id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11511v1 | Self-RAG: Learning to Retrieve, Generate, and Critique through Self-Reflection | 2023-10-17T18:18:32 | 2023-10-17T18:18:32 | Akari Asai, Zeqiu Wu, Yizhong Wang, Avirup Sil, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite their remarkable capabilities, large language models (LLMs) often
produce responses containing factual inaccuracies due to their sole reliance on
the parametric knowledge they encapsulate. Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG), an ad hoc approach that augments LMs with retrieval of relevant
knowledge, decreases such issues. However, indiscriminately retrieving and
incorporating a fixed number of retrieved passages, regardless of whether
retrieval is necessary, or passages are relevant, diminishes LM versatility or
can lead to unhelpful response generation. We introduce a new framework called
Self-Reflective Retrieval-Augmented Generation (Self-RAG) that enhances an LM's
quality and factuality through retrieval and self-reflection. Our framework
trains a single arbitrary LM that adaptively retrieves passages on-demand, and
generates and reflects on retrieved passages and its own generations using
special tokens, called reflection tokens. Generating reflection tokens makes
the LM controllable during the inference phase, enabling it to tailor its
behavior to diverse task requirements. Experiments show that Self-RAG (7B and
13B parameters) significantly outperforms state-of-the-art LLMs and
retrieval-augmented models on a diverse set of tasks. Specifically, Self-RAG
outperforms ChatGPT and retrieval-augmented Llama2-chat on Open-domain QA,
reasoning and fact verification tasks, and it shows significant gains in
improving factuality and citation accuracy for long-form generations relative
to these models. | [
0.0709684342,
0.015993122,
0.0018789845,
0.0230087377,
-0.0511723049,
-0.0456273705,
-0.0149801997,
-0.0229924228,
0.0191801377,
-0.080714345,
-0.0367595367,
0.0042820177,
-0.0422499217,
0.0138311498,
0.0173023399,
0.001320245,
0.0792386085,
-0.0186567623,
0.0191322956,
-0.0126028685,
-0.0047592213,
0.0153904893,
-0.0121611599,
0.0307544004,
-0.0288938321,
-0.0495443307,
0.0053035743,
-0.0173453372,
-0.0135831777,
-0.0240573492,
0.0581196956,
0.0571219586,
0.0104030371,
0.0584771074,
0.0000020745,
-0.0469656065,
-0.018751312,
-0.0091965888,
-0.034294486,
0.0222877599,
0.0705887526,
0.0390835479,
0.0079364004,
0.0267853588,
-0.0571795814,
-0.0041940794,
-0.0145937372,
0.0423018895,
0.0681033731,
0.072553277,
0.0237490665,
0.0036002819,
-0.0013092692,
-0.0352941863,
0.0163345225,
-0.0037073402,
-0.0020079282,
0.0264421217,
-0.0034843958,
0.0726083592,
0.0018585584,
0.0307326894,
0.0230559446,
-0.0352880657,
0.0291671362,
0.0361739136,
-0.0185375176,
0.0058739176,
-0.0073567298,
0.0310786571,
0.0669675916,
-0.0526408441,
-0.0168490149,
0.013037743,
0.0205596797,
0.0164951626,
-0.0403019302,
0.0180269219,
-0.0116785346,
0.0099481773,
-0.0080895266,
-0.0179948211,
0.0140823461,
0.0191187132,
0.0066733439,
0.0433726572,
0.0049772435,
-0.0346484296,
-0.0293991398,
0.015978884,
0.0162622314,
-0.0432714485,
-0.0511470214,
0.0472727232,
-0.0137843322,
0.0208947118,
-0.0281215627,
-0.0201861486,
0.0523330532,
-0.005119686,
0.0349134021,
0.0165296141,
-0.0537595302,
0.0329976045,
-0.0440481044,
0.0314898454,
-0.0209897719,
0.0152918929,
-0.0286687352,
-0.0158889815,
-0.0388293713,
-0.0387961306,
-0.0191542935,
0.0562654287,
-0.0438371338,
0.0100704702,
-0.046635814,
0.0351184383,
-0.0188467875,
-0.0059840251,
-0.0022208085,
0.034878809,
-0.02456869,
-0.01327834,
-0.0843803808,
0.0409245417,
-0.0005097039,
0.0191734806,
0.0355939455,
-0.0645661056,
-0.0284526125,
0.00359723,
-0.0073182625,
-0.0056691864,
0.0071184495,
0.0544947945,
-0.0240255091,
-0.0209199488,
-0.0462579392,
-0.0379941389,
-0.0304598417,
-0.0861476213,
0.0208890699,
-0.0673207417,
0.0164221562,
-0.0088755013,
-0.0447567888,
-0.029720176,
0.0331582054,
0.0408397727,
-0.014447107,
0.0284617469,
-0.0221159197,
-0.0043917429,
0.0442818739,
0.0108129131,
-0.0066242935,
0.0470903739,
0.0129806437,
0.0158118885,
0.0408473536,
0.0272527095,
0.0294867232,
-0.0255022924,
0.0489196889,
0.0020721562,
-0.0016555521,
0.0096853711,
-0.0129505675,
0.0143859284,
0.0387330763,
0.0505903438,
-0.0403431915,
-0.0120534245,
0.0663519055,
0.012522486,
0.0172669198,
0.0458024442,
0.0668782964,
0.0146776512,
0.0263433736,
0.0111263562,
-0.0425242186,
0.0586420074,
-0.0048446087,
0.0005513655,
0.03557951,
0.0126318298,
-0.030574441,
-0.0698059052,
-0.0134045137,
-0.0002577969,
-0.0232128501,
0.0191417169,
0.0302947927,
0.0478206463,
-0.0452693366,
0.063857995,
0.0136993267,
-0.0752021298,
-0.0127055533,
-0.0787352845,
0.0851674676,
0.0574318282,
0.0693812147,
-0.0163947418,
-0.046101667,
0.0041990983,
0.0016829317,
0.0584860444,
0.0667132065,
0.0058290004,
-0.0244984366,
-0.0288605355,
-0.0151457814,
-0.0579017922,
0.0265968032,
0.0011415287,
0.0489304885,
-0.0182748698,
0.0304976534,
-0.0196957327,
-0.017458031,
0.0404295437,
-0.0153317228,
-0.0390433632,
0.0256480388,
-0.0232030563,
0.0146100689,
0.0223804824,
-0.0052067577,
0.0459005348,
0.0322244912,
-0.0182796754,
-0.0667265654,
0.0323471427,
-0.0426825471,
-0.0538764186,
0.0327651538,
0.0259387996,
-0.0000200895,
0.0220573265,
-0.030044727,
-0.0397431143,
0.0483906381,
-0.0279849358,
0.0159370899,
-0.081012249,
-0.020962894,
0.0247382354,
0.0164898727,
-0.01256622,
0.0677335784,
0.0050320025,
0.0012274893,
-0.0051918542,
0.021696629,
0.0243127607,
-0.025763182,
-0.0142759448,
-0.0434466265,
-0.0219034273,
0.0302197281,
0.0380172208,
0.0055504418,
-0.0426460989,
-0.0381716341,
-0.0780694112,
0.007925339,
-0.0162104182,
-0.002583402,
0.0194997471,
-0.020992076,
-0.0068403766,
-0.0145435361,
-0.0042432519,
-0.0001983432,
0.035050597,
0.018954372,
0.053370785,
0.0111231077,
0.0363339521,
-0.056817349,
0.0159137938,
-0.0119100837,
0.0144488923,
-0.0181036349,
0.0603433773,
-0.05559076,
0.004471126,
-0.078614682,
0.0435808152,
-0.0149679622,
-0.0437995531,
0.0399080217,
-0.0229531899,
0.0510799959,
0.0436727107,
0.0416945592,
0.0079564312,
0.0551292337,
-0.0110439733,
-0.0834460631,
0.0510779433,
-0.0209599547,
-0.0320226587,
0.0166970547,
0.0069446135,
0.0062175686,
0.0467211418,
0.0139614167,
-0.0176820718,
-0.0347730368,
0.0260494221,
0.0017410833,
-0.0306157097,
0.008802264,
-0.0264263377,
-0.0219478495,
0.0156215494,
-0.0282471497,
-0.0267691184,
0.0527169183,
-0.0383730195,
0.005665638,
-0.0488351509,
0.0103861177,
-0.0316127576,
0.0571362451,
-0.0230575856,
-0.0086797569,
0.0144258449,
0.0158840772,
-0.0429497883,
-0.0101360362,
0.0443083011,
-0.0660981685,
0.0513362251,
-0.0454506911,
0.0309667625,
0.0066293692,
-0.0534905605,
-0.0811544433,
-0.0366955958,
0.0057830475,
-0.011406851,
-0.0601775832,
0.0075126691,
-0.0241041332,
-0.039061144,
0.0473633297,
0.0410877541,
-0.0379854739,
-0.0158137698,
-0.0051312768,
0.0164534878,
0.0578268394,
0.016804859,
0.0371562131,
-0.0001957765,
0.0387386717,
0.0737992525,
0.0356751606,
-0.0070255324,
-0.0229115542,
-0.0522874519,
-0.0023300119,
-0.0242385752,
-0.0014007882,
-0.0006842618,
0.0598766766,
-0.0694456622,
-0.0489791334,
0.093803905,
0.0251010787,
-0.0146305822,
-0.0299612973,
-0.0712959692,
0.0221869126,
0.0320904739,
0.033983171,
-0.0834094658,
-0.0114812544,
-0.0086071603,
0.0352453105,
-0.0096567757,
-0.0132024558,
-0.0135276727,
-0.1381283998,
0.058608491,
-0.0070363339,
0.0045248684,
-0.0088930372,
-0.0193833169,
-0.0092823263,
0.0154212853,
0.0096780173,
0.0572184101,
-0.0170671847,
0.0175284538,
0.0227303058,
-0.0050441925,
0.0056360569,
0.0309147034,
-0.0161209125,
0.0307357572,
0.0173645932,
0.028040316,
0.0389314778,
-0.0198620949,
0.0411439799,
-0.0374625623,
0.0189099871,
-0.0126683963,
0.0401238687,
-0.0155968927,
0.0130933505,
-0.036755316,
0.0225671101,
0.0009455249,
-0.0153042795,
0.0023397855,
0.042759981,
-0.0328428671,
0.001358554,
-0.0434101075,
0.0265658498,
-0.009838568,
0.0640242025,
0.03229459,
0.0030965421,
-0.0355759151,
-0.0038567935,
0.0096703479,
-0.0622204468,
-0.043443583,
0.0203028377,
0.00483973,
0.0304053649,
-0.0928156301,
-0.0580223203,
-0.0350045338,
0.0184321404,
-0.021534048,
0.0128146978,
-0.0142569887,
-0.0209408775,
-0.0403298512,
-0.0044777095,
-0.0694062263,
-0.0300703347,
0.0078081563,
0.023642052,
0.0548734628,
-0.0336929001,
-0.0097589791,
-0.0048540342,
-0.0386421941,
-0.0531613678,
-0.0016913853,
0.091774039,
0.0191394445,
0.0656851009,
-0.0254163835,
-0.0036285049,
0.0509268902,
0.0355983153,
-0.0668666661,
0.0130997626,
0.0251209699,
0.0199774895,
-0.0094376234,
0.0490648039,
-0.0457108989,
0.0284444541,
-0.0133906836,
0.0524519496,
0.0170684811,
-0.0413183309,
0.0366248451,
-0.0090599312,
0.0525521152,
0.026261989,
0.0084776254,
-0.0365077741,
0.0242922138,
-0.0432500504,
-0.0383101553,
-0.0201276578,
0.0398155116,
-0.0283675715,
-0.0213517211,
-0.003507708,
-0.0155544411,
-0.040274892,
0.1075629815,
-0.0214291289,
-0.0110053169,
-0.0153926816,
0.0201782901,
-0.0282446481,
-0.014865621,
-0.036977604,
0.000173333,
0.0028016218,
0.0262476224,
-0.0246735532,
0.0783963352,
0.0126071461,
0.0012347109,
0.0001086019,
-0.0158684533,
-0.0788751096,
0.0040551359,
-0.007547549,
0.0431167632,
0.0470218658,
0.0474538542,
0.0469343886,
-0.0235807747,
-0.017920075,
-0.0025254043,
0.0370195024,
-0.0145051945,
-0.0231871959,
0.0226103254,
0.0111389998,
-0.0189872682,
-0.0141688203,
0.0563874803,
-0.0170973409,
0.0372408777,
0.0116940355,
-0.0027094081,
-0.0426871777,
-0.0656542182,
-0.0413888954,
-0.0247853044,
-0.0009172629,
0.0071159909,
-0.0598807819,
-0.0725418627,
0.0300151855,
0.0427282862,
-0.014120915,
-0.0378395915,
0.0022686678,
0.0970462188,
0.0032389269,
-0.0569483526,
-0.0712171644,
0.0604473837,
-0.0204729959,
-0.0091536446,
-0.0117896758,
-6.648025199e-33,
-0.0349840634,
-0.0304573178,
0.0696885213,
-0.0095398286,
-0.0447704829,
-0.0087816454,
-0.0384627469,
-0.0002734482,
-0.0325914435,
0.011627065,
-0.0266832113,
0.0204528254,
-0.0013313084,
0.0236669667,
0.0249781739,
0.0148888379,
0.056921754,
-0.0261643566,
-0.0451392159,
0.0251246076,
0.0645356104,
0.0218792204,
0.0355763622,
-0.0386475101,
0.0327402279,
-0.0242546834,
0.0170283671,
0.0312371794,
-0.0326305702,
0.0719963089,
-0.0067736469,
0.04178207,
0.0245017968,
-0.0168181732,
0.0084314272,
-0.0030308603,
-0.0896692723,
-0.0579271391,
0.027411256,
-0.0458986312,
-0.0435430668,
-0.03046537,
0.0400003605,
-0.0139001729,
-0.0160725843,
-0.0050114114,
0.0125216935,
0.0020762219,
0.0017273298,
0.0099849859,
-0.0646031946,
0.0042551579,
0.0398215093,
-0.0336204022,
-0.0510267466,
0.0530113094,
0.0209758393,
-0.0075519602,
-0.0680773258,
-0.0098968949,
-0.043325875,
0.0439624712,
0.0449797958,
-0.0088657299,
-0.013015707,
0.0525783263,
-0.0111232009,
0.0153611777,
-0.0562099628,
-0.0317750052,
0.0266477931,
0.0322016291,
0.0406032354,
0.0928961337,
-0.0071592438,
-0.0213051029,
-0.0641513467,
0.0168898329,
0.0335575752,
0.0644592494,
0.0307713691,
-0.0047927927,
0.0058049602,
0.023466114,
-0.0439432003,
0.0272522923,
-0.0266458075,
-0.0369947739,
0.0395195186,
0.0623435713,
-0.0346787572,
-0.0265500844,
0.0113797849,
-0.015490992,
-0.0079822019,
0.0167566817,
-0.0534722917,
-0.0151144797,
-0.0274316426,
0.0178619158,
-0.0572950095,
-0.0035487234,
0.0232538059,
0.015084031,
-0.0338739082,
0.0235906877,
0.0362896733,
0.0163097903,
-0.0590897091,
0.0159639977,
-0.0451635942,
0.0689868927,
-0.0262618717,
-0.0349248834,
0.0102464613,
0.0536410734,
-0.0260920227,
0.0265099071,
0.0050928886,
0.0187725965,
-0.0509689339,
-0.0060007372,
0.0138580967,
0.0092033148,
-0.0246146917,
0.0226455387,
-0.0337053463,
0.0544160008,
-0.0249972846,
-0.0548543856,
-0.0040801112,
0.0385380797,
2.731e-7,
0.022235306,
0.0187993497,
0.0220290031,
0.0013533254,
0.0237745382,
0.0311164577,
0.0001717369,
0.0246598702,
0.0360968374,
-0.0036746145,
-0.0227693599,
0.0340628289,
0.0415064581,
0.0342741832,
-0.079383187,
0.004262473,
-0.0764295012,
-0.0257378034,
-0.0145245381,
-0.0568939038,
0.0372799411,
0.0459032394,
0.0106398109,
-0.0121800434,
-0.024673244,
-0.0381837077,
0.1021334156,
0.0259448141,
-0.0521584861,
0.0263860095,
0.0571264923,
0.048678875,
0.0130731966,
-0.0285956152,
-0.0081670666,
0.0222705156,
-0.023090126,
0.0378828682,
0.0187499896,
-0.0727031603,
-0.003027996,
0.0179830734,
0.0129216472,
-0.0471622832,
0.0458812043,
-0.054084871,
0.0059408322,
-0.0535714515,
-0.022990495,
0.0223373249,
-0.0031354134,
-0.0158006586,
-0.0495702885,
0.0366586745,
-0.002467921,
0.022714857,
-0.0066781114,
-0.0742132664,
-0.0255302656,
-0.0155918514,
-0.038526006,
-0.0256060716,
-0.0297958888,
-0.0115468092,
-0.0122162281,
-0.0586339459,
0.0176167637,
2.452309657e-34,
0.0323696434,
-0.0222244039,
0.0065500364,
0.0198720824,
0.031353429,
0.0278254151,
-0.0055946484,
0.0180420857,
0.0112347454,
-0.0373100601,
-0.0322730802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11501v1 | CoMPosT: Characterizing and Evaluating Caricature in LLM Simulations | 2023-10-17T18:00:25 | 2023-10-17T18:00:25 | Myra Cheng, Tiziano Piccardi, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Recent work has aimed to capture nuances of human behavior by using LLMs to
simulate responses from particular demographics in settings like social science
experiments and public opinion surveys. However, there are currently no
established ways to discuss or evaluate the quality of such LLM simulations.
Moreover, there is growing concern that these LLM simulations are flattened
caricatures of the personas that they aim to simulate, failing to capture the
multidimensionality of people and perpetuating stereotypes. To bridge these
gaps, we present CoMPosT, a framework to characterize LLM simulations using
four dimensions: Context, Model, Persona, and Topic. We use this framework to
measure open-ended LLM simulations' susceptibility to caricature, defined via
two criteria: individuation and exaggeration. We evaluate the level of
caricature in scenarios from existing work on LLM simulations. We find that for
GPT-4, simulations of certain demographics (political and marginalized groups)
and topics (general, uncontroversial) are highly susceptible to caricature. | [
-0.0144754015,
0.0567241646,
-0.026262952,
0.0255632438,
-0.0193152837,
0.0130635183,
0.0131016327,
0.0007576471,
0.0188456345,
-0.0013603246,
0.0104908915,
-0.0256840959,
-0.0158452559,
-0.0296124779,
0.0576081499,
-0.0736519247,
0.000262794,
0.0016765749,
-0.0278041959,
-0.0115272235,
-0.0236866977,
0.0096003469,
0.0049981731,
0.0457275175,
-0.0126070725,
-0.0024962036,
-0.0212236214,
0.0651026517,
0.0577232875,
-0.0540434122,
0.0263728425,
0.0075989664,
0.0834999904,
-0.0289707612,
0.0000025224,
-0.0315758288,
0.0061262497,
0.0018578199,
0.0142073203,
0.0465981774,
0.1046590731,
0.0456489176,
-0.0322918706,
-0.0006468269,
-0.0242827889,
0.0296027679,
0.0312143266,
-0.0152387684,
0.0396948457,
-0.0172853209,
0.0118374722,
-0.0013139285,
-0.0617631972,
0.0152629064,
0.0135662472,
0.0432322584,
0.0173256472,
-0.0006000597,
0.010685158,
-0.025343474,
-0.0270935036,
0.002575004,
0.0050301701,
0.0515038185,
-0.018549189,
0.0227207281,
-0.0134414639,
-0.0002592489,
-0.0080044633,
0.0481694005,
0.0565101877,
0.0399917439,
0.0029980086,
0.0009101033,
0.0197815839,
0.0159651991,
-0.0340225548,
0.0115247061,
-0.0177016649,
0.0207961556,
-0.0466787331,
0.0335588753,
0.0308513325,
-0.0163512565,
0.0219768435,
0.0406826176,
0.0268892776,
0.0019572102,
-0.0117818657,
-0.0417462699,
0.0282536075,
-0.0316790268,
-0.0139171928,
0.0210922956,
0.0395841748,
0.007895112,
0.004326263,
0.0528910756,
0.0641044378,
-0.0404453687,
0.0631437078,
0.0384194516,
0.0068592634,
0.0162163116,
0.0827432424,
0.0236768983,
-0.024680702,
0.017162079,
0.0201322958,
0.0415197462,
-0.0053855604,
0.0149735427,
0.0394394025,
-0.0268145166,
0.0165125933,
-0.0018749186,
-0.0189863574,
-0.0297017526,
-0.0384314395,
0.0143467775,
-0.0655770153,
0.022590749,
0.0095857149,
0.0243337508,
-0.0638952032,
-0.0004008438,
-0.0577701516,
0.0303336699,
-0.0162122063,
-0.0496672504,
0.0030799676,
0.0229059514,
-0.0185509678,
-0.0269503333,
0.0307333712,
0.0428606756,
0.0344613418,
0.0104505951,
-0.0385790467,
-0.0261760894,
0.0237940326,
-0.0521440953,
0.0722424313,
-0.0634516031,
0.0570592545,
-0.0235262699,
0.0044163591,
-0.0337337703,
0.0079472521,
0.0132942013,
0.0125028631,
0.0877332464,
0.0297884084,
-0.006021671,
0.0234675277,
0.0646890029,
-0.033904884,
0.0311265681,
0.0326414071,
-0.0106780576,
-0.0002471882,
-0.0414856598,
0.0476434603,
0.0467770919,
0.0092130164,
0.0976345539,
-0.0128657511,
0.0030174132,
-0.0136235617,
0.0279500429,
0.0832599923,
0.009908434,
-0.0296014808,
0.0065751262,
0.0367645025,
0.0785236359,
-0.0114918547,
0.0223578606,
0.0193487313,
0.0368663259,
0.0167771187,
0.0361321941,
-0.0425191857,
0.0329129025,
-0.0205348637,
-0.0125014745,
-0.0146135641,
0.0618012063,
-0.0315988734,
0.0430314392,
0.0199447721,
0.0059118643,
0.0545090139,
-0.0334459431,
-0.0503251255,
-0.0397350043,
-0.0211497713,
0.0275825709,
-0.0043786718,
-0.0442756824,
-0.0047562444,
-0.0458010323,
-0.0122202802,
0.0476396456,
0.0056770355,
-0.0114593385,
-0.0039100144,
-0.0558748394,
0.014830837,
0.0452639572,
0.04344045,
0.0148314824,
-0.0512573309,
0.0100025656,
-0.0092102373,
-0.036471013,
0.0207349844,
0.0674059764,
0.0214082506,
-0.0035036029,
-0.0043143868,
-0.0130559038,
0.0510598011,
0.0124864457,
-0.0920251161,
-0.0176519584,
-0.0639074445,
-0.0399152748,
0.0616384372,
0.0032722682,
-0.0028348446,
-0.0210629292,
0.0017850111,
0.0056597623,
0.0181750283,
0.0273335464,
0.0005922975,
0.051466573,
0.009395984,
-0.0675285533,
-0.0004147759,
0.0087072235,
-0.0068690842,
0.0427771509,
0.0365632549,
0.0261678714,
0.0015358878,
-0.0290410444,
-0.0258281548,
-0.0212868061,
0.0435957462,
-0.0115911542,
0.0208613072,
-0.0223319512,
-0.0189455599,
0.0690518767,
0.0295062475,
-0.0036414776,
-0.016881261,
0.011476404,
-0.0042640627,
0.0062303715,
0.0246197172,
-0.0407574885,
-0.0230967198,
-0.07167539,
-0.0165085886,
-0.0437224843,
0.0067290021,
-0.0042097489,
-0.0122896675,
0.0173019841,
-0.048560176,
-0.0572223067,
0.0437661931,
-0.0055766869,
-0.018001711,
-0.0119391559,
0.0139681455,
0.0148631018,
-0.0331718363,
-0.0374615267,
-0.0197414011,
0.0442649722,
-0.0158167556,
0.0166192111,
-0.0064386344,
0.0232193898,
-0.000655754,
-0.0234870464,
-0.0429174714,
-0.015211721,
-0.0209112037,
-0.0238193069,
0.0324606299,
0.0360764861,
0.0622676611,
-0.0138416756,
0.0154070565,
0.0531062819,
0.0262821764,
-0.0099832304,
-0.0472627133,
0.0012054289,
-0.0123687657,
-0.0054979064,
-0.0243987367,
-0.1368183196,
-0.0044654552,
0.0278412607,
-0.0000231492,
0.0589779392,
-0.0071817124,
0.0899199024,
-0.0230994616,
-0.0079497257,
0.0219645761,
0.0037004987,
-0.061296463,
0.033921089,
0.0026405451,
0.005392326,
0.0031959822,
-0.0175296627,
0.0314751044,
0.0487446003,
0.016918255,
0.0054470459,
0.0550911017,
-0.0176661368,
-0.0210546572,
0.0200489927,
0.0522872582,
-0.0293184891,
-0.0041471445,
-0.0287676901,
-0.0647518784,
0.0432799906,
-0.0419952124,
-0.0304764379,
-0.0295045525,
0.0008526686,
-0.0071140584,
-0.0481533557,
-0.0155462436,
0.0098951859,
0.0250704419,
-0.0130133014,
0.0000943835,
-0.0304628871,
0.0340661965,
-0.0306787826,
0.0073224069,
0.0001217614,
0.010506534,
-0.0319792069,
0.0063821315,
0.0388960317,
0.0302419588,
-0.0294525865,
-0.0067301434,
0.0185966045,
-0.0257347226,
0.0093779024,
-0.0441508517,
0.0018839624,
0.0045643356,
0.02443376,
-0.015669154,
0.0153876049,
0.0514501818,
-0.0145001709,
0.0150179323,
0.0704578757,
-0.0208415426,
0.008440176,
0.0221036524,
-0.0314195044,
0.0415502377,
0.0217920225,
0.0094384747,
-0.0640376061,
0.0390144251,
0.016287541,
0.0249604713,
-0.0587086901,
-0.0475079603,
0.0016592374,
-0.0791851729,
0.0867199898,
0.006611017,
-0.026025638,
0.0104148258,
-0.0274389926,
0.0377145708,
0.0163949989,
0.0369971767,
-0.0014412308,
0.0292466581,
-0.0320829973,
-0.0219291188,
-0.0917134881,
-0.0420651212,
0.046618633,
-0.0216146912,
0.0451042168,
-0.0189679358,
0.0652708635,
-0.0286778621,
-0.0512183458,
0.0206125751,
-0.0048903683,
-0.00831265,
0.0212383196,
0.00949647,
-0.0183498748,
0.0338208787,
-0.0307705309,
0.0220902301,
0.0245974269,
-0.0127294939,
0.026813807,
0.037307445,
-0.0508663729,
-0.0552946031,
-0.059496168,
0.0196856912,
0.0166957248,
0.0461053178,
0.0620371811,
-0.0357325636,
0.004678655,
-0.0739214942,
-0.0026827098,
-0.006512295,
-0.0785836652,
-0.0262202639,
0.013367638,
0.0316832811,
0.0572075211,
-0.0317951217,
0.0008195727,
-0.0303029474,
-0.0158618167,
-0.0590368807,
-0.0303872116,
-0.0578079931,
-0.0103892777,
0.0086209374,
-0.0251912661,
0.0295590777,
0.0858701617,
-0.0279641096,
0.0275102984,
-0.0142977936,
-0.003343686,
0.0024269216,
-0.0527911633,
-0.0367631242,
0.0614948273,
0.0519491397,
0.0318526663,
0.0295215901,
0.0410902537,
0.0185299646,
0.0287522655,
0.0394892097,
0.0232766178,
0.0575939529,
-0.0229237173,
0.1014581844,
-0.0031318644,
-0.0125928288,
0.0243551824,
0.046110291,
-0.0061210198,
-0.0081689181,
-0.0606552735,
-0.0569980331,
-0.0424433276,
-0.0172009431,
0.0221152101,
-0.0396097638,
-0.0550243184,
-0.0008546218,
-0.0331401117,
-0.0506709963,
-0.0078954138,
0.0198841766,
-0.0951020122,
0.0255091041,
-0.0213357918,
-0.0132525451,
-0.0393270738,
-0.0478455164,
0.0546591729,
-0.0412586853,
0.0397651978,
0.0383653268,
-0.0060431003,
0.0030931626,
-0.0183362607,
-0.0301105957,
0.0340068936,
-0.0649623945,
0.0234642327,
0.0399038494,
-0.0034816717,
0.0019385454,
0.0006148964,
0.0151805654,
0.0285441782,
0.0151651464,
-0.0369029157,
-0.0310217291,
0.0430302024,
-0.007558722,
-0.0080231698,
0.0067145401,
-0.0379683413,
-0.0023130863,
-0.0138972104,
-0.0284853969,
0.0017155594,
-0.0292170346,
0.079228729,
0.0055775098,
-0.0210807528,
-0.0263378955,
-0.0131172743,
-0.0030421535,
0.0311645195,
-0.0020134801,
-0.0103495149,
-0.0233661588,
-0.043258477,
0.0290547367,
-0.0137760714,
0.0148383044,
-0.051020287,
-0.110232532,
-0.0227967538,
0.0240627546,
-0.0049343063,
-0.0172538348,
-0.0364113301,
0.009597769,
0.0043711583,
-0.0249922406,
0.0386873074,
0.0081071723,
0.0262551773,
-0.0486342683,
-0.0236137137,
0.0124215307,
-7.436584278e-33,
-0.0482475311,
-0.0494301915,
0.0254434403,
-0.0153591326,
-0.0779736191,
-0.0392298698,
-0.0471479148,
0.0033438881,
0.0136485985,
-0.0253245439,
0.0024172431,
-0.0295970403,
0.0052287108,
-0.023770364,
-0.0098864259,
-0.0417017117,
0.0347236358,
-0.0125705004,
-0.0435495041,
-0.0262961388,
-0.0765598789,
-0.0039846739,
-0.0168326218,
-0.0995091051,
0.0347917564,
-0.0670078397,
-0.0247495472,
-0.0803876966,
0.022633478,
0.0273960754,
-0.0481269024,
0.0084169973,
0.0093549602,
-0.0235428251,
0.0151741197,
0.0727963746,
-0.0259731244,
-0.0156765766,
0.0043934812,
-0.0390815027,
-0.0246702097,
-0.0524709448,
-0.0014649121,
0.034376815,
-0.06660676,
-0.0269323364,
0.0369304605,
-0.0600224137,
0.0454726517,
-0.0012590847,
-0.0337818712,
-0.0057235225,
-0.0046188026,
0.0352805592,
-0.0275588986,
0.0616550073,
-0.00807916,
0.0750392452,
-0.07487984,
0.0044427426,
-0.010584984,
-0.0850813836,
0.0583622791,
0.0141800055,
0.0663134381,
0.0658587143,
-0.0043889089,
0.0503393784,
-0.107768029,
-0.0689764619,
0.0409812033,
0.0192609821,
0.0088187009,
0.1024821773,
0.0014105239,
-0.0459898151,
0.0258991066,
-0.000100877,
0.0333668441,
-0.0319691375,
0.0511020087,
0.0213237517,
-0.0107324151,
-0.0243983306,
-0.0253361445,
-0.020253703,
0.0073037222,
-0.0440272987,
-0.005363741,
-0.0276421662,
-0.0236167088,
-0.012588216,
0.0196488742,
0.0036045543,
-0.0179258995,
-0.0624540895,
0.0183116887,
-0.0020605873,
0.0090966616,
0.0005372458,
-0.017329216,
-0.0119439233,
-0.0213338081,
0.0293207746,
0.0612912513,
0.0128412265,
-0.0194092691,
-0.0045092097,
-0.0483746193,
-0.009357837,
0.0081317788,
0.0280108303,
0.0546661019,
-0.0140750455,
0.0035270965,
0.0006831717,
0.0328191742,
-0.0770183578,
0.0401749164,
-0.0025712019,
0.0289260503,
0.0196199566,
-0.0749212131,
0.0077523701,
0.0012545831,
0.0142863877,
-0.0078667104,
0.0083326204,
0.0489218011,
-0.0650879815,
-0.0387534723,
-0.0545368902,
3.126e-7,
0.0234699864,
0.0363089368,
0.0023477541,
0.014451487,
0.0503768176,
0.0334866606,
-0.0195355844,
0.0419812463,
0.029128002,
-0.1164463907,
0.0402827412,
0.0352050737,
0.0253387168,
0.027937606,
-0.0534474812,
0.0284858774,
0.0174678378,
0.0312466063,
-0.048857484,
0.0061470494,
-0.0026572456,
-0.0370193422,
0.0115203848,
-0.0131291635,
-0.0497204214,
0.0456720032,
0.0203207526,
-0.1002816781,
-0.0166446324,
-0.0007344575,
-0.0231094919,
0.0069192708,
0.010930025,
0.0324383564,
0.0018165577,
-0.0388629921,
-0.0050923782,
0.052057609,
0.0246244278,
-0.0547093637,
0.0192959458,
-0.0282541048,
0.0152584016,
-0.0531326458,
0.033118315,
-0.0369620547,
0.0021670493,
-0.0547927395,
-0.077199243,
-0.0098409522,
0.0624616668,
-0.0233664531,
-0.0215757713,
-0.0094507821,
0.0097715212,
0.0142200692,
-0.0024910159,
-0.0066985684,
0.0055874549,
-0.0257019624,
-0.0532162227,
-0.0729414523,
-0.0001997011,
0.023125628,
-0.0083000315,
-0.0508560613,
0.016489787,
3.207168507e-34,
0.0427748412,
0.0412364975,
0.014710756,
-0.0392787121,
0.0329985097,
0.019158408,
0.0364018679,
0.0024191388,
0.0412430055,
-0.013368913,
0.0141541064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11454v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11454v2 | VeRA: Vector-based Random Matrix Adaptation | 2023-10-17T17:59:46 | 2024-01-16T18:59:22 | Dawid J. Kopiczko, Tijmen Blankevoort, Yuki M. Asano | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low-rank adapation (LoRA) is a popular method that reduces the number of
trainable parameters when finetuning large language models, but still faces
acute storage challenges when scaling to even larger models or deploying
numerous per-user or per-task adapted models. In this work, we present
Vector-based Random Matrix Adaptation (VeRA), which significantly reduces the
number of trainable parameters compared to LoRA, yet maintains the same
performance. It achieves this by using a single pair of low-rank matrices
shared across all layers and learning small scaling vectors instead. We
demonstrate its effectiveness on the GLUE and E2E benchmarks, image
classification tasks, and show its application in instruction-tuning of 7B and
13B language models. | [
0.0351423174,
0.0445332602,
-0.0138710197,
0.0573551022,
0.0349611975,
0.0270215292,
0.0398679264,
0.0156548694,
0.0059784558,
-0.0363868438,
-0.0610842295,
-0.0348157063,
-0.0009739483,
-0.0088043278,
0.0198166184,
-0.0504580662,
0.0262848437,
-0.0520607345,
-0.0305512454,
-0.026812721,
-0.019913651,
0.0389767066,
0.0218585674,
0.0183649436,
0.0465419367,
0.0067154337,
0.0013591803,
0.0268605966,
0.0317733698,
0.0346528217,
-0.0005004237,
0.0730068162,
0.0382517166,
0.0207219813,
0.0000018942,
-0.0101559227,
-0.0145379947,
-0.0124616064,
-0.0089086564,
0.0340313204,
0.0279898625,
0.014649488,
-0.030576406,
0.024011841,
-0.0078818072,
-0.0295844078,
0.0932276547,
-0.005552527,
0.0325798467,
0.0599840842,
-0.0122085204,
-0.0386359617,
-0.0034178125,
-0.0358457528,
-0.0221685544,
-0.0699258372,
0.034077961,
-0.0393769816,
-0.0398684293,
-0.0025265131,
-0.0246777199,
0.008914453,
-0.0085493997,
0.0181556549,
0.0078414818,
0.0366472937,
-0.0368923955,
-0.0136396531,
0.0062495149,
0.0766833052,
-0.0624904372,
-0.0189441517,
0.0195306018,
-0.0056791697,
0.0086710891,
-0.0136941625,
-0.029418448,
0.0240492951,
0.0322475135,
0.0175515413,
0.0002508596,
-0.0255656485,
0.0284602474,
-0.0186663158,
-0.0137618557,
0.0300287809,
0.0435141437,
0.0102947829,
-0.0259862784,
0.0054385662,
0.014229211,
-0.0216062199,
-0.0290484652,
0.0114366151,
-0.0069563966,
0.0216667056,
-0.1028037667,
-0.0723079443,
-0.0062956633,
-0.0698265806,
0.1214573607,
0.0390468538,
-0.0279377121,
0.0485711433,
-0.0771983713,
0.0501883775,
-0.013096462,
0.0364832431,
-0.0136706866,
0.0079130419,
0.0058126585,
0.0353163928,
-0.0254572276,
-0.0042784712,
-0.0573080592,
-0.0258482061,
-0.0370455794,
0.02710451,
0.006642194,
-0.0195918586,
0.015829321,
-0.0003476111,
-0.0482420512,
-0.020610692,
0.0083934134,
0.0122585138,
0.0216357242,
-0.002823256,
-0.0371552147,
-0.0378067084,
-0.014210606,
0.0235610474,
0.0367220789,
-0.0343203917,
0.0438036956,
0.0459932275,
-0.0264587235,
-0.0404248238,
-0.0673117638,
0.0428087264,
-0.0169714391,
-0.0764822885,
0.0112877851,
-0.0431058817,
0.0238939822,
-0.0044819014,
0.0149305006,
-0.0725586116,
-0.0007928484,
0.0136968829,
-0.0733941719,
0.0490475334,
0.0231868085,
-0.0212735217,
0.0289839711,
-0.0002093005,
0.0325309373,
0.0679368973,
-0.0034493676,
0.0424092151,
0.0342099741,
-0.0225900635,
-0.0211566053,
0.0478400849,
0.0178973172,
0.0251378994,
-0.008149798,
0.0109725948,
0.0578333065,
-0.0295468587,
0.0657735616,
0.0406556465,
0.0068626064,
-0.0351196639,
0.0429554321,
0.0294315945,
0.011989872,
0.0298239999,
0.0210598521,
-0.0299537051,
-0.00368666,
-0.0298492368,
-0.0344060399,
0.0562934726,
-0.0169974063,
-0.0188369658,
0.0248819739,
0.0792150572,
-0.043704696,
-0.0185664501,
-0.023271801,
0.0029925792,
-0.0097382888,
0.0220124237,
0.0521334596,
-0.0152006531,
-0.033303,
0.0117554823,
0.0444303453,
-0.0405624583,
-0.0299766231,
-0.0834625065,
0.012263217,
0.0235212203,
0.0099638756,
0.0040949555,
-0.0161363594,
0.0032819593,
0.0502108075,
0.0060308748,
0.0155340144,
0.0031494107,
0.0279763024,
-0.0593308061,
-0.013964829,
-0.0066006747,
0.0141677195,
0.0465477817,
0.0224540774,
0.0296901911,
0.0314537734,
-0.0048463689,
-0.0246272497,
0.0273781791,
-0.0243960638,
-0.0025405916,
0.0580638014,
0.0069488944,
0.0172490776,
-0.0142922075,
-0.0139498748,
-0.0520337597,
0.0249631945,
-0.0307311639,
0.0170558486,
-0.0164486449,
-0.016824346,
0.0056250766,
0.0251194593,
0.0171655416,
0.0375173241,
0.0438435338,
-0.030095106,
-0.0420825146,
0.0737159997,
-0.0241895616,
0.0044792378,
-0.0160276983,
0.0308292061,
-0.0337821469,
0.0944752768,
-0.0229126737,
0.0438519865,
-0.0063298587,
-0.0417892151,
0.0324028842,
0.0013818871,
0.0306658465,
-0.0248349868,
-0.046883028,
0.023760749,
0.0301361587,
0.0561073683,
-0.0022491496,
0.0094531886,
0.0104871672,
-0.0201268811,
-0.0334172957,
0.0324275531,
-0.0520493649,
0.0160107389,
0.0211048406,
0.0205464736,
0.015121785,
-0.0712178648,
-0.0133255972,
0.0404899716,
-0.0368084498,
0.0077268104,
-0.0173964687,
0.003749595,
-0.0355280675,
-0.0291409288,
-0.0401226468,
0.0281039774,
0.054329142,
-0.0353211723,
-0.0069080279,
-0.0742134377,
0.0106453802,
-0.011480934,
0.0516466051,
-0.0101142051,
-0.0232647993,
-0.0281108879,
-0.0316184685,
0.0438022204,
0.0943097323,
-0.017610658,
0.0413124301,
0.0906099305,
0.0403958894,
-0.0193948951,
-0.0015712626,
0.0131821586,
-0.0227650795,
-0.0395509861,
-0.0216792505,
-0.0261424705,
0.0421346389,
-0.0313381404,
-0.0159828942,
-0.0816440731,
0.0102477437,
-0.0153406067,
-0.0193813909,
-0.0341317616,
0.0195339657,
-0.0271395724,
0.0135846445,
0.0019696739,
-0.0241110418,
0.0387128443,
-0.0009067415,
-0.0109407827,
-0.0561769009,
-0.0523730218,
-0.0223263763,
0.0261397958,
0.0175660104,
0.0503792875,
-0.0583226047,
-0.0072943387,
-0.0411263518,
-0.0140778879,
-0.0028147467,
-0.0110118631,
0.0631508157,
-0.0361113586,
0.0042380346,
-0.0370780751,
-0.0489083044,
-0.0072616185,
-0.0006763951,
-0.0168931168,
-0.0095038526,
0.0088888397,
-0.0846737996,
-0.0219835993,
0.0000775714,
0.0180468168,
0.0739634484,
-0.0187850427,
0.0127782226,
-0.0120185213,
0.0421217754,
0.0759353787,
0.0080174217,
-0.0020743406,
-0.0249178559,
0.0076081073,
0.0099496236,
0.0299509056,
-0.0226607397,
-0.0642753467,
0.027345011,
0.0617624745,
0.0327010937,
-0.0238407236,
0.0285483915,
0.0163722467,
-0.0231204033,
-0.0000057622,
0.0469911546,
0.0129297543,
-0.0617360845,
-0.0258054305,
-0.012538746,
0.0921353027,
0.0365112759,
0.0802354664,
-0.0296177622,
-0.0246717986,
-0.0125636067,
0.0458420999,
0.0371076278,
-0.0057458882,
-0.010055365,
-0.0942078531,
0.0401709676,
0.0000878459,
-0.0369903184,
-0.042993173,
-0.0333094858,
0.0175370686,
-0.0205145068,
0.0579714105,
-0.0110177342,
-0.0309495889,
-0.0160328168,
0.0298663881,
-0.0162009373,
-0.0588058159,
-0.0026329895,
-0.0097846948,
0.094399184,
0.0245027728,
0.0045818249,
0.0005018142,
-0.0575687401,
0.0098506091,
-0.0162447896,
0.0019222104,
-0.0181642994,
0.044020649,
0.0231039096,
-0.0356952175,
0.0239321869,
0.0067096227,
0.0067943856,
0.0007336041,
-0.0086767944,
0.0666592866,
0.0048169307,
-0.0343274884,
-0.0042396844,
-0.0474968962,
-0.0236840099,
0.0353629738,
0.0288384296,
-0.0539462343,
-0.0159623623,
-0.0017118724,
0.0088567249,
-0.0739312842,
-0.0233118143,
0.0018705458,
-0.0472090691,
-0.0149403252,
-0.0375916399,
0.0108601851,
0.0243947487,
0.0504536852,
-0.0183798838,
-0.0272730868,
-0.0452651493,
0.0297947526,
-0.0448010601,
0.0193534326,
-0.0300843548,
0.0081387777,
-0.0442913063,
-0.0074324347,
0.0177643634,
-0.0217320118,
-0.0235827938,
-0.0106244348,
-0.0728622824,
-0.0619316474,
0.0197683554,
0.0509392545,
0.0156590343,
0.0580645055,
0.020458404,
-0.0994592085,
0.0174290165,
-0.0031947922,
0.0380641893,
0.069052875,
0.0289177746,
-0.0858823583,
-0.041389294,
0.0389311202,
-0.0728773102,
0.0188391041,
0.0474799685,
0.0007768723,
-0.0300478395,
-0.0368167013,
-0.0223495103,
0.0063433838,
-0.0107628992,
-0.0139007131,
-0.0332347192,
-0.0368177332,
0.0539835133,
0.0068677035,
0.0185129289,
-0.0334170759,
-0.0278825127,
0.0398535021,
-0.0072849202,
-0.0147154564,
0.0152497571,
0.0277486667,
0.0213218182,
-0.0121554583,
0.0018993018,
0.0068898117,
0.0293468498,
0.0477388017,
0.0215306636,
-0.0220082197,
0.0241610054,
0.0642375574,
0.0446291603,
-0.0423380472,
0.0032335517,
-0.0084847398,
-0.0250665918,
-0.0534732081,
0.0554095767,
-0.0296896305,
-0.0732631385,
-0.0713108107,
0.0050549097,
0.0418282188,
0.013897894,
0.0814892352,
0.0056759389,
-0.0359705389,
-0.0089226617,
-0.0224045366,
0.004108944,
0.0018485815,
0.0417819284,
-0.0051684766,
-0.0052575301,
0.0438240245,
0.065904811,
0.0387459472,
0.0377317779,
-0.0270732697,
0.0187789891,
-0.0371232592,
-0.0038399098,
0.0066817072,
0.0088790897,
-0.0152770942,
-0.0164342765,
0.0130196959,
-0.0671475828,
-0.0264107473,
-0.0090897847,
0.0090554394,
-0.0213101786,
0.0020674283,
0.0460455716,
0.0253327992,
0.0077300989,
-0.0155505035,
-0.0512420647,
0.0036784834,
0.0104102641,
0.0193048511,
-6.396575937e-33,
-0.0270739589,
0.0382483862,
-0.0103303632,
0.0186259523,
0.0195950717,
0.0047805402,
-0.0162358005,
0.0107230805,
-0.0169515498,
-0.0061551253,
-0.0202744883,
-0.0076310127,
0.0348110534,
0.0184343103,
-0.0085937157,
0.0342729203,
0.0671470314,
-0.0285968836,
0.001304231,
0.0812346488,
0.026127724,
0.017029224,
0.0230451226,
-0.0619681701,
-0.0323971547,
0.0167921465,
-0.0064066248,
-0.0245373193,
0.0334307477,
0.0489502437,
-0.0357177444,
0.0278277192,
0.0036395262,
-0.0370516144,
-0.026473403,
0.0031763287,
-0.0842175335,
-0.0322436616,
0.0089933174,
0.0379865617,
-0.042199485,
-0.0331973769,
0.015543309,
0.0182173476,
-0.0333479047,
-0.0322357193,
0.0524731204,
-0.0213081725,
-0.0405937769,
-0.0125528434,
-0.0515908524,
0.0188993495,
0.0142050404,
0.0177767482,
0.0476183854,
0.0146865388,
-0.0001709953,
0.0089043351,
-0.067053467,
-0.0020553414,
-0.0334500298,
0.0621103384,
0.075419195,
0.0607849769,
-0.0543724746,
0.0199250113,
0.0154889617,
-0.0001431562,
0.0194465388,
-0.0299878679,
0.0361834764,
0.0508617498,
0.0349887088,
0.0463114567,
0.0185110774,
-0.0138893751,
-0.0733979717,
0.0037045025,
0.0461343192,
0.0040779659,
0.0284226891,
0.0130876619,
-0.0215364397,
-0.0182434078,
-0.0365637317,
0.0059909206,
-0.0523606539,
-0.0420001261,
0.0333831124,
0.0219868217,
-0.0401493795,
0.0007523862,
0.0482869074,
-0.0625287071,
0.0033302461,
0.0180348791,
-0.0041644913,
0.0086092837,
0.0242396034,
0.0277033355,
-0.035400115,
-0.0484897904,
0.0338976271,
-0.0116758645,
0.018831227,
-0.0071334587,
0.0388482884,
0.0380052812,
-0.0907501131,
-0.0005967172,
-0.0154137192,
0.0147035355,
0.0220316332,
0.094320327,
-0.020062495,
-0.010733759,
0.0146234622,
0.0354095064,
0.0206735078,
0.0437298454,
0.0112525644,
-0.047795862,
0.023049267,
0.0294168908,
-0.0549323298,
0.0074058399,
-0.0406609438,
0.029560877,
0.0168796964,
-0.0728145465,
-0.010618818,
0.0216566417,
2.615e-7,
0.0038527136,
0.0442671292,
-0.0611090511,
-0.0473597273,
0.0088406783,
0.0201221704,
-0.019177556,
0.0337637924,
0.0260068867,
0.0201305076,
-0.0273289047,
0.0132104838,
0.0430946536,
-0.0070817294,
-0.0404409915,
0.028255932,
-0.0693064779,
0.0527992398,
-0.0524195097,
-0.0326216109,
-0.0301580764,
0.1307083517,
0.0253768619,
-0.04786589,
0.004821185,
-0.019337723,
0.0322072655,
-0.0081967572,
0.0197724439,
-0.0071894517,
0.0591496713,
0.0458667763,
-0.0572132803,
0.0043689022,
-0.0306488108,
0.0393928215,
-0.028907368,
0.0545716844,
-0.0508363768,
-0.002479959,
0.0530820712,
0.0137025407,
-0.0159553532,
-0.0780250058,
0.0735392347,
-0.0134208472,
0.0064781103,
-0.0315288082,
-0.0090161664,
-0.0105431909,
0.0165656488,
-0.0222679134,
0.0188414026,
0.0136007937,
0.0314433128,
-0.0332228839,
-0.0309534576,
-0.1211249605,
0.0131442463,
0.0095100291,
-0.0258898996,
-0.0415867642,
-0.046014782,
-0.0114661437,
0.0296250861,
-0.0545947216,
0.0257918313,
2.311729027e-34,
0.0250191223,
-0.0040378873,
0.0009678639,
0.0188360829,
-0.0138312671,
-0.0284942221,
-0.015287688,
0.0236547291,
0.000268776,
-0.1141445115,
-0.0251412727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11453v1 | BitNet: Scaling 1-bit Transformers for Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T17:59:15 | 2023-10-17T17:59:15 | Hongyu Wang, Shuming Ma, Li Dong, Shaohan Huang, Huaijie Wang, Lingxiao Ma, Fan Yang, Ruiping Wang, Yi Wu, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of large language models has posed challenges for
deployment and raised concerns about environmental impact due to high energy
consumption. In this work, we introduce BitNet, a scalable and stable 1-bit
Transformer architecture designed for large language models. Specifically, we
introduce BitLinear as a drop-in replacement of the nn.Linear layer in order to
train 1-bit weights from scratch. Experimental results on language modeling
show that BitNet achieves competitive performance while substantially reducing
memory footprint and energy consumption, compared to state-of-the-art 8-bit
quantization methods and FP16 Transformer baselines. Furthermore, BitNet
exhibits a scaling law akin to full-precision Transformers, suggesting its
potential for effective scaling to even larger language models while
maintaining efficiency and performance benefits. | [
-0.0353145711,
0.0752552152,
0.0108068325,
0.0593683049,
-0.0061454661,
0.0011061118,
0.0668765977,
0.0080822073,
-0.0533108935,
-0.0315771587,
0.0251905899,
-0.0435209051,
0.0031913852,
0.0307784751,
0.0135472892,
-0.0214562621,
0.0211272351,
0.0166147016,
-0.0465394333,
-0.0169199128,
-0.0018751839,
0.0175693296,
0.0014627657,
0.0503293015,
0.00225265,
0.0050522937,
-0.0296221524,
0.0238062888,
0.0101547902,
0.0110402945,
0.0066351457,
0.0414026007,
0.0347259901,
0.0496153012,
0.0000018557,
0.0222375561,
-0.0218014922,
0.0010706467,
-0.0259856563,
0.019473603,
0.0423410088,
-0.0203646608,
-0.0610155202,
0.0285541415,
0.0058439136,
-0.0462000407,
0.0847786441,
0.0447709188,
0.0541964881,
0.0365245156,
-0.0127579216,
-0.0513527505,
0.0331307538,
-0.0258669555,
-0.0411370546,
0.0283812433,
0.0102249077,
0.0313384756,
-0.0513929464,
-0.0024356542,
-0.0345826894,
0.0208214615,
0.0358690284,
0.0123348963,
-0.0167188253,
0.0376446843,
-0.0678743944,
-0.018834196,
-0.0115327863,
0.029093286,
-0.0703779608,
-0.0248747095,
-0.023678299,
-0.0040537231,
-0.0621550381,
-0.0451470278,
-0.0247769542,
0.0391528606,
0.0228732396,
0.0334960893,
-0.0576496199,
-0.0207949802,
0.0343154296,
0.0238603596,
-0.0416546501,
0.0193931162,
0.0301989932,
0.0337441191,
-0.0111474888,
0.0142673645,
-0.0392833017,
-0.0353705846,
0.0183468908,
0.0052785804,
0.0198515188,
-0.010852525,
-0.0427985378,
-0.0312542841,
0.0012099015,
-0.0504961088,
0.0307768676,
0.0404818617,
-0.0172323976,
0.0101217311,
-0.0440002829,
0.0469919816,
-0.0396029539,
0.0211388301,
-0.0476236194,
-0.0015295087,
0.0121978307,
0.0076771365,
-0.0755323321,
-0.0049111983,
-0.0361906141,
-0.0202658717,
-0.0398632474,
-0.0244288091,
0.0223794617,
-0.0187284686,
0.0474767461,
0.0150234746,
-0.0362831168,
-0.01631747,
0.0506887138,
0.0759527385,
0.0095223999,
-0.0173041672,
0.0121506182,
-0.0683036298,
-0.0344122201,
0.0225975178,
-0.0013924325,
-0.0213013049,
0.0352518409,
0.0143510206,
0.0078861527,
-0.0441460088,
-0.0193268862,
0.0081008114,
-0.0138258692,
-0.0444199666,
-0.036829792,
-0.0701767206,
-0.0394776389,
-0.0112742642,
0.0058944752,
-0.0115479864,
0.0292027909,
0.035935659,
0.014259303,
0.0580289364,
-0.0302226432,
-0.04024316,
0.010884189,
-0.0130269593,
0.0441826247,
0.0787692294,
0.0605170354,
0.0313785151,
-0.0049201618,
-0.0174597707,
-0.0572954156,
0.0681489035,
0.0371664986,
-0.0053676493,
-0.0531638116,
-0.0370011628,
-0.0072383648,
0.0331566855,
0.0550747178,
0.0777551904,
-0.0555435717,
-0.0459825546,
0.032415688,
0.0246552154,
0.0473453775,
0.0572600104,
-0.0131903859,
0.0165676922,
-0.0212606732,
-0.0301587358,
-0.0241345093,
0.0571008585,
0.0392382555,
-0.02816003,
0.0009926669,
0.0766461939,
-0.0483667031,
-0.010375944,
-0.0239286199,
-0.0109291747,
0.0138639221,
0.0012692126,
0.0453176834,
0.046547126,
-0.0147916023,
0.1579213142,
0.0460877903,
-0.0618231371,
-0.0241695158,
-0.0859460682,
-0.0399854556,
0.0062288512,
0.0411368459,
0.0259539653,
-0.0011812191,
-0.0166319478,
0.0040622256,
0.0389940925,
0.0039690114,
0.0017202976,
0.009198376,
-0.0842260271,
-0.0054597468,
0.028292058,
-0.0115334122,
0.016320698,
0.0164423659,
0.0302088037,
0.0068383813,
-0.0249436591,
-0.001199646,
0.0181370508,
-0.006713131,
-0.0376259461,
0.0470372401,
0.0003299422,
0.0047667553,
0.0096145822,
-0.0167247597,
-0.023528114,
0.0465598479,
-0.042940706,
-0.0104107736,
-0.0142421704,
-0.0107519655,
-0.0020829667,
0.0444704965,
-0.0102987569,
0.0465892218,
0.0633682832,
-0.0453506783,
-0.0381983221,
0.033239156,
-0.0308790486,
0.0340847112,
-0.0451071039,
0.0015812464,
-0.0167520698,
0.0717094243,
-0.0441136323,
-0.0003869825,
-0.0080539323,
0.0302319843,
-0.0132040866,
0.0048922347,
0.0315686688,
-0.0056791455,
-0.0687240586,
0.0105366604,
-0.0124707054,
0.0358118676,
-0.0001155283,
-0.0012999525,
0.0250425078,
-0.0157576073,
-0.0870509744,
0.0312053952,
-0.0642785504,
0.0329209119,
0.0223978758,
0.0498709828,
0.0414798371,
-0.0093500931,
-0.0334666222,
0.0119984914,
-0.0439465493,
0.0042844093,
-0.0077982657,
-0.0138448942,
-0.0349664688,
-0.0149658546,
-0.0785172284,
0.0196667984,
0.056943994,
-0.0328224972,
0.0140662128,
-0.0607276261,
-0.0126302503,
-0.0046747387,
0.0474657975,
-0.0228528827,
-0.0551001504,
0.0046522827,
-0.0227022003,
0.0110589648,
0.0380732603,
0.0166629925,
0.0076921284,
0.0651105568,
0.019429801,
-0.044983115,
0.0192797203,
-0.012926125,
-0.0281872898,
-0.0061102342,
-0.0076372353,
-0.0684070587,
0.0751993656,
-0.0454503521,
-0.0091387974,
-0.028898634,
-0.0138410656,
-0.0204629134,
0.0053220638,
-0.0184339751,
0.0152810793,
-0.026253799,
0.0180314593,
0.0064596743,
-0.0189100411,
0.0128917992,
-0.0298572406,
-0.0290368684,
-0.0097180167,
-0.0268916432,
-0.0141120385,
0.0515298434,
0.036889527,
0.0452708676,
-0.0204432607,
-0.0128058605,
-0.040898595,
-0.0152385933,
-0.0049575688,
-0.0371838138,
0.0617932975,
-0.0086281719,
0.0322673358,
-0.0552757233,
-0.0395998955,
-0.0165927261,
0.0132822907,
-0.0343669988,
0.0175637081,
0.0330474786,
-0.0630846545,
-0.0238760486,
0.0854544565,
0.0150955189,
0.0484535359,
-0.0089111496,
-0.0193521399,
-0.0081189005,
0.0533277728,
0.0386007018,
0.0163223445,
0.0647757724,
-0.0010801805,
-0.0142591372,
0.0589918718,
0.0194553602,
0.0501996092,
-0.1008704007,
-0.0281041991,
0.0366199911,
0.0057491791,
-0.0026883571,
-0.0116968704,
0.0367230326,
-0.0150261344,
-0.0016834699,
0.0633776858,
0.012279802,
-0.0548139997,
0.0110210245,
-0.0109233223,
0.0458071344,
-0.0169913676,
0.0096169645,
-0.0893690884,
-0.031761162,
0.0067437133,
-0.0158315245,
0.0208412297,
-0.0070106969,
-0.0141423959,
-0.0348232426,
0.0055179424,
0.0082312617,
0.0212589316,
-0.023347171,
-0.0364446081,
-0.0279148426,
-0.070276238,
0.0484859012,
0.0124441143,
-0.0148766013,
-0.0354843028,
0.0196816325,
0.0311247092,
-0.0114156362,
0.0262231976,
-0.0394422188,
0.0357246585,
0.0475272238,
0.0093386956,
-0.0144156599,
-0.0167808551,
0.0163522828,
-0.0027981121,
-0.0065312427,
0.0039391615,
0.0434764773,
0.0380163863,
-0.0269322693,
0.018592177,
-0.0254071839,
-0.0451502949,
-0.0060924059,
-0.0327202156,
0.0272790119,
0.0053122519,
-0.0164376218,
-0.0031658458,
-0.0241360646,
-0.0229112282,
0.0249083936,
0.0050031682,
-0.0199674219,
-0.0466097891,
-0.0116291735,
0.0160546266,
-0.0387577675,
-0.0768979639,
0.0062449449,
0.0173918847,
-0.0910625011,
-0.014624835,
0.0234415457,
0.0220438465,
0.0133666527,
-0.0072491169,
-0.090575777,
0.0721299872,
0.024792837,
-0.0863798633,
0.001911017,
-0.0265275221,
0.0584727675,
-0.0593802147,
0.0139497966,
0.0610797629,
0.0004616392,
-0.0117538609,
-0.0018407481,
-0.1560148299,
-0.034362793,
0.0252964459,
-0.003592215,
0.0212437846,
0.0089875311,
0.0198507775,
-0.0364692695,
0.0580523461,
0.0469561853,
0.0305419136,
0.0247905012,
0.0210677553,
-0.0672473386,
-0.0056450916,
0.0441316813,
-0.0191459972,
0.0657399818,
-0.0129646631,
0.0078483913,
-0.0549378246,
-0.0411557332,
0.0011618057,
0.0061015617,
0.0664144009,
-0.0086415429,
0.013302749,
0.0132289575,
0.0375586674,
0.0092025399,
0.0508241542,
-0.0508414581,
0.0031584154,
0.0108784242,
-0.0137674585,
-0.0080340458,
0.0227793399,
0.0549865738,
-0.0312011447,
0.0366050154,
0.0126396492,
-0.0466586985,
0.0174299739,
0.0720926896,
0.0100921588,
-0.0262195785,
-0.0082275476,
0.0523960888,
0.0422785915,
-0.0374417938,
0.0249749031,
0.0186738465,
0.0267298669,
-0.0454021469,
0.0429988317,
-0.019995572,
-0.0439693443,
-0.0518588386,
-0.0516182818,
0.0312264655,
0.0263008997,
0.0369756147,
-0.0130539592,
-0.0166842453,
-0.0010321537,
0.026043918,
-0.0104267178,
-0.0184258986,
0.0572856329,
0.0043298956,
-0.0103099346,
0.0086965552,
0.0359776728,
-0.0412301309,
0.0244125146,
0.0063861357,
0.0397351906,
-0.0165661164,
-0.0306083858,
-0.1003765911,
-0.0169032235,
0.0014320362,
-0.020986842,
-0.0106490608,
-0.0275079943,
-0.0006410413,
0.0129172103,
0.0108522149,
-0.0367420875,
0.0268082228,
0.0066644391,
0.0203380473,
-0.0233400948,
0.009893164,
0.0001623894,
0.0041535595,
-0.0041292412,
-0.0228284039,
-6.045591324e-33,
-0.0166015606,
0.0224196315,
0.0272260718,
0.0071265609,
-0.0105103124,
0.0314539112,
0.0016188509,
0.0083861016,
-0.055471994,
-0.0005542146,
-0.018586386,
0.0167881995,
0.0262489766,
0.0273500662,
-0.0030729761,
0.0075276024,
0.0894923508,
-0.010140216,
0.0065561435,
0.0493432917,
0.0104630515,
0.0001672936,
0.0555271618,
0.0056631477,
-0.0732686892,
0.0076239803,
-0.0208529793,
-0.0095650647,
0.003636694,
0.0113597475,
-0.0265808161,
0.0539512895,
0.0006391797,
-0.0429821238,
-0.0147495195,
-0.0061698803,
-0.0745620653,
0.0022564414,
-0.0299063642,
0.0752307847,
0.0290873833,
-0.012098561,
0.0375105701,
0.0180715937,
-0.01737036,
-0.0411580727,
0.0028242024,
0.0079120528,
-0.0347081311,
-0.0470494218,
-0.0177924167,
0.0200840794,
0.0262038279,
-0.0015594775,
0.0349888988,
0.0114255724,
-0.0419013202,
-0.0016862011,
-0.0766509473,
-0.0056445813,
0.0311326981,
0.0786148682,
0.0408988856,
0.0274358727,
-0.0075672609,
0.0485296734,
0.0331236795,
-0.053115949,
-0.0323339216,
0.0183189642,
0.0863799006,
0.022092171,
0.0569546707,
0.0087686516,
0.0897783041,
-0.0456207506,
-0.0439969525,
-0.011046621,
0.0276535302,
0.0251023658,
0.0195582733,
0.0256199092,
0.0311010256,
-0.017945854,
-0.0014602254,
-0.0148725761,
-0.0297563151,
-0.056490276,
-0.018175656,
0.0118386159,
-0.0237076748,
0.0090473648,
0.0348749645,
-0.0615495332,
-0.0118139656,
0.0174276829,
-0.0016303891,
0.0246179439,
0.0047529815,
0.0469609573,
-0.055237826,
-0.0269119032,
-0.0093016922,
0.0078403922,
0.0124475127,
0.0335721299,
0.0295507032,
0.0668273121,
-0.0704228729,
-0.0182128027,
-0.0490540899,
-0.0016585932,
0.0164080169,
0.0898556113,
0.0125765819,
0.0213865321,
0.0033943215,
0.0101593183,
-0.0316807367,
0.0029752599,
-0.002935495,
0.0561037399,
0.0492857546,
0.0415953733,
-0.0621212684,
0.0104793925,
-0.0670894161,
0.0326409265,
0.0529496782,
-0.069629617,
-0.0479625911,
0.0442917943,
2.549e-7,
0.0369795151,
0.0364587978,
0.0156486686,
-0.0036703635,
-0.0047586816,
0.0151638119,
0.0128891179,
0.0437919386,
0.0108814836,
0.0010705485,
0.0056384867,
0.010778618,
0.0351715051,
0.0233630072,
-0.064865008,
0.0019844801,
-0.040500991,
0.014050263,
0.0049939039,
-0.0340020396,
0.0131000709,
0.1238412112,
0.000389047,
-0.0195683707,
0.0544456616,
0.0069001848,
0.0300004035,
0.0067587937,
0.0415149443,
0.0052352925,
0.0030278149,
0.0260563865,
-0.0172095485,
-0.0219007265,
-0.0020781585,
-0.0065884511,
-0.0435710661,
0.0453723073,
-0.0459631421,
-0.0067414655,
0.0051255235,
-0.0266583655,
-0.0547441989,
-0.016552344,
0.0426032506,
-0.0609516315,
-0.0159375183,
-0.0816903189,
-0.0258785021,
0.0085892156,
-0.0047387551,
-0.0080314875,
-0.0044863173,
0.0459836051,
0.0194837302,
-0.0367956907,
-0.0118860956,
-0.0888887197,
-0.0282501187,
0.0113469725,
-0.0319061913,
-0.0210627709,
-0.0373054259,
-0.0591541193,
0.0022152697,
0.00828279,
-0.0176853947,
2.271008938e-34,
0.0292907804,
0.008039711,
0.0139945159,
0.0270724203,
-0.0348650515,
-0.0019861981,
0.0349188931,
-0.0084281005,
-0.0697582066,
-0.0589255393,
-0.0416399091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11451v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11451v2 | Seeking Neural Nuggets: Knowledge Transfer in Large Language Models from a Parametric Perspective | 2023-10-17T17:58:34 | 2024-05-08T12:11:00 | Ming Zhong, Chenxin An, Weizhu Chen, Jiawei Han, Pengcheng He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently encode a wealth of knowledge within
their parameters through pre-training on extensive corpora. While prior
research has delved into operations on these parameters to manipulate the
underlying implicit knowledge (encompassing detection, editing, and merging),
there remains an ambiguous understanding regarding their transferability across
models with varying scales. In this paper, we seek to empirically investigate
knowledge transfer from larger to smaller models through a parametric
perspective. To achieve this, we employ sensitivity-based techniques to extract
and align knowledge-specific parameters between different LLMs. Moreover, the
LoRA module is used as the intermediary mechanism for injecting the extracted
knowledge into smaller models. Evaluations across four benchmarks validate the
efficacy of our proposed method. Our findings highlight the critical factors
contributing to the process of parametric knowledge transfer, underscoring the
transferability of model parameters across LLMs of different scales. Project
website: https://maszhongming.github.io/ParaKnowTransfer. | [
0.0428604931,
0.0560330674,
-0.039799381,
0.0528879687,
-0.0182258021,
0.0122071719,
-0.0143559836,
0.0145013509,
-0.0343859158,
-0.0345433243,
-0.0941445678,
-0.0027468349,
0.0196784176,
0.0211278386,
0.0471276119,
-0.0448306613,
0.0425521545,
-0.046804864,
-0.0389630869,
0.0075106909,
0.0004538323,
-0.000884441,
0.0310587436,
0.0104966965,
0.0266753193,
-0.0041469,
-0.0061116656,
0.0101918383,
0.0176758431,
0.0305711906,
0.0034998658,
0.0440593101,
0.0012756672,
0.0635686889,
0.0000018182,
-0.0429136679,
-0.0315983109,
0.0051094084,
-0.0299945362,
0.0467917956,
0.056965664,
-0.0312692448,
-0.0087404558,
-0.0066271313,
-0.0338333584,
0.0071468395,
0.0615599528,
0.030680852,
0.0434395894,
0.0822254792,
-0.0083993962,
0.0036126622,
0.0528889038,
-0.0516194738,
-0.0344830863,
-0.0349359475,
0.0441779345,
-0.0036580418,
-0.0602032468,
-0.0041654939,
-0.021712495,
0.0443720929,
0.0021532956,
-0.0292976666,
0.0145350862,
0.0100752553,
-0.0180294141,
-0.0097602643,
-0.0004299828,
0.0716852769,
-0.040625751,
-0.0107625732,
-0.006510864,
-0.0147872055,
0.0130255213,
0.0256497934,
-0.0707189366,
-0.0305383299,
0.024083605,
0.0192694813,
-0.0081619769,
-0.0485058352,
0.0556942001,
0.005077811,
-0.0074555399,
0.0333140716,
0.0525022298,
-0.0268777199,
0.0072183744,
-0.0100221373,
-0.0074855001,
-0.0845541656,
-0.0036827924,
0.0550204851,
0.015931461,
0.0267457236,
-0.0594693385,
-0.0100057218,
0.0308682863,
-0.0484049059,
0.0824139491,
0.0094425911,
-0.0017285706,
0.049844157,
-0.0733867809,
0.0668381304,
-0.0220204107,
0.0307381805,
-0.032758452,
-0.0271646809,
-0.0642369315,
-0.0230274312,
-0.0064915759,
0.0283468831,
-0.0150949741,
-0.008831366,
-0.0208728276,
0.0129427584,
0.0203978345,
-0.0043045878,
0.0126390718,
-0.0299767219,
-0.0234464817,
-0.0255499296,
-0.0270234216,
0.0686319321,
0.0002859134,
0.0551921353,
0.0120528759,
-0.0418137871,
-0.0300651044,
-0.0067916643,
0.0276737269,
-0.0571782328,
-0.0006213901,
0.0627364069,
-0.0487163886,
-0.0188741013,
-0.0607294589,
-0.0152695468,
0.0052322843,
-0.059579771,
0.0228408147,
-0.057978563,
0.0382561013,
-0.0141916648,
-0.0047103022,
-0.0575363263,
-0.009174238,
0.0014040967,
-0.0563774705,
0.0539077036,
-0.0070538362,
0.031868808,
0.0301265419,
0.0119641749,
-0.0163829438,
0.0701437891,
0.0396561772,
0.0274195503,
0.0230359733,
-0.0285552684,
-0.0354778208,
0.0468631685,
0.0517116487,
0.0267614126,
-0.0453121848,
-0.0133631472,
0.0326495357,
0.0055652154,
0.0815451741,
0.0290241782,
-0.0344506167,
0.0121757481,
0.1055527776,
0.0246592499,
0.0545866936,
0.0283983182,
0.0601731949,
-0.0326733999,
0.032232862,
-0.0080140661,
-0.0410525762,
0.0312354341,
-0.0261294283,
0.0060773678,
0.0233573988,
0.0500019565,
-0.0303055868,
-0.020299565,
-0.0051350808,
0.0090974309,
-0.0201076996,
-0.022422716,
0.0372129492,
0.0453177579,
-0.0088962056,
0.0641833395,
0.0504319258,
-0.0169514436,
0.0337148122,
-0.0433711223,
0.0091570392,
0.0250204708,
0.0143438904,
-0.0210204422,
-0.0177361276,
0.0203702413,
-0.0111913076,
0.0302670822,
0.0707697421,
-0.0242610928,
0.0121886423,
-0.0310961008,
-0.0141178239,
-0.0313979164,
0.0218949057,
0.0337109081,
0.0356880762,
0.038161438,
0.0139302537,
-0.038164679,
-0.0209028702,
0.0189697873,
-0.0750066787,
-0.0258282963,
-0.0309548602,
-0.0005675015,
0.0200929046,
-0.0155587308,
-0.0193850063,
0.0010094077,
-0.0065973792,
-0.0175126903,
-0.017150281,
0.0153562855,
-0.0316189975,
-0.0198909845,
0.0299140923,
0.0349073857,
0.0012257745,
0.0215406492,
-0.0234469753,
-0.024583783,
0.032643348,
0.0124411779,
0.0784959197,
-0.030760495,
0.0523368269,
0.0009557092,
0.0230903998,
-0.0192376617,
0.0426075608,
0.0097497506,
-0.0095029827,
-0.0043246965,
-0.0161997024,
0.0014383132,
0.0167425107,
0.0119500197,
0.0086623458,
-0.0098832715,
0.0136174327,
-0.0051223226,
-0.0097218519,
-0.0492558368,
-0.0554280914,
-0.047569003,
-0.0012273612,
0.0018927038,
0.0344284996,
0.0620199963,
0.0112590529,
-0.0038129918,
0.0056090453,
-0.0223271064,
0.0345381312,
-0.0453118272,
0.0381115973,
0.03566752,
0.0286853444,
-0.0065295128,
-0.0800320208,
0.0008329619,
0.0069905254,
0.0553082153,
0.0043925955,
-0.0052775433,
-0.0631050169,
0.0276005864,
-0.0355247855,
0.012131176,
-0.012692621,
-0.07231199,
-0.019883303,
-0.0334103853,
0.0336996093,
0.0559664741,
-0.0377141312,
-0.0109491209,
0.0795587227,
-0.0300820712,
-0.0425432138,
-0.0111486651,
-0.0071903262,
-0.0416340791,
-0.0691422224,
-0.0025306735,
-0.0013672145,
0.0842705965,
-0.0156275555,
-0.0397839658,
-0.0463477299,
0.0006137317,
-0.0246194638,
-0.0313317217,
-0.0341531187,
-0.0063037225,
-0.0099679753,
0.0235430785,
-0.0515756272,
-0.0531791449,
0.0299416054,
-0.0466147922,
0.0100362115,
-0.0058556367,
-0.0167204645,
-0.0372717008,
0.0560628287,
-0.002021827,
0.0315478481,
-0.0299934186,
-0.0332390182,
-0.0776763856,
0.0014138328,
0.018190382,
-0.0037467328,
0.0309051741,
-0.0739799663,
0.0168276001,
-0.0170709584,
-0.0042746686,
-0.0101903975,
-0.0260104425,
0.0023051458,
0.0470387116,
0.0200451594,
-0.045980908,
0.0034449312,
-0.0193973891,
0.0312746167,
0.0746745467,
-0.0099814851,
-0.0119690457,
-0.0250379071,
0.0205298718,
0.0633413196,
0.0252396949,
0.0263707731,
-0.0357188284,
0.0233341679,
0.0348897912,
0.0271312464,
-0.0024288988,
-0.0234423541,
0.0181059428,
0.0062606004,
-0.0505794547,
-0.0092753656,
-0.0086857835,
0.0374359712,
-0.0393547155,
0.0002476662,
0.0820579156,
0.0064796163,
-0.0452396385,
0.0070035583,
-0.0468909293,
0.029896101,
0.0390920416,
0.0248608328,
-0.0254885685,
-0.0124919862,
0.0150785465,
-0.0323426276,
0.0052751368,
-0.0406908467,
-0.0271397438,
-0.1203038171,
-0.0088271033,
-0.0019174924,
-0.0452224314,
-0.0532676764,
0.0070051891,
0.0442514941,
0.0190688372,
0.0243887175,
-0.0088475756,
-0.0477589406,
-0.0202135835,
0.008638585,
0.0180874411,
-0.0290072151,
0.0160634927,
-0.0441767573,
0.0643001795,
0.0129412403,
0.0402990505,
-0.0041716602,
0.0083809523,
0.0291413069,
-0.0192070026,
-0.0017967724,
0.0107129635,
0.061073713,
0.0125872949,
-0.0051299562,
0.0340464339,
-0.0063741403,
-0.0150888227,
-0.0096141482,
0.0097904112,
0.0655818135,
0.0312471353,
-0.0338968448,
0.0368870348,
-0.0297927186,
-0.0070773223,
0.0719853044,
0.050867945,
0.0062752073,
0.0174888168,
0.0157526806,
-0.032432951,
0.0283777248,
-0.0395785309,
0.0319481455,
-0.0439650379,
0.0004116427,
-0.1067604646,
-0.0146414833,
0.0319887437,
0.0157561339,
0.0495424122,
0.0343177915,
0.0130767552,
-0.0360381156,
-0.0218479,
0.0337960906,
-0.0479812659,
-0.017542161,
-0.0412172228,
-0.0179647338,
0.001448252,
-0.0394854546,
-0.0316157453,
-0.0124488724,
-0.09785413,
-0.0764334649,
-0.00211339,
0.0267031863,
0.0228733532,
0.0523009896,
-0.0196607001,
-0.0682228133,
0.0734705776,
-0.0164184328,
-0.045240283,
0.0395294428,
0.0268554743,
-0.0215764809,
-0.0152634168,
0.0589051992,
-0.0567503273,
-0.018431535,
0.0513747744,
0.013716463,
-0.0211397335,
-0.025668297,
0.0068908264,
0.0114480797,
0.0069068871,
0.020660378,
0.0051686023,
-0.0668460652,
0.0434163287,
-0.0214285366,
0.0207957365,
-0.0560233705,
-0.0414235815,
0.0489856116,
0.0434944481,
-0.0119429529,
-0.0015859526,
0.0322603732,
0.0226317253,
-0.001167567,
-0.0551886894,
0.0239332356,
0.0379636846,
0.0547446683,
0.0320073143,
-0.0029958128,
0.01441448,
-0.0129758148,
0.0280775577,
-0.0362330899,
0.0156703703,
0.0173613112,
-0.0066005564,
-0.026986124,
0.0223556943,
-0.057118088,
-0.0792594776,
-0.0042003375,
-0.0007652625,
0.0565770417,
-0.0286033601,
0.0915721655,
-0.0353562869,
-0.0288039632,
-0.0033820779,
0.0203856211,
-0.0291894935,
0.0128725329,
0.0306495056,
0.0062217079,
0.0048360117,
0.035767436,
0.0765106007,
0.0122092599,
0.1009082496,
-0.0393479466,
0.0143334772,
-0.0059215156,
-0.0142786261,
0.0580762103,
-0.0201738626,
-0.0192260165,
0.0114792883,
-0.020100126,
-0.0787219033,
-0.0184053015,
-0.043275971,
-0.0475835651,
0.0037357532,
-0.0031376898,
0.0592590235,
-0.0341422297,
-0.0164387729,
-0.0436729193,
-0.0163582135,
0.0042041428,
0.0009708681,
0.0276316907,
-6.70279295e-33,
-0.0533551797,
0.0078103384,
0.0293252356,
0.0146284848,
-0.0268328134,
0.0033406657,
-0.0303193294,
-0.0201823637,
-0.0177092683,
0.0251187868,
-0.0157060698,
0.0192700233,
0.0031563547,
0.0034820952,
0.0158925373,
-0.0159724187,
0.0430123359,
0.0070588836,
0.0013286134,
0.0163270123,
0.0199976545,
0.0245829411,
0.0848646611,
-0.0378185101,
0.0158352088,
0.0594316572,
0.0087920846,
0.0316669978,
-0.0322441868,
0.0624946766,
-0.0235535987,
0.0186470784,
0.0191061236,
-0.0308996923,
-0.030396888,
0.0010728189,
-0.0707264394,
-0.0529140569,
0.0509035476,
-0.0022941546,
-0.0016672541,
-0.0629369617,
0.0594684407,
-0.0162058491,
0.0571918525,
-0.0593341738,
0.0289668553,
-0.0186906289,
0.0078063863,
-0.0013115084,
-0.0944925398,
0.0156382136,
0.0102745276,
0.0062055769,
0.0366711393,
-0.015103884,
0.0136977118,
-0.0081138955,
-0.060237281,
-0.0184145272,
0.0438451432,
0.0919173583,
0.0410459749,
0.0175343025,
-0.0151372747,
0.0573893972,
-0.0013265113,
-0.0020836568,
0.0231885016,
0.0175404847,
0.035206534,
0.0495772436,
0.0194201432,
0.0388880707,
0.0031225127,
0.0034770267,
-0.0625357777,
-0.0226022378,
-0.0105427783,
0.0416358523,
-0.019689953,
0.0038891153,
0.0128252562,
0.0001122689,
-0.0626298562,
-0.0418461524,
-0.050687544,
-0.0212689303,
0.0243487433,
0.0139786014,
0.0174418688,
-0.0251428783,
0.0210928041,
-0.0202117637,
-0.015092371,
0.0038261036,
-0.0139669795,
0.0357509218,
0.0086645354,
0.0182806812,
-0.0910359547,
-0.0262593701,
0.0156914946,
-0.0005022303,
0.0268061701,
0.0159344431,
0.0518625341,
0.0504020937,
-0.0559776723,
-0.0052582426,
-0.0409579463,
0.0191094447,
0.0170720574,
-0.0155776907,
0.0150339082,
0.0112847583,
-0.0168672167,
0.0132986056,
0.0494688861,
0.0089530023,
0.002572821,
0.0140305338,
0.0303427987,
0.0289546382,
-0.0356814601,
-0.0247689281,
-0.0412169844,
-0.016564291,
0.0707539842,
-0.0312362891,
-0.0162245445,
-0.0009297375,
2.724e-7,
0.0437794365,
0.0329390168,
-0.0122366929,
-0.006802774,
0.0235657394,
0.0112121236,
-0.059646219,
0.034088932,
0.0235731099,
-0.0079294043,
-0.0003638201,
0.0355141275,
0.0541053452,
0.01681716,
-0.0846213549,
-0.0474273264,
-0.0503873266,
-0.0100642079,
-0.0322251059,
-0.0441323444,
-0.0169249419,
0.0639127567,
0.0380748734,
-0.0316298008,
-0.0154831875,
-0.0508606061,
0.0720495507,
-0.0417320132,
0.0002487116,
0.0488182232,
0.0510516465,
-0.0133124366,
-0.0078779394,
0.0336411521,
-0.0085300775,
0.0361184105,
0.0095904218,
0.0881655961,
-0.0138713382,
0.0001193332,
-0.0276182853,
-0.0197200198,
-0.0063520223,
-0.0803625658,
0.0670158491,
-0.0513144471,
-0.0247875936,
-0.0113168759,
-0.0140943741,
-0.0243132804,
-0.0085102841,
-0.0192354657,
0.0038673892,
0.0228401981,
0.0222040862,
0.0363073424,
-0.0575659685,
-0.0683899075,
-0.0271228347,
0.012973153,
-0.0202574059,
-0.0892400593,
-0.0591906905,
-0.0509663187,
0.0191829912,
-0.0702939108,
0.0308165066,
2.394926936e-34,
-0.0082035875,
-0.0062647816,
0.0329060182,
0.0113337198,
0.0355391763,
-0.022943493,
-0.0228991415,
0.0262000579,
-0.0080326078,
-0.1082069427,
0.0137894098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13014v1 | Large Language Model Prediction Capabilities: Evidence from a Real-World Forecasting Tournament | 2023-10-17T17:58:17 | 2023-10-17T17:58:17 | Philipp Schoenegger, Peter S. Park | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Accurately predicting the future would be an important milestone in the
capabilities of artificial intelligence. However, research on the ability of
large language models to provide probabilistic predictions about future events
remains nascent. To empirically test this ability, we enrolled OpenAI's
state-of-the-art large language model, GPT-4, in a three-month forecasting
tournament hosted on the Metaculus platform. The tournament, running from July
to October 2023, attracted 843 participants and covered diverse topics
including Big Tech, U.S. politics, viral outbreaks, and the Ukraine conflict.
Focusing on binary forecasts, we show that GPT-4's probabilistic forecasts are
significantly less accurate than the median human-crowd forecasts. We find that
GPT-4's forecasts did not significantly differ from the no-information
forecasting strategy of assigning a 50% probability to every question. We
explore a potential explanation, that GPT-4 might be predisposed to predict
probabilities close to the midpoint of the scale, but our data do not support
this hypothesis. Overall, we find that GPT-4 significantly underperforms in
real-world predictive tasks compared to median human-crowd forecasts. A
potential explanation for this underperformance is that in real-world
forecasting tournaments, the true answers are genuinely unknown at the time of
prediction; unlike in other benchmark tasks like professional exams or time
series forecasting, where strong performance may at least partly be due to the
answers being memorized from the training data. This makes real-world
forecasting tournaments an ideal environment for testing the generalized
reasoning and prediction capabilities of artificial intelligence going forward. | [
0.0258863661,
0.1007252857,
-0.0184784494,
0.0255957786,
-0.0222676396,
-0.0179897789,
0.019156456,
0.0001167814,
0.0277116504,
-0.0051834057,
0.0305270925,
-0.0602264702,
-0.0029589413,
0.0493057407,
-0.0028590756,
-0.0751690492,
0.006542549,
-0.037465293,
0.0219849069,
-0.0358743556,
-0.0150857279,
-0.0115877818,
0.0060233292,
0.0585751683,
-0.0081131402,
0.0068739923,
-0.0259425081,
-0.033163663,
-0.0084462464,
-0.0275012925,
0.0235955436,
0.0162924789,
0.0299448185,
0.0449851044,
0.0000019705,
-0.0636789724,
0.0050902753,
-0.0229388885,
-0.0144642349,
-0.0064641247,
0.0087833898,
-0.0147275189,
0.0288836807,
0.0320707522,
-0.0909854546,
-0.0079085222,
0.0350737497,
0.0110753709,
0.022753641,
0.0433808155,
0.001697974,
-0.016558826,
0.0647490844,
-0.0220377073,
-0.0172776766,
-0.0723261386,
0.0159082823,
-0.0564464219,
-0.0405441746,
-0.0243096892,
-0.0075433822,
0.0186185874,
0.0165015385,
0.0433660559,
-0.0238161888,
0.0815763623,
-0.0243053511,
-0.0202760659,
-0.0320989229,
0.0143727949,
0.0205052309,
-0.0345725231,
-0.0031377929,
-0.0067764674,
-0.0255388413,
0.0385384783,
-0.0597585291,
-0.0002809083,
0.0147310402,
0.0411129631,
0.0380290598,
0.0178974606,
0.034887936,
0.0431448482,
-0.0098592797,
0.1321685761,
-0.0149896285,
-0.0171642564,
-0.0188496839,
0.0281170104,
-0.0095347706,
-0.0526863933,
-0.0097106108,
0.0291239023,
-0.0279363152,
0.0057177087,
0.0019477698,
-0.0084490953,
-0.023880627,
-0.0598079376,
0.0312591121,
0.0546884611,
0.0406346284,
0.0354603752,
-0.007663263,
0.0316245072,
0.0263049547,
0.0002615659,
-0.0200304277,
-0.0315022282,
-0.0581484102,
0.0090666907,
-0.0069693979,
-0.0079146866,
-0.0018972537,
-0.0109197218,
-0.0209813565,
-0.0471858084,
-0.0174393039,
0.0313020907,
0.0294716079,
0.0217155013,
-0.0499673039,
-0.0667649359,
-0.074309893,
0.0180918388,
-0.0554060228,
0.0188688263,
-0.0108675053,
-0.062060792,
0.0106299976,
-0.0027011223,
-0.015614152,
0.0044918326,
0.0145437876,
0.0422174335,
0.0104919616,
0.029559616,
-0.0279085953,
-0.0261154398,
-0.0015443309,
-0.055473417,
0.0143665904,
-0.0039823684,
0.0042642825,
0.0226992723,
0.0158192199,
-0.0009320937,
0.0171229132,
-0.0039794771,
-0.0322460122,
0.071039252,
0.0096640829,
0.028485503,
0.0262332726,
-0.0078539262,
0.0124986898,
0.0710461512,
0.0289003458,
0.0596536472,
0.0404987372,
0.0054468066,
0.0250876006,
0.0388133451,
0.0211657286,
-0.0044976841,
-0.0221822076,
0.0245404094,
-0.0065899529,
0.0163884666,
-0.0014514879,
0.0128426021,
0.0304135401,
-0.0018857361,
0.0855620801,
0.0234733205,
-0.0431338325,
0.0548324771,
0.0158123504,
-0.0518417507,
0.0084511172,
-0.0239642374,
-0.0202667415,
0.0333654843,
-0.0321520753,
0.0318036266,
0.0407219492,
-0.006192842,
-0.0225565545,
-0.0484670512,
-0.0283329636,
-0.00844838,
-0.006842765,
0.0082500726,
0.0406023003,
-0.0674952716,
-0.0480364002,
0.0462350436,
0.0213776324,
-0.0121503817,
0.0146084242,
-0.0524800643,
0.0332278498,
0.044167392,
-0.0034402933,
0.001192904,
-0.0213961005,
0.0168662239,
0.0141029246,
0.0386737622,
0.0630925223,
0.0157000665,
-0.0250458233,
-0.0489260443,
-0.001500568,
0.0329939388,
0.0321247652,
0.0104476595,
0.0293787215,
0.0361842811,
0.0006054819,
0.0013154465,
-0.0217244532,
0.0041151941,
-0.0432183258,
-0.0544377454,
0.0052595502,
-0.0002160022,
0.0471589118,
-0.0428114757,
0.0055384524,
0.0267919656,
0.0252134446,
-0.0307301655,
-0.049895782,
0.0199388545,
-0.0268598441,
0.0426159315,
0.0203585252,
-0.0044822884,
0.0169847254,
0.0499703474,
-0.0287490562,
-0.0170836952,
0.053232111,
0.0245729629,
0.0635743961,
-0.0325778089,
-0.0462429374,
-0.0149819003,
0.011258373,
0.0184737109,
0.0515705198,
-0.0053454763,
-0.0049129883,
-0.0248409435,
-0.0128699224,
0.0227017924,
-0.0207739938,
-0.0332066678,
0.0246054698,
0.029561149,
0.0102564879,
0.0242107827,
-0.0486061573,
-0.0372610241,
-0.0108893821,
-0.1130175367,
0.0122491112,
-0.0153391995,
0.0144405738,
0.0002622498,
-0.0421322137,
-0.0117343795,
-0.0074013509,
-0.0345170349,
0.0011302719,
-0.0026287858,
0.0010902807,
0.0168391895,
0.0168980733,
0.0328549668,
-0.0257674996,
0.0021326856,
-0.0406558998,
0.0404972509,
0.0486359484,
0.0270821583,
0.0108520761,
0.0003553242,
-0.0584129728,
0.0084301727,
-0.0169252586,
-0.0247537829,
-0.0179870613,
-0.0516309179,
0.0210420266,
0.0251450874,
0.0033479247,
-0.0010970653,
0.0365749523,
-0.0160286985,
-0.0300829411,
0.0285597332,
-0.0459529459,
-0.0507132262,
-0.0475715734,
-0.0258798972,
-0.0195208527,
0.0478536151,
0.0326406173,
0.0081857936,
-0.074040994,
0.0476669185,
-0.0395951085,
-0.0127346069,
-0.0530731454,
0.0181372948,
-0.0065740296,
0.0692177862,
0.0065982966,
-0.0627385676,
0.0564185604,
0.0136609674,
0.0178940203,
-0.017661823,
-0.0278459769,
-0.0358137898,
0.0387327746,
0.0033628126,
0.0024856818,
-0.0335899293,
0.0113140065,
-0.0649252832,
-0.0418884382,
-0.0080891727,
-0.0328206606,
-0.0059566488,
-0.0415520743,
-0.0067311553,
0.0087000811,
-0.0387621634,
-0.0097972844,
-0.0394841358,
-0.0815161616,
0.0162509643,
0.0278796535,
-0.0162861962,
-0.0420396253,
0.0080674291,
-0.0200193431,
-0.0279732943,
-0.0216943026,
-0.0290286653,
0.0431998298,
0.033771731,
0.059103962,
0.0197927356,
0.0152418818,
-0.043425031,
0.0040203244,
0.0047204546,
0.0771621391,
0.0315389931,
-0.0411519408,
0.0016369517,
0.0284296237,
-0.0025788404,
-0.0341043659,
0.0621285625,
0.0048128227,
-0.048944246,
-0.0011262797,
0.1211451888,
0.0358193405,
-0.0051634219,
-0.0068884143,
0.0022393225,
0.0300219432,
-0.003928218,
0.0175869223,
-0.0573652051,
-0.0298945624,
0.0339864567,
0.0194631629,
-0.0086526126,
-0.0699286535,
-0.0028271219,
-0.1142582372,
0.0334490128,
0.0036677832,
-0.0010990734,
-0.0095295841,
-0.0586222485,
-0.0085921511,
-0.0457501784,
-0.0027755438,
-0.0345692188,
0.0311957318,
0.0354052223,
0.0176869631,
-0.1097024977,
-0.0378507376,
0.0485422686,
-0.0149386944,
0.0224446822,
0.0723342448,
0.0626299158,
-0.0354693122,
0.0101678949,
-0.0365810879,
-0.0062777749,
0.0426467285,
0.0072786417,
0.0607929602,
0.0116657028,
-0.0024851833,
-0.0250961352,
0.0356993377,
-0.0266131833,
0.0140411481,
0.0526044182,
0.0914251879,
0.0144320605,
-0.0705833212,
0.002232288,
-0.010778388,
0.008785951,
0.0654765889,
-0.0095936125,
-0.0352082774,
-0.0454003625,
-0.0436686501,
0.0285808593,
-0.0301050115,
-0.0251871999,
-0.0087181479,
0.0450760424,
-0.0502678379,
-0.0405154414,
-0.0458729826,
0.0369015411,
-0.0116790524,
0.0162156634,
-0.0075857388,
0.0270192847,
0.0450301655,
-0.0164590273,
-0.0034832146,
-0.0110748876,
0.0138001805,
-0.0548068322,
0.0051782764,
0.0177538749,
-0.012531722,
-0.0190403014,
0.0545130819,
-0.1111171022,
-0.0490601361,
0.0214706343,
0.0395152569,
0.0303915553,
-0.0088421982,
0.0400137901,
-0.0054359385,
0.0580950566,
0.0444242023,
-0.0197510272,
0.0140983444,
0.0064850939,
0.0161350295,
0.0154699916,
0.0454734676,
0.0126185576,
0.0202187411,
0.0047604265,
-0.0034927512,
-0.03957773,
-0.0409376025,
-0.0190625489,
0.0144720161,
0.0860409811,
-0.0055758767,
-0.0598350912,
0.0053784251,
-0.0195210483,
0.0328514613,
0.0126933027,
0.0065346835,
-0.0165778678,
0.0548354127,
0.008910154,
-0.0295492616,
0.0462606996,
0.0217029434,
-0.0440172181,
-0.0458682142,
0.0071478006,
0.0357546508,
0.0343671516,
0.0363762863,
0.0071588876,
0.0065350425,
-0.0336692333,
0.0183018986,
0.0321534574,
0.0131588308,
0.0099721951,
-0.0078926934,
0.0127113881,
0.0265343357,
-0.054073777,
-0.1195438951,
-0.0958231911,
-0.0085560083,
0.0621170849,
0.0191512927,
-0.0122156274,
-0.0371303447,
-0.0825575367,
0.0093042888,
0.0039182878,
0.0005040016,
-0.0157328658,
-0.031610366,
0.0186912343,
-0.0280659795,
-0.0650736392,
0.0095433444,
0.0838170573,
0.0234827623,
0.069485724,
0.0483438633,
-0.0322582908,
-0.0161314886,
-0.0281219333,
0.0135906395,
0.0176556725,
-0.0108837169,
0.0290008578,
-0.0678431168,
-0.0256840643,
0.0148220882,
0.0044333604,
-0.0064155227,
-0.0409226194,
-0.0136710107,
0.044804886,
-0.0279361345,
0.0221223403,
-0.0226706434,
0.0311147664,
-0.0613069423,
-0.0040783612,
-0.0548977554,
-6.381128472e-33,
0.0081194937,
-0.0029606528,
0.0234821141,
-0.0343496576,
0.019271791,
0.0271881279,
-0.0429036953,
-0.0028783903,
-0.0496262424,
0.0161114857,
-0.0300422255,
-0.0023830086,
0.0058501773,
0.0158578251,
0.0799966007,
-0.0529055968,
0.0319561474,
-0.0362077244,
-0.0027098167,
0.0077536274,
0.0486729629,
0.0233410373,
0.0384663641,
-0.0342458263,
0.0176015496,
-0.0292102303,
-0.0270261019,
-0.0028145905,
0.0007280768,
0.0145744877,
-0.009447936,
0.0472271889,
0.0261385348,
-0.0562989935,
-0.0187255759,
0.0095802313,
0.022464931,
-0.0456018113,
-0.0167182162,
-0.0088095665,
-0.0013896711,
0.0198461842,
-0.0055116466,
0.0312600993,
-0.054733105,
-0.0127685731,
0.0417864695,
-0.0303664114,
0.0053826487,
-0.0225790963,
0.0077000144,
0.0009511203,
-0.0047379858,
0.0189201087,
0.001543907,
0.0582350045,
0.0078606401,
0.045373559,
-0.0594550781,
0.0459282324,
0.0026490777,
0.0128990309,
0.0405812114,
-0.0121194869,
0.0085085081,
0.045202069,
0.0482001901,
-0.0221496504,
-0.0669210032,
-0.0154796122,
0.0154282283,
0.0296721328,
0.0499174893,
0.0484965816,
0.0925454348,
-0.0415182263,
-0.0325365141,
0.0367579535,
0.0475108474,
0.0216775928,
0.0426217988,
-0.0013695377,
-0.0422228724,
-0.0372328348,
-0.0312396232,
-0.0131131159,
-0.0277342368,
-0.0121741444,
0.0018934147,
-0.0064045223,
0.0424856506,
0.0270039961,
0.0330310464,
-0.0320828706,
-0.0277232546,
0.04849343,
0.010731156,
-0.0026276808,
-0.0110810008,
0.0619206466,
-0.091872327,
-0.012231594,
-0.0320599526,
0.0254512671,
0.008540337,
0.0010822914,
-0.0259833019,
0.0381047428,
-0.0553927831,
-0.0188914668,
-0.0410180986,
0.0007967829,
0.0503546856,
-0.0023630848,
0.0548668355,
-0.006727295,
0.0284580756,
-0.0333362818,
-0.011408045,
0.0135905445,
0.014306562,
-0.0072345301,
-0.0029014891,
-0.0235618651,
-0.0114935506,
-0.0309663042,
-0.0481315441,
-0.0190725625,
0.0082001835,
-0.0289925616,
-0.0260901805,
0.0205130633,
2.637e-7,
0.0273124836,
0.0894131064,
-0.0435194485,
0.0195409376,
-0.0138969468,
0.0558057353,
-0.0457571968,
0.0153663913,
0.031949915,
0.0038529006,
0.0217653047,
0.0238906797,
0.073466979,
0.0600109138,
-0.0864938945,
-0.0481028408,
-0.1022441685,
0.0350992046,
-0.0573533401,
0.0201479457,
0.0507354699,
0.1125341505,
0.0779763535,
0.0025557824,
0.0431087613,
-0.0436973497,
0.0613358691,
-0.0386288576,
-0.0157454982,
0.0187817756,
-0.0094509088,
0.030297542,
-0.0363725387,
0.0451201797,
-0.0358079933,
-0.0149851758,
-0.0096295495,
0.0127954893,
0.0197478011,
0.0101530589,
-0.0090833316,
0.0104701342,
-0.0200351421,
-0.0699676275,
0.0838470683,
-0.051537957,
-0.0457512513,
-0.0197422542,
-0.0033626508,
0.0222917944,
0.0295721963,
-0.0038796158,
-0.0202145502,
0.0003583818,
-0.0240907799,
-0.0231682602,
0.0201920215,
-0.038743522,
-0.0225449391,
-0.0098313242,
-0.0608389303,
-0.0589074865,
-0.0520720184,
0.0014773899,
0.0461245812,
-0.0632490888,
0.0447221734,
2.203516507e-34,
0.0327725932,
0.0305589139,
-0.0190828051,
-0.029920388,
0.0530316904,
-0.0142859481,
0.0145347035,
0.0098742759,
0.0357668474,
-0.0455109961,
-0.0325837545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11446v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11446v2 | Functional Invariants to Watermark Large Transformers | 2023-10-17T17:56:18 | 2024-01-18T18:50:55 | Pierre Fernandez, Guillaume Couairon, Teddy Furon, Matthijs Douze | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid growth of transformer-based models increases the concerns about
their integrity and ownership insurance. Watermarking addresses this issue by
embedding a unique identifier into the model, while preserving its performance.
However, most existing approaches require to optimize the weights to imprint
the watermark signal, which is not suitable at scale due to the computational
cost. This paper explores watermarks with virtually no computational cost,
applicable to a non-blind white-box setting (assuming access to both the
original and watermarked networks). They generate functionally equivalent
copies by leveraging the models' invariance, via operations like dimension
permutations or scaling/unscaling. This enables to watermark models without any
change in their outputs and remains stealthy. Experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of the approach and its robustness against various model
transformations (fine-tuning, quantization, pruning), making it a practical
solution to protect the integrity of large models. | [
-0.0376528911,
0.0821662471,
0.0112037659,
0.0459259748,
-0.0375601947,
-0.0229620822,
0.0866986364,
-0.0097592156,
-0.0051515792,
-0.0119698895,
-0.040907871,
0.0148209017,
-0.0253285542,
0.046970956,
0.0496151559,
-0.0064307419,
0.007363542,
0.0124298958,
-0.075414069,
-0.0085259676,
-0.0309722479,
-0.0434407033,
0.0706148446,
-0.0082667582,
-0.0078662252,
-0.0006247783,
0.0078815483,
-0.012479797,
0.0150397066,
0.0161695015,
-0.0128261438,
0.0497898832,
-0.0198529288,
0.0919590294,
0.0000019617,
0.0433251411,
-0.0376409814,
0.0393643789,
-0.0240385123,
0.0427204147,
-0.0042175013,
0.0099862618,
-0.0188784711,
0.0002047516,
-0.0010411153,
0.0303239487,
0.0530597754,
0.0755451173,
0.067669265,
0.0247802678,
0.0030431182,
0.0072162477,
0.0342912637,
-0.0192689355,
-0.0260174759,
0.0046897293,
-0.0114730662,
0.012798992,
-0.0626963377,
-0.0089865038,
-0.0106151821,
0.0820043758,
0.0098664416,
-0.0280330721,
-0.0119827976,
-0.000173893,
-0.013924947,
0.0188757367,
-0.0051746299,
0.0082681924,
-0.0693515837,
-0.0345444307,
0.0133532351,
-0.0243045725,
0.0011968353,
0.0388350599,
-0.0049465331,
-0.0277804378,
0.0665155351,
0.0024959485,
-0.1052742824,
0.035533648,
0.0732696652,
-0.0398928337,
-0.0087776445,
0.0011008175,
0.0678922534,
0.019856194,
-0.0581144728,
-0.028593732,
-0.0541419201,
-0.019398516,
0.0417113602,
-0.0225887485,
0.0242206398,
-0.0312736146,
-0.0597159155,
-0.0348435938,
-0.0508562438,
-0.0042568911,
0.0582248643,
-0.033148177,
-0.0112830317,
0.0136035057,
-0.0633008182,
0.0731810033,
-0.1145245209,
0.0765523762,
-0.0170240533,
-0.0022804977,
0.0239073932,
-0.0566568598,
-0.0199810918,
0.036922466,
0.0022713318,
-0.0205353852,
-0.0102173211,
0.040696878,
-0.009170169,
-0.0309720561,
-0.0058672009,
0.019226769,
-0.0182920545,
-0.0195346661,
0.0596190244,
-0.0198704954,
0.0623485222,
-0.011863281,
0.0116723999,
-0.017742252,
-0.028124962,
0.0157626737,
0.0104150251,
0.0146266185,
0.0131699396,
0.0787848383,
0.0217241552,
-0.0626657754,
0.0498023815,
-0.0101133911,
0.0013210081,
0.0063680089,
0.0358412974,
0.0117826108,
-0.0223298296,
-0.0442494936,
0.0250407327,
-0.0634366721,
0.0011984532,
-0.0164013207,
0.0127645889,
0.0293908641,
0.0205228459,
-0.0184754152,
-0.0369118415,
-0.0249935128,
-0.0360547304,
-0.0035335603,
0.0270284656,
-0.0284240767,
0.0393526815,
-0.015927054,
0.0191272702,
0.0048057223,
0.0211010911,
0.0048647719,
-0.0067282366,
-0.0616675057,
0.0435097329,
-0.0473944135,
-0.0417428501,
0.0152629577,
-0.0273988321,
-0.0742089376,
0.063015759,
0.002053227,
0.0065802801,
0.018093314,
-0.0578847304,
-0.0035878709,
0.0128099434,
-0.0203786157,
-0.048798494,
0.023681758,
-0.0137259215,
-0.0397338383,
-0.0473466218,
0.0267702229,
-0.0520316251,
0.003357288,
-0.0104543073,
-0.0367469154,
0.0017103347,
0.0072909943,
0.0170645881,
0.0720912442,
-0.0197757278,
0.0972125828,
-0.0321178474,
-0.0378178954,
-0.0085680606,
-0.0699124634,
-0.0142464489,
-0.0311088469,
0.0567122363,
0.0200663432,
0.0473272055,
0.0177091919,
-0.0389414541,
0.0246896092,
-0.0459567346,
0.0105724093,
0.0144627299,
0.0059755212,
-0.0226763226,
-0.0047981138,
0.0312031358,
0.0123679601,
-0.001100164,
-0.0286055747,
0.030422125,
-0.0325298794,
0.0110518802,
-0.0288809258,
0.0235058721,
-0.0423132628,
0.0477797054,
-0.0253600571,
0.0279486608,
0.031771902,
0.0029949236,
0.0075065121,
0.0010157016,
-0.0047389911,
-0.0227042753,
-0.0152436858,
0.026436653,
0.113154754,
-0.0167422127,
-0.058108449,
0.038553223,
0.0811129361,
-0.0048728697,
-0.0069869854,
0.0068915659,
-0.036182709,
-0.0249426831,
-0.0114095593,
0.0167088248,
-0.0153910164,
0.0410052612,
-0.0136730252,
-0.0087283766,
0.0154623529,
-0.0093769664,
-0.010094204,
0.0106982579,
0.0025507247,
-0.0286157392,
-0.0516358875,
-0.0036415448,
-0.0238612629,
-0.003762614,
0.0051820059,
-0.0361818783,
0.0406118743,
-0.0084623722,
0.0180632416,
0.008741268,
0.0025772846,
0.0143202431,
0.0273686741,
0.0197383165,
0.0315029137,
0.0073887571,
0.0124901496,
-0.0468755737,
-0.0008515822,
-0.0150078535,
0.0054570795,
-0.032066714,
-0.0663518831,
0.0317316502,
-0.0431237072,
0.0156052811,
0.0993943363,
0.0021737923,
0.006141216,
-0.0627714097,
-0.0182836093,
-0.008146828,
0.0245641526,
-0.0112711014,
0.0135044418,
-0.0133699467,
0.0553037114,
-0.0433897376,
0.0814783722,
-0.0082858838,
-0.0047536823,
0.0031957002,
0.046312917,
0.0059767487,
-0.0130773252,
-0.0755770877,
-0.0213179588,
-0.0191600695,
0.0350256599,
0.0318228193,
0.0190880224,
-0.0398071818,
-0.0173215438,
0.0221846737,
0.0066538644,
0.0359724164,
0.0148922894,
0.0169236027,
-0.0148409642,
-0.0339702256,
-0.0185731091,
0.0126963714,
0.0019716474,
-0.013202033,
-0.03717421,
0.0201470573,
0.0270629711,
-0.0062249401,
0.0343308039,
0.0264783464,
0.0150759984,
0.0237914976,
0.0354137085,
0.0223577674,
-0.0031732677,
0.0057264799,
0.0746160522,
-0.0482650287,
-0.0368512645,
0.0189056564,
-0.0079615936,
0.0230191778,
-0.0158968996,
-0.0285435058,
-0.0215243585,
0.0174349844,
-0.0060796076,
0.0222060718,
-0.0080088414,
-0.0404289812,
0.0438194908,
0.0280646849,
0.0480830148,
-0.0203068629,
0.014627004,
-0.049732361,
0.0376395546,
-0.0492218398,
-0.0423089936,
0.0951853245,
-0.0007739986,
0.0136795891,
0.0123646287,
-0.0203296542,
0.0188734513,
-0.0298142023,
-0.0087780766,
0.0084277047,
0.00422672,
0.0048722262,
-0.0223099533,
0.0226465017,
0.0207501855,
0.0023318869,
-0.0096061714,
-0.0256215427,
-0.029291926,
0.0431751795,
0.0423029438,
0.012800565,
0.0351606011,
0.0121257976,
-0.0359942205,
0.0046415608,
0.0275026988,
0.0394414775,
-0.0532452874,
0.0000869644,
-0.0077540646,
-0.0185413249,
-0.0012807157,
0.0488067009,
0.0298423804,
-0.0150471628,
-0.0233742055,
-0.0051082927,
-0.0170282014,
0.0272445995,
-0.0182689242,
-0.001331831,
-0.0382863805,
0.0218077358,
0.037353415,
-0.0577095039,
-0.0341425352,
0.0236767922,
-0.0208453164,
0.0030850051,
-0.0222093444,
0.0120445592,
-0.0693327188,
0.0357580073,
0.0281924289,
-0.0134238247,
0.0340054706,
0.0094938567,
0.0333636999,
-0.0444928631,
-0.0439912751,
0.0311533343,
0.0465507619,
-0.0275431033,
-0.0818245187,
0.0168556944,
0.0013207865,
-0.0115982033,
0.0449233353,
-0.0847370252,
0.0092127528,
0.0140719404,
0.0153898587,
-0.0064849243,
-0.0111241313,
-0.0129685681,
0.0514411665,
0.0124987112,
-0.0909288377,
-0.0045174733,
-0.014876958,
-0.0714965761,
-0.0129789505,
0.0812261328,
-0.0793544576,
0.0351355523,
0.0504459888,
-0.0700257421,
0.0927515477,
-0.0232457574,
-0.0568279363,
0.0095711639,
-0.1111693308,
0.0140314996,
-0.0393462777,
0.0430435725,
0.0551249161,
-0.0302933771,
-0.0743751153,
0.0260487497,
-0.0979718789,
-0.0468416996,
0.0570400394,
0.0180989001,
0.023812728,
-0.0141533678,
0.0083351862,
-0.0286670551,
0.0409540907,
0.0170648396,
-0.0031134614,
-0.0106681697,
0.0555482656,
-0.0874488205,
-0.0377245396,
0.0279652812,
-0.0483224802,
0.0459361523,
0.0779342875,
0.0110613387,
-0.0220089015,
0.0328769423,
0.008731856,
0.0323066227,
0.0608315319,
0.0061171493,
0.0274983756,
0.0357728824,
0.0384061746,
-0.0107989842,
0.0031737429,
-0.0126081007,
0.0009735606,
-0.0102356756,
-0.0219570082,
0.0200225338,
0.0017410185,
0.0498494171,
-0.0072405883,
0.0089799091,
-0.044856824,
-0.0747313574,
-0.0286872312,
0.0017546702,
0.0074900379,
0.005028591,
0.0551548041,
0.0603671707,
-0.0004935784,
0.0208141319,
-0.0599090122,
0.0288604852,
0.0001407664,
-0.1071449742,
0.0316245407,
-0.0571234226,
-0.0430234782,
-0.0523751453,
0.0258792676,
0.0179052278,
0.0905887485,
-0.013586727,
-0.041474361,
-0.0163557492,
-0.0069775418,
0.0041643297,
0.0163379442,
-0.02042385,
0.0111517822,
-0.0409612805,
0.0153320814,
0.0111045819,
-0.0144467084,
0.0213802326,
0.0211612154,
-0.0730934218,
-0.0089199841,
-0.0152819166,
-0.0234458856,
0.0135723259,
-0.0165177416,
-0.0090149706,
-0.0346052274,
-0.040236827,
-0.0304081924,
0.0248295721,
-0.017530838,
0.0421441868,
-0.0447140448,
-0.0070739971,
-0.0198535249,
0.0031112377,
-0.0026647542,
0.0298279431,
-0.0290589016,
0.027730884,
-0.0170347914,
0.0167776067,
-5.735044818e-33,
0.0008621148,
-0.0226555895,
-0.041408591,
0.0258958377,
0.0080833035,
0.0811665878,
0.0018017363,
0.0184442773,
0.0320368968,
-0.037016809,
-0.0152906766,
-0.0208741594,
0.016711276,
0.0216128491,
-0.0403721519,
-0.0314004906,
0.0518869571,
-0.0211393982,
-0.045154687,
0.0444786362,
0.0127637042,
-0.0403462872,
0.0049882005,
-0.0328236297,
-0.0363555849,
-0.0164018888,
-0.060801439,
0.0203814898,
-0.0659491569,
0.013248194,
-0.001171135,
-0.0145576689,
-0.0478895754,
-0.0376690403,
-0.0303560197,
0.0148173785,
-0.0164882578,
0.027678756,
-0.0059010661,
0.0165782366,
0.0168746542,
-0.0692903921,
0.0194252394,
0.013091729,
-0.0722367764,
-0.014074062,
-0.0239886586,
0.0579832569,
-0.0099584628,
-0.0170313846,
0.0286766775,
-0.0131498938,
-0.0146551076,
0.0141108902,
0.0267748516,
-0.0232003685,
-0.0163253844,
0.0110302884,
-0.0992139354,
0.0085696364,
0.0413476527,
-0.0248749796,
0.050333783,
0.0456757769,
0.0260146223,
0.0153833972,
-0.0102675715,
0.0029824141,
0.0291431714,
-0.0374123938,
0.019886056,
0.0534553863,
0.1063203588,
-0.0252500456,
0.0491647534,
-0.0082682343,
0.0156326052,
0.0171774738,
-0.069932811,
-0.0117237326,
0.0635190457,
0.0280324519,
0.0251696203,
0.0021192632,
-0.0370359905,
-0.0879017934,
0.0059403763,
-0.0101639573,
0.0046962067,
0.0214235093,
-0.0756111071,
0.0366611965,
0.0267853793,
-0.0508184507,
-0.0180088524,
-0.0241473615,
0.036083661,
0.0750284195,
-0.0180210918,
-0.0131935384,
0.0693861023,
-0.0135305515,
0.0544676222,
-0.0195206739,
0.0332348868,
-0.0356593467,
0.0521286391,
0.0606104881,
-0.0462560579,
0.0039139921,
0.0042003333,
-0.0155997127,
0.0154175851,
0.009710649,
0.0019091776,
0.005899346,
-0.0024021682,
-0.0342473798,
-0.0184704904,
0.01340158,
0.0043105697,
0.087840721,
0.0154521791,
0.0453754961,
-0.0154657746,
0.0400285237,
-0.0351412855,
0.0509584285,
0.0441575795,
-0.014469577,
-0.0349399261,
0.0090720411,
2.764e-7,
-0.0246688649,
0.0169356391,
0.0411511846,
0.0071331561,
0.0225893091,
0.0435926989,
0.0241439529,
0.0531082079,
-0.0076396144,
0.0184218623,
-0.0316550322,
-0.0146030253,
-0.0016326825,
-0.0610146821,
-0.02319308,
-0.0073654838,
-0.0502387881,
0.0283130482,
-0.0041352394,
-0.0478763394,
-0.0314084366,
0.0533236414,
0.0512320772,
0.0191350635,
0.0255365055,
-0.0223481692,
0.0382978134,
-0.0050072069,
0.04778409,
-0.008688095,
0.003839304,
0.0190316513,
0.0125400098,
0.0182042755,
-0.0161005016,
0.0194526948,
0.0243251044,
0.0163031872,
0.0056488826,
0.0169805214,
-0.0709484816,
0.0134403901,
-0.0232958421,
-0.0072925445,
0.0122149307,
0.0129069211,
-0.0585533679,
-0.0714087114,
-0.0533395559,
-0.0726918876,
0.0269530714,
0.0047265333,
0.0280676205,
-0.0078183888,
-0.0243380107,
0.0291141942,
0.0390102677,
0.0035789071,
0.0120417709,
-0.0602674261,
-0.0353497826,
-0.0057897381,
-0.0090511357,
-0.0352840051,
0.0907854661,
-0.006042039,
0.0170192327,
2.731703082e-34,
-0.0076165227,
-0.0326721594,
0.0293561444,
0.0559931286,
0.0167178586,
0.0060260617,
0.0160529558,
-0.0334466174,
-0.0021386975,
-0.0726377368,
-0.0121718151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11441v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11441v2 | Set-of-Mark Prompting Unleashes Extraordinary Visual Grounding in GPT-4V | 2023-10-17T17:51:31 | 2023-11-06T07:39:49 | Jianwei Yang, Hao Zhang, Feng Li, Xueyan Zou, Chunyuan Li, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | We present Set-of-Mark (SoM), a new visual prompting method, to unleash the
visual grounding abilities of large multimodal models (LMMs), such as GPT-4V.
As illustrated in Fig. 1 (right), we employ off-the-shelf interactive
segmentation models, such as SEEM/SAM, to partition an image into regions at
different levels of granularity, and overlay these regions with a set of marks
e.g., alphanumerics, masks, boxes. Using the marked image as input, GPT-4V can
answer the questions that require visual grounding. We perform a comprehensive
empirical study to validate the effectiveness of SoM on a wide range of
fine-grained vision and multimodal tasks. For example, our experiments show
that GPT-4V with SoM in zero-shot setting outperforms the state-of-the-art
fully-finetuned referring expression comprehension and segmentation model on
RefCOCOg. Code for SoM prompting is made public at:
https://github.com/microsoft/SoM. | [
-0.004710698,
0.0018712271,
0.010185712,
0.034846168,
-0.0014085117,
-0.0131340474,
0.0313645042,
0.0096674608,
-0.0151753547,
-0.0497323647,
-0.0276356284,
0.0275042616,
-0.0129619176,
0.0180347152,
0.0147795342,
-0.0648930669,
0.0365156569,
-0.0244453717,
-0.0209468938,
-0.0074295038,
0.0381393731,
-0.0106046489,
-0.0395405143,
0.0317885429,
-0.0768596083,
-0.0301026963,
-0.0070903674,
0.0209707525,
0.0207391288,
-0.0496897213,
-0.0370719656,
0.0553910471,
0.0319568887,
0.0355871506,
0.000002443,
-0.0314626209,
-0.0208723899,
0.0027245171,
-0.009594705,
0.0238816794,
0.0052061039,
-0.0107943118,
-0.0012628399,
-0.0212740023,
-0.0352208614,
-0.0057044216,
0.0720903575,
0.0476370156,
0.0888488889,
-0.0053736018,
-0.024709845,
-0.0257507153,
0.0359470882,
-0.0145020606,
0.0611242987,
-0.060316056,
-0.0015736708,
0.0472299457,
-0.0219375324,
-0.0023967701,
-0.052872017,
0.0265458543,
0.0246135816,
-0.0086373007,
0.004706589,
0.0500966869,
-0.0501604006,
-0.0147161372,
-0.0313359685,
0.0729791746,
-0.016726248,
-0.0001506899,
-0.034315262,
-0.0094441129,
0.0162420981,
0.0363465771,
-0.0603518672,
-0.0073561938,
-0.0216659233,
0.0336121097,
-0.0942629427,
0.0259414185,
-0.0041882163,
0.0133020524,
-0.0189368725,
0.0191470198,
0.00168792,
0.0093838191,
0.0318893977,
0.0247983169,
-0.0713013932,
-0.0358880274,
0.0179782938,
0.0198154561,
-0.0284618586,
-0.0086127967,
-0.0692861676,
-0.0367967561,
0.0102856429,
0.0326537453,
0.0487165861,
0.0507702827,
-0.1033397466,
0.0702088475,
-0.0627813935,
0.0400437452,
-0.0557991005,
0.0321886912,
0.0168128554,
-0.0142611302,
-0.0402604491,
-0.0208506957,
-0.0726491511,
0.0014265906,
-0.0671384707,
-0.0423840359,
-0.0028555235,
-0.0152467033,
-0.0152329197,
0.0045985747,
-0.0230033677,
0.0037159468,
-0.0399002209,
0.0061410218,
-0.0133617241,
0.0281941965,
-0.0900456533,
-0.0032098657,
0.0084501868,
-0.0798432752,
0.0023842878,
0.013149308,
0.0144684566,
-0.0261824504,
0.0066651446,
0.0474076234,
-0.041724354,
-0.050583858,
-0.0277536605,
-0.0376034342,
-0.0152580552,
-0.0448870435,
0.0819647163,
-0.0225095991,
0.0047051804,
0.0039599966,
0.0196484458,
0.0129745286,
0.0185739566,
0.0189783834,
0.0079974104,
0.1022644415,
-0.0070302021,
-0.0226119477,
0.0064991945,
0.0006077923,
-0.0299609024,
0.0416482203,
0.0256057195,
0.025829928,
0.0178734511,
-0.0204584245,
0.0353614315,
0.0305210184,
-0.0002880658,
0.0076236348,
-0.0520365201,
-0.019754909,
0.0142829334,
0.0159368012,
0.0299322847,
0.0474145599,
-0.0271318983,
-0.0306093693,
0.0736749992,
0.0232249368,
-0.0514370576,
-0.0230325777,
0.0261534769,
-0.0077198502,
-0.0201085787,
0.0218618158,
-0.0848993286,
0.0669350773,
-0.0321758427,
-0.0024775891,
0.0064286902,
-0.0071902238,
-0.0267311372,
-0.0134519879,
0.0203152597,
0.0367034003,
0.0374115519,
0.0110298162,
0.0449725203,
0.016696291,
-0.02597275,
0.0212385654,
-0.0072458652,
-0.0416406952,
-0.0374951176,
-0.0401763879,
0.0301909577,
-0.0046538808,
0.0257206,
-0.0230012722,
-0.0165397283,
-0.0153239807,
0.083634004,
0.0561926328,
-0.0028051271,
0.03618237,
0.0031482873,
-0.0752024502,
-0.0280209109,
-0.0365952142,
-0.0020296634,
0.0127176614,
0.0282817222,
-0.0301037375,
-0.0010805248,
-0.0738785043,
0.0660889819,
0.050453987,
0.0879441723,
0.0084366156,
-0.0563641526,
0.0084102163,
-0.0155292787,
0.0119262747,
-0.018521823,
0.0086093368,
0.0330630504,
-0.0084427521,
0.0586669557,
-0.026586676,
-0.019942712,
0.0357769132,
0.0042112549,
-0.0672641024,
-0.01607286,
0.0126473075,
-0.0367622487,
-0.0262373332,
-0.0254628938,
-0.0175058488,
0.0040858667,
-0.0466383137,
-0.0137008196,
0.012805542,
0.03043437,
-0.0231438968,
0.0660408735,
-0.0242684335,
0.0061373669,
-0.0025467989,
0.026923703,
-0.0088321436,
-0.0311623607,
-0.0003622754,
-0.0089781741,
-0.0085407812,
-0.0297288764,
-0.0187034365,
0.0044656373,
-0.0479755588,
0.0066321222,
-0.0865988731,
-0.039674364,
-0.0318756178,
-0.0199992992,
-0.0020795886,
-0.0043489458,
-0.0044270535,
-0.0506641865,
-0.0136003476,
0.0522543862,
-0.0037179382,
0.0206946004,
0.008860657,
-0.0049187476,
0.0220157765,
-0.0094539551,
-0.013666423,
0.0098638367,
0.0245482661,
0.0324626751,
-0.0639090762,
-0.0585672669,
-0.0019076667,
-0.028504299,
0.0379958861,
-0.0146415811,
0.0007181892,
0.0436316095,
-0.0046522249,
0.0367682762,
0.0849109516,
-0.0263432525,
0.0235454254,
0.0120180342,
-0.0335640088,
-0.0064621931,
0.0284105483,
0.0293815602,
0.0050901286,
0.0059824004,
0.0176423583,
-0.0097504407,
0.0132285152,
-0.0070892759,
0.0413726531,
-0.0468452051,
0.0149707608,
0.0046330779,
-0.0246211365,
-0.043588426,
0.0242207013,
-0.0288127325,
0.0427083932,
-0.0463166237,
-0.046918571,
0.0433394946,
-0.0665411204,
-0.0539231077,
0.0345821194,
0.0300971549,
0.0075766142,
0.0592943765,
0.0175147764,
-0.0078937486,
0.0180503484,
-0.0424005687,
-0.0511735342,
-0.0255323052,
-0.0197747201,
0.0151739456,
0.0910404027,
-0.0438777767,
0.0262419488,
-0.0275986996,
-0.0104785478,
-0.0084723597,
0.0061174207,
-0.0506069399,
0.0339974575,
-0.0281647909,
-0.0131283728,
-0.0212038159,
0.0301389489,
0.0580151193,
0.0535258055,
-0.0076068155,
-0.010361433,
-0.0445196107,
0.0148950247,
0.0278885309,
0.0463121235,
-0.0280362684,
-0.0333803259,
-0.0201383661,
0.0605816171,
0.0439573564,
-0.0187610909,
-0.0481110774,
0.0323280506,
-0.0006775837,
0.0141460281,
-0.0245684218,
0.0266923029,
0.0889486372,
-0.0636983514,
0.008386761,
0.0588729344,
0.012561311,
-0.0460013635,
-0.023625033,
-0.0290464424,
0.0230232514,
0.0746764168,
-0.0322781019,
-0.0937192589,
-0.0837222263,
0.0203672331,
-0.0223922282,
0.0417176299,
-0.0293515418,
0.0247258265,
-0.0957490504,
0.0862254128,
-0.0098688584,
-0.0883934349,
-0.0114095407,
0.0430564284,
0.0486494899,
0.0232329238,
-0.0064777802,
0.007573266,
-0.0134033607,
-0.0095535191,
0.0122850044,
0.0511297584,
0.0149556585,
0.0247768741,
-0.0298406444,
-0.0146827335,
0.0748755187,
-0.005211493,
-0.0037117577,
-0.0795669928,
0.0383048952,
-0.0092091812,
0.0260101091,
-0.0255986638,
0.0750337094,
-0.0145779122,
-0.0339308903,
-0.0023453147,
0.0296467338,
0.0276872609,
-0.0311846007,
-0.0443271883,
0.0488821603,
-0.0445922166,
0.0233792495,
-0.0174920335,
0.0174327344,
-0.0227791257,
0.0189392231,
0.05188879,
-0.0172003992,
-0.0344280563,
-0.0166601054,
0.0706232637,
-0.0207884982,
-0.0020172219,
0.0169504881,
-0.0304113142,
-0.0295216255,
-0.0449503474,
-0.0186229013,
0.0988864452,
0.0425129272,
-0.0186258145,
-0.0306781754,
-0.0073393774,
0.0337979011,
-0.0288780387,
0.0785697177,
-0.0512377881,
0.0335577428,
-0.072013326,
-0.0009294365,
0.0349244177,
-0.0218557175,
-0.0128289312,
0.0673949197,
-0.0024830825,
-0.0172769204,
0.0138660846,
0.0644208118,
0.0289692078,
0.0029779815,
-0.0012319569,
-0.0512088276,
-0.0038235476,
-0.0109710656,
-0.0150521249,
0.02611042,
0.0059870682,
-0.0008354959,
-0.0119054476,
0.0063544684,
-0.048450321,
0.0303948335,
0.010286021,
0.0177229159,
-0.0500286743,
0.0150243333,
0.0253035594,
0.0047796462,
0.0988976359,
-0.0104938261,
0.0557856783,
-0.016170755,
0.0216438361,
0.0104229106,
-0.0114351753,
-0.0747011676,
0.0252134614,
-0.0222637821,
-0.0025019438,
0.0221962053,
-0.024322968,
-0.0150969261,
0.0675846636,
-0.013049922,
-0.0127778342,
-0.0096724024,
0.0110379718,
0.0066487687,
0.0139106112,
-0.0047783717,
0.0271067563,
-0.0134917041,
0.0325457416,
0.0129393376,
0.1109193563,
0.0227361452,
-0.0233236309,
-0.0354629904,
0.0476050824,
-0.0068096812,
-0.018528549,
-0.0335417911,
0.0533208065,
0.0343263671,
0.015163254,
0.0220238324,
-0.0153658735,
-0.0270039607,
0.0043352102,
0.032632973,
0.0442190059,
-0.0409919918,
0.0514851511,
0.0369046032,
0.0000459628,
-0.044823043,
0.0226746369,
-0.0101439441,
0.0449900962,
0.0107874796,
-0.0009520808,
-0.0627374724,
-0.0242668483,
0.034809541,
0.0209116265,
0.0078619635,
0.0419079997,
-0.0484355651,
-0.0367538407,
0.0023867385,
0.0102139991,
-0.0391913764,
-0.0028846513,
0.0662212223,
0.0455897935,
0.013521635,
-0.0426466279,
0.0096017187,
-0.0029722773,
0.0006184552,
-0.0205731038,
-0.0139743201,
-6.909254574e-33,
-0.0462215766,
-0.0305110384,
0.0272381008,
0.005077261,
-0.0313434526,
0.0139922369,
-0.027631592,
0.037590608,
-0.0113983778,
0.0404153764,
-0.0106946789,
-0.0128493123,
0.0329511426,
0.0214614552,
-0.0149022304,
-0.0499514118,
0.0362637155,
-0.0173855107,
-0.0196861327,
-0.0027452121,
-0.0037467123,
0.0018602763,
0.0649727583,
-0.032585863,
-0.0257675778,
0.0329590887,
-0.046875041,
0.0212025326,
-0.0357423499,
0.0540669821,
-0.0217708647,
0.0304750744,
0.0184136499,
-0.0098479502,
-0.0139611745,
0.0526470952,
-0.070695281,
-0.008957427,
0.0030558249,
0.0320094116,
-0.0600731447,
0.0061894809,
0.0375047959,
-0.0302501563,
0.0167527329,
-0.0060508638,
0.0285189766,
-0.0273046587,
-0.0304292794,
-0.0049434979,
-0.0398047119,
0.0084154094,
0.014955963,
-0.0683233514,
0.0423142686,
0.034156356,
0.0414470993,
0.0304760877,
-0.0734981075,
-0.0042014308,
-0.0022908619,
0.0036878295,
0.0376412123,
0.0465387478,
0.0041896459,
0.0393844843,
0.0145272631,
-0.0642117634,
-0.0035246066,
-0.0226796139,
0.0326639898,
0.0708018169,
0.0592072941,
0.0069798399,
0.0157657024,
0.045562502,
-0.0142767476,
-0.0062200516,
-0.0294982623,
0.0796928033,
0.0027111832,
0.0333098955,
-0.0205419995,
0.024051182,
-0.0057128025,
-0.0384360217,
-0.067810908,
0.0076546273,
0.0450050868,
0.0090915337,
-0.0232252683,
0.0653439835,
0.0677867904,
0.0396534316,
0.0208867434,
-0.0104071023,
0.0074986066,
0.0900688171,
-0.0112541933,
-0.0299685169,
-0.0007509838,
-0.016588388,
0.0689410493,
-0.0260367356,
0.0180557519,
0.0054201703,
0.0035801171,
0.0009864295,
-0.0579406768,
-0.0120799756,
-0.0094544133,
0.0403252281,
-0.0133886626,
-0.0032187637,
0.0244979057,
-0.0068360325,
-0.0376193598,
0.0112896366,
-0.0279273167,
-0.015747441,
-0.0251011364,
-0.0308806803,
-0.0182245262,
0.0105945291,
-0.0312933959,
0.0200884752,
-0.0099207349,
-0.037414141,
0.0510389134,
-0.0399693996,
-0.0221771915,
0.0504153892,
2.986e-7,
0.0529368445,
0.0378944054,
0.0134925656,
0.0013818952,
-0.009913899,
0.0496786125,
-0.0109317163,
0.0041762092,
0.00416394,
-0.1183038875,
-0.0153567037,
0.0388670228,
0.0388739444,
0.0246879365,
-0.0440714657,
0.014462024,
0.0052649924,
-0.0153533854,
-0.0413720161,
-0.0002463133,
0.0073131877,
0.0503935665,
-0.0072643952,
-0.0149796344,
0.0582230501,
-0.0336526819,
0.0471983366,
-0.0083359042,
0.0302276351,
-0.0487094782,
0.0209830794,
-0.02018263,
-0.0329967588,
0.0608087406,
0.0171147287,
-0.0195201337,
0.0617815591,
0.0245801583,
-0.0324186683,
-0.0198344886,
-0.0291028358,
0.0162499715,
0.0046916627,
-0.0463396609,
0.0650044009,
-0.0453347266,
-0.0003233795,
0.022499932,
-0.0353314541,
-0.0127731841,
0.0081590973,
-0.0188340042,
-0.0612987392,
0.0265749656,
0.0210112091,
-0.0158929992,
-0.0675223246,
-0.04258902,
-0.0268122982,
-0.030109467,
-0.0449216366,
-0.0211601388,
-0.0531893559,
-0.0601564571,
-0.0078034173,
-0.0424997583,
-0.0782473385,
2.611244758e-34,
0.0317442268,
-0.0075940927,
0.0581807792,
0.038773194,
0.036325682,
0.0220704414,
-0.0509399213,
0.0083388463,
-0.0153780654,
-0.0605422072,
-0.0074410457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11430v1 | An Empirical Study of Translation Hypothesis Ensembling with Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T17:40:21 | 2023-10-17T17:40:21 | António Farinhas, José G. C. de Souza, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are becoming a one-fits-many solution, but they
sometimes hallucinate or produce unreliable output. In this paper, we
investigate how hypothesis ensembling can improve the quality of the generated
text for the specific problem of LLM-based machine translation. We experiment
with several techniques for ensembling hypotheses produced by LLMs such as
ChatGPT, LLaMA, and Alpaca. We provide a comprehensive study along multiple
dimensions, including the method to generate hypotheses (multiple prompts,
temperature-based sampling, and beam search) and the strategy to produce the
final translation (instruction-based, quality-based reranking, and minimum
Bayes risk (MBR) decoding). Our results show that MBR decoding is a very
effective method, that translation quality can be improved using a small number
of samples, and that instruction tuning has a strong impact on the relation
between the diversity of the hypotheses and the sampling temperature. | [
0.0063635614,
0.0137551408,
-0.0220310222,
0.0235336069,
-0.0328678489,
0.0235464815,
-0.0010654286,
0.0194013212,
-0.0085137077,
-0.021638222,
-0.0179366954,
-0.0555981509,
0.0497307703,
-0.0224969909,
0.0278329849,
-0.0416457467,
0.0214343145,
-0.051628001,
-0.0314345025,
-0.0228623338,
-0.0278100017,
0.0162691623,
0.0304466523,
0.0336646661,
0.0244593527,
0.0081026424,
-0.0182630122,
0.0470844954,
0.0181646552,
-0.028856378,
-0.0533270426,
0.0214534141,
0.0056428369,
0.0517104417,
0.0000023615,
-0.0421349183,
-0.0690447688,
0.0057436,
0.0013724897,
0.0140298605,
0.1044611558,
-0.0527498052,
-0.0366290212,
0.0607482567,
0.0104644159,
-0.0142544247,
0.0519089215,
-0.0126781948,
0.0308908969,
0.0685683638,
-0.0098097492,
-0.0392646343,
-0.0195297562,
-0.0244063139,
0.0013792545,
-0.0505414605,
0.012398215,
0.0085971896,
0.0263848659,
0.0623724647,
0.0019026347,
0.0454537608,
0.02304608,
0.0070767421,
-0.0497562103,
0.0132799959,
0.0152876489,
-0.0285839308,
0.0036175414,
0.0288006347,
-0.0710328892,
-0.0255636834,
0.0063088113,
0.0031073964,
-0.007505056,
0.0073246411,
-0.0404056758,
0.0760530606,
-0.02869392,
0.0245138574,
0.0837695822,
0.0229715519,
0.0198501404,
-0.0132823512,
-0.0766404197,
0.0825501233,
0.0429702699,
-0.0404639915,
-0.0402320884,
0.0075767566,
-0.0021603769,
-0.0297284741,
0.0343920104,
-0.0287249908,
-0.0120858494,
0.0310736131,
-0.0420805141,
-0.0314605013,
0.0304150693,
-0.0649596602,
-0.0086692628,
0.0393581428,
0.0153252333,
0.0206304193,
0.0050149094,
0.0302353762,
-0.0149246762,
-0.010205972,
-0.1156292632,
0.0020625761,
-0.0171402991,
0.0069823172,
-0.0442531034,
-0.0333851203,
-0.0477705337,
-0.002999262,
-0.0137035269,
0.0218362883,
0.0608386211,
0.0018600235,
-0.0150778899,
-0.0668893605,
-0.0709064454,
-0.028376041,
0.0123146195,
0.0574568361,
-0.0077060126,
-0.0105105788,
-0.007751856,
-0.0847230181,
-0.0174438637,
0.0332169943,
-0.0145063223,
-0.02545931,
0.0035485097,
0.0487057939,
-0.0186662767,
-0.0279580727,
0.0135416612,
-0.019833006,
-0.0175416227,
-0.0196381211,
0.0049367156,
-0.0653076619,
0.0319806673,
0.0172435082,
0.0292491708,
0.0059281709,
0.0097675892,
-0.0066474406,
-0.0233131275,
0.0410082303,
-0.0040944302,
0.0389713719,
0.0640057623,
0.0161653142,
0.0048229359,
0.1034469903,
0.0307858512,
0.0709054172,
0.0115305912,
-0.0122125894,
0.0035692346,
0.0559801273,
-0.0162395574,
0.0560429916,
-0.0089515112,
0.0033972627,
0.0517291464,
0.0296590384,
0.0090560801,
0.0540584959,
-0.0488290638,
0.0371876433,
0.0688054115,
0.0167051423,
0.0030431151,
-0.0182504859,
0.0165148247,
0.020827597,
-0.0081919786,
0.0064994781,
-0.0023456977,
0.0005768684,
-0.0269651245,
-0.0033319539,
0.054001607,
0.0658252835,
-0.0099589238,
-0.0205784105,
-0.0242165253,
-0.0048501114,
-0.0355266631,
-0.0080100875,
0.064535588,
-0.0025573517,
-0.0541136265,
0.0255243462,
0.0160150491,
-0.0346140265,
-0.0042333608,
-0.0373510495,
-0.0214607324,
0.0963268355,
0.0686733946,
0.0247177556,
-0.0072777802,
-0.0051365844,
-0.0051047704,
0.0271627437,
0.0351643078,
0.0207278542,
0.0114238961,
-0.0600681379,
-0.0218737759,
0.0319088809,
0.0223062057,
0.0638254881,
-0.0328923278,
0.0162211917,
0.0131584862,
-0.0160245672,
-0.0308716316,
0.0182993617,
-0.0088166473,
0.0030227499,
0.0172779597,
-0.0071474127,
0.0525685996,
-0.013545434,
-0.0317724235,
0.0102996081,
0.0197078977,
-0.0512609631,
-0.0296814293,
0.0296813697,
-0.0099033499,
-0.0570145212,
-0.0039227172,
-0.0453710817,
-0.0005673337,
-0.0407774188,
-0.0166030563,
-0.0518120565,
-0.0156656541,
-0.0379009657,
-0.0163097121,
-0.0211608037,
0.0842229724,
-0.0304192249,
-0.0032306709,
-0.0643431842,
0.0312041305,
-0.002996614,
-0.0117450813,
-0.0001794126,
-0.0336227044,
0.0120836105,
-0.0697715133,
-0.0172683597,
0.0726545528,
0.0262116678,
-0.0028700111,
0.0026616966,
0.034108188,
0.0190790761,
-0.0652702674,
-0.0698938221,
0.0282981172,
-0.0175971389,
0.0252637733,
0.0443905219,
0.0279985704,
-0.0135937883,
0.0143983373,
-0.0075852396,
-0.0577043444,
0.0082325051,
0.0445571616,
0.0054680277,
-0.0050822366,
-0.0163786747,
0.0124492291,
-0.0148611683,
0.0227920245,
0.0684742182,
0.0289219283,
-0.0310530011,
-0.1081230491,
0.0834654719,
-0.0148653472,
-0.0382346883,
-0.0162531603,
-0.0534492545,
0.0015299303,
-0.0287846308,
0.0522028692,
0.0353900529,
0.0020568862,
0.0094800051,
0.0703480318,
-0.0015675564,
-0.0453146845,
-0.0281407572,
-0.0203549545,
-0.006034629,
-0.0026936408,
-0.1167396754,
0.017034512,
0.0143189179,
0.0150780557,
0.0016801368,
-0.0515446849,
0.0325508937,
-0.0384195037,
-0.009775891,
-0.0495259464,
0.0062552118,
0.0221131183,
0.0665184706,
-0.0074431933,
-0.0606643781,
0.0426517278,
-0.0597868897,
-0.0061790277,
-0.1058717445,
0.0127865719,
-0.0324655399,
0.0141971251,
-0.0216232389,
0.0440458246,
-0.0173041355,
-0.0175812263,
-0.031708952,
0.0316943973,
0.02406317,
-0.033957608,
-0.0114204846,
-0.0543186069,
-0.002801066,
-0.0245239865,
-0.0012673566,
-0.0055306875,
-0.0145683391,
0.0146314343,
-0.0259882659,
0.0719620883,
0.0075955805,
-0.0361799821,
0.0402889326,
0.0292484481,
0.0324000083,
-0.00808297,
0.0057204505,
-0.0262375735,
0.0055756546,
0.0219601765,
-0.0353661291,
0.0352256037,
-0.0790132135,
0.0252838302,
0.0126385344,
0.0162965991,
-0.0102535682,
0.0023048159,
-0.0212364513,
0.0387658589,
0.0085019562,
-0.052026201,
-0.0093108155,
0.0380531251,
-0.0438416749,
0.0113360705,
0.1002131402,
0.0298201181,
-0.0231532268,
0.0111028356,
0.0012480363,
0.0453358293,
-0.0231173486,
0.038674213,
-0.0958072171,
-0.0047612544,
0.0454854406,
0.0303337127,
-0.0059818369,
0.0362751931,
-0.0197866056,
-0.1280916929,
0.0527085029,
0.0485164002,
-0.0108193522,
-0.0257339813,
-0.0423802435,
-0.0496709198,
-0.0272550434,
0.0225948039,
0.0286437981,
0.0151275508,
0.016840985,
0.0091803372,
0.0097017623,
-0.0940238312,
-0.021207897,
-0.0369205624,
0.0560602322,
0.0611787327,
0.0077972882,
-0.0029876831,
-0.0014654754,
-0.0179259423,
-0.0106782066,
-0.0030675498,
-0.0160497669,
-0.016469609,
0.0177112035,
-0.0007751416,
0.0288872197,
-0.0187585559,
0.0056122895,
0.0249958057,
0.0182842668,
0.0340012535,
-0.0359397158,
-0.016649507,
0.0196786076,
-0.0309272408,
0.0106771979,
0.0689305589,
0.0126113566,
-0.0336392112,
-0.0142822983,
-0.0530472882,
-0.0147180539,
-0.015734693,
0.0186087638,
0.0059931171,
-0.0578876808,
-0.043672666,
-0.0737384036,
-0.0147162667,
0.0225202944,
0.0510433465,
0.0222164616,
0.0318198949,
-0.0022613509,
-0.0125133377,
0.0076155062,
0.0135158328,
-0.0229295064,
0.0219492242,
-0.0471988246,
0.0236016456,
0.0127258925,
-0.050043866,
-0.0017673329,
0.025429748,
-0.048348099,
-0.0788220093,
-0.0116553074,
0.0339694545,
0.0318482816,
0.0109075522,
-0.0379989333,
-0.0623299889,
0.0121350233,
0.0277347099,
-0.0020896592,
0.0202730391,
-0.012584242,
0.0148793571,
-0.0046602618,
0.0265624803,
-0.0083722118,
0.0302701946,
-0.0362874977,
0.0337383822,
-0.0109776361,
-0.0819135457,
0.0013089679,
0.05833406,
-0.0244421978,
-0.0338420942,
-0.0326344371,
-0.0206720587,
0.0281846393,
-0.0409678891,
-0.0125268651,
-0.0347610712,
0.0204344727,
0.061962571,
0.0014924284,
0.0170233175,
-0.00674948,
-0.0217557214,
-0.0004962288,
0.0198784135,
0.0107801044,
-0.0630096123,
0.050308805,
0.0507227331,
-0.0008119115,
0.0060591986,
0.0270611849,
0.0006446262,
0.0150898183,
-0.031555593,
0.0214448813,
0.011149969,
-0.0204954129,
-0.0395540781,
0.064908132,
-0.0360496938,
-0.0344430171,
-0.0343864635,
0.0454577543,
0.0723729357,
0.0594254024,
0.1239316761,
-0.0157241002,
0.0046346774,
-0.0219619386,
0.0465208702,
0.0512203462,
-0.0350885168,
0.0049617309,
0.0003898806,
-0.0350237302,
-0.0117886756,
0.0693954453,
0.0048650103,
0.0251575131,
-0.0005395302,
-0.0062287962,
-0.0027469418,
-0.0014236015,
-0.0191505551,
-0.0368019976,
-0.0347141773,
-0.0408513434,
-0.0385980904,
-0.0176811889,
0.0022150474,
0.0203371793,
0.0170515645,
-0.009065262,
-0.010634752,
0.0677116886,
-0.024887681,
0.0058778613,
-0.0376814008,
-0.0310497079,
-0.0253630988,
-0.0338005759,
0.0151463142,
-7.102105442e-33,
-0.0246440899,
-0.0305041019,
-0.0047267363,
-0.0888832584,
0.0100486698,
-0.0228238273,
-0.021459993,
-0.0282483101,
0.0262705404,
-0.0162345301,
-0.0004736878,
-0.0241415761,
0.0358295999,
-0.0202780161,
0.0087092482,
0.0380964354,
0.0638406426,
0.0342184938,
-0.0481026135,
0.0048157531,
0.0472037084,
0.0144007998,
0.0307122413,
-0.0077643851,
-0.001823151,
-0.0466670096,
-0.0236515179,
0.0106267184,
-0.0107584605,
0.0180529449,
0.0094043827,
0.0010161028,
0.0080550034,
-0.0479913391,
-0.0333688334,
-0.0191783905,
-0.0272503886,
0.0019792793,
0.0181741137,
0.0263998527,
0.049891714,
-0.0673924536,
-0.0076247933,
-0.0179208238,
-0.0036372307,
0.028149195,
-0.0096880784,
-0.0490201414,
-0.0348936245,
-0.0048923888,
-0.0133631155,
0.0528978519,
0.0079589784,
-0.012620342,
0.0164418742,
0.047700949,
-0.0213188659,
-0.0105612651,
-0.0126541248,
0.0493845344,
0.0624057092,
0.0452031344,
0.0734087005,
0.0091422554,
-0.0087441029,
0.0117014283,
-0.0020961862,
0.0315826051,
0.0161178876,
-0.0262405388,
0.0330153145,
-0.0014707338,
0.0382337011,
0.0303836185,
0.051147446,
-0.0099789072,
-0.0527673252,
0.0593134016,
0.0332363136,
-0.0197503362,
0.0296267122,
0.0320187733,
-0.0577754006,
-0.0492545255,
-0.0655010641,
-0.0176687334,
-0.0294945538,
-0.0452172793,
0.0282311812,
0.0158706997,
-0.0621425435,
0.0060244799,
0.0967831016,
-0.0122504374,
0.0036776171,
0.001938116,
-0.0451401398,
0.0152454237,
-0.0254524462,
0.0465821475,
-0.0183502771,
-0.0497783683,
0.0581769794,
0.0141954813,
-0.0204242412,
-0.0096885459,
0.0109889824,
0.0015884878,
-0.0499264598,
0.0283210743,
-0.014886668,
-0.0136697832,
-0.0000091503,
-0.0020277149,
0.022476621,
-0.0335702859,
0.0250898581,
0.0259027705,
0.0627978593,
-0.0001071694,
-0.0506699122,
0.0256179869,
-0.0069502969,
0.0165745988,
-0.0136764981,
0.0634917393,
-0.0299218856,
-0.0170954242,
0.0472685248,
-0.0423697233,
-0.0441830754,
0.0138372676,
3.173e-7,
0.0369774252,
0.0839574188,
-0.0138250627,
0.0271674599,
0.0080984514,
0.0109670982,
-0.0206181332,
0.0233939663,
0.0204155631,
0.0462404229,
-0.0067389295,
0.0173702668,
0.087222971,
0.056048356,
-0.0715025738,
-0.0331266038,
-0.0085862298,
0.0157756694,
-0.0709769204,
-0.0315270759,
0.0407707132,
0.0951869339,
-0.0401510857,
0.013410815,
-0.0000944252,
-0.0139676193,
0.0475704446,
-0.0138468221,
-0.0398290865,
0.029284548,
0.0034840247,
0.0099783149,
-0.0246238094,
-0.0006040218,
-0.0043252097,
-0.0176692698,
0.0246956404,
0.0687113106,
0.0226653535,
0.0001855301,
0.0553117692,
-0.010949254,
-0.0392064899,
-0.0642481297,
0.0572776943,
-0.0416444987,
-0.0124005331,
0.0056951204,
-0.0281414445,
-0.0269036945,
0.0149378162,
-0.0414773114,
-0.006535836,
0.0404839627,
0.0192773845,
-0.0026035821,
-0.0172185693,
-0.0220714882,
-0.0119734025,
-0.0386232659,
-0.0224357471,
-0.0797054395,
-0.0082967384,
0.016504094,
0.0251721013,
-0.0523574576,
0.0089467969,
3.344772059e-34,
0.0543790795,
-0.0362882651,
-0.0050899442,
0.0075070215,
0.0355093926,
-0.0229548905,
-0.0044301567,
0.0378571413,
-0.0133733656,
-0.0774282515,
-0.0134022441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11398v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11398v2 | Neural Attention: Enhancing QKV Calculation in Self-Attention Mechanism with Neural Networks | 2023-10-17T17:06:26 | 2023-10-24T17:12:49 | Muhan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the realm of deep learning, the self-attention mechanism has substantiated
its pivotal role across a myriad of tasks, encompassing natural language
processing and computer vision. Despite achieving success across diverse
applications, the traditional self-attention mechanism primarily leverages
linear transformations for the computation of query, key, and value (QKV),
which may not invariably be the optimal choice under specific circumstances.
