id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13409v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13409v1 | Explicit Alignment and Many-to-many Entailment Based Reasoning for Conversational Machine Reading | 2023-10-20T10:27:24 | 2023-10-20T10:27:24 | Yangyang Luo, Shiyu Tian, Caixia Yuan, Xiaojie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational Machine Reading (CMR) requires answering a user's initial
question through multi-turn dialogue interactions based on a given document.
Although there exist many effective methods, they largely neglected the
alignment between the document and the user-provided information, which
significantly affects the intermediate decision-making and subsequent follow-up
question generation. To address this issue, we propose a pipeline framework
that (1) aligns the aforementioned two sides in an explicit way, (2)makes
decisions using a lightweight many-to-many entailment reasoning module, and (3)
directly generates follow-up questions based on the document and previously
asked questions. Our proposed method achieves state-of-the-art in
micro-accuracy and ranks the first place on the public leaderboard of the CMR
benchmark dataset ShARC. | [
0.0101818722,
0.0148816947,
-0.0103752334,
0.0449061804,
-0.0533499271,
0.0170456953,
0.0103117405,
-0.0438473523,
0.0400589481,
0.0195871815,
0.0134098101,
0.0356787704,
0.0038100553,
0.0311999898,
-0.0071388721,
-0.043854814,
0.0440063514,
-0.0289545804,
-0.0008630781,
-0.0173798781,
0.0394816995,
0.0363507047,
-0.0638075024,
0.0187876858,
0.0211724062,
-0.073566094,
-0.0714262947,
0.0090127233,
0.0393700935,
-0.0212832466,
-0.0105599361,
0.0116643943,
0.0158127695,
0.0335515887,
0.0000017576,
-0.0640956461,
-0.0526124761,
0.0110914614,
-0.0294450894,
-0.0663817897,
-0.0190096255,
-0.019099405,
0.0328207575,
0.0194907952,
-0.0258692689,
0.0360125713,
0.0251606479,
0.0510085635,
0.0702053979,
0.061427407,
-0.0190012269,
-0.003014951,
0.0379108749,
0.0294704102,
0.052751191,
-0.0590116344,
-0.0410241038,
0.0698096603,
0.0338003524,
0.0042558331,
0.0182824899,
0.0419641659,
0.0204508957,
-0.0202346127,
-0.0247045644,
0.0060759396,
-0.0086254124,
-0.0363391452,
-0.0052293204,
0.0880976692,
0.0178271346,
0.0028870685,
0.0044261478,
-0.0139182443,
-0.0010724128,
0.0096246591,
-0.0252387188,
-0.0217302106,
-0.0619541407,
-0.0187347867,
-0.0032463474,
0.0279359967,
0.0164730754,
0.026769422,
-0.0337327272,
0.0432899259,
0.0021168811,
-0.0240766704,
-0.0171909314,
0.0225489791,
0.0033181249,
-0.0240441598,
0.0519896597,
0.0551775731,
-0.0870469138,
0.0304487962,
-0.0700987205,
-0.0013625462,
0.0340925381,
-0.0261100754,
-0.010363536,
0.0838524178,
0.0027015794,
0.0551719181,
-0.0014129274,
0.0241724979,
-0.0414727516,
-0.0050696498,
-0.0414832756,
-0.0379658416,
-0.0117489258,
-0.0151411658,
-0.0208556466,
0.0205251779,
-0.0384091996,
-0.0540375486,
-0.0211106129,
0.0791750625,
0.0430222005,
0.0612788126,
-0.0071000205,
0.003191621,
-0.0217232723,
-0.025693832,
-0.0355294161,
0.0297516584,
-0.0401583277,
0.0085092988,
0.0190962814,
-0.0107796779,
-0.0057673133,
0.0009510557,
0.0189908314,
-0.0263462849,
-0.0273764748,
0.0756229237,
-0.029943971,
-0.0387002006,
-0.0085354876,
-0.0289617181,
0.0070454637,
-0.0681039393,
-0.016799964,
-0.0418541543,
0.0733037964,
0.0470383428,
-0.0214506183,
0.0409830175,
-0.0010606997,
0.0351067111,
0.0066394033,
0.0864016786,
-0.0016088226,
0.007763728,
0.0457071885,
0.0185923688,
-0.0465082042,
0.0462373532,
0.0598460995,
0.0144398101,
0.0405476466,
-0.0071149594,
-0.0357657224,
0.0130488481,
-0.0025949094,
-0.0373786241,
0.0798234791,
0.0334624462,
-0.0281231739,
0.0505781136,
0.0036922668,
0.0377696268,
-0.0221822988,
0.0076784161,
0.0610881746,
0.0263933949,
0.0286447275,
-0.0151860779,
0.0033435454,
0.0521363765,
-0.0010883387,
0.0476584844,
-0.0288418327,
0.0358094089,
-0.0267880838,
0.0431247503,
0.044023525,
0.0116421208,
0.0086440472,
-0.0219643842,
0.0321026035,
0.0499274321,
-0.0276321303,
0.0292845443,
0.0316894911,
-0.0096885292,
-0.0708354861,
0.0296656098,
0.0039045925,
-0.0265487693,
-0.0281935949,
-0.0011976114,
0.0631087199,
0.0629452467,
0.0634988695,
-0.0006208693,
-0.0765122101,
0.0035678404,
-0.013250717,
0.047553353,
0.0405834988,
-0.0203119945,
0.038288638,
-0.0438628383,
0.0058031105,
0.0194369275,
-0.0362991914,
0.0102927433,
0.0151744401,
0.0058780937,
0.0170099195,
-0.0269511752,
0.0119092092,
0.0308310483,
-0.0160254277,
-0.003437378,
-0.0216426663,
0.0369990356,
0.0307511818,
0.0133837443,
0.0306888409,
0.0000307362,
0.0188608076,
0.0020973666,
0.0032996503,
0.0339008756,
-0.0877841786,
-0.0512690768,
0.0142586911,
-0.04320658,
-0.0533551238,
-0.0125084938,
-0.0259677619,
-0.0654083788,
-0.0438636579,
-0.0256681126,
0.0053364709,
-0.0488282777,
0.0081976298,
0.0429365747,
-0.0184986256,
-0.0164607055,
0.0368151292,
0.0125350915,
0.015896529,
0.0056882715,
0.0092809377,
-0.0015931798,
-0.0422565304,
-0.0043505635,
0.0021983441,
-0.0100497054,
0.0005400403,
-0.0013456648,
0.002714131,
-0.0794733241,
-0.0279511716,
-0.0756096095,
0.0205904972,
0.0152480351,
0.0225375704,
0.0139543777,
0.0276673902,
-0.00697004,
-0.0213769283,
-0.0389330201,
0.0077871401,
0.0338098146,
-0.0045578345,
0.0527959503,
0.0071351072,
-0.0039449818,
-0.0202499013,
0.0071899481,
-0.0388385206,
0.0197657868,
0.0350245647,
0.0162324831,
-0.070136793,
-0.0275544208,
-0.0037277492,
0.0060596494,
-0.0202711001,
0.0308990888,
0.0520183519,
-0.0139115388,
0.0398214348,
0.0375885516,
0.0059282319,
0.0191625506,
0.0085111381,
-0.0273374505,
-0.0859074742,
0.0500570089,
-0.0155082913,
0.0073452699,
-0.0138396267,
-0.0335974805,
-0.0038747895,
0.0348511674,
-0.0296488144,
0.0165311582,
-0.0181879774,
0.0116603645,
0.0524552688,
-0.0047196108,
-0.0660765842,
-0.0225239415,
-0.0265975296,
0.0585101806,
-0.0251929406,
-0.0213129576,
0.07816118,
-0.0731785893,
-0.0229438748,
-0.080266878,
0.0138602406,
-0.0136468261,
0.0976394564,
-0.006159496,
0.0050099338,
-0.0133127421,
-0.0590075254,
-0.0629961491,
0.0198282991,
0.0524642579,
-0.0065487516,
0.0456460863,
-0.0361315235,
0.0187956821,
-0.0210455582,
-0.0164311342,
-0.0623788945,
0.0044807815,
-0.0040110992,
-0.0354194306,
-0.0129838157,
-0.0145313004,
-0.0802766606,
0.0123390164,
0.0238376576,
0.0323770531,
-0.0207159761,
-0.0192681979,
-0.0422388613,
0.0626950338,
0.0653729141,
0.0234832205,
0.018535113,
-0.0415401608,
0.0808346719,
0.051817894,
0.0185864009,
-0.0215468556,
-0.0020173811,
-0.028689241,
0.0228201468,
-0.043055106,
0.0342772193,
-0.0181890298,
0.0436233394,
-0.0831667334,
-0.0131165069,
0.0883801281,
0.0329793766,
-0.0351353474,
-0.0176382307,
-0.051143948,
0.0366444886,
-0.010537752,
0.0536445752,
-0.0825396329,
-0.0291119143,
0.0273365043,
0.0388086252,
0.011864746,
-0.0300688278,
-0.013127503,
-0.0709241256,
0.0070709023,
-0.0145707438,
-0.0505158938,
-0.0266633444,
-0.0238068644,
-0.0011464059,
0.0307808593,
0.0401277691,
0.0418380164,
-0.0040525529,
-0.021461878,
-0.0314393975,
0.0368342176,
0.0192069933,
0.0262675416,
-0.0204051733,
-0.0238088407,
0.038633734,
0.041453559,
0.0668970495,
-0.0006028099,
-0.0011687527,
-0.0107678268,
-0.0246258564,
0.0064280871,
0.0299898032,
-0.0435401686,
0.0046570236,
-0.0586295649,
0.0483774468,
-0.0174341016,
-0.0102447625,
0.0352878012,
0.007042787,
-0.0422185622,
-0.0094350241,
-0.0211464502,
0.0310255885,
0.0107756574,
0.0634423345,
-0.0050885025,
0.001727242,
-0.0547631793,
-0.0139464559,
-0.013496751,
-0.0429635271,
0.0346479937,
-0.0164599363,
-0.0006503733,
0.0254692249,
-0.0624119453,
-0.070284903,
0.0134737492,
0.0325315706,
-0.0053337491,
-0.015892975,
0.076741457,
0.0068899221,
-0.0282984413,
0.0279605631,
-0.0110094976,
0.0135205844,
-0.0248456113,
0.0126349283,
0.0270494111,
-0.0148427682,
-0.0173368808,
0.051471822,
-0.0913432166,
-0.0335483626,
-0.0361757688,
0.0179577488,
0.0238436908,
0.0635000765,
-0.0180372074,
0.017610589,
-0.0022446939,
-0.0021860071,
-0.0794501454,
-0.037488699,
0.0035504429,
0.0344016328,
-0.0283876341,
0.0400371067,
-0.0143823428,
-0.0228489079,
-0.0435781367,
0.0663054064,
-0.0414132476,
-0.074998863,
0.020569725,
-0.0095733479,
0.0027863695,
0.0155255701,
0.0326942578,
-0.0237256438,
0.0718240291,
0.0019699489,
-0.0400597863,
-0.0152359316,
-0.0102123925,
-0.0146274362,
-0.0336206034,
0.0186380707,
-0.0215028524,
-0.0078793932,
0.058182966,
0.0010722288,
0.0156047987,
0.0250452589,
0.0266896188,
0.0392448194,
-0.0311334915,
-0.0491326526,
0.0294486023,
0.0155726634,
0.0807926804,
-0.0098946299,
0.1017458662,
0.0402493514,
-0.0015903518,
-0.0093568023,
0.0048927949,
-0.0674470365,
-0.0241349041,
0.0091335084,
0.0338071808,
-0.0019788111,
0.0118368734,
0.0501024053,
-0.0193371288,
0.0134869339,
0.0004731245,
0.0581882223,
-0.0136459684,
-0.0238770153,
0.0231917072,
0.0189669859,
0.0059688222,
0.0049807066,
0.0274804085,
-0.0690988749,
-0.009916693,
0.0078585222,
-0.0108809946,
-0.0833473653,
-0.0802493468,
-0.0070123659,
0.0535011739,
-0.0350100659,
-0.0117278518,
-0.01566118,
-0.0491043888,
-0.0017602463,
0.0211044829,
-0.0188894328,
0.0083168009,
0.0126167824,
0.0616775416,
0.0178106893,
-0.0438808613,
-0.025129471,
0.0220404938,
-0.0675432459,
-0.0379112065,
-0.0330315866,
-5.763996142e-33,
-0.0572300404,
-0.0363055095,
0.0440754108,
-0.0179634541,
0.0099768369,
-0.023393875,
-0.0557041653,
-0.0169594456,
-0.0262373872,
-0.0087818429,
-0.0274373051,
-0.0016166796,
0.024546789,
0.0416066535,
-0.0129799377,
-0.0077323448,
0.0353839025,
0.0273377541,
-0.0235404987,
0.0254014041,
0.0509232767,
0.0276211593,
-0.0129728513,
-0.0426244624,
0.0402562134,
-0.0360513516,
-0.0181743186,
0.0342355557,
-0.0336227752,
0.0293339267,
-0.0292045157,
-0.0038109685,
0.015885992,
0.0233844686,
0.0102679143,
0.0582380965,
-0.1222937182,
-0.0141865844,
0.0131329568,
0.0147823934,
-0.0493839346,
-0.0128026921,
-0.0128854793,
-0.0182396825,
0.0628471449,
-0.0324352756,
0.029179221,
-0.006192619,
-0.0152011747,
-0.0097623002,
-0.0676183477,
0.02654019,
-0.0297281742,
-0.0325766988,
-0.0463115163,
0.0628312081,
0.0427564345,
0.0134364422,
-0.0809410736,
-0.0062825372,
-0.0232399106,
-0.0143496953,
0.0569456704,
0.0074762949,
-0.0026212931,
0.0347526856,
0.0058054738,
-0.0255383048,
-0.0035168221,
0.0377458967,
0.0137817319,
0.0138144884,
-0.0037008389,
0.0405052677,
0.0176939163,
0.0519222207,
-0.0409429744,
0.0435779318,
0.0204987302,
0.0741984621,
0.013976926,
-0.0016746225,
-0.0481780246,
0.0006758625,
-0.0361588113,
0.0133254668,
-0.0413685217,
-0.0197297707,
0.0270617381,
-0.006465381,
-0.0081331087,
-0.0003297434,
0.0421930142,
-0.0134057943,
0.0018647334,
0.0143438959,
-0.0223136153,
-0.0041785445,
-0.0451794304,
0.0799304396,
-0.0308464915,
-0.012046162,
0.0130593814,
-0.0265602469,
0.004915921,
0.0277607478,
0.010552573,
-0.0321072713,
-0.0485697389,
0.0078610759,
-0.033160083,
0.0325264521,
-0.0715442598,
0.0236978885,
0.0379674882,
-0.0043866774,
-0.0322995521,
0.0516342744,
-0.0248175859,
0.0210605823,
-0.060375426,
-0.0397665389,
-0.0144852493,
0.0251845904,
-0.0219227523,
0.0035282804,
-0.0230272133,
-0.0076997834,
0.0276435614,
-0.0532894321,
0.0384047516,
0.0413111039,
2.52e-7,
0.0174258091,
0.0126844645,
0.0467693843,
0.0600525178,
-0.0114880214,
0.0204116311,
0.0082852645,
0.0076370076,
0.0339812562,
-0.0163705442,
0.038192112,
0.0147312675,
0.0547197498,
0.0270188246,
-0.1037385091,
-0.0459696464,
-0.0570130348,
-0.0151056377,
-0.043945048,
0.0307678562,
0.0664408654,
0.0447720625,
-0.0015411553,
-0.0166996997,
0.0211029202,
-0.0312211383,
0.0307320226,
-0.0055802763,
-0.0015286587,
0.022500705,
0.0307464339,
-0.0264704041,
-0.010316981,
0.0226408746,
0.0224775877,
0.0175434407,
-0.0101384902,
0.0495775379,
0.0476616919,
-0.0653314292,
-0.0454473011,
-0.0000020754,
0.0232777875,
-0.0638203546,
0.0500891842,
-0.0326534659,
-0.0264983103,
0.0112297954,
-0.0564704165,
-0.0356143825,
-0.0504891314,
0.0116619151,
-0.020864265,
0.0293539502,
0.0149589051,
-0.0542090237,
0.0297501814,
-0.0758138746,
-0.0262313262,
0.0017614699,
-0.0315138623,
-0.0369402207,
-0.0251801461,
-0.0352189392,
0.0522458367,
-0.0388329439,
-0.0230492894,
1.722210115e-34,
0.002329225,
-0.0015093463,
0.0167168397,
0.026407199,
0.0404483899,
-0.0002429397,
0.0002482463,
0.0175821353,
0.0273474958,
-0.0963117927,
-0.0300432891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13395v1 | Cache me if you Can: an Online Cost-aware Teacher-Student framework to Reduce the Calls to Large Language Models | 2023-10-20T10:05:07 | 2023-10-20T10:05:07 | Ilias Stogiannidis, Stavros Vassos, Prodromos Malakasiotis, Ion Androutsopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting Large Language Models (LLMs) performs impressively in zero- and
few-shot settings. Hence, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) that cannot
afford the cost of creating large task-specific training datasets, but also the
cost of pretraining their own LLMs, are increasingly turning to third-party
services that allow them to prompt LLMs. However, such services currently
require a payment per call, which becomes a significant operating expense
(OpEx). Furthermore, customer inputs are often very similar over time, hence
SMEs end-up prompting LLMs with very similar instances. We propose a framework
that allows reducing the calls to LLMs by caching previous LLM responses and
using them to train a local inexpensive model on the SME side. The framework
includes criteria for deciding when to trust the local model or call the LLM,
and a methodology to tune the criteria and measure the tradeoff between
performance and cost. For experimental purposes, we instantiate our framework
with two LLMs, GPT-3.5 or GPT-4, and two inexpensive students, a k-NN
classifier or a Multi-Layer Perceptron, using two common business tasks, intent
recognition and sentiment analysis. Experimental results indicate that
significant OpEx savings can be obtained with only slightly lower performance. | [
0.0518496931,
0.0665955022,
-0.0107039707,
0.0552155003,
-0.0660759807,
0.022644233,
0.0401003882,
0.0020081403,
0.0640944541,
-0.1042506248,
-0.0241017248,
-0.0401546769,
-0.0129714301,
0.0243183859,
-0.0132479817,
-0.0297573712,
0.0220417175,
-0.0054758755,
0.0136346556,
-0.017182719,
0.0051326309,
0.015814811,
-0.0124317184,
0.0171278939,
0.0054344037,
-0.012952636,
-0.0119584417,
0.0092054028,
-0.0012069363,
-0.0010049652,
0.0442876928,
0.0372427478,
-0.004133367,
0.0445416979,
0.0000020814,
-0.077984117,
-0.0442527793,
-0.0164882429,
-0.0570850857,
0.0430456921,
0.0826002434,
0.0310902297,
-0.0084176445,
0.0516209789,
-0.0437708236,
0.0166023597,
0.0430894345,
0.0187165886,
0.0374841541,
0.0705664232,
-0.0088301599,
-0.0341254212,
-0.037619561,
-0.006276953,
-0.0380000062,
-0.0703000799,
0.0487748682,
-0.0320909321,
-0.0566737503,
-0.0350340344,
-0.0052797496,
0.0298645571,
0.0103425318,
0.005436419,
-0.0033601806,
0.0304939356,
-0.0306228101,
0.0113488501,
-0.035024967,
0.0237159804,
0.008887751,
-0.0114618335,
0.0225796476,
-0.0376151204,
-0.020140795,
-0.0131497923,
0.0082626473,
0.005453187,
0.0158231296,
0.0314193591,
-0.0207984652,
-0.0116099203,
-0.0011116331,
0.0354269668,
-0.0097194761,
0.007809733,
-0.0205550622,
-0.0372323282,
0.0096675595,
0.0743787363,
0.015892949,
-0.0300596431,
0.023123173,
0.0198444966,
0.0111792265,
0.0289283451,
-0.0254226401,
-0.0104665747,
0.0037728266,
-0.0464909077,
0.0162536763,
0.0305863433,
-0.0021453586,
0.0487658903,
-0.0395163819,
0.0121690938,
0.0091762487,
-0.0116273407,
-0.0399936512,
0.0363776721,
-0.0896298066,
0.0047792913,
-0.0351414382,
0.0505035222,
0.0093465559,
-0.0120759998,
-0.0785919204,
0.0097583439,
0.0020422556,
0.0134920618,
0.0111897709,
-0.0085408175,
0.0313150696,
0.0228408463,
-0.0399843082,
0.0714939162,
-0.0012799782,
0.015789168,
-0.046250172,
-0.0763348043,
0.0086474326,
0.0171841439,
0.0419536158,
0.0238594171,
0.0275155324,
0.015202268,
-0.0108110188,
-0.0695816129,
-0.0859362334,
-0.0260167047,
0.0064340457,
-0.0659675375,
-0.0379128866,
-0.0483077988,
0.0094705578,
0.0037054361,
-0.0021104263,
0.0081563452,
0.0035813313,
0.0060092914,
-0.0355868079,
0.0365904048,
0.0175291989,
0.0265802741,
0.0200724844,
-0.0196363777,
0.0118354009,
0.0814533234,
0.0227868408,
0.0012239137,
0.0596974567,
-0.0336460359,
-0.0355380625,
0.0478587486,
0.0158068594,
0.0079376576,
0.0091934949,
-0.0031630644,
-0.007303596,
0.0032526786,
-0.010251414,
0.0327813067,
-0.0197585486,
0.0440087356,
0.0654972792,
0.0357087851,
-0.0073873238,
-0.0123686967,
0.0003512966,
0.0637354329,
-0.0179350115,
-0.0380593091,
-0.0077510122,
-0.0191206299,
-0.0501968041,
-0.0090955105,
0.0248146765,
-0.0007650201,
-0.0341577567,
-0.0346778855,
-0.0192926116,
-0.0397544689,
0.0047789682,
0.0722986162,
0.074441649,
-0.0562889203,
-0.0459465384,
0.058815781,
-0.0100068944,
-0.0395310074,
-0.0042587989,
-0.0691765621,
-0.0020871216,
0.1076807603,
0.0356763229,
-0.0101906983,
-0.0060271197,
-0.0167435594,
-0.0261769444,
0.0374586731,
0.0743409693,
0.0131001519,
0.028590966,
-0.0759562552,
-0.0163976215,
0.0171314385,
0.0169817191,
0.0307424273,
0.0367654674,
0.0467057452,
0.0285433754,
0.0002118472,
-0.0235623028,
0.0155692846,
-0.0080981823,
-0.0609882884,
0.0022839943,
0.0454412624,
0.0308803171,
0.0217297152,
0.0248628706,
-0.0182603858,
0.0007894682,
-0.0004688525,
-0.0167938955,
-0.0295908172,
-0.0322532281,
-0.0080530616,
0.0302344412,
0.0316097066,
0.0032275321,
0.0126203382,
-0.0374379158,
-0.0575684533,
0.0070973975,
-0.0227120388,
0.0708213076,
-0.0366873108,
-0.003183146,
-0.0266530663,
-0.0050712051,
-0.0043146792,
0.0316394493,
0.0232366193,
0.0439313613,
-0.0083372984,
-0.0117376857,
0.0178357176,
-0.0383757241,
-0.0293085109,
-0.0239461064,
-0.0032223789,
0.0470677912,
0.0016185284,
0.0339204893,
-0.0393950157,
-0.0128752533,
-0.0824394524,
-0.0383716114,
-0.0035367887,
0.026277028,
0.0072483351,
-0.0110330973,
-0.021723548,
-0.036470823,
-0.0329786763,
0.0284001026,
0.0122104315,
0.0546816438,
0.0025331995,
-0.0107247513,
-0.0357306264,
-0.0197655521,
0.0093345437,
0.0052801566,
0.0358468667,
0.0226814896,
-0.0581526197,
-0.0720894411,
0.0515049063,
-0.0251687374,
0.0156407095,
0.0094115669,
-0.040437229,
-0.0212709792,
-0.0235790666,
-0.0141129363,
0.0580658503,
-0.032546863,
-0.0254369359,
0.0397581607,
-0.024874676,
-0.1010131165,
-0.0087600136,
-0.0086993175,
-0.058881782,
-0.0375387333,
-0.0378044508,
0.0101124514,
0.0595953874,
-0.0054347301,
-0.008815405,
-0.0278271195,
-0.0124046234,
-0.0209050104,
-0.0160322804,
-0.0407071933,
0.0052791727,
-0.0093857152,
0.0366706513,
0.0518286377,
-0.0438460149,
0.0666098297,
0.0059018661,
0.0001356793,
-0.0437965468,
-0.0344517902,
-0.0389056765,
0.0365915336,
-0.0340326987,
0.0305027068,
0.0057935207,
-0.0457102656,
-0.0154829994,
0.005569315,
0.0550892726,
-0.0571268536,
0.0391232148,
-0.0159794074,
0.0437194295,
-0.0300343037,
-0.0384063162,
-0.0296348929,
-0.051358927,
-0.0689011663,
-0.0330686085,
-0.0088840667,
0.0051387153,
-0.0131870536,
0.0226862393,
-0.0086296955,
0.0780519173,
-0.0091854492,
-0.0071435221,
0.0114040393,
0.006819427,
-0.0218482558,
0.0143665643,
0.0031028329,
-0.0190954208,
0.0323012769,
0.0414696895,
0.0677701607,
-0.0371149816,
-0.0154761262,
-0.0153952492,
0.0655001923,
-0.0235927142,
0.010901859,
0.0182077251,
0.0234160833,
-0.0569652952,
-0.0155266095,
0.0947687924,
0.0217098035,
-0.0832241625,
-0.0396164618,
0.0048408764,
0.0375393629,
0.012111607,
0.0435921885,
-0.0670081377,
-0.0413179323,
0.02055154,
0.0849649757,
-0.0221688151,
-0.0332492292,
-0.0266454145,
-0.1465261132,
0.0283989087,
-0.0176460911,
-0.0040680207,
0.0060829814,
-0.0515308864,
-0.0252454355,
-0.0221968461,
-0.0046421103,
-0.0220843628,
-0.008377918,
-0.0253099203,
0.0366455764,
-0.0364101306,
-0.0682730749,
-0.0061226944,
-0.005276253,
-0.0104666334,
0.0386083163,
-0.0139652444,
-0.0039892984,
-0.0256280452,
0.0287011657,
-0.0352350734,
-0.0028629005,
-0.0130324615,
0.0552523062,
-0.0061309268,
0.0024839833,
0.0191615447,
0.0160773899,
-0.0580304265,
0.0250793602,
0.0437220447,
0.0456021354,
-0.0127517283,
0.0018936396,
0.0464914255,
-0.0077150245,
0.0315799341,
0.0967212915,
0.0026337714,
-0.0671058297,
0.0008598754,
-0.0028231763,
-0.0190394986,
-0.013908295,
-0.00785104,
0.0135883782,
-0.0458495133,
-0.016785495,
-0.0392156243,
-0.0227226969,
0.0358467065,
0.0359447151,
0.0078998888,
-0.0125209633,
0.0383831747,
0.0352591425,
-0.0470171757,
0.0247160979,
-0.0612085313,
0.0148998136,
-0.0920818746,
-0.0205786042,
0.0452814512,
-0.0096661001,
-0.0046562888,
-0.0365718752,
-0.1115209758,
-0.0655680969,
-0.0118089961,
0.0503389537,
0.0287923254,
0.0396465622,
0.001659957,
-0.0302284714,
0.0502144732,
0.0657534003,
-0.0571353734,
0.0286670253,
0.0556581505,
0.0169082638,
-0.0149855874,
0.0201858897,
-0.0583934449,
0.016083546,
0.0470324606,
0.0145066539,
-0.0445466079,
-0.025625458,
-0.0002909853,
0.0394695885,
0.0581699237,
-0.0116695045,
-0.0157420207,
-0.0359519571,
0.0355664454,
0.0290746633,
0.005932448,
-0.0497775711,
-0.0240648985,
0.0388545804,
0.0235824436,
-0.0256969817,
-0.0066572409,
0.0110924449,
-0.0226827711,
-0.0053528161,
0.024413202,
-0.0077922437,
-0.020128319,
0.0374250859,
-0.017841747,
-0.039831847,
0.0195040628,
0.0344806351,
-0.0035313996,
-0.0167809278,
0.0697018877,
0.0270192288,
0.0361552797,
0.0055261753,
-0.0048046825,
-0.0151119288,
-0.067258276,
-0.0038026634,
-0.0015205325,
0.0174289346,
-0.0249746088,
0.0578432418,
-0.0629757047,
0.0096538551,
-0.0233073104,
0.0151332412,
0.0006467914,
-0.0375509374,
0.0229684878,
0.005354132,
-0.01660317,
0.0420933925,
0.0948424339,
-0.0412862077,
0.0298623368,
-0.0171812624,
-0.0209069662,
-0.052605249,
-0.0301620066,
0.0281755086,
0.0104299113,
-0.0070880116,
-0.014343732,
-0.0488060936,
-0.030386664,
-0.029036548,
-0.0540824644,
-0.0116310604,
-0.0339686871,
0.0576737411,
0.0639688447,
0.0060649496,
0.058296185,
-0.0329733491,
0.0246439371,
-0.0328556634,
-0.0294156093,
0.000118204,
-6.879178081e-33,
0.0010009339,
-0.0109133665,
0.0034334182,
0.0030179133,
0.016487686,
0.064489156,
-0.0077105397,
0.014349049,
0.0166108012,
-0.0382717326,
-0.0090407906,
0.0026465182,
0.0386515856,
0.0153742312,
0.033195667,
-0.0282612033,
0.0594288483,
-0.0257376488,
-0.0106964037,
0.0112113347,
0.0306078065,
0.0412313342,
0.0661958158,
-0.0582003668,
0.0060423971,
-0.0055057933,
-0.0067958958,
0.0191481803,
0.0094560841,
0.0241134297,
-0.0353063866,
0.0659516156,
0.0245729089,
-0.0438070334,
0.0284915101,
0.0162145961,
-0.0200085975,
-0.0333773084,
-0.0174378213,
0.0165230483,
0.0031248059,
-0.0042166202,
0.0543290302,
0.0004033567,
-0.0380410142,
0.0461471379,
0.0272985063,
-0.0163736343,
-0.0164673347,
-0.0119113969,
-0.0267863367,
0.0271131918,
-0.0031749147,
0.0075289039,
0.0304322746,
0.066056855,
-0.0076163746,
0.028019052,
-0.07257808,
0.043323949,
0.01377213,
0.0228095334,
0.0259600803,
0.032896556,
-0.0052808998,
0.0564159751,
0.0224078596,
0.0122449342,
0.0086136702,
-0.026446199,
0.0579781719,
-0.0140500981,
0.0373721309,
0.0584955402,
0.0392306112,
-0.0308779441,
-0.0241224393,
-0.0068952744,
0.0963667035,
-0.0122853704,
0.0380750485,
-0.0214883499,
-0.0361305214,
-0.0591993406,
0.0138218869,
-0.0414910614,
-0.0318414383,
-0.0064664194,
0.0352057517,
0.045142822,
-0.0185692329,
0.0018065035,
0.0414191857,
-0.0279684495,
-0.0519907661,
-0.0319176428,
0.0293403473,
0.0201103836,
-0.008948613,
0.0134644937,
-0.0814599246,
-0.0367223918,
-0.0474433787,
-0.0215578787,
0.0030658662,
0.0030074078,
0.0478089713,
0.0270156544,
-0.086539872,
0.0163676552,
-0.0117888516,
0.0142412493,
-0.0139724407,
0.0279182047,
0.0348546803,
-0.0145492088,
0.0079435762,
0.0853981674,
0.023844555,
0.0002424521,
-0.0319610797,
-0.042388916,
0.0162162948,
0.025841862,
-0.034641888,
-0.0084582912,
-0.0226528924,
0.000421522,
0.0244429205,
-0.050080508,
-0.010283283,
0.007819457,
2.934e-7,
0.013000886,
0.0650635362,
-0.0489521399,
-0.0087986235,
0.002837626,
0.0709300339,
-0.0022465936,
-0.029349139,
0.004803862,
0.0270653274,
0.0270562265,
-0.00992746,
0.0748357996,
0.0476514809,
-0.1234001294,
-0.0006442603,
-0.0501999035,
0.0287855249,
-0.0530502051,
0.0395946316,
0.0362109579,
0.0677547082,
0.0618526042,
-0.0232704412,
-0.0087937973,
-0.0336612724,
0.0515435003,
-0.0578882173,
0.0060181282,
-0.0068767145,
0.0524463132,
0.0274767149,
0.0048445342,
0.0189605653,
-0.0283610728,
0.0110234385,
-0.0255746134,
0.0690508932,
0.0262314752,
-0.0239684936,
0.0374736972,
-0.0103479307,
-0.0174728502,
-0.0409479253,
0.0524114817,
-0.0368751101,
-0.0087062772,
-0.004789778,
0.0112008154,
-0.0802009925,
-0.0000254197,
0.0009601779,
-0.0132745774,
0.0319579877,
0.004115955,
-0.0777465254,
-0.0175285004,
-0.0549999997,
0.0375666991,
-0.0271818824,
-0.0086877365,
-0.042356357,
-0.0086420132,
0.0208132565,
0.0225821175,
-0.0238691103,
0.0185393319,
2.648267779e-34,
0.0443126224,
-0.0166950207,
0.0274646822,
0.0482672527,
0.0064283451,
0.0245230943,
-0.0137449363,
-0.0023967647,
0.0246848892,
-0.0666586235,
-0.0040435684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13394v1 | POSQA: Probe the World Models of LLMs with Size Comparisons | 2023-10-20T10:05:01 | 2023-10-20T10:05:01 | Chang Shu, Jiuzhou Han, Fangyu Liu, Ehsan Shareghi, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Embodied language comprehension emphasizes that language understanding is not
solely a matter of mental processing in the brain but also involves
interactions with the physical and social environment. With the explosive
growth of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their already ubiquitous presence in
our daily lives, it is becoming increasingly necessary to verify their
real-world understanding. Inspired by cognitive theories, we propose POSQA: a
Physical Object Size Question Answering dataset with simple size comparison
questions to examine the extremity and analyze the potential mechanisms of the
embodied comprehension of the latest LLMs.
We show that even the largest LLMs today perform poorly under the zero-shot
setting. We then push their limits with advanced prompting techniques and
external knowledge augmentation. Furthermore, we investigate whether their
real-world comprehension primarily derives from contextual information or
internal weights and analyse the impact of prompt formats and report bias of
different objects. Our results show that real-world understanding that LLMs
shaped from textual data can be vulnerable to deception and confusion by the
surface form of prompts, which makes it less aligned with human behaviours. | [
0.0444445536,
0.0237035677,
-0.0345083214,
0.0706478208,
-0.0071294806,
0.013114661,
0.0215793122,
-0.0017236485,
0.0105427857,
-0.0212150235,
-0.0379510373,
-0.0481072702,
0.0256098732,
0.0260124821,
0.0663986057,
-0.0196152572,
0.0413601063,
-0.0613131933,
-0.0401748382,
-0.0187058095,
-0.0118614426,
-0.0051502264,
-0.0210985858,
0.0231401771,
0.0322442688,
0.0026764711,
-0.0511487015,
-0.009238027,
-0.0035330199,
-0.0429140963,
-0.0302838702,
0.0411940925,
0.0587666929,
0.0547623746,
0.0000020422,
-0.0458183773,
0.0494354554,
-0.0145565737,
-0.0535280406,
0.0072835591,
0.0101804603,
-0.03432272,
0.0264455695,
-0.018300686,
-0.0126372669,
-0.0399159379,
0.0452492461,
0.0221618805,
0.020903375,
0.0254140906,
0.0060238326,
0.0221895184,
-0.0035575402,
-0.0037308703,
0.0468993932,
0.0210510138,
0.0287284255,
0.000660337,
0.0392740518,
0.0193754081,
-0.0515416861,
0.0319875591,
0.0460683331,
0.0254601184,
-0.0327672772,
0.0459934361,
-0.030299224,
0.0042566424,
0.0028530234,
0.1205408126,
0.0648599416,
-0.030310804,
-0.0013606346,
-0.0126427496,
0.0063796048,
0.0045886571,
-0.0714132935,
0.0483514406,
0.0146164568,
-0.011055354,
-0.0821395144,
0.0221848935,
0.0135196438,
0.0150855966,
-0.0322948806,
0.0747893825,
-0.0004442112,
-0.0186556168,
-0.0049206037,
-0.0216103215,
-0.035882514,
-0.0559512079,
-0.0071041905,
0.0496702716,
-0.0267868917,
0.0206512827,
-0.0033712988,
0.0040924149,
0.0255173147,
-0.0331155472,
0.0622633994,
0.0387759767,
-0.0073612537,
0.0547507033,
0.0116161862,
0.077030465,
-0.0191613082,
0.0299672447,
-0.0632784218,
0.0399196185,
-0.0136946654,
-0.0246850625,
-0.0352548361,
0.0084788781,
-0.0590575226,
-0.0345337838,
0.0255862325,
-0.0025020374,
-0.0168750919,
0.0071822447,
-0.0306627601,
0.0540659614,
-0.0005408353,
0.0005611446,
-0.0514691621,
0.0275729708,
-0.0521504655,
0.0470422916,
-0.0110017909,
-0.0858368874,
-0.0345685557,
0.0025658708,
0.0191602185,
-0.0341963097,
-0.0108942706,
0.0595786162,
0.0125356624,
-0.02703874,
0.030882515,
-0.0354266427,
-0.0153817274,
-0.040764112,
-0.0055856355,
-0.0554197878,
0.0548279695,
-0.0191728175,
-0.0308374688,
-0.0065609915,
0.0200437326,
0.0253505446,
-0.0202978309,
0.076069057,
0.0185360946,
0.0224160496,
0.0249927845,
0.0101641268,
0.0084431209,
0.059499912,
0.0301201809,
-0.0096117379,
0.0284107029,
0.0040821922,
-0.0095542371,
0.0530096479,
0.0270849597,
0.0231828336,
-0.055789385,
0.0228201244,
0.0076874103,
0.0671050772,
0.0397093296,
0.0417040661,
-0.0301018879,
-0.0445422456,
0.068605192,
0.0422914848,
-0.0723547712,
-0.0366331898,
0.019664526,
0.0157171283,
0.0279672723,
0.0230631493,
-0.0404855348,
0.0179374851,
-0.0410001837,
-0.0034033773,
0.0062463107,
0.0020984423,
-0.0336724184,
-0.0082426053,
-0.0185127296,
0.0274615772,
0.0168501493,
0.0530107319,
0.0505996607,
0.0194478594,
-0.0052996748,
0.0589696951,
0.0089035844,
-0.0258790031,
-0.0208364092,
-0.04246163,
0.0534240678,
0.0011657646,
0.0373194776,
-0.0017975515,
-0.0177442282,
-0.0011262933,
0.0456401482,
0.0529904701,
0.041646868,
0.0056032087,
0.0047132638,
0.0029601632,
-0.0122759202,
-0.0295430198,
-0.0129297022,
-0.0018949697,
0.0173972659,
0.0153413285,
-0.0063337153,
-0.0204648674,
0.0034589618,
0.0294222664,
-0.0243420992,
-0.0241595935,
-0.0332392566,
0.0046315859,
-0.0096807564,
-0.0050916439,
-0.0080506895,
0.0073862006,
0.0191238988,
-0.02999698,
-0.0059425109,
0.0088314544,
-0.0495878868,
-0.0340130888,
0.0319395959,
-0.0136252102,
-0.0156341605,
0.0135725858,
-0.0138613051,
-0.023978116,
0.0177350026,
-0.0324989296,
0.0576429144,
-0.0323024727,
-0.0302895829,
-0.0217876621,
0.0289102625,
-0.04779955,
0.0396715179,
-0.0167391766,
0.0341481268,
0.0495761037,
0.0121868094,
0.0221856236,
-0.0669403151,
-0.0076899352,
0.0210419744,
0.0029715318,
-0.0128967883,
0.0030176772,
-0.0307066552,
-0.0689164251,
-0.0015356573,
-0.0701051205,
-0.027808331,
0.0097556477,
-0.0162916612,
0.0380750485,
-0.0169279557,
-0.0248153266,
-0.0253256857,
-0.0196122378,
0.0074880267,
0.0020207353,
0.0361521505,
0.0289312359,
-0.0078325579,
0.012945883,
-0.022706233,
-0.0041179047,
-0.0348534845,
0.0671820194,
0.0251999386,
0.0078541832,
-0.047204446,
0.0108995968,
-0.0628854036,
0.0320786461,
-0.007189468,
-0.0166560132,
0.0301582664,
-0.0462796725,
0.0261994321,
0.0986980572,
-0.0162091814,
0.0425023697,
0.0698261634,
-0.026670482,
-0.0744125918,
-0.0088799968,
0.0143274516,
-0.0076380493,
0.0001488442,
-0.0507580414,
-0.0050646677,
0.0644649863,
0.0334803425,
0.0023350811,
-0.0258332882,
0.0485107303,
-0.0331106968,
-0.0566164032,
-0.0647327304,
0.0212170389,
-0.040038038,
0.0554182902,
-0.0426615104,
-0.0152758062,
0.0623995066,
-0.0220523179,
-0.002468921,
0.0102057848,
0.0400320441,
-0.0110342233,
0.0881791264,
0.0370878503,
0.0077857869,
0.0024764724,
-0.0048046624,
-0.061077226,
-0.0053377519,
-0.0039624958,
-0.0220359117,
-0.0186335556,
-0.066089727,
0.0187643282,
-0.0273003597,
-0.0086556841,
-0.0171524584,
-0.0367537588,
-0.033537101,
-0.0110227996,
-0.0774099156,
-0.0250588208,
-0.0160795245,
0.0062327865,
0.0523436964,
0.0293790884,
-0.0389954001,
0.000011451,
-0.0420643985,
0.0266629215,
0.0688868016,
0.0791613013,
0.0347537622,
-0.0464849323,
0.0514660887,
0.0534802265,
0.0089536747,
0.0038234438,
-0.021306457,
0.0269676317,
0.049643185,
0.0221547782,
0.0156640913,
0.035886053,
0.0915369987,
-0.0620037355,
-0.0298187509,
0.100039497,
0.0364265442,
-0.0127375517,
0.030299183,
-0.0165630095,
0.0300652664,
0.0361763425,
0.0202845316,
-0.0847824737,
-0.0356350467,
0.0050749541,
-0.0291334931,
-0.0285693649,
-0.0552597232,
-0.0305473413,
-0.16142115,
0.0225383639,
-0.009966094,
-0.0713750795,
-0.0041490542,
-0.022316955,
0.0190305207,
0.0416831411,
0.0238550715,
0.0315495282,
-0.0072038015,
0.023045823,
-0.0286524985,
0.0048962096,
0.0002236255,
0.0510866866,
-0.0290465336,
0.0527775846,
0.016661603,
0.0222401936,
-0.0246873908,
-0.0610186569,
0.0068173362,
0.0006824833,
0.0087994039,
-0.01624473,
0.025492182,
0.0379020087,
-0.0119768968,
-0.0327261388,
0.0414441079,
-0.0160744376,
-0.0437879898,
0.0234870836,
0.0708200186,
-0.0047780061,
-0.0308422949,
-0.0155397253,
0.0048922296,
-0.0108262608,
0.0918025672,
0.0591570251,
-0.0430572405,
-0.0252892543,
-0.0204879455,
-0.0486636125,
0.0300253201,
-0.0474620536,
0.0264256075,
0.0517349616,
0.0148363058,
-0.0551038533,
-0.0275821202,
0.0674504265,
0.0377463922,
0.0189347155,
-0.0259969793,
-0.030517133,
-0.0142723452,
-0.0273579415,
0.0443219952,
-0.0414180681,
0.0542652793,
-0.0080043878,
0.0341626145,
0.0154066784,
-0.0472700372,
-0.0041542747,
0.0056063989,
-0.0640904307,
-0.0597945526,
-0.0230767224,
0.0109747183,
0.0306787938,
0.0233426783,
0.0059300698,
-0.0586212948,
0.0311057027,
-0.0175913107,
-0.0527388081,
0.0694772601,
-0.0217979401,
0.0369972289,
0.0095785093,
0.0372135602,
-0.0229876172,
0.0077367839,
-0.015672259,
0.0313696079,
-0.0141634038,
-0.0300990641,
0.023552049,
0.0251807943,
0.0211593769,
0.0061984747,
0.0078983093,
-0.0336167216,
0.0124142226,
-0.0239499509,
0.0037977046,
-0.0383230671,
-0.0210123807,
0.0102542499,
-0.0099252956,
-0.0023927731,
-0.0083658546,
-0.0169851128,
0.0489293747,
-0.0197328869,
0.0030709009,
0.0128815584,
0.0059388005,
0.0134405857,
0.018752601,
-0.0123469103,
0.0234459862,
-0.060610082,
0.0684689656,
0.0190917645,
0.064748019,
0.0290464461,
-0.036379952,
-0.0458443984,
0.0215551611,
-0.0528713837,
-0.053538125,
0.0272443257,
0.0529609323,
-0.0260736197,
-0.0280135982,
-0.001232992,
0.0053798379,
-0.0078911325,
0.0091911592,
-0.0101262117,
-0.0065260082,
-0.0565098859,
0.0836031362,
0.0430941395,
-0.0050122244,
0.0118633695,
0.0453593247,
-0.0002206293,
0.0356112011,
0.0223427117,
0.0335088782,
-0.006088804,
-0.0017957693,
0.0099841207,
0.0216390323,
-0.0160430782,
0.017220296,
-0.0808125362,
-0.0812254921,
-0.0472578742,
0.0703447834,
-0.036536701,
-0.0305020828,
0.0239663459,
0.0000690725,
0.0135199521,
-0.0280880034,
0.0102842646,
0.0320790187,
-0.0399073325,
-0.0144149205,
-0.0061692395,
-5.816585188e-33,
-0.0164071787,
-0.0361106284,
0.0039795726,
-0.0423581824,
-0.0339748859,
0.0192393884,
-0.0560634322,
0.0035665287,
-0.026962433,
-0.0061337533,
-0.0112085799,
0.0044371765,
-0.0115436092,
0.012762174,
0.0026363267,
-0.0119651277,
0.0013101123,
-0.0295306593,
-0.0297757704,
-0.0049837925,
0.0195662454,
-0.0168103669,
0.0223888271,
0.0237432811,
0.0556058139,
0.0084385294,
0.003933996,
0.0603587478,
-0.0403944589,
0.0407772437,
-0.0517016537,
0.0411573239,
0.0096159037,
-0.0134586049,
-0.0128314812,
0.0528455898,
-0.070100531,
-0.0591318198,
0.0420614369,
0.0186210759,
-0.0714260265,
-0.0020271624,
0.0285961423,
-0.02615018,
0.0044728597,
-0.0214947015,
0.0224504229,
-0.0156675614,
-0.0022293462,
0.0398381092,
-0.011880381,
-0.0026089516,
-0.0260696728,
-0.0023706167,
0.0117491949,
0.0559794828,
-0.0209656134,
0.0346153192,
-0.0632307678,
0.0071738339,
0.0123770824,
-0.0194638278,
0.0621215142,
0.0253090076,
0.041563686,
0.0829445273,
0.0301450584,
0.005266442,
-0.0716306269,
-0.0296377987,
0.0384802856,
0.0362539105,
0.0221434925,
0.0552924201,
0.043361377,
0.0228525288,
-0.0557620414,
0.0052594058,
0.0101007679,
0.0535753034,
0.0181533489,
-0.0220443346,
-0.0349664278,
-0.0226219259,
-0.0728809088,
0.0016875275,
-0.0586655326,
-0.0157611445,
0.0528866723,
-0.0331856012,
-0.0145178363,
-0.0458290838,
0.0325588137,
-0.064778313,
-0.0213669557,
-0.0166813489,
-0.0030970525,
0.024077557,
0.0357057862,
0.0306902714,
-0.0499757603,
0.0173328966,
0.019021498,
0.0120395739,
0.0096784914,
0.0230342969,
-0.0161543824,
0.0081894472,
-0.0203147233,
-0.0190044735,
-0.0360501707,
-0.0173925422,
-0.0057451879,
-0.0251874011,
0.0563827865,
0.019253131,
-0.047190018,
0.0045336392,
-0.0264706537,
-0.0555629283,
-0.0316352509,
0.0316361897,
-0.0423959196,
0.0320960805,
-0.0533114895,
-0.0293201767,
-0.0496682599,
-0.0046048248,
0.0681386366,
-0.06489034,
-0.0099852802,
0.0275886375,
2.73e-7,
-0.0065675396,
0.0289091766,
0.0259674173,
0.0118645234,
0.0318601504,
0.02964532,
-0.0214877483,
0.0482287779,
0.0038635607,
-0.0657398403,
-0.0215607043,
0.0708129406,
0.0334738791,
-0.0162835103,
-0.0870269313,
0.0517819226,
-0.0343046933,
-0.0043569212,
-0.0629728138,
-0.0102611035,
0.0373449847,
0.0371412821,
0.0024301924,
0.0006260745,
-0.0161952972,
-0.0247605424,
0.0435835794,
-0.0499064699,
0.0454523899,
-0.0262938421,
0.0109507013,
-0.0415662415,
0.0073825009,
0.0358916372,
0.0186823644,
-0.0022653032,
-0.0001167875,
0.0289690532,
0.0015138234,
-0.0041040224,
-0.0361440741,
-0.0484614931,
-0.0048920154,
-0.0681952834,
0.1115818843,
-0.0675562099,
-0.051127214,
-0.0178315025,
0.0163281821,
-0.0416932702,
0.0049513108,
-0.0009800215,
0.0005656053,
0.010169276,
0.0155045725,
-0.0278994627,
0.0137455044,
-0.0424770638,
-0.0370494351,
-0.0211700778,
-0.0388138592,
-0.037341658,
-0.0667587295,
-0.0172355417,
0.0068762559,
-0.0688892826,
-0.0063602845,
2.205543316e-34,
0.0019328602,
0.027881531,
0.019893676,
-0.0109246513,
0.0352563262,
-0.0307264682,
0.0297681391,
0.0214129556,
0.0479109846,
-0.0962292477,
-0.0046850108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13385v1 | Tuna: Instruction Tuning using Feedback from Large Language Models | 2023-10-20T09:55:06 | 2023-10-20T09:55:06 | Haoran Li, Yiran Liu, Xingxing Zhang, Wei Lu, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Instruction tuning of open-source large language models (LLMs) like LLaMA,
using direct outputs from more powerful LLMs such as Instruct-GPT and GPT-4,
has proven to be a cost-effective way to align model behaviors with human
preferences. However, the instruction-tuned model has only seen one response
per instruction, lacking the knowledge of potentially better responses. In this
paper, we propose finetuning an instruction-tuned LLM using our novel
\textit{probabilistic ranking} and \textit{contextual ranking} approaches to
increase the likelihood of generating better responses. Probabilistic ranking
enables the instruction-tuned model to inherit the relative rankings of
high-quality and low-quality responses from the teacher LLM. On the other hand,
learning with contextual ranking allows the model to refine its own response
distribution using the contextual understanding ability of stronger LLMs.
Furthermore, we apply probabilistic ranking and contextual ranking sequentially
to the instruction-tuned LLM. The resulting model, which we call \textbf{Tuna},
consistently improves the performance on Super Natural Instructions (119 test
tasks), LMentry (25 test tasks), Vicuna QA, and can even obtain better results
than several strong reinforcement learning baselines. Our code and data are
available at \url{ https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps}. | [
0.0321652554,
0.0462755673,
-0.0211804546,
0.0495588258,
0.0057151914,
0.0173318256,
-0.0406081043,
-0.0244794544,
-0.0282687191,
-0.0485514142,
-0.0792567506,
-0.0172895044,
-0.0115449671,
-0.0038718304,
0.0123483017,
-0.0719580501,
0.0363677777,
-0.0535390228,
-0.0132326614,
0.0043921527,
-0.024315035,
-0.0090672206,
-0.0252749808,
0.0667607188,
0.0705928504,
0.0016616788,
-0.0051756459,
0.0160449427,
0.0231229775,
-0.0334654376,
0.0336081088,
0.0465448312,
0.0323992595,
-0.0054634246,
0.0000020322,
-0.0382716171,
-0.0174637102,
-0.0348255672,
0.0126930783,
0.0222871006,
0.0067434148,
0.0205346514,
-0.0459132679,
0.0322363079,
-0.037741784,
0.0270760357,
0.0261712093,
-0.0036843391,
0.0604447313,
0.0793718845,
0.0358496197,
-0.01718444,
0.0054365029,
-0.0267293099,
0.0316338241,
-0.0436307639,
-0.0005529955,
-0.0006781998,
0.0231759585,
0.0459350497,
-0.0435996018,
-0.016769208,
0.0383029915,
-0.0101357959,
-0.0096227909,
0.0514493734,
-0.0065062912,
0.0097132195,
-0.0228987038,
0.0751874447,
-0.0232954025,
0.0068165837,
-0.0130329095,
-0.0222651232,
0.0261620879,
-0.0281388424,
-0.029567495,
0.0423282832,
0.0119759301,
0.0426438861,
0.0285174344,
-0.0184623711,
0.0095405579,
0.0158076975,
0.0005034482,
0.0603292547,
-0.0007780897,
-0.0351652913,
0.0039909366,
0.0046704765,
-0.0411665812,
-0.0237254705,
-0.015349268,
0.0519113056,
-0.0688222945,
0.0177021213,
-0.0389306284,
0.0205295328,
0.0103312805,
-0.0181358773,
0.0731880367,
0.0588692464,
-0.0232908819,
0.0202231593,
-0.0062875766,
0.0776414052,
-0.0049527083,
0.0240682177,
-0.0540571325,
0.041614335,
-0.0550847761,
0.012765782,
0.0169867408,
0.0101640429,
-0.0475098081,
0.0021206813,
-0.0669805408,
0.0433666743,
-0.008769949,
0.0083380099,
0.0221563168,
0.0029034745,
-0.0501089357,
0.0315300934,
-0.0649105683,
0.0281621888,
-0.0387581512,
0.0137523171,
0.0160195325,
-0.0140874293,
0.0115817385,
0.0047971136,
-0.0391747579,
-0.0246387534,
0.0382421836,
0.0610972345,
-0.0226893295,
-0.0281007886,
-0.0117445784,
-0.0031397569,
0.0118353739,
-0.0624580346,
0.0057134121,
-0.0449092947,
-0.0139389429,
-0.0118883243,
0.008968371,
0.0174983386,
0.0216006152,
0.0229670648,
0.0072655752,
0.0527059175,
0.0603492185,
-0.0063450048,
0.0021832793,
0.0118410941,
-0.028749546,
0.051381737,
0.0411114618,
0.0216282345,
0.0087038083,
-0.0143135889,
-0.0024653904,
0.0186934695,
-0.0041096173,
0.0139878001,
0.0017743626,
0.0070347344,
0.0181765035,
0.0226439256,
0.0780730546,
0.0179060455,
-0.0211321712,
0.0252600294,
0.0622348227,
0.0071135601,
-0.0013911697,
-0.0193432216,
0.0413051993,
0.0197090954,
-0.011624787,
0.0266971607,
-0.0941825435,
0.0668953881,
0.0005279335,
0.0209214203,
0.033363048,
0.0156229455,
-0.0144914128,
-0.0771362707,
0.0230443981,
-0.0041523082,
-0.0258145723,
0.0403878726,
0.037784785,
-0.0205001421,
-0.0663555712,
-0.0307180621,
0.0494839586,
-0.0155394208,
0.0077506183,
-0.1096913964,
0.0538671836,
0.0964392498,
0.0472262464,
-0.0557742789,
-0.0445713922,
0.0057596695,
-0.0103152217,
0.0384567752,
0.0027850268,
-0.0254645534,
0.0003069227,
-0.0420268551,
-0.0489752069,
-0.0144177759,
0.0053144018,
0.0330658667,
0.0244374201,
-0.0027528785,
-0.0098185828,
0.004868702,
-0.0449049063,
0.0427341275,
0.013017768,
-0.0819365904,
-0.0027793334,
-0.0068199071,
0.0367282778,
-0.0051596593,
-0.0058935126,
0.0084964717,
0.0407838821,
-0.0146865565,
0.0106507959,
-0.0387908109,
-0.0750183612,
-0.0073681427,
0.0329234488,
-0.0087703951,
-0.0061536236,
0.0259287581,
-0.0690991059,
-0.0296784882,
0.0081938459,
-0.0041697617,
0.0346057229,
0.0066488255,
0.0257787462,
0.0005508559,
-0.0280887187,
-0.061761599,
0.0692752972,
-0.0207923222,
0.0204027332,
0.0491090789,
0.0277745109,
-0.0258905608,
-0.0540920421,
-0.0101207141,
-0.0005459868,
-0.0095745204,
0.0373379141,
0.0159955733,
0.0678432956,
-0.0448793471,
-0.0536217913,
-0.0575754791,
0.0442189202,
-0.0197482836,
0.0297802556,
0.015360876,
-0.0127954343,
-0.0068177017,
-0.0146836005,
-0.0058842986,
-0.0497534499,
-0.011501207,
0.0280449912,
0.0174519382,
0.0198744796,
-0.0168836806,
-0.0787964165,
-0.0245978683,
-0.0012974397,
-0.0143783223,
-0.0029810686,
0.042712044,
-0.0744051412,
0.0305249672,
-0.0141664511,
0.0444480516,
-0.0235627498,
-0.0612301081,
0.0413086638,
-0.0244761314,
0.0378653593,
0.1407991648,
-0.0023641954,
0.0296782292,
0.0812459588,
0.0154666621,
-0.0779056773,
0.0348006301,
-0.0231355112,
-0.0740769729,
-0.038571272,
-0.0225230101,
-0.0202717241,
0.0584109724,
-0.009594759,
-0.0071148053,
-0.0679717138,
0.0191079043,
-0.0285767745,
-0.0190556701,
-0.0145005872,
0.0182679724,
-0.0274009965,
-0.0001943649,
-0.0367837623,
-0.0652351081,
0.0801084787,
0.0171613935,
0.015897477,
-0.0672096983,
0.0031422647,
-0.0301975552,
0.0184538476,
0.0071084411,
0.0106361266,
-0.0468067974,
-0.0145699838,
-0.0723404661,
0.0053215344,
0.0229322053,
-0.0420194194,
0.0348810777,
-0.0673344284,
-0.0126959085,
-0.0039216736,
-0.0503299311,
-0.0501080267,
0.0397362113,
-0.0043365639,
0.0118523166,
0.0322632194,
-0.0380823798,
-0.0104225175,
-0.0287968647,
0.0446912795,
0.0250647981,
-0.0350509025,
-0.011315749,
-0.0456803031,
-0.0023492742,
0.0472856387,
-0.0044581243,
0.0007924811,
-0.0529970378,
0.0065205572,
0.029253114,
0.0675685704,
-0.0331336297,
-0.0111010987,
0.0173418317,
0.0232293941,
-0.046796944,
-0.0007139394,
0.0730502382,
0.0491242409,
-0.0583343618,
-0.0246267784,
0.1018662453,
0.0411372371,
-0.0446162559,
0.0071547851,
0.0025019431,
0.0388357155,
0.0364869796,
0.0653415844,
-0.0526308678,
-0.0440080985,
-0.0087196361,
0.0655056685,
0.0053641601,
-0.0045955274,
0.0078796409,
-0.1320603937,
0.0111164507,
0.0049114004,
-0.044571124,
-0.0343913026,
-0.048732318,
-0.0015785591,
-0.0205907952,
0.030827485,
0.02800324,
-0.0209890734,
0.0196919926,
0.0392557681,
0.0631273463,
-0.0566808209,
0.0255993772,
-0.0344380885,
0.0498127155,
0.099972643,
0.0089283595,
0.0038894659,
-0.0279883388,
0.0283980928,
-0.0231126472,
0.0074445913,
-0.020115789,
0.0124796843,
-0.0223004576,
0.0053396765,
-0.0249649975,
0.0435340889,
-0.0042886147,
0.0154295741,
0.0110760629,
0.0695494041,
-0.0040301383,
0.0097213993,
-0.024440119,
-0.0246582497,
0.027826041,
0.0495950878,
0.0210551322,
-0.0524135493,
-0.0271592829,
-0.0537247844,
-0.0423993096,
-0.0529099554,
-0.0126416218,
0.0247596111,
-0.0412238948,
-0.0051946081,
-0.0821041316,
-0.0276690554,
0.022140542,
0.003998769,
0.0102036847,
-0.0044066566,
0.0068865153,
-0.0039588334,
-0.008849863,
0.039623417,
-0.0036598167,
0.0226245951,
-0.1235469729,
-0.0418054499,
0.0468563177,
-0.0243921001,
-0.0170509722,
0.0092889154,
-0.0170803014,
-0.0761320889,
-0.0232858583,
0.1067262441,
0.0146163097,
0.0310977791,
0.0173822995,
-0.0442782454,
0.0170450676,
0.0375562869,
0.0026388874,
0.0182808731,
0.0399677716,
0.0111775268,
0.0124170659,
0.0158523377,
-0.0705825463,
0.0408305824,
0.0156751573,
0.0383876599,
-0.0034677577,
-0.000815759,
0.0218615402,
-0.0291067716,
0.0329724811,
-0.0397691801,
-0.0047912006,
-0.0360649526,
0.0355898216,
-0.0116076311,
-0.0092664417,
-0.031357754,
0.0099771107,
0.0302878041,
-0.0131312758,
0.0053541115,
-0.0268600155,
0.0072391406,
0.0325114541,
-0.0489170551,
0.0308507215,
0.0324877687,
0.0117949974,
0.0247417595,
0.0260775909,
-0.0038663133,
0.0032957557,
0.02761936,
0.0623151995,
0.0121190902,
0.0654532984,
0.017692402,
-0.0064593637,
-0.0087615224,
0.0351394974,
-0.0560947135,
-0.0427881181,
-0.037261337,
-0.0104294196,
0.0620220974,
0.0139982654,
0.0319187567,
-0.0071288864,
0.004403092,
0.0006397269,
0.0029039497,
0.004338719,
-0.007016886,
0.0385797545,
0.0449247435,
0.0390906706,
0.0061988398,
0.0723330304,
-0.0025795938,
0.0434485935,
-0.0088259093,
0.0195917245,
-0.0224084351,
-0.0177221652,
0.0121812895,
0.0337086879,
-0.0159879271,
0.0143687492,
-0.0041670939,
-0.0360860713,
-0.0582983382,
0.0574491844,
-0.0076221214,
-0.0465010665,
0.0467495844,
0.0096259108,
-0.0356153883,
-0.0539080389,
-0.038334012,
-0.0256657563,
-0.0148821576,
-0.0188637264,
-0.0198334493,
-6.43764624e-33,
-0.0520935506,
-0.0105493702,
0.022862481,
0.0044878912,
0.0075302976,
-0.0034276389,
-0.0226210766,
-0.0039562564,
-0.0036352524,
-0.0123994676,
-0.0039756172,
0.010799937,
0.0068365093,
0.0057207714,
0.034613166,
-0.0106229894,
0.031522911,
-0.0089303628,
-0.0468625277,
0.0405582488,
0.0073111001,
-0.001767684,
0.053329099,
-0.027727522,
0.0233299714,
0.0191617254,
-0.0051882723,
0.0400613509,
-0.05193533,
0.0812836438,
0.0028182173,
0.0301029235,
0.0060926648,
-0.0450690649,
-0.0124559319,
0.0111466218,
-0.040563155,
-0.0615145937,
0.0030803904,
-0.0297096875,
-0.0259867907,
-0.0448788181,
0.0355800502,
0.0141613847,
-0.0622694865,
-0.0009173033,
0.0314618982,
-0.0157015286,
-0.0353531018,
0.0133004924,
-0.0566352941,
-0.0025149239,
-0.0010755837,
-0.0340705663,
-0.0199495908,
0.0349052921,
-0.0101645924,
0.028290797,
-0.0116028814,
0.0376960672,
0.0444023423,
0.0686255693,
0.0704829991,
0.044253245,
-0.0001998452,
0.0167170689,
0.0105370181,
0.0030311379,
0.0406695493,
-0.0372637324,
0.0137347346,
0.0540268272,
0.0346626677,
0.0080178175,
0.0003871006,
0.0265130866,
-0.068000637,
0.0347789265,
0.0495305955,
0.0214532148,
0.0324239396,
0.012775261,
-0.070163399,
-0.0052915546,
-0.0473956466,
-0.0193501376,
-0.0284752343,
-0.0141549325,
0.0535181761,
0.0241957344,
-0.0273730587,
-0.0444420613,
0.0256975275,
-0.0161963012,
-0.016909685,
-0.0026677859,
-0.0397237465,
0.0258934777,
-0.0107596274,
0.0084864609,
-0.0695723891,
-0.0534377284,
0.0296740923,
-0.0573173426,
-0.0072713466,
0.0183245596,
0.0120509891,
0.0131565994,
-0.057623513,
0.0132767009,
-0.0386125296,
0.0132193547,
0.0102038374,
0.0128767816,
0.0108202072,
-0.0163299274,
0.0007000042,
0.0938400701,
0.0078877704,
-0.0199605878,
-0.0321491808,
-0.055058334,
-0.0070802663,
0.0235100333,
-0.0338166431,
0.012398392,
-0.0417289324,
0.0411823243,
-0.029549608,
-0.0592061132,
-0.034767013,
0.0220176205,
2.751e-7,
0.0049877213,
0.0565485097,
-0.0291539785,
0.0457565077,
0.006056081,
0.056686651,
-0.029098643,
0.0276191048,
0.0458195396,
0.0146265887,
0.0180615559,
0.0336255096,
0.010492797,
-0.0079899346,
-0.0629333779,
-0.0092107356,
-0.0413502529,
0.0083645238,
-0.0652356446,
-0.0337822661,
0.0224685036,
0.095509775,
-0.0112970993,
0.0050004595,
0.0222773235,
-0.0043285997,
0.0236367304,
-0.032184042,
-0.0086463066,
0.0093750777,
-0.0090391263,
0.0115257297,
-0.0275481679,
-0.0113704996,
-0.022053048,
0.002832904,
-0.03219698,
0.082389757,
-0.0141226761,
-0.0413817354,
0.0426064804,
0.0143912015,
0.0124498075,
-0.0548157543,
0.0524393618,
-0.0395713449,
0.0095261587,
0.0128017152,
-0.0125594903,
-0.0459725522,
-0.001252536,
-0.042306304,
-0.0241027195,
-0.0003446678,
-0.0066568428,
-0.0017804016,
-0.0170244668,
-0.0536288098,
-0.0073736073,
0.0097729079,
-0.0086371843,
-0.0685755089,
-0.0590839572,
0.0151899979,
-0.0141714998,
-0.0496977344,
-0.0137386136,
2.52598078e-34,
0.0196783226,
-0.0236261468,
0.0531750135,
0.0231333096,
0.0194794107,
0.0424767546,
-0.0499082431,
0.022713786,
0.0730697885,
-0.060888119,
-0.0416147336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13380v1 | APP: Adaptive Prototypical Pseudo-Labeling for Few-shot OOD Detection | 2023-10-20T09:48:52 | 2023-10-20T09:48:52 | Pei Wang, Keqing He, Yutao Mou, Xiaoshuai Song, Yanan Wu, Jingang Wang, Yunsen Xian, Xunliang Cai, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting out-of-domain (OOD) intents from user queries is essential for a
task-oriented dialogue system. Previous OOD detection studies generally work on
the assumption that plenty of labeled IND intents exist. In this paper, we
focus on a more practical few-shot OOD setting where there are only a few
labeled IND data and massive unlabeled mixed data that may belong to IND or
OOD. The new scenario carries two key challenges: learning discriminative
representations using limited IND data and leveraging unlabeled mixed data.
Therefore, we propose an adaptive prototypical pseudo-labeling (APP) method for
few-shot OOD detection, including a prototypical OOD detection framework
(ProtoOOD) to facilitate low-resource OOD detection using limited IND data, and
an adaptive pseudo-labeling method to produce high-quality pseudo OOD\&IND
labels. Extensive experiments and analysis demonstrate the effectiveness of our
method for few-shot OOD detection. | [
0.048889447,
-0.010032611,
0.022092225,
0.0420450903,
0.0060700495,
0.0299729109,
-0.0005101821,
0.0344832428,
0.0393156111,
-0.0762577951,
-0.0689464808,
-0.0252230633,
-0.0373873636,
-0.007090379,
-0.0091785071,
-0.0179724973,
0.0373069309,
-0.0189359076,
0.0439516827,
0.0426903404,
0.0208592657,
-0.005483408,
-0.0424367301,
0.0486906432,
0.0099176178,
-0.0738864616,
0.00490196,
0.0339627974,
-0.0122892642,
-0.0170024745,
0.0273314621,
0.0240450688,
0.0020340679,
0.0414338112,
0.0000017094,
-0.0517409109,
-0.0103788702,
-0.0144459764,
-0.0642676726,
-0.026248483,
0.0276200548,
0.0337572806,
0.0037596233,
0.0030208617,
-0.0263029616,
-0.0321377851,
0.061314214,
0.0759735778,
0.0143444873,
0.0653115883,
-0.0143750207,
0.0190032963,
0.0155323017,
-0.0137066767,
0.0375797749,
-0.0390535928,
0.0185199101,
-0.0236564614,
-0.0173698217,
0.0109213674,
0.0200332515,
0.001533712,
-0.0305355303,
0.0124439942,
-0.0284766424,
0.0152718527,
-0.0145147657,
-0.013047521,
-0.0285772625,
0.1073544025,
-0.0180411451,
0.0078816498,
0.0015185963,
-0.0199422874,
0.006561466,
-0.0439224206,
-0.047151655,
-0.0299495123,
-0.0154715041,
-0.0196687449,
0.002235757,
0.0366051011,
-0.0218801573,
0.00194564,
-0.0372425281,
0.0273247827,
-0.0027136696,
-0.010180736,
-0.0182951838,
-0.015828805,
-0.0427630022,
-0.0350655243,
-0.0001961809,
0.0131905871,
-0.0247049481,
0.0283237081,
-0.0856112167,
-0.0203155223,
0.0289944839,
0.0072774212,
0.01331669,
0.0189153757,
-0.0605225898,
0.0724968985,
0.0180931743,
0.0453684442,
-0.0136610465,
0.0584814772,
-0.0563576631,
-0.0132147111,
-0.0861440301,
0.0111137191,
-0.0599006526,
0.0539889075,
-0.0179475155,
-0.0235911943,
0.0082568806,
0.0503381714,
-0.0141122546,
-0.0359949395,
-0.0055775135,
-0.0076952311,
-0.0308149159,
0.0090403939,
0.0105363782,
0.0488763638,
-0.0079357279,
0.0358413868,
0.0033367935,
-0.0593194924,
-0.0352142192,
0.054339394,
0.0442858078,
-0.0120832371,
-0.0337294862,
0.0345920064,
-0.0003595173,
-0.060746938,
-0.0275981352,
-0.0450886488,
-0.0288663544,
-0.0237387959,
-0.0192659087,
-0.0288016479,
0.0101468554,
-0.0059342226,
-0.0032659511,
-0.0520180352,
0.0027901493,
0.0403951183,
0.0061293687,
0.062166471,
-0.0559728593,
-0.0322244465,
-0.0338731259,
0.0097891241,
-0.0156797376,
0.0946709067,
0.0037482805,
0.0043453365,
0.0552812256,
0.0438234583,
0.0346732326,
0.0210982487,
0.0194500387,
0.0196729247,
0.0475331768,
0.0432281718,
0.0412383489,
0.0059258365,
0.0025272102,
0.0339968801,
-0.0249408837,
-0.0133705484,
0.044845067,
0.030632548,
0.0032289475,
-0.0468856953,
0.0112951677,
0.075696446,
-0.0204063132,
-0.0059940633,
-0.0149737056,
0.007117718,
-0.0212585758,
-0.0133821098,
0.0142082321,
-0.0247530453,
-0.0536538921,
-0.035340853,
-0.0107959416,
0.0090591265,
-0.044289507,
0.0190601032,
0.0578048639,
0.0150143513,
-0.0420191735,
0.0509857349,
0.0065584402,
0.0080773579,
-0.0328921936,
-0.047358416,
0.0002017979,
0.0194895659,
0.0385158174,
-0.0882859379,
-0.0725138113,
-0.0449373312,
0.031591326,
0.0181502718,
0.0113338782,
-0.0406555869,
0.0438542925,
-0.0419845544,
-0.0455392301,
0.0056354348,
-0.0051659741,
-0.0395266488,
-0.025918154,
-0.011013899,
0.0158800445,
-0.0834298283,
0.0395186655,
0.0145834805,
0.0334370546,
-0.0407984853,
0.0658288524,
0.0420584902,
0.046338968,
0.0494381301,
0.03490448,
-0.007104645,
0.0211789943,
-0.0177774895,
0.0052446336,
-0.0209405962,
-0.009007656,
-0.075628601,
0.0347059779,
0.0101111168,
-0.035247501,
-0.01875416,
-0.0253421981,
-0.0241499711,
-0.0171909314,
-0.0599959902,
0.0124527179,
-0.0445380807,
-0.0162764043,
0.019300459,
0.0207464192,
-0.0228240732,
0.0628920868,
0.0071912464,
0.0074011111,
0.043051213,
-0.0084929615,
0.0489893556,
-0.0173935723,
0.0260006208,
-0.0094755432,
-0.0694109127,
-0.0021925489,
-0.0246174894,
0.0184045825,
-0.0496656448,
0.0208870508,
-0.0668995753,
-0.0022644245,
-0.0434898883,
0.0103118261,
0.0229418036,
0.0191078261,
0.0138584403,
-0.0228357278,
-0.0198635701,
-0.003488024,
-0.0218401868,
0.0184167922,
0.0141821802,
-0.0061157625,
-0.0250729267,
0.0061097136,
0.037981201,
-0.013444406,
0.0066521792,
-0.0281839892,
-0.0445303321,
-0.0519989654,
0.0015016161,
-0.0144523615,
0.0443123877,
0.0002947677,
0.0067703337,
0.0243937969,
0.0168251283,
0.0242504794,
0.033104267,
-0.0312761553,
0.0098642232,
-0.0046094158,
-0.0284698289,
-0.0269992687,
0.0206340123,
0.0090825465,
0.0176020432,
0.0153356614,
0.0090026492,
0.0516688563,
0.0364646129,
0.0059196367,
0.0127161993,
-0.0363259539,
-0.0236170944,
-0.0105561707,
-0.0410255343,
-0.020594079,
0.0344775282,
-0.0147964172,
0.0283040442,
0.0012750487,
0.0039335759,
0.0744204149,
0.0134199075,
-0.023012111,
-0.0785301551,
-0.021467993,
-0.0170169864,
0.035401728,
-0.0531432182,
0.013145756,
0.1060020328,
-0.0617494099,
-0.0273928605,
0.0123471282,
-0.0410363115,
-0.0228020418,
0.0747158974,
-0.0277975481,
0.0235198028,
-0.00089364,
-0.0430975072,
-0.0291837137,
-0.1149127185,
-0.0161800273,
-0.0048118513,
-0.0585562997,
-0.0032005885,
0.0002963889,
0.0220099352,
-0.0215730593,
0.0508057773,
-0.0059372694,
0.0058632642,
-0.0111042419,
0.0762167946,
0.0437629446,
-0.0202865414,
-0.0434688441,
0.0052755815,
0.0544975251,
0.0455753915,
0.0498558097,
-0.0533002354,
0.0452240109,
0.0066793244,
0.0642432794,
0.0044507827,
-0.0212146807,
0.0323181674,
0.0660122037,
0.0170641039,
-0.0368482433,
0.0956446007,
0.0357305519,
-0.0565679111,
-0.0148179522,
-0.0062431921,
0.0152755668,
0.0414918847,
-0.0116634341,
-0.0825350136,
-0.0972747207,
-0.0016758662,
0.0258411374,
-0.0368582904,
-0.0129205892,
-0.01569313,
-0.1091515347,
0.0119770635,
-0.0128032435,
-0.0207591392,
-0.0389788449,
-0.0164387133,
0.031091379,
0.00001462,
-0.0039809947,
-0.0261002276,
0.0030409414,
-0.0324092954,
0.0027599994,
-0.005966648,
-0.0631483644,
0.0163397547,
-0.0279410444,
0.045284193,
0.045627512,
0.0473872609,
0.0617026426,
-0.0136398021,
0.0039033312,
-0.0504029281,
-0.0212834384,
-0.0255721472,
0.0538722984,
-0.0179687664,
-0.0017061507,
-0.0229324065,
0.0268893652,
-0.0791482851,
-0.0300181042,
0.0014932594,
0.0622502565,
-0.0322802775,
0.0442423709,
-0.0014679799,
-0.0026936308,
0.0678015873,
0.086197108,
0.0120076472,
-0.0254798457,
-0.0194295906,
-0.0068588927,
-0.0065699015,
-0.0420093313,
0.0421965756,
-0.0036195933,
-0.0231974646,
-0.044576142,
-0.040930219,
-0.0576785654,
0.0517119206,
0.0405451246,
-0.0041932622,
0.0116921049,
-0.0093570603,
0.0220642611,
-0.0379288979,
-0.0151137635,
-0.0653567314,
0.023180265,
-0.0535883456,
0.0029637588,
0.0587849542,
-0.0219270047,
0.0036255501,
0.0428063385,
-0.0909198001,
-0.0438121781,
-0.0110148424,
0.020805398,
0.0179586615,
0.0266190041,
-0.0562700368,
-0.0180411786,
0.0103407158,
0.0338991471,
-0.0132136345,
-0.0237078518,
0.0458435491,
0.0287580285,
0.003414629,
0.0344852097,
-0.0671634227,
0.0064999205,
0.0288449414,
0.0048455908,
-0.081059128,
-0.0459966958,
0.0386728719,
-0.0139701357,
0.0868780836,
0.0338947028,
-0.0430355072,
-0.0397065431,
0.0449840203,
0.0027805876,
-0.0307032801,
-0.0421520583,
0.0072658183,
0.0268989988,
-0.0485593677,
-0.014666616,
0.0419894941,
-0.0702984184,
0.0215422343,
-0.0349887237,
-0.0137991682,
0.0183394477,
0.004170924,
-0.0068660458,
-0.0183877442,
-0.0308249891,
0.0563329533,
0.0300798044,
0.0358149037,
0.0077082287,
0.098923482,
-0.0067009423,
-0.0236722119,
0.0088397991,
0.0275271144,
-0.0336640552,
0.0248884,
-0.024530109,
0.017714832,
0.0099223005,
0.0083033368,
-0.0017177762,
0.0189723037,
0.028986318,
-0.0375127681,
0.0408684351,
-0.0450514592,
-0.0290558767,
0.0298698936,
0.0266816542,
-0.0080441739,
0.0058233826,
0.0870075896,
0.0109503632,
0.0119495261,
0.0067036012,
0.021509435,
-0.0625757203,
0.0208103675,
0.0430208407,
0.0519278683,
-0.0194244124,
0.0204326715,
-0.0463022366,
-0.0073252358,
-0.0105190137,
-0.0489613526,
-0.0008263471,
0.0191819258,
0.0290340651,
0.0310283694,
-0.0107220309,
-0.0372679271,
-0.0229473617,
-0.0353145525,
-0.0023924008,
-0.0254230853,
-0.0334644802,
-5.40574881e-33,
-0.0355317369,
-0.0113584576,
0.0084093763,
-0.0505400188,
0.0141931651,
0.0061803218,
-0.0010083161,
-0.0185093172,
-0.0191712137,
-0.0085025514,
0.0076982589,
0.0169282909,
0.0327117257,
0.028614331,
-0.0446140096,
-0.0493171997,
0.0424924903,
-0.012221436,
-0.0026083447,
0.0154492119,
0.0443920568,
0.0043441439,
0.0284165721,
-0.0695205927,
0.0135558415,
-0.0091830324,
-0.0043638148,
0.0415836461,
0.0651772469,
0.0609321743,
-0.0169314109,
0.0409247801,
0.028611768,
-0.0232276805,
0.0044924216,
0.0385370702,
-0.0904830173,
-0.0228585117,
-0.0090990793,
0.0390394181,
0.0077914796,
-0.0204123706,
0.008628333,
-0.0140532544,
-0.0058715348,
-0.0047522481,
0.0132413777,
-0.0051509617,
-0.0242207535,
0.0045147873,
-0.0692864582,
0.023859283,
0.0166086089,
-0.0712110251,
0.0152259879,
0.0702635348,
0.0350799263,
-0.0188993514,
-0.068498455,
0.0057766768,
-0.0786998793,
0.0037849755,
0.0127204303,
0.0633018538,
-0.0071554249,
0.0421329476,
0.0276395492,
0.029431358,
0.0183308478,
-0.0168574769,
-0.0117030274,
0.0453126468,
0.0158179812,
0.0222564433,
0.0432808176,
0.0200487189,
-0.0388749391,
0.0137767587,
0.023086207,
-0.0196528379,
-0.0077519668,
0.0254292358,
-0.0684188455,
-0.0064846734,
0.0277917143,
-0.0025857724,
-0.0433569737,
0.0247481056,
0.0496431924,
0.0142897433,
-0.0123118116,
0.0101471283,
0.056475088,
-0.0272577852,
0.0285788141,
-0.0024461634,
0.0400651097,
0.044691436,
-0.0206251442,
0.0012162615,
-0.0488862321,
-0.0513262711,
0.0682090297,
0.0132879596,
0.0047171032,
-0.0192311704,
0.0519253612,
-0.0120808724,
-0.0432327911,
-0.0242084507,
-0.0189323798,
0.024860112,
-0.0175755229,
0.0700502023,
0.035823103,
0.0084926048,
-0.0361409746,
0.0842892006,
0.009223571,
-0.0561761037,
0.0003426946,
-0.047435686,
-0.0160499569,
-0.0167648438,
-0.0301018488,
-0.0166355371,
0.0046384805,
-0.03890929,
-0.0367424935,
-0.0481671356,
-0.0040365937,
0.0134738749,
2.539e-7,
-0.021117853,
0.0350654572,
0.0312692113,
0.0296758283,
-0.0069129337,
0.0777097493,
0.013937748,
0.0277525522,
0.0032374077,
-0.0609567799,
0.0568470284,
-0.0172192287,
0.0225548241,
0.002634736,
-0.1139833853,
-0.003102544,
0.0446683951,
-0.0081949616,
-0.0205213092,
-0.0000230876,
0.0776048973,
0.1005867049,
0.0401300825,
-0.0202073697,
0.0155133512,
-0.0655310154,
0.0130658438,
0.0420053229,
0.0360952429,
0.023401035,
0.0538336858,
-0.0170083456,
0.0134811625,
0.052908998,
-0.0190657489,
0.0165760703,
0.0279733408,
0.0276590809,
-0.0357231498,
-0.0551352575,
-0.0300947148,
-0.01197707,
0.0259240512,
-0.0204058886,
0.0940756276,
-0.0222605281,
-0.0232455805,
0.0137864947,
-0.004102062,
0.0015625677,
-0.0181659721,
-0.0159581602,
-0.0133651784,
0.006270255,
0.035822548,
-0.0183923841,
0.0036149237,
-0.0654397756,
0.0081915259,
-0.0071296846,
-0.0202511996,
-0.0065029971,
-0.0177836511,
0.0268949792,
0.0412839241,
-0.0705854967,
-0.0072119413,
2.19566549e-34,
0.0103496825,
-0.02376757,
0.004503469,
0.0506842695,
0.0086425133,
-0.010737313,
-0.0398392342,
-0.0163769443,
0.0593837611,
-0.0474086069,
0.0161419176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13377v1 | A Human-Robot Mutual Learning System with Affect-Grounded Language Acquisition and Differential Outcomes Training | 2023-10-20T09:41:31 | 2023-10-20T09:41:31 | Alva Markelius, Sofia Sjöberg, Zakaria Lemhauori, Laura Cohen, Martin Bergström, Robert Lowe, Lola Cañamero | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.9; I.2.6; I.2.10 | This paper presents a novel human-robot interaction setup for robot and human
learning of symbolic language for identifying robot homeostatic needs. The
robot and human learn to use and respond to the same language symbols that
convey homeostatic needs and the stimuli that satisfy the homeostatic needs,
respectively. We adopted a differential outcomes training (DOT) protocol
whereby the robot provides feedback specific (differential) to its internal
needs (e.g. `hunger') when satisfied by the correct stimulus (e.g. cookie). We
found evidence that DOT can enhance the human's learning efficiency, which in
turn enables more efficient robot language acquisition. The robot used in the
study has a vocabulary similar to that of a human infant in the linguistic
``babbling'' phase. The robot software architecture is built upon a model for
affect-grounded language acquisition where the robot associates vocabulary with
internal needs (hunger, thirst, curiosity) through interactions with the human.
The paper presents the results of an initial pilot study conducted with the
interactive setup, which reveal that the robot's language acquisition achieves
higher convergence rate in the DOT condition compared to the non-DOT control
condition. Additionally, participants reported positive affective experiences,
feeling of being in control, and an empathetic connection with the robot. This
mutual learning (teacher-student learning) approach offers a potential
contribution of facilitating cognitive interventions with DOT (e.g. for people
with dementia) through increased therapy adherence as a result of engaging
humans more in training tasks by taking an active teaching-learning role. The
homeostatic motivational grounding of the robot's language acquisition has
potential to contribute to more ecologically valid and social
(collaborative/nurturing) interactions with robots. | [
0.0651922449,
-0.0123755326,
-0.0155464569,
-0.0012478877,
-0.0114253787,
0.0358866192,
0.0079889726,
-0.0142029244,
0.0837864503,
0.0135365082,
-0.0051575731,
0.0224254411,
-0.0011678461,
0.0060491059,
-0.0260942318,
-0.0531801805,
0.0536227748,
0.0397959985,
0.0214795843,
0.0019191027,
-0.0000247947,
0.0012458838,
-0.0264072064,
0.04505812,
-0.0295708291,
0.0255525,
-0.0206665192,
-0.0155343404,
0.0188541524,
-0.0619770512,
0.0252491478,
0.0059682741,
0.0777502432,
0.034518294,
0.0000021825,
-0.0466240682,
-0.0047520637,
0.004672783,
-0.0185722802,
-0.121921286,
0.0418094732,
-0.0098369066,
0.0032668293,
-0.0037970329,
-0.0301848445,
0.0278241616,
0.0373877436,
0.032299906,
0.0039396668,
-0.0089304261,
-0.0014323859,
-0.0356369838,
-0.0260514822,
0.029430259,
0.0052101617,
0.0359055586,
0.0120222233,
0.0487636067,
0.0563352443,
-0.06565734,
-0.0132303722,
-0.0145827224,
0.0445762947,
0.033638332,
0.0223518908,
0.0616696551,
0.0762044042,
-0.0694814622,
-0.0047707674,
0.0314883851,
0.0401478633,
0.0380349383,
0.0085137822,
0.0151592791,
0.0530113764,
0.022373151,
0.00910463,
-0.0123646548,
-0.023933867,
0.0162220336,
-0.0152314296,
-0.0481494665,
-0.037586242,
0.0213008765,
0.0429545753,
0.0735410154,
-0.0155442031,
-0.0212867111,
0.0385607705,
-0.019293353,
0.0053885588,
-0.0021021168,
0.0427318662,
0.0778948888,
0.0063259951,
0.0254317243,
-0.062683247,
0.0225143135,
0.0004500303,
-0.0341608226,
-0.0318686143,
0.0311606564,
-0.0588097163,
-0.0290307924,
0.0055259769,
0.023551723,
0.0448337533,
0.0148056345,
-0.0437147319,
0.0680039227,
-0.0919398218,
-0.0029535557,
-0.0494025126,
0.0480664596,
-0.0236365851,
-0.0416954122,
-0.0268576369,
0.0460937023,
-0.0035641002,
-0.0089247944,
-0.0352592655,
0.0247583054,
-0.0082354555,
0.0316647701,
-0.0342403203,
0.0212177001,
-0.053881824,
0.041728545,
0.0178422406,
-0.0051821945,
0.0053438484,
0.0125419926,
-0.0400808603,
-0.0179987829,
0.0405657701,
0.0685804561,
-0.0026863639,
-0.0640666634,
-0.0259507168,
-0.0037488698,
-0.0188776124,
-0.0211054478,
0.0304895844,
-0.0088011175,
-0.0181574989,
-0.0112708313,
0.0085676592,
-0.049253799,
0.026893273,
-0.0187931601,
0.0001818037,
0.0643363595,
-0.0108496817,
-0.0308015756,
0.0237319283,
0.0003994745,
0.0081727849,
0.052542828,
0.0408535376,
0.0258813612,
-0.0208930429,
-0.0228857417,
-0.0338034704,
-0.0305422619,
-0.0138683738,
-0.0029094778,
-0.0035484047,
-0.034239836,
0.0105535751,
0.0497754104,
-0.0261672735,
0.0210863743,
-0.0056891651,
0.0748260692,
0.0701267943,
0.0355714411,
-0.0329626761,
-0.0046567065,
-0.0483712219,
0.0001627138,
0.0097486312,
-0.0340392143,
0.0042699901,
0.0064951195,
-0.0322157331,
-0.0128491214,
-0.0431279056,
-0.0395824686,
-0.0304287989,
-0.0068599349,
0.0328208469,
-0.0389547609,
0.0887532607,
0.0174566023,
0.0667206347,
-0.0125794373,
-0.0032159742,
-0.0118645625,
0.0367188342,
-0.0296689682,
0.0047106072,
-0.0286599435,
0.0071071554,
0.0486632809,
-0.0013066869,
-0.0388747528,
-0.0025973401,
-0.0027336727,
-0.0144087486,
0.0287988223,
-0.0479256697,
-0.0086786542,
-0.0023542205,
0.0196680333,
-0.0142810708,
0.0154090906,
-0.0211755279,
0.0182095841,
-0.0474248566,
0.0417691655,
-0.0315986946,
0.0538049787,
-0.0175398383,
0.0496227406,
-0.004556146,
-0.0030448737,
0.0005394871,
0.0137812188,
0.0194495376,
0.0527052246,
-0.0001368036,
-0.0043436238,
0.0318521187,
-0.0082777776,
-0.0128925126,
0.0844964236,
-0.0105082998,
0.0175210647,
0.0255228188,
0.0243505035,
-0.0154143274,
0.0073040859,
0.0456227139,
-0.0014187461,
0.0062891385,
-0.0504439436,
0.0723377019,
-0.0084546357,
0.0291367341,
-0.0305229221,
0.0154986829,
-0.0213581473,
0.010133178,
-0.0152339255,
-0.0331822336,
-0.049693536,
0.0027774428,
-0.0018600941,
-0.0089212945,
-0.0241770316,
0.0310130976,
-0.0218347758,
-0.0062429407,
0.0217986424,
0.0285507049,
-0.1033312827,
-0.0057688467,
-0.0755239204,
-0.0353927948,
0.0186451841,
-0.019759167,
-0.0156241758,
-0.0486425795,
0.0088455006,
-0.0393361486,
0.0263108704,
0.059155371,
-0.0162189193,
0.0350323208,
-0.00206944,
0.03996123,
-0.0315196626,
-0.0107036587,
0.0214794986,
-0.0092866402,
-0.0531148948,
0.0548735,
0.0034358311,
-0.0433201827,
0.0371727534,
-0.0057010814,
0.0089865606,
-0.0268641599,
-0.0367737524,
0.0747413859,
0.0322435088,
0.0431725755,
0.0748629496,
0.0223251004,
0.0536161251,
0.0945408195,
-0.0054256655,
-0.0378651433,
-0.0208648574,
-0.0285864081,
-0.0193855818,
-0.0074366336,
0.0048696552,
-0.036121022,
-0.0016289378,
0.029535424,
0.0494715646,
-0.0774089247,
-0.0120194769,
-0.0253976732,
-0.0495923907,
-0.0323923156,
-0.0077024484,
-0.0500324667,
-0.0325897895,
0.002187195,
-0.0604556948,
0.0912047476,
0.037234664,
-0.0131995184,
-0.0202751998,
0.0132855186,
0.0397772342,
0.0107033662,
-0.0412113927,
-0.0045501306,
0.0407375842,
-0.0302432831,
-0.0088179624,
-0.0035154417,
-0.0316983648,
-0.0137349451,
-0.0040371828,
-0.0792471021,
-0.0129619017,
0.0246030614,
-0.0021138126,
-0.0638820976,
0.0623150878,
-0.0272451323,
0.0172854178,
-0.0245050918,
-0.001512623,
-0.0282069426,
-0.0394720212,
0.0661525801,
-0.0138391573,
0.0331168659,
-0.0070032175,
-0.0289111137,
-0.0944703668,
0.0645223856,
0.012147259,
-0.0239774976,
0.0061419676,
0.0248082951,
-0.0106143802,
0.0506138839,
-0.0286937933,
0.0112648727,
0.0283937845,
0.0191277899,
0.0131192775,
0.0481985845,
0.0258032791,
0.0257281307,
0.0488650762,
-0.0555495694,
0.0774578303,
-0.0079346607,
-0.0464186445,
0.0510680489,
-0.034335684,
-0.0366324969,
0.0039393869,
-0.0067992792,
-0.0413350873,
0.0105266841,
-0.0129346624,
0.0632817969,
-0.0219423957,
-0.0046055401,
-0.010730274,
-0.038548857,
-0.0280282106,
0.0084766475,
-0.0664904788,
-0.084572807,
-0.023377426,
-0.0041995994,
0.0326327793,
-0.0043456662,
0.0021458198,
-0.0095574679,
-0.0029411383,
0.0485032313,
0.0069348249,
-0.0249160323,
0.0271303486,
-0.0216066744,
0.0308118034,
0.0673980117,
0.0359062999,
-0.0125980638,
0.020519143,
-0.0390417501,
0.0090356814,
0.0219295155,
-0.0464109294,
-0.0036389958,
-0.0275346451,
0.0049088444,
-0.0265934635,
0.0463423841,
-0.0484559089,
-0.0020030581,
0.0218635686,
0.0570302494,
-0.0404854491,
-0.0077214041,
0.0067996364,
-0.0069454396,
0.029225463,
0.0087200031,
-0.0172015019,
-0.0404643975,
0.0234353002,
0.0314407162,
-0.0144834919,
0.0789117888,
-0.0143863047,
-0.0136721656,
-0.0724469796,
-0.0196536332,
-0.0826265812,
-0.0661474466,
0.0253426563,
0.0599755384,
0.0345638096,
0.0011526087,
0.0087089017,
0.0407708921,
0.0024378279,
0.0215327572,
0.0237773024,
0.0002684899,
-0.075732708,
-0.0533215739,
-0.0036097483,
-0.0547408164,
0.0106905131,
-0.0554396659,
0.0660601705,
-0.0551887639,
0.0609260574,
0.0473660305,
0.0180044584,
0.0321129598,
0.0541925021,
-0.0154427383,
-0.0317080058,
0.0389928296,
0.0363593139,
0.0184378754,
0.0004515904,
0.0470416695,
0.0224502664,
-0.0068551875,
-0.0293959528,
-0.013384033,
-0.0165395848,
0.0055702627,
0.0209129509,
-0.026121391,
0.0667907745,
0.0346988849,
0.0251911022,
-0.060016118,
-0.036553558,
-0.0514059886,
0.00022286,
-0.0295533389,
0.0007542667,
-0.0200200472,
-0.0170461163,
-0.0196486861,
-0.001578668,
0.0164186861,
-0.0620178655,
-0.0150533719,
-0.0530962609,
0.0124271754,
0.0205770526,
0.0091054896,
0.0831471086,
-0.0210366193,
0.0380487852,
0.0011640841,
-0.0334629305,
-0.0278015621,
0.0331992321,
-0.0104924627,
0.1150770262,
0.0067271017,
-0.0224495381,
-0.0121176587,
0.0483510233,
0.0329581425,
-0.0634853914,
-0.0037858817,
-0.03755394,
0.0327749513,
-0.0095133269,
-0.0003110508,
-0.084965907,
0.0352346078,
-0.0398423374,
0.0087033054,
-0.0528330468,
-0.0295432266,
-0.0289410558,
-0.0196632743,
0.0004644917,
0.0148324538,
0.0025399171,
-0.0669069886,
0.0894931704,
-0.0490322858,
0.0301600341,
-0.0217272844,
0.0066225668,
0.0181773994,
-0.0135127297,
-0.0513393804,
0.0119180651,
-0.0135002742,
-0.035260018,
-0.0426788144,
0.0194719546,
-0.0042783716,
0.0069598556,
0.0868658125,
-0.0308151655,
-0.0417416729,
-0.053144116,
-0.0192945749,
0.0574358068,
0.0024735276,
0.0200046077,
-0.0324513949,
-5.185757246e-33,
0.0053475574,
-0.0086363303,
0.0112700406,
0.0173611678,
0.0059751486,
-0.0333524682,
-0.0335943736,
0.032985948,
-0.0213061646,
0.0076332577,
0.039803762,
-0.0060734022,
0.0048118914,
-0.0503859594,
0.0527492426,
-0.020625677,
-0.0129227191,
-0.0117167076,
-0.0001524769,
-0.013720857,
0.0445282348,
0.050425496,
0.0233121943,
-0.0601489022,
0.0634397641,
0.0253829844,
0.0183281135,
-0.018138634,
0.0055042813,
-0.0264873859,
0.0010825726,
0.0281334762,
-0.0030686834,
0.0606854297,
-0.0178063828,
0.0176092535,
-0.0454668552,
-0.0391333699,
-0.0068330984,
-0.0014818379,
-0.0489785373,
-0.0146606099,
0.0195626412,
-0.0265243594,
-0.0767722726,
0.0814086422,
0.0134450514,
-0.0167170074,
0.0095165856,
0.0222350676,
-0.0511934534,
-0.0485360585,
0.0053326641,
-0.067597121,
0.0006479635,
0.0483408272,
-0.0394929573,
0.0146768512,
0.0115384404,
0.0300751384,
-0.0621013828,
-0.0119655114,
0.0263662003,
-0.0412464626,
0.0470659807,
0.0288360938,
0.0438380018,
0.0031165467,
0.0257981084,
-0.0130476803,
0.0498474799,
0.0131953154,
0.0547714792,
-0.0589080192,
-0.0166564174,
-0.039057713,
-0.0253427699,
0.0121206082,
0.0023840673,
0.0633502603,
-0.0050839707,
0.0433356687,
-0.0153961629,
0.0011018736,
-0.0130423596,
0.0363228582,
-0.0018179073,
-0.0655513927,
0.0180866979,
-0.0021847044,
-0.0058160294,
-0.0928641781,
-0.0131312348,
-0.0296249595,
0.0429572128,
-0.0119484346,
0.0172150284,
-0.0092419917,
0.0011857243,
-0.0407885648,
-0.0483058915,
-0.0494334847,
0.0110683171,
-0.0088507449,
0.0303667597,
0.0185288452,
-0.0519052669,
0.0285563748,
0.0308794379,
0.0017788723,
-0.0310823694,
-0.0015318013,
0.0943556651,
-0.0554536767,
-0.0031959184,
0.0344480574,
-0.02620342,
0.0654863194,
0.0176342502,
-0.045572076,
-0.0955089405,
0.035171736,
-0.0241244677,
0.0115815345,
-0.0311262123,
-0.0276987944,
-0.0253432784,
0.0494069792,
0.0081605911,
0.0023690616,
0.0138041908,
-0.0400775224,
2.987e-7,
-0.0430466905,
0.074801378,
0.0273286384,
-0.0201614257,
-0.0105990637,
0.0236610733,
-0.0002978714,
0.0546830557,
-0.0020932488,
-0.0216950756,
0.0118865855,
-0.0210080408,
0.0150645534,
-0.0348142236,
-0.0079708584,
-0.0145155005,
0.0024985052,
-0.0093797622,
0.0023410539,
0.0309634376,
0.0388966165,
-0.0253867488,
0.0087011857,
0.0058032912,
-0.0129196094,
0.0028374032,
-0.0144606857,
-0.0371879749,
0.0559164174,
-0.0559873059,
-0.0217565354,
-0.0179200284,
0.0308662131,
0.0283727404,
0.0115677714,
-0.0303088687,
-0.0413572229,
0.040593531,
-0.0767921656,
-0.0196994245,
0.0163297188,
0.0979335755,
-0.0419773348,
0.0054152426,
0.0106850648,
-0.0834580436,
-0.0183925424,
0.0497754514,
0.0199232977,
-0.0348694324,
0.0111922249,
-0.0199537985,
-0.0142070074,
0.0016350922,
-0.0539231449,
0.0554084666,
0.0125127723,
-0.0368709341,
0.0274030138,
0.0239006709,
-0.0727779344,
-0.030330345,
-0.0092258258,
-0.0129944151,
-0.0700136945,
-0.02799863,
-0.0040927548,
1.608778239e-34,
-0.056600485,
0.005032633,
0.0200513992,
0.0577523448,
0.01106844,
0.0216945037,
-0.0184580386,
0.0465968922,
0.0547015108,
-0.0070961672,
-0.0424713604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13362v1 | Towards General Error Diagnosis via Behavioral Testing in Machine Translation | 2023-10-20T09:06:41 | 2023-10-20T09:06:41 | Junjie Wu, Lemao Liu, Dit-Yan Yeung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | Behavioral testing offers a crucial means of diagnosing linguistic errors and
assessing capabilities of NLP models. However, applying behavioral testing to
machine translation (MT) systems is challenging as it generally requires human
efforts to craft references for evaluating the translation quality of such
systems on newly generated test cases. Existing works in behavioral testing of
MT systems circumvent this by evaluating translation quality without
references, but this restricts diagnosis to specific types of errors, such as
incorrect translation of single numeric or currency words. In order to diagnose
general errors, this paper proposes a new Bilingual Translation Pair Generation
based Behavior Testing (BTPGBT) framework for conducting behavioral testing of
MT systems. The core idea of BTPGBT is to employ a novel bilingual translation
pair generation (BTPG) approach that automates the construction of high-quality
test cases and their pseudoreferences. Experimental results on various MT
systems demonstrate that BTPGBT could provide comprehensive and accurate
behavioral testing results for general error diagnosis, which further leads to
several insightful findings. Our code and data are available at https:
//github.com/wujunjie1998/BTPGBT. | [
0.0226240214,
0.040243946,
-0.0530638695,
0.0683286712,
-0.011375702,
0.023739066,
0.0217171479,
0.0482198857,
-0.0092543708,
-0.0210280698,
0.0093943281,
-0.0386569649,
0.0275041927,
-0.0040247017,
0.054107096,
0.0100801811,
0.0688324347,
0.0094201211,
-0.0392453298,
0.0133186746,
-0.0011781899,
0.0226572212,
-0.0028920469,
0.0172662493,
-0.0107058501,
0.0103150345,
0.003904463,
0.0179703683,
0.0521781035,
-0.0309084784,
-0.0041748467,
0.0116211977,
-0.0223427135,
0.0891611427,
0.0000020252,
-0.0515551828,
-0.0405576304,
0.0275396369,
0.0147362668,
-0.0192916375,
0.0439143628,
-0.056111943,
-0.0279452708,
0.0372424088,
-0.0270817801,
-0.0455353893,
0.0359389521,
0.0205923393,
0.07192792,
0.0813739672,
-0.0123120127,
0.0028096251,
-0.0271390062,
0.000519964,
0.0275487993,
-0.0184899252,
0.0004542804,
0.0334370844,
0.0028715588,
0.0005832894,
0.0297569949,
0.0019999903,
0.0070720157,
-0.0008798452,
-0.1158754453,
-0.0319183245,
-0.0271558333,
-0.0380568393,
0.0098839365,
0.0319512337,
-0.0241772979,
-0.0192685258,
0.0110627692,
0.0167916771,
-0.024428403,
-0.0338515826,
0.03346885,
0.0094923396,
-0.0404086299,
-0.0104684206,
0.0403955169,
0.0279706493,
0.0207668077,
0.0000925648,
-0.0584627315,
0.0173939038,
-0.0132974079,
-0.0470015742,
-0.0287809577,
0.0098653203,
0.00160041,
-0.0240036584,
0.0278487094,
-0.0017096952,
-0.0510355383,
0.002490262,
-0.0320939906,
-0.077171579,
0.0584337562,
-0.0488975495,
0.0249378458,
0.0479693748,
-0.0186078511,
0.0152460542,
-0.0333333649,
0.1093787998,
0.0098392628,
0.0039801658,
-0.06389606,
0.0097331638,
-0.0008494768,
0.0454228483,
-0.0385743864,
-0.0187259763,
0.0040897103,
0.0173955448,
0.0045426805,
0.019203715,
-0.0185066406,
0.0517132916,
-0.0336061716,
-0.0640728399,
-0.0362834148,
-0.0000716039,
-0.0028636728,
-0.0246642679,
-0.0140388794,
-0.0613181479,
-0.0190792568,
-0.0202103909,
-0.0213407297,
0.0213588458,
-0.0409427769,
-0.0271924622,
0.0005668246,
0.0968359783,
0.0149803925,
-0.0087941997,
0.0070248498,
-0.0322823003,
-0.0039473474,
-0.0473591313,
-0.0138929375,
-0.0524624027,
0.0206535608,
0.0105846552,
0.0072419485,
0.0036201493,
0.0199329723,
0.0222054757,
0.0019678958,
0.0747676715,
0.0040521906,
-0.0118725374,
-0.0297696069,
-0.0179256927,
0.0236285664,
0.0915624872,
0.0222169422,
-0.0289995484,
0.0468665659,
0.0097442484,
-0.0158994831,
0.0637774691,
0.0107982177,
0.0362767018,
-0.0210628137,
-0.0011515525,
0.0591986626,
0.0324181169,
0.0268512294,
0.0670111254,
-0.0333105028,
0.0147451144,
-0.0212010536,
0.0264526345,
-0.029229518,
0.0304671358,
0.0698413029,
-0.0088853128,
-0.012241846,
0.0083679464,
-0.0143193128,
-0.0428602099,
-0.0500335842,
0.0001621075,
0.0026201194,
0.0252449233,
0.0138423005,
-0.0674616396,
-0.0752333328,
-0.009498179,
0.0823551863,
-0.0363562889,
0.0461288393,
0.0277679898,
-0.044412259,
0.0150369434,
-0.0429448821,
-0.0460065454,
-0.0109091355,
-0.042520795,
-0.0124042369,
0.0460823923,
0.0720457435,
-0.0176532269,
-0.0020817749,
0.001408171,
-0.0450126901,
0.0492945202,
0.071675092,
-0.0040325583,
-0.029075563,
-0.0250491556,
0.0139241247,
0.0426455028,
0.022542838,
-0.0073727653,
-0.0062377951,
0.0515186749,
0.0243347939,
-0.0312458593,
-0.0865286961,
0.0391015485,
-0.015826121,
-0.0253242385,
0.0192256086,
0.0016619676,
0.0317211822,
0.0341346115,
-0.009032988,
-0.0126093961,
0.00553841,
-0.0026054296,
-0.0073295468,
0.035856232,
0.0135234902,
-0.0609509014,
0.0208839159,
-0.0135975508,
-0.0554280877,
-0.0111153442,
-0.0512719676,
-0.030010758,
-0.017755216,
-0.0628892407,
-0.0215927921,
-0.0366786122,
0.0387223214,
-0.0278240703,
0.011235619,
-0.0340188369,
-0.0001162833,
-0.0090674609,
0.0373997279,
-0.0168089848,
0.000594651,
0.0428938828,
-0.0514200516,
-0.0528603345,
0.0631882772,
-0.0009148922,
0.0239765272,
0.0075002997,
0.0703032166,
-0.0276607666,
-0.0168809965,
-0.0467888974,
0.0223123394,
-0.02250834,
0.0658833459,
0.0388855077,
0.0178189296,
-0.0053960131,
-0.0022485291,
0.0093018478,
0.0019601681,
0.0527004488,
-0.0014778123,
0.0552184209,
-0.0250754226,
-0.0064418172,
-0.0141055556,
0.0203304533,
-0.042920433,
0.0344130248,
0.0212081112,
0.0268100817,
-0.1217574775,
0.0131114479,
-0.0127064027,
0.0166878309,
0.0264116935,
-0.0673824474,
0.0253859498,
-0.0015094196,
0.0254597869,
0.0527256951,
-0.0051081865,
0.014817141,
-0.0138424188,
-0.0059026526,
-0.0609916151,
0.0008160658,
0.003206129,
-0.0143675618,
0.0131695895,
-0.0825736821,
0.0137398485,
0.0342704877,
-0.0233125109,
-0.0095714768,
-0.0428132974,
0.0235432368,
-0.0260802507,
-0.0127585419,
0.0057315049,
0.023222791,
0.012712107,
0.0468045175,
-0.009351681,
-0.0199170448,
0.0886475444,
-0.0469396561,
-0.0123696113,
-0.1053501815,
0.0180976577,
-0.0384457931,
0.0369370505,
0.0097974036,
0.0023425696,
0.01694916,
-0.0231631715,
0.0306290612,
0.0222173333,
0.0126313018,
-0.0460618399,
0.045392599,
-0.0796139687,
0.0092586847,
0.0003455844,
-0.0263808407,
-0.0331236199,
0.0188377853,
-0.0065286066,
-0.0227016285,
-0.0041645202,
-0.0288458355,
-0.0248672981,
0.0341397673,
0.024027383,
0.0286085568,
0.0231302697,
-0.0212673172,
-0.0151108894,
-0.0416234657,
-0.0301187206,
-0.0155017292,
0.0238932855,
-0.0379105061,
-0.0117893852,
0.0045635924,
0.0150203342,
0.0001966381,
-0.0289394166,
-0.0367689766,
0.0105892047,
-0.0196796693,
-0.0320113637,
-0.0161419585,
0.0084244609,
-0.0592986085,
-0.0489770286,
0.0661590844,
0.0559366271,
-0.037713673,
0.0155323315,
-0.0220312811,
0.0000458477,
0.020989608,
0.0619615838,
-0.0942720398,
0.0104138944,
0.0283565801,
0.0376697369,
-0.0166090894,
0.0173460133,
-0.01195761,
-0.1289651394,
0.0031331382,
0.0285684727,
-0.0351825394,
-0.0260683894,
-0.0220717415,
-0.0141888373,
-0.0496204048,
0.0635259375,
0.010203382,
0.0159763508,
-0.0101012327,
0.004183474,
-0.0313310437,
-0.0671816319,
0.0182976536,
-0.0304806679,
0.008535292,
0.0831046253,
0.0271110237,
-0.0136263175,
-0.0414031595,
-0.0009841297,
-0.0395305827,
-0.0152383111,
-0.0299343318,
0.0097557362,
0.0323658623,
-0.0332891494,
0.0277423188,
-0.0136794066,
-0.064833127,
0.0019298167,
0.0034660297,
0.0376969427,
-0.0047446564,
-0.0165540762,
0.0109768789,
-0.0010260696,
0.0284915734,
0.0309471544,
0.0043036086,
-0.0381176323,
-0.0338890739,
-0.0230096318,
-0.0464853235,
-0.0792701617,
-0.0608489476,
-0.0219777469,
-0.0261621401,
-0.0081886267,
-0.0915946588,
-0.0557130314,
-0.0021811062,
0.0396076776,
-0.0095577519,
-0.0397205986,
-0.001714931,
-0.0183862988,
0.0150011238,
0.0318301879,
0.0361019522,
0.0446516834,
-0.0446379893,
0.0227670539,
-0.0020440724,
-0.002642286,
0.0145968664,
0.0483415723,
-0.0190266501,
-0.0570262372,
0.0201005004,
0.053540051,
0.0171734858,
0.0139741348,
-0.0757993236,
0.0103242518,
-0.0385001414,
0.0334598012,
0.0222617965,
-0.0194128957,
0.0468083322,
0.0004510513,
-0.0138856256,
0.0181156993,
0.0018881422,
0.0044399146,
-0.0540448576,
0.027480673,
-0.037675675,
-0.0280250441,
0.0302684195,
0.0453311577,
0.0307618789,
-0.0204339828,
-0.0274255015,
-0.0036918905,
0.0017895082,
-0.0347227901,
-0.0479177758,
-0.0073500024,
0.0077068103,
-0.0183834434,
-0.0247371718,
-0.0027979061,
-0.0465603322,
-0.0567108244,
-0.0250453018,
0.0448978171,
0.0386948921,
-0.0221199151,
0.058058206,
0.0113728242,
0.0046088714,
-0.00692053,
0.0165330507,
-0.0026442413,
0.0685288385,
-0.0323729329,
0.073632732,
0.0106144464,
0.0052917423,
0.012359187,
0.033363279,
0.0388552621,
0.0166746415,
-0.0134831592,
-0.0382570811,
0.0534730032,
-0.0089402953,
0.1037006155,
-0.0202023797,
0.0053399536,
0.0111399936,
0.0133512449,
-0.0083525125,
-0.0093473233,
-0.0289435573,
0.0075376127,
-0.0013713347,
-0.0303782187,
0.0426401161,
-0.0327894464,
-0.0097704874,
-0.0111337947,
-0.0007820125,
-0.0053227232,
0.012986552,
0.0010708064,
-0.0683067739,
-0.0433893576,
-0.0487977527,
-0.0410585515,
-0.0860278904,
0.0191204771,
0.0751048848,
0.049369283,
0.0206986964,
-0.0011267359,
0.1143079624,
0.0198283903,
0.0450532623,
-0.0234144162,
-0.0025353907,
0.0004848874,
-0.0236513894,
-0.0599520132,
-5.811404563e-33,
-0.0133632217,
-0.0575999655,
0.0046265479,
-0.0380118228,
0.0162055735,
-0.0241024699,
-0.0411077477,
0.0053836955,
0.0331030972,
-0.006475667,
-0.0037011325,
0.00043394,
0.0289891511,
-0.0488499664,
0.0118837049,
0.0127927642,
0.0455979891,
0.0253765471,
-0.0379512422,
-0.0377381332,
0.0494071096,
-0.0272491388,
0.0829951465,
-0.0798320323,
0.0569488592,
-0.0080609377,
-0.042163793,
0.030942278,
-0.0422547124,
0.0414575115,
0.0154535798,
0.0154777123,
0.0071742125,
0.021880934,
-0.0344045945,
-0.0407790765,
-0.0451593474,
-0.0207732953,
0.0129150404,
0.0591030046,
-0.009832575,
-0.0138486736,
0.0369532853,
-0.0739947632,
-0.0337002613,
0.0496067666,
-0.001656158,
-0.0262230616,
0.0049693463,
0.0225737132,
-0.0549621992,
0.0353808589,
0.0233285446,
0.0201615915,
0.0306482818,
0.0544411615,
-0.019126704,
-0.0556755997,
-0.0902601257,
0.002906692,
-0.018635476,
-0.0119917206,
0.0760844946,
-0.0358706862,
-0.0144780865,
0.0013039262,
0.0028285366,
0.0435860641,
0.038721025,
0.0254548099,
0.0760348514,
-0.0445371233,
0.0813959315,
0.0638643801,
0.045269262,
-0.0434490219,
-0.0004683811,
0.0572664477,
0.0341694094,
0.00856975,
0.005897352,
-0.0040431619,
-0.0802019164,
-0.0114468019,
-0.0414447449,
-0.0108564962,
-0.0312812291,
-0.0603147522,
-0.0029093993,
0.0227964483,
-0.0091951042,
-0.0048714043,
0.0370616019,
-0.0321779251,
0.0018947005,
-0.0447241552,
-0.0395914428,
-0.0118260784,
-0.0405498147,
0.0314392298,
0.0100085912,
-0.0965417027,
-0.0251202192,
0.0532301441,
0.0488969311,
-0.0036607387,
0.0311601907,
0.0075806128,
-0.0504130758,
0.0318742394,
-0.0011271796,
0.0438219421,
-0.0218924321,
0.0074476842,
-0.0018513229,
0.00574065,
0.0069835652,
0.0159038231,
0.0541029908,
-0.0340291113,
-0.0666794628,
0.0489297919,
-0.003127713,
0.0484626442,
-0.01927053,
0.025410654,
-0.020867724,
0.069020465,
0.0293140225,
-0.0090991575,
-0.0113627976,
0.0148311723,
2.779e-7,
0.0432838425,
0.092737332,
-0.0256394446,
0.0631574392,
-0.0023009421,
0.0211721826,
-0.0358631313,
0.0123753427,
-0.0056767836,
0.0433190092,
-0.0087390859,
-0.0093035307,
0.0743716434,
0.0898976028,
-0.0472382866,
-0.016912898,
-0.0031581901,
-0.0022096878,
-0.049452275,
0.015632635,
0.0193019677,
0.0498146303,
-0.0082744025,
0.0251400359,
-0.0140470173,
-0.0364871994,
0.0383405834,
0.0173460022,
-0.0327265002,
0.0144330431,
0.013623992,
0.0242061317,
0.0222528949,
0.0240339432,
-0.013732994,
-0.0151755968,
0.010388976,
0.0091635436,
0.0307700373,
0.0060651647,
0.0177552756,
-0.0418417901,
0.00736544,
-0.0319419056,
0.0315024517,
-0.0235360116,
0.0116648441,
0.0354764648,
0.0107488185,
-0.0064848624,
0.0363593362,
-0.0332606994,
-0.0448960178,
0.0696523264,
0.0365524106,
0.0240227636,
-0.0046816585,
-0.0252622999,
-0.009002598,
0.0043929433,
-0.009265516,
-0.0351063311,
0.0172751751,
0.015163064,
-0.045558732,
-0.0160056837,
-0.0026397146,
2.838970615e-34,
0.0551297627,
-0.0131633431,
0.0026043102,
-0.0398397669,
0.0645834506,
0.0133855427,
-0.0010072695,
0.0363168046,
0.0050542527,
0.0011635094,
-0.0065326514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13361v1 | Bridging the Gap between Synthetic and Authentic Images for Multimodal Machine Translation | 2023-10-20T09:06:30 | 2023-10-20T09:06:30 | Wenyu Guo, Qingkai Fang, Dong Yu, Yang Feng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multimodal machine translation (MMT) simultaneously takes the source sentence
and a relevant image as input for translation. Since there is no paired image
available for the input sentence in most cases, recent studies suggest
utilizing powerful text-to-image generation models to provide image inputs.
Nevertheless, synthetic images generated by these models often follow different
distributions compared to authentic images. Consequently, using authentic
images for training and synthetic images for inference can introduce a
distribution shift, resulting in performance degradation during inference. To
tackle this challenge, in this paper, we feed synthetic and authentic images to
the MMT model, respectively. Then we minimize the gap between the synthetic and
authentic images by drawing close the input image representations of the
Transformer Encoder and the output distributions of the Transformer Decoder.
Therefore, we mitigate the distribution disparity introduced by the synthetic
images during inference, thereby freeing the authentic images from the
inference process.Experimental results show that our approach achieves
state-of-the-art performance on the Multi30K En-De and En-Fr datasets, while
remaining independent of authentic images during inference. | [
0.0213593505,
0.0740148872,
0.0091630556,
0.0694849491,
-0.0232972149,
-0.0095506776,
0.027968986,
0.011329134,
-0.0567878261,
-0.0296888389,
-0.0340479799,
-0.0141147561,
0.0172508322,
0.0025065562,
0.0527389832,
-0.0658868998,
-0.0244177822,
-0.0118999714,
-0.0790984482,
-0.0164293777,
0.0000301102,
0.03556519,
0.0005387664,
0.0157496613,
-0.0615451895,
0.0062675043,
0.0052034687,
0.0889830217,
0.0400163643,
0.0057704677,
-0.0357676223,
0.034750551,
0.0142566832,
0.0239622165,
0.0000022154,
-0.009764214,
-0.0068065054,
-0.0007865942,
0.0267841741,
-0.006301262,
0.078031078,
-0.0885485485,
-0.0119614583,
-0.0085513731,
-0.0188103877,
0.004224054,
0.0908508971,
0.0430617779,
0.058124017,
0.0745926797,
-0.0479796827,
-0.0391235463,
-0.0326725654,
-0.026532365,
-0.0216774661,
-0.0141208498,
-0.0317082219,
0.0002795315,
-0.0605382323,
0.0141240358,
-0.0338646546,
0.0527186804,
0.0579438247,
-0.0065383213,
0.0010334614,
0.0326580033,
-0.0054920102,
-0.0635225326,
-0.0268727634,
0.0559488572,
-0.0758117586,
-0.0049805068,
-0.0312344674,
-0.0185502302,
-0.008394327,
0.0472967401,
0.005608276,
0.052150473,
-0.0276637357,
0.0293240771,
-0.0689408928,
0.0394251086,
0.0099630458,
-0.0254975744,
-0.0575788431,
-0.0427731611,
0.0374424346,
0.0123852836,
-0.0553808361,
0.0426382162,
-0.0707400069,
0.0061787586,
0.049047567,
-0.0268852152,
0.0287705064,
-0.0042610611,
-0.0635200292,
-0.0673811063,
-0.0166264959,
-0.033859279,
0.0339500941,
0.0474846512,
-0.024162028,
0.019046573,
-0.0193213541,
0.0282717627,
-0.0469834395,
0.0425451212,
-0.0531339347,
-0.0307298992,
-0.0152669437,
-0.0000898362,
-0.0275622644,
-0.0576151088,
-0.0627377033,
-0.0303951949,
-0.0202074405,
0.0126414951,
0.0160479806,
-0.039589189,
0.0441550873,
0.0171740577,
-0.085955143,
-0.0315962993,
-0.023550665,
0.0385791063,
0.0177961402,
0.0150624029,
-0.0138665773,
-0.0513482839,
-0.02135868,
0.0458149724,
0.0144684734,
-0.0395147204,
-0.017868517,
0.0789079145,
-0.0551309101,
-0.0273058824,
-0.0058948756,
-0.0017273248,
-0.0158559699,
-0.0501449145,
0.0602792241,
-0.0464905612,
0.0711535513,
0.0001505152,
0.0151340505,
-0.0175605305,
-0.0046316744,
-0.0043239915,
0.0041436087,
0.0720677525,
0.0170578919,
-0.0040186932,
0.0424421951,
-0.006946221,
-0.0226283334,
0.0673321858,
0.0521427989,
0.0411900356,
-0.0010157315,
-0.007132112,
0.0095965238,
0.0644102469,
0.0045114979,
0.0124144461,
-0.0077476082,
-0.0375212654,
0.0024716444,
0.019907346,
0.0792228132,
0.0529757105,
-0.0222568233,
0.0137749445,
0.1164227799,
-0.0225986913,
0.0051046219,
0.0049291858,
0.0555580407,
0.0179294106,
-0.0165608246,
0.0112496689,
-0.0334804021,
0.0543017872,
0.0509809777,
0.0107108848,
0.0349686034,
0.0956238881,
-0.0209541898,
-0.0096138623,
0.0260248668,
-0.0301087182,
-0.0197090581,
-0.0262633152,
0.0314268954,
0.0391872227,
-0.0625551194,
0.0430660285,
-0.0158626903,
-0.0222805906,
0.0099291047,
-0.0148273529,
-0.0407639556,
0.0486839451,
0.0448286831,
0.0489834845,
0.0485574938,
0.022027839,
-0.0236839745,
0.0812710747,
-0.0148051493,
0.0466385446,
0.0491311513,
-0.046041619,
-0.0507150702,
0.0093055079,
-0.0173968524,
0.0278214514,
0.0040177847,
0.0208572075,
0.015288502,
-0.0360990725,
0.0261570588,
0.0328148343,
0.0277350694,
0.0202003717,
0.0146067804,
0.0277161673,
0.0143676251,
-0.0127863698,
-0.0404646844,
-0.0123231756,
-0.0099277431,
-0.0279631875,
-0.0060685147,
0.041350238,
-0.0523148626,
-0.0566325821,
-0.0199231561,
-0.0988878161,
-0.000237625,
0.0271249264,
-0.0287241396,
-0.0370852947,
-0.0196336675,
-0.0298111625,
-0.0048027229,
-0.0492017791,
0.0205929894,
0.0396900177,
0.04660156,
0.0035328702,
0.0314297676,
-0.0384260081,
-0.035958685,
-0.0052013649,
0.00777537,
0.0060857898,
-0.0189903416,
-0.0108136414,
0.0023220996,
0.0384177044,
0.0267423075,
0.0209110826,
0.0162820294,
-0.0170390084,
-0.024611216,
-0.028991228,
-0.0165298749,
-0.0111618936,
-0.0015025034,
0.0252633449,
0.0313578732,
0.0072096139,
-0.0109690223,
-0.0080429353,
0.0299683791,
0.0105481269,
-0.0001255269,
0.0164017025,
-0.0017151927,
0.0434530675,
0.0079659373,
0.0059614535,
0.0277688485,
0.072736524,
-0.006853309,
0.0044223275,
-0.0671514943,
-0.0013975899,
-0.0096462788,
0.0159435254,
-0.0163799357,
-0.0459433384,
0.0046459031,
-0.0035365096,
0.079838343,
0.0354186483,
0.020860482,
-0.0245798938,
0.0017233816,
0.017186394,
-0.0314960442,
-0.0218983348,
-0.0029408338,
-0.0034309896,
0.0015967813,
-0.0560818389,
-0.0067241201,
0.021566255,
0.0326501168,
0.0250178184,
-0.0444978066,
0.0105895614,
0.0426159948,
-0.0239321366,
-0.0020523656,
0.0530069768,
0.0084492248,
0.0101417396,
-0.0375636369,
-0.0690255463,
0.0504225418,
-0.056907054,
-0.0200654138,
-0.0172412004,
0.0350553542,
0.0342376865,
0.0215706341,
0.0180027597,
0.0490650311,
0.0028881754,
0.0277583413,
-0.0319951251,
0.0150443297,
0.0348146521,
-0.01029424,
0.0256177187,
-0.0479090437,
-0.0090110973,
-0.0321256444,
-0.0097242948,
-0.0264494885,
-0.0196504835,
0.0273488685,
-0.0386384316,
0.0007873779,
-0.025456598,
-0.0309022013,
0.0110093262,
-0.0073716906,
0.0451352969,
0.0182469375,
-0.0198904406,
-0.0261122435,
0.0712146536,
0.0151001867,
-0.0014659684,
-0.0231126435,
-0.0602348782,
-0.0061363252,
0.0427964441,
-0.0271208119,
-0.0065243295,
-0.0585203506,
-0.0057034935,
0.0136637101,
0.0890558958,
0.0130551308,
0.0227728486,
0.0529142246,
-0.0308301169,
-0.0009937542,
0.0410055704,
-0.0177183542,
-0.0537652783,
-0.0142286727,
0.0465630181,
0.0479950234,
0.0004934574,
0.004228163,
-0.1050730795,
-0.0270733461,
-0.0212051682,
-0.0042858613,
0.002872355,
0.0422889404,
-0.0321803205,
-0.0911468342,
0.0549166203,
0.0352944434,
-0.0266848393,
-0.0516236052,
0.0076876264,
-0.0351287946,
-0.0154795041,
0.010994046,
-0.0051701986,
0.0329747684,
0.0066187065,
0.0124024106,
0.076309599,
-0.0905584469,
-0.0528333634,
-0.0371786281,
-0.0257349778,
0.0091484776,
0.0114308121,
0.0118900398,
-0.0669355989,
0.0073433397,
0.0132110463,
0.0248085056,
0.0137849022,
0.0404693671,
-0.0217859522,
-0.0208854936,
0.0035294774,
0.0107368072,
-0.0015626863,
0.0153734135,
-0.0086821122,
0.0401448682,
-0.0309126806,
-0.0138486531,
-0.0139967641,
-0.0241375398,
0.0194240529,
0.0135445055,
-0.0135829011,
-0.0442361943,
-0.0099535445,
-0.0269185249,
0.0122920163,
-0.0635068491,
-0.0108508589,
0.0458366908,
-0.020578159,
-0.0839676633,
-0.0770936981,
-0.0083424589,
-0.0131700663,
0.0664366111,
-0.0204108395,
-0.0468686856,
-0.0159771424,
0.0271951128,
-0.0340560153,
0.0657498464,
-0.0556706674,
0.0234741848,
-0.0067710988,
0.0191277694,
0.003343225,
-0.0511641279,
0.0094141932,
0.0509803742,
-0.1011413485,
-0.0319570079,
-0.0593498759,
0.0710444301,
0.0150825195,
0.0410472564,
0.0165683497,
0.0082735959,
0.0220317319,
0.0355393887,
-0.0100843208,
-0.0078921383,
0.0037114588,
-0.0385756865,
-0.0183895808,
-0.000764171,
-0.0051092929,
0.0337081812,
-0.0057400512,
0.0278135557,
-0.000265439,
-0.0542564727,
0.025153229,
-0.0141921854,
0.0179517716,
-0.0619208664,
0.0204996578,
-0.0232827757,
0.0113408025,
-0.0221338067,
-0.032038521,
-0.0602035001,
-0.0133772641,
0.023585327,
0.0431033634,
0.0174186919,
0.0149191814,
0.0117742633,
0.0183329042,
-0.013885404,
-0.0310609899,
0.0228727423,
-0.0055632424,
-0.0035431839,
0.0186550934,
0.0128323212,
0.0068758773,
-0.0045694099,
0.0067463168,
-0.0297702644,
0.0728224292,
0.0153557677,
-0.0170362834,
-0.0150943398,
0.0267916564,
-0.0082319696,
0.0428556502,
-0.0710405856,
0.0344999805,
0.0639773533,
0.0129272901,
0.0717184842,
-0.0182925723,
-0.0036081199,
-0.0245976429,
0.0636556819,
0.0341676027,
-0.0245530922,
0.0466703586,
-0.054045815,
0.0283843279,
0.0081338659,
0.0466311239,
-0.0002159945,
0.0127603244,
-0.0565516204,
-0.0043975557,
-0.0357743539,
-0.0240144897,
0.018845614,
-0.065060474,
0.0192700252,
0.0038177858,
0.0155165475,
-0.0580648705,
-0.0071272529,
0.0378282368,
-0.0187552366,
-0.003320117,
0.0467693657,
0.0592629798,
-0.0128014702,
-0.0157406703,
-0.0097095929,
-0.016993599,
0.016580509,
0.0094049955,
-0.020042913,
-6.367931344e-33,
-0.0051091369,
-0.0283328444,
0.0228980873,
-0.0540341176,
-0.031595502,
-0.0060765687,
-0.0276093986,
-0.0156206824,
-0.0153383203,
0.0102892993,
0.0154570006,
0.0104115549,
0.0220928974,
0.0512683839,
-0.0211177934,
0.0387154631,
0.0586184636,
-0.0124999275,
-0.0366465896,
0.0058712042,
0.0297902226,
0.009608035,
0.0728369057,
-0.0355259143,
-0.0148626827,
-0.0165635981,
-0.0393348299,
-0.0141149601,
0.0145384902,
0.0105819125,
-0.0238765795,
0.0443109646,
0.0040064617,
-0.0525628515,
-0.0151372105,
-0.0061075324,
-0.0400491506,
0.0377999395,
-0.0012767008,
0.0613907389,
-0.0617708005,
-0.0461817198,
0.0550540425,
-0.0376468189,
-0.0181557368,
-0.0421427414,
0.0317785293,
-0.0454012044,
0.0187086258,
-0.0473565198,
-0.0413091779,
0.0109077236,
-0.0023386965,
-0.0288348235,
0.0086347703,
0.0674046502,
0.0170376115,
0.0193264503,
-0.0482712351,
0.0135741392,
-0.0220040772,
-0.0018919988,
0.0731299371,
0.0303249825,
-0.012654637,
-0.0061551766,
-0.0306143854,
-0.0299632624,
-0.0030547688,
0.0077604828,
0.0227652788,
0.0496018045,
0.0563896857,
0.0983782709,
0.0346690379,
0.0002116942,
-0.0243932921,
0.0614260398,
-0.0346162468,
-0.0114961714,
0.0465728194,
0.0031424263,
0.0215709023,
0.0117371706,
-0.0261704642,
-0.0378510095,
-0.0288375076,
-0.0077428478,
0.0160712469,
0.0262032393,
-0.0218094531,
0.005489558,
0.0991666541,
-0.0115219848,
0.0200075544,
-0.0141725941,
-0.0394059978,
0.0445466414,
-0.0289532393,
-0.0003912336,
0.0192636903,
-0.0432633013,
0.0900465921,
0.0470210463,
0.0021675467,
0.0143177575,
0.0365590118,
0.0273228511,
-0.0291180182,
0.0020066879,
-0.050950937,
0.0062037297,
0.0007496665,
0.0276154317,
0.0199032836,
-0.0185316838,
-0.0523003228,
-0.0019720995,
-0.011586749,
0.0127819469,
-0.0247442275,
0.0161926188,
0.018305216,
0.0402959473,
-0.0492572412,
0.0444414429,
-0.049349729,
-0.0464062318,
0.031020686,
-0.0855232105,
-0.0495335795,
0.0181928333,
2.824e-7,
0.0526693352,
0.0028058996,
0.0104907174,
-0.0113145225,
0.0168934204,
0.0283245873,
-0.0185099207,
0.0374641642,
-0.0084807938,
-0.0426545441,
0.0208706129,
0.0314157754,
0.0713579357,
0.0185385477,
-0.0307858139,
-0.0241611525,
-0.0455263592,
0.0171677414,
-0.0394228324,
0.0125844171,
0.0721358061,
0.0969344154,
-0.0477111563,
-0.0430472605,
0.0338452198,
-0.0283678658,
0.0961495265,
0.0240067448,
-0.0109347822,
-0.0329667591,
0.0286591649,
-0.0121862432,
-0.0143464282,
0.0269930921,
-0.0007092446,
-0.0347163901,
0.0404311791,
0.0463747755,
-0.0103730438,
0.0019494725,
-0.0033103114,
0.0051382082,
-0.0501427986,
-0.0416671559,
0.0340486094,
-0.0514995418,
-0.0227133073,
0.0110644922,
-0.0541695282,
0.0111007243,
0.0142409066,
-0.0492052212,
-0.0392529741,
0.0250980426,
0.0792305917,
0.0192626007,
-0.03083455,
-0.0323707312,
-0.0427574851,
-0.0199185517,
-0.0515798889,
-0.0199875887,
-0.0450252183,
-0.0398505703,
0.0648395643,
-0.0066588446,
-0.0320363231,
2.158792161e-34,
0.0059325593,
0.0020755082,
0.0152741577,
-0.0219309889,
0.0242085494,
-0.0146294301,
-0.0177331269,
-0.0080666346,
-0.0344809741,
-0.0385022573,
-0.0472249389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13348v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13348v1 | Analyzing Cognitive Plausibility of Subword Tokenization | 2023-10-20T08:25:37 | 2023-10-20T08:25:37 | Lisa Beinborn, Yuval Pinter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Subword tokenization has become the de-facto standard for tokenization,
although comparative evaluations of subword vocabulary quality across languages
are scarce. Existing evaluation studies focus on the effect of a tokenization
algorithm on the performance in downstream tasks, or on engineering criteria
such as the compression rate. We present a new evaluation paradigm that focuses
on the cognitive plausibility of subword tokenization. We analyze the
correlation of the tokenizer output with the response time and accuracy of
human performance on a lexical decision task. We compare three tokenization
algorithms across several languages and vocabulary sizes. Our results indicate
that the UnigramLM algorithm yields less cognitively plausible tokenization
behavior and a worse coverage of derivational morphemes, in contrast with prior
work. | [
0.0261956099,
0.0460245572,
-0.0281445347,
0.0160604939,
-0.0903462097,
-0.0003225376,
0.0134064145,
0.0635579303,
-0.0854861662,
-0.0154765071,
0.0088185724,
-0.0351571925,
0.0252915677,
0.0103508001,
0.0329710059,
-0.0380541161,
0.0801781043,
-0.0402706079,
0.0143764829,
0.0195495151,
-0.0014677034,
-0.0146589689,
-0.0016340453,
0.0465290211,
-0.0372726656,
0.0089790421,
0.0156395044,
-0.0127541618,
-0.0372238569,
-0.0047532502,
-0.0600179248,
0.0182498954,
-0.0337006375,
0.0522489287,
0.0000017408,
-0.0838509575,
-0.0287636444,
-0.0086544696,
-0.0220330935,
0.0258578714,
0.1240218207,
-0.0126893362,
-0.0152999563,
0.0025398238,
-0.0037588933,
-0.0110342447,
0.0751371458,
0.0239591729,
-0.0109774042,
-0.0077769039,
-0.0131164249,
-0.0171329118,
0.0033226763,
0.0197498538,
-0.0445598811,
0.0115190307,
-0.0126658073,
-0.0189536344,
0.0009411838,
-0.0392236896,
-0.0483984835,
0.0029925515,
-0.0381180868,
0.0235855617,
0.0077501424,
0.0100677311,
-0.0512920693,
-0.0475976393,
0.0066182204,
0.0175445564,
-0.0226546433,
-0.0127646429,
-0.0202160161,
-0.0067070713,
0.013529296,
0.0215911474,
-0.0190649014,
0.0354983546,
-0.0040681753,
0.0100998012,
0.0480170324,
0.0234223697,
0.0090610795,
0.0036497479,
-0.0506105125,
0.1093019992,
0.0364725552,
-0.0447324105,
-0.0075879931,
-0.0295170266,
-0.0417555757,
-0.0824534968,
0.0338933505,
-0.0470643528,
-0.0489330105,
0.0263251271,
-0.0289562624,
-0.0638013035,
0.027499821,
0.0118511552,
0.0167284496,
0.0374640003,
0.0386182703,
-0.0193159077,
-0.0441214181,
0.0565070286,
0.0125889163,
-0.0020238662,
-0.0517356023,
-0.0051101884,
-0.0399114154,
-0.0095734596,
-0.0653084964,
0.0669475049,
-0.0332452618,
-0.0136191612,
-0.0624790788,
-0.0029525305,
0.0184374098,
-0.0298980176,
-0.0385056399,
0.000333954,
-0.0310725123,
0.0072660181,
-0.0450817533,
-0.0256018881,
-0.0577459261,
0.0272811279,
0.0218713731,
-0.0144436006,
0.0007249721,
0.0194783658,
0.0172840487,
-0.0065715197,
0.0002241873,
0.0870177373,
-0.0254703406,
-0.0343945511,
0.0088455668,
-0.0565536283,
-0.0198176112,
-0.0108779063,
-0.0350578241,
-0.1016744897,
-0.0104096644,
0.0101400949,
-0.0204355866,
-0.036108207,
-0.020012388,
-0.0036437002,
-0.0476566292,
0.07147412,
-0.0466141254,
-0.0172580834,
0.0006229639,
-0.0109686451,
-0.0001830618,
0.0444433875,
0.0432600826,
0.0482478105,
0.0779803768,
-0.026284596,
-0.0099615473,
0.0082268789,
0.0033389488,
-0.0336399078,
-0.0382667631,
-0.0567399301,
0.0015272051,
0.0565417819,
0.0694381595,
0.0966682434,
-0.0329674408,
-0.0018728474,
-0.0125854257,
0.1232407689,
0.0167700071,
0.025572693,
0.0390817039,
0.0304401573,
0.0036841736,
0.0411663465,
0.0302718803,
-0.0394328311,
0.0092136189,
0.0253286287,
0.0606071129,
0.0165078752,
0.0178952254,
-0.0498407073,
-0.0417602919,
-0.0146491667,
0.060461551,
-0.0572478324,
0.0261904169,
0.0314841494,
-0.056270346,
0.0524774417,
0.0257883184,
-0.054703407,
0.0031149567,
-0.0593303852,
0.0058040414,
0.0488960743,
0.0476028621,
0.0153623717,
0.0311955865,
0.0309217107,
0.0187651739,
0.0541061424,
-0.0215764903,
-0.0000971383,
0.0124392034,
-0.0399872102,
0.0202028304,
0.0209024139,
0.00268799,
-0.0068639764,
-0.0087820785,
0.0050023254,
-0.006524737,
-0.0793567002,
-0.0225011092,
0.0353067517,
0.0019143689,
-0.0049163979,
-0.0086317528,
0.0158402473,
0.0239113364,
0.0144140739,
-0.0312601663,
0.0472897962,
0.0074843299,
-0.029875353,
-0.0203640983,
0.0053689061,
-0.0236997884,
-0.0015340146,
0.0391598269,
-0.0235753935,
0.0160683766,
-0.0312041901,
0.031329561,
-0.0207026638,
0.0582460836,
-0.0627251267,
0.1213230416,
-0.0198027082,
0.0565666258,
0.0004996313,
0.0046402612,
-0.0490006469,
0.0552854314,
-0.0041469908,
0.0533147901,
0.0126785561,
-0.0265594367,
0.0306339599,
-0.0094035305,
0.0025069863,
0.0379959606,
-0.0342883766,
-0.036097683,
0.0241840146,
-0.0052593583,
-0.0404513143,
-0.0181313902,
-0.0738493726,
-0.0203836411,
0.0128475651,
0.041224245,
-0.0139206126,
0.0020926977,
-0.0130056199,
0.0291948896,
0.0190194286,
0.0073933466,
-0.0184843298,
0.030832395,
0.0439256653,
-0.013464611,
-0.0192442313,
-0.0247521475,
-0.0381775573,
0.0146472361,
0.0670533702,
0.0231932048,
-0.013947444,
-0.0125967534,
0.0312990285,
-0.0492975488,
-0.0176592711,
0.0311953984,
-0.0744836479,
0.0307716485,
0.0172346737,
0.070547767,
-0.0091352249,
0.0136341462,
-0.0214885212,
0.0341624655,
-0.03302918,
-0.0335785374,
-0.0415198691,
0.0168083049,
-0.0154800247,
0.0291606002,
-0.0434269235,
0.0114960987,
0.0650382414,
0.0327271186,
0.023509495,
-0.0292630829,
0.0201345291,
-0.0517062098,
-0.0553004108,
-0.008651115,
-0.0379262455,
-0.0440724045,
0.0676419362,
-0.0147451414,
-0.0328541249,
0.0597242489,
-0.0153166829,
0.0237621572,
-0.0394196287,
0.0195239894,
0.0046486352,
0.0386251211,
-0.0368267894,
0.0429034457,
0.0220185649,
-0.0776721463,
-0.0208639614,
-0.0049208142,
0.0031422691,
-0.0190189909,
0.0304900389,
-0.0458747074,
-0.0079763131,
0.0175104439,
-0.0105365198,
-0.0066399947,
0.0047059329,
-0.0142095527,
0.0403304622,
0.1027882323,
-0.009841091,
-0.0068056602,
0.029267868,
-0.0115698725,
-0.0013595567,
0.0182611514,
-0.0056196623,
0.023950316,
0.0194960292,
-0.0191737004,
0.0160340555,
0.0288906954,
0.0236671045,
0.0062907375,
0.0470140912,
0.0486542732,
-0.0168689936,
0.0046245838,
-0.0027426707,
0.028266497,
-0.0557537042,
-0.041475866,
0.0038945177,
0.0373334251,
0.0038242729,
-0.0107897809,
0.100206092,
0.0625820383,
-0.0095278919,
0.0324646793,
-0.0298475605,
0.022305809,
0.0014127081,
-0.0205646064,
-0.0707069486,
-0.0333098583,
0.0236130506,
0.0315956175,
-0.0060325838,
-0.0354971439,
0.0143213524,
-0.0809917971,
0.0338610262,
0.0056299106,
-0.0329821631,
0.0129826711,
-0.0358190425,
0.0126041071,
0.0194239281,
0.0223003309,
0.0261999443,
-0.041300457,
0.0187667478,
0.0224724822,
-0.0868791714,
-0.009030289,
0.0070706196,
-0.032511685,
0.0184636582,
0.0226388145,
0.0392167643,
-0.0473793596,
-0.0632968396,
0.0499286018,
0.010629667,
0.0210632924,
-0.058106117,
0.0295643676,
0.0136792278,
0.0080117928,
-0.0128250225,
-0.0430693924,
0.0191601794,
-0.0503436103,
-0.0087127574,
0.0239225049,
0.0196341984,
-0.0028068761,
-0.0136361979,
-0.0014695454,
-0.0135591598,
0.0677686483,
0.0244588926,
-0.0257664789,
-0.0284661353,
0.0259168483,
-0.0006346733,
-0.0390027985,
-0.0016246773,
-0.0610075183,
-0.0330898948,
-0.029010674,
-0.0994556025,
-0.0042863479,
0.0260868333,
0.0485712588,
-0.008738623,
0.0181994848,
-0.0476259291,
0.0076936837,
-0.078844972,
-0.0135051068,
0.0251901112,
0.0174266417,
-0.1007536799,
0.0022193445,
-0.0081149042,
-0.0059155561,
-0.0085539082,
0.0319029987,
0.0036657064,
-0.0361912698,
0.0309061836,
0.0057887677,
0.0352759659,
-0.000074959,
0.0018184173,
-0.0486457422,
0.0263199247,
0.0446386077,
-0.0202831831,
0.040038906,
0.0352319144,
-0.0063180681,
0.0064989631,
0.0118403286,
-0.0062749023,
0.0029217829,
-0.0049820603,
0.0329995379,
0.0232822634,
0.030139884,
0.0320230201,
0.0515907332,
0.0391150713,
-0.0797663257,
0.0249880329,
-0.0035589812,
-0.0304149352,
-0.0321298428,
-0.0140679181,
-0.0231878087,
-0.0063716853,
0.0239026509,
0.004155024,
0.0125009902,
0.0033838593,
-0.0741855875,
-0.0123022934,
0.0505885929,
0.0087854452,
-0.0212451257,
0.018441515,
0.0069283145,
0.0258520748,
0.0025611017,
-0.0562297851,
-0.0536741875,
0.0211796947,
-0.0700525865,
-0.0208050944,
-0.0208976548,
0.037272796,
-0.0751943961,
0.0325835533,
0.0034215581,
-0.0065846974,
0.0134420907,
0.0452876799,
0.0095604621,
-0.0244967863,
0.0112920422,
-0.0405764654,
0.000601758,
-0.0003928095,
-0.0144668045,
-0.0313235596,
-0.006224961,
0.0140200285,
0.0045986925,
-0.0519433506,
-0.0432588905,
0.0670921057,
-0.0055689677,
-0.0109258872,
-0.0378370658,
-0.0423054211,
-0.0275046546,
-0.0060484502,
0.0016816698,
0.0697184131,
-0.0240261368,
-0.0251595154,
-0.088249281,
-0.036451444,
-0.0013842824,
0.0509296469,
0.0260678977,
0.0155979628,
0.0522312671,
0.0804243684,
0.0367486663,
-0.0253321808,
-0.0196755044,
0.0074223401,
0.0297350809,
-0.0261390749,
-0.0132809719,
-5.733732305e-33,
-0.022615768,
-0.0285662748,
-0.0316652469,
0.0027184272,
-0.0092402678,
0.0244031828,
-0.0250223484,
0.0590493158,
0.0123585043,
-0.0011604488,
-0.0133792581,
-0.0085364673,
0.02315538,
-0.0294164661,
0.0411513671,
0.0330586694,
0.0136932014,
-0.0184918083,
-0.0521847457,
-0.0468800627,
0.0516924039,
-0.0080970936,
0.0403404236,
-0.0033726527,
0.0375063419,
0.0321754962,
0.0089380732,
-0.0268739667,
0.0329057723,
0.0758021027,
-0.0047517605,
0.0506648012,
0.0132052861,
0.002360655,
-0.0226651412,
0.0200828388,
-0.0665075406,
-0.054295823,
0.0908552706,
-0.0208901204,
-0.0635166392,
-0.0579654947,
0.057716649,
0.0091164708,
-0.0705270544,
0.0532311909,
-0.0081610158,
-0.0085756211,
-0.0460171327,
-0.0078858137,
-0.0884592757,
0.0081038941,
0.0093225213,
0.022499362,
0.0548665859,
-0.0101816524,
0.0060273116,
-0.0279678982,
-0.0037109575,
0.0338911042,
0.0045876098,
0.0479504839,
0.0816274211,
-0.0041426015,
-0.0235099848,
0.0447964855,
0.0526373126,
-0.0027327738,
0.0328007974,
0.0357712358,
0.0475738607,
0.0380666889,
0.036423523,
0.0458695255,
0.0945528597,
-0.0556648932,
0.0042829821,
-0.0132064028,
0.0203684215,
0.035092365,
0.0014434073,
0.0563595332,
-0.0482788756,
-0.040459808,
-0.0024345163,
0.0040065884,
-0.037280269,
-0.0688396022,
0.0318459459,
-0.0240582731,
-0.0065469304,
-0.0269053243,
0.0071459119,
0.0037257331,
-0.0008908491,
-0.0471259356,
-0.0022499748,
0.0183804892,
-0.022192223,
-0.0088428352,
-0.0362456143,
-0.0174195822,
0.000573932,
0.0269826911,
0.0322135948,
-0.0202432964,
-0.0175777599,
-0.0017767814,
-0.0503834598,
0.0222420823,
-0.0037103333,
-0.0037325614,
-0.0166990981,
-0.0510833897,
0.0437781326,
0.0047680684,
-0.0022412203,
-0.0696651563,
0.0395484865,
-0.0489327721,
-0.0292911362,
0.0036904477,
-0.0128846895,
0.028973639,
-0.0291206036,
0.0092259748,
-0.049439162,
0.0228909198,
0.0152840186,
0.0057191537,
-0.0382968001,
0.0396521017,
2.577e-7,
0.0607827343,
0.0919617414,
0.0555415526,
-0.0283842124,
0.0097691379,
-0.0158932749,
0.0020654222,
-0.0223931838,
0.0023871886,
0.0036465193,
-0.005536058,
-0.0157000143,
-0.0016332408,
0.0171215348,
-0.0589249134,
0.0091375113,
-0.0054210811,
0.0443031266,
-0.0541886091,
0.0152169932,
0.0972389281,
0.048932828,
0.0160756242,
-0.0194048993,
-0.053985171,
-0.0282083247,
-0.0027616634,
-0.018965546,
-0.0051283082,
0.0037384822,
0.0063848207,
0.0420380905,
0.0309286043,
0.0278844815,
-0.0192318298,
-0.0188574586,
0.0713866279,
-0.0121969543,
-0.039782092,
0.0212425385,
0.0068959966,
-0.0409884825,
0.0003253502,
-0.0381793492,
0.0426774211,
-0.0024595768,
-0.0073964759,
-0.0283160899,
-0.0263168942,
0.0517268442,
0.0052115149,
0.0005371011,
-0.040198639,
0.0318797529,
0.0362910107,
0.0498539172,
-0.0496922955,
-0.0420515239,
-0.0088566039,
0.0204057842,
-0.0223768465,
-0.0444642901,
-0.0121014873,
0.0499812551,
0.0173163246,
-0.0283776596,
-0.0474325195,
2.064101958e-34,
0.0334866159,
0.0276559629,
0.0310398359,
0.0076374388,
0.0090497639,
-0.024569707,
0.0090780612,
0.0411157683,
-0.0231705252,
-0.02717066,
0.0005473982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13343v1 | Challenges and Contributing Factors in the Utilization of Large Language Models (LLMs) | 2023-10-20T08:13:36 | 2023-10-20T08:13:36 | Xiaoliang Chen, Liangbin Li, Le Chang, Yunhe Huang, Yuxuan Zhao, Yuxiao Zhang, Dinuo Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the development of large language models (LLMs) like the GPT series,
their widespread use across various application scenarios presents a myriad of
challenges. This review initially explores the issue of domain specificity,
where LLMs may struggle to provide precise answers to specialized questions
within niche fields. The problem of knowledge forgetting arises as these LLMs
might find it hard to balance old and new information. The knowledge repetition
phenomenon reveals that sometimes LLMs might deliver overly mechanized
responses, lacking depth and originality. Furthermore, knowledge illusion
describes situations where LLMs might provide answers that seem insightful but
are actually superficial, while knowledge toxicity focuses on harmful or biased
information outputs. These challenges underscore problems in the training data
and algorithmic design of LLMs. To address these issues, it's suggested to
diversify training data, fine-tune models, enhance transparency and
interpretability, and incorporate ethics and fairness training. Future
technological trends might lean towards iterative methodologies, multimodal
learning, model personalization and customization, and real-time learning and
feedback mechanisms. In conclusion, future LLMs should prioritize fairness,
transparency, and ethics, ensuring they uphold high moral and ethical standards
when serving humanity. | [
0.0707395896,
0.0826288462,
-0.0461332984,
0.0490565114,
-0.06314262,
0.0071721566,
0.0101810759,
-0.0081465151,
-0.0022836351,
-0.0701914728,
-0.0133406576,
-0.0372879766,
0.0103210593,
-0.0011327632,
0.033173576,
-0.0680175424,
0.0429467112,
-0.0260193739,
0.0006555681,
-0.0451643802,
0.029574519,
0.0382947847,
0.0301139224,
0.0558156371,
-0.0274494551,
-0.0268000979,
0.0159329344,
-0.0252833385,
-0.001759615,
-0.0077989646,
0.0088992314,
0.0526555739,
0.0584015809,
0.0874440745,
0.0000024477,
-0.0521936975,
-0.0083365059,
0.0052225376,
-0.0274989344,
0.0350524187,
0.0668315515,
-0.0153063172,
0.0017011401,
0.0195525475,
-0.0407779701,
0.0167872421,
0.0607606582,
0.0145710567,
0.0447384045,
0.0448060967,
0.0100760795,
-0.0117870979,
0.0054567386,
-0.0117276898,
-0.032969702,
-0.0173499305,
0.0345563851,
0.0182265006,
-0.0074738367,
-0.007451714,
-0.0290011112,
0.0593371503,
0.0157546233,
0.0157208797,
0.0002374076,
0.0215501115,
-0.012660603,
-0.017925078,
-0.0175452568,
0.0380256623,
-0.0043424894,
-0.0150923934,
-0.0028136824,
-0.0067131198,
-0.0207084529,
0.0074092317,
-0.049085401,
0.0456580669,
-0.0085377283,
0.030606037,
-0.02075978,
-0.0259298012,
0.0460904278,
0.027736403,
-0.0004469162,
0.0615542457,
0.0118795158,
-0.0343470983,
-0.0208433177,
0.0063589807,
-0.0245489478,
-0.0297500342,
-0.0063437056,
0.032405436,
0.0055495948,
0.0528532006,
-0.0054665003,
-0.0208634734,
0.0503487922,
-0.0625020266,
0.0358993858,
0.0208137017,
-0.0005068191,
0.0093019754,
0.0204830691,
0.0421671458,
-0.0035955349,
0.0140305003,
-0.0563337281,
-0.0068454272,
-0.0503843799,
-0.0397019945,
-0.0074661691,
0.0234097205,
-0.0144341681,
0.0116412072,
-0.0206999574,
0.0277539194,
-0.0277926214,
-0.0080922497,
-0.0008606125,
0.0135304714,
-0.0278775152,
-0.0340988897,
-0.0429917499,
0.049752146,
-0.0089266514,
0.0357882902,
-0.0314350426,
-0.0614879467,
0.0259045195,
0.0032147749,
-0.0530000441,
-0.0182524268,
0.0144215031,
0.0947085172,
-0.0038714048,
-0.002371216,
-0.0603772998,
-0.0194657166,
-0.0252941828,
-0.0961130038,
0.0005395638,
-0.0512045883,
-0.0031974812,
0.0221626777,
-0.0093061095,
-0.0428491123,
0.0003625713,
0.0079429438,
-0.057448972,
0.0615298152,
-0.0117862383,
0.0542246066,
0.0720212609,
0.0316382721,
0.0024970623,
0.110599637,
0.0210996252,
0.0075128418,
0.0379948132,
-0.0378021859,
-0.0119220633,
0.0455169454,
0.0024776761,
0.0322147869,
-0.0289550237,
0.0038371852,
-0.0083371447,
0.0335712805,
0.0332558453,
0.0522014163,
-0.0045554978,
0.0014067657,
0.0895675495,
0.044577606,
-0.01841956,
0.0353338271,
0.0179692637,
0.0326857865,
0.0158625022,
0.0106884362,
-0.0474539436,
-0.013717996,
-0.0195771512,
-0.0016230209,
-0.0361593254,
0.0644209087,
-0.0282148048,
-0.0120203188,
-0.0130655253,
-0.0192170907,
0.0256861039,
0.0453466363,
0.0619594455,
-0.035995502,
-0.0320375487,
0.0403978787,
0.0455544554,
-0.0188950822,
0.0113318488,
-0.063836351,
0.0279719625,
0.0913234502,
0.0365969576,
-0.0133812893,
-0.0022039127,
-0.0159412101,
-0.0113840187,
0.0470802709,
0.0572346821,
-0.0073805084,
-0.0145196822,
-0.0512496494,
-0.0490899608,
0.000463981,
0.0038553143,
0.0387514532,
-0.0047627483,
0.0229699258,
0.0231668409,
-0.0483070873,
-0.0430594943,
0.0333482623,
-0.039336659,
-0.0246877111,
-0.0437145345,
-0.013439131,
0.0182452034,
0.0209684838,
-0.0102618458,
-0.0043401304,
0.012270458,
-0.0083463266,
-0.0021258707,
-0.0044252612,
-0.0616892949,
0.0517095923,
0.0349753685,
-0.0339919068,
-0.0098294038,
0.039963007,
-0.0209615659,
-0.017627446,
0.0235332251,
-0.0290697869,
0.062120758,
-0.0694165826,
0.0074028219,
-0.0576133281,
-0.0008032576,
-0.0505974479,
0.0416118577,
-0.0066713667,
-0.0057014176,
0.0158888642,
-0.0286894757,
0.0454514511,
-0.0297054164,
-0.0485152677,
0.0225016866,
0.0107128108,
0.0491658747,
0.0344734751,
0.0045402688,
-0.0248944834,
0.0124013163,
-0.111361295,
-0.0224845707,
-0.0220437534,
0.0122242989,
-0.019110484,
-0.0176453721,
-0.032379508,
-0.0132086491,
-0.0272242445,
-0.0075144246,
0.0116768666,
0.0307045765,
-0.0229344256,
-0.0052633965,
-0.0026106548,
-0.0065171043,
-0.0153421164,
-0.0051259506,
0.0477179028,
0.0087277414,
0.003461926,
-0.0719071701,
0.0184073076,
-0.0433172472,
0.0426532887,
-0.016160816,
-0.0384211577,
0.0232442077,
0.018766975,
0.0349948183,
0.0251458827,
0.0234471597,
0.0288494509,
0.065812178,
0.004651227,
-0.0631257147,
-0.0128139965,
-0.0158893894,
-0.0511541218,
-0.0270287655,
-0.0213301498,
-0.0239370503,
0.0485123731,
0.0239537824,
-0.0136425067,
-0.0461862683,
0.014323093,
-0.0736752823,
-0.0614423342,
-0.0404743552,
-0.0484040529,
-0.0381315686,
0.0011310021,
0.0103901457,
-0.0827957466,
0.0722689256,
-0.0025117618,
0.0241166372,
-0.0491407327,
-0.0083033768,
-0.0055316631,
0.0753482878,
-0.0081787016,
0.0483021364,
0.0333194248,
-0.0338936709,
-0.0666479319,
-0.0062577468,
0.0168361794,
-0.0535651669,
0.0602244288,
-0.0717270896,
0.0108269593,
0.0006796458,
-0.0496586598,
-0.0557728261,
-0.0080605084,
-0.0324370116,
0.0135774724,
0.007745781,
0.0065381709,
-0.012311154,
0.0063117035,
0.0372311026,
-0.0024836117,
-0.0110998983,
0.0020527714,
0.0036653823,
-0.0185389817,
0.0512275174,
-0.0068153148,
0.0234802775,
-0.0216888804,
0.000540496,
0.0386973098,
0.019796377,
-0.0124181937,
-0.0084044514,
-0.0035755264,
0.0418629199,
-0.0222227797,
-0.0154492632,
0.033884678,
0.0285436343,
-0.0687917918,
0.0188524202,
0.1096201241,
0.0018086573,
-0.0735188648,
0.0199606065,
-0.0098252194,
-0.0051339869,
0.015775105,
0.0140140494,
-0.0995271653,
-0.0066712322,
-0.0059972275,
0.0441671237,
-0.0419346839,
-0.0093293888,
-0.0037985174,
-0.1177665293,
0.0296119153,
0.0236549135,
-0.0409816019,
-0.0327645205,
-0.0325478427,
-0.0370973386,
-0.0008046898,
0.0711260587,
0.0164827723,
-0.0214152448,
-0.0212405883,
0.0423480496,
-0.0361314677,
-0.0737833679,
0.0483675636,
-0.0367339477,
0.073240377,
0.0771514326,
0.0111986641,
-0.0403571539,
-0.0188367516,
0.0054676891,
0.0043616313,
0.0219592396,
0.0026832377,
0.0104486132,
-0.0072669359,
-0.0069405101,
-0.0363423117,
0.00245037,
-0.0156288762,
-0.002531576,
0.0255984887,
0.1154932529,
-0.018183751,
-0.0348653235,
-0.0352696627,
-0.0366396122,
0.0143742282,
0.0942729861,
-0.0097061694,
-0.0341832526,
-0.0236652326,
-0.0228868108,
0.008660106,
0.0030946853,
-0.0380497053,
0.0464120992,
-0.0049146516,
-0.00873724,
-0.0265480671,
-0.0545384027,
0.0140648801,
0.0024730472,
0.0381749906,
0.031760484,
0.0064923577,
0.0093367202,
-0.0389014855,
0.0259577334,
-0.0403956771,
0.0244492851,
-0.0472768992,
-0.0192451626,
-0.0064677773,
-0.0442788228,
0.0021863268,
0.0251515154,
-0.0456189327,
-0.0662908256,
0.0173954405,
0.0375765264,
0.0305331778,
0.0481285304,
0.0238630436,
-0.0594416223,
0.0512579121,
0.030755965,
-0.0409899615,
0.0177229736,
0.0235993005,
-0.0141981281,
-0.0030119165,
0.0388491862,
-0.0359481424,
0.0173012465,
0.0221301205,
0.0095993504,
-0.0197431836,
-0.0079673212,
0.0269290116,
0.0376726389,
0.0187291019,
-0.0518350303,
-0.0097617814,
-0.0402016155,
-0.0163212474,
-0.0162778366,
-0.0026408779,
-0.0324394964,
-0.0040630852,
0.0293593872,
0.0156564619,
0.0001418824,
-0.0271195583,
-0.0134835485,
0.0135493744,
-0.063016504,
0.0219358448,
-0.0020008632,
0.0198772624,
0.0455223136,
0.0249620304,
-0.024995124,
0.019443756,
-0.0181499161,
0.0218900368,
0.0105912043,
0.0724183172,
0.0189961009,
-0.0147242425,
-0.0033770737,
0.0201533865,
-0.0164507199,
-0.0875762627,
-0.0259671248,
0.0377181061,
0.0662693456,
0.0055194926,
0.0360467844,
-0.0447751917,
0.0030276873,
-0.0242573638,
0.0050820103,
-0.0020301754,
-0.018294435,
0.0318135954,
0.0162268709,
-0.0482818373,
0.0252970029,
0.1003582627,
0.0167532638,
0.0708477572,
-0.0205888879,
-0.0265488848,
0.0000553584,
-0.0459297635,
0.0483237244,
0.0089133671,
-0.0367062725,
-0.0049904203,
-0.0904591829,
-0.0728567317,
-0.0419265367,
-0.0113065587,
-0.0086652329,
-0.0497168936,
0.0480906963,
0.0924881324,
-0.0175319724,
-0.0195940454,
-0.0429222882,
0.0194518529,
-0.0254217163,
-0.0074863876,
0.0111712934,
-7.264366274e-33,
0.0298023745,
-0.0026255965,
0.0271611474,
-0.0321873277,
-0.0422327667,
0.0011863741,
0.0010374981,
0.0009885522,
-0.0580961183,
0.0105576813,
0.0110495007,
-0.0275678765,
0.0025707264,
0.0158891939,
0.0260285959,
0.0045326436,
0.040400546,
-0.0046462789,
0.0113203758,
0.041445151,
0.035938222,
0.0243686326,
0.0875289291,
-0.0658588335,
0.0379535183,
-0.0003782739,
-0.0128580974,
0.0185698792,
-0.0345219336,
0.0547443219,
-0.047661487,
0.1118408293,
0.0240673982,
-0.0628495812,
-0.0268724021,
-0.0048211454,
-0.0148355085,
0.0031823199,
0.0529533587,
0.018705789,
0.01453437,
-0.0283931941,
0.0558529682,
-0.0164798964,
-0.0500418693,
-0.008052364,
0.0401931889,
-0.023771191,
-0.0318616703,
0.0116451094,
-0.0666533038,
0.0105774635,
-0.0105518121,
-0.0019853413,
-0.0098688509,
0.0067577045,
-0.0064356807,
0.0203155167,
-0.0588744767,
0.0248968136,
0.0394714549,
-0.0043811789,
0.1005430594,
0.0055424077,
0.0249689221,
0.0659047961,
0.005224267,
0.0177082717,
-0.0056148977,
-0.0272023901,
0.0461521298,
0.030632535,
0.0339676477,
0.0443444066,
-0.0065143658,
-0.0587708913,
-0.0504380614,
-0.0169031993,
0.0025617101,
0.0484093539,
0.0461077727,
0.004769892,
-0.0588003397,
-0.0582976379,
-0.024990648,
-0.0099543054,
-0.0171161368,
-0.0382089317,
0.0409377664,
-0.005812123,
-0.0054052225,
0.0207818896,
0.0453547798,
-0.0703799054,
-0.011949257,
0.0034451305,
-0.0164376926,
0.0162007995,
0.0125826197,
0.0549403429,
-0.0792991593,
-0.0103289131,
-0.0186401494,
-0.0156884845,
-0.0016095914,
0.0135031333,
0.0001270252,
0.0404515751,
-0.0281808544,
0.0172145963,
-0.0376430377,
0.0138918031,
0.0254219715,
-0.0134334918,
0.0239498187,
0.0029704596,
0.0090676658,
0.020014666,
0.0466600843,
-0.039847102,
-0.0321999677,
-0.0127224,
-0.0228081513,
0.0085634608,
-0.0395022407,
0.0028393432,
-0.0342777595,
0.0052642147,
0.0533294119,
-0.0455278344,
-0.0292970072,
0.002291559,
3.152e-7,
0.0347725488,
0.0373875536,
-0.0140185105,
-0.0142303957,
0.0135996062,
0.0515102968,
-0.0003979288,
0.0574688017,
0.0118007874,
-0.0058303056,
0.0083487388,
0.0240264386,
0.0487301908,
0.0344287753,
-0.0687077641,
-0.0076523391,
-0.0740636513,
0.0019953665,
-0.0871507972,
0.0367007963,
0.0192751102,
0.0834089667,
0.0096584447,
-0.0400460437,
-0.0036356484,
-0.0409901105,
0.0612070747,
-0.048709441,
-0.0025137414,
0.0260049626,
0.0373682491,
0.0333700106,
0.0104919486,
0.0204159003,
-0.0060015386,
-0.0075520682,
-0.0039517293,
0.0565092973,
-0.0368005298,
-0.0300423652,
0.0011940639,
-0.0370298773,
-0.0024609575,
-0.1061560884,
0.060098011,
-0.0130878054,
-0.0397784635,
-0.0367898755,
0.0071888813,
-0.0434439518,
0.0057811369,
-0.0199973397,
-0.0289859977,
0.0121349283,
0.0094945682,
0.0057741571,
-0.0102515072,
-0.045473408,
0.0088950191,
0.0033214635,
-0.0574994534,
-0.0671575963,
-0.0159561522,
-0.0096028019,
0.0215057787,
-0.0372121111,
0.0412716977,
2.912027819e-34,
0.0200637057,
-0.0064077517,
0.0122084096,
0.0248951744,
0.0112675419,
0.0365444385,
-0.0145613644,
0.0131179923,
-0.0018158209,
-0.0456636399,
-0.0260158181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13340v1 | Large-Scale and Multi-Perspective Opinion Summarization with Diverse Review Subsets | 2023-10-20T08:08:13 | 2023-10-20T08:08:13 | Han Jiang, Rui Wang, Zhihua Wei, Yu Li, Xinpeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Opinion summarization is expected to digest larger review sets and provide
summaries from different perspectives. However, most existing solutions are
deficient in epitomizing extensive reviews and offering opinion summaries from
various angles due to the lack of designs for information selection. To this
end, we propose SUBSUMM, a supervised summarization framework for large-scale
multi-perspective opinion summarization. SUBSUMM consists of a review sampling
strategy set and a two-stage training scheme. The sampling strategies take
sentiment orientation and contrastive information value into consideration,
with which the review subsets from different perspectives and quality levels
can be selected. Subsequently, the summarizer is encouraged to learn from the
sub-optimal and optimal subsets successively in order to capitalize on the
massive input. Experimental results on AmaSum and Rotten Tomatoes datasets
demonstrate that SUBSUMM is adept at generating pros, cons, and verdict
summaries from hundreds of input reviews. Furthermore, our in-depth analysis
verifies that the advanced selection of review subsets and the two-stage
training scheme are vital to boosting the summarization performance. | [
0.0447484702,
0.0279620606,
0.0366430096,
0.0046162298,
-0.0220440663,
0.0074334415,
-0.0289648194,
-0.0075939656,
-0.0609174147,
-0.0493798628,
-0.0263142902,
-0.045536723,
-0.008673626,
0.0307664778,
-0.0283688214,
-0.0752998143,
0.012257007,
-0.0049047023,
0.0085041998,
0.0010148523,
0.0201713368,
0.0380277969,
0.0202077534,
0.0092177838,
0.0081166597,
0.0190700814,
0.0399394408,
-0.0107596023,
0.0530100688,
-0.0361234806,
0.0028732403,
-0.0118937846,
0.0076401215,
-0.0068446533,
0.000001861,
0.0089630997,
-0.0133794285,
-0.0466898121,
0.0640791953,
0.02783316,
0.0859067962,
-0.0331978388,
0.0597355291,
-0.0054281591,
-0.0124435546,
-0.0052288543,
-0.0100970063,
0.0907714888,
0.0691466033,
0.0223196559,
-0.0256746877,
-0.0396477059,
-0.0243160855,
-0.028922515,
-0.056750223,
-0.0059351972,
-0.0160503592,
0.017048439,
0.0027681924,
0.0242628809,
-0.0015452629,
-0.0113241896,
-0.0173368156,
-0.0210541952,
0.0185202938,
0.0048675016,
0.0114727952,
0.0334484205,
0.0117424792,
0.0798174739,
0.0187081639,
0.0103478525,
-0.0072547602,
-0.014355056,
-0.0024281724,
-0.0236341096,
-0.0417620912,
0.0321478434,
0.0052502276,
0.074945569,
-0.023665322,
0.0658742189,
-0.0159496199,
0.0232695471,
0.012277076,
-0.0161582269,
-0.0068421154,
-0.0181402657,
0.0075296112,
0.0595626906,
0.0090507949,
-0.0171510708,
0.0051065125,
-0.012977385,
0.015593335,
-0.0098188035,
-0.0091231437,
0.0010559967,
0.0316521749,
-0.0415311679,
0.0286012515,
-0.0381857269,
0.0217727944,
0.062052723,
0.0289200135,
-0.0419376977,
0.0216245186,
-0.0219291784,
-0.0654438809,
0.00082775,
-0.0622101389,
0.048180148,
0.0199438725,
0.0741093829,
-0.0329836309,
0.0017262845,
-0.0692362413,
-0.0090504466,
-0.0180992708,
-0.0222500395,
0.0019069663,
0.0398724899,
0.048128739,
0.0133054508,
-0.0397580378,
0.0576005615,
-0.0541453362,
0.0171204619,
-0.0248964224,
0.0656615719,
-0.0019785031,
0.0316225886,
0.0082235364,
0.0141570335,
0.0142794214,
-0.00309058,
-0.0140835159,
-0.0452676006,
-0.0289393812,
-0.0014899921,
-0.0528344996,
-0.0364769697,
-0.0199641455,
-0.0725966841,
0.0204787888,
-0.0219447613,
-0.0243548956,
0.0433209352,
0.0002777126,
0.0109400898,
-0.0288528539,
0.0279966686,
-0.0238077193,
-0.057874091,
-0.0168983173,
-0.0002825101,
0.0173204914,
0.043852929,
-0.0013129649,
0.0601666234,
0.0229764543,
0.0235363301,
0.0017490706,
-0.0283153411,
0.0024062181,
0.0215279777,
-0.0119829159,
-0.01496673,
-0.0790060312,
-0.0342259221,
0.0352115221,
0.0540925413,
-0.015597607,
0.0238484442,
0.0386652462,
0.007500181,
-0.0672218129,
0.0578503236,
0.0085209049,
0.0332942344,
0.0263894051,
0.0350241214,
0.0158183463,
0.0541882589,
0.001833741,
0.0275160447,
0.054487925,
0.0444125421,
-0.0332541876,
-0.0329948552,
0.0362584367,
-0.015321739,
0.0015045684,
0.0137235355,
0.0453134663,
0.028049266,
-0.0287260246,
0.00754104,
0.0553844869,
-0.0414425544,
0.0242197774,
-0.0159218404,
0.0278755929,
0.0785342902,
-0.0167097989,
-0.0433360003,
0.0130749904,
-0.0302556977,
-0.032235235,
-0.015502762,
0.0630147904,
-0.0315227211,
-0.0174871925,
-0.0444247127,
-0.0366545953,
-0.0413261242,
0.002582435,
0.0189778544,
-0.052819144,
0.0143279005,
0.0134763131,
-0.0085998913,
-0.0509170257,
-0.0120787127,
0.0576749928,
-0.0031573176,
0.0473672114,
-0.0320726372,
0.0415356904,
0.0676769093,
-0.0349797457,
-0.0258935373,
0.035303764,
-0.0351529159,
-0.0536643714,
-0.0059863413,
-0.0547038428,
-0.0630871132,
0.0028501812,
-0.0697959885,
0.0037447007,
0.0183237623,
-0.0374254882,
-0.0465879217,
-0.00071494,
-0.0202537477,
-0.0207352806,
-0.0252310541,
0.0118640205,
0.0282547008,
-0.0065578637,
-0.0291456468,
0.0574401617,
-0.02819244,
-0.033935044,
0.0102532953,
-0.0983410776,
-0.0090195742,
0.0001769334,
-0.0294304155,
-0.0020917249,
0.0292757433,
0.0423979387,
0.0376130901,
-0.0018017851,
-0.0077907541,
-0.0226108804,
-0.1049973443,
-0.0145543721,
0.0116512235,
0.0009006264,
0.0305657852,
-0.0081834653,
0.0224902816,
0.0213323254,
-0.0382447168,
-0.0169716049,
-0.0043914886,
0.0074185468,
0.0355177484,
0.0522451289,
0.0540037081,
-0.0331825018,
-0.0348559469,
-0.0062473398,
0.0481279008,
-0.000090345,
-0.0254002847,
-0.0068766251,
-0.0318460241,
-0.0253229141,
-0.0455785394,
-0.0011609014,
0.0312576815,
-0.034605097,
0.0157755017,
-0.0122063365,
-0.0342364237,
0.0362163298,
-0.0064504198,
0.0678550303,
0.02841709,
-0.0096389977,
0.003501693,
-0.0232004058,
0.0394500047,
0.0051718215,
-0.0299742967,
0.0211647619,
0.0274970178,
0.0182560608,
0.0081876395,
-0.016925022,
0.0361376405,
-0.032539133,
0.0118762339,
-0.0137130991,
-0.0352899767,
0.0085652983,
-0.0114544705,
-0.0213737283,
0.0499397963,
0.0594240427,
-0.0004434853,
0.0421732925,
-0.0931597427,
0.0130469315,
-0.0419592485,
0.0384501666,
-0.0126446635,
0.0305109341,
0.0011122854,
0.0329982229,
0.0077047311,
-0.0514937043,
0.0418200791,
0.0037517194,
0.0858854353,
0.0012379405,
0.0086585218,
0.0037828092,
-0.0390342958,
0.0240454357,
-0.0371756554,
-0.0458642989,
0.0106603596,
0.0613794476,
0.0090194708,
-0.013028075,
0.0111936172,
0.0157612059,
0.0302546285,
-0.0062328046,
-0.0186023246,
0.0181104075,
0.0289859325,
0.0618559122,
-0.0197690651,
0.0356171913,
-0.0431014784,
0.0250421781,
0.0465357453,
-0.0138608925,
-0.024634907,
-0.0086828759,
-0.0295143407,
-0.0035550615,
-0.0398375504,
0.0163573083,
-0.0684723705,
0.0601339415,
-0.0128201582,
0.0427970663,
0.0841566995,
0.014492508,
-0.111441642,
-0.0235815197,
0.0331955105,
-0.0205605812,
0.0250069462,
-0.0048706261,
-0.0563364476,
-0.0091440473,
-0.0599787124,
0.0377944522,
0.0154643878,
-0.0065271677,
0.0002862646,
-0.0934372619,
0.0156206274,
-0.0072555603,
-0.0469778292,
-0.0619153865,
-0.0217343792,
0.0086816363,
-0.0269338079,
-0.0083518783,
0.0060297428,
-0.038681481,
0.0091091534,
-0.0122768162,
-0.0379688703,
0.0305232629,
0.0454348475,
-0.0237871353,
-0.0022292517,
0.0161481164,
0.046109926,
0.0013577054,
0.0532706939,
0.0384902172,
-0.0722335428,
0.0080501204,
-0.0003239369,
0.1232962832,
-0.004879145,
0.0064033824,
-0.0159829743,
0.0154259633,
-0.011333365,
0.0091922237,
0.04353071,
0.0171067137,
0.0096225636,
-0.0228527226,
-0.0308948234,
0.0411140658,
-0.0043658912,
0.053236302,
0.0054900581,
-0.0610577911,
0.0000310119,
0.0087563526,
-0.0530907474,
-0.0926388577,
0.0066047977,
-0.0196458939,
-0.0352170095,
-0.0061528208,
-0.0895723924,
-0.025220545,
0.0030298047,
0.0179816987,
0.001146907,
-0.0241483841,
0.0130264545,
0.0399505422,
-0.0008036115,
-0.0021570101,
0.0244572647,
-0.0311136786,
0.0261128694,
-0.0298138671,
0.0903718024,
-0.0376802348,
-0.0135255521,
-0.0145570347,
-0.014640958,
-0.0213832315,
-0.0574342608,
0.0698418543,
0.0059187096,
0.0700994954,
0.0252199117,
0.0164975487,
0.0603637844,
0.0073180743,
0.0169730596,
-0.0130561572,
0.0293641333,
0.0669112355,
-0.0197171289,
0.0232879259,
-0.0679239184,
0.0368545204,
-0.0385030285,
0.008985674,
-0.0726161078,
-0.0152412616,
0.0117543126,
-0.012912631,
0.0204023123,
-0.0270745326,
0.0336748064,
-0.0390615202,
-0.0025235082,
-0.0327372625,
-0.0113207763,
-0.0357263908,
0.0325052775,
0.0115833404,
-0.023534812,
-0.0415437222,
0.0552154779,
0.0050259009,
0.0313444659,
-0.0403816178,
0.0488791019,
-0.0117251361,
-0.0399426743,
-0.0450883657,
0.0038825693,
-0.0553162508,
-0.0275500156,
-0.0117607359,
-0.0270149037,
0.004014798,
0.0191016831,
0.0174492951,
0.0110338964,
-0.0626291484,
0.0184862297,
-0.0319320001,
0.0351147689,
-0.0610240102,
0.0088542756,
0.0153802782,
-0.0615083575,
0.0556102023,
-0.0148896882,
-0.0265299287,
0.0049356716,
0.0101047102,
-0.0038197855,
0.0179782715,
-0.0257945023,
0.0157420598,
0.0239106342,
0.0152592687,
0.0683832839,
-0.0845536441,
-0.0074771387,
0.0416908786,
-0.0365445018,
-0.0500606298,
-0.018478699,
-0.0426562242,
0.0501405634,
0.0093800966,
0.0210454203,
-0.0422919989,
-0.0099459374,
0.031630978,
-0.0189305637,
0.024930561,
-0.0282763969,
0.0527368076,
0.0258353222,
0.0543442443,
0.0411314517,
-0.0569037646,
-0.0288334731,
0.0030485408,
0.0142227449,
-0.014494542,
-6.007886975e-33,
0.0095840814,
0.0138384709,
-0.0616452582,
0.0491548888,
-0.0362080783,
0.010627185,
-0.0165506117,
0.0138968276,
0.0162935629,
0.0304950383,
0.0030255318,
0.0056766123,
-0.0039163027,
0.0540843979,
0.0265562776,
0.0081767924,
0.0523166284,
-0.0094137648,
-0.0236774199,
0.0767323375,
0.0317759551,
-0.0024694742,
0.0508353226,
-0.0719352737,
0.0101072704,
0.0111174323,
-0.0345837995,
-0.0063157659,
0.0322611593,
0.0303282626,
-0.0050704889,
0.0539062209,
0.0306829009,
-0.0581265762,
-0.0170966443,
-0.0256431345,
-0.0598817691,
-0.0015522295,
0.026723193,
-0.0448308066,
-0.0338116139,
-0.0246271156,
0.0212839711,
-0.0006353818,
0.0055095409,
-0.0125502516,
0.0345379412,
-0.0609854758,
-0.0058019189,
-0.1202871427,
-0.0090685785,
0.0227011051,
-0.0456842668,
-0.0184705053,
0.009191364,
0.0259473771,
-0.0039397185,
0.042630475,
-0.0070634377,
0.0302943457,
0.0105714602,
0.018371813,
-0.0100630596,
-0.0026316936,
-0.0072351568,
0.0984331146,
-0.0261689927,
0.0158785693,
-0.0382093266,
0.0133267427,
-0.0396409743,
-0.0181076489,
-0.0006312231,
0.0409977324,
0.0341673829,
-0.0121863121,
-0.0557399504,
0.0463679694,
0.0730483234,
-0.0216769986,
0.0656093881,
-0.0151483323,
0.015134288,
-0.0055980277,
0.0165974125,
-0.0488574058,
-0.0102900667,
0.0066874959,
-0.0453639179,
0.0468790829,
-0.0497714654,
-0.0169912428,
-0.0117295077,
-0.0515922755,
-0.0098357275,
0.0100749247,
-0.0524169207,
0.034779571,
0.0327827409,
-0.0568973869,
-0.0340952463,
0.0376882255,
-0.0244719367,
-0.0042740786,
-0.0177454576,
-0.0088217994,
0.0934551954,
0.0016220025,
-0.0480067693,
0.0138999745,
0.0284331385,
0.0399484932,
-0.0250830278,
0.0530208759,
-0.0182785839,
0.0359479338,
-0.0072686593,
0.0582589321,
-0.0165780913,
0.0529610924,
0.0081491703,
0.0009803226,
0.0176680721,
0.0149493907,
-0.0088531189,
0.0026344778,
0.0349825323,
-0.0377648845,
-0.0050653839,
-0.0492585413,
-0.0355634205,
0.026963897,
2.458e-7,
0.0593507364,
0.0424251929,
0.0120852338,
-0.0368480682,
0.0037549108,
0.0485920645,
0.0218733177,
0.0424323343,
0.0160083938,
-0.0218213294,
0.0330308676,
0.0303631071,
-0.0113763576,
0.0369283557,
-0.09667743,
0.015934635,
-0.0224226154,
-0.0400671922,
-0.0151639022,
-0.0015779204,
0.0751122981,
0.0843412578,
-0.0079196971,
-0.0098157274,
-0.0066298805,
-0.0003157581,
0.0446956381,
-0.0058255182,
-0.0481228083,
-0.0022459349,
0.0525365397,
-0.0445075333,
-0.0430089086,
-0.0184389334,
-0.021229364,
-0.0003345476,
0.0241975971,
0.0321201347,
0.0302255992,
-0.054352127,
0.0391564332,
0.0289960746,
0.0325247832,
0.0197231434,
0.0479747467,
-0.0565421954,
-0.0186143629,
-0.0947141126,
-0.0439294837,
0.0371968709,
0.0061059734,
-0.0032131814,
-0.024859529,
0.0619673952,
-0.0424901284,
-0.0140514988,
-0.0195784345,
-0.0517524071,
-0.0016503934,
0.0479086153,
0.0226347856,
-0.0389140174,
0.0365528837,
-0.0181460604,
-0.0110196369,
-0.0450798757,
0.0251486562,
1.867652631e-34,
0.1231554225,
-0.041940622,
-0.0429672897,
-0.0515165813,
0.00473182,
-0.0257054251,
-0.0832401812,
-0.0225073993,
0.0123469308,
-0.0240527019,
-0.0067297984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13332v1 | Democratizing Reasoning Ability: Tailored Learning from Large Language Model | 2023-10-20T07:50:10 | 2023-10-20T07:50:10 | Zhaoyang Wang, Shaohan Huang, Yuxuan Liu, Jiahai Wang, Minghui Song, Zihan Zhang, Haizhen Huang, Furu Wei, Weiwei Deng, Feng Sun, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) exhibit impressive emergent abilities in natural
language processing, but their democratization is hindered due to huge
computation requirements and closed-source nature. Recent research on advancing
open-source smaller LMs by distilling knowledge from black-box LLMs has
obtained promising results in the instruction-following ability. However, the
reasoning ability which is more challenging to foster, is relatively rarely
explored. In this paper, we propose a tailored learning approach to distill
such reasoning ability to smaller LMs to facilitate the democratization of the
exclusive reasoning ability. In contrast to merely employing LLM as a data
annotator, we exploit the potential of LLM as a reasoning teacher by building
an interactive multi-round learning paradigm. This paradigm enables the student
to expose its deficiencies to the black-box teacher who then can provide
customized training data in return. Further, to exploit the reasoning potential
of the smaller LM, we propose self-reflection learning to motivate the student
to learn from self-made mistakes. The learning from self-reflection and LLM are
all tailored to the student's learning status, thanks to the seamless
integration with the multi-round learning paradigm. Comprehensive experiments
and analysis on mathematical and commonsense reasoning tasks demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method. The code will be available at
https://github.com/Raibows/Learn-to-Reason. | [
0.0332885161,
0.0308506507,
-0.0154316612,
0.057320077,
-0.0449993052,
0.0133630093,
0.0149408011,
-0.0223828182,
0.0411768705,
-0.0365630575,
-0.0262447707,
0.045974154,
-0.0435462482,
-0.0038559115,
0.0109436968,
-0.0640261471,
0.0465315133,
-0.0507137887,
-0.0099150706,
-0.0266670883,
-0.0229825433,
0.0048257755,
-0.0258077588,
0.0162957385,
0.0136534711,
-0.0416751057,
-0.0058961781,
-0.0393810049,
-0.0085449843,
-0.0204789788,
-0.0407036431,
0.046991121,
0.0457984023,
0.0313245058,
0.0000025313,
-0.0827089548,
-0.0305930544,
-0.0186065789,
-0.0458954722,
0.0022603839,
0.0251161661,
0.0705203936,
-0.0119707258,
0.0155078918,
-0.0573244207,
0.0409482159,
-0.006703557,
0.0225504637,
0.0817159265,
0.0530484468,
0.0309474915,
-0.0454837456,
0.0135692181,
0.0184174906,
0.0679654852,
-0.0168438442,
-0.0042084674,
0.0631453916,
0.0258352458,
0.0081759365,
-0.0351554528,
0.0187856741,
0.059016414,
-0.0227025189,
-0.0002201524,
0.0280005839,
-0.0020725769,
0.0021838851,
-0.0049640336,
0.0750879273,
0.0170856789,
-0.0158041865,
-0.0306921247,
0.0084492806,
0.0452711172,
0.0347753316,
-0.0765867978,
0.0601057038,
-0.0011059961,
0.0310317017,
0.0181765147,
-0.0233576912,
0.0061727408,
0.0367009789,
-0.0282027703,
0.0878565609,
-0.0233349819,
-0.0196236894,
0.0094529642,
-0.0043329187,
-0.0088263704,
-0.0043258839,
-0.009588208,
0.066204004,
-0.0048091426,
0.0323072597,
-0.0041485969,
-0.0038752111,
-0.0105140302,
-0.0314108767,
0.022852473,
0.0400441661,
0.0003638692,
0.0548101962,
-0.0508344956,
-0.003445921,
-0.0083442638,
0.1075363681,
-0.0235990565,
0.0085985595,
-0.0723584145,
-0.0198379625,
-0.0282819774,
0.0577533767,
-0.0198383667,
0.0120288301,
-0.0372393392,
0.0269350782,
-0.0293864273,
0.011895787,
0.0110516204,
0.0044472213,
0.0255948864,
-0.0574510358,
-0.083596006,
0.0154300639,
-0.0261962563,
0.0201299544,
0.0120464526,
-0.0256824736,
-0.002576397,
-0.0213204361,
-0.0004510109,
0.0014448065,
0.0490571782,
0.0533985533,
-0.0078015216,
-0.0018446328,
-0.0766714439,
-0.0251771417,
0.0391251072,
-0.0585594103,
-0.0103701521,
-0.0940644369,
-0.0365712829,
-0.0089673949,
0.0017403202,
-0.0406333432,
0.0327381715,
0.0102183698,
0.0096133342,
0.0817872211,
-0.0438782908,
-0.0014247759,
0.0375064947,
0.0218685437,
-0.0315057561,
0.0549995042,
0.0358820558,
-0.0311632268,
0.0067676618,
-0.0358297154,
0.0244067945,
-0.0036336118,
0.0109235225,
-0.0114163104,
-0.0171340704,
0.0064333812,
-0.0122841028,
0.0406965911,
-0.0211020093,
0.0139606176,
-0.0333799943,
0.0529625528,
0.036619693,
0.054873053,
0.0069081597,
0.0320947431,
-0.0038538526,
0.0404726751,
0.0244043618,
-0.0243459735,
-0.0491547137,
0.0558808073,
-0.03141414,
-0.0069514266,
0.0216963589,
0.0124537395,
-0.0089833457,
-0.0780098736,
0.0233529676,
-0.0102659082,
0.0206393078,
0.0334843211,
0.0664564595,
0.028020896,
-0.0018682663,
0.0312949903,
0.063775003,
-0.0634054318,
0.0172226466,
-0.1087138876,
0.0668852776,
0.0401880667,
0.0532682426,
-0.0462990291,
-0.0287764091,
-0.0258785076,
0.012657946,
0.0320862792,
0.0089946119,
-0.0151485028,
-0.0626745149,
-0.0622387864,
-0.0366568118,
-0.0125331497,
-0.0053027347,
-0.000382146,
0.0169605464,
-0.0198703278,
-0.0150743378,
-0.0299894921,
-0.0161226224,
0.0225213077,
-0.0142833916,
-0.0628620163,
-0.0281524844,
0.0195365194,
0.0219953712,
0.0166502502,
0.03846737,
0.0252455864,
0.0295073502,
-0.0232353434,
-0.0357040837,
0.0140345432,
-0.0476373583,
-0.0514105111,
0.0480464473,
-0.0417777598,
-0.0114442017,
-0.0036268772,
-0.040111959,
-0.0426927842,
0.0366462059,
-0.0030691484,
0.0333098844,
-0.0237791054,
0.0056491527,
-0.0153732803,
-0.034981396,
-0.0247629918,
0.0967414007,
0.014656662,
-0.0017861074,
0.0134180766,
0.0393123291,
0.0036288502,
-0.0211417917,
0.0134752514,
-0.019792676,
-0.0220980626,
0.0360936485,
-0.0023858915,
0.0222398583,
-0.0735278577,
-0.0172453243,
-0.005109353,
-0.0026354138,
0.0079627158,
0.0291406102,
0.0009235839,
-0.0223095268,
0.0002352616,
-0.0270802993,
-0.0231239665,
0.0188196953,
0.0095404088,
-0.0066436706,
0.0226361416,
0.0171403419,
-0.0259794071,
0.0025876472,
-0.0063085048,
-0.0255129486,
0.017347578,
0.0235988367,
0.0674397647,
-0.0604001619,
0.0218580775,
-0.0113226976,
0.0099102994,
0.0073485733,
-0.0142878946,
0.0419038422,
-0.0422121547,
0.0029957795,
0.0771117583,
0.0169661678,
0.049950812,
0.0493652336,
-0.0062337681,
-0.0926141366,
0.0416447073,
-0.0225169379,
-0.0106642796,
-0.0422771834,
0.014378217,
-0.0373223573,
0.0431761369,
-0.0213978533,
-0.0059826258,
-0.0464863852,
0.0501851998,
-0.0062054973,
-0.0098424181,
-0.0566837415,
-0.0014386044,
-0.0064265388,
0.0070733228,
0.0047988296,
-0.0445206203,
0.0782563835,
0.0144393574,
0.0118095046,
-0.0423736535,
0.0036941399,
-0.0477638766,
0.0818108246,
-0.0334510989,
-0.0009482704,
-0.0061526494,
-0.0177133996,
-0.0386728682,
-0.0016738164,
0.0668380633,
-0.053680148,
0.0610789508,
-0.0490362197,
-0.0227949265,
0.0039543705,
-0.0388449132,
-0.0414023325,
0.0071362997,
-0.0413945839,
-0.0101965666,
-0.034737315,
0.0041385638,
-0.0368976928,
-0.0428681262,
0.0486099795,
0.0088563319,
0.0003564448,
-0.0240326449,
-0.0107042594,
-0.0273728557,
0.010089553,
0.0133627299,
0.0240243804,
-0.0221108813,
0.068869859,
0.0492582284,
0.0956209674,
-0.0303420257,
0.0139983585,
0.0082081305,
0.0176316835,
-0.0236118287,
-0.0034401596,
0.0293804016,
0.0395286568,
-0.0984625295,
-0.0185758527,
0.1179903671,
0.0292878225,
-0.0211008582,
0.0009342671,
-0.0795253143,
0.0329059213,
0.0540663078,
0.037776906,
-0.0719484389,
-0.045478981,
-0.0084404629,
0.025064677,
-0.0036629192,
-0.032044515,
0.0023555916,
-0.159489423,
0.0332496613,
0.0350888297,
-0.0278663579,
-0.0085547892,
-0.047611855,
-0.0300186984,
-0.0003067014,
-0.0148473661,
0.0274574626,
-0.0094431024,
0.0185476914,
0.0483377986,
-0.0143006714,
-0.0326233022,
0.026058292,
-0.0159243625,
0.0462623984,
-0.0026060105,
0.0105461515,
0.0010960496,
-0.0606168136,
0.0116813267,
0.0210982095,
0.0018122253,
-0.0307413675,
0.0283331871,
-0.0099020097,
-0.0002999158,
-0.0409590416,
0.0852071568,
-0.0390189812,
-0.0308375452,
0.0227592438,
0.1286212057,
-0.002392279,
0.0141114453,
-0.0175070111,
-0.0147189638,
-0.0159427971,
0.066491887,
0.0153220557,
-0.0303277448,
-0.010778063,
-0.0518876798,
-0.0556079112,
-0.0266680215,
-0.0734425634,
0.0449390858,
0.0070952782,
0.0175785851,
-0.0274944659,
-0.0139975622,
0.0536736324,
0.0606534407,
0.003837625,
0.0363779664,
0.001567616,
0.0325578526,
-0.020596534,
0.0310741924,
-0.0696177334,
-0.0051215719,
-0.05586778,
-0.0174973123,
0.0058184844,
-0.045121178,
-0.0268622618,
-0.0250505507,
-0.045366697,
-0.0603737272,
-0.0122397048,
0.0537827015,
0.0277482849,
0.0449160933,
0.0138370162,
-0.0330715701,
0.0454581119,
0.0174284521,
-0.0097073512,
-0.03310173,
0.0309794191,
0.0252886303,
0.0312813371,
0.031729769,
-0.008055293,
0.0082589788,
0.0210307073,
0.0373416282,
-0.0342718549,
0.0078532659,
0.0594079196,
0.0442063287,
0.03296756,
-0.0089550242,
-0.0116855083,
-0.0577909388,
0.0230214149,
-0.0100868139,
-0.0400358774,
-0.0331894122,
0.0249251649,
0.0193709321,
-0.0525705107,
0.0171335582,
-0.0264026243,
0.0101612415,
0.0326497257,
-0.0082923798,
0.0602579862,
0.0279484391,
0.0214824285,
0.0112735555,
-0.0235922001,
0.0054008709,
-0.0205874387,
0.0035824289,
0.0418380052,
0.0032956083,
0.0964211002,
0.0048433826,
-0.0242395997,
-0.0088794669,
-0.0169885829,
-0.0447526015,
-0.0720502138,
0.0027614261,
0.0682266876,
0.0116645116,
0.0370202065,
-0.0033559883,
-0.0392512344,
0.011966696,
0.0300562922,
0.0432484224,
-0.0006568322,
-0.0471587293,
0.0463595614,
0.0177523699,
0.0122642322,
-0.0264016949,
0.0401325859,
-0.0572818257,
0.0518422276,
-0.0217083655,
0.0222618897,
-0.0498312451,
-0.0387961045,
-0.0141813047,
0.0094831418,
-0.0038046981,
0.042724371,
-0.0543029532,
-0.0542621017,
-0.0399648957,
0.0431671552,
-0.0096091256,
-0.0323949344,
0.0367601141,
0.0566500537,
-0.0306593794,
-0.0409960859,
-0.0194361731,
0.0545119904,
-0.034317445,
-0.0207613446,
0.0246953443,
-6.68163846e-33,
-0.0369854271,
-0.0240348056,
0.0519840978,
0.0070899152,
0.0189310536,
-0.0561948307,
-0.0146661475,
0.0326675214,
-0.0066824979,
0.0165208206,
-0.0002139308,
0.003382429,
-0.0023326566,
0.0249750782,
0.0315317139,
0.0073790923,
0.0188265126,
0.0126694357,
-0.0181572121,
0.0084580267,
0.0317182057,
0.0103235347,
0.0539549179,
-0.042943649,
0.0185611732,
-0.0006920202,
-0.0086854296,
0.0501540564,
-0.0888447538,
0.0410957076,
0.0173840187,
0.0238596611,
0.0075604147,
-0.0343873315,
-0.0077409931,
0.0243854243,
-0.06009477,
-0.0467923917,
0.0290251784,
-0.0013261921,
-0.0623143651,
-0.0532469936,
0.0296471324,
0.0097527364,
-0.0088361287,
-0.0154494699,
0.0256768502,
-0.0394364819,
-0.00449104,
0.0598675795,
-0.047580149,
0.0216103382,
-0.0288036577,
-0.0412199423,
-0.0085983369,
0.0340307727,
-0.0290069208,
-0.0273358636,
-0.0419264957,
0.0469143689,
0.0156156756,
0.011703413,
0.084574841,
0.0095061073,
0.0082625598,
0.048790209,
0.0166507289,
-0.0158607755,
-0.0536436699,
-0.0218056422,
0.0158501137,
0.0907945409,
0.0528950617,
0.0448701009,
0.0288721584,
0.0034332962,
-0.0705953166,
0.0221388433,
0.0203459002,
0.0291093048,
0.0224997606,
0.0120650278,
-0.0292556752,
0.0060558878,
-0.0756908506,
0.0063236528,
-0.0191297233,
-0.0148273716,
0.023217978,
0.0019443998,
-0.0563765913,
-0.0351713672,
-0.0166243706,
-0.0454064235,
-0.0324460939,
-0.0034283581,
0.0056226342,
0.0088062054,
-0.0222878754,
0.0022740737,
-0.0717683882,
-0.0390191041,
-0.0108288117,
-0.0291391574,
0.0160776768,
0.0384050831,
0.0430222526,
0.0205005147,
-0.053251978,
-0.0297623947,
-0.0550698154,
-0.0130889863,
0.0212024935,
-0.0037507168,
0.0356190391,
0.0259112231,
-0.018667005,
0.028564468,
-0.0150718922,
-0.019932678,
-0.012303194,
-0.0106722144,
-0.0305303931,
-0.0192200895,
-0.0126259932,
-0.0194235407,
-0.0578018799,
0.0022767051,
0.0262563378,
-0.0597629324,
-0.0030221711,
0.0314127952,
3.198e-7,
0.0056962268,
0.0450898074,
-0.0258191545,
-0.0014461295,
0.0098053114,
0.0587292314,
-0.0261147711,
-0.0329678804,
0.018994553,
-0.0366381295,
-0.0115693333,
0.0651136488,
0.0465282016,
0.0289287865,
-0.0569946356,
-0.0209361166,
-0.0159273315,
0.015481065,
-0.0362364501,
0.0029738778,
0.0644834116,
0.0389333144,
0.0564184822,
-0.0211769212,
0.0077054342,
-0.0226166565,
0.0516932942,
-0.0370456614,
-0.0064699263,
0.0094731152,
-0.0064228433,
-0.0026764022,
0.008333154,
0.0167529583,
0.0049421154,
-0.0002041889,
-0.0591910295,
0.0472983979,
-0.0070862067,
0.0023582918,
-0.0115935393,
-0.012974008,
-0.0035909347,
-0.0151776662,
0.0688342452,
-0.0440354533,
-0.0468534976,
-0.0029071427,
0.0232957527,
-0.0319522917,
0.006713009,
-0.0017273707,
-0.008096179,
-0.0417912267,
0.003962622,
-0.0484889038,
0.0024767162,
-0.0646624789,
-0.0252981763,
-0.0244463347,
-0.0199517645,
-0.0264553726,
-0.0551065579,
-0.0062779854,
0.0224711522,
-0.0379668176,
0.0239310618,
2.738625413e-34,
0.0094582364,
-0.0079439012,
0.043307256,
0.0289241355,
0.0315432064,
0.0154929115,
0.0102764098,
0.010229893,
0.039385017,
-0.0448620841,
-0.0217223205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13321v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13321v2 | Beyond Hard Samples: Robust and Effective Grammatical Error Correction with Cycle Self-Augmenting | 2023-10-20T07:31:23 | 2023-10-23T07:41:09 | Zecheng Tang, Kaifeng Qi, Juntao Li, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have revealed that grammatical error correction methods in the
sequence-to-sequence paradigm are vulnerable to adversarial attack, and simply
utilizing adversarial examples in the pre-training or post-training process can
significantly enhance the robustness of GEC models to certain types of attack
without suffering too much performance loss on clean data. In this paper, we
further conduct a thorough robustness evaluation of cutting-edge GEC methods
for four different types of adversarial attacks and propose a simple yet very
effective Cycle Self-Augmenting (CSA) method accordingly. By leveraging the
augmenting data from the GEC models themselves in the post-training process and
introducing regularization data for cycle training, our proposed method can
effectively improve the model robustness of well-trained GEC models with only a
few more training epochs as an extra cost. More concretely, further training on
the regularization data can prevent the GEC models from over-fitting on
easy-to-learn samples and thus can improve the generalization capability and
robustness towards unseen data (adversarial noise/samples). Meanwhile, the
self-augmented data can provide more high-quality pseudo pairs to improve model
performance on the original testing data. Experiments on four benchmark
datasets and seven strong models indicate that our proposed training method can
significantly enhance the robustness of four types of attacks without using
purposely built adversarial examples in training. Evaluation results on clean
data further confirm that our proposed CSA method significantly improves the
performance of four baselines and yields nearly comparable results with other
state-of-the-art models. Our code is available at
https://github.com/ZetangForward/CSA-GEC. | [
0.0586426929,
0.116064772,
0.0012414384,
0.036610309,
-0.0071540303,
0.0264148731,
-0.0269255694,
-0.0249450915,
0.0314108506,
-0.0415403582,
0.0118063111,
-0.0331950672,
0.0352151282,
0.0068951468,
0.0670459494,
-0.0487812795,
0.0698367208,
0.0021716307,
-0.0323380642,
0.0027927626,
0.0095694019,
-0.0114285545,
-0.0227134526,
0.0217550695,
-0.0264616739,
-0.028129926,
-0.0098440181,
0.0430928841,
0.0395549722,
-0.0501775928,
0.0343624651,
0.0506647304,
-0.0120747928,
0.1033024266,
0.0000019873,
-0.0427214056,
-0.0196896438,
0.0007016287,
-0.0191191882,
0.0686375126,
0.0124303754,
-0.0452851281,
-0.0461045131,
0.0000815297,
-0.0244514104,
-0.0131243533,
0.0475827605,
0.0617882349,
0.0740870759,
0.114657715,
-0.0166916456,
-0.0245697349,
0.0638030693,
-0.0644229278,
-0.0262776464,
-0.0063232151,
0.0321479328,
-0.053937681,
-0.0298838932,
-0.0000999652,
-0.0226571187,
0.0305849034,
0.0311648138,
-0.0005301756,
-0.0417750366,
0.0011040731,
-0.0289436877,
0.0121035762,
-0.0288045779,
0.0293178577,
-0.0337421671,
-0.0149559844,
-0.0207111593,
0.0008891992,
0.0438670702,
-0.0001600354,
-0.0044403188,
-0.0366913527,
0.0320857279,
0.0203762744,
-0.0027426928,
-0.043399211,
0.0413142182,
-0.0134077761,
-0.001976969,
0.0329435691,
0.0187671967,
-0.0472264923,
-0.0237713475,
0.0438786857,
-0.03741071,
-0.0542733371,
-0.0014306153,
0.0119014597,
0.0124766277,
-0.0053619421,
-0.0729770139,
-0.044592429,
0.0200696625,
0.0091633294,
0.0395512953,
0.0023851884,
-0.024842944,
-0.0131682744,
-0.0338631459,
0.0309367646,
-0.0157217626,
0.0528005622,
0.0002110958,
0.0223646797,
-0.0181188788,
-0.0014174007,
-0.0216068923,
0.0241277982,
-0.0123527311,
0.0203981418,
-0.0809833482,
0.0094745615,
0.0004814034,
0.0409653373,
0.0086167026,
0.001991349,
-0.0588851832,
-0.0076491814,
0.0229824074,
-0.0296165589,
-0.0219901931,
0.0401469171,
0.0215699188,
-0.0921236649,
-0.0708984882,
0.008889962,
-0.0007975395,
-0.0305132959,
-0.0128816999,
0.0501118936,
0.0096593611,
-0.0565463603,
-0.0573490672,
-0.0207115579,
-0.0570177659,
-0.0641631112,
-0.0336823501,
-0.0280380212,
-0.0257116891,
-0.0256218035,
0.0050964714,
-0.0428424142,
0.0084476369,
-0.0199913066,
-0.0236955769,
0.0788341537,
-0.0275192186,
-0.0667532235,
0.0119855795,
0.0046086693,
0.0232708473,
0.0426804982,
0.0377197042,
-0.0268558618,
0.0473416261,
0.0175732151,
0.0059418362,
0.0238620862,
0.0208742656,
-0.0059266011,
0.0229969211,
-0.0164979119,
0.0127029261,
0.0243778992,
0.034666054,
0.0420441553,
-0.0297117177,
-0.0454642996,
0.1008409858,
-0.0130257532,
-0.002455842,
0.0513930209,
0.0036138233,
-0.0505892038,
0.0277974606,
0.0634689182,
-0.0603144243,
-0.0095386291,
-0.0441542231,
0.0153965065,
0.0233577397,
0.037955448,
-0.0227732845,
-0.0567014739,
0.0050246008,
-0.0113903824,
0.0411618426,
-0.0399057046,
0.0206733458,
0.0604860336,
-0.0265881512,
-0.0017602254,
0.0054401299,
-0.0722406134,
-0.0264330674,
-0.0229203776,
-0.0227138884,
-0.0134020587,
0.0412344225,
0.0074701891,
-0.0465697758,
-0.0556849241,
-0.0334941484,
0.0151359728,
0.0382195003,
0.0175048541,
0.0117197651,
-0.038534604,
-0.0233919993,
-0.0420513749,
0.0119400462,
0.0189851429,
0.0277312454,
0.0318464115,
0.0303430706,
-0.0281452332,
-0.0383264646,
0.035646867,
0.0073189777,
-0.0441808887,
0.0009346424,
0.0108105103,
0.0422442928,
0.0290400218,
-0.0165494811,
0.0199228656,
0.0281865783,
-0.0041506039,
-0.0174309704,
0.0041200207,
-0.0531263389,
-0.0877763852,
0.0419063307,
0.0080406396,
-0.0390951075,
0.0774683431,
-0.0597878397,
-0.0586837009,
0.0179981869,
-0.0404080972,
0.0038316189,
-0.0550566353,
0.0209307112,
0.019049393,
0.0703067854,
0.0092468392,
0.0211506356,
-0.0129172048,
-0.0190702807,
-0.0078370171,
0.0276108943,
0.0021150082,
-0.0696121603,
-0.0668338239,
0.0047778343,
0.0145071913,
0.0248561371,
-0.0063481047,
-0.0244596992,
-0.0328913443,
0.0157512128,
-0.0657583401,
-0.0032068237,
-0.0367171951,
0.0384585597,
0.0211616214,
-0.0119691333,
-0.0070979609,
-0.0345968716,
0.0034199061,
0.0367271677,
-0.0150011405,
-0.0007839725,
0.0193578061,
-0.0123064322,
-0.0123335505,
-0.0181729123,
0.002551435,
-0.0230210759,
0.0423197262,
0.0040747304,
-0.0004848003,
-0.0482360534,
-0.0131248226,
-0.0227098614,
0.0592132062,
0.0224273708,
-0.0783982873,
0.00661967,
0.0384950489,
0.0259399433,
0.0502314009,
0.0285722073,
0.0049984292,
-0.011933025,
0.012756058,
0.0212433618,
-0.0070576984,
-0.0023159259,
-0.0080052875,
-0.0368044116,
0.0290006585,
0.0043384633,
0.1008223668,
-0.0051439954,
-0.0258427095,
0.0001442906,
0.0119682355,
0.0049646241,
-0.0281507317,
0.0021909289,
0.0055347248,
-0.0353059806,
-0.0414774008,
-0.0324990749,
-0.0338446908,
0.1040419415,
-0.0245036166,
-0.0086287055,
-0.0209580641,
-0.0432685427,
0.0189240389,
0.0098942053,
0.0308607351,
0.0214344822,
0.023592256,
-0.0217746459,
-0.0735856146,
-0.0309911128,
0.071338594,
-0.0068547619,
0.0297296792,
-0.0205431171,
0.0148348613,
0.0153637473,
-0.0564495996,
-0.0242733471,
-0.010315951,
0.0085103009,
0.0163786039,
0.0185528249,
-0.0360103846,
-0.0524577983,
-0.0140932538,
-0.0160824079,
0.0423724391,
-0.0352520421,
-0.0094939042,
-0.0184180252,
0.0688388869,
0.0522091836,
-0.0114454981,
0.0135629829,
-0.0154946307,
0.0176564753,
0.0907848701,
0.0043397159,
0.0498934463,
-0.0486158207,
-0.0072747469,
0.0120005393,
-0.0309920385,
-0.018134661,
0.0119360145,
0.0386579856,
-0.0609921739,
-0.0167732108,
0.0682162344,
-0.0180017352,
-0.0194132142,
0.0162483621,
0.010502032,
0.0254584569,
0.0050221109,
-0.0235965028,
-0.0182925295,
0.0045443317,
0.0115207396,
0.0359058529,
-0.0047451984,
-0.0108506037,
0.0171428267,
-0.1194767952,
0.0247232579,
0.0353654101,
-0.0540238209,
-0.0664888322,
-0.0228917859,
0.0215650573,
-0.0203091837,
0.0504064895,
0.0218156539,
0.0090244766,
-0.0214086007,
0.0398347154,
-0.0256523509,
-0.0746014714,
-0.0336072482,
-0.0492856167,
0.0445539318,
0.0829576552,
0.0267043058,
0.0060202111,
-0.0238521378,
0.047814317,
-0.0132499803,
-0.0196500346,
0.0322662517,
0.079668358,
-0.0201978292,
-0.0271352157,
0.0238249935,
0.0711961612,
0.0009712882,
-0.0010240162,
-0.0000634693,
0.0331162587,
0.0188485514,
-0.004704887,
-0.0052876631,
0.0057330318,
0.0418586954,
0.0203907304,
0.0177041851,
-0.0321973376,
-0.0347430333,
-0.1051586792,
0.0378892086,
-0.0719637871,
-0.0238726903,
0.0372628272,
0.0333729275,
-0.0251743216,
-0.0700465292,
-0.0868217275,
-0.0483461395,
0.0252945106,
-0.0253286529,
0.0180414543,
-0.0317194015,
-0.0221051946,
-0.0342637487,
-0.0231813546,
-0.0142369661,
0.026741311,
-0.0380293056,
-0.005442895,
-0.009835477,
0.0266688205,
-0.0155214425,
0.0277216882,
-0.0819618627,
-0.0858367309,
0.0155608542,
0.0773964822,
-0.0000133747,
0.0696011037,
-0.0144761279,
-0.0586968698,
0.0504302643,
0.0558699556,
-0.0056338124,
0.0153860636,
0.0575370751,
-0.029041294,
-0.0111093,
0.0251475796,
0.0137659302,
-0.0036408622,
0.0552062951,
0.0697737262,
-0.0447932258,
-0.0139950672,
0.0437735468,
0.0076117911,
0.0700517595,
-0.019469453,
0.0164363794,
0.0083530284,
0.0506872833,
-0.0329550281,
0.0145495776,
-0.0236693211,
0.0235832296,
0.028704185,
-0.0217869189,
-0.0052875471,
-0.0235278849,
-0.031544134,
0.0147240162,
-0.0771262944,
-0.0042212177,
-0.0198509134,
0.01881532,
0.011372908,
0.006245275,
0.0093969069,
0.022616135,
0.0351607352,
0.0156174358,
-0.0077386261,
0.0272440296,
0.0341470726,
0.0353469364,
0.0310173351,
0.026958745,
-0.0758601576,
0.0577089451,
-0.0624808893,
-0.0093631186,
0.0709457323,
0.0170144029,
0.061781995,
-0.0175829604,
-0.0307535846,
-0.0121374689,
0.0009086007,
-0.0321639813,
-0.0184125174,
0.0007668692,
0.002295007,
-0.012160806,
0.0260913856,
0.0527233295,
0.0224973541,
0.0576332435,
0.0131387301,
-0.0307069067,
-0.0540235154,
-0.0394182168,
0.0274886973,
-0.0418829992,
-0.0158361997,
-0.0301362257,
0.0147803323,
-0.117657505,
0.0151283313,
0.0292247366,
0.0198881794,
0.0134815974,
0.0352453068,
0.007836245,
-0.0359061584,
0.0074990066,
-0.0351876505,
0.0146704055,
0.0583338328,
-0.0352911875,
-0.019441966,
-6.100262831e-33,
-0.0231961887,
-0.001135478,
-0.0297114328,
-0.0555476882,
0.0203502774,
-0.019493632,
-0.0232933145,
-0.0149440458,
0.013529581,
0.0178187359,
0.0028053352,
0.0445571914,
-0.0052893288,
0.057058502,
-0.0116245057,
0.0013736337,
0.0916752145,
0.0050631673,
-0.0391677767,
-0.0234769396,
0.0524252951,
0.048425287,
0.1007151008,
-0.0805221722,
0.0448726639,
0.0060860026,
-0.0535631701,
-0.0313614532,
-0.0267862417,
0.0562203415,
0.029417675,
0.0270405151,
-0.0002837749,
-0.0120195365,
-0.0092335101,
-0.0357179008,
-0.0677665249,
-0.0323651358,
-0.0335969962,
0.0128903072,
-0.0519315973,
-0.0272819381,
0.0113378279,
-0.028777834,
-0.0094028311,
-0.02193854,
-0.0136298016,
-0.0072546126,
-0.0102450587,
0.0037336368,
-0.0085844146,
0.023621913,
-0.009887605,
0.0078497482,
-0.0225208364,
0.0175352357,
0.0168975256,
-0.0203796122,
-0.0892749056,
-0.0033501452,
0.0225628186,
0.0659631938,
0.0060186568,
-0.0125200907,
-0.0076040542,
0.0031859463,
0.0087596355,
-0.0084413085,
-0.0152031444,
0.0412423238,
-0.0020894681,
-0.0070907134,
0.0599842556,
0.0631048456,
0.0593677089,
-0.0380271897,
-0.038900882,
0.0263287574,
-0.0207006335,
0.0493570231,
-0.0073336032,
0.0247426741,
-0.012629631,
0.0040273429,
-0.0017337691,
-0.0699899569,
-0.0171514098,
-0.0365183577,
0.0387158729,
0.0225563683,
-0.024107242,
0.0306479391,
-0.0173709486,
-0.0289037731,
-0.0302063804,
0.0223219581,
-0.0175186265,
-0.0177536868,
-0.0059615914,
0.0310453326,
0.00224297,
-0.015542536,
0.0491021127,
0.0047390643,
0.0300351381,
-0.0332273133,
0.0748579279,
0.0429138243,
-0.0649072304,
0.0034173182,
0.0076666926,
0.0418170467,
0.0201236997,
-0.0181618277,
0.0357963182,
-0.0244867541,
0.0017408304,
0.00753946,
0.0109428959,
-0.0089357616,
-0.0187788568,
0.0102031454,
-0.0120721487,
0.0225209333,
0.0156121012,
-0.0141786011,
0.0083691515,
0.0050143972,
0.0208170861,
-0.0661923438,
0.0135385348,
-0.0009177151,
2.693e-7,
0.0209289491,
0.0133500071,
0.0306352172,
0.0283783302,
0.0063245739,
0.0104962075,
-0.0205399115,
0.0460955948,
-0.0015092257,
0.0324555077,
0.0103586661,
0.0053673075,
0.0449382327,
0.0128209954,
-0.0266367495,
-0.009802565,
-0.0975812972,
0.0524440221,
-0.0216125678,
0.0202686526,
0.0154914344,
0.1067764685,
0.0252256151,
0.0034426793,
-0.0003859676,
-0.0542561747,
0.0430901721,
0.020581888,
-0.022476377,
0.0113936365,
0.0611656867,
0.0308091603,
-0.0011975695,
0.0287454072,
-0.0562311374,
0.0175076146,
0.0174561404,
-0.0057402882,
-0.0212320052,
-0.0175463445,
-0.026653016,
0.0206364524,
-0.0059897904,
-0.0357496701,
0.0515517816,
-0.0308834147,
-0.0036187454,
0.0009049452,
-0.0460102893,
0.0013202596,
0.0472720489,
-0.0563099086,
-0.0332555287,
0.0064961771,
0.0474198237,
0.049281925,
0.0057286122,
-0.038843479,
0.0075250841,
0.015642127,
0.0066608149,
-0.0093539152,
-0.0200240891,
0.0143694049,
0.0364882275,
-0.0287358724,
-0.0455434471,
2.481829258e-34,
0.0411975831,
-0.0447213799,
0.0190464836,
-0.0126291541,
0.028914528,
-0.0163253769,
0.0418201089,
0.0054172026,
-0.0092419693,
-0.039159596,
-0.0557634905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13316v1 | Coarse-to-Fine Dual Encoders are Better Frame Identification Learners | 2023-10-20T07:11:23 | 2023-10-20T07:11:23 | Kaikai An, Ce Zheng, Bofei Gao, Haozhe Zhao, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Frame identification aims to find semantic frames associated with target
words in a sentence. Recent researches measure the similarity or matching score
between targets and candidate frames by modeling frame definitions. However,
they either lack sufficient representation learning of the definitions or face
challenges in efficiently selecting the most suitable frame from over 1000
candidate frames. Moreover, commonly used lexicon filtering ($lf$) to obtain
candidate frames for the target may ignore out-of-vocabulary targets and cause
inadequate frame modeling. In this paper, we propose CoFFTEA, a
$\underline{Co}$arse-to-$\underline{F}$ine $\underline{F}$rame and
$\underline{T}$arget $\underline{E}$ncoders $\underline{A}$rchitecture. With
contrastive learning and dual encoders, CoFFTEA efficiently and effectively
models the alignment between frames and targets. By employing a coarse-to-fine
curriculum learning procedure, CoFFTEA gradually learns to differentiate frames
with varying degrees of similarity. Experimental results demonstrate that
CoFFTEA outperforms previous models by 0.93 overall scores and 1.53 R@1 without
$lf$. Further analysis suggests that CoFFTEA can better model the relationships
between frame and frame, as well as target and target. The code for our
approach is available at https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/COFFTEA. | [
0.0000457096,
0.0033292801,
-0.0016206453,
0.0844754279,
-0.0240082815,
0.0045675728,
-0.014682712,
-0.00744749,
-0.0220324267,
-0.0402447991,
-0.0290250648,
-0.0374118574,
-0.0042617279,
0.0405483991,
-0.0214111824,
-0.0851330608,
0.0473433882,
0.0118660545,
-0.0291485656,
0.0066450187,
0.0107021015,
0.0216405224,
-0.034022186,
0.0245761871,
0.0226995312,
-0.0021223454,
0.0063918293,
-0.0033358501,
0.0736253858,
-0.0270042494,
0.071686171,
0.0311195087,
0.0476139411,
0.0116537213,
0.0000020756,
-0.0334260948,
-0.0025056684,
-0.0268715508,
-0.0286922809,
-0.0094788158,
0.0179232899,
-0.0156659111,
0.0120561542,
-0.0083457623,
-0.0145479823,
-0.0375713222,
0.0372438617,
-0.0213811081,
0.0289854854,
0.0413053632,
-0.0375094786,
-0.0662070736,
-0.0202277135,
-0.0282355025,
-0.0525404029,
-0.0146742668,
0.0036730589,
-0.0131546035,
0.0151995709,
-0.0035717741,
-0.0601591431,
0.0024346472,
-0.0037482304,
0.0393398218,
-0.0166220199,
0.0235737879,
-0.0222137291,
-0.0249951184,
-0.0171984695,
0.0789648369,
0.0028658598,
0.0024014625,
-0.0346635804,
0.0013750429,
-0.0131068956,
0.019184893,
-0.0218765847,
-0.0124892294,
-0.0142823597,
0.0453814082,
0.0633515194,
0.0372757614,
-0.0386931263,
-0.0083023859,
-0.0059738434,
-0.027427474,
0.0440020189,
0.0151217962,
0.0155517524,
0.0201962572,
-0.0157512613,
-0.0085023167,
0.0333796293,
-0.0060603051,
-0.0117606791,
-0.0311847236,
-0.0585874692,
-0.0312931165,
-0.0465986691,
0.0063387766,
-0.008732724,
0.0494783372,
-0.0482847802,
0.0399492234,
-0.0759683102,
0.0226422567,
-0.0280351005,
0.0426841676,
-0.0402950943,
-0.0210519861,
-0.051319439,
0.0137145519,
-0.0483022556,
0.0393820703,
-0.061202392,
-0.0471635386,
-0.0483624972,
-0.010157235,
-0.0225861352,
0.0205975436,
-0.0239674672,
0.0006753849,
-0.0151877506,
0.0057681846,
-0.0131759681,
0.0622719564,
-0.056436941,
0.0106850406,
-0.013978404,
-0.0521847457,
-0.028272314,
0.0352951437,
0.0308848973,
-0.0552102253,
0.0191843212,
0.0285700429,
-0.0390068367,
-0.0415577926,
-0.0381011292,
-0.029321095,
-0.0417815782,
-0.0246666186,
-0.055411607,
-0.0788264424,
0.0184573252,
0.0382821374,
0.0353586636,
-0.0569602847,
0.0082029272,
-0.0168317668,
-0.0080262963,
0.0731473714,
-0.0119579546,
-0.0271360651,
0.0011113799,
0.0196236875,
0.0417417139,
0.0540480725,
-0.0132281957,
0.0141647104,
0.0372321904,
0.0043757916,
-0.0342705958,
0.0488512553,
-0.0303949099,
-0.0119985165,
-0.0289198104,
-0.0341582559,
0.0639471263,
0.0064472682,
0.0309776627,
0.0343690813,
-0.0225504581,
-0.0163118821,
0.0465607457,
-0.0091919322,
0.0357977152,
0.0068278774,
0.062370915,
0.0114698708,
-0.0362210944,
0.062417265,
0.0335796028,
0.0300276205,
0.0161758736,
-0.0101831481,
0.0164364781,
-0.0103079425,
-0.0508852527,
0.0054676933,
0.0083261514,
-0.0157356467,
-0.0240751524,
-0.0234171562,
0.0733102337,
0.0028575042,
-0.0636985749,
0.0382600054,
0.0341394134,
-0.0316617414,
0.0388433523,
0.0049981284,
-0.0229274817,
0.0527833514,
0.0118136667,
-0.0155563913,
-0.0751199722,
-0.0146024721,
-0.021582799,
0.0455779061,
0.0419275574,
-0.0278480612,
0.0033624754,
-0.0639497191,
-0.0183731969,
-0.015099531,
-0.0120410556,
0.0261613391,
-0.0395118818,
0.0487082414,
0.0083216978,
0.0798468068,
-0.0039894003,
0.0514321961,
0.0282384232,
0.0047507607,
-0.0125589725,
0.0386241488,
0.0358284041,
0.0039972481,
0.018955281,
-0.034459047,
0.0234121066,
-0.068001315,
0.0397497229,
0.0534417592,
-0.0818503872,
-0.0854301155,
0.0152880903,
-0.0779176131,
0.0245734584,
0.0661490113,
-0.0188382342,
-0.0371629335,
-0.0019985752,
-0.0135409851,
-0.0024422337,
-0.0124043748,
0.0123199578,
-0.0116333738,
0.0218125638,
-0.0080681453,
0.0528829396,
0.0149017321,
0.0264349598,
0.0075303391,
-0.0183303375,
0.045097813,
-0.0550658256,
-0.0308995899,
-0.0123301409,
-0.0112446677,
-0.0381716751,
0.0429876931,
-0.0276534893,
-0.0353295505,
-0.0304719824,
-0.0308777578,
0.0417894311,
-0.013853278,
0.0017613865,
0.0420201346,
-0.0010532772,
-0.009014694,
-0.0223658849,
0.0127500407,
0.0501039214,
-0.0009084168,
-0.0042193201,
0.0424002111,
0.0147981402,
-0.0663156062,
-0.0203615464,
-0.0002120247,
-0.0125165945,
0.0431597121,
-0.0257124063,
-0.055710692,
-0.0543681718,
0.031494379,
0.0397994593,
-0.0021474469,
-0.0064675366,
-0.0026630193,
-0.015234693,
0.0090574576,
-0.0538325273,
0.0376954563,
0.0204279665,
0.0738356635,
0.0391507261,
-0.0106129479,
0.0070079016,
0.0201375,
-0.0280893017,
-0.0357363857,
-0.0387423486,
0.0115678171,
-0.0196145065,
0.0710934848,
-0.0034999268,
0.0234255139,
-0.0480661392,
-0.0103435125,
-0.006555046,
0.0218718629,
-0.0125354491,
-0.0097399838,
-0.0031131383,
0.0206684191,
-0.0154790645,
0.0142313559,
0.068583481,
-0.0069252122,
-0.0382851884,
-0.0332039818,
-0.0051893508,
-0.0285687689,
0.0086275507,
-0.0090870894,
0.026264051,
-0.0315650105,
-0.0420821123,
-0.0615727603,
-0.0216095746,
0.0555404425,
-0.0175893102,
0.0758568794,
-0.0152337151,
0.0150339324,
-0.031134855,
-0.0488107838,
-0.0533444658,
-0.0264808089,
-0.0256400965,
0.0417309441,
-0.0261771083,
0.0185887851,
-0.078694433,
0.0250362437,
-0.0207443275,
0.0386911593,
-0.0000071098,
0.0064803632,
-0.0351110287,
0.0907198042,
0.0396586098,
0.0243762378,
-0.0319223441,
-0.0234893989,
0.0588346682,
0.0442009196,
-0.0405126251,
0.0107877525,
-0.0457784347,
0.0091434075,
0.039173685,
-0.0431775711,
0.0094990795,
-0.0075909426,
0.0565254167,
-0.0365738161,
-0.0380705483,
0.119947888,
0.0251134764,
-0.0495128296,
-0.0024017345,
0.0185711514,
0.0190436859,
0.0401293188,
-0.0212009866,
-0.0502206162,
-0.0786638707,
-0.0004818316,
0.0070038545,
0.028489355,
-0.0156189492,
0.01817175,
-0.1029762402,
0.0324120447,
0.029755231,
0.0076684044,
-0.0440625437,
-0.0397261679,
0.0189981498,
-0.0094958534,
0.0013767661,
-0.004887443,
-0.0079755215,
-0.0205561537,
0.0092802141,
0.0271390453,
-0.0338261575,
0.0081832912,
-0.0627304539,
0.0090108896,
0.0012049372,
0.0303298403,
-0.0363206007,
-0.0231388025,
-0.0263433624,
-0.1248539239,
-0.0094557032,
-0.0124350581,
0.0609712526,
-0.0272170212,
-0.0421837643,
0.0136112757,
0.0580091923,
-0.0267217383,
-0.0442183912,
-0.0187204704,
0.0372692347,
-0.0026089486,
-0.0102904122,
0.0155096473,
-0.0034129198,
0.0095953727,
0.0632906035,
0.0162233356,
-0.0218559504,
0.0258212201,
-0.0057862843,
0.0109387254,
-0.0284380894,
-0.0109511083,
-0.006951829,
-0.0040347758,
0.0198838115,
-0.0513011217,
-0.0182428006,
0.0376416296,
0.055535879,
-0.0029698678,
0.021062484,
-0.0083575249,
-0.0019699461,
-0.1033776402,
0.0161051266,
-0.0042470088,
0.0105558299,
-0.0548115596,
-0.0135265514,
0.065301761,
0.007372899,
-0.0395104699,
0.0572674237,
-0.00739996,
-0.0383393094,
-0.0211561117,
0.0096817361,
0.0105579942,
0.0612537675,
0.0013475643,
0.0201803893,
0.0411549769,
0.030663427,
-0.0109217614,
0.0193765778,
0.0052780928,
-0.0629975721,
-0.0642734542,
-0.0026825967,
-0.0314373337,
0.0051518343,
0.029271381,
0.0465341099,
0.0329917781,
-0.0040632342,
0.0817122087,
-0.0146241114,
0.0774481371,
-0.0558101237,
0.0127667589,
-0.0447841175,
0.0092603602,
0.030320853,
-0.0068834699,
-0.0040999213,
-0.0352061465,
0.0418613404,
0.0040270998,
-0.0033137565,
0.0238371771,
-0.0113930777,
-0.0210316181,
-0.0081183966,
0.0312197339,
-0.0157141052,
0.0479264893,
-0.0181348044,
0.023082234,
-0.0281161964,
0.0181741342,
0.019469576,
0.0714984909,
-0.0525836609,
0.0973470137,
0.0263697617,
0.018515965,
0.009185737,
0.0518854074,
0.0280054733,
0.0565444902,
-0.0706615821,
0.0251854472,
0.058164455,
-0.0793009326,
0.0011322821,
-0.0106107537,
-0.0157026481,
-0.0359075144,
0.0270555932,
-0.0453828871,
-0.0151586216,
0.0461745411,
0.0224095546,
0.0063691605,
0.0075810198,
0.0598101467,
-0.0576522313,
0.0486722998,
0.0470252745,
-0.0092287632,
-0.0321556479,
0.0129614295,
-0.0020408295,
-0.0067970306,
-0.0141130565,
0.0192489717,
-0.0120485974,
-0.0344655551,
0.0598192587,
-0.0401446931,
0.0245404691,
0.032065928,
0.0447624214,
0.0009377098,
0.0045325416,
-0.0190750975,
-0.0058238665,
-0.0011408494,
-0.0133283008,
0.0047578197,
-0.0348993838,
-6.182197359e-33,
-0.0767720267,
0.0296080522,
-0.0512269624,
0.0468568504,
0.0028307282,
0.0105753168,
-0.0240828469,
-0.0020857316,
-0.0152687682,
0.0134493774,
0.0578176305,
-0.0301398262,
0.0160113294,
0.0353589952,
0.0021379427,
-0.0508781746,
0.037208546,
0.0234939251,
-0.0153474081,
-0.0096425861,
0.0599983372,
0.017373303,
0.0785086527,
-0.050123468,
-0.0350873247,
-0.0080445278,
0.0181812569,
-0.0087872231,
0.0575529747,
0.0624336787,
-0.0142881833,
0.0445129573,
0.0152020557,
-0.0136260344,
0.0005551274,
0.0215783231,
-0.0901103318,
-0.0259072781,
0.0031172903,
0.0386490114,
0.0044057402,
-0.0441508107,
0.0143247759,
-0.0004733265,
-0.0669069067,
-0.0270706285,
0.0389621519,
-0.0256385244,
0.0419310667,
0.0171036515,
-0.0771083534,
0.0000522708,
-0.0364416838,
-0.0417790934,
0.0468004271,
0.0253911931,
0.0232581031,
0.0059594139,
-0.0526747517,
-0.0035360816,
-0.0425658226,
0.0726219714,
0.0448314473,
0.027120458,
-0.0250132047,
0.072755307,
-0.0067171687,
-0.0537644811,
0.0170303509,
-0.0057765152,
0.0213500094,
0.0274052639,
0.0642005801,
0.0812222883,
0.066412203,
-0.0030780565,
-0.0989783481,
0.0568804182,
-0.0429676734,
0.0912645236,
0.0244799759,
0.0152965905,
-0.0068879188,
-0.0105776405,
-0.06050561,
-0.0483344086,
-0.0244195331,
0.0035398158,
0.0368645452,
0.0072028786,
0.014840316,
0.0296295527,
0.0709363595,
-0.0257460214,
0.0368888676,
-0.0036699825,
-0.027110111,
0.0264641158,
-0.0111491401,
0.0312778652,
-0.0118184248,
-0.0640241206,
0.0276324879,
-0.0181955006,
0.0243404154,
-0.0169780198,
0.0546836257,
0.0037186295,
-0.0403534397,
0.0170194898,
-0.0180017333,
-0.0063685668,
-0.029794652,
-0.0150074558,
0.0213823449,
0.027114626,
-0.0425630696,
0.0541812703,
0.0177375618,
-0.0231755283,
-0.0268696267,
-0.0111248232,
0.0301687419,
0.0543533936,
-0.0298958179,
0.0130674103,
0.0004473763,
-0.0305331834,
0.020739207,
-0.0369438082,
0.0042645968,
-0.0114586856,
2.789e-7,
0.0160710756,
-0.0009158897,
0.0396482348,
-0.0374036618,
-0.0060591167,
0.0199824627,
-0.0303154234,
0.0537103191,
-0.0118564414,
-0.0459576882,
0.0211395063,
0.0212144442,
0.0321548656,
0.0017063937,
-0.0720291659,
0.0704869628,
-0.0160634071,
-0.0157488789,
-0.0339398868,
0.0436784662,
0.0437664948,
0.0685457066,
0.008889623,
0.0105521828,
0.0034875832,
-0.0710155219,
0.0445614569,
-0.0043193973,
0.0092549408,
0.0224453751,
-0.0410554968,
0.0297580883,
-0.0348875411,
0.0346364863,
-0.0079265293,
0.0699893609,
0.0350287668,
0.0226382073,
-0.0356073193,
-0.0054993769,
-0.0232461076,
0.0277027786,
-0.0043770489,
-0.0212956257,
0.0477753989,
-0.0671086013,
-0.0071880324,
-0.0351303555,
-0.0677727163,
0.0415909477,
0.0011401146,
-0.0206399113,
0.0142975273,
0.0023956061,
0.050812792,
0.0273319967,
-0.0438135602,
-0.0587710142,
0.0211318526,
0.0396197289,
-0.0347042121,
-0.0142934835,
-0.0038553227,
-0.0394130982,
0.0382112078,
-0.0228311773,
0.0147473719,
2.272144255e-34,
-0.0210560989,
0.040589381,
-0.0083824713,
0.015177669,
0.0023841544,
-0.0308024175,
-0.0755768716,
0.0022539669,
0.0299889911,
-0.0479098745,
0.0083723376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13315v1 | Zero-Shot Sharpness-Aware Quantization for Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-10-20T07:09:56 | 2023-10-20T07:09:56 | Miaoxi Zhu, Qihuang Zhong, Li Shen, Liang Ding, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Quantization is a promising approach for reducing memory overhead and
accelerating inference, especially in large pre-trained language model (PLM)
scenarios. While having no access to original training data due to security and
privacy concerns has emerged the demand for zero-shot quantization. Most of the
cutting-edge zero-shot quantization methods primarily 1) apply to computer
vision tasks, and 2) neglect of overfitting problem in the generative
adversarial learning process, leading to sub-optimal performance. Motivated by
this, we propose a novel zero-shot sharpness-aware quantization (ZSAQ)
framework for the zero-shot quantization of various PLMs. The key algorithm in
solving ZSAQ is the SAM-SGA optimization, which aims to improve the
quantization accuracy and model generalization via optimizing a minimax
problem. We theoretically prove the convergence rate for the minimax
optimization problem and this result can be applied to other nonconvex-PL
minimax optimization frameworks. Extensive experiments on 11 tasks demonstrate
that our method brings consistent and significant performance gains on both
discriminative and generative PLMs, i.e., up to +6.98 average score.
