0.0148603283,
0.015951721,
0.0269838795,
-0.0525092408,
0.0371251181,
0.0419375524,
0.021101037,
0.0579252094,
0.0000019009,
-0.0298567694,
-0.0614277087,
0.0174151789,
-0.033533264,
-0.0230425354,
0.011832837,
-0.0360148437,
-0.0071978476,
-0.0000071597,
-0.0078708353,
-0.0615568794,
-0.0005572558,
0.0488087237,
0.020184543,
0.0965171978,
-0.0171551965,
-0.0206294265,
0.022242507,
0.0047670202,
-0.0025713218,
-0.032811027,
0.0531819947,
-0.0683811232,
0.0108020753,
0.0592876002,
0.0465965346,
0.0094961887,
-0.0476274453,
0.0074911145,
0.0094737737,
0.0320758708,
-0.068872273,
0.0216499921,
-0.0074401367,
0.0551912747,
0.0120932702,
-0.0117540061,
0.0836482719,
0.008468708,
-0.0316058844,
-0.0325192399,
-0.0286996737,
0.0133424969,
-0.0304703973,
0.014017758,
0.0133995013,
-0.0100174695,
0.0181574412,
0.0002337935,
-0.0174385477,
0.0093300156,
0.0212559272,
-0.0405276418,
0.0104541043,
0.0074115689,
-0.0261488892,
-0.0490686893,
0.0191601906,
0.0300718844,
0.020808991,
0.0207988899,
-0.0103066796,
-0.0065835272,
0.0169462655,
-0.0190855525,
-0.009302251,
-0.0099743064,
0.0245807022,
0.0615548566,
-0.0403195843,
-0.0007859407,
-0.0118014682,
-0.0108353393,
0.0385541841,
-0.0162009187,
-0.0570923127,
-0.0181158241,
-0.0543541238,
0.0567381643,
-0.0111176185,
0.0140957097,
0.0079829004,
-0.0219316557,
-0.0055985916,
0.0378891826,
-0.0062442194,
-0.0063387891,
0.0167481229,
-0.0240812898,
-0.0302899312,
0.0401778966,
-0.0097282613,
0.0081148893,
-0.0248267949,
-0.0535047241,
0.007841357,
-0.0352873541,
0.0490484983,
-0.0487235598,
0.038246654,
0.043955382,
0.0334569886,
-0.1184951365,
-0.0921130329,
-0.0208917949,
0.0007863663,
-0.0414360426,
-0.0103621325,
-0.0392846949,
0.0261055175,
0.0075632469,
0.0093051642,
-0.0415489264,
0.031845618,
0.0255518723,
-0.0668036416,
0.0642852262,
-0.0294850506,
0.0000973015,
0.0076285796,
-0.0135326376,
0.0492426567,
0.0465124771,
0.037782155,
-0.0182297602,
0.0747588277,
0.0025922514,
-0.0117501011,
0.0430719256,
0.0049797813,
0.0048936591,
0.0188302696,
0.0099269738,
-0.0299323145,
-0.0168509595,
0.0024803504,
0.0227720886,
0.0039878511,
-0.0319251232,
0.0348257832,
0.0526131317,
-0.0178320967,
-0.0329276733,
0.0263200644,
0.0117414705,
0.0060692891,
-0.031939324,
-0.0109899966,
-0.0331353769,
-0.0440459438,
-0.0161166135,
0.0154274879,
0.051331073,
-0.0274384301,
0.0104110055,
-0.0229242463,
0.0264631975,
-0.0346886069,
0.0134261847,
0.0732047707,
-0.0081310384,
-0.0601231977,
0.0582699217,
0.0266741682,
-0.0414898247,
0.0075982572,
-0.0056939675,
0.037920773,
0.042751763,
0.0554997288,
-0.0674244314,
-0.0322431959,
-0.0276020411,
-0.0332808048,
0.0606425852,
-0.0076475567,
-0.0228764601,
0.0141243571,
-0.0352156423,
0.0174089912,
0.0185223091,
0.0363850147,
0.0189536735,
0.0317438282,
0.0396126285,
0.0205824953,
-0.028098017,
-0.0175507143,
0.0486100726,
-0.0307693407,
-0.0514473058,
0.0028137646,
0.0276515726,
-0.0228195135,
0.0711930916,
-0.0023323372,
-0.0097999424,
0.0260756202,
-0.0217979997,
-0.0230533704,
-0.0467323735,
0.069106847,
-0.0176189095,
-0.0040799845,
-0.0160933733,
-0.0145058138,
-0.0188569389,
-0.0012191642,
-0.0521123111,
-0.0293541737,
0.0461113192,
0.0334475823,
-0.0057838215,
0.0401713252,
0.019782301,
-0.008407684,
-0.0565083735,
0.0676084459,
0.0168904644,
0.0397244878,
0.0143478559,
-0.0408566445,
0.0154081639,
-0.0416142382,
-0.0795294717,
0.0016409794,
-0.0095202895,
-0.0179209169,
0.039003998,
-0.0273881704,
-0.0430712402,
-0.0217557177,
-0.0918176994,
0.0492518283,
-0.0169910379,
0.0530969724,
0.010945363,
0.0262614507,
-0.0316179655,
0.0073839356,
0.0095587419,
-0.0153662367,
-0.0043270998,
0.0160251595,
0.0350499265,
0.0072907307,
-0.0130892582,
-0.019436026,
-0.0067889532,
-0.0675417408,
0.0455119163,
-0.0085827289,
-0.0583738573,
-0.0537459329,
0.077656053,
-0.0215298887,
0.0179616548,
0.0058635054,
0.0226746015,
-0.0080335094,
-0.0193709247,
0.0033935122,
0.0765276775,
-0.0011206797,
0.0286180452,
-0.0435863324,
-0.0178455021,
-0.0551151633,
0.0237495787,
-0.0321270227,
0.0311996154,
-0.0115227737,
-0.0446761847,
0.0526348129,
0.0751854479,
-0.0390034094,
-0.0193409231,
-0.0627344847,
0.008434142,
-0.0093007805,
0.0087606432,
-0.0119148754,
0.0515452772,
0.0256546512,
0.0089014862,
-0.0320908092,
0.0227007605,
0.0208573546,
-0.0559539795,
0.0053661782,
0.0320231095,
-0.0142338937,
-0.0761457682,
0.0647333637,
0.0201112758,
-0.014276688,
0.072182335,
-0.063582629,
0.0257355459,
0.0537867323,
-0.0040528798,
-0.0158643108,
0.0667129606,
0.0147281867,
0.0367918387,
-0.0252681337,
-0.0447555296,
-0.0074324529,
-0.031867329,
-0.0553028844,
0.0049186079,
-0.0074539343,
-0.0072166487,
-0.035973832,
0.0305724088,
-0.0113617191,
0.0200780276,
-0.0157834329,
-0.0098996237,
-0.047315374,
0.0597162656,
0.03632522,
-0.0078112115,
0.0168069396,
0.0178575162,
-0.0108635956,
0.0245230924,
-0.0015186974,
0.0185456313,
0.0098379152,
-0.0200950522,
0.0339791067,
-0.0847444236,
-0.0067411442,
-0.0224527828,
0.0339586288,
-0.0424776897,
-0.0175738055,
0.1035969704,
0.0134878727,
-0.0126537448,
-0.034563072,
0.0346668363,
0.0093256067,
0.0370478071,
0.0301528685,
-0.0949412659,
-0.0445844606,
0.0291481465,
-0.0173384026,
-0.0349636115,
-0.0932574049,
-0.004684234,
-0.1283363253,
0.0112607218,
-0.0330343768,
-0.0448154248,
0.0223867428,
-0.0610084906,
0.0053911787,
-0.0510611907,
-0.0303388014,
-0.0173321068,
-0.0330849327,
-0.0013340575,
0.0170298964,
0.0357954577,
-0.0370043814,
0.0133237038,
-0.0494611524,
0.0333197527,
0.0261524674,
0.0452025644,
-0.024221722,
0.0040085609,
-0.0182763245,
-0.0511627048,
-0.0454475768,
0.0076247882,
0.0683930293,
-0.0683333203,
-0.0108530987,
-0.0180249065,
0.0124563044,
-0.0290732905,
-0.0050254832,
0.0298123322,
0.032391347,
0.0204346944,
0.0065996442,
-0.0405970104,
-0.036349386,
0.010191205,
0.0783832744,
-0.0067543085,
-0.0022347707,
-0.0205189157,
-0.0176134612,
-0.0013510804,
-0.0196912326,
-0.0458501428,
0.0170495901,
-0.0254613366,
-0.0166624337,
-0.0201375689,
-0.033311978,
0.0583480187,
0.0502690077,
0.0185054615,
0.0223038457,
0.0483493321,
0.0160385817,
-0.0679380596,
0.0465409346,
-0.0459074192,
0.0246259216,
-0.0739147663,
-0.0028441041,
0.0189818814,
0.024393959,
-0.0501120202,
-0.0217139106,
-0.0707137957,
-0.0703937188,
-0.0227588769,
-0.0041399752,
0.0153218601,
-0.0026610529,
-0.0111880805,
-0.0390274078,
0.0488253012,
0.0587814972,
-0.0377937108,
-0.0272791106,
-0.0062751416,
0.0313533209,
-0.0214304253,
0.0370708443,
-0.0567788072,
0.0120586734,
0.0021373741,
0.0603151694,
-0.021008268,
-0.0198524855,
-0.0002434912,
0.0173369367,
0.0539520122,
0.0173435677,
0.0041584051,
-0.055808749,
-0.0050492957,
-0.0143925669,
-0.0159868691,
-0.0178678483,
-0.029338656,
-0.0025578521,
0.0014523942,
-0.0378737338,
0.0617376864,
-0.0128517831,
0.0795719028,
-0.0730817318,
0.0111446353,
0.0104616471,
0.0238431618,
-0.0062534139,
-0.0472050682,
0.0175094567,
0.0651488006,
0.0099731786,
0.0457755961,
-0.0323793329,
0.0031273952,
0.0128975641,
0.0078586405,
-0.0303276833,
0.0120790619,
-0.0478745066,
0.0211545713,
-0.0074296212,
0.0422122963,
0.0504968539,
-0.0247830469,
0.0711515397,
0.0024152049,
-0.0362025797,
0.0006471203,
0.0057420689,
0.0179241542,
-0.023294976,
0.0219470561,
0.0462813601,
-0.0327850915,
-0.0100050224,
0.0725835711,
0.0218216348,
0.0678392723,
0.0496461838,
-0.043885041,
-0.0100238044,
-0.0027681007,
0.0425439775,
-0.0209444016,
0.0046927626,
0.0011461497,
-0.0743811131,
-0.014553668,
0.033182539,
-0.037384171,
-0.0129429037,
-0.0118128825,
-0.0131925512,
0.0094552785,
0.0354395285,
-0.039538797,
-0.0715348348,
0.0008620905,
-0.0295862127,
-0.0322008319,
-0.0034287756,
-6.280174078e-33,
-0.0293172542,
-0.0235048439,
0.0093441838,
-0.0293035209,
-0.0073797801,
0.056253273,
0.0111602498,
-0.018567156,
0.0022637467,
-0.0261889193,
-0.020216221,
0.0083341459,
0.0206273198,
0.0165430773,
0.0042082211,
-0.0157117788,
0.0473801158,
0.0149502037,
-0.0128046786,
0.0103820711,
0.0581843965,
0.0530088842,
0.0607577749,
-0.0334022827,
0.0429471284,
0.0001042935,
0.0053267232,
0.0185273923,
0.0630804524,
0.0665681437,
-0.0247583762,
0.0140680047,
0.0372553803,
-0.0583992153,
0.0300926566,
0.0315197706,
-0.1227439269,
0.0237137955,
-0.0351586975,
0.0122423163,
0.0015335951,
-0.0381399505,
0.0284096487,
0.0046476307,
0.0108531313,
0.011012678,
0.0386885144,
0.0096858153,
0.0166820362,
-0.0274165496,
-0.0530184582,
0.0444879644,
-0.0011460767,
0.0347816199,
0.0508627892,
-0.0042045149,
0.0325768813,
0.0541950129,
-0.0681514367,
0.0081071695,
0.0217844434,
-0.0026944536,
-0.0258966535,
0.0205886438,
-0.001077525,
0.0399636924,
0.0221705548,
0.0265884139,
-0.0500225201,
-0.0098831989,
0.030489305,
0.0262802429,
-0.039214462,
0.0585815422,
0.0409291238,
-0.0210371297,
-0.0655571595,
0.0358032435,
0.0021491898,
0.0106440727,
0.0143884346,
-0.0344472639,
-0.0629239157,
-0.0102779735,
-0.0188059378,
-0.0640007108,
-0.0463643409,
0.0165627785,
0.027977122,
0.0209512301,
-0.0278021228,
0.0343932174,
0.0272182263,
-0.0303211957,
-0.0770804361,
0.0250509586,
0.0162750836,
0.0111969113,
-0.0059974645,
0.0247844178,
-0.0802171081,
-0.0532442667,
0.0162170343,
-0.0186179802,
0.0167419109,
-0.0093564223,
0.0405088402,
-0.0139056575,
-0.0680992305,
-0.0101680635,
-0.0045233369,
0.0331671387,
-0.0548486337,
0.0321305543,
0.0116832657,
0.0042175343,
0.0300323665,
0.0314117074,
0.069691956,
-0.0091237193,
-0.001015863,
0.0349414945,
0.0333386585,
-0.003948682,
0.0194526389,
-0.000174333,
-0.0085758986,
0.0047253575,
0.0066231177,
-0.0484808534,
0.0090715168,
-0.0123672243,
2.615e-7,
-0.0177075081,
0.0257291179,
0.0116696451,
0.0111031923,
0.0044392627,
0.0380160064,
0.0186379459,
0.0516411364,
-0.0323626287,
-0.0051236753,
-0.0186244864,
-0.0204534233,
0.0224051345,
0.0185203459,
-0.1165157706,
-0.0303817466,
0.001151448,
-0.0118941646,
-0.0953047201,
0.0048925634,
0.031725321,
0.0615050793,
0.0021899976,
0.0084319562,
-0.0183314178,
-0.0220270194,
0.050843142,
0.0102685047,
0.014767508,
0.04239811,
0.0179994404,
0.0802912712,
-0.010083816,
0.0014953325,
0.0091064358,
0.0609266125,
0.012748614,
0.0692983642,
-0.0026266412,
0.0070504555,
-0.0057364521,
-0.051982183,
0.0077348957,
-0.0267833415,
0.0953725949,
-0.0295132808,
-0.0400220342,
0.0088695167,
-0.0316802152,
-0.0259664189,
-0.0258191749,
0.0121017974,
-0.025496928,
0.0268516056,
0.0220739916,
-0.0353341475,
-0.0004085782,
-0.1003284603,
0.0291125495,
0.0350228883,
-0.0122682359,
0.0138947051,
-0.0049785511,
-0.0121631222,
-0.0208024401,
-0.0900902525,
0.0060231443,
2.657689871e-34,
-0.0394984521,
0.0285110753,
-0.0343351476,
0.0328462124,
0.0368867926,
-0.0144981286,
-0.0710904896,
-0.0166399125,
-0.0136204129,
-0.0760345235,
0.0119058797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14278v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14278v2 | Conversational Speech Recognition by Learning Audio-textual Cross-modal Contextual Representation | 2023-10-22T11:57:33 | 2024-04-28T03:50:18 | Kun Wei, Bei Li, Hang Lv, Quan Lu, Ning Jiang, Lei Xie | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) in conversational settings presents unique
challenges, including extracting relevant contextual information from previous
conversational turns. Due to irrelevant content, error propagation, and
redundancy, existing methods struggle to extract longer and more effective
contexts. To address this issue, we introduce a novel conversational ASR
system, extending the Conformer encoder-decoder model with cross-modal
conversational representation. Our approach leverages a cross-modal extractor
that combines pre-trained speech and text models through a specialized encoder
and a modal-level mask input. This enables the extraction of richer historical
speech context without explicit error propagation. We also incorporate
conditional latent variational modules to learn conversational level attributes
such as role preference and topic coherence. By introducing both cross-modal
and conversational representations into the decoder, our model retains context
over longer sentences without information loss, achieving relative accuracy
improvements of 8.8% and 23% on Mandarin conversation datasets HKUST and
MagicData-RAMC, respectively, compared to the standard Conformer model. | [
-0.0282058045,
0.0551472865,
0.0077678929,
0.0435614176,
-0.0221634842,
-0.0201162733,
0.0188452452,
-0.038076371,
-0.0231522992,
-0.0305362642,
-0.0410163403,
-0.0265000071,
0.0169691648,
0.0440171733,
-0.0142518058,
-0.058760874,
0.0151409162,
-0.048876062,
-0.0028395436,
-0.0022675127,
0.0138920229,
-0.0135804452,
-0.0047997907,
0.0125524011,
-0.0146726044,
0.0053822296,
-0.0319180526,
-0.0006659011,
0.0359418131,
-0.0080735805,
0.0104505569,
-0.0029895315,
0.0654820055,
-0.0206293929,
0.0000020105,
0.0042478489,
-0.0544780381,
-0.0178531706,
-0.047638543,
-0.0151504464,
0.0228422564,
-0.0107358545,
-0.0238995384,
0.0428850763,
-0.018641891,
-0.0049408544,
0.0193738304,
0.0870484784,
0.0408068523,
0.0687296465,
-0.0168866403,
-0.0487453155,
0.0404995941,
-0.0136878937,
0.02596418,
-0.0887097567,
-0.0289029591,
0.0512771048,
-0.005425123,
0.0158645567,
-0.050030835,
0.0448229127,
0.0170340296,
-0.0207991581,
-0.0150214341,
0.040018253,
0.0476413518,
-0.0097194863,
-0.0273980126,
0.0825854167,
0.0434646122,
-0.0157238506,
0.0052078487,
-0.0125990044,
-0.0407993793,
-0.0051632775,
-0.024225181,
0.0165303722,
0.004243609,
0.0082382597,
0.0251370389,
0.0609989651,
-0.003706204,
-0.0356534906,
-0.0219545979,
-0.0135685178,
0.0011602734,
-0.0280462038,
-0.0304362867,
-0.0359043181,
0.0153669473,
-0.0224976297,
0.0417516865,
-0.0022989879,
-0.0495698228,
0.0108743692,
-0.0321457572,
-0.0011298007,
-0.034437485,
-0.0248801634,
-0.0542361364,
0.0347981304,
-0.0537088551,
0.0421493463,
0.0149881216,
0.0364856943,
-0.0169740487,
0.0084314961,
-0.0328277983,
-0.0587839261,
-0.0171221811,
0.0129618244,
0.0050725648,
-0.0034105044,
-0.0571292453,
-0.0331286006,
-0.0305462535,
0.0257719569,
-0.0111812856,
0.0023808624,
0.0393672213,
0.0234837625,
-0.0463396721,
-0.0241339728,
0.02363226,
0.023520492,
0.004462657,
0.0616397783,
-0.0036690379,
-0.0499809049,
-0.031856738,
0.0246287417,
0.0729799867,
-0.0211504549,
-0.0110491719,
0.0633570701,
-0.0321396291,
-0.0400475934,
-0.0021870127,
-0.0051355958,
-0.0418053642,
-0.0430999547,
-0.012876384,
-0.0128967511,
0.0521772765,
0.00969439,
0.0023385726,
-0.0075914576,
-0.0094847344,
-0.0157940648,
0.0057768589,
0.0649097562,
0.0480005033,
-0.0133386813,
0.0366040803,
0.0068171318,
0.0167751331,
0.0204752833,
0.0563647598,
-0.0071539967,
0.0173745733,
-0.0247973558,
0.0206707157,
0.0214450378,
-0.0160723142,
-0.0484060645,
0.0048877872,
0.0109855384,
0.0378943533,
-0.0082668131,
0.0457550287,
0.039710369,
-0.0570353642,
-0.005460511,
0.037955109,
0.0003006544,
0.0474185646,
0.0147092324,
0.0130120227,
0.0276172087,
-0.0356859788,
0.0336411782,
-0.0199059974,
0.0106707225,
-0.0201089513,
0.017516803,
0.0240602698,
0.0148687586,
-0.0295082275,
-0.0248267837,
0.0481760874,
-0.0479733795,
0.0355312899,
0.0316700637,
0.0446312651,
-0.0058584576,
-0.0641592145,
0.0210917033,
0.0186636951,
-0.0628870428,
0.0170573741,
0.0134489629,
0.0227042623,
0.0516069196,
0.0221412238,
-0.0497060157,
-0.0060352916,
-0.0327294804,
-0.0011608704,
0.0073935473,
0.0160654001,
-0.0229817182,
0.0796487406,
-0.0726489648,
-0.0388679057,
0.0092016486,
-0.0062923981,
0.0411339626,
-0.0214197133,
0.0243844166,
0.0314145908,
0.0130713079,
0.0655867457,
-0.0130503112,
-0.05426649,
-0.0241437014,
0.0189077035,
0.0119872903,
0.0510829948,
0.0370901376,
-0.0455380529,
-0.0157885235,
0.0438722484,
-0.0401028059,
0.0122083323,
0.0665401518,
-0.1372035891,
-0.0495904349,
0.0145800877,
-0.0324842259,
-0.0029201841,
0.0097978432,
0.0060679573,
-0.0892542824,
0.0437808223,
-0.0014671955,
0.0843518227,
-0.0592788942,
0.0196202584,
0.051896628,
0.0487031713,
0.0167696979,
0.014836859,
0.0191036891,
-0.0459098369,
0.0423215255,
0.0287181195,
-0.0160646942,
-0.0335103013,
-0.0156118423,
0.0134528894,
-0.001549933,
0.0181910153,
0.0166845042,
0.0044771624,
0.0044044373,
-0.0199603233,
-0.1152455732,
-0.0057889051,
-0.0393172689,
-0.0111322403,
0.002939292,
0.0601745397,
0.0106014106,
-0.0243622009,
-0.0278266296,
-0.006542604,
0.0121368738,
-0.0337150581,
-0.0408831947,
0.0244523901,
-0.0356042199,
-0.0382635146,
0.0362756699,
0.0225642975,
0.0048538186,
-0.0240474269,
0.0018620688,
-0.0116583109,
0.0121262763,
0.0446502455,
0.0611754917,
-0.0614027083,
-0.0071019693,
-0.0265533719,
0.0121280784,
0.050295908,
0.0408809148,
0.0396020561,
0.031335324,
0.0027178291,
-0.0623938292,
-0.0565131642,
0.0163617302,
-0.001249109,
0.0057795011,
-0.0334478132,
-0.000932635,
-0.0093655232,
0.037297599,
0.0357312672,
0.0605656132,
-0.0312068798,
-0.0685551688,
0.0099296719,
-0.0444135144,
0.0091500394,
-0.019659793,
-0.065121524,
0.0214005671,
-0.0030673717,
0.0064195651,
0.0304216426,
-0.0660108402,
-0.0505655184,
-0.0341385752,
-0.0414894111,
-0.0134364609,
0.0291364398,
-0.0229106992,
-0.0059172614,
0.0273486041,
-0.0816393271,
-0.0077366708,
0.0162504949,
0.0354107916,
-0.04440175,
0.0165583007,
-0.023713395,
-0.0092887729,
-0.0107278442,
-0.0246165097,
-0.0377718881,
-0.0580561981,
-0.0094748354,
0.0294860657,
0.0171375554,
-0.0084329741,
-0.0269785784,
0.0325441882,
0.0163433012,
0.0493104421,
0.001683872,
0.0428706333,
-0.0376985408,
0.0793493241,
0.0223335456,
0.06768547,
-0.024632372,
-0.0196338128,
0.0680995435,
0.0236826912,
0.0256820172,
-0.0202844553,
-0.0178587716,
-0.0162127856,
0.0146794273,
0.0387643129,
-0.0114295455,
0.0216572788,
0.0696314499,
-0.0406851359,
-0.0139847146,
0.1046615988,
-0.0124875521,
-0.0418877639,
-0.0444923937,
0.0046744044,
-0.0012467462,
-0.0142207798,
-0.0130625693,
-0.0648798868,
-0.047652185,
0.0432718284,
-0.0030391645,
-0.000955765,
0.0234435666,
0.0069885054,
-0.0641082376,
0.0267477967,
0.0140083451,
-0.0417202935,
-0.0466453433,
-0.0485311076,
-0.0292400401,
-0.0480459481,
0.066525206,
-0.0243492909,
-0.0088928025,
-0.0483641177,
0.0151553564,
-0.0175722949,
-0.0899157301,
0.0278415438,
-0.0209209248,
0.0744028389,
0.0488518141,
0.0234057978,
-0.0064844433,
0.0034523669,
0.0365332738,
-0.0241594277,
-0.0015383804,
-0.0011856162,
0.0260318294,
-0.0599522777,
0.0188078918,
0.0297307968,
0.0311559122,
0.007411106,
-0.0363700986,
0.0289247669,
0.0264958329,
-0.0361545309,
0.0216496997,
0.0400877558,
0.0315772071,
0.0237605609,
0.0609519109,
0.0198419634,
-0.0100825056,
-0.0129472166,
0.0072399103,
0.0357346609,
-0.0131044211,
0.0092625935,
-0.0244779065,
0.022350207,
-0.0151958847,
-0.0195071325,
-0.0352665558,
-0.0041547557,
-0.0256861988,
0.000315653,
-0.0372394584,
0.0156420246,
0.0220016316,
-0.0304926224,
-0.0107425265,
-0.0117003825,
0.031061599,
-0.0413357057,
0.0004193861,
0.0323002636,
-0.0758483261,
-0.0262563918,
-0.0026669423,
-0.0535048321,
-0.0558464676,
0.0153497253,
0.0102471905,
0.0077091609,
0.1239616796,
-0.0154283689,
-0.0025070324,
0.0380776115,
-0.039062161,
-0.0618217848,
0.0001900765,
0.0534837209,
0.0089517515,
-0.0169468261,
0.0036198949,
-0.0230251923,
0.012862023,
-0.0149695994,
0.0084186066,
-0.054432068,
-0.0425705016,
-0.0046838047,
-0.0210660063,
0.0374781936,
0.0220473725,
0.0070394375,
-0.04401749,
0.0411492288,
-0.0504874028,
0.0326037034,
-0.0347190723,
-0.0119486088,
-0.0104075409,
-0.0002472265,
0.0059940745,
0.064112924,
-0.0138332481,
0.0026361512,
-0.0376164466,
0.0750550553,
0.0300799329,
-0.0004558583,
-0.0240590014,
-0.0166364387,
-0.0091704335,
0.00830747,
0.057791397,
0.0398582034,
-0.0246943962,
0.0485560447,
-0.0249911211,
-0.0361814611,
-0.0083661117,
0.0346051455,
-0.0971035138,
0.0049627726,
-0.0355288833,
0.0398744084,
0.0269545503,
-0.0376579389,
0.0413039625,
-0.001549917,
0.0381738991,
-0.0218334254,
0.0660268366,
-0.0163628198,
-0.0077749458,
0.043115221,
0.0033437281,
-0.0254696384,
0.0570475683,
0.0636926666,
-0.0164214522,
0.0285690501,
-0.0434560962,
0.0263505355,
-0.0590473339,
-0.0212285295,
0.0534951687,
0.0347920842,
-0.0397883616,
-0.0122861704,
0.0028635862,
-0.0199847352,
0.0310644768,
0.0090301763,
0.011167773,
-0.006445291,
-0.0202236921,
0.032663215,
-0.0230602976,
0.0095499679,
0.009763835,
-0.0255020875,
0.031483002,
0.0116092209,
-0.0299247485,
-6.298963621e-33,
-0.0373405106,
0.0160013605,
-0.0038817166,
-0.0063176188,
-0.0624884255,
0.0239180941,
-0.0633565858,
0.0031907281,
0.0148582533,
-0.0287888702,
-0.0207215548,
0.0148007423,
0.0398434065,
0.0445867926,
-0.0136132846,
-0.0216086358,
0.0939683095,
0.0105482535,
0.0205059089,
0.0329438448,
0.0224181004,
0.0549445711,
0.0219591428,
-0.1187719256,
0.0020655645,
0.0030855522,
-0.0022688401,
-0.0233107302,
0.0381594114,
0.0440170169,
-0.0135931075,
-0.0044894079,
-0.003924665,
-0.0395281874,
-0.00334913,
0.0312010832,
-0.1174758971,
0.0487111248,
-0.0257907249,
0.0387565978,
0.0089702187,
-0.0091920402,
0.0093632545,
0.003590645,
0.019333316,
-0.0169482734,
0.0324623212,
-0.0116315419,
-0.0072741546,
0.0177412499,
-0.0287230033,
0.0397207364,
-0.0327303968,
-0.0426672921,
0.0544704124,
0.0608184524,
0.0205999389,
0.0068376116,
-0.046530202,
0.0260173902,
-0.0180646107,
-0.0005517868,
0.0232139565,
0.0504747592,
-0.0165139642,
0.0508443788,
0.0495495647,
-0.0646008924,
-0.0117981536,
-0.0437331833,
-0.0006851372,
0.0452606343,
-0.0587582178,
0.0604112521,
-0.0074199247,
-0.0412313268,
-0.0435426198,
0.0197069105,
0.0050480054,
0.0155863734,
-0.0022494304,
0.0392623283,
-0.0213447735,
-0.0016957335,
-0.0292176437,
-0.0229895264,
-0.009255602,
0.0012378341,
0.022322949,
0.0404296294,
-0.0265009757,
-0.0276356582,
0.0812136084,
-0.0179327857,
0.0396991335,
0.0285989568,
0.0040136166,
-0.0122603923,