This paper probes into a novel methodology for QKV computation-implementing a
specially-designed neural network structure for the calculation. Utilizing a
modified Marian model, we conducted experiments on the IWSLT 2017
German-English translation task dataset and juxtaposed our method with the
conventional approach. The experimental results unveil a significant
enhancement in BLEU scores with our method. Furthermore, our approach also
manifested superiority when training the Roberta model with the Wikitext-103
dataset, reflecting a notable reduction in model perplexity compared to its
original counterpart. These experimental outcomes not only validate the
efficacy of our method but also reveal the immense potential in optimizing the
self-attention mechanism through neural network-based QKV computation, paving
the way for future research and practical applications. The source code and
implementation details for our proposed method can be accessed at
https://github.com/ocislyjrti/NeuralAttention. | [
0.0077505629,
0.0382742025,
-0.0179310255,
0.0656566694,
-0.0336069167,
-0.0121614011,
-0.0031938334,
-0.0203993879,
-0.0166166238,
-0.0062150848,
-0.0589763671,
-0.022514686,
0.0007243336,
0.0186479483,
0.0240539685,
-0.0053872005,
0.0544625185,
-0.0040558674,
-0.0173934251,
-0.0115330396,
-0.0233038776,
-0.0331229791,
-0.0010519025,
0.0269907527,
-0.0059412466,
-0.0203012489,
-0.0143725201,
0.0418483168,
0.0233915858,
-0.001318096,
-0.0169317108,
0.0562409796,
-0.0299530607,
0.0346494354,
0.0000022256,
-0.0475722477,
0.0053826636,
-0.0039652805,
-0.0177319758,
0.0218265206,
0.0353976935,
-0.0061090002,
-0.0149918208,
-0.0261831135,
-0.0420568362,
-0.0030421335,
0.0596113056,
0.0294681452,
0.0384016261,
0.0652697757,
-0.0026233294,
-0.0248672795,
0.0296941809,
-0.0284552388,
0.0415304191,
-0.0978988335,
-0.0051752157,
-0.02808645,
-0.0435887799,
0.0038012816,
-0.0175975468,
0.0951607674,
0.0453680828,
-0.0046358593,
0.0330387652,
0.0266959872,
-0.0408250503,
-0.0133336708,
-0.0263758358,
0.089081347,
-0.0508683175,
-0.0028455129,
-0.0290800631,
0.0213743392,
0.0207419302,
-0.0118367588,
-0.0490213819,
-0.0152521906,
0.0366544165,
-0.0131729068,
0.0029855648,
0.0525355488,
0.0173511747,
-0.0033319667,
-0.0372936837,
0.0183810927,
0.0204942822,
-0.034779612,
0.0167169739,
-0.0117638865,
-0.025333317,
-0.0291084722,
0.044644963,
0.0240806062,
0.0438114554,
-0.0007223123,
-0.0225644279,
-0.0614635684,
-0.0081949774,
-0.1042027175,
0.0264194701,
0.057235349,
-0.0547285154,
0.0238610003,
-0.029992722,
0.1168417931,
-0.0257968307,
0.0486623868,
-0.0480519831,
0.0304764193,
-0.0346698277,
0.0106380396,
-0.0502953529,
0.0164780058,
-0.0119736949,
-0.0305709857,
-0.0490269773,
0.0105426786,
0.0071489918,
-0.0499889143,
0.0301551558,
0.0438557081,
-0.0430034697,
0.0040264577,
0.0125808557,
0.0411595069,
-0.0274062566,
-0.0557381622,
-0.0221469998,
-0.0373105519,
-0.0273613241,
0.0037260838,
0.0101128537,
-0.0616263933,
-0.0020855961,
0.0496118926,
-0.0189618003,
-0.0385239571,
-0.0176603235,
0.0018350171,
-0.0419523008,
-0.0700377896,
0.0363147892,
-0.0486185551,
0.0355514996,
-0.0169944633,
-0.01428976,
-0.0291570332,
-0.0048080166,
0.0299304463,
-0.0137095591,
0.0610398427,
0.0350032188,
0.0192954391,
0.0237283278,
-0.0205000471,
0.0060784724,
0.0615964755,
0.0320508778,
0.0274485797,
0.0212513451,
-0.0274726171,
-0.0081417933,
0.0229617245,
0.0422693305,
-0.0035173295,
-0.0667282939,
-0.0021226534,
-0.0155227911,
0.034010008,
0.0497292504,
0.027623333,
-0.0167403016,
-0.0153811416,
0.0742542967,
0.0659890696,
0.0615941919,
0.075797908,
-0.003117,
0.0108016953,
-0.0009309612,
-0.0076264176,
-0.0571897142,
0.0962854996,
-0.0313314125,
-0.0037722331,
0.0164114181,
0.0216908511,
-0.032790225,
-0.0678393841,
0.028312875,
0.0126278959,
0.0286074653,
-0.0043000048,
0.0518655628,
0.0243822765,
-0.0200042278,
-0.0001529383,
-0.0064278995,
-0.0645076707,
0.0137704117,
-0.0380118787,
-0.023755772,
0.0673646778,
0.0375517495,
-0.0207864586,
-0.021777695,
0.0295022801,
-0.0111302566,
0.0419066586,
0.0483287089,
0.0423546769,
-0.003113392,
-0.0472691432,
-0.0432528555,
-0.0298169963,
-0.0151049057,
0.0071245655,
-0.0176969115,
0.0302933156,
0.0306572095,
-0.084088847,
-0.0388097018,
0.0378799476,
0.0046670246,
-0.0320873819,
0.0262333062,
0.0528981835,
-0.0004067306,
0.0490115024,
0.0244767033,
0.0331745446,
0.0345480815,
-0.0440055951,
0.0150266793,
0.0105604324,
-0.023579305,
-0.0414524525,
0.0325437076,
-0.0236578304,
0.0219541062,
0.054603368,
0.0055405633,
-0.0579077005,
0.0617424212,
-0.0471441709,
-0.0124058351,
-0.0299992692,
0.0185049661,
-0.0105380835,
0.032286346,
-0.0421891883,
0.0401052609,
-0.0051796362,
-0.0011943805,
-0.0030208926,
-0.0221688114,
-0.0079358732,
-0.0258406643,
-0.0282566249,
-0.007394535,
-0.0224179663,
0.038115263,
0.0151957646,
0.0074000303,
-0.0265243649,
-0.0026850551,
-0.0428471155,
0.0044494886,
-0.0517951958,
0.0110239042,
0.033682622,
0.0374549665,
0.0179439411,
-0.0187600721,
-0.0308763999,
0.016187055,
-0.0204336885,
0.0169701707,
0.0070292624,
-0.0009610861,
0.0187491253,
-0.044297304,
-0.0601796024,
-0.0174799804,
0.0351427794,
0.0301605463,
0.0023729876,
-0.0324390158,
0.0093646506,
-0.0111796288,
0.0094458573,
0.0020146361,
-0.0765305981,
-0.0091489386,
-0.0327373296,
0.0320782177,
0.087895371,
0.0101371836,
-0.030135572,
0.0374789014,
-0.0094529297,
-0.0851194263,
0.041453138,
-0.0450197943,
-0.0074500586,
0.0041073887,
-0.0169802029,
0.0134720374,
0.0344984084,
-0.0216478575,
-0.0063176914,
-0.0808158517,
0.0045230649,
-0.0014676583,
-0.0579879023,
-0.023319995,
0.0487238504,
-0.0102711143,
0.027527092,
-0.0104309069,
-0.0170654431,
0.0582533814,
-0.0028587424,
-0.0078493059,
-0.0502590276,
0.0376057923,
-0.0100705707,
0.0579185598,
-0.0000037062,
0.0233061276,
-0.0360989757,
-0.0321533419,
-0.0146760438,
0.0046481541,
-0.0252228826,
-0.0180645529,
0.1059240103,
0.0173549466,
0.0049883141,
-0.0003081153,
0.0047751754,
-0.044516962,
0.0051482785,
0.0045473217,
-0.0246040616,
-0.0175793637,
0.0110036423,
-0.0159774814,
0.0355270877,
0.0310479943,
0.0595032312,
-0.0511672199,
-0.0175414905,
-0.0077547221,
0.018834658,
0.0272801556,
0.021320723,
0.0449193865,
0.0001677712,
0.0236486178,
0.0345110595,
0.0480885543,
-0.001379299,
-0.0031303393,
-0.0170072466,
0.0330598466,
-0.0352102257,
-0.0172792729,
0.0182796791,
0.0061811288,
-0.0719742924,
-0.050518021,
0.0916042551,
0.0083241286,
-0.0906239972,
-0.0037797601,
-0.0671301931,
-0.0132814469,
0.0309249237,
0.0553562455,
-0.0311385114,
-0.0277778581,
-0.0076090237,
0.0531565771,
0.0519239679,
-0.0146854939,
0.006764106,
-0.0655348673,
0.0377530418,
0.0315431431,
-0.040851891,
-0.0319934525,
0.005773745,
-0.008047563,
-0.034592133,
0.0294817183,
0.0354381204,
0.0078082266,
-0.0085763894,
-0.0125601729,
0.0228358097,
-0.0235451888,
0.0295741819,
-0.0626701415,
-0.009876783,
0.1033546925,
0.0201528426,
-0.0329733528,
-0.0595644638,
-0.0045356303,
0.0107195182,
0.0158439185,
0.0103745637,
0.049773518,
-0.0194257759,
-0.0328002274,
-0.0005120953,
0.0002273216,
-0.06745065,
0.0185383596,
-0.0083526904,
0.0362462439,
-0.0159074608,
-0.0040785205,
-0.0386398211,
-0.0117995618,
-0.0170211494,
0.0547606498,
0.0388977937,
-0.0448538028,
-0.0384238921,
0.0000394178,
0.0239026751,
-0.1094193459,
-0.0746344998,
0.0206677075,
0.0083273184,
-0.0801423788,
-0.0716406479,
-0.0632842705,
-0.0192731898,
0.0350476876,
0.0147802047,
-0.0080895759,
0.0527575947,
-0.0112355817,
-0.0616370849,
0.0355529226,
-0.0288465414,
-0.0136776427,
-0.0443634018,
0.0257851593,
0.0016072004,
-0.0461805165,
0.0172852352,
-0.0017206128,
-0.024435848,
-0.0326685086,
0.022525169,
0.0887138247,
0.0180283096,
0.0371084437,
-0.053213194,
-0.0292747729,
-0.0168559123,
-0.0011957564,
-0.033062309,
0.0020405776,
0.0142519046,
-0.0406013876,
-0.0223456956,
0.0468700565,
-0.0133933313,
0.0089271404,
0.0293950699,
0.0803774446,
-0.0001932118,
-0.0307823177,
0.0201909356,
0.0135747474,
0.0562347546,
0.0151876025,
0.0084876744,
-0.0229623243,
0.0130723314,
0.0102226064,
0.0053977179,
-0.0644090474,
-0.0129146762,
0.0226892587,
0.0195546038,
0.0158256087,
-0.0111075677,
-0.003483105,
-0.0651256889,
-0.0546469316,
0.0030314312,
-0.0296396837,
0.0334825851,
-0.0097699324,
0.0116709648,
-0.0194979571,
0.015782671,
0.030069489,
0.0281610619,
-0.041114267,
0.0133018289,
0.0058323243,
-0.0030156351,
-0.0342285,
0.0499268435,
-0.0451724231,
-0.020454105,
-0.0049982686,
-0.0316530131,
0.0667127892,
-0.0068153548,
0.0669605657,
0.020511467,
-0.0176521428,
-0.0509066135,
-0.0057027675,
-0.0001885601,
0.0285041369,
-0.0052106865,
0.0172272883,
0.0262358859,
-0.0369271412,
0.0298727136,
-0.0272437818,
-0.0137007004,
0.0274957381,
-0.0197582413,
-0.0378274508,
-0.0187182259,
0.000515894,
0.0220039487,
-0.0392327234,
-0.011465935,
0.0046557481,
-0.0711281225,
0.0372192003,
-0.0110683339,
-0.0173101556,
-0.0231505446,
0.055636704,
0.0871695057,
-0.0173990466,
-0.0152078597,
-0.0331888907,
0.0237244722,
-0.0385240689,
-0.0246957373,
0.013429503,
-6.487911113e-33,
-0.0030703475,
-0.0048429184,
0.003659358,
-0.0181581061,
-0.0226711836,
0.0122006824,
-0.028050689,
-0.01043553,
-0.0237768758,
0.0160329938,
-0.0243742354,
0.0129642058,
0.0250564963,
-0.0000424891,
0.0443485826,
-0.0241305456,
0.0108810049,
-0.0096025392,
0.0047723227,
0.0173099767,
-0.0048174807,
0.0386982672,
0.0922792852,
-0.0368869677,
0.0149685098,
0.0146578439,
0.0336408839,
-0.0136021357,
-0.00392318,
0.0666690469,
-0.0285206828,
0.0446250811,
0.0275213234,
-0.0389393456,
-0.0265564043,
0.0250484012,
-0.0816577375,
-0.0389600396,
-0.0153761236,
0.0498700626,
-0.0647091344,
-0.0362135619,
0.1042090282,
-0.0045398022,
-0.0145556377,
-0.0265487786,
0.0319498852,
-0.0080354698,
-0.0497140363,
-0.0019209451,
-0.0610122755,
0.0135171423,
-0.0137520209,
-0.0339344479,
0.0668615624,
0.0243954994,
-0.0496339984,
-0.0081246877,
-0.1131275743,
0.0077103102,
-0.0155438585,
0.0464672074,
0.062266577,
0.0272241365,
0.0157437865,
-0.0186504163,
0.0943300426,
0.00491009,
-0.0003287855,
-0.0373886488,
0.0583074428,
0.032333564,
0.0945244282,
0.013291264,
0.030634094,
0.0005495828,
-0.07105878,
0.0055915411,
-0.0200018939,
0.0345442034,
0.0301371813,
-0.001241601,
-0.0517187417,
0.0075055938,
-0.0145294582,
-0.0157241989,
-0.0677260011,
-0.0204701237,
0.0287079774,
-0.0069038598,
-0.0263648555,
-0.0042456095,
0.0431697518,
-0.048970405,
0.051565446,
-0.0067053712,
0.0243785791,
0.0348351113,
0.0087409187,
0.0453708544,
-0.0346086547,
0.0338546373,
-0.0227872841,
0.0169793218,
0.0124922274,
0.0166623164,
0.0184961725,
0.0215251297,
-0.0213772003,
-0.0465830192,
-0.0351282395,
-0.0064854203,
0.0154196033,
0.0235682875,
0.0347133502,
-0.0255530681,
0.0099611096,
0.0626862645,
0.0323316157,
0.0154206883,
-0.0459346883,
0.0021219654,
0.0540488325,
0.0403830968,
-0.0279296115,
-0.001911125,
-0.0534236915,
0.0227393024,
0.0226704627,
-0.0501604713,
-0.0365476236,
0.0537246242,
3.055e-7,
0.0717495903,
0.0279698893,
0.0108383019,
0.0210602768,
-0.0140570188,
0.033859808,
0.0042557782,
0.0400382876,
0.0276492462,
-0.0114844181,
0.0397493541,
0.0438459702,
0.0137953833,
-0.0165195689,
-0.0478165112,
-0.0174247511,
-0.0186790694,
0.0683449581,
-0.0098116919,
-0.0149487648,
0.0205133632,
0.0738499612,
-0.0044648964,
-0.007049487,
0.0163697153,
-0.0191931576,
0.0559201986,
0.0172567181,
-0.0123131182,
0.0059447102,
0.0351283886,
0.0039469097,
-0.0443239808,
0.0195222124,
-0.0068023899,
0.0323736034,
0.0420616679,
0.047340557,
-0.0365663357,
-0.0641028583,
0.0038235132,
-0.0083235605,
0.0271425899,
-0.0669258982,
0.0725333169,
-0.0715923682,
-0.0368015692,
0.0176375173,
-0.0249984618,
0.0183044989,
0.0629696622,
-0.0142809348,
-0.0152910938,
-0.0066778199,
0.0573232025,
-0.0121672787,
-0.0293857176,
-0.0694254264,
-0.0232219454,
0.0012311145,
-0.0272911992,
0.0207384415,
-0.0881758556,
-0.020877352,
0.0266834386,
0.0090958206,
-0.0232122857,
2.536714513e-34,
0.0259915255,
0.0127822449,
0.0532072634,
-0.0068422924,
-0.0053755143,
-0.0335201323,
-0.0300700292,
-0.0155669674,
0.0011020547,
-0.0854545459,
-0.0490574464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11379v1 | Robust Wake-Up Word Detection by Two-stage Multi-resolution Ensembles | 2023-10-17T16:22:18 | 2023-10-17T16:22:18 | Fernando López, Jordi Luque, Carlos Segura, Pablo Gómez | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Voice-based interfaces rely on a wake-up word mechanism to initiate
communication with devices. However, achieving a robust, energy-efficient, and
fast detection remains a challenge. This paper addresses these real production
needs by enhancing data with temporal alignments and using detection based on
two phases with multi-resolution. It employs two models: a lightweight
on-device model for real-time processing of the audio stream and a verification
model on the server-side, which is an ensemble of heterogeneous architectures
that refine detection. This scheme allows the optimization of two operating
points. To protect privacy, audio features are sent to the cloud instead of raw
audio. The study investigated different parametric configurations for feature
extraction to select one for on-device detection and another for the
verification model. Furthermore, thirteen different audio classifiers were
compared in terms of performance and inference time. The proposed ensemble
outperforms our stronger classifier in every noise condition. | [
-0.0043466026,
0.0175245423,
-0.0070312093,
0.0114257503,
-0.0652112663,
-0.0286988001,
0.0628093928,
-0.0470344685,
-0.050553821,
-0.0680941343,
0.0302287675,
-0.0543100983,
0.0345477797,
0.0139886243,
0.0043455702,
0.0059167231,
0.0335377567,
-0.0146767059,
0.0124302758,
-0.0111944182,
-0.0119558107,
0.0130077237,
-0.0361664891,
0.0289580245,
-0.0357556865,
0.0066822181,
-0.0363415293,
0.0066673802,
-0.0082958238,
-0.0053730593,
-0.0468951985,
0.056170553,
0.0102019394,
0.0597309582,
0.0000018615,
-0.0262047388,
-0.0329889469,
0.0466506183,
-0.0236300435,
-0.0531352498,
0.0282595642,
0.0590308085,
-0.0441754796,
0.0131773055,
0.0086807655,
-0.0031831891,
0.0649615303,
0.0127041498,
-0.0118263606,
0.0433311053,
-0.0142301386,
-0.0154607277,
0.0287453812,
0.0017514268,
-0.0304373074,
0.0035554164,
-0.0013071903,
-0.0927608088,
0.002432215,
-0.0518432371,
0.027326595,
0.0386021584,
-0.0400546864,
0.0179536883,
0.0312905535,
0.0008874579,
-0.0749932155,
-0.0462387912,
-0.0520153046,
0.0145902345,
0.0134263532,
0.0468399897,
0.0292122215,
-0.0120029273,
-0.0024276823,
0.0029079947,
0.0055179559,
-0.0197118539,
-0.0262048598,
-0.0056464472,
-0.0629553124,
0.053499449,
0.0394748524,
0.0008668239,
0.0191918667,
0.0103601823,
0.0184777789,
-0.0109163672,
0.0091509558,
-0.0000578266,
-0.0015329366,
0.0120267496,
0.0547522791,
-0.0022947399,
-0.0307984874,
0.0012509496,
-0.0501086973,
-0.0830523968,
-0.0084921047,
-0.0408408679,
0.0070314403,
-0.0070735402,
-0.0056672986,
0.0007596865,
-0.002451461,
-0.0110855382,
-0.0036370039,
-0.0558793619,
0.0037050874,
0.0100064119,
0.0038971908,
-0.0069014882,
-0.0082236277,
0.0499820225,
-0.029079169,
-0.0549525991,
-0.0453949869,
0.0028027261,
0.0094202971,
0.0161830857,
0.0033795636,
-0.0099661928,
-0.02663376,
0.0003998874,
0.0555372201,
0.007652828,
0.0497030877,
0.0366603211,
-0.0012689803,
-0.111452654,
0.0110824015,
-0.0042214249,
0.0510950983,
0.0292681791,
0.0213482399,
0.0262077954,
0.0145462025,
-0.063160561,
0.0422173664,
-0.0166499279,
-0.0294724815,
0.0005464108,
-0.0249479357,
-0.0817715824,
0.0350690261,
-0.0453986898,
0.0002590182,
0.0134886056,
0.0136994394,
0.0146666784,
0.0020771991,
0.0399778672,
-0.0300303753,
0.0130475014,
0.028534444,
0.0131519046,
-0.0002961523,
0.0541906655,
0.0916992798,
-0.0076429248,
0.0514213517,
-0.0401209407,
0.0247045364,
0.0432729274,
-0.0026405132,
-0.0558650643,
-0.0248125382,
-0.0048044827,
0.0041915816,
0.011323953,
-0.0212827567,
0.000488539,
0.0419571996,
-0.0344890207,
0.0830640495,
0.0874387249,
-0.020819908,
-0.0030746814,
-0.0245487429,
0.0328111798,
-0.0509662367,
-0.0311304666,
0.027186079,
-0.0014935249,
-0.0630666092,
-0.0003243193,
0.0707613379,
0.0519796759,
-0.0117290393,
-0.0284139775,
-0.006345747,
-0.0472247079,
-0.080806762,
0.0542177297,
0.0464186147,
-0.0197683461,
-0.0259959903,
0.0267739184,
-0.006307682,
-0.0472937748,
-0.0299963523,
-0.059786696,
0.0470667034,
0.0651864037,
0.0484226495,
-0.0203945506,
0.0522125028,
-0.0231914967,
0.0164831877,
0.0235128067,
-0.035566505,
0.0190513227,
0.0607328638,
-0.0043180832,
-0.0515174083,
0.0423146039,
0.0046180757,
0.0426520221,
-0.019318996,
0.0276324805,
-0.0120785441,
-0.0018428405,
0.0094962446,
-0.0172966849,
0.0527973846,
0.0129889399,
0.0338025689,
0.0344316177,
0.0532387234,
0.000993163,
-0.0370357186,
-0.0062103011,
0.0278828237,
-0.0551317744,
0.0222614165,
0.014448341,
-0.0412396155,
0.038555678,
0.0204827059,
0.0299103744,
0.0373320729,
0.0187956784,
0.0211898517,
-0.0208966769,
0.0109840296,
-0.0298512764,
0.0240757037,
-0.0399373621,
0.0432228334,
-0.0498507582,
0.0519664511,
0.0096144946,
0.0262433141,
0.0069911461,
0.0111452602,
-0.0849818438,
-0.0104161557,
0.0111215226,
-0.0437311679,
-0.0054724426,
0.0764071196,
-0.0212343149,
0.019934319,
-0.0067177848,
-0.0356424525,
-0.015244808,
0.0151730534,
-0.084086217,
-0.0017605983,
-0.0220833812,
-0.0018322194,
-0.0265496187,
0.0328441225,
0.0075886492,
-0.0113558369,
-0.0139090912,
-0.000660099,
-0.029128952,
-0.0003752135,
-0.0465342775,
-0.040076077,
-0.0880163237,
0.0180883389,
-0.0103965811,
0.0131160496,
0.0187210403,
-0.0029055942,
-0.0393787585,
0.0018797839,
-0.0330137946,
0.0297207218,
0.0213544033,
0.0305529535,
0.0131823076,
-0.0008407905,
0.0230268575,
0.0133022517,
0.0822675899,
0.0617660321,
-0.0278621521,
0.0536235683,
0.0247129668,
0.0171785112,
0.0114594847,
0.0205665715,
0.0164768435,
-0.0524196401,
-0.0030197301,
-0.0111745847,
0.0486929119,
0.0133865345,
0.0216171201,
0.0156208538,
-0.0083122049,
-0.0117472792,
-0.0562127642,
-0.0347382016,
-0.0200784374,
-0.0320415869,
0.0142848967,
0.0171007663,
-0.0542087443,
0.0264941901,
-0.0541705862,
-0.0160340127,
-0.0596791953,
-0.0561801605,
0.0382291526,
0.04471986,
-0.036229115,
0.0288775209,
0.0066634775,
-0.0597451515,
0.0079624886,
-0.0121292118,
0.0421216376,
-0.1235978305,
-0.0114348531,
-0.0294147972,
-0.0163113177,
-0.0095914332,
-0.0427353308,
-0.0223910306,
-0.055964224,
-0.0357327834,
-0.0354160741,
-0.044217255,
-0.033714097,
-0.0209019333,
0.0396376923,
-0.0004559271,
0.0188783854,
0.0229545534,
-0.0130562335,
-0.0194900837,
0.0471904203,
0.0188670587,
0.0803740397,
-0.0198566653,
0.0256205108,
0.0376067124,
0.0243077148,
0.0685566962,
0.0186456554,
-0.035174977,
-0.0193748698,
0.0315948837,
-0.0040519498,
-0.0302383658,
0.0527487062,
0.0524424613,
-0.0112874266,
0.0299568791,
0.0815147758,
-0.0271815043,
-0.0392289907,
-0.021071177,
0.043071311,
-0.0278746411,
0.0036016305,
-0.0400124826,
-0.0028984745,
-0.0093441857,
0.0586542338,
0.0723807141,
-0.0243456177,
0.0381047949,
-0.0447524637,
-0.0413236357,
0.0313295648,
0.0103157908,
-0.0168029722,
-0.0224332474,
-0.0239155143,
0.0252373479,
-0.006465286,
0.0360382572,
-0.0253359769,
-0.006338995,
-0.0307939965,
-0.0120758452,
-0.0268933531,
-0.0148317814,
0.0181622971,
-0.0633539855,
0.0364295654,
0.094244644,
0.0244060308,
-0.0121630393,
-0.0401270166,
-0.0461109616,
-0.0031918627,
0.0115711074,
0.0081327176,
-0.0306210089,
0.0168307535,
0.0021622276,
-0.0011275843,
0.0185193233,
0.0103763482,
0.0053337696,
0.0509358495,
0.0496910512,
-0.0017515139,
-0.0325152762,
-0.0362979881,
0.0205884762,
0.0296296142,
0.0408973657,
-0.0208128672,
-0.0563395657,
-0.0121847792,
0.0678259805,
0.0039264662,
-0.0358243324,
0.0216739364,
0.0157297291,
0.0121082962,
-0.0855974033,
-0.0132872146,
0.0161096118,
-0.0185742527,
0.0723438561,
0.0243205801,
0.0765589848,
0.0131465355,
0.0731270462,
-0.0939592049,
-0.0431297459,
0.0092886062,
0.0299574565,
-0.0125630517,
-0.019640334,
0.0270347167,
-0.0217160154,
-0.0083178738,
0.0209126547,
-0.0224005263,
-0.0218267329,
0.022624556,
-0.0216990393,
0.01524367,
0.040769767,
-0.0526186377,
-0.0315751061,
0.0837198272,
0.079069823,
-0.0268141609,
0.0375985391,
0.0660193488,
-0.0347562395,
-0.0306373574,
0.015961051,
-0.057558991,
0.0236565694,
-0.0009714295,
-0.0324737951,
-0.00912733,
-0.0499948673,
-0.0112110758,
0.0087369028,
0.0278460756,
-0.0423650853,
0.0314950496,
-0.0139823547,
0.0660747513,
0.0009799422,
0.0294321887,
-0.0329013839,
0.016492283,
-0.0196362901,
-0.0096529145,
0.0037977721,
0.0480710231,
0.0425869301,
-0.0586715415,
-0.0253110118,
0.0362745151,
-0.0045677442,
0.0085074594,
0.0265976656,
-0.0103978198,
-0.0203100741,
0.0525917634,
0.0358840488,
0.0031278837,
-0.0046607722,
-0.0071668825,
-0.0109488359,
-0.0394698791,
-0.0208911207,
0.0490797944,
0.007354869,
0.0269342586,
-0.0241315514,
0.0403243713,
0.0141847357,
0.0129259517,
-0.0249552242,
-0.0059188055,
0.0006807467,
-0.0261793081,
0.0387093425,
-0.0167012978,
0.0031757106,
-0.0122675048,
0.0258062687,
-0.0293209367,
0.0289854296,
0.01298049,
-0.0475039259,
-0.0083849542,
-0.0155413384,
-0.02614896,
-0.0483492911,
-0.0042377468,
-0.0714918748,
0.0397940166,
-0.0287986528,
0.0170518141,
-0.0158849917,
-0.0171477217,
0.0138353556,
-0.0428030565,
0.0485866107,
0.0052652322,
0.0033863382,
0.0581643805,
-0.0057909167,
-0.01953163,
-0.0099841384,
-0.0217423923,
-0.0441173576,
0.0272885002,
0.0336111896,
-5.638732158e-33,
-0.0152902408,
-0.018635571,
-0.0418089814,
0.0036661956,
0.0187097676,
0.0221204087,
0.0372807011,
0.0097999573,
0.0180355441,
-0.0287305471,
-0.0279616807,
0.0419166014,
0.0396338031,
0.0077593545,
-0.0128675662,
0.0037628927,
0.0809651315,
-0.0345015563,
-0.0062165428,
0.0368579216,
0.0764635131,
0.0419585109,
0.0175390337,
-0.0702146664,
-0.0159967747,
0.0058358363,
-0.0316373967,
-0.0620729625,
-0.0363077559,
-0.0009461993,
-0.0218831375,
0.0392999537,
0.0013695403,
0.0276150126,
0.0004430942,
0.0520171709,
-0.0634342954,
0.0236421507,
-0.0126221944,
0.0633697212,
-0.0182368364,
-0.0443112254,
0.0474269576,
0.0064354148,
-0.0546127446,
-0.0228279755,
0.0308260713,
-0.0402322523,
-0.0532787517,
-0.0784637406,
-0.0050431681,
0.0036639783,
0.0296667889,
0.0086757485,
0.0371313095,
0.0090104472,
-0.0098503008,
-0.0480203256,
-0.0389712937,
0.0313070081,
0.0216576438,
0.0064598205,
0.0106464364,
0.0328442901,
0.0127059156,
0.085141845,
0.0656528547,
-0.0877453759,
-0.0056342897,
0.0286131278,
0.0007292482,
0.0371785387,
0.0305022337,
0.0108972862,
0.0369033739,
-0.0587653071,
-0.0274156742,
0.0016562445,
0.0344359875,
-0.0807355419,
0.0738218352,
0.0112748826,
-0.0673719645,
0.0268401355,
-0.0406182483,
0.0005579506,
-0.0302273482,
-0.0122967986,
0.0253318138,
0.0409523286,
-0.0406883731,
0.0122718858,
0.0127471685,
-0.0080752652,
0.0092514642,
-0.0200545322,
0.0420985818,
-0.0155677823,
0.0221055672,
-0.0360924415,
0.0488921627,
0.0275226515,
0.0528600141,
0.0089265322,
0.0078823064,
-0.0183306169,
-0.012054679,
0.0774492919,
-0.045031134,
-0.0056588007,
0.0303589869,
0.0158724803,
0.0139481938,
-0.0002135067,
0.0528963357,
-0.0288863573,
-0.0060456116,
0.0489887074,
-0.0370296836,
0.0010400312,
-0.0212201551,
-0.015454907,
-0.0422657505,
0.0152165722,
0.003377375,
0.0169131439,
-0.0093481895,
-0.0276794806,
0.0592129305,
0.0098836673,
-0.0042861309,
-0.0123595586,
2.903e-7,
-0.0844472647,
-0.0314414576,
-0.000380949,
-0.0754977986,
0.0319247097,
0.0213397425,
0.0131069385,
0.0321641043,
-0.0357027613,
-0.0171945766,
-0.0023000424,
-0.0723930374,
0.1142830551,
0.0204803795,
-0.086416252,
-0.019894626,
-0.0162018277,
0.0580381602,
-0.0803025514,
0.0029055562,
0.034787178,
0.0687470138,
0.0116589516,
-0.0520326346,
0.0176497828,
-0.0342659876,
-0.0109239575,
-0.0168697499,
0.038234219,
-0.0693177283,
0.0474330522,
0.0377403311,
-0.0093344375,
0.0386567861,
-0.0265107881,
0.0681130961,
-0.0121221887,
0.0433108918,
-0.0024482829,
-0.0044845426,
-0.0377270132,
-0.0071003195,
-0.0213344283,
0.0417160355,
0.057202287,
0.0240538996,
-0.0802062675,
-0.0558504201,
-0.0272643659,
-0.0538268276,
0.0106369602,
0.0245928783,
0.0635812134,
-0.0102383839,
-0.0371599346,
-0.0378588624,
-0.0143924598,
-0.0365528464,
0.0198005848,
0.0196963381,
-0.0125335129,
-0.0417065397,
-0.0269936137,
-0.0124709867,
0.0228925645,
-0.0229933392,
0.0075497041,
2.218292838e-34,
-0.0147137213,
-0.0184986852,
-0.0213185698,
0.0661770254,
-0.0154843302,
-0.015622098,
0.0737206042,
-0.0095887827,
-0.005465806,
-0.0375714675,
-0.0146458335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11374v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11374v4 | DialogueLLM: Context and Emotion Knowledge-Tuned Large Language Models for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-10-17T16:15:34 | 2024-01-17T02:44:56 | Yazhou Zhang, Mengyao Wang, Youxi Wu, Prayag Tiwari, Qiuchi Li, Benyou Wang, Jing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) and their variants have shown extraordinary
efficacy across numerous downstream natural language processing (NLP) tasks,
which has presented a new vision for the development of NLP. Despite their
remarkable performance in natural language generating (NLG), LLMs lack a
distinct focus on the emotion understanding domain. As a result, using LLMs for
emotion recognition may lead to suboptimal and inadequate precision. Another
limitation of LLMs is that they are typical trained without leveraging
multi-modal information. To overcome these limitations, we propose DialogueLLM,
a context and emotion knowledge tuned LLM that is obtained by fine-tuning LLaMA
models with 13,638 multi-modal (i.e., texts and videos) emotional dialogues.
The visual information is considered as the supplementary knowledge to
construct high-quality instructions. We offer a comprehensive evaluation of our
proposed model on three benchmarking emotion recognition in conversations (ERC)
datasets and compare the results against the SOTA baselines and other SOTA
LLMs. Additionally, DialogueLLM-7B can be easily trained using LoRA on a 40GB
A100 GPU in 5 hours, facilitating reproducibility for other researchers. | [
0.0426467434,
0.0729584321,
0.00257696,
0.0809159502,
0.0033721607,
0.024409119,
0.0006403383,
-0.007942671,
0.0254397523,
-0.0743720084,
-0.084526144,
-0.0306764003,
-0.0159182493,
0.0381455943,
-0.0065365047,
-0.0665139779,
-0.0024920467,
-0.0140178185,
0.0483175442,
0.0092686024,
0.0236903615,
0.0341264978,
0.0109222205,
0.0274900906,
-0.0416535512,
-0.0256773811,
-0.0075240834,
0.0380187817,
0.0244911183,
-0.0361979827,
0.0119151464,
0.0355483219,
0.0372217037,
-0.0135850674,
0.0000020764,
-0.032732442,
0.0106980372,
-0.0340696983,
-0.0211142488,
0.0139455842,
0.0546926968,
-0.0321583524,
-0.013054234,
0.0082527688,
-0.0242136512,
0.0178978182,
0.0277171843,
0.0816156864,
0.080556348,
0.0859818012,
-0.0326166153,
-0.0298441183,
0.0296847634,
-0.0492061786,
0.0128977634,
-0.0571542382,
0.0093382969,
0.0257996358,
-0.0122291651,
-0.0078133009,
-0.0258235727,
0.0133960554,
-0.0132159274,
-0.0280654654,
-0.0186315682,
0.0155749666,
-0.0001509678,
-0.0293133724,
-0.0227415394,
0.0952911526,
-0.0139169842,
0.0450089909,
-0.0038657044,
-0.005385133,
-0.0146914097,
-0.0609515943,
-0.0429373607,
0.0341725424,
0.0031628455,
0.0349174775,
0.0040680221,
0.0059783086,
0.0120736258,
0.0353055559,
0.0289689414,
0.0055992883,
-0.0115729626,
0.0093780616,
0.0183589328,
-0.0012942355,
-0.0319266468,
-0.0339886621,
-0.0154455034,
0.0197143946,
-0.0209382921,
0.0215010215,
-0.0468976274,
0.0370324813,
0.005033806,
-0.0698523968,
0.0125070829,
0.0249557458,
-0.0437898412,
0.0526703,
-0.0100793885,
0.0600963682,
-0.0036073262,
-0.015278318,
-0.0206785593,
-0.0239920225,
-0.0131589873,
0.005686827,
0.0074477619,
0.0066512222,
-0.0983836725,
-0.0756426975,
-0.0564183667,
0.0253379904,
-0.0048915609,
0.021571273,
0.0041450942,
0.0063953712,
0.0021491395,
-0.0191851947,
-0.0290634278,
0.0139096035,
-0.0104303565,
0.0544755235,
0.0108528761,
-0.0652002394,
-0.007537114,
0.0398390703,
0.0173869785,
0.0043398538,
0.0469375998,
0.061564967,
-0.018268859,
-0.0458827354,
-0.0378434844,
-0.0208716244,
-0.0357428677,
-0.0796066076,
0.0083848555,
-0.0195931718,
0.0551529117,
-0.0129384156,
0.0188884884,
-0.0018165054,
0.0485585146,
-0.0152295036,
-0.0326333977,
0.0700197592,
-0.0010047369,
0.0054148412,
0.0207285509,
0.0183491241,
0.0173253361,
0.0650761127,
0.0364509709,
0.0592809692,
0.0426646657,
-0.0109371915,
0.0247710571,
0.0179119576,
-0.017315805,
-0.0005496822,
-0.0181446541,
-0.0146999257,
-0.0206869803,
0.0613409504,
0.065737702,
0.0580064394,
-0.0506604947,
-0.0011689309,
0.0607206933,
0.0249931365,
-0.0216942709,
0.0367632061,
-0.0175795108,
0.0210115109,
0.0269689914,
-0.0521706492,
-0.0458667018,
0.0343607925,
-0.0059491792,
-0.0106208744,
0.0491927788,
0.0182707421,
-0.0248558782,
-0.0408187881,
-0.0017284286,
-0.0164363831,
-0.0206866879,
0.0143007282,
-0.0093034711,
-0.0085554607,
-0.0666259602,
0.0381333567,
0.0208554212,
-0.0291752107,
-0.0329590403,
-0.0508562326,
0.0430655666,
0.0770338774,
0.0216883123,
-0.0266210195,
-0.0567038581,
-0.0311899371,
0.0119771846,
0.0499431193,
0.0201146975,
-0.0041415715,
0.0564723983,
-0.0978684202,
0.0234222729,
-0.0377995707,
0.0071367854,
0.02581577,
-0.0096465861,
0.0217043497,
0.0121846814,
0.0192783028,
0.0033686578,
0.0424489044,
-0.0014086151,
-0.0342457518,
0.0192709491,
0.0027182761,
0.0279746167,
0.0053809355,
-0.0208528824,
-0.0402588807,
0.0336194858,
-0.0384884737,
0.0075151031,
0.0103084771,
-0.0621349849,
-0.0811621398,
0.0272146557,
0.0180484354,
0.0113518974,
0.003113399,
-0.0736167431,
-0.0301068779,
0.0073165963,
-0.0048580565,
0.0218716711,
-0.0424382947,
0.0299290027,
0.0350192487,
0.0617098399,
-0.0188638959,
0.0339012183,
-0.003885003,
-0.0352742858,
0.0177662577,
0.0274887662,
-0.0011140291,
-0.026640201,
-0.0278258119,
0.0185487438,
0.0174899977,
0.0093742311,
-0.0144702112,
0.0406512581,
-0.0573460124,
-0.0907561705,
-0.1322515905,
0.0139884958,
0.0012640031,
-0.001992167,
0.0001832508,
-0.0109236371,
-0.041778598,
-0.0006113472,
-0.0253978856,
0.0319431908,
0.0372181684,
-0.0133049358,
0.0312045701,
0.0221531186,
-0.0152496379,
-0.0757035166,
0.0453404151,
0.0289074723,
0.0591183901,
-0.0083620446,
-0.0220949277,
-0.0304249302,
0.0257975534,
-0.017790297,
0.0286953896,
-0.0315924101,
-0.0500182174,
-0.0082492372,
0.0278227758,
0.0207475703,
0.0901589543,
0.0165205896,
0.0605968013,
-0.0162334032,
-0.0116135152,
-0.0304356385,
0.0464471094,
-0.0141877597,
-0.0141537655,
-0.0417193398,
0.0034481112,
-0.0111526558,
0.0338374414,
-0.0110470839,
0.0508487448,
-0.0229607802,
0.0007214516,
0.0408079699,
-0.032068193,
-0.0076270709,
-0.0392215066,
-0.013655873,
-0.001054105,
-0.0166727901,
-0.0670309737,
-0.0098694712,
-0.0393030941,
-0.0146995327,
-0.0342682637,
-0.0293572787,
-0.0655454844,
0.0884928405,
-0.0355004407,
0.009704682,
-0.0378662087,
0.0043310984,
0.0077921329,
-0.037168432,
-0.0332114883,
-0.0325701572,
0.0503320247,
-0.0460396856,
-0.0165980905,
0.0131001752,
-0.0468115658,
-0.0365404896,
-0.0419855341,
-0.0557922274,
-0.0285937879,
0.0171320643,
-0.0062461016,
-0.0083069252,
-0.0086984169,
0.0140743386,
-0.0143349031,
0.0040238583,
-0.0057496508,
-0.0142001566,
0.0628834888,
0.0661371425,
0.0149497138,
0.014068367,
-0.0345442221,
0.0599981733,
0.0514437631,
0.0082717082,
0.0105564119,
-0.0320764594,
0.0195658915,
-0.0015516145,
0.0601445809,
-0.0210939758,
-0.0180586427,
0.0489233658,
-0.0465186723,
0.0305943619,
0.1269114166,
0.0124072982,
-0.0423990525,
-0.0044885962,
-0.0250949375,
0.0111934822,
0.018197678,
0.0195955485,
-0.0630492344,
-0.0617290586,
-0.000821129,
0.0020961722,
-0.0018091922,
-0.0138467522,
-0.0177917667,
-0.0780720711,
0.0443955623,
-0.0082846759,
-0.0059988643,
-0.0428546667,
-0.0000156665,
0.0111652752,
-0.0044239564,
0.0064788591,
-0.0434069932,
0.0028515104,
-0.0347413979,
0.0372858047,
-0.0010667556,
-0.0505814441,
0.0453709662,
-0.0214447491,
0.0691422597,
0.0031362334,
0.0927987546,
0.0143735055,
-0.0195470843,
0.0486836471,
0.0202817488,
0.0209907088,
-0.0218698662,
0.0405968949,
-0.0469782539,
-0.0262894817,
-0.0028373117,
0.040853966,
-0.039183028,
-0.0220373441,
-0.0077702608,
0.0223552268,
-0.0388367064,
-0.0144400038,
-0.0030882806,
0.005124405,
0.0174271762,
0.0576324984,
0.0241340362,
-0.0335707217,
-0.0263980217,
0.0003348392,
0.0058996719,
-0.0103401765,
-0.0065731672,
-0.0223318003,
0.0076384726,
0.0161378793,
-0.0507201627,
-0.0314129926,
0.0230285693,
0.0187802482,
-0.0265800301,
-0.0333274305,
-0.0143181123,
0.0139710596,
-0.0144514516,
0.0613713712,
-0.0156104174,
-0.0106508164,
-0.0588380024,
0.0165385548,
0.0602289401,
-0.0335851647,
-0.0147420736,
0.0505276993,
-0.0704158992,
-0.0552248694,
-0.0283210296,
0.0338484421,
0.0121657019,
0.0307576712,
0.0636608228,
-0.0441821404,
0.016139036,
0.0335687138,
-0.0054894625,
0.037169788,
0.0093172155,
0.0461947732,
-0.0222856496,
0.0388476327,
-0.0139393592,
0.0549753234,
0.0089604631,
0.0312660895,
-0.0004206443,
-0.0894008577,
-0.0409859046,
-0.0029897939,
0.024571836,
-0.0103235375,
-0.0318003483,
-0.0467015915,
0.0044552679,
-0.0009634037,
0.0197072774,
-0.067017585,
-0.0240921117,
0.0068915025,
0.002841118,
-0.0389362685,
-0.0493100025,
0.0059920177,
0.0181047246,
-0.015838813,
0.0237409156,
0.0107665649,
-0.0236314405,
-0.0139284283,
0.0187526904,
-0.0152618568,
0.0149274487,
-0.013048769,
0.0169944186,
-0.0210727416,
0.0732833296,
-0.0144546404,
-0.0389218591,
-0.00777752,
0.0449225046,
0.011512707,
-0.0353151038,
-0.0361607485,
0.0357240736,
0.0602605864,
-0.019849347,
0.0505972691,
-0.0465151109,
0.0194721278,
-0.0083067082,
0.0396638475,
-0.0197866671,
-0.0434148759,
0.0570726395,
0.0075147483,
-0.0448835641,
0.0250382908,
0.0478862263,
-0.0248164497,
0.0695870891,
0.0111692706,
0.004627957,
-0.0609828308,
-0.0140845682,
0.0789677799,
-0.0210543331,
0.0163783673,
0.0246648826,
-0.0124799469,
-0.0272352621,
0.0370286331,
-0.0509875901,
-0.0263381675,
-0.0197499357,
0.0331273787,
0.0517313108,
-0.0040926486,
0.0218735691,
-0.0219586007,
-0.0088896072,
-0.0515695438,
-0.0116471602,
-0.0185819212,
-6.305249577e-33,
-0.0224119499,
-0.0106999837,
0.0075677838,
-0.0018313044,
-0.0430837832,
0.0479070768,
-0.0333056077,
0.0041661812,
-0.0245599356,
0.0227521304,
-0.007492288,
0.0069200094,
0.0071829325,
0.0309929643,
-0.0246217046,
-0.0176801812,
0.0239798892,
-0.0171152353,
-0.0048110038,
0.0370735228,
0.0327935033,
0.0296733715,
0.0377919078,
-0.092236571,
-0.0345740728,
0.0176159311,
-0.0420602597,
0.0139036672,
0.0483016446,
0.0538862236,
-0.0564531758,
0.0493365005,
0.0160445031,
-0.0176896043,
0.0176924095,
0.0395210721,
-0.003473368,
0.01675147,
0.0239996836,
-0.0067940964,
-0.0376628079,
-0.0520044863,
0.0036975127,
0.0353053883,
0.0042763618,
0.0062941969,
-0.014548324,
-0.0290858336,
-0.0135005554,
-0.0513183065,
-0.0451569296,
0.0286378674,
-0.0188553706,
-0.0511065014,
0.0276062675,
0.0068450803,
0.008954173,
0.0187010113,
-0.0387263857,
0.0229439549,
-0.0010125916,
0.0030682806,
0.0322178304,
0.0105000362,
0.0006696414,
0.0968791321,
0.0121253412,
0.006882871,
-0.0093046753,
0.0099453852,
-0.022971129,
0.0868867114,
-0.0188442487,
0.0482293293,
-0.0409453101,
-0.0092454823,
-0.0509436764,
-0.0068372921,
0.011021222,
0.0335212462,
0.0477343053,
0.0061255852,
-0.0197200608,
0.0073961038,
-0.0275478382,
0.0016139523,
-0.0194288194,
0.011576796,
0.0503100306,
0.0404841267,
0.0055188974,
-0.014449209,
0.0220594686,
-0.0197627898,
0.0149172219,
0.0349546708,
-0.0344040915,
0.0469917841,
-0.0119452979,
-0.0029412368,
-0.0333333164,
-0.0601338334,
0.0700669885,
-0.02799627,
0.030041445,
-0.017742455,
-0.0133441323,
0.0289499629,
-0.0735395998,
0.0045893239,
-0.0125734461,
0.0655429065,
-0.0189886726,
0.0679019019,
-0.0338112339,
-0.0024236951,
-0.0394396782,
0.0440869033,
-0.0123695564,
0.0359650366,
0.0107152509,
-0.0420949124,
0.0006897953,
0.0310587287,
-0.0510274954,
0.0305300299,
0.0057513677,
-0.0778045133,
-0.0056691612,
-0.0314378291,
-0.0075500873,
-0.0069925329,
2.797e-7,
-0.0304356385,
0.0757410973,
0.0074258628,
-0.0153683228,
0.0288964752,
0.0585421063,
0.0156921223,
0.0409446023,
0.0368500426,
-0.0452787578,
0.0165772866,
0.0275267027,
0.0448626727,
-0.0079233497,
-0.060316477,
0.0021027203,
-0.0234317146,
-0.0273692328,
-0.0386005305,
-0.0289670117,
0.074431099,
0.1312132776,
0.0083112121,
-0.0052783596,
0.0196442902,
-0.024025755,
0.068607457,
-0.0510435216,
-0.0364370197,
0.0443228558,
0.0071922853,
0.0002188253,
-0.0340286978,
0.0053136451,
0.0244711321,
0.0132709658,
0.0050664013,
0.1024723873,
0.0105246902,
-0.0693999976,
0.0315263569,
0.0524867401,
-0.0167724136,
-0.0440496914,
0.039531108,
-0.0226981025,
-0.0305484347,
-0.0580190457,
0.0012570883,
-0.0295031089,
0.0493430831,
-0.041845303,
-0.0047290707,
0.0110095954,
0.0140994005,
-0.037530262,
-0.0462293737,
-0.0926240385,
-0.0120035689,
-0.0240438879,
-0.0700622648,
-0.0039703837,
-0.0539342016,
0.003325081,
0.0468987599,
-0.0471460521,
0.0142592257,
2.223291903e-34,
0.0258217156,
-0.0179109145,
-0.0118126553,
0.0411526673,
0.0345901288,
0.0363319442,
-0.0378733836,
-0.0146963848,
0.0068619964,
-0.097922951,
0.0348048434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11368v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11368v4 | VECHR: A Dataset for Explainable and Robust Classification of Vulnerability Type in the European Court of Human Rights | 2023-10-17T16:05:52 | 2023-10-24T12:30:25 | Shanshan Xu, Leon Staufer, T. Y. S. S Santosh, Oana Ichim, Corina Heri, Matthias Grabmair | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing vulnerability is crucial for understanding and implementing
targeted support to empower individuals in need. This is especially important
at the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), where the court adapts
Convention standards to meet actual individual needs and thus ensures effective
human rights protection. However, the concept of vulnerability remains elusive
at the ECtHR and no prior NLP research has dealt with it. To enable future
research in this area, we present VECHR, a novel expert-annotated multi-label
dataset comprising of vulnerability type classification and explanation
rationale. We benchmark the performance of state-of-the-art models on VECHR
from both prediction and explainability perspectives. Our results demonstrate
the challenging nature of the task with lower prediction performance and
limited agreement between models and experts. Further, we analyze the
robustness of these models in dealing with out-of-domain (OOD) data and observe
overall limited performance. Our dataset poses unique challenges offering
significant room for improvement regarding performance, explainability, and
robustness. | [
0.0245411787,
0.0583519787,
-0.0054637445,
-0.0040774518,
-0.0190399662,
0.0291799437,
0.0499861501,
-0.015439976,
0.0276027825,
-0.0474455506,
0.0542498715,
0.0159953684,
-0.0240381416,
-0.0005841453,
0.0289349277,
-0.0646212474,
0.0453464128,
0.0167221949,
0.0289552584,
0.0068671056,
0.0096037937,
0.0218189545,
-0.01969276,
0.0818590075,
0.0162978321,
0.0188133698,
-0.021223126,
0.0005053126,
0.0075250226,
-0.0357234031,
-0.0064717983,
0.0629464984,
0.0510219075,
-0.0389152803,
0.000001895,
-0.0416632593,
-0.0287719872,
0.011885073,
0.0027241085,
-0.0164099596,
-0.0166011099,
-0.0898404941,
-0.0011157099,
0.0111637432,
0.0265775342,
0.0109631419,
0.0257443208,
0.0394068025,
0.0679384544,
0.0741585046,
0.0038368008,
0.0148486765,
-0.008749444,
-0.004065109,
-0.0137761896,
-0.0741074532,
0.0161927901,
-0.0252436232,
-0.0103215789,
0.0015031995,
0.0543165505,
-0.0076640481,
0.0071538286,
-0.0071979403,
-0.0146894585,
-0.0168831013,
-0.0050028022,
-0.0369011015,
0.0207122508,
0.0752482191,
0.0325367153,
0.0000571434,
-0.0042378642,
0.0007875169,
0.0475949161,
0.0698576272,
0.0146888392,
0.0426978804,
-0.0260805823,
-0.0033693397,
0.0253855903,
0.0761043429,
0.0016070565,
0.0244699623,
0.0032838488,
0.0313304812,
-0.0505902357,
-0.0200891998,
0.0174573231,
-0.0133842602,
-0.0184421595,
-0.018147219,
0.0292346794,
0.0240962058,
-0.0333839394,
0.0282733943,
-0.0157650951,
-0.026410386,
0.0570737384,
-0.0631069392,
0.0243845303,
0.0340902284,
-0.0484134071,
0.0183677189,
0.0064319526,
-0.010482884,
-0.0125510283,
0.0404929183,
0.0161831602,
-0.0150635904,
-0.102545917,
-0.0027616678,
-0.0075149219,
0.0084841736,
-0.0537150949,
0.0321025141,
-0.0292919502,
-0.0165615454,
-0.0385493152,
0.010952672,
-0.0069216969,
0.0075860382,
-0.0197652765,
-0.0039583673,
-0.0751113743,
-0.034524031,
-0.0545783676,
0.0333246589,
-0.0250928681,
-0.046144221,
0.0125837708,
-0.0194830187,
-0.0165707115,
-0.0127003388,
-0.0182470214,
0.0944659635,
0.0228891242,
-0.0032684335,
-0.0548189133,
-0.0606349781,
-0.0092086028,
-0.0223005097,
-0.0141719608,
-0.037347585,
0.0098394593,
-0.0151079008,
0.006174529,
-0.0928652734,
0.0196743011,
0.0180199686,
-0.0351381861,
0.1031776443,
-0.0368117429,
-0.0265897233,
-0.0137693072,
0.0347854085,
0.0142437499,
-0.0081355711,
-0.048206646,
0.0063677551,
0.0307344906,
-0.0341237299,
0.0576032326,
-0.0138106169,
-0.0277573019,
0.0391308144,
0.0560563393,
0.0298878308,
-0.0013948759,
0.0189328268,
0.0169946942,
-0.0334922038,
0.0149289779,
-0.0096617639,
0.0142733091,
0.0415126756,
0.0223330483,
0.0366231315,
-0.0279825535,
0.0175935328,
-0.0317406766,
-0.037713591,
-0.0428634584,
0.0336253159,
0.0186116472,
-0.0294317901,
-0.025422059,
0.0052007535,
-0.0229799263,
-0.0572966225,
-0.0385447666,
0.0343034752,
-0.0100152018,
0.0004445502,
0.030530015,
0.0223749988,
0.0137703996,
0.0511424094,
0.0538703501,
-0.0391691849,
-0.022779787,
-0.0612861104,
-0.0346238948,
0.0308811441,
0.0084924642,
-0.0666077286,
-0.001191631,
-0.0570448749,
0.0239677541,
0.023708364,
0.0304315034,
0.004179121,
0.0025541838,
-0.0126567082,
-0.0475616083,
0.0188646782,
0.0297355428,
0.0486778282,
-0.0158666894,
-0.0512148961,
0.0135779036,
-0.0796333775,
-0.0353720002,
0.0688644573,
0.044519145,
0.010451599,
0.0089673558,
0.0168167204,
0.0297539402,
0.0256677177,
0.0243911333,
-0.0027591479,
0.0225460008,
-0.0159441512,
0.0032037909,
-0.005053815,
-0.0148309832,
0.0260631703,
0.0110388966,
-0.0663705692,
0.0022429498,
0.0244415347,
-0.0588030629,
0.0090837246,
0.0279313382,
0.0200899709,
-0.0230283495,
-0.0547890924,
0.0011215762,
0.0174495187,
0.0006795419,
-0.0209341291,
0.0614015125,
-0.0121490052,
-0.0121153658,
-0.0607105717,
0.0144588882,
0.0777759701,
-0.0114475694,
-0.0244328417,
-0.0030341744,
-0.0610078238,
0.0110162701,
0.020793736,
-0.0136019578,
-0.0089284535,
-0.0009372221,
-0.0504708476,
0.0102812452,
-0.0034457333,
0.0068979943,
0.0202319808,
-0.0363481343,
0.0109958826,
-0.0082206512,
-0.021011617,
-0.0485740267,
-0.0500031151,
0.0119055929,
0.0251478609,
0.0023857201,
-0.0014946099,
-0.0355384424,
-0.0133001255,
-0.0488478988,
0.0647669137,
0.0024004327,
-0.0138957929,
-0.0195335131,
0.0233193934,
-0.0282857362,
-0.0178725068,
-0.0282717831,
-0.0430333242,
0.0084529379,
0.0416178145,
-0.0554128215,
-0.0745311081,
0.0410383977,
0.1075449362,
0.0448949859,
0.0435749739,
-0.0062303348,
-0.0186579097,
-0.027009828,
-0.0296177305,
-0.0098736128,
-0.0105803385,
-0.0000891059,
0.017037591,
0.0282549374,
-0.0054532713,
-0.0517809838,
-0.016157018,
-0.031009445,
-0.0132673299,
-0.0874426067,
-0.0245027691,
-0.0065259486,
0.0668915287,
-0.008788567,
-0.019440148,
0.0487511642,
0.0278615206,
0.0873362869,
-0.0242236983,
-0.0446295775,
-0.0652381554,
0.09381219,
-0.0315543376,
0.0063466458,
0.0330967195,
-0.0261149202,
0.0328338258,
-0.0216154065,
0.0436694548,
-0.0081638489,
0.0273071639,
-0.0643704012,
0.014161014,
0.0044638095,
-0.0678324476,
-0.0078542419,
-0.0352877527,
0.0147054195,
0.0457815528,
0.004683469,
0.0097895842,
-0.0490093566,
0.006472473,
0.0208757147,
0.0293648373,
0.0223811381,
-0.0179830622,
-0.0348040387,
-0.0028808012,
-0.0494108871,
-0.0242679659,
0.015980674,
-0.0304971188,
-0.0108754635,
0.027668424,
0.0079043759,
-0.0138868475,
-0.0063588647,
0.0341879614,
-0.002918252,
-0.0654863417,
0.0059483661,
-0.0056236843,
0.0146505702,
-0.0573159046,
0.0187616926,
0.0689963251,
0.0224746987,
-0.0542947873,
0.0339464992,
-0.0076907878,
-0.0073099444,
0.0476045758,
-0.0072752372,
-0.081869632,
-0.0039980435,
0.0002122188,
0.0278110951,
-0.0781436563,
-0.0430302471,
-0.0000249948,
-0.0519096032,
0.0598055385,
-0.0163180903,
-0.0112093603,
-0.0269311443,
-0.0388141461,
0.020608414,
-0.0204378795,
-0.0146707073,
-0.034186393,
0.0094689783,
-0.009034845,
0.0489928648,
-0.0964683592,
-0.0526617765,
0.0382013321,
-0.0429278761,
0.0795130283,
0.0102439206,
0.0484523177,
-0.0122645814,
0.018765131,
0.0560308471,
-0.0381579809,
0.0059853727,
0.0296245068,
0.0877380744,
0.0288535133,
-0.0130074127,
0.0036805496,
0.0471972004,
-0.050457146,
-0.0338845067,
0.0386042818,
0.0611961149,
-0.0404182747,
0.0394416116,
-0.0069774208,
-0.0420105718,
0.0128973089,
0.0435378291,
0.006803948,
0.0053222156,
-0.0296077523,
-0.0568774454,
0.0004566663,
-0.055047106,
-0.0547060557,
0.0396126248,
-0.0272306595,
-0.0512481816,
-0.0051001143,
-0.0328103527,
-0.0008995103,
0.0474188812,
0.0145075452,
-0.029264776,
0.0040315907,
0.0331355892,
-0.0508159436,
0.0655945018,
0.0173778422,
0.0357504077,
0.0026857997,
-0.0173494536,
-0.0136229694,
-0.0009312162,
-0.0382647701,
0.0075514722,
0.0126974909,
-0.019153621,
-0.0054120682,
-0.0162599236,
0.0299372561,
-0.0159511436,
-0.0059617497,
-0.0702311397,
0.0264104772,
0.0211836547,
-0.0264754724,
-0.0470757112,
0.0468893237,
-0.0469754674,
-0.0364552066,
0.0018056084,
0.0276974477,
0.0334290825,
-0.0002240849,
0.0113816801,
-0.0292087067,
-0.0108449906,
0.0374276452,
-0.0218800623,
0.0647950247,
-0.0080731269,
-0.0950663015,
-0.0579473712,
-0.040314991,
0.0168406982,
-0.0280991849,
0.005666832,
0.027324466,
0.015376444,
-0.007713146,
-0.0052554584,
0.0062441221,
-0.0277091675,
0.0019731643,
-0.016854655,
0.0722712502,
0.0647303611,
0.0296703912,
-0.0236603562,
0.0100673549,
-0.0133864246,
0.0336574838,
-0.0025996489,
0.0385309905,
-0.0163594168,
0.0365215577,
-0.0012399975,
0.033479847,
0.0012991537,
0.0263876785,
-0.0244804062,
-0.015900515,
-0.0194719508,
-0.0267414227,
0.0213551745,
0.0394191928,
0.0013453458,
0.0284549277,
-0.0332348756,
-0.0074976604,
0.047412537,
-0.0250206348,
-0.0147147588,
0.0310144536,
0.0257118661,
-0.018982077,
0.0239971802,
0.0128250066,
0.0372239128,
0.0287698284,
-0.0085763661,
-0.0445116125,
0.0017536458,
-0.0083811032,
-0.0194578078,
0.0155670596,
-0.0055350987,
-0.0243750177,
-0.0939874128,
-0.0354112796,
-0.0184515528,
-0.0050334316,
-0.0230586268,
0.0327831209,
-0.00551914,
0.0386626348,
0.0136851734,
0.0076479758,
-0.0986634344,
-0.0402216911,
-0.0333405882,
0.0136087863,
0.003614564,
-5.763164112e-33,
-0.0035594392,
-0.0577747934,
-0.0322898328,
-0.0461471565,
0.017872652,
0.0107390089,
-0.0112161506,
-0.0024608618,
-0.0334228612,
0.0252655093,
0.0393489972,
-0.0056152795,
0.0091574406,
-0.0007632066,
-0.0098048458,
-0.013874949,
-0.0071349205,
0.0438831933,
0.0056451377,
0.0121235754,
0.0587879047,
0.0132928658,
0.0405187383,
-0.1366864294,
0.0918906182,
0.0468054228,
-0.0461343415,
-0.0067107659,
0.0228655953,
0.070034571,
-0.0322217681,
0.088535957,
0.0258306582,
-0.0721302927,
0.0505141057,
0.0237564035,
-0.0803550482,
0.0186427701,
-0.0238594431,
-0.0241999812,
0.0324716195,
-0.0340861753,
-0.0371401571,
0.0169432219,
0.0112331733,
-0.0313128717,
0.0718564838,
-0.035499569,
-0.0209485795,
-0.0457402281,
-0.0401746929,
0.0430003628,
-0.0643704757,
0.0097034965,
-0.035966225,
0.0430131517,
-0.0136546027,
0.0298655964,
-0.0646199286,
0.0104208207,
-0.0045428053,
-0.0294403732,
0.0375180319,
-0.0385794006,
-0.0191091411,
0.0655323938,
-0.0539587587,
0.0120361038,
-0.0252237171,
-0.0064019375,
-0.0109219616,
0.0583337061,
0.0679992288,
0.0579482391,
0.0327174366,
-0.0031254245,
-0.0837185085,
0.0242878199,
-0.0089681409,
0.0223501977,
0.029648779,
-0.0064563574,
-0.0352475755,
-0.0139972353,
-0.0495115519,
-0.052193515,
-0.03095649,
0.0024488335,
0.0340512954,
-0.0118512865,
-0.0258437321,
0.0385988764,
-0.0056906319,
0.0123012289,
0.0312623307,
0.0188221131,
0.007685089,
0.0197656732,
-0.0070600659,
0.014065722,
-0.0428103991,
-0.0448224992,
0.0093782237,
-0.0113978889,
0.068031244,
-0.0336465985,
0.0676310509,
-0.0257892944,
-0.0468725711,
-0.0096311355,
-0.0362289101,
0.0331068859,
0.0001513412,
0.0760013834,
0.001130815,
-0.014203921,
-0.0111408718,
0.055573035,
0.0290171858,
0.0123615153,
0.001228875,
0.0413825586,
-0.0214683786,
0.0093150325,
0.0152041027,
-0.0335581973,
-0.0067570014,
0.0283520482,
0.0168961361,
-0.0119796786,
0.0116397878,
0.0368873402,
2.548e-7,
0.073669143,
0.0176737178,
-0.0050735325,
-0.03998404,
-0.0137281893,
0.0567182302,
0.0406946018,
0.0545294285,
-0.0165902115,
-0.0520639457,
0.0364719927,
0.0040006666,
0.0649815947,
0.0406877249,
-0.0143197523,
-0.0637281016,
-0.0014162854,
-0.0014206113,
-0.0709675327,
0.0572385974,
0.0760186762,
0.0823636129,
0.0429614894,
0.0112425145,
-0.0243749302,
-0.0048122923,
0.0301820859,
-0.0390763246,
-0.0163208731,
-0.0003254119,
0.0595309101,
0.0324412994,
-0.0261183288,
0.0397282057,
-0.0233298223,
0.0110746454,
-0.0078705745,
0.0316999294,
-0.0000918345,
-0.0141705787,
-0.0321485661,
-0.0209970847,
0.011634361,
-0.0334907956,
0.0436565541,
-0.0228524357,
-0.0218186378,
0.0315532871,
-0.0103315301,
-0.0006228496,
0.0274683461,
0.0021650651,
-0.0162626524,
0.0055634002,
-0.0028618316,
-0.0289824288,
0.0340782255,
-0.1138708144,
-0.0121865273,
0.0422370508,
-0.0230795667,
0.0157963634,
0.0442787707,
0.0232295766,
0.073513411,
-0.0503209345,
0.0236306638,
2.248597634e-34,
0.0021546248,
0.0157630686,
-0.0311545841,
-0.0075773825,
0.0566456094,
0.0305409189,
-0.0062686037,
-0.0381233506,
0.0071186279,
-0.0173382238,
0.0422017798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11363v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11363v1 | Disentangling the Linguistic Competence of Privacy-Preserving BERT | 2023-10-17T16:00:26 | 2023-10-17T16:00:26 | Stefan Arnold, Nils Kemmerzell, Annika Schreiner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Differential Privacy (DP) has been tailored to address the unique challenges
of text-to-text privatization. However, text-to-text privatization is known for
degrading the performance of language models when trained on perturbed text.
Employing a series of interpretation techniques on the internal representations
extracted from BERT trained on perturbed pre-text, we intend to disentangle at
the linguistic level the distortion induced by differential privacy.
Experimental results from a representational similarity analysis indicate that
the overall similarity of internal representations is substantially reduced.
Using probing tasks to unpack this dissimilarity, we find evidence that
text-to-text privatization affects the linguistic competence across several
formalisms, encoding localized properties of words while falling short at
encoding the contextual relationships between spans of words. | [
0.0119114947,
0.0913833901,
-0.0493635349,
0.0638958216,
-0.0348138213,
-0.0209502112,
0.0442922562,
0.0037039192,
-0.0141046541,
-0.0215556975,
-0.0666124225,
-0.043746382,
0.0292627532,
0.008124006,
0.0499954931,
-0.0310622025,
0.0451238491,
-0.0270399973,
-0.003190039,
-0.0304613374,
-0.0112188589,
-0.0053243828,
0.0193942841,
0.0239392444,
0.0216570739,
-0.0158948265,
-0.0152709233,
-0.0122278305,
0.013693138,
-0.0144186644,
0.0116649428,
0.0676175952,
0.0411939248,
0.0585095696,
0.0000016716,
-0.0559753999,
-0.0113422517,
0.0411177538,
-0.0034072567,
0.0342748389,
-0.0061558895,
-0.0343200229,
0.0386170857,
-0.0219041966,
-0.0220595635,
0.0325205959,
0.0328022204,
0.0427411087,
0.0252028387,
0.0589509457,
-0.0123406155,
-0.0243283659,
0.0245409515,
-0.045781929,
0.0066422713,
-0.0017070489,
0.0044049346,
-0.077263996,
-0.0358160958,
-0.0011627326,
-0.0099097071,
0.0124938842,
0.016771635,
0.0253550578,
0.0009033831,
0.0565565787,
-0.0153028192,
-0.0355012193,
-0.0033483102,
0.0450083166,
0.0397902541,
-0.0090847705,
0.0376485065,
0.0294375569,
0.0450896285,
0.0034786989,
0.0139288204,
0.0359742008,
0.00779182,
0.001021469,
0.0105733192,
0.0021985131,
0.0195932221,
-0.0247987751,
-0.024131475,
0.0280836653,
0.0344563499,
-0.0327503905,
-0.0335230045,
0.0087431716,
0.009144349,
-0.0308519248,
0.0873019621,
-0.0137048792,
0.0695282668,
0.0399524271,
-0.0644452944,
-0.0751263499,
0.0215636622,
-0.0461317897,
0.0060257642,
0.0296745263,
-0.022325471,
-0.0173630118,
-0.0587568469,
0.0521962121,
-0.0270814616,
0.0930633917,
-0.0053942767,
0.0458118543,
-0.0474779196,
-0.0245383941,
-0.0203447416,
0.0560244918,
-0.0651262701,
-0.0285525844,
0.0209231693,
0.0322577842,
-0.0174357593,
0.0141609432,
-0.0205442645,
-0.0041181832,
-0.0531760491,
0.0239704307,
-0.0287770256,
-0.0591306873,
-0.0272963699,
-0.014773123,
0.0092699882,
-0.0388874859,
-0.0367125422,
-0.0585928671,
0.004225784,
-0.0445278548,
-0.0419864468,
0.0451826639,
-0.0241377819,
-0.0211520903,
0.0185238328,
-0.0437448695,
-0.0311620943,
-0.0316661485,
0.0285441279,
-0.0204971451,
0.0313579552,
0.001971114,
-0.0137159619,
-0.0567263626,
0.0181259941,
0.0098702544,
-0.045582898,
0.0754413977,
-0.005122697,
-0.0110820085,
0.0092119835,
0.0384760797,
0.0199268796,
0.0202137232,
0.0191577766,
-0.0007729462,
0.0226118434,
-0.0012491879,
-0.0006680159,
0.0044587781,
0.0579543635,
0.0211568717,
-0.0720420331,
0.0214998163,
0.0093602156,
-0.0263999235,
0.0427092016,
0.0513138585,
-0.0228503961,
-0.0567342192,
0.0898849443,
0.0851822048,
0.0284861457,
0.0188834108,
-0.0529750772,
0.0496512912,
0.0065716323,
0.0290337484,
-0.0727855042,
-0.0124964677,
-0.0320527852,
-0.0234546959,
0.0027858696,
-0.0191556904,
0.0069347294,
0.0218779687,
-0.0016953201,
-0.0372465886,
0.0466990843,
-0.032384634,
-0.0239278674,
0.0272203702,
0.0078867758,
0.0811927766,
0.0108177587,
-0.0258718655,
0.0240508709,
-0.0324104242,
-0.0015977467,
0.0616409108,
0.0104328971,
-0.0001752289,
-0.0178535562,
-0.0455287248,
-0.0761806592,
0.0828767121,
-0.0093183098,
0.0218699165,
0.067835182,
-0.0122557348,
-0.045536384,
-0.0731139183,
0.0272775237,
0.025142638,
-0.0244382452,
-0.0250495858,
-0.0017865218,
-0.0825163722,
0.0329195373,
0.0670515075,
-0.0092424816,
-0.0288961735,
0.0037182057,
0.0196509566,
0.014403942,
0.0135645773,
-0.0144377621,
0.0148527175,
-0.000500787,
0.0017484442,
-0.0115924338,
0.009781017,
-0.0641170293,
-0.0664751604,
-0.018690981,
-0.0276979823,
0.0079623163,
0.0610027164,
0.0298642814,
-0.0401416682,
-0.007014655,
-0.0423377268,
0.073235184,
-0.0331059545,
0.0035987569,
-0.0267424546,
0.0463835113,
-0.0065928916,
0.0443487763,
-0.0534404665,
-0.0190988146,
-0.0535597764,
0.0147636933,
0.0364965647,
-0.0199659336,
0.0057520792,
0.0007974534,
-0.0017160623,
-0.0011969281,
0.025086252,
-0.0134418616,
-0.0160847623,
-0.0415660366,
-0.0207726974,
0.0015490942,
0.016049359,
0.0490694232,
0.0464669317,
-0.02420469,
0.0022391544,
-0.0058807191,
-0.0344949923,
-0.0661658719,
-0.0799489766,
0.0372385904,
0.0557159483,
0.0314013623,
-0.0347887278,
0.0041695572,
-0.0105454223,
-0.0358189382,
0.0524411872,
-0.0469054021,
-0.0132090366,
-0.0311174467,
-0.010504269,
-0.0269456655,
0.0275597759,
-0.0103865303,
-0.0409914777,
0.0064777858,
0.0222310033,
0.010715045,
0.0163964517,
0.0049868841,
0.0109288376,
0.0357598402,
-0.0005140637,
-0.0666672513,
-0.0003006519,
-0.0189287402,
0.0135419248,
-0.0307060182,
-0.0219351463,
0.0030520016,
0.0362641513,
0.019220449,
-0.0352800936,
-0.065319553,
0.0032017627,
-0.0267426223,
-0.0634798333,
-0.01178277,
-0.0551499166,
-0.0192127191,
0.0399699174,
-0.0388274007,
-0.0322632864,
0.0887157619,
-0.0321438648,
0.0016202139,
-0.0339682363,
0.0119850105,
-0.0111013632,
0.0514964163,
0.0060376772,
0.0375803486,
0.0266453512,
-0.1052430719,
-0.0278433673,
0.011411598,
0.0189022757,
-0.0095748818,
0.0470170416,
-0.0031821774,
-0.0233059414,
0.0252913795,
-0.0361026078,
-0.0248959251,
-0.0743910223,
0.0626383275,
0.0422886536,
0.0184005909,
-0.0470006876,
0.0145495329,
-0.0396200642,
0.0045489189,
0.0158618018,
-0.0019466198,
0.0081927385,
-0.0375458486,
0.0286226552,
-0.0206400286,
-0.0542804711,
0.0049727894,
-0.0718190372,
0.0051378761,
0.0054281335,
0.0546610281,
0.0201507546,
0.0141328434,
-0.017581569,
0.0079204785,
-0.0183993727,
-0.0753397495,
-0.0091304956,
0.060461767,
-0.0521117039,
-0.0328134298,
0.1004285216,
0.000120103,
-0.0318568572,
0.0141221872,
0.0063727698,
0.0280785151,
0.0005197444,
-0.0055880621,
-0.0629885271,
0.0238265991,
0.0316922069,
0.0356436893,
0.0016082685,
-0.040301647,
-0.0060652755,
-0.100059852,
-0.037622124,
-0.0262005702,
-0.021505082,
-0.0025668875,
-0.0267336275,
0.029325787,
0.045057673,
0.0607543886,
-0.0361182056,
0.0021035336,
-0.0193037447,
-0.0119267749,
-0.0075927805,
-0.006399862,
0.0075302129,
-0.0057424181,
0.0343682952,
0.0734808296,
0.0275859963,
-0.0346739665,
-0.0599951632,
0.0075432304,
-0.0019579933,
0.0011360184,
0.0259119589,
0.0675120428,
0.0122154616,
-0.0050473269,
-0.0122762145,
0.0438712537,
0.0146574238,
-0.0059035216,
-0.048332721,
0.0066333949,
-0.0003658963,
-0.0471192859,
0.0218189787,
-0.0179136358,
-0.0098174047,
0.0692225099,
0.0107807592,
-0.0479443409,
-0.015696859,
-0.0106773758,
0.0196090024,
-0.0197534449,
0.0464263521,
0.0279579293,
-0.007416626,
-0.0897271484,
-0.076223202,
-0.0009845917,
-0.0376462378,
0.003009188,
0.054670047,
0.0150107341,
0.0031570015,
-0.0350518003,
-0.0232769437,
0.0508141741,
-0.0243842881,
-0.0207504388,
-0.0204680283,
-0.0196535308,
-0.0066773426,
0.0078791408,
-0.0207901988,
-0.0162833054,
-0.0144281536,
-0.054130394,
0.0504131913,
0.0096484916,
0.0095724799,
0.0491970181,
-0.0341107436,
-0.0603661053,
0.0953180343,
0.0645395443,
-0.0595426932,
0.0186757874,
0.0567682311,
-0.0010810683,
0.0155330114,
0.0338277221,
-0.0257844217,
-0.0199100338,
0.0536784157,
0.0059433156,
0.0143361865,
-0.0159158148,
-0.0017202306,
0.0311988052,
0.0526763871,
0.0220959783,
0.0508027859,
-0.0604192279,
0.0030004114,
-0.0421978198,
0.0173285864,
-0.0209896583,
-0.0348997712,
0.0778336823,
0.0173790492,
0.0233678669,
0.0342466384,
0.0234881267,
0.0269387402,
-0.0481724367,
-0.004999327,
0.0581626371,
0.051791504,
0.0089336801,
0.0261041094,
-0.0117885163,
0.0627953708,
-0.0063412189,
0.0267763119,
-0.0334119648,
0.0303527806,
0.0248710811,
-0.0040855026,
-0.0126155447,
0.0155803785,
-0.055326961,
-0.0167551003,
-0.0106579326,
0.0231297761,
-0.0509016812,
0.034432929,
0.027107073,
-0.0229710042,
0.0182985682,
0.0167326089,
-0.0282479227,
-0.0077576898,
-0.0283230674,
0.0239947457,
-0.0236142334,
-0.0066373823,
0.0200535767,
0.0536671653,
-0.0289805438,
0.0588805601,
-0.0258954149,
0.0154245375,
-0.0374088064,
-0.0115213059,
0.0644330606,
0.0557541549,
-0.0355702154,
0.0071627786,
-0.0129493736,
-0.0724015161,
0.0045506731,
-0.000191112,
0.0186098497,
-0.006934382,
0.0130587444,
0.0108353915,
0.0004317359,
-0.0758058727,
-0.0390355401,
0.0108119724,
0.0582887717,
-0.0008107515,
-0.0191820171,
-6.002983694e-33,
-0.0301700719,
-0.0020064393,
-0.059721075,
-0.0064098779,
-0.0008040626,
-0.0181033257,
-0.0432596207,
0.0197321363,
-0.0102886399,
0.020050453,
-0.0475069843,
0.0353407301,
0.0038694988,
0.0226563103,
-0.0128701944,
-0.0260561146,
0.0608802475,
-0.0161857512,
-0.0250935685,
0.0150737166,
0.0483302884,
0.0486250967,
0.0603618771,
-0.0439701453,
0.0917364508,
-0.0104664182,
-0.0354724936,
0.0221184008,
-0.0312587284,
0.0281248502,
-0.0408281572,
-0.0126357134,
0.0090780947,
0.0327271037,
-0.0412705988,
0.0588409081,
-0.0503976718,
-0.0311525147,
0.018191576,
-0.0266817044,
-0.013643831,
-0.0647040382,
0.0599455796,
-0.0492645651,
-0.0146164689,
0.0030722246,
0.0059289741,
0.0127586992,
-0.005085126,
-0.0260497704,
-0.0221269503,
-0.0191982798,
-0.0227483623,
-0.0260173585,
0.0591267906,
0.003548072,
-0.0190165881,
-0.0217896532,
-0.0341149867,
-0.019385932,
0.0254422966,
-0.0192017686,
0.0395348072,
-0.0008200923,
0.0376626961,
0.0441516154,
0.064268738,
0.0406051539,
0.0031259316,
-0.0582471751,
0.0732281432,
0.0349740274,
-0.0097384276,
-0.0007155535,
0.0067578047,
-0.002193951,
-0.0211707838,
-0.000040335,
-0.0271305051,
-0.0296732802,
0.0395910591,
0.0216653515,
-0.0452627949,
-0.0144406548,
-0.0663610995,
-0.020268606,
-0.0341216996,
0.0167725682,
0.014859545,
-0.0133664012,
-0.0195413902,
0.0084367925,
-0.0021270886,
-0.0498738028,
-0.0326966718,
0.0002970583,
0.0222351719,
-0.0107583869,
0.0191056039,
0.0271649323,
-0.051033929,
-0.0550222807,
0.0206356328,
0.0205539893,
0.021481365,
0.0231780373,
0.0622017495,
-0.0198106579,
-0.0757552534,
-0.0086007901,
-0.0425185561,
0.0291464645,
0.0013520193,
0.0187292993,
0.0591740385,
-0.0335576162,
-0.0139327515,
0.0133136939,
0.0495330915,
0.0565602966,
-0.033580564,
0.0747470781,
0.006080287,
-0.0027216028,
0.0230716895,
-0.0388841331,
0.0130938319,
0.0325899534,
0.1011618152,
0.006428455,
0.0034776165,
-0.0329508483,
2.486e-7,
0.0331361592,
0.026041925,
0.0347540453,
-0.0137431324,
0.0272339787,
0.0457125269,
-0.0226926804,
0.0732817277,
-0.0300689787,
0.0212605912,
-0.0293708388,
-0.0236308239,
0.0322733931,
0.0427625999,
-0.0207912605,
0.0158830807,
-0.014890803,
0.0378867388,
-0.0428288504,
0.0153979398,
0.013974756,
0.0334622376,
0.0260334723,
0.0094839511,
-0.0208875332,
-0.0581775121,
0.0789770782,
-0.0531939976,
-0.0132670617,
0.0132614011,
0.0103960671,
0.0568914004,
0.0286531989,
0.0170813277,
-0.0013452831,
0.0746591836,
-0.0474658459,
0.083547838,
-0.0129193813,
-0.0377736278,
0.0063878563,
-0.0482265987,
-0.012825585,
-0.058173351,
0.0134487823,
-0.0327769071,
-0.060848698,
0.0192541145,
0.0129232891,
-0.0325463116,
0.044909291,
-0.0018968785,
-0.0217558835,
-0.0013136516,
0.008952166,
0.0067286384,
0.0075349016,
-0.0840106159,
-0.0435550585,
-0.0187138282,
-0.0247430429,
-0.0105036153,
-0.0166009683,
0.0374569297,
0.019808447,
-0.0457203053,
0.0604591817,
2.214625388e-34,
-0.018142689,
-0.007803739,
-0.0053856596,
0.0305561926,
0.0312736966,
-0.0178797357,
0.0898630992,
0.0121389451,
0.0290791653,
-0.0622493103,
-0.0221192986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11360v1 | Enhancing Neural Machine Translation with Semantic Units | 2023-10-17T15:55:31 | 2023-10-17T15:55:31 | Langlin Huang, Shuhao Gu, Zhuocheng Zhang, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Conventional neural machine translation (NMT) models typically use subwords
and words as the basic units for model input and comprehension. However,
complete words and phrases composed of several tokens are often the fundamental
units for expressing semantics, referred to as semantic units. To address this
issue, we propose a method Semantic Units for Machine Translation (SU4MT) which
models the integral meanings of semantic units within a sentence, and then
leverages them to provide a new perspective for understanding the sentence.
Specifically, we first propose Word Pair Encoding (WPE), a phrase extraction
method to help identify the boundaries of semantic units. Next, we design an
Attentive Semantic Fusion (ASF) layer to integrate the semantics of multiple
subwords into a single vector: the semantic unit representation. Lastly, the
semantic-unit-level sentence representation is concatenated to the token-level
one, and they are combined as the input of encoder. Experimental results
demonstrate that our method effectively models and leverages
semantic-unit-level information and outperforms the strong baselines. The code
is available at https://github.com/ictnlp/SU4MT. | [
-0.0127550298,
0.0516995862,
0.0028617862,
0.0736139789,
-0.0167410895,
0.0148446774,
-0.0132623399,
-0.0097282222,
-0.0582047775,
-0.0356326886,
0.0051027657,
-0.0247891881,
0.0042473846,
0.0207092091,
0.03007989,
-0.0534279309,
0.0407247469,
0.0301650316,
-0.0529223382,
0.0217427071,
0.0099507226,
0.0206741206,
0.0391633138,
0.0372414365,
-0.0592279434,
-0.0144005856,
0.0248211473,
0.0540874302,
0.0420967676,
-0.0454105549,
0.0086936066,
-0.0133090829,
0.0502409935,
0.0570131913,
0.0000020341,
-0.0049519911,
-0.0491361581,
-0.0037253015,
-0.0071685589,
-0.0002587715,
0.0363011435,
-0.069639504,
0.0041219923,
0.0243498515,
-0.0286730174,
0.0168443099,
0.0291195624,
0.0228879414,
0.0676141456,
0.0715906098,
-0.0275501572,
-0.0414212942,
0.02338445,
-0.0636644736,
-0.0363202505,
-0.0432576835,
-0.0300100055,
-0.0199889559,
-0.0500750095,
0.0560331121,
-0.0082685035,
0.042394802,
0.0411434583,
0.0285928492,
0.022302065,
0.0348267742,
-0.0094791688,
-0.0396788791,
-0.0329814292,
0.080801554,
-0.0558435954,
0.028413957,
-0.0228957385,
-0.0007429532,
0.0106539046,
-0.0232387185,
-0.0335241184,
0.0000849479,
0.0172671545,
0.0425971225,
0.0003717288,
0.0603741296,
0.0500551164,
0.0043681641,
-0.051478222,
0.0243480112,
0.023504043,
-0.0232713167,
-0.0216300264,
-0.0203976668,
-0.0307042859,
0.0019938778,
0.0545093119,
0.0180136394,
0.0270857513,
0.0330099091,
-0.0380156562,
-0.027141571,
0.008209412,
-0.0751070827,
0.0100036068,
0.069652915,
-0.0044938452,
0.0775740594,
-0.0196093637,
0.0374880545,
-0.0211843289,
-0.0030080297,
-0.0746085495,
-0.018010648,
-0.0185463335,
-0.0019346823,
-0.0845794901,
0.0003825896,
-0.0689034611,
-0.0683334321,
0.0051487377,
0.0111704972,
0.0222154278,
-0.0147671895,
0.0094359908,
-0.0102119828,
-0.0445825532,
-0.0077533587,
0.0073263939,
0.0595741309,
-0.0557723604,
-0.0314955004,
0.0199184548,
-0.0470076576,
-0.0649560243,
0.02061335,
-0.0131365508,
-0.0497967042,
0.0097729657,
0.0787979066,
-0.0203755181,
-0.0449967533,
-0.0024654337,
-0.0391544625,
-0.0293489415,
-0.0045291558,
0.005149337,
-0.0479342192,
0.0862036943,
-0.0191523656,
0.0002718472,
-0.0537198447,
0.0153380688,
0.0154035864,
-0.0145977698,
0.0916717425,
-0.0388716571,
-0.0269648079,
0.0102355219,
0.0194385126,
0.0169237349,
0.0537027754,
0.072357662,
0.0568329804,
0.0201741476,
0.0198087581,
-0.0594412684,
0.0076777246,
0.015408271,
0.0076128128,
-0.0733106434,
-0.0149215637,
0.0338868201,
0.0356408134,
0.0139857782,
0.0544804297,
-0.040236026,
0.0052500698,
0.0328222141,
0.0208724365,
-0.0077157179,
0.0618684553,
0.0527448617,
-0.000503115,
-0.0367741026,
-0.0407103151,
-0.0198831931,
0.0464019962,
0.0383096822,
-0.0135021647,
0.0521305501,
0.0617088638,
-0.0164481215,
-0.0497801006,
-0.0181512963,
-0.0311475955,
0.0201776344,
-0.025832735,
0.0179829337,
0.0171715859,
-0.0634028465,
0.0719187856,
-0.0026763533,
-0.0437661819,
0.0409329981,
-0.0005575498,
-0.0327133164,
0.0644407794,
0.0455019586,
0.0037465524,
-0.0328191668,
-0.0085505061,
-0.0435504988,
0.045951169,
0.0272857603,
0.0289179347,
0.03561588,
-0.0605139956,
-0.0202540215,
-0.0538993813,
-0.0079024825,
0.0132479277,
-0.0191627834,
0.0239161756,
0.0541026592,
-0.0298190862,
-0.0241763704,
0.0378802158,
0.0418721177,
-0.0307416655,
0.0296473783,
0.0122349281,
0.0278353356,
0.0263355207,
0.0124216825,
0.0190766938,
0.0126931267,
-0.0673495382,
-0.0476557538,
0.0258256979,
-0.0675984547,
-0.0794823617,
0.0313262157,
-0.0183467064,
-0.0272282287,
0.022118846,
-0.0513594374,
-0.0275506359,
-0.0166294202,
-0.0461901054,
0.012111146,
-0.030845169,
0.0024394747,
0.0413016193,
0.0662761778,
-0.0205877125,
0.0496620722,
-0.0227555875,
-0.0537835658,
-0.0372965261,
0.0078460639,
0.0395093374,
0.0148272607,
-0.0091685895,
0.017071275,
-0.0084133791,
0.0279734042,
0.0089993645,
0.0200862996,
-0.0356246829,
-0.051486019,
-0.0702935234,
0.0264000483,
-0.0162033997,
0.0294470023,
0.0147533109,
0.0505109429,
0.0136796348,
-0.0270940363,
-0.0336850695,
0.0024774913,
-0.0462056138,
0.0031043987,
0.0309360754,
0.0006386933,
0.006872274,
-0.0322590806,
-0.0275728554,
-0.0347863697,
0.0363638885,
-0.0001163555,
-0.020020375,
-0.0339556187,
0.0197785087,
-0.0278219096,
-0.0150461104,
-0.0023733091,
-0.063161388,
0.0061514913,
-0.0282037426,
0.038704589,
0.0874768123,
0.0151867876,
0.0768910646,
0.0405663922,
-0.0007646428,
-0.0341999456,
0.0732364506,
-0.0253367107,
0.0378587395,
0.0039120009,
0.0346732214,
0.0184265636,
0.0683894455,
0.0010264268,
0.0169822071,
-0.0469647646,
0.0192298107,
0.0067025307,
-0.0412121229,
-0.0276474357,
0.0471664071,
-0.0083760312,
-0.0096441507,
-0.0463397503,
-0.0166995972,
0.0614924096,
-0.0301263072,
-0.0103469584,
-0.0536887236,
-0.0082378248,
-0.0531238504,
0.052813597,
-0.0184176471,
0.0229340214,
-0.0900550187,
-0.003237461,
0.0114152767,
0.01576766,
-0.0494499505,
-0.01348921,
0.0314190425,
-0.0211149808,
-0.0318830088,
-0.0285312273,
-0.0155497817,
-0.0140359178,
-0.0024231335,
-0.0382201634,
0.0352478512,
-0.029930925,
-0.0202885848,
-0.0181411933,
-0.018535709,
0.0090612518,
0.0463827327,
-0.0114710936,
0.0069519291,
-0.0451837182,
0.0370389931,
0.022434948,
0.0168860648,
0.0082725165,
-0.0313930921,
0.028786812,
0.041563943,
-0.0066440967,
0.0314879939,
-0.0609811172,
-0.0003732604,
0.0194245744,
0.0061950409,
-0.0016039624,
-0.0023736258,
0.0304096509,
-0.0779871196,
-0.015167119,
0.1190523058,
0.0327853337,
-0.0186744723,
0.008778736,
-0.0005015038,
0.0264471881,
0.0297840368,
0.0207414255,
-0.0387069695,
-0.0713338852,
-0.0189137664,
-0.0070714401,
0.0688004121,
0.0274487175,
-0.0309810974,
-0.0457931086,
0.003524713,
0.0421027131,
-0.0671225712,
-0.0227144975,
-0.0234593209,
-0.0105819423,
-0.015932994,
0.0534261167,
-0.015634777,
0.0298633743,
-0.0105999261,
-0.0110284677,
0.0239974186,
0.0026217459,
0.0218187459,
-0.0413747132,
-0.000668765,
0.0882405043,
0.0785538033,
-0.0172725804,
-0.0450487323,
0.0479760543,
-0.0396766737,
-0.0034071598,
0.0096735964,
0.0257210918,
-0.0661663264,
-0.0175634045,
0.036074128,
0.0179096181,
-0.0593432263,
-0.0026194628,
0.0022663495,
0.0653772652,
0.0064254575,
0.0010618143,
-0.0569151007,
-0.0279968232,
-0.0202881377,
0.0684197545,
0.0360617861,
-0.0418583266,
-0.0054482431,
-0.0086540813,
-0.0123470863,
-0.0454109795,
0.0047188574,
0.0177286994,
0.0131660858,
-0.009180598,
-0.0651720613,
-0.0730443299,
0.0240945071,
0.029030839,
-0.0220945589,
-0.0059848903,
0.0030420071,
0.0070104431,
-0.0445005931,
0.0339926817,
-0.0058956696,
0.0176422819,
-0.0259257499,
0.0377864093,
0.0229470264,
-0.0076250578,
-0.0121539943,
0.0416302793,
-0.0539773479,
-0.0460766479,
-0.0048499741,
0.0492135882,
0.0067881118,
0.0217456482,
-0.0385614596,
-0.0034827797,
0.0210303292,
0.0290525705,
-0.0460510403,
-0.0147054382,
0.0186652374,
0.0477078855,
-0.0206766166,
0.0352222435,
-0.0196606554,
0.0084920116,
-0.0248329677,
0.0648044273,
-0.0221774913,
-0.0231074654,
0.0407129079,
-0.0253347866,
0.0634034127,
0.0011970802,
0.0257491786,
-0.0079383701,
0.010160096,
-0.0293327179,
0.0050734007,
-0.0755066127,
-0.0087844394,
0.0186912809,
-0.0093459478,
0.0006841196,
-0.0104052043,
0.0444915928,
-0.0134101519,
0.0437097624,
-0.0193598103,
-0.0289296489,
0.0232038852,
-0.0301337857,
0.0067021083,
-0.0073997639,
0.0054218653,
-0.0376466364,
-0.0317926817,
-0.0309276953,
0.036989551,
0.0251521878,
-0.0131024551,
-0.0438192263,
0.0614160523,
-0.0293309409,
-0.0122002903,
-0.0077403304,
-0.0244403966,
0.0082172751,
0.0049650101,
0.0590634346,
0.0054173805,
-0.0157097094,
0.0008085227,
0.0578570925,
-0.012380763,
-0.0343267396,
0.0386730246,
0.0178333484,
-0.0049441825,
-0.0325570181,
0.0196420476,
-0.0565242581,
0.0141630964,
0.0057996707,
0.014957821,
-0.0225988887,
0.013038801,
0.0210755114,
-0.0034452842,
-0.0194652881,
0.0382658131,
-0.0483376682,
-0.0496563315,
0.0049901381,
0.0265357438,
0.0076087201,
0.0151299015,
0.0563285388,
0.070109196,
-0.0430481844,
-0.0181586146,
-0.0039326567,
-0.005768606,
-0.0079418505,
-0.0319251232,
0.0012784713,
-6.706952731e-33,
-0.0397667922,
-0.0075695077,
-0.0052774898,
-0.002084892,
-0.0558116995,
0.0048267948,
-0.0332113542,
-0.0353953317,
-0.0029949846,
0.0030547588,
0.0077373357,
0.0297839232,
0.0036361129,
0.021401193,
-0.0010148789,
0.0052084257,
0.0734600946,
0.0087833665,
-0.0024707746,
0.0064876624,
0.0566450767,
0.0257670227,
0.0724477619,
-0.0522766747,
-0.003507762,
0.0277501699,
-0.0108907195,
0.0380638465,
-0.01003436,
0.0402391031,
-0.0084252963,
0.0180712342,
0.0291427989,
-0.0355823711,
-0.0198380798,
0.0278085228,
-0.0874851272,
-0.0429339819,
-0.0220675152,
-0.0105228946,
-0.0900365189,
-0.0734747201,
0.0841531977,
-0.0245906357,
0.0243580416,
-0.0591463707,
0.0053274147,
-0.0102895591,
-0.02858047,
-0.0216936581,
-0.0471698008,
0.0188991204,
0.000123287,
0.0053105154,
0.0278677754,
0.0043763299,
0.0051368829,
-0.0094655976,
-0.0478773527,
-0.0168986693,
-0.0160755049,
0.0693659559,
0.027533656,
0.0074437228,
-0.0197021347,
0.0302977059,
0.0177533533,
-0.0303764101,
0.0112318164,
0.004949329,
0.0433643498,
0.0223230608,
0.0877615139,
0.0326518938,
0.0532702506,
0.0031793746,
-0.0483158827,
0.0221709516,
0.0301925223,
0.0460549854,
-0.0284617003,
0.0357009545,
-0.0102962907,
0.0193852447,
-0.0208329912,
-0.0356338173,
-0.0454450473,
-0.0505862981,
0.028245002,
0.0287515037,
-0.007712896,
-0.0018211276,
0.0413739569,
-0.0209050011,
0.0598123893,
0.0093644187,
-0.0202648826,
0.002367038,
0.009121662,
0.0473547652,
0.0227309763,
-0.0488619953,
0.0225841124,
-0.0002118273,
0.0189285353,
-0.0140133398,
0.0373421833,
0.0376467183,
-0.0210175756,
-0.0079317149,
-0.0407722034,
-0.0362864211,
-0.030694738,
-0.0238234475,
0.0100870319,
0.0104266629,
-0.0290700831,
0.0261995383,
0.0160278287,
-0.0198708419,
-0.0636267811,
-0.0034222153,
0.0326722153,
0.0341326818,
-0.0603723675,
-0.0062298742,
-0.0281889569,
-0.0219920222,
0.0459237248,
-0.0519266129,
-0.0433984734,
0.0133664636,
2.763e-7,
0.0517658293,
0.0473566055,
0.0350584127,
0.0097766444,
0.0030595593,
0.0283160917,
-0.0140450392,
0.0837390497,
-0.0269126017,
0.0109891165,
0.0320526026,
0.0383363031,
0.0331807658,
-0.0021232408,
-0.0885383785,
0.0103763603,
-0.0485746078,
0.008995072,
-0.0645059869,
0.0036521552,
0.0926338434,
0.1116013974,
0.022608202,
0.0090673948,
-0.0278598182,
-0.0059547788,
0.067446731,
-0.011100512,
-0.0075404807,
0.0032397942,
-0.016103005,
0.0303888712,
-0.0240366105,
-0.0307011642,
-0.0227559581,
0.0542992428,
0.0697446093,
0.0899436623,
-0.0374721587,
-0.016710395,
0.0093208933,
-0.0004327841,
-0.0066881115,
-0.0631962642,
0.0349069647,
-0.0577427745,
-0.0192667767,
-0.0040491773,
-0.0066907587,
0.0285210386,
0.0331930779,
0.0002878509,
-0.0531828329,
-0.0048257825,
0.0415100306,
-0.0048401933,
-0.0103448937,
-0.0904501602,
-0.0364553779,
-0.035671331,
-0.0319335833,
0.0109043438,
-0.045124311,
0.0216064397,
0.0363679044,
-0.0252150819,
-0.0439436473,
2.362837088e-34,
0.0363900587,
-0.0224572178,
0.0142786186,
0.0156481639,
0.040415071,
-0.0315071307,
-0.0581804439,
-0.0060235243,
0.0192142706,
-0.0470551439,
-0.038899336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11344v1 | The effect of stemming and lemmatization on Portuguese fake news text classification | 2023-10-17T15:26:40 | 2023-10-17T15:26:40 | Lucca de Freitas Santos, Murilo Varges da Silva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the popularization of the internet, smartphones and social media,
information is being spread quickly and easily way, which implies bigger
traffic of information in the world, but there is a problem that is harming
society with the dissemination of fake news. With a bigger flow of information,
some people are trying to disseminate deceptive information and fake news. The
automatic detection of fake news is a challenging task because to obtain a good
result is necessary to deal with linguistics problems, especially when we are
dealing with languages that not have been comprehensively studied yet, besides
that, some techniques can help to reach a good result when we are dealing with
text data, although, the motivation of detecting this deceptive information it
is in the fact that the people need to know which information is true and
trustful and which one is not. In this work, we present the effect the
pre-processing methods such as lemmatization and stemming have on fake news
classification, for that we designed some classifier models applying different
pre-processing techniques. The results show that the pre-processing step is
important to obtain betters results, the stemming and lemmatization techniques
are interesting methods and need to be more studied to develop techniques
focused on the Portuguese language so we can reach better results. | [
0.0637079105,
0.0034130095,
-0.0278367233,
0.0749356896,
-0.0573261641,
0.018642446,
-0.0194199272,
0.0402204692,
0.0054852618,
-0.0595451668,
0.015274113,
-0.0063610957,
0.0123249125,
0.0065608118,
-0.003827349,
-0.0053046104,
0.0682033747,
0.0244692117,
-0.0008589617,
-0.0328614786,
0.0377749279,
0.0185474753,
0.0114711849,
0.0135127604,
-0.0160601251,
0.0330262519,
0.0391588174,
-0.0353575945,
0.0107209878,
-0.0158202965,
-0.0226406902,
0.0548289344,
-0.0448402353,
0.0661217421,
0.0000019741,
-0.03588726,
-0.0340603217,
-0.0119944075,
-0.0062927715,
-0.039765887,
0.0723608509,
-0.0356377475,
-0.0348266736,
0.0528525673,
-0.0639147162,
-0.01782858,
-0.0078391619,
0.0238342509,
0.084504433,
0.1207499355,
-0.017004054,
-0.0705707967,
0.0156187173,
0.019684121,
0.0172052644,
0.0201388411,
0.0739436969,
-0.066789493,
-0.0202453844,
0.0115008252,
0.0278322045,
0.0130168777,
-0.0115545336,
-0.0083969897,
-0.056110803,
-0.0160922762,
-0.0173622761,
-0.0586576574,
0.0012803047,
-0.0256215353,
-0.0623069331,
-0.0668005198,
0.0337196775,
0.00647204,
0.0181896742,
0.0631017908,
0.0130177708,
0.0267544091,
-0.0334120616,
0.0323650092,
0.0987611189,
0.0209852308,
0.0258923601,
0.0515251942,
-0.0006777812,
0.0400421545,
0.0029047607,
-0.0385266133,
0.0333793797,
0.0032326144,
0.025826484,
-0.0482029207,
0.0394018702,
0.0329271182,
0.0085597811,
0.0153202377,
-0.0511684008,
-0.0370264687,
0.042578198,
-0.1463591754,
-0.0940612927,
-0.012542109,
0.0262190998,
0.0017010053,
-0.0348203182,
-0.030990025,
-0.0032520008,
0.0007539255,
-0.0309154615,
-0.0042454717,
-0.0151849119,
-0.0009574055,
-0.0155047094,
0.0455279686,
-0.0223442446,
0.0423868559,
-0.0674999133,
0.0045143273,
0.0013910553,
-0.0168237109,
-0.0297266636,
-0.0124830147,
0.0280427933,
0.0184142832,
-0.0112413997,
-0.0246955957,
-0.0073632426,
0.0305386633,
-0.0617454872,
-0.0363030471,
0.0446371362,
0.0204559732,
-0.0051223477,
0.0105922297,
0.0334804095,
-0.0260930862,
-0.0088917101,
-0.0193132404,
-0.0801111087,
-0.0514139719,
-0.0085160555,
-0.0435930304,
-0.0025877338,
-0.0584312007,
-0.0696025267,
-0.0383309461,
0.0161916856,
0.0116262287,
-0.0087290406,
0.0479788929,
-0.0442264117,
0.0386847891,
-0.0202357732,
-0.0081227133,
0.0777569711,
0.0240263641,
0.0391584858,
0.0425638482,
0.0014956862,
0.076748386,
0.0479527749,
0.0134059014,
0.0415795632,
0.0517431311,
0.0086670257,
-0.0244540945,
0.0135061052,
-0.0119352983,
-0.0405394137,
-0.0420052782,
0.0088685183,
0.0249785874,
0.0143989343,
-0.0076447339,
0.0150547847,
-0.013555984,
0.0340105109,
-0.007667819,
0.0372580662,
-0.0082835015,
0.028265845,
0.0288682804,
0.0135484766,
-0.0782586783,
-0.0796060339,
-0.0132097434,
0.0072597587,
0.0484044887,
0.01047487,
-0.0355881751,
0.0186082888,
0.0045528254,
0.0021628165,
-0.0233874004,
0.0103410035,
0.0058158925,
-0.0307171866,
-0.0428268537,
0.0255514719,
-0.0107740797,
0.0022276132,
-0.0708365589,
0.0704588294,
0.0239667334,
0.0212727934,
0.0125133675,
0.022074692,
-0.0156702623,
-0.0326053873,
0.0127355102,
-0.0419097394,
-0.0157388188,
-0.0650843158,
0.0064126984,
0.0094649522,
0.0446065217,
0.0146717662,
-0.0171135925,
-0.004985339,
0.0932516232,
0.0202155598,
0.0062562563,
-0.0373922847,
0.0562714003,
0.0309496615,
-0.0133174621,
-0.0120416945,
0.0253857505,
0.0391336195,
0.0400197357,
0.0178633425,
-0.0449279957,
0.0482892059,
-0.0171265397,
0.0076391422,
-0.0416484736,
0.0152081493,
-0.0300526973,
0.0315142386,
-0.0477728955,
-0.0035585139,
0.0556773543,
0.0173255708,
-0.0017385969,
0.0051022554,
-0.0181886796,
0.0033347527,
-0.0583833978,
0.0367863439,
-0.0374192595,
0.0490445904,
-0.0077505568,
0.0746976286,
-0.0277905595,
0.0517295338,
-0.0188274644,
-0.021365976,
0.0140850442,
0.01090087,
0.0143631203,
0.0289534982,
-0.0059951325,
-0.0086418055,
0.0083928192,
-0.012437759,
0.0216470957,
-0.0190582983,
-0.0436092578,
-0.0196313299,
-0.0284528695,
0.0245743543,
0.0224910285,
0.0020437511,
-0.0291453879,
0.0211970974,
-0.0320710205,
-0.0302700065,
0.0175466351,
-0.0074915872,
-0.0014007386,
-0.02291115,
-0.0073918565,
0.0062456732,
0.0567506067,
-0.0003217772,
0.0445649847,
0.0297368374,
-0.1143465042,
-0.0382987522,
0.0238349028,
-0.0328309909,
0.0168589652,
-0.0114838555,
-0.0364556573,
-0.0070523419,
0.0175584685,
0.0125838798,
0.0239183083,
0.0743692815,
0.0513124876,
0.0385740511,
0.0382313021,
0.0187820252,
-0.059420377,
-0.0251603331,
0.056835521,
-0.0453857407,
-0.0628119484,
0.0691605806,
0.0298388805,
0.0020214431,
0.0166274123,
0.0228456818,
0.0219202507,
-0.0270282682,
-0.0027139564,
0.0643487945,
-0.0407745205,
-0.0308083296,
-0.0087325713,
0.0243085418,
0.0014209741,
0.061392162,
-0.0405907147,
0.0611245744,
-0.0755325556,
-0.058288075,
0.0009209121,
-0.0113424882,
-0.0323130079,
0.0314390883,
0.0027887055,
-0.0272238106,
0.0335586183,
-0.0087449122,
0.0636341944,
-0.0377469696,
-0.0028783015,
-0.0245110188,
0.0157624744,
0.0115121109,
-0.0011425948,
-0.0496835597,
-0.1032300442,
-0.0211145449,
-0.0314018652,
0.0054887785,
0.0076403865,
-0.0467792191,
0.0150292097,
-0.0038302348,
0.0331045352,
-0.0230109971,
0.0156518351,
0.0166812632,
0.0424762517,
-0.023318477,
-0.0637236536,
-0.0015841053,
-0.000268588,
-0.0140704466,
0.0485129915,
-0.0488112681,
0.0015898709,
0.0117846131,
-0.0318945721,
0.0123524712,
-0.0520117804,
-0.0457914136,
-0.0456094705,
-0.0658227652,
-0.0181048829,
0.0186987538,
0.0834726468,
0.0412317365,
-0.0313760564,
0.0081019355,
0.0075160377,
-0.0442805216,
-0.0078980783,
0.0135924695,
-0.0531063043,
0.0121666314,
0.0169510096,
-0.0075242338,
-0.0457253754,
-0.0070498204,
-0.0002387655,
-0.0745083392,
0.034568239,
0.0075359046,
-0.0369351059,
-0.0664170906,
-0.0561649427,
-0.016463792,
0.0125085087,
-0.0205372889,
-0.0083716083,
0.0224460922,
0.0097530056,
0.0406507365,
-0.0333059356,
-0.0799671039,
-0.0786664039,
-0.0056260908,
0.0073904591,
0.007522448,
0.0338644646,
-0.0287257861,
-0.0279151928,
0.0236422867,
-0.007068852,
-0.0293496754,
-0.0641210675,
0.0250579566,
-0.0237727072,
-0.0064066141,
-0.0368754044,
0.0253000725,
0.0664081722,
0.0031056127,
0.0529713854,
0.0549037382,
-0.0066539072,
-0.0523860492,
-0.0275817867,
-0.0130592529,
0.0191838965,
0.0103451563,
-0.0016592449,
-0.0058282111,
0.0076080887,
-0.0135209858,
-0.018843865,
0.0616621375,
-0.0589246228,
0.0311024971,
-0.0434464216,
-0.0930955857,
-0.0884301662,
-0.0252500828,
-0.0112749059,
0.0488177389,
0.0085309958,
0.0062840232,
0.0127125224,
-0.0078011532,
-0.0364597477,
-0.0358425751,
0.001275312,
0.0303025283,
-0.031224519,
0.0321454816,
-0.0017552932,
-0.0027094407,
-0.0101580704,
-0.0063114883,
-0.0309040844,
-0.0355422795,
0.0364827998,
-0.0238250103,
0.0167976338,
0.0111877089,
-0.0291832313,
-0.0741149038,
0.0766169056,
0.0593494996,
-0.0414105728,
0.0200427528,
-0.0104552945,
-0.0286289342,
0.0217756853,
0.0019670418,
0.0242934022,
0.0431646854,
0.0186743569,
-0.0359090902,
-0.0904315859,
0.0028161008,
0.0104273036,
0.0305067599,
0.044047568,
-0.0381695107,
0.0006300993,
-0.0244619548,
-0.0078836689,
0.0016107702,
-0.008439118,
0.0242069438,
0.0213603172,
0.0271677561,
0.0148586789,
-0.0069915033,
-0.0335903428,
-0.0732434392,
-0.0529633947,
0.0036710235,
-0.0012819533,
0.016850777,
0.0949209556,
-0.0004929582,
0.0118461903,
-0.0090859896,
0.0042526005,
0.0218387786,
0.0270986408,
-0.0206714142,
-0.0571311787,
0.0080738571,
-0.021665629,
-0.002850373,
0.0069387825,
-0.0024348542,
0.0610968508,
-0.0782031193,
0.0270675253,
0.0445555262,
-0.0092808353,
0.0191332437,
0.018435169,
0.0082212873,
0.0253195725,
-0.0341985486,
-0.0166920703,
-0.0228698384,
-0.0074553397,
-0.0140749607,
-0.044890251,
0.0351063982,
0.0502074473,
0.0054926951,
-0.0047965916,
0.0274740253,
-0.08267048,
-0.0363326669,
0.028523406,
0.0424209125,
0.0078389477,
-0.0260510109,
-0.0317896679,
-0.0625576526,
-0.0125304749,
0.0394606926,
-0.0085393945,
0.0552075952,
0.0402292609,
-0.0193889737,
0.0838048756,
0.0304822866,
0.0451845191,
-0.0506830662,
0.0138403606,
-0.0070112674,
-0.022659909,
-0.0006198833,
-5.705399218e-33,
0.0268830676,
-0.052843634,
-0.0324334502,
0.0050933603,
0.0070590475,
0.0135842441,
0.0248156283,
-0.0026434581,
-0.0223033652,
0.0202380158,
0.0168276858,
0.0063936184,
0.0199961904,
-0.0209545102,
-0.075720571,
0.0034383531,
0.0321300291,
0.0027579761,
-0.0314836092,
-0.0348595828,
0.0274675041,
0.0242662877,
0.0633812323,
-0.0727263689,
0.0551788695,
-0.0353722684,
-0.059360221,
0.0303182155,
-0.007160143,
0.0343668237,
0.0131625012,
0.0123496475,
0.027797401,
-0.0263417307,
0.0292131193,
0.0264794435,
-0.0023688041,
-0.0535966903,
0.0879853815,
0.0452158749,
0.0127874156,
-0.0091165081,
0.0629820377,
0.0068528526,
-0.0217165146,
0.0633439049,
0.0344447158,
-0.0412359312,
-0.0285256412,
-0.0033090683,
-0.0308779106,
0.0302763283,
0.0405188762,
0.0331986956,
0.062336985,
0.0397651084,
-0.0179390367,
-0.0065911198,
-0.0639488846,
0.0285432301,
0.0033408995,
0.0277661644,
0.0047141132,
-0.0154286567,
-0.0174812041,
0.0294784401,
0.0166218951,
-0.0181217901,
-0.019305801,
0.0294922739,
0.0238405056,
0.0009432547,
0.0476588048,
0.0977334976,
0.0557081066,
-0.0634763092,
-0.0911264494,
0.03239296,
0.0330067948,
-0.0505804308,
-0.0230353028,
-0.0438980758,
-0.0411714092,
-0.0112223495,
0.007583112,
-0.004723914,
0.0012482718,
0.0061604138,
-0.0332747996,
0.0046010381,
-0.0595711358,
0.0436892845,
-0.0147309359,
-0.0291908626,
-0.0088336775,
-0.0185073391,
-0.0371233709,
0.028882945,
-0.0008272085,
0.034778785,
-0.0274479538,
-0.0088525331,
0.0261622518,
-0.0005009135,
-0.0150435297,
-0.0311311372,
0.0251874458,
-0.0268595573,
-0.0535052642,
0.0041574202,
0.0215848014,
0.0288608037,
0.0069489186,
0.0198120661,
0.0170243289,
-0.0032579156,
0.0135842767,
-0.0096869515,
0.011201459,
-0.008979734,
-0.0144136911,
0.0008272648,
-0.0036665967,
0.0326587185,
-0.0345396847,
-0.0123914983,
-0.0110667646,
0.0618915409,
0.0226246379,
-0.0578204915,
0.0097012818,
-0.0229330566,
2.661e-7,
0.0117186373,
0.0257064942,
-0.0446540676,
0.0239479933,
0.0024883829,
0.0190183185,
0.0660130084,
-0.0027657729,
-0.0003565329,
-0.0012281194,
0.0125956116,
-0.0303367395,
-0.0010802292,
0.0399297439,
-0.0833974928,
-0.0206979737,
-0.0521010645,
-0.0227699205,
-0.0285621043,
-0.015221417,
-0.0109833311,
0.0806832388,
0.057997752,
-0.0395578779,
-0.0338999517,
-0.0086391028,
-0.0252337791,
0.0498534925,
-0.0419595428,
-0.0085367383,
0.0529658459,
-0.0193377193,
0.0401460901,
0.026098216,
0.0003812901,
0.0211281162,
-0.0047862064,
0.0063318457,
-0.0096202902,
0.0681608021,
0.0163875818,
-0.0656107068,
0.0082413144,
-0.0451558121,
0.0553961992,
0.0538333431,
-0.0100675318,
-0.0564359426,
-0.0383892916,
-0.0157144181,
0.0350480564,
0.0010457583,
-0.0284097064,
0.055649031,
0.0161918867,
-0.0039267675,
-0.0136017865,
-0.0396272987,
-0.0036487514,
-0.0255085807,
-0.0141160814,
0.0078638121,
0.0197298471,
0.0269373041,
0.0456777401,
-0.006195745,
0.0673930645,
2.123306237e-34,
0.0041346499,
-0.0246303231,
-0.023112135,
0.0071323211,
-0.0005370255,
0.0259887613,
-0.0109353438,
0.0168404989,
0.0044806642,
0.0156529993,
0.0181670785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11324v2 | Quantifying Language Models' Sensitivity to Spurious Features in Prompt Design or: How I learned to start worrying about prompt formatting | 2023-10-17T15:03:30 | 2024-07-01T22:28:01 | Melanie Sclar, Yejin Choi, Yulia Tsvetkov, Alane Suhr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As large language models (LLMs) are adopted as a fundamental component of
language technologies, it is crucial to accurately characterize their
performance. Because choices in prompt design can strongly influence model
behavior, this design process is critical in effectively using any modern
pre-trained generative language model. In this work, we focus on LLM
sensitivity to a quintessential class of meaning-preserving design choices:
prompt formatting. We find that several widely used open-source LLMs are
extremely sensitive to subtle changes in prompt formatting in few-shot
settings, with performance differences of up to 76 accuracy points when
evaluated using LLaMA-2-13B. Sensitivity remains even when increasing model
size, the number of few-shot examples, or performing instruction tuning. Our
analysis suggests that work evaluating LLMs with prompting-based methods would
benefit from reporting a range of performance across plausible prompt formats,
instead of the currently-standard practice of reporting performance on a single
format. We also show that format performance only weakly correlates between
models, which puts into question the methodological validity of comparing
models with an arbitrarily chosen, fixed prompt format. To facilitate
systematic analysis we propose FormatSpread, an algorithm that rapidly
evaluates a sampled set of plausible prompt formats for a given task, and
reports the interval of expected performance without accessing model weights.
Furthermore, we present a suite of analyses that characterize the nature of
this sensitivity, including exploring the influence of particular atomic
perturbations and the internal representation of particular formats. | [
0.0061298022,
0.0440189876,
-0.0261542052,
0.0135523789,
-0.029357357,
0.0007415486,
0.0695652813,
0.0156642627,
-0.0288625173,
-0.0231918991,
-0.0444556996,
-0.0653445199,
0.0112970956,
0.0568088405,
0.0394097753,
-0.0352012515,
0.0792591572,
-0.0561744273,
-0.0047945189,
0.005658302,
-0.0317503624,
-0.0137911346,
-0.0142402016,
0.0493925214,
0.0064335666,
-0.0465389378,
-0.0295568872,
0.0231668949,
-0.0149458963,
-0.0230596531,
-0.0063121784,
0.0833661035,
-0.0244148616,
0.0522073172,
0.0000021654,
-0.0682260916,
0.0032907061,
-0.0163246989,
-0.0407720879,
0.0782214031,
0.0500703417,
-0.008865308,
-0.0472532734,
0.0324260145,
-0.0039827162,
-0.0294841472,
0.054566931,
-0.0112169357,
-0.0019944937,
0.0517470501,
-0.0007384274,
0.0179485213,
0.012014729,
-0.0450591855,
0.014243314,
0.0174961369,
-0.0040085735,
-0.0398293585,
0.0187108964,
0.0250843596,
-0.0227037705,
0.0153296748,
0.0213497654,
-0.0189119652,
-0.0235421192,
0.0292978399,
-0.0169842895,
-0.0181825049,
-0.0374241322,
0.0661855042,
-0.0000237802,
-0.0053766905,
-0.0263471194,
-0.0432295389,
0.0098302271,
-0.0190031789,
-0.031088924,
0.0394968837,
0.0186137799,
-0.0012149648,
-0.0008013438,
-0.0020065987,
0.0218657944,
-0.0221329797,
-0.0031128353,
0.0619087256,
0.0465051606,
-0.0134359766,
-0.0176767912,
0.0102226725,
-0.0244808123,
-0.0652664602,
-0.0085079735,
0.0035271051,
-0.0383197255,
0.0172126945,
-0.0452916734,
-0.0092172483,
0.0551016182,
0.0115789603,
0.0768123344,
0.0639984831,
-0.0671604425,
-0.007910952,
-0.0363216698,
0.0751476586,
0.0015434549,
0.0238615293,
-0.0442471541,
0.0572347827,
0.0123888161,
-0.0027303873,
-0.0190196633,
-0.012119296,
-0.0361125618,
-0.007541399,
-0.033830002,
0.0550381206,
0.0349601023,
0.0037889197,
0.0036234639,
-0.0150992554,
-0.0378742144,
0.0069089248,
-0.0084636724,
0.0290659089,
-0.0522703379,
0.0156197399,
0.0562904216,
-0.0990158692,
-0.0281171165,
0.0033899669,
-0.0207445677,
-0.037306238,
-0.0191946495,
0.0647221208,
0.0021391455,
-0.0298867952,
-0.0327639692,
-0.017656317,
-0.0318199471,
-0.0157539919,
0.0072689299,
-0.0554807447,
0.02156597,
0.0156783722,
0.0091773458,
-0.0364832841,
-0.0141558712,
0.0064045349,
0.0125239054,
0.0531496853,
-0.0280489717,
0.0097480714,
0.000179411,
-0.0050376118,
0.0074830777,
0.063023515,
0.0106867785,
0.0388663299,
0.0466594063,
-0.0260874406,
0.0028010879,
0.0650423542,
-0.0022334955,
0.0029894104,
-0.0177540462,
-0.0211758222,
0.0751600042,
0.0189350117,
0.067600973,
0.0416760556,
-0.0036014607,
-0.0149166919,
0.0777609646,
0.0252708029,
-0.0030914042,
-0.0165040065,
0.0500284471,
-0.0162203312,
0.011387703,
0.0202338193,
-0.0549188592,
-0.0122794872,
-0.0523688123,
0.0361181013,
0.0184255559,
0.0496399105,
-0.0368961021,
-0.0505739897,
-0.0186867006,
0.0010351659,
-0.0339665003,
0.0035704197,
0.0261499975,
0.0123067517,
-0.0555016845,
0.0242215395,
0.0358959436,
-0.0640334114,
-0.018982606,
-0.0810873657,
0.0454233363,
0.0692794397,
0.0405187123,
-0.010583682,
-0.0153720789,
0.0060455571,
0.0250770003,
0.0425520502,
0.0736265928,
-0.0060342019,
0.0218628328,
-0.0320662223,
-0.0246304609,
-0.0446448959,
0.0306491293,
0.0495311655,
-0.0166996177,
-0.0118508833,
0.0076613324,
-0.0042216536,
-0.0150200743,
0.0495339856,
-0.025167862,
-0.0659538954,
0.0026537285,
-0.0074052438,
0.0056913416,
-0.0124871796,
-0.0166387558,
0.0248863418,
0.0086800111,
-0.0207699761,
0.0491153598,
-0.0103553571,
-0.0781104639,
-0.0513881482,
0.0262605529,
0.0467487685,
0.0214817058,
-0.0009558497,
-0.0379017331,
-0.0463573299,
-0.0053931009,
-0.0040908628,
0.0234644879,
-0.0467980094,
0.0429284312,
-0.0080881119,
0.0313806385,
-0.0530632548,
0.0352053195,
-0.014699311,
0.0031659461,
0.028918203,
0.0620083697,
0.0307699237,
-0.0459202901,
-0.0522499979,
0.03820334,
-0.0178861674,
-0.0155306486,
0.0043561738,
0.0154889738,
-0.0368871987,
-0.0269299801,
-0.0757024363,
0.0186332054,
-0.0306581333,
0.0180327408,
0.044106476,
0.0161060095,
-0.0451383926,
0.0007317242,
-0.0156367179,
-0.0272610243,
0.0030915267,
0.0414952673,
0.0308054201,
0.0048262184,
-0.0413038433,
-0.0683166385,
-0.0425980613,
-0.0113351718,
0.0340888761,
-0.0080788322,
0.0099610779,
-0.0598023236,
0.0523537137,
-0.0034083964,
0.0116703296,
-0.0059641176,
-0.0352168344,
0.0297692604,
-0.0156276561,
0.0740341842,
0.0810689852,
-0.0077237766,
0.0192935783,
0.0577698946,
-0.0019530924,
-0.0469875336,
-0.004398806,
-0.0083441604,
-0.059057463,
0.0081007937,
-0.0516756587,
0.010246139,
0.0948605835,
0.0015638737,
0.0061638788,
-0.055363901,
0.0208788048,
-0.0227608122,
-0.0393290445,
-0.0222088322,
0.0052897297,
-0.0319341533,
0.0708668903,
-0.0161886122,
-0.0794891044,
0.0409653336,
-0.0618268512,
-0.0111114634,
0.0086009651,
0.0217248481,
0.0005849977,
0.0469240062,
0.0020822494,
-0.0043172063,
0.0697378665,
-0.0354771987,
-0.046853587,
0.0228792783,
0.0275101364,
-0.0186465569,
0.0296242535,
-0.0582861155,
-0.0099582691,
-0.0238874797,
-0.0330273509,
-0.0399218276,
-0.0433701277,
0.0081305047,
0.0215795133,
-0.0056174602,
-0.0057432353,
0.0086398376,
-0.0012832353,
-0.0042626709,
0.0412534028,
-0.0326245837,
0.0061213854,
-0.0247603022,
0.0199801065,
0.0446069539,
-0.0345193371,
0.0400718749,
-0.0371453688,
0.0436590463,
0.0044075935,
0.01307924,
0.0270399135,
-0.0274556614,
0.0162842069,
0.0484508872,
-0.031768281,
-0.0491045304,
0.0679096654,
0.1008710787,
-0.0490597002,
-0.0166357718,
0.1157225594,
0.0400026701,
-0.0370257758,
0.0246439483,
-0.0140358619,
0.059071105,
0.0271840133,
0.0316562131,
-0.0720061138,
-0.005168166,
0.0218269452,
0.0201609787,
-0.0290911831,
-0.0099597229,
0.0067142248,
-0.1389836669,
0.0388573706,
-0.0080415402,
-0.0316605978,
0.024120165,
-0.0286248922,
0.003086393,
0.0184459221,
0.0715796426,
0.0287080891,
-0.0399275608,
0.0200318769,
0.0376866795,
-0.0102001559,
-0.0621393248,
0.0240678266,
-0.0057968153,
0.0648598149,
0.1033900604,
-0.0222023372,
-0.0093504647,
-0.0694535822,
0.0461218394,
-0.001011967,
0.0328133255,
-0.0179732163,
0.0226602312,
0.0380830616,
-0.0183441546,
0.0009733587,
0.0108573362,
-0.0111633502,
-0.021155173,
-0.0119445818,
0.0218802709,
-0.0095122531,
-0.0110574951,
-0.0082168104,
-0.0268620495,
0.0119670406,
0.0672004223,
0.0705435202,
-0.0510813184,
-0.0469075516,
-0.0524765961,
0.0083663203,
-0.0492061265,
-0.0201192275,
-0.0085358266,
0.0160359237,
-0.0350789167,
-0.0606431514,
-0.0448696092,
0.016578082,
0.0196744613,
0.0026395817,
-0.0351165794,
-0.0690062717,
-0.0126291271,
0.0095922826,
0.049010884,
-0.0178972259,
0.0274522509,
-0.1126868799,
-0.0084941322,
0.0084096491,
-0.0079058474,
-0.0193051528,
0.0023009966,
-0.0611649305,
-0.0664690658,
0.032157857,
0.0718309432,
0.0218556821,
0.0189604871,
-0.0137522621,
-0.061425101,
0.0414900668,
0.0305467527,
0.0083497548,
0.051522769,
0.0288703796,
-0.001717463,
-0.0036110922,
0.0073003331,
-0.0162552893,
0.0279425662,
0.0559146293,
0.0337758325,
0.0146347117,
-0.032949049,
0.0232277066,
0.0363692753,
0.0782832205,
-0.047348097,
-0.0130858775,
-0.0266620927,
0.0083577521,
-0.0414263271,
0.0168133695,
-0.0494261794,
-0.0057499213,
0.0243876874,
0.0009540956,
0.0053662891,
-0.0062279594,
-0.04820076,
0.073137857,
-0.0602770001,
0.0298247561,
-0.0065240529,
0.0499414615,
0.0215008613,
0.0314178914,
-0.0247113723,
0.0410191342,
-0.0096177561,
0.0447383821,
-0.0020094193,
0.0729505867,
-0.0091620833,
0.0105983522,
-0.0081230141,
0.0737514049,
-0.0448906347,
-0.0340407565,
-0.0242954455,
0.0398020297,
0.0295397788,
-0.0088570463,
0.0158642232,
0.0117303552,
0.0018207678,
-0.042964939,
0.0209294911,
0.0478834473,
-0.04507998,
0.0227452368,
0.0127601968,
-0.0162700843,
-0.0605924316,
0.0738047063,
-0.0191974938,
0.0411845222,
-0.0027357354,
0.0301535167,
-0.0108325696,
-0.0083189839,
0.0154340388,
-0.0108792651,
-0.0418110564,
-0.0269080773,
-0.0704090521,
-0.0503704213,
0.0000998712,
0.051343035,
0.0112382229,
0.0077699656,
0.0297372192,
0.0434289388,
-0.0284561794,
-0.0199075136,
-0.0232150741,
-0.0241075009,
-0.0080356663,
-0.0026415591,
-0.0234825164,
-6.251920337e-33,
-0.0574005246,
0.0280709527,
-0.0054243407,
-0.0354915038,
0.0032321971,
-0.000100173,
-0.0519770943,
0.030550722,
-0.0182089731,
-0.0248007793,
-0.0456264839,
-0.0305836927,
0.0227131993,
0.0018477263,
0.0136738298,
0.0052199583,
0.0614319965,
-0.0118980119,
-0.0608328469,
0.0064591928,
0.0080388812,
0.0019787594,
0.0375753343,
-0.0007749354,
0.0329898857,
0.0003042826,
-0.0192065369,
-0.0077250479,
-0.0238167606,
0.0606868379,
-0.0176318921,
0.0397053473,
0.0013346734,
-0.0578820184,
-0.0472302772,
0.0434709266,
-0.0439905301,
-0.0443881229,
0.0310161002,
0.015370436,
-0.017428197,
-0.0681835413,
-0.0140952729,
-0.0215151701,
-0.048811648,
-0.0034619055,
0.0093244081,
-0.0225152206,
-0.0315406807,
-0.0101908566,
-0.0459437668,
-0.0107345833,
-0.0066043171,
-0.0027171897,
-0.0092634354,
0.0358387306,
0.0108513394,
0.0140739065,
-0.0075560501,
0.0160235595,
0.0599455945,
0.0564191826,
0.0768965334,
0.0584647544,
0.0166914556,
0.0336694159,
0.0320712663,
0.0398077853,
-0.0036397635,
0.009578987,
0.0576223545,
-0.0019981295,
0.0260285828,
0.0314527042,
0.0321836881,
-0.0229604635,
-0.0543063581,
0.0237478279,
0.0339647755,
-0.0060121189,
0.0021097346,
0.016570311,
-0.019072203,
-0.0310820993,
-0.0497283377,
-0.0323591381,
-0.0261058304,
-0.0441847369,
0.0609732196,
-0.0185368136,
-0.0016252422,
-0.0368008316,
0.0454245135,
-0.0158685222,
-0.014276444,
-0.0282269977,
-0.04616905,
0.0447479784,
-0.0082888994,
0.0125560844,
-0.034170147,
-0.0282055624,
0.0309077259,
0.0030586747,
0.0358360112,
0.0031394395,
0.0232171323,
0.0251122527,
-0.0845357925,
0.0295141693,
-0.0337878615,
0.0208259467,
0.036829263,
-0.0126729095,
0.0333965495,
-0.0198570751,
-0.0255193301,
0.0302229822,
0.0041140039,
-0.0287756175,
-0.0407230407,
-0.0107106166,
-0.014364711,
0.0272167549,
-0.0494897887,
-0.0262795966,
-0.0286059566,
0.0413849428,
0.055493962,
-0.001384426,
-0.0362756327,
-0.0017438661,
2.749e-7,
0.0501127243,
0.0282941312,
0.0247047003,
0.0307803564,
0.0101065841,
0.0139480839,
-0.0170112755,
0.0312576294,
0.0206893552,
-0.0022882135,
-0.0089197513,
-0.0001458138,
0.0351205692,
-0.0046571698,
-0.0641943887,
0.0388241746,
-0.0551363342,
0.0487887114,
-0.0753870457,
0.0066266176,
0.0387665257,
0.0743876621,
-0.0263637546,
-0.0095057413,
0.0096958438,
-0.0270134695,
0.0344708003,
-0.0578375459,
0.0066820513,
0.0299862567,
0.0440830328,
-0.0286608916,
-0.0028582092,
0.0113365119,
-0.0078026266,
-0.0167513397,
-0.0198558327,
0.0718576536,
0.0042349151,
-0.0199742522,
0.002810389,
-0.0004277603,
-0.0012044406,
-0.0761156231,
0.08810132,
0.0094272476,
0.0090132989,
-0.0275488868,
-0.0174787957,
-0.0176776592,
0.0326073803,
-0.0487043224,
0.0150738927,
0.0251628254,
0.0161996,
-0.0053612273,
-0.0319885984,
-0.0344021618,
-0.0530652404,
-0.0018532362,
-0.0154719502,
-0.0658458471,
-0.070954375,
-0.0007450904,
0.005586592,
-0.0483477525,
-0.0042691734,
2.842601102e-34,
0.0330652706,
-0.0108796153,
0.0477108844,
0.0171273779,
-0.0016132321,
-0.0080427956,
0.0336370692,
0.0188953672,
0.0167717412,
-0.0855268687,
-0.0203849301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11318v1 | Utilising a Large Language Model to Annotate Subject Metadata: A Case Study in an Australian National Research Data Catalogue | 2023-10-17T14:52:33 | 2023-10-17T14:52:33 | Shiwei Zhang, Mingfang Wu, Xiuzhen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In support of open and reproducible research, there has been a rapidly
increasing number of datasets made available for research. As the availability
of datasets increases, it becomes more important to have quality metadata for
discovering and reusing them. Yet, it is a common issue that datasets often
lack quality metadata due to limited resources for data curation. Meanwhile,
technologies such as artificial intelligence and large language models (LLMs)
are progressing rapidly. Recently, systems based on these technologies, such as
ChatGPT, have demonstrated promising capabilities for certain data curation
tasks. This paper proposes to leverage LLMs for cost-effective annotation of
subject metadata through the LLM-based in-context learning. Our method employs
GPT-3.5 with prompts designed for annotating subject metadata, demonstrating
promising performance in automatic metadata annotation. However, models based
on in-context learning cannot acquire discipline-specific rules, resulting in
lower performance in several categories. This limitation arises from the
limited contextual information available for subject inference. To the best of
our knowledge, we are introducing, for the first time, an in-context learning
method that harnesses large language models for automated subject metadata
annotation. | [
0.0286550988,
0.0197745524,
-0.0087514948,
0.0201487783,
-0.0249445811,
0.0238235705,
0.0283831172,
-0.0195511598,
0.0093397927,
-0.0678406358,
-0.0137318745,
0.0230639391,
-0.033941783,
0.0086585106,
-0.0061962069,
-0.0339567624,
0.0246019475,
-0.0207136199,
0.0065350882,
0.0135476962,
-0.0025882139,
0.0186174233,
0.0044519841,
0.0158167258,
-0.0257379375,
-0.027503334,
-0.0168265589,
-0.0146876024,
-0.0047142226,
-0.0125550209,
0.0282535311,
0.0608798303,
0.0206674915,
0.0813406929,
0.0000017565,
-0.0713727251,
-0.0433562733,
0.0312940478,
-0.0300257597,
0.0112093482,
0.0678214505,
0.019437572,
-0.0215609092,
-0.014415591,
-0.0138184791,
-0.0228101518,
0.0714657754,
-0.0109801106,
0.0427136868,
0.0217385087,
-0.0088196602,
-0.0035351187,
0.0162075851,
-0.0212558657,
-0.0024483264,
-0.021413181,
0.0577216446,
0.042695947,
0.0391944535,
0.0866724327,
0.0052986471,
0.0237806942,
-0.0189445168,
-0.0313735493,
-0.015921928,
0.0260774903,
-0.0532968417,
0.0085109165,
0.0355181545,
0.0439196452,
0.0714510307,
-0.0097086178,
0.0291992258,
-0.004922322,
0.0057692924,
0.0557276234,
-0.0742095634,
0.0458248481,
-0.0171755068,
-0.0057387417,
0.0303911231,
-0.02418047,
0.018054666,
0.0349547155,
-0.0027967163,
0.0720981956,
0.0038980597,
-0.0306766722,
0.0084708119,
0.0048136939,
-0.013625945,
-0.0458139442,
-0.0180862825,
0.0192994811,
-0.0123344576,
0.0400950834,
-0.0080230962,
-0.0556759313,
0.062213555,
-0.022439111,
-0.0258699786,
-0.0116906958,
-0.0398768932,
0.0694415644,
0.0283993483,
-0.0215139706,
-0.0246665962,
0.0088872528,
-0.0352669805,
-0.0570279881,
-0.0732192323,
-0.0360361449,
-0.0096479245,
0.0243591778,
-0.0178065673,
0.0284190588,
-0.0544845611,
0.0464501269,
-0.0161447059,
0.0217540562,
-0.0054763118,
-0.0637539178,
-0.0698097125,
0.0073579922,
-0.0138618993,
0.0298835058,
-0.0004373789,
0.033158917,
-0.0044446141,
-0.001827088,
0.0203471184,
0.0351886116,
0.0118985567,
-0.0471714698,
0.0144224418,
0.0318719074,
0.0513670407,
-0.0178612582,
-0.0538883731,
-0.0447594151,
0.0063924906,
-0.0370324925,
0.0490363128,
-0.0741613954,
0.0108123105,
0.0234556813,
-0.012046122,
-0.0311426036,
-0.006759298,
0.0210792497,
-0.034966737,
0.0651358292,
-0.0814344287,
-0.0125283133,
0.0629372373,
0.0014433775,
-0.0166846439,
0.0544243678,
-0.0034221204,
0.02016747,
0.0329522081,
-0.0140487468,
0.0198037811,
0.0380374305,
-0.00281795,
0.0291163176,
-0.0078382976,
-0.0004542262,
0.0794463158,
0.0124431271,
0.0191156194,
0.0335682519,
-0.0366155542,
0.0014609785,
0.0286081713,
0.076603733,
0.0130157741,
0.0048677032,
0.0159644708,
0.0164608676,
0.0061684563,
-0.0336936042,
-0.0198410396,
0.0143003399,
0.0069386545,
-0.0001667582,
-0.0164472274,
0.0027226214,
-0.0110738799,
-0.0328737386,
-0.0254099146,
-0.0107070897,
-0.0343473293,
0.0362512805,
0.0937007368,
0.0017423446,
0.0481636338,
0.0227951333,
0.0561124049,
-0.0129132457,
0.0059443074,
-0.032515876,
0.0286018662,
0.0432224534,
0.0338541493,
-0.094990693,
-0.0692251399,
-0.0390326716,
0.078171894,
0.0678110272,
0.0254789386,
-0.0488726683,
-0.046466846,
-0.0241585374,
-0.0440077931,
-0.0098634325,
-0.0025100226,
0.0167890936,
0.0144817978,
-0.0364117287,
0.0037368964,
-0.0251080971,
-0.0381001756,
0.0539636686,
-0.0599064901,
-0.0190887991,
-0.0020427196,
-0.0364235565,
0.0438278466,
0.0299175885,
-0.0088333953,
-0.0034551548,
0.0345291644,
-0.0067150025,
0.0038429981,
-0.0293225739,
0.0299861692,
0.0005785995,
0.0740250945,
-0.0265164655,
-0.0176936183,
-0.0219228789,
-0.0590413176,
-0.0397178121,
-0.0369894728,
-0.0125495,
0.0184839275,
-0.0444759466,
-0.023343673,
-0.0103401123,
-0.0317909569,
-0.0591487624,
0.0487728044,
0.0222970992,
0.0163890682,
0.0462245792,
-0.0211353227,
0.0254699178,
-0.0188583434,
-0.0350802019,
0.0163220987,
0.0266981665,
0.0268153325,
0.0397153944,
-0.0112895221,
-0.0297814682,
-0.0029593359,
-0.1182128787,
0.0232414734,
0.0018683358,
0.0013336355,
-0.0131447501,
0.004000009,
-0.0142842047,
-0.028393276,
-0.006774094,
-0.0375675,
-0.0296674687,
0.0255514458,
0.0372950733,
0.0254415236,
-0.0021350598,
-0.027310336,
-0.0279457737,
-0.0295405518,
0.0370366536,
0.0378198698,
-0.037387412,
-0.0549533777,
0.0077417539,
-0.0251639597,
0.0200477373,
-0.0108906664,
0.0397577621,
0.0035517763,
-0.0120574068,
0.0414569564,
0.0336864516,
-0.0308517814,
0.0179733876,
0.0832546502,
-0.0032900323,
-0.0452145636,
-0.0056278091,
-0.0379012972,
-0.0134521928,
-0.0058940398,
0.0007205932,
0.0395267271,
-0.0034364529,
-0.0348165296,
-0.0062245708,
0.0073532024,
0.023202844,
-0.0183292255,
0.0034246109,
-0.0572748035,
0.0074462066,
-0.0140888924,
0.0627952963,
0.0087177781,
-0.034658961,
0.0587642081,
-0.0197353065,
0.0068244347,
-0.0468425155,
-0.013686398,
-0.0513568595,
0.0578507893,
-0.0133330328,
0.0073604463,
-0.0009703754,
-0.0193454716,
-0.0279198494,
0.0220096856,
0.0330399089,
-0.0350921303,
0.0035285591,
-0.0536803119,
0.0597315133,
-0.029703863,
-0.0023232109,
-0.0177521724,
-0.0153537998,
-0.0131499385,
0.0412660614,
-0.0491548441,
0.0018730205,
0.0020514322,
0.0104379421,
0.0262973886,
0.0672311485,
0.0046387911,
-0.0129927015,
-0.0222469643,
0.0108486032,
0.0455782898,
-0.0476048738,
-0.0310615618,
0.0124566434,
-0.0008626544,
0.0367715359,
-0.0181490593,
-0.0026472579,
-0.0232451707,
-0.0025798636,
0.016626304,
-0.0890576243,
-0.0078840125,
0.0088235987,
0.0036399898,
-0.0731053725,
-0.0086547378,
0.1145979613,
0.0294355098,
-0.0695016459,
-0.0309351869,
-0.0201496724,
-0.0162164029,
0.0262500457,
0.0321253277,
-0.0920241624,
-0.0023205611,
0.0075862366,
0.0324430168,
-0.0172901358,
-0.0500614829,
0.0037989386,
-0.0952011198,
0.0876424611,
-0.0084932623,
-0.04150334,
0.0209943485,
-0.0569027141,
0.0163928345,
-0.035909757,
0.0119800959,
-0.0260582436,
-0.0045596594,
0.0070953858,
0.0365224965,
-0.0142333256,
-0.0529423207,
0.007228428,
-0.0530887619,
0.0886561573,
0.0284762774,
0.020198198,
-0.0319303907,
-0.0045653973,
0.0739157796,
0.0142302252,
-0.0462198481,
-0.0059099011,
0.0502540655,
-0.0062981942,
0.0014697092,
-0.0151138827,
0.0406492986,
-0.0286859293,
-0.0328377001,
0.0253490824,
0.1378672123,
-0.0312911011,
0.0622214936,
-0.0422393903,
-0.0260727033,
0.0068567311,
0.0745255873,
0.0118531417,
-0.0507666469,
0.0018056199,
-0.0305029117,
-0.012483608,
0.0481816381,
0.0020593475,
0.0306552611,
-0.0716565847,
-0.0453800261,
-0.0249624532,
-0.0286573004,
0.0827509463,
-0.0138443857,
0.0237260982,
0.0517680794,
0.0400641002,
-0.0147894407,
-0.0757729635,
0.055855412,
-0.0704321563,
-0.0027459133,
-0.0441650525,
-0.0482388102,
0.083663173,
-0.0105558345,
-0.028432807,
0.0046024537,
-0.0153335594,
-0.0421719328,
0.0004421319,
0.0176120065,
0.0205466617,
0.0439397544,
-0.0194687042,
-0.0496420972,
-0.012903979,
0.035778299,
-0.0051403432,
-0.0340635367,
-0.0145099405,
0.012328417,
-0.0321423523,
-0.0137603991,
-0.0582480729,
0.0369294323,
0.0076203439,
-0.0103680417,
-0.0584057122,
0.0016163703,
0.0518608391,
0.0241692755,
0.053891398,
-0.0167991538,
-0.0254540257,
-0.0472273119,
-0.0239633806,
-0.0070391186,
-0.0440578721,
-0.0162018631,
0.0209335536,
0.0218617171,
-0.0341444276,
-0.007802675,
-0.0031500468,
-0.0267086811,
0.0616296083,
-0.0524408035,
0.0308581423,
-0.0320631564,
0.0375700481,
0.0248434339,
-0.0112673761,
-0.0300733466,
-0.0014614308,
0.0105000176,
0.0427509323,
-0.015199285,
0.0481535234,
0.0374517329,
0.0151234018,
0.0358190835,
0.0090496615,
-0.0615683049,
-0.0173565596,
-0.0215875115,
0.0584363267,
0.0595905073,
0.0066183535,
0.0165011343,
-0.0525538176,
-0.0432078689,
-0.0462211594,
0.0530211106,
0.0340186879,
-0.0265892148,
0.0153683787,
0.017666392,
-0.0480878688,
-0.003792102,
0.0763809308,
0.0215560198,
0.0318643004,
0.0183927957,
-0.0534643531,
-0.0298898593,
-0.026113065,
0.0163013693,
0.0042421846,
-0.0165576413,
0.0147854388,
-0.0450755246,
-0.0419846922,
-0.0169747341,
-0.0154834734,
-0.0376927927,
-0.0201166552,
0.0240282249,
0.0431289151,
-0.0025658004,
-0.0217235889,
-0.031197777,
0.0124998828,
-0.030203646,
-0.0506324321,
-0.0124636311,
-5.421244029e-33,
-0.0362644643,
-0.0402619354,
0.0380697213,
0.0913835913,
0.0039259205,
0.0063406331,
0.0000028507,
-0.0373609699,
0.0073440922,
0.0099618882,
-0.012156548,
0.0146532822,
0.0114354072,
0.0057749208,
0.0500105657,
-0.0104049388,
0.0295470189,
0.0073049744,
0.0028783751,
0.0383177549,
0.047267016,
0.0147868805,
0.062127687,
-0.0919230878,
0.0531638041,
0.0042388202,
0.0195646528,
0.019529162,
0.0202069618,
0.069609426,
-0.028169835,
0.0377524011,
0.0301445089,
-0.0611634292,
0.0116441939,
0.0150760235,
-0.0772581324,
-0.0178065412,
-0.0066505326,
0.0161648635,
0.0541954674,
-0.051294852,
0.0322997309,
-0.0041027223,
-0.0157428682,
-0.002574885,
0.0555191226,
-0.0419458859,
-0.0300340392,
-0.0822124407,
-0.0597204268,
0.0347847678,
-0.0030490225,
0.0281801205,
0.0359902792,
-0.0126177296,
0.0239997096,
0.0561390184,
-0.0204222985,
0.0309570767,
0.0051529761,
0.0167001784,
0.0420865305,
0.0096094115,
-0.0030454367,
0.0349470153,
-0.0183019135,
0.0471546911,
0.055326093,
-0.0093285153,
-0.0081322044,
0.0259380024,
0.0213511083,
0.0237188824,
0.0034192225,
0.0297709033,
-0.0550564826,
0.036879424,
0.0145287262,
-0.0023359002,
0.0140563631,
0.0081154779,
0.0059178611,
-0.028330883,
-0.0337948389,
0.0069435863,
-0.010981299,
-0.0061027259,
0.0158220995,
-0.037903253,
-0.0306116566,
0.0430821218,
0.0193877891,
-0.0504580364,
-0.0464649647,
-0.0094948383,
0.0102974651,
0.0263024643,
-0.0194668379,
0.0263095368,
-0.0447945446,
-0.0282497536,
0.010441782,
-0.0186834168,
0.0194607731,
0.0157392416,
0.0611878335,
0.023470331,
-0.0386748761,
0.0106397141,
-0.0148506733,
-0.0107406285,
-0.0270012971,
0.0124666523,
0.0193340722,
0.0305008702,
0.0234408602,
0.0294086672,
0.0734648034,
0.0372599997,
-0.0262685642,
-0.059822537,
-0.0118432753,
-0.0358287878,
-0.0080382777,
-0.0187543537,
0.0044544265,
0.0100827087,
0.0381170847,
-0.0247279182,
0.0209718328,
-0.0070603089,
2.543e-7,
0.0968436077,
0.0694340244,
0.0064607062,
-0.0100384289,
-0.0024791942,
0.0068641459,
-0.021532068,
-0.000864787,
0.019451119,
-0.0035342234,
0.0210077837,
-0.0185518302,
0.0313910916,
0.0453107245,
-0.1094645783,
-0.0441199914,
-0.0123449434,
-0.0468514673,
-0.1081521735,
0.0373334438,
0.0123658059,
0.057535056,
0.0172381271,
-0.0056106416,
-0.0194048379,
-0.0290019698,
0.0575232133,
-0.0700061917,
-0.0100229001,
0.0528768934,
0.050564032,
0.0382614918,
0.022986874,
0.0071371496,
0.0100739645,
0.0001469362,
-0.0017075449,
0.0567144044,
-0.0027071268,
0.0213247817,
0.0000519001,
-0.0243037809,
0.0252632312,
-0.0273231287,
0.0231965818,
-0.051714275,
-0.0211704168,
-0.0349303484,
-0.0287023168,
-0.0298095997,
0.0044718343,
-0.0293899141,
0.0129101556,
0.0048260284,
0.0061088526,
-0.0112779737,
-0.0209769569,
-0.0613437966,
0.0177818462,
0.0248345695,
-0.0480290093,
-0.0774823278,
0.01484029,
-0.0105741499,
0.0122799473,
-0.0928197727,
0.0446204618,
2.509735081e-34,
0.050066907,
-0.0011781655,
-0.0085665304,
0.0666203573,
0.002287813,
0.0128104482,
0.0049421759,
0.0335676521,
-0.007657392,
-0.0710482746,
0.0012160577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13013v1 | Generative error correction for code-switching speech recognition using large language models | 2023-10-17T14:49:48 | 2023-10-17T14:49:48 | Chen Chen, Yuchen Hu, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Hexin Liu, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi, Eng Siong Chng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Code-switching (CS) speech refers to the phenomenon of mixing two or more
languages within the same sentence. Despite the recent advances in automatic
speech recognition (ASR), CS-ASR is still a challenging task ought to the
grammatical structure complexity of the phenomenon and the data scarcity of
specific training corpus. In this work, we propose to leverage large language
models (LLMs) and lists of hypotheses generated by an ASR to address the CS
problem. Specifically, we first employ multiple well-trained ASR models for
N-best hypotheses generation, with the aim of increasing the diverse and
informative elements in the set of hypotheses. Next, we utilize the LLMs to
learn the hypotheses-to-transcription (H2T) mapping by adding a trainable
low-rank adapter. Such a generative error correction (GER) method directly
predicts the accurate transcription according to its expert linguistic
knowledge and N-best hypotheses, resulting in a paradigm shift from the
traditional language model rescoring or error correction techniques.
Experimental evidence demonstrates that GER significantly enhances CS-ASR
accuracy, in terms of reduced mixed error rate (MER). Furthermore, LLMs show
remarkable data efficiency for H2T learning, providing a potential solution to
the data scarcity problem of CS-ASR in low-resource languages. | [
-0.0026176465,
0.0553985909,
0.0170154162,
0.008295781,
-0.0148540502,
0.0353843719,
-0.0106205279,
0.0024209276,
0.0434003584,
-0.0517840609,
-0.0523498021,
-0.0486616902,
0.0380676165,
-0.0145233767,
0.054598242,
0.0183888022,
0.0329460092,
-0.0726452097,
-0.0287207011,
-0.0187219847,
-0.02668803,
0.0305444654,
-0.0118649695,
0.0342179686,
0.005937296,
0.0240327474,
0.0054233354,
0.0478525385,
0.0252375733,
-0.0100971879,
-0.0029789098,
0.0385614894,
0.0243173577,
0.0881588385,
0.0000019706,
-0.0326460749,
-0.0386891887,
0.0176044628,
-0.0458044559,
0.0065158363,
0.0373575129,
-0.0251821727,
-0.0246512629,
0.0676167607,
0.0216536112,
-0.0561900102,
0.0887989849,
0.0041932282,
0.0024459641,
0.0877566785,
-0.0087052872,
-0.0412794352,
0.0187597685,
-0.0404991955,
-0.010624364,
-0.0486816391,
0.0532103255,
-0.007539263,
-0.0133593567,
-0.0414122604,
-0.0236916523,
0.0270682778,
-0.0055930754,
-0.0190513693,
-0.0169308092,
0.0055585075,
-0.0210235901,
-0.0060909316,
-0.0295203123,
0.0131989978,
-0.0606587753,
-0.0395425968,
0.0251347963,
-0.0151033886,
-0.0450979397,
-0.0190967452,
0.0117561147,
0.0338508375,
-0.004060925,
0.0201495513,
0.0667530596,
-0.0175950322,
0.0500082746,
-0.0159419272,
-0.0756663904,
0.0154228229,
0.0328201242,
-0.0310052708,
-0.004443069,
0.0093635246,
0.0262005087,
-0.0236579906,
0.0086649293,
-0.0132768108,
-0.0281079169,
0.01943269,
-0.0160242189,
-0.0612858869,
-0.0001480918,
-0.0375243165,
0.0150755802,
0.0416903496,
-0.038856823,
0.0322815478,
-0.0484502874,
0.0536948629,
-0.0257553738,
-0.0267813727,
-0.0188659728,
-0.0309189539,
-0.0023759636,
0.0134340841,
-0.0271270201,
-0.0175956115,
-0.0198318399,
-0.0284490418,
-0.0349541418,
0.0278797857,
0.0163722523,
0.023500938,
0.0280853733,
-0.06485378,
-0.0530254729,
-0.0276462547,
0.0512164719,
0.0131128272,
0.0548821986,
0.0303343851,
-0.0079942401,
-0.0860221907,
-0.0134758465,
0.0491725728,
0.0452178679,
-0.0060770968,
0.0096478201,
0.058655154,
-0.0214284286,
-0.0210602209,
-0.0388239436,
0.0571168326,
-0.0467839651,
-0.0320372954,
-0.011105583,
-0.0716777891,
0.0323224962,
0.0170478951,
0.0389594994,
-0.0543835238,
0.0052442872,
-0.0564533137,
-0.0212195963,
0.0775341392,
-0.0150558278,
0.0200114436,
0.045027364,
-0.0324819796,
-0.0066616219,
0.0844232291,
0.0527919307,
-0.0408534892,
0.0144739347,
-0.0411739014,
0.0246584751,
0.0748153329,
-0.0477868393,
0.0156172672,
0.0089594768,
-0.0373805091,
0.0439724363,
0.0074808914,
0.0365938842,
0.0709087923,
-0.0498337895,
0.0291184336,
0.0167435035,
0.0114339264,
0.02206688,
0.0309566129,
0.0511297435,
0.0041946899,
-0.0180077609,
-0.0000119497,
0.0021088813,
-0.0006333606,
-0.0259855334,
0.0084904591,
0.0755210295,
0.0389098264,
-0.0140635092,
-0.005397141,
-0.0281569827,
-0.0277354084,
-0.0314338431,
0.0379594862,
0.0585091561,
-0.0199259743,
-0.057523489,
0.0227108244,
0.0063432404,
-0.0727302954,
0.0310697462,
-0.0333496891,
0.0141686462,
0.0723905042,
-0.0002793356,
-0.0127143692,
-0.0098989401,
-0.0319960527,
-0.0481144041,
0.0478159003,
0.0024923743,
0.0151368398,
0.0664549395,
-0.0829202384,
0.0151123153,
0.0503367968,
0.0120934015,
0.0686067939,
-0.0293201692,
-0.0052262559,
0.0210316293,
0.003273068,
-0.0214308742,
-0.0082761021,
-0.0346661918,
0.0188470352,
0.0422430709,
0.0073820762,
0.0655625984,
-0.0094905645,
-0.0564003326,
0.0135159297,
0.0016221122,
-0.0394843481,
-0.0230561886,
0.0059296959,
-0.0328391306,
-0.0722408518,
0.0206131656,
-0.0444667675,
0.0001148709,
0.0038457843,
0.0006881769,
-0.0941513479,
-0.0163521059,
-0.0461502746,
0.0420887694,
-0.074569121,
0.0697684288,
0.0355666503,
-0.0106097916,
-0.0043714172,
0.0116992285,
0.0182768013,
0.018187616,
0.0053075915,
-0.0249179862,
0.0039178822,
-0.0585153103,
-0.0156072518,
0.0378667749,
-0.0060825595,
0.0035878059,
-0.0068354155,
0.0166904349,
0.0068716533,
-0.0416002981,
-0.099678807,
-0.0226358064,
-0.0479298234,
0.0070783678,
0.0051861675,
0.0067738406,
0.0036867156,
-0.0104300808,
-0.0413622521,
-0.0250844173,
-0.0074581751,
0.015782224,
-0.0316441171,
-0.0054854676,
-0.047456339,
-0.0349234194,
0.0104320161,
0.0085448064,
0.0303386562,
-0.0212659985,
-0.0429403074,
-0.1122579947,
0.0440889373,
0.0189401619,
0.037763536,
-0.004311563,
-0.0306262821,
-0.0023447077,
-0.0249756072,
0.0663175955,
0.0078974161,
0.0015916666,
-0.0541514009,
0.0608460605,
-0.0189308096,
-0.0464465357,
-0.0123102674,
0.0048809685,
-0.045769494,
-0.0330703557,
-0.0409360789,
-0.0153649542,
0.043810118,
0.0386025757,
0.0107172299,
-0.0821947232,
-0.0567933023,
-0.0071049877,
-0.0224853177,
-0.0009602101,
-0.0247558542,
-0.023259243,
0.0380143113,
-0.0086151836,
-0.0141096385,
0.0287598893,
-0.0915020779,
-0.0242023282,
-0.0470403656,
-0.0075401515,
-0.0377882719,
-0.0339946374,
-0.0081235226,
0.0285597891,
0.0126456842,
-0.0687850639,
-0.0339200981,
0.0124175427,
0.0123300431,
-0.0409644283,
0.0434867404,
-0.0390277877,
0.0415120572,
-0.0193515942,
-0.0846009627,
-0.0006854046,
-0.0186377931,
-0.0176478084,
0.0031601719,
0.0544459261,
-0.0537273772,
-0.0000891527,
0.0092946049,
0.0022064021,
0.0898721665,
0.0144926719,
0.0083091538,
-0.0074465941,
0.0588030517,
0.0227531735,
0.0158673469,
0.0030110155,
-0.0135456901,
0.0408550836,
-0.0029338798,
0.0232718065,
0.0588688627,
-0.0247349907,
0.0130870212,
0.073166199,
0.0257925093,
-0.0181241725,
-0.0062076868,
0.0158989225,
-0.0020942891,
0.0078797843,
0.1230218112,
-0.004031444,
-0.0725582987,
-0.0260439087,
-0.0255710669,
0.0171892978,
0.0084518353,
0.0154860476,
-0.068860203,
-0.0013594859,
0.0222938433,
0.0413836502,
-0.0226759259,
0.013620222,
0.0057027186,
-0.1155048162,
0.0560287386,
0.0565144122,
-0.0214945972,
-0.048738122,
-0.0024735439,
0.0092167845,
-0.0531508252,
-0.0029365469,
0.0343788676,
-0.001544877,
-0.0548624843,
0.0512512587,
-0.0153496815,
-0.0726518705,
-0.0141034899,
0.0005374805,
0.0658107027,
0.082129769,
-0.0006080079,
-0.0308329687,
-0.013363054,
-0.0187953878,
0.0015979754,
-0.0301032774,
-0.013974566,
-0.0143028554,
-0.005280294,
-0.0160453934,
0.0620297156,
0.0564296842,
0.0072848205,
0.0037098562,
-0.0002818272,
0.059150666,
-0.012853655,
0.0126983756,
0.0665215924,
0.0081677325,
0.0307194982,
0.0523518659,
0.0444869809,
-0.0350730978,
0.0275540408,
-0.0169244371,
0.039432846,
-0.0321252495,
0.0480070934,
0.0116421273,
0.0171469878,
-0.0263082925,
-0.0307149328,
0.0250167456,
0.0361742228,
0.0066419337,
0.0242157541,
0.0429325923,
-0.0167646427,
0.0233557671,
0.0069606327,
-0.0242924038,
-0.0165647287,
-0.0050001154,
-0.0824207887,
-0.0201135762,
0.0464239642,
-0.0410024859,
-0.0126368906,
0.0108101415,
-0.0567927398,
-0.0713201091,
0.0054523037,
-0.00697122,
0.0094635878,
0.0383928642,
-0.0060514612,
-0.0450310707,
-0.021418063,
0.0318607725,
-0.016129395,
0.020819921,
0.050801307,
0.0103607588,
-0.0329588316,
0.0341173336,
-0.0397923812,
0.0043807761,
0.0168019887,
0.0258431565,
-0.0627214387,
-0.0588415265,
0.00609871,
-0.0010088112,
0.0483495668,
-0.049633801,
-0.0005810076,
-0.0356707349,
0.0341060944,
0.0032218227,
0.0100700445,
-0.0240943488,
-0.0064897509,
0.0536621846,
-0.0077643772,
-0.035007298,
0.0191271454,
-0.0069723809,
-0.013998392,
-0.0180949811,
0.0602493584,
0.0076729027,
0.0192713793,
0.0385195129,
-0.0139372945,
-0.0556401163,
0.041057203,
0.0502830371,
0.0015352999,
-0.0244929846,
0.0267559011,
0.0017864926,
-0.0096919453,
-0.0048009693,
0.0095350081,
-0.0301516764,
-0.0676831082,
-0.023032235,
0.0204815213,
0.0946312845,
0.0290044248,
0.0902691036,
-0.010596673,
-0.0019106278,
-0.0479299091,
0.0356029496,
-0.0048841396,
-0.0052662059,
0.0295826048,
0.0152859772,
-0.0182441715,
0.0317174532,
0.0574009791,
0.0381648205,
0.0284422357,
-0.0298695154,
0.0170665551,
-0.0329760537,
-0.027807774,
0.0180996619,
-0.0374021083,
-0.0318473876,
-0.0197507702,
0.0004870421,
-0.0780167505,
0.0349173583,
0.0183087662,
0.0228981376,
-0.0159409158,
-0.0181737226,
0.0295173265,
-0.0404519029,
0.0148910638,
-0.02604625,
-0.0355881862,
0.0496557429,
-0.0248644166,
-0.0043855314,
-6.725327177e-33,
-0.0081379926,
0.0135102542,
-0.0191373453,
-0.0568069667,
0.0005147879,
-0.0145088732,
-0.0370149761,
-0.0029270749,
0.0059819422,
-0.048128821,
-0.0073845536,
0.0080865882,
0.0385019556,
0.0127378181,
0.0142491842,
0.0552497953,
0.0891662762,
0.0098686395,
-0.008415971,
0.0292449147,
0.0491364636,
0.0340943374,
0.0522629693,
-0.0469340645,
-0.03492935,
0.0008955376,
-0.0393862948,
-0.0079127429,
-0.0230975263,
0.0406110547,
0.0165352505,
0.0406054817,
-0.0101122167,
-0.0329422317,
-0.0034110777,
0.005079078,
-0.0749409273,
0.00231089,
0.0168113764,
0.0347670689,
0.0235989988,
-0.0318448395,
0.0131412549,
-0.0220329165,
-0.0120807206,
-0.0285478272,
-0.0051852856,
-0.0344004296,
-0.0237073228,
-0.0368321501,
-0.0351929516,
0.0581656061,
-0.0126503194,
0.0069729495,
0.05149436,
0.0397993512,
-0.0183968749,
-0.002336066,
-0.070097141,
0.0258434955,
0.0375037454,
0.0468342528,
0.0347628333,
0.0533265285,
-0.0247368701,
0.003113209,
0.0156756863,
-0.0283380542,
0.0373955816,
-0.0297917277,
0.019457534,
0.0067348052,
-0.0025397115,
0.0546658449,
0.0291764215,
-0.0443540104,
-0.0471690483,
-0.038978409,
-0.0010654458,
-0.0041001616,
0.0602302328,
0.0281569138,
-0.0441910587,
-0.027371034,
-0.0735017955,
-0.0213911273,
-0.0198796801,
-0.0120153073,
0.0264070518,
0.0149946809,
0.0013830459,
-0.0019316538,
0.0800054893,
-0.0084267994,
0.0098653762,
0.023911953,
0.0086674066,
0.0188528243,
-0.0283151437,
0.0624986961,
-0.0493117869,
-0.0321917795,
0.038441807,
0.0114482101,
0.0197261069,
-0.0269717295,
0.0179476682,
0.0476596802,
-0.0713345557,
0.0067450032,
0.005019607,
0.024262717,
-0.0254404396,
0.0317127816,
0.0158464275,
-0.0091548692,
0.0385152586,
0.0005335622,
-0.0168108083,
0.0033310796,
-0.0052941944,
-0.0228085052,
-0.0078630084,
0.0431480408,
-0.0282582641,
0.0090172542,
0.0083756633,
-0.0088910358,
0.0375349969,
0.0030124206,
-0.0029011916,
0.0423515402,
2.871e-7,
0.0004696207,
0.0077943755,
-0.0119901765,
-0.0305872876,
0.0168951042,
-0.0122063803,
-0.0248899274,
-0.0170646701,
0.0236697793,
0.0442578308,
0.0340904966,
-0.0117303496,
0.1146205589,
0.0098158233,
-0.0764264762,
-0.0611066893,
-0.0170094371,
0.0396098606,
-0.0214405823,
-0.0145450383,
0.0364672504,
0.1187010035,
-0.047948733,
-0.0110301664,
0.0063527161,
0.007943375,
0.0489262268,
-0.025484411,
0.0225259196,
0.007480049,
-0.0248960555,
0.0383297205,
-0.0025916405,
0.0332969017,
-0.0196942352,
0.043248117,
0.0089878049,
0.0524585024,
-0.007957085,
-0.0155491736,
0.0218126047,
0.0592512786,
-0.0402672328,
-0.0727268234,
0.0428858399,
-0.0115123559,
0.0117989881,
-0.0299594551,
-0.0273342356,
0.0163006838,
-0.0033142115,
-0.0530608222,
-0.0014140691,
0.0141392276,
0.0149906967,
-0.001112194,
-0.0161867421,
-0.0463298559,
0.0305403303,
0.018681949,
-0.0556146689,
-0.0375699922,
0.0059060776,
-0.0012155367,
0.0240006521,
-0.0167479422,
0.0198300462,
2.372341143e-34,
0.0442277305,
-0.0350317657,
0.0146823693,
0.0305982251,
0.0332368091,
-0.0191109478,
-0.0010104632,
0.0426592603,
-0.0232148785,
-0.0848522037,
-0.0472727828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11303v1 | QADYNAMICS: Training Dynamics-Driven Synthetic QA Diagnostic for Zero-Shot Commonsense Question Answering | 2023-10-17T14:27:34 | 2023-10-17T14:27:34 | Haochen Shi, Weiqi Wang, Tianqing Fang, Baixuan Xu, Wenxuan Ding, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot commonsense Question-Answering (QA) requires models to reason about
general situations beyond specific benchmarks. State-of-the-art approaches
fine-tune language models on QA pairs constructed from CommonSense Knowledge
Bases (CSKBs) to equip the models with more commonsense knowledge in a QA
context. However, current QA synthesis protocols may introduce noise from the
CSKBs and generate ungrammatical questions and false negative options, which
impede the model's ability to generalize. To address these issues, we propose
QADYNAMICS, a training dynamics-driven framework for QA diagnostics and
refinement. Our approach analyzes the training dynamics of each QA pair at both
the question level and option level, discarding machine-detectable artifacts by
removing uninformative QA pairs and mislabeled or false-negative options.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, which
outperforms all baselines while using only 33% of the synthetic data, even
including LLMs such as ChatGPT. Moreover, expert evaluations confirm that our
framework significantly improves the quality of QA synthesis. Our codes and
model checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/QaDynamics. | [
0.0363820828,
0.029967634,
-0.0037756544,
0.0270290468,
0.0133585986,
0.0021585042,
-0.0539239533,
0.0244706906,
0.0054550874,
-0.0520089827,
0.0034175368,
-0.0123437494,
-0.0195556805,
0.0199570712,
0.015011753,
0.0024489828,
0.0663168132,
-0.0179128014,
-0.0419674814,
-0.014269202,
-0.000607963,
0.0142119024,
-0.0194329135,
0.0077915997,
0.0096959807,
-0.0409379005,
-0.0166521668,
-0.0108067114,
0.0116323335,
0.0038432269,
0.0077677472,
0.0566820502,
0.011057741,
0.0150062526,
0.0000019533,
-0.0290412474,
0.0401706845,
-0.0109064598,
-0.048400376,
0.0111694876,
-0.0201739185,
0.0066366671,
0.008122541,
0.0104448115,
-0.0430388786,
-0.0021260036,
0.0228604786,
0.0031380095,
0.0596578792,
0.0606273077,
0.0148796504,
-0.0136593767,
0.0149150202,
-0.0042768,
0.0387598053,
-0.0723367557,
0.0331221111,
0.0079806093,
0.0315814279,
-0.0137769459,
-0.0244127139,
0.0150958067,
0.032367833,
-0.0044837329,
-0.0213373657,
0.0607156977,
-0.0547898225,
0.0236824583,
-0.0236151814,
0.1267301589,
0.0053796899,
-0.0286111571,
-0.0035367631,
0.0071336976,
0.0264340919,
0.0050107501,
-0.045703277,
-0.005590742,
0.0197911821,
-0.0036290593,
0.0151821421,
-0.0230572633,
-0.0029427041,
0.0243338346,
-0.0025304342,
0.0461707115,
-0.0001118163,
-0.0233586114,
-0.0145319058,
-0.0028710051,
-0.0127810417,
-0.0520374365,
-0.0260154475,
0.0861353651,
-0.0048113898,
0.0062029245,
-0.0131816128,
-0.0012631177,
0.0271984935,
-0.0507673584,
0.0068997438,
0.0326395966,
0.0092231464,
0.0389079601,
-0.0481770709,
0.0425278395,
0.0215641856,
0.0224399902,
-0.0489754267,
-0.0102972509,
-0.0652523711,
-0.0084489724,
-0.0271844324,
0.054612048,
-0.0414177366,
-0.0003084048,
-0.0092666298,
0.0037750581,
-0.0111347912,
0.0075207776,
-0.006520493,
0.0697257295,
-0.0238572545,
-0.0093235197,
-0.0431673713,
0.0523259342,
-0.0787867457,
0.0321307667,
0.0151866497,
-0.0359154977,
-0.0581814088,
0.0144996438,
0.0229282472,
-0.0161791407,
0.0033417724,
0.0300439913,
-0.0327142775,
0.0111938817,
-0.0178837348,
-0.0277635977,
-0.0047703874,
-0.0324693583,
-0.0289799161,
-0.052606646,
0.0206894539,
-0.0184715539,
0.0098087732,
0.0270544942,
-0.003676832,
0.0223796517,
-0.0256350264,
0.0674977005,
-0.0403909795,
0.0062960926,
-0.0105064567,
0.0266425442,
0.0393239334,
0.0912903324,
-0.0077411747,
-0.0570304245,
0.0280489866,
-0.0066146757,
0.0239898358,
0.0067756739,
0.0318353474,
0.020794725,
-0.0194448624,
0.0512043163,
-0.0028588644,
0.0232682955,
0.0683519244,
-0.0169854555,
-0.0649235249,
-0.0283934101,
0.0080112573,
0.0642918944,
-0.0100665446,
0.0424678102,
0.0312069021,
0.0121488683,
0.0214727335,
0.0074727284,
-0.0259142518,
0.0167485271,
-0.0587956607,
0.0142826531,
-0.0415108912,
0.0047574556,
-0.0648773536,
0.0016982901,
0.0134578152,
-0.0091143856,
0.0083629182,
-0.0129800132,
0.0031160389,
0.029344229,
-0.017516708,
0.069803983,
-0.0058509107,
-0.0573532172,
-0.0053083492,
-0.042315878,
0.071615614,
0.0475486107,
0.0522346981,
-0.0204049032,
-0.1132233813,
-0.0062563727,
-0.0097314678,
0.0418372005,
-0.0024182836,
-0.0530376099,
0.0377136283,
-0.0448691361,
-0.0065235524,
-0.0175957363,
0.0166175105,
-0.0025876537,
0.0045456933,
0.039640978,
0.0103235291,
-0.0545863025,
0.0245950352,
0.0045387545,
-0.0194377415,
-0.0428916551,
0.0228291508,
-0.0438789316,
0.0290101245,
0.0112570729,
0.0165891089,
-0.0020110332,
0.0248847548,
-0.0081138583,
-0.0144638391,
0.037961401,
-0.0120947324,
-0.0976908058,
0.0491840094,
0.0059138122,
-0.0354837216,
0.0323699042,
-0.0574798398,
-0.0526358224,
0.0199914128,
0.0200346559,
-0.0026621411,
-0.0496376269,
-0.0519138016,
0.0061276085,
0.001386755,
0.0109528191,
0.0835309997,
-0.0212276746,
0.009363357,
0.0260361787,
-0.0073153614,
0.010579464,
-0.0355469063,
0.0114502674,
-0.0181449149,
-0.0216564946,
0.0270420481,
-0.0067481087,
0.0400112979,
-0.0516163856,
0.0130977901,
-0.0826303959,
0.0077846982,
-0.0078915618,
0.0278754421,
0.0231192745,
-0.0066930559,
-0.0059595136,
-0.0122313518,
-0.0413803346,
0.0200414695,
0.0265678558,
0.0041906456,
0.0336094238,
0.0291773528,
-0.0018453324,
-0.0120785339,
0.019951826,
-0.0304220058,
0.0195969976,
-0.0086430088,
0.0938504785,
-0.0308229234,
0.0107899355,
-0.0312530026,
0.0376751013,
-0.0051150061,
-0.0743300617,
0.012033456,
0.0031117599,
-0.0166926105,
0.0556969568,
-0.0189570934,
-0.0078216959,
0.0260111857,
-0.0125424573,
-0.0447453484,
0.0502345376,
-0.0155086331,
-0.0042784316,
-0.0144050019,
-0.007211036,
-0.0287335981,
0.0763731748,
-0.0185559802,
-0.0115908124,
-0.0826368108,
0.0194863044,
0.0133163482,
-0.0125202984,
-0.0534041002,
0.0468856022,
-0.029125927,
0.0267448779,
-0.0243520048,
0.0095557142,
0.0748302415,
0.0016468455,
-0.0122711407,
-0.0575355366,
0.0075603225,
-0.0236099493,
0.0071363761,
-0.0537318923,
-0.0256343894,
0.0029143745,
0.0104799122,
-0.0247501433,
-0.0694653019,
-0.0016697285,
-0.0134156263,
0.0057594334,
-0.0418791957,
0.0413134471,
-0.0229323693,
-0.0323802382,
-0.0325398147,
-0.0496198051,
-0.0102243572,
0.0220574327,
-0.0622702576,
-0.0107709505,
0.0102584939,
-0.003447975,
0.0000192455,
0.0252582878,
-0.0295548588,
-0.0012151428,
-0.0148546882,
0.0747127831,
0.0932326689,
0.052189149,
0.0049172039,
0.0109219914,
0.0226119384,
0.0629267171,
0.0513562746,
0.0275378022,
0.0045431904,
-0.0017091196,
0.0137106981,
-0.0090701915,
-0.0004595291,
0.0476565324,
0.0347150303,
-0.0360341556,
-0.0452009737,
0.0819381475,
0.0393305495,
0.0096043227,
0.0101098754,
-0.0384447016,
0.0223078579,
0.0067332513,
0.0408745594,
-0.0954598263,
-0.0651785582,
-0.0155437803,
0.0347644836,
-0.0254123192,
-0.0373212881,
0.0177768636,
-0.1346358359,
0.0057435171,
-0.0074359472,
-0.0731125474,
-0.0126410779,
-0.0250997916,
0.011931234,
-0.0279149786,
-0.0109355841,
0.0161760002,
0.0000997095,
0.0154716773,
0.0185335558,
-0.0194647126,
-0.0761810988,
0.0520892628,
-0.0237803292,
0.0748542994,
0.0591704026,
0.0538407415,
0.0005819261,
-0.0585195161,
-0.0246104989,
-0.0940226465,
0.0154796317,
-0.0121406941,
-0.0118341688,
-0.0125656631,
-0.0015500413,
0.0002105666,
0.0596460961,
-0.0681845024,
-0.0092583625,
0.0208771359,
0.0875683501,
-0.0180454906,
-0.0133053409,
-0.0424848199,
0.0093094492,
0.0158552732,
0.0798824281,
0.0431484804,
-0.0007009996,
-0.0654077902,
-0.0279482119,
-0.0310033169,
-0.0806219652,
-0.0026520011,
-0.0109415418,
0.0398848727,
0.0074573173,
-0.0898806527,
-0.0502832755,
0.0296792351,
0.0335112214,
-0.0476874821,
0.0213688463,
-0.0448955819,
0.0283758715,
-0.0282187462,
0.0387691744,
-0.0524034575,
-0.017685933,
-0.036959067,
0.0271583553,
0.0411248431,
-0.0071492265,
-0.0130753648,
0.0263264887,
-0.037842866,
-0.0646656975,
-0.0469403788,
0.0684041977,
0.0190406796,
0.0263532549,
-0.0505885668,
-0.0351236798,
0.055287499,
0.0630609766,
-0.0079861218,
0.0112249153,
0.0541091673,
0.006197813,
0.0027904054,
0.0597556643,
-0.0270963144,
-0.0256842058,
-0.0097093815,
0.0602825247,
-0.0703396574,
-0.0185687803,
-0.005398442,
-0.0179260932,
-0.0103865042,
0.0229799468,
0.0146177262,
-0.00226059,
-0.000845894,
-0.0334192105,
-0.0047613424,
-0.034974996,
0.0205772407,
0.0469830781,
-0.0476801433,
-0.0011656368,
0.0272349678,
-0.0778098851,
0.0610501915,
-0.0307079349,
-0.0061472645,
0.0763937011,
0.0071112127,
0.0126952305,
-0.0402243696,
-0.0133170625,
-0.0368477739,
-0.0041872486,
0.0460149422,
0.0190758687,
0.0439786576,
0.0179508943,
-0.0097927731,
-0.0096779428,
0.0086470731,
-0.0423978455,
-0.0076536508,
-0.0132737244,
0.0742589012,
0.0301667657,
0.0260699838,
0.0378170945,
0.0024333012,
-0.0238691438,
0.0169031452,
0.010864771,
-0.0086273523,
-0.0084278667,
0.0646756068,
0.0452375337,
-0.0090673734,
-0.0036224949,
0.11424236,
-0.0233540852,
0.0556937717,
-0.0085721249,
0.0100244712,
-0.0166343804,
-0.0120486869,
0.0099390037,
0.0302395932,
0.0247899778,
0.0435098261,
-0.0774415508,
-0.0562799536,
0.0209846776,
0.0200695731,
-0.0194916688,
-0.0069474685,
0.0354988798,
0.041897364,
0.0336333029,
-0.0476163216,
-0.0050416072,
0.0104963323,
-0.0710815787,
-0.0085969735,
-0.0438506231,
-6.647615245e-33,
-0.013580339,
-0.0248645935,
0.0203548875,
-0.0687066987,
-0.023494795,
0.0040081842,
-0.0351942554,
-0.0219047032,
-0.0368632749,
0.0218417309,
-0.032001216,
0.048748821,
-0.014025256,
0.009506193,
-0.00556318,
-0.042275764,
0.0049448563,
-0.0109117422,
-0.0442505591,
0.0127926609,
0.053464178,
-0.003898717,
0.0738102421,
0.0367698185,
0.0083166873,
-0.0251539759,
-0.0231422111,
0.0413441844,
-0.047155343,
0.0584210381,
-0.0260607824,
0.0605031438,
0.0339297242,
-0.011446639,
0.0216905866,
0.022248175,
-0.0712255538,
-0.0733926222,
0.0458917581,
-0.0327812731,
-0.0304364655,
-0.0291707385,
0.0323675573,
0.0171042494,
0.0146567421,
0.0082894862,
0.0076137986,
-0.0495459549,
0.000953513,
-0.0313229822,
-0.0155573199,
0.0147260446,
-0.0166818518,
-0.0552907102,
-0.0428480692,
0.0498484671,
-0.0196598712,
-0.0243730303,
-0.0483695567,
-0.0189342033,
0.0444670282,
0.0141314184,
0.0560155809,
-0.012589829,
0.0128413206,
0.0161434878,
-0.0230707824,
-0.0194547307,
-0.0343257189,
0.0215272103,
0.0018622226,
0.0127936816,
0.0646650046,
0.097715579,
0.038096264,
0.0240811333,
-0.0608990826,
0.0579977818,
-0.0017018628,
0.069613494,
-0.0032548709,
-0.0107399598,
-0.037767414,
-0.0350096934,
-0.0427265167,
0.0116022276,
-0.0181309432,
-0.0096480409,
0.0181550737,
-0.0081379376,
-0.0512897,
-0.0082852636,
0.0241946019,
-0.0315764099,
0.0386563428,
0.038287431,
-0.0287598241,
0.0168356113,
0.0409653001,
0.0135590667,
-0.0547285639,
0.002464927,
0.0578548126,
-0.0154071208,
-0.0160912294,
0.0392346866,
-0.0014013692,
-0.0006479091,
-0.0072420421,
-0.0115339933,
0.0072867805,
0.0328414552,
-0.03280662,
0.0086328788,
0.0185185485,
0.0401514284,
0.0050657312,
0.0429538041,
0.0031406772,
0.0258206856,
0.0179201383,
0.0209875423,
-0.00084829,
0.0353087038,
-0.025984725,
0.0164582282,
-0.0256794821,
-0.0126152821,
-0.0016929725,
-0.0570280962,
-0.0106497733,
0.0757026747,
2.619e-7,
0.0178149138,
0.0021399611,
0.0257302169,
-0.0064880522,
0.0336375609,
0.0690795034,
0.0042324616,
0.0271172095,
0.0037881613,
-0.0315824337,
0.0090625416,
0.0429023877,
0.0324198455,
0.0232376661,
-0.079978466,
0.0141373873,
-0.0642110109,
-0.0250788145,
-0.0270507224,
-0.0423551872,
0.0226217899,
0.056409169,
0.0057046278,
-0.0177079476,
0.0438627191,
-0.0409582518,
0.0371912457,
0.0210894626,
-0.0129042389,
0.01361412,
0.0100381318,
-0.0092877317,
0.0155107463,
0.0428767577,
0.003522678,
0.0161429029,
-0.0340973176,
0.0350202732,
-0.0286434572,
-0.0586998574,
-0.0027617409,
-0.0685854703,
0.0298576206,
-0.0535077676,
0.117384702,
-0.0733051002,
-0.0140876239,
-0.0204411168,
-0.0386901647,
0.0072792494,
0.0246519297,
-0.0190160181,
-0.0125310495,
-0.0113215288,
0.0137667637,
0.000587389,
-0.0001816424,
-0.0561487935,
0.0193097331,
0.0119313234,
-0.0148064438,
-0.0211827531,
-0.0053550196,
-0.0609431528,
0.0298428442,
-0.1136028618,
0.0259349681,
2.215157804e-34,
0.0222349782,
-0.0094371252,
0.0244035888,
0.0249303207,
0.0116412174,
-0.0012795179,
-0.0246011522,
-0.0270413794,
0.0507205464,
-0.053392034,
-0.0031705657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11282v1 | ChapGTP, ILLC's Attempt at Raising a BabyLM: Improving Data Efficiency by Automatic Task Formation | 2023-10-17T14:06:06 | 2023-10-17T14:06:06 | Jaap Jumelet, Michael Hanna, Marianne de Heer Kloots, Anna Langedijk, Charlotte Pouw, Oskar van der Wal | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the submission of the ILLC at the University of Amsterdam to the
BabyLM challenge (Warstadt et al., 2023), in the strict-small track. Our final
model, ChapGTP, is a masked language model that was trained for 200 epochs,
aided by a novel data augmentation technique called Automatic Task Formation.