Furthermore, we empirically validate that our method can effectively improve
the model generalization. | [
-0.0179936904,
0.0905234516,
0.0177568402,
0.0759129077,
0.0164057501,
-0.0154845463,
0.0207426455,
0.0221931748,
-0.0269238744,
-0.0461059101,
-0.024941219,
-0.0356548838,
-0.0436443686,
0.0003869483,
0.0525989532,
-0.0258873496,
0.0454864725,
-0.0187284388,
0.029031191,
-0.0223278515,
0.0030269928,
-0.0022343246,
0.0189448819,
-0.0030013944,
-0.0198901705,
-0.0304768179,
0.0043726256,
0.0194073021,
0.0414992534,
-0.0021519628,
-0.0022584207,
0.0588031262,
0.0312688388,
0.0542127155,
0.000002227,
-0.0331208669,
-0.0161719359,
-0.0153854927,
-0.0293735322,
0.0391363055,
0.0009793473,
-0.0396623984,
-0.0130230319,
-0.0122787962,
-0.0391171314,
-0.0466152765,
0.0510761328,
-0.0049511064,
0.0590346493,
0.070040375,
-0.0246186908,
-0.0441133976,
0.0266577471,
-0.0546410009,
-0.0298603605,
-0.0661203861,
0.0153395152,
-0.0072098048,
-0.06182082,
-0.0041376199,
-0.0069421413,
0.0469724052,
0.0103915045,
0.0137390355,
0.0142675433,
0.030374527,
-0.0739641115,
0.0008682295,
0.016435273,
0.0733064488,
-0.0943545029,
-0.0302056167,
0.0100090327,
-0.011474357,
-0.0282846969,
-0.0814225972,
-0.0236019418,
0.0188934412,
0.0262929499,
0.0394759104,
-0.0634952039,
-0.0375328138,
0.0414087959,
0.029670598,
-0.0209714454,
0.0150769455,
0.0211086702,
0.0177225154,
-0.019208245,
-0.0316980891,
-0.1249037385,
-0.0428079478,
-0.002697933,
0.0228346363,
0.0025639015,
-0.0136079369,
-0.062792331,
-0.0433029681,
-0.0016171109,
0.0091219032,
0.0848482251,
0.0222667698,
-0.0090368688,
0.0518117212,
-0.0326135121,
0.058074709,
0.003144887,
0.0728100836,
-0.0343981199,
0.007703837,
-0.0084871901,
0.0063252011,
-0.0240375493,
0.0155086871,
0.0146789197,
-0.0036923508,
-0.0401621312,
-0.0158452895,
-0.0124095734,
0.0165720526,
-0.002175682,
0.0083727632,
-0.0332177766,
-0.044884529,
0.0569837689,
0.0088717984,
-0.0386892743,
0.0280601047,
-0.0275590066,
-0.0471658818,
-0.0376086608,
0.0358799361,
0.0443945192,
-0.0151145346,
-0.0100123035,
0.0456026234,
-0.022884775,
-0.0587162375,
-0.0432720073,
-0.0007394902,
-0.0105365021,
-0.0843217745,
-0.0243857894,
-0.0456853099,
-0.0004251767,
-0.0393853001,
0.0231620073,
-0.0586463585,
-0.0112479869,
-0.0286487453,
-0.0067066499,
0.0863374397,
-0.0373906791,
-0.0102747176,
-0.005177666,
0.0199725349,
0.0327763967,
0.0890211388,
0.0104877483,
0.0487998873,
-0.0016901629,
0.02214773,
0.014100112,
0.0658045113,
0.0684949085,
0.0081549874,
-0.0309996195,
-0.02430005,
-0.0049170242,
-0.0019348096,
0.0601821877,
0.0546014942,
-0.0664240941,
-0.0634680763,
0.0497460067,
0.0514102727,
0.0335977897,
-0.0056707598,
-0.0022669393,
0.0174526908,
0.0194452852,
-0.0180632528,
-0.0291847065,
-0.0020408169,
-0.0265205894,
-0.0046885703,
0.0077971923,
0.0138823008,
-0.0673846751,
-0.0224542078,
-0.0179945529,
-0.037633609,
-0.0329733416,
0.0182837546,
0.0397441499,
0.0379432999,
-0.0154262073,
0.0433229171,
0.0152258072,
-0.0336387008,
0.0131168347,
-0.0663895831,
0.0165538136,
0.028786825,
0.0321768299,
-0.0335271843,
0.0163046475,
0.000221396,
0.0147419078,
0.0020402647,
-0.0528149307,
-0.0056594322,
0.0702962726,
-0.0403254665,
-0.0303178765,
-0.0098745916,
0.0282194633,
0.0200595092,
0.0177515037,
0.0025385288,
0.0330673121,
-0.0438208096,
0.020912692,
0.033769004,
0.0031804335,
-0.0608806834,
0.0291516706,
0.0256638862,
0.0161585379,
0.0098914187,
-0.0222286936,
-0.0097247316,
0.0143953552,
-0.049539078,
0.0439716801,
-0.071058616,
0.0118361833,
-0.0449838527,
0.0448195599,
-0.0288027134,
0.0279130582,
0.0490784422,
-0.062470492,
-0.0236279983,
0.0371906236,
0.0299381446,
0.0055947048,
-0.0556264594,
0.0062632416,
-0.0105161918,
0.0545345843,
-0.0303557962,
0.0262366384,
-0.0097160144,
-0.0109487344,
0.013310669,
-0.0053361417,
0.0094306795,
-0.0736273751,
-0.0317663848,
0.009488876,
-0.0121152913,
0.0479306765,
-0.0013336763,
-0.0138638243,
0.0012135934,
0.0189492516,
-0.0750985071,
-0.0176045746,
-0.0464099497,
0.0171583593,
0.022504786,
-0.0016229855,
-0.0098813502,
-0.0263979826,
0.0038585481,
0.0302243102,
-0.0319863781,
0.0023194859,
0.0206733048,
0.0055025844,
0.0245794188,
-0.0417600088,
-0.0270201117,
0.0357322991,
0.0543967113,
-0.0561755151,
-0.0183622353,
-0.0257327948,
0.0600678697,
-0.0174731817,
0.0596984737,
-0.0293991193,
-0.0378510468,
0.0012206043,
-0.026066646,
-0.0103801312,
0.0970298424,
-0.0092559801,
-0.0310066529,
0.0557701625,
0.0211890936,
-0.0219926387,
-0.0117573282,
0.0071607647,
-0.0365468301,
0.0054726922,
0.0192560684,
0.0062317997,
0.0738928318,
-0.0129340366,
-0.0123729501,
-0.0361828692,
0.0641088635,
-0.0147655187,
-0.0257687885,
-0.0490046442,
0.0194724333,
-0.0158293154,
0.0443864353,
-0.0418758951,
-0.0490382649,
0.0385738984,
-0.0477818772,
0.0016157762,
0.0379771069,
-0.0066150175,
-0.0042950893,
0.0368308127,
0.0518757664,
0.0371851698,
0.0025846732,
-0.0092695113,
-0.0681586713,
-0.050583221,
0.0312438719,
-0.007428546,
0.0183311794,
-0.0007803498,
0.0329333097,
-0.0425952114,
-0.0120866029,
-0.013838225,
-0.0401069373,
-0.0369758382,
0.0351054482,
-0.0322792046,
0.0001866444,
0.0256424677,
0.0336301364,
-0.0390007384,
0.0556484051,
-0.0192545112,
0.010055027,
-0.0106173977,
0.0524641946,
0.0597646013,
-0.053429734,
-0.0374953113,
-0.0059983721,
-0.0101358453,
0.0483195595,
0.0072371815,
0.0650620311,
-0.0385533087,
-0.0076389681,
0.0394086912,
0.0246729199,
-0.007937666,
0.0020867325,
0.0409255587,
-0.0092715081,
0.0148566468,
0.0705228299,
0.0099165812,
-0.0176881403,
-0.0045753042,
0.0272734426,
0.0252451971,
0.0076851132,
0.003156225,
-0.1124239266,
-0.0387081616,
-0.013699417,
0.0191058405,
0.0247113928,
-0.0097350851,
-0.0361626334,
-0.0759342387,
-0.0024305223,
0.0376985073,
-0.0225601979,
0.0000207359,
0.0300250519,
0.0064808773,
-0.0655717105,
0.0393643491,
0.0065848725,
0.0076603754,
-0.0023173206,
0.0053621382,
0.0172620993,
-0.0573665351,
0.0096219117,
-0.0399764329,
0.0199097451,
0.0689069703,
0.0255866479,
0.0286900457,
-0.0003878641,
0.028872028,
-0.0062313979,
-0.0281953681,
0.0045469566,
0.039735876,
-0.0373637192,
-0.0174461491,
0.0586940981,
0.0280089825,
0.0191811714,
-0.016754305,
-0.0046702693,
-0.017136069,
0.018141726,
-0.0126349172,
0.0176369324,
-0.031177707,
-0.0219465066,
0.0364874639,
0.0375662483,
0.001612746,
-0.026450811,
-0.0155302603,
0.0258774273,
-0.0546546243,
-0.0500841141,
-0.0040691677,
0.0059381141,
-0.067093052,
-0.0372220613,
-0.0113524394,
0.0242410544,
0.0153160319,
-0.0451954938,
-0.0343411565,
-0.0097284056,
-0.0037340326,
-0.0577039607,
0.0052211685,
-0.0602466464,
0.0091193859,
-0.0219067745,
-0.0000963221,
0.0183385909,
-0.0305013508,
-0.0116982767,
-0.0063655023,
-0.1111678481,
-0.0677587166,
-0.0038616997,
0.0445353426,
0.0133725982,
0.0495623648,
-0.0328917913,
-0.099776648,
0.0914255008,
0.0673477203,
0.0375119112,
0.0190308951,
0.0609463975,
-0.039057713,
-0.0039057832,
0.0648313165,
-0.013938657,
0.0504745878,
0.0665458366,
0.0086834719,
-0.0513941944,
-0.0167752616,
-0.029204322,
0.0113272192,
0.0936243087,
-0.0138265816,
0.0200654119,
-0.0377954282,
0.0014711091,
-0.0137909455,
0.009519225,
-0.0451119877,
-0.0163264424,
0.0333903134,
-0.032652203,
-0.010328562,
0.012701706,
-0.0223775338,
-0.0016118903,
-0.0101422844,
0.0010429426,
0.0211304724,
0.0058628316,
0.0177449416,
-0.0026876985,
-0.0171440896,
0.0555067845,
-0.0039487625,
0.0158728212,
-0.0304097179,
0.0042850161,
-0.0064750868,
0.0364104174,
-0.041125346,
0.0398759618,
-0.020451637,
-0.0409902371,
-0.0662700236,
0.0355024301,
0.0863424614,
0.005400145,
0.0391631052,
0.0106070973,
-0.0281043798,
-0.0323486254,
0.0170634706,
0.0164387077,
-0.0218975339,
0.0228067469,
0.0060168481,
0.0101223076,
0.0289760362,
0.1010714397,
0.0314325541,
0.0272838306,
-0.0075990981,
0.0104008727,
-0.0491042249,
-0.0277453959,
-0.0212231036,
0.0130929444,
-0.0074090292,
0.0188347306,
-0.0077001536,
-0.063409403,
-0.020025067,
-0.0103813298,
-0.0219368134,
0.0427825339,
0.0291801523,
0.0301277936,
-0.0145561155,
-0.0341782682,
-0.0418060832,
-0.0308491476,
0.0317842141,
-0.0149233583,
0.0131249717,
-7.023636052e-33,
-0.0272021778,
0.0065770415,
-0.0134679778,
-0.0373608693,
-0.0096989265,
0.0364329517,
-0.0145674851,
0.0078603392,
-0.0534307025,
-0.0341680497,
-0.0345675088,
0.0216506869,
0.0103883361,
0.032498613,
-0.0477245823,
-0.0114881862,
0.0702036843,
-0.0185842738,
-0.0250527393,
-0.0023623181,
-0.0165114719,
0.0394370332,
0.057997603,
0.0254502948,
-0.0197679885,
-0.0044146581,
-0.0513394475,
0.0153300175,
0.0513551757,
0.0210696775,
-0.023883421,
0.0134173231,
0.0054196543,
0.0103469361,
-0.0235338993,
-0.0304152183,
-0.0608111657,
-0.0012570549,
-0.0032790396,
0.0233064555,
-0.0401150063,
-0.0335008092,
0.027136093,
-0.0319356509,
-0.0085051609,
-0.0257082283,
0.0013954079,
-0.012681067,
-0.0350151286,
-0.0682361871,
-0.0366108045,
0.0375319682,
-0.0000623346,
-0.0087714316,
0.103145659,
0.0005158873,
0.0135635277,
0.0221218225,
-0.0591678135,
0.0117852595,
0.0266259219,
0.0751816407,
0.0779067874,
0.0688249245,
0.0061621382,
0.0234983061,
0.0458019376,
-0.0309890397,
0.0027952862,
0.013504928,
0.0486421324,
0.0228238758,
0.0298865642,
0.0609967522,
0.0756667107,
-0.0104486039,
-0.0695472583,
-0.0160911549,
-0.0436097123,
0.0337602384,
0.0137394853,
0.072827667,
0.0155296149,
-0.0387400724,
-0.045450855,
-0.078007035,
-0.0495005958,
-0.0089481054,
-0.0141502982,
0.0400605612,
-0.0553348325,
-0.0118251685,
0.0342633948,
-0.0541131459,
-0.0046571447,
0.0161147285,
0.0036935427,
0.0057814182,
-0.0001201355,
0.0494817086,
-0.0497225039,
-0.0094884476,
0.0345657915,
0.0279511157,
0.0111504551,
-0.0071233739,
0.0608436838,
0.0147943441,
-0.0246767662,
-0.0133530842,
-0.0340838656,
0.0045360466,
0.0211023167,
0.057481233,
0.0280055013,
0.0124513609,
0.0085830651,
0.0737036243,
0.0134059563,
0.0154224066,
0.0223172288,
0.0262136981,
0.0168224853,
0.0360097289,
-0.0200769566,
0.0185749494,
-0.0060849939,
0.0304024853,
0.0652353689,
-0.0642672181,
-0.0210886747,
-0.019632902,
2.833e-7,
0.0406401157,
0.008332435,
-0.0120838862,
0.0062573492,
0.0027389254,
0.0278170127,
-0.0094741127,
0.0270830933,
-0.0269610621,
-0.0189149342,
0.0089723701,
0.0519867465,
0.0382827148,
0.0116742542,
-0.0680520236,
0.0363692902,
-0.0361922979,
0.0235215053,
-0.0395265035,
-0.0298350081,
0.0324662291,
0.1163939536,
-0.0173043273,
-0.0103824176,
0.0486083142,
-0.045096349,
0.0484001674,
-0.0033823606,
0.0224475041,
0.040077921,
0.0531492829,
0.0471527986,
0.0037400417,
-0.0258018319,
0.0014422116,
-0.0227174032,
0.0160559081,
0.0687908381,
-0.0174102783,
-0.03003815,
-0.0277687032,
0.0094124628,
-0.0149967754,
-0.036741782,
0.1022924557,
-0.0688190535,
-0.0375980735,
-0.0567475781,
-0.0269816816,
0.0029623264,
0.0396304801,
-0.038390927,
0.0020887153,
0.0374024175,
0.0266249944,
0.0032485402,
-0.0324462056,
-0.0837984607,
-0.0332082994,
-0.0039999769,
-0.0031902723,
-0.0233145617,
-0.000976143,
-0.0288901199,
0.0201166552,
-0.0216023307,
0.025215229,
2.08939598e-34,
0.0194626581,
-0.0070613399,
0.0187845528,
-0.0212592874,
-0.0210442562,
-0.0088687325,
-0.0097854231,
-0.0056910291,
-0.0157910865,
-0.0382869951,
-0.0234187916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13312v1 | Exploring the Impact of Corpus Diversity on Financial Pretrained Language Models | 2023-10-20T07:04:08 | 2023-10-20T07:04:08 | Jaeyoung Choe, Keonwoong Noh, Nayeon Kim, Seyun Ahn, Woohwan Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Over the past few years, various domain-specific pretrained language models
(PLMs) have been proposed and have outperformed general-domain PLMs in
specialized areas such as biomedical, scientific, and clinical domains. In
addition, financial PLMs have been studied because of the high economic impact
of financial data analysis. However, we found that financial PLMs were not
pretrained on sufficiently diverse financial data. This lack of diverse
training data leads to a subpar generalization performance, resulting in
general-purpose PLMs, including BERT, often outperforming financial PLMs on
many downstream tasks. To address this issue, we collected a broad range of
financial corpus and trained the Financial Language Model (FiLM) on these
diverse datasets. Our experimental results confirm that FiLM outperforms not
only existing financial PLMs but also general domain PLMs. Furthermore, we
provide empirical evidence that this improvement can be achieved even for
unseen corpus groups. | [
0.0057365112,
0.0860298052,
0.0024558033,
0.0005883047,
0.0321511626,
0.0253160205,
0.0520223081,
0.054045096,
-0.0141404532,
-0.0369291678,
-0.0827453136,
-0.0640103146,
-0.0153325852,
0.0171292759,
0.0570149608,
-0.0377367251,
0.0336893201,
0.0050640865,
0.0478793457,
-0.0418300889,
0.0181670506,
-0.0038376292,
0.0038468556,
0.018602049,
-0.0007464814,
0.0087128226,
0.0221051052,
-0.0257762317,
0.0147035383,
0.0061996314,
0.0294263773,
0.0274120402,
0.0441921726,
0.0480818115,
0.0000017194,
-0.0750985593,
-0.0338586159,
0.0109436763,
-0.0224308204,
0.0344004072,
0.023523625,
-0.0237881057,
0.0471695587,
0.0252391733,
-0.0516478494,
-0.012652386,
0.0467314832,
0.0528344102,
0.0440010689,
0.0759945884,
-0.0260913465,
-0.0567026772,
-0.0037522847,
-0.0955348164,
-0.0329021476,
-0.0601459555,
0.0297899377,
0.0021512834,
0.0069632037,
-0.0225062147,
-0.0330933593,
0.0133904004,
-0.004482612,
0.0401123241,
0.006873779,
0.0312381927,
-0.0669174418,
-0.0172375198,
-0.0313885808,
0.0710527822,
-0.0201076437,
0.0400351733,
0.0294493325,
-0.0353008285,
-0.0030807001,
0.0169573016,
-0.0049113017,
0.0519060567,
0.0207979847,
0.0007412193,
-0.0059828898,
0.0144959362,
0.0280574393,
0.0095115993,
-0.0559102483,
0.0042247241,
0.0032485684,
-0.023218412,
0.0441909991,
0.0334259383,
-0.0378614925,
-0.0140320575,
0.0256068092,
-0.0203320924,
0.0263277777,
0.0178064182,
-0.0565712191,
-0.0607794747,
0.0196854863,
-0.0634006187,
0.043791946,
0.0192670431,
-0.0559646189,
0.0343481563,
-0.0278034005,
-0.0029167426,
-0.0176584478,
0.0033834178,
-0.011553186,
0.0208468325,
-0.0544130392,
0.0041294373,
-0.0591263473,
0.0643756911,
-0.0160872843,
-0.0352959633,
-0.0662344843,
-0.0066737398,
0.0027121655,
-0.0219561141,
0.0077440632,
-0.0123786088,
-0.0270011723,
-0.0241220742,
-0.0050219796,
0.0004591178,
-0.0257537346,
0.0458963029,
-0.0239768997,
-0.042076312,
0.0032398482,
0.0286884103,
-0.0346216746,
-0.0544538796,
0.032388676,
0.0324474722,
0.0320200324,
-0.0638231412,
-0.0422133431,
-0.0014634067,
-0.0199033674,
-0.0253593419,
-0.0036076789,
-0.0065166126,
0.0265993923,
-0.0033909515,
0.0138092246,
0.0051629432,
-0.001923537,
-0.0558024496,
-0.0330667645,
0.0795356482,
0.0092675453,
-0.0278688166,
0.0085660741,
-0.0586332045,
0.0157861114,
0.0715098083,
0.0158224944,
-0.0266871881,
0.0286804177,
-0.005877662,
-0.0190387145,
0.0809723958,
0.0025642514,
-0.052639883,
0.0015285888,
0.0232604332,
-0.027612865,
0.021859156,
0.0612900369,
0.0137031563,
-0.0464345589,
-0.0057698754,
0.0492899194,
0.0406671092,
0.0895285159,
0.0048019043,
-0.0032193987,
0.018167682,
0.0555976778,
-0.0038906971,
0.0223033894,
-0.0465012714,
-0.000532427,
0.0384302996,
-0.0257539749,
0.0057759895,
-0.0449618548,
-0.0094916709,
-0.0160948131,
-0.0369305238,
-0.0280486383,
0.001263077,
0.0611732006,
-0.0201599542,
-0.0380451828,
0.0970081761,
0.0369003192,
-0.0322112143,
0.0027651442,
-0.0065963068,
0.0183229372,
0.0620161407,
0.0236255545,
-0.0484995879,
-0.0099066095,
-0.0204221122,
-0.0139624383,
0.0635109395,
0.0385386646,
0.0177673958,
0.0261784829,
-0.0626154616,
-0.0231970027,
0.0251983479,
0.0327668004,
0.0526105575,
-0.0021082589,
-0.0125413556,
-0.0028462706,
-0.0650494993,
0.0040004561,
0.0295201279,
-0.011358235,
-0.0076806503,
0.0247167982,
-0.0290224347,
0.0135277128,
0.0274158213,
-0.0625675172,
0.0144440653,
-0.0072911778,
-0.0261147693,
-0.0177990906,
0.0042284927,
-0.0495763943,
0.0019844412,
-0.0067055128,
-0.0243462007,
-0.0021583824,
0.0216854233,
-0.0503037199,
-0.0044652764,
-0.0283647142,
-0.0078667691,
0.045558095,
-0.077999711,
0.0002720328,
-0.0027527639,
0.0244665742,
-0.0178550556,
0.0461042076,
-0.0049506519,
0.0137372417,
-0.0434862748,
0.0191575587,
0.015964441,
-0.0644097179,
0.0218996406,
-0.0163225364,
-0.034576524,
0.0380028337,
0.0249939486,
-0.0123212235,
-0.0008077623,
-0.0028950318,
-0.0697426498,
-0.0398728885,
-0.0233657882,
0.0200436842,
-0.0149136987,
0.00110079,
-0.025414126,
-0.0343257785,
-0.0159212351,
-0.0067031798,
-0.0127163632,
-0.0012033568,
0.0583337657,
-0.0157927778,
0.0281275157,
-0.0500117652,
-0.005719352,
0.0029679404,
0.0435245596,
0.0213020965,
-0.0439253263,
-0.0113883531,
-0.0148079032,
0.0065467334,
0.0227394942,
-0.0009082545,
0.0251618456,
0.0037113091,
-0.0092193326,
0.0211236104,
-0.01281978,
0.0077060019,
0.0407929718,
-0.0346803516,
0.0164099485,
-0.0422335938,
0.0263931267,
-0.006234637,
0.0091876918,
-0.0257281717,
0.0322086848,
0.0384831801,
0.0827597231,
-0.0369955376,
-0.0243982356,
-0.0707739368,
-0.0142583726,
-0.0004405056,
0.0152626019,
-0.0402188227,
-0.0043770755,
-0.0156043498,
0.0242193863,
0.0100606894,
-0.0286123659,
0.062307734,
-0.0113233253,
-0.010051243,
-0.039186053,
-0.0054204566,
-0.0558923036,
0.0016408645,
-0.0301437024,
-0.0166459382,
0.0324198008,
-0.0524751283,
-0.0180231202,
0.000844651,
0.0373163335,
-0.0158155374,
0.0656581521,
-0.0354129262,
0.0593113601,
0.0041467329,
-0.0101780081,
-0.0250569545,
-0.0949638933,
0.0015593572,
0.0115489094,
0.0523039401,
-0.0241414197,
-0.0735165998,
0.0157087278,
-0.037472561,
0.0348895453,
0.0127201015,
-0.0048267264,
0.013923754,
0.0285229366,
0.0495968983,
0.0182339344,
0.0304545965,
-0.0681485161,
0.0048645376,
-0.0296044257,
0.0135921417,
-0.021726504,
-0.0173922684,
0.0080165667,
-0.0049657603,
-0.0612220988,
-0.0050246255,
-0.0003842028,
-0.0080800205,
-0.0166945159,
0.0043052756,
0.1133497655,
0.0055907932,
0.0023740586,
0.0067015602,
0.0274423677,
0.0022529443,
-0.0326431617,
0.0275306627,
-0.1150713786,
-0.0276617873,
-0.0294778738,
0.0180945564,
0.0568591133,
-0.0389956683,
-0.011186488,
-0.1092063189,
0.0087165721,
-0.0142484363,
0.0048080725,
0.0022262696,
-0.0203649849,
-0.0433007739,
-0.0594753511,
0.0386085659,
0.0047045266,
-0.0242423639,
0.013957954,
0.0469574332,
-0.0643335953,
-0.051165875,
-0.0050318642,
-0.0228701774,
-0.048020009,
0.0625646785,
-0.0185887069,
-0.0402131863,
-0.0103384228,
-0.0175022818,
-0.0009133001,
-0.0126071423,
0.0068256641,
0.0463122651,
-0.0099540036,
-0.0491246879,
0.0356041044,
0.009256673,
-0.0424973555,
0.0250099227,
-0.0230057836,
-0.0367341936,
-0.0326980576,
-0.0210768227,
-0.0101192519,
0.0129019534,
-0.0290397275,
0.0655118972,
0.0150400829,
-0.0554997995,
-0.0030745426,
-0.0126327807,
0.0112070767,
-0.056446705,
0.0370751657,
0.0083659049,
-0.0241133906,
-0.0436979383,
-0.0818243399,
-0.0552992225,
0.0239392724,
0.0413764343,
-0.0078777159,
-0.0117613645,
0.0538953096,
-0.0032067387,
-0.0307461899,
0.0714775845,
-0.0211242586,
0.0090838391,
-0.0695401654,
-0.0416953079,
0.0015884219,
0.0014638336,
-0.0643642545,
0.0185148437,
-0.0404246971,
-0.047428593,
0.0367198102,
0.0232609715,
0.0188198388,
-0.0212817397,
-0.0064904322,
-0.0081868069,
0.0692510456,
0.0511379614,
-0.0530556291,
-0.0128900837,
0.0747400969,
-0.0436851382,
-0.0187253766,
0.0135324709,
-0.0451233946,
0.043326281,
0.0158946998,
0.0449104458,
-0.0309080668,
0.008712301,
-0.0268224347,
0.005734928,
0.0737771541,
-0.0162300412,
-0.0148779154,
-0.0440057702,
-0.0037324715,
0.0130233271,
0.0249961354,
-0.0436148532,
-0.0470620207,
0.0635683239,
-0.0095460294,
-0.0318442285,
0.0421616584,
-0.0533307642,
0.0047372682,
-0.0234136172,
0.036388725,
0.0029752532,
0.0154865114,
0.0360466465,
-0.0313410126,
0.0283258613,
0.0290436447,
0.0181238893,
-0.01568323,
0.0114746382,
0.0131161259,
0.0071717715,
0.061115481,
0.0011465228,
-0.0159519278,
-0.0242603291,
0.0011631753,
-0.0022411179,
0.0399501733,
0.0308070462,
-0.0592796616,
0.0242129155,
-0.0318888649,
0.0188549105,
-0.015196736,
0.017393535,
0.0014081004,
-0.0099847084,
0.0536811836,
-0.0050531421,
-0.057650432,
-0.0298026633,
0.1327798814,
0.0241820849,
0.0337041095,
-0.0456152931,
0.0146600548,
-0.0462067164,
-0.0419853181,
0.0717224926,
-0.0045919493,
-0.0378333293,
0.0218863245,
-0.0692346022,
-0.0308677759,
0.0292211957,
-0.0192399174,
0.0018132027,
0.0091897184,
0.0556198917,
0.0727216154,
-0.0101490524,
0.0322720818,
0.0099379988,
-0.0016066583,
0.0222270098,
-0.0145242056,
-0.0636805296,
-5.866184804e-33,
-0.0093700197,
0.0257824659,
0.0067516272,
-0.0497151203,
0.0379749388,
0.0384743027,
-0.0062965835,
-0.0034912734,
-0.0025933629,
0.0018565885,
-0.0034784316,
0.0465735868,
0.0281325672,
0.0423897542,
-0.0029214562,
0.0067787943,
0.0397317111,
-0.0238459874,
-0.0082548717,
-0.0297044907,
-0.0005957096,
0.1067819744,
0.0765228868,
-0.0134877143,
0.0382539704,
0.0039293459,
-0.0146342926,
-0.0149789713,
0.0690429881,
0.0487172641,
-0.0184626207,
0.0331144072,
0.0094747711,
-0.0550089553,
-0.0531876869,
0.0011363764,
-0.0509276278,
-0.0323176347,
0.0224320069,
0.04122274,
0.0227453075,
0.0197233912,
0.0379966013,
-0.0197546985,
-0.0234024134,
-0.0117350528,
0.0206210259,
0.0006615491,
-0.0031782212,
-0.057193093,
-0.0565963946,
0.0499971248,
0.0195638984,
0.0330787897,
0.0470024012,
0.0370985568,
-0.0370985977,
0.0467040762,
-0.0025611932,
0.0170567352,
0.0297604464,
0.0036077781,
0.0069694053,
-0.0008744748,
-0.0190984961,
0.0353315324,
-0.0006649034,
0.0094701247,
0.0121893166,
0.0059500937,
0.0384576283,
0.0388996489,
0.0365421996,
0.0300378315,
0.026264254,
-0.0279784575,
-0.0425519496,
0.0308490675,
-0.0122878794,
-0.0162133183,
-0.005797673,
0.0323121808,
0.0031991852,
-0.0352718234,
0.00278558,
0.0341179185,
-0.0013981669,
0.0228972957,
0.0029345257,
0.0203355365,
0.008344586,
0.0512749739,
0.0179381203,
-0.0405283049,
-0.0764237195,
-0.0126142055,
0.0261669233,
-0.0229964554,
0.0110685201,
0.0199841559,
-0.058016561,
-0.0656271577,
0.0315555222,
0.0056166989,
-0.0169117022,
-0.0472830683,
0.0446164086,
0.0045129661,
-0.044274684,
-0.0004211094,
0.0190197062,
-0.0073209414,
0.0324753188,
0.0673719198,
0.0248809289,
0.0496429689,
0.0075630089,
0.0251390263,
-0.0087017631,
-0.0251256805,
-0.0077300807,
-0.0135120032,
-0.0024457909,
0.0891173854,
0.0161945168,
-0.0018149895,
-0.0017249538,
0.0418452211,
0.0659666061,
-0.0316945724,
-0.0291735251,
0.0088341329,
2.385e-7,
0.1035155579,
0.060265813,
0.0425059199,
-0.0148547404,
-0.0039164601,
0.0250403974,
-0.0421384498,
0.0276692435,
-0.0259335823,
0.0359199606,
0.0239389818,
-0.006110467,
0.0816083476,
-0.0332695059,
-0.0548365824,
-0.0592190027,
-0.0721058622,
0.0435513481,
-0.0589185469,
0.0319367759,
0.0002454172,
0.0949868709,
-0.0018322328,
-0.0511057302,
-0.0055857487,
-0.0865355954,
0.0767206624,
-0.0545095503,
-0.0294608772,
0.0275672302,
0.0095562711,
0.0193318222,
-0.0177020971,
0.0249318853,
-0.0263039246,
0.0357173979,
0.0106686978,
0.0186852086,
0.0079341736,
0.0043097953,
0.0166800376,
0.0191317201,
-0.0413751602,
-0.0107358303,
0.012961139,
-0.0770611614,
-0.0252478532,
-0.0169586837,
-0.0423373096,
0.0161989219,
0.0629464388,
-0.0055967588,
-0.0124139981,
0.0236935485,
0.0530059226,
-0.0169079639,
-0.0130759478,
-0.0437108353,
-0.0053746533,
0.0411396511,
-0.0554411747,
0.0303607751,
-0.0202291403,
-0.0121327713,
0.0379883982,
-0.0624560714,
0.012449597,
2.050359236e-34,
0.0736369118,
-0.0161507726,
-0.0228614379,
0.0467768498,
0.0453417189,
-0.0119484235,
0.0010685505,
0.0482038371,
-0.0251871515,
-0.0779736042,
0.0156118087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13307v1 | Test-Time Self-Adaptive Small Language Models for Question Answering | 2023-10-20T06:49:32 | 2023-10-20T06:49:32 | Soyeong Jeong, Jinheon Baek, Sukmin Cho, Sung Ju Hwang, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent instruction-finetuned large language models (LMs) have achieved
notable performances in various tasks, such as question-answering (QA).
However, despite their ability to memorize a vast amount of general knowledge
across diverse tasks, they might be suboptimal on specific tasks due to their
limited capacity to transfer and adapt knowledge to target tasks. Moreover,
further finetuning LMs with labeled datasets is often infeasible due to their
absence, but it is also questionable if we can transfer smaller LMs having
limited knowledge only with unlabeled test data. In this work, we show and
investigate the capabilities of smaller self-adaptive LMs, only with unlabeled
test data. In particular, we first stochastically generate multiple answers,
and then ensemble them while filtering out low-quality samples to mitigate
noise from inaccurate labels. Our proposed self-adaption strategy demonstrates
significant performance improvements on benchmark QA datasets with higher
robustness across diverse prompts, enabling LMs to stay stable. Code is
available at: https://github.com/starsuzi/T-SAS. | [
0.0295255575,
0.0108666057,
-0.0126774833,
0.0410610214,
0.000333835,
0.0237409156,
0.0474042967,
-0.0308850873,
0.0327565633,
-0.0514577441,
-0.0541113131,
-0.0132772801,
-0.0287878402,
0.013435821,
0.0346325375,
-0.0057919165,
0.061092522,
-0.0864964724,
-0.0117290309,
-0.0494919792,
-0.0008828644,
-0.0050896285,
-0.0058190059,
-0.0135653885,
0.0435723029,
-0.0242351107,
0.0013520175,
-0.0091506653,
-0.0094788494,
0.0016175816,
0.0474466123,
0.0632047057,
0.0221257508,
0.014721171,
0.0000019775,
-0.0454385132,
-0.0018204087,
-0.0138145918,
-0.0481171906,
0.0344650745,
-0.0075506298,
0.0450893603,
-0.0082988068,
0.03491785,
-0.0343520194,
-0.042362351,
0.0412621312,
0.0057830843,
0.0893638432,
0.0638711974,
0.033630576,
-0.0150109483,
0.0050752559,
-0.0294561498,
0.0388606749,
-0.0558401719,
0.0493305884,
-0.0058700414,
0.0095908251,
0.0208323244,
-0.0232525561,
0.0421034135,
0.0014777608,
0.0176717341,
-0.0255647376,
0.0394519791,
-0.0177096147,
0.0380218588,
-0.0280157886,
0.0797928274,
0.0207315069,
-0.016062418,
-0.0200576726,
0.0046582124,
0.0079914778,
0.0049838191,
-0.0448521599,
0.0166783761,
0.0102191698,
0.0068252888,
0.0104162041,
0.0108086951,
0.0052076909,
0.0310852546,
-0.0398499109,
0.067932792,
0.0007361699,
-0.0506755635,
0.0064696674,
-0.0062246956,
-0.0275626406,
-0.0405714363,
-0.0183981787,
0.0723848641,
-0.0128950728,
0.0305355322,
-0.0428646691,
-0.0315338112,
0.0210832804,
0.0179146212,
0.0464622118,
0.0022581127,
-0.000213018,
0.0877362117,
-0.0559662431,
0.0643897504,
0.0109536564,
0.0204021018,
-0.0695087463,
-0.0244409721,
-0.0506684743,
-0.0280183069,
-0.0596857555,
0.0627288967,
-0.0217827708,
-0.0035585323,
-0.0043172287,
0.0373754241,
-0.0128236748,
-0.0001882389,
0.0008927218,
0.0114179859,
-0.0434885286,
-0.0131329149,
-0.0320468359,
0.0471346788,
-0.0519805476,
-0.0001215311,
0.0232270062,
-0.0706460625,
-0.0462268069,
0.0026894193,
0.0140102468,
-0.0352960825,
0.0293326452,
0.041039519,
-0.0041177021,
-0.0447809659,
-0.0218784735,
-0.0058084405,
-0.0525417514,
-0.0488795228,
-0.0031594441,
-0.0625622347,
0.0429091267,
0.0013742954,
0.0099089304,
-0.0528783798,
0.0020911193,
0.0439705737,
-0.0414304733,
0.0526872389,
-0.0173650607,
0.040191751,
0.0216081478,
-0.008068841,
0.0337605625,
0.0695302635,
0.0317514017,
0.0005840057,
0.0418583117,
-0.0380464196,
0.021688072,
0.0321397781,
0.0422591716,
0.0211761575,
-0.0214430634,
0.0574255995,
0.0279139746,
0.0227089208,
0.0189875793,
0.0620481558,
0.0188854598,
-0.0318786167,
0.0577142276,
0.0502874963,
-0.0011520721,
0.0184389558,
0.0103944363,
0.0150060775,
0.0124675659,
-0.0125319799,
-0.0459140427,
0.0609613135,
-0.0521568358,
0.0277890917,
0.0296345893,
0.0253948215,
-0.0776374862,
-0.0216608904,
-0.0053318203,
0.0016918269,
-0.0300661344,
0.0628344864,
0.0555255488,
0.0357922167,
-0.0162785985,
0.028497234,
0.0310261212,
-0.0279778671,
0.0030701843,
-0.0647821873,
0.0919331908,
0.0610208735,
0.0376988202,
-0.0290843304,
-0.0373037979,
-0.0274537895,
0.0657997057,
0.006824641,
0.0551573336,
-0.0159536656,
-0.0029404834,
-0.0368823446,
0.003320423,
-0.018959552,
-0.0202710517,
0.0129917879,
0.024546871,
0.0183877833,
-0.0098437527,
-0.0313405991,
-0.0147399493,
0.0165280644,
-0.0262190811,
-0.0651083887,
0.0374233797,
-0.0052154353,
0.0180774312,
-0.0136815067,
-0.0218740311,
0.0110996328,
0.0407353118,
-0.0323339216,
-0.0088438131,
-0.0416802354,
-0.049414929,
-0.0696618557,
0.0164311826,
0.0202114433,
-0.0197404306,
0.0234887898,
-0.0414420068,
-0.0683948472,
0.0068350392,
-0.0496599264,
-0.0587714463,
-0.0429494828,
-0.0207185261,
0.0278095119,
0.0347449854,
-0.058908321,
0.0375880636,
0.0135377795,
0.0256945323,
-0.0270037036,
0.0362710208,
-0.0145309353,
-0.0676742122,
-0.0558100119,
-0.0076929731,
-0.0212615617,
0.028257098,
-0.0068938429,
0.0039392104,
-0.0412594117,
-0.0317949839,
-0.0557482913,
0.0273086317,
-0.0230633337,
0.021120457,
0.0106329089,
0.0233160015,
-0.021183135,
-0.0382968001,
-0.045506116,
0.0023190679,
0.035516277,
0.0240802374,
0.0146757048,
0.0009888794,
0.0114069348,
-0.0356221944,
-0.0262095183,
-0.0066134622,
0.0266487487,
-0.0354197919,
0.0315589197,
-0.0695654452,
-0.0203564186,
-0.0304959323,
0.0372423753,
0.0163472742,
-0.050579343,
-0.022521846,
-0.0384277254,
0.0268376488,
0.0777414441,
0.025238689,
-0.0029019071,
0.0419784896,
-0.023791682,
-0.0418301001,
0.0527570397,
-0.0170049183,
-0.0488695167,
-0.0067362813,
-0.0234814696,
-0.0085539455,
0.0715891123,
0.0108169252,
-0.0268048216,
-0.0415140986,
0.0321343243,
-0.0124694072,
-0.0114918267,
-0.0419089422,
0.0313921794,
-0.014045828,
-0.0124724898,
-0.0113108456,
-0.0200608224,
0.0781854317,
-0.0174500365,
-0.0225207545,
-0.0581325069,
-0.0168078858,
-0.036049936,
0.0485663526,
0.0015898708,
0.0092084268,
0.0108802449,
0.0180957466,
-0.0452206992,
-0.0411877707,
-0.0066321199,
-0.0387497805,
0.0284370184,
-0.0505217947,
0.0371806026,
-0.0107182255,
-0.0483162887,
-0.0319274142,
-0.0510469005,
-0.0384627506,
0.0045452891,
-0.0235682465,
0.0171617661,
-0.0157931689,
0.0349184312,
0.0465807319,
0.026820438,
-0.0450295322,
-0.0006036576,
-0.0253941603,
0.049084723,
0.0831768513,
0.05070851,
0.0090779308,
-0.013330901,
0.064602837,
0.0384862721,
0.0721692592,
0.0145780537,
-0.0267396122,
0.000178325,
0.0179282464,
-0.0242265109,
0.0159021355,
0.0381088555,
0.0647321939,
-0.044783283,
-0.050055366,
0.1202815995,
0.0013543619,
0.0158731975,
-0.0132674351,
0.0148794223,
0.0121902097,
0.0156659298,
0.0423056707,
-0.0326267295,
-0.0498402305,
-0.0187253952,
0.0439203903,
0.0136858663,
-0.0342257656,
0.0056508109,
-0.1040679812,
0.0206898451,
0.0052921921,
-0.0779100135,
-0.023205664,
-0.020433519,
0.0072384477,
-0.0060857823,
0.0378680639,
0.0251667425,
-0.0347060747,
0.007056911,
0.0427306816,
-0.0216256753,
-0.0390173309,
0.050859794,
-0.028604649,
0.0983530954,
0.0587994866,
-0.0186359566,
-0.0162355117,
-0.0091587715,
0.0070516691,
-0.0779703707,
0.0043802639,
-0.0061500669,
0.0323554948,
-0.013583988,
-0.0260119047,
0.0106622549,
0.0526949018,
-0.0660415366,
0.0229480807,
0.0403446034,
0.068290934,
-0.0053869118,
-0.03738866,
-0.0140679525,
-0.0152407764,
0.0039841495,
0.096544072,
0.018966496,
-0.0691971555,
-0.0286757816,
-0.0051349751,
-0.0211681612,
-0.0474102385,
-0.0249587577,
0.0393086113,
0.0153776202,
0.0181666669,
-0.0604054146,
-0.0574681871,
0.0519136228,
0.0494782999,
-0.0175620075,
0.0341085456,
-0.0114554781,
0.0314327218,
-0.0258477498,
0.006162412,
-0.0925863162,
0.0058168592,
-0.0492560975,
-0.0196203087,
0.0492311977,
-0.0098495865,
-0.0038258007,
-0.0160004143,
-0.0990635231,
-0.0403021649,
0.0135479942,
0.0622744039,
0.0149976956,
0.0020924762,
-0.0159926526,
-0.0751566887,
0.0656606779,
0.0268349424,
-0.0404544249,
0.0317037068,
-0.0053557395,
-0.0085337851,
-0.0088859107,
0.0455230996,
-0.0590453111,
0.0307479203,
0.0232343078,
0.0332082845,
-0.0159131326,
-0.0438793041,
0.0209940076,
0.0127388313,
0.009255887,
0.0345365033,
-0.0018429045,
0.0004115375,
0.034949407,
0.0197864231,
-0.017590588,
-0.0131518347,
0.0071660979,
0.0160822105,
-0.0499482527,
0.0043496094,
-0.0188894216,
0.0036938041,
0.0209606886,
-0.0502615571,
-0.0155542204,
0.0273939483,
0.0136151239,
0.0297054239,
0.002415657,
-0.0375191681,
-0.0016079111,
0.0154914632,
0.0423836336,
0.0167249274,
0.0259619057,
0.0283227153,
-0.0212139357,
-0.0223142765,
0.0088401632,
-0.0629799962,
-0.0582503751,
-0.0272551589,
0.0232929848,
0.0147153232,
0.0147750461,
-0.0025207649,
0.0085012801,
-0.0116302585,
-0.0469326675,
-0.0365670398,
0.0155915348,
0.0143267568,
0.0704757124,
0.0354179367,
0.0076212045,
0.0298596136,
0.0899877325,
0.0234630443,
0.0538342632,
0.0306261517,
0.0354129709,
-0.0391260572,
-0.0048509887,
-0.0541100167,
0.012708989,
-0.0076558269,
0.0156414174,
0.0049051568,
-0.0644421279,
-0.0012259841,
0.0218274612,
0.001452888,
-0.0398251973,
0.0412539877,
0.040794082,
0.0079366118,
-0.0042697936,
-0.0232835971,
0.0471592881,
-0.0282627456,
-0.019509634,
0.0123949088,
-6.588554001e-33,
-0.0374675207,
-0.0025025934,
0.0343853198,
-0.0157437138,
0.0429569073,
-0.0142468121,
-0.0333788581,
-0.0097557111,
-0.047602918,
-0.0206252653,
-0.0344803296,
-0.0033905099,
0.0116869844,
0.0603084117,
-0.0056043006,
-0.0300153717,
0.0218996033,
-0.0320703052,
-0.0286523253,
0.0508783758,
0.0226180684,
0.0212101024,
0.0277869292,
-0.0079489378,
-0.0031220836,
-0.0297119673,
0.0067743403,
0.0240882467,
-0.0225065369,
0.0786212981,
-0.0211529396,
0.0501823239,
0.0220002271,
-0.0254880395,
-0.0100921728,
0.0438299216,
-0.1013607532,
-0.0516417325,
-0.013835988,
-0.0188735966,
-0.0313952491,
-0.0192645602,
0.0317101292,
-0.0060263197,
0.0027600401,
-0.0056424271,
0.0131673049,
-0.0147405984,
-0.0333032496,
0.0071751913,
0.012072267,
0.0091492571,
-0.0103366701,
-0.0536334664,
-0.0124374516,
0.0261808913,
-0.0059917229,
0.0093368879,
-0.0122870002,
0.0031361438,
0.0264413301,
0.0530997738,
0.0578954928,
0.0197048597,
-0.0177042838,
0.0223531108,
0.0266902838,
0.0012541071,
0.046359729,
-0.038208656,
0.0048236549,
-0.005637757,
0.0535426587,
0.033850763,
-0.0218025297,
0.006817434,
-0.0642849728,
0.0389317721,
0.0374035239,
0.0238803178,
0.0528134331,
-0.0069396426,
-0.0433769412,
-0.0243775584,
-0.05578411,
0.0480826981,
-0.0296392571,
0.0017677782,
0.0639157519,
0.0013337486,
-0.0350913852,
0.0019542729,
0.047214672,
-0.0486463904,
-0.0196793247,
0.0019035554,
-0.0046494328,
0.002707799,
0.0073116706,
0.0401913747,
-0.0658178031,
-0.0078190137,
0.01027859,
-0.0108038159,
-0.0331081338,
0.0386937484,
0.0043919822,
0.0193788968,
-0.0945161283,
-0.0213444866,
-0.0263593625,
0.0364802852,
-0.0235605016,
-0.0309982263,
0.0093658334,
0.0334487222,
0.007872723,
0.0603372902,
0.0019280604,
-0.064764455,
-0.017427709,
-0.0203682091,
-0.0070857555,
0.0039594336,
-0.0272845067,
0.0063518831,
-0.0247134585,
-0.003046663,
-0.0294680223,
-0.0335045345,
0.0256253239,
0.0468312278,
2.599e-7,
0.0151489126,
0.0344295055,
-0.0016294831,
0.012256912,
0.0507200733,
0.0438224897,
-0.0174958631,
0.0343042463,
0.0462285317,
-0.00639334,
-0.0168462079,
0.0573328622,
0.0293694977,
0.0133184446,
-0.0723717064,
0.0197544154,
-0.051939778,
0.0507144742,
-0.0432247743,
-0.0166497417,
0.0203604084,
0.1004003957,
0.0132239992,
-0.024536252,
-0.0190562271,
-0.0678365007,
0.046924185,
-0.0047341166,
0.0008412137,
0.028489653,
0.0152279846,
0.0401344858,
-0.0226789471,
0.0506683663,
0.0111817718,
0.0221049655,
-0.0233723205,
0.0512841828,
0.0204695556,
-0.0361022316,
-0.0103272712,
-0.0223310627,
0.0274157897,
-0.0498055443,
0.1081697345,
-0.0933602154,
-0.0147264879,
-0.0090045929,
0.0021837957,
-0.0321199484,
-0.0108896978,
-0.0160976555,
-0.0106785959,
0.0045917747,
0.018720964,
0.0051243287,
-0.016583316,
-0.0801200792,
0.0253998488,
0.031783089,
-0.048031792,
-0.037793424,
-0.0609222427,
-0.0012242777,
0.0007968397,
-0.0861421898,
0.0165652148,
2.133966731e-34,
0.0007017273,
-0.019995112,
-0.0021171283,
0.0224281102,
0.0061488072,
-0.0224021785,
-0.0150737446,
0.0025598595,
0.0334954336,
-0.1045475528,
-0.0376722552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13297v1 | Decoding the Silent Majority: Inducing Belief Augmented Social Graph with Large Language Model for Response Forecasting | 2023-10-20T06:17:02 | 2023-10-20T06:17:02 | Chenkai Sun, Jinning Li, Yi R. Fung, Hou Pong Chan, Tarek Abdelzaher, ChengXiang Zhai, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Automatic response forecasting for news media plays a crucial role in
enabling content producers to efficiently predict the impact of news releases
and prevent unexpected negative outcomes such as social conflict and moral
injury. To effectively forecast responses, it is essential to develop measures
that leverage the social dynamics and contextual information surrounding
individuals, especially in cases where explicit profiles or historical actions
of the users are limited (referred to as lurkers). As shown in a previous
study, 97% of all tweets are produced by only the most active 25% of users.
However, existing approaches have limited exploration of how to best process
and utilize these important features. To address this gap, we propose a novel
framework, named SocialSense, that leverages a large language model to induce a
belief-centered graph on top of an existent social network, along with
graph-based propagation to capture social dynamics. We hypothesize that the
induced graph that bridges the gap between distant users who share similar
beliefs allows the model to effectively capture the response patterns. Our
method surpasses existing state-of-the-art in experimental evaluations for both
zero-shot and supervised settings, demonstrating its effectiveness in response
forecasting. Moreover, the analysis reveals the framework's capability to
effectively handle unseen user and lurker scenarios, further highlighting its
robustness and practical applicability. | [
0.0660967976,
0.0808764771,
-0.002364333,
0.0094651124,
-0.0127143329,
-0.0144755384,
-0.0143573722,
-0.0113945147,
0.0549565032,
-0.0272019431,
0.0451931767,
-0.0502457619,
-0.0568393059,
0.0609448142,
-0.0113337953,
-0.0173111949,
0.0217957143,
0.0332023725,
0.0380937979,
-0.0331188329,
0.0150318537,
0.0396933295,
0.0447924137,
0.020530235,
0.0047509954,
0.0177353006,
-0.0038709503,
0.0278829858,
0.0403103977,
-0.0414561667,
0.022057334,
0.0530592389,
0.0639561936,
0.0643342882,
0.0000018469,
-0.0562911704,
-0.0080527989,
-0.0366025753,
0.0072430982,
-0.0384408608,
0.039689023,
-0.0182719883,
0.0317284055,
0.0257338621,
-0.0980109051,
0.0282827783,
0.0279515106,
-0.0127950637,
0.0360500589,
0.0413233601,
-0.0397035442,
-0.0545152724,
0.0143078826,
-0.0089975772,
0.0282958206,
-0.0347192287,
0.0360845961,
-0.0300655365,
-0.0331196524,
-0.0178513508,
-0.0133636883,
0.0106669199,
-0.0105375089,
-0.01163866,
0.0359845273,
0.0214891452,
-0.0005969461,
-0.04884151,
-0.0101073962,
0.0552636236,
0.0410835668,
-0.0465227067,
0.0431355201,
0.008331567,
-0.0137058841,
0.0681933686,
-0.0592363589,
-0.0316208415,
-0.0043683546,
0.0561450012,
0.0076967641,
0.0226256475,
0.018087348,
0.0179621875,
-0.0103471959,
0.0678933263,
0.003175071,
0.0087544201,
-0.0210502464,
0.0486612953,
-0.0111572305,
-0.0496060625,
0.0225994121,
0.0124286665,
-0.0228718892,
0.0061440682,
-0.0205093306,
0.0174290538,
-0.0103742406,
-0.082184568,
-0.035930384,
-0.0037531001,
0.0784821361,
0.0632083863,
-0.0035909154,
-0.0641175583,
-0.0177561007,
-0.031555701,
0.0400079191,
-0.0033227366,
-0.0674137846,
0.0242946725,
0.0075394637,
-0.0009035868,
0.0145481527,
-0.0337493569,
-0.0446077995,
0.019935241,
-0.0331794843,
-0.0114128292,
-0.0418523513,
0.0298326258,
-0.0134680457,
-0.0220371336,
-0.0172981452,
0.0387412682,
-0.0224474408,
0.0269998405,
-0.0105851544,
-0.0281062461,
0.0327277668,
-0.0159075223,
0.0507092848,
0.0173902698,
0.000809148,
0.0295919236,
0.008037108,
-0.0362509191,
-0.0381849185,
-0.029003812,
0.0062268111,
-0.0432959758,
-0.0014202156,
-0.0762193128,
0.0440025255,
0.0578768067,
0.0025639413,
-0.0302441679,
0.0140463887,
0.0017853013,
-0.056746874,
0.0256788526,
0.0057594962,
0.0381808877,
-0.0273030307,
0.032539472,
0.0520282313,
0.0777363181,
-0.0060419315,
0.0516479127,
0.0596824288,
0.0236083493,
-0.0079663517,
0.0311309118,
0.0432442687,
0.0160657037,
-0.0018702672,
0.0028127879,
-0.0608827472,
-0.0483651906,
-0.0046557575,
0.0195454918,
0.0000933947,
-0.0001310927,
0.0566496179,
0.0760118663,
-0.0633647069,
0.0361460857,
0.009209943,
0.0294416435,
-0.026835788,
-0.0217739008,
0.0038801564,
0.0304862335,
-0.0465338789,
-0.0217984132,
0.0292822588,
0.0319431536,
-0.0519082732,
0.020523252,
0.012325217,
-0.0273417942,
0.0610748529,
0.0320275761,
0.005103664,
-0.0238098688,
-0.0440583006,
0.0387150422,
0.0394978561,
-0.03549679,
0.0371691138,
-0.0282871705,
0.0092186192,
0.0590876192,
0.0222436152,
-0.0114482678,
-0.0030587015,
0.0005107449,
0.0368891731,
0.0026722711,
0.0292807929,
0.0074474066,
-0.0141945863,
-0.0244107284,
-0.0247524288,
0.0458103195,
0.0122072473,
0.0375842825,
0.0331125408,
0.0263516139,
-0.0070654266,
-0.0113816755,
0.0066372603,
-0.0310906973,
-0.0081578437,
0.0168215781,
-0.0115145836,
-0.0081572933,
0.0492044054,
0.0721259788,
-0.0022041628,
-0.0267877616,
0.0158739425,
-0.002056269,
-0.0489386804,
0.0062463889,
-0.0071430062,
-0.0070050084,
0.0203672145,
-0.0342123657,
-0.0620085672,
0.0348472036,
-0.0039064046,
-0.0150794657,
0.0708647519,
-0.0066014789,
0.0565761104,
-0.0189931225,
-0.0651780218,
-0.045448672,
0.0133291213,
0.0037092827,
0.0369837172,
-0.0102387285,
-0.0093183229,
-0.016217446,
-0.0616454333,
-0.0152241131,
0.0048294421,
-0.033661399,
-0.0280027445,
0.001560258,
0.003883502,
0.0708333775,
-0.0511622839,
-0.0525141209,
-0.022951955,
-0.0589924231,
-0.0151151167,
-0.030794654,
-0.0129969912,
0.0282262154,
0.0309236553,
0.0074178013,
-0.0067466903,
-0.0483823568,
0.0455555879,
0.0358652174,
0.0344524272,
-0.0093198381,
-0.0187788233,
0.0012703161,
-0.0390150286,
-0.0190678332,
-0.0383294784,
0.0522108451,
0.0667491853,
-0.0452104211,
0.0135337999,
-0.0048131924,
-0.0734690726,
-0.0014861451,
-0.0158406068,
-0.0338877887,
-0.0094327619,
-0.029752396,
0.0236842614,
0.0034226109,
0.0340764113,
0.0023437287,
-0.0014927783,
0.0115282312,
-0.0372237712,
-0.0417639911,
-0.102283217,
-0.0184402019,
-0.0634184256,
-0.0414441377,
-0.0139695657,
0.0205041748,
0.0301069301,
-0.0129097542,
-0.0765207335,
0.0176125485,
-0.0010539303,
-0.0119012976,
-0.0100484779,
-0.0338210575,
0.0090660332,
0.037759807,
-0.0180436205,
-0.0118198562,
0.070150204,
0.0344929583,
0.038559366,
0.0359857008,
-0.026069304,
-0.0270692948,
0.0125244409,
0.0468735658,
0.0138052003,
-0.0391096137,
0.0068641626,
-0.0004494292,
-0.055119969,
0.0222843848,
-0.025638029,
0.0070913429,
0.0354732685,
0.0255384557,
0.0354769044,
0.0050682407,
-0.0061538462,
-0.0909301862,
-0.0535374098,
-0.0190316718,
-0.0046160854,
-0.0424440019,
0.0214728955,
0.0017808583,
0.010215559,
-0.0494013131,
-0.004165377,
-0.0353769697,
0.0109784957,
0.0297246762,
0.0340382196,
-0.0426240414,
0.0348724797,
-0.0471976623,
0.015853269,
0.0475934111,
0.0565621108,
-0.0314211361,
-0.0384626165,
-0.0321937539,
0.0092605827,
0.0538255908,
0.0108776689,
0.0085662901,
0.0824050754,
0.0252856854,
0.0383412093,
0.1069094017,
0.0239496324,
-0.0493333749,
-0.0120342635,
0.0168369804,
0.0582799688,
0.0383910909,
0.0072937785,
-0.0785131529,
-0.01856515,
-0.0257565659,
0.0170480497,
0.0085051572,
-0.0895241797,
0.0115814609,
-0.0760509819,
0.033030916,
0.017378075,
0.0408065096,
-0.0026006536,
-0.089069277,
0.024951214,
-0.0196415149,
-0.0622422807,
-0.0356427543,
0.0166874137,
0.0143031366,
-0.0099610128,
-0.0555771478,
-0.0192826036,
0.0285518076,
-0.0301082283,
0.038796939,
0.0229214579,
0.0449077822,
-0.0088910321,
0.0145191718,
-0.006884844,
0.0117471498,
0.0030145997,
-0.0050915899,
0.0622354485,
-0.0032542809,
0.0379973799,
-0.0469706319,
0.0468472727,
-0.0416110791,
-0.0392217152,
-0.01003116,
0.0491822511,
0.0175205544,
-0.0662802011,
-0.0114851054,
0.0280461572,
0.0348234065,
0.0474483594,
0.0581177771,
-0.0228135847,
-0.0310731549,
-0.0194108393,
0.0276428983,
-0.0456294753,
-0.0732936487,
-0.0474695563,
-0.0175046138,
-0.030721521,
-0.0240285695,
-0.0073182988,
-0.03532416,
0.0121834073,
-0.0116256028,
-0.0181873981,
0.0602527186,
-0.0379434675,
-0.0404845439,
-0.0029629436,
-0.0108434688,
0.0350346267,
0.0076358174,
0.0123318629,
0.0173663069,
0.0222176891,
-0.0103721255,
-0.012553744,
-0.0728172883,
-0.0978273973,
0.0285686329,
0.0359260812,
0.031629391,
0.0329584554,
-0.0128486091,
-0.0116978902,
0.0782960728,
0.0586110316,
-0.0218384117,
0.0141822416,
0.0331410021,
0.0386501476,
0.0097756591,
0.0259032678,
-0.0107458299,
0.0202305876,
0.0143969879,
-0.0287756119,
-0.08635097,
-0.0262248702,
-0.0329934284,
-0.0161054078,
0.0531774387,
0.0117483409,
-0.0491509549,
-0.0324009247,
-0.0691427588,
-0.0287163891,
-0.0028356549,
-0.0118548619,
-0.0236706864,
0.0353121124,
-0.0032810878,
-0.0452473834,
-0.017437445,
-0.0462911427,
0.0407622531,
-0.0681457594,
0.0331443287,
0.0303869098,
-0.0008621617,
0.0466923714,
-0.0095166815,
0.0034390967,
-0.0048810523,
0.0255485233,
0.0135691445,
0.0069433777,
0.0040359446,
-0.0148561774,
-0.0123727396,
-0.002847031,
-0.0155142201,
-0.1013918966,
-0.0409168527,
-0.0304550361,
0.0164357666,
-0.0028096379,
-0.0017559432,
0.0430698059,
-0.0018405173,
-0.0028007526,
0.0155045101,
0.047237128,
-0.0392490551,
-0.0580628067,
-0.0110900346,
0.0066070762,
-0.0237884708,
0.051621832,
0.0510878526,
-0.0027337389,
0.0038831367,
0.0303036403,
-0.0740063116,
0.0030762597,
-0.0070747128,
0.0192911066,
0.0530229695,
0.0131804701,
0.0378859863,
-0.0676308796,
-0.0705231577,
0.0295655131,
-0.0349031128,
0.0033719249,
0.0123680308,
-0.0047003916,
0.0337922014,
0.0117840348,
0.050133016,
-0.0620065108,
0.0097710481,
-0.0201189518,
-0.0396739915,
-0.000402771,
-6.663059772e-33,
0.0334612504,
-0.0399712138,
-0.0495275334,
0.0301552601,
-0.0295220912,
0.0181736648,
-0.0641498864,
-0.0123162279,
-0.0048398632,
0.0105997343,
0.0055390815,
0.0401210636,
-0.0036977797,
0.015409857,
0.0143606449,
-0.012360597,
0.0258599762,
0.0010568722,
0.0112909088,
0.0377551541,
0.0427226573,
0.0149947489,
-0.0073599005,
-0.0724219531,
0.0278322548,
-0.0235770214,
0.0192512069,
0.009778521,
0.0724839419,
0.0020123627,
0.0040801414,
0.0548096262,
0.0257971808,
-0.0178265255,
0.0084029175,
0.0732996687,
-0.0507740378,
-0.0579426736,
-0.0289950352,
-0.040894758,
-0.0086619286,
0.039830666,
0.0033129388,
-0.0065395883,
-0.0216463879,
0.0004391376,
0.0370438173,
0.0241805408,
0.0232810359,
-0.0348279849,
-0.0238638967,
0.0147943124,
-0.0367718078,
0.0257327184,
-0.0238059051,
0.0477495268,
0.0228996295,
0.0282399245,
-0.0903283954,
0.0365283675,
-0.028712742,
-0.0373077244,
0.0065972451,
-0.0083072344,
0.0099039664,
0.0824164227,
0.0311691388,
0.0360569134,
-0.0276368801,
0.0048159687,
-0.0244364124,
0.0122677637,
0.0059133503,
0.100314416,
0.0124151343,
-0.0443390608,
-0.0782993659,
0.0172304753,
0.0619400851,
-0.0223490782,
0.0766585171,
0.0168294683,
-0.0278790109,
-0.0459040478,
0.0071921516,
-0.0241870508,
-0.0187539235,
-0.020423213,
-0.0423504673,
0.0320275277,
-0.048623383,
0.0245418344,
0.0589180738,
-0.0452085808,
-0.0413141549,
0.0740826353,
-0.0000925562,
0.022361936,
0.0192759745,
0.0256586187,
-0.0651871189,
0.0086089363,
-0.0025246828,
0.0023156276,
-0.0116452249,
-0.0179236345,
-0.022366073,
0.0390987284,
-0.0440565646,
-0.0189866722,
-0.0116263097,
0.0206886604,
-0.0274677966,
-0.0510655418,
0.0441943891,
0.0588534288,
-0.0128544681,
0.0172307808,
0.0500585288,
0.0273173749,
0.0477174632,
0.0164508,
-0.0067554996,
0.0048332028,
-0.0272498652,
-0.0196510553,
-0.009365364,
0.0026244482,
0.0023792416,
-0.042238161,
-0.0294779148,
-0.0298418365,
2.648e-7,
0.0213701371,
0.0534872152,
-0.0261542667,
0.0018535014,
0.02536924,
0.0456757061,
0.031934306,
0.0501709133,
0.0366625749,
-0.053965684,
0.0195351206,
0.0524916016,
0.016189849,
0.0763270706,
-0.061120335,
0.0150870429,
-0.0512683094,
-0.0188870896,
-0.0375975221,
0.0036323408,
0.0153678758,
0.0331334136,
0.0751731768,
-0.0000994191,
0.0051233172,
-0.028991824,
0.051722046,
-0.0152720883,
-0.0525884852,
-0.0083715999,
0.0248041786,
-0.0394017175,
-0.0045920522,
0.0146594131,
-0.0518629663,
-0.0019532444,
-0.0344846882,
-0.0158786289,
-0.006475585,
-0.004820216,
0.0064593321,
-0.0156181436,
0.0108361319,
-0.0239182003,
0.0470286049,
-0.0811730176,
-0.0592624694,
-0.0298931189,
-0.0421632789,
-0.0268980134,
0.0130117061,
0.0072199972,
-0.0234844685,
0.0040248879,
0.0059580328,
0.0145406285,
-0.0112336418,
-0.0686617941,
0.0074961293,
-0.0135271838,
-0.0523521677,
-0.0657891706,
0.0198876206,
0.0015140418,
0.0216952469,
-0.0126344208,
0.0801056176,
2.422974185e-34,
0.0540644675,
0.0331433341,
-0.019564461,
-0.0270581804,
0.0418260843,
-0.0096527804,
-0.0294909757,
-0.0150858257,
0.0895110816,
-0.0565971844,
-0.0104871141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13291v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13291v1 | Assessing Privacy Risks in Language Models: A Case Study on Summarization Tasks | 2023-10-20T05:44:39 | 2023-10-20T05:44:39 | Ruixiang Tang, Gord Lueck, Rodolfo Quispe, Huseyin A Inan, Janardhan Kulkarni, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have revolutionized the field of NLP by achieving
state-of-the-art performance on various tasks. However, there is a concern that
these models may disclose information in the training data. In this study, we
focus on the summarization task and investigate the membership inference (MI)
attack: given a sample and black-box access to a model's API, it is possible to
determine if the sample was part of the training data. We exploit text
similarity and the model's resistance to document modifications as potential MI
signals and evaluate their effectiveness on widely used datasets. Our results
demonstrate that summarization models are at risk of exposing data membership,
even in cases where the reference summary is not available. Furthermore, we
discuss several safeguards for training summarization models to protect against
MI attacks and discuss the inherent trade-off between privacy and utility. | [
0.049985718,
0.0838874355,
0.0005116975,
0.047391884,
-0.0367269404,
0.002535444,
0.0258524902,
-0.0249402411,
0.017742468,
-0.0397539511,
-0.014027942,
-0.0028264094,
0.0059258286,
-0.0047073257,
0.0140472399,
-0.0106633045,
0.0311890934,
-0.027882833,
-0.0095814848,
-0.0156419035,
-0.0039871093,
-0.0060423338,
0.0370034948,
0.0419676788,
0.017189296,
0.0010186896,
0.008076244,
-0.0231623966,
0.0193890911,
-0.0083970297,
-0.0236732438,
0.070741877,
0.0057052746,
0.0604702048,
0.0000016092,
-0.0295359828,
-0.0857252777,
0.0515791662,
-0.0371058621,
0.0066249166,
0.0460227095,
-0.0153320413,
0.0443778448,
0.0194823761,
-0.0051217373,
0.0238505788,
0.0188321788,
0.0609521046,
0.080671005,
0.0783386901,
-0.0093569728,
0.0141403424,
-0.0023667382,
-0.041351065,
-0.0291377641,
-0.0372676328,
0.013032753,
-0.0357966051,
-0.0304385182,
0.0109323021,
0.0231953859,
0.0444769002,
0.0001287397,
0.0370072164,
-0.0165388864,
0.022095535,
-0.0516952164,
-0.0192211233,
0.0154156825,
0.0241835173,
0.0320454948,
-0.0185598712,
0.0283807516,
0.0413191877,
0.0458220318,
0.0493989773,
-0.0275382027,
0.0679532513,
-0.0114610782,
0.0276462398,
0.0068033743,
0.0127558373,
0.0354670845,
-0.0009808893,
0.0141956666,
0.045687709,
0.0050666193,
0.0084266141,
-0.045967076,
-0.026244998,
-0.0221593026,
-0.0722194389,
0.0230012611,
0.0041517401,
0.054013148,
0.0211258437,
-0.0897947252,
-0.0690243691,
0.0320432223,
-0.0532996543,
0.0006987221,
-0.023135202,
0.0388204418,
0.0533960983,
0.0121849133,
0.0035868478,
0.0368770212,
0.0394007005,
-0.0092039509,
0.0074028121,
-0.0068577477,
-0.0282071196,
0.0040517421,
0.0750244334,
-0.0374607556,
-0.0111101884,
-0.0197787713,
0.0312292837,
-0.0234331414,
0.0311934557,
-0.0523829982,
0.0001786976,
-0.0149802575,
0.0008639047,
0.0078701461,
-0.0537740886,
0.0109403515,
-0.0149535462,
0.0074357148,
-0.0496613234,
-0.0306477826,
-0.0393287912,
0.0095774326,
0.0084935315,
-0.0424810089,
0.0734342337,
0.0176826492,
-0.0665062815,
-0.0152907986,
-0.1055331156,
0.009776541,
-0.0287200511,
-0.0079444051,
-0.0582027659,
-0.0005209843,
-0.0119244447,
-0.0066742003,
-0.0413962267,
0.0003141169,
0.042217128,
-0.0483496189,
0.0457201861,
-0.0217556041,
-0.0132437404,
-0.0112420833,
0.0404269397,
0.0015925081,
0.057683818,
0.0066388855,
0.0258851629,
0.0840797126,
0.025348125,
0.036166504,
0.0080834571,
0.0456962027,
-0.0067893462,
0.010086921,
-0.0060867397,
0.0006294888,
-0.091030933,
-0.049501434,
0.0530208722,
-0.0093282061,
-0.0504924729,
0.0998144969,
0.1045643762,
-0.0425860956,
-0.0001118563,
-0.0532183535,
0.023391068,
0.014039373,
0.0496598817,
-0.056683559,
-0.0267876219,
-0.1044273153,
-0.0137098236,
0.0420216657,
-0.0034869325,
0.002850909,
-0.0192825422,
-0.0027973761,
-0.0405015759,
0.0302520338,
0.0212631226,
-0.0028215284,
0.0271169394,
0.049057439,
0.0589919984,
0.0286214445,
-0.0729339495,
0.0027236498,
-0.0340903439,
0.0194747727,
0.0115804002,
0.0800473839,
-0.0405562483,
0.0321205072,
-0.0525650159,
-0.0289165564,
-0.0067284456,
0.0387914293,
-0.0056692241,
0.0463119783,
-0.0065425579,
-0.0350189954,
-0.0091485577,
0.0605827533,
-0.0067831976,
0.0370404832,
-0.0412574895,
0.0433825701,
-0.051277712,
-0.0460987017,
0.0215229709,
-0.0158720724,
-0.0448940732,
0.0064401939,
-0.0115212044,
0.0191467106,
0.0444738828,
-0.0132918004,
0.0279875044,
0.0203370098,
0.0065357173,
-0.0050001941,
0.0144910514,
0.0289885569,
0.0013587817,
-0.0043513277,
-0.0425902344,
0.0092006875,
0.0687810928,
-0.018654963,
-0.0252290051,
0.0102589363,
-0.045075018,
0.0288563296,
-0.0052690143,
0.0106731411,
-0.0122517943,
0.0360659584,
-0.0247028358,
0.0449378081,
-0.0307423901,
0.0191021618,
-0.0028249249,
-0.049424585,
0.00005593,
-0.0480739027,
-0.0496522337,
-0.0032643224,
-0.0234943945,
0.0087972842,
0.0423302948,
-0.0444764867,
-0.0035768945,
0.0006108899,
-0.0392281674,
0.0075393538,
0.000989154,
0.0322064683,
0.0186792575,
0.032046508,
-0.012700689,
-0.032034412,
-0.0136959953,
-0.0746994689,
-0.0200858209,
0.0540428646,
0.0220957529,
0.0119302785,
0.0140788937,
-0.021447178,
-0.028873859,
0.0014523203,
0.0796274021,
-0.019244438,
-0.01772267,
-0.0059402818,
0.0125109358,
-0.0164850801,
0.0389358364,
-0.0010906172,
0.0253905244,
-0.0309262536,
0.0185528435,
-0.0252031535,
0.0316291042,
0.0215846132,
0.0254942235,
0.0443859883,
0.0191869009,
-0.0182489473,
-0.0313711725,
-0.0197501332,
0.0154571123,
-0.0146492906,
-0.037808992,
0.0490010791,
0.0197688714,
0.0193135086,
-0.0480588339,
-0.001563187,
0.0582315512,
-0.0139937457,
-0.0369076841,
-0.0124418791,
-0.0150501234,
0.0074055009,
0.0309041161,
-0.0224088766,
-0.0552978814,
0.0481140316,
-0.0511744544,
0.0591157712,
-0.0409935676,
-0.0413258933,
-0.0017248217,
0.0616789944,
0.0407835469,
0.0412798598,
0.0561638884,
-0.0229173768,
-0.0091702091,
-0.0018045931,
0.0727076754,
-0.0463332534,
0.0600200668,
-0.0134111652,
-0.0074392362,
-0.0074716541,
-0.0077094119,
-0.0391900018,
-0.062686801,
-0.0136527326,
0.0127271833,
0.0016192815,
0.0011161492,
-0.0312108565,
-0.0017309008,
0.0455741063,
0.0289771371,
-0.0210150406,
0.0022531203,
-0.0286135729,
0.0432480797,
0.0399890207,
-0.0564231984,
0.031480182,
-0.0602382161,
-0.0278267916,
0.07747145,
0.0558222793,
0.043469727,
0.0361394472,
-0.0620098338,
0.0002431997,
-0.0579793751,
-0.0192326996,
0.0042869542,
0.02223498,
-0.0526749529,
0.0071822694,
0.0782573074,
0.0115481438,
-0.0572323725,
-0.0079514356,
0.0462806933,
0.0028406763,
-0.0078134565,
-0.0306083821,
-0.0812840611,
0.000015435,
0.0412725322,
0.0505192615,
-0.0380375199,
-0.0596985444,
-0.0348625556,
-0.0909576267,
-0.0142057026,
-0.003987391,
-0.0355706103,
-0.0415442698,
-0.0571972281,
0.0233322289,
-0.0090847611,
0.0006635218,
-0.0365942121,
-0.0100498442,
0.0037611441,
0.0051627387,
-0.0570881739,
-0.022952402,
-0.0471186787,
-0.0430265702,
0.0164173208,
0.0570881851,
-0.0060899369,
-0.0198931731,
0.0360294282,
0.0405101143,
0.011558787,
-0.0403410234,
0.0264826026,
0.1121163741,
-0.026730014,
0.0255940203,
0.0055887634,
0.0539547689,
0.026346948,
-0.003909267,
0.0007973257,
0.0003778856,
-0.0053933887,
-0.014371655,
-0.0275138449,
0.0013579784,
-0.0160244238,
0.0669837072,
0.0183299296,
0.0128090428,
0.0072545209,
-0.0459111184,
0.0533535406,
0.0128743285,
0.0197472908,
0.004092291,
-0.0169545133,
-0.0607948564,
-0.0538204797,
-0.0068783625,
-0.024851229,
-0.0052598342,
0.0286852568,
0.026059676,
0.0356269479,
-0.005618942,
-0.0168848783,
0.0084595466,
-0.0721845701,
-0.0021606751,
-0.009603315,
-0.0032609208,
0.0219487548,
0.0103097484,
-0.0326622277,
0.0124790622,
-0.079060562,
-0.0779648945,
-0.006967654,
0.038993828,
0.0252250377,
0.0684005246,
-0.0227284171,
-0.0712698102,
0.0674921796,
0.0536153466,
-0.0038072385,
0.0048332876,
0.0343990698,
-0.023309119,
0.0008938061,
0.0377865881,
-0.054564897,
-0.0126859201,
0.0307142101,
-0.0385652967,
-0.0268958583,
-0.0331766903,
-0.0207516253,
0.0421093442,
0.0140592754,
0.0359596722,
0.0424188823,
-0.0420062505,
0.0136110289,
-0.0273918994,
-0.0197190028,
-0.0276495367,
0.0062788818,
-0.0052392753,
0.0140445679,
0.0251188409,
0.0009020416,
0.019970376,
0.0599327832,
-0.0544485822,
0.0042382288,
0.0285322983,
-0.0236044675,
-0.0128135923,
-0.0141675351,
-0.0410696268,
0.0298908371,
-0.0190646406,
0.0211514551,
-0.0031318702,
-0.0017854538,
0.0084655061,
-0.0177532285,
-0.0061705858,
0.0430514365,
-0.0891618654,
-0.024152169,
-0.0338676497,
0.0295386966,
-0.0177585222,
-0.0416425243,
0.0070669097,
-0.0235658661,
-0.0046796938,
-0.0250763837,
0.0015158246,
0.0157115422,
-0.0228716135,
0.0005657591,
0.0080788983,
-0.0103291133,
0.0507471859,
0.1173393354,
0.010340591,
0.0325472988,
-0.0109985555,
-0.0604085922,
-0.0438930877,
-0.0334089659,
0.0109030232,
0.0522063449,
-0.0234121103,
-0.0027952136,
-0.0531312972,
-0.07334584,
0.0195683949,
-0.008469726,
0.0398899578,
0.0038976062,
-0.0037545597,
0.0139810815,
0.0185358748,
-0.0246788468,
-0.077585943,
-0.0146104386,
0.0042679808,
0.0149224307,
0.0063978429,
-5.065089812e-33,
-0.01861622,
-0.0093101114,
-0.078373298,
0.0508053452,
0.0347593538,
0.0265938397,
-0.0145392036,
-0.0050282949,
-0.0143163912,
-0.0395899415,
-0.0444621593,
0.0314260013,
0.0009340085,
0.0541931204,
-0.0297129303,
-0.0170419142,
0.0448671058,
-0.0077772392,
-0.0481427535,
0.0233323574,
0.0646963045,
0.0103184376,
0.0379856788,
-0.0546194129,
0.0581720136,
-0.0125273438,
-0.0329504348,
0.0012987099,
-0.0259496178,
0.0358544439,
-0.0014606992,
-0.0163917467,
0.0170475282,
-0.0069440827,
-0.0152025027,
0.0016139494,
-0.0461680852,
-0.0240696855,
-0.0125697888,
-0.0319192261,
0.0218382012,
-0.0392239876,
0.0580433235,
-0.0240378547,
0.0255567133,
-0.0334016643,
0.0210193712,
-0.0450260229,
-0.0363924429,
-0.0510976426,
0.0176818427,
0.0290098675,
-0.0180121809,
0.0094927941,
0.0710002705,
0.0288857277,
0.0208804701,
-0.0416496135,
-0.0152632147,
0.0205563661,
0.0807656571,
0.017474724,
0.0397919528,
0.0016082335,
0.0398654565,
0.0585491173,
0.0323654898,
0.0115992529,
0.0102668926,
0.0017217438,
-0.013914614,
0.0136641515,
0.009734395,
0.0276906434,
0.0275149103,
0.011404939,
-0.0165368672,
0.0291067306,
-0.0243767016,
-0.0204019826,
0.083420828,
-0.0225425828,
-0.0522250943,
-0.0176640078,
-0.0511481389,
-0.0317298621,
-0.02083968,
0.0208673421,
-0.0218161903,
0.0313834585,
-0.0642465651,
-0.016195232,
-0.0018237571,
-0.0571529567,
-0.0178796276,
0.0367277041,
0.0426229015,
-0.0334973559,
-0.0126225883,
-0.0279036239,
-0.0311527662,
0.0274869688,
0.0027090181,
-0.0514301807,
0.0101517849,
0.0116377473,
0.0787656531,
-0.0100233741,
-0.0520869344,
-0.0132332761,
-0.0029449486,
0.0594187826,
0.0124244764,
0.0385233574,
0.0479557104,
-0.0240164082,
0.0104168635,
0.0197159145,
0.0175407603,
0.044497896,
-0.0325387828,
0.0631232411,
-0.0302020349,
-0.0386014022,
0.0140000386,
-0.0313200802,
0.0181363784,
0.0303711835,
0.0862735957,
-0.0070822076,
0.0092613995,
-0.0302415136,
2.388e-7,
0.0317716449,
-0.0115962438,
0.0166059751,
-0.0064280084,
0.0051415274,
0.0742842183,
-0.0019562636,
0.0706564113,
0.0113557316,
0.0231244192,
-0.0124883726,
-0.0017864917,
0.03486339,
0.0437030308,
-0.0658078045,
-0.0151145319,
-0.0409367643,
0.0043199146,
-0.0352051929,
-0.0282025933,
0.0058552669,
0.089910686,
0.0353703611,
-0.0053366097,
-0.0346540026,
-0.0618457235,
0.009752064,
-0.0513231568,
-0.0436277576,
0.0031694204,
0.0805664659,
0.062421795,
0.0191883668,
-0.0029560265,
-0.0408912152,
0.0181305502,
-0.0160293039,
0.0535907857,
0.0369745083,
-0.0113369776,
-0.0010316335,
-0.0534664243,
0.0040369788,
0.0023138949,
0.0635375679,
-0.0303128436,
-0.0399877466,
-0.0564767979,
-0.0103889983,
-0.056873098,
-0.0077234861,
0.0140907578,
-0.0160636883,
0.0403137095,
-0.022587914,
0.0007955555,
0.0294021834,
-0.0666975826,
-0.0366629735,
-0.0486790463,
-0.0088493628,
-0.0315667279,
0.02381186,
-0.0023131797,
-0.0302102212,
-0.0601937249,
0.0208427925,
2.599175737e-34,
0.0128893042,
-0.0092498139,
-0.0491536669,
0.0298857111,
0.0324850529,
-0.0435359403,
0.0304828845,
-0.0056729182,
-0.0142472973,
-0.0667089522,
-0.0210238658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13290v1 | Interpreting Indirect Answers to Yes-No Questions in Multiple Languages | 2023-10-20T05:43:33 | 2023-10-20T05:43:33 | Zijie Wang, Md Mosharaf Hossain, Shivam Mathur, Terry Cruz Melo, Kadir Bulut Ozler, Keun Hee Park, Jacob Quintero, MohammadHossein Rezaei, Shreya Nupur Shakya, Md Nayem Uddin, Eduardo Blanco | cs.CL | cs.CL | Yes-no questions expect a yes or no for an answer, but people often skip
polar keywords. Instead, they answer with long explanations that must be
interpreted. In this paper, we focus on this challenging problem and release
new benchmarks in eight languages. We present a distant supervision approach to
collect training data. We also demonstrate that direct answers (i.e., with
polar keywords) are useful to train models to interpret indirect answers (i.e.,
without polar keywords). Experimental results demonstrate that monolingual
fine-tuning is beneficial if training data can be obtained via distant
supervision for the language of interest (5 languages). Additionally, we show
that cross-lingual fine-tuning is always beneficial (8 languages). | [
0.083473824,
0.0135226734,
-0.0345581956,
0.0580865517,
-0.0471703336,
0.0236884467,
0.0154965287,
0.017093366,
0.0057429103,
-0.0426634848,
-0.0453613438,
-0.0535467304,
-0.0407349877,
0.0212794784,
0.0012007626,
-0.0253381878,
0.0685995743,
-0.0206909422,
0.0132546257,
-0.0376441739,
-0.0007308791,
0.0058896337,
-0.0188850686,
0.0004436625,
-0.0116687492,
0.0111382985,
-0.0575718209,
-0.0198616646,
-0.0152124222,
0.0019639302,
0.037575189,
0.059304595,
-0.0043484531,
0.0124691818,
0.0000015841,
-0.0428870358,
-0.0209535677,
-0.0320383199,
-0.0031787048,
-0.018179642,
0.0259393342,
-0.0382425413,
0.040251784,
-0.0008131902,
-0.073511824,
-0.0139034921,
0.0942550823,
0.0481451601,
0.055905018,
0.0416985191,
0.0188259203,
-0.007959879,
-0.0175467394,
-0.0216383189,
0.0387255177,
0.0166012608,
0.0145518063,
0.0050054742,
-0.0507707633,
0.0052302238,
-0.0550835282,
0.0542410947,
0.0221050549,
0.0394398011,
-0.0171428993,
0.0118750017,
-0.014003804,
-0.0629479066,
0.0110795554,
0.0762862489,
-0.0140216975,
-0.0202432778,
-0.0185123961,
-0.0092411237,
-0.0251937248,
0.0274139214,
-0.0074618533,
0.0170057211,
0.0097319251,
-0.0102851251,
0.0179119837,
0.0168132726,
-0.0354451872,
0.0050262213,
-0.0302397665,
0.0672090277,
-0.0039031627,
-0.0501007922,
0.0235630646,
0.0005259815,
-0.0273128953,
-0.0168931428,
0.0265912693,
0.0086856717,
-0.0176053047,
0.0166310035,
0.0171315838,
0.0196696594,
0.0798119083,
-0.0579322502,
0.0056587011,
0.0341497175,
-0.0543528348,
0.0416094735,
-0.0136101702,
0.021463709,
-0.0246498175,
0.0348837301,
-0.0088448869,
-0.036115054,
-0.0438171588,
-0.0129701691,
-0.0038346334,
0.0216925424,
-0.030457655,
0.030191794,
-0.0339616649,
-0.0114812236,
0.0099544758,
0.0245392714,
-0.0219937582,
0.0174351092,
-0.047436852,
0.0056112101,
-0.0452972166,
0.1012844592,
-0.0905204862,
0.0256645214,
-0.0559446961,
-0.0481762029,
0.0210027639,
0.0151654631,
0.0155352112,
-0.0283493735,
0.0282574836,
0.0778330937,
-0.0150015922,
-0.0131722959,
0.0114299702,
-0.0321342945,
-0.0254371595,
-0.0872923583,
-0.0063740145,
-0.0309740193,
0.0540561937,
0.0362615287,
-0.0249638446,
-0.0136053478,
0.036242716,
0.0048600156,
-0.0076560508,
0.071744293,
0.0366320647,
-0.0018075607,
-0.0209297556,
-0.0032438899,
0.0009266537,
0.0629392564,
-0.0149764437,
0.0263401419,
0.0795421004,
-0.0525327176,
0.0228194073,
0.0015326479,
0.0385957733,
0.0267133005,
-0.0146340067,
0.0720190331,
0.0197719,
-0.004400875,
-0.0108968904,
0.0510198511,
-0.0061714463,
-0.0562994145,
0.0687808096,
0.0168662686,
-0.0496891104,
-0.021396827,
0.0007575664,
0.029035354,
-0.0237555746,
0.0236034021,
-0.0648883879,
0.034866672,
-0.0264715385,
0.0151461642,
-0.0178204272,
0.0008115463,
-0.02911398,
-0.045013383,
0.0212324709,
-0.0088275606,
0.0330369063,
0.0456653014,
0.0757998303,
-0.0128012467,
-0.0236950461,
0.0317435302,
0.0357703753,
-0.0624794476,
0.002470514,
-0.0348179713,
0.0742657036,
-0.044324819,
-0.0337026529,
-0.0086661018,
-0.0424381644,
-0.0263864938,
0.0252873972,
0.0464494564,
0.0802235007,
-0.0252615046,
0.0752205551,
-0.0295525547,
-0.0112240529,
0.0347089767,
-0.0047443206,
0.0251629427,
0.0011073211,
0.0179800019,
0.0262436103,
-0.038490843,
-0.0178140644,
0.0236931555,
0.0131865721,
-0.0370568484,
0.0128992004,
0.0442660265,
0.0429491773,
0.0164775271,
-0.0035306178,
0.0044985311,
0.0549487993,
-0.0294618923,
-0.0181742646,
-0.0383924693,
-0.0360715799,
-0.0031761907,
0.021450704,
-0.0180379953,
-0.0372007899,
0.0240669493,
-0.0251078829,
-0.040175695,
0.0259478241,
-0.0168816783,
0.006971763,
-0.0456989594,
-0.0032385786,
-0.0316875316,
0.0142638627,
-0.0477468595,
0.0542858578,
0.0057923524,
0.0716373548,
-0.0127892066,
-0.0564019121,
0.039783854,
-0.0212275963,
-0.022913551,
0.0356868692,
-0.0205111615,
-0.011134618,
0.0474151708,
0.0303527899,
-0.0671002641,
-0.0366237611,
-0.0588798411,
-0.0018928109,
-0.0174298808,
0.0496536382,
0.0230054241,
0.0277403388,
0.0063954643,
-0.0641166493,
-0.0625528544,
-0.0081113726,
-0.0064725131,
0.0542099513,
0.0326417722,
0.0385355912,
-0.0107450802,
-0.0352219194,
-0.0261707753,
-0.0202586502,
0.0011571667,
-0.0095005482,
-0.0337210782,
-0.0123292021,
-0.0193030629,
-0.0492964424,
0.0529573187,
-0.0031910138,
-0.0562669449,
0.0134105291,
-0.0361488312,
0.023665553,
0.0690466538,
-0.0060963584,
-0.0496535264,
0.0485037901,
-0.014553518,
-0.0651651099,
0.0191115048,
-0.0483020134,
-0.0516299941,
0.0021772748,
-0.0606105663,
-0.0318545252,
0.0356700793,
0.038336277,
-0.0235465355,
-0.074369207,
-0.0111564416,
-0.0289806705,
-0.0304272603,
-0.0432029255,
0.0386635326,
0.0209714118,
0.0697692335,
0.0209041499,
-0.0329393409,
0.1049200296,
0.0106923189,
-0.0663111955,
-0.0549463853,
-0.0182544142,
-0.0345145315,
0.0709944442,
-0.0186594464,
0.0019866647,
0.0157920178,
-0.0146396086,
-0.0637376234,
-0.0679572895,
0.0406465605,
-0.0272728112,
0.0098144924,
-0.0104970327,
-0.0328170694,
-0.0292313416,
-0.0344947167,
-0.0344586298,
-0.0760279,
-0.0113720642,
-0.0108978553,
-0.0144972466,
-0.0179023128,
-0.0025681376,
0.0301221292,
0.0289849378,
-0.0134107387,
-0.051871825,
-0.0077148238,
-0.0252583288,
0.0108093284,
0.0461133644,
0.007931632,
0.0034763929,
-0.0341652669,
-0.003549153,
0.0331757776,
0.025605401,
-0.0202980638,
0.0267028473,
-0.014727707,
0.0225369409,
-0.0222955961,
-0.0178469773,
0.0256309118,
0.0372451991,
-0.0340220742,
0.0103733977,
0.0825729594,
0.0431280695,
-0.0431518517,
0.0132159954,
-0.032940194,
0.0249354318,
0.0312263723,
0.047607787,
-0.0828870833,
-0.0387826189,
-0.0412797146,
0.0170910284,
0.002419513,
-0.0156885907,
-0.0052362275,
-0.1025886387,
-0.0261342674,
-0.0130221648,
-0.0541039929,
-0.0908508077,
-0.0351876058,
-0.007551441,
-0.0001702816,
0.0021142333,
-0.0055442881,
0.0124235582,
0.0165463258,
0.0038248301,
0.0004252061,
-0.0159782767,
0.0285813604,
-0.0260913614,
0.0195874814,
0.029973682,
0.0286591686,
-0.0123654306,
-0.0223260168,
0.017440645,
-0.0305172503,
-0.0070586642,
-0.0408606939,
0.0348960012,
0.0169950742,
-0.0124721127,
0.004020825,
0.0150627717,
-0.03579285,
0.0553069189,
0.0807890892,
0.0680955127,
-0.009224196,
-0.0110042961,
0.0394315049,
0.0300006885,
0.0650086403,
0.0472376049,
0.0239621662,
-0.0191399492,
-0.0419202968,
0.0160815082,
-0.005834606,
-0.0086447801,
-0.0333404876,
-0.0365874581,
-0.0303998776,
0.0127512803,
-0.0428858995,
-0.1028603613,
0.0444442183,
0.0338709094,
0.0108696129,
0.0116716688,
0.0003346081,
-0.0035681955,
-0.0348429978,
0.0231651459,
0.0198763814,
0.0226959288,
-0.0142186387,
-0.0315324068,
0.0217755921,
-0.0102205612,
0.01792253,
-0.0404667817,
-0.0222966969,
-0.0511534959,
0.01018003,
0.0520636402,
0.0210803263,
0.0275189318,
-0.0057988702,
-0.0464127623,
-0.0530222505,
0.0511379987,
-0.048009038,
-0.0079435818,
0.075097926,
0.0491537414,
-0.0006631191,
0.0707596838,
-0.0136916284,
0.0029404061,
0.0205525812,
0.0369998328,
-0.0616773553,
-0.0055326875,
0.0245782305,
0.0140862055,
0.0445495248,
0.0126092881,
-0.0110429423,
-0.0134575292,
0.0485761985,
-0.0119996006,
-0.030783413,
-0.0127028897,
-0.0116472337,
0.0000782117,
-0.0539698489,
-0.0079321787,
-0.00604686,
-0.0417594872,
0.0048315539,
-0.0252404157,
0.0334650204,
0.069563508,
0.0186020583,
-0.0122373225,
0.0209909715,
-0.0396018177,
0.0330613106,
0.0465121083,
0.0740503594,
0.0086024422,
0.0887961984,
0.0094251959,
-0.0018295851,
-0.0071947509,
-0.0226333179,
-0.0362224504,
-0.0389560089,
0.0396523699,
0.0230533779,
0.0102043264,
0.0142599614,
0.0185403526,
-0.0144204218,
-0.0098120784,
-0.0039066789,
0.0522354059,
0.0057600774,
-0.0149980327,
0.0597613491,
0.0125799607,
-0.0211414676,
0.0310025681,
0.0584511347,
0.0002593368,
0.0066228849,
0.0155508816,
0.0132477051,
-0.0398419388,
0.0315787047,
0.0557854064,
-0.0115751326,
-0.0121253971,
0.0471054204,
-0.0483166724,
-0.0662245974,
-0.0298590194,
0.0017097102,
-0.0215856321,
-0.0083634248,
0.0103250975,
0.0421441905,
0.0206778254,
-0.0412409119,
-0.0703528523,
0.0768825039,
-0.0213114023,
0.0080632744,
-0.0598977879,
-6.169895076e-33,
-0.0248040464,
-0.0158265978,
-0.0230837073,
-0.000315753,
0.0255968869,
-0.0013994464,
-0.0042197737,
0.0121600023,
-0.0324337967,
0.0052369004,
-0.0092922729,
0.0067429473,
0.0161593184,
0.0041619902,
0.0251394063,
-0.0471547134,
0.0396161973,
0.000330712,
-0.0130948955,
0.0292655658,
0.0438874364,
0.0090250131,
0.0538000353,
-0.1185933277,
0.0829191655,
-0.0277716741,
-0.0071986867,
0.0523202382,
-0.0353205018,
0.05351815,
-0.0270883329,
0.0450805053,
-0.0007758872,
-0.0173230078,
0.0118831927,
0.0259432271,
-0.0656578466,
-0.0587496981,
0.0252851006,
0.0479821526,
-0.0810712352,
0.0127995266,
-0.0110991104,
-0.0455500893,
0.0259246621,
0.0497592203,
0.0108743552,
-0.0064985384,
-0.0184715576,
-0.02843027,
-0.027048938,
0.0043057958,
0.0015360069,
-0.0132961962,
0.0041930904,
0.1129152849,
-0.0086683286,
-0.0250087753,
-0.0132603645,
0.0099274293,
0.0043033585,
0.0347307101,
0.0383470543,
-0.004334481,
-0.0094359117,
0.0235900786,
0.0534644946,
-0.0111669628,
0.0323516801,
-0.0229049847,
0.0205748696,
0.0037472891,
0.0704958215,
0.0556154028,
0.020889502,
0.0170644224,
-0.0309610553,
-0.0115161669,
0.0611559004,
0.0359139666,
0.0273984149,
-0.029263638,
-0.0494017154,
-0.0220910218,
-0.0546428971,
-0.0031297335,
-0.0547722876,
-0.0324703678,
0.0585524924,
-0.0082691768,
-0.0431539267,
0.0023459522,
0.0416191034,
-0.0564471558,
0.0074233739,
0.0224059075,
0.0123485047,
-0.0149267185,
0.0238326062,
0.0127762174,
-0.0405456349,
-0.0040902221,
-0.0038555558,
-0.0407575779,
-0.0043497588,
-0.0116624739,
0.0640350655,
-0.0105956858,
-0.0774000734,
-0.0088139484,
0.025551483,
0.0172607619,
-0.011077893,
0.0411105677,
0.0073347585,
0.0113270609,
-0.0345542952,
0.0664128959,
0.0296137277,
0.0004878178,
-0.0376724862,
-0.0090372683,
-0.0024076712,
0.0505853184,
-0.0459984392,
-0.0073317126,
-0.0442790091,
0.0009889656,
-0.0081864344,
-0.0216167793,
-0.013961887,
0.0472815484,
2.298e-7,
0.0296232793,
0.0291631706,
0.0116570517,
0.0060555227,
-0.0045213909,
0.0671099946,
-0.0066794716,
0.0078554368,
0.0455875583,
0.0190853346,
-0.0139216613,
-0.0213286113,
0.0261722356,
0.0106768515,
-0.0604364797,
-0.0084679909,
-0.0163168665,
-0.0077672019,
-0.0440800749,
0.0339064226,
0.0625455752,
0.0754174814,
-0.0010371344,
0.01965959,
-0.0461599827,
-0.0176120494,
0.0383115001,
-0.0114432909,
-0.0242465902,
-0.0022258149,
-0.0003219112,
-0.0475788377,
0.0107771521,
0.0943897814,
0.0093853706,
-0.014606392,
-0.0288763959,
0.0494227968,
0.0028428549,
-0.0567750223,
-0.0108459312,
0.0098848492,
-0.0093429312,
-0.0433697999,
0.092357263,
-0.0772540942,
-0.0373930819,
-0.004588366,
-0.0010707591,
0.0079196077,
0.0441637039,
-0.0158217736,
-0.0402261168,
0.0154310018,
0.0373614505,
-0.0076852199,
-0.0273498017,
-0.0193449035,
-0.0082770949,
-0.0139440792,
0.0308438055,
-0.0610230267,
0.0112448791,
0.0456057936,
0.0008239246,
-0.0138949072,
-0.0103342272,
1.837502349e-34,
0.0237137489,
-0.0055206623,
0.0344026908,
0.0061963336,
0.0428521633,
-0.0332081616,
-0.0571053587,
0.0185377859,
0.0759357512,
-0.0562350079,
-0.0195165277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13289v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13289v2 | SALMONN: Towards Generic Hearing Abilities for Large Language Models | 2023-10-20T05:41:57 | 2024-04-08T06:12:52 | Changli Tang, Wenyi Yu, Guangzhi Sun, Xianzhao Chen, Tian Tan, Wei Li, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma, Chao Zhang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Hearing is arguably an essential ability of artificial intelligence (AI)
agents in the physical world, which refers to the perception and understanding
of general auditory information consisting of at least three types of sounds:
speech, audio events, and music. In this paper, we propose SALMONN, a speech
audio language music open neural network, built by integrating a pre-trained
text-based large language model (LLM) with speech and audio encoders into a
single multimodal model. SALMONN enables the LLM to directly process and
understand general audio inputs and achieve competitive performances on a
number of speech and audio tasks used in training, such as automatic speech
recognition and translation, auditory-information-based question answering,
emotion recognition, speaker verification, and music and audio captioning etc.
SALMONN also has a diverse set of emergent abilities unseen in the training,
which includes but is not limited to speech translation to untrained languages,
speech-based slot filling, spoken-query-based question answering, audio-based
storytelling, and speech audio co-reasoning etc. The presence of cross-modal
emergent abilities is studied, and a novel few-shot activation tuning approach
is proposed to activate such abilities. To our knowledge, SALMONN is the first
model of its type and can be regarded as a step towards AI with generic hearing
abilities. The source code, model checkpoints and data are available at
https://github.com/bytedance/SALMONN. | [
-0.018432809,
0.035323184,
-0.0114768501,
0.0555393286,
-0.0099429628,
-0.0276827067,
0.0307005513,
-0.044155214,
-0.0415886454,
0.0094122337,
-0.0909576863,
0.0229268018,
-0.0117186764,
0.0493528843,
0.0296370331,
-0.0058316947,
0.029746104,
-0.0445561111,
0.0195555482,
-0.0315760039,
-0.0290304925,
0.0116376616,
-0.0590418987,
0.0260421298,
0.0420792885,
-0.001259461,
-0.038216047,
0.0172790606,
-0.014228493,
0.0123740556,
-0.0453885384,
0.0061897188,
0.0322488919,
0.0204397645,
0.0000017466,
-0.0448494069,
0.0555578396,
-0.0152658364,
-0.0123121627,
-0.0109459283,
-0.0369863249,
0.0048112022,
-0.0316944234,
0.0156546663,
0.0043606348,
-0.0218695067,
0.0188868493,
0.0198320895,
0.0453578234,
0.0725399926,
-0.0009885652,
-0.0840865076,
0.0674978197,
-0.0189605244,
0.0510702506,
-0.0372885279,
-0.0022399216,
-0.021686865,
0.0279532317,
0.0019342006,
-0.0089569082,
0.0575104319,
0.0276757441,
0.0151037583,
0.0014395247,
0.0377210192,
-0.0318320468,
-0.0193395969,
-0.0231974348,
0.0893072188,
0.0203819256,
-0.0328679755,
-0.0033289238,
0.0046792519,
-0.0053174533,
-0.0424216203,
-0.0470943414,
0.0275459513,
0.0479972847,
0.0186053142,
-0.0218843371,
0.0023933526,
0.0472692177,
0.0042818342,
0.0224937648,
0.0228638668,
0.0148903541,
-0.039939139,
0.0340918824,
-0.0555825569,
-0.0044162632,
-0.040520817,
0.0293884408,
0.0437475741,
-0.0138349924,
-0.0157538913,
-0.0284717716,
0.0075710518,
-0.0188785456,
-0.0366263017,
0.0242475476,
0.029898582,
-0.0566625595,
0.0759655312,
-0.0425571911,
0.0381384343,
-0.032453388,
-0.0018288197,
0.0058255913,
-0.027352782,
-0.0323388912,
-0.0322504118,
-0.0354344696,
-0.0122710671,
0.010012174,
-0.0552209467,
-0.0005192394,
0.0020761078,
-0.0354466699,
0.009376293,
0.0072937612,
-0.0072882022,
-0.0128665613,
-0.0245603565,
0.012733114,
0.0326582529,
-0.0268439259,
0.0658175722,
-0.0168281794,
-0.0194714181,
-0.0063731382,
0.0282057952,
0.0411076322,
-0.0102437967,
0.049060788,
0.0527011454,
0.0193887912,
-0.0071741324,
-0.0267632119,
-0.0041419691,
-0.0190572999,
-0.0538038202,
-0.0127571495,
-0.0578681305,
0.0530602485,
-0.0410173386,
-0.0145608736,
-0.0172965284,
-0.0189761315,
0.0148446457,
-0.0164118037,
0.0516166762,
0.0245886985,
0.0540633723,
0.0329133309,
-0.0102182571,
0.0453727841,
0.0410672091,
0.0866240487,
-0.0147070615,
0.038001202,
-0.0263310038,
-0.007016975,
0.0676042363,
0.0082646515,
-0.0676876083,
-0.0094967624,
-0.023479877,
-0.0309825707,
0.0719463155,
0.0257713608,
0.022428073,
-0.0116225407,
-0.0362031572,
0.0617530048,
0.0137892794,
0.056158103,
0.0195789654,
0.0298074707,
-0.0185439959,
0.0151008647,
0.0017433496,
-0.0001317102,
0.0684957877,
-0.0059090815,
0.0296721905,
0.0420745127,
-0.0012349049,
-0.0414875224,
0.020769788,
0.008459324,
-0.0013948662,
-0.0277166106,
0.0305524301,
0.0420209058,
0.0188898426,
-0.0316967554,
0.0182498936,
-0.0023276957,
-0.0402502976,
0.0090653654,
-0.0340676084,
0.0282470044,
0.0132397367,
0.0203172695,
-0.063601166,
0.031445235,
-0.0139718717,
-0.0095249545,
0.0506790243,
0.0407641903,
-0.0201729443,
0.0420052782,
-0.0325937346,
0.0032749579,
-0.0003831721,
-0.0127060683,
0.0430403389,
-0.0511607677,
0.0383467078,
-0.0180000253,
-0.0134576755,
0.0470482558,
0.004552844,
-0.0214425903,
-0.0574915111,
0.0058323974,
0.0364424214,
0.0360776782,
0.0583988726,
-0.0407411754,
0.0056294301,
0.0229227655,
-0.0351408347,
0.0236003306,
0.0361079276,
-0.080346711,
0.0126600582,
0.033416003,
-0.025433274,
0.0173469577,
0.0379739217,
0.0208969321,
-0.0439795852,
0.067846112,
0.0055481591,
0.0075790025,
-0.0471630096,
-0.0081800688,
-0.0122341681,
0.0141017726,
0.0379577167,
0.003435699,
0.0414783433,
-0.0130498596,
-0.0237813089,
0.01823733,
0.0262991823,
-0.0582495555,
-0.0724147856,
0.0699299425,
0.0063160877,
0.0162701011,
-0.0229486227,
-0.0341841318,
-0.0287205689,
-0.0201503616,
-0.1013110802,
0.02226617,
-0.0249030702,
-0.0022057772,
-0.0062155314,
0.0043444065,
-0.0095133502,
-0.0099043874,
-0.0400613286,
0.0314616002,
0.0188766904,
0.006006714,
-0.052448824,
0.0100214211,
-0.0237681903,
-0.0010023898,
-0.026177451,
-0.0047041001,
0.018275639,
-0.0079271486,
0.0021656596,
-0.0196517352,
-0.0145052411,
-0.0157961622,
0.0376694053,
-0.0082052443,
-0.0157977883,
-0.0171098597,
-0.0433960557,
0.028682299,
0.0581246093,
-0.0324388184,
-0.0340277329,
0.0691152588,
0.0005892565,
-0.0222300589,
0.0456756614,
0.0341559164,
0.0054841042,
-0.0516704693,
0.0585471727,
-0.0216004625,
0.035273198,
0.0473975688,
0.0036097907,
-0.006148539,
-0.002965627,
-0.0043621096,
-0.0434417613,
-0.0569224358,
-0.0545410812,
-0.0475823246,
0.0580026433,
-0.0159642193,
0.0074898801,
0.0436118655,
-0.0351163745,
-0.0391228199,
-0.0285271499,
-0.0403449051,
-0.0349300355,
0.0526686311,
-0.0133080035,
0.0313315913,
0.0100611961,
-0.0416145585,
-0.052357275,
0.0057771252,
0.0268309433,
-0.045473516,
-0.0007909172,
0.0153308315,
-0.0149739673,
0.0107871927,
-0.0262879077,
-0.0129241198,
-0.0118226474,
-0.0225888174,
0.0503638126,
-0.0628834441,
0.0114925392,
-0.0334176458,
0.005633533,
0.0373850502,
0.0596929826,
0.000810019,
0.0097554969,
-0.0332149602,
0.0562263317,
0.000663405,
0.01729092,
-0.0280922167,
-0.0341111943,
0.0575787313,
-0.018268764,
0.0193234291,
0.0123219909,
-0.0422212221,
0.0343098566,
0.0288253687,
0.0096483473,
-0.0125052761,
0.0433099158,
0.030645147,
-0.0637540817,
0.0089263171,
0.1039782986,
0.0183984078,
-0.0322947204,
-0.0111291325,
0.0270151403,
0.0018736258,
0.0114276977,
0.0321709961,
-0.0529211499,
-0.0243888982,
0.047799591,
0.0281399917,
0.0392130092,
0.0157676674,
-0.0122690303,
-0.0772851184,
0.0441176854,
0.0101614082,
-0.0684274361,
-0.0866136178,
-0.0032107832,
-0.0032507493,
-0.0065394002,
0.0271283165,
0.0277509708,
0.0020658786,
-0.0216758251,
-0.0037802474,
0.0048528109,
-0.0553969964,
0.0322220437,
-0.0763222724,
0.0675506964,
0.0615039021,
0.0422094278,
-0.0636932403,
-0.030021552,
0.0197072122,
-0.0217798818,
0.0051223435,
0.0368788876,
0.0403671414,
0.0079047941,
-0.012292074,
0.0356112532,
0.0456683375,
-0.0303048976,
-0.0354202799,
0.0010072562,
0.0613861643,
0.007202697,
-0.0048498902,
0.00616749,
0.0499631055,
0.0027376439,
0.077391617,
0.0308840759,
-0.0616422817,
-0.0056452728,
-0.0053359871,
-0.0114589734,
-0.0625914633,
-0.0376981981,
0.0083130961,
0.0349793956,
-0.0594552159,
-0.0227098931,
0.0106089339,
-0.0270392653,
0.0336627699,
0.0397687592,
-0.024094725,
0.0128656803,
-0.0140978778,
-0.0338266231,
0.0294914041,
0.004665459,
0.0586144403,
-0.032264296,
-0.0129695134,
0.058401566,
-0.074834533,
-0.0238941684,
0.0262767244,
-0.0637994111,
-0.0441825278,
-0.0152394874,
-0.0317405052,
0.0202077907,
0.0371364951,
-0.0285873711,
-0.0783240497,
0.0281941034,
0.0003257697,
-0.0263391975,
0.0593101531,
0.0418200344,
-0.029852502,
-0.0101147136,
0.0137388986,
-0.0672309548,
0.0271321665,
0.0247812681,
0.0146756601,
0.0317427218,
-0.0182928815,
0.0002054057,
-0.0267912019,
0.0349085256,
0.0232353173,
0.0335827954,
-0.1047282964,
0.0115524977,
0.00292921,
0.0255458821,
-0.0214033872,
-0.0061156545,
0.023534026,
0.0365321003,
-0.029222792,
-0.0099495864,
0.0497443862,
-0.0214255843,
-0.0495582074,
0.0577127635,
0.0597628281,
-0.0246519893,
-0.0189948622,
0.0018189464,
0.0009106221,
0.0502741821,
-0.0138947535,
0.0194980875,
0.0096481657,
0.0436213724,
-0.0103963679,
-0.021734301,
-0.0015701309,
0.0135213071,
-0.0760718063,
-0.036133118,
0.0172597449,
0.0468308888,
0.0663143471,
-0.0095806606,
-0.0083330404,
0.014166561,
-0.004667283,
-0.0195575375,
0.0218351781,
-0.0204292461,
-0.0152048571,
0.0070571904,
0.0288811568,
0.0011658324,
0.0053578443,
0.0133418189,
-0.0292504802,
0.0389827341,
-0.0538193658,
0.0540810339,
-0.0158955846,
-0.0112144556,
-0.0457857326,
0.0579021536,
-0.0308668986,
0.0416530073,
0.0052965651,
-0.060287375,
-0.0046555693,
0.0540542044,
0.0235974118,
-0.0065916907,
0.0116301877,
0.0454686843,
0.0059126853,
-0.0014803057,
0.0158284754,
-0.0509495661,
-0.0241595469,
-0.0362791754,
0.0105734216,
-5.083948782e-33,
-0.0374847054,
0.0416641347,
-0.0196746476,
0.008973835,
-0.0298861936,
-0.0122599946,
-0.0751052946,
-0.0044046631,
-0.0331409015,
-0.0103463829,
0.0121672433,
0.0137593849,
0.0039332234,
-0.0034771236,
0.006008693,
-0.0223568548,
0.0551351421,
-0.0417485535,
0.0089856694,
0.0218446404,
0.0486136265,
0.0261788722,
0.0073840623,
-0.0460981727,
-0.0329951197,
-0.0008595781,
-0.0329416916,
0.0075675379,
-0.0250751171,
0.0740841627,
-0.0153298071,
0.0237090513,
-0.0034961358,
-0.0179006774,
-0.0164013579,
0.0463236459,
-0.1031576693,
-0.0058559338,
-0.0148300333,
0.0667284802,
-0.0256975126,
-0.0267050378,
0.0686993301,
-0.0058943853,
-0.0237694774,
-0.0220570061,
0.0358861089,
-0.0035607023,
0.0142369587,
-0.0528316163,
-0.0359639041,
-0.0078467689,
-0.0476909876,
-0.0389135256,
0.0353302881,
0.0463268273,
-0.0087879719,
0.0270962901,
-0.0565984175,
0.0586873367,
-0.0381142721,
0.0003788907,
0.0325147547,
0.0342679285,
-0.0002728202,
0.0501761846,
0.0644067451,
-0.0619990826,
-0.0244063959,
0.0042867716,
0.0440083966,
0.0317323022,
0.0200579241,
0.0173558574,
0.0280785058,
-0.0077571361,
-0.0341912992,
-0.0335731879,
0.0289198011,
-0.011745845,
0.0332465768,
0.0479449145,
-0.0319988802,
0.0091667389,
-0.0623940863,
-0.0634663478,
-0.0674265698,
-0.0064301202,
0.0525725484,
-0.0234385561,
0.0468033664,
-0.0161890537,
0.0370234922,
-0.0609456785,
0.0291540548,
0.0326816365,
-0.0164986998,
0.0252855942,
-0.0274396986,
0.0297236796,
-0.0526459999,
-0.0110217528,
0.0625046566,
-0.0056946031,
0.0557359383,
0.0037486332,
-0.0045474246,
0.0762992129,
-0.0525969379,
-0.0123115657,
-0.00923423,
-0.0216363408,
0.0658526495,
0.0552632697,
0.0036704252,
0.007373258,
-0.0219458286,
0.0448228121,
-0.0203248784,
0.005018882,
-0.0552517846,
-0.0590614974,
-0.0271339826,
0.0327004753,
-0.0402624235,
-0.0087155569,
0.0016938455,
-0.0228234176,
-0.0005212566,
-0.0406289361,
-0.0159093421,
0.0529952496,
2.748e-7,
-0.0191849079,
-0.0140989469,
-0.0108641284,
0.0051849117,
0.0628926903,
0.0161265563,
-0.0581664331,
0.0268430896,
0.0121246465,
-0.0124801556,
0.0362162367,
0.024181297,
0.0789504424,
0.0151741998,
-0.1410641521,
0.0223198049,
-0.0732455254,
0.0338250101,
-0.0592268333,
-0.017603403,
0.0434962399,
0.1079839468,
0.0229213294,
-0.0320743583,
0.0158857144,
-0.0591144525,
0.0181358904,
-0.001042306,
0.010061712,
-0.0497780479,
-0.005957874,
0.0045485292,
-0.0346066877,
0.0028482019,
-0.0356268622,
0.0752277151,
0.02697712,
0.035364978,
0.0380821787,
-0.0509814806,
-0.0121632349,
0.0564220361,
-0.0306163412,
-0.0279181115,
0.101029329,
-0.0066714752,
-0.0795923322,
-0.0340786055,
-0.0140984934,
-0.0155369174,
0.0014548547,
-0.0025373534,
0.007656645,
-0.0457401127,
0.0116605256,
-0.0292620752,
-0.0105084712,
-0.0741656721,
0.0083387513,
0.0352911241,
-0.0819527954,
-0.034340173,
0.0098879626,
-0.0506207086,
0.0427372679,
-0.0429892279,
-0.0159718264,
1.673485186e-34,
0.0279682018,
-0.0331629068,
0.0201460999,
-0.0203432888,
0.0082939155,
0.0004136171,
0.0078357467,
-0.0240247287,
0.01517253,
-0.0728520304,
-0.0366547145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13276v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13276v2 | InvGC: Robust Cross-Modal Retrieval by Inverse Graph Convolution | 2023-10-20T04:45:44 | 2023-10-25T00:46:42 | Xiangru Jian, Yimu Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | Over recent decades, significant advancements in cross-modal retrieval are
mainly driven by breakthroughs in visual and linguistic modeling. However, a
recent study shows that multi-modal data representations tend to cluster within
a limited convex cone (as representation degeneration problem), which hinders
retrieval performance due to the inseparability of these representations. In
our study, we first empirically validate the presence of the representation
degeneration problem across multiple cross-modal benchmarks and methods. Next,
to address it, we introduce a novel method, called InvGC, a post-processing
technique inspired by graph convolution and average pooling. Specifically,
InvGC defines the graph topology within the datasets and then applies graph
convolution in a subtractive manner. This method effectively separates
representations by increasing the distances between data points. To improve the
efficiency and effectiveness of InvGC, we propose an advanced graph topology,
LocalAdj, which only aims to increase the distances between each data point and
its nearest neighbors. To understand why InvGC works, we present a detailed
theoretical analysis, proving that the lower bound of recall will be improved
after deploying InvGC. Extensive empirical results show that InvGC and InvGC
w/LocalAdj significantly mitigate the representation degeneration problem,
thereby enhancing retrieval performance.
Our code is available at
https://github.com/yimuwangcs/Better_Cross_Modal_Retrieval | [
-0.0104642026,
0.0067927432,
0.0146720679,
0.0356966332,
-0.0280827805,
-0.0075136772,
-0.0151292738,
0.0209422242,
0.044391349,
-0.0280852262,
-0.0535981432,
-0.0310142189,
-0.0137423333,
0.0045526009,
0.0176831167,
-0.0327823237,
0.0494146645,
0.0297745839,
-0.0173121523,
-0.0270400587,
0.0120475432,
-0.0186401214,
0.0447209254,
0.030816108,
-0.0112991864,
-0.0032840415,
-0.0119989906,
0.0333406851,
0.0095450561,
-0.0420477204,
0.0076430095,
0.0078408755,
0.0466955788,
-0.0074360706,
0.0000020672,
0.0231696907,
-0.0282348413,
-0.0031517097,
0.0452380292,
-0.0199513715,
0.0372843705,
-0.0240272768,
0.0426863022,
-0.0270543993,
-0.0045236768,
-0.0486633107,
0.0337275565,
0.0564128682,
0.0524923727,
0.0508487709,
-0.0304356981,
-0.0242122523,
0.0320233442,
-0.0139583619,
0.0345371813,
-0.0466560572,
-0.004852253,
0.0299011245,
0.0205462258,
0.0109735783,
-0.0362349078,
0.0485118553,
-0.0132589377,
0.0262166318,
0.0199893136,
0.0080382135,
0.0125237256,
0.0154570919,
-0.0126054119,
0.0801705942,
0.0075834007,
-0.0280616842,
-0.0063842628,
0.0186772756,
0.0011630594,
0.0397662818,
-0.0720891654,
-0.0385217778,
-0.0280791111,
-0.0016974538,
-0.1185685694,
0.007764895,
0.0243705995,
-0.017595714,
0.0213639457,
-0.0126807243,
0.0199545119,
0.0102691026,
-0.0226986296,
0.0126160514,
-0.0265108682,
0.0429402329,
0.0300148837,
-0.014569236,
-0.0039791903,
-0.0429625399,
-0.0053430516,
-0.0301635973,
0.018172862,
0.0183080621,
0.0507767573,
0.0153464349,
-0.0824356005,
0.0576024726,
-0.0294254906,
0.0369138084,
-0.0666578636,
0.0923225358,
-0.0454964489,
-0.0299286917,
-0.0565972291,
0.001011494,
-0.0154218003,
0.0129654035,
-0.0158293508,
-0.0214242674,
-0.027330311,
0.0128774345,
-0.0341545939,
-0.0535293818,
0.0136233605,
0.0501863062,
-0.0268553328,
-0.034444496,
0.0247142594,
0.0568232611,
0.0028069625,
0.02010726,
-0.0208147652,
-0.0198566169,
0.0083095152,
-0.0140375691,
0.0427887477,
0.00078073,
0.0220005661,
0.0510406233,
-0.0472505055,
-0.0266458951,
-0.0145642608,
-0.0178222414,
-0.0418951847,
-0.0555828586,
0.0554878116,
-0.0384558477,
0.0193385053,
0.0184415523,
-0.0030143182,
-0.0316668674,
-0.0113576092,
-0.0127954194,
-0.0277987905,
0.0579643548,
0.0313758291,
0.0003367103,
0.0451108627,
-0.0030332685,
0.0070884661,
0.0283562616,
-0.0037026901,
0.0181256365,
0.0227185898,
0.0352700837,
-0.0091100223,
-0.0218734238,
0.0468486734,
0.0016530021,
-0.032804288,
-0.0088376505,
-0.0223473627,
-0.0163261574,
0.0089287348,
0.0677168742,
-0.0654806197,
-0.0906027406,
0.0193767101,
0.0319672152,
0.0038121205,
0.0059088934,
-0.0287417732,
0.0114816641,
-0.0462040938,
-0.0100538861,
-0.0309074651,
0.0577513985,
-0.0342117958,
-0.0197993387,
0.0229864586,
-0.0071660317,
-0.0269874483,
-0.0026943206,
0.0325332135,
-0.0061158165,
0.0733550638,
0.0129354494,
0.0371299796,
-0.0297168996,
-0.0065361783,
0.0043565361,
0.0407029986,
-0.0503614619,
-0.0242955629,
-0.0127053605,
-0.0219257157,
-0.0012053867,
-0.0099521987,
-0.0304689743,
0.0044506192,
0.0215428602,
0.019147845,
-0.0502141379,
0.0023532272,
-0.0038493024,
0.0117343962,
-0.0353642181,
-0.060659606,
-0.0077452641,
-0.0193843897,
0.0425204448,
-0.0186556857,
-0.0089867916,
0.0366628766,
-0.0745193139,
0.0665132999,
-0.0060906843,
0.0734071732,
0.037507128,
0.0183238499,
0.0232140701,
-0.0087672779,
0.0101382732,
0.0015296608,
0.0187670756,
0.0462269671,
-0.0266816225,
-0.0088503892,
0.0037611972,
-0.0345686413,
-0.0320665613,
0.0502988175,
-0.0689619929,
0.01330161,
0.0307106543,
0.0088726087,
-0.0409875922,
0.064115487,
-0.0419228114,
0.0547161549,
-0.0198470578,
-0.008468424,
0.0100235464,
-0.0052983258,
-0.0149260648,
0.0516012162,
-0.0180346034,
-0.0126970336,
0.0059804404,
0.0337267779,
0.0383773968,
-0.0485240929,
-0.0169024244,
0.0443375446,
-0.0234948564,
0.0273372326,
0.0391725823,
-0.0287925694,
-0.0452675186,
0.0210009199,
-0.1194842905,
-0.0212982334,
-0.02525842,
-0.0318448953,
-0.0236000866,
0.0091857137,
0.0034045328,
-0.0866108909,
-0.0310054347,
0.0529965982,
0.0027175918,
0.0459537432,
-0.0111795804,
0.0079132104,
0.010817836,
0.0026436693,
-0.0419511423,
0.0035149718,
0.0497596636,
-0.0294506662,
-0.0458614342,
-0.0062388838,
0.043398723,
-0.0394996405,
0.0417815968,
-0.0316995308,
0.0088595059,
0.0002996821,
-0.0377249122,
0.0106246555,
0.0459849723,
-0.0051020714,
-0.0157298427,
0.0219285302,
-0.0167733021,
-0.035849236,
0.0055083144,
-0.0211646818,
-0.0251654126,
0.0093399426,
0.0204997007,
-0.0656493455,
-0.0271849893,
0.017351767,
0.0162315872,
-0.0269436538,
-0.0379171707,
0.0152833052,
-0.0037221052,
-0.0624089055,
0.026002463,
-0.0032030453,
-0.0026903583,
-0.0637438297,
-0.0192446467,
0.0573517159,
0.0063733459,
-0.0043848059,
0.0203097016,
0.0010628649,
-0.0056991489,
0.102462247,
0.0055202213,
0.0355265923,
0.0198852941,
-0.0354835577,
-0.0689147264,
0.0004585719,
0.0450854897,
-0.0406338423,
0.0467271172,
0.0269926731,
0.0414561257,
-0.0127366874,
-0.0559970364,
0.008571188,
-0.0553606935,
0.0199267976,
0.0083214566,
-0.0334898345,
-0.0055002291,
-0.0204658937,
0.0106098913,
0.0038933069,
0.0152061973,
-0.0273609292,
0.0008949667,
0.0044677523,
0.0708839744,
-0.0182832014,
0.0187728889,
-0.0602387674,
-0.0116432495,
-0.0511050224,
0.0679273084,
0.036390014,
-0.0361045077,
-0.0373662598,
0.0379585065,
0.0213812217,
0.0882802084,
-0.0465118065,
-0.0002664307,
0.0680750832,
-0.0241065975,
0.0017492075,
-0.0127353845,
-0.0185573623,
-0.1126812845,
-0.0533949025,
0.0511088893,
0.0198305678,
0.0410930775,
-0.0087557519,
-0.0374129526,
-0.0415483899,
-0.0079630744,
0.0380187519,
0.0470069312,
0.0027527516,
0.0354115628,
-0.0539637282,
0.0381084457,
0.0156812649,
-0.0085801436,
-0.0724203661,
-0.0613419563,
0.0090722619,
0.0029447025,
0.004725738,
-0.0051020267,
-0.0318700224,
-0.0427349731,
0.0355119221,
0.0371213481,
-0.0097720772,
-0.0009733246,
-0.019423699,
-0.0206177756,
-0.0050736968,
0.0237834007,
0.0246173721,
-0.0745361447,
0.0197818633,
-0.0111339847,
0.0064236056,
-0.0171903353,
0.0642332584,
0.000369708,
-0.0171253271,
-0.0036930437,
0.0127029391,
-0.0045603658,
-0.0284095462,
-0.060937345,
0.0495086946,
0.0122797899,
0.065261133,
-0.035152141,
-0.0133645609,
0.0015467659,
0.0197991505,
-0.0202689413,
0.0188227873,
-0.0307285935,
-0.0187021289,
0.076350905,
0.0133443438,
-0.036719773,
0.0083986232,
-0.0111746285,
-0.0182829555,
-0.0318087935,
0.0005951956,
-0.033411976,
0.0489760488,
-0.0391160771,
-0.0342235826,
-0.0374619216,
0.0119242352,
-0.0961255804,
0.0465073846,
-0.0409628339,
0.0242150351,
-0.0000993996,
0.010657127,
0.0356701612,
-0.0280318651,
-0.0290910713,
0.0008032854,
-0.0949166268,
-0.0786283463,
-0.0121620232,
-0.0038794046,
0.0015843101,
0.0653614029,
0.0411160775,
-0.0265123136,
0.0714813098,
0.0262726396,
-0.0316664875,
0.0191462431,
0.0370054394,
-0.0208989959,
-0.0312050581,
0.0250427201,
-0.0891189575,
0.0013012586,
0.0504990481,
0.0259427894,
-0.0331937633,
-0.0112010753,
0.042921938,
0.037101239,
0.0812274441,
0.0146994535,
0.0133230016,
-0.0401352458,
-0.0190686714,
0.0036102463,
-0.0101647442,
-0.0180457793,
0.0005555181,
0.0246741399,
-0.0505321659,
0.0035799001,
0.0453755818,
0.0564720742,
0.0404695123,
-0.0411961712,
0.0120749194,
0.0209004786,
-0.0048074969,
0.0020565917,
0.0311804693,
-0.0183771886,
0.0193709023,
0.0395740271,
0.0124182291,
-0.0183518697,
0.0362799913,
0.0042137275,
-0.0336441249,
-0.1227603629,
0.0336376987,
-0.083369568,
0.023828974,
-0.0072093229,
0.0300201159,
0.0565131344,
0.0215483494,
0.025472831,
0.0167324357,
-0.0262405518,
-0.0531532429,
0.0224028043,
0.0007142656,
-0.0160666518,
0.0296691786,
0.0059204162,
0.0102863731,
0.0406249426,
0.0514055863,
-0.0356824435,
0.0119895134,
-0.0316447578,
-0.0318267867,
-0.0369526707,
-0.0056679184,
0.0571174249,
0.0334084816,
-0.0037208707,
-0.0425877199,
0.0011631696,
-0.0515404604,
0.0285700895,
-0.0122659197,
-0.0052602226,
0.0313463844,
0.0269186217,
0.0642278641,
0.0333823487,
-0.0144381952,
-0.0348970853,
-0.0047795698,
0.0190721639,
0.0122376783,
-0.0150269447,
-6.260948133e-33,
0.0032969785,
0.0112648867,
-0.0282533467,
-0.0374098346,
-0.0356609076,
0.0208352171,
-0.0400705971,
0.0377604291,
-0.0161223374,
0.013277417,
-0.0124442885,
0.024573382,
0.0203334913,
0.0053475569,
-0.0213186387,
-0.0313007571,
0.0634532794,
-0.0146183791,
0.0066233268,
0.0385778137,
0.0638898388,
0.046908997,
0.0101125129,
-0.1350229234,
-0.005959671,
0.0131654292,
0.0020976025,
-0.011705419,
0.0606274642,
0.0607119016,
-0.0031274864,
0.0393464193,
0.0112850349,
0.0240172707,
-0.0125906561,
0.0193772409,
-0.0479246266,
0.0177930426,
-0.0516485572,
-0.0025476366,
-0.0321854092,
-0.0050651664,
0.0503119975,
-0.0235898569,
-0.0081034936,
-0.0494274236,
0.0351645984,
0.0088220416,
-0.0482428968,
0.0208761692,
0.0182161238,
0.02467677,
-0.0189864468,
-0.0313978344,
0.0397084281,
0.0196339972,
0.0518458374,
0.0193679091,
-0.02362247,
0.055271931,
-0.1298426241,
0.0017376324,
0.0175189376,
0.0535534434,
0.0035008024,
0.077016525,
0.0673321262,
-0.0119219301,
0.0142648704,
-0.0400608927,
0.0344363712,
0.0441667885,
-0.0002412514,
0.0857892111,
0.0232658554,
-0.055977013,
-0.0735412017,
0.0113873668,
-0.0178150646,
0.0235831961,
-0.0257532597,
0.0863872916,
-0.0307247024,
-0.0030787098,
-0.005774491,
-0.0666411668,
-0.0240721293,
-0.0099562742,
0.0066015152,
0.0284631941,
-0.0534970872,
0.0347106159,
0.0562564768,
-0.0326388367,
-0.0038873747,
0.0868240893,
0.0015372158,
0.0474439338,
0.0020315363,
-0.0067178449,
0.0111014582,
-0.0243271831,
0.0070782281,
-0.0198641121,
-0.0019148741,
-0.0472140051,
0.0281844493,
0.0233037025,
-0.053153038,
-0.0238724742,
-0.0059196991,
-0.0621317551,
-0.0241293982,
0.0186642688,
0.0541195497,
0.002255962,
0.0058845417,
0.0392372161,
0.0266058613,
0.065516822,
-0.0250981431,
-0.0939873606,
0.0351287611,
0.0155372461,
0.0228607152,
0.0225843713,
-0.0423140228,
-0.0286557041,
0.0651388764,
-0.0565891229,
-0.0017212214,
0.011683071,
2.879e-7,
0.0218909066,
0.023703808,
0.0392136388,
-0.0532732233,
-0.0217535347,
0.0369306095,
-0.0153591782,
0.0352238268,
0.0369646885,
-0.0603740886,
0.0104505867,
0.0398958996,
0.000166204,
0.0395675488,
-0.0227976367,
0.0498450324,
-0.0314876661,
0.0107259657,
0.0173110645,
0.0319804922,
0.0278033856,
0.0572545156,
-0.0094534382,
-0.0096135242,
0.0151453875,
-0.0649017692,
0.0998844206,
-0.0160279162,
-0.0078982776,
-0.0096606668,
0.0025967802,
0.0182061046,
0.0002666998,
-0.018999083,
-0.0001338351,
0.0075592385,
0.0765956268,
-0.0190256387,
-0.0246205479,
-0.0720525011,
-0.0287566334,
0.0468147248,
-0.0048447894,
0.0244501419,
0.0551512688,
-0.0207807366,
-0.0112241656,
-0.0571686141,
-0.0432233699,
0.020681737,
0.0272036158,
0.0068683703,
-0.0394567028,
0.008246324,
-0.0012457884,
-0.0079679936,
0.0024239104,
-0.0933133438,
-0.0057347645,
0.0107398899,
-0.0510768816,
0.0035324127,
0.0022447959,
0.0218219925,
0.056204576,
-0.0094227195,
-0.0233631227,
2.129833444e-34,
0.0071317558,
-0.0035270976,
0.014033258,
-0.0527746119,
-0.0304875188,
-0.0499835312,
-0.0163918342,
-0.0038839907,
-0.0105438558,
-0.0440771282,
-0.0326144472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13267v1 | On the Language Encoder of Contrastive Cross-modal Models | 2023-10-20T04:21:09 | 2023-10-20T04:21:09 | Mengjie Zhao, Junya Ono, Zhi Zhong, Chieh-Hsin Lai, Yuhta Takida, Naoki Murata, Wei-Hsiang Liao, Takashi Shibuya, Hiromi Wakaki, Yuki Mitsufuji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Contrastive cross-modal models such as CLIP and CLAP aid various
vision-language (VL) and audio-language (AL) tasks. However, there has been
limited investigation of and improvement in their language encoder, which is
the central component of encoding natural language descriptions of image/audio
into vector representations. We extensively evaluate how unsupervised and
supervised sentence embedding training affect language encoder quality and
cross-modal task performance. In VL pretraining, we found that sentence
embedding training language encoder quality and aids in cross-modal tasks,
improving contrastive VL models such as CyCLIP. In contrast, AL pretraining
benefits less from sentence embedding training, which may result from the
limited amount of pretraining data. We analyze the representation spaces to
understand the strengths of sentence embedding training, and find that it
improves text-space uniformity, at the cost of decreased cross-modal alignment. | [
-0.011762117,
0.0130052827,
-0.0039969054,
0.0352885611,
-0.0320140086,
-0.0069072214,
0.0218852311,
-0.0249849912,
-0.0613784045,
-0.0500598997,
-0.0862122402,
-0.0152423568,
0.0460816547,
0.0087373974,
0.0353323668,
-0.1079348996,
0.0174222495,
-0.0470924191,
-0.0118917068,
-0.0049991067,
0.0230407305,
-0.0126964925,
-0.0245807245,
0.0277523678,
0.0002805058,
-0.0106596425,
-0.0023688262,
-0.0034912389,
0.0173072908,
0.0047727972,
-0.0440488346,
0.0314730555,
0.0596365482,
-0.0430574566,
0.0000016424,
0.0102403956,
0.0373113342,
0.004288746,
0.0337538794,
-0.0044783344,
0.0565318093,
-0.0794862658,
-0.0088667218,
0.0367824323,
0.0078313444,
-0.0538000949,
0.0729605258,
0.0634464175,
0.0399888754,
0.0567253307,
-0.0296038035,
-0.0348530412,
0.0179293305,
-0.0204433929,
-0.003250743,
0.0478983074,
-0.0057214065,
0.0262038801,
0.0086513115,
0.0517381988,
-0.0725590885,
0.0507459007,
0.0194711536,
0.0071314275,
-0.0086254757,
0.0416860282,
-0.041472178,
-0.0083172731,
-0.0253374241,
0.0631589517,
0.0166161191,
-0.0082321092,
-0.05716848,
0.0309072025,
0.0102544324,
0.0064879395,
-0.0399265401,
0.0465739965,
0.0203192625,
0.0228068065,
-0.0230100658,
0.026322769,
0.0108722765,
-0.0628583953,
0.0511720218,
-0.0208288617,
0.0379859284,
-0.0314889662,
0.0002433017,
-0.0077491938,
0.0211922433,
-0.0300081763,
0.0140769798,
-0.0141258519,
0.0016252568,
-0.034861289,
-0.0643273741,
-0.0222870689,
-0.013752372,
-0.0214804765,
0.0564016514,
0.038070254,
-0.0817552954,
0.0527883209,
-0.0192777999,
0.0729316026,
-0.0128136054,
0.0755891204,
-0.0402910598,
-0.0094834073,
-0.0237760581,
-0.0368345305,
-0.0309963338,
-0.0173973925,
-0.0442814305,
-0.0572361238,
-0.0443266407,
0.0033566845,
-0.0073497086,
-0.0021943145,
0.0287056863,
0.0057008355,
-0.0389331393,
-0.0008855282,
-0.0078727724,
0.0138668651,
0.0130262831,
0.0602058545,
-0.0340848826,
-0.0443246402,
-0.0129616177,
0.0427294336,
0.0257481653,
-0.021616919,
-0.011057619,
0.0992041454,
-0.0288871415,
-0.0437616669,
-0.0010087983,
0.0246782117,
-0.0515668727,
-0.030573627,
0.0056770085,
-0.0651832372,
0.0268158801,
0.0146070998,
-0.0092922775,
0.0084145507,
-0.0149314655,
0.0095225545,
-0.0190642606,
0.0970101506,
0.0047583156,
0.0106344512,
-0.0129121132,
-0.0121926591,
0.0242961515,
0.0542185716,
0.0365268551,
-0.0269279033,
0.0118235275,
-0.0249570943,
0.0238179341,
0.0434131175,
-0.0292058326,
-0.0236767847,
-0.081491068,
-0.0232715961,
0.0308868252,
0.0251141787,
0.0644969046,
0.0614625029,
-0.0411121845,
-0.0367691442,
0.0797235295,
0.040290527,
0.0207209196,
-0.0022816346,
0.0510097928,
0.0073614027,
-0.0046410887,
0.0326380022,
-0.0274778754,
0.0430504605,
0.016721312,
0.0254459661,
0.0150113851,
0.0210774615,
-0.0401252173,
-0.0142672546,
-0.0199952107,
-0.0331316106,
0.0083009163,
-0.014483016,
0.0377956815,
0.0085151242,
-0.0354024544,
0.0300212651,
0.0116606411,
-0.0317756757,
-0.0082096104,
0.0131518831,
-0.0282206535,
0.0286821779,
-0.0019801164,
0.0048653102,
0.006812124,
-0.0027558585,
-0.0129791992,
0.0526788458,
0.011680495,
-0.002321346,
0.0337634198,
-0.0276925638,
-0.0456028841,
-0.0498429164,
-0.0119096078,
0.0023373412,
-0.0304497965,
0.0377428122,
0.0026308487,
-0.0674997717,
0.003530463,
0.014213806,
0.0440678485,
-0.0018984022,
-0.0159461629,
0.0341147371,
-0.0020246974,
0.0015215764,
-0.062507093,
0.0243264977,
0.0157968905,
-0.0656709373,
0.0319266729,
0.0834163427,
-0.0636238307,
-0.0797230303,
0.040226128,
-0.110205017,
0.0159081053,
0.0509893559,
0.0237466972,
-0.0293903612,
-0.0056979246,
-0.0508826226,
0.0579024889,
-0.0483633988,
0.0147501212,
-0.0064352825,
0.0239150766,
0.032669127,
0.0381791033,
0.0203966666,
-0.0228049699,
0.0281113572,
0.0248108711,
0.0281651076,
-0.0074618696,
-0.0316543467,
0.0373528898,
-0.0007170778,
0.0058350731,
0.0168415252,
-0.0231460929,
-0.0121397739,
-0.0075361836,
-0.0951034352,
-0.0097836396,
-0.0220700223,
0.0090247532,
-0.0041764798,
-0.0138799213,
-0.0005691911,
-0.0255506616,
-0.0454753786,
-0.0043585002,
0.0074704885,
0.0110446196,
-0.0005935236,
0.0063481415,
-0.0154046146,
-0.0120402947,
-0.007517789,
0.0296969078,
0.0334702395,
-0.0199185275,
-0.015111817,
-0.0388919376,
0.0634550378,
0.0112531148,
0.0057690642,
-0.0096362317,
-0.0387985557,
0.0051316721,
0.0455920771,
0.0699628219,
0.0274408963,
0.0108586447,
0.023955863,
0.0655509904,
-0.0081946068,
-0.0146876108,
-0.0061725555,
0.0152653847,
-0.0053243642,
-0.0675131008,
0.0232696086,
-0.0415970869,
0.059673246,
0.0151907438,
0.0477568023,
-0.0587100573,
-0.0166789833,
-0.0012931749,
-0.0280773658,
-0.0452779494,
-0.0297707375,
-0.0487211011,
0.0343963541,
-0.0316059217,
-0.0527082048,
0.0431566089,
-0.057883393,
-0.0467636995,
-0.026899267,
-0.0246236529,
-0.0177357718,
0.0468948111,
0.0076939948,
0.0281319339,
0.0170508735,
-0.035618484,
-0.0601336509,
-0.0139695192,
0.0351685286,
-0.0002818931,
-0.0063604396,
0.0104143657,
-0.019856425,
-0.0438392796,
-0.0527705997,
-0.0166960452,
-0.0378929004,
-0.0372402482,
0.0184210259,
-0.007055094,
0.0125989253,
-0.0298059378,
0.0467319079,
0.0449617654,
0.0218768492,
-0.0423171297,
0.0249972325,
-0.02986807,
0.0733177885,
0.0421825089,
0.0001074988,
-0.0495280474,
-0.0393118784,
-0.0126149971,
0.0082365386,
0.0226580892,
0.0244411565,
-0.0463427939,
0.0281163547,
0.0300954264,
0.0256255921,
-0.0446988232,
0.0372327529,
0.0603498407,
-0.0277322363,
-0.0085783312,
0.0691787899,
0.0055502979,
-0.0440468453,
-0.0215959363,
0.0322388895,
0.003505256,
0.0057580452,
0.0046982896,
-0.0446673036,
-0.0456157885,
-0.0045703938,
-0.0292756129,
0.0538293719,
0.0702350661,
-0.0071496279,
-0.1097720563,
0.0325670727,
0.0110656926,
-0.0401371382,
-0.0907930136,
-0.0282072909,
-0.0009310486,
0.0000479103,
0.0396245159,
-0.0331650265,
-0.0342729017,
-0.004114551,
0.0166462213,
0.0017961862,
-0.0628405735,
-0.0200281665,
-0.0440935679,
0.0382514149,
0.0385663807,
0.0274212938,
-0.038393598,
-0.0844874084,
0.0141426949,
-0.0242677424,
0.0164718628,
0.0293380544,
0.0805116221,
-0.0243890621,
-0.0393238179,
0.0174459592,
0.0292326845,
0.0031736889,
-0.0311347153,
-0.0294177365,
0.0395782404,
0.0133873392,
0.0201400183,
-0.0162049867,
0.0558220483,
-0.0132317189,
0.0609181337,
0.0372482799,
-0.0280666556,
-0.0102534285,
-0.0006201754,
0.0241575837,
-0.0534619838,
-0.0496082865,
0.0047040847,
0.0337483995,
0.0228826813,
-0.0238724612,
-0.0499023534,
0.0259162318,
0.0158890858,
0.0164974909,
0.000318188,
-0.0284090694,
0.0028283247,
-0.0564888343,
0.0505298525,
-0.0074038766,
0.0532001071,
0.0009679682,
-0.0018245709,
0.0232518353,
-0.0097763371,
-0.0197337456,
-0.017873425,
-0.0421237908,
-0.0552961305,
-0.0430465341,
0.0359413847,
0.0056834421,
0.0769248456,
0.0138748009,
0.0033813561,
0.0725919455,
0.0175045803,
-0.0253461543,
0.0374443121,
0.0324812904,
-0.0431999825,
0.0033732236,
0.0184108317,
-0.0385584608,
-0.0123131201,
0.0098371664,
0.007934384,
0.0117480066,
-0.0505631194,
0.0203681216,
-0.0563296713,
0.0620977059,
-0.0076521891,
0.0682651997,
-0.0226175413,
0.0041473331,
-0.0226602945,
0.0022890002,
-0.0495943613,
0.0138598364,
0.0081521478,
0.02998982,
-0.0040593455,
0.049083557,
-0.0275468323,
-0.0218365565,
-0.0062129465,
0.0453114733,
0.0253457986,
-0.0346919112,
-0.0199176222,
0.0429049768,
-0.0003641409,
-0.0054695117,
-0.0147762932,
0.0208568741,
0.0061240951,
0.0333627723,
-0.0026690019,
-0.0103546726,
-0.0293228198,
0.0490940772,
-0.0084960489,
0.0199190695,
-0.0221019462,
0.0192880686,
0.0468666218,
-0.0518593639,
0.0126759149,
-0.0163784754,
-0.0102459323,
-0.006782054,
0.0366168767,
-0.0177524127,
-0.0021512024,
0.0616599433,
-0.00504563,
-0.0367092006,
-0.0258260854,
0.0714273676,
-0.0257784948,
0.0084444229,
-0.0067700343,
0.0071112383,
-0.0328884758,
-0.0090268441,
0.0315397084,
-0.0063979956,
-0.0206346232,
0.0074041006,
-0.0107625192,
-0.0875326768,
0.0135020344,
0.0194850098,
0.0126151973,
0.0028294772,
0.043442782,
0.0143381115,
0.0077180327,
0.0150724621,
0.0267806798,
-0.0454822294,
0.0120265866,
0.0124375988,
-0.0152109489,
-5.030531748e-33,
-0.0381751321,
0.0252968948,
0.0072866394,
-0.015558783,
-0.0461530127,
0.0301705431,
-0.0305360761,
0.03125773,
0.0222644527,
0.0198663846,
0.0425764099,
-0.0157874916,
0.0198067185,
0.0286006145,
0.0164868385,
0.0126868989,
0.052467145,
-0.030854689,
-0.0248212963,
-0.0267433841,
0.014655211,
0.0142536638,
0.0488344952,
-0.0711818188,
-0.0075659808,
0.0277234297,
0.0081692012,
0.0052142562,
0.0653350204,
0.0868850127,
-0.0261403844,
0.0275933947,
-0.0065427809,
-0.0367446393,
-0.0155868037,
0.0520487912,
-0.0496349595,
0.0199600849,
0.0308843069,
0.051706139,
-0.0951853842,
-0.0299725998,
0.0153776212,
-0.026627982,
-0.0081494907,
-0.0312747844,
0.061727684,
-0.0334792398,
-0.0021171726,
0.0028977662,
-0.0669116974,
-0.0004925336,
-0.0221513454,
-0.0408413559,
0.0766120106,
0.063551113,
0.0261457972,
0.0079280064,
-0.0076334793,
0.0369617902,
-0.0083840592,
0.0373989865,
0.0653375015,
0.0262184832,
-0.0064155119,
0.0702375025,
-0.0000561012,
-0.0957402512,
0.0165708493,
-0.0270323064,
0.021168882,
0.0193717517,
0.0133201582,
0.08450225,
0.0336767547,
-0.0054870741,
-0.0095887082,
0.0053928276,
-0.0562969074,
0.017346384,
0.0237884782,
0.0427233279,
-0.0051500183,
-0.009052692,
-0.0300338287,
-0.0636181906,
-0.0311776586,
-0.0493185036,
0.0395604819,
0.002616365,
0.0172716752,
0.0082798162,
0.0680835545,
-0.026360238,
0.0084581496,
0.0005234735,
-0.0371637642,
0.0456144847,
-0.0017149426,
0.0179720446,
-0.0384900123,
-0.0119949067,
0.0672226101,
0.0110631427,
0.0220954213,
-0.0030057647,
0.0556374453,
0.0128080836,
-0.0641553551,
0.0075966185,
-0.0075102025,
-0.0447931997,
-0.001375266,
0.0453196429,
0.0499347709,
0.0281241387,
-0.0686093941,
0.0180989113,
-0.0416943505,
-0.0011634411,
-0.0326157212,
-0.0444470756,
-0.0253612064,
0.0310472101,
-0.0076941331,
0.0171094872,
-0.0379760787,
-0.0027442107,
0.009186862,
-0.0289384164,
-0.027489543,
0.0195230991,
2.374e-7,
0.0093436139,
-0.0070396713,
0.0433233269,
0.0150885256,
0.0470762439,
0.0432498492,
-0.0340744294,
0.0460802577,
0.0123244356,
-0.0364142098,
-0.0062057623,
0.0195505284,
0.0630624294,
-0.0117362933,
-0.0474699736,
0.0491983704,
-0.0495559126,
0.003568498,
-0.0263965055,
0.0158108901,
0.0735019967,
0.1053886265,
-0.0478689373,
-0.0009877223,
0.0114883389,
-0.0396681651,
0.0781222805,
-0.0440818965,
-0.0216515493,
-0.053661339,
-0.0560576543,
0.0450416282,
-0.0328304768,
0.0299172234,
-0.0082377829,
0.0367856026,
0.0445550084,
0.0151773971,
0.0186089762,
-0.0296781827,
-0.0262812823,
0.0892258286,
-0.066001147,
-0.0166030936,
0.0726039484,
-0.0732811689,
-0.0377429873,
-0.0642571971,
-0.0333088487,
0.0197735932,
0.0309271682,
-0.0103436122,
-0.0333393142,
-0.0058215554,
0.0405911095,
-0.0029916051,
-0.0476528481,
-0.049367927,
-0.0369977318,
0.042827405,
-0.0228568055,
-0.0014822362,
-0.0309352372,
-0.017981926,
0.0668147951,
-0.0426205695,
-0.0152750118,
1.731657003e-34,
0.0029009713,
-0.0070485538,
0.0297908131,
-0.026049247,
-0.0344751254,
-0.0225787815,
0.0470329858,
-0.0181446392,
-0.0084305126,
-0.0282860305,
-0.0359771252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13265v1 | MoqaGPT : Zero-Shot Multi-modal Open-domain Question Answering with Large Language Model | 2023-10-20T04:09:36 | 2023-10-20T04:09:36 | Le Zhang, Yihong Wu, Fengran Mo, Jian-Yun Nie, Aishwarya Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-modal open-domain question answering typically requires evidence
retrieval from databases across diverse modalities, such as images, tables,
passages, etc. Even Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 fall short in this
task. To enable LLMs to tackle the task in a zero-shot manner, we introduce
MoqaGPT, a straightforward and flexible framework. Using a divide-and-conquer
strategy that bypasses intricate multi-modality ranking, our framework can
accommodate new modalities and seamlessly transition to new models for the
task. Built upon LLMs, MoqaGPT retrieves and extracts answers from each
modality separately, then fuses this multi-modal information using LLMs to
produce a final answer. Our methodology boosts performance on the MMCoQA
dataset, improving F1 by +37.91 points and EM by +34.07 points over the
supervised baseline. On the MultiModalQA dataset, MoqaGPT surpasses the
zero-shot baseline, improving F1 by 9.5 points and EM by 10.1 points, and
significantly closes the gap with supervised methods. Our codebase is available
at https://github.com/lezhang7/MOQAGPT. | [
-0.0055014067,
0.0696528479,
0.0184351727,
0.0414832495,
-0.0296773463,
0.0014189645,
0.0156888105,
-0.0005794583,
-0.0219052564,
-0.0786907449,
-0.0502008051,
-0.0147187635,
-0.0395395346,
0.0255279113,
0.0215466879,
0.0079012588,
0.0429355279,
-0.0330535285,
-0.0091473153,
-0.0120491786,
0.0114799114,
0.0312179029,
-0.015899919,
0.0233974215,
0.0092757409,
-0.0438216254,
-0.0289695375,
-0.0146505302,
0.0134108141,
-0.0009716584,
0.0221175458,
0.0447000526,
0.0698342547,
0.0243762732,
0.0000017963,
-0.0188266635,
-0.0337187499,
0.0099739814,
0.0088144355,
-0.0278967656,
0.0046603545,
0.0038315083,
0.0428653471,
0.0076560332,
-0.0568546653,
-0.0289437436,
0.0207325425,
0.0659597814,
0.0616544969,
0.0641789436,
0.0119468747,
-0.0343702137,
0.0186537057,
-0.0007255459,
0.0409733504,
-0.0327706337,
0.0195228923,
0.0192165878,
0.0480247177,
0.0389662161,
-0.0114293536,
0.0430134423,
0.0152111175,
0.0204744227,
-0.0537633486,
0.049290631,
-0.0116048735,
0.0320714973,
0.0133735212,
0.1220853254,
0.0401476659,
0.0011467549,
-0.0052850363,
0.0173816551,
0.0024370488,
0.025342904,
-0.0796135366,
0.0502792411,
-0.013632806,
-0.0156546049,
-0.0442637652,
-0.0135284001,
0.0112238582,
0.0293898769,
-0.0046486207,
0.0407888629,
0.0145380301,
-0.0177638642,
0.0037657595,
-0.0130617218,
-0.0467568301,
-0.0376536548,
-0.0391687788,
0.0772248432,
-0.0150646605,
0.0079188645,
0.0013164107,
-0.0067973789,
0.0359194055,
-0.0175753757,
0.0101858256,
0.0241136272,
-0.0451438092,
0.0710143819,
-0.0377701856,
-0.0052186074,
-0.0485901274,
0.0072786235,
-0.0543891117,
-0.0585337244,
-0.0635659024,
-0.0220025405,
-0.0196365099,
0.0243186262,
-0.0558933616,
-0.0323671736,
0.0197008513,
0.0147736315,
-0.0048225787,
-0.0293294657,
0.0183555596,
0.0366454422,
-0.0164953023,
-0.0177303012,
-0.0178545192,
0.0778314248,
-0.0390048362,
0.0560285524,
-0.0108279381,
-0.0465066098,
-0.0295095369,
0.0187420938,
0.0129959453,
-0.030350754,
0.0262053274,
0.0861761048,
-0.0361407734,
-0.0337906815,
-0.0058114883,
-0.0353648663,
-0.0259206537,
-0.0643341169,
0.0133236255,
-0.0673672482,
0.0105680088,
0.0074284077,
-0.0089608198,
0.0076915892,
0.0036405385,
0.044585377,
-0.0152809657,
0.0581433438,
0.0178203527,
-0.0181187019,
0.0434254706,
0.0329573937,
0.0115374476,
0.0892499834,
-0.0011977463,
0.0069894637,
0.036836639,
0.0299595874,
0.0197091773,
0.0149593186,
0.0224134475,
0.0368085094,
0.0215719771,
0.0355697908,
0.0134296585,
0.0133340517,
0.0253200885,
0.0041695628,
-0.03798173,
-0.0346466377,
0.0231521949,
-0.0024557619,
0.0315182321,
0.0033964678,
0.0188226271,
0.0068746442,
0.0089383125,
-0.0154018039,
-0.0213243682,
0.04584736,
-0.0352079459,
0.0134238983,
0.0320939161,
0.0522257872,
-0.0438509993,
0.0093035772,
0.0182438809,
-0.0074757347,
-0.0236381479,
0.0395027846,
0.0441682301,
0.0031842438,
-0.0352804624,
0.0470035933,
0.025796093,
-0.0114033138,
-0.0282060876,
-0.0326000378,
0.0509137511,
-0.0167814717,
0.0207983069,
-0.0668390021,
-0.0269918144,
-0.0266514011,
0.0386774912,
0.0138051119,
-0.0521893613,
-0.018819904,
0.0369686261,
-0.0407071039,
-0.0364233255,
-0.0377712436,
0.0089072688,
0.0103096571,
0.013727067,
0.01680067,
0.0073004686,
-0.0437752567,
0.0726922452,
0.0061835805,
0.0250207298,
-0.0177686568,
0.0078711221,
-0.0131342486,
0.0136340838,
0.0074594854,
-0.0246430747,
0.0170157552,
0.0361217409,
-0.0224937033,
-0.0321240909,
-0.0172636677,
-0.0375810266,
-0.0359839015,
0.0636735409,
-0.0296715144,
-0.0168499723,
-0.0004620847,
-0.0645841584,
-0.0352966152,
0.0018652886,
0.0019782931,
0.0107991491,
-0.0571748503,
-0.0595688894,
0.0564472824,
0.0129249617,
-0.0541800484,
0.0759348869,
-0.0058793705,
0.0053201634,
0.043833971,
-0.0121595059,
0.0220939964,
-0.0099990843,
0.0074622435,
0.0094758151,
-0.0137722166,
0.0385077745,
0.0110943867,
0.0238700286,
-0.058626458,
-0.0294971894,
-0.1452975422,
0.0217533521,
-0.0051587811,
0.0002157275,
0.0384212695,
0.0266076066,
-0.0185222663,
-0.0268081538,
-0.0550683923,
0.0123678856,
0.0293537062,
0.0209521651,
0.0289471447,
0.0221352894,
0.0192204993,
-0.0100470949,
-0.0195255876,
-0.0067253085,
0.0618654937,
-0.0493543409,
0.0161279477,
-0.0154816359,
-0.0234028082,
-0.0594106875,
0.0449208282,
-0.0156149939,
-0.016254805,
0.0131203402,
-0.0522681214,
0.0292234737,
0.0390522368,
-0.0106655061,
-0.0210615769,
0.0376507416,
-0.0262344349,
-0.0593569353,
0.0206222199,
0.0032385162,
-0.0380075611,
0.0045039188,
0.0098560061,
-0.0084941173,
0.0197451729,
-0.0013827725,
-0.021794552,
-0.00868423,
0.0133536141,
0.0384049602,
-0.0092995241,
-0.0623585396,
0.0597876273,
-0.0067973961,
0.0177342147,
-0.009853173,
-0.0143285096,
0.0436745621,
-0.010208454,
-0.0035894562,
-0.0357262343,
0.0068709874,
-0.0661213621,
0.0427947938,
-0.0119430041,
0.0179818291,
0.016948577,
-0.0021764031,
-0.0591290034,
-0.0240712743,
0.0093737189,
-0.0401654355,
0.0624348596,
-0.0324269272,
0.0371051952,
-0.0553696156,
-0.0266457722,
-0.0080308942,
-0.0677351654,
-0.0297156814,
0.0165235046,
-0.0808033422,
-0.0031730768,
-0.0374713875,
-0.0125317238,
0.0488875024,
0.0181049481,
-0.033712998,
0.0044720615,
-0.021927204,
0.0907084867,
0.0870324522,
0.0577583686,
-0.0236189738,
-0.0154857812,
0.0091298698,
0.0788891092,
0.0013555295,
0.0227314252,
-0.0083837863,
0.0008784118,
0.0288321115,
0.0230178013,
-0.0016467051,
0.01832233,
0.0516798943,
-0.0279711001,
0.0165618062,
0.0955616385,
0.0183553156,
-0.0276383683,
-0.041012913,
-0.0104152253,
0.0313456953,
-0.0050629298,
0.0284462906,
-0.1409153193,
-0.0799222365,
-0.028211467,
-0.0049365126,
0.0179254021,
-0.0099692475,
-0.0043198266,
-0.0982260481,
0.0259134937,
-0.0368128866,
-0.0388141274,
-0.0331651047,
-0.0337228328,
0.0209299885,
-0.0181003213,
-0.0121787265,
0.0100498656,
-0.0300041214,
0.0173001438,
-0.0054297945,
0.0817833617,
-0.0190452226,
0.0640508309,
-0.0287635364,
0.0203641113,
0.0227105673,
0.0033911844,
-0.0271004681,
-0.0386079364,
0.0030895805,
-0.034969531,
-0.0127029186,
0.0014920302,
0.0155663239,
-0.0285930503,
0.0010357079,
-0.0282160062,
0.0328017361,
-0.0181240179,
-0.0205705594,
0.0259960201,
0.071308881,
-0.0116640246,
0.0023203092,
-0.0438071564,
0.0127014797,
-0.0089161573,
0.0677323416,
-0.0021645164,
-0.0057722409,
-0.0272401795,
-0.0249354243,
-0.0300843399,
-0.0084239282,
-0.0424629077,
0.0169260167,
0.0195765384,
0.036008779,
-0.0579522736,
-0.0160333309,
0.0506566279,
0.0470825434,
-0.0353733525,
0.0096547445,
-0.0569546334,
0.0320074186,
-0.0511708669,
0.0530226007,
-0.0477459095,
0.0182540938,
-0.0576920174,
0.029915886,
0.0483688787,
-0.0511883199,
-0.0332274996,
0.0139802247,
-0.082763195,
-0.0348350592,
-0.0397583693,
0.0341157615,
0.0108914627,
-0.0068790503,
0.0091101276,
-0.0458522476,
0.0306947194,
0.0264112111,
-0.0313902982,
-0.0086480482,
0.034536209,
-0.0228317771,
0.0020756091,
0.0356185846,
-0.0553534813,
0.0036608747,
-0.0094562322,
0.0550904721,
-0.014392646,
-0.0184266884,
0.0380466916,
-0.0079919258,
0.0409805961,
0.0195787828,
-0.0248063989,
-0.020783456,
-0.0112404125,
-0.0265183635,
-0.0358201712,
-0.0305383075,
0.0539471135,
0.0040525552,
-0.066043511,
0.0062150024,
0.0110799288,
-0.0132312402,
0.0378398262,
-0.0297560524,
0.0189938881,
0.0753410012,
-0.0357885063,
-0.0147569897,
-0.0256827939,
-0.0239273235,
0.0011112065,
0.0024416512,
0.0453766771,
-0.0167471208,
0.0904627964,
0.0027013107,
-0.0521665551,
-0.0390719287,
0.049395971,
-0.0688103437,
-0.0128323697,
-0.0194348954,
0.0660518035,
0.0582485013,
0.0149378171,
0.0091371201,
0.0083886515,
-0.0404459201,
-0.0214381907,
-0.0035619629,
0.0007040854,
0.0365653448,
0.0749797747,
0.0488449708,
-0.012077366,
0.0269317236,
0.0939074978,
-0.0029030577,
0.0314212069,
0.0179170612,
0.0105459476,
-0.0153647242,
-0.0207545087,
0.0193285421,
0.0349687189,
-0.0151666068,
0.0169225782,
-0.0205066167,
-0.0330827683,
-0.01177759,
0.0075195204,
-0.0690681413,
0.0080535905,
0.0270848386,
0.036918655,
0.0406689756,
-0.044305034,
-0.0597412586,
0.0368924737,
0.0111982441,
-0.0336655863,
0.014502652,
-6.243254739e-33,
-0.0161835067,
-0.0110077383,
0.0354124419,
-0.0542009063,
-0.0060075317,
0.0275608059,
-0.0032219957,
0.0026029316,
-0.0567371361,
0.0057480708,
0.0095359739,
0.0021339222,
0.0024648895,
0.0341784507,
-0.0028026483,
-0.0217621513,
-0.0164905675,
-0.0162903648,
-0.0227152295,
0.016747931,
0.0453924909,
0.0092504378,
0.0476524383,
-0.0116052218,
0.0185505114,
-0.0082581798,
-0.0220046397,
0.0284236446,
-0.0174404364,
0.0752192885,
-0.0243542958,
0.0248247087,
0.0382315479,
-0.0407919064,
0.0038627665,
0.0340147913,
-0.0860620812,
-0.0161165204,
0.0231907312,
-0.0452189408,
-0.0555054024,
-0.0223598536,
-0.0029423037,
-0.0082656788,
0.0496475399,
-0.0491926074,
0.0168443322,
-0.0058741532,
0.0031903817,
-0.0006870466,
-0.0229891203,
0.0398466922,
-0.0009002566,
-0.0294904076,
-0.0109644076,
0.0684601143,
0.0347185992,
0.0297881868,
-0.0154096121,
0.0128235836,
-0.0085292002,
0.0287129544,
0.0325695649,
0.0200011861,
-0.0164768435,
0.0335324258,
-0.0027370169,
-0.0601145178,
-0.0547023341,
-0.0266952273,
-0.0307920016,
0.055815272,
0.027220374,
0.0907661021,
0.0077941241,
0.0610075295,
-0.0785426572,
0.0392449498,
-0.0202234834,
0.0540431626,
-0.0173550099,
0.0034392714,
0.011533482,
0.0165653545,
-0.0262313448,
0.0308400076,
-0.036217548,
-0.0017931003,
0.0232210997,
0.0007038523,
-0.0185177997,
0.0078339046,
0.0758282989,
-0.0422061943,
-0.0027055691,
0.0651245862,
-0.0193086397,
0.0264856536,
0.0147983683,
0.0545793921,
-0.031723015,
0.031023249,
0.0681145787,
-0.0343466625,
-0.0304941703,
0.0202163011,
0.0083726682,
0.0076642311,
-0.0564919114,
-0.0135597019,
-0.0288455058,
-0.0094434815,
-0.0380964093,
0.032839153,
-0.0028853843,
0.0245820507,
-0.0143408533,
0.0387958996,
0.0081070103,
0.0135765653,
-0.0287262741,
-0.0479840897,
0.0131458547,
0.0023898012,
-0.0200794321,
0.0505799241,
-0.0436752923,
-0.0296126939,
-0.0169055704,
-0.0413625836,
-0.0047113961,
0.0626644492,
2.532e-7,
0.0682510585,
-0.0163742453,
-0.0049639805,
0.0200366192,
0.0076271566,
0.0500065386,
-0.017641928,
0.0390106738,
0.0302463211,
-0.0391486064,
-0.0212319922,
0.0453585088,
0.0324602015,
0.0344886668,
-0.0432676263,
0.007135259,
-0.0218100343,
-0.0470844582,
-0.0478438474,
-0.0276242178,
0.0630713776,
0.1044756249,
-0.0298640262,
-0.0088475225,
-0.0000236046,
-0.0491173677,
0.0760326385,
0.0084019853,
-0.0259122867,
-0.0234972071,
0.0229119603,
-0.0205175243,
0.0282106008,
-0.0175534077,
0.0241749417,
0.0044109975,
0.0266125128,
0.0771130919,
0.0022610752,
-0.0590288267,
-0.0229475033,
-0.0338166133,
0.0066860202,
-0.0295600928,
0.1235444769,
-0.0350351743,
-0.0289858822,
-0.050876677,
-0.0450960547,
-0.0020293074,
0.0218384508,
-0.0086854249,
-0.0449030474,
0.0322924852,
0.0098945526,
-0.0295555536,
-0.0225674435,
-0.0760909468,
-0.0044307299,
0.0034776537,
-0.0588354245,
-0.0105966646,
0.0163544919,
-0.0471493974,
0.0279096086,
-0.0798099563,
-0.0178583879,
2.119104763e-34,
0.0233373716,
-0.0147761302,
0.0154718785,
0.0320674218,
0.0119736912,
-0.0094351387,
-0.0417544618,
-0.0445900299,
0.016000079,
-0.1055306569,
-0.0195619203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13262v1 | A Quality-based Syntactic Template Retriever for Syntactically-controlled Paraphrase Generation | 2023-10-20T03:55:39 | 2023-10-20T03:55:39 | Xue Zhang, Songming Zhang, Yunlong Liang, Yufeng Chen, Jian Liu, Wenjuan Han, Jinan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing syntactically-controlled paraphrase generation (SPG) models perform
promisingly with human-annotated or well-chosen syntactic templates. However,
the difficulty of obtaining such templates actually hinders the practical
application of SPG models. For one thing, the prohibitive cost makes it
unfeasible to manually design decent templates for every source sentence. For
another, the templates automatically retrieved by current heuristic methods are
usually unreliable for SPG models to generate qualified paraphrases. To escape
this dilemma, we propose a novel Quality-based Syntactic Template Retriever
(QSTR) to retrieve templates based on the quality of the to-be-generated
paraphrases. Furthermore, for situations requiring multiple paraphrases for
each source sentence, we design a Diverse Templates Search (DTS) algorithm,
which can enhance the diversity between paraphrases without sacrificing
quality. Experiments demonstrate that QSTR can significantly surpass existing
retrieval methods in generating high-quality paraphrases and even perform
comparably with human-annotated templates in terms of reference-free metrics.
Additionally, human evaluation and the performance on downstream tasks using
our generated paraphrases for data augmentation showcase the potential of our
QSTR and DTS algorithm in practical scenarios. | [
0.1001774445,
0.0157035775,
0.0014448843,
0.0098442687,
-0.0439489968,
-0.010313483,
-0.0160287432,
0.0213940293,
-0.0233221967,
-0.0462069027,
-0.0091792177,
0.0291975886,
-0.0187156256,
-0.0508347824,
0.0184588227,
-0.092633076,
0.0400888883,
0.0076839612,
-0.0141617386,
0.018771138,
0.0005952702,
0.0392292365,
0.0183705315,
0.061397098,
-0.0038077631,
-0.0068335482,
0.0403774157,
0.049507618,
0.025335772,
0.0132448738,
0.0547581539,
-0.0208866931,
-0.0113218175,
0.0051970072,
0.0000015615,
-0.0233679414,
-0.0380710699,
-0.0054270411,
-0.0065856939,
0.0312318653,
0.1020496786,
-0.0235241819,
0.0138530452,
0.0399671905,
-0.0393083468,
-0.0116860177,
0.0126169873,
0.0069709979,
0.1085372493,
0.0499440394,
-0.0007189934,
-0.0429104604,
-0.0313999876,
0.0177295338,
-0.0144379316,
-0.0149905356,
-0.0102127045,
-0.0066339225,
0.021572914,
0.0108782686,
0.0155316098,
0.0592090115,
0.0059318766,
0.0471002534,
0.0312864035,
-0.0143172722,
-0.039270889,
0.0031259481,
-0.0147829326,
0.0348709002,
-0.0310702603,
-0.0372044034,
0.0212847982,
-0.0103293061,
0.018087443,
0.0483166799,
-0.0621439405,
0.0217428189,
-0.0115882456,
0.0072518196,
0.026596427,
0.0199570674,
-0.0176653247,
0.035689164,
-0.0019153978,
-0.0010520458,
0.0378496461,
-0.0226380434,
-0.0497268513,
0.0053350241,
-0.0468804054,
0.0121810371,
0.0101453569,
-0.0292956401,
-0.0328519046,
0.0277607981,
-0.0656337515,
-0.1102759764,
0.0456741862,
-0.0212356672,
0.0274732932,
0.0064422647,
0.0235335585,
0.0211388227,
-0.0421759002,
0.0294295922,
-0.0562140904,
0.0377854779,
-0.0730758458,
-0.0268549453,
-0.082390435,
-0.0011177021,
-0.0850946233,
0.0644432604,
-0.0219780151,
-0.0338865854,
-0.0369716622,
0.0054982556,
0.0364801958,
-0.0065499377,
0.0037232172,
0.0608144589,
-0.051797349,
0.00893836,
-0.0138990199,
-0.0068116435,
-0.0346533991,
-0.0041666604,
0.0266750082,
-0.0539728068,
-0.0231597032,
0.0488236398,
0.0613112375,
-0.0696659312,
0.0282373521,
0.0444283672,
-0.0028808692,
-0.0398298018,
-0.023209611,
-0.0416870043,
-0.0220893305,
-0.0249973051,
-0.0041474258,
-0.0490721576,
0.0291648228,
0.0265251901,
-0.0107107209,
-0.0273332037,
0.0209186766,
0.0520932153,
-0.0564811453,
0.02360324,
-0.0112866452,
-0.0391810946,
-0.0145241534,
-0.0187500138,
-0.0250991117,
0.01838772,
0.0374330468,
0.0369731858,
0.0634720549,
0.0419174284,
0.0121030901,
-0.0152363107,
-0.0038450807,
0.0165111143,
-0.0271757711,
0.0389796607,
0.0059630247,
0.0172745381,
0.0074300589,
0.0756358206,
-0.0489605218,
0.0008633743,
0.0477647483,
0.0228092149,
0.0143614421,
0.0545034148,
0.0688698217,
0.0677153319,
0.0057654125,
0.0282705389,
-0.0190960169,
-0.0117280968,
0.0088247536,
0.0468416139,
0.0051239682,
0.0432274714,
0.0159467831,
-0.0505637415,
-0.0208721235,
-0.0133759137,
-0.0269243158,
-0.0155797414,
-0.0132726422,
0.0229669511,
-0.0638638586,
0.091749616,
-0.0458863154,
-0.082250528,
-0.0234054402,
-0.0117045278,
0.0052053221,
0.0853577107,
0.1035982743,
-0.0013759905,
-0.01833288,
-0.0081225401,
-0.033110112,
0.0330475159,
0.012493927,
0.0232063401,
0.0321529508,
-0.0773915574,
-0.0096132271,
-0.0471106134,
0.0229234509,
-0.0091212355,
0.0278481115,
-0.0322101377,
0.0555066131,
-0.0207921341,
-0.0683228821,
0.0477771126,
0.0532961152,
-0.0202656277,
0.0294554122,
-0.0132452585,
0.0109529179,
0.0318792351,
-0.0132647939,
0.0355282538,
-0.0101667391,
-0.0657664165,
-0.0119767822,
0.0428952277,
-0.0426694378,
-0.0520397648,
-0.0290068816,
-0.0509932227,
0.0040263236,
0.0244769622,
-0.0168779697,
-0.0434685536,
-0.0010911133,
-0.0877466351,
0.0426742956,
-0.0613969751,
-0.000746486,
-0.0062264497,
0.0166377854,
-0.0343270525,
0.0651534274,
0.0425060764,
0.0073571047,
0.035025306,
-0.0344540812,
0.0482769497,
-0.0396279246,
0.0037205936,
-0.0361448377,
-0.0076303426,
0.025045678,
0.0492588542,
0.0283007436,
-0.0609745681,
-0.0322965719,
-0.0718570352,
0.0312236007,
-0.0151680326,
-0.0099418545,
0.0441151597,
0.010062458,
-0.0058537237,
-0.0212567523,
0.0082378294,
-0.0410444438,
0.0219959226,
0.0197003447,
0.046563141,
0.0459727794,
-0.0124043971,
-0.0677593574,
0.0119774146,
-0.0037425146,
0.0459722318,
0.0206053555,
-0.0074832053,
-0.0164934937,
0.030568786,
-0.0197403934,
-0.0300633777,
0.0476723537,
-0.0593991764,
-0.0011070375,
-0.0167807508,
0.0199987385,
0.0645627603,
0.0243747663,
-0.0337619707,
0.0172887407,
0.017331481,
-0.0739351436,
0.0127271852,
-0.0058292476,
-0.0039461395,
0.0225224439,
-0.0067867874,
0.0701377168,
0.0112035358,
0.053496331,
-0.0042737871,
-0.0755319148,
0.0298846383,
0.0105535416,
0.004356158,
-0.0133806905,
0.018453462,
-0.0386681817,
-0.0080073569,
-0.0324073136,
-0.0188137963,
0.05848049,
-0.0117453877,
-0.0054628416,
-0.0632223785,
0.004885958,
-0.0251071155,
-0.0143665988,
-0.0352941528,
0.0297438595,
-0.0008003039,
-0.0213996135,
-0.0387858562,
-0.0219096392,
0.0624353252,
-0.0386740714,
0.0206159875,
-0.0468587056,
-0.0022077837,
0.016398523,
-0.0368138701,
-0.039745938,
-0.0520491675,
-0.0135958511,
-0.0021469845,
0.0141208032,
0.0075815227,
0.0152890198,
-0.0423908606,
0.0196784735,
0.0398373306,
-0.0298122149,
-0.0156583861,
-0.0391746387,
0.0454300009,
0.0598626025,
0.0054645366,
0.0068950737,
-0.0132587962,
0.0055213361,
0.0100809289,
0.0536740571,
0.0132483765,
-0.0183168706,
-0.0348348692,
-0.001005921,
-0.036726445,
-0.0414305441,
0.0018396357,
0.023835551,
-0.0297996085,
-0.0315613858,
0.084168449,
0.0326315239,
-0.0059083761,
-0.0238402132,
-0.0137470197,
0.0386023447,
0.0068085073,
0.0269959606,
-0.0708642229,
-0.0485142693,
-0.0198861416,
0.0332558826,
-0.0063869432,
-0.0042785988,
-0.0134549495,
-0.0479999557,
0.0488017499,
0.0078505585,
0.0312908851,
-0.0141641134,
0.0172863156,
-0.0212023221,
-0.0110417921,
0.022665523,
0.0215725098,
-0.052775234,
0.0450867005,
-0.0126064355,
-0.0309113599,
-0.0376736298,
-0.0278148949,
-0.069064863,
-0.0197186656,
0.0611266568,
0.0346813239,
0.0306906309,
-0.0181065742,
-0.0113104247,
-0.0776970536,
0.0257275309,
0.0094235335,
0.0325444043,
-0.0199928228,
0.0001922153,
-0.0144972047,
0.0040566204,
-0.0334658623,
0.0076002935,
0.0356280096,
0.0188021529,
0.0076759649,
0.0379938222,
-0.039855618,
0.0110812457,
-0.0210936703,
0.0928787217,
0.054679919,
-0.0306807086,
-0.027094081,
0.0005196274,
0.0137295108,
-0.1176696494,
-0.0114514604,
0.0160156153,
-0.0391355343,
0.0336194858,
-0.0935048535,
-0.0174803864,
0.0093377372,
0.0386079289,
-0.0217482224,
0.0474883467,
-0.0432206467,
0.006976747,
0.0050370106,
0.0105516687,
-0.0510719232,
-0.0047041359,
-0.0279835667,
-0.0058523454,
0.0232639741,
-0.0229724888,
-0.0023342678,
0.0425495952,
-0.0338415354,
-0.0249116775,
0.0095151607,
0.0684382915,
0.0177527703,
0.0204410944,
-0.0112986127,
0.0279787779,
0.0367171839,
0.041479025,
-0.0478784069,
0.0150650507,
0.0380848534,
0.0029066054,
-0.0182793662,
0.0309303906,
-0.0465066023,
-0.0346485078,
0.0090760915,
0.0726613104,
0.0100035435,
-0.0349129587,
0.0695993528,
0.0299223959,
0.0214455016,
-0.0300640427,
0.018728368,
0.0351227485,
0.0125537477,
-0.0037518055,
-0.0276794434,
-0.0403042808,
0.0319594108,
0.0116505967,
0.0010289629,
-0.0227208305,
0.0224921871,
-0.053496588,
0.0719556212,
-0.0376611911,
-0.0332022756,
-0.0566210933,
-0.0127338972,
-0.0219401494,
-0.0156849138,
-0.0236770809,
-0.0079155453,
-0.0531109273,
0.0021934111,
-0.009785885,
0.0394701362,
0.0098448992,
-0.0651906282,
-0.0456244759,
0.057295505,
-0.0513695553,
-0.0163146537,
-0.022585012,
0.0024569186,
0.0612093732,
-0.0018881537,
0.0603112131,
-0.0277174227,
-0.0259425137,
0.0164296012,
0.05629161,
0.0048032063,
0.0084399916,
-0.0151445931,
-0.0022891848,
-0.0125775244,
-0.0367793292,
0.034102492,
0.0154692708,
0.0299632736,
-0.0110972188,
-0.0373824909,
-0.0426619947,
-0.0294743255,
-0.0097701782,
0.0105382791,
0.0115884887,
-0.012895002,
-0.0360024497,
-0.0227969326,
0.05251747,
0.018009264,
0.0081090871,
-0.0344227664,
0.0643712878,
0.0502982512,
-0.0205618329,
-0.0387398377,
-0.0587697029,
0.0110809356,
0.0193925742,
-0.0036440557,
-0.0476913787,
-5.66576963e-33,
-0.0190228168,
0.0210609492,
-0.0291136056,
-0.0356172286,
-0.0102774194,
-0.026025869,
-0.0027817502,
-0.0250393227,
0.0142466584,
0.0002041168,
-0.02160234,
0.018897837,
0.0165307336,
0.03812626,
0.0316715278,
-0.0029223557,
0.0599325709,
-0.0039386018,
-0.0337281674,
-0.0029451346,
0.0343911052,
0.0194102302,
0.0276490878,
-0.029266065,
-0.0308434702,
-0.0259645134,
-0.0050537637,
-0.0163073651,
0.0349589624,
0.0700358227,
0.0339224152,
0.0669964328,
0.0182669759,
-0.0130908834,
-0.0127437413,
-0.0176441707,
-0.0526058376,
-0.0020186012,
0.0581199192,
-0.02710885,
-0.0657881126,
-0.0975834951,
0.0277299918,
-0.0460808426,
0.0002875676,
0.0459375083,
0.0379369743,
-0.0557441376,
-0.0037074995,
-0.0389081538,
-0.0036598593,
-0.0052031442,
0.0023219713,
0.0042653289,
-0.0165693592,
0.0730930269,
-0.0118225422,
0.0390255116,
-0.0044570337,
0.014162546,
-0.0210250355,
0.045695316,
-0.0022418106,
0.0065589845,
0.015649071,
0.0100731123,
-0.0525749288,
-0.0287917629,
0.0138688851,
-0.0254886989,
-0.021928167,
0.050424993,
0.0345785022,
0.0896857902,
0.0089598857,
0.0307995696,
0.0084333895,
0.036077559,
0.0303236693,
0.0242145658,
0.024551779,
0.0025474362,
-0.0180472862,
0.0129106725,
-0.0316999368,
0.0073512797,
-0.0086532282,
-0.0280486103,
0.0500314422,
0.0319680125,
-0.0635439754,
-0.0144261066,
0.0447699018,
-0.0044698073,
0.0162457433,
0.0206748042,
-0.0467240512,
0.0115372231,
0.0036839701,
0.0022085465,
-0.0024294942,
-0.0341601074,
0.0210735239,
-0.0001984776,
0.0145456512,
-0.0125112655,
0.0251987129,
0.0124671338,
-0.0495259538,
0.0265205689,
-0.0313943736,
0.0110924989,
-0.0892481729,
-0.1097219959,
-0.002994102,
0.0376016349,
-0.0020477066,
0.0304322224,
0.0157383028,
-0.0142447725,
-0.0338422991,
-0.0076405164,
0.0093275933,
0.0283461045,
-0.0050746603,
0.0221052598,
-0.0222595949,
0.0054746028,
-0.0016812104,
-0.0183122121,
-0.0097402819,
-0.0037914177,
2.374e-7,
0.0163125787,
0.0467786342,
0.0473516397,
-0.0055527105,
-0.0307369642,
0.0342435017,
0.0322020352,
0.0382495224,
-0.0364122912,
-0.0092973402,
0.0301543996,
0.0119348187,
0.0276730843,
-0.0349265039,
-0.1170397997,
0.0460647009,
-0.0948320031,
0.0191180017,
-0.057449799,
-0.0368518159,
0.0899038464,
0.0728229806,
-0.0039257347,
0.0157746132,
-0.0341868587,
-0.0265271645,
0.0785233453,
-0.0252777841,
-0.0523867905,
-0.0061593144,
0.0505167544,
0.0161603149,
-0.0043803295,
-0.0120757204,
0.0111163491,
0.0286666136,
0.0524034351,
0.0434183329,
0.0372316167,
-0.0142307393,
-0.0120838601,
-0.0558294952,
0.0189202875,
-0.0488424413,
0.0361692794,
-0.0645857453,
0.0324865878,
-0.0168006942,
-0.0628149435,
0.0569457337,
-0.0028936784,
-0.0265460629,
-0.0504405387,
0.0137580885,
0.0140713118,
0.0155669916,
-0.0160580538,
-0.0597270764,
-0.0245294292,
0.0237220991,
-0.010145857,
0.011966167,
-0.0347901769,
-0.0008906784,
0.0278078876,
-0.0761403292,
-0.013816895,
1.82890735e-34,
0.0506579243,
0.0023547064,
0.0453795157,
0.0228776224,
0.045254074,
-0.0017263753,
-0.0092469854,
0.0219741203,
0.0193237625,
-0.023518417,
-0.0108208647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13257v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13257v2 | Visual Grounding Helps Learn Word Meanings in Low-Data Regimes | 2023-10-20T03:33:36 | 2024-03-25T18:48:40 | Chengxu Zhuang, Evelina Fedorenko, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modern neural language models (LMs) are powerful tools for modeling human
sentence production and comprehension, and their internal representations are
remarkably well-aligned with representations of language in the human brain.