-0.0183187798,
0.0201256629,
-0.0528723411,
-0.0316804685,
0.0678055882,
-0.0209178459,
-0.0021678852,
-0.0195893608,
-0.0104893139,
0.0663666874,
-0.0336682387,
-0.0032623808,
-0.0083834296,
0.0065206345,
-0.0200527012,
0.0856284052,
0.0466901883,
0.0090434086,
-0.0220517293,
0.0437366515,
-0.0233416799,
0.0709740445,
-0.0331871845,
-0.0778571293,
0.035698887,
0.0215591975,
-0.0328254923,
0.0048375446,
0.0225797575,
-0.033950489,
0.029152004,
-0.012656942,
0.0053639933,
-0.0028160389,
2.798e-7,
-0.0388797224,
-0.0004683225,
0.0638457462,
-0.0409096032,
0.0323051885,
0.051847972,
-0.0098756021,
0.0092101311,
0.0008041172,
-0.0015867782,
0.0477218181,
-0.0034923982,
0.0864449292,
0.0240998566,
-0.0352917053,
-0.0242735744,
-0.0510652922,
-0.0476638973,
0.0175417289,
-0.0067876689,
0.0624053739,
0.0988546684,
-0.0271493606,
0.0057779811,
0.0054518213,
0.0147050647,
0.0628235415,
-0.0406921506,
-0.0419217683,
-0.0227319207,
-0.0391311087,
-0.0166979693,
-0.027637355,
-0.0018027968,
-0.0324447453,
0.0583333485,
0.0065055317,
0.0812806115,
0.0287049022,
-0.1089635566,
-0.0332646333,
0.0645798817,
-0.0246418379,
0.0088309031,
0.0616553277,
-0.0126872957,
-0.025884077,
-0.0418015607,
-0.0939270034,
0.0289746858,
-0.00395888,
0.0137342401,
-0.0216964372,
0.0258897562,
0.0012669828,
0.0084042642,
-0.0252177864,
-0.0834787339,
0.0142557491,
-0.0222274773,
-0.0760978237,
0.0002605768,
-0.0028783367,
-0.0324977301,
0.0335428305,
-0.0029363933,
0.0177513957,
2.071454997e-34,
0.0304382537,
0.0026625989,
-0.0103609925,
0.0211197864,
0.0099101625,
-0.0269580875,
0.0204968788,
-0.0091767162,
0.0045281015,
-0.0631089211,
-0.0521405973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14265v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14265v2 | CT-GAT: Cross-Task Generative Adversarial Attack based on Transferability | 2023-10-22T11:00:04 | 2023-11-05T14:07:04 | Minxuan Lv, Chengwei Dai, Kun Li, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural network models are vulnerable to adversarial examples, and adversarial
transferability further increases the risk of adversarial attacks. Current
methods based on transferability often rely on substitute models, which can be
impractical and costly in real-world scenarios due to the unavailability of
training data and the victim model's structural details. In this paper, we
propose a novel approach that directly constructs adversarial examples by
extracting transferable features across various tasks. Our key insight is that
adversarial transferability can extend across different tasks. Specifically, we
train a sequence-to-sequence generative model named CT-GAT using adversarial
sample data collected from multiple tasks to acquire universal adversarial
features and generate adversarial examples for different tasks. We conduct
experiments on ten distinct datasets, and the results demonstrate that our
method achieves superior attack performance with small cost. | [
-0.0314414501,
0.0911207125,
-0.0273410473,
0.0400684364,
-0.0231975541,
0.0033383137,
0.0399935991,
-0.0263343845,
-0.0040458795,
-0.0192101207,
-0.0299182776,
-0.0086586494,
-0.0013320609,
0.0358813852,
0.0825418085,
-0.048339542,
0.0231011678,
-0.0025970025,
-0.0552369542,
0.0088660605,
-0.0140636805,
-0.0114924908,
0.0095309457,
0.0319744647,
-0.0026829334,
-0.0219893381,
-0.0204085466,
0.0198730249,
0.0642274693,
-0.0025679653,
0.0264379773,
0.0200527813,
0.0062973755,
0.0408132076,
0.0000021639,
0.0272009801,
-0.0511475988,
0.00544097,
0.0020013452,
0.015180965,
0.0240822006,
-0.0076080291,
-0.0171765145,
0.0151006738,
-0.0322639011,
0.0008699395,
0.0243435036,
0.0666509196,
0.0604722351,
0.1014241949,
-0.029561419,
0.0094595384,
0.0234562419,
-0.0694627911,
0.0264513902,
-0.0769070759,
0.0052623842,
-0.0129577648,
-0.0227417499,
0.0022025511,
-0.0026910617,
0.005730141,
0.0291483775,
0.0144648096,
-0.0220619421,
0.0082690101,
-0.0171636902,
0.0339193419,
-0.0008541213,
0.0700150505,
-0.0774578825,
0.0037745123,
0.0143349441,
0.0020015901,
0.0299393255,
-0.0056242053,
-0.0522696488,
-0.013301122,
0.019949723,
0.0055543371,
-0.0326967128,
0.0079607442,
0.0294242129,
-0.0288739502,
0.0016033043,
-0.0510306284,
0.0359651893,
0.0119493445,
-0.0206818487,
0.0051545873,
-0.048793342,
-0.0153861437,
0.0057832613,
-0.0111611066,
-0.0019784379,
-0.00505867,
-0.1129180193,
-0.0673802793,
-0.0169114321,
0.0328013711,
0.1174044907,
-0.0131776882,
-0.0495072007,
0.0254587959,
-0.050282225,
0.0415175259,
-0.0561784767,
0.0473481715,
-0.0280860141,
-0.01120017,
-0.0821832418,
-0.0116392998,
0.0051787738,
-0.004436437,
-0.0084021529,
0.0023984534,
-0.0216260254,
0.0060755159,
-0.048882883,
-0.015247724,
0.0041897641,
0.040062964,
-0.0595388636,
0.0183940325,
0.0529420115,
-0.0554582588,
-0.0088856518,
0.0276254117,
0.0379431657,
-0.0712198913,
-0.0835396349,
0.022080861,
0.0019425174,
-0.0338294916,
0.0042551821,
0.1073151082,
-0.0098164557,
-0.0355165564,
-0.035287004,
-0.0078053549,
-0.014154573,
-0.028994659,
0.0574907996,
-0.0149627877,
0.0185081419,
-0.0550872721,
0.0060048294,
-0.0631897002,
-0.0214361046,
-0.0005070592,
-0.0199521221,
0.1118526161,
0.0691145733,
-0.0390822664,
0.0134692462,
0.0265049059,
-0.0414573736,
0.0208377969,
0.0137156695,
0.0609427541,
0.0053944094,
-0.0133472094,
0.0199061036,
0.0280508939,
0.0636273026,
0.009192843,
0.0151765877,
-0.0123072425,
0.0376212522,
-0.0025566698,
0.0111137284,
0.0099601252,
-0.0118629364,
-0.0496084243,
0.0897177085,
0.0096777203,
-0.0252969507,
0.0550744161,
0.0136263017,
0.0064067128,
-0.055016458,
-0.0053737354,
-0.0577357709,
0.0495556742,
-0.026691772,
-0.0214084126,
-0.0059159328,
0.0479367226,
-0.0384643078,
-0.0041043195,
0.0432603024,
-0.0037122318,
0.0081121959,
-0.0201851055,
0.0337657295,
0.0847176164,
-0.0426061563,
-0.0142217744,
-0.0092409169,
-0.0481794737,
-0.0161122642,
-0.0595576689,
-0.024596408,
-0.0127495956,
0.0215944406,
-0.0103135426,
-0.0226011202,
-0.0083849188,
-0.0004429172,
-0.0016556117,
-0.0023811907,
0.0035936683,
0.0474908389,
-0.0204356331,
-0.0279034656,
-0.07505548,
0.0165666677,
0.0645874515,
0.0290989112,
0.029545987,
0.0290400591,
-0.0376061872,
0.0123652667,
0.0081083216,
-0.0219743382,
-0.0704657957,
0.0605277978,
0.0166151971,
0.0491672792,
-0.0050177909,
-0.0210457388,
0.0083835255,
0.0392842889,
-0.0297700018,
-0.030337492,
-0.00686588,
-0.0192084089,
-0.0132998843,
-0.0241349414,
-0.0653177202,
0.0115741277,
0.0871026143,
-0.0576744638,
-0.0153897554,
0.0482883342,
0.0077939769,
-0.0287391711,
-0.0011127196,
-0.0192664228,
0.0408300348,
0.066492945,
-0.0000221228,
0.0478362516,
0.0077042729,
-0.0827869698,
-0.0123134321,
0.0081220428,
-0.0283852536,
-0.0552795865,
0.0051099793,
0.0102078887,
-0.0243969224,
0.0039802818,
-0.0115659321,
0.0055071306,
0.0162515324,
-0.0021938982,
-0.0298747253,
0.0088833133,
-0.0220220145,
0.0222207867,
0.0295490604,
-0.0044923979,
-0.0048663574,
0.00018434,
-0.0525601991,
0.0433747694,
-0.0162076838,
-0.0058918633,
0.0200319309,
-0.0159180574,
0.0138679268,
-0.0261934642,
-0.0045483774,
0.0223854836,
0.0614954382,
-0.0490967929,
-0.0026848353,
0.0029015683,
0.0306602772,
0.0447284169,
0.0383902974,
-0.0170272067,
-0.0133603821,
0.0133275259,
-0.0005831821,
-0.0367184617,
0.1030107662,
0.0023794023,
0.036007084,
-0.0053159352,
-0.0223490354,
0.0091368472,
0.0001068042,
0.0129256463,
-0.0248213354,
-0.0180446375,
-0.0250687655,
0.0329360999,
0.0472718962,
0.0098171886,
-0.013658938,
-0.0422219113,
0.0509552695,
0.0013500039,
-0.0333951376,
-0.0027335933,
0.0415384136,
-0.0138070527,
-0.0656489134,
-0.0336177759,
-0.0210876353,
0.001471754,
-0.025023751,
0.029688552,
-0.0011596789,
-0.0431794226,
0.0126133589,
0.0865084827,
0.0309937615,
0.0091933208,
0.0676349178,
-0.0035014118,
-0.0461330153,
-0.0071530449,
0.0549593456,
0.0002558219,
-0.0119858347,
-0.0372609384,
-0.02451998,
-0.0246053003,
-0.0348268859,
-0.0296933427,
0.0042580185,
0.0595265403,
0.053376317,
0.0303590298,
-0.0367543586,
-0.0645812005,
-0.0603668094,
-0.005803898,
0.0239664372,
-0.0132115819,
0.0022723747,
-0.0094368113,
0.0667191073,
0.0761164427,
-0.0186216403,
-0.0302958377,
-0.0096118245,
-0.0174763631,
0.0827091932,
0.0200370979,
0.042470593,
-0.0481736623,
-0.0026499168,
0.0035720177,
0.0102640139,
-0.0101818061,
-0.0078030238,
0.0545056313,
-0.038029436,
-0.0159906503,
-0.0024161497,
-0.0313211791,
0.0118649649,
0.0192391966,
0.0455794968,
0.0127409678,
0.0012143924,
0.015103491,
-0.0558642596,
-0.0426407345,
0.0239276979,
0.0350475162,
-0.0220956113,
-0.0144706201,
-0.0243666526,
-0.0918851644,
0.0134872515,
0.0001903105,
-0.0591446906,
-0.0375440754,
0.0365032516,
0.0118935732,
-0.0587907657,
0.0214978661,
-0.0329426713,
0.0178882238,
0.0086882263,
0.0213935263,
0.0443392284,
-0.063955985,
0.0080432873,
-0.0019043627,
0.0269778818,
0.0778012499,
0.0044610244,
-0.0106035117,
-0.0132360188,
0.0067374604,
-0.000050362,
0.0016029614,
0.0501515344,
0.0873677582,
-0.0025296896,
-0.0189703982,
0.037088111,
0.0828128904,
-0.0229326934,
-0.0121193808,
0.0568051375,
0.0336910635,
0.0538494326,
-0.0249089375,
-0.0288008023,
-0.0444461182,
0.0570489205,
0.0554992668,
0.0086155655,
-0.0468645655,
-0.0334657803,
-0.0590334609,
-0.0168152209,
-0.0708085746,
-0.0697172508,
0.0010121574,
0.0142453657,
-0.0460454077,
-0.0710412189,
-0.0119731287,
-0.0170962382,
0.0434553958,
0.0039994633,
-0.0279020593,
-0.0489951521,
-0.0018701862,
-0.0572164543,
0.016871959,
-0.0117409388,
0.0097687384,
-0.0051514492,
-0.0222969148,
-0.0018916654,
-0.0514132902,
-0.0247073472,
0.0470568463,
-0.091483213,
-0.0455456972,
-0.0169894733,
0.0640792921,
0.0074818134,
0.0328429975,
-0.0173875783,
0.0035693159,
0.0746168867,
0.041937001,
-0.0176680814,
-0.0016897622,
0.1081259027,
-0.0717592612,
0.0217497461,
0.0323340558,
-0.0238298774,
0.0388947837,
0.0583083779,
-0.0100008883,
-0.0030155298,
0.044306498,
0.0237125438,
-0.0339540914,
0.0533430316,
0.026022356,
0.0170837883,
0.0106157316,
0.0244616121,
0.0243540369,
0.0255304426,
-0.0641382784,
-0.0021958044,
0.0375810564,
0.0215346869,
0.0082804943,
-0.0067551751,
0.0431212075,
0.0225818697,
-0.0680779442,
-0.0175610147,
0.0028105015,
0.0374412164,
-0.0092493556,
0.0305981897,
0.0159807038,
-0.0106378645,
0.0032536923,
0.0131049948,
-0.0248176716,
0.0226655994,
0.0257622637,
0.0153506277,
0.0288225133,
0.0518237762,
-0.0482278839,
-0.0147739928,
-0.0632869601,
-0.0011801574,
0.0462883301,
-0.000959847,
0.0351192504,
-0.0170021895,
-0.0202427171,
-0.0254817996,
0.0395653062,
0.0056459559,
-0.0094940215,
-0.0137809003,
-0.0032488098,
0.0220535081,
-0.0197062436,
0.0916086584,
0.0306464676,
0.0280689597,
-0.0099975988,
-0.0379417464,
-0.0459026657,
-0.0310392324,
0.0591442399,
-0.0573948622,
0.0244119149,
-0.020672515,
0.0170154627,
-0.067741245,
-0.0028854595,
-0.0253390148,
0.043994803,
0.0164288506,
0.0191619322,
0.0461869575,
-0.0351589434,
0.0172435418,
-0.0226116329,
0.0112102656,
0.0212430749,
-0.0388943069,
0.0354276188,
-6.365815454e-33,
-0.0044989409,
0.0039982125,
-0.0233132616,
-0.0223919526,
0.0065888246,
0.0102104396,
-0.0369790383,
-0.0244061872,
0.0062523996,
0.0028214662,
-0.0068585081,
0.003948234,
-0.0070539443,
0.0518410131,
-0.0029614116,
-0.0450853668,
0.0317445099,
0.0111429067,
-0.0170001741,
0.0629823655,
0.0435115844,
0.0212909244,
0.0709445626,
-0.0746811926,
0.0086096441,
0.003029871,
-0.0360561758,
-0.0511792377,
-0.0244749058,
0.017633969,
-0.0059551648,
0.0108539918,
-0.0082926555,
-0.0564294532,
-0.0146509111,
0.0133067099,
-0.026596697,
0.0026007288,
-0.0629537702,
-0.0303252898,
-0.0416551121,
-0.058325775,
-0.0153714139,
-0.0245495886,
0.0161775891,
-0.0285724998,
0.010546823,
-0.015555515,
0.023286216,
-0.0098150233,
-0.040404506,
0.0112926159,
-0.0201481078,
-0.0298338905,
0.0066480977,
0.0566656962,
0.0164780021,
-0.0137337102,
-0.0535139516,
-0.0000996691,
-0.0062430152,
0.0179293994,
0.0554389581,
-0.0152976643,
0.0183514003,
0.0469496548,
0.0146425199,
-0.02482781,
-0.0285758525,
-0.0245953538,
-0.0307516251,
0.0742935315,
0.0718261823,
0.0760588646,
0.0677997321,
-0.0452262349,
-0.0737416968,
0.0132223926,
-0.0121429544,
0.0006643698,
0.018464407,
0.0268534999,
0.0034038287,
0.011655218,
0.0099961432,
-0.1010001823,
-0.0063313325,
-0.0168389939,
0.0488399118,
0.0149430279,
-0.0408124104,
0.0212526154,
-0.0097678639,
-0.0398422554,
0.0339364298,
0.0253355987,
-0.0420074426,
-0.0373940133,
0.0039953357,
-0.0148219559,
-0.0067618098,
-0.0150692491,
0.0487355329,
-0.0160370432,
0.0519921146,
0.0026996725,
0.0560115762,
0.0480507761,
-0.015199542,
-0.025628807,
-0.054957889,
0.0735407099,
-0.0100678187,
0.0238057338,
0.0159424394,
-0.0080863396,
-0.0233734939,
-0.0147477342,
0.0040702713,
-0.0018770356,
-0.0237345006,
0.0336779878,
-0.0096740788,
0.0078981379,
-0.0156021342,
-0.0154876178,
-0.0178149771,
-0.0055481051,
0.0333634019,
-0.077806741,
-0.0044788998,
-0.0100096753,
2.926e-7,
-0.0264391154,
-0.0207393598,
-0.0190231316,
-0.006026593,
0.0311362464,
0.0617577247,
-0.0188442562,
0.1058223546,
-0.0432381667,
-0.0402404293,
-0.0309390444,
0.016667977,
0.0787274837,
0.0326648653,
-0.0410584807,
-0.0191497914,
-0.0352166407,
0.031607762,
-0.0296892617,
-0.0001023375,
0.014219054,
0.0710754842,
0.0371622629,
-0.0101187527,
0.0508140624,
-0.0456881784,
0.0365813933,
-0.0529948808,
0.0021385245,
-0.0340726003,
0.0057895575,
0.0246682223,
-0.0141795119,
0.031358812,
-0.0561465546,
-0.0167313833,
0.0405360423,
0.0239148345,
0.0111466581,
-0.0385435,
-0.0392313264,
0.0024643177,
0.021188071,
-0.008029107,
0.0800739154,
-0.0382107645,
-0.0339463092,
-0.0145904198,
-0.0356121063,
0.0215613432,
0.0205562767,
-0.00816717,
0.0284616034,
-0.0444967262,
0.0249442793,
0.0086870566,
-0.0002719072,
-0.0497095957,
0.0240513869,
0.0101400092,
-0.0434325635,
-0.0116094835,
-0.0422094315,
-0.0037080443,
0.0363668278,
0.0140102776,
-0.0239881296,
2.568709541e-34,
-0.0303367507,
-0.0107758259,
0.0239184629,
-0.0415173322,
0.0167403556,
-0.0054804515,
0.0005665291,
-0.0313622989,
0.0005133318,
-0.0049681412,
-0.0452365987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14262v1 | Boosting Unsupervised Machine Translation with Pseudo-Parallel Data | 2023-10-22T10:57:12 | 2023-10-22T10:57:12 | Ivana Kvapilíková, Ondřej Bojar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even with the latest developments in deep learning and large-scale language
modeling, the task of machine translation (MT) of low-resource languages
remains a challenge. Neural MT systems can be trained in an unsupervised way
without any translation resources but the quality lags behind, especially in
truly low-resource conditions. We propose a training strategy that relies on
pseudo-parallel sentence pairs mined from monolingual corpora in addition to
synthetic sentence pairs back-translated from monolingual corpora. We
experiment with different training schedules and reach an improvement of up to
14.5 BLEU points (English to Ukrainian) over a baseline trained on
back-translated data only. | [
0.0230069607,
0.0669900849,
-0.0017245736,
0.0466917008,
-0.0331213214,
0.0228854083,
0.040109016,
-0.0178894233,
-0.0323276073,
-0.0172434449,
-0.0196782947,
-0.0515129454,
0.031626422,
-0.0365162902,
0.0353837386,
-0.0442732461,
0.0099952454,
0.0044349134,
-0.0173708126,
-0.0242997743,
-0.0058280006,
0.0469058007,
-0.0228266511,
-0.0151857296,
-0.0332599431,
-0.0152424099,
0.0226375908,
0.042214416,
0.0279340763,
0.0075690965,
-0.028941337,
-0.007644183,
0.0027445573,
0.0788688138,
0.0000017215,
-0.026685765,
-0.0301055741,
-0.0218339525,
0.0084222425,
0.0275415219,
0.017534323,
-0.0527383722,
-0.0307413228,
0.0353968851,
-0.0471643917,
-0.0447865613,
0.0353178047,
0.0031289125,
0.0459320657,
0.0918539912,
-0.0193274114,
-0.0042748665,
0.0197088942,
-0.0601958968,
-0.0515065491,
-0.0082320524,
-0.0412750877,
-0.0039415965,
-0.0544917136,
0.0337126479,
0.0129198413,
0.0601448305,
0.03959544,
-0.0246188268,
-0.0274783187,
0.0035538874,
-0.0389115512,
-0.0269120988,
-0.0175686181,
0.0891530439,
-0.0657933876,
-0.021291161,
-0.0081615429,
-0.0127888052,
-0.0137933763,
-0.0159293879,
-0.0354401954,
0.0221180171,
0.0211472083,
0.0304210372,
0.0290472079,
0.0178609397,
0.0712040961,
-0.0333107375,
-0.0115271965,
-0.0069066109,
0.0165178906,
-0.0266694203,
0.0165064931,
0.0159141328,
-0.0382937863,
0.0270786081,
0.0561889596,
0.0010455002,
0.0058066975,
0.0042700539,
-0.0088430811,
-0.0693032891,
0.0021918972,
-0.0674840733,
0.0608507767,
0.0661009699,
-0.0123603148,
0.0322027989,
-0.0663300529,
0.0194545649,
-0.0252626147,
0.0092234965,
-0.0674746558,
-0.0149272652,
-0.0285496898,
0.0388589799,
-0.0534070246,
-0.0270206574,
-0.0911738947,
0.0121448403,
0.0073965695,
-0.0145724611,
0.0007586696,
0.0085369321,
0.0416797847,
-0.0025535454,
-0.0923721716,
-0.0175194982,
0.0443158709,
0.0567196682,
-0.0190802068,
-0.030008439,
-0.012504708,
-0.0917465612,
-0.016710842,
0.0109521458,
0.0108856848,
-0.0511048511,
-0.0017549206,
0.0431457385,
-0.0349396542,
-0.0233663879,
-0.0092043011,
0.0180141311,
-0.0151349865,
-0.0736402869,
-0.0156236961,
-0.0574554168,
0.0697907433,
-0.0087193828,
0.0154632516,
0.0012496836,
0.0195553377,
0.0090067368,
-0.0130228801,
0.0568658635,
-0.0299254451,
-0.0091253305,
0.016412599,
-0.0221283101,
0.0336718597,
0.0749363825,
0.064606525,
0.0195999965,
0.0107735991,
0.0179144703,
-0.0403847508,
0.0376793966,
0.028578382,
0.0408488587,
-0.0276733655,
0.0126290172,
0.01515551,
0.0381559171,
0.0603780821,
0.059948761,
-0.0087746168,
0.017686652,
0.0678327009,
-0.0019812621,
0.0351651758,
0.0652788728,
0.0657436699,
0.0011899894,
-0.0305157155,
0.010745056,
-0.0070057507,
0.0241768248,
0.0424448773,
-0.0118984533,
0.0483382717,
0.040877372,
-0.032521423,
-0.0356632099,
0.0042916569,
-0.0212297272,
-0.0081262076,
-0.0347074792,
0.0236169156,
0.0303331371,
-0.0443003774,
-0.000727071,
0.0095845209,
-0.0498705693,
0.0424828343,
0.0221694764,
-0.0785633698,
0.0759401619,
0.0167807471,
0.0164546538,
0.0058169542,
-0.04674422,
-0.004145904,
0.0681222901,
0.03489751,
-0.0058069653,
0.0670100749,
-0.0591662861,
0.0148226367,
-0.0252354592,
-0.0140882423,
0.029837247,
-0.0345102325,
0.0347699896,
0.0397733785,
-0.0362751633,
-0.0251166299,
0.0258005373,
-0.0294725951,
-0.0089917658,
0.0428378396,
0.0389523916,
0.0026287173,
0.0200337004,
0.0225280523,
0.0052405507,
0.0446340367,
-0.079298906,
-0.0210871827,
0.044182159,
-0.0506451391,
-0.0840516239,
0.0416992828,
-0.0241668504,
-0.0091565121,
0.0643763244,
-0.0124770775,
-0.0584740639,
0.0012251018,
-0.0373394862,
0.0152294561,
-0.0475275256,
0.0220599733,
0.0294592027,
0.0160788521,
-0.0353685431,
0.0153251169,
-0.0082887113,
0.0128725143,
0.0023500393,
0.0001605445,
0.0514520667,
-0.0590118356,
0.0153998798,
0.0394672751,
0.0220002178,
0.0351666659,
0.0253603756,
0.0185640138,
0.0001948964,
0.0302672219,
-0.061793156,
0.0203651041,
-0.0427173637,
0.039031934,
0.0432590693,
0.0525669791,
0.0113039007,
-0.0245197378,
-0.0246854108,
0.0183596052,
0.0066722408,
-0.0051181293,
0.0206123311,
0.0146750892,
0.0310116764,
-0.0060154214,
-0.0204171296,
0.0153122563,
0.0139216138,
0.0267617609,
0.0072964556,
-0.0438948087,
0.0030282682,
0.0041852617,
0.0186295174,
0.0123243518,
-0.075510323,
-0.0049436251,
-0.0157269668,
0.0773145854,
0.015397612,
-0.0148396967,
-0.0302769411,
0.0385813601,
0.0409828313,
-0.0579291247,
0.0211695824,
-0.0421718732,
0.0118577927,
-0.0301866625,
-0.0324346386,
-0.023645388,
0.0493931845,
-0.0046800524,
-0.0101729501,
-0.0548134781,
-0.0225842614,
0.0190348364,
-0.0374616981,
-0.0028137255,
0.0422121882,
0.0196790919,
0.0137934461,
-0.038673345,
-0.0386845507,
0.0407373272,
-0.0359670669,
-0.0211680606,
-0.0669902861,
-0.0130971735,
-0.0335901678,
0.0257332381,
-0.0067251674,
0.0073286472,
-0.097003594,
-0.0139972344,
-0.0181835238,
0.040121641,
-0.018957464,
0.0262748692,
0.0013308187,
-0.0417883433,
0.018176103,
-0.0405455455,
-0.0254825,
-0.0233357884,
-0.0535756089,
0.0113391364,
-0.0126516409,
0.0097622508,
-0.0017798899,
-0.0151499705,
-0.0135018835,
-0.0259336345,
0.1007530913,
-0.0149990469,
0.0182650127,
-0.0314570032,
0.0545958094,
-0.0038791434,
-0.0403748266,
-0.0007042279,
-0.0683466196,
0.0052332249,
0.0090385284,
0.0431676544,
-0.0012784651,
-0.0424635336,
-0.0523263104,
0.0117402636,
0.0049313903,
-0.0116927354,
-0.0215823743,
0.0191841014,
-0.0309520476,
-0.052800633,
0.0631015673,
0.0093043903,
-0.0233406778,
0.0158011355,
0.0135139208,
0.0199991111,
0.0077675777,
0.0022979707,
-0.0563247837,
-0.0077233762,
-0.0164684933,
0.0110857785,
0.0049501737,
0.0256344769,
-0.0405413918,
-0.1125894636,
-0.0331340767,
0.0381443538,
-0.0680946335,
-0.0056962851,
-0.0316421986,
-0.0331100747,
-0.0287000686,
0.0337709263,
-0.0002952587,
0.0022859152,
0.0063687824,
0.0226439815,
0.0308021363,
-0.0633316711,
-0.0363317207,
-0.0717616528,
0.0318431631,
0.0363143347,
0.0404473916,
-0.0068046073,
-0.0037514926,
0.0167242903,
-0.0479428582,
-0.0132082384,
-0.0062708142,
0.0145092132,
-0.0210083127,
-0.0293389354,
0.0586456619,
0.0200430062,
-0.0650388375,
0.0441520698,
0.0162913147,
0.0564138219,
-0.0220872927,
-0.0069295322,
0.0280498378,
-0.0170096867,
0.0343616046,
0.0420640334,
-0.0018400415,
-0.0330577493,
0.0213316996,
0.0167584289,
-0.018382147,
-0.1202756763,
0.0186173506,
0.0163882859,
-0.0029962321,
-0.0333624631,
-0.0994215533,
-0.0799038783,
-0.0004880081,
0.0517730899,
-0.0123306243,
0.0467358939,
-0.0179418232,
0.0047272942,
-0.0448152907,
0.0593679212,
-0.0340249091,
0.0044254307,
-0.037278939,
-0.0209883433,
-0.0056317924,
-0.0230910387,
0.0244227238,
0.0192236416,
-0.1000460237,
-0.054039266,
-0.0351713412,
0.0647026971,
0.0153763946,
0.0492813066,
-0.0034670027,