We discuss in detail the performance of this model on the three evaluation
suites: BLiMP, (Super)GLUE, and MSGS. Furthermore, we present a wide range of
methods that were ultimately not included in the model, but may serve as
inspiration for training LMs in low-resource settings. | [
-0.0001751455,
0.0766203925,
-0.0087384088,
0.0490265191,
-0.0420982949,
0.0227611028,
0.018412007,
-0.0173147321,
0.0010097952,
-0.0372475721,
-0.0275386237,
-0.0573533624,
0.0011489219,
0.0523601584,
0.0690225437,
-0.0536709242,
0.0377695002,
-0.0273834057,
-0.0041777552,
0.0034109484,
-0.008094809,
0.0021036051,
-0.0143398745,
0.0315585285,
0.0008343032,
-0.0117819365,
-0.0212150086,
0.0320909135,
0.0266940929,
-0.0435929298,
0.0228523724,
0.0303847138,
0.031735979,
0.035310071,
0.0000021786,
-0.0448749475,
0.0039506671,
-0.0154852811,
-0.0617901348,
-0.0173220616,
0.0295800231,
-0.0211848877,
-0.0248423461,
0.036345426,
-0.0443435311,
-0.0105229691,
0.0500749461,
0.0096348571,
0.0496498533,
0.0943469033,
-0.0012287153,
0.0023662944,
0.0007854948,
-0.0435412005,
0.037911173,
-0.0258129481,
0.0251528043,
-0.0100509804,
0.0162097011,
0.006530914,
-0.0078918394,
0.0457095318,
0.0074925004,
0.0034960862,
0.0187550317,
0.0553708151,
-0.0218339488,
-0.040569786,
-0.016430648,
0.0416144095,
-0.0496070199,
-0.0303148516,
-0.001602701,
-0.0022219126,
-0.007493285,
-0.0453079753,
-0.0614783242,
0.0451366715,
0.0387153663,
0.0359780826,
0.0182429459,
0.0247467365,
0.0557391718,
-0.0059197261,
0.0135976868,
0.0365088508,
0.0016676118,
-0.0512762032,
-0.0162976105,
0.0408925116,
-0.0136659229,
-0.0501283854,
-0.0346956365,
0.0293739215,
-0.0062210569,
0.0228661653,
-0.0441160426,
-0.0512372106,
0.0127947899,
-0.0134834992,
0.0492846742,
0.0043208161,
-0.0145502044,
0.0571972318,
-0.0402788073,
0.0654843897,
0.0270102415,
0.0101152724,
-0.0233306475,
-0.0040459805,
-0.0157641061,
0.0156536754,
-0.0372092612,
0.0131399604,
-0.0734682083,
0.0022814658,
-0.0108137215,
0.0144018941,
-0.0266708769,
0.0079638856,
0.029227145,
-0.0128495507,
-0.0451061167,
-0.003065007,
0.0060383682,
-0.0290376116,
0.0215893239,
0.0128840161,
0.0110622374,
-0.0479257926,
-0.0355619118,
0.0200543292,
0.0024394684,
-0.0296758916,
0.0178713389,
0.0730186179,
-0.0149469562,
-0.0403159373,
-0.0349641405,
0.0130167976,
-0.0017480615,
-0.0731238648,
-0.0015657678,
-0.0598724447,
0.0372947715,
-0.0410255194,
0.0000106275,
-0.0426577181,
0.0144727472,
0.01783734,
-0.0338310599,
0.0567040741,
-0.0486936904,
-0.0057608699,
-0.0174778737,
0.0124115786,
-0.0159270912,
0.0860765427,
0.0225292332,
0.0102317464,
0.0341732129,
0.0001664946,
0.0002399146,
0.0675234273,
0.0338619351,
0.0366911665,
0.0249146335,
-0.0138349701,
0.0244246237,
0.0122035164,
0.0350628681,
0.0356768928,
-0.0342311561,
-0.0108420923,
0.08170598,
0.0263751615,
-0.003726938,
-0.0102566462,
0.0074650818,
0.0214919969,
0.0146526769,
-0.0228990428,
-0.037057586,
0.0230601951,
-0.0047646402,
0.0127220359,
0.038695924,
0.0481864661,
-0.0500955358,
-0.0323021114,
-0.0319161899,
-0.0133022312,
0.0047373823,
0.0171687622,
0.0175193958,
0.0306135938,
-0.0667426139,
-0.0038971661,
0.0322420001,
-0.0351011679,
0.0034025316,
-0.0757026672,
-0.0261213575,
0.0189165622,
0.0245898757,
-0.0239172019,
-0.0647566989,
-0.036429964,
0.0105269933,
0.0759263113,
-0.0274077337,
-0.0057354728,
0.032111872,
-0.0470114723,
-0.017521238,
0.0073468322,
-0.0025172478,
0.0055213575,
0.0155342296,
-0.0474133156,
0.0017134926,
0.0149387363,
-0.0070187971,
0.0510048047,
-0.0739252567,
-0.0306719895,
0.0179852191,
-0.0039150571,
0.0331300311,
0.0098041091,
-0.0119319819,
0.014802604,
0.0488260873,
-0.0684294626,
-0.0003483293,
0.0128112845,
-0.0211086739,
-0.0701123178,
0.032348033,
-0.0290641636,
-0.0221680589,
0.0819416717,
-0.024238335,
-0.0645144209,
-0.0024849838,
-0.0290017817,
0.0282699596,
-0.0466277637,
0.0265287291,
-0.002861114,
0.0025493454,
-0.0653518289,
0.0510577522,
-0.0081312796,
0.0122220973,
0.014573331,
0.0017680064,
-0.0099594807,
-0.0494218245,
-0.0189985596,
-0.0208501238,
-0.0056124339,
0.0312231816,
-0.0042523211,
0.0245116372,
-0.0345340222,
-0.0178506672,
-0.0974380746,
0.0209504105,
-0.0311068986,
0.0079096435,
0.0350138992,
-0.0020349368,
-0.0249661095,
-0.0185044762,
-0.0566569827,
-0.0185978599,
-0.0163907483,
0.0151502984,
0.0235602129,
0.0043893363,
-0.0103076622,
-0.0493661799,
-0.0154283652,
0.0103859575,
0.0107559329,
-0.0159427561,
-0.0581223406,
-0.0304482915,
0.0217307694,
-0.0096599143,
0.0164043233,
-0.020457508,
-0.0181520935,
0.0069339038,
-0.0419142507,
0.0431835502,
0.0678061545,
0.0045253877,
-0.0018187318,
0.0292745065,
0.007819674,
-0.0548729151,
0.0208831225,
-0.0175740402,
0.0071111554,
-0.0152862575,
-0.0183433313,
0.0184638035,
0.0950349271,
-0.0286156721,
-0.0134800496,
-0.0547924116,
0.0048303022,
-0.0153977135,
-0.0279842522,
-0.0375871584,
0.0078143356,
-0.0490356237,
0.0087593142,
-0.0486155115,
-0.0743153244,
0.0153585896,
-0.0507521182,
-0.0548596419,
-0.0701045096,
-0.0475177579,
-0.0043633915,
0.0572947003,
0.0405715257,
0.0241894387,
-0.010050266,
-0.0261126775,
-0.0663293004,
0.0476309322,
-0.0206722841,
-0.0121527975,
0.0203102175,
-0.0349516869,
0.000989328,
-0.020299213,
-0.060359031,
-0.0705525801,
-0.0599525943,
-0.0195731353,
-0.0016178926,
0.0166566987,
-0.0262312349,
-0.0397363342,
-0.0172172338,
-0.0003985036,
0.0367161855,
-0.0223562475,
0.0052240379,
-0.0419630632,
-0.0070597352,
0.0651443899,
0.0426766202,
0.041964151,
-0.0420933552,
0.0125192739,
0.0527901873,
0.0743653327,
0.0158692952,
-0.0142877279,
0.0145452674,
0.0406248048,
-0.0005529723,
-0.052180957,
0.0103197936,
0.0647984296,
-0.0413762741,
0.0011873472,
0.1227685586,
0.0090339212,
-0.0224248096,
-0.0170781221,
-0.0021788934,
0.0671971589,
0.0199908782,
0.0092179151,
-0.0677405745,
-0.0187247321,
0.0301262848,
0.0355128087,
0.0051979683,
-0.0236288309,
-0.0147571433,
-0.1011334062,
0.0564233139,
0.0250033122,
-0.0279074255,
0.0223264415,
-0.0557191856,
0.0010843173,
-0.0133638363,
0.0341939181,
0.0084572863,
-0.0147226341,
-0.0242453814,
0.0461637899,
-0.0222399142,
-0.0642823204,
0.0141523927,
-0.03670647,
0.0901122764,
0.036586266,
0.0126403747,
-0.0061894497,
-0.0412469879,
0.0772834644,
0.016296709,
-0.0404703803,
-0.0016095303,
0.0484688245,
-0.0244846139,
-0.0269885883,
0.0155410757,
0.0490483306,
-0.0266730916,
-0.0004650437,
-0.0025140936,
0.0545390099,
-0.0056952005,
0.0025745416,
0.013374133,
0.0111746164,
0.0108409273,
0.0919658989,
0.0203601066,
-0.0506930351,
-0.0101836156,
-0.005910363,
-0.0179153718,
-0.0332384109,
-0.0271297712,
0.0354259051,
-0.0357372575,
0.0117684016,
-0.0568067245,
-0.0378842056,
0.0686225966,
0.0725324303,
0.0085781356,
-0.0083617186,
-0.0183385294,
-0.0154734468,
-0.0718580857,
0.0252598375,
-0.0460814573,
0.033997789,
-0.0823400915,
-0.0718252361,
0.0086029703,
-0.013137605,
-0.004590088,
0.0314317085,
-0.1089108363,
-0.0724763498,
0.0190064833,
0.0691664517,
0.0315549448,
0.0559554733,
-0.0186411887,
-0.0166848656,
0.0409554131,
0.0151843121,
-0.0209199768,
0.0486522987,
0.0609754398,
-0.0601941273,
-0.0029780534,
0.0357391536,
-0.0217459388,
0.0246485788,
0.0295013431,
0.0441663899,
-0.0351282805,
0.0203409567,
-0.0011006182,
0.0092448778,
0.0803823248,
-0.0394109786,
-0.0109575763,
-0.0440817066,
-0.001554967,
-0.0097711775,
0.0175105538,
-0.0560002811,
-0.0124850795,
0.0177483894,
0.0256015155,
0.0197606869,
0.0557739846,
-0.0300986134,
0.0200927798,
-0.0531787872,
0.0071998541,
-0.0336190425,
0.0382150449,
0.0345119722,
0.0409988053,
-0.0162193589,
0.0142919216,
0.0044671372,
0.0213502739,
0.0019051488,
0.0105222706,
0.0222554356,
0.0237965621,
-0.035853643,
0.0543948524,
-0.0612098537,
0.0040246039,
-0.0216258168,
0.0072294516,
0.0852988884,
-0.0087207556,
0.0862903148,
-0.0137057584,
-0.0118263206,
-0.0339208059,
0.0151320687,
-0.024750134,
-0.0265175011,
0.0257939491,
0.0127140488,
-0.0408264063,
0.0225506295,
0.0859970227,
0.0324723311,
0.0253189392,
0.0489346683,
0.0600313023,
-0.0357879251,
-0.0097917309,
0.0506156869,
0.0490891151,
0.0045382367,
-0.0034979125,
-0.0304069519,
-0.0730552971,
0.0058602476,
0.0014549106,
0.0026947537,
0.0074697374,
0.0417402349,
0.0025013476,
-0.0089813434,
-0.000062537,
-0.0401926264,
-0.0287691448,
0.0369548239,
-0.008039319,
0.0279532298,
-7.198745037e-33,
-0.013350674,
0.0036972193,
0.0312522799,
0.0237239879,
-0.0089980774,
0.0574435927,
-0.0285672545,
0.0302772149,
-0.0047429409,
-0.0002284542,
-0.0098121157,
-0.0081899446,
0.026603654,
0.055371765,
-0.0343955308,
0.0038221483,
0.0521313399,
-0.0256698765,
0.007629185,
-0.0013479013,
-0.0092326347,
0.0267336741,
0.0210183971,
-0.057717137,
0.0118109221,
-0.0161818378,
-0.012820621,
0.0264187828,
0.0341401882,
0.0497009307,
-0.0258056317,
0.0147027466,
0.0335753672,
-0.0363166369,
-0.0676047131,
0.0347428583,
-0.0934491158,
-0.0204755776,
0.0158326831,
-0.0009102781,
-0.076632306,
-0.0242310651,
0.0108111948,
0.0087364698,
-0.0070658373,
-0.0278142337,
0.0123436302,
-0.0271230564,
-0.0442135371,
0.0192924365,
-0.0315627642,
0.0126083735,
0.0281555876,
-0.0277095512,
0.0494143404,
0.0007546849,
-0.0177530441,
-0.0339985564,
-0.0608831011,
0.0047655846,
0.0117419707,
0.0398887582,
0.04623992,
0.0511842556,
0.0131145371,
0.082203187,
0.0227716397,
0.0551643893,
-0.031424202,
0.0445699245,
0.0554770753,
0.0328234211,
0.0553553142,
-0.0348016098,
0.0016779858,
0.02232497,
-0.0717619956,
0.0321015567,
0.0327259041,
-0.007737217,
0.0084772008,
0.0290707983,
-0.0156933181,
-0.0047588251,
-0.0387711003,
0.0252086595,
-0.0147310458,
-0.0121074663,
0.0347092822,
0.0381252319,
-0.039537549,
0.0041777366,
0.0297815166,
-0.037724413,
0.0275940988,
-0.0411711074,
0.0256216079,
-0.0162854549,
0.0097473934,
0.0115936035,
-0.0538110659,
-0.0238554366,
0.0303294417,
0.0345974378,
0.0314217992,
0.0122390725,
0.0466171391,
0.0254820809,
-0.0791116655,
-0.0113638081,
-0.0489679649,
0.0450895615,
0.0334478877,
0.0427914336,
0.019636767,
-0.0145814605,
0.0074805613,
0.0487753339,
0.0037702061,
-0.034959238,
-0.0191976465,
0.0512270257,
-0.0203076303,
0.0050919838,
-0.011073363,
0.0053531756,
-0.0588758774,
0.016651053,
0.0642216727,
-0.0588116087,
0.0002868106,
-0.0179647245,
2.858e-7,
-0.0040828348,
0.0484536588,
0.0333848707,
0.0348361619,
0.0288249329,
0.0100133577,
-0.0602958351,
0.0199022647,
-0.0005276345,
-0.0026568437,
-0.021055514,
0.015394696,
0.0713390261,
0.0185557399,
-0.1037942022,
-0.0353197567,
-0.0311533678,
-0.0066350196,
-0.0360419229,
0.0047719982,
0.0190532804,
0.1123107597,
0.0228275247,
-0.0210857764,
0.026920801,
-0.0343372561,
0.0456268117,
-0.0210090801,
-0.028147893,
-0.0032164545,
0.0041519185,
0.0628605783,
-0.0089937141,
0.0042212158,
-0.0399503931,
0.0117866043,
0.001850407,
0.0821885914,
-0.0048880801,
-0.0220834371,
0.0249168742,
0.0169037152,
-0.0190670062,
-0.0208973344,
0.0698264912,
-0.032538645,
-0.0088349432,
0.0074792723,
-0.0276827496,
0.0024500564,
-0.0031743504,
-0.0232652165,
-0.0489081964,
0.0262293015,
0.0498240739,
-0.02750648,
-0.0322161019,
-0.0891904607,
-0.039597068,
0.0082349246,
-0.0478702188,
-0.064778693,
-0.0204496142,
0.0013227691,
0.0100457277,
-0.0580228269,
-0.0168088432,
3.096605457e-34,
0.022632638,
-0.0368009433,
0.0295147486,
0.0334053822,
0.011084198,
-0.01953106,
-0.0347932167,
0.021629354,
0.0101236962,
-0.0732880384,
-0.010078202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11275v1 | xMEN: A Modular Toolkit for Cross-Lingual Medical Entity Normalization | 2023-10-17T13:53:57 | 2023-10-17T13:53:57 | Florian Borchert, Ignacio Llorca, Roland Roller, Bert Arnrich, Matthieu-P. Schapranow | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: To improve performance of medical entity normalization across many
languages, especially when fewer language resources are available compared to
English.
Materials and Methods: We introduce xMEN, a modular system for cross-lingual
medical entity normalization, which performs well in both low- and
high-resource scenarios. When synonyms in the target language are scarce for a
given terminology, we leverage English aliases via cross-lingual candidate
generation. For candidate ranking, we incorporate a trainable cross-encoder
model if annotations for the target task are available. We also evaluate
cross-encoders trained in a weakly supervised manner based on
machine-translated datasets from a high resource domain. Our system is publicly
available as an extensible Python toolkit.
Results: xMEN improves the state-of-the-art performance across a wide range
of multilingual benchmark datasets. Weakly supervised cross-encoders are
effective when no training data is available for the target task. Through the
compatibility of xMEN with the BigBIO framework, it can be easily used with
existing and prospective datasets.
Discussion: Our experiments show the importance of balancing the output of
general-purpose candidate generators with subsequent trainable re-rankers,
which we achieve through a rank regularization term in the loss function of the
cross-encoder. However, error analysis reveals that multi-word expressions and
other complex entities are still challenging.
Conclusion: xMEN exhibits strong performance for medical entity normalization
in multiple languages, even when no labeled data and few terminology aliases
for the target language are available. Its configuration system and evaluation
modules enable reproducible benchmarks. Models and code are available online at
the following URL: https://github.com/hpi-dhc/xmen | [
0.0070006507,
0.0329893455,
0.0457009971,
-0.0322442241,
0.0245360397,
0.0313061476,
0.0094920909,
0.0197438281,
0.0204216875,
0.0244713053,
-0.0525674298,
-0.033303123,
0.0368651971,
0.0116263274,
0.0294179749,
-0.0436325073,
0.0351933464,
0.0408305675,
-0.0323594771,
-0.0186766759,
-0.0346167088,
0.0056991964,
-0.0010847632,
0.0471940897,
0.0120266629,
0.0386685543,
0.0738075674,
-0.0142038316,
0.0486390889,
-0.0555789843,
-0.017121831,
0.0196748953,
-0.0077601718,
0.0088008959,
0.0000019541,
-0.0385208316,
-0.0252801757,
0.0288408957,
-0.012541729,
-0.0305505823,
0.0171380583,
-0.1101823449,
-0.0286199693,
0.0066257105,
0.0094461087,
-0.0702868924,
0.0439609811,
0.0165746827,
0.0333673805,
0.0531939939,
-0.0046407753,
-0.0200343896,
0.0095595904,
-0.0550474264,
0.0071679587,
-0.0476489775,
0.0383113287,
0.005911334,
-0.011419137,
-0.00038819,
-0.0205205046,
0.0336457975,
-0.0162419155,
0.0357207656,
0.0078949016,
0.0503527261,
0.0241964906,
-0.0220670737,
0.0424166471,
0.0585236885,
-0.0287848581,
0.0121541508,
0.0333266445,
0.0161072481,
-0.024569165,
0.0048416508,
-0.0266855862,
-0.010410862,
0.0103409849,
0.0019942459,
0.0455318987,
-0.0093431771,
0.0416952185,
0.01480434,
-0.0115675703,
0.0055261203,
0.0281524081,
-0.0204888787,
0.0315697789,
0.0075963535,
0.0161117576,
-0.0290246159,
0.0619374104,
0.0299524236,
-0.0664537326,
0.0104792621,
-0.0381964296,
-0.0331737362,
0.0629678667,
-0.0575081669,
-0.0342358761,
-0.0117624057,
0.0163804553,
0.0431926288,
-0.0434981249,
0.0009906361,
-0.0297737774,
0.0595434979,
-0.0263441373,
-0.0540835038,
-0.0202460624,
0.0043768156,
-0.0228379462,
0.0188257843,
0.0037226963,
0.0298197418,
-0.1210886016,
-0.0585227087,
-0.0293649286,
0.0364719331,
0.0553297289,
0.0206540488,
-0.0354604088,
-0.005739213,
-0.03283187,
0.0418755598,
-0.0175700169,
-0.0232585203,
-0.0344042145,
-0.0271143466,
0.0210806485,
-0.006565779,
0.0116009004,
-0.037015371,
0.056935139,
0.0362189785,
0.0126993917,
0.0024257891,
0.0083490442,
-0.0399357826,
-0.0042594676,
-0.0135855628,
-0.0296005253,
-0.0644512847,
0.0561353751,
0.0100871837,
0.0319055729,
-0.0670517981,
0.0236403123,
0.0107258586,
-0.0599414334,
0.0971154794,
-0.0536898524,
-0.0274924319,
0.0312681012,
0.0289617646,
-0.012511882,
0.0162179172,
0.0199762303,
-0.0702417046,
-0.0150399832,
-0.0093629891,
-0.0240059756,
0.0195732024,
0.007931103,
-0.0683652237,
-0.000534059,
-0.0255186092,
0.0205020942,
0.1026788652,
0.0305516142,
0.0717062727,
-0.0156117799,
-0.0468913093,
-0.0433759354,
0.0130664147,
0.0230673309,
-0.0058370242,
0.0404431187,
-0.0483741313,
-0.0365474075,
-0.0133063141,
0.0126856333,
0.0294977631,
0.0671346486,
-0.0084092412,
-0.0009052747,
0.046840746,
-0.0335565545,
-0.0000424525,
0.0260229819,
-0.0416525789,
-0.0137445638,
-0.0324349217,
0.049828805,
0.0210364535,
-0.0227505229,
0.0830698609,
0.0417092256,
-0.0324352011,
0.026203271,
-0.0139686465,
-0.0521616936,
0.0591391437,
0.0718638599,
-0.0159578491,
-0.058486294,
-0.0112634469,
-0.0329219326,
0.0047622914,
0.0351361856,
-0.0466092713,
0.0339298174,
-0.0695955828,
-0.0113835698,
0.0386587344,
0.0041922885,
-0.0019649349,
0.0018856499,
0.0531841591,
0.0405606031,
-0.0618408024,
-0.012932186,
0.0427288823,
-0.0910525471,
0.0026704774,
-0.0037658296,
0.0050734547,
0.0043069683,
0.0394252725,
-0.0145678259,
0.0251919162,
0.0399613827,
-0.0521113649,
0.0105547309,
-0.0132483896,
-0.0016428439,
-0.0350140966,
0.0343561247,
-0.0578971282,
-0.0116856256,
0.013457221,
-0.0374898836,
-0.0280086659,
-0.0541972369,
0.0018110409,
0.006195351,
-0.0185782239,
0.0203505587,
0.0403903611,
0.0238216184,
-0.0051449141,
0.0250185486,
-0.0238562897,
0.0447187349,
0.0598342866,
-0.0291586909,
0.0078402078,
0.0033810234,
-0.0188558698,
0.0278751738,
-0.0095425788,
0.0047565647,
-0.0049342187,
0.0186092909,
-0.0156956594,
-0.0240732469,
-0.0837058648,
0.0050687771,
0.0149075557,
0.0230028629,
0.0257083382,
0.0698343962,
0.0324361697,
-0.0174634606,
-0.0292257909,
-0.0302665979,
0.0163589232,
0.0268676542,
0.0423990861,
0.0151803782,
0.0012597899,
0.0035429946,
-0.0070229569,
-0.0126810335,
0.0159490984,
-0.0118469475,
-0.0295881387,
-0.0028408091,
0.0239497889,
-0.0739225298,
-0.0158196911,
0.0141747491,
-0.0227535963,
0.0026145116,
0.037682645,
0.014846798,
0.0089836093,
-0.0094034476,
0.016458882,
0.0340690352,
0.0135322241,
-0.0432376787,
-0.0057084146,
0.0117046675,
-0.0093183173,
0.0102775441,
-0.0560463108,
-0.0388156995,
0.056854628,
-0.0268081706,
0.010478219,
-0.0290261619,
-0.0163706392,
-0.0108950008,
-0.0271650292,
-0.0512610562,
0.0375305973,
-0.0350183249,
0.0224002581,
0.0084379418,
0.0136836255,
0.092674762,
-0.0101107145,
0.0104904687,
-0.0401568711,
-0.0043938197,
-0.0365875773,
-0.0215472747,
-0.0397324711,
0.0424080342,
-0.0136451982,
-0.0452127829,
-0.0231344141,
0.0501098856,
0.0044688433,
-0.0833796933,
0.0012842884,
0.0332715064,
0.0000392816,
-0.0164737664,
-0.0283412617,
-0.0278874245,
0.0340851471,
-0.0029308398,
0.0378919169,
0.0170909464,
0.0105187921,
-0.0276502147,
0.0448240787,
0.005950971,
0.0524966009,
0.0490393266,
0.0057571009,
0.0096182507,
0.0389125906,
-0.0061156442,
-0.0112544112,
-0.0356641561,
-0.0086837998,
0.0009630945,
0.0456365421,
0.0078716287,
-0.0156449471,
0.0459493026,
-0.0203285236,
0.0024609272,
-0.0389981307,
-0.0039395639,
-0.0239027645,
0.0249806046,
-0.041994255,
0.0063171643,
0.0992440209,
0.0261485539,
-0.0559921563,
0.0176472049,
-0.0052535753,
-0.0057444302,
-0.0060904785,
-0.0018559288,
-0.0574832447,
-0.0190510042,
-0.0088093868,
0.0043905801,
-0.0033621921,
-0.043986313,
0.054941833,
-0.053527616,
0.0016625307,
0.0109893484,
-0.0568277873,
-0.0387312956,
-0.0814581886,
-0.0033077844,
-0.0447471514,
0.0203553177,
0.0024043468,
0.0224429611,
-0.0145593099,
-0.0127575723,
-0.0142274825,
-0.1190022677,
0.0106907543,
-0.0784016326,
0.0490053222,
0.0389078334,
0.0653980598,
-0.0232480038,
-0.0234931074,
0.0149161061,
-0.0131621435,
-0.0331103019,
-0.0155467596,
0.0736139938,
0.0015794919,
-0.0474547893,
-0.0285571031,
-0.0091101294,
-0.0108701866,
-0.0141338045,
-0.0452530421,
0.0524793454,
0.00987643,
0.0059564048,
-0.017934408,
-0.0029215107,
0.0071133142,
0.0489813164,
-0.0036847461,
0.0081776651,
-0.0030949784,
0.0117478995,
0.0447111577,
-0.0180194061,
-0.007107018,
0.036540404,
-0.0681989267,
-0.056595508,
-0.0503460541,
-0.0524533428,
0.0607251823,
-0.0145433145,
0.0040208921,
0.0272969827,
-0.0171685684,
-0.0174850952,
-0.0681867972,
0.0185456052,
0.0333190337,
0.0457406193,
-0.0149058504,
-0.0489555001,
0.0843700171,
0.0435879901,
-0.032008864,
0.036177136,
0.0231405944,
-0.0151081979,
-0.0280437451,
0.0158489533,
0.0090340525,
-0.0014667171,
-0.0039002059,
0.0082700299,
0.0403152034,
0.0450314283,
-0.0278652888,
-0.0394380987,
-0.0095916102,
-0.0076852441,
-0.0187095739,
0.0233248696,
-0.0274380371,
-0.0099811787,
-0.0428703614,
0.0749972165,
0.0004242517,
-0.0409693047,
0.0296445694,
0.0533615947,
0.0017799909,
-0.0704838932,
-0.0162449777,
-0.0270352978,
-0.0023515776,
-0.0298322737,
0.02646764,
-0.0077363844,
0.0103554837,
0.0783472657,
-0.0031434915,
-0.0105195725,
0.0347374007,
-0.0315596685,
-0.0423450731,
-0.0249243267,
0.0492827594,
-0.0312681869,
0.0152559131,
0.0358358696,
-0.024145361,
0.0043617748,
0.000627318,
0.0410377234,
0.0190626718,
-0.0717041492,
-0.0333192833,
-0.0136693539,
0.0790564865,
-0.0125083057,
0.0519128963,
0.0077650137,
-0.0006709495,
-0.0452814661,
0.0207492691,
0.0433604158,
0.0278944429,
0.0806597471,
0.0095065376,
-0.0160590522,
-0.0004671908,
-0.0118948082,
-0.0599654466,
0.0117726149,
0.0144223254,
-0.0097068725,
0.0035783972,
0.0041110096,
0.1078237593,
-0.0310027711,
0.0700083002,
-0.0183671117,
-0.054179091,
-0.0338837877,
-0.0041278065,
-0.009687582,
-0.0206496138,
-0.0659369677,
-0.0161232799,
-0.0311374981,
-0.0637306198,
0.0260341633,
-0.0241606608,
-0.0448217019,
0.0302000288,
0.0290535372,
0.0127278678,
0.0116697522,
0.0148150977,
0.0087473253,
0.0142059578,
-0.0028993569,
-0.0766641498,
0.0441931449,
-5.588628915e-33,
-0.0392314307,
-0.0129421419,
0.0152110551,
-0.0701853782,
-0.0211192202,
0.0355807431,
-0.022595074,
-0.0203392208,
-0.0022000391,
0.0312084313,
-0.0022717279,
-0.0230795145,
0.0171146579,
0.0177290421,
0.0243161283,
-0.0362960435,
0.0163752679,
0.0177887492,
0.0046924073,
0.0258557722,
0.0114942072,
0.0649894029,
0.0995301604,
-0.0992965251,
0.0135369198,
0.0601254441,
0.011870387,
-0.0107240705,
0.0318666473,
0.0619696975,
-0.0366183445,
0.020989459,
0.0174125358,
-0.0437932424,
0.0062765973,
-0.0214257967,
-0.10437648,
0.0077966731,
-0.025063999,
-0.004214508,
-0.035565313,
-0.0462835282,
0.0467259698,
-0.0118599487,
-0.0371307358,
0.0116056781,
0.0227465909,
-0.0307016075,
-0.0139655033,
-0.0382213816,
-0.0264810827,
0.0533550531,
0.0148173822,
0.0062796259,
0.0437343009,
-0.0092982007,
-0.0266672187,
0.015578744,
-0.0183521789,
0.0082398653,
0.0034172845,
0.0491718352,
0.0221319422,
-0.046641089,
-0.0304888394,
0.0393905714,
0.0360460468,
-0.0305150077,
0.0053956578,
0.0305675529,
-0.0309131555,
0.0230800938,
0.0425899513,
0.0413190462,
0.012868369,
-0.0332741216,
-0.0849914104,
0.1085451245,
-0.0362707861,
0.0484574474,
-0.0207886975,
-0.0159583278,
0.0007290867,
-0.0045765401,
-0.0186478458,
-0.0294298232,
-0.0137947081,
-0.052648332,
0.0082394527,
-0.0007995728,
-0.0212304592,
0.0616198629,
0.0136141935,
-0.0231881961,
-0.0355624817,
-0.0026236516,
0.0645078719,
0.0163243618,
-0.0254553296,
-0.0087733315,
-0.0283537563,
-0.0369612351,
0.041311156,
-0.0094570834,
0.0579504892,
0.0258408803,
0.0134122446,
-0.0438065194,
-0.0375830568,
-0.0133317523,
0.0060921996,
-0.0289166141,
-0.0402384624,
0.0377618745,
0.0020036313,
0.013303712,
0.0053489949,
-0.0084091239,
0.0610029921,
-0.0012419539,
-0.0230244361,
-0.0402472839,
0.0613585748,
0.0208081808,
-0.0350737609,
0.0052030399,
-0.0408098064,
0.0012192603,
0.0541269518,
-0.0269553773,
-0.0205466822,
-0.0310256891,
2.778e-7,
0.1006987169,
0.0176966153,
0.0111744702,
-0.0166305285,
-0.009286481,
-0.0112697491,
0.0088356612,
0.0447311103,
-0.0282473881,
-0.0154566895,
0.0425695069,
-0.0426074304,
0.0229037721,
0.0413660854,
-0.0647437125,
-0.01121643,
-0.0799965262,
-0.0314555354,
-0.0065319869,
-0.0144315269,
-0.0116215814,
0.0649181306,
-0.0471663177,
-0.0309420936,
-0.0086806789,
0.0212996099,
0.0329082981,
-0.032502722,
-0.0303383898,
0.0416471101,
-0.0017556866,
0.0206162166,
0.036871966,
0.0218401309,
-0.0376313813,
-0.002176519,
0.0666217133,
0.06541612,
-0.0473607928,
0.0256793164,
0.0317592286,
-0.0076760827,
0.0271778349,
-0.0317355283,
0.027716808,
-0.0347332731,
-0.0322674923,
-0.0070548118,
-0.0266400799,
0.0655955374,
0.0812790245,
-0.0316460952,
-0.0415272973,
0.0395574383,
0.0621343106,
0.0470045917,
-0.0832539797,
-0.0625303537,
-0.0123673491,
0.0529755317,
-0.0001454617,
-0.0295968316,
0.0528969131,
-0.0243955329,
-0.0303796139,
-0.0489865951,
0.0021048416,
2.551787932e-34,
0.0249041524,
0.0122468425,
-0.0134702846,
0.036057841,
0.0354733616,
-0.0460585952,
-0.0022779957,
0.0036307916,
-0.0399761647,
-0.0152461482,
-0.004371874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11266v1 | Emulating Human Cognitive Processes for Expert-Level Medical Question-Answering with Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T13:39:26 | 2023-10-17T13:39:26 | Khushboo Verma, Marina Moore, Stephanie Wottrich, Karla Robles López, Nishant Aggarwal, Zeel Bhatt, Aagamjit Singh, Bradford Unroe, Salah Basheer, Nitish Sachdeva, Prinka Arora, Harmanjeet Kaur, Tanupreet Kaur, Tevon Hood, Anahi Marquez, Tushar Varshney, Nanfu Deng, Azaan Ramani, Pawanraj Ishwara, Maimoona Saeed, Tatiana López Velarde Peña, Bryan Barksdale, Sushovan Guha, Satwant Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.NE | In response to the pressing need for advanced clinical problem-solving tools
in healthcare, we introduce BooksMed, a novel framework based on a Large
Language Model (LLM). BooksMed uniquely emulates human cognitive processes to
deliver evidence-based and reliable responses, utilizing the GRADE (Grading of
Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations) framework to
effectively quantify evidence strength. For clinical decision-making to be
appropriately assessed, an evaluation metric that is clinically aligned and
validated is required. As a solution, we present ExpertMedQA, a multispecialty
clinical benchmark comprised of open-ended, expert-level clinical questions,
and validated by a diverse group of medical professionals. By demanding an
in-depth understanding and critical appraisal of up-to-date clinical
literature, ExpertMedQA rigorously evaluates LLM performance. BooksMed
outperforms existing state-of-the-art models Med-PaLM 2, Almanac, and ChatGPT
in a variety of medical scenarios. Therefore, a framework that mimics human
cognitive stages could be a useful tool for providing reliable and
evidence-based responses to clinical inquiries. | [
0.0823966786,
0.0059091705,
0.0019936988,
-0.0237694681,
-0.018169567,
0.015031185,
0.0111787245,
0.0438997895,
0.0272929873,
-0.0030054329,
-0.0209688712,
-0.0378548764,
-0.0131321941,
0.0482904762,
0.0099909278,
-0.0150287608,
-0.0014355551,
0.0054698079,
0.0964276567,
-0.0080965487,
0.0093936184,
-0.0013348933,
-0.0465035103,
0.044629056,
0.0412067696,
-0.0249677636,
0.0402509235,
-0.0181648508,
0.0285414066,
-0.0825627819,
-0.0002086351,
0.0413280949,
-0.0140360333,
-0.0156895034,
0.0000020762,
-0.0760379955,
0.0138859535,
0.032461945,
-0.0237801038,
-0.0273954645,
0.0507987067,
0.0085197557,
0.0152836265,
0.0142442025,
-0.0359709263,
0.003716313,
0.0150561826,
0.0484396555,
0.0650321469,
0.0273057614,
-0.005967434,
-0.0008769492,
0.04545426,
-0.007169113,
0.0152017064,
-0.0406900421,
0.0182898268,
0.0711330548,
0.0815371126,
0.0129575646,
0.0450561121,
0.0187843088,
-0.0033034238,
0.0218864419,
0.0119105792,
0.0448954962,
-0.0114975814,
-0.0097942837,
0.0210435539,
0.0593995191,
0.0202065557,
0.0024151236,
0.0067836577,
0.0086895349,
0.0098216543,
0.0334301069,
-0.0683374256,
-0.0077220355,
-0.0260037221,
-0.019406803,
0.0146433273,
0.0185975693,
0.0309209153,
-0.0068295845,
0.0124448342,
0.0170017164,
0.0115303872,
-0.0157242902,
0.0346402079,
-0.0184364114,
-0.0001766958,
-0.0525463521,
0.0468781292,
0.0493729524,
-0.0640238747,
-0.0045738742,
0.0425946675,
-0.0030153566,
0.1104923189,
-0.0690588206,
0.0258304421,
0.0091842683,
-0.0011316461,
0.0342436396,
-0.0046382383,
0.0018832429,
-0.0245538,
0.00963833,
-0.0622034781,
0.0220150892,
-0.0636845231,
-0.0269744229,
-0.0110505559,
0.0078683384,
0.0049305866,
-0.0223055258,
-0.0686408579,
-0.0315247662,
-0.0130626718,
0.0090250736,
0.010114044,
0.052654583,
-0.0024698505,
-0.0078529529,
-0.0641199201,
0.0183439907,
-0.0365169719,
0.0225997586,
0.0117548741,
0.0011167696,
0.0396330431,
-0.0130358171,
-0.0220132731,
0.0092412783,
0.0447097719,
0.0476711988,
-0.0233357251,
0.027055122,
0.0285397265,
-0.0523300581,
-0.0386143178,
-0.048410967,
0.0109670451,
-0.0869942531,
0.0419621691,
0.0453401096,
-0.0002921569,
-0.0074764783,
0.01693758,
0.039627552,
-0.0511188768,
0.0243952628,
-0.0407497808,
0.0162156392,
0.038289424,
0.0351741463,
-0.0049256478,
-0.0136251207,
0.0100307362,
-0.018359594,
-0.0004346379,
-0.0150747178,
0.0117274597,
-0.0077284495,
-0.0060120588,
-0.0265588015,
-0.0162668563,
0.0576864704,
0.0078919586,
0.0943159983,
-0.0486896485,
0.0803685039,
-0.0251603685,
-0.0114988768,
0.0428007916,
0.0714600086,
-0.0235833712,
0.0238357577,
0.0068269325,
-0.0306272041,
0.0450613461,
-0.0044881217,
0.0133175217,
0.0306428503,
-0.0090999734,
-0.0127982842,
-0.0005513867,
0.0035103338,
-0.0278773829,
-0.018762704,
-0.0293126628,
0.0157383773,
-0.0374018475,
0.0138935819,
-0.0105061326,
-0.0537073836,
-0.002132871,
0.0471500456,
0.0046561346,
0.0006333369,
-0.0026798919,
-0.0522836037,
-0.0153372539,
0.0825317279,
0.0417229421,
-0.0211144872,
-0.0199838076,
-0.0228657462,
0.013714456,
0.0205563996,
0.021331124,
-0.0254220124,
-0.0124525623,
-0.0267648268,
-0.0077028517,
0.0108414125,
-0.013240438,
-0.0494830012,
-0.0010483541,
0.01945257,
-0.0395864807,
-0.0429502092,
-0.0541168973,
0.026020743,
-0.0685381889,
-0.0041390467,
-0.0159484744,
-0.0513609163,
0.0259056203,
0.018156575,
-0.0176923405,
0.062034931,
0.0295299683,
-0.0252278857,
-0.0296178591,
-0.0094880704,
-0.0339335427,
0.004099139,
0.0187973324,
-0.026295973,
-0.0035834762,
-0.0281136464,
-0.0249013584,
-0.0400987454,
-0.0491984002,
-0.0450276025,
0.0381631628,
0.0179477632,
-0.0060357079,
0.0283055771,
-0.0185662936,
-0.0579296872,
0.0243215375,
-0.0121814413,
0.0267575346,
0.0192944016,
-0.048249457,
-0.0123316599,
-0.0144921932,
-0.0319936797,
0.0242879279,
0.002832301,
0.0221634805,
-0.0032425644,
0.0104656713,
-0.0606298558,
-0.0468599014,
-0.1086267084,
-0.0273559541,
0.0299887266,
0.0031922108,
0.0296603609,
-0.0255064964,
0.0014672971,
-0.0075825392,
-0.070258148,
0.0086847702,
0.0316823348,
0.0177614763,
0.0231828205,
0.0591424517,
0.0169287603,
-0.0502339713,
-0.0222859699,
-0.0212247875,
0.0326855741,
0.0223536417,
0.036646273,
-0.0102966521,
-0.0300293397,
-0.05611559,
0.007595757,
0.0137887411,
-0.0111515215,
0.0515647195,
-0.0008957323,
0.0230245311,
0.0597873554,
0.0285203699,
-0.0163224861,
0.0290921535,
-0.0070044822,
-0.0539418608,
0.0038616415,
-0.0343020819,
-0.0355567969,
-0.0046894052,
-0.0486979969,
0.0073790932,
0.0532145463,
0.0223639458,
0.0202148762,
-0.0185503364,
-0.009758831,
-0.0066733486,
-0.0061260974,
-0.0643138885,
-0.0153125506,
-0.0370334052,
0.0392058864,
-0.0130830808,
-0.0154337585,
0.1046150848,
-0.013144563,
0.0326747075,
-0.0804396048,
0.0161974393,
-0.0347677208,
0.0001136795,
-0.0101722227,
0.0277993046,
0.0002750719,
0.0208479222,
-0.016085254,
0.0099744368,
-0.005019512,
-0.0646541193,
0.0328581892,
-0.0395486318,
0.0214190297,
0.0265509244,
-0.0322851092,
-0.040621303,
0.0142665654,
-0.0490015931,
0.0032393786,
0.0262658373,
0.0077594016,
-0.0892497599,
0.0187691022,
0.0290186275,
0.0289331339,
0.0028743388,
-0.030200826,
0.0121614188,
0.0026179759,
0.0455303453,
0.0263809822,
0.0238868799,
-0.0032245088,
0.0491196103,
0.0976008847,
-0.0134453429,
-0.0105930502,
-0.00340035,
0.0064535579,
0.0198862422,
-0.0426846966,
-0.0093888529,
0.0398210883,
-0.0065903505,
-0.0569143705,
-0.0035296306,
0.107927084,
0.0477277562,
-0.0832504034,
0.0013544437,
-0.0653772652,
-0.0157719702,
0.0116896303,
0.0132467207,
-0.0421141759,
-0.037940871,
-0.0360277258,
0.0235457588,
-0.0159302596,
-0.0212896373,
0.0256434493,
-0.0376995467,
0.0072561079,
-0.0205196962,
-0.0172676835,
0.0038101978,
-0.0226648971,
0.014991302,
0.0295324735,
-0.0257846415,
0.0037245483,
0.0037056727,
0.0025654607,
0.0106325028,
-0.0634983033,
-0.0527958535,
0.0989255756,
-0.0066439067,
0.0756314024,
0.0376283713,
0.0339164659,
-0.0199484359,
-0.0389539748,
-0.0165939182,
-0.0260001309,
0.0066119386,
0.0023208947,
0.0433031358,
0.00865441,
0.0357284993,
-0.0776896253,
0.0208232701,
-0.0243686773,
-0.0227052663,
0.0284278598,
0.0903060362,
-0.0358146913,
-0.0241856184,
-0.0649361461,
0.0552005693,
0.0117836082,
0.056766022,
-0.0055272449,
-0.0142965913,
0.0043369979,
0.023456743,
0.0385883935,
0.0186965186,
-0.0469587371,
0.0213074256,
0.0311630592,
0.0436890237,
-0.0622227341,
0.0013162388,
0.0415327884,
-0.0172146894,
0.0081918389,
0.0450350009,
0.0254114885,
-0.0050622239,
-0.0293170456,
0.0496112034,
0.0474532805,
0.0298664868,
-0.0715178847,
-0.0304773748,
0.0554473586,
-0.0005231845,
-0.0101724546,
0.013458862,
0.0212280862,
0.0121214008,
-0.0038236356,
0.0509454049,
0.0221994221,
-0.0515263155,
-0.0182891395,
-0.0402883068,
0.0212032981,
-0.0091033364,
-0.0528860651,
-0.0372774005,
-0.0118699865,
0.0092740208,
0.0026204449,
-0.009085333,
-0.0241390429,
0.0496720858,
0.0002218238,
0.0456840508,
-0.0301145427,
-0.0670688525,
0.0363570675,
0.02362087,
0.0115261003,
-0.0165148973,
-0.0217407383,
0.0022071989,
-0.0003115533,
-0.0356121548,
0.0116876066,
-0.0021324323,
-0.0033901881,
0.0044218493,
-0.0281766932,
0.0024042071,
0.008014706,
-0.0549278483,
-0.0325378329,
-0.0258357301,
0.0403211378,
0.0142382085,
0.0140443621,
0.0291942619,
-0.0175977722,
-0.0232655536,
-0.0398099907,
-0.0188426878,
0.039675273,
-0.0044081821,
0.0957094431,
-0.0158299934,
-0.0069737211,
-0.0029390771,
0.0410712212,
-0.0590026528,
-0.0693620667,
-0.0004439385,
0.0345605314,
0.0156303942,
0.0240715854,
0.0152012622,
-0.0215982236,
0.0021106598,
-0.0372513309,
-0.0279791988,
-0.0127736721,
0.0146720698,
0.0561630726,
0.0300831851,
0.0022451091,
-0.0084462734,
0.0694142431,
-0.0085883411,
-0.0075579956,
-0.0067157638,
-0.0569675639,
-0.03132274,
-0.049365934,
-0.0114713786,
0.030580759,
-0.0524291173,
0.0102266036,
-0.0974496752,
-0.0239187349,
-0.0131788291,
0.0225326847,
-0.0113862045,
-0.0347048119,
0.0430173986,
0.0559921004,
-0.0005650813,
-0.0226897243,
-0.0293369219,
0.081857726,
-0.0524875969,
0.0028697026,
-0.0298681445,
-5.725795147e-33,
0.026855927,
-0.0393110365,
0.0457866192,
-0.0432127006,
0.0187072363,
0.0334679373,
-0.0467431583,
0.0172131788,
-0.016132988,
0.0555409007,
-0.0407348461,
-0.0263693649,
0.0029142185,
0.0069631143,
0.0091755157,
-0.0191449169,
0.0072529977,
-0.0152223557,
-0.0231528077,
0.0465502366,
-0.0231651552,
-0.0045787757,
0.0052275169,
-0.0649662986,
0.0241701324,
-0.0162480883,
0.0275653899,
-0.0011480764,
-0.0302541777,
0.0783980936,
-0.0468614437,
0.0490250848,
0.0539616197,
-0.0254361238,
-0.0038859972,
-0.0118001131,
-0.0468943939,
-0.0066397367,
0.0303085595,
-0.0736706108,
-0.0598868467,
0.0134882359,
0.0382813588,
0.0057012183,
-0.0196366757,
-0.0001990514,
0.0246053841,
-0.0557660051,
-0.0010431255,
-0.0430152379,
-0.0492059849,
0.0418629088,
0.005837481,
0.0026114134,
-0.0621342361,
0.0411645547,
-0.0537556112,
0.0115283318,
-0.0320041403,
-0.0116907554,
0.0208121743,
0.0090173269,
0.0127739478,
-0.02922263,
-0.032033544,
0.0707179829,
0.0023133466,
0.0032320225,
-0.0174877401,
0.009214079,
-0.0392105952,
0.0376482755,
0.0802080035,
0.0560943559,
0.0085210875,
-0.0029534218,
-0.0747122094,
0.0438569784,
-0.0374437682,
0.0786049515,
0.0611597486,
-0.0307701547,
-0.0491762534,
-0.0126913572,
-0.0385918915,
0.0405164324,
-0.0408311337,
-0.0281359591,
0.0295526534,
-0.01273687,
0.0117025804,
-0.0084980112,
0.0245117489,
0.0104010385,
0.0202851463,
-0.0242731441,
0.0166291464,
0.0241312571,
0.0051164757,
0.0268022027,
-0.0857652873,
0.0274830796,
0.0135078039,
-0.0172839556,
0.0383531377,
0.0215978883,
-0.0033184271,
-0.0441002436,
-0.0304317847,
-0.0125511447,
0.0035452035,
0.0119046904,
-0.0088712526,
0.0070162453,
0.0056539201,
0.0186346825,
-0.0012890245,
0.0369437411,
-0.0341918208,
-0.0163092054,
-0.024649974,
-0.0490497872,
0.0051944111,
0.0057450514,
-0.0423533916,
0.0361294374,
-0.0445534624,
0.0338035226,
0.0045777611,
-0.0275958441,
0.0012734565,
0.0234843772,
2.757e-7,
0.0910726264,
0.0529446267,
-0.0242909938,
-0.0485457629,
0.0655157045,
0.011623391,
-0.004895811,
0.002363279,
0.0625921264,
-0.0549854115,
0.0208810978,
0.0369511358,
0.0015028741,
0.0500945374,
-0.0447650887,
-0.0835950896,
-0.0802161172,
-0.0025644018,
-0.0352884978,
-0.043361228,
0.0765815526,
0.0239026155,
-0.0481269695,
-0.0373701826,
-0.0018666331,
-0.0137306359,
0.0417507626,
-0.0378456973,
0.0030720499,
0.0327108763,
0.0577026382,
-0.0083289621,
0.039119117,
0.0824576244,
-0.0053137261,
-0.0344249122,
0.0059352233,
0.0844293088,
-0.0317076854,
-0.0074423696,
0.0105182333,
-0.0222513918,
0.0562853068,
-0.0706936195,
0.0451747924,
-0.0672832429,
-0.0511295535,
-0.0080151362,
-0.0289574973,
-0.0340634622,
0.0643584356,
-0.042695336,
-0.0758232698,
0.0321070217,
0.0163195524,
0.0426311493,
-0.0172135811,
-0.0396751352,
-0.0112080006,
0.0450057425,
-0.0515589677,
-0.0572871454,
0.0029351451,
-0.0585548617,
-0.0341621377,
-0.072012499,
0.0357653089,
2.386992349e-34,
0.0195765384,
0.0292945728,
0.0273971427,
0.0063390103,
0.0486532897,
0.0135986833,
0.0127086304,
0.0274955127,
0.0327768885,
-0.0946029648,
-0.0109173041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11258v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11258v2 | Utilizing Weak Supervision To Generate Indonesian Conservation Dataset | 2023-10-17T13:23:18 | 2023-10-24T12:01:14 | Mega Fransiska, Diah Pitaloka, Saripudin, Satrio Putra, Lintang Sutawika | cs.CL | cs.CL | Weak supervision has emerged as a promising approach for rapid and
large-scale dataset creation in response to the increasing demand for
accelerated NLP development. By leveraging labeling functions, weak supervision
allows practitioners to generate datasets quickly by creating learned label
models that produce soft-labeled datasets. This paper aims to show how such an
approach can be utilized to build an Indonesian NLP dataset from conservation
news text. We construct two types of datasets: multi-class classification and
sentiment classification. We then provide baseline experiments using various
pretrained language models. These baseline results demonstrate test
performances of 59.79% accuracy and 55.72% F1-score for sentiment
classification, 66.87% F1-score-macro, 71.5% F1-score-micro, and 83.67% ROC-AUC
for multi-class classification. Additionally, we release the datasets and
labeling functions used in this work for further research and exploration. | [
0.0735834911,
0.0773054287,
-0.0015793223,
0.0081392424,
0.0124853915,
0.0364632346,
-0.0049487688,
0.0166625287,
0.0016084976,
-0.0647334531,
-0.0827352405,
-0.0033105703,
-0.008148306,
0.0150396135,
-0.0121947238,
-0.0590943135,
0.0530464686,
0.0008852993,
0.0687832236,
0.0006634739,
0.00642499,
0.018475851,
0.0019326388,
0.0087200478,
-0.0516348183,
-0.0126059521,
0.00043616,
0.003878627,
0.0025494387,
-0.0700654685,
0.0753926113,
0.0464793257,
0.0181632098,
0.0123295235,
0.0000018727,
-0.0261236448,
-0.00764263,
-0.0150953215,
0.0077222916,
0.0011599875,
0.0515080094,
-0.0641647801,
0.0221541785,
-0.003548265,
-0.0426221862,
-0.0793223754,
0.0333568379,
0.0515066721,
0.0592191145,
0.0621036775,
-0.0104300855,
-0.0459381305,
0.0041931537,
-0.0256688725,
-0.0171418265,
-0.0135836173,
0.0394876115,
-0.0128303273,
-0.0550461374,
0.0130401272,
-0.0006558041,
0.0245964304,
0.0169270113,
-0.0339362696,
0.0018385418,
-0.0059452835,
-0.0570352301,
-0.0526404232,
-0.0017733689,
0.0488419458,
-0.0065899957,
-0.0505216382,
-0.0130534526,
-0.0019947097,
-0.0047326814,
-0.0147249112,
-0.02477636,
0.0355246626,
-0.0171335489,
0.0284540653,
0.0512250587,
0.0484183095,
-0.0076120435,
0.0451560207,
0.0632097647,
-0.0125950594,
-0.0089237653,
-0.0216754135,
0.0092587387,
0.0384806991,
-0.0272557531,
0.0215242747,
0.008382868,
0.0052773086,
-0.008303863,
0.0267778374,
-0.0382778794,
-0.0358789116,
0.0525765046,
-0.064746581,
-0.0088526104,
-0.0434071608,
-0.0333753079,
0.0482210368,
-0.0097310944,
-0.0365408212,
0.0476619862,
0.0261800382,
0.0313419104,
-0.001261116,
-0.078539744,
-0.0490156487,
-0.0253137387,
0.0551450141,
0.0029261154,
0.03263947,
-0.0678108707,
-0.0210515633,
-0.0094851535,
-0.0120378183,
0.0335271098,
-0.0130231343,
-0.0348063,
0.0476424508,
-0.0070096557,
0.0154857961,
-0.0448063537,
0.0674562305,
-0.0083424784,
-0.0439977236,
0.0469362736,
-0.0066058231,
0.0060232342,
-0.0098794242,
-0.0036704473,
0.0450472124,
0.0149597926,
-0.0454487279,
-0.100437589,
-0.0285729952,
-0.0472975262,
-0.0278026331,
-0.0020537742,
-0.038101431,
0.0520482212,
-0.016409196,
0.0198541451,
0.0159426741,
0.012657241,
-0.00300218,
-0.013275939,
0.0744737685,
-0.0701416805,
-0.002689109,
0.0207434464,
-0.0092616826,
0.049303852,
0.0858256444,
-0.0247673839,
-0.0024488694,
0.0820190981,
-0.0120174848,
0.0188371949,
-0.0245730765,
0.0008915656,
0.0118833166,
-0.0019887404,
-0.0001975052,
0.0164188892,
-0.0234320313,
-0.0262758061,
0.0353684872,
0.0001024628,
0.0373056009,
0.0407478437,
-0.0093710339,
0.0217531864,
0.0353290886,
0.0163959879,
-0.0344021097,
0.0164330862,
-0.0339487046,
0.0168337692,
-0.0232846681,
-0.0440387428,
-0.0131632164,
-0.0437369049,
-0.0080808848,
-0.0296190847,
-0.0676419139,
0.010432452,
-0.0172404815,
-0.0151365576,
-0.0259617902,
0.0732718855,
0.0408664346,
0.0251663812,
-0.0146809435,
0.0645381883,
-0.0515226647,
-0.0032684614,
-0.0393453278,
0.0415649377,
0.011041265,
0.0036441691,
-0.0425642952,
-0.0065111662,
0.0014137134,
0.0353560597,
0.0272590723,
0.0788604394,
-0.0435775593,
-0.0169593506,
-0.0241769757,
-0.0020795334,
-0.0130065372,
0.0473389365,
-0.0028128079,
0.020051904,
0.0594959781,
0.0269257501,
-0.0118369637,
-0.0767743513,
0.0749167949,
0.0344756655,
-0.0217244718,
-0.000539823,
0.0096512735,
0.0307461191,
0.0495056584,
-0.0153421927,
-0.0167273376,
0.0459978729,
0.0001968826,
-0.0354482271,
-0.0222861227,
-0.0233360268,
-0.0590023547,
0.0375854336,
-0.0379367359,
-0.0437361933,
0.0373092592,
-0.0246206727,
-0.0327663124,
-0.0405206084,
0.031872537,
0.0296734013,
-0.047589317,
0.012826479,
-0.0303860735,
-0.0079267239,
-0.0425643586,
0.0628964007,
0.0443956256,
0.0264608525,
-0.0335527956,
-0.0309809837,
0.0420493782,
0.0202561952,
-0.0262523536,
0.0062642586,
-0.0353979394,
-0.0260606762,
0.0463090055,
0.0726805553,
-0.0549094155,
-0.031343475,
-0.0729551911,
-0.0116720302,
-0.0101696635,
0.0231806636,
0.0284891427,
-0.0203572921,
-0.0068738996,
0.0275232214,
0.0134024601,
-0.018552376,
-0.0331978165,
0.0367108658,
0.0362082757,
-0.0013925974,
0.0156590603,
-0.0165176932,
-0.0112010837,
-0.005445072,
0.0296703018,
0.0341047607,
-0.1136799008,
-0.0027927323,
0.047411114,
-0.0161825791,
-0.0382670425,
0.0103135863,
-0.0527374484,
0.0194051992,
-0.0090937028,
-0.0294493735,
0.0050588567,
0.0243530441,
0.0276423618,
-0.0013445707,
0.015851954,
-0.0327704996,
0.0024044637,
-0.0243767463,
-0.0530261323,
0.0068109781,
0.0392918698,
0.0095364684,
0.0409540348,
-0.0371342972,
-0.0243575368,
-0.0252580978,
-0.0166939329,
-0.0238403194,
-0.0381410047,
-0.0155267492,
0.000055483,
0.0115268799,
0.0091264322,
-0.0202220958,
-0.0240535978,
0.0324131623,
0.0440881141,
0.0155179463,
-0.0525352322,
0.0062042046,
-0.0212295819,
0.0708071366,
-0.0223626662,
-0.007265294,
0.0225520805,
0.0140182953,
0.0024464913,
-0.0182669144,
-0.0151073597,
-0.0133703845,
-0.0348793641,
-0.0288539547,
0.0241177678,
-0.0281309802,
-0.0320240371,
-0.0056999875,
-0.0677077547,
0.0030736283,
0.0195157416,
0.0322373956,
0.0055684485,
0.0207164884,
0.0325251967,
0.017931303,
-0.0090915542,
-0.0123554962,
-0.0204564258,
0.005043915,
0.0204927176,
0.036435198,
-0.0519225113,
-0.0165681876,
-0.0049493844,
0.0187993404,
0.0451006591,
0.015003995,
0.0295353513,
0.0258942842,
0.0099340864,
0.003721633,
0.0290856492,
0.0103726145,
-0.0518382564,
0.0462266691,
-0.0378032774,
-0.0019820067,
0.0745490119,
0.054649245,
-0.0602746569,
0.0021182636,
-0.0235612039,
0.0473451614,
0.0420633666,
0.0100726224,
0.0076087117,
-0.0371363722,
-0.0212919135,
0.0144749349,
-0.0257404689,
-0.0381386019,
0.0272690617,
-0.1167631745,
-0.0181863401,
-0.0085185133,
-0.0759407505,
-0.0117386496,
-0.0606941395,
-0.017822057,
-0.0130342534,
-0.0383848697,
-0.0469534248,
0.0239111222,
0.0041573616,
0.0463496819,
-0.0374790318,
-0.0429552607,
0.0164036043,
-0.0063961931,
0.0406691507,
0.0439926796,
0.0439665765,
-0.0260827672,
0.0166704934,
0.0912773535,
-0.0458726399,
-0.0297886487,
-0.0249170698,
0.0534233898,
-0.0156193944,
-0.0456269421,
0.0298368149,
0.0387627371,
-0.066137366,
0.029430164,
0.0347822309,
0.04813198,
0.0069833831,
-0.0190183148,
-0.0171159692,
-0.0224547405,
0.0367585681,
0.0380625129,
0.0160219669,
-0.0665756762,
0.0107341819,
-0.0269213691,
-0.024634745,
-0.0486307517,
-0.0405206643,
0.0179397147,
-0.0849263296,
-0.068115592,
-0.0843100846,
-0.0471194424,
0.0833922103,
0.0450140797,
0.011734128,
-0.0172217097,
0.026321983,
-0.0092892302,
-0.0293326396,
0.0360074788,
-0.0336511917,
-0.0311627463,
-0.0438285358,
-0.0665324181,
0.0859245285,
0.0634981915,
0.0024367576,
0.011259459,
-0.0131030362,
-0.0571047999,
0.0461589098,
0.0422244072,
0.005433246,
-0.0346955732,
0.0314964652,
-0.0369876474,
0.0097576529,
0.1237716004,
-0.0481445417,
-0.0307175796,
0.0181544889,
0.0179884396,
0.0027401149,
0.021390276,
-0.0320429802,
0.0380658954,
0.0435367711,
0.0323808342,
-0.0214594621,
0.0089359861,
0.0169415101,
0.0099566393,
0.0678526461,
-0.0340234339,
-0.0347005948,
-0.0356714763,
-0.0170718525,
0.005224769,
-0.0456160717,
-0.0218514465,
0.0130649284,
0.034064047,
0.0215507112,
-0.0600190274,
0.0312276538,
-0.0024163546,
0.0422983579,
-0.0357214212,
0.0076812143,
0.0596526749,
0.0227577593,
-0.0259448756,
0.0092639644,
-0.0244405847,
0.0086608492,
0.0013950805,
-0.0290024076,
-0.0063400925,
0.004395809,
0.0401478335,
0.0308627542,
0.0068286071,
-0.0073563973,
-0.0012939424,
0.0342494547,
-0.041759003,
0.0442322083,
0.024840273,
-0.0506490842,
-0.0113593061,
-0.0417423882,
-0.0373892449,
-0.0142783094,
0.0043240455,
0.0072634504,
-0.0444439016,
0.0393227823,
0.0026759992,
-0.0509216301,
0.0291291419,
0.0452333987,
0.0030025893,
0.0493809693,
0.0250583421,
0.0050709839,
-0.0061733555,
0.0426217094,
0.0731563419,
-0.0116286669,
0.0419768021,
0.0061894688,
-0.008243789,
-0.0424904823,
0.0143831633,
-0.0310883373,
0.0045635384,
0.0520521775,
0.0156277865,
0.0354779176,
0.0160734355,
0.0050738575,
-0.051021114,
-0.0350115448,
0.0114717828,
0.0146104023,
-0.0308650881,
-6.047779212e-33,
-0.0267391261,
-0.009079827,
-0.0546678379,
-0.0044971649,
0.0339539647,
0.0180897582,
0.033907298,
0.0185613371,
-0.0133024585,
0.0398763828,
-0.0123027749,
0.0049205781,
0.0082554081,
0.0495999604,
0.0457501151,
-0.0115365181,
0.0189090837,
-0.0149277803,
0.0265675876,
0.0145139024,
0.0361286141,
0.04510938,
0.0669506714,
-0.141628921,
0.0132212276,
0.0275223684,
-0.0312243626,
-0.0041276081,
-0.0139750401,
0.0404182784,
-0.0172898695,
0.0662834942,
0.0415948778,
-0.024656957,
-0.0070075509,
0.0179995708,
-0.0948943794,
-0.019499708,
-0.0114324894,
0.0219986103,
0.003966412,
0.0077665453,
0.0326748081,
0.0006907725,
0.0215866212,
0.0229548253,
0.0319119208,
-0.0413836166,
-0.0258800294,
-0.0881207958,
-0.0431243069,
0.0136097651,
0.0033548693,
0.0208484624,
-0.00815784,
0.0347569175,
-0.0221351497,
0.0425016806,
-0.0504532531,
0.0222076438,
0.0039294632,
0.0446244553,
-0.038865719,
0.0119169895,
0.0176021103,
0.0327535085,
-0.0084707327,
0.0557531826,
0.0404820815,
0.0044602593,
0.0262470022,
0.0124798156,
0.0137696434,
0.0408866443,
0.0409217142,
-0.0467602238,
-0.0562751703,
-0.0042710193,
0.011784534,
-0.022322258,
0.0224754997,
-0.0020667119,
-0.0345752276,
-0.0116914846,
-0.0272117388,
-0.0046063475,
-0.0209915694,
0.0396807007,
0.0174531117,
0.036236573,
-0.0539137609,
0.0161052998,
-0.0102148736,
-0.0572421215,
-0.0530867428,
-0.0219169892,
-0.0097698588,
0.0552381165,
-0.0163504649,
-0.0388832018,
-0.0538960285,
-0.0708156079,
0.00654063,
0.0365049168,
0.0201092977,
-0.0225975644,
0.1201758161,
-0.0023156572,
-0.0915143639,
0.001428745,
0.0090977168,
0.0121130636,
0.0176584609,
0.0170683842,
-0.0108333426,
-0.0230505615,
0.0057289139,
0.039371267,
0.0685277581,
0.0073983441,
0.0102810524,
-0.0271051917,
-0.0356996208,
-0.0085144881,
-0.0082305046,
-0.0233718175,
-0.014940531,
0.0128803393,
0.0012887816,
-0.0499489307,
0.0145944022,
-0.0014823114,
2.65e-7,
0.0441740192,
0.0462976843,
-0.0139062162,
-0.0454753414,
0.0008031782,
0.0440439619,
-0.008771345,
-0.0019129739,
-0.040817257,
-0.0344826579,
0.0221295059,
-0.0263583474,
0.0484525822,
0.0045856102,
-0.1103186756,
-0.0114525435,
-0.0444373712,
-0.0250790995,
-0.0525171049,
0.0305291936,
0.0458485447,
0.1007453948,
0.0069418899,
-0.0073795551,
-0.0103928233,
-0.0300114956,
0.0542943254,
-0.0189173874,
-0.0319694467,
0.0311507247,
0.0542532392,
0.0490149707,
-0.0025992815,
-0.0071717468,
-0.0390918143,
-0.0164381042,
0.004545013,
0.0324327089,
0.0031307568,
-0.0250886343,
0.0428141579,
0.0402267799,
-0.0180216264,
0.0116811562,
0.0809307843,
-0.0609426647,
-0.0415486582,
-0.0234811492,
0.0147859529,
0.0266048275,
0.001779895,
-0.0474768393,
0.0112700583,
0.0336668789,
0.0048279469,
-0.0030328173,
-0.07330437,
-0.0665906966,
0.0036560514,
0.0238702018,
0.0015153163,
-0.003546437,
-0.0089171641,
0.0486638695,
0.0148156118,
-0.061564371,
0.0376129411,
2.194416757e-34,
0.0336144045,
0.0046318979,
-0.014727843,
-0.025851123,
0.0242230333,
-0.0056221387,
0.0021845347,
0.0029797927,
-0.0088176699,
-0.0087667806,
0.0389156006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11252v1 | Revealing the Unwritten: Visual Investigation of Beam Search Trees to Address Language Model Prompting Challenges | 2023-10-17T13:20:16 | 2023-10-17T13:20:16 | Thilo Spinner, Rebecca Kehlbeck, Rita Sevastjanova, Tobias Stähle, Daniel A. Keim, Oliver Deussen, Andreas Spitz, Mennatallah El-Assady | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, H.5.2; I.2.7 | The growing popularity of generative language models has amplified interest
in interactive methods to guide model outputs. Prompt refinement is considered
one of the most effective means to influence output among these methods. We
identify several challenges associated with prompting large language models,
categorized into data- and model-specific, linguistic, and socio-linguistic
challenges. A comprehensive examination of model outputs, including runner-up
candidates and their corresponding probabilities, is needed to address these
issues. The beam search tree, the prevalent algorithm to sample model outputs,
can inherently supply this information. Consequently, we introduce an
interactive visual method for investigating the beam search tree, facilitating
analysis of the decisions made by the model during generation. We
quantitatively show the value of exposing the beam search tree and present five
detailed analysis scenarios addressing the identified challenges. Our
methodology validates existing results and offers additional insights. | [
0.0203681067,
0.0593075491,
-0.0356320292,
0.0173943415,
-0.0273658559,
-0.0302207377,
-0.0004776005,
0.0112150665,
-0.0357984193,
0.0142441243,
-0.0026454381,
-0.0245601386,
0.0202344209,
0.0724389404,
0.0086205788,
-0.1060996056,
0.0403627604,
-0.038880799,
0.010595575,
-0.0072241612,
0.0072405431,
0.032475099,
0.0090024536,
0.0423348695,
-0.030728139,
-0.0521806888,
-0.0280652549,
0.0229183547,
0.006400269,
-0.0447844341,
-0.0624364018,
0.0653469041,
-0.0157109946,
0.0610477924,
0.0000022038,
-0.0409959592,
-0.0037509135,
-0.0032520462,
-0.0523884408,
0.0547490679,
0.0692707002,
0.0203495864,
0.0040975171,
0.0163255818,
-0.0331756845,
-0.0183372945,
0.0730342492,
-0.0199991483,
0.0351820923,
-0.0163552482,
0.0046215891,
0.0101820631,
-0.0290269703,
-0.0202619471,
0.0042342171,
-0.0116739515,
-0.0174891129,
-0.0125159929,
0.0506470762,
0.0385923609,
-0.0333912186,
0.057152871,
0.0338530019,
-0.0800498575,
0.0214772169,
0.029205719,
-0.0157815237,
-0.0783399194,
-0.0099144168,
0.04715259,
-0.0021737975,
-0.036784526,
-0.0315086022,
-0.0518814325,
-0.0129035553,
0.0473990627,
-0.059714064,
0.0144330896,
-0.0025849596,
0.0013355822,
0.0152336694,
0.0115431715,
0.0242988728,
-0.0216996279,
-0.0174667146,
0.0566518828,
0.0488776565,
0.0057054469,
-0.0299004,
0.0173534565,
0.0127029698,
-0.0837602019,
0.0003492311,
0.0075786081,
-0.0785098523,
0.0323073827,
0.0064171515,
-0.0169791989,
0.0150164403,
-0.0159341823,
0.0808873624,
0.0169480927,
-0.0074688229,
-0.0031976246,
0.0125987446,
0.0234643146,
0.0086597838,
-0.0310999751,
-0.0392966419,
0.0086397277,
-0.0011727294,
-0.0310214013,
-0.0657739639,
-0.0760720223,
-0.0624423735,
-0.0100093959,
-0.0282677617,
0.0273651369,
0.002237051,
-0.0220709145,
0.0106594916,
-0.0143482191,
-0.0267432295,
0.0137513336,
0.0016593364,
0.023513915,
-0.0458654352,
-0.0346580744,
0.0048558093,
-0.071399264,
-0.0147487912,
0.0205931868,
-0.0163351782,
-0.0023676627,
-0.0564151891,
0.0271864254,
0.0099615697,
-0.0171202291,
0.0081568435,
-0.0077569261,
-0.0440348387,
0.0109225223,
0.0265663993,
-0.0506120138,
0.0003930473,
0.0173003208,
0.0059987186,
-0.0003005162,
-0.0040829154,
0.0054936986,
0.019634895,
0.0331106521,
-0.0506377853,
0.0319850557,
0.0091962013,
-0.0034253632,
0.003790387,
0.0460128188,
0.0114664827,
0.0380092934,
0.0393677652,
-0.0470343605,
0.050966531,
0.0733495727,
-0.0077427789,
0.0251900516,
-0.0422118455,
-0.0324139893,
-0.0246276613,
0.0248729382,
0.0125640426,
0.0044616545,
-0.0219142921,
0.0283430014,
0.0202217456,
0.0331974253,
0.0609248728,
-0.0127750365,
0.0525464043,
0.0145051973,
0.0020867495,
0.016713189,
0.0095435018,
0.0160019994,
-0.0469682738,
0.0143344318,
-0.0485055037,
0.0514675081,
-0.0051174201,
-0.0128711173,
-0.0237635523,
0.0504991747,
0.0073731956,
0.0105613144,
0.0496313535,
0.0764993429,
0.0005760458,
0.0338087007,
0.0661004037,
-0.0680743307,
-0.0018020453,
-0.0466990583,
0.0359557308,
0.0800805837,
0.0703557134,
0.0170308407,
0.0079254024,
0.0474753045,
-0.0246991888,
0.0609411336,
0.0673499927,
-0.0253084246,
-0.0096176332,
-0.0182899628,
-0.0460033901,
0.0082787052,
0.0103218155,
0.0618871599,
0.0046680379,
-0.0342430919,
0.0056124278,
-0.0516750477,
-0.0629561096,
0.0311053228,
-0.0389445871,
0.0444690585,
0.0018039118,
-0.015803691,
0.0126030147,
0.0421782434,
-0.0207404085,
0.0325899944,
0.0237789061,
0.0152028035,
0.0221007764,
0.0263902601,
-0.029694913,
-0.0013761488,
0.001981301,
-0.0265089702,
0.0013501494,
-0.0434534885,
-0.0207817182,
-0.0337576568,
0.0231111236,
-0.0775145143,
0.0275742114,
-0.0187338889,
0.0436381884,
-0.0422123857,
-0.0140862279,
-0.0356906056,
0.0785418674,
0.0095790373,
0.0120507497,
0.0292651057,
0.0243229717,
0.0205402505,
-0.0452173054,
-0.011849816,
0.0563108437,
-0.0002669151,
-0.0317975543,
0.032249216,
0.0344511159,
-0.0276527666,
0.0116646029,
-0.0740462914,
-0.0573959462,
-0.0112979338,
0.0055631325,
0.0151468469,
0.0219550319,
-0.0474057943,
-0.0107191261,
0.0035602073,
-0.0050403699,
0.0191614572,
0.0289542265,
0.024066044,
-0.0314379185,
-0.0293221399,
-0.0471442342,
-0.0309288874,
0.0028396773,
0.0508189201,
0.0598957613,
-0.0258281697,
-0.0633959845,
0.0395491831,
-0.0154084479,
-0.0265988242,
0.0144395838,
0.0217254888,
0.0524853766,
-0.0299433507,
0.0694765821,
-0.0138749536,
0.0049965861,
0.0895168409,
0.0598884262,
-0.0199274067,
-0.0619260035,
-0.0216475334,
-0.0205025505,
0.0460929647,
0.0233183317,
-0.0699745938,
0.0238176174,
0.0434887968,
-0.0025713034,
-0.0023693382,
-0.0290979259,
0.0189875066,
-0.0330269523,
-0.018684959,
-0.0570306554,
-0.0444000997,
-0.0238498989,
0.0845248029,
-0.0124028791,
-0.0570034981,
0.0510854423,
-0.0549331233,
0.0045426143,
-0.0271742437,
-0.0053787003,
-0.0234534871,
0.0885042027,
-0.0107473964,
0.0124444496,
0.017406188,
-0.0265912265,
-0.0358513892,
0.0324907415,
0.0269457716,
-0.0119176218,
0.0149371242,
-0.0506649576,
-0.0333966166,
-0.0042775371,
-0.00258076,
-0.0433972627,
-0.0393678695,
0.0033413845,
0.0036538963,
0.0748039261,
-0.0277278367,
0.0021881475,
0.0228558369,
0.0273631793,
0.028576754,
-0.0123211751,
-0.0103197377,
-0.0176290218,
0.0351654626,
0.0276095383,
-0.0064138039,
0.0325118229,
-0.0491737761,
-0.0045679389,
0.0284632407,
0.01369638,
0.0389614329,
-0.0462788865,
0.0048380219,
0.0587298535,
0.0011458822,
-0.0411469899,
0.0140822027,
0.0417379849,
-0.0382654704,
0.0132967895,
0.0870796219,
0.0432546996,
-0.0213750266,
0.0497985743,
-0.0499531589,
0.0748127773,
0.0294366293,
0.0393935665,
-0.0975141451,
0.026914224,
0.0190480985,
0.0183615405,
-0.0096721668,
0.0015495477,
-0.0247519333,
-0.1353064179,
0.0783387646,
0.000679442,
-0.0051189791,
0.0221552048,
-0.0180280991,
-0.0098204333,
0.0404671766,
-0.0162551086,
0.0272783451,
-0.0261265803,
0.0273637231,
0.004025477,
-0.0071092886,
-0.058430884,
-0.0047770618,
-0.0279226881,
0.0071434947,
0.0563048609,
0.0434776545,
0.0131294429,
-0.0097261015,
0.003090567,
0.0011320786,
0.0439241268,
-0.0370746031,
0.0173261035,
0.0684888735,
-0.0161711443,
-0.0366337597,
-0.0184904076,
0.0577997118,
-0.0391043425,
-0.0074623721,
0.0556093454,
-0.0372427739,
-0.034758009,
-0.0239350349,
0.0098036723,
0.0055671656,
0.0415723436,
0.0891524777,
-0.0346338451,
-0.0125127155,
-0.0621107109,
0.0457448512,
-0.0204348341,
-0.0684458017,
0.0000984082,
-0.0196263772,
-0.0114069916,
-0.0391630158,
-0.0211786255,
0.0337076336,
0.0409206338,
0.0260095634,
-0.0290430877,
-0.0598855615,
-0.0338794924,
0.0113023333,
0.0523134284,
-0.0024211509,
0.0008064375,
-0.0060387454,
-0.0251349974,
0.0108246552,
-0.0431660563,
-0.0194758978,
0.0629319176,
-0.00531526,
-0.055453077,
0.0143279377,
0.0059104264,
0.0349914171,
-0.0137414364,
-0.0133362515,
-0.0669501349,
0.0404578671,
0.0273579583,
0.0084473714,
-0.0225009974,
-0.0272653364,
-0.0276625454,
-0.0086306613,
-0.0087426417,
-0.0009668059,
0.0391832888,
-0.0136982817,
0.0340353847,
-0.0253208801,
-0.0498492382,
0.0137834605,
0.0320978314,
0.0502646863,
-0.0558756813,
-0.068282783,
-0.0802934617,
-0.0049414625,
-0.06570068,
-0.0169457663,
-0.0298535489,
0.0242236815,
0.0132783074,
-0.0388374962,
0.0138435196,
0.0305096731,
-0.0316407904,
0.0316333137,
-0.0753838718,
0.0357782245,
0.0386677831,
0.0091675362,
0.0310440604,
0.0098381611,
0.0297436863,
0.0301303547,
-0.0289932676,
0.0323590189,
0.022883784,
0.0382462926,
-0.0016187329,
-0.0085611818,
0.0100094089,
0.0290587191,
-0.0370095745,
-0.0692740828,
-0.0107346205,
0.0557087809,
0.0462637432,
0.0194785371,
0.0814437196,
-0.0367344059,
-0.0043251608,
0.0043068002,
0.012260451,
0.033479616,
-0.07107912,
0.0007831485,
0.0248467475,
-0.0428958386,
-0.0679260939,
0.0434370935,
0.0012817839,
0.0141722094,
-0.0290341713,
-0.003541562,
-0.0082728816,
-0.0334255882,
0.0348413251,
-0.0197704826,
-0.020744117,
-0.0097580003,
-0.1048073024,
-0.0485708155,
-0.007200365,
0.0236952398,
-0.0238216538,
-0.0168339368,
0.0495225526,
0.0640599951,
-0.0152670415,
-0.0060106632,
-0.017902514,
-0.0131238699,
-0.027744025,
-0.024236422,
-0.0415881351,
-6.573930851e-33,
-0.0514948294,
-0.0515134409,
0.0172844082,
-0.0083279982,
-0.0140560195,
-0.0293445829,
-0.0708830208,
0.0278286561,
-0.0078492882,
0.0038622594,
-0.021663731,
0.0009508612,
0.0098031536,
0.0158100445,
0.0282770675,
0.043865703,
0.0586763695,
0.0103252409,
-0.0487375185,
0.0198912304,
0.03071847,
-0.0021851964,
0.0205195751,
-0.0399645418,
0.0391362496,
0.0085690571,
-0.0365671255,
-0.0028293901,
-0.0292407274,
0.0306058377,
-0.0229775403,
0.0463844389,
-0.001047663,
-0.057218615,
-0.0649008602,
-0.0120867416,
-0.0074952473,
-0.0438896492,
0.009505868,
0.0026568049,
-0.0550312363,
-0.0241874605,
-0.0013904452,
-0.0007225406,
-0.0333044417,
0.0035234778,
0.0201795548,
-0.0003669864,
-0.0517090298,
-0.0021658011,
-0.064679265,
0.0284655727,
-0.0158780813,
0.0076361266,
-0.0032170953,
0.07170555,
0.0052308738,
-0.0107297441,
-0.005296194,
0.0750629753,
0.0918570384,
0.0378560461,
0.0942460597,
0.0272536762,
0.0070324298,
0.0444665998,
0.0489158817,
-0.0222368725,
0.0256844647,
-0.0146973263,
0.0447812378,
0.0566794574,
0.0687225685,
0.0099625932,
-0.0004090937,
0.0025438773,
0.0021095716,
0.0118243396,
-0.0116104567,
0.0200596582,
0.0170496721,
0.0188892968,
-0.0331354588,
-0.0469259024,
-0.036335025,
-0.0784503743,
-0.0242024828,
-0.0212690718,
0.0287011508,
-0.0301200207,
-0.0227279533,
-0.0067459377,
0.0094650201,
0.0135118095,
-0.0177694429,
0.0486911871,
-0.0395015851,
0.0545824356,
-0.0105610564,
0.0170787089,
0.0087896055,
0.0036709893,
0.0246637557,
-0.0016156523,
0.0049433289,
0.0300347954,
-0.0173556544,
0.013209573,
-0.0437821969,
0.0217198301,
-0.0149812382,
-0.0112062367,
-0.0047054961,
-0.0050064251,
0.0584593378,
-0.0214230902,
-0.0178585965,
0.0101201283,
0.0583021007,
0.0503840707,
-0.0233305246,
-0.0043141781,
-0.0372364335,
0.018033525,
-0.0005451915,
0.0108346818,
-0.0509788953,
-0.0086358963,
0.0664761141,
-0.0340629593,
-0.0330736488,
0.0189476218,
2.807e-7,
0.0707181916,
0.0563854761,
0.047698237,
0.0686384663,
0.0325966068,
-0.0123669216,
0.0065006251,
-0.028653834,
0.0308007225,
-0.0039491998,
-0.0118154418,
-0.0117370933,
0.0637809634,
0.0574177206,
-0.0638752356,
0.0419478305,
-0.1011833102,
0.0094856564,
-0.0677251741,
-0.0173171908,
0.0575948991,
0.0654257536,
-0.0229053181,
-0.0124842711,
-0.0173924267,
-0.0179713015,
0.0331986472,
-0.0263078306,
-0.0040271743,
0.0203110557,
0.001640252,
-0.0265209842,
-0.0033045528,
-0.0058137812,
-0.0428911746,
-0.0302844327,
-0.0164424051,
0.0073555983,
0.0048776721,
0.0133553287,
0.0255151689,
0.0105518857,
-0.0158082936,
-0.0656325296,
0.0417805947,
0.000706048,
0.0085716564,
-0.0060200049,
0.034573067,
-0.0095676454,
0.0153252762,
-0.0523853339,
0.0054944023,
0.0284103695,
-0.0099650789,
-0.0284432769,
-0.0374548845,
0.0015712809,
-0.0602080412,
-0.0393650234,
-0.0368680991,
-0.0271060262,
-0.0399726257,
0.0047435281,
-0.0197598115,
-0.018291356,
-0.0037907374,
2.965372074e-34,
0.0492704995,
0.0227854177,
0.0085792886,
0.0046147723,
0.0281194653,
-0.0055375621,
-0.0174011365,
0.0294083152,
0.0291907825,
-0.0623884574,
-0.0565404594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11248v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11248v2 | CrossCodeEval: A Diverse and Multilingual Benchmark for Cross-File Code Completion | 2023-10-17T13:18:01 | 2023-11-17T02:51:39 | Yangruibo Ding, Zijian Wang, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Hantian Ding, Ming Tan, Nihal Jain, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Ramesh Nallapati, Parminder Bhatia, Dan Roth, Bing Xiang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Code completion models have made significant progress in recent years, yet
current popular evaluation datasets, such as HumanEval and MBPP, predominantly
focus on code completion tasks within a single file. This over-simplified
setting falls short of representing the real-world software development
scenario where repositories span multiple files with numerous cross-file
dependencies, and accessing and understanding cross-file context is often
required to complete the code correctly.
To fill in this gap, we propose CrossCodeEval, a diverse and multilingual
code completion benchmark that necessitates an in-depth cross-file contextual
understanding to complete the code accurately. CrossCodeEval is built on a
diverse set of real-world, open-sourced, permissively-licensed repositories in
four popular programming languages: Python, Java, TypeScript, and C#. To create
examples that strictly require cross-file context for accurate completion, we
propose a straightforward yet efficient static-analysis-based approach to
pinpoint the use of cross-file context within the current file.
Extensive experiments on state-of-the-art code language models like CodeGen
and StarCoder demonstrate that CrossCodeEval is extremely challenging when the
relevant cross-file context is absent, and we see clear improvements when
adding these context into the prompt. However, despite such improvements, the
pinnacle of performance remains notably unattained even with the
highest-performing model, indicating that CrossCodeEval is also capable of
assessing model's capability in leveraging extensive context to make better
code completion. Finally, we benchmarked various methods in retrieving
cross-file context, and show that CrossCodeEval can also be used to measure the
capability of code retrievers. | [
-0.0036592993,
0.0927979574,
-0.0384082943,
0.0219133347,
-0.0214743484,
0.0193574596,
-0.0266758725,
0.0202877671,
0.0267664641,
0.0218112711,
-0.0338541009,
0.0292166043,
0.0455280095,
-0.0002446058,
0.0136986664,
-0.0083772363,
0.0429670028,
-0.01271086,
-0.0485285372,
0.0042933254,
-0.0446713977,
0.0305075739,
0.0199314672,
0.0822309181,
0.0051652486,
-0.0386158451,
0.0109273335,
0.0292434637,
-0.0126350224,
0.0191564839,
0.0267584361,
0.0271186884,
-0.0166527219,
0.0214860477,
0.0000024026,
-0.0361837447,
-0.0089669628,
0.0077042454,
0.008244996,
0.052458439,
-0.0141351661,
-0.0408942737,
0.020910209,
-0.0115913395,
0.0106936116,
-0.005686983,
0.0569716133,
-0.0626075938,
0.0088616638,
-0.0261031743,
0.023564782,
0.0405698977,
-0.0073100785,
-0.0065733539,
0.0756948143,
-0.0494455695,
-0.0223091375,
0.0505885892,
0.0633851662,
0.0193244517,
-0.0016326787,
0.0564559177,
0.0170343313,
0.0166079942,
0.0036452503,
0.0411012247,
-0.0325570703,
-0.0096645514,
0.0257683937,
0.043818038,
-0.0315378197,
-0.0074538202,
-0.0062670829,
-0.0258851517,
-0.0734231248,
-0.0139199691,
-0.0306101646,
0.0093442295,
-0.0251228195,
-0.0215236843,
-0.0014940783,
-0.0154012535,
0.0265562572,
-0.0022484497,
-0.0118831294,
0.0786386579,
-0.000229335,
0.0067884643,
0.0139409713,
0.0208698064,
0.0117332889,
-0.0534114391,
0.0164608769,
-0.01909432,
-0.0293138996,
0.0007361769,
0.0166737419,
-0.0184827335,
0.0746224225,
-0.0165288653,
-0.0397153795,
0.081935592,
-0.088597998,
0.0155922305,
-0.0235279389,
0.0707976595,
-0.0267478414,
-0.0610503778,
-0.0094442163,
-0.048033651,
-0.0353499204,
0.0105590429,
-0.0472062938,
0.0018653427,
-0.0307093039,
0.0393827781,
-0.0574337356,
0.0134719163,
-0.0155072547,
0.0670044273,
-0.020358555,
-0.0526017845,
-0.0456389859,
0.013567837,
0.0396355912,
-0.0191834383,
-0.0564869829,
-0.0384857096,
-0.0067067761,
-0.0398667194,
-0.0156805683,
-0.0339356214,
-0.0553300902,
-0.0674478337,
0.0457237661,
0.0625682399,
0.0429568887,
0.0065696617,
-0.0104476744,
-0.0365484245,
0.0073554697,
-0.0060829986,
-0.0622587018,
-0.1142023355,
-0.0404157639,
0.0719021708,
0.0046692942,
-0.0754199699,
-0.0164851826,
-0.0135334153,
-0.0195684526,
0.0550715104,
-0.0372538678,
0.0164543558,
-0.0015607281,
0.0256608948,
-0.0443942249,
0.0318185948,
-0.0182531215,
0.0302354749,
0.0343937203,
-0.0606930926,
0.0320654176,
0.0223699883,
-0.002445366,
-0.001279208,
0.0043071723,
0.0296793394,
0.0576286614,
-0.044201944,
0.0281812102,
0.0251870081,
-0.0079923589,
0.0111488113,
-0.0228609163,
0.0351543128,
0.0285776816,
0.002536475,
0.0675417036,
0.0514613502,
-0.0065303487,
0.0097567299,
-0.0410707891,
0.0740612149,
0.00323898,
0.0209454913,
0.0305299982,
0.032422673,
0.0111055179,
-0.0642343163,
0.0029416089,
-0.0245407782,
-0.0365902036,
0.0300314948,
0.0409287624,
-0.0285001472,
-0.0194416679,
0.0291577037,
0.0463043489,
-0.0763316378,
-0.0188551992,
-0.0022189007,
0.0416275524,
0.0574104786,
0.0561239421,
-0.0412950329,
-0.022377409,
-0.0010834078,
-0.0008368281,
-0.0536536798,
0.0196484216,
-0.0155695779,
0.0572322197,
-0.0489130095,
-0.037699271,
-0.055322174,
-0.0044071358,
0.0942918733,
0.0217542946,
-0.0078838505,
0.0160531737,
-0.0408267789,
0.0104158316,
0.025111096,
-0.0188466646,
0.0137603823,
0.0248172581,
0.0248186104,
0.0089758281,
-0.0137707498,
-0.0469905138,
-0.009283836,
0.0341829211,
-0.0138542065,
-0.0215347707,
-0.0058020647,
0.0035972036,
0.0275939945,
0.0079027275,
-0.0457054712,
-0.0227818117,
0.0250132661,
0.0177438334,
0.0032764485,
0.0223987158,
-0.0113442903,
0.0416917764,
0.0161147062,
0.0258678328,
-0.0272759143,
0.0262924433,
0.0046209404,
0.0281591285,
-0.0009044022,
0.0631923452,
0.0211497787,
0.0534899272,
0.0770286396,
0.0316301733,
-0.0554945916,
0.0303538498,
-0.0418806002,
0.0075561954,
0.0170524623,
0.0401119255,
-0.0012579049,
-0.0349694975,
-0.0667453483,
0.0280606747,
-0.010688914,
0.0166133828,
-0.0078693358,
0.0541305728,
0.003409744,
-0.0228435788,
0.0288240034,
-0.0106954817,
-0.0104105985,
0.0114477016,
0.0165393148,
-0.0180985089,
-0.0401902571,
-0.0491957515,
-0.0255729333,
0.0037623639,
0.0384970233,
-0.0496171191,
-0.0186779741,
-0.0326903239,
0.0608031191,
0.0106200809,
0.0078149885,
-0.0388746709,
-0.0176885575,
0.0235859733,
-0.0333295129,
0.0442190282,
0.0189358667,
-0.0453508571,
-0.0604208373,
0.0688132048,
-0.0227224082,
-0.0796758458,
0.0156265404,
0.0717490837,
-0.0811865851,
0.0216152277,
-0.0424855798,
0.0161665455,
0.0708126053,
-0.0197854266,
-0.0167327188,
-0.0473459065,
-0.0628058165,
-0.0170583595,
-0.0096931001,
-0.0251704231,
-0.018877307,
0.0248395521,
0.0763194412,
-0.0427297093,
-0.0951900482,
0.059108749,
-0.0867946148,
-0.0245682504,
0.0239704102,
-0.0159661472,
-0.0542932972,
0.0733098686,
-0.0155789545,
-0.0151469307,
-0.0060391845,
-0.051005248,
0.0026106178,
0.0220197886,
-0.0023442076,
-0.0031114968,
0.0498845465,
-0.0073379376,
0.0100325067,
-0.0057439054,
-0.008472112,
-0.0199923571,
0.0367098562,
-0.0130319642,
-0.0061609484,
0.0359894782,
-0.0140581038,
0.0503903516,
-0.0135022327,
0.0514892377,
0.0526831113,
0.0549232215,
-0.0515290834,
-0.011829189,
-0.050611373,
-0.0343805999,
-0.0702671483,
-0.013816582,
-0.0113052335,
-0.0239615962,
0.0252593998,
0.0802457929,
0.0310462508,
-0.0237516835,
0.0020447501,
0.0704745576,
-0.0184402317,
-0.0941689089,
0.058406122,
0.0482100174,
-0.0544035584,
-0.0194099359,
0.0436889976,
0.0441121124,
-0.0490174666,
-0.0024299494,
-0.0325727388,
0.0218161847,
0.0802725479,
0.0470973179,
-0.0864172503,
0.000113584,
0.0034677049,
0.0202821605,
0.0162277445,
-0.0062844898,
0.0147671886,
-0.0414017998,
0.0471254997,
0.0009264675,
-0.0252799131,
-0.0548621602,
-0.0145643447,
0.0135614183,
0.0107523827,
-0.053115312,
0.0057171183,
0.0254135914,
0.0136224004,
-0.0312685892,
-0.0111958329,
0.0479732715,
0.0724680051,
-0.0401142985,
-0.0148863858,
0.077750057,
0.0169920027,
0.0198930576,
-0.0130678322,
0.0047753891,
-0.0407701433,
-0.0080536753,
-0.0343607515,
0.0610447265,
0.0374473222,
-0.0218740962,
0.052985698,
-0.0223020352,
-0.029032087,
-0.037881922,
0.0240418985,
0.0644858778,
0.0049918708,
0.0039543128,
-0.0138498647,
0.0032748471,
-0.0003031328,
0.039825961,
0.0419018082,
0.0038220917,
-0.0379563831,
-0.075768292,
-0.006314504,
-0.0517714806,
0.0018159832,
-0.0024578515,
-0.0068711545,
-0.0385202914,
0.0141165676,
-0.0105215646,
0.0405244567,
0.0169415269,
-0.0055109197,
0.0185202137,
-0.0195726529,
-0.0252646189,
-0.0603557341,
0.0130706774,
0.0079976423,
0.0533733815,
-0.0095067834,
-0.0302454811,
-0.0072289784,
-0.0259089973,
-0.0241899695,
0.0107803959,
-0.0328596458,
-0.0271519814,
-0.0489283763,
0.0106720701,
0.0123912962,
0.0183970947,
-0.0325311385,
-0.0753466412,
-0.0149485432,
-0.0007921435,
-0.0303392131,
0.0149788065,
0.0439713188,
0.0067460467,
0.0223205127,
0.007654876,
-0.0606601946,
-0.023911275,
0.0254369341,
-0.00817669,
0.0003942635,
-0.0050775311,
0.0347658694,
0.0247158408,
-0.0037731321,
0.0245625302,
-0.0256093144,
-0.0076958681,
0.0093556074,
0.0237056091,
-0.0110954819,
-0.0543332845,
-0.0148586882,
0.0253878273,
-0.0289484765,
0.0386049338,
0.0370109752,
-0.0344666578,
0.051620543,
-0.0453273691,
0.0595662557,
0.0183111094,
0.0643370897,
0.0554418713,
0.0036982326,
-0.0060530896,
-0.0355191268,
0.0018014826,
0.0642402247,
-0.0444065444,
0.0482224002,
-0.0241069123,
0.0218283106,
0.0391434617,
-0.0077431132,
-0.0636312291,
-0.0302483067,
0.0113805858,
0.0159450211,
0.0294172987,
0.0057488107,
0.0256708376,
0.0021179311,
0.0091427695,
-0.009803595,
0.0533975996,
-0.0084201172,
-0.0682392493,
-0.0239774249,
0.0118409432,
-0.0142341433,
-0.006190354,
0.084088847,
-0.05203145,
0.0337555408,
-0.0537409186,
-0.0244617742,
-0.0166362114,
0.0065824282,
0.0465246513,
0.0142783597,
-0.0511173643,
-0.011843767,
-0.0500452183,
-0.0911031812,
0.0272528324,
0.0557286106,
-0.0320487544,
0.0158963203,
-0.0072075296,
0.1105568707,
0.0354209095,
-0.0267949514,
-0.014100966,
0.0130721712,
-0.0011139964,
-0.0356242433,
-0.031610962,
-5.373766915e-33,
-0.0500685126,
-0.0039023424,
-0.0023494172,
0.0201308299,
0.0265644733,
0.0125833489,
-0.063079372,
-0.0018697403,
-0.0074744686,
-0.0576884113,
0.000789999,
0.0183818582,
-0.0166206323,
-0.0552376062,
0.0859172493,
0.0509257577,
0.0148865916,
0.0658145025,
-0.0567503348,
0.0235244073,
-0.0082398755,
0.0584139265,
0.0275881644,
-0.050599061,
-0.0103078028,
0.0143560711,
0.0582214221,
-0.0334000848,
0.0117222816,
0.0593810938,
0.0068959529,
-0.0043125092,
0.0042384253,
-0.0087015806,
-0.0275552273,
-0.0346170627,
-0.0395368412,
-0.0224031322,
0.0218979698,
0.0129851978,
-0.0005765163,
-0.0603963174,
0.052726049,
-0.0097632874,
0.0185811296,
0.0008850241,
0.0084383423,
0.0097756935,
-0.0112845926,
-0.0198269784,
-0.0497787111,
0.0245363973,
-0.0557618737,
0.0106031615,
0.016033709,
0.0801445395,
0.0087249661,
0.0762095302,
0.0365079492,
-0.0009172365,
-0.0374480002,
0.0586413629,
0.0787597224,
-0.0440873131,
-0.0064730789,
-0.0043222583,
0.0434821621,
-0.0167157408,
0.009406683,
-0.009053559,
0.0289946515,
0.0531343445,
-0.0127500063,
0.055144649,
-0.0090090493,
-0.0244586151,
-0.0066839368,
0.0523217693,
0.0352492593,
0.0115420213,
-0.0294187535,
0.0105042392,
-0.0425139144,
0.0084031988,
-0.058673501,
-0.0300597046,
-0.036862433,
-0.0456327312,
0.0250472166,
-0.0347374752,
0.0078420257,
-0.0084770806,
0.0145561444,
-0.0292804297,
0.0255624913,
0.0272093304,
-0.0557363927,
0.041586522,
0.0120066721,
0.0322579555,
0.003978936,
-0.0020655841,
-0.0146074975,
-0.0117427772,
0.0747708827,
0.0201376881,
0.0012575268,
0.0020255912,
-0.0674347505,
-0.0112052821,
-0.0466852151,
-0.0183163099,
-0.0514194779,
-0.0210311878,
0.0186578538,
0.0004224308,
0.003318913,
-0.008762137,
-0.0011115739,
-0.0064511085,
-0.0599385612,
-0.0357779674,
0.008462877,
-0.0028551538,
-0.0230178013,
-0.0399528593,
-0.0372688323,
0.0191831607,
0.0671980083,
0.0176107939,
-0.0523530878,
0.0388690419,
3.004e-7,
0.0107828379,
0.0158116985,
0.0106970938,
0.0302876793,
-0.0425756574,
0.0184999164,
-0.0809028,
-0.0152817508,
0.0198666304,
-0.0307855625,
-0.0338877626,
-0.0177524332,
0.0507661812,
0.0627219677,
-0.0442545414,
-0.0025852546,
0.0339862481,
-0.0090122167,
-0.0690903664,
-0.0068943487,
-0.0035526019,
0.0254633054,
-0.0214310996,
-0.0022147801,
0.0262652971,
0.0043530529,
0.0182192959,
-0.0399165228,
-0.0014917158,
0.0148962727,
-0.0843887255,
0.0045494987,
0.0042075012,
-0.0174035542,
-0.0155979665,
-0.00373712,
0.0263689607,
0.0448774397,
0.038946718,
0.0142078763,
-0.0007335824,
-0.0216454342,
-0.0293882489,
-0.0420533493,
0.0372805782,
0.021621393,
0.0263546146,
-0.0286531653,
-0.0542756878,
0.0193218682,
0.0011009782,
0.0074995295,
0.0187738072,
0.0058097141,
-0.005513682,
-0.0298465602,
-0.038491454,
-0.0124623431,
-0.0405125394,
0.0159582905,
-0.0099117002,
-0.0132470876,
-0.0527990423,
-0.0128201544,
0.0267092101,
-0.0049296482,
0.0276775751,
2.851994266e-34,
0.0325522162,
-0.036727801,
0.0366982631,
-0.039127104,
0.0333103724,
-0.0467580408,
-0.0280546881,
0.0376386456,
-0.0134103261,
0.0121808127,
-0.0255035646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11244v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11244v3 | Entity Matching using Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T13:12:32 | 2024-06-05T15:33:25 | Ralph Peeters, Christian Bizer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Entity Matching is the task of deciding whether two entity descriptions refer
to the same real-world entity and is a central step in most data integration
pipelines. Many state-of-the-art entity matching methods rely on pre-trained
language models (PLMs) such as BERT or RoBERTa. Two major drawbacks of these
models for entity matching are that (i) the models require significant amounts
of task-specific training data and (ii) the fine-tuned models are not robust
concerning out-of-distribution entities. This paper investigates using
generative large language models (LLMs) as a less task-specific training
data-dependent and more robust alternative to PLM-based matchers. Our study
covers hosted and open-source LLMs, which can be run locally. We evaluate these
models in a zero-shot scenario and a scenario where task-specific training data
is available. We compare different prompt designs and the prompt sensitivity of
the models and show that there is no single best prompt but needs to be tuned
for each model/dataset combination. We further investigate (i) the selection of
in-context demonstrations, (ii) the generation of matching rules, as well as
(iii) fine-tuning a hosted LLM using the same pool of training data. Our
experiments show that the best LLMs require no or only a few training examples
to perform similarly to PLMs that were fine-tuned using thousands of examples.
LLM-based matchers further exhibit higher robustness to unseen entities. We
show that GPT4 can generate structured explanations for matching decisions. The
model can automatically identify potential causes of matching errors by
analyzing explanations of wrong decisions. We demonstrate that the model can
generate meaningful textual descriptions of the identified error classes, which
can help data engineers improve entity matching pipelines. | [
0.0438642241,
0.0581386983,
0.0088420622,
0.0304360446,
-0.0376432538,
0.033544071,
0.0169429388,
0.0058417735,
0.0123973079,
-0.0525113344,
0.0048735361,
-0.0306408908,
-0.009595314,
-0.0038592624,
0.0133856926,
-0.0244093575,
0.0307781696,
0.0161395818,
-0.0370348208,
0.0138498517,
0.0043716393,
0.0421322137,
0.0085388366,
0.0277142376,
-0.004738607,
-0.0128130447,
-0.0190170202,
0.0276513342,
0.0261164885,
-0.0250908956,
0.0024240981,
0.0391423665,
0.0186308846,
0.0552344024,
0.0000020243,
-0.0857502669,
-0.0416286066,
0.0236432757,
-0.0557672307,
0.0106413392,
-0.0092677595,
-0.0057245609,
-0.0014473576,
0.0272512864,
0.0096212113,
-0.073304832,
0.0542101488,
0.0526483133,
0.0441576652,
0.0692920685,
-0.0227355771,
-0.031281542,
0.0243401993,
-0.0092376918,
0.0078828894,
-0.0466766767,
0.0640918016,
0.003444788,
0.0385908745,
-0.0052080317,
0.0196862463,
0.0157284644,
-0.0291531496,
0.0042809737,
-0.0050696521,
0.0367870964,
-0.0244086832,
0.0402767025,
-0.0124349473,
0.0703769252,
-0.0244737193,
-0.0522947572,
0.0429646857,
-0.019861931,
-0.0088872379,
0.0185221788,
-0.0106567582,
0.0068485681,
-0.0459865443,
0.0129030226,
-0.0267516337,
-0.0394245721,
0.0148243513,
0.0120018199,
-0.0471996553,
0.0095670866,
0.034470927,
-0.0559099838,
-0.021869557,
0.0030025996,
-0.0306911711,
-0.0965247452,
0.0180255286,
0.0327775441,
-0.0299145207,
-0.0039598113,
-0.0624125563,
-0.0265070386,
0.0076190331,
-0.0053017265,
0.0047321622,
0.0260409173,
-0.0184785854,
0.0587662458,
-0.0482455455,
0.0659926683,
-0.0106741181,
-0.0140358787,
-0.0204811059,
-0.0535583496,
-0.0741951913,
0.0085620126,
-0.0498304702,
0.0229332615,
-0.0292900708,
-0.0134014636,
-0.0010591705,
0.0201989226,
-0.0344553925,
0.0735396743,
-0.0171074942,
-0.0230066031,
0.0098746298,
-0.0097782174,
-0.0737222135,
-0.0071936133,
-0.0256913118,
-0.0149797909,
-0.0445604622,
-0.0759588331,
0.0059635942,
0.0048969779,
0.0371989869,
-0.0565867908,
0.0385324769,
0.0443917029,
0.0260755569,
-0.0114561757,
-0.0424843654,
-0.0175740011,
0.0068719722,
-0.0444821119,
-0.0390912928,
-0.0317157693,
0.0366255566,
0.0360326394,
-0.0056143505,
-0.0564306155,
0.0064089429,
0.0224091522,
-0.0352229699,
0.1010085568,
-0.0318802595,
0.0571017973,
0.022992108,
-0.0225286279,
0.0069358223,
0.0222726539,
0.0173024181,
-0.0233520344,
0.0172334295,
-0.0287422575,
0.0402705893,
0.0465217754,
-0.0018612306,
-0.0297405049,
-0.0073524821,
0.0604079999,
0.0461433232,
0.0591224805,
0.0605479665,
0.0523160957,
-0.0069730789,
0.0203998424,
0.04691533,
0.0502227321,
0.0243900456,
0.0143803777,
0.0447113216,
0.0429468565,
-0.0110680237,
-0.0109956106,
-0.0341523178,
0.0049713808,
-0.0175619032,
-0.0066426252,
0.0083824489,
0.0604877733,
-0.048536174,
0.0302579813,
-0.0063316114,
0.0031463646,
-0.0379354805,
0.0352009013,
0.0319035985,
-0.0092929462,
-0.0391330831,
0.0628532022,
0.0067410488,
-0.0292881373,
-0.0171575863,
-0.03848112,
-0.0031678071,
0.095245339,
0.0661715642,
-0.0148565257,
-0.0182773583,
-0.0281934887,
0.0120109953,
0.0408512466,
0.0659490973,
-0.006318843,
-0.0338079296,
-0.0500012673,
-0.0490998141,
0.0390052311,
-0.0094237216,
0.0193508007,
0.0481323712,
0.019762516,
0.038919434,
-0.0435597263,
-0.0469757579,
0.0484425873,
-0.0107152304,
-0.0477408655,
-0.0018830213,
0.0275615547,
-0.0081069246,
0.0136379711,
-0.0190536641,
0.004655859,
0.0126631791,
0.0115173701,
0.0022537946,
0.0003403961,
0.0189754572,
0.0145456521,
0.0189652015,
-0.0014633186,
-0.0289910305,
-0.0121102091,
-0.037295308,
-0.0390599966,
-0.0667374358,
-0.0199770276,
0.0272402149,
-0.024934873,
0.0572908148,
-0.0099019613,
-0.017410621,
-0.0417831689,
0.0652645752,
0.0564248338,
0.0134830652,
0.0038469355,
0.0233259965,
0.0197527688,
-0.0608474612,
-0.0370451473,
0.012045864,
-0.0015836407,
0.0100605329,
-0.010707913,
-0.0436312184,
-0.0335065685,
-0.00999841,
-0.078791976,
0.0353679061,
0.0218084622,
0.027004607,
0.0026355558,
0.0354730412,
-0.039951764,
-0.010247848,
-0.0319264233,
-0.0292136744,
0.0350615382,
0.0265246499,
0.0356830582,
-0.0089940708,
-0.049347844,
-0.0144165503,
0.0198429152,
-0.0496012084,
0.0367117599,
0.0304201283,
-0.0457602516,
-0.0839792341,
0.0410165787,
-0.026994681,
0.0332700871,
0.0153491106,
0.0280787349,
-0.0257470496,
0.0176866073,
0.0513790548,
0.0423945375,
-0.0029112149,
-0.05220728,
0.0170343649,
-0.0175566953,
-0.0967330337,
0.017049348,
0.0152455484,
-0.0193620343,
0.0094246054,
-0.0005695349,
0.0141073493,
0.0174710713,
-0.0251784027,
-0.0135504734,
-0.0410091393,
0.0176376682,
0.026417708,
0.0422714092,
-0.0161502119,
-0.0533039682,
0.0180491023,
0.0107793119,
-0.0271134395,
-0.0168677624,
0.0707899481,
-0.0662698299,
0.0234496165,
-0.0126236165,
-0.0029588209,
-0.0503411256,
0.0369794779,
0.0083978642,
0.017543586,
0.0180735495,
-0.0326582678,
0.0090549747,
0.0243115723,
0.0359589048,
-0.0217182394,
0.0666414127,
-0.0326611996,
0.0533946492,
-0.0260723997,
-0.0451167822,
-0.0620102398,
-0.0151198665,
-0.0429727174,
0.0084053781,
0.0019631849,
-0.0100639649,
-0.0579319485,
0.0531893782,
0.0021400638,
0.0476408899,
0.0129088499,
-0.0274634119,
-0.0301586036,
-0.0150856152,
0.0272660069,
0.0096195275,
0.004200357,
-0.0098964488,
0.0044146823,
-0.0223610438,
0.0465677306,
-0.0181731861,
-0.0296875928,
-0.019695593,
0.0150250243,
-0.0896791592,
0.0152911171,
0.0190726928,
0.0261092894,
-0.0314069018,
0.0180080179,
0.1152742803,
0.0022834595,
-0.0225102343,
-0.0380912982,
0.0173632652,
-0.0119694881,
0.0200697519,
0.0531066246,
-0.0969435871,
-0.0272232313,
0.0194334276,
-0.0019932413,
0.0189255588,
-0.0472975299,
-0.0159347262,
-0.1558447778,
0.0239801314,
-0.0147544388,
-0.0044349125,
-0.0546919666,
-0.0404855274,
0.0205508433,
-0.0142202144,
0.0094190836,
-0.00280564,
-0.0460222661,
0.0037049537,
0.0281936489,
-0.0154457474,
-0.0611547716,
0.0330063216,
-0.1118051782,
0.0553869717,
0.074559845,
0.0241156612,
0.0162540898,
-0.019157229,
0.0041864156,
0.001071547,
-0.0172881112,
0.0120236939,
0.061435353,
-0.0342488699,
-0.001825056,
-0.0240645837,
-0.0098562622,
0.006454458,
0.0023327686,
0.0166120678,
0.0665868223,
-0.0181808062,
0.0181084089,
0.0051082755,
-0.0330972672,
0.0162511226,
0.1231740192,
0.017839225,
-0.022931397,
-0.0258134175,
0.0041687377,
0.0267237853,
-0.0070324265,
0.0218665227,
0.0165013671,
-0.0454751439,
-0.0026609341,
-0.0318074711,
-0.0099400235,
0.0529670268,
0.0331859551,
0.0661389753,
0.0132818324,
-0.0146592464,
-0.0044227326,
-0.0576861948,
0.0409594141,
-0.0788328573,
0.0590481348,
-0.0566935986,
0.0122934673,
0.0292696711,
-0.023144627,
-0.0307065025,
0.0008454281,
-0.0616984069,
-0.0445611812,
-0.0208147317,
-0.0394325294,
0.0245135911,
0.0556549616,
-0.0206479765,
-0.0520254821,
-0.021616457,
0.0489512719,
-0.0357022472,
-0.0300778858,
-0.0280338153,
0.0035336914,
-0.0041461657,
0.0183359478,
-0.0638749599,
0.0140863806,
0.0172152612,
0.0061629508,
-0.0042861341,
-0.0731306225,
0.0366750546,
0.0593787432,
0.0164202321,
0.0162796862,
-0.0245411322,
-0.0427839495,
0.0193631183,
-0.007233643,
-0.0148165701,
-0.0090048108,
-0.0183217712,
0.0232009999,
0.0248384085,
0.0270357579,
0.028586654,
-0.0019468343,
0.0381704606,
-0.0816684663,
0.0003063545,
-0.0286319498,
0.0082853753,
0.0372977033,
-0.0412402041,
-0.0171889644,
0.008752509,
0.0443983786,
0.0563063398,
-0.0348163359,
0.0329646952,
0.0213801879,
0.0337991975,
0.0079874471,
-0.01576747,
-0.0293943826,
-0.0344442353,
-0.0391003974,
0.0323676392,
0.071873717,
-0.0204894077,
0.0213778764,
-0.0156318508,
-0.0170960799,
-0.0094580902,
-0.005393757,
0.0235855225,
-0.0259759836,
0.0436820276,
0.0297992546,
-0.036066439,
-0.0375495292,
0.0651935712,
0.0170160383,
0.102832593,
-0.0215572715,
-0.0418548584,
-0.0279441364,
-0.008932733,
0.0219329521,
-0.0200643986,
-0.028704958,
-0.0419536829,
-0.0357925184,
-0.0393164232,
0.0125088561,
0.0106348181,
-0.0381372347,
-0.0047758636,
0.025197003,
0.0341237821,
0.0332518034,
-0.0403849371,
-0.0032944414,
0.0166384894,
-0.001215321,
-0.0240013301,
-0.0478590503,
-5.551633169e-33,
-0.043369025,
-0.0374924876,
0.02670056,
-0.0331070311,
-0.0004726628,
-0.0019224231,
0.0007583434,
-0.0567335188,
-0.0183942169,
-0.0274298638,
-0.0016721999,
-0.0019507729,
0.0263257511,
-0.0031962956,
-0.0013897133,
-0.0236446261,
0.0710016116,
0.0308113489,
-0.0220407862,
0.0150603252,
0.0061218822,
0.0192167778,
0.0208658297,
-0.0658977255,
0.0226003677,
-0.0341715664,
-0.01609594,
0.0337332413,
0.0306744855,
0.0465745218,
-0.0195077639,
0.0053199641,
0.0006407147,
-0.0077087367,
0.0008399574,
0.0222892016,
-0.1070217341,
0.006383046,
0.0042639072,
0.0099303285,
0.0642994344,
-0.0308621731,
0.0361778401,
-0.0334295519,
-0.0224988237,
0.0425710902,
0.0513009839,
-0.0227450486,
0.0051077185,
-0.0356149934,
-0.0549699105,
0.0355152637,
0.0075162468,
0.0125240181,
0.0592088364,
-0.0057340721,
0.0403843559,
0.0072006308,
-0.0645659938,
0.0197431482,
0.0459520593,
-0.0044044624,
0.0574137308,
0.0155548984,
0.0145053817,
0.0449344255,
0.01896137,
-0.0084454445,
-0.0120512396,
0.0116757443,
-0.0169406272,
0.0437091924,
-0.0091720084,
0.0639797971,
0.0188815184,
-0.012417444,
-0.0497081801,
0.0689350888,
0.0083811777,
-0.0063970182,
0.0099346191,
-0.0076035485,
-0.081123665,
-0.0216261111,
-0.0369007289,
0.0242894012,
-0.0589879453,
-0.0136665991,
0.0623791479,
-0.0029039457,
0.0052030785,
0.0438169055,
0.0020966069,
-0.0484762974,
-0.0668686107,
-0.0042157345,
-0.0058948868,
-0.0354997814,
-0.0085645495,
0.0070293122,
-0.0325963981,
-0.0630497634,
0.041607447,
-0.0019780379,
0.0271873511,
0.0331901535,
0.0223419461,
-0.0065343478,
-0.0904738083,
0.0300640259,
-0.0306194574,
-0.0032433644,
-0.0547175929,
-0.026063351,
0.0478962474,
0.0252617281,
0.0270950459,
-0.007214847,
0.0582128949,
-0.0500477478,
-0.0387427136,
-0.0051457086,
-0.004124511,
0.0174720809,
0.0108205201,
0.0310542099,
-0.0137620522,
-0.0085154492,
0.0395324193,
-0.0257814731,
-0.0007332468,
0.0211962331,
2.745e-7,
0.0187513437,
0.0434568375,
0.0278291702,
0.0222942177,
-0.011955604,
0.0110259848,
0.0052439617,
0.025488589,
0.0089433994,
0.0211185031,
0.0068001519,
0.0015955077,
0.0563954897,
0.0383319482,
-0.0639693439,
0.0021805307,
-0.0341111533,
-0.0012914254,
-0.1107806042,
0.0164237283,
0.0375848711,
0.0402002931,
0.0041717542,
0.0080966577,
-0.0013136773,
-0.0407093279,
0.0408074893,
-0.0350848548,
0.0167071074,
0.0566473119,
0.0344626047,
0.0163768549,
0.0015937226,
0.0874336734,
-0.0046626893,
0.025888877,
0.0242153965,
0.0435313508,
0.0041373982,
0.0408562496,
-0.0525883138,
-0.07526692,
-0.0050376849,
-0.0665243044,
0.0821004733,
-0.0295547992,
0.0096392781,
0.0164321493,
-0.0370429568,
-0.0569068938,
-0.0412262194,
0.0329332873,
-0.0054742997,
0.0092469603,
0.0239644479,
-0.0084839622,
-0.0406190865,
-0.0611684173,
0.0086257961,
0.0183767434,
-0.0264308359,
-0.0265213605,
-0.0300571993,
-0.0150761642,
0.0379804857,
-0.0486588217,
0.0267669596,
2.769457803e-34,
-0.0190803129,
0.0255155489,
-0.0043455288,
-0.0088378452,
0.0695544183,
0.008254596,
-0.0118160015,
0.0366186686,
-0.0188524406,
-0.0810221732,
0.0141318673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11237v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11237v1 | Watermarking LLMs with Weight Quantization | 2023-10-17T13:06:59 | 2023-10-17T13:06:59 | Linyang Li, Botian Jiang, Pengyu Wang, Ke Ren, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abuse of large language models reveals high risks as large language models
are being deployed at an astonishing speed. It is important to protect the
model weights to avoid malicious usage that violates licenses of open-source
large language models. This paper proposes a novel watermarking strategy that
plants watermarks in the quantization process of large language models without
pre-defined triggers during inference. The watermark works when the model is
used in the fp32 mode and remains hidden when the model is quantized to int8,
in this way, the users can only inference the model without further supervised
fine-tuning of the model. We successfully plant the watermark into open-source
large language model weights including GPT-Neo and LLaMA. We hope our proposed
method can provide a potential direction for protecting model weights in the
era of large language model applications. | [
-0.0145334201,
0.0823096707,
-0.0195496157,
0.0856348276,
-0.0244104397,
-0.0117016444,
0.0343510248,
0.0256885886,
0.0249552447,
-0.030872751,
-0.0167140476,
-0.0062691877,
-0.016105406,
0.0119403331,
0.0546489283,
-0.0166385211,
0.0424165539,
-0.0334504917,
-0.0343581066,
-0.0221336186,
-0.0237976257,
-0.0003543512,
0.065092802,
0.0094652642,
0.0280379225,
-0.0238130298,
-0.005687057,
0.0031459869,
0.0016402813,
-0.0284738149,
-0.0276119858,
0.0511763543,
0.0229746792,
0.0824738145,
0.0000018766,
-0.0313863419,
-0.0376282521,
0.0495582782,
-0.0585276261,
0.0723145604,
0.0328173563,
-0.0034059111,
-0.038275186,
0.0068303645,
-0.0249263737,
0.0417958125,
0.0471596941,
-0.0006954983,
0.0827508569,
0.0502441227,
0.0038870557,
-0.0100669879,
0.0284963828,
-0.0067061712,
-0.0046133259,
-0.0422142781,
0.0187116936,
0.0288324449,
-0.013743436,
0.0299564861,
0.0083888564,
0.0480629019,
0.0224984325,
-0.0101580806,
-0.0550840423,
0.0097766593,
-0.0317066312,
-0.0101202941,
-0.0159050338,
0.0253085159,
-0.0474866442,
-0.0420014746,
0.0200106557,
-0.0010417434,
-0.0041871783,
-0.0086881891,
-0.0370924287,
0.0484758578,
0.033086054,
0.0431209728,
0.04419728,
-0.0490123406,
0.056816183,
0.0045793378,
-0.0155395176,
0.0941654891,
0.0518270209,
0.0054624015,
-0.0166725647,
-0.0323044211,
-0.0643949285,
-0.0683587193,
0.0043802783,
-0.0116085224,
0.053360898,
0.0133417053,
-0.0675940514,
-0.0264188703,
0.0156147601,
-0.0620251894,
0.0372759961,
0.0357864834,
-0.0157528091,
0.0200119447,
-0.035771355,
0.0548829734,
-0.0419956222,
0.0265622474,
0.0125670815,
0.0259547569,
0.0205589365,
-0.0276551321,
-0.0378100425,
0.0355218165,
-0.0342432521,
0.0209672786,
-0.0529171452,
0.0425485522,
-0.0144569492,
0.0030687954,
-0.0106372759,
-0.0256334506,
-0.0150625454,
-0.0158237312,
0.0428919941,
-0.0229583215,
0.0351167955,
0.0024308097,
-0.0207384247,
-0.0777967796,
-0.0158990715,
0.0147013571,
-0.0318093561,
-0.0226943269,
0.0169014484,
0.0831465051,
0.059099149,
-0.0305036213,
-0.023701936,
-0.0520935319,
-0.003119326,
-0.0402412824,
-0.0051781577,
-0.0676398873,
-0.0570559427,
-0.0211745501,
0.0248644184,
-0.0704925954,
0.0024459728,
-0.0001082516,
-0.0072027384,
0.0479546525,
-0.0479508154,
-0.0189458318,
-0.0335367396,
0.0002451104,
0.0059121856,
0.0778546035,
0.0383060127,
0.0256780479,
0.0625522137,
-0.0074671973,
0.0137197599,
0.0715106949,
0.0172827728,
0.0443199947,
-0.0442344397,
-0.028025778,
0.0381618105,
-0.0332689397,
0.0255891643,
0.0425808914,
-0.0195804909,
-0.0499592051,
0.0484369621,
0.0681336895,
-0.0124522587,
0.0093819285,
-0.0140834711,
-0.0076750801,
0.0252082217,
-0.0162381697,
-0.0423689224,
-0.0106242606,
-0.0605228245,
-0.0128513919,
0.0011215459,
0.0408656038,
-0.0011073782,
0.0018857622,
-0.0326903574,
-0.0336668193,
-0.0005070355,
0.010824969,
0.0139507325,
0.0064531518,
0.0254123397,
0.1096620783,
0.0164361652,
-0.0440536328,
-0.0090975771,
-0.1140782759,
0.0119626923,
0.0404454023,
0.0409926102,
-0.010565809,
0.0303745549,
0.0023337468,
-0.0107736252,
0.049188856,
-0.0200702231,
0.0030423286,
0.0349913836,
-0.0138925044,
-0.0238425862,
-0.0140568512,
0.0214252044,
0.029637957,
0.0111365579,
0.0172986835,
-0.0001196462,
-0.0572579913,
-0.0135000153,
0.0063454402,
0.01368431,
-0.0699494034,
-0.002768632,
-0.0166057814,
0.0219931435,
0.0332240984,
-0.011433227,
0.0111872768,
0.0438431203,
0.0074562547,
0.0132255666,
-0.0535423569,
0.0201543942,
0.0250852369,
0.0748945475,
-0.0123802302,
0.0140759358,
0.0244020876,
-0.0363345779,
-0.0238798,
0.0208966974,
-0.0138702085,
0.0568948835,
-0.0320754126,
0.0363673754,
-0.0185639262,
0.0437048189,
-0.0350439213,
0.0096014962,
-0.0164056607,
0.0194938555,
0.0430773608,
0.006853031,
0.0419846997,
-0.037377838,
-0.0585113503,
0.0267696809,
0.0103501333,
0.02469787,
-0.0183368269,
0.0256393291,
0.0229593404,
-0.010681645,
-0.047260955,
0.0215954594,
-0.0184266921,
0.0470102727,
0.0272152349,
0.0107118394,
-0.0379570052,
-0.0037701719,
-0.0215687733,
-0.0516846143,
-0.0034381601,
0.0120092705,
0.0000512335,
-0.0373644531,
-0.0403057821,
-0.002959579,
-0.0307085831,
0.0063652992,
0.048811648,
-0.0354489833,
-0.04648415,
-0.0847010091,
0.0347501747,
-0.0462819412,
0.0279159918,
-0.003078901,
-0.0160270575,
0.0254672524,
-0.0129568437,
-0.0173317697,
0.0696481988,
-0.0377136208,
0.0099951234,
0.0849092752,
0.0041139685,
-0.0505471751,
-0.0173815135,
0.0089102099,
-0.065826498,
-0.0340837836,
-0.0193627793,
0.0096606696,
0.0380427577,
-0.0199076906,
-0.0345842727,
0.0074746851,
0.0316651613,
-0.0211694557,
-0.0021539198,
0.0184076354,
0.0063037216,
-0.0467798896,
0.0335145816,
0.0220138524,
-0.0675057694,
0.0243512783,
-0.0638980046,
-0.0014556608,
0.0040952456,
-0.0303059481,
-0.0221977234,
0.0494568236,
0.0029978489,
0.0299109872,
0.0305340681,
-0.0234550349,
-0.021266263,
-0.0065968647,
0.0470981486,
-0.0515202023,
0.0025781924,
-0.0356938243,
0.0082937554,
-0.0360529199,
0.0011859313,
0.0093152421,
0.000154778,
-0.0201275703,
0.0065263202,
0.0069494122,
-0.0239034668,
0.0539488643,
0.0229327828,
0.020230772,
0.0134588284,
-0.0108896317,
0.0181944352,
-0.0424011275,
0.0209422298,
0.0148021495,
-0.0402588733,
0.0158499535,
-0.0285483152,
-0.0170549676,
0.0321936421,
0.0084832553,
0.0113509027,
-0.0305941775,
0.0222628117,
0.0818670169,
-0.0044626296,
-0.0159012079,
0.04658911,
0.0400834419,
-0.0327157453,
0.0372627601,
0.0655934736,
0.0205080081,
-0.0339680687,
0.0113083068,
-0.0111623565,
0.0414791852,
0.0289723277,
0.0162879378,
-0.135345757,
-0.006563989,
0.042511005,
0.0195844732,
-0.0119553423,
-0.0081547396,
-0.0285264459,
-0.0571082756,
0.0274815597,
0.0487029552,
-0.0005483863,
0.0092048841,
-0.0352780521,
-0.0335976221,
-0.0063297865,
0.0412308723,
-0.0299414489,
-0.0013804624,
0.0143032772,
0.0086573735,
0.0063600717,
-0.0279008821,
0.0054227328,
-0.0069685597,
0.0539651923,
0.0573417656,
0.0114259142,
-0.0295488946,
-0.0348359384,
0.0612787306,
0.0172958001,
-0.0322625861,
-0.0107951565,
-0.002609473,
0.021091884,
-0.036242716,
-0.0096992804,
0.0004000533,
0.0306012034,
-0.0377220437,
-0.0251208916,
0.0567362085,
-0.0171791501,
-0.0248721708,
0.0186634976,
-0.0783447772,
0.0062639769,
0.046932999,
0.0181072336,
0.0004299791,
-0.0180348679,
-0.0814994201,
0.0049472065,
0.009435894,
-0.049348142,
-0.0082214838,
-0.0317852944,
-0.0466617085,
-0.0223045964,
0.0227660723,
-0.00743875,
0.0284247957,
0.0416460186,
0.0195326544,
0.0142704714,
-0.0332144909,
-0.0463151112,
0.0140765756,
-0.0994772837,
0.0461225957,
-0.0529024079,
0.0151594495,
0.0204621255,
0.0130461548,
-0.0245293714,
0.0179411899,
-0.085642457,
-0.0987231061,
0.0061462317,
0.0581089891,
0.0397899039,
0.0045590489,
-0.0020215877,
-0.0789733529,
0.0728812218,
0.0477192067,
-0.0020352583,
0.0440637544,
0.0658247322,
-0.0336791463,
0.0032426491,
0.0401137024,
-0.0505305156,
-0.0041889008,
0.0612522475,
-0.0002095402,
-0.0602411963,
-0.0338485949,
-0.005548039,
0.0718602389,
0.0371636786,
-0.0398547575,
0.0071658273,
-0.0027797434,
0.0327773541,
-0.0403471924,
-0.0117739327,
-0.0321549214,
0.0368638746,
0.0239426717,
-0.0284543987,
0.0135356961,
-0.0142183974,
0.0161809511,
-0.0003094073,
0.0146664167,
0.0298485458,
-0.0351741575,
0.0204672329,
0.0514129922,
0.0041727526,
-0.00883085,
0.0548627526,
0.001782331,
0.0556423962,
0.0020415722,
0.0052793878,
-0.0031895298,
0.0098020053,
-0.0142022828,
0.0622520149,
-0.0487891175,
-0.0609874949,
-0.0328994393,
0.0299955942,
0.0565332882,
0.0620844252,
0.0354119651,
-0.0391439646,
-0.0172178,
-0.0181190427,
0.0277769137,
-0.003604437,
-0.0671738833,
0.0309102312,
-0.0287472047,
-0.0229738187,
0.0119737126,
0.0457816646,
0.0588255897,
0.0512799285,
0.0041552056,
-0.0215821657,
-0.0341200829,
-0.043286562,
-0.0088393642,
-0.0143425241,
-0.0274502411,
-0.0242902413,
-0.0429947823,
-0.0776135847,
-0.0068927133,
0.020368075,
-0.0220520161,
-0.0263506919,
-0.0175268222,
0.0136366533,
0.0090917703,
-0.0460622013,
-0.0613093525,
-0.0080073094,
0.0292959772,
-0.0367452167,
0.0031983098,
-5.881860756e-33,
-0.0286412649,
-0.0112418644,
-0.0210878663,
-0.0032168159,
0.0225267466,
0.0258091241,
-0.0105645405,
-0.0113437222,
-0.0088410061,
-0.0335748941,
-0.01362825,
-0.0023552086,
0.0225492027,
-0.0250763744,
-0.0310229473,
0.0159432758,
0.0322328955,
0.0124993473,
-0.0106098177,
0.0083219819,
0.0150346337,
-0.0144465985,
0.0524809286,
0.0017669385,
0.0384438038,
-0.0249336734,
-0.0356775671,
0.0058447481,
-0.0491413549,
0.0484387502,
-0.0197957698,
-0.0031530086,
-0.0111484267,
0.0054013338,
-0.0360459164,
-0.0121668726,
-0.0063881455,
-0.0263505522,
0.0415911898,
0.029113818,
0.0451349132,
-0.0911408886,
0.0501920357,
-0.0050528338,
-0.0422456712,
0.017261276,
-0.0224903245,
-0.0124071073,
-0.0367880538,
-0.042773962,
0.003579336,
0.0117564015,
0.0154519612,
0.0678288117,
0.0491626859,
-0.0593642481,
-0.0011760058,
-0.0072525493,
-0.0488621742,
0.0135006895,
0.0576704368,
0.0290246438,
0.0779329389,
0.0321454741,
0.0293966644,
0.0399203859,
-0.0237650499,
-0.0313768908,
0.0174178593,
0.007541989,
0.0438400246,
0.0412893668,
0.0582719669,
0.038051188,
0.0749742687,
0.0000314244,
-0.0356488787,
0.0091295913,
-0.0194627997,
0.0074044429,
0.0233821571,
0.0302099548,
-0.0146730458,
-0.0214071833,
-0.0439223796,
-0.0693167448,
-0.0282397885,
-0.0433933809,
0.0060740216,
-0.0246620625,
-0.0167030171,
-0.0108207483,
0.0228722915,
-0.0750414729,
-0.0623559579,
-0.0419364758,
0.0151165556,
0.0193539653,
0.0004611287,
0.0353696942,
0.0261187404,
-0.0042891935,
0.0075389701,
-0.0446165353,
0.0364004113,
0.0019056852,
0.0289578661,
0.0545466393,
-0.0785526261,
0.0229393747,
-0.0358857028,
-0.0145438211,
0.047639247,
0.0430128239,
0.0340131931,
-0.0369759686,
0.0338349342,
-0.0295308698,
0.0135505078,
0.0025255329,
-0.0307838805,
0.0357496664,
0.006510553,
0.0468397662,
-0.0176628269,
0.0164960828,
-0.0146245034,
0.0955502391,
0.0824436471,
-0.0371130221,
-0.0243702214,
-0.007263958,
2.672e-7,
0.0389446765,
0.0026382296,
0.0153526831,
0.0146814985,
0.0022762259,
0.0287727583,
-0.0238510743,
0.0314593986,
-0.0054579792,
-0.0130404243,
-0.0319213197,
-0.0056663034,
0.0382026285,
0.0069082356,
-0.0575027466,
0.0462586246,
-0.0003051916,
-0.0107650245,
-0.0744460598,
-0.0224692244,
0.0103325546,
0.1158609018,
0.0171547607,
-0.0141925495,
0.0004480491,
-0.0647104457,
0.0263927337,
-0.0337102488,
0.0068218908,
-0.0082824016,
0.0571971945,
0.0448896773,
0.0190411638,
-0.0234045219,
-0.0205823593,
-0.009965349,
-0.0505621508,
0.0784944668,
-0.0238754973,
0.0032969995,
-0.0276644826,
-0.088909246,
-0.0354588442,
-0.0256019887,
0.053121347,
0.0429313146,
-0.0217448734,
-0.093273215,
-0.02398476,
-0.0779098049,
0.0176875163,
-0.0344996043,
0.0284745414,
0.0313776731,
-0.0033062615,
-0.013010839,
-0.0079188477,
-0.0534190945,
-0.0661857948,
-0.0315009765,
-0.0138614979,
-0.044758372,
-0.0128955478,
-0.001914833,
0.0152001167,
-0.0343462676,
0.0398492254,
2.721287789e-34,
0.0150158089,
-0.0604264811,
0.0305487458,
0.06073476,
0.0129162194,
0.0081004137,
-0.0170385316,
0.0067644836,
-0.0040882407,
-0.0667047352,
-0.0089295655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11227v1 | RealBehavior: A Framework for Faithfully Characterizing Foundation Models' Human-like Behavior Mechanisms | 2023-10-17T12:58:17 | 2023-10-17T12:58:17 | Enyu Zhou, Rui Zheng, Zhiheng Xi, Songyang Gao, Xiaoran Fan, Zichu Fei, Jingting Ye, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reports of human-like behaviors in foundation models are growing, with
psychological theories providing enduring tools to investigate these behaviors.