But to achieve these results, LMs must be trained in distinctly un-human-like
ways - requiring orders of magnitude more language data than children receive
during development, and without perceptual or social context. Do models trained
more naturalistically -- with grounded supervision -- exhibit more humanlike
language learning? We investigate this question in the context of word
learning, a key sub-task in language acquisition. We train a diverse set of LM
architectures, with and without auxiliary visual supervision, on datasets of
varying scales. We then evaluate these models' learning of syntactic
categories, lexical relations, semantic features, word similarity, and
alignment with human neural representations. We find that visual supervision
can indeed improve the efficiency of word learning. However, these improvements
are limited: they are present almost exclusively in the low-data regime, and
sometimes canceled out by the inclusion of rich distributional signals from
text. The information conveyed by text and images is not redundant -- models
mainly driven by visual information yield qualitatively different from those
mainly driven by word co-occurrences. However, our results suggest that current
multimodal modeling approaches fail to effectively leverage visual information
to build human-like word representations from human-scale data. | [
0.0280857924,
0.0789885372,
-0.0211380497,
0.0377545282,
-0.0299986135,
0.0047784536,
-0.0014000315,
-0.0202043559,
-0.0359439068,
-0.0366021506,
-0.0838518441,
-0.0522544608,
0.0396567211,
0.0219846796,
0.0552712046,
-0.0537785552,
0.0231366735,
-0.0257702935,
-0.0448258482,
0.0047228034,
0.020780554,
-0.0076631815,
-0.0111977765,
0.0004669483,
-0.0776691735,
0.0047933436,
-0.0094466349,
-0.0063052485,
-0.0370211005,
-0.0249622371,
-0.0049284389,
0.0668227971,
0.0828651264,
0.012918924,
0.0000016847,
0.0032876269,
0.0389363542,
-0.0607661605,
0.011524803,
-0.0109483059,
0.0497355536,
-0.0696195886,
0.0032509372,
-0.0326950848,
-0.0453209095,
-0.0285028853,
0.0742312223,
0.0532931872,
0.0429595448,
0.0084933359,
-0.0223110151,
-0.0164559595,
0.0213511512,
-0.0305673592,
0.0205145217,
0.0034723072,
-0.0024993902,
0.0522334203,
-0.0170572326,
0.0086076874,
-0.0725955963,
0.0083218487,
0.0118326806,
0.0181592293,
0.0331468061,
0.0929218531,
0.0240995828,
-0.0752552003,
-0.0213071778,
0.0690197572,
-0.0157901831,
-0.0420780368,
-0.0315801762,
0.0148191089,
0.0052965088,
0.0363050997,
-0.0438572913,
0.0803448558,
0.0107197305,
0.0701954067,
-0.0133091267,
-0.0410167016,
0.0017487137,
0.0264376663,
0.0256143715,
0.011310962,
0.0018315021,
-0.007717608,
0.0205185283,
0.0597425848,
-0.0440169796,
-0.0174749531,
-0.0366877876,
-0.0096290428,
0.0228615627,
0.0282374173,
-0.0584847517,
-0.0069799707,
0.0076027396,
-0.0499315672,
0.0520835519,
0.0294233374,
-0.0628678352,
0.0337859541,
-0.0500118211,
0.0209677573,
-0.0060654497,
0.0544992797,
-0.0193113815,
0.0204364602,
-0.012936593,
-0.0340728499,
-0.0010127992,
0.0132409763,
-0.0557995439,
-0.0382315218,
-0.007263578,
0.0149888191,
0.0033552696,
-0.0237816982,
0.0102798482,
0.0449857675,
-0.0394463055,
0.0161941331,
-0.0482914485,
0.0007572684,
-0.0177499186,
0.0717548355,
-0.0203252584,
-0.0549768768,
-0.0122435307,
0.0267573837,
0.0258137211,
-0.0036488262,
0.0179678611,
0.0674519166,
-0.0336379856,
-0.0788736567,
-0.0629354566,
0.0008398863,
-0.0211778395,
-0.0292716045,
0.0526143946,
-0.0343835503,
0.0231754463,
-0.0098674512,
0.0002001539,
-0.0567134246,
0.0187873561,
0.047031153,
-0.0263428148,
0.0781449527,
-0.0075986804,
0.0217006877,
0.0026729295,
0.0037013451,
0.019890096,
0.0371053033,
0.0203780383,
0.0061335703,
-0.0165923908,
-0.0236853156,
-0.0073593352,
0.0076943524,
0.0089877415,
0.0065456992,
-0.0741267353,
-0.0507193245,
-0.0037957402,
0.0361168422,
0.1063238159,
0.0716971159,
-0.0385744907,
-0.012892819,
0.1066806689,
0.0866180137,
-0.0378416739,
-0.0008369284,
0.0360701606,
0.0092400992,
-0.0186045915,
0.0233041309,
-0.0642047673,
0.0425836183,
0.0003309971,
0.0029194551,
-0.0284892134,
0.0072986651,
-0.0363197811,
0.000455028,
-0.0079402169,
-0.023978075,
0.0382558405,
-0.0075348197,
0.034470249,
0.0527667738,
-0.046488937,
0.0120406076,
0.0689646453,
-0.0233543999,
0.0053085759,
0.002065171,
0.0238264855,
0.0185929798,
0.0015561755,
0.0157193355,
0.0125014447,
0.0215483811,
0.0473543741,
0.1060051695,
-0.0166934226,
0.0148320263,
0.016405331,
-0.0373743437,
-0.027114084,
-0.0191632081,
0.015776962,
0.0072017503,
0.0101805739,
-0.0344007313,
-0.0232284591,
-0.0529868789,
-0.0395036452,
0.0863681883,
-0.0108414022,
-0.032114353,
-0.0409445353,
0.0239989571,
0.0092574712,
-0.0396820121,
-0.0188730173,
0.023601573,
0.0300955549,
-0.0287177619,
-0.0026810132,
0.013384237,
-0.0825682878,
-0.0371523723,
0.0002611016,
-0.0451799631,
-0.0017671559,
0.0287163779,
0.0195975117,
-0.020529788,
0.0263801385,
-0.0381196626,
0.0417608134,
-0.0568818972,
0.0033137633,
0.0091599161,
0.0624813586,
-0.0161149967,
0.0579171516,
-0.0343531258,
-0.012558803,
-0.0303683802,
0.0100512011,
-0.0025198876,
-0.011734291,
-0.0119873714,
-0.0222559646,
-0.0108203953,
0.018531397,
-0.0069825309,
0.0347657725,
-0.0537197702,
0.0136197805,
-0.0911819786,
-0.0078209788,
0.027788369,
-0.0204056483,
0.0087849256,
-0.0264124554,
0.0129648298,
-0.039394591,
-0.0175478328,
0.0540416911,
-0.0029668272,
0.0448303744,
0.0606399104,
-0.0237915739,
-0.0176342614,
-0.0496226437,
-0.0123196868,
-0.0105472337,
0.0666986033,
0.0022654422,
-0.0153720891,
-0.0197526496,
0.0213583056,
-0.0396650322,
0.0398164615,
-0.0042635915,
-0.0321509168,
0.05163664,
-0.0054091979,
0.0640231371,
0.0723578408,
0.003484484,
0.0585272536,
0.0587292016,
0.0271221753,
-0.0281694774,
-0.0419721827,
-0.0039683045,
-0.0283998698,
0.0156912636,
0.001181418,
-0.0328942388,
0.0786181167,
0.0389023609,
0.0176580567,
-0.0708350167,
0.030357914,
0.011914704,
-0.0204086751,
-0.0554236099,
-0.0127980374,
-0.0296824723,
0.0211040284,
-0.0742742717,
-0.0828632265,
0.0321073495,
-0.0230996646,
-0.0063875709,
0.0048572938,
-0.0186446477,
0.0140647031,
0.0613746829,
0.0413168669,
0.03694655,
-0.0318651274,
-0.0028323354,
-0.0778194368,
0.0257263631,
0.0249441788,
0.0091447756,
0.0383641683,
-0.0568503626,
-0.0043151914,
0.001692331,
0.000675251,
-0.0500877872,
-0.0189141668,
-0.0414211564,
-0.0055681835,
-0.0378512181,
0.039631214,
-0.0027349256,
-0.0000032065,
0.0464439094,
0.0165012479,
0.0136608165,
-0.0114246206,
-0.0252202488,
0.0323763937,
0.0366826281,
-0.0179832075,
-0.0273847803,
-0.070140481,
0.0106564378,
0.0373565182,
0.0279681478,
0.0120591316,
-0.0434874631,
0.0717102438,
0.016795354,
0.0479178801,
-0.0081688715,
0.0312012266,
0.0344072133,
-0.0023434951,
-0.0281463191,
0.0562819503,
0.0049889269,
-0.0329205953,
0.0297132712,
0.0123350015,
0.0375441313,
0.0264426302,
-0.015032744,
-0.0371724218,
-0.03588425,
-0.0039412566,
-0.0323004089,
0.0244480688,
-0.0227713622,
-0.0233168211,
-0.0812554881,
-0.0105734803,
0.0133931777,
-0.0592939779,
-0.0200965349,
-0.045597896,
0.0044897986,
0.039393995,
0.0298753921,
-0.010538931,
-0.0127188908,
-0.0048086545,
0.0168673936,
0.0464756042,
-0.0635257363,
0.011203032,
-0.0658378378,
0.0370798595,
0.0299311951,
-0.0021770641,
-0.0341198444,
-0.0505159646,
0.0639322847,
0.0149912201,
0.0227520373,
-0.0068880152,
0.0375281572,
-0.0325855836,
-0.0260359533,
-0.0081788786,
0.055772569,
-0.0217382386,
-0.0331747793,
-0.0486245938,
0.0667328909,
0.000825369,
-0.0267538577,
0.0013201181,
0.0286108833,
-0.0160311144,
0.0563233234,
0.0511533767,
-0.0715351328,
0.0041356324,
0.0372446179,
0.0205977764,
-0.0026514912,
-0.0432102345,
0.0313519575,
-0.0125179682,
-0.0127246324,
-0.0902619362,
-0.0281266198,
0.0314542055,
0.0488696024,
0.0212428086,
-0.012579307,
0.0211174227,
-0.0484285355,
-0.02451526,
0.0729825273,
-0.0367091373,
-0.0062660645,
-0.0569122098,
-0.0422541611,
0.0101261511,
-0.0478527136,
-0.0067663128,
-0.0072080493,
-0.0585541949,
-0.0609980524,
-0.0068188179,
0.0151042826,
0.015982924,
0.0366574228,
0.0520283952,
-0.0166628286,
0.0396489128,
0.0472184867,
0.0003247017,
0.0490072258,
-0.0353735574,
-0.0168815907,
0.0016225615,
0.0050149779,
-0.0121204527,
0.0313818939,
0.0310825054,
0.0351289026,
0.0152103975,
0.0203364603,
0.0390756577,
-0.0269741211,
0.0729626268,
-0.0352572575,
0.0011173867,
-0.0730035529,
-0.0468938574,
0.0111279851,
0.0144892475,
-0.0320830829,
-0.0249567125,
0.0459719449,
0.0448518023,
-0.0072016795,
-0.0351681374,
-0.0019472037,
0.0918376073,
0.0017582157,
-0.0548967123,
0.0033918619,
-0.010268487,
-0.0451655835,
0.0394627154,
0.0010515943,
0.0129250893,
-0.073617503,
0.0263815429,
0.0080572926,
0.0605164766,
0.0137607455,
-0.027145613,
-0.0219553635,
0.0214380249,
-0.022396924,
0.0022243212,
-0.0422452465,
0.0173803121,
0.0531569906,
-0.0515981689,
-0.0109666949,
-0.0431220978,
0.016884828,
0.0057757306,
0.0230451096,
-0.0339327231,
-0.0463598035,
0.0706488118,
0.0237293094,
0.0066569797,
0.0042617735,
0.0628674999,
0.0525178611,
0.0467616618,
-0.0436395518,
0.0159013346,
-0.0363604724,
0.0053467271,
0.0638840124,
0.0067496193,
-0.02088397,
0.0556942858,
-0.033957392,
-0.0704140961,
-0.032673452,
0.0321574248,
0.0015565134,
-0.0172116403,
0.0554630011,
0.0208780952,
-0.0059491345,
0.0281408466,
-0.005186188,
0.0150789255,
0.0307967477,
0.0034358529,
-0.0211162027,
-5.854348311e-33,
-0.0384180248,
-0.0331428945,
0.0202849228,
0.0052930843,
-0.017356962,
0.0237398297,
-0.0252068061,
0.0269476511,
-0.0107847834,
0.0273959171,
0.0293000136,
-0.0022586484,
-0.0051860339,
0.0272323582,
0.0215705056,
0.00003963,
0.0076000579,
-0.0475904047,
0.0165260658,
-0.0249207001,
0.0125703588,
0.0182732847,
0.0597533807,
-0.0290687457,
0.0050972085,
0.0105740596,
0.0074216202,
0.0384331271,
0.0282330923,
0.0432850309,
-0.0635074452,
0.0208872594,
0.0324202292,
0.0220585708,
-0.0297290105,
0.0367082432,
-0.0743813664,
-0.011342288,
0.0398222283,
0.0176426731,
-0.0768722817,
0.0217334311,
0.0658758804,
-0.0470091626,
-0.0172445159,
0.0205983836,
0.0209386088,
-0.0196277779,
-0.0407560468,
0.0300922059,
-0.0644301698,
-0.0277964044,
0.0317713618,
-0.0285939761,
0.0015634007,
0.0037336445,
-0.0118725514,
0.0094026579,
-0.018264506,
0.0197675154,
-0.0435434058,
0.0145671628,
0.0584018864,
0.0405501239,
0.0259181503,
0.0939740166,
0.0326740481,
-0.0039043773,
-0.0429244265,
-0.0287849475,
0.0865810886,
0.0369804278,
0.0155052254,
0.0166123919,
0.0231017079,
-0.0031370209,
-0.0381292701,
0.0124092335,
-0.0280128177,
0.054224778,
0.020798916,
-0.0034762321,
-0.0070044082,
-0.0145847276,
-0.0412439518,
-0.0354777873,
-0.050006941,
-0.0091548385,
0.0371358544,
0.0239671674,
0.0095997751,
-0.0300315581,
0.0157252308,
-0.0319886133,
0.0028905997,
-0.0032354151,
0.001021124,
0.0163035784,
-0.0011204439,
-0.014770858,
-0.0450750962,
-0.0689668953,
0.04983541,
0.0159415603,
0.021719519,
0.0291601308,
0.052225519,
-0.0042870827,
-0.0181563366,
-0.0163180195,
-0.0527999662,
-0.0537142456,
0.0174384918,
-0.018439997,
0.0513216034,
0.0146339256,
-0.0584930629,
0.0108473143,
0.0055717444,
-0.0291580111,
-0.0174672808,
-0.0405683257,
-0.0354156829,
0.0559535213,
-0.0247137547,
-0.0059747389,
-0.0459449291,
-0.0360290073,
0.055573944,
-0.0592515618,
-0.0137231508,
0.0156416669,
2.517e-7,
-0.0022193827,
0.0357880592,
0.0034959263,
-0.0066957353,
0.0243520252,
0.0175019819,
-0.0235098153,
0.0307105593,
-0.0370345637,
-0.0889866352,
-0.0209817477,
0.0497005023,
0.0230444148,
-0.0245980788,
-0.0194020011,
0.0230750218,
-0.0401897766,
0.0108327977,
-0.0295631569,
-0.0059522185,
0.0342015475,
0.0530189276,
-0.0160860009,
-0.0580050983,
0.0054111406,
-0.0362060107,
0.0976793021,
-0.0351536274,
0.0041377838,
-0.0551790334,
0.008607829,
0.0293448698,
-0.0074742092,
0.0296239182,
0.0015972483,
-0.0040591061,
0.0318199173,
0.0176260602,
-0.0211007427,
0.0061884536,
-0.0114973895,
0.0159002766,
-0.033808738,
-0.016876502,
0.0495333783,
-0.0518912114,
-0.0119316988,
0.0143011259,
0.0046611745,
0.0029389428,
0.0135716442,
-0.0170725994,
-0.0653908402,
-0.0122811971,
0.0427150279,
0.0135839246,
-0.0272710696,
-0.040020749,
-0.016381247,
0.0472458862,
-0.0470938981,
-0.0024990826,
-0.049255278,
-0.0221972242,
0.0507313944,
-0.012492964,
-0.0392572768,
1.78649944e-34,
-0.0033775894,
-0.0302116908,
0.0407643914,
0.0052695158,
0.016693458,
-0.0326195545,
-0.000228632,
0.0021993625,
0.0214291103,
-0.0536345653,
0.0042153024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13247v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13247v1 | Anomaly Detection of Command Shell Sessions based on DistilBERT: Unsupervised and Supervised Approaches | 2023-10-20T03:04:32 | 2023-10-20T03:04:32 | Zefang Liu, John Buford | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Anomaly detection in command shell sessions is a critical aspect of computer
security. Recent advances in deep learning and natural language processing,
particularly transformer-based models, have shown great promise for addressing
complex security challenges. In this paper, we implement a comprehensive
approach to detect anomalies in Unix shell sessions using a pretrained
DistilBERT model, leveraging both unsupervised and supervised learning
techniques to identify anomalous activity while minimizing data labeling. The
unsupervised method captures the underlying structure and syntax of Unix shell
commands, enabling the detection of session deviations from normal behavior.
Experiments on a large-scale enterprise dataset collected from production
systems demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in detecting anomalous
behavior in Unix shell sessions. This work highlights the potential of
leveraging recent advances in transformers to address important computer
security challenges. | [
0.0405387469,
0.0270439554,
0.0072232448,
0.0524522513,
-0.0353109539,
-0.0172915198,
0.0456915982,
-0.0157029331,
0.0191985182,
-0.0182749536,
0.0217131637,
-0.0306337234,
-0.0223596729,
0.0612802021,
0.0338161997,
-0.0104696676,
0.0852154046,
-0.0221328493,
-0.0429973789,
0.0055478849,
-0.0128372116,
-0.0121421283,
-0.0312720127,
0.0374038443,
-0.001089293,
-0.0158979129,
-0.0368853323,
0.0273876898,
0.0313948505,
-0.0018941724,
0.0204746071,
0.0242793225,
-0.0049687088,
0.0719028115,
0.0000018824,
-0.0490870923,
-0.0099934489,
-0.0043971767,
-0.0478892773,
-0.0015689676,
-0.0131206419,
0.0000531912,
-0.0120143015,
0.0145275602,
-0.0413524695,
-0.0027800989,
0.0153697031,
0.0847679526,
0.0570237152,
0.0651484951,
-0.0235799421,
-0.0275603402,
-0.0161864199,
-0.0048003024,
-0.0175727606,
0.0224277563,
0.0293387584,
-0.0400731973,
-0.0211527999,
-0.0058248788,
-0.0263354145,
-0.0933643803,
0.0008499717,
-0.0395001993,
-0.0098009389,
0.0645256862,
-0.0146238077,
-0.0232794434,
-0.0070259627,
0.0483138338,
-0.0730558038,
0.0269251484,
0.0288110897,
0.0085338643,
-0.0034732358,
-0.0137862815,
0.0200772714,
0.0420824215,
-0.0250346512,
-0.0398960039,
0.0263656545,
0.0609253161,
0.007428715,
0.0054214043,
-0.0468655042,
0.0549387597,
0.0381377786,
-0.0269178227,
-0.0242571607,
-0.0341662355,
-0.0170588065,
-0.0449159145,
0.0111395493,
0.0326076709,
-0.0396272913,
-0.0226647742,
-0.0338371433,
-0.029806599,
0.0249772295,
0.0227509309,
-0.0220923238,
0.0198186152,
-0.0494343974,
0.0112670716,
-0.0025626391,
0.0800661892,
-0.0072295698,
0.041383028,
0.0317188203,
0.0359662101,
-0.0855428129,
-0.0004872606,
-0.0158930477,
0.0509554185,
0.0040972685,
-0.0119670108,
-0.0454234853,
0.0682888255,
0.0180367511,
0.0262952615,
0.0253938418,
0.0091640577,
-0.0440916419,
0.0376329683,
0.0269365814,
-0.0205927007,
-0.0366762839,
-0.0275484808,
-0.003984544,
-0.0553646795,
-0.0280944593,
0.0212810505,
-0.0266636647,
-0.0449041165,
-0.0191622954,
0.0641438663,
0.0249071084,
0.0067918776,
-0.082088612,
-0.0857511386,
-0.0122312559,
0.0291955005,
-0.0135090854,
-0.0566171557,
-0.0342646763,
-0.0399154834,
0.0257645883,
-0.009891686,
-0.0140994526,
-0.0421718694,
-0.0258474872,
0.0453194901,
-0.0055608773,
-0.0311444569,
0.0039065811,
0.0315612406,
0.0271257628,
-0.0495122857,
-0.0471418276,
0.0588218682,
0.0155444779,
-0.0641220883,
0.0960780829,
-0.0177071467,
-0.026643144,
-0.0199484844,
-0.0132290591,
0.0353022777,
-0.0128791872,
-0.0497829653,
0.0501448214,
0.0479119606,
0.0219462495,
-0.0537181124,
0.0353081115,
0.0483123176,
-0.0254764929,
0.0175761618,
0.0268302169,
0.0195410941,
-0.0704195872,
0.0205908921,
-0.022437498,
-0.0011336476,
-0.0335100293,
-0.0408104584,
-0.0520604588,
0.0303956028,
-0.0260172449,
-0.0215664022,
0.0248794444,
-0.0486932434,
0.0057493011,
-0.0587562546,
0.028058853,
0.0347751379,
0.0119298119,
0.0265888274,
0.0153258862,
0.0155257536,
0.0112689324,
-0.0572828278,
0.0014048411,
0.0647424608,
0.0218892675,
-0.0247718561,
-0.018243093,
-0.0683769211,
0.0100520076,
0.0076707718,
-0.0312189534,
0.0201800689,
0.0435018763,
-0.0339315571,
0.0012953699,
-0.026604522,
0.0145021519,
0.0280081648,
-0.0572011806,
-0.0013855158,
0.0151400389,
-0.0564728007,
0.0043582167,
0.0533454344,
0.0213785544,
-0.0956996307,
0.0353557616,
0.0458061323,
0.004568208,
-0.0099799559,
0.0207970459,
0.0153071536,
0.017918678,
0.0055579976,
-0.0345332138,
0.0018567158,
-0.0222643036,
0.0204455014,
0.0042820787,
-0.0337576531,
0.0056135496,
0.0394770354,
-0.0547384396,
-0.046949558,
0.0510922186,
-0.0828970298,
-0.013044131,
-0.0036497149,
-0.0241961982,
0.0250344891,
0.066769734,
-0.0168840159,
0.0424215049,
-0.0070070759,
-0.0026686946,
-0.009487127,
-0.0040548136,
0.033467371,
0.0081550851,
-0.0431360789,
-0.0256068781,
-0.0825181976,
0.0225086734,
0.050845392,
-0.0146959452,
0.0049542584,
0.0157372318,
0.033798907,
-0.0111984117,
-0.0357357301,
0.0447314382,
0.0440924801,
0.0425118878,
-0.0359826311,
-0.034618251,
0.0115768528,
-0.0776957422,
0.0238855649,
-0.0002891904,
0.0680603832,
0.016028747,
-0.0649691522,
-0.0131393764,
-0.015041857,
-0.0394404233,
0.0411449634,
-0.0198897198,
0.0058458778,
-0.0292553026,
0.0508918092,
0.0171521436,
0.001590378,
-0.0097752986,
-0.0273339245,
0.0051421486,
0.000608991,
0.0299496464,
0.0772176534,
0.0458188467,
0.0354496688,
0.0190859791,
-0.0020030795,
-0.0072188238,
-0.0313173272,
-0.0341258794,
-0.0195365269,
-0.0192760359,
-0.0013673484,
0.0496929735,
0.0717698708,
0.0371415392,
-0.0361578017,
-0.0222743433,
-0.024708584,
0.0174862556,
-0.0210965984,
-0.0304223951,
-0.0560341105,
-0.0160011891,
0.0255706981,
0.0043977005,
-0.0482899249,
0.0698452815,
-0.0366593301,
-0.0125814956,
-0.0307278819,
-0.0808633044,
0.0086282417,
0.0391155109,
0.0468684733,
-0.004368837,
-0.0061299587,
-0.1178036407,
-0.005751343,
-0.0148816006,
0.0144953504,
-0.0078498945,
0.007151613,
-0.010375605,
-0.0096571976,
0.0090859449,
0.0035203109,
-0.1020709872,
-0.0870259851,
0.0152018024,
-0.03896714,
0.0126177967,
-0.0346584991,
-0.0503624976,
-0.022118764,
0.0094010737,
0.0205769278,
0.0197991896,
-0.0301687233,
-0.0188837424,
0.0155960619,
0.0130090797,
-0.0361018516,
-0.0299984347,
0.0030720332,
0.0324288979,
0.0308742691,
-0.0004109632,
-0.01917715,
-0.0386711098,
-0.0031849234,
-0.0347397365,
-0.0281507038,
0.0298503581,
0.0530404672,
-0.0133797573,
0.0043520504,
-0.0403703116,
0.0875757784,
0.0229939483,
0.0064947535,
0.0252562147,
0.0032312816,
-0.0039714552,
-0.0043629012,
0.0033307448,
-0.0498479307,
0.0162869915,
-0.0030256708,
0.0435674153,
-0.006562049,
-0.0520740971,
0.021579437,
-0.0667072609,
-0.0062095416,
-0.0083716754,
-0.0184053332,
-0.0607082807,
-0.0194271356,
-0.02758931,
-0.0168896765,
0.0245593246,
-0.0353536792,
0.0095018167,
-0.0076006334,
0.0512866788,
-0.0690237135,
-0.0544727109,
0.0466071665,
-0.0410223827,
-0.0102251917,
0.0682327002,
-0.022786336,
-0.023645319,
-0.0237493962,
-0.0043851444,
0.0078949202,
0.0452631898,
0.033275675,
0.0313786939,
0.0349316411,
-0.0133274551,
-0.0239163209,
0.0501522906,
-0.0684610754,
-0.0275484398,
0.033805754,
0.0500916094,
-0.0934495106,
0.0047110897,
0.0042766766,
-0.0081473142,
0.0536569208,
0.0280736126,
-0.0066081975,
-0.0346902572,
0.0053796712,
0.0056295609,
0.0068674744,
-0.011952796,
-0.0191465765,
0.0217213463,
0.0328239948,
-0.0309480242,
-0.0371435173,
-0.0303619225,
-0.0141216181,
-0.010321497,
0.0245769043,
-0.0361378081,
0.0147297112,
0.0053381845,
-0.0424092747,
-0.0190548077,
-0.020523306,
0.0547145829,
-0.0371740796,
0.0490326881,
-0.0080584083,
0.0073156124,
-0.0609071217,
-0.0046648607,
-0.0679539889,
-0.0305424575,
0.0522467792,
0.0167468488,
0.0131892916,
-0.002648813,
-0.0580443814,
-0.0261168387,
0.0657269657,
0.0463334732,
-0.0093415882,
-0.0307313018,
0.0472753644,
-0.0495763756,
-0.0006769449,
-0.0294585936,
0.0097145392,
0.0488542765,
0.0181212388,
-0.0450384505,
-0.0797107667,
-0.0524001606,
0.0287919287,
-0.0009449453,
0.06612131,
0.0149610629,
0.0378681794,
0.0105998768,
0.0441228971,
0.0046618651,
0.0044044005,
0.0465847477,
0.0169922318,
0.057536535,
0.0100494483,
0.0519073345,
0.0341144428,
-0.0132923918,
-0.002211649,
-0.0128982887,
0.0056099077,
0.0674810708,
0.0259379484,
0.0026628822,
0.0231336802,
0.0279413294,
0.0171445664,
0.0574279688,
0.0924544409,
0.0029535806,
0.0611839853,
0.0043281219,
0.0414043628,
-0.0364332646,
0.0300792661,
-0.0693571121,
0.0152632399,
0.0193208065,
-0.0215595551,
0.0014705861,
-0.0185710005,
-0.0344785675,
-0.0249164756,
0.0313972048,
-0.032175947,
0.0385162868,
0.0022863611,
0.0529275164,
-0.0108304042,
-0.0095687117,
-0.0388672538,
0.0162725337,
0.0630208477,
-0.0257221423,
0.0320366472,
0.0543707088,
-0.0283883717,
-0.0394455828,
0.0244656634,
0.0103564598,
0.0453181155,
-0.0281519275,
-0.0492900349,
-0.0040682014,
0.0031604022,
-0.0218954571,
0.0005205308,
0.043008361,
0.0194929,
0.0327847078,
0.0712253302,
-0.0242031049,
0.005761866,
-0.0657639429,
-0.0032364894,
0.0001583366,
-0.0395967178,
-0.0352617018,
-4.86844577e-33,
0.0221711285,
-0.0058752662,
-0.0185535941,
0.0646172166,
0.036477387,
-0.0107676284,
-0.0038819807,
0.0088529196,
-0.0006970328,
0.0118416678,
0.0271285083,
0.0068073324,
0.0261545721,
0.0030790993,
-0.0049310294,
-0.0293447413,
0.03273803,
0.0286161862,
0.0017896212,
0.0433641858,
0.0749091655,
0.0459648557,
0.0296331402,
-0.1153080687,
0.0049649454,
-0.0211276375,
0.0058574439,
0.0028625885,
0.0176931825,
0.0126661053,
-0.0075991135,
0.0277977809,
0.0117177768,
-0.0488731153,
-0.0288745258,
0.0322397538,
0.0002700899,
-0.0113047333,
-0.0420464911,
-0.0019542291,
0.0239879396,
-0.0181337222,
0.0085092988,
-0.0066246935,
0.0127256913,
0.0140471989,
0.0390562303,
0.0117511321,
0.0195984934,
-0.0247745961,
-0.0414538458,
-0.0191297997,
-0.036657352,
-0.0260965191,
-0.0214350615,
-0.0012901425,
0.0589478053,
0.0175539348,
-0.0673573464,
0.0577515066,
0.0290674362,
0.0087137474,
0.0209164228,
0.0140646752,
-0.0433450267,
-0.0160541739,
0.0202518292,
-0.0119590191,
-0.0121911736,
0.0518780872,
-0.0057428437,
0.0882943571,
0.0224680994,
0.0237760395,
0.0482471101,
-0.0480029173,
-0.03991675,
0.04331512,
0.0223921966,
0.014205819,
0.0026975984,
-0.0020209861,
-0.0452329926,
0.0120592881,
0.0358189531,
0.0421571247,
0.000841635,
-0.0046248832,
0.0016454887,
-0.0162796676,
-0.0461441204,
-0.0150769195,
0.0274794977,
-0.0735226274,
0.0079422295,
-0.0035096586,
-0.0013159299,
-0.0220260844,
-0.0146204159,
-0.0239649694,
0.038465742,
-0.0268666614,
0.0565888546,
-0.0193587188,
0.0297222063,
-0.0227733999,
0.0222372487,
0.0328461975,
-0.0642265975,
0.0125972517,
-0.0027396132,
0.0375180505,
-0.0269627571,
0.078485541,
0.0108866971,
0.0011501063,
-0.0231128018,
0.0238968097,
-0.0043521114,
-0.0123820454,
-0.0298401266,
0.0196966473,
-0.0190965533,
0.0051940968,
-0.0333805606,
-0.0112987868,
-0.0192870237,
0.0019523362,
0.0463042483,
-0.0333405919,
0.0199511107,
-0.0215939414,
2.842e-7,
0.0079920171,
0.0089656785,
0.0741166323,
-0.0376864746,
0.0150419092,
0.0497286841,
0.0146518862,
0.0653364658,
-0.0548677221,
-0.0925614536,
0.0383755453,
-0.0369798802,
0.0342508107,
-0.0011072496,
-0.0090571065,
-0.0339170806,
-0.0786896348,
-0.0503504314,
-0.0765990764,
0.001150314,
0.0699121952,
0.1109145805,
0.0388696119,
-0.0591370687,
0.0300145093,
-0.085388355,
-0.0206788909,
0.0487042144,
0.0062448098,
0.0022118401,
0.0521729514,
0.0606663115,
0.0590243675,
0.0698422268,
-0.0462485403,
-0.0156118469,
-0.0561685227,
-0.0019839904,
0.0043318621,
-0.0037819992,
-0.0587268099,
-0.0259140693,
-0.0031864988,
-0.0406345688,
0.0348174088,
-0.0365061089,
0.0047351336,
0.0167387277,
-0.0250008944,
0.0027477893,
0.02780517,
-0.0112765729,
0.0176240392,
0.0141597241,
0.0401884392,
-0.0026160055,
0.0342745818,
-0.0538461544,
-0.0136151677,
0.0014115651,
-0.065064542,
0.0000961447,
0.032469783,
0.0015632138,
0.0549757369,
0.0669908747,
0.0021515705,
2.567482619e-34,
0.0032676945,
0.0149447657,
-0.0112257767,
-0.0428056158,
-0.014212097,
0.0329648182,
-0.0811863169,
0.0173098594,
-0.0036383192,
-0.0111182621,
-0.0060156682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13243v1 | Open-source Large Language Models are Strong Zero-shot Query Likelihood Models for Document Ranking | 2023-10-20T02:54:42 | 2023-10-20T02:54:42 | Shengyao Zhuang, Bing Liu, Bevan Koopman, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In the field of information retrieval, Query Likelihood Models (QLMs) rank
documents based on the probability of generating the query given the content of
a document. Recently, advanced large language models (LLMs) have emerged as
effective QLMs, showcasing promising ranking capabilities. This paper focuses
on investigating the genuine zero-shot ranking effectiveness of recent LLMs,
which are solely pre-trained on unstructured text data without supervised
instruction fine-tuning. Our findings reveal the robust zero-shot ranking
ability of such LLMs, highlighting that additional instruction fine-tuning may
hinder effectiveness unless a question generation task is present in the
fine-tuning dataset. Furthermore, we introduce a novel state-of-the-art ranking
system that integrates LLM-based QLMs with a hybrid zero-shot retriever,
demonstrating exceptional effectiveness in both zero-shot and few-shot
scenarios. We make our codebase publicly available at
https://github.com/ielab/llm-qlm. | [
0.0182989314,
0.0249786153,
0.0185371172,
0.0241410229,
0.0042380095,
0.0198411103,
0.0220504813,
-0.0028718086,
0.0246868748,
-0.0743701011,
-0.0419181362,
-0.0253135841,
-0.046409484,
-0.0011609353,
0.0133483401,
0.0268677305,
0.033313714,
-0.0191534255,
-0.0119833443,
0.0038771557,
-0.0309471283,
0.022570869,
0.0236791894,
-0.0010273886,
0.0841895938,
0.0049109273,
-0.038600307,
0.0332533941,
-0.0015189063,
-0.0386817567,
-0.0116854543,
0.0367444418,
0.0319919251,
0.0491944924,
0.0000017986,
-0.062582396,
-0.0341808386,
0.0043648807,
-0.0218292326,
0.0018233035,
0.0067455061,
0.0021006202,
0.0364469774,
0.0193244629,
-0.0372132473,
-0.0007659132,
0.0035732277,
0.0246296488,
0.0287657715,
0.0670697615,
0.0049398518,
-0.0224835724,
0.027912885,
-0.0312020872,
0.0888444707,
-0.0578772165,
0.0268267244,
-0.0216196291,
0.0174721833,
0.0816592872,
0.0135233887,
-0.003605813,
-0.0084467717,
-0.0171105396,
0.0316887498,
0.0353039689,
-0.0884807929,
-0.0030879402,
0.030584272,
0.0971847773,
-0.0317037329,
-0.0316187553,
0.0251751598,
-0.0039938181,
-0.0111148497,
0.012798328,
-0.0741485432,
0.0362139642,
0.0180171467,
0.0009645128,
0.0203884356,
0.0028627645,
0.0196334589,
0.0257853698,
-0.030171236,
0.0768943205,
0.0218256731,
-0.039002683,
-0.000336727,
-0.0180729963,
-0.0105172843,
-0.0390414447,
-0.0239754543,
0.0288382173,
-0.0211232901,
0.0121868318,
-0.0191167686,
-0.0065642106,
0.0432330854,
-0.0486475639,
0.0137055358,
0.0061389222,
0.0218221005,
0.0988773704,
-0.0401144736,
0.0164697953,
0.0174075328,
0.0040956382,
-0.0435940064,
-0.0042677028,
-0.0248193163,
-0.0264422558,
-0.0138077531,
0.035430491,
-0.0427371114,
-0.0287757311,
-0.022849828,
0.0326758921,
0.0361170396,
-0.0060976292,
0.0016717515,
0.0309835467,
-0.0622237176,
-0.0095954966,
-0.026533151,
0.0253832452,
0.0085239653,
0.001979782,
-0.0110009806,
-0.0220378041,
-0.0103090741,
0.0123649491,
0.0251693539,
-0.0540768914,
0.0132905617,
-0.0247653686,
-0.0133635122,
-0.0385897197,
-0.0194060318,
-0.0425870717,
0.0297787674,
-0.0494141616,
-0.0118487673,
-0.0575072318,
-0.0032102931,
0.0240966957,
0.0160883516,
0.0236537699,
0.0202349331,
0.0496106409,
-0.0443053171,
0.047133252,
0.0354169868,
-0.00171922,
0.0043498911,
0.0058225663,
0.0488321744,
0.0442452803,
-0.0360262133,
0.0314251631,
0.0462402813,
0.0158799868,
0.0115702786,
-0.0003845814,
0.0174643472,
0.0303082597,
-0.0012179583,
0.0422574766,
-0.0034728558,
0.0303727239,
0.0054926779,
0.0048897709,
-0.0363234207,
-0.0183824971,
0.0373482183,
0.0320026539,
0.0466353931,
-0.024548972,
0.0246881694,
0.0318396688,
-0.0259170588,
-0.0184665918,
-0.0138311582,
0.0301326886,
-0.0361984335,
0.0003015751,
0.0633208528,
-0.0009837218,
-0.0453658216,
-0.0055277972,
-0.0039696922,
0.0179148596,
-0.0596367009,
0.013930575,
0.0613699257,
0.0052152765,
-0.039809715,
-0.0054476326,
0.0041472879,
-0.0344773196,
0.001566674,
-0.0434117615,
0.0468669683,
0.0449925326,
0.0760958418,
-0.0539541431,
-0.0315042473,
-0.0082895029,
0.0141875222,
-0.0061466848,
-0.0030799792,
-0.0239380021,
0.0215669814,
-0.0474605411,
-0.0295748729,
-0.0076119984,
0.0165574178,
-0.0018084657,
-0.0217688289,
0.0345071293,
0.0507838316,
-0.0572398379,
-0.0271064248,
0.0126821538,
-0.0409391485,
-0.068282567,
0.0651692748,
-0.0222317129,
-0.0035621063,
0.0063159554,
-0.0110364761,
0.0245033577,
0.0629983619,
-0.006033794,
-0.0189286117,
-0.0407644846,
0.0063122199,
-0.0277624521,
0.013283846,
-0.0132173868,
0.0473302752,
0.0213243105,
-0.040438097,
-0.0374547318,
-0.0126370238,
0.0512060858,
0.017107049,
-0.0569800697,
0.0107386447,
0.0065694461,
-0.0160948373,
-0.0725815967,
0.0670176074,
0.0305609982,
0.0796174109,
0.0381888263,
0.0222122408,
-0.0012018201,
-0.0494595356,
-0.0582102984,
0.0167140886,
-0.0077336901,
0.0281838663,
0.0157246739,
0.0155306868,
-0.046422217,
0.0130912093,
-0.1163650453,
0.0505120829,
-0.0198652279,
-0.0040785414,
-0.001478003,
0.0217131078,
-0.010357907,
-0.014796922,
-0.0491522439,
-0.0308282599,
0.0248989947,
0.0174830016,
0.0090341046,
0.0064359009,
0.0329221264,
-0.0188914631,
-0.0365928337,
0.0096763261,
0.0393101163,
0.0101902261,
0.045256488,
-0.004318404,
0.0714835301,
-0.0493932031,
-0.0150410095,
-0.0154475812,
0.0140516972,
-0.015592997,
-0.0810208693,
-0.0030450644,
0.0753451288,
0.0139698032,
-0.017284425,
0.0253549721,
0.0034349668,
-0.0815055072,
-0.0092213722,
-0.0353298523,
-0.007988777,
0.015300707,
-0.0145949563,
-0.0040965304,
0.0202189926,
-0.0189505443,
-0.0282663275,
-0.0114338333,
0.0553483702,
-0.0053703766,
-0.0020757127,
-0.0821298286,
0.0515739731,
0.0331534073,
0.0554189719,
-0.0040177037,
-0.0278693996,
0.0288719181,
0.0009654063,
0.0071730111,
-0.0248629004,
0.0152443387,
-0.0574645512,
0.0217804983,
0.0186118614,
0.0103879077,
-0.0097497338,
0.0160204526,
-0.0220040623,
0.0382406265,
0.018742267,
-0.040171016,
0.0134159382,
0.0145815853,
0.0384038873,
-0.0287926327,
-0.050889384,
-0.0256122574,
-0.058598876,
0.0199277531,
0.0046018516,
-0.02039106,
-0.011546473,
-0.0405851193,
0.0100751556,
0.0318553671,
0.0374947898,
-0.0681899264,
-0.0278463699,
0.0010308332,
0.0693146735,
0.0797736049,
-0.0618865266,
-0.0071276464,
-0.024423968,
0.0279930457,
0.0357318856,
0.0690416247,
0.0181914177,
0.0227755457,
-0.0283091962,
0.0376367196,
-0.0258697886,
-0.0239564516,
0.0197165981,
-0.0117636025,
-0.0024434268,
-0.0413777493,
0.1256184727,
0.0603897013,
-0.0536307693,
-0.0381206796,
-0.0425044857,
0.0313851908,
0.03707489,
0.0577079616,
-0.1035927385,
-0.0046747536,
0.0014880882,
0.0506844893,
-0.0036707721,
-0.0446651764,
0.0027694684,
-0.1418772936,
0.0713198334,
-0.016660966,
0.0090693748,
0.0061983149,
-0.0644440427,
0.0046807677,
-0.0347032472,
-0.0442478992,
0.0513760261,
-0.0353772752,
0.0224773623,
-0.0000785059,
0.0411544517,
-0.0361142643,
0.0124493251,
-0.0273976177,
0.0046133036,
0.0299767945,
0.0252062678,
-0.006618686,
-0.0030404653,
-0.0030387882,
-0.0452155583,
-0.0300747547,
-0.0189217366,
0.0170722976,
-0.0462297387,
0.0216496941,
-0.0283627808,
0.0155329779,
-0.006252497,
0.0311307274,
-0.0055153477,
0.0385386497,
-0.0456994846,
0.005344192,
-0.0258048847,
-0.0378396288,
-0.0220292024,
0.0751166642,
0.0037210421,
-0.0125659872,
-0.0348383933,
-0.0422012173,
0.0237585958,
-0.0121852113,
-0.0249045677,
0.0076855808,
-0.0129389754,
-0.0091828983,
-0.0582907721,
-0.0345498584,
0.0211834516,
0.0506535582,
-0.0096538598,
0.033460211,
-0.0310182385,
-0.038410753,
-0.0331920274,
0.0033403928,
-0.0206962787,
-0.005460002,
-0.0649843663,
0.0152419386,
0.0944375247,
-0.0479792841,
-0.0251954067,
-0.0659876391,
-0.0512906052,
-0.0425128415,
-0.0504826382,
0.0479350798,
0.016756108,
0.0121571105,
-0.0471417867,
-0.0617820807,
0.0511721112,
0.0819936022,
-0.0018049153,
0.0049678069,
-0.0068533947,
-0.0010420943,
-0.0057695666,
0.0325392559,
-0.06312114,
0.0268433411,
-0.0204104036,
0.0417617857,
-0.0234409478,
-0.0443712547,
0.0188264865,
0.0383833013,
0.0580342747,
0.020923188,
0.0294108037,
-0.0260450412,
0.0327065326,
-0.0314850509,
-0.0424327627,
-0.0318168625,
0.0294550192,
0.0615833886,
0.006572118,
-0.0158140063,
0.0318350233,
-0.0351671167,
0.0835782811,
-0.0871041864,
-0.024660619,
0.0183133371,
-0.0214343108,
0.0213673841,
-0.014973483,
-0.0238837395,
0.0226063784,
0.0328583084,
0.0801859647,
-0.0171463564,
0.0389237702,
0.0102920057,
0.0096303495,
-0.0257467832,
0.0221554004,
-0.071084708,
-0.0514598638,
-0.0195397418,
0.0023174011,
0.0535025969,
-0.007427474,
0.0366248488,
0.009540475,
-0.0127764577,
-0.0275946669,
-0.0048902687,
0.0299927238,
-0.010729135,
-0.0062987003,
0.0570213497,
0.0080157267,
0.0642698035,
0.0916827098,
0.0368810929,
0.0017630791,
0.0222257599,
-0.042250894,
-0.0038187653,
0.0149293626,
0.0487036519,
0.0576094911,
-0.0054895571,
0.0111267623,
-0.0287703462,
-0.0338970348,
0.0238540694,
-0.0254571252,
-0.0099470504,
-0.0394336842,
0.0387520231,
0.0692228824,
-0.0093632163,
0.0001518018,
-0.0818774924,
0.0018668586,
-0.0331498906,
-0.0378044844,
0.0010059172,
-6.5167695e-33,
0.000847178,
-0.0300627276,
0.0020113823,
-0.0209486634,
0.0153129296,
-0.0015909555,
0.0090257842,
-0.0231517889,
-0.0123197269,
-0.0199413039,
-0.0227303933,
0.0074239108,
-0.0006537238,
0.0390089937,
0.0181205217,
-0.0155048016,
0.0039735464,
-0.0116329491,
-0.0246819109,
0.0248078797,
0.043102961,
0.0457829498,
-0.0119552724,
-0.0059184697,
0.0147695327,
-0.0446112119,
0.0096623302,
0.0028511598,
0.0025577731,
0.0674700886,
0.0082317563,
0.0217423681,
0.0489065014,
-0.0474337265,
0.0144576933,
0.0125633264,
-0.0412995294,
-0.0166876707,
-0.0140268095,
-0.0458654463,
-0.0092273923,
0.0046423324,
0.0131490612,
0.0084890286,
-0.0044277674,
-0.0217626747,
0.0441102348,
0.0159056727,
-0.0579068437,
-0.0798960626,
-0.0214900952,
0.0219230652,
-0.011461447,
-0.0262157489,
0.0128481919,
0.0742457956,
-0.0287323501,
0.0918301269,
-0.0376778319,
0.0358454175,
-0.0209664833,
0.0525895506,
0.0306848641,
0.0193583984,
-0.0096026594,
0.0381746814,
0.0160902031,
0.0089867245,
-0.0124445856,
-0.000012803,
0.0122592179,
0.0236167479,
-0.0088198297,
0.0340055376,
0.0419481769,
0.048717808,
-0.0815044418,
0.0532364883,
-0.0054728184,
-0.0036983548,
0.0384128727,
0.0159962904,
-0.0353222787,
-0.0275208298,
-0.0333029591,
0.001966018,
-0.0614321083,
-0.0004668696,
0.0396854952,
0.0219644774,
-0.0464273132,
-0.0067639267,
0.0706627667,
-0.0195247345,
-0.0303892307,
0.0394645631,
-0.0076282723,
0.012923087,
-0.0305979978,
0.0350543112,
-0.0824104995,
-0.0030516274,
0.0247078184,
-0.0236648843,
-0.0371010639,
0.0167008862,
0.023046555,
-0.0093293479,
-0.0423358418,
-0.0290304627,
0.0034076425,
-0.0107619045,
-0.0226115175,
0.0624885224,
-0.0108072627,
0.0201304648,
0.0082321735,
0.08440274,
0.0312225111,
0.0053961365,
-0.0156442355,
-0.0477643758,
-0.0035971566,
-0.0391624793,
-0.0108421799,
0.0165855717,
-0.0215324126,
0.0272281729,
0.0061561791,
-0.0641237497,
-0.0163862072,
0.0228879899,
2.697e-7,
0.0327753872,
0.0362002477,
-0.0457577817,
0.0259007569,
0.0226432402,
0.0339723639,
0.0136609264,
0.0650095865,
0.0534413978,
0.0068987482,
0.0144976275,
-0.0055914144,
0.0020207171,
-0.0349407457,
-0.100709863,
-0.0055129388,
-0.0501574576,
-0.0318144523,
-0.0682652146,
-0.0620302223,
0.0293809026,
0.095451124,
-0.0310700256,
0.0073877969,
0.0150810666,
-0.0403016731,
0.0571292005,
0.0306357127,
-0.0495128222,
0.0149951773,
0.0225451402,
0.032979399,
-0.0097384416,
-0.0103970608,
-0.0181069132,
0.0260219984,
0.0332908332,
0.0524518043,
-0.0251105279,
-0.0224783011,
0.0161590315,
-0.008324516,
0.0221702792,
-0.0588291213,
0.1194388792,
-0.0347885527,
-0.0126230717,
0.0249321777,
-0.0640539378,
-0.0064646327,
0.0323597006,
-0.0424150564,
-0.0343756005,
0.0041638217,
0.0020985063,
-0.0148113873,
0.0006457833,
-0.0432608984,
0.0041932608,
-0.03207298,
-0.0238614269,
-0.0466761477,
-0.0073222462,
-0.0139561109,
-0.0204431564,
-0.0372357145,
0.0232540667,
2.711930441e-34,
0.0436225682,
0.0290860459,
0.0032262015,
-0.0170640312,
0.0004773802,
-0.0009408987,
-0.0449479036,
0.0186771136,
0.0273458809,
-0.1165046915,
-0.0230657905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13231v1 | Multi-level Contrastive Learning for Script-based Character Understanding | 2023-10-20T02:40:52 | 2023-10-20T02:40:52 | Dawei Li, Hengyuan Zhang, Yanran Li, Shiping Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this work, we tackle the scenario of understanding characters in scripts,
which aims to learn the characters' personalities and identities from their
utterances. We begin by analyzing several challenges in this scenario, and then
propose a multi-level contrastive learning framework to capture characters'
global information in a fine-grained manner. To validate the proposed
framework, we conduct extensive experiments on three character understanding
sub-tasks by comparing with strong pre-trained language models, including
SpanBERT, Longformer, BigBird and ChatGPT-3.5. Experimental results demonstrate
that our method improves the performances by a considerable margin. Through
further in-depth analysis, we show the effectiveness of our method in
addressing the challenges and provide more hints on the scenario of character
understanding. We will open-source our work on github at
https://github.com/David-Li0406/Script-based-Character-Understanding. | [
-0.0000158164,
0.0627254769,
-0.005412925,
0.066342026,
-0.0346143879,
0.0352783725,
0.0265610851,
-0.000560667,
0.0225229654,
0.0065637277,
-0.0035081923,
-0.0820701271,
0.0376733206,
0.0489242375,
0.0394045599,
-0.1026475355,
0.024215484,
-0.0498151146,
0.0168918911,
0.0009008867,
0.0142095024,
0.0481341034,
-0.0083193434,
0.0308383461,
0.0100397002,
-0.0420173071,
-0.0125460988,
0.0148191629,
0.0890337974,
-0.0217572171,
0.0406353436,
0.0176155828,
0.0389822274,
0.0032364049,
0.0000020042,
-0.0319748968,
-0.029148059,
-0.0180200823,
-0.0115589416,
-0.0109812468,
0.0701100603,
0.0001901219,
-0.0147067299,
0.0194428526,
-0.0019395837,
-0.0326650366,
0.0268418957,
0.0490505137,
0.0402801521,
0.0472373143,
-0.0208805148,
-0.0949443951,
-0.0240581278,
-0.0087281223,
0.0266996045,
-0.0386991426,
0.0001186256,
0.008121226,
0.0114485305,
-0.006749311,
-0.0431893654,
0.00947023,
-0.0093738381,
-0.0087026376,
-0.0409772098,
0.0381784216,
-0.0048784069,
0.0204739571,
0.0181887262,
0.1106583476,
-0.003376028,
0.0165407248,
-0.0352469683,
-0.014875371,
0.0077854036,
-0.0080227964,
-0.004209578,
-0.0033963285,
-0.0269169882,
-0.0010392793,
0.0300477091,
0.0414739884,
0.0043626125,
-0.0180518143,
-0.0521717183,
-0.0346227586,
0.0081783766,
0.0052386359,
-0.0208859593,
-0.0190366153,
-0.0071506687,
-0.0325068459,
0.0113339406,
0.0390127711,
0.0185505971,
0.0017926121,
-0.0025983022,
-0.0134771252,
-0.0150846075,
-0.0007230001,
0.043302685,
0.0432187878,
-0.0670186654,
0.0406096987,
0.0057335556,
0.0527532771,
-0.0144734774,
-0.0184309427,
0.0309798922,
0.0055750431,
-0.0378867052,
0.0168877728,
-0.0351632982,
0.0201713759,
-0.0094632171,
0.0291774347,
0.0212136526,
0.014926224,
0.0236957278,
0.0160059221,
-0.0028930001,
-0.0059075383,
-0.0557358228,
-0.0295009706,
-0.0059623444,
0.074687466,
-0.043131426,
-0.0163086709,
-0.0305939857,
-0.0314190313,
-0.0182323065,
0.0102793043,
0.0267568752,
-0.0142406002,
0.0407546498,
0.1031475067,
-0.0127164945,
-0.0624332428,
-0.0528553836,
0.0037053651,
-0.0384482816,
-0.0571525358,
-0.0652578399,
-0.0448448732,
0.0455446765,
-0.02188606,
0.0188401565,
-0.0249267444,
0.0032119371,
-0.014569656,
-0.0023009041,
0.0973285213,
-0.0011628625,
-0.0498291515,
-0.0149405971,
0.0063238768,
-0.0170912351,
0.0086179646,
0.0327209644,
-0.0127053978,
-0.0431468599,
-0.0288632493,
-0.0033518844,
0.0306591801,
-0.0447045937,
-0.0317724012,
-0.0138895353,
0.0044051819,
0.0399871543,
0.0155685619,
0.043142274,
0.0621822998,
-0.0307684429,
-0.0482985154,
0.0557954051,
0.0247080456,
0.0333017185,
0.0208108369,
0.0589754693,
0.053658478,
0.005948233,
0.0485783741,
-0.0108949356,
0.0258782655,
0.0294940788,
0.0166781321,
-0.0615450852,
0.0342500359,
-0.0352979787,
0.0045658699,
0.0111897234,
-0.0095542083,
-0.0156925973,
-0.0193003379,
0.0563942529,
-0.0031308688,
-0.0861961097,
-0.0383927338,
0.0498547405,
-0.0661057979,
0.032764893,
-0.0392961651,
0.0149250068,
0.0844454244,
0.037211135,
-0.0351171456,
-0.0399455279,
-0.0311787426,
-0.0381010473,
0.0051385025,
-0.028360907,
-0.0337073579,
0.0870957971,
-0.0510636829,
0.0372225568,
-0.0082058134,
-0.0394804403,
0.0893455222,
-0.052668117,
-0.0169021375,
-0.0406313501,
-0.0344937555,
0.0070913988,
0.0426949374,
-0.0640877783,
-0.0132400487,
-0.0258559249,
0.0320568755,
-0.0055318032,
-0.0058823065,
-0.0751354098,
-0.0678782016,
-0.0160140544,
-0.0549398996,
0.0379870534,
0.021431949,
-0.0371212102,
-0.0883334056,
0.020443486,
-0.0545200333,
-0.0309174415,
0.0474820584,
-0.0205653831,
-0.0331927836,
0.0096932091,
-0.0377395302,
0.0438376591,
-0.0025153365,
-0.0084430203,
-0.0015334832,
0.043909207,
-0.0339386575,
0.0851569176,
0.0099059083,
-0.0373409539,
0.0050250133,
0.0376700014,
0.0177466497,
-0.0389905162,
0.0006250846,
-0.0038539148,
0.0147302747,
0.0048757386,
-0.0035941564,
0.0091142906,
-0.0121445581,
-0.0650154427,
-0.0387219079,
-0.0034440402,
-0.002033208,
-0.0101757124,
0.016006289,
0.0386971608,
-0.0220023226,
-0.0221115686,
-0.0350323766,
-0.008715366,
-0.0253451616,
-0.0558652952,
0.0459364653,
0.0351636894,
-0.0295694787,
-0.0364827104,
-0.0052086269,
-0.034471374,
0.0544857979,
-0.0136198997,
0.0092274286,
-0.0125458427,
0.0302442424,
0.0254960041,
0.0384185575,
-0.0334081315,
-0.0189512707,
0.0222341977,
-0.0194080956,
0.0058499039,
0.0584044419,
0.0359107554,
0.0137366084,
-0.003011439,
-0.0461059846,
-0.0351287946,
0.037150953,
0.0447785556,
0.0050544464,
-0.0431227237,
-0.0200002231,
-0.0492646284,
0.1184487417,
0.0301971138,
0.0334098861,
-0.0836933628,
-0.0146040451,
0.0474326797,
-0.0042733154,
0.0240030084,
0.0218097139,
-0.0422234237,
-0.0003183692,
-0.0257810857,
0.0246681944,
0.0879412815,
-0.0589202493,
-0.0450191572,
-0.0182002373,
-0.0253076032,
-0.0124093378,
0.0586500764,
-0.0061993692,
0.0340314172,
0.0014140173,
-0.0847445205,
-0.064146176,
-0.0293370821,
0.0085801836,
-0.0216307919,
0.034716323,
0.0191958379,
0.001429032,
-0.0272090249,
-0.0279335938,
-0.0374652892,
-0.0316054076,
-0.0476996712,
0.0030962869,
0.0289625283,
-0.0519727729,
-0.0105127916,
0.0308947731,
0.0055456688,
0.0467466973,
0.017039692,
-0.0335578546,
-0.0354858339,
0.0073749474,
-0.0271129087,
-0.0015241179,
-0.0097698877,
-0.0313316323,
0.0903156325,
0.0112114633,
-0.0394362994,
-0.002284447,
-0.0350683667,
0.0235942248,
0.0221275762,
-0.0088222623,
0.0105564725,
-0.0178720877,
0.0531196035,
-0.0749443918,
-0.0232049339,
0.1037706956,
-0.0216481816,
-0.0465958826,
-0.0108826552,
0.0024837458,
0.0100060012,
-0.0022839366,
0.0124246953,
-0.0440194793,
-0.0534748547,
0.0141259609,
0.0394700989,
0.025791904,
-0.0521043688,
-0.0160400476,
-0.0661903247,
0.0431869999,
0.0014805555,
-0.0561171435,
-0.0496895574,
0.027676329,
0.0118266959,
-0.0339831449,
0.0294351727,
0.0254554246,
-0.0312277675,
-0.0145416688,
0.0048009851,
-0.0409306549,
-0.0113975145,
0.0446987376,
-0.0402354859,
0.0256304443,
0.0178361274,
0.0318469815,
-0.0175549481,
0.0040985742,
-0.0501931384,
-0.0528413467,
0.0077052172,
0.0093088085,
0.0909684747,
-0.0431391522,
-0.0655489117,
-0.044154156,
0.0133344457,
-0.0225243196,
-0.022211872,
-0.0428806208,
0.0146548916,
-0.0241818726,
-0.0011081424,
0.0128330942,
0.0602632873,
0.0121126771,
0.0367424414,
0.0182946511,
-0.0618910193,
-0.01141972,
-0.0310997088,
0.0137321083,
-0.0777314901,
-0.0186329186,
0.0088774981,
0.0373451486,
0.0293393992,
-0.012040508,
-0.0265922006,
0.0226453375,
0.0416454412,
-0.0212458167,
-0.0223691501,
-0.0226932466,
0.0379216671,
-0.0347814411,
-0.0126240738,
-0.0179911535,
0.0030792372,
-0.0080016395,
-0.0550031103,
0.0487467684,
-0.0641440377,
-0.0150006795,
-0.0017391637,
-0.051921092,
-0.0457082167,
0.0372057781,
0.0197506249,
0.0147680985,
0.0514102317,
-0.0281168725,
-0.045229461,
0.0299532823,
-0.0136225205,
0.0046661901,
0.0112277037,
0.0352270044,
0.0084940363,
-0.0337998085,
-0.0068153213,
-0.011454571,
0.0018650864,
-0.0087412521,
-0.0107293846,
-0.0728898197,
-0.0308213346,
0.0190511402,
0.0008670135,
-0.0091108112,
-0.0081653344,
-0.0013032844,
-0.0515072495,
-0.0118301427,
-0.0046338746,
-0.0107587473,
-0.0293215103,
-0.026788801,
0.0435801111,
-0.0171271712,
0.0031768167,
-0.0180005468,
-0.0257428512,
-0.0164678246,
0.0163215436,
0.0482271761,
0.0705815032,
0.0191809852,
0.0238608159,
0.0237781387,
-0.0243814271,
0.0204621628,
-0.0275080744,
0.0712269843,
0.0142181776,
0.0593409128,
0.0024501141,
0.0077087362,
0.0096107852,
0.0164137129,
-0.0206638873,
-0.0390930623,
-0.0356862806,
-0.0129444329,
0.0267371517,
0.0096795773,
-0.0051607145,
-0.0172102042,
0.0406888165,
0.0023491045,
0.0368805639,
-0.0009287419,
-0.0001850717,
-0.0080534006,
0.0289404858,
0.0032497223,
0.0086660776,
0.0625147074,
-0.0197075568,
0.0459464006,
0.0002452628,
0.0416598395,
-0.055079516,
0.0179258771,
0.0347414427,
0.0283181667,
0.0066322051,
0.030085817,
-0.0610005967,
-0.0796309188,
0.0549129322,
0.000811719,
0.0250770394,
0.0155619103,
0.0058817891,
-0.0002290738,
0.0291585289,
0.0179919731,
-0.0284978654,
0.0372182317,
0.0003533203,
0.006244869,
0.0038279747,
-6.047752029e-33,
-0.0622302368,
0.0194043666,
-0.0319661237,
0.03443693,
-0.0133137228,
0.017329311,
-0.0374981612,
-0.0119276848,
-0.0466358475,
0.0212102886,
0.0113287829,
0.0273910873,
0.0037976359,
0.0009996155,
-0.0388246179,
-0.0496887304,
0.0474604182,
0.0142807094,
-0.0259309411,
0.0254062284,
0.0717954785,
0.0722081512,
0.0841314942,
-0.0756123364,
-0.0143418079,
-0.065871805,
-0.0188056435,
0.0122296112,
0.0544393398,
0.0435022153,
-0.0268855654,
0.0197066944,
0.0195472334,
0.0019539457,
-0.0044477852,
0.0475310944,
-0.0865271091,
0.0107777854,
-0.0094412314,
0.0432833992,
-0.038822107,
-0.0292755105,
-0.0127417361,
-0.0337198302,
0.0404555239,
-0.0722995475,
0.0312490296,
-0.0009172924,
0.0609275289,
0.0133411381,
-0.0659265593,
0.0352555215,
-0.0634585842,
-0.0350280926,
0.0205189157,
0.0369660519,
0.0372157842,
0.0090388693,
-0.0386275053,
-0.0283314362,
-0.0269585904,
-0.0110158371,
-0.017134985,
0.0539958701,
-0.0419578254,
0.0763427913,
0.0252154451,
0.0056538833,
0.020175539,
-0.0235370398,
0.0250455365,
0.0009534825,
0.0093360096,
0.0622542277,
-0.0068910969,
0.0254695266,
-0.0734213889,
0.0204859506,
0.0454632118,
0.0300166793,
0.0011163987,
0.0112056965,
-0.0291382484,
0.0091783069,
-0.0176681504,
-0.064932324,
0.0025967434,
-0.0152823813,
-0.0208436772,
-0.0347647555,
-0.0334012248,
-0.0297864173,
0.0819233805,
-0.036361184,
0.0468764231,
0.030802846,
-0.0321659744,
0.0355491154,
0.0154210553,
0.0446095243,
-0.0076916097,
-0.0449243821,
0.0163759626,
0.0191546269,
0.0626021102,
0.0071214335,
0.0449906029,
0.0194573887,
-0.0662690774,
-0.0061201481,
-0.0062266388,
0.0260014627,
-0.0228377637,
0.0529213995,
0.0224394184,
-0.0039953026,
-0.0139160808,
0.0331235602,
0.0142626176,
0.0078848582,
-0.0170722008,
0.0264401808,
-0.0184380766,
0.0031649899,
-0.0561285727,
-0.008781231,
0.0071602324,
-0.0002251328,
0.0333922654,
-0.0444358885,
0.0108607272,
0.0204949528,
2.643e-7,
0.0487444326,
-0.0041768407,
0.064407289,
0.0135793081,
0.0234197192,
0.0571181253,
-0.0010021119,
0.040693257,
0.0074053421,
-0.0307970699,
0.0160183851,
0.0269327052,
0.0404713824,
0.0239954665,
-0.0578747317,
0.003915702,
-0.0218263566,
-0.0001765426,
-0.0151134655,
0.0484496802,
0.0792164356,
0.0791864768,
0.0060418895,
-0.0012706777,
0.0503667705,
-0.0440887064,
0.0574263297,
0.012200498,
0.0016614186,
0.0073687108,
-0.0242966767,
0.0117907496,
-0.0357305184,
0.0342828445,
0.0381563231,
0.0299220234,
-0.0022275855,
0.0405524336,
-0.0356719196,
0.0108454758,
0.0029898749,
0.0015608361,
-0.0161252283,
-0.0190937165,
0.0643712133,
-0.0325646847,
-0.0548896119,
-0.0267332587,
-0.0278678201,
-0.017494265,
-0.0090052281,
0.0184909552,
-0.0365259759,
0.0409477875,
0.0054054321,
-0.0332472883,
-0.0282508321,
-0.1034830511,
0.0075224619,
0.0697439089,
-0.0190458056,
-0.0309940819,
0.0562047288,
-0.048517812,
0.0580407828,
-0.0247150995,
0.0336023606,
1.968744801e-34,
0.0017849229,
0.018431209,
-0.0026012419,
0.0338466614,
0.0364924744,
-0.0103387395,
-0.0279717688,
-0.0104053561,
0.0514988899,
-0.0699913949,
-0.0059880102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13228v1 | The Less the Merrier? Investigating Language Representation in Multilingual Models | 2023-10-20T02:26:34 | 2023-10-20T02:26:34 | Hellina Hailu Nigatu, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Jugal Kalita | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual Language Models offer a way to incorporate multiple languages in
one model and utilize cross-language transfer learning to improve performance
for different Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Despite progress in
multilingual models, not all languages are supported as well, particularly in
low-resource settings. In this work, we investigate the linguistic
representation of different languages in multilingual models. We start by
asking the question which languages are supported in popular multilingual
models and which languages are left behind. Then, for included languages, we
look at models' learned representations based on language family and dialect
and try to understand how models' learned representations for~(1) seen and~(2)
unseen languages vary across different language groups. In addition, we test
and analyze performance on downstream tasks such as text generation and Named
Entity Recognition. We observe from our experiments that community-centered
models -- models that focus on languages of a given family or geographical
location and are built by communities who speak them -- perform better at
distinguishing between languages in the same family for low-resource languages.
Our paper contributes to the literature in understanding multilingual models
and their shortcomings and offers insights on potential ways to improve them. | [
0.0035714633,
0.0680519715,
-0.0229420271,
0.073639065,
-0.0522688478,
0.0364630632,
0.0600064173,
-0.0147560025,
0.01014606,
-0.068726927,
-0.0547075942,
-0.0753007606,
0.0090680122,
-0.0034398341,
0.0346618444,
-0.0653630868,
0.0366540477,
-0.0394028872,
-0.0303485412,
-0.0032273205,
-0.0014417887,
0.0350862443,
0.0479437225,
0.0302482024,
0.0146775469,
0.0184523296,
0.02423862,
-0.012083468,
0.0311936103,
-0.0060995067,
-0.00935027,
0.0343796648,
0.0080916407,
0.053684514,
0.0000017548,
-0.0368455015,
-0.03028314,
-0.0169258919,
0.0387054421,
-0.0115319397,
0.0786615759,
-0.0666283891,
0.0056474935,
0.0306253787,
-0.0028408216,
-0.027055366,
0.0599106438,
0.0115794493,
-0.0114196306,
0.0446131192,
-0.0110298321,
-0.0037962398,
0.0009268168,
-0.0261434447,
-0.0212209318,
-0.0011353692,
0.0224515684,
0.0005156078,
-0.0089018364,
0.0120328506,
-0.0092491014,
0.0356609821,
-0.0069521111,
0.0111179808,
-0.0177342873,
0.0507161394,
-0.0182030909,
-0.0265163817,
0.0123926289,
0.0255110878,
-0.0439066663,
-0.0409327559,
0.0187551752,
0.0109010441,
-0.0165133215,
0.0007482334,
-0.0371867791,
0.0423339419,
0.0051272553,
0.029149577,
0.0597599186,
0.0131671354,
0.0461806059,
0.0043166294,
-0.0036341627,
0.0414616391,
0.0523033738,
0.0244782548,
-0.0132091949,
0.0570500381,
-0.005871274,
-0.0318012014,
0.0077764695,
0.0066146464,
-0.0113011058,
0.0368360691,
-0.0442899726,
-0.0005596175,
0.0141340457,
-0.0223269369,
0.0294314753,
0.0321101546,
-0.0346003398,
0.0393702872,
-0.0737745017,
-0.0025602842,
-0.0022811426,
0.0086898962,
-0.0103738131,
-0.0551238209,
-0.0496689938,
-0.017199602,
-0.0135962926,
0.0137586342,
-0.0333507955,
0.0119994665,
-0.0045487895,
0.0215970092,
-0.0290983934,
-0.0249982923,
-0.0019330349,
-0.0149433315,
-0.0420664325,
-0.0089551266,
0.0132999774,
0.0510998778,
-0.0331186354,
0.0068864739,
0.0132960053,
-0.0884421617,
0.0182181168,
0.0250606705,
0.0207711235,
-0.0484247729,
-0.0077046035,
0.0445794128,
-0.0057114689,
-0.028742604,
-0.0827347785,
0.0108159138,
-0.0439216383,
-0.0634068176,
0.0246361177,
-0.0993361399,
0.0448007323,
0.0456479564,
0.0469511338,
-0.0772492215,
-0.014266476,
-0.0130593479,
-0.0345753022,
0.0210753698,
-0.0009721891,
0.0073478208,
0.0635504872,
-0.0138119245,
-0.0086221416,
0.0763812512,
0.0103591802,
-0.0273080096,
0.0500279777,
-0.0279363059,
-0.0353454947,
0.0242831148,
0.016548045,
0.0321970172,
-0.0378282182,
-0.0364387445,
-0.0178008601,
0.0049070371,
0.0540260449,
0.0510928147,
-0.0124915931,
-0.0036088414,
0.0281602032,
0.0490002856,
0.0017408595,
0.0131074935,
0.0363624357,
-0.0111313509,
-0.0410444364,
0.0124463476,
0.0073124371,
0.0278084166,
-0.0129804509,
-0.0268162452,
-0.0012037113,
0.0596099272,
-0.03730895,
0.0251074266,
0.001616477,
-0.0245901328,
0.0226896759,
-0.0130337738,
0.0542657413,
0.0080058156,
0.0011041558,
0.05362707,
0.0967429876,
-0.019718254,
0.0470612384,
-0.030109819,
0.028840391,
0.0311864335,
-0.0169290714,
0.0167042408,
0.0326622836,
-0.0063331844,
-0.0004010072,
0.051355768,
0.0742635056,
-0.0213012751,
0.0142476577,
-0.033509884,
0.0022283569,
-0.0027387696,
0.0369242243,
0.0782927424,
-0.007134744,
0.036005877,
0.0364599489,
-0.0224936437,
-0.0594210327,
0.0126627767,
-0.0947436765,
0.0180723295,
-0.0041385409,
0.012219917,
-0.0147334058,
0.012795384,
0.0002782275,
-0.0030328194,
-0.0112402076,
-0.0524950847,
0.0121181216,
0.0481771827,
-0.0429680124,
-0.0572322197,
0.0109343454,
-0.0222363081,
0.0337987281,
0.0333738811,
0.0109506035,
-0.0443422683,
0.0337200165,
-0.0215530712,
0.0455114059,
-0.0222134553,
0.0166525766,
-0.0162420869,
-0.0036410678,
-0.0168880448,
0.0634964556,
0.0039095357,
0.036652796,
0.008508102,
-0.0258290749,
0.0238997266,
-0.0363814533,
-0.0140049942,
0.032680802,
-0.0194103178,
-0.016713636,
0.0469505675,
-0.001154407,
-0.018471742,
0.0056001507,
-0.0926483721,
-0.0117381029,
-0.0435455441,
0.0293943249,
0.018849656,
-0.00099238,
0.0087534375,
-0.0172901861,
-0.0639981106,
0.0160168707,
0.0452093109,
0.0528611615,
0.0217083339,
-0.0271171201,
0.0236370005,
-0.0368822925,
-0.0160271898,
0.0238461234,
0.0796449557,
-0.0248623956,
-0.0809402838,
-0.047193978,
0.0346542709,
-0.0485814139,
-0.0155412741,
-0.0015972201,
0.0088548111,
-0.0022591255,
-0.0036338116,
0.0431022458,
0.008195838,
-0.0384799168,
0.0157189704,
0.036861755,
-0.0018176512,
-0.0520584024,
-0.0169141944,
-0.0076948726,
0.0422453396,
-0.0269329585,
-0.0622452982,
-0.0382528007,
0.0767127872,
-0.0005343194,
-0.0361455083,
-0.0486468524,
0.0046659699,
-0.0524373762,
-0.0228303112,
-0.0156862605,
0.0313873515,
0.0178689305,
0.0424436256,
-0.0390957631,
-0.0437184721,
0.0353018269,
-0.024843134,
-0.0015583386,
-0.0143722687,
-0.0115072187,
-0.0388059244,
0.0486034304,
0.038015198,
0.0709899366,
-0.0213798005,
-0.0393970981,
-0.0332938284,
0.047914803,
0.0239332616,
0.0060442183,
0.0336026326,
-0.0321283676,
-0.0198217053,
-0.0192232057,
-0.031108968,
-0.0297366641,
0.026544001,
-0.0338523276,
0.0393258557,
0.0428866856,
-0.0121775111,
-0.0177619029,
0.022236418,
0.0395960212,
0.0370111391,
-0.00869611,
0.0016204905,
-0.0195279382,
0.048193194,
0.0540639944,
0.0144602302,
0.0298343301,
-0.0405352898,
-0.0081573902,
0.0066964752,
0.0311895702,
0.0043172119,
0.0028427278,
0.0102211395,
0.0447885431,
-0.0328025743,
-0.0816848949,
0.0062425877,
0.0747984499,
-0.0086203059,
-0.0268759094,
0.0694597065,
0.0032116834,
-0.0278639924,
0.0114432173,
-0.0446930118,
0.0498513281,
0.0417263806,
0.0251411945,
-0.0597941875,
-0.0029840569,
0.000473094,
-0.0014446138,
0.0199165381,
-0.029142322,
-0.0145436153,
-0.1249751821,
-0.0020823015,
0.018273266,
-0.0864120275,
-0.0305416975,
-0.0442414582,
-0.0099704098,
-0.0163910463,
0.0117906174,
-0.0413142107,
-0.0084751956,
-0.0215795413,
0.0566005856,
-0.0081444839,
-0.0694412664,
0.0116132721,
-0.0416665524,
0.0389012583,
0.006373852,
0.0394660756,
-0.0252101161,
-0.0111760348,
0.0106320847,
-0.0108881136,
-0.0153553514,
-0.0029883245,
0.0338127911,
0.0367830768,
-0.0096607348,
0.0251876824,
0.0016210548,
-0.0360628702,
-0.0121346731,
0.0010078485,
0.0768071264,
0.0297744367,
-0.0502573289,
0.022357909,
-0.0311101917,
0.0209800079,
0.072969012,
0.0146241132,
-0.0201923475,
-0.031725239,
-0.0074347756,
-0.0170042291,
-0.0347999819,
-0.0004284675,
0.0373211987,
-0.0154433921,
-0.0508942083,
-0.0816798136,
-0.0497309528,
0.0197820682,
0.0388267599,
0.0242457204,
-0.0058253808,
0.0197926853,
-0.0412510857,
-0.0010692826,
0.0155921467,
-0.0452145301,
-0.0057692584,
-0.0382168256,
-0.025521718,
0.0129789105,
-0.0634342358,
-0.0095598707,
-0.0444276445,
-0.0848689005,
-0.0687814578,
-0.0177768655,
0.0330463126,
0.0180246606,
0.0344993211,
0.0087838992,
-0.0655564368,
-0.0042923125,
-0.0111737726,
-0.0159703307,
-0.000021584,
0.0231088083,
-0.0166041348,
-0.0311371554,
0.0546302497,
-0.0339876153,
0.0288205948,
0.0102991955,
0.0319256335,
-0.0410472117,
-0.021030942,
-0.0043149213,
-0.0098412139,
0.0058629042,
-0.0460708663,
-0.0295656044,
-0.0850377008,
-0.0399548821,
-0.0285959076,
0.0019877444,
-0.0298557729,
-0.0296246782,
0.0487984903,
0.0074090585,
0.0045933714,
-0.0029669486,
0.0086056618,
0.0424262621,
-0.0181853641,
0.0067475694,
0.0424373038,
0.0463104807,
0.0050160643,
0.0414763391,
-0.0160424896,
0.0231543481,
-0.0395883881,
0.0461751856,
-0.0447341204,
0.0260000117,
-0.0204781257,
-0.0192530565,
0.0176067241,
-0.0340884551,
-0.02779717,
-0.0119920317,
-0.0099711893,
0.028191451,
0.0699929297,
-0.0391940959,
0.1089815497,
-0.0151377982,
-0.0128896441,
-0.0557158291,
0.0496647879,
0.0192495473,
-0.0594341606,
0.0196974073,
-0.0101569379,
-0.0273813698,
0.0032343026,
0.0974619016,
0.0449975803,
0.0284924693,
-0.0116128828,
0.0106069436,
-0.0067580123,
-0.0127195884,
0.0326917917,
0.0094257742,
-0.0192199908,
0.0337101407,
-0.0512463264,
-0.0530146509,
0.0087739844,
-0.0521748997,
0.0175570343,
0.0009459456,
-0.0026339898,
0.0674360096,
-0.017823277,
0.0142711345,
-0.08559113,
0.0229907501,
-0.0118655702,
0.0174331907,
0.0098975543,
-6.223404313e-33,
-0.0244519822,
-0.0433964841,
0.0070178267,
-0.0470254533,
0.0321093351,
0.0022754346,
-0.058633212,
0.0250739921,
-0.0284834877,
0.0011308413,
0.0070033632,
-0.0235549621,
0.0126795024,
0.0521168374,
0.0221804418,
0.0044071609,
0.0386086814,
0.0277847219,
-0.0004371271,
0.0327146389,
0.0793161765,
0.0411092974,
0.0885453448,
-0.0316936038,
0.0298232976,
-0.0102137951,
0.0163945332,
-0.0286208168,
0.0371396244,
0.0585250407,
-0.0472145081,
0.0373613313,
0.0458977968,
-0.0217454564,
-0.0189574882,
-0.0042392882,
-0.0584500693,
-0.0283776261,
0.0235978216,
0.0091576912,
-0.031181667,
-0.0561484583,
0.0123059573,
-0.0131019354,
0.0211378392,
0.0042403834,
0.0303682182,
-0.0258941445,
-0.0314285904,
-0.0010511241,
-0.1287798882,
0.0504752807,
0.019860344,
0.0290848017,
0.0230674632,
0.0958236903,
0.0039422186,
0.0141937425,
-0.0499080122,
0.0059289336,
-0.0132114617,
0.0233111586,
0.080911465,
0.0326300859,
-0.0509591438,
0.0466008745,
0.010783731,
0.011403637,
0.028448971,
0.0005337445,
0.0410576165,
0.040605329,
0.0053627966,
0.0906981453,
-0.0278260019,
-0.0383529775,
-0.0540368222,
-0.0084966384,
0.0118844379,
-0.0312314909,
0.0430185348,
-0.0166830588,
-0.005786818,
-0.0290108379,
-0.0390382968,
-0.0724276602,
-0.0214687698,
-0.0318020023,
0.03682613,
0.0069169323,
-0.0237587802,
0.0015433697,
0.060422428,
-0.032435514,
-0.0829076022,
0.0216711722,
-0.0228930805,
-0.0081534442,
0.0023011847,
0.0641219914,
-0.0760850534,
-0.0839287117,
-0.0235576425,
-0.0038531334,
-0.0220185742,
0.0057741557,
0.0623087324,
0.0075576655,
-0.0500619821,
0.0244450457,
-0.0673507005,
0.0216164812,
0.0001062239,
0.0626102015,
0.0330849327,
-0.0276718885,
-0.0137995379,
0.0179985762,
0.0504468195,
-0.035767328,
-0.004746187,
-0.002105417,
-0.019432608,
0.035112448,
-0.026154343,
-0.0149338553,
-0.0538103133,
0.025007721,
0.0480424687,
0.0016065155,
-0.0127562229,
-0.0374227166,
2.58e-7,
0.0367113538,
0.0154046696,
-0.0158484038,
-0.0279173367,
0.0365949199,
0.0107380236,
-0.0106064966,
0.0582118072,
0.0038624613,
0.0058120838,
-0.0464525558,
0.0167036336,
0.083306618,
0.0433756523,
-0.0283979047,
-0.0016731621,
-0.0473304354,
0.0341375768,
-0.0157461036,
-0.0005991614,
0.0107585816,
0.0656029359,
-0.0165997483,
-0.0182731934,
-0.0269638151,
-0.02693264,
0.1163965315,
-0.0543762036,
-0.0111466013,
0.0118850647,
-0.0039789611,
0.0380323343,
0.0132240802,
-0.020752212,
-0.0376061574,
0.0147670479,
0.0406548902,
0.0566090532,
0.0174480099,
-0.0064230263,
0.0369179696,
-0.0059472355,
-0.0084274113,
-0.0914384648,
0.0611792319,
-0.011520707,
0.0075666672,
-0.0303636901,
0.0236396808,
0.0252155885,
0.0409542955,
-0.0413826779,
-0.0358518325,
0.0064981696,
0.0275089126,
-0.0216236636,
-0.0536890179,
-0.0173388682,
-0.0180770978,
0.0315892026,
-0.0232873671,
-0.0427744761,
-0.0219929107,
-0.0096461596,
0.0315297283,
-0.0441569798,
0.0282452833,
2.028115071e-34,
-0.0097301267,
0.028457582,
-0.0070711588,
-0.0076378798,
0.0148773994,
-0.0361497812,
-0.0408364572,
0.0057118121,
-0.0055867727,
0.0031126258,
0.0033067099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13227v1 | ToolChain*: Efficient Action Space Navigation in Large Language Models with A* Search | 2023-10-20T02:24:35 | 2023-10-20T02:24:35 | Yuchen Zhuang, Xiang Chen, Tong Yu, Saayan Mitra, Victor Bursztyn, Ryan A. Rossi, Somdeb Sarkhel, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated powerful decision-making and
planning capabilities in solving complicated real-world problems. LLM-based
autonomous agents can interact with diverse tools (e.g., functional APIs) and
generate solution plans that execute a series of API function calls in a
step-by-step manner. The multitude of candidate API function calls
significantly expands the action space, amplifying the critical need for
efficient action space navigation. However, existing methods either struggle
with unidirectional exploration in expansive action spaces, trapped into a
locally optimal solution, or suffer from exhaustively traversing all potential
actions, causing inefficient navigation. To address these issues, we propose
ToolChain*, an efficient tree search-based planning algorithm for LLM-based
agents. It formulates the entire action space as a decision tree, where each
node represents a possible API function call involved in a solution plan. By
incorporating the A* search algorithm with task-specific cost function design,
it efficiently prunes high-cost branches that may involve incorrect actions,
identifying the most low-cost valid path as the solution. Extensive experiments
on multiple tool-use and reasoning tasks demonstrate that ToolChain*
efficiently balances exploration and exploitation within an expansive action
space. It outperforms state-of-the-art baselines on planning and reasoning
tasks by 3.1% and 3.5% on average while requiring 7.35x and 2.31x less time,
respectively. | [
0.0375376083,
0.0068876459,
-0.0238904003,
0.0127770072,
-0.0515694506,
-0.0184208453,
-0.0577189326,
-0.0169239752,
0.0311023612,
-0.0163087491,
-0.0055721705,
0.0040542413,
-0.0405451432,
0.0559899956,
-0.0219221748,
-0.0221044812,
0.0154370461,
-0.0480316356,
0.0378828794,
-0.0011013062,
-0.0304468721,
-0.0162890591,
-0.0183949769,
0.0562761724,
0.0034051917,
0.0061052027,
-0.0562954135,
0.0020295638,
0.0146248192,
-0.0205147173,
0.0018940257,
-0.0056124534,
0.0169185568,
0.0653788075,
0.000002339,
-0.0597730987,
-0.0093275262,
-0.0362295993,
-0.0453257896,
-0.0341431275,
-0.0160172675,
0.0434155762,
0.000984441,
0.0407665633,
-0.0547303781,
-0.0114204502,
0.0287295729,
0.0061690439,
0.0294501279,
0.0664433688,
-0.0022547885,
-0.0012191237,
-0.0329239629,
-0.0010576089,
-0.042367056,
-0.0492180362,
0.004421819,
0.0156877674,
0.0646726489,
0.0033413197,
-0.0111031532,
0.0136707313,
0.0313846432,
-0.0320393294,
-0.0110701956,
0.0336959884,
-0.0281696264,
-0.0506430529,
0.0094021047,
0.0248026326,
-0.0503408425,
-0.0361748673,
0.0263771508,
-0.0340745971,
-0.0221435949,
0.016900368,
-0.0404524654,
0.0378072076,
-0.0200058501,
-0.0144542633,
0.0378552601,
-0.0604510121,
0.0438862331,
0.0298021659,
-0.0185946655,
0.0891222805,
-0.0141330725,
-0.0168710295,
0.0402945653,
-0.0297336429,
-0.0216187555,
-0.0625731423,
0.0359297991,
0.0853696764,
-0.0944850892,
0.0422735363,
0.0147081185,
0.0211462248,
-0.0071904268,
-0.0352007896,
0.0331317298,
0.0393562019,
0.00075446,
0.0295674466,
0.0019869867,
0.0526624732,
-0.0131212696,
0.0010724963,
-0.0412934609,
0.0073647932,
-0.0203052014,
-0.0007254545,
-0.0541691221,
0.0322488323,
-0.0775653571,
-0.050301034,
0.0011342763,
0.0562397949,
-0.0064277225,
0.0325139388,
0.0044439049,
-0.007925177,
0.0124819065,
-0.0160317011,
-0.0508882403,
-0.0026343965,
-0.0170998164,
-0.0015560345,
-0.0090143327,
0.0210581664,
-0.0037908703,
0.0180832911,
-0.0044302894,
-0.0159204043,
0.0169467479,
0.1192054152,
0.0103211971,
-0.0100706629,
-0.0421932079,
-0.0297517888,
0.0248327181,
-0.043910332,
0.0056534326,
-0.0870179459,
0.0118251611,
0.0196665395,
-0.0508254282,
-0.0216958448,
0.0113298958,
0.0168041456,
0.0041014915,
0.0199410133,
0.0527043268,
0.0626688078,
0.0164694041,
0.0112542463,
-0.0044204439,
0.0759888217,
0.0290919095,
0.0786379352,
0.0012360278,
0.0485194698,
0.0118291369,
0.054369662,
-0.0416715294,
-0.0062269592,
0.0476743989,
0.0144518288,
-0.0109570622,
0.0731922239,
-0.0330597535,
-0.0111123426,
-0.0360142626,
-0.0028977685,
0.0230387561,
0.0544865429,
-0.0007487583,
-0.0338833183,
0.044226896,
0.0030148192,
-0.0176933166,
-0.0875270143,
-0.0472888388,
0.0186577216,
-0.0496097207,
-0.0125351669,
-0.0601605549,
0.0026721561,
0.0099246558,
-0.0315066129,
-0.0187711194,
0.0246836971,
-0.0188452769,
0.0308034215,
0.0247715581,
-0.001772723,
-0.0709178224,
0.0246678907,
-0.0178311467,
-0.0152510013,
-0.0425351299,
-0.0599903017,
0.0212901141,
0.0499772057,
0.0766070783,
-0.0476991907,
-0.0799376667,
0.0221083164,
-0.0141101992,
0.0297648367,
0.0097224526,
-0.038099397,
0.0111702364,
-0.0311564412,
-0.0433545187,
-0.0031703594,
-0.0123305861,
0.0391243361,
0.0430704691,
-0.0092101367,
-0.0295089111,
-0.0236374214,
-0.0138415955,
0.0214771051,
-0.0171854086,
-0.0103886416,
0.0016034815,
0.0142342588,
0.0595859289,
-0.0064583928,
0.0004155529,
0.012653497,
0.0199689604,
-0.0146019701,
-0.0396265015,
0.0139269587,
-0.0179424491,
0.0295482762,
0.0461089797,
0.0012081165,
-0.019391153,
0.0400088429,
-0.0199174378,
-0.0368774757,
0.0267172251,
-0.0352435894,
0.0139648393,
0.0234397557,
0.0431189016,
-0.0025891075,
-0.0397854485,
-0.0171052404,
0.0626438335,
-0.0055114995,
-0.0225056652,
0.0165849868,
0.0347708873,
0.0255292896,
0.0012718454,
0.013665732,
0.0561964773,
0.0059859855,
-0.0061560781,
0.0421299413,
0.0292970277,
-0.0046978118,
-0.0414852202,
-0.0947302878,
0.040030513,
-0.0157566722,
0.0110428175,
0.0067550172,
0.0322803482,
-0.0000396017,
0.0203895606,
0.0104770632,
0.0403160937,
0.0135798231,
0.0199504998,
-0.0031777699,
0.0224286672,
-0.0527557507,
-0.0347909108,
-0.0037877783,
-0.005554432,
-0.0166646801,
-0.0328094102,
-0.0392804742,
-0.0279840827,
0.0503755771,
-0.0205053072,
0.0545012653,
-0.0340028107,
-0.0349340849,
0.0145429345,
-0.0432569943,
-0.0283973552,
0.0694667622,
-0.0351106972,
0.0461584404,
0.0861730501,
-0.0091283135,
-0.076776579,
0.0584537946,
-0.0121806925,
-0.0090327179,
-0.0588391982,
-0.0117984097,
0.0386691727,
0.0656639487,
-0.0272549819,
0.0277756806,
-0.0220193937,
-0.023279259,
0.0214744452,
-0.0330758654,
0.0143722501,
-0.0301173609,
-0.0202906393,
0.0688375682,
-0.0381397717,
-0.0375307798,
0.0439304225,
0.0032140829,
-0.0368457586,
-0.0169149581,
-0.0273899417,
-0.030512182,
0.1278008968,
0.0414406136,
0.0187824536,
-0.0385509469,
-0.0141813718,
-0.0240411926,
-0.0002924419,
0.0326296128,
-0.0170247462,
0.0900503099,
-0.0748736784,
0.0296420641,
-0.000718191,
-0.0455587544,
-0.0235262569,
0.0134855974,
-0.0319410786,
0.0225612409,
-0.0364568457,
-0.065062888,
-0.0218314566,
0.0010119826,
0.0434283838,
0.0967399105,
0.0206244588,
-0.0080897119,
-0.0259104352,
-0.0513677113,
0.0291341115,
0.0070562712,
0.0608147644,
0.0261514578,
0.0323503315,
0.030856926,
0.0274031255,
-0.0309730489,
-0.0206118394,
-0.003958765,
0.0259105098,
-0.030659575,
-0.0224601999,
0.0303773209,
0.0240040906,
-0.0568508878,
-0.0266345087,
0.0716697946,
0.0418448858,
-0.0012680219,
0.0173013732,
-0.072651796,
0.0212546904,
0.0311860461,
0.0703940243,
-0.0187631492,
-0.0208522435,
0.0256737992,
0.0004175587,
-0.0290124808,
-0.0370841064,
0.0049200687,
-0.1271973252,
0.0428440459,
-0.0136397779,
-0.0144308452,
0.001716033,
-0.044218082,
0.0163685866,
0.004763423,
-0.0381104574,
0.0359055474,
0.018069217,
-0.0249174237,
-0.0340128168,
-0.0173465516,
0.004888528,
0.0203940086,
0.0036623355,
0.0040249513,
0.0517575629,
0.0490409806,
0.0132414494,
0.0405449271,
0.0419770181,
0.0330008082,
0.0112817008,
-0.0527561568,
-0.0380806476,
0.0331400596,
0.0149054024,
0.0418778136,
0.0186047126,
-0.0485866256,
-0.056123469,
-0.002374121,
0.0849775225,
-0.0631890371,
0.020156581,
-0.0220932737,
-0.0040045567,
0.0099896807,
0.0434888415,
-0.0275494792,
-0.0063885893,
-0.0884842575,
-0.0377004854,
-0.0680729672,
-0.0581041351,
-0.0372097716,
0.0106197903,
0.0102969734,
0.0002419615,
-0.0200123973,
-0.0227435846,
0.0552821383,
0.0491629057,
0.0004574452,
-0.0111764055,
-0.0234627444,
0.0192631837,
-0.0265945233,
-0.0107026007,
-0.0260984413,
0.0487296768,
0.0051564253,
0.000827775,
0.0196746476,
-0.0428825952,
-0.0229751542,
0.0592331849,
-0.020356942,
-0.0647219121,
-0.0145181622,
0.0549220853,
0.028318828,
0.0177912544,
-0.0374325961,
-0.0176664628,
-0.0048900549,
0.0313659832,
0.0024932029,
0.0152575225,
0.0276840031,
0.0338680744,
0.0162014533,
0.0472364612,
-0.0773683786,
-0.0158417542,
0.0301322397,
0.071304962,
-0.0303755961,
-0.0144640096,
0.0071976981,
0.0008044575,
-0.0177602228,
0.0051019383,
-0.0006219323,
-0.0246894062,
0.0159629341,
-0.0002128017,
-0.0242376588,
-0.0554063581,
0.0169531312,
-0.0152884442,
-0.0050064619,
0.0502013713,
0.0272550844,
0.0259954762,
-0.0144933844,
0.0139372032,
0.0409624949,
0.0309918821,
-0.0117128408,
0.069070898,
0.0139413057,
-0.008237646,
-0.0117751015,
0.0219590999,
0.0211101267,
0.0058563873,
0.0565136038,
0.0205033608,
-0.0158128627,
-0.0450902618,
-0.0226335302,
-0.071140416,
-0.1300039887,
0.0312130153,
0.0409400314,
0.0650245473,
-0.0276184324,
0.0384755619,
-0.1046007201,
0.015613107,
-0.0010464155,
-0.0309876986,
0.0204786807,
-0.0447484627,
0.0407737717,
0.0398612805,
0.0089992415,
-0.0119752251,
0.0514240451,
-0.0207683258,
0.0944126472,
-0.0005991463,
-0.0530042127,
-0.0403601304,
-0.0763813332,
0.0242873877,
-0.007708679,
-0.0081184329,
-0.0075697824,
-0.0649414957,
-0.0398137942,
-0.042076461,
0.0296000317,
-0.0150898891,
-0.0417172834,
0.0309077892,
0.0328766294,
0.0376118571,
-0.0249766372,
-0.0371847823,
-0.0269113556,
-0.0453471914,
-0.0342762917,
-0.0419745408,
-5.805685783e-33,
0.0030076639,
-0.0462788157,
0.0763104782,
-0.0442012921,
-0.0137306228,
-0.0126815876,
-0.0762114227,
0.0294583589,
-0.0153422765,
0.0078685908,
-0.0134446649,
0.0101131136,
0.0134576084,
0.0096243666,
0.0353785641,
0.0308613274,
-0.0006695884,
0.0279676784,
-0.0422856547,
-0.0152434483,
0.0146952821,
-0.0183732919,
-0.013253266,
-0.026788421,
-0.0705098212,
0.0252021104,
-0.003552034,
0.0747250393,
-0.0120166633,
0.0501234867,
0.0285475273,
0.002678507,
0.0125614777,
-0.0216198061,
-0.0128107062,
-0.0083007812,
-0.0282480028,
-0.0477523021,
0.0554436184,
0.0155678019,
-0.0190276131,
-0.0146809099,
0.0276032463,
0.0364465415,
-0.0260766055,
0.0224143118,
-0.022498522,
-0.017113572,
-0.0316495895,
0.0067167436,
-0.0448357984,
0.0087785106,
0.0207301974,
-0.0474528968,
0.0227178875,
0.0385593511,
-0.0033481934,
-0.0410656631,
0.0156748202,
0.0067467322,
-0.0098019689,
0.0010251791,
0.0404083803,
0.0488349162,
0.0446907952,
0.0392145999,
-0.0001319003,
-0.0031047713,
-0.0052495226,
0.0219856016,
-0.0164718181,
0.0771626309,
-0.0258816089,
-0.0163670108,
-0.0400572941,
0.0323101468,
-0.0400478877,
-0.0036809456,
0.0107194409,
0.0606285892,
0.0490988754,
0.0563423,
-0.0165475868,
-0.0126284491,
-0.0264615621,
0.0002449431,
-0.0246659182,
-0.0115990369,
0.0170331467,
0.032680098,
0.0370374247,
-0.0252559576,
0.0163377151,
-0.0033500213,
0.0137494914,
0.0568805337,
-0.0380127542,
0.0512023829,
-0.0024819018,
0.029883543,
-0.0381187387,
-0.0220412333,
-0.0470103361,
-0.0315441415,
-0.0079757962,
0.0210092682,
-0.0504300483,
0.0466191396,
-0.0248607062,
-0.0077747446,
-0.0800542533,
-0.0056520384,
-0.0007160961,
0.0097057689,
0.0350385904,
-0.023972638,
0.0007132071,
0.0395141803,
-0.0050552036,
-0.0539846085,
-0.0060719815,
0.0109012686,
-0.0173889715,
-0.0078633763,
-0.0335694775,
0.0006347335,
-0.04197542,
0.0462920144,
0.0027844277,
-0.0573147535,
0.009084384,
0.0255351905,
3.024e-7,
-0.0120050665,
0.0246925391,
-0.0114248786,
0.0692933425,
0.0334841125,
0.0391964614,
0.017617397,
-0.0132845994,
-0.0164884925,
-0.0298851375,
0.0237851273,
0.0436923578,
0.0234964974,
0.0026365852,
-0.0842532441,
-0.0010160428,
0.0183549412,
-0.0576965027,
-0.0645138323,
0.0024511206,
-0.0112821413,
0.0818259344,
0.0240244642,
-0.0157453883,
-0.0172779039,
-0.0616235025,
0.0069317683,
-0.0351026207,
0.0194147415,
-0.000625772,
-0.0395732932,
0.0233333837,
0.0066648312,
0.0003120333,
0.0098460391,
0.031574931,
-0.0300125983,
0.0962324366,
-0.0083537446,
-0.0248952229,
-0.0186650101,
-0.0395265892,
-0.0055269636,
-0.0235451758,
0.0390590727,
-0.0259901658,
-0.0047225873,
0.0027982073,
0.0698151737,
0.0166672822,
-0.0540197641,
-0.0092208562,
0.0184185561,
0.0176338945,
-0.0044820616,
-0.0258042142,
0.0040660067,
-0.0686568171,
-0.0058136983,
0.0418310016,
-0.0354426429,
-0.0047146594,
-0.0413438827,
0.0205346551,
-0.0084953615,
-0.0307233538,
-0.0399280116,
3.07294473e-34,
0.0043602558,
-0.0267720092,
-0.0018937018,
0.0310324095,
0.0579372682,
0.0389156938,
0.0087397052,
0.03989885,
0.0418710522,
-0.0374179371,
-0.0468354486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13226v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13226v1 | Enhancing Zero-Shot Crypto Sentiment with Fine-tuned Language Model and Prompt Engineering | 2023-10-20T02:15:51 | 2023-10-20T02:15:51 | Rahman S M Wahidur, Ishmam Tashdeed, Manjit Kaur, Heung-No-Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Blockchain technology has revolutionized the financial landscape, with
cryptocurrencies gaining widespread adoption for their decentralized and
transparent nature. As the sentiment expressed on social media platforms can
significantly influence cryptocurrency discussions and market movements,
sentiment analysis has emerged as a crucial tool for understanding public
opinion and predicting market trends. Motivated by the aim to enhance sentiment
analysis accuracy in the cryptocurrency domain, this paper investigates
fine-tuning techniques on large language models. This paper also investigates
the efficacy of supervised fine-tuning and instruction-based fine-tuning on
large language models for unseen tasks. Experimental results demonstrate a
significant average zero-shot performance gain of 40% after fine-tuning,
highlighting the potential of this technique in optimizing pre-trained language
model efficiency. Additionally, the impact of instruction tuning on models of
varying scales is examined, revealing that larger models benefit from
instruction tuning, achieving the highest average accuracy score of 75.16%. In
contrast, smaller-scale models may experience reduced generalization due to the
complete utilization of model capacity. To gain deeper insight about how
instruction works with these language models, this paper presents an
experimental investigation into the response of an instruction-based model
under different instruction tuning setups. The investigation demonstrates that
the model achieves an average accuracy score of 72.38% for short and simple
instructions. This performance significantly outperforms its accuracy under
long and complex instructions by over 12%, thereby effectively highlighting the
profound significance of instruction characteristics in maximizing model
performance. | [
0.0445557758,
0.0864593759,
-0.0130036175,
0.0188570656,
-0.0144186802,
0.0215161908,
0.0570604764,
-0.0032528329,
-0.0192362182,
-0.0343737677,
-0.0087218666,
-0.0131232338,
-0.037164256,
0.0509012081,
0.0179493371,
-0.0565555356,
0.0427853391,
0.0217200313,
0.0348612517,
-0.0236493014,
0.0452069156,
-0.0236060545,
0.0072793574,
-0.0089773042,
0.0129956836,
-0.0161859486,
-0.0075892708,
0.0239103585,
-0.010494045,
-0.0065232469,
0.0176592674,
0.0616326481,
-0.0194299202,
0.0341209583,
0.0000022098,
-0.0212305915,
-0.0325465351,
0.0152334124,
-0.0240372773,
-0.0161464196,
0.0449532904,
-0.0661478266,
0.0276145358,
0.0152236922,
-0.0504207648,
-0.0034161147,
0.080135338,
0.0666020587,
0.020708181,
0.0853195861,
-0.0170166418,
-0.0415145829,
0.0019553062,
-0.0260615982,
0.00079865,
-0.0355279669,
0.0259831604,
0.0158788357,
-0.0265966076,
0.0587876737,
-0.0232597273,
0.0008553438,
-0.0036767216,
0.0057326807,
0.0034258328,
-0.0232940447,
-0.0238273833,
-0.0156064723,
-0.0506805331,
0.0293647796,
-0.0268330202,
0.0164728779,
0.0089339698,
-0.0467919111,
-0.0370291658,
0.0006055892,
-0.0405052677,
0.0183236022,
0.005384889,
-0.0090918355,
-0.0008263389,
0.0162626673,
0.0331361331,
0.0407165103,
-0.0105484398,
0.0328388065,
-0.0238024034,
-0.0248890221,
-0.0077605275,
0.0184953529,
-0.0332490765,
-0.0016966512,
-0.0300296787,
-0.0058020651,
-0.0158148147,
0.0048969775,
-0.004779214,
-0.029364178,
0.0184224267,
-0.0783404261,
0.0560075827,
0.0455843359,
-0.032477919,
0.0504786223,
-0.0322560519,
0.0166855138,
0.0492108464,
0.0255745612,
0.0136681041,
0.0172253512,
-0.0756454393,
0.0212116279,
-0.0502952784,
0.0292128436,
-0.0238714777,
0.0143574355,
-0.0819042996,
-0.0080191446,
-0.0051313671,
-0.0032188171,
-0.0230675936,
-0.0161461029,
0.0143319145,
-0.0146194771,
0.0271523818,
0.0466407984,
-0.0906246156,
0.0467851087,
-0.0053842743,
-0.0130442977,
0.0046649151,
0.01275816,
-0.0023851166,
-0.0125590339,
0.0208381321,
0.0687532574,
0.0780685917,
-0.0453202873,
-0.0627041161,
-0.0645589828,
0.0125591327,
-0.0302337371,
-0.0306086205,
-0.0375984423,
-0.0230472498,
-0.0014012598,
-0.0072321794,
0.0518985465,
-0.0266691279,
-0.0369122177,
-0.0709508136,
0.0875844061,
-0.0271135326,
-0.0551868156,
-0.0256584231,
-0.0212268624,
0.0328048691,
0.0627819747,
-0.032870885,
0.0706947297,
0.0433070064,
-0.037615601,
0.0011556137,
0.0038728674,
0.0264351331,
-0.0452868715,
-0.0262068845,
0.0133176511,
0.0057196137,
-0.0174090657,
0.0193380006,
0.003273228,
-0.0322086252,
0.0039206194,
0.0722986683,
-0.0080612097,
0.001584205,
0.0133486409,
-0.0002670436,
0.0102060586,
-0.0006839636,
-0.019661149,
-0.0693781599,
0.017882809,
-0.0266376622,
0.0089234347,
-0.0042478512,
-0.0149431471,
-0.0544077978,
-0.0309014376,
-0.008625227,
-0.0449045151,
0.0379443578,
0.0091251116,
0.0382380486,
-0.0195831079,
-0.0729512051,
-0.0003584166,
0.0695221722,
-0.0150333587,
-0.0340956151,
-0.056872651,
0.051386442,
0.0641669258,
-0.0008353239,
0.0177973993,
0.043094378,
-0.0288979243,
0.0245831758,
0.0631083325,
0.027533669,
0.0027520356,
-0.0302571058,
-0.0488296188,
-0.0214477032,
0.0043336726,
0.0375856496,
0.0186504442,
-0.0147308344,
0.0076771011,
-0.0232106913,
0.027250981,
-0.0310329646,
-0.0046989303,
0.0161189847,
-0.0551144853,
-0.0015586555,
0.0543942004,
-0.0153508037,
0.0350041129,
-0.0068086646,
0.0068362434,
-0.0048958305,
0.0074899839,
-0.0389341451,
-0.0259831976,
-0.0168063715,
0.0133743109,
0.0237343963,
-0.0094733546,
0.0293267462,
-0.0271434262,
-0.0457234532,
-0.0163932554,
0.0931585431,
0.0140453484,
0.0213566851,
-0.0144421551,
-0.068631418,
-0.058971554,
0.0217925161,
-0.015570051,
0.0044488055,
-0.0036264157,
-0.0092581175,
-0.0238770414,
-0.0078898016,
0.0196789391,
0.028722195,
0.0030275167,
-0.0344291665,
-0.0184600037,
0.0470841117,
0.0623918176,
0.004387896,
0.000669859,
-0.0510886982,
-0.094990693,
-0.0469502918,
-0.0356428325,
0.0527346097,
0.0110550812,
0.0231214333,
-0.0066802939,
-0.0109192561,
-0.0186423808,
0.0057074972,
-0.0426213294,
0.0189253762,
0.0333400555,
0.0158059523,
-0.0264214315,
-0.0462066941,
-0.0251535717,
-0.0051069977,
0.0068976972,
0.0557713434,
0.0215392914,
0.0336797573,
-0.0155415973,
-0.0296395402,
-0.0079754833,
-0.0259368662,
-0.0442846455,
0.0074019739,
0.0313382782,
-0.0063579823,
0.044086244,
0.0099172127,
0.0289551672,
-0.0085774474,
0.0293013863,
-0.025822185,
0.0019738234,
-0.0299260896,
-0.0253173001,
-0.0416865796,
0.0208622757,
-0.0332705528,
0.1014927626,
-0.0034494323,
-0.0044677411,
-0.0755897909,
0.0285463873,
-0.0136960018,
0.0115523851,
-0.0177147593,
0.0077737314,
0.0207442213,
0.0150113851,
-0.0046232245,
-0.0753826201,
0.0287937801,
0.0267804358,
0.0155672226,
-0.0171797574,
-0.0281912759,
-0.0499489009,
0.0231178664,
-0.0061002593,
0.0286980458,
0.0070408867,
0.0296118315,
-0.0118815871,
-0.0708590895,
0.0221136082,
-0.0149825616,
-0.0191167295,
-0.0017136789,
0.0260916259,
-0.0124892723,
-0.0081777172,
0.0233939271,
-0.0519108064,
-0.0564812198,
0.0367722735,
0.0704285651,
-0.0562612154,
0.0124421632,
0.043507535,
-0.0158129204,
-0.039409712,
-0.0234728456,
-0.0366880447,
-0.014239626,
-0.0347120278,
0.0589770675,
-0.0479668379,
0.051804617,
-0.0224811826,
0.0342145301,
0.0036816492,
0.0067740669,
-0.0098095667,
-0.0587648787,
-0.0016210544,
0.0032089653,
-0.0125740087,
-0.0049206126,
0.0369990915,
0.0548966862,
-0.0436015092,
0.0120218704,
0.1240780279,
0.0236048568,
-0.0053662225,
0.0039416342,
0.008421923,
-0.0013584287,
-0.0133638028,
0.02046616,
-0.1209268123,
-0.024566764,
-0.0288210083,
0.0389988348,
-0.0439361334,
-0.0414153561,
-0.002398032,
-0.11299216,
0.0515113622,
0.0110129481,
-0.0221651029,
-0.0355819911,
-0.0709903091,
-0.0271369144,
-0.0309117939,
0.0277819037,
-0.0259803273,
-0.0290921666,
0.0154751325,
0.0257452875,
-0.0428198688,
-0.0214744434,
0.0288175046,
-0.0419213511,
0.0258313585,
0.0645733103,
0.0038574513,
-0.0191663653,
-0.0007736646,
0.0033910612,
0.0185730606,
-0.0038427061,
-0.0065797861,
0.0667191669,
0.0130870026,
-0.0401615985,
-0.0065038209,
0.0349678881,
-0.0190932583,
0.0463022701,
-0.0343163572,
-0.0153670916,
0.0226940606,
-0.0679009855,
-0.0292814542,
0.0080184378,
0.0379928872,
0.0339309648,
0.059746936,
-0.0504138619,
-0.0656623095,
-0.0436983705,
-0.0023248296,
-0.0920201167,
-0.0098728128,
-0.0347554274,
0.0525688343,
0.019405758,
-0.0440132022,
-0.0321286134,
-0.0169077609,
0.0094984807,
-0.0161192138,
0.0158176906,
0.0799321905,
-0.0135769183,
-0.0121463714,
0.0520657599,
-0.0297565293,
0.0380747095,
-0.0830869153,
0.01157426,
0.0121005215,
-0.0392828397,
-0.0121783707,
0.0152426464,
-0.092026338,
-0.0311667211,
0.0353883803,
0.0745887831,
0.0153897358,
-0.0068955529,
-0.0445796773,
-0.0348522477,
0.0258458741,
0.062585257,
-0.0328266397,
-0.0299586114,
0.0967384353,
0.034648072,
-0.0443079472,
0.0287711509,
0.0001202062,
0.0589688644,
0.0473444425,
-0.0372563787,
-0.0561237708,
-0.003790305,
-0.0029132923,
0.0166880582,
0.0470841266,
0.0026573902,
-0.0092629092,
0.0205891896,
-0.0171996225,
0.0011346715,
0.006521753,
-0.0250444319,
-0.0635153204,
0.0235492662,
-0.0192782991,
-0.0318565071,
-0.0074366946,
-0.0206662621,
-0.0149007328,
-0.0353900269,
0.0676999539,
-0.0398004055,
0.0668850467,
0.0256158262,
-0.0063840058,
-0.0072026099,
0.0317999683,
0.036047399,
0.028276423,
-0.0113941012,
0.0244772173,
0.0062148571,
0.0401478559,
-0.04088182,
-0.0013207417,
-0.01677786,
-0.0446787775,
0.0056501999,
0.0346792974,
0.0280988161,
-0.0219954923,
0.0051699081,
-0.0097054066,
-0.0003188199,
0.0000776003,
0.0500464328,
-0.0176190976,
-0.0327959135,
0.008376318,
0.0037248041,
-0.0411796197,
-0.0337693803,
0.0566258878,
-0.0223388672,
0.0584726743,
0.0039620646,
0.0174001399,
-0.0270979349,
0.0142698511,
0.0182635132,
-0.0172208585,
-0.0302494355,
0.0625472292,
-0.0606020987,
-0.043222446,
0.0141395703,
-0.0334766284,
0.0116007933,
0.0294119585,
0.0410574451,
0.0293262098,
-0.0299793947,
0.056668058,
-0.0119662927,
-0.0065590912,
0.0023646629,
-0.0290835556,
-0.0353288278,
-6.829098349e-33,
-0.0115192179,
-0.0162050966,
0.0306580719,
-0.0054051643,
0.0297810957,
0.0078928135,
-0.0535712652,
0.0343426168,
-0.0263420045,
0.0326884463,
0.0085697053,
-0.0153431986,
0.013947661,
0.0615169741,
0.0221578963,
0.0149678029,
0.0619635694,
0.009387264,
0.0116645144,
0.0118715009,
0.005963821,
0.0127165979,
0.0462544523,
-0.0719685405,
0.065740481,
0.0119915605,
-0.0457507595,
-0.0329755805,
0.0298175775,
0.0601920448,
0.0062388536,
0.0229127798,
0.0026485219,
-0.045479726,
-0.026678307,
0.0140074715,
-0.0045358441,
-0.0220779423,
-0.0136007704,
0.0361082107,
0.0157506876,
-0.0459051393,
0.0214433391,
0.0169493984,
-0.0064493339,
0.0054986351,
0.0105079534,
0.0078758309,
-0.0034158314,
-0.0515216589,
-0.0936200917,
0.0322259068,
-0.016086163,
0.0192687623,
0.0129594225,
0.0402584448,
0.019420024,
0.0468103811,
-0.0408001915,
0.0471989065,
0.0550460145,
-0.0030260708,
-0.0265206974,
0.0172825605,
-0.0133795384,
0.0460735597,
0.0000512444,
0.0425980911,
0.0098824007,
0.062341392,
0.0436669514,
0.0514552742,
0.0666752979,
0.0450636037,
0.081439428,
-0.057233531,
-0.0521996692,
-0.0367996357,
0.0156046478,
0.0194909666,
0.0550623834,
0.0045060064,
-0.0373804681,
-0.0257084481,
-0.0089540817,
-0.0388475545,
-0.0280297399,
-0.0389488637,
-0.0175555609,
0.0234022345,
-0.0335073993,
-0.0096552521,
0.0208806489,
-0.0944777951,
-0.0774202421,
0.0038882508,
-0.001418552,
0.0524421521,
0.0009067983,
-0.0146714235,
-0.0606451556,
-0.0668898597,
-0.0143985413,
-0.0296456963,
0.0030184793,
0.0130928643,
0.0329088159,
0.016691247,
-0.0553386807,
-0.012276127,
-0.0088641718,
0.0364848822,
0.0097152283,
0.0490045995,
-0.0235674437,
0.030638596,
-0.0192322768,
0.0480272397,
-0.0426451899,
0.0143705904,
0.0332083143,
0.0169652551,
-0.0254852884,
0.0547392666,
0.0127713336,
-0.0266599394,
-0.0111554256,
0.0130435806,
-0.0057053976,
-0.0259389151,
-0.0279689413,
0.0247689355,
2.98e-7,
0.018126715,
0.0992924049,
-0.0049548112,
0.0051746466,
0.0092811938,
0.073849,
-0.0072317487,
0.0024212096,
-0.0241681486,
-0.0257101171,
-0.010937511,
0.0520272627,
0.0554568432,
-0.0029815189,
-0.0734711736,
-0.0102656418,
-0.0188640095,
0.0409538485,
-0.039234098,
0.0704329982,
0.0066379909,
0.1015793607,
-0.0008919303,
-0.0118792867,
0.007643763,
-0.0143045848,
0.0335892215,
-0.0192547459,
-0.0208513178,
0.0208427738,
-0.0269340426,
0.0508208983,
0.0259477478,
0.0166796558,
0.0097789811,
-0.004350936,
-0.0449893214,
0.0404389538,
0.0038916308,
0.0227614921,
0.0123469653,
-0.0102716973,
0.0132642044,
-0.0329316705,
0.0450236648,
-0.0797447488,
-0.0343529508,
-0.0841260478,
-0.0311252568,
0.0357448347,
0.0736130625,
-0.0211910196,
-0.0071284976,
0.0044219629,
0.0179931093,
-0.033206556,
-0.0065167532,
-0.0286500286,
-0.0169236958,
0.0079436954,
-0.0135444868,
0.0069675716,
-0.0191258993,
0.014915945,
0.0463466831,
-0.0147966109,
0.0450955592,
2.722193746e-34,
0.1103571579,
-0.0468664505,
0.0054902001,
0.031471014,
0.0180030223,
0.0157237109,
-0.0299931169,
0.0260430221,
0.0485581383,
-0.0561782494,
0.0254791342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13213v1 | MultiCoNER v2: a Large Multilingual dataset for Fine-grained and Noisy Named Entity Recognition | 2023-10-20T01:14:46 | 2023-10-20T01:14:46 | Besnik Fetahu, Zhiyu Chen, Sudipta Kar, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present MULTICONER V2, a dataset for fine-grained Named Entity Recognition
covering 33 entity classes across 12 languages, in both monolingual and
multilingual settings. This dataset aims to tackle the following practical
challenges in NER: (i) effective handling of fine-grained classes that include
complex entities like movie titles, and (ii) performance degradation due to
noise generated from typing mistakes or OCR errors. The dataset is compiled
from open resources like Wikipedia and Wikidata, and is publicly available.
Evaluation based on the XLM-RoBERTa baseline highlights the unique challenges
posed by MULTICONER V2: (i) the fine-grained taxonomy is challenging, where the
scores are low with macro-F1=0.63 (across all languages), and (ii) the
corruption strategy significantly impairs performance, with entity corruption
resulting in 9% lower performance relative to non-entity corruptions across all
languages. This highlights the greater impact of entity noise in contrast to
context noise. | [
0.0255359318,
0.0908753574,
0.023953421,
0.06336274,
0.0148269767,
0.0541600287,
0.0009570869,
0.0303846002,
-0.0110452725,
-0.0191552304,
-0.0382418446,
-0.0127952285,
0.035733439,
-0.0218829345,
0.0483196974,
-0.0224404037,
0.0302309487,
-0.0327543728,
0.015460032,
0.0083658276,
-0.0046975738,
0.0251271874,
0.0076732342,
0.005217039,
-0.0075783301,
0.0313087292,
-0.0076809428,
0.0285915546,
0.0635123551,
-0.0628553778,
0.0478223749,
0.0448029339,
-0.0179721825,
0.070161432,
0.0000017644,
-0.0656378269,
-0.0060478239,
0.0187928602,
-0.0047651255,
-0.0098868236,
0.009445101,
-0.049265217,
-0.0252544191,
-0.0277384091,
0.0326829143,
-0.0291519519,
0.0256376155,
0.0784879997,
-0.0034118341,
0.0680399761,
-0.0166332945,
-0.0360842496,
0.0155261876,
-0.0215846431,
0.0106973909,
-0.0364145972,
0.0340380482,
-0.0210529119,
-0.0301541835,
0.0138605684,
0.0110994205,
-0.0066584484,
-0.0277738739,
0.0077681281,
-0.050908424,
0.026670441,
-0.031609036,
-0.0134662148,
0.0145403063,
0.0677734092,
-0.0093484074,
0.0279368423,
0.0277055483,
-0.0062257312,
0.0066685984,
-0.0388118364,
0.0039873887,
0.0043665268,
-0.0650769398,
-0.0047473824,
0.0347561389,
-0.0058975103,
0.0456571244,
0.003200012,
-0.0054930197,
-0.003047911,
0.0267958939,
-0.0480269715,
0.0422794148,
0.0160685927,
-0.0019056813,
-0.0399405621,
0.0227715354,
0.0066653569,
0.0100621451,
0.0007264704,
-0.0555750206,
-0.0080671962,
0.0248547941,
-0.0387727655,
-0.0245739799,
0.0098441048,
-0.0112912031,
0.0462222584,
-0.0197409522,
-0.0014541097,
0.0072763907,
0.005746352,
0.0574227683,
-0.0439513065,
-0.0256889239,
0.0390794352,
-0.0232677497,
0.0323545486,
-0.0186138451,
0.0137574971,
-0.0458809845,
-0.0303238612,
-0.0105527062,
0.059749905,
0.0010037916,
-0.0257084146,
0.0140497023,
-0.0007161094,
-0.0214941949,
0.0343500525,
-0.0270289071,
-0.0023651801,
-0.0154237393,
-0.0365574211,
-0.0041936398,
-0.0369145684,
0.0301905219,
-0.0485152416,
0.0610990301,
0.0345130935,
0.0214282107,
-0.0928298607,
-0.060752552,
-0.0163332354,
-0.025318088,
-0.0657476485,
-0.0399886072,
-0.0425365344,
0.0583984517,
0.0146751702,
0.0242386516,
-0.0621004552,
0.0259842239,
-0.0223774202,
-0.0670741722,
0.111427255,
-0.0733821541,
-0.0317410529,
0.0270683132,
0.0081263008,
0.0370990857,
0.0483938046,
0.0385699086,
-0.021484999,
0.0559591316,
-0.0041639837,
-0.0235010888,
0.060930118,
-0.0091423774,
-0.0078632804,
0.0387060829,
0.0008340979,
-0.012689773,
0.0238801166,
0.0324630737,
0.0421358533,
-0.0011246832,
-0.0235541798,
0.0351882726,
0.0125808436,
0.0054535377,
-0.0081582535,
-0.0147128934,
-0.0234407354,
0.0146816233,
-0.0119703123,
-0.0520241708,
0.0123313041,
-0.0136850439,
0.0295131169,
0.0334202424,
0.0788701624,
-0.0064806845,
-0.0049503762,
0.0073473561,
-0.0083111301,
-0.0224047024,
-0.0076444107,
0.0811019614,
0.0160619151,
-0.0568117276,
0.043763835,
0.0472323224,
-0.0339772142,
0.0439781062,
0.002078725,
0.0052166292,
0.081182614,
0.0513767786,
-0.0481801666,
-0.0690097734,
-0.0270986222,
-0.0410825796,
0.0473845452,
0.0154542373,
-0.0442485139,
0.0737810582,
-0.0522863269,
-0.0312012769,
0.007779601,
0.0115174716,
0.0348351598,
0.0189130381,
0.0651829243,
0.0174886491,
-0.0400145054,
-0.0583422408,
0.0428486355,
-0.0051666838,
-0.0224825256,
-0.0223604944,
0.0309991464,
-0.0078334138,
0.0680174604,
-0.0313154794,
-0.0515347682,
0.0117198536,
-0.016025655,
0.0390767939,
-0.044612743,
0.022149859,
-0.0312798806,
0.0179430414,
-0.0221494809,
-0.0533636548,
0.0118396636,
-0.0276530739,
-0.0503539182,
-0.0640442893,
0.0524114445,
-0.006294352,
-0.0204461329,
0.0253922846,
0.0200387463,
0.0424291156,
0.0108133173,
0.0481635556,
-0.0254610777,
0.045771677,
0.0422754213,
-0.0275305696,
0.0130240498,
-0.0342922248,
-0.0815599486,
0.0180605426,
-0.0071416623,
-0.0152154788,
0.0199625418,
0.005169,
-0.0477577634,
-0.0229323283,
-0.037480779,
-0.011624408,
-0.0248386618,
0.0536046289,
-0.013085383,
0.0448716804,
-0.0295852572,
-0.020250136,
0.0118929381,
-0.0024251887,
-0.0379007421,
0.0003986757,
0.027290307,
0.0025905545,
-0.0058908015,
0.0029873452,
0.007288659,
-0.0183654223,
0.0202118345,
0.025990881,
-0.0576205067,
-0.0751187354,
0.0359133072,
-0.0198471602,
-0.0109461294,
-0.0105934227,
0.023088526,
0.0067300252,
0.0354561023,
-0.0114465924,
0.0183560196,
-0.0291900113,
0.028049361,
-0.0109709576,
-0.0181336012,
-0.0217620637,
0.0229802448,
0.0093665738,
0.0238116551,
-0.0525231995,
-0.0481577478,
0.0201475602,
0.0549852327,
-0.0678667501,
0.0353457183,
-0.0340488553,
-0.0039509833,
-0.0049545453,
-0.0070357262,
-0.0031247432,
0.0349431634,
-0.00653427,
0.0307175666,
-0.0154956235,
0.0200001765,
0.0578768961,
-0.0658496097,
-0.0153969321,
0.0307444725,
0.0009176722,
-0.0127236759,
0.0321377479,
-0.0007112967,
0.0121090058,
0.0613352694,
-0.09350916,
-0.0003368225,
0.044296436,
0.0252607651,
-0.0242623985,
0.0378241315,
0.0164221395,
0.0136627583,
-0.0263319332,
-0.0382123627,
-0.0098172082,
0.0151107954,
-0.0366001464,
0.0075981058,
0.0084007112,
-0.0420125201,
-0.012061201,
0.055390466,
-0.0170789808,
0.02898716,
-0.0004748004,
-0.0169464592,
-0.0067102988,
0.0699853897,
0.052644521,
0.0069572404,
0.0221043844,
-0.0364867337,
-0.0290050749,
0.0112098567,
-0.0355495848,
-0.0219071005,
0.0097674625,
-0.008278247,
0.0348225497,
-0.0431807861,
0.0125486525,
-0.0429591611,
0.0507954843,
-0.0517652929,
-0.0013774316,
0.0979662389,
-0.0150917964,
-0.0409670807,
-0.0224369913,
-0.0102502443,
0.0318421386,
0.0223969836,
-0.0018939186,
-0.0839013383,
-0.0399818905,
0.0193838105,
0.0340606794,
0.0089321434,
-0.0933451802,
0.0109891361,
-0.0882439464,
0.0151289515,
-0.0069892174,
-0.0863497257,
-0.0239301752,
-0.0555032156,
0.0072897919,
-0.0519914851,
0.0414194614,
-0.0393949598,
0.0108060604,
-0.0098034916,
-0.002228555,
-0.0012388637,
-0.0831453651,
0.0089417975,
-0.0556761958,
0.064132601,
-0.0046948483,
0.0277957637,
-0.0504567884,
0.0111947665,
0.0253767259,
-0.0531744324,
-0.0174634866,
-0.008733565,
0.0779426321,
-0.0475400388,
-0.0417330526,
-0.0225189738,
-0.0048089698,
-0.0179970935,
-0.0162736047,
0.0079310788,
0.0382139795,
0.0085814483,
0.0138152894,
0.0177521855,
-0.0571833029,
0.0418894701,
0.0542324744,
0.0082208738,
-0.0283501949,
-0.013275845,
-0.0032932821,
-0.0122617241,
-0.0447239503,
0.0148823587,
0.0377097651,
-0.0401661359,
-0.0562738478,
-0.020709144,
-0.1120163724,
0.0609353185,
0.0167440362,
0.0229905825,
0.0104590189,
0.0342249759,
0.0103614768,
-0.0708775148,
0.0224131998,
-0.0119600464,
-0.0011862769,
-0.0397959203,
-0.0084649157,
-0.0138338786,
0.0413401127,
-0.0316952877,
0.010228199,
-0.0530432276,
-0.0750926808,
0.0115054827,
0.0491669625,
0.0077608251,
0.0534889586,
0.0099507244,
-0.0339784585,
0.0428761393,
0.0700000748,
-0.0151657527,
-0.0287969634,
0.0065160166,
0.004178769,
-0.0408210829,
0.0351477675,
-0.0464596041,
-0.0106162261,
0.0196052603,
0.0534856543,
-0.0273159873,
-0.0455612689,
-0.0153065799,
0.0194108896,
0.0321526974,
-0.0630906299,
-0.0107603604,
-0.0770636275,
0.0253549851,
0.0149358092,
0.0147001594,
0.0009086093,
-0.0307549443,
0.0316036232,
-0.0196711402,
-0.0103534954,
0.0595130101,
0.0048995353,
0.014975464,
-0.0835305825,
0.0212830175,
0.0344169661,
0.0463349484,
0.0366495959,
-0.0379450992,
0.0196092222,
0.0549359508,
0.0437883921,
0.0504857227,
-0.0509309769,
0.0023015554,
0.0187968686,
0.0047571943,
0.0086128721,
0.0319337025,
0.0100097023,
0.0413461328,
-0.0189682562,
0.0373943485,
0.0609978624,
0.004058178,
0.0853991285,
-0.0121644614,
-0.0143356193,
0.0059263906,
0.0012528989,
-0.0088879634,
-0.0083211558,
0.0299794897,
0.0271718763,
-0.0139094554,
0.0218015146,
0.0688221306,
-0.0112346141,
0.03253996,
0.0479276069,
-0.0092637269,
-0.0215021614,
-0.010746561,
0.0089830533,
-0.0166184474,
-0.0372381583,
-0.026473254,
-0.0383470319,
-0.0444453284,
0.0159647167,
-0.0252530463,
-0.0314231776,
0.0169169083,
-0.0250277817,
-0.0017888105,
0.0221175775,
-0.0170724522,
-0.0215533543,
-0.014227205,
-0.018559387,
-0.037014883,
0.0077898386,
-6.033635077e-33,
-0.0238457806,
-0.0328320637,
-0.0053315395,
-0.0080698766,
-0.0116690239,
0.0232001003,
-0.0115495045,
-0.0136768464,
-0.0037933979,
0.0061924537,
-0.0127429292,
0.0085777799,
0.0315410756,
0.0033620547,
0.0165096298,
-0.0315705352,
0.0481030755,
0.0529482514,
-0.0473083667,
0.004636406,
0.0344046131,
0.0653804466,
0.1266547889,
-0.0760851428,
0.0768856406,
-0.0120110959,
-0.0111812595,
-0.0267859716,
0.075104557,
0.0533777997,
-0.011708837,
0.0327966474,
0.0170591716,
-0.0496775806,
0.0223251712,
-0.025311891,
-0.1684329361,
0.0180094801,
-0.040401943,
0.0716937929,
0.0107964454,
-0.02531543,
0.0218182895,
-0.0030255655,
0.0194216166,
0.013590497,
0.0348833799,
-0.0048943586,
0.0095655108,
-0.0111158853,
-0.0564141497,
0.0458580032,
0.0008304651,
0.0420183651,
0.041271437,
-0.0212427583,
0.0408088155,
-0.0068975156,
-0.0977066606,
-0.001420801,
0.0086503988,
-0.0074458388,
0.021951234,
0.024976274,
-0.0390940942,
0.0348265022,
0.0559391119,
0.0341031589,
-0.0044877017,
-0.0077528409,
0.0124701457,
0.0145205092,
-0.0163206141,
0.0789657682,
0.0557379909,
-0.0383718573,
-0.053012576,
0.063940905,
-0.0292538926,
0.0180967972,
-0.0179129932,
-0.0554166362,
-0.0345571078,
0.0023050457,
-0.0128542678,
-0.0432105102,
-0.0422396585,
0.0185253136,
0.0009182786,
-0.0052164425,
-0.0186116528,
0.0517015569,
0.0095768515,
-0.0152962813,
-0.0658663809,
-0.004413764,
0.0375701524,
0.0105573414,
-0.0215644594,
0.0040143807,
-0.0283172932,
-0.0414706767,
0.0118243163,
-0.0038819115,
0.0504974686,
-0.00842865,
0.0775512978,
0.0092576705,
-0.0667197257,
0.0050004092,
0.0016437484,
0.0254202187,
-0.0267068502,
0.02877336,
0.0136953602,
-0.023137385,
0.0041927039,
-0.0089291176,
0.1021654606,
0.0112975528,
0.0155557944,
0.0284287501,
0.0366518609,
0.0236609932,
-0.0086746775,
-0.0059989402,
0.0016282583,
-0.0218903888,
0.0171209089,
-0.0296216216,
0.0003085277,
-0.0190008376,
2.486e-7,
0.0251772571,
0.0236413404,
0.0081211496,
0.009154235,
-0.0419918448,
0.0223291311,
0.0087183956,
0.0564891659,
-0.0573570095,
0.0028338062,
0.0088762138,
-0.0415598936,
0.0259745121,
0.0388335474,
-0.098819986,
-0.0379536599,
-0.0052423943,
0.0120698158,
-0.0668424442,
0.0488502346,
0.011493383,
0.0488394834,
-0.0223983955,
-0.0501367971,
-0.0182770938,
-0.0518275984,
0.0415453203,
-0.0222404115,
0.0108251357,
0.0268711746,
0.0198373292,
0.0557353124,
-0.0228998456,
0.0434790254,
-0.0138108535,
-0.0034015994,
0.0101603484,
0.0372555926,
-0.0222388078,
-0.0006903323,
-0.0044149663,
-0.0411315784,
-0.003977478,
-0.0512154736,
0.0560613461,
0.0125798974,
-0.0283592679,
0.0009754677,
-0.0367514379,
-0.0075164051,
0.0169391204,
-0.0118249329,
-0.0110546984,
0.0036233161,
0.0339160487,
-0.0113406079,
-0.009165301,
-0.0553362928,
0.0433357246,
0.0266605094,
0.0440279841,
-0.0204167627,
0.0034029426,
-0.0678663179,
0.0118988547,
-0.0567806736,
-0.0011897149,
2.087942683e-34,
0.0076602516,
-0.0100125587,
-0.0240394175,
0.0129551403,
0.0138283717,
-0.0327668153,
-0.0471245982,
-0.0106916074,
-0.0501258038,
-0.0177385602,
-0.0076456508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13206v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13206v2 | Primacy Effect of ChatGPT | 2023-10-20T00:37:28 | 2024-05-14T17:17:17 | Yiwei Wang, Yujun Cai, Muhao Chen, Yuxuan Liang, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have led to
promising zero-shot performance in discriminative natural language
understanding (NLU) tasks. This involves querying the LLM using a prompt
containing the question, and the candidate labels to choose from. The
question-answering capabilities of ChatGPT arise from its pre-training on large
amounts of human-written text, as well as its subsequent fine-tuning on human
preferences, which motivates us to ask: Does ChatGPT also inherits humans'
cognitive biases? In this paper, we study the primacy effect of ChatGPT: the
tendency of selecting the labels at earlier positions as the answer. We have
two main findings: i) ChatGPT's decision is sensitive to the order of labels in
the prompt; ii) ChatGPT has a clearly higher chance to select the labels at
earlier positions as the answer. We hope that our experiments and analyses
provide additional insights into building more reliable ChatGPT-based
solutions. We release the source code at
https://github.com/wangywUST/PrimacyEffectGPT. | [
0.047757227,
0.0024649655,
0.0059181126,
0.0216132887,
-0.0296574961,
0.034597896,
0.0082823467,
-0.0280095767,
0.0546790585,
-0.0612316355,
-0.0461481996,
-0.0317880437,
-0.034466207,
-0.022203235,
0.0105585782,
-0.0339975432,
0.068921417,
-0.0562297106,
0.055552993,
-0.0166879296,
-0.0080546346,
-0.0008611885,
-0.0273634382,
0.0258550402,
0.0111232931,
-0.0191344786,
0.0166362189,
-0.0025247782,
-0.0046274625,
-0.0230400655,
0.0267082024,
0.0697144419,
0.0141164996,
0.0456282236,
0.0000019966,
-0.0373996571,
0.0080637429,
-0.0218634624,
-0.0468764491,
0.0183496345,
0.0148080261,
0.0545827188,
0.0077473586,
0.0103537161,
-0.0327708423,
-0.0115144448,
0.0353481248,
0.0604183935,
0.0404459834,
0.0657797158,
0.0096529853,
-0.0157407615,
-0.0009232546,
-0.017414365,
0.0581592545,
-0.0911532491,
0.0163660813,
0.0181964785,
0.0105206808,
0.0473580956,
-0.0214313604,
0.0226618648,
0.0157943293,
0.0355361551,
-0.0016067083,
0.0740508512,
-0.0297128353,
-0.027057711,
-0.0157790575,
0.0765545592,
0.0024801549,
-0.0246297717,
-0.018288875,
0.0033518346,
0.0391160734,
-0.0301929433,
-0.0691783056,
0.0371612422,
-0.0240097716,
0.0140378829,
0.0249920599,
-0.0058449171,
-0.009527294,
0.0268276911,
-0.012929054,
0.0989943296,
0.0022308647,
-0.0386808813,
0.0381141379,
0.0229911301,
-0.0595892072,
-0.0634487718,
0.0002761961,
0.02122044,
-0.0548162647,
0.0041273055,
-0.0419853814,
0.0365941599,
0.0095972177,
-0.0165448394,
0.0003775631,
0.0629075244,
-0.0373147689,
0.0618988238,
-0.0059994208,
0.073991783,
0.0047247135,
0.0364841297,
-0.0649478883,
-0.022464307,
-0.0621036924,
-0.0331262946,
-0.0340480059,
0.0381447934,
-0.0082009016,
-0.0126687065,
-0.0477089621,
0.0306479558,
0.0271542836,
-0.0274802409,
0.0162214153,
0.0282396059,
-0.0325140841,
0.0173178054,
-0.0258979425,
0.0647205934,
-0.0575136915,
0.0232095588,
0.0004652833,
-0.071363233,
-0.0244004969,
0.0200485699,
-0.016370859,
-0.0583660528,
0.0118385069,
0.0632183626,
-0.0477581024,
-0.0599938631,
-0.0122817699,
0.0058771279,
-0.0202289317,
-0.043407049,
0.0069254083,
-0.0415116735,
0.0057842536,
0.0381747708,
0.001656963,
-0.0149269449,
0.0122543564,
0.052462101,
-0.0527874418,
0.0598628931,
0.0312585793,
0.0153034991,
0.0343225636,
0.0094973361,
-0.0317455679,
0.0767153576,
0.0064363629,
0.0354116447,
0.0482715182,
-0.0159653816,
0.0146239987,
0.0287713334,
-0.0046754126,
-0.0125540951,
0.0207064245,
0.0432209559,
0.0143289026,
0.0315210968,
0.0491187759,
0.0315232836,
-0.0495298244,
-0.039872054,
0.0803568587,
0.0639946759,
-0.0253287908,
-0.0362332091,
-0.0012717104,
0.0411772244,
-0.0099488422,
0.0412859544,
-0.0706378892,
0.0437889025,
-0.0328341201,
0.0007461392,
0.020130625,
0.0141914701,
-0.036768876,
-0.0065837693,
-0.012402188,
0.0396811888,
-0.0260746703,
0.04547479,
0.0288185608,
-0.0156966355,
-0.0420265011,
0.056150768,
0.0185237415,
-0.0091702295,
-0.0262226816,
-0.0598516725,
0.0131372558,
0.014177341,
0.0196540244,
-0.0243406147,
-0.0299545657,
-0.012575482,
0.0312760137,
0.0296065453,
0.0607018434,
-0.0163971148,
0.0109551642,
-0.036888957,
0.0030449613,
0.0096807219,
0.001459234,
0.0191576183,
0.0275043957,
-0.0036276651,
-0.0012599063,
-0.0133892428,
-0.0087545589,
0.0309646148,
0.0393277854,
-0.0607644655,
0.0104956124,
-0.00486336,
0.0154730668,
-0.018267775,
-0.0244158264,
0.017552847,
0.013576326,
0.0121262129,
-0.0143064829,
-0.0178208482,
-0.0623860545,
-0.0526568815,
0.0261780173,
-0.0317666531,
-0.0496691056,
-0.0031552971,
-0.0563679934,
-0.032813888,
-0.036899507,
-0.0307037886,
-0.0177929867,
-0.032707423,
-0.0041736201,
0.0136842616,
-0.013563497,
-0.0868825316,
0.0736535341,
0.0094961319,
0.0078266039,
0.020582309,
0.0055510523,
0.0148017984,
-0.0575654656,
-0.0025212511,
0.0208607446,
-0.0049189767,
-0.0097261807,
0.0414416604,
0.0075528203,
-0.0745172203,
-0.0379858017,
-0.1133227944,
0.0335347354,
-0.0118466066,
0.0197546314,
0.0118670939,
0.0028782398,
-0.0357171483,
-0.0293345042,
-0.0336719565,
-0.0154705718,
0.0054893428,
0.0529786609,
0.018208731,
-0.021127196,
0.011876625,
-0.0482981578,
-0.0006717395,
-0.0137151396,
0.0113894548,
0.0231003705,
0.0014573529,
-0.024584841,
0.0123482672,
-0.0050649336,
0.0309714004,
-0.0084144324,
-0.0269900691,
0.0321604796,
-0.0078613162,
-0.0007236853,
0.1188216507,
0.0180583913,
0.0034734609,
0.0252380669,
-0.0032404694,
-0.0373439044,
0.0203788225,
-0.0295900311,
-0.0504504852,
-0.0159420557,
-0.0157587528,
-0.0199104026,
0.1103228703,
0.0169057641,
-0.0144831417,
-0.0449153967,
0.0229877196,
-0.0203387532,
-0.0035592162,
-0.0602548569,
0.0112979347,
-0.0173596498,
0.0285868701,
-0.0323125795,
-0.0193303972,
0.0779744536,
-0.0168868452,
-0.0302907545,
-0.0636655688,
-0.0005616693,
-0.0520311855,
0.0372759886,
0.0383435078,
-0.0074588,
0.0217560399,
-0.0324861705,
-0.0804308951,
-0.0162231382,
0.0310671236,
-0.0187296122,
0.0145651503,
-0.0542664714,
0.0281003192,
-0.0298336912,
-0.0575143844,
-0.054737404,
-0.0481740236,
-0.0445164666,
0.0199142247,
-0.0084105814,
0.0183211956,
-0.0564624928,
0.00839247,
0.0434668586,
0.0195537992,
-0.0363878608,
-0.0023953265,
-0.0165404491,
0.0526878089,
0.0641659647,
0.0049720583,
0.0063581537,
-0.0067339768,
0.0123560615,
0.0642310157,
0.0310401898,
0.0150380563,
0.0169967283,
0.0063890358,
0.0242136084,
-0.0390877463,
-0.0270155165,
0.0366016775,
0.0523890369,
-0.0158457682,
-0.0068665938,
0.1259641051,
0.0324472487,
-0.0447360091,
-0.0066381185,
0.0185933411,
0.0491188616,
0.0507554263,
0.0218622163,
-0.0791604295,
-0.0659067854,
0.0051872423,
0.0140835019,
-0.0174889211,
-0.0225154981,
-0.020272525,
-0.1087202579,
0.0173404384,
-0.0191294849,
-0.0673289225,
0.0126263816,
-0.0319375582,
0.007281539,
-0.0286594667,
0.0094347298,
0.0212338269,
-0.0264217164,
0.0337931886,
0.0293725766,
0.0032387378,
-0.0132751092,
0.0549124666,
-0.0124002285,
0.0322942361,
0.0400704108,
0.0198838934,
0.0101603791,
-0.0018911774,
0.0368158594,
-0.024043154,
0.0058067846,
-0.0130743105,
0.0259477757,
-0.03097382,
-0.0016180531,
-0.0337738991,
0.0437584929,
-0.0138204684,
0.004463796,
0.0255229864,
0.0480918102,
-0.0137562854,
-0.0091637112,
-0.0141832288,
0.0039322022,
0.0063954252,
0.1034837216,
0.0282820128,
-0.0387408026,
-0.0562149882,
-0.0354993269,
-0.0097569991,
-0.0315999202,
-0.0803364515,
0.0310988873,
0.0000616608,
-0.0223224387,
-0.0449614339,
-0.0479861908,
0.0358646549,
0.0161088165,
-0.0195911098,
0.0013381371,
-0.0235998146,
0.0261784233,
-0.0026498912,
0.0519345291,
-0.0501607507,
0.0069062123,
-0.089708589,
-0.0050222618,
0.0470816568,
-0.0236897822,
-0.0351205058,
0.0189598892,
-0.0710015222,
-0.0502576306,
0.0022863687,
0.0211237613,
0.0274853278,
0.0390124992,
-0.0051643439,
-0.0681221262,
-0.0024540215,
0.0589132272,
-0.0380374305,
0.0195463393,
0.0032381879,
-0.0036780313,
-0.0151544465,
0.0161102824,
-0.0370323434,
0.0423926674,
0.0232773069,
0.0322241634,
-0.0045816125,
-0.0263907649,
0.0466097631,
0.0204526912,
0.0790753216,
-0.0104227047,
0.0455059893,
-0.0228879154,
0.0158362072,
0.0126015423,
-0.0192824584,
0.0026113575,
-0.0198728424,
0.0132397739,
-0.0528832786,
-0.0117881251,
-0.0342298634,
-0.0285736099,
0.0376913622,
-0.0234447289,
-0.0155572509,
0.0476043671,
0.0092836972,
0.0281257201,
-0.0184726976,
-0.0499278009,
0.0233033653,
0.0268128403,
0.0770552829,
0.0124612497,
0.0954042003,
0.0220300667,
-0.0193443857,
-0.0093136737,
-0.0121380752,
-0.1058718488,
-0.0567268431,
-0.0162053369,
0.0223835725,
0.0748003721,
-0.038594909,
0.0128502371,
-0.0172104985,
-0.017776547,
-0.034432143,
-0.0130506931,
0.0068242704,
0.0052487417,
0.0327277109,
0.0258729905,
-0.0008371099,
0.0204745308,
0.0921502039,
0.0608190112,
0.0321831889,
0.0151553648,
-0.0141719319,
-0.0171302985,
-0.0389733501,
-0.0187327098,
0.0018513334,
0.0064742435,
0.0443281792,
-0.0574886203,
-0.0451522991,
-0.0254965834,
0.003382996,
0.0072285109,
-0.0283761565,
0.0473823287,
0.0530283228,
-0.0170741063,
-0.0723223761,
-0.0333978273,
0.039648205,
-0.0243252162,
-0.0140165053,
-0.0446013138,
-6.749236732e-33,
-0.0435161255,
-0.0227886103,
0.0220361874,
0.0107589019,
0.0060146996,
-0.0180829298,
-0.0134160239,
0.0123383049,
-0.0316426083,
-0.0035302718,
-0.0357228518,
0.0084060188,
0.0241417624,
0.0239975844,
-0.0102350805,
-0.0438898541,
0.0153744137,
-0.0155609455,
-0.0360797793,
0.0060830363,
0.0142485686,
0.013346673,
0.0428796001,
-0.0438017137,
0.0215809345,
-0.0164449178,
0.0406279862,
0.0224489663,
-0.0227359142,
0.0609635115,
-0.0208281446,
0.0589460693,
0.0289101675,
-0.0609731227,
0.0028670395,
0.0416240841,
-0.0696695596,
-0.0559289791,
0.0332663767,
0.018973846,
-0.0011725152,
-0.0219575148,
0.0020014644,
-0.0205103941,
0.0043183188,
-0.0164845269,
0.0244914945,
-0.0017698166,
-0.0553670488,
0.0204798654,
-0.0435840264,
0.0177481268,
-0.0367333777,
-0.0198576041,
0.0155747812,
0.0568498559,
0.007136147,
0.0093078809,
-0.0309786834,
0.012016722,
0.0281584598,
0.0310831685,
0.0389347523,
0.0438973606,
0.0128950169,
0.0435355045,
0.0511958301,
0.0099394899,
-0.0090760253,
-0.0265401714,
-0.0206826124,
0.0088862209,
0.0254945103,
0.0143747404,
0.0374106206,
0.0187708624,
-0.0751097798,
0.0038650907,
0.0366219282,
0.0074549201,
0.0299609415,
0.0307295099,
-0.0399133787,
-0.0508118756,
-0.0497613028,
0.0078522693,
-0.0437438674,
-0.000089666,
0.0592749156,
-0.0095657986,
-0.0039188531,
-0.0451469496,
0.0561233088,
-0.02412601,
-0.0256111622,
0.0024445094,
-0.0275784656,
0.0190713666,
-0.0072558392,
0.0524819717,
-0.0634387657,
0.0019854703,
0.0266469754,
-0.0046143867,
0.000446605,
0.014256889,
0.0203074962,
-0.0211562924,
-0.0360738486,
-0.0178780556,
-0.0355212092,
0.0082967635,
-0.0026122411,
-0.0007772107,
0.0300917886,
0.023648398,
-0.0071322462,
0.0739190355,
0.0111183813,
-0.0210924596,
-0.0305443965,
-0.0302134603,
-0.014832492,
0.0010638249,
-0.0316634625,
0.0234762654,
-0.0053661568,
0.0067847683,
-0.0391691439,
-0.0524315946,
-0.0235351417,
0.0483083613,
2.703e-7,
0.0329282247,
0.0625880212,
0.0132114664,
0.0117319608,
0.0415988415,
0.0600058436,
0.0043412703,
0.0054565878,
0.0606700629,
-0.0307082888,
-0.0032569724,
0.0395431966,
0.0322942361,
0.0223145932,
-0.0918600932,
-0.0214555021,
-0.0453991294,
0.0215412192,
-0.0403642431,
0.0068628713,
0.0630790442,
0.0856944174,
-0.0071175275,
-0.0021771316,
-0.0078135086,
-0.0097952196,
0.0546852425,
-0.0105364304,
0.0183083694,
0.0279021338,
0.0183490347,
0.0032081145,
-0.0002939599,
0.0631619543,
0.03089213,
-0.0135525651,
0.033253409,
0.0584282465,
-0.0111356471,
-0.0365873091,
-0.0229553599,
-0.0086663365,
0.0135764647,
-0.0612468608,
0.1249315366,
-0.0904335976,
-0.0354759432,
-0.033177115,
-0.0167066548,
-0.0250656344,
0.0166927576,
-0.0010646177,
-0.0128321592,
0.002452814,
0.0080254292,
0.0059734662,
-0.0221370142,
-0.0742858499,
-0.0096246991,
0.0112740053,
-0.0462047271,
-0.0442497544,
-0.0347576514,
0.0328775086,
0.0204893518,
-0.0391676873,
-0.022831602,
2.315228419e-34,
0.027842924,
-0.0130964592,
0.0242769644,
0.0206008423,
0.0444448292,
0.0015288853,
-0.0164325144,
-0.0130908657,
0.0378464833,
-0.1001094356,
-0.011883527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18330v1 | Towards Detecting Contextual Real-Time Toxicity for In-Game Chat | 2023-10-20T00:29:57 | 2023-10-20T00:29:57 | Zachary Yang, Nicolas Grenan-Godbout, Reihaneh Rabbany | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Real-time toxicity detection in online environments poses a significant
challenge, due to the increasing prevalence of social media and gaming
platforms. We introduce ToxBuster, a simple and scalable model that reliably
detects toxic content in real-time for a line of chat by including chat history
and metadata. ToxBuster consistently outperforms conventional toxicity models
across popular multiplayer games, including Rainbow Six Siege, For Honor, and
DOTA 2. We conduct an ablation study to assess the importance of each model
component and explore ToxBuster's transferability across the datasets.
Furthermore, we showcase ToxBuster's efficacy in post-game moderation,
successfully flagging 82.1% of chat-reported players at a precision level of
90.0%. Additionally, we show how an additional 6% of unreported toxic players
can be proactively moderated. | [
0.0331288204,
0.0001755152,
-0.0472609997,
-0.018722795,
-0.0151750222,
0.0140628926,
0.0237569362,
0.0455918722,
0.0349431857,
-0.0344325788,
0.0036101178,
-0.0042392849,
-0.0179537199,
0.0797927156,
0.0069201286,
-0.0033979209,
-0.0145751564,
0.0106273163,
0.0260039046,
0.049671419,
0.0571153499,
-0.0228987113,
-0.0081815813,
0.0737736002,
-0.0134511786,
-0.0267427061,
0.0245584287,
0.0102449311,
0.0325317755,
-0.0330841057,
0.0125866197,
-0.0220248774,
-0.0323442258,
-0.0199228749,
0.0000018479,
-0.0145813702,
-0.021472251,
-0.0229066331,
0.0177438557,
-0.0274321679,
0.0528558381,
-0.0009298613,
-0.0025255296,
0.0617804006,
-0.0154465726,
0.0275174361,
0.0665250421,
-0.0059432196,
0.090444617,
0.0192439165,
-0.0489084795,
0.0632953718,
0.0075996378,
0.0125825582,
0.0121749602,
-0.0007503736,
0.0184654705,
0.0125336647,
-0.0225602165,
0.0003116031,
-0.0128896842,
0.0112911155,
-0.0546460636,
-0.0024315245,
-0.0269501098,
-0.0033486364,
0.0143906977,
-0.0202007033,
0.0214146301,
0.0567815416,
-0.0759715959,
-0.0148512982,
0.0284991413,
0.0179495607,
-0.0021562518,
-0.0213119965,
-0.0360629186,
0.0023683365,
-0.0269877445,
-0.012853574,
-0.0294248424,
0.0376679488,
0.051013872,
0.0013838289,
0.0649209619,
-0.0243702177,
-0.0163689349,
-0.0275372472,
-0.0653294474,
-0.0147513952,
-0.0039151497,
0.0053001344,
0.02592903,
-0.0064917719,
-0.1068515107,
0.0053868056,
-0.0424642898,
-0.0299892426,
0.0116954492,
-0.0714050829,
0.014470391,
0.0341940634,
-0.0513485186,
0.0442916304,
0.0158382002,
-0.0076355436,
0.0372983813,
-0.0234289318,
-0.0063270004,
0.001339566,
0.0074889585,
0.0125495652,
-0.0107580069,
-0.0111857392,
0.0511522703,
0.0124017559,
-0.0538728647,
0.0333227441,
-0.0495546274,
0.0193379559,
0.0196612366,
-0.0068642995,
0.0029251692,
0.0830595642,
0.0207402091,
-0.0224203225,
-0.023212513,
0.0127440654,
-0.0184970237,
-0.0464238897,
0.0083717024,
0.0070568216,
-0.0210739579,
-0.0075377249,
0.0233456157,
0.0795675293,
0.0519380197,
-0.0000527719,
-0.0075676674,
-0.0297323316,
-0.0251176823,
-0.0054723336,
-0.042470254,
-0.056114085,
0.0146813439,
-0.0330899619,
0.0078808852,
-0.0113196559,
-0.005312792,
0.0074230474,
-0.0144518735,
0.074419193,
-0.0325848758,
0.0271953996,
-0.0073042735,
0.0139227193,
-0.0245065819,
0.0598097518,
-0.0091077965,
0.0091043971,
0.0296046417,
-0.0009560364,
-0.0169126112,
0.0289710183,
-0.0037382029,
-0.0067435941,
-0.0476742573,
-0.04174513,
-0.0431381874,
-0.0199254137,
-0.0331916474,
0.0307273082,
-0.0296217483,
-0.0319158211,
0.0922697783,
0.0075590527,
-0.0435423292,
-0.0075126905,
0.0490615442,
0.0089958832,
-0.0576818064,
-0.0528039783,
-0.0343929604,
0.0125328787,
0.0142675852,
-0.0419281945,
-0.0040431707,
0.0574844219,
-0.0168442894,
-0.0560306162,
-0.0019877409,
-0.0105864229,
0.0441621989,
-0.0054246155,
0.0193931218,
0.0021683499,
-0.0298920516,
0.0361558609,
0.0570258908,
0.0042455946,
-0.0211935062,
-0.0451947302,
0.0684976876,
0.0849209428,
0.0381060019,
-0.0243066791,
-0.0449947454,
-0.0663838834,
0.0215212405,
-0.0114051104,
-0.027971644,
0.0198603906,
0.0139831454,
0.0012926055,
-0.0185378231,
0.0373043753,
0.0027638453,
-0.0107818395,
0.0042068786,
0.0299725104,
-0.0457670651,
-0.0017368626,
-0.0153323468,
0.016309591,
0.0323541351,
-0.042322468,
-0.0108287856,
0.0159155782,
0.039590057,
-0.0118191028,
0.0238552354,
-0.0401059315,
0.0353937149,
0.0132301087,
-0.0228504073,
0.0093078054,
0.0229463652,
0.0425200649,
0.0734522939,
-0.030845711,
0.020331597,
0.0572301,
-0.0231270008,
0.0423361324,
0.0198523831,
-0.0297060702,
-0.0127935726,
0.0129787801,
-0.0308560506,
-0.0378891192,
0.0840255544,
0.014248142,
0.0101142135,
-0.0135815302,
-0.0376722515,
-0.0227114782,
-0.0698775277,
-0.0262948275,
0.0090394709,
0.0052376785,
-0.0158398747,
-0.0633091629,
0.0020243393,
0.0236312784,
0.0289769322,
-0.0223246962,
0.0170209128,
-0.0455808379,
-0.0005696244,
-0.0337069668,
-0.0163171366,
0.0303582363,
0.0408552103,
-0.0081613502,
0.0170428883,
-0.0253179744,
-0.0253909994,
0.082239233,
0.0251759831,
0.0028376402,
-0.0436834395,
-0.0121941753,
-0.0298767388,
-0.0113935219,
-0.0223003533,
0.0374940261,
-0.0353522226,
-0.0762561113,
0.0529434979,
0.0042845588,
-0.0341715328,
0.0044877571,
-0.0295287408,
-0.0637889802,
0.0346096829,
-0.0080519607,
0.0022239657,
0.0760085583,
0.0534217432,
0.0683554709,
0.065147467,
-0.0038382022,
-0.0031405226,
0.0058368687,
-0.0146817304,
-0.0437790677,
-0.0223445036,
-0.0407692939,
0.0319592804,
0.0521469042,
0.0153369196,
-0.0078321518,
-0.033721976,
0.0212812554,
-0.0142757446,
-0.000949475,
-0.020292094,
-0.081731312,
0.0051528248,
-0.0568895936,
-0.0027914469,
-0.0579530299,
0.0161081143,
0.0078056501,
0.0322614349,
0.034295544,
-0.0421089754,
0.0255669039,
0.0055558649,
-0.0114148883,
0.0029230188,
0.0084505491,
-0.0051303138,
0.0800625309,
-0.0787863731,
0.1016764194,
-0.0619185492,
-0.0394958928,
-0.0211404804,
-0.0006737521,
0.0353510641,
-0.021431582,
-0.0168161318,
-0.0367839858,
-0.0244742725,
-0.0385498703,
-0.0016976419,
0.0022945711,
-0.060086228,
0.0317537598,
0.0171242133,
-0.0566765815,
0.0169298407,
-0.049774576,
0.0120550413,
-0.0448012501,
0.0499640815,
-0.0573831461,
0.024312662,
-0.0084045613,
0.0643609241,
0.1118187979,
-0.0348959714,
-0.0505126715,
-0.0079501225,
0.0232757106,
0.0053901519,
0.0033145307,
-0.0099583222,
0.0164340138,
0.0042072753,
-0.0221934542,
0.0094682425,
0.0406994708,
0.0115339318,
0.0117757106,
0.0330333151,
0.0059668105,
-0.0263888314,
0.0037884568,
-0.0196516328,
-0.0804182738,
-0.011000352,
0.0086468104,
0.0450449139,
-0.0820362717,
-0.0866090208,
0.0261236858,
-0.0438369997,
0.0086503588,
0.0087424899,
-0.0565909706,
-0.0265501235,
-0.0197215099,
0.0142518701,
-0.0594481044,
0.0656132028,
-0.0599656031,
0.011188983,
0.0121274944,
0.0124809574,
-0.0585070774,
0.0116814626,
0.0217518341,
-0.0667405277,
0.0777142197,
-0.0144126369,
0.0696775168,
-0.0126293181,
0.0298560131,
0.0002255221,
0.0522833653,
-0.0304790568,
-0.0050010034,
0.0965095833,
-0.0075954017,
0.000302219,
-0.0430112518,
0.0147029664,
-0.014191296,
-0.0066840155,
0.0052417596,
0.0330145955,
0.0182075873,
-0.0250307787,
-0.0276012421,
0.0127370143,
0.0696936697,
0.0252157561,
0.0246379431,
-0.0537440144,
0.0120735075,
-0.0142055107,
-0.0035011326,
0.0001855762,
-0.0807262585,
-0.0608554371,
0.0027326324,
-0.0443050377,
-0.0509168059,
0.022541659,
-0.0503347442,
0.0340204239,
-0.0144779934,
0.0097968355,
-0.0445233211,
0.0197667107,
0.0274315439,
0.0211576112,
0.0245145485,
0.03278514,
-0.0008576168,
0.0599648356,
-0.0203637071,
-0.019607719,
-0.0093089025,
0.1000453681,
-0.0300738197,
-0.0110387215,
0.0600584932,
0.0805405378,
0.0131962653,
-0.0213090926,
-0.0222048648,
0.0203145258,
0.0246892311,
0.0212780889,
-0.0262176432,
-0.0375842564,
0.0482896678,
0.0154866148,
0.0440995656,
0.0033826455,
-0.0440459289,
0.0640102699,
0.0463421941,
-0.038451694,
-0.0694526881,
0.0406848304,
0.0088070966,
0.0161967259,
0.0664326772,
-0.0072582704,
-0.0485783592,
0.0367712677,
-0.0336101018,
-0.0523543544,
0.0041834628,
0.0331910439,
0.0246845875,
0.0270980261,
-0.024114944,
-0.034451779,
0.0109735383,
-0.0112579754,
-0.0118724639,
-0.0282279588,
-0.0000310941,
0.0229323339,
-0.0382290296,
0.0500270799,
0.0157453977,
0.036149893,
0.0404448658,
0.0191463474,
0.0171951856,
-0.0050293496,
-0.0491907224,
0.0026163326,
-0.0062216558,
0.0319549516,
0.0160879213,
-0.0018877143,
0.0115879038,
0.0114915594,
0.0164441131,
0.0036096207,
0.0305667855,
0.046308659,
0.0039068242,
0.0095302602,
-0.002772653,
0.0208194833,
-0.0382660143,
-0.0341897346,
-0.0670783669,
0.013396373,
-0.0114616808,
0.0111440122,
-0.0054592495,
0.0051876851,
0.00240545,
0.0047428217,
-0.073879838,
-0.0237923618,
0.0416433066,
0.0123112397,
0.0570851229,
-0.0370828509,
-0.0103666354,
-0.0341129899,
-0.0087959459,
-0.0204836875,
0.0142028518,
0.0239075515,
0.0115471203,
-0.0572874546,
0.0471126363,
0.0415884256,
0.0107131144,
-0.0498550832,
0.0255985986,
-0.0277884509,
-0.0389111228,
0.0048324042,
-5.806190511e-33,
0.0244004019,
-0.0645439774,
-0.0154687501,
0.0477422997,
-0.0255159531,
-0.0012158436,
-0.0165265445,
-0.0057855258,
0.0083312895,
-0.0056173056,
-0.0057772263,
0.0140951686,
0.0033471689,
-0.0177278202,
0.0002717788,
-0.0433457978,
0.0146144833,
0.0016414942,
-0.0151106045,
0.0528886877,
0.0501597524,
-0.0171147399,
-0.0297660418,
-0.0914455503,
0.0081290705,
0.0001275597,
-0.0175742116,
0.0214205123,
0.0088726897,
0.0608358942,
-0.0004053238,
0.0465443507,
0.0237052236,
0.0183549114,
-0.0023393671,
0.0238863714,
-0.057571426,
-0.0186766647,
-0.0099901976,
-0.0367763713,
0.0001315221,
-0.0125555238,
0.0491199046,
0.0411216505,
0.0259655099,
-0.0871307924,
0.0506744646,
0.0023733175,
0.0190329142,
-0.0676752403,
-0.0175142847,
-0.0064117643,
-0.0850757137,
-0.0093063731,
0.0089381151,
0.1141996086,
0.0219876394,
0.0141038811,
-0.0696468949,
0.0201403238,
-0.0631960258,
-0.0408815853,
-0.0144284545,
0.0341118202,
0.0316103883,
0.0202658102,
-0.0137180015,
0.0866850168,
-0.0401010141,
0.0091164969,
0.0350229554,
0.0272211023,
0.0339667909,
0.0375709236,
0.026944777,
-0.0746840537,
-0.0579508506,
0.0136116436,
0.0753816739,
0.0159864742,
0.0124312015,
-0.0300296824,
-0.0831901655,
0.0059073591,
0.0252292901,
-0.0387469828,
-0.0012925845,
-0.0808132142,
0.0127658509,
0.0069214054,
-0.0438872986,
-0.0737874433,
0.0037059831,
-0.0318650119,
0.0105207553,
0.0112610999,
0.0094152419,
0.0212636851,
-0.0159004591,
-0.0177795887,
0.017384138,
0.0274728183,
0.022732323,
-0.0211075451,
0.0186406691,
-0.0292148888,
0.0545789525,
0.0660944954,
-0.0248313602,
0.0096506821,
0.0023551185,
0.0889375731,
-0.0225144215,
0.0319090821,
-0.023187397,
0.0085320575,
0.0109182457,
-0.0363585688,
0.0303978845,
-0.0016813318,
0.0062190783,
-0.036660891,
-0.05062804,
-0.0056226458,
-0.0300719105,
-0.0253622513,
-0.0386695713,
0.0268072225,
0.0352063105,
-0.0613430291,
-0.0218051672,
-0.0882351622,
2.764e-7,
-0.0116851488,
0.0428580754,
-0.0002801086,
0.0016187789,
-0.0152167045,
0.0295600165,
0.0418658555,
0.0453432351,
0.0385279134,
-0.0447557382,
0.0352975614,
0.0261942204,
0.0254411325,
0.0513729528,
-0.000942898,
-0.0399431139,
-0.0420181565,
-0.0302218962,
-0.0490471907,
0.0241050068,
0.0516139939,
0.0319111124,
0.0760717988,
-0.0658525378,
0.0459071845,
0.0003525401,
-0.0271607097,
-0.072690472,
-0.0136356419,
-0.0057222941,
0.0728510469,
-0.0120738512,
-0.0201601032,
-0.0030281227,
-0.0234028008,
-0.0159045979,
-0.018011976,
0.0124564897,
-0.0024725017,
0.023075074,
-0.0195304826,
-0.0479847975,
0.0454161316,
-0.0320396423,
0.0694414824,
0.0128788585,
-0.0154139977,
-0.0645689219,
-0.0119222328,
-0.0618237853,
0.0191073213,
-0.0203649458,
-0.0322912373,
-0.0119288685,
0.0147719122,
0.017774364,
0.0079408605,
-0.0347456485,
-0.0178534649,
0.0173318144,
-0.0141464835,
-0.0454283915,
0.048012156,
-0.0085021341,
0.0171800051,
0.0313290916,
0.0375837646,
2.21679592e-34,
-0.0109710079,
0.0002755084,
0.0162691195,
-0.0788152367,
0.0290409196,
0.0153029598,
0.0169448294,
-0.0239301696,
0.0546521582,
-0.015450363,
0.0363159366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13196v1 | NameGuess: Column Name Expansion for Tabular Data | 2023-10-19T23:11:37 | 2023-10-19T23:11:37 | Jiani Zhang, Zhengyuan Shen, Balasubramaniam Srinivasan, Shen Wang, Huzefa Rangwala, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | Recent advances in large language models have revolutionized many sectors,
including the database industry. One common challenge when dealing with large
volumes of tabular data is the pervasive use of abbreviated column names, which
can negatively impact performance on various data search, access, and
understanding tasks. To address this issue, we introduce a new task, called
NameGuess, to expand column names (used in database schema) as a natural
language generation problem. We create a training dataset of 384K
abbreviated-expanded column pairs using a new data fabrication method and a
human-annotated evaluation benchmark that includes 9.2K examples from
real-world tables. To tackle the complexities associated with polysemy and
ambiguity in NameGuess, we enhance auto-regressive language models by
conditioning on table content and column header names -- yielding a fine-tuned
model (with 2.7B parameters) that matches human performance. Furthermore, we
conduct a comprehensive analysis (on multiple LLMs) to validate the
effectiveness of table content in NameGuess and identify promising future
opportunities. Code has been made available at
https://github.com/amazon-science/nameguess. | [
0.0432338752,
0.0855462253,
-0.0146656474,
0.0000928701,
-0.006519373,
0.0248148255,
0.006918007,
0.0472456403,
-0.0082769301,
-0.0121377856,
0.0051315376,
-0.0260366555,
-0.0255894773,
0.0279334392,
0.0759344324,
-0.0068173958,
0.0609961338,
0.0121381385,
-0.0612464361,
0.0436122939,
-0.0057875039,
-0.009629352,
0.017648384,
0.0154391592,
0.0009322909,
0.0619649068,
-0.0239611343,
-0.0028878555,
-0.0532799847,
0.0089092739,
-0.01749596,
0.0855956003,
-0.0012516857,
0.0226361528,
0.0000019465,
-0.0343311839,
-0.064176105,
-0.0036676044,
-0.0159530789,
-0.0163557958,
0.0646919534,
-0.0598198473,
0.0320406966,
-0.007114667,
-0.034343224,
-0.0422862954,
0.0203014165,
0.010561497,
0.0350829065,
0.0488038659,
0.0012022902,
-0.0319074988,
-0.0265756734,
-0.0004327983,
0.0728593543,
-0.0267535076,
-0.0221268646,
-0.0171729866,
0.0111904731,
-0.0076382514,
0.020419972,
0.0273603313,
-0.0079593742,
-0.0047882646,
0.0250972956,
0.0276838522,
-0.0376061127,
0.0088061392,
0.0083436519,
0.0837317556,
0.0083815968,
-0.0155339148,
0.0279459432,
-0.0019731212,
0.0090459352,
-0.0221145749,
-0.0280615762,
-0.0138479136,
0.002559565,
-0.0325606838,
0.0185914468,
-0.0042411746,
0.0207750034,
-0.0003524611,
-0.0293390919,
0.0159267802,
0.0046959291,
-0.0324759036,
0.0113703217,
-0.0447976515,
0.0189276487,
-0.0120561365,
0.0247610565,
0.0288333651,
-0.0673665628,
0.0348268151,
-0.0288018677,
-0.0372766107,
0.0203509983,
-0.0518321507,
0.0459971912,
0.0588743724,
0.0342441611,
-0.0077913082,
-0.050148312,
0.0373908989,
0.0112171704,
-0.0078778025,
-0.018313162,
-0.028606087,
-0.0575004742,
-0.0043048738,
-0.0563860126,
0.0115402639,
-0.0801301897,
-0.0099756522,
-0.0405185856,
-0.0199614801,
0.0108961118,
0.0163669791,
0.0541876666,
0.0449192338,
-0.0327797905,
-0.0127616534,
-0.0445200987,
-0.0187252965,
-0.0332109705,
-0.0136355618,
0.0174083579,
-0.0767181739,
-0.0208200235,
-0.0036809491,
0.006801757,
-0.0105156992,
0.0328892656,
0.0870416313,
-0.0085850311,
-0.0192238111,
-0.0496076643,
-0.0766750202,
-0.015024079,
-0.0213677734,
-0.0117020272,
-0.0430744365,
0.065819256,
0.0025484744,
-0.0145908678,
-0.071198076,
-0.0003556585,
0.0378934331,
-0.017758755,
0.0778467953,
-0.0830824077,
0.0245771911,
-0.0071173091,
-0.0235435944,
0.0307006966,
0.0457682051,
0.0401273295,
0.0124961631,
-0.0025370747,
-0.014743791,
0.0298386831,
0.0316013061,
0.0399331972,
-0.0069612958,
-0.0178698096,
0.0253327955,
-0.0189375896,
0.0766709968,
-0.0020689806,
0.0347449332,
0.0074058208,
0.0115456134,
0.0204426739,
0.0191192627,
0.0275984295,
0.0638632551,
0.0731918141,
0.0207919329,
-0.0028770319,
-0.041978579,
0.0203258619,
-0.0132939685,
-0.0059421952,
0.0309821423,
0.0330809504,
0.007684689,
-0.0139470194,
-0.062230885,
0.0210507102,
-0.0217604097,
0.0106227454,
-0.0167254116,
0.0065221246,
0.056204237,
-0.0529356375,
0.0248878617,
0.0111627514,
-0.0875298753,
0.0006099645,
-0.0154836606,
0.021765383,
0.101165168,
0.0485464558,
-0.0390312113,
-0.0323054008,
0.0020871283,
0.0242462866,
0.0174256098,
0.0154905627,
-0.0308884587,
0.0196543224,
-0.0345379412,
0.0043423311,
0.0804913864,
0.0231662076,
-0.0035296571,
0.0163444374,
-0.0140111074,
0.0523110554,
-0.048342865,
-0.0723581463,
0.0331484191,
-0.0404049754,
-0.0226534363,
0.027220495,
-0.0134570412,
-0.0251130201,
0.0524124429,
-0.001192801,
0.0315082707,
0.0485418923,
-0.0092175463,
0.0035691075,
-0.0004346276,
0.0129998866,
0.0247049797,
-0.004243487,
0.0242909808,
-0.0353325531,
-0.0634168237,
-0.0200946089,
-0.0289923083,
0.0005167462,
-0.0185463354,
-0.0355330221,
-0.0163950063,
0.0391042493,
0.0268500447,
0.0111738369,
-0.0430202708,
0.0562706627,
-0.0283047259,
0.0718771815,
0.0380113944,
-0.0761638582,
0.0210079737,
-0.0418372639,
0.0380767882,
-0.0042842962,
-0.0153612318,
0.0103841927,
0.0042888308,
0.0119971065,
-0.0686088577,
-0.0000550732,
-0.0590411201,
0.0456149653,
-0.0017552065,
0.0337116234,
0.0001809522,
0.0211615264,
-0.0371387489,
-0.0231880415,
-0.0416795909,
-0.0259217713,
0.0354866348,
-0.0247893985,
0.0582099669,
-0.0094435047,
-0.0320080966,
-0.0342439823,
-0.0237804446,
-0.0475327447,
0.0237166714,
-0.0043755979,
-0.0259938929,
-0.0015761759,
-0.0066268635,
0.010381422,
-0.0104352515,
0.0052696373,
0.0065298523,
-0.0249621868,
-0.0151588079,
0.0303357616,
0.004757761,
0.0039633852,
0.0092617385,
-0.003989703,
-0.0362018123,
-0.0186661314,
0.0010317401,
-0.0226620696,
0.0239802692,
-0.0009560519,
-0.0813652501,
0.058968354,
0.0323609821,
-0.0230138768,
-0.0032886199,
-0.0551208928,
0.0055462425,
0.0213268418,
-0.0248476602,
-0.0092347162,
0.0511834398,
0.0126378387,
0.0370539501,
-0.0154746817,
-0.0078975363,
0.0394307449,
-0.0452814512,
0.0127541078,
-0.0241978429,
0.0054189037,
-0.0299766157,
0.0710240304,
0.0075136358,
-0.0097197788,
0.0022336321,
-0.0503339581,
-0.0241892915,
0.0113009308,
0.0091358181,
-0.0465998016,
0.091172643,
-0.060107749,
0.0100579932,
0.0063824919,
0.00458539,
-0.0150555121,
-0.0355866998,
-0.0193731189,
0.0039761821,
0.070666261,
-0.011779923,
-0.028673593,
0.0003581378,
0.005720506,
0.0256517641,
0.0121518523,
-0.0180046447,
-0.0371387824,
0.0184847936,
0.0238875821,
0.0508055538,
-0.0341917686,
-0.0260608885,
0.0060816356,
0.0036105644,
-0.0344262533,
-0.0106015606,
0.0026686559,
0.0344595648,
-0.0081410408,
-0.0397977531,
-0.0198505484,
0.0569896102,
-0.0269291699,
-0.0470473617,
-0.0145524591,
0.0932261571,
0.0291031338,
0.0231619067,
-0.0111758085,
0.0280401483,
0.0579182245,
0.0434527174,
0.0411021709,
-0.1179972738,
-0.0291640889,
0.0047901031,
0.0110189095,
0.0040154238,
-0.0764077902,
-0.0259391665,
-0.1305280179,
0.0150272083,
-0.0291433353,
-0.050599169,
-0.0379976705,
-0.0204910226,
-0.0466686897,
-0.0330760255,
0.0286376588,
0.0580705963,
-0.0361262523,
0.0407717451,
0.0393603072,
-0.0449722409,
-0.0750317723,
-0.0494472459,
-0.0917636752,
0.0718594864,
0.0410135984,
0.0237649828,
0.0068771173,
-0.017646065,
-0.0318868496,
0.0387377478,
0.01427738,
-0.0312103517,
0.07845027,
0.0088283829,
-0.0036841177,
-0.0293927621,
-0.0185664333,
-0.0445144512,
0.021269897,
0.0259197559,
0.0268296059,
-0.0185565259,
0.0224399362,
0.0169552322,
-0.0057001868,
0.0092583513,
0.0512895584,
0.0374820195,
0.0178667847,
-0.0456753299,
0.0070591816,
-0.0412995704,
-0.0584249273,
-0.0269008093,
0.0217368752,
-0.0607728027,
-0.0217562206,
-0.0433014221,
-0.0436118655,
0.0710408986,
0.0536454581,
0.0168570615,
0.067940414,
-0.0440294184,
-0.001342766,
-0.0769756138,
-0.0159384422,
-0.0155994855,
-0.005409216,
-0.025300825,
-0.0496384799,
0.013777934,
-0.0026933576,
-0.0097134467,
0.0701323524,
-0.048241362,
-0.0356422551,
-0.0241610333,
0.0202534329,
0.0279040877,
0.0100790272,
0.0259470567,
-0.0458895341,
-0.0490915924,
0.06524802,
-0.0515117571,
-0.0602996573,
-0.0066501433,
-0.0312269479,
0.0071377764,
0.0412041806,
0.0213875882,
-0.0249729678,
-0.0397838987,
0.0457955413,
-0.0036641464,
0.0432671867,
0.071717687,
0.0243453179,
-0.0131419031,
-0.0159273464,
-0.0435699522,
-0.0298373662,
0.0239296854,
-0.0678125769,
-0.0539632812,
-0.0083440756,
0.0260565132,
0.0036820008,
0.0102893328,
-0.0082166167,
0.0301726256,
-0.0171570331,
0.0264340527,
-0.0382632427,
-0.01707769,
-0.0070206183,
0.0069024619,
0.0329641588,
-0.0378076956,
0.0111783696,
0.0078903316,
0.0298994798,
0.0329416022,
-0.0087659452,
-0.013518041,
0.028426202,
-0.0072035375,
-0.0384133458,
0.0302661564,
0.0072364337,
-0.0238654781,
-0.0313621126,
0.035113167,
-0.0033624349,
-0.006685101,
0.022985002,
-0.0107906042,
-0.0193725508,
0.0152078578,
0.0464380682,
0.0106001003,
-0.0048495573,
0.0088480432,
-0.001090723,
-0.0464925393,
-0.056715332,
0.0946449637,
0.0589468107,
0.0023428719,
-0.0186035875,
-0.0350248031,
-0.0524940789,
0.009365214,
0.0091837384,
-0.0051921578,
-0.0343908072,
0.0048307092,
-0.0487511232,
-0.0462816954,
0.0308365673,
0.0397792459,
-0.0071171084,
0.0115163149,
0.0498367399,
0.0506970473,
0.0455502868,
-0.002950588,
-0.0287153963,
0.001106937,
-0.0307969227,
-0.083733052,
-0.0265857577,
-6.031808285e-33,
-0.0640275851,
-0.0256561581,
0.0450704545,
-0.0164078567,
-0.0136453286,
-0.0189320054,
-0.0521059968,
0.0459752791,
0.0403759405,
-0.0083004292,
-0.0414600447,
0.0270688068,
0.0368517749,
0.004122172,
0.0378238894,
-0.0740688518,
0.0090750111,
0.0036832262,
0.0021963131,
0.0023338869,
-0.007310987,
0.072815381,
0.0366385989,
-0.044061102,
0.0427752361,
0.0080663646,
-0.0022420993,
-0.0126486253,
0.0420453325,
0.0371606313,
-0.023267068,
0.0206648298,
0.0386782289,
-0.0340954512,
-0.0426129252,
-0.0183313098,
-0.1130153686,
-0.016218219,
0.0061370153,
0.0157038309,
-0.0284505561,
-0.0165061634,
0.0688618422,
-0.0179222319,
-0.0575433224,
0.0509833395,
0.0232466906,
-0.0497701392,
-0.0247719605,
-0.0269368738,
-0.0402750224,
0.022882821,
0.0254089627,
0.0115292035,
0.0561806373,
0.0207613651,
-0.0037600975,
0.002444518,
-0.0200720895,
0.0336573049,
0.059146516,
0.0610268041,
0.0578072108,
0.0032704431,
0.014423823,
-0.007849833,
0.065965496,
0.018262025,
-0.0443647951,
0.0219169725,
-0.0094773546,
0.0613523908,
0.0398787931,
0.0544111915,
0.0408257768,
-0.0479152948,
-0.0336842425,
0.0586421303,
0.0111489976,
-0.0382462963,
-0.0210721716,
-0.034570571,
-0.03684007,
-0.0115238726,
-0.045453947,
0.0328937657,
-0.0305293445,
-0.0116869872,
0.0348712802,
0.0123921409,
0.0156421177,
-0.0114261415,
-0.0126667786,
-0.0024556671,
-0.0526021235,
0.0052133724,
-0.0283423625,
-0.0281939209,
0.0055621262,
-0.0152243311,
-0.0118403779,
-0.0671979934,
0.0187714864,
-0.0155571848,
0.0259362385,
0.0045799557,
0.0217371564,
0.0121474508,
-0.0723672658,
0.0000452804,
-0.0190073177,
0.0663708076,
0.0068781041,
0.0078928694,
-0.0029230441,
0.0093589211,
-0.0038601756,
0.042756021,
0.0424662977,
-0.0026384217,
-0.0053794486,
0.0016345317,
0.0200810917,
0.0268763192,
0.0142491339,
0.0208195224,
-0.0324982926,
-0.0439671278,
0.02904086,
-0.0214279704,
0.0029385514,
0.0213465784,
2.553e-7,
0.0495982692,
0.046759069,
0.0481992327,
0.0138493208,
-0.0360879749,
-0.0283621121,
0.0059519554,
0.0207788162,
-0.0377945118,
-0.0441103987,
0.0537440665,
-0.0431602336,
0.070770815,
-0.0135171814,
-0.0445971489,
-0.0286450014,
-0.0240542199,
-0.0013103104,
-0.0868797153,
-0.0065083448,
0.0377729274,
0.0900191441,
-0.0467732251,
0.0034257642,
0.0092439363,
0.0049874401,
0.0172239281,
-0.0493329801,
0.0271663684,
0.0413355902,
0.0834320113,
0.0011020764,
-0.0250761788,
0.0409710035,
-0.0210479517,
0.0068264171,
-0.0172995571,
0.0314472578,
0.0180579629,
0.0323483124,
0.0056905602,
-0.1176484674,
0.0130081065,
-0.022977775,
0.0592304766,
-0.03004089,
-0.0039883615,
0.0679360703,
-0.0066683432,
0.0300847013,
0.0158409718,
-0.0064414688,
-0.0247610975,
-0.0024093618,
0.0537177883,
0.0201269425,
0.0051344428,
-0.0461395308,
0.0026183811,
0.0421574563,
-0.0335621461,
0.026982747,
-0.014150966,
-0.0190733708,
-0.0267198924,
-0.0256527439,
-0.0014817582,
2.49073799e-34,
0.0266316719,
0.0339584611,
0.0320939161,
0.0138472775,
0.0901759639,
-0.035951376,
-0.0009195574,
0.0252117794,
-0.0020353538,
-0.0435976423,
-0.0249342993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13191v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13191v3 | Towards Robust Pruning: An Adaptive Knowledge-Retention Pruning Strategy for Language Models | 2023-10-19T23:02:29 | 2024-01-11T04:07:39 | Jianwei Li, Qi Lei, Wei Cheng, Dongkuan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The pruning objective has recently extended beyond accuracy and sparsity to
robustness in language models. Despite this, existing methods struggle to
enhance robustness against adversarial attacks when continually increasing
model sparsity and require a retraining process. As humans step into the era of
large language models, these issues become increasingly prominent. This paper
proposes that the robustness of language models is proportional to the extent
of pre-trained knowledge they encompass. Accordingly, we introduce a
post-training pruning strategy designed to faithfully replicate the embedding
space and feature space of dense language models, aiming to conserve more
pre-trained knowledge during the pruning process. In this setup, each layer's
reconstruction error not only originates from itself but also includes
cumulative error from preceding layers, followed by an adaptive rectification.
Compared to other state-of-art baselines, our approach demonstrates a superior
balance between accuracy, sparsity, robustness, and pruning cost with BERT on
datasets SST2, IMDB, and AGNews, marking a significant stride towards robust
pruning in language models. | [
0.0050166799,
0.0905804485,
-0.0087557668,
0.0473008677,
-0.0025562271,
-0.0021365567,
-0.0072293663,
0.0387183763,
-0.0221284274,
-0.0145997154,
-0.0243180245,
-0.0310402177,
-0.0037913304,
-0.0041500349,
0.0176209956,
-0.0400237814,
0.0179481432,
0.0059004873,
0.0271205157,
-0.0295701008,
0.0245316774,
0.0018703255,
0.0210123584,
0.0301425587,
-0.0074029532,
-0.0117540071,
0.0049600154,
0.0100818276,
0.0003513484,
0.0071706185,
0.0567831062,
0.0710677877,
0.0296169724,
0.0772575811,
0.000001991,
-0.00358615,
-0.0049539814,
0.0056803902,
-0.0493846983,
0.0720307976,
0.0170882847,
-0.0238368791,
-0.0109949475,
-0.0064370134,
-0.0236374624,
-0.0404894873,
0.0187806431,
0.0441794246,
0.067867212,
0.0701239035,
0.0021749223,
-0.0159824174,
0.0086161997,
-0.0584136546,
-0.063905485,
-0.0417819172,
0.0327423438,
-0.0648850575,
-0.0456455275,
-0.0147492699,
-0.0029351495,
0.0336873382,
0.0255651306,
0.0101006515,
-0.0313051306,
0.0455615446,
-0.0428440347,
-0.0064151809,
0.0123385144,
0.0547455698,
-0.052632343,
-0.0239744503,
-0.0113075078,
-0.0051425318,
0.007515884,
-0.0037577949,
-0.0440998562,
-0.0210286267,
0.0278583989,
0.0132855643,
-0.0717790574,
-0.0615901388,
0.0584779307,
0.0137611153,
-0.0039682016,
-0.0034767508,
0.0423513316,
-0.0405349545,
-0.001600173,
0.0004872901,
-0.044129122,
-0.0228576884,
0.0015433787,
0.0221168231,
0.0264101364,
0.0174896121,
-0.0673797876,
-0.013786952,
0.0114470776,
-0.0309159346,
0.0391448215,
0.0009985323,
-0.02896435,
0.0291061066,
-0.036029432,
0.0441728197,
0.0272545721,
0.0356000736,
0.001391576,
0.0023728495,
-0.0344326124,
-0.0268989336,
-0.0385706462,
0.0355670713,
-0.0000070529,
0.0183945019,
-0.0309024379,
-0.0141295483,
-0.0384913199,
0.021645939,
-0.0107474877,
0.0274236761,
-0.0295722205,
-0.0224729236,
0.0245954059,
0.0271285195,
-0.0073746527,
0.0237637125,
-0.0239537247,
-0.0654633716,
-0.0488650538,
0.024168985,
-0.0122347409,
-0.0367101356,
0.0051620463,
0.0352950878,
0.015869515,
-0.0613047481,
-0.0503903851,
0.0041440143,
-0.0378236957,
-0.049079638,
0.0169001948,
-0.0430722497,
0.0277217366,
-0.0634110197,
-0.0190491043,
-0.1104608476,
-0.0174847301,
0.0006479206,
-0.0615115315,
0.0623050258,
-0.0155078815,
-0.0041579567,
0.0298264697,
0.029796144,
0.0286081601,
0.0481312759,
0.0261212476,
0.0126327034,
0.0332152545,
-0.0164469779,
-0.0140163908,
0.0493044667,
0.0731454417,
0.0311731286,
-0.0643291697,
-0.0193928275,
-0.0401608646,
-0.0052486728,
0.0274397116,
0.0471776277,
-0.0449503586,
-0.0604162067,
0.0740284026,
0.0238875765,
-0.0013362683,
0.0617779754,
0.0352840237,
-0.0103023676,
0.0169670004,
0.0184278209,
-0.0712473094,
0.0022227496,
-0.0363209173,
-0.0176360365,
-0.0304833408,
0.0205027014,
-0.0433494076,
-0.000368063,
-0.0209828988,
-0.0202593412,
0.0167739578,
0.0008705751,
0.0426121689,
0.0274624657,
-0.0131388279,
0.076258488,
0.0319174416,
-0.0434368849,
0.0240707621,
-0.0495756641,
-0.0051076785,
0.0233147368,
0.0367610641,
-0.0291560739,
-0.0196125135,
0.0122556221,
0.0296653137,
-0.0061737048,
0.0473647229,
-0.0213669594,
0.0621651299,
-0.0369019769,
-0.0263402909,
-0.01340215,
0.042793218,
0.014780703,
0.0508774519,
0.0178741906,
0.0159653835,
-0.049070321,
-0.0187252834,
0.0411023386,
-0.0399266146,
-0.033299055,
-0.0147568323,
0.0095329145,
0.0055828393,
0.0127485776,
-0.0396754034,
0.0034053007,
0.0631886423,
-0.0118577937,
-0.0110032167,
-0.0021583908,
-0.0285147522,
-0.0412250422,
0.0566593036,
0.0194110628,
-0.0103433039,
0.0624971651,
-0.049057927,
-0.0088027399,
0.0418341458,
-0.0248336922,
0.0513423346,
-0.0590086393,
0.0038760614,
-0.0363275819,
0.0343691446,
-0.0116983252,
0.0476702116,
-0.0399848856,
0.0005387488,
0.0061202687,
-0.0486278683,
0.0172089674,
-0.0450223312,
-0.0569169261,
0.0226559509,
-0.0232895799,
0.0352394767,
0.0232789032,
0.0030855245,
-0.0112163695,
-0.0088208821,
-0.0700844154,
-0.0118993353,
-0.0432176776,
0.0142577644,
0.0151658934,
0.0085794749,
-0.0226934161,
-0.0407149829,
0.0305788256,
0.00038837,
-0.0132295191,
0.02493852,
0.0089231776,
-0.01877575,
0.0006228759,
-0.0126916859,
-0.0260480605,
0.0245830435,
0.0615822859,
-0.0497068465,
0.0005833254,
-0.02276849,
0.0115637416,
-0.0376698524,
0.0595066994,
-0.0043350114,
-0.0597525835,
-0.007087701,
0.0004456064,
-0.0216576904,
0.0649321899,
0.0010268993,
0.0934100673,
0.0633134618,
0.025818415,
-0.0294217151,
0.0196044352,
-0.0286352411,
-0.0179521553,
-0.0291946884,
-0.0218392722,
-0.0142351743,
0.0658149868,
0.0039172885,
-0.0071288995,
-0.058218766,
-0.0083301207,
0.003116162,
-0.0302159935,
-0.0252525918,
-0.0166520216,
-0.0407425202,
-0.0109246206,
-0.038037084,
-0.0518667214,
0.0693534613,
-0.0307339132,
0.013531859,
0.0118618086,
-0.0225520581,
0.0343176275,
0.0442897491,
0.0218837541,
0.0063599837,
-0.0052257432,
0.0025294391,
-0.0907999203,
-0.0440585576,
0.0259986203,
-0.01467002,
0.0137158604,
-0.0507214852,
-0.0008661484,
0.0049847048,
-0.042842824,
-0.0507551134,
-0.031596344,
-0.0243709534,
0.034643244,
-0.0296101049,
-0.0346546322,
-0.0322439149,
-0.034128461,
0.0287152175,
0.0636568144,
0.0188696776,
0.0277448148,
0.0227395799,
0.0623750351,
0.0518393144,
0.0108156539,
0.0056302403,
-0.0435058102,
0.0370675661,
0.073770605,
0.0225716699,
0.0314708725,
-0.0566965677,
0.002625542,
0.0114464927,
-0.0016888394,
-0.0171639454,
0.0068877712,
0.0458583981,
-0.04689328,
-0.0075391708,
0.0849076807,
-0.0088700317,
-0.0107584689,
0.0107783386,
0.0261154491,
0.0790859982,
0.0095850658,
0.0133688003,
-0.0409142822,
-0.0168675892,
0.0116652148,
0.0240541045,
0.0605664887,
-0.04067434,
-0.0131616583,
-0.1071624681,
0.0180924553,
-0.0028031203,
-0.027242193,
-0.0184844546,
-0.0275308136,
0.0156560428,
-0.0151887322,
0.0341370739,
-0.0006866829,
0.0097279828,
0.0012526402,
0.0278522354,
-0.0203987751,
-0.0697684959,
0.0165482424,
-0.0377857201,
0.0427476168,
0.0593925305,
0.0414775461,
-0.014738664,
-0.012049742,
0.0442488939,
-0.0172033887,
-0.0293338262,
0.0244483817,
0.0692850351,
0.004033681,
0.0051912442,
0.0406061187,
0.0283604749,
-0.0048434697,
-0.0234610196,
0.0073405872,
0.0563733876,
0.0022492949,
-0.0518932939,
-0.0163473841,
-0.0225305967,
-0.0217403751,
0.0782648697,
0.0519323274,
-0.014599815,
-0.0290719233,
-0.0152676962,
0.0147423716,
-0.0601363517,
-0.0151859019,
0.0673565939,
-0.0165879913,
-0.0311624203,
-0.0472305082,
-0.0358783416,
0.0238809288,
0.0200628731,
-0.0087558255,
-0.0204365719,
-0.0200404637,
0.0087086242,
-0.0626565665,
0.0216663424,
-0.0223040543,
0.0044476506,
-0.0225375481,
0.0091785863,
-0.0048481449,
-0.0024861221,
-0.022842152,
-0.0263983533,
-0.0995235369,
-0.0697494671,
0.0253255479,
0.0582544506,
0.0247987136,
0.0792144835,
-0.0241386294,
-0.0647105873,
0.0974851176,
0.0370264649,
-0.0132874781,
0.0224362444,
0.056831181,
-0.0642040446,
-0.0016314111,
0.0874620453,
-0.0466861241,
0.0082395393,
0.0687555298,
0.023631027,
0.0090293568,
-0.0191952158,
-0.0079538506,
0.0164810643,
0.0317038409,
-0.0371220671,
-0.0109312152,
-0.0199016742,
0.012734862,
0.0077034673,
0.0055176616,
-0.0345970541,
0.0251501277,
0.0137075251,
0.0298613962,
-0.0138246696,
0.0259946249,
0.0201149452,
0.0528564788,
-0.0519561991,
-0.0002737641,
0.0179674067,
0.0103152152,
0.0555870235,
0.0375604145,
-0.0080034472,
0.0427502766,
-0.0298568588,
0.0096947253,
-0.0362753384,
-0.0117907887,
0.0319430009,
0.0127001256,
-0.0342092961,
0.0247107632,
-0.0537569411,
-0.0660236552,
-0.044719208,
0.0371248275,
0.0318757966,
-0.0278136171,
0.0208008904,
-0.0235200729,
-0.0281597041,
-0.0342899263,
-0.0042514326,
0.0113978395,
-0.0205336381,
0.038083028,
0.0148986783,
-0.0132300034,
0.0259907115,
0.091846399,
0.0395800769,
0.0804441199,
-0.0098511521,
-0.0158665422,
-0.0507099889,
-0.0520602837,
0.0284307543,
0.0002229076,
-0.0319568887,
0.0214094482,
-0.029658448,
-0.1055165157,
0.0154081229,
-0.0165600665,
0.0058238539,
0.0243829116,
0.0316103622,
0.0514703616,
-0.0034247651,
0.0481723025,
0.01371546,
0.006840155,
0.0016486405,
-0.0625955388,
0.0080674952,
-6.362540967e-33,
0.0118203685,
0.0189105347,
-0.006728217,
-0.0654490143,
-0.0248925369,
0.0163004957,
-0.0473573655,
-0.0204173215,
-0.0368037224,
0.0502160452,
-0.0160597619,
0.0187582951,
-0.0136461593,
0.0387526564,
-0.0398532115,
-0.0314860828,
0.0647454709,
-0.0242139921,
-0.0336358286,
0.0262593906,
0.0212985855,
0.0524999052,
0.0954339951,
-0.011795342,
-0.0045965691,
0.0290890262,
-0.021700399,
0.0292400178,
-0.0004707335,
0.0424098745,
-0.0251065698,
0.0266039204,
0.001061935,
0.0107164122,
-0.013000126,
-0.0064734383,
-0.0832576081,
-0.030148901,
-0.0137649504,
0.0045045628,
-0.0215124376,
0.0100036813,
0.0479502976,
-0.0217101984,
-0.001627458,
-0.0130128274,
0.0217298754,
-0.0237689149,
-0.0562174469,
-0.0050959745,
-0.0235680658,
0.0151896309,
-0.021335341,
-0.0402004868,
0.0164755639,
-0.0049288282,
0.016991226,
0.0347385816,
-0.0699642971,
-0.0184776895,
-0.0032507875,
0.0425535403,
0.0324029736,
-0.0101369191,
-0.0053659296,
0.0837344229,
-0.0017515747,
0.0084965909,
-0.0203176979,
-0.0052045039,
0.0770033374,
0.0266375095,
0.0557040125,
0.0541699156,
0.0395750143,
-0.0544044822,
-0.075509809,
-0.000102393,
0.0082255611,
0.0580074862,
0.0090909582,
0.0296582766,
0.0159849133,
-0.0194415804,
-0.0250166971,
-0.0619302318,
-0.0254986268,
-0.0228715986,
0.0033906512,
0.0203092787,
-0.0382593907,
-0.0033444683,
-0.0063537396,
-0.0407281965,
-0.0052429624,
0.0475424491,
-0.0289165713,
-0.0235589575,
0.0259183701,
0.0635702312,
-0.0205717422,
0.0146880634,
0.0036152736,
0.0008793441,
0.0086438386,
-0.0007327811,
0.0795423463,
0.0523307398,
-0.03411486,
0.0055583492,
-0.0464549102,
0.0199139826,
0.0390849821,
0.0676648319,
0.0216116235,
0.0259790402,
0.0160187576,
-0.0039376616,
0.0509685464,
-0.0135296099,
-0.0276336875,
0.0368715301,
0.0311004408,
0.0175827146,
-0.005771698,
-0.0433869772,
0.0011088402,
-0.0000367266,
0.0218848214,
-0.0837498158,
0.0077144853,
-0.0287215877,
2.636e-7,
0.0163713228,
0.0037761789,
0.0161314346,
-0.0427948572,
0.0200484619,
0.0225961376,
-0.0387787856,
0.0354387015,
-0.0422614217,
-0.0116823213,
-0.0008802866,
0.0200692229,
0.0841895714,
0.0216894355,
-0.0890153274,
-0.0116798757,
-0.1194587126,
-0.0230137035,
-0.017437093,
-0.0309101474,
-0.0056111119,
0.1111163497,
0.0575154461,
-0.037102174,
-0.0117481621,
-0.059332516,
0.040349599,
-0.0199901219,
0.0386820957,
-0.0095008649,
0.047386039,
0.032739751,
0.0043198969,
-0.0070120147,
-0.0626567528,
0.0087355403,
0.014007641,
0.0700434893,
-0.0153805949,
-0.0025187582,
-0.0183665343,
-0.0062158275,
-0.0081484886,
-0.04944098,
0.0392335951,
-0.0289596505,
0.0030448507,
-0.004495515,
-0.0331044383,
-0.023284886,
0.0160131976,
-0.0370763727,
-0.0082193287,
0.0319952369,
0.0084713548,
0.0093679456,
-0.0083015496,
-0.1022933051,
-0.0196016468,
0.005178507,
-0.0548809357,
-0.0219738316,
-0.0218904018,
-0.0364979431,
0.0404311083,
-0.0616226383,
0.0350480005,
2.184248731e-34,
0.0237486698,
-0.0045296126,
-0.0177720208,
0.0233940501,
0.0315915979,
-0.0233407412,
0.0576170422,
-0.0135520548,
-0.0020061848,
-0.0346574672,
-0.0173810273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13189v2 | Fast and Accurate Factual Inconsistency Detection Over Long Documents | 2023-10-19T22:55:39 | 2023-10-23T03:51:33 | Barrett Martin Lattimer, Patrick Chen, Xinyuan Zhang, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative AI models exhibit remarkable potential; however, hallucinations
across various tasks present a significant challenge, particularly for longer
inputs that current approaches struggle to address effectively. We introduce
SCALE (Source Chunking Approach for Large-scale inconsistency Evaluation), a
task-agnostic model for detecting factual inconsistencies using a novel
chunking strategy. Specifically, SCALE is a Natural Language Inference (NLI)
based model that uses large text chunks to condition over long texts. This
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance in factual inconsistency
detection for diverse tasks and long inputs. Additionally, we leverage the
chunking mechanism and employ a novel algorithm to explain SCALE's decisions
through relevant source sentence retrieval. Our evaluations reveal that SCALE
outperforms existing methods on both standard benchmarks and a new long-form
dialogue dataset ScreenEval we constructed. Moreover, SCALE surpasses
competitive systems in efficiency and model explanation evaluations. We have
released our code and data publicly to GitHub. | [
0.0239173602,
0.058621686,
0.0022529962,
0.0409851409,
-0.0534913428,
0.0210578367,
0.0108412327,
-0.006002753,
0.0085617481,
-0.0217688903,
0.0222162586,
-0.0505607463,
0.0398741215,
0.0432036333,
0.0140945883,
-0.0477657355,
0.0815826431,
-0.0048740082,
0.0147526078,
0.0143199973,
0.0114559447,
0.0105149839,
-0.0256165285,
0.0033385823,
-0.0392777324,
-0.0436287113,
-0.0392999835,
0.0077889101,
0.0269891974,
-0.0071296887,
-0.0164905358,
0.03736981,
-0.0019916687,
0.097740747,
0.0000019726,
-0.0357122011,
-0.0214921851,
0.0091189258,
-0.0605118312,
0.0248022471,
0.0095832236,
0.0128982784,
-0.0232658628,
0.0103879068,
0.0084381253,
0.0053777476,
0.0219328236,
0.0961092338,
0.0647401884,
0.1030952036,
-0.0033596982,
-0.0118518556,
-0.0006838,
-0.0066911303,
0.0146042733,
-0.0142625049,
0.0359542556,
0.0343068205,
-0.0083542475,
0.0062788809,
-0.0021102116,
-0.0139362281,
0.038756229,
-0.0287150089,
-0.010093946,
0.012056876,
-0.0507958643,
-0.0126840435,
0.0183399916,
0.0665725246,
0.0019277254,
-0.0295572951,
0.0147607019,
-0.0114172036,
0.007925489,
0.0002149274,
0.0065043112,
0.028505845,
-0.0565546788,
0.0185996667,
0.0277062971,
-0.0211737249,
0.0262279976,
0.009038086,
-0.027756609,
0.0262464378,
-0.004656482,
-0.0654210076,
-0.0284602977,
0.0073564649,
-0.0168630201,
-0.0713830143,
0.0025597734,
-0.0033228968,
-0.0755794719,
-0.0080548087,
-0.0632538348,
-0.0166917928,
0.0353061743,
-0.0574839413,
-0.0162689723,
-0.0201989282,
-0.0792358667,
0.0785354525,
0.009088425,
0.0777213126,
0.0022459095,
-0.004205131,
-0.0041003479,
-0.0254946072,
-0.0450821333,
0.0121128829,
-0.0368431993,
-0.0115831057,
-0.0498828664,
-0.0202197228,
-0.0113021377,
-0.0175720286,
-0.0450912081,
0.0523115098,
0.0216346867,
-0.0056427578,
-0.0091789598,
-0.028848609,
-0.0561083481,
0.0310493261,
-0.0438318588,
-0.0042677596,
0.0398185961,
-0.0860524401,
-0.0514657125,
0.0198070444,
-0.0236135032,
0.0170972776,
-0.0138906585,
-0.0104914447,
0.0011631391,
0.0117243603,
-0.0523719713,
-0.0226786267,
-0.056122303,
-0.0958349854,
-0.0359887704,
-0.0630787537,
0.0243546925,
-0.055546049,
-0.0240826495,
-0.0239274614,
-0.0020868974,
0.0347815603,
-0.0379388034,
0.0685075,
-0.038835153,
-0.0123035321,
0.0381719582,
-0.0013082783,
-0.0027143606,
0.0427198522,
0.0060775825,
-0.0106354356,
0.069443047,
0.0453142747,
0.0400127284,
-0.0373741537,
0.0068373918,
-0.0140141863,
0.0277300682,
0.0119265672,
-0.0035301165,
0.0406555496,
0.0120216245,
0.0572417863,
-0.0164576098,
-0.0564324372,
0.0439180136,
-0.0092721088,
0.0032945594,
-0.0063977567,
0.0403282456,
0.0392594971,
0.0047091083,
0.0410061963,
-0.0454999954,
-0.0053229318,
0.0286534373,
0.0127153564,
0.0706063062,
0.0384676754,
-0.0123157045,
-0.0601296537,
-0.0365230665,
0.0178174656,
-0.0351034291,
-0.0046093455,
0.0100761009,
0.0211778507,
-0.0480928533,
0.0220036283,
0.032614015,
-0.0351362526,
-0.0207343809,
-0.0227556173,
0.0197425038,
0.0945527479,
0.0700938925,
-0.0287225004,
-0.0001082627,
-0.0418303534,
0.0303790048,
0.0521584228,
0.0509257615,
-0.0204667021,
0.0083283419,
-0.0514025688,
0.0079650907,
-0.0047765695,
0.0636491105,
-0.0050738244,
0.0159609262,
0.0130012138,
0.0236396752,
-0.0509710051,
-0.028578965,
0.0210984778,
-0.0046643359,
-0.0124601563,
-0.0051822178,
-0.0090890704,
0.0139684109,
0.0044212355,
-0.0486257114,
-0.0076259505,
-0.0125416135,
0.0071940538,
-0.0385789536,
0.0021045031,
-0.0393585414,
-0.0438579321,
0.029524941,
0.0058208178,
-0.0253427345,
-0.0214443654,
-0.05633967,
-0.0334407911,
-0.0115782097,
-0.0520888194,
-0.0417399034,
-0.0346636213,
0.0606081076,
0.0187666789,
0.0416396856,
-0.0069415397,
0.0765201747,
-0.0244202875,
-0.0155925527,
0.0189443547,
0.0314666219,
0.029923493,
-0.0503344536,
0.0195907224,
0.0553837754,
0.0173966959,
-0.0110822981,
-0.001293545,
-0.0529519878,
-0.0307004508,
-0.0188603792,
-0.0541387536,
0.0121543147,
-0.0403155386,
0.0289788339,
0.0233562477,
-0.031545911,
-0.0189535711,
-0.0087215547,
0.0205959827,
-0.0054188715,
0.0282573402,
-0.0067836153,
0.0554976314,
-0.0077278819,
-0.0016224125,
-0.0417493246,
0.0206027012,
-0.0305162836,
0.0602364875,
0.0103013366,
-0.0278553069,
-0.1038030609,
0.0019422052,
-0.0465268642,
0.0425258093,
-0.0205662958,
-0.0118839638,
0.0187762324,
0.0101798931,
0.0939202234,
0.054377269,
0.0448649339,
0.0316199213,
0.0312416013,
-0.0469095968,
-0.0030422441,
0.0308513101,
0.0194477253,
0.046083685,
-0.006564118,
-0.0256571602,
0.0381791182,
0.0389545895,
0.0081898021,
0.0049899779,
-0.0272514634,
0.0135577433,
-0.0255968384,
-0.0268641822,
0.042961292,
-0.0175964292,
-0.0063183811,
0.032509096,
-0.0441269577,
-0.0252228323,
0.0675284788,
-0.0607321262,
0.0423106663,
-0.0564010367,
-0.0131399855,
-0.0064265355,
0.0502527803,
0.0127120903,
-0.0001740051,
0.0304881856,
0.0161497034,
-0.0260575023,
0.0197452437,
0.0414413214,
-0.0260923859,
0.0426069312,
-0.0633307695,
0.0036584835,
0.0072752247,
-0.0363786407,
-0.0424253121,
-0.0415614732,
0.0168604497,
-0.0218470283,
0.0058200741,
-0.0486154929,
-0.0578060597,
-0.0464290306,
0.0224423949,
0.056108512,
-0.0035821381,
-0.0053317202,
0.001538211,
0.0211030059,
0.0486281738,
0.0343893953,
0.0834035352,
-0.0258454084,
0.0185738914,
0.0614400879,
0.0001627574,
0.0248615015,
-0.0159031563,
-0.0411293581,
-0.0512051284,
-0.0470470376,
-0.0166662969,
0.0001350054,
0.0532940105,
-0.0707671419,
-0.0113150831,
0.0990888029,
0.0332833305,
0.000635105,
-0.0072427704,
-0.0366817266,
0.0310699921,
-0.0052985628,
0.0244076699,
-0.0887487754,
-0.0292691793,
0.0178900436,
0.0104017025,
-0.0194114596,
-0.0472657047,
-0.0061053862,
-0.1027178764,
0.0677108839,
0.0050919033,
0.0261995327,
-0.0384625606,
-0.0231774151,
0.0223933738,
0.011717597,
0.0104802689,
0.0357917994,
-0.0005297281,
0.0066501284,
-0.0034612801,
-0.012897661,
-0.0479935631,
0.0245036017,
-0.0307445768,
0.0680432022,
0.0349958427,
0.0420267582,
0.0393111147,
-0.0304948483,
0.0165793281,
-0.0002148568,
-0.0293421336,
0.0236434117,
0.1010601744,
0.0138750933,
0.0038439764,
-0.0325192027,
0.0047952635,
0.0097081298,
-0.0331487358,
-0.0102481302,
0.034964405,
-0.0260510854,
-0.0180555433,
-0.0124435453,
0.0245622266,
0.0329472683,
0.0859100893,
0.0173760168,
0.0296893679,
-0.0902402624,
-0.0250355378,
0.014185342,
-0.0269953813,
0.0194747839,
0.0242879633,
0.0419027247,
-0.0175590795,
-0.0990697667,
-0.0553751253,
-0.0270040035,
0.0141256033,
-0.04211751,
-0.0171333533,
0.002594535,
-0.0200837422,
-0.0105131688,
-0.0101979841,
-0.0204336327,
0.0084856488,
-0.0097287111,
0.0160413422,
-0.0004380829,
0.0046789604,
0.0039833407,
0.0368838795,
-0.1133020446,
-0.0318837985,
0.0275824945,
-0.0100717731,
0.0099259419,
0.0865114704,
-0.040828947,
0.0213887841,
0.0150167989,
0.0463068672,
-0.0267622862,
0.0440881141,
0.023414338,
-0.0155753596,
0.0007758901,
0.0325461179,
-0.0195869766,
0.0022125547,
-0.0379849859,
0.012051017,
-0.0276836678,
-0.0006910224,
0.0132020796,
0.0027628778,
0.016811097,
0.0204481594,
0.0274508968,
-0.0412945971,
0.0194973983,
-0.0244600009,
-0.0405665934,
-0.0004865928,
0.0411219113,
-0.0231637396,
-0.0383523665,
-0.004689903,
0.0218243655,
-0.0355196558,
0.0160681549,
-0.0107465358,
-0.0384742394,
0.01160808,
-0.0004901427,
-0.0026931905,
-0.0346227363,
-0.0151486928,
-0.006285388,
-0.0232865717,
0.0625493303,
0.0062879575,
0.0642854795,
0.0482345037,
-0.0431187898,
0.002946405,
-0.0128288707,
-0.071243003,
-0.0236326288,
-0.0188160799,
0.0381179526,
0.0413178466,
-0.0026410816,
0.0572197586,
-0.0099964021,
0.0020605079,
-0.0239683185,
0.0137918135,
0.0433427915,
-0.0282188952,
-0.0346804149,
0.0395664424,
-0.0240640678,
0.0165723413,
0.0517169721,
-0.0093700457,
0.0453479216,
0.0080681825,
-0.0407017246,
-0.0145023866,
-0.079925783,
-0.1127026156,
-0.0074140918,
-0.0009833948,
-0.0223459173,
-0.0471552163,
-0.0312193818,
0.0115918871,
0.0453020968,
0.036452949,
0.0327212401,
-0.001882425,
0.0860904679,
-0.0013275163,
-0.0245242715,
-0.0176351778,
0.0003137479,
0.0070166788,
-0.016767174,
-0.0101351552,
-5.961414908e-33,
-0.0142512489,
-0.0403628834,
0.0078388443,
-0.051853437,
-0.0438372865,
0.0073821135,
-0.0305641424,
-0.0405420586,
-0.0008197112,
0.0763090178,
0.0189470109,
0.0661929175,
0.0149964783,
0.0153558888,
-0.0254010614,
-0.0471495166,
0.0871083587,
0.0306196641,
-0.013641322,
0.0147753432,
0.0696438625,
-0.006126408,
0.0232598931,
-0.0625069663,
0.0410767198,
-0.0174430478,
-0.0207136907,
0.0149999298,
-0.0142375622,
0.0394094773,
0.0115891015,
0.0287399907,
0.0137905702,
-0.0419991314,
-0.0183959771,
-0.0227174088,
-0.069702737,
-0.0164990388,
-0.0214406662,
0.0194477774,
-0.0347898975,
0.0025970526,
0.0255878288,
0.0053207562,
0.043985121,
-0.0463393442,
0.0195778944,
-0.0387488902,
0.0355792791,
0.034203805,
-0.0611322969,
0.0432180651,
0.002967299,
-0.0005600264,
-0.0558264069,
0.0400059856,
0.02447428,
-0.0204853378,
-0.0747705325,
-0.0313183255,
0.0267292783,
0.0147909019,
0.0193538032,
-0.041627083,
-0.0182825774,
0.0760203898,
0.0042932048,
0.0130907707,
-0.0971389934,
-0.0233648028,
-0.0406702943,
0.0138711212,
0.0323789567,
0.0599779338,
0.0672305152,
0.0130012315,
-0.0588231944,
-0.014355069,
-0.0145676648,
0.0566016138,
0.008694035,
-0.0111420276,
-0.0570437275,
-0.0079513099,
-0.0073010488,
0.0062567121,
-0.0183198843,
-0.0040758951,
0.0406883843,
0.0151190441,
0.0161561612,
0.0105482889,
0.0176583435,
-0.0169182569,
0.0118674506,
0.0130659686,
-0.0549848564,
-0.0165490098,
0.0186883193,
-0.0050451001,
-0.014767861,
0.0204122346,
0.054591354,
0.0471051298,
0.0066973181,
0.0141898375,
0.0379804522,
-0.0225473121,
-0.0618592761,
0.0292590428,
-0.0096224146,
0.0387765691,
-0.0403057933,
-0.0008873526,
0.0430909619,
0.0000263321,
-0.0474654399,
0.0306307729,
-0.0015631256,
0.0218840092,
-0.0012476733,
0.010800791,
-0.0218904223,
0.0142404223,
-0.0233513564,
0.0179041531,
-0.0292615741,
-0.024466455,
-0.0004882657,
-0.0629829317,
0.0181746855,
0.0363460667,
2.638e-7,
-0.0182492193,
0.0563354753,
0.0650850907,
-0.0123281144,
0.0268374234,
0.0095534045,
0.015544707,
0.0117298923,
-0.0443070196,
-0.0420081764,
-0.0308751278,
0.0647070929,
0.0699668825,
0.0502708703,
-0.0472747162,
-0.0183517244,
-0.0798776671,
-0.050725732,
-0.0834223852,
-0.0430390015,
0.0584557243,
0.0640552491,
0.0478951894,
-0.0081863897,
0.0395814069,
-0.0335933454,
0.028962696,
0.0366985947,
-0.0043340181,
0.0213798191,
0.0524350107,
-0.0020656527,
0.013899886,
0.0220458899,
-0.023757318,
-0.010415676,
-0.0149696516,
0.0345022455,
0.0140613774,
0.0411368944,
-0.0477854945,
-0.0174314659,
-0.0037440006,
-0.0383341722,
0.0637184158,
0.0031757636,
0.0029791268,
-0.0558698438,
-0.0348214135,
-0.0034173399,
0.0465614982,
0.0212135874,
-0.003746433,
0.0326587893,
-0.0044408212,
0.0073692319,
-0.0036857652,
-0.0524980612,
-0.0132804336,
0.005016542,
-0.0448551029,
0.0104945581,
-0.0101106986,
-0.0299330056,
0.0464920029,
-0.0502701886,
0.027696941,
2.426346843e-34,
0.0388763435,
0.0038464784,
-0.0001568213,
-0.02236831,
0.0807960555,
0.0008752882,
-0.0093039554,
-0.0279303044,
-0.0065316847,
-0.0392622687,
-0.0012049604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13183v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13183v2 | Breaking through Deterministic Barriers: Randomized Pruning Mask Generation and Selection | 2023-10-19T22:32:51 | 2024-01-11T04:17:28 | Jianwei Li, Weizhi Gao, Qi Lei, Dongkuan Xu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | It is widely acknowledged that large and sparse models have higher accuracy
than small and dense models under the same model size constraints. This
motivates us to train a large model and then remove its redundant neurons or
weights by pruning. Most existing works pruned the networks in a deterministic
way, the performance of which solely depends on a single pruning criterion and
thus lacks variety. Instead, in this paper, we propose a model pruning strategy
that first generates several pruning masks in a designed random way.