-0.018891504,
0.0356211774,
0.0485875048,
-0.037278071,
-0.0194651131,
0.0156412069,
-0.0131166046,
0.0120457141,
0.0627926141,
0.0247890092,
-0.0034481422,
0.0325215943,
0.0450810865,
-0.0203110576,
-0.0188187268,
0.0234147627,
0.0045654941,
0.0610165447,
-0.0267994609,
-0.0003756745,
-0.0301342979,
0.0372967422,
-0.0293358844,
0.0245155208,
-0.0506718718,
0.0130346948,
0.0481192991,
0.0136786904,
-0.0008551196,
0.00580162,
0.0042168489,
-0.0136216749,
-0.0217792261,
-0.0073146848,
-0.0374052823,
0.0190504678,
-0.0011470525,
0.0224051382,
-0.0076051657,
0.0201193839,
-0.0065599578,
0.004852551,
-0.026423635,
-0.0082473243,
0.0278797299,
-0.0069014425,
0.0148234395,
0.0356308408,
-0.0393057019,
0.0186545029,
-0.0225507747,
-0.0135332122,
0.0867053494,
-0.014878842,
0.1211921722,
-0.0026501694,
-0.0164525453,
-0.0220894087,
0.005534566,
-0.0046877218,
-0.0031816934,
-0.0322020538,
0.0036386743,
-0.0079745231,
0.0835150629,
0.068643339,
-0.0108071342,
0.0098163728,
0.0258869063,
0.0349248014,
-0.0417094603,
0.0049790624,
-0.0206397679,
0.0190235786,
-0.0166433901,
-0.0094019286,
0.0089880545,
-0.0363634005,
-0.0047417767,
0.0406120233,
-0.0133741358,
-0.0138979862,
0.0396478176,
0.0420853235,
-0.0356881917,
0.0259174984,
-0.0555118695,
0.0505047739,
0.0200181454,
-0.0227440745,
-0.0346338041,
-5.910838161e-33,
0.0105566401,
0.0084035452,
0.0071888445,
-0.0620586313,
-0.0137879495,
-0.0070256181,
-0.01578632,
-0.037057545,
-0.0115390038,
0.0103415931,
-0.0014417486,
0.019858567,
0.0221401807,
0.0215645824,
0.0045698369,
0.0355380885,
0.080617398,
0.0162752215,
-0.0156174423,
0.0294128414,
0.076263994,
0.0478496589,
0.0879891291,
-0.0538025871,
0.0097578643,
-0.0621917993,
-0.016814366,
0.0480282642,
0.0064013596,
0.0003312341,
-0.0184327718,
0.0141462414,
0.0193289444,
-0.0192240886,
-0.0155437263,
-0.0218697414,
-0.0880348533,
0.0304627009,
0.0120545672,
0.04567362,
-0.0804209411,
-0.0252174586,
0.0506751128,
-0.0200164262,
0.0071588294,
-0.0019184153,
0.0033946144,
-0.0622090995,
-0.0152659733,
0.0204451457,
-0.0459821932,
-0.0001883563,
-0.0182495974,
0.0093452781,
0.0178455897,
0.0596210435,
-0.008878299,
-0.0036499675,
-0.0747913867,
-0.0026436737,
-0.0551552102,
0.060725484,
0.0683677644,
-0.0077378419,
-0.0112319309,
0.0146307768,
0.0427421033,
-0.0090285325,
0.0551229268,
0.030102808,
0.0356422625,
-0.0120191677,
0.0627259687,
0.0554015152,
0.085353747,
-0.0270950999,
-0.1027755514,
0.0376699306,
0.0208429825,
-0.0324471369,
-0.0062487633,
0.0128943278,
-0.0152296415,
-0.0080928383,
-0.0117243584,
-0.0540898629,
-0.0053496887,
-0.0369528234,
-0.0098369373,
0.0267018545,
-0.0307900142,
0.0451759063,
0.0452652387,
-0.0186199043,
0.008741485,
-0.0088553885,
-0.0120123457,
0.0045654709,
-0.0076270504,
0.0560895652,
-0.0433038026,
-0.0483906753,
-0.0069737704,
0.0470507592,
0.0123036616,
-0.0071384902,
0.0639677271,
0.0028576218,
-0.0428658389,
0.0029186129,
-0.052637171,
0.0051731276,
-0.0257406682,
0.0291107576,
0.0213068798,
-0.0277439617,
-0.0037982634,
0.0677514076,
0.0199252293,
-0.021349458,
-0.0051706904,
0.0094643924,
0.0219673812,
0.0306523684,
-0.0166260526,
-0.005171957,
-0.0152738206,
-0.0042066309,
0.0416634865,
-0.0867213011,
-0.0055768699,
-0.000066821,
2.487e-7,
0.0164137539,
0.038241148,
0.0282223467,
-0.0333755426,
0.0179661978,
0.0021167665,
-0.0516558215,
0.0311551373,
-0.0207881853,
0.0103835287,
0.0411948301,
0.0192454923,
0.0756415501,
0.0201638155,
-0.0771177337,
-0.0068222308,
-0.0411785357,
0.0194907654,
-0.0549893863,
-0.0101957899,
0.0103723602,
0.0809718966,
0.0037360119,
-0.0164385512,
0.0011274868,
-0.0315320864,
0.0742267519,
0.0207629707,
-0.0462446213,
-0.0140445046,
0.0103263585,
0.0195462815,
-0.0537304394,
0.0030312019,
-0.0381171405,
0.0414550267,
0.034890607,
0.0600621216,
0.0204693582,
-0.0097703775,
0.029389767,
-0.027129421,
-0.0351873115,
0.0116203791,
0.0496150032,
-0.0435366817,
-0.0168263074,
0.0284953732,
-0.0194086209,
0.0465275347,
0.0319443196,
-0.0263692755,
-0.046613317,
0.0369746834,
0.0510120504,
-0.0325617678,
-0.0143940272,
-0.0266164914,
-0.0213811882,
-0.0149376579,
-0.0136260213,
-0.0398596749,
-0.0112163182,
0.0562803857,
0.0182736553,
-0.0171039347,
-0.0102118291,
1.969164718e-34,
0.0473405197,
-0.0024823695,
0.021029098,
-0.063487567,
-0.0162395481,
-0.0501368381,
0.0016523744,
-0.0275472607,
-0.006931101,
-0.012683697,
-0.0413008109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14261v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14261v1 | RSM-NLP at BLP-2023 Task 2: Bangla Sentiment Analysis using Weighted and Majority Voted Fine-Tuned Transformers | 2023-10-22T10:55:56 | 2023-10-22T10:55:56 | Pratinav Seth, Rashi Goel, Komal Mathur, Swetha Vemulapalli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper describes our approach to submissions made at Shared Task 2 at BLP
Workshop - Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Social Media Posts. Sentiment Analysis
is an action research area in the digital age. With the rapid and constant
growth of online social media sites and services and the increasing amount of
textual data, the application of automatic Sentiment Analysis is on the rise.
However, most of the research in this domain is based on the English language.
Despite being the world's sixth most widely spoken language, little work has
been done in Bangla. This task aims to promote work on Bangla Sentiment
Analysis while identifying the polarity of social media content by determining
whether the sentiment expressed in the text is Positive, Negative, or Neutral.
Our approach consists of experimenting and finetuning various multilingual and
pre-trained BERT-based models on our downstream tasks and using a Majority
Voting and Weighted ensemble model that outperforms individual baseline model
scores. Our system scored 0.711 for the multiclass classification task and
scored 10th place among the participants on the leaderboard for the shared
task. Our code is available at https://github.com/ptnv-s/RSM-NLP-BLP-Task2 . | [
0.0520160124,
0.039542526,
0.0034471147,
0.0209177453,
-0.0302941334,
0.0093768975,
-0.0541666895,
-0.0197790191,
-0.0043084691,
-0.0546354726,
-0.01528876,
-0.0343911685,
-0.0205671303,
0.0031914273,
-0.0327254869,
-0.0574390218,
0.015967397,
0.0745715499,
0.032540217,
-0.0187408961,
0.032472454,
0.0338766128,
0.0018903147,
-0.0039507458,
-0.0273337197,
0.0250974465,
0.0252639074,
0.0335492082,
0.005735632,
-0.0376473106,
0.033514563,
0.0857373774,
-0.0182031374,
0.0173174758,
0.0000018914,
-0.0529147573,
-0.0192972869,
-0.0022407712,
0.0212621875,
-0.0315462872,
0.0479774065,
0.0125601487,
-0.0119046206,
0.0397679135,
-0.0431269296,
0.013101398,
0.0736554712,
0.0747940093,
0.061551895,
0.0951233581,
-0.0131849684,
-0.053148903,
-0.0345868804,
0.008849632,
0.0174767282,
0.0266065951,
0.009293329,
-0.0370165445,
-0.0203532018,
-0.0240753125,
-0.0131228063,
-0.0203055572,
-0.0158641618,
-0.0095403809,
0.0050100987,
-0.0253326241,
-0.0396496467,
-0.0477304794,
0.0261921138,
0.0276726671,
0.0003131143,
-0.0201426316,
-0.0014774735,
0.0082504265,
-0.02929979,
-0.0268705972,
-0.0114571843,
0.0181756057,
-0.0221738163,
0.0648119077,
-0.0217584558,
0.045884382,
0.0130075077,
0.047955703,
0.0072403718,
0.0420482829,
-0.0152784595,
-0.0439063162,
0.0049479152,
0.0690948218,
0.0051354789,
0.031972371,
0.0487658158,
-0.0191384647,
0.0208479464,
0.0181044005,
0.0455769934,
-0.0422187746,
0.0412509218,
-0.0854990631,
0.0083829351,
0.0125301201,
-0.0074770204,
0.0225785505,
-0.0067440635,
-0.025376983,
0.0132666072,
0.0188966561,
0.012435412,
0.0064831465,
-0.0474669151,
0.008354852,
0.0112006571,
0.036323186,
0.0069254669,
0.0420814864,
-0.0853800997,
0.0009751543,
-0.0349082127,
-0.0248769559,
0.0588562377,
0.008562793,
0.0230829231,
0.0018332612,
-0.0038220368,
0.0874383822,
-0.0352622867,
0.0126173953,
-0.0462992117,
-0.0325883478,
0.0397827812,
0.0153406076,
-0.0063263751,
-0.0269046891,
0.0207537878,
0.0302973688,
0.027943911,
-0.0427746773,
-0.060382124,
0.0361387916,
-0.0340163745,
-0.0690785423,
-0.0050942418,
-0.0583444014,
0.026661776,
0.0372903794,
0.0074197296,
0.0270599462,
0.0340660065,
0.0212937742,
0.0047128582,
0.0493303947,
-0.0086576398,
-0.008130597,
0.0206132159,
0.0034973556,
0.0289086774,
0.0718771294,
-0.0139559973,
0.0501882583,
0.0267022811,
-0.0128618022,
0.025157474,
0.0205286127,
0.0030482004,
-0.0328388177,
-0.017055992,
0.0036694668,
-0.0526140742,
-0.0341001414,
-0.0208253097,
0.0238590669,
0.025459433,
0.0277240444,
0.0483605303,
0.0060600773,
-0.0453023724,
0.0451834984,
-0.0474672168,
0.0119221285,
0.0112944515,
-0.0151375541,
-0.0181731321,
0.0233518519,
-0.0390876271,
-0.0270047989,
0.009072179,
0.0524934903,
-0.015671296,
-0.0260079391,
-0.0192209985,
-0.0223949552,
0.0174872633,
-0.0239998996,
0.0670661703,
-0.0135603687,
-0.0293667614,
0.0412684195,
0.0454307087,
-0.1088711768,
0.003557648,
-0.0399333462,
0.0286021493,
0.0079353042,
-0.0147184618,
-0.0218040813,
-0.0466602854,
-0.0294599887,
-0.0291139949,
0.0491821617,
0.0084305303,
0.0156998206,
-0.0170235932,
-0.0236818977,
0.0339003503,
0.0614862777,
0.0050598611,
-0.0121979574,
-0.0101128388,
0.030969942,
-0.0190801155,
0.0013434598,
-0.0335513279,
0.0019074364,
0.0730575919,
0.0132166725,
0.0265273135,
0.0251931995,
0.0602380633,
0.0428949557,
-0.0308482032,
-0.0296193231,
0.0334155932,
-0.0002435559,
-0.0687965825,
0.0399970636,
0.001528783,
-0.0576574206,
0.00847294,
-0.0605893694,
-0.0204061754,
0.0672303289,
-0.0250625983,
-0.0074154362,
0.0523789451,
-0.0200497918,
-0.0046782186,
-0.03755375,
0.0321140252,
-0.0636578202,
-0.0121587012,
-0.0305801909,
0.0413436219,
0.0063339481,
0.0089497846,
-0.0300615598,
-0.071352616,
0.0503813066,
-0.0041917972,
-0.0625739247,
0.0281999744,
0.0171379037,
0.0217458792,
0.0359460562,
0.01476321,
-0.0421248488,
-0.0459379144,
-0.0910119414,
-0.0136002274,
-0.0155772148,
0.0217147022,
0.0181094706,
0.0213375241,
-0.0107748071,
0.003334946,
0.0025985173,
-0.0233300906,
0.0407951511,
-0.0045731347,
0.0327544063,
-0.0288670622,
0.0399742946,
-0.0232762098,
-0.0060281157,
-0.0194624159,
0.0115354955,
0.0201643482,
-0.0134326434,
0.011213135,
-0.0119877821,
-0.0116073405,
-0.002896752,
0.0193214044,
-0.0874223486,
-0.0135661215,
-0.0266456306,
-0.0034584317,
0.0301208217,
0.0621015131,
0.0219274983,
-0.0124263801,
0.0223130826,
-0.0002688892,
0.0064431615,
-0.0575822219,
0.0235314313,
-0.0138832033,
-0.0163873807,
0.0177834574,
0.0379828736,
-0.0120119536,
-0.0064660432,
-0.0503692664,
-0.0408488922,
-0.0265302863,
-0.0190150291,
-0.0147483256,
0.0159228425,
-0.0140296314,
-0.0003776929,
0.0222953316,
-0.0272174664,
0.058665894,
0.0086183902,
0.0090146316,
-0.1053469554,
0.0143785421,
-0.0311586242,
0.0423018076,
-0.0178284198,
0.009055106,
-0.0253846738,
0.0122802909,
-0.0021231417,
-0.0531499498,
0.0004163243,
-0.0316689126,
0.0051410128,
0.0159874074,
0.0173324216,
-0.0159346964,
-0.0680716634,
0.0016377395,
-0.065249972,
-0.0431277007,
-0.0157366171,
0.033527635,
-0.0236433316,
-0.0103182895,
0.0326910168,
-0.0267752428,
-0.1035408825,
-0.0227016099,
-0.0142335808,
0.0505118147,
0.0179724377,
0.0211692937,
-0.0209718999,
0.0469474122,
0.0049716216,
-0.0477445349,
0.0042656283,
0.0234647095,
0.0218565986,
-0.0327441134,
-0.0425160043,
0.0459941737,
-0.0574513935,
0.012555819,
-0.0585841499,
0.048432339,
0.0094105899,
0.0094717955,
0.11670582,
0.0283639301,
-0.0508602671,
-0.0361256078,
-0.0281328056,
-0.0122655258,
0.0012963389,
0.0391300917,
-0.0365026183,
-0.0144303311,
-0.0115814134,
0.0112354439,
-0.0116006341,
-0.0138573507,
0.0186795965,
-0.1268358231,
-0.0037905148,
-0.0191023014,
0.008869946,
-0.0336612426,
-0.047775995,
-0.0094822971,
-0.0551977344,
0.0051847715,
-0.0285095964,
-0.0072074188,
0.0267332438,
0.0366180576,
-0.0462008677,
-0.0267938543,
0.0347638279,
-0.0436359979,
0.0283990391,
0.0370079279,
0.0601242669,
-0.0619889013,
-0.0348489918,
-0.0141236158,
-0.0506523997,
-0.0163429379,
-0.035301052,
0.0475841723,
-0.0389564,
-0.0458251238,
-0.0406359956,
-0.0189614203,
-0.044127211,
0.0250613298,
-0.026824709,
0.0476891883,
-0.0136040347,
-0.0440848619,
-0.044324778,
0.0282583684,
0.0359184146,
0.0452438965,
0.0114215752,
-0.0553820804,
-0.0156700909,
0.0036698978,
0.0069610258,
-0.0516228899,
-0.0184272025,
-0.0099554388,
-0.038031213,
-0.0302414596,
-0.0334016159,
-0.0511931255,
0.0314862765,
0.039725624,
-0.0183347296,
-0.0206925329,
0.0322761163,
0.0199190713,
-0.0398121737,
0.0110863941,
0.0139022199,
0.0437439308,
-0.0373408049,
-0.0381220765,
0.0657126233,
0.0369769,
-0.0079671647,
-0.0631207824,
-0.0316413678,
-0.0249164999,
0.0378520712,
0.0486312024,
0.018327551,
-0.0387084298,
-0.0182864815,
-0.0445407107,
0.0331393182,
0.0898212418,
-0.0128297471,
-0.0045819064,
0.0439290814,
0.0502225161,
-0.012376043,
0.0351509787,
-0.0034083403,
0.0451964922,
0.0029273992,
-0.0137126334,
-0.0031260971,
-0.0155962603,
-0.0219312795,
0.0090707988,
0.0631973892,
-0.0081952736,
-0.0737084821,
-0.0037414501,
-0.0102800708,
0.0374575034,
-0.0317417048,
-0.0106971906,
-0.0357687958,
0.0046507996,
0.0246772822,
-0.0528252125,
0.0330976546,
-0.0352276191,
0.0181629099,
-0.036656443,
0.0965607986,
0.0657167211,
0.0167195238,
-0.0030345488,
0.0082043679,
-0.0125580849,
-0.021287268,
0.0322304443,
-0.0110207833,
-0.0101339612,
0.0396876261,
0.0001070752,
0.0260747634,
0.0210148133,
0.0594179705,
0.0151466345,
0.0662541837,
-0.0406133868,
0.0080213435,
0.0321376249,
-0.020312326,
0.0572624877,
-0.0115372995,
0.0069285738,
-0.0282249115,
0.010504717,
-0.0529637113,
0.0105922893,
0.0446531326,
-0.018449951,
-0.0291940868,
-0.0136939688,
0.0343854129,
-0.1047114804,
0.0225712433,
0.0708134398,
-0.0155180143,
-0.0246794578,
-0.0075402725,
0.0445922427,
-0.0286932793,
0.0272524673,
0.0195467323,
-0.0512740687,
-0.0397846848,
0.0601584688,
-0.0832426026,
0.0376976877,
-0.0003647172,
0.0175255854,
0.0466143489,
0.0191925392,
0.0772503987,
-0.0474819317,
-0.0123855751,
-0.0658163354,
0.015331204,
-0.0144574167,
-6.547145743e-33,
0.0005268207,
-0.0070560914,
-0.0602013394,
-0.0088639362,
-0.00792416,
-0.0121908151,
0.0101918625,
0.0144103514,
-0.0112537602,
0.0311873369,
-0.0323337093,
0.0063994396,
0.0127837583,
0.0532178469,
0.0551234111,
-0.0213108547,
0.027038509,
0.0280354153,
-0.0046791313,
0.0142374914,
0.0395957008,
0.043765638,
0.0815454125,
-0.0791060552,
0.0146040879,
-0.0013149213,
-0.0645873025,
0.0100232903,
0.0284049846,
0.0327451117,
-0.0094477935,
0.0642929152,
0.0541075207,
-0.0293300357,
0.0102835624,
0.0277250502,
-0.0086044641,
-0.0165819656,
0.000014782,
0.0592918694,
0.0107558761,
0.0139063606,
0.0292028878,
0.0056754062,
-0.0579728559,
0.0424387306,
0.0204031765,
0.0040089958,
0.0265898593,
-0.0673302934,
-0.044991985,
0.0254799929,
-0.0003648702,
-0.0085360808,
-0.0036876462,
0.0316176638,
0.0011678013,
0.0176495593,
-0.0444821939,
0.0080905231,
0.0067000608,
0.016998766,
0.004848395,
-0.0052205897,
-0.0111482283,
0.0436826088,
0.0229712091,
-0.0087235672,
0.0099136587,
-0.0001333449,
0.0234084297,
0.0106942747,
0.0266928487,
0.0569873825,
0.0109604429,
-0.0501843728,
-0.0198777653,
0.0380470678,
0.0921468586,
0.0302500669,
0.0512076356,
-0.0029293804,
-0.0196689889,
-0.033173956,
0.0300874263,
-0.038304843,
-0.0300138202,
-0.0154161584,
-0.0055348752,
-0.0295196064,
-0.0221746638,
0.0335090086,
0.0071642823,
-0.0427575558,
-0.0211992804,
0.0333497673,
-0.0406695157,
0.0452488884,
0.0059120567,
0.0018231594,
-0.0350416303,
-0.0171120856,
-0.0168942083,
0.0579459593,
-0.0320698358,
0.0222895965,
0.0419928394,
0.0311423261,
-0.0847322643,
-0.0049965219,
-0.0118108457,
0.0209015775,
-0.013307821,
0.1032366306,
-0.0244141836,
0.0032968496,
-0.0132412687,
0.0223315619,
0.0140625788,
0.0710740983,
0.0208273195,
0.016071314,
0.004509022,
-0.0145876026,
-0.0199885331,
-0.0288107861,
0.002632217,
-0.0285152085,
-0.0173892733,
-0.0331192203,
0.0104993461,
-0.0513285697,
2.803e-7,
0.0515821613,
0.0852025151,
-0.0002534976,
-0.0428791307,
-0.0093121333,
0.0535040647,
-0.0203533266,
0.01184671,
0.0085535878,
0.0453757197,
0.0044015502,
-0.0079580629,
-0.0045293802,
0.0393861271,
-0.1249763593,
-0.0136898886,
-0.0631836504,
-0.0156727098,
-0.0122258514,
0.0520335883,
0.0383676849,
0.1059022471,
0.0338435099,
-0.0306576323,
-0.0405281074,
0.0030429594,
0.0470879152,
-0.0493431017,
-0.0032241498,
0.0095619559,
0.0145716835,
-0.0174036641,
-0.0104544833,
-0.028821392,
-0.0039977673,
0.0007969404,
-0.0091881463,
0.0348962769,
-0.0185160041,
-0.029636642,
0.0350641534,
0.0327882022,
0.0107575944,
-0.0268625878,
0.0394739173,
-0.0634241924,
-0.081362173,
-0.07128001,
-0.03765288,
-0.0036383511,
0.0630339757,
-0.0014810663,
-0.0334385335,
0.0119588934,
-0.0106024016,
-0.0419907197,
-0.0781672522,
-0.0879965872,
0.0228093155,
0.0042818282,
-0.0117815379,
-0.0389804691,
0.0126094529,
0.0260511134,
0.0320625901,
-0.0351421162,
0.05511152,
2.107102552e-34,
0.0793923661,
-0.0143661546,
-0.0017712587,
0.015945917,
0.0128660575,
0.0191471986,
-0.0173657369,
-0.0133439945,
0.0193868447,
-0.0414005853,
0.0241903216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14248v1 | From Static to Dynamic: A Continual Learning Framework for Large Language Models | 2023-10-22T10:18:53 | 2023-10-22T10:18:53 | Mingzhe Du, Anh Tuan Luu, Bin Ji, See-kiong Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The vast number of parameters in large language models (LLMs) endows them
with remarkable capabilities, allowing them to excel in a variety of natural
language processing tasks. However, this complexity also presents challenges,
making LLMs difficult to train and inhibiting their ability to continuously
assimilate new knowledge, which may lead to inaccuracies in their outputs. To
mitigate these issues, this paper presents DynaMind, a novel continual learning
framework designed for LLMs. DynaMind incorporates memory mechanisms to
assimilate new knowledge and modular operators to enhance the model inference
process with the newly assimilated knowledge, consequently improving the
accuracies of LLMs' outputs. Benchmark experiments demonstrate DynaMind's
effectiveness in overcoming these challenges. The code and demo of DynaMind are
available on GitHub: https://github.com/Elfsong/DynaMind. | [
0.0479080714,
0.0641124025,
-0.020058915,
0.0250936393,
-0.0116649074,
0.0333977602,
-0.0386555493,
-0.0387157314,
0.0099652549,
-0.0749229863,
-0.0253047831,
-0.0256523397,
-0.0043646726,
0.0266094729,
0.0197112896,
-0.0390435234,
0.068881534,
-0.0471944846,
-0.0156522337,
0.0065096938,
0.0028462131,
-0.002209933,
-0.0193354599,
0.0440750718,
-0.0125585645,
-0.0093586082,
-0.0018310858,
-0.0240341555,
-0.0063498747,
-0.0139101176,
0.0074147121,
0.0342166759,
0.031913925,
0.0580318421,
0.0000021221,
-0.0439647548,
0.00064522,
-0.0259245336,
-0.0506836995,
0.0081838788,
0.0647953078,
0.0000087755,
-0.0047751418,
0.0140398396,
-0.034547843,
-0.0433821157,
0.0367655158,
0.0124475546,
0.0474986844,
0.0484056994,
0.0101843607,
-0.041040197,
0.0578196272,
-0.0118264351,
-0.0206294004,
-0.0309495926,
0.0429936536,
0.0103051374,
0.008621593,
-0.0267638508,
0.015746031,
0.0438345708,
0.0063335993,
-0.0114820432,
0.0205386262,
0.0469308496,
-0.0349730253,
-0.0197168291,
-0.0171807669,
0.054936301,
-0.0304654464,
-0.0425817594,
0.0064560594,
0.0059410767,
-0.0286973082,
-0.0098842289,
-0.0677864775,
0.0332022943,
0.0128985308,
0.019526571,
0.0420511514,
-0.0063695814,
0.0357023142,
0.0357513614,
-0.0511680208,
0.0438056067,
0.0309607461,
-0.0009293359,
-0.0375597998,
-0.0205282196,
-0.0410668291,
-0.0357734077,
0.004998717,
0.062803939,
-0.0088830991,
0.0294842962,
-0.0288215559,
-0.0349073447,
0.0343957022,
-0.0909245536,
0.005581161,
0.0371641368,
-0.0051562996,
0.0573781095,
-0.0429101177,
0.03895716,
-0.0120419096,
0.0064758533,
-0.028216403,
-0.0207181741,
-0.075522311,
-0.023378253,
-0.0162434224,
0.0695082098,
0.0501488559,
-0.0565781295,
-0.0291970223,
0.0453951322,
0.0220502075,
0.0179194342,
-0.015793141,
-0.0009266311,
-0.0271402728,
-0.0145161366,
-0.0248956252,
0.0504299589,
-0.0129467072,
0.0144037548,
-0.0317875668,
-0.0246115923,
-0.0033143407,
0.0209498778,
0.0023537648,
-0.0173072498,
0.0014098464,
0.0704894215,
0.0008079006,
-0.038191963,
-0.0479629077,
0.0165522136,
0.0133143216,
-0.0832828209,
-0.0320229866,
-0.0688065812,
0.0275518876,
0.0121388417,
0.0056058895,
-0.0386854373,
0.0244019255,
0.0022956771,
-0.0379325189,
0.0712899342,
0.008058764,
0.0039346563,
0.0239864681,
0.019058479,
0.0159002505,
0.0848236755,
0.0282098763,
0.0038754547,
0.0099633131,
0.0170731135,
0.0096113738,
0.028502021,
0.0056138318,
0.0107372301,
-0.0692250729,
0.00426888,
0.0479826257,
0.0094665447,
0.0020458181,
0.0452746414,
-0.0045897928,
0.0266052429,
0.0618779771,
0.0075750817,
0.0242786594,
0.0488636866,
0.0531649888,
-0.0075653554,
0.0397858098,
-0.0008340874,
-0.0729394481,
0.0001465034,
-0.0388109311,
0.0164865591,
-0.0297114328,
0.0463731736,
-0.0100993523,
-0.0210265871,
0.0000220743,
-0.0257588364,
0.0142716672,
0.0125834802,
0.0728165582,
-0.0187684242,
-0.023509413,
0.0928812176,
0.0334095769,
-0.0208344664,
-0.0075983591,
-0.056791719,
0.0433256291,
0.0661495775,
0.0468272269,
-0.0561889224,
-0.062372338,
-0.02197331,
-0.0304065477,
0.0129833696,
0.029254077,
-0.0030524477,
0.0268220287,
-0.0471236408,
0.0020665359,
-0.0056317756,
0.0369309597,
0.0225884784,
0.0453235283,
0.0425520875,
0.0226016026,
-0.0072797081,
-0.0080334898,
0.044224292,
-0.0360995606,
-0.0292500015,
-0.0057999091,
-0.0347967111,
-0.0189047772,
0.0039718081,
-0.0373679325,
-0.0004407721,
0.0329258367,
-0.0358067788,
-0.0186583363,
0.0144258235,
-0.0296294671,
-0.0200803708,
0.0667763576,