However, current research tends to directly apply these human-oriented tools
without verifying the faithfulness of their outcomes. In this paper, we
introduce a framework, RealBehavior, which is designed to characterize the
humanoid behaviors of models faithfully. Beyond simply measuring behaviors, our
framework assesses the faithfulness of results based on reproducibility,
internal and external consistency, and generalizability. Our findings suggest
that a simple application of psychological tools cannot faithfully characterize
all human-like behaviors. Moreover, we discuss the impacts of aligning models
with human and social values, arguing for the necessity of diversifying
alignment objectives to prevent the creation of models with restricted
characteristics. | [
0.025905598,
0.0911136717,
-0.0300568473,
-0.0159842763,
-0.0020947603,
0.0357356258,
-0.0213537198,
0.0091705117,
-0.0396525413,
0.0533805378,
-0.0288382117,
-0.0356738791,
-0.0036029934,
0.0283854622,
0.0490277782,
-0.0644304454,
0.0375242382,
0.0103165703,
-0.0237224028,
0.006326755,
0.005432257,
0.0142893046,
0.0096939551,
0.0238198303,
-0.0372197665,
0.0014815218,
-0.01987583,
-0.0066771712,
0.0421671644,
-0.010258629,
0.0073088529,
0.0007538826,
0.0549784973,
-0.0035637405,
0.0000022101,
-0.0368891805,
0.0050270907,
0.0280798413,
0.0045965621,
-0.0118981628,
0.0542504378,
-0.0106168967,
0.0146345738,
0.00580444,
-0.0212692898,
-0.0018135232,
0.0028157528,
0.0662875548,
0.0112671498,
-0.0099367946,
-0.0076141283,
-0.0094540091,
-0.0189536642,
0.0176820345,
-0.0070455968,
0.0391076468,
0.002714192,
0.0374080949,
0.0312473308,
-0.0480668135,
-0.0055006887,
-0.0655429289,
0.0160810295,
0.028825365,
0.0179065112,
0.0036212814,
0.0218797866,
-0.0792104974,
0.0284821689,
0.0413203239,
0.0258720051,
-0.0292674899,
0.0329866521,
0.00699449,
0.0329763442,
0.0628653467,
0.0156386551,
0.0238125511,
-0.0206704792,
-0.006936769,
-0.0289537311,
0.0511542112,
0.0059052287,
0.0063037644,
0.0072796457,
0.0362685919,
0.0087968698,
0.0069077285,
-0.0029171011,
-0.0237654895,
0.0118583813,
-0.0409573056,
-0.0049827523,
0.0122383283,
-0.0053289989,
-0.0275470521,
-0.0470003672,
0.0821879432,
0.0313092656,
-0.0065680966,
0.0471869111,
0.0496203192,
0.005419319,
-0.0165558308,
-0.0103700617,
0.0684750229,
-0.066294007,
0.0377711691,
-0.0223011989,
0.0458853394,
-0.0426635295,
0.011095372,
0.0220297147,
-0.0116119301,
0.0095234597,
-0.0284805577,
0.0149669694,
0.0157103986,
-0.0572099164,
-0.0133441892,
-0.0824540779,
0.0317320749,
0.0200741738,
0.0375825316,
-0.0075264,
-0.0679673404,
-0.0498900414,
0.0469209664,
-0.0146960802,
-0.0383971147,
-0.0052700792,
-0.0290833395,
-0.0312116109,
0.0127846021,
0.035452459,
-0.0034935256,
0.0519682392,
0.0328848697,
0.0489365794,
-0.0112407412,
0.0880101249,
-0.0378293023,
-0.0043009138,
-0.0155383628,
0.0096073383,
-0.0088791987,
0.0137685798,
-0.0390329957,
-0.0256601516,
-0.0353102386,
0.0594535097,
0.0332498513,
0.03855367,
0.0321123451,
-0.0030758914,
0.0217343643,
-0.038276501,
0.0244863015,
-0.0101031782,
-0.0068544475,
-0.0360527746,
-0.0262441728,
-0.0009740081,
-0.0067506884,
0.0111558903,
0.0148267495,
0.0353875756,
0.0004939451,
0.0666545704,
0.0385232754,
0.0550657697,
-0.0201439261,
-0.0544187501,
0.0466341674,
0.03595604,
0.0545946285,
-0.0301548671,
0.047982011,
0.030389525,
-0.0395695195,
0.0287291855,
0.0251846854,
-0.051451616,
-0.0099034328,
0.004131827,
0.0174648687,
-0.1074164882,
0.0276584867,
-0.0358720198,
0.0201054681,
0.0054321643,
-0.0175668411,
0.0621109977,
0.0143007357,
-0.021813754,
0.0203366354,
0.0314967521,
-0.0120759057,
0.0004671357,
-0.0497246049,
-0.0032948172,
-0.0369575992,
0.0144540342,
0.009601837,
-0.038110856,
-0.0210736413,
-0.0021847941,
-0.0145772509,
0.0127505781,
0.0140631776,
0.0043078051,
-0.0168048907,
0.0024942171,
0.0312412623,
0.0213465542,
0.00470642,
0.0385924876,
0.024500262,
-0.0114556085,
0.0120551288,
-0.0068570664,
0.04492414,
-0.0199956074,
0.0509145558,
-0.1051864251,
0.0705154017,
-0.0588621534,
-0.0349805281,
0.0461616553,
0.0018616718,
-0.0037414618,
-0.0149258571,
0.0043033091,
0.0162815731,
0.0052438769,
0.041508276,
0.0096148904,
0.1030468047,
0.0269772671,
-0.0032016041,
-0.0071066362,
0.0393514335,
0.0294459853,
0.0297985747,
-0.0058135265,
-0.0246256348,
0.0381872617,
-0.0204545129,
0.0314455517,
-0.0344671682,
-0.0030201999,
0.028281644,
-0.0146716358,
-0.0085220188,
-0.0156000825,
0.0366698168,
-0.0074634957,
0.0159692727,
-0.0708322823,
0.006716569,
0.0348442458,
-0.0221463889,
0.0467215739,
0.0243694466,
0.0238500405,
-0.0476703495,
0.0361525416,
-0.0684347823,
-0.026669234,
0.0377859585,
-0.0267043002,
0.0119085219,
-0.0468600392,
-0.0230775401,
0.0443413854,
-0.0165370516,
0.0011856053,
0.018161634,
-0.0104717771,
0.042921707,
-0.0328300111,
-0.0444726683,
-0.0470468178,
0.0380329452,
-0.0087630125,
-0.0198267233,
-0.0104245096,
0.0282586943,
-0.0220183451,
0.0159083921,
-0.0354088061,
0.0289181136,
-0.0058864639,
-0.0578296557,
0.0466701724,
0.0385521241,
-0.027615279,
0.0757288039,
0.0220256057,
0.0667691082,
0.0282213353,
0.0767838955,
-0.0412260816,
-0.0360454023,
-0.01443219,
0.0342693403,
0.0028591373,
-0.0725835562,
0.0432501286,
0.0183337331,
-0.0368702747,
0.0431260243,
-0.0451218039,
0.0426717661,
0.008265458,
-0.0758378953,
0.0568412468,
-0.0114407251,
-0.0612009019,
0.0379689522,
-0.0276844557,
-0.0067684278,
0.0372872278,
0.0023464381,
-0.0082040811,
0.0975781679,
0.0407455489,
0.011517901,
0.0678073838,
0.0086284298,
0.0041183406,
0.0519115627,
0.0385401174,
-0.0063101999,
-0.0177106336,
0.0485435724,
-0.0333315656,
-0.0201701615,
-0.0250749849,
0.0108164065,
0.0112559032,
-0.0061944686,
-0.0248176139,
-0.0409181528,
-0.0274323002,
0.0300539434,
-0.0348530449,
-0.0555760711,
-0.0301743038,
-0.0065876935,
0.016424872,
0.0078181764,
-0.0245601367,
0.0303916819,
0.0050648311,
-0.0764349848,
0.053216476,
0.0531680249,
0.0212565381,
-0.0449055396,
0.0104563273,
0.0544010699,
-0.0048265387,
0.0057263463,
-0.0541726425,
0.0221701358,
-0.0051671821,
0.0412461907,
0.0084176324,
0.0064227213,
0.0277210437,
0.0326622836,
-0.017435357,
0.0745208114,
-0.0015699059,
0.0417031571,
0.0397357792,
-0.022154171,
0.0315872058,
-0.0014865143,
-0.0503352396,
0.0098018702,
0.0155686252,
0.0061054137,
0.0300400648,
-0.0325984024,
-0.0415504463,
0.0732730031,
-0.0599383563,
0.0083766701,
0.0193814542,
-0.055185575,
-0.023236623,
-0.0226904992,
0.0617851317,
-0.0284633506,
-0.0245625097,
0.003757443,
0.0265898891,
-0.0146446368,
0.0140424492,
-0.0209041703,
-0.0295242257,
0.0333885178,
-0.0837260932,
0.0180498157,
0.0274353176,
0.058453083,
-0.0163218044,
-0.0547512025,
-0.0420799293,
0.0360220224,
0.0385695286,
0.0104279518,
-0.0459853634,
-0.0317603312,
0.0288392678,
-0.0396751203,
0.0140115181,
0.000747388,
-0.0216231402,
-0.0179474652,
0.0370137468,
-0.0220062081,
-0.0388404131,
-0.0700020716,
-0.0308935791,
-0.00641528,
0.0453635938,
0.0123957777,
-0.0523337238,
0.0283211879,
0.0145215038,
-0.0014639292,
0.0616821125,
-0.0981385633,
-0.0324175954,
-0.0062499442,
-0.0146283656,
-0.0681219548,
-0.0423328467,
-0.0171680041,
0.048004929,
-0.0133580724,
-0.1000194401,
-0.0095689632,
-0.0046093664,
-0.0150928181,
0.0459356718,
0.0062996261,
0.026247004,
0.0086391028,
0.0125544295,
0.0341232046,
-0.038256634,
-0.0014958689,
-0.0013354101,
0.0480568483,
-0.0366970561,
0.0642700419,
0.0305194128,
0.0350942314,
-0.0006311674,
0.0018509864,
0.0211153403,
-0.0306375343,
-0.0302440841,
-0.0206191503,
0.0543005206,
0.0126482807,
-0.0426028371,
-0.0313238427,
-0.0025716596,
-0.0207259487,
0.012392181,
-0.0488857105,
-0.024241522,
0.0016289516,
-0.0981865153,
0.0209983215,
0.0239098314,
0.0223022755,
-0.0099842837,
0.007424945,
-0.0042494698,
-0.0670913309,
0.0016106791,
-0.0086925309,
-0.0314672142,
-0.0421950333,
0.0518621355,
0.0665002689,
0.0030694918,
-0.0261170827,
-0.0281612147,
0.0563691705,
-0.0233952589,
-0.005513588,
-0.0036755996,
0.0670350567,
-0.0461012572,
0.0178663265,
-0.02889245,
0.0116768228,
-0.0684764311,
0.0280018374,
0.0176723246,
0.0406743921,
-0.0068846089,
0.0318065844,
-0.0201840159,
0.0292436611,
-0.0380431749,
-0.0661002398,
-0.0344771706,
-0.0729426369,
-0.0423631854,
-0.0179680642,
0.0226045717,
-0.0554204807,
-0.0227156691,
-0.0217863396,
0.0047269175,
-0.0186104551,
-0.0069240127,
-0.005128291,
0.0244994201,
-0.0230951924,
-0.0160306506,
-0.039452374,
0.0116994316,
0.0239162091,
-0.0617901348,
-0.0393665098,
0.0076508513,
-0.0178779941,
0.0025216087,
-0.0261742044,
-0.0126962531,
-0.0660743862,
-0.0893899277,
-0.0453094319,
0.0440688282,
0.0264464691,
-0.0227116998,
-0.0202765651,
0.0358211286,
-0.0066189715,
-0.0377508327,
0.0030393964,
-0.0105935447,
-0.0336775742,
-0.0337323211,
0.0017220065,
-0.0600737222,
-5.646713029e-33,
-0.0286521669,
0.0193163808,
-0.0265088845,
-0.0414534174,
-0.071019493,
-0.0469366089,
-0.0468772911,
-0.0032030337,
-0.0469139777,
-0.0157171134,
0.021318106,
-0.0144517329,
-0.011255322,
-0.0759697258,
0.0471155234,
0.0124756051,
0.0186516326,
0.0050731162,
-0.0378803387,
-0.0386136137,
-0.0319462717,
-0.0408490859,
-0.0034314001,
-0.0970724076,
0.0036225948,
-0.0339229926,
-0.0465166755,
-0.0229549725,
-0.0089281527,
0.0314890668,
-0.0146254264,
-0.0565851443,
-0.0006314819,
0.0166388284,
0.0085416315,
0.0051210583,
-0.0442158729,
0.0084589748,
-0.0164975803,
-0.0172644164,
-0.0333585292,
0.0160625968,
-0.034385141,
-0.0120206708,
-0.0583767258,
-0.0244260114,
0.0113935666,
-0.0303868242,
0.0909758881,
0.0666408911,
-0.0483441763,
-0.0285629928,
0.0105499234,
-0.0334933735,
0.0045482786,
0.0551135652,
-0.0364663899,
-0.0019678248,
-0.0037820367,
-0.0091680968,
-0.0572364256,
-0.0943815932,
0.026504349,
0.058478225,
0.0947269201,
0.0648262426,
0.0251357704,
0.0302804224,
-0.0227455478,
-0.0374783948,
0.0476347543,
0.0729732364,
0.0431713536,
0.0895475894,
0.0066493121,
-0.0378599204,
0.046634797,
0.0480113775,
0.011746888,
0.0447016805,
0.0005328449,
0.048459392,
-0.03637347,
0.0037655635,
0.0400407277,
-0.0663235486,
0.0343152843,
-0.0253206454,
-0.0179661103,
-0.0082918676,
-0.0060597956,
-0.0170674827,
0.0150701143,
-0.0013625451,
0.0118548963,
-0.0004647088,
-0.0076790936,
0.0320532769,
0.0277066026,
-0.0302286055,
-0.0138255628,
-0.0379346982,
0.0083047599,
0.0259431694,
0.0764418617,
0.042373877,
-0.0306199715,
0.0193609465,
0.0148131978,
-0.0280912966,
0.0213801283,
-0.0145363016,
0.0371467173,
-0.0205154903,
0.0349065401,
-0.0347894318,
-0.0015676444,
-0.0056989961,
-0.0213351399,
0.0113296267,
-0.0860460475,
0.0587706305,
-0.0487829,
-0.0010581353,
0.0150938844,
-0.0338634439,
-0.023146078,
0.0496520028,
0.0251676571,
-0.0421372913,
-0.0022986154,
-0.0377442911,
2.927e-7,
-0.0710756704,
-0.0162234344,
0.0325072333,
-0.006125499,
0.0290791038,
0.0671302378,
-0.038494356,
0.0715264007,
0.0127871074,
-0.117425628,
0.0554497093,
0.0191701911,
0.0149838692,
-0.0179847032,
-0.0032981564,
0.0029179838,
-0.0121876597,
-0.0258088149,
0.0284251124,
-0.0144279497,
-0.0684887618,
-0.0140961558,
0.0270145331,
-0.024475351,
0.0394621156,
0.0357907973,
-0.0020135706,
-0.023296915,
0.0337774493,
-0.0581225716,
-0.0475709401,
0.0136001697,
0.0014109556,
-0.0187997259,
0.0153247193,
0.0389570892,
0.0366859585,
0.0195714422,
-0.0473151579,
0.0521664545,
-0.0278077666,
0.0049392832,
-0.0189242531,
-0.0260824058,
0.0198941343,
-0.0274417717,
0.0110350838,
-0.0415111296,
-0.037760064,
-0.0119018396,
0.0114374869,
0.0158629119,
0.025383126,
0.032117147,
-0.0295338668,
0.0065217041,
-0.008443716,
0.0130920717,
0.0355896652,
-0.0163259488,
-0.0659598112,
-0.0617756508,
0.023027638,
0.028845828,
-0.0243805014,
-0.0520167165,
-0.014723544,
2.271496815e-34,
-0.0364816189,
0.0637581572,
0.037503276,
-0.0188029967,
0.0694456324,
-0.0025698699,
0.0068953126,
0.0246112905,
0.0742643028,
-0.0008736007,
-0.0128067294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11220v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11220v1 | KG-GPT: A General Framework for Reasoning on Knowledge Graphs Using Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T12:51:35 | 2023-10-17T12:51:35 | Jiho Kim, Yeonsu Kwon, Yohan Jo, Edward Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have made considerable advancements in
understanding and generating unstructured text, their application in structured
data remains underexplored. Particularly, using LLMs for complex reasoning
tasks on knowledge graphs (KGs) remains largely untouched. To address this, we
propose KG-GPT, a multi-purpose framework leveraging LLMs for tasks employing
KGs. KG-GPT comprises three steps: Sentence Segmentation, Graph Retrieval, and
Inference, each aimed at partitioning sentences, retrieving relevant graph
components, and deriving logical conclusions, respectively. We evaluate KG-GPT
using KG-based fact verification and KGQA benchmarks, with the model showing
competitive and robust performance, even outperforming several fully-supervised
models. Our work, therefore, marks a significant step in unifying structured
and unstructured data processing within the realm of LLMs. | [
0.0329687931,
0.009775226,
0.0102519253,
0.0626988783,
-0.0626986995,
0.0130754067,
0.0060378648,
-0.0058596642,
0.0937046781,
-0.0415366627,
0.0323999226,
0.0070465859,
-0.0377502181,
0.0269956775,
0.0085846726,
-0.0255246684,
0.032405559,
-0.0262878872,
0.0624404699,
0.0004493427,
0.0107193301,
0.0278273709,
0.0006953663,
-0.0306217335,
-0.0356220193,
-0.0232834499,
0.0205201898,
0.0061219777,
0.0051658475,
-0.0235212985,
-0.0181436799,
-0.0139047811,
0.00962622,
0.0133514907,
0.0000015952,
-0.0372151434,
-0.0431811437,
-0.000512679,
-0.0409749784,
0.0153272403,
-0.0138059827,
-0.016406931,
0.019250771,
0.0060512242,
-0.0408699997,
-0.0416021422,
-0.0086316373,
0.0813614577,
0.0544221774,
0.0967880264,
-0.0309858508,
-0.0628605634,
-0.023942925,
0.0081225103,
-0.0172165651,
-0.0120360544,
0.0661152601,
0.0735028386,
0.0135431821,
0.0118757281,
0.0189069826,
0.0273767728,
0.0068279873,
0.0177541133,
0.0064218598,
0.0341689065,
-0.0495572127,
0.0418108962,
0.0163958352,
0.0668268204,
0.0252343081,
-0.0085493289,
0.0305883698,
-0.0056026848,
-0.0182954837,
0.0273284987,
-0.0242091771,
0.0310205352,
-0.042092938,
0.0353409499,
0.0005418326,
-0.0557257608,
0.0719661638,
-0.0115924589,
-0.0464686193,
0.1423510462,
0.0050407513,
-0.0272344686,
0.0134864915,
0.0135835176,
-0.0774795413,
-0.0344172753,
0.021812439,
0.0453004465,
-0.0065951808,
0.0263451487,
0.0050802375,
0.0242071617,
-0.0080216108,
-0.0441040136,
-0.0294057298,
-0.0326151103,
0.0098477053,
0.0803767592,
-0.0317686535,
0.0190627594,
-0.0290968269,
0.0075475927,
-0.0199832283,
-0.0409358703,
-0.0574124642,
-0.0248903353,
-0.0009872257,
0.0357727148,
-0.0496146902,
-0.0253338628,
-0.0216664094,
0.0334689431,
-0.0027703177,
0.0328285284,
0.0749402568,
-0.0128646949,
0.0536397547,
-0.031360928,
-0.037488088,
0.0240398869,
-0.0173274633,
0.0165616609,
-0.0099540502,
0.0057816408,
-0.0023833003,
0.0203864947,
0.0453187525,
-0.0309049245,
0.0156091088,
0.0347259864,
0.035480693,
-0.0064921821,
-0.0550226606,
-0.0764177516,
-0.0609680079,
-0.0891922414,
0.0344475582,
-0.0810400322,
0.0247559659,
0.0349830762,
-0.0194061585,
0.0033494767,
0.0145586012,
-0.0067033395,
-0.0470553003,
0.0326836929,
-0.0097600836,
0.0182832666,
-0.0096932584,
-0.0061565004,
0.0080643231,
0.029128138,
0.0296851546,
0.0070947381,
0.0436664484,
0.031263236,
-0.0241729412,
0.0194500387,
0.0055088829,
0.0010238884,
0.0309547074,
0.0044496031,
0.0085020512,
-0.0072278045,
-0.0372840799,
0.0660724267,
-0.0231797677,
0.0223816317,
0.0220582876,
0.0010848922,
-0.0111730853,
-0.0120376414,
0.0207504705,
0.0142451599,
0.0032088449,
0.0089837164,
-0.0338606797,
-0.0435031317,
-0.0122036943,
0.0370350629,
-0.0019469847,
-0.0017061328,
0.0073922547,
-0.0308582392,
-0.0484044328,
0.0141278123,
0.0152330212,
0.0132614197,
0.089089103,
-0.0260466076,
-0.0316114463,
0.0312173311,
0.0116221812,
-0.0347226225,
-0.0147466166,
0.0132591361,
-0.0023474633,
0.0491023362,
0.0583991483,
-0.0427290462,
-0.0194024537,
0.0279847849,
-0.0092734853,
-0.0116073331,
0.0089662801,
-0.0144061139,
-0.0316124111,
-0.042937018,
-0.0208088737,
-0.0263318457,
0.0118669691,
-0.014111503,
0.0530255772,
0.0227269493,
0.0244630165,
-0.076554358,
0.0050724698,
0.0026067595,
0.0243612546,
-0.0045331558,
0.0022570828,
-0.0048685311,
0.0067104776,
0.0156972855,
-0.023060061,
0.0186503306,
0.0153962271,
-0.0167333353,
-0.0101544913,
0.0026830973,
-0.0099437134,
-0.1138166264,
0.0523609966,
0.0150470212,
-0.0404574089,
-0.0177993979,
-0.0688500851,
-0.0424649268,
-0.0032388521,
0.0126783177,
0.0472448245,
-0.0305645708,
-0.0264603794,
0.0390350148,
-0.0456912965,
0.0086659435,
0.1081239507,
0.0144438464,
-0.0188079439,
-0.0308327079,
-0.0457579792,
0.0123090716,
-0.0442530327,
0.0012223858,
0.0131960483,
-0.0092177624,
0.0163284298,
0.0095663434,
-0.0332170315,
-0.0462565832,
0.0251728874,
-0.0981684029,
0.044078894,
0.00313311,
0.0280474611,
-0.013778571,
-0.0180216543,
-0.0069543631,
0.0097102746,
-0.0415324531,
0.0109082693,
0.0590039082,
-0.0013364495,
0.0408376232,
-0.0284945071,
0.0099530751,
0.0071509192,
-0.030079456,
-0.0466795787,
0.0748602897,
0.0055723866,
-0.0256765578,
-0.0078359274,
0.0420570225,
-0.0520431474,
0.0154808844,
-0.0120442938,
0.0486947224,
0.0020483441,
-0.0411241278,
0.0584139451,
0.0661681443,
-0.048576057,
0.0105776098,
0.02566926,
-0.033098001,
0.0091496166,
0.0169913005,
-0.0270459559,
0.0110982955,
-0.0446223691,
-0.0046687797,
0.0074782986,
0.0198450629,
0.015268242,
-0.0426712446,
-0.039143838,
-0.031005742,
-0.0212054085,
0.0367469341,
-0.0189780146,
0.0070145712,
0.0288179386,
0.0093261143,
-0.0339896865,
0.0139084123,
0.0571837686,
-0.0366571806,
0.0267708153,
0.0075039286,
-0.024458997,
-0.0460595861,
0.0596026108,
0.0197849292,
-0.001229842,
-0.0226253495,
0.0059066364,
-0.0106830057,
-0.0200447477,
0.0631002262,
-0.0074610813,
0.0333495066,
-0.0221764874,
0.0235969704,
0.0276581571,
0.0035058192,
-0.0041538193,
0.0318120755,
-0.069179222,
0.0218696818,
0.0117720943,
-0.0061751055,
-0.0119830593,
0.0235524308,
-0.0023724858,
-0.0071749599,
-0.0118483044,
0.0262643639,
-0.0269370731,
0.0574026294,
0.0496448465,
-0.026094038,
0.0208048504,
-0.0371576138,
0.0235129669,
0.0604222603,
0.0044426676,
-0.0171493478,
-0.0001511135,
-0.0011156546,
-0.0535700917,
-0.0299028009,
0.0002641404,
-0.021184558,
0.0501264296,
-0.0564248897,
0.0060121594,
0.0980135649,
0.0242622551,
0.0229292344,
-0.0314404964,
0.0361726321,
0.0193899684,
-0.0003593688,
0.0082415827,
-0.1132156774,
-0.0283214077,
-0.0081556486,
0.0073629725,
0.0086255921,
-0.056639757,
0.0017167,
-0.1026664376,
0.0558717325,
0.0146457236,
0.0082024261,
-0.0687416121,
-0.074925825,
-0.0131873442,
0.006700187,
-0.0648200512,
-0.0017229145,
-0.0099955108,
0.0073151928,
-0.0084520429,
-0.0116821658,
-0.0116183562,
0.0440962091,
-0.0204098187,
0.0117938872,
-0.0325623751,
0.0272412989,
0.0239175428,
-0.0009816817,
0.0237669107,
0.0067187632,
-0.0515747368,
0.0026645835,
-0.0084046014,
-0.0253044926,
0.0118605066,
-0.0574384406,
0.0229379591,
-0.0550393239,
-0.0251166597,
0.0260610972,
0.1151453257,
0.0133919399,
-0.0699497983,
0.0180364847,
-0.0107374731,
-0.0297198351,
0.0548858643,
0.0106638772,
0.0574510433,
-0.0661941096,
-0.0066265021,
-0.0181192849,
-0.0067637078,
-0.009535227,
0.0366608091,
-0.0413563997,
0.0423746668,
-0.0579012185,
-0.0163646918,
0.0525368936,
0.0128619168,
-0.0459340848,
0.011857463,
0.0448384695,
-0.0101191672,
-0.0584015511,
0.0280905403,
-0.0564387478,
0.002347185,
-0.0180855934,
0.0129967136,
-0.0090922359,
-0.0082156891,
-0.0212801509,
0.0123869153,
-0.0739110634,
-0.0782011375,
-0.0284833182,
-0.0234423615,
0.0072702565,
0.0759368092,
-0.0294523314,
0.0395054035,
0.0455196612,
0.0334577896,
-0.0492559895,
-0.0055864346,
0.0065635014,
-0.0036547638,
-0.0000537364,
0.0159355942,
-0.0676307157,
0.0117674517,
0.0199176148,
0.0501951538,
-0.0271446109,
-0.0397541672,
0.0119130956,
0.0991127789,
0.0270831697,
0.0380030982,
-0.0064143841,
-0.0448968187,
-0.0043109329,
-0.0352655873,
-0.0327964872,
-0.022534892,
0.004613589,
-0.0040998133,
0.0025636305,
-0.0219757445,
-0.0294500533,
0.0149216922,
0.0342723541,
-0.0001319479,
-0.0226315428,
0.0277394969,
-0.0313462876,
0.0398926362,
-0.0582760759,
-0.0074873939,
0.0217023361,
0.0005899567,
0.0006777734,
-0.0114688752,
0.0378343835,
0.0398037955,
-0.0451101772,
-0.0696137473,
-0.0136491247,
-0.064809218,
-0.0071986122,
0.0238603204,
0.0375730023,
0.0554405302,
-0.0028384167,
0.0264110025,
-0.0377373211,
-0.0258776993,
-0.0216617174,
0.0521896333,
0.026323732,
-0.0124722468,
0.0111240735,
0.0322875492,
-0.0438560359,
0.003767319,
0.0433326028,
0.0479154587,
0.029777756,
0.035311494,
-0.0834243298,
-0.0346600451,
-0.0615335591,
-0.0345403589,
0.0101270275,
-0.0146451341,
0.0225328095,
-0.0305643175,
-0.0884564668,
0.0105973743,
0.0177216791,
-0.0151943257,
0.0077858781,
0.0024530375,
0.0621645227,
0.0471491665,
-0.0430523343,
-0.0330077112,
0.0348235816,
-0.0187244322,
-0.0059800586,
0.0416078009,
-5.60319329e-33,
0.0067916997,
-0.0590684377,
0.0442771614,
0.0237154905,
-0.0313661695,
0.0071653775,
-0.0424737036,
-0.0173211563,
-0.0307148155,
0.0408241563,
0.0051361416,
0.0406218171,
0.0095770089,
0.0255615041,
-0.0311591588,
-0.0101113748,
0.0069097336,
0.0218932815,
0.0017385373,
0.0218245853,
0.0452798381,
0.0057609845,
0.0621023811,
-0.0381441936,
0.0382845625,
-0.0177061595,
0.0263789222,
0.0402273871,
-0.0291604232,
0.0337833241,
-0.01846583,
0.0426956415,
0.0431375355,
-0.0058904216,
0.0383454002,
0.0064652478,
-0.0804933682,
-0.0173948463,
0.0417966768,
-0.0178821646,
-0.0234598164,
-0.0143705448,
0.0378884599,
0.0067872242,
0.0632479712,
-0.0591219962,
0.0397646353,
-0.0050061778,
-0.0252355244,
-0.0441269092,
-0.0319569632,
0.0625868291,
0.004445265,
0.0288386755,
0.0219598785,
-0.0046421108,
-0.0018635774,
0.0062811552,
-0.0494786762,
0.0275350921,
0.0169367045,
-0.0119002517,
0.0110414829,
0.0195443537,
0.0092929788,
0.0279547218,
-0.0403938219,
-0.0148589388,
-0.0719073117,
0.0244993474,
-0.0093961777,
0.0722973794,
-0.0240677707,
0.014429437,
-0.0355555862,
-0.0023244387,
-0.1217487901,
-0.0140393944,
0.0140998838,
0.0099903941,
-0.0049845707,
0.0209318828,
-0.0144645162,
-0.0442004241,
0.0135424482,
-0.002081028,
-0.0113763688,
0.0136751486,
0.0078171743,
-0.0199449454,
-0.0113456808,
0.0071154665,
0.0131736109,
-0.0538454354,
-0.0035000863,
0.0369049087,
-0.0017200062,
0.0014587841,
-0.0259372406,
0.0709012821,
-0.0757289454,
-0.0030914578,
0.0158737041,
-0.0409450531,
-0.0291969348,
0.0150261559,
0.0300861578,
-0.0266401041,
-0.0244810805,
0.0040298565,
-0.0244519971,
-0.0053415727,
-0.0481040478,
-0.0008223727,
0.0436865017,
0.0679211318,
0.0216123089,
0.0351716504,
0.0459003076,
0.0309249908,
-0.0047214855,
0.0496937633,
0.0033776544,
0.0161795598,
-0.0027794309,
0.0019558554,
-0.0303974543,
-0.0060877767,
-0.0177693292,
-0.0471072495,
0.002917819,
0.0028666328,
2.47e-7,
0.0536884964,
0.0302412733,
0.0237405449,
0.0468400307,
0.0124778049,
0.0197614525,
-0.0094334809,
-0.0140935769,
0.0085948389,
-0.042284593,
0.0451168157,
0.0728163272,
-0.0284613241,
0.0484968536,
-0.0667567626,
0.0587256365,
-0.0439477488,
-0.0812556297,
-0.0810579509,
-0.0047178888,
0.0682549551,
0.0429737829,
0.0446655191,
-0.0116321836,
-0.0041600503,
-0.0682490543,
0.0311897155,
0.0246704482,
-0.0369888954,
-0.01234785,
0.0309343915,
0.0002347837,
-0.0099480636,
0.0510401316,
0.0360082909,
0.0217840634,
0.0146206478,
0.0772192776,
-0.0084855026,
0.0187567752,
0.0044783484,
-0.0325749777,
0.0026603625,
-0.0328503922,
0.1129057929,
-0.0268049538,
-0.0126605071,
0.0085345944,
-0.034837544,
-0.0753502995,
-0.0363120548,
0.0250854101,
0.0090777362,
0.0064252228,
0.0121883666,
-0.0245013498,
0.0083331885,
-0.0563588813,
0.009887849,
0.0340592489,
-0.038514901,
-0.039038118,
0.0226654895,
0.0134151662,
0.0165568683,
-0.0371602997,
0.0350115374,
2.387029083e-34,
0.0325426981,
0.0266508181,
-0.0225170366,
-0.015249338,
0.084279649,
-0.0271097664,
-0.0598231219,
0.0017950665,
-0.0064855344,
-0.1106841788,
0.0040789763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11207v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11207v1 | Can Large Language Models Explain Themselves? A Study of LLM-Generated Self-Explanations | 2023-10-17T12:34:32 | 2023-10-17T12:34:32 | Shiyuan Huang, Siddarth Mamidanna, Shreedhar Jangam, Yilun Zhou, Leilani H. Gilpin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have demonstrated superior
performance on a variety of natural language processing (NLP) tasks including
sentiment analysis, mathematical reasoning and summarization. Furthermore,
since these models are instruction-tuned on human conversations to produce
"helpful" responses, they can and often will produce explanations along with
the response, which we call self-explanations. For example, when analyzing the
sentiment of a movie review, the model may output not only the positivity of
the sentiment, but also an explanation (e.g., by listing the sentiment-laden
words such as "fantastic" and "memorable" in the review). How good are these
automatically generated self-explanations? In this paper, we investigate this
question on the task of sentiment analysis and for feature attribution
explanation, one of the most commonly studied settings in the interpretability
literature (for pre-ChatGPT models). Specifically, we study different ways to
elicit the self-explanations, evaluate their faithfulness on a set of
evaluation metrics, and compare them to traditional explanation methods such as
occlusion or LIME saliency maps. Through an extensive set of experiments, we
find that ChatGPT's self-explanations perform on par with traditional ones, but
are quite different from them according to various agreement metrics, meanwhile
being much cheaper to produce (as they are generated along with the
prediction). In addition, we identified several interesting characteristics of
them, which prompt us to rethink many current model interpretability practices
in the era of ChatGPT(-like) LLMs. | [
0.0386613607,
0.0240035001,
-0.0036988219,
0.0633165911,
-0.0342335328,
0.0146095399,
0.0030577492,
-0.0201631766,
0.013859868,
-0.0564981289,
-0.0159083419,
-0.0063242344,
0.0034451925,
0.0441562869,
-0.0034135338,
-0.0466902629,
-0.0059018624,
-0.0171317291,
0.0265080798,
-0.0094048688,
0.0010356019,
0.004783609,
0.0116644334,
0.0451768897,
0.0142877558,
-0.0104207769,
-0.0206283163,
-0.0182045642,
-0.0222504586,
0.0098022427,
-0.0402955227,
0.0172653869,
0.0142333405,
0.0083878972,
0.0000020013,
-0.0292291455,
-0.0061487355,
-0.0073068412,
-0.0396044776,
0.0506669469,
0.0386006571,
-0.0058993376,
0.0182186291,
0.0031505313,
-0.0238150172,
0.0240452215,
0.0561118759,
0.0422389731,
0.0729878992,
0.0754517242,
0.0011617778,
-0.0439623781,
-0.0118598295,
-0.0107156346,
0.0236514881,
-0.0174437985,
-0.0243504532,
0.0325956754,
-0.0195538253,
0.0252320636,
-0.0290588364,
0.0251884814,
0.0140086412,
-0.0474862792,
0.0489769317,
0.016660532,
-0.0172172114,
-0.0263909157,
-0.0016385353,
0.0353903808,
0.0136214243,
-0.0279507209,
0.0015504344,
0.0038900208,
-0.0137762781,
0.023468012,
-0.0650178418,
0.0057303794,
0.0249505173,
0.0289919488,
0.0126883248,
0.0285449177,
0.052534949,
0.0162987597,
-0.0190979242,
0.0651623607,
-0.0196024254,
-0.0044367481,
-0.0597658753,
0.010031946,
-0.039655745,
-0.0482289232,
-0.0064100758,
0.0545769893,
0.0257619265,
0.0342048965,
0.0104962951,
0.0457020514,
0.0073869391,
-0.0634737164,
0.0294722505,
0.0167305022,
-0.0414492115,
0.0624440312,
-0.0061797975,
0.0583325289,
-0.0124430414,
0.0119138351,
-0.0409690849,
-0.0098970048,
-0.0787297934,
-0.0239245072,
0.0029947418,
0.020546563,
-0.0150840897,
-0.0024980814,
-0.0473949127,
0.0214141421,
-0.0230106004,
-0.0108430348,
0.0152199958,
0.0229369365,
-0.0001414488,
-0.0291256588,
-0.0483707227,
0.020304108,
-0.0366740599,
-0.0114743542,
-0.0133652613,
-0.04554943,
-0.0055318042,
0.04185763,
0.0066121202,
0.0196944587,
-0.009749922,
0.0829321519,
0.0380854048,
-0.0239515156,
-0.0130661307,
-0.0574066825,
-0.0570814274,
-0.0663627461,
-0.0123926345,
-0.0424489416,
0.0082974574,
0.0223881286,
-0.0201426558,
-0.0095389951,
0.0022768469,
-0.0227300748,
-0.0456716642,
0.0706395879,
-0.0290141907,
0.0347819701,
-0.0221497323,
0.0024526373,
-0.0084158042,
0.0565758236,
0.0342600793,
0.0431409106,
0.0497403778,
-0.0558406599,
0.0571214259,
-0.0131168785,
0.0217545256,
-0.0016074016,
-0.0215012357,
-0.0034585071,
-0.0545994528,
0.0128798112,
0.0173113067,
0.0269471034,
-0.011491213,
-0.0110227298,
0.0362369902,
0.058372397,
0.0215151422,
0.0598558225,
0.0283658113,
0.0190227106,
0.0125406906,
0.0651456639,
-0.0576226115,
0.0467514247,
-0.0332445502,
0.0073667071,
0.0285228044,
-0.027749069,
-0.026954852,
-0.0925241411,
-0.0255310368,
-0.0033958973,
0.0090916045,
0.0160800926,
0.0698977709,
0.0066130171,
0.0004721968,
0.0333567262,
0.0392980985,
-0.054951597,
0.0033148569,
-0.0993960798,
0.0498913042,
0.1021301672,
0.0356780551,
-0.0150677944,
0.0019092339,
0.0046662521,
-0.014377065,
0.0098083317,
0.0488144532,
0.0093202172,
0.0176659748,
-0.0101695294,
-0.0115057947,
-0.0600699596,
0.0378353521,
0.0326117724,
-0.0216224454,
-0.044644393,
0.0181934927,
-0.0477275774,
-0.0368728265,
0.000387519,
0.0058943122,
-0.022924155,
0.0176005252,
-0.0190980136,
0.035871774,
0.0568069965,
-0.0065055774,
0.0260837097,
0.0144409863,
-0.0168434717,
-0.0371694937,
0.0592471994,
-0.0539338663,
-0.0456919186,
0.0017766058,
-0.0286994968,
-0.0137511771,
0.0063934075,
-0.029349003,
-0.0465989597,
0.047243204,
-0.042535346,
0.0646080449,
-0.029416021,
0.0114458054,
-0.0066422387,
0.0044494234,
-0.0062999087,
0.0462465957,
-0.0004076904,
0.012486618,
-0.0365846343,
0.000467436,
0.0140060214,
-0.0078665828,
-0.0014618899,
0.0088914502,
0.0029315427,
0.0073176012,
0.0399382412,
-0.0222156532,
-0.0200358592,
-0.0301050376,
-0.0983541533,
-0.0200341549,
-0.0227979869,
0.0085354261,
0.0504554175,
-0.015557589,
0.0146961492,
-0.0074891136,
-0.0458749644,
-0.0244597644,
0.0115164658,
0.0177157708,
0.0508942381,
0.0040999074,
-0.0275014043,
-0.0502557941,
-0.0136578288,
-0.0335323103,
0.0596104003,
0.0398579761,
0.0009888432,
-0.0674272627,
0.0188755225,
-0.0275573097,
-0.0151759256,
-0.031291686,
-0.0544635355,
0.0174738262,
-0.0052665547,
-0.0230265576,
0.0636197925,
0.00779182,
0.0836943313,
0.0443936437,
0.015142275,
-0.0514406525,
-0.0253195334,
-0.0574905314,
-0.0146812377,
-0.0148420772,
-0.0526405685,
-0.0044852593,
0.0854210928,
-0.002281267,
0.0003897778,
-0.0611166656,
0.0118356002,
0.0054140487,
-0.0085164485,
-0.0185315516,
-0.0283747986,
0.0251602493,
0.0593065098,
-0.0014518524,
-0.078447327,
0.0551810861,
-0.046703279,
-0.0064779446,
-0.0216753073,
-0.0270209294,
-0.0707497001,
0.088304542,
-0.002476752,
0.0060718511,
0.0145726027,
-0.0090685254,
0.0106473872,
-0.0454773717,
0.0425735749,
-0.0206679478,
0.047363475,
-0.0239430349,
-0.007035186,
0.043213468,
-0.0120466566,
-0.0120154712,
-0.0672816113,
-0.0468571596,
-0.0185558498,
0.0245300084,
-0.0186674707,
-0.0048830803,
0.0379033536,
0.0087350206,
-0.0349722616,
-0.0290652253,
-0.0050012469,
0.0043049389,
0.007171487,
0.0307433195,
0.0352595635,
0.0365220346,
-0.016987795,
0.0332916789,
0.0363990776,
-0.0014820484,
0.0002022593,
-0.0418192223,
0.004532434,
-0.0176803637,
-0.0102705806,
-0.0326849595,
-0.0192415956,
0.0673612207,
-0.0744437426,
0.0134454435,
0.1275019944,
0.012301621,
-0.0429322794,
0.0059032319,
-0.0087316483,
0.0007949052,
0.0115640033,
-0.0135802897,
-0.0366938598,
-0.0234589782,
-0.0120735317,
0.0282106455,
-0.0028035552,
0.0134252962,
-0.0334938541,
-0.0867145583,
0.0577142313,
-0.0065530837,
-0.0045953277,
-0.0278113782,
-0.0667790473,
-0.0156477131,
-0.0369083583,
-0.0197291542,
-0.0123586087,
0.0101696206,
0.0284020007,
0.0156974997,
-0.0627054051,
-0.0189229306,
0.0354965888,
-0.0062894546,
0.0564170554,
0.0698661283,
0.0534229614,
-0.0008988563,
-0.0027253546,
0.0215213597,
0.0100812037,
0.0390084796,
-0.0038868212,
0.0898517892,
0.008397636,
-0.0186104644,
-0.0202138387,
0.0326408669,
-0.0360857472,
-0.0038147713,
-0.004861644,
0.0363583304,
-0.0182687044,
-0.0302689224,
-0.0265729856,
0.042478621,
-0.0186543055,
0.1111668348,
0.0513736047,
-0.0148126706,
-0.0396892577,
-0.0435741767,
-0.0109405778,
-0.0096670343,
-0.0682016462,
-0.0030720078,
0.0210664682,
-0.0398903564,
-0.0364138298,
-0.0580105521,
-0.0145896161,
0.0083614755,
-0.0083095031,
-0.0127005801,
-0.0187193882,
0.0058216876,
-0.0035190796,
0.0416172557,
-0.0017602349,
-0.0321902707,
-0.0064832177,
-0.0291212704,
0.0393214971,
-0.0453557037,
-0.0000718711,
-0.0202434938,
-0.0410605595,
-0.0387884714,
0.0134199737,
0.0375976488,
0.0329440534,
0.0707668737,
0.0048237983,
-0.0545828082,
0.0062655099,
0.0424387567,
-0.0595466122,
0.0013155502,
0.0463047735,
0.064986974,
0.0126625886,
0.0505282879,
-0.0342469737,
0.0370870344,
-0.0126952538,
0.008113957,
-0.0297911931,
-0.0355839953,
0.0295105893,
0.0159390308,
0.0630720332,
0.0068739001,
0.0082448442,
0.0048862603,
-0.0106867356,
-0.0371454135,
-0.0184368305,
-0.069588989,
0.0334885195,
-0.0112306913,
-0.0232132934,
-0.0226267297,
-0.026565576,
-0.0566467494,
0.0009856422,
-0.0255264286,
0.0291434471,
0.0021948474,
-0.0387280993,
-0.0189484786,
0.017382985,
-0.0245159753,
0.0093884775,
-0.013577885,
0.0095854755,
0.0245063938,
0.0456191413,
0.0097559961,
0.0020125029,
-0.0124450652,
0.0101702893,
-0.0951400176,
-0.0494522825,
-0.0066431416,
0.046428483,
0.0247094352,
-0.026100941,
0.0670442656,
-0.0326846354,
-0.0154661881,
-0.0031643093,
0.0790799931,
0.0290893614,
-0.0189374983,
0.0031824464,
0.0232318658,
-0.042350322,
-0.0312082637,
0.0651890561,
-0.0074729286,
0.0052258242,
0.0430822559,
-0.0366120003,
-0.0227060858,
-0.0172390249,
-0.0068722772,
0.0010994375,
0.0294381082,
0.0319169536,
-0.071527414,
-0.0727357492,
0.01077531,
-0.017733328,
0.0126240104,
-0.0477260761,
0.0096740127,
0.0794708878,
-0.0086845104,
0.0134335887,
-0.0568463989,
0.0362006277,
-0.0416897684,
0.0268229935,
0.0143664591,
-6.275846055e-33,
-0.0108066201,
-0.060364645,
-0.0132631781,
0.0275661945,
0.0094335424,
0.0001675854,
-0.0509822182,
0.0226564035,
-0.0044448455,
0.0584030487,
0.0013754716,
0.0384794101,
0.005850886,
0.015966367,
0.0071021444,
-0.038210284,
0.0437132008,
0.0058862367,
-0.0310750026,
0.0445570238,
0.0493826121,
-0.0073802527,
0.0609500706,
-0.1029712707,
0.0612353943,
-0.0085520679,
-0.0331321694,
0.0221567173,
0.007221695,
0.0767274648,
-0.0276044589,
0.0500158742,
0.0292252973,
-0.051120095,
-0.0076697916,
0.0134253046,
-0.0386263989,
-0.0274714697,
0.0486269072,
-0.0017907553,
-0.0566887856,
-0.0244029108,
0.0632967055,
-0.0138887418,
-0.0237278324,
-0.0277797151,
0.044684425,
-0.0219215043,
-0.0020732798,
-0.0038368027,
-0.0198734142,
0.0402314328,
-0.0421258137,
-0.0611553155,
0.0482140034,
0.0115676383,
0.003756833,
0.0403461084,
0.0001849755,
0.0221031513,
0.031044839,
0.0358569697,
0.064366363,
-0.0210999325,
0.0128101092,
0.0720485747,
0.0408851877,
0.0151928198,
-0.0771768466,
-0.0135138826,
-0.0192629769,
0.0454250723,
0.0656402782,
0.0324226394,
0.0325076953,
0.0207258314,
-0.0314726941,
-0.0011968348,
-0.0117677003,
0.0012917368,
0.0737398267,
0.0026671072,
-0.0616150983,
-0.0221121516,
-0.031709753,
-0.0325586684,
-0.0391891003,
-0.0475307256,
0.0019191777,
-0.0162772313,
-0.0551353209,
-0.0307981241,
-0.0090352111,
-0.0760705993,
-0.0039086533,
0.0338512994,
-0.0566440709,
0.0046389764,
0.0215434711,
0.0006258974,
0.0015273102,
0.0100441203,
-0.0523617826,
0.028239768,
0.0161641445,
0.0156682916,
0.0367142707,
0.0173541959,
-0.0407638662,
-0.0051627294,
-0.0539241396,
-0.0191409085,
-0.0457501598,
-0.0256004408,
0.0224508885,
0.0234638099,
-0.0521293767,
0.0651053786,
-0.0002334967,
0.0563076437,
-0.0214126818,
0.0271482281,
-0.0247846078,
0.0082364716,
-0.0208133366,
-0.0297906622,
0.0008047677,
-0.0507657304,
0.0370406322,
-0.0330380127,
-0.0262928922,
0.0084183877,
2.642e-7,
0.0485570952,
0.0551542975,
0.0232601501,
-0.0085624391,
0.0431699418,
0.0627314225,
0.0074114371,
-0.0203484464,
0.02771415,
-0.0525995195,
0.017411191,
0.0455386415,
0.031499438,
0.0096000321,
-0.0476467013,
0.0383359455,
-0.0538172908,
-0.0384069271,
0.006252123,
0.0195246115,
0.0751653612,
0.0931997597,
0.0261426829,
0.0162854251,
-0.0044380771,
-0.0373681821,
0.0563234054,
-0.0561796501,
-0.0325166024,
0.0305968095,
0.040948011,
0.0107491305,
-0.0044309129,
-0.0277548451,
0.0098487362,
0.0038033768,
-0.0029890335,
0.0752013475,
0.0083461767,
-0.0347226523,
-0.0173384808,
-0.0185337886,
0.0251664259,
-0.0582364798,
0.0688594729,
-0.0628107041,
-0.0745551214,
-0.0851094648,
0.0131526198,
-0.0216123909,
0.0074993558,
0.0007678398,
-0.0010773826,
0.0301412698,
-0.024139002,
-0.0455563441,
0.0073431125,
-0.0849606469,
-0.0526283793,
-0.0081413453,
-0.0356935002,
-0.0179305803,
-0.0133940233,
0.0231649596,
0.0549734235,
-0.0583249182,
0.0001399708,
2.348771104e-34,
0.0700565055,
0.0065416163,
0.0000238646,
0.0100392662,
0.0389386378,
0.0174422786,
0.0005410269,
-0.0039547309,
0.0734503195,
-0.0321239606,
-0.0109381471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11191v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11191v2 | Medical Text Simplification: Optimizing for Readability with Unlikelihood Training and Reranked Beam Search Decoding | 2023-10-17T12:14:03 | 2023-10-26T02:54:41 | Lorenzo Jaime Yu Flores, Heyuan Huang, Kejian Shi, Sophie Chheang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text simplification has emerged as an increasingly useful application of AI
for bridging the communication gap in specialized fields such as medicine,
where the lexicon is often dominated by technical jargon and complex
constructs. Despite notable progress, methods in medical simplification
sometimes result in the generated text having lower quality and diversity. In
this work, we explore ways to further improve the readability of text
simplification in the medical domain. We propose (1) a new unlikelihood loss
that encourages generation of simpler terms and (2) a reranked beam search
decoding method that optimizes for simplicity, which achieve better performance
on readability metrics on three datasets. This study's findings offer promising
avenues for improving text simplification in the medical field. | [
0.0172989052,
0.0118140979,
0.0013274256,
-0.026467327,
-0.0086205108,
0.0276709255,
-0.0064487066,
0.0627053753,
0.0142549807,
0.0399206132,
0.0009804461,
-0.0116846124,
0.0384331048,
0.0117537538,
0.0056231604,
-0.0696432814,
0.0300601199,
0.0269593485,
0.0637099445,
-0.0220356546,
-0.008611585,
-0.0042102952,
-0.0301723424,
0.033272244,
0.036837589,
-0.0093693873,
0.0523264185,
0.0410727039,
0.0269405898,
-0.051719185,
0.0076508406,
0.0195387155,
-0.036958769,
-0.0074193603,
0.000001997,
0.000502342,
-0.0298243295,
0.022845367,
-0.0023938415,
0.0160993636,
0.0974100679,
-0.0603167005,
0.011925647,
0.0116152493,
-0.020713076,
-0.0482529439,
0.0609382987,
0.0593470223,
0.0290180482,
0.04831101,
-0.018116938,
-0.0401278771,
-0.0184330922,
-0.0214021225,
0.0341876,
-0.0248614755,
0.0174870808,
-0.0275002494,
-0.0193485562,
0.0092138899,
-0.0150696849,
0.0641886741,
-0.0092574805,
0.0050556278,
0.0539780296,
0.0644398108,
-0.021784015,
-0.0064975512,
0.0218682848,
0.0687739253,
-0.0230688639,
-0.0685128197,
0.0389601588,
-0.0178016964,
-0.0229333714,
0.036996495,
-0.0323181674,
-0.0266913828,
-0.0037358527,
0.0136941951,
0.0083297817,
0.0193306878,
0.0309736319,
0.0015215647,
0.0003542066,
-0.0162219796,
0.0249557607,
-0.0358662009,
-0.0001586823,
-0.0226325858,
-0.0039204783,
-0.0215113107,
0.0793853402,
0.001688342,
-0.0307262316,
0.0154319331,
-0.0499446541,
-0.0844035819,
0.0541449301,
-0.0353068151,
0.0130467387,
0.018251393,
0.0260028057,
0.0230076648,
-0.0388286449,
0.0188890044,
0.0128711704,
0.0065349876,
-0.0758016407,
0.0352415144,
-0.0011440607,
-0.00586566,
-0.0201302599,
0.0319821574,
-0.0301039964,
-0.0092680128,
-0.0780792832,
-0.0558104962,
0.0173708815,
-0.0267016627,
0.0042803707,
0.0370440781,
-0.0687151477,
-0.032509841,
0.0215228274,
0.0568843149,
-0.0143799037,
0.0014590458,
-0.0287892781,
-0.0420268513,
-0.0176252499,
0.0381183103,
0.0283493102,
0.0158696566,
-0.0162363704,
0.0023495259,
-0.045597814,
-0.0059089391,
0.010395403,
-0.0188146569,
0.0067907101,
0.0130535513,
-0.0070613255,
-0.058775939,
0.0423203185,
-0.0286790375,
0.0145092923,
-0.0725701004,
0.0094588371,
0.0017706037,
-0.0590369441,
0.0484565087,
-0.0814519897,
0.0062933094,
0.0544747971,
0.0495417267,
0.0236762092,
-0.0102944914,
0.0138194114,
-0.0189383961,
0.0260150395,
-0.0175562836,
0.0293277148,
-0.0192033406,
0.0442310236,
-0.0369837955,
0.0300435834,
-0.0314530581,
-0.0655957907,
0.0623544864,
0.0260940678,
0.074601233,
-0.0451409072,
-0.0171729997,
0.0475970246,
0.0667961165,
0.0566285625,
0.0132729234,
0.0009868671,
0.019606838,
0.0165102128,
0.0613070279,
0.0193221308,
0.006841471,
-0.0170668419,
0.0278435331,
0.0159465987,
-0.0227529276,
-0.026290914,
-0.0359571911,
0.0206592362,
-0.0327702202,
0.0071675675,
-0.0446465164,
0.0055942326,
0.0287304968,
-0.0559394248,
0.0423444398,
0.0611782372,
-0.059639018,
0.0098675527,
-0.0186976399,
-0.0400155522,
0.0478131846,
0.0664000586,
-0.0407721065,
-0.0585418232,
0.0222191177,
-0.0327826925,
0.0338534378,
0.0214144886,
-0.0269199442,
0.0158645567,
-0.0813407078,
0.0091224546,
0.0603069253,
0.0333136991,
-0.0197555665,
-0.0093831718,
-0.0044049448,
0.0054797684,
-0.0278166831,
-0.0595217124,
0.0444151945,
-0.0643076748,
-0.0084269708,
0.0287631098,
0.0063171461,
0.0144988792,
0.0233550724,
-0.0082043447,
0.0294747502,
0.0211243089,
-0.0428495221,
-0.0277475975,
-0.0000169164,
-0.0318162553,
-0.0645362288,
-0.0123350928,
-0.0857625008,
0.0045823627,
0.0400349237,
-0.028670093,
-0.0121338861,
-0.0252681486,
-0.0720739365,
0.0178734418,
0.0109053748,
0.0495637432,
0.0279108956,
-0.0104519967,
-0.0454031862,
0.0167138875,
-0.0257549342,
0.0369551107,
0.004400115,
-0.069952637,
0.0016134931,
-0.0135310544,
0.0210466553,
-0.0150826173,
-0.0180941764,
-0.0309873316,
0.0148982201,
0.0102151753,
-0.0138910124,
-0.0128773376,
-0.0949904248,
-0.0251560956,
0.018329693,
-0.005276002,
0.0356184095,
0.0181002039,
0.0128719676,
-0.0126438765,
-0.0281854272,
-0.0089967968,
-0.011673484,
-0.0009860077,
0.0504291989,
0.020028837,
-0.016870277,
-0.0320904702,
-0.026212696,
-0.0110408794,
0.0336213671,
0.0288459957,
-0.0193644613,
-0.0057490007,
0.0504988991,
-0.0274615847,
-0.0489151329,
0.0224675406,
-0.0351205505,
-0.0213331878,
0.0222613998,
0.0254037175,
0.0584642887,
0.0202770811,
0.0331085175,
0.0239258837,
0.042458076,
-0.0094318083,
-0.0135105429,
-0.0377415046,
0.0126685975,
0.0061596171,
-0.1027410701,
0.043329861,
0.0232865978,
0.0489584915,
0.0045771538,
-0.0428808182,
-0.0011434697,
-0.0364990085,
-0.0457283556,
-0.0647563934,
0.0090701468,
-0.0183422845,
0.0365092307,
0.0019885984,
-0.0243984535,
0.0976695418,
0.025826687,
0.0238168873,
-0.0915561765,
-0.0094888723,
0.0016155236,
-0.0346672498,
-0.017013507,
0.0413134322,
0.0123577444,
-0.0456370972,
-0.0077692713,
0.018344041,
0.0222615022,
-0.0392698646,
0.0541863404,
-0.0289174393,
-0.0195485465,
0.0010252577,
-0.0422173701,
0.0000869564,
-0.0321499668,
0.0608647056,
-0.0218243524,
0.0642026961,
-0.0167835373,
-0.0753647164,
-0.0170498174,
0.004913772,
0.075487107,
0.0076000574,
-0.0093172174,
0.0077115558,
0.0666216835,
0.0001098546,
-0.0379183106,
0.0338240154,
-0.0273825694,
-0.0046621156,
0.0674754456,
-0.0083221626,
-0.0130265635,
0.0157360025,
-0.0217018705,
0.0039092088,
-0.0399881229,
-0.0067648301,
0.0080857407,
0.0153701659,
-0.0506997928,
0.0249141771,
0.0985202342,
0.0237772688,
-0.0186973698,
0.0408557691,
0.0168969948,
0.0181924962,
-0.0403117873,
0.0085413838,
-0.0670183674,
0.0071427738,
0.0056173778,
0.0594496317,
-0.0029880025,
-0.0326854363,
0.0078418739,
-0.0066337204,
0.0243341401,
0.0288215131,
-0.0233667921,
-0.0700603202,
-0.052892901,
-0.023033997,
-0.0056046373,
-0.0470357314,
0.0235381462,
-0.018941585,
0.0064232056,
-0.0168897249,
-0.0651245937,
-0.0892363787,
-0.048998706,
-0.0079488363,
0.086059697,
0.0207708366,
0.0583395399,
0.0005716888,
-0.0152631048,
-0.0397197753,
0.0245826934,
0.0030512966,
-0.0482825674,
0.0594433434,
0.0445423722,
-0.0067809396,
-0.0440002345,
0.0392196663,
0.0037183608,
-0.0137236491,
-0.015434335,
0.0082919439,
0.0042096055,
-0.0698965043,
-0.0043271091,
0.0376775451,
0.0164681803,
0.0749139488,
0.0194344893,
0.0556183569,
-0.0153008988,
-0.007640718,
0.0763977394,
-0.0254417099,
-0.0500407256,
-0.0190914441,
-0.0532132089,
-0.0643228665,
-0.0734049603,
-0.0061532459,
-0.0029402378,
0.0028301938,
0.0086699622,
0.0225744452,
0.019097155,
-0.0054243887,
-0.0435157567,
-0.0016960939,
0.0306260213,
-0.0133081637,
0.0097833248,
-0.0403424539,
0.0091505777,
0.0081460821,
-0.0330705494,
0.0307667982,
0.0058094612,
-0.0184927452,
-0.0121126557,
0.0446347259,
0.0154587729,
-0.0060321898,
0.0155948466,
-0.0520904511,
0.0322256908,
0.0550693683,
-0.0634119362,
0.0380365476,
0.0351016074,
-0.0294710342,
-0.0005078989,
0.025663482,
0.0056406255,
-0.0029966491,
-0.0063501676,
0.0336448364,
-0.0078216856,
0.0162364431,
0.0245342553,
0.0458193235,
0.0041854107,
-0.0451127663,
-0.0221572574,
-0.0207421146,
0.0183834545,
-0.0523770973,
0.0317124538,
-0.0112395333,
0.0135382935,
0.0436452702,
0.0226914342,
-0.0403386541,
0.0638034493,
-0.024611216,
-0.0375450999,
-0.0025589699,
0.0474149436,
-0.0351496078,
0.0183371175,
0.040604353,
-0.0235533826,
-0.0271948315,
0.0150219621,
-0.0226008426,
-0.01029607,
-0.0077527547,
-0.0035282886,
0.0188124646,
0.0461918525,
-0.0197231323,
0.0531225279,
-0.0224306919,
-0.0291012209,
-0.0361760706,
0.0080263419,
0.0087727932,
0.0106449211,
0.0725800917,
-0.0305166151,
0.0022921336,
-0.0399375856,
0.0075311139,
-0.0185711924,
0.0194171481,
0.0048524695,
-0.0040099937,
0.0105994409,
0.0003930572,
0.1377570331,
-0.03551751,
0.0335806757,
0.0009893987,
-0.0320825651,
-0.0457339138,
-0.0357583277,
0.0303936675,
0.0740429014,
-0.0626713559,
-0.0332750082,
-0.042573031,
-0.0276368819,
0.0471008569,
-0.001486632,
-0.0031408248,
-0.0168261901,
0.0529821031,
0.0206081346,
-0.0269713271,
-0.0312921703,
-0.0063319919,
0.0142970793,
-0.0240043681,
-0.0284900963,
-0.0032661518,
-6.050163629e-33,
-0.0043193861,
-0.0358330458,
0.0048833704,
-0.0350652374,
-0.0289181303,
0.0582274571,
-0.0805830956,
-0.0062282309,
0.0038008967,
0.0711582229,
-0.0059300093,
0.0233809669,
0.0087764487,
0.0220605135,
-0.0312928334,
0.0156737808,
0.063241072,
0.0108173555,
0.0032298111,
0.0279478319,
-0.0670367032,
0.0433351547,
0.0227031391,
-0.1073054448,
-0.0181986876,
0.0104913833,
-0.0085201394,
0.0049606268,
0.038287472,
0.0141033502,
-0.0365469605,
0.0172442943,
0.0262887776,
-0.0161672235,
-0.0233863965,
-0.0170985106,
-0.0619893894,
-0.0159895141,
0.0365118086,
-0.0342552699,
-0.0509464853,
-0.0631549284,
0.0426831134,
-0.0251456983,
-0.0412959605,
-0.0214074068,
0.0172960963,
-0.0316963494,
-0.0252035689,
-0.0328700282,
-0.0300551634,
0.060235519,
-0.0283339228,
0.0029453873,
0.0011499408,
-0.0305355676,
-0.0346999504,
0.0419755913,
-0.0176254641,
0.0344203748,
0.0508693382,
0.0591290928,
0.0023121543,
-0.0851107612,
-0.0068716118,
0.0393543877,
0.0662350804,
-0.0003952125,
-0.0246859472,
-0.0385221727,
-0.0104566766,
-0.0056975526,
0.0673259348,
0.0236467775,
0.0432093926,
-0.026744362,
-0.0516060591,
0.050585933,
-0.0817211419,
0.0369116031,
-0.0062554698,
0.0299242157,
-0.0506015942,
-0.0117817428,
-0.0015269691,
-0.0047594816,
-0.0149379745,
-0.0341732316,
-0.0079268441,
0.0188266598,
-0.0275847912,
0.0184419844,
-0.0127387913,
-0.0096022282,
0.0450960658,
0.016821688,
0.0621568896,
0.0244798344,
-0.0426741317,
-0.0518949591,
-0.040130984,
0.0360567756,
0.0369037353,
-0.0003529521,
0.0249108933,
-0.0106273647,
0.0063297241,
-0.0167320892,
-0.0517071858,
-0.0069149877,
0.0495334044,
-0.0561403409,
0.0335622393,
-0.0070814635,
0.0168062188,
0.0309933349,
0.0153061431,
0.0366364121,
0.0153610175,
0.0072984556,
-0.0359239206,
0.0088266646,
0.0345194675,
0.0097407578,
-0.0254075229,
-0.002180154,
-0.0334755108,
0.0090312548,
0.0335581787,
-0.0469622537,
-0.0366807655,
-0.0139564462,
2.674e-7,
0.0821912661,
0.0843949988,
0.0267495979,
-0.0133612547,
0.0161257051,
0.0058258404,
0.0373572744,
-0.003699302,
-0.064088732,
0.0348777473,
0.0688772276,
-0.0006442947,
0.0145655852,
-0.0013428152,
-0.0564334504,
0.0065914947,
-0.0793893263,
-0.0660161227,
-0.0057859109,
-0.0433724374,
0.0467461534,
0.0353764519,
-0.0481758006,
-0.024453003,
0.0421630852,
0.0355386063,
0.0036303333,
-0.0132132936,
0.0024284578,
0.0622470975,
0.0265255719,
-0.0343395248,
0.0193733927,
0.0198561493,
-0.0550935008,
-0.056429144,
0.0336147472,
0.0968677998,
-0.0196932536,
0.0157862175,
0.040431153,
0.0000718865,
0.0015249106,
-0.0342460163,
0.0137828067,
-0.0323488563,
-0.0271809381,
0.0072252215,
-0.0338131972,
0.0147330575,
0.0561362803,
-0.0278577898,
-0.0745158568,
0.0456757136,
0.0253197961,
0.0423586257,
-0.0372001007,
-0.0563622043,
-0.0041255415,
0.0166139863,
-0.0096407915,
-0.0138975605,
0.0188302286,
0.0277890284,
0.0227851458,
-0.057186719,
0.017203765,
2.57178029e-34,
0.0555929206,
0.0146424975,
-0.004020513,
0.0332838818,
0.007875911,
-0.0308551397,
-0.0237231199,
0.0237840172,
0.0137400674,
-0.0533143319,
0.0027021938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11166v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11166v2 | ViSoBERT: A Pre-Trained Language Model for Vietnamese Social Media Text Processing | 2023-10-17T11:34:50 | 2023-10-28T16:22:19 | Quoc-Nam Nguyen, Thang Chau Phan, Duc-Vu Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | English and Chinese, known as resource-rich languages, have witnessed the
strong development of transformer-based language models for natural language
processing tasks. Although Vietnam has approximately 100M people speaking
Vietnamese, several pre-trained models, e.g., PhoBERT, ViBERT, and vELECTRA,
performed well on general Vietnamese NLP tasks, including POS tagging and named
entity recognition. These pre-trained language models are still limited to
Vietnamese social media tasks. In this paper, we present the first monolingual
pre-trained language model for Vietnamese social media texts, ViSoBERT, which
is pre-trained on a large-scale corpus of high-quality and diverse Vietnamese
social media texts using XLM-R architecture. Moreover, we explored our
pre-trained model on five important natural language downstream tasks on
Vietnamese social media texts: emotion recognition, hate speech detection,
sentiment analysis, spam reviews detection, and hate speech spans detection.
Our experiments demonstrate that ViSoBERT, with far fewer parameters, surpasses
the previous state-of-the-art models on multiple Vietnamese social media tasks.
Our ViSoBERT model is available only for research purposes. | [
0.0669090375,
0.0478314534,
0.0105726086,
0.0149608431,
0.0007077102,
0.0320764296,
-0.0197170228,
0.0091176154,
0.0498498902,
-0.055750981,
-0.0539084189,
-0.0630729273,
-0.0107143121,
0.021753516,
-0.0438655242,
-0.0478272587,
0.0297260024,
0.017839808,
0.0243539605,
0.0011853308,
0.0337391086,
0.029445881,
0.0345905274,
0.0128701786,
-0.0258691255,
-0.0002683288,
0.0067296959,
0.0362286121,
0.0127869304,
-0.0354464203,
0.0413030535,
0.0676227137,
-0.026432775,
0.0225281492,
0.0000020016,
-0.0049591763,
-0.0410721339,
-0.0194326434,
0.0279341768,
-0.018981142,
0.1085577384,
-0.0510068946,
-0.0149212675,
0.0528164357,
-0.0538532846,
-0.0756459609,
0.0450243466,
0.1130012944,
0.0902408212,
0.0828484744,
-0.0360385403,
-0.0163660329,
0.0117876315,
-0.0264470689,
-0.0100236153,
0.0119340215,
0.0335936509,
-0.0366695821,
-0.0091860034,
0.0092438245,
-0.0328978263,
0.0098920101,
0.0118648829,
0.012875204,
-0.0234292019,
-0.0428902768,
-0.0160168055,
-0.0158539731,
-0.0073595569,
0.0433906838,
-0.0652374998,
-0.0330161527,
0.0014605742,
0.0124378437,
-0.0338761955,
-0.0359118506,
-0.016195463,
-0.0014103384,
-0.0148156015,
0.0581452101,
0.0438225679,
-0.0033430262,
0.0097815944,
0.0327232778,
-0.0112438742,
-0.0090778563,
-0.0206184275,
-0.0418998897,
0.0078209406,
0.0259194709,
-0.0479515791,
-0.0014535991,
0.0466604903,
0.0023352373,
0.0053364527,
0.0166940838,
-0.0469818786,
-0.0350172557,
0.0139634777,
-0.114613004,
-0.0064420309,
0.0239536315,
-0.0296846367,
0.0219524056,
-0.0023908068,
0.0377751812,
-0.0300565716,
0.0189785063,
-0.0088734189,
-0.0200560987,
-0.0518441126,
0.0120105371,
-0.0246333033,
0.0368987098,
-0.0475669093,
-0.0087895859,
-0.0534483679,
0.0036652389,
-0.0099648405,
-0.0405094661,
0.0239562988,
0.0023419906,
0.0036796106,
-0.0182202961,
-0.0157527328,
0.0505998395,
0.0390320532,
0.0372096375,
-0.0417314135,
-0.0698622987,
0.0248765275,
0.0325567834,
0.0072098942,
-0.0258363374,
0.0234989878,
0.0319543518,
-0.0061764764,
-0.0310232062,
-0.0488943681,
0.0050782743,
0.0106298504,
-0.0390526168,
0.0089999633,
-0.057727091,
0.0298298374,
0.0166415777,
0.0281838011,
-0.0083290515,
0.03547379,
0.0374948531,
-0.0770598128,
0.092875056,
0.0146336285,
0.0141590014,
0.0018889607,
0.022946028,
0.0462103002,
0.0468508601,
-0.0056746113,
0.0475076325,
0.0779034793,
-0.0184327979,
0.0086949393,
0.0602091067,
-0.0236754473,
-0.0216004532,
-0.0078472942,
0.0085124895,
-0.0644131303,
-0.0491973646,
0.0234148372,
0.0581088327,
0.0018018991,
-0.0025652268,
0.0519478545,
0.0185352247,
-0.0173643008,
0.0267355386,
0.0370442383,
0.0198276434,
0.0012292609,
-0.0361571088,
-0.060316015,
0.0046207714,
-0.0265421662,
-0.0332501791,
0.0008542505,
0.035343308,
-0.0335673839,
-0.0447639935,
-0.005181219,
-0.0307578593,
0.0252120141,
-0.0312116817,
0.0326913483,
0.0249878932,
-0.0573226884,
0.0596540235,
0.0435347445,
-0.0338533223,
-0.0045779767,
-0.0288025737,
-0.0087045925,
0.0469860919,
0.0035722512,
-0.0302478634,
0.0217482112,
-0.0527058803,
-0.0000121817,
0.0654221252,
0.042850323,
0.0138705606,
-0.0209494233,
-0.0251696296,
0.016158985,
0.0412084013,
0.0168534052,
0.008991343,
0.0609171428,
0.0731853768,
0.0133051053,
0.0005456017,
-0.0521254689,
0.024101641,
-0.0054195016,
-0.0252188835,
0.0131192766,
0.0163349975,
0.0270436835,
0.0292910822,
-0.0191185698,
-0.0089367293,
0.01841777,
-0.0137426602,
-0.0313095413,
0.0137423323,
-0.0032269158,
-0.0469741598,
0.0186469462,
-0.0297268815,
-0.0007274388,
0.0962738916,
-0.0304425266,
0.0006049493,
0.0297004953,
0.043001622,
0.0141669791,
-0.0432680622,
0.0463222079,
-0.0298746563,
0.0547697619,
0.0042350069,
0.0406042896,
-0.0226840768,
0.001327627,
0.0113733504,
-0.0398486592,
0.0273396242,
0.0260327514,
-0.0880557746,
-0.001134383,
0.0055256244,
0.0315054581,
0.007112239,
0.0094467346,
-0.0043502268,
-0.0331096835,
-0.1145710796,
0.0233001038,
-0.042857293,
0.018200418,
0.0129639423,
-0.0055020894,
-0.0263026766,
-0.0225125607,
-0.0112698022,
-0.0132172853,
0.0493248887,
0.0225254055,
-0.0167351291,
-0.0422732569,
0.0489107557,
-0.0648060068,
-0.0196179319,
0.0091221584,
0.0054714438,
0.0076723369,
-0.0717957169,
0.0086421901,
0.0058449609,
0.0093887476,
0.006908197,
-0.0018707116,
-0.0758729205,
-0.0210348852,
-0.0019083905,
0.0259362143,
0.0288913026,
0.0322873592,
0.0568891019,
-0.0290650129,
-0.0089286147,
-0.0040525696,
0.0048899446,
-0.0661830306,
-0.0037193752,
-0.0457011499,
-0.0235694535,
0.0040664254,
0.0915333331,
-0.0024541384,
0.0037765438,
-0.0325156935,
-0.0557735227,
-0.0340701081,
-0.0024930942,
0.0271131061,
-0.0190649927,
-0.001609982,
-0.0147602651,
-0.0482777134,
-0.026193412,
0.0316125527,
-0.0078261066,
0.0086912215,
-0.0468031429,
-0.0159533676,
-0.0356184766,
0.0411373228,
0.052896969,
0.0068360763,
-0.0192914996,
-0.0005213653,
0.0155532435,
0.0295002386,
-0.009268349,
-0.055046808,
0.0138060031,
0.0200915635,
-0.0208029132,
0.0092585227,
-0.0232363865,
-0.0389423929,
-0.0469102524,
-0.0524539985,
-0.0204384886,
0.0154678142,
0.0081216926,
0.0000902914,
0.0416236445,
0.0028632842,
-0.0110497605,
-0.0005819129,
-0.0031849886,
0.000944483,
0.0440940298,
0.0371798761,
-0.0476449616,
0.0160785485,
-0.0211198851,
0.0300266016,
0.033271499,
0.0107667716,
-0.0275092945,
0.0013571664,
-0.0064786011,
0.0296786223,
-0.0254483782,
-0.0104709025,
-0.0581088848,
0.0423372611,
-0.0187491626,
0.0139226979,
0.1068232656,
0.0193402953,
-0.0287653338,
-0.0220089965,
-0.0104743605,
-0.0148528684,
0.0283059832,
0.0266479757,
-0.0649359524,
-0.0195948929,
-0.0281725097,
-0.0208434388,
0.0047841626,
-0.0190791469,
0.0072918073,
-0.1123286337,
-0.0027658325,
-0.0256078169,
-0.0031784088,
-0.0346767083,
-0.0186363067,
-0.0128316283,
-0.0509653762,
0.0143860513,
-0.0437298343,
-0.0255347881,
-0.0078226421,
0.0241982527,
-0.044126261,
-0.0117017915,
0.0382159688,
-0.0490029566,
0.0283562671,
0.039538525,
0.0183094554,
-0.0168536752,
-0.0201612748,
0.0621975847,
-0.0126982005,
0.003372343,
-0.0350317508,
0.0665476322,
-0.0105758123,
-0.0287380815,
-0.012740544,
-0.0102402875,
-0.0554649457,
-0.0030570976,
-0.0262317788,
0.0671306178,
0.0238978565,
-0.0226346683,
-0.0049881577,
0.0258516818,
0.0118161915,
0.0482887849,
0.0069863889,
-0.0755247325,
-0.0337811671,
-0.0195336621,
-0.0233626738,
-0.0266160164,
-0.0684579089,
0.0105429003,
-0.0510227941,
-0.0744871795,
-0.0501996912,
-0.0407540239,
0.0227417797,
0.0101051517,
-0.0061491863,
-0.0135812573,
0.042250149,
-0.0230701789,
-0.0509986915,
0.0384596772,
-0.0077081206,
0.027643986,
-0.0450447574,
-0.0154604986,
0.0197561979,
-0.016651392,
0.006660792,
-0.0273857638,
-0.0467288606,
-0.0403408185,
0.0303867627,
0.0533313379,
0.0154106254,
0.0215053689,
-0.0275346115,
-0.0438304842,
0.0341900773,
0.0745443553,
-0.0564398989,
-0.0251013972,
0.0326880552,
0.0057985578,
-0.0087080374,
0.0318494551,
0.0227709953,
0.0472726598,
0.0468287207,
-0.0141842738,
-0.0362093523,
-0.0358800218,
-0.0136867994,
-0.0117720375,
0.0859402865,
0.0086183948,
-0.0159383081,
-0.0743335336,
-0.0243256036,
-0.0179017354,
-0.0126687158,
-0.0341569744,
-0.0177964363,
0.0316482969,
0.020771848,
-0.069766365,
0.0078741722,
-0.0267645977,
0.0015462257,
-0.0120725818,
0.0431445502,
0.0292148646,
0.0475124866,
0.027948726,
0.0301592965,
0.0139389038,
-0.0084391711,
0.027404638,
-0.005831793,
-0.0197380129,
0.0630588457,
-0.0216423217,
0.03201456,
0.0501095131,
0.0200092476,
0.0117547624,
-0.0276900139,
-0.0304666497,
-0.025668636,
0.0369654261,
-0.0606642887,
0.0720458105,
-0.030374594,
0.0072102826,
-0.0112565458,
0.0090614324,
-0.0321137756,
-0.0260931104,
0.0028423646,
-0.0014030944,
-0.0281026606,
0.0298344847,
0.0596554056,
0.0008011149,
0.0386253744,
0.0833350569,
-0.0255204998,
-0.0204694886,
0.013667834,
0.0618953705,
0.0000670633,
-0.0172435176,
0.0292649921,
-0.0129564721,
-0.0775124654,
0.0298169889,
-0.0411283709,
-0.0026565122,
0.0189423449,
0.0011842891,
0.0567953736,
0.0127175171,
0.0477289408,
-0.0675120503,
-0.0175001174,
-0.029607283,
-0.019986432,
0.0398126841,
-6.517119209e-33,
-0.0206141286,
0.0005619257,
-0.019588653,
-0.0082043717,
-0.0037954007,
-0.0174296275,
-0.0103790518,
0.0413953401,
-0.0247602332,
0.0268489923,
-0.0192604754,
0.0195623785,
0.0216386225,
0.0401641056,
-0.0059789792,
-0.0014460454,
0.0532347076,
0.0179332886,
0.0375557393,
-0.0002996064,
0.0233654678,
0.051113043,
0.062477909,
-0.0639977455,
-0.0006816543,
0.0071486211,
-0.0094513269,
0.0130933616,
0.0697420761,
0.0701264963,
-0.0306639262,
0.0625604019,
0.0355118439,
-0.0436202809,
-0.0136199584,
0.0245649852,
-0.1102118939,
-0.0045708325,
0.0125415074,
0.0699769035,
-0.0152411647,
0.0171738174,
0.0418970473,
-0.004456108,
0.0093217343,
0.0071703494,
0.0243132189,
-0.0205075759,
0.0460825898,
-0.0313692652,
-0.0643747002,
0.0340773463,
0.033579573,
0.0037694809,
0.0290809087,
0.0323373117,
-0.0009946423,
0.0397345163,
-0.1167924479,
-0.0028731523,
-0.020845728,
0.0051900484,
-0.0065250052,
-0.0191230774,
-0.0046864552,
0.0509622172,
0.0057764314,
-0.0104051903,
-0.0312134754,
0.0581667498,
0.0120297447,
0.0355447344,
0.0266431235,
0.0474445187,
0.051528994,
-0.076647684,
-0.0555425696,
0.0107114809,
0.019597264,
0.0191440135,
0.0343361683,
-0.0161779262,
-0.0210308861,
-0.0122217014,
0.0141781177,
-0.080293946,
-0.0491251312,
-0.0562475175,
0.0027408765,
0.0364058465,
-0.0194475222,
0.0069557247,
0.053123828,
-0.0857350305,
-0.0281550959,
0.0213210005,
-0.0466760881,
0.0168698262,
-0.0393589213,
0.04125062,
-0.0625657141,
-0.0285543073,
0.0106301811,
-0.0237725917,
-0.0079144482,
0.0005538264,
0.037545152,
0.0089307483,
-0.1191575602,
0.0323732905,
-0.0101384716,
0.071269691,
0.00110183,
0.0950909555,
-0.0132347271,
0.0271802247,
-0.0191442631,
0.0410854146,
0.0181103088,
-0.0055048224,
-0.0287469551,
-0.0067665405,
-0.0160766374,
0.0021139686,
-0.0243971851,
-0.0041438616,
-0.0330028571,
0.0359042212,
-0.0188411493,
-0.0617064983,
0.0074275122,
-0.0084625557,
2.711e-7,
0.0183895584,
0.0313435607,
0.0304966141,
-0.0298211426,
0.0084029576,
0.0338668674,
0.0142971789,
0.0252997167,
0.0022814733,
-0.0143613443,
-0.0091918353,
0.0478346497,
0.0428320244,
0.0195866153,
-0.0786003545,
-0.002570149,
-0.0467274375,
-0.0055361078,
-0.0218636487,
-0.0173300877,
0.0131414272,
0.1251859218,
-0.0042367522,
-0.0064077172,
-0.0636241734,
-0.0057893195,
0.0589075387,
-0.0195819195,
-0.0268488023,
0.0268573929,
0.0472113304,
0.00090789,
-0.0235520825,
-0.0351624265,
-0.0284827463,
0.0084312735,
0.0296713579,
0.0640968531,
0.0121937469,
-0.0120669166,
0.0243662428,
-0.0016655935,
-0.0263910163,
-0.0500270538,
0.0650825053,
-0.0441126563,
-0.0287393965,
-0.0383065753,
-0.0079460861,
0.0073861298,
0.0523272492,
-0.014693018,
-0.0337732397,
0.0413693152,
0.0619659275,
0.0021439942,
-0.0394699462,
-0.0656264573,
-0.0150919585,
-0.0043645776,
-0.0063190064,
0.0088974433,
-0.0126513951,
0.013228396,
0.047987625,
0.0217094757,
0.0571651757,
2.328899051e-34,
0.0451427177,
-0.0103965029,
-0.0205961,
-0.0118961791,
0.0422437303,
-0.0040373788,
-0.0387804024,
0.0125953825,
0.0061816117,
-0.0619428195,
0.0153266033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11163v1 | IMTLab: An Open-Source Platform for Building, Evaluating, and Diagnosing Interactive Machine Translation Systems | 2023-10-17T11:29:04 | 2023-10-17T11:29:04 | Xu Huang, Zhirui Zhang, Ruize Gao, Yichao Du, Lemao Liu, Gouping Huang, Shuming Shi, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present IMTLab, an open-source end-to-end interactive machine translation
(IMT) system platform that enables researchers to quickly build IMT systems
with state-of-the-art models, perform an end-to-end evaluation, and diagnose
the weakness of systems. IMTLab treats the whole interactive translation
process as a task-oriented dialogue with a human-in-the-loop setting, in which
human interventions can be explicitly incorporated to produce high-quality,
error-free translations. To this end, a general communication interface is
designed to support the flexible IMT architectures and user policies. Based on
the proposed design, we construct a simulated and real interactive environment
to achieve end-to-end evaluation and leverage the framework to systematically
evaluate previous IMT systems. Our simulated and manual experiments show that
the prefix-constrained decoding approach still gains the lowest editing cost in
the end-to-end evaluation, while BiTIIMT achieves comparable editing cost with
a better interactive experience. | [
0.031424921,
-0.0114252428,
-0.0209015924,
0.0267004576,
-0.0233682375,
0.0191948786,
0.0131498566,
0.0169914607,
-0.0123168277,
0.0121505223,
-0.0561106168,
0.0058942726,
0.0087887738,
0.0337857343,
0.03556237,
-0.0590183847,
0.0556658916,
-0.0192761738,
-0.0257283896,
0.0325904563,
0.0136081018,
0.0240935776,
-0.0233749878,
0.0356741212,
0.0142521821,
-0.0038080204,
-0.0357968323,
0.0326481722,
0.0292894337,
-0.0140409535,
-0.0339608304,
0.0481691435,
0.0106604882,
0.080165714,
0.00000229,
-0.0253138188,
-0.0299022496,
0.0234348942,
-0.0257686041,
0.0202666111,
0.0695655271,
-0.035523694,
-0.0569148883,
0.0110033043,
-0.0129333697,
0.0048619304,
0.0874124169,
-0.0270966515,
0.1105002239,
0.0237346906,
-0.0238901656,
0.0280621536,
-0.0361835808,
-0.0314406045,
-0.0156118441,
-0.0286790431,
-0.028309783,
-0.0110619199,
0.0120199751,
0.022469908,
0.0269575808,
0.0536701083,
0.0368450917,
-0.0277407989,
0.0007902707,
0.0167520568,
-0.0281289313,
-0.0664726421,
-0.0535110831,
0.0518288054,
0.0005421428,
0.0024268806,
-0.0372460112,
0.0034549164,
-0.0045777657,
-0.0492519923,
-0.0309514422,
0.000703548,
-0.0300922655,
-0.0300797634,
-0.0441118628,
0.0312616229,
-0.0112865875,
-0.0021242676,
-0.0540342815,
-0.0226769149,
0.0285924226,
-0.0126805445,
-0.0349511094,
0.0159791317,
-0.0071522547,
-0.0366407,
0.0555067025,
0.0088686431,
-0.0352937095,
-0.0018480872,
-0.0357131585,
-0.0582791083,
0.0110356528,
-0.0537380837,
0.0248053484,
0.0814805925,
-0.0154188313,
0.0351003632,
0.0309998561,
0.0669499859,
-0.0134781133,
0.0190892816,
-0.0112482384,
0.0059755417,
-0.0249084644,
-0.0053090984,
-0.0683546141,
-0.016293209,
-0.0677532852,
0.0125494041,
-0.0235590488,
0.0619715005,
0.029300509,
0.0328636914,
0.0154397152,
-0.0286365077,
-0.0629775897,
-0.0042963987,
-0.0209704638,
0.02189436,
-0.0060278801,
-0.0302961189,
-0.0041658273,
-0.0662945807,
-0.0394499265,
0.0141746625,
-0.018281905,
-0.0271173846,
-0.0354263783,
0.0863393322,
-0.0464709923,
-0.0187244918,
0.0364601724,
-0.0253419057,
-0.0009517352,
-0.0455543101,
-0.0196572859,
-0.0425787419,
0.0595437363,
0.0226779897,
-0.0076658558,
-0.0212710872,
0.0007856525,
0.0074115135,
0.010036136,
0.0882171765,
-0.0338112116,
-0.0301025063,
0.0206311215,
0.0188580323,
-0.0116707599,
0.0394160748,
0.0272091143,
0.0405897908,
0.0173771419,
0.0132856956,
0.0127833188,
0.0763681382,
-0.00697084,
0.0309087746,
0.0024193809,
0.0241198782,
-0.0164275337,
0.0531461723,
-0.0020802447,
0.0434414521,
-0.0449424125,
0.0259063896,
0.0756061077,
0.0251012165,
-0.0142393922,
0.0236487817,
0.0281567667,
0.0533807725,
-0.0096118785,
-0.0215667058,
-0.0019299028,
0.0578802526,
0.0379365794,
-0.0140355444,
0.0447607189,
-0.0035178009,
-0.0005544346,
-0.0251602791,
-0.0101698954,
-0.0005038136,
0.0030624331,
-0.0246859901,
0.0465200469,
0.0131657049,
-0.0532702878,
0.0252726525,
-0.0223913305,
-0.0667281747,
-0.0110040167,
-0.0452388823,
0.0024291254,
0.1111889929,
0.0746134594,
-0.0153342839,
-0.0048710718,
-0.003912189,
-0.0226921681,
0.0689869225,
0.0633611977,
-0.0001710626,
-0.0037819343,
-0.0257733669,
-0.0208879765,
0.0540761054,
0.0053492407,
0.0405818038,
-0.0024718968,
0.0231033657,
0.0019328686,
0.0141048403,
-0.0216195602,
0.009419309,
0.0144874556,
-0.0312051922,
-0.013919076,
0.0058006612,
0.0199274588,
0.032172855,
-0.036568258,
0.0030011896,
0.0092517715,
-0.0099977003,
-0.0115177026,
0.0493967533,
-0.0064573018,
-0.0080795521,
0.001474497,
-0.0334596895,
-0.0293045063,
0.0143396016,
-0.0213891622,
-0.0220589358,
-0.0039146743,
-0.0735284984,
-0.0097677326,
-0.0363086015,
0.0318076946,
-0.0057102595,
-0.0183449183,
-0.0444829017,
-0.0186776333,
0.0098149655,
-0.0470603853,
0.0453297384,
-0.0164500233,
0.0025190182,
-0.0679295585,
-0.0085029975,
0.0425126292,
0.0080999574,
-0.0132584963,
-0.0132949278,
0.029299479,
-0.0088551259,
-0.0228810199,
-0.1069440022,
0.0096969875,
-0.0150154093,
0.0353398621,
0.0398832746,
0.0521876365,
-0.0117641566,
-0.0165905915,
0.0199485924,
-0.0064429305,
0.0134476684,
0.0113293501,
0.0302925389,
0.0165902451,
0.0081071481,
-0.0378446691,
0.0003801344,
0.008192027,
0.022400992,
0.0431524105,
-0.0697657317,
-0.0759892911,
-0.0168203935,
0.003968454,
-0.0118561015,
0.0081732431,
-0.052740261,
0.0399709642,
-0.0081297811,
0.0131772673,
0.0361129455,
-0.0231467262,
0.0373054706,
0.0239288025,
-0.0297218282,
-0.0587285683,
0.0201552231,
0.0245869346,
-0.0285286605,
0.0339217931,
-0.0383028612,
0.0219355151,
0.0596787147,
0.0131174354,
0.0362649672,
-0.0691962987,
0.0589827038,
-0.0015846732,
-0.0156697165,
-0.0384020433,
0.0027184265,
-0.0229045618,
0.0449445732,
-0.0284463912,
-0.0476918034,
0.0601048395,
-0.0549561679,
-0.0468702838,
-0.027249774,
0.0170270912,
-0.0121899555,
0.0550116785,
-0.065958932,
-0.0129956733,
0.0080570159,
-0.0229699053,
-0.0332855619,
0.0608566329,
0.0321087465,
-0.04848947,
-0.0352834426,
-0.0912265927,
-0.0033943539,
-0.0378984325,
-0.0330493897,
0.001213063,
0.0245102942,
-0.0445907898,
-0.0310168285,
0.0785150453,
-0.0502629094,
0.0038746912,
0.0446735471,
0.0470947959,
0.0375160649,
0.0023710998,
-0.0301623456,
-0.0186952632,
-0.0229649954,
-0.0271084495,
0.0391228609,
0.0012177529,
-0.0286680162,
0.0281814914,
0.0570936501,
-0.0358201638,
-0.0124035804,
-0.0277269259,
-0.0115661863,
0.0357511714,
-0.0002991375,
-0.0212588757,
-0.0230634846,
0.0464378223,
-0.0629983097,
-0.0075916871,
0.0843251348,
0.0343291126,
-0.0910477713,
-0.0224089604,
-0.0115164677,
0.0411029756,
0.0034446898,
0.0412209779,
-0.1185074225,
-0.0500642508,
0.0286278408,
0.0719935298,
-0.0041231103,
0.0149994679,
-0.0230439994,
-0.0611904711,
0.0562961064,
0.0305753108,
-0.021203706,
-0.0367372222,
-0.011745288,
-0.0392769203,
-0.0234799869,
0.0226098262,
0.0280524772,
0.0362367071,
0.0163669493,
-0.0260137152,
0.0033348643,
-0.0239871051,
-0.0062138452,
-0.0072191516,
0.0461402237,
0.0949427038,
0.0305363722,
0.0542190932,
-0.0087461993,
0.0189832877,
0.0165723432,
0.0054011545,
-0.0411492102,
0.0494724102,
0.0090724546,
-0.0241791066,
-0.0462423265,
-0.0267801993,
-0.0042368895,
0.0349194445,
0.0045405729,
0.0435664766,
-0.038167689,
0.0640763342,
0.0099111041,
-0.0385197178,
0.0277949236,
0.0407014117,
0.0190697163,
-0.0282099843,
-0.0502707288,
-0.0398346968,
-0.0234681647,
-0.0967402309,
-0.028703589,
-0.0030851155,
-0.0566846021,
-0.0578202382,
-0.0893076584,
-0.0558426268,
0.0316538289,
0.0276261847,
0.0054972311,
-0.0360381007,
0.0116714062,
0.0259787608,
-0.0458051674,
0.0249056499,
-0.0091672689,
0.0096476628,
-0.0309915151,
-0.005404334,
-0.0087929815,
-0.0377037786,
0.02603749,
0.101206705,
-0.0264957696,
-0.0643565208,
-0.0243368391,
0.0630492419,
0.0314626954,
0.0525979921,
-0.0507960953,
-0.0312622972,
0.0104613993,
-0.0292893648,
-0.0253726095,
0.0143947676,
0.0233495496,
0.0181234721,
-0.018524183,
0.0031070905,
-0.0275523532,
-0.0253443606,
-0.0153734051,
0.0183861461,
-0.0170303192,
-0.0736335292,
0.0280191191,
0.0322555006,
0.0145287933,
-0.0205219556,
-0.0524008684,
0.0094330152,
0.0375422984,
-0.0367598012,
0.0096492777,
-0.075088799,
0.000139447,
0.0142136598,
-0.0415764786,
0.0172499195,
0.0557553805,
-0.046751678,
-0.0255225971,
0.0008596669,
0.0213255584,
-0.0381805971,
0.0362450331,
0.044592008,
0.020930808,
-0.0145385573,
0.0257765055,
-0.0219019204,
0.0236735605,
-0.0219194014,
0.07506603,
-0.0064464929,
-0.0087165963,
0.043343924,
0.0766657665,
-0.0056739426,
0.0108281979,
-0.0159054436,
0.0421051495,
0.0481752083,
0.0540318973,
0.088197954,
-0.0301468205,
0.0064465422,
-0.021563394,
0.0533608608,
0.0123117045,
-0.0215526316,
-0.0297300108,
0.0021826518,
0.0061633298,
-0.0167432111,
0.0095664728,
-0.0466854386,
-0.0132605368,
-0.0414803363,
-0.0316944681,
-0.0256088562,
-0.001898346,
-0.010278902,
-0.0448818281,
-0.0303983185,
-0.035536062,
-0.0345057771,
-0.031856399,
-0.0117424969,
0.0493073389,
-0.0053301007,
-0.0027180139,
0.0554379262,
0.0703348517,
-0.0022682599,
-0.0052197813,
0.0082201222,
0.0006729297,
-0.0437044464,
-0.0497913361,
-0.0407502241,
-6.41882878e-33,
-0.0351254791,
-0.0222775023,
0.027591113,
-0.0293278601,
-0.0327339917,
-0.0340914354,
-0.0627629086,
0.0254172683,
0.0303315166,
-0.0020749648,
-0.0089655938,
0.0119843977,
0.0226686392,
-0.0404641479,
0.0022021183,
0.0332331397,
0.0699079335,
0.0151092373,
-0.052493874,
0.007273885,
0.0384871252,
0.0104608778,
0.0481747463,
-0.0517236888,
0.0414786711,
-0.0000742757,
-0.0164031368,
0.0114057586,
-0.0079652686,
0.0248057786,
-0.0062537505,
0.0217043776,
0.0018202763,
-0.0445065871,
-0.0157982074,
0.0312714055,
-0.0694723204,
0.0278454572,
-0.0027753285,
0.0726631135,
-0.0166429188,
-0.0362835377,
0.0033169503,
-0.0354294181,
-0.0139613878,
0.015947178,
-0.0112514142,
-0.0150349345,
0.002860988,
0.0079856412,
-0.0449700654,
0.0337075107,
-0.0198286697,
-0.0526016913,
0.0385742076,
0.0504364297,
0.0045620985,
-0.0292463489,
-0.051623188,
0.0143137667,
-0.0024995606,
-0.0012884433,
0.0943599641,
-0.0215590596,
-0.0280239731,
-0.0175497551,
0.0203704126,
-0.0227826554,
-0.037983682,
0.0333808661,
0.0114493119,
-0.0008437383,
0.1041961983,
0.0528173409,
0.0061895484,
-0.007063299,
0.0113761835,
0.0623333044,
0.0172178652,
0.0172937382,
-0.0004731217,
0.063419193,
-0.0376104712,
0.0231999643,
-0.0337791443,
-0.0082326559,
-0.035593275,
-0.0578728803,
0.0287237298,
0.0093763629,
-0.0162438508,
-0.0387361944,
0.0772090182,
0.0333511122,
0.0389854461,
-0.0618689582,
-0.0273689274,
0.049596291,
-0.037529394,
-0.0074289632,
0.0406432077,
0.0157307293,
0.0358032621,
0.0205043815,
0.0298041105,
-0.0178799778,
0.0017559602,
0.036176797,
-0.0154815949,
0.0143150054,
-0.0304037742,
0.0413915701,
-0.0067158109,
0.0040187133,
0.0008680464,
-0.0192566235,
-0.0249918178,
0.0177282207,
-0.0041713822,
0.0083432849,
-0.0521000624,
-0.009935189,
-0.0092486013,
-0.0170092676,
-0.0430862419,
0.026272485,
-0.0203933995,
0.0351400077,
0.0077305464,
-0.0455214158,
-0.0328724533,
0.0195296388,
2.923e-7,
0.0350274034,
0.0735910088,
0.0548233576,
0.0169925056,
0.0183782801,
0.0165294725,
-0.0180419609,
0.0320260935,
-0.0133172283,
0.0196414012,
0.0079346122,
0.0232113972,
0.0890284777,
0.0259083714,
-0.0765774474,
-0.0715929717,
-0.0234384034,
0.0524755456,
-0.0522254482,
0.0021399602,
0.1060722843,
0.0553938895,
-0.0130357128,
0.0199241675,
0.0443963334,
-0.0422973111,
0.0320562273,
0.0000350132,
0.0079329032,
-0.0059173494,
0.0218253694,
-0.015778577,
-0.0283896383,
0.0253540259,
-0.0212881584,
-0.0728565156,
-0.0004958664,
0.0688679889,
-0.0171468239,
-0.0538645498,
0.0210887063,
-0.004930004,
0.0004589459,
-0.0369331539,
0.0355598666,
-0.0534054413,
0.0121084806,
0.0290517509,
-0.0079349484,
-0.0071517951,
0.0127201062,
-0.0497452915,
-0.0134856617,
0.0316635035,
0.0259530731,
0.0044111288,
-0.0044691297,
-0.0362257361,
-0.0138743371,
-0.068206802,
-0.0309282225,
-0.0448690467,
-0.0666327775,
-0.0095656635,
0.0031554871,
0.0002204819,
-0.0050254301,
2.559605199e-34,
0.0258895289,
0.0015519129,
0.0396781377,
0.0314145312,
0.0463410802,
0.0072862236,
0.011224295,
0.034254916,
0.0329845548,
-0.0273364987,
-0.0381415039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11158v1 | Probing the Creativity of Large Language Models: Can models produce divergent semantic association? | 2023-10-17T11:23:32 | 2023-10-17T11:23:32 | Honghua Chen, Nai Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models possess remarkable capacity for processing language,
but it remains unclear whether these models can further generate creative
content. The present study aims to investigate the creative thinking of large
language models through a cognitive perspective. We utilize the divergent
association task (DAT), an objective measurement of creativity that asks models
to generate unrelated words and calculates the semantic distance between them.
We compare the results across different models and decoding strategies. Our
findings indicate that: (1) When using the greedy search strategy, GPT-4
outperforms 96% of humans, while GPT-3.5-turbo exceeds the average human level.
(2) Stochastic sampling and temperature scaling are effective to obtain higher
DAT scores for models except GPT-4, but face a trade-off between creativity and
stability. These results imply that advanced large language models have
divergent semantic associations, which is a fundamental process underlying
creativity. | [
0.0217884537,
0.0456576459,
-0.0506453104,
0.038757164,
-0.0525622331,
0.0206461251,
-0.0114291115,
0.0104973447,
-0.0526707582,
-0.0061667571,
-0.0157255381,
-0.0639519542,
0.0176157076,
0.0295352302,
0.0063170786,
-0.0438743904,
0.01723787,
-0.0568290763,
0.0240939464,
-0.0083202971,
-0.05462908,
0.0110763861,
0.0134062218,
0.0452952422,
0.0329134762,
-0.0233842731,
0.0225392636,
-0.0119016236,
0.0262946859,
0.0002347357,
-0.049255114,
0.0639145896,
-0.0049841101,
0.0936383903,
0.0000017495,
-0.0589108132,
0.0191316865,
-0.016665224,
0.0202495307,
0.0017873794,
0.048729606,
0.0190175269,
-0.0295916777,
0.000752533,
-0.0346364751,
-0.0002310294,
0.085681431,
0.0509158671,
0.008235544,
0.0165992267,
0.0105262082,
-0.0890744478,
0.0453726761,
-0.0317526832,
0.0276329666,
0.0015278956,
0.0252846628,
0.0307059325,
0.0152774826,
-0.0090777334,
-0.0322155431,
0.0131581128,
0.0139340525,
0.0342684425,
0.0174669046,
0.0524204373,
0.0032358882,
-0.0366402082,
0.0466040708,
0.0448511355,
-0.0234354585,
-0.022422675,
-0.0285017695,
-0.0097657461,
-0.0292143468,
0.0277731158,
-0.0432840735,
0.0255654361,
-0.0019944953,
0.0233973209,
0.0431963094,
-0.0014045434,
0.0165885873,
0.001775995,
-0.0243392549,
0.0399679132,
0.0455306843,
-0.0290331729,
-0.0060428991,
0.0166815706,
-0.0689626262,
-0.0457691997,
0.0030708781,
-0.0442101434,
-0.0138821453,
0.0169023611,
-0.0338640064,
-0.0410129838,
-0.0014208158,
-0.0306593198,
0.1026916057,
0.0450133532,
0.0361799411,
0.0382874049,
-0.00399706,
0.0315329842,
-0.0608410016,
0.0078345388,
-0.0690025538,
0.0038483955,
-0.0636303648,
-0.0525413528,
-0.0068761711,
0.0051663406,
-0.0247525014,
-0.0600509979,
-0.0626512691,
0.0383991934,
0.0210287739,
-0.0700358897,
0.0089989854,
0.0250361003,
-0.0186920036,
0.0012746162,
-0.0607390814,
0.0195411704,
-0.0376753621,
0.0169850942,
0.0024702584,
0.0125718834,
-0.0120231435,
-0.0079532545,
-0.0169666521,
-0.0796010792,
0.0087913349,
0.0433276668,
-0.0052585602,
-0.0255745742,
-0.0084678959,
-0.0151938144,
0.0083090542,
-0.0537257232,
0.0556126684,
-0.0629329234,
-0.0068223397,
0.0337040015,
-0.0240598079,
-0.0513106845,
-0.0088390764,
0.0068794629,
-0.0808032528,
0.0267365035,
-0.0156214302,
0.0466597192,
0.0174963642,
0.0114450641,
0.0248597451,
0.0351783745,
0.0557499714,
0.0210697576,
-0.0112629719,
-0.0150112463,
-0.0013474565,
0.0119734751,
-0.0309505593,
-0.0022742527,
-0.0557493716,
-0.0239894651,
0.0021620332,
0.0709378272,
0.040316049,
0.0709486678,
-0.0342799239,
0.0187910218,
0.111049369,
0.0562327057,
0.0477568395,
0.0458111987,
0.0315662585,
-0.0329006016,
0.0122207887,
0.0030787089,
-0.0220667012,
0.0361621901,
-0.0113761015,
0.0450357758,
0.027997423,
0.0628054217,
-0.0125267357,
0.0044305911,
-0.02550615,
0.0190987196,
0.0334062912,
-0.0396694057,
0.0232701283,
0.0106774932,
-0.0310355183,
0.0046836999,
0.0121012665,
-0.0119140455,
-0.0200734437,
-0.0360355712,
0.0391052924,
0.0919943824,
0.0382389948,
0.0266049467,
0.0101716798,
0.0025584735,
-0.026514709,
0.0585466586,
0.0230540838,
0.0141930534,
-0.0109843127,
-0.0110736527,
-0.0108556449,
-0.0137041844,
0.0224945862,
0.0287804306,
-0.0356796682,
0.0018266932,
-0.0060331882,
-0.0437306389,
0.013281689,
0.0045300378,
-0.0573808476,
0.0070986548,
-0.0072224215,
-0.0083988467,
0.0174353886,
0.0238010548,
-0.0536338948,
0.0568817221,
0.0108170267,
-0.0605651215,
-0.0532055944,
0.0422992744,
-0.0459967181,
0.009452926,
0.0029665106,
-0.0500220545,
0.0347805582,
0.0148617094,
0.0590787865,
-0.0218945779,
0.0940784961,
-0.0493786968,
0.0689779148,
-0.0265859552,
0.0395911261,
-0.0167579371,
0.0315202065,
-0.0219401009,
0.1164651513,
0.0009867456,
0.0277863182,
0.013088353,
0.0147979688,
0.0257046893,
-0.0156940427,
-0.0060304194,
0.0266258847,
0.0274446812,
0.001581736,
0.0130113885,
-0.0038822228,
-0.0414903909,
-0.0605251715,
-0.0428475924,
0.0108574452,
0.0047718468,
-0.0071484251,
0.0110102296,
0.003480314,
-0.0351979099,
0.0376025327,
-0.0130844954,
-0.0173288789,
0.000716607,
0.0595724359,
0.0008653556,
-0.0209811386,
-0.0484198444,
0.0005920352,
-0.0297251455,
0.000925662,
0.0561749451,
0.0322801657,
0.0231135469,
-0.0175059345,
0.0166163538,
-0.0737383217,
-0.0299821086,
0.0037019241,
-0.0269325823,
0.0493340418,
0.0007179244,
0.0718340874,
0.0349031538,
0.0238836221,
0.0103250081,
0.0627629235,
-0.02267267,
0.0020365294,
-0.0191744082,
-0.0253815316,
0.0158045534,
-0.0016613624,
-0.0369942151,
-0.0488328077,
0.0763903782,
0.0523302369,
0.0018660902,
-0.0472630933,
0.1154375076,
-0.0093776416,
-0.0496902652,
-0.0018094288,
-0.0056586624,
-0.0382236876,
0.0833011642,
-0.0143129928,
-0.0383920223,
0.0576032251,
0.0050118663,
0.0298345499,
-0.0255806949,
0.023739703,
0.0083061308,
0.0805953592,
-0.0036573096,
0.0302399267,
0.0094263433,
-0.0052888645,
-0.0650562719,
-0.0056472379,
0.0414503552,
-0.0469945259,
0.014508443,
-0.0116758915,
-0.0168260299,
0.0002173942,
-0.0133443037,
-0.0281000752,
-0.0097867232,
-0.0125494897,
0.0249872077,
0.0758882985,
-0.0195902847,
-0.0243034158,
-0.0017573158,
0.0244101193,
-0.008655169,
-0.000528123,
-0.0031487856,
-0.0102601666,
0.0305959899,
0.0916474089,
-0.0205115546,
0.0278449915,
-0.0362065844,
0.0095216632,
-0.0097204763,
-0.0385676548,
0.0260168537,
-0.0357801057,
0.0425833166,
0.0083406372,
0.0197114963,
-0.0393597856,
0.0074609295,
0.0353073329,
-0.0139364926,
-0.011165956,
0.0848203525,
0.0346596129,
0.0196464043,
0.03435589,
-0.012422421,
0.0470275171,
0.0248440392,
0.0095413616,
-0.0276786871,
-0.0154527482,
-0.0053496566,
-0.0172407702,
-0.039142888,
-0.0485604145,
-0.031369552,
-0.1022634283,
0.0274801292,
0.0179253295,
-0.0385071449,
0.0088908765,
-0.0319691636,
-0.0113942139,
0.0148583055,
-0.0023357796,
0.0006791483,
0.0040741949,
0.0189889111,
-0.0129101947,
0.0324967578,
-0.0602161996,
0.029617656,
-0.0211041011,
0.0593149737,
0.1019897684,
0.024037417,
-0.0389683507,
-0.0322892293,
-0.0189472232,
-0.0066858479,
0.0240934957,
-0.0001879955,
0.0064320392,
0.0697495565,
0.0060041617,
-0.0467160307,
-0.000643452,
-0.034568999,
-0.035933651,
-0.0451426618,
0.0857552439,
-0.0103211645,
-0.0614259392,
-0.0410672911,
-0.0005184389,
-0.0205059759,
0.0836656913,
0.0290909857,
-0.0379484631,
-0.0475480631,
-0.0182835665,
0.0005756931,
-0.0373091251,
-0.0441558361,
-0.0177825112,
0.0243594926,
-0.0395969488,
-0.0718468353,
-0.0141960299,
-0.0065023252,
0.0242052954,
0.0183606613,
0.0590026416,
-0.028968066,
-0.0254452657,
-0.0427066162,
0.0125681683,
0.0240792688,
0.0138590401,
-0.0119840726,
-0.0089910766,
-0.0131113157,
-0.0660875514,
-0.0314371698,
0.0219526552,
-0.138571471,
-0.0836196989,
0.0173574984,
-0.0119931521,
0.0372666121,
-0.005971883,
0.0167067945,
-0.0798688456,
0.0122541748,
0.0329521671,
0.0014850161,
0.0647069588,
-0.0251760166,
0.0076615657,
0.009736402,
0.015788978,
-0.0202709213,
0.0355763696,
0.0478461459,
0.0617983453,
0.0270985309,
-0.0196186714,
0.0333808325,
0.0270074643,
0.0035635331,
-0.0272051357,
-0.0137009034,
-0.0509883724,
-0.0253207479,
-0.0235058293,
-0.0024627449,
-0.0382435136,
-0.0364510827,
0.0639858991,
-0.0093298061,
-0.0175129119,
-0.0337155797,
0.0016960385,
0.0095530543,
-0.036232844,
-0.0378284305,
-0.0299585517,
-0.0101211295,
0.0307343733,
0.0057923328,
-0.0056293067,
0.0207841303,
-0.0490585864,
0.0448906533,
-0.0080733523,
0.0585254431,
-0.0025001303,
0.000155698,
-0.0203907117,
0.0223078672,
-0.0772649646,
-0.0627768338,
-0.0024575738,
0.0133762201,
0.0681232214,
-0.0141481459,
0.0381497666,
-0.0667744875,
0.0213779956,
-0.0312000904,
0.0212643966,
0.0003756556,
-0.0081487568,
-0.0075735035,
0.0190761294,
-0.0087818662,
-0.0297412407,
0.065322727,
-0.0213143621,
0.0000113144,
0.0018812862,
-0.0112527758,
-0.0088376002,
-0.004119148,
0.0053676581,
0.0227868631,
-0.0107737714,
0.0283291861,
-0.0700711831,
-0.0590525232,
0.0207002889,
0.0040172427,
0.0165489856,
0.0005002092,
0.0226087868,
0.0619366691,
-0.0512339883,
-0.0165754836,
-0.0101348972,
-0.0140373232,
-0.0393659323,
-0.0211244561,
-0.0360508338,
-6.125209025e-33,
-0.0226919316,
0.0073750289,
0.0149010876,
-0.0590275936,
-0.0470944382,
-0.0581664518,
-0.0473278612,
0.0329080038,
-0.0354165956,
0.0224047042,
-0.0121144466,
0.0027075626,
-0.0019993803,
-0.005259621,
0.0114239529,
-0.0071670315,
0.0276761334,
0.0074274554,
-0.0001853155,
-0.0060656066,
0.0432060696,
-0.0122493096,
0.0189108122,
-0.0599654056,
-0.0220380798,
-0.0127118314,
0.0040328861,
-0.0147127379,
0.0178009905,
0.0706921965,
-0.0501101315,
0.0350439772,
0.0447382964,
-0.0201214235,
-0.0269863922,
-0.0443315767,
0.0126760472,
-0.0509525426,
0.0259032194,
-0.051513195,
0.020751169,
-0.038543243,
0.0454461686,
0.0128645673,
-0.0364539661,
-0.0268293135,
0.0334364846,
-0.0310416408,
-0.025409719,
0.0006949611,
-0.0791273415,
-0.0000596949,
-0.0079420023,
0.0045084185,
-0.0065831887,
-0.0615225472,
-0.0150275817,
0.031282533,
-0.0170235988,
0.0550589412,
0.0268897135,
0.0362222753,
0.0647715479,
0.0388658121,
0.0200584158,
0.0586418509,
0.036002066,
0.0230668578,
-0.0198349264,
0.0069595869,
0.0221632998,
0.0702419281,
0.0287216771,
0.0463085994,
0.0601455495,
-0.019622542,
0.0106219007,
-0.0253454596,
-0.003785928,
-0.0319601111,
0.0677309707,
0.0019177273,
-0.0237298962,
-0.0117012188,
-0.0241726227,
-0.0155883376,
-0.0517661422,
-0.0245929621,
0.0374157801,
-0.0351127312,
0.0201834608,
-0.0312877856,
0.0367886834,
-0.0396973342,
0.0390934087,
0.0056565031,
-0.0694897696,
0.0279432964,
-0.0256187264,
0.00145052,
-0.0206621047,
-0.0393967181,
0.0088901436,
0.0550176315,
0.007248376,
0.0129176648,
-0.0365517437,
-0.0128009282,
-0.0412611999,
-0.0047041164,
-0.0322398804,
-0.0194459874,
0.026442375,
-0.0567387007,
0.0257542171,
-0.0167965405,
-0.0033716511,
-0.03714443,
0.0522394888,
0.0046205781,
-0.0339516997,
-0.0106206415,
-0.0168616474,
0.0146352174,
0.0153633449,
0.0068425974,
-0.0195500236,
-0.0194267519,
0.0820182562,
-0.0534762517,
-0.0393701233,
0.0167442281,
2.645e-7,
0.0297376942,
0.0652483329,
-0.0215297248,
0.0349189825,
0.0280309636,
0.0204686765,
-0.0122041721,
0.0101778284,
0.013018324,
0.0061215241,
-0.0098426556,
0.0153115038,
0.0274359602,
0.0357818455,
-0.0504972637,
0.0621314608,
-0.0840468258,
0.0353431292,
-0.0613476038,
-0.012779776,
0.0571801625,
0.0573470891,
0.0170929506,
-0.0335456654,
-0.0049775224,
-0.0413207188,
0.0610328428,
-0.0229718927,
0.0267067943,
0.0194930825,
-0.0115264524,
-0.021829294,
0.0251884907,
0.0097604422,
-0.0014014392,
0.0109174978,
0.044305142,
0.0154910004,
-0.0172240548,
0.0059767803,
-0.0010283877,
-0.0136407735,
-0.0144545594,
-0.066384308,
0.0479486249,
-0.0239423588,
-0.0336954668,
0.0316704921,
-0.0016556311,
-0.0020900595,
0.036994487,
-0.0356570855,
0.0203700569,
-0.0161666702,
0.019175902,
0.0327432826,
-0.0072933398,
-0.0263393093,
-0.0124960281,
-0.0028474892,
-0.0723923966,
-0.0545485467,
-0.0437438525,
0.0240258481,
0.0832989812,
-0.0401469804,
-0.0227791853,
2.37952199e-34,
0.0391746759,
0.000211761,
0.0221017972,
-0.0076669212,
0.0166141279,
-0.0044836965,
0.0365624614,
0.017439235,
-0.0169743225,
-0.0980202407,
-0.0411707833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11146v1 | The Quo Vadis of the Relationship between Language and Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T10:54:24 | 2023-10-17T10:54:24 | Evelina Leivada, Vittoria Dentella, Elliot Murphy | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of Artificial (General) Intelligence (AI), the several recent
advancements in Natural language processing (NLP) activities relying on Large
Language Models (LLMs) have come to encourage the adoption of LLMs as
scientific models of language. While the terminology employed for the
characterization of LLMs favors their embracing as such, it is not clear that
they are in a place to offer insights into the target system they seek to
represent. After identifying the most important theoretical and empirical risks
brought about by the adoption of scientific models that lack transparency, we
discuss LLMs relating them to every scientific model's fundamental components:
the object, the medium, the meaning and the user. We conclude that, at their
current stage of development, LLMs hardly offer any explanations for language,
and then we provide an outlook for more informative future research directions
on this topic. | [
0.0610720068,
0.0307033267,
-0.0506582633,
0.0467994064,
-0.0556043573,
0.0162763782,
-0.0069306032,
0.0210870374,
-0.0057854941,
-0.0686727613,
-0.0237952787,
-0.0508881509,
0.0303472038,
0.0255794451,
0.036083024,
-0.058864098,
0.0167047903,
-0.0385088213,
0.0357624404,
-0.0073680929,
-0.010020162,
-0.0032075858,
0.0329115205,
0.043075785,
-0.0018196855,
0.0168615002,
0.0103594428,
-0.032308165,
-0.043000523,
0.0078676846,
-0.0542585626,
-0.0010548109,
0.0336109102,
0.0366765037,
0.0000018742,
-0.0786324069,
0.0472511351,
0.0113698663,
-0.0687168837,
0.0259385295,
0.0548435003,
-0.0326026492,
0.0024549512,
-0.0263128038,
-0.0077684787,
0.0129785342,
0.0630337074,
0.0250659939,
-0.0068501686,
0.0590655208,
0.0087993154,
-0.0893121958,
0.0563206486,
-0.0050801639,
-0.0086273532,
-0.0252152067,
0.0664117187,
0.0341172107,
0.0458861589,
0.0368131436,
-0.0441199802,
0.0458557829,
0.0127906101,
-0.00556657,
-0.005097399,
0.0110520106,
0.0038635479,
-0.0554719791,
0.0169750769,
0.0243815966,
0.024274312,
-0.0237919781,
0.0041641071,
0.0119807627,
-0.0150505127,
0.0367837846,
-0.0705648512,
0.0588600263,
0.0195576511,
0.0344276018,
0.0599000379,
-0.0111773219,
0.0616940223,
0.0546327792,
-0.0530380942,
0.0986197069,
-0.0059932508,
-0.0181439742,
-0.0090732761,
-0.0033158869,
-0.0238258261,
-0.0590853803,
-0.0110807838,
0.0403800718,
-0.0147698298,
0.0391861275,
0.0051208274,
-0.0012173333,
0.027552424,
-0.0448453426,
0.060432978,
0.0101654995,
0.0067491056,
0.0440208241,
0.0195081774,
0.0614271238,
-0.048962187,
0.0018248045,
-0.0246966146,
-0.0141550237,
-0.0583056286,
-0.0663185045,
-0.0077255131,
0.0342104211,
-0.0438671187,
-0.0510681197,
0.0001035565,
0.0233661067,
0.0151762674,
-0.0384846553,
-0.0056598657,
-0.0045259106,
-0.002948324,
0.0002836078,
-0.0463059545,
0.0116635589,
-0.0093146143,
0.0325350873,
-0.027276475,
-0.073469609,
0.0265417751,
0.0329314359,
-0.0203612223,
-0.0293115936,
0.0023437429,
0.0724508539,
0.0660445243,
-0.0141087146,
-0.0009025232,
-0.0114759225,
-0.0476496629,
-0.0781411976,
0.0077487021,
-0.0226116627,
0.0112263663,
0.0428689234,
-0.0041987118,
-0.0488691293,
-0.0157106537,
-0.0192104019,
-0.0767188296,
0.0650234222,
-0.0246250462,
0.042927999,
0.0363748595,
0.0094350278,
0.023306068,
0.0335998237,
0.0462169237,
-0.0249796733,
0.034700986,
-0.0471553281,
0.0187929273,
0.0476993509,
-0.0206749141,
-0.011946681,
-0.0480711907,
-0.01440222,
-0.0314150751,
0.0269635133,
-0.0002384921,
0.0781735033,
-0.008790941,
-0.0178116877,
0.0567567199,
0.0720951185,
-0.0005307128,
0.0372597463,
0.0637316629,
-0.0211127084,
0.0313807614,
0.0328261107,
-0.0271693841,
-0.0191368312,
-0.0374207497,
0.0001261987,
0.0031960432,
0.0169141367,
-0.0249138325,
-0.040653795,
-0.0453757122,
-0.001519821,
0.013644754,
0.0099877231,
0.0753438622,
-0.0233398657,
0.0297925789,
0.0050479113,
0.0374220908,
-0.0043484364,
0.0194646809,
-0.0896027237,
0.0240193717,
0.0473208725,
0.0430971012,
0.0013956076,
0.023845667,
0.0065195966,
-0.0074505974,
0.0558223017,
0.034496095,
-0.0173312929,
-0.0396735594,
-0.0092839748,
0.0182636753,
-0.0207883809,
0.0224777628,
-0.0018109493,
-0.025322713,
-0.0218302403,
-0.0176576525,
-0.0194724835,
-0.0435012989,
0.0420426428,
-0.0468197875,
-0.0209365711,
-0.0566635467,
-0.0199786983,
0.0593197979,
0.015547784,
-0.0071206661,
0.0345245562,
0.027646346,
-0.0316416249,
-0.0070847692,
0.0180939101,
-0.0071922736,
0.0462460108,
0.0442321189,
-0.0030809105,
0.0268764887,
0.0312426053,
0.0310895387,
-0.0283167344,
0.0372627862,
-0.0588952899,
0.0665984452,
-0.0133292079,
0.0360365249,
-0.0544779748,
0.0088233724,
-0.0343939029,
0.061216455,
0.0086304825,
0.0133298635,
0.0094120866,
-0.0035916436,
0.0215593614,
-0.0269990712,
-0.0283558685,
0.04902298,
0.0328289457,
-0.0078804856,
0.0467136204,
-0.059828233,
-0.0080795763,
-0.0303388704,
-0.0444146432,
-0.0338222943,
0.0085552037,
0.0014127517,
0.00374548,
-0.0225998778,
-0.0111095114,
0.0385248624,
0.0159139056,
-0.0019402482,
0.0301547498,
0.0321286507,
0.0330057256,
0.0021217447,
-0.0529062785,
-0.0367874019,
-0.0260337424,
-0.03654873,
0.0698851719,
0.0052937721,
-0.0381365567,
-0.0816030353,
0.0403170586,
-0.0324548706,
-0.0051035495,
-0.0147006502,
-0.0085456064,
0.0277096424,
-0.0044769333,
0.0299861506,
0.0577562414,
0.0016371404,
0.1062099338,
0.0602569096,
-0.0130270701,
-0.0392812565,
-0.0395971462,
-0.034609694,
-0.0296787675,
-0.065459542,
-0.0324202478,
-0.0073026316,
0.073589392,
-0.0033306719,
-0.0153237814,
-0.0197985135,
0.0666359589,
-0.0594443493,
-0.0473447405,
0.0000438612,
-0.0519366264,
-0.0355291069,
0.0281144716,
-0.0170924496,
-0.0443989709,
0.0405030772,
-0.0404738933,
0.0088858455,
-0.0224513877,
-0.0430191681,
-0.027168842,
0.0711847469,
0.0055734492,
0.0223845895,
0.0093094558,
-0.0106056305,
-0.0088955248,
-0.0077376789,
-0.0256981496,
-0.0224408954,
0.0141552566,
-0.0593210496,
0.023829259,
0.0037012077,
-0.0211310331,
0.0019900575,
-0.0150726521,
-0.0710161254,
0.0468531176,
0.027186878,
-0.0178775825,
-0.0501083545,
0.0347216502,
0.0531221218,
-0.0289696697,
0.0052957227,
-0.0005772234,
-0.0358366184,
-0.0068242052,
0.0408583805,
-0.0155553129,
0.0521404184,
-0.0060480279,
0.0206797887,
0.0254114624,
0.0059729288,
0.0479031503,
-0.0298324134,
-0.0121745355,
0.0429175533,
-0.0204019118,
-0.0676631704,
0.0111747608,
0.0188228097,
-0.0600680709,
0.0078521818,
0.1172938943,
0.0147718405,
0.0085977539,
0.0348385163,
-0.0056253802,
-0.023215754,
0.023350371,
-0.0067254244,
-0.0572548322,
0.005143451,
0.0131660551,
-0.038321767,
-0.0308760926,
-0.0411931686,
-0.0126008112,
-0.0953138545,
0.0327788219,
-0.0005710368,
-0.0327292494,
-0.0304374881,
-0.0564957075,
-0.0071826945,
0.0102791153,
0.0425883085,
-0.008047834,
-0.0021498101,
-0.0118378159,
0.0189442616,
-0.0234953891,
-0.0660092607,
0.0040456904,
-0.0294078626,
0.0751732141,
0.0573556721,
0.0536823459,
-0.0467466675,
-0.0044821682,
0.0247473642,
-0.0053687752,
0.0190997496,
-0.010978885,
-0.004570886,
0.028213799,
-0.0026273385,
-0.0434731096,
0.0133083025,
-0.0230959989,
-0.0184187815,
-0.0280134622,
0.0818935186,
-0.0334181711,
-0.0574865006,
-0.020911552,
-0.0224405807,
-0.0329008698,
0.0995017067,
0.0264675282,
-0.0495060161,
-0.0367523395,
-0.021479737,
-0.013054275,
0.0688235611,
-0.0912762582,
0.0221203789,
0.0164458714,
-0.0013447338,
-0.0209298916,
-0.0221808795,
0.0141468272,
-0.0108142719,
0.0454291105,
0.0251146387,
0.0113637121,
-0.0319986716,
0.0194379669,
0.0307042096,
-0.028671341,
0.0063198777,
-0.045404613,
0.001521568,
0.0469035879,
-0.0348927826,
0.000818616,
0.0069371276,
-0.0139137777,
-0.088188149,
0.0139887733,
-0.0004193835,
0.0381884426,
-0.0048881918,
0.01589269,
-0.1117649823,
0.0123625612,
-0.0195152648,
-0.0315292031,
0.0541293994,
-0.0204752441,
0.0085394327,
0.0181459785,
0.0393183269,
-0.01472631,
0.0274003893,
-0.004745726,
0.0178126618,
-0.0315089263,
-0.0268134661,
0.0379311927,
0.0366594754,
0.0235257968,
-0.0155449901,
-0.0170203894,
-0.0067452383,
-0.042734649,
-0.0362233035,
-0.0142987771,
-0.0263952967,
-0.008579582,
0.0262415577,
0.0368427075,
-0.0346780419,
-0.0222333893,
-0.0263694786,
0.0340551548,
-0.006368082,
0.0172035061,
-0.0047295364,
-0.0057540559,
0.0190886334,
0.0214761645,
0.0137282368,
0.0386809558,
-0.0766271576,
0.0179847851,
0.0029834271,
0.0345310196,
0.019813275,
0.0004238556,
-0.0074940012,
0.0079521583,
-0.0590383932,
-0.0832952335,
0.0373604596,
0.0376532897,
0.0095469989,
-0.0210885648,
0.0462449417,
-0.0467322581,
-0.0191416014,
-0.0377968587,
0.0028320493,
0.0280681849,
-0.0319657587,
0.0349227674,
0.0270558503,
-0.0566972829,
-0.0023538391,
0.0576650426,
0.0270919148,
0.053222172,
-0.0086624725,
-0.0133341225,
0.0109326383,
-0.0402557701,
-0.0037695195,
-0.0192201324,
-0.00819638,
0.0277378336,
-0.0807871222,
-0.0629102588,
0.0081847887,
0.0015536103,
0.009162331,
-0.0608129092,
0.0007102586,
0.0717674643,
-0.0014754131,
-0.0197457969,
-0.0290764514,
0.0144494483,
-0.02544179,
0.0008617116,
0.0129687423,
-6.058237071e-33,
-0.0004316372,
-0.027201388,
0.022129951,
-0.0052547273,
-0.0163236987,
-0.0035499611,
-0.0203585476,
-0.0015067884,
-0.0369289368,
0.0153322713,
-0.0016938155,
-0.0165134352,
0.0031997785,
0.0002931711,
0.0221998747,
0.007748229,
0.0324625708,
-0.0134248026,
0.0208296608,
-0.0218050815,
0.025701575,
-0.0112404395,
0.0150004989,
-0.0884649307,
0.0556880124,
0.0044495119,
0.0323718861,
0.0554198027,
-0.005677958,
0.0627102852,
-0.0497635081,
0.0413436033,
0.0513294712,
-0.0555293448,
-0.0006623726,
0.0343339182,
-0.0192249939,
0.0112751247,
0.0699679255,
0.0217593759,
-0.0005956824,
-0.061094448,
0.0520861447,
-0.0297490638,
-0.0525264889,
0.021415798,
0.0182034336,
-0.0464712307,
0.0065637296,
0.0109554781,
-0.0738470107,
0.0070250668,
-0.0034686744,
0.0140142497,
0.0434489772,
-0.0194406845,
-0.0267741717,
0.0375794321,
-0.0105513055,
0.0257707164,
0.0153810186,
0.0049512107,
0.0497758016,
0.0283274055,
0.039070271,
0.0609764196,
0.05495473,
-0.0087669259,
-0.043789953,
-0.0282127857,
0.0279594082,
0.0444712937,
0.0227125231,
0.019418234,
-0.0125342235,
-0.0021816238,
-0.0702440292,
-0.0505428612,
-0.0051732995,
0.0334756076,
0.0434179455,
0.0226589795,
-0.0414139107,
-0.0454942584,
-0.0451514348,
-0.0444818959,
-0.0171491243,
-0.0097847786,
0.0228142031,
-0.0219917372,
0.0108471839,
0.0034733261,
0.0269713867,
-0.0956793427,
-0.0329927616,
-0.0046609528,
0.0102592455,
0.0384738557,
0.0221915431,
0.0220151711,
-0.0672708079,
-0.0449707732,
-0.0378886834,
0.0109085655,
0.0084484424,
0.0175581519,
-0.004519315,
0.0239389073,
0.007771045,
-0.012117561,
-0.0208082013,
-0.0560391918,
0.0358707756,
-0.0190137494,
0.0452840403,
0.0216588657,
0.0083734086,
0.0192522462,
0.0327501856,
0.0159229431,
-0.0034827997,
0.0092229228,
-0.0216475911,
-0.0005329991,
-0.0232364126,
-0.0150091872,
-0.0276677292,
0.0189577881,
0.0653444976,
-0.0377688333,
-0.0035650749,
-0.0258611497,
2.686e-7,
0.0669527873,
0.0815982595,
0.0068039172,
0.0034466651,
0.0465102047,
0.0120564774,
-0.0188235324,
-0.00681281,
0.0009035801,
-0.0225781649,
-0.0109961201,
0.0414422415,
0.0235882867,
-0.0112881856,
-0.0469291955,
0.0020573039,
-0.0397561267,
-0.0166695584,
-0.0637726262,
0.0374217555,
-0.0025764822,
0.072672829,
0.019836884,
-0.0141476505,
-0.0489428192,
-0.0580552854,
0.048281882,
-0.0723025352,
0.0059005697,
0.034439113,
0.0200718492,
0.0279693883,
0.0214665625,
0.0129436627,
0.0501219481,
0.048079662,
0.0106195426,
0.057104148,
-0.0119139878,
0.0137972003,
-0.0057286229,
-0.0480392575,
-0.0170158539,
-0.0684952959,
0.0665104985,
-0.0545095801,
-0.0747172013,
-0.0459022596,
0.0237183608,
-0.0220383555,
-0.0097240303,
-0.0121804951,
0.0215500928,
-0.009115139,
-0.0003875521,
-0.0250088666,
0.0110633364,
-0.0619375743,
0.0093116043,
0.0132825729,
-0.0559541136,
-0.0446575657,
-0.0218257923,
-0.0041296692,
0.0432920679,
-0.0745917782,
0.0013778299,
2.409704644e-34,
0.0232930295,
0.0094893938,
0.0266993511,
0.0224389993,
0.0364985839,
0.0147187337,
0.0025512215,
0.0406996161,
0.021428179,
-0.1038338616,
-0.0098573063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11141v1 | Long-form Simultaneous Speech Translation: Thesis Proposal | 2023-10-17T10:44:05 | 2023-10-17T10:44:05 | Peter Polák | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Simultaneous speech translation (SST) aims to provide real-time translation
of spoken language, even before the speaker finishes their sentence.
Traditionally, SST has been addressed primarily by cascaded systems that
decompose the task into subtasks, including speech recognition, segmentation,
and machine translation. However, the advent of deep learning has sparked
significant interest in end-to-end (E2E) systems. Nevertheless, a major
limitation of most approaches to E2E SST reported in the current literature is
that they assume that the source speech is pre-segmented into sentences, which
is a significant obstacle for practical, real-world applications. This thesis
proposal addresses end-to-end simultaneous speech translation, particularly in
the long-form setting, i.e., without pre-segmentation. We present a survey of
the latest advancements in E2E SST, assess the primary obstacles in SST and its
relevance to long-form scenarios, and suggest approaches to tackle these
challenges. | [
-0.0239525549,
0.0517824776,
0.005045169,
0.014335461,
-0.0217397083,
0.0013076481,
0.0576157793,
-0.0310237855,
-0.0481554121,
0.0024363226,
-0.0363424681,
-0.0676005408,
0.0386303179,
0.038217444,
0.0119096814,
-0.0654875338,
0.0191802718,
-0.0147795482,
-0.0156080294,
0.0163764767,
0.0037884004,
-0.0014186285,
-0.0288353451,
0.0233164988,
-0.0298632532,
0.0151727227,
-0.0353609249,
0.0247778222,
0.0308056269,
-0.0036498853,
-0.0177508071,
-0.0224458221,
0.0511187352,
0.0618416294,
0.0000019307,
-0.0109016588,
-0.0288872588,
0.0136006791,
-0.036102064,
-0.0177041907,
0.0230420306,
-0.0258404184,
-0.0146430284,
0.0411329642,
-0.0119514428,
-0.0160818398,
0.0450944379,
0.0221133474,
0.0465651974,
0.0326469839,
-0.0230581369,
-0.0446427837,
0.0356032066,
-0.0648039207,
-0.0223349426,
-0.0404189341,
-0.0200163256,
-0.0524776168,
-0.0287984256,
-0.0281030685,
-0.0000515229,
0.0823217928,
0.0518252254,
-0.0185948629,
-0.0250020511,
-0.0382789262,
-0.0383791663,
-0.0493455082,
-0.019374229,
0.089990586,
-0.0465995595,
0.0435429588,
0.0206531733,
-0.0092447801,
-0.0239205249,
-0.0692737252,
-0.0144714341,
0.028841706,
0.0221545398,
-0.0222587977,
-0.0186953843,
0.0260510333,
0.0378445946,
-0.049610015,
-0.0895872191,
0.0305169169,
0.029252328,
-0.01491726,
0.0240706354,
0.0050802133,
-0.0296655912,
-0.0137824547,
0.0957114324,
0.0124688232,
-0.0257354211,
0.0243970025,
-0.0452763028,
-0.0746688023,
-0.0277811699,
-0.0248753056,
-0.0077337692,
0.046237275,
-0.0418734401,
0.0133439442,
-0.0271129049,
0.0219483692,
-0.0478332862,
-0.0089714024,
-0.0462879762,
-0.0238042139,
0.0109331114,
0.031275101,
-0.0636534095,
-0.0269407853,
-0.0717282519,
-0.0345503911,
-0.0129884109,
0.0123796007,
-0.0025983076,
0.0173101109,
0.0332329459,
0.0009948277,
-0.0840232074,
-0.0416756831,
0.0437380895,
0.0853306353,
-0.017650567,
0.0302434862,
0.0294964034,
-0.0302639399,
-0.0183839221,
0.0321251154,
0.0082138358,
-0.0212166328,
-0.0229962822,
0.0333878882,
-0.0093301041,
-0.0086186295,
-0.0271841064,
-0.018654177,
-0.0349480323,
-0.0287180096,
0.0172376353,
-0.0449410453,
0.058146216,
-0.0196442287,
0.0352871642,
0.0197211131,
-0.0075837076,
-0.032493595,
0.0273551438,
0.0762227625,
0.0088018076,
0.0163071118,
0.0560063161,
0.0235179886,
0.049543824,
0.0483279787,
0.0799836591,
0.0086398032,
0.0136950761,
-0.0132036116,
-0.0275523718,
0.0988400131,
0.0123226224,
0.0381559059,
-0.0329483002,
0.0007451561,
0.0274379272,
0.0383297801,
-0.0056915153,
0.0346300788,
0.0031681061,
0.0105970185,
0.0351276547,
0.0149753066,
0.0217376202,
0.0321355127,
0.0970597044,
0.0259111952,
-0.0442107171,
0.0014639329,
0.010323137,
-0.0037800053,
0.0348042399,
-0.0075325002,
0.0627365932,
0.0191474929,
-0.026541885,
-0.0079348255,
0.033449132,
-0.0413212962,
0.0066356901,
0.0215338692,
0.021832915,
0.0027999156,
-0.0494464114,
0.0523637086,
-0.0351518989,
-0.0701944679,
0.0561004728,
-0.0230396353,
-0.0733085498,
0.0680697635,
-0.0171088818,
-0.018486781,
-0.0284962878,
-0.046386607,
0.008751926,
0.0441454239,
0.0222453922,
0.0142418472,
0.0912870318,
-0.0415441468,
-0.0129485494,
0.0476931371,
0.0031278969,
0.0286557283,
-0.0298533626,
0.0651192591,
0.035926003,
0.0161039047,
0.0275079887,
0.0026428287,
-0.030920662,
0.0203109141,
0.0441517718,
0.0399909578,
0.0223947931,
0.0193303693,
-0.0148882894,
-0.0088397823,
0.0296893287,
-0.0395595245,
-0.0130286282,
0.015725838,
-0.0721398517,
-0.0217706542,
-0.0022068545,
-0.044538103,
-0.0108732432,
0.0395137854,
-0.0062980833,
-0.0983601287,
-0.0150001496,
0.0028702251,
0.011728745,
0.0087105529,
0.0428877138,
0.0235181078,
0.0103013562,
-0.004290198,
-0.032935705,
0.0221561212,
-0.0333656967,
0.0467890203,
-0.0257205311,
0.0090559153,
-0.0822762996,
-0.0316210128,
0.0582318082,
0.0088536311,
0.0039675869,
0.0069018537,
0.0100077111,
-0.0199128203,
-0.0218989067,
-0.0897744298,
0.0215005577,
-0.0294662155,
0.0172394775,
0.0333988443,
0.0525349528,
-0.0073349802,
-0.0055706315,
-0.025142964,
-0.001196094,
0.0187712647,
-0.0390105397,
-0.0495641194,
0.0051020249,
-0.0198672228,
-0.0034439017,
-0.01482898,
0.016996786,
-0.0009512045,
0.0052848272,
-0.0499653704,
-0.0469351783,
0.0028058563,
0.0378071368,
0.0354992636,
0.0199259054,
-0.0383874588,
-0.0237051919,
-0.0246268436,
0.0366841778,
0.0361472666,
0.0137218526,
-0.0197300855,
0.0005666644,
-0.0587329939,
-0.0227175914,
0.0319345519,
-0.0172168966,
0.0141342878,
-0.0367362946,
0.015103627,
-0.0116836112,
0.0238499735,
0.0089098569,
0.0061921766,
-0.0473502465,
-0.0661961213,
-0.0153490305,
-0.0515870638,
0.000964699,
-0.0370806009,
-0.0060630441,
-0.000935068,
-0.0013371693,
-0.0159713756,
0.0245811939,
-0.0752613023,
-0.0620254762,
-0.0329836383,
-0.0166636556,
-0.0130130276,
0.030885851,
0.0010060687,
-0.0114064105,
-0.0606312566,
-0.0479705818,
-0.0293949638,
0.0443675742,
-0.0461196862,
-0.025194183,
0.0334024131,
-0.0309697557,
-0.0195452552,
-0.0205431376,
-0.0128160911,
-0.0230338089,
0.0147841536,
-0.0299249385,
0.0076954518,
0.0177781489,
-0.0549194142,
-0.0417619832,
0.0114908712,
0.0197524447,
0.0842729136,
-0.0092528816,
0.0201670378,
-0.0300810095,
0.0394994542,
0.018256668,
0.0071412125,
-0.0036742729,
-0.0533517674,
0.0384471305,
-0.0079496363,
0.07870882,
0.0012700398,
-0.046543099,
-0.0254025515,
0.0336164311,
-0.0022662831,
-0.0286451448,
-0.0208414253,
0.0305353943,
-0.0734042227,
0.022348864,
0.0967535079,
-0.0080148447,
-0.0505068339,
-0.0240389835,
0.0118468031,
0.0142040886,
0.0097919051,
-0.0010281488,
-0.0702035204,
-0.0409927741,
0.0338892862,
0.0264017805,
0.0388517976,
0.0332166217,
-0.0327071622,
-0.047731407,
0.0389327705,
0.040487688,
-0.0482418314,
0.002076406,
0.0460026748,
-0.0297157131,
-0.0148992976,
0.0555525944,
-0.0156524405,
0.0110222781,
-0.0497540943,
-0.0086160293,
-0.0228335503,
0.0307685547,
0.0036472401,
-0.0215322655,
0.0296646133,
0.0516489521,
0.0229295976,
0.00804957,
0.0036739171,
0.0792497769,
-0.0405180901,
-0.0175659265,
0.0210185573,
-0.0184629224,
-0.0227070898,
-0.0338536948,
0.0242915638,
0.0326899737,
-0.0262768064,
0.0440918133,
0.0408031531,
0.046706818,
-0.0172413979,
0.0262905452,
0.009289287,
-0.0022478837,
0.0329475813,
0.0368960313,
-0.0069856071,
-0.0700527653,
0.0001901973,
0.0095993616,
-0.0113217589,
-0.0553697869,
-0.0046389885,
-0.001843157,
-0.0122691207,
-0.0124224154,
-0.0414091162,
-0.0136161782,
0.0394633301,
0.0408520959,
0.0281027779,
0.0104557639,
0.0399239287,
0.0139120603,
-0.0077878395,
0.0028718885,
-0.0195873752,
0.0521146506,
-0.0656103939,
0.037466459,
0.0171933323,
-0.0479880273,
0.0091003673,
0.0373932868,
-0.0994836017,
-0.0375147872,
0.0250438601,
-0.023373751,
0.0202006102,
0.0659422576,
-0.0568897426,
-0.0191018172,
0.0475343876,
-0.0332791656,
-0.0297974236,
-0.0223347452,
0.045567099,
0.0011852335,
-0.0158495437,
0.0324443579,
-0.0199948959,
0.0239648614,
-0.0279480554,
0.0077313492,
-0.0067740506,
-0.088269569,
-0.0125904055,
0.0369544923,
0.0485839471,
0.0200896952,
0.0283285882,
-0.0286517832,
0.0665596873,
0.0089117223,
0.0382684022,
-0.0765916556,
0.0137718376,
0.0342109688,
0.0165620036,
0.0259757694,
0.0217697974,
0.0478605404,
-0.0613031499,
0.010447544,
0.0204694774,
-0.0122549925,
0.0350645147,
0.0143002076,
0.0152445016,
-0.0034062744,
0.0322258808,
0.0253459848,
0.0193500407,
-0.0478395559,
0.0378828607,
0.0144759174,
0.0132657457,
0.0193922631,
0.0378836021,
-0.0316042863,
-0.0358792394,
-0.0075638178,
0.0182613768,
0.0337623619,
0.0139647648,
0.1116118133,
-0.0027475716,
0.0167038869,
-0.0376582146,
0.0450128168,
-0.0164402444,
-0.0258389246,
-0.0568182319,
-0.0128951985,
-0.0028606891,
0.0446461886,
0.012117791,
-0.0044710664,
0.0166890286,
-0.0157757141,
-0.0056288275,
-0.0101826442,
-0.0483335182,
-0.0385356992,
-0.0434672832,
-0.0363665223,
-0.046814654,
0.0307603478,
-0.0370249338,
0.0019603032,
0.0045548896,
0.00216581,
-0.0201175027,
0.0240645465,
0.0325567909,
-0.0519969836,
-0.0104077607,
0.0212348681,
-0.0054276842,
0.0218731128,
-0.0112961438,
0.0267932471,
-5.865848319e-33,
-0.0195625424,
0.0111396229,
0.0060646664,
-0.0501355268,
-0.0908568501,
-0.0088311322,
-0.0144895818,
-0.0008832223,
0.0008690375,
-0.0009072332,
-0.0125897815,
0.0402870364,
0.045178201,
0.0292174947,
-0.0123682646,
0.0042502093,
0.0832639486,
-0.0159722511,
0.0070961919,
0.0591742471,
0.0399237163,
0.0251672231,
0.0303151906,
-0.0314241797,
-0.0010333465,
0.0168698672,
-0.0159979444,
0.0310969725,
-0.0432940759,
0.0052990671,
0.0117181614,
-0.0237421189,
-0.0148117142,
-0.0515254885,
-0.0434842147,
0.0634393096,
-0.1057500467,
0.0531855524,
-0.0360191427,
0.061689619,
-0.0779926702,
0.0066158534,
0.0579360947,
0.0077227345,
0.0442209542,
-0.0250398424,
0.0184728578,
-0.0374683402,
0.0118165025,
-0.0363174193,
-0.0519911051,
0.0013846959,
-0.0384009853,
-0.0040185903,
0.0641396418,
0.08264447,
-0.0059619537,
-0.0493887477,
-0.0577004403,
0.0162493102,
0.002480228,
0.0314569548,
0.0506366566,
0.0194151849,
-0.0217723958,
0.0037397929,
0.0583610497,
-0.0420232117,
0.038226109,
-0.016788654,
0.0361145586,
0.0173073281,
0.0355651453,
-0.0172623657,
0.0272544902,
0.00428838,
-0.0719082952,
-0.0069542048,
0.0000239911,
-0.0073365299,
-0.0035545414,
-0.0068047475,
0.0105139893,
0.0178759769,
-0.0413630642,
-0.0088301254,
-0.0026788923,
0.0086125843,
0.0340628736,
0.0393559746,
0.0115611693,
-0.0026650014,
0.1131349653,
0.0101677589,
0.0419860221,
-0.0108059328,
-0.0286594983,
0.0006349802,
-0.0373587757,
0.0540627688,
-0.0026391249,
-0.0276855398,
0.0217462629,
0.030803673,
-0.003890418,
-0.0470566303,
0.0065521207,
0.0485157371,
-0.0207395051,
0.0027337011,
-0.0253331792,
0.0302694105,
-0.0087332157,
0.0176749248,
0.064608112,
-0.0359649919,
0.0063197664,
0.0731246471,
-0.0167037398,
-0.004103384,
0.00156327,
-0.0286852382,
0.0555753037,
0.0574929491,
-0.073896125,
0.00602342,
-0.0177347939,
-0.0236909539,
0.0558779463,
-0.0606622696,
-0.0183723103,
-0.0116611253,
2.608e-7,
-0.0010089714,
0.0083035566,
0.057690192,
-0.0088123372,
0.0350291356,
0.0142514147,
-0.0124873035,
0.0298656486,
-0.008623058,
0.0533318259,
0.0373607613,
-0.0009663231,
0.09257783,
0.0084643252,
-0.0874032453,
-0.053667523,
-0.034530703,
0.0402880646,
-0.050362125,
0.0117180999,
0.0350446515,
0.0580309667,
-0.0263822675,
-0.0070888083,
0.0046079084,
-0.0212068204,
0.0312006325,
0.0087721664,
0.0182940159,
-0.0177238416,
0.0009712829,
0.0077834511,
-0.0750279874,
0.0252992511,
-0.0260933209,
0.0201629903,
0.0576459952,
0.0689524785,
0.0244592074,
-0.037343353,
0.0150121236,
0.0308517236,
-0.0331969336,
0.0195594206,
0.0665014759,
-0.0608473904,
0.0135146938,
0.0330056772,
-0.0323153362,
-0.0012843282,
-0.0132293217,
0.0087713543,
0.0344710276,
0.0014649435,
0.0213674419,
-0.0161221325,
-0.0191127155,
-0.0698480159,
-0.0129687414,
-0.0129427258,
-0.0578103699,
-0.0270301979,
-0.0586959235,
0.0092726937,
0.0231064577,
-0.0083919372,
-0.0304253511,
2.197091007e-34,
0.0194681957,
-0.0053687994,
0.0291222651,
-0.0452293418,
-0.0068872897,
-0.0621932112,
-0.0198489111,
0.005908669,
-0.0234293193,
-0.0577816069,
-0.0862703398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13012v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13012v2 | H2O Open Ecosystem for State-of-the-art Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T09:40:58 | 2023-10-23T10:24:55 | Arno Candel, Jon McKinney, Philipp Singer, Pascal Pfeiffer, Maximilian Jeblick, Chun Ming Lee, Marcos V. Conde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) represent a revolution in AI. However, they also
pose many significant risks, such as the presence of biased, private,
copyrighted or harmful text. For this reason we need open, transparent and safe
solutions. We introduce a complete open-source ecosystem for developing and
testing LLMs. The goal of this project is to boost open alternatives to
closed-source approaches. We release h2oGPT, a family of fine-tuned LLMs of
diverse sizes. We also introduce H2O LLM Studio, a framework and no-code GUI
designed for efficient fine-tuning, evaluation, and deployment of LLMs using
the most recent state-of-the-art techniques. Our code and models are fully
open-source. We believe this work helps to boost AI development and make it
more accessible, efficient and trustworthy. The demo is available at:
https://gpt.h2o.ai/ | [
0.0163889099,
0.0911612585,
-0.0179185439,
0.0634646639,
-0.0444685519,
-0.0067530312,
0.0094522228,
0.0120664006,
0.039688345,
-0.0178666543,
-0.0450122654,
-0.029683942,
-0.0009128566,
0.0838826373,
0.0080786636,
-0.0189175121,
0.0277472083,
-0.0665539131,
-0.0238167681,
-0.0266022515,
0.0116089564,
0.0377919525,
-0.0069324705,
0.0538218692,
0.0211704951,
-0.0159855727,
-0.0066917934,
0.0107535673,
0.0053860191,
-0.0149312532,
-0.0077063781,
0.0732567012,
0.0049208677,
0.0971041471,
0.0000021529,
-0.0629337057,
-0.0090978844,
0.0081963791,
0.0011688528,
0.0513268486,
0.059583731,
0.0044559436,
-0.0462156683,
0.0328775793,
-0.0233285837,
-0.0056852777,
0.0504004955,
0.0063956026,
0.0864973068,
0.0783067793,
0.0062524695,
-0.0272682998,
0.0366426781,
-0.0384729989,
-0.0225822758,
-0.0272753518,
0.0485699587,
-0.0090408493,
0.0322937369,
-0.0030417738,
-0.0009039065,
0.0339823887,
0.0223829541,
-0.0180887897,
-0.0154912472,
0.0297502764,
-0.050256446,
-0.0435660481,
-0.0126293655,
0.0744355023,
-0.0216313303,
-0.0470169708,
0.0159457605,
-0.0023124095,
-0.0346231423,
-0.0283739287,
-0.0539825968,
0.0745199025,
0.0211312324,
0.032444682,
0.0215206575,
-0.0397475511,
0.0286980662,
0.0226832721,
0.0072226101,
0.0649166927,
0.0338105969,
-0.0092414785,
-0.0176156908,
-0.0234333277,
-0.0104952203,
-0.0857534558,
0.0362792239,
0.0164899342,
0.0359478071,
0.0261368621,
-0.0566325262,
-0.0341944434,
0.0302684139,
-0.0634403899,
0.0304749031,
0.0176061522,
-0.0081840176,
0.0515852496,
-0.0032383725,
0.029954046,
-0.0297727473,
0.0228145793,
-0.0086422199,
-0.0068675177,
-0.0017279171,
0.0224172771,
-0.0491446964,
0.01146363,
-0.0406469256,
-0.0139357597,
-0.0168110281,
0.0202844702,
0.0097304611,
0.0231127571,
0.0388159454,
-0.0120003438,
-0.0188743155,
-0.0372069664,
0.0038339028,
0.0001489404,
-0.0134045873,
-0.0035560587,
-0.0191037506,
-0.0759185255,
0.0144760981,
0.0426372439,
-0.0144953635,
-0.0089182071,
0.0086564086,
0.0709087402,
0.0347417481,
-0.0098322928,
-0.0079047643,
-0.0032156906,
-0.0027738682,
-0.070786342,
-0.0396964028,
-0.0846969262,
0.0160747785,
0.0034988406,
-0.004467953,
-0.0700179711,
0.0122863706,
0.0120680146,
-0.0436082855,
0.0197866485,
-0.0570171811,
0.0084975343,
0.0262320153,
0.0105886152,
0.0051647704,
0.0759954005,
0.0576556921,
0.0407534465,
0.0530919097,
-0.007206609,
0.0260998886,
0.088901706,
-0.0006834812,
0.0365246199,
-0.0315185674,
0.0159963183,
-0.0038528603,
0.0482119732,
-0.0043536774,
0.0977131277,
0.0012612191,
-0.0140411286,
0.0764308646,
0.0543615036,
0.0149217648,
0.031051388,
0.0250559822,
0.0355397873,
0.0234053619,
-0.0708958507,
-0.0531786084,
0.0093968511,
-0.0259985384,
-0.0105958376,
-0.0018363409,
0.0723027363,
0.0081022922,
-0.0144216698,
-0.0348605625,
-0.0374312103,
-0.0169258099,
-0.0043181148,
0.06539803,
-0.024488382,
-0.03743333,
0.0452201143,
0.0382845514,
-0.0543576591,
0.0157580208,
-0.0658352897,
0.0679708347,
0.0875567049,
0.0683631524,
-0.0089959521,
0.0132559668,
-0.0363114588,
-0.0144810639,
0.0500820577,
0.0265119392,
0.0016534628,
-0.0026119654,
-0.0457196236,
-0.0251300149,
-0.008213832,
0.0034787667,
0.0249425452,
0.0348173082,
0.0290707219,
0.0062193009,
0.0018190123,
-0.0355011001,
0.0267605744,
-0.0168119818,
-0.0051434846,
-0.0193891097,
-0.020012442,
0.0181458388,
0.0127261104,
-0.0193445999,
0.0008706765,
0.033633817,
-0.0095694242,
-0.0163082462,
-0.0080153588,
0.0061019133,
0.0257400181,
0.0594010316,
-0.0269867275,
0.0164546799,
0.0396112055,
-0.0444937684,
-0.0063632843,
0.0256043114,
-0.0154507197,
0.0330942422,
-0.0444867648,
0.0180600304,
-0.0651493445,
0.0306694526,
-0.026481878,
0.0207186658,
-0.0033013872,
-0.0142483348,
-0.0047216462,
-0.0089766597,
0.0176293459,
-0.0226450171,
-0.0421520025,
0.0342437066,
-0.0143197114,
0.0324027427,
0.0036120049,
0.0371804237,
-0.0210547782,
-0.0226700213,
-0.0768638402,
0.0190627109,
-0.0319007523,
0.0200065449,
0.0127203865,
-0.0037651986,
-0.0503839739,
0.0117622428,
-0.0008137904,
-0.0011181533,
0.006927764,
0.0007855124,
0.0083489204,
-0.0079962919,
-0.0541563295,
-0.0301869418,
-0.0306477398,
0.0081947334,
0.0343563631,
0.0036644964,
-0.0162688717,
-0.0649245232,
0.0436298624,
-0.0312324315,
0.0574652255,
0.0078778239,
-0.0386098363,
0.0088241985,
-0.0301206913,
0.0205502529,
0.0597724095,
0.0051293783,
-0.0049028681,
0.0909908265,
0.0048514954,
-0.0373640992,
-0.0133148683,
-0.008294262,
-0.0342567191,
-0.045544263,
-0.0254521966,
-0.0133619355,
0.0686638206,
-0.0058535272,
-0.0134165939,
-0.0426289216,
0.0123089459,
-0.0386680253,
-0.0109104533,
-0.0119489478,
-0.0141504239,
-0.0271821562,
0.0385796018,
-0.0091581102,
-0.0628655627,
0.0647181571,
-0.0639381707,
0.010111534,
-0.0069687939,
-0.0291876607,
-0.0664832592,
0.0610692166,
-0.0020048404,
0.0245321468,
0.0043976102,
0.0028686083,
-0.0123057263,
-0.0053305943,
-0.0039783809,
-0.0427364409,
0.0375751294,
-0.0471042134,
0.0037661816,
-0.0143154627,
-0.0522286072,
-0.0320231691,
-0.021583125,
-0.0849966332,
0.006814905,
0.0261843856,
-0.032122314,
-0.0254461151,
0.0104487762,
0.028954979,
0.0388358086,
-0.0079916604,
0.0220762659,
-0.0230142903,
0.0085186549,
0.0642221719,
-0.0068328562,
0.0196196586,
-0.0348665342,
0.0051357886,
0.0525964014,
0.0402497798,
0.0300858188,
-0.0410940126,
-0.0245541986,
0.0528398268,
-0.0157830752,
-0.0079222675,
0.0138736041,
0.0232689455,
-0.0487508215,
0.0204159915,
0.1139842421,
0.0040440592,
-0.0625860095,
0.0135299433,
-0.0285045616,
0.0471358262,
0.0316151157,
0.036217615,
-0.1036161035,
-0.0228521135,
0.0154862106,
0.0104167322,
0.0096469466,
-0.0127747022,
-0.0005043096,
-0.1013785005,
0.04656009,
0.0317847617,
-0.0299359635,
-0.0041379505,
-0.0411156416,
-0.0067689666,
-0.037324585,
-0.0029944663,
0.0202858392,
-0.0126478504,
-0.0111801894,
-0.0171378013,
-0.0117792385,
-0.0344871245,
0.0351364575,
-0.049104549,
0.0700274333,
0.0763869286,
0.0154667934,
-0.0143482238,
-0.0294430256,
0.0401665345,
0.0025970559,
-0.0203273166,
-0.0316933282,
0.0118928878,
-0.0057522892,
-0.0185572598,
-0.025812855,
0.0348467454,
-0.0321339369,
-0.0023120712,
0.0083816266,
0.0802315772,
0.0101010296,
-0.0290695466,
-0.014596099,
-0.0250375941,
0.0005983106,
0.0609841384,
0.0196254551,
-0.0545096286,
-0.0420970321,
-0.0420456678,
-0.0370215774,
-0.0386232696,
-0.025858935,
-0.0026843038,
0.0034435878,
-0.0262944587,
-0.0384725742,
0.0103367222,
0.0072025741,
-0.0054333154,
0.0256255604,
-0.0107826656,
0.0093413945,
-0.0045002908,
-0.0324173458,
0.0285974573,
-0.0720827132,
0.0510396846,
-0.0788038746,
-0.000893832,
0.0297100618,
-0.0194017123,
-0.0177432597,
0.0419201255,
-0.0867162496,
-0.0750541762,
0.0040924032,
0.0643765777,
0.0247263834,
0.020311458,
-0.0254558101,
-0.0961663276,
0.0296316426,
0.0073759453,
-0.0529267676,
0.0320338644,
0.0181917381,
-0.0019441657,
0.0114930021,
0.0565899946,
-0.0580483787,
-0.0061416114,
0.0191571806,
0.0054725036,
-0.0079614883,
-0.0463489555,
-0.0203533787,
0.0237656366,
0.017258428,
-0.0350792967,
0.0008587982,
-0.043784935,
0.0258364566,
-0.0174688473,
-0.0043953448,
-0.0374835096,
0.0383341685,
0.0436138585,
-0.0413030535,
0.0117027126,
0.0157121625,
0.0040691993,
0.0135934819,
-0.0352119617,
0.0515310876,
-0.0118793603,
0.0170154907,
0.068211019,
0.0091108931,
-0.0256353486,
0.0509777404,
-0.034947399,
0.0472339988,
-0.0140315229,
0.0287164599,
-0.0092492327,
-0.028571669,
0.0149344811,
0.0487455241,
-0.0116637684,
-0.0559393205,
-0.0307467952,
0.0679117441,
0.0760817975,
0.063230224,
0.07371445,
-0.0362795107,
-0.0013087813,
-0.0417062193,
0.0236652233,
-0.0190839116,
-0.0635353103,
0.0087702293,
0.0088823009,
-0.0251145735,
0.0292151012,
0.0640757382,
0.0342040062,
0.0397715122,
0.0135063697,
0.0227916576,
-0.0275022425,
-0.0216797665,
0.0034121796,
0.002790777,
-0.0747311339,
-0.0182242934,
-0.0351044312,
-0.0741995126,
-0.019209763,
0.0326724872,
-0.0240798146,
0.0003455287,
0.0323559195,
0.0412270203,
-0.0116640357,
-0.0145501317,
-0.0420273542,
-0.0018098713,
-0.0380213857,
-0.0509615242,
0.0010700569,
-6.791342939e-33,
-0.0066641415,
-0.0008278271,
0.0059196884,
-0.0100743612,
-0.0226611234,
-0.0110886479,
-0.0354501568,
0.0052894345,
-0.0161233135,
-0.0203853548,
0.0027475189,
0.0048585273,
0.0088732392,
0.014440327,
0.0006469084,
0.0213127043,
0.0242694523,
-0.0093836356,
-0.0326554254,
0.0364548564,
0.0089821238,
0.0207072981,
0.0388232991,
-0.0591109283,
-0.018290231,
-0.0276561491,
-0.0442586318,
0.0313969515,
-0.0679155067,
0.0569705889,
-0.0241537746,
0.0406079181,
-0.0051251599,
-0.0065554157,
-0.0061953692,
-0.0129460897,
-0.0158903636,
0.0110777048,
0.0032292828,
0.027424233,
-0.0095035536,
-0.0465152301,
0.0599954613,
-0.014942199,
-0.0299031101,
0.0044010668,
0.0205114465,
-0.0175475646,
-0.0131494738,
-0.0037859164,
-0.0379052088,
0.0323385969,
-0.0076324558,
-0.0133993309,
0.027612824,
-0.0098999748,
0.0109663568,
0.0250720438,
-0.0284984596,
0.0180941448,
0.0248005111,
0.0198258869,
0.1095894873,
-0.0024618404,
0.0261919238,
0.0494877025,
0.0256577041,
-0.0066141649,
-0.0343075134,
0.0049786135,
0.0525165498,
0.0545441769,
0.0539631546,
0.037179742,
-0.0053365412,
-0.0266262144,
-0.0445927344,
0.0070880065,
0.011407651,
0.0413853042,
0.0152739184,
0.0347343758,
-0.0402355753,
0.0084671192,
-0.0469834656,
-0.031049747,
-0.0501235835,
-0.0341275856,
0.0129661802,
0.0124538857,
-0.0426488966,
-0.0142078158,
0.0331811495,
-0.070290044,
-0.0028726014,
0.0189615842,
-0.0129185626,
0.0331939422,
-0.0086629586,
0.0533899777,
-0.0580014475,
-0.0361849256,
-0.0235588681,
-0.0476007126,
0.0104246391,
-0.0057301312,
-0.0169934034,
0.0365309417,
-0.0549577028,
0.0260137562,
-0.0363927297,
0.0176165905,
0.0416192263,
0.0276427083,
0.0032878749,
-0.0157556254,
0.0131146247,
0.0516778566,
0.0309239868,
-0.0003460834,
-0.0246112123,
0.0035885342,
0.0028312462,
0.0075409836,
-0.0298760049,
0.0109416824,
-0.0488591641,
0.0369133614,
0.0452685431,
-0.0512344278,
-0.0252195057,
-0.0021804892,
2.815e-7,
0.0252153687,
0.0584612861,
0.0168989226,
0.0235397574,
0.0296231098,
0.0270649344,
-0.0243182369,
0.0364984646,
-0.0186491478,
0.0055554439,
-0.0331378467,
0.0433587767,
0.0792403147,
0.0171783548,
-0.087288022,
0.0067748157,
-0.0683779866,
0.0138597749,
-0.0912039205,
-0.0116923144,
-0.0044307904,
0.1076155826,
0.0405883715,
-0.0048623602,
-0.0084503153,
-0.0414029136,
0.0427359305,
-0.0231741928,
0.0050923442,
0.0540816076,
-0.0261097271,
0.0296404064,
-0.0134225655,
-0.0391987301,
0.0054518795,
0.0134635773,
-0.0090782912,
0.0825005993,
0.0107692461,
-0.00437713,
0.0424742177,
-0.0580800585,
-0.0313308239,
-0.0953576267,
0.073414892,
0.0012610679,
-0.0176051874,
-0.0538798161,
0.0335895643,
-0.0454093628,
0.0083996113,
-0.0671326295,
0.0045851702,
-0.0058331252,
0.0108291367,
-0.0573673919,
-0.0108967284,
-0.061358545,
-0.0352061056,
-0.039905645,
-0.0459903851,
-0.0302530304,
-0.0340555198,
0.0155808497,
-0.0064280042,
-0.0067070294,
0.0473861322,
2.602559416e-34,
0.0416589677,
-0.0383833982,
-0.0227323044,
0.0294070672,
0.046512045,
0.0004702345,
-0.0058451011,
-0.0005136336,
-0.0272575561,
-0.0712146908,
-0.0247549526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11097v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11097v5 | Experimenting AI Technologies for Disinformation Combat: the IDMO Project | 2023-10-17T09:27:43 | 2023-12-31T12:09:52 | Lorenzo Canale, Alberto Messina | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Italian Digital Media Observatory (IDMO) project, part of a European
initiative, focuses on countering disinformation and fake news. This report
outlines contributions from Rai-CRITS to the project, including: (i) the
creation of novel datasets for testing technologies (ii) development of an
automatic model for categorizing Pagella Politica verdicts to facilitate
broader analysis (iii) creation of an automatic model for recognizing textual
entailment with exceptional accuracy on the FEVER dataset (iv) assessment using
GPT-4 to detecting content treatment style (v) a game to raise awareness about
fake news at national events. | [
0.0275622159,
0.034753751,
-0.0378336497,
0.0148104765,
-0.0658195242,
0.0208120923,
0.0260154922,
0.0024307612,
0.0563429594,
-0.0078299996,
0.0261552408,
0.0043343585,
0.011449513,
0.0929131806,
0.0090363929,
-0.050256215,
0.0547456071,
0.0184006747,
0.0758402869,
-0.0134787634,
0.0212756768,
0.0272046849,
-0.0326018408,
0.0116622625,
-0.0554971024,
-0.0183363203,
0.0031727587,
-0.0118376818,
0.0355174132,
-0.0252332408,
0.0054421038,
0.0232670698,
0.0260243043,
0.0766330808,
0.0000019305,
-0.0074995151,
-0.0045480486,
0.0034167476,
-0.0188501403,
-0.018097192,
0.044094041,
-0.006969214,
-0.0083541395,
0.0277430769,
-0.0640718043,
0.0242246334,
0.0333268456,
0.0081618624,
0.0651542023,
0.1127049029,
-0.0262882151,
-0.0201457776,
0.0778587013,
-0.0025587254,
0.0046052751,
0.0110930391,
0.0292927381,
-0.018209435,
-0.0124564515,
-0.0072753946,
0.066235207,
0.0223905444,
0.0146141807,
0.0185108762,
-0.100169763,
0.0253941454,
-0.0179530513,
-0.0304325707,
-0.0174357537,
0.0041243657,
0.0205447134,
-0.0440086238,
0.0279747639,
0.0096647497,
0.0109033342,
0.0200163033,
-0.0087363645,
0.0171146635,
-0.0493444502,
0.0117040761,
0.0677014962,
-0.0023286662,
0.0233214162,
0.0388405658,
0.0134952078,
0.0625517964,
-0.0026694583,
-0.0259802565,
0.0449211597,
-0.0039010996,
0.0219347533,
-0.0532034487,
0.0103890998,
0.0191010255,
-0.0052470588,
-0.0017534964,
-0.0559417196,
-0.0302928872,
0.0304448698,
-0.089217253,
0.0042844857,
-0.0044852481,
0.0254649129,
0.0581830405,
0.0371200405,
0.0270143636,
-0.0373525657,
0.035504289,
0.0182795655,
-0.0121063832,
-0.0177114196,
0.0182176996,
-0.0236193649,
0.0318789631,
-0.0040009222,
0.0071585504,
-0.027759403,
-0.0192828979,
-0.0588478558,
0.0401883274,
-0.0188189279,
0.0059820223,
-0.0062991204,
0.0156795271,
-0.0419146083,
0.0593099445,
-0.0554953553,
0.0447805487,
-0.0212726332,
-0.0425887443,
0.0058537554,
0.0184342209,
-0.029609818,
-0.0158094019,
0.0516932681,
0.0027251486,
-0.0004655354,
0.010910593,
-0.0184277799,
-0.0396143533,
0.0079181464,
-0.1041677147,
0.0469791554,
-0.0547480993,
0.008258014,
-0.0297555178,
-0.003046893,
-0.0478096418,
-0.0266853459,
0.0237051062,
-0.0235280786,
0.0625279471,
-0.0412123203,
-0.0098421453,
0.0583011732,
0.0267361067,
-0.0001919118,
0.0617148429,
0.0042559602,
0.0787818059,
0.0413235798,
0.0143326605,
0.0676361099,
0.020270614,
0.0480875783,
0.0568262562,
-0.0251298212,
0.0166493692,
-0.0530159362,
-0.0114183603,
-0.0257552788,
0.020228507,
0.001190112,
-0.0236847606,
0.0803112909,
-0.009104264,
-0.0279916804,
-0.0274005197,
0.024890732,
0.0002772192,
0.0309180543,
0.0106157511,
-0.013717345,
0.0370718837,
-0.0398795232,
-0.0272114128,
-0.0136714447,
0.0716866851,
-0.0341513567,
-0.0400782749,
0.0173569135,
-0.0255546141,
0.0648097172,
0.0052827452,
0.0057709874,
-0.0145626906,
-0.0258701723,
-0.0919291899,
0.0232665353,
-0.0085643483,
-0.0122492937,
-0.1127581596,
0.0285572242,
0.041558858,
0.0340251178,
-0.0397444405,
-0.0237184074,
-0.0254423283,
0.0127258757,
0.0376222841,
0.0325945355,
-0.0259177424,
-0.0492046177,
0.0100959837,
-0.0198806375,
-0.0183266383,
0.0202298276,
0.0499797054,
-0.0091176005,
0.0513509475,
-0.0301446877,
0.0245781243,
-0.0175737944,
0.0318315402,
0.0238055643,
-0.0136885364,
-0.0304984301,
0.0261693634,
0.042282559,
0.0557004511,
-0.0048936289,
-0.0142962504,
0.071040757,
0.0131684318,
-0.0059183263,
-0.0416208431,
0.0593317337,
0.035231594,
0.0102032786,
-0.0742827877,
-0.0132657886,
0.0371908136,
-0.0210018437,
0.0178921614,
0.0571163781,
-0.0392568968,
-0.0232621245,
-0.0318958722,
-0.033224795,
-0.0334343314,
0.0180379413,
0.0249607004,
0.0748554841,
-0.0268266611,
-0.0170500316,
-0.0025260802,
-0.0389399417,
0.0086295307,
0.007105974,
0.0148380082,
-0.0033584188,
0.0007243013,
0.0069905361,
0.0318016224,
-0.0370903648,
-0.0179697424,
-0.0105516613,
-0.0346815102,
-0.0034889001,
-0.012994783,
0.0071627763,
0.0275101475,
-0.012071657,
-0.0297596101,
0.0270618536,
-0.0112506794,
-0.0512390919,
0.0092547685,
0.0084364191,
0.0046294639,
0.012053716,
-0.012178015,
0.019408524,
0.0270601083,
-0.0503406711,
0.0026509194,
0.0518049039,
-0.0361814499,
-0.0133793335,
-0.0333894007,
-0.0528663695,
0.040150445,
-0.0389603525,
-0.0525469854,
0.017736027,
0.0189531613,
-0.0464987233,
0.0422363766,
0.0155658582,
0.051286377,
0.0485776365,
0.0384423248,
0.0063869073,
-0.0012825984,
-0.0374029838,
0.0311302878,
-0.032069575,
-0.0711144805,
0.0203695837,
0.0122804726,
0.0388208553,
0.0355435051,
-0.0061595081,
0.0949331075,
-0.0106738443,
-0.0201045908,
0.0413089544,
-0.0571310818,
-0.0038147415,
0.0406509601,
0.0029990987,
-0.0228326432,
0.0886977986,
-0.0191808101,
0.0531033538,
-0.0664214715,
-0.0251110736,
0.0258357283,
0.0297212284,
-0.0143414596,
0.0300315414,
0.0183755867,
0.0425473414,
-0.0100773145,
-0.0641142949,
0.0565484464,
-0.0502463505,
-0.0202707667,
-0.0401649736,
0.0068093557,
0.0317736827,
-0.011856501,
-0.0355466045,
-0.0631308779,
-0.0082402751,
-0.0250344928,
0.026760241,
-0.023052074,
-0.0905482396,
-0.0218175873,
0.0707088709,
0.0418270603,
-0.0199834965,
0.0177205577,
0.0136035262,
0.0168186594,
0.0171501338,
-0.0195750743,
0.0127861062,
0.0015533143,
-0.0254630223,
0.0392553248,
-0.018949056,
0.0137050655,
-0.0552955978,
-0.0156747308,
-0.009252741,
-0.0075041205,
-0.0031150708,
-0.0247503873,
0.0012609625,
-0.046094425,
0.0129050892,
0.0659781769,
0.035267368,
-0.0759965852,
-0.0142290611,
0.0205803216,
-0.0173397381,
0.0121053895,
0.0251169559,
-0.0910030529,
0.0285631139,
0.005115381,
0.0158296563,
-0.0921792313,
-0.021848578,
-0.0111038657,
-0.0567700937,
0.0564653575,
-0.0077092303,
0.0093148062,
-0.0743253455,
-0.1007089838,
-0.0115323132,
-0.0102222832,
-0.0315676294,
-0.0410595387,
0.0583223887,
-0.0009003684,
-0.0083156815,
-0.0077212937,
-0.0486625843,
-0.0162007008,
0.0002122326,
0.0743774772,
0.0685982257,
0.0736794993,
-0.0401985683,
-0.0497140884,
-0.0083533879,
0.0177877955,
-0.0366911516,
-0.0185550023,
0.0979593322,
-0.0170898866,
0.0172294434,
-0.0336634703,
0.0360546112,
0.0626648441,
0.0057588299,
0.0492170565,
0.0461651236,
-0.0410846286,
-0.0455884077,
-0.0361994132,
-0.034206979,
0.0680955872,
0.0254750829,
0.0096686669,
0.0129619306,
0.0023585889,
-0.0036305399,
0.0528576747,
-0.0340400077,
-0.0284213368,
0.0056797718,
-0.0233884715,
-0.0333425142,
-0.0491552949,
-0.0454670265,
-0.0180497468,
0.0143573377,
-0.0062524052,
-0.0413303263,
-0.0041417843,
0.0147313662,
-0.0563390031,
-0.0065492461,
0.0117306458,
0.0329519175,
0.0114498734,
-0.0354743712,
-0.0439171195,
-0.0082763257,
-0.024955295,
0.0507014021,
-0.0264065545,
-0.0238162763,
0.0185814146,
0.0410779677,
0.0247910153,
0.043860022,
-0.0230619013,
-0.0119702518,
0.0441842303,
-0.0067022727,
-0.0238592289,
-0.0074174632,
0.0165997408,
-0.0429900624,
0.0354955383,
-0.0073034242,
0.0199817549,
0.0704375058,
0.0110077811,
-0.0384900495,
-0.054437086,
-0.0000300985,
0.029744789,
0.0116933491,
0.0562219359,
-0.0392838344,
-0.0216521192,
-0.0179363918,
-0.0159821194,
-0.0088872705,
-0.0208376572,
0.031467028,
-0.0049161171,
0.0183995739,
0.0099935541,
0.0165318996,
0.0036325492,
-0.0626464039,
-0.0446913764,
-0.045552291,
0.0054870131,
0.0328840688,
0.0799466074,
-0.0238936506,
-0.0049796724,
-0.0101009374,
0.0867495015,
-0.0047679888,
0.0463805236,
-0.0209388323,
0.0093089342,
0.035879489,
-0.0271788854,
0.0259038862,
0.0286975615,
-0.027452454,
0.0157303456,
-0.0226997416,
0.0620742738,
0.0382670276,
0.0521520227,
-0.0117410272,
0.0058145919,
-0.0092565222,
0.0107997181,
-0.0356998295,
0.0025320542,
0.0011621424,
-0.0186892133,
0.01697262,
-0.0458994061,
0.051706586,
0.0282518808,
-0.0283485316,
0.0448346101,
0.0525267012,
-0.0506255701,
-0.0263565406,
-0.0299259014,
-0.0180215444,
0.0361047052,
-0.0270660147,
-0.0213028919,
-0.0711499453,
-0.043978408,
-0.0026490362,
0.0158780869,
0.000877365,
0.0071999724,
0.0072201286,
0.0328466892,
0.0033548998,
0.0309546515,
-0.0331749767,
0.0277492218,
-0.0658637509,
-0.0559278056,
0.0080384417,
-6.573360002e-33,
-0.0132915862,
-0.0497935265,
0.0107465144,
0.026298441,
-0.0249661971,
0.0389432013,
0.0035557372,
-0.0303334091,
-0.0400279835,
0.0328639001,
0.0098216599,
0.0013451041,
-0.0001805372,
-0.0277930107,
-0.055376038,
-0.0144398622,
0.004870601,
-0.0374288261,
-0.0716307461,
0.0342872366,
0.0124514513,
-0.0380425565,
0.0235505737,
-0.0990830138,
0.0437764302,
-0.0152959935,
-0.0658044145,
-0.0187588427,
-0.0231838934,
0.0443344787,
0.0099370759,
0.0045824246,
0.0256845411,
-0.0122042475,
0.0214741062,
0.0633950979,
-0.0226814281,
-0.0306449831,
0.0206201095,
-0.005920093,
0.0136329709,
-0.0099411542,
-0.0143858148,
-0.0063546984,
-0.0350327343,
0.0466147698,
0.040261019,
-0.024892319,
0.0446020178,
0.0078890417,
-0.0286374856,
0.0012466441,
-0.0159542672,
-0.0316483155,
-0.0309728738,
0.0434691273,
0.0223088786,
0.026605539,
-0.1008691639,
0.0518167354,
-0.0236126091,
-0.0174685996,
0.0301868189,
-0.039786946,
0.0053369328,
0.041059643,
0.058451239,
-0.0039455984,
-0.0698234141,
-0.007049968,
0.015806552,
0.0284161158,
0.1039424688,
0.0676475018,
0.0058453297,
-0.0558261201,
-0.0895127952,
0.040725939,
0.0631038919,
0.0057034399,
-0.0076229232,
-0.0579673387,
-0.0580468439,
-0.0025861159,
0.0029478169,
-0.0684403554,
-0.0221273098,
-0.0275770631,
-0.0243051481,
-0.0063281641,
0.0039606038,
0.0535216331,
-0.0072639342,
-0.0324136503,
0.0274346117,
0.0284842514,
0.0161939021,
0.048444476,
-0.0020235078,
0.0321055688,
-0.0332189873,
-0.0011681374,
0.0025030051,
0.0418693796,
0.0322252363,
-0.0186965652,
0.0369827114,
0.0290973652,
-0.0128095774,
-0.0010777705,
0.0045044422,
0.0597863086,
0.0210441127,
-0.0122623425,
0.010671692,
-0.001018933,
0.0117800282,
-0.0414384678,
0.0188441854,
0.0333707109,
-0.0258581433,
-0.0069862627,
-0.0426384509,
0.0245705433,
-0.027961053,
-0.0281380042,
-0.050096944,
0.011692225,
-0.0157343149,
-0.0828241929,
-0.0233226046,
-0.0505890101,
2.808e-7,
-0.0183766969,
0.0778202116,
-0.0198104922,
-0.0080439607,
0.0120963631,
0.0453070216,
-0.0068649449,
0.0252653044,
-0.0360884815,
-0.0420711301,
0.0239098351,
0.0188424625,
0.014401041,
0.0446666405,
-0.0308278222,
0.0024300904,
-0.0218314435,
-0.0096054403,
-0.0730102658,
0.0315527953,
-0.028661374,
0.0358938761,
0.0852932408,
-0.0273429807,
-0.0380972214,
-0.0090422519,
0.0041090143,
0.0496160313,
-0.0249489453,
0.0033537985,
0.0184447318,
0.0260222964,
-0.0040152776,
0.0435881764,
-0.0122446967,
-0.0033178811,
-0.043405693,
0.0112788584,
-0.0217238925,
-0.0197773539,
-0.0222848188,
-0.0563079901,
0.0026331742,
-0.0625252426,
0.0654185265,
-0.0164173394,
-0.0540495999,
-0.0575424023,
-0.059238743,
-0.02171975,
0.0422990471,
-0.0137904324,
-0.0209087897,
0.0095722331,
-0.0171984453,
-0.0002592893,
0.0116914203,
0.0047804718,
0.017882321,
0.0078945486,
-0.0406819433,
-0.0400126763,
0.0113893915,
0.0001513293,
0.0234776661,
0.0072950479,
0.0425678976,
2.366921012e-34,
0.0330970436,
-0.0291498955,
-0.0257687867,
-0.0221909508,
0.0275877286,
0.0094429804,
-0.043947909,
-0.0191448424,
0.0252785273,
-0.0116034141,
0.0082839942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11085v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11085v3 | Document-Level In-Context Few-Shot Relation Extraction via Pre-Trained Language Models | 2023-10-17T09:10:27 | 2024-05-23T08:33:51 | Yilmazcan Ozyurt, Stefan Feuerriegel, Ce Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Document-level relation extraction aims at inferring structured human
knowledge from textual documents. State-of-the-art methods for this task use
pre-trained language models (LMs) via fine-tuning, yet fine-tuning is
computationally expensive and cannot adapt to new relation types or new LMs. As
a remedy, we leverage the generalization capabilities of pre-trained LMs and
present a novel framework for document-level in-context few-shot relation
extraction. Our framework has three strengths: it eliminates the need (1) for
named entity recognition and (2) for human annotations of documents, and (3) it
can be updated to new LMs without re-training. We evaluate our framework using
DocRED, the largest publicly available dataset for document-level relation
extraction, and demonstrate that our framework achieves state-of-the-art
performance. We further show that our framework actually performs much better
than the original labels from the development set of DocRED. Finally, we
demonstrate that our complete framework yields consistent performance gains
across diverse datasets and across different pre-trained LMs. To the best of
our knowledge, we are the first to reformulate the document-level relation
extraction task as a tailored in-context few-shot learning paradigm. | [
0.0280712098,
0.0662998632,
0.0322075933,
0.0709753707,
0.0095516331,
0.0417174846,
0.025899725,
0.0150140142,
0.0085190944,
-0.0587941147,
-0.0462694764,
-0.0101351943,
-0.0327085368,
-0.0309500191,
-0.0005288649,
-0.0541301407,
0.0110924933,
0.0047440021,
0.0604376309,
0.0360088162,
0.0014383369,
0.0265466236,
-0.0083732288,
-0.0147897126,
-0.023474209,
-0.0282046646,
0.0184479821,
0.0044710906,
0.0601675846,
-0.0443775207,
0.0239925478,
0.0446101613,
0.0330538116,
-0.0282292329,
0.0000018524,
-0.045071736,
-0.0055623059,
0.0027855653,
-0.0302376319,
-0.0024546222,
0.0085339928,
-0.0505479611,
0.0172754359,
-0.0366840698,
-0.0385337509,
-0.0880485103,
-0.0216928814,
0.0440699123,
0.0148819406,
0.0671686009,
-0.0468236245,
-0.0609726161,
0.0291968323,
-0.0445459373,
0.0461431965,
-0.0557469577,
0.0287741777,
-0.0082905572,
0.0071233567,
0.0093703093,
0.0063904128,
0.005647385,
-0.0087942639,
0.0013110699,
0.0368968099,
0.0491609797,
-0.048242189,
-0.0033785929,
0.0056346883,
0.1270627826,
-0.0022861692,
0.0221629869,
0.0325546339,
-0.0197231788,
-0.029912537,
0.0046762633,
-0.0257164724,
-0.004238483,
-0.0093502803,
0.0089355735,
-0.0068447068,
0.018289268,
0.0342235938,
0.0098422552,
0.0042277668,
-0.0023041414,
-0.0016046074,
-0.0182146821,
0.0232676938,
0.0179016273,
-0.0053411666,
-0.0627194494,
-0.0282874871,
0.0476292446,
0.0407989994,
0.02039041,
-0.0435801484,
-0.015870139,
-0.0196537562,
-0.0430158228,
0.0195153803,
-0.0217282195,
-0.0173547436,
0.1000545323,
-0.0449232049,
0.015534916,
-0.0146480724,
-0.0192570481,
0.0008412713,
0.0027578583,
-0.0189140644,
0.0355262272,
-0.0244491026,
0.0437152795,
-0.0183649566,
-0.0111522293,
-0.0148540726,
0.0107513815,
0.0116695603,
0.04135672,
-0.0240185298,
-0.0136628589,
-0.0056359731,
-0.0446344838,
0.0215638205,
0.0128524555,
-0.034637481,
0.0034307875,
-0.0230872035,
-0.0019149983,
-0.0215153042,
-0.0169862434,
0.0522633009,
-0.0331880376,
0.0303436965,
0.0682796612,
0.0174215492,
-0.0899496526,
0.0018182878,
-0.0333737805,
0.022361923,
-0.0682407618,
0.0090001877,
-0.0090397038,
0.0745022595,
0.0329905301,
-0.033672791,
-0.0211294126,
0.0262216665,
0.0104180928,
-0.0852882937,
0.0684125796,
-0.0251385085,
0.0006706401,
-0.00578911,
0.0163798295,
0.0420243628,
0.0721915886,
0.0390293896,
0.0024922928,
0.043704614,
0.017940551,
0.0109339431,
0.0423486456,
0.0061047138,
-0.0215411428,
-0.0023280839,
0.0218052249,
0.0159375444,
-0.0084138624,
0.0307264552,
0.0105669871,
-0.0424168408,
-0.0084645171,
0.0296937004,
0.0385814272,
0.0032185602,
-0.0042290539,
0.0361789167,
-0.0039219246,
0.035972286,
-0.0116954176,
-0.0741996914,
0.018462589,
-0.015324804,
-0.002984127,
-0.0344285853,
0.0067284764,
-0.0279134605,
0.0294187292,
0.000026077,
-0.0169641022,
-0.0437980033,
0.0071214698,
0.0866022259,
0.0304415673,
-0.0441766307,
0.0448541604,
0.0504475236,
-0.0259421244,
-0.0101195006,
0.0323008411,
-0.0035250469,
0.0384328403,
0.0459909029,
-0.049959451,
-0.0612580925,
-0.025635045,
0.048162818,
0.0224810857,
0.0313955471,
-0.029369399,
0.071038425,
-0.0234428681,
-0.0381296724,
-0.000113833,
0.0091881035,
-0.0155529156,
0.0348937288,
0.0166463107,
0.021001162,
-0.0295270048,
0.0236649532,
0.0477561429,
-0.0426251255,
-0.0704685077,
0.0289296992,
0.0220637657,
-0.0066860286,
0.0214908086,
-0.0337596722,
-0.0353082791,
0.0477949977,
-0.0206591822,
0.0373514518,
0.0195577648,
-0.0387528427,
-0.0693862066,
-0.0017236673,
0.0159635041,
-0.0456107371,
-0.0607255027,
-0.0673909411,
-0.0093744891,
-0.0189673305,
0.075862512,
0.0505592562,
-0.0045380774,
-0.0124241496,
0.0491037443,
-0.0002073869,
-0.024285838,
0.0729228929,
0.0072475993,
-0.0162199978,
0.0234692842,
-0.0298234057,
-0.0062104315,
0.0130564049,
-0.0121723246,
-0.0091721946,
-0.0097753424,
-0.0416962132,
0.0115224468,
0.0300827343,
-0.0403413177,
0.0181873068,
-0.0651874766,
0.013730485,
0.0254462473,
0.0366454571,
0.0010560022,
0.0171019882,
-0.0150797283,
-0.0476524085,
-0.0002619764,
0.0307281129,
-0.0215839092,
-0.0155145293,
0.0576924644,
0.021178104,
0.0115590496,
-0.0421664268,
-0.0035361915,
-0.0219287779,
0.0484449491,
0.0064282906,
0.0064426973,
0.0059722057,
0.0586126335,
-0.005816821,
0.0542478412,
-0.0108433561,
0.0141707165,
-0.0206446182,
-0.0228015222,
0.0034366851,
0.051989425,
-0.0180469695,
0.0544427894,
-0.0278018862,
-0.0159944985,
-0.0125047239,
0.0316551104,
-0.0148624768,
0.0141284447,
-0.0003607842,
0.0127729746,
-0.0248515382,
0.0657857731,
-0.0226188973,
0.0396793447,
-0.0190684609,
0.0171321314,
0.0381262898,
0.0099059548,
-0.0379154682,
0.0231114347,
0.036791414,
-0.0046543935,
-0.0524586588,
0.0201037563,
0.0474275462,
-0.0329023004,
-0.0255755316,
0.0241000596,
0.0129753835,
-0.0296784956,
0.0647873282,
0.013250594,
-0.0035814401,
-0.0038543546,
0.004915555,
-0.0308337975,
-0.0231222529,
0.0248276219,
0.0114205265,
0.0067791929,
-0.0501888879,
0.0249267686,
-0.0328750871,
-0.030048022,
-0.0455163233,
-0.0532578528,
-0.0488222018,
-0.0074738255,
-0.0488100946,
0.0101597793,
0.0261403397,
0.0003105525,
0.0049680294,
0.0576171316,
-0.0112439645,
-0.0265811961,
-0.0119300205,
0.0840286463,
0.0657486469,
-0.0598308444,
-0.0199018102,
-0.0030045572,
0.0511247106,
0.0505728126,
0.001962767,
-0.0044005387,
0.0020375587,
0.0123019274,
-0.0075954441,
-0.016710408,
0.0209333543,
-0.0181699842,
0.0509245992,
-0.0780273974,
-0.0292717963,
0.1163010895,
0.0106673064,
-0.0318537541,
-0.0148634519,
0.0376947001,
-0.026821157,
0.0277170036,
0.0339472219,
-0.0896537378,
-0.0545453466,
-0.024031993,
-0.0294057708,
0.0373523422,
-0.0700196698,
-0.0191748664,
-0.0944002643,
-0.0050722775,
-0.0140068755,
-0.0369394496,
0.0258401949,
-0.045817364,
0.0063984729,
-0.0105134053,
-0.0230742395,
0.000926633,
-0.0343368538,
0.0021853342,
-0.0387873203,
0.0067332676,
-0.0542991348,
0.0497225784,
-0.0383812003,
0.026476616,
0.042362418,
0.0199581534,
-0.0011049408,
0.0358445868,
0.0333328024,
-0.0113891112,
-0.0120250788,
-0.0190111119,
0.0653885826,
-0.0796265155,
-0.0278830696,
-0.0249858852,
0.0280569419,
-0.0605449863,
-0.0288612545,
-0.0017444565,
0.0418170579,
0.0079785688,
-0.027803801,
-0.0153442034,
-0.0130443508,
0.0077205133,
0.0666592643,
-0.0017994293,
-0.0204334557,
-0.0308887605,
0.0109023722,
0.0214799158,
-0.0410110764,
0.0109033259,
-0.027559625,
-0.0484727062,
0.0066375788,
-0.0542050749,
-0.0608502813,
0.0682847872,
0.0003346349,
-0.0157328192,
-0.0308623612,
0.0261514951,
0.0045061195,
-0.0619232655,
0.0177945271,
-0.0083496096,
-0.0214352682,
-0.0151911834,
-0.001565947,
0.0369580798,
-0.0099923294,
-0.0228430144,
-0.0185487438,
-0.0788953677,
-0.0160233732,
-0.0266868137,
0.0554678887,
0.0032718377,
0.0644742101,
-0.0024914914,
-0.0131772505,
0.0441831872,
0.0706696138,
-0.0606432594,
-0.0093444576,
0.0276110005,
-0.0226312988,
-0.0037017916,
0.0401693955,
-0.051601693,
0.0593164116,
0.0589914173,
-0.000717858,
-0.0530753955,
-0.0245570783,
-0.0151915979,
-0.0269895419,
0.10202232,
0.0021351762,
-0.0128389429,
-0.0219788123,
0.0180044491,
-0.0726410374,
-0.0126365628,
-0.0391481742,
-0.0015016369,
-0.0034313216,
0.0009014829,
-0.0317917578,
0.0035016437,
-0.0115886098,
0.0555102862,
0.0018240851,
-0.0081164101,
0.0242368393,
0.0023011877,
0.0235652886,
-0.0186204035,
-0.0072670807,
0.05590415,
-0.0203448925,
0.0131871346,
-0.04876706,
0.0434954092,
-0.0030443126,
-0.0290502571,
0.006411599,
0.002451055,
-0.0160267428,
0.0218076892,
-0.0517421886,
0.0400669873,
0.0524147935,
-0.0611106679,
0.019412823,
-0.0074797468,
-0.0080818851,
0.0122377938,
0.0238705985,
-0.0414851792,
0.003878687,
-0.0035379338,
0.0321968943,
-0.0224205013,
0.0443893224,
0.0796385258,
0.0164677072,
0.0472287573,
0.0458916835,
0.0183820408,
-0.0511372462,
0.0196810067,
0.0192681942,
0.0403444916,
-0.0001836586,
0.0382638611,
-0.0530945361,
-0.04486477,
-0.0046029147,
-0.0477006882,
-0.0423900299,
0.0463596992,
-0.0035271465,
0.0149719939,
0.022831684,
-0.0306472816,
-0.0289589241,
0.032428991,
-0.0303438585,
-0.0281696264,
0.0036337376,
-6.269532916e-33,
-0.057185702,
-0.0201705042,
0.0146998018,
-0.000515333,
0.0050580068,
0.0163363628,
-0.0321413875,
-0.0219330769,
-0.0074823448,
0.0318676084,
-0.030311767,
-0.0058546024,
-0.0053045289,
0.0207411796,
-0.0065432196,
-0.003053108,
0.0176859144,
-0.0087646525,
0.0205236636,
0.0128623387,
0.0221311003,
0.0638949499,
0.1019914746,
-0.0554386228,
-0.0045757922,
-0.02626119,
-0.0040775356,
0.0187514983,
0.0621931255,
0.0044780867,
-0.0385003276,
-0.0241381768,
0.0304717813,
-0.0169727132,
0.0140319746,
0.0177170616,
-0.1610363722,
-0.0223018862,
-0.0424940102,
-0.0057912907,
-0.0172524657,
-0.011369111,
0.0138341812,
-0.019670194,
0.0524425693,
-0.0602334887,
0.0230515338,
-0.0354814716,
0.0044708708,
-0.0756785572,
-0.0625895932,
0.0245367475,
0.0131857395,
-0.0088668941,
0.0301934127,
0.0139914611,
0.0099735931,
0.0262380913,
-0.0706472471,
-0.0408122353,
-0.0103410957,
-0.0060678422,
0.019587731,
-0.0041399896,
0.0078880526,
0.0348072685,
0.0021991383,
-0.0139404768,
-0.0184685029,
0.0187821817,
0.0114104738,
0.0699842274,
-0.0307252351,
0.0609637126,
0.0547417067,
0.0190340001,
-0.1108277962,
0.0152685167,
0.0155779365,
0.0585713126,
-0.0475792065,
-0.0027164749,
-0.030676309,
0.0038864184,
0.0176186729,
-0.0353823267,
-0.0097914403,
-0.0327399708,
0.0026794341,
0.0195423476,
-0.0245709494,
0.0278955325,
0.0275360737,
-0.0421377085,
-0.0269929338,
0.028365735,
-0.0164357647,
-0.0045497916,
0.0083688684,
0.0132953413,
-0.0870664492,
-0.035314884,
0.0063419254,
0.0103407996,
0.023121329,
0.032095179,
0.083010383,
-0.0297423787,
-0.0611031651,
-0.0356536768,
-0.0149965007,
0.0130494554,
0.0209628474,
0.041517891,
-0.0077831186,
0.0384767018,
-0.0185969304,
0.0790845305,
0.0228827484,
-0.017955102,
-0.0086222999,
0.0285083707,
0.0150821321,
0.0188456383,
0.0308726262,
-0.0140057588,
0.0038888734,
-0.0075956979,
0.0313769802,
-0.0417054482,
-0.0006698161,
-0.0048545324,
2.5e-7,
0.0442789495,
0.0266536996,
0.0335654318,
0.0171303954,
0.019809477,
0.0388917327,
0.0119581427,
0.0510180369,
-0.0079446668,
-0.0184372924,
0.0377032273,
0.0160517953,
-0.0024958886,
0.0271309428,
-0.0638774782,
-0.007491366,
-0.0681822598,
-0.0601796322,
-0.0440321788,
-0.0502965413,
0.030947106,
0.0568011738,
0.0334731229,
0.0064504058,
-0.0449158661,
-0.0468289964,
0.0873945877,
-0.038919393,
-0.0065030949,
0.0281998552,
-0.0067690685,
0.0325888209,
-0.0605805479,
0.0356647149,
-0.0288463943,
0.0339195095,
0.0039114356,
0.0852637142,
-0.0314190947,
-0.0039357468,
-0.0096099498,
-0.0155439889,
0.0150496522,
-0.01944061,
0.1088902801,
-0.0864460915,
-0.0015381534,
-0.0264189504,
-0.0341704264,
-0.0049575795,
-0.0215507876,
0.0236183796,
-0.008903699,
0.0356469303,
0.042417001,
-0.024730172,
-0.0434103645,
-0.0861524045,
0.0140566649,
0.080904983,
0.0207236856,
0.0202258974,
0.004640263,
-0.040634606,
-0.0048414445,
-0.0111334128,
0.0070431726,
1.939861619e-34,
-0.0252484735,
0.0243150964,
-0.0184306689,
0.036682941,
0.0115473354,
-0.0303347353,
-0.08170975,
-0.0053037005,
0.0131233595,
-0.0764245912,
0.0461495556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11081v1 | Understanding writing style in social media with a supervised contrastively pre-trained transformer | 2023-10-17T09:01:17 | 2023-10-17T09:01:17 | Javier Huertas-Tato, Alejandro Martin, David Camacho | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Online Social Networks serve as fertile ground for harmful behavior, ranging
from hate speech to the dissemination of disinformation. Malicious actors now
have unprecedented freedom to misbehave, leading to severe societal unrest and
dire consequences, as exemplified by events such as the Capitol assault during
the US presidential election and the Antivaxx movement during the COVID-19
pandemic. Understanding online language has become more pressing than ever.