Subsequently, along with an effective mask-selection rule, the optimal mask is
chosen from the pool of mask candidates. To further enhance efficiency, we
introduce an early mask evaluation strategy, mitigating the overhead associated
with training multiple masks. Our extensive experiments demonstrate that this
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance across eight datasets from GLUE,
particularly excelling at high levels of sparsity. | [
-0.0075308057,
0.0740611404,
-0.001113277,
0.0192378275,
-0.0373423882,
-0.0284138639,
0.0775675178,
0.0088168234,
0.0028284348,
0.047667481,
-0.0129046105,
-0.0198589284,
-0.0089319907,
0.0308551099,
0.0215607993,
-0.07212466,
0.0049731554,
-0.0059029702,
-0.0079290606,
-0.0026491724,
-0.0007755353,
0.0013200013,
0.0220330786,
0.0565545037,
-0.0318728015,
-0.0099650007,
-0.0084365495,
0.0252475943,
0.0118463831,
-0.0185368638,
0.0446005315,
0.0505126491,
-0.0168952364,
0.0251983944,
0.0000024673,
-0.0229595881,
-0.0056436071,
0.024067333,
-0.0350015201,
0.0484717079,
-0.0198888332,
0.0225762501,
0.0046174405,
-0.0121773733,
-0.0401982144,
-0.0230682828,
0.0435995348,
0.0424983352,
0.022534335,
0.067468062,
-0.0109852357,
-0.0234759878,
-0.0349459685,
-0.0640189499,
-0.0381597243,
-0.030013876,
0.0154468007,
-0.0531950444,
-0.0769223571,
-0.0981591642,
-0.0152083505,
0.0057026758,
0.0593742989,
0.0524847656,
0.0545016006,
0.0535095148,
-0.0223697498,
-0.0445908532,
0.0228039734,
0.0133829191,
-0.1276257485,
-0.0330781639,
0.0180695318,
-0.0364977345,
-0.0195720661,
-0.0012624592,
-0.035487812,
0.003021993,
0.0365278535,
0.0375184529,
-0.0801408738,
0.0639947876,
0.0710150972,
0.0052918298,
-0.0502873473,
-0.0099962289,
-0.0081592435,
0.0280897412,
-0.0022974212,
-0.0131261488,
-0.0310752317,
-0.0680800825,
-0.0126203066,
0.0057517248,
-0.0028612008,
-0.0242956113,
-0.054073479,
-0.0302505847,
0.0047660396,
0.0216977894,
0.0108177848,
-0.012456744,
0.030157363,
0.048837807,
-0.0393106528,
-0.028234316,
0.0373928994,
0.0427067392,
0.0039286432,
-0.015741365,
0.0149125466,
0.0154437982,
0.0041536214,
0.0834651291,
-0.0069571887,
-0.0336720832,
-0.0497346669,
-0.0679176003,
-0.0445852615,
-0.0016314874,
0.0036069879,
0.0230965726,
-0.0399355181,
-0.0046509956,
0.0279122572,
-0.0458468646,
-0.0167037137,
0.0203233864,
-0.0070169284,
-0.0324414372,
-0.0523779541,
0.0457220152,
-0.0150757059,
-0.0355507173,
0.0436424986,
0.0561107099,
-0.035303887,
-0.0352028534,
-0.0706766769,
-0.0273784753,
0.0221668016,
-0.016187299,
0.0291790143,
-0.0565198921,
0.011978169,
-0.0523116812,
0.0400102548,
-0.1005550548,
0.00148145,
-0.0028220802,
-0.0313702598,
0.0192438625,
-0.0011732162,
-0.0111068431,
-0.013067985,
0.0257655457,
0.016430622,
0.0455602035,
0.0270147976,
0.081562914,
0.0091518564,
-0.0159662701,
-0.0300319213,
0.0270311963,
0.050093364,
-0.0243644975,
-0.0144533329,
-0.055953823,
-0.000976069,
-0.0494114384,
0.035154745,
0.033056736,
-0.066997394,
-0.0733859465,
0.0228687357,
-0.0125704631,
0.0351168513,
0.0363184847,
0.0289972201,
0.0028691597,
0.0039599705,
0.0065126219,
-0.0177300517,
0.0273176357,
-0.0180938374,
-0.0170235243,
-0.0604547709,
0.058178477,
-0.0736808777,
-0.0428663269,
0.0139833288,
-0.04336036,
0.0212794282,
0.0372035615,
0.0673240349,
0.0168545563,
0.0025901718,
0.0106087057,
0.0089405747,
0.0072660763,
-0.0201496035,
-0.0751330853,
-0.0157068409,
-0.0576258078,
-0.0005364566,
-0.0066912216,
-0.0276235305,
0.0404669195,
0.0165765714,
-0.0124786934,
-0.0063811066,
0.0027111403,
0.0967462659,
-0.0539974086,
0.0001897189,
-0.0045724944,
0.0086169317,
0.0248827636,
0.0570963919,
0.0097794579,
0.0167637113,
0.0260913875,
0.0104415501,
0.0509206727,
-0.0610671975,
-0.0081299748,
0.0397950597,
0.0161299463,
0.0232003964,
-0.0153087284,
-0.0166394189,
-0.0490699075,
0.0544225499,
-0.05539364,
0.0099672731,
-0.0206136815,
-0.0399034768,
-0.0143155875,
0.0266721435,
-0.0416591503,
0.0002004107,
0.1176511198,
-0.0398902968,
-0.0330676362,
0.0004300534,
-0.0093462262,
-0.0021891608,
-0.0447322316,
-0.0440410115,
-0.005479414,
0.0497139022,
0.0026820779,
0.0330744497,
-0.0142758666,
-0.0176653136,
0.0240633152,
-0.0307066422,
0.048444096,
-0.0414881296,
-0.0235683713,
-0.0447236672,
-0.0561287403,
-0.0056329179,
-0.0083399573,
-0.0066453451,
-0.0071397102,
-0.0010902156,
0.0254609119,
0.0249950495,
-0.0390039384,
-0.0155706042,
-0.0305847879,
0.0114555424,
0.0189306643,
-0.0514152274,
0.0332351364,
0.0137142055,
-0.0020660853,
-0.0109055294,
0.0040502409,
-0.0084279338,
-0.0299747847,
0.0004467282,
-0.0489583462,
0.0621720776,
0.0425953642,
0.0021072854,
-0.0702303275,
0.0078527918,
0.0647464171,
-0.0221867189,
0.0111215031,
-0.0174108353,
-0.0220183898,
-0.0320049785,
-0.0249284152,
-0.062454395,
0.0890532359,
-0.0240276996,
0.0005424593,
0.0467821136,
0.0411244109,
-0.0274069048,
0.0146868834,
-0.0152742816,
0.0568152927,
-0.0156477503,
-0.0346693471,
0.0115022603,
0.0303149037,
0.0023366134,
-0.0054450086,
-0.0679992586,
0.0347707346,
0.0296012945,
-0.0737189576,
-0.0227418002,
0.0316170454,
-0.0009325374,
0.0219821539,
-0.0224528518,
-0.0376045071,
-0.0087516988,
0.003886065,
-0.0168035347,
0.034869723,
-0.0533895008,
0.0093935048,
0.0265492089,
0.0437010042,
0.019897297,
-0.0162209105,
-0.0001065411,
-0.0670644715,
-0.0200933684,
0.0133244218,
0.0051341332,
-0.0219085272,
-0.0434946492,
0.0182166267,
0.0088402601,
-0.0337109379,
-0.0261535607,
-0.0416673794,
-0.0018049926,
0.0208966155,
-0.0043687215,
-0.0194178056,
-0.0116532668,
-0.0001251232,
0.0000389186,
0.0464373119,
0.0054108589,
0.0308638364,
0.0095378757,
0.035689611,
0.0684514046,
0.0276611205,
0.0545984954,
-0.003726189,
0.0434604548,
0.0428467318,
0.0406187177,
0.0293103959,
-0.1010227427,
-0.0179358888,
-0.0140396263,
0.0208588857,
0.0020343624,
-0.0054600565,
0.046153944,
-0.0324553177,
0.0346204862,
0.0477295704,
0.0007684582,
-0.0140629187,
-0.0013734479,
0.011836133,
0.0851409137,
0.0036508439,
0.0237021223,
-0.0050084461,
-0.0127835907,
0.0229229443,
0.0254224278,
0.0095236972,
-0.0030088653,
0.0285174381,
-0.1038946584,
0.075349696,
0.0126629183,
-0.0229767449,
0.0322559588,
-0.004201279,
0.0343402363,
-0.0544541404,
-0.0076868501,
-0.0267821737,
0.0163930655,
-0.016213024,
0.0207041185,
-0.0300852433,
-0.0472042449,
0.0166548938,
-0.0294190962,
0.0189742837,
0.0070672403,
-0.0341163985,
-0.0394695289,
-0.0686644018,
0.0635663345,
0.009710812,
-0.0068107224,
-0.0436647534,
0.0911185071,
0.041176945,
-0.0138226449,
-0.0210509524,
0.0357021838,
0.0395032503,
-0.0136980098,
0.0069857137,
0.0296643805,
0.0033485743,
-0.0108578727,
-0.0110202469,
-0.0155021837,
-0.0027260752,
0.0308441184,
0.0369015299,
-0.0183579847,
-0.04715937,
0.0052799028,
-0.0254709609,
-0.0980508476,
-0.0196087994,
0.0577315651,
-0.0098490464,
-0.0748857111,
-0.016920317,
0.0191844068,
0.0244807415,
0.0200033821,
-0.0098775178,
-0.0167304836,
-0.0294323545,
0.0276704151,
-0.0275900029,
0.0136504639,
-0.0144353919,
0.0288543981,
-0.0054914299,
0.0046984977,
0.0106976833,
-0.0326157436,
-0.0425638705,
0.0133001292,
-0.0760423839,
-0.0386661105,
-0.0075319689,
0.0758848712,
0.0198783632,
0.0617855489,
0.0001519431,
-0.0501223207,
0.0325501263,
0.0302191135,
0.0127698369,
0.043321263,
0.0792554617,
-0.1032595783,
-0.021673115,
0.044360362,
0.0053976225,
0.0714795887,
0.0512974523,
0.0066551641,
-0.0332474262,
0.0583916083,
-0.0165799223,
0.0296023618,
0.0273839179,
-0.0079386448,
0.0378650576,
-0.0306415744,
0.0409670211,
0.0468170829,
0.0129835317,
-0.035404589,
0.0256079379,
0.0177071597,
0.0641409457,
-0.0084990533,
0.01977681,
0.0496230908,
0.027876325,
-0.0517345965,
-0.0008650787,
-0.0213267915,
-0.0006633323,
0.0294581354,
0.013790994,
-0.0164866392,
0.0391424894,
0.0259508491,
-0.0069413097,
0.0003165254,
-0.0503098927,
0.0481328554,
0.0346516967,
-0.0688661486,
0.0119789727,
-0.0391930901,
-0.0793146119,
-0.0355004817,
-0.0273526162,
0.0335154943,
-0.0215438418,
0.0272787996,
-0.0092425495,
-0.0097061014,
-0.027140202,
0.019445179,
0.0332216136,
0.0088992603,
0.0052620131,
-0.0353522412,
-0.0064469608,
-0.0272508617,
0.0672806799,
0.0236376747,
0.0123829292,
-0.0072270725,
0.0071072881,
-0.0712471306,
-0.0242351536,
0.0348989218,
0.0647453666,
-0.0078441678,
-0.0201179199,
-0.0221516844,
-0.0541362315,
0.0228877999,
-0.0188050009,
0.0491423905,
0.0249902457,
0.0336697288,
0.0115461685,
0.0186836328,
0.023034893,
0.0304264408,
-0.054520376,
-0.0108698355,
-0.0123271402,
0.0132527016,
-7.113584879e-33,
0.024736857,
0.0119545637,
-0.0105857467,
0.0490433723,
-0.0156722721,
0.0091036456,
-0.0180102028,
-0.037209101,
-0.0044768509,
0.0095179975,
-0.0508913547,
0.0033925483,
0.0052012745,
0.0320463292,
-0.0276141576,
-0.0044727977,
0.0834450573,
-0.0199782643,
0.0160712451,
0.0440563187,
-0.0132227279,
0.0287492089,
-0.0101125212,
-0.0546075366,
-0.100105688,
0.033587791,
-0.0469289757,
-0.0227432828,
-0.0240810644,
0.0200370979,
0.0075821988,
0.0182938911,
0.013693057,
-0.0154779823,
-0.0105581898,
-0.0059376108,
-0.0700165182,
-0.0456382781,
-0.0203049276,
-0.0047794925,
-0.0528454185,
-0.0109140463,
0.0437961146,
0.0017383416,
-0.0073426729,
-0.0275551435,
0.0380179994,
-0.0407559015,
-0.044791244,
-0.0215978641,
0.0055443882,
0.041265063,
0.0144079421,
-0.0299606342,
0.0495717414,
0.0134612508,
-0.0375153646,
0.015801236,
-0.0602494776,
-0.0344824642,
0.0191353559,
0.0259058699,
0.0183215979,
0.059460476,
-0.0027827665,
0.0519012436,
0.0182445049,
0.0074611478,
-0.0034904934,
0.0553366616,
0.0375391804,
0.0705084875,
0.0781525597,
0.0321415775,
0.0578256808,
-0.0525991805,
-0.1346361041,
0.0240029935,
-0.0133941956,
0.0285684541,
0.0099264234,
0.0275477618,
0.0542872138,
0.0168406665,
-0.0024708423,
-0.0109962774,
-0.0171824507,
-0.001471823,
0.0227248576,
0.0616313331,
-0.0683589652,
0.0442185849,
0.0094672507,
-0.0218009055,
0.0289884862,
0.0215988178,
0.0098216599,
0.0195819158,
0.0440976769,
-0.0260112286,
-0.0377801359,
0.0026608102,
0.0051343068,
-0.0084292637,
0.0447777212,
-0.0182520729,
0.0459957048,
0.0290296059,
-0.0136664417,
-0.0182341449,
-0.0303101633,
0.0606819615,
0.0331225321,
0.0797500387,
0.0085894763,
0.005114858,
-0.000606314,
-0.0146907642,
-0.0006121136,
-0.0167568382,
-0.0265179891,
0.0445872098,
0.0290961955,
0.0004658675,
-0.025289163,
-0.0038009933,
-0.032547649,
-0.0128758093,
0.0635658205,
-0.0531521887,
-0.0172473975,
0.0204654876,
3.01e-7,
-0.0292195734,
-0.0389136635,
-0.0355782472,
0.0078294417,
0.0068483604,
0.0014245413,
-0.0348304808,
-0.017682001,
-0.0546054877,
-0.0128646363,
-0.0134632541,
0.0240081791,
0.0600768812,
0.0026206193,
-0.0741602033,
0.0209521819,
0.0091427378,
-0.0109425932,
-0.0175908655,
-0.0036502113,
-0.0317575932,
0.0788034797,
0.0506965034,
-0.057473667,
0.0380134694,
0.0000046212,
-0.009859723,
-0.0170449745,
0.0364090465,
-0.0321275108,
0.0293658637,
0.0138527798,
-0.0333068855,
0.0342689604,
0.0077359718,
0.0235855952,
-0.0126186656,
0.0709732398,
-0.0091805197,
0.0047704154,
0.0068492861,
0.0553859994,
0.0160513185,
-0.0314229466,
0.0654371232,
-0.0251332279,
-0.0008492854,
0.0039816732,
-0.0031876815,
0.0024192682,
0.0225375202,
-0.0274959076,
0.0023470402,
0.026558347,
0.0193416551,
-0.0285737161,
0.0019816814,
-0.0574397333,
-0.0103303958,
-0.0272853393,
-0.0824132413,
-0.0373463258,
-0.0330651179,
-0.0217930228,
0.015288122,
-0.0632266402,
-0.0496711992,
2.686793688e-34,
0.0072700987,
0.0009611339,
-0.0266429503,
0.0226280298,
0.0166022163,
-0.002499389,
-0.0389963612,
0.0070802681,
-0.0248734597,
-0.0383342095,
-0.0412374549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13146v1 | CLIFT: Analysing Natural Distribution Shift on Question Answering Models in Clinical Domain | 2023-10-19T20:43:11 | 2023-10-19T20:43:11 | Ankit Pal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.DC, cs.LG | This paper introduces a new testbed CLIFT (Clinical Shift) for the clinical
domain Question-answering task. The testbed includes 7.5k high-quality question
answering samples to provide a diverse and reliable benchmark. We performed a
comprehensive experimental study and evaluated several QA deep-learning models
under the proposed testbed. Despite impressive results on the original test
set, the performance degrades when applied to new test sets, which shows the
distribution shift. Our findings emphasize the need for and the potential for
increasing the robustness of clinical domain models under distributional
shifts. The testbed offers one way to track progress in that direction. It also
highlights the necessity of adopting evaluation metrics that consider
robustness to natural distribution shifts. We plan to expand the corpus by
adding more samples and model results. The full paper and the updated benchmark
are available at github.com/openlifescience-ai/clift | [
0.0251786355,
0.0543486029,
-0.0036119216,
0.0015605908,
-0.0105093177,
-0.0123481629,
-0.0432479307,
0.0265117027,
-0.0314353853,
-0.0056988872,
-0.0210300032,
-0.056430392,
-0.0568739586,
0.0267249234,
0.0183674861,
-0.0401829593,
0.0341799818,
0.0310579818,
0.0095801791,
0.0187072847,
-0.029718142,
-0.0182014816,
-0.0350786634,
0.0365984328,
0.0502500385,
-0.0502866283,
0.0211335421,
0.0230284631,
0.0553602912,
-0.0481069759,
0.0210837834,
0.0532391109,
-0.0148560395,
-0.0043755961,
0.0000019198,
-0.0457112417,
-0.0033612614,
0.0184360091,
-0.0598182082,
0.0064781867,
-0.0074717747,
-0.0166206285,
0.0030467412,
0.0274290275,
-0.0602516495,
-0.0238893498,
0.0178367402,
0.0134310909,
0.053965684,
0.0547638424,
0.0004078644,
0.0067288629,
0.024051832,
-0.0372245498,
-0.0169866141,
-0.0759233534,
0.0223675128,
0.0143486783,
0.0268929694,
-0.0117766578,
-0.0228687059,
0.0244028158,
0.0415702909,
0.0228802077,
0.0088832583,
0.039005246,
-0.0630071014,
0.0155227408,
-0.0003730176,
0.1175769791,
-0.0345242582,
-0.0167761352,
-0.0143039785,
-0.0092391903,
0.0271079149,
0.0137191238,
-0.0523284674,
0.0116743576,
-0.0072100516,
-0.0207678955,
-0.0050874529,
0.0253427941,
0.0383279249,
-0.0065152943,
-0.0272301938,
-0.0167164002,
0.0283324961,
-0.0469730869,
0.013517892,
-0.0115945283,
-0.0799042061,
-0.0429870263,
0.0402072184,
0.0454185195,
-0.0266218632,
0.0089512523,
0.0040453188,
-0.0302354787,
0.0608232394,
-0.0326982103,
0.0210132748,
0.0275641512,
-0.048666887,
0.0169490706,
0.0004826661,
0.0402111895,
-0.0308850855,
0.0207789708,
-0.0523011126,
0.0009960994,
-0.0332224257,
-0.0244828686,
0.004503672,
0.0124096787,
-0.0197168868,
0.008546656,
-0.050471846,
0.0190089773,
0.0055919131,
-0.0300961882,
0.018266039,
0.0755857378,
-0.0085006272,
0.0444833227,
-0.0294847488,
0.0473329797,
-0.0804707706,
0.0097074416,
0.0107961809,
-0.0676710904,
-0.0241213329,
0.005971753,
-0.0015781173,
-0.0211752001,
0.0143005373,
0.0443995893,
-0.0006608169,
-0.0177308563,
0.0159411971,
-0.0023515108,
-0.0256274901,
-0.024036115,
-0.0014425353,
-0.0512228869,
0.0159443486,
0.0173970424,
0.0044109072,
-0.0381526276,
-0.0034702912,
0.0338994712,
-0.0042350977,
0.0496382229,
-0.0076605417,
0.0012233582,
0.0117209777,
0.022188196,
0.0080538355,
0.0557856895,
0.0260430146,
-0.0583085604,
0.0362010971,
-0.0421224535,
0.0267458167,
-0.0012500078,
0.0236548334,
-0.0212946851,
0.0165318381,
0.0513863601,
-0.0307603832,
0.0867247283,
0.0020143138,
0.0298412405,
-0.0097366646,
-0.0749923885,
0.0113121141,
0.0828709602,
0.0067838272,
0.0095776776,
0.0061966525,
-0.0515961535,
0.0074981223,
-0.0061811986,
-0.0348195359,
-0.010252174,
0.0099942917,
-0.0030668613,
-0.0577597506,
-0.016330909,
-0.0431775227,
-0.0082436353,
-0.0083814384,
-0.0061547901,
-0.0255234968,
0.0091710761,
0.0020632795,
0.0001643507,
-0.0052627251,
0.0648300722,
0.0162320603,
-0.0321055613,
0.0014391562,
-0.063695319,
0.0072979867,
0.0069742519,
0.0381183699,
-0.0662900731,
-0.056083791,
-0.0020894927,
0.0219616648,
0.0179375317,
0.0178029034,
-0.0161248315,
0.0203220323,
-0.0097982874,
-0.0016830255,
-0.0109611936,
0.0030141808,
-0.0304696411,
0.010780775,
0.0456027649,
-0.0207630433,
-0.1086092293,
0.0041078287,
0.0424592011,
-0.0503711104,
-0.003429966,
0.0359268151,
-0.0088812327,
0.0013136156,
0.0086408351,
-0.0242280364,
0.020540705,
0.0268687699,
-0.0344847851,
-0.011328049,
-0.0060068737,
-0.0285434742,
-0.023211984,
0.0068618148,
-0.0364704579,
0.0036906132,
0.0538138263,
-0.0384899192,
-0.0257201549,
-0.0016198456,
-0.0188591052,
0.0157700628,
0.0221848059,
-0.0119575439,
0.0104520787,
0.0280294605,
-0.0790261254,
0.0357157513,
-0.016526442,
0.0127028236,
-0.0130511038,
0.014846731,
-0.0084552448,
-0.0133670326,
0.0389058515,
0.0013193559,
-0.0378410034,
0.0149489641,
-0.0126331756,
-0.0090329088,
-0.0491567999,
-0.0215048026,
-0.0497529358,
0.0315525346,
-0.0288936291,
0.0414881557,
0.0584214553,
0.0312488265,
-0.0164306257,
-0.0163578149,
-0.0828750059,
-0.0058127367,
0.0303595141,
0.0388922803,
0.0516136363,
0.010545169,
0.0355601572,
-0.0501824841,
-0.0164907277,
-0.0289256051,
0.0346493088,
-0.0282171182,
0.0092632137,
-0.0287707504,
0.0061359792,
-0.0351239927,
-0.003907721,
-0.0150834331,
-0.0333874896,
0.0044576139,
0.0156004447,
0.0078326473,
0.0755585656,
0.025861796,
0.0042742854,
0.0090432139,
0.050722722,
-0.0347390249,
0.04062346,
-0.019883085,
-0.0588293746,
-0.0059889737,
-0.0143512022,
0.0094952108,
0.0610905886,
0.0218306929,
-0.0040363437,
-0.0444528572,
0.0027594173,
-0.025486486,
0.0017873528,
-0.0084149288,
0.0484718792,
-0.0367447734,
0.0320778638,
-0.0143952006,
0.0002876459,
0.0652968213,
0.0274733752,
0.0204827115,
-0.0779768825,
-0.0201828349,
-0.0480256043,
0.0032280486,
-0.0074519333,
-0.0126154711,
0.0254090019,
-0.0302877575,
-0.0503129177,
-0.0078218412,
-0.0244116988,
-0.0516574867,
0.0806490704,
-0.0287602451,
0.0090338234,
-0.0352793187,
-0.070041962,
-0.059130393,
-0.0809697136,
-0.0031882043,
0.0263097696,
-0.0127632944,
-0.0198180731,
-0.0246508326,
0.0057277088,
-0.0185532477,
0.0547258705,
-0.0268142708,
-0.0062381011,
-0.0295899287,
0.0794373006,
0.0624709651,
0.0891423896,
0.0375877135,
0.0023637239,
0.0235087927,
0.0617903285,
0.013995897,
0.033470612,
-0.0042487127,
0.0063203964,
-0.0074455366,
-0.057089217,
-0.0085339276,
0.0204011388,
0.0776878819,
-0.02882131,
-0.0321726725,
0.0869771913,
0.0296497717,
-0.0521277525,
0.0477979816,
-0.0261973403,
0.0354403667,
0.0111274682,
0.0260971803,
-0.0911500379,
-0.0508227237,
-0.0271263067,
0.0445030741,
0.0060733622,
-0.0456968807,
0.0270765685,
-0.0759257004,
0.0177511778,
-0.0574785508,
-0.0728887618,
-0.00358732,
-0.0409386717,
0.0325434655,
-0.0036020749,
0.0091007287,
-0.0167662986,
-0.0073614158,
-0.0037476039,
0.0357003137,
-0.0282072816,
-0.0676465034,
0.0560285226,
-0.0467703454,
0.0285027139,
0.0731499568,
0.0099965185,
-0.0324055925,
-0.0199228972,
-0.0060150209,
-0.0780454502,
0.001967357,
0.0296198521,
0.0747210979,
0.0156471878,
-0.0202770531,
-0.0226361807,
0.0263734832,
-0.0886278376,
0.0124707865,
0.0324509367,
0.0753453225,
0.0022608594,
-0.0494515412,
-0.0742240995,
0.0238768384,
0.0101008322,
0.0303581953,
0.0140831824,
-0.0154777979,
-0.0340390243,
0.0142704649,
0.0211456716,
-0.0170455389,
-0.0342900567,
0.0375492945,
0.0257093124,
0.0097645437,
-0.0775615871,
-0.0246498678,
-0.0132875517,
0.0010982701,
-0.0205163918,
-0.0024054418,
-0.0139738368,
0.0155067937,
-0.0686080009,
0.0669752583,
0.011552983,
0.0025344072,
-0.0487211086,
-0.0177372582,
0.0606399812,
0.0206075404,
-0.0409171693,
-0.0163935777,
-0.0669184104,
0.0058263331,
-0.0072880466,
0.0400321744,
0.0130121857,
-0.0187968649,
-0.0347692259,
-0.020002028,
0.029231634,
0.0299178008,
-0.0359946638,
0.0047444967,
0.0182636399,
-0.0652661845,
-0.0313860141,
0.0257198252,
-0.02651521,
0.0183720961,
0.0109898988,
0.0514596328,
-0.0206256621,
-0.0586911365,
0.0031489886,
-0.0086549241,
0.0134603726,
0.0189693682,
-0.0524185449,
0.008928542,
0.0260802638,
0.0087448703,
0.0232334156,
0.0053034578,
-0.0126650408,
0.0407582112,
-0.0264011417,
-0.0170121901,
0.0332199708,
-0.0512620248,
-0.0104788058,
-0.052965723,
0.0218987931,
0.0915574506,
0.0208196454,
0.0131079471,
-0.0023568356,
-0.0145390481,
-0.0124602821,
0.0103506017,
0.0793973058,
0.0085476832,
0.0494824536,
0.0051228064,
0.0103472993,
0.0087193903,
0.0435150191,
-0.0770728886,
-0.0120172426,
-0.0231262911,
0.0302435961,
0.0330166072,
0.0197737068,
0.0023290224,
0.0233225245,
0.007638521,
-0.013594998,
-0.0018031265,
-0.0229519047,
0.0344107784,
0.07695961,
0.0353457071,
0.0088491663,
0.0057126754,
0.0635895878,
0.0175735876,
0.0500176065,
0.0019359423,
0.0064866655,
-0.0287829824,
-0.0026423808,
-0.0030780737,
-0.009146858,
-0.0185949523,
0.0466729291,
-0.0497655906,
-0.0511221401,
0.0501634851,
-0.0096260197,
-0.0130852265,
-0.0146317044,
0.0395137332,
0.051462736,
0.0182472467,
-0.0447546579,
-0.0241178218,
0.044728063,
-0.051639434,
-0.0015669729,
-0.0227642749,
-6.285832614e-33,
0.0024463241,
-0.0178280231,
0.0127001116,
-0.0258777142,
0.0008140836,
0.0288571622,
-0.0290636849,
0.0066219722,
-0.0650141314,
0.0179129671,
-0.045463942,
0.0457853526,
0.0099085895,
0.0323049463,
-0.0087522836,
-0.0893807039,
-0.0119223157,
-0.0129205147,
-0.0304487199,
0.0329474583,
-0.0403284207,
0.0565313511,
0.0613055453,
-0.0337787308,
-0.0171696264,
-0.0004809519,
0.0611911565,
0.0164934937,
-0.0159683209,
0.0601774119,
-0.0336966589,
0.0652346238,
0.0582736842,
-0.0173455738,
0.0387963057,
0.0053359736,
-0.0641944557,
-0.0345635973,
-0.0090025505,
0.011605096,
-0.0653855279,
-0.0125774508,
0.0456808805,
0.0036201891,
0.017785456,
-0.0315066688,
0.0174764041,
-0.0338231511,
-0.0020326045,
-0.0231493302,
-0.0310743041,
0.0446926616,
-0.0053594937,
-0.0250675678,
-0.0872776136,
0.0365756191,
-0.0303046908,
0.0481362641,
-0.0184377767,
-0.0584779046,
0.0308449529,
0.0364061482,
0.0205568988,
0.0038056595,
-0.0446265228,
0.036165677,
0.0035666423,
0.006971329,
-0.0250747316,
-0.0022809943,
-0.0187661424,
0.0127794566,
0.0684994385,
0.0897919461,
0.0476238132,
0.0286722668,
-0.1089675203,
0.033900775,
-0.016986819,
0.0231703818,
-0.006758396,
-0.0241033658,
-0.0233856123,
0.021456942,
-0.0308927726,
0.0206948724,
-0.0200307909,
-0.0011338838,
0.044441212,
-0.0329033136,
-0.0084060747,
0.022546161,
0.0099558644,
-0.0322407447,
0.0370039083,
0.0138634332,
0.0140930349,
0.0184839647,
-0.0000709312,
0.0449581705,
-0.0190731082,
0.0375107452,
0.0036695837,
-0.0081505366,
0.0517704487,
0.018387109,
0.0087444913,
-0.0345332883,
-0.0343716033,
-0.0198971238,
0.006142939,
0.0159360878,
-0.0316255987,
0.0818388984,
0.0030030829,
0.0411505178,
0.0059561334,
0.0487663262,
0.0193092618,
0.0189800169,
-0.0281329267,
0.0129641127,
0.0278862175,
0.0163312275,
-0.0267772842,
-0.0011129443,
-0.0261192173,
0.0844304785,
-0.0280679017,
-0.099767603,
0.0016463596,
-0.0019010627,
2.6e-7,
0.1206634268,
0.0161435604,
0.0312307794,
0.0170644559,
0.0217509698,
-0.0051712417,
0.003292464,
0.0312783644,
0.0347442739,
-0.0233800244,
0.0121598681,
0.0099021494,
0.0189524125,
0.0453063808,
-0.0721113682,
-0.0326390825,
-0.0972222388,
0.006044596,
-0.0176604986,
-0.0443029851,
0.036997091,
0.1085820571,
-0.0466164388,
-0.0420304313,
0.0064221071,
-0.0364167802,
0.0290079676,
0.0082556978,
0.0141142337,
0.0306561161,
-0.0041008936,
0.0116749797,
0.0207799114,
0.0512053818,
-0.0045945784,
-0.0130002862,
0.0246589966,
0.074444972,
-0.0405381881,
-0.0553368367,
-0.025354214,
-0.02081169,
0.0398032591,
-0.045105461,
0.083249636,
-0.0463891998,
-0.0468696319,
-0.0244509913,
-0.0561605506,
-0.0169290286,
0.0828073621,
-0.0317085646,
-0.0101640457,
0.0214466564,
0.0182675272,
0.020984767,
-0.0160235856,
-0.0581574403,
-0.0162009038,
0.0563298613,
-0.0308016315,
-0.017681865,
-0.0024106666,
-0.0736289546,
-0.0184593871,
-0.0419527367,
0.0222127568,
2.097456381e-34,
0.0117826425,
0.0226276051,
0.0449098609,
0.0394385569,
-0.0053229677,
0.0004485657,
0.0132805575,
-0.0362813361,
0.0390183851,
-0.0589037538,
-0.0053825392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13132v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13132v2 | Better to Ask in English: Cross-Lingual Evaluation of Large Language Models for Healthcare Queries | 2023-10-19T20:02:40 | 2023-10-23T17:47:47 | Yiqiao Jin, Mohit Chandra, Gaurav Verma, Yibo Hu, Munmun De Choudhury, Srijan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are transforming the ways the general public
accesses and consumes information. Their influence is particularly pronounced
in pivotal sectors like healthcare, where lay individuals are increasingly
appropriating LLMs as conversational agents for everyday queries. While LLMs
demonstrate impressive language understanding and generation proficiencies,
concerns regarding their safety remain paramount in these high-stake domains.
Moreover, the development of LLMs is disproportionately focused on English. It
remains unclear how these LLMs perform in the context of non-English languages,
a gap that is critical for ensuring equity in the real-world use of these
systems.This paper provides a framework to investigate the effectiveness of
LLMs as multi-lingual dialogue systems for healthcare queries. Our
empirically-derived framework XlingEval focuses on three fundamental criteria
for evaluating LLM responses to naturalistic human-authored health-related
questions: correctness, consistency, and verifiability. Through extensive
experiments on four major global languages, including English, Spanish,
Chinese, and Hindi, spanning three expert-annotated large health Q&A datasets,
and through an amalgamation of algorithmic and human-evaluation strategies, we
found a pronounced disparity in LLM responses across these languages,
indicating a need for enhanced cross-lingual capabilities. We further propose
XlingHealth, a cross-lingual benchmark for examining the multilingual
capabilities of LLMs in the healthcare context. Our findings underscore the
pressing need to bolster the cross-lingual capacities of these models, and to
provide an equitable information ecosystem accessible to all. | [
0.0846327096,
0.055301182,
-0.0097580897,
0.0031820228,
-0.0076573994,
0.0173029918,
0.010338312,
0.0163367409,
0.0601831712,
-0.0054095672,
-0.02785643,
-0.0659162477,
-0.0083729224,
-0.0001916703,
0.0288398769,
-0.0348057337,
-0.0111135924,
0.0105966618,
0.0198610295,
-0.021310091,
0.0270630382,
0.0163956583,
-0.0334440656,
0.0662244782,
0.0278256796,
0.0271614566,
0.0186198112,
-0.0026574286,
0.0225227792,
-0.0761977062,
0.0094225165,
0.0449371375,
-0.0319950581,
0.0017406495,
0.000002044,
-0.0590551905,
0.0183344707,
0.0278400332,
-0.0339819156,
-0.0503744632,
0.0371685885,
-0.0352412462,
-0.0106730759,
0.0155537426,
-0.0387587845,
-0.0141649144,
0.0402462557,
0.0009580323,
0.0342815407,
0.0371776447,
-0.0168367978,
0.0027065198,
-0.0092389788,
-0.0202941727,
0.0129286144,
-0.0441477485,
0.009904176,
0.0076249,
0.0576034337,
-0.0098684663,
0.0179843828,
0.0429944731,
0.0092781391,
-0.0130121214,
-0.0188072268,
0.0136586223,
-0.0348407328,
-0.0492976345,
0.0168738887,
0.0791937485,
0.0433671176,
0.0038994956,
0.0047570928,
0.0143557508,
0.0007495747,
0.0308709592,
-0.0393031351,
0.0272936802,
-0.0291102827,
-0.0120390449,
0.0116653964,
-0.0010226154,
0.0382589102,
0.028497912,
0.0075745457,
0.0461216494,
0.0108660469,
-0.018667791,
0.0200358853,
-0.0044303825,
0.0406969227,
-0.0319518894,
0.0377576165,
0.0380234048,
-0.0719317421,
0.0167198051,
0.0373003855,
-0.0083513847,
0.1057092696,
-0.0772889629,
-0.0119466297,
0.0248871148,
-0.0114688529,
0.0264859293,
0.0586111359,
0.0012139546,
-0.0380131826,
0.0416136384,
-0.0621089414,
-0.0132396156,
-0.0281198677,
-0.0034885295,
0.0052018319,
-0.0020881749,
-0.0278449822,
0.0587666854,
-0.0791428536,
-0.0110263089,
0.0021860253,
0.0203523487,
-0.004969025,
0.0061463728,
-0.020051768,
-0.0226106346,
-0.0544951893,
0.0338207483,
-0.0330315419,
0.018639544,
0.0092817675,
-0.0754855722,
0.0413282104,
0.0233586561,
-0.0147254663,
-0.0049464959,
0.0137760099,
0.0358301438,
-0.0067925025,
0.009849851,
-0.0102670947,
-0.0449831523,
-0.0172917377,
-0.0379670002,
-0.007516305,
-0.0742573664,
0.0496299416,
0.0295299198,
-0.0001429959,
-0.0359751359,
0.0392989367,
0.0503868423,
-0.0559490323,
0.039857652,
-0.015529261,
0.0369169861,
0.0624953248,
0.0479905456,
0.0292286016,
0.0404515341,
0.0126028229,
-0.0519181639,
0.0442492217,
-0.0021747109,
0.0024156359,
0.0237055812,
0.0057219169,
0.0138047729,
0.0177929867,
0.0624386333,
0.0090635065,
0.0375873707,
-0.0538692661,
0.0790391266,
-0.0252083428,
0.0254691932,
0.0356770828,
0.0873348266,
-0.0328847654,
-0.0099810446,
0.0117578879,
-0.0215455592,
-0.0135634923,
-0.0137788337,
0.0091869449,
0.0009474698,
0.0043679541,
-0.0163860358,
0.0162960663,
0.0095724752,
-0.0443689935,
-0.0443772152,
-0.025980778,
0.0043890541,
0.0014578813,
0.0236068536,
0.0006950879,
-0.02279149,
0.0013721997,
0.0740295276,
0.0275221653,
-0.0828640908,
0.0006030283,
-0.0602089614,
0.0093750143,
0.0659770742,
0.030144861,
0.0093037561,
-0.0242470875,
-0.0156626962,
0.0258522835,
0.0361923836,
0.0333308764,
-0.0295147914,
-0.0050299861,
-0.034724161,
-0.013593669,
0.0523310713,
-0.0093782321,
-0.0383462347,
-0.00128253,
0.0717243701,
-0.0158665851,
-0.0326376148,
-0.0688249394,
0.0064107152,
-0.0707731545,
0.0039812978,
-0.0125853373,
0.017425444,
0.023463957,
0.0610411987,
0.0061043976,
0.0499768592,
0.0133322654,
-0.0424368307,
-0.000412135,
0.0238798596,
-0.0072225505,
0.0137495622,
0.0170871466,
-0.0373304524,
0.0034104618,
-0.0232675951,
-0.0161949992,
-0.0283785164,
-0.0474358462,
-0.0313633382,
-0.0077089621,
-0.035808403,
0.0055354205,
0.0200218987,
-0.0102112843,
-0.0506801084,
-0.0060115061,
-0.0393040664,
0.027970273,
0.0178899709,
-0.025642544,
-0.003156435,
-0.0554546975,
-0.0298599787,
0.0789497495,
0.0066100494,
0.0373847224,
0.0342479981,
0.0536240451,
-0.0587825961,
-0.0142287444,
-0.1309905201,
-0.0325535275,
-0.0171562955,
0.0217327513,
0.0322216488,
0.0386572629,
0.0057488047,
-0.0190371741,
-0.0747351646,
-0.0244306885,
0.0525328815,
0.0259936471,
0.0186109766,
0.0222399477,
0.0212286301,
-0.0201035906,
-0.0035757085,
-0.0109596634,
0.0100167235,
0.0271541756,
-0.0145906713,
0.0091131032,
-0.0463420898,
-0.0597226247,
-0.0518218987,
0.0095315995,
-0.0555226915,
0.0110506695,
0.0161060821,
-0.003376886,
0.0159664825,
0.0143451421,
-0.0331530124,
0.0213792324,
0.0059253611,
-0.0221866332,
-0.002352945,
-0.0043710931,
-0.0231890399,
-0.0131800519,
-0.0814211071,
0.025172485,
0.0540109053,
0.0038269842,
0.0147226276,
-0.021623835,
0.0195350591,
-0.0616445169,
-0.0134948911,
-0.0836361796,
0.0234336443,
-0.0205821972,
0.0962866247,
0.0168995094,
-0.0022596428,
0.0588691533,
-0.0018421263,
0.0214745384,
-0.0785793364,
-0.0091325734,
-0.0372035131,
-0.0043501379,
-0.0656090304,
0.0578508452,
0.0100824926,
-0.0210789144,
-0.0232570786,
-0.0085203703,
0.0059304279,
-0.0711078346,
0.0385814905,
-0.0270063374,
0.0138065498,
0.0014974179,
-0.0727694258,
-0.0434128605,
-0.0207641348,
-0.0484523252,
0.0016001154,
0.0322458558,
0.0048695896,
-0.0162863899,
0.0338376351,
0.0304118562,
0.0422261283,
0.023556266,
-0.0129187079,
0.0160133746,
0.0157585144,
0.0120252194,
0.0396632478,
0.0319739059,
-0.0100458022,
0.0679491758,
0.0616248138,
0.0320242457,
-0.0235061608,
0.0831768736,
0.007457891,
0.0354046673,
-0.0040051714,
-0.0228032023,
0.0187870711,
0.0462682173,
-0.0337589718,
-0.0021387369,
0.0742639005,
0.0152735831,
-0.0533461571,
-0.0022612612,
-0.0771564543,
-0.0205256324,
0.0175270662,
0.0385658592,
-0.0859588161,
0.000762998,
-0.0111728897,
0.035801705,
-0.0369241983,
0.0009798636,
0.020512376,
-0.069711104,
0.0401948206,
-0.0016934349,
-0.0311262533,
-0.0048645427,
-0.0047631739,
-0.01512028,
0.0209837109,
0.0397626385,
0.0175359771,
0.0041752225,
-0.0187449213,
-0.0111935511,
-0.0406115092,
-0.068140991,
0.0269114319,
-0.0177264661,
0.0063215746,
0.0637353957,
0.0596345067,
-0.006555282,
-0.053904999,
0.020949183,
-0.0052821576,
-0.0183772482,
-0.0162650328,
0.0236863233,
0.0265972447,
-0.003856048,
-0.0727324188,
0.0250321478,
-0.0422843359,
-0.002126599,
0.0173548684,
0.0590626448,
-0.0082675368,
0.0036654926,
-0.0302707627,
0.0444338992,
0.026182808,
0.0393495634,
0.0169705972,
-0.0280455295,
0.006843918,
-0.0129581317,
0.0113885468,
0.001953441,
-0.0623327643,
0.0656083003,
-0.0079996316,
-0.0393847227,
-0.0526108779,
-0.0451422371,
0.0133128567,
-0.0167201981,
0.0199906193,
0.0032737623,
0.049219165,
-0.0091219051,
-0.0004784836,
0.0137835406,
-0.0066462546,
0.0304955989,
-0.0689157248,
-0.017407978,
0.0343782194,
-0.0055445009,
-0.0039427662,
-0.006481078,
0.0043888888,
-0.0278837308,
-0.0259295069,
0.0411940068,
0.016271783,
-0.0155855361,
-0.0122646671,
-0.0392038338,
-0.0035630129,
0.0249925721,
-0.041434437,
-0.0320621841,
-0.0166070946,
0.0307898838,
-0.0098815737,
0.0371094607,
-0.0262646601,
-0.0179277752,
-0.0019661086,
0.0515366942,
-0.0203018729,
-0.0530208945,
0.0357120708,
0.0603475235,
-0.0195428021,
-0.0173752122,
-0.0017707838,
-0.0240374058,
0.0063284356,
-0.0294736326,
-0.0266747605,
-0.0217115432,
-0.0278749559,
0.0089844465,
-0.0308408774,
0.0141584082,
0.0366239771,
-0.0726026669,
-0.0047203186,
-0.038342353,
0.0538270622,
-0.0004651389,
0.0471787862,
0.0203400608,
-0.0177786816,
0.0030028599,
0.0326943547,
0.0101881847,
0.0449407101,
-0.0073570199,
0.0734022334,
-0.0307763536,
-0.0176732931,
0.0324717127,
0.0210946929,
-0.0213273782,
-0.1169902533,
0.0087510422,
0.0039920518,
0.0404340886,
0.0136871645,
0.0304639079,
0.0183474272,
-0.0119528063,
-0.0158807728,
-0.0023707745,
0.0085458625,
-0.0162697807,
0.0817129984,
-0.0046065692,
-0.0105776871,
-0.0302272458,
0.0819903538,
-0.0206205957,
-0.0044934228,
0.0057099159,
-0.0344044007,
-0.0252878536,
-0.0474844687,
0.0205446221,
0.0013119358,
-0.0820557624,
0.0023754416,
-0.0830251947,
-0.0556619689,
-0.0129259862,
-0.0247131065,
-0.0207741112,
-0.0077648619,
0.028566923,
0.0607038364,
0.0207751747,
-0.0279101077,
-0.0556932166,
0.0496715754,
-0.0743019804,
0.0028331641,
0.0474230722,
-6.279559148e-33,
0.0190857444,
-0.0367414653,
0.0210348442,
-0.0572584905,
0.0072662341,
0.0081938384,
-0.0435742065,
0.0246389117,
-0.0324652269,
0.0354775675,
-0.0261344537,
0.0096538691,
0.0141499462,
0.029617263,
0.0260618217,
-0.0556251928,
0.0093616471,
0.0089807836,
-0.0226569716,
0.0487254262,
-0.0145031577,
0.011840404,
0.0380077139,
-0.0587213226,
0.0864257887,
-0.0426000394,
0.0255693626,
0.0422641151,
-0.013359597,
0.0607933924,
-0.0158703178,
0.0619035512,
0.0525907949,
-0.0225147121,
0.020859696,
0.0257225782,
-0.0491472892,
-0.0088738268,
0.0170921646,
-0.0021001957,
-0.0549531989,
-0.0470507666,
0.0250673685,
-0.0171605796,
-0.0591131821,
0.015888406,
-0.0018567458,
-0.0248441659,
0.0337774865,
-0.0226051211,
-0.0187223125,
0.014529149,
-0.0050824024,
0.0138521064,
-0.0278587528,
0.0867501572,
-0.0509362295,
0.0153283868,
-0.0437956937,
0.013910789,
0.0046491819,
0.0173158236,
0.0621469282,
-0.022509912,
-0.0320909917,
0.0208686236,
0.0083861789,
0.0103529189,
-0.0202299487,
0.0006759121,
-0.0437828116,
0.021935463,
0.0172823705,
0.0891224369,
-0.0362066738,
-0.0268596504,
-0.0961783081,
0.0546552874,
-0.0592593364,
0.068010956,
0.0169236101,
-0.0316017941,
-0.0398364104,
-0.026066957,
-0.0476350822,
0.0001613645,
-0.0486438386,
-0.0287234765,
0.032972753,
-0.0147836152,
0.0007817821,
-0.0138841374,
0.006492787,
-0.0191882029,
-0.0196513385,
-0.0009833601,
0.0196742397,
-0.0340067148,
0.0014063832,
0.0426612422,
-0.0721399859,
0.0428667851,
-0.0542247556,
0.0060966155,
0.0090288194,
0.0270539615,
-0.0181355588,
-0.0560264476,
-0.0378375612,
-0.0152325984,
0.0068271337,
0.0434243754,
-0.0170895644,
0.0389906801,
0.0264628232,
0.0145854298,
0.0117315818,
0.0838708952,
0.0225363355,
-0.0047342903,
-0.0601994656,
-0.0558643378,
-0.0101964893,
0.0282374769,
-0.0584577732,
0.0216321051,
-0.0484217443,
0.0437883846,
0.0218270477,
-0.0278238393,
-0.0073197088,
-0.0318674445,
2.756e-7,
0.0631953403,
0.0273247622,
-0.0191229098,
-0.0091031091,
0.0219034683,
0.0222921018,
-0.0032369851,
-0.0011517227,
-0.0090431497,
-0.0240103845,
0.0043344744,
-0.0118908174,
0.0554303341,
0.0516518541,
-0.0632458106,
-0.0121992445,
-0.0891348273,
0.0070583099,
-0.0261340067,
-0.0193313956,
0.0125320125,
0.0260672718,
-0.0771644562,
-0.0308335535,
-0.0303106401,
-0.0101922462,
0.0512764119,
-0.0485555753,
-0.0302116089,
0.0451440737,
0.024407493,
0.0083715348,
0.0497498773,
0.0351942889,
-0.0297316182,
-0.0154227447,
0.0251463652,
0.0819154903,
-0.0171537064,
0.0138362693,
0.0212367307,
-0.0168852862,
0.030623937,
-0.0990092158,
0.0448533632,
-0.0174750742,
-0.0474104993,
0.0022516688,
0.0195209365,
-0.0427661389,
0.0847000629,
-0.0480909906,
-0.058594726,
0.0260064341,
0.0490083694,
0.0326696225,
0.0116924411,
0.0034008191,
-0.0189346876,
0.0002158596,
-0.0061579123,
-0.0755815879,
0.0164521281,
-0.0003167741,
-0.0788034648,
-0.0355985314,
0.0327690989,
2.095674084e-34,
0.0146912877,
0.0320300683,
0.0208034329,
0.028682882,
0.0563318953,
0.0297211576,
0.0070671267,
0.0052838153,
0.0189813375,
-0.0353984721,
-0.0083848266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13127v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13127v1 | Auto-Instruct: Automatic Instruction Generation and Ranking for Black-Box Language Models | 2023-10-19T19:52:55 | 2023-10-19T19:52:55 | Zhihan Zhang, Shuohang Wang, Wenhao Yu, Yichong Xu, Dan Iter, Qingkai Zeng, Yang Liu, Chenguang Zhu, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can perform a wide range of tasks by following
natural language instructions, without the necessity of task-specific
fine-tuning. Unfortunately, the performance of LLMs is greatly influenced by
the quality of these instructions, and manually writing effective instructions
for each task is a laborious and subjective process. In this paper, we
introduce Auto-Instruct, a novel method to automatically improve the quality of
instructions provided to LLMs. Our method leverages the inherent generative
ability of LLMs to produce diverse candidate instructions for a given task, and
then ranks them using a scoring model trained on a variety of 575 existing NLP
tasks. In experiments on 118 out-of-domain tasks, Auto-Instruct surpasses both
human-written instructions and existing baselines of LLM-generated
instructions. Furthermore, our method exhibits notable generalizability even
with other LLMs that are not incorporated into its training process. | [
0.0427855216,
0.0302544702,
-0.0117295738,
0.0032582597,
-0.0284169447,
0.0282890927,
-0.0053263353,
-0.0118493624,
0.0277816709,
-0.0873273686,
-0.0366029777,
0.0020789821,
0.009812708,
0.0161939729,
0.0442707092,
-0.0501007698,
0.0079469671,
-0.0366857126,
-0.0243079811,
0.0089340769,
-0.0136605008,
0.0390252769,
-0.0062173912,
0.04685634,
0.0175500289,
-0.0110554518,
0.001695817,
0.0041305809,
0.0224666744,
-0.0373978838,
0.0297895838,
0.0747947171,
0.0056113466,
-0.0194301773,
0.0000021123,
-0.0255371239,
-0.0223423112,
-0.0209383648,
-0.0205070544,
0.0089318063,
0.0169746578,
-0.004896584,
-0.0124941561,
0.0423348323,
-0.0544681512,
-0.0049922359,
0.0092821456,
0.0409637876,
0.0934155881,
0.0970122442,
0.0067123114,
0.0023893202,
0.0196227431,
-0.0354510881,
0.0169770177,
-0.0366662666,
-0.0056691165,
0.0391620658,
0.0065440075,
0.0717673376,
0.002313057,
0.0205441862,
0.0340611078,
-0.0272001754,
0.0431744531,
0.0322676301,
-0.0176878069,
-0.0020126433,
-0.0315790288,
0.1115580574,
-0.0450568944,
-0.0078454316,
-0.0012677429,
-0.0020814466,
0.0062373546,
-0.0180368759,
-0.0474869832,
0.0212275628,
0.0265846029,
-0.0017232402,
0.0039396207,
-0.0033706583,
0.0242991485,
0.0091220001,
0.0462689362,
0.0659833848,
0.0279743969,
-0.0409916341,
-0.0012609942,
0.002402219,
-0.020371139,
-0.0783152282,
0.0070574675,
0.0375545956,
-0.0450591072,
0.0116347056,
-0.0344941281,
0.0085224686,
0.0112198014,
-0.0298707485,
0.1030496433,
0.0265287831,
-0.0222217515,
0.0532599762,
-0.0439330749,
0.0526874401,
0.0318792053,
0.0266390685,
-0.0392517559,
0.0294383485,
-0.074407272,
-0.0180724952,
-0.0144023569,
0.0138241351,
-0.0308683272,
-0.0243156608,
-0.0472598821,
-0.0070217587,
-0.0330068022,
-0.0036261971,
0.0657476559,
0.0327885114,
-0.0176758394,
-0.0393262096,
-0.0355356224,
-0.0312581137,
-0.0329068825,
0.0035903787,
-0.0140095558,
-0.0340073705,
-0.0065471334,
0.0158573035,
-0.0086371126,
-0.0023405664,
0.0321948938,
0.0697383657,
-0.0098772356,
-0.0153202992,
-0.0273106676,
0.0015757902,
0.0035879938,
-0.0502309911,
-0.0195074137,
-0.0618576705,
-0.0021161283,
0.0121944677,
0.0026638065,
-0.0216536131,
0.0345896259,
0.0316289999,
0.0051888619,
0.0719629526,
0.0116721382,
0.0134093529,
0.0357226394,
-0.0092097195,
-0.0023938389,
0.0441719182,
0.0147615029,
0.0252630692,
0.0078009227,
0.0100379651,
0.0359221362,
0.0432486199,
-0.014021663,
0.0046098945,
-0.0205324739,
0.0086444402,
0.0016221158,
0.0366981328,
0.0370579921,
0.0283188019,
-0.0013506787,
0.0186663345,
0.0517621785,
0.0195441172,
-0.0065802298,
-0.0106272977,
0.0866541117,
0.0117345871,
-0.0084038759,
0.0124826021,
-0.0662533417,
0.043537125,
-0.005752888,
-0.0254102703,
0.024489183,
0.0436032005,
-0.0087837093,
-0.0762334839,
-0.0101785017,
-0.0247011706,
0.0231459364,
0.0139267026,
0.018506214,
0.0514179468,
-0.0590319373,
0.0341984481,
0.0260047838,
-0.0216695257,
-0.0040809754,
-0.0481818728,
-0.0080169756,
0.1006622538,
0.0544324182,
-0.0171117447,
-0.0284161642,
-0.0117142871,
0.0190830119,
0.0468926281,
0.0332442969,
-0.0300862808,
-0.0073319632,
-0.0739284009,
-0.0418974943,
-0.0256906692,
0.0331425108,
0.0294993166,
0.0366268605,
-0.0446348265,
0.0367767438,
-0.0314286575,
-0.0887494013,
0.0444652252,
-0.0346071608,
-0.0904536843,
0.0161933731,
-0.0183088481,
-0.0125932321,
-0.0078797452,
0.0040747919,
0.0263362508,
0.0218709335,
-0.0470197387,
-0.0415811576,
-0.0336969793,
-0.0393293686,
-0.0252414942,
0.0205757394,
-0.031343095,
-0.0184351634,
0.0481688716,
-0.0598324053,
-0.0302197766,
-0.0039287023,
-0.0284476057,
0.0143460948,
-0.0120686619,
0.0411770903,
0.0398601741,
-0.0263340045,
-0.0606601015,
0.064395383,
-0.0170106329,
0.0326373279,
0.0495467819,
0.0101023261,
-0.0212603938,
-0.0218507778,
0.0253071301,
-0.0216580741,
-0.0140167726,
0.0102735069,
0.0388916098,
0.0600589812,
-0.0404154994,
-0.0249022152,
-0.0909909755,
0.0243900549,
-0.0319424644,
-0.0029431421,
0.0386063941,
0.022474274,
-0.0005492364,
-0.0300308652,
-0.0406765305,
-0.0256076343,
0.0103197591,
-0.0027808978,
0.0350360125,
-0.0105053438,
-0.0064653503,
-0.0469743647,
-0.005981944,
0.0013705132,
0.0083176522,
0.0135722468,
0.0549635813,
-0.0796313956,
0.0683215037,
-0.0126386127,
0.0122863716,
0.0101426514,
-0.0690296367,
0.0102792205,
-0.0207180213,
0.0474450104,
0.10459584,
0.0182597227,
0.0432618223,
0.0589880086,
0.0174071286,
-0.0903175101,
0.0094470875,
-0.0174414758,
-0.0158239976,
-0.0173975024,
-0.0626459867,
-0.0041795205,
0.0791853145,
0.0092830742,
0.0060456325,
-0.0588610247,
0.0189760588,
-0.034439031,
-0.0167869758,
-0.0303060878,
0.0014832156,
-0.0158983637,
0.0098175397,
-0.0343358442,
-0.064632155,
0.046377968,
-0.0302008968,
0.0057184547,
-0.0513137393,
-0.020084573,
-0.0543561503,
0.0461662151,
0.0245308261,
0.0184686445,
-0.0006350517,
-0.0230313335,
-0.0485637635,
0.0204965193,
0.01924254,
-0.0256114788,
0.0135461716,
-0.0515662208,
-0.0053995149,
0.0190097354,
-0.0355167091,
-0.0542221889,
-0.0091267293,
-0.0116323847,
0.0155226644,
0.0305113941,
-0.0012335656,
-0.0098415688,
-0.0164333768,
0.0276522096,
0.0440123938,
-0.0422734953,
-0.0185294542,
-0.0349064283,
-0.0039960868,
0.0572403781,
-0.0165439211,
-0.0174533892,
-0.0117573235,
-0.0049370015,
0.0109160682,
0.0255291965,
0.0194868203,
-0.0176384114,
0.0057105953,
0.042065952,
-0.0477565452,
-0.0322709568,
0.0361666121,
0.0461861081,
-0.0626646206,
-0.0167340487,
0.1524827927,
0.0554975383,
-0.0143306041,
0.0111692045,
0.0045302249,
0.0079329591,
0.03336576,
0.028566042,
-0.0623202249,
-0.042591814,
0.0074943788,
0.030194629,
-0.0082290387,
-0.0036575596,
-0.0153674753,
-0.1599341035,
0.0331237502,
0.0178961474,
0.011818896,
-0.0176415592,
-0.0480925851,
-0.0093248347,
-0.0157897715,
0.0080460235,
0.0068556978,
-0.0331610739,
0.0099286661,
0.0312465243,
-0.0237568971,
-0.0766013637,
0.0394650474,
-0.0270032361,
0.0673800856,
0.0997135043,
0.0196281318,
0.0194214601,
-0.0061131013,
0.0247271154,
0.0186857972,
0.0088954782,
-0.0208598897,
0.0543350317,
-0.0160582308,
-0.0038636227,
0.0060269311,
0.0217176098,
-0.0509970039,
0.0214258563,
-0.0179664604,
0.0428076312,
-0.0177375823,
-0.0110424776,
-0.0061101224,
-0.0004504071,
0.0216195732,
0.0807401985,
0.0136383018,
-0.036963433,
-0.0246295948,
-0.0755249783,
0.0111125838,
-0.0933054984,
-0.0480989926,
0.0209551845,
-0.0243067369,
-0.0133457808,
-0.1023716182,
-0.047659561,
0.0646161512,
0.024010295,
0.0373210311,
-0.0062038377,
0.0128178522,
-0.014931405,
-0.0236039497,
0.0235847738,
-0.0121717677,
0.0037990927,
-0.0792943537,
-0.0725300461,
0.0656076223,
-0.0093613695,
-0.0292464495,
0.0046589086,
-0.0224746633,
-0.056257356,
-0.0087855319,
0.0956894606,
0.017997073,
0.0329181477,
-0.0204188395,
-0.0788382739,
0.0036746198,
0.0144754685,
-0.0458172113,
-0.0311597269,
0.0106242467,
-0.0034766162,
-0.0015874379,
0.0387235396,
-0.0602481291,
0.0663214028,
-0.002920398,
0.0475123785,
-0.0177994482,
-0.0335431658,
0.0454688631,
-0.0025296065,
0.0159237087,
-0.0452156812,
0.0111003499,
-0.0320398733,
0.0131393354,
-0.0258785766,
-0.045462992,
-0.051240202,
0.0727235004,
0.0331336111,
0.0221197903,
0.0033209573,
0.0149368793,
-0.0261312723,
0.0220768452,
-0.0427837148,
0.0045066234,
0.0227346886,
-0.0011489275,
0.0179122239,
-0.0140843578,
-0.0209031682,
0.0297114886,
0.008676419,
0.0347180218,
-0.0186325852,
0.0359604396,
-0.003276557,
0.0078015067,
-0.0262887552,
0.0529392846,
-0.0401868485,
-0.0418395884,
-0.0445561744,
0.0279797446,
0.0830700919,
-0.0170946065,
0.0606648326,
-0.0209979955,
-0.0137035521,
-0.0065990593,
0.0162229519,
0.0152444858,
-0.0067603095,
-0.0014552197,
0.0538224652,
-0.0030878116,
0.00802314,
0.0789095834,
0.0265913066,
0.0376632586,
0.015170658,
0.0000428032,
-0.0528210998,
-0.0087590134,
0.0163679607,
0.0026002419,
-0.0018481177,
0.0517590083,
-0.0131372828,
-0.0622415505,
-0.0159937441,
0.0199315436,
-0.0089773005,
-0.0381053351,
0.059241835,
0.0452479497,
-0.028838275,
-0.0156140439,
-0.071190387,
-0.0308980234,
-0.0161438491,
-0.0438466407,
-0.0397283398,
-6.487343203e-33,
-0.0443518907,
-0.0633885935,
0.0040368838,
-0.0332895555,
0.0342937969,
-0.0084382193,
-0.01641698,
-0.0121863578,
0.0397936329,
0.0320056714,
-0.001058085,
-0.0040358035,
0.0147967404,
0.0335262902,
0.0471701548,
-0.0047807111,
0.0588383935,
-0.0116927102,
-0.0384233892,
0.0281813331,
0.0080829868,
0.0263551679,
0.0216694344,
-0.0427452363,
0.0355569459,
0.0112627763,
-0.024966592,
0.0114241047,
0.0063550994,
0.0635227934,
-0.00655154,
0.0152738057,
0.0273116715,
-0.0659430325,
-0.0131233577,
0.0231212582,
-0.0431060307,
-0.0130477995,
0.0205463003,
-0.0228210967,
-0.0434066989,
-0.0349801369,
0.0215807725,
-0.0278887618,
-0.0364871062,
0.0032144184,
0.0445357226,
-0.0286679789,
-0.0017928027,
-0.0058344766,
-0.0731596127,
0.0233122353,
-0.016578747,
-0.0878865048,
-0.0061088204,
0.032305751,
-0.0159285124,
-0.0153772263,
-0.0122558642,
0.0334048718,
0.0058647618,
0.0722104758,
0.0669736639,
0.0126853688,
-0.0197249297,
0.0343522877,
-0.0186791737,
0.0033986447,
0.0068768244,
-0.0223441347,
-0.0028350633,
0.0543641187,
0.0388890803,
-0.002410097,
0.0191862769,
0.0293779969,
-0.0297465175,
0.061099451,
0.0171862375,
0.0085112359,
0.0067583313,
-0.0028136719,
-0.0431972705,
-0.0127710802,
-0.0241371207,
-0.0176637135,
-0.0140805794,
-0.0313910656,
0.0456917882,
0.0402575135,
-0.042835772,
-0.0265683029,
0.0017358941,
-0.0139033105,
-0.022822218,
0.008821249,
-0.0049728011,
0.0204049163,
0.0203534309,
0.0256106723,
-0.0488515683,
-0.0136056216,
0.0298584756,
0.0072029205,
0.022923138,
0.0202195253,
0.0134052671,
0.0018525987,
-0.0729726031,
0.0093062939,
-0.0253118128,
0.0249540843,
-0.024340339,
0.0406497344,
-0.007224347,
0.0058632428,
-0.0217532869,
0.0601498224,
0.0002288654,
-0.0224693865,
-0.0303438213,
-0.0094401659,
0.0183770917,
0.0111303097,
-0.0402240194,
0.0207468756,
-0.0335352495,
-0.0101025524,
0.0101956865,
-0.0160701219,
-0.0266938377,
-0.0059371581,
2.731e-7,
0.0412804782,
0.0698383972,
-0.0122080036,
0.0591926873,
-0.0032873843,
0.0423058681,
-0.0214092731,
0.0240611006,
0.0264459383,
-0.0321125947,
-0.0152818235,
0.026403252,
0.0538144596,
-0.0129948063,
-0.0884405375,
-0.0174391158,
-0.0340334475,
0.0047253659,
-0.0444529988,
-0.0311667006,
0.0294726808,
0.0763672441,
-0.0393823311,
0.0082224132,
-0.0215032771,
-0.0317052715,
0.0546809174,
-0.0176793486,
-0.0164626166,
0.0263159852,
0.0212693792,
0.0406708829,
-0.0279869568,
-0.0044476534,
-0.0403641984,
-0.0019082284,
0.0315055698,
0.1065004468,
-0.0219805147,
-0.0385660119,
-0.0079797162,
0.000617922,
0.0169440154,
-0.034647245,
0.0588466786,
-0.05389468,
-0.0073583093,
-0.0229951218,
-0.0185459051,
0.0144094797,
0.0232985541,
-0.0386292376,
-0.0345679484,
0.0251821894,
0.0314113237,
-0.0210010838,
-0.0362071097,
-0.070340924,
-0.032319434,
0.0267107412,
-0.0077362377,
-0.0352450609,
-0.0235692766,
0.002632542,
-0.0125915948,
-0.0507577509,
0.0038322215,
2.700278583e-34,
0.0376415364,
0.003315279,
0.0435115546,
0.036910478,
0.0303694215,
0.011817595,
-0.0547800064,
0.0208112616,
0.0226670951,
-0.0692374408,
-0.0147339422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13106v1 | Unsupervised Candidate Answer Extraction through Differentiable Masker-Reconstructor Model | 2023-10-19T19:07:08 | 2023-10-19T19:07:08 | Zhuoer Wang, Yicheng Wang, Ziwei Zhu, James Caverlee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question generation is a widely used data augmentation approach with
extensive applications, and extracting qualified candidate answers from context
passages is a critical step for most question generation systems. However,
existing methods for candidate answer extraction are reliant on linguistic
rules or annotated data that face the partial annotation issue and challenges
in generalization. To overcome these limitations, we propose a novel
unsupervised candidate answer extraction approach that leverages the inherent
structure of context passages through a Differentiable Masker-Reconstructor
(DMR) Model with the enforcement of self-consistency for picking up salient
information tokens. We curated two datasets with exhaustively-annotated answers
and benchmark a comprehensive set of supervised and unsupervised candidate
answer extraction methods. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the DMR model by
showing its performance is superior among unsupervised methods and comparable
to supervised methods. | [
0.0317313671,
0.0601413585,
-0.0095339613,
0.0632850081,
-0.0386051238,
0.0207135025,
0.0201191716,
-0.0201444589,
0.0035968309,
-0.0371150114,
0.0651669055,
-0.0241941083,
-0.0356950648,
0.0329272971,
0.0027653144,
-0.0232752766,
0.0012453927,
-0.0128359869,
-0.0038312916,
0.0094668502,
0.0209021736,
0.0180462189,
-0.0182122383,
-0.0101485969,
-0.0029594267,
-0.0213496517,
-0.0222245883,
-0.0267460141,
0.0291317683,
-0.0351614654,
0.0549071617,
0.0271191187,
0.0236300454,
0.0267258007,
0.0000019147,
-0.0548587628,
-0.0484485961,
0.0013594242,
-0.0506421886,
-0.0383403711,
-0.0087372661,
-0.0021172587,
0.0377268344,
0.0119607905,
-0.075140208,
-0.0065447097,
0.0188096575,
0.0248684455,
0.0860086679,
0.0448029414,
0.0029111984,
-0.0262763407,
0.0103271026,
-0.0077632442,
0.0420658849,
-0.0030320599,
0.0284821298,
0.0087234564,
0.0032810557,
0.0204748958,
-0.0113991471,
0.0361851379,
0.0353546068,
-0.0228659306,
0.042898953,
0.0213315524,
-0.0023343076,
0.0035042663,
-0.0078060962,
0.1063864902,
0.0075313044,
0.006081915,
0.0328506716,
-0.0217072573,
0.0118984161,
0.022765439,
-0.0320660323,
0.0235915538,
-0.0364520252,
-0.0177007262,
0.0220604055,
0.0216794834,
-0.0198011156,
-0.0116835106,
-0.0488186143,
0.0685496032,
0.0009342837,
-0.0168885794,
-0.0435374528,
0.0089551574,
-0.0166325811,
-0.0695725754,
0.0224568471,
0.0728309304,
0.007956095,
0.0082216738,
-0.0384929143,
-0.0547972955,
0.0017895935,
0.009996471,
-0.0228260495,
-0.0061502843,
-0.0237004347,
0.0310346913,
-0.0243142825,
0.0253434554,
-0.0336601883,
0.0180578921,
-0.0570936762,
-0.0298245829,
-0.0223159157,
-0.0251988992,
-0.020424189,
0.0746976063,
-0.0834598914,
-0.0033402371,
-0.0229562707,
0.0389074832,
0.000352604,
0.0159344431,
-0.0128575331,
0.0202150103,
-0.0536138304,
0.0104511287,
-0.0164846536,
-0.0221049413,
-0.055682499,
0.0001981922,
0.064667955,
-0.0618894324,
0.0073869182,
0.0273425039,
0.0746835843,
-0.032755211,
-0.0023270929,
0.0294420328,
-0.0143627338,
-0.0044336859,
-0.0010302346,
-0.0563388914,
-0.0156525895,
-0.0326060615,
-0.0003358908,
-0.065198116,
0.0731194839,
0.0204565432,
-0.0638502538,
-0.0054059192,
0.0282821786,
0.0408656523,
0.0297571421,
0.0474248827,
0.0050691958,
-0.0316071957,
0.0814668387,
0.0144868065,
0.0022451705,
0.0245647635,
0.031848412,
0.0158347655,
0.0606996082,
0.0005314848,
0.0401957259,
-0.0015104568,
0.0244260021,
-0.0194560792,
0.0227656476,
0.0605904348,
0.0008874796,
0.0020301871,
0.0033342405,
0.0401570871,
-0.0164270531,
-0.0507179759,
0.0225805137,
0.0103796246,
0.0162245966,
-0.0042876564,
0.0359589681,
0.0412439108,
0.003690005,
0.0629420951,
-0.0089759454,
0.0428759344,
0.005265214,
0.0290131606,
0.0120504098,
0.0240344461,
-0.0092012286,
-0.0327681191,
0.0269888025,
0.0174345449,
0.013356369,
0.0531406216,
0.0118620126,
0.0296040867,
-0.0175009109,
0.0088170003,
-0.0144473026,
-0.0441208556,
0.0256614704,
-0.0079873642,
0.0579871424,
-0.0159309879,
0.0213214755,
-0.0495501868,
-0.036627613,
-0.0317248031,
-0.0167236477,
0.0348262489,
0.0233980026,
-0.0295350775,
0.0191937853,
-0.0463878028,
-0.0239750929,
-0.0390071198,
-0.0158791095,
0.0115807876,
0.0123451194,
0.005495239,
0.0472858846,
-0.0255536102,
0.0150783323,
0.0681028068,
-0.0038963414,
-0.0635340437,
0.023948811,
-0.0073797056,
0.0194949117,
0.0194731355,
-0.0026893818,
-0.0066241664,
0.0344236009,
-0.066557996,
-0.0120280674,
-0.0136594092,
-0.0902494416,
-0.0742803589,
0.0206799563,
-0.0460282676,
-0.01996601,
0.0497825481,
-0.0485241078,
-0.0451188162,
-0.0340169705,
-0.0274428669,
-0.0096153673,
-0.0578399263,
-0.0412534587,
0.0485202782,
0.0281166825,
-0.0707514063,
0.0780299678,
0.0212099608,
-0.0000609053,
0.0310859419,
0.0247204229,
0.0165889673,
-0.042335663,
-0.0125050088,
-0.0108897761,
-0.0525128804,
-0.0091918316,
0.0508743413,
-0.0005544216,
-0.0560576133,
-0.0311535951,
-0.0512248352,
0.0317688771,
-0.0316151679,
0.0201276019,
0.04923103,
0.0554690436,
-0.0128782932,
-0.0316840932,
-0.0968060493,
-0.0585955307,
0.0122939479,
0.0093456134,
0.0725598931,
0.0201790147,
0.026660407,
-0.0451467074,
0.005335561,
-0.0015647014,
0.0156511273,
0.0510764681,
-0.0057055652,
-0.044639077,
0.0062842537,
-0.0223449636,
0.0360521264,
0.0217798147,
0.0133254975,
-0.0018629808,
-0.0261457097,
0.0293587316,
0.0608894303,
0.0308056641,
0.0150648039,
-0.0263819676,
0.0042113648,
-0.0788582414,
0.0337824635,
-0.0606678724,
0.0458867252,
0.0295036286,
-0.02572296,
0.0370082445,
0.0478997454,
0.0458293185,
-0.0259480271,
-0.0046661757,
0.05437015,
-0.0134613812,
0.0044326629,
-0.0774548724,
0.0169805139,
-0.0297903698,
0.0532266013,
-0.0045558466,
-0.0247137286,
0.0773851424,
-0.0267697703,
-0.0207613707,
-0.0415138975,
-0.0055539981,
-0.0757911131,
0.0274502542,
0.0326209143,
-0.0023292126,
0.017837394,
-0.0112072118,
-0.0560825355,
0.0242603086,
0.0183695443,
-0.050570894,
0.0190322064,
-0.0446656421,
0.0038264983,
-0.0279731918,
-0.0318564288,
-0.0841472819,
-0.074409239,
0.0252218433,
-0.0148133626,
0.0279575679,
-0.0083539663,
0.0225491878,
0.0054307613,
0.0148317674,
0.0600774065,
-0.0329618789,
-0.0089649195,
-0.0470453426,
0.1185432076,
0.0925171301,
0.0534864664,
0.040133357,
-0.0295809377,
0.0356674604,
0.0564144515,
0.0220346451,
0.0449886546,
0.008440651,
-0.0072201993,
0.0173611119,
-0.047380846,
0.0419497229,
0.0064621153,
0.0853371769,
-0.0540755279,
-0.0423631556,
0.0607344843,
0.0254456215,
0.0160321556,
-0.0158291832,
0.0160708651,
0.0171663594,
0.0053196508,
0.0312604606,
-0.095177114,
-0.0106204506,
-0.0431489535,
0.0268465094,
-0.0259259734,
-0.0403766111,
0.0088308044,
-0.1053156331,
0.0312016346,
-0.0240208674,
-0.0849003717,
0.0083236871,
-0.0082056094,
-0.0064795334,
0.0147090713,
-0.0239620227,
0.0178286787,
0.0074706967,
0.0010462365,
0.0126659684,
-0.0283063743,
-0.0050215041,
-0.0066501279,
-0.018865237,
-0.0187392011,
0.0509850942,
-0.0097264647,
0.014708912,
-0.0124237724,
0.0178940259,
-0.1125904545,
-0.031971246,
0.0259087514,
0.0321562141,
-0.0295113064,
-0.0129720764,
-0.0384024344,
0.0854495466,
-0.0275455173,
0.0043528378,
0.0558930449,
0.0492954031,
0.0038947701,
0.0249084756,
-0.0405589454,
0.0267740134,
0.0203643739,
0.0632230267,
0.0391668938,
-0.0418689921,
-0.0243783053,
-0.0320064686,
0.0394886918,
-0.0980267227,
0.012337897,
0.015796043,
0.0145132691,
0.0797241107,
-0.0999871567,
-0.0569062158,
0.0178515464,
0.0103910416,
-0.0165305696,
0.0064644949,
-0.0170996338,
-0.0323093161,
-0.0412166864,
0.0069991518,
-0.0111069018,
-0.0165072568,
0.0002041684,
-0.043976862,
-0.0314788744,
-0.0536014289,
-0.0387798138,
0.0069447407,
-0.0837224498,
-0.0212079138,
0.0303000472,
0.0317099988,
0.0174757149,
0.0475618429,
-0.0062904013,
-0.0075225211,
0.0431082882,
0.011213664,
-0.0262410883,
-0.0167891774,
-0.0371528715,
0.0101133818,
0.0001777962,
-0.0100427,
-0.0448966585,
0.0232966468,
0.0165657718,
0.027997354,
-0.0049881181,
-0.0213050656,
0.0420631394,
0.0112008378,
0.0032046123,
0.0407819301,
0.009483167,
-0.032998547,
0.0192613658,
-0.0160550773,
-0.0404988229,
-0.0366141163,
0.0316874534,
-0.0010201081,
-0.0463960804,
0.0169408731,
-0.0019727971,
-0.0100462046,
0.0751386061,
-0.0435085595,
0.0065517137,
0.025720587,
0.006426583,
-0.0084368894,
0.0034758134,
-0.0249461439,
0.0044881208,
0.0126306033,
0.09234377,
0.0313673615,
0.0814938992,
0.0009673599,
-0.0444937795,
0.0235221349,
0.0031367594,
-0.0874458477,
0.0174958315,
-0.0510622375,
0.0252769515,
-0.0056698518,
-0.0256413203,
-0.0207935032,
0.017836282,
0.001607449,
-0.0145004932,
0.0356322266,
0.0178515818,
-0.0011082146,
0.0237783566,
0.0248340163,
-0.0216855183,
0.0240041725,
0.0328900851,
0.0011084724,
0.0066953111,
0.0314579122,
0.0382019244,
-0.0803140923,
0.0257864986,
0.0007181506,
0.0749916807,
0.0160064381,
-0.005504088,
-0.028443573,
0.0039396794,
0.0160841495,
0.0244241562,
0.015766643,
0.0278761256,
0.0110546658,
0.0302815735,
-0.0149309738,
-0.0655063465,
-0.0876504108,
0.0701627359,
-0.0311482437,
-0.0242615882,
-0.0115530426,
-6.583094564e-33,
-0.0216099862,
-0.0518774576,
0.0144366156,
0.0016555939,
-0.021095613,
-0.0030270207,
-0.0070638023,
-0.0337515436,
0.0039436258,
-0.0235583019,
0.0056278105,
-0.0141345793,
0.0037565366,
0.0711724758,
-0.0219779219,
-0.0360051356,
0.0112780938,
0.0157576744,
-0.0357426219,
0.0408440344,
0.0463909879,
0.0320594274,
0.00917478,
-0.0469985679,
0.0244243909,
-0.0732890964,
0.0123914378,
0.0288448688,
0.0059258142,
0.0643476173,
-0.0260782875,
0.0021210522,
0.0310104731,
-0.0429273248,
-0.0037148604,
0.0461393259,
-0.0791949183,
-0.0135046495,
-0.0568208732,
-0.0122287646,
-0.0792505369,
-0.0263687242,
0.0325776488,
-0.0402851067,
0.0552677773,
-0.0204957575,
0.03737491,
-0.0067527522,
0.004183677,
-0.0158682987,
-0.0491658114,
0.0238043442,
-0.0097685792,
-0.010128065,
0.0033464087,
0.0866053924,
0.038778659,
0.0163095053,
-0.0640166029,
-0.0130450195,
0.0364213958,
0.0276391767,
0.0333650485,
0.0182130989,
-0.0135743748,
0.0567657277,
0.0490610935,
-0.0258811116,
0.0056245481,
-0.0258375313,
-0.0442082435,
0.0392045528,
0.0436516702,
0.0512312651,
0.0510825627,
0.051263798,
-0.068862766,
0.0635240078,
-0.0275951196,
-0.0185825787,
-0.0003828986,
-0.0236694347,
-0.0214654412,
0.0143918935,
-0.0136995539,
0.0057292832,
-0.0243824329,
-0.0003339929,
0.0464294702,
0.0180647392,
-0.0838930085,
0.0299579613,
0.0404341556,
-0.035235621,
0.0154036907,
-0.0313767083,
-0.0097138351,
0.0033855599,
0.0165441427,
0.0089572985,
-0.0342719853,
0.0259621553,
0.0130510395,
-0.0063889865,
-0.0001504055,
0.0231955554,
-0.0019345549,
-0.0219908692,
-0.0561107509,
-0.0038995421,
-0.0382740125,
0.0288052186,
-0.0592131428,
0.0287830234,
0.0018178261,
0.0140508432,
-0.0252087582,
0.0512464941,
0.0111914957,
0.0188094676,
-0.0325732268,
-0.0250814538,
-0.0027846687,
0.0185102709,
-0.0086655617,
-0.0034208121,
0.014483762,
0.0375953093,
0.0089649204,
-0.0357119776,
0.0289782509,
0.0079346448,
2.499e-7,
0.0387157388,
-0.0018209958,
0.0638331175,
0.0021076254,
0.0099671315,
0.0246079937,
0.0348265581,
0.0304597784,
0.022279378,
-0.029788468,
-0.0249376763,
-0.0196502116,
0.0290800296,
0.0185531583,
-0.0651047081,
-0.0022199827,
-0.0395676345,
-0.0425524861,
-0.0262118503,
-0.011306419,
0.0772655308,
0.0617582686,
-0.0137206009,
0.0051100394,
-0.0226743165,
0.0097896336,
0.0325738043,
0.0083383033,
-0.0209763926,
0.0480981544,
0.0310180485,
-0.0051495493,
0.0041401293,
0.0166546814,
-0.0139455236,
0.0237920675,
0.0226191524,
0.0493763462,
0.0508075655,
-0.0437239446,
-0.0280849226,
0.0252478663,
0.0293615162,
-0.0716653392,
0.0555824898,
-0.0742785931,
-0.007285431,
-0.043005757,
-0.0814465284,
-0.0083164731,
0.0074005555,
0.0081683742,
-0.0206790343,
0.0372297242,
0.0054408573,
-0.0105403801,
-0.0177354775,
-0.038148351,
-0.0127328178,
-0.0076693366,
-0.0303199161,
-0.0108899632,
-0.0357747823,
-0.0138797015,
-0.0251907296,
-0.0645107329,
-0.0184491277,
2.317332829e-34,
-0.0205520857,
-0.0006438321,
-0.028607836,
0.0200321693,
0.0237804987,
-0.0165322777,
-0.0080838883,
0.0167042278,
0.0009833234,
-0.0674412027,
-0.0061753648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13099v1 | No offence, Bert -- I insult only humans! Multiple addressees sentence-level attack on toxicity detection neural network | 2023-10-19T18:56:50 | 2023-10-19T18:56:50 | Sergey Berezin, Reza Farahbakhsh, Noel Crespi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce a simple yet efficient sentence-level attack on black-box
toxicity detector models. By adding several positive words or sentences to the
end of a hateful message, we are able to change the prediction of a neural
network and pass the toxicity detection system check. This approach is shown to
be working on seven languages from three different language families. We also
describe the defence mechanism against the aforementioned attack and discuss
its limitations. | [
0.0460414663,
0.0466509759,
-0.0237133075,
0.0322825834,
0.0074695428,
0.0300281029,
0.0246311445,
0.0053058863,
0.0282545388,
-0.0326126255,
-0.0228660833,
0.0362610631,
-0.011342016,
0.0030200891,
0.048394151,
-0.0158519391,
0.0435527787,
0.0403300971,
0.0086801304,
-0.0227314625,
0.0270775128,
-0.0011226167,
0.0182255879,
0.032722801,
-0.0424773581,
0.0003902238,
0.008967448,
0.0416908078,
0.04116638,
-0.0315827653,
0.0186715331,
-0.0077962154,
-0.0058960472,
0.069671914,
0.0000016427,
-0.0131219802,
0.0067614461,
0.0235745832,
-0.0132825952,
-0.0031731087,
0.0505211279,
-0.0037488269,
-0.0448740236,
0.0345370695,
-0.0195025448,
0.0314031728,
0.0639151707,
0.0412800722,
0.1120549142,
0.0861211121,
-0.0144096958,
-0.0180023052,
0.0430779532,
0.0045761433,
0.014664107,
0.0130801732,
0.0622974597,
-0.0585063323,
-0.0292834416,
-0.0250926334,
-0.00492138,
0.0266133081,
0.0163845234,
0.0027526729,
-0.0190527812,
-0.0058214846,
-0.014937425,
-0.0258492585,
-0.0040603182,
0.0470054746,
-0.0555146262,
0.0148034021,
-0.0313818492,
0.0395505317,
0.0153720425,
-0.0596570671,
0.0168565344,
-0.0055783861,
0.007863218,
-0.0038373119,
-0.0213304125,
0.0008607242,
0.0221048091,
0.0308531374,
0.0073391059,
0.0623125136,
0.0307374131,
-0.0631567091,
0.0304781348,
-0.0081616389,
-0.0087129194,
-0.0054086572,
0.0262613781,
-0.010618466,
0.0195923243,
0.0195308868,
-0.0446401313,
-0.0792168975,
0.0216715932,
-0.1561709791,
0.0391203202,
0.0025668999,
-0.0856635273,
-0.0120918201,
-0.0007176863,
-0.0061020465,
-0.0199000593,
0.0218658149,
-0.0017717392,
0.0278727226,
0.0137226805,
-0.016477352,
-0.0380040295,
0.0188162904,
0.0129047027,
0.0471086912,
-0.0521873273,
0.0408422276,
-0.0668376908,
-0.0044713113,
-0.0097535476,
0.0300273784,
-0.000492654,
0.0320269875,
0.0196467377,
-0.0185784604,
-0.039737653,
-0.0310344547,
-0.0546961389,
-0.0623220988,
0.0064074583,
0.0149950003,
-0.0592732653,
-0.0471932702,
0.0353064723,
0.1099373996,
0.0319430754,
-0.020982828,
-0.025679851,
-0.0275430176,
-0.0580685288,
-0.028235469,
0.0165007859,
-0.0131254215,
-0.0199606065,
-0.0324507169,
-0.0453533828,
-0.0781836584,
0.0188545082,
-0.0027048616,
-0.0683551803,
0.0544684269,
-0.019642774,
-0.0490558557,
0.0422917753,
0.0152259581,
0.0044132387,
0.0418146737,
0.0263126958,
0.0112460237,
0.0326953828,
0.0295445025,
-0.0358884856,
0.0368846431,
0.0469914265,
0.0235210098,
-0.0484094955,
-0.0117013315,
-0.0412863791,
-0.011271229,
-0.0302981194,
0.0761212707,
-0.0093194311,
-0.0712093636,
0.0768148005,
0.0201431792,
-0.0724542588,
0.0581840314,
0.0403866693,
0.0113011915,
-0.027062729,
0.0022375982,
-0.052967675,
-0.0142096253,
-0.0691991672,
-0.0514725596,
0.020452993,
0.0274046678,
-0.006499507,
-0.0405135676,
0.0084049162,
0.0012107893,
0.0597796999,
-0.0505895093,
0.0316539593,
0.0226917081,
-0.0314931311,
0.031027291,
0.0357282273,
-0.0458398834,
-0.0017540029,
-0.0108970255,
-0.0129457004,
0.0689179674,
0.0418101326,
-0.0173828937,
-0.0204745959,
-0.0510060228,
-0.0535617284,
0.0495872237,
-0.0149765015,
0.0195952803,
0.0167681724,
-0.0080206348,
0.0184439979,
0.0287398566,
0.0083116572,
0.0181592014,
-0.0171482377,
0.0320779383,
-0.0314495191,
0.0149900159,
-0.0457936227,
0.0215603299,
0.0379406884,
-0.0517954752,
0.0009899335,
0.0363614485,
0.0329593457,
0.0282749906,
-0.0566783585,
-0.0142953387,
0.0350595266,
-0.0264083594,
-0.0357282981,
0.0017779933,
-0.0109995594,
-0.0295766219,
0.0073089697,
-0.0359122939,
0.0010667297,
0.1080273613,
-0.004715343,
0.016453648,
0.0480835922,
-0.0751342773,
0.0127844466,
-0.0112018576,
-0.0081859417,
-0.0334382132,
0.0437371358,
-0.0104227802,
0.0110470736,
-0.0245803576,
-0.0168995466,
-0.0133456374,
-0.0161211696,
0.0087491879,
-0.0275386684,
-0.1144365147,
-0.0305417031,
-0.0192557946,
0.0080306511,
0.0003816435,
0.0146587212,
0.0058276723,
0.0114421286,
-0.0685045421,
-0.0209966712,
0.0035505889,
0.0044652144,
0.0118578793,
-0.0102940202,
0.013184539,
0.0036495407,
-0.0029650703,
-0.0335399881,
0.0004373879,
0.0292110089,
0.0104356203,
-0.0264792014,
-0.0387338549,
-0.0060587856,
-0.0331731848,
-0.0575326681,
0.0622598641,
-0.0000217627,
-0.0783376023,
-0.0023848058,
-0.0320763886,
-0.0302919261,
0.0435126796,
0.0210409444,
-0.1042801812,
0.0369419605,
0.0259681046,
-0.0181626584,
0.0986918136,
0.05063501,
0.0819333494,
0.0141594717,
0.0299059823,
-0.0003583846,
0.0409837514,
0.0026269138,
0.0193794165,
-0.0263226517,
-0.0486270785,
-0.0199598651,
0.0629360527,
0.0181643013,
-0.0310629047,
-0.0249943901,
0.0645051822,
-0.027268583,
-0.0391004197,
-0.0240050908,
-0.0901419893,
-0.0170171093,
-0.0463532545,
0.013054437,
-0.0456643179,
0.079717502,
-0.0268514585,
-0.0154806711,
-0.009956819,
-0.0118196122,
0.0637551844,
0.0353372544,
-0.007434913,
0.0329936519,
0.0337739699,
0.0082781352,
0.0084006591,
-0.051444754,
0.0234154444,
0.0101456176,
-0.0152779371,
-0.0213518348,
-0.0191934742,
0.0286192652,
-0.0799019262,
-0.0526896566,
-0.0336458907,
-0.0327397324,
-0.0079736905,
0.0169542991,
-0.014312244,
-0.0530657992,
-0.0015728786,
0.0056664138,
-0.0490986519,
-0.0363550037,
-0.0035726712,
-0.0013619012,
0.001282437,
-0.007422545,
-0.0455092937,
0.0468518585,
-0.0092626,
0.0099729905,
0.0604095608,
-0.0448459722,
0.0121397739,
-0.0150281386,
0.003401116,
-0.0126754502,
0.0101444907,
0.0194364935,
-0.0192059726,
-0.0016471202,
-0.0122562088,
-0.0301615782,
0.0511210635,
-0.0041562035,
-0.0060634678,
0.0361849144,
-0.0053051235,
0.0257376693,
-0.0104486849,
0.0344849117,
-0.0785819218,
-0.0048421556,
-0.0010233186,
0.0281068683,
-0.0693073794,
-0.0136380354,
-0.0099926917,
-0.0802504346,
-0.0090250196,
0.017158363,
-0.0273467787,
-0.0213236157,
0.030724721,
-0.0269077737,
-0.0016734083,
0.0506131202,
0.0005348884,
0.0382245742,
-0.0390882529,
0.0010408165,
-0.0122852186,
-0.0040546353,
0.006618679,
-0.0127755525,
0.0541087575,
0.0604879223,
0.0431407988,
-0.0757000446,
-0.0049860957,
0.0314122625,
-0.008343447,
-0.0262632091,
0.0010043341,
0.0658606887,
-0.0263253581,
-0.0306665916,
-0.0172676556,
0.022820672,
0.013236763,
0.0416394807,
0.0088612344,
0.0316527821,
0.0081210369,
-0.0202622563,
-0.0534396432,
0.0505581051,
0.03299357,
0.0572492294,
0.0128483614,
-0.1018401459,
-0.0102300858,
-0.0490187705,
-0.0284309816,
-0.0497083105,
-0.0345855914,
-0.0087696696,
-0.0618752241,
-0.0816205963,
-0.0779929236,
-0.0212077815,
-0.0318776891,
0.0409791656,
0.0251371339,
-0.0472464226,
0.0179072767,
0.0335003994,
-0.0057116486,
0.0083819758,
0.0499668978,
0.0308583658,
-0.0451502539,
0.0067663603,
-0.0120063843,
-0.0041311411,
-0.0352124311,
0.0141455429,
-0.0235400945,
-0.0767709836,
0.0602437034,
0.094425559,
0.0173695385,
0.0212503597,
-0.0225900039,
-0.0673875958,
0.0640923604,
0.0484986603,
0.0317506418,
0.0165076498,
0.0960099101,
-0.0109204864,
0.0223415382,
0.0252316352,
-0.0194688793,
0.0574338883,
0.0665872842,
-0.0108977882,
-0.0444699302,
0.0132680433,
-0.0139887976,
0.0211144593,
0.044593282,
-0.0046894518,
-0.0226259623,
0.0132053327,
0.0350908116,
-0.0037320748,
-0.0143856537,
-0.0065363371,
0.0122651141,
-0.0334951207,
0.0001383705,
-0.0289250016,
-0.0263136718,
-0.0296036266,
0.0064796465,
0.0040936675,
0.0135102142,
0.029520357,
0.0296115689,
0.0388807096,
0.0280006267,
-0.0415717326,
0.032729093,
0.0217717402,
-0.012328269,
-0.0290681422,
0.0067251669,
0.0202520899,
0.0125479726,
0.0049250419,
0.0564511716,
-0.0145313665,
0.0245724525,
-0.0225063469,
0.0038486375,
0.0045937551,
0.0376654267,
0.0220925827,
-0.0087459609,
0.004259666,
-0.0260480884,
-0.0268774759,
-0.0317703746,
-0.0294531621,
0.003432628,
-0.0010826737,
-0.0181503221,
0.0016915628,
0.0194506347,
-0.0037741452,
0.0658527315,
0.0157394297,
-0.0440255068,
-0.0077605816,
-0.0061092703,
0.0575637445,
0.0090593444,
-0.0133805098,
0.0052051796,
-0.0321524441,
-0.0605981648,
0.018713858,
-0.0000765535,
0.0551500544,
-0.0031347813,
0.0173881017,
0.0100773545,
0.0306622852,
0.0173738617,
0.0155701144,
0.0393350162,
-0.0149378041,
-0.047778219,
0.0039674989,
-5.417241471e-33,
0.0018585352,
-0.0187736209,
-0.0578298196,
-0.0029960328,
-0.0025457658,
-0.0097140158,
0.0241665654,
0.0084713344,
-0.0134772519,
0.0335932672,
0.0106130503,
-0.0027960208,
0.0060404632,
0.0067872987,
-0.0168117229,
-0.0188034791,
0.0400110111,
0.0195624903,
0.0028358048,
0.009127818,
0.0763758793,
0.0446109399,
0.0325609185,
-0.0436074436,
0.0352986194,
-0.0106064966,
-0.0422926322,
0.0225767605,
-0.0173110962,
0.0444550179,
0.0188493729,
0.0610293411,
0.0038417124,
0.0382309631,
0.0110573284,
0.0515407212,
-0.0287013184,
-0.0182422157,
0.0084267035,
-0.0073285056,
-0.014980779,
-0.021671854,
0.0752413049,
0.004588332,
-0.063074857,
0.0182270184,
0.0147402789,
-0.0094291465,
0.0196715239,
-0.0423112661,
-0.0539337583,
-0.0039140065,
-0.0225803293,
-0.0218412802,
-0.0429802462,
0.0125980396,
0.0055011609,
-0.0301415622,
-0.0337578803,
-0.0037852598,
-0.0046660621,
-0.0270836446,
-0.0209835712,
-0.0100224707,
0.0046839495,
0.0483139418,
0.0407162048,
0.0392184183,
0.0101421606,
-0.0224342011,
0.0223553292,
-0.0074641914,
0.0892345682,
0.0163224973,
-0.0018843914,
-0.049895525,
-0.0634627789,
0.0002861042,
0.0792285725,
0.0105896462,
0.022328278,
-0.0318328105,
-0.0567227975,
-0.0208399929,
0.0125252269,
-0.0692911968,
-0.014927173,
-0.0381233841,
0.0067301914,
-0.0351670757,
-0.012621236,
-0.0101367524,
0.006819502,
-0.0484480448,
0.0532376878,
0.0113361841,
0.0051469221,
-0.0224766657,
0.0042409943,
0.0154362218,
-0.0022175175,
0.0047980095,
-0.0094631696,
-0.0315746367,
0.0297054294,
0.0051519638,
0.1010503843,
0.0196444914,
-0.0573794171,
-0.0052933204,
-0.0066514895,
0.0462814122,
0.0289305542,
0.0681390092,
-0.0003711704,
0.015359357,
0.0031342958,
-0.0121207647,
0.0463764332,
0.0356971882,
-0.0318611749,
0.0330175497,
-0.0289627146,
0.0005907702,
-0.0430950373,
-0.0081213685,
0.0052242079,
0.0574489869,
0.0085901758,
-0.1257162243,
0.0036118785,
-0.0609725043,
2.583e-7,
0.0102756312,
0.0421141163,
0.0285731461,
-0.0080679022,
0.0507630818,
0.040785946,
0.0109306108,
0.0729828328,
-0.0362411216,
0.0453803912,
-0.0111401025,
-0.0274853017,
0.0199831352,
0.0268540569,
-0.0531451777,
0.006339794,
-0.1212210208,
0.0114323124,
-0.0517563559,
0.011214924,
0.0511210002,
0.0756909177,
0.0548881516,
-0.0270247273,
0.0019231752,
-0.048062034,
-0.0081804413,
-0.012819143,
0.0203512516,
-0.0235228781,
0.0338908173,
0.0067364145,
0.0038591838,
0.026441332,
-0.0140798818,
-0.0125719635,
-0.0302977189,
0.0384686701,
-0.0370640196,
-0.0268777218,
0.0267830286,
-0.0150012113,
-0.0237382911,
0.0050516804,
0.0297664888,
0.0145177273,
-0.0153953275,
-0.0048116394,
0.0043789069,
-0.034635812,
0.047427319,
-0.0540604405,
-0.0385786109,
-0.0077364855,
0.0209843628,
-0.0341310501,
0.0443041809,
-0.0795681849,
0.0002735803,
0.0014561227,
0.0040978333,
-0.0828736797,
-0.0039356006,
0.012994335,
0.0380909555,
-0.018941747,
0.0113771288,
1.887123248e-34,
0.0303922929,
-0.0285874754,
-0.0093063489,
-0.0058191032,
0.0385111198,
0.0204760507,
0.0038846768,
-0.0081663495,
0.0222242679,
-0.0309757907,
-0.0330863707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13092v1 | Do Language Models Learn about Legal Entity Types during Pretraining? | 2023-10-19T18:47:21 | 2023-10-19T18:47:21 | Claire Barale, Michael Rovatsos, Nehal Bhuta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language Models (LMs) have proven their ability to acquire diverse linguistic
knowledge during the pretraining phase, potentially serving as a valuable
source of incidental supervision for downstream tasks. However, there has been
limited research conducted on the retrieval of domain-specific knowledge, and
specifically legal knowledge. We propose to explore the task of Entity Typing,
serving as a proxy for evaluating legal knowledge as an essential aspect of
text comprehension, and a foundational task to numerous downstream legal NLP
applications. Through systematic evaluation and analysis and two types of
prompting (cloze sentences and QA-based templates) and to clarify the nature of
these acquired cues, we compare diverse types and lengths of entities both
general and domain-specific entities, semantics or syntax signals, and
different LM pretraining corpus (generic and legal-oriented) and architectures
(encoder BERT-based and decoder-only with Llama2). We show that (1) Llama2
performs well on certain entities and exhibits potential for substantial
improvement with optimized prompt templates, (2) law-oriented LMs show
inconsistent performance, possibly due to variations in their training corpus,
(3) LMs demonstrate the ability to type entities even in the case of
multi-token entities, (4) all models struggle with entities belonging to
sub-domains of the law (5) Llama2 appears to frequently overlook syntactic
cues, a shortcoming less present in BERT-based architectures. | [
0.0657328665,
0.0212743338,
-0.022600133,
0.012060577,
-0.0155904703,
0.0404669344,
0.0161302201,
0.041583959,
0.0285927933,
-0.1056097075,
-0.0376289748,
-0.0443868116,
-0.0344003439,
-0.0187865682,
0.028269561,
-0.0496618487,
0.032508947,
0.0044680135,
0.0681321099,
-0.0098767215,
0.0175699126,
0.0102351569,
0.0182829909,
0.0134942466,
-0.0308260191,
0.0054268744,
-0.0093179327,
-0.0012952447,
-0.0170244817,
-0.0128968339,
0.0015070643,
0.0692614019,
0.0256117489,
0.001850544,
0.0000018958,
-0.085007675,
0.0098463176,
-0.0335386917,
-0.0414522067,
0.043387603,
0.006622341,
-0.0386572555,
-0.0263926256,
0.0080217291,
-0.0186503585,
-0.0094372639,
0.0008951457,
0.023696389,
0.008604086,
0.0863519534,
-0.0187707879,
-0.0173311606,
0.0620074272,
-0.0417530388,
0.0003585274,
-0.0243875682,
0.0316057876,
-0.0419966355,
0.02826114,
0.0199670382,
0.0141649907,
0.0090998355,
0.0408441089,
0.0071734013,
0.0029651029,
0.0303129926,
-0.0150074167,
0.0027304583,
-0.0296537392,
0.0221756045,
0.0653354079,
-0.0088970726,
-0.0028710929,
0.0162197556,
0.054674346,
0.0013735938,
0.0042386656,
0.0674721971,
-0.0180943385,
0.0000636625,
0.0376515463,
-0.0120085822,
0.0054654959,
0.0244824868,
-0.0231170878,
0.0384468623,
0.0262846518,
-0.0532316267,
0.0241462961,
0.0277784802,
0.0119919963,
-0.0994175449,
0.0441041552,
0.0423509106,
-0.0028339266,
0.0439185463,
-0.0465621799,
-0.0198375005,
0.0605345294,
-0.0526366197,
-0.0033555699,
0.0290866811,
-0.0545886345,
0.062312454,
-0.0729743913,
0.0288125779,
-0.000871476,
0.0545899943,
0.0072712866,
-0.0270460453,
-0.0167406332,
-0.0311838537,
-0.0605335496,
0.077703841,
-0.0540291332,
0.0126861259,
0.0053126765,
0.0231149644,
0.0192426685,
0.0244516265,
-0.0173335019,
-0.0280618966,
-0.0064634341,
-0.0386562087,
-0.0893547758,
-0.0458732173,
-0.0682246387,
0.0427532271,
0.0105142565,
-0.0381950326,
0.0011151914,
-0.0190115068,
-0.0215106569,
-0.0256856941,
0.0241661724,
0.0985025093,
-0.0155838989,
-0.0738628805,
-0.0607179105,
-0.0329078026,
-0.0150936758,
-0.0582074486,
-0.0076399865,
-0.0507718883,
0.0020435867,
0.0151829217,
-0.0064441958,
-0.0668114424,
0.0143224979,
0.0286119357,
-0.0196496751,
0.0776836276,
-0.0183951203,
-0.0090773972,
-0.012289485,
0.0114845261,
0.020261379,
0.050388623,
0.0201339275,
-0.0066679572,
0.0221667364,
-0.0041570677,
0.0135090118,
0.0655244365,
0.0089924792,
-0.0032977676,
-0.0133033488,
0.0142112691,
-0.006418102,
0.0247568004,
0.0690246597,
0.0392640494,
-0.0120434584,
-0.0031601693,
0.0166238435,
0.0753782541,
0.013778151,
0.0298998822,
0.0281649139,
-0.0583572425,
0.0445551425,
0.0353945717,
-0.0761287361,
0.0170352049,
-0.0213454664,
0.011745533,
-0.0726460069,
0.0386886969,
-0.0429809503,
-0.0434433483,
-0.01939236,
-0.0035699971,
-0.0245803799,
-0.0304996036,
0.0292204712,
0.0509697981,
-0.0446130484,
0.0924492106,
0.0224470403,
-0.0488992669,
-0.0119121019,
-0.0163572542,
0.0167557821,
0.0711169615,
0.0450204015,
-0.0216237083,
-0.0412777439,
-0.0132542821,
-0.0359958373,
0.0700920969,
0.0338360853,
-0.0115142455,
-0.0176644959,
-0.0406474993,
-0.0179009009,
-0.0034032455,
0.0511014424,
0.0151379304,
0.0064064153,
0.0170774944,
0.0254864022,
-0.085861288,
0.0267978646,
0.0604896918,
-0.0194031298,
-0.0469061956,
-0.0276832283,
0.0276750289,
-0.003988496,
0.0404478833,
0.0173535012,
-0.0232714154,
0.0284887254,
-0.0192059707,
0.0108891297,
0.0152482176,
0.0048434101,
-0.0168602094,
0.030088976,
0.026582282,
-0.031665545,
-0.0282448176,
0.0061857491,
-0.0150422854,
-0.0523703061,
-0.021878805,
0.0705254897,
-0.0538682975,
-0.0013537123,
-0.0023760966,
-0.0321185403,
-0.0198589303,
0.0710238963,
-0.0126822339,
-0.0296557974,
0.0129993772,
0.002979944,
0.0112929316,
-0.0101817418,
-0.021882778,
-0.019731611,
-0.0233724695,
-0.0114275049,
-0.0120042926,
0.0093563823,
-0.0598975159,
-0.0327970833,
-0.0786422193,
0.0093652494,
-0.0317232423,
0.033152733,
-0.0106243994,
-0.0253972746,
-0.0397737622,
-0.0192238428,
-0.0086382395,
-0.0287454762,
-0.0279877037,
0.0171367601,
0.0315944739,
-0.0382782221,
-0.0318408869,
-0.0258689877,
-0.0094460128,
-0.0371766947,
0.0244709961,
0.0185171086,
-0.0478029624,
-0.0295814909,
0.0715194494,
-0.0009034374,
-0.025700571,
-0.011781496,
-0.0184928086,
0.0074304068,
0.0387042277,
0.0370628051,
0.0556607172,
0.0124891382,
0.0385059267,
0.0105889617,
0.0061156382,
-0.0658913851,
0.0183735527,
0.0287242625,
0.0044059567,
-0.0528058223,
0.0101078982,
0.0200882964,
0.0694461241,
-0.0451689884,
0.0012907276,
-0.03299715,
-0.0119543821,
0.0030212644,
-0.0044200751,
-0.0101764183,
-0.0211527459,
-0.0237441286,
0.0482714586,
0.0030138108,
-0.0448192321,
0.0575236194,
-0.0073406403,
0.0157605521,
-0.0223426688,
0.0311310496,
-0.0312578641,
0.0591182858,
0.0037411381,
-0.0032898318,
-0.0005299178,
-0.0986336246,
-0.0012403578,
0.0231717657,
0.0266320501,
-0.0194711257,
0.0855621919,
-0.0050277873,
0.0262019169,
-0.0025881403,
-0.0502977259,
-0.0616271868,
0.0066972603,
-0.0266298279,
0.0460420996,
-0.0079293828,
0.0255264938,
-0.0056768549,
-0.0290929563,
-0.0335743316,
-0.01026267,
0.0150268329,
-0.0052479985,
-0.0439630859,
0.0440209433,
-0.0158204008,
0.023919493,
0.0075721247,
-0.030009849,
0.0076365224,
-0.0084559247,
0.0001599478,
-0.0430337861,
0.0309203528,
0.0067432895,
0.021693984,
-0.0887552798,
-0.0430277176,
0.0320027508,
0.0396475866,
-0.042675145,
0.0074786502,
0.0997568145,
0.040355444,
-0.0087167723,
-0.0025592423,
0.0010116319,
0.0122773368,
0.0616746023,
0.0260488391,
-0.1065197513,
-0.00554532,
0.0242955424,
-0.0158781707,
-0.0301261563,
-0.013117441,
-0.0001401847,
-0.0945625529,
0.0563097671,
-0.0073445491,
-0.0259462409,
-0.0146782575,
-0.0138992742,
0.0070419037,
0.0124339974,
0.0382285081,
0.0136968084,
-0.0353867933,
-0.0084005194,
0.0316139162,
-0.0209863074,
0.0083517767,
-0.0024312302,
-0.0708891377,
0.0728432089,
0.0534524918,
0.0060486244,
-0.0489941761,
-0.0231275149,
0.0022687155,
-0.0317588672,
0.0042486042,
0.0001117417,
0.0335260592,
-0.0274781473,
0.0083408607,
-0.0413928144,
0.0330335088,
0.002764212,
-0.0226116944,
0.0296699964,
0.0359934308,
-0.016116092,
-0.0085072201,
-0.0249437373,
-0.0399908163,
-0.022638876,
0.0721348152,
0.0406616442,
-0.0146187302,
-0.0134763364,
-0.0482655279,
-0.0158586316,
-0.0273500513,
0.0112650348,
0.0025466452,
-0.0244450402,
0.0032652072,
-0.0546303838,
-0.0731720999,
0.0308258943,
0.040331848,
0.0327413231,
0.0164597537,
0.0341002867,
-0.0317203924,
-0.0417817384,
0.0391393937,
-0.0170771256,
-0.0029648554,
-0.0458669104,
-0.0276589375,
0.0024734219,
-0.0003817865,
-0.0183671732,
-0.0325046852,
-0.0131442128,
-0.0177346244,
0.0092475694,
0.0170941688,
0.0209765211,
0.0042742612,
-0.0397199504,
-0.035486564,
0.058732532,
0.0495788902,
-0.0479083955,
0.0059571252,
0.0509927124,
-0.0103166671,
-0.0084331166,
0.0028873642,
-0.0148372995,
0.0209189504,
0.0187735222,
0.0166520178,
0.0003250789,
-0.0214975905,
0.040968053,
0.0514269508,
0.0091632763,
0.0081826486,
0.0040102578,
-0.0481741764,
0.0226303972,
-0.0070047085,
0.0120134559,
-0.0146356588,
-0.045441322,
0.0056548519,
0.0107319215,
-0.0352338031,
0.0650269911,
-0.0349674374,
0.0526830666,
-0.0396601297,
0.0269536376,
0.0232385583,
0.0231238808,
0.0125615513,
-0.0425029509,
0.010322094,
0.0333247148,
-0.0113974959,
0.0425307378,
-0.0223078169,
0.0386892222,
0.0015505301,
-0.0068565756,
-0.0214494467,
0.0171448998,
-0.0081431288,
-0.0048248894,
-0.0104251467,
0.0980875641,
0.0426219851,
-0.0219186433,
0.0059401905,
-0.0374782793,
0.0129135512,
0.0268312357,
0.0003225615,
0.0125506418,
-0.0481695496,
0.0805546045,
0.0075615044,
-0.0231999941,
-0.020481674,
0.0488823764,
-0.0056178551,
0.0742836669,
-0.0064096893,
0.0225106888,
-0.0251435619,
-0.0174779892,
0.028283041,
-0.011441499,
-0.0566547289,
-0.0206762142,
-0.1000567004,
-0.0412682444,
0.0108056525,
-0.0194538217,
-0.0178645905,
-0.0048065451,
0.0226065759,
0.0694345087,
0.0315376148,
-0.0572139509,
-0.0086814631,
0.0245200545,
0.0051204637,
-0.0059109516,
-0.0032846536,
-5.89316791e-33,
-0.0720203593,
-0.0499331839,
0.0362409949,
-0.0074668666,
-0.0013541648,
0.0012743184,
-0.004756839,
-0.0061351713,
0.0010163598,
0.0190096553,
-0.0399505012,
0.0327933095,
0.012396507,
-0.0243631601,
0.0318792462,
-0.0392537788,
0.0213006325,
-0.0209309142,
-0.0138238389,
-0.0220305435,
-0.0360765085,
0.0335902497,
0.0366413854,
-0.0298952181,
0.046648223,
0.0378209278,
-0.0174888261,
-0.0322038755,
-0.0608523712,
0.0765740871,
-0.0151379537,
0.034545619,
0.0157236233,
-0.0335986726,
-0.0024687457,
0.0589449927,
-0.1188255996,
-0.0186791215,
0.0374787226,
0.0079189185,
0.0011736448,
-0.0734032989,
0.0488050617,
0.0004233089,
-0.0229088496,
0.0340132155,
0.0245903209,
-0.0236979984,
-0.0082708076,
-0.0450428911,
-0.0803821981,
0.0188729186,
0.0088676037,
0.0123962155,
0.0483989939,
-0.0205675885,
0.0113868453,
0.0179582182,
-0.0598390065,
0.0037765945,
0.0230999626,
-0.0090530002,
0.0187835936,
-0.0506367087,
-0.0400652178,
0.0469352789,
-0.0216994528,
0.0118543301,
-0.0518318303,
-0.0025291832,
0.0698503032,
0.0734588951,
-0.0123664327,
0.0252435841,
0.0275816564,
-0.0279212967,
-0.0570281707,
0.008560718,
0.037974678,
0.029816784,
-0.0191664901,
-0.0385254174,
-0.0398457609,
-0.0051056738,
-0.0298878811,
-0.0355178937,
-0.0128893312,
-0.0136881117,
0.0227124281,
0.0138349356,
0.0477304682,
-0.0516801029,
-0.0491110682,
-0.01292089,
-0.0240314957,
0.0060930545,
-0.0118273115,
0.0269688461,
-0.0058379718,
0.0425200611,
-0.0847141817,
-0.0484127104,
0.0378834903,
-0.0198487006,
0.000856729,
0.0137655865,
0.0474003442,
-0.0134877032,
-0.0811177865,
-0.0022202241,
-0.0041065095,
0.0305717755,
0.0254407506,
0.0053507602,
0.0354198329,
0.0346428119,
0.010494438,
0.0073788231,
0.0271384381,
-0.0384054221,
-0.0411406197,
0.0397267379,
0.0053799134,
0.0302548446,
-0.0101405093,
-0.0020526443,
0.0153281437,
0.0429885462,
0.0241319239,
-0.0165164433,
0.0115982518,
0.0355123617,
2.588e-7,
0.0782982036,
0.0781711563,
0.0094426628,
0.0128427651,
-0.0106195584,
0.0342354812,
0.0116046127,
0.0687050372,
0.017826125,
-0.0423737355,
0.0011195149,
-0.0098367818,
0.0320922881,
0.0319561884,
-0.0952143967,
-0.0203371644,
-0.0093969367,
0.0089102546,
-0.0708291382,
0.0268956907,
0.0474814065,
0.0704523847,
0.0095362691,
-0.0251958258,
-0.0156048434,
-0.0148558803,
0.0581725501,
-0.0212077498,
-0.0048471163,
-0.0060689193,
0.0697574764,
0.0048314705,
-0.0055714333,
0.0806409642,
-0.0009865172,
0.0581222624,
-0.0310121141,
0.0371771678,
0.008373281,
0.0108220177,
-0.0070803398,
-0.0433667824,
-0.0085387453,
-0.0347373672,
0.0522712655,
0.0036268593,
-0.0128866388,
0.0179569144,
-0.034894716,
-0.0194833893,
-0.02115882,
0.0059242379,
-0.0036759821,
-0.0071504219,
0.0360440016,
-0.0299007557,
0.0139369564,
-0.092488125,
0.0096086375,
0.0332996957,
0.0165727884,
-0.0018069209,
-0.0414821655,
-0.0128643876,
0.052286543,
-0.1287562549,
0.0201781485,
2.213456781e-34,
0.0025511566,
-0.009506532,
0.0168782249,
0.0991287455,
0.0169314239,
0.0152628291,
-0.0072327205,
0.0123539502,
-0.0288091302,
-0.0669884533,
0.0441807956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13080v1 | From Multilingual Complexity to Emotional Clarity: Leveraging Commonsense to Unveil Emotions in Code-Mixed Dialogues | 2023-10-19T18:17:00 | 2023-10-19T18:17:00 | Shivani Kumar, Ramaneswaran S, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Understanding emotions during conversation is a fundamental aspect of human
communication, driving NLP research for Emotion Recognition in Conversation
(ERC). While considerable research has focused on discerning emotions of
individual speakers in monolingual dialogues, understanding the emotional
dynamics in code-mixed conversations has received relatively less attention.
This motivates our undertaking of ERC for code-mixed conversations in this
study. Recognizing that emotional intelligence encompasses a comprehension of
worldly knowledge, we propose an innovative approach that integrates
commonsense information with dialogue context to facilitate a deeper
understanding of emotions. To achieve this, we devise an efficient pipeline
that extracts relevant commonsense from existing knowledge graphs based on the
code-mixed input. Subsequently, we develop an advanced fusion technique that
seamlessly combines the acquired commonsense information with the dialogue
representation obtained from a dedicated dialogue understanding module. Our
comprehensive experimentation showcases the substantial performance improvement
obtained through the systematic incorporation of commonsense in ERC. Both
quantitative assessments and qualitative analyses further corroborate the
validity of our hypothesis, reaffirming the pivotal role of commonsense
integration in enhancing ERC. | [
0.0427896269,
0.0724264383,
-0.0376719087,
0.054412026,
0.0029665772,
0.0223517865,
-0.0362105668,
-0.0151139898,
0.0887643248,
-0.0471540615,
-0.0209488012,
0.0571269505,
0.0136436867,
0.0404189937,
-0.0093453089,
-0.0309083574,
0.0100873513,
0.0161476247,
0.0286060888,
0.0098342467,
0.0353053585,
0.0625820234,
-0.0182885602,
0.0628089905,
-0.0349083729,
-0.0312572196,
-0.0026065079,
0.0300950371,
0.0261301529,
-0.0071465969,
0.0254329052,
0.0348078758,
-0.0145549225,
-0.0026204258,
0.0000020333,
-0.0080868239,
-0.0007850878,
-0.0404968411,
-0.0009767293,
-0.0141790109,
0.0642612502,
-0.0002530361,
0.000221726,
-0.0077587892,
-0.0484944694,
0.0116626779,
0.0579518005,
0.0346318409,
0.068268083,
0.0458837599,
-0.027389003,
0.0048743035,
-0.0054635489,
0.0282463841,
-0.0117042745,
-0.0357863009,
0.0080320025,
0.0359724723,
0.0310732089,
-0.0536643527,
-0.0104736127,
0.0233071763,
-0.0114354249,
-0.0387244113,
-0.0139467446,
0.028348323,
-0.0463132225,
-0.0116587719,
-0.0401915051,
0.0706929415,
-0.0122286659,
0.026683623,
0.0023642669,
0.0000545414,
0.0223766398,
-0.0232195128,
-0.0358530022,
-0.0138293561,
-0.0206834339,
0.0219833888,
-0.0064759948,
-0.0005765813,
-0.0212006569,
0.0246162526,
-0.012015162,
0.0466094762,
-0.043727003,
-0.0016239075,
0.0366903022,
0.0110850604,
0.0244162194,
-0.0351179615,
-0.0032488669,
0.0323780328,
-0.005547897,
0.0378798842,
-0.0047396822,
-0.012330668,
-0.0107087018,
-0.060474392,
-0.0362692773,
0.0353215672,
-0.020302387,
0.0320674032,
-0.0020005375,
0.026259644,
0.0305278972,
0.004882161,
-0.0044258763,
-0.018591335,
-0.0909330323,
-0.0222965945,
-0.0079811197,
0.0425454862,
-0.0373685062,
-0.0150739262,
-0.0432519428,
0.0076525551,
-0.051221434,
0.0345574692,
-0.0142801795,
0.0025641813,
0.0059602577,
0.0162312072,
0.0182336643,
0.0458057374,
-0.0325596444,
0.0111266514,
0.0255473591,
-0.0834325477,
-0.0092122862,
0.0241189953,
0.00020325,
-0.0030804565,
0.0039315731,
0.0397531278,
-0.0050226459,
0.0086007239,
-0.0171648879,
-0.0469414368,
-0.0258325376,
-0.0078764213,
-0.0106508834,
-0.0441671051,
0.0341960564,
0.0097739669,
0.0280494541,
-0.0306202713,
0.0264008734,
-0.0276583303,
-0.0438304506,
0.063870661,
-0.0620805919,
-0.0163013134,
-0.002812865,
0.0156866275,
-0.0029788676,
0.0574772507,
-0.0037907269,
-0.0347205289,
0.0582054108,
-0.0115749398,
0.0275621191,
0.0050995257,
-0.0221696533,
-0.0270844158,
0.0245668329,
-0.0296737645,
-0.0230549444,
-0.0048439526,
0.0785163268,
-0.0156785864,
-0.0381821319,
0.0144272614,
-0.0083979573,
0.0650346577,
-0.0354646035,
0.0510021374,
-0.0282109194,
0.0558505356,
0.0270859357,
0.018078329,
-0.0177673586,
0.0516422242,
-0.03156434,
-0.0245159063,
-0.0179722253,
0.005461982,
-0.0087470328,
-0.025540866,
-0.0174997877,
0.001713756,
0.0428268127,
-0.0010359643,
-0.0177434664,
-0.0185127016,
-0.0098300353,
0.0371505804,
0.048086226,
-0.0958671123,
-0.0101796715,
-0.0074311406,
-0.0481274277,
0.0885035545,
0.0213090349,
-0.0359525084,
-0.0464587547,
-0.0010823067,
-0.0535159037,
0.0351894684,
0.021463735,
-0.0157631058,
0.0543302372,
-0.0571815036,
-0.0033030568,
-0.0355242305,
-0.0268391855,
0.0199358612,
-0.027009286,
0.0046247528,
0.0004642134,
0.0074060233,
0.0000518409,
-0.0166369863,
-0.0310587119,
0.0154864136,
0.0003181362,
-0.0035439231,
0.0294817891,
0.0180872921,
-0.0077133738,
-0.0021890756,
-0.0076800683,
-0.0157243721,
-0.0233968291,
0.0928189084,
-0.0170521811,
-0.0861490667,
0.0467874408,
-0.0419423729,
-0.0642940998,
-0.0049215741,
-0.0163010936,
-0.0255372282,
0.0581719317,
-0.0276480131,
0.0631986633,
-0.0216573682,
-0.0151749551,
-0.0133248344,
0.0125581054,
0.008268158,
0.0287314951,
-0.0011702521,
-0.0034732632,
-0.006953666,
-0.0571576431,
0.027800899,
0.012757807,
-0.0098404214,
0.0410285555,
0.003911857,
0.0005812678,
-0.0033950442,
0.0294228401,
-0.0684222057,
-0.0500237718,
-0.136359632,
-0.0104250833,
0.0101102833,
-0.0092807207,
-0.0135893384,
0.0057265433,
-0.0122716939,
0.0091715446,
-0.0527730174,
0.0106446072,
-0.0028448252,
-0.0019898752,
0.0205919817,
0.0161309987,
0.0141489338,
-0.040780209,
0.026134979,
-0.0394068658,
0.0536719263,
-0.0115802502,
0.0012783862,
-0.014041123,
-0.0081721498,
-0.053233061,
0.0077278437,
-0.021424327,
-0.0814766884,
0.0124983788,
0.0110589238,
0.0380187891,
0.0424877815,
-0.0036097686,
0.0593551323,
-0.0168609992,
-0.0591268465,
-0.0438838601,
0.0557799265,
0.0394422188,
0.0218903366,
-0.0301178861,
0.0140104964,
0.0039533875,
0.0476532616,
-0.0021112161,
0.0142367277,
-0.0551753007,
-0.0219557229,
0.0208333489,
-0.0504724532,
-0.0229130201,
-0.0398750603,
-0.0062298849,
0.013466076,
-0.0128104538,
-0.0307620838,
0.0783876106,
0.0060901763,
-0.0447548777,
-0.075529933,
-0.0159029458,
-0.0438255891,
0.0618237518,
-0.1035163403,
0.0082762465,
-0.0526740626,
-0.0416186564,
-0.013807049,
-0.0310395937,
-0.0274049323,
-0.0375714749,
0.0430524535,
-0.0509740748,
-0.0192238297,
0.0237685759,
-0.0466363169,
-0.0168070178,
0.0148049835,
-0.0667086244,
0.0035738139,
0.0798953995,
-0.0289503597,
0.0192616321,
-0.030832842,
0.0455934964,
-0.0291173477,
0.0123559395,
-0.0418345146,
0.0267507918,
0.0064699897,
0.0104209585,
0.0112965107,
0.0296956133,
0.0261479933,
0.0534272045,
0.0523649938,
0.0543243103,
-0.0107411463,
0.0016962725,
0.0270519312,
0.022255687,
0.022132162,
-0.0418553762,
-0.0315067731,
0.051679682,
-0.0222262871,
0.0075964704,
0.0926237181,
0.0269803461,
-0.0398469791,
0.0010276581,
-0.055959329,
0.0245964807,
0.0321727023,
0.0271675549,
-0.0574526712,
-0.0328411907,
-0.015128376,
0.0126840351,
0.0014464298,
-0.0665603504,
0.0063175811,
-0.0943474248,
0.0154428408,
0.0265507475,
-0.0104847774,
-0.0631607249,
0.0101489844,
0.0174020529,
0.0265415907,
-0.0469320267,
-0.0637563318,
0.022615226,
0.0098328637,
0.0212148447,
-0.0260948762,
0.0014259402,
0.0424802825,
0.0012585714,
0.0441099964,
0.0268418826,
0.1103191748,
0.0058405781,
-0.0330278091,
0.0231050923,
-0.0177805237,
0.0170889366,
-0.0259915441,
0.0158226825,
-0.0247632693,
-0.0285061263,
-0.0087130005,
0.0228124429,
-0.0592516325,
-0.029767219,
0.0194839574,
0.0717334747,
-0.0392033607,
-0.0046655061,
-0.0296107214,
0.0348507501,
0.0262653716,
0.0510261618,
0.0524359383,
-0.0230555385,
-0.0070071439,
-0.0552063435,
0.0471186303,
-0.0354955196,
-0.0383628346,
0.0188472718,
0.0550355725,
0.0087952465,
-0.0431346633,
-0.0823020637,
0.0245942529,
0.0288034584,
-0.0178334899,
-0.0380002111,
0.0316865854,
0.0304726623,
-0.0522401072,
0.0257708952,
-0.0034630958,
0.0158163831,
0.0141917868,
-0.018559197,
-0.0098385857,
-0.0114193326,
-0.0174196381,
0.0492077023,
-0.0060072481,
-0.0563000664,
-0.0249594431,
0.0145357633,
0.0118896691,
0.0241407193,
-0.0020499988,
-0.0322297588,
0.0096086161,
0.0225371122,
-0.0463100299,
-0.0175329912,
0.0587411486,
0.0758479536,
-0.0018427063,
0.035470929,
-0.0296085514,
-0.0207569953,
-0.0199422538,
0.0225081798,
-0.0329881087,
-0.0935810283,
-0.0147666428,
0.0046696807,
0.0053818338,
0.0085142609,
0.0162471682,
-0.0314827748,
-0.0195166934,
-0.0136273047,
-0.028474275,
-0.0529923178,
-0.0306237545,
-0.0139501896,
-0.025521433,
-0.0249689668,
0.0179308653,
-0.0131234964,
0.0109699164,
0.0397516489,
0.0298343915,
0.0730773434,
0.0060712239,
-0.020331569,
0.0036501931,
-0.0145284506,
0.0054946644,
-0.0068486272,
0.015421343,
-0.0082990639,
0.064696081,
0.0169187095,
-0.0714879707,
0.0578868873,
0.0069822916,
-0.0400764048,
0.0100130895,
0.0564362034,
0.0036722212,
0.0264339671,
0.0020452645,
0.0519185737,
-0.0346166156,
0.0322061777,
0.011271514,
0.0478237309,
-0.0198876522,
-0.0632673055,
0.0044641807,
0.0250135977,
-0.0439764298,
-0.024577992,
0.0382509828,
-0.1176165044,
0.0344249345,
-0.0180482287,
-0.0334712453,
-0.0519141965,
-0.0144810583,
0.0870462134,
0.0256754868,
0.0340106227,
0.0512434579,
-0.0980794355,
-0.0498604663,
0.0394888334,
-0.0383229926,
0.0235000867,
-0.0208766554,
0.0240906384,
0.0879034176,
-0.0004878335,
-0.002150472,
-0.0186525621,
0.0321720839,
-0.095790796,
-0.0092771407,
-0.0302790347,
-5.697144309e-33,
-0.0107887359,
-0.0540742837,
-0.0528680757,
0.016505383,
-0.019204326,
0.0331447273,
-0.051726874,
0.0129899504,
-0.0355299413,
0.049065806,
-0.0149977151,
0.0504831485,
-0.0155948373,
-0.0231186859,
0.0254927278,
0.0136835612,
0.013308241,
0.0401847363,
0.0099934358,
0.0383965075,
0.0508198738,
0.0136197135,
0.0656660199,
-0.1004060805,
0.0385436974,
0.0386393443,
-0.002864419,
0.0057900916,
0.0687965974,
0.0390714668,
-0.0065066745,
0.0968979001,
0.0055010016,
0.0160022713,
0.0075271963,
0.0109236194,
-0.0068571265,
-0.047300566,
0.0307252482,
0.010200087,
-0.009341049,
-0.0344600938,
0.0260260906,
0.0187117849,
0.01158679,
-0.0474340431,
0.030895561,
0.0056041554,
0.0196861755,
-0.0711201876,
-0.0280897897,
0.0386346281,
-0.0893347338,
-0.0132940225,
0.0038143129,
0.0339533575,
0.0108339749,
-0.0259547923,
-0.0340013169,
0.0034322119,
-0.0369739458,
-0.0090880543,
0.0181885678,
-0.0281723142,
0.0152952457,
0.073837325,
-0.0191023853,
0.0332404673,
-0.0195837859,
0.0530338623,
0.0554351173,
0.0225851275,
0.0294952877,
0.0523663983,
-0.0500777215,
-0.0122918598,
0.0063696406,
0.0352303796,
0.0316369347,
0.0411336012,
-0.015707735,
0.0457169972,
-0.0494765565,
-0.0002455525,
0.0021918935,
-0.0308792293,
0.0008152629,
-0.0199267771,
0.0135762775,
-0.0546812601,
0.001292674,
0.0179892741,
-0.0060351286,
-0.0341975689,
0.0105922809,
0.0638057664,
-0.0390231609,
0.0374795459,
0.0036778194,
0.0250122845,
-0.003373794,
0.0020265391,
0.0589169338,
0.0265752748,
0.0923859701,
0.0183865521,
0.0180620253,
0.0072956053,
-0.0440501273,
-0.0238720141,
-0.0246892218,
0.0433997624,
-0.0442934819,
0.0051914733,
-0.0215919539,
0.0243810434,
-0.0059429873,
-0.0103317378,
0.0023395354,
0.043826133,
-0.0192332864,
0.0162381288,
-0.010457525,
0.017655611,
-0.0693913847,
-0.017503839,
-0.0013306333,
-0.0656166747,
0.0015174018,
-0.0208745599,
-0.0307891741,
0.0025291562,
2.791e-7,
-0.021740187,
0.0343987197,
0.0272305459,
-0.0359670185,
-0.0041599367,
0.0516599976,
-0.0097401859,
0.0162230339,
0.0454000346,
-0.0570630468,
-0.0063164979,
0.0332015157,
0.0785696581,
0.0401779525,
-0.0887514874,
-0.0470999405,
-0.0051637804,
0.0000669217,
-0.0326236524,
0.0421776883,
0.1080938503,
0.0345729105,
0.0364448689,
0.0189015325,
0.0023744679,
0.0006625769,
-0.0103380475,
-0.0135194333,
0.0156707149,
0.0088462187,
-0.0024649359,
-0.0274910945,
0.0068708346,
0.0241193976,
-0.0015123768,
0.0154155642,
0.0349157713,
0.0456472002,
-0.0282722265,
-0.0529023297,
0.0091919471,
-0.011354804,
-0.0142512228,
-0.046426028,
0.020894967,
-0.033012718,
-0.0173560232,
-0.0459849276,
-0.0183778126,
-0.0393610448,
0.0348925069,
0.0043366775,
-0.0429245047,
0.0525706708,
0.0004436625,
-0.0481034592,
0.0065367245,
-0.0701441169,
0.0096513685,
0.0115145277,
-0.0285698194,
-0.017692443,
-0.0140545191,
-0.0022154879,
0.0513410419,
-0.0445270129,
0.0372752361,
2.218098836e-34,
-0.0142063377,
-0.0023390555,
0.0246100444,
0.0259235241,
0.0909889191,
-0.000575169,
-0.0449553244,
0.0207251944,
0.0484558791,
-0.0241938662,
0.0188712589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13068v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13068v1 | GARI: Graph Attention for Relative Isomorphism of Arabic Word Embeddings | 2023-10-19T18:08:22 | 2023-10-19T18:08:22 | Muhammad Asif Ali, Maha Alshmrani, Jianbin Qin, Yan Hu, Di Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Bilingual Lexical Induction (BLI) is a core challenge in NLP, it relies on
the relative isomorphism of individual embedding spaces. Existing attempts
aimed at controlling the relative isomorphism of different embedding spaces
fail to incorporate the impact of semantically related words in the model
training objective. To address this, we propose GARI that combines the
distributional training objectives with multiple isomorphism losses guided by
the graph attention network. GARI considers the impact of semantical variations
of words in order to define the relative isomorphism of the embedding spaces.
Experimental evaluation using the Arabic language data set shows that GARI
outperforms the existing research by improving the average P@1 by a relative
score of up to 40.95% and 76.80% for in-domain and domain mismatch settings
respectively. We release the codes for GARI at
https://github.com/asif6827/GARI. | [
-0.0138486326,
0.0682252124,
-0.0010715083,
0.0536223091,
-0.0418217592,
0.0214752033,
-0.0185439736,
-0.0349634103,
0.0230070371,
0.0021323613,
-0.0385656394,
-0.0528180636,
0.027565686,
-0.0132160876,
0.084892951,
-0.0100220181,
0.0347043052,
0.0208953787,
-0.0310361218,
-0.0085236393,
0.0336685143,
0.0162605681,
0.0362289734,
0.0140589923,
-0.0153212175,
0.0026154784,
0.0198357217,
-0.0064733881,
0.0200278889,
-0.0142849991,
-0.0129717225,
0.0445331372,
0.0014108598,
0.0268251728,
0.0000017335,
-0.0315397494,
-0.0026958447,
-0.0014307545,
0.0294981357,
-0.026256755,
0.0205455162,
-0.0317123346,
0.0164706465,
0.0007695811,
-0.0254184008,
-0.0419781767,
0.0800471976,
0.0638591945,
-0.0141959693,
0.0404497273,
-0.0128499735,
-0.0538777523,
-0.0122984154,
-0.0398177356,
0.0001970877,
-0.0335763469,
-0.0051914915,
0.0124064302,
-0.0164665077,
-0.0005488798,
-0.0719787255,
0.047758583,
0.027402617,
0.0127982749,
0.0192584582,
0.0358762778,
-0.0381451473,
0.0088809533,
0.0441074036,
0.0865299553,
-0.065874517,
-0.0712360889,
-0.0199935697,
0.0190072041,
0.0230033025,
0.0295918789,
-0.0037511834,
0.0004361216,
-0.0462617166,
0.0530369096,
0.0564452447,
-0.0154871065,
0.0568063557,
-0.0264745485,
-0.0532963611,
0.0768369436,
0.0419536419,
-0.0494351313,
0.0567788333,
0.0436263867,
-0.0239291955,
-0.0030549236,
-0.0013355418,
-0.0388402715,
0.0032051576,
-0.0003466476,
-0.0509977676,
-0.0063895551,
0.0216242969,
-0.0729506612,
0.0572578087,
0.0407166183,
-0.0194607563,
0.0341452584,
-0.061421629,
0.0407458283,
-0.009741541,
0.0513408408,
-0.0609400347,
-0.0061568483,
-0.030905718,
0.022256799,
-0.0199343469,
0.0049883146,
-0.0085329721,
-0.0263472665,
-0.0163833946,
0.0383942388,
-0.039608188,
0.0025502448,
0.0179252476,
-0.0071655419,
-0.0154396128,
0.0074358657,
0.0128097069,
0.0063121715,
-0.0264314841,
0.0110108843,
-0.0652790517,
-0.041119229,
-0.0384350531,
0.051751554,
0.0112085268,
0.0088846264,
-0.024316512,
0.0620608293,
0.0151915429,
-0.0613128282,
-0.0338848568,
0.0567504726,
-0.0060871872,
-0.0216687657,
0.0101454165,
-0.0738329738,
0.0630022138,
-0.0117230974,
-0.0234559812,
-0.0530102849,
0.0106397942,
0.0046535926,
-0.0336459801,
0.0720448494,
0.0536259599,
-0.0048759715,
0.0201132502,
-0.0422781408,
0.0274508018,
0.0646083802,
-0.0085704774,
-0.0567561686,
0.0186535325,
-0.0129749198,
-0.0339065678,
0.025658194,
0.0489524603,
0.0161814559,
-0.0119213834,
-0.0227542538,
0.02490451,
0.0536414236,
0.0635401458,
0.0292735659,
-0.025416553,
-0.0567781106,
0.0321292244,
0.0339280702,
-0.0053853975,
0.0147502515,
0.0389121473,
0.0191780608,
-0.0323806964,
0.0283960812,
-0.0598946959,
0.0146417404,
0.0288960263,
0.0346799307,
0.0409912989,
0.0673203096,
-0.0560751371,
0.0026941851,
-0.0013257663,
-0.0200797245,
0.0640046522,
-0.0158655606,
0.0514180511,
0.062549375,
-0.0486117676,
0.0524866879,
0.0477073528,
-0.0038322294,
0.0278484467,
0.0171355903,
-0.0646732375,
0.001224854,
-0.014067499,
0.0096964529,
-0.0406308025,
-0.004281383,
-0.0061162659,
0.0257146098,
0.0178157426,
0.0063097477,
-0.0129126767,
-0.0510382466,
-0.0201153643,
-0.0060119121,
-0.0028972123,
0.0436064079,
0.0138069326,
0.0223041438,
-0.001440999,
-0.0791377425,
-0.035868682,
0.0219362099,
-0.0517826937,
-0.0192815773,
-0.0199592598,
0.0347378477,
0.011704376,
-0.0067483387,
-0.0026053174,
0.0134188328,
0.0089341942,
-0.0373925827,
-0.0258632582,
0.0145144481,
-0.0322734416,
-0.0569646098,
0.0481990539,
-0.0749100447,
0.0021294444,
0.0050253468,
-0.0601316281,
-0.0185673833,
0.0887176618,
-0.0259699598,
0.0593120269,
-0.0289808903,
0.033838585,
-0.0053977026,
0.042693194,
-0.0264694318,
0.0730004534,
-0.0358034037,
0.0323104747,
-0.0173824299,
0.0206794962,
0.0370369777,
-0.0045562396,
0.0043823193,
0.0286762435,
0.0029850246,
0.020651225,
0.0049336446,
-0.0097958725,
-0.0371742509,
-0.004235819,
-0.0594666936,
0.0036482187,
-0.0233202837,
0.0646010563,
0.0003848832,
0.0261172466,
-0.0053798845,
-0.0098889237,
-0.0354065709,
-0.0044726604,
-0.0105246371,
0.0267920475,
0.0388499722,
-0.0594337098,
0.0084776012,
-0.0196440704,
-0.0368274227,
0.0180341415,
0.0614096485,
-0.0083239749,
-0.0143611459,
-0.0201389659,
0.0154151972,
-0.0217949674,
0.0253766198,
0.0081478218,
-0.0379905291,
-0.007019022,
0.0387882739,
0.0386385769,
0.0562433302,
-0.0177923981,
-0.028622359,
0.0408825688,
0.0086839963,
-0.0554742031,
-0.0166310165,
-0.0394879319,
-0.0003782864,
-0.0351529419,
-0.0289875809,
-0.0199106,
0.0439744554,
-0.0098404167,
-0.0434460156,
-0.0594358891,
-0.0366285704,
-0.0202173498,
0.0003603394,
0.025964275,
0.0142024299,
-0.0248223282,
-0.0182605088,
-0.0657489449,
-0.0246500261,
0.0659639314,
0.0015905548,
0.0176459365,
-0.0497823134,
0.0166481566,
-0.04503344,
-0.0109491143,
0.0230037607,
0.0155222174,
-0.0321940184,
-0.053040728,
-0.0458460934,
-0.006123214,
0.0359890349,
-0.0008782101,
0.0396506377,
0.0055977604,
-0.005849638,
0.0200076066,
-0.0254397932,
-0.0266400203,
-0.012836202,
0.0044126464,
0.0086627118,
-0.0013487134,
0.0050491043,
-0.0270944368,
-0.0042939335,
0.0136467824,
0.0018905846,
-0.0000834622,
0.0159282945,
-0.0224748105,
0.0088682044,
0.0244717542,
-0.0182234608,
0.0085938089,
-0.0278252531,
-0.0464531593,
0.0263926499,
0.0071786391,
0.0153731145,
-0.0299381334,
-0.002102589,
0.0250079799,
-0.0149972793,
-0.0524967797,
-0.0767333508,
0.01087284,
0.0197053999,
-0.0139162401,
0.0402282476,
0.0019416386,
-0.0707311034,
0.0306270272,
-0.0087398347,
0.036958091,
0.0395550132,
-0.0069602178,
-0.0697486326,
-0.0045306915,
0.0028639468,
0.0079501886,
0.0532499962,
-0.000745339,
0.0033691868,
-0.1142204329,
-0.0439964049,
0.0282232463,
-0.0485829376,
-0.0751125664,
-0.0586084835,
0.0447556712,
0.0054123658,
0.0145254703,
-0.0470561869,
0.0075334916,
-0.0008834379,
0.0311118551,
0.0194269866,
-0.0929332972,
-0.0359507725,
-0.05047841,
-0.0001099302,
-0.0024072961,
0.0181696266,
-0.0161133409,
-0.0256795045,
0.0315228626,
-0.0410179831,
-0.1082529277,
0.019382257,
0.0535894409,
0.0147226611,
0.0063661207,
0.014407794,
0.0042720959,
-0.0446217731,
0.0131462319,
-0.0452220663,
0.0890149251,
0.0183696114,
-0.0230706483,
0.0305717643,
0.0146175968,
0.0187941417,
0.0320373252,
0.0549802147,
-0.0232154448,
-0.0214737877,
0.0051808897,
0.0086532366,
-0.0346698798,
-0.0339025185,
0.0435706377,
-0.0196538288,
-0.0317519233,
-0.0571699217,
-0.0570557714,
-0.0300698802,
0.0152854174,
0.0280575864,
0.0087815272,
-0.0039149141,
-0.0671344474,
-0.0079902913,
0.0166372359,
-0.0042274515,
0.0097363275,
-0.0244110823,
0.0022377712,
-0.0097996723,
-0.0216022749,
-0.0053716302,
-0.0130592147,
-0.076267615,
-0.048996564,
0.0124281747,
-0.0051873694,
0.0052463291,
0.0504226796,
-0.0476618409,
-0.0038816941,
0.0312891528,
-0.0168292709,
0.0451405756,
-0.0042069857,
0.0379333347,
-0.0461856313,
0.023865534,
0.0660723895,
-0.0015133092,
0.0053339279,
0.05306058,
0.0115266815,
0.0274406541,
-0.0388761312,
-0.0084510157,
-0.0273166858,
0.0130985342,
-0.0259239003,
-0.0064326948,
-0.0694968477,
-0.001989152,
0.0092669828,
0.012502227,
-0.005418112,
-0.0195199251,
0.0334372744,
0.0200862382,
-0.00197212,
-0.0266963169,
0.0188358556,
0.0114395618,
0.0083653014,
0.0001272941,
0.0324777029,
0.0240201429,
0.0000421374,
0.0507976264,
-0.0273796339,
-0.0238703806,
0.0009099601,
0.0452267118,
-0.0634097084,
0.0116300844,
0.0286985822,
-0.0066782963,
-0.0154382251,
0.0216005147,
0.0095333857,
0.004550572,
-0.0025927874,
0.0169841237,
0.0778633952,
-0.0734713823,
0.0779271349,
0.0074898098,
-0.0147569207,
-0.0247116517,
0.0272632856,
-0.0368016399,
-0.0284238383,
0.0335501768,
-0.0279871002,
-0.0129467528,
0.0133618703,
0.0561713725,
0.0059690713,
-0.0068851537,
-0.0310271066,
-0.0223346408,
-0.0107615404,
0.0021396524,
-0.0029738117,
0.0150678009,
-0.0359735303,
0.0361642502,
-0.0612419248,
-0.1120953858,
-0.0115564531,
0.004114585,
-0.0173409749,
0.0475390702,
0.0544046797,
0.0664657578,
0.010178132,
0.0035784415,
-0.0467684641,
0.0447675437,
0.0278794542,
-0.0446946025,
-0.0265235566,
-5.966714551e-33,
0.015132417,
-0.0372675769,
-0.0318360552,
-0.0226087421,
-0.0422923788,
-0.0054450701,
-0.036356993,
-0.017677946,
-0.0505082458,
0.0220863968,
-0.0076897088,
0.0362865739,
0.008340016,
0.0312150158,
0.0261299685,
-0.0490691476,
-0.0200700071,
0.0523881614,
-0.0076127257,
0.0219544545,
0.0220878851,
0.0128869135,
0.1201768368,
-0.069501467,
0.0029146962,
0.0089061176,
0.0427287668,
0.0006151787,
0.0325598903,
0.0777363777,
-0.0197220985,
0.0752940923,
0.0397917219,
-0.0092999609,
-0.0111359274,
-0.0038920979,
-0.0918163583,
-0.0741701871,
0.0265403148,
0.0231810398,
-0.0255213156,
-0.0318455398,
0.0302887466,
-0.0111052375,
0.0095431767,
-0.0576385185,
0.0266287588,
0.0353531316,
-0.0601379164,
0.0807081386,
-0.1016429365,
0.0513910949,
0.059282925,
0.0339802466,
0.0383394994,
0.0373682342,
0.006990829,
-0.0249786805,
-0.0327981748,
-0.0026088122,
-0.0539093502,
0.0296524391,
0.044362165,
0.0301570315,
-0.0212637931,
0.0234104991,
0.0070857196,
-0.0240568817,
0.0599535443,
-0.0543827228,
0.0226590559,
-0.0198037121,
-0.0040114108,
0.0453266874,
-0.0097614825,
-0.0111705847,
-0.0491145402,
-0.0148658957,
-0.0367736891,
0.0136382394,
0.0239712112,
-0.0211658701,
-0.0397448614,
-0.0342782363,
-0.0087686144,
-0.0405093767,
-0.0193510819,
-0.0225590356,
0.0060007893,
-0.0236591492,
0.0062682009,
0.0400187969,
0.0114731658,
-0.0148961134,
-0.0078416653,
0.0687985718,
0.0320006683,
-0.0054905168,
0.0083178086,
0.0506887659,
-0.0451562069,
-0.0421051718,
-0.042394422,
0.0142066646,
0.025740983,
0.048492115,
0.0649720058,
-0.0018141224,
-0.0524742939,
-0.0086737946,
-0.0552825518,
-0.054894153,
-0.0278835874,
0.0549433418,
0.050252188,
0.0243599061,
0.015522602,
0.0453690737,
0.1070806012,
0.0337500945,
-0.0192855187,
0.0057561789,
-0.0080989236,
0.0642425194,
-0.0281746052,
0.0274997354,
-0.0627866313,
0.049123358,
-0.0001802325,
-0.0640816092,
-0.0323214978,
-0.027792301,
2.718e-7,
0.0775697976,
-0.0080439216,
0.0071228947,
0.0024826515,
-0.0237067584,
0.0121968333,
0.0013476481,
0.0625099838,
0.0099577708,
0.0360865295,
0.0116458805,
0.0172180459,
0.0327061415,
-0.0177560598,
-0.0963361412,
-0.009429683,
-0.0220919531,
0.0322774388,
-0.0146881137,
0.0029008265,
0.0313784704,
0.1353339106,
0.0221343972,
0.0196504258,
-0.0532965921,
-0.0460001938,
0.055813048,
0.0097624976,
-0.0244922992,
-0.019060865,
-0.0013441332,
-0.0210255645,
-0.004862356,
0.006697658,
-0.0463591963,
0.0354506075,
0.0406767838,
0.0104286103,
-0.0032418452,
-0.0158687457,
-0.023010347,
-0.0248174053,
-0.0067581665,
-0.0751228929,
0.0318057574,
-0.0167674925,
-0.0470782295,
0.0115603786,
-0.0247886367,
0.0489543676,
0.0463031083,
0.0045400234,
-0.0487479866,
0.0167276673,
0.0567004234,
0.0235510264,
-0.0259909388,
-0.0314673185,
-0.0042574629,
0.0307823904,
-0.0035410598,
-0.0064863851,
0.0041323104,
-0.0115403878,
0.0417494737,
0.0390618443,
0.0070977653,
2.525168955e-34,
0.0107692676,
0.0047330027,
0.0397695266,
0.0044409637,
0.0256523751,
-0.0625487641,
-0.0090371408,
0.0076855849,
0.0270767808,
-0.0487408116,
0.0023039354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12973v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12973v2 | Frozen Transformers in Language Models Are Effective Visual Encoder Layers | 2023-10-19T17:59:05 | 2024-05-06T15:45:30 | Ziqi Pang, Ziyang Xie, Yunze Man, Yu-Xiong Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper reveals that large language models (LLMs), despite being trained
solely on textual data, are surprisingly strong encoders for purely visual
tasks in the absence of language. Even more intriguingly, this can be achieved
by a simple yet previously overlooked strategy -- employing a frozen
transformer block from pre-trained LLMs as a constituent encoder layer to
directly process visual tokens. Our work pushes the boundaries of leveraging
LLMs for computer vision tasks, significantly departing from conventional
practices that typically necessitate a multi-modal vision-language setup with
associated language prompts, inputs, or outputs. We demonstrate that our
approach consistently enhances performance across a diverse range of tasks,
encompassing pure 2D and 3D visual recognition tasks (e.g., image and point
cloud classification), temporal modeling tasks (e.g., action recognition),
non-semantic tasks (e.g., motion forecasting), and multi-modal tasks (e.g.,
2D/3D visual question answering and image-text retrieval). Such improvements
are a general phenomenon, applicable to various types of LLMs (e.g., LLaMA and
OPT) and different LLM transformer blocks. We additionally propose the
information filtering hypothesis to explain the effectiveness of pre-trained
LLMs in visual encoding -- the pre-trained LLM transformer blocks discern
informative visual tokens and further amplify their effect. This hypothesis is
empirically supported by the observation that the feature activation, after
training with LLM transformer blocks, exhibits a stronger focus on relevant
regions. We hope that our work inspires new perspectives on utilizing LLMs and
deepening our understanding of their underlying mechanisms. Code is available
at https://github.com/ziqipang/LM4VisualEncoding. | [
0.0280770436,
0.0579608232,
0.0037534027,
0.086034596,
0.0079268981,
0.0166078582,
0.0189186092,
0.0198233929,
0.007351914,
-0.0532794856,
-0.0468679927,
-0.0313060023,
0.0178967584,
0.0515212938,
0.0224165861,
-0.072745584,
-0.009420841,
-0.0495083407,
-0.0292356089,
0.0075963493,
0.0139452461,
0.0136782592,
0.0240495559,
0.03833507,
-0.0179276466,
0.0121520115,
-0.0088815494,
0.0216921251,
0.0113970637,
-0.0184560008,
-0.0331144221,
0.0198829919,
0.0640725046,
-0.0191537123,
0.0000020575,
0.0015081633,
0.0321783088,
-0.0355896801,
0.0065674032,
-0.0009149028,
0.0103248302,
-0.0694402307,
0.020573359,
-0.0102269044,
-0.0312004853,
-0.0374944955,
0.0681616664,
0.033328481,
0.0415781401,
0.0540269352,
-0.0328088813,
-0.0165885761,
0.0215029698,
-0.0049845665,
0.0062082373,
-0.0247404184,
0.0226342566,
-0.0150575209,
-0.0327984802,
0.0296878517,
-0.0594732836,
0.043263562,
0.0303267576,
-0.0052397358,
0.0164571833,
0.068255648,
0.002799897,
-0.0467995964,
-0.0223590788,
0.0652174726,
-0.0653307289,
-0.0175213944,
-0.0164066181,
0.0009691492,
-0.002536986,
0.0165102761,
-0.038363751,
0.0282771382,
0.0129172979,
0.0317868032,
-0.036930643,
0.0137182912,
0.0177773144,
0.0117831379,
-0.0158105325,
0.0306009222,
0.0038474668,
0.0146478014,
-0.0333205834,
0.0359898619,
-0.0256228093,
-0.058332365,
-0.0068929731,
0.0444464833,
0.0230452642,
-0.0208553132,
-0.0579112917,
0.0023701326,
-0.045729205,
-0.0223004203,
0.0304322746,
0.0253902599,
-0.0551797301,
0.0536148138,
-0.0513104573,
0.0861824527,
-0.0127204284,
0.0794086307,
-0.0448029377,
-0.0364419781,
0.0019097493,
-0.0060018296,
-0.0433627963,
0.0001221892,
-0.0165765155,
-0.0444408059,
-0.0020508817,
0.0310334656,
-0.0059644384,
0.0030750569,
-0.0082235904,
0.03113278,
-0.0055110953,
-0.0454173833,
-0.048108913,
0.0382249691,
0.0227193367,
0.049490273,
-0.0370797478,
-0.0643490553,
-0.0210287217,
0.0524108224,
0.0209399723,
-0.0146939391,
0.0296714753,
0.0712666214,
-0.0374781862,
-0.0456606932,
-0.0102132093,
0.0210708585,
-0.0055173915,
-0.0414308496,
0.0735592768,
-0.0544437282,
0.0248267241,
-0.0004559018,
0.0263193212,
-0.0417089052,
0.0143247573,
0.0070923087,
-0.0295797046,
0.0881526917,
0.0057044211,
-0.0185264349,
0.0149457939,
0.0164457504,
0.0309874769,
0.0429264009,
0.0557967015,
0.0685823932,
0.0135363489,
-0.0194724556,
0.0665603727,
0.0590939857,
-0.0136045059,
0.0331801772,
-0.0717211813,
0.0107292375,
0.0101022255,
-0.0070184879,
0.0463562198,
0.0423464291,
-0.0402893573,
-0.0334227681,
0.0724965334,
0.0494355969,
-0.0308968145,
0.0260719731,
0.0274395198,
-0.0340633616,
-0.0071465876,
-0.0217037015,
-0.049977608,
0.0795424208,
0.0201446209,
-0.0309669264,
-0.0398459323,
0.0277684256,
-0.0637159273,
-0.0401318632,
-0.0135218659,
-0.024653811,
0.0054551675,
0.0428108051,
0.0430593155,
0.0104483543,
-0.0521965027,
0.0702350736,
-0.0329547189,
-0.0247072354,
0.0386518613,
-0.0438728929,
0.0177062843,
0.0683069006,
0.0048795301,
0.0133513184,
0.0095411297,
-0.0008016897,
0.0304301083,
0.0191382356,
-0.0270955283,
0.0089833029,
0.0444758683,
-0.0726580173,
-0.0445404723,
-0.0134320594,
-0.0096460441,
-0.0076646977,
0.0148768835,
0.0175204389,
0.0214904975,
-0.0233305953,
0.0468040556,
0.038092047,
0.0296789128,
-0.0077923201,
-0.0028748133,
0.0160007458,
0.0009516181,
-0.0551432222,
0.0032525754,
-0.0184813496,
0.0338439308,
-0.0700948685,
-0.0100261075,
0.0389610976,
-0.04323164,
-0.0356615707,
0.0011322254,
-0.0129028074,
0.0168250166,
0.0308859684,
-0.0515132286,
-0.0247212257,
0.0127420267,
-0.0086181359,
0.0037474467,
-0.0207495261,
-0.0095193358,
0.021865543,
0.0465614796,
-0.0339091085,
0.0219108034,
-0.0573520549,
-0.0275871716,
-0.0088043837,
-0.0081612393,
0.0138894711,
-0.0053259442,
-0.0085711218,
0.0417660698,
0.0111280773,
0.0043169199,
-0.0128589859,
0.0060152439,
-0.0142119098,
-0.0333511196,
-0.0664366707,
-0.0208874587,
-0.0399089679,
-0.0286156144,
0.0094725871,
0.0051224707,
0.0036686254,
-0.0404510461,
-0.031811744,
0.023955334,
0.0096541457,
0.0014691317,
0.0157362893,
0.0109735336,
-0.0201236103,
-0.0090402411,
-0.0170004647,
0.0369502008,
0.0811399892,
-0.0110177463,
-0.0420509279,
-0.0261552688,
0.0148254493,
-0.0213389359,
0.0259355605,
-0.0341545679,
-0.0407570228,
0.004776272,
-0.0537571982,
0.0098655866,
0.0755799264,
-0.0021333161,
0.0223525278,
0.0287452694,
-0.0094569847,
-0.0225667227,
0.0028282984,
-0.0399888977,
0.0050748009,
-0.0518841892,
-0.0113954535,
-0.0322996825,
0.022238858,
-0.0076997476,
0.0277162045,
-0.0638050064,
0.0035289493,
0.0065173944,
-0.0214550402,
-0.0727736428,
-0.0045968131,
0.0056716832,
0.0413040183,
-0.0544268861,
-0.0731905848,
0.0161182415,
-0.0669727027,
-0.0277818199,
0.0497291498,
-0.0049779578,
-0.0494866781,
0.0850465745,
0.0507766418,
0.0077701197,
-0.029238075,
-0.0201105084,
-0.0296866726,
-0.0167394169,
-0.0303727388,
-0.0096475957,
0.0626150444,
-0.0386933237,
0.0091501148,
-0.0187589489,
-0.023210451,
-0.0348910913,
-0.0072073722,
-0.0450413972,
0.0123004336,
-0.0311762579,
-0.0287364963,
-0.0138661452,
0.0372505076,
0.0156434048,
0.0546841547,
-0.0068535875,
-0.0034106658,
-0.0272727162,
0.0329995491,
0.0490069166,
0.0661375448,
-0.0396176018,
-0.0355983451,
-0.0028262888,
0.0676654503,
0.0173364636,
-0.0212149229,
-0.0498863161,
0.0370578691,
0.0725733787,
0.0719789714,
-0.0012764725,
0.0294931624,
0.0549156033,
-0.0633069575,
-0.0310326405,
0.0688370466,
0.0067644068,
-0.0329047777,
-0.0435249098,
0.0490738377,
0.0299379248,
0.0367830098,
0.0017743495,
-0.0625599101,
-0.049047403,
-0.0135956127,
-0.0259462576,
0.0275486466,
0.0120528555,
-0.0161212776,
-0.0550176464,
0.0619751848,
-0.0011320692,
-0.0132492101,
-0.0518778935,
-0.0251838733,
-0.0107874963,
-0.0105779367,
-0.0245378818,
-0.0324592181,
-0.0054084682,
-0.0121470457,
0.0065571456,
-0.0262548737,
-0.0151388263,
0.0080697313,
-0.0086802999,
-0.0339926444,
0.0619092323,
0.006980849,
-0.0347737595,
-0.0961109623,
0.0390387699,
-0.0064177471,
-0.0059987972,
-0.0183535963,
0.0466373712,
-0.0177855212,
-0.0315459259,
0.0402913317,
0.0113590909,
-0.0234869532,
-0.0475995392,
-0.0361626707,
0.0526548587,
-0.0381320938,
-0.0090497639,
-0.004729473,
-0.0094660763,
-0.0129289264,
0.0376326442,
0.0160751697,
-0.0172998104,
-0.0265806448,
-0.0342835486,
-0.0081819948,
-0.0520169884,
-0.0560613945,
0.0050613619,
0.0378810503,
-0.0042201816,
-0.036716111,
0.0037521948,
0.0392718203,
0.0347336605,
-0.018470576,
-0.0211352259,
0.0121170813,
0.0003551668,
-0.05505744,
0.05553158,
-0.0515370853,
0.027055217,
-0.0286391973,
0.0007124278,
0.032187216,
-0.0452307202,
-0.0236974861,
0.020896323,
-0.0932104662,
-0.0219106451,
-0.0302001499,
0.0695503056,
0.0069855978,
0.0590391904,
0.0164212044,
-0.0305398423,
0.080200702,
0.0330835767,
0.0170143899,
0.0317613706,
0.0089474767,
-0.0345262922,
-0.0017832273,
0.0100825578,
-0.0453427173,
0.0241978727,
0.0225248206,
-0.0310353432,
-0.0325239971,
-0.0495668799,
-0.0028361354,
-0.0347648375,
0.068277061,
0.005137458,
0.0332351401,
-0.0321972631,
0.0176893007,
0.0386128463,
0.0141661083,
-0.0906607732,
-0.0130042415,
0.0420912243,
0.0287572294,
0.0201861672,
0.0572384968,
0.0193799417,
0.0103526469,
-0.0019125374,
0.0114058489,
0.0125445519,
-0.0116496449,
0.0260940697,
0.0376671217,
-0.0039622886,
0.0314272866,
-0.0070376419,
0.0201474242,
-0.0113829039,
0.0407257192,
0.0184045509,
-0.0075443638,
-0.0649837554,
0.0366198793,
-0.0750304684,
-0.0534347408,
-0.0393382013,
0.009300923,
0.0503330231,
-0.023170229,
0.0067040473,
-0.0283578858,
-0.0074364082,
-0.0161862411,
0.0469455309,
0.0213632416,
-0.0594512038,
0.0973641127,
0.017220417,
-0.0205529723,
-0.0297178347,
0.0362498499,
0.0272912178,
0.0352973416,
0.0004154624,
-0.0080496017,
-0.0227695629,
-0.023157144,
0.0180427749,
-0.0324625522,
0.0057808296,
0.0198993068,
0.0151758837,
-0.0518002734,
0.0139503581,
-0.004907683,
-0.0214140154,
-0.010586272,
0.0347776562,
0.0444872379,
0.0384380072,
-0.0222226437,
-0.0325356051,
-0.0156563409,
0.0253008679,
-0.0205455311,
-0.0066124815,
-6.258267272e-33,
-0.0134162344,
-0.0215655863,
0.0472882763,
0.0104975691,
-0.0118572311,
0.0182014201,
-0.0235566851,
-0.0092823608,
-0.030830808,
-0.0051512658,
0.0098044798,
0.0107513629,
0.0165510587,
0.0461904146,
-0.0252527744,
-0.0364457294,
0.0489378162,
-0.0053329426,
-0.0105941594,
0.0126186647,
0.0206968691,
0.002958582,
0.0595470369,
-0.0281841494,
-0.03845286,
-0.0188105498,
-0.0485203713,
0.0220667608,
0.0168177076,
0.0485238805,
-0.0300456062,
0.0062447577,
0.022735877,
-0.0416308045,
-0.0201501288,
0.0320073478,
-0.0623304769,
0.016514739,
-0.0220895763,
0.0607020855,
-0.0785722509,
-0.005975625,
0.0672958046,
-0.0023677091,
-0.0050622877,
-0.0238495246,
0.0393085256,
-0.0030826267,
-0.0086929873,
-0.0201076195,
-0.0088257939,
0.0038554657,
-0.0133022098,
-0.0309611652,
0.0635706708,
0.0174008664,
0.0346665345,
0.0477026254,
-0.0762623698,
0.0222992916,
-0.0352485701,
0.0514604375,
0.0518095791,
0.0760246664,
0.008603096,
0.070250079,
-0.0040148259,
-0.0371604525,
-0.051963862,
0.0040422603,
0.0609627962,
0.0473383591,
0.037326429,
0.0178413521,
0.0198275317,
-0.0145342546,
-0.0546984114,
0.011414079,
-0.061223384,
0.0583828203,
-0.0010619062,
0.0138626657,
0.0207377039,
-0.021938473,
-0.0448730066,
0.0116372388,
-0.0390499756,
0.0251491349,
0.0533875786,
0.0641656965,
0.0147404158,
0.0183100551,
0.0820943788,
-0.0372673273,
-0.0116593279,
0.0316513143,
-0.0419575982,
0.0575377457,
0.0217120275,
0.020280987,
-0.0330311656,
-0.0411308259,
0.0372722521,
-0.0291382689,
-0.0043281899,
0.0107688233,
0.0533217676,
0.053607475,
-0.0590194836,
-0.0174954347,
-0.0539636984,
0.0112122791,
0.0276825055,
0.0425388925,
0.0114017781,
0.009190619,
-0.0458310917,
0.0256635603,
-0.0431305356,
-0.010044178,
-0.0287104081,
-0.0203390904,
-0.0073331543,
0.0387223735,
-0.0274975356,
0.0039796759,
-0.0619875379,
-0.0413105302,
0.0307248365,
-0.0734483898,
-0.0150576802,
0.0262719821,
2.682e-7,
0.0201384332,
0.0303243212,
-0.0163463019,
-0.0085420469,
0.0266179778,
0.0515870377,
-0.0364731885,
0.0274353027,
0.0189911611,
-0.0399665572,
0.0027502447,
0.0607117862,
0.0447045155,
0.0129088676,
-0.0623195767,
0.0290030576,
-0.0128225861,
-0.0080100559,
-0.0319408029,
-0.0063263485,
0.0439106524,
0.1204987019,
-0.0050251526,
0.0016941144,
0.0301505085,
-0.0513978936,
0.1137759015,
-0.0378292613,
0.0141758313,
-0.0021132731,
0.0075959829,
0.0387251042,
-0.0127452463,
0.0101888431,
-0.0279902685,
-0.0054753739,
0.033697065,
0.0687281266,
-0.0121317431,
-0.0513046905,
-0.0141504239,
0.0419335365,
-0.0197020527,
-0.0626328811,
0.1003494114,
-0.0551503934,
-0.0011416769,
-0.031809032,
-0.0115021858,
0.0190642532,
0.0421192087,
0.0108523248,
-0.0120586352,
0.0257272907,
0.048675172,
-0.038576927,
-0.0266547557,
-0.0894190595,
-0.0375727341,
-0.0423446447,
-0.0691159219,
0.0036494655,
-0.0709620863,
-0.0266348738,
0.0252239369,
0.0211574733,
-0.0434240475,
2.221058694e-34,
0.0138293775,
-0.0085116196,
0.002240587,
0.0261088219,
0.000396986,
-0.0209260974,
0.0258411616,
0.019223744,
-0.0185715593,
-0.0733825639,
-0.012298923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12971v1 | CLAIR: Evaluating Image Captions with Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T17:59:01 | 2023-10-19T17:59:01 | David Chan, Suzanne Petryk, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Trevor Darrell, John Canny | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The evaluation of machine-generated image captions poses an interesting yet
persistent challenge. Effective evaluation measures must consider numerous
dimensions of similarity, including semantic relevance, visual structure,
object interactions, caption diversity, and specificity. Existing
highly-engineered measures attempt to capture specific aspects, but fall short
in providing a holistic score that aligns closely with human judgments. Here,
we propose CLAIR, a novel method that leverages the zero-shot language modeling
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to evaluate candidate captions. In
our evaluations, CLAIR demonstrates a stronger correlation with human judgments
of caption quality compared to existing measures. Notably, on Flickr8K-Expert,
CLAIR achieves relative correlation improvements over SPICE of 39.6% and over
image-augmented methods such as RefCLIP-S of 18.3%. Moreover, CLAIR provides
noisily interpretable results by allowing the language model to identify the
underlying reasoning behind its assigned score. Code is available at
https://davidmchan.github.io/clair/ | [
0.0393998101,
0.085225381,
0.0055945497,
0.0479881912,
-0.0256352313,
0.0186460279,
0.0125087379,
0.0307614878,
0.0044572433,
-0.0658682287,
-0.0457357652,
-0.0187257752,
0.0003096096,
0.0356991962,
0.009020187,
-0.0613426492,
-0.0062521929,
-0.0393184051,
0.0059027001,
0.0039578932,
0.0322347581,
-0.0066176853,
0.0085158283,
0.060368292,
-0.0003702696,
-0.0098179644,
0.0399096347,
0.0300807878,
0.0073439241,
-0.0324956328,
-0.0330508687,
0.0778075308,
0.0171604231,
0.0473520868,
0.0000015792,
-0.0096541904,
0.0297277421,
-0.00263358,
0.0408406518,
0.0198214892,
0.0971169174,
-0.017894933,
-0.0058022756,
-0.0254609585,
-0.0256345589,
0.005272069,
0.0874258429,
0.0127419243,
0.086003527,
0.032192789,
-0.02320797,
-0.0292045735,
-0.033994671,
-0.0316564925,
0.0214713644,
-0.0224189702,
-0.0075825169,
0.0660418123,
-0.0112020317,
0.0019204023,
-0.0160610974,
0.0510485843,
-0.0183068141,
-0.0477859937,
0.0124020884,
0.0442528538,
-0.0698308721,
-0.0615197457,
-0.00076296,
0.0769710094,
0.0052777161,
0.0038840587,
-0.040537253,
0.0077186427,
-0.0150167271,
0.0089020217,
-0.0783656687,
0.0126928193,
0.0491454862,
0.0191487912,
-0.0315003172,
0.041616004,
0.0087448061,
0.0156162065,
0.0297952611,
0.0084464662,
0.042316746,
0.0217815787,
-0.0372052416,
0.0349012204,
-0.032477811,
-0.0565706566,
0.0053675664,
-0.0047013094,
0.0223166738,
-0.0026187794,
-0.0215624385,
-0.019537,
0.0463943221,
-0.0437774286,
0.0226270948,
-0.0048444103,
-0.0456427932,
0.0937464833,
-0.0366255902,
0.0613694638,
0.0009852769,
0.0181519911,
-0.0488269329,
-0.0145141631,
-0.0350885689,
0.0013490723,
0.022893643,
0.0127012171,
-0.0302483663,
-0.0601275526,
-0.0467066467,
-0.0012661428,
-0.032262817,
0.0028734221,
-0.0033644228,
0.0238029547,
0.0013432796,
0.010522617,
-0.0481159277,
0.0367336981,
0.0013590632,
-0.008996686,
-0.0262056142,
-0.0248926021,
0.0040644417,
0.0568847694,
0.0197542123,
-0.0117985308,
0.005466864,
0.0705204159,
-0.0052064909,
-0.0349291824,
0.0187863521,
-0.0345263109,
-0.0500029847,
-0.039808169,
-0.0125463391,
-0.0680248886,
0.0125774024,
0.0074409964,
0.0037754367,
-0.0658752918,
0.0090760021,
0.0382136591,
-0.0210633241,
0.0787441432,
-0.0183434617,
0.0061811716,
-0.0038623053,
0.0206871126,
-0.020591069,
0.0655518398,
-0.0046182945,
0.0528668612,
0.0607301556,
-0.005474952,
0.0566569194,
0.0415776111,
-0.0192730855,
0.0283753853,
-0.0690750852,
-0.0049468656,
0.0001171416,
0.0069108894,
0.0623522922,
0.0574937202,
-0.0159361977,
0.0117129423,
0.1005656645,
0.0577322394,
0.005669042,
0.023150146,
0.0442859754,
0.0066772946,
-0.0083857384,
-0.0081003383,
-0.0358112343,
0.0703746155,
0.0014361946,
0.01298152,
0.06319803,
0.0361099504,
-0.0152503727,
-0.0211756006,
-0.0148744136,
-0.0079277996,
-0.006771212,
-0.0315763466,
0.018657472,
-0.0085733775,
-0.0294424761,
0.0305474587,
0.00392628,
-0.0295779333,
0.0036717907,
-0.0359464772,
0.0016244976,
0.0957990661,
0.0448722877,
0.0297261681,
-0.0215081107,
-0.0061376481,
0.0180371143,
0.0696590096,
-0.0099705411,
0.0214422923,
-0.0038127296,
-0.0360887386,
-0.0300187059,
-0.0173014812,
0.0145994863,
0.0042614038,
-0.0154853361,
0.0157943778,
0.0428547785,
-0.0312528051,
-0.0721669793,
0.0190803763,
0.0650507063,
-0.0157336108,
-0.0162224993,
0.0088937785,
0.0099641327,
0.0100260433,
-0.0339520611,
0.0242766403,
-0.0086800428,
-0.0206213053,
-0.0215880685,
0.0406187661,
-0.0331678912,
-0.0396781117,
0.0403103232,
-0.0861359611,
-0.0071596117,
0.0033540588,
-0.0269871745,
-0.0198607258,
0.0256608333,
-0.0398053266,
-0.0065180981,
-0.082109198,
0.0206561014,
-0.009253622,
0.0296797156,
-0.0075242859,
0.0460185446,
0.0046136961,
-0.0009248151,
0.0529674143,
-0.0179502554,
0.0154497297,
-0.0248669013,
-0.0636036322,
0.0056153564,
0.0154398484,
0.0394037813,
0.0449769534,
0.064428404,
-0.0476470888,
-0.0169668961,
-0.0881374106,
-0.0405444615,
-0.0105609437,
-0.0238863099,
0.0026834586,
-0.0209136382,
0.0223058201,
-0.0124990009,
-0.0295550022,
-0.0255460609,
0.0057562855,
0.0374607965,
0.0372546129,
-0.0054194652,
-0.0333748683,
-0.0334347375,
-0.007417615,
0.034277115,
0.1091892198,
0.0375761464,
0.0151829412,
-0.0201986134,
-0.001041549,
-0.0452374034,
-0.0373420082,
0.0219064355,
-0.0390004069,
0.0067937179,
-0.0020189413,
-0.0210018605,
0.0302020572,
0.0093558142,
-0.0147713656,
0.0189985931,
0.0039196429,
-0.029575713,
-0.0426209196,
0.0065587042,
-0.0662992895,
0.04255924,
-0.0373658836,
-0.0088164033,
0.0156017747,
-0.0430399813,
0.0434908345,
-0.0668640956,
0.046616178,
-0.0366326869,
-0.0367800556,
-0.052581206,
0.0171455108,
0.0004235396,
0.0400388539,
-0.0340501033,
-0.0571549758,
0.046484571,
-0.0699980184,
-0.0296739824,
0.0011122442,
0.0013740261,
-0.0373661295,
0.0837526843,
0.0102940425,
0.0377482548,
-0.0225039441,
0.0052236486,
0.0113752624,
-0.004408374,
0.0231098179,
-0.0335223787,
0.0414994657,
-0.0336576961,
-0.0113911508,
0.0144030675,
-0.0135755399,
-0.0190124828,
-0.030108152,
-0.0446894355,
-0.0063611888,
-0.0199945699,
-0.0079491679,
0.0003574369,
0.0616929866,
0.0161549281,
0.0048545008,
-0.0019552803,
0.0036303943,
0.0075487006,
0.0438020788,
0.0627313852,
-0.0162363816,
-0.0392843187,
-0.0198251549,
0.0173484497,
0.0088794176,
-0.0001556837,
0.0265965443,
-0.0465955473,
0.0270820521,
0.0198744163,
0.0234194249,
0.0027753985,
0.0105402535,
0.0547792464,
-0.02085297,
0.0017329911,
0.0957791954,
0.0107169859,
-0.0758299455,
-0.0233341679,
0.0015280154,
0.0368224196,
0.035027843,
-0.0148040066,
-0.0605223849,
-0.056432683,
-0.0273900181,
-0.0165924821,
0.0205954202,
0.015330866,
-0.0350174122,
-0.0974664092,
0.0389741994,
0.022095181,
-0.0444336496,
-0.0398043506,
-0.0222310405,
-0.0027886478,
-0.0326858275,
-0.004788389,
-0.019237591,
0.0041029011,
0.0159952119,
-0.0107937651,
0.0211106054,
-0.0550649464,
0.0190786049,
-0.0576004088,
0.0335500389,
0.0708584264,
0.0384787694,
-0.0144443559,
-0.0481925905,
-0.0212123394,
-0.0089410162,
-0.0005852187,
0.0071760025,
0.0650153235,
-0.0185387749,
-0.0317165367,
0.0019526094,
-0.0108100297,
-0.0123217059,
-0.0127385128,
-0.0132764764,
0.0284233931,
0.0148568004,
-0.0028870462,
-0.0549791381,
0.0342601873,
-0.0030239187,
0.0757674575,
0.071460478,
-0.0234315917,
-0.0031257432,
-0.0153035568,
-0.0278682094,
-0.0621558316,
-0.0516130105,
-0.0027847223,
-0.0041651856,
-0.045453582,
-0.0812493563,
-0.0240036808,
0.031400457,
-0.0066199587,
0.008700816,
0.0168238785,
-0.0491265729,
0.0264632721,
-0.0424459502,
0.0498165525,
-0.0493783876,
-0.0005818013,
-0.0385001972,
0.005130528,
0.0603651665,
-0.0129233627,
-0.0348489024,
0.0427127145,
-0.0665030628,
-0.0185380857,
-0.0437360108,
0.0750764161,
0.0176105164,
0.001401665,
-0.0023312178,
-0.0447779372,
0.0118753426,
0.0561365038,
0.0071572573,
-0.0027178505,
0.0036708238,
-0.0043791835,
-0.0156460032,
0.0326894373,
-0.0389105715,
0.022908492,
0.0008965571,
0.0417628363,
0.0068286955,
-0.0716816708,
-0.0000457177,
0.0214142017,
0.0177602582,
-0.0704115331,
0.0087251477,
0.0127103198,
-0.0281801522,
0.0012467745,
-0.0146815814,
-0.0487346947,
0.0184555892,
0.0137524605,
0.036136888,
-0.0138528012,
-0.0030243916,
-0.0373166054,
0.0161647759,
-0.0019150771,
0.0004252553,
0.01399743,
-0.027158238,
-0.0126995156,
-0.0014521381,
-0.018157199,
-0.0026743631,
-0.0197432432,
0.0017380896,
-0.0320380442,
0.0310566835,
0.0095441295,
-0.0107798716,
-0.0031351072,
0.0750369355,
0.0000020788,
-0.0271748696,
-0.0686664358,
0.0386841372,
0.0930998847,
-0.0254870299,
0.0597586781,
-0.012035897,
-0.0166062806,
-0.0048024799,
0.0283692069,
0.0004944954,
-0.0379452445,
0.0133967232,
0.0233372096,
0.0041967188,
0.0237952173,
0.0586208329,
-0.0135964388,
-0.003417443,
0.0147048878,
-0.0470649637,
-0.0243094731,
-0.0046199202,
-0.0151205109,
-0.0045966278,
-0.0190544445,
0.0215458591,
-0.0520329885,
-0.0749472827,
0.0053480496,
-0.0102517977,
0.0112754917,
0.0488858968,
0.0412692167,
0.040599741,
0.0078079537,
0.04710586,
-0.0263786707,
-0.0511304364,
-0.0153443106,
0.0268142335,
-0.0336649865,
-5.555265446e-33,
-0.0273223519,
-0.0497543029,
-0.0168381818,
-0.0359757431,
-0.0206712205,
0.0154527649,
-0.0580703728,
0.0158826634,
0.0123894298,
0.0121994782,
0.0259625651,
-0.0292209703,
0.012170583,
0.0229877308,
0.015688723,
-0.0010653315,
0.0430037305,
0.0274245366,
-0.0316577703,
0.0044074673,
-0.0080821645,
-0.0214050282,
0.0167273283,
-0.0443125963,
0.0247910153,
-0.0074204011,
-0.0322647132,
-0.0088534057,
0.0671570823,
0.0979619995,
-0.0301494263,
0.0463824868,
0.0085607944,
-0.0418253392,
-0.0158174541,
-0.0254765302,
-0.0174441077,
-0.0030838824,
0.0430805422,
-0.0047123018,
-0.0131336451,
-0.0241690334,
0.0362889506,
-0.0415753052,
-0.0313480124,
-0.0107239904,
0.0625564903,
-0.0333648436,
0.0196742471,
-0.019450143,
-0.0367851406,
0.0264283698,
-0.04044687,
-0.0423950516,
0.0605807379,
-0.0002487092,
0.0092161652,
0.0643872023,
-0.0459282845,
0.0538388602,
-0.0153873721,
0.0297553018,
0.1055893973,
0.0248428192,
0.0131402127,
0.0735975802,
0.0040819766,
-0.0172880869,
-0.0129084717,
-0.0204112548,
0.0175213646,
0.0587911718,
0.0693077296,
0.065606989,
0.03982931,
0.0237894636,
-0.0091843633,
0.0446293093,
-0.0619554482,
0.0374018773,
0.0247505307,
0.0341106802,
-0.0043172166,
0.040870823,
-0.0554408468,
-0.0380042195,
-0.0830747262,
-0.0458141714,
0.0147702135,
-0.0017097191,
-0.0490929335,
0.026364699,
0.0747162327,
-0.0448658429,
0.0063556796,
-0.0031165241,
-0.0381309763,
0.038619902,
0.0015485141,
0.000449172,
0.0153267896,
-0.0145899458,
0.0360075086,
0.0202236902,
0.0262813028,
0.0007413913,
0.0597338565,
0.0082056066,
-0.0313357636,
-0.0021907273,
-0.0269939899,
-0.0385691002,
-0.0509237349,
-0.0107384557,
0.0066883862,
0.0110262046,
-0.080349654,
0.0060211783,
0.0017884924,
0.041390352,
-0.004565448,
-0.0322999507,
0.0210392512,
0.0085853133,
-0.0508454293,
0.0292758532,
-0.0143975336,
-0.0386082456,
0.0010252562,
-0.0444180332,
-0.049127683,
0.0024918616,
2.261e-7,
0.0329883359,
0.0409725457,
-0.0099080568,
0.0272312742,
0.0082772272,
0.0414832458,
-0.0402700827,
-0.0020761595,
0.0067588007,
-0.0194159634,
0.0291568842,
0.0252098609,
0.0335113332,
-0.0226357337,
-0.0544990338,
0.0341705158,
-0.0586937182,
-0.0206354186,
-0.0306865238,
-0.02017227,
0.0654457733,
0.087566413,
-0.0110838721,
-0.0315289311,
0.0199833736,
-0.0816957355,
0.0804890245,
-0.0482279137,
-0.008011057,
0.0003204774,
0.0293405652,
0.0283171684,
-0.018447727,
0.002812078,
-0.0049557816,
-0.0296965633,
0.104545638,
0.0488918461,
-0.0353785194,
-0.0248179361,
-0.0274846554,
0.0179009754,
0.0086762812,
-0.0512433462,
0.0682053491,
-0.0301758219,
-0.0220649764,
-0.03786809,
-0.0425182953,
-0.0041656666,
0.0814618394,
-0.0562836044,
-0.0545422398,
0.0421913676,
0.041163519,
0.0080904569,
-0.0511312708,
-0.0481215678,
-0.0387044363,
-0.0169928931,
-0.0062631746,
-0.021201795,
-0.0675676987,
-0.0201409422,
0.0223197807,
-0.0288265739,
0.0035698353,
1.697739285e-34,
0.0715867206,
-0.006477511,
0.0089582736,
0.0103315804,
0.0424745418,
0.0048931134,
-0.0346542746,
0.0019683484,
-0.0046725124,
-0.0641731769,
0.0175828096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12963v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12963v4 | AutoMix: Automatically Mixing Language Models | 2023-10-19T17:57:39 | 2024-06-28T17:57:05 | Pranjal Aggarwal, Aman Madaan, Ankit Anand, Srividya Pranavi Potharaju, Swaroop Mishra, Pei Zhou, Aditya Gupta, Dheeraj Rajagopal, Karthik Kappaganthu, Yiming Yang, Shyam Upadhyay, Manaal Faruqui, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are now available from cloud API providers in
various sizes and configurations. While this diversity offers a broad spectrum
of choices, effectively leveraging the options to optimize computational cost
and performance remains challenging. In this work, we present Automix, an
approach that strategically routes queries to larger LMs, based on the
approximate correctness of outputs from a smaller LM. Central to Automix are
two key technical contributions. First, it has a few-shot self-verification
mechanism, which estimates the reliability of its own outputs without requiring
extensive training. Second, given that self-verification can be noisy, it
employs a POMDP based router that can effectively select an appropriately sized
model, based on answer confidence. Experiments across five language models and
five challenging datasets show that Automix consistently surpasses strong
baselines, reducing computational cost by over 50% for comparable performance. | [
-0.0028797414,
0.1283310205,
0.003025295,
0.044952713,
-0.0361181945,
-0.0050493069,
0.0053740218,
-0.0249177217,
0.0327004977,
-0.0647094026,
0.0078447545,
-0.0276330542,
0.0064258482,
0.0594073869,
0.0309302993,
-0.022314908,
0.0258819982,
-0.0446257219,
-0.0219549146,
-0.0363923311,
-0.0276532453,
0.0151397437,
-0.0117204152,
0.0119573418,
0.0218312312,
-0.008640172,
-0.0042064167,
0.0040341797,
-0.0302223042,
-0.013190872,
0.0008195827,
0.0482373051,
-0.0252862126,
0.0617251545,
0.0000020155,
-0.0617639609,
-0.0333022512,
0.0288017523,
-0.0557499379,
-0.0378823131,
-0.0007092073,
0.0123598678,
-0.0141015295,
0.058489453,
-0.0388801619,
-0.019679673,
0.0402979404,
-0.0142096234,
0.0660052449,
0.0819199011,
0.0038407105,
-0.0045632045,
-0.0105174342,
0.0053610546,
-0.0331735015,
-0.023143081,
0.0213510599,
-0.0275785532,
0.0191911273,
0.0159639977,
0.0026855161,
-0.0058637336,
-0.0081317369,
0.0168304387,
-0.0361047499,
0.0170000438,
-0.0346446745,
-0.00262241,
-0.0293003283,
0.0187579934,
0.0078798356,
-0.0261589903,
0.0015262115,
-0.0185994133,
-0.0691798925,
0.0257407855,
-0.0223458484,
0.0059458674,
0.0236183535,
0.014627981,
0.0014152232,
-0.0073792026,
0.0519068241,
0.0233485177,
-0.0749274716,
0.1228769496,
0.0350552946,
-0.0031822152,
-0.0080483183,
-0.0013536472,
0.05205746,
-0.0816641524,
-0.0091661634,
0.0580461882,
-0.0188420415,
0.0228398163,
-0.0355184413,
0.000732269,
0.0363380909,
-0.0522466749,
0.0326729231,
0.0310490839,
-0.0188512579,
0.0495227128,
0.0102610812,
0.0256618597,
-0.002970557,
-0.0012199291,
-0.0260287467,
-0.0308346637,
-0.0000860495,
0.031295687,
-0.0063306689,
0.0255508274,
-0.0014132415,
-0.0196999181,
-0.0544933788,
0.0275842212,
-0.024643885,
0.0596477129,
-0.0003590726,
-0.0180943515,
-0.0074756951,
-0.0209656376,
-0.0203617569,
0.0186747871,
-0.0029991441,
-0.0087066088,
-0.0071334853,
-0.1039208695,
0.0058777719,
0.0069388356,
-0.0032836506,
0.0096159689,
0.0373338871,
0.0998508707,
0.0416184813,
-0.0091880513,
-0.0108084586,
-0.0402072072,
0.0335326381,
-0.0552796759,
-0.0426480472,
-0.091500707,
0.0160470288,
0.020650994,
0.0074125179,
-0.0401667617,
-0.0064342977,
0.0087748794,
-0.0278295521,
0.0402776636,
-0.0087327696,
0.0569640808,
0.0231430382,
-0.0081164557,
-0.0048869937,
0.1042535082,
0.0162599087,
-0.0439855009,
0.0707821772,
0.0012214017,
0.032895077,
0.0519943275,
0.0104816398,
0.025675334,
-0.016742589,
0.0329405367,
0.0255355611,
0.0186690204,
-0.0236994922,
0.0452488139,
0.0221792571,
-0.0273355003,
0.0296190325,
0.0113525186,
0.0177934337,
-0.0259122346,
0.0243192855,
0.0001160128,
0.0198558047,
-0.0277337655,
-0.0558790676,
-0.0068295272,
-0.0514470972,
0.019619137,
0.0880552679,
0.0545986332,
-0.0210750699,
-0.0295299795,
-0.0407515913,
-0.0168699808,
-0.0551619157,
0.0354111344,
0.0714047551,
-0.0104720853,
-0.0184914935,
0.0545693375,
0.0107806893,
-0.0130066033,
-0.0234188233,
-0.0370503552,
-0.0064631701,
0.0145081431,
0.071228914,
-0.0349724665,
-0.0249424167,
0.0017726758,
-0.0039956281,
0.0478485189,
0.0522223413,
0.0042351596,
0.0229091439,
-0.0350852311,
-0.0345050618,
0.0547714122,
0.0368558243,
-0.0250153858,
0.0729027838,
0.0179147944,
0.0089524016,
-0.0629674047,
-0.0410044491,
0.0388422124,
-0.0461005792,
-0.0301084872,
0.0430597179,
0.0000409784,
0.0361998491,
0.011630089,
-0.0047520534,
0.0181331523,
0.0140326722,
0.0048197308,
-0.0141374962,
-0.0137019809,
-0.0160739925,
0.0323705412,
0.0540863387,
0.0403534621,
-0.002327289,
0.0120906364,
-0.0635608062,
-0.0394543782,
0.0325449258,
-0.0097841611,
-0.0027721173,
-0.0134355836,
0.0311447214,
-0.0075094854,
0.0191988163,
0.000550637,
-0.004166231,
-0.0003817391,
0.0505461656,
-0.0258301068,
0.0058623967,
0.0319642946,
-0.0165043287,
-0.0304746795,
0.006895205,
-0.0261985939,
0.0568339415,
-0.0064202794,
0.00122567,
-0.0405707285,
-0.0154080484,
-0.0680724308,
0.004418843,
-0.0199337676,
0.0204361975,
0.005764157,
0.0222103596,
-0.01501837,
-0.0155728785,
-0.0236589424,
-0.0008876226,
0.0307647791,
0.061266128,
-0.0025811398,
-0.0122413142,
-0.0137609895,
-0.0267249718,
-0.0355787575,
-0.0347379111,
0.0823185965,
-0.0291453935,
-0.0056669153,
-0.0311767608,
-0.03316769,
-0.0513553917,
0.034249071,
0.0051780427,
-0.0166796669,
-0.0037828207,
-0.0634400919,
0.0009945617,
0.0146478359,
-0.0149934161,
-0.0633768961,
0.0655406713,
-0.0146270404,
-0.0587804578,
-0.0209986717,
-0.0327874683,
-0.0364450552,
-0.006789946,
-0.0295412578,
0.0106573738,
0.0186243188,
-0.0344237462,
-0.0300384741,
-0.0187687911,
0.0076407297,
-0.0199356284,
0.0379562676,
-0.0090401601,
0.015861176,
0.0121074561,
0.0663525313,
0.0289200805,
-0.0691232309,
0.0792395025,
-0.0484080911,
0.0224219374,
-0.0422155634,
-0.03311662,
-0.0205635875,
0.0292488839,
0.0117853787,
0.0426525585,
-0.0398567729,
-0.0075418698,
-0.0047343555,
-0.0018256517,
0.0233701915,
-0.0620122887,
0.0387873054,
-0.0390221216,
0.0197845567,
0.0249963738,
-0.0454984233,
-0.0460651331,
-0.0049335421,
-0.0895948783,
0.0179035198,
-0.0395347252,
-0.0341394097,
-0.0132138664,
0.0044921027,
-0.0219139811,
0.049683772,
-0.0256040841,
-0.0058710282,
0.0088044144,
-0.024150867,
0.0216752458,
0.0459630974,
0.0447108559,
0.0038418034,
0.0228830688,
0.0244325753,
0.0993396789,
-0.0332426801,
-0.042971082,
-0.0057154894,
0.0450953431,
-0.0539299324,
-0.0046372702,
0.0502575636,
-0.0093548978,
-0.0588215701,
-0.0337129757,
0.0991775319,
-0.0049658809,
-0.0418775007,
-0.0107013574,
-0.017287761,
0.0027985612,
0.0334376246,
0.0863394514,
-0.0809833705,
-0.0259007197,
0.0297924615,
0.0660384148,
-0.0136409886,
-0.0115075,
-0.0333489142,
-0.1394119263,
0.0480899438,
0.0031672481,
-0.0080779726,
-0.0107339732,
-0.0955119804,
0.0151884891,
-0.0161645096,
-0.0095745455,
0.0293132775,
0.0097913584,
-0.0378570519,
-0.0146779241,
-0.0624339879,
-0.0868432596,
0.0208143909,
-0.0597979054,
0.0573399849,
0.0395374186,
-0.0190055668,
-0.0179575402,
-0.0228916351,
0.055089552,
0.0137793738,
-0.0236179009,
-0.0191411469,
0.0429399908,
-0.0053891186,
-0.0090693692,
0.0319776684,
0.0052015646,
-0.0400364101,
0.0053471765,
-0.0094527574,
0.1043861881,
-0.0338538438,
-0.0081910705,
-0.0220769122,
0.0037678361,
0.0082432088,
0.0603937022,
-0.007583451,
-0.0100682238,
-0.0394735076,
-0.0428233035,
-0.0213808063,
0.0083798738,
0.0039490699,
0.0423607789,
-0.0063907476,
-0.048220735,
-0.0154073611,
0.013728749,
0.0258704219,
0.0381874256,
0.0313191563,
0.0338065475,
0.0275931861,
-0.0062479214,
-0.0510385595,
-0.0022104862,
-0.0575785711,
0.0355162621,
-0.0792680457,
-0.0004730439,
0.0497582555,
-0.0006852208,
-0.0141627509,
0.0012808593,
-0.0611969754,
-0.0983539596,
0.0393625423,
0.0824088752,
0.0293525942,
0.0417651832,
-0.0255787354,
-0.0665408,
0.0404857472,
0.0555811487,
-0.0381194912,
-0.0040657092,
0.0294705722,
-0.0196310151,
-0.0122255273,
0.0310511142,
-0.0965541154,
-0.0169993658,
-0.0266490616,
0.0100060767,
-0.0230938438,
-0.043998614,
0.0180859994,
0.0562220924,
0.0259867869,
0.0042015789,
0.0411950126,
-0.0354183763,
0.0328061543,
-0.0147259766,
-0.0310032442,
-0.0009218629,
0.0308275316,
-0.0083958507,
-0.0291843656,
0.013601209,
-0.0092382198,
-0.0121509945,
-0.0170493331,
-0.0066517424,
-0.0147219785,
0.0091380253,
-0.0112337712,
0.0547095463,
-0.0316426083,
-0.0029704063,
0.0039384123,
0.0056297961,
0.0412328206,
-0.0343143679,
-0.011062107,
0.0266768187,
0.0136733185,
-0.042096287,
-0.0031351524,
-0.0448930487,
-0.1177144274,
-0.020824803,
-0.0207915399,
0.0484827682,
-0.0034581434,
0.0472441204,
-0.0575608239,
-0.0032057976,
-0.0404343829,
-0.0137804281,
0.0301575698,
-0.0229829978,
0.0214925967,
0.0137594538,
-0.0105691012,
0.0330471434,
0.0734961256,
-0.007152678,
0.032498531,
0.0099064279,
-0.0109290089,
-0.0472866297,
-0.00171421,
-0.0138470009,
0.0464688614,
-0.0569471978,
-0.0140131861,
-0.0181133077,
-0.0529892519,
-0.0013418007,
0.0149495434,
-0.004016601,
-0.0123535749,
0.0016423768,
0.0925914943,
0.0535101183,
0.0470080152,
-0.061023023,
0.0109719289,
-0.0269269701,
-0.0146901077,
0.050966423,
-6.738132718e-33,
0.0190028455,
-0.0415905938,
0.0200190358,
-0.0513743274,
0.0313952491,
-0.0018749852,
-0.0133685544,
0.0118916724,
-0.0128817745,
0.0032439663,
-0.0181251839,
0.0209673159,
0.039773073,
0.0372186303,
0.0510824546,
0.0229481291,
0.0270987209,
-0.0139367376,
-0.0145650338,
-0.0029774993,
0.0185637213,
-0.0116266245,
0.0058187246,
-0.0671656057,
0.0084802294,
-0.0189198591,
-0.006069269,
0.0389226526,
-0.0345797017,
0.0593454093,
0.0010181388,
0.0423385203,
-0.0002518202,
-0.0137829212,
-0.0265798904,
-0.0555789508,
-0.040165931,
-0.0319214761,
-0.0325473994,
0.0240921974,
-0.0271770358,
0.0212431569,
0.0294281077,
0.0003469568,
-0.0293609966,
-0.0053258082,
0.0084835002,
-0.0285028592,
-0.0133918682,
-0.0268035419,
0.0263484046,
0.0443941988,
0.0222420692,
0.0017491445,
0.0464172252,
0.0261840653,
-0.001397122,
0.0364475362,
-0.0348276421,
0.0401627235,
0.0155530758,
0.0679958984,
0.0691081062,
0.0109291002,
-0.0202746727,
0.0361717865,
-0.015945496,
-0.0195552651,
0.0057132784,
0.0096591534,
0.0332809314,
0.0286211781,
0.048933208,
0.0153507823,
0.015395483,
-0.0172302425,
-0.0168935079,
0.0448888727,
0.0232150797,
-0.0149396723,
0.0290555712,
-0.019037962,
-0.0434060246,
-0.0329991654,
-0.0388372727,
-0.0500232168,
-0.0698995069,
-0.0059039341,
0.0117860362,
0.0146148251,
-0.0166910589,
-0.016656315,
0.0314417705,
-0.0537226237,
-0.0687161833,
0.0143453404,
-0.0218037013,
-0.0279244632,
-0.0023181303,
0.0552865118,
-0.0093354061,
-0.0320586823,
-0.0431715325,
-0.0243011825,
-0.0055961623,
0.0197172854,
-0.020712493,
0.0244802162,
-0.0870789215,
0.0112076048,
-0.0222580638,
0.0322375707,
0.0032893911,
0.0007722222,
0.0383863412,
0.0070656668,
0.0369992703,
0.0660669357,
0.0109397518,
0.0024660083,
0.0064784992,
0.0502954982,
-0.0047104466,
0.0138604548,
-0.019990867,
0.0013757006,
-0.0351712853,
0.0153015694,
0.022795096,
0.0003143769,
-0.0198282171,
0.0243126228,
2.782e-7,
0.0409049019,
0.0571959764,
0.0073851189,
0.0464025587,
-0.0106539791,
0.044654455,
-0.0231645778,
-0.0228728149,
-0.0025245568,
-0.0046813088,
-0.036642421,
0.0055532036,
0.0764075965,
0.0641362965,
-0.0501944311,
0.0162410494,
-0.0562858209,
0.0394469462,
-0.0734860227,
-0.0308863297,
0.0158846639,
0.1041626483,
0.0104158092,
-0.0058840197,
-0.015814269,
-0.0248707272,
-0.0066692126,
0.0099232048,
0.0049356404,
0.054842025,
0.0372531153,
0.033488892,
0.0419199653,
0.0008111677,
-0.0563049987,
0.0123270815,
-0.0450101718,
0.0488997586,
0.004827043,
-0.0109372782,
0.0202959049,
-0.0346875452,
0.0086522875,
-0.0663580969,
0.0484064035,
-0.0034659335,
-0.0312636793,
-0.0374484323,
-0.0141488649,
-0.0619863421,
0.0687825009,
-0.0228195246,
-0.0532771461,
0.0392635316,
0.024256587,
-0.029809108,
0.0049117832,
-0.0750835091,
-0.0402029417,
-0.0091551607,
-0.0182176568,
-0.006591762,
-0.0035712603,
-0.002238553,
0.0175632183,
-0.0185506996,
0.0063748062,
2.798234226e-34,
0.0487250201,
0.0308967512,
-0.0138320094,
0.0458825938,
0.0363546051,
-0.0229002517,
0.0093888007,
0.0244261697,
-0.0101240417,
-0.0496853329,
-0.0208589304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12962v1 | An Emulator for Fine-Tuning Large Language Models using Small Language Models | 2023-10-19T17:57:16 | 2023-10-19T17:57:16 | Eric Mitchell, Rafael Rafailov, Archit Sharma, Chelsea Finn, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Widely used language models (LMs) are typically built by scaling up a
two-stage training pipeline: a pre-training stage that uses a very large,
diverse dataset of text and a fine-tuning (sometimes, 'alignment') stage that
uses targeted examples or other specifications of desired behaviors. While it
has been hypothesized that knowledge and skills come from pre-training, and
fine-tuning mostly filters this knowledge and skillset, this intuition has not
been extensively tested. To aid in doing so, we introduce a novel technique for
decoupling the knowledge and skills gained in these two stages, enabling a
direct answer to the question, "What would happen if we combined the knowledge
learned by a large model during pre-training with the knowledge learned by a
small model during fine-tuning (or vice versa)?" Using an RL-based framework
derived from recent developments in learning from human preferences, we
introduce emulated fine-tuning (EFT), a principled and practical method for
sampling from a distribution that approximates (or 'emulates') the result of
pre-training and fine-tuning at different scales. Our experiments with EFT show
that scaling up fine-tuning tends to improve helpfulness, while scaling up
pre-training tends to improve factuality. Beyond decoupling scale, we show that
EFT enables test-time adjustment of competing behavioral traits like
helpfulness and harmlessness without additional training. Finally, a special
case of emulated fine-tuning, which we call LM up-scaling, avoids
resource-intensive fine-tuning of large pre-trained models by ensembling them
with small fine-tuned models, essentially emulating the result of fine-tuning
the large pre-trained model. Up-scaling consistently improves helpfulness and
factuality of instruction-following models in the Llama, Llama-2, and Falcon
families, without additional hyperparameters or training. | [
0.05628445,
0.0485756658,
-0.0525426343,
0.0246266611,
-0.0348921381,
0.0361052006,
-0.0327484794,
-0.0013903723,
-0.0364746489,
-0.0481684096,
-0.0464708209,
-0.0000685337,
-0.0126665914,
-0.0095434627,
0.0352818556,
-0.0632334799,
0.0323002487,
-0.0231878497,
0.0245773867,
-0.0076968134,
0.0313912444,
0.0155361788,
0.0190094039,
0.033524245,
0.0265394039,
0.0210701358,
0.012889849,
-0.011651081,
0.0146724414,
0.0159631371,
0.037835978,
0.062831521,
0.0396701954,
-0.0045780027,
0.0000022345,
-0.048193071,
0.0058687157,
-0.0158565063,
0.0041484335,
-0.0016038584,
0.071207203,
-0.0123324897,
-0.0000596115,
0.0266141538,
-0.0283731781,
-0.0210110527,
0.0338420458,
0.0286077578,
0.010444059,
0.0775495991,
0.0169246215,
-0.0269864611,
-0.0000717451,
-0.0163979158,
-0.0052234568,
-0.0171652082,
0.0343178362,
-0.0004941032,
0.0031249165,
0.0131844515,
-0.0319651328,
0.0117099853,
-0.0125102242,
0.0083480664,
0.0124355638,
0.0314669423,
-0.0284581296,
-0.0262999386,
0.0080531389,
0.0472615473,
-0.0608919151,
-0.0494651198,
0.0023330068,
-0.0433615334,
0.0245925002,
0.0189562999,
-0.0057603298,
-0.0103543764,
0.007843174,
0.0256450493,
0.0168913677,
-0.0514712445,
0.0312219281,
0.0188058876,
0.0192326158,
0.0396981761,
-0.0038389422,
-0.0495358594,
0.0075420896,
0.0085795233,
-0.0035737264,
-0.0391827524,
-0.0134089096,
-0.021547256,
-0.0264967009,
0.0164018199,
-0.0665128753,
-0.0059326598,
0.028318407,
-0.0072584776,
0.0552891605,
0.0087728482,
0.005609883,
0.0200425666,
-0.0077267974,
0.0279091671,
0.0088249762,
0.042064473,
-0.0455580801,
0.0111923609,
-0.0520313382,
0.0073129064,
-0.0368380882,
-0.0043711015,
-0.0146331321,
0.0094980719,
-0.0440138243,
0.0108241318,
-0.0088189328,
-0.0093251821,
-0.0063244808,
0.0010159313,
-0.0552993342,
-0.0060771243,
-0.0289889462,
0.0296916608,
-0.0575966947,
0.0272986423,
-0.0053102751,
-0.0427766852,
0.0095874406,
-0.0103877299,
0.0113793835,
-0.0383028425,
0.0306305457,
0.0265119933,
-0.0003956659,
-0.0414058529,
-0.0277985204,
0.0072485749,
-0.0187674854,
-0.0600609072,
-0.0026447354,
-0.071317479,
0.0015094515,
-0.0160753001,
0.0112872375,
-0.0486253835,
-0.014314496,
-0.0015708182,
-0.0931374505,
0.0593931042,
-0.0173146818,
0.0255440082,
-0.0166439991,
-0.0308278631,
-0.0009029304,
0.0774081424,
0.0377144963,
-0.0195684694,
0.0268585645,
-0.0225629844,
-0.0117740259,
0.0322415158,
0.0215612445,
0.0269199703,
-0.0254111141,
-0.0254841056,
0.0083745979,
0.0142407548,
0.0470011532,
0.0191945769,
-0.0321770683,
0.0003251174,
0.0985082537,
0.0302728061,
0.0357868969,
0.0372438096,
0.0172196794,
0.0339278132,
0.0014499313,
0.0342783965,
-0.0761907548,
0.0146995308,
-0.0410472304,
0.0213371087,
-0.0151835289,
0.0582427941,
-0.0202495735,
-0.0365913175,
-0.0061278674,
-0.0067203138,
0.0386949405,
0.0010874192,
0.0470224209,
0.0215965807,
-0.016512474,
0.0148220807,
0.0844158679,
-0.0150254155,
0.00886421,
-0.0700136945,
0.0313321985,
0.0600249432,
0.036641337,
-0.0307184234,
0.0009198262,
-0.0167389344,
0.0150671145,
0.0295166597,
0.087555632,
-0.0095680906,
-0.0094281463,
-0.0538882501,
-0.0150522301,
0.001110552,
0.0261951424,
-0.0039735073,
0.0243534334,
-0.0094610332,
-0.0144211184,
-0.0189545229,
-0.0507347956,
0.0315570123,
-0.0174829904,
-0.0267976392,
-0.0042138016,
0.0229902845,
0.0088743018,
-0.0266870353,
-0.0340712741,
-0.0107157072,
-0.0058355839,
0.0089494502,
0.0074293516,
0.0006785548,
-0.0221197363,
0.0067323702,
0.0053363526,
0.0142276967,
-0.0122063449,
0.0467218161,
-0.0475269519,
-0.0005107553,
-0.0160068106,
-0.0141765922,
0.0515970439,
-0.0239691846,
0.0367139764,
-0.0542019233,
0.0049376674,
-0.0611641295,
0.0315112211,
-0.0047702892,
0.004231981,
-0.0380486548,
-0.012850781,
-0.0396452136,
-0.0320118144,
-0.0406404212,
-0.0173576847,
0.0131372586,
0.0620130748,
0.0489526391,
0.042758625,
-0.0491172932,
-0.0517741963,
-0.0387461782,
-0.0060837185,
-0.0328752548,
0.0023464705,
0.0331279375,
-0.0051330668,
-0.0281797573,
0.0044529503,
-0.021362165,
0.0055657178,
0.0103538791,
0.0156006385,
0.0373890884,
-0.0014008594,
-0.0432475656,
-0.0442419983,
-0.0114175696,
-0.0008315772,
-0.0048033288,
-0.0077779223,
0.0310919061,
-0.0639038235,
0.0135274883,
-0.0187346824,
0.0328880101,
0.0026266808,
-0.0944278091,
-0.0244571082,
0.0034627633,
0.0237900671,
0.1140576452,
0.0185402185,
-0.0016299937,
0.0768441185,
0.0339993648,
-0.0471888371,
0.0126254773,
-0.043269366,
-0.0637987703,
-0.0594935529,
-0.0049443329,
-0.0207442492,
0.069589451,
-0.0058366014,
-0.0014991385,
-0.07797914,
0.0392294936,
0.0005936331,
-0.0564385355,
0.0092912382,
0.0092192814,
-0.0436604731,
0.0192150921,
-0.0270976275,
-0.0803253874,
0.0833741799,
0.0094313892,
0.0072456924,
-0.0490645953,
-0.0183177348,
0.0201313086,
0.0184725765,
0.0177778173,
0.0271718316,
0.050688237,
0.0268436745,
-0.0639494285,
-0.0390385613,
0.0513859168,
-0.0161109064,
0.0526071712,
-0.0567569323,
-0.0116515597,
0.0173357613,
-0.061799407,
-0.0392431468,
-0.057303492,
-0.033788316,
-0.002421974,
0.0259318091,
-0.0260324925,
-0.0437267758,
-0.0199231245,
0.0181419738,
0.0131290499,
-0.0322300605,
-0.01145114,
0.0010288132,
-0.007630677,
0.0728057325,
0.0052108984,
0.0244642589,
-0.0338707715,
-0.0084175887,
0.0188782215,
0.0298961103,
0.0105529288,
-0.0021076233,
0.0101461057,
0.0146243563,
-0.0309326723,
-0.0173608717,
0.0580350682,
0.0695343912,
-0.0314795859,
-0.0552028008,
0.11927443,
0.0063626277,
-0.0327796414,
0.038338542,
0.0085767871,
0.053559158,
0.0283550192,
0.0441596694,
-0.051243715,
-0.0261743702,
0.0100313583,
0.0418960415,
-0.0191002134,
-0.0196864158,
0.022143675,
-0.1200627387,
0.0346914269,
0.0456444211,
-0.0551939048,
-0.0385595597,
-0.0200290866,
0.0167123526,
-0.0250411946,
0.0259448681,
0.0155386729,
-0.0243506264,
-0.0071775187,
0.0107051153,
0.0180755388,
-0.0809226558,
0.0410437919,
-0.0675428733,
0.0657316372,
0.0484469831,
0.0313344561,
0.0018141728,
-0.0378869325,
0.003251143,
0.015091965,
0.0285472535,
0.00067035,
0.0474279523,
-0.0071219834,
-0.0158238765,
-0.0123015456,
0.044154603,
0.0059322529,
-0.0013466598,
0.0011529152,
0.0467608944,
0.0189279187,
-0.039268408,
0.014217318,
-0.0209185053,
0.0292004254,
0.0667748079,
0.0278309472,
-0.0775945559,
-0.0016338534,
0.0043439302,
-0.0524570234,
-0.0132879186,
-0.0564802624,
0.0215565674,
-0.0168960057,
-0.015483248,
-0.0605546758,
-0.0469477177,
0.0082049575,
0.0114497961,
0.0115218796,
-0.014572762,
0.0469723567,
0.018354008,
-0.0165225938,
0.032585647,
-0.0613017604,
0.0127416933,
-0.0422058031,
-0.0493796319,
0.0365464352,
-0.0414648242,
-0.0091585424,
-0.030337248,
-0.0667209625,
-0.0871168226,
0.0332031883,
0.0807106942,
0.0190763567,
0.0943847448,
-0.0101907533,
-0.0874132439,
0.0318340138,
0.046889428,
-0.0438285694,
0.052667927,
0.018013075,
-0.0670330077,
0.0033871275,
0.0511868522,
-0.0409691334,
0.0452335216,
0.0333416909,
0.0076458897,
-0.0219413936,
-0.0501564108,
0.028740827,
0.0099914763,
0.0578264967,
-0.0148282927,
-0.0096702464,
-0.0322733521,
0.0056179515,
0.0132325767,
-0.0309249442,
-0.0169811621,
-0.0342264175,
0.0121430689,
0.0302130897,
-0.0154963043,
-0.0367993414,
-0.0148196472,
0.0322643071,
-0.0583800375,
0.010384623,
0.00584256,
0.0227293689,
0.0433956571,
0.029279843,
-0.0254593771,
0.0252372082,
0.0054654712,
0.0644629896,
-0.0046936274,
0.0414798371,
0.020743819,
0.01334632,
-0.0451201387,
0.0222957861,
-0.038876839,
-0.0607676171,
-0.0278695673,
0.0289078522,
0.0498062484,
-0.0510190092,
0.0501879789,
-0.0370072089,
-0.0170326103,
-0.0242647137,
0.0231657419,
-0.0087397443,
-0.0128299696,
0.0139212934,
0.0213912223,
-0.0353160724,
-0.0099273967,
0.0450712852,
-0.0287705678,
0.0699938983,
-0.0186681747,
-0.0078323316,
-0.0290415864,
-0.0274313651,
0.0107870148,
0.0210445598,
-0.0259002168,
0.0196119081,
-0.0794687048,
-0.0608800314,
-0.0390287675,
0.0356555581,
0.0256258901,
-0.0451464504,
0.0412702449,
0.0446151122,
-0.0383257642,
0.0048848265,
-0.0401030555,
-0.01883219,
0.0032957378,
0.0107990066,
-0.022691207,
-6.585495511e-33,
-0.0183085781,
0.0345124379,
-0.0069952426,
0.0000433231,
0.0155807277,
-0.0228526015,
0.0106654773,
0.019843284,
-0.0434881262,
0.0264834147,
-0.0155503592,
-0.0273159537,
0.0036504273,
-0.0139250308,
0.0304711126,
0.0132750981,
0.0580143146,
-0.0229674317,
-0.0550625995,
0.0145367673,
0.0187416747,
0.0108193755,
0.0586677082,
-0.0552479625,
-0.0097122742,
0.003848356,
-0.0133619662,
0.0298993737,
-0.0442758352,
0.0850390643,
0.0250412449,
0.0479831398,
0.0072667296,
-0.0237061568,
-0.0256565772,
0.0060515599,
-0.0739495754,
-0.0216400456,
0.0661396235,
-0.0039620702,
-0.009988334,
-0.0075601609,
0.06821803,
-0.0123001309,
-0.0409010425,
-0.0015670839,
0.0303615462,
-0.0326769613,
-0.0032475311,
0.005689241,
-0.0754959062,
0.001254492,
0.0138362814,
-0.0512456931,
-0.0015667272,
-0.0162184685,
-0.0158982929,
0.0185418669,
-0.0303626452,
0.0073546725,
0.048920203,
0.0223490503,
0.0478087962,
0.0361738019,
0.0069929953,
0.0655133054,
-0.000302213,
0.0350046307,
0.0515574552,
-0.0113651296,
0.0965852588,
0.0180633664,
0.0036425956,
0.0636905879,
0.0387025587,
-0.0539403968,
-0.0322916843,
-0.0111445673,
0.0311888475,
0.0389388241,
0.0324446596,
0.0430962071,
-0.0518941097,
-0.0425805822,
-0.064087674,
-0.0065212189,
-0.0241802894,
-0.0255430359,
0.02890292,
0.0339862965,
-0.0430069976,
-0.0211874377,
0.0097723557,
-0.0368210897,
-0.0063238936,
0.0063177203,
-0.0402971208,
-0.0077465121,
-0.0232227091,
-0.029520914,
-0.0806444511,
-0.0407816581,
-0.0193696935,
-0.008445655,
0.0093857208,
0.0354105644,
0.0702253357,
0.0233476609,
-0.0562987588,
0.0219788346,
-0.0192227606,
0.0256513003,
0.041616369,
0.0157177988,
0.0395750888,
0.0256467517,
-0.0112441946,
0.0306445044,
0.0235145465,
-0.0662514418,
-0.0566659942,
0.0157187562,
0.0245761778,
0.0175654758,
-0.0267553385,
-0.0173258074,
-0.0409534313,
0.0008739415,
0.0497984365,
-0.0353555642,
-0.0157687403,
-0.0172400735,
2.881e-7,
0.0069771707,
0.0549011789,
0.0052535865,
0.0214395225,
0.0047358647,
0.0693372339,
-0.0082441922,
0.0417322926,
0.0506840758,
-0.0037932235,
0.0171825271,
0.0520571955,
0.0365310796,
-0.0011430464,
-0.0671593845,
-0.0038300061,
-0.0502221584,
0.0223757923,
-0.0128839966,
-0.0494185463,
0.0003821484,
0.0881903619,
0.0681538284,
-0.0078404695,
0.0182083715,
-0.0377114676,
0.0571353287,
-0.0631641448,
0.0061628832,
0.023668414,
-0.0336406343,
0.0325324647,
-0.0123707913,
0.0433950797,
-0.0027943838,
0.0219065957,
-0.0616090372,
0.0977195948,
-0.0341883339,
0.0429804176,
-0.0110955685,
0.0077217198,
-0.0174650401,
-0.0750730857,
0.0414548181,
-0.1033325568,
-0.0094072204,
-0.0302139055,
0.0076004071,
-0.0218651462,
0.0011925655,
-0.0241793282,
-0.0262588225,
0.0447541587,
0.0195826273,
0.0333283059,
-0.0272013526,
-0.0528402738,
-0.0284129828,
0.0718179047,
-0.0123109492,
-0.0957356989,
-0.0121110352,
-0.0107491314,
0.0005962712,
-0.0579207689,
0.0264089145,
2.54930516e-34,
0.0287939832,
0.0235690624,
0.0408935472,
-0.0110356612,
0.0410677455,
0.0107336016,
0.0333010256,
0.0293174312,
0.0404221378,
-0.0520793796,
0.0001917954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12960v1 | SEGO: Sequential Subgoal Optimization for Mathematical Problem-Solving | 2023-10-19T17:56:40 | 2023-10-19T17:56:40 | Xueliang Zhao, Xinting Huang, Wei Bi, Lingpeng Kong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have driven substantial progress in artificial
intelligence in recent years, exhibiting impressive capabilities across a wide
range of tasks, including mathematical problem-solving. Inspired by the success
of subgoal-based methods, we propose a novel framework called
\textbf{SE}quential sub\textbf{G}oal \textbf{O}ptimization (SEGO) to enhance
LLMs' ability to solve mathematical problems. By establishing a connection
between the subgoal breakdown process and the probability of solving problems,
SEGO aims to identify better subgoals with theoretical guarantees. Addressing
the challenge of identifying suitable subgoals in a large solution space, our
framework generates problem-specific subgoals and adjusts them according to
carefully designed criteria. Incorporating these optimized subgoals into the
policy model training leads to significant improvements in problem-solving
performance. We validate SEGO's efficacy through experiments on two benchmarks,
GSM8K and MATH, where our approach outperforms existing methods, highlighting
the potential of SEGO in AI-driven mathematical problem-solving.