0.0373845585,
-0.0051003639,
-0.0100356052,
-0.0313888751,
-0.0309573337,
0.0486772135,
-0.0305873305,
0.0735192075,
-0.0566322692,
0.0334439985,
-0.0292329658,
0.0464195609,
-0.014905896,
0.0758751109,
-0.0137860728,
-0.0161493924,
0.0382981859,
0.0093470188,
-0.0219808538,
-0.0174219795,
-0.0172397234,
0.0308487862,
0.0065114736,
0.0124685271,
-0.0083001582,
-0.0108681554,
-0.0420373976,
-0.0302651096,
-0.1055629253,
0.0035593596,
-0.019205559,
-0.0175095759,
-0.0104331812,
0.0175488219,
-0.0261496697,
-0.0135362567,
0.0233542677,
-0.0135656018,
-0.000997061,
-0.0031091992,
0.0001419894,
0.0305347722,
-0.0358058028,
-0.0439665914,
-0.0118856207,
-0.0145460833,
0.052242592,
-0.0277471002,
-0.03547135,
-0.0511596352,
0.0111990878,
-0.0422570221,
0.0438830629,
-0.0061060521,
-0.0215040911,
-0.0260049514,
-0.0381887481,
0.0623228066,
0.0538814329,
0.008088138,
-0.0034583856,
0.0756611228,
-0.0448322967,
-0.0587789863,
0.0216114782,
-0.0277640596,
0.0139938043,
-0.0106271533,
0.0197719038,
-0.0135253919,
0.0762496665,
-0.0035274513,
-0.0137368003,
0.0011042777,
0.022147445,
-0.0291526373,
-0.0132067511,
-0.0234313831,
-0.001577962,
-0.0195275936,
-0.007647878,
0.0038552301,
-0.0675545633,
0.0674631447,
-0.034047626,
-0.0087267598,
-0.0444435999,
-0.023553798,
-0.0299192611,
0.0630523115,
0.003241966,
-0.0012303523,
0.0213976465,
-0.0517169051,
-0.0095877675,
-0.0206750669,
0.0197774041,
-0.0175159816,
0.0659100264,
-0.0380809866,
0.0273161996,
-0.0053414847,
-0.0074660066,
-0.0696764588,
-0.0381952934,
-0.0578013398,
0.023712635,
-0.0127862561,
-0.0309092216,
-0.0357885808,
0.0078889998,
0.0372045822,
0.0381653048,
-0.0046523716,
0.0019963419,
-0.0373234265,
0.0449515395,
0.0491416901,
0.0188229289,
0.0410192013,
-0.0193715766,
0.0421029218,
0.0400701389,
0.0256838091,
-0.0019854829,
-0.0406465381,
-0.0133642005,
0.0092220036,
-0.0354033224,
0.0013115603,
0.0062796031,
-0.0100749424,
-0.101898253,
0.0027218629,
0.1389141083,
0.0394502729,
-0.0536969453,
0.003126607,
-0.0168611649,
0.0304298196,
0.0445923992,
0.0496207662,
-0.0695898011,
-0.0389137827,
0.0304660294,
-0.0024666172,
0.004431996,
-0.0314119197,
-0.0276254099,
-0.0858866274,
0.0169580188,
0.0249509066,
-0.0090039372,
0.0035033461,
-0.0227107015,
-0.0113265188,
0.0150293745,
-0.0103377691,
0.0176094584,
-0.0230538119,
-0.0209154766,
-0.0073510441,
-0.0619300082,
-0.0330104753,
0.0243622176,
-0.0445737317,
0.0877069309,
0.0321710147,
0.0321157798,
0.0062919101,
-0.0132577205,
0.0722954348,
-0.0316062942,
-0.0004362865,
-0.0423521176,
0.0225058682,
-0.0053680171,
-0.0006298946,
0.0074604764,
0.0015070579,
-0.0252257232,
-0.0168566294,
-0.0060267141,
0.0832767487,
-0.012737019,
0.0042462847,
-0.0239904579,
-0.0195120499,
-0.0061042095,
0.0538463555,
0.030281337,
-0.016481841,
-0.0425826423,
-0.0096669486,
-0.0517716371,
0.0189385451,
-0.024980545,
0.0076556113,
-0.0355852768,
-0.0129644405,
-0.0423058495,
0.0217156298,
0.0324220285,
0.0170224495,
0.0231634881,
0.0251575559,
0.0151972957,
-0.0059073851,
-0.0609121658,
0.0095640998,
-0.0194801651,
0.0247629769,
-0.0396544859,
-0.0155887231,
0.0742811486,
-0.0050630127,
0.0076612053,
0.0463777222,
-0.1102808639,
-0.0762435347,
-0.0029811936,
0.0492941439,
0.0249044597,
0.0716119632,
-0.046823211,
-0.039454177,
0.0140882386,
-0.0053754295,
-0.0592716411,
0.0022774874,
0.0030934229,
0.0242338479,
0.0330658033,
0.0438874885,
-0.0184622481,
-0.0119983526,
0.0040883641,
0.0400975533,
-0.0040750913,
0.0145132588,
0.0097669298,
-0.0190591384,
0.0091501987,
-0.0043691443,
0.0028284569,
-0.0328756385,
0.0178378951,
-0.0220132694,
-0.0299609341,
-0.0373957045,
0.0416206755,
0.0334572047,
0.0298667476,
-0.0227086861,
-0.0008677281,
0.0209230557,
0.0509561412,
0.0079504587,
0.0156018706,
0.0011107537,
-0.0251856912,
0.0565993115,
-0.0043780473,
-0.0301836394,
0.0096404385,
-0.0140101071,
0.0385388471,
-0.0351012871,
0.0343993716,
-0.0078004883,
-0.037013974,
-0.0775226578,
0.001134537,
-0.0489591286,
-0.1023459285,
-0.0284933746,
0.0564721264,
0.0685594305,
0.0109848808,
0.0417199843,
-0.031997107,
-0.0140449442,
-0.0177136194,
0.0159946326,
-0.021305507,
-0.0157128591,
0.0234684832,
0.0065734922,
-0.0433550701,
0.0380867384,
0.0772990361,
0.0017979899,
0.0467369072,
-0.0094403205,
-0.0050920723,
-0.0382790342,
-0.0046552587,
0.0106679583,
0.0308310799,
-0.0407473892,
0.0578945763,
-0.024916552,
-0.0725693107,
0.0216974244,
-0.0270036384,
-0.0072202077,
-0.024759084,
-0.0031022625,
0.0342656896,
0.0127812056,
-0.0330793709,
-0.0330794603,
0.0298477989,
0.0246393569,
-0.0285964534,
-0.004241806,
-6.66248231e-33,
-0.035710521,
-0.0025444534,
0.0221857484,
-0.0098915603,
-0.0707526356,
0.0014689164,
-0.0216413531,
0.0142129455,
0.0121095926,
-0.0196040962,
-0.0003486431,
0.0337445289,
0.0118569061,
0.0093560982,
0.0276528336,
-0.0322470106,
0.0353641361,
0.0014698928,
-0.0076594786,
0.0225946121,
0.024408171,
0.0752835497,
0.0556021556,
-0.0405825116,
-0.0234231725,
0.0429370739,
0.0108304126,
0.0474387743,
-0.0096302126,
0.0466286726,
-0.0515737198,
0.0197037626,
0.0118931215,
-0.0210270453,
-0.0371496119,
0.0123983603,
-0.0707921833,
-0.0043683867,
0.0211595669,
0.0187800415,
0.0033945078,
-0.0261254776,
0.0272183605,
0.0042722709,
0.0106378077,
0.01578255,
0.030272685,
-0.0528845303,
-0.0400617532,
-0.0180056319,
-0.0770823434,
0.0283584911,
-0.0146838371,
0.0174144469,
0.0064575388,
-0.0044395081,
-0.0111249788,
0.0000277222,
-0.0711826757,
-0.0148132034,
0.0213569086,
0.0525568947,
0.0420274697,
0.0062675662,
0.0320085622,
0.0572768636,
0.0356584825,
-0.0435324796,
-0.0345369801,
0.0083731506,
0.0637171939,
0.0360433199,
0.0047463495,
-0.0137847504,
0.0337403826,
-0.0114387767,
-0.0327061862,
-0.0234789699,
0.068620652,
0.0736974403,
0.0405771323,
0.0151479049,
-0.0180347916,
-0.0269352105,
-0.0290648118,
0.0284627546,
-0.0544599891,
-0.0019740742,
0.0247943196,
0.0406231768,
-0.032025829,
-0.0266745854,
0.0381160118,
-0.0752409473,
-0.0260459092,
0.0252928343,
0.0054579824,
0.0220291708,
0.012393713,
0.0442882776,
-0.0450448394,
-0.0388774499,
-0.0267717019,
-0.0093584508,
-0.0132201407,
-0.0196271054,
0.0007088982,
0.0617193952,
-0.0617350638,
-0.0060607456,
-0.0122550996,
0.0153732328,
0.0168161094,
0.0409498401,
0.009690878,
0.0065904651,
-0.0057052486,
0.0217841007,
0.0262468942,
0.0020913195,
-0.0299964864,
0.0253203344,
0.0410917141,
0.0523546636,
-0.0299576763,
-0.0252525564,
-0.0502808318,
-0.0240483712,
0.0123390295,
-0.0790344179,
-0.0007612531,
0.015371291,
2.788e-7,
0.0211801622,
0.0731820539,
-0.003299261,
-0.0335651413,
0.0514956154,
0.0107160034,
-0.0358298384,
0.0014996649,
0.029426977,
0.023496259,
-0.0040373234,
0.0464641713,
0.042634815,
0.0192172378,
-0.0906803831,
-0.0004312886,
-0.0227242168,
-0.0054483367,
-0.0840111598,
-0.0206300672,
0.0181918852,
0.1133567765,
0.0165093411,
-0.0034672942,
0.0125217568,
-0.0820470527,
0.0874098539,
0.0143574215,
0.0074940706,
0.0121657941,
0.0347400382,
0.0346597582,
-0.0032973865,
-0.00174193,
-0.0119423512,
0.0517776459,
-0.0222283341,
0.0630587041,
0.0015582417,
-0.0206320975,
0.0191602092,
-0.0424077809,
0.0129756881,
-0.0809857622,
0.0829875171,
-0.0617157966,
-0.0172386337,
-0.0622080006,
0.0279205553,
-0.0094183013,
0.006324748,
-0.0127607221,
-0.0264465511,
0.0299116969,
0.0365170278,
-0.0187364612,
-0.0423045009,
-0.105524011,
-0.0457868688,
-0.0073859165,
-0.0748603716,
-0.0336454622,
-0.032966651,
-0.0333992429,
0.0166316759,
-0.052813258,
0.0279792137,
2.758319994e-34,
0.0606974363,
0.0012066445,
-0.0060488973,
0.0891952738,
0.0365590006,
-0.0166845918,
-0.0010024047,
0.0124087175,
0.0006869401,
-0.0981992707,
-0.0138615509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18343v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18343v2 | PHD: Pixel-Based Language Modeling of Historical Documents | 2023-10-22T08:45:48 | 2023-11-04T11:30:01 | Nadav Borenstein, Phillip Rust, Desmond Elliott, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | The digitisation of historical documents has provided historians with
unprecedented research opportunities. Yet, the conventional approach to
analysing historical documents involves converting them from images to text
using OCR, a process that overlooks the potential benefits of treating them as
images and introduces high levels of noise. To bridge this gap, we take
advantage of recent advancements in pixel-based language models trained to
reconstruct masked patches of pixels instead of predicting token distributions.
Due to the scarcity of real historical scans, we propose a novel method for
generating synthetic scans to resemble real historical documents. We then
pre-train our model, PHD, on a combination of synthetic scans and real
historical newspapers from the 1700-1900 period. Through our experiments, we
demonstrate that PHD exhibits high proficiency in reconstructing masked image
patches and provide evidence of our model's noteworthy language understanding
capabilities. Notably, we successfully apply our model to a historical QA task,
highlighting its usefulness in this domain. | [
0.0315874219,
0.0920604989,
0.0222948641,
0.053497728,
-0.0314819179,
0.0020650243,
0.0228177831,
0.0387192219,
-0.0329865851,
-0.0417110771,
0.0437334292,
-0.0336599946,
0.0402963124,
0.0102819689,
0.0091583012,
-0.0519683287,
-0.0046881591,
-0.0322393738,
-0.0167139694,
0.0095066354,
0.0120990761,
-0.0082145836,
-0.0025266348,
-0.008184813,
-0.0641225725,
-0.0272680689,
-0.0166945551,
0.0209833365,
0.0029716266,
0.0285868403,
-0.0345284827,
0.0429288149,
0.0593401454,
0.0543072298,
0.0000019146,
-0.0149657195,
-0.0347031616,
0.0101181064,
0.0026594168,
0.0383184664,
0.1106063277,
-0.0417362899,
-0.0643388927,
-0.0521167107,
-0.0504688844,
-0.0103741372,
0.052306965,
0.0601979718,
0.0347266532,
0.0839037746,
-0.0275929254,
-0.0124240443,
0.0312352087,
-0.0072219414,
-0.0072718044,
-0.0272161532,
0.0143653676,
0.0158899296,
-0.0139059024,
0.0069487216,
-0.0004891969,
0.0398121513,
-0.0106106205,
-0.0392479412,
-0.023528425,
0.0199623443,
0.0028105658,
0.0205699038,
-0.0135817435,
0.0090111764,
-0.0600925423,
-0.0108789671,
0.0253144726,
0.0133346524,
-0.0483506285,
0.0087614618,
-0.0332238562,
-0.0121890744,
-0.0314798877,
0.032477811,
-0.0071983486,
-0.0503161959,
0.0005342674,
-0.0090853898,
-0.0391038172,
0.0228168275,
0.0002813819,
-0.0072253868,
-0.0545684621,
0.017132042,
-0.0024041459,
-0.0249659698,
0.0523304604,
0.0264959037,
0.0582916178,
0.0162915736,
-0.0337922275,
-0.0767029673,
0.0105977617,
-0.0113134757,
-0.0123995468,
0.0085113095,
-0.0426345579,
0.0728895813,
-0.0412596874,
0.0671730489,
0.0133060161,
0.0671277046,
-0.0390909463,
0.0033029986,
-0.0305024274,
-0.014333602,
-0.0515327305,
-0.0000227701,
-0.034498658,
-0.030605834,
0.0202252902,
-0.0369989797,
0.0218942221,
0.0125398953,
-0.005588219,
0.0036796771,
-0.0489301309,
-0.0395549089,
-0.0085225152,
0.0005997561,
0.0275655575,
0.0085708108,
-0.030079687,
-0.0501687154,
0.0056678439,
0.0223746374,
0.0282185003,
0.0149574224,
-0.0135257598,
0.0110159554,
-0.0554679632,
-0.016157629,
-0.0177491345,
0.0172355436,
-0.0311083663,
-0.0265033972,
0.0320040435,
-0.0632196069,
0.0165623091,
-0.0383332223,
0.0174822994,
-0.0322782099,
0.0135835577,
0.032686606,
-0.0425006635,
0.085883081,
-0.0126672331,
-0.0211154278,
0.0612891577,
-0.0000876792,
0.0447337739,
0.0575378053,
0.056569811,
0.0522712395,
0.0463177934,
0.0186065156,
0.0229143482,
0.0686463416,
0.0096425312,
-0.0258343592,
-0.0143799828,
-0.0316926986,
0.0341173485,
0.0109056374,
0.0689851344,
0.0693778917,
-0.029103063,
-0.0351419635,
0.0563498475,
0.0505253635,
0.0003425589,
0.0166454744,
0.0009877566,
0.0087912148,
0.0310843717,
0.0221625138,
-0.0234534983,
-0.042284213,
0.0623890646,
0.0074380208,
-0.0371946096,
0.0078449361,
-0.0125874327,
-0.0077782148,
0.0020512594,
0.0024219048,
0.0001853431,
-0.0101645766,
0.085207209,
0.0251925252,
-0.0707887188,
-0.0027907472,
-0.0280124992,
-0.0477901287,
-0.0081336852,
-0.0524386838,
0.0402232707,
0.080028452,
0.1141541377,
-0.0559743568,
0.0466189422,
-0.0023323284,
0.0209352151,
0.0662469342,
0.0268459488,
-0.0119862957,
0.0267722066,
-0.0734207854,
-0.0199427065,
-0.0249167532,
-0.0072514326,
0.021544721,
0.0215276442,
0.0233827326,
-0.0228179675,
-0.054061763,
-0.0401238054,
0.0533264019,
0.0145170512,
-0.0873140544,
-0.0154356621,
0.0305507071,
-0.003748466,
0.0257840771,
-0.0264128894,
-0.0065737623,
0.0366988704,
-0.063179329,
0.0228085686,
-0.0181663502,
-0.0365008563,
-0.0435841829,
0.0298779327,
-0.0572632365,
-0.0123305945,
0.0423389338,
-0.0595073551,
-0.027349731,
0.0235709269,
-0.0268361494,
0.0321075544,
-0.0541094355,
-0.0061317398,
-0.0017281956,
0.013727461,
-0.0643690377,
0.0519524738,
-0.0006406271,
-0.0261916034,
0.0477649979,
-0.0051429388,
0.0036037711,
-0.0102377282,
-0.0025568206,
-0.0279106312,
-0.0183584634,
0.0325979814,
0.0018040781,
0.0157489181,
-0.0228520371,
-0.0492361151,
-0.0700199679,
-0.0123031279,
-0.0387289748,
-0.0161717702,
0.0294781066,
-0.0296347477,
0.0101760197,
-0.0438187271,
-0.0254002325,
0.0008463456,
0.0047879359,
-0.0111703826,
0.0453047566,
0.0050690337,
0.0159252938,
-0.0339740552,
-0.0238316059,
-0.0045966809,
0.0279170424,
0.0138006769,
-0.0523195192,
-0.0323386304,
0.0214122906,
0.0396453999,
0.0526429527,
-0.0402128547,
-0.0121213095,
-0.0038149317,
-0.0504436456,
0.024838075,
0.1037840471,
0.0138453115,
0.0157315712,
-0.0037274444,
-0.0352996849,
-0.0217623189,
0.0025606705,
-0.0316124521,
-0.0130857453,
0.0224317349,
-0.0575591996,
-0.0029022109,
0.0417362042,
-0.0035535716,
0.0647563785,
-0.0273260735,
-0.003199019,
-0.0248681027,
-0.0093732569,
-0.0428391099,
0.0074794549,
-0.0102735702,
0.0700524151,
-0.0704116672,
-0.0410984084,
0.0285273846,
-0.0253242012,
-0.0058435942,
-0.0267921872,
0.0043879002,
-0.0163032524,
0.0542644188,
0.0228959452,
0.0193876904,
-0.0050082589,
-0.0446823016,
-0.0517816506,
-0.0268690363,
0.0173765626,
-0.0681710988,
0.0269793458,
-0.04322033,
0.0402492695,
-0.022625979,
-0.011922244,
-0.019945614,
-0.0845691934,
-0.0111614466,
-0.0176850669,
-0.0476863086,
-0.0056113154,
-0.0273793563,
0.0642744899,
0.0002015282,
0.0684751645,
0.0042921766,
0.0166158285,
-0.0319983177,
0.0955269784,
0.0608584695,
-0.006750288,
-0.0191452559,
-0.0108947242,
0.0221267156,
0.0198172498,
0.0481793694,
0.0386363789,
-0.0242672898,
-0.0022486185,
0.0034267853,
0.0133144269,
-0.0126822712,
-0.0001642043,
0.0373881459,
-0.0631894395,
-0.0164695848,
0.0671892911,
0.022286864,
-0.039250955,
-0.0635994598,
-0.0185221713,
-0.0188725162,
-0.0098858662,
0.003854075,
-0.091420278,
-0.0072584515,
0.0136400368,
0.0087230597,
-0.0040441421,
-0.0007893849,
-0.0148631409,
-0.0815001428,
0.042388916,
0.0072515421,
-0.0208433084,
-0.0154753225,
-0.0529193021,
-0.0093947817,
-0.0209436957,
-0.0430040136,
-0.0068279221,
0.0178825855,
-0.0121952491,
-0.0070113633,
-0.0036758049,
0.0065293224,
-0.0026063034,
-0.0167213473,
-0.0107402932,
0.0867038965,
0.0512119271,
0.0074991789,
-0.0376350321,
0.003885872,
-0.0126688015,
0.0126242526,
0.0000831344,
0.1108999327,
0.0063629062,
-0.0138858762,
0.017563168,
0.0373647474,
-0.0224907286,
-0.0190988071,
0.0220648423,
-0.0227081273,
0.0053958967,
-0.0157575067,
-0.0094783772,
-0.0018332999,
0.0273771193,
0.0103100538,
0.0248422381,
-0.0067833848,
-0.0871967599,
-0.0615299046,
0.0866322741,
-0.0780837238,
-0.0298054833,
0.0344629809,
-0.024066098,
-0.0803597793,
-0.0620755628,
-0.0386395566,
0.0056492831,
0.040631894,
0.0250601713,
-0.0098825945,
0.0267942045,
-0.0128784878,
-0.0807862505,
0.0264219176,
-0.0653096065,
0.0205970965,
-0.0577879362,
0.0097175743,
-0.0079534743,
-0.0124302823,
-0.0039136792,
0.0325564891,
-0.0976305008,
-0.0213694945,
0.044696141,
0.0738435686,
0.0224845558,
0.0370868556,
-0.020843897,
-0.0351354294,
0.06126187,
0.0110094938,
0.0422294438,
-0.0182369966,
-0.0129511375,
-0.0298273563,
-0.0460266769,
0.0170120317,
-0.0249600243,
0.0173911769,
0.0021238266,
-0.0376650095,
-0.043655619,
-0.0112787373,
0.0124098081,
-0.0461826138,
0.0632843971,
-0.0164077543,
-0.0010654429,
-0.007734891,
0.0032608251,
-0.022045983,
0.0101194736,
-0.0070901453,
-0.0237801429,
-0.0139063066,
-0.019477183,
0.0156053072,
0.0016635177,
-0.0401940942,
0.0659114718,
-0.0159932077,
-0.0059307264,
-0.0005913444,
0.0493365936,
-0.0010913676,
0.007175901,
0.0110160969,
0.0792067945,
-0.0079190936,
0.066684112,
0.0197224617,
0.0362393223,
0.0091717001,
-0.0043501016,
0.0193132758,
0.0131414402,
-0.0857755467,
-0.0284318384,
-0.0506150573,
0.0277376473,
0.0808391422,
-0.0313301347,
0.0573669486,
0.0063483831,
-0.0187942237,
-0.0179576594,
-0.0138162617,
0.0430580005,
-0.0046197739,
0.0025744711,
0.0354071707,
0.0220248085,
0.0354959294,
0.0566544607,
-0.0097601535,
-0.001272495,
0.0297438595,
-0.0272669569,
-0.0594122522,
0.0037495806,
-0.0020176852,
-0.0009441533,
-0.01618631,
0.0147772301,
-0.0157700125,
0.0052322247,
0.0155100143,
0.0160455555,
-0.0090757571,
0.0115902452,
0.0178081077,
0.0163164791,
-0.039018508,
0.0070451563,
-0.0481755212,
0.0453978106,
0.0137495371,
-0.0441910736,
0.0065823779,
-5.550701957e-33,
-0.0135848336,
-0.0396162271,
0.0338528529,
0.0197074153,
0.0170475245,
0.0121520823,
-0.0202998649,
-0.0326495618,
-0.0079822876,
-0.0088771535,
-0.0437619202,
-0.0056231339,
0.043659199,
0.0327389352,
-0.0473383218,
0.0421918407,
0.0710346028,
-0.0330152214,
-0.0156203415,
0.0058049387,
0.0073479023,
0.0144381616,
0.0377817973,
-0.0313452445,
-0.0035197071,
-0.0085249189,
-0.0417645462,
-0.0240780227,
0.0662313402,
0.0336538553,
-0.0335229076,
-0.0258513521,
0.0337766297,
-0.0253795478,
-0.0093007637,
0.0847479776,
-0.0922027528,
0.0261602048,
-0.0224418156,
0.0865963027,
0.0137906214,
-0.025668662,
-0.0189026464,
-0.031782344,
0.0038026788,
-0.0219628531,
0.0667219684,
-0.0264685899,
-0.0105749946,
-0.0089306617,
-0.0276417602,
0.0241307393,
-0.0064248946,
-0.0367458276,
0.052363459,
0.017726101,
0.0266644191,
0.0339429304,
-0.0872512311,
0.0163410958,
0.0488414615,
0.0498780385,
0.0638741404,
0.0184233543,
-0.0079277856,
0.0130656464,
0.0182942785,
0.0174886584,
-0.015818648,
0.011590939,
0.03279946,
0.0012920988,
0.0417301767,
0.0677854419,
0.0823437795,
-0.0055909702,
-0.0197254885,
0.0500244088,
0.0034434376,
0.0530910753,
0.0289358664,
0.0038851036,
0.0296606608,
0.0202725548,
-0.0428096354,
-0.0367874876,
-0.0269007571,
-0.0047931359,
0.0336405039,
0.0537482947,
-0.0176469795,
0.0258355327,
0.0508023277,
-0.0620323941,
-0.0207151007,
-0.0407311767,
-0.031791158,
0.0548972785,
-0.0324422307,
0.0355629213,
-0.0425913744,
-0.0354082361,
0.0560948737,
0.0551620908,
-0.0094675543,
0.0002114479,
0.0225925036,
0.01366009,
-0.0565153845,
0.0084162075,
0.0166490041,
0.0006864834,
0.0230909977,
0.0177666172,
0.0075594033,
-0.0137394387,
0.0155525329,
0.0079154242,
0.0098119667,
-0.0031639633,
0.0184125192,
-0.036121536,
0.0036486359,
0.0270762444,
-0.0315872096,
-0.0041240663,
-0.0117984544,
0.0036896584,
0.0181790087,
-0.0310382396,
-0.0073234076,
0.0046245242,
2.373e-7,
0.0196583662,
0.0272690374,
0.0575536415,
-0.0002427122,
0.0054621524,
0.0238905028,
-0.013139151,
0.0021641783,
-0.0264627207,
-0.0565539934,
0.0399736799,
-0.0029250006,
0.0880177245,
0.0093348967,
-0.0902697742,
0.0071023651,
0.0003273667,
-0.0283368938,
-0.0566514283,
0.0258931164,
0.0242446773,
0.0953428373,
-0.0243523736,
-0.0724689588,
0.0091388784,
-0.0367151424,
0.0449688397,
-0.0071302145,
-0.02757922,
0.0142023107,
0.0642460957,
-0.0091279959,
-0.0200423356,
0.0431850255,
-0.0142205181,
0.0080440734,
0.0552366972,
0.0608174317,
-0.0198571682,
0.0129276747,
-0.0186914634,
-0.0090000192,
-0.0138909165,
-0.0850561857,
0.0505170748,
0.0332879089,
0.0240600184,
-0.0600624345,
-0.0575262606,
0.0228314027,
0.0241316147,
-0.0412682518,
-0.0260763112,
0.0302101243,
0.0394215025,
0.0085494826,
-0.0142180305,
-0.0538070165,
-0.002326848,
-0.0057231076,
0.0062535102,
0.000898434,
-0.0234138984,
-0.0235622805,
0.0003005424,
-0.0396884903,
-0.0004442494,
1.941713252e-34,
0.0223664418,
-0.0142294001,
-0.0250016805,
0.0283380095,
-0.0059132269,
-0.020618936,
-0.0108702127,
-0.0105899274,
-0.0114336209,
-0.0798085406,
0.0000454758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18342v1 | MIRACLE: Towards Personalized Dialogue Generation with Latent-Space Multiple Personal Attribute Control | 2023-10-22T08:44:26 | 2023-10-22T08:44:26 | Zhenyi Lu, Wei Wei, Xiaoye Qu, XianLing Mao, Dangyang Chen, Jixiong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Personalized dialogue systems aim to endow the chatbot agent with more
anthropomorphic traits for human-like interactions. Previous approaches have
explored explicitly user profile modeling using text descriptions, implicit
derivation of user embeddings, or utilizing handicraft prompts for ChatGPT-like
models. However, textual personas are limited in describing multi-faceted
attributes (\emph{e.g.}, \emph{language style, inner character nuances}),
implicit embedding suffers from personality sparsity, and handicraft prompts
lack fine-grained and stable controllability. Hence, these approaches may
struggle with complex personalized dialogue generation tasks that require
generating controllable responses with multiple personal attributes. To this
end, we propose \textbf{\textsc{Miracle}}, a novel personalized dialogue
generation method through \textbf{M}ult\textbf{I}ple Pe\textbf{R}sonal
\textbf{A}ttributes \textbf{C}ontrol within \textbf{L}atent-Space
\textbf{E}nergy-based Models. ttributes \textbf{C}ontrol within
\textbf{L}atent-Space \textbf{E}nergy-based Models. Specifically, our approach
first disentangles complex personality into multi-faceted attributes.