While existing works predominantly focus on content analysis, we aim to shift
the focus towards understanding harmful behaviors by relating content to their
respective authors. Numerous novel approaches attempt to learn the stylistic
features of authors in texts, but many of these approaches are constrained by
small datasets or sub-optimal training losses. To overcome these limitations,
we introduce the Style Transformer for Authorship Representations (STAR),
trained on a large corpus derived from public sources of 4.5 x 10^6 authored
texts involving 70k heterogeneous authors. Our model leverages Supervised
Contrastive Loss to teach the model to minimize the distance between texts
authored by the same individual. This author pretext pre-training task yields
competitive performance at zero-shot with PAN challenges on attribution and
clustering. Additionally, we attain promising results on PAN verification
challenges using a single dense layer, with our model serving as an embedding
encoder. Finally, we present results from our test partition on Reddit. Using a
support base of 8 documents of 512 tokens, we can discern authors from sets of
up to 1616 authors with at least 80\% accuracy. We share our pre-trained model
at huggingface (https://huggingface.co/AIDA-UPM/star) and our code is available
at (https://github.com/jahuerta92/star) | [
0.0343554169,
0.0703112036,
-0.0127027901,
0.0333147533,
-0.0100578489,
0.0184222292,
0.0423791409,
0.0092019429,
-0.0079656756,
-0.0232718047,
-0.0376885831,
-0.0392908528,
0.0095207766,
0.016934542,
0.0461215526,
-0.0326620266,
-0.0105874874,
0.0288613867,
0.0609201677,
-0.0127557665,
0.0809422433,
0.0281898845,
0.0117743304,
0.025508333,
-0.0337671824,
-0.037328247,
0.0404986627,
0.0186604392,
0.0572955571,
0.0040804544,
0.0689849705,
0.0685973763,
0.017880993,
0.0732952356,
0.0000018795,
-0.011387011,
0.0000305386,
-0.0301765408,
0.0236742459,
-0.0223353356,
0.0642204359,
-0.0220517851,
0.0057855975,
0.0285309274,
-0.0240286607,
-0.0408145338,
0.0482998006,
0.082577683,
0.0646969974,
0.1063369215,
-0.031192353,
-0.0615672432,
0.0510039777,
0.0030709417,
-0.004949348,
0.0291900877,
0.0319439843,
-0.0733061135,
-0.0377704725,
0.0317667313,
-0.0022870179,
0.0236507151,
0.0329507589,
-0.0123008201,
0.0262132324,
-0.0075410474,
-0.0199913196,
0.0104220444,
0.0168363508,
0.067267023,
-0.0034121862,
-0.0452444926,
0.0212672465,
0.0081835743,
-0.0125727681,
0.0165871698,
-0.0198969785,
0.0258602388,
-0.0241126753,
0.0031684272,
-0.0084389038,
0.0471594483,
0.0368684344,
0.0409302376,
0.0207174812,
-0.048744075,
-0.0078950031,
-0.0401785448,
-0.0273226518,
-0.0029883364,
-0.0099714557,
-0.0190215278,
0.0519393645,
0.0064712395,
-0.0104269441,
-0.0064004716,
-0.0444676317,
-0.0719519183,
0.0133460723,
-0.0624279156,
0.0422419459,
-0.0352011807,
0.003052956,
0.0202888567,
0.0094030779,
0.0216569789,
-0.0140106659,
0.0372738205,
0.0137624638,
-0.0141601004,
-0.0408849381,
-0.0199921373,
-0.0169776659,
-0.0160024632,
0.0630222857,
0.0025298949,
-0.0322607122,
-0.0321154408,
-0.0459609702,
-0.004491312,
-0.0128887612,
0.0104441578,
-0.0276608355,
-0.0209586564,
0.0289882701,
0.0258863457,
-0.0195231903,
0.0200112257,
-0.0016849015,
0.0173761733,
-0.0234604906,
0.0499481149,
0.0396849774,
-0.0257399883,
0.027550295,
0.0049601384,
-0.0072797039,
-0.0403457955,
-0.0060237832,
-0.0367023237,
-0.033342015,
-0.0302711669,
-0.0096036,
-0.0731763169,
0.0159659032,
0.0056309458,
-0.0427595489,
-0.0667472035,
-0.0295606069,
0.0267514717,
-0.0291977767,
0.0486012995,
0.0215816405,
-0.0273050349,
0.0492679328,
0.0505177714,
0.0159218553,
0.003907145,
0.0215567276,
0.0652679652,
0.0218164828,
-0.0207522474,
0.0427801497,
0.0290131364,
0.0485424288,
0.0067392853,
0.0141661707,
0.0011457436,
0.0058579035,
0.0077529224,
0.0196212493,
0.0407545455,
-0.0284139048,
-0.0482248366,
0.0750388429,
0.0408232734,
0.0055874451,
0.0159068834,
0.03523691,
0.0451782569,
-0.004669081,
-0.0352568217,
-0.0201462097,
0.0090173343,
-0.0307298489,
-0.0567294955,
0.007418476,
0.037816748,
-0.0508718975,
0.008335202,
0.0265048388,
-0.0088545391,
0.001152133,
-0.0307029933,
0.0119798752,
0.0348810926,
-0.0403418094,
-0.0068856371,
0.0215011369,
-0.0548762456,
0.0065219291,
-0.0188065395,
0.0165691096,
0.05108466,
0.0240551531,
-0.0147012658,
0.000181067,
-0.0627968609,
0.0462096892,
0.0270838384,
-0.0216325466,
-0.0159647446,
0.0212947745,
-0.0405650623,
-0.0247538816,
-0.0019738635,
-0.0206261836,
-0.0066174935,
0.0429641828,
0.016980581,
0.0250213649,
-0.0063163289,
-0.0133469403,
0.0200342666,
-0.0083546955,
-0.0427190214,
0.0040591499,
0.0552482344,
0.0104400637,
0.0182948895,
-0.0226113666,
-0.0375543833,
0.0022305869,
-0.0485940911,
-0.045480594,
-0.0168246273,
-0.0322602242,
-0.0285727922,
0.0269901957,
-0.0669254437,
-0.033982113,
0.0579009317,
-0.0375288501,
-0.0277695842,
0.0659465864,
-0.0188024286,
0.0096713966,
-0.0142777832,
-0.0266898721,
-0.0304881912,
0.0213423502,
0.0062040016,
0.0675853193,
-0.011689459,
0.014396172,
-0.0446107648,
-0.0102913678,
0.0257244091,
0.0228979718,
-0.0228940193,
-0.0831325352,
-0.0411307998,
0.0476086475,
0.0398168042,
0.0004729863,
-0.030961426,
-0.0401822999,
-0.0605367459,
-0.007189929,
-0.0396207236,
0.0063357865,
0.0205327645,
0.0022136439,
0.0222801287,
-0.0074337446,
-0.0545196086,
-0.0341618732,
-0.0203443281,
0.0047932607,
0.0389139131,
-0.0310571212,
-0.0282493271,
-0.0257429741,
-0.0227182992,
-0.0136217577,
0.0526256673,
0.0262313895,
0.007667921,
0.0225238204,
0.0046589705,
-0.011030335,
-0.0219474509,
-0.0054151607,
-0.0288604274,
0.0208486654,
-0.0150005845,
-0.0042308127,
0.0481865481,
0.0610825606,
0.0703995302,
-0.0357708633,
0.0290572215,
-0.0214543529,
-0.0314911641,
-0.0424412824,
0.0365163758,
-0.018957993,
-0.0283015072,
0.0020379364,
0.0559578054,
0.0193891954,
-0.0004166201,
-0.0513818562,
0.0022203575,
0.0299169049,
-0.029331943,
0.024252886,
-0.0242122579,
0.0184431002,
-0.0462503918,
-0.0545401163,
-0.0364925787,
0.0526281632,
-0.0355979949,
0.0265594739,
0.0369766019,
-0.0355263427,
-0.0051191221,
0.0466436297,
0.0305084214,
0.0291495249,
-0.011181972,
-0.0505979136,
-0.0128463283,
0.0061800312,
0.0465379246,
0.0157851707,
-0.0128859077,
0.0338351056,
0.0265273638,
0.0013685985,
-0.0443035476,
-0.0278301761,
-0.1085858047,
-0.0055766026,
-0.0299008097,
-0.0041028927,
-0.0382412784,
-0.0333542861,
-0.0472748466,
0.0376478992,
0.0228547063,
-0.0231489278,
-0.0387022048,
-0.0045295665,
0.0340678543,
0.0078227669,
-0.046639394,
0.0037274326,
-0.0464775339,
-0.0167878866,
0.0604850724,
-0.0259807706,
-0.0110786846,
-0.0315978676,
-0.0147046968,
0.0097252494,
-0.0209737103,
-0.0139779355,
-0.0094415424,
0.0767592266,
-0.0265509784,
-0.0113413185,
0.1117283255,
0.0138883162,
-0.0427225195,
-0.0158523228,
0.0421289541,
0.0227333587,
-0.006884844,
0.0137160262,
-0.0984969065,
-0.0295235626,
-0.0428131931,
0.0184682757,
-0.0192322191,
-0.0333955586,
0.0092175342,
-0.0528591797,
0.0165844914,
0.0025258523,
-0.0434897989,
-0.0031191513,
-0.0466964655,
-0.0356714651,
-0.0171010308,
0.0029240628,
-0.028015716,
0.0038600334,
-0.0074430113,
0.0043921992,
-0.0231939405,
-0.0218849499,
0.0163305588,
-0.0568217598,
0.0327077247,
0.0078049065,
0.0543089136,
-0.015057154,
-0.0347556695,
-0.0438758023,
0.0060814591,
-0.0252981167,
-0.0251318812,
0.1015330851,
-0.0210986249,
0.009689956,
-0.065337427,
0.05409161,
-0.0534549318,
-0.0290710144,
-0.0031545095,
0.0513866022,
0.0040288777,
-0.0354634039,
-0.0131184049,
0.0094195008,
0.0391503163,
0.0465645008,
0.0300303455,
-0.0319263637,
-0.0402840525,
-0.0572770201,
0.0304374322,
-0.0579228885,
-0.0555380024,
-0.0333902314,
0.0002124616,
-0.032602407,
-0.0273027029,
-0.0195248332,
-0.0052645672,
0.0216244441,
-0.0128433863,
-0.0353693776,
-0.0115521941,
-0.0443717539,
-0.0625847355,
0.0079588005,
-0.0362346657,
0.0519987643,
-0.0372757614,
-0.0099586286,
-0.0036485712,
-0.0261897799,
0.0058012325,
0.0252656136,
-0.090305306,
-0.0510062836,
0.0109233577,
0.0258593541,
0.0025950761,
0.057191398,
-0.0255484376,
-0.0838647112,
0.1050207764,
0.0489732996,
-0.0230239537,
-0.0090342704,
0.0455049239,
-0.0563882515,
0.0031420472,
0.0288517214,
-0.0015964289,
0.0348345377,
0.0502972007,
-0.0539409369,
-0.0578794517,
0.0250908714,
-0.0308167823,
-0.0114533473,
0.0647746921,
-0.0049903193,
-0.008069464,
-0.0461394414,
-0.0365961045,
-0.009986585,
-0.0182988457,
0.0044686054,
-0.0063511641,
0.0226398259,
-0.0030548358,
-0.0351758264,
0.0550599433,
0.0029096471,
0.044034481,
-0.0636737943,
0.0216141455,
0.0369839184,
0.0721359551,
0.0228471346,
0.0267662313,
0.0123157995,
0.0449575596,
0.0247494187,
0.0118523808,
-0.0051217452,
-0.0062037795,
0.0146284411,
0.0549429059,
0.0082623921,
0.0187278781,
-0.0758968741,
-0.0051998021,
-0.0304026157,
-0.0487283096,
0.0011799034,
-0.0327376835,
0.0512492396,
0.0105611971,
0.0075745042,
0.0000696108,
0.0653822124,
-0.0332033634,
-0.0443210341,
-0.030101819,
0.0166465808,
-0.0238363687,
0.0225645714,
0.0820330307,
-0.0144804753,
0.0111616403,
0.0386227444,
-0.0389453359,
-0.0068371193,
-0.0215967651,
0.0458737761,
0.0446680225,
0.014213522,
0.0042445706,
-0.0082276231,
-0.0544167832,
0.0464324169,
-0.0574424528,
0.002935769,
0.0307734832,
-0.0031967864,
0.0379365869,
0.0095317652,
0.0228857882,
-0.0322549939,
0.0226743408,
0.0244035944,
-0.0609008819,
0.0252440721,
-6.138535825e-33,
0.0266676992,
-0.0360984802,
-0.016341364,
0.022613598,
-0.0054853591,
0.0174615178,
-0.0176517628,
-0.0204155091,
-0.0167585369,
0.0416954532,
-0.0048408718,
0.0381904952,
-0.0205156449,
0.0586456172,
-0.0138231935,
0.0075173737,
0.0470865555,
0.0108193997,
-0.0153811146,
0.0523132011,
0.0830995515,
0.0013738105,
0.0466034338,
-0.0832451731,
0.0118563781,
-0.0480482206,
-0.0430019125,
0.0031890452,
0.0254821274,
0.0219945293,
-0.0086069666,
0.0574635938,
0.0125421192,
-0.0179681852,
-0.0146346577,
0.0462966897,
-0.0681974217,
-0.0376640297,
-0.0380919762,
0.0126033081,
0.0031707042,
-0.0437839292,
0.0628705621,
-0.0142174838,
0.0161816683,
-0.0402081348,
0.0605090745,
0.0495250672,
0.0290485639,
-0.0564107224,
-0.0651398972,
0.0258933455,
-0.0381065495,
-0.0085453829,
-0.0182480421,
0.0194555447,
0.0301643126,
0.0306505337,
-0.1203982532,
0.0275636334,
-0.0293616466,
-0.0085363742,
-0.0100405021,
0.0395839475,
-0.0222293213,
0.0543846451,
-0.0131066646,
0.0327861272,
-0.0304417983,
0.0255638789,
0.0325009041,
0.0223344825,
0.0325048827,
0.1029912233,
0.0239466093,
-0.0538248718,
-0.0685555339,
0.0295938309,
0.0183572751,
-0.0383063145,
0.0107678352,
-0.0024404088,
-0.03345019,
-0.0437621064,
-0.0011821133,
-0.0544965416,
-0.0190171152,
-0.0000510163,
-0.0233496986,
0.0018186554,
-0.0134834442,
0.007153837,
0.0197132397,
-0.0519693792,
-0.018402297,
0.0331778862,
-0.0285531301,
0.0447607525,
0.013424091,
0.0184197295,
-0.0443592295,
-0.0037913914,
0.0354996063,
-0.0027907745,
0.021522237,
0.0100687025,
0.1416432261,
0.0408283435,
-0.0619105175,
-0.0114745125,
0.0196515191,
0.0232372545,
-0.0022922345,
0.031686984,
-0.011599456,
0.0479977243,
-0.003351582,
0.0349108726,
0.038745869,
0.0314356126,
0.0057843188,
-0.0144666154,
-0.024086345,
-0.0113186678,
-0.0233226772,
-0.0250200555,
-0.0480909757,
-0.0160486102,
0.0116167292,
-0.0974498093,
0.002298289,
-0.0537466109,
2.613e-7,
0.0529837795,
0.0210203305,
0.0168637242,
0.0018763088,
0.0105853621,
0.0607495978,
0.0756270438,
0.0512015745,
-0.04609292,
-0.0214817449,
0.0287708379,
0.0649961159,
0.0475582406,
0.0380312353,
-0.0450077988,
0.0162010826,
-0.0881137028,
0.0315187946,
-0.058565408,
0.0205970593,
0.0362109765,
0.0727618635,
0.0471569523,
-0.0563362502,
0.0130131803,
-0.02391758,
0.0801403001,
0.0128016453,
0.0134852696,
0.008529827,
0.0130255399,
-0.0270611197,
0.0057764016,
-0.0127694774,
-0.0374503136,
0.0135661485,
-0.0168659128,
0.0447393209,
0.0043606875,
-0.0094697475,
0.0273369979,
-0.0180498678,
0.0161084048,
-0.0383530483,
0.060397923,
-0.0177718736,
-0.043240428,
-0.0311077647,
-0.0424961299,
-0.0173694137,
0.0286076032,
0.002320928,
0.0005836193,
0.0199462734,
0.0205445029,
-0.0098210238,
0.0008049732,
-0.0949588791,
-0.0027684341,
0.0078360522,
-0.0007522394,
0.0154531179,
-0.0054471879,
-0.0121406196,
0.0612230077,
0.0013054138,
0.0671512187,
2.55033234e-34,
0.0152801182,
-0.0032628018,
-0.0129608382,
-0.0456714705,
0.0243219715,
0.0058825212,
-0.0194668174,
-0.0120515851,
0.0350242294,
-0.06118403,
-0.000807966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11079v1 | Learning from Red Teaming: Gender Bias Provocation and Mitigation in Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T08:56:04 | 2023-10-17T08:56:04 | Hsuan Su, Cheng-Chu Cheng, Hua Farn, Shachi H Kumar, Saurav Sahay, Shang-Tse Chen, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, researchers have made considerable improvements in dialogue systems
with the progress of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4.
These LLM-based chatbots encode the potential biases while retaining
disparities that can harm humans during interactions. The traditional biases
investigation methods often rely on human-written test cases. However, these
test cases are usually expensive and limited. In this work, we propose a
first-of-its-kind method that automatically generates test cases to detect
LLMs' potential gender bias. We apply our method to three well-known LLMs and
find that the generated test cases effectively identify the presence of biases.
To address the biases identified, we propose a mitigation strategy that uses
the generated test cases as demonstrations for in-context learning to
circumvent the need for parameter fine-tuning. The experimental results show
that LLMs generate fairer responses with the proposed approach. | [
0.0514598116,
0.0638216957,
-0.0414031595,
0.0372111276,
-0.0228365976,
0.0050588446,
0.0377153791,
-0.0023727741,
0.0393581018,
-0.0734592304,
-0.0151185179,
-0.0075839884,
-0.0008833028,
0.00485323,
0.0078386702,
-0.0355292074,
0.0412836,
-0.0084520169,
0.0175668243,
-0.0477559492,
0.0224310383,
0.0317352228,
-0.0114719309,
0.0778940469,
-0.0194917154,
-0.0278353952,
-0.0027884156,
0.0293694921,
-0.0175252911,
-0.0048478148,
0.0552897416,
0.0631516054,
-0.01043218,
0.0461772867,
0.0000020945,
-0.0647953153,
-0.0045821499,
0.004341187,
-0.0070939967,
-0.0091809155,
0.0338346921,
0.0286545809,
-0.0295765009,
0.0650501326,
-0.0287878402,
-0.0131946178,
0.0303278435,
0.0170803666,
0.0710486844,
0.0457240492,
0.0055500101,
0.0528827794,
-0.044571653,
-0.0149733648,
-0.0032263184,
-0.0416736603,
0.0130036958,
-0.0107869999,
0.0021604013,
-0.0224580374,
-0.0190264061,
-0.0041057575,
0.0200979169,
-0.0234814361,
-0.0548954308,
0.0173158478,
-0.0719791055,
-0.0384955071,
-0.020501608,
0.0624236465,
-0.0104935486,
-0.0241799541,
-0.0085619492,
-0.0053449129,
0.0336053334,
-0.0064854678,
-0.0229396969,
0.0343813412,
-0.0351114683,
-0.0124419499,
-0.0249874964,
-0.0312504545,
0.0035149257,
0.0366132408,
-0.023694966,
0.0669567138,
0.0104014408,
-0.042947825,
-0.0091848951,
0.0198959317,
0.0208989866,
-0.0564174689,
-0.0200744662,
-0.0103780581,
-0.0361104272,
-0.0004377744,
-0.02398647,
-0.0125224506,
0.0511955768,
-0.0293815639,
-0.0359365344,
0.0541507937,
0.0109594613,
0.019724302,
-0.0267334897,
0.040534243,
0.0181525368,
0.0117770014,
-0.020964412,
-0.0382789075,
-0.0308843218,
-0.0111129079,
-0.0524213985,
-0.0143051539,
-0.0386838019,
0.0302641578,
-0.002037571,
0.0262614135,
-0.0457123071,
0.018739216,
0.0050964276,
0.0017237674,
-0.0411172509,
-0.0037878114,
0.0035396558,
-0.0080830501,
-0.0370546356,
0.008386761,
-0.0269336514,
-0.1352429241,
-0.0239309724,
0.0272794701,
-0.0345060341,
-0.0228443407,
-0.0150736906,
0.0620512404,
0.0146449869,
-0.0280387402,
0.0175572429,
-0.0324845165,
-0.0161579009,
-0.06552881,
0.007674762,
-0.0514877401,
-0.0008958709,
0.0306789428,
0.0052179713,
-0.0230734143,
0.0038204733,
0.0081834169,
-0.0261577219,
0.0576186292,
0.0523227416,
0.0060747084,
0.0569886193,
0.0180156268,
-0.0364406779,
0.1251874268,
0.0530796684,
-0.010240539,
0.025657298,
-0.0031051086,
0.0270113926,
0.0540176891,
0.0474341772,
0.0531953312,
-0.0239542648,
0.0138770537,
0.0037566321,
0.0384506062,
0.0488851182,
0.0184975769,
-0.0043441714,
-0.0289810263,
0.0607066527,
0.0558774509,
0.0109848604,
0.0379113927,
0.0255587064,
0.0043026414,
-0.0234440621,
0.031717591,
-0.0597850755,
-0.0145922247,
-0.0198557675,
-0.0427953713,
0.0107097831,
0.0305428635,
-0.0317533277,
-0.0104123559,
-0.0019825594,
0.0076727443,
0.0222235303,
0.0288912021,
0.0222975966,
0.0138457241,
-0.0372300856,
0.0466804728,
0.0328065939,
-0.0628770962,
-0.0159977302,
-0.0873602554,
0.0196803678,
0.0318710692,
0.0276217386,
-0.0487614498,
-0.0141954478,
-0.0373811536,
-0.0370254144,
0.0553766005,
0.0836335123,
0.0173034556,
0.0051760036,
-0.044795569,
-0.0232479218,
0.019398937,
0.0170958135,
0.0357918106,
0.0473610833,
0.0255883448,
-0.0027409035,
-0.0121695092,
-0.0285601299,
0.0198473502,
0.0200764481,
-0.0160411485,
0.0216023549,
-0.0001116609,
0.0419319011,
-0.0035895,
-0.0290048514,
-0.0182908103,
-0.0084535982,
-0.0034665263,
-0.0029260302,
0.0528845899,
-0.0290940199,
-0.0557714738,
0.0078604231,
-0.0372495912,
-0.0859175026,
0.0492936149,
-0.0198897291,
0.0123446304,
0.038768556,
-0.0123517867,
0.0256667919,
-0.0279266834,
0.0010127306,
-0.017986631,
0.0373729728,
-0.0360644348,
0.0061038989,
-0.0042506014,
-0.044071164,
0.0121712936,
-0.0115303015,
-0.0061485167,
-0.0822989419,
-0.0123119783,
0.0558330305,
0.0175690446,
0.0164770912,
0.0280754156,
-0.0004099367,
-0.0277306996,
-0.0376514643,
-0.090771012,
0.0018278708,
-0.0206325762,
-0.0177969597,
-0.0040404615,
0.0203463472,
-0.0350730196,
-0.0324596241,
-0.0216835272,
-0.0238387231,
0.051061213,
0.031150559,
0.0200983882,
-0.021213932,
-0.0155696832,
-0.0265828241,
0.0093589909,
-0.0479260013,
0.0517219231,
0.0445013978,
0.0110761989,
-0.0690145865,
0.0119104972,
0.0124763614,
0.0317777582,
0.0006666359,
-0.0589309521,
0.0189603809,
0.0081713889,
0.0145937996,
0.1150843725,
0.0469385646,
0.0388373174,
0.0413832478,
0.0008541106,
-0.0812660456,
0.0207837522,
0.025535671,
-0.0150938816,
0.0143777486,
-0.0451781861,
0.0031324551,
0.0134934736,
0.0056591402,
-0.0181717463,
-0.0625133291,
0.0577886291,
-0.0249397717,
-0.0582765229,
-0.0000380248,
-0.041040428,
-0.0269274265,
0.0088656498,
-0.0161757991,
-0.069853358,
0.062830545,
-0.018943673,
0.0004866756,
-0.0682302043,
0.0116307987,
-0.0628766939,
0.0357094966,
-0.0363159068,
0.0192346983,
-0.0080496063,
-0.0277136751,
-0.054536283,
-0.035688784,
0.0247210376,
-0.026134558,
0.0333854444,
-0.0469763204,
0.0055698748,
-0.0171331055,
-0.0525100976,
-0.0624679998,
-0.0393967032,
-0.0225338675,
0.0218291692,
0.0222238135,
0.0053463872,
-0.0185996816,
0.0467935912,
-0.0189731978,
0.0393000208,
-0.0250518285,
0.0011102688,
-0.0106485244,
-0.0235785712,
0.0141319055,
0.0052025388,
0.0236340947,
-0.037405137,
0.0309059117,
0.0370861441,
0.0180331003,
0.0391089916,
-0.0149377538,
-0.0077174902,
0.0362266712,
-0.0393655188,
0.0257163309,
-0.0235338937,
0.0357424989,
-0.0677270591,
0.0087798918,
0.1060950607,
0.016750643,
-0.1051483601,
0.0105257714,
-0.032790523,
0.0430550948,
0.0211318024,
0.0247166473,
-0.1077236459,
-0.014501906,
0.0412769765,
-0.0004031441,
-0.0499782972,
-0.0438015759,
-0.0224876404,
-0.1784520745,
0.0071668853,
0.009580601,
-0.0510177091,
-0.0190878734,
0.0008434833,
0.0104718804,
-0.0188930891,
0.0728474781,
0.0147843808,
0.0133784087,
0.0143908374,
-0.0039057329,
-0.0497474894,
-0.0224459842,
0.0340564437,
-0.0764040425,
0.0826807544,
0.0543297455,
0.0527811907,
-0.001328271,
0.0370558091,
0.0351000354,
0.0007118378,
0.0122906668,
-0.021283241,
0.0190396402,
-0.0260403883,
-0.0190598443,
0.0007877123,
0.0407650657,
0.0299936216,
0.0341091603,
0.0540310815,
0.0037159876,
-0.010785386,
-0.0087740272,
-0.0312147811,
0.0008391115,
0.0543931685,
0.0697703511,
0.0215787739,
-0.0447045006,
-0.0524525754,
-0.0587648898,
0.0064464905,
0.0175886899,
-0.0595338903,
-0.0080900723,
0.0201638639,
0.0046690619,
-0.0417170227,
-0.0457589626,
0.0350907631,
0.0079443594,
0.003918597,
-0.0620405413,
-0.0303664245,
0.0405810624,
-0.0031976581,
0.032085456,
-0.036803443,
0.0327547416,
-0.0257016718,
-0.0049696104,
-0.0261707157,
-0.0637827665,
-0.0020012197,
0.0417425856,
-0.0259726737,
-0.0718347505,
0.0169836953,
0.059630014,
0.0224330686,
0.0764620081,
-0.0185578261,
-0.0417060517,
0.0060818507,
0.0411751792,
-0.0300253592,
0.0282257535,
0.0689207539,
0.0353662893,
0.0037523329,
0.03455038,
-0.0530560315,
0.0226507541,
-0.0258054174,
0.0069064461,
-0.0096536353,
-0.0588268004,
0.0248444453,
0.0090713277,
0.0248800907,
-0.0267210416,
0.0007524253,
-0.022307219,
0.0367531627,
-0.0348641314,
-0.0317256972,
-0.0267543904,
0.0005799956,
-0.0212169979,
0.0001392853,
0.01101996,
-0.0301850345,
-0.0471896082,
0.0267489944,
-0.0049177795,
0.040420752,
0.0276597608,
0.0308134127,
0.0152549846,
-0.0073106405,
-0.0007996939,
0.0048108059,
-0.0002445015,
0.0255311262,
0.0325618125,
0.0599260889,
0.031595327,
-0.0060567553,
-0.0011819886,
0.0159625299,
-0.0342695229,
-0.0507910438,
0.0142461993,
0.0410913564,
0.0374513529,
0.0018036559,
0.0432774127,
-0.025678739,
-0.0049396157,
0.0063834977,
-0.0002327772,
-0.0055615781,
0.0109829344,
0.0174927171,
0.0259502996,
-0.0060513811,
0.0025925606,
0.0531076752,
0.0531437285,
0.0810072124,
-0.0286948252,
-0.0129535431,
-0.0240248926,
-0.0297560859,
0.035858836,
-0.0433859266,
-0.0035461779,
-0.0124882068,
-0.0806169808,
-0.0391032733,
-0.037351612,
0.015822703,
0.0177046321,
-0.0117923245,
-0.001160001,
0.0634473413,
-0.0252831299,
-0.0260272119,
-0.0363618769,
-0.0153079554,
-0.0274242386,
-0.0139493681,
-0.0107623301,
-6.380884557e-33,
-0.0314277112,
-0.060509149,
-0.005618494,
0.0056091677,
-0.018499203,
-0.0072232978,
-0.0113583785,
-0.0145092979,
-0.0056950347,
0.0076247486,
-0.0070708236,
0.0256361589,
0.0133610768,
-0.0233911145,
0.0003421061,
-0.0068904744,
0.0791822448,
0.0050403727,
-0.0365384221,
0.0076138675,
-0.0271585397,
0.0073928684,
0.0079809204,
-0.0726647675,
0.0318650492,
-0.0163881034,
-0.0034367205,
0.0363600515,
-0.0603810027,
0.030861415,
0.0127641615,
0.0587299392,
0.0113339936,
-0.0406331383,
0.0103690401,
0.0480535328,
-0.0294362996,
-0.0179774314,
-0.0068421685,
0.0304702818,
0.0253706574,
-0.008222199,
0.0232666489,
0.0106965629,
-0.0439869352,
-0.0123494705,
0.034507025,
0.0046879374,
0.0453318954,
0.0433720835,
-0.0504518487,
0.0230727643,
-0.0386884809,
-0.0340084806,
0.004391416,
0.0234177951,
0.0029128322,
-0.0030274198,
-0.0195724834,
0.037736997,
-0.0231516864,
-0.0421444997,
0.0460615978,
0.0096253427,
0.0406293012,
0.044661127,
0.0424328335,
0.0734696835,
-0.025116099,
-0.0978018492,
0.0245005954,
-0.0075407214,
0.0308251642,
0.0779205412,
0.0030215897,
0.0071530784,
-0.0491602458,
-0.0260434356,
0.0801882744,
0.0325365067,
0.0208416432,
-0.0055251764,
-0.0956465006,
-0.0318692774,
-0.0312989093,
-0.0430052169,
-0.0169524085,
-0.0201219879,
0.0336072892,
0.0157041643,
-0.0425764136,
-0.0109331878,
0.030462293,
-0.0516254231,
0.0125013245,
0.0382061526,
-0.018870499,
-0.0505991355,
-0.0019942105,
0.001692783,
-0.0400132239,
0.0011516116,
0.0253450591,
0.0100656366,
0.0392400213,
0.025799688,
-0.0268702079,
0.0128396638,
-0.0594843775,
0.0034278501,
-0.0380466171,
0.0495507419,
-0.0275349449,
0.0162596647,
0.023006415,
0.01864581,
0.0076643899,
0.0239638202,
0.0431084186,
-0.0112991259,
-0.0551099628,
-0.0004126935,
-0.0193600766,
0.0025248332,
-0.0350446701,
-0.0088572074,
0.0280190967,
-0.0030739505,
0.0426378734,
-0.05399229,
-0.0240687281,
-0.0460571386,
2.766e-7,
-0.0244538356,
0.0672466531,
0.0356396362,
0.0208225101,
0.025515696,
0.0541570038,
0.0034784058,
0.0430588201,
0.0631908551,
0.0241883341,
-0.0217653811,
0.0519302189,
0.0287549961,
0.0500586331,
-0.0882415473,
0.0056228456,
-0.0878746584,
-0.0058121895,
-0.01986509,
-0.0088263722,
0.0008062125,
0.0395263098,
0.0297902171,
-0.0014054381,
-0.0005596992,
-0.0333359987,
0.0293590613,
-0.0142682036,
-0.0008511636,
0.0466286279,
0.0076117008,
-0.01520932,
0.0189366136,
0.0604193211,
0.0335683487,
0.0180322696,
-0.0239341594,
0.0237314813,
-0.0027872683,
-0.012254999,
-0.0038697785,
-0.0026477994,
-0.0141088776,
-0.0683617666,
0.0570978187,
-0.0079140719,
-0.0181395914,
-0.069847241,
0.0145990243,
-0.0545981228,
0.053368289,
-0.0164225157,
-0.0120699182,
0.0378567763,
0.0000740742,
0.0216324385,
0.0106662055,
-0.0595828518,
-0.0374396965,
-0.0456014909,
-0.0616722107,
-0.0815852433,
0.028155053,
0.031259615,
0.0022854274,
-0.0150896162,
0.0489368923,
2.459697134e-34,
0.0114690755,
0.0151223829,
0.0213209502,
0.0406843275,
0.0409046039,
0.0137774181,
0.002891402,
0.0007708586,
0.0745327845,
0.0054996489,
-0.0057303421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11069v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11069v4 | VoxArabica: A Robust Dialect-Aware Arabic Speech Recognition System | 2023-10-17T08:33:02 | 2023-10-27T13:32:15 | Abdul Waheed, Bashar Talafha, Peter Sullivan, AbdelRahim Elmadany, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Arabic is a complex language with many varieties and dialects spoken by over
450 millions all around the world. Due to the linguistic diversity and
variations, it is challenging to build a robust and generalized ASR system for
Arabic. In this work, we address this gap by developing and demoing a system,
dubbed VoxArabica, for dialect identification (DID) as well as automatic speech
recognition (ASR) of Arabic. We train a wide range of models such as HuBERT
(DID), Whisper, and XLS-R (ASR) in a supervised setting for Arabic DID and ASR
tasks. Our DID models are trained to identify 17 different dialects in addition
to MSA. We finetune our ASR models on MSA, Egyptian, Moroccan, and mixed data.
Additionally, for the remaining dialects in ASR, we provide the option to
choose various models such as Whisper and MMS in a zero-shot setting. We
integrate these models into a single web interface with diverse features such
as audio recording, file upload, model selection, and the option to raise flags
for incorrect outputs. Overall, we believe VoxArabica will be useful for a wide
range of audiences concerned with Arabic research. Our system is currently
running at https://cdce-206-12-100-168.ngrok.io/. | [
-0.0210052356,
0.0549856089,
0.0147611387,
0.0102204699,
-0.0233954005,
0.0235426333,
0.0416541696,
-0.0295576062,
-0.0374099165,
-0.0005955748,
-0.0582091175,
-0.0588668175,
0.0704397187,
0.0051072738,
0.0228047036,
-0.0417853147,
0.0259976219,
-0.1182232052,
-0.0074952459,
-0.01714609,
0.0587253459,
0.021430118,
-0.0399937108,
0.0075601544,
0.0168233346,
-0.0150887696,
-0.0128108403,
0.0051320922,
0.0235939994,
0.0441452377,
-0.0060746633,
0.0372681245,
-0.0040741819,
0.0418560542,
0.0000018906,
-0.0316922218,
-0.0374007113,
-0.0243157335,
-0.0760574788,
-0.0039273202,
0.0337979905,
-0.0021806569,
-0.0437750854,
-0.0007446529,
0.0134710297,
-0.0230425242,
0.0566798896,
-0.0105534745,
0.008768036,
0.0009051916,
0.0049185599,
-0.035226725,
-0.0158136655,
0.0102552287,
-0.0287733413,
-0.000560311,
-0.0346972048,
-0.0273593776,
0.0091246087,
-0.01821905,
-0.0047011068,
0.0497008786,
-0.031689465,
-0.0060781944,
-0.0494615585,
-0.0463789254,
-0.0346149914,
-0.033097554,
0.0074272119,
0.0336006284,
0.0057787369,
-0.0362237617,
-0.0017757907,
0.0324152447,
-0.0324327834,
0.0002683065,
-0.0060561411,
0.0189292338,
-0.0539990105,
-0.0221298449,
0.0232245456,
0.0327046067,
-0.0082778437,
-0.0115215108,
-0.0083332676,
0.030768333,
0.0053706127,
-0.0019019165,
0.0259940941,
-0.0158311632,
0.0249801893,
0.0020678998,
0.0665173605,
-0.0135853617,
-0.0049315086,
-0.0132174743,
0.0111700539,
-0.020750694,
-0.0013707613,
-0.0344194919,
0.0378643982,
0.054400079,
-0.046631176,
0.009440342,
0.0000845043,
0.0200744104,
0.0378898121,
0.0442151576,
-0.0245937817,
-0.0029358529,
-0.0490481034,
0.0281304959,
-0.0163049903,
0.0225828551,
-0.0334379114,
0.0138345081,
-0.0446778312,
-0.0049021267,
-0.0128238741,
0.0227703638,
0.0170501042,
-0.0444201641,
-0.0352988318,
-0.0653918236,
0.0527566075,
0.0245506223,
-0.0008973535,
0.0408071429,
-0.063759394,
-0.1057880595,
-0.0100982981,
0.0299637057,
0.0419318564,
0.0586608946,
-0.0126816928,
-0.001909351,
-0.0048209256,
-0.0632655025,
-0.0735422596,
0.035930384,
-0.0399886593,
-0.0260788891,
-0.0201167893,
-0.0468465686,
0.0462100916,
0.0086966129,
-0.0036727048,
0.0059190956,
-0.0335853398,
-0.0433674231,
0.0902698264,
0.077027671,
0.0265109669,
0.0209774282,
0.1055161655,
0.0108974455,
0.0309872944,
0.0765808746,
0.0144200698,
-0.0268624313,
-0.0198772121,
0.0111282086,
0.0127565069,
0.0528547987,
-0.035806112,
0.0302885976,
-0.0757631361,
-0.0461320244,
-0.0085956752,
0.0377594866,
0.0148367565,
0.0414051935,
-0.0112643074,
-0.0288066082,
0.0645537227,
0.0196963008,
-0.0202061292,
0.0029984654,
0.0193793941,
0.0336740986,
0.0429417379,
-0.0031747355,
0.0622056909,
-0.0170973502,
0.0301526077,
0.0272843726,
0.0019049001,
0.0872438252,
-0.0508540608,
-0.0141230552,
-0.0373072736,
-0.0348041132,
-0.0055369087,
0.0459253453,
0.0936527029,
-0.0143446298,
-0.038165886,
0.0032003378,
0.0177438259,
0.0082482146,
0.0193528943,
-0.0577611364,
-0.012203021,
0.0277114976,
0.0076000425,
-0.043904189,
-0.0307712182,
-0.031368725,
0.0084491689,
0.0394430794,
0.0389471911,
-0.0290264208,
0.0548550338,
-0.0772872046,
0.0060701533,
0.0693374947,
0.0120140836,
0.0414755717,
-0.0136457235,
0.0479964465,
-0.0459607653,
-0.051095508,
0.0359525532,
-0.005451058,
-0.0309132244,
0.0100629916,
0.0199009962,
0.0248900801,
0.0425823741,
0.0413357951,
-0.0186735969,
-0.0129309902,
-0.0001495358,
-0.0243974086,
0.0403272174,
0.0643296167,
-0.0196272563,
-0.0324686058,
0.0643543229,
0.0391828977,
0.0106174648,
0.0301511884,
0.0274517927,
-0.0538573153,
0.0956125706,
-0.0507282577,
0.0553508289,
-0.0390396193,
0.0751612857,
0.0076583633,
0.0100057283,
0.017852962,
-0.0009678522,
-0.0089053409,
-0.0484426096,
0.0145674739,
-0.0351069942,
0.0302905235,
-0.0413823351,
0.0127101392,
0.0038328972,
-0.0244851857,
0.0142674465,
0.0072000241,
-0.0458255149,
0.0087600304,
-0.0140396683,
-0.054410696,
-0.0325446464,
-0.0302584991,
0.054359071,
-0.0564282164,
0.0216839593,
-0.0207216218,
-0.0513901114,
0.0220483653,
-0.005331126,
-0.0079907272,
-0.0032201656,
-0.044945769,
-0.0163099524,
-0.0149070704,
-0.0523315035,
0.0105665196,
0.0244283192,
0.0206608418,
0.0023898419,
-0.0537877865,
0.0146192424,
-0.0991686806,
0.0195927341,
0.0334376395,
0.0041233087,
-0.0026657465,
-0.0151134636,
0.0042504556,
0.0180921629,
0.0358310342,
-0.0279679745,
-0.0003570013,
0.0056437817,
-0.0226955023,
-0.0348232314,
-0.0033750564,
0.0178605951,
-0.015940899,
-0.0301078428,
-0.0542389043,
-0.0644423962,
-0.0019765061,
0.0332941189,
0.0456148088,
-0.0294966195,
-0.00621532,
-0.0063376548,
0.003701322,
0.0451078154,
0.0145536494,
-0.0261511579,
0.0515984483,
0.0018361319,
-0.0364017561,
0.0172106382,
-0.0601034462,
-0.0350971296,
-0.0100146243,
-0.0128639583,
-0.0275410824,
-0.0388638899,
-0.0567926839,
0.0309613012,
-0.0086727124,
-0.0711050928,
-0.0064367056,
-0.0148318661,
0.022491781,
-0.0420376584,
-0.0091879899,
-0.0432307459,
-0.002276723,
-0.0182328038,
-0.0209368207,
0.0224818438,
0.0393744744,
-0.0798311532,
0.0161635969,
0.0174828488,
-0.0069701578,
-0.0211927332,
0.0519328862,
0.0287344102,
0.0728068575,
-0.0011895326,
0.0443197712,
-0.0024993096,
0.0043789204,
0.0334470682,
0.0318654776,
0.0018634526,
-0.0168978553,
0.0527139269,
-0.0264789332,
-0.0315397568,
0.0059669954,
-0.0684373826,
-0.0189525839,
0.0555061288,
-0.0128416885,
-0.003845046,
-0.0297612008,
0.025525583,
-0.0055849496,
0.0083582299,
0.0747211128,
-0.002061842,
-0.0209555738,
-0.0367277414,
-0.0192162097,
0.0236333199,
-0.0173351541,
-0.0264429804,
-0.0573924333,
-0.0175063629,
0.0858930796,
0.0581872612,
0.0338615663,
0.0569059961,
0.036902003,
-0.0512539186,
0.0202790257,
0.0088634752,
-0.0303036459,
-0.0362436101,
-0.0476743951,
-0.0202064756,
-0.0500585139,
-0.0002177618,
-0.0324811041,
-0.0014915648,
-0.0147376368,
0.0649952441,
-0.0136125414,
-0.0764371008,
0.0348805524,
-0.0192077607,
0.0675601736,
-0.0114671914,
-0.0346280113,
-0.0152899977,
-0.0325985476,
-0.0280849859,
-0.014339447,
-0.0442590006,
-0.0102462824,
0.0094428426,
0.0115367845,
0.0056006471,
-0.0194160771,
-0.0268695448,
-0.0226777494,
0.0105791492,
-0.0080475742,
0.0247245207,
-0.035718035,
0.0342361331,
0.0329046659,
0.0360291861,
-0.0072117327,
0.029750431,
-0.0097470889,
-0.0047873817,
-0.030969549,
0.0229612738,
0.0146939512,
-0.0486484803,
0.0026406783,
0.0050250264,
0.0443447232,
-0.0339254513,
-0.0416162908,
0.0020716281,
0.0135437548,
0.0120724197,
0.0268800352,
0.006869453,
-0.0105344886,
0.0700638443,
-0.0443653576,
-0.0278163943,
0.0292359814,
0.0011104399,
-0.087299116,
-0.0273577813,
0.0506872199,
-0.0720111281,
0.0252012424,
-0.0063339267,
-0.0600613803,
-0.0618744381,
0.0387024619,
-0.011065077,
0.0196344629,
0.0306586679,
-0.0086572301,
-0.038376946,
0.0285693426,
-0.0484659746,
0.0080265161,
0.0177294072,
0.0678088218,
-0.0053150896,
-0.0593480244,
0.0363990441,
-0.0041725002,
0.0089771198,
0.0083377343,
-0.0312994123,
-0.0795715004,
-0.0516242348,
-0.0255116373,
-0.0508861132,
0.01161863,
-0.0402400866,
-0.0448095277,
-0.0494330935,
-0.0024812096,
0.0029079122,
0.0799588114,
-0.0023684271,
0.0228807144,
0.0160303544,
0.0332970284,
0.0133332592,
0.0205714051,
-0.0311879013,
-0.0124182468,
0.0273658372,
0.0625564083,
-0.0044635311,
-0.0093516214,
-0.0156432055,
0.006738998,
-0.0057879537,
0.0327307358,
-0.0203510653,
0.0362805948,
-0.0241940655,
0.0106204841,
-0.0428787693,
-0.0038291193,
0.0243773628,
0.045404084,
0.0208391156,
-0.0222074427,
-0.0272697378,
0.1005063131,
0.0274599008,
-0.0086461417,
0.053252276,
0.0215498134,
0.0111810463,
-0.0376422107,
-0.0022288389,
-0.0286560971,
0.0115527743,
-0.0205514859,
0.0063997004,
-0.0118521582,
0.0497266911,
0.0326694362,
0.0292981416,
-0.0201296024,
0.0016599105,
0.0299021825,
-0.0132328942,
-0.029397808,
0.0195788294,
0.0118037593,
-0.0706260949,
0.0190845542,
-0.0354437046,
-0.0795221925,
0.0435358137,
0.0119689936,
0.0220121201,
-0.0044534784,
-0.0050108139,
0.0152390162,
-0.0166834164,
-0.0101029016,
-0.0294162538,
-0.0042087361,
-0.0088222232,
-0.0045208987,
0.0179000255,
-5.786803303e-33,
0.0099052265,
0.010762495,
-0.0190470349,
-0.0261366926,
0.039590437,
-0.0347694755,
-0.0444415323,
0.0281914622,
-0.0068148542,
-0.0199645683,
-0.0250089467,
-0.0090994788,
0.0413859822,
0.000763694,
0.034909036,
-0.0112609873,
0.0484221205,
-0.0175160598,
-0.0017081792,
0.0088927699,
0.0318087302,
0.0483549461,
0.0678426176,
-0.0496927239,
-0.0469818488,
-0.0123236682,
-0.0140981814,
-0.0077321441,
0.0054485174,
0.0907353237,
-0.0263689738,
0.0485599265,
-0.0090317717,
-0.0285487901,
0.0239098221,
0.0000397422,
-0.0513746142,
0.0383116938,
-0.0100826966,
0.1061026007,
0.0353998952,
-0.0148915267,
-0.0353603624,
-0.00800703,
-0.0635234639,
0.0088173347,
-0.0076324367,
-0.0392413139,
-0.0002792102,
-0.0051571503,
-0.0410266817,
0.0591838583,
-0.010650591,
-0.0446940809,
0.1062255949,
0.0467428267,
-0.0094806962,
-0.0172758251,
-0.0335971192,
0.0162719842,
0.0132517815,
0.031610474,
0.0641090497,
0.0647761673,
-0.0735145211,
0.0016814984,
0.0536458008,
-0.0814239234,
0.0728823319,
0.0108967433,
0.0231216289,
-0.059286017,
0.0021166196,
0.0714463592,
0.0160978772,
-0.0268545263,
-0.0329377688,
-0.0238788761,
0.0435033031,
0.013435727,
-0.0037732339,
-0.005081065,
-0.0605175607,
0.0141010378,
-0.010574121,
-0.0866473615,
-0.0075665023,
0.0161223337,
0.0443917103,
-0.0027284534,
0.0041559576,
0.0306602661,
0.0411672853,
0.0459590852,
0.0287549589,
-0.0092059467,
0.0240391362,
-0.0131542562,
-0.0051698051,
0.0584136732,
-0.0265634563,
-0.0277830586,
0.0059496453,
0.0467478223,
0.0020031906,
-0.0216024369,
0.0191414673,
0.0616338179,
-0.0479186289,
0.0303799715,
0.015809061,
0.0276576634,
0.0081841163,
0.0949098691,
0.0283415988,
-0.0172267146,
0.0151080303,
0.0437659398,
0.0103997104,
0.021460712,
0.0054929918,
-0.0217856318,
-0.0431180969,
0.0090859542,
-0.0084141428,
0.023100581,
0.0043665613,
-0.0368909799,
-0.0232186262,
-0.0138741517,
0.024552146,
-0.0105895866,
2.728e-7,
-0.0382855497,
0.0005432554,
0.04663793,
-0.0548754297,
-0.0051700012,
0.0015851905,
-0.0003828051,
-0.0314925052,
0.0081601627,
0.0021586181,
-0.0074484968,
-0.0291220248,
0.10673967,
0.0168949924,
-0.1080843583,
-0.0330782644,
-0.019006582,
0.0455236621,
-0.0178920124,
0.0023852852,
0.0113841891,
0.1438891292,
-0.0505199619,
-0.0058297906,
-0.0320181213,
-0.0262723044,
0.0176475439,
0.0219523553,
0.0046543055,
0.0347167253,
0.0348750167,
-0.0821858719,
-0.0190342236,
-0.0484225377,
-0.0357924215,
0.0345475413,
0.0092881592,
0.0861594528,
-0.0097039388,
-0.0665993989,
0.0176993906,
0.0115098152,
-0.0326732099,
-0.0201327056,
0.0327781327,
0.0552738979,
-0.0035754649,
0.0002181969,
-0.0212527886,
0.0262064952,
0.0161839426,
-0.0511950143,
0.0157468729,
0.0110196341,
0.0295084976,
-0.0332076997,
-0.0082573751,
-0.0268768966,
0.0362187773,
-0.0017481939,
-0.037582919,
0.0210999772,
0.0330428183,
-0.0125520211,
-0.0138326939,
-0.007080738,
0.0135432016,
1.940187176e-34,
0.0405813046,
0.0037647588,
-0.0023392397,
0.0214938112,
-0.0019737866,
-0.0531652868,
-0.0565133877,
0.0238042735,
0.0154686188,
0.0176681876,
-0.0281133186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11053v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11053v3 | Denevil: Towards Deciphering and Navigating the Ethical Values of Large Language Models via Instruction Learning | 2023-10-17T07:42:40 | 2024-03-04T07:14:10 | Shitong Duan, Xiaoyuan Yi, Peng Zhang, Tun Lu, Xing Xie, Ning Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made unprecedented breakthroughs, yet their
increasing integration into everyday life might raise societal risks due to
generated unethical content. Despite extensive study on specific issues like
bias, the intrinsic values of LLMs remain largely unexplored from a moral
philosophy perspective. This work delves into ethical values utilizing Moral
Foundation Theory. Moving beyond conventional discriminative evaluations with
poor reliability, we propose DeNEVIL, a novel prompt generation algorithm
tailored to dynamically exploit LLMs' value vulnerabilities and elicit the
violation of ethics in a generative manner, revealing their underlying value
inclinations. On such a basis, we construct MoralPrompt, a high-quality dataset
comprising 2,397 prompts covering 500+ value principles, and then benchmark the
intrinsic values across a spectrum of LLMs. We discovered that most models are
essentially misaligned, necessitating further ethical value alignment. In
response, we develop VILMO, an in-context alignment method that substantially
enhances the value compliance of LLM outputs by learning to generate
appropriate value instructions, outperforming existing competitors. Our methods
are suitable for black-box and open-source models, offering a promising initial
step in studying the ethical values of LLMs. | [
0.0333458111,
0.1025707349,
-0.0271302909,
0.0665655807,
-0.0751105025,
0.0043214858,
0.0212668497,
-0.0194760673,
-0.0031041324,
-0.0126476232,
0.0016239947,
-0.0058931024,
-0.0169823319,
0.0093369447,
-0.0263638925,
-0.0197901931,
0.0635887831,
0.0158314053,
0.0642327443,
-0.0311254058,
0.011778025,
0.0380957425,
0.0270301402,
0.0196789131,
-0.0012871115,
-0.0133132311,
0.0005240207,
-0.0006620075,
0.063399516,
-0.0045348997,
0.0270236246,
0.0544166379,
0.0122800367,
0.0321419872,
0.0000020271,
-0.0667274669,
-0.0248405579,
-0.0062632822,
-0.0083583416,
0.0262374189,
0.1046531871,
-0.0006584125,
-0.0207089093,
-0.0038654383,
-0.0472752266,
0.0467175096,
0.045415923,
0.0186135359,
0.0418910794,
0.0645723715,
0.007193218,
0.0194938816,
0.0168814603,
0.0060516633,
0.0003231499,
-0.0202286057,
0.0264718421,
0.0295822807,
-0.035473749,
0.0491668023,
-0.017345177,
0.0191236939,
0.0329581015,
-0.0287490524,
-0.0039640707,
-0.0330184735,
-0.0132007785,
-0.0481388718,
-0.0224919505,
0.0665022954,
0.0055110184,
-0.0153239053,
0.0036062482,
-0.0008065676,
0.0273397565,
-0.0300271139,
0.0113030849,
0.077622585,
-0.0103998575,
0.0251650885,
0.0483682528,
0.0118891308,
0.008486134,
0.0636832491,
0.0660823509,
-0.0196892619,
-0.0110801999,
-0.0142675806,
-0.0134318983,
-0.0163867567,
-0.0310324039,
-0.020612888,
0.015196058,
0.0309184194,
-0.0205576196,
0.039463684,
-0.0325586945,
0.013726891,
0.0765035227,
-0.0481571071,
0.0427180156,
0.0425578803,
0.0023788728,
0.0247016903,
0.010430851,
0.026447678,
0.0051134881,
0.0568981133,
-0.0569548942,
0.0452829935,
0.0203904975,
-0.0094624795,
-0.0071435361,
0.0229746699,
-0.0168188903,
0.0367576852,
-0.0299307592,
-0.002983225,
-0.0589886121,
0.0272284318,
-0.040409077,
0.0079201013,
0.0061126677,
-0.0028501619,
-0.009629814,
0.0120224226,
-0.0527758971,
0.013035262,
-0.0111657158,
-0.0251413025,
0.0284897834,
-0.0300683603,
-0.0250942614,
0.0186932646,
0.0298720151,
0.0975074321,
0.0068512894,
0.0044480227,
-0.0267801564,
-0.0370090231,
-0.0021038109,
-0.058491759,
-0.0144273341,
-0.0535912737,
0.0042005684,
-0.0252022557,
-0.0256658699,
-0.0681693032,
0.0461534895,
0.039087534,
-0.000882921,
0.0441775322,
0.0252446271,
0.0024400516,
0.0079387566,
0.0301035065,
0.007933124,
0.0456093848,
0.0128177954,
0.0378832258,
0.0551814325,
-0.0407241173,
-0.0232692342,
0.0113857025,
0.0155475484,
0.0044162208,
-0.0500257574,
0.0122782784,
0.0358521864,
0.0395757332,
0.000893729,
0.0467415899,
-0.0094891125,
-0.0393335335,
0.0622828193,
0.0654193312,
-0.0425890684,
-0.0134331305,
0.0326568112,
0.0068216636,
0.0136368405,
-0.0272817183,
-0.0702332556,
-0.0003908579,
-0.0102763269,
-0.0191604253,
-0.0814979672,
0.0727904141,
0.0039869305,
-0.0516120866,
0.0029431414,
-0.0079906648,
0.0393299535,
0.0308508482,
-0.0112096518,
-0.0084172664,
-0.0357277915,
-0.0538479313,
0.0629699752,
-0.0795130357,
0.005020122,
-0.0328020602,
0.0845687836,
0.0889896527,
0.0405517407,
0.0041387961,
-0.0202285312,
-0.048355449,
-0.0149838217,
0.0276832208,
0.0206183661,
-0.0383804329,
-0.0175484382,
-0.0479830578,
-0.0448691361,
-0.0179684963,
-0.0124954488,
0.0163118728,
0.0030412516,
-0.0175024103,
0.0169160143,
-0.0327357724,
-0.0662708506,
0.0295840017,
-0.0272936467,
-0.0119406786,
-0.0365656912,
0.0313307419,
0.0081340671,
0.0056274305,
0.0159756504,
-0.0089097507,
0.0079403259,
0.004341214,
0.0192575455,
-0.0346918292,
-0.0632505119,
0.0070320745,
0.0401685573,
-0.084372595,
-0.0110263862,
0.0410088375,
-0.0254349988,
0.0520904027,
-0.0320229679,
-0.0186016876,
-0.014680705,
-0.0560309924,
-0.0037682639,
-0.0769704655,
-0.0126884691,
-0.0405118912,
0.0646940097,
-0.0264304653,
0.0023829122,
0.004331999,
-0.001345317,
0.0219797492,
-0.0063371323,
-0.0008888633,
-0.002481804,
-0.0468371287,
0.0738181844,
0.0456655174,
0.0657194331,
-0.0214529708,
-0.0285286922,
-0.0592829324,
-0.0153671065,
0.0044182548,
-0.0128347725,
0.0091892388,
-0.0328967646,
-0.0013128038,
0.0173901506,
-0.0466763191,
-0.0203057472,
0.0076320553,
0.0160198025,
0.0045767571,
-0.0396282598,
-0.0383492522,
0.0076009724,
0.0011459398,
-0.029421052,
0.0135093257,
0.0329293832,
0.0460635945,
-0.0261239074,
0.0099279378,
-0.0385758765,
-0.0246358812,
0.0131130526,
-0.0462056808,
-0.0131089818,
0.0397712141,
-0.0190925617,
0.0775127709,
0.0778438747,
0.0522222407,
0.0199363306,
0.0418921076,
-0.0619527102,
-0.0278080385,
-0.0219158195,
-0.002962538,
-0.0297065452,
-0.0552113317,
-0.0202786885,
0.0465107746,
0.0005796842,
0.0025652491,
-0.0478858873,
0.0780716762,
-0.0475987382,
-0.054625161,
-0.0234926958,
-0.0416995734,
-0.0237265881,
0.0195937436,
-0.0287820864,
-0.0708055422,
0.0773829371,
0.0349944495,
0.0408241712,
-0.0240913946,
0.0150440028,
-0.0202895459,
0.0274905991,
-0.0214783512,
0.0729707554,
0.0315577202,
-0.0329345725,
-0.0311806705,
0.0257723182,
0.07250797,
-0.0793712363,
0.0560499467,
-0.0238051806,
-0.0163328517,
0.0049584941,
-0.0561721995,
-0.0744332895,
-0.0572666973,
0.0030206577,
-0.0067641628,
0.0069971448,
0.0131923584,
0.0154620931,
-0.0538243093,
0.0154290674,
-0.0284247361,
-0.0134844212,
0.0213779584,
-0.018691007,
-0.0370141268,
0.0376666225,
-0.0444745384,
0.0430915803,
-0.0058281324,
0.0474792048,
0.0360289887,
-0.0149987983,
-0.0010289709,
0.0266392957,
0.0524583496,
0.0472830236,
0.0046319589,
0.0408433676,
0.0406582467,
0.0452558473,
-0.0123082846,
-0.0028029943,
0.0831598341,
0.0062074214,
-0.0576079935,
0.0316408575,
-0.0270117298,
-0.0067823669,
0.0180318505,
-0.0040946491,
-0.0933446735,
-0.0077522541,
-0.0329037979,
0.042098891,
-0.0756901801,
-0.0510413386,
0.0066208979,
-0.1060571969,
0.0305154771,
0.0332167037,
-0.0297133029,
-0.0157007184,
-0.0119126271,
-0.0253240708,
-0.012678178,
0.0617038794,
0.010879918,
-0.0145131089,
-0.0521499477,
0.0218143631,
0.0446242169,
-0.0233073197,
0.0672481954,
-0.0147960614,
0.0707004815,
0.0780005902,
0.0297103152,
-0.0270896554,
-0.0618060827,
-0.0163905751,
-0.0015165631,
-0.0409882776,
0.0178447422,
0.0032901575,
-0.0286418237,
-0.0061103604,
-0.0445759818,
0.0603090972,
0.003503503,
-0.0452418476,
0.0190066993,
0.0789361149,
0.028180996,
-0.0276308358,
-0.0230801217,
0.0075146155,
0.0363719426,
0.0682901964,
0.0014696202,
-0.0640682653,
0.0170877557,
-0.048158247,
-0.0425715595,
-0.0105551928,
-0.0531299226,
-0.0139385229,
-0.016771961,
-0.0019694555,
-0.0515212379,
-0.0396269187,
-0.0131518887,
-0.0013369907,
0.0500511378,
-0.0788703561,
0.0139177805,
0.0014724823,
-0.0435266495,
0.0129599571,
-0.0360420831,
0.0257717539,
-0.0445459858,
0.0086858533,
-0.0107544167,
-0.0518299714,
-0.0086124949,
0.0020632583,
-0.0065820888,
-0.0491932966,
0.0416016579,
0.0521066114,
0.0101479236,
0.0302463323,
-0.0113584138,
0.0236789379,
0.0209191907,
0.0540307052,
-0.055525966,
0.0168007221,
0.0385742858,
0.0028596681,
-0.0119496398,
0.0038630962,
-0.0125606945,
0.029791696,
0.0405762009,
0.0066235061,
-0.0454385653,
-0.0231448319,
0.0405028425,
0.0335794948,
-0.0125559894,
-0.0460224077,
-0.0140359756,
-0.0469287112,
-0.034800157,
-0.0162876677,
-0.0670054629,
-0.0208373349,
0.0190270487,
0.0516354293,
-0.0195615403,
0.0135915913,
0.0077825226,
-0.0275246706,
0.0170207079,
-0.0195220113,
0.0134540685,
-0.0029384738,
0.0728161931,
-0.0011440938,
0.0024533491,
-0.0381111279,
0.0372216143,
-0.0150680523,
0.0589302666,
-0.0106728924,
0.093271181,
0.0350446478,
0.0077536111,
0.0028149874,
0.0250006355,
-0.0170282088,
-0.0264717806,
-0.0416956171,
0.0085706916,
-0.0115560489,
0.0162149481,
0.0034628939,
-0.0234005805,
-0.002203926,
-0.0241492521,
0.0183518603,
-0.0039607505,
-0.0977820083,
0.0198641233,
0.0223915186,
-0.0161140971,
-0.0094553297,
0.0155357299,
-0.0447528139,
0.0370316729,
0.0157055575,
-0.0047874297,
-0.0249284152,
-0.0218239501,
0.0695890859,
-0.0425594263,
-0.0118416175,
0.0069153761,
-0.0939904675,
-0.0277035479,
-0.0213343408,
0.0252901763,
0.0006757808,
-0.0260271337,
0.0073086182,
0.0543585271,
-0.0449562371,
0.0090771206,
-0.0424699858,
0.0125544174,
-0.0398485214,
-0.0009550951,
-0.0394384079,
-5.451089464e-33,
-0.011752204,
-0.0382960141,
-0.0089879511,
-0.0141388047,
-0.0124517959,
-0.0061350623,
0.0127042271,
0.0161780622,
-0.0499442257,
0.0439767018,
0.015119791,
-0.026649598,
-0.0087763565,
0.0079650842,
0.0143360179,
-0.0632310137,
0.0022913797,
-0.0011680076,
-0.0495641641,
0.0301291794,
0.0016352475,
-0.0242610388,
0.0628587455,
-0.0692011416,
0.0530006848,
0.0071157934,
-0.0346383005,
0.0375055894,
-0.0398179106,
0.0298484769,
0.0042311843,
0.0702229738,
-0.0065002046,
-0.0286219958,
0.0027321817,
0.0385258794,
-0.0082421973,
-0.0037494476,
0.0540730543,
-0.0105436677,
-0.0441236794,
-0.0779012516,
-0.0013744726,
-0.0366607159,
-0.035757117,
-0.0079922872,
0.0470497087,
-0.0262111947,
0.0085112406,
-0.0076829786,
-0.0892766267,
-0.0157987215,
-0.0614218786,
-0.0455351062,
-0.0268283132,
0.0471601412,
-0.0020909847,
0.012791872,
-0.002610629,
0.0474651381,
0.0224655382,
-0.033031784,
0.0566818304,
-0.0076476838,
0.0121954726,
0.0810213834,
-0.005593549,
0.0226888191,
-0.0171104018,
0.0176085047,
0.0184914805,
0.0384809263,
0.0435489677,
0.0815816894,
-0.0245187674,
-0.0297281183,
-0.0176257882,
-0.0113271764,
0.0378132537,
0.0018617179,
0.0166122597,
-0.0387870893,
-0.040661931,
-0.0180854071,
-0.0528335497,
-0.0507877991,
-0.0077453819,
-0.0118260188,
0.0307981037,
-0.018450696,
-0.0594402477,
-0.0215934142,
0.0213769861,
-0.043441236,
0.0087616798,
0.0676997826,
0.0133326929,
-0.0088069597,
-0.0002025881,
0.0361681841,
-0.0478058159,
-0.0158652551,
0.004379028,
-0.0498304106,
0.04531914,
0.0217018574,
0.0356182046,
0.0078461757,
0.0020501015,
0.0107792355,
-0.0270228274,
0.0321117155,
0.0001843743,
-0.0144132497,
0.0227763299,
0.0040664864,
0.002890717,
0.0160762351,
0.0505541004,
0.0073013934,
-0.045818381,
-0.0033745293,
-0.0148847932,
0.0454735048,
-0.0302655213,
-0.0006300756,
-0.0476404727,
0.0378980115,
0.0290402118,
-0.0327402689,
-0.0022102639,
0.021679448,
2.617e-7,
-0.0068284571,
0.0064257411,
0.0267398227,
0.0106412917,
-0.0404808931,
0.0840377659,
0.0375440419,
0.0516707525,
0.0356117636,
-0.0738621801,
0.0113947866,
0.0175877102,
0.0635435656,
0.0088198595,
-0.0287326109,
0.0041898424,
-0.0332258157,
-0.0065351794,
-0.0566912517,
0.0378959104,
0.0157443024,
0.0492330939,
0.0267265812,
-0.0184578877,
0.0190594755,
0.041546233,
0.0168310963,
-0.065062739,
-0.0244321171,
0.0102467202,
-0.0369132981,
-0.0489020087,
0.015871834,
-0.0163809434,
0.01689093,
0.0009567626,
0.0188626591,
0.0920641273,
-0.0138786985,
-0.0197165534,
-0.0426531993,
-0.0420720689,
-0.0147149712,
-0.0462868288,
0.0452919155,
0.0144861843,
-0.0066049839,
-0.0499261729,
-0.0109559158,
-0.0234769993,
0.0217629075,
-0.0357386097,
-0.0210296828,
-0.0004319306,
0.0078889858,
0.0003028322,
0.024546193,
-0.0166424923,
-0.0103978701,
-0.0279067978,
0.004268141,
-0.0778155103,
0.0247776881,
0.0433385149,
0.0184380356,
-0.0668190196,
0.0290260781,
2.325266498e-34,
0.0140078049,
-0.0608215593,
0.038175799,
0.0180676021,
0.0281360783,
0.051136788,
-0.0130284624,
0.01357623,
0.0182926375,
-0.0048539196,
0.0025602977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11049v1 | Nonet at SemEval-2023 Task 6: Methodologies for Legal Evaluation | 2023-10-17T07:35:11 | 2023-10-17T07:35:11 | Shubham Kumar Nigam, Aniket Deroy, Noel Shallum, Ayush Kumar Mishra, Anup Roy, Shubham Kumar Mishra, Arnab Bhattacharya, Saptarshi Ghosh, Kripabandhu Ghosh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | This paper describes our submission to the SemEval-2023 for Task 6 on
LegalEval: Understanding Legal Texts. Our submission concentrated on three
subtasks: Legal Named Entity Recognition (L-NER) for Task-B, Legal Judgment
Prediction (LJP) for Task-C1, and Court Judgment Prediction with Explanation
(CJPE) for Task-C2. We conducted various experiments on these subtasks and
presented the results in detail, including data statistics and methodology. It
is worth noting that legal tasks, such as those tackled in this research, have
been gaining importance due to the increasing need to automate legal analysis
and support. Our team obtained competitive rankings of 15$^{th}$, 11$^{th}$,
and 1$^{st}$ in Task-B, Task-C1, and Task-C2, respectively, as reported on the
leaderboard. | [
0.0454245433,
0.0351260081,
0.0014853373,
0.0143311946,
-0.0625281483,
0.0520207733,
0.0405304208,
0.041918043,
0.0009805077,
-0.0658193231,
-0.0022843068,
-0.0033613255,
0.0005195243,
0.009326593,
0.0000852183,
-0.0449280851,
0.011046092,
0.0010370335,
0.0727205724,
0.0027652557,
0.0041398103,
0.0027781201,
-0.0150016844,
0.0033636268,
-0.0095732175,
0.0146376416,
-0.0157680027,
-0.0034952569,
0.0256824475,
-0.0385169014,
-0.0034911416,
0.083703652,
-0.0112748621,
0.0181917958,
0.0000020347,
-0.0883108526,
-0.014441981,
-0.0060887998,
-0.0194168556,
0.005884842,
-0.0008641934,
-0.0329546891,
-0.03871556,
-0.0101013398,
-0.0130869141,
0.0033428487,
0.0008055886,
0.0321965478,
0.0241443012,
0.0767439976,
-0.0071302727,
-0.0553785898,
0.0383976623,
-0.0366946943,
0.0140581522,
-0.0447120294,
0.0158309117,
-0.0034678923,
-0.0059410711,
-0.0223207716,
0.0336333066,
-0.0077604554,
0.0201754645,
-0.0421092138,
-0.0040345946,
0.0086530214,
-0.042545978,
-0.0023613439,
0.004475289,
0.028695548,
0.0925135538,
-0.0191943664,
0.031175198,
0.0157380421,
0.0250726305,
0.0152447252,
-0.0216598623,
0.0773584768,
-0.0211501736,
-0.0040870612,
0.0238592606,
0.0620636865,
-0.013734878,
0.0287216902,
-0.0049809734,
0.0532988086,
0.0172337331,
-0.0429425649,
0.0247438569,
0.0364076979,
0.0284103192,
-0.0638070777,
0.0606502742,
0.0340271555,
0.0076120063,
0.0181809552,
0.002548981,
-0.056475278,
0.0489424504,
-0.0783740804,
0.0157738067,
0.000052585,
-0.0100464253,
0.0919619873,
-0.0838815346,
0.0182639938,
0.0269139279,
0.0053232904,
0.023068212,
-0.0341425128,
-0.0322603025,
0.01723627,
-0.0211705007,
0.065809086,
-0.0834204778,
0.0216392558,
-0.0299076587,
-0.0174564533,
-0.0338211395,
0.0422009267,
0.0191009399,
-0.0138772791,
0.0129712978,
-0.0308583416,
-0.0864176601,
-0.0442888066,
-0.0473165326,
0.0162217375,
-0.0313652791,
-0.0032225689,
0.0066490541,
-0.008101495,
-0.0066282493,
-0.01779503,
0.0426017269,
0.1123793125,
-0.011617939,
-0.0543836243,
-0.0238828529,
-0.0692632943,
-0.0014889311,
-0.0850472823,
-0.0623658895,
-0.0487669036,
0.0136905117,
0.0014337417,
-0.0225362331,
-0.0342966169,
0.0222003665,
0.0365076736,
-0.0130107282,
0.0687606856,
-0.0033025381,
-0.0112816766,
-0.0210944396,
0.0240755528,
0.0294424072,
0.0003879516,
-0.0067334864,
0.028179761,
0.0316902436,
-0.0025345769,
0.0265718624,
0.0331482738,
0.0136050759,
0.0030317106,
0.011107727,
0.016648151,
-0.0124272285,
0.0141378967,
0.0268838089,
0.0210427493,
0.031299077,
-0.0100077139,
0.0224093273,
0.0518667623,
0.00666638,
0.0445104651,
-0.0092197722,
-0.053803023,
0.0470596664,
-0.0033938803,
-0.0728577822,
0.0268896744,
-0.0342537649,
0.0078910524,
-0.0670525059,
0.01738167,
-0.0114011718,
-0.0529631749,
0.0021971941,
0.0039521437,
-0.0210624058,
-0.0025242963,
0.0588709898,
0.005276477,
-0.0644494817,
0.0215526614,
0.0069073373,
-0.0504619442,
-0.0118296202,
-0.0078171268,
0.0177663323,
0.0295254607,
0.0515081808,
-0.0264285412,
-0.0335444659,
-0.0033709239,
-0.0128921997,
0.0368717462,
-0.018349966,
-0.0020043196,
-0.0028657359,
-0.0319542401,
-0.0537412316,
0.0322623141,
0.0273189172,
0.0173248891,
0.0308174063,
0.0334936939,
0.0584998354,
-0.0674808994,
-0.0069870818,
0.0471591093,
0.0099480338,
-0.0553250723,
0.0149517888,
0.0195566844,
0.0393841453,
0.0567128174,
0.011693567,
-0.0170542691,
0.0429490656,
-0.0023723599,
0.0241402909,
0.0279665366,
0.010304668,
-0.0146487271,
0.0313416086,
-0.0617051423,
-0.0119486749,
0.0195745546,
-0.0209775083,
-0.0214537121,
-0.0427654088,
0.0048969709,
-0.0097339191,
-0.0370414518,
-0.0098289475,
0.0131576303,
-0.0284456816,
-0.011110845,
0.0464986339,
0.0045650648,
-0.0133867878,
0.0208475962,
-0.0044429032,
0.0317455046,
-0.0046887905,
-0.0322543383,
-0.0394004807,
-0.0315444991,
-0.0453078337,
0.0183733664,
0.0187833756,
-0.0646015853,
-0.0267508198,
-0.0582377277,
-0.0044168993,
-0.0191671439,
0.0422500372,
0.0265711248,
-0.0393726304,
-0.0247027613,
-0.0369402617,
-0.0064548519,
-0.0196824297,
0.0046130097,
-0.0270008259,
0.0306875259,
-0.0213916823,
-0.0179928709,
-0.0094931861,
-0.017054176,
-0.0446260497,
0.0299311243,
0.047799997,
-0.0337488465,
-0.0456880666,
0.0843229517,
-0.0262333639,
-0.0293589849,
-0.0137583818,
0.0125179458,
-0.034308929,
0.0246352106,
-0.0249765217,
0.0364730209,
0.0411516279,
0.0365412347,
-0.0039023852,
0.0132790897,
-0.0364978872,
-0.0187842548,
0.006539572,
0.0502355434,
-0.0044014812,
-0.0351767913,
0.0228440948,
0.042928759,
-0.0289411377,
0.0247134529,
-0.0277628843,
-0.0083032353,
-0.0108623728,
0.001790375,
-0.0118202241,
-0.021766413,
-0.0209176149,
0.05054814,
0.0029023634,
-0.0654421672,
0.0709759369,
-0.0030859518,
0.031022422,
-0.0524110086,
0.0001145341,
-0.0380831584,
0.1108274981,
0.0076086638,
-0.0069455551,
-0.0125075895,
-0.071571447,
0.0202757455,
-0.004465905,
0.0793007314,
-0.0299980398,
0.0695355013,
-0.0103908367,
0.0314718448,
-0.0328308381,
-0.0264940951,
-0.0298370048,
-0.0280960537,
-0.0239617042,
0.0360118523,
0.0147211635,
0.0264210328,
-0.0255483575,
0.0018950445,
-0.021564858,
0.0001803964,
0.0109956814,
-0.0058692531,
-0.0280423127,
0.0572427474,
-0.0210041143,
-0.0207691714,
0.0220995452,
-0.0140178613,
-0.0065901889,
0.0139738647,
0.013311645,
-0.0067154593,
0.0490796641,
-0.0130028566,
0.0232222229,
-0.1046330035,
-0.0086535932,
0.0134497797,
0.024190763,
-0.0562270693,
0.0444986187,
0.1053192541,
0.0190862119,
-0.0418726318,
-0.0268142913,
0.0249959659,
-0.0060967519,
0.0397960544,
0.0285193436,
-0.1007914022,
0.0165394433,
0.0071157161,
0.0058022845,
-0.0374074467,
-0.0700981617,
-0.013734987,
-0.0775694624,
0.0728175491,
-0.003059716,
-0.0224080198,
-0.0234609023,
-0.0395179056,
0.0052622152,
-0.0333819762,
-0.0345137864,
-0.0099793002,
-0.0135796983,
-0.0083010606,
0.0211615767,
-0.0535134599,
0.0174418557,
0.0360112637,
-0.0791899338,
0.0577449612,
0.0391593464,
0.017134184,
-0.0388271585,
-0.026101565,
0.001194276,
-0.0470551848,
0.0021297808,
-0.0099987471,
0.0547877625,
-0.00700814,
0.024984695,
-0.0646985248,
0.0344917588,
-0.0111937132,
-0.0268848948,
0.074527815,
0.0548369959,
-0.02945292,
-0.0187781136,
-0.0064461166,
-0.0086767403,
-0.0144754881,
0.0665775239,
0.0000994109,
0.0184417851,
-0.0493611842,
-0.0154832238,
0.0107037202,
-0.047782205,
0.014379859,
-0.048411198,
-0.0209779814,
-0.0293004252,
-0.0227488801,
-0.0512007587,
0.0331627168,
0.0677906573,
0.0250574406,
0.0074212695,
0.0088314181,
0.0103934109,
-0.069656238,
0.0170714501,
-0.0217108037,
0.0083809802,
-0.0190618448,
-0.0045786384,
-0.007481786,
0.0440929867,
-0.0244553816,
0.0046453923,
-0.0317876674,
-0.0091882423,
0.0039799935,
0.0187829603,
0.0189324021,
0.0053779813,
-0.0395746194,
-0.024246024,
0.0452434421,
-0.0013327717,
-0.0072342553,
-0.0204070173,
0.0534759089,
-0.0107891466,
-0.0359928235,
-0.0127163334,
0.0121391593,
0.0370136127,
0.0213038456,
0.0197598208,
0.005864996,
-0.0309936404,
0.0083829286,
0.0693737417,
0.0380740166,
-0.0296038706,
-0.0254283268,
-0.0179948043,
0.0018096043,
-0.0085933916,
0.0142041156,
-0.0051695453,
0.005316644,
0.0052698422,
0.0105831036,
-0.0371996649,
0.1109284833,
-0.0342672281,
-0.0012605409,
-0.0590777248,
0.0636272654,
0.0423904546,
0.0395160951,
-0.0054266653,
-0.0384263508,
0.017333094,
0.0247477293,
0.0141880699,
0.0639126152,
-0.0234374963,
0.0373857766,
0.0110667543,
0.0166239589,
-0.0019570603,
0.0094760275,
-0.0130698308,
0.0403367095,
-0.0343430564,
0.063156575,
0.0515747853,
-0.0071879188,
0.0221370365,
-0.0320298187,
-0.0005266094,
0.0078331009,
0.0250346046,
-0.015071989,
-0.0196472164,
0.0044173365,
0.0197822154,
-0.0075197867,
0.0344825648,
0.0207364578,
-0.0404299088,
0.0079295458,
0.0457817316,
-0.0267945249,
-0.0130700395,
-0.0157108363,
-0.0238691475,
0.0107031791,
-0.0389227495,
-0.0601191856,
-0.0758576021,
-0.022610845,
0.0141682774,
-0.003395973,
-0.0096018761,
0.0263060015,
0.0029614312,
0.0365343653,
0.0343888402,
-0.0150352446,
-0.0512342416,
0.0230356101,
-0.0164692178,
-0.0372941606,
0.0081025036,
-5.859217429e-33,
-0.0409477651,
-0.0804620087,
-0.0036465127,
0.0110164965,
-0.0270094108,
-0.0075432099,
-0.0401720218,
-0.0065010688,
0.0199698247,
0.0327861346,
-0.0045292601,
-0.0043515591,
0.0361033268,
-0.0201638229,
0.0358025171,
-0.0247703753,
-0.0025359099,
0.0024026001,
-0.0187637974,
0.0118682068,
-0.0311404169,
0.0436745174,
0.0461605638,
-0.1320465803,
0.0789721012,
0.0508194007,
-0.0474928208,
-0.0353179015,
-0.0045637651,
0.0499036759,
-0.0087506464,
0.0008333919,
0.02478127,
-0.0873227045,
0.0098837782,
0.0331518613,
-0.1137315482,
0.012234767,
-0.0006691553,
0.007006479,
-0.0062136236,
-0.0186546519,
0.008682414,
-0.0105163474,
-0.0173371583,
0.0003139649,
0.0512114502,
-0.0367883109,
-0.010518834,
-0.0590954088,
-0.0740198568,
0.0715421066,
-0.0190211758,
0.0168010704,
0.0596805513,
0.0058535519,
0.0289952587,
0.0173771288,
-0.081612125,
0.0102244867,
-0.0257837791,
-0.0093712965,
0.049990207,
-0.0653490126,
-0.0334142372,
0.0286788531,
0.0019747745,
-0.0024626194,
-0.0743462294,
-0.0244992189,
0.0250652619,
0.0686733723,
0.0495143272,
0.0384859815,
0.0389041491,
-0.0233390592,
-0.0597115755,
0.018524101,
0.069030188,
0.0232847203,
-0.0113041224,
-0.0819141716,
-0.0545375906,
0.0063761473,
-0.0287598427,
-0.0644125938,
-0.0061463495,
-0.017989859,
0.0147436317,
-0.0023756367,
0.0333794765,
-0.0055174399,
-0.0171710011,
-0.0409487598,
-0.005844391,
0.0376546495,
0.0162840616,
0.0240837559,
-0.017842019,
0.0293899607,
-0.0451805666,
-0.0225221701,
0.0036992049,
0.0168482997,
0.0097116213,
-0.0487259105,
0.0314044543,
-0.027983861,
-0.0672412142,
-0.0092637166,
0.0063429954,
0.0317445695,
0.0316004381,
0.0518753864,
-0.0030343402,
0.0115819359,
0.0343118124,
0.0001543803,
0.028659381,
-0.0071780626,
-0.0074935113,
0.0202756319,
0.0344665386,
0.0103107644,
0.0147810094,
0.0070507773,
0.0094855893,
0.0034491217,
0.01079378,
0.0307141468,
0.0212652367,
0.0420756452,
2.681e-7,
0.0721507296,
0.0433565266,
0.0010514609,
-0.0375892371,
-0.0251237117,
0.0077181682,
0.0138888247,
0.0428384468,
-0.002308296,
-0.0153508317,
0.0334743597,
-0.0193556305,
0.0567189641,
0.0422384813,
-0.0912899598,
-0.0754916668,
-0.0445088707,
-0.0386450067,
-0.0640547276,
0.0805591568,
0.0361383036,
0.069548957,
0.0153147066,
-0.0038623053,
-0.0228614453,
0.0210297015,
0.0140380803,
-0.0062936624,
0.0046997094,
-0.0188943967,
0.0734926686,
-0.0662268773,
-0.0175365955,
0.055934485,
-0.0154329455,
0.0410011634,
-0.039495457,
0.0584008098,
0.0108595937,
0.0408533327,
-0.01983371,
-0.0272542275,
0.0249321237,
-0.0334463529,
0.0566535257,
0.0158384666,
-0.0220830794,
-0.0003382028,
-0.0533388779,
-0.034640789,
0.0155495461,
0.0409836397,
-0.0098793423,
-0.0009120611,
0.0347403064,
-0.0462847613,
0.0037862984,
-0.0945579559,
0.0255194455,
0.0598836541,
0.0135757327,
0.0022251687,
-0.0073028319,
-0.0449953824,
0.0778185427,
-0.080275692,
0.000737079,
2.138806691e-34,
0.0055149621,
0.0003416214,
-0.0016289823,
0.0388968661,
0.0189947672,
0.0232521072,
-0.045855388,
0.0088727623,
-0.0141447866,
-0.0535767935,
0.0450484045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11035v1 | Lyricist-Singer Entropy Affects Lyric-Lyricist Classification Performance | 2023-10-17T07:02:26 | 2023-10-17T07:02:26 | Mitsuki Morita, Masato Kikuchi, Tadachika Ozono | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Although lyrics represent an essential component of music, few music
information processing studies have been conducted on the characteristics of
lyricists. Because these characteristics may be valuable for musical
applications, such as recommendations, they warrant further study. We
considered a potential method that extracts features representing the
characteristics of lyricists from lyrics. Because these features must be
identified prior to extraction, we focused on lyricists with easily
identifiable features. We believe that it is desirable for singers to perform
unique songs that share certain characteristics specific to the singer.
Accordingly, we hypothesized that lyricists account for the unique
characteristics of the singers they write lyrics for. In other words,
lyric-lyricist classification performance or the ease of capturing the features
of a lyricist from the lyrics may depend on the variety of singers. In this
study, we observed a relationship between lyricist-singer entropy or the
variety of singers associated with a single lyricist and lyric-lyricist
classification performance. As an example, the lyricist-singer entropy is
minimal when the lyricist writes lyrics for only one singer. In our
experiments, we grouped lyricists among five groups in terms of lyricist-singer
entropy and assessed the lyric-lyricist classification performance within each
group. Consequently, the best F1 score was obtained for the group with the
lowest lyricist-singer entropy. Our results suggest that further analyses of
the features contributing to lyric-lyricist classification performance on the
lowest lyricist-singer entropy group may improve the feature extraction task
for lyricists. | [
0.0458398946,
0.0600543357,
-0.0160825253,
0.0042468137,
-0.0456486009,
-0.0074091027,
0.0421838425,
0.0062146392,
-0.0674562678,
-0.0083446931,
-0.0336510614,
-0.0076694679,
0.0261791348,
-0.0482250638,
-0.0031030308,
-0.0658023953,
-0.0154508417,
0.0143268146,
0.0718737319,
-0.0184786618,
-0.0592941269,
0.0019104545,
-0.0086331768,
0.0508127846,
-0.024407478,
-0.0123094004,
0.0186532009,
0.0158176962,
0.0025288486,
0.0453095026,
-0.079503797,
0.0827907696,
-0.0362421796,
-0.0057516671,
0.0000013814,
-0.0422823317,
-0.014776364,
-0.0211413614,
0.0371530727,
-0.049933061,
0.0116422726,
0.0464814268,
-0.0166458767,
0.0053734309,
0.0134176938,
-0.0277947858,
0.0424084924,
0.0596012585,
0.0270287655,
0.0491639227,
0.0325957239,
-0.0723087043,
0.057717476,
-0.0139259491,
0.0531520881,
0.0023362366,
0.0009135244,
-0.0384759828,
-0.0050533768,
-0.0657066628,
-0.0257613976,
0.0726905763,
-0.0297521465,
0.0436876528,
0.0716425255,
0.0478851311,
-0.0499831922,
-0.0202479586,
0.0332496464,
-0.0382431224,
0.0547063351,
0.0058872802,
0.0274677761,
0.036126174,
0.0131185912,
0.0143641671,
0.0125922319,
-0.008630991,
-0.0097506391,
-0.0390033051,
-0.0351144075,
0.0278558824,
0.0069101737,
-0.0198107027,
-0.0077821775,
-0.0227496568,
-0.0004796225,
-0.0625136048,
0.0490602106,
-0.0065130689,
0.0325189978,
-0.0628417358,
-0.0084317261,
-0.0122868977,
0.0183065142,
-0.0221725795,
-0.0142108956,
-0.0411485471,
-0.0057103927,
-0.037654724,
0.0693242773,
-0.0367071591,
0.0123452749,
0.0293107107,
0.017603375,
0.0022625946,
-0.0012418698,
0.0306809694,
-0.0175687689,
0.0220877454,
-0.0603083745,
-0.0330645293,
-0.0120362947,
0.019394381,
0.0956768617,
-0.0108198617,
-0.0429248065,
-0.0128313191,
-0.0299195088,
0.0079966644,
-0.0220274962,
-0.0056313081,
0.0099693416,
0.0256972034,
-0.0129632391,
-0.0069330959,
0.0004662733,
-0.0044751121,
-0.0182394776,
0.0324445888,
0.0490585268,
0.0163844246,
0.0397758745,
0.0076888097,
0.0908354446,
0.0317282453,
0.0771506131,
-0.0856764466,
-0.016048409,
-0.0131777814,
-0.0367833413,
-0.0684776455,
-0.0321937576,
-0.0756446645,
0.0232845973,
0.0214841142,
-0.0221561193,
-0.0738514736,
-0.0374194123,
0.0075408234,
-0.0089047533,
0.0125520071,
0.0210421197,
0.0489081703,
0.0194415562,
-0.0031995436,
-0.0088912658,
-0.0106966356,
0.0658274069,
0.0118248425,
0.0104436679,
-0.0160438232,
0.0257837381,
0.002397093,
-0.0494771041,
-0.0076735602,
-0.0412443057,
-0.0287976786,
-0.0120051736,
0.0679358467,
0.0362495445,
0.0212663431,
0.0236767363,
-0.0224595293,
0.0435537286,
0.066343978,
0.086549513,
0.1104136556,
0.0233288351,
0.0354240462,
0.0479911268,
0.0342259444,
0.0003618322,
0.0443708561,
0.0415491574,
0.0141321672,
0.0997245982,
0.0001230385,
0.0069163814,
-0.0077619017,
-0.0337706357,
0.0004218304,
-0.0349630192,
-0.0027293407,
-0.0049738763,
-0.0057454379,
0.0150723634,
0.0196709428,
0.0272577275,
-0.0668463334,
-0.0314187817,
0.0046692728,
0.0018917824,
0.0988306552,
0.0350115635,
-0.0101880059,
0.0911941975,
-0.0185366254,
-0.0582009442,
-0.0189352706,
-0.0550489128,
-0.0009456172,
0.0194563437,
0.0256775338,
0.0169890467,
0.0105589991,
0.0080983378,
-0.0014406557,
-0.0452878438,
0.0242314432,
0.0053045037,
0.0393152498,
-0.0007545547,
0.0000287334,
0.0221230201,
-0.0241445377,
0.0133823799,
0.0571704134,
0.0324961878,
0.0485731848,
-0.0726718009,
0.0087901093,
-0.0133410562,
0.0037973186,
-0.0320485868,
0.0133948755,
-0.0182916429,
-0.0175046958,
0.0126655856,
-0.0042927549,
0.0108041903,
-0.0130954012,
0.0407989211,
-0.0163984913,
0.0596501529,
-0.0098644905,
0.0281310026,
-0.0116629573,
0.0386274718,
-0.035575591,
-0.0199833792,
0.0149807353,
0.0126791736,
0.0519369319,
0.0549076311,
-0.0799589828,
-0.0390286036,
0.0467147157,
-0.0344794281,
-0.0074446215,
0.0349275135,
0.0134095941,
0.0217243358,
-0.0404069871,
-0.0480453819,
-0.0043348791,
-0.0717933625,
-0.0444148146,
0.0132974507,
-0.0201415792,
-0.034822654,
-0.0176684875,
-0.0268035997,
-0.0320162438,
0.0198476985,
0.0027974737,
-0.0276710074,
-0.0240293071,
0.0064835763,
-0.0147540541,
-0.0049422043,
-0.0681878328,
0.0093734423,
-0.0012530701,
-0.0344952047,
0.0103164455,
-0.017658418,
0.0025998272,
0.0416829772,
0.0159945861,
-0.0726409554,
-0.0377062298,
0.0197959505,
0.0029348959,
-0.0145754376,
-0.0614884384,
0.0191113129,
0.0028198909,
0.0118410634,
0.0155306701,
0.0838546529,
-0.0041214796,
0.0576757751,
-0.0063656666,
0.0114209317,
0.0610475987,
0.0127246249,
-0.0292291455,
0.0066068126,
-0.0155015523,
0.0720027536,
0.0034765375,
0.0160022397,
0.0350632854,
-0.0281512588,
0.0303561296,
-0.0096447105,
0.0554381199,
-0.0439138971,
0.0463002399,
-0.0003113133,
-0.0078922799,
0.0572312027,
-0.0198784079,
0.0082360087,
-0.0156418998,
-0.0436279364,
-0.0455131195,
0.0227660779,
-0.0425598808,
0.0380931683,
0.0292546656,
-0.0458961241,
-0.0243569817,
0.00606337,
0.0306086484,
-0.0407210365,
0.0264311526,
0.0379205607,
-0.0240574107,
-0.0073913587,
-0.0146920839,
0.0205390789,
-0.0651660785,
0.0132655986,
0.0016892338,
-0.0204842817,
-0.0710481927,
0.0282810424,
-0.0212610401,
0.0368080288,
-0.0005658171,
0.0054458664,
-0.0146396281,
-0.0089640329,
0.0152371144,
0.0022899252,
-0.0145409442,
-0.0531348176,
-0.018184429,
0.0061810408,
-0.0377925821,
-0.0072756754,
0.0282614995,
-0.0031861665,
-0.018559251,
-0.0008549966,
-0.020368889,
-0.0041860892,
0.0382352993,
-0.0176396184,
-0.0289555602,
0.0354360901,
0.0903690383,
0.0246905778,
-0.012163803,
-0.0243737008,
0.0223990791,
0.0170016456,
0.0081906309,
-0.008206455,
0.0182274822,
0.009913357,
0.0205207895,
0.0385568552,
-0.0104615027,
0.0156984162,
-0.0404938757,
0.003211075,
0.0244193356,
0.002807149,
-0.0619836114,
-0.024890516,
-0.0504768118,
-0.0303237308,
0.0051832367,
-0.0530071892,
-0.0121592348,
-0.030301366,
0.022189552,
-0.0083465585,
-0.0447603203,
-0.0134661831,
0.0097537572,
-0.0657106414,
0.0159260128,
0.0537005886,
0.0417822115,
-0.0318730325,
-0.0126445917,
-0.108344689,
-0.0310796797,
0.0160522088,
0.0169333685,
0.0689137354,
0.0121079674,
0.0140541429,
-0.0266320445,
-0.0118011124,
-0.0131123895,
0.0320964977,
0.00062524,
0.0362329669,
-0.0226260331,
-0.0283030719,
0.0210467037,
0.0712777674,
0.0054179817,
0.0755791664,
0.0842532143,
-0.0270817876,
-0.0129884342,
0.0210977849,
0.0177482162,
-0.0374656171,
-0.0289849676,
-0.03181348,
-0.0070435526,
-0.0829060674,
-0.0209160242,
-0.0351003259,
-0.0299140923,
0.0252531637,
0.0044826721,
0.0498774834,
-0.0527447276,
-0.037196707,
-0.0598183684,
-0.0168294571,
0.0165729597,
0.0342691801,
-0.038709268,
-0.0847056434,
0.0384560563,
0.0085893264,
-0.0262848455,
-0.0320844874,
-0.0879786015,
-0.0429429188,
0.0408336185,
-0.0406739302,
0.0152734071,
0.0089154476,
0.0157418698,
-0.0469204821,
0.0322816186,
0.0278768409,
0.0334151872,
0.0381021574,
0.0436633341,
-0.0110223191,
-0.0153764933,
-0.0074069882,
-0.0255984291,
0.0479808189,
0.0279881395,
-0.0302786771,
0.0152920233,
-0.0768094435,
0.0055974,
0.0071932571,
0.0049753785,
-0.0147403013,
-0.0128418282,
-0.0064197443,
-0.026934512,
-0.0003984755,
0.0120058758,
0.0082447827,
-0.0346188173,
0.0628361106,
0.0205581486,
-0.0416478626,
-0.024281688,
-0.0140567869,
-0.0194681883,
-0.0308540259,
-0.0105360951,
0.0303513799,
-0.0481849499,
0.004670436,
0.0100194877,
-0.008257539,
-0.0217984859,
0.0779928118,
0.0013142986,
0.0351718254,
-0.0077212774,
0.0161704458,
-0.0221096128,
-0.0505670235,
0.0337775908,
-0.0520350523,
-0.0343789011,
0.0228238422,
0.0084545696,
0.0491858572,
0.0210088436,
-0.0128473863,
-0.0048529794,
0.0129210949,
0.0064039831,
0.0330885686,
-0.0260936059,
-0.0094289668,
-0.0224946644,
0.0104771946,
0.0026408697,
-0.0336578973,
0.0364290774,
-0.0078784795,
-0.0125458175,
-0.0526911467,
-0.0258073788,
0.0176553931,
0.0167008806,
-0.0624490902,
-0.0104379188,
0.0245690197,
0.0351548307,
-0.0657568723,
-0.0272212718,
0.0826750249,
-0.0172802657,
0.0377740711,
-0.0109230001,
0.006742985,
0.0186824203,
0.0072437478,
0.0000513162,
-0.0193804596,
-0.0528915934,
-0.0195417218,
0.0072764503,
0.0226798952,
-5.077307974e-33,
-0.0201185662,
-0.0026713535,
-0.0229715202,
0.0585537553,
-0.0320464894,
-0.0591991469,
-0.0401975811,
0.0241102856,
0.0020130738,
-0.0174922217,
-0.011485721,
-0.0055953488,
0.0047462485,
-0.024470279,
0.0449826829,
-0.0115027437,
0.0503130443,
0.0160511602,
-0.0432104841,
0.0495333374,
0.094523631,
0.0302127432,
-0.0181683842,
-0.0748074725,
-0.0069883452,
-0.036959976,
0.0380445048,
0.0019709955,
0.0314004235,
-0.0025913902,
-0.0092966631,
0.0286438596,
0.0346650593,
-0.0219280645,
-0.0089519806,
-0.0187541842,
-0.0291604642,
-0.0650005415,
-0.0334128588,
0.0219533257,
0.0692706704,
-0.0460142307,
0.044199653,
-0.0051599639,
-0.029091429,
-0.0405254923,
0.0773135051,
-0.0116508873,
-0.0232988037,
-0.079330191,
-0.0267808922,
0.0035750901,
-0.0209772587,
-0.0177276861,
0.0368270092,
-0.0060519339,
0.0078769401,
-0.0003883,
0.0056635789,
0.0029696212,
-0.0498024188,
0.0338648595,
0.0036333043,
0.0371358544,
-0.0044704163,
0.046531409,
0.0344642401,
-0.0463197678,
-0.0213553477,
0.0475426428,
-0.0067910203,
0.0601847209,
0.0044824574,
0.0139970928,
0.0543700866,
-0.0530713089,
0.023679167,
0.0418264195,
-0.0057292576,
-0.05932118,
-0.0051066913,
0.026125811,
-0.0526743867,
-0.0387044735,
0.0230463631,
-0.0573981069,
-0.0297494326,
-0.0450177118,
0.0111064203,
-0.0518773124,
0.0075479192,
0.0216992125,
0.0001326472,
-0.0111814747,
-0.0088422969,
0.0218651555,
-0.0721717551,
0.0511574596,
-0.0028289228,
-0.0169190131,
-0.0250163823,
-0.0375347696,
0.0757533759,
0.0421490818,
0.0479114912,
-0.0021707441,
0.066737622,
0.0439545065,
-0.0736679062,
-0.01082261,
0.0080603929,
-0.0140640838,
0.0256282557,
-0.0309769809,
0.0346942469,
0.043062415,
0.0239971485,
-0.0130889593,
0.0582649298,
0.0282015111,
-0.0150463516,
0.0374318808,
-0.0124005061,
-0.0166021138,
0.0299711563,
-0.009077725,
-0.0147062559,
-0.0707937703,
0.0192966927,
0.012371568,
-0.022605747,
-0.0554481149,
2.338e-7,
0.0285957754,
-0.03537222,
0.0299320593,
-0.0325020738,
0.0192003176,
0.0416517928,
-0.0805274099,
-0.008451202,
0.007777086,
0.0225757211,
0.0551278964,
-0.02781724,
0.0935590416,
0.053937275,
-0.0979920328,
0.005947635,
-0.07727658,
0.0043882299,
-0.0961353034,
0.0197518207,
0.0728066787,
0.0219081715,
0.0346054472,
-0.0368275419,
0.0043801023,
-0.0374708176,
0.0090900753,
-0.0315364078,
0.0429414921,
-0.0206654724,
0.0404972211,
-0.0412166379,
0.0121595273,
0.0270075575,
-0.0322406814,
0.0577981658,
0.0158793442,
0.0168320257,
0.0189958848,
-0.0146487048,
0.0191395059,
0.0507195741,
-0.0150885945,
0.0214869641,
0.0434917063,
0.0555227436,
-0.080976747,
0.0006990723,
-0.0091646444,
0.0015174813,
0.016964281,
0.0306858178,
-0.018161701,
-0.0356351994,
-0.0079738284,
-0.0488261208,
0.0471097119,
-0.0577646345,
0.0160864294,
0.0466529392,
-0.0454698578,
-0.0074063367,
0.0263628121,
-0.0034840438,
0.0354450606,
-0.0598257966,
0.0066892891,
1.859125475e-34,
0.0405232422,
0.0124940975,
0.0034940476,
-0.010710855,
0.0068851458,
-0.0024076728,
-0.0255148467,
-0.0278769284,
-0.0469166785,
-0.0215374641,
-0.0025177696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11026v1 | Exploring Automatic Evaluation Methods based on a Decoder-based LLM for Text Generation | 2023-10-17T06:53:00 | 2023-10-17T06:53:00 | Tomohito Kasahara, Daisuke Kawahara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic evaluation of text generation is essential for improving the
accuracy of generation tasks. In light of the current trend towards
increasingly larger decoder-based language models, we investigate automatic
evaluation methods based on such models for text generation. This paper
compares various methods, including tuning with encoder-based models and large
language models under equal conditions, on two different tasks, machine
translation evaluation and semantic textual similarity, in two languages,
Japanese and English. Experimental results show that compared to the tuned
encoder-based models, the tuned decoder-based models perform poorly. The
analysis of the causes for this suggests that the decoder-based models focus on
surface word sequences and do not capture meaning. It is also revealed that
in-context learning of very large decoder-based models such as ChatGPT makes it
difficult to identify fine-grained semantic differences. | [
0.0148187159,
0.0288488492,
0.0086642448,
0.067964673,
-0.0454263613,
0.0153574832,
0.0091225272,
0.0332574323,
-0.039450068,
-0.0450219475,
-0.0229738448,
-0.0538774058,
0.0285682511,
0.004925326,
0.0102995569,
-0.0330314636,
-0.0102863489,
0.0048091579,
-0.016288273,
0.0077733882,
0.0171320159,
0.0038193518,
0.0170698855,
0.0429306291,
0.0103190821,
0.0116557674,
-0.006949388,
0.0188187324,
0.0431188494,
-0.0269319247,
0.0005691983,
0.0199583918,
0.0062156157,
0.0015103889,
0.0000018437,
-0.0420360267,
-0.0102758091,
-0.0286116395,
0.0403879136,
0.0217645727,
0.0708757862,
-0.0395383909,
-0.0000776214,
0.0277399737,
-0.0097196028,
0.0075612683,
0.030156998,
0.0010305583,
0.04874878,
0.0588191673,
-0.0026697328,
-0.0372246467,
0.0128938258,
-0.0016713017,
0.0161194243,
-0.0242341869,
-0.0275167339,
0.0308105126,
-0.0153556122,
-0.0038892343,
-0.0095084226,
0.0080247987,
0.0110301329,
0.0170622859,
0.0106590791,
0.0413360074,
0.0175918005,
-0.006574559,
-0.0188411921,
0.0362590849,
-0.0295451507,
-0.0479124747,
0.0087119881,
-0.0303438026,
-0.0309934001,
-0.0030637379,
-0.0253622644,
0.0696933046,
-0.0453146994,
0.0434362367,
0.0672496408,
0.0347882025,
0.0060675801,
0.0184713472,
-0.0149487136,
0.0197797883,
0.0478619859,
-0.0386428609,
-0.041742485,
0.0321936049,
0.0006444968,
-0.0518152826,
0.0119180223,
0.0576420501,
-0.0276055858,
0.0041144988,
-0.081408605,
-0.0164460577,
0.0004904036,
-0.0452118777,
0.0431293547,
0.0697779208,
0.0216809697,
-0.0322800167,
-0.0355998203,
0.096627079,
0.0148358541,
0.0027167955,
-0.0823105201,
0.0114744911,
-0.0403887816,
-0.0237658154,
-0.0494750254,
0.0390233658,
-0.0477254465,
-0.0318698771,
-0.0544396155,
0.035213951,
0.0343939438,
-0.0147956954,
0.0323542915,
-0.0303349085,
-0.0370383896,
0.0261573102,
-0.0184983369,
-0.0229265746,
-0.0138935596,
-0.0090154558,
0.0180296935,
-0.0292996485,
0.0051962314,
0.0469871424,
0.016620025,
-0.0064404216,
-0.0125024794,
0.0625859722,
-0.0297126938,
-0.0360793211,
-0.019846769,
-0.0431720428,
-0.0137248514,
-0.0493727438,
-0.0153437639,
-0.0671917647,
0.0199584644,
0.0134534407,
-0.006197799,
-0.0379641205,
0.0092245582,
0.0226265285,
0.0295398347,
0.0062428485,
-0.000102318,
0.0250853729,
0.0378027894,
-0.0025188271,
0.0173113681,
0.0506205186,
0.0529124513,
0.04873522,
0.0186118167,
0.0262957029,
0.0088446978,
0.0510877371,
-0.0109081734,
-0.0116018075,
-0.0416631065,
-0.0207737051,
-0.0037510046,
0.0539583378,
0.0456730947,
0.06587971,
-0.0534595177,
0.0455053598,
0.0406667814,
0.0206434187,
0.0478826277,
0.0526865907,
0.0998103544,
0.0168197565,
-0.0089905998,
0.0676263496,
0.0312912464,
0.0235364456,
-0.0358748883,
0.0390233658,
0.0546630286,
0.0312299151,
-0.0330113545,
-0.0591269322,
-0.0239574034,
-0.0201068651,
-0.0030446667,
-0.0499027558,
0.0038371992,
0.0273896959,
-0.0846360922,
0.0377342515,
0.0075754053,
-0.0785683915,
0.0318551213,
-0.0435741544,
0.0091516357,
0.1008718684,
0.0681839511,
0.0502958894,
-0.0067483135,
0.0363715887,
-0.0257369597,
0.0847361907,
0.0226228628,
0.0044863215,
-0.0372725278,
-0.0818640366,
-0.0279935524,
-0.015546767,
0.0014084808,
0.0197678618,
-0.0067017782,
0.0433452986,
0.0798408538,
-0.0369806401,
-0.0428141616,
0.0505647771,
-0.040584214,
-0.0083471043,
0.0011087444,
-0.0062902248,
0.0171230808,
-0.0088069625,
-0.0061026388,
0.0372495912,
-0.0115341786,
-0.0663660541,
-0.0198790859,
0.0289307665,
-0.0476271622,
-0.0967012942,
0.0026447331,
-0.0352489315,
0.0451422781,
0.0072087818,
-0.0196257159,
-0.0458398908,
-0.0137064047,
-0.0519111305,
0.025172893,
-0.0663037151,
0.0661316663,
-0.020091055,
-0.0181106944,
-0.0373463072,
0.079318963,
-0.0145285297,
0.0039622202,
0.0191944409,
0.0473656878,
0.0137515478,
-0.0468957722,
-0.0298086777,
0.0181157347,
0.0237827878,
0.0107947001,
0.0253578871,
0.0540967919,
-0.0053841867,
-0.0745901614,
-0.0682154894,
0.0269475915,
-0.0273493696,
0.0381189324,
0.062618807,
0.0095133511,
0.0111735491,
0.0385934897,
-0.0402106345,
0.0174427591,
0.0475333072,
-0.0021234795,
0.0589903854,
-0.0245270859,
-0.0179505553,
-0.0258660335,
0.0058571259,
0.0372610949,
0.0359068289,
0.0430359021,
-0.0226347074,
-0.0964116901,
0.076890856,
-0.0425438657,
-0.0384852067,
0.0079436526,
-0.0651338547,
0.0188480075,
0.0084976144,
0.0630128905,
0.0123928087,
0.057044629,
0.0598747917,
0.0248014107,
0.0216568168,
-0.0448111333,
-0.0369506739,
-0.0356799029,
-0.0329679251,
-0.0102393078,
-0.0620255135,
0.0425647572,
0.0617793612,
0.0511797518,
0.0197153483,
-0.0693340376,
0.0166942589,
-0.0325799175,
-0.0247940272,
-0.0244715102,
-0.0131540643,
-0.0297781043,
0.0380742252,
-0.0179777462,
-0.0566045046,
0.0571656935,
-0.0519282408,
0.0176992584,
-0.0371360518,
0.0154253813,
-0.0649537221,
0.0403523892,
-0.0032827416,
0.0466249809,
-0.0325588137,
-0.012910068,
-0.025904147,
0.0251177158,
0.0288268514,
-0.0374226235,
0.028837923,
-0.0585940257,
0.0035220184,
0.0053043752,
0.00314365,
-0.0499387085,
-0.011703724,
-0.0032479146,
-0.0098384814,
0.0322350264,
0.022012474,
0.0109827556,
0.0671031997,
-0.0186922718,
0.0047983732,
-0.0171608087,
0.0043351813,
-0.0271963328,
0.0359504484,
0.0289967265,
-0.0212304946,
-0.0225585178,
-0.0493371338,
0.0403156392,
0.0031143932,
-0.0282050762,
0.0342788957,
-0.0298115574,
0.0129321422,
0.0166344866,
-0.0350178294,
-0.0228637233,
0.0316122696,
0.0625871867,
-0.040953856,
-0.0523110554,
0.1219447032,
0.0312460102,
-0.003873226,
0.0111079877,
-0.0081899548,
0.0339693911,
-0.0182787385,
-0.0125947436,
-0.0529752746,
-0.0300609991,
-0.009148648,
0.0336051621,
-0.0203184225,
0.0143467477,
-0.0097422274,
-0.1235393137,
0.019902749,
0.040523123,
-0.0485820882,
-0.0346997567,
0.0000489851,
-0.0522907712,
-0.0012578474,
0.0293859541,
0.0266283285,
-0.0272835288,
0.0244896729,
0.0104191769,
-0.0245635435,
-0.0721728057,
-0.041219186,
-0.0411177091,
0.0039356579,
0.0629649088,
0.0253328029,
0.0139447236,
-0.0277867727,
0.0377979279,
-0.0268724188,
0.0250835009,
-0.0364100896,
0.0037916955,
-0.0012715992,
0.0147656715,
-0.0175986383,
0.0025121775,
0.0004191961,
0.0120042218,
0.0047263885,
0.0086124102,
-0.0379041731,
-0.0361409895,
0.0116345566,
0.003485922,
0.0118443184,
0.0689573139,
0.0599981435,
-0.0358196422,
-0.0529531315,
-0.0147909988,
0.0041060071,
-0.0814689323,
-0.0075549087,
0.0062728073,
-0.0219291616,
-0.0077840695,
-0.1189920753,
-0.0403444953,
-0.0270062704,
-0.0043775905,
0.0037867418,
0.0261880662,
-0.0037896556,
-0.0447240062,
-0.0334313586,
-0.0299615003,
0.003539152,
0.0022666282,
-0.0506130122,
-0.0165599138,
0.0353148989,
-0.0499265939,
0.0146711487,
0.0243473016,
-0.0874334872,
-0.041812107,
-0.0575587787,
0.0293545071,
0.0134297982,
0.0328855515,
0.0092259459,
-0.0196938273,
0.0134137869,
0.0185045246,
0.010463072,
0.047801163,
-0.0060175406,
0.0423268937,
-0.0098680202,
0.0074696601,
-0.0171179753,
0.0189377796,
0.0038575914,
0.0588930324,
0.0093754167,
-0.0528668053,
0.0413340963,
0.051551722,
-0.0252077021,
-0.0646690503,
-0.0189678259,
-0.020767739,
-0.0081999144,
-0.017599728,
-0.011348105,
-0.0718348101,
-0.0051781517,
0.026230922,
0.0090150209,
-0.0092877029,
-0.0083190687,
-0.0480381437,
0.0348056592,
-0.0316961519,
0.0368375704,
-0.044743862,
0.0330037475,
0.014063973,
-0.009579286,
-0.0427999757,
-0.0207644701,
-0.0093669174,
0.0120985238,
-0.0194358639,
0.0506534055,
0.0192319974,
0.0309011657,
0.0217224211,
0.0560422614,
-0.0009933856,
-0.0034081901,
-0.0659227818,
0.0160327591,
0.0723641515,
0.0282087103,
0.0723813921,
-0.0336088277,
0.0197435729,
-0.0105149774,
0.0722814202,
0.0033696669,
-0.0358752944,
0.0329162218,
-0.0172501914,
-0.0133774849,
-0.0496141128,
0.0900665522,
0.0201371349,
0.0157083049,
0.0022590768,
-0.0032173106,
-0.0528830066,
-0.0135015436,
0.0059451591,
-0.016847048,
0.0084681781,
-0.020380836,
-0.0268624648,
-0.0177900754,
0.0042453031,
0.0277388599,
0.0312927328,
-0.0003127557,
0.0313989259,
0.0370320156,
-0.051451236,
0.028276233,
-0.0372543298,
-0.005688691,
-0.0356518403,
-0.003519977,
-0.0498926006,
-5.738502241e-33,
-0.0599960387,
-0.0535138473,
0.044311665,
-0.0056590685,
-0.0561663434,
-0.0233402736,
-0.0520419329,
-0.0297281351,
0.0516426153,
-0.0174674802,
0.0295795649,
-0.0462169684,
0.0068980367,
0.0309858993,
-0.0054818015,
-0.0140897613,
0.0527811348,
0.0088393167,
-0.0534077175,
0.0075900359,
0.019477291,
0.0057261889,
0.0164259411,
0.0206852723,
-0.0015479811,
-0.0673306361,
-0.0188187119,
-0.0042350544,
0.0273703281,
0.0420367345,
-0.0170695856,
0.0311120842,
0.0348480828,
-0.0084017329,
-0.0541065149,
-0.0088797472,
-0.0224629939,
-0.0253967289,
-0.0012780359,
-0.0016415485,
-0.0044858111,
-0.0640103742,
0.0276619848,
-0.0070051644,
-0.0629071742,
0.0218460299,
0.0202845205,
-0.03297453,
-0.0286875926,
-0.0511083268,
-0.0695072487,
0.0277893227,
0.0094129061,
-0.0214073528,
0.0166810453,
0.0294796601,
-0.0451637469,
0.0107756155,
-0.0251986068,
0.0226506852,
0.0340586305,
0.0289997365,
0.0697702616,
0.0399811454,
-0.0069022141,
0.023807209,
-0.0181501452,
-0.025058344,
-0.0210433062,
0.0204475634,
-0.0101384977,
0.0348969363,
0.0245797019,
0.0464364216,
0.0352041312,
-0.0255717337,
-0.0344156213,
0.078664504,
-0.041898191,
-0.002691803,
0.0520583093,
-0.0012275612,
-0.0082552182,
-0.0182977524,
-0.0462312996,
-0.0079692211,
-0.0274305493,
-0.0408960208,
0.0609530397,
0.0155895762,
-0.0122488178,
-0.0517253801,
0.030765323,
-0.0261093881,
0.0441909321,
0.013284198,
-0.0499017946,
0.0268211756,
-0.0338815227,
0.0086974297,
-0.0214407537,
-0.0882735029,
0.0200747978,
0.0362947956,
0.0064628203,
0.0003821706,
-0.0030467529,
-0.0065212948,
-0.0220456552,
0.0464531891,
-0.0645449609,
-0.0020336034,
-0.005214375,
-0.0002996399,
0.0029821103,
-0.0383355431,
-0.0338187329,
0.0424177162,
-0.0044101952,
-0.0178647786,
-0.0257070307,
-0.0359659977,
0.0182871688,
0.0454997458,
-0.0324798636,
0.0647023395,
-0.0130428104,
0.0207958091,
0.0430986919,
0.0027700369,
-0.0109040467,
0.0205198433,
2.517e-7,
0.0304265656,
0.0291627347,
0.0435792245,
0.0290166028,
-0.0099484511,
-0.0049228771,
-0.0046315501,
0.0307428632,
0.0130241895,
0.0160467234,
0.0284204483,
0.0197254103,
0.0827415138,
-0.0164362192,
-0.0496031828,
0.0487305336,
-0.0721037015,
-0.0028126228,
-0.0470113568,
-0.0057945461,
0.0883605704,
0.0106061418,
-0.0462625995,
-0.0044832253,
0.0032614248,
-0.0138259232,
0.084349215,
-0.0232504066,
-0.0275908969,
0.0271374285,
0.0271544773,
0.0107867932,
-0.0075731333,
0.0123127941,
-0.0231209658,
-0.0061807102,
0.0324222557,
0.056337744,
0.0327276662,
-0.0052040918,
0.0342789665,
-0.0046219015,
-0.0033024794,
-0.0559407882,
0.0536768511,
-0.0343980156,
0.0079526342,
0.0118323313,
-0.0020471183,
0.0101080127,
-0.004499089,
-0.0557028688,
-0.0196674746,
0.0568900518,
0.0387127511,
0.0043193935,
-0.009587883,
0.0083387224,
-0.0420309342,
-0.0131802531,
-0.0410172231,
-0.0456543975,
-0.0520749502,
0.0038914743,
0.0190566555,
-0.0530497767,
-0.0105401911,
2.067550381e-34,
0.0355898663,
-0.0192786306,
0.0053740125,
0.0153991133,
0.0280381702,
0.0160308573,
-0.0001218448,
0.0425666459,
-0.025739897,
-0.0491898321,
0.0068331207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11016v1 | Reading Order Matters: Information Extraction from Visually-rich Documents by Token Path Prediction | 2023-10-17T06:08:55 | 2023-10-17T06:08:55 | Chong Zhang, Ya Guo, Yi Tu, Huan Chen, Jinyang Tang, Huijia Zhu, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in multimodal pre-trained models have significantly improved
information extraction from visually-rich documents (VrDs), in which named
entity recognition (NER) is treated as a sequence-labeling task of predicting
the BIO entity tags for tokens, following the typical setting of NLP. However,
BIO-tagging scheme relies on the correct order of model inputs, which is not
guaranteed in real-world NER on scanned VrDs where text are recognized and
arranged by OCR systems. Such reading order issue hinders the accurate marking
of entities by BIO-tagging scheme, making it impossible for sequence-labeling
methods to predict correct named entities. To address the reading order issue,
we introduce Token Path Prediction (TPP), a simple prediction head to predict
entity mentions as token sequences within documents. Alternative to token
classification, TPP models the document layout as a complete directed graph of
tokens, and predicts token paths within the graph as entities. For better
evaluation of VrD-NER systems, we also propose two revised benchmark datasets
of NER on scanned documents which can reflect real-world scenarios. Experiment
results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, and suggest its potential
to be a universal solution to various information extraction tasks on
documents. | [
0.0417476594,
0.0131942676,
0.0374176055,
0.0169817414,
-0.009476359,
0.0099526178,
-0.0110846991,
0.0330599584,
0.0351543091,
-0.0574422441,
-0.0023129983,
0.0329493359,
0.0150633566,
0.0353508443,
0.0471914709,
-0.0491086915,
0.0196139235,
-0.0410575978,
0.0286770668,
0.0456421599,
0.0183857195,
-0.0005357733,
-0.0276014134,
0.0181189235,
-0.0752053261,
0.0041839294,
-0.0277485754,
0.0410109982,
0.0467961505,
-0.079509981,
-0.0265961401,
0.0186962541,
0.0059433668,
0.0414805077,
0.0000017936,
-0.0260911845,
-0.0583462603,
0.0476110466,
0.021044407,
-0.0362301953,
0.0216122475,
-0.0338489637,
0.0041026413,
-0.0301771462,
0.0280625299,
-0.0411202684,
0.0365144089,
0.0915437117,
0.0191347674,
0.0419918597,
-0.0271023717,
-0.0050400207,
0.0605134219,
0.0180383734,
0.01470026,
-0.0127007635,
0.0180625636,
-0.0347119458,
-0.0068565779,
0.0329853892,
-0.0155893546,
0.0160146859,
-0.0159576312,
0.0032619906,
0.0492160246,
0.0604800768,
-0.0039465204,
-0.0128482776,
-0.0408364758,
0.0842651054,
-0.0278581772,
0.00218057,
0.0389424711,
-0.0234414954,
-0.0450399704,
-0.0271438342,
-0.019552255,
0.0017336855,
-0.0466272607,
0.01180935,
0.0014769252,
0.0088835275,
0.0126828598,
-0.0030492207,
-0.016253585,
0.0380839892,
0.0131866112,
-0.0213632584,
0.0080299554,
0.01055679,
0.0125326989,
-0.0349811278,
0.0568655841,
0.0289318655,
0.0564225428,
0.0069031143,
-0.0380101874,
-0.0715612024,
0.0076420144,
-0.0263533462,
-0.0073833936,
-0.01796606,
-0.0730079561,
0.0535750426,
-0.0484784208,
0.0169090088,
-0.0476327427,
0.0429700874,
0.0134583125,
-0.0061748433,
0.0015839329,
-0.0218297131,
-0.0135611426,
0.0498608239,
-0.0646119639,
-0.0562787279,
-0.0211787969,
-0.0073457384,
0.0232734103,
0.0038695903,
-0.0131528899,
-0.0055361087,
0.0080167828,
0.0053368686,
-0.0008072826,
-0.0109401867,
0.0005177272,
-0.017739404,
-0.0198993683,
-0.0194226373,
0.0103904735,
0.0260157101,
0.0511465147,
-0.0017991862,
0.0042524766,
0.135492757,
0.0196152143,
-0.0840203315,
-0.0108362762,
-0.0333293863,
-0.0250954404,
-0.0042219302,
0.0429898389,
-0.0223904699,
0.0490878485,
0.0387113057,
0.0016348263,
-0.000373405,
0.0156186549,
0.0017849312,
-0.0678048879,
0.074857384,
-0.0355090685,
-0.0238651596,
0.043801941,
-0.0077415397,
0.01213805,
-0.0051183342,
0.0474965461,
0.0601267554,
0.0540477708,
-0.0071571507,
0.0057041948,
0.0482845493,
0.0096554216,
-0.0666311309,
0.0449100621,
0.0054491004,
0.0145527851,
0.0137894452,
0.0418885425,
0.0482944772,
-0.0417859182,
-0.0145970387,
0.0177617744,
0.0696866959,
-0.0293412935,
-0.0435077734,
0.0261743311,
-0.02112245,
0.0130729256,
0.004826284,
-0.0411965512,
-0.0156935062,
0.0060093091,
0.0369081274,
0.0412523709,
0.0082679335,
0.0245281029,
0.0155036394,
-0.0103541324,
-0.011502983,
0.0233800709,
-0.0491574965,
0.0751677379,
-0.0094773648,
-0.1043012962,
0.0183721278,
0.0302553121,
-0.0522849932,
-0.033672411,
0.0167514347,
0.0035335838,
0.0682528615,
0.0659256428,
-0.0381340645,
-0.0530768298,
0.0340378061,
-0.0169621613,
0.0213855375,
-0.0080570159,
-0.0300436094,
0.0253998861,
-0.0279893465,
-0.0416660868,
0.0089246724,
-0.0443529487,
0.0381957144,
0.0196516272,
0.0076164589,
0.0061967252,
-0.0542068742,
-0.0310867671,
0.0700663403,
0.0201834142,
-0.0358866937,
-0.0320303068,
0.0342973992,
0.0184397344,
0.0369591042,
0.0045485026,
0.0026933239,
0.0565496646,
-0.0217149667,
0.0445117913,
-0.0019902871,
-0.0246884525,
-0.0304093771,
0.0047277524,
-0.0032262504,
-0.0369887687,
0.0006004008,
-0.0392257757,
-0.0130782761,
-0.0331725553,
0.0193799939,
0.0284469444,
-0.0198078342,
0.000306518,
0.0589099973,
0.0093783168,
-0.0183981825,
0.0205785297,
-0.0070681111,
0.0106498692,
-0.0141601441,
-0.0038525581,
-0.002136678,
-0.0238079503,
-0.000267735,
0.0176789854,
0.0108310478,
-0.0599390604,
0.0038964737,
0.0077603292,
-0.0463750362,
0.0019203804,
-0.142442733,
-0.0255182553,
0.025488019,
0.0256163981,
-0.0171951056,
-0.0199659057,
-0.001907378,
-0.0580624118,
-0.0143979024,
0.0136840958,
-0.0112872152,
-0.0114249447,
0.052142363,
-0.0048954268,
-0.0040547685,
-0.0009875555,
0.0007918265,
-0.0498667657,
0.0478149205,
0.0314533934,
-0.1022797525,
-0.0230718125,
-0.0105588101,
-0.013088204,
0.0093096662,
-0.0102091162,
0.0194462743,
-0.0033440278,
0.0042858347,
0.0455878228,
0.060908556,
-0.0053263726,
0.0597069003,
-0.0529621616,
-0.0194472633,
-0.0232354961,
0.0057312008,
-0.0280236527,
0.0788826868,
-0.0063233301,
-0.0234633647,
0.03090843,
0.0516249016,
-0.0334890187,
0.0572998784,
0.0085661542,
-0.0030594654,
0.001579944,
-0.0327190757,
-0.0204497892,
0.0029995455,
-0.0064923479,
-0.0043137111,
-0.033995904,
-0.034660764,
0.0378661305,
-0.0832893476,
-0.0231973547,
0.0014349995,
0.0344697945,
-0.0479999818,
0.0807076842,
0.0776557103,
0.0088066151,
0.0110231666,
-0.0731143355,
0.0064021396,
0.0250823777,
-0.0285536386,
-0.0107749468,
-0.008574306,
-0.0123472968,
0.0301479269,
-0.0372099541,
-0.0204068404,
-0.0050899172,
-0.0027148395,
-0.0247431435,
0.0158178452,
-0.0047685509,
-0.0108615356,
0.0086781979,
0.068989262,
0.0247151256,
0.0596870892,
-0.026749026,
0.001023992,
-0.0401784815,
0.0895563737,
0.0193119012,
-0.0384037644,
-0.0009400401,
-0.0288595967,
-0.0370208994,
0.0600266159,
0.0150093064,
-0.0380938873,
-0.0117684323,
0.0001533677,
0.0173319466,
-0.0337868854,
0.0073257368,
-0.0230288096,
0.0326468572,
-0.0606305823,
0.014639589,
0.0981834382,
0.0215089079,
-0.0149905607,
-0.0288072191,
0.0311183725,
-0.0193119179,
-0.0128317149,
-0.009575271,
-0.0633434877,
-0.038532272,
0.0139860893,
0.0011262874,
0.0164558403,
-0.0386158898,
0.0048822877,
-0.0458028466,
0.0269443616,
-0.0170536768,
-0.0734754279,
-0.0030993277,
-0.0671784654,
-0.0280091707,
-0.0103874924,
-0.015352956,
-0.0059259422,
-0.0132042812,
-0.0223323945,
0.0195832383,
0.0073412275,
0.0389772803,
-0.0194662418,
-0.0182036851,
-0.0416307151,
0.0507462993,
0.0492876433,
0.0012644249,
0.0049087526,
0.057540454,
0.0132599883,
0.0239347331,
-0.0279928688,
0.0647437572,
-0.0761653483,
0.0258204732,
-0.0259673242,
0.0078148767,
-0.0054301023,
-0.0299596097,
-0.007369956,
0.0377683491,
0.0070422119,
-0.0190471839,
-0.0390315168,
-0.0209429935,
-0.0165020674,
0.0084666349,
0.0086488882,
-0.027582258,
-0.0778419599,
-0.0174579546,
0.0698823184,
-0.0191855021,
0.0169121213,
-0.0346831568,
-0.0719387159,
-0.0652325079,
-0.075741984,
-0.0371735208,
0.0568389408,
0.0809039474,
-0.0027843488,
-0.0019746532,
0.0240942407,
0.0094256792,
-0.0535585918,
0.0423908383,
0.014824206,
-0.0160190314,
-0.0820774361,
0.0029553813,
0.0373732932,
-0.0085957367,
-0.0429874286,
0.0357404202,
-0.0319589041,
-0.061846476,
0.0033040997,
0.0488797128,
0.0039957576,
0.0224663541,
0.0252029672,
-0.0217174962,
0.0665513724,
0.0323089473,
-0.0295096785,
-0.0321658514,
0.0084659103,
0.0236576051,
-0.025621403,
-0.0206513461,
-0.0199542381,
0.0423611514,
0.0270372797,
0.0221476648,
0.0047386619,
-0.0273236185,
-0.0252409913,
0.0398986898,
0.099384442,
-0.0267821625,
-0.0112393433,
-0.055121772,
0.0504044481,
0.0005027962,
0.0109637994,
-0.0008828947,
0.0170627534,
-0.0230907165,
0.0514105111,
-0.0258240104,
0.0177126005,
0.0284723118,
0.0354371108,
-0.0043542967,
0.0020987832,
0.0047719507,
0.0238508582,
0.0040796874,
-0.0334210023,
0.0008201099,
0.0258813314,
-0.003139701,
0.021500038,
-0.0298135597,
0.0347332172,
0.0244068131,
-0.0149431191,
-0.017904764,
0.0505540483,
-0.0333912298,
0.0352803394,
-0.0607460104,
0.0734302327,
0.0251627397,
-0.000368152,
0.0457861461,
-0.0347617492,
-0.0215643719,
0.0146336593,
0.0258356743,
-0.0081582721,
-0.0138372341,
0.0044668759,
0.0336432047,
-0.0302236099,
-0.02134124,
0.0493928641,
0.0625270382,
-0.0108144274,
0.040715564,
-0.0392535254,
-0.0470013358,
0.0249581728,
0.0437353924,
0.0109109376,
0.0012524538,
0.0180137232,
0.0015475759,
-0.0165984705,
0.0974103957,
0.0056791482,
-0.0235736631,
0.0114655392,
0.028186338,
0.0215546116,
0.0462228991,
-0.0478057042,
-0.0312609337,
0.0346971788,
0.0201343074,
-0.0573057942,
0.0104937404,
-5.789397105e-33,
-0.0308876224,
-0.0740294456,
0.0193558037,
0.0303199776,
-0.0001413401,
0.0408032276,
-0.0178972036,
-0.0376998223,
0.0303137302,
-0.0023529362,
-0.0122775696,
-0.0490762182,
0.0363477729,
0.0412665941,
-0.0257152207,
0.0129841287,
0.031750299,
0.0094978185,
-0.0221366119,
0.0055706752,
0.041392006,
0.0750521123,
0.0783140212,
-0.0640801489,
0.0129668638,
-0.0028372731,
0.0273749977,
-0.0315601267,
0.0521579385,
0.0134500889,
-0.0422057062,
-0.0226996932,
0.0125628384,
-0.0175519884,
0.0159510374,
0.0439030938,
-0.1663929075,
0.0141582433,
-0.0451302566,
0.0441888347,
-0.0374405906,
-0.0093068117,
0.0289941169,
-0.0334733389,
-0.0143262949,
0.0245581381,
0.0481140949,
0.0201110113,
-0.0181424636,
-0.0274003744,
-0.0664912835,
0.045798324,
0.0077575324,
0.0370797589,
0.0770875365,
-0.0182070918,
0.0474471152,
0.0439811349,
-0.0866701007,
-0.0076948204,
-0.0198018681,
-0.012515842,
0.0306574255,
0.0361888111,
0.0187700819,
0.0403441265,
0.0391051359,
-0.0132771172,
-0.0141063221,
0.0368233621,
0.0030097964,
0.0322426222,
-0.01591097,
-0.0124493027,
0.0246562324,
0.0056217131,
-0.0684118792,
0.0412019566,
-0.0287555456,
0.0042445781,
-0.0006563556,
-0.0066102138,
-0.0393920578,
0.0197841711,
0.0184460767,
-0.0352007002,
-0.0096611911,
-0.0213872772,
0.020144755,
0.0154634593,
-0.0378214754,
0.0365154557,
0.0471054725,
0.0163487531,
-0.0800147578,
0.0149180554,
0.0365112163,
0.0474933423,
-0.048001498,
0.001678027,
-0.0790363476,
-0.0747528747,
0.0366041102,
-0.0284140389,
0.0199681353,
-0.0432718098,
0.0545293167,
-0.0464241803,
-0.0696736276,
-0.0004804887,
0.0169527084,
0.0006749209,
-0.0039411094,
0.0322203897,
0.0539865009,
-0.046284318,
-0.002084441,
0.0204316415,
0.0387094431,
0.0238412898,
-0.0319036096,
-0.0129680866,
-0.0047811684,
0.0200884081,
-0.003571637,
-0.0078620231,
0.0021341359,
-0.0130053638,
-0.0330789648,
-0.0759634897,
0.0102425274,
0.034135811,
2.566e-7,
0.0369569249,
0.0516885258,
0.07540714,
-0.034619987,
-0.0008199223,
0.0256075822,
0.0138598634,
0.0373242833,
-0.0469144769,
-0.0301768556,
0.0105188666,
-0.0420532934,
-0.0046032639,
0.0077729272,
-0.0893686339,
-0.012915682,
-0.016363563,
-0.0174072906,
-0.0641569793,
0.0337079801,
-0.012209475,
0.0369246155,
-0.051643163,
-0.0150988363,
-0.0254972801,
-0.035565041,
0.0362184532,
0.0182542223,
0.0252861213,
0.0048950575,
0.0099190893,
-0.0203118045,
-0.0255187303,
0.0134875029,
-0.0008558378,
0.006738578,
0.069763802,
0.0403629057,
-0.0489672907,
-0.0165242702,
-0.0103404457,
-0.0083480515,
0.0100823967,
-0.0335852019,
0.0368737541,
0.0074273632,
-0.0144825196,
-0.0396240056,
-0.046498239,
0.005194278,
-0.0181575119,
-0.0053985277,
-0.0169732384,
0.0626314655,
0.0226805694,
-0.0557157397,
-0.004958794,
-0.0829564482,
0.0070401598,
0.0062487707,
0.011837082,
-0.003119532,
-0.0124922292,
-0.0023716425,
0.0342801176,
-0.0504109263,
-0.0614904128,
2.395257084e-34,
-0.0013150729,
-0.0113577349,
-0.034675058,
0.0359655693,
0.0104920808,
-0.0217264667,
-0.0295866784,
-0.009040283,
-0.0299214274,
-0.0410265177,
-0.0172835384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11010v1 | Iterative Shallow Fusion of Backward Language Model for End-to-End Speech Recognition | 2023-10-17T05:44:10 | 2023-10-17T05:44:10 | Atsunori Ogawa, Takafumi Moriya, Naoyuki Kamo, Naohiro Tawara, Marc Delcroix | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | We propose a new shallow fusion (SF) method to exploit an external backward
language model (BLM) for end-to-end automatic speech recognition (ASR). The BLM
has complementary characteristics with a forward language model (FLM), and the
effectiveness of their combination has been confirmed by rescoring ASR
hypotheses as post-processing. In the proposed SF, we iteratively apply the BLM
to partial ASR hypotheses in the backward direction (i.e., from the possible
next token to the start symbol) during decoding, substituting the newly
calculated BLM scores for the scores calculated at the last iteration. To
enhance the effectiveness of this iterative SF (ISF), we train a partial
sentence-aware BLM (PBLM) using reversed text data including partial sentences,
considering the framework of ISF. In experiments using an attention-based
encoder-decoder ASR system, we confirmed that ISF using the PBLM shows
comparable performance with SF using the FLM. By performing ISF, early pruning
of prospective hypotheses can be prevented during decoding, and we can obtain a
performance improvement compared to applying the PBLM as post-processing.
Finally, we confirmed that, by combining SF and ISF, further performance
improvement can be obtained thanks to the complementarity of the FLM and PBLM. | [
0.0102978786,
0.0193210766,
0.0374834649,
0.0099457875,
-0.0312727839,
0.0058345678,
-0.0352308936,
-0.0263708681,
0.0158623848,
-0.0282026399,
-0.0300143119,
-0.0231085271,
0.0605210885,
0.0275365952,
0.0288398713,
0.0194271579,
0.0163376052,
-0.0197810195,
-0.0096423486,
-0.0028528792,
0.0027466803,
0.0064706537,
0.0144483568,
0.0349783935,
0.0270424951,
0.0209215377,
-0.0057640229,
0.0243314952,
0.0519339368,
-0.005488134,
-0.0471206121,
-0.0317969322,
0.0156648904,
-0.0148317767,
0.0000022691,
-0.0184303932,
-0.0391013138,
-0.0154877063,
-0.0259252153,
-0.0345258899,
0.0135672819,
-0.0044669081,
-0.0131026544,
0.054755792,
0.0057828384,
-0.002227051,
0.0268322639,
0.0664285347,
0.0410148911,
0.049286034,
0.005808081,
-0.0647397786,
0.0785507709,
0.0020987287,
-0.0496026538,
-0.0395397022,
-0.0007347884,
-0.0630825534,
-0.0005688476,
-0.0433842242,
-0.0301708672,
0.08243981,
0.0271633398,
0.0216784459,
0.0127057396,
0.0071471636,
0.0224843416,
-0.0022381227,
-0.0494519919,
0.0237836242,
-0.0296729803,
-0.055200547,
-0.0007039034,
-0.008279724,
-0.0339677483,
-0.0557500198,
-0.0135658188,
0.0091176974,
-0.0114938691,
0.0024401753,
0.0771992952,
0.0292234365,
0.0336105339,
0.0177004952,
-0.0652536526,
0.048048906,
-0.0028321943,
-0.063993603,
0.0031955543,
-0.0241468716,
0.0316636637,
-0.0182270221,
0.0607364811,
0.0266835671,
0.0054420088,
0.0148597034,
-0.0137275262,
-0.060111396,
-0.0043601999,
-0.0384478532,
-0.0038242929,
0.06890212,
-0.0382166617,
0.0165942125,
-0.0233524945,
0.0467259549,
0.0067850128,
0.0155008705,
-0.0504719093,
-0.0120925177,
0.0113861877,
0.0117244925,
-0.0443531089,
0.0271961913,
-0.0143008735,
-0.0635435358,
-0.0359859355,
0.0151933515,
0.0231327247,
-0.060522534,
0.0162760224,
-0.0366483219,
-0.0357381813,
-0.0097188307,
0.0516949445,
0.0491081215,
0.0410732329,
0.0425035581,
0.016016487,
-0.0335134156,
-0.0264668707,
0.0168897118,
0.0115483329,
0.0077597965,
-0.0088865124,
0.0367929973,
-0.0316987969,
-0.0334274173,
-0.052471038,
0.0219924003,
-0.0173231717,
-0.0705545694,
0.0130030401,
-0.0301264562,
0.0308421049,
0.0175168049,
0.0178303327,
-0.0114872279,
-0.0051287627,
-0.0005089187,
0.0219784137,
0.0839533359,
-0.0176599268,
0.0111742448,
0.0429218262,
-0.0258131269,
0.0511599481,
0.0583281256,
-0.0056102048,
0.0045316368,
-0.0450863428,
0.0036763099,
-0.0319825746,
0.0560705103,
0.007081856,
0.0157369711,
-0.0685340613,
-0.01050088,
-0.0125803035,
-0.0068478137,
-0.0127215823,
0.0563816503,
-0.0222603139,
0.0426453464,
0.0118112452,
0.0168380048,
0.0352165587,
0.0292308498,
0.0232237261,
0.0232946333,
-0.0221995078,
0.0168435816,
0.0341355279,
0.015492226,
-0.0682311952,
0.0210875832,
0.0829921961,
0.0356419608,
-0.0179587156,
-0.024724206,
-0.0070771007,
-0.0322880372,
0.0106755039,
0.0443647243,
0.0700335652,
0.0145550352,
-0.1061357707,
0.0397620983,
-0.0086921593,
-0.0902459323,
0.0239485614,
-0.0187977757,
-0.0202640146,
0.0420554914,
0.0426352099,
0.0098980628,
-0.014214565,
-0.0154246818,
-0.0501193739,
0.0309573617,
-0.0140773822,
0.0527306423,
0.0202194825,
-0.0703008696,
-0.0285863895,
0.0792198703,
-0.0195789412,
0.0619364083,
-0.058481358,
-0.0057204305,
0.0267065894,
0.0298698023,
0.0098977592,
0.0084570153,
-0.0312749892,
-0.0003716889,
0.0072759767,
0.0221905224,
0.067060411,
0.0279336665,
0.0171469096,
0.027805781,
0.0745250806,
-0.0383445174,
-0.0348420851,
0.0434842929,
-0.0871229395,
-0.059697032,
0.0573277287,
0.0133634107,
0.0332919993,
0.0421875603,
0.032367263,
-0.1046010554,
0.0384838618,
-0.0446348116,
0.0520213135,
-0.0552350208,
0.0889647231,
0.0565844774,
-0.0164080281,
-0.0146879349,
0.0070152325,
-0.0570699722,
0.0258416701,
-0.0019974406,
-0.0526532531,
-0.013334468,
-0.0782171264,
-0.010003875,
0.0164645836,
-0.0447001904,
0.0216176808,
0.0035798997,
-0.0122150956,
-0.0022299681,
-0.0076659,
-0.09801016,
-0.0165062379,
-0.0388280116,
0.0050838441,
-0.0226912592,
0.0413407013,
0.0050088749,
-0.0371723585,
-0.0047434764,
-0.0070016542,
-0.0099404128,
-0.0083705271,
-0.0373799503,
0.0546049401,
-0.0368168913,
-0.0218162052,
-0.0200208258,
-0.0095830709,
0.0128374519,
-0.0273033306,
-0.0590489022,
-0.0859865919,
-0.0107431216,
0.0120520256,
0.0227035265,
-0.0200976357,
-0.0473057032,
-0.009656325,
-0.0218369067,
0.0457818955,
0.0052752802,
0.0171719287,
-0.0353371389,
0.0021508101,
-0.023594236,
-0.0326169617,
0.024387138,
-0.0001258367,
0.0134311337,
-0.0000985349,
-0.0163508467,
-0.0017853654,
0.0434992723,
0.0081059048,
0.0451481044,
-0.0561724938,
-0.0522087067,
0.003380666,
-0.0363489315,
-0.0317893922,
-0.0409997925,
-0.0459273905,
-0.0011554002,
-0.0287889242,
-0.0060501536,
0.039243225,
-0.1114714444,
-0.0089653246,
-0.0491303504,
-0.0253253542,
-0.0160677359,
-0.0165640749,
-0.0088070538,
-0.0015683974,
-0.0353090726,
-0.0561700426,
0.0176853184,
0.0337581895,
-0.0440923497,
-0.025675578,
0.0701893046,
0.0016534458,
0.0414534062,
-0.0345560312,
-0.0055732713,
-0.0166789219,
-0.0671348572,
-0.0189423617,
0.0213528257,
-0.0143225593,
0.0146472566,
-0.0499767885,
0.0576455444,
-0.0058019576,
0.0632605404,
0.0009637388,
0.028129369,
-0.0419633761,
-0.0041559455,
-0.0046226983,
-0.0045894245,
-0.0237119813,
0.0069040013,
0.032576248,
-0.0259131305,
0.0781729445,
-0.0260430537,
-0.0194494072,
-0.0208597705,
0.0456515849,
0.0099411961,
0.0009812126,
0.0152912112,
0.0340373963,
-0.0600177608,
-0.0069065052,
0.0818074793,
-0.0047504841,
-0.0257606879,
-0.0406979658,
0.0136528388,
0.0000032674,
-0.0002269788,
-0.0172613971,
-0.0036844031,
-0.0502349772,
0.0421987735,
0.0290788915,
0.005051217,
0.0329503193,
-0.0040984359,
-0.1108977199,
0.0096296566,
0.0406512879,
-0.0471576788,
-0.0232081097,
-0.0410207249,
-0.028662581,
0.0062718675,
0.0186186451,
0.050810568,
-0.0169699546,
-0.0431790501,
0.0135949235,
-0.0028116785,
-0.0151270898,
-0.0077611911,
-0.0028323226,
0.0149051147,
0.0650155693,
0.0464152135,
-0.0019675207,
-0.0364921391,
0.0752362534,
-0.0694721565,
0.0052674399,
-0.0281563736,
0.0242194235,
-0.0465269126,
0.0024258941,
0.0476506799,
-0.0066825687,
-0.0190686714,
0.0220778491,
-0.0185094047,
0.0622576475,
-0.0246523507,
0.0559758544,
0.0058978121,
0.0140184807,
0.0085768653,
0.0610899031,
0.0196376108,
-0.0375499502,
-0.0281835962,
-0.0084730899,
0.027925346,
-0.0089835478,
0.0263276044,
0.009471992,
0.003988422,
-0.0609510727,
-0.000183061,
-0.0484132506,
-0.0005972032,
0.0122757833,
0.0164993815,
0.0613818653,
-0.0328103565,
0.0172938481,
-0.0422407575,
0.0040072957,
0.0174065307,
0.0431687161,
-0.0800620094,
0.0318716057,
0.0165216252,
-0.0445278846,
-0.0103762317,
0.0577522144,
-0.0365947112,
-0.042201601,
0.0071612606,
-0.0221488476,
0.0067165717,
0.0284873154,
-0.0358719341,
-0.0229637753,
0.0522425137,
0.0236430615,
-0.05313088,
0.0099578351,
0.0420088209,
-0.0190776475,
-0.0265812166,
0.0149508836,
-0.0369158089,
-0.0069495644,
0.0166071709,
0.0340461619,
-0.0138636073,
-0.0564874038,
0.018010376,
0.0445534401,
0.0757118091,
-0.0480012111,
-0.0118109183,
0.0007819046,
0.0421859547,
-0.0094427662,
0.0440463871,
-0.0172124635,
-0.0033851378,
0.0265031774,
0.0181712937,
0.0168097056,
0.0248179697,
-0.0413730033,
-0.0227390304,
-0.029731933,
0.0787029415,
0.0192244314,
0.0381364301,
0.0050415229,
-0.0180642549,
-0.0401214287,
-0.0027815541,
0.0186240878,
-0.0304520838,
-0.0227123499,
0.0154157905,
0.0012055045,
0.0267536044,
-0.0299556535,
0.0507360771,
-0.0424334332,
0.0140709337,
-0.0356206819,
0.0258496497,
0.0483111143,
0.0067385589,
0.0666973218,
0.0349322595,
0.0281726476,
-0.05954789,
0.0310938358,
-0.0376605019,
-0.052554328,
0.0296225194,
0.0030855285,
-0.0121135078,
0.0231802315,
0.0294112712,
0.0070490823,
0.0356220156,
-0.0269764662,
0.0345900431,
-0.0439612195,
-0.0320334546,
-0.0054340623,
0.0273278095,
-0.0458823517,
0.0162613746,
-0.0064886548,
-0.0578529872,
0.0704886764,
-0.0030175676,
0.0268779173,
-0.018716177,
0.0015687873,
0.008724127,
-0.0266942959,
-0.0223279987,
-0.0043616998,
-0.0020722272,
0.0014687901,
-0.0064445073,
0.0038058774,
-6.748904655e-33,
-0.0274578929,
0.0440164283,
0.0048551871,
-0.0531214252,
-0.0383656397,
-0.0084745754,
-0.0343695991,
0.0038348895,
0.0414448306,
-0.0289066192,
-0.0425298549,
0.00249407,
0.0300739072,
0.0140912235,
-0.0167803634,
0.0322294906,
0.1039052606,
0.0035919463,
0.010073103,
-0.0015902719,
0.0430276766,
0.0705053508,
0.0378179438,
-0.0256010592,
-0.0632072911,
-0.0131677911,
-0.022418404,
0.0168263335,
-0.0259897392,
0.0382107422,
0.0076103457,
0.0251651816,
0.01559225,
-0.0267584156,
-0.0535569191,
0.0563683435,
-0.0695049614,
0.0461028926,
0.0279653464,
0.0369730666,
-0.0125841964,
-0.0353638567,
0.0566854067,
0.0078608291,
-0.0199229121,
-0.0167362485,
-0.0047180308,
-0.042404566,
0.016114939,
-0.0209222082,
-0.0019464256,
0.0360209718,
0.0104282331,
-0.012041973,
0.0663003623,
0.0080811009,
-0.0305502377,
-0.0093836989,
-0.0523154177,
-0.0007773234,
0.0448334552,
0.0251058955,
0.0712170899,
0.0672564283,
-0.0147743793,
-0.0028667792,
-0.0079032322,
-0.0440658294,
0.0069039958,
-0.0450647324,
0.0488500334,
0.0208633579,
0.0230135471,
0.0050418493,
0.0499530844,
-0.0079665063,
-0.0451678708,
-0.0164910071,
0.0098737329,
0.0487692989,
0.0115238847,
0.0538232699,
-0.0278907884,
-0.008950931,
-0.0496114977,
-0.045813892,
-0.0212932918,
0.0064599589,
0.0627271682,
0.0395917185,
-0.0064126579,
-0.0307972822,
0.0839888155,
-0.0393947214,
0.0551649854,
0.0502558462,
-0.0036461854,
-0.0022289522,
-0.010039608,
0.0350062177,
-0.122069478,
0.000249316,
0.0265685245,
0.0185026787,
-0.033020556,
-0.0291162226,
0.0105723115,
0.0253406689,
-0.0378884822,
-0.0053096572,
-0.0055587776,
0.0165771861,
-0.0086401906,
0.0305948704,
0.0678088292,
-0.0000991396,
0.0018548587,
0.0364038162,
-0.0258691665,
0.0038592734,
-0.0240426585,
-0.020652242,
0.0389898717,
0.0450895131,
-0.0137969721,
0.0070010913,
0.0143228956,
-0.0066900975,
0.0122297229,
-0.0151246926,
-0.0009463207,
0.0630663559,
2.883e-7,
-0.0259542055,
-0.0275543295,
0.0803213641,
-0.023358712,
-0.0142555265,
0.0039877836,
-0.0295345169,
-0.01968842,
0.0403421707,
0.0391939543,
0.0020554855,
-0.01151626,
0.0683035851,
-0.0246844813,
-0.1039223224,
-0.0226368234,
-0.0393989906,
0.0318101756,
-0.0137328589,
-0.0039268769,
0.0289867781,
0.0685602799,
-0.0259746872,
-0.013912512,
-0.0296210572,
-0.0144481994,
0.054593984,
-0.0015073924,
-0.0333809219,
-0.0096717933,
-0.0030311891,
0.0022826502,
-0.0230932534,
0.0031292613,
-0.0166958272,
0.0647599101,
0.0241698343,
0.0118031884,
-0.0444094092,
-0.0940023661,
0.0327286609,
0.0797783956,
-0.0296560973,
0.0062024626,
0.034002088,
-0.0199735556,
0.0067136702,
0.0082670068,
-0.0766781867,
0.028279284,
-0.0028063608,
0.0112188729,
0.0145512568,
0.027902469,
0.0222423375,
-0.0248252172,
-0.037550725,
-0.0847599506,
-0.0168449227,
0.0246604197,
-0.0587357655,
0.0125603052,
-0.0395953283,
0.0392504819,
0.0394762531,
-0.0519054905,
-0.0151830465,
2.623438216e-34,
0.0263258219,
-0.0280306786,
0.0090921931,
0.0023101133,
-0.002797856,
-0.0455840826,
-0.0130605567,
0.0575204492,
-0.01261493,
-0.0891597942,
-0.0298840273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11003v1 | Correction Focused Language Model Training for Speech Recognition | 2023-10-17T05:10:39 | 2023-10-17T05:10:39 | Yingyi Ma, Zhe Liu, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Language models (LMs) have been commonly adopted to boost the performance of
automatic speech recognition (ASR) particularly in domain adaptation tasks.
Conventional way of LM training treats all the words in corpora equally,
resulting in suboptimal improvements in ASR performance. In this work, we
introduce a novel correction focused LM training approach which aims to
prioritize ASR fallible words. The word-level ASR fallibility score,
representing the likelihood of ASR mis-recognition, is defined and shaped as a
prior word distribution to guide the LM training. To enable correction focused
training with text-only corpora, large language models (LLMs) are employed as
fallibility score predictors and text generators through multi-task
fine-tuning. Experimental results for domain adaptation tasks demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed method. Compared with conventional LMs,
correction focused training achieves up to relatively 5.5% word error rate
(WER) reduction in sufficient text scenarios. In insufficient text scenarios,
LM training with LLM-generated text achieves up to relatively 13% WER
reduction, while correction focused training further obtains up to relatively
6% WER reduction. | [
0.0177191645,
0.0200077742,
0.0173359495,
0.0237346161,
-0.0340253562,
-0.0031803979,
0.015570364,
0.0017358314,
-0.0065194778,
-0.0684060603,
-0.0450817458,
-0.0546753891,
0.0320286006,
-0.010185034,
0.0365053676,
-0.0539268255,
0.0318430662,
-0.0549640544,
-0.0083029903,
-0.011986617,
0.0099486606,
0.0095695397,
-0.0238134004,
-0.0035094514,
0.0213796161,
0.0163162202,
0.0378187597,
0.0362707898,
0.018617386,
-0.0242258441,
-0.0088739647,
0.0377440676,
0.0235918295,
0.0189681966,
0.0000021944,
-0.0596117675,
-0.0360691547,
0.0048299064,
-0.023769455,
0.0052962182,
0.0677959025,
0.0111973854,
-0.0220575966,
0.0783403665,
0.0101209627,
-0.0203598514,
0.0453525558,
0.0460484214,
0.0136558814,
0.0987885222,
-0.009090866,
-0.0239854623,
-0.0027900285,
-0.0280954204,
-0.040075928,
-0.0734975263,
0.027984431,
0.048367396,
-0.0186054092,
0.0004157973,
-0.012768656,
0.0124133639,
-0.0447862446,
0.0076477453,
0.0030063896,
-0.0038365698,
-0.0023745219,
-0.0231135469,
-0.0148254018,
0.0209497027,
-0.0193470325,
-0.0618704259,
-0.0011876003,
-0.0204606149,
-0.0321952887,
0.0350638516,
-0.0118387341,
0.0057083569,
-0.0079888841,
0.0192450657,
0.0194543414,
-0.0239991173,
0.032241866,
0.0168105643,
-0.0287005082,
0.0177873634,
0.0211068504,
-0.0441668667,
0.0180481989,
-0.0186228864,
-0.0244705454,
-0.0264478903,
0.0617398284,
0.0073781013,
-0.0077208634,
0.0216420945,
-0.0488667488,
-0.0645089,
0.0063565345,
-0.0764520541,
0.02907959,
0.0266178157,
-0.0300213061,
0.0098788394,
-0.0383039489,
0.0901870206,
0.0408875979,
-0.0136619844,
-0.055646766,
-0.0116623938,
-0.0212645363,
0.0209273379,
-0.0276656654,
0.0003574162,
-0.0416951105,
-0.0074732625,
-0.0314939991,
0.014597428,
0.0080432976,
-0.0557007827,
0.0422262661,
-0.0294035599,
-0.0676376596,
-0.031308312,
0.0159751121,
0.0278847273,
0.0304602198,
0.0664559454,
-0.0354320221,
-0.0564351007,
-0.0128329722,
0.0240534209,
0.0398049615,
-0.0296297427,
0.0196915567,
0.045337785,
0.0039020278,
-0.0661477819,
-0.0718062446,
0.0641327873,
-0.0237291455,
-0.0446657613,
-0.0131528173,
-0.0391192958,
-0.0338167995,
0.015178768,
0.0352937207,
-0.0552641675,
-0.0071796575,
-0.0073372349,
-0.0284385215,
0.0708171353,
0.0009094166,
0.0236253068,
0.0805421323,
-0.018222902,
0.0190356635,
0.0615871698,
0.057637915,
-0.0213768668,
0.0067347512,
-0.0323273465,
0.0204517636,
0.0614476837,
-0.0440463647,
0.0187086705,
-0.008383044,
-0.0359206088,
-0.0016955833,
-0.0058839461,
0.0890705213,
0.0554136038,
0.0139779914,
0.0111361882,
0.0681160912,
0.0146292606,
0.055676233,
0.000087668,
0.0027210373,
0.008848248,
-0.0117421476,
-0.005436589,
-0.0413924865,
-0.0324437842,
-0.0505627878,
0.0404630713,
0.0296510849,
0.0351398364,
-0.0165237188,
-0.0017484128,
-0.031933967,
-0.0177300666,
0.0431414992,
0.0157935917,
0.0741495341,
0.0261632372,
-0.0661178678,
0.036296621,
0.0439304076,
-0.0514407828,
0.0361342318,
-0.0578126237,
-0.0052264598,
0.0512878224,
0.0492844656,
-0.0411040373,
-0.0001318812,
-0.0015750832,
0.0079188198,
0.0752994642,
0.0220555253,
0.0274979305,
0.0039573889,
-0.0862398818,
0.0060870345,
0.0664525032,
0.0153480452,
0.0443935469,
-0.0057828454,
0.0203941781,
0.0355332792,
-0.0292168017,
-0.0627547577,
0.0173195805,
-0.0410719477,
-0.0271667726,
0.0231914129,
-0.0109983506,
0.0473229997,
0.0317865126,
-0.0386388749,
-0.002677656,
0.0129003301,
0.0018435883,
0.0011743127,
-0.0021347716,
-0.0403616615,
-0.0279160794,
0.0554775186,
0.0208077114,
0.0553046986,
0.0419064052,
0.0125048263,
-0.0709799379,
0.0101166712,
-0.0235855002,
0.0196906142,
-0.0540272854,
0.0775965378,
0.0031189527,
0.0084935743,
-0.025652973,
0.014483979,
0.0151773989,
-0.0089694373,
-0.032888677,
0.0243810192,
-0.0148088578,
-0.0519947484,
-0.0158063434,
0.0180879068,
-0.0049652564,
0.0633812174,
0.0132545363,
0.0244960692,
-0.0036569401,
0.0039123152,
-0.0851070881,
-0.0048063621,
-0.0588098057,
0.0405238681,
-0.0020469427,
0.0269000102,
-0.019933844,
-0.0216761138,
0.0117561137,
-0.0126712918,
0.0030052243,
-0.0087146163,
-0.0300527494,
-0.0082694376,
-0.0268270597,
-0.0399068967,
0.026476793,
0.0222559981,
0.0102348765,
0.0048011239,
-0.0351405405,
-0.0869284719,
0.1217332259,
0.0224228855,
0.0342816822,
-0.0037425139,
-0.0234099589,
-0.0384348147,
0.0306584034,
0.0358845927,
0.0254462343,
0.0363524407,
-0.0209436342,
0.0413341671,
0.01444232,
-0.0355707295,
-0.0161320698,
-0.0006182573,
-0.0332779065,
-0.0161505882,
-0.0430678502,
-0.0096839145,
0.022077797,
0.0216753557,
0.0196206588,
-0.0456747673,
-0.0476473495,
-0.0416786969,
-0.0092135556,
0.014172812,
-0.0417315997,
-0.0618530922,
-0.0290940553,
-0.0065181968,
-0.0487932414,
0.0183602609,
-0.1080686226,
0.0116087105,
-0.096066758,
-0.036368791,
-0.0240601096,
-0.0107448334,
0.0020282757,
0.0044803661,
0.027018426,
-0.0515661314,
-0.0030912261,
0.0091563491,
0.0200704318,
-0.0494557582,
0.0536783673,
-0.0592536665,
0.0303865131,
-0.0062849619,
-0.0042118393,
-0.0278590303,
-0.0218773112,
-0.0263401698,
0.022164274,
-0.0105417538,
-0.0058569051,
-0.0444467105,
0.0486239456,
0.0111372322,
0.0893204659,
-0.0103142811,
0.0321141854,
-0.0078257453,
0.0291976556,
0.0412643142,
0.0526584834,
-0.017167028,
-0.0156618375,
-0.0214555804,
-0.0357000418,
0.0564760417,
-0.0187582858,
-0.0355332494,
-0.0163376499,
0.0435505621,
-0.0129021564,
-0.0050149439,
0.0120306974,
0.0444394574,
-0.0081447782,
-0.0139600057,
0.1007592678,
0.0069171735,
-0.0302282963,
-0.025136007,
-0.0179843437,
0.0119327921,
0.0219627079,
-0.0209960118,
-0.0154615007,
-0.0346377194,
0.0332976878,
0.0542355478,
-0.0131539777,
0.0217883661,
-0.0242238864,
-0.0886896774,
0.0265729502,
0.0579866022,
-0.0223284457,
-0.043001499,
-0.0664477646,
0.0062162364,
-0.0377448536,
0.0577388741,
0.0069440473,
-0.0275715031,
-0.0318014398,
0.0684627891,
-0.0502416678,
-0.1234641671,
-0.0196013041,
-0.0276023354,
0.0794114098,
0.0788956136,
-0.0117531251,
-0.0504290573,
0.0176465157,
0.0327778943,
-0.0122530647,
0.0132921236,
-0.0232332889,
0.017230751,
-0.021438757,
0.0166966654,
0.0380848907,
0.0241935924,
-0.0080401786,
-0.0177597702,
0.0399162695,
0.0372257866,
-0.0132759362,
0.0053215777,
0.0220091026,
-0.0010009265,
0.0282260012,
0.0804034546,
0.0080533363,
-0.0421614833,
0.0315561928,
0.0112764733,
0.0072181202,
-0.0288147889,
-0.0070081027,
0.0019409653,
-0.0324281454,
-0.0207675323,
-0.0467128418,
0.005816136,
0.0003573565,
-0.0008879103,
0.0386240855,
0.0378897414,
0.0035905293,
0.0311040245,
-0.026133243,
0.0154445907,
-0.0481781177,
0.015071027,
-0.102162689,
-0.0121881627,
0.0133169135,
-0.0586751029,
-0.035342209,
0.0169231165,
-0.0545906126,
-0.0568577498,
0.018158352,
-0.0047942195,
0.0242003091,
0.0348025896,
-0.0234906171,
-0.0783350691,
0.0271328315,
0.0248008259,
-0.0627367347,
0.0740946084,
0.0283735972,
-0.0468235202,
-0.0390839949,
-0.0052298005,
-0.0534807406,
0.0453014188,
0.0146654341,
0.0294588394,
0.0260021053,
-0.062073119,
-0.0210581943,
0.0377374552,
0.0345745943,
-0.0188594274,
0.001095762,
-0.0544228554,
0.0215119515,
0.0086158635,
0.0265510194,
-0.0060481313,
0.0221880488,
0.0234031212,
0.0024743865,
-0.0222806111,
-0.0020951699,
-0.0696726292,
-0.0060860063,
-0.0299920198,
0.0549701564,
-0.0008762156,
0.0265280828,
0.018278325,
-0.0178456213,
-0.0163992364,
-0.0242735371,
0.0322629809,
0.0045862645,
0.006273285,
0.0332803987,
-0.0322224051,
-0.001065692,
-0.0269202683,
0.0334793963,
-0.0088564558,
-0.0013451467,
-0.065887332,
0.0495531298,
0.0569526106,
-0.0158768147,
0.0848038495,
-0.0319998302,
0.02019508,
-0.0840604901,
-0.0165383108,
0.0278578196,
0.0270230807,
0.0102892797,
-0.0106455348,
-0.0130414488,
0.0617205761,
0.0677413568,
0.0674693137,
0.015746912,
-0.0313206241,
-0.0050561684,
-0.0293321479,
-0.0272307079,
-0.0307671558,
-0.0142622832,
-0.0543611571,
-0.0089786723,
-0.044811666,
-0.0724135563,
0.0514655225,
-0.0201130565,
0.0288709216,
-0.0454761162,
-0.003249207,
0.0354489312,
-0.051375661,
0.0323707424,
-0.0285931434,
-0.0091875512,
0.0026745507,
-0.0035920436,
-0.0148492344,
-6.477571171e-33,
-0.0310374591,
0.0064343065,
0.0091656623,
-0.0210718252,
-0.0102132875,
0.0115604391,
-0.0105413739,
0.0089471536,
0.0034168889,
-0.0192375593,
-0.0157917067,
-0.0011698343,
0.0413556956,
0.0080206841,
-0.0444089584,
0.0311433207,
0.0832295045,
-0.0112445103,
-0.0237411708,
-0.0139019443,
0.0190695468,
0.0517280325,
0.0244825743,
-0.0874695405,
0.0011298233,
-0.0072159064,
-0.0124806706,
-0.0193027183,
0.045757398,
0.0599047877,
0.0019941542,
0.0449716635,
0.0220264215,
-0.0379815586,
-0.0185911823,
0.0303999707,
-0.0749570951,
0.0337846279,
0.0288097858,
0.0297577716,
0.0562245026,
-0.0299397912,
0.0480393954,
-0.0051782699,
-0.0472393744,
0.001276357,
0.0083264457,
-0.0564793311,
-0.045383323,
0.010501557,
-0.0407311656,
0.064262107,
0.0336417854,
-0.0230201613,
0.0322547406,
0.0235544238,
-0.0355272666,
0.0051802304,
-0.0323248915,
0.0143533237,
0.057545457,
0.0328112505,
0.0396187007,
0.0626882985,
-0.0616524108,
0.0246498305,
-0.0151803549,
-0.0285924636,
0.0314036086,
-0.0560996458,
0.0421554744,
-0.0195892584,
0.0198577177,
0.042685274,
0.0090018194,
-0.068535924,
-0.0523868129,
0.0097648147,
-0.0397507995,
0.0186042562,
0.0709797144,
0.0263874289,
-0.0766241103,
-0.0125875184,
-0.0438366197,
0.001769106,
-0.0359267667,
-0.0014890517,
0.0653453991,
0.0192886945,
-0.0165780131,
-0.0088027762,
0.0433114804,
-0.0198151506,
0.0118042398,
0.0152236652,
-0.0122506153,
-0.0052999584,
-0.0326276459,
0.0293323621,
-0.0427532308,
-0.0182845052,
0.032809779,
0.0412142649,
-0.0231070593,
-0.030788064,
-0.0026078511,
0.0308829211,
-0.0456108525,
0.0029268893,
0.0156666022,
-0.0118780639,
0.0038254368,
0.0867930502,
0.0281815734,
0.0035028546,
0.0075627025,
0.0500461571,
-0.0001778022,
-0.0472269282,
-0.0060161133,
0.0011582848,
0.0021420913,
0.0430490784,
-0.0316710398,
0.0116647827,
0.0413717255,
0.0048192148,
0.0188891254,
-0.0184166003,
-0.008814171,
-0.0072974656,
2.932e-7,
-0.0072441106,
0.0494195186,
-0.0246567428,
-0.0245934222,
-0.0016384143,
0.0266530644,
-0.0316008553,
0.018227296,
0.0428955182,
0.0296213385,
0.0173220225,
-0.0048401682,
0.0656833202,
-0.0135524934,
-0.0552566387,
-0.047049433,
-0.0167349316,
0.0382032655,
-0.0001574426,
0.0015881528,
-0.0135074928,
0.0941160619,
-0.0199735649,
-0.0249552224,
-0.0118980901,
-0.0641519874,
0.0499326475,
-0.0293845031,
-0.0174450763,
0.0063435701,
0.0097322827,
0.0334398337,
-0.0033477279,
0.0402960479,
-0.0333645903,
0.041237887,
0.0404300801,
0.0654563606,
-0.0266878288,
0.0140822865,
-0.0010763076,
0.0391102508,
-0.0111504598,
-0.0214588027,
0.0403121635,
0.0101050232,
0.0156722479,
-0.0232129246,
-0.0421697237,
0.0208310429,
0.0062953057,
-0.019668797,
-0.0096476041,
-0.0001574839,
0.0274944659,
0.0196544155,
-0.059807647,
-0.0406687818,
0.01035548,
0.0142504368,
-0.0471635871,
-0.0155491251,
-0.0295901559,
-0.012597491,
0.0191758275,
-0.0546623357,
0.0480679348,
2.489948205e-34,
0.031806007,
-0.0298101064,
-0.0148004247,
0.0150049189,
0.0184114035,
-0.0085086562,
0.0090537695,
0.0397774577,
-0.0199319478,
-0.0815785602,
-0.0076944926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10981v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10981v2 | Instructive Dialogue Summarization with Query Aggregations | 2023-10-17T04:03:00 | 2023-12-09T05:38:43 | Bin Wang, Zhengyuan Liu, Nancy F. Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conventional dialogue summarization methods directly generate summaries and
do not consider user's specific interests. This poses challenges in cases where
the users are more focused on particular topics or aspects. With the
advancement of instruction-finetuned language models, we introduce
instruction-tuning to dialogues to expand the capability set of dialogue
summarization models. To overcome the scarcity of instructive dialogue
summarization data, we propose a three-step approach to synthesize high-quality
query-based summarization triples. This process involves summary-anchored query
generation, query filtering, and query-based summary generation. By training a
unified model called InstructDS (Instructive Dialogue Summarization) on three
summarization datasets with multi-purpose instructive triples, we expand the
capability of dialogue summarization models. We evaluate our method on four
datasets, including dialogue summarization and dialogue reading comprehension.