Data and code associated with this paper will be available at
https://github.com/zhaoxlpku/SEGO | [
0.0104798349,
0.119334653,
0.0000395784,
0.040266227,
-0.0703805089,
0.0196101312,
0.0139054386,
0.0232097208,
-0.0171310008,
-0.0185288712,
-0.0057522156,
-0.0442972891,
-0.0241002999,
0.0292316657,
0.0212026108,
-0.0686352476,
0.0082635647,
-0.0686902404,
0.0300828665,
-0.0109450379,
-0.0264489669,
-0.0202272199,
-0.0446073301,
0.0238397289,
-0.0395568907,
-0.0472694561,
0.0123122763,
-0.0410950147,
0.0263674669,
-0.0326422043,
0.0014973093,
-0.0010440593,
0.0191281419,
0.0322549902,
0.0000024417,
-0.0464856885,
-0.0209067054,
0.0111935968,
-0.0141746588,
0.0111765666,
-0.0076955175,
-0.0413889736,
-0.00231466,
0.0184961744,
-0.0658813491,
0.0345817842,
-0.0000596667,
0.0317429565,
0.058600653,
0.0801138654,
0.000580818,
-0.0465484448,
0.0409212299,
-0.0196650606,
0.0377011485,
-0.0910817012,
0.0132949064,
0.0274118017,
0.0367014445,
-0.0206541531,
-0.0402034298,
0.021589065,
0.0355148539,
-0.0105726868,
-0.0121151526,
0.0180163048,
-0.0208000317,
-0.0062491698,
-0.029301133,
0.0438722186,
-0.0520754978,
0.0020257737,
-0.0116794631,
-0.0294647794,
-0.0233262666,
0.0004091414,
-0.063085407,
0.0076693725,
-0.0181557126,
0.0074597253,
-0.0018031922,
0.0152814332,
0.0327260047,
0.0204074178,
-0.0567129143,
0.1119108349,
-0.0119631635,
-0.0379937477,
0.0202633385,
-0.0381732024,
-0.1035135612,
-0.0412140787,
0.0451874062,
0.0599771626,
-0.0249572508,
0.0171669591,
-0.0084383059,
-0.0291590933,
-0.0571107119,
0.0101256436,
0.0665248558,
0.0741455033,
0.0870442167,
0.0291818026,
0.025836736,
0.0684889853,
-0.0625470057,
-0.0393737368,
-0.0385218002,
0.0320431031,
-0.0481956974,
-0.0082208505,
-0.0423369408,
0.0519396402,
0.0115276417,
-0.0194918867,
-0.0352513939,
0.0218966268,
-0.0316413566,
0.0170129295,
-0.0027180084,
0.0050460482,
-0.016275866,
-0.0693321005,
-0.0377102159,
-0.0291099232,
-0.0624971762,
0.0058513489,
-0.0179927368,
0.0033905741,
-0.0187595226,
0.0295093227,
-0.0167950243,
-0.0317163505,
0.0105929431,
0.0868957639,
0.0107173938,
-0.0223032162,
0.0023761319,
-0.0331446938,
0.0166638233,
-0.1227842197,
-0.0208313037,
-0.0724334419,
0.01276768,
-0.0081762355,
-0.0324246436,
-0.0458276905,
0.0115881898,
-0.0214781519,
0.0196507145,
0.0541864485,
0.0526603572,
0.0121416431,
0.0316955298,
-0.0021302542,
-0.0005777985,
0.0818915367,
0.074710086,
0.0067679128,
0.0061160326,
-0.0062136892,
-0.0088008596,
0.0560057499,
0.0223019775,
0.013476952,
0.0047770492,
-0.0175945722,
0.0249550436,
0.0530621745,
-0.0075687598,
0.0328242891,
-0.0387566835,
-0.0081158839,
0.0185005385,
0.0876633301,
-0.0095785344,
0.0362269692,
0.0228874087,
-0.0008566881,
0.0201893989,
0.0101035507,
-0.0509184003,
0.0030540638,
-0.0088691832,
-0.0055334349,
-0.0043038004,
0.0168673806,
-0.0203172993,
-0.0754693672,
-0.0274585169,
-0.0083655398,
-0.0427505672,
0.0127738016,
0.0698370188,
-0.0138726933,
-0.0416630693,
0.0229967162,
-0.0253856052,
0.0162818711,
-0.0045949155,
-0.0574344397,
0.0305592548,
0.0019479166,
0.0593700446,
-0.0758959875,
-0.0353310332,
0.0012928677,
0.0327333026,
0.0201472957,
0.0259286221,
-0.0106094657,
-0.0084904488,
-0.0328993611,
-0.0192968063,
-0.0032062184,
0.0237374976,
-0.0032626078,
0.0613008365,
-0.0164337065,
0.0157446451,
-0.001990106,
0.0068354793,
0.0310326442,
-0.0530413613,
-0.0655804276,
0.0163145158,
-0.0035357068,
0.0200679041,
-0.0226595905,
0.004798898,
0.0284597818,
0.0094919987,
-0.0389990024,
-0.0099583166,
-0.0116879866,
-0.0339690782,
0.0000321865,
0.0660915524,
-0.015731981,
-0.0107454564,
0.0167348366,
-0.0634776801,
0.0062699388,
0.0668550506,
-0.0284937266,
0.0255409516,
-0.0100604082,
0.0116377464,
0.0057160417,
-0.0404128209,
-0.0143311452,
0.0600595549,
-0.0135735935,
-0.0150709534,
0.0317725353,
0.0063575362,
0.0209956504,
-0.0593509153,
0.0595367663,
-0.0112112332,
-0.0182287544,
0.0344289169,
0.0059148762,
0.0177442692,
-0.0186661091,
-0.0368790068,
-0.0078562554,
0.0241308622,
0.008305626,
0.0619352125,
-0.0090052346,
-0.0446629561,
-0.0215316378,
0.0062230355,
0.0305346083,
0.0251517463,
-0.0048076813,
-0.0530196354,
0.0251203123,
0.0293613654,
-0.0153639279,
-0.0359766223,
-0.0159804374,
-0.0358836912,
0.0235369336,
-0.013854024,
0.0644448772,
-0.0274069048,
0.0480699576,
-0.0316289216,
0.0142256152,
-0.0171439089,
-0.0109449644,
-0.0017398024,
-0.0206497591,
0.0244328026,
0.0818750933,
-0.0080033382,
0.0294398107,
0.0005534718,
-0.0208755638,
-0.0466852449,
0.0152172586,
-0.0403032266,
-0.0179639049,
-0.0104779731,
-0.0235377811,
0.0234208889,
0.0957583413,
-0.0367054045,
-0.0299221501,
-0.044311367,
0.0671332553,
-0.0059559443,
-0.0198060181,
-0.0195251703,
0.0070383064,
-0.0289712138,
0.0307956729,
-0.0168404952,
-0.0569238067,
0.0567877665,
0.0309928749,
0.0025572549,
-0.0848988742,
-0.0075207413,
-0.0799426585,
0.0083753588,
0.0149672916,
-0.0005097734,
-0.0335065722,
-0.0050831954,
-0.0352293923,
0.0061713625,
0.0260892641,
0.0138399638,
0.0446461588,
-0.0330325142,
0.0260634851,
0.0113282204,
-0.0800900981,
-0.0426873527,
0.0244666077,
-0.0282472689,
0.0349897705,
0.0020115296,
-0.0486991853,
-0.0343864299,
0.0027480421,
0.0293615554,
0.024314303,
-0.044604294,
-0.0271231961,
-0.0106583601,
-0.0086833714,
0.0248999242,
0.018780563,
0.0263885166,
-0.0395240709,
0.0146184433,
0.0130292363,
0.0952916145,
-0.0099717248,
0.0026919728,
0.0354513265,
-0.0032066586,
-0.0578793138,
-0.0310199335,
0.0299013592,
-0.0147130778,
-0.067691572,
-0.0183744319,
0.0830805376,
0.0575573035,
-0.0190319009,
0.0124240015,
-0.0468521081,
0.0360686108,
0.0169147048,
0.0473831147,
-0.0411847979,
-0.0102385301,
0.0129677141,
0.0336750858,
0.0010133147,
-0.0185812507,
-0.016012961,
-0.112635836,
0.0371928774,
0.0195956826,
-0.0416883118,
0.0119049354,
-0.0090782847,
-0.0088231731,
-0.0330611765,
-0.0458866246,
0.0152596058,
-0.0401521623,
0.003026267,
0.009889584,
-0.0234989915,
-0.0359057374,
-0.0130067486,
-0.0178937372,
-0.0494830683,
0.0413569883,
0.0185539071,
-0.0179053023,
-0.026883401,
0.0438339897,
0.0315147117,
-0.0331277363,
-0.026571786,
-0.0202635862,
-0.0136278644,
0.0178590119,
0.0029883054,
0.0693679154,
-0.0394041985,
-0.0455350578,
0.038414713,
0.1126747131,
-0.0068665612,
-0.0144074094,
-0.0233347677,
0.0163042881,
-0.0056870668,
0.0412883349,
-0.0005606672,
-0.0258589033,
-0.0568526909,
-0.0388514064,
-0.010246898,
-0.0664700866,
0.0134962657,
-0.0223096423,
0.0395877026,
-0.0050029829,
-0.0251353662,
-0.0023593421,
0.0130676422,
0.0600658692,
0.0096037975,
-0.0506607853,
0.0304724313,
-0.003800659,
-0.0086457226,
0.0014531685,
-0.0265033692,
0.0315909311,
-0.0728551447,
0.0318518803,
0.0011543025,
-0.0146766994,
-0.048412133,
-0.0113169681,
-0.1006055102,
-0.0615651086,
-0.000887257,
0.0799248442,
0.0220846999,
-0.0046016206,
0.0067774844,
-0.0678104907,
0.0494343787,
0.0400792472,
-0.0103488453,
0.0132067837,
0.0393394753,
-0.0202337299,
0.0110868234,
0.0143098859,
0.0185083598,
0.0093223872,
0.0060075321,
0.0412594602,
-0.0194061734,
0.026934877,
0.0084105264,
0.0152565883,
-0.0299170502,
0.0062252874,
-0.0111184539,
-0.032071203,
0.0124920262,
-0.0035876932,
0.0268064402,
-0.0368858352,
0.011884043,
0.0382415541,
-0.0282183066,
0.0433779918,
0.0257605333,
0.0199882481,
0.0148195457,
0.0383330323,
0.0512464456,
0.020443948,
0.0071355803,
0.0651015416,
-0.0108864363,
0.037960615,
0.0131266033,
-0.0064308411,
0.0468521938,
-0.0029700084,
0.0449077412,
0.0412641354,
0.0124382628,
-0.0536989942,
-0.0288877804,
-0.0274210591,
-0.0870122239,
-0.0129374517,
0.0125495233,
0.0681849048,
0.0134121822,
-0.0402491428,
-0.0530151725,
-0.0211675148,
-0.0164449215,
-0.0010965557,
-0.0096849287,
0.005562711,
0.0220234431,
0.0392129906,
0.0151417572,
-0.0074093407,
0.0543219037,
0.0278676525,
0.0574797429,
0.0053947079,
0.035068009,
-0.0407252237,
-0.0343224071,
-0.0067725275,
0.043690864,
-0.0258665308,
0.0107697053,
-0.0824722573,
-0.0763697103,
-0.0054518464,
0.0072542834,
-0.0245180093,
0.0023516996,
0.0486116558,
0.0368184,
-0.0557508878,
-0.0091705844,
0.0039566145,
0.0048802178,
-0.0468684286,
-0.0408166163,
-0.0089613618,
-6.070705026e-33,
-0.006345266,
-0.0710005984,
0.0523411185,
0.04501798,
-0.0109381555,
-0.0315210782,
-0.0089223059,
0.022692075,
0.0106346216,
-0.0032911315,
-0.0212410763,
-0.000782471,
0.0018076021,
-0.0218053348,
0.0127522573,
0.0202415641,
0.0117007513,
-0.0387185737,
-0.0618824475,
-0.0157319568,
-0.0337395817,
0.0189093072,
0.0320816487,
-0.0431273915,
-0.021970205,
-0.0021556027,
-0.0174517073,
0.0622288436,
-0.0092615057,
0.1009354666,
-0.0213660505,
0.0045299418,
0.0130581446,
-0.0197543781,
-0.0165532511,
-0.0058396845,
-0.0100453068,
-0.0496643521,
0.0022423507,
0.0094504468,
-0.0476212762,
-0.042232234,
0.0079599656,
0.0335238129,
-0.0703740492,
-0.0304946862,
0.0104941251,
-0.0231138561,
-0.0185246188,
0.0314837806,
-0.0511900298,
0.0438734367,
-0.0082260408,
-0.0143032009,
0.0614508875,
0.0143261077,
-0.0182665233,
-0.007091132,
0.0391534679,
0.0279982388,
0.0319587365,
0.0124051571,
0.0533528812,
-0.0033479696,
-0.0082543576,
0.001383216,
0.0121738659,
-0.0350738466,
-0.0104222735,
-0.0515415333,
0.0575406961,
0.025551863,
0.0275509115,
0.0150673948,
0.0504686981,
0.026733635,
-0.0788204372,
-0.0033830113,
0.0008542654,
0.0522875153,
-0.0029227845,
0.031095868,
-0.0257250834,
-0.001639285,
-0.0576376058,
-0.0017803666,
-0.032311704,
-0.034431044,
0.0213907659,
0.0219991989,
-0.0056909234,
0.0072093033,
0.0401077308,
-0.033621382,
-0.0099850241,
0.0404852815,
0.0073579373,
0.0342071503,
0.0051688706,
0.0389427766,
-0.1021495312,
-0.0490892902,
-0.0315913372,
0.0080301967,
0.0234648455,
0.0088740448,
0.0141930925,
0.0415697843,
-0.0280329827,
-0.0010178138,
-0.029584894,
0.0046793865,
0.0599063486,
0.0710167661,
0.0326451175,
0.00820156,
0.0067242994,
0.0497658961,
0.0196292847,
-0.0247022472,
0.0028402086,
0.0363287851,
-0.0156022869,
0.048581738,
-0.0060518919,
0.0004485535,
-0.0262031499,
0.0063883699,
-0.016264854,
-0.0545789674,
-0.0393364057,
0.0100578992,
3.015e-7,
0.0477203652,
0.0890376419,
0.0064066341,
0.062249478,
0.0276357755,
0.0391003639,
-0.0361206643,
-0.0283618104,
-0.0036822071,
0.0062435525,
0.0339994915,
0.0504440591,
0.0339153223,
0.0241153389,
-0.0540231131,
0.0399119295,
-0.0077954247,
0.0137309963,
-0.076310873,
-0.0003500453,
0.0275642779,
0.064770624,
0.0334891528,
-0.0125657236,
-0.0127937477,
-0.0368512683,
0.074318625,
-0.0020735511,
-0.0181658175,
0.0424098745,
-0.009546509,
0.0508506745,
0.0114005608,
0.0114972433,
0.0032729732,
0.0527517721,
-0.01003771,
0.0820733756,
0.0233259387,
-0.0182695258,
0.0057796929,
0.0159807056,
-0.0072161006,
-0.047416456,
0.0688733086,
-0.0482132584,
-0.0399632826,
-0.0137546705,
0.0372302197,
-0.0652796999,
0.0299567003,
-0.0722365081,
0.0138084777,
0.0234202612,
0.0028440699,
0.0136930076,
0.0003918436,
-0.0277771782,
0.0056431009,
0.0273490939,
-0.050839249,
-0.027600443,
-0.0307854563,
0.0427571461,
0.045905564,
0.0122647742,
-0.030933395,
3.133632152e-34,
0.0426943302,
-0.0144596417,
0.0126375249,
0.0462056175,
0.0177610163,
-0.0032331387,
-0.0580581427,
0.032579679,
0.0311321113,
-0.0579530187,
-0.0146494908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12942v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12942v5 | On the Representational Capacity of Recurrent Neural Language Models | 2023-10-19T17:39:47 | 2024-05-30T14:49:25 | Franz Nowak, Anej Svete, Li Du, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work investigates the computational expressivity of language models
(LMs) based on recurrent neural networks (RNNs). Siegelmann and Sontag (1992)
famously showed that RNNs with rational weights and hidden states and unbounded
computation time are Turing complete. However, LMs define weightings over
strings in addition to just (unweighted) language membership and the analysis
of the computational power of RNN LMs (RLMs) should reflect this. We extend the
Turing completeness result to the probabilistic case, showing how a rationally
weighted RLM with unbounded computation time can simulate any deterministic
probabilistic Turing machine (PTM) with rationally weighted transitions. Since,
in practice, RLMs work in real-time, processing a symbol at every time step, we
treat the above result as an upper bound on the expressivity of RLMs. We also
provide a lower bound by showing that under the restriction to real-time
computation, such models can simulate deterministic real-time rational PTMs. | [
-0.0078893118,
0.0374280363,
-0.0232391842,
0.0191150587,
-0.0366863385,
0.0058442256,
-0.0243273452,
-0.0043545058,
-0.0347576886,
-0.0002632134,
0.0201758444,
-0.0519010313,
0.0297973193,
0.0269028377,
0.0483465679,
-0.0263693109,
-0.0179515481,
-0.0591570064,
0.0403956994,
-0.0181951951,
-0.0514259823,
-0.0348432176,
-0.0132047851,
0.0286248941,
0.0591639429,
-0.0208182037,
-0.0117745306,
-0.0573488623,
-0.0471055955,
-0.0081524253,
-0.0619257465,
0.0142709604,
-0.0115753235,
0.0152120255,
0.0000018411,
-0.0311717317,
0.0357189737,
-0.0092792558,
-0.0179725941,
0.0240366831,
0.0194728822,
0.0267197341,
0.0023014047,
0.0412971787,
-0.024022961,
0.0263708811,
0.0519118644,
0.0284691993,
-0.0085037388,
0.0487899892,
-0.0020563153,
-0.0163495634,
0.0533259362,
-0.0520377345,
0.0043672798,
-0.0147663392,
0.0393123701,
0.0065450561,
0.0180396456,
-0.0191526394,
-0.01631511,
0.0146918651,
0.0225066002,
0.0169932693,
-0.0387693942,
0.011687994,
0.0620761663,
0.029061852,
0.009733336,
0.0310492162,
-0.0701993629,
-0.0142551633,
0.0223153234,
0.0144213159,
-0.0039580264,
-0.052287586,
-0.0067923851,
0.0745482221,
0.0172636081,
0.0656912625,
0.0309095383,
0.0281050988,
0.0715169385,
-0.0127816992,
-0.0015773393,
0.076034449,
0.0338519886,
-0.0075982399,
-0.0584372096,
-0.0066782073,
0.0026732071,
-0.0665570274,
-0.0097295195,
0.0557028279,
0.0362426043,
0.0526894853,
-0.0354866646,
0.0119156986,
-0.0097082797,
-0.0882491842,
0.0367708057,
0.0329811424,
0.0758522227,
0.0299899187,
-0.0122791436,
0.0643687919,
-0.0360006727,
-0.0478273816,
-0.0042084269,
0.0160424076,
-0.0517656952,
-0.0265722945,
-0.0503735691,
0.0709459782,
-0.0067797215,
-0.010594938,
-0.0570672192,
0.0471303016,
-0.0099422596,
-0.0151816383,
-0.0002483158,
-0.023216527,
-0.0486243144,
0.0157045797,
-0.0866694376,
0.0032455563,
0.0349347703,
0.0074559241,
-0.0174267888,
-0.0651461333,
-0.0011726649,
0.0021214697,
-0.0098158643,
-0.0182075948,
-0.0505815297,
0.0491970554,
0.0054577291,
-0.005006237,
-0.0296817068,
-0.0068066157,
-0.0002996524,
-0.0369130448,
-0.009989921,
-0.0533035509,
-0.0027040017,
-0.0117602926,
-0.0192774832,
-0.0576843917,
0.013942454,
0.0182164721,
-0.0030349137,
0.0706892684,
0.0484617911,
0.0149222771,
-0.0058030523,
-0.0077168224,
0.0110720927,
0.0392004289,
0.0679629669,
0.0261748377,
0.0045677009,
-0.0185887981,
0.0477704816,
0.0475512892,
-0.0233815871,
-0.0182972103,
-0.0993106738,
-0.0349262096,
0.0458972789,
0.0230341442,
-0.0041626133,
0.0809256434,
0.0042330394,
-0.034414459,
0.0394249111,
0.0235142745,
0.0224251784,
0.0734041482,
0.0541380011,
-0.0134994071,
0.0308848936,
0.0337707475,
-0.0459501334,
0.0149399182,
-0.0362926722,
0.0363915563,
0.0328654461,
0.0019683733,
-0.0373683013,
-0.0464278795,
-0.0271292794,
-0.0401857272,
0.0508959815,
-0.0450509116,
0.0765307546,
0.0074397479,
-0.0617180727,
0.0119031956,
-0.0319294818,
-0.0034015609,
0.0280572418,
-0.0431395322,
0.0281389281,
0.0486280359,
0.0569017865,
-0.0447425656,
0.0587866008,
-0.0057739513,
-0.0141003653,
0.032585986,
0.0411246046,
0.0219236836,
0.0090076104,
-0.0196448527,
0.0182119943,
0.0231677927,
0.001834847,
0.0442659296,
-0.0249174219,
0.0602887273,
-0.0228635576,
-0.0283236392,
-0.0481864922,
0.0127522182,
-0.0133977076,
-0.0475757122,
-0.0024092472,
-0.0172425751,
0.0617709644,
-0.011362494,
-0.0008671395,
0.0542357266,
0.0060845604,
-0.0380133167,
-0.0594445579,
0.0075071207,
-0.037205711,
0.008605551,
0.0505925566,
-0.0187473316,
0.046153374,
0.0235718042,
-0.0118419435,
-0.0356174074,
0.1146981791,
-0.0348776393,
0.0253038928,
-0.0027552822,
0.0191370156,
0.0009300331,
0.0209044069,
0.0017405465,
0.0525860935,
-0.0240410455,
0.0589569286,
0.0143254744,
0.0070918696,
-0.0142411711,
-0.0630550086,
-0.0516431518,
0.0058055418,
-0.0201589353,
0.0118550118,
-0.023341557,
-0.0465172045,
0.0656682402,
-0.0337200649,
-0.0061237435,
-0.0328983441,
0.0063948007,
0.0276528746,
-0.0246040151,
0.0021940467,
0.0420033894,
-0.008784581,
-0.0507362559,
0.0057509146,
0.0022290733,
0.0108826542,
0.0792406648,
-0.010715019,
-0.0050485698,
-0.035182815,
-0.0391874127,
0.0011281421,
0.0360751525,
0.0060269316,
-0.0170604922,
-0.0203040019,
0.0077157915,
0.0025363823,
0.059212923,
-0.023576986,
-0.0432885662,
0.0005605126,
-0.0167702064,
0.0476152897,
0.0415439419,
0.0159459226,
-0.0065142466,
0.0278155934,
0.0072210906,
0.0022015146,
0.0277200397,
-0.0309721678,
0.0065350449,
-0.0224981867,
-0.0258696154,
0.017328145,
0.1471305043,
-0.0163440779,
-0.0219102055,
-0.0432968065,
0.0257853866,
-0.0174521934,
0.0104032271,
0.0038975959,
-0.0285059679,
-0.0228112247,
0.0337075852,
-0.0237232409,
-0.0606979243,
0.0517961606,
-0.0551067479,
0.0086670136,
-0.0119035849,
-0.0367763937,
-0.0264424719,
0.0606703684,
0.0417923667,
-0.0249656346,
0.00019382,
-0.0067605567,
-0.0068984781,
-0.0352792367,
-0.0162599199,
-0.0271140318,
0.0351682007,
-0.0378260724,
0.0295486171,
-0.0229960121,
0.0082335649,
0.0037439489,
0.0260825194,
-0.0429215133,
0.022636259,
-0.0108597754,
-0.0543664061,
0.0028269733,
0.0811809674,
0.0028427544,
0.0246857964,
-0.0162590407,
0.0156374089,
0.0001401939,
-0.0326319672,
0.0113883261,
0.0060429801,
-0.0024515479,
-0.0033250155,
0.0372979492,
-0.0310179256,
0.0127955191,
0.0122940801,
-0.0544932932,
-0.0083189318,
0.0140045499,
-0.0233075526,
-0.0330461077,
0.0620147996,
-0.023635922,
-0.0283804517,
-0.0138684968,
0.1083546802,
0.0008793032,
-0.00697958,
0.0143116815,
0.0230386481,
-0.035304416,
0.0348656587,
0.0147763975,
-0.0597487614,
0.0010634528,
0.007000532,
-0.0079708165,
-0.0122830002,
-0.0588601455,
-0.0233620293,
-0.0872591287,
-0.0190028511,
0.0007405074,
-0.0246854164,
-0.0456299186,
0.0248046871,
-0.0495982952,
-0.0219476204,
-0.0407690033,
0.0138955554,
-0.012603051,
0.0272252858,
0.0093988962,
-0.060187161,
0.0334821343,
0.0144659486,
-0.0016678806,
0.0074828877,
0.0277127977,
0.0279923212,
-0.0556353219,
-0.0884548426,
-0.0118202502,
-0.0174055137,
-0.0290167257,
0.0272942521,
-0.0549919941,
0.0324280709,
-0.033222314,
0.0176269263,
-0.0050067278,
-0.0269289743,
-0.0026660382,
-0.0090991221,
0.0808410868,
-0.012196403,
-0.0595632382,
-0.018826399,
-0.0176419616,
0.0341072381,
0.0699744225,
0.0331481583,
-0.0463519916,
-0.0635949001,
-0.0195008516,
0.0123550296,
-0.0363351442,
-0.0306446981,
-0.0647624508,
0.0421559028,
0.0053554876,
-0.0679870024,
0.0085818013,
-0.0319180004,
0.0249371454,
0.0035808519,
0.0057089753,
0.060409043,
-0.0223815199,
-0.0271088369,
-0.0102159586,
-0.0725653544,
0.0140048414,
-0.0425858386,
0.0171220135,
0.0415451378,
-0.0248390958,
-0.0261678565,
-0.0332946144,
-0.0678682104,
-0.0369956233,
0.0092662927,
-0.0023585991,
0.0300970934,
-0.0799706802,
-0.0416143984,
-0.0548962839,
0.0176396705,
-0.0549933054,
0.0049537667,
0.0317128971,
0.0261550099,
0.0437089652,
0.0277411658,
0.0521824509,
-0.0210582428,
0.0218063034,
-0.0172354542,
0.0047178864,
-0.006812599,
-0.0660893321,
-0.0435292944,
0.0042469576,
0.0117656337,
0.0798565298,
0.0011905094,
-0.0030824328,
-0.0098790294,
-0.0059089735,
0.0205343794,
-0.0690667257,
0.0096586943,
0.0273473896,
0.0321661159,
-0.0154159339,
-0.0515906401,
0.0179514792,
-0.0031734311,
0.0634862557,
-0.001901108,
0.0026012328,
0.0229201671,
0.0167028606,
0.0017615464,
0.0102289943,
0.0181481931,
-0.0496109389,
0.0042770198,
0.0191311054,
-0.0012934295,
-0.0041093323,
0.055722829,
-0.012647951,
-0.0340462252,
-0.0354266949,
-0.0590784587,
0.033317972,
0.0236597843,
0.0521953776,
0.0200370494,
-0.0278389789,
-0.0573135428,
0.0298763402,
-0.0632491112,
0.006558043,
0.0227396134,
-0.0144934822,
0.0618969388,
0.0434541628,
-0.0452218689,
0.0435263291,
0.0763638318,
0.0294953175,
0.0370700434,
-0.0004636837,
0.0077209622,
0.0072441646,
-0.0466737971,
-0.0432314835,
0.012950426,
-0.0015477295,
-0.0105907889,
-0.0470297076,
-0.0770521015,
0.0680842623,
0.0293530431,
0.0348069072,
-0.03511969,
0.0054778159,
0.0003012961,
0.0174317956,
0.0524277724,
-0.0323546715,
0.0375087261,
0.0343000516,
-0.0253896303,
-0.0381560177,
-6.122543959e-33,
-0.0180193726,
-0.0222642962,
0.0033330354,
-0.0268713925,
0.0144527797,
-0.0018013394,
-0.0530192144,
0.0112594506,
-0.0122492043,
-0.0115263313,
-0.0081909606,
0.026048772,
-0.001962191,
0.055916544,
0.0038062627,
-0.0181871485,
0.0300912894,
-0.0210309252,
0.0158684086,
-0.0021191144,
-0.0008655117,
-0.0176522192,
-0.0035031207,
0.040202301,
0.0305609573,
-0.038085103,
-0.0064329901,
0.03416574,
0.0097404839,
0.062920928,
-0.0510644615,
0.0277328137,
0.0230204035,
-0.0647617131,
-0.0290310103,
0.0322809964,
-0.0303920824,
-0.040753115,
0.0146111157,
-0.0171821639,
-0.0277971514,
-0.0261398647,
0.0935124978,
0.0077074384,
-0.015700046,
0.0232639369,
0.0111723952,
-0.0273092445,
-0.0423452705,
-0.0415892601,
-0.0047442317,
0.017160885,
0.0144116012,
0.0262120999,
0.0182407144,
-0.0285463333,
-0.035830792,
0.0168030877,
-0.0740387738,
-0.013885594,
0.0081674419,
0.0502427183,
0.0111837508,
0.0169829316,
0.0458250679,
0.0054940423,
0.0397341698,
0.0065780454,
-0.0445114188,
0.0467637964,
0.0177043006,
0.0099291727,
0.0829166695,
-0.0105677135,
0.055442363,
-0.0241834596,
-0.031293828,
-0.0234400779,
0.0553437471,
0.0293098167,
0.0396682695,
-0.0120646516,
-0.0484570973,
-0.0431408137,
-0.046639543,
-0.0465921685,
-0.0264292341,
0.0007725813,
-0.0063762772,
-0.0013380368,
0.0495558344,
-0.0325185582,
0.0030554074,
-0.0371624269,
-0.0052993358,
0.0075172926,
0.0485049002,
0.0070901141,
0.0184820183,
0.0315467268,
-0.0216550305,
0.0046460731,
-0.038689971,
0.0075981109,
-0.0144131267,
0.0336874686,
-0.0279803537,
0.0441282429,
-0.0577663928,
-0.0325107574,
-0.0139315901,
0.0189945381,
0.0223846957,
0.0991725698,
0.0541718677,
-0.0290436428,
-0.0051001455,
0.005036735,
-0.0532251298,
-0.0304431226,
0.0262721311,
0.0152808744,
0.0170220397,
0.0462600812,
-0.0447059907,
-0.0467427596,
-0.0233398173,
0.0744191334,
0.0312106628,
-0.0172436908,
-0.0070458106,
0.0444182456,
2.772e-7,
0.0147811258,
-0.0199403111,
0.0698526129,
0.0068335687,
0.0652489662,
0.017915858,
-0.0180493239,
0.0341919884,
-0.012288251,
0.0017430902,
0.001045351,
0.0289950464,
0.0261660814,
-0.0277518816,
-0.0941015631,
-0.0274521094,
-0.0486320034,
0.0502454042,
0.0029020461,
-0.010497326,
-0.0034541758,
0.0886626765,
0.0484290048,
0.0276841931,
-0.025688285,
-0.0607152805,
0.0091219926,
-0.0112503115,
0.0091502992,
-0.0233203452,
0.0234938618,
0.0630410463,
-0.0312391035,
-0.0344786495,
0.0167200677,
0.0578074604,
-0.0175763313,
0.0678627789,
0.0364470035,
-0.014283793,
-0.007598327,
-0.0717388466,
-0.0254438892,
0.0332157388,
0.0481836051,
-0.0371705033,
-0.051356066,
-0.0146637838,
0.0446455777,
0.0022424608,
0.0241145641,
0.03630336,
-0.0195301212,
-0.0244185571,
-0.0127018197,
-0.008350214,
0.025296608,
-0.0477568842,
0.001607422,
-0.0324086919,
-0.0599636436,
-0.0069431313,
-0.0521742366,
0.0176968686,
0.0419322811,
-0.0499683172,
0.0111917136,
2.285200278e-34,
0.0637123361,
-0.0431535654,
-0.0026747906,
0.0199091379,
0.0214368273,
0.0026014838,
-0.0258701034,
0.0066927299,
0.0592865311,
-0.0798285306,
-0.0562127978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12936v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12936v2 | A Predictive Factor Analysis of Social Biases and Task-Performance in Pretrained Masked Language Models | 2023-10-19T17:33:33 | 2023-10-22T14:19:01 | Yi Zhou, Jose Camacho-Collados, Danushka Bollegala | cs.CL | cs.CL | Various types of social biases have been reported with pretrained Masked
Language Models (MLMs) in prior work. However, multiple underlying factors are
associated with an MLM such as its model size, size of the training data,
training objectives, the domain from which pretraining data is sampled,
tokenization, and languages present in the pretrained corpora, to name a few.
It remains unclear as to which of those factors influence social biases that
are learned by MLMs. To study the relationship between model factors and the
social biases learned by an MLM, as well as the downstream task performance of
the model, we conduct a comprehensive study over 39 pretrained MLMs covering
different model sizes, training objectives, tokenization methods, training data
domains and languages. Our results shed light on important factors often
neglected in prior literature, such as tokenization or model objectives. | [
0.0466401465,
0.0191279743,
-0.0483476259,
0.0313895196,
-0.0106601669,
0.0381541438,
0.0778881982,
-0.0057138242,
0.015332914,
-0.0678604543,
-0.076082252,
-0.0246278755,
0.0003963122,
0.0365255699,
0.0486359894,
-0.0714822784,
0.0366768837,
0.0015343638,
0.0195896886,
-0.0429553278,
0.0053075575,
0.0109921545,
0.0426723957,
0.0316147283,
-0.0208194535,
0.0118673742,
0.0475776941,
-0.0287079401,
-0.0051037916,
-0.0248659551,
0.0470357649,
0.0633528978,
0.0038277726,
0.0347914957,
0.0000017925,
-0.0834535211,
-6.808e-7,
-0.0217825994,
-0.0162757114,
0.014604602,
0.0621325299,
-0.0279391948,
0.0117582828,
0.0447842926,
-0.0738144517,
-0.0392295308,
0.0189000554,
0.0420279615,
0.0162051599,
0.0356279798,
-0.0242534727,
-0.0319745354,
-0.0563384369,
0.0040036705,
-0.0645708665,
-0.0271323994,
0.0469565615,
-0.0197133496,
-0.0749102831,
-0.0216463543,
0.0032581436,
0.0054677147,
-0.0175383296,
0.042576462,
0.0283391234,
0.020632701,
-0.0257545821,
-0.0368794911,
-0.0248424783,
0.0249175187,
-0.0195706915,
-0.0498024747,
-0.0093458025,
-0.0088533955,
0.0193032343,
0.0374325141,
0.0081648715,
0.0081870044,
0.0279443432,
0.0251117256,
0.0108106723,
0.0292851198,
0.0114256265,
-0.0113069098,
-0.0179048683,
0.0677810162,
-0.0038260559,
-0.0345492996,
0.0030698797,
0.0035643552,
-0.0068748817,
-0.0757160038,
0.0179767683,
0.0105679817,
0.0063477536,
0.0346889868,
-0.0680053681,
-0.0836840123,
0.0098699061,
-0.0576136522,
-0.0064833849,
0.0159411766,
-0.0125558041,
-0.0078523327,
-0.0458363481,
0.0201134663,
0.0250562243,
0.0360451527,
-0.0209527705,
-0.0208290648,
-0.0071171001,
-0.040009819,
-0.0471771806,
0.0287588518,
-0.0202080142,
0.016271336,
-0.03703513,
-0.0052798684,
-0.0218755323,
-0.0181920901,
-0.0037592622,
-0.0145091936,
-0.0219510682,
0.0027775809,
-0.0209804941,
-0.0252173096,
-0.0422989912,
0.0364369564,
-0.04198502,
-0.061107941,
0.0421893112,
-0.0141503932,
0.0181937236,
-0.0520686246,
0.0277138464,
0.035811685,
-0.0232651662,
-0.0479009785,
-0.030925354,
0.0069688098,
0.0001326074,
-0.0404820554,
-0.0054198317,
-0.0108389081,
-0.0054021222,
0.0400341749,
0.0168853458,
-0.0186718628,
-0.0304862596,
0.0087773036,
-0.0463101231,
0.0510995165,
0.0063723698,
0.0347652622,
0.0613164641,
0.0090474328,
-0.0032030095,
0.0609354079,
-0.0089727677,
-0.0116250776,
0.0324008539,
-0.0600671545,
0.0322086997,
0.0493237339,
0.0256582871,
-0.0211242866,
0.0068999431,
-0.0073815985,
0.018642677,
-0.0504919142,
0.0826998055,
0.0327866934,
-0.0178087484,
-0.0270159859,
0.0615586415,
0.0460648723,
0.0070337346,
0.0311179478,
0.0008216599,
0.0243229698,
0.0168501697,
0.0310239587,
-0.0579090863,
-0.0276687145,
-0.030170938,
-0.0195917003,
-0.0374493264,
0.0384053141,
-0.0189006142,
-0.0067391116,
-0.0299570765,
0.0126197934,
0.054307878,
0.0012650681,
0.0386775509,
0.0166227985,
-0.0437088832,
0.02658429,
0.0277543496,
-0.015985189,
-0.0003191599,
-0.0353019498,
-0.0072361296,
0.0095567526,
-0.0187675357,
-0.0216407496,
0.0139004197,
-0.0026868009,
0.00478289,
0.0254507866,
0.0736937225,
-0.0040991902,
-0.0189972259,
-0.0351002999,
0.0130377049,
-0.0021311876,
0.0131729627,
0.0262262225,
0.0206371211,
0.0256377999,
0.0018047795,
-0.0227875691,
-0.0361143835,
0.0519912429,
-0.0201175883,
-0.0422431827,
-0.0407407805,
0.0099894181,
0.0505945273,
0.0057363119,
-0.0217426103,
0.0193416234,
-0.0046043773,
0.0109424051,
0.0107999127,
0.0303804688,
-0.0562219098,
-0.0170344971,
0.0146066332,
-0.0208451785,
-0.0099718776,
0.0944201872,
0.0137369111,
-0.0131094977,
0.0354688391,
-0.016407216,
0.0814764202,
-0.0201706681,
0.0298772678,
-0.0494892858,
0.0353942029,
-0.0282829124,
0.0301996879,
0.0065294784,
-0.0119589251,
0.00126203,
-0.0416491739,
0.007265334,
-0.0218172371,
-0.0146650514,
-0.0236659423,
-0.017553268,
-0.0162826069,
0.0030422881,
-0.0317180157,
-0.0302319974,
-0.0148154506,
-0.0972104967,
-0.0492694639,
-0.0320340581,
-0.0121505093,
0.0104973456,
-0.0392164141,
-0.0535149835,
-0.024321951,
-0.0494349115,
-0.0348954611,
-0.0019037048,
0.0324629918,
-0.0189204104,
-0.0083315456,
-0.0066328822,
-0.0341109708,
-0.0102599636,
-0.0091720475,
0.0365873314,
0.0162804723,
-0.073860243,
-0.0399926119,
0.0542694852,
-0.0301911682,
0.0484114327,
-0.0269908141,
-0.0200313143,
0.0208094195,
0.0642346889,
0.0573767424,
0.0631046295,
0.0033915685,
0.0164380949,
0.0686897263,
0.0072389445,
-0.0407069623,
-0.0259854179,
-0.0160050429,
-0.0169274844,
-0.0383835509,
-0.0650727078,
0.0201707613,
0.070099771,
0.045107536,
-0.0148410536,
-0.0401293933,
0.0247747656,
-0.0381909609,
-0.0772621855,
-0.013458034,
-0.0573077612,
-0.0238285698,
0.0393617004,
-0.0205998439,
-0.0685683861,
0.0550813712,
-0.0161253903,
-0.0223122984,
-0.0256798584,
-0.0139976777,
-0.0100179212,
0.0225222632,
0.0196185373,
0.0177722424,
0.0244147163,
-0.0497191399,
-0.0452122241,
0.0045937733,
0.0186739881,
-0.027040977,
-0.04227392,
-0.0073257848,
-0.0098026581,
0.0210117958,
-0.0166896582,
-0.0305424575,
-0.0712064952,
-0.0348971523,
-0.0100795534,
0.0439001247,
0.0136177978,
0.0173152424,
0.0136554809,
-0.0103729106,
0.0205650814,
0.0074448083,
0.010807462,
0.0096863462,
-0.0498819686,
0.0551400147,
0.006383379,
0.0425870866,
-0.0382321514,
0.0182543397,
-0.0085791079,
0.0705037639,
-0.041338861,
-0.0068005929,
-0.001873838,
0.0588554703,
0.0084614223,
-0.0396321528,
0.0097064972,
0.0594809763,
-0.0050575733,
0.0293661095,
0.1078473404,
0.0133722676,
0.0006502663,
0.0187702738,
-0.017529184,
0.0531162769,
0.0244665276,
0.0081186639,
-0.0570060983,
0.013072066,
0.020050969,
0.0192153268,
-0.0344367251,
-0.0232996996,
-0.0131047415,
-0.126895085,
0.0238711517,
-0.0035298753,
-0.0652517229,
-0.000021437,
-0.045263648,
-0.0050216038,
-0.0062016123,
0.0367364585,
-0.0234509129,
-0.0075703007,
-0.0191850066,
0.0459547266,
-0.0603247173,
-0.0385469161,
0.0203235503,
-0.0463156775,
0.081513077,
0.0308036413,
0.0025227421,
-0.0262611844,
-0.0221436489,
0.0475890115,
0.0390299186,
0.0257485937,
-0.055802986,
0.0662058815,
-0.0650309771,
-0.024237508,
0.0050170659,
0.0107242959,
0.0025954484,
0.0072959415,
-0.0044227568,
0.0240177419,
0.0189303327,
-0.0610781088,
0.0203025211,
-0.0023591153,
-0.0054378412,
0.0916568339,
0.0298572015,
-0.0262066424,
0.015367358,
-0.0018246419,
0.0297293309,
0.0295854826,
-0.0392606556,
0.020239396,
-0.0472679138,
-0.0199838169,
-0.0291276276,
-0.0619976707,
0.0600576438,
0.0446176045,
0.0309786238,
0.0041806027,
0.0265878476,
-0.0167262219,
-0.0272126645,
0.0443583243,
-0.0189885795,
0.0396555439,
-0.0305718705,
-0.0566885211,
0.0091694016,
-0.0398807861,
-0.0069298842,
-0.0317105129,
-0.018646067,
-0.0462588258,
0.0604498349,
0.0582867637,
0.0283204187,
0.0335984454,
0.0248349831,
-0.1095682755,
0.0637161359,
-0.0293818526,
-0.051883921,
0.0694834739,
0.0553594902,
-0.0258773584,
0.0109554483,
0.0119693233,
-0.0027288215,
0.0238935128,
0.0643413216,
-0.0307054259,
-0.0288907457,
0.0042728102,
0.0004504425,
0.0129247801,
0.0910757706,
-0.0360374264,
0.0281395148,
-0.0544765703,
-0.0260829199,
-0.0532941893,
-0.0173168778,
-0.0190460365,
-0.04064532,
0.0132562304,
0.0583213642,
-0.0330864191,
-0.0220724251,
-0.0792542621,
0.0254581068,
-0.037098527,
0.0290356502,
-0.0152584752,
0.0464982055,
0.0226681884,
0.0459001325,
-0.0083284006,
-0.0093786698,
0.011314163,
0.0177404936,
0.0576201491,
0.0423509255,
0.0086848652,
-0.0006570601,
-0.0166931245,
0.0370930061,
-0.037498042,
-0.0103014419,
-0.0214883666,
-0.0052544158,
0.0000570179,
-0.0616212152,
0.059621539,
-0.0154137062,
0.0140206665,
0.0052834623,
-0.0184203759,
-0.0046290066,
-0.0359319113,
0.0564552806,
-0.0216697678,
-0.0635981932,
0.0253109783,
0.1003792509,
0.0632609576,
0.0208424274,
-0.0123870764,
-0.0290336572,
-0.0279261377,
0.0159675032,
0.0679573044,
0.043371249,
-0.0234633572,
-0.0312821157,
-0.0756440908,
-0.0784045532,
-0.0189627111,
-0.0267717503,
0.0090543665,
-0.0201874301,
0.0242292639,
0.0588694848,
-0.0350508466,
-0.034922272,
-0.0337070785,
0.0059259203,
0.0543835498,
0.0106910635,
-0.012804837,
-6.040072378e-33,
-0.0244308189,
-0.0311301779,
0.0031867314,
0.0177974757,
0.0249475129,
-0.0002131108,
-0.0251817629,
0.0493281856,
-0.019943973,
-0.006669289,
-0.0054365117,
-0.0012461009,
0.0332537293,
-0.0207948592,
-0.0097438395,
-0.0023490584,
0.0592137873,
-0.0282712057,
-0.0146749401,
-0.0656972453,
-0.0033622941,
0.0286206119,
0.0443967953,
-0.0757084265,
0.0601576231,
0.0007219622,
-0.0086530754,
-0.017178582,
0.0203569811,
0.01570745,
-0.0253451373,
0.0271002613,
0.0245708935,
-0.0192108192,
-0.0469253026,
0.0719205439,
-0.0380298793,
-0.0355475284,
0.04801891,
0.0398472659,
0.026080709,
-0.00441253,
0.0371577255,
-0.0164834838,
-0.0713248998,
0.0475404672,
0.0384269506,
-0.0098711224,
0.0008254374,
0.0166079234,
-0.0542311668,
0.0122877732,
0.0178621784,
0.0139492657,
0.0373950563,
0.042065952,
0.0009664002,
-0.0097059868,
-0.0537851378,
0.0185305513,
0.0072074933,
-0.0259332936,
0.0673614666,
0.0563401245,
0.0552211888,
0.0582151003,
0.1039390415,
0.0691861883,
-0.0148431528,
-0.0003870877,
0.1031988114,
-0.0129402215,
0.0586554296,
0.021015048,
0.0108047538,
-0.023125669,
-0.0013800905,
-0.0140364897,
-0.0312854014,
-0.0484161377,
0.0245697983,
0.0237137042,
-0.0532041118,
-0.0676162913,
-0.032198824,
-0.0044635548,
-0.0029782017,
0.0011568569,
0.0343950614,
0.0057505486,
-0.0284749474,
0.0259781368,
0.0440608747,
-0.0339923501,
-0.0254203379,
-0.0467549525,
-0.0006768091,
0.0214089043,
-0.0039454596,
0.0048076012,
-0.0799095929,
-0.0097979344,
0.0130761378,
0.0295705758,
0.0252643526,
-0.0236395653,
0.0176578332,
0.0114241615,
-0.0706038177,
0.0089988392,
-0.0128706181,
-0.0021149544,
0.0616344735,
-0.0036007788,
0.0400001891,
0.0065713385,
-0.002450892,
-0.0185771193,
0.0367921963,
-0.0542749949,
-0.0556747206,
0.0264459439,
-0.0226704869,
0.0242960732,
-0.0259557664,
-0.0169251636,
-0.0206059404,
0.0120351743,
0.0940824002,
-0.0001168559,
-0.0064604431,
-0.0408055075,
2.433e-7,
0.0149894841,
0.056105569,
-0.0338676274,
0.0067465873,
0.0024098994,
0.0452949442,
0.0218370091,
0.0445060804,
0.0560015552,
0.0154200718,
-0.0088679222,
0.0057045775,
0.024929028,
0.0238977037,
-0.0356559455,
-0.0317878425,
-0.0450626761,
0.0141551821,
-0.0283573866,
0.0158720855,
-0.0234421641,
0.065373145,
0.0316197909,
0.0062762401,
-0.036115922,
-0.0501285866,
0.0287968796,
-0.0619475693,
0.0025550178,
0.0062814211,
0.0284186713,
0.0388857722,
0.0137421666,
0.0697316825,
-0.0140815983,
0.0392978601,
0.0378134549,
0.0313363001,
-0.0232190005,
-0.0031288841,
0.0113791553,
0.0084391348,
-0.0677423999,
-0.0780382007,
0.0477574542,
-0.0228906907,
-0.0243383124,
-0.0217766911,
-0.0027996139,
-0.0021320747,
0.0279086065,
-0.0274022557,
-0.0112681771,
0.0303580835,
0.0584720038,
-0.0130527262,
-0.0178321861,
-0.0460800119,
-0.0197565611,
-0.0329707712,
-0.0316225477,
-0.0399935395,
0.0080886399,
0.0184406918,
0.0188420489,
-0.0136647122,
0.0257460084,
2.197699647e-34,
0.0111213895,
-0.0136886388,
0.0304512233,
0.0086857043,
0.0585721768,
-0.0004550281,
-0.0293274429,
0.0390986428,
0.0301599242,
-0.0622788891,
0.0190605335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12902v1 | Experimental Narratives: A Comparison of Human Crowdsourced Storytelling and AI Storytelling | 2023-10-19T16:54:38 | 2023-10-19T16:54:38 | Nina Begus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The paper proposes a framework that combines behavioral and computational
experiments employing fictional prompts as a novel tool for investigating
cultural artifacts and social biases in storytelling both by humans and
generative AI. The study analyzes 250 stories authored by crowdworkers in June
2019 and 80 stories generated by GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in March 2023 by merging
methods from narratology and inferential statistics. Both crowdworkers and
large language models responded to identical prompts about creating and falling
in love with an artificial human. The proposed experimental paradigm allows a
direct comparison between human and LLM-generated storytelling. Responses to
the Pygmalionesque prompts confirm the pervasive presence of the Pygmalion myth
in the collective imaginary of both humans and large language models. All
solicited narratives present a scientific or technological pursuit. The
analysis reveals that narratives from GPT-3.5 and particularly GPT-4 are more
more progressive in terms of gender roles and sexuality than those written by
humans. While AI narratives can occasionally provide innovative plot twists,
they offer less imaginative scenarios and rhetoric than human-authored texts.
The proposed framework argues that fiction can be used as a window into human
and AI-based collective imaginary and social dimensions. | [
0.0574816056,
0.0632743314,
-0.0403921828,
-0.0009928081,
-0.0503051169,
0.0235004649,
0.0050258352,
-0.0075813755,
0.0156483278,
-0.0311514139,
0.0212907735,
-0.0360248387,
0.0400018208,
0.0719401836,
-0.0002080173,
0.0101366732,
-0.0420387909,
0.0289576035,
0.0644761398,
-0.0001507567,
-0.0274216365,
0.0725651979,
0.0097856084,
0.038781587,
0.0234091617,
-0.0215911716,
0.0039001086,
0.0250950009,
0.0036606544,
-0.0527035818,
0.0018039881,
0.0164916441,
0.0243302956,
0.002630892,
0.000001995,
-0.0511465706,
0.0672025755,
-0.0034985566,
0.0182923079,
-0.0015414733,
0.0434414111,
0.0360059738,
-0.0070405975,
-0.0152664678,
-0.0294667594,
0.0272769351,
0.049575422,
0.0575440452,
-0.034636233,
0.0456005745,
-0.0035460936,
-0.015437372,
-0.0257383417,
0.0035560366,
0.0165157747,
0.0476210788,
0.0037143577,
-0.0431170538,
0.0456083603,
-0.048529543,
-0.0050837221,
0.0024128144,
0.0027439401,
0.0237521902,
-0.0171986204,
0.0553003512,
-0.0097137727,
-0.0760278702,
-0.0008485255,
0.034074761,
0.0699128956,
-0.0419209115,
-0.0042822077,
-0.01332899,
0.0126997177,
0.0147662256,
-0.0226467066,
0.0833286345,
-0.0344581567,
0.0079590846,
0.0125251263,
-0.038590692,
0.008990407,
0.0242404975,
0.0603352487,
0.0257695243,
0.0043081576,
0.051704172,
-0.0356531255,
0.0075570154,
0.0176480282,
-0.0918405652,
0.0240701493,
0.018787453,
0.0124263922,
-0.0133785214,
-0.0353603959,
0.0366586298,
0.0046255621,
-0.0593527332,
0.0368374921,
0.0378159918,
0.0113992868,
0.0143618574,
0.0253543146,
0.0115287481,
0.0072857304,
0.0110958619,
-0.0095635774,
0.0361329578,
-0.0210196786,
0.0017863557,
-0.0097226175,
-0.0333385505,
0.0055820802,
0.0164729115,
0.0245646089,
-0.0105917277,
-0.0157007352,
-0.006418495,
-0.0722582415,
0.0179495029,
-0.0279772915,
0.0076553524,
-0.044245176,
0.0112627167,
-0.0912791491,
0.0171912313,
-0.0040170825,
-0.0690246001,
-0.000206902,
-0.0082274172,
0.0446404181,
-0.0135211488,
0.0511037931,
0.0001067658,
0.0180035476,
-0.0122517254,
-0.0450602435,
-0.0139973992,
0.0344077423,
-0.0410471633,
-0.0053380737,
-0.0369723588,
0.0496385731,
0.0205523167,
0.0136855608,
-0.0453895144,
0.0073036244,
0.0237609744,
-0.0136859734,
0.0248817075,
0.0061216578,
0.0066523175,
0.0552584752,
0.0172745623,
-0.0147785936,
0.0170408115,
0.1160956398,
0.0518501997,
0.027158957,
0.0037625208,
0.0771763548,
-0.0246134251,
-0.0292891748,
0.022924006,
-0.0041602133,
0.0099755628,
-0.0125979241,
0.0379799455,
0.0206841137,
0.0739478394,
-0.0097466791,
0.0247285161,
0.0532598495,
0.1211442426,
-0.0276082885,
0.0275420602,
0.0752962083,
0.0058235596,
0.0174485128,
0.036616575,
-0.0398978107,
0.0120993778,
0.0065461663,
-0.0251933113,
-0.0330487117,
0.0216661375,
0.0050797071,
-0.0110970857,
0.0008440671,
0.0172965862,
0.0424117707,
-0.0123030869,
-0.0108267842,
0.0050388603,
-0.0166607685,
-0.0897679627,
0.0241808128,
-0.0389198102,
0.025715569,
-0.0414726175,
0.1038089469,
0.0535236821,
0.0151167149,
-0.0065692686,
0.0269893762,
-0.0410013646,
-0.0331298374,
0.0274720881,
-0.0072373757,
0.0048988522,
-0.0291410498,
0.0039874907,
0.0298607014,
-0.024985699,
-0.004048897,
0.0415557921,
-0.0266251117,
0.0371570326,
-0.0111736115,
0.039182473,
-0.0794704184,
0.0466128252,
-0.0781233236,
0.0033498465,
-0.0492990389,
-0.0200509652,
-0.0002404666,
0.0040491545,
-0.0590493418,
0.0031447324,
0.0263321046,
-0.0000144824,
-0.0678142235,
0.0562733933,
-0.0286577661,
0.0223145448,
-0.0000948257,
-0.1062083095,
-0.026543906,
-0.0117444657,
0.0377173908,
0.0178593993,
0.0271959063,
-0.0395994857,
0.0269744378,
-0.0060930378,
-0.0354646854,
-0.0113135874,
-0.0082794325,
0.0137758795,
0.0002558605,
-0.0017635063,
0.0097449403,
-0.0429897159,
-0.0345274173,
0.0245247167,
0.0030427717,
0.0067068064,
0.0825797617,
0.0179997105,
0.0173942558,
0.0360152908,
-0.0204956923,
-0.0439985618,
-0.0377325378,
-0.085587658,
-0.0125747407,
0.0136348475,
-0.0235306192,
0.0075913616,
-0.0281451717,
-0.0599305257,
0.0237227455,
-0.0450083204,
-0.0417869389,
-0.0042959452,
0.0075088036,
0.0072445753,
0.0266299974,
0.019754,
0.0026390664,
0.0372170731,
-0.0266012419,
0.0369346105,
0.1018548533,
0.0050457669,
-0.0479882918,
-0.008038017,
-0.0708098263,
-0.0327615552,
-0.0312629603,
-0.0219475273,
0.0246091597,
0.0071008406,
0.059576381,
0.0329265073,
0.033120878,
0.0189824775,
0.0677144378,
0.0225677863,
0.0135409553,
-0.0213365387,
0.0451977849,
0.0292610861,
0.0054241098,
-0.0826593786,
-0.0068524769,
0.0135382973,
0.0172052607,
0.0228622723,
-0.0403351188,
0.0831488222,
-0.0127654802,
-0.036279723,
0.0449179076,
-0.0637017637,
-0.0028363371,
0.0801517963,
-0.0144527983,
-0.039814461,
0.0666644871,
-0.0123207364,
-0.0063024755,
0.0078544104,
-0.0192035642,
0.0040720766,
0.0733540505,
0.0175274294,
0.0433725677,
0.0506340787,
0.0302419793,
-0.0659453645,
0.0137690045,
0.0140268235,
-0.026365323,
0.0113549111,
-0.0345522612,
-0.0072929771,
0.0071959919,
0.0012895503,
-0.0274303816,
-0.0488028079,
-0.0463990644,
-0.0277355518,
0.0182083063,
-0.0399077907,
0.0034768188,
-0.0366787016,
0.0285348985,
0.0138816917,
0.0287686344,
-0.0156487264,
0.0174802188,
-0.0142234312,
0.0479818173,
0.0200871732,
-0.0094229374,
-0.0117066763,
-0.0180253666,
0.0343804844,
-0.0256612096,
0.0112750195,
0.0143574309,
0.0165852327,
0.0095551619,
0.0046493015,
-0.029743325,
-0.0041190065,
0.0418372266,
-0.0346188173,
0.0415173322,
0.0802941695,
0.0082786223,
-0.017487457,
0.0275783204,
-0.0150378821,
-0.0110002058,
0.0327532142,
0.0262294151,
-0.0762963817,
0.0509121194,
0.0313592479,
0.035830263,
-0.032629244,
-0.05806816,
-0.0359809622,
-0.0832049549,
0.0539371148,
-0.0045394008,
0.026121337,
-0.0083521726,
-0.0421627015,
-0.0208370872,
0.0319772251,
-0.0283483639,
0.0006029047,
0.0091662658,
0.0324994177,
-0.0634671673,
0.0107375337,
0.022139309,
0.0103710433,
-0.0551421642,
0.0692419708,
0.0514108911,
0.1081676036,
-0.0510368347,
-0.0159435924,
-0.0591495931,
0.0643360913,
-0.0081914226,
-0.0099420957,
-0.00021435,
-0.0040134639,
-0.0010249538,
-0.0368344784,
0.0543993637,
-0.010707397,
-0.0460656509,
0.0325729027,
0.0242976826,
0.0206913427,
-0.1120788604,
-0.009909654,
0.0008947192,
-0.0033125833,
0.0744111165,
0.0136144487,
-0.0482740775,
-0.0197907984,
-0.060195528,
0.0166850686,
0.0249881316,
-0.0667217448,
-0.0420232266,
0.0183519591,
-0.0081194062,
-0.0901922435,
-0.0921587497,
0.0086529953,
0.0306583848,
0.0332046151,
-0.0489471667,
0.0137973251,
-0.0155051826,
-0.0472098291,
0.0351637825,
-0.0059423428,
0.010910471,
-0.0029388655,
-0.0111599052,
-0.0234843642,
-0.0597770363,
0.0048960387,
0.0475669913,
-0.0341560766,
-0.0512346663,
0.0324593112,
0.0027771548,
0.0228767693,
0.0298378207,
0.0113581456,
-0.0179847106,
0.0194497518,
0.0200437959,
-0.0537851155,
0.0686576366,
-0.0555349141,
0.0856446028,
-0.0188727472,
-0.0034061719,
-0.0022443538,
-0.0060203369,
-0.0169861913,
-0.0136148725,
0.0044929343,
-0.0157489553,
0.0173693784,
0.0278524086,
-0.0210718848,
-0.0930956602,
0.012039816,
-0.065267235,
-0.0631288886,
-0.0104205394,
-0.0208084676,
-0.0321499519,
-0.0259435326,
0.0006757608,
-0.01735669,
-0.0213339273,
-0.0141409459,
-0.0357097685,
0.0079217162,
-0.0442783348,
0.0078252982,
0.0541814528,
0.0525510125,
0.0164729264,
-0.0024962083,
0.0003452227,
0.0259567406,
-0.0518038645,
0.0756425709,
-0.0013740404,
0.0038029628,
0.0164267216,
-0.0253694635,
0.0320436209,
0.0300911479,
-0.0312195085,
-0.0775729567,
0.0074589686,
-0.0045799245,
0.0050384481,
-0.0385235883,
0.0233529694,
-0.0008955122,
0.0071240971,
-0.0150689464,
-0.0043176212,
-0.0015204713,
0.007917054,
-0.0425491557,
0.0132719865,
-0.0453549623,
0.0430416204,
0.0361783132,
-0.0412674882,
0.0619216077,
0.0156245567,
-0.0160681158,
-0.0130834654,
-0.0386696793,
-0.0432111397,
-0.0106822178,
0.0180108231,
0.0129239382,
-0.0580847338,
-0.0373027064,
0.0205676798,
-0.0147808027,
0.0185209997,
-0.0661314428,
-0.0309346579,
0.0061784727,
-0.0305873752,
-0.0139248762,
-0.0375635922,
0.0200228915,
-0.0255447198,
-0.0058759204,
-0.0211094934,
-6.208515208e-33,
-0.018032128,
-0.0512420721,
0.0012094963,
0.028328184,
-0.0634816214,
-0.0378411599,
-0.0491741784,
0.0087782117,
0.0154657522,
0.0555904359,
0.0059760064,
0.0009635552,
-0.004427046,
-0.0465136096,
0.0127796279,
0.0104734814,
0.0144649344,
-0.0117188273,
-0.0508864969,
0.0064717247,
0.0044023478,
0.0254984237,
-0.0007110912,
-0.0717210472,
0.0695589855,
-0.062525779,
-0.020682523,
-0.0574991331,
0.0037472525,
-0.0353323333,
-0.0200362783,
0.0140373083,
0.0380313024,
0.0204101112,
0.0037210151,
0.0262578502,
0.0039433087,
-0.0106761847,
-0.0054026856,
-0.0192608032,
0.0092307953,
-0.0180274919,
0.0002315674,
-0.0078851627,
-0.0064617777,
-0.0034471785,
0.0589202866,
-0.0198869817,
0.0712611675,
0.0272701085,
-0.0649546161,
-0.0239122175,
-0.0109055582,
0.0006302866,
-0.0212457143,
0.0345250517,
0.0025840774,
0.0345793068,
-0.0460352376,
0.0236294102,
-0.0542325191,
-0.0054000332,
0.0002821087,
-0.0092230178,
0.0257394947,
0.0538842715,
0.0774697959,
0.042185165,
-0.0910558328,
0.0217734519,
-0.0069742696,
-0.0106350742,
0.0430927426,
0.0821110457,
-0.0199611355,
-0.022220999,
-0.0042043873,
0.0184997767,
0.0030507713,
-0.0323520936,
0.0009020033,
0.012447929,
-0.0259586275,
-0.0463288538,
-0.0135171181,
-0.0787366852,
0.0005335493,
-0.0085844267,
-0.031880565,
-0.0369393565,
-0.012021645,
0.0039493279,
-0.0247370638,
-0.0458578058,
-0.0000816394,
-0.0176391415,
-0.0568000041,
0.0043812012,
0.0382031947,
0.0026792996,
-0.0112288902,
0.0565589145,
0.0107985642,
0.0518222451,
0.071992591,
0.0225217808,
-0.0419786088,
0.0309740771,
-0.0342750475,
-0.0158256162,
-0.0272742305,
-0.0146264024,
0.0490981899,
-0.0540776066,
-0.0005167406,
0.0032457791,
0.0063630231,
-0.0449526645,
0.0355172604,
0.032533519,
-0.0372401625,
-0.0147476466,
-0.0574535429,
-0.0054941885,
-0.0458854511,
0.0210745484,
-0.0254575573,
0.0240558553,
0.073135145,
-0.0117863808,
-0.0292514116,
-0.0655993596,
2.858e-7,
-0.0204547439,
0.023292806,
0.0442079119,
0.021732254,
0.0000334255,
0.0531768091,
-0.0127053065,
0.0271718856,
0.0285381395,
-0.0249388013,
-0.0071610101,
0.0327090733,
0.024748046,
0.0497083589,
-0.0685283095,
0.0615847558,
-0.054103408,
-0.0121239051,
-0.0356072672,
0.0130062466,
0.0215203073,
-0.0205779113,
0.0646300241,
-0.0214080848,
-0.0045503578,
-0.0374871716,
0.0040706359,
-0.0531693585,
0.0076827086,
0.0144325355,
-0.0539825782,
0.0285122246,
-0.0056019579,
-0.0102381418,
-0.0253366381,
-0.00993359,
0.023660671,
0.0101135289,
-0.0272444617,
0.0400046073,
0.0374939069,
0.0087119043,
-0.0141521627,
-0.0557797924,
0.0466510542,
0.0544729531,
-0.020556245,
-0.0033710508,
0.0210579578,
-0.0252414253,
0.0140249198,
-0.0365256481,
0.0032729367,
0.0245545339,
0.0139201023,
0.0170234852,
0.0177415591,
-0.0279051512,
0.016351372,
-0.009326037,
-0.0346388407,
-0.0576729253,
-0.003583492,
0.039391838,
-0.0284585692,
-0.0482791215,
0.0196803268,
2.249774735e-34,
0.0215315949,
-0.0040871454,
-0.0422892161,
0.0106558865,
0.0798931718,
0.0473755933,
0.0213883687,
-0.030353684,
0.0556646548,
-0.006095144,
-0.04092535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10733v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10733v1 | Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Mining and Learning in the Legal Domain (MLLD-23) | 2023-10-19T16:49:11 | 2023-10-19T16:49:11 | Masoud Makrehchi, Dell Zhang, Alina Petrova, John Armour | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.IR | This is the Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop on Mining and
Learning in the Legal Domain (MLLD-23) which took place in conjunction with the
32nd ACM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management
(CIKM-2023) at the University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK on Sunday 22nd
October 2023. | [
0.0209711492,
0.0046777539,
-0.0320981778,
0.0243203156,
-0.0748330876,
-0.0086495206,
0.0205780771,
0.0415109619,
0.0012757489,
-0.0110780541,
0.0220617689,
0.0752839893,
-0.0762101337,
0.0185496286,
-0.032327164,
-0.0249717385,
0.041514013,
-0.0168502238,
-0.0011288304,
0.0271115862,
-0.0303836837,
-0.0314530656,
0.0121653015,
0.0009592954,
-0.0154989762,
0.0153273903,
-0.0328951813,
-0.0087005207,
0.0254342016,
-0.0174073447,
-0.0073012966,
0.0187257174,
-0.0083975568,
0.0318015032,
0.0000020351,
-0.0689529181,
-0.0626542196,
0.0258623995,
0.0316605866,
0.0269687399,
-0.030545149,
-0.0052490486,
-0.0257329307,
0.0272422768,
-0.0677444115,
0.0545830168,
-0.007139666,
-0.0169785693,
0.0138050718,
0.0052662562,
-0.0040947385,
0.017985953,
-0.0251193978,
-0.0610388033,
-0.0571992658,
-0.0644807145,
0.0031901256,
0.0687837154,
0.0199095644,
-0.0068432442,
0.0277888104,
0.0557837598,
-0.0248422548,
-0.0373405218,
0.0267393198,
-0.0209955536,
-0.0159524512,
0.0083503509,
0.0135572422,
0.0070603085,
0.0688687712,
0.0067020478,
-0.0166470706,
-0.0053766123,
0.0363563783,
0.0270212758,
-0.0061789523,
0.1019169092,
-0.0450313389,
0.0342982076,
-0.0450440794,
0.0451172888,
0.0035201286,
0.0318782516,
-0.0106707988,
0.0261355154,
-0.0496081933,
-0.0310657136,
-0.0180691704,
0.0422934182,
0.0311603509,
0.0412236974,
0.0259159673,
0.0171244666,
0.0113501521,
-0.0029614442,
0.0395416394,
0.0326846018,
0.0712085962,
-0.0261900891,
-0.0105855353,
0.0233599395,
-0.0004869651,
0.0764444172,
-0.0227083322,
-0.0644684806,
0.0057102144,
0.0102470852,
0.0235433243,
0.0146850869,
-0.0293238182,
0.0083875386,
-0.0335117467,
0.0080027934,
-0.0556736924,
0.030846661,
0.0160920452,
0.027976241,
-0.0219650585,
0.0490799658,
-0.0174085833,
0.0120778885,
0.0217607729,
-0.0372935198,
-0.0564723127,
-0.0577880107,
-0.0245407205,
0.0795625374,
0.0012611335,
0.0471527167,
0.020516187,
-0.0106087541,
0.0063459179,
0.0383488946,
-0.0045023686,
0.0667170733,
0.0084388051,
-0.0295580719,
-0.1256722957,
-0.0763459653,
0.0490769371,
0.0080253575,
-0.0402200632,
-0.008700788,
0.0088819601,
-0.0390643515,
-0.0267570969,
-0.0380274169,
-0.0131431315,
-0.0220752414,
0.008088314,
-0.0006940392,
-0.0322746895,
-0.0111787105,
-0.022540506,
0.091899924,
0.0434378684,
0.0240927953,
0.021521654,
0.0447218008,
-0.0112367189,
0.0025745216,
-0.0143562192,
-0.0088361586,
-0.0192770846,
-0.0276858211,
0.0239274092,
0.0197392106,
0.0251804013,
-0.0172294844,
-0.0370805264,
-0.0176350176,
-0.0297837425,
0.0174016636,
0.0364859141,
-0.0024693306,
0.0253261477,
0.0190162957,
-0.0260584485,
-0.030461153,
0.0092911934,
-0.0610624105,
0.0145806652,
-0.0165732726,
0.0028378109,
-0.0153872706,
-0.0030987766,
0.0256390013,
0.0139569342,
-0.0714396909,
-0.0157557037,
0.0109396353,
0.0225614179,
-0.0017999006,
0.0146394474,
-0.0105598448,
-0.0009630531,
-0.0187147725,
0.0033647954,
0.0032436426,
-0.0433827862,
-0.0559907593,
0.036449533,
-0.0087031852,
-0.0055152364,
-0.0590626709,
-0.0030226877,
-0.017268585,
-0.0880525261,
0.0725712478,
-0.0074691749,
-0.024991747,
-0.0236543957,
0.0139778489,
-0.0708231702,
-0.0153282378,
-0.0065767402,
0.0265866816,
-0.0314558968,
0.0237833727,
0.0053151078,
-0.0146080172,
-0.0167547259,
-0.016283771,
0.0037389293,
-0.0220568329,
-0.0205220245,
0.0416242927,
-0.0027725215,
0.0511704274,
0.0266685206,
-0.0066935886,
0.0766038448,
0.0076151616,
-0.026471734,
0.0103133833,
0.0713635683,
0.0835478902,
0.0508490391,
-0.0799659565,
0.0780118927,
-0.079229176,
-0.0184535962,
-0.0132712033,
0.0100791343,
0.0553952344,
0.10999538,
-0.0363898277,
-0.0107125659,
-0.0211707242,
0.0166066717,
-0.056416586,
0.0212146994,
0.0025371849,
-0.0563029982,
0.0020301389,
-0.065311946,
0.0696293488,
-0.0310753658,
0.0277446024,
-0.00554435,
-0.0602679588,
-0.0170102548,
0.0026558319,
-0.0126461908,
-0.0100479973,
-0.0067177396,
0.0219835211,
-0.0237363018,
-0.023332119,
0.04955272,
-0.0013838245,
-0.0256311428,
-0.0360733233,
-0.0133742848,
0.034865424,
-0.0597511604,
0.0368562862,
-0.0581967123,
0.0032528685,
0.0060108793,
0.0237653572,
0.0285520609,
-0.0129553135,
-0.0202141851,
0.0190224592,
0.0329905599,
0.0055975071,
-0.0627368167,
0.0647196323,
-0.0101220189,
-0.051170487,
-0.0329444855,
0.0271011647,
0.0011416363,
0.022659447,
-0.0248505231,
-0.0398595706,
0.015262044,
0.0432434976,
0.0663792267,
-0.0078103105,
-0.0140288714,
-0.0339919627,
0.0441541821,
0.0372890681,
0.0321149901,
0.0465539321,
0.0298874062,
-0.0122404667,
-0.0269698445,
0.0069962414,
0.0093642147,
0.0057040541,
-0.0010182492,
-0.0171118136,
-0.0086192954,
-0.0673319027,
0.0078241089,
0.0570256524,
0.0335221402,
-0.066926904,
0.0323667675,
0.0028013564,
0.0434418432,
-0.0745670795,
-0.0692055002,
-0.0394163616,
0.0527396798,
-0.0396895036,
0.0332569331,
0.0475140437,
-0.0060474537,
0.0043566418,
-0.0467180833,
0.0770922974,
-0.0410244837,
-0.0284945723,
-0.0115630571,
0.0086225551,
-0.0109435022,
-0.0261891261,
-0.0403571911,
0.0268739145,
0.0610347502,
0.0594153963,
-0.0164452195,
0.0103297671,
0.0013623295,
0.0693206117,
0.015100548,
-0.0395581834,
0.0465020239,
-0.0118392874,
-0.0220938995,
0.0432416834,
-0.0411866121,
0.0103945881,
0.0498701259,
0.0303411316,
-0.0103734387,
0.0257540867,
-0.0105563374,
-0.023320023,
0.0270114467,
0.0319340453,
0.0167069379,
-0.0081250509,
0.0456784479,
0.0016721217,
-0.0644278079,
0.0131442547,
-0.0168080423,
-0.0172611047,
0.0237198249,
-0.0653621033,
0.0136767719,
0.0104230046,
-0.0425837636,
0.0013306236,
0.0057521435,
-0.0965386927,
0.1052726805,
0.0000437667,
0.0314138867,
-0.0702242032,
-0.0011802324,
-0.0064177653,
-0.0276974607,
0.0898910761,
0.012420157,
-0.029118387,
-0.0261669792,
0.0069095963,
-0.0195192359,
-0.0117664468,
-0.0393320471,
-0.0240810886,
-0.0304989927,
-0.0099611292,
0.0928182453,
-0.0456226952,
-0.0001228194,
-0.0482152998,
-0.0545901321,
-0.0012639248,
0.0850130096,
-0.0010820499,
0.0011644152,
0.0036503596,
-0.0405990928,
0.0164814591,
0.0125272134,
0.0033794793,
-0.0021520187,
0.0161272772,
0.002797026,
0.020346364,
0.0551420897,
0.0047721346,
-0.0686158463,
0.0191563722,
0.0989050567,
-0.0489254482,
0.0017415237,
-0.029442586,
-0.0505683385,
0.0371994488,
0.0123719769,
-0.0261979997,
0.0231519081,
0.0017644473,
-0.0272195376,
0.0045899418,
-0.0038139501,
-0.0156315826,
0.0081500225,
0.0406367108,
0.0520099066,
-0.0181327015,
-0.0559506752,
0.0090305135,
0.0847805366,
-0.0006275397,
-0.0313416235,
0.0173153654,
-0.0001291707,
-0.0569339395,
0.018474102,
-0.0107927034,
0.0025855138,
-0.0491641015,
-0.0271021593,
-0.0046116384,
-0.031190984,
-0.0025943473,
-0.0580848679,
-0.0570383146,
0.0030261278,
-0.0032379455,
0.0246954784,
0.0351762921,
-0.0028884502,
-0.0152775897,
-0.0006423407,
0.0627448186,
0.0177593529,
-0.0227821693,
-0.0455125906,
0.0132347075,
0.0153039834,
-0.0528604016,
-0.0405903682,
0.036225792,
-0.0003077639,
0.0448678769,
-0.0180797484,
-0.0050397548,
-0.0392388664,
0.0235360228,
0.021632053,
0.0201200359,
0.0406017825,
-0.0289349183,
0.0138172517,
0.0394698568,
0.0721258819,
-0.00155851,
-0.0372478366,
-0.0400948189,
0.0060353004,
-0.0247698873,
-0.0218420904,
0.084358871,
0.0181165114,
-0.0148070641,
-0.0655828938,
0.0475702621,
-0.0002147338,
-0.0005659899,
0.0224772468,
-0.0075774631,
0.0040780162,
-0.0083700297,
-0.0096640596,
0.0928092822,
0.006234624,
0.0508815609,
0.0186285917,
0.0118374089,
-0.0049610608,
0.0235853754,
-0.0046070907,
-0.0358957425,
0.0079250401,
0.0272538457,
0.03294833,
0.0117268329,
-0.0014419681,
-0.0697153434,
0.0344091468,
0.0372073874,
0.0105046974,
-0.0220395364,
-0.0301155876,
-0.0015246272,
0.0086922683,
-0.002758502,
0.0513586663,
-0.0108798733,
-0.0040052631,
-0.014823419,
-0.0991724432,
-0.01178707,
0.0104226964,
-0.0580579713,
0.0293491147,
0.0067936722,
-0.0305947401,
-0.0072189462,
-0.088393338,
-0.0038017759,
-0.034020111,
0.0323109105,
0.0009947115,
-0.0143648861,
-0.0068565779,
0.030194385,
0.0597493872,
-0.0295497943,
0.005699445,
-0.0493622981,
-0.0028239323,
0.0378726721,
-0.0396437943,
-5.952028953e-33,
-0.018541595,
-0.0682788566,
0.0328760147,
0.0342149809,
-0.0204144809,
-0.0752681196,
-0.0081582414,
-0.0126630142,
0.0126466816,
-0.0221074764,
-0.0147907166,
0.0063456548,
0.0330565721,
0.0202151071,
0.0154370796,
0.0099824704,
0.0099601662,
0.0240345988,
-0.0198146198,
-0.006767753,
-0.0035514289,
0.0468020886,
0.0483246334,
-0.0530031472,
0.0679475442,
0.0888784826,
-0.0339295641,
0.0009768358,
-0.0612445921,
0.0392023586,
-0.0213191789,
0.0016208801,
0.0234315284,
-0.034270253,
0.0140289525,
-0.0212704036,
-0.0590913519,
0.0533048511,
-0.0192395039,
0.0331344232,
0.0598595999,
-0.0216940623,
0.0453587472,
-0.0425599106,
-0.026219964,
-0.0176516362,
0.0233802572,
-0.0214087199,
-0.0417828262,
-0.052359663,
-0.0599671677,
-0.0107147479,
-0.0288290828,
0.0571709052,
0.0365170091,
-0.0139987962,
0.0139015466,
-0.0234795492,
-0.1016103849,
0.0531932972,
-0.0042185988,
-0.0345368646,
0.0405706987,
0.0003026113,
-0.0051599001,
0.0354143381,
-0.038370546,
0.0360519364,
0.0367818065,
0.0034806405,
0.0109689077,
0.1138802692,
-0.0284866206,
0.0066205347,
-0.011381533,
0.0040344778,
-0.0680329502,
-0.0020882981,
0.0715792924,
-0.0167717822,
0.0138581842,
-0.0122002074,
0.0089847613,
-0.0433157012,
-0.0226376634,
-0.0056669232,
0.0098249828,
0.001659296,
0.0009550283,
0.0092860069,
0.0001063269,
-0.0027941102,
-0.0324629731,
-0.0589303821,
0.0066955728,
0.0298357643,
0.0420712493,
0.0218696743,
-0.0186884757,
-0.0352103487,
-0.0366461463,
-0.0562432148,
-0.0514870249,
-0.0394943506,
0.0109361066,
-0.0272373985,
-0.0308121294,
0.0075827395,
0.0005648275,
0.051329501,
0.0007617676,
0.002754661,
0.0618475638,
-0.0451259501,
-0.0202289689,
-0.0122633399,
0.0029866919,
-0.0249536727,
0.0258777142,
-0.0001584348,
0.0173129849,
0.0187948328,
-0.0350593589,
0.0037245706,
0.0221047364,
-0.0119918864,
0.0075185746,
-0.0225030482,
0.0427716225,
0.0174307041,
0.0269630197,
-0.0232984051,
2.702e-7,
0.0030253881,
0.0269377939,
0.0039624809,
-0.0418207906,
-0.0060589323,
0.0022310906,
-0.0369242765,
0.0315521657,
0.0083820941,
0.0337271765,
0.0389336012,
-0.0165929999,
0.014737335,
0.0120111369,
-0.0311950892,
-0.0459462665,
0.0491695181,
-0.0776525363,
-0.0348368436,
0.0334628224,
-0.023895245,
-0.0312480573,
0.0254703667,
-0.0148499031,
0.0192315541,
-0.0485227667,
0.0148326969,
-0.0401935801,
-0.0036744808,
-0.0083793905,
0.0634479746,
-0.0248766206,
-0.0173009653,
-0.0045426288,
0.0142688723,
0.0220869761,
-0.0426112004,
0.0323464125,
0.0468156114,
0.0586293787,
-0.0566789769,
-0.0761836991,
0.051136855,
0.0563817136,
0.0329513624,
0.0784707591,
-0.0222848877,
0.0183917824,
-0.0165329482,
-0.061170727,
-0.0018783481,
0.0265022777,
0.0190687701,
-0.0582900606,
-0.0341516957,
0.0263521802,
0.0114014614,
-0.0226423796,
0.0325316451,
0.0613641888,
-0.0091120461,
-0.0154595291,
0.0010668858,
0.0067151506,
0.0489480272,
-0.0336210988,
0.0023092271,
2.654084869e-34,
-0.0383308269,
-0.0227573365,
-0.005883303,
0.0210168473,
-0.011535571,
0.0339808129,
0.0042936667,
-0.0101156952,
0.0496811718,
-0.0336878859,
0.0548207946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12892v1 | A Systematic Study of Performance Disparities in Multilingual Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems | 2023-10-19T16:41:44 | 2023-10-19T16:41:44 | Songbo Hu, Han Zhou, Moy Yuan, Milan Gritta, Guchun Zhang, Ignacio Iacobacci, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL | Achieving robust language technologies that can perform well across the
world's many languages is a central goal of multilingual NLP. In this work, we
take stock of and empirically analyse task performance disparities that exist
between multilingual task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems. We first define new
quantitative measures of absolute and relative equivalence in system
performance, capturing disparities across languages and within individual
languages. Through a series of controlled experiments, we demonstrate that
performance disparities depend on a number of factors: the nature of the ToD
task at hand, the underlying pretrained language model, the target language,
and the amount of ToD annotated data. We empirically prove the existence of the
adaptation and intrinsic biases in current ToD systems: e.g., ToD systems
trained for Arabic or Turkish using annotated ToD data fully parallel to
English ToD data still exhibit diminished ToD task performance. Beyond
providing a series of insights into the performance disparities of ToD systems
in different languages, our analyses offer practical tips on how to approach
ToD data collection and system development for new languages. | [
0.0227355715,
-0.0024424172,
-0.0264813993,
0.050839439,
-0.0218834747,
0.0234027375,
0.0479245335,
-0.0291024074,
-0.0092828795,
-0.0498514399,
-0.0848356262,
-0.035595309,
0.009288162,
0.0069849929,
0.0246109311,
-0.0639105886,
0.0447271653,
-0.0396348797,
-0.0004036994,
-0.007593526,
0.0199976377,
0.0009482953,
-0.0398317687,
0.0505119748,
-0.0029100131,
-0.0100013213,
-0.0069285366,
-0.0235548653,
-0.0094081331,
-0.0109015321,
0.0129436655,
0.0546952784,
-0.0141613409,
0.0470725708,
0.0000017509,
-0.0671517923,
0.024115026,
-0.0168100465,
-0.0156477541,
-0.0233315006,
0.0208503529,
-0.0249358844,
-0.0298561547,
0.0179627221,
-0.0372887589,
-0.0272024851,
0.0507569835,
0.0625072718,
0.0241730567,
0.0715968832,
-0.0125630135,
0.0357025862,
-0.0045092404,
-0.0044385707,
-0.0245694984,
-0.0495873168,
-0.0399229452,
0.0287437756,
-0.0130158551,
0.0015908998,
0.0027234764,
0.0182037577,
0.021190118,
-0.0201642737,
-0.0547748096,
-0.0116070444,
-0.021524705,
-0.030930724,
-0.0266551524,
0.0712570772,
0.0181354377,
-0.0013854039,
-0.0367266275,
0.0145085379,
0.0039666328,
-0.0303447228,
-0.0597399697,
0.0045360117,
-0.0082128197,
-0.0038475657,
0.0053613423,
0.0466937385,
-0.0136299515,
-0.0067326464,
-0.0269580018,
0.0705519095,
0.005192203,
-0.0394734852,
0.0194412023,
0.0336336344,
0.0107081831,
-0.0595786385,
0.0142296366,
0.0011251066,
-0.0832411572,
0.0064819464,
-0.0085233757,
-0.0790165514,
0.0226719324,
-0.0637715235,
0.0686223134,
0.0445255525,
-0.0480867103,
0.0257764123,
-0.0048445603,
0.067915909,
-0.001920366,
-0.0060777301,
-0.0208583586,
-0.0556636043,
-0.0556899421,
0.0251651257,
-0.0098096551,
0.0117499698,
-0.0387332514,
0.0189367812,
-0.0387392491,
0.0537913106,
-0.0202809889,
-0.0025917548,
0.0293899253,
-0.0111838179,
-0.0450305864,
0.0060809706,
-0.054235287,
0.0399082229,
-0.0361070111,
0.0231165513,
0.0085482197,
-0.058857169,
0.007699762,
0.0311653074,
-0.006900744,
-0.0474635661,
-0.0110705495,
0.0725986734,
-0.0134365708,
-0.0150319068,
-0.0011838264,
0.0115504907,
-0.0103747509,
-0.0790189132,
-0.0036461155,
-0.0335291922,
0.052573923,
0.0282742046,
-0.0022247224,
-0.0140867354,
-0.0037160546,
0.0202303063,
-0.0069722892,
0.0562191606,
0.0008453567,
0.0072920648,
0.0243780818,
-0.0274543799,
-0.0448208377,
0.0871311799,
0.0327235907,
-0.0355999619,
0.0726001933,
0.0032360549,
-0.0328970887,
0.032705687,
-0.0086268429,
0.0157578886,
0.0688988864,
0.0279887356,
0.0162880551,
0.0010602335,
0.0242121145,
0.0459828787,
-0.0164251216,
0.0295781083,
0.0652954802,
0.0422479287,
-0.0128499977,
0.0004334702,
0.017119674,
0.0097146416,
-0.0016134817,
0.0177657846,
-0.0353835002,
0.0192290973,
0.0021198131,
0.0017874131,
0.035520684,
0.0450662039,
-0.0511613116,
-0.0496181957,
-0.0186993927,
-0.0086688101,
0.0350480787,
0.0149808023,
0.0767861158,
0.0069746212,
-0.0306044817,
0.0226472747,
0.0197093803,
-0.0597933792,
-0.0106226886,
-0.034016408,
-0.0353549197,
0.015154128,
-0.0118434634,
-0.0298523232,
-0.0655685365,
-0.0016766192,
0.0435777307,
0.0661079735,
0.0788060129,
-0.0133460686,
0.0399224907,
-0.0205395091,
-0.0203851555,
-0.0152878668,
-0.0030149929,
0.0263518468,
-0.0051519205,
0.0266165305,
-0.0043312362,
-0.0507820435,
-0.051545836,
0.0193534028,
-0.0242253318,
0.0127942599,
0.0249901116,
0.0206861999,
0.0059926715,
0.0375104435,
-0.0162437819,
-0.0154898381,
0.0151488287,
-0.0324918479,
0.0205748379,
0.0494805314,
-0.0349338613,
-0.029318789,
0.037577603,
0.0030880563,
-0.0096119503,
0.0480669662,
-0.0078099174,
-0.0685959533,
0.0521725304,
-0.0145358471,
-0.0020672956,
-0.0217744578,
0.0230371822,
-0.0088551911,
0.0155600253,
-0.0266495794,
0.0024600595,
0.033991918,
0.0231851898,
0.0334879681,
-0.0097057056,
0.0611249097,
-0.0399774164,
-0.0033126445,
0.057586737,
0.0029443863,
-0.0095701907,
0.0561287813,
0.0128235808,
-0.0171698369,
0.0003591328,
-0.1370583028,
0.0074621504,
-0.0484017543,
0.0503249466,
0.0079552922,
0.0274849255,
-0.0078268182,
-0.032447353,
-0.0559761189,
-0.0184270162,
0.0691276938,
0.0401215665,
0.0403094217,
0.0136994505,
0.0106267631,
-0.0422290191,
-0.0019195523,
0.0273505654,
0.0057219365,
-0.0019081964,
-0.0465014763,
-0.0469448045,
0.0179635268,
-0.0406543538,
0.0446943715,
-0.0079636993,
0.002384092,
0.0516110659,
0.0492772907,
0.0701396242,
0.0450938381,
-0.0233524237,
0.0195931681,
0.01664038,
-0.0300902333,
-0.0614715181,
0.0318779424,
0.0148869511,
-0.0354891717,
-0.0507948883,
-0.0341838524,
0.0138716325,
0.0422688201,
-0.0265164468,
-0.0256160516,
-0.0469447076,
-0.0068867118,
-0.0539906695,
-0.0345987454,
-0.0160973649,
0.0308963303,
-0.0138014173,
0.0543691181,
-0.0172850098,
-0.0176495109,
0.0458947606,
-0.0039795353,
-0.0212042481,
-0.0705786422,
0.0022115677,
-0.0232333075,
0.0605161227,
-0.0292552859,
0.0232775919,
0.0408871695,
-0.0429100171,
-0.0669044405,
0.0381254479,
0.0205553044,
-0.0136101358,
0.0403780714,
-0.0437924936,
-0.0028427395,
-0.057038486,
-0.0752732158,
-0.0289285146,
0.0186333843,
0.0101241563,
0.035174001,
0.0239891689,
-0.0386016592,
0.0065416521,
-0.0001117515,
0.0252182446,
0.0244513303,
-0.0006766772,
-0.0130542638,
-0.0115646441,
-0.0039860732,
0.025322685,
0.0277927984,
0.0344609842,
-0.0181457549,
0.0470347106,
0.0173532665,
0.0862230882,
-0.0444274954,
-0.0031816952,
-0.0241701063,
0.0625273436,
-0.0342111327,
-0.0400614738,
-0.0157611053,
0.084930025,
-0.0241444092,
0.0105317999,
0.0953343436,
0.0076766857,
-0.0216330681,
-0.0030084189,
-0.02701395,
0.0118695153,
0.0275501851,
0.0254511889,
-0.1044369191,
-0.0130066425,
0.0126920734,
-0.0005328048,
-0.0078118956,
-0.0285438858,
-0.005276619,
-0.1114029065,
-0.0177516006,
-0.0614463612,
-0.034195371,
0.0027415503,
-0.0472969413,
0.0007980498,
-0.0121717956,
0.0783869773,
-0.027147904,
0.0248907022,
-0.0066199196,
0.0312762111,
-0.0270288624,
-0.0365519561,
0.0156006897,
-0.0435173362,
0.0301400796,
0.0558554754,
0.0450683385,
0.0009821161,
0.0176285598,
0.0391260684,
0.0141927954,
-0.0146473553,
-0.0014977704,
-0.0013497587,
0.0215330571,
-0.0264458675,
-0.021639036,
-0.021951545,
-0.0322836749,
0.0259441305,
0.0329944342,
0.037190441,
-0.0138812708,
0.0373420306,
0.0171380099,
-0.0110131791,
0.0359016769,
0.0724626631,
-0.0068389997,
-0.0687026083,
-0.0446310639,
-0.0140295746,
-0.0419679657,
-0.0668495148,
0.0146197053,
-0.0083490107,
-0.0338766463,
0.0018582293,
-0.0813563317,
-0.0776008219,
0.0236550774,
0.0186878312,
0.0230348706,
0.0229613259,
-0.0108822584,
0.0096188448,
0.0066158283,
0.0290690139,
0.000197055,
0.024813937,
-0.0579466708,
-0.0151286628,
-0.0084012365,
-0.0004899484,
0.0176957883,
0.0094994819,
-0.0758387074,
-0.0569203235,
-0.0411805846,
0.047001265,
0.014844235,
-0.0024017047,
0.0120239276,
-0.0346774422,
-0.0324762166,
-0.0494050495,
-0.0394127071,
-0.0010900771,
0.0611873791,
0.0051881154,
0.0000355246,
0.0586452596,
-0.0359319411,
0.0075381994,
0.0030684986,
0.0339276567,
0.0070302938,
-0.051455982,
-0.0035019771,
-0.000409416,
0.0590249076,
-0.0164539777,
-0.0561024249,
-0.0282820351,
0.0253247451,
-0.0382108428,
-0.0210698564,
-0.0362486765,
0.0063596987,
-0.0271225665,
0.0215419941,
0.00876801,
0.0663304031,
-0.0283409916,
0.0164304152,
-0.050400693,
0.0042026993,
0.0128962277,
-0.0155684585,
-0.0034777825,
0.0306224395,
-0.0243032854,
-0.0144537836,
0.0408519767,
0.0446633473,
-0.0219064895,
0.071023874,
0.006892371,
-0.0127362749,
0.0556424297,
0.055535052,
-0.0395056382,
-0.0299743675,
0.0498305298,
0.0131180687,
0.0747822449,
-0.001781409,
0.0976005271,
-0.0095461085,
0.0214449633,
-0.0299159028,
0.0334394537,
0.0062477477,
0.0121148694,
0.0009939462,
-0.0214124657,
-0.0123561621,
0.0225435123,
0.0916977078,
-0.0267925132,
-0.0061921189,
-0.0068230261,
0.0142701222,
-0.0132563487,
-0.0334321856,
0.002585842,
0.0164038464,
-0.0348787382,
0.0070056221,
-0.0224408787,
-0.0604247116,
-0.0081211189,
-0.0153508019,
0.0030493026,
-0.0149510773,
0.0192286596,
0.0698873475,
-0.0085621495,
-0.0075662034,
-0.0507551469,
-0.0547175109,
-0.0167432651,
-0.0144732557,
-0.0088204956,
-5.364476836e-33,
-0.0195723008,
0.0200128462,
0.0147897992,
0.0117125697,
0.0109917857,
-0.0214141849,
-0.0173782464,
0.0358077921,
-0.0695114881,
0.006225876,
-0.0446053669,
0.001566331,
0.0270839073,
0.0255525596,
0.0027025105,
-0.0104077784,
0.0305134114,
-0.0122630522,
-0.0232024472,
0.0058627757,
0.0485266633,
-0.0064404383,
0.0890192538,
-0.0508866757,
0.1029301882,
0.0110161807,
0.0258309878,
0.009466812,
0.0535549745,
0.0604727343,
-0.0062082959,
0.1009072065,
0.0374065265,
-0.066044569,
-0.0417314619,
0.0167586561,
-0.0493166707,
-0.0161038749,
0.0421153419,
0.0633309633,
-0.0205593389,
0.0076715206,
-0.0449520499,
-0.0126668131,
-0.050703615,
0.0270705204,
0.0068546697,
-0.0085583003,
0.0130941682,
0.0103558386,
-0.0992001295,
0.0205540042,
-0.0100979125,
-0.0315276049,
0.0273978487,
0.0903786868,
0.0020133872,
-0.0841044113,
-0.0258515887,
0.0035132761,
-0.0395302512,
0.0204717368,
0.0642294735,
0.0264693443,
-0.0030844009,
0.0360133536,
0.0380731225,
0.0713416785,
0.0392840616,
-0.0226242673,
0.007967622,
-0.0065854108,
0.0418279544,
0.0399432816,
-0.0278521385,
0.0398631021,
-0.0930915028,
0.0196644384,
0.0388604701,
0.0235781837,
-0.0058282735,
0.0036571701,
-0.0340204723,
-0.0367473923,
-0.0235989392,
0.039406687,
-0.0176085327,
-0.0444465801,
0.0426557884,
-0.0041210847,
0.028200794,
0.0173852611,
0.0650847331,
-0.0240017362,
-0.0267488211,
0.0028305817,
-0.0081871143,
-0.000293784,
-0.0083123883,
0.0173811913,
-0.0595032014,
-0.0229751263,
-0.015987616,
0.0379807353,
0.0174905565,
0.0087923184,
0.0431910418,
-0.0105523262,
-0.0659713373,
0.0039750147,
-0.0412065201,
0.0558361895,
-0.0125843566,
0.0654839948,
0.0270903874,
-0.0372824073,
-0.0326399393,
0.0850334987,
0.0286905356,
-0.0548997559,
-0.0603258647,
-0.0276114587,
0.0004690119,
-0.0225904547,
-0.02602534,
-0.0064406814,
-0.0319597274,
-0.000473983,
-0.0208033081,
-0.0067240209,
-0.0399910659,
-0.0444043837,
2.391e-7,
0.0248597879,
0.035057079,
0.0056009488,
0.0453432575,
-0.0068249786,
0.0287691317,
-0.0204235613,
0.0170840453,
0.0053812005,
0.0139683541,
-0.0598536879,
0.0001815246,
0.0564882345,
0.0225175004,
-0.0792580172,
-0.0764063671,
-0.0108725214,
0.0184390135,
-0.0348457433,
0.0307104755,
0.0338030271,
0.0522722639,
-0.0207118243,
0.0099038444,
-0.0364853553,
-0.0383073613,
0.0493498221,
-0.0497685149,
-0.0106700482,
0.0303926133,
0.0595815107,
-0.0221040845,
0.0185276289,
0.0277127866,
-0.0265319403,
0.0305265896,
0.0273382366,
0.0348097049,
0.0045662578,
-0.0351637714,
0.0039033121,
-0.0239921063,
-0.0161647238,
-0.0557692535,
0.080385536,
-0.00791384,
-0.0337033197,
-0.0158591084,
0.0311729647,
-0.0061628441,
0.0209590662,
-0.0389643423,
-0.0184983853,
0.0280686505,
0.0364506729,
-0.0107558323,
-0.0023426025,
-0.0389504619,
-0.0199319236,
0.0306561813,
0.003468778,
-0.0653219298,
-0.0198379084,
-0.020978678,
-0.0037185524,
-0.0077790744,
-0.0068329331,
1.733544452e-34,
0.0277490225,
0.0139411148,
0.0587323792,
0.0337761939,
0.0271407012,
-0.0192985237,
-0.0237618703,
-0.0214418061,
0.0329551585,
-0.0185925085,
-0.0174280014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12874v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12874v2 | StoryAnalogy: Deriving Story-level Analogies from Large Language Models to Unlock Analogical Understanding | 2023-10-19T16:29:23 | 2023-10-23T11:58:24 | Cheng Jiayang, Lin Qiu, Tsz Ho Chan, Tianqing Fang, Weiqi Wang, Chunkit Chan, Dongyu Ru, Qipeng Guo, Hongming Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Yue Zhang, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Analogy-making between narratives is crucial for human reasoning. In this
paper, we evaluate the ability to identify and generate analogies by
constructing a first-of-its-kind large-scale story-level analogy corpus,
\textsc{StoryAnalogy}, which contains 24K story pairs from diverse domains with
human annotations on two similarities from the extended Structure-Mapping
Theory. We design a set of tests on \textsc{StoryAnalogy}, presenting the first
evaluation of story-level analogy identification and generation. Interestingly,
we find that the analogy identification tasks are incredibly difficult not only
for sentence embedding models but also for the recent large language models
(LLMs) such as ChatGPT and LLaMa. ChatGPT, for example, only achieved around
30% accuracy in multiple-choice questions (compared to over 85% accuracy for
humans). Furthermore, we observe that the data in \textsc{StoryAnalogy} can
improve the quality of analogy generation in LLMs, where a fine-tuned
FlanT5-xxl model achieves comparable performance to zero-shot ChatGPT. | [
0.0113785379,
0.0463068374,
-0.025778614,
0.0514532961,
-0.0283805393,
0.043894697,
0.0180422962,
-0.0270129927,
0.0183849055,
-0.0504555888,
-0.0093257083,
-0.0351944491,
-0.0118377926,
0.0281099882,
0.0197705757,
-0.0477401316,
-0.0123159606,
0.0188323911,
0.0005365994,
0.0189541355,
-0.0064865388,
0.0429456048,
-0.0051811738,
0.0524140596,
0.0317721032,
-0.0318268239,
0.0307444781,
-0.0206198879,
0.0700281113,
-0.0519692674,
0.0041022818,
-0.0051084915,
0.0572743937,
0.0046230438,
0.0000019756,
-0.0481346175,
0.0394072533,
-0.008752849,
0.0080197984,
0.0257785115,
0.0698379725,
0.0235720146,
0.0375721306,
0.0083324974,
-0.0049844803,
-0.0310822669,
0.0278151296,
0.0420207083,
0.0259200092,
0.0546434037,
-0.0240800045,
-0.1001921967,
0.0053925328,
-0.0140873231,
0.0046510459,
-0.0262191854,
-0.0040102592,
0.03794422,
0.0508680567,
0.0048465934,
-0.0145239374,
0.0082152234,
0.0296437647,
0.0278291982,
0.0029634,
0.0759411305,
0.0022118185,
0.0502251089,
0.0168285333,
0.0916805938,
-0.0090556312,
-0.0649240091,
0.0061156051,
0.0042308304,
-0.0043265852,
0.0278744102,
-0.0740031973,
0.0333405733,
-0.0026389849,
0.0574753881,
0.0635034218,
0.0159944911,
0.0178744383,
0.0160395261,
0.0011621112,
0.0042132856,
0.024953438,
0.0101795495,
-0.012601966,
0.0033286766,
-0.0273322649,
-0.0605312437,
0.0012559355,
0.0242361911,
-0.0110219102,
-0.0068364721,
-0.0607425198,
0.0116206007,
-0.0033164003,
-0.0950524136,
0.0604156405,
0.0575970896,
-0.0012258535,
0.0513589084,
-0.0841395631,
0.0514115654,
-0.032925427,
0.0279994793,
-0.0654395074,
-0.0135929734,
-0.0631064773,
0.0160398614,
-0.0239579454,
0.0168206859,
-0.0141926249,
-0.038466569,
0.0040907105,
0.0169124082,
0.015418929,
-0.0381081924,
-0.0641298816,
0.0210360494,
0.0014751646,
-0.0100928936,
-0.0333901644,
0.0087010646,
-0.091214776,
0.0277486648,
0.0067683887,
-0.0269052088,
-0.0215943754,
0.003445534,
0.0168771911,
-0.0552653782,
0.0122696636,
0.0357102714,
-0.0280754976,
-0.0097264787,
-0.038409695,
-0.0284875836,
0.0540282726,
-0.0578073896,
0.0035422284,
-0.0504321046,
0.0443151407,
0.0041794362,
0.0196104683,
-0.0230205674,
0.0054210727,
0.0497699268,
-0.0738122091,
0.0485513806,
0.0384842418,
-0.0111188702,
-0.0220130198,
0.0114257215,
-0.0054502171,
0.0179495737,
0.0310856774,
-0.0010790748,
0.0177056286,
0.0292305741,
-0.0099685257,
-0.0052653812,
-0.0342577174,
-0.0067432625,
-0.0218805056,
0.0004616302,
-0.0063314517,
0.085190855,
0.0500806123,
0.0356286839,
-0.0425723381,
-0.0374857858,
0.0576290376,
0.0737653971,
0.0326470956,
0.0325309969,
0.0664413422,
-0.0029951935,
-0.0014173952,
0.0105105955,
-0.0196436271,
0.026313154,
0.0134936711,
-0.0044531841,
-0.0012050805,
0.0411289856,
-0.0521541648,
0.0357048251,
-0.0274594277,
0.0075390236,
-0.0407102369,
-0.020280974,
-0.0283489246,
0.0127203306,
-0.0022656703,
0.000991286,
0.0403492339,
-0.0416697264,
0.0150702149,
-0.0005942942,
0.0365042947,
0.0432789028,
0.0658656582,
0.0163279269,
-0.0338993408,
-0.0197625309,
-0.0055307276,
0.0487160124,
0.0489903167,
-0.0265356358,
-0.0031704102,
-0.0594174415,
0.002902779,
-0.044527635,
-0.0040784278,
0.0066462033,
-0.0175502934,
0.012975676,
-0.0011281369,
-0.0744641125,
-0.0075059584,
0.0378014743,
-0.0767731369,
-0.0096927593,
-0.0013697864,
0.004476483,
-0.0165868308,
0.012741792,
-0.003281778,
0.0059670121,
-0.0008983074,
-0.0848083124,
-0.0318097919,
0.0865556821,
-0.0630406365,
-0.0697138757,
0.0209201798,
-0.0880576372,
0.0172933601,
0.0174848605,
-0.0171943419,
-0.0112959286,
0.0349985845,
-0.0079120519,
0.079209052,
-0.0025911801,
0.010587899,
-0.0112463804,
0.0241427012,
-0.0129610151,
0.0800237581,
0.0128757339,
0.0051201168,
-0.0175816901,
0.0203800499,
0.0096526528,
0.0220896006,
-0.0232742112,
-0.004454792,
0.0429851785,
-0.0326562934,
-0.0030141969,
-0.032993637,
-0.024815537,
-0.0035717511,
-0.0504012816,
0.0469878763,
0.0192960128,
0.0054908688,
0.0588027164,
-0.0004832407,
-0.0119017074,
0.0105536636,
-0.0642481297,
-0.0100278538,
-0.0269825812,
0.021030983,
0.0315875709,
0.0005521874,
-0.0190483686,
-0.0322852433,
0.0313088559,
-0.0360117704,
0.0882877856,
0.0260469224,
0.0240425188,
-0.0441267788,
0.0377428569,
0.0034048602,
-0.00829593,
-0.0078898957,
-0.004020466,
-0.0065412009,
0.0210442729,
0.0567894876,
0.0432401076,
0.0034715834,
0.0046978001,
0.0680691674,
-0.0017138906,
-0.043474067,
-0.0054284651,
0.0016973972,
0.0130789578,
-0.0149928275,
-0.0429402106,
-0.0219153874,
0.079675667,
-0.0015987527,
0.0075502386,
-0.0186525118,
0.0362347215,
0.0082023833,
0.01396944,
0.0099129016,
-0.0135720363,
-0.0146454461,
-0.0098670693,
-0.0221367721,
0.0318787806,
0.0753463507,
-0.0333131216,
0.0058495081,
-0.0369454138,
-0.0070764706,
-0.0540278703,
0.0643048137,
0.0036221768,
0.0203877594,
0.0121538546,
0.0115290172,
-0.0334492885,
-0.0113840234,
0.0087492345,
0.0083894553,
0.0441294685,
-0.027578406,
0.0039570369,
-0.0007924045,
-0.0378436856,
-0.0417386256,
-0.0320980661,
-0.0524128303,
-0.0043089576,
-0.0109102922,
-0.0087004295,
-0.0740130618,
0.0026676627,
-0.0024569836,
0.018774813,
-0.0069980938,
-0.0227939207,
-0.012123405,
0.0860931277,
0.0827595145,
0.0087857042,
0.0192217082,
-0.0077754548,
0.0748586208,
0.0431542173,
0.0162210725,
0.0350933708,
-0.0175457243,
0.0031655375,
0.0011565267,
-0.0486599468,
-0.0082695847,
-0.0222309232,
0.0414591245,
-0.0403680615,
-0.0470782183,
0.0869650021,
0.0426928252,
-0.048905693,
0.0347054414,
0.0018286577,
0.0368630439,
0.0219316613,
0.001832089,
-0.0872037858,
-0.0526540391,
0.0159894917,
-0.0328579843,
0.0100143505,
-0.0714744702,
0.0010874416,
-0.1012988016,
0.0239574667,
0.0046781157,
-0.0280112028,
-0.0490748771,
0.0041540391,
0.0271201991,
-0.0105844801,
-0.0175679345,
-0.0068897191,
-0.0321911648,
0.0187644884,
-0.0157797541,
0.0173694771,
-0.0169396661,
0.04943702,
-0.0633297339,
0.0708109066,
0.0187760927,
0.0444242209,
0.0208949316,
0.0104574291,
-0.0111553278,
-0.0056980085,
-0.0338602364,
0.0183001719,
0.0251627173,
-0.0162366964,
0.0138537651,
-0.02260812,
0.0833075941,
-0.0209334232,
-0.0431395471,
0.0114831412,
0.0788056031,
0.0075445031,
-0.0501275808,
-0.027399024,
0.0343341865,
-0.0496293977,
0.0975016281,
0.068618618,
-0.0422511399,
-0.0287216268,
-0.0091892583,
0.0045995321,
-0.0796121061,
-0.0344507806,
-0.00848844,
0.0011834744,
0.0471166857,
-0.0574348532,
-0.0609227829,
-0.0254072584,
-0.0063085859,
0.0130733624,
-0.0265419539,
-0.0135703553,
-0.0169700272,
-0.0224850103,
0.0251112897,
-0.0604619756,
0.0315323249,
0.0265240278,
0.0178940501,
0.041013021,
-0.0464381874,
-0.0322893932,
0.0366872326,
-0.0816656202,
-0.0269614886,
-0.0313996002,
-0.0280614719,
0.0061273086,
0.0233939383,
0.0162150394,
-0.0380170606,
0.0512998886,
-0.0007305598,
-0.0159010421,
0.0375328735,
-0.0403778441,
0.0172063038,
0.0246305671,
0.0327400751,
-0.0106460359,
0.0132673122,
0.0055488748,
0.0727190524,
0.016270712,
-0.00776996,
0.0295583308,
-0.0224452112,
-0.0215621684,
0.0091503384,
-0.0244390052,
-0.0657973439,
-0.0018227617,
-0.0063039507,
-0.0021676905,
-0.039397113,
-0.0002982896,
0.0309258644,
0.000722508,
-0.0263078939,
-0.070498094,
-0.0238956083,
0.0564418845,
-0.002329695,
-0.0048289006,
0.0223376881,
0.0172254872,
-0.0085549289,
0.0067512454,
-0.0528932884,
-0.0102601973,
-0.0112446481,
0.0605413541,
-0.0524897426,
0.0446803495,
0.0261288583,
-0.0168877691,
0.0013755839,
0.0263553374,
-0.0506062135,
-0.0123527711,
-0.0252006035,
0.0115504237,
0.0531018637,
-0.0359384269,
0.0415858738,
-0.0334441103,
0.009526425,
0.0040005082,
0.0082636476,
-0.0416697711,
-0.0184056778,
-0.0013174227,
0.0108083542,
-0.0011156372,
0.0126560982,
0.0578779317,
-0.0450930335,
0.095413141,
0.0197242107,
-0.0210926495,
-0.0084394235,
-0.0223694313,
0.0171856731,
0.0366252474,
0.023407938,
-0.0126515534,
-0.0569467917,
-0.0312979855,
-0.0030464334,
0.0004850382,
-0.0224745478,
0.0064275386,
0.0028190389,
0.0106497128,
-0.0079902541,
-0.0099212062,
-0.0310608614,
0.0222094711,
-0.0426174439,
-0.0327883884,
-0.0330273733,
-6.186116163e-33,
-0.0204846282,
0.0228973124,
-0.0022110688,
-0.014441953,
-0.0603128523,
-0.0167140719,
-0.0420240313,
-0.0183895659,
-0.0481354184,
0.0335463397,
0.0164660849,
-0.0353773013,
-0.0143265817,
0.0094890706,
-0.0043654614,
-0.0050679292,
0.0229591895,
0.0135243451,
-0.040245764,
0.0275995713,
0.0332244933,
-0.0006764148,
0.0445937999,
-0.0216414258,
-0.0444732197,
-0.0312120747,
0.0248969719,
-0.0052266796,
0.0448242463,
0.0614019446,
-0.0482909307,
0.0277230591,
0.0438777171,
0.005650539,
0.0005801762,
-0.0088138804,
-0.0594914593,
-0.0224590302,
0.0411710329,
-0.0293847769,
0.0235133898,
-0.0455503799,
0.0263008084,
0.001522709,
0.0189749543,
-0.0631357729,
0.0510928258,
-0.018707063,
0.0455109328,
0.0101269223,
-0.0747261643,
0.0025493102,
-0.0077432389,
-0.0513690189,
-0.0310838502,
0.0780094713,
0.015404474,
0.069532387,
-0.0401584022,
0.0240014382,
-0.0109734833,
0.0050588427,
0.0209093783,
-0.0086358599,
-0.0169279594,
0.1014378294,
0.002609717,
-0.0577060878,
-0.0346223228,
0.0207203534,
-0.0062189712,
0.0171307195,
0.0151056154,
0.0558226891,
0.046895206,
0.0143528488,
-0.0490643494,
0.0314817019,
0.0630129948,
0.0243611019,
0.0502831563,
0.0108867241,
-0.0142670833,
-0.0022548237,
-0.0622287802,
-0.043515522,
-0.0444365032,
-0.0336573608,
0.0341282077,
-0.0329638273,
0.0330872685,
0.0185392369,
0.0292031001,
-0.0331022255,
0.0100358399,
-0.0088368971,
-0.0396597832,
0.0245746896,
-0.0209161118,
0.0256921742,
-0.0479111969,
-0.0288086329,
0.0152696772,
0.0028574495,
0.0443468392,
-0.0076980838,
0.0335126147,
-0.000016925,
-0.0522768945,
-0.0118310638,
-0.0444023907,
-0.0627819374,
-0.0281134266,
-0.0377977304,
-0.0159619581,
0.0285042189,
0.0027605582,
0.0452593565,
0.0075622546,
-0.0072702672,
-0.0347364582,
-0.0371831581,
-0.0186958425,
0.0146042872,
-0.0100494549,
0.0276544709,
-0.0338877514,
-0.0074307891,
0.016638888,
-0.0839760527,
-0.0075160312,
0.0104179485,
2.625e-7,
0.0096611995,
0.014684353,
0.0159150735,
-0.0203883909,
-0.0064158891,
0.0470962673,
0.0271475129,
0.0535773523,
0.0049183164,
0.0108691035,
0.0001238825,
0.0354630873,
0.0351511799,
0.0405315533,
-0.0775367692,
0.038537465,
-0.1024206653,
-0.0382926352,
-0.0487740785,
-0.0781680569,
0.0709738582,
0.0622114949,
0.0536900051,
-0.0198950823,
0.0374770314,
-0.0610553212,
0.0629555881,
-0.0424487665,
-0.0338588357,
0.0441363603,
-0.0477385335,
0.016502725,
-0.0054592029,
-0.0302228257,
0.019683091,
0.044324778,
0.0277123675,
0.0100766886,
0.0139624905,
-0.0293478891,
-0.0108701764,
-0.0390099362,
-0.0142471222,
-0.0872983783,
0.0679889694,
-0.0863178894,
-0.0263766907,
-0.0260190293,
-0.0073842974,
0.022335656,
0.0158438887,
-0.0072335061,
-0.0443399474,
0.0291752778,
0.0350257084,
0.0032202932,
-0.0080482708,
-0.0640125275,
-0.0109052965,
0.0387238041,
-0.0549896918,
0.0066546025,
-0.0258787647,
-0.0316426083,
0.019384088,
-0.0441865884,
0.0167911015,
2.178285393e-34,
-0.000097044,
0.0147157339,
-0.0006803921,
0.0377012044,
0.048627615,
0.0076734149,
0.0348616615,
0.0008005057,
0.0229018666,
-0.0914245322,
-0.0038850394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12864v1 | The Locality and Symmetry of Positional Encodings | 2023-10-19T16:15:15 | 2023-10-19T16:15:15 | Lihu Chen, Gaël Varoquaux, Fabian M. Suchanek | cs.CL | cs.CL | Positional Encodings (PEs) are used to inject word-order information into
transformer-based language models. While they can significantly enhance the
quality of sentence representations, their specific contribution to language
models is not fully understood, especially given recent findings that various
positional encodings are insensitive to word order. In this work, we conduct a
systematic study of positional encodings in \textbf{Bidirectional Masked
Language Models} (BERT-style) , which complements existing work in three
aspects: (1) We uncover the core function of PEs by identifying two common
properties, Locality and Symmetry; (2) We show that the two properties are
closely correlated with the performances of downstream tasks; (3) We quantify
the weakness of current PEs by introducing two new probing tasks, on which
current PEs perform poorly. We believe that these results are the basis for
developing better PEs for transformer-based language models. The code is
available at \faGithub~ \url{https://github.com/tigerchen52/locality\_symmetry} | [
0.0476463065,
0.0680131391,
-0.0459485427,
0.0660362169,
-0.0412563011,
0.005293827,
0.0195635762,
-0.009347897,
-0.0327035375,
-0.0730373561,
-0.0371656045,
-0.0483123772,
0.0398421772,
-0.0103673218,
0.0624310933,
-0.0626301318,
0.0424180217,
-0.0193131138,
-0.0374626443,
0.0018778518,
-0.0115108164,
-0.0218341276,
0.017473923,
0.0490188375,
0.0242307857,
-0.0066991793,
-0.0189301558,
0.0092419079,
0.0277674664,
-0.0134724434,
0.0062458413,
0.0381383821,
0.0078263944,
0.0350652449,
0.0000016745,
-0.0059002498,
-0.0256288927,
0.005171719,
0.0179507732,
0.0455558226,
-0.0097867819,
-0.0747565329,
-0.0242148247,
0.0154327862,
-0.0109341899,
-0.0194764789,
0.0706248954,
0.0142408898,
0.0285140257,
0.0722345859,
-0.0239524394,
-0.0573669262,
0.0072916406,
-0.0365569331,
0.0075654918,
0.003596097,
0.0150382752,
-0.0661061183,
-0.0083169881,
0.0643590614,
-0.0519112945,
0.0056525483,
-0.0079292804,
0.02666164,
-0.0295947567,
0.0361973532,
-0.0228784196,
-0.0077796914,
-0.0034559483,
0.0096074641,
-0.0447165184,
-0.0358919427,
-0.002981836,
0.0281256456,
0.0165752769,
0.039895203,
-0.0301278606,
0.0423243269,
0.0415712036,
0.0085531501,
0.0252278727,
0.0309366062,
0.0053629591,
-0.0378320366,
-0.0647727922,
0.0743637085,
0.0276524108,
-0.0781363696,
-0.0856860951,
-0.0102510508,
-0.0562619455,
-0.0219036788,
0.0158271529,
-0.0114536034,
0.0445744619,
0.0152712241,
-0.0034816328,
-0.0537417643,
0.0124309622,
-0.0238070022,
0.0380403623,
0.0423295833,
-0.0339179561,
0.0023172086,
-0.0328707062,
0.1016840637,
-0.0070907343,
0.0490588993,
-0.0436895043,
0.0095863026,
0.0064685177,
-0.0441390872,
-0.0382435955,
0.0186881125,
-0.0477693491,
-0.0418665819,
-0.0042638634,
0.0296051167,
-0.0135586429,
0.0038280853,
0.0209246892,
0.0191959236,
0.0011481511,
0.0245606229,
0.0337979756,
0.0196893383,
0.0085528279,
-0.0123877292,
-0.0411113985,
-0.0225165524,
-0.0417687893,
0.0328811929,
0.0197398122,
-0.0245532971,
-0.0225480702,
0.034981586,
0.0361258388,
-0.0602397807,
0.0513418615,
0.0661983863,
-0.0554105118,
-0.0087165507,
0.0324093923,
-0.0326173045,
0.0100355716,
0.062111605,
0.0042483117,
-0.0393780172,
0.0270429142,
0.0254939273,
-0.0396800824,
0.0639817044,
0.0392903611,
0.0167577807,
-0.026970543,
0.0008018273,
-0.0038579926,
0.0090921875,
0.0438274555,
0.0241501182,
0.0457109436,
-0.0447598025,
0.0023065466,
0.0345121585,
0.0000396377,
-0.0220074113,
-0.0067178775,
-0.0187645834,
0.0370610841,
-0.0033250472,
0.0345693268,
0.0579027534,
-0.0198427103,
-0.0329354443,
0.0679401606,
0.0653767586,
0.0166142061,
0.0098199276,
0.0160505995,
0.0149029195,
-0.0334012732,
0.022282593,
-0.0313610472,
-0.0131697906,
0.0179674868,
0.0198163353,
-0.0090884855,
0.0416208431,
0.0061080474,
-0.0100245755,
-0.0737791359,
-0.0172601137,
0.007599588,
-0.0236306693,
0.0202748906,
0.0271810461,
-0.0571869202,
0.1033579782,
-0.0099672424,
-0.0348518454,
-0.0359936468,
-0.0160381533,
-0.0315139145,
0.0141886799,
-0.0006730137,
-0.0240854956,
-0.0196499527,
0.0529712141,
-0.0295134746,
0.0443547368,
0.0167714041,
0.0208629742,
0.0047677155,
-0.0191775113,
-0.0177389476,
-0.0313915126,
0.0222617332,
0.0427201912,
0.0292815827,
-0.0319773704,
0.0216591377,
-0.0413778611,
0.0333138146,
0.0240655076,
0.0050523984,
-0.0030560135,
-0.0155373532,
0.0077597485,
-0.0054530087,
-0.023273671,
-0.0190729126,
0.0727379918,
0.0568266995,
-0.0457351208,
0.0261080805,
0.0401210003,
-0.0470550992,
-0.0475846641,
0.0245302394,
0.0048151324,
0.0258374792,
0.0863162652,
-0.0039021783,
-0.0089840582,
0.0192490052,
-0.0430563092,
0.0500796214,
-0.0105278902,
0.0525614321,
0.0097621242,
0.0324008726,
-0.050942909,
0.0913038403,
-0.0175467264,
0.049899172,
0.0083465613,
0.0011808255,
0.0090736542,
-0.0233078189,
-0.0466800854,
0.0026213771,
-0.005053367,
-0.0180809796,
0.009584778,
-0.0293937903,
0.0251078699,
-0.0764573142,
-0.0829988569,
0.0017253187,
-0.0187642202,
0.0213207975,
0.0406927019,
0.020207895,
0.0044544218,
-0.002243828,
-0.0373486578,
-0.0455375873,
-0.0021258416,
0.0304458234,
0.0644063577,
-0.003517685,
-0.0511044301,
-0.0179906618,
-0.0193380807,
-0.0392534509,
0.0670632794,
-0.0470179394,
-0.0140523054,
-0.0958550349,
0.0490979627,
0.0087600322,
0.0188669041,
-0.0159539096,
-0.0603881776,
-0.0023649354,
0.0034535923,
0.0351227447,
0.0311576948,
0.0159285348,
0.0390184484,
0.0341811888,
0.0185392816,
-0.023400208,
-0.0187926982,
-0.0401450768,
0.0398890562,
-0.0185492132,
-0.0202235244,
-0.0086995456,
0.092911914,
0.0191786718,
-0.0246604905,
-0.0458241478,
0.0021353215,
-0.0281969979,
0.0063319737,
-0.0170027856,
-0.0444203466,
-0.0432002917,
0.0113273375,
-0.0580493808,
-0.0315699689,
0.0227124151,
-0.0590463877,
-0.0141677996,
-0.0423028842,
0.0012989942,
-0.0733363107,
0.0608653948,
0.0406669751,
0.0434633046,
-0.0316546746,
-0.0494259633,
-0.0634044558,
0.0055153915,
-0.0098769031,
-0.0286710784,
-0.0221201684,
-0.0205625352,
-0.0182007961,
-0.0178519282,
-0.0800531879,
-0.0393853672,
-0.0786048248,
0.042617619,
0.0141383028,
0.0541686565,
-0.0509802699,
-0.0155487768,
0.0435302183,
0.0205394384,
0.0435462333,
-0.0134837562,
0.0253568217,
-0.0326895937,
0.0601639859,
0.0380587764,
0.0197992846,
0.0312049035,
-0.0053551197,
-0.0121931601,
0.0213382095,
0.0179660339,
0.0329690352,
-0.0142818503,
0.00818587,
0.0674695224,
-0.0439741462,
-0.0676376745,
-0.0296417642,
0.0325497277,
-0.0021931529,
-0.0419923291,
0.132778883,
0.0574718304,
0.0080310293,
0.0473214798,
-0.0164211839,
0.0470941626,
0.0077187577,
0.0119760027,
-0.0648164153,
0.0292881764,
0.0148329167,
-0.0247227773,
0.0005353177,
0.0216929633,
0.0067815832,
-0.1286057085,
0.0201440603,
0.0047096391,
-0.013209641,
-0.0561897457,
-0.0218975134,
-0.0091167931,
0.0091278991,
0.0288326647,
0.0217931718,
-0.0144548435,
0.0020761194,
0.0485629849,
-0.0312858187,
-0.0082080206,
-0.021689197,
-0.0419887602,
-0.0008271743,
0.0394792557,
0.0314163901,
-0.021358693,
-0.0759527981,
-0.0309705175,
-0.0130949784,
0.0084528569,
0.0298549831,
0.0203546006,
-0.0177703034,
-0.0519520231,
0.0000309815,
0.0009885327,
-0.0423948914,
-0.034353476,
-0.0651284605,
0.0312559418,
0.0018246241,
-0.0114538278,
-0.008564949,
0.0089529715,
-0.0331791602,
0.0578282662,
0.0270292405,
-0.0174165927,
-0.0235537626,
-0.0113869272,
0.0679221153,
-0.0055542109,
-0.0424087346,
0.0293704905,
0.05137318,
-0.0335813425,
-0.079322204,
-0.0280618537,
0.0034650872,
0.0277172569,
0.0061181164,
-0.0188999642,
-0.0307948403,
-0.0264194664,
-0.0542446822,
0.0003779668,
0.0153423166,
0.0167538803,
-0.0339061581,
-0.021566486,
0.0465675294,
0.0037711214,
-0.044498302,
-0.0370910577,
-0.04949072,
-0.0446331613,
0.0559232309,
0.0535890758,
0.0198859051,
0.014948816,
-0.0054655164,
-0.0139209982,
0.0420931876,
0.0416893028,
-0.0062256968,
0.0376497135,
0.0538960919,
-0.0380954444,
0.0106753204,
0.0240227394,
-0.010316113,
-0.0185825862,
-0.0027002122,
0.0456019118,
-0.0082418602,
-0.0408151671,
0.0347904451,
-0.0089592505,
0.0703756958,
-0.0011376395,
0.0151081281,
0.0110459989,
0.0254571326,
-0.060945034,
-0.0265275687,
-0.0333249457,
-0.0192287397,
0.0563041493,
0.0377854705,
-0.0274260882,
0.021796694,
0.0191476531,
-0.0186701138,
-0.0053694169,
0.020601768,
-0.0088455584,
-0.0110584814,
-0.0198989399,
0.0580023155,
-0.0069862041,
0.0313064605,
-0.0029209212,
0.0358775817,
-0.0118992673,
0.013598755,
-0.0028073646,
-0.0223159585,
-0.0560627468,
0.0981324911,
-0.0861424729,
0.0258806963,
-0.0215340592,
-0.0186749399,
0.0300126802,
-0.0510805622,
0.074495472,
-0.021723466,
-0.0119370511,
0.0234092399,
-0.0009914552,
0.0197355058,
-0.0344913788,
-0.0201158244,
0.0266078431,
-0.0178864766,
-0.0075963107,
0.0819350407,
0.0319697224,
0.022068521,
0.0105180135,
-0.0426011346,
-0.0037617839,
0.0000130142,
0.071579583,
-0.0059360117,
-0.023188144,
-0.0077575576,
-0.073217243,
-0.0581620447,
0.0302132517,
0.0066205291,
0.0193441194,
-0.0400288217,
0.0125289224,
0.0486297682,
0.0024326779,
-0.0158070736,
-0.0632799342,
0.0053655161,
0.0502971523,
-0.0200599376,
-0.0382041782,
-5.532723873e-33,
-0.0292371195,
-0.0074233646,
-0.0486838073,
-0.0205419939,
0.0159388073,
0.013680093,
-0.0046143462,
0.0054938458,
0.0039719255,
0.0082670981,
-0.0120887896,
0.0046223812,
0.0093345372,
0.0191750266,
-0.0210387371,
-0.0177440885,
0.014892037,
0.0221922416,
-0.016617544,
-0.0558624566,
0.0369417258,
0.032862667,
0.0607167073,
-0.0087055108,
0.0242949277,
-0.0304844268,
0.0081810672,
0.0034234205,
-0.0126279416,
0.0490008593,
-0.0137841357,
-0.0001430023,
0.0158614907,
-0.0339439027,
-0.0109282238,
0.0327889621,
-0.0407345742,
-0.0234982297,
0.0235480778,
0.0256640147,
-0.0038818605,
-0.0336984321,
0.0539352223,
-0.0296064802,
-0.0383038484,
-0.0001674899,
0.0078661973,
0.018288387,
-0.0405027568,
0.0116473641,
-0.0509492233,
-0.0081587322,
-0.0082542524,
-0.0384832434,
0.0255889334,
-0.004062342,
0.0263223015,
0.0096045639,
-0.0404028147,
0.0084254108,
-0.0094315177,
0.0592010207,
0.0196999367,
0.0053620096,
-0.0001786368,
0.0625889525,
0.0502539873,
0.0194941889,
0.0054152939,
-0.0074032214,
0.0244331993,
0.0302015021,
0.0506834462,
-0.0245825071,
0.0094528953,
0.0237243511,
-0.025457304,
0.0190002266,
-0.0488002114,
-0.007563245,
0.0199451279,
0.0173629411,
-0.0514033027,
-0.0317116156,
-0.0091907261,
-0.034630388,
-0.009012809,
0.0024015303,
0.0250530317,
-0.0104638971,
-0.0356470086,
0.0475573242,
0.0131770717,
-0.0563853085,
-0.0169340186,
0.0221623462,
-0.0191475265,
0.0531020649,
0.0001608337,
0.042508848,
-0.0049510268,
-0.0334587134,
0.0131412251,
0.033182282,
0.0103819249,
0.019049624,
0.0363346078,
0.0326976664,
-0.0650763437,
-0.0173762944,
-0.0362893417,
-0.0342500955,
-0.0641726106,
0.0282011852,
0.0284095313,
0.012405985,
-0.0037078839,
0.0175571907,
0.0671645552,
0.0336357877,
-0.0325982347,
0.0490170829,
-0.0240459237,
-0.0000135994,
0.0031660211,
-0.0195431951,
-0.0394335166,
0.0733835325,
0.0536052212,
-0.0455445312,
-0.0188472159,
-0.0331472345,
2.492e-7,
0.092644684,
0.047555998,
0.075461708,
0.0295413323,
0.0268995464,
0.0076891072,
-0.0021261191,
0.0525859296,
0.00086917,
0.041128803,
0.0067920922,
-0.0068233698,
-0.0051709213,
-0.0214845091,
-0.0825618356,
0.0162618179,
-0.0761049837,
-0.0034482025,
-0.0270601548,
0.057295762,
0.0230142977,
0.1080760136,
-0.0189153887,
0.0274974424,
-0.0328134559,
-0.0163398832,
0.0698246434,
-0.0381925628,
-0.0079601901,
-0.0070868963,
0.0009059362,
-0.0364032909,
0.0178671014,
-0.0289322641,
0.0000843279,
0.049032256,
0.0254947133,
0.0170384627,
-0.0116788168,
-0.0249308776,
-0.024252506,
-0.012971024,
-0.0254028793,
-0.0870444477,
0.0619995035,
-0.0442879312,
-0.041962225,
-0.0086791497,
-0.057599064,
0.0493825413,
-0.0085717868,
0.0087655699,
-0.0434920378,
0.0160752181,
0.03685477,
-0.0180440992,
-0.0174428914,
-0.0733415857,
-0.0824061781,
-0.0146016246,
-0.0257178172,
-0.0175118931,
-0.0159944333,
-0.0158745162,
0.0568275191,
-0.0591054186,
-0.04049192,
2.807365429e-34,
-0.0054200478,
-0.0013004423,
-0.0067876228,
0.0401854478,
0.0228030793,
-0.0413479991,
0.0208473746,
0.0223313011,
0.0151244961,
-0.0737526044,
-0.0334607214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12860v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12860v2 | Probing LLMs for hate speech detection: strengths and vulnerabilities | 2023-10-19T16:11:02 | 2023-10-28T05:07:31 | Sarthak Roy, Ashish Harshavardhan, Animesh Mukherjee, Punyajoy Saha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Recently efforts have been made by social media platforms as well as
researchers to detect hateful or toxic language using large language models.
However, none of these works aim to use explanation, additional context and
victim community information in the detection process. We utilise different
prompt variation, input information and evaluate large language models in zero
shot setting (without adding any in-context examples). We select three large
language models (GPT-3.5, text-davinci and Flan-T5) and three datasets -
HateXplain, implicit hate and ToxicSpans. We find that on average including the
target information in the pipeline improves the model performance substantially
(~20-30%) over the baseline across the datasets. There is also a considerable
effect of adding the rationales/explanations into the pipeline (~10-20%) over
the baseline across the datasets. In addition, we further provide a typology of
the error cases where these large language models fail to (i) classify and (ii)
explain the reason for the decisions they take. Such vulnerable points
automatically constitute 'jailbreak' prompts for these models and industry
scale safeguard techniques need to be developed to make the models robust
against such prompts. | [
0.0521908365,
0.02846523,
-0.0281552263,
0.0485864244,
-0.03100756,
0.0477528907,
0.0400057249,
0.0336035602,
0.0158641115,
-0.0700158849,
-0.0067458833,
-0.0324120447,
-0.0234516785,
0.0185103007,
-0.0024919447,
-0.0313207842,
0.0223787501,
0.0143144419,
0.0256498586,
-0.0193848852,
0.0552416854,
0.0165036358,
0.0224484894,
0.0299795587,
-0.0400130823,
0.0183581654,
0.0160038341,
0.0282570571,
0.0176090896,
-0.0103870919,
0.0280703828,
0.0212421138,
0.0371378772,
0.0625881478,
0.0000019863,
-0.0586230345,
0.0228866115,
-0.0179088395,
-0.0356469341,
-0.0370201059,
0.0740245953,
-0.0247992333,
0.0010760596,
0.0484745391,
-0.0105701312,
0.0478691459,
0.0686702877,
0.0450644009,
0.0500836,
0.0651647672,
-0.0087072179,
-0.0537524745,
0.0022612913,
0.011252027,
0.0172025245,
0.0154085848,
0.0360678397,
-0.0607218742,
-0.0410507955,
0.0023787697,
-0.0011627311,
0.0077523729,
0.0228729583,
0.015483262,
0.0028888201,
-0.0235625766,
-0.0060464465,
-0.0570812114,
-0.0022923476,
0.0520021729,
-0.0451524928,
-0.0123755084,
0.0123893684,
-0.0160644986,
-0.0133865187,
-0.0261394568,
-0.0365975834,
0.0141015192,
-0.0139737371,
0.0194113683,
0.0093582617,
0.011536737,
0.0836855173,
0.0658044517,
0.0214613806,
0.0607673861,
-0.0160902198,
-0.0190386698,
0.0054612248,
-0.0218895897,
-0.018723717,
0.0018045934,
-0.0090680886,
0.0172348078,
-0.0180115774,
0.0181371439,
-0.0370518714,
-0.0015088748,
0.0208356604,
-0.0763545409,
0.0432162806,
0.0480134077,
-0.0312843658,
-0.000942189,
0.0030816323,
0.0208239611,
-0.0105499672,
0.0056524337,
0.0035706006,
0.0000480277,
-0.0231798124,
-0.0065849144,
0.0316351913,
-0.0008462371,
-0.024398502,
0.0534904115,
-0.0285365395,
0.0201134402,
-0.042584274,
-0.0185250584,
-0.0040416042,
-0.0059873625,
0.0071140011,
0.0082499692,
-0.025047427,
0.0055683563,
-0.0400430225,
0.0119144712,
-0.0163122676,
-0.0929429829,
0.0013373275,
0.0368100591,
-0.0246455129,
-0.0280590188,
0.0234783553,
0.0983471125,
0.0499316715,
-0.0405905247,
-0.0574419312,
-0.0448398702,
-0.0390142091,
-0.0732715875,
0.0138532305,
-0.0506205671,
0.0189913269,
-0.0019100723,
-0.0290036108,
-0.0659835115,
0.0096759079,
0.011190108,
-0.0687227175,
0.0879025012,
0.0034410805,
0.0000995255,
0.0351973698,
0.0457183719,
-0.0049708327,
0.0791852698,
0.0155638559,
0.0272935685,
0.0511565208,
-0.0201817229,
0.0155225042,
0.0470853783,
0.0391757153,
0.0411691256,
-0.056462571,
0.0266350918,
-0.05716772,
-0.0317846723,
0.0174334887,
0.0417474695,
0.004859311,
-0.0656472817,
0.056109868,
0.088885963,
-0.0252804477,
-0.0076784361,
0.0613370016,
0.0109750479,
-0.0408408158,
-0.0313027538,
-0.0719304681,
-0.0296091102,
-0.0541496463,
-0.0513579361,
0.009726705,
0.0260832757,
-0.0291518699,
-0.0317554846,
-0.0509056188,
-0.0252441168,
0.0374959707,
-0.0036201188,
0.0229477901,
-0.0229259394,
-0.0133208744,
0.045704104,
0.0589748137,
-0.030721264,
-0.0043108105,
-0.0735707954,
0.0437361598,
0.0890476778,
0.0084789945,
-0.0023166745,
0.018050326,
-0.074740842,
-0.0155675532,
0.0296413042,
-0.0106928973,
0.0091924602,
0.0123933256,
-0.0484727472,
-0.0212972108,
0.0286751166,
0.0179568529,
0.0037340838,
0.0402797423,
-0.0107489303,
0.0065074763,
0.0319283903,
-0.0323272385,
0.0227494333,
0.0055404394,
-0.0371725671,
-0.0134208193,
0.0027584664,
0.0649809614,
0.0248331018,
-0.0065337052,
-0.0519883446,
0.0123489378,
0.0067072269,
-0.0243768338,
-0.0142341517,
-0.0565642528,
-0.0006852429,
0.0279382244,
-0.0152804349,
-0.002910017,
0.0445674509,
-0.0028882402,
0.0224598944,
0.0314120688,
-0.0127054853,
-0.0050212508,
-0.0171759371,
-0.020827923,
-0.0581362732,
0.028123511,
-0.0217126049,
0.0417859778,
-0.0338887833,
-0.0170485582,
0.0133624924,
-0.0281013381,
0.017332105,
0.0074244724,
-0.0382029675,
-0.0125869829,
-0.0106981201,
0.0070843943,
-0.021815056,
0.0135474941,
-0.0160937831,
-0.0158597492,
-0.0662321374,
-0.0058976775,
-0.043214567,
-0.0361874141,
0.0114869205,
0.0024552185,
-0.0346151404,
0.0250332095,
-0.0089129228,
-0.0193231348,
0.0643692985,
0.0445045233,
0.003205233,
-0.0406774729,
-0.0407657251,
-0.0326172598,
-0.0192776248,
0.0005873531,
0.0223226454,
0.0077685402,
-0.0702001825,
0.03317542,
0.0220360234,
-0.0400600173,
-0.0062776217,
-0.0250202212,
-0.0502102673,
0.0214172713,
0.0174498111,
-0.0151082426,
0.0342015959,
0.0387915522,
0.1188824847,
0.0282797869,
-0.0025204686,
-0.0381151326,
-0.0050000059,
-0.0251943488,
-0.0176734701,
-0.050895229,
-0.0534536727,
-0.0343123004,
0.0769381747,
0.0366678908,
-0.0080711935,
-0.0660851002,
0.0331283286,
-0.0403674841,
-0.0355730541,
-0.0265398156,
-0.0825930983,
-0.0408287644,
0.0010016173,
-0.0295352861,
-0.098784171,
0.054138802,
-0.0112948073,
0.0191957504,
0.0098897358,
-0.0619957782,
-0.0158885252,
0.0465859286,
0.0117962938,
0.0188896488,
-0.0316402577,
-0.0071825958,
0.0250293873,
-0.0505031906,
0.0237978082,
-0.0153292287,
0.0118946061,
-0.0275809057,
0.0169008486,
0.0056369635,
-0.0165941101,
-0.0562103465,
-0.0672243685,
-0.0545887463,
-0.0439486317,
0.0132339559,
-0.0150845796,
0.0077654896,
0.0217616968,
0.0218994357,
-0.0204658415,
0.000852267,
0.013786599,
0.0153308921,
-0.0417785831,
0.0004315298,
-0.0071217818,
0.0362717025,
-0.0075834445,
0.0184536353,
0.0418621711,
0.0096319718,
0.0023205841,
-0.0028715641,
0.0316459835,
0.026579354,
0.0302415974,
-0.0150804836,
0.0162286609,
0.0404863581,
-0.0193531383,
0.0282762479,
0.1021264642,
0.0111192903,
-0.0217520427,
-0.005526064,
0.0094916746,
0.026080694,
0.023108514,
-0.0461470075,
-0.0998981893,
-0.0175150856,
0.005972873,
0.0501535125,
-0.0852705687,
-0.0314486958,
-0.0142800184,
-0.0639825314,
0.0418375656,
-0.0026990429,
-0.0209774394,
-0.0049008415,
-0.019461507,
0.0124831358,
-0.0021808567,
0.0598739833,
-0.0258314051,
0.0146417161,
-0.026854191,
0.009183662,
-0.0893098041,
-0.030190926,
0.0248748306,
-0.0159513019,
0.0596293435,
0.0316646956,
0.0241547506,
-0.0368339047,
-0.0173963793,
0.0630574226,
0.0069751167,
-0.0078710867,
-0.0631252453,
0.0495910309,
0.0039479183,
-0.0134458179,
-0.0346719027,
0.0645039678,
-0.0161369685,
0.0025668391,
0.013816948,
0.0449806973,
-0.0018391199,
-0.0070485515,
-0.0358296782,
0.0192199331,
-0.0086408462,
0.1101961955,
0.0315504,
-0.0506982617,
0.0142667415,
-0.062989153,
-0.0591610335,
0.0095353974,
-0.0984711945,
-0.021992119,
-0.022001775,
-0.0129292691,
0.0042081601,
-0.0269923545,
0.0302713737,
0.0261631217,
0.0227396917,
-0.0090989657,
-0.0499431491,
-0.0032546269,
-0.0288449228,
0.0330998078,
0.0023279297,
0.045961272,
-0.0227763075,
0.0387363248,
-0.0100791482,
-0.0238067135,
-0.0049596247,
0.0257984009,
-0.0605538487,
-0.0594625995,
0.0691827163,
0.0417894758,
0.0299401414,
0.0386402681,
-0.0036694328,
-0.0839203447,
0.0575277805,
0.0423290059,
-0.0037233562,
0.0212700181,
0.0508047268,
0.0192821007,
0.0144663965,
0.0205277596,
-0.0105507178,
0.0327655114,
0.0561589114,
-0.0525232702,
-0.0606399775,
-0.0117002772,
-0.0147730773,
0.0038642634,
0.0525290817,
-0.0169526227,
-0.0486396663,
-0.01368625,
-0.0158417299,
-0.0093782917,
-0.0228811055,
-0.0171031617,
0.0043489821,
0.0088586491,
-0.019629132,
-0.0497090556,
-0.0631741583,
-0.0603101403,
0.0257479604,
-0.0359997787,
0.0552103482,
0.0361333638,
0.0230554882,
0.0433561988,
0.0224560779,
-0.0291561484,
0.0512479655,
-0.0058452985,
-0.0305722915,
0.0298038572,
0.0479711182,
0.0059244731,
0.0172362421,
0.0326536745,
-0.017377859,
0.005444102,
-0.021688981,
-0.0312394332,
-0.0019733065,
-0.0224749576,
-0.023233436,
0.0372855775,
0.0143914949,
-0.0151023176,
-0.0343111157,
0.0144325858,
-0.0104380641,
-0.0599846728,
0.0369802676,
0.0370185338,
-0.0435429364,
0.0162862614,
0.0331787802,
0.0197701212,
0.0514097288,
0.0339283049,
-0.0211607013,
-0.0111840591,
0.0082836933,
0.0553460978,
0.0278900787,
0.0165623873,
0.0148924012,
-0.0704391524,
-0.0512011535,
-0.0016899431,
-0.0611352436,
0.0195634309,
-0.0160983261,
0.0162726901,
0.0543212071,
-0.007411764,
0.0288234074,
-0.0010556666,
-0.0034694823,
0.0032976794,
-0.0578914247,
0.0117694261,
-6.169347736e-33,
-0.0010940076,
-0.0517132469,
-0.032619305,
0.0040686447,
-0.0122381262,
-0.0249896366,
0.0332967751,
0.0195280127,
-0.0020529791,
0.0007432263,
0.0100039141,
0.0231782347,
0.0089914482,
-0.0076655503,
-0.0156826358,
-0.0596074834,
0.0185663272,
-0.0311211962,
0.0009918503,
0.0025064168,
0.0487508066,
-0.0018566906,
0.0089129852,
-0.0605941266,
0.0846913531,
-0.0156739131,
-0.0220540911,
0.0313628986,
0.0010963462,
0.0650695786,
-0.0166054834,
0.0933540538,
0.0350337774,
-0.0106073394,
0.0114743765,
0.0574727654,
-0.0291073564,
-0.0087890774,
0.044417087,
-0.0123159289,
0.0271806344,
-0.0356783643,
0.0435516983,
0.0106273107,
-0.0604710542,
-0.0199583862,
0.0086418539,
-0.05027337,
0.0281816609,
-0.0324419439,
-0.0202746354,
0.0318279639,
-0.0320288241,
0.0081638247,
-0.0028930281,
0.0242742971,
0.0250443537,
0.0394196697,
-0.0540717766,
0.0185715929,
0.0052634943,
-0.0282238033,
0.0377475619,
0.0131569477,
-0.0005674308,
0.0756706297,
0.0010102671,
0.0069489619,
-0.0385864079,
0.0128877275,
0.014196679,
0.0460513048,
0.0581540838,
0.0583055094,
-0.0089055793,
-0.0618781559,
-0.0636371821,
-0.0120293405,
0.0508789495,
-0.0102431662,
0.0359413065,
-0.0168529376,
-0.0670614839,
-0.0548279248,
-0.0331423953,
-0.0543445572,
-0.0246485155,
-0.0436649658,
0.0321300849,
-0.0173241217,
0.0027747548,
-0.0423311144,
0.0234321486,
-0.0272455439,
-0.0001979388,
0.0367707685,
-0.0157036185,
-0.0027068488,
0.0357850194,
0.0318342969,
-0.0293811411,
0.0144687844,
-0.0033562542,
-0.0332102664,
0.0272524916,
-0.0043357639,
0.0424181856,
0.0461298376,
-0.064412266,
0.0109051876,
-0.0179737881,
0.0625105426,
-0.0381684117,
0.0403621681,
0.011233707,
0.0280051623,
-0.003437716,
0.0064238254,
0.0235543177,
-0.0299347136,
-0.0043810667,
0.0090904888,
-0.0508250371,
0.016928779,
-0.0137010803,
-0.004328209,
0.026324166,
0.0052567185,
0.0582668632,
-0.0700381249,
0.0188078117,
-0.0427056812,
2.649e-7,
0.0048491363,
0.0351350047,
-0.0122418189,
0.0039357217,
0.0225004498,
0.0493861213,
0.0314814337,
0.0102699138,
0.0018955718,
-0.0295705386,
-0.0182722043,
0.0570831224,
0.0290359855,
0.0449763387,
-0.0113633247,
0.0134195536,
-0.0582010038,
-0.0158674102,
-0.0638269782,
0.0278536323,
0.0184217133,
0.0881458223,
0.0722666234,
-0.0346335992,
-0.0262794159,
-0.0121331243,
0.0007563281,
-0.09309569,
-0.0207490418,
-0.0217980165,
0.0895312577,
0.0127293039,
0.0304759797,
-0.0012287361,
0.0106455432,
0.012380966,
-0.0360985659,
0.0598529316,
0.0260887463,
-0.029749807,
-0.0061656167,
-0.0378549211,
-0.0126741221,
-0.0527865887,
0.0634831563,
0.0114021972,
-0.0232794434,
-0.0387901999,
0.0095038302,
-0.0618028864,
0.0288260859,
-0.0267729592,
0.0020202138,
-0.017064821,
0.0201467965,
-0.0423393473,
0.0218366012,
-0.0988484249,
-0.0025952598,
-0.0040042107,
-0.0277700517,
-0.0535405241,
-0.0162234716,
0.0159594025,
0.0581915006,
0.0154797724,
0.0310993232,
2.40594444e-34,
0.0285384376,
-0.0289695561,
-0.0022128178,
-0.0238756314,
0.0338071138,
0.0566420555,
-0.0267209411,
0.0057661906,
0.0633344725,
-0.0396388918,
0.0164741315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12851v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12851v1 | EmoDiarize: Speaker Diarization and Emotion Identification from Speech Signals using Convolutional Neural Networks | 2023-10-19T16:02:53 | 2023-10-19T16:02:53 | Hanan Hamza, Fiza Gafoor, Fathima Sithara, Gayathri Anil, V. S. Anoop | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In the era of advanced artificial intelligence and human-computer
interaction, identifying emotions in spoken language is paramount. This
research explores the integration of deep learning techniques in speech emotion
recognition, offering a comprehensive solution to the challenges associated
with speaker diarization and emotion identification. It introduces a framework
that combines a pre-existing speaker diarization pipeline and an emotion
identification model built on a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) to achieve
higher precision. The proposed model was trained on data from five speech
emotion datasets, namely, RAVDESS, CREMA-D, SAVEE, TESS, and Movie Clips, out
of which the latter is a speech emotion dataset created specifically for this
research. The features extracted from each sample include Mel Frequency
Cepstral Coefficients (MFCC), Zero Crossing Rate (ZCR), Root Mean Square (RMS),
and various data augmentation algorithms like pitch, noise, stretch, and shift.
This feature extraction approach aims to enhance prediction accuracy while
reducing computational complexity. The proposed model yields an unweighted
accuracy of 63%, demonstrating remarkable efficiency in accurately identifying
emotional states within speech signals. | [
-0.0269817393,
0.0470345318,
0.0026757808,
0.0215975959,
0.0255708806,
0.0271017682,
0.0362868607,
-0.0532292798,
-0.0114910463,
0.011773522,
-0.02762172,
-0.0053782072,
-0.0499480553,
0.0038316639,
-0.0377903655,
-0.083300069,
0.0061289831,
0.0615210906,
0.0810724646,
-0.0105526708,
0.0200728811,
0.0251941159,
-0.0358318612,
0.0129690729,
-0.0686327517,
-0.0223910473,
-0.018084608,
0.051444564,
0.0527773611,
0.0008892993,
0.035075523,
0.0533253066,
0.0324907117,
0.0580985509,
0.000002186,
0.0103826541,
-0.0178000983,
-0.0386070609,
-0.0605472736,
-0.0201246608,
0.0498350076,
0.0041322908,
-0.0364245474,
0.0074190698,
-0.0028283859,
-0.0332252309,
0.029819794,
0.0521688685,
0.0878266841,
0.0503142215,
0.0002310112,
-0.0041063172,
0.002850889,
0.0125213796,
-0.0302067623,
-0.0116394525,
0.0084355203,
-0.0346219093,
-0.0216844156,
-0.0868214816,
-0.0255244132,
0.0246674288,
0.013402327,
0.0095290979,
0.0501785912,
-0.041379109,
-0.0348103717,
-0.0447137244,
-0.0151416119,
0.0789417475,
-0.0336263962,
0.0066481605,
0.0106606344,
0.0124269044,
-0.0113006616,
-0.0361343399,
-0.0057643601,
-0.0084789004,
0.0203817636,
-0.0108350441,
-0.072376281,
0.03399124,
0.0312213022,
0.0187344719,
-0.0199222025,
-0.0023836805,
-0.036244072,
-0.0191990715,
0.0596590824,
-0.0635974705,
-0.0056289234,
0.0015193914,
0.0240937322,
-0.0123770833,
-0.0194754694,
-0.0179678369,
-0.0162248351,
-0.0678813979,
-0.0529637448,
-0.024503611,
-0.0718517303,
0.0126670739,
-0.0409291424,
0.0136937797,
0.0154049881,
0.0347266048,
0.0226769708,
-0.0327204168,
-0.0254697986,
-0.0219340362,
-0.0527219437,
0.0293527655,
0.0152699919,
0.0174546055,
0.0566638932,
-0.0315255374,
-0.1080246791,
-0.0147472946,
-0.0788263902,
0.0101943808,
-0.0365565494,
0.0322118998,
-0.0051761703,
0.0069184513,
0.0163781475,
0.0587345846,
-0.0345970131,
0.0343353748,
-0.0035027994,
-0.062706463,
0.0236586351,
0.0257101674,
0.0244160499,
0.0114065399,
0.0690030307,
-0.0266048312,
0.0340778865,
-0.0382410251,
-0.0178938564,
-0.0281881653,
-0.0206577554,
-0.0321608819,
0.0280278251,
-0.0505501516,
0.036381539,
-0.032415837,
0.010062784,
-0.0457392931,
-0.0094643589,
-0.0507160425,
0.0108870473,
0.0428722613,
-0.0019870095,
0.0039993087,
0.0508850515,
0.0100438436,
0.033579845,
-0.0096367802,
0.0437567122,
0.0215751976,
0.0208928846,
-0.0669827238,
0.0457017832,
0.0306803733,
-0.0214591324,
-0.0343378522,
-0.0195807945,
-0.0614807084,
-0.0424620956,
0.0490884222,
0.0448734015,
-0.0303641427,
-0.0131750805,
-0.0270997491,
0.0005776781,
0.052271191,
0.008342769,
0.0461649597,
0.0102203563,
0.014317208,
0.0512834936,
-0.0374265499,
-0.0207382198,
0.0101828026,
0.0241469555,
-0.0608858466,
0.0380327404,
-0.0084733702,
-0.0326721221,
-0.0283567831,
0.031831719,
-0.0491819754,
0.0071947416,
0.0414947383,
-0.008931879,
-0.042202957,
0.0065515474,
0.0133321024,
0.0069787689,
-0.0726774633,
0.0023852724,
0.0025761977,
-0.0218480602,
0.0344100408,
-0.0278062262,
-0.0453332514,
0.0006776424,
-0.0688787997,
-0.0174932405,
-0.0209026206,
0.0109542524,
-0.0116717638,
0.0280490499,
-0.0795425475,
0.0080131004,
0.0396470837,
-0.0105011035,
0.0174507909,
-0.0356872603,
0.0160855837,
0.0054715653,
-0.0097591495,
0.0239316896,
-0.0000904526,
-0.0027771592,
-0.0602937229,
-0.0056699212,
0.0570182502,
0.0339494646,
0.0685867891,
-0.0091179488,
-0.0550025515,
0.0429941826,
0.0065546273,
0.0232248697,
0.0117426664,
-0.0338248909,
-0.0143887755,
0.0472148061,
-0.0481237695,
0.0056975032,
0.08866705,
-0.0274436101,
-0.0625685304,
0.0926979259,
0.0218794756,
0.0143181849,
-0.0160871968,
0.0389206111,
-0.0107004438,
0.0485428609,
0.028062148,
0.0066381185,
0.0120180957,
-0.0073766559,
0.0050215577,
0.0171832405,
0.0219906308,
-0.0377866067,
-0.0490633324,
-0.0248145927,
-0.0217998084,
0.014701996,
-0.013837426,
-0.0433852449,
-0.0465412699,
-0.0340920612,
-0.0838459507,
0.0242255032,
-0.0216333978,
-0.0292969048,
-0.0290386863,
0.0147159835,
-0.0397769324,
0.0026633479,
-0.0073748063,
0.0009884739,
-0.0045788321,
-0.0359597281,
-0.0303239059,
-0.0155660771,
-0.0515446588,
-0.0394249745,
-0.0025207901,
-0.0333392248,
-0.0115458854,
-0.0271105114,
-0.024793474,
0.0468513034,
-0.0317551009,
-0.0297192615,
0.0525168255,
0.0070760422,
-0.034924902,
-0.0356849208,
0.020365864,
-0.013715216,
0.0190280136,
0.0006423026,
0.0798291713,
-0.0345125608,
0.0275304299,
-0.0204069689,
0.0584569238,
-0.0037384306,
0.0405597314,
-0.0239964146,
-0.0164184533,
-0.0260581896,
-0.0033968699,
-0.0105713122,
0.0222908445,
0.0012914183,
-0.0303719677,
0.0474987552,
-0.0368739776,
0.0349302143,
-0.0276396777,
0.0035013983,
-0.0116153294,
0.0365259498,
-0.0417504087,
-0.01538774,
-0.0118369292,
-0.057330478,
-0.0506719537,
-0.0814985335,
-0.0196089484,
-0.0072921701,
-0.0277140252,
0.0250960402,
0.0069142156,
-0.0134092225,
0.005774471,
-0.0656240806,
-0.0347606465,
-0.0616161563,
0.0179812945,
-0.0094078602,
-0.0401332304,
0.0163486879,
-0.0074885581,
-0.0546484403,
-0.0087000998,
-0.0404348709,
0.0160233825,
0.0073576733,
-0.0401403494,
-0.0081512071,
-0.0440915786,
0.0335141495,
-0.0374967866,
0.0220734458,
0.0211738385,
0.003081758,
0.0609147474,
0.0336059667,
0.0574871562,
0.0308350138,
-0.0098338062,
0.0190668199,
-0.0139301009,
0.0292627029,
0.048692368,
-0.0571641028,
0.0207261015,
-0.0028402396,
0.0111235213,
-0.0070364894,
-0.0131012425,
-0.0182387568,
-0.0231583323,
0.0655888319,
0.1297366917,
0.0348400958,
-0.0971138179,
-0.0016448516,
-0.0272684097,
-0.0148159713,
0.004945097,
0.0038623076,
-0.0213451404,
-0.0293403808,
0.0325482041,
0.0231431331,
-0.0014762499,
-0.0141386064,
-0.0183802973,
-0.0312573798,
0.0562924929,
-0.0023930955,
0.0047866167,
-0.0384786688,
-0.0134770581,
0.0039284788,
-0.0074610324,
0.0349590741,
-0.0451637954,
0.0175816379,
-0.0182288475,
0.0494009331,
-0.0545422547,
-0.0214829128,
0.0338567905,
-0.0363481939,
0.065910019,
0.0076723271,
0.0579514541,
-0.0425000824,
-0.0145236794,
-0.0140246758,
-0.0105664162,
-0.0267218202,
-0.0163090993,
0.0529911369,
-0.0228018668,
-0.0112471813,
0.0020275079,
0.0467530079,
-0.0209912974,
0.0143388435,
0.0016160281,
0.0482581258,
-0.0085952776,
-0.0179656446,
-0.0250116754,
0.0465891734,
0.048170533,
0.0455318168,
0.0144847156,
-0.0361742564,
-0.0160581581,
-0.0007707205,
0.053862609,
0.0234238133,
-0.0250130463,
0.0174373798,
0.0202114526,
-0.0632691532,
0.0183660444,
-0.0469975732,
-0.0154229719,
0.0048698764,
-0.012016437,
-0.036269024,
0.0113447877,
-0.0087185409,
-0.0384484679,
0.0513327532,
0.0257869754,
0.0539216809,
-0.0260811802,
0.0027680011,
0.0512045212,
-0.0241259541,
0.0035154554,
-0.0042945663,
-0.0423397943,
-0.00052727,
0.0302589387,
-0.019309191,
0.0122354431,
0.044626046,
0.0078583034,
-0.0694919229,
0.0478506461,
-0.0116290227,
-0.0127361435,
-0.0026583888,
0.0798542723,
0.0032864537,
-0.0469832644,
0.0152891483,
-0.031832017,
0.074077405,
0.0083634285,
-0.0561800078,
-0.0640164092,
-0.0741366223,
-0.0393369831,
0.0068124458,
0.0187967941,
0.0287637003,
-0.0261462666,
-0.0189118255,
-0.0036018186,
0.0438368395,
0.0285178609,
-0.0086372597,
-0.023884045,
0.0002983724,
0.0385892801,
-0.0272880569,
-0.0232803654,
0.0050524008,
-0.0717833489,
0.0144564658,
0.0835349262,
-0.0028997951,
0.0009747833,
-0.0239861533,
0.0271999668,
0.018816201,
0.0440799594,
0.0119385999,
0.0090555539,
0.0088942079,
-0.0014914962,
-0.0076306476,
0.0002748166,
-0.0310103633,
0.0558179431,
-0.0069798133,
-0.0168825705,
-0.0104812784,
0.0068462598,
0.0408963412,
-0.0365486704,
0.0479869917,
-0.0214224923,
0.0322655886,
-0.0042858184,
-0.0196570717,
-0.0396158695,
0.0120691489,
0.0365679376,
-0.002706127,
-0.0192638896,
0.0240578949,
0.0057326611,
-0.0381543487,
0.0501635298,
-0.0228634775,
0.0054905876,
-0.0775245056,
0.0116431275,
0.0499737822,
-0.0256990939,
-0.0093170172,
0.007287581,
0.0103526907,
-0.03803901,
0.0838739574,
-0.0522656925,
0.0004589073,
-0.0114438254,
0.0096854782,
0.009336425,
-0.0624628849,
0.0386993438,
0.0150347445,
-0.028076997,
-0.0481185988,
-0.0490046293,
-0.0019732721,
-6.257971194e-33,
0.0232969914,
0.0369163044,
-0.0547688305,
-0.0049793217,
-0.0390564539,
0.0028624805,
0.0116145555,
0.0310184918,
-0.0174617302,
0.0213140547,
-0.0220331922,
0.0400771052,
0.0234855302,
0.023948336,
-0.0284345467,
-0.0517158508,
0.054396607,
-0.0036803589,
0.0309063364,
0.0439002998,
0.0354040675,
0.0510992892,
0.0410370268,
-0.1338819116,
-0.046320837,
-0.0002948081,
-0.0192490816,
-0.0173008665,
0.0487746298,
0.0211711507,
0.0085782027,
0.0476570278,
-0.0078013111,
-0.0196014233,
0.012501142,
0.0391910858,
-0.0475807935,
0.0299729668,
-0.0830693468,
0.047102116,
-0.0167599283,
-0.0536809228,
0.0404018722,
0.0478470065,
-0.0139496094,
-0.0326960497,
0.0578975715,
-0.0083327526,
0.0285920557,
-0.0293622836,
0.0181903634,
0.0148994364,
-0.0557527579,
-0.0454718545,
0.0461203717,
0.0442759618,
-0.019042749,
0.0189198833,
-0.0854452699,
0.0143401679,
0.0106567228,
-0.0147509631,
0.0096050613,
0.0453439355,
-0.0282974299,
0.0641421303,
0.0848363489,
-0.0623392724,
0.0255786888,
0.0075661317,
0.0569199473,
0.0707462206,
0.0358439535,
0.0320630595,
0.028252326,
-0.0457607731,
-0.0343602262,
0.0447300337,
0.085508056,
-0.0098269144,
-0.0026722164,
-0.0110924337,
-0.0239304528,
0.0061187474,
-0.0107790297,
-0.0219093021,
0.0045559928,
-0.0174842793,
0.0230941698,
-0.0330636986,
-0.0020019864,
-0.0172568969,
0.0233138707,
-0.0188689586,
0.0319921598,
0.0209681541,
-0.0194473658,
0.0600923337,
0.0199129637,
0.0045624152,
0.0208415221,
-0.016726071,
0.0861176029,
0.0209050663,
0.0680021793,
-0.0231883582,
-0.0110768648,
0.0644530579,
-0.0033915769,
-0.0007019896,
0.0225547217,
0.040111471,
0.0056752502,
0.0555578806,
-0.0355508178,
0.0082965028,
0.0207350142,
-0.0492479689,
0.0218060371,
0.0723873824,
0.0189877935,
-0.0215946697,
0.0090633985,
0.0326772556,
-0.0617023446,
-0.0111904936,
-0.0105859917,
-0.0130392741,
0.022591915,
-0.0415343828,
0.0179150216,
-0.0243779235,
3.001e-7,
-0.055000063,
-0.0039437423,
0.0488460213,
-0.0563848168,
0.0319708958,
0.0412119925,
0.0098519949,
0.0105253775,
0.0361698642,
-0.0224556774,
0.0723477304,
-0.0067015719,
0.0764416233,
0.0148015143,
-0.0926592425,
-0.0339442492,
-0.0130110141,
0.0425906591,
-0.0078754202,
0.0323213935,
0.0503132939,
0.0969453976,
0.0455212705,
-0.0430086106,
0.047267545,
0.009351152,
-0.0257911813,
-0.0390557945,
0.0368065648,
0.0152501548,
0.0006315249,
-0.0277137179,
-0.0178265311,
0.0437343195,
0.0098642809,
0.0531879999,
0.0361559205,
0.0339227617,
0.0274691228,
-0.0532304272,
0.0013089887,
0.0458844416,
-0.0253499988,
0.0319668464,
0.0408382006,
0.0029385632,
-0.0287844203,
-0.0231436491,
-0.0360099301,
0.0269760936,
0.0503991805,
-0.0138644595,
-0.0140454536,
0.0089334734,
-0.0113799535,
-0.0547354445,
-0.0251094121,
-0.0829210803,
0.0094443681,
0.0485278144,
-0.0586055741,
-0.0005874599,
0.0016377614,
-0.0220933519,
0.0602890514,
-0.0053302096,
0.0065681376,
1.991606559e-34,
-0.0117834806,
0.0268966388,
-0.0141190272,
0.0042262543,
-0.0196043439,
0.0023936627,
-0.0281871855,
-0.013216679,
0.0353794582,
-0.0567740425,
0.0021952649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12836v1 | Knowledge-Augmented Language Model Verification | 2023-10-19T15:40:00 | 2023-10-19T15:40:00 | Jinheon Baek, Soyeong Jeong, Minki Kang, Jong C. Park, Sung Ju Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent Language Models (LMs) have shown impressive capabilities in generating
texts with the knowledge internalized in parameters. Yet, LMs often generate
the factually incorrect responses to the given queries, since their knowledge
may be inaccurate, incomplete, and outdated. To address this problem, previous
works propose to augment LMs with the knowledge retrieved from an external
knowledge source. However, such approaches often show suboptimal text
generation performance due to two reasons: 1) the model may fail to retrieve
the knowledge relevant to the given query, or 2) the model may not faithfully
reflect the retrieved knowledge in the generated text. To overcome these, we
propose to verify the output and the knowledge of the knowledge-augmented LMs
with a separate verifier, which is a small LM that is trained to detect those
two types of errors through instruction-finetuning. Then, when the verifier
recognizes an error, we can rectify it by either retrieving new knowledge or
generating new text. Further, we use an ensemble of the outputs from different
instructions with a single verifier to enhance the reliability of the
verification processes. We validate the effectiveness of the proposed
verification steps on multiple question answering benchmarks, whose results
show that the proposed verifier effectively identifies retrieval and generation
errors, allowing LMs to provide more factually correct outputs. Our code is
available at https://github.com/JinheonBaek/KALMV. | [
0.0427492186,
0.0207627267,
0.0206826851,
0.0440012142,
-0.0217678025,
-0.0041404101,
-0.0151899746,
0.009910333,
0.0174260382,
-0.0862636119,
0.01121445,
-0.0291078296,
-0.0047279578,
-0.0078286007,
0.0584005676,
0.0062956889,
0.0727331117,
-0.0148748625,
0.0030661635,
-0.0234320145,
0.0192763489,
0.0250891615,
0.0024487292,
0.0099535044,
0.0038678341,
-0.0150775136,
-0.0022045127,
0.0013558996,
0.0148429396,
0.0051557152,
0.0568268597,
0.0538411476,
-0.0314584635,
0.0291250814,
0.0000020712,
-0.0371270664,
-0.018210141,
0.00961293,
-0.0532994047,
0.0276652854,
-0.0183836594,
0.0051254341,
-0.0050620981,
0.0468316972,
-0.0431136936,
-0.0162806585,
0.0147768045,
0.0364122279,
0.0948019102,
0.0869615152,
0.0259655789,
0.0255418271,
0.0318753459,
-0.0014557653,
0.0159466919,
-0.0205857195,
0.0445655026,
0.0237786975,
0.0137819285,
0.0185757689,
0.0187776536,
0.063023448,
0.0208363757,
-0.0082456386,
-0.0094326604,
0.0252337158,
-0.0214293338,
0.0212913472,
-0.0226856135,
0.0445622094,
-0.0000634587,
-0.0639829412,
-0.0179896522,
0.003586496,
-0.0239147209,
0.0166481938,
-0.0009218823,
0.0298955701,
0.0018216979,
-0.0124633936,
0.0050598481,
-0.0163696576,
0.0341129936,
0.0433869809,
-0.0263347272,
0.0845276639,
0.0210706461,
-0.0557763092,
-0.0099168066,
0.0042704279,
-0.0208484735,
-0.089876011,
-0.014082171,
0.0552870296,
-0.0054769581,
0.0383674726,
-0.049361743,
-0.0298050866,
0.0546275154,
-0.0401867405,
0.0215827506,
0.0191020053,
-0.0135376379,
0.0365226269,
-0.056063164,
0.0869144723,
0.0198437609,
0.0182759855,
-0.0266464818,
-0.0058139744,
-0.0229140874,
-0.0271574892,
-0.0199527778,
0.0389478058,
-0.0106900102,
0.0146932667,
-0.0209408216,
0.0388624072,
-0.0213339571,
0.0647118166,
-0.0157346632,
0.0019269527,
0.0043760762,
-0.0272890683,
-0.0749037042,
0.0401783362,
-0.0261450429,
0.0113698132,
0.0217288807,
-0.0912551805,
-0.009686619,
0.0212189145,
-0.0075249188,
-0.0028603689,
0.0195958596,
0.0111237606,
-0.0102721015,
-0.0000856994,
-0.0257938411,
-0.055123318,
-0.0330457538,
-0.0683068931,
-0.0144549794,
-0.0890770331,
0.0323918499,
-0.0072231581,
-0.0230125599,
-0.025386693,
0.0227876958,
0.0495339856,
-0.0121383332,
0.0656571165,
-0.046453815,
0.0136267608,
0.0172172654,
0.0107176891,
0.0202965476,
0.040297661,
0.0413858481,
-0.0107837506,
0.0334335454,
0.0129404748,
0.0205464866,
0.0130412467,
0.0459722504,
0.0017513231,
-0.0039857472,
0.0390089378,
-0.0077729677,
-0.0124515155,
-0.0389321223,
0.0956992209,
-0.0244904701,
0.0003824189,
0.0372645967,
-0.0196179561,
-0.0041590072,
-0.0317616463,
0.0403880514,
-0.0203957185,
0.0363048427,
0.0170063861,
-0.0437091067,
0.0076479013,
-0.0602102764,
0.0345692337,
0.0289351586,
0.0254318863,
-0.0218683779,
-0.0717008039,
-0.0238642599,
-0.0145041775,
-0.0013129404,
0.0160899106,
0.0477237776,
0.0276808832,
-0.044057332,
0.0244534705,
0.0128305694,
-0.045414269,
0.0233658869,
-0.0644299313,
0.0657868534,
0.0632734969,
0.083374612,
0.0055705295,
-0.0531964041,
-0.0009001113,
-0.005406423,
0.0329334475,
0.0671804473,
-0.0080742324,
-0.0298878588,
-0.0390648358,
-0.0117408587,
-0.0174102671,
0.0095730992,
-0.0241763387,
0.091809839,
0.019238133,
0.042446252,
-0.0396459885,
-0.0235578697,
0.0312770158,
-0.0265534017,
-0.0290399697,
0.0043074773,
0.0023119247,
0.0001586158,
0.0017496424,
-0.0176024772,
0.0399737656,
0.0273188371,
0.0121136168,
-0.0418895148,
-0.0097506894,
-0.0263531506,
-0.0638173148,
0.055736009,
-0.014242107,
-0.0014312639,
0.0107842963,
-0.0318709537,
-0.0521655791,
-0.0185846966,
-0.0330036283,
-0.0141101647,
-0.085451588,
0.0092022903,
0.0182708874,
-0.0078323241,
-0.0234595798,
0.0670416281,
-0.0028026372,
0.0308220442,
-0.0222148839,
0.0022678382,
0.006897734,
-0.0409526601,
-0.0530469567,
-0.012040413,
-0.0123817744,
0.0618300289,
0.036574278,
0.0009365904,
-0.0522967055,
-0.0270047113,
-0.0858019367,
0.0213648379,
-0.0141999135,
0.0173341911,
0.0232717525,
-0.0016880123,
0.0021888223,
-0.0007591913,
-0.0495098792,
-0.0160515048,
0.0815862343,
0.0185185969,
0.0254265666,
0.0162979327,
0.0086637372,
-0.0322696194,
0.0066143735,
-0.0229772665,
0.0311225392,
0.0003048647,
0.0238378868,
-0.0712051913,
0.0105402656,
-0.0796638057,
0.0443046987,
0.0084408522,
-0.0216874089,
0.0100885453,
-0.0225253738,
0.0020529949,
0.0061229942,
0.0333667956,
-0.0331362337,
0.0471904948,
-0.0149993263,
-0.0631734654,
0.0351763554,
-0.0172553323,
-0.0213356297,
0.0133244097,
-0.0182698891,
0.0054931617,
0.0250478722,
-0.0032310362,
-0.0390950218,
-0.0392264761,
0.0390456952,
-0.0017359097,
-0.0207173843,
-0.0217370093,
-0.0081584342,
0.0112131191,
0.0252282489,
-0.0540111363,
-0.0325463638,
0.091317907,
-0.0606633462,
0.015044258,
-0.026416624,
0.0017178908,
0.0108366748,
0.0125193167,
0.0034941018,
0.0230311379,
0.0252034515,
0.0305664893,
-0.0315599814,
-0.0225351695,
0.0082091484,
-0.0766522884,
0.0628145337,
-0.0578734055,
0.0249402653,
0.027109433,
-0.0272646863,
-0.0860405937,
-0.0372299999,
-0.0068778982,
0.0114244204,
-0.0092721656,
-0.0017133765,
-0.0215811469,
0.0048542512,
0.0484829172,
0.008598079,
-0.0320897251,
-0.010866629,
-0.019721657,
0.037833821,
0.0626451671,
0.0296585374,
0.0338864997,
-0.0489703342,
0.0138486736,
0.0480522886,
0.0294925664,
-0.0050274297,
-0.0319528133,
-0.0346958116,
0.0056208959,
-0.0372736342,
0.0079571847,
0.0149124982,
0.0457952954,
-0.0673301592,
-0.0320718624,
0.1209704578,
0.0230566822,
0.015951667,
-0.0252861399,
0.010925645,
-0.0117204804,
0.005551334,
0.0725164786,
-0.0861107111,
-0.0177247003,
0.0046903579,
0.0566960722,
-0.0084232595,
0.0013527641,
-0.0204905961,
-0.1316917837,
0.02297749,
0.0134640252,
-0.0395511426,
-0.0553918891,
-0.0283777677,
0.0001520271,
0.0361475162,
0.0129125481,
0.0489181951,
0.0076868641,
0.0053337142,
0.0240141675,
-0.0204264745,
-0.0749143958,
0.0271909982,
-0.0486426577,
0.0422539115,
0.091166161,
-0.0104592219,
0.0173654947,
-0.0356638432,
-0.0240379721,
-0.043071758,
0.0037296624,
0.0076340288,
0.0267877169,
-0.0210653711,
-0.0101316804,
0.0037551853,
-0.0009121736,
-0.0297086202,
0.0123593621,
0.0076088221,
0.0649378672,
-0.0131968083,
-0.0301096756,
0.0024032386,
0.012748302,
-0.0002290045,
0.0732939765,
0.0037730064,
0.0283520576,
-0.0415335782,
-0.0290292986,
-0.0172156766,
-0.0557940081,
-0.0023562843,
0.0617457181,
0.0106805516,
0.0226652697,
-0.0762117803,
-0.0609906986,
0.0349435583,
0.0367018022,
-0.0166735612,
-0.0104615334,
0.0078485934,
-0.0250978377,
-0.0397046953,
-0.0136928074,
-0.0857780427,
0.0319646075,
-0.0250695366,
0.0046063252,
0.0052048797,
-0.0165616255,
0.0008443286,
0.0121935187,
-0.0718749911,
-0.0779626518,
-0.0443316847,
0.0777909756,
0.0186351538,
0.046426557,
-0.0528622344,
-0.0173402205,
0.0442192331,
0.0607996993,
-0.0280903317,
0.0425311439,
0.0006039566,
-0.042167943,
-0.0197311155,
0.0080300225,
-0.0625549033,
-0.0009184039,
-0.00949472,
0.0473990329,
-0.0355548672,
-0.0615320168,
0.0443390645,
0.057144355,
0.0022973644,
-0.0137451561,
-0.0124150114,
-0.0088735269,
0.0221804157,
-0.0056338371,
-0.0550213754,
-0.0086464509,
0.0117497928,
-0.0090074744,
-0.0391367301,
0.0199443884,
-0.0015123492,
0.0037417074,
0.0384826511,
-0.0407546349,
-0.0305368192,
0.0200873334,
0.0218583196,
0.0218931045,
-0.0222777929,
-0.0306286532,
0.0072099315,
0.0014300885,
0.0475184508,
-0.0263450295,
0.0150736216,
0.0327892415,
-0.009030791,
-0.0132440496,
-0.0059931283,
-0.0567554645,
-0.0328794234,
-0.0635329634,
0.0098006288,
0.0742836893,
0.0124501474,
0.0431015119,
-0.0299039017,
-0.0187796634,
-0.0582527705,
-0.0150217218,
0.0337892026,
-0.0304121021,
0.0380325913,
0.0236076005,
-0.0018883708,
-0.002438511,
0.0724305511,
-0.0092815645,
0.0696211904,
0.0151628843,
-0.0053117545,
-0.054993134,
-0.0316749401,
-0.0333075188,
-0.0074854479,
-0.0244280268,
0.0013679947,
0.0024398277,
-0.0859804079,
0.0338239223,
0.049335476,
0.021825498,
0.0130535997,
0.0218653791,
0.0611048192,
0.034007553,
-0.0148068219,
-0.0555324852,
0.0181397926,
-0.0381512977,
0.0055151833,
0.0108434549,
-6.486228687e-33,
-0.062984176,
-0.0436155684,
0.0300798789,
-0.0367722921,
-0.0040716622,
0.0127782477,
-0.0508418716,
-0.033348687,
-0.0152072841,
0.0277110115,
-0.0016305601,
0.0122709321,
0.0028838795,
0.011677186,
-0.0070876619,
-0.0139692165,
0.0402905867,
-0.0070234835,
-0.0436205454,
0.0038246056,
0.0377986245,
0.0079909284,
0.026940519,
-0.0329356268,
0.0451615155,
-0.0406044684,
-0.0462741964,
0.0338767804,
-0.0579477884,
0.0861022845,
-0.0144166416,
0.0371796601,
0.0190794021,
-0.0330615267,
-0.0209104475,
-0.0040606689,
-0.0852677822,
-0.0246426743,
0.0165422745,
-0.0081607234,
-0.0583526455,
-0.0074408241,
0.0545397662,
-0.0278893057,
0.0125100836,
0.0096432818,
0.0162333492,
-0.0335464887,
0.0026051714,
-0.0380489938,
-0.0167888384,
0.0362668931,
0.0261430573,
-0.0405923128,
-0.028028354,
0.0463396423,
0.0202345084,
-0.0193661675,
-0.049903404,
0.0100724781,
0.0246235244,
0.055724591,
0.0782881305,
0.0070939399,
-0.0402400792,
0.0446880236,
-0.0310284328,
-0.0082387803,
-0.0431782305,
0.0152484067,
0.0307796821,
0.0268719327,
0.0609942265,
0.0467477925,
-0.0009628489,
-0.0048791203,
-0.0468320139,
0.0557524264,
0.0023756546,
0.0271050874,
0.023228582,
-0.0355146602,
-0.039710708,
-0.0131332995,
-0.0704587325,
0.027862832,
-0.0577898584,
-0.0156125063,
0.033870168,
0.0441366434,
-0.0303336568,
-0.012211048,
-0.0032946435,
-0.0655176565,
0.0034130949,
0.0257436093,
-0.0265046488,
-0.0147526646,
-0.0271031372,
0.0466279723,
-0.0338153765,
-0.0001238057,
0.0318902731,
-0.0070217061,
-0.0353388079,
0.0520971268,
0.0150578544,
0.0190424453,
-0.0604625866,
0.0290012769,
-0.0286173541,
0.0536579303,
-0.0014978668,
-0.030692935,
0.0223833937,
0.0218365658,
0.0072566974,
0.0334208012,
0.0093595777,
-0.0056821834,
0.0027333221,
-0.0099451663,
0.0167278964,
0.0266941264,
-0.0199295916,
0.0379853174,
-0.0414415561,
0.0068462794,
-0.0397939309,
0.0062548411,
0.0286402442,
0.0281966105,
2.753e-7,
0.0321532041,
0.0456050187,
0.0568744801,
0.0530574992,
-0.0016774155,
0.0298333671,
-0.015877448,
-0.0221021995,
0.0154696628,
-0.0409506708,
-0.0059185196,
0.0568669513,
0.0579746142,
0.0545989498,
-0.0369436927,
-0.0077442825,
-0.0468988456,
-0.0152986608,
-0.0248773899,
-0.012281456,
0.0570193529,
0.0534670204,
0.0173104368,
0.0018590965,
-0.0323094167,
-0.0753611326,
0.0674140304,
0.0241623521,
-0.0366274267,
0.0394882001,
0.0852475688,
0.0314106569,
0.0185772739,
0.0558571815,
-0.026425343,
0.0033486476,
-0.0321136266,
0.0590095334,
-0.0004328148,
-0.0182164889,
-0.0215015747,
-0.0125007275,
0.0199453868,
-0.0660548136,
0.0787153468,
-0.0060108779,
0.0394822918,
-0.0413881131,
-0.0169814583,
-0.0221065059,
0.0081734173,
-0.0298927221,
-0.0388576612,
0.0093916496,
0.0174112134,
0.0203104243,
-0.0087614888,
-0.0688124523,
-0.0364009105,
0.0037779477,
-0.035858728,
-0.0606685951,
-0.0156158227,
-0.0005934793,
0.0044379318,
-0.0783777907,
0.0087430179,
2.645784547e-34,
0.0239905398,
0.0014933046,
-0.010829865,
0.0175945461,
0.0501873195,
0.0092115151,
-0.0378950834,
0.0013525885,
-0.007738187,
-0.0776012912,
-0.0428764783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12823v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12823v2 | AgentTuning: Enabling Generalized Agent Abilities for LLMs | 2023-10-19T15:19:53 | 2023-10-22T16:19:16 | Aohan Zeng, Mingdao Liu, Rui Lu, Bowen Wang, Xiao Liu, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Open large language models (LLMs) with great performance in various tasks
have significantly advanced the development of LLMs. However, they are far
inferior to commercial models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 when acting as agents
to tackle complex tasks in the real world. These agent tasks employ LLMs as the
central controller responsible for planning, memorization, and tool
utilization, necessitating both fine-grained prompting methods and robust LLMs
to achieve satisfactory performance. Though many prompting methods have been
proposed to complete particular agent tasks, there is lack of research focusing
on improving the agent capabilities of LLMs themselves without compromising
their general abilities. In this work, we present AgentTuning, a simple and
general method to enhance the agent abilities of LLMs while maintaining their
general LLM capabilities. We construct AgentInstruct, a lightweight
instruction-tuning dataset containing high-quality interaction trajectories. We
employ a hybrid instruction-tuning strategy by combining AgentInstruct with
open-source instructions from general domains. AgentTuning is used to
instruction-tune the Llama 2 series, resulting in AgentLM. Our evaluations show
that AgentTuning enables LLMs' agent capabilities without compromising general
abilities. The AgentLM-70B is comparable to GPT-3.5-turbo on unseen agent
tasks, demonstrating generalized agent capabilities. We open source the
AgentInstruct and AgentLM-7B, 13B, and 70B models at
https://github.com/THUDM/AgentTuning, serving open and powerful alternatives to
commercial LLMs for agent tasks. | [
0.0191892292,
0.0155165978,
-0.0200893562,
0.0381579921,
-0.028082341,
0.0170302838,
-0.0171110854,
-0.0142753003,
0.0212620646,
-0.0031291281,
-0.0514823347,
-0.0078944666,
-0.0265031774,
0.0059905346,
0.0030186616,
-0.052332297,
0.0579742491,
-0.0588170812,
-0.0224692542,
-0.0098806685,
-0.0211148877,
-0.0226144642,
-0.0226552226,
0.0613901429,
0.0178907178,
-0.0118779792,
-0.0450597145,
0.0057968274,
0.0145180654,
-0.0136271799,
-0.0090283891,
0.021667257,
0.0477290004,
0.0246590581,
0.0000022538,
-0.0628594458,
0.0155235184,
-0.0306885447,
-0.035154555,
0.0120057417,
0.0248621684,
0.0187948458,
-0.0402514301,
0.0229013506,
-0.0483334363,
0.0071499408,
0.0371290594,
0.0164286159,
0.0643842593,
0.0846869275,
0.0227680802,
0.018391734,
-0.0001260749,
-0.0013267114,
0.0098288255,
-0.0540246926,
0.004094074,
-0.0251309853,
0.0539891385,
0.0127935242,
-0.0030185336,
0.0040510022,
0.0377419367,
-0.0160437636,
-0.0170096233,
0.0462047271,
-0.013805313,
-0.0293240342,
-0.0230802242,
0.0538644008,
0.0250210669,
0.0112531241,
0.0197509974,
0.0042091683,
0.013871341,
0.0101600392,
-0.0401136428,
0.0229373518,
-0.0012006259,
-0.0054560741,
0.0069141947,
-0.0265839081,
0.0086990772,
0.0100417947,
-0.0242670141,
0.0820310712,
-0.0016262619,
-0.0126374187,
-0.0126514556,
-0.0317550562,
0.008663483,
-0.0700380802,
-0.0043755006,
0.0771115199,
-0.0884132981,
0.0227427837,
-0.0413485467,
0.0389667116,
0.007459153,
-0.031663999,
0.0540182628,
0.0652749464,
-0.0272580702,
0.0370582379,
-0.009431567,
0.0731819943,
-0.0097434446,
0.0476072095,
-0.0210997164,
0.0238666181,
-0.072575219,
0.01236114,
-0.0446935892,
0.0205194596,
-0.06023404,
-0.0168088786,
-0.0187984407,
0.0874782577,
0.0021812427,
0.0230982415,
0.001480227,
-0.0128438435,
-0.0282298159,
-0.0055262521,
-0.0698648989,
-0.0206710864,
-0.0580820851,
-0.0014344907,
0.034566123,
-0.068318978,
-0.0239110645,
0.0016626891,
-0.005183585,
-0.0152784474,
0.0041075386,
0.114256382,
-0.0068973601,
-0.0267756488,
-0.0444277227,
-0.015555854,
0.0544847175,
-0.0768999979,
-0.0003537338,
-0.0431345589,
0.0297191963,
-0.0120788626,
-0.0268538073,
-0.0309085026,
0.0091314139,
0.0021447637,
0.0023252869,
0.0486227944,
0.0100671891,
0.0230065323,
0.0110569047,
0.0146765355,
-0.0465689674,
0.0579252951,
0.0248393789,
0.0435729101,
0.0131805046,
0.0181558058,
0.0399686359,
0.0603795759,
-0.0373392403,
0.0141810402,
0.0557776168,
0.0185448788,
0.016696468,
0.0517149754,
0.0229376797,
0.0362414457,
-0.0310438294,
-0.0105277356,
0.0694075301,
0.0483021736,
-0.0166036766,
0.0074532824,
0.0432517007,
0.0308358371,
0.0037900477,
-0.0076269256,
-0.0813798904,
0.0623715557,
-0.0062117749,
0.004161105,
-0.0253359992,
0.0402683131,
-0.0386805721,
-0.0251844265,
0.0170379598,
-0.0015106195,
0.0126947155,
0.0020428665,
0.0269442536,
-0.015736673,
-0.0780216902,
0.0061171153,
0.0182746239,
-0.0458965786,
-0.0313784033,
-0.0892121419,
0.0253426339,
0.0886949673,
0.0437623784,
-0.0268860068,
-0.0559560768,
0.0009997141,
0.034068007,
0.047856193,
0.0188198593,
-0.0239465348,
-0.0095712412,
-0.0459244549,
-0.0281764735,
-0.0112670781,
-0.0035911398,
0.0677509978,
0.0314669535,
-0.0121351518,
-0.0191051215,
0.0106223915,
-0.0135312276,
0.0313640386,
-0.0148424655,
-0.0504361056,
-0.0232561342,
0.0053012827,
0.0316888019,
0.0155894151,
-0.025780797,
-0.0106518222,
0.0410362557,
-0.0000703509,
0.0060126474,
0.0072961836,
-0.0392676555,
-0.0035589102,
0.0392165855,
0.0395745002,
-0.0109853791,
0.0250442438,
-0.0271616504,
-0.0481437258,
0.0246100668,
-0.0058984761,
0.0568792298,
-0.0263542999,
0.0304147154,
-0.0086045889,
-0.0171800032,
-0.0105931042,
0.0421406031,
0.0006495323,
-0.0425184667,
0.0782874078,
0.0574901327,
-0.0172632225,
-0.0511058867,
-0.0090686949,
0.0454786718,
0.0212913584,
0.0294389091,
-0.0014622051,
0.0298509952,
-0.0353743583,
-0.0426240154,
-0.0676491484,
0.0218709409,
-0.0348041095,
0.0202143528,
0.0063735526,
0.0070843678,
-0.0276593287,
0.0006005669,
-0.0004264293,
0.0411966629,
-0.0052897092,
0.0229902603,
0.0092786131,
0.0224941168,
-0.078912206,
-0.0522778891,
0.023090763,
0.0132229812,
-0.0369735137,
-0.0134426337,
-0.0143563868,
-0.0648614839,
0.0485454723,
-0.025822375,
0.0453126766,
-0.0383513905,
-0.0557275973,
0.0458177365,
-0.0271863751,
0.014373159,
0.077712819,
-0.0409940518,
0.0420158952,
0.0664078146,
-0.036756061,
-0.074311994,
0.0470743589,
-0.0209459607,
-0.0426075235,
-0.0510025211,
0.0248037316,
0.0078055155,
0.0653765202,
-0.0271114483,
0.020730149,
-0.0321693532,
-0.0140313059,
0.0148272095,
-0.0404180065,
0.0140306158,
0.0152440742,
-0.0632824898,
0.014711652,
-0.0285218135,
-0.0609810315,
0.0618248992,
-0.0356717519,
-0.0416238196,
-0.0022797491,
-0.0392901339,
-0.0375094227,
0.080742687,
-0.013043914,
-0.0093486086,
-0.0022043837,
-0.0314578749,
-0.0285440292,
-0.0067336261,
0.0014660422,
-0.0078675896,
0.029655261,
-0.0838685781,
0.0102375662,
-0.0074901907,
-0.0218683034,
-0.0294060726,
0.0288929753,
-0.0304458011,
0.0256183464,
-0.0058374167,
-0.0629999116,
-0.0305731017,
-0.0039640176,
0.0341517776,
0.0391898155,
-0.0165416896,
-0.0069807312,
-0.0651383922,
-0.056678772,
0.0204913039,
0.0450183861,
-0.0300599989,
-0.0362782851,
0.0432736427,
0.0405565649,
0.0384079739,
-0.0726361275,
-0.0303778909,
0.0026575772,
0.0290382802,
-0.0392666049,
0.002533959,
0.0469169579,
0.0588131174,
-0.073717773,
0.0040089758,
0.1028097793,
0.0179790054,
-0.0419764668,
0.005872983,
-0.0272127707,
0.0498575009,
0.0294588897,
0.0422555618,
-0.0542153008,
-0.0393361151,
0.0177846793,
0.0253044404,
-0.0071064746,
-0.0343134515,
-0.0009425519,
-0.0976825356,
0.0450677052,
0.0014110097,
-0.0122504057,
0.011267622,
-0.0227524228,
0.0208655931,
-0.004545067,
0.0276438855,
0.0295276754,
0.0126149571,
-0.0208709128,
0.0038470756,
-0.0018775018,
-0.030411344,
0.034413822,
-0.0376533084,
0.0920534655,
0.086279504,
0.0079959417,
0.0159527902,
-0.0293740705,
0.0420163199,
0.0255534519,
0.0393702909,
-0.0277600307,
-0.0080698682,
-0.0190367382,
-0.0069916584,
-0.0080033271,
0.0275785327,
-0.0337033607,
-0.0089652333,
0.024834251,
0.0838044211,
-0.0424070209,
0.0063029346,
-0.0176489018,
-0.0313569419,
0.0136267869,
0.0471590944,
-0.0021772971,
-0.017300833,
-0.0501345582,
-0.0433896706,
-0.0703749582,
-0.0361978076,
-0.0217717215,
0.0044582579,
-0.0239965227,
-0.0370679013,
-0.0403294042,
-0.0698603243,
0.0753871873,
0.0223010033,
0.0198353063,
-0.0129320119,
0.0088165244,
0.0163884964,
-0.0022098254,
-0.0016819133,
-0.0405791178,
0.0395839401,
-0.0548587441,
-0.0397377275,
0.0391437821,
-0.0332956053,
0.0248763338,
0.0046740044,
-0.042405095,
-0.0936939418,
-0.0045355302,
0.0592156835,
0.0276865363,
0.0516205058,
-0.009316681,
-0.043819271,
0.0225637592,
0.0147188418,
-0.0449951328,
0.0494131297,
0.0113676032,
0.0277230516,
0.0007064868,
0.0466599613,
-0.0591761731,
0.0037302242,
-0.0005784723,
0.0334206261,
-0.0441339016,
-0.019526856,
0.0048582088,
0.0007710561,
-0.0087614805,
0.0108327176,
-0.0074114106,
-0.0237700976,
0.0228467882,
-0.0153936492,
0.0197357424,
-0.0649873689,
0.011014862,
-0.0082078315,
-0.0112289255,
0.0585941449,
-0.0144537194,
-0.0103709651,
0.0081513049,
0.0011172054,
0.0332477726,
-0.0217057001,
0.0137110138,
0.0420126691,
0.0374467894,
-0.0078048743,
0.0189459566,
-0.0032001708,
0.0364669599,
0.0209368356,
0.0723225176,
0.0053984234,
-0.0023516517,
-0.0147848641,
0.029330954,
-0.074630186,
-0.0773804784,
0.019472139,
0.0637554601,
0.0599928536,
0.0387584753,
0.0307743307,
-0.0523576513,
0.0319004878,
-0.0168628022,
0.0143591929,
0.0140852919,
-0.031999182,
0.0250940956,
0.0373090506,
0.0018517841,
-0.0211939402,
0.0550751016,
-0.0197097976,
0.0768354088,
-0.018061582,
0.0149805173,
-0.0402620025,
-0.0485097989,
0.0282286722,
-0.0014937693,
-0.0056902608,
-0.0341189802,
-0.0417827703,
-0.0120392414,
-0.0358682275,
0.0525465682,
-0.0308357421,
-0.0727792904,
0.0504297875,
0.0162510816,
0.0035353219,
-0.0289978851,
-0.0189609937,
-0.0549036749,
-0.0248184446,
-0.0178997479,
-0.0011720054,
-6.201574648e-33,
-0.0463737585,
-0.0084208772,
0.0844927356,
0.0215243101,
-0.0378107987,
-0.032575313,
-0.0472323596,
0.0096139759,
-0.0191731043,
-0.023042744,
-0.0249564014,
0.0082582338,
0.0238541253,
-0.0243294556,
0.0239714459,
-0.0109534189,
0.0310030039,
-0.012185419,
-0.0329636671,
0.0205465611,
0.0074216104,
0.0192334931,
0.0271041766,
-0.0458246842,
0.0104857134,
-0.0186451823,
0.0012404131,
0.0356439091,
-0.0092715416,
0.0448815525,
-0.0028374589,
0.0167682711,
-0.0033422583,
-0.0204304717,
-0.0257157646,
0.0156682674,
-0.0331451185,
-0.0394505113,
0.0307278093,
0.0060930639,
-0.0342891775,
-0.0628727078,
-0.006197508,
0.0163202956,
-0.041573368,
0.0091243684,
0.0004438263,
0.0019657353,
-0.0153938644,
0.0493942611,
-0.0595026724,
0.0200806111,
0.0207167286,
-0.0525208078,
0.012919981,
-0.0074010687,
-0.0077517577,
-0.0466068909,
-0.023140382,
0.0253650434,
0.0122283679,
0.0109025957,
0.063870199,
0.0440534353,
0.0241371766,
0.0519122593,
0.0389521755,
0.0203230083,
-0.0291867461,
0.0129173687,
-0.0133227939,
0.0880816579,
-0.0216818061,
0.0334850103,
-0.038868621,
-0.0023156076,
0.0037745379,
0.0382383019,
0.0786808282,
0.0439355224,
0.0275851265,
0.0348983444,
-0.0394390039,
-0.0091004902,
-0.0083664022,
0.0378370248,
-0.0129208853,
-0.0649135262,
0.0528159849,
0.0325211063,
0.0102804173,
-0.05472425,
0.0388185941,
0.0020325575,
0.0170463193,
-0.0175891556,
-0.0414225869,
0.0454713106,
-0.0056097903,
-0.012626606,
-0.0477925129,
-0.0598259531,
0.0121057667,
-0.0197728928,
0.0320931561,
0.0310111139,
-0.0383191295,
0.0623150393,
-0.0329356529,
-0.0005055325,
-0.0645975694,
0.0273909643,
0.0165748075,
-0.0208969545,
0.0085924789,
-0.0420905873,
-0.0075377245,
0.0548337698,
-0.0347204134,
-0.0625366494,
-0.0248849448,
-0.0025569932,
0.0010866412,
-0.0075094481,
-0.0386658162,
0.0061352425,
-0.0524680614,
0.0369380414,
-0.0033940393,
-0.0402402729,
-0.0035950541,
0.0031217644,
3.065e-7,
-0.0387479328,
0.037638478,
0.0201333705,
0.0639515743,
0.0021849035,
0.0453658253,
-0.0429164506,
0.0398660041,
0.0034170232,
-0.0304044206,
0.0126833497,
0.064620249,
0.0111051369,
0.0016197741,
-0.0860956758,
-0.0155137489,
0.00502139,
-0.0155799957,
-0.0713543296,
-0.0368929431,
0.0450308062,
0.0619829185,
0.0048464895,
0.0031080972,
0.0205169488,
-0.0474933796,
0.0215305164,
-0.0496010445,
-0.0208703354,
0.0110533191,
-0.0279734526,
0.0233755764,
-0.0292096082,
-0.0072463173,
0.0192410871,
0.0131514492,
-0.0411036201,
0.1026489437,
-0.0045474949,
-0.0370354541,
0.043062605,
-0.0259493105,
0.0009657349,
0.0073212772,
0.044483155,
-0.0131873749,
0.0050585796,
0.0237833504,
0.0185117461,
-0.0225168858,
-0.0413357057,
-0.0121295955,
0.007570189,
0.0101987943,
-0.0148955174,
-0.0204198249,
-0.0191924497,
-0.0513210632,
0.0159137622,
-0.0286570005,
-0.0431972817,
-0.0994784534,
-0.0539888851,
0.0196140036,
-0.0184039846,
-0.0185792372,
-0.01997496,
2.722373514e-34,
0.0150148654,
0.0023500072,
0.0272629745,
0.0756784156,
0.0381527543,
0.0185824391,
-0.006984259,
0.0402609371,
0.0494248904,
-0.0661817491,
-0.0482156463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12821v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12821v4 | GestureGPT: Toward Zero-shot Interactive Gesture Understanding and Grounding with Large Language Model Agents | 2023-10-19T15:17:34 | 2024-06-21T10:12:41 | Xin Zeng, Xiaoyu Wang, Tengxiang Zhang, Chun Yu, Shengdong Zhao, Yiqiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Current gesture interfaces typically demand users to learn and perform
gestures from a predefined set, which leads to a less natural experience.