Subsequently, we employ a conditional variational auto-encoder to align with
the dense personalized responses within a latent joint attribute space. We have
also tailored a dedicated energy function and customized the ordinary
differential equations sampling method to offer flexible attribute composition
and precise attribute control. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
\textsc{Miracle} outperforms several strong baselines in terms of personality
controllability and response generation quality. Our dataset and code are
available at \url{https://github.com/LZY-the-boys/MIRACLE} | [
0.0333140157,
0.0597129203,
-0.0250465702,
0.0036729125,
0.0095471144,
-0.0001718642,
0.0375603251,
-0.0410638116,
0.0149807837,
0.0201281458,
-0.0159451421,
-0.0417946205,
-0.0304714721,
0.0921812207,
0.0586717464,
-0.0867388025,
0.0005066848,
-0.0053917943,
0.0181171559,
-0.0327285677,
0.0315285586,
0.0110827824,
-0.0151434802,
0.0492795669,
-0.0177142769,
-0.0245384704,
-0.0682736486,
0.0090894764,
0.0403835736,
0.0148614431,
0.0160693228,
0.0536455624,
0.0217377599,
-0.0079916399,
0.0000023367,
-0.0049558235,
0.0035796205,
-0.013507924,
0.0034742162,
-0.0061347042,
0.073069334,
0.0533701666,
0.0021215689,
0.0044959686,
-0.0269684885,
-0.025931133,
0.0624016076,
0.0536163487,
0.0909186229,
0.0573714972,
-0.0158611443,
-0.0222284272,
0.0006910702,
-0.0199037809,
0.0702960268,
-0.0168301798,
-0.0020092654,
-0.0324209444,
0.0332338996,
0.0259945784,
-0.0063463971,
0.0172918122,
0.0288100801,
-0.0291749332,
0.0512470193,
0.0434207506,
0.0081539182,
-0.0396730714,
-0.0089643225,
0.083144851,
0.0289788581,
0.0092355795,
0.0055969618,
-0.0160578396,
0.0350417569,
-0.0041806055,
-0.0080073634,
0.0109781781,
-0.0208301544,
-0.0298225023,
-0.018517267,
0.0371933207,
-0.04270133,
-0.0246637408,
-0.0161646716,
-0.0089709358,
0.0431001782,
-0.0203742795,
-0.0303016771,
0.0011120171,
-0.0390390679,
-0.0599092431,
0.0253537651,
0.0161794964,
-0.0251916666,
-0.0081170509,
-0.0820657238,
-0.016996488,
-0.0354335681,
0.0163549241,
0.0386712439,
0.0380246416,
-0.0050900043,
-0.0180857163,
0.015825795,
0.0695965067,
-0.0428999923,
-0.0138802473,
-0.0194420945,
0.0097173546,
-0.0326971151,
-0.0468697883,
-0.0471437052,
0.0223130845,
-0.0188510027,
-0.0219754111,
-0.0548377447,
0.0789139941,
-0.0012581866,
-0.0041234409,
0.007558383,
0.0605846271,
-0.0338108726,
0.0394548476,
-0.018090168,
-0.0124977473,
-0.0698945671,
-0.0122432811,
0.0509916134,
-0.0192593597,
-0.022731781,
0.0395367257,
0.0392918326,
-0.0169734303,
-0.008972411,
0.0737370774,
-0.0461736172,
-0.0135326507,
0.0471705981,
-0.0599183254,
-0.0325381309,
-0.0535097681,
-0.0049726623,
-0.0122840581,
0.046255175,
-0.0245353952,
-0.0130853876,
-0.0647525191,
-0.013859719,
0.0072059478,
0.0004383367,
0.0534455292,
0.0185886808,
-0.0051015723,
0.0439208858,
0.0037723847,
-0.0171288885,
0.0137494691,
0.0318236686,
0.045391079,
-0.0163780302,
-0.0040971539,
0.0338401459,
0.0033644103,
0.0132813659,
-0.0071838712,
-0.0109020351,
-0.0306384265,
-0.0029119963,
0.053568989,
0.0296963174,
0.0518675596,
-0.0588422865,
-0.0242369343,
0.0706969798,
0.0369065814,
0.0072259712,
0.0367384329,
0.0595965721,
0.0432144627,
0.0214658529,
-0.0008776871,
-0.0095219482,
0.0503353402,
-0.01083735,
-0.0005809403,
0.0139280548,
0.021748662,
-0.0418345854,
-0.0315616429,
0.0507790558,
-0.0056666881,
0.0354002789,
-0.0220209938,
0.0008794453,
-0.0009295173,
-0.036082685,
0.0069246222,
0.0078158788,
-0.0682312325,
-0.0155319702,
-0.0150651373,
0.0180305094,
0.1105699167,
0.0227672104,
0.0123588862,
-0.0162670873,
-0.0158243794,
-0.0322997347,
0.0471779667,
0.0087174755,
-0.0103594102,
0.0179185551,
-0.0339185148,
-0.0071020653,
-0.0485815555,
-0.0111241629,
0.056632027,
-0.031004753,
0.0261082854,
-0.0050800801,
0.0621514134,
0.0558079556,
-0.0010645967,
-0.0597171672,
0.0040954668,
0.0151907178,
0.0134845115,
0.0313456543,
0.0168194063,
0.0070118569,
0.0052668294,
-0.0110701779,
-0.0405409075,
-0.0450485609,
0.0484783053,
-0.0267475024,
-0.0443011262,
0.0300259609,
-0.0192696452,
0.0091936868,
-0.0083384719,
0.0096250474,
-0.0547109172,
0.0359949283,
-0.06805861,
0.0032700882,
-0.0390889086,
0.0031241262,
0.0235200841,
0.0513842292,
0.000692158,
0.0346311666,
-0.0095286053,
-0.0317904316,
0.0244466886,
0.0807460546,
-0.0154674798,
-0.0601176433,
-0.0276888702,
-0.0029953155,
0.0295258518,
0.0197785031,
0.0188355558,
0.0334594473,
-0.0294053294,
-0.0625388771,
-0.060916312,
-0.0142012676,
0.0158019122,
-0.0420218371,
-0.0108980834,
0.0392179005,
-0.0194248259,
0.0259380825,
-0.0802350789,
0.0167547092,
0.040544536,
-0.0098733911,
0.0524197966,
-0.0054765698,
-0.025112262,
-0.0349670053,
0.0135904774,
0.0057922499,
0.0347440802,
-0.0115264356,
0.041157797,
-0.0118387649,
-0.0284617916,
-0.045073662,
0.0146557614,
-0.0134803718,
-0.0691708475,
0.0116110062,
-0.0274224617,
0.0524357036,
0.0409754924,
0.0479972698,
0.069676958,
-0.0011093585,
-0.007342075,
-0.0605147034,
0.0393429734,
-0.0276381839,
0.0357792154,
0.0242162719,
-0.0105926841,
0.0200450402,
0.0457915813,
0.0350467972,
0.0336926728,
-0.1071138605,
0.0953127965,
0.0458362624,
-0.0830199718,
0.044153396,
0.040338438,
-0.0350642316,
0.0196807403,
-0.0059738285,
-0.0140467389,
0.1100652069,
-0.0116632888,
-0.0341242701,
0.016409589,
0.0027635249,
0.0188479014,
0.0270487405,
-0.0011544429,
0.0289457235,
0.0410151631,
-0.0142508866,
-0.03214553,
0.0378444418,
0.0274582915,
-0.0353695937,
-0.0222044438,
0.0166522488,
-0.016433334,
0.0274873041,
-0.032255698,
-0.0352768525,
-0.0647430494,
0.0272400994,
-0.0197952054,
0.0191416051,
-0.0471412688,
-0.0223445036,
0.0051549249,
0.0041864594,
-0.0077096624,
-0.0684663728,
-0.0088183563,
-0.0424515195,
0.0265279934,
0.053999044,
0.020702228,
-0.0330581963,
-0.0459630229,
0.0171296895,
0.0164647214,
-0.0284319073,
-0.0059874519,
0.0184031334,
0.0356893986,
0.010975291,
0.0044736434,
0.0015615629,
-0.0125599978,
0.076243192,
-0.0028186,
-0.0406058058,
0.1177062541,
0.006559236,
-0.0128663247,
0.018582901,
0.0174420364,
0.057723172,
-0.0194953959,
0.0505606271,
-0.0466634445,
-0.0161932874,
-0.0260686167,
0.0356273465,
-0.0250280276,
-0.0224323925,
-0.0272794906,
-0.06299036,
0.0287312288,
0.0160686951,
-0.0538607128,
-0.0286174323,
0.0203101952,
-0.0109930513,
-0.0129904523,
0.0023954348,
-0.0061317151,
0.0230483655,
0.0078046666,
-0.0031735206,
0.0159291457,
-0.0316100642,
-0.0035194207,
-0.0194931012,
0.0772948042,
0.0442956761,
0.0526397862,
0.0201466959,
-0.0268116333,
-0.0714769065,
0.0160314068,
-0.0019205351,
-0.0083266152,
0.0291867647,
-0.0048436173,
-0.0123228058,
-0.045078937,
0.0752558932,
0.0001317835,
0.0098709054,
-0.0134624103,
0.0135770142,
-0.0403102152,
-0.0125864912,
-0.0404375196,
0.026653925,
0.0337307267,
0.048412215,
0.0133546237,
-0.0891411677,
-0.0645448491,
-0.0366523303,
-0.0064531709,
-0.0395545214,
-0.0686652735,
-0.0123994052,
0.0045567867,
-0.0735721439,
-0.0798643976,
-0.059496779,
0.0012694682,
0.0480395891,
-0.0406426378,
-0.0432133339,
-0.0130365919,
0.0112417238,
-0.0305700842,
-0.0141230682,
-0.026496416,
-0.0039184219,
-0.0060603563,
-0.0553331077,
0.0441441312,
-0.1026059389,
-0.0028606185,
-0.0044606668,
-0.0507581346,
-0.073025845,
-0.0102175344,
0.0567216128,
0.015252945,
0.0794590563,
-0.0183386933,
-0.0611082241,
0.0325857736,
-0.0019146982,
-0.0280318353,
0.0264101978,
0.0206356235,
0.0744769126,
-0.0096088471,
0.01488066,
-0.0172710065,
0.01869574,
-0.0307671353,
0.0216668714,
-0.0038671831,
-0.1090278998,
0.0138914641,
0.0145382509,
-0.0474603921,
-0.0161828753,
-0.0143790999,
-0.013755599,
-0.0365682021,
-0.0500943474,
-0.0019139939,
-0.0590570383,
-0.0348805748,
-0.000275914,
-0.0014610448,
0.0028847069,
-0.0611549206,
-0.0191385783,
0.0382866897,
-0.0448572971,
-0.0098656965,
-0.011098003,
0.0447179638,
0.0050288765,
0.0128598763,
0.0098889926,
0.0112220738,
-0.0239837393,
0.0065843323,
-0.0139571475,
0.0802061036,
-0.0078906808,
-0.0096295597,
-0.0209252797,
0.0463274159,
-0.053186994,
-0.0029773882,
-0.0142123718,
0.0427518897,
-0.0072893817,
0.0488276556,
0.0666321814,
-0.0317047834,
0.0085989777,
-0.017354127,
0.0533402264,
0.0168064814,
-0.0330411568,
0.0238378718,
-0.0061521693,
-0.011027175,
-0.0615726002,
0.0490515381,
0.024690954,
0.014708966,
-0.0504019447,
-0.0043383059,
-0.0642362237,
-0.0032237133,
0.0032813947,
0.0176808164,
0.0055971299,
-0.0057940674,
-0.0496076904,
-0.0356451981,
0.0232591443,
0.0370194986,
-0.0166279282,
0.0107342433,
0.0377246067,
0.0331831351,
-0.0353657007,
-0.012176319,
-0.0412852354,
0.0138208931,
-0.0043830187,
-0.0368055403,
0.0015798135,
-6.567066699e-33,
-0.057602305,
-0.0086590387,
0.0163705703,
0.0100721596,
-0.0692145005,
-0.0316868685,
-0.0578622669,
0.0062311408,
0.0115726199,
-0.0065611741,
-0.0054220473,
-0.0225104745,
-0.0049532088,
0.0282845497,
0.0332140774,
0.0124329804,
0.0609058328,
0.0059679388,
-0.0223873761,
0.0814877823,
0.0370307192,
0.0000542339,
-0.0067586838,
-0.0692306012,
0.0005226391,
-0.0577983111,
-0.0145013016,
-0.0026976452,
0.0439176038,
0.055730179,
-0.0414107293,
0.0137645304,
-0.0152364653,
0.0114232292,
-0.0252401512,
0.0129283965,
-0.0573510379,
-0.0490980372,
-0.0211225413,
0.0062297215,
-0.0294450186,
-0.073688589,
0.0008131262,
-0.0217919238,
0.0042001195,
0.0008168452,
0.0296805426,
0.0164185259,
0.0244034473,
-0.0334890448,
-0.0525166392,
0.0027320522,
-0.0386124663,
-0.0392422862,
-0.0176711772,
0.0189704113,
0.012374498,
-0.001187761,
-0.0169743001,
0.0340101533,
-0.0267250016,
-0.0625225753,
0.0166295059,
0.0430111438,
0.0439068414,
0.0291936416,
0.0754741207,
0.0190620925,
-0.0483434312,
0.0079991417,
0.0191175025,
0.0258906484,
-0.0045466493,
0.0766130537,
-0.0342716128,
-0.0234759692,
0.0043627596,
0.0410293937,
0.0762824714,
-0.0327082239,
0.0203402229,
0.0374224223,
-0.041665297,
-0.0096687982,
-0.0127503248,
-0.0165992901,
-0.0162047558,
-0.0598844886,
0.0031972062,
0.0103955204,
-0.0375239477,
-0.0698913932,
0.0375791825,
-0.0133808954,
0.0111704692,
0.0027514505,
-0.0578343831,
0.0317155533,
-0.0237375256,
-0.0011147476,
0.0069242315,
-0.0356314927,
0.0710443109,
-0.0268031787,
0.0062391083,
0.0577352121,
-0.0431055836,
0.0326256491,
-0.0205823649,
-0.0121729514,
-0.0112214861,
0.0262223203,
-0.0098553831,
0.0102331573,
0.0239664447,
0.00467599,
-0.0406813286,
0.0495501868,
0.0007456414,
0.0202729851,
-0.055067379,
-0.0134172915,
0.0527214296,
0.006096906,
-0.0366486683,
0.0249866527,
-0.0386200175,
-0.0332475789,
0.0179341063,
-0.056350641,
0.0065721772,
0.0086940406,
3.051e-7,
-0.0510309935,
0.0000598125,
0.0320308991,
0.0236886013,
0.0357937887,
0.0641852915,
0.0144995572,
0.0318003744,
0.0034608038,
-0.0176955182,
0.0172779039,
0.0487544984,
0.0467635728,
-0.0060447142,
-0.0402331464,
-0.0037585355,
-0.0133240009,
-0.01203092,
-0.0182340369,
-0.0083608385,
0.101086095,
0.0383009501,
0.0467325337,
0.0135744764,
0.022101704,
0.0482328869,
0.0829395503,
0.02994732,
-0.0175119042,
0.0158278495,
-0.0016637134,
-0.0130732087,
0.0110195223,
-0.0034818889,
0.0135990083,
0.0082848528,
0.0257090386,
0.0805199966,
-0.0138345193,
-0.0412623063,
0.0167054702,
0.0233614594,
-0.0129487943,
-0.0142070772,
0.0344223306,
-0.028545035,
-0.0307076145,
-0.0349163674,
-0.0251037553,
-0.0076838676,
0.0231803078,
-0.0326755419,
-0.0385124087,
0.0350593887,
-0.0083645992,
0.0029526709,
0.0260663275,
-0.0614796914,
0.0122473529,
-0.0154447732,
-0.0920211524,
-0.0231211931,
-0.0251381546,
0.005749193,
0.0638399869,
-0.0119372681,
-0.0084113013,
2.73186609e-34,
-0.0103679597,
0.0147441206,
0.0094854096,
0.0079430649,
0.0056502256,
0.0166555494,
0.0578866228,
0.010672017,
0.073299095,
-0.0664750189,
-0.0528138131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14225v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14225v1 | Customising General Large Language Models for Specialised Emotion Recognition Tasks | 2023-10-22T08:09:13 | 2023-10-22T08:09:13 | Liyizhe Peng, Zixing Zhang, Tao Pang, Jing Han, Huan Zhao, Hao Chen, Björn W. Schuller | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has gained tremendous attention
over the past year. Previous studies have shown the astonishing performance of
LLMs not only in other tasks but also in emotion recognition in terms of
accuracy, universality, explanation, robustness, few/zero-shot learning, and
others. Leveraging the capability of LLMs inevitably becomes an essential
solution for emotion recognition. To this end, we further comprehensively
investigate how LLMs perform in linguistic emotion recognition if we
concentrate on this specific task. Specifically, we exemplify a publicly
available and widely used LLM -- Chat General Language Model, and customise it
for our target by using two different modal adaptation techniques, i.e., deep
prompt tuning and low-rank adaptation. The experimental results obtained on six
widely used datasets present that the adapted LLM can easily outperform other
state-of-the-art but specialised deep models. This indicates the strong
transferability and feasibility of LLMs in the field of emotion recognition. | [
0.03382558,
0.0743765607,
-0.0029275205,
0.0318307504,
0.0097555351,
0.0380526669,
0.0344893336,
-0.0137725379,
0.0387212671,
-0.0333423875,
-0.0923893079,
-0.0453388691,
-0.0336373299,
0.0346063003,
-0.0095423171,
-0.0686504915,
0.0360990949,
0.0310613792,
0.0328251794,
-0.0171481315,
0.020648811,
0.0389235839,
-0.0185985491,
0.03001054,
-0.0170292649,
-0.0163993333,
-0.0445190333,
0.0374496803,
0.0315242223,
-0.0178595595,
-0.0054978896,
0.0745421797,
0.048183389,
0.0478073806,
0.0000021,
-0.0346831866,
-0.0212896727,
-0.0324531607,
-0.0572961047,
-0.0095907208,
0.0710148141,
-0.009914184,
-0.0361067504,
-0.0014721934,
-0.0123518007,
-0.0166060831,
0.0743332431,
0.0325707234,
0.0812890008,
0.1107310876,
-0.0214465279,
-0.0057351249,
-0.0001054496,
-0.050920058,
0.0196536854,
-0.061899852,
0.0282460395,
0.0045224647,
0.0136737861,
0.0078954855,
-0.0564397275,
-0.0002440497,
-0.014282533,
-0.0167585127,
-0.0165390745,
-0.0238287412,
-0.0069621918,
-0.02460864,
-0.0255114138,
0.0985075161,
-0.0304102991,
0.0079814447,
-0.014795511,
-0.011530038,
0.0135876043,
-0.0346888155,
-0.0319976583,
0.0113099935,
0.0389431864,
0.0029188823,
0.0043479577,
0.0004912784,
0.0031054171,
0.0163079519,
-0.0354604833,
-0.0217596758,
-0.0142867649,
-0.0054269843,
0.0286506191,
-0.0188224502,
-0.0314871073,
-0.0080311028,
-0.010285683,
0.0089258421,
-0.0208409522,
0.0077020838,
-0.0399448983,
-0.0120670162,
-0.0192275606,
-0.0119794142,
0.0121427635,
0.0441990681,
-0.0514266491,
0.058273416,
0.0104248226,
0.0502153784,
-0.0156583935,
0.0115148434,
-0.0523237251,
-0.0240051933,
-0.0552774481,
0.0207022093,
0.0043245396,
-0.016409019,
-0.0583966821,
-0.0460198857,
-0.0651155189,
0.0323895663,
-0.000013407,
0.007827837,
0.0028710009,
-0.0046360968,
-0.0349233821,
-0.0460004695,
0.0151694817,
0.0525244176,
0.0086230095,
0.0334126763,
-0.0058666696,
-0.1000246108,
-0.0067381747,
0.0291787256,
0.0417952426,
-0.006720148,
0.0409287922,
0.0371143855,
-0.0195521154,
-0.0332706906,
0.006664976,
0.0312149748,
-0.0509692878,
-0.0443595238,
-0.001385006,
-0.023471877,
0.0501261987,
-0.0131585402,
0.028201187,
-0.0049010869,
0.0023771944,
-0.0420053899,
-0.0314149559,
0.0752824321,
0.0097743971,
-0.0083950879,
0.0007987272,
0.0071030948,
-0.0129402429,
0.0480070934,
0.0172654353,
0.0572327636,
0.0288329981,
-0.0345997289,
0.0271739233,
0.0451829806,
-0.0263199285,
-0.0126706744,
-0.0140592698,
-0.027246967,
0.0070087598,
0.0346511528,
0.0360990055,
0.0228191167,
-0.0125289578,
-0.0177099071,
0.0611365139,
0.0355533212,
0.0344386622,
0.0463778041,
-0.0224046074,
0.0414576828,
0.0269195605,
-0.061924722,
-0.0387410261,
0.0185587183,
-0.0202564951,
-0.0282852333,
0.0021094368,
0.0163363628,
-0.0498561077,
-0.0450776257,
-0.0159464572,
-0.0090820212,
-0.019246038,
0.0519085266,
0.0290964209,
-0.0366859101,
-0.0436690189,
0.0087320544,
0.0544550121,
-0.0302651096,
-0.01871459,
-0.051091928,
0.0248894375,
0.04860292,
-0.0099885669,
-0.0675230548,
-0.0230918229,
-0.0293580815,
0.0104818409,
0.0430225842,
0.0332041644,
-0.0015000688,
0.057795126,
-0.0765881464,
0.0234714337,
0.0192854311,
0.008890558,
0.042412132,
-0.0421551727,
0.0138700958,
-0.0051170075,
0.0041469317,
0.0089823622,
0.0127143608,
-0.0109029114,
-0.0443882793,
0.0296784621,
0.013614716,
0.0405545346,
-0.0009900454,
-0.0060010138,
-0.052538123,
0.0286781508,
-0.0164154563,
0.0033088536,
0.0028499824,
-0.0525152534,
-0.0686337575,
0.0308574345,
0.0081919059,
0.0050614839,
0.0516477823,
-0.0746396109,
-0.0493505485,
0.0293637365,
-0.0080977166,
0.0098013831,
-0.0263253246,
0.0184634272,
-0.0101754731,
0.064598076,
-0.0104292668,
0.0285659786,
0.0233625714,
-0.0394314863,
0.022228783,
0.03887894,
-0.0391371958,
-0.04163884,
-0.0708822235,
0.0433787853,
-0.0153574962,
0.0224871598,
0.0050751627,
0.0269762836,
-0.0576703697,
-0.0775918737,
-0.1457866579,
0.0247210953,
-0.0078336261,
-0.0002258134,
0.0145349894,
0.0213194769,
-0.0587663911,
-0.0346360616,
-0.0376054458,
0.0424242839,
0.014393067,
-0.0144715048,
0.0074579027,
-0.0119688781,
-0.0134501485,
-0.0764463544,
0.0141832409,
0.0071699289,
0.0459750555,
-0.0464817472,
-0.0193982851,
-0.0140136536,
0.005839027,
-0.0130974241,
0.033215519,
-0.0190505777,
-0.0615276769,
-0.0168464519,
-0.0176181737,
0.0237536337,
0.0831558555,
0.0232564658,
0.0883659869,
-0.0017521884,
0.0110161407,
-0.044304356,
0.0454885922,
-0.0252878461,
-0.0418148153,
-0.0316638984,
-0.0126862926,
-0.0204891879,
0.0530101322,
-0.0057912748,
0.0205672197,
-0.0469452366,
0.0054140952,
0.0232473407,
-0.0374194272,
-0.0490228496,
0.0171025805,
-0.0318092182,
-0.022141654,
0.0021608195,
-0.0508300103,
0.0133921644,
0.0076412731,
-0.0442492366,
-0.0608451068,
-0.0430948064,
-0.0431266874,
0.080867961,
-0.0350162536,
0.0119444281,
-0.0030335139,
0.0086069759,
-0.0278790966,
-0.0301505122,
-0.0341191292,
-0.0335449316,
0.0291983895,
-0.0218647644,
-0.0266486257,
0.0172262453,
-0.0272155441,
-0.0364740156,
-0.0792755485,
-0.0574694276,
0.0058666221,
-0.0107356859,
-0.011903882,
-0.0221823771,
-0.0194834657,
0.0385988355,
-0.012760737,
-0.0066576824,
0.0141129736,
-0.0337029323,
0.0374567397,
0.0539445542,
0.0455370508,
0.002586497,
-0.0153334551,
0.0607458614,
0.0219866429,
0.0232280083,
0.0107601918,
-0.0294658579,
0.0325984731,
0.01665527,
0.0452062003,
-0.0054523097,
0.0004240063,
0.0489948913,
-0.0315494202,
0.0434748195,
0.1297276765,
0.0122587355,
-0.0566088334,
0.0071072895,
-0.0130124707,
0.0131270336,
0.0011916383,
0.0140262786,
-0.0544020198,
-0.0557095781,
0.0045490987,
-0.0057377354,
0.0030120551,
-0.0035608704,
-0.0070726704,
-0.075789772,
0.0187838916,
0.0071649202,
-0.0179405808,
-0.0201412328,
-0.0253814347,
0.0395105444,
-0.0368311368,
0.0311083663,
-0.038489338,
0.0147035737,
-0.0578833409,
0.0505599678,
0.0113772899,
-0.0726581067,
0.03609607,
-0.0232917685,
0.0887955427,
0.002475329,
0.066149421,
-0.0150994845,
-0.0059460327,
0.0357126333,
0.0174856186,
-0.0083602956,
-0.0132419504,
0.0148597127,
-0.0074140429,
-0.0230643079,
-0.0013249782,
0.0367450938,
-0.0344538949,
0.0270483997,
-0.0088291662,
0.0412270688,
-0.0124630891,
-0.0193473678,
-0.0106382947,
0.004421209,
0.0194249153,
0.0710488632,