Experimental results show that our approach outperforms the state-of-the-art
models and even models with larger sizes. Additionally, our model exhibits
higher generalizability and faithfulness, as confirmed by human subjective
evaluations. | [
0.052346088,
0.027257368,
0.0224268623,
0.023309309,
0.0109911049,
0.0166577697,
-0.0157989804,
-0.0472739413,
0.0024075126,
-0.0392790288,
-0.0272683296,
-0.0269323587,
-0.0059372461,
0.0018183377,
0.0090391822,
-0.0937890857,
0.0451039262,
-0.0290709566,
-0.0166927017,
0.0181839149,
0.0331040248,
0.0477897897,
-0.0083999699,
0.0278987773,
0.0314607173,
-0.0047744862,
-0.0144741666,
0.0281869844,
-0.0003369846,
-0.0154074691,
0.0355303138,
0.0092687039,
0.0343714468,
-0.0197497085,
0.0000017711,
-0.0144193796,
-0.0228128154,
-0.0308025815,
-0.0027616085,
0.020508213,
0.0287114475,
-0.0184002444,
0.0446510091,
0.0316614695,
-0.0218132194,
0.0350864194,
-0.019171847,
0.0679298267,
0.1162083149,
0.0726566911,
-0.0071730884,
-0.0512207374,
0.0078964131,
0.0049673221,
-0.0131549519,
-0.0278653726,
-0.025254827,
0.0408429168,
0.0173337404,
0.019547388,
0.0044886926,
0.0359550528,
0.0060242801,
-0.0285115652,
0.0207316894,
0.0028735336,
-0.0262081549,
0.0016050591,
-0.0084972195,
0.0887717083,
0.0429057181,
0.0209024027,
0.0070083374,
0.0129134106,
0.0240606498,
-0.0206512623,
-0.0712722316,
0.0321655162,
0.0002419281,
0.0106079523,
-0.0127952863,
0.0562068895,
-0.0269217975,
0.0349978879,
-0.0058014733,
-0.0071065258,
-0.0153576406,
-0.0189239997,
-0.0361987427,
-0.0083871605,
-0.0065695615,
-0.0227082223,
0.0049144914,
0.0145725133,
-0.059305355,
0.0192056261,
-0.0604900755,
-0.0048587299,
0.0016149062,
-0.0077873208,
0.0010610424,
0.022827806,
0.0240551326,
0.0474393368,
0.0216716491,
0.0293090343,
0.0352591723,
0.0421408452,
-0.0901943892,
-0.0071646203,
-0.0397923775,
0.0083432486,
-0.0665741414,
0.0389546677,
-0.0510461368,
-0.0243629571,
-0.0175757539,
0.0349820592,
0.051195167,
-0.0079951966,
-0.0087282145,
0.0411203653,
-0.0131017696,
-0.0066569918,
-0.0042688614,
-0.000028009,
-0.0571901761,
-0.0203627776,
0.0495758131,
-0.0254774857,
-0.0209193975,
0.0426746011,
-0.0093072485,
-0.0167524796,
-0.0182743389,
0.009702825,
-0.0695251077,
-0.0509745665,
-0.0250357762,
-0.0335232802,
-0.0035470948,
-0.0138546405,
-0.0169656333,
-0.0123474859,
0.0344941318,
-0.0109293824,
-0.0165412296,
-0.021381259,
0.0049714241,
0.037798956,
-0.0317101814,
0.0216063671,
-0.0058421833,
0.0171949044,
0.0388732925,
0.0197057799,
0.0336529724,
0.0680023506,
0.0490618832,
0.0280106012,
0.0506841317,
0.0117540611,
-0.0092424816,
-0.0174508207,
0.0060652229,
0.0356723964,
-0.000521228,
0.04640349,
-0.0629828945,
-0.0031718307,
0.00284634,
0.0831625462,
-0.0501583591,
0.001451125,
0.0550911725,
0.0462021641,
-0.0111025404,
0.0111432225,
0.0196524523,
0.0767655894,
0.0139946155,
0.0599581674,
-0.0329123624,
0.0236174054,
-0.0091283387,
0.0469669811,
0.1036570817,
0.0011496035,
-0.0378055535,
-0.0781737193,
0.0227818657,
0.0172204264,
0.0149021707,
0.0176301077,
-0.006821509,
0.0333678797,
-0.0764165595,
0.0191558469,
-0.0033663609,
-0.0802236572,
0.0132416924,
-0.0129273869,
0.0155075612,
0.0649421215,
0.0484949239,
-0.0076923417,
-0.0514869615,
-0.0182780735,
0.0397778079,
0.0117866211,
0.0271322485,
-0.0384286456,
0.0180578511,
-0.0804923996,
-0.0116273649,
-0.0138631314,
-0.0123168239,
-0.0105348621,
0.0037221336,
-0.0559418835,
0.0424505509,
-0.0131659219,
-0.0468454584,
0.0161838233,
-0.0151563268,
-0.0314378701,
0.0081746299,
-0.003690643,
0.0162323434,
0.0467255749,
0.0176363084,
0.0032094109,
0.0361785404,
0.0018139199,
0.0055608344,
0.0174476095,
-0.0843874067,
-0.0653724521,
0.0010773968,
-0.0323577747,
-0.002710571,
-0.033657562,
-0.0346216708,
-0.0660082921,
-0.0015816613,
-0.0814286545,
0.0028127397,
-0.0506444685,
0.0048001213,
0.0355008543,
-0.0257878639,
-0.0472684987,
0.0249732062,
-0.0065439516,
-0.0278980471,
0.0825733021,
-0.0162753165,
-0.0058522229,
-0.062652126,
0.0081089456,
-0.0067134877,
-0.0028128147,
0.0020161292,
0.0411617346,
0.0056891907,
-0.0560429245,
-0.0232604705,
-0.1022522002,
0.0239691362,
-0.019612588,
0.0003387642,
0.0346229672,
0.0394023694,
-0.0149916587,
-0.0119990418,
-0.0630303472,
-0.0565639064,
0.0571660697,
0.0058088135,
0.0172715504,
0.0659713522,
0.0169441588,
-0.05096066,
-0.0087145949,
0.0113976812,
0.0368825272,
0.0128145963,
-0.0212569535,
-0.0192326754,
-0.0056800102,
-0.0104185576,
-0.0126183722,
-0.0147647522,
-0.0286077522,
-0.0059386394,
-0.0077018803,
0.0341002494,
0.055467695,
0.0701929852,
0.0127102723,
0.0112038981,
-0.0257461518,
-0.0597003624,
0.0434519649,
-0.0235448796,
0.0055768597,
-0.005859511,
-0.0085606454,
0.0387277417,
0.0135390079,
0.0403880738,
0.0224338416,
-0.0363133624,
0.0115804598,
0.0064821565,
-0.0224174671,
-0.0283520166,
-0.028604662,
-0.0037949027,
0.0116342148,
-0.0351926126,
-0.0127156004,
0.0713967755,
-0.0240362864,
-0.0330606177,
-0.0831559375,
-0.0183803625,
-0.0489574522,
0.0099818967,
-0.0230277199,
0.0452327803,
-0.0176502429,
-0.0463199653,
-0.0365940779,
-0.0461402722,
0.0323216468,
-0.0213708561,
0.0823019072,
-0.0406037122,
-0.0004752325,
-0.0035033645,
-0.0075026508,
-0.051057972,
-0.0385611951,
0.0014664029,
0.0028076365,
0.0183991902,
0.0049932725,
-0.0526114628,
0.0035327189,
0.0263169818,
0.0324410796,
-0.0378258638,
-0.0189569034,
-0.0169548448,
0.0198930427,
0.058696907,
0.0188425835,
-0.009694946,
-0.0661114529,
0.0742934272,
0.024614552,
0.0195147991,
-0.0579283312,
0.024961669,
-0.0080293408,
0.0106668286,
-0.0461190492,
0.0313236713,
-0.0016350333,
0.0661746189,
-0.0311352815,
-0.0038755524,
0.1191690192,
0.0163439494,
-0.0288106147,
-0.0262583084,
0.0185343362,
0.0374944471,
-0.000408657,
0.0015042977,
-0.0498179309,
-0.0360459611,
-0.0082659908,
0.0560925938,
0.0274657402,
-0.0093094343,
-0.0210318323,
-0.0714595616,
0.019068554,
0.0258516781,
-0.0318370312,
-0.04178074,
-0.0119194314,
-0.0126683703,
-0.0252347421,
0.0468038172,
0.0283330102,
-0.0413434021,
0.0115632601,
0.0185422897,
-0.0063236528,
0.0073197503,
-0.0305978451,
0.0121317329,
-0.0138287134,
0.0550946668,
0.0302859992,
0.0467036106,
0.0445661284,
0.0430046245,
-0.0453673527,
-0.005014345,
0.0092352359,
0.0835249424,
-0.0391276032,
0.0098550469,
-0.0273968708,
0.0531838387,
-0.0031840915,
-0.0004941159,
0.0114475545,
-0.0279612355,
-0.0220264643,
0.0315025188,
-0.0548910834,
0.0680320337,
-0.0093767708,
0.0913592055,
0.0456495695,
-0.0218419023,
0.0044643083,
-0.034992896,
0.0146963811,
-0.0882619694,
0.0079145748,
0.0102582229,
-0.0174394958,
0.0158941504,
-0.0809677169,
-0.0785978138,
0.0234684534,
-0.0094547663,
-0.0107023576,
-0.0047777002,
0.0257571954,
0.0121201649,
-0.00316625,
-0.0008275939,
-0.0278008655,
-0.0061125769,
-0.0815214664,
-0.0376907177,
0.0598448776,
-0.0457302555,
-0.0137809366,
0.0294189155,
-0.0380931348,
-0.0544371605,
-0.0504264086,
0.0512272567,
0.012567183,
0.078949675,
0.0110568125,
0.016748786,
0.0099955071,
0.0205091853,
-0.0138698732,
-0.0103027131,
0.0215932392,
0.0582722872,
-0.0208943151,
0.0224607326,
-0.0232943203,
0.0174222421,
-0.0426138714,
0.0388413854,
-0.0841629729,
-0.0937528014,
0.0215760171,
0.0208037402,
-0.0016779511,
0.0136760576,
0.0354194604,
-0.028264517,
0.0279048793,
-0.0198074356,
-0.0373113267,
-0.0547793917,
0.0445968732,
0.0025161682,
-0.0474477112,
-0.0007021662,
0.0329424329,
-0.0335389674,
0.0188148636,
-0.0522604696,
0.0126340846,
-0.0389406756,
-0.040542338,
-0.0329690427,
-0.0071116434,
-0.0511597507,
0.0277800281,
-0.003090848,
0.0273736659,
0.0121727018,
0.0640465319,
0.0131027708,
-0.0246426221,
0.0250029638,
0.0437801071,
-0.0733737946,
-0.0043813917,
-0.0454227924,
-0.0015432378,
-0.0007875814,
-0.0363506861,
0.0430477709,
0.0211115815,
0.0299455971,
-0.0209629759,
0.0511640459,
0.0094789555,
-0.0195528101,
-0.0310804062,
0.0284275152,
0.0225231834,
0.0008595964,
0.073151283,
-0.0312441606,
0.0175756663,
0.0349150859,
-0.0229422655,
-0.0593815111,
-0.050414782,
0.0117418235,
0.052986972,
-0.0039274348,
0.0129154492,
-0.005385566,
0.0119643072,
-0.0012316672,
-0.0132831065,
0.0181998424,
-0.0158228129,
0.0770292059,
0.0299344324,
-0.0206992142,
-0.0123927332,
-0.0484411456,
-0.0138202207,
-0.0404454879,
-0.0033884309,
-0.039219629,
-5.561798256e-33,
-0.0468186252,
-0.0059229904,
0.004672911,
-0.005277528,
-0.0403586291,
-0.0427309237,
-0.0406851806,
-0.0131218228,
-0.010493678,
-0.0166814197,
-0.0041832132,
0.0243985299,
0.0092890477,
0.0815688819,
-0.0361769013,
-0.0115811108,
0.0577767417,
0.001955729,
-0.0344126225,
0.0888059139,
0.0304387081,
0.0098896753,
0.0095457854,
-0.0561948568,
-0.0092659174,
-0.0470375419,
-0.024314668,
0.0228253324,
0.0254429933,
0.0524145365,
0.0091728065,
0.0158685464,
0.0132459952,
-0.0149387643,
-0.0458298251,
0.0157333873,
-0.0620698258,
0.0055363779,
0.0432548895,
-0.0009700636,
-0.0339574143,
-0.0385108851,
0.0144218169,
-0.0333302803,
0.0436126217,
-0.0482162163,
0.0307436995,
-0.0422108695,
-0.0226564575,
-0.0520547852,
-0.0121343052,
0.0233688224,
-0.0764230415,
-0.0698677599,
0.0103801424,
0.0797508359,
0.0355266072,
-0.0022735011,
0.0059522809,
0.0603378303,
0.0343621261,
0.0213894341,
0.0257269088,
0.0262496211,
-0.0216538589,
0.0482339114,
-0.0253368821,
-0.0018167601,
-0.0129766976,
0.0112320259,
-0.0270283278,
0.0320163853,
-0.0130881174,
0.0219145305,
-0.0049316348,
0.0408344939,
-0.0245787129,
0.0826668292,
-0.0128285214,
0.0107238656,
0.009406155,
0.0083284928,
-0.0229206383,
0.0004223919,
-0.0357660465,
0.0105601959,
-0.0084178578,
-0.0114221219,
0.0142074442,
0.0288465824,
-0.0516069196,
-0.0183280949,
0.027906768,
-0.0120644281,
0.0280776806,
0.0352894068,
-0.0219704118,
-0.0173699073,
-0.0189641975,
0.0023502756,
-0.020920692,
0.0029251196,
0.0532870963,
-0.0085466336,
-0.0288462918,
0.0206700452,
0.0350857824,
-0.0128900027,
-0.0218270887,
0.0203605946,
0.0305032898,
0.0532925054,
-0.0762811899,
0.0372421108,
-0.0162837338,
0.0458150133,
-0.0181309283,
0.0971928984,
-0.041569002,
-0.0019486413,
-0.029204512,
-0.0526542664,
0.0152265513,
0.0275881402,
-0.019719569,
0.0349303931,
-0.0009201527,
-0.0083771748,
0.0186184384,
-0.0237422325,
-0.0013419057,
0.0296571329,
2.341e-7,
0.0142409392,
0.0436848179,
0.0729779527,
0.0279542487,
-0.0431959927,
0.0273383334,
0.0223931242,
0.0136279725,
0.048732806,
-0.0221160073,
0.0389912426,
0.053985849,
0.0408473611,
0.0105482647,
-0.1112777889,
-0.0332685076,
-0.0774364024,
-0.0479870997,
-0.0343227312,
-0.0137716373,
0.0926628336,
0.0547337011,
-0.0404966474,
0.0124414377,
-0.0257443581,
-0.0285759978,
0.0132194962,
-0.0079868482,
-0.0622597039,
0.0672589168,
0.0460548773,
0.0289114136,
-0.0103426725,
-0.0055920524,
-0.0150312288,
0.0096654436,
0.0462035313,
0.0564290248,
0.0338982828,
-0.0571821406,
-0.0109228622,
0.0122572966,
0.02495379,
0.0120094689,
0.0314777493,
-0.036267411,
0.0199003872,
0.0261023436,
-0.0523179173,
0.0096802982,
-0.0007538004,
-0.020484712,
-0.0450663827,
0.0453626849,
0.0161353555,
-0.0266625714,
0.0292481892,
-0.0635880157,
-0.0069515025,
0.0004376083,
-0.0302789994,
-0.0225651953,
-0.0304432753,
0.0069087334,
-0.0234393887,
-0.0384840965,
-0.0096279737,
1.995667524e-34,
0.0642917603,
-0.0062523563,
0.0103295594,
-0.0001070709,
0.0466398858,
-0.0208123904,
-0.0153053459,
-0.030695159,
0.035026975,
-0.0979355127,
-0.010747388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10967v1 | EXMODD: An EXplanatory Multimodal Open-Domain Dialogue dataset | 2023-10-17T03:28:29 | 2023-10-17T03:28:29 | Hang Yin, Pinren Lu, Ziang Li, Bin Sun, Kan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | The need for high-quality data has been a key issue hindering the research of
dialogue tasks. Recent studies try to build datasets through manual, web
crawling, and large pre-trained models. However, man-made data is expensive and
data collected from the internet often includes generic responses, meaningless
statements, and toxic dialogues. Automatic data generation through large models
is a cost-effective method, but for open-domain multimodal dialogue tasks,
there are still three drawbacks: 1) There is currently no open-source large
model that can accept multimodal input; 2) The content generated by the model
lacks interpretability; 3) The generated data is usually difficult to quality
control and require extensive resource to collect. To alleviate the significant
human and resource expenditure in data collection, we propose a Multimodal Data
Construction Framework (MDCF). MDCF designs proper prompts to spur the
large-scale pre-trained language model to generate well-formed and satisfactory
content. Additionally, MDCF also automatically provides explanation for a given
image and its corresponding dialogue, which can provide a certain degree of
interpretability and facilitate manual follow-up quality inspection. Based on
this, we release an Explanatory Multimodal Open-Domain dialogue dataset
(EXMODD). Experiments indicate a positive correlation between the model's
ability to generate accurate understandings and high-quality responses. Our
code and data can be found at https://github.com/poplpr/EXMODD. | [
0.0285928119,
0.0628360212,
-0.0076829311,
0.0414124131,
0.0071098534,
0.0115201166,
0.0230926927,
-0.021557238,
-0.0182585511,
-0.053669095,
-0.0403979756,
-0.0317899287,
0.005756163,
0.0721617192,
0.029743582,
-0.0823947191,
0.0092474082,
-0.0446260795,
0.024741102,
0.0093074143,
0.060096439,
0.008117795,
-0.0503050834,
0.0714543611,
-0.0440367013,
-0.0310266986,
-0.079324834,
0.0314417146,
-0.0166420341,
-0.0332136452,
-0.0202770196,
0.0293048546,
0.0511704087,
-0.0004980161,
0.0000018594,
-0.0220384169,
0.0258660335,
-0.037795078,
-0.0176949576,
-0.0339973271,
0.0191508904,
-0.0163978506,
0.0207057763,
-0.0051575056,
-0.0214162339,
-0.0103901131,
0.0737557858,
0.0665770173,
0.1240298301,
0.057351958,
-0.0158977881,
-0.0300334115,
-0.0180629753,
0.0125203924,
0.0012173647,
-0.0091991453,
-0.0311548375,
0.0498739369,
0.0136774117,
0.0143165048,
-0.032954447,
0.0196691975,
0.0140788555,
-0.0540817305,
-0.0166077614,
0.0183246788,
0.0126830004,
-0.0617500693,
-0.0211809855,
0.1414561272,
0.0329896808,
0.0292377658,
-0.0151812704,
-0.0124842795,
0.0103047108,
0.0017617801,
-0.0625094995,
0.0458526239,
-0.0180021375,
0.0064551337,
-0.0762621462,
0.024431061,
-0.008125077,
-0.0005361669,
0.0019343127,
-0.0157715958,
-0.0272487402,
0.0188139174,
-0.0182339661,
-0.0385034792,
-0.037109375,
-0.0690372959,
-0.0226116739,
0.0364213958,
-0.043469429,
0.0202421676,
-0.0398623273,
-0.0305888038,
0.0123719182,
-0.0110809235,
0.0614819191,
0.0195243172,
-0.0763381124,
0.041208975,
0.0398078859,
0.0419156291,
-0.0175664779,
0.023200253,
0.0008306588,
0.0023581404,
-0.0394588858,
-0.0045768614,
-0.019287724,
-0.0055692643,
-0.0809600577,
-0.0403352454,
0.0108423457,
0.0290056597,
-0.003603722,
0.0006742229,
0.0112855416,
0.0280295648,
-0.0196444411,
0.0214921981,
-0.0625350922,
0.0320305638,
-0.0504282638,
0.0278037339,
0.0302178618,
-0.0362082832,
-0.0066941185,
0.0475527309,
0.023081908,
-0.0068850438,
-0.0218164623,
0.1028521433,
-0.021497922,
-0.0251412597,
-0.0021063322,
-0.0380101912,
-0.0261672996,
-0.0577801988,
0.0223356206,
-0.0124955587,
0.0460114069,
-0.0129897213,
-0.0131265745,
-0.0216434263,
0.0018718159,
0.007292876,
0.007180314,
0.0899558738,
-0.0435497276,
0.0244516209,
0.0307171755,
0.0006920021,
-0.0210283585,
0.0553498976,
0.0334759168,
0.0242049173,
0.057139907,
-0.022129165,
0.0233088806,
0.007167025,
0.0088361595,
-0.0171108916,
0.021253923,
0.036382284,
-0.0189038385,
0.0669086203,
0.0319545828,
0.0300609209,
-0.0508968942,
-0.0197673291,
0.0750271678,
0.016207248,
-0.0171744451,
-0.0249452796,
0.0192495864,
0.0190455019,
0.0089307623,
-0.0176222101,
-0.0341080278,
0.0636114329,
0.0386297107,
-0.0206149351,
0.0447151847,
0.0048634955,
-0.0325856246,
-0.0521570258,
0.0177079067,
-0.0167032257,
0.026026899,
-0.0002795162,
0.0260805786,
0.0311449058,
-0.0584353767,
0.0307019502,
-0.0027644548,
-0.068371214,
-0.0412828997,
-0.0273072552,
0.0533201769,
0.0500866696,
0.0267849825,
-0.0012162889,
-0.0315580107,
-0.0371941663,
0.0679702312,
0.03822916,
-0.0035508659,
-0.0131659843,
0.0617821813,
-0.0813015401,
-0.0524617024,
-0.0579454117,
-0.01289747,
0.0117823128,
-0.0047314134,
-0.038240049,
-0.009382749,
-0.0131672295,
0.0113706691,
0.029679155,
0.0256767776,
-0.0098944148,
-0.025627356,
0.0014755533,
0.0288115852,
0.030599216,
-0.02361238,
-0.0125728371,
0.0256170016,
-0.0004823373,
0.0121326372,
0.0313191451,
-0.0408001877,
-0.0370841771,
0.0162161309,
-0.0534240715,
-0.00964972,
0.0110149365,
-0.0478728004,
-0.0327508189,
0.0117616542,
-0.0463290177,
-0.0065964493,
-0.0671893209,
-0.0322014429,
0.0452194624,
0.0312239286,
-0.0063495878,
0.0277296249,
-0.0087503325,
-0.0085479245,
0.0435990132,
0.0215929393,
0.0349981822,
-0.0363452882,
-0.0102313375,
0.0186221562,
-0.028185349,
0.028195696,
-0.0034347069,
0.0137667125,
-0.0500752628,
0.0273173321,
-0.0944189057,
-0.0114875743,
-0.000189404,
-0.0186558682,
0.0129115544,
-0.0054716691,
0.006130042,
-0.0310855284,
-0.0250978172,
0.0325582512,
0.0509049296,
0.0001045357,
0.0333577506,
0.0239706282,
0.0183117762,
-0.0116550615,
0.0086603779,
0.0419781208,
0.0646480992,
-0.0041041477,
0.0178879146,
-0.0456641316,
-0.0001773733,
-0.044709757,
0.0311534144,
-0.032307446,
-0.057323277,
0.0542829297,
0.0027734076,
0.0206830576,
0.0432077497,
0.0224330593,
0.0370054655,
0.0037860365,
-0.0379785039,
-0.0550361015,
0.0046115904,
-0.0021167472,
0.0030024869,
-0.0302745551,
-0.0025715937,
-0.0026499478,
0.0273685213,
0.0152293444,
0.0543323681,
-0.0389464684,
0.0160508938,
0.0362597369,
-0.054508958,
-0.0443763249,
-0.0140401311,
-0.0220341496,
0.0592687987,
-0.0385863185,
-0.0552104115,
0.0308115222,
-0.0339273699,
-0.0378215797,
0.0164780803,
0.0164715257,
0.0006009826,
0.0936228484,
-0.0073947646,
0.0317926928,
0.0368963555,
-0.0130510712,
-0.0154263545,
-0.0090031698,
0.0241027679,
-0.000646726,
0.0281338748,
-0.0585257001,
-0.0171316527,
-0.002217442,
-0.0218498632,
-0.0359456874,
-0.0361795351,
-0.0042085797,
-0.0480466634,
-0.0236306489,
-0.0185576435,
-0.0021284157,
0.0095573831,
0.0260506738,
0.0153264431,
-0.0010631961,
0.0048489459,
-0.0324157551,
0.0346935689,
0.0350462757,
0.0774035454,
-0.0065613054,
-0.0495369174,
0.0344273448,
0.047473155,
-0.0069157551,
-0.0458251722,
-0.0531472526,
0.0075365584,
-0.0132642388,
0.048870828,
0.0072807199,
0.0110174716,
0.0920296982,
-0.0187109653,
0.0198588204,
0.0682754666,
0.0053275526,
0.0016500647,
-0.0069583324,
0.0129416073,
0.0065072333,
0.0183838774,
-0.0191433206,
-0.081570968,
-0.0580218472,
0.0031955536,
-0.0000794919,
0.0112049673,
-0.014700369,
-0.0106355501,
-0.0999072492,
0.0468372107,
-0.0318804309,
-0.0284150578,
-0.0068793222,
-0.0083360206,
-0.0029901739,
-0.0034158123,
-0.0139560839,
0.024316676,
0.0261229388,
-0.0020267549,
0.0124843679,
0.013525418,
-0.0334717557,
0.0265193023,
-0.0318887904,
0.0317397714,
0.0417947471,
0.0349818841,
0.0319400243,
-0.0277911015,
0.0421046913,
0.0186918806,
0.0013860962,
-0.0027067263,
0.1041773781,
0.0045451326,
-0.0311203599,
-0.0305495262,
0.0434398614,
-0.0136313112,
-0.0237416588,
-0.0110113751,
0.0184832811,
-0.0539420433,
0.0316701941,
-0.0365405902,
0.0277093947,
0.0325801224,
0.0491405092,
0.0365544334,
-0.0443423502,
-0.0406555235,
-0.0134791052,
-0.0228280257,
-0.0556712709,
0.0111536356,
0.0242750049,
0.0067346622,
-0.0056006792,
-0.0685447454,
-0.0372797474,
0.0394957215,
0.046462141,
-0.01146165,
-0.039888937,
-0.0435164273,
0.052870132,
-0.018196851,
0.0723772198,
0.010898021,
0.0125275571,
-0.0498038493,
-0.0137306983,
0.0259876549,
-0.0419450477,
-0.0038907144,
0.0544531681,
-0.0311360415,
-0.0271256994,
-0.0361064561,
0.0883660689,
0.0197620913,
0.0355399363,
0.0566008911,
-0.0384236723,
-0.0062462883,
0.0036493258,
-0.045460511,
-0.0314191021,
0.0434314758,
0.030159995,
0.0022685777,
0.0231132247,
-0.0172599964,
0.0382830687,
-0.0323642604,
0.0073467689,
-0.0276505072,
-0.0553259626,
0.007899344,
0.0058676777,
0.0433148108,
-0.0162114371,
-0.0267534815,
-0.0432999916,
0.0028637669,
-0.0269248225,
-0.0069215614,
-0.0972624198,
0.0449820943,
-0.0228681117,
-0.0192119125,
0.0133574205,
-0.0230908245,
-0.0231517535,
0.037043009,
-0.0266307704,
0.0301094651,
0.033796858,
0.0084268423,
0.0007566874,
0.0213280637,
-0.0041430118,
0.0253906082,
-0.0199278332,
0.0094334483,
0.013067578,
0.1169351116,
0.0225813165,
-0.0301535465,
0.0151341362,
0.0520416684,
-0.0168764852,
-0.0183571558,
-0.0251966398,
0.0090287616,
0.0145121142,
0.0330994278,
0.0503254756,
-0.0061937692,
0.0012322798,
-0.0055793962,
0.1204820648,
0.0226139277,
-0.0500470698,
0.0674051344,
0.0124163488,
-0.0132894525,
-0.0310276207,
0.0543904789,
-0.0302614477,
0.0011793197,
0.0101636592,
0.0199696962,
-0.0678305104,
-0.0251106583,
0.0265537649,
0.0336539485,
0.0109880557,
0.0234625395,
0.0179475714,
-0.0454444923,
-0.0415635817,
0.0427510887,
-0.0166348908,
0.0060833269,
0.0685457811,
0.0417994037,
0.008895454,
-0.0006999676,
-0.0350440182,
-0.0084198387,
-0.0182151608,
-0.0040363953,
0.0007238433,
-5.373130678e-33,
-0.0193406921,
-0.0503880344,
0.0335971601,
-0.0298999995,
-0.0086320769,
-0.019806657,
-0.0525667183,
0.0197937228,
-0.0022856952,
0.0052883341,
0.0315897986,
-0.0110755479,
-0.0032628544,
0.0414495803,
-0.0233448483,
-0.0056342925,
0.0333308019,
-0.0133258235,
-0.0148028452,
0.03863208,
0.0608457737,
0.008970974,
0.0225317311,
-0.0678639412,
0.013723474,
0.0165003557,
-0.0560611896,
0.0201844629,
0.0194650311,
0.0696365237,
-0.0278857406,
0.0411163755,
0.0146821737,
-0.0379330777,
-0.0437451713,
0.0378490277,
-0.0660989434,
0.0062430678,
0.0232634973,
0.0138804382,
-0.0851266161,
0.0013037514,
0.0082656564,
-0.024654638,
0.0232634414,
-0.0300037377,
0.0360733084,
-0.0134566482,
0.015330404,
0.0208954979,
-0.0242670011,
0.0159759223,
-0.0439287573,
-0.0865919441,
0.0139415553,
0.0759797767,
0.0176228974,
-0.0040147235,
-0.0092480248,
0.0303889606,
-0.0074870144,
-0.034012679,
0.0625074059,
0.0202511642,
0.0089716613,
0.0708935037,
0.00747965,
-0.0205101669,
-0.0324648134,
0.0112540228,
-0.0106678912,
0.0878631473,
0.0086415336,
0.0905987397,
0.0047050999,
-0.0105241993,
-0.0357332453,
0.0265413728,
-0.0573920459,
0.0292775407,
0.0008288455,
0.0033315488,
0.0175597463,
0.0135929948,
-0.0326723307,
0.0186106637,
-0.0234857462,
-0.0340834558,
0.045079343,
0.0011994622,
-0.0060911286,
-0.0196769256,
0.0755958781,
-0.0477055348,
0.0023592003,
0.0075162202,
-0.0288216416,
0.0264136028,
-0.0053690528,
-0.0317232087,
-0.0034508838,
-0.0166361108,
0.0631647334,
-0.0073946086,
0.0298639089,
0.0264384374,
0.0204899628,
0.0266715605,
-0.0340525396,
0.008947257,
-0.025569614,
0.0567880012,
-0.0307836775,
0.0437362865,
-0.0034471417,
-0.0040458571,
-0.0880500749,
0.0603758581,
-0.0348883681,
-0.0159656946,
-0.0488852561,
-0.0685845762,
0.0122684212,
0.0047169533,
-0.0429285429,
0.0045568198,
-0.0429998599,
-0.0719956681,
0.0212609395,
-0.0696663633,
-0.0018269616,
0.0321441367,
2.424e-7,
0.0030460013,
0.0149292201,
0.0200939681,
0.0361397527,
0.0332836546,
0.0555264242,
-0.010642726,
0.0129533466,
-0.0065046428,
-0.0718003213,
0.0004051902,
0.0289293155,
0.0479090922,
0.0223958381,
-0.0373535976,
-0.0022042275,
-0.0329258852,
-0.0339963101,
-0.0536456667,
0.0351039022,
0.0887569785,
0.062066216,
-0.0441197529,
-0.0130148996,
0.0177459698,
-0.0147312488,
0.0577492267,
-0.0419351459,
-0.0130391847,
-0.0175259542,
0.0369128324,
-0.025812339,
-0.0010628095,
-0.0095130196,
-0.0056235879,
-0.0388405807,
0.0138245914,
0.0437264554,
-0.0061780913,
-0.0818229765,
-0.0014509381,
0.0040308107,
-0.015752757,
-0.0428178944,
0.0521584675,
-0.0475655273,
-0.0655042008,
-0.0226980858,
-0.0251101386,
-0.0438423157,
-0.0003592032,
-0.030929083,
-0.0069316062,
0.0195672326,
0.0257815737,
-0.0284374617,
0.0170416962,
-0.0803123489,
-0.0319962054,
-0.0272502396,
-0.0622854829,
-0.0209054202,
-0.0329222456,
-0.0469225012,
0.0259796157,
-0.0195356999,
-0.0382907949,
1.555414584e-34,
0.0291009452,
-0.0138590951,
0.0262787268,
0.0049543511,
0.0316689275,
-0.0004562919,
-0.0080488287,
-0.030342903,
0.0247781035,
-0.054020714,
-0.026942296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10962v2 | Large Language Models can Contrastively Refine their Generation for Better Sentence Representation Learning | 2023-10-17T03:21:43 | 2024-05-17T06:47:30 | Huiming Wang, Zhaodonghui Li, Liying Cheng, Soh De Wen, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have emerged as a groundbreaking
technology and their unparalleled text generation capabilities have sparked
interest in their application to the fundamental sentence representation
learning task. Existing methods have explored utilizing LLMs as data annotators
to generate synthesized data for training contrastive learning based sentence
embedding models such as SimCSE. However, since contrastive learning models are
sensitive to the quality of sentence pairs, the effectiveness of these methods
is largely influenced by the content generated from LLMs, highlighting the need
for more refined generation in the context of sentence representation learning.
Building upon this premise, we propose MultiCSR, a multi-level contrastive
sentence representation learning framework that decomposes the process of
prompting LLMs to generate a corpus for training base sentence embedding models
into three stages (i.e., sentence generation, sentence pair construction,
in-batch training) and refines the generated content at these three distinct
stages, ensuring only high-quality sentence pairs are utilized to train a base
contrastive learning model. Our extensive experiments reveal that MultiCSR
enables a less advanced LLM to surpass the performance of ChatGPT, while
applying it to ChatGPT achieves better state-of-the-art results. Comprehensive
analyses further underscore the potential of our framework in various
application scenarios and achieving better sentence representation learning
with LLMs. | [
0.0345885828,
0.0490534566,
-0.0036260695,
0.0319618993,
-0.0631388724,
0.0193383507,
0.0161542892,
-0.0499674715,
0.0228189267,
-0.0728509277,
-0.0009367223,
-0.0451079458,
-0.0167018156,
-0.0060953242,
0.0419299752,
-0.0625910163,
0.0256938431,
0.0109106693,
-0.005498921,
0.0136720063,
0.0338484496,
0.0500877313,
0.0347815305,
0.0387344845,
-0.023494361,
-0.0552550294,
0.0027621579,
0.0321031287,
0.0298312325,
-0.0419266373,
0.0608532466,
0.0475276411,
0.0529408865,
0.0216288827,
0.0000017905,
-0.0070736236,
-0.0150725823,
-0.0062850486,
0.0104105435,
0.0370854028,
0.0940019563,
-0.0280185733,
0.0131450593,
0.0471141264,
-0.0270771142,
0.0151919508,
0.0076786927,
0.0514937565,
0.072009407,
0.0942458287,
-0.0186982621,
-0.0579494014,
0.0186533835,
-0.0383128636,
-0.0361804925,
0.0167415198,
0.0004982837,
0.0325204991,
-0.0137811573,
0.0505321249,
-0.0023731252,
0.0052831448,
0.0333487429,
0.0018935207,
-0.0080538066,
0.0338257216,
-0.0125316009,
0.0181982573,
-0.0229528975,
0.0639226288,
-0.0186209083,
-0.0128894439,
-0.0044245566,
-0.0046370858,
-0.0152614322,
-0.0294079948,
-0.0294524524,
0.0264622793,
-0.0126718432,
0.0621925332,
0.0583091639,
0.0004425672,
0.0128623415,
0.0051698862,
-0.0057767569,
-0.0550126657,
0.0282228105,
-0.0382147841,
-0.0183463041,
0.0099051297,
-0.0494233929,
-0.0230280776,
-0.0009292472,
-0.0061423057,
-0.0562585779,
0.0027854352,
-0.0538423657,
-0.0490657762,
0.0244631246,
-0.0276282597,
0.0518143214,
0.0417400263,
-0.004120687,
0.0241851155,
-0.026823571,
0.038890738,
-0.0158185903,
-0.0169334635,
-0.0685728267,
-0.0218763947,
-0.0419203639,
-0.0203401204,
-0.052413065,
0.0145750102,
-0.06051597,
-0.0387178063,
-0.029148763,
0.0328419879,
0.0104092304,
0.0029646328,
0.0364612825,
0.0148784081,
-0.0482237861,
-0.0070757219,
0.0087053925,
0.0166160297,
-0.0216778144,
0.0074966131,
0.0396836139,
-0.0402306318,
-0.0195600912,
0.029626457,
0.011070244,
-0.0370306075,
0.0166495014,
0.0359022953,
-0.0245855041,
-0.0440604687,
-0.0592836738,
-0.0193274375,
-0.0291543324,
-0.0694307536,
-0.0062353197,
-0.0597741157,
0.0264275726,
-0.0039509502,
-0.0000842776,
-0.0211301204,
0.0155132571,
0.0369048305,
-0.0218640976,
0.043861758,
-0.0069030635,
-0.0297253057,
-0.0397890136,
-0.0068986043,
0.0041677542,
0.0704105422,
0.0444337502,
0.0056101331,
-0.0006714322,
0.02057123,
-0.0134011097,
-0.0041896952,
-0.01452283,
0.0046947259,
-0.0163561534,
0.0055733225,
0.0235956497,
0.0371828601,
0.0517901741,
0.0764687881,
-0.025083812,
0.0119884182,
0.0648444816,
0.001985929,
0.034646254,
0.0555007681,
0.0951059312,
0.0452887714,
-0.0359825604,
0.0513845533,
0.0006343574,
0.0192052573,
0.0145247942,
0.028880978,
0.0435937829,
0.0615099221,
-0.0357527398,
-0.0157385282,
-0.0175404437,
-0.0243104771,
-0.0000151207,
-0.0244548712,
0.0156684946,
0.0257853363,
-0.0690377131,
0.0303045195,
0.0518746562,
-0.0598515049,
-0.0025629783,
-0.005451689,
0.0043210192,
0.0907349512,
0.029789174,
0.0026516775,
-0.0064204428,
-0.0149180526,
0.0077113439,
0.0565094501,
0.0419115722,
-0.0080841836,
0.0089507792,
-0.0577374622,
-0.0063173617,
-0.0746568963,
0.0211008433,
0.0034866561,
-0.0035848028,
-0.0062391632,
0.0427976623,
-0.0148699274,
-0.0073372372,
0.0371679217,
-0.0292670764,
0.0036651939,
0.0246230233,
-0.0061255684,
-0.0070842579,
0.0123444572,
-0.0254543219,
0.0144201107,
0.0113207418,
-0.0654939041,
-0.0065116328,
0.0171404034,
-0.0790408775,
-0.1382549256,
0.0082178051,
-0.0453205369,
-0.0069982503,
0.0559583195,
-0.0667382106,
-0.0249420796,
-0.0033891806,
-0.0481698439,
0.0224925671,
-0.0585043207,
-0.0138406754,
0.0508605316,
0.0404733568,
-0.0216518268,
0.0709019378,
-0.0101665566,
-0.0092564104,
0.024101425,
0.0372681394,
0.0014012537,
-0.0402724482,
-0.0026915136,
-0.0503663719,
0.0231316462,
0.0299115013,
0.0018448601,
0.033308059,
-0.0350013338,
-0.0440956913,
-0.0876058713,
0.0386265442,
-0.0288833696,
0.0011816447,
0.0457755141,
0.002839834,
0.0121156778,
0.0157307982,
-0.0500965379,
-0.0172671378,
0.0122743389,
0.0219099466,
0.0347000621,
-0.0336021073,
-0.0128788892,
-0.03441168,
0.0182664003,
-0.0142205302,
0.0773272738,
-0.0279852133,
0.0084537892,
-0.0598939583,
0.0596346371,
0.01184492,
-0.0145830838,
0.0075660874,
-0.0300277714,
-0.014131044,
0.0044116126,
0.0772997886,
0.0500773489,
0.0427229106,
0.0427748375,
0.0251466781,
-0.003425631,
-0.0191056095,
0.0218095444,
-0.02133164,
0.030740384,
-0.0207072794,
-0.0402443744,
-0.006447203,
0.0825228915,
0.0120001417,
-0.0074849525,
-0.0531740636,
0.0152417561,
0.0122239897,
0.0022579669,
-0.004992648,
0.0147777069,
-0.0283673108,
-0.0236017499,
-0.0490973815,
-0.0188388228,
0.0446078554,
-0.0394191332,
-0.0045228554,
-0.0499263667,
-0.0267544873,
-0.0408108532,
0.019104084,
0.0064689745,
0.031041408,
0.0125788935,
0.0130051337,
-0.0475850143,
-0.0077861212,
0.0032964956,
-0.0114754383,
0.0097735878,
-0.0171290468,
-0.0066215787,
-0.0229250845,
-0.0490183756,
-0.0347245783,
-0.0570551306,
-0.0328456536,
0.0473276339,
0.0588322319,
0.0081026126,
-0.0024002881,
-0.0117414137,
0.0039277677,
0.0355897434,
-0.0166308619,
-0.0115839709,
-0.0236917902,
0.0862655193,
0.0595800318,
0.0073913415,
0.005981918,
-0.0309086796,
0.0401356257,
0.0458753593,
-0.0103738327,
0.0236090124,
-0.0513327718,
0.0157667641,
-0.0097167762,
-0.0051769754,
-0.0013472683,
-0.0002284832,
0.0510705076,
-0.0353651233,
-0.0487180464,
0.1013969854,
0.0187331364,
-0.0213843212,
0.0052294149,
0.024568649,
0.0550184436,
0.013735367,
0.0017755721,
-0.0847562179,
-0.0435827449,
-0.0074660485,
-0.0130187729,
-0.0014919552,
-0.0109333349,
-0.0348149166,
-0.1039665267,
0.0453594327,
0.0180526171,
-0.0273433756,
-0.017253885,
-0.0151083907,
-0.0292912293,
0.0020885563,
0.0400971733,
0.0129887694,
-0.0368923061,
0.0046623847,
0.0259308591,
-0.0253466051,
-0.0517474674,
0.0020948725,
-0.0444917157,
0.0272317212,
0.0304448921,
0.0339965113,
0.0307484083,
-0.0047553815,
0.0222320743,
-0.0490409583,
0.0061941277,
-0.0147616453,
0.0407356136,
-0.0338619202,
-0.011947711,
-0.0343242474,
0.0267924238,
-0.0285934508,
-0.0341690518,
-0.005431667,
0.0590368435,
0.0175640155,
0.0094549935,
-0.0304996092,
0.0325149149,
0.0244378522,
0.0859417245,
0.0651550367,
-0.0652745962,
-0.0362417251,
-0.0209842082,
0.0094116116,
-0.0684150085,
-0.0002224186,
0.0226109028,
0.0055978117,
0.0542208888,
-0.0686503202,
-0.0730944127,
-0.0004047868,
-0.0021992391,
-0.034998253,
0.0086087938,
-0.0648724064,
-0.0221386608,
-0.0277823154,
0.0162236895,
-0.0426003896,
0.0152751338,
-0.0105962856,
-0.0225120299,
0.0302176476,
-0.0432169177,
-0.0363431051,
-0.0046372758,
-0.0833199024,
-0.0624522157,
-0.0384148732,
0.0410053916,
0.0039437423,
0.0391723551,
0.0270390734,
0.0082564959,
0.0586920455,
0.0469547883,
-0.0246704444,
0.0064182039,
0.036255341,
0.0265864264,
0.0046568108,
0.0390287228,
-0.0210138913,
0.0147647997,
0.0188358407,
0.0854796097,
0.0216643624,
-0.0209289249,
0.0382394046,
-0.0124000078,
0.0417241231,
-0.0324630216,
0.0163706988,
-0.0288704671,
0.0008587791,
-0.0440213531,
-0.0260774735,
-0.0631662384,
0.0237351116,
0.0003439314,
0.0173195153,
-0.0316004008,
0.015770087,
-0.0051786383,
0.0394074507,
-0.0059189843,
-0.0058479449,
0.0100094918,
-0.0169711355,
0.0042573758,
0.0006854277,
-0.0338395461,
-0.0073231286,
-0.0368255265,
-0.0015308271,
-0.0070841708,
0.0459218957,
0.0031124831,
-0.0095750215,
-0.0378133096,
0.0285319909,
-0.0473132692,
0.0153255267,
-0.0566518679,
-0.0107990252,
0.0965456367,
-0.0131870164,
0.0505017899,
-0.0369893983,
-0.0143087478,
-0.0201382488,
0.0768058822,
-0.0118967844,
-0.0208503809,
0.0038776684,
-0.0033778916,
-0.0418226048,
-0.0044441661,
0.0852875337,
-0.0140323713,
0.0409610383,
0.0242455248,
-0.0036671187,
-0.0529311709,
-0.0197939202,
0.0215935819,
0.0059754997,
0.0166445598,
-0.0052091996,
-0.0337504186,
-0.0679506212,
0.0438101776,
0.016468158,
0.0046016295,
0.0026320014,
0.0463164821,
0.0248988736,
-0.0234729629,
0.0020776764,
-0.0473772958,
0.0051671853,
0.000040709,
-0.0378227122,
-0.0431598425,
-6.348864825e-33,
-0.0101928227,
0.0114272311,
0.0020446826,
-0.0269885007,
-0.0363242254,
0.0092909019,
-0.0428439192,
-0.0139619727,
0.0094461236,
0.0314248167,
0.0042159637,
-0.0197000448,
-0.0075366031,
0.0528742708,
-0.0244349968,
0.0008607753,
0.0776945502,
0.0010644965,
-0.0113824448,
0.0277503617,
0.0320121273,
0.043288298,
0.0542956144,
-0.0293143988,
-0.0264862627,
-0.0178520307,
-0.0078979209,
0.0225387756,
0.006334391,
0.0602717958,
-0.0370312072,
0.0573822781,
0.0339310057,
-0.027174389,
-0.0178131331,
0.0328191929,
-0.0486535914,
0.0030702879,
0.0068059452,
-0.0424304344,
-0.0522037782,
-0.0770754367,
0.0062033706,
-0.0154327443,
0.0229376387,
-0.0395125188,
0.0276834741,
-0.0324695259,
-0.0028713257,
-0.0336895585,
-0.0647521541,
0.0083593596,
-0.0037171659,
-0.0227983054,
-0.027780829,
0.0496128835,
0.0170650482,
0.0548700355,
-0.0051493412,
-0.0168079585,
0.0115529308,
0.0303972419,
0.0001920455,
0.0139919752,
-0.0009011402,
0.0690327436,
-0.0111317094,
-0.006097679,
0.0070351558,
-0.0041132285,
-0.0172332302,
0.033992894,
0.033793401,
0.1075170189,
0.0129996687,
0.0038919188,
-0.0830936804,
0.0195551831,
0.0043242238,
-0.0041308221,
0.0539804325,
-0.0108637381,
0.003285978,
-0.0167538691,
-0.0178898573,
-0.0387525819,
-0.0231014732,
-0.0170065332,
0.0327091813,
0.0374045931,
-0.0171659756,
-0.0217473358,
0.0368615463,
-0.0349195711,
0.002354739,
0.0212490764,
-0.0498117767,
-0.0126038976,
0.0027330064,
0.0185785796,
-0.0539999194,
-0.0382850952,
0.023215279,
0.0155199375,
-0.0134708816,
0.0030770546,
0.0712689459,
-0.0016000204,
-0.0641427711,
0.0359012671,
-0.0224579368,
0.012456229,
-0.0407007001,
-0.0057224664,
0.0233205352,
0.0099288132,
-0.022672914,
0.0548067726,
0.0231705923,
-0.0073902761,
-0.0382246561,
-0.0139447721,
-0.0058169127,
0.0577693358,
-0.0003815718,
0.0318082795,
-0.0470288396,
0.001617959,
0.0435423329,
-0.0555952303,
-0.0238859504,
-0.0071011656,
2.385e-7,
0.0146157779,
0.0211530719,
0.0129278926,
0.0124929184,
0.019569423,
0.0387409739,
-0.0029962137,
0.0553036407,
0.001385639,
0.0033355416,
0.0281267408,
0.027418036,
0.0774916038,
0.0055787368,
-0.0949008465,
0.0589861684,
-0.1109896749,
-0.016121015,
-0.0371244885,
-0.0010515925,
0.0883835256,
0.1060859859,
0.0048681106,
-0.0063460069,
0.0242653303,
-0.0244427584,
0.1100284904,
-0.0305076391,
-0.0376432724,
-0.0069060521,
-0.0072556078,
0.0365235843,
-0.0098863179,
-0.0088889161,
0.0030537273,
0.0347918347,
-0.0183040146,
0.062467359,
0.0483603403,
-0.0216132421,
0.0265997015,
0.0066182609,
-0.0157126877,
-0.0331299864,
0.0577259883,
-0.0928095356,
-0.0066945371,
-0.0702984259,
-0.0398321189,
-0.0050776186,
0.0177930892,
-0.0242945086,
-0.038742397,
0.0105591184,
0.008988589,
0.0122098308,
-0.0115900934,
-0.0629693195,
-0.0223643165,
0.0322824083,
-0.0556341447,
-0.0313825421,
-0.0210681576,
0.0205925163,
0.0388332009,
-0.065210335,
0.0299139079,
2.392636329e-34,
0.0600721687,
-0.0197265595,
0.0138666909,
0.0168382842,
0.0255514085,
-0.0143668437,
-0.0058911522,
-0.0312956348,
0.0147971483,
-0.0842961892,
-0.0117291668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10956v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10956v1 | Computing the optimal keyboard through a geometric analysis of the English language | 2023-10-17T03:05:42 | 2023-10-17T03:05:42 | Jules Deschamps, Quentin Hubert, Lucas Ryckelynck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | In the context of a group project for the course COMSW4995 002 - Geometric
Data Analysis, we bring our attention to the design of fast-typing keyboards.
Leveraging some geometric tools in an optimization framework allowed us to
propose novel keyboard layouts that offer a faster typing. | [
0.014347028,
-0.0475198291,
-0.0356961936,
0.0515737422,
-0.0798428506,
-0.0299707334,
0.0483680293,
0.0261283964,
0.0108558489,
0.0377384983,
0.0185560361,
-0.0599262491,
0.0557692759,
0.022361774,
0.0170128662,
-0.0626660362,
-0.0128822979,
-0.0331111476,
-0.0495359749,
0.0007329337,
-0.0200915057,
-0.0103815924,
-0.061921332,
-0.0033942591,
-0.0168556012,
-0.0097287362,
-0.0712371767,
-0.0081968419,
-0.0109092798,
0.0063131363,
-0.012916849,
0.0453900546,
-0.0419619009,
0.0385740325,
0.0000014263,
-0.021706,
0.0449684151,
0.0195730161,
0.0124077275,
0.0549182855,
0.0457684584,
0.0213611946,
-0.0204849299,
-0.0249528363,
0.0187784247,
0.0139080863,
0.019756576,
0.0047705313,
-0.039580185,
0.027756324,
-0.0352714024,
-0.0263973847,
-0.0123939142,
-0.028868081,
0.006838582,
0.0319709107,
0.0105023105,
-0.0530344062,
0.0569917671,
0.0318444483,
-0.0068364316,
0.0381839946,
-0.0081358477,
0.008226986,
0.0355074927,
0.0095893154,
0.0018346773,
0.0218943637,
-0.0392137058,
0.0587232932,
0.0044261063,
0.012345125,
0.0707981586,
-0.0090164803,
0.0078259716,
0.0435408838,
-0.0128907738,
-0.071231693,
-0.0473073199,
-0.0699938834,
-0.0506160557,
-0.0118984254,
-0.0553721525,
-0.0299734697,
0.025646152,
-0.0055556465,
0.0639072806,
-0.0336975977,
-0.0134443436,
-0.0351378284,
0.0306079388,
-0.0416725688,
0.0455648229,
0.0342232473,
0.0011128683,
-0.0056857732,
-0.0029725479,
-0.0351873636,
-0.0031128493,
-0.1227910742,
0.0779528841,
-0.0009293312,
0.1199243143,
0.0025423428,
-0.0618673488,
0.0319780111,
-0.0217388272,
-0.0145515613,
-0.0328120142,
0.0867225975,
0.0087008663,
-0.0151117323,
-0.0222382694,
-0.0083955554,
0.0022759838,
0.0042025801,
-0.0207311641,
0.0678460076,
0.0694220588,
-0.0074278088,
0.0436541252,
0.0033351069,
0.046652548,
-0.0319055542,
0.0072374344,
-0.0663378611,
-0.0529048778,
0.0006146256,
-0.0657295436,
0.0095653208,
0.0274877958,
-0.0033531531,
0.0462332144,
0.0004618765,
-0.0089145582,
0.0618706383,
-0.014418277,
0.0352869183,
0.0091464845,
0.00146001,
-0.044342164,
0.0334595703,
-0.0282077752,
-0.0327412039,
-0.0027201874,
-0.000557214,
-0.0286592748,
-0.0083672227,
-0.0146206962,
0.0084904637,
0.0254732314,
-0.000200892,
0.0400226191,
0.0579861738,
0.0692503825,
-0.0351200737,
-0.0360536538,
0.0606847219,
0.0106273536,
0.0958373472,
0.0208904017,
-0.0582399592,
0.0338568315,
0.0802682713,
-0.0130604366,
-0.0085384576,
0.0045379903,
-0.0412607938,
0.0173751153,
0.020544704,
-0.0388292223,
0.0212252773,
0.0076432191,
0.03572971,
0.0614336729,
0.1033879966,
0.0509516597,
0.0510362387,
-0.0592252128,
-0.0327752344,
-0.0033352785,
-0.0275863688,
-0.0086712809,
0.0075865579,
-0.0255027302,
0.0204552766,
0.0118336612,
0.0447312221,
0.0166740566,
-0.0265885107,
-0.0245653559,
-0.029097883,
-0.0491212234,
-0.001524265,
0.0479501039,
-0.0210110713,
-0.0629232079,
0.0190837197,
-0.0147005571,
-0.0650112033,
-0.0675860494,
0.0045188838,
-0.0043593612,
0.0152843613,
0.0124304052,
-0.0193135291,
0.0170054007,
0.0433693938,
0.0038902985,
-0.0098386183,
0.0525817499,
-0.0045740441,
0.023855675,
0.0212808903,
-0.0127837164,
0.0730298534,
0.0112344259,
0.0113036698,
-0.0088564688,
0.0278257411,
0.0104513476,
0.0012403768,
0.0062397132,
0.0059919171,
-0.0018948581,
-0.009760621,
-0.021406075,
0.0531629324,
-0.0267945938,
0.03093821,
-0.0217887722,
0.0168378968,
0.002516804,
-0.0772891715,
0.0445653908,
-0.020824302,
0.0176332742,
0.0589595214,
0.0674023405,
-0.0598312244,
0.0126034319,
0.0048634401,
0.0535711087,
0.0013758787,
0.0261564348,
-0.0179198496,
0.0648526847,
0.0196191277,
0.0152427759,
-0.0560133792,
-0.0531094074,
-0.0181013774,
0.0278980229,
-0.0019286496,
0.07871259,
-0.0296064205,
-0.0430141091,
0.0680751726,
0.0162163042,
-0.0082848789,
0.0408330075,
-0.0367321409,
0.0259213522,
0.037322782,
0.0055013299,
0.0214343891,
-0.0435687341,
-0.0379327871,
-0.0218867902,
0.0246617682,
0.04341859,
0.0301953815,
0.0164793935,
-0.0161352009,
-0.0019511549,
-0.036903087,
-0.0409464128,
-0.0469023585,
-0.0171809793,
0.0298684966,
-0.0323936939,
-0.0395191386,
-0.0212349705,
-0.0124280974,
-0.0279847141,
-0.0335464962,
0.0322294869,
-0.0322257616,
-0.0240902714,
0.091049619,
0.0633897111,
0.0171757154,
0.0036171428,
-0.0381271131,
0.0020304727,
-0.0100581991,
0.0571004897,
0.0823085681,
0.004238293,
-0.0860591754,
-0.0107440967,
0.0148453247,
0.0076847058,
0.0002969018,
-0.0078060315,
0.0490619503,
0.0113629317,
-0.0780082121,
0.0615804531,
0.0441073589,
-0.0301064178,
-0.0069912886,
-0.0091346484,
-0.0348205641,
0.0032328591,
0.0104968008,
-0.0448591672,
0.0167228878,
-0.0411850885,
0.0331983753,
-0.0414553657,
-0.0006619859,
0.0203975812,
-0.0429437533,
0.0017335581,
-0.0043520853,
0.0307673998,
-0.0008598139,
0.0055614775,
-0.0249806195,
-0.0088238195,
-0.0106885945,
-0.0153541453,
0.0278396402,
0.0784579217,
0.0518036783,
-0.0307170432,
0.0163491368,
0.0091022188,
0.0190553982,
-0.0353759527,
-0.0664770082,
0.0045868214,
-0.0317810848,
-0.0106705772,
-0.1101669073,
0.0175402965,
-0.0855941176,
0.0107068559,
0.0571476854,
0.0566380657,
0.0271037314,
-0.0252650511,
0.0136279287,
0.0268967953,
-0.0158103574,
0.007206426,
0.0005777534,
-0.0727093667,
-0.0268044677,
-0.0292685404,
0.0440019071,
0.0435351543,
0.0261159781,
0.0291264486,
-0.0169770699,
0.0476062745,
0.0431735404,
-0.0691533238,
0.0062668305,
0.0029620833,
0.0654844865,
0.0224061441,
0.0359937027,
0.0172187351,
-0.0514693521,
0.006284486,
0.0055099498,
0.0387093052,
-0.0059017013,
0.0062339567,
-0.0138482964,
0.0200156178,
-0.010642603,
-0.0012250812,
0.0074839285,
-0.0103527708,
0.0042569987,
-0.0707981363,
-0.0497059561,
-0.013356844,
-0.0222799014,
-0.0345361345,
-0.0092693958,
0.0202692952,
0.0017308446,
-0.0584921427,
0.0254367702,
-0.0257125031,
0.0223312695,
0.0055302721,
-0.0629316345,
0.0170055795,
-0.0511056297,
0.0202064738,
-0.075422436,
-0.0427466519,
0.0214557126,
0.0052763331,
-0.0578714311,
-0.0308536366,
0.0264071319,
-0.0000621703,
-0.0111434953,
-0.0205584336,
0.0587555952,
-0.0243445616,
-0.0486944951,
0.0004382817,
-0.0683699772,
0.0240245592,
0.048309844,
-0.0041265371,
0.02182745,
0.0590189025,
-0.0056474768,
-0.0449650772,
-0.0027250429,
-0.0273519326,
0.0038845493,
-0.0363556817,
-0.0396141186,
-0.0567721277,
0.0573398098,
-0.0968674645,
-0.0705207661,
-0.0204413384,
0.0114136068,
-0.0490412973,
-0.0751312971,
0.0491507277,
-0.0010735779,
0.0744920075,
0.0043042237,
-0.0260172561,
-0.0048571224,
-0.000571702,
-0.0115561998,
-0.0674605295,
0.0310575869,
0.0368197486,
-0.0283753388,
0.0560336746,
-0.0418904833,
-0.0102496725,
-0.0134983435,
0.0049001523,
0.0318957232,
-0.0664719716,
0.0453449786,
0.0715128258,
0.0175440423,
-0.0499262586,
-0.0209530871,
-0.0210407004,
-0.0104376599,
-0.0161297601,
0.0619249716,
0.0352521725,
-0.010224835,
-0.0289430656,
0.0093508428,
-0.0309781469,
0.0241859686,
-0.061593499,
-0.0104962708,
-0.0302585717,
-0.0176742319,
-0.0167538691,
-0.0259270687,
0.0204846803,
-0.0015146041,
-0.0003199232,
0.0278474651,
-0.0128944106,
0.0280198641,
-0.0644733161,
0.0215167161,
0.0403502472,
0.0149768526,
-0.0750228763,
-0.0214268304,
-0.0149475578,
-0.026133718,
-0.0331936777,
-0.0112664606,
-0.0178830605,
0.0367070362,
0.0367348008,
0.043044202,
0.0334130228,
0.0067109019,
0.0035920136,
0.0457810685,
-0.0181912296,
0.0051388857,
-0.0244650003,
-0.0637786239,
0.0090656029,
-0.0292581972,
-0.0112327524,
0.0291624088,
-0.0375896581,
-0.0323040597,
-0.0388533846,
-0.0177334342,
0.0615174733,
-0.014453765,
-0.0447278731,
-0.0046229619,
-0.016900342,
-0.0145665351,
-0.0250938758,
-0.0209668223,
0.0359235406,
-0.0501442812,
0.0067612301,
0.0397253819,
-0.0585575998,
0.045240052,
-0.0353404731,
0.0115607865,
0.0362083577,
-0.0452155247,
-0.0478816405,
0.0424589887,
0.0049324664,
0.0336611345,
-0.0023471264,
-0.041856233,
-0.0706977397,
-0.016447328,
0.0329245515,
0.0009290104,
0.0068208906,
0.0075418046,
0.0580023341,
-0.0099864257,
-0.030494146,
0.0158606302,
0.013193693,
0.0213618111,
-0.0441643596,
-0.001199029,
-0.0041361116,
-4.476620075e-33,
0.0580667183,
0.0084725963,
-0.0543756075,
0.025862461,
-0.0370291322,
-0.0204184726,
0.0325810052,
0.0481052548,
-0.0257061403,
-0.0402228609,
-0.0670619309,
-0.0333205499,
0.0181217995,
-0.0171284247,
0.0274228901,
0.041775126,
-0.025278477,
-0.0031797728,
-0.0274797622,
0.0007615297,
-0.0100982273,
0.0302790143,
0.013243679,
-0.0014776961,
0.0047777272,
-0.0454063155,
0.0038303195,
-0.0345400982,
-0.0066114822,
-0.0033192239,
-0.0157437027,
0.066440843,
-0.0044327555,
0.0189595446,
0.0231610592,
0.0563879944,
0.0041056774,
-0.023750186,
-0.009907919,
0.064150922,
0.0187428277,
-0.0535631143,
0.0125276418,
-0.0066698757,
-0.0620456114,
-0.0136301601,
0.0068724123,
0.0013287395,
-0.0602578856,
0.0078393305,
0.0030453065,
-0.0004759687,
-0.0049555227,
-0.0048455149,
0.0422998518,
-0.0300703514,
-0.0035898855,
-0.057200741,
0.0454180092,
0.065432772,
0.0335587114,
0.0400102362,
0.0221373606,
0.012309595,
0.0564240292,
-0.0030617968,
0.0389354341,
0.007436139,
-0.0305403471,
-0.0189996567,
0.0582021587,
0.0141213099,
0.033574719,
0.0381252654,
0.0314556025,
-0.0496907122,
-0.033384908,
0.0073355851,
-0.0146324812,
0.0062470478,
-0.0420489535,
0.0229287036,
-0.0637436882,
-0.0219321866,
-0.0289401356,
0.0589304157,
0.0123239104,
0.0035818426,
-0.048396863,
-0.0294953454,
0.0510644689,
-0.0220034812,
-0.0296831541,
0.0266897157,
-0.006548475,
-0.0367367826,
0.0542862266,
0.0517365225,
0.0295032561,
-0.0017505507,
0.0259860773,
-0.0051707737,
-0.0543831065,
0.044434689,
0.0332847312,
-0.0125290733,
-0.0851418227,
0.0044529019,
-0.0324191414,
0.0135846557,
0.0059342915,
-0.0429701135,
0.0701797679,
0.0163574982,
0.0549018197,
-0.0178847369,
0.0055471086,
0.0409736224,
0.0036683443,
-0.0218116529,
-0.0003099964,
-0.016632529,
-0.0074012191,
0.0161245838,
0.0187964942,
-0.0173913427,
0.0089392532,
0.0368570648,
0.0375289917,
-0.0629018173,
-0.0354867242,
-0.0382357538,
2.274e-7,
0.0641452447,
0.0632609576,
0.0448853299,
0.0067689931,
-0.0183804855,
0.0193593912,
-0.0232150052,
0.0244999249,
-0.033057157,
0.0011307343,
0.020705441,
-0.0056197681,
0.0427523442,
-0.0443007238,
-0.0089521939,
0.0357294939,
-0.0175396148,
0.0401988328,
-0.0180714522,
0.0849488899,
0.0317236036,
-0.0177075528,
-0.0066514076,
0.0061588953,
-0.025503505,
-0.0074527604,
-0.0179953314,
-0.0209949762,
0.0690369308,
-0.0215324014,
0.0365980528,
-0.0550589077,
-0.0182312634,
-0.0113304248,
0.0362022966,
-0.0225475021,
0.0135149583,
-0.0255421735,
-0.0345955454,
0.0337316133,
0.0135896252,
-0.0357224531,
-0.055356659,
-0.0294032097,
0.0577344783,
0.0164966043,
0.022919951,
-0.0110078724,
0.0129056219,
0.0293138903,
0.0065566427,
-0.0028353592,
0.0402152278,
0.0291730277,
0.0060979649,
-0.0076918243,
0.0598702915,
0.0134742688,
-0.0000773407,
0.0533867963,
-0.0315905735,
0.0061161635,
-0.0244013481,
0.0337665007,
0.0163151454,
-0.0141140083,
-0.0095345192,
1.964827558e-34,
-0.0336351246,
-0.0195741672,
0.0554783493,
0.0415656529,
-0.0235072058,
0.0027477567,
0.0515023656,
-0.0194985885,
0.0326252244,
-0.0333064273,
-0.0206634235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10955v1 | A State-Vector Framework for Dataset Effects | 2023-10-17T03:05:06 | 2023-10-17T03:05:06 | Esmat Sahak, Zining Zhu, Frank Rudzicz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The impressive success of recent deep neural network (DNN)-based systems is
significantly influenced by the high-quality datasets used in training.
However, the effects of the datasets, especially how they interact with each
other, remain underexplored. We propose a state-vector framework to enable
rigorous studies in this direction. This framework uses idealized probing test
results as the bases of a vector space. This framework allows us to quantify
the effects of both standalone and interacting datasets. We show that the
significant effects of some commonly-used language understanding datasets are
characteristic and are concentrated on a few linguistic dimensions.
Additionally, we observe some ``spill-over'' effects: the datasets could impact
the models along dimensions that may seem unrelated to the intended tasks. Our
state-vector framework paves the way for a systematic understanding of the
dataset effects, a crucial component in responsible and robust model
development. | [
-0.0141727896,
0.0927269533,
-0.0460998826,
0.0593108013,
-0.0199341159,
0.0227054134,
0.0355004519,
0.0147259403,
-0.0494763814,
-0.0263698529,
-0.0204253402,
-0.0493995138,
0.0290298052,
0.0311454311,
0.0303644668,
-0.0372280441,
0.0730649084,
-0.02018952,
-0.0592081398,
-0.0217352286,
-0.0203224402,
-0.0399543084,
-0.008070075,
0.036645893,
-0.0193379428,
-0.0169155989,
-0.0229908861,
0.0279431641,
0.0120842466,
0.0048424243,
-0.0043996694,
0.0541039333,
0.0553364083,
0.071354799,
0.0000018232,
-0.0367801562,
0.0182936229,
0.0042218217,
-0.047717303,
-0.0175912697,
-0.0159248728,
-0.0376023464,
0.0199486166,
-0.0337935351,
-0.00134498,
-0.0647970065,
0.0519810244,
0.0003314514,
0.0363739096,
0.0744105652,
-0.019524876,
-0.0328101553,
0.0176491365,
-0.0357302353,
0.0055074738,
-0.014325561,
0.0480784029,
0.011643121,
-0.0347542837,
-0.037802577,
-0.0399906188,
0.004493949,
0.0454360433,
0.0366330668,
-0.0191875789,
0.0190942399,
-0.0310672242,
-0.0242475998,
0.0018075071,
0.089690879,
-0.0126296105,
-0.0131720137,
0.0007932648,
-0.051658053,
0.0006780843,
0.0219984166,
-0.0173417106,
-0.006298684,
0.0118690906,
0.0275105145,
0.0195867885,
-0.0244168323,
0.0726666376,
0.0204238687,
-0.0325741842,
0.0677795038,
-0.0066092527,
-0.0481138304,
-0.0025726748,
0.0262800679,
0.0145302825,
-0.0374341011,
-0.0111658741,
-0.0007302394,
0.0123975128,
0.0433309451,
-0.0161455963,
-0.0510384031,
0.0333736613,
-0.0468202718,
0.0294452049,
0.0344629288,
-0.0990970209,
0.038426701,
-0.0060031312,
0.052990254,
-0.0202636663,
0.0202524886,
-0.0217094999,
0.0034097149,
-0.0432984568,
-0.0012007753,
-0.0074726371,
0.0170251746,
0.0023214007,
0.0090220431,
-0.0224124379,
-0.0003370184,
-0.0271926746,
0.0262401849,
-0.0191059522,
0.0094484119,
-0.0572059266,
0.0428727455,
-0.0192620885,
-0.0007816022,
-0.0320347361,
0.0448573381,
-0.0072629335,
-0.0864460692,
-0.0121277561,
0.0028732298,
0.0198950581,
-0.0502949022,
0.0063604587,
0.037419986,
0.0135501875,
-0.045376353,
-0.0252603181,
-0.0022643863,
0.0017628983,
-0.0517093875,
0.0580540411,
-0.0376410112,
0.0638659596,
0.0052573089,
0.0153000616,
-0.0720045269,
-0.0212723874,
0.000265225,
-0.0193111058,
0.0724741891,
-0.0154053764,
-0.0024393201,
-0.0165820159,
0.0057720928,
0.0150203565,
0.1013307199,
-0.0223692302,
0.0005275405,
0.0302540082,
-0.0262310728,
0.0192076527,
0.0185044203,
0.0351271108,
0.0248991977,
-0.0823016986,
0.0250118282,
-0.0349481031,
0.0099257333,
-0.0014715774,
0.0160255264,
-0.0386322215,
-0.0233568624,
0.0481691137,
0.0365567841,
0.0305419751,
0.0345218293,
0.0137423826,
-0.020432096,
0.016967088,
0.0349057429,
-0.0463099591,
-0.0240485016,
0.015796097,
-0.0198474694,
-0.0562592559,
-0.0081218397,
-0.0481620356,
-0.0552044325,
-0.0261248071,
-0.0018921508,
0.0273816753,
0.0544572659,
0.0749469921,
0.0013776231,
0.0015349453,
0.0209111962,
0.0207057949,
-0.0384180024,
0.0147351036,
-0.0592574887,
0.0176507551,
0.0077361539,
0.0274317004,
-0.0481863879,
-0.0412148349,
-0.0042432216,
0.03642039,
0.0127796475,
0.0268133357,
-0.0084712133,
0.0701494813,
-0.0312707461,
-0.0264464915,
-0.0167462435,
0.0209472198,
0.0120265502,
-0.0111270742,
-0.0186299905,
0.0051616365,
-0.035438478,
-0.0506756417,
0.0592461415,
0.0273548942,
0.0027092334,
0.0188528951,
0.0315723568,
0.0461711101,
0.0227095261,
-0.0472548977,
-0.0340800099,
0.0207558759,
-0.0145274671,
-0.01496985,
0.0169133469,
0.0026221103,
-0.0203454196,
-0.0172343235,
-0.0468006171,
-0.0227664392,
0.0506547764,
-0.058502961,
-0.0565643124,
0.0019665156,
-0.0238147695,
0.0042938115,
-0.0266843513,
-0.020569481,
-0.0356519111,
0.0714687482,
0.0083447909,
0.0504436493,
-0.0110863009,
0.0295481812,
0.008830172,
0.0491597205,
0.0374389514,
-0.0377057008,
-0.0618650392,
0.0183800366,
-0.0477794632,
0.0163601972,
0.0109358523,
-0.0152011281,
-0.0388967618,
0.0268901344,
-0.0224689692,
-0.0202897452,
-0.0537941381,
0.0149879968,
0.0159621965,
-0.0105728991,
-0.017175369,
-0.0174416769,
-0.0300445277,
-0.024489034,
0.0291365217,
0.0441267416,
0.0395656154,
0.0086315386,
-0.0175399128,
-0.0481348708,
-0.0523869507,
-0.0164720993,
0.0470431447,
-0.0228723083,
0.0047863582,
-0.047743395,
0.0239539724,
-0.0399313048,
0.0404438488,
-0.037255086,
-0.0362584777,
0.0234188568,
0.0156230703,
-0.0379964262,
0.0591280237,
-0.0510188751,
0.0428438634,
0.048364304,
0.0046073506,
-0.0179791991,
0.0090664951,
-0.010763512,
0.0246929862,
-0.0366231129,
-0.0097094234,
-0.0308930706,
0.0519116186,
-0.0073119625,
-0.0230396912,
-0.0446026959,
0.0252555422,
-0.0445370637,
-0.0415566526,
-0.0302154869,
-0.0148535641,
-0.0064189523,
0.0852772817,
-0.0434435531,
-0.0480253175,
0.079357028,
-0.0051932181,
-0.0214557312,
-0.0135055333,
-0.0193730928,
-0.0332409628,
0.0433013961,
0.0236652121,
-0.0143089145,
-0.0141351512,
-0.0070597851,
-0.0403668322,
-0.0363939106,
0.0030077707,
-0.010472022,
0.0732542127,
-0.0397682004,
0.0118480818,
-0.0266394168,
-0.02877165,
-0.0701498389,
0.0043142061,
0.0064878748,
0.0073359348,
0.0278295111,
-0.0065104803,
0.028359415,
-0.0103368536,
-0.027917875,
0.0450053699,
-0.0189561732,
-0.0013179565,
-0.0327999182,
0.045380082,
0.0149815818,
0.0161029436,
0.0026553345,
-0.0187151134,
0.0042998325,
-0.0111045158,
0.046626538,
-0.0168820098,
-0.0605334304,
0.0383692905,
0.0406285338,
0.0082542142,
-0.0180909,
-0.0082647763,
0.0158531331,
-0.0705404133,
-0.0352618769,
0.0379737206,
0.0079343775,
-0.040800523,
0.0189295001,
0.0085397614,
-0.0118997861,
0.0151941944,
0.021770345,
-0.0905411616,
-0.0087799579,
-0.0073222467,
-0.0136436522,
-0.0215227325,
-0.0143641243,
-0.0056419447,
-0.0516478233,
0.0160364117,
-0.0339202508,
-0.069839783,
-0.0281710625,
-0.0388021953,
0.0234885011,
-0.0392355584,
0.0685391203,
-0.0313470364,
0.021648813,
-0.0480946116,
0.0300817862,
-0.0155545427,
-0.102898702,
0.021367088,
0.0097708516,
0.0520294979,
0.067789726,
0.0299245119,
-0.0525486767,
-0.029193908,
-0.0065919766,
-0.0484135449,
0.0316839628,
0.0050681126,
0.0641577691,
0.0009733395,
-0.0364022143,
0.0308407508,
0.0219490658,
-0.0252640639,
-0.018216474,
-0.0209678002,
0.0129790613,
-0.031598568,
-0.0206467472,
-0.0184391048,
-0.0588239245,
0.0357297659,
0.0595864095,
0.0481941663,
-0.0305180997,
-0.0225897897,
0.0054849614,
0.0133289415,
-0.0385031775,
-0.0011513089,
-0.0039038516,
0.0295105353,
-0.0098070316,
-0.0059186365,
-0.0774947628,
0.0170939565,
0.0080088489,
0.0064953212,
0.0118955374,
-0.0170162935,
0.0156715792,
-0.0265906546,
0.0851802453,
0.0167057123,
0.0224468652,
0.0218348242,
-0.0328244567,
0.0373307243,
0.0025039187,
-0.0283364896,
0.0408246703,
-0.0981105566,
-0.0575748086,
0.0500282459,
0.0317995548,
0.0296677686,
0.0561413094,
0.0014349013,
-0.0933658183,
0.0420119762,
0.0095375022,
-0.0084904348,
-0.0119809043,
0.078076005,
-0.0381344408,
-0.0002574044,
0.0303065162,
-0.0363349505,
0.0259851068,
0.0398535207,
-0.0281093773,
-0.032971967,
0.0098608509,
-0.0015256213,
-0.0191749204,
0.0958343744,
-0.0083853137,
-0.0234046802,
-0.0478698947,
0.0123962061,
-0.0039267857,
0.0031058867,
-0.0321738273,
-0.01527505,
0.0326403677,
0.010839697,
-0.0223212503,
0.0171790719,
-0.0223013237,
0.0063633355,
-0.0354839079,
0.035314396,
0.033583574,
0.0233691148,
0.0533024147,
0.0514465049,
-0.0150970928,
0.0402166955,
0.0008526397,
0.0236787796,
0.0146011319,
0.0471919812,
0.0321142972,
0.0396188572,
-0.0045958618,
-0.0074601551,
-0.0573668778,
-0.0411470383,
-0.0129086291,
-0.0017832898,
0.0542673208,
-0.0469163246,
0.0232820623,
-0.0160041023,
0.0120793441,
-0.0044684494,
0.0166137312,
-0.0073011499,
-0.0308924858,
0.0481699742,
0.0276803467,
0.0039254148,
0.0217823721,
0.0595243014,
0.0330557562,
0.051988177,
-0.0246867258,
0.067097351,
-0.0166832209,
-0.0086914869,
0.042531874,
0.033015538,
-0.0373255685,
-0.0079274485,
-0.0466510542,
-0.1237269938,
-0.0171399452,
-0.0071953046,
0.0415049046,
0.0143064298,
0.0473901667,
0.0584556498,
-0.0162013508,
-0.0089328177,
-0.0171231441,
-0.0061730584,
-0.0230337828,
-0.0164169315,
-0.0141866598,
-6.05153859e-33,
0.0103634261,
0.0097256824,
-0.0030554121,
-0.0164139457,
0.0174161736,
0.0284351856,
-0.0223422758,
-0.0065945843,
-0.0532376766,
0.0018637484,
-0.0331439935,
0.0627658367,
0.018764466,
0.0417390652,
-0.0302150603,
-0.0608587563,
0.0549533516,
-0.0217213333,
0.0033395321,
0.0087740244,
0.0109783337,
0.0364040211,
0.0758528188,
-0.053045813,
0.0585986041,
-0.0165921077,
0.0140642673,
0.0343081281,
-0.0301545039,
0.0391635261,
-0.0327716209,
0.1009579748,
0.0361782834,
-0.0565635078,
-0.0041383607,
-0.0023145501,
-0.0424366295,
-0.0525099561,
0.0222357363,
0.0610771403,
-0.0426953584,
0.0034167413,
0.0776443705,
0.008332422,
0.0105054257,
0.0286030099,
0.033787936,
-0.0108771427,
-0.030575389,
-0.0310772453,
-0.0314442441,
0.019130094,
-0.0421474129,
-0.0079225181,
0.0747656077,
0.0503438376,
0.0057027573,
-0.007574541,
-0.0768033862,
0.005039521,
0.0176191702,
0.0177806336,
0.0898636654,
0.0483853146,
0.0189324841,
0.0480409265,
0.0951650664,
0.022537645,
0.0045256931,
-0.0171416067,
0.0699729398,
0.0308252815,
-0.0006389085,
0.0628536195,
0.0599893145,
-0.021752445,
-0.082029894,
-0.0124616493,
0.0237997752,
0.0001763615,
-0.0120095573,
-0.0093660327,
-0.0228997879,
-0.03143581,
-0.0422282517,
-0.0301056281,
-0.0226568226,
-0.0095364423,
0.0184464175,
-0.0159470756,
-0.0284016561,
0.0303594843,
0.0319549665,
-0.0776389316,
-0.0269231945,
0.0378173217,
-0.0009722497,
0.0123754218,
0.0313068926,
0.0045438991,
-0.0283934195,
-0.0674729794,
-0.0212622341,
0.0393058844,
0.0548187643,
-0.0232064147,
0.0458805189,
0.0310122743,
-0.0114514334,
-0.0050281119,
-0.046513807,
-0.0047762175,
0.0038486335,
0.0458767824,
0.0609665848,
0.0230618287,
-0.0028564457,
0.0472282395,
0.0452446714,
0.0031058763,
-0.0473329313,
-0.0124847451,
-0.0351442136,
0.0477416143,
-0.0381546132,
-0.0674922168,
-0.0235387981,
-0.0098322304,
0.0955648422,
-0.0617112517,
0.00525861,
0.0153428242,
2.525e-7,
0.0297286399,
0.0424211882,
0.0066351742,
0.0215509553,
0.0267109163,
0.0132186944,
-0.0482653417,
0.0223158523,
-0.0171464067,
-0.0221566688,
0.0231231693,
0.0252779685,
0.044610735,
0.0338826329,
-0.0589028597,
0.0227426421,
-0.0489170887,
0.0334798731,
-0.0390608162,
0.0254301969,
-0.000679493,
0.0849596262,
-0.0018513881,
-0.0251666792,
-0.0017872776,
0.0168843791,
0.0322795622,
-0.0349086411,
0.0575410984,
0.0393369012,
0.0214931052,
0.0461322516,
0.0059328722,
0.0727481246,
0.0079135196,
0.0297614988,
-0.0027392886,
0.0057755844,
0.0123884901,
-0.0239952859,
-0.0386025831,
-0.0123337191,
-0.0178181902,
-0.0739078,
0.0848914683,
-0.0778003484,
-0.0539050885,
-0.0252746847,
0.0011119239,
0.0159476101,
0.0577609502,
0.023054136,
0.0080845403,
0.0085933786,
0.0054564318,
-0.0196476001,
-0.0095959986,
-0.0579522848,
-0.0094641969,
0.0071633547,
-0.0607883409,
-0.0493182875,
-0.0413793176,
0.0032722224,
0.0295155365,
-0.03013785,
-0.0186298359,
1.966519627e-34,
0.0017528648,
-0.0000891416,
0.0098584052,
-0.0141441245,
-0.0213734377,
-0.0495937169,
-0.0006194719,
0.0062883594,
-0.0058407909,
-0.0384630375,
-0.00764377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10944v1 | TEQ: Trainable Equivalent Transformation for Quantization of LLMs | 2023-10-17T02:42:34 | 2023-10-17T02:42:34 | Wenhua Cheng, Yiyang Cai, Kaokao Lv, Haihao Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become more prevalent, there is a growing
need for new and improved quantization methods that can meet the
computationalast layer demands of these modern architectures while maintaining
the accuracy. In this paper, we present TEQ, a trainable equivalent
transformation that preserves the FP32 precision of the model output while
taking advantage of low-precision quantization, especially 3 and 4 bits
weight-only quantization. The training process is lightweight, requiring only
1K steps and fewer than 0.1 percent of the original model's trainable
parameters. Furthermore, the transformation does not add any computational
overhead during inference. Our results are on-par with the state-of-the-art
(SOTA) methods on typical LLMs. Our approach can be combined with other methods
to achieve even better performance. The code is available at
https://github.com/intel/neural-compressor. | [
-0.0450443327,
0.0626594871,
0.0052648322,
0.0691739395,
-0.0060758539,
0.0030391568,
-0.0029583676,
0.0101551572,
-0.045856595,
-0.0329245776,
-0.0512151234,
-0.0262381341,
0.0167830121,
0.0008598001,
0.0480998158,
-0.0251521245,
0.031394545,
-0.0169382393,
-0.0268548913,
-0.0118486518,
0.0055130743,
0.013551807,
0.004769552,
0.0169336665,
0.0029523773,
-0.0050377781,
-0.0107850526,
0.0211846381,
0.0034573583,
-0.0114115039,
0.0080171805,
0.0265302956,
0.0489748344,
0.0433062464,
0.0000019581,
-0.0141035113,
-0.0107322764,
-0.0089934692,
-0.0456353314,
0.0227811486,
0.0355705954,
-0.0369610041,
-0.0539781339,
0.0229332261,
-0.0182687286,
-0.0117515251,
0.062995933,
0.0063798572,
0.0608740002,
0.1037814692,
-0.0065239337,
-0.0400406159,
0.0490041487,
-0.0235773884,
-0.0508539341,
-0.03125057,
-0.0035418395,
0.03180952,
-0.0389592387,
0.0089607704,
-0.0211729258,
0.0346707813,
0.0237381253,
0.0191827584,
-0.037134815,
0.0105268424,
-0.0163442492,
-0.0176139623,
-0.0239516012,
0.0426221974,
-0.0701418445,
-0.0324267447,
-0.0111056045,
0.0197185222,
-0.0367251337,
-0.1082116142,
-0.0494140461,
0.045290567,
0.0522627123,
0.0661189705,
0.0068407515,
-0.0292194709,
0.0556461103,
-0.0023336562,
-0.0262421761,
0.0589287356,
0.0312775224,
0.0242498368,
-0.0140062207,
-0.0026885713,
-0.0602213517,
-0.0338213257,
0.0066346386,
0.0170899555,
0.0238241386,
-0.0149700744,
-0.0729670748,
-0.0212737042,
-0.0292312335,
-0.0520537831,
0.024655275,
0.0686707869,
-0.0011753199,
-0.0000183519,
-0.0585274175,
0.0338488109,
-0.0088985991,
0.0366573222,
-0.0366429538,
0.0115233213,
0.006362034,
0.0100178346,
-0.0379185826,
0.0262524504,
-0.0299264509,
-0.0187329352,
-0.0617830046,
-0.001446021,
-0.0204815995,
-0.0255513433,
0.0220468752,
0.0001318337,
-0.0201245565,
-0.0151433134,
0.0346568637,
0.0514952801,
-0.007147369,
0.0213974286,
-0.0236020051,
-0.0695084333,
-0.0146426512,
0.0317221321,
-0.0034254116,
-0.0111535704,
0.0335253254,
0.0211286284,
0.0037086271,
-0.0445385017,
-0.0589945838,
0.0333460011,
-0.0011894578,
-0.0346763358,
-0.0011794819,
-0.0816710144,
0.0003688424,
-0.0336144753,
0.0082759922,
-0.0474763364,
0.0175811611,
0.011660086,
0.001587012,
0.060607519,
-0.0607351027,
-0.0061049354,
0.0204865932,
-0.0002305361,
0.0429781601,
0.0757508352,
0.0707247928,
0.0314283818,
0.0053743045,
0.0009392695,
-0.0302160606,
0.0825375989,
0.0301608983,
-0.0106938798,
-0.0766685158,
-0.0463402197,
-0.0399788953,
0.0480020158,
0.1228199527,
0.08825472,
-0.0705927089,
-0.035477791,
0.0147085516,
0.0274949055,
0.0501710251,
0.0376371033,
0.002126443,
0.001045799,
0.0127950972,
-0.0150685403,
-0.04142984,
0.0392137803,
0.0152697153,
0.00934448,
0.0397903286,
0.0512979738,
-0.0338547565,
-0.0229644123,
-0.0167499855,
-0.0106831007,
0.0042099757,
-0.0068190205,
0.007020948,
0.0334748887,
-0.0138955172,
0.1235712022,
0.0213307012,
-0.0445521921,
-0.0154416449,
-0.0926056281,
-0.0051586288,
0.031913992,
0.0094853854,
0.00616686,
-0.0152016087,
0.0067520346,
-0.0473155566,
0.0241601802,
0.0094668223,
-0.004576907,
0.0294174161,
-0.0679776743,
0.001688172,
0.0122567723,
0.0054653967,
0.002956202,
0.0457175858,
-0.0072895768,
0.0125357416,
-0.0279427003,
-0.0001200594,
0.015420232,
-0.0026284258,
-0.0607975349,
0.0317806005,
0.0016069502,
0.0197049398,
0.0162203219,
-0.0103727495,
0.0071198246,
0.0291780215,
-0.0487528183,
0.0263048448,
-0.0340657644,
-0.0277826451,
-0.0438661464,
0.0700022429,
0.015333442,
0.0316140726,
0.0712484345,
-0.0630501658,
-0.0458761975,
0.0170610677,
-0.0363836288,
0.0576173775,
-0.0565923341,
0.0305873137,
0.0227507725,
0.0463183448,
-0.0401841961,
-0.0025287494,
-0.0144988857,
0.0073609287,
0.0174238496,
0.0035553677,
-0.0013424321,
-0.0389754847,
-0.0322891809,
0.0067899767,
0.0124266511,
0.0409993827,
0.0016468117,
-0.0023743319,
0.0122716343,
-0.0116171502,
-0.0893321633,
0.0084243584,
-0.0352660827,
0.0453320406,
0.0453930981,
0.035081014,
0.0077157915,
-0.0106158946,
-0.044724904,
0.0126883062,
-0.0156302955,
-0.0082580084,
0.0198164303,
-0.0101346914,
-0.0272725467,
-0.0461202227,
-0.04829612,
0.0031508147,
0.038627021,
-0.0767280906,
-0.0427248813,
-0.0721301064,
0.0193192065,
0.0015566759,
0.0489938706,
0.0076487148,
-0.0407531224,
-0.0021557182,
-0.0302479416,
0.0135144172,
0.0578075089,
0.0111150369,
-0.0115551809,
0.0777163133,
0.0202108826,
-0.0644808486,
0.0291989874,
0.0038170803,
-0.0322623961,
-0.0278638732,
-0.0343042798,
-0.0103239305,
0.0579472072,
-0.0164327547,
-0.0039587179,
-0.0253994092,
-0.0123862326,
0.0052865609,
-0.0055145803,
-0.0084398594,
0.0230170768,
-0.0191398077,
0.0262413211,
-0.0022254616,
-0.0420570336,
0.0069628973,
-0.0701065138,
-0.0004015352,
-0.0004319279,
-0.0237989277,
-0.0243270546,
0.0665381923,
0.0295788739,
0.0511548333,
-0.0347934663,
-0.0179333668,
-0.0484595224,
-0.0111453533,
-0.0272538606,
-0.0202134587,
0.0424356014,
-0.0288774949,
0.0230552144,
-0.0576188117,
-0.0203144904,
0.0151204877,
0.0377878323,
-0.0399992988,
0.0404359363,
0.0156264007,
-0.0613476299,
0.0363559201,
0.0364452675,
-0.0120884031,
0.0554067865,
-0.0165231843,
0.0077591981,
-0.0183856115,
0.0481374599,
0.033876799,
0.029454479,
0.0342873484,
0.0063309935,
-0.0170392226,
0.0269946866,
0.0252181347,
0.0869731009,
-0.0945123807,
-0.016164843,
0.0506788082,
-0.003632592,
-0.0202889144,
0.031837441,
0.0293568373,
-0.0417590961,
0.0059623001,
0.0954403505,
0.0124650197,
-0.0271340441,
0.0137180937,
0.0163660329,
0.0249245167,
0.0014232871,
0.0161436163,
-0.0855274349,
-0.0306334496,
0.024730159,
-0.0048085297,
0.0168009978,
0.0220747385,
-0.0273863245,
-0.0597736239,
-0.0002167725,
0.0376453772,
0.0291583091,
-0.0285468958,
-0.0206117257,
-0.0140067423,
-0.0458758138,
0.0650525242,
0.041796241,
-0.0288343616,
-0.0092742089,
0.0239525847,
-0.0154293971,
-0.0332739167,
0.0271457415,
-0.0025029166,
0.07390742,
0.0643593818,
0.0237928424,
-0.0071591409,
-0.0134503273,
0.044617869,
0.0345295481,
-0.0148755964,
-0.0139372349,
0.0297292192,
0.0095274029,
-0.0068878001,
0.0297292806,
-0.0009970679,
-0.0042091636,
-0.0075073587,
-0.0241113286,
0.0109594241,
-0.0027580205,
-0.0188907646,
0.019249443,
-0.0314489231,
-0.0637238026,
0.0402850173,
0.0240093321,
0.0063651185,
-0.0418902151,
-0.0204676818,
-0.016861802,
-0.0471989475,
-0.053286463,
-0.0035304998,
-0.0071075028,
-0.0552200302,
-0.0412849002,
0.0207057018,
0.0217428077,
0.0220029149,
-0.0214059036,
-0.0564272851,
0.0130400341,
0.0008054082,
-0.0888772458,
-0.0136385597,
-0.0401701666,
0.0376747362,
-0.0594012365,
0.016561918,
0.024515627,
-0.002124463,
0.0091655999,
-0.0116493339,
-0.1470344216,
-0.0536422357,
-0.0080131935,
0.0195707828,
0.016960714,
0.0550951287,
-0.0008495825,
-0.0423665792,
0.0495130196,
0.0504319072,
-0.0280192271,
0.060157571,
0.0416145734,
-0.0030341544,
-0.0052445028,
0.0480960719,
-0.0136719309,
0.0287503321,
-0.0037949956,
0.0462053344,
-0.054290127,
-0.0506880954,
-0.0014345151,
0.0157776326,
0.0416511297,
-0.0127103729,
0.023341829,
0.0114900758,
0.0150812538,
-0.0044145859,
0.0405408219,
-0.0455731787,
0.024654543,
0.0276956856,
0.0171384085,
-0.0103694964,
-0.0285788812,
0.0347139686,
-0.0172788631,
0.0287462957,
-0.0175059941,
-0.0272237211,
0.022284599,
0.0200958345,
-0.0088062203,
-0.0347755849,
0.0097106649,
0.0030528521,
0.0380274244,
-0.0513359308,
0.0075293519,
-0.011424833,
0.0116712078,
-0.044942081,
0.0543074049,
-0.0253187642,
-0.0476577468,
-0.0757798404,
0.0143195717,
0.0616276674,
0.0243206229,
0.0430245809,
-0.0087904045,
-0.011049727,
-0.0149353109,
0.0226448029,
-0.0227434728,
-0.0021493486,
0.050180506,
-0.0014431213,
-0.0082177408,
-0.0252047554,
0.0449877754,
0.0017550989,
0.0249466822,
0.0131277312,
0.01222564,
-0.0135919657,
-0.0540255234,
-0.0682402775,
-0.0088287275,
-0.000087463,
-0.0147465281,
0.0246207714,
-0.0429089852,
0.0125784753,
0.0234007966,
0.0011172114,
-0.0324244089,
0.0244253799,
0.0250727274,
-0.0085294154,
-0.0488516912,
-0.0215071645,
-0.0231094416,
0.0333945937,
-0.0139807118,
-0.0285325032,
-5.996054522e-33,
-0.0286330786,
0.0441839248,
0.0269340649,
-0.0300351232,
-0.0423904881,
0.0108760726,
-0.0145563111,
-0.0155827049,
-0.0208094865,
-0.0447381623,
-0.0223766863,
0.0330349877,
0.0208553728,
0.0279555358,
-0.0276733711,
0.0202303957,
0.0991158187,
-0.0110442638,
-0.0018621965,
0.0084550027,
-0.0038747757,
0.0226399582,
0.0687966496,
0.028136678,
-0.039627187,
0.0296457633,
-0.0178257637,
0.0238244478,
0.0243693143,
0.0150363455,
-0.0267562419,
0.0246782154,
0.0145311952,
-0.0214837473,
-0.0119214496,
-0.0132189533,
-0.0804110467,
-0.0055451314,
0.0249549001,
0.0403380729,
0.0044983965,
-0.0380827896,
0.0593444258,
0.0096298791,
-0.0253568776,
-0.0374664664,
-0.0384268016,
-0.0272479244,
-0.015128714,
-0.0742009208,
-0.020217564,
0.0253373254,
0.0386293307,
0.0137533601,
0.0741817877,
0.0004817753,
-0.063098304,
-0.0333448835,
-0.0772797167,
-0.0232222192,
0.0292240176,
0.1214593425,
0.0421304218,
0.0438479036,
0.0106966933,
0.0289904047,
0.0267337076,
-0.0595831424,
-0.027149763,
0.0747538134,
0.0784477368,
0.0298806932,
0.0236366596,
0.0330224559,
0.0846680626,
-0.0118576502,
-0.0514205545,
0.0017777754,
0.0179015715,
0.0298020653,
0.0030794095,
0.0342193618,
0.0053004934,
-0.0292714573,
-0.0324395113,
-0.0123159597,
-0.0304644722,
-0.0416617393,
-0.0011061738,
0.0026801713,
-0.0087034339,
-0.0260960683,
0.0127163837,
-0.0467290916,
0.0121617792,
-0.0290839113,
-0.00667693,
0.0188841075,
0.0093977489,
0.0442597643,
-0.0050536981,
-0.0297741927,
-0.003801716,
-0.0030219734,
0.0133254863,
-0.0030193494,
0.0210618917,
0.0830769017,
-0.0706362873,
-0.0247692615,
-0.0312882438,
-0.0070646871,
0.0100621469,
0.0540372245,
0.0072081652,
0.0232122019,
0.0151042603,
0.0219367072,
-0.0300781988,
0.0181824341,
-0.0127315633,
0.0175439008,
0.0437004082,
0.0788320825,
-0.0562937707,
0.0060144556,
-0.0410838835,
0.0306217298,
0.0371856987,
-0.0867049918,
-0.0435043201,
0.0315480568,
2.561e-7,
0.0259091146,
0.003279659,
0.035185717,
0.0008935848,
-0.0022347223,
-0.0082809702,
0.0021258665,
0.0303057358,
0.0152978525,
-0.0032186951,
0.0160492752,
0.0260264669,
0.0187135134,
0.0295604244,
-0.0719482675,
0.0176042225,
-0.0309339501,
0.0081736175,
-0.0098923882,
-0.0209858175,
0.0265067667,
0.1360991746,
-0.0072830343,
-0.0112131005,
0.0426985286,
0.0094378777,
0.0258572232,
-0.0070191068,
0.0201183725,
0.0117527302,
0.0282807685,
0.0101323975,
-0.0063767615,
-0.0431450903,
0.0097688874,
-0.0026110096,
-0.0440575965,
0.0857307017,
-0.0202758275,
-0.0270195659,
0.0000460742,
-0.0460729264,
-0.0229314975,
-0.0152985901,
0.0302866939,
-0.0311356466,
0.0045939889,
-0.0902748108,
-0.0214952212,
0.0101616839,
-0.0154927336,
-0.0268539879,
0.0209035464,
0.019356478,
0.0500927977,
-0.0146124316,
-0.0144978696,
-0.0717126578,
-0.0578964613,
0.0100337472,
-0.0175983869,
-0.052573774,
-0.0409360789,
-0.0125989076,
0.0115378043,
-0.0410782658,
0.001701709,
2.166370885e-34,
0.0237349793,
-0.0075908699,
0.0189265981,
0.0237843301,
-0.0092410669,
-0.0204174854,
0.0220693685,
-0.0061160889,
-0.0372210443,
-0.055267062,
-0.0412584208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10941v1 | MASON-NLP at eRisk 2023: Deep Learning-Based Detection of Depression Symptoms from Social Media Texts | 2023-10-17T02:34:34 | 2023-10-17T02:34:34 | Fardin Ahsan Sakib, Ahnaf Atef Choudhury, Ozlem Uzuner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Depression is a mental health disorder that has a profound impact on people's
lives. Recent research suggests that signs of depression can be detected in the
way individuals communicate, both through spoken words and written texts. In
particular, social media posts are a rich and convenient text source that we
may examine for depressive symptoms. The Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)
Questionnaire, which is frequently used to gauge the severity of depression, is
one instrument that can aid in this study. We can narrow our study to only
those symptoms since each BDI question is linked to a particular depressive
symptom. It's important to remember that not everyone with depression exhibits
all symptoms at once, but rather a combination of them. Therefore, it is
extremely useful to be able to determine if a sentence or a piece of
user-generated content is pertinent to a certain condition. With this in mind,
the eRisk 2023 Task 1 was designed to do exactly that: assess the relevance of
different sentences to the symptoms of depression as outlined in the BDI
questionnaire. This report is all about how our team, Mason-NLP, participated
in this subtask, which involved identifying sentences related to different
depression symptoms. We used a deep learning approach that incorporated
MentalBERT, RoBERTa, and LSTM. Despite our efforts, the evaluation results were
lower than expected, underscoring the challenges inherent in ranking sentences
from an extensive dataset about depression, which necessitates both appropriate
methodological choices and significant computational resources. We anticipate
that future iterations of this shared task will yield improved results as our
understanding and techniques evolve. | [
0.0474354923,
0.0686806291,
-0.0143402768,
-0.0059292372,
-0.0146345273,
0.0438961349,
-0.0058765798,
0.0234230049,
0.0694924593,
-0.0311119538,
0.020254612,
0.0106624756,
-0.0379337147,
-0.0097801164,
-0.029617751,
-0.0433335379,
-0.0110497549,
0.0623218715,
0.0437346026,
0.0251352843,
0.009747576,
0.0375581197,
-0.0155881317,
0.0285149589,
-0.0270661246,
-0.0260247514,
0.0501745082,
0.0350822993,
0.0518844761,
-0.0551234894,
0.0309712775,
0.0685190707,
0.0019543944,
0.013756454,
0.0000021495,
-0.0098087462,
-0.0310525671,
-0.0416657738,
-0.0005432772,
-0.0404245071,
0.0406092741,
-0.0280741993,
0.0218546521,
0.0097766221,
-0.060229864,
-0.0322687216,
0.0340114459,
0.0967773572,
0.0565043129,
0.070083864,
-0.0344615951,
-0.0006774904,
-0.0028813116,
-0.0143870739,
0.0250112154,
-0.0056217471,
0.0520845912,
-0.0120347496,
0.0130690783,
-0.0328804962,
-0.0012628607,
0.0105836494,
-0.0038765487,
0.0433302373,
-0.0209775232,
-0.0099971108,
-0.0216972269,
-0.0207057986,
0.0080572851,
0.0996502861,
0.034440577,
0.0193951409,
0.0391797982,
0.0085023548,
-0.0017773469,
-0.0202431716,
-0.011679275,
-0.0324693657,
0.0043419879,
0.0358184204,
0.0006788387,
0.0278460328,
0.0083870366,
0.0150519051,
0.0147628356,
0.0549420454,
-0.0066014342,
-0.0334372036,
0.0207809396,
0.0191118754,
-0.0364521965,
-0.0586064011,
0.0515723787,
-0.0080006216,
-0.010742316,
-0.0024075625,
-0.0135273496,
-0.092648156,
0.0139087234,
-0.0047822669,
-0.0189112388,
0.0159316808,
-0.0497459322,
-0.0032052184,
-0.0029431516,
0.0380759574,
0.0043978309,
-0.0124687683,
-0.025302954,
0.0030109086,
-0.0714508444,
0.0005911444,
-0.0307590552,
0.0329136513,
0.0095597543,
-0.0370946638,
-0.0761753917,
-0.0140154418,
-0.0143314712,
-0.0451683477,
-0.0027245556,
0.0455230176,
-0.0073692882,
0.0270112082,
0.0050734715,
0.0547426417,
-0.0218210202,
-0.0139989173,
-0.004174313,
-0.0279468261,
0.0355125479,
0.004089721,
0.0399983078,
-0.0592804551,
0.018181093,
0.0189888608,
0.0368545689,
-0.0252183955,
-0.039085187,
-0.0342163034,
-0.0172175001,
-0.022108255,
0.0039513819,
-0.0326977,
0.0259806309,
0.0021852884,
0.0127519853,
-0.0449258089,
0.0284150913,
0.0114320302,
-0.011714939,
0.0639162362,
-0.0401649699,
-0.0085838372,
0.0174502544,
0.0213681199,
0.0313043036,
0.0506943688,
0.0167663805,
0.0644506663,
0.0312653184,
-0.0155881057,
-0.0068969768,
-0.0059109633,
-0.0007157249,
-0.027126573,
0.0089476118,
-0.0179437324,
-0.064775832,
0.0509531312,
-0.0119840642,
0.0370328762,
-0.0109857041,
0.0148093896,
0.0546938218,
0.0685064197,
0.0349061377,
0.02985413,
0.0122814504,
0.0446872488,
-0.003015931,
-0.0152442912,
-0.0230956171,
0.0132073108,
-0.0145642264,
-0.0294354931,
0.0139536187,
0.0095139025,
-0.0031542124,
-0.0608385988,
-0.0353103727,
-0.0199054331,
0.0146472016,
-0.0091332961,
-0.0011151046,
-0.0131688965,
-0.0199800394,
0.0556015857,
0.0141585348,
-0.0339770913,
-0.0391945355,
-0.0257182438,
-0.0142760165,
0.0708253458,
-0.005371985,
-0.0498668067,
-0.0282182526,
0.0086134477,
0.0641744807,
0.0574253388,
0.0080295103,
0.0287546534,
0.0245564748,
-0.0342817642,
0.0091112694,
0.0031136279,
0.0151003264,
-0.0243350752,
-0.0235915296,
0.0219097231,
-0.0162877459,
-0.0254972503,
-0.0146076242,
0.0344846807,
0.0423430949,
-0.0350247473,
0.0339232199,
0.0330695882,
0.0087179253,
0.0045669214,
0.00595529,
0.0176077783,
0.0187202096,
-0.0568033159,
-0.072026588,
-0.0129825547,
0.0037140937,
-0.0466108359,
-0.0081370575,
-0.0366481915,
-0.0139426617,
0.1104975343,
-0.064492479,
-0.0273526795,
0.0750835612,
-0.0529136844,
0.0131690595,
0.0047680968,
-0.0448018424,
0.0255618487,
0.0467337519,
-0.0432799309,
0.0769443959,
-0.0021330707,
0.0255385824,
0.0192418508,
-0.0832804516,
-0.0138580743,
-0.0228130911,
-0.038748689,
-0.0307636764,
-0.0288269781,
0.0171369575,
0.0046529043,
0.0301920287,
-0.0346518829,
-0.0055364389,
-0.1238991767,
0.0095510334,
-0.0236181691,
0.0024476682,
0.0107153561,
0.0070664226,
-0.0162837561,
-0.0411332063,
-0.0175278019,
0.0123838214,
0.0317417905,
0.025801897,
0.0631834567,
-0.0078838924,
0.0159241352,
-0.0720456392,
-0.0312624834,
-0.0442017093,
0.0265169516,
-0.017607538,
-0.0471652597,
-0.0054451069,
-0.0210668594,
-0.0757946298,
-0.0009043905,
0.0339640938,
-0.0429725647,
-0.0157518499,
-0.0111643029,
0.0340288877,
0.0384356827,
0.0065153083,
0.0857243538,
-0.0110017108,
0.0299590137,
-0.0197587367,
0.0271426421,
-0.0077232374,
0.0484035052,
-0.0219150819,
-0.0421559177,
-0.0041541276,
0.0432888195,
0.0149600701,
-0.0001908272,
-0.0329275206,
0.0084462706,
-0.0301439241,
0.0129745798,
-0.0277995132,
0.0049391324,
0.0223740786,
0.0072232769,
-0.0272551719,
-0.0423271433,
0.0421724841,
0.0287098046,
-0.0147233447,
-0.0701060891,
-0.0463231988,
-0.0471666679,
0.0435347483,
0.0321705379,
0.0214701518,
-0.0032309366,
-0.0332470275,
-0.0056520975,
-0.0113080498,
-0.0132009694,
-0.0182830486,
0.0288600773,
-0.0214827359,
0.0051109716,
0.0152256908,
-0.0370344892,
-0.0232724696,
-0.0477128029,
-0.0687638,
-0.0092035783,
-0.0313959233,
-0.0037130201,
-0.0462100618,
-0.0634749681,
-0.007803156,
0.0008869676,
-0.0285056699,
-0.0176182613,
0.0067302701,
0.0653579682,
0.0728889182,
0.0146296462,
0.0252512731,
-0.0013808761,
0.015436314,
0.0606076941,
-0.0312549323,
0.048215881,
-0.0370854847,
0.0232111476,
-0.0099305511,
-0.0218232255,
-0.0076260711,
-0.0101943612,
0.0147235328,
-0.017336173,
-0.0230740309,
0.115128316,
0.0074654007,
-0.0326053761,
0.0362718292,
-0.0091570998,
0.004395315,
-0.0057403855,
-0.0087403813,
-0.0450288616,
-0.0705565214,
-0.0518411808,
0.0014691552,
-0.0319549441,
-0.0091819996,
0.0031208931,
-0.0087043503,
0.0202437993,
-0.046776209,
0.0028653955,
0.0254906155,
-0.0028862976,
0.0012263405,
0.0051952745,
0.0003371513,
-0.0642840415,
-0.0091380496,
-0.0008252113,
0.0193103682,
-0.0624132119,
-0.0522483177,
0.0309938006,
-0.0069811107,
0.02788366,
0.0324729793,
0.0927861407,
0.0117155043,
-0.0200742595,
-0.0245201383,
0.0125717316,
-0.0041736951,
-0.002565667,
0.0837453082,
0.0039251046,
-0.0249764621,
-0.0724176764,
0.0327920727,
-0.1039806306,
-0.0037891404,
-0.0271216333,
0.0808521584,
-0.0125173703,
-0.04272338,
-0.0290299095,
0.0470758863,
0.0339242071,
0.0392334536,
0.0359505452,
-0.0422600284,
-0.0558422022,
0.0205234978,
0.0181205571,
-0.0519736223,
-0.0388696305,
-0.0068395697,
0.0116346162,
-0.0025705115,
-0.0976951644,
-0.043947652,
0.0388695858,
-0.0367814451,
-0.025272049,
-0.0272982251,
-0.0335036814,
0.0030819585,
-0.092182368,
0.0572534539,
0.0408934057,
0.0276746452,
0.0025823012,
-0.0017473289,
0.0288695078,
0.0060963072,
-0.0253965557,
0.0133669088,
-0.1030403748,
-0.0166671425,
0.0278299972,
-0.0234227795,
0.0177366678,
-0.0478268452,
0.007409581,
-0.0517441332,
0.0427845381,
0.0403585732,
0.0012042752,
-0.0086896894,
0.0244917497,
0.0163143296,
-0.0115138059,
0.0555254743,
-0.0269183032,
0.0466853678,
0.0254670195,
0.001090579,
0.0189082157,
-0.0124067888,
0.0097237471,
0.0182840917,
0.0095380014,
0.0235283915,
-0.0557881854,
-0.0230294652,
-0.0499781705,
0.017535381,
-0.0096780742,
-0.0324332342,
0.0060268524,
0.0246325992,
0.040328037,
-0.0495342612,
-0.0404170901,
0.0073004705,
-0.0146145383,
-0.0586723052,
-0.013310059,
0.0072766519,
0.018574439,
-0.0295436103,
0.0123435101,
-0.0266599245,
0.0544304997,
-0.0138334753,
0.0124628684,
-0.0295425486,
0.0321339294,
-0.0012424364,
0.0023433703,
0.0205953866,
0.0763197988,
-0.0419548936,
-0.0398445539,
-0.040748693,
-0.022531148,
0.0723812804,
-0.0100121107,
0.0973929539,
-0.0115026329,
0.0111197811,
0.0040527405,
0.0051077683,
-0.0241692476,
-0.0100231497,
0.0139365671,
-0.0117040668,
-0.0141317202,
0.0030240575,
0.0410803258,
-0.0023595809,
0.0132520795,
0.0555932298,
-0.0149457697,
-0.0158509985,
-0.0017829256,
0.025546968,
0.0456060357,
-0.0325160176,
0.0033436748,
-0.0020831171,
-0.0551147424,
0.0615877509,
-0.0296506528,
-0.0203561988,
-0.0244095288,
0.031657055,
0.0221863277,
0.0273437798,
-0.0169357248,
-0.0311975405,
0.0005133982,
-0.0597440898,
-0.0504979342,
-0.0562556572,
-5.996219459e-33,
0.0058534066,
-0.0210263878,
-0.0319031365,
0.0020383182,
-0.012129887,
0.0543906279,
-0.0152291488,
0.0067905048,
0.0100140311,
0.0603514537,
0.0325581133,
0.0607604571,
0.0027199092,
0.0586905964,
0.0140530365,
-0.0336749107,
0.0038621349,
-0.0001287809,
0.0005900832,
0.0347705409,
0.016980553,
0.0775514692,
0.0814350843,
-0.0510994531,
-0.0035529891,
0.0266337041,
-0.0016257891,
0.0048580403,
0.0421062112,
0.063244462,
-0.0581352301,
0.077889815,
0.0575477444,
-0.0025680652,
0.0122133428,
0.0253311582,
-0.0514991879,
-0.0679699257,
-0.0278113727,
-0.0117141809,
-0.0838547274,
0.004886983,
0.0421614163,
-0.0052542463,
0.0391933657,
-0.0103748003,
0.0694422796,
0.0112252366,
0.050785888,
-0.0370407216,
-0.0435901396,
0.0082757352,
-0.004311319,
-0.0040559676,
-0.0207605939,
0.0622901656,
-0.0374613367,
0.0417045429,
-0.0639844984,
-0.0061544226,
-0.0689797699,
-0.0055376408,
0.0098282322,
-0.0737986937,
-0.0353626311,
0.0790282488,
0.0046942066,
-0.0153415995,
-0.0072153206,
0.0037414557,
-0.0092978245,
0.0427876525,
0.0777475089,
0.0312918425,
0.0556366555,
0.0187391918,
-0.0668820217,
0.0237462465,
0.0398196839,
0.0063317078,
0.0037349195,
-0.0228289049,
-0.0126632676,
0.0024710996,
0.003504653,
0.0085577797,
-0.0462729931,
-0.0385298654,
0.0313404985,
-0.0052432348,
-0.0324086286,
-0.0059337821,
-0.0186813362,
-0.0451525636,
-0.0142057706,
-0.0070225294,
0.0016818949,
0.0340526588,
0.0339211971,
0.0088863559,
-0.0115428707,
0.0016766586,
0.0174030084,
0.0204964429,
0.0766964704,
-0.004287851,
0.0292342249,
-0.0385621749,
-0.0307496041,
-0.0015430838,
0.0108390879,
0.0139686679,
-0.0417607203,
0.0672800839,
-0.0422833972,
0.0095308637,
-0.0076767472,
0.0308584366,
0.0503282174,
0.0338533074,
-0.050118424,
-0.0346009508,
0.0264996309,
-0.0086989487,
0.0022604349,
-0.0503635146,
-0.02225269,
-0.0035166482,
0.0236673187,
-0.0727445707,
0.0004706727,
-0.0215057991,
2.841e-7,
0.0463810079,
0.0558463857,
-0.0037200737,
-0.0105574923,
0.0243954044,
0.0054968917,
0.0384291187,
0.0650020614,
0.0311540645,
-0.0084380778,
0.0233837329,
0.026062537,
0.0498955175,
0.0344563834,
-0.0495111682,
-0.0355870873,
-0.0206624214,
-0.0394506007,
-0.0562013984,
-0.0196278021,
0.0905461311,
0.0830752626,
0.0032105618,
-0.0382929817,
0.0179590546,
-0.0203077756,
0.0241752639,
-0.01175455,
0.0359385386,
0.0243063234,
0.0715356395,
-0.0100342231,
-0.0042132265,
0.0006529734,
-0.0017393437,
-0.0131928334,
0.0294865407,
0.0170768313,
-0.0308769401,
-0.0381081328,
-0.0155345621,
0.0308666043,
0.0007111593,
0.0029110303,
0.0594338812,
-0.1000253111,
-0.0540651493,
-0.006376937,
-0.0026212423,
-0.0448831879,
0.0752030313,
0.00264864,
-0.0331935138,
0.020164974,
0.0424508564,
-0.0044089132,
-0.0171267688,
-0.0965702385,
-0.0213847011,
0.0145067107,
-0.0410795659,
0.0172294416,
-0.0425343029,
-0.0276346169,
-0.013099594,
-0.0561131351,
0.0027008753,
2.406619661e-34,
-0.0081733158,
0.0334386677,
0.0104174586,
0.0007453772,
0.0110485526,
0.0117702978,
-0.031027738,
-0.0235137399,
-0.021909764,
-0.1071840897,
0.0022784506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10935v1 | Intent Detection and Slot Filling for Home Assistants: Dataset and Analysis for Bangla and Sylheti | 2023-10-17T02:12:12 | 2023-10-17T02:12:12 | Fardin Ahsan Sakib, A H M Rezaul Karim, Saadat Hasan Khan, Md Mushfiqur Rahman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As voice assistants cement their place in our technologically advanced
society, there remains a need to cater to the diverse linguistic landscape,
including colloquial forms of low-resource languages. Our study introduces the
first-ever comprehensive dataset for intent detection and slot filling in
formal Bangla, colloquial Bangla, and Sylheti languages, totaling 984 samples
across 10 unique intents. Our analysis reveals the robustness of large language
models for tackling downstream tasks with inadequate data. The GPT-3.5 model
achieves an impressive F1 score of 0.94 in intent detection and 0.51 in slot
filling for colloquial Bangla. | [
0.0483270139,
0.032490436,
-0.027407391,
-0.0090914275,
-0.0549516268,
-0.0065864986,
0.0042224429,
-0.02636889,
0.0173020363,
-0.0206927825,
-0.0163998511,
-0.0639641285,
0.0390893742,
0.0189008601,
-0.0073407246,
-0.0379740521,
0.0228085648,
-0.0297875348,
0.0414854586,
0.0088274451,
-0.0057433164,
0.0422611982,
-0.0459283441,
0.0612800382,
-0.0320505686,
-0.0214791559,
-0.0236991365,
0.0119956098,
-0.0187633745,
-0.0133791007,
-0.0023620373,
0.0588371493,
0.0036935955,
0.0306656081,
0.0000017642,
-0.0754414424,
0.0026176197,
-0.0093420492,
-0.0881322175,
-0.0159885362,
-0.0038509143,
0.0178471897,
-0.0239839721,
0.0367140435,
-0.011936144,
0.0187859982,
0.0654099509,
0.0157184731,
-0.0200225487,
0.0649839193,
-0.016592009,
-0.019425964,
0.0279578511,
-0.0310561936,
0.0476458855,
-0.0500766821,
0.0124241281,
-0.0059707072,
0.0249245055,
-0.0299140718,
0.0164022576,
0.03329904,
-0.0015207694,
-0.0210673641,
-0.0298046563,
-0.0022590039,
-0.0229107924,
-0.0390830114,
-0.0209794994,
0.0430441201,
-0.0129425181,
-0.0061111334,
0.0083686113,
-0.026718745,
-0.0177398864,
-0.0121936807,
-0.0252361875,
0.0094126081,
-0.0193979926,
-0.0101560792,
0.0508835725,
0.0080214934,
0.0099045141,
-0.0173092429,
0.0044585406,
0.0499573201,
0.0208879393,
-0.0429055132,
-0.0095743136,
-0.0091094607,
-0.003390919,
-0.017952593,
0.0278217476,
-0.0086044371,
-0.0419788919,
0.0363321528,
-0.0059020007,
-0.0060560796,
0.0391353369,
-0.0046884585,
0.0272876527,
0.064777784,
-0.0591959395,
0.0249584746,
0.0406263471,
0.0185976252,
0.0021270898,
-0.0121121714,
-0.0471164435,
0.0079321787,
-0.0309278723,
-0.0209348835,
-0.033095438,
-0.0123827318,
-0.0587569624,
-0.0068334718,
-0.040607512,
0.0263418779,
0.0082126567,
-0.0051572965,
0.0177917853,
-0.0328601897,
-0.0288669709,
-0.0190671533,
0.0192919113,
0.0300109908,
-0.0241971277,
0.0862017646,
-0.0078562638,
-0.1029306427,
0.0150302052,
0.016518848,
-0.0002661496,
-0.0266929269,
-0.0054042581,
-0.0138308872,
-0.0122435614,
-0.0579525381,
-0.0379995108,
0.0198315792,
-0.0345245562,
-0.0819271281,
-0.0477025285,
-0.0459712371,
0.0296522044,
0.01458102,
0.0115063116,
-0.0026512304,
-0.0126237962,
0.0220713578,
0.0047926987,
0.0848554224,
0.0028015012,
0.0463196486,
0.0435773022,
0.0144625278,
-0.0007427027,
0.0608568005,
-0.0008210047,
0.0057398267,
0.0362794623,
-0.0146187916,
-0.0116521418,
0.0513003878,
-0.0135666523,
0.0225456581,
0.0290482696,
0.0310369544,
-0.002386098,
0.0047909762,
-0.0132649392,
0.0392690897,
0.004570412,
0.0335064232,
0.0663389862,
0.0871022344,
0.0009335829,
0.0257590562,
0.0370060205,
0.0446869284,
-0.0174833462,
-0.011491878,
-0.0297902562,
-0.0257120375,
-0.0316638164,
-0.0067409673,
0.012497819,
0.0093577029,
-0.0229053237,
0.0100882137,
-0.0136614582,
-0.0567993633,
-0.0117666069,
0.0002409057,
0.043320898,
-0.0087921638,
-0.0336699598,
0.0192310512,
-0.0004835151,
-0.0380996801,
-0.030248668,
-0.0430380479,
0.0546158068,
0.031379018,
0.0108107971,
0.0058350693,
-0.0379530191,
-0.0330664963,
-0.0030919993,
-0.0174858849,
0.0055796513,
-0.0086463224,
0.0338836163,
-0.0314256363,
0.0058405544,
0.0625864714,
0.0027924657,
0.0218992885,
-0.0454210155,
0.0131893959,
0.0068090255,
-0.0293631442,
0.0266555604,
-0.0074100858,
0.0117400968,
-0.0058065788,
0.0274416655,
0.0282827709,
0.0600345209,
0.0472470932,
0.0134357065,
-0.031711828,
0.011395921,
-0.0048758853,
0.033272747,
0.0518975183,
-0.0398784876,
0.0032214327,
0.0235535111,
0.0038504782,
-0.0096601741,
0.0248399265,
0.0243046563,
-0.0808642283,
-0.0070111728,
-0.0210729521,
0.0241353083,
-0.071563527,
0.052141469,
0.0107581532,
0.0076902532,
0.0242078975,
0.0221884884,
0.0068211439,
-0.0021338167,
0.0457947776,
0.0377178714,
0.0456233323,
-0.0697330832,
-0.0315826349,
0.0215834118,
-0.0246087071,
0.0157291964,
-0.0004279284,
0.0502111763,
-0.0534166023,
0.0117280884,
-0.1276396364,
-0.0235207938,
-0.0242977459,
-0.0168159101,
0.0104144895,
0.06526158,
-0.0205675848,
-0.0266607124,
0.0087282173,
-0.0273848027,
0.0252521653,
0.012814668,
-0.0287635941,
-0.013925124,
-0.052734945,
-0.0223906767,
0.0154595915,
0.0032768936,
-0.0266687199,
0.0128292423,
-0.0378833041,
-0.0448045321,
-0.0288752094,
0.0262107812,
0.0128088379,
-0.0151850963,
-0.0482006334,
-0.0152602047,
-0.0194972809,
-0.0157559123,
0.053226497,
-0.0398939401,
-0.0170046147,
0.0284807961,
-0.0010498837,
-0.0143332742,
0.0122102154,
-0.0066092084,
0.0074835406,
-0.0278107598,
-0.0198134389,
0.0051410822,
0.0166498981,
0.0272095595,
0.042947229,
-0.0387210362,
-0.0589073673,
-0.0271867346,
-0.0406104736,
-0.0289960559,
0.0151180662,
-0.0837955773,
0.0901653618,
0.0209881607,
-0.0772516951,
0.0401085392,
-0.0491130576,
-0.0512091219,
-0.0673862696,
0.0019065849,
-0.011059585,
0.028506536,
-0.051217027,
0.0199765302,
0.0175191015,
-0.0641601607,
-0.0092312451,
0.0204813816,
0.0071705035,
-0.0107399803,
0.0528181121,
-0.0736119896,
0.0305484291,
-0.0055844886,
-0.0540849715,
-0.0404971391,
-0.0504058935,
-0.0264295898,
0.0169866998,
0.0133949742,
-0.0109005664,
0.0229157377,
0.0373184457,
-0.0331399478,
0.0378418379,
0.0185597725,
0.0176299345,
-0.0030158127,
0.0018798783,
0.0524250828,
0.0338297337,
-0.0631356388,
0.0452634729,
0.0150351888,
-0.0499997884,
0.0406156816,
0.0191434678,
-0.0065046027,
0.0494820029,
0.0552503839,
0.017092539,
-0.0144931823,
0.061168246,
0.0611709431,
0.0139396228,
-0.0240525212,
0.1083747819,
0.0115536004,
-0.0369329453,
-0.0191158969,
-0.0716950148,
0.0060065989,
-0.0185826551,
0.0141793042,
-0.0731062964,
-0.0294686835,
0.0362147987,
0.0249012578,
0.0119972304,
0.0284857582,
-0.0126078716,
-0.1417526603,
0.0523398221,
-0.000229194,
-0.0341425389,
-0.0416147523,
-0.0185177606,
0.0226778537,
-0.0253548361,
0.0328111909,
0.0133118909,
-0.0227570683,
-0.0712207854,
0.0307524577,
-0.0338269211,
-0.0478302911,
0.0485338606,
-0.0230646748,
0.1035351381,
0.0491096377,
0.0040290598,
-0.0012662432,
-0.0126966657,
-0.0220700577,
0.0010833812,
-0.0218050815,
-0.0059810644,
-0.0112483092,
0.0038283346,
0.0022268305,
0.0263501853,
0.0636373609,
-0.0451631919,
0.0127892522,
0.0387958214,
0.0655272603,
-0.0288603362,
0.0151550118,
0.000947683,
0.0187417306,
0.0797478557,
0.0586033501,
0.0319826528,
-0.0408962965,
-0.0004108276,
0.0002401862,
-0.018576242,
0.0316778682,
0.0113565419,
0.0563802272,
-0.0374938212,
-0.0643365681,
-0.0020426672,
-0.065750055,
0.0654445887,
0.0324566923,
0.062832512,
0.0726950467,
0.0238290131,
0.0270159356,
0.0108232079,
-0.0224940646,
-0.0157142356,
0.0681578964,
-0.0842449218,
-0.0285006277,
0.0182760227,
-0.0397932678,
-0.0041040662,
-0.0031474142,
-0.0516375937,
-0.0394287631,
0.0306251999,
0.0297986083,
0.0355028771,
0.0498469844,
-0.0623080693,
-0.0315484777,
-0.0306225475,
-0.0132266162,
-0.0437996909,
-0.0082212221,
0.0624165908,
0.0223312993,
0.0091553247,
0.0477482416,
-0.0379910767,
0.0103157479,
-0.0381941609,
0.0117097581,
-0.0488944426,
-0.0166523457,
0.0223575532,
0.0171574205,
0.0358684063,
-0.0481681898,
0.0080816066,
-0.0443061963,
0.0491384417,
0.0305035207,
0.0153938774,
-0.0215524435,
-0.006927561,
0.0522514805,
0.0242674779,
0.0023519094,
-0.0578993484,
-0.0622618124,
-0.0020836869,
-0.0239174645,
0.0280936826,
0.0210427791,
0.041544117,
0.0446172729,
-0.0096765971,
-0.0164457969,
0.0186306238,
0.0002986287,
0.0188900065,
0.0216667615,
0.0741360337,
-0.0258353297,
-0.0207872074,
0.0290197283,
0.0532714725,
0.0638899952,
-0.048578877,
0.0160813052,
0.0208831951,
0.0599897876,
-0.0631531402,
0.0591166615,
-0.0319845825,
0.0416398495,
-0.0521849506,
0.0448856205,
-0.0293063037,
0.0015797245,
0.0392929986,
-0.0102254786,
-0.0433093421,
0.0066631618,
0.0301803444,
-0.0020217844,
0.0289908722,
0.0079223141,
0.0251248144,
-0.0443549715,
-0.0458593592,
0.0036898497,
0.0383205786,
-0.0371855721,
-0.0022299269,
-0.0687472001,
-0.0563833043,
-0.036332991,
-0.0433425009,
0.027200859,
-0.0019310954,
0.0299634691,
0.0509646758,
-0.0164502468,
-0.0033574624,
-0.0429337956,
-0.0675192699,
-0.0480767265,
0.0116886422,
-0.0088865608,
-5.664657685e-33,
-0.0090119634,
0.0055123139,
0.0007920804,
-0.0396453589,
0.0208819415,
-0.0084163332,
-0.0168662257,
-0.001393433,
0.0074995426,
-0.02256101,
-0.0348306373,
-0.000898318,
0.0347765349,
0.0201669615,
0.0530360788,
-0.0011605104,
0.0394911729,
0.0066909171,
-0.0002437418,
0.0049705589,
0.0379895531,
0.0264391731,
0.0568392612,
-0.0613489449,
-0.0000331668,
-0.0119254356,
-0.0286478028,
0.0149629815,
-0.0286375321,
0.0467479527,
-0.0144873243,
0.0267694127,
0.0171548277,
0.0050554187,
-0.0012804697,
0.0488877296,
-0.0735555291,
-0.0190173555,
0.075576894,
0.0551740862,
-0.0095087923,
0.0129078301,
-0.0262798928,
-0.0059418101,
-0.039551001,
0.0605308376,
-0.0104882708,
-0.0115577234,
-0.0124579174,
0.0383112654,
-0.0547775291,
0.0231434163,
-0.0182519406,
-0.0437035523,
0.0174140967,
0.0415786766,
-0.0205251221,
-0.0699362308,
-0.0560657494,
0.0303466003,
0.0138292443,
0.0218094103,
0.0400845148,
-0.0048715435,
-0.0080273505,
0.0240662638,
0.057984516,
-0.068430379,
0.0387874916,
0.001528285,
-0.0114310654,
0.0705827773,
-0.0318645686,
-0.0169214141,
0.050865721,
-0.0490905643,
0.0005232677,
0.0139492434,
0.0678638071,
0.0384835526,
0.0258196294,
0.0220173113,
-0.0762598142,
-0.0277335569,
-0.0089716949,
-0.0410491228,
-0.0373363681,
-0.0316088796,
0.0867489204,
-0.0002493215,
0.0128458953,
0.012157633,
0.0504707582,
-0.0038791243,
0.0239991862,
-0.0129630091,
-0.0285315178,
0.0161355399,
-0.0105669554,
0.0414224491,
-0.0708711371,
-0.0245534535,
0.0192970913,
0.062217705,
0.006640499,
-0.0013845195,
0.000646178,
0.0426643305,
-0.0424113125,
0.0162807181,
-0.0282662082,
0.0156087959,
-0.023147637,
0.052374769,
0.0685713664,
-0.0189788975,
-0.0176048484,
0.0616019964,
0.0128276506,
-0.0028280925,
-0.0326722376,
-0.0515677482,
-0.012729656,
-0.0051159761,
-0.0327832885,
0.0081011336,
-0.0465805195,
-0.039700713,
0.0423888229,
-0.0075353454,
0.0106501793,
-0.0078990189,
2.604e-7,
-0.0229086876,
0.0199385863,
0.0129600028,
0.0253192391,
-0.0267695729,
0.0326981582,
-0.0323312506,
0.0163298603,
-0.0039573759,
0.0428883471,
0.0485450551,
-0.0678094253,
0.0544644408,
-0.0032283096,
-0.1487099975,
0.018747421,
-0.0626974925,
0.0040454403,
-0.0726650134,
0.0188663658,
0.0061437334,
0.0878730863,
0.0125836954,
-0.049232319,
0.0084627457,
-0.0452371314,
0.0004236053,
-0.045234073,
0.0214308221,
0.0060030534,
0.0525618643,
0.0151427453,
0.0007940146,
0.0056818607,
-0.0251202509,
0.0102108158,
0.001723115,
0.070756793,
-0.0084579596,
-0.0380559489,
0.012587294,
0.008359584,
-0.0169217959,
-0.0630812272,
0.0700099468,
0.0199866053,
-0.0474837646,
0.0082380492,
-0.006910746,
-0.0139898984,
0.005576368,
-0.0238108002,
0.0089579821,
-0.0092164371,
-0.0068061659,
-0.0575938486,
-0.0282757729,
-0.025741348,
0.0243820231,
0.0097210845,
-0.0324200988,
-0.0427010655,
-0.0216937792,
-0.0072168331,
-0.0006958835,
-0.0437408462,
0.0023473175,
2.086088295e-34,
0.0443235748,
-0.0040884279,
0.0382251553,
0.0659147054,
0.0286022052,
-0.0061601847,
0.0194883607,
0.0436918028,
0.0300056133,
-0.0667419657,
-0.0282202139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10930v1 | Enhanced Transformer Architecture for Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-17T01:59:07 | 2023-10-17T01:59:07 | Woohyeon Moon, Taeyoung Kim, Bumgeun Park, Dongsoo Har | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformer is a state-of-the-art model in the field of natural language
processing (NLP). Current NLP models primarily increase the number of
transformers to improve processing performance. However, this technique
requires a lot of training resources such as computing capacity. In this paper,
a novel structure of Transformer is proposed. It is featured by full layer
normalization, weighted residual connection, positional encoding exploiting
reinforcement learning, and zero masked self-attention. The proposed
Transformer model, which is called Enhanced Transformer, is validated by the
bilingual evaluation understudy (BLEU) score obtained with the Multi30k
translation dataset. As a result, the Enhanced Transformer achieves 202.96%
higher BLEU score as compared to the original transformer with the translation
dataset. | [
0.0193949211,
0.0115191014,
-0.0158859491,
0.0524204783,
0.002718301,
-0.0050601377,
0.0259662922,
-0.0364038609,
-0.0120143732,
-0.0287329238,
-0.0691380128,
-0.0154459327,
0.0031932078,
0.0021019981,
0.0137561345,
-0.0521961376,
0.0231837444,
0.0021537472,
-0.0251832362,
-0.0114811948,
-0.0220616441,
-0.0138746435,
0.0070035858,
0.0314280652,
0.0048526768,
0.0129979448,
0.009454756,
-0.0169853233,
0.0356819741,
-0.0351187587,
-0.0133097628,
0.045309972,
-0.0061013368,
0.0342688449,
0.000002377,
-0.0216916688,
-0.0101091703,
-0.0166158564,
0.0174256675,
-0.0654466897,
0.0187974703,
-0.0628729463,
-0.0407410115,
0.0063536088,
-0.0269798078,
-0.0071830731,
0.0615241602,
0.1290844828,
0.0483304337,
0.0825296938,
-0.0121964328,
-0.1022155285,
0.024469316,
-0.0168538708,
-0.0207881313,
-0.0394269153,
-0.0052600536,
-0.008336327,
-0.0365880094,
0.0053751315,
-0.0563589074,
0.0380732603,
0.0454169624,
-0.0050268406,
-0.004915785,
0.0201827772,
-0.0232451912,
-0.0348590501,
-0.0348394476,
0.054069262,
-0.0756698549,
-0.0109114256,
-0.0331990905,
0.0142133264,
-0.0022011101,
-0.0226515811,
-0.0321405157,
0.0255417321,
0.0359494314,
0.02358713,
0.0235451125,
0.0540409312,
0.0164130423,
-0.0065749944,
-0.048194252,
0.053396225,
-0.006656026,
-0.0568224564,
-0.0085539427,
0.020848399,
0.0220943857,
0.0031418274,
0.0499548689,
0.0142172696,
-0.0219295695,
0.0111778844,
-0.0074348077,
-0.074945271,
-0.0128643708,
-0.0630403534,
-0.0113717215,
0.0653468743,
-0.0274109785,
0.0276059471,
-0.0825791731,
0.0951586068,
-0.0414613932,
0.0307804048,
-0.0423411056,
-0.0323697552,
0.0050132563,
0.0006769885,
-0.0457426496,
0.0451350212,
-0.0430303365,
-0.0130662629,
-0.0304544829,
0.0191720687,
-0.0367413126,
-0.0241114087,
0.0535352454,
0.0498731136,
-0.0554162189,
0.0077024805,
-0.0219427831,
0.0631086975,
0.0008938582,
-0.0390325598,
-0.0279768743,
-0.0353794172,
-0.0022559967,
0.0213512499,
0.023225626,
-0.045087602,
0.0059984368,
0.0675463453,
-0.0053467811,
-0.053787794,
-0.0061362688,
0.0492265485,
0.003652978,
-0.0686659515,
-0.0111671779,
-0.0674161091,
0.0350355357,
-0.0080628414,
0.0149466572,
-0.005989071,
0.0138627701,
0.0313434303,
-0.0080120442,
0.0477777049,
0.0434796326,
-0.0212209001,
0.0135306641,
0.0016888286,
0.0243164934,
0.0637443811,
0.0413358733,
0.0271196254,
0.0086020054,
-0.0261198282,
-0.0198334381,
0.0101232519,
0.0056921272,
-0.0110473959,
-0.0155299203,
-0.0251555182,
-0.0378757827,
0.0173214618,
0.0503022522,
0.0315329023,
-0.0184904113,
-0.0207997896,
0.0341836959,
0.0385650285,
0.0218300857,
0.0565410703,
0.0130971801,
0.025108885,
-0.0166224856,
0.0020181593,
-0.0234961491,
0.068843089,
-0.0072497167,
-0.0260215215,
-0.0250331257,
0.0555450954,
-0.0496456586,
-0.0305982418,
0.0057152486,
-0.0120008048,
0.0594464056,
-0.0253383853,
0.0400375128,
0.0354712754,
-0.0432601683,
0.0819355324,
-0.0057687284,
-0.0270868782,
-0.0085666403,
-0.0194835514,
-0.0431910232,
0.0153934034,
0.0271497499,
0.0045856345,
-0.0224667639,
-0.0398532003,
-0.0405929834,
0.073614791,
0.0103547629,
0.0350243412,
-0.0058154152,
-0.0577540956,
-0.0229513142,
0.0248863008,
-0.0181350652,
0.0239911024,
-0.0109642018,
0.0152987344,
0.0194979385,
0.0167129617,
-0.0442560129,
0.0258217305,
-0.0050841249,
-0.0379884467,
0.0315851904,
0.0189631116,
0.0151727777,
0.0260997359,
0.0067490609,
-0.0280764587,
0.0431183055,
-0.0382456444,
-0.0505862646,
0.0260536987,
-0.0776883066,
-0.0389804095,
0.0326901264,
-0.0666510314,
-0.0089923656,
0.0676587969,
-0.0304584485,
-0.0631865039,
0.0292046946,
-0.0390731469,
0.0133764688,
-0.0089608403,
0.0261176452,
-0.002245561,
0.044206664,
-0.0290555358,
0.0542145409,
-0.0228046309,
0.0453339592,
-0.0075495257,
-0.0055615278,
0.0265829917,
-0.0350171067,
-0.0712744743,
0.0098572783,
-0.0292953383,
0.023230426,
0.0340786763,
0.0111940466,
0.0041579441,
-0.041155342,
-0.0383743159,
0.0172347631,
-0.0222941041,
0.0081697498,
0.0229598284,
0.0325962901,
0.008192325,
-0.0402516089,
-0.0253327526,
-0.0156942271,
0.0386188067,
-0.0216870941,
0.0296377204,
-0.0234851111,
0.0089235902,
-0.0063496572,
-0.0251085013,
0.0084720617,
0.0290612876,
-0.0018892458,
-0.0190308355,
-0.0545893647,
-0.0069618481,
0.0057566362,
0.0587999523,
0.0219311919,
-0.0865795538,
-0.013821925,
0.0465010852,
0.0595644526,
0.0634679273,
0.0218295511,
0.0061898245,
0.0421421602,
0.0066888249,
-0.0292699803,
0.0471363589,
-0.0605234839,
-0.0040208036,
-0.0474684052,
-0.0186712295,
0.005036056,
0.0784932896,
0.0194848124,
-0.0137297632,
-0.0568162501,
-0.0490804277,
0.004183759,
-0.0143178646,
0.0171277262,
0.0222868156,
-0.0441522412,
0.0126802931,
-0.0403490737,
-0.0132500706,
0.0391676091,
-0.0275501385,
-0.0157379359,
-0.1029753238,
-0.001553283,
-0.0194734037,
0.0197328124,
0.0317220502,
0.0426583104,
-0.0613058694,
-0.0435946137,
-0.0169922728,
0.0079556657,
-0.0075013964,
-0.0352567658,
0.0487897657,
0.0084327161,
-0.0100321583,
-0.0141144041,
-0.0377768986,
-0.0581749752,
0.0381260067,
-0.0070841135,
0.0171723869,
0.0313112251,
-0.0092496667,
-0.0794415101,
0.0199188776,
0.0500570908,
0.0878837332,
-0.0162129551,
-0.0034381093,
-0.0192702487,
0.0199092869,
-0.0045942534,
0.0551402271,
0.051049076,
0.0250925217,
0.0179892536,
0.0412901752,
0.0039752894,
-0.0132501936,
-0.0199110098,
-0.0320966318,
0.0371886939,
-0.0486889035,
0.0116088279,
-0.013410042,
0.0119262636,
-0.0656902716,
-0.007094285,
0.0964764208,
0.0380495265,
-0.0453108661,
0.0008486562,
-0.024471296,
-0.0152301583,
0.0519809984,
0.0288945343,
-0.0538183525,
-0.0102140922,
-0.0211632475,
-0.0209752545,
-0.0073556243,
0.000447201,
0.0271105822,
-0.1039225757,
0.0125444466,
-0.0068972073,
-0.0144786499,
-0.0487107486,
-0.0435097553,
-0.0071075386,
-0.0314684622,
0.040772602,
-0.0243105888,
0.0186583493,
-0.0610301085,
0.0095555419,
-0.0042802012,
-0.0727008358,
-0.0145294312,
-0.0379992202,
0.0061687985,
0.0211396273,
0.0405465886,
-0.0484548062,
-0.0596587509,
-0.0149598159,
-0.0099781808,
0.0153218266,
-0.0038996048,
0.0377523787,
0.0000015485,
-0.0205157381,
-0.0302077755,
-0.0353050791,
-0.0259401761,
-0.0081811091,
-0.0430757105,
0.087259464,
-0.0096712792,
0.0137755927,
0.0060737538,
-0.0056459317,
-0.0238702279,
0.0389618464,
-0.0193660092,
-0.0483435914,
-0.021951817,
-0.0041857897,
-0.0191847309,
-0.0642860532,
-0.0623162277,
0.0412019864,
-0.0110702179,
-0.0635761395,
-0.0590107739,
-0.0387006439,
-0.0056964587,
0.0216766782,
0.0119470377,
-0.0158441719,
0.0295022838,
-0.029127581,
-0.0211774446,
0.028202679,
0.0043795719,
-0.0006306196,
-0.056281615,
0.0372216515,
-0.0010168137,
-0.0281596575,
-0.0121163521,
0.0032397255,
-0.0662351921,
-0.0182587747,
0.0245590452,
0.0533059686,
0.009946811,
0.016740473,
-0.0546291284,
-0.0616967119,
0.0153658418,
0.0336989015,
-0.0631899536,
-0.0175614953,
0.0271658562,
-0.0425200537,
0.0028004267,
0.0203067102,
0.0206986722,
0.0452364273,
0.0085303178,
0.0368302129,
-0.0182775017,
-0.0084367255,
0.0194702055,
-0.0015571846,
0.0857176632,
0.0087174494,
0.0751453415,
-0.0293615181,
0.0295205545,
-0.0252116472,
0.0051338077,
-0.0094945636,
-0.0026013674,
0.0456066802,
0.0060184048,
0.0097594801,
0.0330281518,
-0.0264001917,
-0.069097057,
-0.0010733185,
0.049923256,
-0.0017866977,
-0.0234847181,
-0.0122255189,
0.0524681844,
-0.01436288,
-0.0274056327,
0.0694797486,
0.0465314798,
-0.0066480697,
0.035552118,
0.0233867355,
0.0020031724,
-0.0382762253,
0.0247603785,
-0.0364473797,
0.0035081522,
-0.0012722762,
-0.0183209814,
0.0564998537,
-0.0256424751,
0.0477640443,
0.0405633301,
-0.0139566483,
0.0081972806,
0.0082311183,
-0.029816879,
-0.0165745057,
0.0307377055,
-0.014922821,
0.0027988038,
-0.0175549947,
0.0330030546,
-0.0634595603,
-0.0191517342,
-0.0153935663,
0.0012081808,
-0.0266670398,
0.0210413355,
-0.0153934099,
0.0105700493,
-0.0287139788,
0.0098062586,
-0.0184354819,
-0.0566004999,
0.0142522613,
-0.0193292219,
0.0244052485,
-0.0447995476,
0.0240947921,
0.0229689032,
-0.0022784569,
-0.0264980514,
-0.0256025717,
0.0122604826,
0.0261830706,
-0.0092907511,
-0.0220304094,
-6.994802644e-33,
-0.0135641787,
-0.0210466105,
0.0149561185,
-0.0184095353,
-0.0136066284,
0.0198136605,
-0.0086026127,
-0.0017758685,
-0.0202048626,
0.0010686457,
-0.0253522005,
-0.0135572739,
0.0233065262,
0.0448891595,
-0.0064645498,
0.0102374014,
0.0524800085,
0.0227441061,
-0.0009866616,
-0.0198535137,
0.0294725746,
0.0300730616,
0.1272162944,
-0.0598330125,
-0.0211966336,
0.0090715475,
0.0012663866,
0.0236550495,
0.039363917,
0.0573213995,
-0.0164718889,
0.0517199934,
0.0443956517,
-0.1035089493,
-0.0081222877,
0.0077024112,
-0.0922469869,
-0.0453151502,
0.0085317241,
0.0747093111,
-0.0335079283,
0.0034390807,
0.0809163824,
-0.0012340022,
-0.0025727137,
-0.0006576933,
0.0253893584,
-0.0104495566,
-0.0210564174,
0.0201887116,
-0.0729871765,
0.0367226973,
0.0225609969,
0.0118424902,
0.0450541563,
0.0569967218,
-0.0370976068,
0.0061796242,
-0.1331649274,
-0.0319530033,
-0.0131525276,
0.0385275483,
0.0503622703,
0.0229956713,
-0.0243427735,
-0.0007486365,
0.0368891731,
-0.0004164336,
-0.0480749495,
-0.0257717855,
0.0450076014,
0.0007508101,
0.0670803785,
-0.0024615617,
0.0286688898,
-0.0387500077,
-0.0434162728,
0.0209785346,
-0.0091531146,
0.075287126,
0.044508934,
0.0319902711,
-0.0260589514,
-0.0027875041,
-0.0252104327,
-0.0164573509,
-0.010405995,
-0.0405133329,
0.0061430605,
0.0297436304,
-0.0256250184,
0.0274893828,
0.0366608277,
-0.0374430753,
0.0379019044,
0.0100659346,
0.0054837652,
0.0267554205,
0.0007815604,
0.0165300518,
-0.0627353564,
-0.009454743,
-0.006279374,
0.031449765,
-0.0024903573,
0.0016590089,
0.0500281714,
0.0237403475,
-0.0786252618,
-0.0011733507,
-0.036812637,
0.0109861307,
-0.0000320771,
0.1022089496,
0.000865359,
0.0084692016,
-0.0145189073,
0.0570516065,
0.0120085832,
-0.0068904008,
-0.017742062,
0.0401133262,
0.0478921272,
0.0361031964,
-0.0290424749,
0.0133517561,
-0.0545370616,
0.0596886724,
0.0137971519,
-0.0816387385,
-0.03118884,
0.0208034758,
3.143e-7,
0.0489693992,
0.0326390639,
0.0146267731,
0.0040916526,
-0.0054482752,
0.0195275862,
0.0474201441,
0.0510328673,
0.0268235449,
0.0453456193,
-0.0197248366,
0.0255932193,
-0.0063305162,
0.0288891271,
-0.0937641114,
-0.0278373845,
-0.0354447812,
-0.0078313379,
0.0042653917,
0.0157883801,
0.0320300274,
0.1127525046,
0.0006262219,
0.0093368767,
-0.0043498115,
0.0239063855,
0.0355291441,
0.0156080024,
0.0061317612,
0.0026871646,
0.0513550304,
0.0723670721,
-0.0169254616,
0.0088931303,
-0.0084518939,
0.0666706786,
0.0013461013,
0.0360712633,
-0.0403776206,
0.0035548874,
0.0558461212,
-0.017841097,
-0.0174720641,
-0.0622274093,
0.0278621688,
-0.0908826888,
-0.029368747,
0.0316119008,
-0.0157948211,
0.0517351441,
0.0225329157,
-0.0178401098,
-0.0510228649,
0.0020212762,
0.052897986,
-0.005931865,
-0.0231638625,
-0.0870857984,
-0.0135263903,
0.029682776,
-0.0088658631,
0.0377341323,
-0.0269177537,
-0.0445371158,
0.0229628384,
0.0159056224,
-0.0037038999,
2.616203186e-34,
0.0008417586,
0.0110447519,
0.0120657692,
-0.0039667124,
0.0106699057,
-0.0193080641,
0.0032832357,
-0.010767662,
-0.0054295459,
-0.056316074,
-0.0233693197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10922v1 | Spatial HuBERT: Self-supervised Spatial Speech Representation Learning for a Single Talker from Multi-channel Audio | 2023-10-17T01:31:59 | 2023-10-17T01:31:59 | Antoni Dimitriadis, Siqi Pan, Vidhyasaharan Sethu, Beena Ahmed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-supervised learning has been used to leverage unlabelled data, improving
accuracy and generalisation of speech systems through the training of
representation models. While many recent works have sought to produce effective
representations across a variety of acoustic domains, languages, modalities and
even simultaneous speakers, these studies have all been limited to
single-channel audio recordings. This paper presents Spatial HuBERT, a
self-supervised speech representation model that learns both acoustic and
spatial information pertaining to a single speaker in a potentially noisy
environment by using multi-channel audio inputs. Spatial HuBERT learns
representations that outperform state-of-the-art single-channel speech
representations on a variety of spatial downstream tasks, particularly in
reverberant and noisy environments. We also demonstrate the utility of the
representations learned by Spatial HuBERT on a speech localisation downstream
task. Along with this paper, we publicly release a new dataset of 100 000
simulated first-order ambisonics room impulse responses. | [
-0.0552862808,
0.0367507711,
0.0183102861,
0.0044844071,
-0.0099173198,
-0.0389077924,
0.0671210289,
-0.061545819,
-0.0176762734,
-0.0071510607,
-0.0929897428,
-0.0076065599,
0.0034639002,
-0.0006158456,
0.0269898511,
-0.0497055352,
0.0233695097,
-0.0319123603,
-0.0220773835,
-0.0707201734,
0.0053422246,
-0.0064413645,
-0.0564818792,
0.0398205593,
-0.0349800736,
-0.0147822956,
-0.0196885243,
0.0219613835,
-0.0242297389,
-0.0073761865,
-0.0080965692,
0.0366892144,
0.0974160731,
0.0161907542,
0.0000016922,
0.0334089361,
-0.0212214794,
-0.0024894539,
-0.0089141671,
-0.0049460805,
-0.027502073,
0.0260118712,
-0.0150234001,
0.0267230067,
-0.0056582512,
-0.0394554101,
0.0128118452,
0.0085439356,
0.0187644288,
0.008786479,
0.0063947057,
-0.0903631747,
-0.0400847532,
-0.0422048345,
0.023553079,
-0.01154467,
-0.0327418819,
-0.0350762233,
-0.00555686,
0.0138520254,
-0.0285671446,
0.0419927575,
0.0117525095,
-0.003570765,
0.055519525,
0.0056289402,
-0.0414183587,
0.0300935563,
-0.0174521599,
0.06810949,
0.0487805568,
-0.0268723238,
0.0154904211,
0.0502844453,
0.0171730649,
-0.0077420883,
-0.033929389,
-0.0030919816,
0.0412135571,
-0.0366731882,
-0.1083807424,
0.0721819252,
0.0016423169,
-0.0335542671,
-0.0314262398,
0.0471054316,
-0.0395428538,
-0.0033212085,
-0.0215069614,
-0.041725833,
0.0076066498,
0.0363546312,
0.0311842207,
0.0008053139,
-0.0101021957,
-0.0280841608,
-0.0100557785,
-0.0046265889,
-0.0042478563,
-0.0495981313,
-0.0439434163,
0.0314210095,
-0.0698980615,
0.0185571667,
0.0004170359,
0.0411600769,
-0.0259991288,
0.0517483577,
-0.0232552476,
0.0216602292,
-0.0405987464,
0.0212723929,
-0.0745449588,
0.0234918464,
-0.025727842,
-0.0116284089,
-0.0602840669,
-0.0180876404,
-0.0795518011,
0.0029547021,
-0.0034885283,
0.0656560659,
-0.0368297994,
-0.0258869361,
0.0377107859,
0.0435163267,
0.028992461,
0.0398888849,
-0.0069518588,
-0.0305733718,
-0.0435867086,
0.0252215173,
0.0736879408,
0.0206619166,
-0.0188031867,
0.0692190006,
0.0342119001,
-0.024039425,
0.0104490425,
0.0179659333,
-0.0514431819,
-0.0178445261,
0.000719943,
-0.0576197729,
0.0004301142,
0.0091849389,
0.0060243397,
-0.01393707,
-0.0083310399,
-0.0424259268,
0.0533110164,
0.0563571416,
0.0483068861,
0.0383369997,
0.1058420688,
-0.0169009287,
-0.0139055299,
-0.000510429,
0.0332022533,
-0.0002728785,
0.0025195344,
-0.0473367982,
0.0317203104,
0.0405559242,
0.0127540091,
-0.0142104104,
-0.0389831066,
0.0102219181,
0.0029836386,
0.0455360189,
0.062451221,
0.0015795658,
-0.013517959,
-0.0528299622,
0.0459407456,
0.0578952245,
0.0110122273,
-0.0053111259,
0.0491271652,
0.0435845256,
-0.0163757186,
-0.041559305,
-0.0211825222,
0.0244743563,
0.0085644899,
-0.0218505505,
0.0321641304,
-0.0333531275,
-0.0432452075,
-0.0007564745,
0.0336427242,
-0.0351862162,
-0.0126329316,
0.0236716084,
0.0372011475,
0.0139099071,
-0.0163201299,
0.0523569621,
-0.0158207193,
-0.0232542194,
-0.0063103274,
0.0036700983,
-0.0424290039,
0.0264117513,
-0.0289509483,
-0.0362013057,
-0.0038897449,
-0.068212688,
0.0060167434,
-0.0027584024,
0.0205383096,
0.0015243983,
0.0901996568,
-0.0149292098,
-0.0378066301,
-0.0125909159,
-0.0012572198,
0.0518308952,
-0.0231954902,
-0.0073828297,
-0.0055304039,
-0.0275721326,
0.0431433544,
-0.0119491294,
-0.0049889293,
-0.0484890305,
0.0036643802,
0.0155608347,
0.0337867104,
0.0031818233,
-0.0269261058,
-0.0001269739,
0.0272010006,
-0.0137062808,
-0.0047432831,
0.0440737046,
-0.071834147,
-0.0363055132,
0.0326802284,
-0.0149491904,
-0.0042549828,
0.0963860601,
0.0164283607,
-0.0396615453,
0.0688301027,
-0.028677512,
0.0336741954,
-0.0298599936,
0.0138420118,
0.0468080901,
0.0116808377,
0.0339435115,
-0.0044239815,
0.0050806673,
0.0191579219,
-0.0207274295,
0.0601561256,
0.0296532027,
-0.0349543504,
0.0051488099,
-0.0986628085,
-0.0230642874,
0.0481152907,
-0.036470782,
-0.023675276,
0.0145550082,
0.0283639561,
-0.0277274996,
0.0109691015,
-0.0258633234,
-0.0432981662,
-0.0044061434,
-0.0498840883,
0.0059005287,
-0.0581571534,
-0.0305636581,
-0.0418828316,
0.0079742912,
0.0026368394,
-0.0623985678,
-0.0379175358,
-0.0143727567,
-0.0165743139,
0.0189872049,
0.0311801471,
-0.0165011231,
-0.0438171625,
-0.0205023345,
0.0313827917,
-0.0342290774,
0.0215284284,
0.0524751842,
0.0122501422,
-0.0190898739,
-0.0012861222,
-0.0259932335,
0.0131467339,
-0.002420424,
0.0020446545,
-0.0094365003,
0.0010329155,
-0.0151978973,
-0.0438239016,
0.0147004668,
-0.0056342664,
0.0570531115,
-0.0057749297,
0.0442442112,
-0.0483912006,
-0.0202401131,
0.0615135916,
0.0240103267,
-0.0064398777,
-0.0303964894,
0.0115262279,
-0.0622543618,
-0.0596231967,
-0.0038279453,
-0.027753938,
-0.0188607499,
-0.0294962451,
-0.0448314957,
-0.0276929103,
-0.04402785,
-0.0434126221,
-0.0020021293,
-0.041114904,
0.0228487384,
0.0175780039,
-0.0234177709,
0.0485820547,
-0.066312395,
-0.0435806476,
-0.0052246535,
-0.0302107017,
0.0235306751,
-0.039233841,
0.0271624867,
-0.0024758345,
-0.0048790048,
0.0055512381,
-0.0468647778,
-0.0285037477,
-0.0536552705,
0.0089520384,
-0.0105696786,
-0.019932691,
-0.0137517918,
-0.0276379678,
0.0471817702,
0.045250006,
0.0772940665,
-0.0127077214,
0.0075770994,
-0.0193192195,
0.0280579422,
0.0221793186,
0.1066015959,
-0.009943801,
0.0270641521,
-0.0097217169,
0.0079675531,
0.0364531502,
-0.0059662159,
-0.090333879,
0.0310264807,
0.0217406582,
0.0160990302,
-0.0392296016,
0.0267972406,
0.0756318048,
-0.0336981043,
-0.0126336003,
0.074919425,
0.0332336202,
-0.0368021019,
-0.0044989157,
-0.0397744067,
-0.0225016791,
0.0455218144,
-0.0402756147,
-0.0022579315,
-0.0118616931,
0.020909356,
-0.0070248917,
0.0459166951,
0.0332074128,
0.017867893,
-0.0456952341,
0.057839632,
0.0317042656,
-0.0799075589,
-0.0761543065,
-0.0191957783,
-0.0404115245,
-0.0210456047,
0.0486127846,
0.0103827221,
-0.0237244833,
-0.0231098067,
0.0375660062,
-0.0685518831,
0.0230896547,
-0.0087035764,
-0.0358241387,
0.0843275264,
0.017205283,
0.0211474821,
-0.0157311149,
-0.0054606441,
-0.0365341119,
0.0194566455,
0.0213324223,
-0.0096404171,
0.0415610075,
0.0322373025,
0.0134799629,
0.0144163417,
0.0332562439,
-0.0321640186,
-0.0048908629,
0.025790615,
0.0350877717,
-0.0591780059,
0.0978673175,
-0.0325988829,
0.0776716918,
0.0296893045,
0.0398402475,
0.0103042852,
0.0195708796,
-0.0449701212,
-0.0030487245,
0.0562961437,
0.0155401761,
-0.016200671,
0.0038388744,
0.005109637,
-0.0338238552,
-0.0146249253,
0.0024370451,
0.0099411029,
0.0485488474,
0.0000838098,
0.0010906602,
-0.0512538813,
0.0053646197,
-0.0228773672,
0.0379212387,
-0.0058596306,
0.0234007929,
0.0133273099,
-0.0196681824,
0.0874892473,
-0.0356775969,
0.009441724,
0.0548120327,
-0.0063947989,
-0.0332253017,
0.023455957,
0.0352722928,
0.0173837785,
0.0505612977,
-0.0171208996,
0.0346798263,
0.1025697142,
-0.026870558,
-0.0770199075,
0.0418282747,
0.1235332042,
0.0541848876,
-0.0124666002,
0.0270552915,
-0.0503124855,
0.0653480515,
-0.0404759198,
-0.0040677711,
-0.0350848921,
-0.0267571267,
-0.001418888,
-0.0554297008,
0.0882611498,
0.0198091641,
0.0464497916,
-0.0115295062,
0.0402352437,
-0.06486734,
0.0472372584,
-0.0413524322,
0.0194092877,
0.0356158093,
-0.0051461183,
-0.0239561964,
-0.028633967,
-0.0187114328,
0.0035509148,
0.0006980894,
-0.0073578213,
0.0225185268,
-0.0385892019,
-0.0196300708,
0.0414794199,
0.016901914,
0.0378009565,
0.051810082,
-0.0185036212,
0.0099806432,
0.0128213177,
-0.0141297998,
0.0227652434,
-0.0384968035,
0.0111183999,
-0.0639651045,
-0.028058771,
0.0007461414,
-0.0095485616,
0.0356288292,
0.004523512,
0.0048887273,
0.0368405692,
0.0143389506,
-0.0099893901,
0.0281543229,
-0.0362859443,
-0.0034735929,
-0.0001787152,
-0.0164747108,
-0.0377467908,
0.0088515496,
0.0566173866,
-0.0065932488,
0.0023190528,
-0.0343790166,
0.0434698313,
-0.0589395165,
-0.0458924212,
0.0161209237,
0.0426240042,
0.002499653,
-0.0230263919,
0.0123555399,
-0.0544704907,
0.0184928626,
-0.0076828599,
-0.0279025063,
-0.0324763581,
0.0462468006,
-0.0154332314,
0.0017334428,
-0.0006333353,
-0.003839002,
-0.0384040475,
0.0243295282,
-0.0017031366,
0.0413785838,
-4.875120374e-33,
-0.0339356437,
0.003118665,
0.0043323394,
0.0026887576,
0.017387975,
-0.0141587257,
-0.0134063018,
0.0374109671,
0.024652293,
-0.0061791898,
-0.0042359033,
0.0323833525,
0.0230624564,
-0.0050082756,
0.0308157951,
-0.0099330908,
0.0818790346,
-0.0224528145,
0.019617578,
0.0099959066,
0.0717748031,
0.0235489383,
0.018903248,
-0.0449510925,
-0.0722165555,
-0.0323675126,
-0.0361737423,
-0.0136426724,
-0.0143102854,
-0.0093151089,
-0.0024932323,
0.0365391001,
-0.0544085316,
-0.0360982232,
-0.0187362153,
0.0042507844,
-0.0900265276,
-0.0139768841,
-0.0773399249,
0.0438540503,
-0.0260708611,
0.0184862893,
0.0648585707,
0.0180132668,
-0.0167630129,
0.0036519761,
0.035630744,
-0.0134993782,
-0.0444878079,
0.0146126254,
0.0050183432,
0.0087764226,
-0.0230248403,
-0.041244898,
0.0324717537,
0.0635823905,
0.020376971,
-0.0499673896,
-0.0937415883,
0.0266730879,
-0.0281291716,
0.0238555297,
0.0230989903,
-0.0009510584,
0.0279019382,
0.0631995797,
0.1163821593,
-0.0572201684,
0.0505664647,
-0.0486783907,
0.0402554721,
0.0370769762,
0.0089124544,
0.0109242992,
-0.0006720537,
-0.019215893,
-0.0404264182,
0.0340666994,
-0.0128166704,
-0.0071194177,
0.0160375815,
0.0378255658,
-0.0119971465,
0.0230293851,
-0.0204445105,
-0.0293334592,
0.017021006,
-0.0204603504,
0.0454674922,
-0.0043061106,
0.0353882276,
-0.0045196372,
0.0810238495,
-0.0311145429,
-0.0134811383,
-0.0043114838,
-0.0072315978,
-0.0107096247,
-0.001056102,
0.0545444749,
-0.0231002551,
-0.0097779231,
0.038761124,
0.0381903425,
0.0218774639,
-0.0023518177,
-0.0005460873,
0.0979686379,
-0.0563796647,
-0.0208370127,
0.0066232686,
-0.0097952001,
-0.0033518721,
0.0142327314,
0.0459441356,
-0.0169118885,
0.0051134215,
0.0452998802,
-0.0419135243,
0.0230268035,
0.0078096967,
-0.0225616153,
-0.0157682449,
0.0188733321,
-0.0310426261,
-0.0358804427,
-0.0403009951,
-0.0396793038,
0.0551722981,
-0.0577607416,
-0.0127664655,
-0.0413174964,
2.484e-7,
-0.0479207411,
-0.0167428479,
0.0153756356,
-0.0365486667,
0.0162956249,
0.0099122459,
-0.0255604722,
0.0333917849,
-0.0279653911,
-0.0247651339,
0.0373179577,
0.0295871776,
0.053579431,
0.0283798128,
-0.0877771974,
0.0419263616,
-0.0723826364,
0.0512569435,
0.0083913971,
0.0306644496,
0.005195362,
0.061579451,
0.0126318596,
-0.0264541786,
0.0272837337,
-0.0003756601,
0.0371331461,
0.0048581916,
0.0118488939,
-0.0142926928,
0.0379836522,
-0.0089793,
-0.0374001935,
-0.0354274213,
-0.0344986431,
0.0294928867,
0.0044647576,
0.046892032,
-0.0362341292,
-0.09301126,
0.0170059204,
0.056611754,
-0.0246970188,
0.0173517521,
0.0507537127,
-0.0654755756,
0.0011429195,
-0.0081239566,
-0.0436540768,
0.0052363821,
0.0038285716,
0.0352867469,
0.0194043834,
-0.0406819172,
-0.0194489248,
-0.0200463124,
-0.0186822452,
-0.0750020519,
-0.0022647982,
0.0120325657,
-0.0618022941,
0.0175396483,
0.0059910673,
-0.0145590352,
0.0067381458,
0.0057522422,
-0.0199695751,
1.368715776e-34,
0.0022058324,
-0.0143612679,
0.0167723335,
0.0009351157,
-0.0503167138,
-0.0536280908,
-0.0250081755,
0.0122071076,
0.0437383652,
0.0386196524,
-0.0232927036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13011v2 | Compositional preference models for aligning LMs | 2023-10-17T01:31:59 | 2024-03-14T18:07:10 | Dongyoung Go, Tomasz Korbak, Germán Kruszewski, Jos Rozen, Marc Dymetman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As language models (LMs) become more capable, it is increasingly important to
align them with human preferences. However, the dominant paradigm for training
Preference Models (PMs) for that purpose suffers from fundamental limitations,
such as lack of transparency and scalability, along with susceptibility to
overfitting the preference dataset. We propose Compositional Preference Models
(CPMs), a novel PM framework that decomposes one global preference assessment
into several interpretable features, obtains scalar scores for these features
from a prompted LM, and aggregates these scores using a logistic regression
classifier. Through these simple steps, CPMs allow to control which properties
of the preference data are used to train the preference model and to build it
based on features that are believed to underlie the human preference judgment.