Interfaces supporting user-defined gestures eliminate the learning process, but
users still need to demonstrate and associate the gesture to a specific system
function themselves. We introduce GestureGPT, a free-form hand gesture
understanding framework that does not require users to learn, demonstrate, or
associate gestures. Our framework leverages the large language model's (LLM)
astute common sense and strong inference ability to understand a spontaneously
performed gesture from its natural language descriptions, and automatically
maps it to a function provided by the interface. More specifically, our
triple-agent framework involves a Gesture Description Agent that automatically
segments and formulates natural language descriptions of hand poses and
movements based on hand landmark coordinates. The description is deciphered by
a Gesture Inference Agent through self-reasoning and querying about the
interaction context (e.g., interaction history, gaze data), which a Context
Management Agent organizes and provides. Following iterative exchanges, the
Gesture Inference Agent discerns user intent, grounding it to an interactive
function. We validated our conceptual framework under two real-world scenarios:
smart home controlling and online video streaming. The average zero-shot Top-5
grounding accuracies are 83.59% for smart home tasks and 73.44% for video
streaming. We also provided an extensive discussion of our framework including
model selection rationale, generated description quality, generalizability etc. | [
-0.0257192012,
0.0157996342,
0.0174314361,
0.043467883,
-0.0095720282,
0.0529839844,
0.0506507345,
0.005592519,
0.0453613214,
-0.1003981158,
-0.0215437412,
-0.0167625584,
0.0004583318,
0.0127859591,
-0.004555088,
-0.0204233397,
0.031973049,
-0.0338945165,
-0.017880423,
0.0311686117,
0.0382699035,
0.0110325953,
-0.0354248546,
0.0439832881,
-0.0648158342,
-0.011412764,
-0.0349916592,
-0.010676356,
0.0086908424,
-0.0209272504,
-0.0322940722,
0.029596407,
0.0661564544,
0.0430383496,
0.000002038,
-0.0434273519,
0.0315545425,
-0.0187394433,
-0.0067029223,
0.0056124316,
0.0221339744,
-0.0059153736,
0.0115336543,
0.0123389736,
-0.0394901484,
-0.0208249353,
0.0374397598,
0.0895339474,
0.0423076786,
-0.0049157902,
-0.0057103736,
-0.0232298784,
-0.0146282045,
0.0060758381,
0.0514536351,
-0.016151743,
0.0197458211,
0.0031276543,
0.0257333089,
-0.0072638909,
-0.0221760105,
-0.0065929904,
0.0062935976,
-0.028947996,
-0.0113065159,
0.060590148,
-0.0368335992,
-0.0254663527,
-0.0138923191,
0.0331902802,
-0.0009615315,
0.0068212552,
0.0468349941,
0.0021567552,
0.0090261716,
0.0024222257,
-0.0342294425,
0.0148250721,
-0.0313832164,
-0.0123084486,
-0.0047159865,
0.026737513,
0.0230624173,
0.0191858578,
-0.0136090973,
0.0640884638,
-0.0018729236,
0.0417043716,
-0.038119521,
-0.0172963012,
0.0248990767,
-0.0490416624,
0.0306719933,
0.0553439744,
-0.0341334268,
-0.0122622931,
-0.0301124565,
0.0085021695,
-0.0412367098,
-0.0117503684,
0.0198234003,
0.0721112713,
0.0016091859,
0.0580355525,
0.0056173629,
0.0274475012,
-0.0426010862,
-0.0327272415,
-0.0408340618,
0.0168674532,
-0.023375459,
-0.0275576711,
-0.0293215774,
-0.0016979583,
-0.0620345324,
-0.0486312583,
0.0061816256,
0.044402834,
-0.0121458462,
-0.0085143549,
-0.0174941197,
0.0383157097,
0.0066823494,
-0.0045182402,
-0.0058347788,
0.0412894823,
-0.0672444701,
0.0358864665,
0.0088095581,
-0.0655288175,
-0.0170738362,
0.0308369547,
0.0201925952,
0.0009077205,
-0.0170258768,
0.035895858,
-0.018982254,
-0.0086666932,
-0.0072899824,
-0.0067116972,
0.0068031517,
-0.0482910685,
-0.0173907075,
-0.0595949739,
0.0137583073,
0.0077295103,
-0.0166360717,
-0.031009106,
-0.0047587063,
0.0115180379,
0.0026785147,
0.0606696047,
-0.0520317703,
0.0135174599,
0.0613312423,
0.0249405093,
-0.0400961228,
0.0124905491,
0.031611003,
0.0255064797,
-0.0114037655,
-0.0032235833,
0.0530688874,
0.032745257,
-0.0483000465,
-0.0318704396,
0.0159333888,
0.0038564743,
0.0183333103,
0.0358476788,
0.0137323979,
0.0011515649,
-0.0358477309,
0.0041311532,
0.0516530685,
0.1413662881,
-0.0426324531,
0.0063258684,
0.001441122,
0.0038594939,
-0.0047310819,
-0.0547237881,
-0.082267344,
0.0549960323,
-0.0055554723,
-0.0420449004,
-0.0611432567,
-0.0156280436,
-0.0498284996,
-0.0321792401,
-0.0120698707,
-0.0435991473,
0.0566858985,
0.0035623207,
0.0481610149,
-0.0209997799,
0.0040513701,
0.0025642042,
0.0170313418,
-0.0546094365,
0.006004151,
-0.0535029545,
0.0741187632,
0.09433534,
-0.016135823,
-0.0187773854,
-0.0363701247,
-0.021289736,
0.0767176375,
-0.0099575501,
-0.0324293375,
0.0013594809,
0.028498793,
-0.0196354799,
-0.05515543,
0.0038426551,
0.0376961045,
0.0528106466,
-0.0669051856,
-0.0191198755,
0.0366818234,
-0.0225028023,
0.0104433345,
0.0198715478,
-0.0167499874,
-0.0265939329,
0.0077603059,
0.0100650666,
0.0012296839,
0.033389084,
0.0007392063,
-0.0198296867,
0.0160123408,
-0.0288065337,
0.0120943775,
0.0091082044,
-0.0516188145,
0.0076388149,
0.0164657254,
-0.018568119,
-0.0112571865,
0.0042551165,
-0.0101938574,
-0.0452897362,
0.0278512407,
0.0312880129,
0.0276130084,
-0.0401603617,
-0.0219277628,
0.0158833452,
-0.0349438339,
0.0308537446,
0.0441474766,
0.0361472815,
-0.019384725,
0.0182469636,
0.0085878316,
0.0105437227,
-0.0445652045,
-0.0023253392,
-0.0038323931,
-0.0248538628,
0.0191353038,
0.0201610141,
0.0411551706,
-0.0313452817,
0.0542497635,
-0.1025388837,
0.0000921556,
-0.0494529195,
0.008677071,
0.016292097,
0.0408510268,
-0.0178472064,
-0.0519212,
-0.0059138145,
0.0094832378,
-0.0084051015,
-0.0062730131,
0.0271336883,
0.0084596779,
-0.0494896621,
-0.0071928664,
0.033966098,
-0.0227292348,
0.0208023395,
0.0397569463,
0.0156879257,
-0.0341820791,
-0.0046012904,
-0.002701404,
0.0437644981,
-0.0522649623,
-0.0157638509,
0.0391743146,
-0.020662412,
-0.0787303746,
0.0764248893,
-0.0285841879,
0.0321851075,
0.0351831764,
-0.0384062976,
-0.0229141377,
0.0036169381,
0.0206221621,
0.0283674635,
-0.0785090104,
0.0588723868,
-0.0048243403,
0.0643675551,
0.000408005,
0.0341384523,
-0.0470525399,
-0.0413879342,
-0.0151146753,
-0.023960121,
-0.0318542942,
-0.0019458508,
-0.047164727,
0.0311294105,
-0.0053253546,
-0.0432178043,
0.0328424089,
-0.0609938018,
-0.0468323566,
0.0536770672,
-0.0336373225,
-0.0211873464,
0.0818534717,
-0.0025584018,
0.0047606626,
-0.0052831839,
-0.059893474,
0.0047954833,
0.0004645716,
0.0174105335,
0.0131942304,
-0.0138004199,
-0.0836968496,
-0.0033511233,
-0.0303487703,
-0.0021481721,
-0.0003255443,
0.0003897924,
-0.0432761721,
0.002538207,
-0.0650932714,
-0.0115012452,
0.0111031597,
0.0353407785,
0.0184821989,
0.0678913072,
0.001999432,
-0.0236133467,
-0.0344230346,
-0.0554617867,
0.033420939,
0.0265034512,
-0.1064570919,
0.0355794057,
0.0137699218,
0.0648103282,
0.0268404149,
0.0166520141,
-0.0651560873,
0.0519481041,
0.017393453,
-0.0220408496,
-0.0413508378,
0.0617419668,
0.0442017466,
-0.0419336073,
0.0242925156,
0.12349087,
0.0032451928,
-0.0441358313,
0.0102866087,
0.0177204944,
-0.0234183017,
0.0284563564,
-0.0096161021,
-0.0963124856,
-0.0690188259,
-0.027606355,
0.0146665564,
0.0496515408,
-0.0643379465,
0.0129869943,
-0.0727760866,
0.0114120562,
-0.0021109707,
-0.0237855259,
-0.03384009,
-0.035339389,
0.0535942279,
-0.0157284271,
-0.0265185684,
0.0127536766,
-0.0160444379,
-0.0079849456,
0.0010642555,
-0.0232784934,
-0.0540809706,
0.065255627,
-0.0485170819,
0.0210741069,
0.0317356661,
0.0022555327,
0.0215736646,
-0.0109233884,
-0.0154480813,
-0.0081459759,
0.0205951054,
-0.0242596082,
-0.0157179479,
-0.023653945,
0.0165624488,
0.0015786958,
0.1088050231,
-0.0841660202,
-0.0452264324,
0.0238017533,
0.0729324669,
-0.0497448333,
0.0069558425,
-0.0058510141,
-0.0751338005,
0.0422528051,
0.0692280605,
0.002822933,
-0.0225686133,
-0.0331107862,
-0.0355941765,
-0.0529970862,
0.084181428,
-0.0198733136,
0.0109544117,
0.0097304797,
-0.0817138478,
0.0015225206,
-0.0326806642,
0.0867466778,
0.0649864897,
0.0049042567,
0.0336502753,
0.0226938762,
0.0274529848,
-0.0139536476,
0.0415610895,
0.0116421105,
0.047769621,
0.0155834341,
0.0305251982,
0.0309763756,
-0.0289840475,
0.0087747099,
-0.0146086421,
-0.0061473926,
-0.0336688533,
-0.0106020477,
0.0583199933,
0.0256588552,
0.0491658822,
-0.0377740823,
-0.0099065397,
-0.022481665,
0.0420987494,
-0.0511090308,
0.0057951068,
0.0123018865,
-0.000903069,
-0.0107412357,
0.0327936709,
-0.0523184761,
-0.0024840061,
-0.0247820523,
0.0046297098,
-0.1218142733,
-0.0109683378,
0.0077687381,
0.0091657424,
0.0594121329,
-0.006625026,
0.0403627343,
-0.0170639884,
-0.0131803295,
-0.0342168733,
-0.010904613,
-0.0681574419,
0.0189335234,
-0.013711934,
-0.0170068555,
0.0502442196,
0.0065416796,
-0.0052181608,
0.0057110158,
-0.0294783581,
0.041912172,
0.0083726617,
0.0221688915,
0.0250547267,
-0.0093605071,
-0.0064897682,
0.0178983398,
0.0078709582,
0.0180122163,
-0.015286359,
0.0571220927,
0.0285534486,
-0.0140976459,
-0.0317019373,
0.0513357855,
-0.0169361047,
-0.0439574085,
0.0230373368,
0.0594919175,
0.0206960719,
-0.0152339172,
0.0193250123,
-0.0378283001,
0.0218113791,
-0.0195806492,
0.0794749409,
0.0078437068,
-0.0662007332,
0.023001451,
0.0154374326,
-0.0189052299,
-0.0432546996,
0.0300821699,
-0.0181652401,
0.0262082908,
0.021697687,
-0.0500389114,
-0.0377875827,
-0.0246305186,
0.038738247,
-0.0076572024,
-0.0269252304,
-0.0048426264,
-0.0428428948,
-0.0215051845,
-0.0469880626,
0.0025640987,
0.0073639266,
-0.0229067598,
0.0647435337,
0.0420532897,
-0.0219424181,
-0.0220145509,
-0.0034146293,
-0.0359509923,
-0.0595991947,
0.0067200586,
-0.0875331685,
-5.592479026e-33,
-0.0075959433,
-0.0623456351,
0.0276432205,
-0.0169646125,
-0.0089359172,
-0.0179933794,
-0.0137649868,
0.017859444,
0.0239575412,
-0.0133528113,
-0.0161054917,
0.0147758806,
0.0043223561,
-0.0054487921,
0.0183569752,
-0.0418572389,
0.0204381738,
-0.02744947,
-0.0409930833,
0.0098960064,
0.0314860269,
0.004471058,
0.0594708212,
-0.0635522902,
-0.0017232776,
-0.0247850101,
-0.018502105,
0.0062153162,
0.0017349895,
0.01097578,
-0.0262184888,
0.0141399093,
0.0325787552,
0.0051504341,
0.0238116644,
0.0552153662,
-0.039506387,
-0.0428752452,
-0.0069570234,
0.0615418255,
-0.0026664697,
0.0130777536,
-0.0140806884,
0.0244601108,
-0.0724518523,
0.0191576649,
0.0411417708,
-0.0164182354,
0.0215343647,
-0.000454414,
-0.0044513252,
0.0193643067,
-0.0058046011,
-0.0654825494,
-0.006095686,
-0.0042853639,
-0.0117439404,
-0.032337755,
-0.0542373322,
-0.0018341541,
-0.0063215112,
0.0075574405,
0.0995887816,
-0.0049032387,
0.0486323014,
0.0403247476,
-0.0159706026,
-0.0215919595,
-0.0331784487,
0.0123839164,
0.0087779313,
0.0726782829,
-0.0502179526,
0.0692459717,
0.051245667,
-0.0295067113,
-0.0163126756,
0.0501793176,
0.0368611217,
0.1121990308,
-0.0266053062,
0.0346567072,
-0.0161144193,
-0.0054611834,
-0.016154347,
0.0157652814,
-0.0027999706,
-0.0261183977,
0.0554196164,
0.0164083317,
0.0011169957,
-0.0159693565,
0.0462421738,
-0.0026919565,
-0.0172541756,
0.0139705483,
0.0001732594,
0.0211849399,
0.0283874944,
0.0058260551,
-0.0087175192,
-0.0497318171,
-0.0083479853,
0.0011617846,
0.0418438613,
0.0190149453,
-0.0274927244,
0.0591732711,
0.0114455558,
-0.0124336239,
-0.0090560447,
-0.0186729431,
-0.0006703589,
0.0253865011,
0.0423892178,
-0.030336868,
-0.0174403545,
0.0656262934,
-0.0548322536,
-0.0308052674,
-0.0037510924,
-0.0034971591,
-0.003031756,
-0.0196448788,
-0.0477584153,
-0.0214816239,
-0.0434953645,
-0.0148012638,
0.0678035542,
-0.0396199413,
-0.0044314689,
0.0382872298,
2.872e-7,
-0.0183375329,
0.0108890925,
-0.0287169069,
0.0286536552,
0.0051326328,
0.0723424032,
-0.0002329658,
0.0762807354,
-0.0125933755,
-0.0063990783,
0.0171259083,
0.0159421004,
0.0240663644,
-0.0033981595,
-0.0647192225,
0.0272938237,
0.0159728508,
0.0242054183,
-0.0540522225,
0.0512670875,
0.0478736237,
0.0426651426,
0.0070587886,
0.0222021267,
0.0762985274,
-0.081514731,
0.0223652422,
-0.0538385063,
0.0469858088,
-0.0301900003,
0.0303649344,
0.0054441295,
0.0003117346,
-0.0090852994,
0.019354593,
-0.0043330481,
-0.0432746261,
0.0564249158,
-0.0628212616,
0.0049162232,
-0.0277452786,
-0.0418603234,
0.0073015317,
-0.0537398979,
0.0684381351,
-0.05678159,
-0.0070852637,
0.0186044052,
-0.0193010606,
-0.0243205,
-0.0451942906,
0.0329733565,
0.0223249998,
-0.013242132,
0.0042887572,
-0.0506302565,
-0.0333906449,
-0.0632653832,
0.0094280494,
-0.0321422704,
-0.0431630276,
-0.0267209914,
-0.0300642531,
-0.0281799007,
0.0366296396,
-0.0174558889,
-0.0231362171,
2.097295669e-34,
-0.0260933321,
0.0111199655,
0.0044279834,
0.0491385423,
0.0325270295,
0.0399598926,
0.027276393,
0.0729485527,
0.071071431,
-0.0248284843,
-0.0162290111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12818v1 | Boosting Inference Efficiency: Unleashing the Power of Parameter-Shared Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-10-19T15:13:58 | 2023-10-19T15:13:58 | Weize Chen, Xiaoyue Xu, Xu Han, Yankai Lin, Ruobing Xie, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Parameter-shared pre-trained language models (PLMs) have emerged as a
successful approach in resource-constrained environments, enabling substantial
reductions in model storage and memory costs without significant performance
compromise. However, it is important to note that parameter sharing does not
alleviate computational burdens associated with inference, thus impeding its
practicality in situations characterized by limited stringent latency
requirements or computational resources. Building upon neural ordinary
differential equations (ODEs), we introduce a straightforward technique to
enhance the inference efficiency of parameter-shared PLMs. Additionally, we
propose a simple pre-training technique that leads to fully or partially shared
models capable of achieving even greater inference acceleration. The
experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods on both
autoregressive and autoencoding PLMs, providing novel insights into more
efficient utilization of parameter-shared models in resource-constrained
settings. | [
0.0001226126,
0.1288681328,
-0.0093207974,
0.0629267022,
0.011186461,
0.0197572429,
0.067737937,
-0.0316123553,
-0.0302274171,
-0.0013977769,
-0.0500864908,
-0.0438937768,
-0.0151734315,
0.0139336977,
0.010535703,
-0.0243400242,
0.0407681465,
-0.0351383537,
-0.0238117669,
-0.0424632989,
0.0071813995,
-0.0012958829,
-0.0003923216,
0.0217186119,
0.0032023366,
0.0068024779,
-0.013697925,
-0.0092779649,
-0.0009581461,
0.02002896,
0.0178512782,
0.0590944402,
0.0399579369,
0.0605566092,
0.0000019917,
-0.0074136104,
0.0142389946,
-0.0318777189,
-0.0634069666,
0.0744506791,
0.035131488,
0.0029040021,
0.0378622934,
-0.0019159709,
-0.0289504994,
-0.0629931018,
0.0631251037,
-0.0662186816,
0.0491339639,
0.0626911595,
0.008154057,
0.00526937,
0.013970268,
-0.0699022859,
-0.0238651279,
-0.038506832,
0.0033092338,
-0.0109711625,
0.0173316859,
-0.0241561979,
-0.0201239455,
0.0761454105,
0.0645901039,
0.023957219,
-0.0194907188,
0.0602588058,
0.0141060594,
-0.0192070566,
0.0049461517,
0.0509827882,
-0.0587627813,
-0.0488827899,
-0.0149500789,
-0.0433641374,
-0.0403437801,
0.0325665846,
-0.0202214103,
0.0065163844,
0.0290794801,
0.0454313271,
0.0334188119,
0.0183418281,
0.0414611027,
0.0299406108,
-0.0403332822,
0.0440592878,
0.0185097903,
0.0251443963,
-0.0305817388,
0.0171591844,
-0.0215351339,
-0.033852119,
0.0390166789,
0.0289631188,
0.0468119942,
-0.0039273622,
-0.0668248832,
-0.0774270296,
-0.00883001,
-0.0491612293,
0.0912699699,
0.0396587774,
0.0094441753,
0.0245460756,
-0.0467380024,
0.0335043781,
-0.0410615243,
-0.005851591,
-0.0241427142,
-0.0010078928,
0.008917029,
-0.0179863442,
-0.0636102483,
0.0020936336,
0.0064428914,
-0.0257666092,
0.0003607242,
0.03379675,
-0.0088027949,
-0.0477259345,
0.016390685,
0.0156964976,
-0.0107970517,
-0.0276610292,
0.0185755864,
0.0276543964,
-0.0394465625,
0.0407603532,
-0.0054561449,
-0.0677930862,
-0.0312346462,
-0.0033125929,
0.0329170227,
-0.0323444121,
0.0131003652,
0.0286021009,
0.0330350697,
-0.0108141564,
-0.0408062898,
-0.0111815827,
0.007191197,
-0.0381942727,
0.0090674227,
-0.0791381672,
0.0496536382,
0.0139300805,
0.0064381268,
-0.0672140494,
-0.0015403816,
-0.0120986309,
-0.0351117253,
0.0545606166,
-0.0357450657,
0.0135170342,
0.0268255975,
0.0036316325,
0.0336414091,
0.0837411061,
0.023006266,
0.0146719059,
0.0147404848,
-0.006898649,
0.0124523761,
0.0406479761,
0.0774908513,
0.008433274,
-0.0023444938,
-0.028527502,
0.0090183262,
0.0124206021,
0.0851712301,
0.0151340151,
-0.033714097,
-0.0504265837,
0.0707423314,
0.0414248779,
0.0124498,
0.0166593641,
0.0613862798,
-0.0148883164,
0.0241944306,
0.0069242911,
-0.0225274805,
0.0259525105,
0.0332267992,
-0.0019586997,
0.0501131453,
0.0397273265,
-0.0621053576,
-0.0465702936,
0.0154807894,
-0.0373720862,
0.0186558794,
0.033632189,
0.0308536291,
-0.0198615417,
-0.0227854159,
0.0746498555,
0.0341426507,
-0.0530467331,
0.024231635,
-0.023845192,
0.0169759747,
0.0256933756,
0.0034037952,
-0.0126773082,
-0.0378513411,
0.0052265902,
0.0454645604,
-0.0068859593,
0.0300458428,
0.0337803401,
0.0554624647,
-0.0452399254,
-0.0210415628,
-0.0298792291,
0.0131557602,
0.0649258271,
0.0259755999,
0.0363809317,
0.0531913415,
0.0254764706,
-0.0409290716,
0.0027426912,
-0.0535756089,
-0.0304252189,
0.0158105455,
0.0034669568,
0.014239897,
-0.0184022393,
-0.0387084372,
0.0391107164,
-0.0138371969,
-0.0573655739,
0.0037877276,
0.0211657509,
-0.084157832,
-0.0254647676,
0.004647804,
0.0210505929,
0.0305670779,
0.0354804732,
-0.0165992901,
-0.0330449715,
0.0539408699,
-0.010550864,
0.0507080257,
-0.0440547839,
-0.0144291408,
0.0100134928,
0.040156465,
0.0171468891,
0.0128404573,
-0.0311552063,
0.0011225854,
-0.0017133995,
0.0542001203,
0.0212651268,
-0.0185584221,
-0.0403810702,
-0.0361700282,
0.0161097758,
0.0002718134,
0.0198359992,
-0.0269916169,
0.0454857759,
0.0108118849,
-0.0682212859,
-0.0248353034,
-0.0629840642,
-0.0004741784,
0.0112270825,
0.0350478366,
-0.0152565669,
-0.0146170184,
0.0085232956,
0.0091603408,
-0.0042742034,
0.0273230951,
-0.007608335,
0.0190714356,
0.0024266483,
-0.0558953732,
-0.0480744801,
0.0073388717,
0.0608777292,
-0.0231364612,
-0.0211063381,
-0.0057821907,
0.0128285959,
-0.0279546473,
0.0462950431,
-0.0040829992,
-0.0545991771,
-0.0025147884,
-0.0533684529,
0.0374111012,
0.0495785289,
-0.0210485104,
-0.0141156167,
0.0395008661,
-0.0230208095,
-0.0555749238,
0.0128327999,
-0.0308800042,
-0.0144370161,
0.0119258082,
0.0015119173,
-0.0288534183,
0.091228433,
-0.0157767609,
-0.0554594137,
-0.0482247174,
0.0121899508,
-0.0030732842,
-0.0231035575,
-0.030664688,
-0.0083459606,
0.0099469228,
0.0317567289,
-0.0219315104,
-0.0810584575,
0.0935961008,
-0.0486350171,
-0.0221998747,
0.0150933694,
-0.0223785788,
-0.0323886536,
0.0300082564,
0.0415356681,
-0.0109296916,
-0.0275435243,
-0.0031299989,
-0.0025922169,
0.0714833587,
0.0304245055,
0.0065758587,
0.0277519505,
-0.0367787704,
0.008581561,
0.0101976329,
-0.0293580759,
-0.0197008513,
-0.0490837805,
-0.0439560115,
0.010253882,
-0.0041609583,
-0.0178569369,
0.0313098393,
0.0178738926,
-0.0247400962,
0.0733417794,
-0.0192465037,
0.0397906005,
-0.0087704314,
-0.0259030182,
0.041166462,
-0.0250941254,
-0.008161081,
-0.0461569875,
0.022177849,
0.0078285495,
0.0512467809,
0.014463664,
-0.0573241152,
0.015154629,
0.0020807264,
0.0210840367,
-0.0255867597,
0.007389978,
-0.011594221,
-0.041578237,
-0.03883617,
0.1091827229,
-0.0059117838,
-0.0569630079,
-0.019329017,
-0.0057077729,
0.0371743664,
-0.0026015525,
0.0165215693,
-0.0635355785,
-0.0177590828,
-0.0168683995,
-0.0135119017,
0.0248016678,
-0.0167555977,
-0.0076486142,
-0.0857793838,
-0.011294893,
0.0184351411,
0.0218834691,
-0.0053077722,
-0.0449138656,
-0.0333709307,
-0.011701744,
-0.0185000151,
-0.0032152496,
0.0135788517,
0.0080719078,
0.0139468405,
-0.0280805398,
-0.0140032526,
-0.0038419978,
-0.0672306195,
-0.0006724318,
0.0366432592,
-0.0154338861,
0.0058933161,
-0.0372392423,
0.0287289992,
-0.0400367714,
0.0000333771,
-0.0158578679,
0.0020250482,
-0.0128201703,
-0.0258717407,
0.050038673,
0.0501977764,
-0.0300201736,
0.0148843657,
-0.0351486355,
0.0741065666,
-0.0151943751,
-0.0223308373,
-0.0169580914,
0.0030739389,
0.0070919353,
0.0665658936,
0.0795090199,
-0.0329046845,
-0.0290188603,
0.0150148449,
-0.0276999157,
-0.0291062314,
-0.01070402,
-0.0173424017,
0.0156668331,
-0.0463768691,
-0.020323474,
-0.0283259898,
0.0259382837,
0.0237387847,
-0.0157925729,
0.0251182076,
0.01244119,
-0.0351290666,
-0.0436764807,
0.0350802466,
-0.0082345987,
-0.0072142598,
-0.035878364,
-0.01171871,
0.0308998767,
0.0169507936,
-0.0105094286,
0.021225255,
-0.1327395439,
-0.0950977281,
0.0383264497,
0.0458589159,
0.015781926,
0.0475850813,
-0.0084645087,
-0.0618469454,
0.0476634093,
-0.0081514204,
0.0074755326,
0.0215231199,
0.0433879234,
-0.0090328511,
0.0295979083,
0.0360636786,
-0.0222599301,
0.0331251062,
0.020198809,
-0.0231961589,
-0.0397140384,
-0.0353295952,
-0.0303685181,
-0.0289549511,
0.0711615235,
0.015472129,
0.0120753953,
-0.0382554457,
0.0278825425,
-0.02823277,
-0.0005398529,
-0.0686846152,
0.003807391,
0.0121879159,
0.012832785,
-0.0422832854,
0.0083809132,
0.0649131462,
0.0070738466,
-0.0162998904,
-0.0137426369,
0.0175312143,
0.0022317818,
0.0354790725,
0.0007724771,
-0.010023226,
0.0381170139,
0.000995822,
0.0035704691,
-0.0488173924,
0.0282081384,
0.0129282419,
0.0239340905,
-0.0352534503,
-0.0029739053,
-0.0677452907,
-0.1069066525,
-0.0152363339,
-0.0004788463,
0.060744822,
-0.041504059,
0.0188376456,
-0.0426635444,
-0.0038443448,
-0.0282588694,
0.0371358767,
-0.0166825987,
0.0044150464,
0.0446612835,
0.0061432743,
-0.0027129867,
-0.0074323555,
0.0884223282,
0.039978236,
0.0460881367,
0.0072068069,
0.014352533,
0.0184081439,
-0.0221539009,
-0.0108575802,
-0.0056529539,
-0.0235761013,
0.0231035538,
0.0215921495,
-0.0603191741,
0.002997533,
0.0104016457,
-0.0290976223,
0.0110998871,
0.0448853076,
0.0433010012,
-0.0116288848,
0.0048744036,
-0.0061063841,
0.0236096047,
0.0102339117,
-0.037535347,
-0.0030442094,
-6.805312955e-33,
-0.0143952798,
0.0298154708,
0.0197789911,
-0.0228228569,
0.0045110038,
0.0174636822,
-0.0303787496,
0.0044290992,
-0.0497793704,
-0.0023820461,
-0.0018947801,
0.0573220439,
0.0172815751,
0.0275786109,
0.0236850977,
-0.0317846723,
0.0255413949,
-0.0257111546,
0.0057383794,
0.0183679555,
0.0261720177,
0.0744824186,
0.0536767803,
0.0106392065,
-0.02632365,
-0.005533726,
0.0334130488,
0.0108735617,
0.0077112904,
0.0089925248,
-0.0346059948,
0.0306743123,
0.0011585663,
0.0044055087,
-0.0518216901,
-0.0088575603,
-0.0844539702,
-0.0552477874,
0.0068619666,
-0.0055781482,
-0.0223227777,
-0.0213054921,
0.0450649373,
0.0230943225,
0.0145465005,
-0.0202847086,
0.0007342255,
0.0063806102,
0.0057835705,
-0.0352841206,
-0.0411650799,
0.0147268437,
0.0152739454,
0.0122235883,
0.0806294978,
0.0326415859,
-0.019182289,
0.0324732736,
-0.0519920327,
-0.0155050186,
0.0026447903,
0.0566999912,
0.0484716855,
0.0078098257,
0.0357891917,
0.0361336246,
0.0081056235,
-0.0208360069,
-0.0764576197,
0.0415023006,
0.08781524,
0.0193158705,
0.0472513884,
-0.0180158857,
0.0389360227,
-0.0078811534,
-0.0526637621,
-0.0151075358,
0.0179218892,
0.0152004985,
0.0117816683,
0.0129387239,
-0.0260578059,
-0.0644142404,
-0.0509461425,
-0.0364297368,
-0.0424512438,
-0.021531608,
0.0042612888,
0.0150822336,
-0.0238617621,
-0.0084481835,
0.073498033,
-0.0470620021,
-0.0138470978,
0.0097554056,
0.0318318233,
-0.0155232018,
0.0197040047,
0.0387275368,
-0.0687177479,
-0.0193428788,
-0.0352125578,
0.0029757393,
0.0217399746,
-0.0066237529,
0.0030832705,
0.0241296329,
-0.0457573161,
-0.0335657373,
-0.0447900593,
0.0047467933,
0.0644779131,
0.0132520683,
0.0634157658,
0.0177683402,
0.0117330933,
0.0571676567,
-0.0001362758,
-0.0161602087,
-0.0238474123,
-0.0398960225,
0.0291380044,
0.0509548746,
-0.0266244672,
-0.0298905447,
-0.0615719557,
-0.0239071473,
0.0354080424,
-0.0821743309,
-0.0200339593,
0.0360491611,
2.612e-7,
0.0591788441,
-0.009194877,
0.0395839997,
-0.0063084452,
0.0275107119,
-0.0126209799,
-0.0372039303,
0.0043356665,
-0.0027286159,
0.0092115672,
0.032720644,
0.0464992151,
0.0868464857,
0.0215610173,
-0.0460308567,
-0.0259056538,
-0.0988595709,
0.0140403667,
-0.0355620943,
-0.0689199343,
-0.0239180941,
0.1024946645,
0.0237211771,
0.0113359606,
0.0300294142,
-0.0390832573,
0.069651641,
-0.0324317738,
0.0152972033,
0.0268857423,
0.0203207172,
0.0117646409,
-0.0248626992,
-0.0200588685,
-0.0195415635,
0.0131110195,
-0.0209575035,
0.0383188054,
0.0207514465,
-0.0255275834,
0.0034919931,
-0.0403359085,
-0.029285349,
-0.0608077049,
0.0769004077,
-0.066988118,
0.0223380737,
-0.040290419,
0.0178819466,
-0.0267665815,
0.0762431398,
-0.0298602227,
0.0098049231,
0.0282612406,
0.0186669361,
-0.0238267872,
-0.0056849462,
-0.1047841236,
-0.050297603,
0.0174562372,
-0.0692347065,
0.0096610375,
-0.0570755787,
-0.0240880996,
0.0730255023,
-0.0293078478,
0.0178240556,
2.233459011e-34,
0.0346595943,
-0.019987477,
-0.000976138,
0.0471591726,
0.0051203864,
-0.0428636074,
-0.0034382152,
0.0136847822,
0.0003725734,
-0.0844664723,
-0.0608343221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12815v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12815v3 | Formalizing and Benchmarking Prompt Injection Attacks and Defenses | 2023-10-19T15:12:09 | 2024-06-01T21:21:07 | Yupei Liu, Yuqi Jia, Runpeng Geng, Jinyuan Jia, Neil Zhenqiang Gong | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | A prompt injection attack aims to inject malicious instruction/data into the
input of an LLM-Integrated Application such that it produces results as an
attacker desires. Existing works are limited to case studies. As a result, the
literature lacks a systematic understanding of prompt injection attacks and
their defenses. We aim to bridge the gap in this work. In particular, we
propose a framework to formalize prompt injection attacks. Existing attacks are
special cases in our framework. Moreover, based on our framework, we design a
new attack by combining existing ones. Using our framework, we conduct a
systematic evaluation on 5 prompt injection attacks and 10 defenses with 10
LLMs and 7 tasks. Our work provides a common benchmark for quantitatively
evaluating future prompt injection attacks and defenses. To facilitate research
on this topic, we make our platform public at
https://github.com/liu00222/Open-Prompt-Injection. | [
-0.0179787334,
0.0159559958,
0.0201522652,
0.0442530662,
-0.0185345709,
-0.04535193,
0.0116050057,
-0.0243028868,
0.0169389714,
-0.018092161,
0.0123692071,
0.0363384411,
0.0231588837,
0.0125566553,
0.0863275826,
0.0278356262,
0.0700271055,
-0.0300457329,
-0.0559884086,
0.0146408845,
-0.0243010428,
-0.0533307642,
-0.0221294276,
-0.0156008303,
0.0045651649,
-0.0051437877,
-0.0454334654,
0.1100256592,
0.0181548446,
-0.0160930213,
-0.0135235488,
-0.0454623252,
-0.0057798191,
0.018148724,
0.0000020237,
-0.0307838973,
0.0035370619,
0.0585214011,
-0.0804257393,
0.0590055548,
-0.0593949556,
0.0154060135,
-0.0352866054,
0.0489963405,
0.0493291952,
0.0314402208,
0.0209261384,
0.0245289672,
0.0832990706,
0.0766179562,
0.017481884,
0.0504001155,
0.0597591363,
0.0098504592,
0.0289413184,
0.0186111294,
-0.0036613941,
-0.0763958469,
0.0201083925,
0.0507426113,
0.0071228235,
-0.0619242713,
0.0101575423,
-0.0275509655,
-0.0409982912,
0.0211051665,
0.031683594,
0.0104811238,
-0.0697324723,
0.0017603784,
-0.0390804447,
0.0176048558,
0.0202747937,
0.0031199961,
0.0010420262,
-0.0128980577,
0.0329235718,
0.0154223489,
0.0074697412,
-0.0179895665,
0.0116669182,
0.0047049485,
0.0215316806,
-0.0445438586,
-0.0106132329,
0.059336476,
0.0666912571,
-0.0460970886,
0.0113189099,
-0.0778051838,
0.0470417328,
-0.0409490541,
-0.072016038,
0.0522595681,
-0.0115870973,
0.0155497603,
-0.0510381982,
0.0069690505,
0.0415111594,
0.0152383577,
0.0277974065,
0.0488938466,
-0.0371462889,
0.0035544944,
-0.0195191577,
0.0305257048,
-0.0209043827,
0.0372620933,
0.077428259,
0.0394246317,
0.022572441,
0.0327738337,
0.0286324974,
0.0403287448,
-0.0213898011,
0.0527489074,
-0.0043777283,
0.074339591,
-0.0299090911,
0.0885703936,
-0.0321757831,
-0.018020954,
0.0106680878,
0.0571671762,
0.0172981098,
-0.0772652701,
-0.0044651306,
-0.065149121,
-0.0246847998,
-0.0907015428,
-0.0373356976,
0.0105672283,
-0.0710136145,
-0.0192169379,
0.0135217598,
0.1007614285,
0.041439157,
-0.0080920178,
-0.0579983331,
-0.1076027602,
0.0085190507,
-0.0113843828,
-0.0081427805,
-0.0596928559,
-0.0313978828,
-0.0515200645,
-0.0173428822,
-0.0240314025,
-0.0143599566,
0.0084962593,
-0.0125688091,
0.0461687893,
-0.0085933721,
-0.0361005738,
0.021207653,
0.0666885674,
-0.0215740558,
-0.0083361315,
-0.021284828,
0.0443397462,
0.0283718072,
-0.0301507171,
0.0611287728,
-0.0088887336,
-0.0066664,
0.0284837,
0.0272110123,
0.0352117755,
0.0544099994,
-0.0064607537,
-0.0345852114,
0.036074657,
0.0384707823,
-0.0124231987,
0.0437948629,
0.0563426688,
-0.0380176641,
-0.0659385994,
0.0313482545,
0.018860044,
0.0034163087,
0.0094224541,
-0.0674183294,
-0.0042741229,
-0.074802205,
-0.0009287439,
-0.0131375864,
0.0389359631,
0.002842329,
-0.0028260159,
0.0127192428,
-0.0334383771,
-0.0713981241,
-0.0008642399,
-0.0092351679,
0.0142820058,
0.012984015,
0.0251396764,
0.007827336,
-0.0215640981,
-0.0404446013,
-0.078712061,
-0.0009272023,
-0.0015446702,
0.0285728537,
-0.0364288948,
-0.0352567732,
0.0153516307,
-0.013794791,
0.0094907722,
-0.0030308058,
0.0453559794,
0.0137873078,
0.0105563337,
-0.0098666912,
-0.0344453678,
0.0117286835,
0.0451392755,
-0.0150744626,
-0.0108801769,
-0.0026793347,
0.031444367,
0.0305471607,
0.0346295089,
0.0045391931,
-0.1306527853,
0.0209302753,
0.0530873537,
-0.0179271027,
0.0305280518,
0.00137042,
0.013480043,
0.0747240484,
0.0569539927,
-0.0033488732,
-0.0266843885,
-0.0044215475,
0.0350629203,
0.0142152049,
0.0035247661,
-0.0068094726,
-0.0145024452,
-0.0354677513,
-0.0265470352,
0.0257312655,
-0.0150209842,
-0.0077350778,
0.017151719,
0.0111579532,
0.0164124761,
0.0062631587,
-0.0440382287,
-0.0148654785,
0.028673267,
0.0099507822,
0.0435170569,
0.0494714528,
-0.0308251474,
-0.0309287235,
-0.0701262206,
-0.0016793357,
-0.039300736,
-0.0190451443,
-0.0489903279,
-0.0027521888,
0.0066460907,
-0.0154081918,
-0.0197462309,
0.0456294529,
0.0037798812,
0.0439776294,
0.0178154111,
0.042688515,
-0.0185184684,
-0.0300379898,
0.0083131082,
-0.0328061134,
-0.0132186059,
-0.0201761164,
0.0361725017,
-0.011570422,
-0.0305215977,
0.0245396998,
0.0084041245,
-0.0189442467,
0.0583841726,
-0.0487061515,
-0.015980171,
-0.0413281284,
0.0319827572,
-0.0040909131,
-0.0152570438,
-0.0255469196,
-0.0035200212,
0.0295726731,
0.0157877859,
-0.0139498031,
0.0525366776,
-0.0028708579,
0.0348696932,
0.0446054302,
-0.0026447664,
-0.0360083878,
-0.0178281274,
0.0510607734,
-0.0137954587,
-0.0367088541,
-0.0008181869,
0.0692284852,
0.0457216315,
0.0299177002,
-0.0117281172,
0.0147736836,
0.0156023623,
0.0482712463,
-0.002836426,
-0.0116217751,
-0.033623632,
-0.0537236035,
0.018793406,
0.0014734433,
-0.0935289189,
0.0512963049,
-0.1002363116,
0.0051243934,
0.0340661556,
-0.0503928736,
-0.0145505965,
-0.0039856886,
-0.0336794518,
-0.0445377119,
0.0288433209,
-0.0491986908,
-0.0239885338,
-0.0167542621,
0.034465082,
-0.0212696176,
0.0478509627,
-0.0338575654,
-0.0931209996,
-0.0498964563,
-0.0059213899,
-0.0485253558,
-0.0436342247,
0.0215894878,
-0.0273710452,
-0.0167852491,
-0.0100035304,
0.046915438,
-0.065893583,
0.0067489292,
-0.0100962473,
0.0022929178,
-0.0250669252,
-0.0316944048,
-0.0430637412,
-0.0178781915,
-0.0567476414,
-0.0332063474,
0.0473804772,
0.0602705441,
0.0511652566,
0.0321120881,
-0.005758448,
-0.0297463406,
-0.0161007829,
-0.0112723839,
-0.0481829271,
0.0310450327,
0.0699008182,
0.0306099821,
-0.0169537086,
-0.012485397,
0.023963429,
0.0219832715,
-0.0070396508,
0.0062244725,
-0.0096515836,
-0.0103888419,
0.0274908859,
0.0393173359,
-0.0870324969,
-0.0010150806,
0.029309893,
0.0719260648,
-0.0254714433,
0.0163617358,
-0.0246961806,
-0.0820095092,
0.0132728117,
-0.0042527034,
0.0437730476,
-0.0053836955,
-0.0350037627,
0.0248966068,
0.0768512115,
0.0381750204,
-0.0125499107,
0.0157319903,
-0.0018367297,
0.0129212756,
-0.0144725088,
0.0175682213,
0.0030470653,
-0.0319636837,
0.045014184,
0.0056226216,
-0.0209464114,
-0.0011904686,
0.0150883161,
0.0732167065,
-0.0385136567,
-0.0135107338,
0.0074096406,
0.0092002284,
0.0296562631,
-0.0114696138,
0.0220733266,
0.0260005761,
-0.032951843,
-0.0078953169,
0.0666835159,
0.0240823869,
-0.0341635495,
0.0281570256,
-0.01553897,
-0.0499228202,
0.0408764184,
0.0232964754,
0.0089881336,
0.0083970912,
-0.0029413463,
-0.0648647919,
-0.0143953674,
-0.011475184,
-0.0419100598,
0.0101744905,
-0.0016107449,
-0.030281743,
-0.0055142879,
0.0223798025,
-0.0374809839,
0.0218307637,
0.070139572,
-0.0348616019,
-0.0363366343,
0.0004470472,
-0.0341687426,
-0.0111762052,
-0.0186903253,
0.0473004505,
-0.0500559658,
0.0724112988,
-0.0142066767,
-0.004827234,
-0.0145140709,
0.0003162946,
-0.0485936105,
-0.0639560521,
-0.0055321716,
0.0796554089,
0.0155736106,
-0.0066972831,
-0.0295925271,
0.0186819062,
0.0747467428,
0.0093440581,
-0.017889902,
0.0088447426,
0.0536508411,
0.0048533245,
0.0241395831,
-0.0629505962,
-0.0182772055,
-0.0417575613,
0.0869860798,
-0.058914084,
-0.0144492639,
-0.0560825169,
-0.0211729761,
0.0533421002,
0.0618474185,
-0.0036917028,
0.0262309872,
0.0516068265,
0.0577447191,
-0.0246799868,
-0.0094880471,
0.0110946782,
-0.0058311662,
-0.0578755923,
-0.0053711631,
0.0469707586,
-0.0212151464,
0.0246325266,
0.0353705138,
0.004493203,
0.0438694768,
0.0252068825,
0.0295888148,
0.0153152077,
0.0238362346,
-0.0020792019,
0.0472131185,
0.0304152947,
0.037483383,
-0.0143866949,
0.0158010721,
-0.0104622226,
0.0313005596,
-0.009323338,
0.0203443822,
-0.0524461605,
-0.0252251066,
0.0834429488,
0.0371641107,
-0.0244120378,
0.0459255539,
-0.0385135338,
0.0270932987,
0.0232632961,
-0.0310668834,
-0.01050294,
-0.0407878421,
-0.0017263641,
0.0194641203,
-0.0182391871,
0.0158631038,
-0.0117968963,
0.0066980831,
-0.0427824371,
0.0175995808,
0.0151188262,
-0.0265241936,
-0.0589617044,
0.0025150306,
0.0407691263,
0.0004156149,
-0.0241747033,
-0.0908861756,
-0.0425795019,
-0.0399655141,
-0.0008675071,
-0.0108714048,
0.0298291333,
0.025419319,
-0.0076822327,
-0.0069536637,
0.0514333844,
0.0449626707,
-0.0604226403,
0.0555448271,
0.0004913619,
-0.0916320831,
0.0512544811,
-4.97162993e-33,
-0.0004717986,
-0.0367072262,
-0.0346715637,
0.0388193876,
0.020149976,
0.013387193,
-0.0158811025,
0.0002351425,
0.0223220233,
-0.0446698107,
-0.001790577,
-0.010759281,
0.0296946988,
-0.0008774516,
-0.0387891755,
-0.0235589426,
-0.0501128323,
-0.0060407608,
-0.0309256557,
0.004135997,
0.043301858,
-0.009644133,
-0.0060849763,
-0.0072492454,
0.0648554042,
-0.0289074443,
0.0159122664,
-0.0159832034,
-0.023198314,
0.0494438447,
0.0288586747,
-0.0009253161,
-0.0042873197,
-0.0152362604,
0.0088974508,
0.0971939117,
-0.0248160064,
-0.0489806868,
-0.0262258239,
-0.0259219892,
-0.0191551093,
-0.0814182013,
-0.0152721703,
-0.031709753,
0.0193937514,
0.0019262437,
-0.0027020872,
0.0225856155,
0.0005808054,
-0.0605885237,
-0.0103410091,
-0.0130808689,
-0.0200279374,
0.0063894582,
-0.009172109,
-0.0330705345,
0.0403840579,
-0.0152603807,
0.0047424231,
0.0176737215,
-0.0207944363,
0.0076761264,
0.0055254214,
0.0131859398,
-0.0125479465,
-0.0121700419,
-0.0086673023,
-0.0194125772,
-0.0024368658,
0.0359544307,
-0.0156691168,
0.0130758509,
0.0260264203,
0.0103784315,
0.0301054716,
-0.0178865194,
-0.0038289286,
0.0335308202,
0.0670461282,
0.0043957476,
-0.0086381976,
-0.0336366072,
-0.0704705566,
0.0065818611,
-0.0016590485,
0.0197981428,
-0.0218530763,
-0.0030548989,
0.0143401753,
-0.0054290025,
0.0126153734,
-0.0375214107,
0.0024050246,
-0.0285526216,
0.0588518158,
-0.0500473939,
0.0332699753,
-0.0569299087,
-0.0256605782,
-0.0347524546,
0.0615701266,
-0.0078482889,
0.0060231588,
-0.062160138,
0.0496349707,
-0.0262359325,
-0.0080687869,
0.0359657966,
-0.0766118467,
-0.008786777,
-0.0408665799,
0.0234910771,
-0.0045606876,
0.0459127501,
0.0210422687,
-0.0189162083,
0.0023043405,
-0.0157719273,
-0.0049488777,
-0.0296141244,
-0.0349265598,
0.0247867815,
-0.0050586034,
0.0260568056,
-0.0092277704,
0.0365409963,
0.0280581824,
0.0508054718,
0.0017928585,
-0.0083372174,
0.0048476285,
-0.0128969224,
2.889e-7,
-0.0119463075,
-0.0151457461,
0.0611993112,
0.0833389387,
0.0100953039,
0.0433452688,
-0.0258725751,
0.075057134,
-0.0202514566,
-0.0631029233,
-0.0406625159,
-0.0414139926,
0.038126085,
-0.028115835,
-0.0635944381,
-0.0188773479,
-0.0045837951,
0.0085094981,
-0.0383214653,
-0.0135770962,
0.050928019,
0.0113677224,
-0.0164935812,
-0.0416369289,
0.0075740991,
-0.0220896844,
-0.0156281199,
-0.006158134,
-0.006325365,
-0.0089579411,
0.0497387312,
-0.0005233712,
0.039284762,
0.0572660118,
-0.0605397746,
-0.0177024957,
-0.0573645271,
0.0515015051,
0.0544729531,
-0.0441403501,
-0.0412452109,
-0.0509914644,
0.0010819223,
0.015491074,
0.0427288041,
0.0687200874,
-0.0097231492,
-0.007581736,
-0.0414582305,
-0.0475679003,
0.0144479983,
-0.0234266259,
0.0127814235,
-0.0002287577,
0.0146051245,
-0.0113663971,
0.0254560392,
-0.0432844907,
-0.0576210842,
-0.0165388379,
-0.0151637336,
-0.0621628091,
0.0282937512,
0.0374536477,
0.0332505442,
-0.0086569246,
-0.0324008651,
3.002245633e-34,
-0.0569102354,
-0.0426273867,
0.0372975878,
0.0005906216,
-0.0135908742,
0.0053131036,
-0.0379745662,
0.0045877849,
0.0428054519,
0.009260131,
-0.030126676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12808v1 | Model Merging by Uncertainty-Based Gradient Matching | 2023-10-19T15:02:45 | 2023-10-19T15:02:45 | Nico Daheim, Thomas Möllenhoff, Edoardo Maria Ponti, Iryna Gurevych, Mohammad Emtiyaz Khan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Models trained on different datasets can be merged by a weighted-averaging of
their parameters, but why does it work and when can it fail? Here, we connect
the inaccuracy of weighted-averaging to mismatches in the gradients and propose
a new uncertainty-based scheme to improve the performance by reducing the
mismatch. The connection also reveals implicit assumptions in other schemes
such as averaging, task arithmetic, and Fisher-weighted averaging. Our new
method gives consistent improvements for large language models and vision
transformers, both in terms of performance and robustness to hyperparameters. | [
-0.0159106161,
0.1201402321,
0.0283382908,
0.0483132601,
0.0017254262,
0.0360601768,
-0.0059797894,
-0.0289937314,
-0.0593369268,
-0.024301568,
-0.0382042192,
-0.0658179149,
0.0941434503,
-0.0138190528,
0.0452077091,
-0.0683242008,
0.0220422428,
-0.0150422351,
-0.0471667573,
-0.0179931801,
-0.005666337,
0.006197344,
0.0156866759,
0.0286070742,
0.0129040517,
0.0295485407,
0.0245223809,
0.0208315905,
0.069582589,
0.0484534912,
0.0284705758,
0.0154323326,
0.0013114916,
0.0721170753,
0.0000016135,
-0.0173520334,
0.017842805,
0.021782998,
-0.0169731434,
-0.0144288521,
0.02544735,
0.0092183752,
-0.0363977067,
0.0189654138,
-0.0128377872,
-0.019627342,
0.0560317338,
0.0526047349,
0.0439472198,
0.0219367333,
-0.0162607525,
-0.0623660535,
0.0638828129,
-0.033147838,
-0.0146625768,
-0.044280719,
0.0483500287,
-0.0053240578,
-0.0213129204,
-0.0350277238,
0.0075065973,
0.0160097182,
-0.0057850941,
0.0092997327,
-0.0075256312,
0.0294773187,
0.0011997133,
-0.0268565901,
-0.0136508048,
0.0472597182,
-0.0839155093,
0.0146043142,
0.0057579926,
-0.0036701886,
-0.0191124454,
-0.010893181,
-0.016135579,
-0.0107454285,
0.0082393112,
0.0388334841,
-0.0303625371,
-0.0271353386,
0.043664135,
0.0084589934,
-0.0568234362,
0.0146394596,
0.0268779993,
0.0131434416,
-0.0353218764,
-0.003546891,
-0.0326835029,
-0.0630639195,
-0.0434814207,
0.0369376168,
-0.0457973219,
-0.0204112995,
-0.1222796887,
-0.0483388789,
-0.0107568651,
0.0109874839,
0.0526002795,
0.0463340506,
-0.0276430324,
0.0536855496,
-0.0409036912,
0.0969001651,
-0.0565306917,
0.0246882085,
-0.0854613259,
-0.0210027099,
-0.0251028519,
0.0258125849,
0.0259334464,
0.0033594063,
-0.0034767187,
-0.0250837598,
-0.0434335731,
0.019540282,
-0.0269583762,
0.0153507851,
0.0088829547,
-0.0192671213,
-0.0291948766,
-0.0225690398,
-0.0069397404,
0.0171352383,
0.0513898022,
0.0485811196,
0.0160890352,
-0.0321445502,
0.003122889,
-0.0004159042,
0.0029620901,
-0.0165356491,
-0.004682173,
0.0750041455,
-0.0537534542,
0.0072803269,
0.0000241331,
0.0241839457,
0.0248948149,
-0.0653546154,
-0.0190003496,
-0.0369173139,
0.057598386,
-0.0304301903,
0.0188114326,
-0.0495209508,
0.0002611372,
-0.0029319897,
-0.0330554619,
0.1078622043,
0.001301937,
0.0004826331,
0.0313240364,
-0.0254658312,
-0.0522191301,
0.0429132544,
0.0112560159,
0.0011746943,
-0.0339658819,
0.0215883739,
0.0084909191,
0.0161079355,
-0.0034997135,
0.0098587964,
-0.0128678847,
-0.0355538651,
0.0398507901,
-0.0183206927,
0.0499218442,
0.0872647464,
-0.0377138257,
-0.0235785358,
0.0682732835,
0.0214821696,
0.0055469335,
-0.0089658899,
-0.0032750703,
-0.0323842764,
0.0255467016,
0.0269281976,
-0.0731186271,
-0.0002625026,
-0.041758582,
0.0293183587,
0.0249513946,
0.1037460566,
-0.0583140552,
-0.0329516605,
-0.0454552099,
-0.0285360198,
-0.011064373,
0.0096025849,
0.0550352857,
-0.0412749983,
-0.0499333926,
-0.0135821616,
0.006710642,
-0.039252799,
0.0030956313,
-0.0773121417,
-0.0180607364,
0.0021323378,
-0.0034553932,
-0.0080217607,
-0.0297487229,
-0.0114868423,
0.0088892141,
-0.0157399178,
0.0204609446,
0.0078994101,
0.0329144225,
-0.0692718178,
-0.0869867429,
0.0605969429,
-0.0011266484,
0.0302148927,
-0.0056910096,
-0.0230284519,
0.0413988382,
-0.0076685604,
-0.0175165907,
0.0478444882,
-0.0001487611,
0.0151685271,
-0.0071443897,
-0.0293042529,
0.0380308181,
-0.0218697693,
-0.003057749,
0.0135185532,
-0.0048204898,
-0.0072509819,
-0.0562282912,
0.024301555,
-0.0006721155,
0.0025850132,
0.0419647582,
-0.0103270337,
-0.0223047379,
0.0573157221,
-0.0656552985,
-0.0726957247,
-0.0239361469,
-0.0035356183,
0.0176684055,
-0.0142452698,
0.0826603547,
-0.0063498244,
0.0205006823,
-0.0243818052,
0.0606226027,
-0.0285851043,
-0.0107838986,
-0.0030386692,
-0.0149799939,
-0.0036508802,
-0.0380397774,
-0.052368857,
0.0014595061,
-0.0126964217,
0.0419030488,
0.0062627969,
-0.0434116349,
0.0096583236,
-0.022749465,
-0.0274985228,
0.0224209893,
-0.0150069334,
0.0277203172,
0.006193765,
0.0167999379,
0.0194190517,
0.0156344548,
0.0134734735,
0.0156954341,
-0.0087737739,
0.0025091143,
0.0246849842,
0.0073515638,
-0.0064186924,
-0.049089998,
-0.0273549743,
-0.0070827524,
0.0486920886,
-0.0327414498,
-0.0200560596,
-0.0754003748,
0.0427045561,
-0.0244578142,
0.0404460616,
-0.0437548049,
-0.0370910689,
-0.0136889229,
-0.0236229934,
0.0491736829,
0.0738603622,
0.0114040412,
-0.0326951295,
0.06160767,
0.0161131881,
-0.0008550427,
-0.0047808005,
0.0058070635,
-0.0423070081,
-0.0077378396,
-0.0275898352,
-0.0341201127,
0.0415392444,
-0.0348703191,
-0.0294603184,
-0.0507222153,
0.0067225085,
-0.0209473167,
0.0212252997,
-0.0256879944,
-0.0159448665,
-0.0075671216,
0.013321979,
-0.0478370525,
-0.03643113,
0.0631627515,
-0.0421260074,
0.0059956065,
-0.0083748484,
-0.0150100254,
0.006947835,
-0.0189971793,
0.0199304465,
0.0030638173,
0.0095502501,
0.02181492,
-0.085881874,
-0.0352354012,
0.0716308951,
-0.0227021389,
0.04546009,
-0.0349700674,
0.05644596,
-0.0355751701,
-0.0364617184,
-0.0528131351,
-0.0155125018,
-0.0275470242,
-0.0039569992,
0.0267006401,
-0.0618587695,
-0.0685510114,
0.0221002661,
-0.0088760601,
0.053247638,
-0.0140372356,
-0.0206302684,
-0.0247155391,
0.0350097045,
0.020235572,
0.0177481771,
0.0427994058,
-0.02840041,
0.0083738388,
0.0143314591,
0.096484229,
0.0379884169,
-0.0861401632,
-0.0165710561,
0.0428037569,
0.0293884575,
-0.0191636756,
0.0067796074,
0.0254706517,
0.0064511676,
0.0401249491,
0.0761681497,
-0.0086404895,
-0.032456547,
-0.0572066829,
0.0134984516,
0.0535989888,
0.0253281295,
-0.0008756145,
-0.0151396114,
-0.027178796,
0.0443051532,
0.0021065995,
0.0273694079,
0.0174983554,
-0.021473445,
-0.0816342607,
-0.0025000668,
0.0425235145,
-0.0083026607,
-0.0365509689,
-0.0065696971,
0.0426896624,
-0.044230815,
0.0595251881,
-0.0092238719,
-0.027900286,
-0.016086407,
0.0103673041,
0.0043947301,
-0.0764544383,
-0.0319628455,
-0.0455509163,
0.0507448055,
0.0582265593,
0.0101824328,
0.0221658386,
-0.0230673812,
0.0674622133,
-0.0205912087,
-0.0469651893,
0.0379874744,
0.0281344503,
0.0240500625,
-0.0217245538,
0.0191168077,
0.0338753238,
-0.0247699954,
-0.0116396053,
-0.0686769038,
0.008997431,
-0.0021323089,
0.0202895477,
-0.0012176527,
-0.037366543,
0.0053160456,
0.0476425253,
-0.0327828303,
-0.0130631942,
0.0163984969,
0.034485206,
-0.0008217494,
0.0424441174,
-0.0078414725,
0.0452127866,
-0.0379436202,
-0.0354617015,
-0.0423084721,
0.0046171113,
-0.0199481621,
0.0385560542,
-0.0152800754,
-0.0333740078,
0.0331788734,
-0.0046328194,
-0.0598740876,
0.0519160144,
0.0119519131,
0.048671551,
-0.0583025105,
0.0142712845,
0.0353563689,
-0.0055013113,
-0.0325128324,
0.0009048707,
-0.131610319,
-0.098455213,
0.0046731955,
0.01371329,
0.0191635583,
0.027053006,
-0.0148468306,
-0.0499445163,
0.0230949763,
0.0203538202,
0.0382898115,
0.040337611,
0.0336538553,
-0.0585068241,
-0.0096066417,
0.0244409591,
-0.0900885984,
0.0168742035,
-0.0040371665,
-0.0299654622,
-0.0474759489,
-0.0125426585,
-0.0010711934,
0.0014985964,
0.0427684188,
-0.0439345501,
0.0018945262,
-0.0152797308,
0.0231526941,
0.0187017005,
-0.0020580874,
-0.0337948166,
-0.0151358619,
0.0358005054,
0.0227061491,
0.0120536098,
0.0588630699,
0.0678192154,
0.0128790988,
-0.0358700417,
-0.0528436415,
-0.043441698,
-0.0015191195,
0.0284837261,
0.0122945011,
0.0194296036,
0.047490526,
0.0075360942,
0.0071851336,
0.0003800754,
-0.0004755639,
0.0320376866,
0.0333775468,
-0.020270681,
0.0462827384,
-0.1083687842,
-0.1272579283,
-0.0381196812,
-0.0054621566,
0.0735171288,
0.0085049169,
0.0636992157,
-0.0002207574,
-0.0207978394,
-0.0375178643,
0.0064465422,
-0.0059329201,
0.0396695584,
0.0965812355,
0.0146728177,
0.0289575495,
0.0022881925,
0.0491691642,
-0.0139399022,
0.0194329824,
-0.0291362368,
0.0251759086,
-0.0041705803,
-0.0284670573,
0.0054161269,
-0.017869629,
-0.0255176146,
-0.0450716987,
0.0402123593,
-0.0770303831,
0.0243334975,
0.023087088,
-0.0079366695,
0.0276321415,
0.0139368279,
0.0160226598,
-0.0093992976,
0.009715463,
0.0074852263,
-0.0543095171,
0.0099696461,
-0.0025792539,
0.0321244597,
-5.652356137e-33,
-0.0191075187,
0.0118693942,
-0.0267548226,
-0.0456856377,
-0.0026698415,
0.0173827875,
0.0429538079,
-0.0052607958,
-0.0350163206,
-0.0031962637,
-0.0128466729,
0.0471465737,
0.0315135643,
0.0378881395,
-0.0417806916,
-0.0219478104,
0.0580901951,
0.0183231644,
0.0078286836,
-0.0238972604,
-0.00859953,
0.0019421728,
0.0060464856,
-0.0421480499,
-0.0144131659,
0.0119590946,
-0.0363753699,
0.0280313883,
0.023943238,
0.051869791,
-0.026935922,
0.010872676,
-0.0129088741,
0.0250019245,
-0.0600412712,
-0.0333822481,
-0.0473507717,
0.0128502874,
-0.0083067399,
0.0428241938,
-0.0270978659,
0.0004014172,
0.06507577,
-0.0044858977,
-0.0185046457,
-0.052463457,
0.039641086,
-0.0223251134,
0.0094351592,
-0.0208939277,
-0.0342739224,
0.0033317548,
0.0312805735,
-0.0442696176,
0.0686606914,
-0.0128640449,
0.0215534642,
0.0003154163,
-0.0404157527,
-0.014260605,
-0.0124222767,
0.0503349863,
0.0741899163,
0.0786846727,
-0.0147121539,
0.0402411073,
0.0020923824,
-0.0325533152,
-0.0121412035,
-0.0286702905,
0.018752899,
0.0267326869,
0.0464232601,
0.0474515408,
0.0240077656,
0.0021614269,
-0.0332345665,
0.0710067898,
-0.0058266204,
0.0180064812,
-0.0136150178,
0.0775568336,
0.021400528,
-0.0023750502,
-0.0503830537,
-0.0094187586,
-0.0460968576,
0.0529796146,
0.0040978678,
0.0103691723,
-0.0023477762,
-0.0036732249,
0.0193664134,
-0.0421457663,
-0.021573469,
0.0233853683,
-0.0085675297,
0.0159839541,
0.0007647707,
0.0429971814,
-0.0020394886,
-0.0577898696,
0.0324426703,
0.0657058582,
0.0024765444,
0.0176781416,
-0.0077300007,
0.0277894661,
-0.053264007,
-0.0044542882,
-0.0179419424,
0.0040835491,
0.0133705633,
0.04629758,
0.0829809085,
-0.0015879498,
0.0201085079,
0.0201862752,
-0.0258930288,
0.014944654,
-0.040116407,
0.0550512932,
0.0022462404,
0.0299401656,
0.0135851502,
0.0009014592,
-0.0170198791,
-0.0071706567,
0.0476813242,
-0.0261963252,
-0.0459427796,
0.0187389329,
2.369e-7,
-0.0003803988,
-0.0412674434,
0.0062003853,
0.0113272788,
-0.0219316967,
0.0480532907,
-0.0314650349,
0.0052673449,
-0.006804158,
-0.0069397776,
-0.000747583,
0.0259429999,
0.0497633219,
0.00296956,
-0.0172995683,
-0.0359988101,
-0.0192078762,
0.0075940713,
-0.0085144136,
-0.0247237552,
0.0390582904,
0.0901645795,
0.0150751304,
-0.0116323037,
0.0254018418,
0.0222363193,
0.0652574599,
-0.0236459579,
0.0181911029,
0.0368558839,
0.0266176388,
-0.0040871752,
-0.0283154268,
0.0585606471,
0.0046559842,
0.0057567856,
0.0263929274,
0.0211457629,
-0.0502736866,
-0.0042945519,
-0.0654817894,
0.0323588066,
-0.0106776915,
-0.0308204703,
0.0491736531,
-0.0523854084,
-0.0040942174,
-0.0915361196,
-0.0188587625,
-0.0015442106,
0.0507552661,
0.0225150529,
-0.0043146587,
0.0502781756,
0.0153858373,
0.0141445082,
-0.0227497928,
-0.0761323273,
0.0109342895,
0.0355629735,
-0.0714670494,
-0.0308802482,
-0.0204178654,
-0.0087753301,
0.0709202066,
-0.0465872288,
-0.0231885854,
1.821280297e-34,
0.0091550667,
-0.0022093933,
0.01802825,
0.0072095119,
-0.0251179859,
-0.002590853,
-0.0167558677,
0.015609446,
-0.0201598406,
-0.0453473516,
0.0079653347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12803v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12803v2 | Data Augmentations for Improved (Large) Language Model Generalization | 2023-10-19T14:59:25 | 2024-01-09T17:46:22 | Amir Feder, Yoav Wald, Claudia Shi, Suchi Saria, David Blei | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The reliance of text classifiers on spurious correlations can lead to poor
generalization at deployment, raising concerns about their use in
safety-critical domains such as healthcare. In this work, we propose to use
counterfactual data augmentation, guided by knowledge of the causal structure
of the data, to simulate interventions on spurious features and to learn more
robust text classifiers. We show that this strategy is appropriate in
prediction problems where the label is spuriously correlated with an attribute.
Under the assumptions of such problems, we discuss the favorable sample
complexity of counterfactual data augmentation, compared to importance
re-weighting. Pragmatically, we match examples using auxiliary data, based on
diff-in-diff methodology, and use a large language model (LLM) to represent a
conditional probability of text. Through extensive experimentation on learning
caregiver-invariant predictors of clinical diagnoses from medical narratives
and on semi-synthetic data, we demonstrate that our method for simulating
interventions improves out-of-distribution (OOD) accuracy compared to baseline
invariant learning algorithms. | [
0.03602314,
0.1041429788,
-0.01091717,
-0.0117014069,
-0.0304339882,
0.0323176607,
-0.0148194889,
0.0309799742,
0.0259192437,
-0.0461902022,
0.0389517583,
-0.0453138612,
-0.0105333617,
0.0350092351,
0.0101924501,
-0.0163367577,
0.0260644201,
-0.0001354393,
0.0176829528,
-0.0270624701,
-0.0212280322,
-0.0037063134,
0.0066728382,
0.006120441,
-0.010814541,
0.0237175655,
0.0238596722,
0.0046307156,
0.0309071671,
-0.0180354044,
0.0187735185,
0.0322285704,
0.0172535218,
0.0146570001,
0.0000021416,
-0.0338478982,
-0.0242605209,
0.0276317392,
-0.0123295877,
-0.0308519583,
0.0248129573,
-0.0649467781,
0.0133130802,
0.0179066658,
-0.0036026561,
-0.0248158444,
0.0416635759,
0.0490524955,
-0.008070752,
0.090204455,
-0.0263656881,
0.0110922502,
0.0105281444,
-0.0136777917,
0.0360187888,
-0.0239586942,
0.0590858534,
0.006604651,
0.0010391769,
-0.0355110653,
-0.0304500926,
0.0334870927,
0.0055525503,
0.0394183621,
0.0367915556,
0.0518495068,
-0.0111892987,
0.0265252199,
0.0126547776,
0.0495898426,
-0.0229081288,
-0.0296957865,
0.0244223718,
-0.0411499627,
0.0332910866,
0.0707745403,
-0.012963308,
-0.0397179723,
-0.0071822354,
0.0212200191,
0.0352137387,
0.0081241699,
0.0487087816,
0.0144281955,
-0.0231372677,
0.0381197147,
-0.0047751316,
-0.0317229852,
0.0067585595,
0.0112842843,
-0.0460553765,
-0.0341199413,
-0.0042674034,
0.0073199729,
-0.0353501849,
0.0101549802,
-0.0337875448,
-0.0726804957,
0.0409017392,
-0.0956416056,
0.0142918909,
0.0079449229,
-0.0346970335,
0.035924986,
-0.0042077336,
0.0211678669,
-0.0028320502,
0.0545899309,
-0.0513481162,
0.0191902071,
-0.0450560302,
0.0021605201,
-0.0079135746,
0.0237195231,
0.0130351121,
0.0253344141,
-0.0476261377,
0.0030475396,
-0.0330134332,
0.0031687971,
0.0055874726,
0.042496644,
-0.0518294163,
-0.0053336308,
0.0164612234,
-0.0175097287,
0.0158269797,
0.0529683121,
-0.048462566,
-0.0267115831,
0.0044244896,
0.0227153301,
0.0161178336,
-0.0173448194,
0.0218806919,
0.0536329523,
0.0112677319,
-0.0474702045,
0.0036710852,
-0.0246094149,
-0.0518593118,
-0.0284704156,
-0.0254073832,
-0.0746940747,
-0.0348060615,
0.0165053476,
0.0201056208,
-0.0998341814,
0.00748885,
-0.0295346454,
-0.0785331801,
0.0354643203,
-0.0231823772,
-0.0178566352,
0.0004956042,
-0.0105032055,
0.0034449061,
0.0547649525,
0.0527894609,
-0.0256861616,
0.0146860871,
-0.006385297,
0.0512384214,
0.0276687928,
0.0242530592,
0.0253397152,
-0.0416656211,
-0.0123636639,
0.0668853968,
0.0091465469,
-0.003458777,
-0.0146635836,
0.0059992466,
-0.0240129773,
0.0483490564,
-0.0245625209,
0.0112080369,
-0.013854349,
0.0087461341,
0.007976694,
-0.0460799895,
0.0082535911,
-0.0156677198,
-0.0070336866,
-0.0515629426,
-0.0035442431,
-0.0416534357,
-0.0102143427,
-0.0340858027,
-0.0422731973,
-0.0175950918,
-0.0188207347,
0.0248549879,
0.0206046533,
0.0656185821,
-0.0011772409,
0.0078273285,
-0.0066965455,
0.0723885894,
0.0120007545,
-0.0067973407,
-0.0424863137,
-0.046964217,
0.1010420248,
0.0462711342,
-0.089283444,
-0.0036165949,
-0.0264767613,
0.040255487,
-0.0321321525,
0.002756333,
-0.001927295,
0.0175661929,
-0.0053493604,
-0.0261592381,
0.0321424678,
0.0518353768,
0.0005001684,
-0.0051835901,
0.0100635337,
-0.0022995882,
-0.0338276252,
-0.0686835423,
0.0561504774,
-0.0642662123,
-0.0255828761,
0.0422920138,
0.0055116527,
0.0282344334,
-0.0067120222,
-0.0374116115,
-0.0154221868,
-0.0004096458,
-0.0249134339,
-0.0610855259,
0.0169372074,
-0.0117201852,
-0.0294480585,
0.0045743799,
-0.0082237571,
0.0024218932,
-0.0124240341,
-0.051701434,
-0.0047291187,
0.0113648577,
-0.0495752804,
0.0368110165,
-0.0072056456,
0.0188616775,
0.0053187851,
0.0033520747,
-0.0265144259,
0.0395485014,
-0.0354727618,
-0.0121935038,
-0.0495694987,
-0.0188670456,
0.0046089096,
0.0087774452,
0.0055546071,
-0.0029766455,
0.0029023725,
0.0133621953,
0.0095917154,
-0.0174321625,
0.01069366,
-0.0374743231,
-0.0918929353,
-0.015987752,
-0.045032084,
-0.02124184,
-0.0023024932,
0.0150127877,
-0.009976238,
-0.0169776361,
-0.0384951383,
-0.0337724537,
0.0118096014,
0.0267891791,
0.007281648,
0.035851948,
-0.0316402949,
-0.0109801507,
0.0009103881,
-0.0286402032,
0.0709184483,
0.0154359322,
-0.0428438783,
-0.0490471236,
-0.0207997505,
-0.0086999862,
0.0057072588,
-0.0308983307,
-0.0140039688,
-0.055189617,
0.0089568254,
-0.0172115359,
0.025172988,
0.000991076,
0.0033476776,
0.0659071058,
0.0375929102,
-0.0337477028,
0.0050310674,
-0.0420642309,
-0.0304988958,
-0.0333648771,
-0.0614733659,
-0.0271946285,
0.044855807,
0.0032540471,
-0.0477462523,
-0.0554504991,
-0.0309642851,
-0.0139905475,
-0.0194887947,
-0.0246101208,
-0.0343605056,
-0.0344509408,
0.018345153,
-0.0044939565,
-0.067229934,
0.0978518724,
0.0091906814,
0.048570849,
-0.0720283017,
-0.0531445108,
-0.0307635795,
0.016723169,
0.0120344926,
0.0199940037,
0.0408839397,
0.0189788695,
0.0014794996,
0.0082962587,
0.0149499448,
-0.0276698861,
0.0375390612,
-0.0629426017,
0.0507902503,
0.0538687743,
-0.068433091,
-0.0489648245,
-0.097401239,
0.0014209322,
-0.0164891277,
-0.0286558941,
-0.0108042285,
-0.0372352041,
-0.013391491,
-0.0200383887,
0.1026879847,
0.0075244112,
-0.0041433801,
0.0102022029,
-0.0285420623,
0.0250066705,
-0.0298847929,
-0.0377112515,
-0.0378512144,
-0.0063664042,
0.0259794574,
0.0137191936,
-0.0189956184,
0.0038218577,
0.0215597041,
-0.0139818108,
-0.0003704683,
-0.0116774263,
0.0418742374,
-0.0171948448,
-0.0298595242,
-0.0153321819,
0.0732606053,
0.0343015492,
-0.0387661606,
0.0502654128,
0.0181292575,
0.041612722,
0.0141398143,
0.0111845518,
-0.0533658117,
-0.0246697925,
0.00852679,
0.0158983916,
-0.0474576056,
-0.0490900949,
0.0257867984,
-0.0460731089,
0.0214051437,
0.0106742028,
-0.0311718564,
-0.0334461741,
-0.0406039953,
0.0187314395,
-0.0434967317,
-0.0371932015,
-0.0198341198,
-0.0110358661,
-0.0104228407,
0.0074461605,
-0.0500143059,
-0.0977641642,
-0.0102929417,
0.0011693892,
0.0256223511,
0.0714397058,
0.0009626352,
-0.0319859535,
0.013536498,
0.040471375,
0.0245291404,
0.0218398366,
0.017788168,
0.1184545681,
0.0043629939,
0.0043056561,
-0.001272693,
0.0535652228,
0.0010452033,
-0.0239124056,
0.0015875685,
0.0688430816,
-0.0327612311,
-0.0258166455,
-0.0026653493,
-0.0072960211,
0.0563720018,
0.0425223894,
-0.0222359952,
-0.0613933131,
0.0107305637,
-0.0102030048,
-0.00421105,
0.040002998,
0.0195559729,
0.0161455572,
-0.0004002194,
-0.0773994625,
-0.0600727983,
-0.033207465,
0.0208572336,
0.007054117,
0.0193050019,
0.037495289,
-0.0127913188,
-0.0224683136,
-0.0551046245,
0.0449951813,
-0.0105905533,
0.0480285697,
0.0225585718,
-0.0438043103,
0.0349781178,
-0.0336830169,
-0.0345501378,
-0.0000541655,
-0.0420564711,
-0.0633246377,
0.0486788638,
0.0392520651,
0.0230605286,
0.0795368105,
0.0029206728,
-0.0468723066,
0.058168035,
0.0863726735,
-0.042920623,
0.0023433645,
0.0219866186,
-0.0791594237,
0.0118981935,
0.010362084,
-0.0239477661,
0.014063959,
0.036049217,
0.0058875526,
-0.0382882543,
-0.0035195441,
0.0202196036,
-0.0020729862,
0.053566616,
-0.0339423679,
-0.0174212698,
-0.0351729468,
0.045393873,
-0.0133506022,
-0.0057867453,
-0.0135561926,
0.0282618459,
0.031168988,
0.0171855651,
-0.021849066,
0.0204699039,
-0.0626319572,
0.0010216596,
-0.0250816997,
0.0355300307,
-0.0096716778,
0.0238398593,
0.0765300989,
-0.0103556681,
0.0118674049,
0.0132338749,
0.064325124,
0.0274270773,
0.0098422179,
0.0216401108,
0.0310929362,
0.0408763215,
-0.0517485477,
-0.0220229216,
-0.0766418874,
0.003852275,
-0.0643860921,
0.053341914,
0.0109533481,
-0.0325315148,
0.0009385738,
-0.055166699,
-0.0107349018,
-0.0134992851,
0.0027079312,
0.0084481603,
-0.0122268461,
0.023625914,
0.0124610215,
-0.0238472261,
0.0452782176,
0.0932912603,
0.0455222949,
0.07219024,
-0.0403984338,
-0.0142741445,
-0.0301573873,
-0.0378470905,
0.0530288555,
0.0372526757,
-0.0586752146,
0.0240248311,
-0.0972079635,
-0.0602594204,
0.0331177376,
-0.0562013313,
0.0120486021,
-0.0158795062,
0.024080148,
0.0212247763,
-0.0008849644,
0.0165610351,
-0.0261572842,
0.0005170751,
0.0296434313,
-0.0385741703,
0.0072752135,
-6.471031014e-33,
0.0261381716,
-0.0456039123,
-0.0161247645,
-0.0311741997,
0.0299499817,
0.0165400449,
0.0146213351,
-0.008932977,
0.0379371941,
0.043927405,
-0.0050055287,
0.020849552,
0.0084088873,
0.0325886346,
-0.0039428612,
-0.0156455431,
0.0299200919,
0.026302116,
-0.0148331998,
0.0233941656,
0.0107109686,
0.0404856429,
0.0463472903,
-0.1336186975,
0.0565125719,
-0.0012159921,
-0.0099112354,
0.0002872512,
-0.0150101008,
0.0190799274,
-0.0010431935,
0.0546225794,
0.0273218621,
-0.004959784,
0.0115688508,
-0.0244854819,
-0.0338015072,
-0.0023615274,
0.0135520203,
-0.0036218853,
0.006319527,
-0.0272334907,
0.0261766426,
-0.0004143286,
-0.0254713465,
-0.0180041827,
0.0483411364,
-0.0686778277,
-0.0077320514,
-0.0124684172,
-0.0639136434,
0.0630893931,
-0.0158891976,
0.0283170268,
-0.0050751902,
0.0372660458,
-0.0008491281,
0.0605906248,
-0.0084804613,
-0.0119314604,
0.0391683988,
0.0113763958,
0.0069259098,
0.0064778286,
-0.0182155725,
0.0786707178,
-0.0045219087,
0.0193321537,
-0.0385438763,
0.0012157884,
-0.0148077933,
0.0041186702,
0.0472889133,
0.1110228002,
0.0810344219,
-0.045221474,
-0.1055031344,
0.0304131322,
-0.0570527911,
-0.0327391922,
0.0443802848,
-0.0135299768,
-0.0717213973,
-0.0351734944,
-0.0367416404,
0.0255930051,
-0.0134301502,
-0.0177867375,
-0.0020198973,
0.0368364304,
-0.0194817018,
0.0285641886,
-0.0058562527,
-0.0453033894,
-0.0261616781,
0.0208589546,
-0.0012087026,
0.000494166,
-0.0186112616,
-0.0018445469,
-0.0039485805,
-0.0305297934,
0.0346933305,
0.024570955,
0.057927262,
-0.0042256536,
0.1052646264,
0.0057584336,
-0.065364562,
0.0084667262,
0.0233750343,
0.0075717238,
0.0028099543,
0.029462561,
0.0424758382,
0.0317163952,
-0.0047069499,
0.047035154,
0.0321314,
-0.0024130687,
-0.0241628308,
-0.0195223596,
-0.0344923548,
-0.011931398,
-0.0336783081,
-0.0002209872,
0.018610524,
-0.0145977885,
0.0354536809,
-0.083052665,
-0.0171087384,
-0.0119257718,
2.954e-7,
0.0691044107,
0.0577615686,
-0.0063411291,
-0.0555466227,
0.016995497,
0.0308317486,
-0.0271948073,
0.0384534001,
0.0290086493,
-0.0104245236,
0.0701556653,
0.0211882889,
0.0391338654,
0.0133564528,
-0.0647770986,
0.0125880903,
-0.0688370094,
-0.0144291576,
-0.0402270146,
-0.0383529849,
0.0455222167,
0.0937378481,
0.0054749032,
-0.0292360056,
0.0192014128,
-0.0083102873,
0.0398227051,
-0.0539410077,
0.0136558153,
0.020922251,
-0.0015921445,
0.006314435,
0.0070759649,
0.0767322257,
-0.0454255603,
0.0121595673,
-0.0157596655,
0.053036619,
-0.052481547,
0.0504324026,
-0.0203580335,
-0.0123589728,
0.0111471321,
-0.0423316956,
0.0614728443,
-0.0347057022,
-0.019949913,
-0.0079146558,
-0.0386205539,
-0.0063013812,
0.0489439406,
-0.0111662587,
-0.0090650804,
0.0450260676,
0.0164801702,
0.0341890194,
-0.0034632257,
-0.0494125038,
-0.0458464585,
0.0499020666,
-0.0348433219,
-0.047167398,
0.0322560854,
0.0390902758,
0.0357405432,
-0.0622749142,
0.0592402816,
2.903094291e-34,
0.0681168959,
0.036050234,
-0.018550247,
-0.0300071929,
0.0170750581,
-0.004649499,
0.0170203652,
0.0314725265,
0.0378673673,
-0.0496219061,
0.0232990049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12798v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12798v4 | MolCA: Molecular Graph-Language Modeling with Cross-Modal Projector and Uni-Modal Adapter | 2023-10-19T14:52:58 | 2024-01-18T09:03:24 | Zhiyuan Liu, Sihang Li, Yanchen Luo, Hao Fei, Yixin Cao, Kenji Kawaguchi, Xiang Wang, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Language Models (LMs) have demonstrated impressive molecule understanding
ability on various 1D text-related tasks. However, they inherently lack 2D
graph perception - a critical ability of human professionals in comprehending
molecules' topological structures. To bridge this gap, we propose MolCA:
Molecular Graph-Language Modeling with Cross-Modal Projector and Uni-Modal
Adapter. MolCA enables an LM (e.g., Galactica) to understand both text- and
graph-based molecular contents via the cross-modal projector. Specifically, the
cross-modal projector is implemented as a Q-Former to connect a graph encoder's
representation space and an LM's text space. Further, MolCA employs a uni-modal
adapter (i.e., LoRA) for the LM's efficient adaptation to downstream tasks.
Unlike previous studies that couple an LM with a graph encoder via cross-modal
contrastive learning, MolCA retains the LM's ability of open-ended text
generation and augments it with 2D graph information. To showcase its
effectiveness, we extensively benchmark MolCA on tasks of molecule captioning,
IUPAC name prediction, and molecule-text retrieval, on which MolCA
significantly outperforms the baselines. Our codes and checkpoints can be found
at https://github.com/acharkq/MolCA. | [
0.0444574319,
0.0702070072,
0.013396333,
0.017637426,
-0.0202695634,
-0.0076308199,
0.0190707352,
0.0276204627,
0.0476007424,
0.0198603608,
-0.0498914048,
-0.0584046803,
0.0106158983,
0.0740908831,
0.0456420109,
-0.0217052586,
-0.0080852071,
-0.0290276222,
-0.041069407,
-0.0428511277,
-0.0019508101,
0.0075259805,
0.0367851295,
0.0015575782,
0.0234728605,
-0.0209797416,
-0.027006736,
0.0174912717,
0.0083322907,
-0.0619548634,
-0.0002721422,
0.0500021204,
0.0432930179,
0.016498806,
0.0000019467,
0.005502094,
-0.0246217884,
0.0086171962,
0.0176910106,
0.0135152936,
0.0821102336,
-0.0720465928,
0.0185156502,
-0.012605736,
-0.0270464532,
-0.0295364633,
0.0853702947,
0.0136139868,
-0.0170824025,
0.030312106,
-0.0127255768,
-0.0406257808,
0.0417662673,
-0.0311144199,
0.0602266528,
-0.0083505865,
0.0358392335,
0.0526519492,
0.0260570981,
0.011308331,
-0.064795427,
0.0448474512,
-0.0122319888,
-0.0458830968,
0.0256703626,
0.0278070141,
0.0292726103,
-0.0410118438,
-0.0188440923,
0.1270457953,
0.008669531,
-0.0363510735,
-0.0328313299,
-0.0005230788,
-0.0402633622,
0.0346916243,
-0.0462627485,
-0.0183488205,
-0.0021005194,
0.0227422733,
-0.0088849803,
-0.013977156,
0.0425650962,
-0.0331896096,
0.0020646364,
0.0088600153,
0.0183268357,
-0.0155590689,
-0.0005519023,
0.0099952845,
-0.0178997852,
-0.0179381818,
0.0273253657,
0.0238081757,
0.0267796125,
0.0090545397,
0.0079604462,
-0.0321684889,
0.0291154236,
-0.0147768389,
0.0611695498,
0.0024797441,
0.0089632943,
0.0204578172,
-0.0306953341,
0.0348052382,
-0.0383985564,
0.0814339146,
-0.0372386947,
-0.0335466936,
-0.032056313,
0.0164122377,
-0.0288775843,
0.0213319398,
-0.0525170229,
-0.0300000217,
-0.0429557338,
0.0231321827,
0.0263543595,
-0.0246224459,
0.0340187401,
0.032371413,
-0.0308188088,
-0.0052813585,
-0.0116561344,
0.0817652196,
0.0411910713,
0.0053592278,
-0.027173074,
-0.0535994023,
-0.0319044255,
0.0164688267,
0.0266154073,
-0.0275365338,
0.0271624457,
0.1430642009,
-0.0142169371,
-0.0689331889,
0.0306828003,
-0.0238330662,
-0.0254910868,
-0.0298639443,
0.0568525456,
-0.0543097779,
0.0455301106,
0.0402217023,
-0.0018853082,
-0.0254945997,
0.0424453244,
-0.0175733808,
-0.0359350927,
0.1095374525,
-0.027396122,
-0.0531851538,
0.0246960316,
-0.0017461246,
-0.0275317617,
-0.0179150887,
0.0369472131,
0.0139577007,
-0.0502745807,
0.0301579498,
-0.0056333295,
0.0030308526,
0.0365568474,
-0.0426966436,
-0.0090915384,
-0.0211925916,
-0.0021613438,
0.0344410278,
0.0151585527,
0.0552184954,
-0.0132227316,
-0.0027812214,
0.0386247709,
0.0247393344,
0.07216537,
0.0320757329,
-0.0038371729,
0.0437310189,
-0.0335713886,
-0.0247949306,
-0.0201597624,
0.0833637193,
0.031386219,
0.0184895881,
0.0414046273,
0.008265445,
-0.0139363557,
-0.0352128409,
0.0117701329,
-0.0017552013,
0.0637438446,
-0.0511384197,
0.0538093299,
-0.0046911566,
-0.1085033193,
-0.0026846707,
0.0524880812,
-0.04097794,
0.0046854159,
-0.0150271468,
0.013729224,
0.0765882954,
0.0473987721,
-0.0358649343,
-0.0393175967,
0.0249561332,
-0.0388006791,
0.0466135666,
-0.0011678888,
-0.0098379273,
0.0221154243,
-0.0329632163,
-0.045976758,
-0.0411313958,
-0.0176543016,
0.0260594729,
-0.0308921188,
-0.0051973145,
-0.0129842497,
-0.0840823054,
-0.0146718547,
0.0168278757,
0.0185145754,
-0.0052928785,
-0.0232133046,
-0.0071722334,
0.004088623,
-0.0073464806,
0.0013857855,
0.0312892161,
0.0532208383,
-0.0387852639,
0.0054606576,
-0.0370411314,
-0.0236273576,
-0.0741511583,
0.045801919,
-0.0544038713,
0.0304530021,
0.0165664889,
-0.0201318897,
-0.0412740223,
0.0749969259,
-0.0468529724,
0.0312575139,
-0.0172792543,
-0.0294648502,
-0.0171249006,
0.0684632957,
0.017909864,
0.0395500585,
0.0002704332,
-0.0054422985,
0.0176062174,
0.0295348726,
-0.0067174551,
-0.0207432844,
0.0140593164,
0.0148881841,
0.055672396,
0.0407656282,
0.0182797816,
0.0091723893,
0.0014088778,
-0.0066772024,
-0.0566371679,
-0.0302565079,
-0.0199496113,
0.0033870372,
0.0128862727,
-0.0018852057,
0.0115350233,
-0.0288091134,
-0.0502060726,
0.0169134531,
0.0000209664,
-0.0034205879,
0.0342662781,
0.0024155371,
-0.0297225732,
-0.034485016,
-0.0465102941,
-0.0364487544,
0.0680267066,
0.0052386872,
-0.0816978887,
0.0063618575,
0.0040104371,
0.0056334077,
-0.0006771301,
-0.0156339295,
0.0035344379,
0.0220026448,
-0.0033903238,
0.0418629311,
0.051861465,
-0.0081113251,
0.0316789597,
0.0872051269,
-0.0024457786,
0.0016234104,
-0.0151910977,
-0.031934645,
-0.0090603773,
-0.0049855909,
-0.0381859131,
-0.0160345621,
0.0719664171,
-0.0121933166,
0.0140086142,
-0.0600802265,
-0.0281693749,
0.0098596625,
-0.025856832,
-0.005672249,
0.0223737992,
-0.012624112,
-0.0053110532,
-0.0163103528,
-0.0282069854,
0.0738450885,
-0.0362546891,
-0.012938193,
0.003167606,
0.0052038082,
-0.0124880718,
0.0273922589,
0.0316277556,
0.0386129096,
0.0139765125,
-0.0331447721,
-0.0163521506,
0.0203439482,
-0.0135427108,
-0.0352218412,
-0.0101939179,
-0.0305875335,
0.0083715981,
-0.0017521095,
-0.035238985,
0.0202796869,
0.0220028087,
-0.0229170956,
0.0510632098,
0.0095359096,
-0.0410280302,
-0.0187984891,
0.0169272274,
0.0251577012,
0.0046533067,
-0.0386335663,
0.008132414,
-0.0483528152,
0.0458943769,
0.0348945782,
-0.0101042725,
0.0062637161,
-0.0458624363,
-0.0076128254,
0.0329760239,
-0.0086264201,
-0.0109072924,
0.0064918045,
0.0259041581,
0.0081181042,
0.072829999,
-0.0280931462,
-0.0003952748,
0.044745367,
-0.0200858526,
-0.026533952,
0.0476999991,
0.0004386737,
-0.0610138215,
-0.0122527126,
-0.0097698439,
0.0308744702,
-0.0067438129,
0.0239281356,
-0.1048948094,
-0.0416054241,
-0.065404214,
0.0314702243,
0.0288736746,
-0.0067684809,
-0.0102110868,
-0.0493913665,
0.0236102883,
0.0281475876,
-0.0275657419,
-0.048880931,
-0.0749618039,
-0.0384759456,
-0.0247598272,
0.0092584128,
0.0140421391,
-0.0065844245,
-0.0022434453,
0.0476350188,
0.0524119623,
-0.0070326519,
-0.0053160735,
0.0144527303,
-0.0220226776,
0.0185978562,
0.0202290881,
0.0351284631,
-0.0302745644,
-0.0060341922,
-0.0102456072,
0.0049088788,
-0.0028357601,
0.0678865835,
0.0185933113,
-0.0210776478,
-0.0332163647,
0.0229958277,
-0.0469239503,
-0.0260273218,
-0.0762768313,
0.0794993788,
0.0053170025,
-0.0244612191,
0.0000145977,
0.0179996919,
-0.0300701205,
0.0216801204,
0.0366470143,
-0.0125451591,
-0.0981159508,
-0.0398762375,
0.0591899529,
-0.03198101,
-0.0063951793,
-0.0065076398,
0.0041352003,
0.0177322384,
-0.0150996745,
-0.0238129776,
0.0002216963,
-0.0034148514,
-0.0249178074,
0.012560891,
0.0092866216,
-0.0382032357,
-0.0931248441,
-0.0137475468,
-0.0175760798,
-0.0001693213,
-0.0263401866,
-0.0641822889,
0.0413068868,
-0.0314792879,
-0.0049726153,
0.0417333841,
-0.0667604059,
-0.0797473043,
-0.0516579971,
0.0213270299,
0.0133313322,
0.0395451263,
0.0119327074,
-0.01101596,
0.0991171747,
0.0206977986,
0.0088254483,
0.0087842923,
0.0241892245,
-0.0153532345,
-0.0228715967,
0.0273709763,
-0.0473745801,
-0.0034552848,
0.0076503642,
0.0382855535,
-0.0029079902,
-0.0472334437,
0.0284803975,
0.0070093237,
0.0550805815,
0.0098789474,
0.0065196548,
-0.0376439467,
-0.0119142802,
-0.0054272027,
0.0033767773,
-0.0301321801,
-0.0202588551,
0.0439615101,
-0.0068982551,
-0.0007431697,
0.0034597276,
-0.0179057196,
0.0060106819,
-0.0038337153,
0.025886083,
0.0367240719,
-0.0298637655,
0.0706056207,
0.0095689083,
0.0124187246,
0.0095878933,
-0.0233368557,
0.0273722708,
-0.0078695407,
-0.0018178637,
0.0010180733,
0.0072489735,
-0.0562787987,
0.0484279878,
-0.0280709583,
0.0155682201,
-0.056024421,
0.0637534708,
0.0343280137,
0.0232263915,
0.0753709227,
-0.0142246569,
0.0004823728,
-0.0293327235,
0.0385276675,
-0.013127923,
-0.0527225174,
0.0981396809,
0.0057942318,
0.0000484099,
-0.013484383,
0.0652506575,
0.0375578366,
0.0130008338,
-0.0158917345,
-0.0262369961,
-0.0302594546,
0.0013604965,
-0.0148230176,
-0.0209365766,
-0.0231419522,
0.0051798802,
-0.0156011153,
-0.0522243008,
0.0747618824,
0.0221909937,
-0.0171750542,
-0.0098175444,
0.0398340225,
0.0340234227,
0.0332444794,
-0.0660328269,
-0.0285036601,
0.0433518402,
0.0208320301,
-0.0204535872,
-0.0082503017,
-6.435780878e-33,
-0.0298128463,
-0.0445123576,
0.0024062342,
0.0296637658,
-0.0012303328,
0.0102141108,
-0.0961572453,
-0.0032297338,
-0.002905827,
0.0522533804,
0.011813188,
0.0011167267,
0.0093734488,
-0.008408146,
-0.0212673806,
0.0016051712,
0.0230950508,
0.00115552,
-0.0107240295,
0.0459288284,
0.0376079418,
0.0557473265,
0.0638244674,
-0.0308425687,
0.0152105121,
0.025163278,
0.0308883283,
-0.0131354528,
-0.0011225997,
0.0321832187,
-0.0610032305,
0.0528369024,
-0.0078976033,
0.0063231783,
-0.0343303308,
0.0333638005,
-0.0622216947,
0.0157328919,
-0.0107568512,
0.0102536138,
-0.0502591841,
-0.03883918,
0.0488215238,
-0.0030580855,
-0.0540919639,
-0.0365376696,
0.0336945318,
-0.0034825935,
-0.0332608409,
0.0466345437,
-0.0416902155,
0.0176598169,
0.0260337312,
-0.0013716345,
0.0301924497,
0.0161306188,
0.0344043337,
0.0211726762,
-0.0234163254,
0.0600599349,
-0.0560019203,
0.021956414,
0.0591571853,
0.0314626358,
0.0233927276,
0.0537467785,
0.0319810323,
-0.0349679403,
0.0140168192,
0.0263662543,
-0.0039594956,
0.0240378194,
0.0148309683,
0.027432533,
-0.0069963285,
0.0124209775,
-0.1061361656,
0.0084285568,
-0.0787548423,
0.012552307,
-0.0108483173,
0.063155964,
0.0304394867,
-0.0370993055,
-0.0089031775,
-0.0401953422,
-0.0126245683,
-0.0315664895,
-0.0318573937,
-0.0254154447,
-0.0405080281,
0.0033824088,
0.0136586288,
-0.041356694,
-0.0337788388,
0.0569883958,
-0.0260760132,
0.0516572222,
-0.0107483836,
0.0247187838,
-0.0515588112,
-0.0372349583,
0.0475182869,
-0.0290589686,
0.0119887711,
-0.0160110295,
0.0166659839,
0.0313142501,
-0.0322481059,
-0.0231473073,
-0.0718054101,
-0.0258919578,
0.0239612367,
0.013162774,
0.0344070047,
0.0039333748,
-0.0222357865,
0.0432064049,
0.0045347107,
0.0308986418,
-0.0089320177,
-0.0150327347,
-0.0014454672,
0.0546736196,
-0.0986464918,
-0.0074201967,
-0.0788072944,
0.0257444512,
0.043842189,
-0.0887516439,
-0.0462334864,
0.0054415939,
2.808e-7,
0.0862963423,
0.0602735393,
0.0653227642,
-0.0309726968,
0.0122646969,
0.0192191564,
-0.0249528158,
0.0668321848,
-0.0416590869,
-0.0501701683,
0.0121433586,
0.01777808,
-0.0246850345,
-0.0043026404,
-0.0150629031,
0.0677314028,
-0.0669646189,
-0.0117096826,
-0.0457819998,
0.0464411154,
0.0131645184,
0.0788189694,
-0.0265775919,
-0.019797476,
0.0161124561,
-0.0542275906,
0.0959253758,
0.0079990989,
-0.0046169073,
-0.0117955944,
-0.0473318882,
-0.0330325924,
-0.0392845161,
0.0122466255,
-0.0061714514,
-0.0040045884,
0.0227260012,
0.026009554,
-0.0357285812,
-0.0383062027,
0.0573247783,
0.0286170859,
-0.0082097212,
-0.0040457686,
0.0304811709,
-0.0316580012,
-0.0643167943,
-0.0071734986,
-0.0018523367,
0.0134463701,
0.0143754371,
-0.0170529801,
-0.0091290306,
0.021270331,
0.0063980371,
-0.0053338869,
0.0150612546,
-0.0155012719,
-0.0063828393,
0.0101199942,
-0.012780535,
0.008428013,
-0.0723694116,
-0.0230314843,
0.0208287872,
0.0070652394,
0.0010963379,
2.341870126e-34,
0.0291098207,
-0.0333300866,
-0.0255576577,
-0.0382997729,
0.05287081,
-0.0401572697,
-0.0175372958,
0.011890091,
-0.0147367101,
-0.11988765,
-0.0403739437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12794v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12794v2 | Are Structural Concepts Universal in Transformer Language Models? Towards Interpretable Cross-Lingual Generalization | 2023-10-19T14:50:51 | 2023-12-22T15:00:26 | Ningyu Xu, Qi Zhang, Jingting Ye, Menghan Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited considerable cross-lingual
generalization abilities, whereby they implicitly transfer knowledge across
languages. However, the transfer is not equally successful for all languages,
especially for low-resource ones, which poses an ongoing challenge. It is
unclear whether we have reached the limits of implicit cross-lingual
generalization and if explicit knowledge transfer is viable. In this paper, we
investigate the potential for explicitly aligning conceptual correspondence
between languages to enhance cross-lingual generalization. Using the syntactic
aspect of language as a testbed, our analyses of 43 languages reveal a high
degree of alignability among the spaces of structural concepts within each
language for both encoder-only and decoder-only LLMs. We then propose a
meta-learning-based method to learn to align conceptual spaces of different
languages, which facilitates zero-shot and few-shot generalization in concept
classification and also offers insights into the cross-lingual in-context
learning phenomenon. Experiments on syntactic analysis tasks show that our
approach achieves competitive results with state-of-the-art methods and narrows
the performance gap between languages, particularly benefiting those with
limited resources. | [
0.0210501105,
0.0245313514,
-0.033834409,
0.0658087432,
-0.0197255164,
0.0329116955,
-0.0204693526,
-0.0254310742,
-0.0810332671,
-0.0304736178,
-0.0772114322,
-0.0459519252,
0.0245256964,
0.0203837398,
0.0155514283,
-0.0611118749,
0.029116882,
-0.0224653836,
-0.0238442626,
-0.0088195922,
-0.0064198584,
0.0008738606,
0.0275121201,
0.0188644342,
0.0284550469,
-0.009997542,
0.0004224478,
-0.0226678029,
0.0331865922,
0.0015179986,
-0.0216412488,
0.0203306209,
0.0258538276,
0.0659599379,
0.0000019861,
-0.0547537804,
-0.0174926985,
-0.0143240299,
0.0022909362,
-0.0083147017,
0.0021450405,
-0.1319741905,
-0.0022651169,
-0.0198654067,
-0.0141329672,
-0.0742659867,
0.0970596001,
0.0180848688,
0.0175185762,
0.0307165999,
-0.0267754793,
-0.0543317012,
0.0236844048,
-0.0327327289,
0.0197257604,
-0.026614774,
0.0216094013,
0.0276144389,
-0.0460240319,
-0.0054591931,
-0.0607984886,
0.0452252589,
0.0060786321,
0.0148045206,
0.0057286066,
0.023079766,
-0.0292053521,
-0.024061773,
0.0041516968,
0.0577752776,
-0.0286147129,
-0.0274752453,
-0.036964044,
-0.0050918348,
-0.0136139765,
0.0336050503,
-0.0700710863,
0.0424559377,
0.0023653975,
0.0280105695,
0.0279120635,
0.0143531365,
0.0306183249,
-0.0213889387,
-0.0613064691,
0.0314681865,
0.0221331846,
-0.0136043103,
-0.0007422033,
0.0353386514,
-0.0264974292,
-0.0169149619,
-0.0367335193,
0.003918888,
0.021659201,
0.0241025779,
-0.0242012963,
-0.0229601841,
-0.0076591037,
-0.0359162465,
0.0588793121,
0.0406556129,
-0.0083036479,
0.0504670404,
-0.0380264446,
0.0729458034,
-0.0376281179,
0.024801882,
-0.0499413349,
-0.0552937575,
-0.0672778189,
-0.0265520476,
-0.0358935818,
0.0251390096,
0.0110961385,
-0.0053375638,
-0.0480842777,
0.0266285855,
-0.0074954596,
0.0067660208,
0.0207851566,
-0.0551977679,
-0.0292081218,
-0.0153593989,
0.0037766295,
0.0485970452,
0.0078917947,
-0.0149471974,
-0.043818146,
-0.0522778369,
0.0106413225,
0.0156541821,
-0.0178113915,
-0.0558436476,
-0.0033830155,
0.0546699129,
-0.0154044339,
-0.0151849687,
-0.0150793986,
0.0278253332,
-0.0270786434,
-0.0480460003,
0.0034668199,
-0.0603194162,
0.0461085178,
0.0302682687,
0.0143544273,
-0.0137299551,
-0.0101919984,
-0.022990033,
-0.012256505,
0.0771727934,
0.0115946475,
0.0049052732,
0.0052564004,
-0.0274001677,
-0.0129598472,
0.0804521516,
0.0136057511,
-0.0106990924,
0.0125573296,
-0.0386720635,
-0.0364423878,
0.0446178056,
0.009162521,
0.0003900842,
-0.0523440726,
-0.0119763706,
0.0642099679,
0.010483481,
0.0191982836,
0.0205146503,
-0.0099983504,
0.0194368903,
0.0364297368,
0.0196753107,
-0.0003064887,
0.0432821624,
0.0753936991,
-0.0093683675,
-0.0293787494,
-0.0045062872,
-0.0263996907,
0.0372826755,
-0.0162267648,
0.0111450376,
-0.036179509,
0.0339113474,
-0.0463689715,
-0.0215359293,
-0.0109095834,
-0.0280810725,
-0.0153213562,
0.0065997699,
0.0946349278,
0.0333706513,
0.013436324,
0.0695977286,
0.0458664298,
-0.0368909538,
0.0257356819,
-0.007689096,
-0.0007513858,
0.0367118716,
-0.016591927,
-0.0012008734,
-0.0175181851,
-0.0105397077,
0.013985591,
0.0550792031,
0.0299602859,
-0.0243856274,
0.0179815479,
-0.0587569177,
-0.0240921564,
-0.0273912083,
0.0046557062,
0.030062316,
-0.0415081382,
0.009884919,
0.0053940299,
-0.0744703636,
0.0289771613,
0.0215476695,
-0.061095465,
-0.0000107548,
-0.0107728131,
0.0355829746,
0.0211543664,
0.0021857696,
-0.001421854,
-0.0075269365,
0.0140185058,
-0.0808402449,
-0.0048361346,
0.0620157756,
-0.0463488996,
-0.038561713,
0.0204850174,
-0.0421410315,
-0.0113557922,
0.0140192797,
-0.0286891274,
-0.0377676897,
0.0275592022,
0.001616637,
0.085502401,
-0.0343030281,
0.0507520847,
-0.0408266932,
0.0302783381,
-0.0102008581,
0.0623889342,
0.00348678,
0.0305806361,
0.0052898363,
-0.0453248583,
0.0553348325,
0.0174496099,
-0.0419514924,
0.0510349087,
-0.0160913058,
-0.0077613629,
0.056145601,
-0.017432224,
-0.0039646002,
-0.005960044,
-0.0700989366,
-0.0138003826,
-0.0086240629,
0.0193540566,
0.0556830652,
0.0338035263,
0.0288583599,
-0.0064788475,
-0.0214571413,
0.0162274465,
-0.0113522792,
0.0282722041,
0.0402570516,
0.0175861139,
-0.0430776589,
-0.0006139282,
-0.0212566312,
0.0067786435,
0.0981323421,
-0.032137394,
-0.0289846398,
-0.0383028053,
0.0273908209,
-0.0141240954,
0.00495417,
-0.0285832491,
-0.0403425656,
-0.0169447083,
-0.0188243054,
0.0023974951,
0.007238559,
-0.0265306681,
-0.000939212,
0.0813566372,
0.0128815603,
-0.0676637143,
-0.0322161615,
0.0116016679,
-0.0282887965,
-0.0575993769,
-0.0279975981,
-0.0033373663,
0.1199163795,
-0.0129367467,
0.0026327139,
-0.0915632397,
-0.0032075057,
-0.0330265686,
-0.0128347557,
-0.0416023508,
0.0199002083,
0.0108439298,
0.0343573093,
-0.0374531448,
-0.0262487866,
0.0605956241,
-0.0061096614,
-0.0218161885,
-0.0028338993,
-0.0093940021,
-0.0622018017,
0.0875464603,
0.0068883835,
0.0301564168,
0.0510266945,
-0.0427686721,
-0.0801849067,
-0.0176925063,
0.0449599586,
0.0167267416,
0.0620547831,
-0.0416403487,
0.0302300956,
-0.0276593063,
-0.0414133184,
-0.0337493531,
0.0212375969,
-0.0210573822,
0.0230631866,
0.0036295489,
0.0025372033,
-0.051010862,
0.0122651039,
0.024789758,
-0.0036585343,
0.0167882927,
-0.0020535435,
-0.0112919379,
0.0312527344,
0.0224770196,
-0.0335109606,
-0.0332934149,
-0.0295324344,
0.0172397289,
0.0136282295,
-0.0162120275,
0.0017382238,
-0.0145202195,
-0.0030657235,
0.0578973256,
-0.0185315814,
-0.0458706394,
-0.0337347575,
0.0091366619,
-0.0140642496,
-0.0206499416,
0.1037401706,
0.0342172645,
-0.0337596275,
0.0118820919,
-0.0448307917,
0.0089341663,
0.0404215306,
0.0088784164,
-0.0681054443,
-0.0303031486,
-0.011780574,
-0.0492650233,
0.0265785791,
-0.0126288729,
-0.0029015043,
-0.1306513995,
-0.022297347,
0.009436965,
-0.090711154,
-0.0662573799,
-0.0106818685,
0.0021514024,
-0.0485019311,
0.0171442144,
-0.0101429857,
-0.0144576253,
-0.0023206794,
0.0062913159,
0.0015051843,
-0.0583628193,
0.0173038747,
-0.0233376138,
0.0106935306,
0.0338914581,
0.0351271518,
-0.0304504912,
-0.0309673492,
0.0591340736,
-0.0308954287,
-0.0071792719,
0.0062664761,
0.0324225985,
0.0075069261,
-0.0271265525,
0.0321135074,
0.0102126412,
-0.055442363,
-0.0306869447,
-0.0131030772,
0.0961066559,
0.0269823205,
-0.0222330019,
0.0225449502,
-0.0318971016,
-0.0049217576,
0.0680436194,
0.0128241172,
-0.0347928368,
-0.0214806106,
-0.0229443815,
-0.0146474792,
0.009867589,
-0.0149245001,
0.0341656916,
0.0027842433,
-0.0220645443,
-0.0318566486,
-0.0269286949,
0.0265523493,
-0.0110298321,
0.0287245829,
0.0251337886,
-0.004444425,
-0.0199395362,
-0.0509520434,
0.0079886764,
-0.0292948075,
0.0150781106,
-0.0223781466,
-0.0208417717,
0.0478710905,
-0.0470494144,
-0.0097088218,
-0.0313772745,
-0.0297069363,
-0.0660489649,
-0.0044239424,
0.041398298,
0.0149063896,
0.0544159971,
0.027809089,
-0.0208981037,
0.0605731681,
0.014258015,
-0.0233009849,
0.0056789224,
0.0524541326,
0.0138689047,
0.000812969,
0.0602669418,
-0.0604144596,
0.0191401746,
0.022651555,
0.0267396085,
-0.036412321,
0.0146835372,
0.056571655,
0.0007717989,
0.0399075523,
-0.0328216441,
-0.0162873305,
-0.0261234846,
0.0090868575,
-0.0218790285,
-0.0253384616,
-0.0427000374,
-0.0294317901,
0.0696916282,
0.0029718003,
0.0238938034,
0.0225806721,
-0.012462805,
-0.0026864286,
0.0137526644,
0.0255810376,
0.0201731939,
0.0441889875,
0.0336954035,
0.0388117172,
-0.00193744,
0.0018152131,
0.010963751,
0.0126470122,
-0.043753475,
0.0213108491,
0.0075210403,
0.0285713002,
-0.0220031589,
0.0119532654,
-0.0231634881,
-0.0242252145,
0.0073843882,
-0.0185982157,
0.069969818,
-0.0094323307,
0.0601287782,
-0.027848145,
-0.017175395,
-0.002399365,
0.0581952482,
-0.0199460015,
-0.0310020912,
0.0468847342,
0.0084995748,
-0.0144326389,
-0.0111721782,
0.0896579251,
-0.0272183213,
0.0244708583,
-0.0043649692,
0.0103637166,
-0.0285594929,
0.0010070187,
0.0311612953,
-0.0140252076,
-0.0289085787,
0.0207094159,
-0.0536453202,
-0.0688785613,
0.0066522579,
-0.013905922,
-0.0160805304,
0.0050206468,
0.0244850796,
0.0587671287,
0.0057283686,
0.0008395807,
-0.0316908285,
-0.0073820236,
0.0128999008,
0.0110214287,
-0.0175451096,
-5.858459602e-33,
-0.0306174494,
0.0197476298,
-0.0006710052,
0.0151415886,
-0.0070628906,
-0.0020360406,
-0.0323790796,
0.0019608638,
-0.0327880792,
0.0074556898,
0.0277271923,
-0.0122157102,
0.0107551226,
0.0339960977,
0.0510429889,
-0.0043446324,
0.0438291356,
0.0153800938,
-0.0025625785,
0.0003470832,
0.058604151,
0.0464911163,
0.0965986773,
-0.0286410172,
0.0164994448,
0.0186073128,
0.0137682818,
0.0316000953,
0.0514602065,
0.0517797768,
-0.0038878969,
0.0391113758,
0.0352032371,
-0.0239170361,
-0.0183630325,
-0.0072166892,
-0.0788807273,
-0.0309408754,
0.0419512279,
0.0501226746,
0.0058907354,
-0.0558269508,
0.0198384393,
-0.04706157,
0.016908152,
-0.033090584,
0.0416095443,
-0.0342523456,
-0.0161737334,
-0.0117161218,
-0.1050491631,
0.0033265646,
-0.0152614713,
0.0084690629,
0.0581420437,
0.0495062247,
0.0145798214,
0.0304478686,
-0.0501919016,
0.039737232,
-0.0354973786,
0.032836847,
0.1016133204,
0.0280337613,
0.0298187993,
0.0394503996,
0.0254465248,
-0.0338578895,
0.0283655878,
0.008752672,
0.0330741592,
0.014575609,
-0.0126691703,
0.0974343047,
0.0704959482,
0.0132512832,
-0.0682432726,
-0.0091410335,
-0.0057790857,
0.0512781478,
0.0089799277,
0.0285463966,
-0.0119588226,
-0.0291394368,
-0.0503931828,
-0.0435522571,
-0.0357139632,
-0.0412504375,
0.0137958257,
-0.0226026084,
-0.0053058169,
-0.0057588583,
0.0678771138,
-0.069423832,
-0.0231459253,
0.0348242633,
-0.014522762,
0.0396894626,
0.0085778898,
0.0254181195,
-0.0783841237,
-0.0749452859,
-0.008194902,
0.0151883131,
0.0280428622,
0.0386935361,
0.0795878693,
0.0078518894,
-0.0443908237,
0.0012695305,
-0.0515806191,
-0.0435943156,
-0.0399559252,
0.0265830196,
0.0137480749,
0.0377485976,
-0.0396322832,
0.021514358,
0.0208075214,
-0.0221734382,
0.0066709882,
-0.0065283626,
-0.00339861,
0.0261536855,
-0.0073571932,
-0.0162291341,
-0.0346313491,
-0.0124764694,
0.1041058451,
-0.0179703087,
-0.0073758201,
0.0165554062,
2.72e-7,
0.0625168905,
-0.0026527257,
0.0036179556,
-0.0008789577,
0.0159857925,
0.0285158195,
-0.0369168594,
0.031584207,
-0.0017710689,
-0.0210067797,
0.0108724628,
0.0161877144,
0.03168891,
0.0274743401,
-0.0772115663,
0.0391757861,
-0.0172210075,
-0.0174468756,
-0.0039368449,
0.0272045154,
0.0032460613,
0.1096849814,
-0.0076008579,
0.0031545744,
-0.0240878761,
-0.0315353014,
0.1047137231,
-0.0681930706,
0.0019569241,
0.0375083275,
-0.0642824471,
0.0222749468,
-0.0260746423,
0.0203705728,
-0.0171721913,
0.03589065,
0.0379498899,
0.0308208726,
-0.0098799393,
0.0121169388,
-0.0050597428,
-0.0040007667,
-0.0248295572,
-0.0676014349,
0.0576182008,
-0.1051960438,
-0.052213762,
0.0049550175,
-0.01179347,
0.0384978615,
0.0216756687,
-0.0059827846,
-0.0061513907,
0.0175462402,
0.0511931032,
-0.0017780692,
-0.0495531596,
-0.0323696211,
-0.0270796772,
0.0360858142,
-0.0095536457,
-0.0221651476,
0.0115484102,
-0.0536713228,
0.0355167538,
-0.0351627208,
0.029140003,
2.180299345e-34,
0.0091994228,
-0.0031992034,
0.026136959,
-0.0094070984,
-0.0165516064,
-0.0682525486,
-0.0334448181,
0.0509214923,
0.0077688075,
-0.050391037,
0.0167233273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12778v1 | Label-Aware Automatic Verbalizer for Few-Shot Text Classification | 2023-10-19T14:30:07 | 2023-10-19T14:30:07 | Thanakorn Thaminkaew, Piyawat Lertvittayakumjorn, Peerapon Vateekul | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Prompt-based learning has shown its effectiveness in few-shot text
classification. One important factor in its success is a verbalizer, which
translates output from a language model into a predicted class. Notably, the
simplest and widely acknowledged verbalizer employs manual labels to represent
the classes. However, manual selection does not guarantee the optimality of the
selected words when conditioned on the chosen language model. Therefore, we
propose Label-Aware Automatic Verbalizer (LAAV), effectively augmenting the
manual labels to achieve better few-shot classification results. Specifically,
we use the manual labels along with the conjunction "and" to induce the model
to generate more effective words for the verbalizer. The experimental results
on five datasets across five languages demonstrate that LAAV significantly
outperforms existing verbalizers. Furthermore, our analysis reveals that LAAV
suggests more relevant words compared to similar approaches, especially in
mid-to-low resource languages. | [
0.023377372,
0.0237506796,
0.0066418331,
0.0107881082,
-0.01534996,
0.0273689404,
0.067725338,
0.016776748,
0.003273424,
-0.1044060886,
-0.0262684636,
0.0107789868,
-0.0138731105,
-0.0244588535,
0.0253600385,
-0.0513137467,
0.0538424402,
-0.0176012125,
0.0402727164,
0.0103134243,
0.0100696795,
0.0257245507,
-0.0016808495,
0.0321350731,
0.0177682806,
0.0196464956,
-0.0021197721,
0.0002274362,
-0.0218590163,
-0.0210443437,
0.0135068996,
0.086271055,
-0.0095612761,
0.0110607957,
0.0000018256,
-0.0695588887,
0.0091568353,
-0.0048902729,
-0.0183817632,
-0.015625909,
0.0729316026,
-0.0198521223,
0.0088890335,
0.0189555287,
0.0000603206,
-0.064555116,
0.0322804749,
0.0338623561,
0.0199474469,
0.0371167473,
-0.0112034194,
-0.0413353369,
-0.0030898829,
-0.005282905,
0.0231801551,
-0.0403017737,
0.0263309628,
-0.0563011654,
-0.0018817448,
0.0541239716,
-0.0219494961,
0.0308481771,
-0.0307061523,
-0.0068431208,
0.0550548248,
0.016634617,
-0.028915586,
-0.0515612625,
0.006440795,
0.0392971486,
0.0077919974,
-0.032767877,
-0.0003572944,
-0.0168861765,
0.0059364894,
-0.0183343962,
-0.0160766784,
0.013516481,
-0.0239880718,
0.0018188469,
0.0159204658,
0.0411694124,
0.0005470222,
0.0273753088,
0.0092181172,
0.0213376302,
0.0148077141,
-0.0051142522,
0.0137707759,
0.0242494959,
-0.0281278901,
-0.0723341629,
-0.0300917756,
0.0312732533,
-0.0359336659,
0.0040758052,
-0.0542199872,
-0.0513264723,
0.0491684675,
-0.0112417154,
0.0364747755,
0.0154811293,
-0.0265946686,
0.0384889618,
-0.0456211418,
0.0225201473,
0.0732641816,
0.0477049612,
-0.0339482129,
-0.0068198657,
-0.0726501644,
-0.0179936402,
-0.0552650243,
0.0378505588,
0.0211644135,
0.0051522371,
-0.0555447973,
0.0100547709,
0.0077275666,
-0.0000860604,
-0.0345285907,
-0.0130383642,
-0.0049176682,
0.0156768989,
-0.0220340919,
0.0063902945,
-0.0464820862,
0.0267096646,
-0.0016952967,
-0.0314255431,
0.0057499567,
0.0175745767,
0.0264012758,
-0.0137824211,
-0.0005249201,
0.0257127155,
-0.0578632839,
-0.0916772708,
-0.0239240527,
-0.0060697976,
-0.0337244496,
-0.0212482661,
-0.0631892607,
-0.0453314334,
0.0126057994,
0.0146882702,
-0.0087168394,
-0.0132778985,
0.0195429418,
0.0333501175,
-0.0148573527,
0.0979930684,
-0.0141684655,
-0.0314148255,
0.0741592348,
-0.0123265693,
0.0198579673,
0.0422558151,
-0.004114667,
0.0209045131,
0.0509569347,
0.0062951655,
0.0514831245,
0.0278577972,
0.0056620799,
-0.0066000056,
-0.0465974882,
-0.014410561,
0.0441536382,
-0.0098411851,
0.0146953268,
0.0337688439,
-0.0132396892,
0.0378204882,
0.0277300086,
0.0334285982,
0.0247850157,
-0.0037192707,
0.0657816976,
0.027637152,
-0.0068211108,
-0.0092978124,
0.0028542897,
0.002961122,
-0.0629707351,
-0.0081275906,
0.0350255556,
-0.0040275636,
-0.043499209,
-0.0689303875,
-0.0153813343,
-0.0210230015,
0.0124018844,
0.0040871133,
0.0637738928,
0.0444635525,
-0.0134193124,
0.0389934815,
0.065582417,
-0.0277924649,
-0.0015480691,
-0.0451897047,
0.0353159122,
0.027532123,
0.0103803072,
-0.0318277478,
0.0182803851,
-0.0535919406,
0.0349132456,
0.0358047858,
0.0863844082,
-0.0261905547,
-0.0002225052,
-0.0353178941,
-0.0124676311,
-0.0021305417,
0.0305124093,
0.0031911652,
-0.0237722173,
0.0451584384,
0.0182879958,
0.0423875935,
-0.0441070609,
0.0384896994,
0.0072786119,
-0.062942192,
0.0754691437,
0.0296211392,
-0.0168830603,
0.0039871451,
0.0052635362,
-0.0074225869,
-0.0128347324,
-0.0150863463,
-0.0033987009,
-0.0254840106,
-0.0071948408,
-0.073752366,
-0.0090748863,
0.08166866,
0.018799508,
-0.0514104404,
-0.0494183674,
-0.0538953505,
-0.0208342485,
-0.010045493,
-0.0286009666,
-0.0530823544,
0.0393601842,
-0.0120938094,
0.0139635121,
-0.0739909708,
0.0506293178,
0.056008283,
0.0428891815,
0.0061847372,
0.0212114062,
0.0458997935,
-0.0124988584,
-0.0458339565,
0.0071432479,
-0.0068476843,
0.010470558,
0.053856533,
0.009104969,
-0.0170842521,
-0.0094283121,
-0.0832307711,
-0.0052975439,
-0.0172179248,
-0.0117354123,
-0.0140824718,
-0.0113061368,
0.0011539488,
-0.0274332706,
-0.0346339121,
0.0098401643,
-0.0116612613,
0.0149101932,
0.0633399934,
0.0165920686,
-0.0327507593,
-0.0043697087,
0.016515851,
-0.0033383681,
0.0449436717,
0.0478622541,
-0.0747885406,
-0.0539545491,
0.0203153566,
-0.0091609899,
-0.0057389964,
0.0164005831,
-0.0348295979,
-0.0137171084,
-0.0329185277,
-0.0338062868,
0.0396314561,
0.0292045698,
0.0175680127,
0.0380994081,
0.0332902037,
-0.0224178508,
0.0114553235,
-0.0219816938,
-0.0318051316,
-0.0054767723,
-0.0272277948,
0.0018305414,
0.0573870018,
0.0294457041,
0.0091322949,
-0.0632877648,
0.00972775,
-0.0215210598,
0.0014067218,
-0.0893039405,
0.0304447692,
-0.0066123428,
0.0340624712,
0.0173242968,
-0.0379588753,
0.0681908801,
-0.0121249193,
-0.0035968404,
-0.042831108,
-0.0398695059,
-0.0413840599,
0.0214445535,
0.006026973,
0.0074923155,
0.0463515781,
-0.0364365652,
-0.0410928987,
-0.0464552045,
0.0293935295,
-0.0013336203,
0.0086396765,
-0.0263312533,
0.0052093957,
-0.0152784446,
-0.0594354793,
-0.0263382159,
-0.0883472636,
-0.0470020771,
0.0309560262,
-0.0211301353,
0.0214770548,
-0.0316622928,
0.0091507575,
0.0393315405,
0.0585117005,
-0.0331689194,
-0.0199503954,
-0.0188617371,
0.0532090962,
0.0297434237,
-0.0226380527,
-0.0467342921,
-0.003670926,
0.0727679133,
0.0137054333,
-0.0130402213,
0.0316426679,
-0.0060639163,
-0.0072909864,
0.0251606572,
-0.0294327736,
-0.0492436625,
0.0185034703,
0.0346495658,
-0.0392189398,
-0.011391365,
0.1060011238,
0.0306548905,
-0.0577991568,
-0.0285763964,
-0.0024229614,
0.0139384698,
0.0373450294,
0.0584239587,
-0.0598545745,
-0.0692618042,
-0.0046629449,
0.0302026607,
-0.0211019088,
0.0136856623,
-0.0236789864,
-0.1070590913,
0.0199081693,
0.0019364,
-0.0506694242,
0.0257538725,
-0.0387688875,
0.0087961406,
-0.0125027923,
-0.021719208,
-0.0223563034,
-0.0069993446,
-0.0050996938,
0.0154509172,
-0.0390964411,
-0.0292741265,
0.0332673788,
-0.0040952959,
0.0226342399,
0.0501957573,
0.014317207,
-0.0328080952,
-0.0004798769,
0.0396806002,
-0.046312768,
0.0031741112,
-0.0178547595,
0.0567289405,
-0.0093504395,
-0.0086663524,
0.0066244928,
0.006791078,
0.0261249337,
-0.0296846312,
0.0151672382,
0.035884846,
0.0043751691,
0.0042584087,
-0.0059193778,
-0.0012788122,
0.0100271823,
0.0635924935,
0.0238360111,
-0.0792283341,
-0.0428574272,
-0.0400247835,
-0.0278074741,
-0.067985177,
-0.0277951751,
0.0056781694,
-0.039865315,
-0.0879202932,
-0.0649584681,
-0.0622376017,
0.0525724553,
0.0222822148,
-0.0082811872,
0.0268524196,
-0.0464184135,
0.0150299361,
0.0011996747,
-0.007629164,
0.0093066292,
0.0184755903,
-0.0700488612,
-0.0302938353,
0.0653322339,
-0.0699985251,
-0.0164909456,
-0.0194314159,
-0.0480889492,
-0.0321575664,
-0.0299279653,
0.0337646976,
0.0076937708,
0.0412826166,
-0.022170512,
-0.1013126746,
0.0734138414,
0.1292913556,
-0.0173277836,
0.0244655944,
0.0314376354,
0.0623474531,
-0.0464373678,
0.030316351,
-0.0314622074,
0.0279571861,
0.0115874475,
-0.0257764254,
-0.0610823035,
-0.0059733829,
0.0087429797,
0.0127002122,
0.0783421472,
-0.0578661263,
-0.0353113487,
-0.0150550324,
0.004438852,
0.0042000692,
-0.0481459275,
-0.0225017611,
0.0124093909,
0.0014715253,
-0.0628990009,
-0.0211899951,
-0.0444347747,
-0.0412303694,
0.0477736853,
-0.0320119746,
-0.02200922,
0.0140090287,
0.0432992987,
0.0126862423,
0.0220109709,
-0.0296360701,
0.0174570177,
0.0290694684,
0.025767874,
-0.0529784188,
0.0706807002,
0.0087229358,
0.009533098,
-0.0320212729,
-0.0049705859,
-0.0326441042,
0.0041809231,
-0.0324031338,
0.0159009825,
0.0253217872,
-0.0002484935,
-0.0030632226,
-0.0033811713,
-0.0361703858,
-0.0217482224,
0.0531199314,
0.0099820634,
-0.0585940927,
0.0300971549,
0.0022665898,
-0.0336899534,
-0.0045832605,
0.0654264912,
0.0243598986,
-0.0097644292,
0.012708379,
0.0124043608,
-0.0570634864,
0.0465883613,
0.0701316148,
0.0287552346,
0.0033258237,
0.0217667483,
-0.0476424731,
-0.0120232431,
0.0447017476,
-0.0528490245,
-0.0296540521,
-0.0073425085,
0.0297618452,
0.0385742895,
0.0001054515,
-0.0036917038,
-0.0730638131,
0.0079797804,
0.0385103002,
0.0062061064,
-0.0117167393,
-5.707450455e-33,
-0.0396305546,
-0.0252868515,
0.001227965,
0.0141157154,
0.0607137904,
-0.0047274437,
-0.0195256732,
0.0027733061,
0.0211449731,
0.0433272794,
-0.0040185298,
-0.0216806643,
0.0155204702,
0.0427988805,
0.0481857844,
-0.0344286747,
0.0345522836,
0.0012083797,
-0.0270197242,
0.0248898305,
0.0361383446,
0.040237952,
0.0255296938,
-0.0289679896,
0.0287133232,
0.0127754891,
-0.0375735871,
-0.0059155617,
0.0418144502,
0.0534225665,
-0.0074169314,
0.0649866685,
0.0210449826,
-0.016464984,
0.0069344849,
0.0675099716,
-0.0816447139,
-0.0417284667,
-0.0274279583,
0.0261070523,
-0.0021439104,
-0.0541563034,
-0.0233038217,
-0.0355682597,
0.0011725799,
-0.005590592,
0.0591115505,
-0.0345660411,
-0.0618424155,
-0.0460144915,
-0.0319302045,
0.0253587384,
0.0018722197,
-0.0195074063,
0.0384385176,
0.0780971497,
-0.0004929418,
0.0582876578,
-0.0664671138,
0.018432755,
0.0123105552,
0.0127716595,
0.0120643293,
0.0389414653,
-0.0492734089,
0.0579216331,
0.0432866961,
-0.0017682392,
-0.0069680647,
0.0177754536,
0.0005199327,
0.0081196036,
0.0376671255,
0.0654527619,
0.0446373112,
-0.029251039,
-0.0562801436,
0.0114851035,
0.0365466513,
-0.0070519974,
0.0238855463,
-0.0143716801,
-0.0657050163,
-0.0526014157,
-0.0246021021,
-0.0517373644,
-0.0631457567,
0.0116517749,
0.0188013017,
0.0419310331,
-0.0157616027,
0.0064762183,
0.0462845564,
-0.0091395481,
-0.0479880497,
0.0026094157,
-0.031467706,
0.045469366,
-0.0133795012,
-0.0263284519,
-0.0377747826,
-0.0420037247,
0.0102660088,
0.003255123,
0.0154890101,
0.0307765715,
0.0769604966,
0.005422357,
-0.0829791427,
0.0065871882,
0.0122011555,
-0.0021494168,
0.0151981991,
0.0160422511,
-0.0046064197,
0.0503256693,
-0.0169783905,
0.0964165926,
0.0192210451,
-0.0442147106,
0.0184855163,
-0.0152846249,
-0.027397437,
0.0124852927,
-0.0093000494,
0.0048096171,
0.0264655873,
0.0296816099,
0.0273292437,
-0.021502208,
0.0239263251,
0.002232498,
2.59e-7,
0.0450519286,
0.0527033396,
-0.0449671894,
0.0020261838,
-0.01018517,
0.0730975196,
0.0120562306,
0.0098235467,
-0.0180846248,
0.0133558298,
-0.0011541921,
-0.0078219175,
0.0425642096,
0.0200944021,
-0.0840778798,
0.0110143637,
-0.0319440439,
0.0151537666,
-0.0458294414,
0.0112554571,
0.0915556848,
0.092706047,
0.036245387,
-0.0075597344,
-0.0216490943,
-0.0412124395,
0.0460987613,
0.0075610937,
-0.0093689384,
0.033238668,
0.0454809554,
0.0015921557,
-0.0030783932,
0.0436033346,
-0.0568196587,
-0.0031317272,
-0.0053073904,
0.0502644107,
-0.0076731429,
-0.000108697,
0.0035496091,
0.0096590184,
0.0010450635,
-0.0227573924,
0.0909570456,
-0.0704857036,
0.0110043064,
0.0265811328,
-0.0025480709,
-0.0067987493,
0.0434627868,
-0.0224728398,
-0.0411059,
0.026544366,
0.0378836058,
0.0012085534,
-0.0338838734,
-0.1085678712,
-0.0147301191,
0.0041771247,
-0.0088671027,
-0.0000476848,
-0.0102581466,
-0.003227181,
0.0292571858,
-0.086084947,
0.0348443836,
2.169482961e-34,
0.0201956164,
-0.0055760015,
-0.0227742065,
0.0189212989,
0.0068636835,
-0.0080304705,
-0.0120067159,
0.0401407965,
0.05855795,
-0.0565186553,
-0.0021226138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12774v1 | Survival of the Most Influential Prompts: Efficient Black-Box Prompt Search via Clustering and Pruning | 2023-10-19T14:25:06 | 2023-10-19T14:25:06 | Han Zhou, Xingchen Wan, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Prompt-based learning has been an effective paradigm for large pretrained
language models (LLM), enabling few-shot or even zero-shot learning. Black-box
prompt search has received growing interest recently for its distinctive
properties of gradient-free optimization, proven particularly useful and
powerful for model-as-a-service usage. However, the discrete nature and the
complexity of combinatorial optimization hinder the efficiency of modern
black-box approaches. Despite extensive research on search algorithms, the
crucial aspect of search space design and optimization has been largely
overlooked. In this paper, we first conduct a sensitivity analysis by prompting
LLM, revealing that only a small number of tokens exert a disproportionate
amount of influence on LLM predictions. Leveraging this insight, we propose the
Clustering and Pruning for Efficient Black-box Prompt Search (ClaPS), a simple
black-box search method that first clusters and prunes the search space to
focus exclusively on influential prompt tokens. By employing even simple search
methods within the pruned search space, ClaPS achieves state-of-the-art
performance across various tasks and LLMs, surpassing the performance of
complex approaches while significantly reducing search costs. Our findings
underscore the critical role of search space design and optimization in
enhancing both the usefulness and the efficiency of black-box prompt-based
learning. | [
0.0442414731,
0.0245378073,
-0.0035924476,
0.0132241687,
-0.0306129456,
-0.0040667318,
0.0615453087,
0.0194041785,
0.0157746822,
-0.0208185483,
-0.0732379481,
-0.034513142,
-0.0084637264,
0.0277751181,
0.0232396983,
-0.0104799634,
0.0510187373,
-0.024714632,
0.0077804071,
-0.0180190019,
-0.014006936,
0.0186883975,
-0.0132327927,
0.055809103,
-0.0139075285,
-0.0120573612,
-0.0266328678,
0.0297978185,
-0.0263957642,
-0.0203658864,
0.0072319433,
0.0845636129,
0.0126780579,
0.0721297264,
0.000002235,
-0.0473548211,
-0.0493747368,
-0.0227663796,
-0.0979916006,
0.0229705963,
0.0243418943,
0.0361821055,
0.0077605122,
0.0404513925,
-0.0163913742,
-0.0314217992,
0.0589507818,
0.0041956385,
0.0320471786,
0.0947906747,
-0.002326821,
0.0193170458,
-0.0212620944,
-0.0465999059,
0.0098078605,
-0.0502301641,
0.0103665367,
-0.0832599401,
-0.0042363997,
0.0137741165,
-0.0250633061,
0.0574505962,
0.0120942453,
-0.0173383094,
-0.0016769124,
0.0393226966,
-0.0263871811,
-0.0337390341,
-0.0534886122,
0.0830809176,
-0.0357049629,
-0.019754041,
0.0057253786,
-0.0403084904,
-0.0113470955,
-0.0098007508,
-0.021648027,
0.0100874221,
0.0131811313,
-0.007609325,
-0.0326131806,
0.0162479766,
0.0311584137,
-0.0003088739,
-0.0183506571,
0.0726794899,
0.0176885836,
-0.0379480757,
0.015497948,
0.000450004,
-0.0121660354,
-0.0675996616,
0.0137328822,
0.0150600048,
-0.0745589882,
0.0165335406,
-0.0124399532,
-0.0323481336,
0.0077114664,
0.027398115,
0.076158464,
0.04159154,
-0.0425373763,
0.0657694563,
-0.0127277402,
0.0215232577,
-0.0058941068,
0.0241492484,
-0.0376058184,
0.0177328605,
0.0012247168,
-0.0348096006,
-0.0913813114,
0.0270267874,
-0.0424068905,
-0.0359128304,
-0.0082813427,
0.0192471296,
0.0180464871,
-0.0082353093,
0.0110751512,
0.0022817201,
0.0194192287,
-0.0169216432,
0.0086075151,
-0.008806522,
-0.034474954,
0.011194082,
0.0004998084,
-0.0547510087,
-0.0222065896,
0.0164618269,
0.0029440129,
-0.028828973,
0.0152300829,
0.0359599255,
-0.0103470441,
-0.0572744794,
-0.0247771051,
-0.0239308197,
-0.007844382,
-0.0151762376,
-0.0222947318,
-0.0338041373,
0.0320480131,
-0.0127075706,
0.0094344066,
-0.0195488483,
-0.0190390889,
0.0161002316,
-0.0020491439,
0.0581596047,
-0.0033172988,
0.0227953121,
0.0404977426,
-0.0193861183,
-0.0100570368,
0.0725019574,
-0.0120385,
0.0510157347,
0.06002919,
-0.006851458,
0.0154678738,
0.0544443317,
0.0454033241,
0.01957421,
0.0059139864,
0.029928511,
0.0438150801,
0.0390445031,
-0.0042607845,
0.0216510333,
-0.0267322566,
-0.0115194404,
0.0364680178,
0.0654287562,
-0.0263805725,
-0.020016484,
0.0563328154,
0.0124177048,
-0.013530585,
-0.0373856165,
-0.0380838625,
-0.0153946467,
-0.056170132,
-0.0355901681,
0.0430545732,
0.0265451521,
-0.0488420911,
-0.0294021536,
0.0251630768,
0.0067387023,
-0.028150348,
0.0480645746,
0.0257670172,
-0.0062082778,
-0.0824871734,
0.0706813782,
0.0161446966,
-0.035810668,
-0.009093211,
-0.0763793066,
0.0329699777,
0.0408164673,
0.0565372929,
-0.0330366716,
-0.0130695496,
0.0024397552,
0.0551153459,
0.0219665971,
0.017522838,
-0.0020042213,
0.0291702412,
-0.0593195297,
-0.0415882878,
0.0253965575,
0.0205666814,
0.0450976938,
0.0051848316,
0.0039085806,
0.0140723716,
0.002909824,
-0.0174285825,
0.0414084308,
0.0035269242,
-0.0480340533,
0.0259145126,
0.0382513478,
0.0433296785,
0.0022262766,
0.0069772638,
0.000398558,
0.0124418922,
-0.0188189466,
0.0016863891,
-0.0460624248,
-0.0684867576,
-0.0504341274,
-0.0047902325,
0.0341944583,
0.0135659436,
0.0368721336,
-0.0493561327,
-0.033978913,
-0.0226636846,
-0.0254385415,
0.0663549155,
-0.0213171635,
0.0340407379,
-0.0231893212,
0.0285708271,
-0.0449381657,
0.0195801519,
0.0158448759,
0.0026280144,
0.0234488025,
0.0338423289,
0.0199620575,
-0.0521318279,
-0.0408877879,
-0.0102892807,
-0.0216346383,
0.0038177422,
0.0319367275,
0.0174192209,
-0.0304227527,
0.0063539604,
-0.1255919188,
0.0095148422,
-0.048747398,
-0.0183344968,
0.0141764721,
0.0447269566,
-0.0366805419,
-0.0493588671,
0.0008440089,
-0.0228719525,
-0.004746242,
0.0294201896,
0.0037621893,
0.0320865288,
-0.0319736525,
-0.0420703143,
-0.0338737853,
0.006305574,
0.0535018593,
-0.0152910864,
-0.0017953622,
-0.0194252208,
0.0392302908,
-0.0078806747,
0.0221944619,
-0.0038143406,
-0.0206421316,
0.0016828295,
-0.0263465401,
0.0269140098,
0.0664087161,
0.0337120257,
0.003860177,
0.0235902481,
-0.00159159,
-0.0772772953,
0.0121036954,
-0.049898278,
-0.0609704144,
-0.0155042009,
-0.0105862096,
0.0834697932,
0.0711519793,
0.0074794325,
-0.0037935413,
-0.0868279487,
0.0111163957,
0.0055627292,
-0.0230002329,
-0.1052289605,
-0.0031134258,
-0.0306966957,
0.0619146377,
-0.011035529,
-0.0598199368,
0.0613609999,
-0.040294122,
-0.0058160503,
-0.0079977335,
-0.0062312265,
-0.0295594241,
0.023900833,
-0.0049212808,
0.0069307894,
0.0245768093,
-0.0398496427,
-0.0474598669,
0.0149430847,
0.0040851338,
-0.0239820462,
0.0073270053,
0.0166738965,
0.0074910829,
0.0117498534,
-0.0489457138,
-0.0246701669,
-0.0938946605,
-0.0222929213,
-0.0071796849,
0.0155423926,
0.0134478072,
-0.0198691506,
0.0137084089,
-0.0088859629,
0.0860982463,
-0.0242362339,
0.002208184,
-0.0250571463,
0.0128660705,
0.0315858349,
-0.0306593757,
0.0197769608,
-0.0348301493,
0.0206365138,
0.0060212831,
0.0564541332,
-0.0207562,
0.0138188601,
-0.0070201936,
0.0710780621,
-0.0314504132,
-0.031139018,
0.0269830376,
0.0362356491,
-0.034204185,
-0.014475856,
0.134148702,
0.0251191277,
-0.0829573274,
-0.0114963958,
-0.003788745,
0.0350157917,
-0.0007164536,
0.0507182851,
-0.0335915312,
-0.0435476415,
0.0160985719,
0.0476419441,
-0.0223415606,
-0.0302318875,
-0.0247072615,
-0.1308003813,
0.0280974954,
-0.013363312,
-0.02624874,
0.0149679147,
-0.0276286919,
0.0006015945,
-0.0225757323,
0.0160734151,
0.0262857005,
-0.0081744399,
-0.0120525565,
0.0173119754,
-0.0168887731,
-0.0285643004,
0.0329769962,
-0.0244271886,
0.0286029652,
0.0961849168,
-0.0177558139,
0.0240587611,
0.0029674249,
0.0477848351,
-0.0055865198,
-0.0059651462,
-0.0367984623,
0.0267484039,
-0.0379287563,
-0.0043498548,
0.0265686028,
0.0128012039,
-0.0243153293,
0.0125433244,
0.0303072464,
0.0601642095,
-0.013478254,
0.0020726842,
-0.007909392,
-0.0134827476,
0.0396094136,
0.098293595,
0.0299758073,
-0.0603809059,
-0.0186680704,
-0.0220681578,
0.0192479622,
-0.0222091693,
-0.0163768623,
-0.0129243275,
-0.0121892877,
0.0181934163,
-0.0369486287,
0.024143301,
0.0270352829,
0.0556150116,
-0.0099845091,
0.014851992,
-0.0223083701,
-0.0011364308,
-0.0113003226,
0.0282515641,
-0.0528556667,
0.015516324,
-0.1190268323,
-0.0086138602,
0.0280346815,
-0.0318869762,
-0.0319248959,
-0.0205914304,
-0.0714787394,
-0.0473075882,
-0.0018248514,
0.0465976261,
0.0180878583,
0.0480318815,
-0.0238596201,
-0.0677850619,
0.1091929302,
0.0576005355,
-0.0252723116,
0.0088208951,
0.0251891315,
-0.0082607856,
-0.0184031781,
0.0364969373,
-0.0607918613,
0.0108795715,
0.0560992882,
0.0166418403,
-0.0186014846,
-0.0056222277,
-0.0005456048,
0.0264421906,
0.0881014541,
-0.0460717864,
-0.0231152605,
-0.046030093,
0.0443780757,
0.0114930812,
0.0037393705,
-0.0499371029,
0.0185275599,
0.0005976378,
-0.0313845463,
0.0003399904,
0.0036316409,
-0.0143915974,
0.03947936,
-0.0404878184,
0.0118382182,
0.0164878387,
-0.0107880579,
0.0859633908,
-0.0117257461,
0.0121510271,
0.0512866639,
0.0084694335,
0.0174876209,
-0.034569338,
0.04491961,
0.0402824841,
0.0085018408,
-0.0292207021,
0.0706634596,
-0.043095462,
-0.0776021332,
-0.0364534296,
0.0234636776,
0.0313138887,
-0.0246419776,
-0.0258957911,
-0.0129760457,
-0.0042473469,
-0.0217447951,
-0.0105746351,
0.0301436447,
-0.0276565477,
0.0191429853,
0.035991542,
-0.0142816184,
0.0288433395,
0.0699874833,
-0.006873636,
0.0474871174,
-0.0040296977,
-0.0119524263,
-0.0405382216,
-0.0095416754,
0.025723353,
0.0282567032,
-0.0245414432,
0.020580085,
-0.0466737822,
-0.034369085,
-0.0012679182,
-0.0072037131,
-0.0505417809,
0.0046457178,
0.0712952316,
0.0756088644,
-0.0046271966,
0.0383527726,
-0.0334434435,
-0.0321997851,
-0.0215117261,
-0.0418388806,
0.0096975258,
-7.05123519e-33,
-0.0295311268,
-0.024082236,
0.0032834501,
-0.0359134302,
-0.0121012926,
0.0277976021,
-0.0170885436,
-0.0093643945,
-0.0013953593,
-0.0148649644,
-0.0560359769,
-0.0024475676,
0.0293660667,
0.0365127549,
0.0002479799,
-0.0028830187,
0.0560111217,
-0.0201281738,
-0.0642098412,
0.0301340111,
0.0201330315,
0.0549728945,
-0.0081474157,
0.0310566071,
-0.0171978623,
0.0000788541,
-0.0108705116,
0.0514060408,
-0.001165348,
0.0592846163,
0.0005236352,
0.0305923801,
-0.0088770138,
-0.0438068025,
-0.0169232637,
0.0506995507,
-0.0449861623,
-0.0275055487,
0.0067383721,
-0.0016392973,
-0.0302277729,
-0.0090421662,
-0.0107867951,
-0.0178805143,
-0.0066314293,
0.023286337,
0.0104939044,
-0.0058432198,
-0.0409510396,
-0.0187696181,
-0.0086630303,
0.0040714047,
-0.0094983447,
-0.0354272649,
0.0105367713,
0.0382056013,
0.0075866934,
0.0364983827,
-0.0258619078,
0.028389385,
0.0150274858,
0.0501645431,
0.0449405536,
0.0713742375,
0.0229755286,
0.0477100909,
0.0483690389,
-0.009263101,
-0.0064824517,
-0.0078082071,
0.0339488722,
-0.0085834851,
0.0138456561,
0.0174121205,
0.0191156026,
-0.0158760324,
-0.0489461236,
-0.0094241295,
0.0305619463,
-0.0176213998,
0.0531901829,
-0.0087097222,
-0.0174053814,
-0.0440589078,
-0.0469398201,
-0.0422528721,
-0.0347403772,
-0.0040276828,
0.0431862138,
0.0477707013,
-0.0289793219,
-0.0514056161,
0.0678825378,
-0.0012937264,
0.0277774353,
0.0139148673,
0.0045970418,
0.0022714951,
0.0217746403,
0.0318095237,
-0.064594835,
-0.0323450193,
0.0116093336,
-0.0386343896,
0.0007598625,
-0.0012667247,
-0.0014555838,
0.0410797894,
-0.0754911825,
0.0076065925,
-0.0054318639,
0.0368110947,
0.0025208187,
0.0058037983,
0.0372967348,
-0.0037997921,
0.0088822395,
0.0687176064,
0.0171408579,
-0.0257009882,
0.009187161,
-0.0119269649,
-0.0240010172,
0.0105690146,
-0.0476659797,
0.0076283268,
-0.010508013,
0.017308889,
0.0546012744,
-0.0295128934,
-0.015406305,
0.0009624595,
2.886e-7,
0.023091523,
0.0350321829,
-0.0204438493,
0.0151214441,
0.0090503115,
0.0444324128,
0.0100287516,
-0.0162857585,
-0.0020063412,
-0.0024656111,
0.0330266729,
0.0080751013,
0.0617995039,
-0.0231420416,
-0.1260925978,
-0.0072540254,
-0.0983762071,
0.054637894,
-0.0607906245,
-0.0226047449,
0.0132334745,
0.1120138243,
0.0130418101,
-0.0298504774,
-0.0368131325,
-0.0217667166,
0.03364053,
-0.0487453826,
0.0167803168,
0.0428164415,
0.0177283343,
-0.0048074899,
-0.0122745968,
0.0097118933,
-0.016712172,
0.0390124135,
-0.005667353,
0.0650273561,
0.0402714014,
-0.0505836792,
0.0223491192,
0.0222839694,
-0.0207552202,
-0.0554778017,
0.0908385962,
-0.0410981998,
0.0050376938,
-0.0470573492,
0.0039334544,
-0.0424161181,
0.0301517695,
-0.0527583584,
-0.0090826051,
0.03627453,
0.0124703581,
-0.0205327794,
0.0084191076,
-0.1078919396,
0.0048407526,
-0.0322608799,
-0.0254826304,
-0.0399719439,
-0.0523989983,
-0.0047499021,
-0.0045054979,
-0.0461492501,
0.0193046536,
2.964128851e-34,
0.0455238596,
-0.0393429808,
0.0321351625,
0.0382201895,
0.0052124984,
-0.001063053,
-0.0087381098,
0.0083062723,
0.0219070353,
-0.0788853541,
-0.0166000221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12766v1 | Transformer-based Entity Legal Form Classification | 2023-10-19T14:11:43 | 2023-10-19T14:11:43 | Alexander Arimond, Mauro Molteni, Dominik Jany, Zornitsa Manolova, Damian Borth, Andreas G. F. Hoepner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose the application of Transformer-based language models for
classifying entity legal forms from raw legal entity names. Specifically, we
employ various BERT variants and compare their performance against multiple
traditional baselines. Our evaluation encompasses a substantial subset of
freely available Legal Entity Identifier (LEI) data, comprising over 1.1
million legal entities from 30 different legal jurisdictions. The ground truth
labels for classification per jurisdiction are taken from the Entity Legal Form
(ELF) code standard (ISO 20275). Our findings demonstrate that pre-trained BERT
variants outperform traditional text classification approaches in terms of F1
score, while also performing comparably well in the Macro F1 Score. Moreover,
the validity of our proposal is supported by the outcome of third-party expert
reviews conducted in ten selected jurisdictions. This study highlights the
significant potential of Transformer-based models in advancing data
standardization and data integration. The presented approaches can greatly
benefit financial institutions, corporations, governments and other
organizations in assessing business relationships, understanding risk exposure,
and promoting effective governance. | [
0.0403048061,
0.0683367103,
-0.0027545444,
-0.0004945243,
-0.0016415144,
0.0316933356,
0.05076975,
0.0560253561,
0.0126718134,
-0.0820581913,
-0.0283139665,
-0.0306809414,
-0.0019337706,
0.0122859254,
0.008691648,
-0.0314320736,
0.0403607786,
0.0294442903,
0.0379340351,
-0.008806794,
-0.0009471157,
0.0121271163,
0.0185236558,
0.0237304475,
-0.015476888,
0.0400425047,
0.0061604385,
-0.0047384473,
0.0005596738,
0.0271738023,
0.0220526122,
0.0817460939,
0.0094027063,
0.0602262206,
0.0000018049,
-0.073082976,
-0.0775432214,
0.012412467,
-0.0129601518,
0.0308918934,
-0.0268561952,
-0.0512764677,
-0.039920181,
0.0222408511,
-0.0208245181,
-0.0281332545,
0.0357448012,
0.0316473618,
0.0630167574,
0.0826644078,
-0.0227144584,
-0.0685795844,
0.0570116974,
-0.0310125127,
-0.0441852957,
-0.0086371005,
0.0426135026,
-0.0077880584,
-0.0407933854,
-0.0263548605,
0.0072176345,
0.0044250116,
0.0229242295,
-0.0032423872,
-0.020205088,
0.0333888903,
-0.0488187745,
0.0092223147,
-0.0143339485,
0.0346357301,
0.0388747826,
-0.0204540119,
0.0190883931,
0.0056713312,
0.0487687811,
0.0219713543,
0.0097127436,
0.0729276463,
-0.0044269962,
0.0200084746,
-0.01131522,
0.0184581522,
0.0165065825,
0.0151110152,
-0.0748359635,
0.0311022848,
0.0205636472,
-0.0462051146,
0.0072775143,
0.0029030235,
-0.0262958128,
-0.0504795015,
0.0329116136,
0.0025580409,
0.027456753,
0.0155519024,
-0.0585415773,
-0.0512179323,
0.0324432999,
-0.0585483797,
-0.0002023674,
0.0051718815,
-0.0309833419,
0.0308888257,
-0.0781310052,
0.0406842083,
-0.0059586694,
0.0423102044,
0.0120279873,
-0.0170500539,
-0.0422018059,
0.001880032,
-0.0534051657,
0.0644073039,
-0.0706272721,
0.0106739681,
-0.0584089942,
0.0265384577,
-0.0156690124,
0.035529051,
0.0261596143,
-0.0199650042,
0.0417626537,
-0.0334806032,
-0.0511830151,
-0.0183147155,
-0.0058012912,
0.0105337733,
-0.0088379662,
-0.0116514321,
0.0625075176,
-0.0160282589,
-0.0019598955,
-0.0353674926,
0.0291458853,
0.0359001122,
0.0222513955,
-0.0438530259,
-0.0357952267,
0.0090770246,
-0.0158895925,
-0.0239309575,
-0.008830077,
-0.0226302203,
0.0020611284,
-0.0117379846,
-0.0203874838,
-0.0577150993,
0.0033693411,
-0.0132828411,
-0.0111537362,
0.0631051287,
-0.0431316793,
-0.0016310568,
0.0128666693,
-0.0171532296,
0.0493509807,
0.008019723,
0.0268647037,
-0.0179308206,
0.0436101891,
-0.0446626283,
0.0207643099,
0.0710516274,
0.0088651245,
-0.0100021176,
0.0122170122,
0.025775373,
-0.0046074446,
-0.0211339872,
0.017086884,
0.0520323254,
0.0168530848,
-0.0454224348,
0.0514877811,
0.0136032673,
0.0443322696,
0.0399158485,
-0.005494134,
0.0182987135,
0.0054084552,
-0.0374736153,
-0.0324226581,
-0.0342216864,
-0.0296696555,
0.0024714603,
-0.0479790755,
0.0157060865,
-0.0445380695,
-0.0355153643,
-0.0123595884,
-0.0200402271,
0.0175247211,
0.0023759312,
0.048046872,
0.0154958675,
-0.0629584193,
0.1334834844,
0.0001223082,
-0.0520591624,
-0.02829477,
-0.0381936878,
0.0008654589,
0.0474443175,
0.0271162596,
-0.0222700275,
-0.0157751422,
-0.050617639,
-0.0352595784,
0.0476368628,
0.0312326197,
-0.0025210078,
-0.0068071517,
-0.0223033242,
-0.0179243311,
0.0755864158,
0.0219090506,
0.0256124604,
-0.0087980255,
0.0028123595,
0.0218325052,
-0.0694375858,
-0.003969295,
0.044693619,
0.0060204077,
-0.0384688228,
0.0299475081,
0.0469124727,
-0.0063596764,
0.0274971463,
-0.0213955473,
-0.0142985275,
0.0285315663,
0.00815346,
-0.030248018,
-0.0023970108,
0.0212448891,
0.026270207,
0.0272887684,
0.0204895325,
0.0092566302,
0.0013151134,
-0.0152327912,
-0.020401407,
-0.0692647845,
-0.0131347608,
0.0295244493,
-0.0565710962,
0.0205710437,
-0.0367856137,
0.0011458666,
-0.0365926586,
0.0548202917,
-0.0293249749,
0.015375548,
-0.0278364439,
-0.0041366485,
0.0480658449,
-0.0103335837,
-0.0318838581,
-0.0081920354,
-0.0665863603,
0.0155524956,
0.0365577266,
0.0097845402,
0.0027738765,
-0.0514010824,
-0.091816403,
-0.0059109125,
-0.0244724173,
0.0236724056,
-0.0028968044,
-0.001235599,
-0.0297819618,
0.0206134804,
-0.0169089381,
-0.0700971708,
-0.0134912059,
-0.0015416653,
0.039626848,
-0.0222054496,
-0.0549324676,
0.0104592256,
-0.0275979843,
-0.0259422287,
0.0336860903,
0.023140274,
-0.040836215,
-0.0636987388,
0.0098165106,
-0.0209170245,
0.0006135332,
0.0092287529,
-0.0020623805,
-0.0132225063,
0.0295392629,
0.0173695087,
0.0216352176,
0.0280761532,
0.0297123082,
-0.0363339037,
0.0148848342,
-0.0589955412,
-0.0140144117,
0.0027288564,
0.0374416076,
-0.0362667963,
-0.0115338741,
0.0512130558,
0.0502107479,
-0.0425313935,
-0.0030681586,
-0.063064158,
-0.0143168084,
0.0211873539,
0.0065962132,
0.0008810362,
0.0049320841,
-0.0159180388,
0.0320876539,
0.0220100805,
-0.0353144482,
0.0328483097,
-0.0276907366,
0.0131156743,
-0.0169688966,
0.0049292892,
-0.0302120224,
0.0418903679,
-0.0247676484,
-0.0044624968,
0.0052343505,
-0.0832281411,
0.0042205956,
0.0357651636,
0.0476951301,
-0.0375388898,
0.0835583508,
0.0116912723,
0.0271084365,
-0.0103856642,
-0.0252994429,
-0.0441848077,
-0.0248130094,
0.0215916131,
0.0837935805,
0.0153711699,
0.0064925463,
-0.0557458922,
0.066043213,
-0.0369949713,
0.0042223898,
0.0128162727,
-0.0106450962,
0.0031214883,
0.0365373194,
-0.0114864968,
-0.0307273623,
0.0487940982,
-0.0208867434,
-0.0177534074,
-0.0305579957,
0.0015857781,
0.0047566472,
0.0157673564,
-0.0352758616,
0.0106472028,
-0.0979260132,
-0.0128310416,
0.0070626549,
-0.001262825,
-0.0261028353,
0.0258005001,
0.1123247147,
0.027598517,
0.022368446,
-0.0104918946,
0.0604868867,
0.0096767284,
0.026782576,
0.0380964428,
-0.1015248001,
0.0226985905,
-0.0204249471,
-0.0097309053,
-0.0027476565,
-0.0438043326,
0.0418879203,
-0.0868496671,
0.0510171466,
-0.0167674646,
-0.0257951729,
-0.0461192429,
-0.0095828744,
-0.0095966915,
-0.0352536067,
0.0118112275,
-0.0205809046,
-0.0305815544,
-0.0355063491,
0.0567705072,
-0.0452895947,
0.0088712042,
-0.0280218534,
-0.0709140152,
0.0086117676,
0.0839273334,
-0.0013458993,
-0.0583814345,
-0.0342120305,
-0.0376653187,
-0.0510065705,
-0.0583281852,
0.0087338835,
0.0524222851,
-0.0099531356,
-0.006450532,
-0.0105814701,
-0.0005713101,
0.0083656032,
-0.0084288623,
-0.0066839359,
0.0297504682,
-0.0230210554,
-0.0253346991,
0.0211149137,
-0.0302901398,
-0.015241907,
0.0656822622,
-0.0101866303,
-0.0538309515,
-0.0101824347,
-0.040155489,
0.0299709644,
-0.0268125553,
0.0124661392,
0.0142132333,
-0.0385079794,
-0.0687469691,
-0.0708626509,
-0.0443206951,
0.0222262088,
0.0385312699,
0.0126443338,
-0.0392604768,
0.0591369048,
-0.0227367133,
-0.0432718471,
0.0122630196,
-0.0185505375,
0.0246709753,
-0.0796229467,
-0.0136870155,
0.0135716684,
0.0311426576,
-0.0502121337,
-0.0318921842,
-0.0221328754,
-0.0243115108,
0.018924864,
0.0174689069,
0.0179233961,
-0.0284174215,
-0.0237216521,
0.0023346697,
0.0577351898,
0.0473474674,
-0.0268118475,
-0.0505062975,
0.0701534674,
-0.0250664074,
-0.0320671462,
-0.0065645953,
-0.0337758884,
0.0160023589,
0.0469295196,
0.0137257511,
-0.0317682363,
-0.015187704,
0.0257055741,
0.0283281729,
0.0339815281,
-0.0088096093,
-0.0032163754,
-0.0172305591,
-0.0003652941,
0.0029935599,
0.0224989038,
-0.0260771234,
-0.0241656993,
0.0383735374,
0.0001650035,
-0.0363201536,
0.1174187288,
-0.0440247022,
0.0079540983,
-0.0689920783,
0.0668609589,
-0.0103274034,
0.0564256497,
0.0057992977,
-0.0425142422,
0.0077700065,
0.0008109859,
0.0807753727,
0.0341493152,
-0.0187510233,
0.0318756625,
0.0106912274,
0.0334880576,
-0.0030917914,
0.0260605775,
0.0034788304,
0.0055747172,
-0.0255927444,
0.0419772044,
0.0337477103,
0.0013392655,
0.0025819479,
-0.0488733947,
0.0065451311,
0.0006308261,
0.0005741693,
0.0331051312,
-0.0458857492,
0.025061043,
0.0028984244,
-0.043352399,
0.0044909217,
0.0350986496,
0.0078126956,
0.0289251693,
-0.0339276381,
0.0051240753,
-0.0462618247,
-0.0340252295,
0.0434364155,
-0.0364362672,
-0.0450291187,
-0.0468208492,
-0.0706283227,
-0.0280349888,
0.0326092988,
-0.0119392853,
0.0092799366,
0.0148489634,
0.0074349344,
0.0450311564,
0.0031747976,
-0.0116643244,
-0.0189272612,
-0.0202086028,
0.0143569978,
-0.0338833593,
-0.0365404822,
-5.155819609e-33,
-0.0159219112,
-0.0097679356,
0.011558379,
-0.0199500434,
0.0084638,
0.0039983341,
0.0127547383,
-0.0111435391,
0.0026496078,
0.0141408136,
-0.0253282785,
-0.0009567694,
0.0344227813,
0.0360675193,
-0.0008388471,
-0.0332555622,
0.0224856101,
0.0060588927,
-0.0200870801,
-0.0056321099,
-0.0271923952,
0.0403197147,
0.081610769,
-0.0824854001,
0.0408315435,
0.0201324075,
-0.0396129563,
-0.0026907478,
0.0214311406,
0.0723647773,
0.0192568712,
-0.0038532778,
0.0071741557,
-0.0797986239,
0.0112701338,
0.0408836827,
-0.0902187079,
0.0374405868,
-0.0106660714,
0.0260428786,
0.0690596849,
-0.0161143802,
0.0560558885,
-0.0272741765,
-0.0483017936,
0.009163945,
0.0117783416,
-0.0252790414,
-0.0217342153,
-0.091248557,
-0.0691586435,
0.0446074083,
0.0100914417,
0.0522977971,
0.0619462878,
0.010964022,
0.0314246081,
0.0192555021,
-0.0706651211,
0.0010326202,
0.0348516591,
-0.0353542119,
0.0333398283,
-0.0199918039,
-0.0065063229,
0.0046353093,
-0.001986227,
0.0174016934,
-0.0345950536,
-0.0102050072,
0.070559673,
0.0751389936,
0.0242458712,
0.0236724708,
0.001682449,
-0.0407176465,
-0.044905521,
0.0707153752,
0.0206656717,
-0.0237794518,
0.0012179711,
-0.0389315039,
-0.0422687568,
-0.0243684333,
-0.0109718656,
-0.041809015,
0.0046842927,
-0.0000478438,
0.0114947278,
-0.0196611602,
0.0025710373,
0.0207909942,
0.0305438731,
-0.0522520766,
-0.0731260031,
0.0007644777,
0.0094316099,
0.0531998128,
0.0023854699,
0.0173261836,
-0.0362509191,
-0.0539404564,
0.0426413566,
-0.0044964193,
-0.0160603672,
-0.0067595695,
0.0455552824,
-0.0205182787,
-0.0866985992,
0.0196510684,
0.0281143561,
0.0253227521,
0.0183835384,
0.0382800959,
-0.0122871809,
0.0305707641,
0.0379658528,
-0.0125626288,
0.0218616333,
-0.0325010866,
-0.000340167,
0.0292118713,
0.0360434726,
0.0502655283,
0.0008634996,
-0.0041913064,
-0.0141335288,
0.0382196456,
0.018779926,
0.0020738004,
0.0057267072,
0.0260952003,
2.394e-7,
0.0947133973,
0.0705027208,
0.0037954426,
-0.0240551028,
-0.0187657177,
0.0316514857,
0.0565396361,
0.0396226682,
-0.0117004355,
0.0032389637,
0.030275831,
-0.071482271,
0.0520622432,
0.0299940035,
-0.08238516,
-0.0626448169,
-0.0565761589,
0.0146241896,
-0.0702675655,
0.0459271707,
0.0316865295,
0.0832067803,
0.0253841225,
-0.0371241421,
-0.0062313643,
-0.0029891867,
0.0443432778,
-0.0565747432,
0.0311846919,
0.0254607182,
0.0583707057,
-0.0308366548,
0.0235682204,
0.0337191783,
-0.0174467564,
0.0442813262,
-0.0137787722,
0.0631329939,
0.0039613368,
0.0385474153,
-0.0052929004,
-0.0679553598,
-0.0060399259,
-0.0467288829,
0.0387955308,
-0.0327512883,
-0.0143068517,
0.0480430275,
-0.0767142698,
-0.0084654931,
-0.0028733762,
0.0170066226,
-0.0198384132,
0.0321357101,
0.0631015003,
-0.0285771824,
0.021231696,
-0.0518251881,
0.0389040783,
0.0137037421,
-0.00463313,
0.0446072407,
-0.017122766,
-0.0192305204,
0.0554279462,
-0.0477515124,
0.0389719978,
2.488301595e-34,
-0.0052583101,
-0.0096311029,
-0.0039174319,
0.0530032776,
0.0449847393,
0.014919403,
0.028904397,
0.0169407986,
-0.0374674462,
-0.0615136772,
0.032055743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12751v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12751v1 | Character-level Chinese Backpack Language Models | 2023-10-19T13:54:57 | 2023-10-19T13:54:57 | Hao Sun, John Hewitt | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Backpack is a Transformer alternative shown to improve interpretability
in English language modeling by decomposing predictions into a weighted sum of
token sense components. However, Backpacks' reliance on token-defined meaning
raises questions as to their potential for languages other than English, a
language for which subword tokenization provides a reasonable approximation for
lexical items. In this work, we train, evaluate, interpret, and control
Backpack language models in character-tokenized Chinese, in which words are
often composed of many characters. We find that our (134M parameter) Chinese
Backpack language model performs comparably to a (104M parameter) Transformer,
and learns rich character-level meanings that log-additively compose to form
word meanings. In SimLex-style lexical semantic evaluations, simple averages of
Backpack character senses outperform input embeddings from a Transformer. We
find that complex multi-character meanings are often formed by using the same
per-character sense weights consistently across context. Exploring
interpretability-through control, we show that we can localize a source of
gender bias in our Backpacks to specific character senses and intervene to
reduce the bias. | [
0.0305825192,
0.0632610098,
-0.0031217984,
0.0413462371,
0.0218756422,
0.0131184617,
0.0266441591,
-0.0066043264,
-0.0269013047,
-0.0341811068,
-0.0314072743,
-0.0728382692,
0.0287980009,
0.0360801332,
0.0318887867,
-0.0350900404,
0.0361923799,
-0.0068103964,
-0.0286634546,
-0.0023796132,
0.0180019476,
0.0083881607,
0.0452258475,
0.0809576884,
0.0056070834,
-0.0271944012,
-0.0018481028,
0.0323835723,
-0.0063447189,
-0.0029698985,
0.0098670358,
0.0273055024,
0.0126899108,
0.0192436557,
0.0000020175,
-0.0467623658,
-0.0488711856,
0.0080266623,
-0.0383211374,
0.0241733398,
0.085625872,
-0.0667019114,
-0.0157059841,
0.0005111324,
-0.0030353419,
-0.0508117042,
0.0531234704,
0.0692385361,
0.0291784815,
-0.0016057504,
-0.0132035147,
-0.0466072373,
-0.0149715394,
-0.0422760881,
0.0118746106,
-0.0157716312,
0.0101142311,
0.0116202878,
-0.0293895695,
-0.0166189354,
-0.0814083219,
0.0126944631,
0.0223805066,
-0.0009372067,
0.0033812525,
0.0278588403,
-0.0287986472,
-0.0297866054,
0.0153088337,
0.0527021401,
-0.0507330783,
-0.0327508487,
-0.0367179178,
-0.015547201,
-0.0200704727,
-0.0175638646,
-0.0263147093,
0.0009760146,
0.0333726518,
0.0152677707,
0.0415794663,
0.0048806388,
0.0475863144,
0.0371153541,
-0.0717607439,
0.0752069131,
0.0077167805,
-0.0183583237,
-0.0380113795,
-0.0196731724,
-0.0400862843,
-0.0170476697,
0.01131065,
-0.005817777,
0.007301203,
0.0416538864,
0.0190553851,
-0.0183617137,
0.0019258523,
-0.0254574511,
0.0082714194,
0.0690948442,
-0.0306799486,
0.0222904589,
-0.0572100095,
0.0662785396,
-0.0197821688,
0.0504365265,
-0.0703603253,
-0.0619242787,
-0.0327247865,
-0.0322829708,
-0.0723209754,
0.0250176862,
-0.061813999,
-0.0078218346,
-0.0563020445,
0.013537446,
-0.005046872,
-0.0502399467,
0.0463628955,
0.0003904359,
-0.0595389418,
-0.0319574326,
0.0250567291,
0.0525162369,
-0.0121269552,
0.0274357907,
-0.039261125,
-0.0428710096,
-0.0130144842,
0.0150271999,
-0.0013239147,
-0.0358446613,
-0.0201760828,
0.063648805,
-0.0109651964,
-0.0376520455,
-0.0302359983,
-0.0090518352,
-0.0363116972,
-0.0199049991,
-0.02691257,
-0.0542264581,
0.0171466172,
0.0102347154,
0.0627747625,
-0.0661391616,
0.00134225,
-0.025379369,
-0.0018313287,
0.0870970786,
0.0628416464,
-0.0158806425,
-0.0158426836,
0.0129479226,
-0.0340557136,
0.0671204776,
0.0622930489,
0.0498354137,
0.037192829,
-0.012311955,
-0.0422364138,
0.0256751683,
0.0062148278,
-0.0131413424,
-0.0535194315,
-0.0133712944,
-0.0012698538,
0.0493549779,
0.0255966894,
0.0500486381,
-0.0180628505,
0.0127060534,
0.0601183176,
0.0575009361,
0.0641533136,
0.007507809,
0.0493712351,
-0.0027459518,
-0.0445165932,
-0.0190897714,
-0.0470565036,
0.0091238599,
-0.0117966868,
-0.0116807856,
-0.0205284059,
0.0157546382,
-0.015633231,
-0.0524365827,
-0.0161282346,
-0.0282270256,
0.0545275658,
-0.0109196492,
0.0362324007,
0.0141531955,
-0.0158066358,
0.0679672956,
0.0393411368,
-0.0560113154,
0.0400409438,
-0.0447131097,
0.0190735832,
0.0739761367,
0.0155246155,
0.0146645764,
0.0153993005,
-0.0048785899,
-0.0132134715,
0.0235908907,
0.0095444666,
0.0016513341,
0.0458641537,
-0.071405001,
-0.0004776925,
0.043099612,
0.0201342739,
0.0377708115,
-0.0017308265,
0.0219473541,
0.0097235339,
-0.0778492764,
-0.022066813,
0.038045641,
-0.0341498889,
-0.0376611054,
0.0269742142,
0.0195069145,
0.0044630924,
0.002867941,
-0.0105122095,
0.0243734028,
-0.0020370157,
-0.0617610067,
-0.0478633195,
0.0486877784,
-0.0344665907,
-0.0262747481,
0.0227405746,
-0.0209111776,
-0.0175257884,
0.0306888744,
-0.0247596651,
-0.0378419906,
0.0360439904,
-0.0222637914,
0.0627118871,
-0.0835264027,
0.0107885422,
-0.0236174203,
0.0548579358,
-0.0262233634,
0.0417672507,
-0.0367066078,
-0.0058760149,
-0.0246061403,
0.0199995022,
0.0221477114,
-0.0198547691,
-0.0664921552,
0.0181673076,
0.0161414165,
0.0144904871,
0.0328018777,
-0.0050999904,
0.010084074,
-0.056275703,
-0.0672078207,
-0.0106460005,
-0.0272886846,
-0.0221764687,
0.018382512,
0.0439968444,
-0.0025171658,
-0.0027449513,
-0.0149399936,
-0.0177056957,
-0.0356780551,
0.0193235148,
0.0321150608,
-0.0222782996,
0.0042607035,
-0.0181244835,
-0.0372264646,
-0.0333201736,
0.0717628524,
-0.0141153214,
-0.0258027725,
-0.0261977725,
-0.0563647673,
0.003479464,
-0.0216856841,
-0.0229215156,
-0.0716240034,
-0.0143936072,
-0.005887066,
0.0414923057,
0.0676263198,
0.037596032,
0.0560451001,
0.0466605537,
0.0201880448,
-0.0637777671,
-0.0173537657,
0.0269936733,
0.0095213018,
-0.0242000446,
-0.0565736294,
-0.0400026627,
0.088268131,
0.0147215044,
-0.0191041511,
-0.1003900394,
-0.0092302859,
-0.0575575456,
-0.0487529337,
-0.0204573087,
0.0127239022,
-0.0416235812,
0.0101960599,
-0.0491343848,
-0.0233163238,
0.0613200516,
-0.0232965034,
-0.0395772867,
-0.0251257457,
-0.012743881,
-0.071206145,
0.0750838295,
-0.0025229042,
0.0320640169,
0.0089766234,
-0.0249452796,
-0.0514254421,
-0.0053682509,
-0.0197271593,
-0.0478284024,
0.0395624563,
0.0137431128,
0.0046525584,
-0.0111647146,
0.0095258579,
-0.0258205365,
-0.0373402312,
-0.0271805692,
0.0303213354,
0.0721168742,
-0.0224310532,
0.0010824824,
0.0443124436,
0.0087161902,
0.0211794861,
-0.0092181824,
0.0064648683,
-0.0219340753,
-0.0236731544,
0.0327382013,
0.0032262688,
0.0404379331,
-0.0368146189,
0.0277049989,
0.0433388725,
-0.0082601961,
-0.0157066397,
-0.0237908978,
0.0347812437,
0.0398703776,
-0.0114190774,
0.0034885919,
-0.0240240078,
0.0734674707,
-0.0592461042,
-0.0030407473,
0.1166159138,
0.0239607263,
-0.0415959209,
0.0437838398,
-0.0072544059,
0.0310130697,
0.0134446127,
0.0060214703,
-0.0640373677,
-0.0412465781,
0.0137266936,
0.0103571806,
0.0232766382,
-0.0128631834,
-0.0044578356,
-0.1002903357,
-0.0093297604,
0.0055241757,
-0.0631558299,
-0.0151376138,
-0.009300964,
-0.0290458929,
-0.0620314889,
0.0628524572,
0.0117245782,
-0.0102851512,
-0.0089028822,
0.0106974877,
-0.0124220392,
0.0186016653,
0.053033445,
-0.0383680724,
0.0355797857,
0.0251520667,
0.0527417809,
-0.0260671284,
-0.0043340502,
0.0027289449,
-0.0141776232,
0.0113508441,
0.0046523646,
-0.0107944496,
-0.0216066353,
-0.0276067741,
0.0004198167,
0.0158795081,
-0.030819919,
-0.0158394221,
-0.0422431119,
0.0274380241,
0.0230783485,
-0.0097442381,
-0.040687643,
-0.0201322474,
-0.0091295587,
0.085532546,
0.0154252844,
-0.0752990246,
-0.0345961824,
-0.0378715396,
-0.0164420586,
-0.0344408043,
-0.0303116199,
0.0078281648,
0.0200584922,
-0.0057760091,
-0.0579787754,
-0.0490623713,
-0.0104196118,
0.0195531026,
-0.0252033975,
-0.010107642,
-0.0446719788,
0.0149331167,
-0.0514601357,
0.0163238943,
-0.0050663762,
0.038408041,
-0.033475358,
0.0200285371,
0.0288631562,
-0.0528935567,
-0.022807857,
0.0190150328,
-0.0541638695,
-0.058686465,
0.0450673848,
0.0292374268,
0.0184826422,
0.0287951231,
-0.0091176834,
-0.0347809084,
0.0535171144,
0.0169753563,
-0.0234858338,
0.0356272087,
0.0544459037,
-0.0127395904,
0.0112460209,
0.048294384,
-0.0537064448,
0.0482401066,
-0.0157606099,
0.0449669547,
-0.0337327681,
-0.0138371335,
0.0298983268,
-0.0014129842,
-0.0094724959,
-0.0300041661,
0.0058808578,
-0.0238109883,
0.0229605325,
-0.0323859937,
-0.0166309923,
-0.0365147404,
-0.0346784927,
0.0722842515,
-0.0013815257,
-0.0136268483,
0.0238776654,
0.0176928379,
0.0316695347,
0.0413908884,
0.0269196797,
0.0020903654,
0.0167668182,
-0.0218248665,
0.0355260521,
-0.0065654307,
-0.0206011608,
-0.0453210622,
0.0123133324,
-0.0160559732,
0.0118080005,
-0.0059054778,
0.0354703702,
-0.0498629734,
0.0298177171,
-0.0657557473,
-0.007541352,
-0.0022609271,
0.0132559827,
-0.0006550251,
-0.0225356594,
0.0396496654,
-0.0266172271,
0.0083373021,
-0.0282966476,
0.0280497298,
-0.0021590553,
-0.0117310379,
0.0175211858,
0.0243220776,
-0.0022221806,
-0.0412981659,
0.0528349169,
0.0227237176,
0.0487251729,
-0.0054280395,
0.0104851648,
-0.0178496689,
0.0183209758,
0.0216273125,
0.0244919285,
-0.0471665934,
0.0320061184,
-0.0803482458,
-0.0581321307,
0.0308152288,
0.0217981525,
0.0068150247,
0.0026428071,
-0.0124377217,
0.0373567455,
0.0072909775,
-0.000059159,
-0.0501328819,
-0.0180486124,
0.0207826551,
0.0100181065,
0.0070587043,
-6.516712194e-33,
-0.0282976981,
-0.0120095909,
-0.0346577391,
-0.0313319489,
-0.0043666321,
0.0278408118,
-0.0379399844,
-0.000775867,
-0.027576752,
0.0114562875,
0.0004413909,
0.0339481533,
0.0107412366,
0.0307230651,
0.0159196481,
0.0172311403,
0.0587613396,
0.0455489196,
0.0234535094,
-0.0350914709,
0.0701275393,
0.0572001189,
0.0629785061,
-0.033332482,
0.0499493554,
-0.0006582531,
0.0049586366,
0.0092374664,
0.0020676428,
0.07082095,
-0.0197909307,
0.0534722768,
0.0124552082,
-0.0276645012,
-0.0280772299,
0.0134393936,
-0.1132306308,
-0.0295585189,
0.0236159898,
0.0426208042,
0.0028450717,
-0.0108100567,
0.0467337668,
-0.0290445723,
-0.0012652136,
-0.0477100462,
0.0213382989,
-0.0053244834,
-0.0189155675,
0.0059945267,
-0.0504121184,
0.0137007274,
0.0121649997,
-0.0037907625,
0.0248480458,
0.0173471197,
0.0061163479,
0.0359946862,
-0.0297836754,
-0.0086356718,
-0.0428715646,
0.0180058591,
0.0170119237,
0.0232139546,
0.0082872985,
0.031401746,
0.066850923,
-0.0198831018,
-0.045071654,
-0.0553576127,
0.079552196,
-0.0218101591,
0.0397265144,
0.0766952559,
0.0781042799,
-0.0021988831,
-0.0567683913,
0.0002098332,
0.0356299728,
0.0686320141,
0.0429483317,
0.060440544,
-0.0532252342,
-0.0075757015,
-0.0336955041,
-0.0381722338,
-0.0372761525,
-0.0443173274,
0.0144230435,
0.0103236707,
-0.0878679976,
0.0224331897,
0.0544818416,
-0.0818149447,
-0.0150714898,
0.0365828164,
0.0431544669,
-0.0230158009,
0.0143391835,
0.0486318059,
-0.0272600725,
-0.0257949978,
0.010987334,
-0.0003653375,
-0.0075466041,
0.0053941845,
0.0371059924,
0.0395968333,
-0.0440479591,
-0.0049084458,
-0.011352093,
-0.0340193994,
-0.036617592,
0.0358129852,
0.0361421816,
0.0209112093,
-0.0304582939,
-0.0118094618,
0.0279106908,
0.0311272405,
-0.0389096402,
-0.0152017176,
-0.0029963481,
0.0388938934,
-0.045509994,
-0.0079137105,
-0.0242855251,
0.0215924755,
0.0861958861,
-0.052268818,
0.0008297832,
0.0226057135,
2.751e-7,
0.0773456022,
0.0152448425,
0.0597795658,
-0.0023197061,
0.0061702654,
0.0074814195,
-0.0032864138,
0.0527755097,
0.0026021409,
-0.0010963765,
-0.0010408661,
0.0384936109,
0.0240119081,
0.0144760935,
-0.0671180263,
0.0376048461,
-0.0387420021,
0.0469084382,
0.0163546931,
0.0255654976,
0.0417147726,
0.1426069587,
0.0009104996,
0.0063925125,
-0.0001882237,
-0.0270090867,
0.0612874255,
-0.0162679963,
0.0188136511,
0.0095894057,
0.0361987129,
0.0154460873,
0.0219196957,
-0.0203230642,
0.0067227981,
0.0413788967,
0.0675550103,
0.0366054587,
-0.0461807884,
-0.0131255575,
-0.0264244676,
-0.0331970751,
-0.0435169078,
-0.0632460266,
0.0538265705,
-0.0348788425,
-0.0140317762,
-0.0460197777,
-0.0076965024,
0.0480799042,
0.0284156892,
0.0039379853,
-0.0247647874,
0.055431094,
0.0374424197,
-0.0037497499,
-0.0249741804,
-0.0760558695,
-0.0776213408,
-0.0300760865,
-0.020095706,
-0.0057680211,
-0.0147392815,
0.0004528576,
0.0127886394,
-0.0602902249,
-0.0279028472,
2.21919076e-34,
0.0258942265,
0.0146246208,
0.0123784393,
0.0208000224,
0.0220570453,
-0.0215347018,
0.0385968089,
0.018790327,
0.0255029686,
-0.044078365,
-0.0414535515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12727v1 | Representing and Computing Uncertainty in Phonological Reconstruction | 2023-10-19T13:27:42 | 2023-10-19T13:27:42 | Johann-Mattis List, Nathan W. Hill, Robert Forkel, Frederic Blum | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the inherently fuzzy nature of reconstructions in historical
linguistics, most scholars do not represent their uncertainty when proposing
proto-forms. With the increasing success of recently proposed approaches to
automating certain aspects of the traditional comparative method, the formal
representation of proto-forms has also improved. This formalization makes it
possible to address both the representation and the computation of uncertainty.
Building on recent advances in supervised phonological reconstruction, during
which an algorithm learns how to reconstruct words in a given proto-language
relying on previously annotated data, and inspired by improved methods for
automated word prediction from cognate sets, we present a new framework that
allows for the representation of uncertainty in linguistic reconstruction and
also includes a workflow for the computation of fuzzy reconstructions from
linguistic data. | [
-0.0239513647,
0.103294,
-0.0534094013,
-0.0080553005,
-0.0469642021,
-0.0230215564,
-0.0565343462,
-0.0024284013,
-0.0921891406,
-0.0534871966,
0.0180606283,
-0.0857002437,
0.0721749365,
-0.0184316933,
0.0380348563,
-0.0424919128,
0.0293931272,
-0.0158445742,
0.0535349473,
-0.0012886586,
-0.0168150216,
-0.0233357139,
-0.0101021808,
0.0196955204,
-0.0168297812,
0.044023633,
-0.0176540054,
0.0043513076,
-0.0405329987,
-0.0031062004,
-0.0209586285,
0.0299152117,
-0.0139267659,
0.0428694896,
0.0000017213,
-0.0592322722,
0.0008537592,
-0.0190557782,
-0.0112865316,
0.0181008652,
0.0202755127,
0.0531541556,
-0.0597588308,
-0.0275141802,
-0.0099225789,
0.0406295061,
0.0847747847,
-0.0743961185,
-0.0347021744,
-0.0019399121,
-0.0037577448,
-0.0446845219,
-0.000991295,
0.0106416624,
0.0000270895,
0.0224950816,
0.0161794331,
-0.0294274054,
0.023295451,
-0.0105718728,
-0.0221095011,
0.0237761792,
-0.0694140941,
0.0379697867,
-0.0398926288,
-0.0389579013,
0.0092538232,
-0.057478264,
-0.0139436601,
-0.0210713539,
-0.0174394362,
-0.0456752107,
-0.027056925,
0.021083612,
-0.0200618599,
-0.0102326889,
0.0122736702,
-0.0078207729,
-0.0191371478,
0.0276675317,
0.060039442,
-0.0301322956,
-0.0005576186,
0.0059509715,
-0.0346548036,
0.116030775,
0.0362066813,
-0.0033707947,
-0.0062591713,
0.0325156786,
-0.0171817932,
0.0039092256,
0.0079342481,
0.0394180752,
-0.0282147843,
0.013856573,
0.0116431825,
-0.002367994,
0.0354177728,
-0.0117358668,
0.0117146717,
0.0004764753,
0.0028160058,
-0.0119342683,
-0.0018515,
-0.0240744185,
0.0393754691,
-0.0614475682,
-0.0355470777,
0.0093995873,
-0.0219346248,
0.002522721,
-0.0653646439,
-0.0040886067,
0.0251120869,
0.0512283184,
-0.030666979,
-0.0213907007,
-0.0218280926,
0.0130873593,
-0.0237472318,
-0.0293611586,
-0.0523843914,
-0.0142555851,
-0.0382337347,
-0.0270389989,
-0.0131093003,
0.0525120646,
-0.0512286685,
-0.0668037459,
0.0097560789,
-0.0215946082,
0.0087933606,
0.0149884652,
0.0016567711,
0.0197003577,
-0.005717386,
-0.0200573262,
-0.0185406618,
-0.0458746366,
-0.064050369,
-0.003589022,
-0.0458305478,
-0.0578541234,
-0.0048166411,
-0.0107290735,
-0.0211802553,
-0.0389902219,
0.000219236,
-0.0106924856,
-0.0342712365,
0.0574977845,
-0.0460879877,
0.0226236265,
-0.0131910192,
-0.0160857402,
-0.0433937721,
-0.0076067918,
0.0563773699,
-0.034369491,
0.0515733026,
0.0156741589,
-0.0173000414,
0.0397912115,
0.0232896823,
-0.0335053802,
-0.0436343737,
-0.0238098204,
-0.0051457034,
0.0367562957,
-0.008518585,
0.0715613216,
0.0121813472,
-0.033016976,
0.0472376421,
0.0620819665,
0.0483624637,
0.0202241633,
0.0082011269,
0.0004339246,
0.0528956652,
0.0107655041,
0.0195842497,
-0.0643559098,
-0.0304862317,
0.0269807428,
-0.0396424346,
0.032295417,
0.0252812337,
0.0131691843,
-0.0228223056,
-0.0551432855,
0.0013209035,
0.0042653084,
0.0670537874,
-0.0160637461,
-0.0258277822,
-0.041918695,
0.0282241758,
-0.0214588176,
0.0120158661,
-0.0141695468,
0.0428199582,
0.0023723189,
0.0163690224,
-0.0894716382,
0.0082386378,
0.0298515502,
-0.0698700249,
-0.0091276178,
0.0133109009,
-0.0332307033,
0.0137696145,
-0.0192258265,
-0.0043906029,
0.0568772145,
0.0373937078,
0.0155703668,
-0.0179462228,
0.0423124321,
-0.000145025,
-0.0343235619,
0.0006967912,
0.0089994017,
0.0226690006,
-0.0187904444,
0.0037656915,
0.0181934815,
0.0438970886,
0.0438828394,
0.0053284834,
0.0750125572,
0.0283885375,
0.0039997543,
-0.00967992,
0.0015137219,
-0.0117401937,
0.0070197857,
0.0782884881,
0.0149972113,
0.0079153636,
-0.0867303088,
0.0368588306,
-0.0258894246,
0.0431240946,
-0.0804409087,
0.051400464,
-0.007726809,
0.0519796126,
-0.0246611666,
0.0030606184,
-0.0619083196,
0.068616204,
0.0580672808,
0.0412224159,
0.0310230479,
-0.0344979502,
0.0216173083,
-0.0268872939,
-0.0206158217,
-0.0293571353,
-0.0181718413,
-0.0149825085,
0.0316965394,
-0.0449982658,
0.000848995,
-0.0405914634,
-0.0117674675,
-0.021493867,
-0.0119867921,
0.0194173418,
-0.0309915394,
0.0138913766,
0.0021254313,
0.0116871111,
0.0226635411,
0.0478055142,
-0.011527448,
0.0278578047,
0.0123398863,
-0.0407248959,
-0.011108825,
-0.027750738,
0.0034126211,
0.0039239954,
0.0271557923,
0.0042750784,
-0.0338333808,
-0.0655565634,
-0.0202442147,
-0.0641286522,
0.0096454667,
-0.0000214116,
-0.0191777367,
0.0093041137,
-0.0187774096,
0.0160087775,
-0.0480913855,
-0.0072077848,
-0.0200594105,
0.0438197069,
-0.0667672604,
-0.006014931,
-0.0565399081,
-0.0389826819,
-0.027307868,
0.0025557168,
-0.0493096374,
-0.0235050209,
0.0346926525,
0.0172668919,
-0.0229181852,
-0.0256650187,
0.0212464929,
-0.0445347503,
0.0174348634,
0.0151532916,
-0.0658111125,
-0.0338250287,
0.106994763,
-0.0028884644,
-0.0172665324,
0.0554635487,
-0.0476005897,
0.0176477041,
-0.0275886599,
-0.0235020742,
-0.0172531977,
0.02910625,
-0.0049739373,
-0.016534498,
0.0448693968,
-0.0313390791,
-0.0735343397,
0.0149940588,
0.0960979015,
-0.0709212571,
-0.0115153342,
-0.0561358705,
0.0137350308,
0.0127674332,
-0.0100057367,
0.0241800658,
-0.0023225381,
-0.0235587358,
0.0187675636,
0.0255345311,
0.0097337738,
0.0151730329,
0.0131626707,
-0.0294904727,
-0.0059457473,
0.0225433614,
0.020583868,
-0.0186834987,
0.0321648493,
-0.0354690403,
0.0468176305,
0.0252440609,
0.0324504673,
-0.0121503808,
-0.0138064111,
0.0322086178,
0.0086333361,
-0.0020054951,
0.0013561317,
0.0694937184,
-0.0097654322,
-0.0363933481,
0.0179996565,
0.0185641758,
0.0227852222,
0.0296205562,
0.0697770938,
0.0341884494,
-0.0024363885,
0.027835425,
-0.0307150166,
0.0006780577,
0.0100843906,
-0.0228945538,
-0.0555491596,
-0.0027348076,
0.034858115,
0.0276707038,
-0.0132770576,
-0.0259089693,
0.0324984156,
-0.0846908689,
0.0170887765,
0.010850803,
-0.0326762348,
-0.0432932712,
-0.0479048826,
0.0226268023,
0.0020868082,
-0.0771169588,
0.0583408996,
0.0026462374,
0.0339156203,
0.0007039193,
-0.0181755554,
-0.0298782941,
-0.0413792618,
-0.0718016028,
0.044961635,
-0.0215886701,
0.0546178035,
-0.0290148351,
0.0183227025,
-0.0429121926,
-0.0316296816,
-0.0136368014,
-0.0041854572,
0.0300978161,
0.1113303974,
-0.009057302,
0.0013437269,
0.0120003764,
-0.0148032317,
-0.0677673593,
0.0230446216,
0.0602505617,
-0.0009400911,
-0.023928808,
0.0286696013,
0.0192187652,
0.0577948578,
0.033169087,
0.0140564479,
0.0066681998,
0.0016401843,
-0.0152088134,
0.0747787282,
0.0442546904,
-0.0617184751,
0.001722359,
0.0105609577,
-0.0487619638,
-0.0924834162,
-0.0116520533,
0.00292643,
0.0514197946,
0.0565987751,
-0.0099072633,
0.0727042705,
-0.0014479121,
-0.0829871669,
-0.005541902,
0.0463154092,
0.0438729599,
-0.0512594767,
0.0018110108,
0.0462099835,
-0.0136251897,
0.0030570508,
0.0610966124,
0.0269048978,
-0.0624997802,
0.0515971482,
0.0203616638,
0.031414777,
-0.0232822224,
-0.0287610944,
-0.0468358658,
0.0584910139,
0.031475801,
-0.0305692125,
-0.0023433077,
0.0416327007,
0.0205678493,
-0.0141440043,
0.0432466939,
-0.021657249,
-0.0391668454,
-0.0431971215,
0.0418211073,
-0.0157248657,
-0.0889005587,
0.0335460603,
-0.0016228602,
0.0706009194,
-0.0805432349,
0.0059976997,
-0.007136825,
-0.0520069003,
-0.0104903113,
-0.0052224011,
0.0046469928,
0.0244622771,
0.0122233955,
-0.0347974636,
0.0032152713,
-0.0552777052,
-0.0120568601,
0.0461188518,
0.0242706817,
-0.0028257561,
0.0259180553,
0.0442544855,
-0.0061900015,
0.0195997525,
0.0283587929,
0.074494347,
-0.0416722558,
0.0744476542,
-0.0148554724,
-0.063207224,
0.0078527676,
0.0256607085,
-0.0442190766,
-0.039987877,
-0.0204363056,
-0.0485381223,
-0.0161217973,
0.012302991,
0.0296271294,
-0.0068212198,
0.0606741607,
-0.0508774593,
-0.0235532392,
-0.0196140911,
0.0066326424,
-0.0035909123,
0.0298821274,
-0.0005711152,
-0.0024258192,
-0.0145230545,
0.0334480889,
0.044308424,
-0.0553884506,
0.0183850378,
-0.040035639,
-0.0749331266,
0.0110211372,
-0.0517292991,
-0.0466555245,
0.0164459571,
-0.035466902,
0.0017504396,
-0.0860594958,
-0.0438595377,
0.0058169491,
0.0148568824,
-0.0011407068,
-0.0116180247,
0.0149430465,
0.0392125435,
0.0099308137,
0.078174606,
-0.0256404039,
0.0463810265,
0.0452267975,
-0.006152709,
-0.0331966355,
-5.353772123e-33,
-0.0081154248,
-0.0001996162,
-0.025962919,
0.0128919175,
0.0195858311,
-0.033537697,
0.015577117,
0.07201989,
-0.0087765278,
0.012393292,
0.0109478729,
-0.0391662344,
0.0127046872,
-0.0208041929,
0.0276529044,
0.0363751128,
-0.0092512071,
-0.0200433526,
0.0026830491,
-0.079496637,
0.0448740199,
0.0008838574,
0.0689863116,
-0.0315265022,
0.0365144983,
0.0553632341,
-0.0225558467,
0.0653186664,
-0.008430752,
-0.0096026026,
0.0141064851,
0.0539851189,
-0.0098831598,
0.0638762489,
-0.0049833665,
-0.02908138,
-0.0526006334,
-0.0511135943,
0.0213890933,
0.0550745949,
0.0396516882,
0.0326506831,
-0.0222435631,
-0.0021019108,
-0.0712988451,
0.0386062972,
0.0146716181,
-0.0223618373,
-0.0504360721,
-0.0317938328,
-0.0305720028,
0.0271288343,
-0.010452223,
-0.0390898921,
0.044534605,
0.0340864956,
0.0017391271,
-0.0181379337,
-0.0219561234,
0.0340955555,
-0.0400183536,
0.0420889854,
-0.0027200496,
-0.011736704,
-0.0479704849,
0.0168273319,
0.0359674022,
-0.0489124432,
-0.0036547226,
0.0173970815,
0.0294533279,
0.015398615,
-0.0041761273,
0.0499851368,
0.0459816344,
-0.019128751,
0.0223359335,
0.0088993693,
0.060297247,
0.0156140374,
-0.0036550499,
0.0174896289,
-0.0013524307,
-0.0275188871,
-0.0467012376,
-0.0929691344,
-0.0114544509,
0.0554960594,
-0.0486243293,
-0.0418885946,
-0.019609293,
0.0396257937,
-0.0025881829,
-0.0173421986,
-0.0242429022,
-0.0534606352,
-0.0163385347,
0.0354661122,
-0.0061752307,
0.0329966359,
0.0475005247,
-0.0205546133,
0.0375167653,
0.0448307358,
-0.0074196742,
0.0082764225,
-0.0343814418,
0.0357138403,
-0.0253072605,
0.0177983772,
-0.0165278148,
-0.0263850056,
-0.005179971,
-0.0628621131,
0.0429072566,
0.0251209103,
0.0441474207,
-0.0249938294,
0.0547437333,
0.0084043602,
0.0156507045,
0.0253501236,
0.0196673237,
-0.0306019094,
0.0009781095,
-0.0107660498,
0.0254587121,
0.0219492558,
0.0473407544,
0.0126380576,
-0.010462434,
-0.002416533,
2.717e-7,
0.0620201677,
0.0379736423,
0.0483349711,
0.0419415459,
0.0293762404,
0.0276136827,
-0.0374214239,
-0.0600740127,
0.0093692653,
0.016086312,
0.0551070236,
-0.0451141186,
0.0335792936,
0.0748992413,
-0.014208613,
-0.0530443676,
-0.0498174839,
-0.0331150144,
-0.0180170685,
0.0112337889,
0.0426442698,
0.0816848651,
0.0158169828,
-0.0593407787,
-0.0317304283,
0.0213142727,
0.0283117518,
-0.021073848,
-0.0055503389,
0.0278577674,
0.0448664986,
-0.0606641322,
0.0174462013,
0.0128314253,
-0.0442022868,
0.0405482128,
0.0474372171,
-0.0277200025,
0.0330812111,
0.0409456976,
0.027316289,
-0.0406563878,
-0.0023363775,
-0.0307619944,
0.0124984654,
-0.0091046225,
-0.01394263,
-0.0098488741,
-0.0694562197,
0.0395077951,
0.0318506584,
-0.0185019672,
-0.0266205128,
0.0248080026,
0.0149738686,
0.0615817346,
-0.0398250259,
-0.0198537484,
-0.0069301412,
0.0217861403,
-0.0356347933,
-0.0139665259,
0.072866194,
0.0053890692,
0.027790593,
-0.0565083809,
0.0237649567,
2.013132799e-34,
0.0305986814,
-0.011743932,
0.0215965975,
0.019229006,
0.0050077247,
-0.016791828,
0.0237236582,
0.0581693761,
0.0170710161,
0.0330824666,
-0.009909071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13032v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13032v4 | Quality-Diversity through AI Feedback | 2023-10-19T12:13:58 | 2023-12-07T19:56:21 | Herbie Bradley, Andrew Dai, Hannah Teufel, Jenny Zhang, Koen Oostermeijer, Marco Bellagente, Jeff Clune, Kenneth Stanley, Grégory Schott, Joel Lehman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | In many text-generation problems, users may prefer not only a single
response, but a diverse range of high-quality outputs from which to choose.