0.0100514507,
-0.0627962649,
-0.0020937747,
-0.0182749629,
-0.0005795955,
0.0168564431,
-0.048391778,
0.0056381654,
-0.0091612581,
-0.0166943893,
-0.0392331704,
-0.0312088132,
0.0095803561,
0.0086265774,
-0.0257777572,
-0.0408114977,
-0.0346987434,
0.0198993664,
0.0110405618,
0.082558997,
-0.0207878128,
-0.0104362899,
-0.0584996529,
0.0170931835,
0.0268480852,
-0.0317478105,
-0.0130935982,
0.0060098208,
-0.0612851828,
-0.0450234786,
0.0108437585,
0.0212672111,
0.0176490974,
0.008883263,
0.0150283771,
-0.0610016584,
0.0314734317,
0.0228241384,
0.0044663865,
0.0023643321,
0.0449234918,
0.0274292883,
-0.0427487269,
0.0246619154,
-0.050681185,
0.0768377855,
0.0482182726,
0.0117938695,
0.0108743627,
-0.0666795596,
-0.0108250957,
0.0071685826,
0.028321214,
0.0329082534,
-0.0671046972,
-0.0289024301,
0.000589952,
-0.0017601216,
0.0130540533,
-0.037654236,
-0.0100198574,
0.0450560376,
-0.0132618044,
-0.0314465836,
-0.0419879705,
0.0092147738,
0.0218655597,
-0.0395407155,
0.0548780002,
0.0280463062,
-0.0096442206,
-0.0042748787,
0.0470703468,
-0.032468345,
0.0273837838,
0.0170246791,
-0.0079873605,
-0.0078654559,
0.0500997901,
0.0053902031,
-0.0574942864,
-0.0061516999,
0.0569432266,
-0.0259185005,
-0.0331644937,
-0.0258351453,
0.0362653397,
0.0397048742,
-0.0103968726,
0.031469617,
-0.0150847053,
0.0158112179,
-0.0440241322,
-0.0019297386,
0.0105029484,
-0.0194723587,
0.0237060543,
0.0154778734,
-0.0409317389,
0.0207063742,
0.0326700695,
-0.0056228088,
0.064672932,
0.0164589658,
0.0178219751,
-0.060664285,
0.0231585354,
0.0749269128,
-0.0143900514,
-0.0049906387,
0.043046549,
-0.0255499762,
-0.0431104824,
0.0137809375,
-0.0606687181,
-0.0064656185,
-0.025625227,
0.017469883,
0.0487079173,
-0.0398732871,
0.0325060189,
-0.0160610788,
0.0129710203,
-0.0186080672,
-0.0235621594,
-0.0209972132,
-5.975063867e-33,
0.0039670574,
0.041068878,
-0.0450077765,
-0.0402510092,
-0.0199866705,
0.0226316992,
-0.0155778322,
-0.0002615769,
-0.037618462,
0.0076814755,
-0.0222650897,
0.0023238608,
0.0197977852,
0.0238389,
-0.0335794799,
-0.0219487697,
0.0464990996,
0.0123935668,
-0.0024295319,
0.0189380925,
0.0356353894,
0.0325138383,
0.0579352714,
-0.0533601865,
0.0101826331,
0.0031587842,
-0.038616959,
0.0226422809,
0.0664209574,
0.0687707737,
-0.0298940018,
0.0650595874,
0.0241578259,
-0.0337452553,
-0.0015837688,
0.0715056509,
-0.0146782612,
0.0279170368,
-0.0178679321,
-0.0022241019,
-0.003623643,
-0.0428723693,
-0.0059337192,
0.0076345722,
-0.0148344273,
-0.0143634817,
0.0096630622,
-0.0252971053,
0.0213394072,
-0.0167069733,
-0.0383986793,
0.0275755934,
-0.0252728052,
-0.0419853665,
0.0169777274,
0.0648261309,
0.0018423193,
0.0223192964,
-0.024446778,
0.0115602789,
-0.0016648088,
0.0236751251,
0.0142980758,
0.0287711062,
-0.0146042379,
0.0684046522,
0.022528749,
0.0006498717,
0.0002054875,
-0.0054497928,
0.0306020305,
0.0488250963,
0.0318853892,
0.0586804897,
-0.0068480778,
0.0162097383,
-0.0483976454,
0.0074515552,
0.0699136481,
0.0146962842,
0.0405967794,
0.0347326957,
-0.0276680458,
0.0201299656,
-0.0305832718,
0.0168397836,
-0.0286671966,
-0.0031088786,
0.0395201705,
0.0106309019,
-0.0064107222,
-0.0341248624,
0.0476368852,
-0.0390609764,
0.013184906,
0.0310667548,
-0.0144174797,
0.0382674336,
0.0112349661,
0.0321405753,
-0.0240783487,
-0.0572852679,
0.087826632,
-0.0179679561,
0.0161898695,
0.0031817879,
-0.0058556194,
0.0401977636,
-0.0529447161,
-0.0074057509,
-0.0147014968,
0.0217758622,
-0.026091205,
0.0687260702,
-0.0207675174,
0.0070054559,
-0.0210983139,
0.0377528556,
0.0049881455,
0.0484551862,
0.0095566297,
-0.0330412686,
-0.0123774959,
0.0228307638,
-0.0534029566,
0.011704159,
-0.0086350515,
-0.0246144459,
0.0183166303,
-0.0334812403,
-0.0054659038,
-0.0118021825,
2.759e-7,
-0.017078232,
0.0469108894,
0.0014711708,
-0.0449313633,
0.0433493443,
0.0542524345,
-0.0050502066,
0.0667544082,
0.0489718504,
-0.0391416922,
0.0446660817,
0.0257017836,
0.068861194,
-0.0265980847,
-0.0836565718,
-0.0255123675,
-0.0454314575,
0.0160536133,
-0.0239965487,
0.0411784574,
0.0671807081,
0.1611821353,
0.0161560327,
-0.005080055,
0.0257345513,
-0.0216379855,
0.0351378806,
-0.0624004006,
-0.0376261435,
0.047223188,
0.0401281826,
-0.0085909655,
-0.0074751992,
-0.0021813605,
0.0308002234,
0.0369256623,
0.0154649653,
0.0703766569,
0.00376416,
-0.0328511596,
0.0088403244,
0.0520490184,
-0.0228937604,
-0.0539448485,
0.0693755746,
-0.056234125,
-0.0380847789,
-0.0693386123,
-0.0064746463,
-0.0094280504,
0.0293656439,
-0.046772968,
-0.0246474557,
0.0294535458,
0.0294257607,
-0.0336217992,
-0.0430993922,
-0.0803449824,
-0.0061402777,
-0.0022392075,
-0.0882519037,
-0.0462678187,
-0.0232950281,
-0.0027458651,
0.0403106101,
-0.0636403635,
0.0289022569,
2.109793562e-34,
0.0145627102,
0.0065634917,
-0.0162272099,
0.018810641,
0.0255942382,
0.0129643464,
-0.0190964825,
-0.0053185765,
0.0445804819,
-0.1177903712,
-0.0042117266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14211v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14211v2 | LUNA: A Model-Based Universal Analysis Framework for Large Language Models | 2023-10-22T07:26:21 | 2024-06-13T21:40:02 | Da Song, Xuan Xie, Jiayang Song, Derui Zhu, Yuheng Huang, Felix Juefei-Xu, Lei Ma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.SE | Over the past decade, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has had great success
recently and is being used in a wide range of academic and industrial fields.
More recently, LLMs have made rapid advancements that have propelled AI to a
new level, enabling even more diverse applications and industrial domains with
intelligence, particularly in areas like software engineering and natural
language processing. Nevertheless, a number of emerging trustworthiness
concerns and issues exhibited in LLMs have already recently received much
attention, without properly solving which the widespread adoption of LLMs could
be greatly hindered in practice. The distinctive characteristics of LLMs, such
as the self-attention mechanism, extremely large model scale, and
autoregressive generation schema, differ from classic AI software based on CNNs
and RNNs and present new challenges for quality analysis. Up to the present, it
still lacks universal and systematic analysis techniques for LLMs despite the
urgent industrial demand. Towards bridging this gap, we initiate an early
exploratory study and propose a universal analysis framework for LLMs, LUNA,
designed to be general and extensible, to enable versatile analysis of LLMs
from multiple quality perspectives in a human-interpretable manner. In
particular, we first leverage the data from desired trustworthiness
perspectives to construct an abstract model as an auxiliary analysis asset,
which is empowered by various abstract model construction methods. To assess
the quality of the abstract model, we collect and define a number of evaluation
metrics, aiming at both abstract model level and the semantics level. Then, the
semantics, which is the degree of satisfaction of the LLM w.r.t. the
trustworthiness perspective, is bound to and enriches the abstract model with
semantics, which enables more detailed analysis applications for diverse
purposes. | [
0.000262785,
0.0739308521,
-0.018141605,
0.0592352711,
-0.0367790088,
-0.0209874921,
-0.0163717363,
-0.0259042941,
0.0161201283,
-0.0270744041,
-0.0145449843,
-0.0277308449,
-0.0161017962,
0.0700607523,
0.0336927399,
0.0193902869,
0.067997776,
-0.0434800461,
-0.011869289,
0.0218180604,
-0.0203376226,
-0.0195986126,
0.0326053984,
0.0669068396,
-0.0065570683,
-0.0374539904,
-0.0058527505,
0.0016337483,
0.0094796699,
-0.0152542479,
0.0010593896,
0.0529928133,
0.0015437267,
0.0365453698,
0.0000022898,
-0.0594636574,
-0.0307079889,
0.0453962721,
-0.008917856,
0.0437772796,
0.0133150863,
0.0314425491,
-0.0313366093,
0.0129211564,
-0.0150784263,
0.0719154403,
0.0508236028,
0.0231219679,
0.0684556514,
0.0422842987,
0.0043187155,
0.0115772588,
0.0682929233,
0.000808688,
-0.0157180913,
-0.0479944758,
0.0128088966,
0.0305760559,
-0.0015140352,
0.0017058535,
0.0306048933,
0.0513884351,
0.0494899638,
-0.0345584638,
0.0079722302,
-0.007088203,
0.0037437237,
-0.0353638195,
-0.0294759311,
0.0204834454,
-0.0044181324,
-0.0214341264,
-0.0142923398,
-0.0282287411,
-0.0134665184,
0.0264558811,
-0.0234090015,
0.0165809747,
0.0128944525,
0.0066369353,
0.033725623,
0.0003697004,
0.0292046294,
-0.0052440558,
-0.0475396775,
0.0901781991,
-0.0050338646,
-0.0196494348,
0.0169698335,
-0.0244647004,
0.0065070619,
-0.0569117591,
-0.0219799727,
0.0362056755,
-0.0079383682,
0.0074564731,
-0.0062784464,
0.0073732291,
0.0553648658,
-0.0353690647,
0.0461466946,
-0.0266622901,
-0.0127451671,
0.0097852359,
0.0101506319,
0.0702367723,
-0.024455959,
0.0135206804,
0.001138891,
0.0217316281,
-0.019191511,
0.004163397,
-0.0225230027,
0.0444967672,
0.0118015399,
0.013631396,
-0.0415726155,
0.0499213673,
-0.0502191596,
0.0866374895,
0.0196857955,
-0.0084460611,
-0.0124014942,
0.0017310254,
-0.0362405032,
-0.0324310288,
0.0040311767,
-0.0185919795,
-0.0038891304,
-0.0858053938,
0.0004899607,
0.0196093507,
-0.0629917681,
-0.012693854,
-0.014677994,
0.1234243661,
0.0611219704,
-0.0139922174,
-0.0531021096,
-0.0487724543,
-0.0136778625,
-0.0637558848,
-0.0118777538,
-0.0650121868,
-0.0392424576,
-0.0117780128,
0.0093675004,
-0.052099511,
-0.0142996358,
-0.0167810731,
0.012394473,
0.0377847478,
-0.0387289226,
0.0225289855,
-0.0344233625,
0.0144114289,
-0.0111403856,
0.0383648872,
0.0563551337,
0.0355414674,
0.0652683601,
-0.0180050135,
0.0504472293,
0.0353995711,
-0.0095166704,
0.0006871918,
-0.0202600583,
0.0351849087,
-0.0338116102,
-0.0463497452,
-0.0269749239,
0.0527345762,
0.0098086447,
-0.0154497884,
0.0506272502,
0.0258611199,
0.0277920291,
0.0454912707,
0.0456033684,
0.016684128,
0.0119523918,
0.002179594,
-0.0597435832,
0.0191231593,
-0.0182088185,
0.0285748038,
-0.0192526393,
0.0169853829,
-0.0133434599,
-0.1127798259,
-0.0361417718,
-0.0222669169,
-0.0196931567,
-0.0193514246,
0.0347113945,
-0.0139241507,
-0.014017202,
0.0496796519,
-0.0006698315,
-0.0602279976,
-0.0358088091,
-0.0715301335,
0.0591626056,
0.0530866869,
0.038257353,
-0.060241174,
-0.0146140689,
-0.0202327818,
-0.0305791963,
0.0239086896,
0.024943525,
-0.0010385567,
-0.00425534,
-0.0204546191,
-0.0267407428,
-0.015800301,
0.0159090534,
0.0209478084,
-0.0043431446,
0.0035677343,
-0.0028288763,
-0.0591787547,
-0.0762789026,
0.0358100049,
-0.0435552634,
-0.0185751282,
-0.0047502597,
0.0084765283,
0.0663994253,
0.0359737724,
-0.0398706384,
0.0435181186,
0.0695665926,
0.0099494886,
-0.0240848884,
0.0045377733,
0.0000017987,
0.0656671748,
0.0181444138,
-0.0472510979,
-0.0002664386,
0.0517463125,
-0.0336531736,
-0.0227141399,
0.0266628787,
-0.0430066027,
0.0424587764,
-0.0120403944,
0.0320991389,
-0.0483068228,
0.0126199806,
-0.0483936034,
0.0250216294,
-0.0362799019,
0.0051656952,
-0.022253463,
0.0362652093,
0.0352700129,
-0.031252142,
-0.0539604053,
0.0126913805,
-0.0105833467,
0.0566299148,
0.0431461632,
0.0348922163,
-0.0307452884,
-0.0281929001,
-0.0502438694,
-0.000899375,
0.0018558884,
0.0479453579,
-0.0024395001,
-0.0366338082,
-0.0172197595,
0.01106303,
-0.0038549067,
-0.003756301,
-0.0091388868,
0.0001889461,
0.0592631884,
-0.0314454325,
-0.0681491718,
-0.0315776318,
-0.0244052541,
-0.0268538073,
0.0665674061,
0.0060212999,
-0.0159974955,
-0.0795774758,
0.0549811088,
-0.0283897072,
0.0262935534,
-0.0023774931,
-0.0296264924,
0.023588784,
0.0113363648,
-0.0231795255,
0.0337414183,
-0.0190653633,
0.0200735759,
0.0386642553,
-0.0110268611,
-0.0669397637,
-0.0014455648,
0.0237525981,
-0.0197196826,
0.004779303,
-0.0230734926,
0.0432829,
0.0641729906,
-0.0165681615,
-0.047395248,
-0.0000913999,
0.0180306453,
-0.0080038654,
-0.0148958825,
0.0512721352,
-0.0283412226,
-0.0037456101,
0.0701421425,
0.0074611078,
-0.1120210961,
0.0757213011,
-0.0766835511,
0.0324614085,
-0.0071499329,
-0.0413350128,
-0.0444832891,
0.0430012383,
-0.0138569716,
0.0042604669,
0.0241591055,
0.0021884216,
-0.0076972232,
-0.0104821613,
0.0027399499,
-0.0177004002,
0.0718599334,
-0.0414111651,
0.0125135267,
0.0080593079,
0.0086021088,
-0.0325158685,
0.0009366227,
-0.0284256022,
0.0148325916,
-0.0168467723,
-0.010785548,
0.0010865598,
0.028502604,
0.0032654065,
-0.0310559627,
0.0033843529,
-0.0167852473,
-0.0336148068,
-0.0197269712,
0.0016298284,
-0.0116696609,
0.0682633966,
-0.0113462843,
0.035006851,
0.0247770771,
0.0073039797,
0.03206072,
-0.0826396793,
-0.0397654511,
-0.0013934618,
-0.0413265377,
-0.0083750095,
0.0425014943,
0.026046088,
-0.0752958208,
-0.0075990874,
0.0726495981,
0.009762276,
-0.0200244263,
0.0286167003,
-0.0148241324,
0.0419077426,
0.0325576477,
0.0149778612,
-0.0774981007,
0.001439838,
-0.0027346746,
0.0163602363,
-0.0090066986,
-0.036461588,
0.0064982101,
-0.0767879412,
0.0813655183,
-0.0067690485,
-0.0421143025,
-0.0367049798,
-0.0601979196,
-0.0036224623,
-0.0400748514,
0.0264363419,
0.0100722527,
0.0040103886,
-0.0197047424,
-0.0129692052,
-0.0450213291,
-0.0315626524,
0.0480228513,
-0.0527013801,
0.0427008942,
0.0633100718,
0.011101367,
-0.0376578532,
-0.0479108468,
0.0564543046,
0.0087967496,
0.0234698318,
0.0000700873,
0.0198191572,
0.0138576962,
-0.0132156098,
0.0015298452,
0.0086296052,
-0.0394774936,
-0.0208897702,
0.0192978494,
0.0760418922,
-0.0251232609,
-0.0247316863,
-0.0431388877,
-0.0359162465,
0.000007719,
0.06127299,
0.0474303365,
-0.0061391694,
-0.0536813177,
-0.0249955337,
-0.0114498846,
-0.0260504484,
-0.0268085748,
0.0248434395,
-0.0186479725,
-0.0324400216,
-0.0396521203,
-0.0157185867,
-0.0384429991,
-0.0026165498,
0.0145438379,
-0.0305185281,
0.0627604946,
-0.0061431532,
-0.0516727269,
0.0375780091,
-0.035963349,
0.0368024409,
-0.0432838202,
0.0420600027,
0.0271786284,
0.00690282,
-0.0106240837,
0.0419461578,
-0.055301182,
-0.0632623285,
-0.014024755,
0.0850902647,
0.0297675226,
0.0118417535,
-0.0412042998,
-0.0343013033,
0.0622705035,
-0.0175947901,
-0.0300456882,
-0.0018049566,
0.0523721725,
0.0138302036,
0.0070889196,
0.0095070079,
-0.0480188951,
0.0199496504,
0.0022089751,
-0.011652587,
-0.0009361799,
-0.0504445545,
-0.0102368733,
0.0724971965,
0.0175573062,
0.0223223511,
0.0254138838,
-0.0209738202,
0.0203761011,
-0.0245245658,
-0.0115976343,
-0.0585674979,
0.0619799234,
-0.0035607552,
-0.0535074659,
0.0080893859,
-0.0362423733,
-0.0346520655,
0.0180659909,
0.0172052868,
0.0515829772,
-0.0361498147,
0.0317087732,
0.0218951907,
0.0065272609,
-0.0236777533,
0.0102448845,
-0.050199911,
0.0323250443,
0.0230753869,
0.0272634439,
0.0000760998,
0.0124939978,
0.0113660796,
0.0553691685,
-0.047700543,
-0.0823250636,
-0.018836664,
0.002538708,
0.0212373957,
0.0316478536,
0.053321436,
-0.0175953694,
0.0303164702,
-0.0369013138,
0.0633186698,
0.0118633118,
-0.0208176281,
-0.0018000688,
0.02690644,
-0.0401593409,
-0.021546578,
0.0405416414,
-0.0127004609,
-0.0202496666,
-0.0504817441,
-0.0430983119,
-0.0567884929,
-0.0159700271,
-0.0026331143,
-0.021207625,
-0.0236068256,
-0.0590630472,
-0.0815149918,
-0.0882468969,
0.0101310797,
0.064325951,
0.019988196,
-0.0026196183,
-0.0164589584,
0.0764222518,
0.0396130867,
0.0256071538,
-0.0145325027,
-0.0540479124,
-0.0075132367,
-0.0113828834,
-0.0291105565,
-5.880287063e-33,
-0.0114812851,
-0.0620492361,
0.014071295,
0.0041670799,
-0.0116899516,
0.0061956071,
-0.0367761999,
-0.0059013502,
-0.0075589656,
-0.0142856417,
0.0078974664,
0.0185546242,
0.0058573568,
-0.0196476486,
0.0371672139,
0.0080829551,
0.0151926028,
0.0012735217,
-0.006167572,
0.0102017252,
-0.0009562673,
-0.0122470167,
0.0350373648,
-0.0634294525,
0.07584811,
0.0002349454,
-0.0096767619,
0.0147163253,
-0.0320555754,
0.0760401562,
-0.021860607,
0.0307193156,
0.0109765902,
-0.0440496206,
-0.0213666223,
-0.0275393818,
-0.0203461964,
-0.039266862,
-0.0010314059,
-0.0281966403,
-0.0282371417,
-0.0347774737,
0.0700074956,
0.0009972954,
-0.0206340011,
0.0122653712,
0.0400036462,
-0.0223340802,
0.0028024968,
-0.0391982049,
-0.0334426314,
0.0406770222,
-0.04503043,
0.0283640232,
0.018430924,
0.0477779731,
0.003017846,
0.041363962,
-0.0138521893,
0.0038467753,
0.0416920744,
-0.0042489842,
0.1177921146,
-0.0338065885,
0.0277390461,
0.0316330418,
0.0095955543,
0.0108677819,
-0.0147934603,
-0.0167462304,
0.0158854779,
0.092497535,
0.0576730743,
0.0186873022,
-0.0124220373,
-0.0008796785,
-0.0757062584,
0.035259176,
-0.0061177723,
0.0707099736,
0.0114939343,
0.0192032326,
-0.0710544065,
0.0225393977,
-0.0381044447,
-0.0317709558,
-0.0225546025,
-0.0335465223,
0.0278590415,
-0.0361378305,
-0.0508649126,
0.0066026617,
0.0061038951,
-0.0808170661,
-0.0151944393,
-0.0126011455,
-0.0097175948,
-0.0107555827,
0.0044016885,
0.030513294,
-0.0073379083,
-0.0095086079,
-0.0530737042,
0.0196275078,
0.0632213801,
0.0035880522,
0.010249557,
0.0252139475,
-0.0448486209,
0.0155605366,
-0.0442376137,
-0.0121532381,
0.0257531498,
-0.0005382731,
0.0195453372,
-0.0356958993,
-0.0161680207,
0.0761117935,
0.0061697932,
0.0096402299,
-0.0292020384,
0.0699079186,
0.0024977052,
0.0358009934,
-0.0082494374,
-0.046774216,
-0.0292987954,
0.0610909611,
0.0860883147,
-0.0256045051,
-0.0229178667,
0.010454393,
3.003e-7,
0.0189434178,
0.0340485461,
0.0377268977,
0.0674500391,
0.0060237455,
0.045525685,
-0.0178163163,
-0.0025323869,
-0.0091096153,
-0.0122920033,
-0.0043301615,
0.0123082073,
0.0384530611,
0.0422195941,
-0.0269770194,
0.0053363685,
-0.0605945364,
-0.01000096,
-0.0519430004,
0.0012561169,
0.0479684621,
0.0570911653,
0.0108023845,
-0.0032690777,
-0.0255359504,
-0.0477933325,
0.0009358326,
-0.0361156538,
-0.0060448688,
0.0558080226,
0.0611407757,
0.0106159979,
0.0094301216,
0.0099385539,
0.0111751789,
0.040233735,
-0.019830605,
0.0531118959,
0.0072517581,
-0.0310576186,
0.041349858,
-0.0666470155,
0.0253094994,
-0.0841377527,
0.0479458496,
-0.0366162993,
-0.0314300545,
-0.053907197,
-0.0174022317,
-0.0279281139,
0.0534527749,
-0.026576383,
0.0310914889,
0.0181649458,
-0.0342807621,
-0.0296848845,
0.0109566078,
-0.0201366898,
-0.0513903499,
-0.0135882562,
-0.0237931162,
-0.0486034527,
-0.0121852327,
-0.0089894002,
0.0156632923,
-0.0813419819,
0.0368247628,
2.889682406e-34,
0.065835841,
-0.0507963486,
0.0146427564,
0.0498635545,
0.0651029646,
0.0051330775,
-0.0380873829,
0.0280057061,
-0.0098399119,
-0.0289212,
-0.0284758992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14206v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14206v1 | Manifold-Preserving Transformers are Effective for Short-Long Range Encoding | 2023-10-22T06:58:28 | 2023-10-22T06:58:28 | Ayan Sengupta, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multi-head self-attention-based Transformers have shown promise in different
learning tasks. Albeit these models exhibit significant improvement in
understanding short-term and long-term contexts from sequences, encoders of
Transformers and their variants fail to preserve layer-wise contextual
information. Transformers usually project tokens onto sparse manifolds and fail
to preserve mathematical equivalence among the token representations. In this
work, we propose TransJect, an encoder model that guarantees a theoretical
bound for layer-wise distance preservation between a pair of tokens. We propose
a simple alternative to dot-product attention to ensure Lipschitz continuity.