Our experiments show that CPMs not only improve generalization and are more
robust to overoptimization than standard PMs, but also that best-of-n samples
obtained using CPMs tend to be preferred over samples obtained using
conventional PMs. Overall, our approach demonstrates the benefits of endowing
PMs with priors about which features determine human preferences while relying
on LM capabilities to extract those features in a scalable and robust way. | [
0.0392633751,
0.0688001812,
0.0026099752,
0.0053582555,
-0.0234764367,
0.0332133844,
-0.0307336226,
-0.0469615087,
-0.0288326386,
-0.0374664441,
-0.0393324234,
-0.0680918545,
-0.0045072995,
0.0200667996,
-0.0105789062,
-0.0659468472,
0.020075107,
0.0039423909,
-0.0017035579,
-0.0233778469,
0.0258394293,
0.0478115045,
0.0178189687,
0.0349906608,
0.0494705588,
0.0051050521,
-0.0032828564,
-0.025704693,
0.0156233395,
0.0167128127,
0.0227609798,
0.0571174249,
0.0304257441,
-0.0549794845,
0.000002283,
-0.0580956154,
-0.0091661941,
-0.0325095318,
0.0099303275,
-0.0044910931,
0.0654605925,
0.0426930971,
-0.0000843505,
0.0148229143,
-0.0391530395,
0.0003492969,
0.0410593599,
0.0217892099,
0.0081225531,
0.0352479219,
-0.0039004406,
-0.0400113687,
-0.0425182655,
-0.0196428541,
-0.000034757,
0.0038563118,
0.0065869014,
-0.0668441802,
-0.0117524294,
0.0063303551,
-0.0006670486,
-0.0140545145,
-0.0114320386,
0.0297157131,
0.0350468904,
0.0155821294,
-0.0005030133,
-0.009516309,
0.008577764,
0.0813307315,
-0.0060366336,
-0.0344589129,
-0.0085968366,
-0.0354889445,
-0.009662997,
-0.0275138672,
-0.0113103753,
-0.0033724979,
0.0027796063,
0.0650668517,
0.0150827589,
0.0027612462,
0.0276765116,
0.0390783325,
-0.0241710804,
0.0743546039,
-0.0064800042,
0.0038076893,
0.0426623523,
0.0095133828,
-0.0012432896,
-0.0416883789,
0.0242685899,
-0.0095773013,
-0.0301360451,
0.0319350287,
-0.0306121316,
0.0406962708,
0.0116356751,
-0.0712702945,
0.0440806746,
0.0468357578,
-0.0066157714,
0.0359377936,
0.0259219687,
0.0630678162,
0.0069646412,
0.0071516461,
-0.0719840527,
0.0077988692,
-0.0260853432,
0.0024461797,
0.0473061576,
0.0457811654,
0.0064702304,
0.0164212603,
-0.0631861314,
0.0217331704,
-0.0088831289,
0.0169525892,
0.0349835828,
0.0741455108,
-0.0099191125,
-0.0082824109,
-0.0572223254,
0.0690245405,
0.0084524117,
0.01601886,
0.0036474604,
-0.005978426,
0.0653505698,
0.0071638073,
-0.016963236,
-0.0270717312,
0.019926466,
0.0443718247,
0.0006068422,
-0.022657698,
-0.0041669835,
0.0064637437,
-0.0470755249,
-0.0487419777,
-0.0177263655,
-0.0757315159,
0.0409155488,
0.0208446961,
0.0029806443,
-0.0431237482,
-0.0017639792,
0.0165015198,
-0.0488708466,
0.0576138608,
0.0334792733,
-0.0035369662,
-0.0168955252,
-0.0139412787,
0.0017493343,
0.0501138046,
0.026851058,
0.0671667606,
0.0396456979,
-0.0192655213,
-0.0271270443,
0.0048916531,
-0.0422686934,
-0.0036368093,
-0.0458634906,
0.0098044379,
-0.0382060371,
-0.0199380834,
0.0622450858,
0.0616095997,
0.0152877392,
-0.0411059894,
0.1083422825,
0.0231255069,
0.0299957823,
-0.0089971395,
0.0256270152,
0.060838107,
-0.0237638783,
0.0198580548,
-0.0150985336,
0.0243563447,
-0.0341737755,
-0.0026907392,
0.0400003344,
0.029793147,
-0.0191804823,
-0.0650112182,
0.0041928012,
-0.0307010058,
0.0441196784,
0.0506186187,
0.0584465712,
-0.0410287715,
-0.022949582,
-0.0122555448,
0.051259093,
-0.074425444,
0.0349820368,
-0.0155564426,
0.0615100525,
0.1364924908,
0.0249102432,
0.0031348537,
0.0121709509,
-0.0152147617,
-0.0354145952,
0.0090331705,
0.0587365516,
-0.0289388169,
0.0210084822,
-0.0682474449,
-0.0202121884,
0.0146612441,
0.0055316295,
0.0443855971,
-0.0003152705,
-0.0348770693,
-0.0038997307,
-0.023667004,
-0.0122995302,
0.001798723,
0.0101171741,
-0.0205788016,
0.0417498313,
0.0170660559,
0.0425768569,
0.0259830169,
0.0245945677,
0.0074340338,
0.0100556854,
0.007727562,
-0.0190728363,
0.035717994,
-0.0563163757,
-0.0045448453,
0.0266665146,
-0.0177410264,
-0.0007916575,
0.0303879157,
-0.0299696326,
-0.0222211778,
-0.0237732194,
-0.0162234008,
0.0444613285,
-0.044410672,
0.0117643308,
-0.02238678,
-0.0382230021,
-0.0529511459,
0.042268876,
-0.0282557085,
0.0097503569,
-0.0047605145,
-0.0526937991,
0.0046371804,
-0.0533699803,
-0.0633805916,
0.0259194802,
0.0038821844,
0.0323169604,
0.0138266766,
-0.007703302,
-0.0248459056,
0.0022840435,
-0.0798170269,
-0.0146222003,
0.0088017713,
-0.0069477628,
0.0015596928,
-0.0092201056,
0.0015412509,
0.0077823689,
-0.037634965,
-0.029181838,
-0.0332755484,
0.0279482622,
-0.003048002,
-0.0031020904,
0.0265094135,
-0.0679348037,
0.005708545,
-0.0203144327,
0.0124172475,
-0.0390391499,
0.0343046114,
-0.0128537044,
0.0165877901,
-0.0242943969,
-0.0113335066,
-0.0208193623,
-0.0269849785,
-0.0024846548,
-0.0302928463,
0.033708781,
0.0572565421,
0.0375246368,
0.0194382872,
0.1031068787,
0.0104894796,
-0.0825639367,
-0.0122475158,
-0.0681188479,
0.0119453873,
-0.0259343442,
-0.0383156836,
0.0099835536,
0.0675800517,
0.0194177777,
-0.010654333,
-0.0624193512,
0.0196498577,
-0.0142479306,
-0.0093198167,
-0.0388376713,
0.0074648331,
-0.0300207604,
0.059107516,
-0.0029765242,
-0.055799216,
0.1031125709,
-0.0088248523,
0.024736505,
-0.0485891029,
-0.0303870235,
-0.0305934064,
-0.0011883181,
-0.0085659251,
0.0013475538,
0.0088986326,
0.0153798591,
-0.06051163,
-0.0271922536,
0.0325822718,
-0.0571338497,
0.0466420166,
-0.0668280199,
-0.0161953233,
0.0224666204,
-0.0550545789,
-0.040902663,
-0.0350356586,
-0.0265098661,
-0.0041792374,
0.0432019569,
-0.0066511487,
-0.001486409,
-0.0215060487,
-0.0083261337,
-0.0217684936,
0.0187967215,
0.0032412249,
0.0226351805,
0.0025462809,
0.0629620254,
0.0184447188,
-0.0162142161,
-0.0151566714,
-0.0206552688,
0.033640638,
0.0272486247,
0.0063180029,
-0.0224848613,
0.0103190131,
0.0560206957,
-0.0082568359,
-0.0254437644,
0.0250987094,
0.0128784208,
-0.0108057996,
0.0371988043,
0.1086029634,
0.035599418,
-0.0917735323,
-0.0023822666,
0.0060884263,
0.0269001201,
0.0226350557,
0.0356708877,
-0.0405203141,
-0.0129582491,
0.0079123769,
0.0349649079,
-0.0105829136,
0.0102798771,
-0.0124753481,
-0.1113584787,
-0.0059846663,
0.0097220326,
-0.0455498248,
0.0237198304,
-0.0408367179,
0.0077034063,
-0.0712681264,
0.0041609206,
-0.0063543511,
-0.0013169243,
-0.0014488929,
0.0150954612,
-0.0522630699,
-0.0469944291,
0.0414073057,
-0.0301115811,
0.0157306828,
0.0839931071,
0.0154086994,
0.0146300616,
-0.0324333347,
-0.001747278,
0.0072292457,
-0.0095203863,
-0.0252187736,
0.0177838504,
-0.0476460941,
0.0030527578,
-0.0460979529,
0.0465669259,
-0.0145085566,
-0.0109394109,
-0.0180255547,
0.0446946621,
0.0016539909,
-0.0198759902,
-0.0194245614,
0.0224005282,
0.0134744626,
0.0742077678,
0.0238615498,
-0.1244172379,
0.0019744262,
-0.0564780906,
-0.0531921983,
-0.0539849214,
-0.0172713343,
0.0051116198,
0.0206144433,
-0.0260977112,
-0.0582337864,
-0.0269360449,
0.0163590237,
-0.0178631097,
0.0057755499,
-0.0044288421,
0.017860109,
-0.0228164066,
-0.0519607626,
0.0318837911,
-0.0024451271,
0.0206300449,
-0.0692690611,
-0.0169229768,
0.0537394993,
-0.0532959625,
-0.0214354098,
-0.0254580826,
-0.0197459832,
-0.0847646073,
-0.0201418363,
0.0789949,
0.0170199908,
0.0108093852,
0.0005978487,
-0.0808998644,
0.0142799728,
0.0395383202,
0.0040808707,
0.0020037212,
0.0270891692,
0.0317118615,
0.008129579,
0.014848832,
-0.0265857037,
0.0193358958,
0.0078875963,
0.0047728443,
-0.0124975229,
-0.0176456552,
0.0519047603,
-0.0443402641,
0.0094699301,
-0.0193073116,
0.0093004694,
-0.041577071,
-0.0108792959,
0.0076001519,
-0.0391768292,
-0.0344630256,
-0.058641836,
0.0515982509,
-0.0007949082,
-0.0374286659,
-0.0447632447,
-0.0551406816,
0.0334908217,
-0.0022570295,
0.0351288877,
0.0306454822,
-0.0143381609,
0.0462337174,
0.0195860993,
-0.0151845524,
-0.0077836197,
-0.0164326522,
0.0349895731,
0.0269379728,
0.0429909937,
-0.0158816706,
-0.0108355954,
-0.0116784275,
0.0193883572,
-0.0005438081,
-0.0257535204,
-0.0544270352,
-0.0408284552,
0.0313680917,
-0.0652986541,
0.0438122973,
-0.0109630264,
0.0029150045,
-0.0492562391,
0.0534247309,
-0.0303068031,
-0.0271097831,
0.0491206683,
0.0315312482,
-0.0220772848,
0.0043965182,
0.0867982358,
0.0177448057,
-0.0165759567,
-0.0203839503,
-0.0141630275,
-0.0457175225,
-0.0015920207,
-0.0065763481,
0.091805473,
-0.0442215502,
-0.0262538306,
-0.0423857272,
-0.0665378794,
0.0049175443,
0.0041420814,
0.0246150531,
-0.0113268038,
0.043814607,
0.0550190657,
-0.0434429906,
0.0193204489,
-0.0548150726,
-0.0224612914,
-0.0340829156,
-0.003110541,
-0.0391023904,
-6.706436248e-33,
-0.0079751061,
-0.0333383866,
0.0066009881,
0.0081363022,
0.012011094,
-0.0442928597,
0.0220729895,
0.0364025421,
-0.0011700751,
-0.0147885196,
-0.0033840816,
-0.0293204524,
0.0117011424,
0.0141414488,
0.0342123695,
-0.0096496213,
0.047611203,
0.0126612922,
-0.0320393965,
-0.0202438124,
0.0581055097,
0.0216522794,
0.0597355105,
-0.0713724494,
0.0238217898,
0.0458385572,
-0.0099487463,
-0.0014862674,
-0.0235034302,
0.0842239112,
-0.0076220413,
0.0553653315,
0.0265297126,
-0.0165889654,
-0.0093926927,
0.0373343118,
-0.0258462019,
0.0049697096,
0.0661468059,
0.0160748791,
0.0320949815,
-0.0319788791,
0.0257235672,
0.0020628767,
-0.0220629629,
-0.0025257845,
0.0464088321,
-0.0402395651,
-0.0286802389,
-0.0014418412,
-0.0188489109,
0.0135717485,
-0.0028722917,
0.0000831817,
0.0124199996,
0.0713254064,
-0.0391274765,
0.0738561302,
-0.0406511053,
0.085211657,
-0.0067854822,
0.0050329994,
0.0665278137,
-0.0047683665,
-0.0019495634,
0.065951176,
0.0406098068,
-0.0300089289,
-0.0089025525,
-0.0048856046,
0.0164518859,
0.0455902144,
0.0337832384,
0.023686314,
0.0259155612,
-0.0328537337,
0.0049279518,
0.0526652336,
0.0235077702,
-0.0358458906,
0.0619063899,
0.0625716746,
-0.0436411761,
-0.0574616864,
-0.0448018909,
-0.0381624028,
-0.0626638383,
-0.0504353642,
0.0337603651,
0.0143804783,
-0.0467724986,
-0.0149276303,
0.0201511495,
-0.0498796515,
-0.0268970672,
0.0125315785,
-0.0395220853,
0.0276785474,
0.0179165937,
-0.0315826088,
-0.0771095231,
0.0245955549,
-0.0010253761,
-0.013417054,
-0.0407187566,
0.0094664544,
0.0202464685,
0.0128786955,
-0.0288510621,
-0.0084676137,
-0.0102272369,
-0.0472278297,
-0.0117758429,
0.0555756241,
0.0492113493,
0.0246626213,
-0.0252128057,
0.0603496395,
-0.0362035967,
-0.012684186,
-0.0516669452,
-0.0698332265,
0.0001239447,
0.0417805389,
-0.0008880756,
-0.0046093101,
0.0078037432,
-0.0331408083,
0.0457789041,
0.02969083,
-0.011428982,
0.0021169141,
2.793e-7,
0.0449354388,
0.0458863676,
-0.0210839119,
-0.0058480208,
-0.0270609055,
0.0467284583,
0.0096440855,
-0.0068494291,
0.0408359133,
0.0089748763,
0.0243285522,
0.0098817348,
0.0633230805,
0.0156923048,
-0.1059115455,
0.012270445,
-0.017643515,
-0.0159581713,
-0.0273457244,
-0.0140323481,
0.0461408794,
0.0663859546,
0.049059514,
-0.0084673306,
-0.000495103,
0.0604532473,
0.0665306672,
-0.1037630215,
-0.0044880137,
-0.0142578939,
-0.0035785628,
0.0036206003,
-0.0420972556,
-0.0228960123,
-0.025877608,
0.0047069769,
-0.0068102391,
0.0830019489,
0.0128212981,
-0.0849459469,
0.0000069873,
0.0219909083,
-0.0048377304,
-0.0624367036,
0.0541191399,
-0.0478728339,
-0.0172135103,
-0.044975128,
-0.0106019704,
0.0072263652,
0.0127792219,
-0.0265540853,
-0.0175032336,
-0.0131189162,
0.0056086513,
-0.0073197726,
-0.0274932031,
-0.0696856827,
-0.008826402,
0.034217041,
-0.0499738492,
-0.0203275047,
-0.028911246,
0.0584112331,
0.002137349,
-0.0208950657,
0.0142254075,
2.122658337e-34,
0.0399384461,
0.0209729411,
0.0249684285,
-0.011367063,
0.0323204733,
0.033225812,
0.0047171726,
0.0159716271,
0.046351321,
-0.0830238536,
-0.0175238792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10920v1 | NuclearQA: A Human-Made Benchmark for Language Models for the Nuclear Domain | 2023-10-17T01:27:20 | 2023-10-17T01:27:20 | Anurag Acharya, Sai Munikoti, Aaron Hellinger, Sara Smith, Sridevi Wagle, Sameera Horawalavithana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | As LLMs have become increasingly popular, they have been used in almost every
field. But as the application for LLMs expands from generic fields to narrow,
focused science domains, there exists an ever-increasing gap in ways to
evaluate their efficacy in those fields. For the benchmarks that do exist, a
lot of them focus on questions that don't require proper understanding of the
subject in question. In this paper, we present NuclearQA, a human-made
benchmark of 100 questions to evaluate language models in the nuclear domain,
consisting of a varying collection of questions that have been specifically
designed by experts to test the abilities of language models. We detail our
approach and show how the mix of several types of questions makes our benchmark
uniquely capable of evaluating models in the nuclear domain. We also present
our own evaluation metric for assessing LLM's performances due to the
limitations of existing ones. Our experiments on state-of-the-art models
suggest that even the best LLMs perform less than satisfactorily on our
benchmark, demonstrating the scientific knowledge gap of existing LLMs. | [
0.0349137597,
0.0668628439,
-0.0061677396,
0.0419406928,
-0.0482722335,
0.0056916615,
0.0272531845,
0.0468179919,
0.0057390202,
-0.0093811443,
-0.0235489253,
-0.0468160063,
-0.0268261451,
0.0316302478,
0.0372528695,
-0.0065581761,
0.0376986861,
-0.0452833176,
0.0060365796,
-0.0099360533,
-0.0132941548,
-0.0272912364,
0.0043270015,
0.0234240498,
0.0080753984,
0.0018964947,
0.0158650931,
0.0096520334,
-0.0102053452,
-0.0501571596,
-0.019901745,
0.0427688584,
0.0058101304,
0.0350689478,
0.0000018735,
-0.0427465253,
-0.0142920725,
0.0312574655,
-0.0096938331,
0.0407711267,
0.0760977566,
-0.0075126844,
-0.0253818855,
0.0105864126,
-0.0072751786,
0.0404136069,
0.0669559315,
-0.0195437223,
0.0158335976,
0.0577363372,
0.0015766849,
-0.0201803595,
0.0434553511,
-0.0155853415,
-0.0042643663,
-0.0208938699,
0.0487487763,
0.0383230783,
0.0393008031,
0.0051135072,
-0.0085546104,
0.059899915,
0.0393411778,
0.003828601,
-0.0350302607,
0.0370124057,
-0.0199046005,
-0.0021080882,
-0.0064171124,
0.0700969771,
-0.0045833662,
-0.0356006734,
0.0158046596,
-0.0058961902,
-0.0487098321,
-0.0061460668,
-0.0512042493,
0.0095698806,
0.0183300897,
0.0107246824,
0.0186137296,
0.0096600642,
0.0426520966,
0.0148913031,
-0.0043716198,
0.1173969582,
0.0657357574,
-0.0295373686,
-0.0235258825,
-0.0018047529,
0.0027876035,
-0.0552208982,
0.0280321334,
0.0214709416,
0.0016270316,
0.0407581739,
-0.0191446748,
0.002071826,
0.0773709342,
-0.0285809189,
0.0435169116,
0.0290243942,
-0.0082547646,
0.0548667423,
-0.0042298553,
0.050775405,
-0.0157286804,
0.0031732321,
-0.0275584906,
0.0155331679,
-0.0521240383,
-0.0011693268,
0.0060911127,
-0.0000537417,
-0.0035125937,
-0.0067338627,
-0.0124861524,
-0.0076064728,
0.0372474566,
0.0105576431,
0.0161735117,
-0.0208920036,
-0.037907403,
-0.001828787,
-0.0237088446,
0.0449514985,
-0.0432259142,
0.0075487029,
0.0028315904,
-0.094663702,
-0.0095974552,
0.0136368135,
-0.0479005575,
-0.0124326199,
0.0103718797,
0.0867892355,
0.0281566624,
-0.0342760719,
0.0125144655,
0.0193938706,
-0.0406083427,
-0.0689146072,
0.0261101332,
-0.0746352673,
0.0212514549,
0.0206233058,
-0.008313057,
-0.0520847142,
0.0315183923,
-0.0183087885,
-0.0011349927,
0.0663216338,
0.0002829276,
0.0014239569,
0.0281692911,
0.0306897108,
0.021706583,
0.0556012802,
0.0274655465,
-0.0237894505,
0.0247913692,
-0.0139923478,
0.000018239,
0.0367462225,
-0.0096028568,
0.0396015085,
-0.0495167971,
0.0151928915,
-0.025063239,
0.0537031442,
-0.0027565528,
0.0853061154,
0.0018902019,
-0.047380928,
0.0391263403,
0.0837116241,
-0.0125601143,
0.0453013889,
0.0309979785,
-0.0127730872,
0.0186396483,
0.0211012326,
-0.0231415313,
0.0350975171,
-0.0540819131,
0.0265877265,
-0.002883709,
0.0114308763,
-0.0118662398,
-0.0617841408,
-0.05909428,
0.000758371,
0.0167736467,
-0.011248379,
0.0469745509,
-0.0130053163,
-0.0391199999,
0.0409377106,
0.0332998298,
-0.0716017857,
-0.0016861503,
-0.0591093488,
0.0445666164,
0.0402715541,
0.0536042713,
-0.0482822396,
-0.0451183692,
0.0190159287,
-0.0104418676,
0.0828626826,
0.0809428543,
0.0249982029,
-0.0219571721,
-0.0333839357,
-0.0197755303,
-0.0225964971,
0.0335317999,
0.0113852425,
0.0010668264,
-0.0104084816,
0.0044160048,
-0.0492185242,
-0.0274881423,
0.0512562841,
-0.0942653343,
0.0008414431,
-0.050445985,
-0.04554414,
0.019093141,
-0.0172885973,
-0.0294297244,
0.0566463545,
0.0519541577,
-0.0439795963,
-0.0177816749,
-0.0528072789,
-0.0042845109,
-0.0135750482,
0.0598376542,
-0.0522565097,
-0.0057369401,
0.0198619366,
-0.0211428534,
-0.0308756884,
0.0382056274,
-0.0291071013,
0.0131175313,
-0.0359210446,
0.023309445,
-0.0308510642,
0.0127238994,
-0.0393096842,
0.0681640059,
-0.0358389765,
0.0766773894,
0.032701429,
-0.026646886,
0.033552628,
-0.0413848944,
-0.0352463275,
0.0115111796,
-0.0035296946,
0.0054179286,
0.0206149798,
0.0202467833,
-0.0539777614,
-0.0570359044,
-0.0650199279,
-0.0050416901,
-0.0118884128,
0.0148153007,
0.0213616099,
-0.0200891253,
-0.0277573615,
0.0259470847,
-0.040271841,
-0.0263538621,
-0.0099016903,
0.0007250832,
0.0516954511,
-0.0027862848,
-0.0415202156,
-0.077180244,
-0.0457066447,
-0.0523194335,
0.0453842878,
-0.0198956765,
0.0359061323,
-0.0330749005,
0.0414860882,
-0.0414721705,
0.0112847295,
-0.002776898,
-0.0590340532,
0.055215966,
-0.039386671,
0.0314536355,
0.0203530509,
0.0013469992,
0.008480492,
0.0779835358,
-0.0250589345,
-0.0516643561,
-0.0144381998,
-0.01839393,
-0.0042965226,
-0.0307747256,
-0.0396290869,
0.0054322579,
0.0845864639,
-0.0195116363,
-0.0092199789,
-0.026791526,
0.0430704765,
-0.0608388707,
-0.0199889876,
0.0013688639,
0.0096733253,
-0.0250321105,
0.0425987802,
-0.0096954228,
-0.0279461965,
0.0795462579,
-0.0556510128,
0.0071024601,
-0.0585490204,
-0.0056305388,
-0.0467333607,
0.0457092971,
-0.0005685031,
0.0061926302,
0.0305234678,
0.0071795797,
-0.0485581532,
-0.0132996896,
-0.0231029,
-0.0477638654,
0.0382707864,
-0.0475913137,
0.0247553084,
0.0120756682,
-0.0091586569,
-0.027143836,
0.0067025819,
-0.0322638303,
0.0429083072,
0.0202433802,
-0.0356257558,
-0.0330299623,
0.0269869957,
0.0051940084,
0.0087417085,
-0.0075494498,
-0.0046928865,
-0.0201173052,
0.0330000445,
0.0611596778,
-0.022049021,
0.0628196821,
-0.0350351669,
0.0388018005,
0.0337734371,
0.0302874278,
0.0383309685,
-0.0386328064,
0.0186058115,
0.0458785072,
-0.0339813232,
-0.000406043,
0.0313479938,
0.0665011853,
-0.0576716699,
-0.0319972746,
0.1156542525,
0.0402646437,
0.0060319616,
0.0225214809,
-0.02508571,
0.0114288051,
0.0438596867,
0.0298275054,
-0.0579674579,
-0.0201898757,
-0.0112951724,
-0.0161819421,
-0.0050698444,
-0.0203760248,
-0.0122996764,
-0.0851118118,
0.0136094494,
0.0154379206,
-0.0407454111,
-0.0088780597,
-0.0437701046,
-0.0051967809,
0.0113483081,
0.0289143268,
0.0278713722,
-0.0021849109,
-0.0254371315,
0.0213624146,
-0.0210841745,
-0.0755944476,
0.0432374291,
-0.0315543786,
0.060344059,
0.0692202449,
0.0485900156,
-0.0244790409,
-0.0598576739,
0.04918487,
-0.0121005699,
-0.0047072638,
0.0031355962,
-0.0152341528,
0.0671809167,
-0.0175415315,
-0.0152586605,
0.0150203612,
-0.0518037267,
0.002602837,
-0.0119613521,
0.0646222159,
-0.0068999138,
-0.0595299937,
-0.0298069492,
0.006686043,
-0.0152645269,
0.0969489664,
0.0546950549,
-0.0185771342,
-0.0586878024,
-0.0430551991,
0.0190452933,
-0.0184090845,
-0.0656229481,
0.007024934,
0.0180198383,
-0.0069102156,
-0.0743415356,
0.0192521196,
0.0187675525,
-0.010642468,
0.0029313422,
-0.0052967798,
-0.0011166037,
-0.0314442664,
0.0104450407,
0.0264489558,
-0.0345201306,
0.0281233992,
-0.0751894787,
-0.0053305505,
0.0500749499,
0.0206119288,
-0.03291234,
0.0527888834,
-0.0867935866,
-0.0735981166,
-0.0231944099,
0.0518231243,
0.0292473622,
-0.0473356284,
-0.0134395286,
-0.0642844513,
0.0125389928,
-0.0034022983,
-0.0115063712,
-0.0031183045,
-0.0050213444,
-0.0198871903,
-0.0009166452,
0.0194803402,
-0.0328571536,
0.0374052227,
-0.0291978382,
0.0928336978,
-0.0603192113,
-0.0637520701,
0.0398069806,
0.0539700948,
0.0243885014,
-0.0168829784,
-0.0288697463,
0.021096101,
0.0050560925,
-0.0376718193,
-0.0044017471,
-0.0338096619,
-0.0164848585,
0.0356178135,
0.0091561843,
-0.004056192,
-0.0444811955,
-0.0491704531,
0.0652085468,
-0.0157901216,
0.0605956875,
0.0436412133,
0.0167441089,
0.0277562141,
-0.0179083385,
-0.0144778984,
0.038719438,
-0.0456410199,
0.0408397913,
-0.0215955488,
0.007230524,
0.0138939545,
0.0289304312,
0.001482691,
0.0201803651,
-0.0617783852,
-0.0597126819,
-0.0036046607,
0.0293509141,
0.0396842994,
0.0539543219,
0.0220637545,
-0.0417758673,
-0.0229851268,
-0.033430744,
0.0106827132,
0.0180174224,
-0.0182213709,
0.0799974203,
0.0405645184,
-0.0156883337,
-0.0183635056,
0.04563234,
0.0373590738,
0.034504272,
0.0058862288,
0.0212524459,
-0.0354534499,
-0.0241490118,
-0.051315885,
-0.0035519758,
-0.0230537597,
0.0064908327,
-0.0870201513,
-0.0684480593,
0.0017196796,
0.0535351522,
0.0092714662,
-0.0312656611,
0.0239662789,
0.0370876454,
-0.003921831,
0.0005891452,
-0.0071247974,
0.0171604753,
-0.0036085024,
-0.0440849997,
-0.0038870925,
-6.173004993e-33,
-0.0281903502,
0.0011767455,
0.0305832829,
-0.0015226989,
-0.0115633467,
0.0065362598,
-0.0792815983,
0.0049156211,
-0.0275053754,
-0.0057644327,
0.0081592174,
0.0015805799,
-0.002928623,
-0.0146109462,
-0.022387987,
-0.0159483291,
0.0277410559,
-0.0090434123,
-0.0190552697,
-0.0228242297,
-0.0005279928,
0.0127123343,
0.0248328485,
-0.0199045017,
0.020038398,
-0.0153398719,
-0.0135140345,
0.0120126596,
-0.0364181921,
0.0702682659,
-0.0506173633,
0.020891767,
-0.0245365314,
-0.0601648502,
-0.0030181557,
-0.0127432747,
-0.0382718854,
-0.0237369835,
0.0160677638,
-0.040797051,
-0.0187417008,
-0.0349510461,
0.0437749214,
0.00716927,
-0.0284435414,
-0.0155687258,
0.0265223589,
-0.0253898092,
-0.0219394621,
-0.0142379878,
-0.0485588014,
0.0224074088,
-0.0110554527,
0.0252085999,
0.0073218686,
-0.0128284059,
-0.0136394268,
0.0392817631,
-0.0250145383,
0.020691596,
0.0446932316,
0.0633905903,
0.0975958183,
-0.0380645767,
0.0148625914,
0.0424843356,
0.0090220878,
-0.0013509128,
0.0216138251,
-0.0372366607,
0.0504055098,
0.0667276308,
0.0753518194,
0.0049520321,
0.0146130528,
-0.0136841815,
-0.0747572854,
0.0218798034,
0.0612360761,
0.027264351,
0.0023096409,
0.0285894312,
-0.0284564439,
-0.0039719511,
-0.0646829382,
-0.0085116988,
-0.0360291675,
-0.0479718409,
0.0210104659,
-0.0369700417,
-0.0232556369,
-0.0153815364,
0.0209103022,
-0.066376321,
-0.0270922426,
0.0422559083,
-0.0132130599,
0.0297899861,
0.0113983909,
0.0685074255,
-0.0652577206,
-0.0241008475,
-0.005961827,
-0.0222658981,
0.0411531739,
-0.0097248126,
-0.0224561971,
0.0177024119,
-0.0540817492,
-0.0089407833,
-0.040851634,
-0.0165921412,
0.0137381554,
0.0240694173,
-0.0040081446,
0.0215741936,
0.0091881445,
0.0152663635,
0.01328196,
0.0267627034,
-0.0041869655,
0.0286097415,
0.0029775936,
0.0426425375,
-0.038766522,
-0.0240626801,
-0.0387673117,
0.0480665863,
0.0548896566,
-0.0128094656,
-0.0249508396,
0.026206363,
2.511e-7,
0.0979566574,
0.0771450251,
0.0369601212,
0.0189409126,
0.0149580669,
0.0225029439,
-0.0853139684,
-0.00493949,
-0.0093764216,
-0.0215507764,
-0.0081045218,
0.0140857957,
0.0489698499,
0.0358098038,
-0.0628340021,
0.0191290341,
-0.0747529194,
0.001996197,
-0.0486119799,
-0.033674106,
0.0078939563,
0.0527485497,
0.0167354066,
-0.0185932554,
-0.0299170874,
-0.0321115218,
0.0529364869,
-0.0514021739,
-0.0048232139,
0.0545883924,
0.0196065903,
0.0130269704,
0.0109352488,
0.0115355654,
-0.009574635,
0.0015887219,
0.0269173551,
0.076446794,
0.0279663075,
-0.0557548255,
0.0367265195,
-0.0207876414,
0.0112246657,
-0.0474249721,
0.0449352637,
-0.0121085579,
-0.0201018099,
-0.0238275956,
-0.0185284019,
-0.0006891831,
0.020064475,
-0.0332541876,
-0.0047507477,
0.0245077368,
-0.0074338024,
-0.0099875024,
-0.0115316305,
-0.0222342853,
-0.0478574783,
0.00937868,
-0.0495197177,
-0.0524057373,
-0.0668173954,
0.0080121243,
-0.0195602216,
-0.0313007571,
-0.0203074291,
2.673343232e-34,
0.0443838239,
-0.0123271514,
-0.0052811755,
0.0352849998,
0.0114093032,
0.0051843822,
-0.0290276837,
0.0182156544,
-0.00165998,
-0.0876848251,
0.0063408953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10903v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10903v2 | Emergent AI-Assisted Discourse: Case Study of a Second Language Writer Authoring with ChatGPT | 2023-10-17T00:22:10 | 2023-10-23T17:31:26 | Sharin Jacob, Tamara Tate, Mark Warschauer | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid proliferation of ChatGPT has incited debates regarding its impact
on human writing. Amid concerns about declining writing standards, this study
investigates the role of ChatGPT in facilitating academic writing, especially
among language learners. Using a case study approach, this study examines the
experiences of Kailing, a doctoral student, who integrates ChatGPT throughout
their academic writing process. The study employs activity theory as a lens for
understanding writing with generative AI tools and data analyzed includes
semi-structured interviews, writing samples, and GPT logs. Results indicate
that Kailing effectively collaborates with ChatGPT across various writing
stages while preserving her distinct authorial voice and agency. This
underscores the potential of AI tools such as ChatGPT to enhance academic
writing for language learners without overshadowing individual authenticity.
This case study offers a critical exploration of how ChatGPT is utilized in the
academic writing process and the preservation of a student's authentic voice
when engaging with the tool. | [
0.0279720239,
-0.0225100946,
-0.0336484462,
-0.0205662902,
-0.0472719446,
-0.0149000138,
0.0199002754,
-0.0367211141,
0.025456259,
-0.045451194,
0.0125046903,
-0.0113948928,
-0.0017845314,
0.0523629636,
-0.0008712275,
0.0041469154,
-0.0068987967,
0.0217965133,
0.0653154925,
0.0263941456,
0.0564015396,
0.050874088,
-0.0213601869,
0.0839600563,
-0.0373027921,
-0.0721151531,
-0.0211770535,
-0.0173607823,
0.0143647129,
0.0171813574,
0.0403034985,
0.0582840331,
0.0055176322,
0.0433734432,
0.0000019942,
-0.011225828,
0.0178564172,
-0.0048373593,
0.0029620805,
0.004692737,
0.0422322564,
0.1243465915,
-0.0364276245,
0.0092185987,
-0.0724767894,
0.0143174389,
0.0508454815,
0.0186746605,
-0.0082259187,
0.0318953581,
-0.029438369,
-0.0040030656,
0.0457590111,
0.0377344266,
-0.0180190131,
0.0425270759,
-0.0083893519,
0.0201839954,
0.0532690063,
0.0158783309,
-0.0023611828,
0.0493415482,
0.0139033319,
-0.0744567215,
-0.0008934512,
0.0327507779,
0.0001079474,
-0.0139801782,
0.0558165647,
-0.0166178532,
0.0894627795,
-0.0249800812,
-0.0019237768,
-0.0005718058,
0.0075468929,
0.0059620203,
-0.0267359652,
0.0254601315,
-0.0300629344,
0.0000807329,
0.0283342879,
-0.0309532583,
-0.026573645,
0.0178670306,
0.0507206433,
-0.0198164042,
-0.0183294993,
0.0097261192,
-0.0129077556,
0.0119592799,
0.039255403,
-0.0309707038,
-0.0052394923,
0.0533277057,
-0.0318964683,
0.0150053101,
-0.0122098699,
-0.0240437184,
-0.0265515875,
-0.0219927896,
0.0373243205,
0.0273127779,
0.0448719487,
-0.0364682563,
0.049535837,
0.0467567183,
0.0200074781,
0.0352346487,
-0.040117573,
0.0341968648,
-0.060795527,
-0.0564918071,
-0.0604689233,
0.0139596332,
-0.0216117129,
-0.0340140238,
-0.0050663762,
0.0078933565,
-0.0070679658,
0.0155207282,
-0.0366056599,
0.0101883914,
-0.0509060025,
0.0247810017,
0.0393094793,
0.0025520164,
0.0110043185,
0.0205446389,
-0.0219284929,
-0.0267966464,
0.0477152839,
0.0296196807,
-0.0037302694,
-0.020373879,
-0.0210156552,
-0.0063501028,
-0.0417451747,
-0.0257185884,
-0.0205357727,
-0.0261359755,
0.0265606456,
-0.0550548136,
-0.016861001,
-0.0357935913,
0.0004506152,
0.0291736741,
-0.00630594,
-0.1006736234,
-0.0174870808,
0.0264429022,
0.0505497232,
-0.006249602,
-0.0229853485,
-0.0043695569,
0.0503832512,
0.0205632783,
0.0250004977,
-0.0129808346,
0.0927081183,
-0.0107966643,
0.006105667,
0.0110449092,
0.0418346487,
0.017097991,
-0.0544628017,
-0.0037011451,
0.0450333245,
-0.0278302077,
0.0067843697,
0.0173840281,
-0.0416007638,
0.0175847169,
-0.0002945879,
0.0739047751,
0.0770637542,
0.0754595101,
-0.0222391058,
0.0255561601,
0.0231114756,
0.0168603193,
0.0199230481,
0.0122422688,
0.0386183187,
0.0101862345,
0.0310197268,
-0.0041078078,
-0.0425061509,
0.0143243996,
-0.0205306616,
-0.0804337338,
-0.0151823442,
0.0051973634,
0.011750075,
0.0017107754,
-0.054217115,
-0.0121647585,
-0.0048708692,
-0.0294851307,
-0.0165440366,
-0.0749673918,
0.0224026479,
-0.0412783846,
0.023965003,
0.0676891208,
0.0511913598,
-0.0183500554,
0.0038849753,
-0.0398897715,
0.0175494067,
0.0671791434,
-0.0434549153,
0.0059550842,
-0.0401561782,
-0.0141740404,
0.0339302644,
-0.0534579307,
-0.0207683574,
-0.0160622597,
-0.0190061815,
0.0537978224,
0.0037157254,
0.0236840732,
-0.0747656971,
0.017015608,
-0.0841118768,
-0.0486517549,
0.0078644659,
-0.0220572017,
-0.0106870132,
0.0406914167,
-0.0410851762,
0.0115649793,
-0.0112854606,
0.0140852844,
-0.0252995249,
0.1005040184,
-0.0024667319,
0.0167367365,
0.0166633334,
-0.0694500208,
0.0081188902,
-0.018364124,
0.0245863274,
-0.0327681638,
0.0085351393,
-0.0078856023,
0.0041305986,
-0.0286814366,
-0.027244661,
-0.034924034,
-0.0299527999,
-0.0305307414,
-0.0214288197,
0.0122235101,
-0.006464418,
-0.0135483975,
0.0156447757,
0.0315652341,
0.0320786573,
-0.0177280344,
0.0721956789,
0.0142277833,
0.043948628,
0.0104089882,
0.0090659885,
-0.0472651832,
-0.0134081868,
-0.0845191926,
-0.0250190459,
-0.0169899892,
-0.0184191205,
0.0318639278,
-0.0169440862,
-0.0234125834,
0.0467247963,
-0.0400892459,
-0.0503670312,
0.0002586088,
-0.0480148345,
0.0448758267,
-0.0134343551,
0.0753174648,
-0.0168849174,
0.0315198153,
-0.012462425,
0.0036650123,
0.0829357952,
-0.051881481,
-0.0304418523,
0.0448699147,
0.010044598,
-0.0503374115,
-0.0061622774,
-0.0232696813,
0.0545195043,
0.0140303299,
0.0613751784,
0.0385434553,
-0.0039003734,
0.0745403245,
0.0207462125,
-0.0156379677,
0.0084998561,
0.0142600322,
0.0313356481,
0.0315775909,
-0.0052788872,
-0.0342928134,
-0.0093001919,
-0.016571654,
0.029273387,
-0.004512893,
-0.0140571622,
0.0293502808,
-0.0643709376,
0.0145842768,
0.016263267,
-0.0473446772,
-0.0513472557,
0.0132879429,
-0.0176067501,
0.0183773879,
-0.0011544509,
0.0006235722,
-0.0393358879,
-0.0565155856,
-0.0173567962,
-0.0083300127,
0.0928375199,
-0.0185731146,
0.0324019231,
0.0171529092,
-0.0273655429,
-0.045120161,
-0.0336364582,
0.0425068848,
-0.0036359229,
0.0167822726,
-0.0271016397,
0.0046725878,
-0.0153889749,
0.0163879506,
-0.009473728,
0.0246633645,
0.0148565583,
0.0411520004,
0.0293682422,
-0.0320649594,
-0.0040705903,
-0.0377403237,
0.027681306,
0.059271358,
-0.0220738426,
-0.0056308722,
-0.0286732186,
0.002073196,
0.0119618084,
-0.0212691166,
-0.0280327946,
-0.0008122262,
0.0457434393,
0.0511988476,
-0.0082201846,
0.0144764716,
-0.0149327414,
-0.0684339926,
0.0128782969,
-0.0455725417,
-0.044620242,
-0.0103566395,
0.0866922289,
-0.0057760892,
-0.035680797,
0.0991271958,
-0.028517507,
-0.0331746452,
-0.0047359262,
-0.0290186778,
0.0089159608,
-0.0114369057,
0.050034713,
-0.035782069,
0.0418464541,
-0.0129222274,
0.0091367541,
-0.0599872246,
-0.0178817026,
-0.0170597639,
-0.0387436785,
0.0741563588,
-0.0017208572,
-0.0091626104,
0.0561879165,
0.0136002861,
-0.0077186809,
0.0265576467,
0.0287240408,
-0.0218398217,
-0.0010393924,
0.0454061888,
0.0395777449,
-0.0569881797,
-0.0271127783,
-0.0194292255,
-0.0097996676,
0.0314081348,
-0.0110647948,
0.0757812709,
-0.003940084,
0.0167741887,
-0.0068993522,
0.0268124565,
-0.0023812449,
0.0050430135,
-0.0229510348,
-0.0191032402,
0.0300735105,
-0.0357394107,
0.0441987701,
-0.044808764,
-0.0567772426,
0.0386371911,
0.0430769287,
-0.0477554277,
0.0231575668,
-0.0095761158,
0.0140448101,
0.0406208262,
-0.0123647796,
0.0331458487,
-0.0321464166,
-0.0201842338,
-0.0239967182,
0.054199107,
-0.0108817946,
-0.055647444,
-0.028418785,
0.0011323857,
0.0093548559,
-0.0091160461,
-0.1202006862,
0.0337081105,
0.0671515539,
0.0243942086,
0.0608396307,
-0.0045229755,
-0.0002755533,
-0.0360310711,
-0.0350790806,
-0.01849062,
0.045733124,
0.0050023124,
-0.0622081086,
-0.0333535708,
-0.0363527946,
0.0148098981,
-0.0110740755,
-0.0103543131,
-0.0402863808,
0.0296722893,
0.0141355498,
0.0191166885,
-0.0016032379,
0.0017695248,
-0.0080948118,
-0.0349571854,
0.0214634947,
0.0285169948,
0.0447096117,
0.0247179549,
-0.0138665987,
0.0002223398,
-0.0080860229,
0.0566916429,
-0.0173858795,
-0.0032413253,
0.0007209883,
-0.0473897569,
-0.0542725399,
0.0138917416,
0.0334281549,
-0.0056029828,
-0.0405105501,
0.0112808989,
-0.0870486274,
-0.0348300636,
-0.0215163305,
-0.0351606868,
-0.0421138704,
-0.0298303012,
0.0059409379,
0.0339726545,
-0.013588774,
0.0065198014,
-0.0689913779,
-0.0111249564,
-0.0198439155,
0.0512001701,
0.0012051015,
0.1011870131,
-0.0045697782,
-0.0050557717,
-0.016576713,
0.053020671,
-0.0102413865,
0.0356981829,
0.0163451675,
0.0409111679,
0.0228670146,
-0.0004361029,
0.065868035,
0.0230974909,
-0.0468360409,
-0.0231536888,
-0.0168730784,
0.0188952871,
0.041008465,
0.0043412838,
0.0445203818,
-0.0493055023,
0.0383034497,
-0.0170268901,
0.0601360723,
0.0261064786,
-0.054061152,
-0.0646860376,
-0.0223422218,
-0.0196157768,
-0.0393951312,
0.0416813344,
-0.0340087302,
0.0259487499,
0.0261302367,
-0.0147685036,
-0.0024331138,
-0.0976402238,
-0.0068526277,
-0.0038093936,
0.0561743267,
0.0094465278,
-0.0500807166,
-0.0390572511,
-0.023203386,
-0.0297426786,
0.0007513539,
-0.0745476857,
-0.0091128349,
0.0426988713,
0.0092330752,
0.0029089083,
-0.0653528646,
0.0030360473,
-0.0474396646,
-0.015519266,
0.0089483513,
-5.463740722e-33,
-0.0177088976,
-0.0900398195,
0.0543626286,
0.0778536052,
-0.0374378935,
0.0048656007,
-0.0322152488,
0.0416293144,
0.0166381486,
0.0501078926,
-0.0559808835,
0.006632233,
-0.0103761209,
0.0262575764,
0.0133851748,
0.0335145779,
0.0493190028,
0.0159530696,
-0.0017862623,
0.0140213473,
-0.0051677595,
-0.0153144654,
0.0263935551,
-0.0623615868,
0.0715327784,
-0.0771787614,
-0.0468364805,
-0.0338909999,
-0.0259108469,
0.0049658865,
0.0060287029,
0.0390181616,
0.017767584,
0.0144281005,
0.0040513081,
0.0039847577,
-0.0046312911,
-0.0660060272,
0.0305887498,
0.0363511704,
-0.0132333292,
-0.0602092892,
-0.015521301,
-0.0576173253,
-0.0573418327,
0.0212111529,
0.0567409657,
0.0430126116,
0.0025636351,
-0.0226741508,
-0.1099456698,
-0.0015397008,
-0.0443777554,
-0.0071800891,
-0.0288109593,
-0.017706437,
0.0014336504,
-0.1176582426,
-0.0578083508,
0.0072819083,
-0.026162535,
0.0148310382,
0.012578385,
0.0204047337,
-0.0284037255,
0.0322599597,
-0.0058953897,
0.0577696487,
-0.0395088345,
0.0144618899,
0.0157983378,
0.0080085564,
0.0206382219,
0.0360645279,
-0.1028614342,
-0.0325421281,
0.0020454028,
0.0209195167,
0.0484414063,
-0.0297512934,
-0.0022719912,
-0.0117448429,
-0.0091796881,
-0.0732832029,
-0.021646766,
-0.0307148043,
0.031477835,
-0.0433418974,
-0.0053609898,
-0.0790743977,
-0.0260936003,
-0.0305796061,
-0.0193706881,
-0.0120759327,
-0.0003797594,
0.0139598316,
-0.0651663393,
0.0361065455,
-0.0092002517,
0.0297801364,
-0.0201526452,
-0.0010243268,
-0.0097998688,
0.056504149,
0.013806452,
0.0379695669,
0.0066654971,
0.0452821627,
0.0038907728,
-0.0247032866,
-0.0405339897,
0.0542418845,
0.0139466701,
-0.0269937888,
-0.0026018946,
0.0048727766,
-0.0114258379,
0.017800333,
0.0467900001,
0.0141773336,
-0.027790647,
-0.0303133354,
-0.0359418355,
-0.0404001623,
-0.0301777199,
0.0208926648,
-0.0187222473,
0.0505627505,
0.0395920686,
-0.0192551017,
0.0118197314,
-0.0376843549,
2.719e-7,
0.037147589,
0.0207041278,
-0.0042882981,
0.0042018564,
0.0074974662,
0.0143900486,
0.0120310811,
0.0227427837,
0.0242067538,
0.0620907769,
0.0424956568,
0.0397132635,
0.005963888,
0.0336584784,
-0.0696415901,
-0.0273869559,
-0.0278816205,
-0.0017178458,
-0.0525534451,
0.0625790209,
0.0791460946,
-0.0644530728,
0.0242677219,
-0.0177730881,
-0.0323011167,
-0.0499054529,
0.0102620283,
0.0027484996,
0.0170899108,
0.0398973301,
-0.0148706259,
0.0102196923,
0.0410247147,
-0.0070536211,
0.0012092186,
-0.0547537431,
0.0147198495,
0.0797362477,
-0.0083774291,
0.0303064585,
0.0523266345,
0.0351572149,
0.007503462,
-0.0321015455,
0.0439112671,
0.0025245482,
-0.0113995699,
-0.0352671631,
0.0085038245,
-0.0533010177,
0.0066118347,
0.0183444601,
-0.0242837593,
0.0478818156,
-0.0147509612,
-0.0340570547,
0.0216733459,
0.0120559596,
-0.0079131769,
-0.0468292683,
0.0013712548,
0.0071623507,
-0.0132226245,
-0.0185634084,
0.0006019728,
-0.0286856033,
0.0299538486,
2.146979361e-34,
-0.0030070909,
-0.0042636502,
0.038381964,
0.0659643263,
0.0284228381,
0.0735684559,
0.0669927448,
0.0300232731,
0.0229278039,
0.0420501009,
-0.0377616063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10873v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10873v2 | IDEAL: Influence-Driven Selective Annotations Empower In-Context Learners in Large Language Models | 2023-10-16T22:53:54 | 2024-01-20T03:58:10 | Shaokun Zhang, Xiaobo Xia, Zhaoqing Wang, Ling-Hao Chen, Jiale Liu, Qingyun Wu, Tongliang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning is a promising paradigm that utilizes in-context examples
as prompts for the predictions of large language models. These prompts are
crucial for achieving strong performance. However, since the prompts need to be
sampled from a large volume of annotated examples, finding the right prompt may
result in high annotation costs. To address this challenge, this paper
introduces an influence-driven selective annotation method that aims to
minimize annotation costs while improving the quality of in-context examples.
The essence of our method is to select a pivotal subset from a large-scale
unlabeled data pool to annotate for the subsequent sampling of prompts.
Specifically, a directed graph is first constructed to represent unlabeled
data. Afterward, the influence of candidate unlabeled subsets is quantified
with a diffusion process. A simple yet effective greedy algorithm for unlabeled
data selection is lastly introduced. It iteratively selects the data if it
provides a maximum marginal gain with respect to quantified influence. Compared
with previous efforts on selective annotations, our influence-driven method
works in an end-to-end manner, avoids an intractable explicit balance between
data diversity and representativeness, and enjoys theoretical support.
Experiments confirm the superiority of the proposed method on various
benchmarks, achieving better performance under lower time consumption during
subset selection. The project page is available at
https://skzhang1.github.io/IDEAL/. | [
0.0309939217,
0.0335260592,
-0.0088170404,
0.0338924266,
-0.0139456997,
0.0271785241,
0.0067939321,
-0.0026195527,
0.01584916,
-0.0695202798,
-0.0215607639,
-0.029550964,
-0.0275348369,
-0.0251154415,
0.0392665453,
-0.0380197912,
0.026066754,
-0.049080316,
0.0004471404,
0.0023016974,
-0.0065860474,
0.012840936,
0.0391204581,
0.040878199,
-0.0100167096,
-0.0181443226,
0.0190842226,
0.0130466241,
-0.0048000901,
-0.0422052853,
0.0261079613,
0.0743294954,
0.0214345213,
0.0405129194,
0.0000022792,
-0.0600459576,
-0.0407667868,
-0.0097827511,
-0.0481102802,
0.0177760255,
0.0391533114,
-0.0053925118,
0.0065145683,
-0.0160641819,
-0.0068872338,
-0.000110484,
0.063637875,
0.0016750916,
0.0464615189,
0.0618290678,
-0.0010553091,
-0.0013136906,
-0.0313252732,
-0.0299956687,
0.0123316022,
-0.0362322591,
0.0484154262,
-0.0033516109,
-0.0059471745,
0.0138378907,
-0.043807812,
0.0169503391,
-0.0192252956,
-0.0335439257,
0.0511323661,
0.0178656783,
-0.034967415,
-0.0169311259,
0.0086598815,
0.1003069729,
0.0042840755,
-0.0455495566,
0.0174827557,
-0.0550685674,
0.0065898686,
0.0217884742,
-0.0443186499,
0.0016947021,
0.0082205515,
0.0456903838,
0.0325940214,
0.0264028832,
0.0632452592,
0.0121300807,
-0.0050456761,
0.0223902203,
-0.0014928813,
-0.0189928301,
0.0377939194,
0.0204663929,
-0.0604996271,
-0.040002089,
-0.0242694467,
-0.0274209734,
-0.0457219966,
0.0273655578,
-0.0169102568,
-0.0419542454,
-0.0046973447,
-0.0416012891,
0.020519156,
0.0184116568,
0.0239499919,
0.054742869,
0.0194867756,
-0.0419197083,
-0.0144026754,
0.0155095113,
-0.0371331759,
-0.0278173406,
-0.046330031,
0.0367121994,
-0.0581790209,
0.034127783,
0.0057043266,
0.0084836259,
-0.0567456447,
-0.0023491245,
-0.0503122583,
-0.0076273698,
0.0180913676,
-0.0228884984,
-0.0378005281,
0.0333738513,
0.0133562339,
0.0061865016,
-0.0160419401,
-0.0203173812,
0.0076325489,
-0.0445278808,
0.0024336083,
0.0264977142,
0.0152995549,
-0.0590020753,
-0.0111612044,
0.0525925942,
0.0084630745,
-0.064502731,
-0.0300509278,
0.0088919364,
-0.0127628259,
-0.0465514809,
-0.0111636771,
-0.0613098815,
-0.0130835706,
0.0141567811,
0.0266346447,
-0.0292387139,
0.0055847797,
0.0142355394,
0.0054986048,
0.0524651445,
-0.0204268657,
-0.0136534097,
0.0155270202,
-0.0113501167,
-0.0268672183,
0.088549234,
-0.0067134197,
0.0007884375,
0.0557493977,
0.017470967,
0.0244762748,
0.0499148853,
0.0537285767,
0.021446906,
0.0006819359,
0.0074711698,
0.0434468091,
-0.0017371881,
0.0010339882,
0.0065414142,
-0.0381555259,
-0.0113460161,
0.0458112657,
0.0147982202,
-0.0237189643,
-0.0251342226,
0.0342026614,
0.0323176533,
-0.0086681265,
-0.0217256937,
-0.0258651525,
0.0035749858,
-0.0006503605,
-0.0228418652,
0.0135333929,
-0.0214747954,
-0.025576055,
-0.0338801146,
-0.0159337595,
-0.0022142248,
0.0139704132,
0.0635221377,
0.0655452013,
0.0237597879,
-0.0147619052,
0.0661490113,
0.0720927268,
-0.0139408568,
-0.0073257084,
-0.0193189364,
0.0541522391,
0.0248660464,
0.0217396487,
-0.056333892,
0.0097736837,
-0.0401374511,
0.048303172,
-0.0069165025,
0.0537813976,
-0.0601717606,
-0.0042598457,
-0.0642262623,
-0.040853899,
0.0079200091,
0.0255849399,
0.0212277044,
0.0164275374,
-0.0205427483,
-0.0167528018,
-0.0376492031,
-0.047538612,
0.0353986211,
-0.0026033628,
-0.0515607223,
0.0231908429,
-0.0036917583,
0.0613149926,
0.0166572984,
-0.0151421949,
-0.026419742,
-0.000519463,
-0.018643897,
-0.0161455069,
-0.0283357576,
-0.0568993874,
-0.0628812984,
0.0110990908,
-0.027058294,
-0.0527490899,
-0.0024166941,
-0.0525129139,
-0.0446350314,
-0.0180360358,
-0.0418786928,
0.0575964861,
-0.0480774716,
0.0004105376,
-0.0219245795,
0.0284297727,
-0.0642294958,
0.0809512138,
0.0102937194,
0.0119854901,
0.0551291294,
0.0414199084,
-0.0103606246,
-0.0347382426,
-0.039705053,
0.0037370559,
0.0234488938,
-0.0021813349,
0.0358318985,
-0.0199931413,
-0.0385240614,
0.0238715075,
-0.1021379977,
-0.0100592962,
-0.0484354794,
-0.0207583793,
-0.0070375749,
0.0404063463,
0.0040265555,
-0.0234776605,
-0.0115001304,
-0.0124940686,
-0.044413887,
0.0317506418,
0.0013294693,
0.0209377632,
0.0105801784,
-0.0273579396,
-0.0337892659,
-0.0042239618,
0.0528963245,
0.0202195272,
-0.070544824,
-0.0169293247,
-0.0067674438,
-0.018232692,
0.0160509218,
-0.0207749698,
0.0422911867,
-0.0201482251,
-0.011084497,
-0.0232399218,
0.0213520695,
-0.0112586776,
0.0495972522,
0.0419241637,
0.0126298852,
-0.0484222397,
0.0020545369,
-0.0346569642,
0.0463898405,
-0.0214238893,
0.0071681845,
0.006678272,
0.0487527475,
0.0121821361,
-0.0490035564,
-0.0259968005,
0.0016927134,
-0.0514428914,
-0.0151431328,
-0.0617204569,
0.0032814185,
-0.0226020738,
0.0319676921,
-0.0074873972,
-0.0477579162,
0.0697443858,
0.0179062709,
-0.0010778371,
-0.0390883051,
-0.0288387071,
-0.0331883803,
0.0341661572,
0.0084172841,
0.0006973228,
0.0204477888,
-0.0249428246,
-0.0170490164,
-0.0165976696,
0.0643297806,
0.0060400171,
0.052971825,
-0.0280875135,
0.066162914,
0.0049516843,
-0.0392075665,
-0.0345938094,
-0.0687377378,
-0.008967774,
0.0254284311,
0.0230450444,
0.0203202777,
0.0200142507,
-0.0089154094,
-0.0096758613,
0.0750171095,
0.0042823586,
-0.0015025008,
-0.0168404188,
0.0042019216,
0.0295075811,
0.0009858282,
0.0039411988,
-0.0505571179,
0.0291880649,
0.0262646116,
0.0204537511,
-0.0345340855,
-0.0119771408,
0.0162442196,
0.0381576642,
-0.049326513,
-0.009958853,
0.0214644372,
0.0657245591,
-0.0444442742,
-0.024247149,
0.0952374414,
0.0237079058,
-0.0791855976,
0.0227160417,
0.0186519157,
0.0348142982,
0.0383813716,
0.0150026763,
-0.0862554833,
-0.042746488,
0.0144232977,
0.0203494634,
0.0005508703,
-0.0496618785,
0.0124969678,
-0.129695937,
0.0762371942,
0.0015978424,
-0.0643144846,
0.0371410288,
-0.0646354258,
0.0263523869,
-0.0568512902,
-0.0049805515,
-0.0321003757,
0.0149350008,
0.0003132927,
0.0423046649,
0.0199902635,
-0.0603897609,
0.032134112,
-0.0058453018,
0.026569942,
0.0272531155,
0.0312867202,
0.0059325569,
0.00468875,
0.0838149339,
-0.0375032797,
-0.0281903446,
-0.0415280163,
0.0708904043,
0.0024965238,
-0.0171601884,
0.0266084783,
0.050479617,
-0.0061603328,
-0.014692747,
0.0079852445,
0.1067706421,
-0.0152193187,
-0.0038575185,
0.0033082417,
-0.0605844669,
0.067653276,
0.0816292688,
0.0391744375,
-0.0650055334,
-0.0076476531,
-0.0199819319,
-0.0037605444,
-0.0031157539,
-0.0116377398,
0.016707683,
-0.0295342561,
-0.0421693213,
-0.0650250912,
-0.0043851584,
0.0276952405,
0.0602237061,
0.0044434052,
0.0637057498,
0.0126427142,
0.0117562739,
0.0064813755,
0.0332708359,
-0.0691181198,
0.0100234374,
0.0008969181,
-0.0591336675,
0.036536932,
-0.0353959799,
-0.0402673483,
0.0414002091,
-0.0476444438,
-0.069345884,
0.0106294304,
0.0290861372,
0.0166582335,
0.0888542831,
-0.0169273987,
-0.0394179523,
0.0879070461,
0.0233093482,
0.0290261172,
-0.0204720646,
0.0396581106,
-0.0004646242,
-0.0122715468,
0.0504860803,
-0.0613611341,
0.0360909253,
0.0765530467,
0.0075084823,
-0.0506559722,
0.0118183065,
0.0173550583,
-0.0029207296,
0.0246678721,
-0.0321860239,
-0.0125324,
-0.0697245523,
0.0128846746,
0.0121766329,
-0.052831132,
-0.0598074868,
0.0249888804,
0.0097018816,
-0.0336894281,
-0.0193533879,
-0.0129695963,
-0.0000260827,
0.0180027168,
-0.0504071377,
0.0218715891,
0.0300343335,
0.0230285861,
0.0247147251,
0.0154469432,
-0.004704203,
0.0108431997,
0.0271755513,
0.0289009809,
0.0002563922,
0.0167667344,
0.0253533088,
0.012063181,
-0.0240959674,
-0.0314514711,
-0.0650073737,
0.0163573977,
-0.0449854136,
0.0524634011,
0.0686291903,
-0.0638972595,
0.0644539073,
-0.0059979237,
-0.0336863548,
-0.0214468576,
0.0410785712,
0.0145172682,
-0.049794022,
0.0167245325,
0.0167509392,
-0.0273694415,
0.0606235601,
0.0535880029,
-0.0137081686,
0.0315051302,
0.0166351292,
-0.0128096696,
-0.0527641624,
-0.0045496756,
0.0188860539,
0.0559102856,
-0.0151301725,
0.0300804898,
-0.0409829393,
-0.0647332445,
-0.0127981454,
-0.024846863,
-0.0490069091,
0.0137694096,
0.0790260285,
0.0286540147,
-0.0067524714,
-0.0157544278,
-0.0789349899,
-0.0300695356,
-0.014803037,
-0.0040097297,
-0.015755374,
-6.714719075e-33,
-0.001953705,
-0.0148847308,
-0.0234335419,
0.0122770825,
0.0048538046,
0.0139276171,
-0.0480915047,
-0.0188607555,
-0.0094309496,
0.0075737261,
-0.0238070525,
0.0023756884,
0.0139590101,
0.0541980118,
-0.0098057194,
-0.0225568078,
0.0580884814,
0.0146288192,
-0.0282003637,
0.0582944751,
0.0494601689,
0.0251984857,
0.0412795693,
-0.0545021147,
0.0524634533,
-0.0225355197,
0.0010209056,
0.0003766162,
-0.0254261028,
0.0601422675,
0.0035875707,
0.0587733015,
0.0080846427,
-0.0591951832,
-0.0233393684,
-0.0163980573,
-0.0488476045,
-0.0374056138,
-0.0165246222,
0.0011478073,
-0.0149776023,
-0.0171923097,
0.0335801132,
-0.0009444709,
0.0206580199,
0.0013912132,
0.0570176169,
-0.0034258226,
-0.0471699052,
-0.0057732682,
-0.0554959401,
0.0413303524,
-0.0295861512,
0.0267979056,
0.0260080267,
0.0133151505,
0.0125340065,
0.0504682437,
-0.0596326254,
-0.0237084907,
0.0052941432,
0.019981036,
0.0402391516,
0.0388588682,
0.0338471979,
0.0642946288,
0.0034718784,
0.0173772536,
0.0609919094,
-0.0381819457,
-0.0002653601,
0.0291052405,
0.0122794835,
0.0505560637,
0.0360187404,
0.0009209763,
-0.1064859554,
-0.0075070383,
0.0457793362,
-0.0425625034,
0.026038833,
0.0177942105,
-0.0470958129,
-0.0441442356,
-0.0513309911,
-0.0559228174,
-0.0101123555,
0.0017458216,
0.0229833946,
0.0174040068,
-0.0660030469,
0.0498676002,
0.0333073288,
-0.0540496409,
-0.0748583823,
0.0136288768,
-0.017370265,
0.0244708974,
0.0153461676,
-0.0203193352,
-0.0599662252,
-0.0380281359,
-0.0213017017,
-0.0224872306,
0.0057735876,
-0.009028716,
0.0702867135,
0.0271147173,
-0.042043291,
-0.0010069868,
-0.0323031135,
0.0132943308,
-0.0325508676,
0.0578745864,
0.0374714881,
0.0138728376,
0.0017268348,
0.053728532,
0.0455161668,
0.0223470088,
0.0220319871,
-0.0299725514,
-0.0413915627,
-0.0174596757,
-0.0341195092,
-0.0130803436,
0.0150155006,
0.0460751578,
0.0488501675,
-0.0495148264,
-0.0050103008,
0.00549682,
2.833e-7,
0.0462642051,
0.0432811268,
-0.0309698135,
-0.0041724807,
0.0384508856,
0.036168877,
-0.0117644509,
0.0066042757,
0.0041916673,
-0.0306575131,
0.0202186722,
0.0012760268,
0.0395256281,
0.0210186075,
-0.1228910536,
0.0380186364,
-0.061894346,
0.0205868501,
-0.0265833307,
0.0026928198,
-0.0078495881,
0.1411685795,
0.0437399,
-0.0083725657,
-0.0153260361,
0.0035186941,
0.0578926951,
-0.0539808311,
0.0072979778,
0.0488688014,
0.0203373656,
0.0237552747,
-0.0063909939,
0.0296732578,
-0.0432012975,
0.0283952169,
0.0225895029,
0.0456746481,
0.0094486391,
0.0088616665,
-0.0008004041,
0.0130376015,
0.0185980685,
-0.0346646234,
0.0677026063,
-0.0650507733,
-0.0434956253,
-0.0524647832,
0.0103590079,
-0.0272781998,
0.0285155736,
0.0176992919,
0.0023446016,
0.016496893,
0.0084183365,
-0.014835679,
-0.0407051742,
-0.0654098168,
-0.0081663225,
-0.0272443183,
-0.0308461525,
-0.0482669361,
-0.0024572103,
0.022286173,
0.0030924922,
-0.0360717438,
0.0325583816,
2.702529241e-34,
0.0292688794,
-0.0239484366,
0.0042158687,
0.02874914,
-0.0102431048,
-0.0103909206,
-0.0058588455,
-0.0007515429,
0.0314860456,
-0.0402352437,
-0.0160020888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10865v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10865v2 | Will the Prince Get True Love's Kiss? On the Model Sensitivity to Gender Perturbation over Fairytale Texts | 2023-10-16T22:25:09 | 2023-11-15T21:32:28 | Christina Chance, Da Yin, Dakuo Wang, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies show that traditional fairytales are rife with harmful gender
biases. To help mitigate these gender biases in fairytales, this work aims to
assess learned biases of language models by evaluating their robustness against
gender perturbations. Specifically, we focus on Question Answering (QA) tasks
in fairytales. Using counterfactual data augmentation to the FairytaleQA
dataset, we evaluate model robustness against swapped gender character
information, and then mitigate learned biases by introducing counterfactual
gender stereotypes during training time. We additionally introduce a novel
approach that utilizes the massive vocabulary of language models to support
text genres beyond fairytales. Our experimental results suggest that models are
sensitive to gender perturbations, with significant performance drops compared
to the original testing set. However, when first fine-tuned on a counterfactual
training dataset, models are less sensitive to the later introduced anti-gender
stereotyped text. | [
0.0746096075,
0.0696173459,
-0.0212053321,
0.042910751,
-0.0104268407,
0.0231359489,
0.0196596477,
-0.0237791836,
-0.0173803344,
-0.0496159717,
-0.0095966328,
-0.0721967295,
0.0123386998,
0.0129377916,
0.0433711782,
-0.0344366655,
0.0458664894,
-0.0131418351,
0.0019032648,
-0.0453389362,
-0.00323977,
0.0508302525,
0.0186646916,
0.0258025583,
0.0180826765,
-0.0602663308,
0.0375077017,
0.0099040577,
0.0143281063,
-0.0038241269,
0.0815456435,
0.0292157847,
0.004601541,
-0.0072338893,
0.0000016586,
-0.0740961879,
0.0210230388,
0.0132400142,
-0.0094049936,
0.0272499416,
0.0085897464,
0.0246407501,
0.006708995,
0.0079963002,
-0.0035982381,
0.0312881395,
0.011791585,
0.0749971792,
0.054817412,
0.0562682115,
0.0105982097,
-0.0136424648,
-0.0483494662,
-0.0357116312,
0.0129247839,
-0.0182001963,
0.0141247613,
-0.0299958587,
-0.0287184231,
0.0019425106,
-0.0208728053,
0.0059743212,
-0.0129065989,
0.0304907151,
-0.0320836604,
0.0361904912,
-0.0180580057,
0.0180051494,
-0.0078756837,
0.0593697913,
0.0164393205,
-0.0167769045,
-0.0080686295,
-0.0015559299,
0.0262836982,
0.0384390764,
-0.0392624699,
-0.0003707437,
-0.0088941818,
-0.0334711149,
-0.0255179983,
-0.0466252491,
0.0398779362,
0.048911456,
0.0012278986,
0.0594691783,
0.01911496,
-0.0204064474,
0.0062110038,
-0.0149811506,
-0.0344523452,
-0.0437355451,
-0.0063869515,
-0.0146068726,
0.0251090173,
0.0028649743,
-0.0357352272,
-0.0003910095,
0.0058368491,
-0.0630476996,
0.0002659599,
0.0365547799,
-0.0184738208,
0.0366731584,
-0.0319102481,
0.017574003,
0.0042376029,
0.0049092909,
-0.0151652284,
-0.0539638065,
-0.0128788222,
-0.0338753536,
-0.0366731286,
0.0063998164,
-0.0345088243,
0.0329485796,
-0.0117779886,
-0.0242555402,
-0.0205649789,
-0.0020801651,
0.0108448649,
0.0590079948,
-0.020638166,
-0.0127694337,
-0.0444560274,
0.0243600048,
-0.0818417668,
0.0309610609,
-0.0361872837,
-0.0564794391,
-0.0273257326,
-0.0263604876,
0.0226072017,
-0.0530562997,
0.0542475693,
0.0472282097,
0.01998391,
-0.0196546521,
-0.0379575081,
0.0079999873,
-0.0308930445,
-0.0659246817,
-0.0051855422,
-0.0424245,
0.0057606203,
0.013495883,
0.0345600657,
-0.0465780534,
0.0151985995,
0.0418859571,
-0.0358474255,
0.0536810532,
0.0667816624,
-0.0203579869,
0.0518908463,
0.0111336177,
-0.0225488823,
0.0930259675,
0.0655436143,
-0.012401822,
0.04622785,
-0.0034170679,
0.0174710918,
0.0418484434,
0.0386231132,
0.0052014054,
-0.0221724324,
0.0492772833,
0.0209647827,
0.0105760628,
0.036580462,
0.0102785612,
0.0243665576,
-0.0737451613,
0.0616101362,
0.0607569218,
0.0017058171,
0.0764950663,
0.0382346325,
-0.0256106593,
0.0242570695,
0.047638841,
-0.0580258518,
-0.0001116933,
-0.0116522703,
-0.0020275854,
-0.0466016792,
0.0165974014,
-0.0118101183,
-0.0257310942,
-0.0154871782,
0.0161385071,
0.0097107626,
0.0125001799,
0.0254029408,
0.0443230756,
-0.0153331552,
0.0227429904,
0.0320572592,
-0.076764293,
0.0060345759,
-0.0277211536,
0.0310567636,
0.0546827465,
0.0179553963,
-0.0516988374,
0.0102411415,
-0.0422843173,
-0.0114688324,
-0.0055679418,
0.026360631,
-0.00732631,
0.0661557168,
-0.0227236599,
0.0105599724,
-0.0243701618,
0.0389253125,
0.030072799,
0.0212150216,
0.0363226682,
-0.0052895276,
-0.0251079574,
-0.0480383374,
0.0326713063,
-0.0413307957,
-0.0330017246,
0.0250111483,
0.0121484157,
0.0076523661,
0.0115117393,
-0.0412738621,
-0.0281063635,
0.0257296264,
0.0026033872,
-0.0249038767,
0.0259236805,
-0.0433854423,
-0.060638167,
0.0345897824,
-0.089228414,
-0.0655373186,
0.048716303,
-0.0176706109,
0.0102052102,
0.0640162751,
-0.0478500724,
0.0220003985,
-0.0185662396,
0.006766167,
-0.01275576,
0.0233063586,
-0.0336248353,
0.0234664567,
0.0018865148,
0.0062899776,
-0.0575728714,
-0.0196858607,
0.0164056607,
-0.057341367,
-0.0495900437,
-0.0072589233,
0.0161556359,
0.0037546875,
0.0346939787,
-0.0519832522,
-0.0256624594,
-0.0272360686,
-0.0650350004,
-0.0187671613,
-0.0063670636,
0.0030130779,
0.0072635626,
0.0144691123,
-0.051973477,
-0.0115230214,
-0.0509884506,
-0.0390022546,
-0.016234763,
0.010033316,
0.0353852063,
0.0093785161,
0.0311394539,
-0.0322547108,
-0.0002491116,
-0.0457745753,
0.0834595859,
0.0109164929,
0.0468271635,
-0.0206574667,
-0.0542357937,
-0.0476497076,
0.0311999545,
-0.0187447313,
-0.0228005275,
-0.0160815194,
0.0294979867,
0.0120892003,
0.0779411569,
0.035122171,
-0.0199797116,
0.0491496027,
0.0169398244,
-0.0359970704,
0.0323535129,
0.0393930413,
-0.0172524247,
0.0206998643,
-0.0576758124,
-0.0051899077,
0.0437749252,
-0.0169209819,
-0.0369313732,
-0.0417511277,
0.0518549867,
-0.0028549088,
-0.0316879712,
-0.0154652586,
-0.0250719655,
-0.0003264953,
0.0407955237,
-0.0319176801,
-0.0260030478,
0.0609570406,
-0.0154284788,
-0.0340561382,
-0.055280827,
-0.0020504533,
-0.0475155823,
0.0515763946,
-0.0286462307,
0.0316249318,
0.0308189299,
0.0110844234,
-0.0994199142,
-0.0452443399,
0.0312751718,
-0.0200893842,
0.0464743972,
-0.0068504284,
0.0121511295,
0.0105339661,
-0.0249930248,
-0.0458827801,
-0.0478549674,
-0.01655435,
-0.0374291763,
-0.0348323025,
-0.022028178,
-0.021348482,
-0.0080316393,
-0.0498266406,
0.0240531489,
-0.0256145056,
-0.0238180328,
0.0169990547,
0.0169416927,
0.0730052292,
0.00837122,
0.0045297542,
-0.0224004537,
0.0170251075,
0.0206840429,
-0.0314191356,
-0.0120449588,
0.007238552,
0.0214969479,
0.025263017,
-0.0535038114,
0.0043131011,
-0.0222851541,
-0.013928703,
-0.0816714689,
0.0015543273,
0.0789356828,
0.0371854976,
-0.0015814127,
0.0154892383,
0.0036536634,
0.0262702908,
0.035779696,
0.0213623513,
-0.0629215762,
-0.0060455548,
0.0163652077,
0.0215702504,
0.0032742789,
-0.0462368019,
-0.0468295291,
-0.135275811,
0.0096343355,
-0.0095354822,
-0.0239531547,
-0.0624895468,
-0.0020761297,
-0.0103411926,
-0.0252050348,
0.0284726471,
-0.0183738489,
-0.0204744674,
0.0116294362,
-0.0200523771,
0.0073843985,
-0.0139680104,
0.0296029802,
-0.0531475097,
0.0511272997,
0.0341446623,
0.045857694,
-0.0465540066,
0.0448709913,
0.0065545635,
0.0062983898,
-0.0180816092,
-0.0032094871,
0.0664521009,
-0.0302005038,
-0.0205989163,
-0.0072914623,
0.0389454588,
0.0505926199,
-0.0173550639,
0.0334730558,
0.0099775242,
0.0641890466,
-0.0485221371,
-0.0352569297,
0.0155182704,
-0.0006859397,
0.1007723808,
-0.0119196493,
-0.0397166163,
-0.0319632404,
-0.074606277,
-0.031570591,
-0.0154428547,
-0.0687895343,
0.0036762692,
0.0656706244,
0.0264998488,
-0.0712631047,
-0.0372179784,
0.0127385342,
0.009637652,
0.0137776183,
-0.0322564617,
-0.0102296723,
0.0422106124,
-0.0721235648,
0.0395705737,
-0.0164256003,
0.0136470664,
-0.0112560401,
-0.0282221381,
0.0050774575,
-0.0509108603,
-0.0449451804,
-0.0010000451,
-0.0533752702,
-0.0562036224,
0.0307236128,
0.0338755362,
0.0191734843,
0.0695687458,
-0.0118578235,
-0.0623117909,
0.060537111,
0.0226691552,
-0.0481327772,
0.0247348119,
0.0385172665,
0.0433366932,
0.0007219686,
0.03252941,
-0.0368084274,
0.0003707338,
-0.0013462214,
0.0017861763,
0.0282712616,
-0.0333339795,
0.0049690395,
0.002813613,
-0.0200219955,
-0.0377971232,
0.0094303722,
-0.0332419164,
0.0145867839,
-0.00452777,
-0.0342225172,
-0.0024786643,
-0.0227148551,
0.0201502014,
-0.0211038589,
-0.0340396613,
-0.0124897966,
-0.0304097813,
0.005992217,
-0.0723012462,
-0.0034922538,
0.0423964113,
0.0087895188,
-0.0091373455,
0.0300391782,
-0.0003712865,
-0.0409005359,
-0.0187709555,
0.0759870186,
0.0234763958,
-0.0055995211,
0.018174734,
0.0143220695,
-0.0460952781,
-0.0051026214,
-0.0826473609,
0.0072146468,
-0.0339753404,
0.0224018078,
0.0136879543,
-0.0603739619,
0.0351917148,
-0.011525536,
-0.0179444645,
0.0058237379,
-0.0345214382,
0.0244509559,
0.0288538635,
0.0139888059,
0.0225382727,
-0.0020916509,
0.025007477,
0.0679895133,
0.0349894054,
0.1084812582,
-0.0097433627,
-0.0375508405,
-0.0114259189,
-0.0365730375,
0.0094539784,
-0.0009615622,
0.010061387,
0.0433652923,
-0.0852892399,
-0.0790413544,
-0.0052854614,
-0.0254104175,
0.0157416519,
-0.0318467282,
-0.0051770438,
0.013628874,
0.0063043004,
-0.009585415,
-0.0422552414,
0.0150659923,
0.0459318124,
-0.0067822482,
-0.0555324405,
-5.516903923e-33,
-0.0365197286,
0.0021217423,
-0.036947798,
0.0074636913,
-0.0031796596,
-0.0241110399,
0.0036996671,
0.008071647,
-0.0230807755,
0.0477133952,
-0.0015923571,
0.0428695455,
0.0009995606,
0.0183909163,
-0.0197338946,
-0.0286273155,
0.035071291,
0.0032039303,
-0.0586435907,
-0.0517904982,
0.0014356623,
0.0508534461,
0.0459960736,
-0.089390263,
0.0624347851,
-0.0234535765,
-0.0246506296,
-0.0137138795,
-0.0079165744,
0.058083389,
-0.0093246354,
0.0574837103,
0.0125834867,
-0.0110461256,
0.0222704392,
0.0414964482,
-0.0986075103,
-0.0403473862,
0.0124038337,
0.024501361,
0.051494997,
-0.0158262867,
0.0228242986,
0.0253353529,
-0.0000112772,
-0.0449597389,
0.0566875711,
0.0006141284,
0.0635872036,
0.01222564,
-0.0561196394,
0.000928728,
-0.0548965856,
-0.0185197704,
-0.0158817787,
0.0797427073,
0.0233154241,
0.0384064578,
-0.0250651613,
0.0207485482,
-0.0006385807,
-0.0067471326,
-0.0038153327,
0.0270649511,
-0.003182217,
0.056364052,
0.0725549385,
0.0235291403,
-0.0289646145,
-0.0177140906,
0.01911382,
-0.055971358,
0.0666035488,
0.0877867192,
0.0413293727,
0.0193647482,
-0.0892613307,
0.0044858572,
0.010166632,
0.0008224963,
0.0283734184,
-0.0328533761,
-0.0419143215,
-0.0366763808,
-0.0524726361,
-0.006273177,
-0.0132683301,
0.0167672839,
0.0091652889,
-0.0214584079,
-0.0717090443,
0.0170033872,
-0.0327236429,
-0.0585434623,
-0.044013299,
0.0462105945,
-0.0163154025,
-0.0372423381,
0.0526360385,
0.0286572073,
-0.0033707884,
0.0556900278,
0.0425758325,
0.041043859,
0.0356390923,
0.0077756876,
0.0314144492,
0.0274807885,
-0.0994687006,
-0.0014020334,
-0.0109582497,
0.0119643165,
-0.0017820246,
0.0625213459,
0.0100503834,
0.0242058598,
-0.0105862627,
0.011081052,
0.0311351828,
0.0153732998,
-0.0455457196,
-0.0228416957,
-0.009788774,
0.0254856274,
-0.014540798,
-0.0147458864,
0.0223861691,
-0.0249811485,
0.0108559383,
-0.0448787846,
-0.0042509977,
-0.0241910759,
2.392e-7,
0.0281034727,
0.0321999677,
0.0482690781,
0.051348038,
0.0209964942,
0.0498420149,
-0.0195327289,
0.0156852249,
0.0491314903,
0.0174603499,
-0.0154569298,
0.0188626964,
0.0059293155,
0.0397138745,
-0.071375072,
0.0136246923,
-0.077255033,
0.0193548203,
0.0093783205,
-0.026345972,
0.0105856974,
0.0836965591,
0.0439993255,
-0.0096640559,
-0.0037379274,
-0.0313340686,
0.0446772948,
-0.0170491468,
0.029432781,
0.0186480563,
-0.0233487263,
0.0210957043,
0.0212333873,
0.0183384437,
-0.0032726405,
0.0515622608,
0.0082251383,
0.0122881485,
-0.0342401452,
0.0068095429,
-0.019151669,
0.0074745873,
-0.0176944304,
-0.0744330809,
0.090914987,
0.0262402669,
-0.0236490127,
-0.0321691409,
-0.0077982419,
0.0161612201,
0.0627961978,
-0.0123317558,
-0.0269550122,
0.0331285,
0.0324572995,
0.01934628,
0.0171062686,
-0.0910377949,
-0.0189588908,
0.0067306552,
-0.0271307454,
-0.036754936,
0.0038876755,
0.0467632934,
-0.0104820384,
-0.0574473068,
0.0313934796,
1.832579277e-34,
0.0263854507,
0.0099289948,
-0.0183621664,
0.029169606,
0.0421454348,
-0.0083272448,
0.0862928033,
-0.0275920983,
0.0643811896,
0.0083522527,
-0.0170702841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10845v1 | CoTFormer: More Tokens With Attention Make Up For Less Depth | 2023-10-16T21:37:34 | 2023-10-16T21:37:34 | Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Matteo Pagliardini, Martin Jaggi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The race to continually develop ever larger and deeper foundational models is
underway. However, techniques like the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) method continue
to play a pivotal role in achieving optimal downstream performance. In this
work, we establish an approximate parallel between using chain-of-thought and
employing a deeper transformer. Building on this insight, we introduce
CoTFormer, a transformer variant that employs an implicit CoT-like mechanism to
achieve capacity comparable to a deeper model. Our empirical findings
demonstrate the effectiveness of CoTFormers, as they significantly outperform
larger standard transformers. | [
0.0003977555,
0.0549199246,
-0.015081469,
0.0094723972,
-0.042129159,
-0.0302642025,
0.0083893603,
-0.0114058098,
-0.0648887306,
-0.0073133917,
0.0076853228,
-0.0345180854,
0.0108369943,
0.0629457161,
0.0516664609,
-0.0439982228,
0.0184085462,
0.0353148133,
-0.0738686696,
-0.0068571912,
-0.0104359612,
-0.06567844,
0.0203955825,
0.0078668678,
0.0041627972,
-0.0065749632,
-0.047036618,
0.0406635813,
-0.0206007995,
-0.0288985856,
0.0012032537,
0.0386389345,
-0.0331776403,
0.0736928657,
0.000002547,
-0.0075227767,
-0.0411070548,
0.0279188007,
-0.0224668682,
0.0511492677,
-0.0517368503,
0.0040949816,
0.0074632005,
0.0168043561,
0.0098873181,
0.0300997645,
0.0849052593,
0.0606386364,
0.0248133037,
0.02561979,
-0.0141446441,
-0.0102157723,
0.0499853306,
-0.0024483132,
-0.0560647547,
-0.0397794135,
-0.0013112595,
0.0025228027,
-0.0127265863,
-0.0285799261,
-0.0641367733,
0.0098064793,
0.0199332926,
-0.0175003912,
0.0406779386,
0.0054654111,
0.0064333584,
-0.0346616954,
-0.0301654283,
0.0152878538,
0.0043347999,
0.0167367626,
-0.015063894,
-0.0312251151,
-0.0591728836,
0.001032615,
-0.051695317,
-0.0088216076,
0.0004915693,
-0.0038438619,
-0.0062065059,
0.0345613286,
0.0474401861,
-0.0154136093,
-0.0648230836,
0.0405281223,
-0.0045250226,
-0.0345849879,
0.0067583071,
0.0128738927,
0.0069470652,
-0.0350272655,
0.0139609305,
0.0037464127,
-0.0368919484,
-0.0366816558,
0.0505638272,
-0.0093557751,
-0.0424875095,
-0.0004485309,
0.0926587656,
0.0590630434,
-0.0080464287,
0.013629457,
-0.0309180338,
0.0503848307,
-0.1056487411,
0.0167773683,
-0.0519334413,
0.0232367925,
0.0079330252,
-0.0051706228,
-0.0485799201,
0.0605555028,
-0.0443516821,
-0.0216762666,
-0.0434170216,
0.0175666846,
-0.0178220533,
-0.0586149357,
0.0236367527,
0.0127718262,
0.0407564454,
0.0140501549,
0.0053988406,
0.0956462398,
-0.0158500858,
-0.0129748425,
0.0469568148,
-0.057343591,
-0.0182043724,
-0.0334545821,
-0.0245728809,
-0.0167402998,
0.0088613778,
0.0559836887,
-0.0045632473,
-0.0345429741,
-0.0010059854,
-0.0073045571,
0.0121691581,
-0.0403189585,
-0.0231481995,
-0.0386365168,
-0.0237719268,
-0.0105046527,
0.0250128042,
0.0076432335,
-0.0054034297,
-0.0266964659,
-0.0220612809,
0.0125858542,
0.0191672593,
-0.0144030275,
-0.0250269044,
0.0136740096,
-0.0326017365,
0.0680164173,
0.0269331168,
0.0442650877,
0.0105113257,
0.0027815257,
-0.0257176235,
0.0453360677,
0.0273273475,
-0.0171860624,
0.014687472,
-0.0288986154,
-0.0305180661,
0.0022838369,
-0.0112849222,
0.0180481188,
-0.0291076936,
0.062139526,
0.043636933,
0.0070081595,
0.0659780651,
0.0621264353,
0.0281449873,
-0.0062201414,
0.0078559816,
-0.0087341657,
-0.0488185026,
0.0510765761,
0.0552810803,
-0.0019261542,
0.0697050616,
0.0550839454,
-0.0269499738,
-0.0210921746,
0.003942064,
0.028459318,
-0.00754428,
-0.0095717125,
-0.0006074165,
0.0370176472,
-0.0557542667,
0.1268685758,
0.0042597237,
-0.0443103127,
-0.029089516,
-0.0800487772,
-0.0015714809,
-0.0022223652,
0.0524432771,
-0.0066417544,
-0.0194973461,
0.0011190844,
-0.020885149,
0.0540717877,
0.0421424918,
0.036558561,
-0.0263652205,
-0.0058587478,
-0.017433051,
0.0226303898,
0.0415107831,
0.0039606905,
-0.0106738191,
-0.0121518774,
-0.0089747487,
0.0171756465,
0.0012798095,
0.006142227,
-0.0130372392,
0.0358483903,
0.027276488,
0.0225039087,
0.0474537872,
0.0382280089,
0.0058147009,
-0.0000232823,
0.0211426355,
0.0185614843,
-0.0733100697,
0.0075982437,
-0.0328076556,
0.085229516,
0.0094946306,
-0.0275930427,
0.0211675745,
0.0304862894,
0.0067000552,
-0.0342133567,
0.0405696966,
-0.0575849265,
0.048664663,
0.0071135228,
0.0482921973,
-0.037247438,
0.012886066,
0.0087397993,
0.0231192932,
-0.006265217,
0.0166127309,
-0.0249767043,
-0.0002708227,
0.0161479171,
0.0118629923,
0.0296386797,
-0.0160843078,
-0.0612318404,
-0.0012042463,
0.0264339708,
-0.0055088657,
-0.0201480631,
-0.0046243258,
-0.0701640695,
0.0015216427,
-0.0028569116,
0.0271025058,
-0.0011707902,
0.0470666103,
0.0383876972,
0.0606821813,
0.0088938056,
-0.0042252974,
-0.0016705809,
0.0201303679,
-0.0095297666,
-0.0110422364,
-0.0781525224,
-0.0108301975,
-0.0265890919,
-0.0249227788,
0.0740573108,
0.0000313868,
-0.0088174306,
-0.0119289812,
-0.0025610169,
0.0292181745,
-0.0084745307,
-0.0342876539,
-0.0142438784,
0.0085560773,
-0.0006072395,
-0.0005746083,
0.0120748309,
0.0244456474,
0.0183417071,
-0.0072770654,
-0.0102993995,
-0.0332727917,
0.0127344374,
-0.0410865135,
-0.0139550678,
-0.0378318951,
0.0112194726,
-0.0000605587,
0.1083283201,
-0.024397552,
-0.0069782459,
-0.025667429,
-0.013854349,
0.0008050898,
-0.0276479479,
0.036259301,
-0.0301530492,
-0.0464023836,
0.0624980703,
-0.0053493422,
0.0016655043,
0.0356085151,
-0.0218714662,
0.0199074093,
-0.0183835197,
0.0270388406,
-0.0365038924,
0.0193287842,
-0.0285092853,
0.0335901119,
-0.0189591516,
0.0033169822,
-0.0323722474,
0.0310637057,
0.0029015611,
-0.0196597036,
0.0501406118,
0.0269175675,
-0.0087127341,
-0.0165936444,
-0.0624336004,
-0.037758749,
0.0059038731,
0.0015844267,
0.0385794044,
0.0841364861,
-0.0448706262,
-0.069444187,
0.0279923268,
0.0366133824,
0.0383341163,
-0.0323209018,
-0.0521545187,
-0.0225417912,
0.0095347138,
-0.040984422,
-0.0009999425,
0.1215748936,
0.0091316355,
0.0940563828,
0.0579138324,
0.0230203569,
-0.0286576804,
-0.0381088741,
-0.0162865501,
0.0159346592,
-0.0084577855,
-0.0512625948,
0.0262910295,
0.0258466061,
-0.0140955662,
-0.0623702742,
0.0471415892,
-0.0263725258,
-0.021411173,
0.0489354804,
-0.0116235707,
0.0381977856,
0.0135354511,
0.0378378034,
-0.107251972,
-0.0045100194,
0.0209411103,
0.0222600326,
-0.0358479917,
-0.0390611552,
-0.0437114239,
-0.0590871796,
0.050128974,
-0.008680216,
0.0066254409,
0.0389688574,
-0.0857340246,
-0.0264552273,
0.0076358132,
-0.0311703496,
0.0406987071,
0.0061175926,
-0.0260373689,
-0.0072517954,
-0.0105282273,
-0.0215316545,
0.0254399013,
-0.038567476,
-0.0675259233,
-0.0169517007,
0.0015657321,
-0.0100420238,
0.0060765333,
0.0524179637,
-0.0211605318,
-0.0002678754,
-0.0227202736,
0.002338049,
0.0287531763,
-0.0206806455,
-0.0257547237,
-0.0023332764,
-0.0175991803,
0.0151226697,
-0.0267861616,
0.0762638822,
0.0422451459,
-0.0045561893,
-0.0216913782,
-0.0230202135,
-0.0194519199,
0.0359778777,
0.0064771348,
-0.0526019521,
-0.0750512481,
-0.0467588603,
-0.032808397,
-0.0200237744,
-0.0805323869,
-0.0149412313,
0.0402517207,
-0.0050818995,
-0.0176605359,
0.0501357242,
-0.0794191584,
0.0659766197,
0.0400274694,
-0.0290774629,
0.0673135146,
-0.0081698578,
-0.0570815429,
-0.0007956034,
-0.0161850341,
0.0289313868,
-0.0679131448,
0.0141698159,
0.022847537,
-0.0326097645,
-0.0296449065,
0.029884072,
-0.0802282169,
-0.0663912073,
0.0416571125,
0.0552712902,
0.0466679372,
-0.0209167954,
0.0085143335,
0.0090228934,
0.049858477,
0.0816703513,
-0.0937497169,
0.0076246657,
0.0397653207,
-0.0088295499,
-0.0224641692,
0.0136359697,
-0.0423892587,
0.020922672,
0.0262187812,
0.0539108999,
0.0116713224,
0.0409515798,
0.0260721259,
0.0307975356,
0.0572383702,
-0.0251298212,
0.0158615932,
0.0221259035,
0.0381128415,
-0.0307605658,
-0.0148748513,
-0.0363120101,
-0.0091348263,
0.0095114391,
-0.0037358534,
0.0180507526,
0.0212218873,
0.0531540141,
-0.0227054209,
-0.0112546785,
-0.0134086888,
-0.0333777107,
-0.0057294271,
0.0334574319,
-0.0148916999,
0.0127831772,
-0.0480434783,
0.0149862049,
0.0360408463,
-0.0208055582,
0.0213661361,
0.0167044606,
-0.0004237008,
-0.0895075276,
0.0221976303,
-0.081069164,
-0.0918966308,
-0.0323422477,
-0.0229538418,
-0.0013640431,
0.0623046644,
0.005152679,
-0.0216192026,
-0.0040433458,
0.0363387428,
-0.0008478871,
-0.0327821597,
-0.0488887317,
-0.0069299624,
0.0099511482,
0.0243215971,
-0.0544410385,
0.021190621,
-0.0168243665,
-0.0033811624,
-0.0689952523,
0.0176170468,
-0.0139545286,
-0.0586454533,
-0.0439512283,
0.0425016992,
0.030800052,
-0.0169040915,
-0.1134423688,
-0.0133809159,
-0.0177039076,
0.0080732414,
0.0631967187,
-0.0208760612,
0.0272699893,
0.043602448,
0.0310643744,
-0.0372322872,
0.0113531044,
-0.0336354747,
-0.0185562689,
-0.0122074783,
0.0004397327,
-7.523414372e-33,
0.0072300015,
0.0168860648,
0.03536392,
0.0718954802,
-0.0506077744,
0.0465285107,
-0.0508687012,
0.0132998331,
-0.0096028168,
0.0001031682,
-0.0452320725,
-0.0022322976,
0.009160188,
0.030841006,
0.0419284068,
0.0123343756,
0.0430761799,
0.0006621029,
-0.0550118238,
0.0254996456,
0.0196503252,
0.0062944419,
-0.0197977424,
0.0023682269,
-0.0139670661,
-0.0201201737,
0.0042336965,
0.0199284013,
-0.0046502999,
0.0425325781,
-0.0078479387,
-0.0144836903,
-0.0091579575,
-0.0917540044,
-0.0036038943,
-0.0329669602,
-0.0700628683,
0.0363641568,
0.0165187493,
-0.0038175639,
-0.0344892181,
-0.0033863178,
-0.0038714167,
0.0436961986,
-0.0202201419,
-0.0877691284,
-0.0075437026,
0.0432474874,
0.0197206922,
-0.0446354188,
-0.0593017079,
-0.00856693,
-0.025292635,
0.0356925726,
-0.0074274493,
0.037667457,
-0.0361740366,
-0.0198553409,
-0.0431081131,
0.0287523922,
0.0045431624,
0.0293270722,
0.0373314805,
0.0402238071,
-0.0174505766,
0.0228833035,
-0.0072689247,
0.0374240912,
-0.0325453952,
0.014113442,
0.0121446028,
0.0677429661,
0.0727132708,
-0.0315351114,
0.0422370099,
0.0154211577,
-0.05143141,
-0.002229034,
-0.0062618777,
0.029254647,
0.0709119961,
0.0034392411,
0.0006980096,
-0.0174414311,
-0.0044253138,
-0.0369159095,
-0.0225118548,
-0.0083570797,
-0.0002048243,
0.0186368395,
-0.055487942,
-0.0041572247,
0.0380182564,
-0.0394365788,
0.0231875591,
0.0600685887,
0.0126256347,
0.0655193031,
0.0041973135,
-0.0029786632,
-0.0200356822,
-0.0447213799,
-0.0282792095,
0.0773800313,
0.0142453825,
0.0012155471,
0.0115534151,
0.0291679669,
-0.0494810119,
0.0025473158,
-0.0511933416,
0.0047589629,
-0.005079852,
-0.0335758328,
-0.0099249929,
0.0225403924,
-0.0081043001,
0.0104695437,
-0.0294323433,
0.00668053,
0.0031775692,
0.0868241414,
0.0275295861,
0.0675013661,
0.001599845,
0.0049594129,
-0.0614509471,
0.0270951483,
0.0428273007,
-0.0983675867,
-0.0653584301,
0.0448210612,
3.196e-7,
0.0034258519,
0.0367215499,
0.0282737166,
0.0209717136,
0.0332896486,
0.0189025514,
0.022350939,
-0.0070198388,
0.0197082479,
-0.0236998349,
-0.0187792815,
0.0174214467,
0.0038394129,
0.000139113,
-0.037719965,
-0.0544598848,
-0.08192949,
0.0206786282,
0.0101791974,
-0.0691380501,
-0.0155264707,
0.0561296903,
0.0138182677,
-0.0278700944,
-0.0178201813,
0.0124468403,
0.0272513349,
0.0502749719,
0.0748366117,
0.0607029833,
-0.0392278545,
-0.0058782017,
0.0119566517,
0.0161895957,
0.0037801226,
0.0416282639,
-0.0221331287,
0.0149718691,
0.0418087915,
-0.0078975372,
0.0078228107,
0.0190101061,
-0.0001227116,
-0.0614173524,
0.0064852764,
-0.0578061119,
-0.0340689085,
-0.012802612,
-0.0621487387,
-0.0487885363,
-0.0102047101,
0.0290940013,
0.0175099745,
0.0383487269,
-0.0178501997,
-0.0014412426,
0.0456509255,
-0.0523951836,
-0.0318212658,
-0.0085830847,
-0.0307477061,
-0.0238091387,
-0.0359116048,
0.0013164204,
0.021786483,
-0.0032077273,
-0.0291888677,
3.338337605e-34,
0.0500455424,
-0.020262789,
0.0490860827,
0.0453169122,
0.0445100814,
-0.0458134264,
0.0258729924,
-0.0192453954,
0.0207635853,
-0.0606803447,
-0.0460455865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10844v1 | Survey of Vulnerabilities in Large Language Models Revealed by Adversarial Attacks | 2023-10-16T21:37:24 | 2023-10-16T21:37:24 | Erfan Shayegani, Md Abdullah Al Mamun, Yu Fu, Pedram Zaree, Yue Dong, Nael Abu-Ghazaleh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are swiftly advancing in architecture and
capability, and as they integrate more deeply into complex systems, the urgency
to scrutinize their security properties grows. This paper surveys research in
the emerging interdisciplinary field of adversarial attacks on LLMs, a subfield
of trustworthy ML, combining the perspectives of Natural Language Processing
and Security. Prior work has shown that even safety-aligned LLMs (via
instruction tuning and reinforcement learning through human feedback) can be
susceptible to adversarial attacks, which exploit weaknesses and mislead AI
systems, as evidenced by the prevalence of `jailbreak' attacks on models like
ChatGPT and Bard. In this survey, we first provide an overview of large
language models, describe their safety alignment, and categorize existing
research based on various learning structures: textual-only attacks,
multi-modal attacks, and additional attack methods specifically targeting
complex systems, such as federated learning or multi-agent systems. We also
offer comprehensive remarks on works that focus on the fundamental sources of
vulnerabilities and potential defenses. To make this field more accessible to
newcomers, we present a systematic review of existing works, a structured
typology of adversarial attack concepts, and additional resources, including
slides for presentations on related topics at the 62nd Annual Meeting of the
Association for Computational Linguistics (ACL'24). | [
0.0335674845,
0.0897537023,
-0.0243933275,
0.0696682781,
-0.0565970205,
0.0068675568,
0.0200252905,
-0.0216088705,
0.0459882095,
-0.0571609363,
-0.039938096,
-0.0281303283,
0.032067433,
0.0152107095,
0.0683687702,
-0.0090279477,
0.066213049,
-0.030681273,
-0.0173827577,
-0.020292135,
-0.0098828515,
-0.0185870603,
0.0144968685,
0.0495560467,
-0.0113879573,
-0.0333874002,
-0.0075301235,
-0.0057061431,
0.0082741575,
-0.0249667894,
0.012365669,
0.0299743507,
-0.0084789777,
0.1113860011,
0.0000019488,
-0.0188964885,
-0.0241310354,
0.036901731,
-0.0066611343,
0.0368873142,
0.0291357432,
-0.0340244062,
-0.0190324113,
0.0037272093,
-0.0254469644,
-0.0098472824,
0.0264402051,
0.0456497557,
0.0684054121,
0.1192553788,
0.0040167384,
-0.0242577568,
0.0665536225,
-0.0396097377,
-0.0468109623,
-0.0773905441,
0.0521091297,
-0.0347208828,
-0.0195221286,
0.0190654565,
-0.0064485571,
0.0209256411,
0.0104282806,
-0.0065504313,
-0.064020656,
0.0196817964,
-0.0216516051,
-0.0246435087,
-0.0016298393,
0.0549656227,
-0.0248119514,
0.0029630852,
-0.0125627033,
0.015192192,
0.0146731306,
0.0107835084,
-0.0098370137,
0.0370971635,
-0.0079141427,
-0.0082860216,
0.0156850312,
-0.027441442,
0.0760041922,
0.0292977672,
0.0243969988,
0.0390904322,
0.0289992653,
-0.0125204409,
0.0103266621,
-0.0052147959,
-0.0272316113,
-0.0482013747,
0.00160133,
-0.0042442577,
-0.0288450606,
0.0309675392,
-0.0914957672,
-0.0269307178,
0.0452907346,
-0.0502126813,
0.031045679,
-0.0051528187,
0.0116543984,
0.0253963005,
0.028182812,
0.01798377,
-0.0434939601,
0.0497813448,
0.0112823779,
0.0184806101,
-0.0150894076,
-0.0288645588,
0.0185457319,
0.0099646952,
-0.0163502488,
0.0086916555,
-0.0340789333,
0.0351770446,
-0.046483703,
0.0586761162,
-0.0471457615,
0.006054326,
-0.0027504291,
-0.0089481063,
0.0032516012,
-0.0152873034,
0.0124435751,
-0.0048878151,
-0.0057437974,
-0.0927873105,
-0.0347622,
0.0194352977,
-0.0776186138,
-0.0250567142,
-0.0160279144,
0.1187477559,
0.0244485252,
-0.048550304,
-0.0361025631,
-0.0598794222,
-0.058311671,
-0.051161509,
0.0002322638,
-0.0468964763,
-0.0190512259,
-0.0320210047,
-0.027020473,
-0.0628067479,
0.0192851052,
0.0148422504,
-0.0582410209,
0.0791630149,
0.0123603316,
-0.0287949648,
0.0011943744,
0.0255536251,
-0.0175859928,
0.0745830014,
0.0171255078,
0.0388267711,
0.0615554787,
0.0200855043,
0.0154237505,
0.0411371738,
0.0193366706,
0.0273949094,
-0.0054453695,
0.0021619636,
0.0070759826,
-0.0082290415,
-0.0466170534,
0.092959106,
-0.0086171841,
-0.0779106915,
0.113121368,
0.044204507,
-0.0437093042,
0.0378248654,
0.0034860973,
-0.0223842803,
0.0347471014,
0.0092565771,
-0.0842343196,
-0.0367373079,
-0.0763264671,
-0.0481170975,
-0.0171723273,
0.0516969822,
-0.0082355551,
-0.0360442773,
-0.0066846726,
-0.0162426718,
0.0313145183,
-0.0014943928,
0.0275008325,
0.0177740827,
-0.0056607598,
0.0100726811,
0.0335258655,
0.0013114328,
-0.0053125499,
-0.0695205331,
-0.0348077267,
0.0180402454,
0.0746767074,
-0.0321747474,
0.0016818033,
-0.0401747413,
-0.0010262214,
0.0239953417,
0.0228141807,
0.0001050295,
0.0055677751,
-0.0058720633,
0.0131693706,
-0.0238074604,
0.0257063657,
0.0184056517,
-0.0029846237,
0.0046393205,
-0.0301369876,
0.0098729404,
-0.050748378,
0.0398768932,
0.0088702766,
-0.0499835685,
-0.0052232821,
0.0180236734,
0.0354070142,
-0.0009246491,
-0.0530658178,
0.0226631686,
0.0663487017,
0.0123867635,
-0.0137250498,
-0.0163016077,
-0.0148854703,
-0.0315357596,
0.0324034914,
-0.0117924865,
-0.0237464849,
0.0629794076,
-0.0468899757,
0.0171660837,
0.0412131064,
-0.0543446094,
0.0175398663,
0.0127324564,
0.0207050033,
-0.008428379,
0.0383885279,
-0.0372033715,
0.0433125608,
-0.0461194105,
-0.0243507121,
-0.0298272055,
0.0179258976,
-0.0008131171,
-0.0197275933,
-0.0397680663,
0.0435591266,
-0.012733439,
0.0265737567,
-0.0055658035,
-0.0035589405,
-0.0085394364,
-0.0304814484,
-0.0122975903,
-0.0249334052,
-0.0275108591,
0.0287126303,
0.0053196568,
-0.0368102081,
-0.0218207277,
-0.0199070871,
0.0118385674,
0.0140986545,
-0.0092165945,
0.0247157887,
0.0018962902,
-0.0114406878,
-0.0360035747,
-0.0067113908,
-0.0124073941,
-0.0190433264,
0.0690510049,
-0.0010806435,
-0.0262009911,
-0.0259032808,
0.006515115,
-0.0066756504,
0.0627345443,
-0.0294889398,
-0.0293680131,
0.040852569,
0.0396052003,
-0.020500239,
0.0881804302,
0.0168754105,
0.0852955729,
0.0617843159,
0.0106602367,
0.0077658948,
-0.0085330168,
0.0122583536,
-0.0420829318,
-0.0495705977,
0.0054382333,
0.0247870833,
0.0452537015,
0.018286461,
-0.0234096032,
-0.0173812322,
0.0464757457,
-0.0240103286,
-0.0486332886,
-0.0089303581,
-0.0385144502,
-0.0294407215,
-0.0104743494,
-0.0091002295,
-0.0675216019,
0.089310281,
-0.048738379,
0.0220612679,
-0.0410332195,
-0.0537590869,
0.0127098914,
0.063744925,
0.014386368,
0.0334218182,
0.0450960696,
-0.0072284089,
-0.0616124757,
-0.0203310307,
0.0289339423,
-0.0205995739,
0.0359690972,
-0.0271071661,
0.0019732392,
0.0044647353,
-0.0530722328,
-0.0570795871,
-0.0652807355,
-0.0339892022,
0.0080989245,
0.0079816785,
-0.035224542,
-0.041244939,
-0.0384080335,
0.0150688393,
-0.0424905755,
-0.0117260814,
-0.0019434219,
-0.0403963961,
0.039342422,
0.0439640135,
-0.0477356054,
0.022140434,
-0.0240054801,
0.0363507234,
0.1063812152,
0.0097534368,
0.0290971417,
-0.0063739563,
-0.0151564777,
0.0127182081,
-0.0093883919,
0.0049653165,
0.0050653997,
0.0365227237,
-0.0497183129,
-0.0080099953,
0.0366199352,
-0.0052336692,
-0.0157825779,
0.0303810146,
0.0288972259,
0.0320416428,
-0.0147040049,
-0.0030768127,
-0.0519974977,
-0.0130531788,
0.0359552763,
0.0435721166,
-0.0005016167,
-0.0282461699,
-0.0238724556,
-0.1016153917,
-0.0002098761,
0.0118083609,
-0.0211520344,
-0.0411924869,
-0.0202769842,
-0.0227600522,
-0.0097862734,
0.0570637397,
-0.0139143262,
0.0080057941,
-0.019210374,
0.0037870619,
-0.0100339185,
-0.0419675224,
0.0100658499,
-0.0502601936,
0.0741891488,
0.0670621023,
0.0281261001,
-0.0344954878,
-0.0040831189,
0.0147712352,
0.0233675968,
-0.0273400806,
0.0183651224,
0.0420076586,
-0.0369772464,
-0.0251184516,
0.009397516,
0.0431608893,
0.0132297333,
-0.0109475655,
0.0298428833,
0.039882578,
-0.0050225765,
-0.0123733385,
-0.0249572732,
0.0042766822,
0.0225591492,
0.0620308556,
0.0005934604,
-0.0401870869,
-0.0323655456,
-0.0759117529,
-0.0073103202,
-0.0134346113,
-0.0648283586,
0.038640853,
0.0083656656,
-0.0291293096,
-0.0498514287,
-0.0217335746,
-0.021808533,
0.0085647199,
0.015698364,
-0.0025672689,
0.0121784098,
0.0255417619,
-0.0031570103,
0.0151025029,
-0.0225438979,
0.0465977602,
-0.0374229588,
0.0112008667,
0.0119791031,
-0.013872697,
-0.0061763381,
0.0090879314,
-0.0831232145,
-0.1095855907,
0.0267632194,
0.0550280251,
0.0129134925,
0.031910684,
-0.0427692123,
-0.0847821906,
0.0770107731,
0.0486429036,
-0.0323795713,
0.0196107198,
0.0708550513,
-0.0210268721,
0.0138057945,
0.0648486167,
-0.0382032022,
-0.0205794107,
0.0504268855,
0.0129816737,
-0.0198650453,
-0.015233892,
0.013771018,
0.0283796191,
0.05877956,
-0.0062677986,
0.0162709132,
0.0215360597,
0.0133985933,
-0.0205451511,
-0.0356039628,
-0.0121303489,
0.022459304,
0.0087957783,
0.0035950288,
-0.0000463011,
-0.0089998282,
0.0357841738,
0.0246623289,
0.0130426316,
0.0204755589,
0.0347374044,
0.0264564399,
0.0390991829,
0.0248627868,
-0.0185836535,
0.0607269406,
-0.0172562841,
0.0445910357,
0.0015259804,
0.0446911715,
0.0061146175,
-0.0193275157,
-0.0223354362,
0.0300666895,
-0.0701790601,
-0.0559578761,
0.002868162,
0.0512817241,
0.024202602,
-0.0048642755,
-0.00236873,
-0.0413487889,
-0.0223830249,
-0.0398523211,
-0.0343361348,
0.0002593239,
-0.0258764047,
0.0279486142,
0.0068428232,
-0.0242779329,
0.0513876677,
0.0728610456,
0.0261810869,
0.0682861432,
0.0161268525,
-0.0318843834,
-0.0286757909,
-0.0391266532,
0.0516415574,
-0.0025869114,
-0.0345717482,
-0.0283883661,
-0.0661481321,
-0.0981677175,
-0.0141611937,
0.0169591047,
0.0304897111,
-0.0021341238,
-0.0232821088,
0.038474448,
0.0317442827,
0.0646798089,
-0.0676289722,
0.0249003451,
-0.0055345846,
-0.0508677699,
0.0159360413,
-5.802884433e-33,
0.0203713011,
-0.0319661312,
-0.0420150235,
-0.0116647501,
0.0188820437,
0.0154768815,
0.0055202045,
0.0069083134,
-0.0311065521,
-0.0018640098,
-0.0060443929,
-0.0038944099,
-0.0107796062,
0.0368824266,
-0.0381860733,
-0.0473378301,
0.0058973776,
-0.0238157697,
-0.0115918582,
0.005607578,
0.0552362278,
0.0012973719,
0.0207448136,
-0.060892161,
0.0654136688,
0.0015745852,
-0.0371095836,
0.0339712575,
-0.0530218408,
0.0580024645,
-0.0170516372,
0.0388010666,
-0.0088394973,
0.0021751982,
0.011583535,
0.0417233817,
0.0066204066,
0.0051181195,
-0.0158794001,
0.0106679993,
-0.025482256,
-0.0311442632,
0.0447071977,
-0.0374130942,
-0.0234541576,
0.0036565564,
-0.0109963305,
-0.005237197,
-0.0172260422,
0.0071793525,
-0.033463493,
0.0104904911,
-0.0102635194,
-0.0229665898,
-0.0079164123,
-0.00098171,
0.0364920385,
0.0159453601,
-0.0515742451,
0.0188848507,
0.0214207228,
0.0194314942,
0.0522268787,
0.0070363549,
0.0090868296,
0.0807566121,
0.0498080887,
0.0083523765,
-0.033568915,
-0.0003184653,
-0.003342374,
0.0428871438,
0.0589904413,
0.0813029036,
0.0185477342,
-0.0015880498,
-0.0773648843,
-0.0137517452,
0.0389746428,
0.0376229845,
0.0259114485,
0.0039015564,
-0.0609269589,
-0.000972835,
-0.0291983522,
-0.0376767293,
-0.0263802707,
-0.0091919657,
0.003251578,
0.0097312927,
-0.0318488516,
-0.0183919948,
-0.010755226,
-0.0602657422,
-0.0143060852,
0.0205650497,
0.0144150387,
-0.0276585091,
0.0136367325,
0.0249616243,
-0.0175717454,
0.0104855914,
-0.0067979433,
-0.0564387366,
0.0270070378,
0.00322669,
0.0522869155,
0.0428819358,
-0.0355186351,
-0.0105505101,
-0.002234919,
0.0105029233,
0.0438353382,
0.0305741448,
0.0621790029,
-0.0357757211,
-0.0182193033,
0.0100829182,
0.0530401058,
0.040109843,
-0.017431885,
0.0074101901,
-0.0475226454,
0.0006628883,
0.0113325277,
-0.0105909631,
-0.0281187724,
0.0159610007,
0.051660262,
-0.0832494348,
0.0157373287,
-0.0523422211,
2.786e-7,
0.00206013,
0.0416797996,
0.0036194874,
-0.0213474315,
0.0384849571,
0.0751390159,
-0.0351454616,
0.0713587776,
-0.0230948702,
-0.0120953787,
-0.0305503905,
0.0021745551,
0.0663566589,
0.0296821166,
-0.0348962508,
-0.0018902841,
-0.0842615813,
0.0126353279,
-0.0508046709,
-0.0197254047,
0.0281191356,
0.128607735,
0.0279797502,
-0.025121564,
-0.0076560066,
-0.0806129873,
0.0257221721,
-0.0123747531,
-0.0245246254,
-0.0215499699,
0.0388992764,
0.0406345204,
0.0107699139,
-0.0089155314,
-0.0177458376,
0.0113585871,
-0.0352858454,
0.0406830497,
0.0126785012,
-0.0026504926,
-0.033759214,
-0.0339098908,
-0.0121008884,
-0.0210860316,
0.0723297819,
-0.0336760581,
-0.0421655364,
-0.0389520414,
0.0199553706,
-0.0197654124,
0.0661837682,
-0.0327455252,
-0.0377466865,
0.0049317451,
-0.0056897588,
0.0025873804,
0.0271523595,
-0.0845480934,
-0.0034087976,
-0.0149587272,
-0.0120649887,
-0.034940958,
0.013844748,
0.0329195373,
0.0210659523,
-0.0404326394,
-0.0126418378,
2.70578481e-34,
0.0062635173,
-0.065762423,
-0.0065610223,
-0.0218442995,
0.0373146161,
0.0065072845,
-0.0116860867,
-0.003516698,
0.0029637048,
-0.0438213535,
-0.0295778178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10830v1 | Fake News in Sheep's Clothing: Robust Fake News Detection Against LLM-Empowered Style Attacks | 2023-10-16T21:05:12 | 2023-10-16T21:05:12 | Jiaying Wu, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is commonly perceived that online fake news and reliable news exhibit
stark differences in writing styles, such as the use of sensationalist versus
objective language. However, we emphasize that style-related features can also
be exploited for style-based attacks. Notably, the rise of powerful Large
Language Models (LLMs) has enabled malicious users to mimic the style of
trustworthy news outlets at minimal cost. Our analysis reveals that
LLM-camouflaged fake news content leads to substantial performance degradation
of state-of-the-art text-based detectors (up to 38% decrease in F1 Score),
posing a significant challenge for automated detection in online ecosystems. To
address this, we introduce SheepDog, a style-agnostic fake news detector robust
to news writing styles. SheepDog achieves this adaptability through
LLM-empowered news reframing, which customizes each article to match different
writing styles using style-oriented reframing prompts. By employing
style-agnostic training, SheepDog enhances its resilience to stylistic
variations by maximizing prediction consistency across these diverse
reframings. Furthermore, SheepDog extracts content-focused veracity
attributions from LLMs, where the news content is evaluated against a set of
fact-checking rationales. These attributions provide supplementary information
and potential interpretability that assist veracity prediction. On three
benchmark datasets, empirical results show that SheepDog consistently yields
significant improvements over competitive baselines and enhances robustness
against LLM-empowered style attacks. | [
0.066457577,
0.0364481434,
-0.0091919601,
0.0471778736,
-0.0344862677,
0.0157926455,
0.0102468245,
0.0170841571,
-0.0151023734,
-0.044069618,
-0.0245039444,
-0.0241782349,
-0.0030174358,
0.0292665809,
0.030664267,
0.0191212259,
0.031963598,
0.0057654213,
0.0597729795,
-0.0095191477,
0.0654060468,
0.0418718755,
0.0105869276,
0.0253863037,
-0.0055593736,
-0.0039514047,
0.0280442219,
0.0574074835,
0.0204839148,
-0.0104784844,
0.015584738,
0.0540497005,
-0.0002621998,
0.075242281,
0.0000017597,
0.0010381986,
-0.0171920992,
-0.0083642621,
-0.0166480895,
0.0346956402,
0.0761686563,
-0.0687250793,
-0.0292269606,
0.0108897192,
-0.0271401107,
-0.02568065,
0.0049289498,
0.0798318461,
0.0930630043,
0.1443676054,
-0.0161175337,
-0.0190185886,
0.0423566513,
-0.0120736295,
0.0074383304,
-0.0252316426,
0.0430109464,
-0.0213408414,
-0.0490915403,
0.0580165386,
0.0353620984,
0.0070081134,
0.0034544908,
-0.0370876901,
-0.0441904739,
-0.0139659662,
-0.0553191304,
0.0083313202,
0.0046733445,
0.0348167792,
-0.0346853621,
-0.0575351194,
0.0273678899,
-0.0122760767,
0.019951215,
0.0473689996,
0.0033505445,
0.0465779863,
-0.0406923965,
-0.0065576918,
0.0056449296,
-0.0162335243,
0.0408590287,
0.0602174997,
0.0229902379,
0.0355201773,
-0.0109486077,
-0.0193025339,
-0.0376915336,
-0.0077147619,
-0.0171121117,
-0.0409070887,
0.0158940405,
-0.004851744,
-0.0046296334,
-0.0024421208,
-0.0935478434,
-0.0352422148,
0.0279169083,
-0.0603200495,
0.0141763482,
-0.0099940738,
0.0002285442,
0.0392080955,
-0.0302242097,
0.011043096,
-0.0343134254,
0.0118001923,
-0.0074036825,
-0.0000761159,
-0.0093731452,
0.0036573282,
0.0069846711,
-0.0020694332,
0.0165426899,
0.003111559,
-0.0187565554,
-0.0034288671,
-0.0194859896,
0.0256854165,
-0.0297575258,
-0.0050770212,
-0.0180827435,
-0.0307885185,
0.0097659063,
0.0300833173,
0.0271335673,
0.0241603032,
-0.011694164,
-0.0441930555,
-0.0143680517,
0.0352302864,
-0.0159577299,
-0.0159218963,
0.0057618003,
-0.0085459454,
-0.0005762986,
-0.0124643315,
-0.0720819235,
-0.0432607606,
-0.0188546311,
-0.0317241102,
0.0052593015,
-0.0644266605,
-0.0267129,
-0.0195490308,
0.0028786799,
-0.023813067,
-0.0171271693,
0.0351717472,
-0.0249985885,
0.0294226408,
0.0180205535,
-0.0166453663,
0.0452789553,
0.0239312686,
0.0104250824,
0.0780394599,
0.0061690877,
0.0965071544,
0.0507992022,
0.0141992653,
0.0220875032,
0.0235177036,
0.0297295637,
0.0465735383,
-0.0023508868,
-0.0113629242,
0.0353092588,
-0.0040616645,
0.0371301286,
0.0165320989,
-0.0038621097,
-0.0536861606,
0.1333916783,
-0.0573376454,
0.007706719,
-0.0026231343,
0.0641322359,
0.0300431084,
0.0289108921,
-0.0025606302,
-0.0531841367,
-0.0104369773,
-0.0581268482,
-0.0155570516,
-0.04112982,
0.0557878837,
-0.0080825742,
0.0003439485,
-0.0089208325,
0.0039708558,
-0.0099581294,
-0.0036733141,
-0.0215780847,
0.0230245423,
-0.0352886356,
-0.0158416945,
0.0101073012,
-0.0094497073,
-0.0009251261,
-0.0560752936,
0.023390945,
0.0395082571,
0.0508932658,
0.0206729509,
0.0322129205,
-0.0426585674,
0.0346861593,
0.0426816493,
0.0289980397,
-0.022262089,
-0.0290997978,
-0.0156308468,
-0.0077304421,
-0.0349805318,
0.0150467157,
-0.0049872403,
0.0380908512,
0.0169976596,
0.0121342642,
-0.007726917,
-0.0460986979,
0.0294823423,
0.0169137623,
-0.0332497843,
0.0077448147,
0.0204782691,
0.0017277529,
0.0052175005,
-0.0251055881,
0.0022290952,
0.0284734685,
-0.019124642,
-0.0185742043,
-0.0290253479,
-0.0026997793,
-0.0406224392,
-0.0011562894,
-0.016741557,
-0.0367399007,
0.0574291013,
-0.018216623,
0.0073786909,
-0.0119016161,
-0.0565591045,
0.0084337955,
-0.0437525995,
-0.0123871323,
-0.038336765,
0.0324381776,
-0.0088561727,
0.0639481321,
-0.0152662173,
-0.0043328963,
-0.0025451793,
-0.000071802,
-0.0088337697,
0.005796962,
-0.0207393598,
-0.0294666905,
-0.0132979201,
0.0174388587,
0.0171799883,
-0.015039403,
0.0105707478,
-0.0448319092,
-0.058548402,
-0.0071358662,
-0.0351416618,
-0.0009345118,
0.049920328,
-0.030322805,
-0.0113825193,
0.0071115806,
-0.0447048992,
-0.0190123785,
-0.0165085495,
0.0181913599,
0.0071120178,
-0.0331726335,
-0.0056951847,
0.0057736058,
0.0095239319,
-0.0149933472,
0.0488202572,
0.0119588394,
0.0081249764,
-0.0424989313,
-0.0271186251,
-0.0317440219,
-0.0160777159,
-0.0353112258,
-0.0181316342,
-0.0047707185,
-0.0091410149,
-0.0041317781,
0.0785811692,
0.0715050548,
0.0166918729,
0.0268150121,
0.0575388037,
0.0007058154,
-0.0315870643,
-0.0066025681,
0.0226787142,
-0.0395165123,
-0.0875262618,
0.0417530797,
0.0291410256,
0.0331142806,
0.0191991515,
0.000943989,
0.0561897419,
0.0148761319,
-0.0246006921,
0.0331689641,
-0.0346891098,
-0.0004488333,
-0.0093443561,
-0.0437959246,
-0.0444825999,
0.0873293206,
-0.0513404571,
0.0365639627,
0.0026306,
-0.0429993495,
-0.0186076313,
0.0037566789,
-0.0169008579,
0.0272408612,
0.0009402852,
-0.0011051507,
-0.0005533427,
-0.0245607775,
0.1001884863,
-0.0359082893,
0.0335276686,
-0.0183661431,
0.0278532002,
0.0291801784,
-0.0130138388,
-0.048294276,
-0.1211912185,
-0.000196458,
-0.0207475387,
0.0035889349,
-0.0424261652,
-0.0517315753,
-0.0200826749,
0.0500546806,
0.037772622,
-0.0498387478,
-0.0024734025,
0.0168212634,
0.0489338264,
0.0260095056,
-0.0309999287,
0.048768267,
-0.0091184927,
-0.0112084094,
0.0681304261,
0.001346429,
0.0341355763,
-0.0022063828,
-0.0043985141,
0.0095824292,
-0.0211715735,
-0.0170942135,
-0.0130494246,
0.0472042374,
-0.0575560257,
-0.0013035451,
0.0927926227,
0.0081773195,
-0.0177417919,
-0.0127420509,
0.0309306104,
0.0301394891,
0.0266843475,
0.0061751772,
-0.0586495735,
-0.0100449417,
0.0038972008,
0.0356687978,
-0.0450470075,
-0.0251644161,
-0.0171090495,
-0.0790544972,
0.0155782672,
-0.0061438144,
-0.0373387933,
0.0069090039,
-0.0728075579,
-0.0064171739,
0.0160495751,
-0.0156041458,
0.0018030226,
0.0002032914,
-0.0275238678,
-0.003255707,
0.0102920691,
-0.022542337,
-0.0091821598,
-0.0315859467,
0.0466203541,
0.0313248225,
0.028127024,
-0.025924731,
-0.0424461327,
-0.0120858401,
-0.0156895425,
-0.0271814726,
-0.0062343199,
0.0545752719,
-0.0519041903,
-0.0113922982,
-0.0383563489,
0.058635328,
0.024435997,
-0.0124816308,
0.0067995358,
0.0243309978,
0.0053969342,
-0.0718602315,
-0.0351646878,
-0.0049673175,
0.0372265205,
0.0642396435,
0.0317961574,
-0.032012701,
-0.0174064934,
-0.0483016595,
-0.0257481951,
-0.0255130548,
-0.0734917819,
0.0451454185,
-0.0165353883,
-0.048592899,
-0.063794665,
-0.0063193375,
-0.0476309434,
0.0152438385,
-0.0036554977,
-0.0194946807,
-0.0007301505,
-0.0392488353,
-0.0738953352,
-0.0088317413,
-0.0130130015,
0.0562615469,
0.0027648523,
0.0289569981,
0.0178050417,
-0.0342363939,
0.0036902134,
0.0448393337,
-0.0777493268,
-0.0340327956,
0.015976157,
0.0248734709,
0.0124360574,
0.0447528288,
-0.0170077626,
-0.0565368086,
0.0802647173,
0.054540541,
-0.0140873808,
0.0561744533,
0.0392833948,
-0.0339616574,
0.0331353247,
0.0359151363,
-0.015357893,
0.0303331502,
0.0339126624,
-0.0318610631,
-0.0055838637,
0.0350736082,
0.0212204885,
0.0157939065,
-0.0013396312,
0.0006788674,
0.0228944328,
-0.000418786,
-0.0127784861,
-0.0230007395,
-0.0440309718,
0.0059408611,
0.0151571389,
0.0344564505,
-0.0027336213,
-0.0138632199,
0.0430932529,
-0.0369980335,
0.0424188077,
-0.0573149063,
-0.0113979056,
-0.0178263504,
0.050601773,
0.0018018999,
-0.0053969775,
-0.0359557457,
0.0469892062,
0.0063190185,
0.0360584669,
0.0022537897,
0.0251541976,
0.0262145735,
-0.0305776261,
-0.0017412346,
-0.0080560548,
-0.0834962353,
0.0253694374,
-0.0334164649,
0.0110756317,
0.0008080257,
-0.0338096395,
0.0437156484,
-0.014609715,
-0.0136364093,
-0.0100244666,
-0.01929003,
0.0072527118,
-0.0479375534,
0.0013681267,
0.0120832277,
-0.0306838006,
0.0348087251,
0.0620132461,
0.0221266523,
0.0421887822,
0.0274169184,
-0.0671474338,
-0.0163190439,
-0.0284373704,
0.0141108045,
0.0398757309,
-0.0332864746,
-0.0495146178,
-0.0622420162,
-0.0562128425,
0.0367310159,
-0.0073293163,
0.016945608,
-0.008563688,
-0.0499574915,
0.084038265,
0.0127062583,
0.0033063041,
-0.0580234677,
0.0463048294,
0.0074066771,
-0.0289008077,
0.0209682994,
-6.16878056e-33,
0.0334158354,
-0.0452458858,
-0.0525523908,
-0.016930297,
0.0024308544,
0.0698909611,
-0.0046745832,
-0.0202413294,
-0.0506163538,
0.0433710478,
-0.0015335828,
0.0412642807,
-0.0154499291,
0.0362682603,
-0.063124232,
0.0042187176,
0.0393625386,
0.0012011754,
-0.0607547052,
0.0161146056,
0.0493610017,
-0.0173899531,
0.0474859737,
-0.070687443,
0.063843973,
-0.0522818901,
-0.0580470376,
0.0014750481,
-0.0109870397,
0.0543431565,
0.0136007797,
0.0382706746,
0.0375055894,
-0.0538472012,
0.0096801836,
0.0285080522,
-0.0271180402,
-0.0117710056,
0.0314722955,
-0.0071768216,
0.0086143818,
0.0089834891,
0.0647114292,
-0.0101870615,
0.0125620347,
0.0001683232,
0.0076881428,
-0.0203255229,
-0.0180625115,
-0.0371902809,
-0.0330755711,
0.0246619303,
0.0008840635,
0.0010293258,
-0.0373439379,
0.0240402818,
0.0294215642,
0.0192048214,
-0.0788614526,
0.0281025786,
-0.0356380455,
0.0085940603,
0.0268341042,
-0.010613326,
-0.0374551602,
0.0735335127,
-0.0192509107,
0.0754391626,
-0.0619796477,
0.0033140867,
0.0302082747,
0.0177845061,
0.0710598826,
0.1153416783,
0.0119523536,
-0.0432126895,
-0.0618157536,
0.0422146879,
0.0898951814,
-0.0256165341,
0.0261916462,
-0.0215486605,
-0.0364389606,
0.0085640717,
-0.0394779965,
-0.0236756541,
-0.034205161,
-0.0030759368,
-0.0010639756,
0.0309446342,
-0.0538289733,
0.0347888805,
-0.002923863,
-0.0539575927,
-0.0104995817,
0.0359775908,
-0.0675671101,
0.022584362,
0.0025148352,
0.0254416745,
-0.0190087743,
0.0096269697,
0.0524373464,
0.0048697609,
-0.0069852252,
-0.0235162061,
0.0841314495,
0.0309578832,
-0.0618108436,
0.0036718894,
-0.0060748514,
0.0329643302,
-0.0054923939,
-0.0193657614,
0.0427205861,
-0.0019080186,
-0.0164847225,
-0.0167389531,
0.0088108703,
-0.0089226617,
-0.0291740783,
0.0023335882,
-0.018051425,
0.03174299,
-0.012762554,
-0.0118108457,
-0.0213189349,
0.0030689936,
-0.0138220787,
-0.1031396985,
0.0143909771,
-0.0073987646,
2.614e-7,
0.0134959156,
0.0341499522,
-0.0152086513,
0.0370758846,
0.0398999043,
0.065307118,
0.0365811288,
0.0444194935,
-0.0525579229,
-0.0944189876,
-0.0219424218,
0.0267236549,
0.0240996126,
0.0389826111,
-0.0686487183,
0.0070024966,
-0.0708122551,
0.0140769798,
-0.0725641847,
-0.0074936897,
0.0129776848,
0.0815919489,
0.0317705125,
-0.0527885184,
0.0310959537,
-0.038716387,
0.068434827,
0.046927534,
-0.0178961158,
0.0032569137,
0.0735226348,
-0.0234813392,
0.0173093695,
0.0005667299,
-0.04383507,
-0.0050399797,
-0.0184946246,
0.0680995658,
0.0302997306,
0.0147081325,
-0.0037659397,
-0.0362776071,
0.0270379279,
-0.0853913128,
0.0935843959,
0.0214607567,
-0.0145705529,
-0.087721847,
-0.0638283715,
-0.0380329862,
0.0165086798,
-0.0378817618,
-0.0127991429,
0.0527717397,
-0.0026411333,
0.0139999893,
0.0030822135,
-0.0549578667,
-0.0370998904,
-0.0286789872,
-0.0442360602,
-0.0067102783,
-0.0324571468,
-0.0011245819,
0.0631199554,
-0.0532669798,
0.0465718061,
2.506728617e-34,
0.0426827297,
-0.0204855707,
-0.0062093725,
0.0077449414,
0.0195658542,
0.0482637957,
-0.0153323188,
0.0118106855,
0.0013210541,
-0.0442814492,
-0.0020959652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10803v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10803v2 | SD-HuBERT: Sentence-Level Self-Distillation Induces Syllabic Organization in HuBERT | 2023-10-16T20:05:36 | 2024-01-16T05:54:49 | Cheol Jun Cho, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Shang-Wen Li, Alan W Black, Gopala K. Anumanchipalli | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Data-driven unit discovery in self-supervised learning (SSL) of speech has
embarked on a new era of spoken language processing. Yet, the discovered units
often remain in phonetic space and the units beyond phonemes are largely
underexplored. Here, we demonstrate that a syllabic organization emerges in
learning sentence-level representation of speech. In particular, we adopt
"self-distillation" objective to fine-tune the pretrained HuBERT with an
aggregator token that summarizes the entire sentence. Without any supervision,
the resulting model draws definite boundaries in speech, and the
representations across frames exhibit salient syllabic structures. We
demonstrate that this emergent structure largely corresponds to the ground
truth syllables. Furthermore, we propose a new benchmark task, Spoken Speech
ABX, for evaluating sentence-level representation of speech. When compared to
previous models, our model outperforms in both unsupervised syllable discovery
and learning sentence-level representation. Together, we demonstrate that the
self-distillation of HuBERT gives rise to syllabic organization without relying
on external labels or modalities, and potentially provides novel data-driven
units for spoken language modeling. | [
-0.027046578,
0.0903383344,
0.0136211198,
0.0067985482,
-0.0315967649,
-0.0284576174,
0.0641745925,
-0.0375254452,
-0.0493328907,
0.0062832008,
-0.0544821359,
0.0002625474,
-0.0221313201,
0.0021601436,
0.0328001939,
-0.0383584984,
0.0659517571,
-0.0381246991,
0.0035596329,
-0.0246687327,
0.0292234514,
0.0074059376,
-0.0238001365,
0.0041951463,
-0.052727025,
-0.0140352426,
-0.0411271974,
0.0294463281,
-0.0223893989,
-0.0079109985,
-0.0259672571,
0.07083413,
0.022353502,
0.0294926018,
0.0000017702,
-0.0692719221,
-0.0077537727,
-0.03350747,
-0.0496510006,
0.061851792,
0.0293435548,
-0.0160215199,
-0.0072736214,
0.013255896,
-0.013666017,
0.0106159654,
0.0206311531,
-0.0454098359,
0.0540521033,
0.0482945852,
-0.0088433325,
-0.0529209971,
-0.022338178,
-0.0459106751,
-0.034129601,
0.0220702384,
-0.0028638174,
-0.0551022813,
0.0142132873,
-0.0261300672,
-0.0473710112,
0.0442926995,
-0.0016879903,
0.0128118442,
0.0214034207,
0.0140398135,
-0.0338871554,
-0.0199561808,
0.0006087394,
0.0353643261,
0.0323396549,
0.0000297635,
0.0324618146,
0.0227397233,
-0.0010260988,
-0.0051010894,
-0.0035795011,
-0.0142191602,
0.049318593,
0.0227685068,
0.0274889506,
0.0577700883,
0.0115713859,
-0.007146013,
-0.0906822905,
0.0469074883,
-0.0210251324,
-0.0369523205,
0.0046771979,
-0.0084869983,
-0.0046100402,
-0.0091000786,
0.0200711582,
0.0135495104,
0.0149986353,
-0.0113077415,
0.0108459685,
-0.0107781813,
0.0141142271,
-0.0067441305,
0.0222553443,
-0.0194656439,
-0.0362902172,
0.0025416114,
0.0192891788,
0.0375102088,
-0.0199858099,
0.0468355045,
-0.0527239926,
0.0242557451,
-0.0288124494,
0.0144176707,
-0.0834228545,
0.0465721823,
-0.0241779145,
-0.0176817179,
-0.0244642645,
0.003392186,
-0.0020774305,
-0.0508576483,
0.0288566146,
0.0046954635,
0.0083247144,
0.0126110269,
-0.0084033525,
0.0471540503,
-0.0662155896,
0.0048833028,
0.0214227438,
-0.0266808756,
-0.0296262205,
0.0044403919,
0.0485712029,
0.0065777656,
0.0232472122,
0.0152855916,
-0.000565142,
-0.0353732258,
-0.0190147106,
-0.0523045994,
-0.1175493672,
-0.0568819977,
-0.0050972216,
-0.0878075212,
0.0266434699,
-0.0049423445,
-0.0064148358,
-0.0159728937,
-0.0051663974,
-0.0386511162,
0.0176931992,
0.0527122766,
-0.0151506355,
0.0538637936,
-0.0192668121,
-0.0078019877,
0.0656019747,
0.0420380533,
0.0097058062,
0.0464681759,
0.0217833538,
-0.0246358663,
-0.0003524697,
0.0218541753,
0.0163611863,
0.0014968417,
-0.0375055894,
-0.0422614701,
-0.0825796276,
0.0481417365,
0.0604732521,
0.0720572621,
-0.029820893,
-0.0552743822,
0.0727333128,
0.075229995,
0.0633509979,
0.0157557782,
0.0137522677,
0.0568447411,
0.0105041508,
0.0443897918,
-0.0105971396,
-0.0091656568,
0.0757878348,
0.0463810042,
0.0362366401,
0.0250396412,
-0.0524099916,
-0.0408944152,
-0.0055646915,
-0.0177257471,
-0.0094064474,
0.0141691174,
0.0530761443,
0.0620441288,
0.0131718069,
0.0839343145,
0.0372068323,
-0.0531661622,
0.0121405935,
0.0056231278,
-0.0099914726,
0.0499003492,
0.0093450462,
-0.032036487,
-0.0178211629,
-0.0169592258,
0.0167587828,
0.0292121153,
-0.0078689028,
-0.020946404,
0.0585925579,
-0.0484723002,
0.0065408698,
0.0004890879,
0.0063428222,
0.0072316197,
-0.0329619683,
0.0016403541,
-0.0233800225,
-0.0564782843,
0.0448168144,
0.0170529224,
0.0297539718,
-0.0588681586,
0.0311732832,
0.0372621417,
0.0471942984,
0.0485814884,
-0.0238809679,
0.0222879015,
0.0494172238,
-0.0427214578,
0.0224376526,
0.0163120721,
-0.1143213212,
-0.0806616321,
0.0217510499,
0.0134717757,
0.0259576347,
0.020863058,
0.018222129,
-0.0508141033,
0.0543982647,
-0.0280892998,
0.0254744217,
-0.0556138083,
0.0057227244,
0.0422521345,
0.0528442711,
-0.0162982233,
0.0016158957,
-0.0124770366,
-0.0140640354,
0.0071658473,
0.0369695202,
0.0159702469,
-0.0184153803,
-0.0075910459,
0.0060461396,
-0.0562156998,
0.0323246941,
0.0052642017,
-0.0539012328,
0.0121287871,
-0.0422840267,
-0.0635772049,
-0.0188564342,
-0.0311178789,
0.0203106273,
0.0236039646,
0.0128817651,
-0.0113021797,
-0.0490777791,
0.0125974938,
-0.0316753611,
-0.0025209435,
0.0020079194,
0.0205712263,
0.0013778603,
-0.0392717235,
-0.0316362008,
-0.0364075154,
-0.0157004725,
0.0299162641,
-0.0715471581,
0.0179389864,
-0.0077359271,
-0.0114962598,
-0.0098116752,
0.0014611172,
0.0163245425,
-0.0683069751,
0.0110329799,
-0.0320293829,
0.052352719,
0.0386385396,
0.0169658903,
0.0245160274,
0.0433832817,
-0.0608437061,
0.0233986434,
0.015824696,
-0.0245063119,
0.0534244217,
-0.0298778284,
0.0364682898,
0.0196529906,
0.0854308754,
0.0211050473,
0.0138811897,
0.0050755539,
-0.0299002174,
-0.0219463687,
-0.0474918224,
-0.0230093021,
-0.0110521764,
-0.0485951416,
0.0093797129,
-0.0272713937,
-0.0348025821,
0.0235630181,
-0.0644355938,
-0.0364523344,
-0.0575725734,
-0.0467005149,
-0.0226703379,
0.0559577309,
-0.0218613651,
0.0304483585,
-0.0198759194,
-0.0491861477,
-0.0509129763,
0.0052099009,
-0.0033891802,
-0.0158865992,
0.0317665413,
-0.007228123,
-0.0290929768,
0.0137972804,
-0.0359397978,
-0.0303103812,
-0.0486431234,
-0.025023371,
0.0262783393,
0.0205662251,
-0.0120839989,
0.0108093005,
-0.0095974365,
-0.0038858789,
0.0369580723,
0.0082047405,
0.0197910052,
-0.0172916204,
0.0906847864,
-0.0121728871,
0.028145384,
0.0097704493,
-0.004833662,
0.0426615588,
0.0152341584,
0.0797817484,
0.0369234197,
-0.0385266617,
0.0199506916,
0.0086808847,
-0.0315428935,
0.0242233779,
-0.0062184953,
0.0573925823,
-0.0210130401,
-0.0148613155,
0.1260980964,
0.0027452295,
0.0268449262,
0.0253672432,
0.0362361148,
0.0525125489,
0.0216442309,
-0.0113675371,
-0.0313737132,
-0.0242394228,
0.0245955177,
-0.0044193463,
0.0443095453,
0.0199458972,
-0.0017612365,
-0.0075112302,
0.0218611043,
0.0177906007,
-0.0333291255,
0.0163766779,
-0.0255882815,
-0.0363844857,
-0.058135096,
0.0051729572,
0.0274346862,
-0.0427723266,
-0.0058987779,
0.0453421585,
-0.0606588461,
0.0356568322,
-0.0153580587,
-0.0537580326,
0.0213700905,
0.0282553099,
0.0394410007,
-0.0194395334,
-0.0063507645,
0.022346586,
-0.0769591406,
0.0025316647,
0.0273610782,
0.0587079786,
0.000314613,
-0.0425060391,
-0.0261049308,
0.0374197252,
-0.0558869168,
-0.018892061,
-0.0245421585,
0.0297880098,
0.0281656943,
-0.0100099426,
-0.0214942358,
0.0455386713,
-0.0230838023,
0.0484317318,
0.0456405543,
-0.0284436215,
-0.0509579293,
0.0247069318,
0.0513717905,
0.0093278745,
-0.0296458993,
0.0074646361,
0.0432884581,
-0.0320398584,
-0.0627051294,
-0.0618263446,
-0.0225643758,
0.0736800656,
-0.0294336453,
0.0134249236,
-0.0072236466,
-0.0053925286,
-0.0671581402,
0.0029960135,
0.0061318725,
0.006711015,
-0.0563344285,
-0.0206341036,
0.0220415518,
-0.0156803466,
-0.0296469852,
0.0302377734,
-0.0401541963,
-0.0727723613,
0.0812530518,
0.0095244469,
0.0182148945,
0.0267969295,
-0.025625065,
-0.0207540691,
0.1160182878,
0.0260759909,
-0.0344572216,
0.0320259854,
0.0395846888,
-0.0273914337,
-0.0231323056,
0.016109461,
0.0205851551,
0.0735577121,
-0.0424588695,
0.0309622213,
-0.0269394778,
-0.0198466852,
0.0334320366,
-0.022428209,
0.0610150434,
-0.0027733669,
0.04404746,
-0.0306946486,
0.0035987424,
0.0163340718,
0.0606940873,
-0.021660164,
-0.014559539,
0.0477097817,
-0.0040607755,
-0.019603407,
0.0184439532,
-0.0065429602,
-0.0373972766,
0.0223475341,
-0.0041559022,
-0.0047013774,
0.0064435946,
-0.0447986983,
0.0314944759,
0.0396427996,
0.043717958,
-0.0063757189,
0.0078429086,
-0.0140634812,
0.0259963777,
-0.0215089731,
-0.0033872481,
-0.0260280017,
0.0590924174,
-0.0518567339,
0.0268827286,
-0.0185067467,
0.0044269785,
0.0099412743,
-0.0267448779,
0.0313634053,
-0.0159360617,
0.0077638612,
-0.0531500988,
0.0053931577,
-0.07374309,
0.0375572443,
-0.030165635,
0.0363972299,
-0.0422382802,
-0.0222563259,
0.043084912,
0.0326856785,
0.0074572139,
0.0336294621,
0.0522558354,
-0.0344281755,
-0.0239830352,
-0.0430575944,
0.0269780364,
-0.045432698,
-0.0506689362,
-0.0500375219,
-0.0618650056,
0.0162806418,
-0.0038305509,
0.0470741689,
-0.0225905459,
0.0511484928,
0.0256587751,
-0.0276757311,
0.0059477654,
0.0325008929,
-0.0500047095,
0.0133739859,
-0.0218776483,
0.0602792501,
-6.246384493e-33,
-0.0121805789,
0.0321616717,
-0.0124468543,
-0.0186540987,
0.0014016493,
0.0251247138,
-0.0101417145,
0.0345770828,
-0.0068517206,
0.0365206264,
-0.0037885078,
0.0088355867,
0.0245437548,
0.032856375,
-0.0003456657,
0.0221437272,
0.0853413492,
-0.0295584276,
0.0050683036,
0.0066533727,
0.019038029,
0.0614637546,
0.0462587923,
-0.0319394059,
-0.0797597617,
-0.0245703664,
-0.0031047771,
0.0098147867,
0.0403055958,
0.0448011011,
-0.0352243185,
0.0407737605,
0.0033121808,
0.0111509021,
-0.0443798639,
0.0367444158,
-0.1172999218,
-0.035378512,
-0.0118286982,
0.0120287221,
-0.0497602299,
0.012923846,
0.0385221131,
-0.0257848203,
-0.0239755474,
-0.007145673,
-0.0010807,
0.0342530496,
0.0047354237,
-0.0187489316,
-0.0215321369,
0.0076468568,
0.002364605,
-0.0833213404,
0.090061225,
-0.0364360698,
0.0090168444,
-0.0391381904,
0.0372414552,
0.0354813896,
-0.015297723,
0.0836483911,
0.0264536515,
0.0122871408,
-0.0359666906,
0.048319649,
0.1223570555,
-0.0349661075,
0.0382666886,
-0.0295595042,
0.0631438121,
0.0821224675,
-0.0027738428,
0.015198552,
0.0341480896,
-0.0177757759,
-0.0109618464,
-0.0358122997,
0.0357339643,
-0.0138567826,
-0.0230584852,
0.0136450706,
-0.0134176053,
-0.0067439326,
-0.0375190862,
-0.0531472526,
-0.0156690385,
-0.0068836091,
0.0359995216,
0.0295430925,
-0.0070031607,
0.0181125663,
0.0383944884,
-0.0308973547,
-0.0086908229,
-0.0064108893,
-0.0044910773,
0.0022974524,
0.0256758928,
0.0044476949,
-0.0670411587,
0.010196764,
0.0367357284,
0.0381954312,
-0.026331732,
-0.0149989612,
-0.0021105369,
0.0283414982,
-0.0669842809,
0.00013839,
-0.0161824226,
0.0211316701,
-0.0412277766,
-0.0592792556,
0.063472487,
0.0132525638,
-0.0061154412,
0.0281394031,
0.0242688209,
-0.0069786981,
-0.0153970262,
0.0353954062,
-0.0205354393,
0.06989225,
0.0102772061,
-0.0292108934,
-0.000249998,
-0.0227376949,
0.0331181847,
-0.0425906479,
-0.0153404344,
-0.0187702756,
2.562e-7,
0.0118998559,
0.0249536447,
0.0730695426,
-0.0519519299,
0.0378939882,
-0.0015426826,
-0.0379543342,
0.0101742372,
-0.0528339781,
-0.0688204318,
0.0213571433,
0.0351793244,
0.036392305,
-0.0093718637,
-0.0874195844,
0.0278327931,
-0.0462687202,
0.0111126341,
-0.0510372296,
-0.0322533883,
-0.0174938254,
0.0927459523,
-0.0103906943,
-0.0317345746,
0.0034471429,
-0.0376749113,
0.0060448661,
0.0107072443,
0.0124235172,
0.0255839005,
-0.0334526785,
-0.0475629754,
-0.0156076653,
-0.0442292914,
-0.0181150138,
0.0481681488,
0.0225740466,
0.0281911008,
0.0091670733,
-0.0649479777,
0.0272678267,
0.0337698013,
-0.038804926,
-0.012236177,
0.0195291713,
-0.0033493293,
0.0031923982,
-0.0258356296,
-0.0467718542,
0.0332583524,
0.025123084,
0.0251468401,
-0.0075949021,
0.0318975151,
0.0135153066,
-0.0155015122,
-0.0210618693,
-0.0738201663,
-0.0228996947,
0.0219050273,
-0.0398673229,
0.0073763137,
-0.0265133344,
-0.0008223445,
0.0251889415,
-0.0429191813,
-0.028436983,
2.142719113e-34,
0.0142064597,
-0.0233013909,
0.0097443825,
0.0130711431,
-0.0178766567,
-0.0738691464,
-0.0301210675,
0.023337502,
0.0220368002,
-0.0040334794,
-0.0181697812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10788v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10788v2 | Self-Supervised Models of Speech Infer Universal Articulatory Kinematics | 2023-10-16T19:50:01 | 2024-01-16T08:09:15 | Cheol Jun Cho, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Alan W Black, Gopala K. Anumanchipalli | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) based models of speech have shown remarkable
performance on a range of downstream tasks. These state-of-the-art models have
remained blackboxes, but many recent studies have begun "probing" models like
HuBERT, to correlate their internal representations to different aspects of
speech. In this paper, we show "inference of articulatory kinematics" as
fundamental property of SSL models, i.e., the ability of these models to
transform acoustics into the causal articulatory dynamics underlying the speech
signal. We also show that this abstraction is largely overlapping across the
language of the data used to train the model, with preference to the language
with similar phonological system. Furthermore, we show that with simple affine
transformations, Acoustic-to-Articulatory inversion (AAI) is transferrable
across speakers, even across genders, languages, and dialects, showing the
generalizability of this property. Together, these results shed new light on
the internals of SSL models that are critical to their superior performance,
and open up new avenues into language-agnostic universal models for speech
engineering, that are interpretable and grounded in speech science. | [
-0.0302768089,
0.0763558969,
-0.0215628706,
0.0086826459,
-0.0201561637,
-0.0236355234,
0.0404236801,
-0.0513336323,
-0.0225966461,
0.0265245549,
-0.0965766162,
-0.0044471589,
0.0259931795,
0.0063234833,
0.0526995659,
-0.0055539468,
-0.0104918079,
-0.0989237428,
-0.0214816127,
-0.0661039054,
-0.0131353913,
-0.0144618759,
-0.0559342541,
0.0114490958,
0.0022368396,
0.013642529,
-0.0246219747,
0.0192949716,
-0.0017088167,
0.041609183,
-0.0349643491,
0.0312153623,
0.0358009487,
0.0172491334,
0.0000019526,
-0.0191430841,
0.0157091748,
0.0174697768,
-0.0452224165,
0.0279816166,
0.0142927235,
0.0255361851,
-0.0368662402,
0.0070077586,
-0.0130519215,
-0.0084952228,
0.0256376658,
-0.0734564736,
0.0210635066,
0.0491450056,
0.005188847,
-0.051443208,
0.0036148308,
-0.0260746162,
-0.0334549025,
0.0086696977,
0.0018899646,
-0.0099075669,
0.0041795573,
-0.004003956,
-0.0713042766,
0.0874480829,
-0.0079671247,
0.0085852919,
0.0220084004,
0.002805273,
-0.0150970975,
-0.0500565097,
-0.0015409472,
0.0469275862,
0.0557133891,
-0.0056773014,
0.0287995413,
0.0470408611,
0.0194447245,
0.0528632104,
-0.0323829018,
0.0120487688,
0.0710977241,
-0.0333964117,
-0.0341363698,
0.0257636495,
-0.000894369,
-0.0432163402,
-0.0047878437,
0.0707382113,
0.0028354388,
0.0030596263,
0.011930624,
-0.0393004119,
0.0636100173,
0.0184058379,
0.0474931858,
0.0371604115,
0.0344416536,
-0.011024937,
-0.0088992938,
-0.0615369938,
-0.0318888314,
-0.0402530693,
0.0315500535,
0.0249755494,
-0.0419513285,
-0.0293815453,
-0.0448258966,
0.0462570004,
-0.0432467535,
0.0525281914,
-0.0092618531,
0.0200260039,
-0.0178818852,
-0.0352383777,
-0.0258487239,
-0.0018531432,
-0.0303518474,
0.014033854,
-0.0267308019,
0.0148846479,
-0.0673961341,
-0.0101161981,
-0.014151358,
0.039776925,
-0.0456793047,
-0.052821815,
0.0045129964,
0.0306908991,
0.0129478704,
0.0574451126,
-0.02106327,
-0.0262743961,
-0.0022212097,
0.0299683344,
0.0340642482,
0.0164679848,
0.0346978977,
0.0579866506,
0.0170481186,
0.0436322056,
0.04434219,
0.0061065555,
-0.0709232017,
-0.0172591135,
0.0070301276,
-0.0602827407,
0.0044947416,
0.0198975354,
-0.0001600613,
-0.0475329496,
-0.0306904987,
-0.0473753475,
0.0134356283,
0.0370238945,
0.0337795094,
0.0874383748,
0.0702958331,
-0.022545917,
-0.000548725,
0.0207207222,
0.0304525662,
-0.0186317936,
-0.0015729911,
-0.0894576013,
0.0035744207,
0.0680385381,
0.0532833114,
-0.0115968799,
-0.0494680442,
-0.0516903773,
-0.0117793288,
0.0430077687,
0.0756298378,
-0.0211308543,
0.0243883356,
-0.0822280571,
0.0747687966,
0.0817262679,
0.0031913761,
0.0276173707,
0.0633392036,
-0.0172667205,
0.0133093353,
0.0035564618,
-0.0034315621,
0.0243014488,
-0.0101004988,
0.0072362702,
-0.0218418557,
0.0463609658,
-0.0451348759,
-0.028743282,
0.0261761546,
-0.0191113576,
-0.013300552,
0.0238880906,
0.0578585304,
0.0536917895,
0.0215338059,
-0.0164514054,
-0.0152768698,
-0.0444053747,
-0.0056495457,
-0.0052933325,
-0.0755455047,
-0.0266424473,
-0.0245157946,
-0.0291162431,
-0.0444361344,
-0.0103826523,
-0.0254668053,
0.0467964634,
-0.0108960783,
0.0089893378,
0.0092159128,
0.0034060199,
-0.0090754051,
0.018069841,
0.0085898861,
0.0305211581,
-0.0685051456,
0.0375911817,
-0.0153779825,
-0.0253581405,
-0.0109334318,
-0.0373244584,
-0.0840906203,
-0.0261342805,
0.0534907356,
0.0370243154,
0.0332883745,
0.014256442,
-0.0046395403,
0.0160624888,
0.015437766,
-0.0320848152,
-0.0039867875,
0.0642341971,
-0.0451986156,
-0.0329933725,
0.0339174643,
-0.0228269305,
0.0148131093,
0.0251025241,
0.0557401702,
-0.1080016717,
0.1047995761,
-0.0103776986,
0.0348851122,
-0.0020174927,
0.0395925976,
0.0348559953,
-0.0182016883,
0.0320704579,
-0.0595420338,
0.0513029695,
-0.0296511836,
0.0180938765,
0.0305329822,
-0.0015979384,
-0.0476139672,
-0.0292406883,
0.0201894064,
-0.0294401664,
0.0248807687,
0.0062973839,
-0.0275405273,
0.0260265078,
-0.0169032421,
-0.0448908433,
-0.0241555981,
-0.0043189921,
0.025195105,
0.0012435894,
0.0040686238,
-0.0057601011,
-0.0482594259,
-0.0325002596,
-0.0234052334,
-0.0374145657,
-0.0336101465,
-0.0108251786,
-0.0098846573,
-0.0258985814,
-0.0201698747,
0.0019166678,
-0.0064009223,
-0.0096542612,
-0.0356235839,
0.0183065664,
-0.0052379156,
0.0103188241,
0.0135509195,
0.0116090868,
-0.0001159002,
-0.0504049659,
-0.0216692816,
-0.0141396765,
0.0064341021,
0.0423561968,
-0.0322527401,
-0.006969112,
0.0334953517,
-0.0472127944,
-0.0386851579,
0.0027553714,
-0.0211320519,
0.0442887358,
-0.0333341174,
0.0054337918,
-0.0259886682,
0.0553535186,
0.0454810634,
-0.0101787215,
-0.0531731956,
-0.024854131,
-0.0165255778,
-0.0316831656,
-0.0162534378,
-0.0295551196,
-0.0302747823,
0.0058631478,
-0.0237943418,
-0.0214409642,
0.0286931172,
-0.0390500836,
-0.0617779344,
0.0516805463,
-0.0340855829,
-0.0205762368,
0.0627608672,
0.007162611,
-0.0071149808,
0.031300433,
-0.0133286044,
-0.0381559506,
0.01887157,
0.0577428713,
-0.0370413736,
0.00453396,
-0.0686277896,
-0.0045283535,
0.0008874546,
-0.0442792028,
0.0025460606,
0.0030833767,
0.0089288699,
0.0059747319,
-0.0438740738,
-0.0552616306,
0.0549380779,
0.003993399,
0.0412725993,
0.044126071,
-0.0318570919,
0.0346367061,
-0.0091553973,
0.011424521,
0.0310173109,
0.0482021309,
-0.0654937401,
0.0011960798,
0.0296537112,
-0.0444793142,
0.0422106832,
0.0407118089,
-0.0730872452,
0.0409282893,
0.0258877743,
0.0137378601,
-0.0255222823,
-0.0301785078,
0.0399814174,
-0.0025308058,
-0.01125661,
0.0621428527,
-0.0340361819,
0.0253994204,
0.0036960265,
0.011433892,
0.0342623368,
-0.0124479514,
0.0067524146,
-0.0290717911,
-0.0006936418,
0.0384735614,
0.0205981135,
0.0244476646,
0.0195678901,
0.0177091006,
-0.1005169228,
0.0486741439,
0.0439627096,
-0.0482123047,
-0.0280691534,
0.0014751117,
0.0078150267,
-0.0370112024,
-0.0029575808,
0.0160079543,
-0.0124449367,
-0.0004449018,
0.0506714024,
-0.1183581948,
-0.0324376933,
-0.0027369852,
-0.0079974802,
0.0709309578,
0.029407436,
0.0211843457,
-0.045484826,
-0.0252332222,
0.0227333847,
0.034382239,
0.0078637348,
-0.005678819,
0.0307362676,
0.051437296,
-0.0433739685,
0.0096737714,
0.0807915106,
-0.0577310175,
0.0429182835,
-0.0141055584,
0.0783687532,
-0.0140193496,
0.0323246755,
-0.0165304188,
0.003637101,
-0.0295244884,
0.0446560904,
0.0055752369,
-0.057206735,
-0.0262830704,
-0.0122889765,
0.0250697732,
0.043294359,
-0.0800844505,
0.0169518776,
0.0373833776,
-0.0883217379,
-0.0252748653,
0.0119911255,
-0.0038948965,
0.0757547095,
0.032650888,
-0.0161673129,
0.0146475248,
-0.0171437282,
-0.0259132218,
-0.0060894508,
0.0138123082,
0.0188186672,
-0.00003529,
-0.0478347056,
0.0729161724,
-0.0377009958,
0.0002678093,
0.0072260401,
-0.004179264,
-0.0708162859,
0.0382073112,
0.0358634815,
0.0156610422,
0.079700686,
-0.0205742884,
-0.0234312937,
0.0564078428,
0.0060036541,
-0.0594013333,
0.040410053,
0.0623675101,
-0.0083495695,
-0.0098763444,
0.0156419501,
-0.0099741546,
0.0434335507,
-0.0249735788,
-0.0144405328,
-0.0177529212,
-0.0619433373,
0.0190323647,
0.0074407435,
0.0419023745,
0.0164381992,
0.0008157183,
-0.0146849891,
0.012123554,
-0.0203438811,
0.041596245,
-0.0386347137,
-0.016859062,
0.0550170131,
0.0291415602,
0.0023353372,
-0.0225084201,
0.008635954,
-0.0098959859,
0.0156031819,
0.0405953079,
0.0160889253,
0.068669267,
-0.047786653,
0.0403264537,
0.0271897819,
0.0456588306,
0.0020427401,
0.0323508792,
0.008672514,
-0.0395479649,
0.004947369,
0.0041097403,
0.0152532933,
-0.010751049,
-0.0595913194,
-0.0193524882,
0.0038155681,
-0.024586264,
0.011099074,
-0.0288915485,
0.0406039208,
-0.0196884535,
0.0204037745,
0.0002259014,
0.0221401397,
-0.0649658293,
0.0446833409,
0.0013308233,
-0.019594498,
0.0015524089,
0.0135476515,
-0.0080498122,
0.0098605156,
0.0097610271,
-0.0279281959,
0.0190440658,
-0.0290215909,
-0.0313103981,
0.0238842461,
-0.0453658551,
-0.0198685303,
-0.0215812419,
-0.0368338078,
-0.0612740517,
-0.0038492596,
-0.009132538,
0.0258953627,
-0.0492802896,
0.0484992042,
0.0221652817,
-0.0554910488,
-0.0140129384,
0.0064572538,
-0.0146895889,
0.0164357647,
0.0136230392,
0.0102579463,
-5.546729153e-33,
-0.0485585369,
-0.000759334,
0.0271382295,
0.0378801897,
-0.0068536033,
-0.0132496413,
-0.0283235498,
0.0171675533,
-0.0104260854,
0.0369312987,
0.0093776612,
-0.0263956916,
0.0106803467,
0.0034278382,
0.0563028716,
0.0360147841,
0.032315731,
-0.0505969189,
0.0430391058,
-0.0239893422,
0.031076353,
0.0425909609,
0.053193517,
-0.0647542775,
-0.0097599924,
0.0328648947,
-0.0030527343,
-0.036301665,
-0.0014571771,
-0.0188978706,
-0.0242763218,
0.0205382723,
-0.0193045884,
0.0022612498,
-0.0138046434,
-0.0210027825,
-0.0575195886,
-0.0376609154,
-0.0212535858,
0.0490663238,
-0.0208747052,
0.00750713,
0.0886827409,
-0.0044295485,
-0.0795273334,
-0.0184272379,
0.0264874753,
-0.0243771411,
0.0445717461,
-0.0118407756,
-0.0210849661,
0.0139425937,
-0.0384107456,
-0.0658143982,
0.0764170513,
0.0534976423,
-0.0450792722,
-0.0611103885,
0.005451405,
0.0372682661,
-0.0424425714,
0.0389965102,
0.08996436,
0.008699703,
0.029885307,
0.010552844,
0.0969644487,
-0.0369946808,
0.0292088706,
-0.0211541485,
0.0677409917,
0.0957688019,
0.0127517506,
0.0211605132,
-0.0009146964,
0.0266926996,
-0.0024199917,
-0.0054424871,
-0.016600294,
-0.0158611592,
-0.0278656576,
0.0365992785,
-0.0350014307,
-0.012345219,
-0.0548520796,
-0.0696920604,
0.0390048996,
0.0156875532,
0.0248402022,
-0.0352076925,
0.0247027855,
0.0048420462,
0.035392087,
-0.0316367038,
-0.0222117361,
-0.0428443588,
-0.0349998251,
0.0215550922,
0.0217791907,
0.0229272936,
-0.0039579771,
0.0211850349,
-0.013604261,
0.0747284666,
0.0496249683,
-0.0019448642,
-0.0438355841,
0.0647664443,
-0.0578678213,
-0.0356706977,
-0.0319843031,
-0.0200552978,
0.0129246302,
-0.038526535,
0.0646016002,
0.0081185829,
-0.0210853424,
0.0476866253,
-0.0431156196,
0.022880774,
-0.0179954395,
-0.0085775126,
-0.0253527146,
0.0252869744,
-0.0260446817,
-0.0030531194,
0.0487227403,
-0.0293854494,
0.018999977,
-0.0417747721,
-0.0095046731,
-0.0222174339,
2.801e-7,
0.0136739407,
-0.021470163,
0.0794137195,
-0.0067081023,
0.0296517164,
0.0284671467,
-0.0767314881,
-0.01719076,
0.0197965372,
-0.0329395793,
0.0347312242,
0.0253274068,
0.0696384236,
-0.0100601427,
-0.0208182931,
0.020526208,
-0.0609207675,
0.0325606577,
-0.003871138,
0.0056295074,
-0.0643801242,
0.0011449568,
-0.0303703099,
-0.0498269349,
0.0101689799,
0.003600206,
0.043484956,
-0.0329943113,
0.039293956,
-0.0097311577,
-0.0298544168,
-0.0561823621,
-0.0104719866,
0.0019767517,
-0.039580375,
0.0613366552,
-0.003353447,
0.0277770199,
-0.0249592829,
-0.0290217269,
0.0348583199,
0.0421347991,
-0.0188856553,
-0.0101211062,
0.0459126011,
-0.0080210818,
-0.0138202989,
-0.0494381711,
-0.0258095544,
0.0374655202,
0.0496091619,
0.0076166489,
0.0375888087,
-0.0064045181,
0.0267295483,
-0.0390308388,
-0.0352439657,
-0.0133696226,
-0.01257296,
0.0229660366,
-0.0989856794,
0.0223638378,
-0.0286152735,
0.0042078006,
-0.0086520445,
-0.0225561634,
-0.0110056447,
2.007348081e-34,
-0.0104270885,
-0.0085754609,
0.0442154482,
0.0237890165,
-0.0445914716,
-0.0359022059,
0.0342766158,
0.0620678626,
0.0556037202,
0.0149223041,
-0.0560904332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10781v1 | BanglaNLP at BLP-2023 Task 1: Benchmarking different Transformer Models for Violence Inciting Text Detection in Bengali | 2023-10-16T19:35:04 | 2023-10-16T19:35:04 | Saumajit Saha, Albert Nanda | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the system that we have developed while solving this
shared task on violence inciting text detection in Bangla. We explain both the
traditional and the recent approaches that we have used to make our models
learn. Our proposed system helps to classify if the given text contains any
threat. We studied the impact of data augmentation when there is a limited
dataset available. Our quantitative results show that finetuning a
multilingual-e5-base model performed the best in our task compared to other
transformer-based architectures. We obtained a macro F1 of 68.11\% in the test
set and our performance in this shared task is ranked at 23 in the leaderboard. | [
0.0482891165,
0.0081083411,
-0.0202465821,
0.0517992638,
-0.0117068011,
0.0393267833,
0.0335024148,
0.0018621816,
-0.0183221344,
-0.0136875231,
-0.017503012,
-0.0401032902,
-0.0175802596,
0.0668449551,
-0.0157507267,
-0.045748122,
0.012912767,
0.0045609083,
-0.0005040137,
0.010372472,
0.0328464843,
0.0100961328,
0.0101960385,
0.007718442,
-0.0815705955,
0.0310068931,
-0.0151722198,
-0.0144762527,
0.0515253507,
-0.0092483209,
0.0081074191,
0.0676190928,
-0.0072275405,
0.0562029704,
0.0000021248,
-0.0399439931,
-0.0260355063,
-0.0095219817,
-0.0071284133,
-0.0715524852,
0.0627835467,
-0.0784859732,
-0.0432284772,
0.0025116522,
-0.0261280891,
-0.0153569635,
0.0822342113,
0.1263573766,
0.0579956211,
0.0838635564,
-0.0205548126,
-0.1131129637,
0.0504578725,
-0.0068772053,
-0.0144788679,
0.0292030182,
0.039293889,
-0.0295629427,
0.0016258591,
0.026724739,
-0.0369391553,
0.0194305424,
0.0534726232,
-0.0186190102,
-0.0112910895,
-0.0138016427,
-0.0076894714,
-0.0172350518,
0.0127256885,
0.0226109233,
-0.1006127149,
-0.0056186472,
-0.003534779,
-0.0193490051,
-0.0139165977,
-0.0377197675,
0.0086415708,
0.0261857398,
-0.0124546587,
0.0077198739,
0.0065011731,
0.053129714,
0.0161077697,
0.0322870687,
-0.0057522566,
-0.0115432115,
-0.0248737521,
-0.0175403096,
-0.0154258721,
-0.0076683718,
-0.0073989742,
0.0163001493,
0.0225817952,
-0.0048524109,
0.0018989614,
-0.0053773453,
-0.0467934422,
-0.0760977268,
-0.0011446364,
-0.067299448,
0.0073829009,
0.0530043356,
-0.0569289103,
0.0100326473,
-0.0257632062,
0.0569464676,
-0.0453130789,
0.0204416346,
-0.0342343897,
0.0104662972,
-0.006927467,
-0.0105682556,
-0.0167940799,
-0.0093405554,
-0.0083936295,
0.012435223,
-0.0750921071,
0.0041703824,
-0.0221412517,
-0.0409776196,
0.018875761,
-0.0197003726,
-0.0325818174,
-0.0141436774,
0.0482103676,
0.0004419439,
-0.0068763997,
-0.0141761554,
-0.0359874964,
-0.1095574275,
0.0066800695,
0.0193128809,
-0.0226279497,
-0.0350462794,
0.01275515,
0.0382076539,
-0.0281146709,
-0.0471936576,
-0.0628025234,
0.0272223707,
-0.0557293147,
-0.053457737,
0.0073268437,
-0.0564098731,
0.0133803636,
-0.0127080176,
-0.0064039431,
-0.0088478066,
-0.0020185693,
0.0114336815,
-0.0032856888,
0.1070736796,
0.0148572288,
-0.0230886806,
0.057745073,
0.0397210717,
0.0255275518,
0.0898523256,
0.009735371,
0.0251917094,
0.0121828225,
0.003346028,
0.0172524378,
0.0601568408,
-0.0302779004,
-0.0061869211,
-0.0094489455,
-0.0198264029,
-0.0131568182,
-0.0173946749,
-0.0082636969,
0.0243037883,
-0.0085854707,
-0.0484396741,
0.0632893443,
0.0552133024,
-0.002779068,
0.0592921786,
0.0013490912,
0.0164478905,
-0.024407031,
-0.0136825386,
-0.0176408347,
0.0111964932,
-0.0302800853,
-0.0309007168,
-0.0381063148,
0.0636055693,
-0.0310637709,
-0.0082781622,
0.0017588076,
-0.0339643508,
0.0024732009,
-0.0285799075,
0.0710393488,
0.0342263803,
-0.0256464407,
0.0268190708,
0.040563453,
-0.0391776115,
-0.0159090888,
-0.0709516481,
0.0156047866,
0.0172464419,
0.0078516947,
-0.0112880962,
-0.0054852311,
-0.0718346983,
0.0307415109,
0.0700357482,
-0.0394556038,
0.0179624688,
0.0149449296,
-0.0445111841,
-0.0231424011,
0.0200338978,
-0.0039028509,
0.0036430045,
0.0213544425,
-0.0023598194,
0.0089293923,
0.0526468419,
-0.0677821562,
0.0298179891,
0.0144459484,
0.0133359516,
0.0047977073,
0.036660444,
0.0401079915,
-0.004350258,
-0.0340416543,
-0.0621004403,
0.0243237577,
-0.0556555912,
-0.0256815515,
0.0201637782,
-0.0377262607,
0.0098070828,
0.023074409,
-0.0596815571,
0.0176643711,
0.0402418822,
-0.0140584921,
-0.0039848606,
-0.0103209838,
-0.0469494462,
-0.0451229215,
-0.028578354,
0.0321672671,
-0.0504147038,
0.0264889058,
-0.0090209534,
0.0597100109,
-0.0191605948,
-0.021741759,
0.001219632,
-0.0159758944,
0.0735577345,
-0.0083434917,
-0.0834379047,
0.0062498827,
-0.0009430241,
-0.0044465815,
0.017885033,
0.0377720892,
0.0073179137,
-0.0391542614,
-0.0192193892,
-0.0299116522,
-0.0422527716,
-0.0398509912,
0.0284686498,
0.0392204188,
-0.0113232322,
-0.0217633191,
-0.0012945854,
-0.013666423,
0.0554075912,
0.003932579,
-0.0051006987,
-0.0268068332,
0.0219566599,
0.0223893505,
-0.0168057997,
-0.0034610853,
0.0679894239,
0.0090105701,
-0.0804053918,
-0.003353867,
-0.0127982972,
0.0479372442,
0.027807245,
-0.0401732586,
-0.0910979733,
0.010291433,
-0.0016971237,
0.0196484979,
0.0812300146,
0.0587965138,
0.0424287356,
0.0237682089,
0.0152430134,
-0.004333301,
-0.0026001902,
-0.0369371884,
-0.0067437771,
-0.0243002865,
-0.0249484722,
-0.0327797048,
0.058879476,
-0.0096164504,
0.0223544203,
-0.041169215,
-0.0283670425,
-0.0088511631,
-0.034201432,
-0.0338863768,
-0.048377268,
-0.0485183783,
0.0177249797,
-0.015303256,
-0.040589191,
0.0487969182,
0.009652419,
0.014525881,
-0.0202888753,
0.0178573914,
-0.0030456102,
0.0298803225,
0.019034991,
0.0409895666,
-0.0108377319,
-0.0156034529,
-0.0028732542,
0.0063047479,
0.0141910687,
-0.0304715112,
0.0278944578,
0.0064541227,
-0.0063938466,
-0.0096558714,
-0.0487103201,
-0.0627495795,
-0.0232002418,
0.0030530933,
-0.0169273671,
0.0195970722,
-0.0178455617,
-0.0532871522,
0.0630625188,
0.0419364125,
0.0275951233,
-0.0273492131,
-0.0077479985,
0.0052494309,
0.0157507993,
0.0226083267,
-0.0179022662,
0.0210164879,
-0.0198000185,
-0.0119547956,
0.038385462,
-0.0472749397,
-0.032183636,
-0.0633099228,
0.0166548658,
0.0380217806,
0.0130723771,
0.0067650881,
-0.0265732501,
-0.0091519291,
-0.0039059864,
-0.0289985668,
0.09129107,
0.0009053728,
-0.0062070135,
-0.0035911619,
-0.0513024293,
0.0023495217,
-0.011202231,
0.0128601706,
-0.0450636744,
0.0003405965,
0.0000950868,
-0.0013807596,
-0.0375471748,
-0.0110129807,
0.012036778,
-0.0605689734,
0.0237617046,
-0.0132457511,
-0.0151685709,
-0.0767605007,
0.016206,
0.0027905919,
-0.0433728844,
0.0414150134,
0.0021136436,
0.0022487065,
-0.0561856367,
0.0210444033,
-0.0073569678,
-0.043564599,
-0.0282098353,
-0.0439866781,
-0.0301736202,
0.0429217331,
0.0055825873,
-0.0539667308,
-0.0045814877,
-0.0168753732,
0.0420564823,
-0.0096750921,
0.0056800316,
0.0665979609,
-0.0048311707,
-0.0430764258,
-0.0081190234,
0.0465833843,
0.0382944494,
-0.0180504564,
-0.0145443045,
0.0438914672,
0.0015314131,
0.0270658303,
-0.0040289965,
0.0051368377,
-0.0127430949,
0.0271091461,
0.0093321735,
-0.0517774001,
0.0129199345,
-0.0388193205,
-0.0235111825,
-0.035593953,
-0.1038985923,
0.0246550217,
-0.0363100208,
-0.1225520372,
0.0014851724,
-0.0231690332,
-0.001997439,
0.0557672568,
0.0138902636,
-0.0510914102,
0.0186626017,
-0.0058675059,
-0.0542030595,
-0.0049086059,
0.0043961252,
0.0357701406,
-0.0479983576,
0.0575396195,
0.0027008473,
-0.0501889847,
-0.0243649445,
0.0102616269,
-0.0861922577,
-0.0259116273,
0.0887948945,
0.066457957,
0.0175640322,
-0.0132189952,
-0.0404068567,
-0.056968037,
0.081857115,
0.069723472,
-0.0318655111,
-0.0161987208,
0.0467586257,
-0.0666638762,
-0.0144700045,
0.0076347711,
0.0044533424,
0.0329006985,
0.0542943068,
-0.0374367051,
-0.0602241904,
-0.0016257995,
-0.0041901749,
-0.0284458268,
0.0471946523,
-0.0209799223,
-0.0691063181,
-0.0313691311,
0.0032599645,
0.0095637795,
-0.0096859625,
0.0096751982,
0.0109401718,
0.0537058637,
0.0259419139,
0.002397004,
0.0060550505,
-0.0182977058,
-0.0055133919,
-0.0329886898,
0.0503913835,
0.0343045257,
0.0285078809,
0.0554156676,
0.0213157479,
-0.0158347897,
0.0052282587,
0.0289085582,
-0.0240982324,
-0.0023878589,
0.0551462509,
0.0061322786,
0.015733039,
0.0262561738,
0.0635638982,
-0.0063724099,
0.0363759957,
-0.0593499728,
-0.0407040156,
0.0231658388,
-0.0372619927,
0.0491455682,
-0.025740765,
-0.0037867001,
-0.0249169134,
0.0044986494,
-0.0129434876,
-0.0312774591,
0.0364211164,
0.0025035169,
0.009638275,
0.0188883897,
0.0492153727,
-0.0610117503,
0.0115959998,
0.0741261467,
-0.0320570283,
-0.0388634391,
-0.0402845815,
0.0373880714,
0.0071318601,
-0.0295474865,
0.013392657,
-0.0241856687,
-0.0234882403,
0.0443966053,
-0.0394263454,
0.0118116299,
0.0166377071,
0.0383106582,
0.0158419088,
0.0193907451,
0.0157167502,
-0.0165464059,
0.0088124396,
0.0274332277,
0.0076666726,
0.0107172923,
-5.818320511e-33,
-0.0146185327,
-0.0208389368,
-0.0170271508,
0.0052453601,
-0.0045493091,
0.0057857037,
0.0176106058,
0.0058618127,
-0.0294285342,
0.0137438281,
-0.0131493583,
0.0161176864,
0.0186510086,
0.0066042696,
0.0030589581,
-0.037003167,
0.0297128055,
0.03286428,
-0.0016210499,
-0.017459115,
0.0591871068,
0.0390393846,
0.0839606449,
-0.0575238205,
-0.0217731446,
-0.0067817606,
-0.0501915254,
0.0051257322,
-0.0187152848,
0.0741946027,
-0.0260560289,
0.0482820943,
0.0319945291,
-0.0611233003,
-0.0013088192,
0.0299702883,
-0.0475543849,
0.0348198675,
-0.0121334139,
0.095571503,
0.0029116448,
-0.0218949895,
0.0296248645,
-0.0176498201,
-0.017209027,
-0.0181710627,
0.0088086464,
-0.0466891937,
0.0185987446,
-0.0404555611,
-0.0652488396,
0.0264349692,
-0.0007652175,
-0.000900212,
0.0188558009,
0.0285874512,
0.0215424448,
-0.0031581202,
-0.084173739,
0.0184024852,
0.0652020425,
0.0205712952,
0.0251468047,
0.0378085375,
-0.0304411165,
0.0288667623,
-0.0131602716,
-0.0504553355,
0.0070252838,
-0.0106653906,
0.0607511476,
0.0240531918,
0.0670622438,
0.0804526657,
0.0490620546,
-0.0314008445,
-0.0634934977,
0.0354544669,
0.0485190451,
0.0866898745,
0.0764914751,
-0.0066366014,
-0.049438566,
-0.0188234281,
0.0376772471,
-0.0198152103,
-0.0211367887,
-0.0381917544,
0.0268110093,
-0.003887577,
-0.0072728251,
0.0408295467,
0.0417524353,
-0.0309397113,
0.069933556,
0.0520424284,
-0.0472005866,
0.0666462854,
0.0074265734,
0.0363235809,
-0.0402056128,
-0.0280404389,
0.0438134484,
0.0042048856,
0.0030561991,
0.004641694,
0.0977414921,
0.0494181477,
-0.0699240044,
0.0003358207,
0.0103491135,
0.0431715995,
0.0315241516,
0.1026658416,
0.0078709461,
-0.0030173792,
-0.0104203923,
-0.0181586687,
0.0251287539,
-0.0121790469,
0.0099625941,
0.0136520034,
0.0070548556,
-0.0087049808,
0.0004516915,
0.0141286086,
-0.0341948196,
0.0445487313,
0.0017936451,
-0.0729051977,
0.0009331109,
0.003621177,
2.76e-7,
0.0200934969,
0.0326743461,
0.0153530054,
-0.0109492326,
-0.0210404545,
0.0336086825,
0.0151539929,
0.0373235121,
0.0140216779,
0.0358811356,
0.0238548312,
0.0066428916,
0.0536889546,
0.0423724204,
-0.082090579,
0.0148634976,
-0.0925872102,
-0.0038171592,
-0.0412247665,
0.0068949689,
0.0146986116,
0.0695441216,
0.0261105467,
-0.0158602223,
-0.004518914,
0.006976027,
0.0160662811,
-0.0305804312,
-0.0032126519,
-0.0117562655,
0.0493504219,
0.0370369069,
-0.0203240197,
0.0333175771,
-0.0085549979,
0.0108744409,
0.0228618402,
0.0297609512,
-0.0147464992,
0.0553202182,
0.0198276676,
-0.0013258646,
-0.0299175382,
-0.065942362,
0.065940313,
-0.0168939065,
-0.0397142917,
-0.0033404268,
-0.0324880369,
0.005016949,
0.0116644651,
-0.0703494847,
-0.0152364373,
-0.0189267285,
0.056915883,
-0.0505980253,
-0.0219633263,
-0.0393014997,
0.0142670134,
0.0106959231,
-0.0043038097,
-0.0176149439,
-0.0477151535,
0.0311974008,
0.0299769118,
0.0066191242,
0.024144046,
2.489357473e-34,
0.0112561798,
0.0053606182,
-0.0045249844,
-0.0275672711,
0.0049121459,
0.029680511,
-0.0065395613,
-0.0165630896,
-0.0100512225,
-0.0743320212,
-0.0159443058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10765v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10765v3 | BiomedJourney: Counterfactual Biomedical Image Generation by Instruction-Learning from Multimodal Patient Journeys | 2023-10-16T18:59:31 | 2023-10-21T02:59:47 | Yu Gu, Jianwei Yang, Naoto Usuyama, Chunyuan Li, Sheng Zhang, Matthew P. Lungren, Jianfeng Gao, Hoifung Poon | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Rapid progress has been made in instruction-learning for image editing with
natural-language instruction, as exemplified by InstructPix2Pix. In
biomedicine, such methods can be applied to counterfactual image generation,
which helps differentiate causal structure from spurious correlation and
facilitate robust image interpretation for disease progression modeling.