Quality-diversity (QD) search algorithms aim at such outcomes, by continually
improving and diversifying a population of candidates. However, the
applicability of QD to qualitative domains, like creative writing, has been
limited by the difficulty of algorithmically specifying measures of quality and
diversity. Interestingly, recent developments in language models (LMs) have
enabled guiding search through AI feedback, wherein LMs are prompted in natural
language to evaluate qualitative aspects of text. Leveraging this development,
we introduce Quality-Diversity through AI Feedback (QDAIF), wherein an
evolutionary algorithm applies LMs to both generate variation and evaluate the
quality and diversity of candidate text. When assessed on creative writing
domains, QDAIF covers more of a specified search space with high-quality
samples than do non-QD controls. Further, human evaluation of QDAIF-generated
creative texts validates reasonable agreement between AI and human evaluation.
Our results thus highlight the potential of AI feedback to guide open-ended
search for creative and original solutions, providing a recipe that seemingly
generalizes to many domains and modalities. In this way, QDAIF is a step
towards AI systems that can independently search, diversify, evaluate, and
improve, which are among the core skills underlying human society's capacity
for innovation. | [
0.0744615868,
0.0276372768,
-0.0277074818,
-0.0105969114,
-0.0465512015,
-0.0285418518,
-0.0088052275,
0.0040010652,
-0.0212853868,
-0.0104462579,
0.0012106759,
-0.0664278418,
0.0004680543,
0.0698470995,
-0.006709402,
-0.0185506027,
-0.0041551273,
-0.0031251903,
0.0373537205,
0.0009628299,
-0.008301558,
0.0333394967,
0.0089298515,
0.0656142458,
0.0081095388,
0.0068076188,
0.0044687139,
0.0023246869,
0.0414447747,
-0.0082665384,
-0.0135666113,
0.0624208041,
-0.0120754624,
0.0264007021,
0.0000018277,
-0.0534743853,
0.0080489609,
-0.0257163364,
0.0318074375,
-0.0308090393,
0.0401009358,
0.0701147988,
-0.0287877135,
0.0050947885,
-0.0423523448,
0.0562616698,
0.0332156643,
0.0048222509,
0.0510589294,
0.0557863526,
0.0057828831,
-0.0149941249,
0.0181803051,
-0.026311554,
0.002415559,
0.032885246,
-0.0144610563,
-0.0454477891,
0.072669968,
0.0207411908,
-0.0078856591,
0.0179972462,
0.0129695805,
-0.047595989,
0.0547762699,
0.0314658508,
0.0117504122,
-0.0276215468,
0.0070566777,
0.0307090189,
-0.0189105682,
-0.0174985901,
0.0026887367,
-0.0335416757,
0.0231574867,
-0.0016409297,
-0.0178237241,
0.0247846283,
-0.0263521969,
-0.0004629548,
-0.000161545,
0.0024351955,
-0.0134112509,
0.0231387205,
0.0299715698,
0.0306508616,
0.0296678487,
-0.0293506011,
-0.0000146621,
-0.0065304693,
-0.0178185441,
-0.0552416369,
0.0248815995,
0.0150000909,
-0.0484429486,
0.0079295551,
-0.0284311846,
-0.0564067401,
0.0068428037,
-0.0248704311,
0.0732341856,
0.0003384468,
0.0120345671,
0.017967904,
0.0416893587,
0.0225702599,
-0.0054477816,
-0.0151048377,
-0.0691572428,
0.0085240444,
-0.0470213778,
-0.0330104642,
-0.0272905976,
0.0189907607,
-0.0084249899,
-0.0268070139,
-0.032924559,
0.0222249366,
-0.0163572207,
-0.0335191078,
0.0161529258,
0.0624947622,
-0.0234359186,
-0.0027600599,
-0.0546601564,
-0.0008808651,
-0.0287093446,
0.0048659518,
0.0247738641,
0.0132102584,
0.0204465855,
0.0252093039,
0.0195828415,
-0.0312967673,
0.0217000563,
0.0188602954,
0.0165737271,
-0.032481119,
-0.03255824,
0.0108587705,
-0.0233450308,
-0.010987984,
-0.0033647905,
-0.0600759201,
0.0112766344,
-0.0150691234,
-0.0168649219,
-0.0535513721,
-0.0093239872,
0.0223182235,
-0.0218981411,
-0.0063402192,
-0.0231711678,
0.0252224058,
0.0630187988,
-0.0173962731,
0.0059674112,
0.0197715014,
0.0680040866,
0.020764811,
0.0384085774,
0.0247322731,
0.0634259135,
0.003640685,
-0.033117339,
0.0116300825,
0.0089720339,
0.0034636662,
-0.0600665621,
0.0743602812,
-0.0160104297,
0.0798974037,
-0.0088176169,
0.0152960466,
0.0850294605,
0.0561208539,
0.0740859658,
0.056562975,
0.0613601767,
0.0148135861,
-0.0283890683,
0.0118475789,
0.0330451243,
0.068370454,
0.0221487228,
0.0003649631,
0.0510786176,
0.0322044753,
-0.0050415173,
-0.0767784119,
-0.0157106593,
0.0213319454,
0.0233329665,
-0.0334459804,
-0.0065285154,
0.0220359825,
-0.0316868275,
-0.0457364954,
-0.0054826946,
-0.0737050399,
0.024552647,
-0.0337056071,
0.100138545,
0.1263679415,
0.0855951533,
0.0076744747,
0.0212541185,
-0.0108423568,
-0.0353239216,
0.0443152301,
0.0178783927,
-0.0039616763,
-0.0203294083,
-0.0313459225,
-0.0187720768,
-0.0324119553,
-0.0007090635,
0.0141868116,
-0.0241432451,
0.0245319977,
-0.0041580033,
0.0048145223,
-0.0892278403,
0.040109694,
-0.0144727975,
-0.0057496005,
0.0406029932,
0.0063182134,
-0.0084892968,
0.0412048884,
-0.053002838,
0.0463455692,
-0.0081888372,
-0.0520152003,
-0.082264632,
0.0340523124,
-0.0207818635,
0.0157427248,
0.0102453018,
-0.0959501565,
0.0425536782,
0.0000243367,
0.016427286,
-0.027264392,
0.0525482967,
-0.0588942543,
-0.0398398563,
-0.0399586856,
0.0086279698,
-0.0284644701,
-0.0179480202,
-0.0511559136,
0.062223319,
0.0095676454,
-0.0069172769,
-0.014942416,
0.0151810097,
0.0378707014,
-0.0289664008,
-0.0190086327,
-0.0014141435,
0.0287320111,
0.0415716991,
0.0471206978,
0.0335024223,
-0.0322654694,
-0.0551771112,
-0.060710188,
0.0091852928,
-0.0167520717,
-0.0063868999,
0.0142910276,
0.0138011873,
-0.0160932932,
0.0318843573,
-0.0491575673,
-0.0509497263,
0.0146095566,
0.0004116747,
0.0318976678,
0.0148105435,
0.0146445679,
-0.0259851348,
-0.0057418793,
-0.0036192809,
0.0343837477,
0.0474234819,
0.0574946404,
-0.0436601788,
0.004384086,
-0.0619254708,
-0.0379304998,
0.0160954334,
-0.011300006,
0.0140697407,
-0.0031900981,
0.0498737916,
0.0329918489,
0.0549920946,
-0.0009550349,
0.0594130941,
0.022823235,
-0.0229286589,
0.0225027893,
-0.0178071205,
0.0613473766,
0.032436002,
-0.0356530845,
0.0592729747,
0.0200060457,
0.0320298076,
-0.0200331379,
-0.0745179132,
0.0803525001,
-0.0173407868,
-0.0309972987,
-0.0165399015,
-0.0630424619,
-0.0215432961,
0.052701667,
-0.0223398358,
-0.0272003803,
0.07815817,
0.0262217745,
0.0264075994,
-0.0684202835,
0.0052045733,
-0.0497635975,
0.0288464595,
-0.0552723408,
0.0223022085,
0.0137868337,
0.0586781278,
-0.0498317741,
0.0253045857,
0.0377428494,
-0.0362923183,
0.038024012,
-0.0389236212,
-0.009625054,
0.0165084321,
-0.0275292434,
-0.0263396204,
-0.0048680492,
0.0266916379,
-0.0073403274,
0.0876105279,
0.0160562284,
0.0163168907,
0.0065334425,
0.0246760994,
0.043679174,
-0.0244715028,
0.0009528939,
0.0102301352,
0.0381368399,
0.0572803207,
-0.0104857832,
0.0206876118,
-0.030389471,
0.0020403978,
-0.0225936677,
-0.0316234678,
-0.0110361427,
-0.0006848409,
-0.0044210698,
-0.0025135675,
-0.016379321,
-0.0278902464,
0.0169588588,
0.0310411155,
-0.0156704355,
-0.0540921688,
0.0538453087,
0.045778852,
-0.0358808078,
0.0201018024,
-0.0425137095,
0.0070086499,
0.0059583061,
0.0621692464,
-0.0133753149,
0.0189279709,
-0.0327514,
0.029063981,
-0.0307692196,
0.00165619,
-0.0384461954,
-0.0879113153,
0.050301116,
0.0069696698,
-0.0162302572,
-0.0124519859,
0.012966278,
-0.0368178673,
0.0179041456,
-0.0415619612,
0.0139106307,
0.0130295381,
0.0397172533,
-0.0002215494,
0.0094833244,
-0.0424916111,
-0.0348773114,
-0.0581371672,
0.0147316894,
0.1073940024,
0.0472351126,
0.0042135203,
-0.0643973872,
-0.0335104093,
-0.0259165242,
0.0259066634,
0.0041426993,
-0.006117654,
0.0121382978,
0.0224873908,
-0.0385705493,
0.0190252401,
-0.0110099474,
-0.0251899492,
0.0351660214,
0.0188335925,
-0.0175250005,
-0.014113239,
-0.0730085075,
0.0249724854,
0.0189166367,
0.0482647419,
0.0545893461,
-0.1050510183,
-0.0172024667,
-0.0513882115,
-0.0042932727,
-0.1442783028,
-0.043850746,
-0.0120765986,
0.0193168577,
-0.008937859,
-0.1221147105,
-0.0068101566,
-0.0339020491,
0.0365312919,
0.0280410033,
-0.0053296159,
-0.0490898006,
-0.023683155,
0.0076730917,
-0.015194729,
0.0391498357,
0.0113414275,
-0.0323674493,
-0.0068604178,
-0.0370655507,
-0.0896710232,
-0.0087174224,
0.0115818307,
-0.0803916082,
-0.0511276685,
-0.009129256,
0.033036273,
0.0187885333,
-0.0099735223,
-0.0134044103,
-0.0909977257,
0.0565893762,
0.0329981148,
0.0403039306,
0.0277563166,
-0.0281635486,
0.0273389407,
-0.0006929737,
0.0134864198,
-0.0328967609,
0.0104416311,
0.028879907,
0.0677638128,
0.0479347035,
-0.0182150155,
0.0112312045,
-0.0166270044,
-0.0470791645,
-0.0625150874,
-0.0048630587,
-0.0571264662,
-0.0357639156,
0.0036811144,
-0.043497704,
-0.0347073041,
0.0053602178,
-0.0057432028,
-0.0224740803,
-0.0183037166,
0.016195124,
-0.0273352098,
0.06515681,
-0.0690227523,
0.011171056,
0.0044417731,
0.0115539841,
-0.0149959568,
-0.0147141684,
0.0066332552,
0.049241703,
-0.0570967719,
0.0382543318,
0.0093845874,
0.0364005305,
0.0234185364,
-0.0328040011,
0.0416118465,
0.0545276143,
-0.0703006089,
-0.0238928199,
-0.0267050732,
0.0057168887,
0.049623616,
0.0328681543,
0.0225583278,
-0.006637862,
0.0195293017,
-0.0140998354,
0.0145429773,
0.0033798032,
-0.0357306674,
-0.0329528265,
0.0195563007,
0.0016922764,
-0.0505481251,
0.0667037293,
-0.0634053946,
-0.0096911667,
-0.0325407907,
-0.0000919527,
-0.0270495228,
0.0009250402,
-0.0132581675,
0.026588127,
0.0075653824,
0.0241648443,
-0.0681339651,
0.0025944584,
0.0705038235,
0.0265192986,
0.0586110353,
-0.0194146652,
0.0430479459,
0.0627052411,
-0.0376530588,
0.0109421629,
-0.0501848459,
-0.0517096929,
-0.0427774005,
0.0022356214,
-0.0426055826,
-5.496677706e-33,
-0.0053716516,
-0.0493476056,
-0.0074571809,
-0.0376374312,
-0.0090333968,
-0.0285365079,
-0.0216279477,
0.0079280548,
0.0267056935,
0.0081583839,
-0.0152643286,
0.0048294165,
-0.0261815079,
-0.0069627552,
0.0418477915,
0.0140508236,
0.0306180697,
0.0017474799,
-0.0646514669,
-0.0025030102,
0.0053644571,
0.0019414057,
-0.0055945832,
-0.0011241289,
0.005110316,
-0.0176531393,
-0.027820278,
-0.000410386,
-0.0038573311,
0.0725726858,
0.004356734,
0.0572648309,
0.0352428034,
-0.0458523929,
-0.0019925931,
-0.0208580326,
0.0445485078,
-0.0363816693,
-0.0007513606,
-0.0554655269,
-0.0242738631,
-0.0655065328,
0.0409611054,
0.0170802455,
-0.0451620258,
0.0328574032,
0.0539196171,
-0.0179728381,
-0.0000736654,
-0.0708965138,
-0.0391953997,
0.0142651424,
-0.0202577524,
-0.0389051884,
-0.0589331985,
0.0346283652,
-0.0053963857,
0.0048160451,
-0.0211225841,
0.0837235078,
0.0084445588,
0.0060818521,
0.0416334793,
-0.0223499369,
-0.0263090041,
0.0294113569,
-0.0277934521,
0.0257157944,
-0.0297847651,
-0.0320812091,
0.0065444899,
0.0267918482,
0.061405737,
0.0776441172,
0.00594847,
-0.0157160237,
0.0115029151,
0.055692073,
-0.0448445231,
-0.049404189,
0.0548583567,
0.0276163649,
-0.0338684246,
-0.0295045599,
-0.0034593402,
-0.0406756774,
-0.0349398032,
-0.013420362,
0.0172643214,
0.0165022761,
-0.038398277,
-0.029370131,
-0.0088172946,
-0.021618735,
0.0284600649,
0.0012934061,
-0.0803792849,
0.026236508,
-0.0006619437,
0.0006801882,
-0.0305838976,
0.0053115622,
0.054739207,
0.0491410084,
0.0108385738,
0.009442403,
0.0004686503,
0.020762844,
-0.0456529893,
0.0042063748,
-0.0084202047,
0.0491696298,
0.0130623449,
-0.0182746612,
-0.0164252426,
0.0100421272,
-0.0050882814,
0.0364536047,
0.0469720848,
0.0091862744,
-0.0481444225,
-0.039376393,
-0.0093728788,
0.0075549823,
-0.0289774556,
0.0149145266,
0.0043041348,
-0.0167931225,
0.0158897452,
-0.0311916806,
-0.0507454388,
0.0016780727,
2.576e-7,
0.0189915318,
0.0504534207,
0.0084363855,
0.0057691112,
0.0350798368,
0.0261957888,
-0.0061969529,
0.0229578745,
-0.0234751683,
0.0397075415,
0.0284084082,
0.0156591721,
0.02203051,
0.0137247732,
-0.0503567867,
0.0568940155,
-0.0959290192,
0.034567114,
-0.0745438784,
-0.0219505057,
0.0832611024,
0.0057775248,
0.0221978426,
-0.0169593394,
-0.0174933411,
-0.0212707035,
0.0621144995,
0.0101553621,
0.0172849782,
0.0238252878,
0.0454716273,
-0.0203728564,
-0.0176607706,
-0.028825907,
-0.0212236904,
0.0310445316,
0.02482903,
0.0102133648,
0.0073572635,
-0.0413862728,
0.0547704436,
0.0451272875,
0.0103048142,
-0.0583045036,
0.0370226949,
0.0236886386,
-0.0070606694,
-0.0719834268,
-0.0034032203,
-0.0021992717,
0.0386624821,
-0.074216783,
-0.0093425,
-0.004350882,
0.0007681752,
0.0209526736,
0.0236652642,
-0.0323369317,
-0.0285021402,
-0.0300044883,
-0.0250998195,
-0.0055110455,
-0.0640782565,
0.0213866346,
0.0040581552,
-0.0671779737,
0.0211582109,
2.18215006e-34,
0.0561384745,
-0.0270679779,
0.0011783581,
0.0024211318,
0.042038355,
0.0378955528,
-0.0008227134,
0.0029504946,
0.0041638436,
-0.0193867683,
-0.0469439849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12664v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12664v1 | Is ChatGPT a Financial Expert? Evaluating Language Models on Financial Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-19T11:43:15 | 2023-10-19T11:43:15 | Yue Guo, Zian Xu, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, has
revolutionized general natural language preprocessing (NLP) tasks. However,
their expertise in the financial domain lacks a comprehensive evaluation. To
assess the ability of LLMs to solve financial NLP tasks, we present FinLMEval,
a framework for Financial Language Model Evaluation, comprising nine datasets
designed to evaluate the performance of language models. This study compares
the performance of encoder-only language models and the decoder-only language
models. Our findings reveal that while some decoder-only LLMs demonstrate
notable performance across most financial tasks via zero-shot prompting, they
generally lag behind the fine-tuned expert models, especially when dealing with
proprietary datasets. We hope this study provides foundation evaluations for
continuing efforts to build more advanced LLMs in the financial domain. | [
0.0249957256,
0.0787271559,
-0.0036120433,
0.0194182601,
-0.013714375,
0.0258939378,
0.0266616363,
0.0318279117,
-0.0159013011,
-0.0243155528,
-0.0361048616,
-0.0169498213,
0.0007357162,
0.0499189124,
0.0312787071,
-0.0296562985,
0.0198632441,
-0.0132092005,
0.0532617979,
0.0089022983,
0.0182068236,
0.0053917021,
0.0098194415,
0.0522642024,
0.0202474725,
-0.0043273675,
0.0090811467,
-0.0213824231,
-0.0396884456,
0.0144673754,
-0.0090547213,
0.0375779942,
0.0048823259,
0.0349057838,
0.0000018786,
-0.0504104607,
-0.029098941,
0.0019341543,
-0.0435192399,
0.0117182592,
0.0530633815,
-0.0725441873,
0.0333587267,
0.0200819559,
-0.0539873987,
-0.0187918823,
0.0561936572,
0.0549076498,
0.0805844814,
0.0906261206,
-0.0221064948,
-0.0715316087,
0.0232182778,
-0.0595717803,
-0.0048011206,
-0.0637019053,
0.0050082868,
0.0612465851,
-0.0343885422,
0.0185304135,
-0.0373356082,
0.0531082228,
0.0115240635,
0.0047778538,
0.0227366406,
-0.002885432,
-0.0509050749,
-0.0251841005,
-0.0653828159,
0.0205760952,
-0.0160473511,
0.0550522543,
0.0019225874,
-0.0213605892,
0.001948357,
0.0098078586,
-0.0401178487,
0.0503645837,
0.0062135444,
-0.0030487473,
0.0186307859,
0.022282552,
-0.0030251234,
-0.0213827901,
-0.0129720476,
0.0242215116,
-0.0014017341,
-0.0140412282,
0.0197416134,
0.0288941525,
-0.0118317641,
-0.0450319164,
0.0437707081,
-0.029055465,
0.0347882994,
0.0046034614,
-0.0186770801,
0.0050917068,
-0.0247910954,
-0.0561193302,
0.0201767385,
0.0608135462,
-0.0078964746,
0.0284926575,
-0.0457029939,
0.0494293571,
0.008817289,
-0.0256621577,
-0.019492548,
0.023313351,
-0.0768741295,
-0.019133037,
-0.0698565543,
0.0584104322,
-0.0523723587,
-0.0615558997,
-0.0551172644,
-0.01693248,
0.0229377151,
-0.0006082611,
0.0369588807,
-0.0181031339,
-0.0002565194,
-0.0292247031,
-0.0399733558,
0.0251785349,
-0.02474574,
0.0251001604,
0.0022356571,
-0.047929395,
0.0196571555,
0.0284330118,
-0.0280009117,
-0.0316253938,
0.002783735,
0.0856614336,
0.0176944733,
-0.0246129874,
-0.0422223099,
-0.0491461605,
-0.0018373927,
-0.0057696882,
-0.0229201633,
-0.0207723621,
0.0367378108,
-0.002379291,
-0.0011601971,
-0.0034656376,
-0.0026636329,
-0.0100863706,
-0.0202551689,
0.0877233073,
0.0119075524,
-0.0159621015,
0.0015692213,
-0.0475337803,
-0.0097726006,
0.07305976,
0.0096471617,
0.0130429063,
0.0336682275,
-0.0104058897,
0.0079846857,
0.069642365,
-0.03473242,
-0.0637565702,
-0.0033522863,
0.0208920427,
-0.0138103394,
-0.0177460294,
0.0728108585,
0.0340308547,
-0.0449276678,
-0.004766745,
0.0502290092,
0.0488576293,
0.0833949,
0.0238176808,
0.0199254118,
0.0577400289,
0.0408574603,
-0.0105442619,
0.0231969263,
-0.0114677045,
-0.0518366508,
0.0372908078,
-0.0278844573,
0.0141044538,
-0.0100536114,
-0.0336323865,
-0.0100212563,
-0.0186468139,
0.0111835413,
-0.0135672018,
0.0208187588,
-0.0023964911,
-0.0535427071,
0.0426160432,
0.0037763212,
-0.0191762578,
-0.0075407429,
-0.0203202292,
-0.0029882032,
0.1060878113,
0.0598163418,
0.0378357098,
0.0108983787,
-0.029311521,
-0.0456116982,
0.0569973961,
0.0391209945,
0.0033690422,
-0.0064994381,
-0.0655050203,
-0.0106965769,
0.0162243713,
0.0367275141,
0.035701029,
0.0027148589,
-0.0066752131,
0.0108510796,
-0.0072415383,
-0.0096600633,
0.0144961225,
-0.0006169088,
-0.0424415581,
-0.0018787845,
-0.0416295491,
-0.0083859013,
0.0228145812,
-0.0071853455,
0.0231068004,
-0.020561168,
-0.0220680647,
-0.0299376175,
0.0182452239,
-0.0453065708,
-0.0622827187,
-0.00298746,
-0.0348873027,
-0.0041795089,
-0.0025752534,
-0.0463461429,
-0.0199309345,
-0.0388969667,
-0.0211484693,
0.035562437,
-0.0476214625,
0.0095944609,
0.0173241217,
0.0132426219,
-0.001229248,
0.0604541898,
-0.016040951,
0.0224736109,
-0.0114534087,
0.0225418601,
-0.0138027957,
-0.050892625,
0.0404073372,
0.0086283907,
-0.0338785835,
0.0292691551,
0.039197538,
0.0411225893,
0.0095614754,
-0.0230853688,
-0.0664706975,
-0.0354001671,
-0.0169000681,
0.0394915566,
0.0123941069,
-0.006813121,
-0.0213057939,
-0.0077293399,
-0.0199162941,
-0.0134315109,
0.0000476727,
-0.0034574247,
0.0524467491,
-0.0233418774,
-0.0299655534,
-0.0538471043,
-0.0178639796,
0.0248163324,
0.0281203184,
0.0336304866,
-0.0684205443,
-0.0228666961,
-0.0051818299,
0.0255541075,
-0.0119947996,
-0.0021424303,
0.0076219658,
-0.0025366812,
-0.0089466684,
0.0121915815,
0.0074534975,
-0.0048783277,
0.0821156353,
-0.0676430389,
-0.0284090918,
-0.040314123,
-0.0038438675,
-0.0056854193,
-0.0307670236,
-0.0347107798,
-0.0034322974,
0.0413555726,
0.0884368047,
-0.0200523119,
0.011829895,
-0.0952671468,
0.0306996964,
-0.0063883308,
0.0025461153,
-0.0384320915,
-0.0089088362,
-0.0041376287,
0.0673089847,
-0.0035046835,
-0.012146024,
0.0498078354,
-0.0243151523,
-0.0460132435,
-0.0193044282,
-0.0182623677,
-0.0660435036,
0.0313417241,
-0.0259802844,
0.0005108787,
0.0090328036,
-0.0797729641,
-0.0072127567,
0.0026128134,
0.0453390032,
-0.0151285399,
0.0138837164,
-0.0326642208,
0.0312776789,
0.0035617752,
0.0188526139,
-0.0095321536,
-0.0713648796,
-0.0252343901,
0.0244742651,
0.0737115219,
-0.0232169013,
-0.0560361855,
0.0507926084,
-0.0486425273,
-0.0084171975,
0.0087866392,
-0.0236018207,
-0.0053375922,
0.0289831813,
0.06239767,
0.0056444295,
-0.0007200951,
-0.0377809554,
0.0576932766,
-0.016964348,
-0.0079146689,
0.0070981062,
0.0027228531,
0.0188738666,
0.0065868655,
-0.0577099957,
-0.0018574849,
0.0233927555,
-0.0183457267,
-0.0503995381,
-0.003574559,
0.1155502722,
0.0216175634,
0.0209538583,
-0.0017227292,
0.0085624559,
0.0168197732,
-0.030262135,
0.0133097079,
-0.1139091924,
-0.053215228,
-0.0016465548,
0.0013991534,
0.0359428525,
-0.0303420182,
-0.0177809335,
-0.128027454,
0.0407027788,
-0.0165784005,
-0.0135351727,
-0.0201148577,
-0.010917794,
-0.0648422986,
-0.0634864345,
0.034045402,
0.0387511142,
-0.028166661,
0.0284280665,
0.0204761103,
-0.0790376589,
-0.0361976512,
0.0022748858,
0.0024075436,
-0.0103766937,
0.0450845957,
-0.0187911578,
-0.0069170748,
-0.0103083076,
-0.0435764827,
0.0156850982,
0.0077752154,
-0.0056768786,
0.0462765135,
-0.0312465113,
-0.0169701651,
0.011058853,
0.0110090794,
-0.0380984396,
0.0499817468,
0.005301056,
-0.0197394677,
-0.0271128528,
-0.0032490429,
0.0139120761,
0.0345123298,
-0.0244028401,
0.0951383635,
0.0258555543,
-0.0388917029,
-0.0256044529,
-0.0492275916,
-0.0024736875,
-0.045245111,
-0.044998236,
0.0098896259,
0.0326447412,
-0.0331156626,
-0.1010492817,
-0.0801367089,
0.0449809805,
0.0113834469,
-0.0095292954,
-0.0070975032,
0.0511292145,
-0.0177540313,
-0.0139664337,
0.042103529,
-0.0544073023,
-0.0057979142,
-0.0548922829,
0.0221985504,
0.0094479565,
0.0046085618,
-0.0560580716,
0.0456001125,
-0.0624192804,
-0.0255591422,
0.0051404885,
0.0213988647,
0.0308886711,
-0.0242883768,
-0.0375140496,
0.021459857,
0.0068333307,
0.0469106995,
-0.0832463875,
-0.0203225259,
0.0659402534,
0.0224427748,
-0.0052432227,
0.0265705828,
-0.0240235422,
0.022308344,
-0.0562719516,
0.072433129,
-0.0236475058,
-0.0177602563,
0.0256062746,
0.0162513815,
0.0207041111,
0.0025682042,
-0.0010185468,
-0.0171307679,
-0.031943962,
-0.0286861379,
0.0221265387,
-0.0694580525,
-0.0234267823,
0.0691203251,
0.0172334928,
-0.0059735444,
0.0126278289,
-0.0463419147,
-0.0152738784,
-0.0075932583,
0.0293287169,
0.00954461,
-0.0151168425,
0.0050174827,
-0.0423365794,
0.0208809227,
0.0131183881,
0.0236213412,
-0.0218713656,
-0.001899928,
0.0196463615,
0.003453406,
0.0422317162,
-0.0275548659,
-0.0013476179,
0.0002563743,
-0.0397267416,
0.0047396389,
0.0519128256,
0.0359550007,
-0.0452261381,
0.0196871907,
-0.0492005609,
0.0213092994,
-0.0001304743,
0.0068476293,
0.0283337459,
-0.0401341282,
0.0351226144,
-0.0011117628,
-0.052143842,
-0.0611527786,
0.112072967,
0.0146707157,
0.018745074,
-0.0452657938,
-0.000265142,
-0.0447182879,
-0.0447182842,
0.0372542553,
-0.0100195715,
-0.0174650662,
0.0171142984,
-0.080265373,
-0.0354247279,
-0.02635796,
-0.0039840909,
0.002224931,
0.0055850777,
0.0476347618,
0.0491718985,
-0.0128175383,
0.0197447576,
0.0057879454,
0.0058396184,
-0.0184873398,
-0.0129119214,
-0.0879086405,
-6.143905998e-33,
-0.0374317989,
0.009634071,
0.0464246087,
-0.007378262,
0.02654103,
0.0133333011,
-0.0091455309,
0.0022270752,
0.0192428213,
0.0064099408,
0.0074874405,
0.0202512816,
0.0208110772,
0.0164524186,
0.0179769639,
-0.0010155286,
0.0480552912,
-0.0351103283,
-0.0158588123,
-0.0443038084,
-0.0018990913,
0.0599346757,
0.071515657,
-0.0374333449,
0.0459676534,
0.0132786082,
-0.0282239951,
-0.0015768391,
0.0880439803,
0.04250893,
-0.0137605984,
0.0313365273,
0.00617187,
-0.1112226322,
-0.0390818119,
-0.00244008,
-0.048089698,
-0.0355908237,
0.0443030111,
0.0519150905,
0.0048712585,
-0.0085330857,
0.0367519222,
-0.0302884001,
-0.0398913957,
0.0217881333,
0.0007747024,
-0.0201643668,
0.0142943338,
-0.0218531881,
-0.0609919392,
0.0555105656,
-0.0077876532,
0.013660837,
0.0851902962,
0.0766620636,
-0.0154979974,
0.0001092207,
0.0123904683,
0.0083226645,
0.0255698878,
0.0125133106,
0.04122556,
-0.029280046,
-0.0145894103,
0.035082899,
0.0006222178,
-0.0096823862,
-0.0105389468,
0.0290147047,
0.0231592897,
0.0670368448,
0.0418126024,
0.0254182126,
0.0313036181,
-0.0366720222,
0.0101902904,
0.0313291028,
0.0074051027,
0.0253625643,
-0.0054422268,
0.0363988355,
-0.0402584933,
-0.0509712473,
-0.0151581801,
-0.0001111568,
-0.0142202815,
-0.0145959826,
0.0382635854,
0.0086768847,
0.0138883153,
0.0156328734,
0.0478663184,
-0.0424749851,
-0.0302910488,
-0.0001584108,
0.0032910814,
0.0306369737,
-0.0101577574,
0.0173735321,
-0.0304552037,
-0.0265970211,
0.0305437837,
0.0063584065,
-0.0139202802,
-0.0387205668,
0.0043667229,
-0.0034630084,
-0.0430165306,
-0.008647861,
0.0034958667,
0.0264024623,
-0.0119036268,
0.0496114679,
0.0266830921,
0.0297378544,
-0.0354434997,
0.0033350301,
-0.003929324,
0.0036591394,
-0.0216642339,
-0.003484275,
-0.0001788284,
0.0558003671,
0.0157380197,
0.0250808764,
-0.0126271006,
0.028733829,
0.0582554229,
0.0129097477,
-0.0265810508,
0.0502405018,
2.549e-7,
0.0646700487,
0.0934180096,
0.037020985,
0.0034219436,
0.0046803099,
0.0285302643,
-0.0199523903,
-0.0158517361,
0.0155640701,
-0.0098261358,
0.0206439216,
0.0076573994,
0.080135189,
-0.0208824407,
-0.0688214004,
-0.0635314658,
-0.0670356154,
0.0190663692,
-0.0538281128,
0.0240827035,
0.0527064428,
0.0742203593,
-0.0253792852,
-0.0136671551,
-0.0207637828,
-0.0864391103,
0.0549061373,
-0.0451907516,
-0.0489434898,
0.0148550607,
0.0332463421,
0.0305137094,
0.0020983289,
0.022729449,
0.0033189484,
0.0205629654,
0.0507326163,
0.0614809915,
0.0110373162,
0.0107963877,
0.0051607657,
0.0024582262,
-0.0432188883,
-0.0188322905,
0.0408800617,
-0.0827944204,
-0.0354299434,
-0.0324984975,
-0.0685058832,
0.0264280383,
0.041111026,
0.0091270236,
-0.0205823015,
0.0299736969,
0.0570562743,
0.0041207881,
-0.0125714922,
-0.0262685213,
-0.0204572678,
0.024301542,
-0.0271315034,
0.0416623205,
-0.0451914258,
0.0118664587,
0.026248794,
-0.0635466278,
0.0010797556,
2.257821591e-34,
0.0624640174,
-0.008401867,
0.0017126043,
0.0498974696,
0.0788015649,
0.0109112104,
-0.0029835035,
0.0617802665,
-0.0391780362,
-0.0950984433,
0.0029383164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13031v1 | A Use Case: Reformulating Query Rewriting as a Statistical Machine Translation Problem | 2023-10-19T11:37:14 | 2023-10-19T11:37:14 | Abdullah Can Algan, Emre Yürekli, Aykut Çayır | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One of the most important challenges for modern search engines is to retrieve
relevant web content based on user queries. In order to achieve this challenge,
search engines have a module to rewrite user queries. That is why modern web
search engines utilize some statistical and neural models used in the natural
language processing domain. Statistical machine translation is a well-known NLP
method among them. The paper proposes a query rewriting pipeline based on a
monolingual machine translation model that learns to rewrite Arabic user search
queries. This paper also describes preprocessing steps to create a mapping
between user queries and web page titles. | [
0.0737867057,
0.0147176869,
-0.0170515329,
-0.0017693156,
-0.0578193516,
0.0168483444,
0.0162572749,
0.0024017971,
-0.0103862807,
-0.0504004881,
-0.0079039074,
-0.0318658873,
-0.0211682003,
0.0307661928,
0.0399875008,
-0.0729574114,
0.0109664602,
0.0001857544,
-0.0311012845,
0.0177350044,
0.0200630613,
0.0129628778,
0.0309368465,
0.0306948796,
0.0138556603,
0.0148304636,
-0.0240378417,
0.0424311943,
-0.0364207923,
0.0304396283,
0.0242184922,
0.0467644371,
-0.0161189679,
0.0467152596,
0.0000014431,
-0.0571749806,
-0.057517007,
-0.0073911296,
0.0116557376,
0.0060888757,
0.0482423082,
-0.0218036342,
-0.0220932104,
0.0545131937,
-0.0097178817,
0.0421622433,
0.0378949195,
0.0316901617,
0.0702859983,
0.0704313964,
0.0151229119,
-0.0815105811,
-0.0063815112,
0.0022410897,
0.0295375846,
-0.0375088491,
0.0051915739,
-0.0310347676,
-0.0001783683,
0.0051702224,
-0.003279103,
0.0612670332,
-0.0279508103,
-0.0380725861,
-0.0124119166,
-0.0456162877,
-0.0510994531,
-0.0061236923,
0.0270847287,
0.0313585438,
-0.0613061935,
-0.0189519059,
0.0052698916,
0.040614374,
-0.0047166799,
0.0582401492,
-0.020604128,
-0.0088692242,
-0.0090955887,
-0.0206501018,
0.0223754477,
-0.0360668264,
0.0092920391,
-0.0005703737,
-0.084516488,
0.0369299948,
0.0290694535,
-0.0130834794,
-0.0091972491,
-0.0146512603,
0.0627493262,
-0.0292828977,
0.0850695074,
0.0179382302,
-0.007024026,
0.0337288305,
-0.0621572398,
-0.0404550917,
0.02732867,
-0.121493347,
-0.0036143519,
0.0378106162,
0.0319789276,
0.0460412689,
-0.0579341948,
0.0281752627,
0.0240868218,
0.0221266337,
-0.090983972,
-0.0216789786,
-0.057971999,
-0.01317963,
-0.0564300083,
0.016866073,
-0.0242381375,
0.0197311547,
-0.0688753054,
0.0541734993,
0.0451949723,
-0.002573516,
0.0011214904,
-0.0144607592,
-0.0327624753,
-0.0440494828,
-0.0339275971,
0.0287516657,
0.0317819118,
-0.0235414319,
-0.0182615053,
-0.0554375462,
-0.0033787698,
0.0259066671,
0.0286201611,
-0.0009002757,
-0.0189768896,
0.0316579752,
-0.0149897449,
-0.0111168809,
-0.0759060159,
-0.0503684208,
0.0225030202,
0.0649691075,
-0.0074687372,
-0.0464789867,
0.0666184425,
-0.0124515211,
-0.0121495184,
0.0149995098,
-0.0041015409,
0.0498802923,
0.0028474589,
0.0593997799,
0.0419894308,
0.0242965594,
0.0684139282,
-0.0048482395,
0.047269661,
0.0289028455,
0.0075826282,
0.0371484347,
0.0375071429,
0.0084435325,
0.049570471,
0.0179134663,
0.008665367,
0.0130975656,
-0.007777303,
0.0340860039,
0.0225438345,
0.048785381,
-0.0213984735,
0.0459838621,
-0.0066110496,
-0.0191451423,
0.0429955088,
0.036518503,
0.0237262249,
0.013931185,
0.0596919097,
0.0173515715,
0.0071007456,
-0.0005016011,
-0.0220710915,
-0.0019859991,
0.0124607226,
0.0064275009,
0.0185636226,
0.0527198128,
-0.0155652948,
-0.0318337642,
0.0337886438,
-0.0134231336,
-0.0191822648,
0.0021537112,
0.0474164225,
0.0169731136,
-0.0429374985,
-0.0464209169,
-0.0472235121,
-0.0088437693,
0.0633482188,
-0.0750641376,
-0.0771025047,
0.0849413797,
0.0558727831,
-0.0145113636,
-0.0338618979,
-0.0526040047,
-0.0222865716,
-0.008480696,
0.0582673289,
-0.023464635,
-0.0137507971,
-0.0195319802,
-0.0553677157,
0.0483293347,
0.0267950371,
0.0094486391,
0.0106961858,
0.0116662541,
0.0619109459,
-0.042032212,
-0.0459207967,
0.0422240831,
-0.0177113041,
-0.0113103446,
0.0456920154,
0.0177370645,
0.008652484,
0.0195848513,
-0.0054557994,
0.0324252807,
-0.0195534304,
-0.0107597187,
-0.0582249053,
-0.0211712718,
0.0232907403,
-0.0058674216,
0.0072158705,
-0.0719493553,
0.0302470196,
0.0231853966,
-0.0370276086,
-0.056321457,
0.0155185508,
-0.047100503,
0.0194475539,
-0.0341295339,
0.0800551623,
-0.0126421144,
-0.0037767366,
-0.1091667935,
0.0013852853,
0.0174726546,
-0.013139951,
-0.0190799534,
-0.0651181564,
0.0191583429,
-0.0317933895,
-0.0134563074,
0.030258825,
-0.0097297542,
0.0430259705,
0.0391095728,
-0.0114622647,
-0.0387150943,
0.0073829731,
-0.0435766764,
-0.0174661949,
-0.0143783242,
0.0351110958,
0.039873004,
0.0659481212,
-0.0150515884,
-0.0318287797,
-0.020003628,
-0.0744123384,
-0.0092662945,
0.0288659278,
0.0337258689,
0.0059083267,
-0.0228224862,
-0.0203392264,
-0.0451255739,
-0.0077834767,
0.0308131576,
0.0183726661,
-0.0354114659,
-0.0076792086,
0.0071833357,
-0.0189754292,
-0.0179110821,
0.0191583224,
-0.0238493178,
-0.0453197286,
-0.0427313522,
0.0149101969,
0.0420851186,
0.0354465097,
-0.0470664836,
0.0174112283,
-0.0006157976,
-0.0248593837,
0.0030522067,
-0.0491826497,
-0.0460237488,
-0.0049975668,
-0.0900155306,
0.1019309685,
-0.0462734737,
0.0202973858,
-0.0116019892,
-0.0053237262,
0.0041818488,
-0.0227177422,
-0.0112440474,
-0.0484563336,
0.038378153,
0.0390523858,
0.077315338,
0.0079486407,
-0.0383036919,
0.0631661341,
0.0394874364,
0.0350580737,
-0.0667732581,
-0.0118279941,
-0.0317167826,
0.0039209034,
-0.0390271395,
0.0686369017,
-0.0506108403,
-0.0362479016,
-0.0318659544,
-0.0030385412,
0.0414226167,
-0.0452803895,
-0.0134271262,
-0.0309187304,
0.0007494837,
-0.0116389534,
-0.0173558071,
-0.0040897662,
-0.025933573,
0.0117974728,
-0.0326391868,
0.0276188906,
-0.0213912539,
-0.0587477311,
0.0489743017,
0.0488228127,
0.046663098,
-0.0172125828,
-0.0421160236,
0.0096791135,
-0.001527609,
0.031707719,
-0.0133222137,
-0.0408102721,
0.021494098,
0.0136337141,
0.0152118504,
0.0069417385,
-0.0499017425,
0.0119658522,
-0.012558423,
0.0398000404,
-0.0903245136,
-0.0292644836,
-0.0196083207,
-0.0642328411,
-0.0420644134,
0.0266038273,
0.0664604455,
0.0576389171,
-0.0329589844,
-0.0412458219,
-0.0165542252,
-0.0217728559,
0.0193684436,
0.0633405447,
-0.0362601317,
0.0251748804,
0.0242951177,
0.0494790375,
0.0131407976,
0.0231869929,
0.0071982238,
-0.0494729951,
0.0048136748,
-0.0306672007,
-0.0411882736,
-0.0398407653,
-0.0682817027,
-0.0131613044,
-0.0242744815,
-0.0160122346,
0.0171248075,
-0.0218495112,
0.0323404223,
0.0366195999,
0.0234284159,
-0.0586451963,
-0.0434304848,
-0.0688936263,
-0.0185754318,
0.0778542757,
0.0342746973,
0.0061410656,
0.0314795226,
-0.0170405321,
-0.0128957378,
0.001627289,
-0.0123790242,
0.0324302353,
-0.0056504323,
0.0112205083,
-0.0126215694,
-0.0414008722,
-0.0327073112,
0.0742992312,
0.0103036407,
0.0445060953,
-0.0432167239,
0.0426337346,
-0.0190109294,
-0.0319379605,
-0.0344534628,
0.0257531535,
-0.01745506,
-0.0017262327,
-0.0611460172,
-0.049884215,
-0.0142246699,
-0.0496035703,
-0.020576369,
-0.0145926801,
-0.0508591682,
-0.0036686342,
-0.0734429136,
-0.0358688161,
0.0128701758,
0.0359752364,
0.057794299,
0.034317065,
0.0514945872,
-0.0270874556,
-0.0570259877,
-0.0559967943,
-0.0268799029,
0.043570105,
-0.0341528282,
0.015706785,
0.0513423309,
-0.0508824028,
0.0012344258,
-0.017154213,
-0.0071995263,
-0.0520392917,
-0.0152912736,
0.0183931999,
0.019079335,
0.0047065932,
-0.0362229086,
-0.0459957644,
-0.0041459054,
0.0025240637,
-0.0037543077,
-0.0467163175,
0.0142429229,
0.0281416513,
-0.0314123705,
0.0481074899,
-0.0107209366,
-0.0391559713,
-0.031196136,
0.0061733685,
-0.0075811171,
-0.0501372665,
0.0955837294,
0.0182559732,
0.0083307782,
-0.005876991,
-0.0223364644,
-0.019067008,
0.0464629419,
-0.0268793385,
-0.0102615282,
0.0063665211,
0.0195908137,
0.0651973188,
0.0268508177,
0.0117760701,
0.0034716141,
-0.0321234353,
-0.046529837,
-0.0200612936,
-0.0129164206,
-0.0251885504,
0.0024173178,
0.0087434892,
0.0329398103,
0.015675202,
0.0030998583,
0.0313951485,
0.0125813438,
-0.0385469086,
-0.0222293474,
0.023935914,
0.0150415981,
-0.0181227196,
0.052715715,
-0.0506174713,
-0.0350899324,
-0.0107626608,
-0.004837113,
0.0376819372,
-0.0190318339,
-0.011410973,
0.0243055485,
-0.0214697067,
0.0010400887,
0.0311198719,
0.0183915887,
0.021597201,
0.0084221736,
-0.0192926954,
0.009422835,
-0.000541552,
0.0682232305,
0.0017813052,
-0.0108835548,
-0.0019782132,
-0.0595002025,
-0.0143358121,
-0.002517838,
0.0316725858,
0.0111286575,
-0.0496532694,
-0.0504777469,
0.0084147789,
-0.0473502688,
-0.0028252506,
-0.0095891831,
0.0465496406,
-0.0089436024,
0.0528860316,
0.1387064755,
0.0172821879,
-0.0048321281,
-0.0553574003,
0.0098493891,
-0.0205527972,
-0.0490369536,
-0.0249128416,
-5.736563042e-33,
0.0165725853,
-0.0028311554,
0.0337531306,
0.0036400948,
-0.0026576314,
-0.0292283855,
-0.0197621286,
-0.0113259517,
-0.04194187,
-0.0185990166,
-0.0335213505,
0.0314334594,
0.0366833843,
0.0073577752,
0.0154779116,
-0.0100492314,
0.0316644385,
0.0048211482,
-0.0058634984,
0.0212078672,
0.0206032116,
0.05582086,
0.0546693578,
-0.0413532257,
0.0104502905,
-0.0153984372,
-0.0224802308,
0.0419676565,
0.0289368145,
0.0251131561,
0.0059063188,
-0.0123847816,
0.040453434,
-0.0313007608,
0.0208630376,
-0.0310707055,
-0.0533025898,
0.0025693015,
0.0170246772,
0.0532793663,
0.0259189457,
-0.0095863706,
0.0301479492,
-0.0421255231,
-0.0041979905,
0.072256498,
0.0307335425,
-0.0049790824,
-0.0181989651,
-0.0440097079,
-0.0697829649,
0.0239198226,
-0.005768043,
0.0044900216,
0.0234411061,
0.0677255988,
-0.0019473552,
0.014043537,
0.0237750597,
0.0292462111,
-0.0245145075,
0.0646199286,
0.0882438049,
0.0658830106,
-0.0295670982,
-0.0127458479,
0.0188990142,
0.0135227628,
0.0437105633,
0.0219937526,
0.0066881599,
-0.0420264862,
0.0438490659,
0.0230240077,
-0.0180404987,
-0.0063247802,
0.008354716,
0.0792630762,
-0.0012242186,
0.0058547808,
0.0154207489,
0.0293785781,
-0.036178235,
-0.0234472547,
-0.0354654416,
0.0041105552,
-0.0449462421,
0.0123111969,
0.0121921347,
0.0311113335,
-0.0407663174,
0.0346952341,
-0.0118580116,
-0.0170949791,
0.0078947954,
-0.0163686275,
0.0170818157,
-0.0165252667,
-0.0062945173,
0.0324360467,
0.0255945623,
0.0093626203,
-0.0144864991,
0.0103854295,
-0.0356210135,
-0.0396990627,
-0.0077985292,
0.0338446908,
-0.0436731614,
0.0116495062,
-0.0147551168,
-0.0192245394,
0.0000179738,
0.0250657815,
0.0010469994,
0.0273790862,
0.0082563339,
-0.0180459358,
0.078698568,
-0.0084284693,
-0.0322801769,
-0.0408653319,
-0.0013315534,
0.0251254532,
-0.0279946383,
0.0215433333,
-0.04645532,
0.0215190444,
0.0315582007,
-0.0810801238,
-0.0155194933,
-0.0114349565,
2.398e-7,
0.0685328469,
0.0556707568,
-0.0126454039,
0.0489028804,
-0.034982942,
0.0105289109,
0.030100774,
0.0316989236,
0.0199206527,
0.0743866563,
0.0521317534,
-0.0376482159,
0.011605856,
-0.0214791913,
-0.1073696837,
-0.0287912693,
-0.0058322861,
-0.0052444115,
-0.0472619459,
0.0023250401,
0.0456262752,
0.1088107303,
-0.0173054729,
0.0006758314,
-0.0412446447,
-0.0636693239,
-0.0177943278,
-0.0061391685,
-0.0268011205,
0.0414699316,
0.068269901,
0.0222011711,
0.0082781455,
-0.0043016919,
-0.0381619334,
0.0008248761,
0.0747084171,
0.045078557,
0.0053852019,
0.0218522158,
0.0012984375,
-0.0494497307,
0.0054834229,
-0.0763762742,
0.0355760306,
0.0286949966,
0.0126471352,
0.0304951649,
-0.0119514577,
0.015952494,
0.0648666173,
-0.0755668879,
-0.022963509,
0.0161129031,
0.0453395471,
0.0442932248,
0.009447501,
-0.020237809,
-0.0023140148,
-0.0337947942,
0.0026304591,
0.0113761351,
-0.0213901792,
0.0384044684,
-0.014306291,
0.0153039508,
0.0107291788,
2.088996266e-34,
0.0496479049,
0.0195766091,
-0.0463916734,
-0.0105791753,
0.031071445,
-0.007512975,
-0.0430003554,
0.0275444873,
0.004639389,
-0.0631965697,
-0.0528640598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12648v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12648v2 | Towards Real-World Streaming Speech Translation for Code-Switched Speech | 2023-10-19T11:15:02 | 2023-10-23T11:47:53 | Belen Alastruey, Matthias Sperber, Christian Gollan, Dominic Telaar, Tim Ng, Aashish Agarwal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code-switching (CS), i.e. mixing different languages in a single sentence, is
a common phenomenon in communication and can be challenging in many Natural
Language Processing (NLP) settings. Previous studies on CS speech have shown
promising results for end-to-end speech translation (ST), but have been limited
to offline scenarios and to translation to one of the languages present in the
source (\textit{monolingual transcription}).
In this paper, we focus on two essential yet unexplored areas for real-world
CS speech translation: streaming settings, and translation to a third language
(i.e., a language not included in the source). To this end, we extend the
Fisher and Miami test and validation datasets to include new targets in Spanish
and German. Using this data, we train a model for both offline and streaming ST
and we establish baseline results for the two settings mentioned earlier. | [
-0.027447734,
0.0299358461,
-0.0109479018,
0.0153249213,
-0.0448620766,
0.0215737801,
0.017456416,
0.0011342438,
-0.0321573503,
-0.0130170863,
-0.0437779091,
-0.0237711668,
0.0543991476,
0.0562615469,
0.0642315,
-0.0085911462,
0.0529347099,
-0.0408932157,
-0.0424512066,
0.0181614775,
0.011004407,
0.0144618815,
-0.0272692814,
0.0201211888,
-0.0020908425,
-0.0157324355,
0.010956171,
0.0530451722,
0.0256898552,
-0.0135154594,
-0.0100358734,
0.0018415964,
0.0270172749,
0.0391640104,
0.0000017706,
-0.009484387,
-0.0494058467,
0.0081162285,
-0.0338103995,
-0.0094252387,
0.0320106372,
-0.0365573876,
-0.0209658407,
0.0710706189,
-0.0395242237,
-0.0319180451,
0.0559976846,
-0.0408938043,
0.0285762511,
0.0969879031,
-0.0284543447,
-0.0328609087,
0.0010947601,
-0.0348573998,
-0.0423424765,
-0.0347744972,
-0.0013965189,
-0.015829308,
-0.0185404979,
-0.0198366102,
-0.0261229537,
0.0725354552,
-0.0039675981,
0.0001990824,
-0.0256537627,
-0.022749763,
-0.0785999447,
-0.0077333148,
-0.0063692322,
0.0583104938,
-0.0655741543,
-0.0129021546,
0.0334545858,
-0.0217228495,
-0.0189915113,
-0.0838258192,
-0.0151288603,
0.0087542702,
-0.0130856754,
-0.0174347479,
-0.0065616965,
0.0338258743,
0.0104684932,
-0.0469046645,
-0.0644895434,
0.0003610511,
0.0297880117,
-0.0153116658,
-0.0079345535,
-0.0113099143,
0.031584505,
-0.0231691524,
0.0321363732,
-0.0254368987,
-0.0190125052,
0.0135793434,
-0.0256114416,
-0.0336479582,
-0.0316081271,
-0.0344837122,
0.057440985,
0.0663819388,
-0.0432929322,
0.0105965743,
0.0092119211,
0.0500408858,
-0.0137001583,
0.0158384088,
-0.0220263898,
0.012563847,
-0.0362046883,
0.0269957706,
-0.0656944215,
-0.0230073743,
-0.0331518538,
-0.0187893528,
-0.0054608434,
0.0066905278,
0.0150132282,
0.0069493568,
0.0151491137,
-0.0534071736,
-0.0345681794,
0.0249292329,
0.063057214,
0.0631698444,
-0.0043316595,
-0.0000778723,
0.0252494421,
-0.1088732257,
-0.0055603236,
0.0203450844,
0.0038895491,
-0.000765936,
-0.0104261991,
0.050273288,
-0.0041260202,
-0.0095886132,
0.008847299,
0.0159782842,
-0.0446339846,
-0.0618863069,
0.0067352029,
-0.0552950427,
0.0571592525,
0.0212417115,
0.046733588,
-0.0525419936,
-0.0160912927,
-0.0343251154,
0.0186486859,
0.0656228215,
-0.0184075292,
0.0187314227,
0.0047235601,
-0.0331861153,
-0.0490349457,
0.1074299365,
0.0741470456,
-0.0554854013,
0.0564111136,
-0.0342031866,
-0.00450736,
0.0874166936,
-0.0084120324,
0.0259476658,
-0.0299492385,
-0.0106954984,
0.0456948727,
0.0344980843,
0.0252632182,
0.0167827234,
-0.0394449942,
0.0243999455,
0.0158528872,
0.0131493872,
0.047887072,
0.0207148474,
0.0408791117,
0.0379739441,
0.007386873,
0.0035403261,
0.0129611911,
0.0030068527,
0.0208661053,
0.0067293672,
0.0550216064,
0.0372237638,
-0.0311785825,
-0.003360355,
-0.0087875817,
-0.0240545869,
0.0200530924,
-0.0359180644,
0.0089354813,
0.0044276104,
-0.0355879143,
0.0135456799,
-0.0027220137,
-0.0594935454,
0.0294408947,
-0.0244592112,
-0.0538788997,
0.0762685835,
0.03164123,
0.0262067169,
-0.0025629716,
-0.0440827645,
0.0082350709,
0.0341980308,
0.0215975121,
0.0090253958,
0.0791995004,
-0.052483853,
0.0266789645,
0.0185946766,
0.0150581766,
0.0522700362,
-0.0096636647,
0.0373369381,
-0.017094275,
0.0074647926,
-0.0383917615,
-0.0132141504,
-0.0250366461,
0.0290059391,
0.0347772278,
-0.0120662972,
0.0163377132,
-0.0153197972,
-0.0405993834,
0.0203321334,
-0.0123658851,
-0.0230637025,
0.0025164909,
0.0675426573,
-0.0059662713,
-0.0556422956,
0.0073820809,
-0.0731297359,
0.0000873866,
0.0583788678,
0.0109447902,
-0.0601592511,
0.0073565897,
-0.0190683659,
0.0414690487,
-0.0065564057,
0.0538438261,
0.0084036803,
0.0201638825,
0.0158358533,
-0.0261994712,
0.0181972608,
0.019693451,
-0.0155306794,
-0.0277298298,
0.0235532988,
-0.0579993501,
0.0189389028,
0.0638037398,
-0.032833077,
0.003558011,
-0.0174415056,
0.0072481111,
-0.022350274,
-0.0148338601,
-0.0441089086,
0.0331075862,
-0.0374817625,
0.0422252528,
0.0380105786,
0.0184651949,
-0.0173670128,
0.0025334843,
-0.0314747244,
0.0076046572,
0.0036197517,
0.0161013696,
-0.0191370994,
-0.0269684084,
0.0066203894,
-0.0491789281,
0.0123423757,
0.0093065333,
0.0333366692,
-0.0332967229,
-0.045286689,
-0.0915998891,
0.0192280989,
0.0063279346,
0.0021220522,
0.0153505709,
-0.0446917042,
0.0213338546,
0.0122138541,
0.0541267917,
0.0202718992,
-0.0095526827,
-0.0471168533,
0.0242436044,
-0.046907261,
-0.0535696037,
-0.0128972875,
0.0483812205,
-0.0369425304,
-0.0301686749,
-0.0238774419,
0.0370535702,
0.0300121382,
0.0137685882,
0.0379387289,
-0.071306102,
-0.0730873644,
-0.0379171968,
-0.0190058667,
0.0225761663,
0.0005278028,
-0.0238699205,
0.0528370999,
-0.0037941365,
-0.0363333598,
-0.0002406261,
-0.0520019941,
-0.0561991334,
-0.0599326454,
-0.0010033452,
-0.0151473982,
-0.0040522353,
-0.0384626016,
-0.0095766969,
0.0122700436,
-0.03067361,
-0.021028107,
-0.0002799958,
0.0003003803,
-0.0410394259,
0.021836875,
-0.0553451627,
0.0059760893,
-0.0105729848,
-0.0367694534,
0.0060813851,
-0.0043439353,
-0.0402092673,
-0.0235716086,
0.0631272495,
-0.0528990068,
-0.0036729635,
0.0233548079,
-0.0062593985,
0.094849728,
-0.0219343174,
-0.0069428743,
-0.0031411143,
0.0386261791,
-0.0100341598,
-0.0106309243,
-0.0085704001,
-0.0254264586,
0.0188833699,
-0.0112221735,
0.0568204634,
0.0616143532,
-0.0456918143,
-0.0204024483,
0.0533539988,
0.0285529699,
-0.0605453327,
0.0053503797,
0.0446698405,
-0.0223360024,
-0.0244041607,
0.0898282677,
0.0200974736,
-0.0544776805,
-0.0221917238,
-0.0136313103,
0.0503448546,
0.0290243346,
0.0313082859,
-0.0846655741,
-0.02467422,
0.0183584988,
0.0481659956,
0.0209831949,
0.0256414656,
-0.0621507205,
-0.0723545179,
0.0325509571,
0.0525366329,
-0.0617158823,
-0.0565710142,
-0.004498479,
-0.015356143,
-0.0372520797,
0.0104570333,
-0.0082268957,
-0.0070083374,
-0.025811322,
0.0154525926,
-0.0319960676,
-0.0027652418,
-0.0084557505,
-0.022374412,
0.075645268,
0.0851943716,
0.0247611292,
0.0047170152,
-0.0259170178,
0.0470075719,
-0.0221955087,
0.0026383873,
-0.0064020692,
0.0141761433,
-0.014690279,
-0.0127413953,
0.0456312858,
0.0052295718,
-0.0256974027,
0.007415195,
0.0289447755,
0.0330698304,
0.0068808785,
-0.0022851853,
0.0479844175,
0.0411310755,
0.0366150104,
0.026853025,
0.029445447,
-0.0648042858,
0.0120616937,
-0.0188230667,
0.0142365992,
-0.0354740061,
-0.0118515352,
0.0055920216,
-0.0022467861,
-0.052782245,
-0.0638854206,
0.0109006939,
0.0159599613,
0.0647116601,
0.0083808983,
0.0154210432,
0.0404480137,
0.0069536264,
-0.003514284,
-0.0071793604,
-0.0319396108,
0.0429552086,
-0.0516844764,
-0.0108601106,
0.048303131,
-0.0349662304,
0.0126550216,
0.0187049285,
-0.1233886853,
-0.0812815502,
0.0051193251,
-0.0162755139,
0.028444713,
0.0619873554,
-0.0550095774,
-0.006632688,
-0.0650345087,
-0.0235199202,
-0.0513571166,
0.0254213288,
0.0946111158,
0.0176778231,
-0.0019582203,
0.025909109,
-0.0146251516,
-0.036888916,
-0.0304009188,
0.0066576689,
-0.0366575979,
-0.0122580063,
-0.0066270176,
-0.0226822887,
0.0126431677,
-0.0092129158,
-0.0690639317,
-0.0141921928,
0.0450864509,
0.012195617,
0.0342910811,
-0.0360998847,
-0.015923718,
0.0460848436,
0.0091731632,
-0.0345316082,
0.026249744,
-0.0561912656,
-0.0455542132,
0.0113470107,
0.0154030984,
0.0396786742,
0.0257156417,
0.0032553663,
0.0089078201,
-0.0125579247,
0.0591789447,
-0.0053938124,
0.0014015981,
-0.0484030098,
0.027144473,
0.0063740979,
-0.0036738974,
0.0395584702,
0.0423712544,
-0.0407480299,
-0.0296486393,
0.0274334345,
-0.0134255579,
0.0407316908,
0.0220026169,
0.1300000399,
0.0214486122,
0.0331749059,
-0.023498483,
0.0405746847,
-0.0287887324,
-0.0313482061,
-0.0215008408,
-0.0141840279,
-0.011523894,
0.0198585987,
0.0544391461,
0.0127736162,
-0.0052189166,
-0.0110741593,
0.0334452465,
-0.0124473162,
0.0137134055,
0.0084785027,
-0.0128062535,
-0.0056435233,
-0.0508698262,
-0.021148365,
-0.0589198396,
0.0463755839,
0.0109289158,
0.0379705615,
-0.0114741968,
-0.0034551944,
0.0729810521,
-0.0264036711,
0.023350101,
-0.0209228825,
-0.0344188102,
0.0958710313,
-0.0320140943,
-0.0147179905,
-5.683605185e-33,
0.0034241497,
0.0114364615,
-0.0148289641,
-0.0189506225,
-0.0304704998,
-0.0307826567,
-0.0444282964,
-0.0082436604,
-0.0090986127,
-0.0430673733,
-0.0317285247,
0.0568605997,
0.0392841399,
-0.0079586934,
0.0136108119,
-0.0159435626,
0.0451220796,
-0.000875535,
-0.0375656746,
0.0270652734,
0.0108030383,
0.0128360214,
0.0384480543,
-0.0427161604,
0.0017288271,
0.0017276981,
-0.0414075106,
-0.0265857391,
-0.0067591495,
0.0189721398,
0.0380520076,
0.0197397768,
0.0106417891,
-0.0179993659,
-0.0363111757,
0.0101346355,
-0.0500360392,
0.0279452261,
0.036125876,
0.070677124,
-0.0095660351,
-0.0255405903,
0.0179088283,
-0.0334105268,
0.0101757934,
-0.0177652482,
-0.0069538006,
-0.0374609716,
-0.0250983592,
0.000879129,
-0.0716619194,
0.0357175618,
-0.0281537883,
-0.0207228567,
0.0344621018,
0.1003050432,
-0.0255908798,
-0.0449809358,
-0.060191147,
0.0655713081,
-0.0106905838,
0.0293995924,
0.0282103624,
-0.011771244,
-0.011607904,
0.013220964,
0.0572885014,
-0.0191852972,
0.0658937544,
-0.0331466682,
0.0698488429,
-0.0141492644,
0.0415126309,
0.0364938788,
0.0474972203,
-0.0413096398,
-0.0145079382,
-0.0424214117,
0.0178928059,
-0.0422174931,
0.0017984919,
0.0374508835,
-0.0172414146,
-0.0023485583,
-0.0440626182,
-0.0857519656,
-0.0092216544,
-0.0195654891,
0.0446036234,
0.0116120847,
0.0139823593,
-0.0175161995,
0.1020812318,
-0.0045644566,
0.0053817304,
0.002346403,
0.000322864,
0.0503246747,
-0.026550537,
0.0828397647,
-0.0307493154,
-0.0297170207,
0.0531580783,
0.0340870358,
0.0550759956,
-0.0245663784,
0.0328829922,
0.0573474132,
-0.0649601445,
-0.0119116958,
-0.0032850993,
0.0285130292,
-0.0251512136,
0.0166678969,
0.0261363722,
-0.0100438856,
0.0056162295,
0.0163724683,
-0.0333577469,
-0.0239685234,
-0.0429680981,
-0.0328148119,
-0.0032452948,
0.0683290809,
-0.0631135255,
-0.0007351829,
-0.0336808823,
0.0314517394,
0.041765146,
-0.0366857499,
-0.0398249775,
-0.0049177869,
2.56e-7,
0.0175623018,
0.0240812562,
-0.0129062999,
0.0243534092,
0.0237735063,
-0.0261404049,
-0.0544123575,
0.0178481638,
0.0272971522,
0.041308064,
-0.025896702,
-0.0127664711,
0.129226312,
0.0234415345,
-0.0718787313,
-0.0630708039,
0.0106043937,
0.0517522879,
-0.0349795371,
-0.0227124002,
0.0524787083,
0.1003194451,
-0.0409575701,
0.0340541899,
0.0153939398,
0.0226221606,
0.0223905705,
-0.0031470675,
0.0202832837,
-0.037010964,
-0.0440173,
0.010794661,
-0.0388939641,
0.0190628394,
-0.0311315265,
-0.009276446,
0.0409828871,
0.0592535213,
-0.0034387463,
-0.0259383414,
0.0047018714,
0.0056575523,
-0.0723394006,
-0.0285339784,
0.0545482226,
-0.0090058614,
0.0374816805,
-0.0080533316,
-0.0107860863,
0.0340592153,
0.0070946622,
-0.0333263576,
-0.0325173624,
0.042800542,
0.0370822623,
0.0147818504,
-0.0234564431,
-0.0179033577,
-0.0107059078,
-0.0158283096,
-0.0034506596,
-0.0485846251,
-0.0377086923,
0.0130850673,
0.0465450324,
-0.0217955988,
-0.0051107868,
2.132746466e-34,
0.0378764458,
-0.0205185823,
0.0318571962,
-0.0018402935,
0.0203084592,
-0.0378109477,
0.0267678667,
0.0344585404,
-0.0130955912,
-0.0131101217,
-0.0423482843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12640v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12640v1 | Non-Autoregressive Sentence Ordering | 2023-10-19T10:57:51 | 2023-10-19T10:57:51 | Yi Bin, Wenhao Shi, Bin Ji, Jipeng Zhang, Yujuan Ding, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing sentence ordering approaches generally employ encoder-decoder
frameworks with the pointer net to recover the coherence by recurrently
predicting each sentence step-by-step. Such an autoregressive manner only
leverages unilateral dependencies during decoding and cannot fully explore the
semantic dependency between sentences for ordering. To overcome these
limitations, in this paper, we propose a novel Non-Autoregressive Ordering
Network, dubbed \textit{NAON}, which explores bilateral dependencies between
sentences and predicts the sentence for each position in parallel. We claim
that the non-autoregressive manner is not just applicable but also particularly
suitable to the sentence ordering task because of two peculiar characteristics
of the task: 1) each generation target is in deterministic length, and 2) the
sentences and positions should match exclusively. Furthermore, to address the
repetition issue of the naive non-autoregressive Transformer, we introduce an
exclusive loss to constrain the exclusiveness between positions and sentences.
To verify the effectiveness of the proposed model, we conduct extensive
experiments on several common-used datasets and the experimental results show
that our method outperforms all the autoregressive approaches and yields
competitive performance compared with the state-of-the-arts. The codes are
available at:
\url{https://github.com/steven640pixel/nonautoregressive-sentence-ordering}. | [
0.0166150015,
0.107157819,
-0.0017378404,
0.0585517883,
-0.011144896,
0.0237394348,
-0.0120195812,
-0.0505890064,
-0.0346421748,
0.0064960606,
0.0287043508,
-0.0096476655,
0.0394851454,
0.0358065031,
-0.0051331678,
-0.0687741265,
0.0122844838,
-0.0133071002,
0.0004701717,
-0.0028896721,
-0.0089274021,
-0.0058304924,
-0.0481113642,
0.0299652796,
-0.0110676605,
-0.023737425,
-0.0254644491,
0.0357486829,
0.0527044944,
-0.0355703309,
0.0345797352,
0.0344869159,
0.0153041873,
-0.0131174633,
0.0000021921,
0.0250998475,
-0.0041609025,
-0.0283755716,
0.0470312126,
-0.0149377258,
-0.038682662,
-0.0533716716,
-0.0312643684,
-0.0097518386,
-0.0349456295,
0.0044065504,
0.0212213695,
0.0490820333,
0.10584867,
0.0734267756,
-0.0118430527,
-0.0585277118,
0.0111447433,
-0.0637096986,
0.0087715052,
0.0025887405,
-0.0113545265,
0.0002110705,
-0.0303658694,
0.0600308888,
-0.0498639718,
0.0561430641,
0.0740506724,
0.0192718767,
0.0079344213,
0.0423805006,
-0.0115889478,
-0.01790905,
-0.0228885617,
0.0766663849,
-0.0064729387,
0.012829138,
0.0269989222,
-0.0163372997,
0.015154995,
-0.0190545376,
-0.0215031076,
0.0546568595,
0.0366389044,
0.0330726244,
-0.0033509459,
0.0665119514,
-0.0206199586,
-0.014729999,
-0.0215963516,
0.0555971488,
0.0043978039,
-0.0449004583,
-0.038144391,
0.0159850512,
0.00615098,
0.0169106424,
0.0201055612,
-0.016809687,
-0.0115632387,
-0.0110708494,
-0.0030633509,
-0.0119748842,
-0.0249846261,
-0.0382575579,
0.0351402089,
0.0092634633,
-0.0170415025,
-0.0077083297,
-0.0419391729,
0.0665383115,
-0.0048396871,
-0.0335678235,
-0.0332856812,
0.0174321849,
-0.0073385062,
-0.0296227653,
-0.0196436048,
0.0419589467,
-0.0422403626,
-0.0547392555,
-0.0702626333,
0.0157764722,
0.0149635701,
0.0029790865,
0.0215600487,
0.0684249252,
-0.025546141,
-0.0087753497,
0.0079294527,
0.0231252033,
-0.0144839063,
-0.0290240366,
0.0003377651,
-0.0182612129,
-0.0289438367,
0.0470253006,
0.0113633107,
-0.0099610379,
-0.0254766662,
0.0448380746,
-0.0236105844,
0.0111587038,
0.0005585247,
-0.0043873559,
-0.032857433,
-0.0279566403,
0.0187887605,
-0.0511892028,
-0.0054859389,
0.0176172219,
0.0157517791,
-0.0296400543,
0.0236958601,
0.0305448808,
-0.0501035601,
0.0458176583,
0.053722851,
-0.0284610353,
-0.0026499012,
0.0119524626,
0.0582410581,
0.0191024598,
0.058578819,
0.0664353669,
-0.0256205928,
0.0228812359,
0.0046643601,
0.0078154253,
-0.0136847794,
-0.0267163608,
-0.0256908163,
-0.0255952962,
-0.03601408,
0.0286037549,
0.0556150079,
0.035187725,
-0.0203116983,
-0.0184461679,
0.0399546064,
-0.005012359,
0.0286603887,
-0.0094663082,
0.0496233515,
0.0133614922,
-0.0334421806,
0.0548375994,
-0.0207096506,
0.0536134839,
0.0269333441,
0.0197559763,
0.0044779526,
0.0025250332,
-0.0263183508,
-0.0699513778,
0.0530234911,
-0.0414266363,
-0.0011495709,
-0.0345941,
0.0003969817,
0.0581788197,
-0.0859045163,
0.0297932494,
-0.0179690626,
-0.0424678326,
-0.0523242466,
0.0129657555,
-0.0366905369,
0.0767633617,
0.0059511727,
0.0078938184,
-0.0500927381,
0.0236927625,
-0.0145103289,
0.0868078023,
-0.0420254804,
0.0060950718,
0.0330730788,
-0.0440328158,
-0.003918455,
-0.0093474733,
0.0000232815,
0.0441407114,
-0.0075788684,
0.0337104239,
0.0690394044,
0.0650109202,
0.0073570954,
0.0107307928,
0.0018190409,
-0.0145922936,
0.0324837007,
0.0199455842,
0.0142371505,
0.0117397401,
-0.0008675872,
0.0518880859,
0.0572735034,
-0.0713481829,
-0.0337455869,
0.0231061224,
-0.1227729023,
-0.1047871858,
-0.0319257192,
-0.0496855378,
-0.0185831636,
0.0629337281,
-0.0655329302,
-0.0583002828,
0.0518267639,
-0.0109079536,
0.0308885332,
-0.0338312276,
-0.005161298,
0.082512103,
0.017437594,
-0.0234188326,
0.0554715954,
-0.0424348116,
0.0219081361,
0.0038403645,
0.0285218973,
-0.0074690292,
-0.0375921614,
-0.0056201383,
0.0046900162,
0.0142183742,
-0.0052570049,
0.0290104765,
0.0012372547,
-0.0139261074,
-0.0556945689,
-0.0484416448,
-0.0105681457,
-0.0243130401,
-0.0214061197,
0.0217617787,
0.0327718928,
0.0199515298,
-0.0594228506,
-0.043339096,
0.0145074185,
0.0402108692,
0.0147479745,
0.0541875362,
-0.0274151973,
-0.038783811,
0.002875302,
-0.0232063867,
-0.0009498267,
0.0419242866,
-0.0350826569,
-0.0238746442,
-0.0495191813,
0.0160248838,
-0.0292003341,
-0.0083366968,
-0.0041645477,
-0.0391497985,
0.0221554469,
0.0026650173,
0.0325094722,
0.0533448122,
0.0468470678,
0.0370132327,
-0.001107996,
-0.0051367208,
0.0010684822,
0.0067975302,
-0.0296329912,
0.0513272248,
0.0129226735,
-0.021668192,
-0.0353683755,
0.0652204007,
0.0455744863,
0.028890742,
-0.0404979847,
-0.0104291905,
-0.0228780862,
-0.0215178523,
-0.0420348383,
-0.0298553798,
-0.0260159206,
-0.0128645608,
-0.0294108856,
0.0112124747,
0.0213432293,
-0.0350977033,
-0.0124857528,
-0.0208700076,
-0.0108989226,
-0.051135473,
0.0637699738,
0.0697165951,
0.0180832669,
0.0045388113,
-0.0508000627,
-0.0697948113,
0.008350878,
0.012153957,
-0.0077883485,
0.0305279773,
-0.0049748393,
0.0022559655,
-0.0154074784,
-0.0731221884,
-0.0593226254,
-0.0381198898,
0.0121697895,
-0.0102929166,
0.0166022088,
-0.0142806759,
-0.0188493971,
-0.0187144727,
0.0019794139,
0.0461615697,
-0.0423961617,
-0.0016926718,
-0.0254233778,
0.1236876175,
0.0485132337,
0.0124771399,
-0.0085657472,
-0.0347565599,
-0.001700834,
0.053416986,
-0.0162082706,
-0.0055520921,
-0.0623667911,
0.0191308465,
-0.0154646197,
-0.0040661073,
-0.0082520312,
-0.0002195744,
-0.0200381521,
-0.0379584543,
-0.0076357694,
0.1032987684,
0.0183149893,
-0.0057627154,
0.005907618,
0.0269819871,
0.0877641514,
0.0194588173,
0.0027291453,
-0.0729273558,
-0.0316009112,
-0.0104607623,
0.0018155755,
0.0464926846,
-0.012123256,
-0.0094256634,
-0.0729347095,
0.0154428352,
0.0137224561,
-0.0075124763,
-0.0233419631,
-0.0185099673,
-0.0509859063,
-0.0146790762,
-0.0085442523,
0.038326364,
-0.0045026424,
0.0117259976,
0.0236220472,
-0.0347266644,
0.0071312189,
-0.0399432071,
-0.0028403027,
0.0206006374,
0.0681223944,
0.0313663147,
0.0004325278,
0.0056539089,
0.0128178606,
-0.0344066732,
0.0390378311,
0.0239065159,
0.0388763472,
-0.0244587306,
-0.0084390566,
-0.0231650658,
0.0205144081,
-0.0798005983,
0.0019822009,
0.0060362373,
0.0089569017,
-0.0264661573,
-0.0271334294,
-0.022152612,
0.0168487728,
-0.0214890409,
0.0490928777,
0.026946323,
-0.0139988819,
-0.0580497719,
-0.0513894334,
0.0395641439,
-0.0610250011,
-0.0299442932,
-0.012415193,
0.1065799519,
-0.025042953,
-0.094498612,
-0.0670874789,
-0.0513835624,
0.0107523464,
-0.0212949142,
0.0095742606,
0.023575848,
-0.0331710465,
-0.0511358976,
-0.0178064611,
0.0196475405,
-0.027708482,
-0.0474653356,
0.0072320802,
0.0639604181,
0.0201819185,
-0.0469387136,
0.008629323,
-0.0614967458,
-0.0466687717,
0.0193274524,
0.0598276742,
0.0068321452,
0.0411825329,
0.023238929,
0.0209429041,
0.0508207753,
0.0327278115,
-0.0336337425,
0.0247413386,
0.0357996188,
-0.0068094525,
-0.0134006934,
0.0193413552,
-0.0314915851,
0.0563994497,
-0.0562138893,
0.0464796387,
-0.0018272224,
-0.0560756661,
0.0197108835,
-0.0298594795,
0.0440852977,
-0.010464075,
0.0161616188,
-0.0356024839,
0.0606132783,
-0.0302896574,
-0.0236505549,
-0.0457903221,
0.0371372588,
0.0381351337,
0.0227392707,
-0.0264794212,
-0.0050185905,
0.028656844,
-0.0120948646,
0.0019855867,
-0.0016441832,
0.0311839134,
-0.0134166498,
-0.0137709454,
0.0101041226,
-0.0245191008,
0.0363749415,
0.012288806,
0.0442306399,
-0.0280456096,
0.0264420323,
0.0232195444,
0.0083821611,
-0.0323314853,
0.0828382224,
-0.0679391399,
0.0502378717,
-0.0248697568,
-0.0182642136,
0.0617852062,
-0.0173522215,
0.0939513594,
-0.0054359324,
0.0419421904,
0.007865251,
0.0444158353,
0.0160286743,
-0.0221972,
-0.0562530234,
0.014217956,
-0.0041288328,
0.0419827513,
0.0930559188,
0.0029582484,
-0.0126139894,
0.040961042,
0.0199038107,
-0.0344587602,
-0.0246931165,
-0.0098567083,
-0.0334323458,
-0.0289024413,
0.0140330745,
0.0250179302,
-0.0342985466,
0.0058380496,
-0.0153117515,
0.0334293693,
-0.0101701766,
0.0370968729,
-0.0050435206,
0.0054829903,
-0.0130058499,
-0.035394121,
-0.0170697402,
-0.0199340526,
-0.0563972257,
-0.0508402772,
-6.683633861e-33,
-0.0459781848,
-0.0348815806,
-0.0295182299,
-0.0288357902,
-0.0060147196,
0.0133571746,
-0.0300694462,
-0.0096291769,
0.027173968,
0.0048511843,
0.0022587278,
0.0272276942,
0.0089943381,
0.047330901,
0.0419015214,
0.0089924894,
0.0512918532,
-0.0083514536,
0.0064945845,
0.0151306456,
0.0358538218,
0.0654660761,
0.0122573702,
-0.0378029831,
-0.0172959622,
-0.0540731736,
-0.0094294045,
0.0054685134,
0.0047379448,
0.0210415293,
0.0086487141,
0.0061184582,
0.0412020348,
-0.0435351729,
-0.0039481502,
0.0448607206,
-0.0835994929,
-0.0517577939,
-0.0467759743,
-0.0176632777,
-0.0536866002,
-0.0131839877,
0.0162822381,
-0.025574604,
0.0218898933,
-0.0074794092,
0.0350067914,
0.0165498964,
-0.0135352379,
-0.0082507469,
-0.0353599675,
-0.0025123269,
-0.043623209,
-0.0385116972,
0.0267043468,
0.0711847991,
0.0012118893,
-0.0127474554,
-0.0590242632,
0.039416004,
-0.0234652124,
0.0839376375,
-0.0022435116,
0.0265097301,
-0.0347826965,
0.055847086,
0.0131967189,
-0.0350728594,
-0.0299428497,
-0.0076468922,
-0.0530806296,
0.0334570557,
0.0108909979,
-0.0351573899,
0.0316754803,
0.0019505679,
-0.0652962029,
0.0331204087,
-0.0014382751,
0.0483918451,
0.0170743875,
0.0110293282,
-0.0203701388,
-0.0269842129,
0.0167212952,
-0.0149252247,
-0.0119539332,
-0.0369621515,
0.0385678895,
0.0278657842,
-0.0207512714,
-0.0133429803,
0.0180283636,
-0.0202748049,
-0.027767282,
0.0540128537,
-0.0566136204,
0.0097646043,
0.0093716457,
0.0507790372,
-0.0545060039,
0.0151471505,
0.0230341628,
0.0339133628,
0.019785963,
0.0026422364,
0.0530384891,
0.0034692239,
-0.0449889712,
-0.0238801334,
0.0070652571,
0.018108286,
-0.0625891164,
0.0190756936,
-0.0205068421,
0.0064741112,
-0.0351570174,
0.0596793331,
-0.0264918376,
0.0216580518,
-0.0258107781,
-0.0130150793,
0.0223135073,
0.019902898,
-0.0138554731,
-0.0036008311,
-0.0153834783,
0.0692868009,
0.0405635238,
-0.0786619633,
-0.021304924,
0.0237252619,
2.901e-7,
0.0000436662,
0.033026427,
0.0604944453,
0.0058989259,
0.0522336625,
0.0025313257,
-0.0384681784,
0.0332847945,
-0.0317410976,
0.0085499519,
0.0292870738,
0.0204275865,
0.0392070115,
-0.0212492216,
-0.116184853,
0.0371337049,
-0.093726851,
-0.0261591207,
-0.0259784926,
-0.0250537191,
0.0561877117,
0.0646397322,
-0.0670201331,
0.0225255154,
0.0007256173,
0.0438146889,
0.0530329458,
0.0432013236,
-0.0082662208,
-0.0464882329,
0.0010533109,
-0.0231676064,
-0.0301513858,
-0.0103619499,
0.0002918901,
-0.0045658443,
0.0325440913,
0.0291971285,
-0.0092081977,
-0.0760118216,
0.0281096306,
0.0478963181,
-0.0072447103,
-0.0039167912,
0.0422776416,
-0.073355943,
-0.0340374447,
0.0338983759,
-0.047742568,
0.0668315589,
0.0189805198,
0.0144479293,
-0.0497759469,
-0.0281320084,
0.0266879983,
-0.014878205,
-0.0195350889,
-0.0554636233,
-0.0427351706,
0.0120466491,
-0.0210369993,
0.0167943668,
-0.047860343,
-0.0033915939,
0.0371750779,
-0.0206980947,
-0.0328291804,
2.496558065e-34,
0.0263703372,
0.0003092861,
0.0282815304,
0.0184786338,
0.0252855346,
-0.0300747976,
-0.0406881012,
0.0349893011,
-0.0181847084,
-0.0424019434,
-0.0503170453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12620v1 | Predict the Future from the Past? On the Temporal Data Distribution Shift in Financial Sentiment Classifications | 2023-10-19T09:59:52 | 2023-10-19T09:59:52 | Yue Guo, Chenxi Hu, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal data distribution shift is prevalent in the financial text. How can
a financial sentiment analysis system be trained in a volatile market
environment that can accurately infer sentiment and be robust to temporal data
distribution shifts? In this paper, we conduct an empirical study on the
financial sentiment analysis system under temporal data distribution shifts
using a real-world financial social media dataset that spans three years. We
find that the fine-tuned models suffer from general performance degradation in
the presence of temporal distribution shifts. Furthermore, motivated by the
unique temporal nature of the financial text, we propose a novel method that
combines out-of-distribution detection with time series modeling for temporal
financial sentiment analysis. Experimental results show that the proposed
method enhances the model's capability to adapt to evolving temporal shifts in
a volatile financial market. | [
0.0119319176,
0.0763745755,
-0.0279186741,
-0.0273156147,
-0.0170905758,
0.0014894672,
-0.0432030074,
0.0205235481,
-0.0311843678,
-0.0475467406,
0.0269509461,
-0.0494871661,
-0.025060717,
0.0256228074,
-0.0221731029,
-0.0108801145,
0.0373662896,
0.0042694598,
0.032596603,
-0.0027868524,
0.0191358402,
-0.020105131,
0.0101483138,
-0.0129923727,
-0.0149339819,
-0.0209740419,
-0.0126805324,
0.0093277628,
0.0292991586,
-0.0268458482,
0.0412723757,
0.0061782752,
0.0211081058,
0.000768002,
0.0000018304,
0.0230500475,
-0.0249642394,
-0.0382478125,
0.0208092015,
0.0097266408,
0.0616399571,
-0.0438120291,
0.0166733302,
0.0059654159,
-0.0861135423,
0.0126913926,
0.0387912542,
0.035272833,
0.0325324908,
0.0750525743,
-0.0251576621,
0.0095355147,
0.0074887089,
-0.0581414849,
-0.0249598846,
-0.0493218042,
0.0176304132,
0.0002826529,
-0.0131864091,
-0.0186915137,
-0.0128420973,
0.0100748595,
-0.0296307132,
0.0292284135,
0.0539734587,
-0.0015017211,
-0.0203897748,
0.0686543286,
-0.0669435188,
0.0157850888,
-0.0066230013,
-0.0265495852,
0.0085135438,
-0.0177813508,
-0.0174684934,
0.0384027958,
0.0079971561,
-0.0147985481,
-0.0032506455,
0.0391731299,
-0.0045052948,
0.0422842391,
0.0226752181,
0.0300452169,
-0.0394512787,
0.0342158154,
-0.0702143908,
-0.0518349893,
-0.0218378641,
0.00564923,
0.0051853685,
-0.0034157825,
0.0228013657,
0.0046451497,
0.0499105528,
-0.0160883106,
0.0059766034,
-0.0399843268,
-0.0035395306,
-0.1029407531,
0.0228997022,
-0.0065893941,
-0.0245343409,
0.0474853218,
0.0251004677,
-0.0072106803,
0.0223733429,
-0.0486646518,
0.0031238978,
0.0632582009,
-0.0992726311,
0.0198902804,
0.0121548772,
0.0383142494,
-0.0186212249,
-0.0013528346,
-0.0534394048,
0.0225833375,
-0.0052337991,
-0.0331377052,
-0.0256166086,
-0.0012871876,
-0.0149641018,
0.0077401088,
-0.0092941299,
0.0254531316,
-0.0086009931,
0.0527252741,
-0.0641166419,
0.0224549752,
0.0103657348,
0.0204739068,
-0.0090988697,
0.0127078155,
-0.0049374085,
0.0440133922,
0.0317373909,
-0.0254356805,
-0.0870666504,
-0.0131559866,
-0.007654666,
-0.0039524459,
-0.0080952328,
0.0142394742,
-0.0405278727,
-0.0081002126,
-0.038642142,
0.0751153156,
0.0012395108,
-0.021502519,
-0.0385846943,
0.0564542562,
0.0143843237,
-0.0136506232,
0.0137055339,
-0.0626188442,
0.0157673527,
0.0485218205,
0.0065660966,
-0.0039236755,
0.0383912548,
-0.0025339534,
0.0038712372,
0.0251201428,
0.0113364337,
-0.0426070169,
-0.0347013995,
0.022352403,
-0.046917852,
-0.0324580558,
0.0295277014,
-0.032151971,
0.0166610014,
-0.0119581399,
0.0483066775,
-0.0350259058,
0.0197066385,
-0.0231479909,
-0.0408543609,
-0.0194127355,
-0.0161102954,
-0.0192208383,
0.0204828847,
-0.0295494143,
-0.0217263587,
0.0106981369,
-0.0917245597,
0.0007095671,
-0.0465785004,
-0.0398546793,
-0.0037050531,
-0.028438285,
0.0343395732,
-0.0322182551,
0.031824559,
-0.0363562293,
-0.0203276649,
0.0595470853,
0.0519802719,
0.0175652895,
-0.0109403757,
-0.0200760402,
0.0397639498,
0.0776126683,
0.0138372444,
-0.0242733117,
0.0624445602,
-0.0447033308,
0.0380031206,
0.0302296765,
0.0050813234,
0.0193401333,
-0.057535924,
-0.0335818082,
-0.0070360173,
0.060316775,
0.0364270881,
0.0091641517,
-0.0318382531,
0.0495298803,
0.0033703519,
-0.0646021962,
0.0152552789,
0.0013049738,
0.0441765897,
-0.0110237561,
0.0078973817,
-0.0090465201,
0.0323482007,
0.0014020534,
-0.0325227268,
-0.021763226,
0.0305207595,
-0.0110782348,
-0.0609429218,
0.0123335151,
-0.0433933549,
-0.0105754957,
-0.0017121905,
0.0138839195,
0.0190985799,
0.0190949999,
-0.0608031191,
0.0160233136,
0.0617209822,
-0.0247448068,
0.044572413,
-0.0729064792,
-0.0318926834,
-0.0082017612,
0.0304866172,
-0.0003079689,
0.0610037781,
-0.0496461131,
-0.0375829637,
-0.0537482426,
0.0072671417,
0.0164688788,
0.0193240717,
0.0379247032,
-0.0078405645,
-0.0143417474,
0.0424084663,
0.0238676481,
-0.0036856534,
0.0184214842,
-0.0339425839,
-0.0342840664,
-0.0437239856,
-0.0224110708,
0.0106989266,
-0.0017452397,
-0.0234928187,
-0.0103668571,
-0.0178585686,
-0.0051267906,
0.0197361279,
-0.0136253489,
0.0116175609,
0.0726112798,
-0.0168629903,
0.0089859078,
-0.0294774976,
0.0047176629,
-0.0205577258,
0.0500468165,
0.0089146905,
-0.0710897446,
-0.0205706824,
-0.0070460485,
-0.0407632813,
0.006454723,
-0.0090648541,
0.01600991,
-0.0621211044,
0.0091252644,
0.0328491926,
0.0579928346,
0.0603016652,
0.0375388563,
-0.0253178142,
0.0064231553,
-0.0041630082,
0.0246533267,
-0.0230062399,
0.026215164,
-0.0176656563,
0.0280567016,
0.021031417,
0.038230978,
-0.0092981607,
-0.0015977687,
-0.0567157269,
-0.0018734179,
-0.0335843861,
0.0320002027,
0.0215078928,
0.0129906544,
-0.0385428146,
0.010582787,
-0.0198759809,
-0.0417981222,
0.0169088319,
0.049663756,
0.0250623152,
-0.0146664195,
-0.0678846389,
-0.0652249604,
-0.0078147259,
-0.0219708849,
-0.0340818204,
0.0266312566,
0.010921848,
0.0038256089,
-0.0551513284,
0.0262265373,
-0.0078485543,
0.0276294723,
-0.0115534617,
0.0604417659,
0.0199898947,
-0.0042049312,
0.0076589035,
-0.1226497665,
-0.0153405732,
-0.0055595576,
-0.0254876558,
-0.0208110921,
-0.0264507085,
0.0522937849,
-0.0944337025,
0.0029894826,
-0.0253316294,
-0.0341896638,
0.0189635456,
0.0418426469,
0.0426358543,
-0.0395512134,
0.0133876726,
-0.023551587,
-0.0276998654,
-0.0226958022,
0.0084531736,
-0.0146202557,
-0.0341283157,
-0.0134767406,
-0.0345875472,
-0.0013668917,
0.011657224,
-0.0037981947,
-0.0046593882,
-0.0155582717,
0.0104389898,
0.0637199804,
-0.0044426974,
0.0002126108,
0.0222343579,
0.0346227661,
0.0156823508,
-0.0184361972,
-0.0153291691,
-0.077892378,
-0.003259043,
-0.0333899744,
0.0125430301,
0.0045214035,
-0.035270717,
0.020561086,
-0.0992972478,
0.0593854301,
0.0202505831,
0.006979852,
-0.0140991425,
-0.0216919109,
0.0218598731,
-0.0326983444,
0.0133214584,
-0.0157625265,
-0.0120574655,
0.0406579189,
0.0555774122,
-0.0790719092,
-0.0308411419,
0.0156993307,
0.0224940144,
-0.023347687,
0.0296317022,
0.0411953218,
-0.0099334773,
-0.0310809892,
-0.0099558756,
-0.0442828201,
0.0302874781,
-0.0019096654,
0.0727201551,
-0.0150802359,
-0.0195066575,
0.0292856339,
0.006352515,
-0.0332772695,
0.0651994869,
0.0004779796,
0.0302227531,
-0.0290794354,
-0.0842529461,
-0.0335750878,
0.0270177461,
0.0430895425,
0.0146333082,
-0.0234703012,
-0.0560238473,
-0.0395191647,
0.0021808003,
-0.0030954736,
-0.0417397618,
0.0493280329,
-0.007756378,
0.0107135614,
-0.057563521,
-0.1064068079,
-0.0140176676,
-0.0819211155,
0.0202759523,
-0.0063884957,
0.0307273306,
0.0272717439,
-0.002552209,
-0.0564965606,
-0.0174868442,
0.0200595818,
0.0324675329,
0.016980093,
-0.0006505242,
0.0476990752,
0.0096166758,
-0.0484903269,
0.0012047091,
-0.0825290754,
-0.0601679161,
0.0367879644,
0.0014609417,
0.0189724229,
-0.0031503511,
0.0188231617,
0.0509416796,
0.1139665768,
0.0962489024,
-0.032321509,
0.006598386,
0.0600007884,
0.0255864225,
-0.0136214839,
0.014214647,
-0.0101303067,
0.0427966118,
-0.0165701099,
-0.0642231032,
-0.0711331964,
0.0052335407,
-0.0469477139,
-0.0594309494,
0.0504936576,
0.0467331223,
-0.089848347,
0.011111686,
-0.0302469544,
0.0341844745,
0.0184519477,
-0.0106291492,
-0.0379254855,
0.0335573293,
-0.010489095,
-0.0689196736,
0.0578597263,
0.0275650024,
-0.00203013,
-0.0227200054,
0.0304899421,
0.0433508232,
0.0451222882,
0.0085303783,
0.0069183204,
0.0102475453,
-0.0286000725,
0.0265035685,
-0.0394785777,
0.0316579267,
0.0182000641,
0.0123309242,
0.0339835137,
-0.0200945437,
-0.0376268476,
-0.0737124905,
0.0306681972,
-0.0047376184,
0.0171776563,
0.0202079359,
-0.0316036344,
0.0206817202,
-0.0119974315,
0.0225771833,
0.0090466887,
0.0340974629,
-0.0193277281,
-0.0097281672,
0.0158987995,
-0.0115804896,
-0.0666408017,
0.0028651296,
0.0492713042,
-0.0115281185,
0.0559746586,
-0.0108969491,
-0.0078818696,
-0.0217551887,
0.0142567931,
0.0324156433,
-0.0360334404,
0.0320517868,
0.0332804769,
-0.0394081697,
-0.0395326205,
0.1067138314,
-0.0429980084,
0.046765577,
-0.0117486101,
0.0379869789,
0.0505287088,
0.0208466686,
0.0606793314,
-0.016362438,
0.0048882714,
-0.0003048097,
-0.0022036275,
-0.099198617,
-5.9648558e-33,
0.0194812659,
0.0083300406,
-0.0227843653,
0.0241646506,
-0.0103779007,
0.0279039573,
-0.0208499432,
0.007729087,
0.0141525436,
0.0060556512,
0.0014275433,
0.0752768219,
0.0018251176,
0.0004164485,
0.0479149334,
-0.0218007192,
0.0354005694,
-0.0587443374,
0.0213317052,
0.0017830613,
0.0291225035,
0.0653945208,
0.0539700277,
-0.0666718856,
-0.0185343623,
-0.0204243865,
-0.0370046087,
0.0020962444,
0.0834884122,
0.018754974,
0.0121366559,
0.0827582777,
0.0414308645,
-0.0229276754,
-0.0100646634,
-0.0062255035,
0.0252607726,
-0.0379809253,
-0.0206448864,
0.0183540098,
0.0608432218,
0.0380017869,
0.0100752823,
0.0196738057,
-0.0273215435,
-0.003825496,
0.024656035,
-0.0134340236,
0.0066654757,
-0.0805339664,
-0.044065427,
0.0639764518,
0.0059388936,
0.0182614513,
-0.0190966018,
0.0694738403,
0.0242238492,
0.0245337076,
-0.0208027326,
0.0322969705,
-0.0069798576,
-0.0017358254,
-0.0215466339,
-0.0066154688,
-0.0217796732,
0.0406506769,
-0.0452418514,
0.0663088858,
-0.0083674518,
0.0400843546,
0.0288338065,
-0.0064356318,
-0.0168177839,
0.0479848161,
0.0483563282,
-0.0930786431,
-0.0263514668,
0.0070067472,
0.050632529,
-0.0069076712,
0.0370266587,
0.0144423908,
-0.0403102413,
-0.0178451426,
0.072522141,
-0.0022688496,
0.0322296508,
0.0030987831,
0.0045909057,
0.0465722233,
0.0282471813,
0.0117062191,
0.0021650523,
-0.064328149,
-0.0696368665,
0.0182095077,
-0.0503224581,
0.0091449386,
0.0203207713,
-0.0337883756,
-0.018311169,
-0.0684321225,
0.0031911465,
0.0452293679,
-0.0093656173,
-0.0501741953,
0.0508160591,
0.0501501188,
-0.0343285538,
-0.0114529291,
0.0433077104,
0.042160321,
0.0116244517,
0.0649703071,
-0.0119963754,
0.0001705939,
-0.0069782082,
0.0262079649,
-0.0169330463,
0.0571766607,
0.0157434382,
0.0375387184,
-0.0095370207,
0.048462458,
-0.0172468834,
-0.0393630192,
0.0362783372,
0.052442532,
-0.0209458414,
-0.0647765547,
-0.0111895809,
0.0052482705,
2.611e-7,
0.0459626727,
0.0753238648,
0.0057207895,
0.0067738923,
0.0396753773,
0.0285381079,
-0.0323038995,
0.004810458,
-0.0455047823,
-0.0138335153,
0.0669487938,
0.0051919371,
0.0066283401,
0.0076815444,
-0.0712170601,
-0.0394222438,
-0.0477155149,
0.0537618659,
-0.0449349172,
0.0167411063,
0.0335844345,
0.0595093481,
0.0113799013,
-0.0366028212,
-0.005361631,
-0.0782943964,
0.048339732,
-0.0214936677,
-0.0058802492,
0.0088178804,
-0.008277134,
0.0005272524,
-0.022801524,
0.0102102058,
-0.0060013379,
0.0341556445,
-0.0261038113,
-0.0008303823,
-0.0286377501,
0.0077081057,
0.0297986977,
0.0431852452,
-0.0135973906,
-0.0047616404,
0.0151993595,
-0.078140147,
-0.0168693569,
-0.0961596519,
-0.0623559207,
0.0344919004,
0.0390897095,
0.0404360332,
-0.0137839355,
0.0382471159,
-0.0028528774,
-0.0011259622,
-0.0106933229,
-0.0723518431,
-0.0005140869,
0.0596691146,
-0.0495585054,
0.0226428602,
-0.0106846448,
0.0229587425,
0.0246219337,
-0.0317733996,
0.0623932593,
1.75174223e-34,
0.0964817628,
-0.0273837745,
-0.0624607578,
0.0087840976,
0.0246318802,
0.0277626049,
-0.0118282251,
0.012834589,
0.0189030562,
-0.019101128,
0.0101263123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12611v1 | Identifying and Adapting Transformer-Components Responsible for Gender Bias in an English Language Model | 2023-10-19T09:39:21 | 2023-10-19T09:39:21 | Abhijith Chintam, Rahel Beloch, Willem Zuidema, Michael Hanna, Oskar van der Wal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models (LMs) exhibit and amplify many types of undesirable biases
learned from the training data, including gender bias. However, we lack tools
for effectively and efficiently changing this behavior without hurting general
language modeling performance. In this paper, we study three methods for
identifying causal relations between LM components and particular output:
causal mediation analysis, automated circuit discovery and our novel, efficient
method called DiffMask+ based on differential masking. We apply the methods to
GPT-2 small and the problem of gender bias, and use the discovered sets of
components to perform parameter-efficient fine-tuning for bias mitigation. Our
results show significant overlap in the identified components (despite huge
differences in the computational requirements of the methods) as well as
success in mitigating gender bias, with less damage to general language
modeling compared to full model fine-tuning. However, our work also underscores
the difficulty of defining and measuring bias, and the sensitivity of causal
discovery procedures to dataset choice. We hope our work can contribute to more
attention for dataset development, and lead to more effective mitigation
strategies for other types of bias. | [
0.0062809787,
0.0770187005,
-0.0529242754,
0.0538984649,
-0.0048592025,
0.0277589317,
0.0424260385,
-0.0206556767,
0.004821606,
-0.0479529649,
-0.0032485656,
-0.0254352093,
0.0356606729,
0.0104272803,
0.0521910526,
-0.022620311,
0.0418095104,
-0.0052230041,
-0.0212139152,
-0.0488219485,
0.0014734624,
0.0170852244,
0.0203713514,
0.0562922321,
0.0305004343,
-0.0153518822,
0.0432511382,
-0.0052333409,
0.0065015256,
0.0333722569,
0.0405583382,
0.0769272223,
-0.0297738388,
0.0456291735,
0.000002152,
-0.0501658283,
-0.0103418892,
0.0254031513,
-0.0044379309,
0.0075867409,
0.0040113949,
-0.0010733021,
-0.0293136127,
0.032839343,
-0.005510062,
-0.0364029482,
0.0780403912,
0.0346381702,
0.0295898709,
0.0456910506,
-0.0315837264,
-0.016549997,
-0.0279188193,
-0.0294990037,
0.0131535921,
0.0361897424,
0.0627085194,
-0.0603941083,
-0.0477729104,
-0.0574974865,
-0.0620920248,
-0.0234891176,
-0.0183136351,
0.0150501803,
-0.0111518344,
0.026769897,
-0.0272832196,
-0.0352322944,
0.0149307447,
0.0386719741,
0.0083390102,
-0.0476880968,
0.0234528612,
-0.015201834,
0.0071880263,
0.0401631854,
-0.0237340648,
-0.0181058627,
0.000362663,
0.0117852697,
0.0433406793,
-0.0593784899,
0.0287102479,
0.0283343382,
-0.0492046364,
0.1081560105,
0.0397225395,
-0.0365576036,
-0.0190162119,
0.0235373285,
0.0041650939,
-0.0357280858,
0.0061827661,
-0.0469794013,
0.0022398978,
-0.0046133003,
0.0110245543,
-0.0447924994,
-0.0168654975,
-0.0543172807,
-0.0047183512,
0.0681252182,
0.0206860099,
-0.0218190942,
-0.0374572016,
0.0606701225,
-0.0347127691,
0.0507279113,
-0.0221155249,
-0.0033573443,
-0.0103352135,
-0.0400031321,
-0.0189920533,
-0.0240579844,
-0.0146047696,
0.0367404036,
-0.0238515325,
0.0097357128,
-0.0530583709,
-0.0465880111,
0.0342718661,
-0.0084368484,
-0.0447147861,
0.0186975244,
0.0212067068,
0.0573235527,
-0.0305176117,
0.0220919345,
-0.0496036783,
-0.0907288864,
-0.0375394225,
-0.0028500301,
0.0239254329,
-0.0602975972,
-0.0149027612,
0.0414878614,
0.0156466141,
-0.0376106799,
-0.0321369246,
0.0143474713,
-0.0299458243,
-0.0369959697,
0.0286143534,
-0.0597806983,
-0.0150490655,
0.0530887619,
0.0355101787,
-0.0435502343,
-0.003980516,
0.0046021068,
-0.0436923504,
0.0475750528,
0.0348051339,
0.0021990705,
0.046759963,
-0.006887929,
-0.0144560756,
0.0995791107,
0.0367428511,
-0.0259377621,
0.0127778603,
-0.0294326637,
-0.0066333073,
0.0587976426,
0.0518166311,
0.030352192,
-0.0548280925,
-0.0322705917,
0.0232586935,
-0.0189504065,
0.0717997476,
-0.02113102,
0.0100800395,
0.0078090555,
0.0691042989,
0.0169028118,
0.0394839756,
0.068313159,
0.0042200661,
-0.0088201286,
-0.0270553734,
0.026634682,
-0.0590627678,
0.0039453986,
-0.0217989367,
-0.0146002444,
-0.0215246156,
0.0572612621,
-0.0104403952,
-0.0235877577,
-0.0053721457,
0.0453731976,
0.0073154308,
-0.0018310818,
0.0398242921,
0.0142546352,
-0.0254171118,
0.0866742805,
0.0446192883,
-0.0407337286,
-0.0080403909,
-0.0554248989,
0.0047451966,
-0.0010021545,
0.007815524,
-0.0339118503,
0.0140656941,
-0.0176352728,
-0.0299799237,
0.0370516069,
0.0195551012,
0.0174913798,
0.0096822903,
-0.0247079413,
-0.0228117369,
0.0227106251,
0.038723018,
0.0250204504,
0.0208471399,
0.006008551,
0.0138231339,
-0.0261349939,
-0.0313963927,
0.0162077621,
0.012517632,
-0.036584001,
0.048906479,
0.0039879321,
0.0415693894,
-0.0038285553,
-0.0425258689,
-0.0000831407,
-0.0206082165,
-0.0106519507,
-0.0193931554,
0.0437364019,
0.0042740721,
0.006729383,
0.0082825758,
-0.086696595,
-0.0215915646,
0.0813686326,
-0.0107043628,
-0.0324780531,
0.065661937,
-0.0428788625,
0.0090360316,
-0.0025026088,
0.0119304582,
-0.0107416864,
0.0337917209,
-0.0204122793,
0.0287318993,
-0.0061955173,
-0.0102284076,
0.0159921162,
-0.0120685427,
0.0082723834,
-0.0248463955,
-0.0336972624,
0.0323605388,
-0.0041912408,
-0.0100437123,
0.050834693,
-0.0490763821,
-0.0179274715,
-0.0510772616,
-0.0262277629,
-0.024898706,
-0.0047577824,
0.020797085,
0.0102472175,
0.007118423,
-0.0263601504,
0.0061128591,
-0.0083014257,
-0.0430692658,
-0.0042357636,
0.0465438031,
0.0121356174,
-0.0304552373,
-0.0257542487,
-0.0441051945,
-0.0362938978,
-0.0632922053,
0.0571609847,
0.0267799813,
-0.0376201868,
-0.0367253534,
0.013150041,
0.0181356389,
0.0079639982,
-0.0111201229,
-0.0577738397,
-0.0047787991,
0.0170712247,
0.0824043974,
0.0723676458,
0.0036297673,
-0.0028804576,
0.0655899718,
-0.0239475854,
-0.0316246226,
-0.0128720049,
-0.0076607796,
0.0112547865,
-0.0028853205,
-0.0740464404,
-0.0273869224,
0.0802959576,
0.0134352688,
-0.0409351997,
-0.0651583448,
0.020409191,
-0.0461233892,
0.0034314662,
-0.0088955397,
-0.0421355404,
-0.0383276716,
0.0175620969,
-0.0360275693,
-0.0555407181,
0.0107830176,
-0.017455833,
0.0020799451,
-0.057252951,
0.0210268684,
-0.0431236997,
0.015331558,
-0.0004034222,
0.0141654061,
0.0484665297,
-0.0203389991,
-0.0784547776,
-0.0060168128,
0.0604897216,
-0.0187811852,
0.019641133,
-0.0173596609,
0.0309620891,
-0.000536798,
-0.0377005748,
-0.0241023116,
-0.0251459237,
0.014972792,
-0.0174219105,
0.0631356165,
-0.0244993269,
-0.0331760645,
0.0220336244,
-0.0092395628,
0.0655056313,
-0.0433170721,
0.0072565172,
-0.0224855393,
-0.0281148087,
0.0349939354,
-0.0080451323,
0.0436814502,
-0.0535925701,
0.0170614757,
-0.0283196382,
-0.0115596876,
0.0070775594,
-0.0120596988,
0.0409712009,
0.0478111133,
-0.0250717923,
-0.0017206456,
-0.013842715,
0.0088874456,
-0.0347641334,
-0.012894202,
0.0999889299,
-0.0008937253,
-0.0938560963,
0.0240979381,
-0.0115429033,
0.0322329476,
0.0468449704,
0.0218100417,
-0.0830071568,
0.0283180438,
0.0413031466,
-0.008152578,
-0.0333895907,
-0.0053020804,
-0.0081559708,
-0.1187658682,
0.0275390372,
0.0234985147,
-0.0421230085,
-0.0202177111,
-0.0281732306,
-0.0003378118,
-0.0568810105,
0.0179396011,
-0.0049171979,
-0.0092228185,
0.0071040085,
0.0094482908,
-0.0306825489,
-0.0479180068,
-0.0075716772,
-0.0308131259,
0.0376439914,
0.0303653777,
0.0116703687,
-0.0417735465,
0.0010278744,
0.0501993299,
-0.0081535205,
-0.0138566494,
-0.0307317358,
0.0473014265,
0.0061343415,
-0.0288110878,
-0.0386493467,
0.0495572016,
0.0220457204,
-0.0037744103,
-0.0382348932,
0.0464433618,
0.0198655967,
-0.0209896043,
0.0054612258,
-0.0185127519,
-0.0081574349,
0.0583343506,
0.0239095446,
-0.031232886,
-0.0275361519,
-0.0419424772,
0.0129938647,
0.0330251716,
-0.0770612657,
-0.0375438035,
0.0416710936,
-0.0559307337,
-0.0186253767,
-0.0026193035,
0.0237893779,
-0.0027822023,
0.0287297592,
-0.0310956966,
-0.0148248011,
-0.009426171,
-0.0640958101,
0.0515156239,
-0.000963724,
0.0218973607,
-0.0208149664,
-0.0366687328,
-0.0344598405,
-0.0474141501,
-0.0352120921,
0.0229283106,
-0.0921618938,
-0.0800994337,
0.0500926673,
0.0460126139,
0.0275353119,
0.0522908866,
0.0142935785,
-0.0701121315,
0.0279840548,
0.0308828335,
-0.0106248651,
0.0446809232,
0.0511621758,
-0.0358067229,
-0.0011228814,
0.0296533424,
-0.0132253673,
0.0271672662,
0.043942038,
0.0309698973,
0.0078801066,
0.012471945,
0.0325026475,
0.001381926,
0.0732241943,
-0.0411353372,
0.0202062204,
-0.0826207027,
0.0222344063,
-0.0362627506,
-0.0209152009,
-0.0058424291,
-0.0202056747,
0.0449221991,
0.0329895802,
-0.0276322737,
-0.0254484657,
-0.0340209976,
-0.0044308128,
-0.0444237962,
0.0433271527,
-0.013009565,
0.0392701216,
0.0115568368,
0.0253720339,
0.01344111,
-0.0005425757,
0.0282678921,
0.0305312295,
0.023966657,
0.0213043373,
0.0261480734,
0.026935963,
-0.0362127051,
-0.0065709841,
-0.0478311405,
-0.0027797732,
-0.0336688012,
0.0007203649,
0.0319406539,
-0.0435992144,
0.0747667775,
-0.0079609603,
-0.0172676854,
-0.0036823917,
0.0020359985,
0.012615934,
0.033318799,
0.0338065587,
0.0079537285,
0.0004304224,
-0.0356957018,
0.050411623,
0.0526350066,
0.0571385622,
-0.04220891,
-0.0188791193,
-0.000964682,
-0.0463524684,
0.0129494816,
-0.0139024546,
-0.0377080925,
-0.0130426353,
-0.1007079929,
-0.0603942908,
-0.0483582281,
-0.0488771684,
0.0377775729,
-0.0271250159,
-0.0091776783,
0.0244811028,
-0.0184302907,
-0.0641528815,
-0.0208829939,
-0.0362408385,
0.0032726859,
-0.0060326364,
-0.0068981135,
-6.898531861e-33,
-0.0504905283,
-0.0339385457,
-0.0248432104,
0.0337578841,
0.0037937276,
0.0208087806,
-0.0428723544,
0.0141261388,
-0.0056700953,
0.0250665154,
-0.0034993056,
0.0444227569,
0.0195554439,
-0.0189240426,
-0.0031244315,
0.0190590769,
0.0663344264,
0.028261276,
-0.0297420081,
-0.0233880449,
-0.0105655575,
0.0487030409,
0.0521794483,
-0.0484352037,
0.0638669729,
-0.0037624028,
-0.0312758535,
-0.013233318,
-0.0592485368,
0.0380298533,
-0.0120858178,
0.0633053705,
0.0046147807,
-0.0647961795,
0.007573125,
0.0286945421,
-0.0569590703,
-0.0269689243,
0.0438290723,
0.0305739436,
0.0731600821,
-0.0413902737,
0.0260680225,
0.017003227,
-0.0505948104,
-0.0476772375,
0.0511675514,
0.0104555674,
0.0596051626,
0.0475384258,
-0.075553827,
0.0237523001,
-0.0348747335,
0.0256942566,
0.0250256229,
0.015187121,
0.0001274851,
0.0276352242,
-0.0492983982,
0.036156565,
0.0594425537,
0.042650111,
0.0463638902,
0.0370851532,
0.0451178104,
0.0173267759,
0.0663777515,
0.0545162298,
0.0019240573,
-0.0728930905,
0.0501380861,
-0.0051827328,
0.0596884079,
0.0345477015,
0.0698685497,
-0.003908434,
-0.05916816,
-0.0208333079,
-0.0190918501,
0.0530743785,
0.0381970406,
-0.0004316744,
-0.0484176204,
-0.0468842238,
-0.0408234037,
-0.0488726534,
-0.0335216448,
0.0021656405,
0.0187203083,
-0.0113843698,
-0.0592284612,
-0.0129037965,
0.015022031,
-0.0845963731,
0.0071780235,
0.0037429263,
-0.0308976751,
-0.0119986534,
0.0170596428,
-0.0024339082,
-0.0390790924,
-0.0132593913,
0.030284727,
0.0411477536,
0.033313565,
0.0142724393,
-0.0295326915,
0.0249758288,
-0.0704085529,
-0.0019980278,
-0.0469706319,
-0.0128753651,
0.0037437244,
0.0509988368,
0.0020127322,
0.0223983619,
-0.0034230459,
-0.0118335923,
0.0726630241,
0.0238028876,
-0.0154691124,
0.0145905688,
0.0056847571,
0.0488336571,
-0.0105697773,
-0.0088960472,
0.0202141758,
0.0278379545,
0.089871861,
-0.0512539111,
-0.0287313461,
-0.0343178846,
2.843e-7,
0.0298757032,
0.0673007816,
0.0319911726,
0.0453290492,
0.0219887253,
0.0037215129,
0.0192136616,
0.0317805484,
0.0599080473,
0.0453289747,
0.0022067486,
0.0185346231,
0.0277492832,
-0.000360032,
-0.0499025844,
0.0305287894,
-0.0768300071,
0.0094243223,
-0.0214380678,
0.0012300754,
-0.0124200331,
0.0639229566,
0.013487312,
0.0088483756,
-0.0236145779,
0.0194360707,
0.0390625596,
-0.0338460803,
0.0494118407,
0.0323974043,
-0.0147370659,
-0.0273250677,
-0.0010896337,
0.0547215827,
-0.0038139632,
0.0472145006,
-0.0119281299,
0.0072514028,
-0.0169590693,
0.0389029011,
-0.007090129,
0.0017776509,
-0.016891297,
-0.0973974317,
0.0616069511,
-0.0281382706,
-0.0554990098,
-0.0410174318,
-0.0246250816,
-0.0183030721,
0.0611850396,
-0.0362359062,
-0.0033899345,
0.0124820154,
0.0066544563,
0.0005297092,
0.0071435729,
-0.0346101858,
-0.0436019935,
-0.0069859871,
-0.0301952325,
-0.0658089668,
-0.0062637939,
0.0195089653,
0.0135210836,
-0.0105282487,
0.0212989952,
2.946719137e-34,
-0.0065201018,
0.0097155645,
0.0161218755,
0.0212834217,
0.052882202,
-0.0259937756,
-0.0073172906,
0.0190619659,
0.0238007251,
-0.0594650172,
-0.0249355119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12585v1 | Time-Aware Representation Learning for Time-Sensitive Question Answering | 2023-10-19T08:48:45 | 2023-10-19T08:48:45 | Jungbin Son, Alice Oh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Time is one of the crucial factors in real-world question answering (QA)
problems. However, language models have difficulty understanding the
relationships between time specifiers, such as 'after' and 'before', and
numbers, since existing QA datasets do not include sufficient time expressions.
To address this issue, we propose a Time-Context aware Question Answering
(TCQA) framework. We suggest a Time-Context dependent Span Extraction (TCSE)
task, and build a time-context dependent data generation framework for model
training. Moreover, we present a metric to evaluate the time awareness of the
QA model using TCSE. The TCSE task consists of a question and four sentence
candidates classified as correct or incorrect based on time and context. The
model is trained to extract the answer span from the sentence that is both
correct in time and context. The model trained with TCQA outperforms baseline
models up to 8.5 of the F1-score in the TimeQA dataset. Our dataset and code
are available at https://github.com/sonjbin/TCQA | [
0.0335227996,
0.0489750393,
-0.0049816226,
0.0247725025,
-0.04369241,
0.0077645541,
0.0353688449,
-0.0099379942,
-0.031825453,
-0.0506133623,
0.0024418482,
-0.0352798104,
-0.037966188,
0.0114343865,
0.0005913588,
-0.0134830931,
0.0867870301,
0.0172799323,
0.0088259438,
0.0260706469,
-0.0022005567,
0.0094803385,
-0.0133589478,
0.0109876208,
-0.0090831043,
-0.051169645,
0.0070315651,
-0.0567149892,
0.0547363572,
-0.010815979,
0.0447421409,
0.0493833311,
0.0319092274,
0.0324919559,
0.0000018721,
-0.0136384349,
-0.0290617086,
-0.0238435995,
-0.0463124514,
0.019013973,
0.0083689196,
0.0242756493,
0.0315100588,
0.0196116529,
-0.0963623375,
0.0003338822,
-0.0015843911,
0.0236808769,
0.0534579828,
0.06395486,
-0.0010188143,
0.0256254245,
0.0173309054,
-0.000849922,
0.0398346893,
-0.0767562911,
-0.0079492219,
0.0368810073,
0.0284205936,
0.0108971568,
0.0045108073,
0.0244921297,
0.0329793431,
0.0140136452,
0.0379359759,
0.0433622822,
-0.0603221618,
0.0425390191,
-0.054221265,
0.1035094708,
0.0399234667,
-0.0325965732,
-0.0222996939,
0.0024792892,
-0.0336709283,
-0.0485616103,
-0.0262021273,
-0.041563563,
0.033445999,
0.0178155042,
0.0024099622,
0.0484473258,
0.0102748265,
0.0193286538,
0.013544308,
0.0692457333,
0.0041587483,
-0.0207154732,
-0.0449454114,
-0.006359315,
-0.0137215806,
-0.0218659919,
0.0221899897,
0.071322456,
0.0096169496,
0.0071354327,
-0.0190642774,
-0.017549511,
0.001086449,
-0.0327799544,
-0.042629499,
0.0297815762,
0.0082140211,
0.0453546233,
-0.0050159688,
0.0517343841,
-0.0261335652,
-0.0244519096,
-0.0560930036,
-0.0451648906,
-0.0236775056,
-0.0378660299,
-0.0077492706,
-0.0043798792,
-0.0452909581,
0.0066119763,
-0.0496182591,
0.0273760241,
-0.0105471266,
-0.0133424941,
-0.0015494276,
0.0460895151,
-0.0158419777,
0.02197049,
-0.0339369439,
0.0356047787,
-0.0610006377,
0.0410057269,
-0.0195180643,
-0.0732279271,
-0.0304673221,
-0.0110432729,
0.0474220105,
-0.0549888387,
0.0021560842,
0.0186150782,
-0.0685258284,
-0.0151175465,
-0.0455030799,
-0.0264149066,
-0.0053791176,
-0.0042636893,
-0.0269204192,
-0.0654791668,
0.0406554267,
-0.0058213393,
-0.0348602906,
0.0328653716,
-0.0023259579,
0.0144777764,
0.0388440453,
0.0516679101,
0.0203873925,
0.0070861597,
0.051901903,
0.012982632,
0.0754727423,
0.0453359559,
0.0265200194,
-0.0424291454,
0.0433330163,
-0.0039341105,
-0.0134194074,
0.0196991507,
0.0378012359,
-0.0148286261,
-0.0283805784,
0.0524677448,
0.0112057133,
0.0175875295,
0.0367120691,
0.0074781328,
-0.0234769825,
-0.0368064828,
0.0182784721,
0.0163464472,
-0.0025263936,
0.0064659603,
0.0661914349,
-0.0202969033,
0.0290288851,
-0.0284173973,
-0.012668564,
0.0171356369,
-0.0294592995,
0.0129396534,
-0.0477455743,
-0.0111198286,
-0.0504732653,
-0.0234655887,
0.0074435612,
0.003743072,
0.0043895189,
0.0339422785,
0.0293997787,
0.0122567518,
-0.0197056998,
0.0841907188,
-0.0029631231,
-0.0129853142,
0.0018346888,
0.0026722976,
0.0306842662,
0.0564893447,
-0.0001431695,
-0.0509121642,
-0.0349667259,
-0.0218231175,
0.0454503931,
-0.0085185366,
0.0471640751,
-0.0458114445,
0.0212395173,
-0.0159824621,
0.0221202932,
-0.0129789338,
0.0010186852,
-0.0248821843,
0.0466767326,
0.0659216568,
0.0149825299,
-0.0360616148,
0.0058990205,
0.0297428723,
-0.0018487067,
-0.057553567,
-0.001223866,
0.0047909999,
0.0133044692,
0.0480716936,
0.0036287503,
0.0141169839,
0.0419525057,
-0.0328686386,
-0.0202782992,
0.017936781,
-0.1059939414,
-0.0959110633,
0.0418941751,
-0.0076294318,
-0.0486643836,
0.0497062467,
-0.0468643792,
-0.0280289836,
0.021688804,
-0.0134525094,
0.0352448374,
-0.0531549528,
-0.011736935,
0.0039673545,
0.0168635622,
-0.0672267452,
0.085136041,
-0.0199394058,
0.0268286038,
0.0074019087,
0.0488670766,
-0.0011469191,
-0.0116578089,
0.0243099108,
-0.0161006022,
0.0083309663,
0.0003959959,
0.0141293686,
0.0205339417,
-0.0725963786,
0.0315010473,
-0.0931671113,
-0.0005985391,
-0.0056861085,
0.040605139,
0.0320847929,
0.004580115,
0.0103993956,
-0.0426669978,
-0.0495814607,
-0.0041285162,
-0.015432612,
0.0020403874,
0.063534461,
0.0056765769,
0.0055291373,
-0.0494031869,
-0.0273280721,
-0.066697903,
0.0661933199,
-0.0090332991,
-0.0258488432,
0.0244916268,
0.0028213232,
-0.0182157625,
0.0398151688,
0.0177009404,
0.0014310793,
0.007426057,
-0.0134776831,
0.0396624953,
0.0424571708,
0.0216139648,
0.0183540042,
0.0436491556,
-0.0044888775,
-0.0458107106,
0.0561580621,
-0.0270823203,
-0.0009024793,
-0.0011427265,
-0.0400559194,
0.0055768192,
0.0715086833,
0.0144163882,
0.020455787,
-0.034844134,
0.0186048523,
-0.0282025579,
-0.0187447816,
-0.0389053673,
0.0384605564,
-0.0382255577,
0.0287011061,
-0.0394963212,
-0.0090256901,
0.0570634194,
0.0255007036,
-0.0193633977,
-0.0369079597,
-0.0158380046,
-0.0659138858,
0.0710197017,
-0.0211901795,
-0.0093758879,
-0.0172752291,
-0.0330347531,
-0.0543851294,
-0.0134094888,
0.014358948,
-0.0360090397,
0.0271828156,
-0.0395821519,
0.0184944868,
-0.010239834,
-0.0189604573,
-0.0599823296,
-0.0965647697,
-0.0391273648,
-0.0058414922,
-0.0964916945,
0.015522236,
-0.0190819539,
-0.014646858,
-0.0224418174,
0.0354404822,
-0.0383270085,
-0.0064462479,
-0.0134350024,
0.1207959279,
0.0954632908,
0.0521707982,
0.0465404317,
0.0169818662,
0.0241643079,
0.0246355291,
0.0711757764,
-0.0063610175,
-0.0498045273,
0.0352296717,
-0.004560383,
-0.0161269959,
0.0255843382,
0.0157757867,
0.0409459025,
-0.0301125981,
-0.0377194956,
0.124768801,
0.0711356103,
-0.0216747727,
0.0199838672,
-0.026944939,
-0.0205390565,
0.02281221,
0.0183643848,
-0.0526373237,
-0.0496518947,
-0.0322406366,
-0.0074338396,
-0.026747182,
-0.0327024423,
-0.0130693242,
-0.0771495402,
-0.0089995982,
0.0021927617,
-0.0684943125,
-0.0010275164,
-0.003396169,
-0.0020659058,
-0.0124915866,
0.0541442111,
0.0081789047,
-0.0131052891,
0.0130040934,
0.0479831696,
-0.0153488563,
-0.0344958641,
0.0818908364,
0.0434063748,
0.0548849478,
0.054311201,
0.0420656539,
-0.030367231,
-0.0240140725,
-0.0099909473,
-0.05180775,
-0.0286959372,
-0.0139518864,
0.0043622563,
-0.0154174073,
-0.0199663639,
-0.0169972386,
0.0459036268,
-0.025351882,
-0.0139327943,
0.031193573,
0.1075763181,
-0.0031455958,
-0.0093409866,
-0.0096334144,
-0.0197465848,
0.0218227673,
0.0720704272,
0.0268668644,
-0.0413232967,
-0.0398648195,
0.0461083651,
-0.0241690464,
-0.0646945164,
-0.0369121432,
-0.0115306983,
0.0318374187,
0.0205199532,
-0.0774809942,
-0.0572058298,
0.0007381539,
0.0102439616,
-0.0408262946,
-0.0135097988,
-0.020639414,
0.041341871,
-0.0986980274,
0.030878989,
0.0075595728,
0.0204857644,
-0.0199480597,
0.008078183,
0.0050092041,
-0.0007885506,
-0.0275058132,
0.0325346179,
-0.0813290253,
-0.0111593166,
0.0132685201,
0.0032598637,
0.0094097666,
0.0116301542,
-0.0207148567,
-0.0114511177,
0.0337391198,
0.0136213638,
-0.0514817163,
0.0084576542,
0.0093457978,
0.0263620056,
0.008457941,
0.0381974988,
-0.0605899021,
0.0228710715,
-0.0002721568,
0.0271113906,
-0.0706843212,
0.0030342939,
0.0191173237,
-0.0311610121,
0.0005873131,
0.0583317019,
-0.0077784671,
-0.0019179441,
0.0006342678,
-0.0481450707,
-0.0063707205,
-0.0167380162,
0.0082495995,
-0.0025998072,
-0.0310960189,
-0.0330158994,
-0.0115151666,
0.0229101684,
0.0042671761,
-0.0550641827,
0.0066804602,
0.0399817638,
0.0417381488,
-0.0236049648,
-0.0168143995,
-0.0360203981,
-0.0173011832,
-0.0222354475,
0.0280785244,
0.0145948669,
0.0318003818,
-0.0116580399,
-0.0117136417,
-0.0594168492,
-0.0141461082,
-0.0998152718,
0.0461667031,
-0.0146487951,
-0.025452124,
0.0183943082,
-0.03251414,
0.0614385344,
0.0156617686,
-0.0059245378,
-0.004760561,
0.0051548285,
0.0181385074,
0.0143025927,
0.0690861791,
0.0083371596,
-0.0026092762,
0.0094171185,
0.0770248547,
-0.0007571619,
0.0369749367,
0.018111987,
-0.0289576519,
-0.0134164542,
0.0146345934,
-0.0706657544,
-0.0004414634,
-0.0212519169,
0.0101129776,
-0.0588338971,
-0.0409065597,
0.0238098577,
0.0018493269,
-0.0284714755,
0.0288893636,
0.0342265181,
0.0532081239,
0.0278143976,
-0.0721316114,
-0.0437833928,
0.062161006,
0.034734685,
-0.0314270817,
-0.0726205334,
-6.536902779e-33,
-0.0124712698,
-0.0262649842,
0.0179956183,
-0.0298401192,
-0.0243951883,
0.067644909,
-0.0471526533,
-0.0040084207,
-0.0517958663,
-0.016586069,
-0.0182540528,
0.0546251386,
0.0125301648,
0.0243812874,
0.0152556077,
-0.0216348413,
-0.0014663492,
-0.0344612524,
0.0210324377,
0.038164597,
0.0481931046,
0.0311987605,
0.0647010207,
-0.0045647933,
-0.006121702,
-0.0189155769,
0.0011610126,
0.0390109681,
0.0252532829,
0.0744225383,
-0.0296597183,
0.0403817222,
0.0375054777,
-0.0294618197,
-0.0092757158,
0.0456006974,
-0.1463845968,
-0.0845443457,
0.0019106941,
0.0178666878,
-0.05987335,
-0.0458935499,
-0.0102407979,
-0.0154894385,
0.0114462515,
-0.035253305,
0.0306986589,
-0.0023703559,
0.0051255305,
-0.0436170138,
-0.034069892,
0.0306055676,
-0.0327116176,
-0.0008082965,
0.0005294502,
0.0756334066,
0.0010678782,
-0.005044776,
-0.0268389564,
-0.0095748389,
-0.0015023826,
0.0134780509,
0.0384061746,
0.0182799622,
-0.0143730864,
0.0240195654,
0.0129790585,
-0.0382318459,
-0.0114723714,
0.0146095864,
0.0047789081,
-0.0228410605,
0.049474515,
0.0305339601,
0.0174033958,
-0.0215219408,
-0.0864119232,
0.0210157968,
0.0640081912,
0.0153960418,
0.0157234073,
-0.0408482887,
-0.0221752953,
0.0214704257,
-0.0019469543,
0.0437774248,
-0.0352843851,
0.0227027554,
0.0354746617,
0.0083322329,
0.0057762098,
0.0424207076,
0.027344821,
-0.0317843035,
0.0272652395,
0.0401989147,
-0.0309831202,
-0.0001707342,
0.0347456373,
0.0367217883,
-0.0425434224,
0.0310899876,
0.0116002597,
-0.0108934334,
0.008746841,
-0.0214838758,
0.0050496855,
0.0142378993,
-0.0324522741,
-0.0234308969,
-0.0223726053,
0.0142625887,
-0.0162922349,
0.0098604057,
0.0242392328,
0.0187706947,
-0.0276551861,
0.021033328,
0.0141724534,
0.0028135404,
-0.001190596,
-0.0039827721,
0.00457882,
0.0499089994,
-0.0303279515,
-0.0100459037,
-0.008677124,
0.0666288659,
0.015466555,
-0.0188498963,
-0.0091959676,
0.0198374074,
2.432e-7,
0.060850054,
0.0081641739,
0.0075826687,
0.0208839681,
0.022227874,
0.0009197732,
0.0361021571,
0.0354730822,
-0.0406202003,
0.0299760066,
0.0505510271,
0.0109952521,
0.0402380154,
0.0307221878,
-0.0051688896,
-0.0071742185,
-0.080541186,
-0.0173109714,
-0.0321578346,
-0.0298196152,
0.0316757075,
0.0791304633,
0.0134125492,
-0.0013331096,
-0.0455209874,
-0.0217731167,
0.0385703258,
-0.0039584069,
-0.0078560784,
0.0083152065,
0.0064818282,
0.0089384615,
0.0217494164,
0.0067630233,
-0.0206716377,
0.0388365127,
0.000225684,
0.0375622101,
-0.0394284129,
-0.0717410073,
-0.0478873923,
-0.0378302895,
0.00080493,
-0.028244881,
0.0991143957,
-0.034567643,
-0.0254889745,
-0.0540733971,
-0.0236794185,
0.0364307538,
0.0260305889,
0.0183178391,
-0.0146637456,
0.0100692483,
0.0343598053,
-0.0246196855,
-0.0237324387,
-0.088569887,
-0.0140666598,
0.0645817593,
-0.0186791811,
-0.0128293,
-0.0355161354,
-0.0147604076,
-0.012107743,
-0.0431017168,
0.0137954131,
2.081670318e-34,
-0.0193022471,
-0.0011836202,
-0.0164957158,
0.0613393746,
0.0066464837,
-0.0165331587,
-0.0020133569,
-0.0557014197,
0.0490055755,
-0.0612531044,
-0.0008638526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12580v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12580v2 | Pretraining Language Models with Text-Attributed Heterogeneous Graphs | 2023-10-19T08:41:21 | 2023-10-23T01:46:04 | Tao Zou, Le Yu, Yifei Huang, Leilei Sun, Bowen Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In many real-world scenarios (e.g., academic networks, social platforms),
different types of entities are not only associated with texts but also
connected by various relationships, which can be abstracted as Text-Attributed
Heterogeneous Graphs (TAHGs). Current pretraining tasks for Language Models
(LMs) primarily focus on separately learning the textual information of each
entity and overlook the crucial aspect of capturing topological connections
among entities in TAHGs. In this paper, we present a new pretraining framework
for LMs that explicitly considers the topological and heterogeneous information
in TAHGs. Firstly, we define a context graph as neighborhoods of a target node
within specific orders and propose a topology-aware pretraining task to predict
nodes involved in the context graph by jointly optimizing an LM and an
auxiliary heterogeneous graph neural network. Secondly, based on the
observation that some nodes are text-rich while others have little text, we
devise a text augmentation strategy to enrich textless nodes with their
neighbors' texts for handling the imbalance issue. We conduct link prediction
and node classification tasks on three datasets from various domains.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our approach over existing
methods and the rationality of each design. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Hope-Rita/THLM. | [
0.0168324765,
-0.0042550676,
-0.0134620406,
0.0523535833,
0.0028527873,
-0.0138447387,
0.0087880036,
-0.0146474829,
0.0832479075,
-0.0529490784,
-0.0448331796,
-0.0165100861,
-0.0109113641,
0.032580886,
0.0432055481,
-0.0027896482,
0.0179346651,
0.0178766716,
0.0244984142,
-0.043881461,
-0.007265598,
0.0729905069,
0.0278386269,
0.0016477974,
-0.007409838,
-0.0018287242,
0.0029375567,
0.0289422646,
0.0221125633,
-0.0298221707,
0.0132327992,
0.0302301869,
0.0059435139,
0.0139803309,
0.0000019966,
-0.038522847,
-0.02965343,
0.0006284632,
-0.0158354975,
-0.0235479157,
0.0295407176,
-0.0039210264,
0.0291065648,
-0.0023623989,
-0.04010351,
-0.0170620587,
0.0481466204,
0.0374590233,
0.0062187784,
0.0928474739,
-0.0377041474,
-0.0117694912,
0.0302920751,
-0.0166769121,
0.0178926811,
-0.0206935406,
0.0268023554,
0.0036846828,
-0.0253967904,
0.0162937753,
-0.038156841,
0.0111726774,
0.0262570661,
0.0088558588,
0.0911999419,
0.0485748313,
0.0212946367,
0.0187936351,
-0.0027093242,
0.1566345543,
-0.0398469903,
-0.0387008414,
0.0247387215,
-0.0322081037,
-0.0187281128,
0.0334356651,
-0.0210545119,
-0.02589898,
0.0092539601,
0.0306275561,
-0.0147504704,
0.0097857127,
0.0798947439,
0.0250513647,
-0.0157751199,
0.0642133132,
-0.0144021809,
-0.0052510696,
0.0190362949,
0.041733738,
-0.0240009949,
-0.042225562,
0.0369618125,
0.0373175293,
0.0187439471,
0.0217461437,
-0.0272094924,
-0.0105534429,
0.0170308668,
-0.0186475478,
-0.0206061229,
-0.0128088351,
0.0032231756,
0.0363703705,
-0.0349858738,
-0.0747934729,
-0.0144823752,
0.0103864837,
-0.0349448919,
-0.0142282946,
-0.0342443436,
0.0113402558,
-0.029823387,
0.0281529315,
-0.0212947782,
-0.024059318,
-0.0361914672,
0.0170238651,
-0.0357913673,
-0.0083794855,
0.028178433,
0.0373752937,
-0.0187414847,
-0.0325370915,
0.0016864269,
0.0148099996,
-0.0077197426,
0.0479758084,
-0.0344717056,
-0.006017237,
0.0082854535,
0.02026009,
0.0435937755,
-0.0627912432,
0.0154049732,
0.0677700937,
0.0373225585,
-0.0322822966,
-0.036596261,
-0.0378235839,
0.0182125941,
-0.0653845668,
0.049698554,
-0.070642136,
0.0328434668,
0.0287465528,
-0.0154002393,
-0.017835889,
0.0017193832,
-0.0148824779,
-0.0647928417,
0.0350832045,
-0.0436069742,
-0.0094025824,
0.028301008,
-0.0218923036,
0.0326968133,
0.046801962,
0.028830247,
0.033389952,
0.0373379849,
0.0185252018,
-0.0463649109,
0.0418664142,
0.0650151893,
0.0275261551,
0.0180394575,
0.0118860006,
-0.0034884631,
-0.0016467787,
0.0253111236,
0.0413793586,
-0.0299575217,
-0.0361872353,
0.0321251191,
0.0437214114,
0.0132718049,
0.0235943906,
0.051404655,
0.0098919142,
-0.0177340601,
-0.0118206115,
-0.0366334505,
0.0123656671,
-0.0494477153,
0.0076245139,
0.008462281,
0.0339719839,
-0.0367413051,
-0.0017360066,
0.0106462063,
-0.0279855933,
0.0554928333,
0.0026956499,
0.0875504985,
0.0057156901,
-0.0481609181,
0.0387308709,
0.0486566611,
-0.0155128995,
0.0237213634,
0.0307081919,
-0.0098801181,
0.0470202453,
0.0073600151,
-0.0413941741,
-0.0046223965,
-0.0294110849,
0.0169990752,
-0.0250376109,
0.0453297198,
-0.0177222602,
0.0116358073,
-0.055084262,
-0.0440859906,
0.0058265487,
0.0116498517,
0.0223288722,
-0.0065893093,
0.0242606644,
0.0201717392,
-0.0687331334,
-0.0372846909,
0.0144248428,
-0.0183508471,
0.0381683484,
0.0143845398,
0.0150571549,
-0.0212432854,
0.0637631267,
-0.0140190553,
-0.0369048417,
0.0197061859,
-0.0016597374,
-0.0618095659,
-0.0356630497,
-0.0593439527,
-0.0427058451,
0.047036048,
-0.0347353853,
-0.0093660494,
-0.0045442064,
-0.0280188676,
-0.0386067294,
0.0573849194,
-0.0183281861,
0.0418809094,
-0.0044877641,
-0.0231789201,
-0.0054802871,
0.0090712402,
-0.0103505878,
0.0522483438,
0.0050431928,
0.0316833444,
-0.0146283889,
0.0206882767,
0.0012005576,
-0.0321585722,
-0.0234099794,
-0.0202308185,
0.020722514,
0.0122310482,
0.0313336663,
-0.0040854593,
-0.037691012,
0.0008330377,
-0.1100620106,
-0.026181858,
-0.0061822291,
0.001473356,
-0.0008241208,
0.0180148501,
0.0192385502,
-0.0332295746,
-0.0197220705,
0.035296306,
-0.0070766779,
-0.0012391229,
0.0466417186,
-0.0163560528,
0.0070949891,
-0.0294352248,
-0.0620576404,
-0.0342159271,
0.1094559878,
0.0375396125,
-0.0522192121,
0.0168137904,
0.0225110371,
-0.0493472517,
0.0216745194,
-0.0171454325,
0.0081860619,
-0.0501378812,
0.0157508962,
0.0361135267,
0.0143835098,
-0.0148162143,
-0.0188683048,
0.0283921231,
0.0270701218,
-0.0485980734,
-0.013390433,
-0.0475713722,
0.0547673181,
-0.0267310925,
-0.01508391,
-0.0241839513,
0.0141357882,
-0.0078701405,
-0.0486211404,
-0.0414898358,
-0.0051339143,
-0.0192098711,
0.0270338263,
-0.0181503557,
-0.0111004617,
0.0357477479,
-0.0119403126,
-0.0283178445,
-0.0419305041,
0.061054904,
0.0075763366,
0.0244546104,
0.018748302,
-0.0406879261,
-0.0550187379,
0.0433291122,
0.0272099916,
0.0149372825,
0.0386197418,
-0.010655486,
-0.0601029471,
0.0373506807,
-0.0042569847,
-0.01797143,
0.0282684881,
0.0234928858,
0.0379441604,
0.0095177237,
-0.0169016048,
0.0059633576,
-0.0214682389,
-0.0065534646,
0.027357446,
0.0227407049,
-0.0177395437,
0.0432936214,
-0.021483263,
-0.0400060564,
0.0275983624,
-0.032827653,
0.0029274763,
-0.003733488,
0.0784444436,
0.0464529134,
-0.0322082601,
0.004674511,
-0.0310105067,
-0.0424013585,
0.0000183138,
-0.0267986823,
-0.0595155135,
-0.0138628362,
-0.0066856337,
-0.0004291109,
-0.0114105325,
-0.0327279046,
-0.0201216806,
0.0484157167,
-0.0074016647,
0.017687127,
0.0749723837,
0.021289276,
-0.0671948716,
0.0067437813,
0.0225417279,
0.0339889675,
0.0280428492,
-0.0016988516,
-0.1202158183,
-0.0050648148,
-0.0422476232,
-0.0043256492,
0.0278928038,
-0.0530133806,
-0.0002224155,
-0.079867892,
-0.0433562472,
0.020102039,
-0.0596355759,
-0.0190960728,
-0.043893449,
-0.0105793634,
-0.0347537808,
0.0081476588,
-0.0416302644,
-0.0115820765,
0.0103982491,
0.034690626,
-0.0365772247,
-0.0508810356,
0.0091470238,
-0.04124327,
0.0742076263,
-0.0271986816,
0.0210611578,
-0.0202281512,
0.0209293216,
0.039972052,
0.014498069,
-0.0123380981,
-0.0211065933,
0.0692251921,
-0.0164094828,
0.0169827286,
-0.0022660214,
0.0204344355,
-0.0513383634,
-0.0025052582,
-0.0313854963,
0.0933511332,
0.0114866402,
-0.0376693644,
-0.0151407458,
-0.0255984496,
0.0275844336,
0.0320659205,
-0.0029817324,
-0.0122664059,
-0.046522785,
-0.0366377123,
0.0260354914,
-0.0478647873,
-0.0115062017,
-0.0068796873,
-0.0633140504,
-0.0201526433,
-0.0290318634,
-0.0488594994,
0.0100787273,
-0.0014880822,
0.0058648982,
0.0088012349,
0.0319696181,
-0.0374900959,
-0.0819949061,
0.038520813,
-0.0347274393,
0.0453113727,
0.0217625499,
-0.0280336533,
0.0403716303,
-0.0640321299,
-0.0125632212,
-0.0035940269,
-0.0531399101,
-0.0911241099,
-0.0206256658,
0.0141108818,
0.009843274,
0.0795291886,
-0.0354794189,
-0.0605506226,
0.0748976767,
0.0525143407,
-0.0653951317,
0.0126711447,
0.0549394041,
-0.0019359037,
-0.0033310782,
0.0377517901,
-0.0638946295,
0.0445017107,
0.0447555706,
0.0069113374,
-0.0613310039,
-0.0386215262,
-0.0379422307,
0.0131576108,
0.036916405,
0.0095735062,
0.029851811,
-0.0904732049,
-0.009125337,
0.0122392187,
-0.0199989732,
-0.0159051977,
-0.0073237321,
0.0197508149,
0.0165061764,
-0.0012325795,
-0.0475251414,
0.0060096439,
0.0641752109,
-0.0532638095,
-0.0143147996,
-0.0070634591,
-0.0037935616,
0.0406712517,
0.0256422944,
0.0097014746,
0.0041581318,
0.0083480859,
0.00715842,
-0.0231133327,
-0.0095594814,
0.0265932996,
-0.0124142161,
-0.0514198653,
-0.0043640276,
-0.0270314701,
0.057804469,
-0.0434261598,
-0.0251782965,
0.0840529948,
0.0032048919,
0.0361774527,
-0.0050343615,
-0.0022986303,
-0.0099900058,
0.0524534173,
-0.0060742828,
-0.0369956642,
0.0349660888,
-0.0039907666,
-0.0223735366,
0.0618449375,
0.0593242496,
0.0364381857,
0.0258042701,
0.02971326,
-0.0268221684,
-0.0187389348,
-0.0054582139,
0.0048304829,
0.0774122626,
-0.0300760511,
0.0218956303,
-0.0509238802,
-0.0995331928,
0.0505747609,
-0.0183304921,
-0.0015095383,
0.0313082635,
0.0459655076,
-0.0030802435,
-0.0199234802,
0.0337895267,
-0.0408602543,
0.0127709638,
0.0111169172,
0.0021786042,
-0.0075199222,
-6.745220949e-33,
0.0214832891,
-0.0670605972,
0.0068371911,
-0.0286341347,
-0.0451627336,
0.052094344,
-0.0383401774,
-0.0011475116,
-0.042248223,
0.0289240833,
0.0036211552,
0.0340240188,
-0.0041220519,
0.0502030738,
-0.0453567989,
-0.0263603162,
0.0267002452,
0.0067099831,
0.0426859707,
0.0341063626,
0.0087771891,
0.0299062561,
0.0698839128,
-0.0912447572,
0.0423158854,
-0.0544263236,
0.0121966191,
0.0088015357,
0.0409505256,
0.0269263498,
-0.0231430009,
0.0814637542,
0.0317768157,
0.0067681917,
0.0172255915,
0.0091516031,
-0.0814902931,
-0.0519078486,
-0.0153696034,
-0.0150877275,
-0.0206161924,
-0.017462695,
0.0384884663,
0.0249998868,
0.0195219852,
-0.0341634899,
0.0861165002,
0.0296459869,
-0.0488256291,
-0.0319492705,
-0.0221851449,
0.0642981529,
-0.0207893979,
0.0220544077,
-0.0127091566,
0.0197781809,
0.0262572579,
0.0218734406,
-0.0851555616,
0.0099891061,
-0.0385284908,
-0.0346485376,
0.0145949759,
0.0060000909,
0.000028178,
0.0495240651,
0.0107244505,
0.0359607488,
-0.0432612114,
0.0243262462,
0.0460627452,
0.0019261873,
0.0073738671,
-0.0065021245,
-0.0170684364,
-0.0321292765,
-0.1052712649,
-0.0031131962,
0.0295815058,
-0.0380938873,
-0.0103857806,
0.0169438366,
-0.0003862801,
-0.0495238379,
-0.0092060743,
-0.0663770959,
-0.014357538,
-0.0333029032,
-0.0667446628,
-0.0015728145,
-0.0273363534,
0.064442873,
-0.0135694994,
-0.0689276233,
-0.0553242378,
0.0730908066,
-0.0125914812,
0.0396250859,
0.0137800034,
0.0293119196,
-0.0745743141,
-0.0298652574,
0.0081566628,
0.0044783959,
0.0088351686,
0.0034016576,
0.0475254208,
0.0261633042,
-0.0304119904,
-0.0215458684,
-0.0114868367,
-0.0240163486,
-0.0119575113,
0.0135445921,
0.0273706727,
0.0600483231,
0.0003174831,
0.1010155529,
0.0802577734,
0.0300221965,
0.0129638556,
0.0149801131,
-0.0117835812,
0.0075316587,
-0.0193922631,
-0.0233100448,
-0.0009492817,
0.0367755182,
0.0467419215,
-0.0784900263,
-0.0158436187,
0.0020897766,
2.753e-7,
0.064354144,
0.0356218331,
0.0225724019,
-0.0201123729,
-0.0046012187,
0.0136466539,
0.0284746028,
0.0498915017,
-0.0204853304,
-0.0130356923,
0.0185352638,
0.0303088352,
-0.0247227419,
0.0119953267,
-0.0758976489,
0.0082287788,
-0.090371564,
-0.0042516785,
-0.0427036695,
0.0273994915,
-0.0050538429,
0.0543188378,
0.0498746037,
0.0018716553,
-0.0383305214,
0.0147147579,
0.0403623842,
-0.0243937802,
-0.0058814315,
0.0319660418,
0.0058460589,
-0.0159220193,
-0.0349843502,
0.0281989258,
-0.0280980114,
0.0676910803,
0.0233955253,
0.0263585132,
-0.0270629767,
-0.0118130082,
0.0172564257,
-0.0445054881,
-0.0030762353,
-0.011448022,
0.0735574141,
-0.0534625575,
-0.0305285305,
0.0134459045,
-0.0400943458,
0.0016357143,
0.0284520201,
-0.0148540419,
-0.023184685,
0.0421975814,
0.0156326275,
-0.0171629228,
-0.020458132,
-0.0984515026,
-0.0027436025,
0.0347524025,
-0.0037426637,
-0.0468448102,
0.0280735027,
0.0238758419,
0.0504038259,
-0.0351336896,
0.0516984463,
2.605206574e-34,
0.0460404754,
-0.0148637025,
-0.0257838257,
-0.0030722301,
0.0061260234,
-0.0521704815,
-0.0050648381,
-0.0047291978,
0.0387848876,
-0.0764610693,
-0.002309774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12575v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12575v1 | Multilingual estimation of political-party positioning: From label aggregation to long-input Transformers | 2023-10-19T08:34:48 | 2023-10-19T08:34:48 | Dmitry Nikolaev, Tanise Ceron, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scaling analysis is a technique in computational political science that
assigns a political actor (e.g. politician or party) a score on a predefined
scale based on a (typically long) body of text (e.g. a parliamentary speech or
an election manifesto). For example, political scientists have often used the
left--right scale to systematically analyse political landscapes of different
countries. NLP methods for automatic scaling analysis can find broad
application provided they (i) are able to deal with long texts and (ii) work
robustly across domains and languages. In this work, we implement and compare
two approaches to automatic scaling analysis of political-party manifestos:
label aggregation, a pipeline strategy relying on annotations of individual
statements from the manifestos, and long-input-Transformer-based models, which
compute scaling values directly from raw text. We carry out the analysis of the
Comparative Manifestos Project dataset across 41 countries and 27 languages and
find that the task can be efficiently solved by state-of-the-art models, with
label aggregation producing the best results. | [
-0.03573763,
0.0475078113,
-0.0135624995,
0.0320740156,
-0.0087823542,
0.0063641537,
0.0067868945,
-0.0418646783,
0.0148091288,
-0.0314938687,
0.0519433841,
-0.0437859967,
0.0058257384,
0.0411023386,
-0.0220054295,
-0.0861493871,
0.0307874475,
0.0289540198,
-0.0033455028,
-0.0112048369,
0.0141314343,
-0.0093023218,
0.0027384216,
0.0491653979,
-0.0338602252,
0.0114537217,
-0.0341178402,
-0.0101410355,
0.0753754154,
0.0102903759,
-0.0366912,
0.0058882325,
-0.0296368655,
0.0180713963,
0.0000016119,
-0.0365560018,
-0.0573316514,
-0.0274691153,
0.093157582,
-0.0330961868,
0.0615151264,
-0.0265732985,
-0.0490396284,
0.0278360881,
0.005635065,
-0.0148730613,
0.0754551664,
0.0303014014,
0.0580908805,
0.0417763628,
0.0014636869,
-0.0749092698,
-0.0309685692,
-0.0110514816,
-0.0477925651,
-0.0272415336,
0.0484256931,
-0.0366702937,
-0.065359734,
0.0423758663,
-0.026908122,
0.0285306182,
-0.0023476123,
-0.0346559137,
-0.028714709,
0.000915593,
0.0059129833,
-0.0433423109,
0.0049193483,
0.0226764325,
0.0143647222,
-0.006804924,
0.0324623436,
-0.0419151112,
-0.0032731011,
0.0483034998,
-0.027810201,
0.0139666637,
-0.003460828,
0.0180297066,
0.0292602573,
0.0169029683,
-0.0137137128,
0.0029609567,
-0.0809649304,
0.0950922817,
-0.0229043011,
-0.0262536537,
-0.0035038956,
-0.0324024372,
-0.0023987622,
-0.0205247682,
0.0170541815,
-0.0060536033,
0.02700416,
0.0277967565,
0.0263879262,
-0.0183559321,
0.0129091758,
-0.0378591456,
-0.0126568414,
-0.000496579,
0.0005555278,
0.0740526915,
0.0505697951,
0.0401331782,
-0.0237572938,
-0.0021221715,
-0.0335121788,
-0.0233902223,
-0.0107264156,
-0.0086161746,
-0.0096243694,
-0.024489725,
-0.03016413,
0.0272096526,
-0.0361839607,
-0.0206426773,
-0.0288536977,
0.0094638504,
0.0239639059,
0.006207644,
0.0113704754,
0.0021785009,
-0.0317314379,
0.1267850995,
-0.0555676967,
-0.0050751604,
-0.0256126113,
0.0223925151,
0.038131237,
0.0496854819,
-0.0086189369,
-0.0168926176,
0.0042345468,
0.063075684,
0.0181274693,
0.0250322279,
0.054230541,
0.0024924621,
-0.0688427091,
-0.0362120606,
0.0337751806,
-0.0633916631,
0.064681612,
0.0014800687,
0.0270508099,
-0.0707720891,
0.0098082284,
0.0260782707,
-0.020717347,
0.0634623468,
0.040484719,
0.0351870656,
0.0364639238,
-0.0084684212,
0.0005399358,
0.0737713948,
0.0507377833,
0.0164551977,
0.0474240705,
-0.0404360294,
0.0079275193,
0.0552017614,
-0.0010174753,
0.0280191377,
0.0063734446,
-0.0271632001,
-0.0064804303,
-0.0246008597,
0.0127253914,
0.024707824,
0.043063391,
-0.013423319,
0.0408970118,
0.0655110776,
0.0232448149,
-0.0094359769,
-0.0035194086,
0.0123947002,
-0.0277354158,
0.0192739107,
-0.0131611926,
0.0159140024,
0.0407741964,
-0.0127025498,
0.0497236326,
0.0539032966,
0.0173290838,
-0.0218811762,
-0.0283440556,
0.0186106954,
0.0267862193,
-0.0247714166,
0.0557487421,
-0.0211834237,
-0.0085126394,
0.0218910202,
0.0070724008,
-0.0589816272,
0.0184620023,
0.0094065908,
-0.0426359475,
-0.022652965,
-0.0288063362,
-0.0566658638,
0.0176257882,
-0.0305631831,
0.0301222298,
0.0448170565,
0.0537696294,
-0.0509884171,
-0.053997457,
-0.0038539856,
-0.0211608019,
0.0431141853,
-0.0051666251,
0.0390182137,
0.0027629074,
0.0120135462,
-0.0025275738,
-0.0368051119,
-0.0050372579,
0.0192568954,
-0.0073304898,
-0.00237014,
0.0286477897,
0.0423562489,
0.0193045381,
0.0570724048,
0.0064932159,
-0.0003817582,
0.0544473529,
-0.0175375398,
-0.0324707218,
0.0042431019,
0.027944183,
0.0498670749,
0.037062861,
-0.0416312963,
0.0230379291,
0.0034072457,
-0.0320436098,
-0.0233783703,
0.0554269813,
0.0016298617,
-0.0365674458,
-0.0172089525,
0.0251118354,
-0.0401108339,
-0.0329788886,
-0.0891174302,
0.078763783,
0.0124382386,
0.0334683172,
-0.0229340922,
-0.0451023951,
0.0241802186,
0.0136489356,
-0.0143345175,
0.0144741843,
0.018264614,
0.0341055505,
0.0554988608,
-0.057260748,
0.0097251283,
-0.0591913946,
-0.0131728733,
0.0159616694,
-0.0108957542,
0.0587881953,
0.0281275343,
0.0002471653,
0.0189588331,
0.0330398753,
-0.02164804,
-0.0432727113,
-0.0242611244,
-0.004269545,
0.0647742823,
0.0131819909,
-0.0384741165,
-0.0027771706,
0.0093832798,
-0.0526343584,
0.0276023485,
0.0128279356,
-0.0782838091,
-0.0136638312,
-0.0017801143,
-0.043474175,
0.0100889998,
-0.0591774099,
-0.0383180566,
0.0048862337,
0.0318289585,
0.0658793002,
0.0197768286,
0.0529156588,
0.0320833363,
0.0288770087,
0.0218817685,
-0.0586472154,
-0.0211733636,
-0.066019848,
0.0170565005,
-0.0089847175,
-0.0253449995,
0.041706048,
0.0914432779,
-0.0222149529,
-0.0050055915,
0.0021573361,
0.0035652583,
-0.0432376452,
-0.0026113482,
-0.0151482346,
0.0094964867,
-0.035649769,
0.0391707681,
0.0430829674,
-0.0166092124,
0.0134720448,
-0.0240700413,
0.0529126115,
-0.0085359327,
-0.0254179779,
-0.0428195223,
0.0846065283,
0.0202316865,
0.0221441668,
-0.0003583461,
0.0026863681,
0.0001145122,
-0.0179745406,
0.0464139096,
-0.0428106524,
0.0691821873,
-0.021165086,
0.0167289283,
-0.0330983065,
-0.0288671106,
-0.011499743,
-0.0410156138,
0.0002666638,
-0.0110386256,
-0.005252732,
-0.0626908243,
-0.0461302847,
0.0556174442,
0.0510253645,
-0.0118477531,
0.0283423085,
0.0364793278,
0.0143294046,
0.0196373519,
-0.0210361648,
-0.0280025713,
0.0138729317,
-0.0156997498,
-0.0432552397,
0.0371240936,
-0.0008069869,
0.0382617973,
-0.0236678068,
-0.0708354041,
0.001521796,
-0.0508589298,
-0.0114846444,
-0.0287559275,
0.0175325535,
-0.0292263161,
0.0191201158,
0.0619358495,
0.0248227268,
-0.0225158986,
0.0164650735,
0.0107908482,
0.015347207,
0.0421436206,
0.0070474544,
-0.100988254,
0.0471420363,
0.0239546057,
-0.0124302888,
-0.0311447978,
-0.0303540435,
-0.0155062685,
-0.077984184,
-0.0070587313,
0.0221200828,
-0.0162077025,
-0.0168824475,
-0.0857656747,
0.0299077798,
-0.052634459,
-0.083513096,
-0.0124298241,
-0.0063979304,
0.00805772,
-0.0025962533,
-0.0882332548,
-0.0371630453,
-0.0246568602,
-0.0384092219,
0.0281618237,
-0.0007345276,
0.0597296394,
-0.0110965576,
-0.0059715603,
0.1054911911,
-0.0225751884,
-0.0250500944,
0.0369793065,
0.0192206018,
0.0048023541,
-0.0196526609,
-0.007061983,
0.0147821233,
0.0342088565,
-0.0247005913,
0.0292918347,
0.0502143018,
0.0011074705,
-0.0171678197,
0.0158232842,
0.0248315018,
0.0557467118,
0.0579663478,
0.0320842564,
-0.0098689515,
-0.0088331662,
-0.0503076315,
0.0051849191,
-0.0193585996,
-0.0776475221,
0.0197918918,
-0.0542238057,
-0.0219002813,
-0.0197737012,
-0.0417798236,
0.0238039996,
0.0306452271,
0.0109108407,
0.0198529437,
0.041891221,
-0.0001794021,
-0.0244274642,
-0.0058733965,
-0.0181769822,
0.0417339951,
0.0034476661,
-0.0217327829,
0.011917212,
0.0412000716,
-0.0569267347,
-0.0190723129,
-0.0416053124,
-0.0614000894,
0.0128316479,
-0.0507305935,
0.0223656427,
0.0009076092,
-0.0089281667,
-0.0318197981,
0.0434744097,
0.0950385332,
-0.0043205307,
-0.0167976096,
-0.0041407375,
0.0176945701,
0.0027424293,
0.0121618556,
-0.0034307628,
0.0503119566,
-0.0166726056,
-0.0133242235,
-0.0784023628,
-0.0329070464,
-0.0007008252,
0.0084293438,
0.0384884253,
-0.0381640755,
-0.0670326054,
-0.0459035151,
-0.0206417013,
-0.0260181613,
-0.0432490557,
0.0118412664,
0.001643284,
0.0140762692,
-0.0271910541,
-0.0068796673,
0.0122486008,
-0.0267207529,
0.0196101442,
-0.0248697829,
0.0775453672,
0.0142156947,
0.0090551814,
0.0208561383,
-0.0044017965,
0.0104466621,
0.0245115235,
0.0146794636,
0.0730486214,
0.0195836034,
-0.0249378942,
0.0277964175,
0.0308801644,
0.0380754732,
0.0173669979,
-0.0297908559,
-0.0232095327,
-0.0351298042,
0.0192892347,
0.030763736,
0.0165526941,
0.0612429529,
0.0213649049,
-0.0194781795,
-0.0046296944,
-0.0119491629,
0.0195041709,
-0.0494786166,
0.0091705956,
0.0098144421,
-0.0352545232,
-0.0017862455,
0.0284151342,
-0.0059082536,
-0.014199215,
0.0628695786,
-0.0034581714,
-0.0167343821,
-0.0275928415,
-0.0607468672,
-0.0364734903,
-0.0343812369,
-0.0466711856,
-0.074827224,
-0.0248085056,
-0.012350902,
0.0147449533,
-0.0270798132,
0.0454907194,
-0.0185354408,
0.023600718,
-0.0100363279,
0.0702189878,
-0.0599085763,
0.0276201908,
-0.0551530868,
-0.01190277,
0.0482156016,
-5.482226105e-33,
-0.0458441079,
-0.0389703624,
0.0156923123,
-0.0000083262,
-0.0121556865,
0.0144266468,
0.0061379946,
0.0264931638,
0.0006551713,
0.0361317284,
-0.0042498955,
-0.0148928855,
0.0369746722,
-0.0023384981,
0.015352726,
-0.0126393372,
-0.003447308,
0.0118432408,
-0.041255381,
0.0125009064,
0.0698796734,
-0.0209907535,
0.0801524222,
-0.1021477208,
0.0431110263,
0.0214243755,
-0.0262416061,
-0.0091372412,
0.0463730879,
0.0288017187,
0.0138848526,
-0.0122994613,
0.0272143967,
-0.0932326242,
-0.0021059627,
0.0817350894,
-0.0441678241,
-0.0070356689,
-0.0130135063,
0.0164207928,
0.0319564901,
0.0038148689,
0.0303410944,
-0.0028946225,
-0.0332220793,
-0.0398279168,
0.0733526275,
-0.0070032128,
0.0236172453,
-0.0074707558,
-0.0369780995,
0.0298284758,
-0.0192300975,
0.0480863005,
-0.0279456917,
0.0410421304,
0.041321665,
0.0284512304,
-0.0694053993,
0.0316009037,
-0.0149281928,
0.037029136,
0.0308496654,
-0.0137970923,
0.0012456356,
0.0675532073,
-0.0094370889,
0.0281901285,
-0.064608708,
-0.0242325142,
0.0229988564,
-0.0270574503,
0.0466450602,
0.0643441454,
0.0329320692,
-0.0216103774,
-0.0883009657,
0.0447113067,
0.0615482591,
-0.008260035,
-0.0196313672,
-0.0331734084,
0.0145185599,
-0.0241610911,
-0.0495013408,
-0.0503619388,
-0.0168981012,
-0.0268801004,
-0.0116064576,
0.004140595,
-0.0438762158,
0.0644494742,
0.0382087156,
-0.0644581616,
-0.033843454,
-0.0015123995,
-0.0089543378,
0.0315787494,
-0.0377059169,
0.0060860403,
-0.0205628537,
-0.0689384863,
-0.0198930725,
0.043227993,
0.0510486625,
-0.0095984982,
0.0005547262,
-0.0267314091,
-0.0866535529,
-0.0162331872,
-0.0135120396,
-0.0380738787,
-0.02556118,
0.070690982,
0.0273212343,
-0.0105639296,
-0.0030864177,
0.0032490389,
0.0366565511,
0.0151167614,
0.0197143555,
0.0163701512,
-0.0273811165,
0.0123449229,
-0.0364009328,
-0.0250150412,
-0.0254404955,
0.0303402748,
0.0601836592,
-0.0277350564,
-0.0200218707,
-0.0368142575,
2.322e-7,
0.0786935389,
0.0423147678,
0.0418897867,
-0.0028342514,
-0.018850157,
0.0294593479,
0.0284698438,
0.0385829508,
-0.0619659573,
-0.0554684997,
-0.0253285728,
-0.0138831446,
-0.0004197732,
0.0417072326,
-0.0890375599,
-0.0286698546,
-0.0513846166,
-0.0003441603,
-0.0687113553,
0.0446036719,
-0.0439840518,
0.0476912521,
0.044280313,
0.0079327626,
-0.030994812,
-0.0075549036,
0.0376195796,
-0.0183832459,
-0.035713736,
0.0446075946,
0.0002953765,
-0.0579896681,
0.0253205691,
0.018865725,
0.0186598022,
0.0241253674,
0.0113405539,
0.0657069758,
0.0016294047,
0.0186581016,
-0.0383330174,
-0.0356710106,
-0.0073132943,
-0.0496066585,
0.0524162054,
-0.0570774935,
-0.0186593588,
-0.0452564806,
-0.0653096735,
0.0007885654,
0.0504473001,
0.0222821496,
0.0130376518,
0.0484784096,
0.0052709091,
-0.0164093487,
0.0315059088,
-0.0392321311,
-0.0306902174,
-0.0260307286,
-0.0047021531,
-0.024798952,
0.0357283168,
0.0047195093,
0.0412966087,
-0.0480496362,
-0.0250815004,
2.022244717e-34,
0.0251314137,
-0.0150234476,
-0.0280342475,
-0.0388086215,
0.0298311301,
-0.0256033503,
0.0095100002,
0.0093543986,
-0.0408398397,
-0.0697562397,
-0.0023813483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12558v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12558v2 | Large Language Models Help Humans Verify Truthfulness -- Except When They Are Convincingly Wrong | 2023-10-19T08:09:58 | 2024-04-01T21:55:06 | Chenglei Si, Navita Goyal, Sherry Tongshuang Wu, Chen Zhao, Shi Feng, Hal Daumé III, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used for accessing information
on the web. Their truthfulness and factuality are thus of great interest. To
help users make the right decisions about the information they get, LLMs should
not only provide information but also help users fact-check it. Our experiments
with 80 crowdworkers compare language models with search engines (information
retrieval systems) at facilitating fact-checking. We prompt LLMs to validate a
given claim and provide corresponding explanations. Users reading LLM
explanations are significantly more efficient than those using search engines
while achieving similar accuracy. However, they over-rely on the LLMs when the
explanation is wrong. To reduce over-reliance on LLMs, we ask LLMs to provide
contrastive information - explain both why the claim is true and false, and
then we present both sides of the explanation to users. This contrastive
explanation mitigates users' over-reliance on LLMs, but cannot significantly
outperform search engines. Further, showing both search engine results and LLM
explanations offers no complementary benefits compared to search engines alone.
Taken together, our study highlights that natural language explanations by LLMs
may not be a reliable replacement for reading the retrieved passages,
especially in high-stakes settings where over-relying on wrong AI explanations
could lead to critical consequences. | [
0.0689580739,
0.0519930013,
-0.0138000762,
0.0422230661,
-0.0436426848,
-0.0047581387,
0.0165515449,
0.0068996083,
0.0084294081,
-0.0454195216,
0.0209517684,
-0.02432446,
0.0211567096,
0.0101068439,
0.024660334,
-0.059159752,
0.0132423667,
-0.0182357468,
0.0916319415,
-0.0069503514,
0.0318630747,
0.0194837581,
-0.0010167856,
0.048691947,
0.0033668571,
0.0042549963,
-0.0046713245,
-0.0012411335,
0.0053757066,
-0.0436591133,
-0.0199459027,
0.0463582017,
0.0203133691,
0.0276504476,
0.000001871,
-0.0314874239,
0.0244860407,
0.0181441773,
-0.0951307788,
0.0491830446,
0.0100045623,
0.0345948488,
0.0264433343,
0.015086622,
-0.0047125537,
0.01301968,
0.0351707339,
0.0567915998,
0.0606890768,
0.0558090918,
0.021827247,
-0.0079305647,
-0.0114838984,
0.0033358363,
0.0193749145,
-0.0538436547,
0.01338147,
0.0084581263,
-0.0027232298,
0.0373084061,
0.0283750501,
0.016939614,
-0.0031829372,
-0.0317724198,
-0.0222913679,
0.0528381132,
-0.0465141535,
-0.0262085143,
0.0228414536,
0.0400627069,
0.0307198614,
-0.037989445,
0.0177780073,
-0.0088336607,
0.0058216997,
0.0651009232,
-0.0401201844,
0.0754847378,
-0.0426988788,
-0.0070502376,
0.0063490695,
0.0076775337,
0.0468409397,
0.0597449504,
0.0261590406,
0.0609115772,
-0.0343412496,
-0.0245513525,
0.00020485,
0.0122901713,
0.0299373679,
-0.0658366233,
-0.0110818865,
0.0097837066,
-0.0211470351,
0.0315218009,
0.0148337195,
0.002228339,
0.0567070358,
-0.0738189071,
0.0032237771,
0.0094329594,
-0.0447573215,
0.0726154447,
-0.0231832694,
0.0082845325,
-0.0128760682,
0.0145998253,
0.0145592727,
-0.0321322531,
0.001332673,
0.0036265426,
0.0014676636,
-0.006946105,
-0.00902637,
0.027237922,
0.0035447984,
-0.0131960427,
-0.033869613,
0.0384553969,
-0.0236325879,
0.0205330998,
0.0018167966,
-0.0548770055,
-0.0961626098,
0.0259176642,
-0.0468429215,
0.0458567962,
0.0112513062,
-0.086364463,
0.0000308728,
0.0225945115,
0.0041553392,
0.0183949955,
0.0204881057,
0.0153788216,
0.0358712636,
-0.0021672531,
-0.0783044323,
-0.0289071593,
0.0117120212,
-0.0393957905,
-0.0514003001,
-0.0697660297,
0.0181345828,
0.0208518095,
-0.0078432029,
-0.0118616344,
0.0129981991,
0.0360034183,
-0.0411439836,
0.0734484568,
-0.0396992788,
0.0197631884,
0.0351898931,
0.0174174532,
-0.0374867469,
0.0385758877,
0.0188645031,
0.0418449603,
0.0422556847,
0.0144357486,
0.0401579291,
-0.0362397693,
-0.0049035009,
0.0130511541,
0.0286439899,
0.0160860941,
-0.0411989242,
0.0187211875,
0.0015002316,
0.0845630392,
-0.0244586151,
-0.0055565909,
0.1118018329,
0.0313185491,
-0.0181455109,
-0.0073190713,
0.0102249244,
0.0026293963,
0.0401729755,
-0.0039948034,
-0.049922131,
0.0541015267,
-0.053991586,
-0.0052760136,
0.0388466455,
0.031730067,
-0.0010764458,
-0.0559999198,
-0.0428374782,
0.0015914526,
0.0217436571,
0.0323973782,
0.0239521079,
-0.029835688,
-0.0178718045,
-0.0032566267,
0.045205649,
-0.0297600944,
0.0017963785,
-0.0687353984,
0.0349574238,
0.0771060139,
0.0290767625,
0.001376542,
0.0230755024,
-0.0227852259,
0.0208032504,
0.0642089099,
0.0719401687,
0.0036721795,
-0.0382402651,
-0.0134754628,
-0.0352198854,
-0.0107566798,
0.0087397862,
-0.0036334228,
0.0304553695,
-0.016350003,
0.0212671421,
-0.0403483175,
-0.0717036128,
0.0268971417,
0.0054471698,
-0.0020765737,
-0.0367445089,
0.01210267,
0.0004070891,
0.015201279,
-0.0004808637,
0.0129517121,
0.0135848494,
0.0094041023,
-0.0598064847,
0.0001401415,
0.0003383174,
0.0404192097,
0.0130226826,
-0.0694274232,
-0.0285245702,
0.0334799066,
-0.0078127803,
0.0027246857,
-0.0241875965,
-0.0584714189,
0.0248394273,
-0.0014030231,
-0.0090608755,
-0.0127409231,
-0.019862337,
-0.0230943263,
0.076058127,
-0.0113753378,
0.021297507,
-0.0068373829,
-0.0309079736,
-0.0100506824,
-0.0323176906,
-0.00977806,
-0.0037312342,
0.0269449875,
0.0359373987,
0.0501284599,
-0.06102084,
-0.0484532192,
0.0249040425,
-0.0691539943,
-0.0262299012,
-0.0152645782,
0.0412589349,
0.0189842824,
-0.0509118922,
-0.0030053833,
0.0114304665,
-0.0344161689,
-0.0099889664,
-0.0118408808,
0.0294162612,
0.0523821861,
0.0129951956,
-0.0016711523,
-0.0468405336,
0.0133284815,
-0.0189252794,
0.0222822241,
0.0689065084,
-0.0125916032,
-0.0700600073,
0.009336655,
-0.0463026837,
0.0099720443,
-0.0276427343,
-0.0061444449,
0.0203243643,
0.0190043915,
-0.0247835014,
0.0440526046,
0.0337488092,
0.0230434462,
0.0625875965,
0.0574644804,
-0.0612620488,
-0.029442586,
0.0032080901,
-0.0112035852,
-0.0278678313,
-0.0829841942,
0.0357747599,
0.0134035647,
0.0301190112,
0.0288396608,
-0.0283303913,
0.0314400978,
-0.022924019,
-0.0187581964,
-0.0177693311,
-0.06595622,
-0.0163316783,
0.0869996399,
-0.0119618848,
-0.0461441502,
0.0872181281,
-0.032506492,
0.023452092,
-0.0072981576,
-0.0110248309,
-0.0023944934,
0.0239903741,
-0.0360523574,
0.0308657587,
0.0295045935,
0.0168911833,
-0.0100114318,
-0.0375629701,
0.0719842464,
-0.0530835949,
0.0352797955,
-0.0519147217,
0.0020800158,
0.0210871752,
-0.0331355482,
-0.0492905304,
-0.0924971104,
-0.0623238869,
-0.0198925287,
0.0073048896,
-0.0361151956,
-0.0532865934,
-0.045367267,
0.0943671688,
-0.0014035131,
0.019656755,
-0.0352918766,
0.0214306824,
-0.0039121811,
0.0100628631,
0.0350428782,
0.0738273188,
-0.0413652696,
0.0005106918,
0.0663063079,
0.0079977065,
-0.0094816582,
-0.0290414207,
-0.0778221488,
-0.0106990682,
-0.0293611772,
-0.0023775115,
0.0162011404,
0.0083948215,
-0.0654843226,
0.0266633797,
0.0755816549,
0.0128872767,
-0.0258066375,
-0.01832496,
-0.0361198746,
-0.0247785076,
0.0327445604,
-0.003390617,
-0.0748581961,
-0.0199900288,
0.0148975877,
0.0305524208,
-0.0190120414,
-0.0240127761,
-0.0025003979,
-0.1137212664,
0.0301999506,
-0.0041586137,
0.0447517186,
-0.0266188681,
-0.081966944,
0.0025739644,
-0.0113147106,
-0.0214381069,
0.03358832,
0.0193920154,
-0.0108635454,
0.0264580715,
0.0200160146,
-0.0157975163,
0.05851328,
-0.0613314994,
0.0398857817,
0.0297505744,
0.0266472138,
-0.0471662208,
-0.0664459616,
0.007369665,
0.0247829109,
0.0136109572,
0.007294625,
0.0646077618,
-0.0029629115,
0.0114039518,
-0.0569858402,
-0.0179804917,
0.0152708162,
0.0021544374,
0.0054707797,
0.0631040558,
0.0122309318,
-0.0369292423,
-0.0088806152,
-0.0104188537,
0.0034720129,
0.0862441212,
0.0175782666,
-0.0023066553,
-0.0178881381,
-0.0487125367,
-0.0255645756,
-0.0142098414,
-0.0813836157,
0.0222800225,
0.0270774141,
-0.006033936,
-0.0601997152,
-0.0324266367,
0.0012530652,
0.0005860308,
-0.0096256826,
-0.0228181481,
0.02910861,
0.0134856822,
-0.0096597681,
0.0425549448,
-0.0374485441,
0.0384020917,
-0.0226956736,
-0.0213598441,
0.0041633612,
-0.0360169411,
0.0062934044,
0.0093675898,
-0.0295215994,
-0.0458970107,
-0.0030484996,
0.0153542515,
0.0269966088,
0.0241517201,
-0.0129762264,
-0.0569719113,
-0.0140981404,
0.0448664166,
-0.0515278317,
-0.0083873831,
0.024921881,
0.0005876943,
0.0234869607,
0.004154366,
-0.0412538201,
-0.0182421077,
-0.0122177424,
0.0042469064,
-0.0514063314,
-0.0490886644,
0.0592180155,
0.0591639727,
0.0519599393,
0.0019025399,
0.0197140612,
-0.0110297436,
-0.0101360735,
-0.0059691775,
-0.0302636102,
0.0409809165,
0.0109814974,
-0.0222638473,
-0.0280046407,
0.0169779398,
0.0323364846,
-0.0202284344,
-0.016614655,
-0.0356307253,
0.0254148617,
0.0072542247,
0.0217542835,
-0.0094619524,
-0.0073534427,
-0.0309274308,
0.009277001,
-0.0028161588,
0.0625315458,
0.0137744844,
0.0242753569,
0.0109926155,
-0.0323053934,
0.0159397982,
-0.0285050701,
-0.0701498464,
-0.0846377015,
0.0275454503,
-0.0091274688,
-0.0041900924,
0.0083163911,
0.027429793,
-0.0315913782,
-0.016541142,
-0.0038522962,
-0.0252008047,
0.0205975957,
-0.0200620294,
0.0290794168,
0.0154981166,
-0.0407775566,
0.0204539653,
0.0683595166,
-0.0159510616,
0.0346157886,
-0.0163933281,
-0.0644896626,
-0.0066686501,
-0.0331305265,
-0.0375586301,
0.0270855576,
-0.0306000076,
-0.0194097552,
-0.0879841819,
-0.0344960652,
-0.0226398129,
0.0388862044,
0.0498324782,
-0.0308604129,
-0.0094513046,
0.0731455237,
0.0173630714,
-0.0231371894,
-0.0606443845,
0.0629827157,
-0.0163601972,
0.036581371,
-0.0364545919,
-6.616242036e-33,
0.0079811243,
-0.095142886,
-0.012925894,
-0.030260738,
0.0405817516,
0.0174218807,
-0.028169116,
0.0277701858,
-0.0640974194,
0.0533633828,
0.0113710528,
0.0337925032,
0.0101422658,
-0.041661229,
0.0132605853,
-0.0286873039,
0.0405261107,
0.0253473856,
-0.0474549085,
0.0150116235,
0.0482635759,
-0.044177141,
0.0192213971,
-0.093901597,
0.086247772,
-0.0002359774,
-0.0206260495,
0.0302342772,
-0.0552082956,
0.0279059652,
0.0182936508,
0.045722492,
0.0307593103,
-0.0320969336,
0.0054544201,
0.0336967707,
-0.0388938077,
0.0066371337,
0.0796608552,
-0.0185538847,
-0.0366749279,
0.0112717962,
0.0528995134,
-0.0038026501,
-0.022987904,
0.0288403016,
0.0231171213,
-0.0209045596,
0.0165755525,
-0.0020015249,
-0.037978448,
0.0204522759,
-0.0001185759,
-0.0100293756,
-0.0234512463,
0.0545075499,
-0.0099270055,
0.0542765483,
-0.0744003505,
0.0260037184,
0.015112116,
-0.0071994192,
0.0551570356,
-0.0164330304,
-0.0282929204,
0.0652543977,
-0.0046710102,
0.0325295888,
-0.0982452407,
-0.0245064516,
-0.0146726174,
0.0244874563,
0.0949891284,
0.0787706748,
0.0286452249,
-0.028489789,
-0.0615221113,
0.0325775519,
0.0059260554,
0.023738347,
0.0421418734,
-0.0002080017,
-0.0603253841,
-0.002079295,
-0.0491032712,
-0.0064801746,
-0.0591910742,
0.0010209857,
-0.0064616911,
0.0172188245,
-0.0301598702,
-0.0205750391,
-0.0277753156,
-0.0338126719,
0.0373478495,
0.0335446447,
-0.0037806768,
-0.0220233314,
0.0049228705,
-0.047409106,
-0.0549375378,
0.0516494066,
-0.0419061668,
0.045492243,
0.0196013935,
0.0017938422,
0.0265006479,
-0.0105189392,
-0.0389916077,
0.0284023099,
-0.0557016432,
-0.0018822915,
0.0055068876,
-0.0904184878,
0.0499944873,
0.0008293223,
-0.0109639456,
0.005814862,
0.0128937662,
0.0117044486,
-0.051349882,
0.000349132,
-0.0440884233,
0.0010307884,
-0.0157828908,
0.002858035,
-0.0451080799,
0.0402578488,
0.0209115669,
-0.0408692919,
-0.0173862781,
0.0000938544,
2.602e-7,
0.0227400269,
0.0553518198,
0.0087583233,
0.0395156965,
-0.0005943078,
0.06791199,
0.0033567459,
-0.0052503133,
-0.0064110118,
-0.0805834681,
-0.0054208976,
0.0342083834,
0.0301356912,
0.0505889058,
-0.0165230613,
-0.0216711555,
-0.075899139,
-0.0271496903,
-0.0374307223,
-0.0031759741,
0.0572628342,
0.0171249416,
0.0261291377,
0.0062361993,
0.0007921587,
-0.0451363586,
0.0544458441,
0.0020673336,
-0.0163078588,
-0.0211439915,
0.0608681254,
0.0100258878,
0.0138190435,
-0.0020321268,
-0.0062927995,
-0.0321942195,
-0.0188719612,
0.0457182638,
0.0081526879,
0.006209529,
-0.0427907519,
-0.0594497882,
0.0176316537,
-0.0596274696,
0.0487422459,
0.0141845848,
-0.0068981103,
-0.0558396541,
-0.0064055184,
-0.0083601624,
-0.0062406901,
-0.016548859,
-0.0440195166,
-0.0016636647,
-0.0318571031,
0.0074068261,
0.0021247042,
-0.0278988164,
-0.0317966528,
0.0156466626,
-0.0258789789,
-0.0460364558,
0.0022863236,
0.0129157966,
0.0192170218,
-0.0119974473,
0.0175328944,
1.803984688e-34,
0.023538962,
0.0127733434,
0.0063445871,
0.0004388912,
0.0679645836,
0.0777648836,
-0.0520115644,
-0.0215342324,
0.0397011675,
-0.0222860221,
-0.0171145983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12557v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12557v2 | DepWiGNN: A Depth-wise Graph Neural Network for Multi-hop Spatial Reasoning in Text | 2023-10-19T08:07:22 | 2024-03-08T14:16:55 | Shuaiyi Li, Yang Deng, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spatial reasoning in text plays a crucial role in various real-world
applications. Existing approaches for spatial reasoning typically infer spatial
relations from pure text, which overlooks the gap between natural language and
symbolic structures. Graph neural networks (GNNs) have showcased exceptional
proficiency in inducing and aggregating symbolic structures. However, classical
GNNs face challenges in handling multi-hop spatial reasoning due to the
over-smoothing issue, i.e., the performance decreases substantially as the
number of graph layers increases. To cope with these challenges, we propose a
novel Depth-Wise Graph Neural Network (DepWiGNN). Specifically, we design a
novel node memory scheme and aggregate the information over the depth dimension
instead of the breadth dimension of the graph, which empowers the ability to
collect long dependencies without stacking multiple layers. Experimental
results on two challenging multi-hop spatial reasoning datasets show that
DepWiGNN outperforms existing spatial reasoning methods. The comparisons with
the other three GNNs further demonstrate its superiority in capturing long
dependency in the graph. | [
0.0255243517,
0.0427480191,
-0.0076142899,
0.0547800548,
-0.0538261011,
0.0142372781,
0.0278544333,
-0.0382044688,
0.0800746977,
-0.0190334599,
0.0312664136,
-0.0109387236,
0.0308263861,
0.0348630026,
0.0116681727,
-0.0561518855,
0.0207390971,
-0.0063963775,
-0.0099559762,
-0.0216425993,
-0.0060706185,
0.051808387,
-0.016837975,
0.0085174581,
-0.0591282398,
-0.0001113196,
-0.0346045829,
-0.0005171325,
0.0154723283,
-0.0688500181,
-0.0061382013,
-0.0122846495,
0.0513074622,
0.0247971918,
0.0000019686,
0.0238050576,
-0.0170404781,
0.0075392341,
0.0097441832,
-0.0124991275,
-0.033418864,
-0.0301487483,
0.0263341684,
-0.0243255179,
-0.0357151255,
-0.0320635475,
0.0400480852,
0.0249534324,
0.0212157592,
0.0350564718,
-0.0307927579,
-0.0720456392,
0.0226909742,
-0.0074703279,
0.0141860042,
-0.0020882855,
0.0168727301,
-0.001272421,
0.0193324853,
0.0266643874,
-0.0350062996,
-0.0043167146,
0.0497868732,
0.0182298943,
0.0093307467,
0.0537832752,
0.0237436201,
0.0595976263,
0.0044104033,
0.0887845457,
-0.0229064487,
-0.0106075462,
0.0216787588,
-0.0066435379,
-0.0056602503,
0.0470901057,
-0.0473332517,
-0.0349927805,
-0.0169547927,
0.0127456831,
-0.0500557125,
0.0083401045,
0.0305959284,
-0.005591732,
-0.0453147888,
0.0957729146,
-0.0127785001,
-0.0039451122,
-0.0252287891,
-0.0227274429,
-0.0075310525,
-0.0371573493,
0.0346691869,
0.0564432368,
0.0006523645,
0.0312440526,
0.0408944748,
0.0488859601,
-0.0027856147,
-0.068456836,
0.0015250552,
0.0062049683,
0.0022864603,
0.0566353202,
-0.0453613028,
0.0421478525,
-0.0340382904,
0.064212352,
-0.0017643783,
-0.0277608577,
-0.0228089094,
-0.0067358012,
-0.0724161044,
0.0525020175,
0.0021609815,
-0.0411455221,
-0.0227046944,
-0.0108927125,
-0.0365314782,
0.0290409625,
-0.022527812,
0.0898668393,
0.0183317661,
-0.0263093971,
0.0099644084,
0.0309173875,
-0.0282593518,
0.0178111289,
-0.0153800398,
0.0402325168,
-0.0034861527,
-0.0110984584,
0.0788561776,
-0.0216624029,
0.0073861172,
0.0713316202,
0.0556133576,
0.0035956709,
-0.0395720042,
-0.045900207,
-0.021770196,
-0.0662079304,
0.0425044186,
-0.0851107091,
0.0241698753,
-0.0002338494,
-0.0547646768,
-0.0345505215,
0.0074791303,
0.0328901112,
-0.0521415211,
0.0482039899,
-0.0019094695,
-0.0224758349,
0.0316981673,
-0.0061889878,
0.0225455388,
0.0299154613,
0.0599852093,
0.0901953653,
-0.0001273706,
0.0310161188,
-0.0320012383,
-0.0176887941,
0.0408237651,
-0.0023571542,
-0.0272127669,
-0.0172232743,
-0.0596200451,
0.0188918691,
-0.0232359748,
0.0451383963,
-0.0393283293,
-0.0338453203,
0.0218500737,
0.0849994272,
0.0056615621,
-0.0203280915,
0.0465098731,
0.0309241619,
-0.0576235726,
0.0097070634,
-0.046223931,
0.0586896986,
-0.0075392672,
0.0021929687,
-0.0069433721,
-0.0090780351,
0.0004070931,
-0.029713314,
-0.0243760459,
0.0001209664,
0.0825815871,
0.0150342099,
0.0581626445,
0.0072892606,
-0.0355325229,
0.0348846018,
0.0420081541,
-0.0026179876,
-0.0192016754,
0.0463034511,
-0.0032936714,
0.0245007928,
0.01868519,
-0.0023071165,
-0.0389913693,
0.0217117853,
0.0130799776,
-0.0027016189,
0.03926659,
-0.0027844531,
0.0024839253,
-0.042418655,
-0.0540656373,
-0.0123577323,
0.0109938886,
0.0387000293,
0.0493768156,
0.0056054201,
0.0391371772,
-0.0584313534,
0.0063648159,
-0.0018195037,
0.042213425,
0.0111083658,
-0.0247138441,
0.0275610108,
-0.0211974196,
-0.0093647214,
0.0271360613,
-0.0004988567,
0.0200183988,
-0.0316548124,
-0.040880952,
-0.0011138163,
-0.0957568362,
-0.0525826924,
0.0154164508,
-0.0330266766,
-0.0272358116,
0.0147230495,
-0.0542236753,
-0.0292518493,
0.0635423437,
-0.0702621341,
0.0274431333,
-0.0096547958,
-0.0625662059,
0.0343554169,
0.0079223448,
-0.0111175589,
0.0561156571,
-0.0173734352,
0.0277334824,
-0.0355953015,
0.0359262787,
0.0340807736,
0.0036210632,
0.0328628421,
-0.0077910991,
-0.0026433526,
-0.0029278807,
-0.0194586795,
-0.0082648126,
-0.0347040668,
0.0081166169,
-0.0679723471,
0.0137164313,
0.0017527732,
-0.0007022581,
-0.0281238127,
-0.016397981,
0.0156226885,
-0.0428130627,
-0.0650442913,
0.0128566092,
-0.0160798151,
0.0096975649,
0.0407406129,
-0.0353836976,
0.0060068895,
0.014936896,
-0.050223954,
-0.0602668449,
0.0577330142,
0.0311095733,
-0.0510063283,
0.0214354824,
-0.0025995546,
-0.0473023579,
0.0179892965,
-0.008103407,
-0.0162321869,
0.0168417767,
-0.0479534008,
-0.0046258117,
0.0322014429,
-0.012899532,
-0.0143613275,
0.0067633167,
-0.0511327982,
-0.0483103916,
0.0157777648,
-0.0545867719,
0.0746901333,
0.0140960487,
0.0083454186,
-0.0552065969,
0.0216334015,
0.0006846178,
-0.0215561446,
-0.0185746029,
-0.0098081529,
-0.016521994,
0.0356854312,
-0.0205021277,
-0.0251162648,
0.03705246,
-0.0080585033,
-0.0405205525,
-0.009809386,
0.0447503254,
-0.0195012428,
0.0095308423,
-0.0044299751,
0.0230063666,
-0.0523240454,
0.1191522479,
0.0354547128,
0.0292149149,
-0.025571581,
-0.0498264842,
0.0012462775,
-0.0197486877,
-0.0025777165,
0.0101116654,
0.0225557443,
-0.0372488499,
0.0404270887,
-0.0135678239,
-0.0209914166,
-0.0114006726,
0.0115096383,
-0.0381285995,
0.0163422637,
-0.0225599222,
-0.0465964787,
0.0381261259,
-0.0009090934,
-0.0086889872,
0.0383236744,
-0.0306009203,
-0.0075487699,
-0.0120753935,
0.0470019206,
0.0202560294,
0.0540627651,
-0.0189712755,
-0.0160324033,
-0.0308382139,
0.0523480996,
-0.044419542,
-0.0301826596,
-0.0386616625,
0.0632977411,
0.0042706914,
0.0145844445,
0.0069946167,
-0.0104813799,
0.04468707,
-0.1058025956,
-0.0404253602,
0.0190499853,
0.0515700392,
-0.0315852799,
-0.0082029002,
0.0070287096,
0.0230436288,
0.0221329927,
0.0099619152,
-0.054419551,
-0.0451164097,
-0.0043861927,
-0.0503904223,
0.0428781137,
-0.0329434797,
-0.0049181469,
-0.0718158782,
0.0319035649,
0.0030200537,
-0.0634387359,
-0.034355782,
-0.0373931117,
-0.0209013671,
0.0598076582,
-0.0405412465,
-0.0472637601,
0.026312368,
-0.0325578153,
0.0200056825,
-0.0524888821,
0.0402730256,
0.0340537019,
-0.0248150453,
-0.0271224882,
-0.0324214138,
0.0736051127,
0.0179085303,
-0.0530122817,
0.0286582913,
0.0373270959,
0.0084021967,
-0.0041321535,
0.052362781,
0.0229522176,
0.015527756,
-0.0168903805,
0.0198386721,
-0.0747015551,
-0.0313589573,
-0.0364193767,
0.0702510253,
-0.00164623,
0.018994417,
-0.0254493244,
0.0424736813,
-0.0181711093,
-0.019278869,
0.0201097392,
0.0326135755,
-0.0986218303,
-0.0502785333,
-0.0233983248,
-0.0873101279,
-0.0019237412,
0.0402107723,
0.0236344505,
0.0266693793,
-0.0462728068,
-0.0124090295,
0.0054230136,
0.043806117,
-0.0326554962,
0.0012207259,
0.0606718287,
-0.0357619636,
-0.075071916,
0.0305245612,
-0.0204759482,
0.057598833,
0.0699552149,
0.0316494592,
0.0003389394,
-0.0174465328,
-0.0069190855,
0.0351263769,
-0.0808655471,
-0.0532329455,
0.001566237,
0.0049782055,
0.008647399,
0.0502080917,
-0.0312567838,
0.019457614,
0.0407022387,
0.0205285586,
-0.0241453499,
-0.0049745701,
0.0287523493,
0.0049717496,
0.0012681567,
0.0182667617,
-0.0137396781,
0.0238187928,
0.0278779529,
-0.0020107743,
-0.0275452174,
0.042131424,
-0.0061291675,
-0.0183115024,
0.0293562505,
0.0504489727,
0.0002018211,
-0.0473256856,
0.0341683924,
-0.0467541106,
-0.0064433897,
-0.0126721226,
0.0181971248,
-0.0107675623,
0.0134623712,
-0.0280331429,
-0.046462208,
0.0789780319,
-0.0216546338,
0.0200920776,
-0.0259912293,
0.0357410088,
-0.032790821,
0.0387102142,
0.0175903104,
-0.0356802046,
0.005945053,
-0.0306261685,
0.0327234343,
-0.0333400294,
0.0175850727,
0.040909335,
-0.032383509,
-0.0849089697,
0.000862035,
-0.0723824427,
-0.0354891345,
0.0020603661,
-0.0263000056,
0.0848928839,
-0.0114549231,
-0.0349304974,
-0.0057828384,
0.0162058268,
0.0419834889,
0.0194863696,
-0.0002487366,
-0.0637373552,
0.0136110978,
0.0154303741,
-0.0056133657,
0.0223662071,
0.0109855849,
0.0183765069,
0.0222513452,
0.0135622453,
-0.0119868359,
-0.0026732129,
-0.0253387149,
0.0026077717,
0.072765857,
-0.0003136967,
-0.0071636392,
-0.0555509403,
-0.0760189444,
0.0108889686,
0.0220696628,
0.0286376327,
0.0331543274,
0.0273756422,
0.0015795806,
0.0239280853,
-0.0279218741,
-0.0271838065,
0.0371967517,
-0.0193197802,
-0.0171563905,
-0.0053854235,
-6.00109225e-33,
0.029353492,
-0.0883740112,
0.0382212289,
-0.014903889,
-0.0443314351,
0.0293798111,
-0.0609693676,
-0.04755513,
-0.0220613219,
0.0427771024,
-0.029211726,
0.0313184634,
-0.0014367632,
0.0443370454,
0.0133817187,
-0.0095042018,
-0.0073215691,
0.0296574831,
0.0411757939,
0.0247816648,
0.0837050602,
0.007238409,
0.0214115921,
-0.0410663262,
0.0085532106,
0.0056323214,
0.028383268,
0.0104069784,
-0.0381430537,
0.0230316129,
-0.0142541565,
-0.0025707777,
0.0440931953,
0.0226890203,
-0.023779802,
0.0281363036,
-0.1029869244,
-0.0521577559,
-0.0388001986,
0.0081108129,
-0.0723149851,
0.0055703977,
0.0381727405,
0.0128980866,
0.0581703149,
-0.0402357355,
0.0459496044,
0.0248869862,
-0.0698384419,
0.0121768238,
-0.0235449784,
0.0465903729,
-0.0035180512,
0.0002773733,
0.0038799134,
-0.016112851,
0.0449224748,
0.0068981512,
-0.0326075181,
0.0028672896,
-0.0456743501,
-0.0035097385,
-0.0053521972,
0.0097110244,
0.0128006814,
0.0677137524,
0.019866148,
-0.0169372838,
-0.0479747169,
0.0236381665,
0.0260880962,
0.0566548035,
0.0379002281,
0.0049719941,
0.0551541001,
-0.0110307541,
-0.0939299613,
-0.01134203,
-0.0517895781,
0.0282303356,
-0.0060766093,
-0.0025621506,
-0.0228276514,
-0.0518564135,
-0.0016813872,
0.00595072,
-0.0206810609,
-0.0068939407,
-0.0249212198,
0.001438424,
0.0057326932,
0.0509328581,
-0.0109082879,
-0.0488250069,
-0.012051872,
0.0590944365,
0.0201960877,
0.0190443154,
-0.0032438438,
0.046591185,
-0.0168598313,
0.008449126,
-0.0379984416,
0.0116426144,
0.0109931184,
0.0304068495,
0.0755390078,
0.0211112872,
-0.0322536528,
-0.0250722673,
-0.0569869876,
-0.0323394462,
-0.0266495589,
0.0057955789,
0.0595356598,
0.0293473676,
-0.009730638,
0.0666638613,
-0.004903187,
0.0444578081,
-0.0079330439,
0.027629884,
-0.0387426056,
0.0447101258,
-0.0066840695,
-0.0342403054,
-0.0400963351,
-0.0185307134,
0.0361905806,
-0.0822666213,
-0.0057015507,
0.0419422276,
2.753e-7,
0.0075850375,
0.0499644838,
0.0682916865,
-0.0219852775,
-0.0039859512,
0.0064609777,
0.0102289617,
0.0158444159,
-0.0340600908,
0.0183700379,
0.0322408192,
0.0597158931,
0.0069357934,
0.057471633,
-0.091608122,
0.0462433733,
-0.0324216634,
-0.0424712561,
-0.0415087007,
0.0108542405,
0.0486498512,
0.0120265996,
0.0455797687,
-0.0160274934,
0.0091656176,
-0.0346819647,
0.0153736938,
0.0326814689,
0.0352363884,
-0.0019122822,
0.0201347377,
-0.0421891659,
-0.0287961699,
0.0030280335,
-0.0154030463,
0.0094419261,
-0.0031510219,
0.0391366445,
-0.0262995828,
-0.0306542274,
-0.0056631463,
-0.0618305691,
-0.020746043,
-0.0416402146,
0.0628547892,
-0.090745151,
-0.0280064046,
0.0223451238,
0.0073078615,
0.0107516972,
0.0073874607,
0.0590229444,
-0.0069434429,
0.0011950266,
0.0196090117,
-0.036569342,
0.027160272,
-0.133959353,
-0.0193992872,
0.0236458443,
0.007226686,
0.019527385,
-0.0073676184,
-0.001291348,
0.0516295321,
0.0032802769,
-0.052277267,
2.214398324e-34,
-0.0013173629,
-0.0028054866,
-0.049844943,
-0.0443365984,
0.0372368284,
-0.0431174673,
-0.0089096138,
0.0334159099,
0.0327172987,
-0.050402917,
-0.0109290471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12541v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12541v3 | Large Language Model for Multi-objective Evolutionary Optimization | 2023-10-19T07:46:54 | 2024-03-26T12:04:44 | Fei Liu, Xi Lin, Zhenkun Wang, Shunyu Yao, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan, Qingfu Zhang | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET | Multiobjective evolutionary algorithms (MOEAs) are major methods for solving
multiobjective optimization problems (MOPs). Many MOEAs have been proposed in
the past decades, of which the search operators need a carefully handcrafted
design with domain knowledge. Recently, some attempts have been made to replace
the manually designed operators in MOEAs with learning-based operators (e.g.,
neural network models). However, much effort is still required for designing
and training such models, and the learned operators might not generalize well
on new problems. To tackle the above challenges, this work investigates a novel
approach that leverages the powerful large language model (LLM) to design MOEA
operators. With proper prompt engineering, we successfully let a general LLM
serve as a black-box search operator for decomposition-based MOEA (MOEA/D) in a
zero-shot manner. In addition, by learning from the LLM behavior, we further
design an explicit white-box operator with randomness and propose a new version
of decomposition-based MOEA, termed MOEA/D-LO. Experimental studies on
different test benchmarks show that our proposed method can achieve competitive
performance with widely used MOEAs. It is also promising to see the operator
only learned from a few instances can have robust generalization performance on
unseen problems with quite different patterns and settings. The results reveal
the potential benefits of using pre-trained LLMs in the design of MOEAs.To
foster reproducibility and accessibility, the source code is
https://github.com/FeiLiu36/LLM4MOEA. | [
0.0158260353,
0.1036117151,
-0.0033804046,
0.0318436176,
0.0026455384,
-0.0244020894,
0.0014776362,
0.0047716517,
-0.0495618023,
-0.0244206544,
-0.0530939065,
0.001146687,
-0.0413660519,
0.0005342858,
-0.0078337183,
0.0173841473,
0.0192903634,
-0.037615262,
-0.0537469201,
-0.0102234753,
-0.0113665387,
0.0051063551,
0.0420949273,
0.0387501381,
0.027142426,
0.0133164795,
-0.0336048864,
-0.0245361589,
-0.0455702916,
0.0261460952,
0.0058796196,
0.0288739819,
0.015484741,
0.0583319403,
0.0000025538,
-0.0632781014,
-0.0648083165,
-0.0078249816,
-0.0095616654,
0.0096120778,
0.0730762184,
0.0106866406,
0.0095301084,
-0.0026974187,
-0.0234495476,
-0.0147392256,
0.0363357626,
0.0015075739,
0.0547929965,
0.0668667331,
-0.0011013907,
-0.0172485802,
0.0269322526,
-0.0202978831,
-0.0046570613,
-0.0445560254,
0.0193378497,
0.000351644,
0.0246980488,
0.0030345642,
-0.0183552168,
-0.0151281003,
-0.0042197602,
0.0078880657,
-0.0347780548,
-0.0212376621,
-0.0102031231,
-0.0179045387,
-0.0235945303,
0.0515380986,
-0.0968635678,
0.0288421251,
0.0099890642,
0.0016776827,
0.0131193977,
-0.01248617,
-0.0244810898,
0.031486202,
0.0214172136,
0.0078515308,
-0.0370827578,
0.0019448982,
-0.00950188,
0.019135749,
-0.0209489819,
0.0635602772,
0.0060652988,
0.0187366996,
-0.0135344658,
-0.071604535,
-0.0689218566,
0.0096864989,
0.0146346027,
0.0511907637,
-0.031560421,
0.0119647831,
-0.0333213806,
-0.0392732546,
0.0072838273,
-0.0492764376,
0.1007758752,
0.0167034864,
-0.0080614202,
0.0137094306,
-0.0123345759,
0.0341445245,
-0.0468481332,
-0.0632228479,
-0.0642659739,
-0.0447116494,
-0.0292183887,
-0.0095132962,
0.0206778999,
0.0789830685,
-0.0087495446,
0.0078999372,
-0.0439623669,
0.0338489264,
-0.0150964651,
-0.0126791988,
0.0128311906,
-0.0104576861,
0.0506119244,
-0.0150098372,
-0.0182755291,
-0.027640393,
0.0245148037,
0.015580168,
-0.0495884866,
0.0120300399,
0.0038440074,
0.0597987138,
-0.0163566656,
0.0010461552,
0.0219021868,
0.1220638752,
-0.0026881143,
-0.0311494786,
-0.0107104899,
-0.0310649853,
-0.0170889962,
-0.0011100874,
0.005593413,
-0.0487239286,
0.0259397794,
-0.0499629974,
-0.0125539294,
-0.035146948,
0.0082231788,
-0.0199276898,
-0.0085355518,
-0.015703816,
0.0173624456,
0.0654851496,
0.0293543953,
0.0023942529,
0.0390301049,
0.1023707911,
-0.0310540497,
-0.0058822045,
-0.0112118665,
-0.005544675,
-0.0229491051,
0.0553533845,
-0.0288257916,
0.0019694611,
0.0333630964,
-0.0054339767,
0.022945242,
0.0180165917,
0.0471707173,
0.0084162774,
-0.0420203097,
-0.0095657203,
0.0093247751,
-0.0179879814,
0.0657852963,
0.0868928656,
0.0105955778,
0.0072085443,
-0.040713679,
-0.0595910512,
0.0444800705,
0.0263890009,
-0.0514685996,
-0.013821478,
-0.0088373404,
0.0632817447,
-0.0179834608,
-0.0254710391,
-0.0097548431,
-0.0298721083,
-0.0489841402,
-0.017455183,
0.0291993413,
-0.0132246139,
-0.0564976558,
0.0045779613,
0.0283196215,
0.0124393543,
0.0057216352,
-0.0863876864,
0.0024717543,
0.0148804747,
0.0525336713,
-0.0200232603,
-0.0282114223,
0.0028810133,
-0.0222490691,
0.0107701393,
0.0557540432,
0.0052178996,
-0.0011121113,
-0.0579258278,
-0.0274342671,
-0.0101573262,
0.0336628146,
0.0111763915,
0.0243302751,
-0.0009458616,
0.038345024,
0.0115514705,
-0.0057136677,
0.0382792056,
-0.0221000761,
0.0164761208,
0.019593887,
-0.0150206788,
0.0390760154,
-0.0258176867,
0.007124546,
-0.0129337888,
0.0138944024,
-0.0194867607,
-0.0769180581,
-0.0388025306,
-0.0135050537,
0.0140997339,
0.049605038,
-0.0071333968,
0.0113044959,
-0.005045231,
-0.0298355743,
-0.0221492462,
0.0252801478,
-0.0207950771,
0.0588397086,
-0.0193822552,
0.0151146725,
-0.077253446,
0.0261459276,
-0.0350484513,
0.0309198853,
-0.0092825629,
-0.0221390966,
0.0058801291,
-0.053837724,
0.0599708445,
-0.0089918999,
-0.0625197589,
0.0085424324,
-0.0177127756,
0.0565334894,
0.0078392588,
0.0658016428,
0.0119483545,
-0.0677684322,
-0.04602433,
0.0513736308,
0.0426627286,
0.0201269239,
0.031199621,
-0.0034822582,
0.0117972475,
0.0675280541,
0.0215001609,
0.06855575,
-0.0390991792,
-0.0345096588,
0.0206523817,
-0.0129592819,
-0.0063240714,
-0.0027929624,
-0.0176449567,
-0.0106159579,
0.0794131607,
-0.0395665951,
0.0528730117,
-0.0485581122,
0.0875029266,
-0.0522335172,
0.0313521996,
-0.0175028946,
-0.0034613416,
-0.0410443991,
-0.0327000245,
0.0230681524,
0.0638903305,
0.0106687201,
-0.0055749007,
0.0525420085,
-0.02342139,
-0.0323204584,
0.003840239,
-0.0484148152,
-0.0408772714,
-0.0140956379,
-0.008733619,
0.0322677158,
0.0447654985,
-0.0227465928,
-0.0367159694,
-0.0126463678,
0.0158070829,
0.009254491,
-0.0117920917,
-0.0370428078,
0.0049136011,
0.0206629783,
0.0183235407,
-0.0039463434,
0.0134695554,
0.0599193275,
0.0489378572,
0.0097706784,
-0.0196579527,
-0.0019801562,
-0.1213170961,
0.0058240104,
-0.0406362899,
0.0378249995,
-0.0045534335,
0.0447618552,
-0.0694634616,
0.0200013984,
-0.0085147452,
-0.010602029,
0.0005183061,
0.0108142411,
-0.0129269389,
0.0079620061,
-0.0441417731,
0.0082996106,
0.0053396993,
0.0227301437,
0.0307294317,
0.0078946436,
-0.0108366404,
-0.0825526118,
0.0233108569,
-0.0044568302,
0.0371122621,
-0.0214263294,
0.0065566427,
-0.0372275896,
-0.0136697926,
0.0572420731,
0.0042593959,
0.0266462881,
-0.0004978142,
0.0496718846,
-0.0068118786,
0.0013926029,
-0.0269660614,
-0.0412607789,
0.0189368315,
0.0277355146,
0.0077905739,
-0.0507107116,
-0.0067065926,
-0.0228035543,
-0.0522524677,
0.0470322631,
0.0681799501,
0.0086750509,
-0.0138251642,
0.0261175055,
-0.0586072542,
0.0424892604,
0.0202555507,
0.0619974732,
0.0042437669,
-0.036842294,
-0.0242946073,
-0.0023805227,
-0.015279389,
-0.0254768264,
-0.0097414134,
-0.1174546331,
-0.0014127966,
-0.0095732491,
-0.026100643,
0.0419218168,
-0.0186758246,
0.0069364011,
-0.043037653,
0.0001318425,
0.0206023306,
0.0073610791,
-0.052595567,
-0.0202733781,
0.0517574176,
-0.0337920114,
0.0367522202,
-0.0080302591,
-0.013365522,
0.0465531871,
0.0104459086,
-0.0017121518,
0.0303887278,
0.0875485092,
0.0160513632,
-0.0072587794,
0.0147996834,
-0.0255334228,
-0.0154033545,
0.0002655757,
-0.0285434444,
0.0418603607,
-0.039659705,
0.0075439732,
0.0145521006,
0.0673233271,
0.0086450865,
-0.0467371978,
-0.0444509126,
-0.0703390539,
-0.0147821074,
0.0233348217,
-0.0349915214,
-0.1059916988,
-0.0113669569,
-0.0127316499,
-0.0450428911,
-0.0281403009,
-0.0073501728,
0.0029901245,
0.0056721619,
-0.0225182138,
-0.0267670974,
0.063026756,
0.0013568425,
0.0185943339,
0.044201605,
-0.0084121702,
0.0042689783,
-0.0410857014,
-0.0109599167,
-0.0019496103,
-0.0168873221,
-0.0383383892,
-0.0533477738,
0.0639315397,
0.0951850563,
-0.053928595,
-0.0471702218,
0.0117717283,
-0.0535821654,
-0.0353716575,
0.0077937413,
0.0557128862,
0.0084938984,
-0.0176770333,
-0.0044184793,
-0.0671997145,
0.0552540459,
0.0679974779,
0.0406351201,
0.0173794739,
-0.027271878,
-0.010109609,
0.0059396294,
-0.0012082496,
-0.0012982468,
0.0369999073,
-0.0014153278,
0.022185687,
0.0072640367,
0.0035393508,
0.0035525146,
0.0469632633,
-0.008321817,
-0.0026641735,
0.000085548,
-0.0232430231,
0.0137961525,
0.0075126677,
-0.0327761136,
-0.0186527427,
0.0210147537,
-0.0140218129,
-0.0196766276,
0.0420563109,
0.0078564743,
0.0686496645,
0.0389581285,
-0.0042172028,
0.0195541792,
0.0070336098,
-0.0063461987,
0.0243905038,
0.0183745287,
0.0697401091,
0.062863268,
-0.0068502533,
-0.0137283038,
-0.0212587025,
0.0134475995,
0.0070567871,
-0.0063717733,
-0.0399872847,
0.0203920864,
0.0027576666,
-0.0092227682,
-0.0743618459,
0.01178749,
0.0358738489,
0.009459788,
-0.0203855876,
-0.0261335243,
0.0065006902,
-0.0124783516,
-0.0077050678,
-0.0562584065,
-0.0064137313,
0.0098954383,
-0.0138216093,
-0.0233745649,
-0.0157435723,
0.0561915971,
0.0228115376,
0.044798784,
-0.058985576,
0.0196457282,
-0.0315323845,
-0.0010277089,
0.0828766748,
0.0111731756,
-0.0210328512,
0.0005579492,
-0.0368580408,
0.0119299628,
-0.0191459153,
-0.0211958177,
0.0362541564,
0.0247138087,
0.0450454578,
0.0598954819,
-0.0564641766,
0.0121136792,
-0.0179286785,
-0.0497757979,
-0.0507853143,
-0.0335220508,
0.0142399017,
-6.308281617e-33,
0.0128038637,
-0.025630245,
0.0172717236,
-0.0289394613,
-0.0025681641,
0.011178324,
0.0313298032,
0.0311041661,
-0.0225697383,
-0.0869181231,
0.015868457,
-0.03688794,
-0.0370857269,
-0.006239953,
0.0250725262,
0.0312693119,
-0.0243563559,
-0.0312714688,
-0.0442224555,
-0.0537600107,
0.0134940231,
-0.0087617645,
-0.030095011,
0.0417697802,
-0.0608291477,
0.0314748809,
-0.0406305417,
0.0165457446,
-0.0061967303,
0.0637787282,
-0.0019678932,
0.0528131612,
-0.0065544085,
0.0076224753,
-0.0134313535,
-0.0258255992,
0.0292680319,
-0.0370354317,
-0.0141056264,
0.0018435629,
-0.0020237523,
-0.0425105244,
0.0398173369,
0.0406821705,
-0.051691141,
0.038693022,
0.0133553771,
0.0135794347,
0.010717852,
0.0071149678,
0.0038717357,
-0.001973253,
-0.0153738093,
-0.0379047319,
0.0221027359,
-0.0274636187,
-0.0096071027,
0.0549921617,
0.0361338444,
0.0781422406,
-0.0604356937,
0.0049273507,
0.0546733402,
0.0336572118,
0.0238968413,
0.0198635664,
-0.0152006522,
0.0135320537,
0.0385384522,
-0.0543795973,
0.0521351472,
0.0587360747,
0.0159456898,
0.0071416521,
-0.0194548257,
-0.0010801622,
-0.0746918395,
0.0322375074,
-0.0468165018,
-0.0148660298,
0.0820790827,
0.0521071665,
0.0474830456,
0.0004873092,
-0.0425293408,
-0.0293705575,
-0.0541282818,
0.0159284603,
0.005514795,
-0.0084387828,
-0.0291114785,
-0.0353322029,
0.0154157486,
-0.0514162034,
0.0336463861,
0.0146802003,
-0.1029480919,
0.0265193321,
0.0119383289,
0.0570723638,
-0.0346161164,
-0.104519926,
0.0065735802,
-0.029991081,
0.0061178259,
0.0199014135,
-0.0032867303,
0.024078859,
-0.0567281693,
-0.0144375768,
-0.0207880195,
-0.0146722309,
0.0055477605,
0.0216253083,
0.017362345,
-0.0098994644,
0.014765596,
-0.0082037859,
0.0880462453,
-0.0126997437,
-0.0378358848,
0.0271131657,
0.0244383477,
-0.0111136632,
0.0018339161,
0.0308449287,
0.0019424687,
-0.0385059603,
-0.0054820618,
-0.0078786863,
-0.032575421,
0.0138457874,
3.181e-7,
0.0670400411,
0.0683326796,
-0.059601441,
0.0167789627,
0.0195430778,
0.0260365084,
-0.0115400068,
0.0043308064,
-0.048058372,
0.0570377111,
-0.0034359773,
0.022491945,
0.0016511003,
-0.0266730953,
-0.0348789282,
0.0464012623,
0.0103411209,
0.0356917605,
-0.1074607521,
-0.0204430316,
0.0209250562,
0.075457409,
0.0155915963,
-0.0129095204,
-0.0505340137,
-0.0208660923,
0.0578750744,
0.0057727294,
0.0117129693,
0.0509239025,
-0.0683152452,
0.0264479574,
-0.0269272234,
-0.0157278012,
0.0349518619,
0.076454632,
0.0277910102,
0.0826406181,
0.0270949695,
-0.0332350098,
0.1053192094,
0.0537804104,
-0.0394498929,
-0.0555375963,
0.062591508,
-0.0130832475,
-0.0471812673,
-0.0632000789,
0.0224256814,
0.0272917431,
-0.0214597154,
-0.0926551074,
0.0265909694,
0.0208217409,
-0.0489641093,
-0.0027595391,
-0.0105775325,
0.0003579848,
0.0054405769,
0.0066537904,
-0.0296176095,
-0.0621334165,
-0.0343536586,
0.0015134744,
0.067190811,
-0.0339044966,
0.0050643301,
2.956449337e-34,
-0.0034403154,
-0.0092447903,
-0.0147586707,
0.0500256792,
0.0033910456,
0.0178650413,
-0.0704003498,
0.0347987078,
-0.0205613561,
-0.01013909,
-0.0069220169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13028v1 | Reliable Academic Conference Question Answering: A Study Based on Large Language Model | 2023-10-19T07:39:07 | 2023-10-19T07:39:07 | Zhiwei Huang, Long Jin, Junjie Wang, Mingchen Tu, Yin Hua, Zhiqiang Liu, Jiawei Meng, Huajun Chen, Wen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid growth of computer science has led to a proliferation of research
presented at academic conferences, fostering global scholarly communication.