This allows TransJect to learn injective mappings to transform token
representations to different manifolds with similar topology and preserve
Euclidean distance between every pair of tokens in subsequent layers.
Evaluations across multiple benchmark short- and long-sequence classification
tasks show maximum improvements of 6.8% and 5.9%, respectively, over the
variants of Transformers. Additionally, TransJect displays 79% better
performance than Transformer on the language modeling task. We further
highlight the shortcomings of multi-head self-attention from the statistical
physics viewpoint. Although multi-head self-attention was incepted to learn
different abstraction levels within the networks, our empirical analyses
suggest that different attention heads learn randomly and unorderly. In
contrast, TransJect adapts a mixture of experts for regularization; these
experts are more orderly and balanced and learn different sparse
representations from the input sequences. TransJect exhibits very low entropy
and can be efficiently scaled to larger depths. | [
-0.0354936682,
0.0218552072,
0.0016974966,
0.0593603738,
-0.0206249524,
-0.0231710337,
0.0406093262,
-0.0242583174,
-0.0257221088,
-0.0116374977,
-0.040701244,
-0.0365449972,
0.0175278448,
0.0115562016,
0.0545763038,
-0.0728698,
0.0273144897,
-0.0081370845,
-0.0523764007,
-0.0233195629,
-0.0265876632,
-0.0404605418,
0.0169432405,
0.0447468795,
-0.0247609355,
0.0057175946,
-0.017229883,
-0.0306217987,
0.0372202247,
-0.0213753972,
-0.00189064,
0.0739075989,
0.0346212201,
0.0336115211,
0.0000021005,
-0.020556109,
0.0038083419,
-0.0038501858,
0.0099418126,
-0.0279801786,
-0.0247920025,
-0.0324367359,
0.0003396625,
-0.0318438709,
-0.0006345731,
-0.0386104174,
0.0419105962,
0.0014675374,
0.0572261736,
0.0519763492,
-0.0251254626,
-0.0517277941,
0.0051587797,
-0.0451300293,
0.0313972011,
-0.0271301195,
-0.0007189208,
-0.0655842125,
-0.0130992588,
0.0260625202,
-0.0760425478,
0.0518742464,
0.031226255,
0.0217316654,
0.1029292047,
0.0837116539,
-0.0156801119,
-0.0070475936,
0.0039639613,
0.0826128796,
-0.0738033801,
-0.0153738568,
-0.0110564232,
0.0126110148,
0.0077516604,
-0.0416025035,
-0.0393130109,
0.0135628153,
0.0136033548,
0.0044036447,
-0.0341083892,
0.0234914757,
0.0112935835,
-0.027681917,
-0.0981518552,
0.0092158411,
0.0131998416,
-0.0008456714,
-0.0306212176,
-0.0261849817,
0.018067982,
-0.0084918886,
-0.0072798533,
0.0126585178,
0.0279533323,
-0.01998231,
-0.0237195641,
-0.0505475178,
-0.0170481335,
-0.0470676087,
0.0361485146,
0.0212328192,
-0.0307177082,
0.0402281024,
-0.0507685021,
0.0356729291,
-0.0423268937,
0.1032977402,
-0.0318926945,
-0.0109168887,
-0.0107172299,
0.0084014395,
-0.0321715996,
0.043251466,
0.0061819009,
-0.0283323955,
-0.0287500508,
0.022039406,
-0.0023014692,
-0.0074486206,
-0.0080210567,
0.0205993485,
-0.0265090857,
-0.027020609,
0.0060340618,
0.0188516583,
-0.0293131117,
0.0332662351,
0.0191892162,
0.0063360319,
-0.0784896612,
0.0484961718,
0.0237724427,
-0.0228962991,
0.0008091013,
0.0945606977,
0.0084455004,
-0.033019308,
0.0014558915,
0.0013548259,
-0.0418169387,
-0.0545929261,
0.0529102124,
-0.0626905113,
0.0243222695,
0.0256374497,
-0.0000874587,
-0.0515151843,
-0.0179988015,
-0.0033511631,
-0.0116485041,
0.0702457577,
0.0461368747,
-0.0330101065,
0.0505208448,
0.014888172,
-0.0297093596,
0.0246973373,
0.0170170683,
0.0175828841,
-0.0158549566,
-0.0368066616,
-0.0085727163,
0.0068542096,
0.0344554931,
0.0010969337,
-0.0342050381,
-0.0187870972,
0.0316356272,
0.0559356771,
0.0401466377,
0.0560857914,
-0.0434006713,
-0.0664269254,
-0.0072749965,
0.0514295474,
0.0255434401,
0.0444603823,
0.0340617895,
-0.0340470895,
-0.0356730185,
0.0164853558,
-0.0379365273,
0.0913039222,
0.0437299237,
-0.030854607,
0.0557950363,
-0.0004882314,
-0.0628796965,
0.0043750168,
0.0119526014,
-0.0345940068,
-0.0024106747,
-0.028775271,
0.0547637716,
-0.0112404255,
-0.0252715442,
0.0871175081,
-0.0325327963,
-0.0429409854,
0.0262793694,
-0.0049685217,
-0.0092318077,
0.0186325759,
-0.0409353264,
-0.0161451865,
-0.0320283994,
-0.033437673,
0.0433414616,
0.0284334868,
-0.0168667212,
0.0275273528,
0.0269256327,
-0.0085242512,
-0.0412947051,
-0.0053870501,
-0.0284103435,
0.0232917331,
-0.0237002485,
0.000305913,
0.0390604958,
-0.0294334926,
0.0665584356,
0.0342977084,
-0.0270273797,
-0.0252228305,
0.0151834376,
0.0306291115,
0.0543254949,
0.0021992116,
0.0077687656,
0.0259455461,
0.0522322133,
-0.0918004289,
-0.0321930312,
-0.0087411683,
-0.0810859799,
-0.0372933708,
0.0310960319,
-0.0479792319,
0.0072542382,
0.0273253173,
-0.0155477244,
-0.0601273067,
0.0536076054,
-0.0378731191,
0.0117421858,
-0.0056336829,
-0.0451520979,
0.0170928203,
0.0698482692,
-0.0287122373,
0.0162645318,
-0.0039195893,
0.007237134,
-0.0105524184,
0.0033888586,
0.0094691357,
0.0043660114,
-0.0165995397,
0.0284725744,
0.0207993723,
0.0088627888,
0.0155779645,
-0.0373427607,
-0.0034122465,
-0.0303681139,
-0.0431016609,
-0.0473954827,
-0.015439692,
0.0297591016,
-0.0137712164,
0.0003801754,
0.0162163116,
-0.0063200332,
-0.0028145453,
0.0075924029,
-0.0104833655,
0.0027459755,
0.0391446128,
-0.0009068567,
-0.0359675474,
0.0027951917,
-0.039700713,
0.0033457191,
0.0497009046,
-0.0421664678,
-0.0067355745,
-0.0499765612,
-0.0647368953,
-0.0093575185,
0.0173190832,
-0.0012955047,
-0.0368882157,
-0.0067916531,
-0.0492162704,
0.0623675846,
0.0818500891,
0.0364792794,
0.0022640016,
0.0406951122,
-0.0029914712,
-0.0389253944,
0.000692427,
-0.0514601432,
0.0298014991,
-0.0372951776,
0.0360291749,
-0.0102938218,
0.0467234217,
0.0119470619,
-0.0134529043,
-0.0868280679,
0.0078379419,
0.0167371426,
-0.0069891657,
0.0086086011,
0.0266997702,
-0.029976476,
0.0174678676,
0.0046378965,
-0.0145305637,
0.0679167807,
-0.0058382996,
-0.0019596051,
0.0119995438,
-0.003491919,
-0.0474405475,
0.0405256487,
0.0081812022,
0.020283889,
-0.0342384093,
-0.0278956257,
-0.0333006456,
0.0321829282,
-0.0026026382,
0.0294457786,
0.0396474898,
-0.0019040721,
0.0091463393,
-0.0307532791,
-0.0184753891,
-0.0212979242,
-0.0348331966,
0.0192050468,
0.0185419042,
-0.0069705183,
-0.015812885,
-0.0622675233,
0.0163259003,
0.0399089679,
0.0723493099,
-0.0235628169,
0.0106423153,
0.0034013351,
0.0180587918,
-0.0032966442,
0.0616576411,
0.0275140442,
-0.0358232893,
0.0247096065,
0.0376778208,
0.0224279538,
-0.0028252376,
-0.0391841456,
-0.0092367772,
0.0073711602,
0.0258495808,
0.0090040835,
0.0108216982,
0.0283709615,
-0.0346501283,
-0.0324547514,
0.0744349435,
-0.0329461545,
-0.0533078946,
0.0005603725,
0.0036028491,
0.0165520068,
0.010166917,
-0.017220607,
-0.02647225,
-0.0243746992,
-0.0148139866,
0.0259265453,
0.0661772192,
-0.0114541706,
0.0407845415,
-0.0498997644,
0.0146064628,
0.0490040183,
-0.0910477862,
-0.0547933951,
-0.0429346897,
-0.0017327346,
0.0165601261,
0.0273297802,
-0.0125496127,
-0.0116903465,
-0.0614816323,
0.0248601232,
0.0069369706,
-0.0320732854,
0.027059434,
-0.0105103198,
0.0085643232,
0.0191287789,
-0.0047119106,
-0.0203787666,
-0.0700489581,
0.0193470288,
0.0157093722,
0.0006065459,
0.014006298,
0.0538250841,
-0.0188609678,
0.0059570428,
0.0604044497,
0.0443584137,
-0.0480036959,
0.0127920145,
-0.0163675398,
0.1141630188,
-0.0256784558,
-0.0285280365,
-0.0541830771,
-0.0312663093,
-0.0383318849,
0.0553178303,
0.0377595015,
-0.0193332005,
-0.0412932262,
-0.0058070552,
0.0459670424,
-0.0291601438,
-0.0180409923,
0.0229726899,
0.0047090482,
-0.1030504331,
-0.0239653457,
0.0105435792,
-0.0063410271,
0.0525242984,
-0.0046617389,
-0.0360264517,
0.0042256163,
0.0044893757,
-0.0411537439,
0.0017672321,
-0.0052168006,
-0.0051533547,
-0.0511641018,
0.0263615306,
0.0607515834,
-0.0001334275,
-0.009863033,
0.0080267228,
-0.0925095305,
-0.0593316779,
0.0279319249,
0.031800352,
-0.0025829664,
0.0676610544,
0.0202557016,
-0.0240138918,
0.0593537986,
0.0424833447,
-0.0400271416,
0.0365770198,
0.045969747,
-0.0364999063,
-0.0168291181,
0.0127582485,
-0.0387823544,
0.0456530266,
0.0061670118,
0.008141215,
0.0179454479,
-0.0083357794,
-0.0102029424,
-0.030451471,
0.0821152031,
-0.0157543663,
0.03593117,
0.0264042355,
0.0251964442,
-0.0038342816,
0.0247781891,
-0.0193504356,
-0.0331842229,
0.0056207241,
-0.0086248303,
0.0099746333,
0.0257539898,
0.0226346478,
0.026982896,
-0.0077491784,
0.0686368495,
-0.0618380494,
0.0031620483,
0.0019288613,
0.0179066807,
0.0039205574,
-0.0554501303,
0.0050590304,
0.0057589584,
-0.0440447293,
-0.0269397479,
0.0550435856,
0.0472052321,
-0.0493689254,
0.0025794457,
-0.0854188204,
-0.0061566141,
-0.0123876417,
-0.0009866063,
0.0342369042,
0.0024914399,
-0.0034890154,
-0.002783654,
-0.0076195393,
-0.0140869254,
0.0290931221,
-0.0224689506,
-0.0074253273,
0.0420184173,
0.0064853923,
0.0132854367,
-0.0212235507,
0.0558818355,
-0.008027656,
0.0019168241,
0.007545304,
0.0079433722,
-0.065201968,
-0.0174108278,
-0.0366483219,
0.0187134389,
0.0231879726,
0.0107386364,
0.0003412027,
-0.0497953594,
0.041119583,
-0.0504055806,
-0.0127094546,
0.0161352903,
0.0324517228,
0.041881524,
-0.0004713445,
-0.0217026416,
0.0357276872,
0.0488247313,
0.0402569398,
-0.0303363781,
0.0298646931,
-6.449066902e-33,
-0.0005743477,
-0.0196124539,
-0.0146590751,
0.0081134476,
-0.0286617521,
-0.0169616938,
-0.0384216979,
-0.0054296078,
-0.0011837905,
-0.020279618,
-0.0105057294,
-0.0080154678,
-0.005484805,
0.0470215715,
0.0569088459,
-0.0136276064,
0.0500314087,
-0.0017110831,
0.0070915599,
0.0494954549,
0.0431914516,
0.0359921344,
0.0741238371,
0.0086252289,
-0.0247352589,
0.0196625497,
0.0444380082,
0.0071132039,
-0.0076089632,
0.0184745006,
-0.0280640759,
0.0342580453,
0.0006387726,
-0.0566665195,
-0.0448773503,
0.0005191998,
-0.0877827257,
-0.0396582484,
-0.0839112774,
-0.0095126098,
-0.0504030772,
-0.0574768037,
0.0915322676,
0.021138696,
-0.0236777142,
-0.0672046021,
0.0503397733,
-0.001704056,
-0.0285191238,
0.0008648281,
-0.0150348116,
0.033358898,
-0.0290260594,
-0.0066007967,
0.0607740507,
0.0315970443,
0.0069080521,
0.0472553559,
-0.0623790994,
0.0088708131,
-0.0616462864,
0.0488297828,
0.0424464121,
0.0275554433,
0.0242993813,
0.0363907926,
0.0383848846,
-0.0115213329,
-0.0495573021,
-0.0108202938,
0.0418880396,
-0.000575352,
0.0215458255,
-0.0125837792,
0.0224584285,
-0.0177402794,
-0.0682904646,
-0.0185258929,
-0.0796117634,
0.0554274321,
0.0246045198,
0.0397513434,
-0.0026048722,
-0.0179467034,
-0.0091727776,
0.0157589838,
-0.0210481398,
-0.0075372644,
0.0123992618,
-0.0054739825,
0.0209272932,
-0.0120249419,
0.061667446,
-0.0190055035,
-0.0122988336,
0.015000375,
0.0031928245,
0.0159666911,
0.0361172929,
0.0160774011,
-0.031193167,
-0.0168682411,
0.0260258745,
0.0271840896,
0.0221363399,
-0.0171585083,
0.0124635231,
0.0538333505,
-0.0467163846,
-0.0658283457,
-0.0399054661,
-0.0311315525,
-0.0073143682,
0.0245612506,
0.0516324751,
0.0288771875,
0.0043158028,
0.0816787854,
-0.0382041968,
0.0077444543,
-0.0057288832,
0.0311455224,
0.009618517,
0.0250153001,
-0.0360646807,
-0.004283038,
-0.0461244807,
-0.0079619354,
0.0675397739,
-0.0679523945,
-0.0245830677,
0.0398430862,
2.883e-7,
0.012787478,
0.0436280407,
0.0427043401,
-0.0645109937,
0.0078314226,
0.0171739664,
-0.0116289565,
0.0741667002,
-0.0316104852,
-0.0062790653,
-0.0016927479,
0.0218450427,
0.0288359113,
0.0281500071,
-0.1120434776,
0.0149680758,
-0.0391516425,
0.035030432,
-0.0350640863,
0.0447031222,
0.0721317604,
0.1060369313,
0.0149729382,
0.0158710331,
0.0306280069,
0.0330586508,
0.0446372367,
-0.0087366914,
0.0662234128,
-0.0051022004,
-0.0188771058,
-0.0235906392,
0.0067856992,
0.0022850416,
-0.013943864,
0.0347249471,
0.0182061493,
0.032949958,
-0.024541432,
-0.0431866124,
0.0264052283,
0.0454237647,
-0.0073989909,
-0.0569590963,
0.0363129787,
-0.1112649515,
-0.0460148081,
-0.0336228721,
-0.0254579429,
0.0380183831,
0.0529022142,
0.0079904739,
0.0079394244,
0.0054616225,
0.0214136448,
-0.0292707942,
0.0280504748,
-0.106711939,
-0.0003330743,
0.0208971854,
-0.0936079994,
0.0273011029,
-0.0472148992,
-0.016915923,
0.0646255761,
0.0242375564,
-0.0374061428,
2.268421933e-34,
-0.0164239574,
-0.0312381703,
0.0018426026,
0.0044823661,
-0.015807718,
-0.0595837645,
-0.0122450991,
0.015589538,
0.0101773022,
-0.054111965,
-0.0504041687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.14198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.14198v1 | QA-NatVer: Question Answering for Natural Logic-based Fact Verification | 2023-10-22T06:27:31 | 2023-10-22T06:27:31 | Rami Aly, Marek Strong, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fact verification systems assess a claim's veracity based on evidence. An
important consideration in designing them is faithfulness, i.e. generating
explanations that accurately reflect the reasoning of the model. Recent works
have focused on natural logic, which operates directly on natural language by
capturing the semantic relation of spans between an aligned claim with its
evidence via set-theoretic operators. However, these approaches rely on
substantial resources for training, which are only available for high-resource
languages. To this end, we propose to use question answering to predict natural
logic operators, taking advantage of the generalization capabilities of
instruction-tuned language models. Thus, we obviate the need for annotated
training data while still relying on a deterministic inference system. In a
few-shot setting on FEVER, our approach outperforms the best baseline by $4.3$
accuracy points, including a state-of-the-art pre-trained seq2seq natural logic
system, as well as a state-of-the-art prompt-based classifier. Our system
demonstrates its robustness and portability, achieving competitive performance
on a counterfactual dataset and surpassing all approaches without further
annotation on a Danish verification dataset. A human evaluation indicates that
our approach produces more plausible proofs with fewer erroneous natural logic
operators than previous natural logic-based systems. | [
0.040580675,
0.0672607794,
0.0333759189,
0.0108587062,
-0.0332085937,
-0.0057917847,
-0.0059366715,
-0.0466965623,
0.030428065,
-0.0357465409,
0.0035308271,
0.0280531161,
-0.0341732427,
0.0533678755,
0.0488313884,
-0.024372533,
0.0719605088,
-0.0163133927,
0.0599561259,
-0.0152682438,
0.0003529706,
0.02885589,
-0.009619575,
0.037533123,
-0.0016135947,
-0.0057448237,
-0.0135089755,
-0.0043644211,
0.0350482836,
-0.0230448805,
-0.005315295,
0.0487370417,
0.0238328334,
0.0068725115,
0.0000019146,
-0.0856087655,
0.016884625,
0.0279030446,
-0.0694241077,
0.0060710111,
-0.0121196043,
-0.0007486888,
0.0155085251,
0.0247017555,
-0.0362594612,
-0.021263089,
0.0046654805,
0.0432843976,
0.0899408981,
0.0810132325,
0.0064546503,
-0.0640105978,
0.0143482415,
0.002446831,
-0.0096832654,
-0.0389312245,
0.0435209833,
0.018318437,
0.0329582728,
-0.0023958462,
0.014636212,
0.0189211443,
0.0196659099,
0.0053740405,
-0.033529751,
0.037764091,
-0.0301378593,
0.0001229083,
-0.0211270247,
0.0652828813,
0.0052671386,
-0.0530685112,
-0.0081125768,
0.003249042,
-0.0130536146,
-0.0116881272,
0.0138524435,
0.0396412052,
-0.0230776481,
-0.0226394124,
0.0513077937,
0.0185377728,
0.0188647043,
-0.0035435059,
0.0029265436,
0.0509754606,
0.0076136338,
-0.02553376,
0.0292906556,
-0.0190820415,
-0.0163227245,
-0.084321022,
0.012060306,
0.0421571992,
-0.0320472643,
0.0080639403,
-0.0234918371,
0.0088527286,
0.0405561887,
-0.0257873014,
-0.0108083365,
0.0244829543,
-0.021676451,
0.0570121855,
-0.0248991437,
-0.0037883869,
0.010145071,
0.0186866466,
-0.0104158344,
-0.038315855,
-0.0367108509,
-0.0058634831,
-0.019103257,
0.0031534277,
-0.0039644586,
0.0450051799,
-0.0120921191,
-0.0240232572,
0.0121491151,
0.0390412994,
-0.0127016613,
0.0318369418,
-0.0100369789,
-0.0205207542,
-0.0688623041,
0.0170578063,
-0.0681208745,
0.0179039259,
0.0030192418,
-0.0567233711,
-0.0164840501,
0.0029450511,
-0.0051189414,
0.0094500445,
0.06896469,
0.0238333791,
0.0090257749,
-0.0023473343,
-0.0167181231,
-0.008085141,
0.0002531912,
-0.0852585733,
-0.0309757162,
-0.0653974786,
0.0218547806,
0.0159112792,
-0.035189122,
0.0040773172,
0.0210002903,
0.038453456,
-0.0279705096,
0.0738994554,
-0.0475995615,
-0.024413893,
0.0011901641,
-0.0144207608,
0.0276310518,
0.0152958259,
0.0338473134,
-0.0274615325,
0.0284086727,
0.0115088783,
-0.0015956355,
-0.0167668518,
0.058859963,
-0.0309468564,
-0.0001581236,
0.0693228692,
0.0211531147,
-0.0109127602,
0.0053956667,
0.0470966846,
-0.0048590037,
-0.0534437411,
-0.0126623353,
0.0057133385,
-0.0420438871,
-0.0223610383,
0.0311027206,
0.0112209478,
0.0349222198,
-0.0206806287,
-0.0533277877,
0.0124053871,
-0.0314778872,
-0.0019132936,
0.0090064863,
0.037194591,
-0.0321595185,
-0.0776681378,
-0.0246170405,
-0.001336516,
-0.0176313762,
0.0338073522,
0.0240018442,
0.0159551632,
-0.0145435398,
0.0089799119,
0.0438879877,
-0.0431913547,
-0.0092046317,
-0.0572321378,
0.0518470593,
0.0192628931,
0.028240554,
-0.0430203266,
-0.0362795405,
-0.0437512472,
0.0207135063,
0.0331981108,
0.0542169213,
-0.0064367484,
0.0202115085,
0.0041662585,
0.0142014502,
-0.0569487512,
0.0195739139,
0.0213402845,
-0.0065970877,
0.0277751386,
-0.0136430776,
-0.0111164777,
-0.0176685154,
0.0356514193,
-0.0261905249,
-0.0292850845,
0.0228200853,
0.0005293482,
0.019199349,
0.0205585249,
-0.0087994589,
0.0165059082,
0.0270255618,
-0.026568139,
-0.0151199596,
0.0145115657,
0.0103038577,
-0.0738900453,
0.0486684442,
-0.0363727473,
-0.028232554,
0.0083492789,
-0.062623851,
-0.046492897,
-0.0055587091,
-0.0521337986,
-0.0001876737,
-0.0240773931,
-0.072199434,
0.0346887112,
-0.0206450727,
-0.0253685489,
0.0761996657,
0.0167950373,
0.0016942355,
-0.0347053371,
0.0034118327,
0.0307907593,
-0.0430359431,
0.0312034264,
-0.0054125353,
-0.0038163455,
-0.0020468747,
0.0378451161,
-0.0297357123,
-0.0169751197,
0.0217871778,
-0.0669737533,
0.0405532457,
-0.0245204475,
0.0331328511,
0.0011825946,
-0.0198953729,
0.0000346099,
-0.0198024008,
-0.0550766326,
-0.0471835136,
0.0350386985,
-0.0337567925,
0.0443361253,
-0.0202066824,
-0.024081422,
-0.0218168478,
0.0060552494,
-0.0560283959,
0.0315555707,
0.0240151342,
0.0336002298,
-0.0391554907,
-0.0608580261,
-0.049283009,
0.0379270352,
-0.0181125607,
-0.0108150644,
0.0385166183,
0.0166140888,
-0.0376326144,
0.0753236488,
0.0205952916,
-0.0532948077,
0.0416791402,
0.0267795008,
-0.0196771529,
0.0550097376,
-0.0260423627,
0.0088584283,
-0.0123471823,
-0.0260403603,
-0.0201370306,
0.0476909243,
0.0257492978,
-0.0147816585,
-0.0317239836,
0.0325808078,
0.0097531788,
-0.0152008822,
-0.0088795386,
0.012023733,
0.0113045173,
0.0584216341,
0.0038819336,
-0.0027417301,
0.0972865522,
0.0021765428,
-0.008010203,
-0.0905597135,
-0.0258875471,
-0.0119003439,
0.03045642,
0.0117371529,
0.0016921106,
0.0413934812,
0.0178301409,
0.0082940115,
-0.0554333441,
0.041458603,
-0.0258534383,
-0.0139896991,
-0.0250260402,
0.0271167718,
0.0153293144,
-0.0383479968,
-0.0813125148,
-0.0315451398,
-0.0769891739,
-0.0029365481,
-0.0679487213,
0.000409118,
-0.0369993709,
-0.0100368205,
0.0417688973,
0.0218362771,
0.0172164068,
0.005015586,
-0.0212129839,
0.0037798826,
0.038792599,
0.0400111526,
0.0462521873,
0.0291508604,
-0.0004045709,
0.0476009883,
-0.0329820924,
0.015331544,
-0.034445297,
0.0031763155,
-0.0449951775,
-0.0349382907,
0.0117500722,
0.0141130798,
0.0489564501,
-0.0669095144,
0.0162847377,
0.0846854374,
0.0363076106,
0.0776267499,
0.009764554,
-0.0188412946,
0.0140571436,
0.029012803,
0.0467563793,
-0.1024135947,
-0.0656488538,
0.0027123794,
0.0286707375,
-0.0249863137,
-0.0318912119,
-0.0155056026,
-0.092297554,
0.0381287448,
-0.0084981835,
-0.0355374031,
-0.0253924653,
-0.1013865694,
0.0102524646,
-0.032831829,
-0.0349977873,
0.0032441085,
0.0132626882,
0.0220545698,
-0.0000376873,
-0.0207142197,
-0.0209482647,
0.0865706131,
-0.0398251005,
0.0182005223,
0.0607649088,
0.0039648218,
-0.0101275407,
-0.0495146699,
-0.0279063657,
-0.0163008962,
0.0063711712,
0.0084616877,
0.056719467,
-0.0260230917,
0.0093697542,
-0.0603989176,
0.0542207286,
-0.0102402791,
-0.0418187939,
0.0173465479,
0.0774681941,
0.0111857038,
-0.0313256197,
-0.0455450527,
0.0221740697,
0.0021357138,
0.092071332,
0.0062837806,
0.0187778231,
-0.0512647666,
-0.0560516715,
0.0027282841,
-0.0406988859,
-0.0488606095,
0.0323395096,
0.0153888986,
-0.0568525381,
-0.0322588012,
-0.031512741,
0.0113416761,
0.0462900624,
-0.0553961247,
-0.0391845256,
0.0427305028,
0.0307501182,
-0.054459393,
0.0303176064,
-0.044970654,
0.01689923,
0.0024959289,
-0.0086066369,
0.0249892138,
0.0230662115,
-0.0426620133,
0.0148072951,
-0.0162819196,
-0.0432212427,
-0.0291916244,
0.0526658595,
0.019501593,
0.0309634767,
-0.0328778215,
0.0090700332,
-0.0103661167,
0.0758781657,
-0.0445768461,
-0.0131197898,
0.0574803799,
-0.0243988447,
-0.0011157243,
0.0006301368,
-0.0212624241,
0.0347138308,
-0.0146372141,
0.0439187922,
-0.0326960832,
-0.0278374702,
0.0586988442,
0.0285393018,
0.0455777012,
0.0114079686,
-0.042237509,
-0.0076428554,
-0.0033049986,
-0.0347641483,
-0.030747965,
-0.0061548976,
0.0422133394,
-0.0224383045,
-0.01756946,
-0.0135339405,
-0.0497356355,
-0.0910743624,
0.0024534767,
-0.0089679006,
-0.0003560845,
0.0398385301,
0.0398471244,
-0.009257582,
-0.0465326458,
-0.0332215764,
0.0069310358,
0.0311942194,
0.0733130798,
-0.0104011605,
0.0123704728,
0.0461400375,
-0.0033321334,
0.0162976943,
-0.0265354291,
-0.080831185,
-0.0007282548,
-0.0235940274,
0.0153720677,
0.0269258227,
0.0098750144,
-0.0282635223,
0.0070029264,
-0.0011548854,
-0.0018894561,
0.0211282056,
0.0071585714,
-0.0364296399,
0.0516129546,
0.0018509509,
-0.0632265657,
-0.006311954,
0.0282901432,
-0.007723622,
0.0660569742,
0.0142532876,
-0.0153681096,
-0.0527730994,
-0.050287202,
-0.0427329317,
0.0171362404,
-0.0094861863,
0.0267258622,
-0.0836135671,
-0.0495662428,
0.0118997935,
0.0252593718,
-0.0186978821,
0.0271386392,
0.010137043,
0.0477120876,
0.0325818695,
-0.0906611085,
-0.0116780214,
0.0459633842,
-0.0033810292,
-0.025349116,
-0.0028219863,
-6.040341639e-33,
-0.0056882692,
-0.019146543,
0.0148701286,
-0.0153498752,
0.0495362319,
-0.0117740668,
-0.0177328456,
-0.037390057,
-0.0532170534,
0.0422224104,
0.008226064,
0.0185103305,
0.0182659496,
-0.0085630389,
-0.0263084676,
-0.0512611233,
0.0104683638,
0.0129615301,
-0.0302040838,
0.0307034086,
0.0292253755,
0.0021837337,
0.078748405,
-0.0686517879,
0.0265452303,
-0.0182281639,
0.0104580028,
0.0324531719,
-0.0420978107,
0.0103265224,
-0.0013812344,
0.0272608865,
-0.0024018073,
-0.0349061005,
0.0379179679,
0.013605197,
-0.0774698332,
-0.0579958782,
0.0459065922,
-0.0217767488,
-0.0640816018,
-0.0127824228,
0.0342107825,
0.011893115,
-0.0085096629,
0.0093314983,
0.0370285846,
-0.0104404865,
0.0395657271,
-0.0217888523,
-0.0558433644,
0.0406187326,
-0.0080690123,
-0.028070312,
-0.0713646784,
0.0570929013,
-0.0071542016,
-0.00793334,
-0.063446857,
-0.0199071094,
0.0283261519,
-0.0135971196,
0.0514878854,
-0.03269713,
-0.0211382043,
0.0252572577,
0.0332127064,
-0.021409357,
-0.0559096262,
0.0494746938,
-0.0098030772,
0.0490137525,
0.068876572,
0.0742967576,
0.046924632,
0.040060509,
-0.130961135,
0.0340366848,
0.0453475043,
0.0570413209,
-0.0171667058,
-0.0444998927,
-0.0414826311,
0.0017962205,
-0.0477390848,
0.0199233573,
-0.0019525571,
0.0155835189,
0.020067906,
0.0015525565,
-0.0295548663,
0.016238343,
0.0004072764,
-0.0192934554,
0.0104993125,
0.0328855887,
0.0126087554,
-0.0365130343,
0.014495315,
0.0560079142,
-0.0708794892,
0.0479157008,
0.0373838022,
-0.0078034061,
0.0210543144,
0.0095306234,
-0.0050953645,
0.0033397027,
-0.0518406741,
0.0280735381,
-0.0065788343,
0.0334169306,
-0.0258601401,
-0.023929162,
0.0458316058,
0.04816835,
0.0078545427,
0.0414847545,
-0.0218144525,
-0.0104450164,
-0.0337330587,
0.0147899259,
0.0029122233,
0.0339834951,
-0.0036966559,
-0.0059737279,
-0.0203608442,
0.008286817,
-0.0502739884,
-0.0668881461,
0.0238767639,
0.0266883336,
2.634e-7,
0.0415877216,
0.0422315709,
0.032283444,
0.0411895812,
-0.018022215,
0.0544557348,
0.0194166284,
0.0366469808,
0.0176260695,
-0.0877998248,
-0.0281191524,
0.0463734753,
0.0070166821,
0.068167381,
-0.0610214733,
0.006101043,
-0.0666888505,
-0.0165613964,
-0.0674504563,
-0.0115499878,
0.0609094724,
0.1111912206,
0.0361195095,
0.001927332,
0.0242336076,
-0.0381129794,
0.0376463309,
0.0445710272,
-0.0369175784,
-0.0081859799,
0.0754231587,
-0.0110436361,
0.0119786933,
0.0601615235,
-0.0080907401,
0.0307441894,
-0.0444072373,
0.0726508498,
-0.016695343,
-0.0129027693,
-0.0410644636,
-0.0437337011,
0.0049033253,
-0.0456501134,
0.0946717858,
-0.0341623873,
-0.0085504204,
-0.0044808174,
-0.0382372029,
0.0196598023,
0.013981876,
0.016432656,
-0.0076245884,
-0.0024474433,
0.0153792007,
-0.0172575973,
0.0067527182,
-0.0288831983,
-0.0210504215,
0.0250943713,
-0.0050951238,
-0.018291479,
0.0129553601,
-0.0034228519,
0.0358791426,
-0.0711971819,
0.0106203994,
2.305703011e-34,
0.0418068022,
0.0045144251,
-0.0199105386,
-0.0227553565,
0.0634962842,
0.0132989939,
-0.0316081829,
-0.0007687523,
0.0652036816,
-0.0516672097,
-0.0090599339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18341v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18341v3 | CXR-LLAVA: a multimodal large language model for interpreting chest X-ray images | 2023-10-22T06:22:37 | 2024-01-14T13:29:15 | Seowoo Lee, Jiwon Youn, Hyungjin Kim, Mansu Kim, Soon Ho Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Purpose: This study aimed to develop an open-source multimodal large language
model (CXR-LLAVA) for interpreting chest X-ray images (CXRs), leveraging recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) to potentially replicate the image
interpretation skills of human radiologists Materials and Methods: For
training, we collected 592,580 publicly available CXRs, of which 374,881 had
labels for certain radiographic abnormalities (Dataset 1) and 217,699 provided
free-text radiology reports (Dataset 2). After pre-training a vision
transformer with Dataset 1, we integrated it with an LLM influenced by the
LLAVA network. Then, the model was fine-tuned, primarily using Dataset 2. The
model's diagnostic performance for major pathological findings was evaluated,
along with the acceptability of radiologic reports by human radiologists, to
gauge its potential for autonomous reporting. Results: The model demonstrated
impressive performance in test sets, achieving an average F1 score of 0.81 for
six major pathological findings in the MIMIC internal test set and 0.62 for
seven major pathological findings in the external test set. The model's F1
scores surpassed those of GPT-4-vision and Gemini-Pro-Vision in both test sets.
In human radiologist evaluations of the external test set, the model achieved a
72.7% success rate in autonomous reporting, slightly below the 84.0% rate of
ground truth reports. Conclusion: This study highlights the significant
potential of multimodal LLMs for CXR interpretation, while also acknowledging
the performance limitations. Despite these challenges, we believe that making
our model open-source will catalyze further research, expanding its
effectiveness and applicability in various clinical contexts. CXR-LLAVA is
available at https://github.com/ECOFRI/CXR_LLAVA. | [
0.0176673476,
0.0519571118,
0.0120978439,
0.0258765109,
-0.0149503788,
0.0408423506,
0.0095580835,
0.053558372,
-0.0170679111,
0.0001620927,
-0.0533623509,
-0.029596569,
0.0077260789,
0.0545417443,
0.0114012836,
-0.0883818194,
-0.0073583424,
-0.0242355317,
0.0028876399,
-0.0183073599,
-0.0118563436,
-0.0030871721,
0.0053769615,
0.0365891941,
-0.0245496593,
-0.0045762039,
0.0209348164,
0.0265435874,
0.0180489663,
-0.012014281,
-0.0356187224,
0.0432103463,
0.014606392,
0.0319509581,
0.0000023295,
-0.04241338,
-0.0110348463,
0.0287603494,
-0.0155431135,
-0.0399342775,
0.094825305,
-0.0734225065,
-0.0197424348,
-0.0162272789,
-0.0391163304,
-0.0670734718,
0.0606864691,
0.0497029945,
0.0796740577,
0.0565829687,
-0.0148224765,
-0.0156367701,
0.0191197377,
-0.007943186,
-0.0114087034,
-0.0548187792,
0.0198172014,
0.0611058809,
0.0072490196,
0.0335608684,
-0.0468325205,
0.0670511276,
0.0390126519,
0.0127098542,
-0.0004634495,
0.0537736379,
0.0095518921,
-0.0363998264,
-0.0063056746,
0.0427339338,
-0.0452114828,
0.0154483486,
-0.0312628411,
-0.0114303315,
-0.0168875437,
-0.0082955919,
-0.0263921916,
0.0338714421,
-0.0113528753,
-0.0106857792,
-0.0294481553,
-0.0248154905,
0.0002716166,
-0.0002738998,
-0.0425868891,
-0.0290457737,
-0.0052883178,
0.0124725448,
0.0297150966,
0.0227366071,
-0.0077678543,
-0.0427194759,
0.0096949004,
0.0333825424,
-0.0406247862,
0.0112418467,
-0.0308817476,
-0.0036728103,
0.0380079001,
-0.0732442141,
0.0224265624,
-0.0134428442,
-0.091026172,
0.0761889145,
-0.0373462476,
0.0588686466,
-0.0849156976,
0.0950412825,
-0.0354737751,
-0.0005233855,
-0.0149040865,
-0.0144491168,
-0.0104535623,
-0.0252000298,
0.0087462189,
-0.0380555429,
-0.0678816363,
-0.0191328581,
0.0132848974,
0.0130710164,
0.0455702022,
0.0538140833,
-0.045141004,
0.0209777672,
-0.0131055731,
0.0726694614,
0.0426851697,
-0.0096327756,
-0.0401473753,
-0.044144921,
0.0350869037,
0.0666595176,
-0.0098506073,
0.0026170402,
0.0018116579,
0.0542943627,
-0.0293244384,
-0.008110391,
0.0237496383,
-0.0425110646,
-0.0322758891,
-0.037397109,
0.0409188606,
-0.0846196711,
0.0073786471,
0.0128554385,
0.0538916774,
-0.0142764486,
-0.0156258717,
-0.0166221093,
-0.0221731979,
0.0528351068,
-0.044225309,
-0.0031858538,
0.0231317244,
0.0247426759,
0.0327469744,
0.027639417,
0.0174710732,
0.0050784415,
-0.018326465,
-0.0172522571,
0.0110698612,
0.0363083258,
-0.0746580884,
-0.025938116,
-0.0463204198,
0.0006096155,
0.0042286352,
0.0918691829,
0.0321391784,
0.0337620378,
-0.0068818042,
-0.0450051688,
0.049009569,
0.0348269492,
0.0491822138,
0.0013641454,
0.0331216604,
-0.0033691798,
-0.0089598745,
-0.0311087612,
-0.0209205225,
0.0463129543,
0.0414421149,
-0.0232752953,
-0.0474213138,
0.0101057524,
-0.0336120054,
-0.0285764914,
-0.0478405803,
-0.0202446654,
-0.0391141996,
-0.0019126883,
0.0820201114,
-0.0245362073,
-0.031427227,
0.0077446597,
0.0145290457,
-0.0034519401,
-0.0180547312,
-0.0897139981,
-0.033028163,
0.0528028719,
0.0187194981,
-0.0028085541,
-0.0091245221,
-0.0030828782,
0.047701519,
0.0281784683,
0.016434703,
0.0207492132,
0.0265010446,
-0.0513937138,
-0.0515771173,
0.0625611544,
0.0157959219,
-0.0081969779,
-0.0311927404,
-0.0002759925,
-0.0282909703,
-0.0335564017,
0.0033929874,
0.0418511033,
-0.0190545972,
-0.0151245268,
-0.0262151957,
0.0231695361,
0.0167745538,
-0.0074959323,
-0.0313793086,
-0.0289058182,
-0.0038251805,
0.0129430639,
-0.0398419425,
0.0418174192,
-0.0430473983,
0.0162616912,
0.0393537171,
-0.0630553365,
-0.0131586958,
0.0262713879,
-0.0428411476,
0.0057451827,
-0.02649571,
-0.0696825013,
-0.0041271974,
-0.0254324619,
0.0062644919,
0.0357400924,
0.0152894575,
-0.0014400263,
0.0321937092,
-0.0189848375,
-0.0103982082,
0.0098322742,
-0.0203799177,
0.0169001482,
-0.0597693883,
-0.0145786339,
0.034868829,
0.013533365,
0.0256314408,
-0.0273877662,
0.0416043513,
-0.014170561,
-0.0173896272,
-0.0317119993,
-0.0213306751,
-0.0038623621,
-0.0411249362,
0.0568935387,
-0.0151430629,
-0.0017519471,
-0.0466612913,
0.0038389247,
0.0137003129,
0.0812824741,
0.0175231583,
0.0290909652,
0.0230644904,
-0.0090310043,
-0.0155216651,
-0.0167362522,
-0.0162882265,
0.0225828793,
0.0391044877,
-0.0293331929,
-0.03930071,
0.0345629156,
-0.0159034282,
0.0302681904,
-0.0033896081,
-0.058688201,
0.0233817007,
-0.0616315678,
-0.0661648363,
0.0840971768,
-0.0229781829,
0.0274876691,
0.0149609288,
-0.0048500109,
-0.0136316884,
-0.0306432378,
-0.001445396,
-0.0935899094,
-0.023401754,
-0.0593674183,
-0.0504317358,
0.0666277409,
0.0181526281,
0.0291584153,
-0.034495391,
-0.0295395162,
-0.055671785,
-0.0357447043,
-0.062050119,
0.0078388629,
0.0005128119,
0.0258289166,
-0.0233935006,
-0.0434552617,
0.070624806,
-0.0123702409,
0.0023265786,
-0.0296560265,
-0.0055047283,
-0.0276023466,
0.0316840596,
0.0241424106,
0.0480608754,
0.0179436915,
-0.0139782606,
-0.0376640745,
0.0041141445,
-0.0085696569,
-0.0721496269,
0.0031502158,
-0.0507599786,
0.0050874627,
-0.0228127148,
-0.0041082567,
-0.0186969936,
-0.0000456397,
-0.0081450287,
-0.0081135202,
-0.0186312497,
0.0137766972,
-0.0626151264,
0.0470325761,
0.0228278618,
0.0317033865,
0.004214827,
-0.0168405082,
-0.0094900522,
0.035573408,
0.0181800481,
0.0502122752,
-0.0181473866,
-0.0482478477,
-0.0099752825,
0.082333073,
-0.0316584855,
0.0212240107,
-0.0827357471,
0.0192892794,
0.0012987608,
0.0589991324,
0.0059653963,
-0.0001770138,
0.0441648588,
-0.0458509661,
-0.0016692107,
0.0660527423,
0.0138857383,
-0.0410744846,
-0.0421030149,
0.0087089166,
-0.0469479226,
-0.0129105067,
-0.0156948548,
-0.053063862,
-0.0363498442,
-0.0083811097,
0.0248503052,
0.0010765619,
-0.0114927208,
0.0322287753,
-0.0216042716,
0.0718898699,
-0.0000811139,
-0.0480967388,
-0.0493350886,
-0.0260070022,
0.0177035574,
-0.0491481423,
-0.0228941943,
-0.0031187609,
-0.0054911901,
-0.0242514946,
-0.0037522756,
-0.0173200183,
-0.045744434,
0.0303004123,
-0.0547648259,
-0.0481032431,
0.0461284965,
0.0146176163,
-0.0480608828,
-0.0367285348,
-0.0180316903,
0.0552692339,
0.0281438082,
0.02108985,
0.0770879462,
0.0006894188,
-0.0209181011,
-0.0470896475,
0.0363024808,
-0.0163565204,
0.0160582159,
-0.0573769026,
0.0430597179,
-0.0088277962,
-0.0200722273,
-0.0625151768,
0.0285842046,
0.0120115597,
0.0061346805,
-0.0230772234,
-0.0086995549,
-0.0182371158,
0.0025515251,
0.07597588,
0.0119231855,
-0.0518017374,
0.0747531131,
-0.046269428,
-0.054712791,
-0.0268805698,
-0.0184614751,
0.0111463526,
0.0155090922,
0.0025011227,
-0.0048832232,
-0.0008149841,
0.0066107195,
-0.0512580723,
0.0837808549,
0.0065080109,
0.0327716731,
-0.0318926908,
-0.0088405833,
0.0617975108,
-0.0169294197,
0.0011115754,
0.0676198378,
-0.0456103645,
0.0394164138,
0.0087835956,
0.0599724874,
0.0278975703,
-0.0194430612,
-0.0188187081,
-0.0418789126,
0.0415311456,
0.034910392,
-0.0189591311,
0.0412495323,
0.0006296571,
-0.0592451468,
-0.0265015513,
-0.0002793307,
-0.0165191609,
0.0126102241,
0.0231451802,
-0.0151702669,
-0.0447910503,
-0.0362241156,
0.0223851185,
0.0296659283,
0.0261650458,
-0.0225570165,
-0.0070374119,
-0.0021922518,
-0.0054347748,
0.0046037454,
0.0298361294,
-0.0281884558,
0.0162127595,
0.0299205817,
0.0060260389,
0.0112738507,
-0.0068860115,
-0.0119564673,
-0.0360888429,
-0.0544912405,
0.0694866925,
0.0366360918,
-0.034752015,
0.0496071614,
0.0034939377,
-0.0043360027,
-0.0438892916,
0.0061221397,
-0.0074578659,
0.0287480988,
0.0706114769,
0.0067425463,
0.0259919968,
0.0015229767,
0.0356651507,
0.012379854,
-0.0470682904,
-0.0326356515,
0.021158319,
0.0630610362,
0.0135672353,
0.0001477481,
-0.0416216068,
0.0085063307,
-0.018050395,
0.062054988,
-0.0061046924,
0.0114561729,
0.0838083327,
-0.0037650487,
0.0363817364,
-0.0272344574,
0.0608705506,
0.0200306736,
0.0255630072,
-0.0474434868,
-0.0306133851,
-0.065469034,
-0.0153582562,
0.0254063495,
-0.0274757743,
-0.0397362225,
0.0105979126,
-0.0171126705,
-0.0757547468,
-0.0023489872,
0.0267073736,
0.0010138354,
-0.0241967086,
0.035576243,
0.0710351244,
0.0138595318,
-0.0615197457,
-0.0122164711,
0.0266796984,
0.0144139696,
-0.0012515261,
0.0489420295,
-6.287148433e-33,
0.0083720488,
-0.0074206935,
0.0530116037,
-0.0616535433,
0.013260291,
0.0418891311,
-0.0223662611,
-0.0051076757,
-0.0115538277,
0.013696949,
-0.0038176652,
-0.0167679042,
0.0247799214,
0.0148410639,
0.0079958392,
-0.0042061433,
0.0101657473,
-0.0270484649,
0.01220595,
-0.0211764965,
-0.0094299112,
0.0102894278,
0.0493610501,
-0.1304260194,
-0.037030749,
0.0312960111,
-0.0125571005,
0.00590593,
-0.0092666959,
0.0448321588,
-0.0435348488,
0.0191038214,
0.0373413973,
-0.0610746741,
-0.0038693927,
0.0236553364,
-0.0574624725,
0.0354255624,
-0.0027161965,
0.0759098455,
-0.0626087412,
0.0164789464,
0.0610145144,
-0.0344796069,
0.0260426309,
-0.0349309631,
0.0435222536,
-0.0350305624,
0.0104813408,
0.0258461405,
-0.0206532367,
0.0604930408,
0.024167655,
-0.02671507,
0.0234427825,
-0.0127226636,
-0.0390653126,
0.0376503803,
-0.0189215951,
0.0237488206,
0.0691753775,
0.0152922338,
0.0382866636,
0.0049422183,
-0.0260325316,
0.0429239348,
0.0711278245,
-0.0951715857,
-0.0091734715,
0.0029143542,
-0.0017364563,
0.0649549291,
0.0575175285,
0.0779611692,
0.001882189,
-0.0113661112,
-0.0601941161,
0.0261092465,
-0.0729533285,
0.0883935466,
0.0198664013,
0.0063466267,
-0.0287448727,
0.0183100402,
0.0258281566,
-0.0416180119,
-0.0307337567,
-0.0132529084,
0.0351060815,
0.026593009,
0.0102985613,
0.0471880846,
0.0574333183,
-0.0120584145,
0.0010918707,
-0.0270877313,
0.0392298214,
0.0672206134,
-0.0379755907,
0.0084374733,
-0.0165709555,
-0.0279648993,
0.0393879823,
0.0044596493,
0.0551732965,
0.0002062211,
0.0217899512,
0.0347760841,
-0.0484829843,
0.0103858737,
-0.003631202,
-0.0281080026,
0.0067571127,
0.012709856,
0.0621300042,
-0.0046098339,
-0.0222721584,
0.0392253138,
-0.0282013714,
-0.0170717668,
-0.0390317254,
-0.0653246567,
-0.0208510682,
-0.0095331324,
-0.0503877923,
-0.0183139797,
-0.034701746,
-0.0330494121,
0.0619237423,
-0.0418966785,
-0.0282500815,
0.0396478623,
3.04e-7,
0.0495921187,
0.0359368324,
0.0024121497,
-0.0229534935,
0.0123135215,
0.0269973483,
-0.0530309118,
0.0287043937,
0.0363921709,
-0.0486167036,
-0.0059814574,
0.0288990289,
-0.0119003821,
0.0346450955,
-0.0257018637,
-0.0035317822,
-0.0042627477,
0.0164317358,
-0.0208667405,
0.0130062532,
0.0805816725,
0.0728526786,
-0.0517084673,
-0.0608429424,
0.0308931414,
-0.0210002474,
0.0282002129,
-0.0303945206,
0.0348722488,
-0.0323249437,
0.0044978908,
0.0122717712,
0.0053029582,
0.0701700225,
0.042291753,
-0.0437143967,
0.0388798006,
0.0836330578,
-0.0546201803,
0.0098872706,
0.0286403093,
0.0234812945,
-0.0126590077,
-0.0607302859,
0.0378177129,
-0.0549782291,
-0.0150586581,
-0.0027672776,
-0.0278735813,
0.0034777015,
0.0205290858,
-0.0583258979,
-0.0115491562,
0.0486119837,
0.0248188283,
0.0096233413,
-0.0555324219,
-0.0702318922,
0.001323242,
0.0072851307,
-0.0315853283,
-0.0320835859,
0.0092513654,
-0.0084942253,
0.0142373694,
-0.0326101296,
-0.0293415114,
2.220685382e-34,
-0.0001530649,
0.0111249452,
0.0074550179,
-0.0216916632,
0.0056153848,
0.0094747227,
-0.0019390974,
0.0325043201,
-0.0192447081,
-0.0491750315,
-0.001392805
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.