Researchers consistently seek accurate, current information about these events
at all stages. This data surge necessitates an intelligent question-answering
system to efficiently address researchers' queries and ensure awareness of the
latest advancements. The information of conferences is usually published on
their official website, organized in a semi-structured way with a lot of text.
To address this need, we have developed the ConferenceQA dataset for 7 diverse
academic conferences with human annotations. Firstly, we employ a combination
of manual and automated methods to organize academic conference data in a
semi-structured JSON format. Subsequently, we annotate nearly 100
question-answer pairs for each conference. Each pair is classified into four
different dimensions. To ensure the reliability of the data, we manually
annotate the source of each answer. In light of recent advancements, Large
Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance in various NLP
tasks. They have demonstrated impressive capabilities in information-seeking
question answering after instruction fine-tuning, and as such, we present our
conference QA study based on LLM. Due to hallucination and outdated knowledge
of LLMs, we adopt retrieval based methods to enhance LLMs' question-answering
abilities. We have proposed a structure-aware retrieval method, specifically
designed to leverage inherent structural information during the retrieval
process. Empirical validation on the ConferenceQA dataset has demonstrated the
effectiveness of this method. The dataset and code are readily accessible on
https://github.com/zjukg/ConferenceQA. | [
0.0734837279,
0.0609426647,
-0.010215777,
0.0928200707,
-0.0139669189,
-0.0073834294,
-0.0217664633,
-0.0080577163,
0.0240960531,
-0.0539308749,
-0.0319449306,
-0.0231506415,
-0.0469798297,
0.0268900823,
0.0118350415,
-0.0226014256,
0.0225572754,
-0.0081767431,
0.0368655138,
0.0022180595,
0.0203129835,
0.0126979267,
-0.0111100134,
0.0314377062,
0.0398094356,
-0.0363500454,
0.0028381811,
-0.0267201252,
-0.0125953322,
-0.0246600807,
0.0435815938,
0.0303662848,
0.0211611874,
0.0217566881,
0.0000017053,
-0.0543620437,
-0.0269551389,
0.0022932563,
-0.0082182428,
0.0222306997,
0.0007878418,
0.0079128435,
0.0117338132,
0.0370134972,
-0.0516167544,
-0.0211393125,
0.0056602955,
0.037171863,
0.0542416722,
0.0513889529,
-0.0039824601,
-0.0478195474,
0.0407478213,
0.0109411338,
-0.0089620939,
-0.0358873084,
0.0609321371,
0.0432967208,
0.0166036952,
0.0780814514,
0.0485590249,
0.0246113557,
-0.0220404677,
-0.0260570534,
0.0260471329,
-0.0111298664,
-0.0812837183,
-0.0077623208,
0.007025918,
0.0790379345,
0.074333325,
-0.0120929703,
0.0322514586,
0.0106995627,
-0.0215984881,
0.0421041362,
-0.0726222768,
0.0230700206,
0.0009504532,
-0.0175880492,
-0.0017406726,
0.0174838528,
-0.0022661756,
0.0278910883,
0.0015055652,
0.0620793216,
0.0137519166,
-0.0438426249,
-0.0483340546,
0.0146738514,
-0.0228517018,
-0.0555838346,
0.013542477,
0.0793294087,
0.0050861822,
0.0193838868,
0.048236303,
-0.0294359755,
0.0367566347,
-0.0743569806,
-0.0342979506,
-0.0059321211,
-0.0028669657,
0.05914912,
0.0057223192,
0.0185693037,
-0.0359332152,
0.0075890468,
-0.0492527112,
-0.0442029908,
-0.0287708584,
-0.0253700502,
-0.0286551174,
0.0562019087,
-0.0484518521,
-0.0058471863,
-0.0015437005,
0.0117898639,
0.0048612687,
-0.0113205146,
-0.0448303893,
0.0230580214,
-0.0176006872,
0.0158124212,
-0.0583913028,
0.0621993057,
-0.0530351289,
0.006051369,
-0.0208945908,
-0.0289761648,
0.0047681974,
0.0389752239,
0.0243684109,
-0.0108180558,
0.0211634021,
0.0418742821,
0.0057694735,
-0.0156051805,
-0.0004749204,
-0.0408654064,
0.0012611663,
-0.0413524099,
0.0135960812,
-0.0423205383,
0.0465475395,
0.0313637964,
-0.0565334484,
-0.0230856054,
0.0143845445,
0.0586997643,
-0.0334149152,
0.034720704,
-0.0300426055,
0.0238835197,
0.0889716446,
0.0091236439,
0.0039371587,
0.0196481794,
-0.0006099233,
0.0307602063,
0.0720451474,
0.0140250633,
0.024957601,
0.0096058045,
0.0346414782,
0.0083228545,
0.0113252727,
0.0865616053,
-0.0075847115,
-0.0001684814,
-0.0143537186,
0.0692114085,
-0.0265680179,
-0.0083243437,
0.0028446577,
0.0439266264,
-0.0236948784,
0.005749091,
-0.013235026,
0.0196812544,
0.0378021076,
-0.0179206636,
0.0248135217,
0.0225575138,
-0.0216127615,
0.0061175348,
0.0824695528,
0.000443969,
-0.006979858,
-0.0518670306,
-0.0377524234,
0.0253304113,
-0.0176212881,
0.0476348884,
0.0330862217,
-0.0055399868,
-0.0267675519,
0.0335304551,
0.0282132719,
-0.0239533111,
-0.0069462354,
-0.0240721442,
0.0608833805,
0.0201689471,
0.0343117975,
-0.0263783913,
-0.0253158882,
-0.0080002313,
0.0302958563,
0.0427318439,
0.045254048,
-0.0309473556,
-0.0245671552,
-0.0132848164,
0.0190541595,
0.0018191712,
-0.0181426313,
-0.0330083743,
0.0266925823,
0.0010450786,
0.0179795213,
-0.0226995684,
-0.0357707851,
0.029085055,
-0.0174646322,
-0.0132763544,
-0.0170090832,
-0.0314556845,
0.0271988176,
0.0276205726,
-0.0094570946,
0.037187539,
0.064649187,
-0.0526290238,
-0.0206848737,
-0.0343211479,
-0.0116662057,
-0.0278798118,
0.0582297035,
-0.012494456,
-0.0279712379,
0.03457845,
-0.0192926135,
-0.0348512307,
0.0248736739,
-0.0242824983,
0.0185133182,
-0.0369703434,
-0.0403561555,
0.0102375075,
0.0095806997,
-0.0602845848,
0.0609334931,
0.0303711351,
0.0446496867,
0.0488102399,
-0.0135512231,
0.0417180546,
-0.0386815965,
-0.037028376,
0.0308317058,
0.0013899879,
0.017826397,
0.0872127116,
-0.0376432873,
-0.0477645881,
-0.013664403,
-0.0872792155,
0.0309744682,
-0.0188418869,
0.015801359,
0.033507064,
0.0089141242,
0.0065394756,
-0.0228253026,
-0.0417970233,
-0.0314803831,
0.0052596722,
0.0092625245,
0.0657233447,
0.0322433747,
-0.0032438021,
-0.0642443448,
-0.0194287226,
-0.0387068801,
0.0473622419,
0.0370465964,
-0.0269639734,
-0.0443860665,
-0.0095792329,
-0.0449548736,
0.0200699512,
0.0025108871,
-0.0123791872,
-0.0086186416,
-0.0338713378,
0.007722165,
0.0663550794,
0.0266055577,
-0.0080314623,
0.0139151467,
0.0026881131,
-0.0524911135,
0.0180215929,
-0.0227256324,
-0.0097294729,
-0.0197065286,
-0.0161138102,
0.0352810435,
0.0312858298,
0.0106072119,
0.0010206505,
-0.0247800853,
0.0003425223,
-0.0135550648,
0.0370132476,
-0.0341113545,
-0.0273220073,
-0.0021925999,
0.0607555769,
0.0172882546,
0.0084905876,
0.0390853211,
-0.0331465155,
-0.0053937398,
-0.0652988553,
-0.0175173618,
-0.0924616009,
0.0550394356,
-0.0107375719,
0.0218675546,
-0.0233118217,
-0.0044118748,
-0.0285262056,
-0.0219406225,
-0.0035975529,
-0.070398815,
0.0002297633,
0.0107290549,
0.0361745544,
-0.0311698616,
-0.0267989691,
-0.0103593934,
-0.0350411534,
-0.0499471352,
0.011799993,
0.0038069454,
-0.0003963729,
-0.0465869382,
-0.001530273,
0.0332782753,
-0.0045190272,
-0.0297087077,
-0.0175288543,
-0.0042484454,
0.0656541362,
0.0755689517,
0.0537291169,
0.0167676844,
0.0026148101,
-0.0143148797,
0.0623308197,
-0.0088008838,
0.0499151237,
-0.034265887,
-0.0585209467,
0.0349226594,
-0.0571563765,
0.0095916037,
-0.0076690866,
0.0524311662,
-0.0571348928,
-0.0028939489,
0.1032574475,
0.040262416,
-0.045644585,
-0.0408786945,
-0.0560996458,
0.0294465441,
0.0253940821,
0.0707069561,
-0.0881490037,
-0.0176612586,
-0.0218118187,
0.0431348197,
-0.0120406803,
-0.0133423954,
0.0205774717,
-0.0781477243,
0.0271856859,
-0.0284315292,
-0.0008935484,
-0.0445837975,
-0.0522595234,
0.0126971295,
-0.0105403261,
0.0113086179,
0.0395090133,
-0.0255518164,
-0.0047695455,
0.0356242172,
-0.065680258,
-0.0246619303,
0.0595304519,
-0.0190054942,
0.0474066399,
0.0544706248,
0.0368084013,
-0.0184416622,
-0.0168233458,
0.0044695656,
-0.0462275408,
-0.0224720892,
0.0126737729,
0.0274226181,
-0.014551484,
-0.0084706089,
-0.020314103,
0.0277653672,
-0.0472465679,
-0.0133148348,
0.0535778813,
0.0711206719,
-0.0026946901,
0.0270093363,
-0.0835201144,
0.0154412007,
-0.0476238467,
0.1016269624,
0.0209146142,
0.0039643073,
-0.0434654094,
-0.0358337052,
0.0258499049,
-0.011275393,
-0.0253919736,
0.0052805636,
0.0379752144,
0.0368976519,
-0.0777282938,
-0.0459668525,
0.0489600375,
-0.0105333338,
-0.0303905196,
0.0459493399,
0.0039020015,
0.0153956544,
-0.0676786751,
0.0358889103,
-0.0475018956,
0.0032090808,
-0.0366021954,
-0.0121353706,
0.0522409491,
-0.0081724934,
-0.0512937158,
0.0225595124,
-0.0526627339,
-0.0447983146,
-0.0457362495,
0.0022555727,
0.0139487684,
0.0350680314,
-0.0179008469,
-0.040651992,
-0.0073676538,
0.0029676766,
-0.0405074283,
-0.0274995659,
0.014760714,
0.0103858151,
-0.0265630726,
0.0038509022,
-0.0649505258,
0.0201349873,
-0.0414817072,
0.0714360252,
-0.0418695919,
-0.0589982271,
0.0419517383,
0.0703685805,
0.0126428828,
0.0386915319,
-0.0131240217,
0.0049071177,
0.0186941326,
-0.0208827965,
-0.0233231634,
-0.0104116751,
-0.002881597,
-0.0093328133,
-0.0426641926,
-0.0027925111,
0.0032378645,
-0.0408826731,
0.0477973931,
-0.0282163192,
0.0575604327,
0.008279616,
-0.0128406277,
0.0098177269,
-0.0277378857,
-0.0352037698,
-0.0114333574,
-0.0061138016,
0.0595078394,
-0.0196832456,
0.0111278994,
0.0395076945,
-0.037846528,
-0.0082896836,
-0.0006158978,
-0.0972067937,
-0.0692533776,
-0.0254667588,
-0.0063995002,
0.0217705928,
0.0059348238,
0.0305339303,
-0.0086538941,
-0.0196854398,
-0.0198203083,
-0.0040190686,
-0.0052626296,
-0.017371932,
0.068472676,
0.0261967108,
-0.0287080221,
0.0127847437,
0.0742360204,
0.0158892106,
-0.0167653393,
0.0044487431,
-0.018067006,
-0.0245792512,
-0.0004320013,
-0.0081046075,
0.0241234321,
-0.0117105898,
-0.0038019123,
-0.0230888613,
-0.0361735523,
0.0390306637,
-0.0376778506,
-0.0246152263,
-0.0388899669,
0.0034251283,
0.0748404711,
0.0588505566,
-0.0253987256,
-0.066431053,
0.0412593521,
0.0041708378,
-0.0287010595,
-0.0336364023,
-6.374956392e-33,
-0.0064685745,
-0.0217382926,
0.0246927664,
0.0096238106,
-0.0084198834,
0.0218847692,
-0.0604802705,
-0.0218156613,
-0.0746359006,
-0.0144274822,
-0.0136401094,
-0.0010823024,
-0.0085125621,
0.0397042669,
0.0151409116,
-0.0318206362,
0.0077316673,
-0.0196659938,
0.0023935891,
0.0251363404,
0.0209318064,
0.0103416899,
0.0161115024,
-0.0686481223,
0.0337827243,
-0.0540638268,
0.0194276981,
0.0353748649,
0.0405531526,
0.0717385709,
-0.03520035,
0.0165655557,
0.0251489524,
-0.054930117,
0.035072621,
0.0238865372,
-0.0749320239,
-0.0256220158,
-0.0122284517,
-0.0094569419,
-0.0508311577,
-0.0119681414,
0.0406264476,
-0.0188120659,
0.0306533519,
0.0030107095,
0.0527630337,
-0.0254572779,
-0.0171299372,
-0.0472555347,
-0.0316810943,
0.0230768155,
-0.0426665433,
0.0189479236,
-0.0038955037,
0.0460396782,
-0.0015602035,
0.0714104399,
-0.0302107427,
0.0190776885,
-0.0048456318,
0.0214616396,
0.0069139749,
-0.0098026097,
0.0137025155,
0.043661397,
0.0051142122,
0.0218495056,
-0.0296274647,
-0.0342600569,
-0.0297399554,
0.0119895255,
0.0385585204,
0.050895907,
0.0086204326,
0.0214248337,
-0.089107208,
0.0256223418,
0.0240165293,
0.0480755381,
0.0345253199,
-0.0037834989,
-0.0255686697,
0.0099006202,
-0.0315005034,
0.0333268791,
-0.0319798589,
-0.0215040836,
0.0269261226,
-0.0198938418,
-0.0318363979,
0.0320512131,
0.042054709,
-0.0738888383,
-0.0427215695,
0.0584606342,
-0.0282313637,
0.030108247,
0.0065050242,
0.0574633665,
-0.0863566473,
0.0154759502,
-0.0164368376,
-0.0287633389,
0.002090927,
0.0262290724,
-0.0139820455,
-0.0264147185,
-0.0360496305,
-0.0104718423,
-0.0093107717,
-0.0083201341,
-0.0625869557,
-0.0160898827,
-0.0087334672,
0.0778298602,
-0.0015560342,
0.0606593303,
0.016604688,
0.0488999896,
-0.0248178337,
-0.003374191,
0.0300919563,
0.0206016656,
-0.0140961641,
0.0046372223,
-0.0128324442,
0.0442775004,
-0.0295706932,
-0.0600425974,
0.0089695873,
0.0032104691,
2.538e-7,
0.0882304758,
0.0622895695,
-0.0068614557,
0.053633865,
0.0073324395,
-0.0034817704,
0.0055834907,
0.0138365328,
0.0378951766,
0.0023133834,
-0.0195977408,
0.025399873,
0.0105129201,
0.0413437374,
-0.1032813117,
-0.001447512,
-0.1090783328,
-0.0434412658,
-0.0597502962,
0.0026234898,
0.0525400154,
0.0848195702,
-0.0244993269,
0.0218067225,
-0.0620897897,
-0.0599502288,
0.0554890297,
0.0023103624,
-0.0162326153,
0.0542850383,
0.0125325974,
0.0372394994,
0.027453104,
-0.008750503,
-0.0113149043,
0.0239519216,
0.019816814,
0.017154647,
0.0090943864,
-0.0380988643,
0.0063493494,
-0.026951611,
0.0437117219,
-0.0461786352,
0.0745249093,
-0.057436619,
-0.0245169457,
-0.006079786,
-0.0806333348,
0.0200888999,
-0.0037897518,
0.0051152534,
-0.014901082,
0.0308676101,
-0.0009617815,
-0.0200271364,
-0.0006569406,
-0.0559398979,
0.0179340318,
0.0070480471,
-0.0266283546,
-0.0171569418,
-0.020511983,
-0.0559752397,
-0.0190793034,
-0.0226165745,
0.0237001479,
2.205441149e-34,
0.055011455,
-0.0074412837,
-0.0396447144,
0.0856187344,
0.051615648,
-0.0211738851,
-0.0161505751,
0.0085472148,
0.0047793742,
-0.072773248,
0.0236700475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12537v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12537v2 | Product Attribute Value Extraction using Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T07:39:00 | 2024-01-26T09:07:59 | Alexander Brinkmann, Roee Shraga, Christian Bizer | cs.CL | cs.CL | E-commerce platforms rely on structured product descriptions, in the form of
attribute/value pairs to enable features such as faceted product search and
product comparison. However, vendors on these platforms often provide
unstructured product descriptions consisting of a title and a textual
description. To process such offers, e-commerce platforms must extract
attribute/value pairs from the unstructured descriptions. State-of-the-art
attribute/value extraction methods based on pre-trained language models (PLMs),
such as BERT, face two drawbacks (i) the methods require significant amounts of
task-specific training data and (ii) the fine-tuned models have problems to
generalize to attribute values that were not part of the training data. We
explore the potential of using large language models (LLMs) as a more training
data-efficient and more robust alternative to existing attribute/value
extraction methods. We propose different prompt templates for instructing LLMs
about the target schema of the extraction, covering both zero-shot and few-shot
scenarios. In the zero-shot scenario, textual and JSON-based approaches for
representing information about the target attributes are compared. In the
scenario with training data, we investigate (i) the provision of example
attribute values, (ii) the selection of in-context demonstrations, (iii)
shuffled ensembling to prevent position bias, and (iv) fine-tuning the LLM. The
prompt templates are evaluated in combination with hosted LLMs, such as GPT-3.5
and GPT-4, and open-source LLMs based on Llama2 which can be run locally. The
best average F1-score of 86% was reached by GPT-4 using an ensemble of shuffled
prompts that combine attribute names, attribute descriptions, example values,
and demonstrations. Given the same amount of training data, this prompt/model
combination outperforms the best PLM baseline by an average of 6% F1. | [
0.0317744426,
0.0274919011,
-0.0043150312,
0.0387573689,
-0.0276591145,
-0.0006541959,
0.0211387817,
-0.010613787,
-0.0404314548,
-0.1066018939,
-0.0405338369,
-0.0229933783,
-0.0119755669,
0.0535004511,
-0.0178820211,
-0.0507376678,
0.0050379825,
-0.0167262945,
0.0256827921,
0.0176464468,
0.0087055545,
0.007486253,
-0.008066765,
0.0049981652,
0.02823033,
-0.0348931439,
-0.0284365956,
-0.0167753398,
0.0286673158,
-0.0531699471,
0.0157364774,
0.0285174511,
0.0029020959,
-0.0208202284,
0.000002147,
-0.0647067651,
-0.0184432846,
0.0143833896,
-0.0779907778,
0.0311284568,
0.0682184175,
0.0682715029,
0.0226821862,
0.0151809379,
-0.0310794897,
-0.0635468289,
0.0400068201,
0.0800018683,
0.0295949876,
0.0495613329,
-0.0306564327,
-0.0506088957,
0.0035392127,
-0.0082143452,
0.0337601602,
-0.0223716032,
0.0432553589,
-0.0640531629,
0.0413661376,
0.0589289777,
0.02792692,
0.0130532645,
-0.0149478819,
0.0349942446,
-0.0086211795,
0.0640647486,
-0.0644298568,
0.0111003201,
-0.0379209481,
0.0852638632,
-0.0123791024,
0.0395458676,
-0.0071973982,
-0.0307573117,
0.0105842957,
-0.0236165896,
-0.0247434974,
0.0358099826,
-0.0075966665,
-0.0099301841,
-0.0388246812,
0.0187747404,
-0.0008532338,
0.019678941,
-0.022876462,
0.0699838474,
0.0089400299,
-0.0487256832,
-0.0036298449,
-0.011069919,
-0.0542348027,
-0.0526678413,
-0.0123952739,
0.0067522484,
0.031866841,
0.0268121846,
-0.0113267936,
-0.0373114347,
0.0100874985,
-0.0321264863,
0.0532065257,
-0.0215476621,
-0.0674582049,
0.0605427884,
-0.0482708104,
0.0599311069,
0.0351311043,
-0.0002968279,
-0.0549362563,
0.0323291123,
-0.0447671562,
-0.0334719457,
-0.0262563396,
0.056538038,
-0.0346768126,
-0.0160470083,
-0.0026597474,
-0.0172643512,
-0.0074877292,
0.029065745,
-0.0224068929,
-0.0131795509,
0.0071301772,
-0.0132578136,
-0.0381813645,
0.0019957013,
-0.0079119718,
0.005486357,
0.0005277396,
-0.0526848696,
0.015510764,
0.008746204,
0.0416769087,
-0.0568819493,
0.0445121825,
0.0407061018,
0.0296670794,
-0.0600495897,
-0.0240593981,
-0.0259788278,
-0.002948062,
-0.0193449073,
0.0058416054,
-0.0514370427,
0.0470502228,
0.0091449609,
-0.0135204447,
-0.0223308709,
0.0160324555,
0.0139021296,
-0.0116581377,
0.0939082876,
-0.0019786051,
-0.0030554866,
0.0109503688,
-0.027868066,
0.0261397939,
0.0138873914,
-0.0035701552,
0.0937060118,
0.0360524505,
-0.0042470968,
0.0178249776,
0.0405400805,
-0.0384733193,
-0.0390134156,
-0.0420030095,
0.0418540053,
0.0442853272,
0.0077006309,
0.0213469807,
0.0301003009,
-0.0334301367,
0.0282652024,
0.111164391,
0.0550457314,
-0.0064402008,
-0.0227221772,
0.0113152526,
0.0507088639,
0.035268981,
-0.0691985562,
0.0062319585,
-0.0130298994,
-0.0267818179,
0.0260284282,
-0.0077889855,
0.0187583938,
-0.0141736278,
-0.0338642485,
-0.0185657144,
-0.0486984588,
0.0212987661,
0.0563457347,
0.034767203,
-0.0314738601,
-0.0482209176,
0.0386786647,
0.0210202206,
-0.0328930244,
-0.008018964,
-0.0162917208,
0.0160969775,
0.115637213,
0.0370702296,
-0.0251155999,
-0.0431128591,
-0.0107748555,
-0.0016273096,
0.0231964048,
0.0131802242,
-0.0413416103,
-0.0083860802,
-0.0373538695,
-0.0380249023,
-0.0672461316,
-0.0053972118,
0.0139625072,
-0.0093298536,
0.0063463408,
0.0225584563,
-0.0163373463,
-0.0163225289,
0.0197838172,
0.027783148,
-0.0670450702,
0.033625301,
0.0126705617,
-0.0072142682,
0.0242173336,
-0.0102591058,
0.0029777929,
0.0186787527,
-0.0344497785,
-0.0109523889,
0.0059371153,
0.0050211269,
-0.016562108,
0.0326775201,
0.0226053353,
-0.0025746976,
-0.0348629244,
-0.0224074163,
-0.0256578531,
-0.0658101887,
-0.0166082345,
0.0188906174,
-0.0142063722,
0.0276155546,
-0.0231309999,
0.0150148505,
-0.0468500406,
0.0665287897,
0.0498795398,
-0.0076921238,
-0.0246992391,
-0.0150037045,
-0.0141608985,
-0.0471445918,
-0.0183883682,
0.0516588986,
0.0243263431,
0.0184113979,
-0.0073072868,
0.0142486896,
-0.0007905041,
0.0090734763,
-0.0846994296,
0.0154029643,
0.0226567294,
0.0489674509,
-0.0183782633,
0.0204402003,
-0.0292801727,
0.0046872701,
-0.0465763509,
-0.0369336866,
-0.0663191676,
0.0060977731,
0.0492486432,
0.0377549864,
-0.0146993175,
0.0104929591,
0.0189734548,
0.0059042904,
0.0582993627,
0.02531147,
0.0068218564,
-0.0640932545,
-0.0015600414,
-0.0069750389,
0.0143501926,
0.0351297557,
0.0119170025,
-0.0553284734,
-0.0153402109,
0.0269057415,
0.0639088973,
0.0114928344,
-0.0109160906,
0.034371309,
-0.0102490662,
-0.0655030608,
-0.0028454321,
-0.0202253666,
0.0153934788,
0.0063180677,
-0.0035849439,
0.0491871387,
0.0578164794,
-0.0346496776,
0.0193378627,
-0.0283231437,
-0.0062123113,
-0.0090238415,
0.0015241456,
-0.0503948219,
0.0052205417,
-0.0234965514,
0.046760682,
-0.0109443273,
-0.0296000745,
0.0723719075,
-0.048550643,
-0.0012636917,
-0.0549057461,
0.0065428205,
-0.0511785485,
0.0540753007,
-0.0122281751,
0.0266561583,
0.0144424904,
-0.0537232459,
0.0175415073,
0.0224520359,
0.0268078987,
-0.0440197513,
0.0343311429,
-0.025996957,
0.0223165993,
-0.0464002006,
-0.0539107583,
-0.0215539243,
-0.0719784647,
0.0035189246,
0.0101787727,
-0.0109064961,
0.0030402669,
-0.0558190569,
0.0315897651,
0.0144555504,
0.0504184291,
-0.0031298036,
-0.0034316878,
0.007510771,
0.0081045702,
0.0691891536,
-0.0388476215,
-0.0379172154,
-0.0351981446,
0.011064237,
0.0159680694,
0.0111532062,
-0.0112109948,
-0.0150197018,
-0.0036682012,
0.0250748675,
-0.068018578,
0.0120809833,
0.033206623,
-0.0258571953,
-0.0373745188,
0.0288847238,
0.1080950424,
0.0158738643,
-0.0420694612,
-0.0001598702,
0.0445881635,
-0.0416684598,
-0.0062262774,
0.0375161916,
-0.0994436443,
-0.0133048212,
-0.0059950324,
0.0338739976,
0.019146936,
0.0086979456,
-0.0108033381,
-0.1784225702,
0.0271748137,
-0.0131408647,
-0.0008194268,
-0.0497306623,
-0.0167684723,
-0.0102239326,
-0.0233811364,
0.0706151724,
0.0062358412,
-0.0622237474,
0.0080148391,
0.019191578,
0.0074583506,
-0.0767996162,
0.0603506379,
-0.0209072884,
-0.0119896904,
0.0802373961,
-0.0158033334,
-0.0467768274,
-0.0277919378,
-0.0077924225,
0.0041223937,
-0.0273958631,
0.0123858778,
0.0221029483,
-0.0414288603,
-0.0105591696,
0.0385981016,
0.0120644569,
0.0186677985,
-0.0114045069,
0.0205104202,
0.0463208482,
0.0179737806,
-0.0052919844,
0.0068135187,
-0.0847586766,
-0.0204271805,
0.0699399039,
-0.0002389767,
-0.0858081281,
-0.0309968349,
-0.0192649383,
-0.032671839,
0.0097404402,
-0.0165275205,
0.0440280624,
-0.025344139,
-0.0175481159,
-0.0713972375,
-0.04226055,
0.0466431975,
0.0167058278,
0.0445675626,
0.0062477291,
0.0017164648,
0.0422456264,
-0.0685323775,
0.0403357334,
-0.0128851365,
0.0481069051,
-0.0451898053,
0.024703268,
0.0471906997,
-0.083964318,
-0.030714659,
-0.0399048813,
-0.0046744267,
-0.0467438586,
-0.0246453267,
0.0286219157,
0.0128219072,
0.0533355363,
-0.0123598138,
-0.0632626861,
0.0062596416,
0.0727643669,
-0.029002253,
-0.0403947122,
0.0269110221,
0.0605734326,
-0.0019056331,
0.004196492,
-0.0391805805,
0.0425802171,
0.0096558519,
0.0324187838,
0.0550847948,
-0.0409361906,
0.0469175614,
0.0573291294,
0.0367150567,
0.0096774232,
0.0125976484,
-0.0286742225,
0.0407561809,
-0.0026750981,
-0.041011069,
-0.0283441618,
0.0028061089,
0.0001914626,
-0.004399444,
0.0010219452,
0.021664083,
0.0085414667,
0.0330897458,
-0.0583191551,
0.0341535583,
-0.0394349135,
0.0084420443,
0.0195632912,
-0.0309628397,
-0.0170693733,
-0.0147919459,
0.009474542,
0.0258909911,
-0.0319972411,
0.0355490893,
0.0234358422,
-0.0251150448,
-0.0429483093,
0.0640305504,
0.0423733741,
-0.008504427,
-0.0636458695,
0.0146051589,
-0.0043052225,
-0.0276619531,
0.0231161602,
-0.0384322815,
-0.0129347332,
-0.0323027931,
0.006078958,
0.0005090105,
-0.014707963,
0.0414169915,
0.0391188189,
-0.0372639224,
-0.0468410589,
0.0726259798,
0.027734654,
0.0571568199,
-0.004829003,
-0.0196014587,
-0.0554094762,
0.0034357661,
0.0332737081,
-0.0149018662,
-0.055896502,
-0.015348603,
-0.0460849032,
-0.0235648248,
-0.0047466853,
-0.0156043852,
0.0340745673,
0.0098977564,
0.0490753427,
0.0778875723,
0.0186147373,
0.0066498891,
-0.0180575214,
0.0023873623,
0.0090693366,
0.0098231938,
-0.0262567122,
-6.094978984e-33,
0.0081469165,
-0.0198564753,
-0.0090164393,
0.026055567,
0.003517221,
0.0063680671,
0.0008558657,
-0.0205729268,
0.0127815111,
0.0146771912,
0.0217995476,
-0.0487964302,
0.02545394,
0.0343380719,
0.0391020142,
-0.0282244384,
0.0257316064,
0.0162919275,
-0.0333738588,
0.028143011,
-0.0036988945,
0.0381472185,
0.083875306,
-0.0426960588,
0.0239320565,
-0.0182840824,
-0.0073991604,
0.011249084,
0.0408765636,
0.060770236,
-0.015286454,
0.0338261686,
0.0108325621,
-0.0549655147,
0.0061209071,
0.0059517403,
-0.0702169836,
0.014679281,
0.0191179775,
0.0179241952,
0.012545865,
-0.0093962159,
0.0095907776,
-0.0224409513,
-0.0132694766,
0.0547405444,
0.0519391038,
-0.0513288267,
-0.0213469584,
-0.0619634502,
-0.0494780429,
0.0199222546,
0.0160786491,
-0.0084278565,
0.1018181518,
0.0260244645,
0.0092663877,
0.0189849753,
-0.009551785,
0.0360677987,
0.0297536682,
-0.0081823524,
0.0531374626,
0.0325134993,
0.0216661114,
0.0627279282,
0.0034893025,
0.0100317113,
0.0168890655,
0.0451869182,
-0.0145483324,
0.086629428,
-0.0075024301,
0.0177701637,
0.0473726802,
0.0290824734,
-0.0062432336,
0.0365336984,
0.035015922,
-0.0079820389,
0.0075869593,
0.0036933848,
-0.0521755591,
-0.0229920987,
-0.0011076878,
0.026070293,
-0.0645012856,
-0.0259999055,
0.0416685864,
0.0121243205,
-0.0624332279,
0.0553188883,
0.0067441603,
0.0024542182,
-0.0725086778,
-0.0186129659,
-0.0036049015,
0.0358378775,
-0.0195221864,
-0.0421001762,
-0.0291865189,
-0.0546177737,
0.0030534267,
-0.023026567,
-0.0001011541,
0.0123120341,
0.0362620763,
0.0097553739,
-0.0485556982,
0.0153493825,
0.0018028741,
-0.0255383868,
-0.0293559525,
0.0181635134,
0.0559681952,
0.018411044,
-0.0265361369,
0.0602495931,
0.0269196723,
-0.0298274346,
-0.0603584908,
-0.0339611657,
0.0337711796,
0.0019707661,
0.0096191317,
0.021811692,
-0.0033007627,
-0.0354140289,
0.0085054617,
-0.0355698541,
0.0017840451,
0.0203562528,
2.927e-7,
0.0175396018,
0.0691068918,
-0.0183679871,
0.0115071796,
0.002308365,
0.0563000478,
0.0058719264,
0.025981186,
-0.0042623975,
-0.0178862084,
0.0204438213,
-0.0042754319,
0.040186882,
0.0221092328,
-0.0919235349,
-0.0032145686,
-0.0397296399,
-0.0111029055,
-0.1002318189,
0.0013918573,
0.0727441311,
0.0691081509,
-0.0040207603,
0.0049026026,
0.0112227714,
-0.0061392984,
0.054073669,
-0.0300358143,
0.0127459615,
0.0154187903,
-0.0039169546,
0.0188998897,
-0.0437074751,
-0.0053355438,
-0.0101854969,
0.0251450539,
0.0437056571,
0.0630616248,
0.0152723426,
-0.0014996487,
-0.0128920348,
-0.0557567999,
-0.006881794,
-0.04737949,
0.0707663819,
-0.0565958992,
-0.0368293487,
-0.0258071031,
-0.0607634187,
-0.0196432434,
-0.0280949026,
-0.0341242589,
0.0095475288,
0.0227424167,
0.0004606823,
-0.0484950058,
-0.0303347968,
-0.0584381409,
-0.0211606752,
0.006339008,
-0.019566346,
-0.029565718,
-0.0114210267,
0.0355770662,
0.0060306913,
-0.065071471,
0.013912796,
2.864709809e-34,
0.0267361645,
-0.0091591896,
-0.0088010281,
0.0657792464,
0.0074280608,
0.013969061,
0.0328982249,
-0.0181416459,
-0.0166194476,
-0.0772590786,
-0.0146064311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12531v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12531v3 | ICU: Conquering Language Barriers in Vision-and-Language Modeling by Dividing the Tasks into Image Captioning and Language Understanding | 2023-10-19T07:11:48 | 2024-02-05T10:28:43 | Guojun Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most multilingual vision-and-language (V&L) research aims to accomplish
multilingual and multimodal capabilities within one model. However, the
scarcity of multilingual captions for images has hindered the development. To
overcome this obstacle, we propose ICU, Image Caption Understanding, which
divides a V&L task into two stages: a V&L model performs image captioning in
English, and a multilingual language model (mLM), in turn, takes the caption as
the alt text and performs cross-lingual language understanding. The burden of
multilingual processing is lifted off V&L model and placed on mLM. Since the
multilingual text data is relatively of higher abundance and quality, ICU can
facilitate the conquering of language barriers for V&L models. In experiments
on two tasks across 9 languages in the IGLUE benchmark, we show that ICU can
achieve new state-of-the-art results for five languages, and comparable results
for the rest. | [
0.032451123,
0.0572159104,
0.0111893835,
0.0980444923,
-0.0235421285,
0.0336267427,
0.0314827748,
-0.0222374965,
0.0235088021,
-0.0668401942,
-0.0561701283,
-0.0660012886,
0.0145537499,
0.0328508914,
0.0205190219,
-0.0963263512,
0.0219809506,
-0.0643600225,
-0.0287884306,
-0.0171259996,
0.0261918139,
0.0251537897,
0.0207495708,
0.02103002,
0.0019442018,
-0.0141617097,
0.0240668412,
0.0253188629,
-0.0112327291,
-0.0261504743,
-0.0512518883,
0.0524203293,
0.0375089124,
0.0379133746,
0.0000018734,
-0.0104205217,
0.0272328742,
-0.000049643,
0.0262436736,
-0.0444109291,
0.0616612583,
-0.104330264,
-0.0081884218,
-0.0257536769,
-0.0274433214,
-0.0011520946,
0.0671473593,
0.0347883105,
0.0466119274,
0.0017987587,
-0.0287015773,
-0.0444653071,
-0.0355387628,
-0.0485164523,
-0.020020619,
-0.0200743936,
-0.0052697309,
0.051101476,
-0.0068850932,
-0.0051685655,
-0.0529275015,
0.0945806578,
0.0134283584,
-0.0197065547,
-0.0332831033,
0.0413631499,
-0.0018731891,
-0.0687173381,
-0.0344375968,
0.0746247768,
-0.0236871131,
-0.0028736752,
-0.0556115136,
0.0203641113,
-0.0012337577,
-0.0296489894,
-0.0530002229,
0.0426296368,
-0.0014701198,
0.011965828,
-0.0085235843,
0.0082431184,
0.0284127109,
0.0000992498,
-0.0012704964,
-0.0127742877,
0.0151089374,
0.0394211896,
-0.0100110676,
0.0202868618,
-0.0372328237,
-0.0449021384,
0.0190251023,
0.0001659957,
-0.0100427745,
0.0116179185,
-0.0446632989,
-0.044500757,
0.0019905276,
-0.0535929278,
0.0174210072,
0.0060308166,
-0.0616920218,
0.0936247483,
-0.0259949341,
0.064370349,
-0.0123466561,
0.0307397377,
-0.052569624,
-0.0519734025,
-0.0106634172,
-0.0071021793,
-0.0112611083,
-0.0156901702,
-0.0684726313,
-0.0361554176,
-0.0135698952,
0.0052760127,
-0.0063912822,
0.0093283746,
-0.0237788633,
-0.0255974308,
-0.028396707,
-0.0115432581,
-0.0089119282,
0.0341661796,
0.0020546622,
-0.0076902946,
-0.0582706444,
-0.0562084317,
0.0080669457,
0.0597994998,
0.0030944115,
-0.024343133,
0.0002757874,
0.0788739845,
-0.059901759,
-0.0183756743,
-0.0007539754,
-0.0051460457,
-0.0290270094,
-0.0613695234,
0.0084401323,
-0.0707084388,
0.047389742,
0.0055129528,
0.026519917,
-0.0369218849,
0.0106119178,
-0.010291189,
-0.0279220045,
0.1292966306,
-0.0220346991,
-0.0106344009,
0.0168500319,
0.0128331063,
0.0026674606,
0.0926243886,
-0.0029868323,
-0.0021279664,
0.0440308638,
0.0145045416,
0.0147259291,
0.0670888498,
-0.005733931,
0.0149527518,
-0.0370365679,
-0.0111500202,
0.0104947956,
-0.0033343988,
0.0531677566,
0.0474228114,
-0.0010473932,
0.00034048,
0.0603750572,
0.0418911017,
-0.0213649236,
0.0334157422,
0.037104696,
0.0046315705,
-0.0097681656,
0.0094202207,
-0.053112343,
0.0669984296,
0.0203448087,
0.0057318774,
-0.0211686231,
0.046780929,
-0.0460045524,
-0.0298638884,
0.001315073,
-0.0217896625,
0.0212736856,
0.0077643045,
0.0523037203,
0.0155483969,
-0.0170684606,
0.0307746083,
0.0046542203,
-0.0192378126,
0.0120670749,
-0.0207149405,
-0.0248449259,
0.0589868017,
0.0228555202,
0.0180089474,
-0.0322135054,
-0.008748767,
0.037708886,
0.0828489587,
0.0257662423,
0.0122060077,
0.0357019641,
-0.043078538,
-0.0265518837,
-0.0033417048,
-0.015641354,
0.0423676409,
-0.0364305638,
0.0079669077,
0.0183018781,
-0.0063309059,
-0.0669705346,
0.0301524904,
0.0144708091,
0.0135503439,
-0.0393862464,
0.0230093468,
-0.0259475783,
0.0086398507,
-0.0006065752,
-0.0100042149,
-0.0207707137,
-0.0492348447,
-0.0054084091,
0.0853227451,
-0.0354224704,
-0.0468985885,
0.0340331718,
-0.069482781,
-0.0167289618,
-0.0103706773,
-0.0131843714,
-0.0401272997,
0.0154832592,
-0.0233075935,
-0.0138492454,
-0.061353188,
-0.0032147942,
-0.0093578091,
0.0388751999,
-0.0048734271,
0.0340769999,
-0.0101743313,
-0.0014100538,
0.0319315679,
-0.0233825874,
0.0172804762,
-0.018557772,
-0.0593693517,
0.0423322171,
0.008772511,
0.0219085868,
0.0207020063,
0.0460583866,
-0.015783282,
0.0032427153,
-0.083596237,
-0.0443388037,
-0.0418892428,
0.0116304401,
-0.0023488402,
-0.0014104799,
0.0038618855,
-0.0746801421,
-0.0274057742,
-0.0070701437,
0.022672927,
0.017267745,
0.0385358557,
0.0327795595,
0.0090928534,
-0.020528296,
0.0120211234,
0.03732384,
0.0694420263,
0.0276312102,
-0.068938151,
-0.0473039933,
-0.014828044,
-0.0288984608,
0.0253340788,
-0.01020189,
-0.0142758675,
-0.0076878015,
0.0052534975,
0.0297731776,
0.0221300144,
-0.0286039282,
0.0103886547,
0.0275726542,
-0.0220217556,
-0.026381569,
0.0178275909,
0.0318026468,
-0.0477144606,
-0.0155228414,
-0.0350788012,
-0.0234098136,
0.078881681,
-0.0449466221,
0.0159172881,
-0.0616602041,
0.0105135459,
-0.0400178283,
-0.0483542308,
-0.0736371279,
0.0407058932,
0.02516222,
0.0249149427,
-0.0474410541,
-0.0440166779,
0.0422546454,
-0.0681810752,
-0.0491150431,
-0.0254981872,
0.0031385096,
-0.0343501978,
0.0898386687,
0.0113516757,
0.0442263708,
-0.0439121909,
-0.0160823204,
-0.0042102057,
-0.0005044129,
-0.0012647455,
-0.0024215537,
0.0791882798,
-0.0796396807,
0.0026563907,
-0.0506310947,
-0.0237058662,
-0.0063193659,
-0.0159199294,
-0.0473660193,
-0.0134991882,
-0.0139704421,
0.006553622,
-0.0164095163,
0.0538019165,
0.0554883033,
0.0279469006,
0.0126534496,
0.0053403843,
-0.0051240604,
0.0054227845,
0.043634776,
0.0390187725,
-0.0398696065,
-0.0273474697,
0.0465695336,
0.0109577542,
0.0202538911,
-0.0216950048,
-0.0295809172,
0.0255341697,
0.0449403636,
0.0559969954,
-0.0465512313,
-0.0177122802,
0.0503660105,
-0.0463941619,
0.0015395752,
0.0563872382,
0.0075937263,
-0.0797914043,
-0.0456620269,
-0.0117945876,
0.0340476297,
0.0483436994,
0.0142009007,
-0.0780967176,
-0.0489846095,
-0.02068769,
-0.0358465873,
0.0424995422,
0.0250293668,
-0.0476106741,
-0.0628327876,
0.0279422272,
0.0136762802,
-0.0595611185,
-0.0748681128,
0.0160493497,
-0.0241217278,
0.0120411962,
0.0012919619,
-0.0377568156,
0.017277766,
-0.0110427169,
0.0095174061,
0.0355030075,
-0.0469494499,
0.0019520975,
-0.0421765894,
-0.0060398141,
0.0461942106,
0.0324228629,
-0.0042435676,
-0.0161241964,
0.0146454656,
0.0098738233,
0.0021800587,
-0.0186957773,
0.0443867072,
0.0088435337,
-0.0537480973,
0.0257819444,
0.0052645057,
-0.0324597657,
-0.0063879765,
-0.0200960208,
0.0193715673,
0.0006257117,
0.0040490101,
-0.0048431857,
0.0011697244,
-0.0004878399,
0.0516462959,
0.0291087236,
-0.0461211093,
-0.0140014291,
-0.0386805944,
-0.0214172062,
-0.0828912184,
0.0007454613,
0.027396163,
0.001723647,
-0.0234086551,
-0.0428380258,
-0.0528425612,
0.0126043754,
0.0121719735,
0.026897179,
0.0140381102,
-0.0166271403,
0.0090512512,
-0.0287797172,
0.0450204834,
-0.0516320691,
0.0134178642,
-0.0271448065,
0.0060130944,
0.0454766527,
-0.043499656,
-0.0136072114,
0.0454416126,
-0.0535924211,
-0.0158168711,
-0.0403539464,
0.0489266068,
0.0125516644,
0.0571212918,
0.0044117682,
-0.0439606756,
-0.0236404333,
0.0166197233,
0.0576420128,
0.0130915521,
0.0248023719,
0.0027868494,
-0.0172594395,
0.0609351993,
-0.0292614494,
0.0231840108,
0.0125797438,
0.019934563,
-0.0225278772,
-0.0442428067,
-0.0081341108,
0.0103767645,
-0.0058535556,
-0.0476224683,
0.0193579532,
-0.0356734619,
0.0126926387,
-0.0057253903,
-0.0174101423,
-0.0638663918,
0.0077676298,
0.0251954123,
-0.0008571156,
0.0042034024,
-0.0072761583,
0.0197365843,
-0.0230388418,
0.0042937598,
0.0299813468,
0.0351206921,
-0.0199283846,
0.0017747064,
0.0341009423,
-0.0073276442,
0.025628712,
-0.006658467,
0.0268290229,
-0.0285359994,
0.0520937182,
0.0181125402,
-0.0381783955,
-0.0128698712,
0.0501444563,
0.0372355357,
-0.0072621461,
-0.0143293189,
0.0369712412,
0.0859767571,
0.0055225613,
0.0589007512,
-0.0136814108,
-0.0067621614,
0.0007431817,
0.0521868169,
0.0124443034,
-0.0614706837,
0.0682211071,
-0.0134550538,
-0.0059983758,
0.0036445807,
0.0764864534,
-0.0007639042,
0.0008906585,
0.0079261092,
-0.0001928583,
-0.0377840661,
-0.0145262433,
-0.0031410388,
-0.027548207,
-0.0329149812,
0.0524793193,
-0.0240845215,
-0.0635452047,
0.0035237973,
0.0026238982,
-0.0104265166,
0.0332749188,
0.0341752283,
0.0680097938,
0.0411246717,
0.0216126051,
-0.0258647371,
-0.0223545562,
-0.0044693304,
0.0300822072,
-0.0001206602,
-5.548870023e-33,
-0.0486590788,
-0.0112692351,
0.0135331377,
-0.009609431,
0.0172765534,
0.0137972916,
-0.0515624173,
0.0249404572,
-0.0207923129,
0.0133442087,
0.0357435457,
-0.0215608887,
0.0218795128,
0.0486925952,
0.0225010924,
-0.0099227624,
0.0297817942,
0.0105410954,
0.0155784218,
-0.0024127339,
0.0126919998,
0.0185973532,
0.0725765824,
-0.0302892607,
0.0329344235,
0.0002558416,
-0.0030039051,
0.0252982918,
0.0441579185,
0.0553023741,
-0.0484168455,
0.0364519879,
0.031816531,
-0.0144815268,
-0.0418836474,
0.012135148,
-0.0646535829,
0.000184596,
0.0389456935,
0.0715573803,
-0.0521979555,
-0.0075651063,
0.033563219,
-0.0330438763,
0.0046541197,
-0.0096957833,
0.0414632596,
-0.0305539295,
0.0194639638,
0.0198227186,
-0.0573473535,
0.0190983955,
-0.0006182245,
-0.0126327593,
0.104968138,
0.0557835586,
0.0142616965,
0.036881566,
-0.0443416759,
0.0033363861,
-0.0311758574,
0.0198258124,
0.1300538033,
0.043085292,
-0.022944985,
0.0368920602,
0.0024842781,
-0.0104626175,
-0.0024708407,
0.0140491743,
0.0453868136,
0.0176323,
0.0492009223,
0.0709058195,
-0.001114322,
0.0284987167,
-0.0156985484,
0.0080820732,
-0.0573588833,
0.0212974083,
0.0136763994,
0.0176958889,
0.0097168293,
0.0121570872,
-0.0579513535,
-0.036944896,
-0.0499511696,
-0.0074035125,
0.0384731367,
-0.007525743,
-0.0132790357,
0.0455273651,
0.0875363722,
-0.0181641243,
-0.0348890759,
-0.017749887,
0.0119903777,
0.0493973419,
-0.0085220635,
0.0331723206,
-0.0371313915,
-0.0498294458,
0.0193955433,
0.0221264586,
0.0109761031,
0.0069044968,
0.058749903,
0.0021163314,
-0.0329321474,
-0.0071675507,
-0.0526553988,
0.0019262115,
-0.0222794916,
0.0561070219,
0.0268186778,
-0.0057021603,
-0.0755738243,
0.0172792953,
-0.003009028,
-0.0363331921,
-0.0189326946,
-0.038277097,
-0.0255045425,
0.041537147,
-0.0375868827,
0.0207771678,
-0.0425034165,
-0.0376507975,
0.0122690797,
-0.0474511944,
-0.0177113973,
0.05071133,
2.379e-7,
0.0468396284,
0.0196051858,
0.0218334347,
0.0041126111,
0.0320932381,
0.0451687351,
-0.0568034314,
0.0012829868,
-0.0282272305,
-0.0136019066,
-0.0056110658,
0.0293490216,
0.0598219186,
-0.0144622792,
-0.0345477201,
0.0296866726,
-0.0171590224,
0.0283521395,
-0.0296612456,
-0.0177788381,
0.0282650236,
0.094965823,
-0.055071298,
-0.0125377346,
0.0054204301,
-0.1061202586,
0.0840261206,
-0.0440875441,
-0.0010659375,
-0.0035042828,
0.0122798234,
0.0655596033,
-0.0385460407,
0.0432827137,
-0.0117279533,
-0.022740189,
0.0815241039,
0.0198357143,
-0.0421403833,
0.0094968202,
-0.0090462156,
0.0339221172,
-0.04498671,
-0.0576804392,
0.0467647761,
-0.0287443828,
-0.0046507479,
-0.0305438191,
0.0191358346,
0.0015893421,
0.0318481065,
-0.0441055261,
-0.0411634594,
0.051678136,
0.0637241229,
-0.0324981213,
-0.0502539873,
-0.0442139804,
-0.0445027053,
-0.0077344188,
-0.0170577038,
0.0236221701,
-0.0823473409,
-0.0116190612,
0.0192922298,
-0.0138441883,
-0.0131192002,
1.54360121e-34,
0.0279579703,
-0.0128369732,
0.001881131,
0.0367752016,
0.0136093888,
-0.0358821936,
-0.0392329656,
0.0182842053,
-0.0299238712,
-0.0358397663,
0.0022645881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12522v1 | Named Entity Recognition for Monitoring Plant Health Threats in Tweets: a ChouBERT Approach | 2023-10-19T06:54:55 | 2023-10-19T06:54:55 | Shufan Jiang, Rafael Angarita, Stéphane Cormier, Francis Rousseaux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | An important application scenario of precision agriculture is detecting and
measuring crop health threats using sensors and data analysis techniques.
However, the textual data are still under-explored among the existing solutions
due to the lack of labelled data and fine-grained semantic resources. Recent
research suggests that the increasing connectivity of farmers and the emergence
of online farming communities make social media like Twitter a participatory
platform for detecting unfamiliar plant health events if we can extract
essential information from unstructured textual data. ChouBERT is a French
pre-trained language model that can identify Tweets concerning observations of
plant health issues with generalizability on unseen natural hazards. This paper
tackles the lack of labelled data by further studying ChouBERT's know-how on
token-level annotation tasks over small labeled sets. | [
0.0257148556,
0.0523436815,
0.0377788767,
0.0032308176,
-0.0059714168,
0.0327963866,
-0.0230874065,
0.0175948683,
0.0435062721,
-0.0485858768,
0.0626686737,
0.0279190019,
-0.0781777725,
0.037990097,
0.0040934482,
-0.0166152269,
0.053621646,
0.0311715733,
0.0204990841,
0.0219337363,
0.0388917774,
0.0319304317,
0.0114321075,
0.0299069602,
-0.0610997267,
0.0326202773,
0.0084996494,
0.0052346876,
0.0678540319,
-0.0684451088,
-0.0063781389,
0.0116839875,
-0.0185994152,
0.0495084785,
0.0000016374,
-0.0126615493,
-0.0842066854,
-0.0159540921,
-0.0128311506,
-0.0115494318,
0.0118499901,
-0.026636444,
0.0150717832,
0.0061941002,
-0.030555319,
-0.0045671002,
0.065141961,
0.042058561,
0.0328438468,
0.0763296336,
-0.0157514773,
-0.0082702376,
0.0297217369,
0.0057128649,
0.0114773242,
-0.0009460627,
0.0588267483,
-0.0429873131,
0.0145766456,
0.064166829,
-0.0020635005,
0.0513963588,
-0.0015837392,
0.0114550432,
0.0006311876,
0.0502699055,
-0.0766204521,
-0.0118293269,
-0.0063605504,
0.0512073003,
-0.0149142621,
-0.0072693676,
0.0322387069,
-0.0256678294,
-0.0364962593,
-0.008033921,
-0.0259677768,
-0.0253365431,
0.01027105,
0.0254123397,
0.0518716276,
0.0382661894,
0.0033773258,
0.0114918612,
-0.0098268799,
0.0510806888,
-0.0267735999,
-0.0361050665,
0.0064776773,
0.0133060748,
-0.0067664906,
-0.0525958091,
0.0255539268,
0.0363555662,
-0.0113905063,
0.0134749357,
-0.0073028668,
-0.0425326489,
0.0160566363,
-0.0725936815,
-0.069072485,
-0.0031527302,
-0.0257125553,
0.032859765,
0.0313618295,
-0.0435104445,
0.0173582491,
0.0556423329,
0.0481458455,
-0.0191166513,
-0.07276427,
-0.0064464658,
-0.0508883111,
0.0213980023,
-0.0025529803,
0.0242301412,
0.0010682633,
-0.016738344,
0.00138199,
-0.0134038571,
-0.0084797554,
-0.0115875425,
0.0038151955,
0.0054870229,
-0.0179063901,
0.0534583963,
-0.0257744975,
0.0137240468,
-0.0348949805,
-0.0828650221,
-0.0030656187,
-0.0215298086,
0.0635827109,
0.0043138154,
0.0009933618,
0.0691587403,
0.0504118577,
-0.0714654848,
-0.0287036151,
-0.0292213503,
-0.0072940509,
0.0205741972,
-0.0532660522,
-0.0277201869,
0.0263066031,
0.0209950916,
0.036369171,
-0.0246263351,
0.0184666198,
0.0128647871,
-0.0812489539,
0.0647332445,
-0.0634259507,
0.0027349633,
0.0235393792,
0.0137594957,
0.0356477089,
0.0564984344,
0.0105648721,
0.0702692494,
0.0221830737,
0.0126623968,
0.0328011364,
0.0218758434,
0.0173635501,
-0.0120489039,
0.0098053506,
-0.0002818264,
-0.0191942528,
-0.0358705334,
-0.0613686554,
0.0424039215,
0.0177704953,
0.0329912789,
0.0517883934,
0.0602207705,
-0.0328596272,
-0.0387651697,
0.0395595618,
0.0604022592,
-0.020207921,
-0.0539463758,
-0.0203331057,
-0.0116946893,
-0.0790193453,
-0.0112511599,
-0.004427908,
-0.0154419402,
-0.0173731837,
-0.0234210342,
-0.0334227048,
0.0109923966,
-0.0095902123,
-0.0269628055,
0.0526486337,
-0.0225124452,
0.0138253272,
0.0051626679,
0.0469914228,
-0.0384240039,
0.0275538489,
0.0124222813,
0.0181826502,
0.0260733292,
0.0003561419,
-0.0718765855,
0.0067392355,
0.0005142447,
0.0338685103,
0.0246920493,
0.000835617,
-0.0413146093,
-0.0115479827,
0.0363021791,
-0.0051147332,
0.0242599398,
-0.0017324171,
-0.0377693921,
-0.0162864514,
0.0595687591,
-0.0238297898,
-0.0280020759,
-0.0476232134,
0.0514431782,
0.0242709108,
-0.0408632234,
-0.0355737843,
0.0181874633,
-0.025575649,
0.0719783902,
0.0178816132,
0.0039784336,
0.0356049836,
-0.0328757428,
-0.0409669913,
0.0313228592,
0.0323675014,
0.0273190644,
0.0113486145,
-0.027693972,
-0.0497411601,
-0.0047402699,
-0.0593360178,
-0.0272045601,
0.0120843751,
0.0144298347,
0.018875638,
-0.0295640603,
0.0025619268,
-0.0005787413,
-0.0061517661,
-0.0304943901,
0.0333880708,
-0.0267644431,
-0.0015021281,
-0.051294148,
-0.0784005374,
0.0190511793,
-0.0056657479,
-0.0241212398,
0.0082512833,
-0.0205787532,
-0.0121763721,
0.0272381492,
0.0141402064,
-0.0511717275,
0.0198719725,
-0.0725733191,
-0.0157208797,
-0.0395916402,
0.0400048532,
0.030819647,
0.0426457562,
-0.023401048,
-0.0022673602,
0.0109852795,
0.0614350811,
-0.0177450441,
0.0212986097,
0.0395029224,
0.0060143508,
0.0180415418,
0.0133645274,
0.0191781595,
-0.066507861,
0.0436241217,
0.070329912,
-0.1007013693,
-0.0089735128,
-0.0070191598,
-0.0135308029,
0.0076514953,
0.0380315408,
-0.006930518,
-0.0322443508,
0.0047745723,
-0.0104419347,
-0.0043579163,
-0.0110341618,
0.0781598687,
-0.0197743494,
0.0156315845,
-0.0106082661,
0.0158055052,
-0.0552754365,
-0.0035253237,
-0.0101080136,
-0.0232106298,
0.03808029,
0.0806770176,
-0.0494191498,
-0.0115024699,
-0.0257396083,
0.0406302698,
-0.0330675319,
0.0224148184,
-0.0390296988,
0.0323285684,
0.0400245376,
0.0058902293,
-0.0174356978,
-0.024435183,
0.036536105,
-0.0116837295,
0.038492661,
-0.039887879,
-0.0460532084,
-0.0161899086,
0.0630420074,
0.0420691855,
0.0194627084,
0.0583576523,
-0.0292048063,
0.0356128365,
0.0402408056,
-0.0481774434,
0.0168208182,
-0.0357725024,
0.0042230799,
0.0616874546,
-0.0304117538,
-0.0243522748,
0.0079130242,
-0.0479289964,
-0.095453538,
0.052937828,
0.0073702293,
0.0218805522,
-0.0224079303,
0.051312685,
-0.0154742682,
-0.0107923159,
0.0323602036,
-0.0240091085,
-0.0030733801,
0.0180146024,
-0.0179851018,
-0.0525761582,
-0.0100663174,
0.0029074603,
0.0123736365,
0.0246345829,
0.0015244238,
-0.025579378,
-0.0001104215,
-0.0076263151,
-0.0205553044,
-0.0623490624,
0.0185459126,
-0.0207115393,
0.0650287941,
-0.0064408281,
0.0065459255,
0.1095594019,
0.018269496,
0.0445272177,
0.0296983682,
0.0108566936,
-0.0159765705,
0.0215499792,
-0.0000219286,
-0.050147891,
-0.0176243689,
-0.026719233,
-0.0178334992,
-0.0113097336,
-0.072331883,
-0.0042006848,
-0.0656760335,
0.0009182321,
-0.0368649699,
-0.0502894372,
-0.0040399269,
-0.0383417308,
-0.0175965186,
-0.0854596123,
-0.0362756848,
-0.0563343354,
-0.0142019112,
0.0463194065,
0.0341494344,
-0.0592665747,
-0.0229107589,
-0.0044197338,
-0.0405277684,
0.0334785692,
0.0464988016,
0.0112069789,
-0.0118455254,
-0.0057328315,
0.0465085916,
0.0119411666,
0.0061023994,
-0.02575339,
0.0468578562,
-0.0455855355,
-0.0341141932,
0.0333225317,
-0.0044534109,
-0.0418228395,
-0.0393630974,
0.0027390432,
0.0655077547,
0.010539636,
0.0025375467,
-0.005459948,
-0.0099892402,
0.0634269938,
0.0340727456,
0.0389327556,
-0.0354186222,
-0.0543274246,
-0.0197015312,
-0.0159773398,
-0.0295135155,
-0.0231525488,
0.0008639125,
-0.0408315286,
-0.0974427462,
-0.0362570323,
-0.026493039,
0.096373111,
0.0057229893,
-0.0190908741,
-0.0176076982,
0.0771722123,
-0.0240115244,
-0.0720823482,
0.042578157,
-0.0256855767,
0.002143912,
-0.0323007703,
-0.0260724351,
0.0805756822,
0.038438268,
-0.027644299,
-0.0035118421,
-0.0979016647,
-0.0613420345,
-0.009435528,
-0.0105098924,
0.0167309418,
0.0072368183,
-0.0155507661,
-0.0570064038,
0.0177084319,
0.0610127822,
-0.0683808252,
-0.0261309166,
0.013370268,
0.0085859196,
0.0167272575,
0.0440138504,
-0.0012518582,
0.0535075441,
0.0656145439,
0.0485787503,
-0.0654185787,
0.0534452088,
0.0130484123,
0.0206548944,
0.1035974845,
0.0308004133,
-0.0458332412,
-0.0534956418,
-0.0241615176,
0.0142166205,
-0.0226080958,
0.0002565959,
0.0160728153,
-0.0227161329,
0.0392306298,
-0.0496210158,
0.0299872309,
-0.016065903,
0.0265081711,
-0.0482603908,
-0.0081601469,
0.0120116454,
0.0357962921,
0.002018369,
-0.0089666145,
0.0259646941,
-0.012763015,
0.0287061352,
-0.0248286631,
-0.0012495563,
-0.0322267897,
-0.002137416,
0.0167398155,
0.014551579,
0.0143062202,
-0.0231530163,
-0.0131975124,
-0.051433228,
0.0642658547,
0.002376084,
-0.0308870561,
0.014382151,
-0.0234356243,
-0.0306192059,
-0.0050894823,
0.0131027848,
-0.0076021501,
-0.0477136858,
0.0372394621,
-0.0364637151,
-0.0610364638,
-0.0108183995,
0.0430703536,
0.0069610872,
0.0308024026,
0.054242488,
-0.0191411506,
0.0103662778,
0.0226180647,
0.0138935503,
-0.0075230403,
0.0140030822,
0.049379997,
-0.0247454848,
-0.0277854763,
0.0565230548,
-0.0130068138,
-0.0173647832,
0.0561444499,
-0.0036615906,
-0.0074323094,
0.0200790521,
0.0470946357,
-0.0218333136,
-0.0090962546,
-0.0388425589,
-0.05767956,
0.0061187814,
-6.346232453e-33,
-0.0352491364,
-0.0497678667,
-0.0124185057,
0.0237283148,
0.025515113,
0.0560362488,
0.0137280943,
0.0035250685,
0.0226880908,
0.0218124464,
0.0239363629,
0.0072349007,
0.0122577781,
0.033766102,
0.0190213658,
-0.0368378833,
0.0213268269,
0.0281334482,
-0.0250659641,
0.0210797768,
0.0386958495,
0.0432503335,
0.0674674138,
-0.1210296974,
0.0095906639,
-0.0077163028,
0.0002104135,
-0.0125803342,
0.0526745543,
0.0312034953,
-0.0322281793,
0.0627145842,
0.0465536304,
-0.0416739956,
-0.0213121735,
0.0606988594,
-0.1017177701,
-0.06831301,
-0.0444672294,
-0.0069793793,
-0.0265694018,
-0.0131087834,
-0.0019657721,
0.0004718593,
0.0042018495,
0.0349483378,
0.0266713314,
-0.0153123224,
0.0162631348,
-0.0558399595,
-0.0239192862,
0.0320923664,
-0.026263997,
0.0342078656,
0.0228523593,
-0.0052200747,
0.0567740873,
0.0327956416,
-0.0154737886,
0.0090817865,
0.0265621077,
-0.0257092416,
0.0090724966,
-0.0134768141,
-0.0370558426,
0.0378433689,
0.0021743902,
-0.0346678458,
-0.0119852284,
0.0154123148,
-0.0286328383,
-0.0105922874,
0.0232183542,
0.0235617068,
0.0327612199,
-0.0571844541,
-0.0920234397,
0.0409455635,
-0.0542469509,
-0.0007907808,
-0.0079089673,
-0.0066214651,
0.0090810349,
-0.0129679404,
-0.009274859,
-0.016959561,
-0.0399854332,
0.0335719436,
-0.0108598787,
0.0121250832,
-0.0165272225,
0.0925455987,
-0.0223263949,
-0.0115023963,
-0.0353646614,
-0.0221304633,
0.012599308,
0.0265860092,
-0.0238969885,
0.0378772318,
-0.0769477636,
-0.0529324636,
0.0059493049,
0.050213851,
-0.0009100683,
-0.0041297767,
0.0620298795,
0.0158281028,
-0.0608742908,
-0.0066573005,
0.011394389,
0.0198172331,
-0.030852614,
-0.0105428873,
0.0268362127,
-0.0044889706,
0.0310756452,
0.0587094016,
0.0580927171,
-0.0135013796,
0.030052511,
0.0149592562,
-0.0054686116,
-0.0241986811,
0.0103710685,
0.0043427381,
0.0031854284,
-0.0223685745,
-0.0251066796,
-0.0314735435,
0.0128289647,
-0.0381157473,
2.57e-7,
0.0976220891,
0.0391657613,
0.0200620759,
-0.045651976,
-0.00600809,
-0.0087718051,
0.027216522,
0.0538970605,
-0.0674089417,
-0.0133376997,
0.0346171297,
-0.0347976945,
-0.015307175,
0.0231841188,
-0.0472747833,
-0.0121728694,
-0.0808728859,
-0.0055255271,
-0.0943161398,
0.0439600535,
0.0479658954,
0.0327045098,
0.0031497658,
0.0304502808,
-0.0365378149,
-0.0131400395,
0.050602261,
-0.0436306745,
0.04092554,
0.032718841,
0.0100572426,
0.047040876,
0.0012857941,
0.0374705046,
-0.0165065061,
0.0034126085,
0.0212165024,
0.0089288792,
-0.0193199106,
-0.0001653811,
-0.00069651,
-0.0628081486,
0.0276158955,
-0.023146132,
0.0627553836,
-0.068161808,
-0.0700026229,
0.0279405881,
0.0442633443,
0.0185865145,
0.0234293696,
-0.0208207257,
-0.0153713115,
0.007787426,
0.0058296137,
-0.0124858506,
-0.0148890307,
-0.0931750089,
0.0447948016,
-0.0101657845,
0.014257296,
-0.0466170125,
0.0179354679,
-0.0313510671,
-0.0095789097,
-0.0262503047,
0.0113708479,
1.962522257e-34,
-0.0046669403,
0.0267198347,
-0.0506098978,
0.0064265775,
-0.024692215,
0.0304844212,
0.0164889004,
-0.0156970322,
-0.0207471903,
-0.0243357047,
-0.004912456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13025v1 | Powerset multi-class cross entropy loss for neural speaker diarization | 2023-10-19T06:51:43 | 2023-10-19T06:51:43 | Alexis Plaquet, Hervé Bredin | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE, eess.AS | Since its introduction in 2019, the whole end-to-end neural diarization
(EEND) line of work has been addressing speaker diarization as a frame-wise
multi-label classification problem with permutation-invariant training. Despite
EEND showing great promise, a few recent works took a step back and studied the
possible combination of (local) supervised EEND diarization with (global)
unsupervised clustering. Yet, these hybrid contributions did not question the
original multi-label formulation. We propose to switch from multi-label (where
any two speakers can be active at the same time) to powerset multi-class
classification (where dedicated classes are assigned to pairs of overlapping
speakers). Through extensive experiments on 9 different benchmarks, we show
that this formulation leads to significantly better performance (mostly on
overlapping speech) and robustness to domain mismatch, while eliminating the
detection threshold hyperparameter, critical for the multi-label formulation. | [
-0.05375918,
0.0297726877,
0.0173402131,
0.0359529331,
0.0092278151,
0.0115757091,
0.0488990173,
-0.0110938642,
0.0111291846,
0.0170130599,
-0.0255119819,
-0.0381626114,
0.0135417581,
-0.0577967465,
0.0244975258,
-0.0829127952,
0.0456188805,
0.0199096985,
-0.0206417963,
-0.0095287049,
0.0086942762,
-0.0181965139,
-0.0445115343,
0.0160498749,
-0.055642385,
0.0117904944,
0.0019879411,
0.0135853477,
0.0606928542,
0.0095647294,
0.0293944012,
0.0604633018,
0.0041675125,
0.0468740724,
0.0000019818,
-0.0338894576,
-0.0095448205,
-0.0255593732,
0.0118939662,
0.0328200608,
-0.0121882502,
0.0116643803,
0.020237634,
0.0109087825,
-0.0099657858,
-0.0619034208,
0.0282651279,
0.0506417714,
0.0418981463,
0.0037541536,
-0.0004120283,
-0.068977274,
0.0237337891,
-0.0311737973,
-0.003920693,
-0.0632931963,
0.005185463,
-0.0496925823,
-0.0846584141,
-0.0771340951,
0.0271493718,
0.0306764841,
0.0131086353,
-0.0017849843,
0.0058064051,
0.0247087851,
0.0086278785,
-0.0082268156,
0.0120567437,
0.0614668764,
0.0218516197,
0.0400139764,
0.0384072512,
0.0217683576,
0.0019867618,
-0.0485786423,
0.018026771,
-0.0088832136,
0.0140371639,
-0.0407797396,
-0.0797859207,
0.0619918667,
0.0476813614,
-0.027654428,
0.0073886476,
0.0119129578,
-0.0184652433,
-0.0229535513,
-0.0210824944,
-0.0160035156,
-0.0351003073,
0.0246254541,
0.0303985979,
-0.0160280559,
0.010263578,
-0.0133284694,
-0.0003938813,
-0.0242244788,
-0.0443808846,
-0.0082738996,
-0.0280196704,
-0.0094236461,
0.0073794499,
0.0091523258,
0.017207941,
-0.0115274061,
-0.0174992196,
0.053796798,
-0.0129585396,
-0.0038544959,
-0.061970558,
0.0096886819,
-0.050801076,
0.0101947552,
0.1161097139,
0.0217519552,
-0.0560765415,
-0.0265616439,
-0.0619309284,
-0.029338982,
-0.008830064,
-0.005055537,
0.0040987474,
-0.0334063768,
0.02071709,
0.0736728683,
-0.0227057189,
0.0300219152,
-0.0182671957,
0.009019468,
-0.002475189,
0.0624879189,
-0.017291531,
0.0227789022,
-0.007842442,
0.0489851981,
-0.0108764153,
-0.0334896706,
-0.0517563149,
-0.0211025514,
-0.0475220308,
-0.0313646086,
0.0019273784,
-0.0619283505,
0.0732652918,
-0.011786758,
0.0084011452,
-0.0490861163,
-0.0223650374,
-0.0444632545,
0.0494717211,
0.0548150353,
0.0246526618,
0.0174260754,
0.0939702988,
0.0324023925,
0.0158403292,
0.061498791,
0.0458091684,
-0.0419091657,
0.0187151898,
-0.0407488011,
-0.0320763513,
0.0565675534,
-0.0144347828,
-0.0062470273,
-0.0282940771,
-0.0639546663,
0.0517733991,
0.0388815291,
0.0285497773,
-0.0262486134,
-0.0742598921,
-0.030754758,
-0.0082654469,
-0.0001454498,
0.0115591194,
-0.0137329269,
0.0149599388,
-0.0272044409,
-0.0098510636,
0.0237253178,
0.0178014375,
-0.0348968096,
-0.0045706159,
-0.0669084862,
0.093872346,
-0.0274767615,
-0.039182134,
-0.036470592,
0.0600161664,
-0.0558220968,
0.0001285706,
0.0039147274,
0.0191670377,
-0.0066899932,
0.0515016057,
0.1467555016,
0.0202310979,
-0.0556981266,
0.0250045676,
-0.0009514328,
-0.0697011575,
0.0041069095,
-0.0404680893,
-0.0525339097,
0.0578673035,
-0.0207808949,
0.0288962945,
-0.0114713274,
0.0306086671,
-0.0117736543,
0.0499854051,
-0.0477841273,
-0.0325067043,
0.0243803859,
-0.0036386556,
0.0314869843,
-0.027009448,
0.0043063196,
0.0321705006,
-0.0165680703,
0.0309620816,
-0.0105959885,
-0.0119809834,
-0.0035088416,
0.0307647735,
0.028890945,
0.0260829832,
0.0355027094,
-0.0217407737,
-0.0148939788,
-0.0087792892,
-0.0445369892,
-0.0113789216,
-0.0496609919,
-0.0383795798,
-0.0137013039,
0.0514880456,
-0.0057443338,
-0.0309840217,
0.030589737,
-0.0304754823,
-0.0515376925,
0.0513498373,
0.0019666774,
0.0042692809,
-0.0259366613,
-0.0011926111,
-0.0307059065,
0.0313147157,
-0.0415803045,
0.034566544,
0.0353659205,
0.0244229883,
-0.0410206914,
-0.0078614755,
0.0416380055,
-0.0383764543,
-0.0168064926,
0.0235293992,
0.0121160299,
0.0413859561,
-0.0168994237,
-0.0227700695,
0.0000872743,
-0.0415707789,
-0.0423598327,
-0.0137168821,
-0.0230868272,
0.0052147405,
-0.0034260058,
0.0212524328,
0.0185501222,
-0.0282197036,
0.0093766283,
-0.0204540137,
-0.0406925976,
-0.0131801208,
-0.0042602434,
0.0013937496,
-0.0469466038,
0.0489955246,
-0.0179556645,
-0.0123402579,
0.0329044983,
-0.031299267,
-0.0382330008,
-0.0275209527,
0.0062598763,
0.0193748381,
-0.0013494521,
-0.0075909658,
0.0311739761,
-0.0329254195,
0.0051768227,
-0.0091597596,
0.0405761823,
0.0382804647,
-0.035439685,
0.0095054675,
0.0212546531,
-0.0037002321,
0.0093038045,
-0.0063454346,
0.0315392129,
-0.0408046953,
0.0114508504,
-0.0064405827,
0.0421993695,
0.0044067889,
0.0385983847,
-0.007366308,
-0.0644848645,
-0.0031132915,
-0.0292823203,
-0.0271667838,
-0.0272845645,
-0.008480655,
-0.0038227378,
-0.0219684951,
0.0124197183,
0.0268402752,
-0.0664455146,
-0.008660092,
-0.0329842381,
-0.0662697479,
-0.0257811509,
-0.0111709889,
0.0264182817,
0.0463714413,
-0.0039702272,
-0.0208098926,
-0.0532774925,
-0.0460002907,
0.0106023503,
-0.0021276814,
0.0220419858,
0.0333430767,
-0.0020234927,
-0.0372628458,
-0.0337875187,
0.0073338868,
0.0064854017,
0.0039553284,
-0.0030073489,
-0.0170164499,
-0.0202199817,
-0.0654514953,
0.0272087604,
0.048136875,
0.0064528184,
0.0122973705,
0.0128900167,
0.0110280458,
0.1088288799,
-0.050660722,
0.0284578074,
-0.0328646526,
-0.0244422052,
-0.0109174121,
0.0218582284,
0.0182239152,
0.0338892862,
-0.0207730569,
-0.007877999,
0.0237707682,
0.0080330595,
-0.0486257337,
-0.024465384,
0.0189287961,
0.0143682444,
0.0186568517,
0.1125368923,
0.026253162,
-0.1116952747,
-0.0297383573,
0.003792868,
0.0060099582,
-0.01856024,
-0.0137842102,
-0.0028303256,
-0.0312192831,
0.0179660823,
0.0199724752,
0.0419099443,
0.0096554523,
0.0181621872,
-0.0489315875,
0.0021433102,
0.0315336026,
-0.0382957309,
-0.0237332247,
-0.035361141,
-0.0326891728,
0.0081650568,
0.0413362123,
-0.0355620906,
0.0462414287,
-0.0589400753,
0.0775148422,
-0.067924507,
-0.0047812299,
0.0107894614,
-0.0214060191,
0.0228676405,
0.0234937873,
0.0148414848,
-0.0118169198,
-0.0558293276,
0.0268709771,
-0.0594938025,
-0.0413489826,
0.010159486,
0.042864792,
0.0093744798,
-0.0052528363,
0.0451027043,
-0.0231233016,
0.0013077775,
-0.0174882915,
0.0374981388,
0.0199977588,
0.0148947379,
0.0038240219,
0.0113812108,
0.038918186,
0.0121310949,
0.0197467934,
0.0220276415,
0.0002209874,
-0.0084733674,
0.0298022162,
0.0707010478,
0.0002970824,
-0.0257616397,
0.0236950088,
0.0044432194,
-0.1074003205,
0.0339589305,
0.0059677125,
-0.0270106234,
0.0257841032,
-0.0212161038,
-0.0093863541,
-0.0292334892,
0.0282409936,
-0.0255360566,
0.0228072107,
-0.023220636,
0.0479097404,
-0.0673606992,
-0.0342420228,
0.0654974878,
0.0083018495,
-0.0256684721,
0.0391477011,
-0.0114466315,
-0.049996525,
0.0110916141,
-0.0729402378,
0.0061933566,
0.0577895641,
-0.029991081,
-0.0679925382,
0.080351159,
0.0432492755,
-0.0005939998,
0.0384716392,
0.0696579963,
-0.0074286447,
-0.0356771946,
0.0473365001,
-0.0235954318,
0.0634942949,
0.0001589094,
-0.0439131148,
-0.0755424723,
-0.0550601631,
-0.0538397655,
0.00319911,
0.0724859461,
0.0171715301,
-0.006094222,
0.0137571469,
0.0093965046,
0.0177922882,
-0.0002618083,
0.0221646391,
-0.0390932001,
0.0407931469,
-0.0018443277,
0.002905139,
0.0621892586,
0.024461979,
-0.0583701693,
0.0268635135,
0.0131477006,
0.0259254351,
0.0433718152,
-0.0178771857,
0.0296695437,
-0.0070742816,
0.0080031026,
0.052584175,
-0.0079869572,
-0.0131554939,
-0.0068139196,
-0.0066699111,
0.0291002467,
-0.0270472486,
0.0439031534,
-0.040214289,
0.0107636061,
0.0006668425,
-0.0104806563,
-0.0247424636,
0.0348840207,
0.0252139904,
0.0255783778,
-0.0157250818,
-0.0013491595,
-0.0092337467,
-0.030415073,
-0.0321398824,
0.0402547829,
-0.0020709068,
0.0086561237,
0.0388947129,
0.0778892115,
-0.0108558713,
0.0369345024,
-0.0219003111,
0.0221402086,
-0.0288396422,
-0.0321216732,
0.0261442252,
0.0213159006,
-0.0094792172,
-0.0416976176,
0.0172503162,
-0.0353465527,
0.018378824,
-0.0583505109,
0.0145994127,
0.0733355731,
0.0132054854,
0.0150937727,
-0.0164510049,
-0.0000033243,
0.0287371688,
-0.035418015,
0.041006133,
-0.024672905,
0.0158380475,
-5.887163338e-33,
-0.054267019,
0.0191243235,
-0.0457513519,
0.0141854929,
-0.0048814402,
-0.0204979088,
-0.0017416019,
0.0450322926,
0.000358118,
-0.0226339493,
0.0117994314,
0.0249490682,
0.0241123978,
0.0264903568,
-0.0050097252,
-0.0371370539,
0.061263632,
-0.0302961413,
0.0061868266,
0.0538605601,
0.0447939709,
-0.0182611328,
0.0143217929,
-0.0840514824,
-0.0584728532,
-0.0077118338,
-0.021485975,
0.0242902711,
-0.0326875038,
0.0038661652,
-0.0391091518,
0.0699979812,
0.0185433384,
-0.0116027342,
0.0081590349,
0.0331513733,
-0.0582653433,
-0.0177367702,
-0.1152672395,
0.052060876,
-0.0030179564,
-0.0433519408,
0.0511034429,
0.0318761505,
-0.0088463696,
-0.034905456,
0.0665395334,
0.0163895376,
-0.0193227213,
-0.0261782445,
0.0652436763,
0.0335901156,
-0.0127439918,
-0.0094291894,
0.0145262349,
0.0094279414,
-0.0082035167,
0.0108276801,
-0.1041209698,
0.0238412023,
-0.0212654434,
0.0244696662,
0.0131696351,
0.0608591698,
-0.0244083796,
0.0235980749,
0.1065263152,
-0.0134888086,
0.0702209771,
-0.0353609286,
0.0164394211,
0.0173367243,
0.0102377953,
0.0296360943,
-0.0066225617,
-0.057792116,
-0.0516580641,
0.0226475708,
-0.0073315324,
-0.0392015949,
-0.0090646595,
0.011440902,
-0.0174025167,
-0.0389620699,
-0.0079937307,
-0.0595655367,
-0.0120071797,
0.0003285476,
-0.002078926,
0.008836451,
-0.0161820799,
-0.0343340673,
-0.0093329754,
-0.0200566221,
-0.0457788892,
0.0113456324,
0.0143028488,
0.065574944,
0.0132359238,
-0.0379486494,
0.0365857407,
-0.0867506862,
0.0600089133,
0.0424870327,
0.0273213033,
-0.0520229377,
0.0385358445,
0.0203379896,
-0.0213519465,
-0.0071270061,
0.0323071778,
0.0136713507,
-0.0058259433,
0.0084564313,
0.0022336738,
-0.0188024007,
0.0092587229,
0.0099976482,
0.0491502285,
-0.0168498773,
0.0387722701,
0.0332292542,
0.0184784885,
0.0479891151,
-0.0081042275,
-0.0039616581,
0.0162183587,
-0.0561887473,
0.0815250725,
-0.0339955389,
-0.0086857844,
-0.0837144703,
2.861e-7,
-0.0113279931,
-0.0108402791,
0.0168362577,
-0.0910840482,
0.0517944023,
0.0632772297,
0.0006060883,
0.0438447744,
-0.0309291687,
0.0088047562,
0.0178763624,
0.0052464795,
0.0438662879,
0.0223121587,
-0.0721931532,
-0.0370659977,
-0.0097306082,
0.0813726857,
-0.0319588967,
0.0404999144,
0.0114433626,
0.0588101633,
0.0192474704,
-0.0307688285,
0.0031817609,
-0.0624951087,
0.0151863089,
-0.0223480016,
0.0280835852,
0.0176273789,
0.0135645093,
-0.0292052981,
0.0311324019,
0.0864372849,
0.015784923,
0.0188374277,
0.0383344702,
0.0080968514,
-0.0036172415,
-0.0604332685,
-0.0478872284,
0.0631567463,
-0.00145432,
0.0136079267,
0.0513555035,
-0.0376291759,
-0.0551796518,
0.0382248424,
-0.0552776493,
0.0016156075,
0.0451124273,
0.0398109928,
-0.0263138097,
0.0196298957,
-0.0273460113,
-0.03728313,
-0.0168662574,
-0.0665989667,
0.0054679299,
0.0280714072,
-0.0730549395,
-0.0145373195,
0.0366487615,
-0.0245409403,
0.0289322883,
0.0154126538,
0.0344684236,
2.087641922e-34,
-0.0095889699,
0.0185046047,
0.0109595712,
-0.064868331,
-0.0135024106,
-0.056193918,
-0.0609061532,
-0.0368073657,
0.0060075866,
-0.0237025451,
0.0243392624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12520v1 | Lost in Translation: When GPT-4V(ision) Can't See Eye to Eye with Text. A Vision-Language-Consistency Analysis of VLLMs and Beyond | 2023-10-19T06:45:11 | 2023-10-19T06:45:11 | Xiang Zhang, Senyu Li, Zijun Wu, Ning Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent advancements in multimodal techniques open exciting possibilities for
models excelling in diverse tasks involving text, audio, and image processing.
Models like GPT-4V, blending computer vision and language modeling, excel in
complex text and image tasks. Numerous prior research endeavors have diligently
examined the performance of these Vision Large Language Models (VLLMs) across
tasks like object detection, image captioning and others. However, these
analyses often focus on evaluating the performance of each modality in
isolation, lacking insights into their cross-modal interactions. Specifically,
questions concerning whether these vision-language models execute vision and
language tasks consistently or independently have remained unanswered. In this
study, we draw inspiration from recent investigations into multilingualism and
conduct a comprehensive analysis of model's cross-modal interactions. We
introduce a systematic framework that quantifies the capability disparities
between different modalities in the multi-modal setting and provide a set of
datasets designed for these evaluations. Our findings reveal that models like
GPT-4V tend to perform consistently modalities when the tasks are relatively
simple. However, the trustworthiness of results derived from the vision
modality diminishes as the tasks become more challenging. Expanding on our
findings, we introduce "Vision Description Prompting," a method that
effectively improves performance in challenging vision-related tasks. | [
0.0207428001,
0.0657436028,
-0.0100623518,
0.0766613632,
-0.0389496684,
0.0171231423,
0.0235942341,
-0.0024741304,
-0.009574851,
-0.0840475187,
-0.0618610084,
-0.0728913322,
0.044150345,
0.0387307703,
0.0239598248,
-0.0556529872,
0.0163789187,
-0.0554151461,
-0.033596646,
0.0032199027,
0.0288968682,
0.0143141951,
0.0032340665,
0.0407150127,
-0.0010033383,
-0.0081453649,
0.0031986407,
0.0284801461,
0.018027002,
-0.0200305041,
-0.0416766889,
0.0429426059,
0.026876526,
0.0490646362,
0.0000017487,
-0.0272413548,
0.0469788797,
0.0102146007,
0.0478193983,
0.0017037604,
0.0563939884,
-0.091808036,
-0.0174729563,
-0.0110268863,
-0.0224161241,
-0.0362181775,
0.0872045234,
0.0433845334,
0.0239447877,
0.0275294073,
-0.0315138735,
-0.0085529527,
0.0207727924,
-0.0224952977,
0.0131022725,
-0.0160059966,
0.0055563273,
0.0091301845,
-0.0092300437,
0.0324167833,
-0.0314486139,
0.0560263805,
0.0213012677,
-0.0182566624,
-0.0251043178,
0.047258351,
-0.0022106513,
-0.0577096529,
-0.0432867035,
0.0561060943,
0.0128224296,
0.0018276279,
-0.0243366286,
0.006131852,
-0.0168188345,
0.0042314623,
-0.0310708582,
0.048944287,
-0.0113561647,
0.00311738,
-0.0493483096,
-0.0001113007,
0.0186957624,
0.0127347885,
-0.0023828365,
-0.0127221663,
0.0315409116,
0.014820274,
-0.0041332049,
0.026606407,
-0.0383465253,
-0.0583687834,
0.0041755019,
-0.0002831435,
0.012600068,
-0.0059051546,
-0.0489404649,
-0.0136600146,
0.0052451515,
-0.0258530583,
0.0530506,
0.0264606103,
-0.0778278038,
0.0524748974,
-0.0200403165,
0.0697868913,
-0.038046822,
0.0338918827,
-0.0263200011,
-0.0167443175,
-0.0342676975,
-0.0100520933,
-0.0005838158,
-0.0318031833,
-0.0448077731,
-0.0610923581,
-0.0311899111,
0.0222956799,
0.0095126163,
0.0033255133,
-0.0121404687,
-0.0105382716,
-0.0402547903,
-0.0113339443,
-0.0189800002,
0.0590943694,
0.0350904949,
0.008761364,
-0.0265497696,
-0.07733877,
0.008885595,
0.0519987121,
-0.0089330692,
-0.0306137186,
-0.0263424776,
0.0890743509,
-0.0358008258,
-0.0427314639,
0.0115672741,
0.0003457197,
-0.0540333614,
-0.0784874558,
0.0175635237,
-0.0512956381,
0.0112461848,
0.0146401478,
0.0153856585,
0.0109258834,
0.0048640664,
0.0079147145,
0.0075230831,
0.1208167598,
0.0052210451,
-0.0007936049,
0.0052483361,
0.0118199922,
0.0290570389,
0.0676278397,
0.0309245121,
0.0091766147,
0.028422296,
-0.0045629032,
0.0172315612,
0.0673608705,
-0.0448078401,
0.0157989338,
-0.0586860999,
-0.0284185447,
0.0140035562,
0.0020597288,
0.039536003,
0.0763272718,
-0.0073784795,
0.0017983357,
0.12900424,
0.0414183438,
-0.0051048142,
-0.0126133105,
0.0289603006,
0.0051348438,
-0.0037181342,
0.0247472581,
-0.0595501848,
0.0462113358,
-0.0007275341,
0.0125160357,
-0.0147009166,
0.0396244749,
-0.0194845349,
-0.0315312259,
-0.0347315259,
-0.0208253358,
0.025794914,
0.0147435227,
0.0674438924,
-0.009206689,
-0.0250565112,
-0.016058201,
-0.0174289104,
-0.0395469703,
-0.0132298637,
-0.0596290529,
0.0069389655,
0.052569095,
0.0288941991,
0.0183697138,
-0.0001672767,
0.0049660318,
0.0401280709,
0.0955626145,
0.0404063091,
0.0310688596,
0.0304656308,
-0.0455333292,
-0.0354885794,
0.0062663993,
0.0038442782,
0.0273359902,
-0.0132906036,
0.0113954945,
0.0270985924,
-0.0325493924,
-0.0202267803,
0.031787768,
0.0487371571,
0.01811851,
-0.0335989818,
0.0054764999,
-0.0109354565,
0.0003068692,
-0.0345359258,
0.0042913919,
0.0085970666,
-0.0218442008,
0.024988139,
0.0596537478,
-0.0379362069,
-0.0038526207,
0.0359647274,
-0.0372800641,
0.0165360197,
0.0330973342,
0.006997569,
-0.0383537002,
0.0083215246,
-0.0537538603,
-0.0053576194,
-0.0687710866,
0.0045511173,
-0.0096456371,
0.0344589949,
-0.002253901,
0.0308808386,
-0.0003550625,
-0.0065701758,
0.0220124237,
-0.0042223022,
0.0104012284,
-0.0088684848,
-0.053740181,
0.058589384,
0.0302078482,
0.0329036899,
0.0182263423,
-0.0041503785,
-0.012293675,
-0.0208706576,
-0.1123630553,
-0.0341544151,
-0.0315186158,
-0.0020115625,
0.012791004,
-0.0095256511,
0.0034978001,
-0.0311829038,
-0.0314310826,
0.0288966708,
0.0360762998,
0.0323197953,
0.0326786786,
0.0045774356,
-0.0064183748,
-0.0038300499,
-0.006404114,
0.0081329541,
0.0446923338,
0.0180472955,
-0.0442034714,
-0.0737332404,
0.025325615,
-0.0266933572,
0.0312470272,
-0.0251948889,
-0.033219099,
0.0281275716,
-0.0009147602,
0.0409538969,
0.0602798797,
-0.0015246419,
0.0248721261,
0.04369618,
-0.0190945305,
-0.0121103348,
-0.008288986,
0.0301818829,
-0.0586570092,
-0.0200018156,
-0.0216768105,
-0.0336010344,
0.0562429093,
-0.0071993689,
0.0221356135,
-0.0440501608,
0.0021856765,
-0.0417522639,
-0.0515277386,
-0.0304253977,
0.0052790763,
-0.0231880844,
0.0566092506,
-0.0261188056,
-0.0942201242,
0.0257232264,
-0.0716772154,
-0.0424311012,
0.0074802251,
0.0010523801,
-0.0173076745,
0.1011574864,
0.0264713746,
0.0165920127,
0.0019318623,
-0.0201758444,
-0.0441063941,
-0.019851869,
0.0101215513,
-0.0096340999,
0.0856150165,
-0.0670982376,
0.0078248121,
-0.0476891026,
-0.014222946,
0.0010565273,
-0.0036655958,
-0.0356475972,
-0.0073151379,
-0.0286244564,
-0.0277477782,
-0.0181687195,
0.0511867329,
0.0572977662,
0.0416927822,
-0.0183066912,
-0.0123429345,
-0.0208368395,
0.009988023,
0.0414885171,
0.0370480791,
-0.019566793,
-0.0644815341,
0.0014091028,
0.0381419472,
0.0197856296,
0.0047751549,
-0.0721863955,
0.0081429025,
0.0406579673,
0.0590659454,
-0.0477512442,
0.02004431,
0.0756751224,
-0.0603831746,
0.0071923928,
0.0679133311,
-0.0124833565,
-0.0638440475,
-0.0359111987,
0.0189477894,
0.0277353935,
0.031992387,
-0.0103305504,
-0.0874217227,
-0.0477574877,
-0.0086660972,
-0.0142606134,
0.020879766,
0.0334253423,
-0.0440836027,
-0.0780403465,
0.0620168522,
0.0111504616,
-0.0371371992,
-0.0396723039,
0.018533621,
0.0007812745,
-0.002718139,
0.0236429796,
-0.0224582106,
-0.0172329973,
-0.0255127437,
0.008185192,
0.0283893812,
-0.0575316846,
0.0001438622,
-0.0357588902,
-0.0208475757,
0.0817025229,
0.0101976022,
-0.0300581157,
-0.0684088245,
0.0398038477,
-0.016351711,
0.0167818386,
0.0126620969,
0.0417257696,
-0.024774095,
-0.041815944,
0.001291633,
0.0018507695,
-0.0079086311,
-0.0261781141,
-0.016269017,
0.0077168527,
-0.0202267319,
-0.0075134798,
-0.0113602821,
0.0112099266,
-0.0152526731,
0.0421387553,
0.0235540643,
-0.0429141931,
-0.0422370546,
-0.0012545636,
0.0042361901,
-0.0306164213,
-0.0263120532,
0.006514133,
0.0143614933,
-0.0249619856,
-0.0469931513,
-0.0430912524,
0.0113045918,
0.035678681,
0.0116811302,
-0.0002782008,
-0.0128995553,
0.0236962326,
-0.0342927277,
0.0664454326,
-0.0124423876,
0.043344412,
-0.0490740761,
0.014980915,
0.0205340721,
-0.0685349181,
-0.0009631033,
0.0328558385,
-0.0845913887,
-0.0446971841,
-0.0463601761,
0.010884203,
0.0248391908,
0.0404844508,
0.0007086247,
-0.054160364,
0.0040151081,
0.0202152524,
0.0099565992,
0.0520660281,
0.0259578228,
-0.0148943979,
-0.0276474133,
0.030578021,
-0.0184422005,
0.0195189938,
0.0220614504,
0.0030095964,
0.0119050927,
-0.0373510458,
0.0034630429,
-0.0008974817,
0.056851387,
-0.0423920415,
0.0219945144,
-0.0319135934,
-0.0087134773,
-0.0051341192,
-0.0112478044,
-0.0832787529,
0.0139825316,
0.0234622117,
0.0360571444,
-0.0060928273,
0.0115016392,
0.0035036448,
-0.0015155302,
-0.0302985758,
0.0225496348,
0.0027108293,
-0.0280076824,
0.0077917911,
0.0278713796,
-0.016673822,
0.0233603995,
-0.034375675,
0.017687412,
0.0012893643,
0.0749543607,
0.0144094983,
-0.0399458557,
0.0091481656,
0.0582284965,
-0.0280515384,
-0.0135059636,
-0.0226472579,
0.0394624844,
0.058161281,
-0.0140701225,
0.0716855675,
-0.0363292769,
0.0009601249,
-0.0398760773,
0.0514685921,
0.0223898813,
-0.0139641287,
0.0557109565,
0.0120714651,
-0.0105799772,
-0.0087784417,
0.0575296991,
-0.0039814725,
0.0126442201,
-0.0065073636,
-0.0157637019,
-0.024175195,
-0.0337296128,
0.0364533104,
-0.003264626,
-0.0261374544,
0.0071696471,
-0.0310483426,
-0.0642599687,
0.006878213,
0.0049857381,
-0.0030164488,
-0.0106312027,
0.0320734493,
0.0831578448,
0.0127329351,
-0.0044721114,
-0.0151391337,
-0.0643239319,
0.0053044893,
0.0389749371,
0.0128008006,
-5.467909318e-33,
-0.0338562913,
-0.0256294254,
0.0056802831,
-0.0249766,
-0.0234835204,
0.0383290946,
-0.0370621309,
0.028464362,
0.0057808729,
0.0155868977,
0.0283113401,
-0.0019984357,
0.0256119594,
0.0387714654,
0.013696136,
0.0082622552,
0.031484846,
-0.0055413991,
-0.0203969665,
-0.0172551498,
0.0240923706,
-0.0173200034,
0.0810504407,
-0.0461720303,
0.0415788107,
0.0196929052,
-0.0314945541,
0.0021021748,
-0.0036066128,
0.0940291137,
-0.051813405,
0.05409633,
0.0386638306,
-0.010478735,
-0.0289412774,
0.055378288,
-0.02555269,
0.0198868774,
0.0414555557,
0.0605107062,
-0.079677552,
0.0097420709,
0.0391787291,
-0.0546177551,
-0.0298778582,
-0.02834641,
0.0467857867,
-0.0371777564,
-0.0019090474,
0.0212917291,
-0.0813324898,
0.0234048218,
0.0296999589,
-0.023430001,
0.0528550968,
0.0380578339,
0.004028975,
0.0301664583,
-0.0294340812,
0.0190383755,
-0.0110394927,
0.0331547149,
0.0999624878,
0.0610781349,
-0.0100753531,
0.0617597029,
0.0286437459,
-0.0444773063,
-0.0247044712,
-0.0326782353,
0.0430233739,
0.0255967528,
0.0575735383,
0.0841097534,
-0.0070549995,
0.0246448591,
-0.0179915745,
-0.0115389144,
-0.0453039296,
0.0374470167,
0.0375348777,
0.0041747657,
-0.0280379858,
0.0032167989,
-0.0349215493,
-0.0179919135,
-0.0533468686,
-0.0101115704,
0.0569860712,
0.0239907485,
0.004077578,
0.0451150648,
0.08210475,
-0.0194943715,
-0.0195424873,
-0.0111911688,
-0.0432469361,
0.0623202957,
-0.0032834026,
0.0120005505,
-0.0295951869,
-0.0160725284,
0.0429054573,
0.0260989964,
0.001183659,
-0.0009941176,
0.01564564,
0.0171256978,
-0.0693076774,
-0.0030272941,
-0.0508162789,
-0.0039198082,
-0.0066958205,
0.041268453,
0.0598031431,
-0.0320891626,
-0.0680549443,
0.0274718981,
-0.0326298028,
-0.0339853428,
-0.0520124137,
-0.0279316884,
-0.0252629649,
0.0331874751,
-0.0293622334,
0.0210188404,
-0.0195583217,
-0.0354540721,
0.0408494398,
-0.0193601623,
-0.0287530869,
0.034510117,
2.423e-7,
0.0317826942,
0.0120299421,
0.0122734234,
0.0004378805,
0.0255885571,
0.058154583,
-0.0506779216,
0.0288907867,
-0.0210559554,
-0.0285906307,
-0.0156328902,
0.0308925901,
0.0727126226,
-0.003628772,
-0.010624663,
0.0234479532,
-0.0292296819,
0.0144565329,
-0.0483692959,
0.0072342148,
0.058544971,
0.0734166279,
-0.0485532656,
-0.0180771276,
0.0196516439,
-0.092328392,
0.085216023,
-0.0460172296,
-0.0051013846,
-0.0421287157,
0.0094907191,
0.0461402759,
-0.0286215525,
0.0519343838,
0.0081699183,
-0.038466949,
0.0568906851,
0.0368838385,
-0.0228959415,
0.0079009281,
-0.0182034355,
0.0310440976,
-0.0321857296,
-0.0696279183,
0.0712248608,
-0.0435865447,
-0.0198979024,
-0.0362705626,
0.0109839281,
-0.0360827148,
0.0205845553,
-0.0279797874,
-0.0348055772,
0.0303065889,
0.0346202664,
-0.0142970458,
-0.0556933507,
-0.0459383912,
-0.0204382278,
-0.013616656,
-0.0334671959,
-0.049653586,
-0.0770372897,
-0.0061545502,
0.0418691412,
-0.0426665731,
-0.0431928299,
2.063253858e-34,
0.0149066104,
-0.0232067835,
0.0119225727,
-0.0064628208,
0.0048543247,
-0.0010353674,
-0.0074214018,
0.0059771244,
-0.0286688339,
-0.0506160296,
-0.0124863563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12516v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12516v2 | ReEval: Automatic Hallucination Evaluation for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models via Transferable Adversarial Attacks | 2023-10-19T06:37:32 | 2024-05-31T23:46:24 | Xiaodong Yu, Hao Cheng, Xiaodong Liu, Dan Roth, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite remarkable advancements in mitigating hallucinations in large
language models (LLMs) by retrieval augmentation, it remains challenging to
measure the reliability of LLMs using static question-answering (QA) data.
Specifically, given the potential of data contamination (e.g., leading to
memorization), good static benchmark performance does not ensure that model can
reliably use the provided evidence for responding, which is essential to avoid
hallucination when the required knowledge is new or private. Inspired by
adversarial machine learning, we investigate the feasibility of automatically
perturbing existing static one for dynamic evaluation. Specifically, this paper
presents ReEval, an LLM-based framework using prompt chaining to perturb the
original evidence for generating new test cases for evaluating the LLMs'
reliability in using new evidence for answering.
We implement ReEval using ChatGPT and evaluate the resulting variants of two
popular open-domain QA datasets on a collection of LLMs under various prompting
settings. Our generated data is human-readable and useful to trigger
hallucination in LLM. Accurate models on static data are observed to produce
unsupported answers from the perturbed evidence, with pronounced accuracy drops
across LLMs including GPT-4. We find that our adversarial examples are
transferable across all considered LLMs. The examples generated by a small
model can be used to evaluate a much larger model, making our approach
cost-effective. | [
0.0147050377,
0.0773183033,
-0.0188628398,
0.040114671,
-0.0476219766,
-0.0010587546,
-0.0342941992,
0.0097894529,
0.0473073125,
-0.0363002382,
-0.0269961506,
-0.0416724831,
-0.0181428939,
-0.0043269964,
0.0393839367,
-0.0223469734,
0.0603249893,
-0.0423821434,
-0.0327841714,
-0.0257776342,
-0.0146748293,
-0.0146722002,
0.004136018,
0.0177779943,
0.0194061548,
-0.0328515805,
-0.0190259181,
-0.0201746393,
0.0191795416,
-0.0024486557,
0.0249143858,
0.0686265603,
0.0049791862,
0.0957974195,
0.0000020982,
-0.0441903509,
-0.0385064892,
0.0021404065,
-0.0343232118,
0.0225029998,
0.005693926,
0.0226175711,
0.0069096461,
0.0134072341,
-0.0430041812,
-0.0112285754,
0.0105041666,
0.0446247421,
0.092338644,
0.079746291,
0.0096655786,
-0.0165898241,
0.0664153099,
-0.0205726698,
0.0488655046,
-0.0522253029,
0.0404167101,
0.02733819,
-0.0036929713,
0.0234461259,
-0.0088779004,
0.0458994992,
0.0493189543,
0.018217938,
-0.0312805735,
0.0114876311,
-0.0802982673,
0.0142001985,
-0.0048540826,
0.0837735012,
0.0036930172,
-0.0520803854,
-0.011763854,
0.0228231587,
0.0360316969,
0.0205914341,
-0.0608966276,
-0.0111223776,
-0.0146047231,
-0.013622147,
-0.0008043284,
-0.0273030102,
0.0631051064,
0.0216803197,
-0.0158686079,
0.0579003021,
0.0352589488,
-0.0371502265,
0.0140078329,
-0.0111999689,
-0.010732159,
-0.0298441816,
0.0072707869,
0.0228280723,
-0.0340682454,
0.013562304,
-0.0433064848,
-0.0233500339,
0.0589433573,
-0.0176353808,
0.0031940448,
-0.0016666075,
-0.0567930676,
0.0486370139,
-0.0303804483,
0.0451362245,
-0.0345371179,
0.0888439417,
-0.0200758036,
-0.0112829125,
-0.047086481,
-0.0406743437,
-0.0182645228,
0.0200085193,
0.0073758154,
0.0147241242,
-0.0166448317,
0.0095452257,
-0.0408573225,
0.0193160977,
-0.048260279,
0.0283855628,
-0.0160841011,
-0.0128646391,
-0.0105391266,
-0.0107422099,
-0.0319572948,
-0.008149473,
0.0407560393,
-0.1100218669,
-0.0448988937,
0.0001572165,
-0.0203776676,
-0.0143982358,
0.013705276,
0.07015118,
0.0007214471,
-0.028509846,
0.0037256056,
-0.0427733697,
-0.0173913818,
-0.0629655942,
0.0216646269,
-0.0456224792,
0.0112359002,
-0.0320089646,
-0.0179717857,
-0.0467489213,
-0.0019810386,
0.0411015674,
-0.0230355971,
0.0738043562,
0.0367569812,
-0.0302397683,
0.0246854778,
0.0402468368,
-0.0426622927,
0.0450466909,
-0.0151699753,
0.0584404133,
0.0527189896,
-0.0195010137,
0.0580066703,
0.0234907232,
0.0524477772,
0.0279003959,
-0.0074733803,
0.0340854265,
0.04215746,
0.0095160902,
-0.0326483287,
0.0681268051,
-0.0272151381,
-0.0651843771,
0.0734978691,
0.0112979468,
-0.0236824304,
0.0253342614,
-0.0043798056,
-0.0087867137,
0.0184840802,
0.0352949128,
-0.0850980133,
0.009645368,
-0.0768197179,
-0.0197207648,
0.0469353013,
-0.0075857295,
-0.0201265533,
-0.0389433689,
0.0260617696,
0.0076484983,
0.0109333023,
0.0484635495,
0.012101233,
0.039487876,
-0.0478701144,
0.0317614973,
0.0111422287,
-0.0348075293,
-0.0125348028,
-0.0841796026,
0.0265188832,
0.0165296383,
0.0809939951,
-0.0534713864,
0.010893506,
-0.0231700279,
0.0330307819,
0.0091758315,
0.0455827117,
0.0108753443,
0.0222098883,
-0.0318122543,
-0.0025338519,
-0.035011597,
0.0253814124,
0.037765488,
0.0201505888,
-0.004964435,
0.007718876,
-0.0359237976,
-0.0272333324,
0.0362662338,
-0.0098633701,
-0.0654439181,
-0.0031768822,
-0.0094181728,
0.0191812161,
-0.0096205687,
-0.0032044628,
0.0369018354,
0.0467488915,
-0.0031823069,
-0.0395740159,
-0.0197788477,
-0.0257738624,
-0.0166770443,
0.0189886075,
-0.0020113923,
-0.022467453,
0.0388630666,
-0.0445789769,
-0.0206260551,
0.0073299161,
-0.0419008955,
0.0094704637,
-0.0455869213,
0.0060135592,
-0.0170014985,
0.0584385507,
-0.0364377424,
0.0679168627,
-0.0203567147,
-0.0026741477,
0.0178796835,
0.0229244474,
-0.0176138878,
-0.0459497571,
-0.0374865048,
0.005400999,
-0.0165208671,
0.0234762952,
0.0195006412,
-0.0344903432,
-0.0588785782,
-0.0119373137,
-0.0513465255,
0.0191726759,
-0.0372862592,
0.0154531766,
0.0177296326,
-0.0129775088,
-0.0081555871,
-0.0168587938,
-0.036392536,
0.0010575709,
0.0193374623,
0.0504967123,
-0.0069755209,
0.0093375947,
-0.00596222,
-0.0224986468,
-0.010567016,
0.0005952527,
0.0427881479,
-0.0232008714,
0.0055947774,
-0.0536413491,
0.0076156612,
-0.0235689152,
0.0345799439,
-0.0230103843,
-0.0151227321,
0.0293219034,
-0.0151759181,
0.0055371402,
0.0977573916,
0.0225811023,
0.0116241351,
0.0496152118,
0.0091786589,
-0.0518955179,
-0.0054049883,
0.0071908957,
-0.0555574931,
-0.0016163406,
-0.023358129,
0.0029169242,
0.0019797543,
0.027077619,
-0.0068512131,
-0.0397912785,
0.048545707,
-0.006984957,
-0.0582594983,
-0.0393352732,
-0.0110302214,
-0.0345359035,
0.0170134492,
-0.0257768407,
-0.0774741098,
0.0876720473,
-0.0291426238,
-0.0000565888,
-0.0125681423,
-0.0078652399,
0.0005168078,
0.0543150641,
0.0161387008,
-0.0020733553,
-0.0040748459,
-0.0077225715,
-0.0609021746,
-0.0375184193,
-0.0028789034,
-0.0731165707,
0.0112263318,
-0.0197263546,
-0.0076976563,
0.0225560535,
-0.0177373737,
-0.0878978297,
-0.0366723202,
0.0010373219,
0.0018045501,
-0.0479854494,
0.0176954735,
-0.0417114459,
-0.0400156602,
0.0165239815,
0.0152197005,
-0.0312538072,
-0.0046566967,
-0.0199598242,
0.0276322886,
0.0729125813,
0.0103343548,
0.0132410508,
-0.0254498348,
0.0254660007,
0.0988593474,
0.0425628237,
0.0264800806,
-0.0152341165,
-0.02981993,
4.737e-7,
-0.0153213181,
0.0103198588,
0.0013977913,
0.0219214316,
-0.0708201006,
-0.0218063053,
0.0652316734,
0.0142837157,
-0.0402896963,
-0.0061383215,
-0.0291035473,
0.0419980884,
-0.0090213297,
0.0243976433,
-0.0935234278,
-0.0217001047,
0.0118082846,
0.0453918912,
-0.0304360688,
-0.0310623255,
0.0040477985,
-0.1338781863,
0.0037048876,
-0.0074287467,
-0.0207238272,
-0.0094034122,
-0.0397606418,
0.005012108,
0.0009661764,
0.0598493852,
0.0008459713,
0.0265699457,
-0.0098962607,
-0.0021595031,
-0.0044705519,
-0.0197458901,
0.0575949773,
-0.0119399531,
0.0460467078,
0.0853990018,
0.0207721796,
-0.0137787918,
-0.0814837292,
0.036200203,
-0.0244703032,
-0.01165142,
0.024578061,
0.0728198439,
0.0140824215,
0.0050744019,
0.0002193141,
0.0510236137,
0.0023916964,
-0.0139865624,
0.0387237892,
0.0599882156,
-0.0269689355,
-0.0161471926,
-0.0257839672,
0.0113078831,
0.0233124271,
0.0769881308,
0.0133889345,
-0.0240792725,
-0.026552435,
-0.0434938706,
0.0289896019,
-0.0216093305,
-0.0584290139,
0.0488167703,
0.0409911238,
0.0220519807,
-0.065436013,
-0.0386150293,
-0.0072448915,
0.0221439674,
-0.0036532383,
0.0358825475,
-0.0689501464,
0.0159667656,
-0.0180707555,
0.0447061174,
-0.0627791137,
0.0159043204,
-0.0377652235,
-0.0001099143,
0.0139777986,
-0.0229624938,
-0.019974865,
0.0221151356,
-0.0676193684,
-0.0673506856,
0.0293715093,
0.0707950369,
0.0218412019,
0.0525100864,
-0.0334815606,
-0.0413951203,
0.0695559457,
0.0292905364,
-0.0067950161,
0.0023622394,
0.0516482629,
-0.0167918373,
-0.0058793244,
0.0339170434,
-0.0382486209,
-0.0092568137,
0.0292769093,
0.0092741763,
0.0004331267,
0.0139634516,
0.0400328226,
0.0239609666,
0.0441989377,
0.0115966061,
-0.0249461345,
0.0215591453,
0.0070143314,
-0.0058369613,
-0.0030178884,
-0.0070215994,
0.0203239843,
0.0492152721,
-0.0425079875,
0.0242019482,
-0.0349199213,
-0.0046129259,
0.0061477106,
-0.0452685282,
-0.0070405528,
0.0261624064,
0.0224587582,
0.0222942922,
-0.0017918739,
-0.0273323525,
0.0218684226,
0.008016468,
0.0842660144,
-0.0026548763,
0.0525720939,
0.0151481172,
-0.0287461672,
-0.0030974767,
0.0335583501,
-0.0958352908,
-0.0783279911,
-0.0151869971,
0.0526030958,
0.0003156412,
0.0135732852,
0.0115581751,
-0.0225795396,
-0.0070444779,
-0.0226172302,
-0.0192280803,
0.0305510368,
-0.0345827863,
0.0210249536,
0.0185819548,
-0.0005078832,
0.0441662706,
0.0636477396,
-0.0143963173,
0.0542681664,
-0.0029942072,
-0.0165547673,
-0.0312375203,
-0.0497315675,
-0.0119340476,
-0.0237106998,
-0.0121117365,
-0.0071577593,
-0.0198213719,
-0.0808825046,
-0.0484524481,
0.0259725973,
-0.0107576763,
-0.0089556947,
-0.0011086062,
0.0603927821,
-0.0102223791,
-0.0012060159,
-0.0483035743,
0.0559318699,
0.0264799278,
-0.03996953,
0.0153079024,
-6.480008853e-33,
0.009510369,
-0.023943767,
0.0035025282,
-0.035872899,
-0.0017356311,
0.0089372164,
-0.0144922985,
-0.0077173919,
-0.0276007168,
-0.0116372034,
-0.0231313091,
0.0161855686,
0.0066185719,
0.0285002831,
-0.0143668558,
-0.0749885365,
0.0217612665,
0.0043421686,
-0.0413888134,
0.0465484187,
0.0443133712,
0.0204743184,
0.037100181,
-0.0553344823,
0.0696213543,
-0.0370048359,
-0.0188757647,
0.0229840707,
-0.0598095991,
0.0281095132,
-0.0136815766,
0.0307306107,
-0.0044604964,
-0.0435082354,
0.006338214,
0.0344937518,
-0.0508006476,
-0.0179708414,
0.0033720685,
0.0081063965,
-0.0565236211,
-0.0300408565,
0.0282474626,
-0.0269835442,
0.0296709035,
-0.0093245255,
-0.0108341975,
-0.0178865474,
-0.0338684842,
0.0277950335,
-0.0125722205,
0.0084601659,
0.0012581232,
-0.0266133565,
-0.0129083004,
0.0812984556,
0.0162150729,
0.0001409859,
-0.0689105466,
-0.0000991597,
0.0139933908,
-0.0101752514,
0.0508600846,
-0.0005709397,
0.0227093641,
0.0614961125,
0.0341334939,
0.016647622,
-0.0209365897,
-0.0436449535,
0.0074648978,
0.0290036388,
0.0724978521,
0.0514163487,
0.0750960559,
0.0087752771,
-0.0452530235,
0.0125683965,
0.0024092894,
0.0424814671,
0.0489564165,
0.0109228045,
-0.0430648476,
-0.0021283037,
-0.0409918502,
0.0031165751,
-0.0361378416,
-0.0348685943,
0.0422102138,
0.0087124631,
-0.0519713685,
-0.0365206338,
0.0226791333,
-0.0542569645,
0.0100620454,
0.050099045,
-0.0040800381,
-0.0313364677,
-0.0157059524,
0.041519396,
0.0235209502,
0.0219323039,
0.0342300497,
-0.0222585425,
0.0365554169,
0.0206381939,
0.0349491425,
0.0096560968,
-0.0446450859,
0.001487236,
-0.0336695947,
0.0425943062,
0.0121712508,
-0.0118828407,
0.0422496088,
0.0341859162,
-0.0108465785,
0.0021697131,
0.0319001377,
0.0388233475,
-0.0397581272,
0.0057958253,
-0.009561142,
-0.0188538115,
-0.0237225648,
-0.0200393721,
-0.01348319,
0.003872972,
0.0162713546,
-0.0866734311,
0.0144966925,
0.0095184697,
2.859e-7,
0.0079743769,
0.0207577311,
0.0162993092,
0.0151510397,
0.0289644729,
0.0270601399,
-0.0057837996,
0.0282360949,
0.0501340628,
-0.0622699112,
-0.0217920505,
0.0241857991,
0.0906003267,
0.0541533679,
-0.0851455331,
-0.0407267399,
-0.0729910955,
-0.0014000313,
-0.0378438607,
-0.0218692813,
0.0345537998,
0.0940141082,
0.0131715024,
-0.0248906314,
0.0085942149,
-0.0685359761,
0.0536672436,
-0.0213392861,
0.0016933221,
0.0137148239,
0.0715699568,
0.0254577491,
0.0395803452,
0.0382585973,
-0.0137568312,
-0.0324904509,
0.002325577,
-0.0075740973,
0.0203257129,
-0.0842558146,
-0.0516596548,
-0.0219807215,
0.0324165188,
-0.0640283525,
0.1035662666,
-0.0275986157,
-0.0214827508,
-0.005867702,
-0.0272768456,
-0.0511365235,
0.0651606321,
-0.0099086585,
-0.0169924274,
0.0180002954,
-0.0039547393,
0.0261890013,
0.0147871384,
-0.0465778783,
-0.023905037,
-0.0148599073,
-0.0492356382,
-0.0222730078,
-0.0136258639,
-0.0293780789,
-0.0339300111,
-0.065362446,
0.0180801656,
2.676616478e-34,
0.0316121913,
-0.0061032381,
0.050069008,
0.0097431969,
0.0329441689,
-0.0007494924,
0.0655688345,
0.0053658397,
0.0223526377,
-0.0835364237,
-0.0239771102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13024v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13024v1 | Towards Anytime Fine-tuning: Continually Pre-trained Language Models with Hypernetwork Prompt | 2023-10-19T06:34:40 | 2023-10-19T06:34:40 | Gangwei Jiang, Caigao Jiang, Siqiao Xue, James Y. Zhang, Jun Zhou, Defu Lian, Ying Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Continual pre-training has been urgent for adapting a pre-trained model to a
multitude of domains and tasks in the fast-evolving world. In practice, a
continually pre-trained model is expected to demonstrate not only greater
capacity when fine-tuned on pre-trained domains but also a non-decreasing
performance on unseen ones. In this work, we first investigate such anytime
fine-tuning effectiveness of existing continual pre-training approaches,
concluding with unanimously decreased performance on unseen domains. To this
end, we propose a prompt-guided continual pre-training method, where we train a
hypernetwork to generate domain-specific prompts by both agreement and
disagreement losses. The agreement loss maximally preserves the generalization
of a pre-trained model to new domains, and the disagreement one guards the
exclusiveness of the generated hidden states for each domain. Remarkably,
prompts by the hypernetwork alleviate the domain identity when fine-tuning and
promote knowledge transfer across domains. Our method achieved improvements of
3.57% and 3.4% on two real-world datasets (including domain shift and temporal
shift), respectively, demonstrating its efficacy. | [
0.0189201236,
0.0631815344,
-0.0176294651,
-0.006198843,
-0.0291137248,
0.0169757139,
0.0486058667,
-0.0461481139,
-0.0391709246,
-0.0310300421,
-0.0746706724,
-0.0417584144,
-0.0101990681,
0.0391890369,
0.0213884674,
-0.0166719183,
0.0821418315,
-0.0080122082,
-0.0122602731,
-0.0068568778,
-0.0030496828,
-0.0086671738,
-0.0369381681,
0.0403315835,
-0.0219236892,
-0.0225110836,
-0.0309545957,
-0.0021214769,
0.0304600261,
-0.0351426899,
0.0394056104,
0.0724393278,
0.0241432339,
0.00034329,
0.0000021522,
-0.0433794148,
-0.0034187413,
-0.040388193,
-0.0436297394,
0.0087617533,
0.001851437,
0.0036466131,
-0.0319487602,
0.017469449,
-0.0640028045,
-0.0315547995,
0.055044055,
0.0269254483,
0.0516161099,
0.0649935752,
-0.0021548672,
0.0157272872,
0.0241180509,
-0.0604278557,
-0.0398003869,
-0.0756694153,
0.0225671846,
-0.0131749939,
-0.0491390079,
-0.0254548397,
-0.0123642879,
0.0339599513,
0.0336756818,
0.0026860358,
-0.0011767286,
0.0381089672,
-0.0247871056,
-0.0098769711,
-0.0299156979,
0.0763829648,
-0.037332315,
-0.0141401887,
0.0160579383,
-0.018796837,
-0.0027956287,
0.0008864158,
-0.0044288235,
0.006000021,
0.0344834104,
0.0010197861,
-0.0122778844,
0.0235661436,
0.0248155911,
0.0373713337,
-0.0556156188,
0.0347874425,
0.0147114526,
-0.0229826607,
-0.00665823,
0.0077664643,
-0.0534729436,
-0.0651308224,
0.0286061484,
0.0352718718,
-0.0096792281,
0.003410069,
-0.0846117958,
-0.0094238687,
-0.001621813,
0.0079299873,
0.0543990098,
0.0212955512,
-0.0519137643,
0.0378793105,
-0.0246871058,
0.0328692012,
-0.0117143886,
-0.0101277139,
-0.0029699502,
0.0104805119,
-0.0588916764,
-0.0066060824,
-0.0736388117,
0.019587703,
-0.0220638402,
-0.0349822156,
-0.0245159827,
0.0391321555,
-0.0005072866,
-0.0050686137,
-0.0107222116,
-0.0071461527,
-0.0627910271,
-0.0363252647,
-0.0106881009,
0.0429604575,
-0.0449826866,
0.0718806311,
0.044339288,
-0.0552915633,
-0.0308009963,
0.0336849391,
-0.0014984863,
-0.0057839183,
0.0047921492,
0.0897332877,
-0.022290973,
-0.0348903388,
-0.0361139327,
-0.0211740304,
-0.0175434761,
-0.048127301,
0.0164345447,
-0.0209057182,
0.0165996142,
-0.033725962,
-0.0095394831,
-0.0391370021,
-0.0303078722,
-0.0348533541,
0.0147870565,
0.0477319658,
-0.0256741624,
0.0049925535,
0.0366431512,
-0.0082020052,
0.0008193262,
0.0679710284,
0.0172946695,
-0.0170728713,
0.0126134316,
0.011707224,
0.0103391241,
0.041518081,
0.0575059243,
0.019081153,
-0.0115364613,
0.0008506011,
0.0458382592,
0.0240061767,
0.0128250001,
0.0115441373,
-0.0492933765,
0.0087438924,
0.0706018582,
0.0225377493,
0.0107615869,
0.0214868616,
0.0690200701,
-0.0161110256,
0.0020872524,
0.0045837578,
-0.0886226371,
0.0170910917,
-0.024276793,
0.0138786398,
-0.0093488237,
0.0193923954,
-0.0585728139,
-0.0568170212,
0.0493064597,
-0.0154314516,
-0.0063184747,
-0.0031775991,
0.0544776097,
0.0560196564,
-0.0478497967,
0.0641067252,
0.0406564325,
-0.0314243771,
0.0205856953,
-0.0360203423,
0.0091561079,
0.0419091322,
-0.0057951142,
-0.0338817202,
-0.0487993583,
-0.0293139406,
0.0612763017,
0.0417716652,
0.0569981374,
-0.0160270669,
0.0327563435,
-0.0754406676,
-0.0204932,
0.0395350643,
0.0267269406,
0.0582971387,
-0.0018127096,
0.0473835766,
0.0280645192,
0.0230607018,
-0.015485825,
0.0173701718,
-0.0343079418,
0.0099596865,
-0.0038387403,
0.0110264206,
0.014574334,
0.0121558364,
-0.0460705161,
0.0028286774,
-0.0026032818,
-0.0163927376,
-0.0118169989,
-0.0223632082,
-0.0958439857,
-0.0300401431,
0.0129049029,
0.0132180024,
0.0060321842,
0.031280566,
-0.037524946,
-0.0324681923,
-0.0080094216,
0.0451326184,
0.0341054685,
-0.0258932132,
0.0318612233,
-0.0081744865,
0.0265196171,
-0.0526559986,
0.009749379,
0.0146166943,
-0.0222234428,
-0.0047546173,
0.0222886521,
-0.0098658269,
-0.0489149727,
-0.0267754309,
-0.0010900117,
-0.0179293845,
0.017172195,
0.0033347115,
0.0226531196,
-0.0287551004,
-0.0201136563,
-0.0794677213,
-0.0016070736,
-0.0546365902,
0.0301505495,
0.0308750719,
0.0010792187,
-0.0334512144,
-0.0338569768,
-0.0146775991,
0.0374899581,
-0.0230986718,
0.0158856139,
0.0170697682,
0.0192612372,
-0.0071282391,
-0.0460460894,
-0.0179085508,
0.0180031378,
0.0242016129,
-0.0122249937,
-0.0150169767,
-0.0468510799,
0.0427436903,
-0.0496731624,
0.0260206535,
-0.0079377173,
-0.0402503759,
-0.0068578231,
-0.0242112298,
0.0188523196,
0.0695524141,
0.0067210286,
-0.016439002,
0.0614151843,
-0.004387253,
-0.0566635467,
0.0000872222,
-0.0510143973,
-0.0224747192,
-0.0493269712,
0.0648011044,
0.0280135814,
0.0907851905,
0.0101519916,
-0.0228424352,
-0.053627979,
0.0114966379,
-0.0376246348,
-0.0315149315,
-0.0140080918,
-0.0114280088,
-0.0158912651,
0.0425470024,
-0.0109932637,
-0.0544400513,
0.0683741197,
-0.0102332104,
0.0127536012,
-0.0364696681,
-0.0254691858,
0.0211241264,
-0.0009915259,
-0.0185662564,
0.0087274201,
0.0785978734,
-0.0458618551,
-0.0636108518,
-0.0323302746,
0.0278445128,
0.008265472,
0.0577793084,
-0.0334522575,
0.0142042655,
-0.0117066866,
-0.0409373194,
-0.0525649562,
-0.0487829968,
-0.0192900784,
0.0149495415,
-0.0047590821,
-0.0011808312,
-0.0088884905,
-0.0115331821,
-0.0335157514,
0.0957714394,
-0.0442149974,
-0.0158793665,
-0.0322692245,
0.032896515,
0.0246924311,
0.032042142,
0.0317064151,
-0.0144369081,
0.0031181243,
0.0239571426,
0.0244244952,
-0.0109229917,
-0.0321644209,
0.0303622168,
-0.0084582111,
-0.0093731917,
-0.0021240825,
0.0164334811,
0.0597686879,
-0.0473853052,
0.0007750579,
0.1107248813,
0.0155778769,
-0.0566869192,
0.0049561514,
0.0163560882,
0.0311962422,
0.0208997242,
0.0188796688,
-0.0785552859,
-0.0237288363,
0.0176246986,
0.0222562943,
0.0146305161,
-0.0273963045,
-0.0111748651,
-0.0879087821,
-0.0107747726,
0.0207326505,
-0.0053838496,
0.0286542512,
0.0297077037,
0.0008502831,
0.0058275266,
0.0129124112,
-0.0120822731,
0.0250794943,
-0.0273609683,
0.0318522528,
0.0057420828,
-0.0710220113,
0.0360405296,
-0.0282344427,
0.0972157642,
0.0793185756,
0.0005819401,
-0.0023267753,
-0.0257840306,
0.0932087228,
0.0086207381,
0.0198301207,
-0.0168196764,
0.0357502513,
-0.0186218489,
-0.0304373112,
0.0308054853,
0.022756841,
-0.0108894352,
-0.0157223921,
0.0273011122,
0.0490537845,
-0.0166150201,
-0.0056673926,
0.0032891086,
-0.012847797,
0.0506300703,
0.0324570276,
0.0218390115,
-0.0532713123,
0.0161415897,
0.0144405914,
-0.0110226311,
-0.0508357212,
-0.0222107079,
-0.0106647583,
-0.0158344489,
-0.0214653667,
-0.0717930496,
-0.0280747954,
0.0007246065,
0.0663857087,
0.0437710248,
-0.0555881262,
0.0483897105,
0.0206461307,
-0.0270876773,
0.0448932014,
-0.0332587622,
-0.0091944775,
-0.0985081047,
-0.009105688,
0.1095994338,
-0.0141730374,
-0.0206448659,
-0.005604675,
-0.0383845791,
-0.0670924187,
0.000964552,
0.0416388102,
0.0208256282,
0.0756802633,
-0.0254758559,
-0.061176952,
0.0491286404,
0.0186041035,
-0.0569432005,
0.0172812734,
0.0753322318,
-0.0043654586,
-0.013192798,
0.0423186868,
-0.0342459194,
0.0639508441,
0.0581065007,
0.0090837749,
0.0142820543,
-0.0438437387,
-0.0109469611,
-0.0378867835,
0.0766236931,
0.0053606071,
0.0348740183,
-0.0526300259,
0.0282921828,
0.0355882458,
0.0106620034,
-0.0584844351,
0.0225651711,
0.0125839375,
-0.0237998962,
0.006134545,
0.0347080454,
0.0284064971,
0.0188773274,
-0.0313456804,
-0.0134506514,
-0.0242826305,
0.0516512394,
0.0438087881,
0.0213729627,
-0.0235468466,
0.0073091267,
0.0144087998,
0.0068583516,
-0.0412133224,
0.0458888412,
0.0412787199,
0.0196531639,
-0.0445878357,
0.0576175861,
-0.0568773411,
-0.0541891493,
-0.0149847567,
0.0145636862,
0.0603279099,
0.0053203711,
0.0316401161,
-0.0119934771,
0.005640992,
-0.0299434662,
0.0459040068,
0.0202089138,
-0.0056307283,
0.0426711999,
0.0111231739,
-0.0154131819,
0.0351585783,
0.0558853149,
-0.0198461562,
0.0543370917,
0.0076707932,
0.0340592936,
-0.0357103869,
0.0081255669,
-0.0162654836,
0.0262770411,
-0.0356790461,
0.0185577217,
-0.012206451,
-0.0733067393,
0.0219980348,
0.0221930146,
-0.0153874997,
0.0167775825,
0.0391354449,
0.0383541733,
-0.0366393216,
-0.0112719825,
0.0046822829,
-0.0063440693,
0.0400309265,
0.0091770524,
-0.0072817681,
-6.749848724e-33,
-0.0289942622,
0.0193643216,
0.0234134905,
-0.023624694,
-0.0592918433,
-0.0171479993,
-0.0427722335,
0.0112336148,
-0.0284231268,
0.0265531354,
-0.0214154944,
0.0127158267,
0.030141335,
0.0266745165,
0.0055530309,
-0.0345141627,
0.074877128,
-0.0083250562,
-0.02584159,
0.0398702733,
0.0228457563,
0.0260269102,
0.0602774955,
-0.0666216686,
-0.0178617537,
0.0083411997,
-0.0165467374,
0.0280189235,
-0.00160499,
0.0280902088,
0.005843875,
0.0194718502,
-0.0004371633,
-0.0558830909,
-0.0618472733,
0.0248112809,
-0.0978173465,
-0.0554650016,
-0.025644552,
0.0034982048,
-0.006197121,
-0.040692836,
0.018362429,
0.0040932773,
-0.0088694505,
-0.0040533156,
0.0227630902,
-0.018930573,
-0.0419977903,
-0.0584268607,
-0.0602018312,
0.0032289417,
-0.0126268156,
-0.0476342663,
0.0074343341,
0.0207093321,
0.0014682907,
-0.0608079582,
-0.0746733621,
0.0367284007,
0.0267700255,
0.0254442953,
0.0417448021,
0.0068586054,
0.0116281155,
0.0436670557,
0.0273083989,
0.0231807418,
0.049461294,
0.0123005453,
0.0731414184,
-0.0070701069,
-0.0137809059,
0.0004646074,
0.0047946107,
-0.0764773712,
-0.041446086,
-0.039140448,
-0.0194246769,
-0.0099706613,
0.023945909,
-0.0011594999,
0.0107676182,
-0.0166141633,
-0.045208659,
0.0021666577,
-0.0249249712,
-0.0234631989,
0.0484607965,
0.035728056,
-0.01006334,
0.0130113689,
0.0484820493,
-0.046642106,
-0.0253686272,
0.0423529297,
0.001295776,
0.0313969739,
-0.0010078879,
-0.0057248273,
-0.0625801012,
-0.0194672979,
-0.0115848156,
0.0247157458,
0.0138984099,
0.0077086315,
0.018177595,
0.0507065989,
-0.069393307,
-0.0238242354,
-0.005368345,
0.0194475893,
0.0542586371,
0.0406774357,
0.0238738079,
0.0160186868,
-0.022786092,
0.0851009861,
-0.0134501457,
-0.0813672319,
-0.0248298198,
0.0821091011,
0.0289102178,
0.0730652288,
-0.043893192,
-0.0157088488,
-0.0435789563,
0.0175420213,
0.0313423909,
-0.0503788292,
-0.026471328,
0.0028350155,
2.874e-7,
-0.0218374096,
0.0201591011,
0.0243957005,
-0.0334164649,
0.0278077163,
0.0287191663,
-0.0206388719,
0.0152128059,
0.0005981248,
0.0108397063,
0.016835263,
0.0436542109,
0.0178153459,
-0.0080994824,
-0.0752496496,
-0.0228423513,
-0.011563478,
0.032995075,
-0.0430358574,
-0.0127535872,
0.0403713994,
0.0696256161,
0.0153247509,
0.0156208333,
0.0190985426,
-0.0119017493,
0.0473582186,
0.0187804699,
0.0248513818,
0.0366332084,
-0.0371501036,
0.0106159495,
-0.0367431045,
0.0403236188,
-0.0141103789,
0.0345861316,
-0.0376036018,
0.058598876,
-0.0070679234,
-0.0261262357,
-0.0062874407,
0.010917752,
-0.0174841546,
0.0071066278,
0.0697195977,
-0.1360588521,
-0.0058602886,
-0.0155643607,
0.0135099562,
-0.0236176345,
0.0055313366,
-0.0044035786,
-0.0163185038,
0.0149977114,
0.0229553171,
0.0495903306,
-0.0313897692,
-0.1251665652,
0.0438987166,
0.0286765527,
-0.0394869298,
-0.052813638,
-0.0325693265,
-0.0310039278,
0.0476574861,
-0.0346008651,
0.0202353969,
2.348973372e-34,
0.0209465176,
-0.0199850872,
0.0307412706,
0.0353202708,
-0.0300963577,
-0.0095486576,
0.0063091675,
-0.0090516992,
0.0279688239,
-0.0651536509,
-0.0201081894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13023v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13023v3 | GraphGPT: Graph Instruction Tuning for Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T06:17:46 | 2024-05-07T10:10:14 | Jiabin Tang, Yuhao Yang, Wei Wei, Lei Shi, Lixin Su, Suqi Cheng, Dawei Yin, Chao Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have evolved to understand graph structures
through recursive exchanges and aggregations among nodes. To enhance
robustness, self-supervised learning (SSL) has become a vital tool for data
augmentation. Traditional methods often depend on fine-tuning with
task-specific labels, limiting their effectiveness when labeled data is scarce.
Our research tackles this by advancing graph model generalization in zero-shot
learning environments. Inspired by the success of large language models (LLMs),
we aim to create a graph-oriented LLM capable of exceptional generalization
across various datasets and tasks without relying on downstream graph data. We
introduce the GraphGPT framework, which integrates LLMs with graph structural
knowledge through graph instruction tuning. This framework includes a
text-graph grounding component to link textual and graph structures and a
dual-stage instruction tuning approach with a lightweight graph-text alignment
projector. These innovations allow LLMs to comprehend complex graph structures
and enhance adaptability across diverse datasets and tasks. Our framework
demonstrates superior generalization in both supervised and zero-shot graph
learning tasks, surpassing existing benchmarks. The open-sourced model
implementation of our GraphGPT is available at
https://github.com/HKUDS/GraphGPT. | [
0.0062053064,
0.0427909307,
0.0212464035,
0.0531477369,
-0.025796162,
0.0020620187,
-0.0140534677,
-0.0102092735,
0.0525053144,
-0.0292314459,
-0.0329592898,
-0.005572326,
-0.0110675637,
0.0149612129,
0.0468559638,
0.0014300998,
0.0344314501,
0.0104772653,
-0.0127922865,
-0.0082021309,
0.0109211244,
0.0548986271,
0.0226107761,
-0.0122099156,
-0.0112500992,
-0.0330176651,
-0.0199005231,
0.0584150553,
-0.0098256506,
-0.0481684655,
-0.0101126581,
0.0326863341,
0.0356868096,
0.0692813322,
0.0000019941,
-0.0097936587,
-0.0184458923,
0.0104303202,
-0.0424600504,
0.01843578,
0.0391354449,
-0.0313943624,
0.0120970979,
-0.0144868819,
-0.0327036567,
-0.0490953699,
0.0704743713,
0.0092803603,
0.0648322776,
0.1039891988,
-0.0136786895,
-0.0255140923,
0.0176044255,
-0.0439529307,
0.0174196493,
-0.0458660647,
0.0232786499,
0.0184855983,
-0.0014746621,
0.0099739553,
-0.0682398602,
0.0116656153,
0.0153391659,
-0.0166414455,
0.068582207,
0.0287759621,
-0.0199353918,
0.0017958635,
-0.0075739948,
0.1230024695,
-0.0114560239,
-0.0379613526,
-0.003839962,
-0.0422263779,
0.0018327767,
-0.0140781803,
-0.0471866205,
-0.0331040807,
0.0309556536,
0.0266987607,
-0.0320546739,
-0.0552406572,
0.0770992041,
-0.0140997795,
0.0067626294,
0.0978175774,
-0.0005443461,
0.0141235609,
0.0058200471,
0.0075022844,
-0.019897718,
-0.0370545164,
-0.030507654,
0.0566697083,
-0.0123086171,
0.0157245491,
-0.0311236344,
-0.0176058747,
-0.0115214977,
-0.0117972186,
0.0760547295,
0.0180540793,
0.0101863258,
0.0378039442,
-0.0127552487,
0.039999105,
-0.0356567837,
0.077837199,
-0.0404947363,
0.0021129115,
-0.0465882868,
0.0139812827,
-0.0492576919,
0.0177979134,
0.0019285131,
-0.0376474448,
-0.0433172286,
0.0561405346,
-0.0009500496,
0.0062853247,
0.0427608192,
0.0139102964,
-0.0268595237,
-0.0338503979,
0.0421643555,
0.0602239482,
0.0085681239,
-0.0137643274,
-0.0158763286,
-0.0140736531,
-0.0346006267,
0.0123947933,
0.06457939,
-0.0355592631,
0.0222428907,
0.0776589885,
0.0224767961,
-0.0400924869,
-0.0307540838,
0.0145067433,
-0.0332585797,
-0.0639934838,
0.0137755303,
-0.071118556,
0.0283099432,
0.0203193538,
-0.0075905262,
-0.0543724522,
0.0250115544,
-0.0077681099,
-0.0385246277,
0.0582312606,
-0.0372313559,
0.0003477955,
-0.0062048114,
-0.0254818704,
0.005564441,
0.0507001132,
0.0366353095,
0.0162111949,
0.0252156258,
-0.0205524135,
-0.0190300588,
0.0360084325,
0.0467450395,
0.0186146367,
-0.0093524363,
0.0024977138,
-0.0185140613,
0.0016477876,
0.0193245076,
0.031172961,
-0.0275373254,
-0.0305496119,
0.0528942458,
0.0370573737,
0.0007429232,
-0.0107967891,
0.039522171,
0.0448271297,
-0.0161714386,
0.009881814,
-0.0679235086,
0.0289226528,
0.0010107269,
0.0248360187,
-0.0107006226,
-0.0155153526,
-0.0348042287,
-0.016485136,
-0.0102450466,
-0.0121657932,
0.0758855343,
0.0029032708,
0.0565636158,
0.0239989478,
-0.0413384587,
0.0042715245,
0.0462461561,
-0.0288241953,
0.0030565029,
0.0025828392,
-0.018803807,
0.054399956,
0.033106491,
-0.0098972041,
-0.0784102529,
0.0106258206,
0.0246629268,
0.0174432825,
0.0155689884,
-0.0168021787,
0.0226947684,
-0.0571491644,
-0.0415968746,
-0.0617888942,
-0.0057396544,
0.0179137141,
0.0183124151,
-0.0324272066,
0.0148465922,
-0.0833799765,
-0.0436931364,
0.0145364888,
-0.0006774667,
-0.0334331207,
0.0172935948,
0.0008524744,
-0.02253302,
0.0198086333,
-0.0049361642,
0.0072201542,
0.014435159,
0.0243533235,
-0.0218617115,
-0.0355440602,
-0.0477772467,
-0.0335077569,
0.0574218035,
-0.0098228296,
-0.0375209376,
-0.0094046434,
-0.0794440806,
-0.0499349125,
0.0666476712,
-0.0529676788,
0.01946087,
0.000208264,
0.0075500044,
-0.0179692023,
0.0195006393,
0.0090839826,
0.0287547298,
0.0231314693,
-0.0134220859,
-0.0182202403,
0.0323981717,
-0.0026364103,
-0.0491970144,
-0.0108878864,
-0.0102331582,
-0.0000848766,
0.0272564534,
0.0272723697,
0.0220224205,
-0.0457848646,
0.0352487974,
-0.0908050463,
0.0266706813,
-0.0147871561,
0.0313668363,
0.04116809,
0.0141387777,
0.0015564971,
-0.0545262471,
-0.0451978184,
0.0437124521,
0.0058099916,
0.0080028912,
0.047776103,
-0.0196898524,
-0.0095503824,
-0.0340442024,
-0.0588882528,
-0.0476043262,
0.0582802556,
0.0178850479,
-0.0347429551,
-0.0062887119,
0.0222774409,
-0.0421845764,
0.0247930344,
0.0000220756,
-0.0084651783,
-0.0063815387,
-0.010970111,
0.0134358304,
0.0817067176,
-0.0560974665,
0.0124103706,
0.0431266166,
-0.0053799255,
-0.021231506,
-0.006797669,
-0.0519261397,
-0.016370913,
-0.0394030623,
0.0171235539,
-0.0516426079,
0.0692811087,
-0.0236544572,
-0.0209168084,
-0.0506638959,
-0.008492643,
-0.0199416373,
0.0215801969,
-0.0143877072,
-0.0074536875,
0.009805535,
-0.030725725,
-0.0661427379,
-0.0336934105,
0.072099492,
-0.0288097635,
-0.0341365784,
0.0331113376,
-0.0286526904,
-0.0721235797,
0.0564821698,
0.0882698148,
0.0148507599,
-0.0062938156,
-0.0227606408,
-0.0531208739,
-0.0108141256,
0.0388991013,
-0.0101188114,
0.0230182763,
0.0102700349,
0.0245387759,
-0.0019879271,
-0.0302062351,
-0.0020207129,
0.0106285382,
-0.0120162116,
0.0182545073,
-0.0108419992,
-0.0539118722,
0.0033019152,
-0.0368699878,
-0.0124333994,
0.0534828417,
-0.0380587168,
0.0154761821,
-0.0469709188,
0.0268962495,
0.0449589826,
-0.0354933031,
-0.0080650011,
-0.0309586357,
-0.0135712605,
0.0479475372,
0.0313247815,
-0.0292434711,
-0.0356545188,
0.022888476,
0.0052387821,
-0.0134303831,
0.0010318439,
-0.0093743308,
0.0569637269,
-0.0563109256,
-0.001063314,
0.0762241408,
0.0071615791,
-0.0518530533,
-0.0078454567,
-0.0007428927,
0.020872809,
0.0413138345,
0.0210078731,
-0.0968635082,
-0.0229324326,
-0.0227921288,
0.0319825113,
0.04818983,
-0.0336665772,
-0.0295981672,
-0.1106488183,
-0.0008945445,
0.0550839007,
-0.0161169041,
-0.0084298924,
-0.0623082109,
-0.0076215025,
-0.0420331508,
0.0171842966,
-0.013197761,
-0.0236165319,
0.0011841508,
0.0038595612,
-0.0107347444,
-0.0275025014,
0.0114936884,
-0.0206911843,
0.0179635566,
0.0015936003,
0.018978674,
0.028527936,
0.0204081181,
0.0644153282,
0.024087958,
-0.036974147,
0.0052485634,
0.0637585297,
-0.0227498244,
-0.000578585,
-0.0034889788,
0.0386075862,
-0.0299957804,
0.000183977,
-0.0388956852,
0.0841822475,
0.0313052572,
-0.0220350567,
0.0225558318,
-0.0302382652,
-0.0222053193,
-0.0007817422,
0.0536070243,
0.0027856019,
-0.0530618578,
-0.0411831588,
0.0067082038,
-0.0675122514,
-0.0457278714,
0.0382919163,
-0.0357164368,
0.0030591898,
-0.0099156192,
-0.0296447109,
0.029502077,
-0.0133646987,
-0.004152786,
-0.0176629443,
0.0378312059,
-0.0504011624,
-0.1006779,
0.0169839785,
-0.0683617964,
0.0104566626,
-0.0196312051,
-0.0106282635,
0.013475623,
0.0053650448,
0.017977871,
0.0109141851,
-0.1097039059,
-0.1098809466,
-0.0287925452,
0.0148157431,
0.0065459632,
0.0868153125,
-0.0270083025,
-0.0291380528,
0.0416848771,
0.0474624112,
-0.0102518741,
-0.006600671,
0.030071063,
-0.0397927649,
-0.0129553843,
0.0410200022,
-0.0444591567,
0.0444094501,
0.0551333092,
0.0293978564,
-0.0029204495,
-0.0191914309,
0.019366568,
0.0586965568,
0.0380328186,
0.0258682966,
0.0516218171,
-0.0497413091,
-0.020556489,
-0.0237074215,
-0.0200779419,
-0.0189819708,
-0.0362403877,
0.0221879352,
-0.0206169598,
-0.0059046643,
-0.0286549199,
-0.0029200774,
0.0487418585,
-0.0485906713,
-0.0085959835,
-0.0083812587,
-0.0400962569,
0.0555086359,
0.0151739651,
0.0091553489,
0.0542817935,
0.0294390246,
0.0170752592,
-0.0151510518,
0.0114949923,
0.0195339322,
0.0066478001,
-0.0558564626,
0.0107383151,
-0.0533689894,
-0.0036673718,
-0.0561575443,
0.013566195,
0.0584547371,
0.0092701744,
0.0698866397,
-0.0070470357,
-0.0201759599,
-0.0299463402,
0.0569253378,
-0.028290268,
-0.0458263531,
0.0126607232,
0.0323640294,
-0.0123145459,
0.0393939875,
0.0402755551,
0.0800988972,
0.0302433521,
0.0387790948,
-0.0135503886,
-0.0254287366,
-0.0227612536,
-0.0184049718,
0.0125743821,
-0.0126014072,
0.003271105,
-0.0238397811,
-0.1103638858,
0.0010401485,
-0.0002650741,
-0.0082175266,
0.0113707408,
0.0086088274,
0.0053460915,
0.0092732543,
-0.001843767,
-0.0229876488,
0.0541755818,
0.0144235315,
-0.0178587958,
0.0192279089,
-6.478786338e-33,
-0.0174900088,
-0.0618034527,
0.0149128372,
0.0165990107,
-0.0334931165,
0.0258391369,
-0.054089997,
0.0107443677,
-0.0248982385,
0.0253991429,
-0.0084054191,
0.0295113884,
-0.0008084903,
0.0422045588,
-0.0230635591,
-0.0136819053,
0.0330476314,
-0.0068837157,
-0.0068834228,
0.0359278843,
0.0125215892,
0.0280090813,
0.0729911476,
-0.0465558916,
0.012100691,
-0.0269520953,
0.0205423404,
0.0267449208,
0.0414337963,
0.0302953981,
0.0021378195,
0.051016815,
0.0287434589,
0.00758463,
-0.0145294638,
0.004658455,
-0.0970323682,
-0.0391397923,
0.0013134761,
0.0238490999,
-0.0662047043,
-0.0225741267,
0.0522767901,
-0.0159783103,
-0.0006925375,
-0.046024628,
0.0301615912,
0.0302799046,
-0.0234078728,
0.0465723872,
-0.0552574918,
0.0325153656,
-0.0038764493,
-0.0015264559,
0.0302778035,
-0.0125814117,
0.0260521788,
0.0257187989,
-0.0710915104,
0.01546878,
-0.0585311018,
0.0265765619,
0.0463775806,
0.0398674421,
0.0097294049,
0.0242648143,
0.0167149361,
0.001804776,
-0.0375733376,
0.0150828473,
0.0273658056,
0.0433989018,
0.011709258,
0.010943329,
-0.0010010898,
0.0084654503,
-0.0896556675,
-0.0372559652,
-0.0019608187,
0.0219862107,
-0.0245491378,
0.0412893109,
0.0035977119,
-0.0390856415,
-0.0176632479,
-0.0643920377,
-0.0400371961,
-0.0301131252,
-0.0125744995,
-0.0126490267,
-0.0433965363,
0.0449815877,
-0.0041334964,
-0.0655756891,
-0.0183673222,
0.0748757049,
-0.036249496,
0.0434239656,
-0.0014701305,
0.0516800024,
-0.060162317,
-0.0251418184,
0.0084485868,
0.0018953989,
0.0192359295,
0.0147515954,
0.0771608055,
0.0315030739,
-0.0336906016,
-0.012039667,
-0.055171147,
-0.0250119101,
-0.029415898,
0.0171050318,
0.0457987562,
0.0532813109,
-0.0121843815,
0.0860642567,
0.0650647506,
0.0464939922,
-0.0003068147,
0.0100236731,
-0.005271377,
0.017892113,
-0.0056868871,
0.0002765179,
-0.0229604822,
0.0252727196,
0.0351886749,
-0.0770201758,
-0.0222374368,
-0.0228642989,
2.713e-7,
0.0660287812,
0.0545810945,
0.0651572719,
0.031783659,
0.0188360773,
0.0277146213,
-0.0246710591,
0.0440726168,
-0.007472727,
-0.0376154706,
0.0394895263,
0.066277191,
-0.0119465133,
0.0065295743,
-0.0453063026,
0.0523174889,
-0.097933881,
0.0138191581,
-0.024673922,
0.0150465453,
-0.0221010558,
0.0772889331,
0.0534344986,
0.0028618325,
-0.0102710295,
-0.0434281677,
0.0549104176,
0.0192660578,
-0.0108183371,
0.0244528204,
-0.0252543036,
0.0145771028,
-0.0420254692,
-0.00737437,
-0.0124182394,
0.0393218771,
0.0131764645,
0.0436409712,
-0.0528435297,
0.0162335914,
0.004339539,
-0.0077753812,
-0.0016057907,
-0.004227859,
0.0759563446,
-0.0853254646,
-0.0529875569,
-0.0274753571,
-0.0303184539,
0.0009273876,
0.037198104,
0.0001425302,
-0.011658405,
0.021419879,
0.0456316136,
-0.0171707422,
-0.025236303,
-0.0522309728,
-0.0237003751,
0.0102800876,
0.0115206931,
-0.0221847966,
-0.0117568681,
0.0129005229,
0.0187684018,
-0.0069311336,
0.0201736167,
2.533484659e-34,
0.0341077261,
-0.0075547616,
-0.0036076694,
-0.0388851278,
0.0138314683,
-0.0321979411,
-0.0536288098,
0.0182772353,
0.0204343442,
-0.0793081224,
-0.0229186509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12505v1 | Attack Prompt Generation for Red Teaming and Defending Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T06:15:05 | 2023-10-19T06:15:05 | Boyi Deng, Wenjie Wang, Fuli Feng, Yang Deng, Qifan Wang, Xiangnan He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are susceptible to red teaming attacks, which
can induce LLMs to generate harmful content. Previous research constructs
attack prompts via manual or automatic methods, which have their own
limitations on construction cost and quality. To address these issues, we
propose an integrated approach that combines manual and automatic methods to
economically generate high-quality attack prompts. Specifically, considering
the impressive capabilities of newly emerged LLMs, we propose an attack
framework to instruct LLMs to mimic human-generated prompts through in-context
learning. Furthermore, we propose a defense framework that fine-tunes victim
LLMs through iterative interactions with the attack framework to enhance their
safety against red teaming attacks. Extensive experiments on different LLMs
validate the effectiveness of our proposed attack and defense frameworks.
Additionally, we release a series of attack prompts datasets named SAP with
varying sizes, facilitating the safety evaluation and enhancement of more LLMs.
Our code and dataset is available on https://github.com/Aatrox103/SAP . | [
0.0247124992,
0.0445987098,
-0.007498384,
0.0338080749,
-0.050922025,
-0.0305479821,
0.0476000085,
-0.011612867,
-0.0337973125,
-0.0385101698,
-0.014935473,
-0.0051356871,
-0.0106898556,
0.0437582433,
0.0454319045,
-0.0130326683,
0.0450781807,
-0.0426830165,
-0.0140669001,
-0.0178212132,
0.014193451,
-0.0039966209,
-0.0060816603,
0.0436839499,
-0.0095255589,
-0.0113756498,
-0.0380478464,
0.0144877369,
0.0363585055,
-0.041860871,
0.019340042,
0.0380319133,
0.0028539612,
0.0432347842,
0.0000019253,
-0.0607614405,
-0.0589461289,
0.003860615,
-0.04532234,
0.0523868799,
0.0092842141,
-0.0227138419,
-0.0451188162,
0.0347656533,
-0.0282169767,
0.0155316303,
0.0362062939,
0.0655162409,
0.1105808616,
0.1037849411,
0.0215046108,
0.0079241013,
0.0038935551,
-0.029745426,
-0.0292651262,
-0.0245765913,
0.0244481917,
-0.0340650789,
0.0046609952,
0.0364044197,
0.0169797447,
-0.0353375226,
0.015401558,
-0.0223883353,
-0.068502143,
0.0087670684,
-0.0233037267,
0.0060490319,
-0.0136676459,
0.0312558934,
-0.050676398,
-0.0129858227,
-0.0113616148,
-0.0021636833,
0.0154092591,
0.0122770006,
-0.000679426,
0.0391154625,
-0.0116230482,
-0.0045553651,
0.0105630085,
0.0054522762,
0.0303505063,
-0.0034566633,
0.0003717896,
0.0213761274,
0.0058956803,
-0.0446722209,
-0.0208843872,
-0.0603684224,
-0.0013795417,
-0.0541293472,
-0.0117918095,
0.0133347837,
-0.0307826474,
0.020450497,
-0.0905164182,
-0.0624907054,
0.0617058165,
-0.0253573079,
0.0432933904,
0.02709122,
-0.0161921009,
0.0061987452,
-0.0278950147,
0.0262111351,
-0.0080422824,
0.0106252301,
0.0209009033,
0.0085425451,
-0.0292011909,
0.0032434964,
-0.0192585345,
0.0180812422,
0.0135422414,
0.012045416,
-0.0473570675,
0.0637706667,
-0.0579838678,
0.0523713678,
-0.0170315336,
-0.0321462341,
-0.0199640524,
0.0072608637,
0.0201728623,
-0.0585589707,
-0.0150822755,
-0.0258879513,
-0.0170956701,
-0.1015982702,
-0.0212050676,
0.0106213363,
-0.0626173839,
-0.0279309675,
-0.0120773138,
0.1032504514,
0.0230659563,
-0.0053675519,
-0.0286026411,
-0.0963988826,
0.0029072275,
0.0176091269,
-0.0107930778,
-0.0708902329,
-0.033919435,
-0.0128119551,
-0.0271178093,
-0.0566762201,
0.0090183951,
0.0141344555,
-0.0135484105,
0.0684708953,
-0.0168472826,
-0.011238819,
0.0013522663,
0.0183060784,
-0.0175089743,
0.0710334852,
-0.0077134641,
0.0436746739,
0.0360981002,
-0.0152681991,
0.0437809452,
0.0703312904,
0.004100767,
0.050622467,
-0.0247519948,
0.0006118873,
0.0655200183,
-0.0232343003,
0.0094772018,
0.0280803684,
-0.0098886676,
-0.052659329,
0.0721722841,
0.0146256564,
-0.0184149649,
0.0602054372,
0.0510288179,
0.0283519831,
-0.0137199769,
-0.0001474032,
-0.0314543024,
0.0004568603,
-0.0806907639,
-0.0212455466,
0.0004720964,
0.0339848027,
-0.0026302547,
0.0141470656,
-0.0030520128,
-0.0197694656,
-0.0161268525,
0.0098229116,
0.0170604605,
0.0492488295,
-0.0250331778,
0.029341707,
0.0326162204,
-0.0130230803,
-0.0241627954,
-0.074264884,
-0.0064826426,
0.0282472298,
0.0556771979,
-0.042347528,
-0.0238897633,
-0.0336199328,
-0.0096685952,
0.0450761057,
0.0351288579,
0.0068693804,
-0.0256161708,
-0.0372712128,
-0.0296243541,
-0.0352861024,
0.005012929,
0.0171017889,
0.02273353,
-0.0386437438,
0.0054691932,
0.0448432863,
-0.042264685,
0.0260838568,
0.0202237703,
-0.0184868649,
0.0061617391,
0.0219964944,
0.0662542805,
0.0040180958,
-0.0278134458,
0.0328160003,
0.0437409505,
0.0156621952,
0.0014546141,
-0.0080382107,
0.0085828025,
0.0083768321,
0.0205018315,
0.0013982799,
-0.0007575201,
0.0420146137,
-0.0351726748,
0.0018477953,
0.0460458137,
-0.0604015552,
0.0053242617,
-0.0123245362,
0.0119635286,
0.0029042282,
0.0470048487,
-0.0332779624,
0.0306524765,
-0.0042864219,
-0.0094680609,
-0.0014099295,
0.021764908,
0.0211343654,
-0.0583501719,
-0.017184712,
-0.0174162313,
-0.0551442765,
0.0224377979,
0.0245546363,
0.0136375651,
-0.0115629602,
-0.0146879265,
-0.0237763803,
0.0043513863,
-0.0137505131,
0.0144170476,
0.0491139591,
-0.001527595,
-0.0395565331,
-0.0204665978,
-0.0068112072,
-0.002680457,
-0.0089203967,
0.0284480881,
0.00627155,
-0.0336129032,
-0.058410529,
-0.0183205958,
-0.005132047,
-0.009968224,
0.0576439202,
-0.0044508893,
-0.0364917181,
-0.0441161655,
0.0392147638,
-0.0093216486,
0.019118337,
-0.0021676854,
-0.0589790531,
0.0376742743,
-0.0212153383,
0.0189360995,
0.0342504941,
0.0467853099,
0.039611835,
0.0747469291,
0.0081866849,
-0.0695018247,
-0.0153540233,
-0.0175416321,
-0.0317086168,
-0.0322823152,
-0.0480287187,
0.047390148,
0.0781918466,
0.0415683948,
-0.0083713327,
-0.0179537479,
0.0006309961,
0.0216870271,
-0.0096788192,
-0.0078509785,
-0.0651706532,
-0.0253330655,
0.0230681021,
-0.0072866846,
-0.0598694235,
0.0896415487,
-0.0440713242,
0.0315532759,
-0.0452919863,
-0.0215698201,
0.0112574901,
0.0226578433,
-0.010118477,
0.0228652172,
0.0313898176,
-0.0087445816,
-0.0364767686,
-0.0243562777,
0.0479501747,
-0.0062955581,
0.0174353048,
-0.036882896,
-0.0050604679,
-0.0007108824,
0.0027581768,
-0.0786374956,
-0.0623964183,
-0.0456967168,
-0.010509355,
-0.0166743733,
-0.0150466012,
-0.0329178385,
-0.0230047554,
0.0586073138,
0.0007484236,
-0.0036219382,
-0.0132664209,
-0.0105957631,
-0.0038714046,
0.0283742491,
-0.0576761775,
0.0001666344,
-0.0461431779,
0.0339608938,
0.081089817,
0.0386541411,
0.0107456008,
-0.0296800137,
-0.0130535392,
0.0440903418,
-0.0246224832,
0.0039608004,
0.0256892368,
0.015076655,
-0.04674742,
-0.010321334,
0.0678635761,
0.0350456908,
-0.015679149,
0.0205217935,
-0.0303490534,
0.0289031863,
0.0162307639,
0.0211984348,
-0.0792831331,
-0.0153323421,
0.0136533296,
0.0449107327,
-0.0445959792,
-0.0148619991,
-0.0252686925,
-0.138569966,
0.010356361,
0.0076199239,
-0.0503392741,
0.009482678,
-0.0400111042,
-0.004326541,
0.0506523028,
0.0174154844,
-0.0009098504,
0.0207670908,
0.0037005995,
0.029263638,
-0.0353834257,
-0.0451702252,
0.0119201755,
-0.0498720482,
0.0751584247,
0.0794100985,
-0.0076860324,
-0.024703173,
0.0090482328,
0.0670905188,
-0.0171133187,
0.0023652255,
0.014985037,
0.0134776272,
0.0222992655,
-0.0307862274,
0.0122394199,
0.0432260185,
0.0096657258,
-0.0311674345,
0.0646805167,
0.0442632437,
-0.0380744711,
0.0191385131,
-0.0282384921,
0.0088023013,
0.0592220947,
0.0572017357,
0.0469984673,
-0.0536730513,
0.0091893561,
-0.0770154819,
-0.0001634335,
-0.0622592643,
-0.0498439483,
0.0289600864,
-0.0313462391,
-0.0453545228,
-0.0538169183,
-0.023025725,
0.0009400273,
0.0235140417,
0.0383299105,
-0.0365434922,
-0.0528996326,
0.0162706878,
-0.0259387121,
-0.0165325999,
-0.0443177223,
0.0571055375,
-0.0659503639,
0.0142123876,
-0.0227520671,
-0.0560871139,
-0.0162319541,
0.014790507,
-0.0396480896,
-0.0911464542,
0.0207605548,
0.0768927261,
0.0268673077,
0.00231404,
-0.0467540473,
-0.0867854506,
0.0808533803,
0.0518135652,
-0.037547268,
-0.0145458281,
0.0700495467,
-0.0236752555,
0.0173748527,
0.0141407689,
-0.0394426174,
0.0122612389,
0.0636171699,
-0.0101268534,
-0.0485107414,
-0.0273230951,
0.0358827487,
0.0509167835,
0.039914906,
-0.043418359,
0.0054547829,
0.0212565437,
0.0221638493,
-0.0205784626,
-0.0416642278,
0.033299055,
0.0521199703,
0.0010671741,
-0.0307207685,
0.0510392711,
0.0160979852,
-0.0262819156,
0.0181016922,
0.0014703383,
0.0308004487,
0.0652279109,
0.0533829741,
0.0834363252,
-0.0025664123,
-0.0083727865,
0.0141839348,
0.0265913978,
0.0113799023,
0.0299523976,
0.0572624542,
0.0021627888,
-0.009388933,
-0.0013132876,
0.0385192595,
-0.042531766,
-0.0476108827,
0.0402577184,
0.0317761898,
0.0393373147,
0.0423855595,
0.0248086508,
-0.0320065282,
-0.0083145276,
-0.0222850796,
0.0002699538,
-0.0042889705,
-0.0645965189,
0.0337749645,
0.015778916,
0.0017566334,
0.0349677913,
0.0750875399,
-0.0313117169,
0.0588288046,
0.0107931951,
-0.0316271819,
-0.0460880101,
-0.0002075759,
0.0046976358,
0.0275482908,
-0.0556755289,
-0.0391320176,
-0.0752629787,
-0.0615710132,
0.0018751448,
0.0361535661,
0.0362946801,
0.0318858661,
0.0015866037,
0.0432885848,
-0.0179030076,
0.0729972497,
-0.078354761,
0.0524261817,
-0.0138858324,
-0.0640666187,
0.026715748,
-5.335331923e-33,
0.0304106437,
-0.0387111418,
-0.0198553782,
-0.0060151955,
0.0273693819,
0.035889145,
-0.0349655189,
-0.0002723497,
-0.0040462548,
-0.0078961793,
0.0071855229,
-0.0397396274,
0.0066811056,
0.0197932161,
-0.0382592715,
-0.0126271462,
0.0027448672,
-0.0032021983,
-0.0330599248,
0.0240884405,
0.0742029995,
-0.0152344648,
0.002805968,
-0.0771321282,
0.0302733481,
-0.0196806137,
-0.0399553031,
0.0228243414,
-0.0386255197,
0.0694381893,
0.006367051,
0.0350645892,
-0.0039535654,
-0.0289470907,
-0.0112388898,
0.0541217774,
0.0203321278,
-0.0159849394,
-0.0150006553,
-0.0262565799,
-0.0192596726,
-0.049327489,
0.0044083036,
-0.0067233378,
0.0005095129,
0.009706418,
0.0113587622,
-0.0156740788,
-0.0210043378,
-0.022682989,
-0.0322976299,
0.0114116501,
-0.0275144596,
-0.0312314443,
-0.0136145465,
0.0312750638,
0.0470781103,
-0.0093584508,
-0.0300119761,
0.0590043664,
-0.018052116,
-0.0011789384,
0.0544194989,
0.0192973521,
-0.0146499444,
0.0506312139,
-0.0224715732,
0.0131364306,
0.0142253228,
0.0156128993,
-0.0138763944,
0.0439000539,
0.0657846853,
0.071976468,
-0.0088488227,
-0.0178262051,
-0.0565564409,
0.036917083,
0.0713807046,
0.0179562103,
0.0422808416,
-0.0105421366,
-0.0523428023,
0.0115663186,
-0.0025578428,
-0.0280574113,
-0.0205186922,
-0.034238454,
0.0121870041,
0.0049183657,
-0.0613695309,
-0.0025176881,
0.0137052555,
-0.0106407646,
0.0125659527,
0.0414339155,
-0.0284028221,
-0.0174639169,
-0.0181687213,
-0.0066674752,
0.0123837916,
-0.003767272,
0.0124704912,
-0.0853947103,
0.0264595207,
-0.0048143836,
0.0475357324,
0.0349890888,
-0.0645911694,
-0.0003024896,
-0.0509281009,
0.0770037174,
0.0060672793,
-0.0005817326,
0.0262850691,
-0.0080705844,
0.001892617,
-0.0068344595,
0.0451767407,
-0.0603297725,
-0.0176946707,
0.0403428376,
-0.0412654169,
0.0136304013,
-0.0170807261,
0.0169383846,
0.0029095591,
0.0349872485,
0.0334138609,
-0.0510303155,
-0.0108607532,
-0.040952757,
2.649e-7,
-0.0099871857,
0.0106015205,
0.0556427687,
0.0329125784,
0.0181353614,
0.0863833576,
-0.0158430152,
0.0746973157,
0.0020196959,
-0.0243771896,
-0.038538862,
0.0096981544,
0.0387909412,
0.0497785322,
-0.0593638942,
0.0095800133,
-0.0783564225,
0.0103246756,
-0.0842619687,
-0.0088369772,
0.0687303841,
0.0750099197,
0.0325589627,
-0.0375706181,
-0.004127678,
-0.0419156067,
0.0137598366,
-0.0128377546,
-0.020335393,
0.0117000043,
0.0311636813,
-0.0049424963,
-0.0113825966,
0.0504472293,
-0.0462500453,
-0.0301759187,
-0.0403820984,
0.036521662,
0.0577587113,
-0.0046371091,
-0.010555746,
-0.0586886257,
-0.0074189259,
-0.0354934111,
0.0640842393,
0.0017927602,
-0.0041017584,
-0.0035605261,
-0.025644701,
-0.0437995829,
-0.0031111741,
-0.0579320975,
-0.0157027282,
0.0189285874,
0.0048910542,
0.0026824109,
0.0202636905,
-0.0549352206,
-0.0365714133,
-0.0176105294,
-0.034011405,
-0.0231512431,
0.014977308,
0.041641172,
0.0337597094,
0.0043853014,
0.0180982817,
2.58740587e-34,
-0.0128499074,
-0.0444476008,
0.0031261975,
-0.0095589263,
0.0228747446,
0.0026552305,
-0.0188515335,
0.0355052948,
0.0296955723,
-0.0026840256,
-0.0443852656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12490v1 | Co$^2$PT: Mitigating Bias in Pre-trained Language Models through Counterfactual Contrastive Prompt Tuning | 2023-10-19T05:49:58 | 2023-10-19T05:49:58 | Xiangjue Dong, Ziwei Zhu, Zhuoer Wang, Maria Teleki, James Caverlee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained Language Models are widely used in many important real-world
applications. However, recent studies show that these models can encode social
biases from large pre-training corpora and even amplify biases in downstream
applications. To address this challenge, we propose Co$^2$PT, an efficient and
effective debias-while-prompt tuning method for mitigating biases via
counterfactual contrastive prompt tuning on downstream tasks. Our experiments
conducted on three extrinsic bias benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of
Co$^2$PT on bias mitigation during the prompt tuning process and its
adaptability to existing upstream debiased language models. These findings
indicate the strength of Co$^2$PT and provide promising avenues for further
enhancement in bias mitigation on downstream tasks. | [
0.0363757536,
0.0316209123,
-0.0218012277,
0.0407040268,
0.0002528704,
0.0195615795,
0.0472434536,
-0.0177804176,
0.0168513414,
-0.038204629,
-0.0726387128,
-0.0328619145,
0.0181742478,
0.0146562699,
0.0277215447,
-0.069101572,
0.0787471831,
-0.0092581129,
0.0555670857,
-0.0473781265,
0.0182488002,
0.0126990248,
-0.0114353038,
0.0071909507,
0.0039771195,
-0.0146211442,
0.0328505188,
0.0342805795,
-0.0063418988,
-0.0133588724,
0.0608116426,
0.1000076607,
-0.0210881606,
0.0247604251,
0.0000019441,
-0.0595030896,
0.0072312295,
-0.0439950749,
-0.0424366072,
0.0018987701,
0.0672033951,
-0.0032145116,
0.0047283899,
0.0348853283,
-0.0398495756,
-0.0258391015,
0.0383380912,
0.012357031,
0.0282623004,
0.0597761124,
-0.0087043252,
-0.0088992575,
-0.0315639675,
-0.0453783125,
-0.0189530328,
-0.0188828949,
0.0266693123,
-0.0643880069,
-0.0447903275,
0.0266851764,
-0.0169876907,
-0.0012386281,
0.0042174649,
0.0310524926,
0.0091613475,
0.0146466009,
0.0047617322,
-0.0325711779,
-0.0489880219,
0.0623747073,
-0.0236440636,
-0.047677923,
-0.0162750166,
-0.052475892,
0.022631811,
0.0032387809,
0.0022463435,
-0.0061593479,
0.0090173585,
0.0083292155,
0.0120764971,
0.0212224666,
0.0052886377,
0.012399368,
0.0082625318,
0.0389723554,
0.0315824412,
-0.0274365935,
0.0336628221,
0.0537632294,
0.0189029612,
-0.0628056601,
0.0241824109,
-0.0382049978,
-0.0574489683,
0.006091089,
-0.0606384389,
-0.0087487753,
0.0047794315,
-0.0234460812,
0.0130425692,
0.0331641808,
-0.0586894341,
0.0325561501,
-0.0076068048,
0.0170592554,
-0.0096867066,
0.0248493813,
-0.0274125729,
0.0010282672,
0.0187320504,
0.0119784409,
-0.0381113701,
-0.0255796295,
-0.0405185521,
0.0202772245,
-0.0156064909,
0.0074725221,
-0.0192996003,
-0.025221765,
0.0167354196,
0.0112570496,
-0.0606735982,
-0.0276457295,
-0.0146710444,
0.0412341617,
-0.0490802489,
0.0320910551,
-0.0058957324,
-0.0972646251,
-0.0346156806,
-0.0028600837,
0.019482825,
-0.0666125715,
-0.0053281598,
0.0326567367,
-0.007879152,
-0.0274893846,
-0.0163192563,
-0.0091301594,
-0.0249797478,
-0.0446101055,
-0.0197606795,
-0.0191426799,
0.0332207829,
0.0133225722,
-0.0001205222,
-0.057807792,
-0.0280849822,
0.006721993,
-0.0619592108,
0.0609286353,
-0.0291771218,
-0.0027285835,
0.0192415137,
-0.0013151951,
-0.0049324175,
0.0816443861,
-0.0075188195,
-0.0085106576,
0.0522951409,
0.0080065979,
0.0082046026,
0.0433074161,
0.0503957048,
-0.0047868947,
-0.033538647,
0.0098860217,
0.052431155,
-0.0003266621,
0.0916908681,
0.0429611355,
-0.0271892846,
-0.0227403324,
0.0868178084,
-0.0037664892,
-0.0142408563,
-0.0073313196,
0.0290206932,
0.0181847792,
-0.0242390204,
0.0306716785,
-0.0763455182,
0.0068313293,
-0.0355903283,
-0.0136797968,
0.0401087739,
0.0452117063,
-0.0384010039,
-0.0073700272,
0.0267158095,
-0.0004629482,
-0.0066715237,
0.0106417518,
-0.0078892093,
0.0261811409,
-0.0342908576,
0.0386015885,
0.0485665575,
-0.0396309942,
0.0299178753,
-0.0254123118,
-0.0079572089,
0.05912707,
0.0113653634,
-0.018797921,
-0.0171381533,
-0.0244012121,
0.0082709044,
0.0688596293,
0.1042051613,
-0.0089875394,
0.021771349,
-0.0498666577,
-0.0471779443,
0.0083625773,
0.0226626638,
0.0111865625,
0.0196605641,
0.0299742296,
0.0178179182,
0.0183816887,
-0.0215613022,
0.0307566598,
-0.0191553235,
-0.0460504293,
-0.0062505091,
0.0235548578,
0.0097257169,
0.0131790675,
-0.0210419558,
-0.0085060569,
-0.0114957131,
0.0168265235,
0.0457089283,
0.0272073261,
-0.1091743186,
-0.0719927028,
0.0154111898,
-0.0099948319,
-0.0307137687,
0.0385674052,
-0.0237491634,
-0.0370856971,
0.0214416571,
0.0095919538,
0.0528667755,
-0.0255909171,
0.0084130773,
-0.0311956014,
0.0447745733,
-0.0331164226,
0.0284605343,
-0.000847169,
-0.01256066,
0.0316729136,
0.0073085618,
-0.0088804355,
-0.0376049019,
-0.0196319185,
-0.0216041543,
0.0225619134,
-0.0174946375,
0.043076057,
-0.01015261,
-0.0316562131,
-0.0106425993,
-0.0633025318,
-0.0028938593,
-0.044329837,
-0.0136036025,
0.0437983833,
0.0162241384,
-0.0286068507,
-0.0382157341,
-0.027523376,
-0.0240593143,
-0.0041528796,
0.0517358333,
0.0092163552,
0.0003037716,
0.0072718933,
-0.0487028807,
-0.0145294005,
-0.0236621164,
0.0321164764,
0.0084973723,
-0.0221011918,
-0.0561289378,
0.0365569405,
0.0136408033,
0.0493718609,
-0.0080407709,
-0.0077391271,
0.0029757002,
0.0223645102,
0.0582226738,
0.0771496072,
0.004777167,
-0.0168784522,
0.0384150743,
-0.0078695817,
-0.0562977456,
-0.0109671075,
-0.0207131039,
-0.0212876741,
-0.0208794605,
-0.0376432166,
-0.0158286449,
0.0773783848,
0.028873153,
-0.0164941158,
-0.0690609962,
0.012309948,
-0.0134590073,
-0.0463499092,
-0.009868674,
-0.053786587,
-0.034126237,
0.0424753912,
-0.0581289232,
-0.0664652213,
0.0688351169,
-0.0127660306,
-0.0135495299,
-0.0414926112,
0.041734729,
0.0003399638,
0.0174320862,
-0.0011726973,
0.0163554624,
0.0324526839,
-0.0076212627,
-0.0797688365,
-0.0116499383,
0.0301688854,
-0.0167834926,
-0.0042316783,
-0.0202479474,
-0.0082923686,
-0.011018361,
-0.0475932024,
-0.0345645659,
-0.0956354141,
-0.0170003865,
0.0062042051,
0.0433702022,
0.0102958698,
0.0174213555,
-0.0142976521,
-0.0095418785,
0.0804296359,
-0.0218349062,
0.0105519006,
-0.025892226,
0.01587178,
0.0450378321,
0.0020793201,
0.0449278876,
-0.029038135,
0.0178879015,
-0.0033399959,
0.0637534037,
-0.0192990452,
-0.019980792,
0.0138246119,
0.051200822,
-0.0367799029,
-0.0177839659,
0.03545646,
0.0527578071,
-0.0113267647,
-0.0143095506,
0.1115470976,
0.0006702165,
-0.1228574663,
0.007316228,
0.0317849293,
0.0369576812,
0.0379158556,
-0.0007023189,
-0.0913234651,
-0.0369749255,
0.02037213,
-0.0015438866,
0.0066519645,
-0.0300260503,
-0.0337387286,
-0.1572290957,
0.0040753526,
-0.0068985061,
0.0257286374,
-0.0022616489,
-0.0360729806,
0.0346142352,
-0.0227730758,
0.0410972349,
0.0099419383,
-0.0106503936,
0.0109960856,
0.024057379,
0.0149030965,
-0.0781402737,
0.0047807205,
-0.0477718413,
0.0742019862,
0.0645830184,
-0.0066745211,
-0.0013463597,
-0.0079954239,
0.0551964752,
-0.0517978929,
0.0023555055,
-0.0324335061,
0.0654681697,
-0.0567895137,
-0.0024321266,
0.0018647868,
0.031312041,
0.0000658845,
0.0072913873,
-0.0235410538,
0.0305425022,
0.0135443695,
-0.0119654648,
0.0056265919,
0.0080461223,
0.0540352054,
0.0825668275,
0.0401881859,
-0.0603773557,
-0.0029986252,
-0.0168888196,
0.0148265157,
0.006395468,
-0.0222036559,
-0.0307592098,
0.0228855349,
-0.0218771994,
-0.0319951028,
-0.0420220979,
-0.0102213686,
0.0219704751,
0.00777729,
-0.0165303629,
-0.0216825642,
-0.007028026,
-0.0032786157,
0.0566036627,
-0.0373698957,
0.0365549885,
-0.0486562625,
-0.0200973824,
-0.0066506821,
-0.0370268337,
-0.0330408886,
0.016161317,
-0.0371391214,
-0.0787853673,
0.055948168,
0.0582389459,
0.0228603352,
0.0885884836,
-0.0313878581,
-0.0886170641,
0.0589172393,
0.0245674383,
-0.060092479,
0.0350828916,
0.0376027897,
-0.0007372886,
0.0022493214,
0.0347538851,
-0.0244436711,
0.0202959217,
0.0786257759,
0.0084455954,
0.0173506513,
-0.0796365663,
-0.0079708025,
-0.0098486179,
0.1388500929,
-0.039152652,
0.0411363132,
-0.0694526508,
0.0131165041,
-0.0192438699,
-0.0164173301,
-0.0195655432,
-0.0004540225,
0.0112546459,
-0.0102902632,
-0.0321888365,
-0.0082205208,
-0.0519980937,
0.0019954848,
-0.0493118763,
0.0221949834,
0.0127118872,
0.0431458019,
0.0197167415,
0.013626894,
-0.0069133923,
0.0649590641,
0.006031388,
0.037084233,
-0.0101235704,
0.0326989368,
0.0467419997,
-0.0103794448,
-0.0138315875,
0.0423848927,
-0.0539629571,
-0.0038051174,
-0.0190021507,
0.0134570692,
0.0293430537,
-0.0377832875,
0.0419027805,
0.0145985689,
0.0107630435,
0.0051002218,
-0.0063140532,
0.0242410321,
-0.0264038388,
0.0200074632,
-0.0114392899,
-0.0271806922,
0.0479733646,
0.0830306709,
-0.0415111594,
0.0497848988,
-0.0170474388,
0.0097814165,
-0.003222516,
-0.0190074388,
0.0112837469,
-0.0138857849,
-0.0488022231,
0.009570851,
-0.057303831,
-0.0601969771,
-0.0070522954,
0.0135715799,
0.0162163079,
-0.0031545539,
0.0531459898,
0.0474801511,
-0.0494612195,
-0.030141091,
-0.0003800582,
0.0003944112,
0.0042832564,
-0.0175975021,
-0.0264696423,
-6.671599738e-33,
-0.0429137535,
0.0305426139,
-0.0212388895,
-0.0382496528,
-0.0072051645,
-0.0034061552,
-0.0314689465,
0.0114459107,
-0.0254847296,
0.0109493658,
-0.0496397279,
0.0217292272,
0.0366003998,
-0.0201622676,
-0.0068901908,
-0.0007811034,
0.0796430558,
-0.0280094054,
-0.0459310077,
0.0294110961,
-0.0088224234,
0.0282735769,
0.0601345338,
-0.0277451482,
0.0451820567,
0.0081236204,
-0.005072617,
0.0215370208,
0.0127050234,
0.0149916569,
-0.0264130272,
0.0274928492,
0.0163301881,
-0.0283247624,
-0.0392624252,
0.0559081547,
-0.0459601171,
-0.0445816256,
0.0271374136,
0.0263686422,
-0.0122637665,
-0.0119424481,
0.0157861747,
-0.0143561726,
-0.0883533508,
0.0174498167,
0.0250527821,
0.0105074709,
0.0148158725,
0.0415175892,
-0.0428057127,
0.020550983,
0.0018169122,
-0.0017589444,
0.0077283578,
0.032184314,
0.0113860648,
0.0232423861,
-0.0281323493,
0.0201664288,
0.0192912221,
0.019909123,
0.0219383594,
0.0282048993,
0.010682229,
0.0536653176,
0.0765323788,
0.0563089699,
0.0284787584,
-0.0422505178,
0.0541689433,
-0.0369890705,
0.0241465103,
0.0801940411,
0.0328129902,
-0.0329435878,
-0.0402313508,
0.0102350889,
0.0307320952,
0.0030119724,
0.0329236649,
-0.0202960707,
-0.0193156358,
-0.0545979701,
-0.0652078912,
-0.0760260001,
-0.0186680742,
-0.0001527376,
0.0217927303,
0.0239203218,
-0.0022084226,
0.0179152582,
0.0459854007,
-0.0263369791,
-0.0114478506,
0.0402046815,
-0.0108817099,
-0.0119053638,
0.0018211369,
0.0452868268,
-0.1008644328,
-0.0058913846,
0.0149887353,
0.0442976244,
-0.0004225313,
0.0042686346,
0.01019892,
0.0193581115,
-0.067816928,
0.0235331934,
-0.0220299251,
0.0245605614,
0.0233584233,
0.010286577,
0.0535079129,
-0.0043278728,
-0.0028014511,
0.0282847919,
0.0254738834,
-0.0269697718,
-0.0366997048,
-0.0112156579,
0.0098682316,
0.0582582802,
-0.0256326385,
-0.0049144975,
-0.0000384395,
-0.0104213059,
0.011218139,
-0.0409376323,
-0.0235488731,
-0.0187205803,
2.551e-7,
-0.0130246636,
0.0504566841,
0.0045315111,
0.0135744223,
0.0192948598,
0.0182580501,
0.0228447802,
0.0423369594,
0.0125870612,
-0.018402908,
0.0057477001,
0.0505677499,
0.0200730711,
0.0042184107,
-0.0639794618,
0.0122549236,
-0.0794939473,
0.0639844686,
-0.0213673413,
-0.0250356495,
-0.0214133784,
0.0571343191,
0.0013656768,
-0.0019487549,
-0.0048965579,
-0.0116020748,
0.0442811027,
-0.0387404151,
0.0300673041,
0.0207829382,
0.0212378744,
-0.0163155198,
0.0024270038,
0.0428998172,
-0.0053754617,
0.0596102215,
-0.0389483944,
0.0403734036,
-0.0055675502,
-0.0214000288,
-0.0118594263,
0.004842984,
-0.0397079214,
-0.0753231123,
0.0761627033,
-0.0277156178,
0.0139966886,
-0.0645376295,
-0.0225216374,
-0.0294750165,
0.034437608,
-0.0253731348,
-0.0376193747,
0.0065043108,
0.0422002822,
0.0348534845,
-0.0300873425,
-0.0884037316,
-0.0387961529,
0.0251295473,
-0.0154515859,
-0.0585103221,
0.003053657,
0.0089721782,
0.0139096593,
-0.031926319,
0.0425615609,
2.344896564e-34,
0.0451175272,
-0.013307686,
0.0432200693,
-0.036621172,
0.0227411147,
-0.0222082157,
-0.0233223438,
0.0023610848,
0.0642027408,
-0.0730283335,
-0.0233143996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12489v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12489v3 | MedAI Dialog Corpus (MEDIC): Zero-Shot Classification of Doctor and AI Responses in Health Consultations | 2023-10-19T05:48:28 | 2024-01-12T06:24:21 | Olumide E. Ojo, Olaronke O. Adebanji, Alexander Gelbukh, Hiram Calvo, Anna Feldman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot classification enables text to be classified into classes not seen
during training. In this study, we examine the efficacy of zero-shot learning
models in classifying healthcare consultation responses from Doctors and AI
systems. The models evaluated include BART, BERT, XLM, XLM-R and DistilBERT.
The models were tested on three different datasets based on a binary and
multi-label analysis to identify the origins of text in health consultations
without any prior corpus training. According to our findings, the zero-shot
language models show a good understanding of language generally, but has
limitations when trying to classify doctor and AI responses to healthcare
consultations. This research provides a foundation for future research in the
field of medical text classification by informing the development of more
accurate methods of classifying text written by Doctors and AI systems in
health consultations. | [
0.042321872,
0.0104910377,
0.0020490128,
-0.0123650832,
-0.0304177664,
0.0375724919,
0.0438461266,
0.0324859172,
0.035213355,
-0.0948496088,
-0.0225809067,
-0.0437175073,
0.0207287408,
0.0092935544,
-0.0154095488,
-0.0380495526,
0.0374338441,
0.0517184995,
0.0609417558,
0.036085479,
-0.0059102667,
0.0068151383,
-0.0689319521,
0.0704944879,
0.0016781352,
0.0008672954,
0.0109167602,
-0.0257208999,
0.0105190324,
-0.0768870711,
0.0299886335,
0.0337145291,
-0.0363635421,
0.0300737154,
0.0000016162,
-0.0434292704,
0.0217636898,
0.0337759331,
-0.0688035488,
-0.0592712089,
0.0365993343,
-0.0459062904,
0.0040039071,
0.0503264852,
-0.0098138629,
-0.041697897,
0.042197302,
0.0558908172,
0.0347809717,
0.0968998,
-0.0288598742,
0.0034083773,
0.0299577918,
0.0122558838,
0.0221829936,
-0.0253282767,
0.0319671221,
-0.0290255863,
0.0368753411,
-0.012316213,
0.0265253633,
0.0062265005,
-0.0444553904,
0.0240063984,
0.0117247002,
0.0427130163,
-0.0550559163,
-0.015662903,
0.0077478932,
0.0633850321,
0.021831464,
-0.0210153852,
0.0117581682,
-0.0002623553,
-0.0019982345,
-0.0168076884,
-0.0240066722,
-0.004255591,
-0.0202205125,
0.0130838724,
0.0022575711,
0.0275783613,
0.0153055331,
0.0139436005,
-0.0198391378,
0.0130971614,
-0.0094463937,
-0.0318294652,
0.0121940691,
0.0017415773,
0.0407016911,
-0.0535215065,
-0.0075374036,
0.0517206565,
-0.0156954173,
0.0052086245,
-0.0174926613,
-0.0380583331,
0.0796565562,
-0.0416580401,
0.0156205837,
0.0127058113,
-0.0069645727,
0.0240112673,
-0.003102937,
-0.0051449966,
0.0278080683,
0.0438074321,
-0.0022004687,
0.0347216874,
-0.0953255072,
-0.0139357857,
-0.0235025603,
0.0491714515,
0.015394181,
-0.0172696281,
-0.0675897896,
-0.0188354738,
-0.0018187622,
-0.007050992,
0.0044749123,
0.0163374096,
-0.010243942,
0.0222314876,
-0.0163961314,
0.0406434499,
-0.0015461647,
0.047398787,
-0.0345344022,
-0.0584594011,
0.020412581,
0.0394612923,
0.0061462778,
0.0068611945,
0.0007981184,
0.0286109969,
-0.0239714328,
-0.057875596,
-0.01624652,
-0.0250517819,
-0.0413398184,
-0.0137378601,
0.0013946675,
-0.0147556383,
-0.0188134983,
0.0083642239,
0.0073785316,
-0.0095273256,
0.0207995567,
-0.0040795542,
-0.0542921089,
0.0589018539,
-0.0376669839,
0.0008044014,
0.0602992885,
0.0223845467,
0.0095020821,
0.0198593102,
0.0180818234,
-0.056504257,
0.0080494955,
-0.0044564246,
0.0484875664,
-0.0019133973,
0.0182972234,
-0.028565919,
0.0125209391,
0.0091793258,
-0.0372331068,
0.0295421295,
-0.0496374369,
0.0263466816,
-0.0124029284,
0.0006352135,
-0.0019206223,
0.0751203597,
0.0255756304,
-0.013564405,
-0.0008823485,
-0.0058132894,
-0.0038468179,
-0.0176299419,
0.0204987079,
-0.0326428898,
0.0112035628,
-0.0161159933,
-0.0135901328,
-0.0637621656,
-0.0519266352,
-0.039001137,
-0.0518666394,
-0.0416587777,
-0.0400437489,
-0.0345281065,
0.0545863248,
-0.00807878,
-0.0457570478,
0.0455446839,
0.0294993799,
-0.0456813723,
-0.0488691479,
-0.0762204453,
0.020404147,
0.0402838886,
0.0328658782,
-0.0708869249,
-0.0370035656,
-0.0450744964,
0.0126724029,
0.0291779675,
0.0159408022,
-0.0144549021,
0.013904009,
-0.0368902013,
0.0027632704,
0.0229015741,
0.0531505495,
-0.0265031438,
-0.034003213,
0.0404568054,
-0.0121417381,
0.0082296738,
-0.0194297321,
0.0410950035,
-0.009009935,
-0.0499916263,
0.038094528,
0.0018719232,
0.0475381389,
0.0336680152,
-0.0421950072,
0.0302445386,
0.0154050076,
-0.0226709079,
-0.0226373188,
0.0128311059,
-0.0089956019,
-0.0411045775,
-0.0043309005,
-0.0115962168,
0.0277543347,
-0.0255251694,
-0.0292603504,
-0.0294012371,
-0.0421277694,
-0.0348177254,
0.016146455,
-0.0153942686,
0.0352055617,
0.0256019235,
-0.0099669583,
-0.0414225608,
0.0003510611,
0.0088045821,
0.0127930623,
0.0112183914,
-0.0184672885,
0.0558985285,
-0.0296566226,
-0.0094452212,
0.0250022635,
-0.0282167774,
0.0059948638,
-0.0177876148,
0.0231317692,
-0.002692271,
-0.0322525203,
-0.1455791593,
-0.0246524401,
0.0025463256,
0.0050059296,
0.0150681911,
-0.013506203,
0.0085075051,
-0.0230789464,
-0.0377308391,
0.014052867,
0.0337493978,
0.0003918137,
0.0433591194,
0.0257069916,
0.0105071263,
-0.0174127948,
0.0096886717,
-0.0573116615,
0.0290423352,
0.0358656719,
-0.0281001125,
0.0097327773,
-0.0497597978,
-0.0289504435,
-0.0129966671,
0.0001328541,
-0.0454743691,
0.0071159503,
0.0021070391,
-0.0435315631,
0.0198175032,
0.0127480589,
0.022865817,
-0.0036428683,
0.042296093,
-0.025614908,
0.0086040702,
-0.0099344011,
-0.0083645107,
0.0207131933,
-0.042251803,
0.0105337389,
0.0998255163,
0.016243862,
0.0057737334,
-0.0385799296,
-0.0058267862,
0.0027011905,
0.024413513,
-0.0293929111,
0.014983641,
-0.0458430015,
0.04316606,
0.0102477595,
-0.0421039052,
0.0563156866,
-0.008649555,
0.0220721085,
-0.0913760439,
-0.0370689183,
-0.0550068356,
-0.0158166606,
-0.028901238,
0.0133036571,
0.0538187362,
-0.0303037465,
0.0197232403,
-0.0147720743,
-0.0035024418,
-0.0433745235,
0.0327510498,
-0.0020700812,
0.0373120159,
-0.0196989067,
-0.0405781716,
-0.039773047,
-0.0307949763,
-0.0195395164,
0.0240040999,
-0.0080159996,
0.0316280983,
-0.0846289396,
0.0271079894,
-0.0184542835,
0.0877514482,
0.0042331824,
0.0019196901,
0.0081814611,
0.0558487587,
0.0158117935,
-0.0061421352,
-0.0586128719,
0.0211111568,
0.0419714041,
0.0271679275,
0.0196303856,
0.0616243519,
0.0050999159,
-0.0487601385,
0.0025403693,
-0.0342808068,
-0.0259186607,
0.0355149955,
0.001551863,
-0.0058447956,
-0.0088430503,
0.0962788016,
0.0476803482,
-0.0755316317,
0.0027212796,
-0.0339999646,
-0.0248934627,
-0.0031369324,
-0.0179673601,
-0.0853742734,
-0.0394893028,
-0.0182774104,
0.023784196,
-0.0391422994,
-0.007678526,
0.0330219902,
-0.0569486059,
0.0006346536,
0.0128907785,
-0.0252813194,
0.0051349774,
-0.033969827,
-0.002869711,
-0.0034417917,
-0.0447988957,
-0.0476845726,
-0.0142998677,
-0.0267109033,
0.0231174268,
-0.0567219667,
-0.0662923828,
0.0177139305,
0.0213301685,
0.0479019284,
0.063277632,
0.0522396974,
-0.025369307,
-0.010660938,
0.0178574696,
-0.025003748,
0.0058580665,
-0.0119607942,
0.0993635729,
-0.0069601126,
0.0193186887,
-0.016485868,
0.0199527405,
-0.0331385173,
-0.0210434794,
0.0161986221,
0.052435562,
-0.0431106016,
-0.0252368823,
-0.0610006824,
0.0411045253,
0.0424635746,
0.0485918745,
-0.0033324447,
-0.0052277655,
-0.0641012341,
0.0149883358,
0.0347279161,
0.0013736167,
0.0141732944,
0.0219748635,
-0.0296234209,
-0.0485923514,
-0.0682406798,
-0.0281784311,
0.0208636168,
-0.0014708476,
0.0192986745,
0.0055367732,
0.0135468403,
0.0270871837,
-0.026797073,
0.0037610566,
0.0257138535,
0.0265968852,
-0.0810920447,
-0.0366180167,
0.078055732,
0.0154728536,
-0.0103859594,
-0.042157203,
0.0002581878,
-0.0216861572,
-0.0336618312,
0.0638915822,
0.0254562739,
-0.0372947492,
0.012886174,
-0.034094654,
0.0525054969,
0.0748028457,
-0.025099257,
-0.0287864152,
0.0347189158,
0.0278321039,
-0.020988496,
0.0116959913,
0.0125474865,
0.0349295214,
-0.0121652903,
-0.0152458372,
-0.0706758723,
-0.0078013949,
-0.0109556466,
0.0070668501,
0.0388977937,
-0.0093643321,
-0.031513568,
-0.0243980344,
0.0240078438,
0.0007856039,
0.0207263697,
-0.0109745925,
-0.0159045849,
0.0147636589,
-0.0289045479,
-0.0109300092,
-0.0008457897,
-0.1104096696,
0.0158470459,
-0.0098033603,
0.0364476517,
0.0510605872,
0.0217476618,
-0.0130318059,
-0.0202298369,
-0.0182589348,
0.0179068502,
0.0145420758,
0.0041744993,
0.0096586784,
0.0997839868,
-0.0125471158,
0.059753105,
0.0000839093,
0.0321488529,
-0.0243135411,
-0.0062641259,
-0.0060764351,
0.0345850587,
0.0356931649,
-0.0025664698,
0.0170848407,
-0.0058594272,
-0.0083522191,
-0.0221938267,
0.059482459,
-0.032344684,
0.013016534,
0.0469406396,
0.0225412063,
-0.0106198248,
-0.0023964425,
0.1043287814,
0.0250259507,
0.0366650596,
0.0145141361,
-0.0210101288,
-0.0668573603,
-0.0028576637,
0.0561287627,
0.0362657644,
-0.023404751,
0.0365090035,
-0.0728856996,
-0.0104695903,
0.0275070388,
-0.0626910701,
0.0098526124,
-0.0367878526,
0.0478532612,
0.0211596638,
0.0254606716,
-0.001291123,
-0.0530547574,
0.0357888564,
-0.0173688456,
0.0123661449,
-0.0190077648,
-5.038283766e-33,
0.0013834629,
-0.0521882996,
0.0024500031,
-0.0047227065,
0.0249486137,
0.023633711,
-0.0142922206,
0.0192918107,
-0.0275180377,
0.0197738763,
0.0035963163,
-0.0082073081,
0.0003139576,
0.0455625467,
0.0047879573,
-0.0360686183,
0.0308574978,
-0.0204172246,
-0.0237889737,
0.0205021836,
-0.0037957374,
0.0189438388,
0.007121129,
-0.0855845585,
0.0225488171,
-0.0103335502,
0.0144678727,
0.0078942273,
0.0196052957,
0.0761046186,
-0.025471,
0.0522989631,
0.0652530864,
0.0249160491,
0.0322620235,
0.058093816,
-0.0516432598,
-0.0206661429,
-0.0117435027,
-0.0103744408,
-0.003787009,
-0.0363340713,
0.0163923316,
0.0038158242,
-0.0301538873,
-0.0258307811,
0.0540228374,
-0.0331062526,
-0.032235615,
-0.0327983312,
-0.0642322227,
0.0424532741,
-0.0260601677,
-0.0418892391,
0.0015769079,
0.0710503981,
-0.0223075189,
0.0507393777,
-0.0421130322,
-0.0057069217,
0.0272020698,
-0.0101814792,
-0.0121344868,
-0.0184998307,
-0.0419701152,
0.0488540083,
0.0413567871,
-0.0002436922,
-0.0699882582,
-0.0152450716,
-0.0396090634,
0.0115516204,
0.0381268486,
0.0480568558,
0.0486492328,
-0.0361099988,
-0.074640967,
0.0244514924,
-0.0141855171,
0.027354978,
0.0169879217,
-0.0342634432,
-0.0610948354,
-0.000035808,
0.0083256494,
-0.0486123934,
-0.0290904101,
-0.0136918211,
0.0425162278,
0.0038236617,
0.0362804718,
0.0166720916,
0.0222197399,
-0.0186003651,
0.0252850968,
0.0157138482,
0.0152708152,
0.0328771919,
-0.030657405,
-0.0218865573,
-0.0889385417,
-0.036786817,
0.0301638935,
0.0302144568,
0.0752540231,
0.0256355386,
0.0483955145,
-0.0418661311,
-0.0613334216,
-0.0273825675,
0.0421318486,
0.0089166099,
0.0113029787,
0.0978647098,
-0.0020671405,
0.0264508985,
0.010514061,
0.0797316954,
-0.0315768458,
-0.0039096624,
-0.0102728875,
-0.0712153465,
-0.0279758051,
-0.0242751576,
-0.0661667213,
-0.0024689436,
-0.0204105545,
0.0491321497,
0.0276172608,
-0.035754323,
0.0113561619,
-0.0251409467,
2.326e-7,
0.0739926398,
0.0562705658,
-0.0038947135,
-0.0566369519,
0.0521055982,
0.0406968109,
-0.00459855,
0.0115784379,
0.0030499001,
0.0122288754,
0.0287045222,
-0.0426318906,
0.0408687219,
0.0220737811,
-0.0766678602,
-0.0420532115,
-0.105261758,
-0.0116850333,
-0.0331038497,
-0.0014409847,
0.0937932059,
0.0810055435,
-0.0420159586,
-0.0273827799,
-0.0151544651,
0.0021526378,
0.0427020527,
-0.0018468491,
0.0287462026,
0.0474485345,
0.0356642306,
-0.0172021203,
0.0138919074,
0.0429721177,
-0.0337927304,
0.0109831365,
-0.0094526941,
0.0951849073,
-0.0917110369,
0.0001443442,
0.0283473954,
0.0286690425,
0.0205840468,
-0.0300125554,
0.0607133545,
-0.0752951726,
-0.0534532256,
-0.0029473035,
-0.0228185691,
-0.0201921817,
0.1009659916,
-0.0159724541,
-0.0102028558,
0.0554411821,
0.0313203633,
-0.0209345594,
-0.0142812394,
-0.0594213977,
-0.016511444,
0.0255289357,
-0.0213179849,
0.0048892181,
0.0543773025,
-0.036758557,
0.0170943402,
-0.0725007206,
0.0371459685,
1.799015011e-34,
0.0146670239,
-0.0207393207,
-0.0003514983,
0.0471097343,
0.0033022533,
-0.0139174322,
0.0101919407,
0.0135097094,
0.0497216433,
-0.0395687558,
0.0178114399
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.