However, generic image-editing models are ill-suited for the biomedical domain,
and counterfactual biomedical image generation is largely underexplored. In
this paper, we present BiomedJourney, a novel method for counterfactual
biomedical image generation by instruction-learning from multimodal patient
journeys. Given a patient with two biomedical images taken at different time
points, we use GPT-4 to process the corresponding imaging reports and generate
a natural language description of disease progression. The resulting triples
(prior image, progression description, new image) are then used to train a
latent diffusion model for counterfactual biomedical image generation. Given
the relative scarcity of image time series data, we introduce a two-stage
curriculum that first pretrains the denoising network using the much more
abundant single image-report pairs (with dummy prior image), and then continues
training using the counterfactual triples. Experiments using the standard
MIMIC-CXR dataset demonstrate the promise of our method. In a comprehensive
battery of tests on counterfactual medical image generation, BiomedJourney
substantially outperforms prior state-of-the-art methods in instruction image
editing and medical image generation such as InstructPix2Pix and RoentGen. To
facilitate future study in counterfactual medical generation, we plan to
release our instruction-learning code and pretrained models. | [
0.034543395,
0.0833498538,
0.0093840649,
-0.0181928538,
-0.0310618449,
0.0167672299,
0.011704647,
0.0181324705,
-0.0126227057,
0.0149593167,
0.0004924436,
-0.049565047,
-0.0250849985,
0.0498424657,
0.0337782837,
-0.0809465349,
0.0313737318,
0.0272072647,
-0.0006459251,
0.0000974127,
-0.0322885364,
-0.0097503131,
-0.0220160875,
0.0172751844,
-0.0116146356,
-0.0341244154,
0.0079919314,
0.0401074365,
0.0483842194,
-0.052635666,
0.0112651195,
0.0427808426,
0.0529480763,
-0.0283116214,
0.0000024274,
-0.0207459331,
-0.0044917101,
0.0300183762,
0.0079642488,
-0.0262950994,
0.0246251207,
0.0068692002,
0.0037310172,
-0.025142381,
-0.0486036316,
0.0246407203,
0.044929985,
0.0660472959,
0.0979781672,
0.0644676238,
-0.0265342016,
-0.0524211079,
-0.0050840732,
-0.022189077,
0.0737051293,
-0.0020174107,
0.0101467455,
0.0136833079,
0.0062245033,
-0.0181323662,
-0.021310227,
0.0473377854,
0.0415956602,
0.018304633,
0.0308988448,
0.0600113198,
0.0656453222,
-0.0442851447,
-0.0234537702,
0.0658583045,
-0.0255122054,
0.0050799227,
-0.0017206232,
-0.0172775071,
-0.02332142,
0.0323217623,
-0.038460806,
-0.0364650264,
-0.0083231088,
0.0277659148,
-0.041128207,
-0.0031110595,
0.0405416973,
-0.0108831665,
0.0335173942,
-0.053450156,
0.0331361257,
0.0209941529,
-0.0563178472,
0.0002379096,
-0.006581659,
-0.041895207,
0.0424382649,
0.0378892757,
-0.0446914248,
-0.0244820863,
-0.0141893839,
-0.026361838,
0.0443056859,
-0.0320775993,
0.0229691528,
-0.0071384613,
-0.0271011014,
0.0415242538,
-0.0006496108,
-0.027009517,
-0.0581380725,
0.0247764979,
-0.0276151914,
0.0535538048,
-0.0242058989,
-0.0062115295,
-0.0302040149,
0.011364622,
-0.0312823243,
0.0228869636,
-0.0582048632,
-0.0167971198,
-0.0194078702,
-0.0038350236,
0.0380539969,
0.0794093311,
-0.0836686864,
-0.0183742177,
-0.0055115023,
0.0143207544,
-0.0094415732,
0.0245893579,
-0.0233041197,
0.0114405742,
-0.0140348021,
0.0052953782,
0.0129137468,
-0.0109629165,
0.0129186492,
0.0819890648,
-0.0369763486,
0.0304481722,
-0.037793044,
-0.035845492,
0.0336620361,
-0.078973189,
0.053775955,
-0.0693839341,
0.0064914892,
-0.0117561296,
-0.0059199533,
-0.036224395,
0.0184317008,
-0.0109683778,
-0.0178406835,
0.0776768401,
-0.0235428642,
-0.0385687985,
0.0457044356,
0.0285854526,
0.0249231681,
0.0171876457,
0.054368671,
-0.0253819339,
-0.0033448187,
-0.0220767334,
-0.0054343357,
-0.0226895157,
0.0497911572,
-0.0063425112,
-0.0210541449,
-0.0322658755,
-0.016042782,
0.0692016333,
0.0167936124,
0.047301285,
-0.0248905197,
-0.0270810798,
0.0453302562,
-0.0313366242,
0.0323091373,
-0.0141471205,
0.0557420105,
0.001107642,
-0.057926666,
0.0484061949,
-0.0002864435,
0.0525530539,
0.0075474512,
0.028405318,
-0.019601969,
0.0043698335,
-0.0410394222,
-0.0450829677,
0.0177123807,
-0.0022691307,
0.0365273952,
-0.0359249897,
0.0290705189,
-0.0070611434,
-0.0553493761,
-0.0429489687,
0.0492606796,
-0.0001345382,
-0.0069292393,
-0.0504950583,
-0.0227966383,
0.0697958618,
0.0396872796,
-0.0129558798,
-0.032704588,
-0.0208177343,
0.001027744,
0.0129021285,
0.0175076425,
0.0186209492,
0.05017782,
-0.0566157214,
-0.0334875695,
-0.0215929803,
0.0283113196,
-0.0241625886,
-0.0283242036,
0.0158865824,
-0.0191164277,
-0.0022291748,
-0.00577405,
0.0274025016,
-0.0467933603,
-0.0168795735,
0.0298549552,
0.0058197002,
0.0117308851,
-0.0117254853,
-0.0271224082,
-0.0174739547,
0.0291395187,
-0.0217370689,
-0.0216685012,
0.0379422233,
-0.0534551889,
-0.0849585831,
-0.0007798687,
-0.1010120809,
-0.0405254662,
-0.0106847845,
-0.0555125065,
-0.0262767877,
0.016587982,
-0.0282762088,
0.011736027,
-0.0196898803,
0.0017582965,
0.0732192397,
-0.0106077576,
-0.020074822,
0.0302965287,
-0.0120302504,
-0.0365903936,
0.0333832689,
-0.0113623654,
-0.0211166888,
-0.0084632682,
0.0105892224,
-0.0423500203,
0.011194773,
-0.0552277826,
-0.0178070534,
0.0205733832,
-0.0451661274,
0.0205196943,
-0.0239420086,
-0.0047325934,
-0.000635895,
-0.0292636771,
0.0347011015,
0.009290657,
0.0055299443,
-0.0414479934,
-0.0177342817,
0.0288787913,
0.023920441,
-0.003733696,
0.0644124448,
0.0314650685,
0.0154533442,
-0.0619850345,
0.0141215147,
-0.0145894615,
0.007381422,
0.0306411088,
-0.0278181657,
0.0089162579,
-0.0119905071,
-0.0224028397,
-0.0002167416,
-0.0044342438,
-0.0318559147,
0.0033506583,
0.0131975375,
0.0318913236,
0.0201501362,
0.0117103867,
0.0433623083,
-0.0028214622,
-0.0257217269,
0.0043133595,
0.0160931759,
-0.0567433983,
0.0028482031,
0.0100223515,
-0.0860191882,
-0.0309165847,
0.036911808,
0.0499086119,
0.0264799371,
-0.0605830662,
0.0048175096,
0.0066646971,
-0.0065495316,
-0.0026603781,
0.0293643642,
-0.0387885198,
-0.0287170559,
-0.0464156196,
-0.0456504077,
0.1069048941,
0.0403372906,
0.0159673002,
-0.0491798185,
-0.0119673051,
0.0219914112,
-0.0034420036,
0.0232911501,
0.0530778468,
0.0560782142,
0.0151476916,
-0.0442618132,
0.0212467536,
0.0626735762,
-0.0081817321,
-0.0225712471,
-0.0797232538,
0.0040905946,
0.0081463391,
-0.00936478,
-0.0224672984,
-0.0228810925,
0.0610283315,
-0.0205497742,
-0.0371441096,
0.0240347926,
-0.0375775397,
0.0042354208,
-0.0229873098,
0.0534896106,
0.0029546225,
-0.0208312403,
0.001685802,
0.0306441933,
0.0451747142,
0.0119363684,
-0.0431891903,
-0.054569602,
0.0542678162,
0.0395925567,
-0.0179360602,
-0.0272686202,
-0.0284591336,
0.0516396798,
-0.0715356246,
0.0132463351,
0.0112559684,
0.0454102494,
0.0936125144,
-0.0345552377,
0.0000664778,
0.0324300788,
0.0027036984,
-0.0380428061,
0.0147603685,
0.0504928157,
-0.0008526167,
0.0083590457,
-0.0171000864,
-0.07141193,
-0.0292650312,
-0.0155462036,
0.0122100646,
-0.043899402,
0.0113474745,
-0.022786174,
0.0086001037,
0.0841727778,
0.0322768688,
-0.0180942733,
-0.0070833992,
-0.0715990216,
-0.0065267812,
-0.014942877,
-0.0386724137,
-0.0279039256,
-0.0034637621,
0.0082923472,
-0.0059853671,
0.0121718198,
-0.1133285686,
-0.0284208786,
-0.0008735668,
0.0094875358,
0.0381710529,
0.0081355805,
-0.0059761778,
-0.0413390771,
-0.0004593489,
0.0323887169,
0.0401073545,
-0.029092636,
0.084240362,
0.0237185471,
0.0009065024,
-0.0474745855,
0.0830810219,
-0.0037447673,
-0.0089616533,
-0.0226158462,
0.0670718551,
-0.033214137,
-0.0128256101,
-0.0841921121,
0.0248688236,
0.077324301,
0.0263699014,
0.0002041529,
-0.0066122464,
-0.0275682416,
-0.004521383,
0.091496326,
-0.0335710645,
0.0036017613,
-0.0296563171,
-0.0426828526,
0.004538083,
-0.0480052307,
-0.0398846902,
-0.0056689116,
0.0144063355,
0.0048594926,
0.0120924721,
0.0016244539,
-0.0305350441,
-0.069797866,
0.0342877507,
0.0423716791,
0.0109380241,
-0.0269293189,
-0.077729933,
0.0085258763,
-0.0059708841,
-0.0166283417,
0.0455689915,
-0.0630438402,
-0.0432273597,
-0.0394972041,
0.0810453817,
0.0195749495,
0.0379235707,
0.0191021878,
-0.001423633,
0.0465392098,
0.0379203968,
-0.0094381245,
-0.0235222261,
0.0115942098,
-0.0382430218,
-0.0227940325,
-0.0026699821,
-0.0025755302,
0.0304477625,
-0.0215740148,
0.0311450157,
-0.0281835943,
0.0226208922,
0.0225510579,
-0.0385190472,
0.0546018407,
-0.0542699508,
0.0273310822,
-0.0480974838,
0.0128075294,
-0.0433529019,
0.0253942553,
-0.0360718779,
-0.0135684824,
0.0313943252,
0.0160204731,
-0.0288804211,
0.0058995988,
-0.0398286805,
-0.0284979381,
-0.0671150833,
0.0175410863,
0.0176411998,
-0.0012881316,
0.0159355365,
0.0038000285,
0.0047889543,
0.0130469687,
0.0058530569,
-0.002577944,
0.0153745301,
0.0387499556,
0.015388893,
0.0680409968,
-0.0171948299,
0.0175936986,
-0.0451492481,
0.0130303791,
-0.0593366623,
0.0254240893,
0.0639032722,
-0.0065031066,
0.0330340266,
-0.0106889457,
0.0069039767,
-0.0135662751,
0.0741509423,
-0.0240041129,
0.0050255526,
0.0647482127,
-0.0310614444,
0.0414676219,
0.0073560881,
0.1008150727,
-0.0145489611,
0.0811139867,
-0.0517372526,
0.0010307208,
-0.0607123524,
-0.0397459753,
0.0439116433,
0.0102404477,
-0.0177007131,
0.0321732275,
-0.01226837,
-0.0466643833,
-0.0260294229,
-0.0170380734,
-0.0213408265,
-0.0159118455,
0.0835716203,
-0.0047908388,
-0.0208702479,
-0.050498303,
0.019104192,
0.0341907032,
0.0054871347,
-0.0344058685,
-0.0297686104,
-6.635146924e-33,
-0.002010271,
-0.022135308,
0.0338529535,
-0.0471839197,
0.0087337019,
-0.0016532566,
-0.0663078502,
-0.0111889327,
0.0199385677,
0.069182083,
0.0113415243,
0.0056606806,
0.0126579003,
0.0600700155,
-0.0271880794,
0.0357527286,
0.0786123723,
-0.0310775638,
0.0086453622,
0.0514568165,
-0.0344056822,
0.0201151744,
0.0558030568,
-0.0840490088,
-0.0315896086,
0.0004077418,
-0.0149026075,
-0.0102124065,
-0.0162208043,
-0.0027571914,
-0.00929204,
0.0156152034,
-0.0002070771,
0.0015793447,
-0.0232485514,
-0.0771840587,
-0.0408391543,
-0.0441804081,
-0.008308691,
-0.0137616685,
-0.1175791025,
-0.0360898115,
0.0364461578,
-0.0277033541,
-0.0055014128,
0.0184440669,
0.0564426482,
-0.0029127288,
0.0354500711,
0.0111583164,
-0.0606861115,
0.0282482766,
-0.0371888727,
-0.0450896323,
-0.0243339706,
-0.0015146907,
-0.0172881614,
-0.0028998787,
-0.0485324413,
0.0118814884,
0.0212399624,
-0.0137239015,
0.0185165983,
-0.0114621082,
0.0134065105,
0.0364156254,
0.0093236547,
-0.022808291,
-0.0201465059,
0.0329367891,
-0.0445137881,
0.0429063886,
0.0553277507,
0.0255795661,
0.0416150875,
0.0052778586,
-0.0838788971,
0.0428414829,
-0.1048638448,
0.0563905202,
-0.0138585791,
0.0050745402,
0.0548514277,
0.000407206,
-0.0018813937,
-0.0480086766,
0.0010613555,
-0.0219889227,
-0.0103347823,
0.0203081071,
0.002376331,
0.0049898629,
0.029675493,
0.0200738236,
0.0006624105,
-0.0171544217,
0.0382610261,
0.01844915,
0.0132898344,
-0.0137787173,
-0.0484974608,
-0.0142653259,
0.0864135846,
0.0396859907,
0.0383003242,
0.0112422984,
0.000935332,
-0.006609749,
-0.0049599656,
0.0153442193,
-0.0263602808,
0.0292017497,
-0.0118286591,
-0.0137023153,
0.0312790908,
-0.0203567091,
-0.0506567769,
0.043774154,
0.0049210172,
0.0346138217,
-0.0285953488,
-0.0061237551,
-0.0205031279,
0.0515268333,
-0.0292893704,
0.0149935959,
-0.0412120521,
0.0019356481,
0.0319039449,
-0.0858704671,
-0.0416053273,
0.0384227559,
3.109e-7,
0.0325914547,
0.034415964,
0.0302662645,
0.0042661675,
0.0289914776,
0.0110007962,
-0.0617989972,
-0.0227519013,
0.0001587408,
-0.0313889161,
0.0538696647,
0.0540422313,
-0.01694615,
0.0111453235,
0.0379304849,
0.0138997808,
-0.0594224408,
-0.0038116379,
-0.0024383799,
-0.0179047287,
0.0678971559,
0.033605203,
-0.0311995,
-0.0355649069,
0.0601925179,
0.0417629555,
0.0805018619,
-0.0164925847,
0.0175818764,
-0.0198315959,
-0.0062427376,
-0.0036775167,
0.0165885761,
0.0270344932,
-0.0296255555,
-0.05747189,
-0.0217252169,
0.0259827953,
-0.0619318374,
-0.0102990363,
0.0155976061,
0.050960578,
0.0149633894,
-0.0258452427,
0.0447261482,
-0.0339481421,
-0.0363053717,
0.0012899413,
-0.0493627489,
0.0522782207,
0.085529007,
-0.0544350147,
-0.0758709013,
0.0161400624,
0.0385973603,
0.0735046566,
-0.0313211046,
-0.04368525,
-0.0156167643,
0.0202334616,
-0.0417538434,
0.0052973269,
-0.0122462017,
-0.0390843861,
0.0157529041,
-0.018403383,
-0.0246797148,
2.537987353e-34,
0.0667317957,
-0.0004427597,
0.0082076164,
-0.0266719796,
0.0030956399,
0.0142168067,
-0.0128767807,
0.0015120963,
0.010057319,
-0.010758318,
-0.0389745459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10760v1 | Towards reducing hallucination in extracting information from financial reports using Large Language Models | 2023-10-16T18:45:38 | 2023-10-16T18:45:38 | Bhaskarjit Sarmah, Tianjie Zhu, Dhagash Mehta, Stefano Pasquali | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-fin.PM, q-fin.ST, stat.AP | For a financial analyst, the question and answer (Q\&A) segment of the
company financial report is a crucial piece of information for various analysis
and investment decisions. However, extracting valuable insights from the Q\&A
section has posed considerable challenges as the conventional methods such as
detailed reading and note-taking lack scalability and are susceptible to human
errors, and Optical Character Recognition (OCR) and similar techniques
encounter difficulties in accurately processing unstructured transcript text,
often missing subtle linguistic nuances that drive investor decisions. Here, we
demonstrate the utilization of Large Language Models (LLMs) to efficiently and
rapidly extract information from earnings report transcripts while ensuring
high accuracy transforming the extraction process as well as reducing
hallucination by combining retrieval-augmented generation technique as well as
metadata. We evaluate the outcomes of various LLMs with and without using our
proposed approach based on various objective metrics for evaluating Q\&A
systems, and empirically demonstrate superiority of our method. | [
0.028009234,
0.0872803405,
0.0074542058,
0.0430044234,
-0.016597854,
0.0013120262,
-0.0056826905,
0.0435525812,
-0.0067028119,
-0.0728032216,
-0.0207938049,
-0.0385634527,
-0.0100064417,
0.0076355189,
0.0021429728,
-0.0157623235,
0.0186548289,
-0.0322995335,
0.0066331713,
0.0168249924,
0.0352235734,
0.0068246936,
0.0488320477,
-0.0068879407,
0.0095999893,
-0.0057593533,
-0.0038795713,
-0.0090805748,
-0.016322162,
0.0089214435,
-0.0251504816,
0.0118401013,
0.0015456391,
0.0647764578,
0.0000019069,
-0.0622981079,
-0.0620000064,
0.0307670943,
-0.0112635102,
0.0205742717,
0.062293902,
-0.0214827396,
0.0176092684,
0.0268874299,
-0.0354449451,
-0.0221750028,
0.0538442843,
0.0836972445,
0.070302695,
0.0596439652,
-0.0352549292,
-0.0622507259,
0.0066537717,
-0.0034849471,
0.0405090712,
-0.0748836845,
0.0249993466,
0.0708061755,
0.0023689077,
-0.0076919077,
0.0255536083,
0.0450291187,
-0.0188488513,
-0.0321487524,
0.0214372147,
0.0100567192,
-0.0434948169,
0.0117870402,
-0.0349031016,
0.0308504533,
0.0085953055,
0.0438665263,
0.0142680034,
-0.0083992463,
0.0276965741,
-0.0004477028,
-0.0316037983,
0.0262957029,
-0.0374838375,
-0.0068777646,
0.006440578,
-0.0138897598,
-0.0121949045,
0.0049641184,
-0.0698673353,
0.0341736972,
-0.0081102904,
-0.047180783,
0.0458615683,
0.0377610512,
0.0185218081,
-0.0147925904,
0.0306617972,
0.0354834683,
0.0328034014,
0.0267598554,
-0.0317112766,
-0.0592847764,
0.0004468394,
-0.0818876773,
0.0170670524,
0.0101316543,
-0.0326385871,
0.0686479583,
-0.052859325,
0.0434270427,
-0.0077445726,
-0.0159498453,
-0.0297949538,
-0.0065981052,
-0.0199915227,
-0.0178131703,
-0.0413813442,
0.0897423029,
-0.0814626068,
-0.0321061164,
-0.0130240088,
0.0067879222,
0.0004101041,
0.0307441521,
-0.0040555955,
-0.0471432768,
0.0023800402,
-0.0337408222,
-0.0209070332,
-0.0347016044,
-0.0004328154,
0.0043722498,
-0.0041465485,
-0.0590772517,
0.010479046,
0.0354366899,
0.0304963794,
-0.004752819,
0.0101029919,
0.0739273056,
0.0023377838,
-0.018329775,
-0.0136582041,
-0.059576273,
-0.0205299035,
-0.0300753284,
-0.031524092,
-0.0286425855,
0.0331922919,
0.009568694,
-0.0404032059,
0.0078073447,
0.0365003534,
0.005718376,
-0.0156923886,
0.0550589189,
0.003579641,
-0.0179237835,
0.0574392974,
-0.0276780874,
0.0411949828,
0.0645865723,
0.0054115709,
0.0251460895,
0.0406698585,
0.0060682767,
0.0379099585,
0.0709065273,
-0.0124219637,
-0.0557604395,
-0.0017664778,
0.0609133653,
0.0323051475,
-0.0313691087,
0.0430303924,
0.062304195,
-0.0316572711,
-0.0023196272,
0.0485143028,
0.0504819266,
0.0137303574,
0.0387712717,
-0.0232628379,
0.0205425862,
0.0300154444,
-0.0258051232,
0.0389705896,
0.0077110175,
0.0091503588,
0.0439821854,
0.0615253635,
-0.0098926872,
-0.0203359127,
-0.0374012552,
-0.0152940331,
0.0012327185,
-0.0456471667,
0.0183622111,
0.0359193757,
-0.0217849314,
-0.0776065737,
0.0695761368,
0.0199408066,
-0.0555408634,
0.002626196,
-0.033798404,
0.0275225956,
0.0728405938,
0.0582783855,
-0.0549259298,
0.0728860795,
-0.0176539328,
-0.0435963757,
0.0564841926,
0.048730094,
-0.0059206355,
-0.0514750853,
-0.0636527836,
0.0131744388,
0.0378309898,
0.008778302,
0.0006190084,
-0.0172175597,
0.013241373,
0.0234581977,
-0.0268701296,
-0.0732050017,
0.0334103629,
0.0190830659,
-0.0503144003,
0.0054461104,
-0.0302528851,
0.0025035625,
0.04062289,
-0.0230583977,
0.0282321628,
-0.006068673,
-0.0178224985,
-0.0151495915,
0.0015934356,
-0.0499656349,
0.0133451484,
-0.0101203527,
-0.0023885174,
-0.0091073615,
-0.0055936817,
-0.019923728,
0.0037785342,
-0.0297686998,
-0.0635463968,
0.0437839404,
-0.0843418688,
0.0138207953,
0.0050685238,
0.0269874688,
-0.0300807618,
0.0638265461,
0.003853607,
0.0115865367,
-0.0390354916,
-0.0213590823,
-0.0084579689,
-0.0514877215,
0.0308248978,
0.0511686355,
-0.0269076955,
0.0663186461,
0.028862901,
-0.0350151807,
-0.0283225365,
-0.0721327588,
-0.0888755322,
-0.0376504026,
-0.016973298,
0.0306084603,
0.0130440202,
0.0323113948,
-0.0075883875,
-0.0053678979,
-0.0306910425,
-0.0431629494,
-0.0017928786,
0.0075043929,
0.0500272401,
0.0340518393,
0.005109414,
-0.0364243872,
-0.0098439874,
0.0079191811,
0.056919422,
0.0558520257,
-0.0449213982,
-0.0695290118,
0.0424687043,
-0.019344274,
-0.0037761999,
0.014375845,
0.0429273993,
0.002394672,
-0.049949389,
0.0312923081,
0.074133262,
0.0326578505,
0.0526777729,
-0.0545945615,
-0.0224842243,
-0.0543770269,
0.0037362452,
-0.0203782879,
0.0083299689,
0.0002849018,
-0.0430383347,
0.036700543,
-0.0040189177,
-0.0147088962,
0.0299601797,
-0.0482234135,
0.0308502298,
-0.0255417731,
-0.0101422276,
-0.0457065254,
-0.0150606157,
-0.0223803371,
0.065755181,
-0.0010992226,
-0.0392998084,
0.022989409,
-0.0381921567,
-0.0220226198,
-0.0416354015,
0.0179509856,
-0.054942254,
0.039615076,
-0.0333845429,
0.0147824762,
-0.0396608599,
-0.0655055791,
0.0053120665,
-0.0624982975,
0.0093843816,
-0.0913795978,
0.0438069962,
-0.0021545931,
0.042373389,
-0.0052980594,
-0.0062682778,
-0.0352757946,
-0.0420385934,
-0.0155577101,
-0.0171215739,
0.0303100366,
-0.0119332038,
-0.090957433,
0.0629455596,
0.0200362559,
0.0132711669,
-0.0325977355,
-0.0175274368,
0.0114752874,
0.0544954948,
0.0700452253,
-0.0141820479,
0.0545589142,
-0.0773382857,
0.0596168935,
0.0399162769,
0.0654484034,
0.0149127841,
0.0497088432,
-0.0415750667,
-0.005381546,
-0.0150833363,
0.0181992501,
0.0062313573,
-0.0027473227,
-0.0318323076,
-0.0251215529,
0.0833342448,
0.0266935378,
-0.0211480819,
-0.0260851998,
-0.0009686719,
-0.0036604628,
-0.0339054875,
0.0619104579,
-0.0793603808,
0.0060842107,
-0.0178079177,
0.035376858,
0.0076886015,
-0.0382632129,
-0.0194968563,
-0.145045191,
0.0617407709,
0.004407329,
-0.0170684066,
-0.0728249773,
-0.0448108017,
-0.0208018627,
-0.0200697761,
-0.0007704477,
0.043633692,
0.0009893726,
-0.010333986,
0.0090588015,
-0.0787896961,
0.0208499543,
-0.0017771228,
0.0039923121,
-0.063886568,
0.1109147221,
0.0143763274,
-0.0139896888,
-0.0243966281,
-0.026844291,
-0.03426845,
-0.032218907,
0.0045860587,
0.057923127,
-0.023175111,
-0.0148237161,
0.0086068418,
0.048685573,
-0.0065512285,
0.0581619889,
0.016638007,
0.0161271449,
-0.0125431297,
-0.0261405185,
0.0135350116,
0.036614798,
0.0030630939,
0.0665908977,
-0.0083033424,
-0.0498995036,
-0.0322993211,
-0.0347863138,
0.018915385,
-0.0950961038,
-0.0059172059,
0.0333554745,
0.035821937,
-0.0106411446,
-0.0908363909,
-0.0732077882,
0.0078643123,
0.0262469184,
-0.014022897,
0.0262487028,
0.0312237777,
0.0301965624,
-0.0318647474,
-0.005905441,
-0.0429368131,
-0.0097141257,
-0.0304145198,
0.0135778934,
-0.0029115241,
-0.0122591872,
-0.0480538532,
0.018335782,
-0.0551942997,
-0.039296627,
0.0023818908,
-0.0078036902,
0.0230105557,
-0.0128337527,
-0.019685911,
0.0250610746,
0.0412178598,
0.056813404,
-0.0487689301,
-0.0178092811,
0.0019123342,
0.0124646332,
-0.0089478418,
0.0084013948,
-0.0592304058,
0.010980431,
-0.0075964201,
0.0258980989,
-0.030390434,
-0.0518139228,
0.0142081631,
0.0167413484,
-0.0190621726,
0.0546405092,
-0.0079006245,
-0.0079643447,
-0.0082343007,
-0.0097173378,
-0.0084629441,
-0.0249001384,
-0.0107188756,
0.0062034559,
-0.015042983,
-0.0014629723,
0.0548006333,
-0.0391344242,
-0.0033091742,
-0.0340740234,
0.0254424009,
-0.0327290185,
-0.0069205752,
0.0155183747,
-0.0441432372,
-0.0186628662,
-0.0402301662,
0.0259040073,
0.0290270466,
0.0159999914,
0.0376075841,
0.0055468814,
0.01255388,
0.0246706437,
-0.0047475798,
-0.0295358077,
-0.0247777123,
-0.0380616263,
0.0241362825,
-0.0030869034,
-0.0365185179,
0.0044563469,
-0.0443983078,
0.0225815512,
-0.0166608896,
0.0029571957,
0.0774447769,
-0.0289527941,
0.0204615202,
0.0214382224,
-0.030762922,
-0.0327194557,
0.056726221,
-0.0098866951,
-0.0055303895,
-0.0338678919,
-0.019343948,
-0.0681095421,
-0.0529592261,
0.0494198315,
-0.0383136906,
-0.0157408472,
-0.0004500047,
-0.0523803681,
-0.0158890355,
0.0172002409,
0.0179622937,
-0.008515574,
-0.0082335817,
-0.0028997103,
0.0939480811,
0.0120419841,
0.0202867985,
-0.0474811047,
0.0420520268,
-0.0339083187,
-0.0291174166,
-0.0187563896,
-6.017961329e-33,
-0.0042807623,
-0.0159027521,
0.0216779113,
0.0045786905,
0.0102998996,
0.0093750656,
0.0029281422,
-0.0151672242,
0.0033882456,
-0.0122324303,
0.0000764353,
0.0186362062,
0.0345650129,
0.0132902078,
-0.0199505612,
0.0156645272,
0.0134629691,
-0.0338331908,
-0.0199690182,
-0.0114172921,
0.0142564885,
0.0369374603,
-0.007755646,
-0.0619058497,
0.0444108695,
-0.0429354683,
-0.0337798148,
-0.0238166153,
0.0886522606,
0.020972833,
-0.0090300487,
0.0097920028,
0.0036978771,
-0.089085646,
-0.0150662921,
0.0416648947,
-0.0301844049,
0.0099487379,
-0.0040969644,
0.0354297422,
0.0114656473,
0.0043492601,
0.0309116561,
-0.0237721205,
0.0029924125,
-0.0060416413,
0.0195118356,
-0.0027026006,
-0.0103594745,
-0.0401406474,
-0.0657931492,
0.0541969948,
0.0235854965,
0.0474465452,
0.0670293197,
0.0823659822,
-0.0080031119,
0.0058748093,
-0.0233174339,
0.0126602687,
0.0405607484,
0.0264691357,
0.0123283993,
0.0483777933,
0.0106456671,
0.0377002694,
0.0074780914,
0.0214670282,
0.015092588,
-0.003355311,
0.0160174817,
0.0209092144,
0.0162572879,
0.0114531824,
0.0248911623,
-0.0015031957,
-0.0632191822,
0.0397147685,
-0.0585124381,
0.0158782769,
0.0855545774,
-0.0034051538,
-0.0405835323,
-0.0046982742,
0.0234303232,
0.0467308089,
-0.0356186144,
0.0072832517,
0.009868362,
0.0063929162,
-0.0522845909,
0.0186804328,
0.0598018207,
-0.0246199947,
-0.0509263128,
-0.024266744,
0.0006752583,
0.0174863953,
-0.0430710837,
-0.010451776,
-0.0386903733,
-0.023126414,
0.0074255611,
0.0263559371,
-0.0185848456,
-0.0044093649,
0.0023414502,
-0.04871317,
-0.065220587,
-0.019362228,
0.0010560963,
0.0492287092,
0.0044974769,
0.0179313887,
0.0208232552,
0.0233803019,
0.0041169636,
0.0044511459,
0.0094442312,
-0.0042516044,
-0.0052649314,
-0.0263683796,
0.0168353431,
0.0310123786,
-0.0097230664,
0.0085536726,
0.0023250426,
0.033893358,
0.0071427608,
-0.0022252433,
0.0016233617,
0.0546754263,
2.623e-7,
0.0394713618,
0.0391915254,
0.022284342,
0.022872733,
0.0279715043,
0.0212693047,
0.0328571014,
0.0051412638,
0.0017393422,
-0.0265051648,
0.0425377078,
0.016215615,
0.0871825367,
0.0167356431,
-0.0916522741,
-0.0684395134,
-0.0447280928,
-0.0010474485,
-0.070221357,
0.0099191284,
0.0427669585,
0.0666814893,
-0.0577894822,
-0.0090653077,
-0.0164970085,
-0.0818013251,
0.0633695871,
-0.0059029832,
-0.0144498432,
0.0328184478,
0.0363223962,
0.0043696137,
-0.0168534797,
0.0021701492,
0.0195016954,
0.0091129858,
0.0615295991,
0.0231908336,
0.0125142448,
0.001554417,
-0.002103009,
0.0062322058,
-0.0062134922,
-0.0506667718,
0.0485768989,
-0.0025576083,
-0.0234899875,
-0.0215432104,
-0.0465470925,
-0.0082449466,
0.0059581562,
0.0049514892,
-0.0283873435,
0.0407825299,
0.0125569655,
-0.0159277637,
0.0298352595,
-0.0314232633,
0.0044695474,
0.0202368144,
-0.0244934093,
-0.0104666287,
-0.0246910024,
0.010146264,
0.0005837381,
-0.0316530541,
0.0489639752,
2.20799739e-34,
0.0472808033,
-0.0095420005,
-0.0364034884,
0.059009511,
0.0896445513,
0.0016111024,
0.0137614543,
0.0655281171,
-0.016217785,
-0.1084449664,
0.0074084322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10735v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10735v1 | Building Persona Consistent Dialogue Agents with Offline Reinforcement Learning | 2023-10-16T18:05:54 | 2023-10-16T18:05:54 | Ryan Shea, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Maintaining a consistent persona is a key quality for any open domain
dialogue system. Current state-of-the-art systems do this by training agents
with supervised learning or online reinforcement learning (RL). However,
systems trained with supervised learning often lack consistency as they are
never punished for uttering contradictions. Additional training with RL can
alleviate some of these issues, however the training process is expensive.
Instead, we propose an offline RL framework to improve the persona consistency
of dialogue systems. Our framework allows us to combine the advantages of
previous methods as we can inexpensively train our model on existing data as in
supervised learning, while punishing and rewarding specific utterances as in
RL. We also introduce a simple importance sampling method to reduce the
variance of importance weights in offline RL training which we call
Variance-Reducing MLE-Initialized (VaRMI) importance sampling. Our automatic
and human evaluations show that our framework improves both the persona
consistency and dialogue quality of a state-of-the-art social chatbot. | [
0.088948898,
0.0535106733,
-0.0228196755,
-0.0161390863,
-0.0077377707,
0.0304285437,
-0.0006465609,
-0.0274912734,
0.0123366425,
-0.004281702,
-0.0117156664,
-0.0249267053,
-0.0040487126,
0.0466293953,
-0.0155998273,
-0.1014025733,
0.0346727781,
-0.0205396917,
0.0382138118,
-0.0213273261,
0.0428144485,
0.0279150754,
-0.0451337397,
0.0572028682,
-0.0475251302,
-0.0219874792,
-0.0419086739,
-0.0011946253,
0.0426674075,
0.0054466506,
0.0067622792,
0.0103885457,
0.0387707278,
0.0150319012,
0.0000018563,
-0.0597065091,
-0.0296436101,
-0.0225029439,
-0.0246022865,
-0.0518886037,
0.0086906916,
0.0125824111,
-0.0149208717,
0.0343335569,
-0.040061634,
-0.0137640135,
0.053054031,
0.062000934,
0.0616155341,
0.0758258775,
0.0168821178,
-0.0013258659,
0.0253982432,
-0.0069354074,
0.0024974239,
-0.0816933811,
-0.0157679878,
0.0389494859,
-0.0176659301,
-0.0337137058,
-0.0101781283,
-0.0057257977,
0.0227297228,
-0.0083686141,
0.0137280077,
0.0145635065,
-0.0377921052,
-0.024204623,
0.0001734906,
0.1079066172,
0.0286533292,
0.0170833245,
0.0251334552,
0.0015511079,
0.0305418856,
-0.0068554692,
-0.0217239931,
0.0451832041,
-0.0233902205,
0.0085844947,
-0.0299340021,
-0.0019751007,
-0.0323564261,
0.0113443835,
-0.0181140099,
0.0077943611,
-0.0328054354,
-0.0358278491,
0.0124220746,
-0.0101409424,
-0.0634776801,
-0.0441152938,
0.0089648115,
0.0112021891,
-0.0817268789,
0.0193487275,
-0.0479283184,
0.0172357447,
-0.0201333147,
-0.0141549138,
0.0065674353,
0.0352991596,
0.0308613144,
0.0358349606,
0.0227921307,
0.0839175805,
0.0390259586,
-0.0041166274,
0.0343254358,
-0.0101795606,
-0.0941985473,
0.0099448301,
-0.0424452834,
0.0409384854,
-0.0069398833,
-0.022841949,
-0.0281550772,
0.0404788963,
-0.0655125231,
0.0362904742,
0.0047803265,
0.0198262334,
-0.0725147277,
0.0147881573,
-0.0874710828,
0.0352031887,
-0.0303839352,
-0.002843719,
0.0016638334,
-0.0859034583,
-0.0077364119,
-0.0095963581,
0.0396675244,
0.0344626904,
-0.0176279843,
0.0612611808,
-0.0248868056,
-0.0451581515,
0.0294422377,
-0.0182183534,
-0.0205931254,
-0.0865439177,
-0.038787581,
-0.0299685411,
0.0267073847,
-0.0429969467,
-0.0019623113,
-0.0151158199,
0.0181842819,
0.0104559977,
0.0116901733,
0.0549402572,
0.0181094967,
0.015059378,
0.0196874421,
-0.0067206416,
-0.041448243,
0.0528635606,
0.0285918359,
-0.0240288842,
0.0146961501,
0.0045856093,
0.0362828858,
-0.0170681123,
-0.0007680035,
-0.0078930371,
-0.0052796132,
0.0040004198,
-0.0066580591,
0.0304096807,
0.0433003828,
0.0221660212,
-0.0734333247,
0.0162728,
0.0786570162,
0.015328032,
-0.0466189012,
-0.0278262533,
0.0224170573,
0.0826939791,
0.0148564512,
0.0063775191,
-0.0306757204,
0.042210456,
0.0290047415,
0.0022716599,
0.0110485917,
0.0194610804,
-0.0374072529,
-0.0497711673,
0.0460788123,
-0.0069306032,
0.0179492701,
0.0180853978,
0.0296489913,
0.0201488137,
-0.0271164719,
0.0166645162,
0.0400746018,
-0.0242849998,
-0.0458862409,
-0.0345891453,
0.0365632847,
0.0876844451,
0.0471348949,
-0.0171376728,
-0.0328062773,
-0.0671400502,
0.0042432467,
0.0641060621,
0.0094508082,
-0.0449249707,
0.0319832154,
-0.0544821806,
-0.0420691818,
-0.0045690369,
-0.0023900154,
0.0445887856,
0.0415488258,
0.0228976402,
-0.0174395572,
0.016714653,
-0.0175192468,
-0.0018883306,
-0.0200881213,
0.001084819,
0.0061592357,
0.0186981708,
0.0486885831,
-0.0046996986,
-0.0123978434,
-0.0381031036,
-0.0107599851,
0.0119852377,
-0.0335004702,
0.0019172502,
-0.0319534354,
-0.0298831277,
0.0495172143,
-0.0464988984,
-0.0345906205,
0.0268566385,
-0.030803578,
-0.0278377235,
0.0122665754,
-0.0496980846,
0.0220281705,
-0.0302756894,
0.0258696508,
-0.0094455518,
0.0340740196,
-0.0325463265,
0.0366813466,
-0.019284999,
-0.0048459102,
0.0441747047,
-0.0034191052,
-0.0306389555,
-0.0928659216,
0.0480241179,
0.0005822729,
0.0038829669,
0.0351004824,
0.0172754116,
0.0292308144,
-0.0308670327,
-0.0583335459,
-0.079756543,
-0.0164366923,
0.0027831802,
-0.019097358,
0.0030666841,
0.0243286323,
-0.0326698571,
-0.0412600972,
-0.0133752134,
-0.0093141692,
0.0248471759,
0.0022508714,
0.042614758,
0.0120202163,
-0.0157805905,
-0.0271978844,
0.0382195115,
0.0301121902,
-0.0086509585,
-0.034137059,
0.0088477647,
-0.0525043346,
-0.0494743101,
-0.0688177273,
0.0567218289,
-0.0036646046,
-0.0237913541,
0.0524909496,
0.0137195541,
0.0471269302,
0.0977960974,
0.0541697703,
0.0562702529,
0.0080525288,
-0.0186887775,
-0.1156250909,
0.0643382296,
-0.0031774645,
0.0084937373,
-0.0293371547,
-0.0117825679,
0.0146180075,
0.014531157,
-0.0064470666,
0.0478599593,
-0.0639023483,
0.0727517754,
0.0270881299,
-0.0739263743,
0.0455919169,
0.0288472101,
-0.0343184769,
-0.0075446032,
-0.017898513,
-0.0287512522,
0.088123098,
0.0200677365,
-0.0082256673,
-0.052113343,
-0.0356394425,
0.0141320061,
0.0191468541,
-0.0249093901,
0.0154790431,
0.0313801207,
-0.0276549216,
-0.0514763258,
-0.0374011993,
0.0795208812,
-0.0388517492,
0.0055247708,
-0.0444673039,
0.0088254502,
0.0314544179,
-0.0384397469,
-0.0563189834,
-0.0223619938,
-0.0438672528,
-0.0388441272,
-0.0458442196,
-0.0118815992,
-0.0304337312,
0.0195147172,
0.0207766369,
-0.0092055807,
-0.02091657,
-0.0274683293,
-0.0375343375,
-0.0246576928,
0.0693561211,
0.0553603768,
0.0199320912,
-0.0264709331,
0.0514451526,
0.0177498646,
0.0186040867,
-0.0349049233,
0.0042375433,
-0.0021399055,
0.0018979019,
-0.0426826626,
-0.0027721622,
0.0205462147,
0.0378081724,
-0.0219140127,
-0.0154763702,
0.1278559715,
0.0102031212,
-0.0157488529,
0.0040658079,
-0.0064822156,
0.0531095974,
0.009531673,
0.046234455,
-0.0364187881,
-0.0384656824,
0.0090748481,
0.0676458701,
-0.0406978913,
-0.0514781624,
-0.0298241265,
-0.0884398967,
0.0260254033,
-0.0173128154,
-0.0508470275,
-0.0217179824,
-0.0077065667,
0.0118350768,
-0.0433748066,
0.0588543974,
0.0127888955,
0.0002754473,
0.0076233028,
0.0138905691,
-0.0199489314,
-0.0202264078,
0.0188457407,
-0.0402109399,
0.0915869623,
0.0739897713,
0.0646217093,
0.0437526107,
-0.0236416329,
-0.0310504269,
0.059371233,
-0.0010580064,
-0.0145087289,
0.0694899336,
-0.0206834115,
-0.0290611498,
-0.0523829125,
0.0142007656,
0.0191648621,
0.0177169815,
0.0193979442,
0.0046827733,
-0.0327147618,
0.0023722046,
0.0138840256,
0.012086275,
0.0478045642,
0.0351650417,
-0.0032669776,
-0.0570966117,
-0.0526184812,
-0.0050526457,
-0.0286839418,
-0.0193105154,
-0.0039564986,
-0.0316019282,
-0.0491577089,
-0.0205866601,
-0.0850964114,
-0.0553675406,
-0.0006895281,
0.069785513,
-0.0337361656,
-0.047257483,
0.035967268,
0.0580573864,
-0.0048975814,
-0.0047965818,
-0.0753122345,
4.018e-7,
-0.0212089717,
-0.0135382209,
0.0304336157,
-0.0473712981,
0.0143285524,
-0.0256210621,
-0.0034315775,
-0.0268275607,
-0.0082611665,
0.0808037221,
0.0276496876,
0.0887393355,
-0.0067848582,
-0.0312000941,
0.0116447778,
-0.0129686929,
-0.0132351024,
0.0213123038,
0.0523254648,
0.0409967527,
-0.0035616916,
0.0475773513,
-0.0551664419,
0.0146498894,
-0.033055827,
0.0238502622,
-0.033763878,
-0.0317146555,
0.0116865532,
-0.0119941207,
0.0031420859,
0.0525384732,
-0.0526923575,
-0.0151422638,
0.0300015751,
-0.0113111194,
-0.0261435285,
-0.0512687787,
0.0408514403,
-0.0176903754,
0.0375277363,
0.017402621,
-0.0036438343,
-0.0300926864,
0.0173189882,
0.0132489828,
-0.0775772929,
0.0227479246,
0.0223733298,
-0.0072246292,
-0.0208965465,
-0.0224837419,
0.0384327024,
0.0304951984,
0.048507072,
0.0278848689,
0.0553405248,
0.0137083931,
-0.0071616326,
0.013437775,
0.0011726706,
-0.0660653412,
-0.0579230338,
-0.0056665456,
0.0349586159,
0.0372800604,
0.0457880348,
0.0793447942,
-0.0216549505,
0.0209927354,
-0.013752616,
0.033143688,
0.0083955601,
-0.0151171852,
-0.013362891,
0.0317778885,
-0.0234079286,
0.0216759853,
0.0596529804,
0.0036847282,
0.0096019302,
-0.0429503955,
-0.0064489851,
-0.0546386205,
-0.0226175096,
-0.0140117658,
0.050152842,
0.0158841237,
-0.02080925,
-0.0371101648,
-0.0183396656,
0.0048590889,
0.0253754705,
-0.027517207,
-0.0221066773,
0.0436162502,
0.0026798786,
-0.0129921343,
0.0155863827,
-0.0567525737,
-0.0067201741,
-0.0045540058,
-0.009510546,
-0.0052684853,
-5.667001327e-33,
-0.0293655675,
-0.0167378765,
0.0094351014,
-0.0061145583,
-0.064274095,
0.0022691325,
-0.0362168178,
-0.0071373531,
-0.0041353125,
0.0201855246,
0.0024872301,
0.0307191797,
0.0153817767,
-0.0129266391,
-0.0203553848,
-0.0411370918,
0.0354655385,
0.0060831383,
-0.0376472436,
0.0487209298,
0.0575784221,
0.0089006238,
0.0027412106,
-0.0595205575,
0.0020136128,
0.0235690773,
-0.0143444883,
0.024256669,
0.0272072144,
0.0770500675,
0.0223286971,
0.0123377936,
0.0000291265,
-0.0419577323,
-0.0232120287,
-0.0005111043,
-0.0549874194,
-0.0404938906,
-0.030645255,
0.0246058814,
-0.0301491395,
-0.0013979248,
0.019963935,
-0.0136561291,
0.0141211664,
0.007777439,
0.0247019138,
-0.0191484503,
-0.0270482693,
0.002371893,
-0.0328028053,
-0.0048808777,
-0.0199636836,
-0.0483304709,
-0.030300606,
0.0211214405,
0.0198550671,
-0.0266730823,
0.0005229578,
0.0278012231,
-0.0355598032,
-0.0481105335,
0.0372474305,
0.0373484977,
0.035705775,
0.0587267019,
0.0266315285,
0.0224767625,
0.0149341682,
-0.0269193631,
0.0263900701,
0.0225950163,
-0.0096928934,
0.0559584089,
-0.0112686185,
0.0051106908,
-0.028406797,
0.024360517,
0.0755753443,
0.0405860394,
0.0052083055,
0.0111299241,
-0.0707726479,
0.0029511063,
-0.0238383878,
0.0105641503,
-0.0062938649,
-0.0289296899,
0.0363687761,
0.0325623937,
-0.0640835017,
-0.0489715748,
0.010489786,
-0.0455015115,
-0.0430643111,
0.0100882361,
-0.0307897944,
0.0004698176,
-0.0037209822,
-0.050270915,
-0.046832893,
-0.031560529,
0.0532673784,
-0.0185293891,
0.005528362,
0.0328587182,
-0.0128865605,
0.0329901651,
-0.0434106104,
-0.0076631666,
0.0033091933,
0.0664427727,
-0.0279687662,
0.0647821426,
0.0165513176,
-0.0166846868,
-0.0318268798,
0.0759287253,
-0.0205196533,
-0.0333584659,
-0.0402441584,
-0.0082778372,
0.0129978908,
0.0089959782,
-0.0592771098,
-0.0029959411,
-0.0479372442,
-0.0190518517,
-0.026881367,
-0.0456697159,
-0.0228642877,
0.0060145678,
2.584e-7,
-0.0745313764,
0.0098331068,
0.0462983213,
0.0168461595,
0.0387816429,
0.0656471699,
0.0228110887,
0.0523905009,
0.0019379045,
-0.024995897,
0.0093966695,
0.0718136877,
0.0459523685,
-0.0021260097,
-0.0939758345,
-0.0350888297,
-0.007967419,
-0.0427839905,
-0.0310660638,
-0.0154723357,
0.0184635874,
0.0454904661,
0.0452110283,
-0.0098466426,
0.0554720163,
0.0401185602,
0.0339735635,
0.0304488931,
0.0033530998,
0.0093908291,
0.0344062783,
0.0009780767,
0.0035858573,
0.0236145537,
0.0154375602,
0.0224140808,
-0.0326670893,
0.0770814568,
-0.0112294331,
-0.0400685109,
-0.0145504046,
-0.0005689898,
0.0320634842,
0.0154856602,
0.0509643443,
-0.0639618635,
-0.0024044781,
-0.0111215655,
-0.0219101645,
-0.0374714732,
0.0131799122,
0.017288303,
-0.0723577961,
0.044559408,
0.0091118114,
0.0102561759,
-0.0069461716,
-0.0564778633,
0.0339221172,
-0.0344016142,
-0.0012046628,
-0.0892737359,
0.0005314901,
0.0061909701,
0.0360579863,
-0.0029291117,
-0.0093399249,
1.934704367e-34,
-0.0055877897,
0.0184311364,
0.0307743531,
0.01790791,
0.0254927762,
0.0263059922,
-0.0053808615,
-0.00501617,
0.0802128613,
-0.0238466505,
-0.0052878861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10648v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10648v3 | Bridging the Novice-Expert Gap via Models of Decision-Making: A Case Study on Remediating Math Mistakes | 2023-10-16T17:59:50 | 2024-04-06T16:15:27 | Rose E. Wang, Qingyang Zhang, Carly Robinson, Susanna Loeb, Dorottya Demszky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Scaling high-quality tutoring remains a major challenge in education. Due to
growing demand, many platforms employ novice tutors who, unlike experienced
educators, struggle to address student mistakes and thus fail to seize prime
learning opportunities. Our work explores the potential of large language
models (LLMs) to close the novice-expert knowledge gap in remediating math
mistakes. We contribute Bridge, a method that uses cognitive task analysis to
translate an expert's latent thought process into a decision-making model for
remediation. This involves an expert identifying (A) the student's error, (B) a
remediation strategy, and (C) their intention before generating a response. We
construct a dataset of 700 real tutoring conversations, annotated by experts
with their decisions. We evaluate state-of-the-art LLMs on our dataset and find
that the expert's decision-making model is critical for LLMs to close the gap:
responses from GPT4 with expert decisions (e.g., "simplify the problem") are
+76% more preferred than without. Additionally, context-sensitive decisions are
critical to closing pedagogical gaps: random decisions decrease GPT4's response
quality by -97% than expert decisions. Our work shows the potential of
embedding expert thought processes in LLM generations to enhance their
capability to bridge novice-expert knowledge gaps. Our dataset and code can be
found at: \url{https://github.com/rosewang2008/bridge}. | [
0.0500863008,
0.0012611335,
-0.0375618972,
0.0165032223,
-0.0254015829,
0.002712148,
0.007520271,
-0.0372312665,
0.0141083999,
-0.0386473686,
-0.0105815446,
0.0121418023,
-0.0159679037,
0.0046901628,
0.0172696933,
-0.0621816292,
-0.0106499027,
-0.0242370907,
0.080231294,
0.0042088684,
0.025547171,
-0.0188463517,
-0.0518795885,
0.0679128915,
-0.001076899,
-0.0618116558,
-0.0003014775,
-0.0481278487,
-0.0016359832,
-0.0092842141,
0.0513146631,
0.0755024105,
0.0010185682,
0.0216870792,
0.0000022186,
-0.0293595083,
-0.0054892772,
-0.0520796925,
0.0012891957,
0.0293493923,
-0.0122606531,
0.0641840324,
-0.0040547429,
0.0246626157,
-0.083972156,
0.0239528585,
0.0142757371,
0.0052675754,
0.0760497004,
0.0408687107,
0.0182569008,
0.0062893839,
0.0221911073,
0.0220170617,
0.0365125649,
-0.0506478362,
0.0324453749,
0.0711733848,
-0.0150873484,
0.0212947447,
-0.0644145459,
0.0144456103,
0.0086014774,
-0.0605903305,
0.0091239102,
-0.0152767701,
0.0463236086,
-0.0106601799,
-0.0199876782,
0.0559284426,
-0.0056255492,
-0.0078893658,
-0.0103649627,
-0.0173227526,
0.0413192548,
0.1018472239,
-0.0831732824,
0.0048115943,
-0.0203323551,
0.0043961876,
-0.0275447071,
-0.035940975,
-0.0066494495,
0.0160410907,
0.0120562715,
0.0182987135,
-0.0386319049,
-0.0196306519,
-0.0267371032,
0.0453170761,
-0.0304304752,
-0.0232404768,
0.0158240348,
0.0554096811,
-0.0483900681,
0.016495226,
0.011316753,
-0.0343917608,
-0.011812306,
0.0194906164,
0.0273893215,
0.0559356175,
0.0097133871,
0.0269401204,
-0.0064008296,
0.0112047372,
0.0027609908,
-0.000939376,
-0.0129669756,
0.0313956141,
-0.0682638437,
-0.0190142766,
-0.0134218466,
0.0376960151,
0.0284323469,
0.0340044685,
-0.0414545052,
0.0098256152,
-0.0737867504,
0.0234961882,
-0.040913593,
0.0097395824,
0.0047643092,
-0.0173227228,
-0.0672466531,
0.0664050952,
-0.0003878554,
0.0460764095,
0.0092607858,
-0.0506861173,
-0.0055856826,
0.0064277733,
-0.0010870501,
0.0230710525,
0.0005757415,
0.0390178449,
-0.041831553,
0.0204079095,
-0.0513366275,
-0.049187094,
0.030823743,
-0.0181455854,
-0.0019581779,
-0.0672631562,
-0.0202009026,
0.0192559138,
0.0080675818,
-0.0516851246,
0.0127366101,
0.0170599092,
0.0093880435,
0.033430066,
0.0085833287,
0.0327766947,
0.0495945401,
0.029128436,
-0.0639495477,
0.0379005782,
0.0337456241,
-0.0188043788,
0.0117969317,
-0.0387721136,
0.0829236358,
0.0002252497,
0.0025812867,
-0.0134193618,
0.0113365334,
0.0011829468,
-0.0101563456,
0.0419491008,
0.0000476493,
0.0097634541,
-0.0330267884,
0.0593688861,
0.0559507683,
0.0648303032,
-0.0568813793,
0.032754574,
0.0361707956,
0.0288656075,
0.0374169648,
0.0092682056,
-0.0550090447,
0.0378658287,
-0.0201564673,
-0.0148955174,
0.0219013244,
-0.0033585986,
-0.008197871,
-0.0714632198,
0.0228452887,
0.0188466385,
-0.0297115427,
0.0339731015,
0.0309209675,
-0.0185060445,
-0.0092640305,
0.0382496193,
-0.0194943734,
-0.0309152044,
-0.0050973534,
-0.0878086984,
0.0492199324,
0.0323627852,
0.0467432588,
-0.0564694442,
-0.0373266861,
-0.0272527561,
0.0307802558,
-0.0129570346,
0.0509195477,
-0.0230911952,
-0.0510872863,
-0.0498974696,
-0.0398036763,
-0.0054314425,
0.0217461549,
-0.019410938,
0.0317722112,
0.0229082983,
0.0108813513,
-0.032881435,
-0.0137710851,
-0.0032082053,
-0.0233116541,
-0.0642794073,
-0.040387921,
-0.0041560768,
-0.0043317094,
0.015783716,
0.0223862864,
0.0302467346,
0.008437478,
0.0270915404,
-0.0251299813,
-0.0025928349,
-0.0659275427,
-0.0035697785,
0.0447201356,
-0.0982439891,
-0.039814949,
-0.0008157084,
-0.0548471026,
-0.0427865386,
0.0548067428,
-0.0186462291,
0.0193183757,
0.0135950893,
0.0145272603,
-0.0434693061,
-0.059908323,
-0.0026487543,
0.0456599109,
0.0216306169,
0.0401375256,
0.0216873232,
-0.0050984002,
-0.0033850719,
-0.0169775914,
0.0117844529,
-0.0392491333,
0.0060355212,
0.04911834,
0.0107557718,
0.028740827,
-0.0580531433,
-0.0108584464,
-0.0449607484,
-0.0390596353,
0.0076355748,
0.0409017652,
0.0097594326,
-0.0427495241,
-0.0197530445,
-0.010715819,
-0.0352835655,
0.010501259,
0.0010098012,
-0.00420652,
0.0210951455,
0.0040504993,
0.0090778954,
-0.0503473505,
-0.0049548349,
-0.0354289487,
0.0130440546,
0.0545912609,
0.0013106663,
-0.0182680096,
0.0564665347,
-0.0222613402,
0.0159251969,
-0.013072093,
-0.0202297606,
0.0264391694,
-0.0385304093,
0.0661457628,
0.0408656895,
-0.0037166437,
0.0631439313,
0.0223051626,
-0.0519971289,
-0.0724171028,
0.0143646076,
0.0027697964,
-0.0490146019,
-0.0234394707,
-0.035166502,
-0.0343748704,
0.0533345789,
0.0086372932,
-0.0420593657,
-0.0370924547,
0.0387223959,
-0.030829031,
0.0113591347,
-0.0352859013,
-0.0293638073,
0.0118151903,
0.0407071002,
-0.0011413831,
-0.0361285098,
0.0825375021,
0.060258735,
0.0018419122,
-0.0493687466,
0.0096104247,
-0.0407859497,
0.0209375881,
-0.038809672,
-0.0174282622,
-0.0462986231,
-0.0150067527,
-0.0495143905,
0.0072383732,
0.0744801909,
-0.0617448911,
0.0524132662,
-0.1031944901,
-0.0269869082,
0.007495678,
-0.0093679717,
-0.0213600714,
0.0078033069,
-0.0343170911,
-0.0393487588,
0.044011008,
-0.0461317226,
-0.0337968469,
-0.0489662997,
0.0468213446,
0.011637575,
-0.0241030324,
-0.0474740192,
0.0015627225,
0.0003319082,
0.0070956652,
0.0186981633,
0.0453389324,
-0.0549642779,
0.0855629444,
0.0724222213,
0.0702061951,
-0.0446232259,
-0.0084621385,
-0.0117308451,
0.0298613906,
-0.0084974589,
-0.0248570349,
0.0645562187,
0.0441296846,
-0.0795873702,
0.0191920232,
0.0843864977,
0.0257755741,
-0.0710342675,
-0.0213815328,
-0.0804454535,
-0.0199490041,
0.0101074204,
-0.0073850811,
-0.0949410871,
-0.0381199494,
-0.0181161202,
0.0129786786,
-0.0066378014,
-0.0548127107,
0.0126624964,
-0.0959344879,
0.0433903225,
0.0275188591,
0.0125518562,
-0.0142935356,
-0.007826251,
0.0032934337,
0.0121332519,
0.0084626796,
-0.0037081426,
-0.0196913946,
0.0436670557,
0.0629310682,
-0.0232223738,
-0.0709648132,
0.0094707897,
0.0219371039,
0.034502238,
-0.0312917084,
0.0111722583,
-0.0232618228,
-0.0248926468,
0.0104346247,
0.0370079838,
-0.0225421786,
0.0069533791,
0.0180400927,
0.0004140459,
0.0181553233,
-0.0381363928,
0.0552368499,
-0.0498681702,
-0.0312372632,
0.075682357,
0.1057196259,
-0.0069119371,
-0.0009361011,
-0.0283808205,
0.0159003679,
0.0268704463,
0.0507685505,
0.0375807099,
-0.0297473222,
-0.0064282347,
-0.0453163683,
-0.0131268669,
-0.0113012586,
-0.0479017831,
-0.0003441183,
0.0694218725,
0.037138015,
-0.0036157516,
-0.0426188298,
0.0799122676,
0.0093515702,
0.0200925078,
-0.0023903653,
0.0148122236,
0.0175546519,
-0.0359054916,
0.0499256998,
-0.0096184053,
0.029586222,
-0.0724491179,
0.0084992321,
-0.0273541752,
-0.0153146917,
0.000958995,
0.0017839969,
-0.0593527518,
-0.0577434674,
-0.0352780595,
0.0519456826,
0.0314277075,
-0.0268510226,
0.0316052027,
-0.0615854599,
0.0117822466,
0.004180423,
-0.0536332987,
-0.0104789045,
0.0338534825,
0.0243881121,
0.0262759682,
0.0117363837,
-0.0076285494,
-0.0137244202,
0.017937649,
0.0245548151,
-0.0561078936,
-0.0115751084,
0.0406526513,
-0.0078789489,
0.0153579693,
0.0156096956,
0.0516467541,
-0.0362300575,
0.0060522379,
-0.0024421469,
-0.0102273412,
-0.0323326439,
0.0008788735,
0.025690062,
-0.0229247902,
0.0272225887,
-0.0007294085,
0.0110973753,
0.0086915949,
0.0147716999,
0.0754107386,
-0.0042939787,
0.0065546259,
0.0464198999,
-0.0066498434,
-0.0052509969,
-0.0334618762,
0.0235647149,
0.0348932743,
0.0469304249,
0.0986707509,
0.0280013066,
-0.0001479859,
0.0265458953,
-0.0255958997,
-0.0226495098,
-0.1315410882,
0.0028134757,
0.0615201294,
0.0314962827,
0.0167073235,
0.0086097792,
-0.0379824154,
0.0172395241,
0.0133863119,
0.0444514751,
-0.0052704937,
-0.0061028958,
0.0385213569,
0.022511011,
0.0318989716,
-0.0109764421,
0.0580413081,
-0.0498949029,
0.0211648438,
-0.0279741716,
-0.0428469628,
-0.0128498068,
-0.0017668764,
0.0438147523,
0.0196074042,
0.0245836824,
0.0126863159,
-0.0965241119,
-0.042277012,
-0.066109091,
0.0260509718,
-0.0145311402,
-0.048728995,
0.0162059944,
0.0664234161,
-0.0044494243,
-0.0050086137,
-0.0117339538,
0.0615489967,
-0.0335231721,
-0.0258217491,
-0.0688277856,
-5.728494376e-33,
-0.0061457613,
-0.068268992,
0.0284666289,
0.0208679643,
0.0346893482,
-0.0046326984,
-0.0326907262,
0.0441989265,
-0.006009669,
0.050061319,
-0.0035268981,
0.0414667726,
-0.0048834644,
0.0164346434,
0.0599571615,
0.0186035149,
0.0322190262,
0.0014877226,
-0.0045843413,
0.0297487024,
-0.0142703578,
-0.0185594205,
0.0611370765,
-0.0730718821,
0.0539123453,
-0.0227761474,
0.0034738912,
0.0202021394,
-0.0452151187,
0.0339179412,
-0.0007586159,
0.0668023899,
0.0076096342,
-0.0498146564,
-0.028521359,
0.0172651839,
-0.0031231204,
-0.0767422765,
0.0254751984,
0.0060827262,
-0.055503048,
-0.0189629588,
-0.0072019156,
0.0161324944,
-0.0385087468,
-0.0218648836,
0.0501043387,
-0.0078773964,
0.0252287239,
0.0179163367,
-0.0452373549,
0.0120290052,
-0.076167129,
-0.0273730941,
0.006670245,
0.0420533307,
-0.0267880522,
-0.0517240837,
-0.0611889064,
0.0563378148,
0.0687654093,
-0.0057516382,
0.0514334477,
-0.0225308798,
-0.0279599503,
0.0274630915,
0.0137809711,
0.0050197369,
-0.0148760835,
-0.0427877866,
-0.0015768966,
0.0456625298,
0.0413549058,
0.0155673521,
0.0082861464,
-0.0003304968,
-0.0571215302,
0.0244778469,
0.0579282865,
0.0399301238,
-0.0009755207,
-0.0178264212,
-0.0515179597,
-0.0315926969,
-0.0439269766,
0.0128905447,
-0.0138001414,
-0.023763625,
0.0180196464,
-0.0147157405,
0.0182137676,
-0.0089267716,
-0.0098645231,
-0.0279404707,
-0.0333046056,
-0.0150787579,
-0.0327146426,
0.0440968834,
-0.0129306223,
0.015872011,
-0.0499418601,
-0.0121731143,
-0.0217055976,
-0.0301703624,
0.0230443627,
0.0359434858,
-0.0084628705,
0.0389784276,
-0.0297977719,
-0.019683376,
-0.0532765649,
-0.0034843187,
0.0249947067,
-0.0366813242,
0.0083682444,
0.0220715459,
-0.0122549543,
0.0082338452,
0.0083922762,
-0.0106381197,
-0.0164714772,
-0.0155127812,
-0.0222753584,
-0.0232595727,
-0.0226391926,
-0.0331548154,
-0.0283552464,
-0.0000677466,
0.0018888948,
-0.022640489,
-0.0114928773,
-0.0153608937,
2.834e-7,
0.0217439346,
0.0565587394,
-0.0253181513,
-0.0232523326,
0.0199724734,
0.0543064028,
-0.0114404112,
-0.0194336418,
0.0640851036,
0.0021745132,
0.0306033175,
0.0282775145,
0.0235665087,
0.0278746095,
-0.0618946068,
-0.0339314975,
-0.006011568,
-0.0230875853,
-0.0204857327,
0.0332102552,
0.0858307555,
-0.0140896961,
0.0439489633,
0.0092424881,
-0.027868839,
-0.0076116445,
0.0445280075,
-0.0477090776,
0.0080506504,
0.0419013351,
0.0741042197,
-0.0265712757,
0.0157003179,
0.0506774262,
0.0082828775,
0.0015094471,
-0.0112154074,
0.0508454703,
0.0113481497,
0.0515321419,
-0.0112786833,
-0.0121622821,
0.013780904,
-0.0471253544,
0.0051108235,
-0.0738270059,
-0.038973812,
0.044109188,
-0.0296456516,
-0.0481288359,
0.0043145418,
-0.0029115349,
-0.0232678838,
-0.0134973181,
-0.0083642742,
-0.004055589,
0.0151289571,
-0.0203508902,
-0.0119848317,
0.0387971997,
-0.0386817232,
-0.0414385609,
-0.0394289941,
-0.0091661941,
0.0247422867,
-0.0310773309,
0.0304913856,
2.245422651e-34,
0.0187701397,
-0.0133589199,
0.0698553994,
0.0156586133,
0.0169776026,
0.0247145332,
-0.0276605543,
0.0525328629,
0.0600411668,
-0.0005932634,
-0.023680713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10645v1 | Interactive Task Planning with Language Models | 2023-10-16T17:59:12 | 2023-10-16T17:59:12 | Boyi Li, Philipp Wu, Pieter Abbeel, Jitendra Malik | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | An interactive robot framework accomplishes long-horizon task planning and
can easily generalize to new goals or distinct tasks, even during execution.
However, most traditional methods require predefined module design, which makes
it hard to generalize to different goals. Recent large language model based
approaches can allow for more open-ended planning but often require heavy
prompt engineering or domain-specific pretrained models. To tackle this, we
propose a simple framework that achieves interactive task planning with
language models. Our system incorporates both high-level planning and low-level
function execution via language. We verify the robustness of our system in
generating novel high-level instructions for unseen objectives and its ease of
adaptation to different tasks by merely substituting the task guidelines,
without the need for additional complex prompt engineering. Furthermore, when
the user sends a new request, our system is able to replan accordingly with
precision based on the new request, task guidelines and previously executed
steps. Please check more details on our https://wuphilipp.github.io/itp_site
and https://youtu.be/TrKLuyv26_g. | [
0.0229723379,
0.0127798896,
0.0064856834,
-0.0339442007,
-0.0284392294,
0.0037757559,
-0.0173547287,
-0.0308523644,
0.0213297419,
-0.0190851316,
-0.0335343257,
0.0115593588,
-0.0149657903,
0.0678187981,
0.0078593474,
-0.107033819,
0.048109062,
-0.0551524758,
-0.018093342,
0.0151471393,
-0.020613594,
-0.0147761954,
-0.01846168,
0.0434983745,
0.0052402182,
0.001190527,
-0.0768618658,
0.0102942958,
-0.0075403415,
-0.0183509123,
-0.0156984255,
0.0209557302,
0.0521778204,
0.0006367139,
0.0000022378,
-0.0678161234,
-0.0214608572,
-0.0267497562,
-0.0406806208,
-0.0509667695,
0.0045082835,
0.0130023835,
-0.0341170318,
0.0332199633,
-0.0253041107,
0.0155707654,
0.0383720882,
0.0529791303,
0.0543867797,
0.0502951741,
0.0177176334,
0.014206972,
-0.0434662625,
0.0122034,
0.0077985348,
-0.0442674235,
-0.0023275316,
-0.0070569376,
0.0595758855,
0.0367019214,
0.0124948714,
-0.0192391481,
0.0372074917,
-0.0355075076,
-0.0332320891,
0.0220057834,
0.0016529494,
-0.0535047837,
-0.0284637474,
0.0331153348,
-0.0490110964,
-0.0057145199,
0.0351467356,
0.0104461424,
0.0124659752,
0.001662665,
-0.0148956757,
0.0397064388,
-0.0164986607,
-0.0177720226,
-0.0306793097,
-0.0256229844,
-0.0023701512,
0.0116454493,
-0.0074617108,
0.0881329477,
0.009789383,
-0.0076917987,
0.0202143416,
-0.021481799,
0.0052424795,
-0.084267512,
0.0130023388,
0.0932211354,
-0.0801963061,
0.0218805354,
-0.029696364,
0.0047013592,
-0.0132057453,
0.006011283,
0.0420315526,
0.0605108775,
-0.0369669683,
0.0273930226,
-0.0167198852,
0.0741815269,
0.0016339349,
-0.0208529197,
-0.0272370428,
0.0269731246,
-0.0200166795,
0.026669452,
-0.0591064282,
0.0144941229,
-0.0694852024,
0.0006595634,
-0.0148811126,
0.0911731422,
0.0051372508,
0.0364606492,
0.0066143549,
-0.0099539282,
-0.0492068417,
-0.0223534536,
-0.0457344986,
-0.035515748,
-0.0470928885,
-0.0030581986,
0.0022440592,
0.0072488529,
-0.0154391276,
0.0321879871,
-0.0068929191,
0.0051776012,
-0.0061949366,
0.0962164104,
-0.0109481951,
0.0062144017,
0.0046834568,
-0.0567093976,
0.0063561555,
-0.0566121489,
0.0187454093,
-0.0443741269,
-0.005979572,
-0.0267085955,
-0.0360326581,
-0.0020687117,
0.0073090475,
0.0203160439,
0.0185085703,
0.0775158331,
0.0242816415,
0.0239494517,
-0.0075152242,
-0.0071867262,
-0.0388654321,
0.0301528275,
0.0013774143,
0.0638616681,
0.011931058,
0.0484513678,
0.0180975907,
0.0586847663,
-0.0645915493,
-0.0322685279,
0.0424397998,
-0.0089311674,
0.0451936461,
0.0259375591,
-0.0169557016,
0.0104987705,
0.0038203846,
0.0409250297,
0.0181228742,
0.005519357,
-0.0220350586,
-0.0438852906,
0.0650414377,
0.028876869,
-0.0194035433,
-0.0335635617,
-0.0558821447,
0.0277559143,
-0.0187573601,
-0.0106227547,
-0.0569382124,
-0.020086918,
-0.0205194987,
-0.0317171849,
0.0222752914,
-0.0033364387,
0.0322934501,
-0.0039355331,
0.0647815838,
0.0552334189,
-0.0672853887,
-0.015703354,
-0.0026427791,
-0.0263384078,
-0.0156735964,
-0.0372912362,
0.0146250175,
0.054445561,
0.0116988234,
-0.0537363477,
-0.0484349392,
0.0265350565,
0.0087971929,
0.0333317704,
0.004628926,
-0.0418817289,
0.0084902914,
0.0158684961,
-0.0158641879,
-0.0046718344,
0.0061317058,
0.0279853754,
0.0268404093,
-0.0186601672,
-0.0237271208,
-0.0080777286,
0.0155217126,
0.0471556224,
-0.0110202283,
-0.0176091008,
0.0101410626,
0.0318009444,
0.0374709778,
0.0056496579,
-0.0046390034,
0.0151175121,
0.0398288891,
0.0037398341,
0.0116933212,
-0.0016618506,
-0.0146782789,
-0.0028850026,
0.0319263451,
0.0213862658,
-0.0349335633,
0.036545191,
-0.02455304,
-0.0496737547,
0.0177497789,
0.0027834245,
-0.0260641817,
0.025257187,
0.0442983098,
0.0083715748,
-0.0520466194,
-0.0383193046,
0.0162566844,
0.0229532607,
-0.0248630755,
0.0559769906,
0.030875152,
-0.0049739843,
-0.0308827795,
-0.0404717624,
0.0293209516,
-0.0223539844,
-0.0044907378,
0.0420463011,
0.0538543798,
0.0104976743,
-0.0286588669,
-0.0983479023,
0.0030207275,
-0.0364089943,
-0.045741979,
0.0083463006,
0.0233127736,
0.0027935856,
-0.0456506237,
0.0357677713,
0.0353270583,
0.0028781858,
0.0089893267,
0.0139675448,
0.0439746045,
-0.046034608,
-0.0383683965,
0.0060297851,
-0.0101516424,
-0.0314604566,
0.0244979467,
-0.0304140337,
-0.0662062094,
0.0436946303,
-0.0328703448,
0.0716166422,
-0.0248396005,
-0.0079923868,
0.0603676811,
-0.0399738736,
0.0383559577,
0.0608142801,
-0.0338998586,
0.0303647313,
0.0912627876,
-0.000354322,
-0.036627464,
0.046210479,
-0.0548502617,
-0.037722677,
-0.017436808,
0.0075410767,
0.0516078584,
0.0637111515,
-0.02243804,
0.0174402706,
-0.0500751771,
-0.0178897772,
0.0081413677,
0.0003960161,
-0.0241950769,
-0.0097100008,
-0.0592015721,
0.062546283,
-0.0202197358,
-0.0370258205,
0.0511599295,
-0.0076257945,
-0.0326559991,
0.0180925932,
-0.0320264325,
0.0150018623,
0.093985565,
0.0297449082,
0.0069767945,
0.0426410735,
-0.0270716883,
-0.0582327954,
0.0355956256,
-0.0138552021,
-0.0162898917,
0.019109793,
-0.0894089192,
-0.0071578436,
0.0040462073,
-0.0430797897,
-0.0428895168,
0.0258817412,
-0.0103123533,
0.0505770072,
-0.0387885161,
-0.0632648692,
-0.0090861116,
-0.0374486186,
0.0388446786,
0.0766841695,
-0.0140882293,
-0.0116818463,
-0.0526260026,
-0.0610249974,
0.0325883441,
0.0544174016,
-0.0768161491,
0.0047573838,
0.0215170942,
0.0098797586,
0.0437526666,
-0.0408684649,
-0.0326028466,
0.0089408392,
0.0344394147,
-0.0142385066,
0.0018303503,
0.0674583688,
0.0768878832,
-0.0428067558,
-0.023288453,
0.0787326619,
0.0203838218,
0.0048829196,
0.0206000172,
-0.0218902845,
0.0311578941,
0.0394837186,
0.061084941,
-0.0309480466,
-0.0357981361,
0.0357426293,
0.0222306903,
-0.0072241244,
-0.0371608734,
-0.0410414711,
-0.0999609455,
0.0314835049,
-0.0242062621,
-0.0131640565,
-0.0238297805,
-0.0572940633,
0.0172815043,
0.0311092939,
-0.0240320191,
0.0486188792,
0.032063581,
-0.0005630119,
-0.000663046,
-0.0243333243,
-0.022972336,
0.0330535546,
0.0083819497,
0.0073558451,
0.0847600028,
0.0158483647,
0.0064531653,
0.046399489,
0.0320010446,
0.0423646308,
0.0039259386,
-0.033327654,
-0.0120300082,
-0.0013445575,
-0.0159932394,
-0.0089998115,
0.0204458479,
-0.0278356802,
-0.0553743057,
-0.0024363585,
0.0536098778,
-0.0464095734,
0.0156777482,
-0.0215747673,
-0.0105673568,
0.0454812311,
0.0423383527,
-0.0351735279,
-0.0411199965,
-0.0395416394,
-0.045916643,
-0.0741138384,
-0.0111718224,
-0.0315055475,
-0.001171709,
-0.0323660523,
-0.0258210842,
-0.0689742193,
-0.0244988948,
0.0712194964,
0.0312401298,
0.0123469839,
-0.0404647104,
0.0336529128,
0.0407479182,
-0.0526611358,
0.0087846871,
-0.0106825046,
0.0076140543,
-0.0448237211,
-0.0357592069,
0.0052621141,
-0.04300512,
0.0021613927,
0.0240080543,
0.0035237507,
-0.0545140617,
-0.0118097914,
0.0578298382,
0.018614674,
0.0065771085,
-0.0350295492,
0.002066199,
0.0215199552,
-0.0119808847,
-0.0143292518,
0.0141909933,
0.0078654476,
0.0473101139,
0.0088354591,
0.0325263366,
-0.1051512882,
0.0096726529,
0.0177914556,
-0.0033554379,
-0.0241435282,
-0.050191246,
0.0324728675,
0.0063814884,
0.0462895669,
-0.0035721881,
-0.0396108851,
-0.0170403756,
-0.0185568687,
-0.0264791977,
-0.0460220128,
-0.0766375884,
0.0410133339,
-0.0297163315,
0.0032280628,
0.0860886052,
0.0369989686,
-0.0183673091,
0.0351930857,
-0.0189127643,
-0.0044828751,
-0.0329502001,
0.0080889137,
0.0549607091,
0.03649823,
-0.0065237689,
-0.0026691735,
-0.0001139295,
0.0250821486,
0.0229315329,
0.0461739525,
0.0110255098,
-0.0001609677,
-0.0498088002,
0.0191819146,
-0.0424249507,
-0.1001087576,
0.0337402113,
0.0402667373,
0.0205099266,
0.0245580319,
0.0009424195,
-0.0941218883,
0.0238888375,
-0.0398838483,
0.0168585498,
0.0390859805,
-0.0472274721,
0.0375086404,
0.0385254733,
0.0105622234,
-0.0088476902,
0.0360874012,
-0.0357095711,
0.0380132012,
-0.0082708579,
-0.0098427571,
-0.0633798391,
-0.0409127995,
0.0330592543,
0.0007303259,
-0.0201190989,
-0.0188138131,
-0.0132532017,
-0.018945355,
-0.0236243494,
0.019407399,
-0.0290223658,
-0.030142054,
0.0825754628,
0.0128299873,
-0.0157260541,
-0.0332967862,
-0.0307313949,
-0.0402259864,
0.0282664914,
-0.0298256986,
-0.024132289,
-5.365176622e-33,
-0.0364770032,
-0.0223646797,
0.0462656617,
-0.0360282958,
-0.0058609121,
-0.0030982059,
-0.0600028895,
0.0390159637,
-0.0098994514,
0.0135601722,
-0.001401197,
-0.0048439358,
0.0191945601,
-0.006996356,
0.0160180181,
0.0174981114,
0.0563995242,
-0.0084507167,
-0.0596516244,
-0.0065522688,
0.0478389449,
-0.0033905057,
-0.0124148671,
-0.0190178044,
0.0376262702,
0.0085050659,
-0.0425092094,
0.0552783348,
0.0288189128,
0.0078701815,
-0.005685667,
0.0057155145,
-0.0019762302,
-0.0410588942,
-0.0529658236,
0.0973669887,
-0.0397399329,
-0.0462886021,
-0.0131933801,
0.0367364772,
-0.0627473071,
-0.0171168,
0.008640063,
0.0065783882,
-0.0289240386,
0.039126724,
-0.0024233151,
0.0319294706,
0.0200808123,
0.035510961,
-0.0507383533,
0.008953562,
0.025027195,
-0.0859787092,
0.0224680565,
0.0721342787,
-0.0051996908,
-0.0315346904,
0.0231502205,
0.0022812446,
-0.0339165106,
0.0157879051,
0.0338921398,
0.0121540176,
0.0211038701,
0.024947511,
0.0281782206,
0.0033286856,
-0.0101235434,
0.0301771797,
-0.0328865647,
0.0788235813,
-0.0064082653,
-0.0047630924,
-0.0228713881,
0.0348459817,
-0.0135229807,
0.0199273787,
-0.0027416064,
0.084362112,
0.0199927352,
0.0102123134,
-0.0288903713,
-0.0025337734,
0.0021864481,
0.0462185368,
0.0117439609,
-0.0072437329,
0.0148971211,
0.0304840226,
0.0064843087,
-0.0620568432,
0.0295560956,
0.0473874621,
0.0202234499,
-0.0019922822,
-0.0417416878,
0.0433090627,
-0.0108234314,
0.01992012,
0.0279478543,
-0.045802176,
0.0193804707,
-0.0521272421,
0.0187008455,
0.0362568274,
-0.0387386791,
0.0925691351,
-0.0250649136,
0.002341623,
-0.0552543886,
0.0069253528,
0.0497591048,
0.0477130041,
0.061672572,
-0.0350792371,
-0.0188044049,
0.0321410373,
-0.0079814736,
-0.1267763078,
-0.0126536246,
0.0138576478,
0.0180710796,
-0.0048703556,
-0.0526871048,
-0.0203771032,
-0.0359002165,
0.0404452868,
-0.0205530263,
-0.0235551875,
-0.0065939971,
0.0110002477,
3.025e-7,
-0.0211002082,
-0.0041470826,
-0.0038231565,
0.0963401794,
0.0088051911,
0.0422012396,
0.0059973439,
0.0503372215,
-0.045392707,
-0.0168790147,
-0.0287644099,
0.0306759719,
0.0024563209,
-0.0208342317,
-0.0839623734,
-0.0152901057,
0.0195782147,
-0.0265407786,
-0.0518905856,
0.0174619984,
0.0390450768,
0.072556667,
0.004221017,
0.0159263946,
0.0241350904,
-0.0442059822,
0.0028568795,
-0.0327913724,
0.0160372648,
-0.0074963546,
-0.0361069217,
0.0089220796,
-0.006604143,
0.0086793229,
-0.009420949,
-0.0198789872,
0.0034175811,
0.1060619578,
0.0185604841,
-0.0110998806,
0.0019256027,
-0.0004130897,
-0.0126361763,
-0.027270874,
0.0370399505,
-0.0163001101,
0.0164937824,
-0.0028949629,
0.0447536595,
-0.0039061382,
-0.0633867607,
0.0001537725,
0.0154916877,
0.0005578166,
0.0095925787,
0.0081379879,
-0.0209618788,
-0.0506476127,
-0.0000059116,
-0.0149566755,
-0.0726259053,
-0.0481564999,
-0.0173193682,
-0.014775387,
-0.0144818863,
-0.0416128635,
0.0000880665,
2.779082392e-34,
-0.021834109,
0.0174368266,
0.0019082068,
0.0482016355,
0.0081221201,
0.0198344104,
-0.0554152615,
0.0442313142,
0.092163153,
-0.0176182389,
-0.0802586898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10638v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10638v6 | In-context Pretraining: Language Modeling Beyond Document Boundaries | 2023-10-16T17:57:12 | 2024-06-24T06:28:42 | Weijia Shi, Sewon Min, Maria Lomeli, Chunting Zhou, Margaret Li, Gergely Szilvasy, Rich James, Xi Victoria Lin, Noah A. Smith, Luke Zettlemoyer, Scott Yih, Mike Lewis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LMs) are currently trained to predict tokens given
document prefixes, enabling them to directly perform long-form generation and
prompting-style tasks which can be reduced to document completion. Existing
pretraining pipelines train LMs by concatenating random sets of short documents
to create input contexts but the prior documents provide no signal for
predicting the next document. We instead present In-Context Pretraining, a new
approach where language models are pretrained on a sequence of related
documents, thereby explicitly encouraging them to read and reason across
document boundaries. We can do In-Context Pretraining by simply changing the
document ordering so that each context contains related documents, and directly
applying existing pretraining pipelines. However, this document sorting problem
is challenging. There are billions of documents and we would like the sort to
maximize contextual similarity for every document without repeating any data.
To do this, we introduce approximate algorithms for finding related documents
with efficient nearest neighbor search and constructing coherent input contexts
with a graph traversal algorithm. Our experiments show In-Context Pretraining
offers a simple and scalable approach to significantly enhance LMs'performance:
we see notable improvements in tasks that require more complex contextual
reasoning, including in-context learning (+8%), reading comprehension (+15%),
faithfulness to previous contexts (+16%), long-context reasoning (+5%), and
retrieval augmentation (+9%). | [
0.0447145142,
0.046589952,
0.0264477078,
0.0310045537,
-0.0095989183,
0.0306852292,
0.0216960628,
-0.0113463337,
0.0349622667,
-0.0574043356,
-0.0221451111,
-0.0300648808,
-0.0255908333,
0.0181830544,
0.003052932,
-0.0483038239,
0.0254379883,
-0.0424144827,
0.0038983205,
0.0045547015,
0.0000225967,
0.0260338597,
0.0145071382,
0.0101781404,
-0.0109538957,
-0.0265780836,
-0.0305821672,
0.0357547887,
0.0044647269,
-0.0447845981,
0.0054677869,
0.0202716216,
0.0701874048,
0.0455836952,
0.0000019455,
-0.0326324552,
-0.0402517803,
-0.0184652824,
-0.0226754285,
-0.0177055318,
0.0524620302,
-0.0088468287,
0.0229972117,
0.0170417111,
-0.0317285471,
-0.0365033522,
0.0192800481,
0.0546932779,
0.0758009553,
0.0814479738,
-0.0186884254,
-0.0193346385,
0.025217142,
-0.0428364798,
0.0633670539,
-0.0512325838,
0.0017129376,
-0.0075799287,
0.0327396169,
0.0451784283,
0.0050441036,
0.040483553,
0.0426667631,
-0.021744756,
0.0234942026,
0.0475510098,
0.0004829656,
0.0025756182,
-0.0255929753,
0.0928734541,
-0.0346580148,
-0.0417552181,
0.0145047614,
-0.0025107244,
-0.0327744596,
0.0044001886,
-0.0458401516,
0.0166320354,
-0.0079625789,
0.0158597268,
0.0212399792,
-0.0043789917,
0.063644506,
0.024922695,
-0.0329708233,
0.075646244,
0.0165821835,
-0.0367733054,
0.0126977544,
-0.0023556117,
-0.0101136221,
-0.0420744121,
0.032848835,
0.0468031988,
-0.0460910015,
0.0299750827,
-0.0447107628,
-0.016450217,
0.0141123757,
-0.023945326,
0.0004194499,
0.0128951231,
-0.015583274,
0.0810493082,
-0.0333805643,
0.0223675985,
-0.0196625087,
-0.0069545,
-0.0905619562,
-0.0070091006,
-0.0179561414,
-0.0163176246,
-0.0522273295,
0.0129447309,
-0.066613555,
-0.0555628501,
-0.0085168174,
0.0477950908,
0.0231042095,
0.0110109476,
0.0158815179,
0.0240268894,
-0.038523037,
-0.0563380942,
0.0001072783,
-0.0172941368,
-0.0364068449,
0.0018740888,
0.0076536597,
0.00543665,
-0.0039235591,
0.012064388,
0.0112022767,
-0.0385511033,
0.0035111054,
0.0375206731,
-0.0256430916,
-0.0360815786,
-0.0395067595,
-0.0285256319,
0.0168041382,
-0.032305833,
0.0022836602,
-0.0629749149,
0.0206475351,
0.0249248538,
-0.0033313176,
0.0011309221,
0.000643054,
0.0269018002,
-0.0337434486,
0.0672057867,
0.0114430403,
0.0176332816,
0.0513590537,
0.0152065679,
0.0137733109,
0.0279516559,
0.0108587323,
0.0239659902,
0.0311564878,
0.0174415708,
-0.0145969642,
0.0098897209,
0.0020339729,
-0.0065540392,
-0.0005301271,
0.0151972556,
-0.0007846457,
0.0407506749,
0.0414874293,
0.0364002585,
-0.0563116558,
-0.0059486544,
0.0256372988,
0.0563695095,
0.0212665498,
-0.0297496095,
0.055248592,
-0.006573197,
-0.0389845222,
0.0137331476,
-0.0719635412,
0.0076099867,
-0.0000435851,
0.0120719029,
0.0446102284,
-0.021351397,
-0.0301731937,
-0.019145241,
0.0225040037,
-0.0137392413,
0.0108375093,
0.0112043368,
0.0382944159,
0.0274841078,
-0.0470407829,
0.0149827125,
0.0186878964,
-0.0497000962,
-0.0007078172,
0.0134586785,
0.0219395831,
0.1054786891,
0.0340276062,
-0.0471303649,
-0.036418736,
0.0177608486,
0.0555248931,
0.003644333,
0.0369021595,
-0.033639539,
0.008268103,
-0.0528277233,
-0.0217220802,
-0.0193140693,
-0.0208421089,
0.0203755535,
0.0193337519,
0.0115388315,
0.0621769577,
-0.0618911125,
-0.0043655201,
0.0464848466,
-0.0673700646,
-0.0578381903,
-0.0008932723,
0.0233719535,
-0.0000047016,
0.0118783955,
0.0053356746,
0.0286414418,
0.0457593277,
-0.0494443364,
-0.0016520524,
-0.0020870885,
-0.102536574,
-0.0253429301,
0.0268184841,
0.003930632,
-0.0065861279,
-0.0229826588,
-0.0433236845,
-0.0481296256,
0.0090167476,
0.0152472658,
0.0659043416,
-0.0511470437,
0.0128827915,
0.032946378,
-0.0398603603,
-0.0342670679,
0.0628127009,
0.0165115595,
0.0386587046,
0.0203918349,
0.0523665212,
-0.0015711263,
-0.0220665913,
-0.0012199469,
0.0214960966,
0.0304558538,
-0.0174572598,
0.0216647275,
0.0200682543,
-0.0725696906,
-0.0022344268,
-0.12918441,
-0.011148897,
0.0022934277,
-0.0028561356,
0.0035560115,
0.0295204036,
0.0095135504,
-0.0490136929,
-0.035131596,
0.0028223863,
0.0390617549,
0.0126452772,
0.0164246671,
0.0084442394,
-0.0024284271,
-0.0404332615,
-0.0467006601,
-0.0069711157,
0.0502156615,
0.0234051608,
0.0125905527,
-0.0446646214,
0.0306425821,
-0.0149436472,
0.0348178037,
-0.0375764854,
0.0289129205,
0.0203194451,
-0.0687992722,
0.0544689298,
0.0924907327,
0.0178041942,
-0.0014604334,
0.0346481316,
-0.0042582634,
-0.0607118197,
0.0037477338,
-0.0151076177,
-0.0049839951,
-0.0352005623,
-0.0085737016,
-0.0139604267,
0.0368265547,
-0.0392930545,
-0.0064965202,
-0.0281210411,
-0.00788562,
-0.0234522503,
-0.0271052662,
-0.0672253594,
-0.0483923517,
0.01805057,
0.0307428669,
-0.0463696755,
-0.0356598608,
0.0778825507,
-0.033505775,
-0.0068654241,
-0.0314440466,
-0.0057733757,
-0.050461065,
0.0806884393,
0.0215460733,
0.0147790806,
-0.0511544123,
-0.0271014087,
-0.0593117662,
0.0057488335,
0.0077799116,
-0.0053975368,
0.0358115174,
-0.0043954463,
0.0452662632,
0.0042514508,
-0.0477425195,
-0.0684108138,
-0.0306984335,
-0.0079743247,
-0.0155835059,
-0.0062163402,
-0.0039083436,
-0.0288770273,
-0.0027701869,
0.0250824168,
0.0947830081,
-0.0276092272,
-0.0199468769,
-0.0222899858,
0.0593694597,
0.0324844345,
-0.0381630398,
0.0152619351,
-0.0657867715,
0.0412072465,
0.049233485,
0.0729871541,
-0.05637661,
-0.0265129991,
0.0150931142,
0.0046083955,
-0.0480982848,
-0.018526949,
-0.0107120778,
0.0125228418,
-0.0704919994,
-0.0431857146,
0.1358493418,
0.0519938618,
-0.0764388517,
-0.0182241239,
-0.0158644374,
0.0221740436,
0.0409166254,
0.0493477695,
-0.0676358864,
-0.0194704365,
0.0281217787,
0.0278302953,
0.040715266,
-0.0346736461,
-0.0117464187,
-0.0992399305,
0.0106216669,
0.0355693959,
-0.0411723405,
-0.0198289193,
-0.0411762148,
-0.0307489485,
0.0443393178,
0.0106387725,
0.0548993796,
-0.0184839126,
-0.0098465402,
-0.0037798907,
0.0547256656,
0.0120121818,
0.0056803669,
-0.0314098522,
0.0072338479,
0.0217592902,
0.0083153881,
0.0536269993,
0.0008924122,
0.0541800745,
-0.0069276332,
0.0264493823,
-0.0150612947,
0.0237542819,
-0.0322305672,
0.0313324705,
-0.0006446515,
0.0330209248,
-0.070881322,
-0.0261431858,
0.0037555632,
0.0681779012,
-0.0302174222,
-0.0242038239,
-0.0168724507,
-0.0305951834,
0.0211113114,
0.0515806824,
0.017505262,
-0.0026205305,
-0.0548631996,
-0.0471682139,
0.0369045883,
-0.0066038417,
0.0328013003,
-0.0240663365,
-0.0231279954,
0.0081881182,
-0.0886798576,
-0.0453433655,
0.0293321088,
0.0419260599,
-0.0099292565,
0.010530971,
0.0063994764,
-0.0490712784,
-0.0691251829,
0.0531079546,
-0.0104188053,
0.0033184025,
-0.067420274,
0.0046869591,
0.0351721905,
-0.0412662625,
-0.0242137015,
0.0221091285,
-0.0672844723,
-0.0421823375,
-0.0106348088,
0.022999635,
0.0163069703,
0.0817115977,
-0.0263602268,
-0.058409147,
0.0389986411,
0.0159331281,
-0.0604808368,
-0.0146894576,
0.016374616,
-0.0090900976,
0.0088776024,
0.0327461436,
-0.0650624931,
0.0422729142,
-0.0000040444,
0.0115407174,
-0.0137205869,
-0.0287634917,
0.0090873847,
-0.0028940947,
0.0186563004,
0.0089924559,
0.0176493805,
-0.0692724586,
0.054560069,
-0.0217614919,
-0.0426259339,
-0.017124895,
0.0170836262,
0.0422254913,
0.0180967972,
0.0056871772,
-0.0062664361,
0.012255881,
0.0498674139,
-0.0101265889,
-0.003582014,
0.0136928018,
0.0301253479,
0.0448779389,
-0.0030458451,
-0.0139657035,
0.008629553,
-0.013364519,
0.0566052459,
-0.0551197715,
0.0347311646,
0.0456093103,
-0.0049239178,
-0.0433615074,
0.0317347944,
-0.1093985587,
-0.0477052405,
-0.0275594611,
0.016590571,
0.0449402295,
-0.0375530683,
0.0466220938,
-0.033176329,
0.0003618902,
-0.0087043932,
0.0020387194,
0.0359448157,
-0.0504295789,
-0.017072862,
0.0554602183,
0.0045184158,
0.0674703717,
0.080266878,
0.0155779691,
0.0156699587,
0.0238525588,
-0.0223045852,
-0.0314248577,
-0.0016623455,
0.0068111471,
0.0756710619,
-0.0320283175,
0.0127507178,
0.0135338614,
-0.0799096152,
0.0213529337,
0.0101963393,
-0.0538968779,
0.0128349736,
0.0552944764,
0.0751297176,
0.0008922481,
0.0004204965,
-0.0268467516,
0.0397936553,
-0.0098788375,
-0.0661362782,
-0.0324599966,
-6.226068277e-33,
-0.0134030404,
-0.0431365557,
0.0193014648,
-0.012031965,
-0.0176555216,
-0.0001229882,
-0.0548878275,
-0.0306051932,
0.0123521257,
0.0058854404,
-0.0513162799,
0.0388166457,
0.0081324186,
0.0376050211,
0.0036708945,
-0.0076521239,
0.0399028026,
-0.0124092214,
-0.0006813218,
0.0588791594,
0.0496381335,
0.055898007,
0.0255008023,
-0.0735548809,
0.0067260214,
-0.026573604,
0.0246073753,
0.047045771,
0.0183531251,
0.0276178531,
-0.0114175035,
-0.0012921424,
0.0307518207,
-0.0205860492,
-0.0103140092,
0.0607677251,
-0.102549471,
-0.0344958603,
-0.0081251906,
-0.0246509761,
-0.0301117189,
-0.014595584,
0.0263343807,
-0.0199467354,
0.0216140691,
-0.0041635865,
0.0223304294,
-0.0111680618,
-0.0404001921,
-0.0201193355,
-0.0402564146,
0.0100387223,
-0.0106017338,
-0.0023619055,
0.0251161084,
0.0405579656,
0.0027693652,
0.0451976843,
-0.035994038,
0.0328420065,
-0.0444767214,
0.0380478613,
0.0273903683,
0.0133108301,
0.0076941592,
0.0280634519,
0.0242739227,
-0.0249855835,
0.0071183736,
0.0057928185,
0.0190001559,
0.0266331192,
-0.0188020822,
0.012672619,
0.0442194976,
0.0046362607,
-0.0574997552,
0.0436514691,
0.0058696605,
0.0218190812,
0.0259782635,
0.0249566734,
-0.0194987487,
-0.0329234041,
-0.0398697071,
-0.0014383156,
-0.0370514691,
-0.0193602871,
0.0324331671,
0.0271533616,
-0.0245220382,
-0.0252449978,
0.0366855562,
-0.0158497617,
-0.036598213,
0.0778755173,
-0.0029231012,
0.0094780009,
-0.0155877611,
0.0561847314,
-0.0612529367,
-0.0327972658,
0.0315032601,
-0.0200655591,
-0.0215930063,
-0.0024734945,
0.0447072759,
-0.0084520271,
-0.0682836697,
0.0066544255,
-0.0274181105,
0.0263954252,
-0.018151328,
0.0239174739,
0.0471802689,
0.0283714831,
0.006841185,
0.0698919594,
0.0103408787,
-0.0008843869,
-0.0423206203,
-0.0369160101,
0.0000582986,
0.0063089016,
-0.0200312715,
-0.0043577692,
-0.0351783484,
0.0174238794,
0.0634247065,
-0.0829275921,
-0.0064745024,
0.0379600003,
2.743e-7,
0.0325566828,
0.0416652597,
0.0300292,
0.0250698496,
0.0243925229,
0.0050215959,
-0.006773199,
0.0142397434,
0.0456244163,
-0.0198788252,
0.0462942645,
0.0317506194,
0.0180537384,
0.0104512908,
-0.0941101313,
-0.0054554148,
-0.057082843,
-0.0164519344,
-0.0526792109,
-0.0408238322,
0.0044030091,
0.0814715549,
-0.0078783343,
-0.0270558298,
0.0089461701,
-0.0794132575,
0.051657334,
-0.0232356787,
0.0020224659,
-0.0148133095,
0.0085065132,
-0.0062776455,
-0.0148134353,
-0.0026770111,
-0.0038179988,
0.0297589414,
0.0131720444,
0.0423000492,
0.0043246597,
-0.0341391675,
-0.0077269459,
-0.0171373058,
0.0077996207,
-0.0562947243,
0.0702384487,
-0.0278564841,
0.0193305966,
-0.0353292152,
-0.0353312232,
-0.0200302619,
-0.0300202388,
-0.0039702263,
-0.0254836101,
0.0348703712,
0.0355104767,
-0.023721436,
0.0304839965,
-0.0956987813,
-0.0374729596,
0.0165855139,
-0.0342426375,
-0.0145550696,
-0.0382328555,
0.0283614788,
0.0163756572,
-0.009588955,
0.0011532673,
2.711589043e-34,
0.0303651541,
0.0130830817,
0.0210412685,
-0.0062322062,
0.0334975868,
-0.0081604468,
-0.0156258103,
0.0232438128,
0.0407918431,
-0.1162235662,
-0.0217242874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10637v1 | "Mistakes Help Us Grow": Facilitating and Evaluating Growth Mindset Supportive Language in Classrooms | 2023-10-16T17:56:07 | 2023-10-16T17:56:07 | Kunal Handa, Margaret Clapper, Jessica Boyle, Rose E Wang, Diyi Yang, David S Yeager, Dorottya Demszky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Teachers' growth mindset supportive language (GMSL)--rhetoric emphasizing
that one's skills can be improved over time--has been shown to significantly
reduce disparities in academic achievement and enhance students' learning
outcomes. Although teachers espouse growth mindset principles, most find it
difficult to adopt GMSL in their practice due the lack of effective coaching in
this area. We explore whether large language models (LLMs) can provide
automated, personalized coaching to support teachers' use of GMSL. We establish
an effective coaching tool to reframe unsupportive utterances to GMSL by
developing (i) a parallel dataset containing GMSL-trained teacher reframings of
unsupportive statements with an accompanying annotation guide, (ii) a GMSL
prompt framework to revise teachers' unsupportive language, and (iii) an
evaluation framework grounded in psychological theory for evaluating GMSL with
the help of students and teachers. We conduct a large-scale evaluation
involving 174 teachers and 1,006 students, finding that both teachers and
students perceive GMSL-trained teacher and model reframings as more effective
in fostering a growth mindset and promoting challenge-seeking behavior, among
other benefits. We also find that model-generated reframings outperform those
from the GMSL-trained teachers. These results show promise for harnessing LLMs
to provide automated GMSL feedback for teachers and, more broadly, LLMs'
potentiality for supporting students' learning in the classroom. Our findings
also demonstrate the benefit of large-scale human evaluations when applying
LLMs in educational domains. | [
0.0667216182,
0.0460806303,
-0.0249677021,
-0.0028441907,
-0.0111425491,
0.0176669024,
-0.0202498399,
-0.0367760323,
-0.0054933731,
-0.0101782586,
0.032728456,
-0.0081501594,
-0.010362749,
-0.0030449377,
0.0210094415,
-0.0920373574,
0.005537028,
0.0072673126,
0.03978936,
0.0180308577,
-0.0051175216,
0.0197101552,
-0.0315237902,
0.0180203374,
-0.0306955557,
-0.0313746817,
0.028164655,
-0.0056003146,
-0.0033094161,
-0.048324164,
0.0194329526,
0.0464755185,
0.0122649372,
-0.0243257508,
0.0000023592,
-0.0270945132,
-0.0031481821,
-0.0649700314,
-0.0163809173,
0.0603367612,
0.0746614113,
0.0461819768,
-0.0097851511,
-0.0030534889,
-0.0561531,
0.0055230036,
-0.0160507616,
0.021032447,
0.0517768003,
0.0023888606,
0.0159163959,
-0.019424092,
0.0101208678,
0.0000570744,
0.0111448476,
-0.0322623551,
0.0324290581,
0.045896966,
-0.0255990159,
0.0279244017,
-0.0569376759,
0.0166866332,
-0.0129263029,
-0.0619755611,
0.0300300438,
-0.0349420942,
-0.0030262289,
-0.01717351,
0.0137747945,
0.0076364563,
0.0653947517,
0.0298099089,
0.0007922489,
-0.0313286632,
0.0577167906,
0.0462514684,
-0.0800607651,
0.0191109385,
0.0037964459,
-0.0198357422,
-0.0423118807,
-0.0273043215,
-0.0346907303,
0.0120423688,
0.0312703736,
-0.0099875592,
-0.0472137779,
-0.0334456526,
-0.0572538897,
0.0626761243,
-0.0160188526,
-0.0148856128,
-0.0314647853,
0.0391648188,
0.0090541067,
0.0438000746,
0.0112625565,
-0.01754063,
0.0190010406,
0.0032876104,
0.0423843153,
0.0112637281,
0.0015549412,
-0.0243175905,
0.0276850872,
0.0561544374,
0.0210032333,
0.0227762982,
-0.0238441005,
0.0637187958,
-0.0820692107,
-0.0189273767,
-0.0288555492,
0.0307292826,
0.0568876117,
0.0147013161,
-0.0601591878,
-0.0235849749,
-0.0781835839,
0.0125653408,
-0.0944143459,
0.0048089847,
0.0013057061,
0.0138422288,
-0.0324688293,
0.0801236778,
0.0234367549,
0.0123293437,
0.0064898613,
-0.0669923276,
-0.0045338618,
0.0098173432,
-0.0177906342,
0.0262717847,
0.0162166879,
-0.0178796258,
-0.0168418046,
-0.0157995224,
-0.0219504628,
-0.0377328508,
-0.0264092442,
0.0210334901,
-0.0033368291,
-0.0608659238,
-0.0454481766,
-0.0106466692,
0.0252598282,
-0.0354717001,
0.0119378641,
0.0157161411,
0.0063535757,
-0.0249197613,
-0.0192291643,
0.0302826595,
0.0422105044,
0.0444391631,
0.0167084504,
0.0255116634,
0.0082954317,
-0.0267302617,
0.0151050957,
-0.0314794853,
0.0163765252,
0.000972045,
0.0109976707,
0.0418170728,
-0.0442507751,
0.0055325939,
0.0436832197,
0.0250818692,
-0.031105699,
-0.0062037879,
-0.0283761919,
0.091770865,
0.0164734852,
0.0724497437,
-0.034333609,
0.0306480862,
-0.0053095282,
0.0149221597,
0.0539512187,
-0.0328575075,
-0.0078590233,
-0.0464957207,
0.0214280896,
-0.0099528395,
-0.0070712967,
0.0300472919,
0.0018930287,
-0.0514118709,
-0.0426077023,
-0.0052678795,
0.0139358984,
0.0165407024,
0.0313717686,
-0.0153800854,
0.0081355134,
0.0223993324,
-0.0014373489,
-0.0542534925,
0.0214936342,
-0.0857082531,
-0.0036648335,
0.0912026018,
0.0316500738,
-0.0310849976,
-0.0634932071,
-0.0548159853,
0.0011661402,
-0.0011179837,
0.0330579951,
0.0003897195,
-0.0661798939,
-0.0073046847,
-0.018992791,
0.0087100714,
0.0199270472,
-0.017754605,
0.0088776741,
0.0127182053,
0.0128589505,
0.0272012819,
-0.0976049602,
0.0223963112,
-0.002672964,
-0.0500133634,
-0.0135197714,
-0.0270431787,
-0.0094365478,
0.0449409857,
-0.0315665454,
0.0154861994,
-0.0117208688,
0.0535627939,
-0.055098623,
0.0160482898,
-0.0654867962,
0.0577758998,
0.0352851115,
0.0133096986,
-0.0082942564,
-0.032198865,
-0.0305373687,
-0.0041601751,
0.0518324189,
0.0127662504,
0.0593611971,
0.027219994,
0.0382134207,
-0.0863693804,
-0.0325579494,
-0.0351756737,
-0.0270113926,
0.0353796966,
-0.0271679237,
0.0150789879,
0.0052466928,
0.012289105,
0.0240878724,
0.0053938646,
-0.0003336207,
0.0083615519,
0.018381834,
0.0234220996,
0.0285622925,
-0.0616013557,
0.0018352048,
-0.0702604502,
-0.0716744289,
0.0166537464,
0.0163794234,
-0.0146407103,
-0.0437509194,
-0.0343609788,
0.0027565472,
0.0027898918,
-0.0431427173,
0.0405369028,
-0.0162717365,
-0.0115014473,
-0.0062137051,
0.0099725435,
-0.0345784537,
0.0125479978,
-0.0341304764,
0.0082142139,
0.0862607881,
0.0375815332,
-0.0480614342,
0.0335098356,
-0.0270269755,
-0.0170653332,
0.0000853573,
-0.0186151899,
0.0296011847,
0.0049813362,
0.0575136729,
0.0474884473,
0.0179814622,
0.0459073856,
0.0285711903,
-0.0440990925,
-0.0404533222,
-0.0086193867,
0.0135890758,
-0.0428243093,
-0.0217900481,
-0.0471797362,
-0.0273752697,
0.0187186915,
0.062517412,
-0.024896089,
-0.028220864,
0.0544896983,
-0.0570502393,
0.0390070751,
-0.0584600084,
-0.0465688929,
0.0027174251,
0.0095020114,
0.0233073477,
-0.0141341053,
0.0237540919,
0.0340483971,
0.0138451615,
-0.031152118,
0.0100398771,
0.0141675649,
0.0476993062,
-0.011603619,
-0.016003672,
0.0668691769,
0.0224288385,
0.0026152604,
-0.0186373871,
0.0527136959,
-0.030854702,
0.0199185237,
-0.1118072942,
-0.0137892878,
-0.0028631727,
0.0389137715,
-0.0622365586,
-0.0216212384,
-0.0208337791,
-0.0371419005,
0.0073436224,
-0.0261559226,
-0.0486873463,
-0.0752760842,
0.0491072722,
0.0156089459,
-0.0666656718,
-0.0325159021,
0.0392877162,
-0.0524323285,
0.0186496004,
-0.0025662696,
0.0262946133,
-0.0555350259,
0.052449353,
0.0448343381,
0.0223767329,
0.0066734636,
-0.008528634,
-0.0219410192,
0.0235227868,
0.0350874476,
-0.0172231365,
0.0471388698,
0.0571370311,
-0.0432011373,
-0.0581746362,
0.0622705407,
0.0113891372,
0.0086289309,
-0.0141890412,
-0.0490092486,
0.0372924283,
0.0084824692,
0.0046566203,
-0.0876679048,
-0.0021545619,
-0.0488766022,
0.0393511876,
-0.0269054826,
-0.009573034,
0.011727822,
-0.0846603438,
0.0504712723,
0.0411536805,
0.024544917,
0.027712876,
-0.000603838,
-0.0322522894,
0.0464107879,
0.0030935179,
0.0129606007,
-0.0397174694,
0.0512695014,
0.073641479,
-0.0511834919,
-0.0861782357,
0.0070251939,
0.046468135,
0.0587782674,
0.0131809786,
-0.0139534548,
-0.0046845977,
-0.0326551646,
-0.0167161357,
0.0478703715,
-0.007625768,
-0.0008918514,
-0.0261627957,
0.007010696,
0.0080926968,
-0.0271547083,
0.0043459423,
-0.0254601985,
-0.0165741257,
0.0876847804,
0.1036570743,
0.0488058962,
0.0486691482,
-0.0452939868,
0.0305638313,
-0.0035106461,
0.0413181707,
0.0239614397,
-0.0428817272,
0.0744338781,
-0.0394413695,
-0.005855808,
0.0578468777,
-0.062950708,
0.0251728911,
-0.0432723127,
0.1438646615,
0.0093610566,
-0.0302561838,
0.0322748609,
-0.0059529357,
0.008059863,
-0.0101121813,
-0.0271117669,
0.0125340661,
-0.0594031624,
0.0093651833,
0.0092915148,
0.0046256636,
-0.0334889181,
-0.0300893225,
0.0073108617,
-0.0022197845,
-0.0125502339,
0.0278565958,
-0.058415439,
-0.0467280559,
-0.0089750616,
0.0435198359,
0.0193028562,
-0.0263465345,
0.0843321234,
-0.025395114,
-0.0036092557,
0.0071792277,
0.0029456883,
0.0239722319,
0.0078653572,
0.0201710518,
0.0156746507,
-0.0030151289,
0.0182504747,
0.0445201993,
0.0284073874,
-0.002393581,
-0.013585967,
-0.0203346089,
-0.0150078489,
0.0246229153,
0.0281815436,
-0.0387507826,
-0.0387383401,
-0.0476233587,
-0.0379570089,
-0.0123438425,
-0.0344797634,
0.0088568758,
0.0374588482,
0.0379010551,
-0.0210167989,
-0.0007456727,
-0.0226279311,
-0.0673129782,
0.0465157181,
-0.041103214,
0.0409510769,
-0.0475577042,
-0.0020424584,
-0.0043140505,
0.0178496614,
-0.0214830041,
-0.0512038693,
0.0158666652,
0.0389383249,
0.0309629757,
0.081042394,
0.0025885396,
0.028733626,
0.0360482559,
-0.0352357663,
-0.0019136459,
-0.0826178193,
-0.0022622414,
0.0092333853,
-0.0044361679,
0.0217189863,
0.0537758283,
-0.0212534331,
0.0281859823,
0.012790557,
0.0010963688,
-0.0191211123,
-0.03645733,
0.0452309139,
-0.0188904032,
0.0074765384,
-0.0285064112,
-0.0371205509,
-0.0195964929,
0.0193274561,
-0.0381018706,
-0.0037573925,
-0.0229980722,
-0.0116993524,
0.0516213626,
0.0430249311,
0.0178747028,
0.0382192247,
-0.0699436367,
-0.0107454397,
-0.0055010356,
0.03997688,
0.0333362073,
-0.076752834,
-0.0055298409,
0.0042878366,
-0.0429897644,
-0.0477648191,
-0.0067752064,
0.0248506144,
0.0006238781,
0.0068875058,
-0.0342573635,
-5.895425594e-33,
-0.0367286056,
-0.0351956673,
0.0291549116,
0.0597397499,
-0.0424626209,
-0.006786664,
-0.0120351603,
0.0500648879,
-0.0121007385,
0.0428800881,
0.0257081613,
0.0192739684,
-0.0254408885,
0.0365919806,
0.0849721134,
0.0480000861,
0.0027053012,
0.0038282291,
-0.0193459392,
0.0018714987,
-0.0037403977,
-0.0093626454,
0.1010642126,
-0.0642163604,
0.0726634338,
-0.0150834313,
-0.0166429933,
0.0203303937,
-0.0045000128,
-0.0067946101,
0.0065168324,
0.0235282797,
0.0049834657,
-0.0500227958,
-0.0040879948,
0.0055050445,
0.0088190697,
-0.0398568362,
0.0334239714,
-0.0177939329,
-0.0106063653,
0.0023560424,
-0.0066165584,
0.0088468688,
-0.0700835064,
0.01313016,
0.0498825163,
-0.0372020788,
0.0276952907,
0.0185826849,
-0.0738024935,
0.034352392,
-0.0082598375,
-0.0109341545,
-0.0461057052,
0.036411386,
-0.0079692341,
-0.0333167948,
-0.0222337265,
0.031314671,
0.0847043097,
-0.0015075854,
0.0092056962,
0.0393638052,
-0.0211038888,
0.0812564865,
0.0162802637,
0.0026397796,
0.024577681,
-0.0398998894,
0.050029695,
-0.0170806758,
0.0604363903,
0.027905466,
-0.0088289687,
-0.0110840909,
-0.0591813959,
-0.0136757819,
0.0467139296,
-0.0097953957,
0.0010140644,
-0.023795329,
-0.0188935008,
-0.0388927162,
-0.0450825505,
-0.0212368909,
0.0101295859,
-0.0030103084,
0.0189517792,
-0.0227686819,
-0.0405780263,
0.0071329121,
-0.0192614216,
0.0393186174,
-0.0096371975,
0.0066326545,
-0.0400540605,
0.0068582851,
-0.0338434167,
-0.0093810037,
-0.0609191135,
-0.036721345,
-0.0197081584,
0.0175365098,
0.0149015412,
0.0282221176,
0.0025922807,
0.0003110431,
-0.0403948389,
-0.0055716,
-0.0141298473,
0.0320660658,
-0.0310882181,
-0.1160660759,
0.0172668323,
0.0155816963,
0.0045594056,
0.0718612075,
0.005525548,
-0.0816103593,
-0.0501099862,
0.0332389809,
0.0463696942,
-0.0172854066,
-0.0226393603,
-0.03876248,
-0.0064538373,
0.0187223982,
0.0274983104,
-0.0428212062,
0.0073590041,
-0.0469111577,
3.027e-7,
-0.0068298262,
0.0720565543,
0.0011543744,
-0.0308887418,
0.0206494909,
0.0487263836,
-0.0287880339,
-0.0279052239,
0.0531847775,
0.0450341664,
0.0164524373,
0.0170658287,
0.0207918547,
0.0012134131,
0.0325378254,
0.0023422409,
-0.0327641368,
-0.0238780342,
0.0088869454,
0.0109297987,
0.0984592587,
-0.0286316238,
0.0419857465,
-0.0077313352,
-0.0149500929,
0.0371108316,
0.0447445549,
-0.0333527662,
0.0082359975,
0.0061425739,
0.0095020942,
0.0116484426,
0.0127623854,
0.0314463861,
0.0171426199,
-0.0023561793,
-0.0460311472,
0.0505323038,
-0.0075254948,
0.0486150943,
-0.010121339,
0.036867585,
-0.0488743745,
-0.0624468438,
-0.0341109633,
-0.0741360709,
0.0094208503,
-0.0129369535,
-0.029859025,
-0.0372657254,
0.0082448442,
0.0125677716,
-0.026867047,
0.0328277349,
-0.001734963,
-0.0122395707,
0.0126446933,
-0.0323708057,
0.0171980821,
0.006082423,
-0.0361471809,
-0.0096140848,
-0.0443335362,
0.0100390567,
-0.0543362647,
-0.0218504071,
0.0465349481,
2.186868798e-34,
0.0371173508,
-0.0040429449,
0.0509218164,
-0.066052869,
0.0345247798,
0.0457225144,
-0.0071420167,
0.0473733023,
0.0276289098,
0.024823254,
-0.0407558419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10634v1 | OpenAgents: An Open Platform for Language Agents in the Wild | 2023-10-16T17:54:53 | 2023-10-16T17:54:53 | Tianbao Xie, Fan Zhou, Zhoujun Cheng, Peng Shi, Luoxuan Weng, Yitao Liu, Toh Jing Hua, Junning Zhao, Qian Liu, Che Liu, Leo Z. Liu, Yiheng Xu, Hongjin Su, Dongchan Shin, Caiming Xiong, Tao Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language agents show potential in being capable of utilizing natural language
for varied and intricate tasks in diverse environments, particularly when built
upon large language models (LLMs). Current language agent frameworks aim to
facilitate the construction of proof-of-concept language agents while
neglecting the non-expert user access to agents and paying little attention to
application-level designs. We present OpenAgents, an open platform for using
and hosting language agents in the wild of everyday life. OpenAgents includes
three agents: (1) Data Agent for data analysis with Python/SQL and data tools;
(2) Plugins Agent with 200+ daily API tools; (3) Web Agent for autonomous web
browsing. OpenAgents enables general users to interact with agent
functionalities through a web user interface optimized for swift responses and
common failures while offering developers and researchers a seamless deployment
experience on local setups, providing a foundation for crafting innovative
language agents and facilitating real-world evaluations. We elucidate the
challenges and opportunities, aspiring to set a foundation for future research
and development of real-world language agents. | [
0.0423154235,
0.064511165,
-0.0327037387,
0.0376213416,
-0.0451882556,
0.0038398688,
0.0440643691,
0.005820415,
0.0958328173,
-0.0339410342,
0.0063251662,
0.0206631012,
-0.0357172638,
0.0705595911,
-0.0053520645,
-0.0231360942,
0.0416308492,
-0.0449830256,
0.0276398212,
0.0043152147,
0.0164587647,
0.0162721444,
-0.019949792,
0.0567251183,
0.0020001282,
-0.0108514149,
-0.023494279,
-0.0262572318,
-0.0101405643,
-0.0064661275,
0.0062617087,
0.0213656649,
0.0318953693,
0.0865524858,
0.0000020237,
-0.0453817211,
0.0114261452,
0.0155597962,
-0.0443357714,
-0.0177957918,
0.0624155141,
0.0269771442,
-0.0279153399,
0.0339214243,
-0.0662425682,
-0.0259321835,
0.053911265,
-0.022927938,
0.0586938858,
0.0457087234,
-0.0056831283,
0.011389317,
-0.0203086976,
0.0315480866,
-0.0099791475,
-0.0011217346,
-0.0049446234,
-0.0349823199,
0.052864179,
-0.017281916,
0.0246623363,
0.0334056988,
0.0035249658,
-0.0133882342,
-0.0228449944,
0.026215313,
-0.0697117671,
-0.0629174113,
-0.041957289,
0.0576274656,
0.0072792741,
-0.0324586481,
-0.0038472158,
0.0144744199,
-0.0141094215,
0.0267312601,
-0.0433692187,
0.0493368283,
0.0216539688,
-0.0170748699,
0.0152059682,
-0.0301755946,
-0.0095257321,
0.0089985961,
-0.0386438668,
0.0934299827,
0.0118055688,
-0.0037345716,
-0.0186643731,
-0.0118091824,
0.0414464809,
-0.0735397413,
0.0316885263,
0.0548164137,
-0.0497800149,
0.039069891,
-0.0182493906,
-0.0272824746,
0.0376801156,
-0.0445708819,
-0.003893611,
0.0481151938,
-0.0376458243,
0.045825161,
0.0081024924,
0.030079186,
0.0234446228,
0.0216446221,
-0.0016666624,
-0.0308972728,
-0.0154756671,
0.0065181307,
-0.0333894677,
0.0077500264,
-0.0627728254,
-0.0170111936,
0.028927641,
0.0719861165,
-0.0040848004,
0.0562816374,
-0.030283967,
0.0126892272,
-0.0152347572,
-0.0027635377,
-0.0367437042,
0.0320249125,
-0.0468266942,
-0.0082800779,
-0.002550297,
-0.0924176425,
0.0151316226,
0.0267339833,
0.0235351752,
-0.0096115759,
-0.007845602,
0.1010850295,
0.023774296,
-0.0217227954,
-0.0140812183,
-0.0183347929,
0.0495111383,
-0.0530892983,
-0.049251724,
-0.0945635289,
0.0298152715,
0.056308955,
-0.0242310837,
-0.0760806724,
0.0037638629,
0.0311956257,
-0.0161963571,
0.0447208881,
-0.0607501529,
0.0087049697,
0.0077564926,
-0.0023666811,
0.0102793099,
0.0456764325,
0.0231211912,
0.0330720656,
0.0584980771,
0.0085247699,
0.0484662876,
0.0398872532,
-0.0591125749,
0.0174644683,
0.0153102586,
0.0372012444,
0.0182623547,
0.037750259,
-0.022560155,
0.0337428153,
0.0025686971,
0.0283661895,
0.0644255057,
0.0833423659,
0.0073697143,
0.0042207367,
0.0286752917,
0.052201625,
0.0000414712,
-0.0530786738,
-0.040637251,
0.0340568945,
-0.0133066438,
-0.0136863645,
-0.0457349122,
0.0526064932,
-0.0109287826,
-0.0343286134,
-0.0014164323,
-0.0420953818,
0.0359364934,
0.0127519201,
0.0423613153,
-0.0111283623,
-0.0039751739,
0.0035066984,
0.0337364674,
-0.0614923388,
-0.0009560432,
-0.0637925342,
0.0269369166,
0.1167769432,
0.0695824474,
-0.042849198,
-0.0309929792,
-0.0031824135,
-0.0077867159,
0.0586184375,
0.0216362532,
-0.0265349932,
-0.0218392946,
-0.0247605387,
-0.0205084439,
0.0052752951,
0.0136841172,
0.0203483701,
0.0032197679,
0.0366673619,
-0.0140807144,
-0.0169304665,
-0.0314930156,
0.0235010926,
-0.0269030072,
-0.0330439731,
-0.0252094418,
0.02035705,
0.0059238346,
0.0212890469,
-0.0091773802,
-0.0052066632,
0.0219954643,
-0.0042681093,
-0.0045017018,
0.0329883359,
0.0517558493,
0.0341210589,
0.0482002832,
-0.0141503578,
-0.0025103076,
0.0572533011,
-0.0213840492,
-0.0250618663,
0.0521944314,
-0.0165365636,
0.0329881608,
-0.0235321168,
0.0041070594,
-0.025875045,
0.022832891,
-0.0031537262,
0.0196621306,
0.0427800938,
-0.024558438,
0.0235413015,
0.0272866003,
-0.0043595578,
-0.0128876911,
-0.03105391,
0.012312361,
0.0164934751,
0.0516850762,
0.0123200156,
0.024721073,
-0.0387854166,
0.0068514813,
-0.092097491,
0.0168159455,
-0.0401729792,
-0.0025429656,
0.0225490425,
0.052584637,
-0.0190829057,
-0.0355971903,
-0.027006153,
0.0497756489,
0.0069247745,
0.0300129522,
0.0305903964,
-0.0046869805,
-0.0632941723,
-0.0465128273,
0.0122107659,
-0.0054947049,
0.0014279849,
0.0057507828,
-0.0279170144,
-0.0507174022,
-0.0291978922,
-0.0469755381,
0.0376797058,
0.0095126843,
-0.0554150157,
0.0144732101,
-0.0467998087,
-0.0169169046,
0.0482297502,
-0.0197680686,
0.0220578723,
0.0790780485,
-0.0428083986,
-0.0689066201,
0.0083831521,
-0.0157017354,
-0.0122877313,
-0.02375081,
0.0003249172,
-0.0005992291,
0.0570503287,
-0.0011782316,
0.0100695333,
-0.0136360703,
0.013370282,
-0.0084715281,
-0.0301353335,
0.0078344941,
0.0285049826,
-0.0319136903,
0.0475045443,
0.0201182719,
-0.0548869409,
0.0783152282,
-0.0050937743,
-0.019407915,
-0.0455516204,
-0.0541381501,
-0.0528425723,
0.0729362443,
-0.0036154359,
0.0198162813,
-0.0206678044,
-0.019177366,
-0.0170550942,
0.0140170101,
0.0027911717,
-0.0344251581,
0.0427209102,
-0.0738750473,
-0.0015988805,
0.0040792539,
-0.0375697501,
-0.035378214,
-0.011490602,
-0.0766971335,
-0.002478491,
-0.0328947306,
-0.0250705387,
-0.0538735352,
-0.0221550688,
0.0523719788,
0.0755494907,
0.0249113459,
-0.0135236038,
-0.0333479121,
-0.0592778474,
0.0223824494,
0.0457571074,
-0.001117429,
0.0428074636,
0.0347799174,
0.0334420353,
0.0197739154,
-0.0332932882,
-0.0224130154,
-0.015894996,
0.0314404741,
-0.0389182679,
-0.0131950332,
0.0341045,
0.0084581636,
-0.072806865,
-0.0111064008,
0.1010495797,
0.0411163159,
-0.0491276942,
-0.0046997094,
-0.0454429463,
0.0083541693,
0.0361823142,
0.0647178888,
-0.0996672288,
-0.0359426513,
-0.0047121057,
0.033357434,
0.0021104128,
-0.0121759493,
0.0019876151,
-0.0753027648,
0.0471210927,
-0.011145466,
0.0045539886,
0.0153905516,
-0.0624461174,
0.0240850672,
-0.0178119056,
0.0213488955,
0.0249268226,
0.0090949973,
-0.0151048843,
-0.0345690139,
-0.0393615142,
-0.0431563668,
0.0180082787,
-0.0573436618,
0.0628599674,
0.0725956112,
0.0214053001,
-0.0025453765,
-0.0261625443,
-0.0175325479,
0.018924728,
-0.0000646737,
-0.0257050712,
0.012381563,
0.0096983574,
-0.0219291728,
-0.0396567173,
0.0257746838,
-0.0770628303,
0.0123211686,
0.0104886275,
0.0831809193,
-0.026487587,
0.0232869033,
-0.0233727153,
-0.0278289635,
0.0508723184,
0.036875423,
-0.0142882764,
-0.0545412675,
-0.0662249774,
-0.0506662093,
-0.0680081025,
0.0101497313,
-0.0466678478,
0.0340046771,
0.0033666552,
-0.0534415655,
-0.0597961955,
-0.0572540425,
0.0713948458,
0.0000827102,
0.0438469723,
0.0011369851,
0.027100509,
0.0148398178,
-0.0012171884,
0.0108095407,
-0.0433583185,
0.03781702,
-0.0473597571,
-0.0526094586,
0.0124042565,
-0.0578453019,
0.0062331343,
0.0035950968,
-0.0294433609,
-0.051542066,
0.0463177934,
0.0597793907,
0.0260175448,
0.0135175288,
-0.0442188457,
-0.0500745028,
-0.0058336491,
0.0372241773,
-0.1043719649,
-0.0096531557,
0.0157720819,
0.0039603552,
0.0078119333,
0.0392271765,
-0.0802180916,
-0.0021814881,
-0.0437124409,
0.0129376808,
-0.0262017399,
-0.0167874228,
0.0397250168,
0.0430021659,
-0.0120688509,
0.0119422385,
-0.0127779832,
-0.0338158309,
0.0307074469,
-0.0189088695,
-0.031144416,
-0.0386026278,
-0.0065145916,
-0.0239079483,
-0.0059434255,
0.0604550987,
0.036311809,
-0.0394570939,
-0.0037168243,
-0.0183855034,
0.060919527,
0.0100728413,
0.016001733,
0.038619671,
0.0215568114,
-0.0350996889,
0.0205079168,
-0.0172886625,
0.0522163659,
-0.0181883629,
0.0368711129,
-0.0149749126,
-0.0434196778,
-0.0029301704,
0.0260939132,
-0.0564804822,
-0.0662236065,
0.0478737541,
0.031137649,
0.0215592775,
0.0239827484,
0.0673920363,
-0.0648113191,
0.0204150602,
-0.0178058296,
-0.0014636311,
0.0125451982,
-0.0374912955,
-0.0169164892,
0.0176141299,
-0.0056071701,
-0.0381950885,
0.0291243009,
-0.0240771025,
0.0425946228,
-0.0114335213,
-0.0275604241,
-0.0441872701,
-0.0185667537,
0.0100339781,
0.0055693923,
-0.0519897267,
-0.0383339673,
-0.0453920513,
-0.0275508147,
-0.057449244,
0.0393357687,
-0.0410482623,
-0.0409839861,
0.0220575575,
0.0426069871,
0.035605181,
0.0140561778,
-0.0372836962,
0.0118214237,
-0.0518178493,
-0.0132531356,
-0.0093396688,
-5.873138221e-33,
-0.0083471956,
-0.0312781334,
0.0498275533,
0.0095605645,
0.0343832858,
-0.0263861176,
-0.0510132723,
0.0079129348,
-0.0170827881,
-0.0066110496,
-0.0172253679,
0.0085986545,
0.0324094035,
0.0037050669,
0.0382444449,
0.0045135897,
0.0270660259,
0.0039509274,
-0.0031147816,
0.0099793356,
0.047561314,
-0.0047202245,
0.0236750878,
-0.0786546767,
0.0388879143,
-0.0180654861,
-0.0022509652,
0.0146445036,
0.0021975301,
0.0531079173,
-0.0080362074,
0.0589496903,
0.0033097777,
0.0215161759,
-0.0194948558,
0.0111983381,
-0.0548624396,
-0.0292918086,
-0.0021192741,
0.0591217726,
-0.0215104129,
0.0036910623,
0.0238297414,
-0.0390071869,
-0.0278583281,
0.0680759847,
0.0234652143,
-0.0082875034,
-0.0003669661,
0.0577023029,
-0.07332699,
0.0197495706,
0.0113636991,
-0.0144251296,
0.0231445991,
0.0039122202,
0.0025175239,
-0.0389127806,
-0.0333023965,
0.0211558659,
-0.0024235107,
-0.0114011569,
0.0672856048,
0.0084072147,
-0.0129861189,
0.0437403172,
0.034061335,
-0.0153596867,
-0.0142442733,
0.0476084873,
0.0174204949,
0.0447230972,
0.044588808,
0.0450170413,
-0.0314789861,
-0.0229723938,
0.0036161221,
0.025573384,
0.0758600831,
0.004490362,
0.0044296994,
0.0341375023,
-0.0348449498,
0.0059464718,
-0.0168183576,
0.0369001739,
-0.0546234474,
-0.0631401986,
0.0403632373,
0.015788693,
-0.0039788554,
-0.0470038466,
0.0021358633,
-0.0099505484,
-0.0162348319,
0.0063431929,
-0.0212158039,
0.0148064261,
-0.0063219625,
0.0192267653,
-0.0256245155,
-0.0075443275,
-0.0290188938,
-0.0117637394,
0.0235062744,
0.035398148,
-0.0242115632,
0.0512349755,
-0.0365049914,
0.0171229932,
-0.0590083785,
0.0213033408,
0.0227541011,
-0.0156450439,
0.0201894864,
-0.0212366283,
-0.001470407,
0.0482456684,
-0.0005645773,
-0.0227336828,
-0.0369139686,
-0.010989584,
0.000676205,
-0.0331392661,
-0.0777848884,
-0.0134817669,
-0.0740260109,
0.0468727052,
0.0250443444,
-0.035320282,
0.0067882207,
-0.0111835534,
2.734e-7,
0.01211657,
0.0445702225,
-0.0134516936,
0.0388951376,
0.0167547613,
0.0278942771,
-0.0305696763,
0.040559724,
-0.0385808051,
0.0065432074,
-0.0205565505,
0.0086176861,
0.0208726097,
0.0606886074,
-0.0877645761,
0.003709256,
0.0108227357,
0.0249365494,
-0.0907082036,
0.0054479572,
0.0524113588,
0.0702644289,
0.0251661036,
0.0072084293,
-0.0079655731,
-0.0739155188,
-0.0207600705,
-0.0123525662,
0.0049407356,
0.0204199106,
-0.0255627912,
0.0576997958,
0.0008015017,
0.0034335763,
0.0031097985,
0.0061504184,
-0.0457346328,
0.0522546545,
-0.0020013622,
-0.0072551118,
0.0261600837,
-0.0830760673,
-0.0049367934,
-0.0502509549,
0.0552827939,
0.001919683,
-0.0094366893,
0.009321929,
-0.0023091228,
-0.0290623996,
-0.0554294512,
-0.0616578497,
-0.0288515668,
-0.0049450807,
0.0004112477,
-0.0459225141,
-0.0114451908,
-0.0578968488,
-0.0032937487,
-0.0202752128,
-0.0194454212,
-0.0347406566,
-0.054229442,
0.0006519011,
-0.0033229138,
-0.0173781794,
0.0385566205,
2.487612599e-34,
-0.0023716488,
0.0413912237,
-0.0174191929,
0.0520964786,
0.0492018163,
0.0231372342,
0.025180513,
0.0200130232,
0.0488367639,
-0.0603837594,
-0.0365234315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10632v1 | BioPlanner: Automatic Evaluation of LLMs on Protocol Planning in Biology | 2023-10-16T17:54:20 | 2023-10-16T17:54:20 | Odhran O'Donoghue, Aleksandar Shtedritski, John Ginger, Ralph Abboud, Ali Essa Ghareeb, Justin Booth, Samuel G Rodriques | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO | The ability to automatically generate accurate protocols for scientific
experiments would represent a major step towards the automation of science.
Large Language Models (LLMs) have impressive capabilities on a wide range of
tasks, such as question answering and the generation of coherent text and code.
However, LLMs can struggle with multi-step problems and long-term planning,
which are crucial for designing scientific experiments. Moreover, evaluation of
the accuracy of scientific protocols is challenging, because experiments can be
described correctly in many different ways, require expert knowledge to
evaluate, and cannot usually be executed automatically. Here we present an
automatic evaluation framework for the task of planning experimental protocols,
and we introduce BioProt: a dataset of biology protocols with corresponding
pseudocode representations. To measure performance on generating scientific
protocols, we use an LLM to convert a natural language protocol into
pseudocode, and then evaluate an LLM's ability to reconstruct the pseudocode
from a high-level description and a list of admissible pseudocode functions. We
evaluate GPT-3 and GPT-4 on this task and explore their robustness. We
externally validate the utility of pseudocode representations of text by
generating accurate novel protocols using retrieved pseudocode, and we run a
generated protocol successfully in our biological laboratory. Our framework is
extensible to the evaluation and improvement of language model planning
abilities in other areas of science or other areas that lack automatic
evaluation. | [
0.033888232,
0.0379711948,
0.0065780431,
0.0058852648,
-0.0671873316,
-0.0330794267,
-0.0007583364,
0.0177365635,
-0.0043651541,
-0.0051700799,
0.0024301526,
0.0070378552,
0.0279597938,
0.0739000812,
0.0086757485,
-0.0044134292,
0.0290857274,
0.0026773238,
0.0144002084,
-0.0018750281,
-0.0025579273,
-0.0006099754,
0.0108049084,
0.0295385681,
0.0572356507,
-0.0134391515,
-0.0374903567,
-0.0110793775,
0.0114963241,
-0.0503991768,
-0.0063697342,
0.032073386,
0.0113456389,
0.0363762863,
0.0000016873,
-0.0533645749,
-0.0217680093,
0.041484192,
-0.0031703769,
0.0415123254,
0.0202931818,
0.0027643351,
0.0283119828,
0.0194986854,
-0.0262310617,
-0.0031266815,
0.0666901842,
0.0176405124,
0.0567321405,
0.0361736231,
0.0098107653,
-0.0176942572,
0.0640337467,
0.0229093432,
0.0218389072,
-0.0057178517,
0.0187414698,
0.0156531595,
0.1011795327,
0.0373386778,
0.034942925,
0.0145669002,
0.0390730724,
-0.0160364602,
-0.021265842,
0.0433404408,
-0.0531451441,
-0.0425662063,
-0.0368427783,
0.0553331114,
-0.0090998411,
-0.0421514623,
0.0382474624,
0.0053186002,
-0.0312218983,
0.0068827556,
-0.045227807,
-0.005883689,
0.0020021028,
-0.0088903513,
0.0109340856,
-0.0113935061,
0.0177572668,
-0.0102983871,
-0.0023886794,
0.1224178001,
0.0203555673,
-0.0389203243,
-0.0353305563,
-0.0020027636,
0.0248046871,
-0.0622064136,
0.0322810225,
0.0401270576,
-0.02970054,
-0.0136866234,
0.0020541414,
0.0115643945,
0.0767181367,
0.0026957134,
0.0368264914,
0.0270313881,
-0.0081556942,
-0.0012977226,
-0.0076798955,
0.0223084185,
-0.0328717306,
0.0492930077,
0.0003846612,
0.0411710888,
-0.1113731489,
-0.0092131374,
-0.0011097706,
0.0415864326,
-0.0185732525,
0.0279987361,
-0.0258100871,
0.0233627446,
0.0137651004,
0.0075574825,
0.0219247453,
-0.0152763687,
-0.0235561971,
0.0084359245,
-0.0367170274,
0.0148648005,
-0.0229274742,
-0.0188902784,
-0.0193007868,
-0.0305902436,
-0.036763791,
0.0097400229,
0.0165036693,
0.0084483409,
-0.0119001409,
0.0896553844,
-0.0015980063,
-0.0160633307,
0.0354497321,
-0.0660682693,
-0.006414792,
-0.0325561799,
0.0322936848,
-0.0566881187,
0.0520012602,
0.0015714413,
-0.010651635,
0.0100767743,
0.0165446829,
-0.0189641416,
-0.0215639956,
0.066688478,
-0.0268841889,
-0.017800143,
-0.0042457553,
0.0152594866,
-0.0059050056,
0.0204940625,
0.0124935573,
-0.0070561441,
-0.0137485694,
-0.0007843858,
0.0305002388,
0.0056674168,
0.0062030233,
-0.0327184908,
0.0018283168,
0.032739304,
0.0314510539,
0.0675374418,
-0.0147259347,
0.0344477743,
-0.0036858912,
0.0036149288,
0.0040618908,
0.081622608,
0.0051608076,
0.0200777091,
0.0732738301,
0.0099948663,
0.0193747003,
-0.0096849222,
-0.0183871593,
0.0342360586,
-0.0499781966,
0.0311670061,
0.0071882629,
0.0206680205,
0.0035924471,
-0.0440619066,
-0.0375274569,
0.0075395871,
0.0055231662,
-0.067366235,
0.0081711803,
-0.0256037116,
-0.0442481264,
-0.0117075611,
-0.0071331607,
-0.0512214266,
0.0092376675,
-0.0489530675,
0.0242116973,
0.1011678427,
0.0568855815,
-0.0694560334,
-0.0113172866,
-0.0035962351,
0.0106172953,
0.0586345606,
0.0126539096,
-0.0259256661,
-0.0082009425,
-0.0216934122,
-0.0266164001,
0.0026961947,
0.0084762638,
-0.004285126,
-0.0056728413,
-0.003447324,
0.0019664506,
-0.0208395813,
-0.0302572623,
0.044362627,
-0.0446553305,
-0.0011065373,
-0.0030463294,
-0.044812452,
0.0567434467,
0.0123784412,
-0.0274342448,
0.0623818114,
0.0559120439,
-0.0206324328,
-0.0139710046,
-0.0131326299,
0.0365273543,
-0.0515446849,
0.0333873816,
-0.0339560956,
-0.0461588539,
0.027442852,
-0.0336352512,
-0.0441484787,
0.0179794058,
-0.0207951777,
0.0459752344,
-0.0008466303,
0.0059075505,
0.0009801263,
-0.0483976901,
-0.0129140401,
-0.0019320344,
0.0125369811,
0.0357676186,
0.0059312209,
-0.0320205614,
0.0277382564,
-0.0422567353,
0.0020378709,
0.0131798554,
0.0046404246,
0.006999142,
0.0439977348,
0.0435623527,
-0.0321818814,
-0.0176218376,
-0.0778369009,
0.0163938869,
0.007362593,
0.0398597196,
0.0160669256,
-0.0267937165,
0.0142315123,
0.0068789078,
-0.039830137,
0.0378362536,
-0.0183135383,
-0.0105020404,
0.0552678593,
-0.0078943754,
-0.0689762831,
-0.0547509342,
-0.0084861955,
-0.0573523939,
0.0708510131,
0.03892738,
0.0203703288,
-0.0659844875,
0.0212095361,
-0.0257023312,
-0.0160392001,
0.016985245,
-0.0678754747,
0.0568038523,
0.0110020312,
-0.0145089542,
0.0255043227,
-0.0103483154,
-0.0389647596,
0.0660060272,
0.0160826854,
-0.044471126,
-0.0033886756,
-0.0450206697,
-0.011929485,
0.0008809268,
-0.0432736427,
0.0017620261,
0.0580771007,
-0.020218078,
-0.0122010922,
-0.0548192784,
0.0127394348,
0.0279825777,
-0.0061730039,
-0.0063823177,
-0.0044430825,
-0.0042561549,
0.0620326363,
-0.0090911537,
-0.0541352257,
0.1017144471,
-0.0281152874,
-0.0005545163,
-0.0675702989,
0.0067520342,
0.0042874338,
0.0718868822,
-0.0071698804,
0.0186583251,
0.0302403737,
-0.006073561,
0.0014417289,
-0.0071356925,
-0.0215738211,
-0.019460151,
-0.0181067158,
-0.0850722715,
0.032844115,
0.0366232209,
-0.0303034745,
-0.0271145795,
0.0116085829,
-0.029901091,
0.041690141,
-0.0428649299,
-0.0293652695,
-0.0357360244,
0.0116624068,
0.0340464152,
0.0195841808,
-0.0130308224,
-0.0150291948,
-0.0367554985,
-0.018261835,
0.0125782844,
-0.0172216427,
-0.005131925,
0.0146784177,
0.0251911469,
0.0138417548,
-0.0500997975,
0.0699022263,
-0.024705641,
0.0331643373,
-0.0173002463,
-0.0259226263,
-0.0003928286,
0.0624427386,
0.0453090072,
-0.0268319696,
-0.0428249165,
0.0849311799,
0.048218973,
-0.023683561,
0.0072357366,
-0.0396801233,
-0.0084123341,
-0.0030215571,
0.067335479,
-0.0691614449,
0.002774507,
-0.0132856295,
0.0084370943,
-0.0403819978,
-0.0376318097,
-0.0017434238,
-0.0685549825,
0.0489290506,
0.0266754571,
-0.0446579345,
-0.0237014312,
-0.1180200279,
-0.0495812334,
-0.0276914518,
0.0146922702,
0.0407370925,
0.0379982069,
0.0007404616,
-0.0195176527,
-0.0556996837,
-0.0885815546,
0.0481287464,
0.0134985847,
0.0596443191,
0.1027402356,
0.014405122,
-0.0076855468,
-0.0187790208,
0.0304031819,
0.0213935915,
-0.002700377,
-0.0162963346,
0.0015091771,
0.0718392879,
-0.0112214815,
-0.0421950966,
0.0247688126,
-0.0884950235,
-0.0336999446,
0.0109640816,
0.1231370419,
-0.0259993672,
-0.048492372,
-0.0455067083,
0.0129183838,
0.0110953739,
0.0749588236,
0.0348865949,
-0.0188828036,
-0.0651290864,
-0.0455155596,
-0.0114490679,
-0.0675368458,
-0.0471651889,
-0.0017689414,
-0.0151950568,
0.0120010274,
-0.0632620007,
-0.0028339594,
0.0798085108,
-0.0043624635,
0.028752178,
-0.0167013519,
0.048451528,
-0.018635653,
-0.0584602356,
0.0054792794,
0.0070409323,
0.0001341545,
-0.0482228212,
-0.0497423746,
0.0618908517,
0.0309323817,
-0.0016222964,
0.0590554662,
-0.0108983526,
-0.0920104831,
-0.0291757938,
0.0890768021,
0.030585859,
-0.0180670451,
0.0066524651,
-0.0285637956,
0.0343190245,
0.0296792295,
-0.0172161255,
0.0020766028,
-0.0204154626,
0.0086127948,
-0.0217974707,
-0.0270356052,
-0.0182609893,
0.0334766805,
-0.0272090565,
0.0715902746,
-0.0296472516,
-0.0147826737,
0.0581770353,
0.0610477701,
0.0368587263,
-0.0218700171,
-0.0585527569,
0.0183336698,
-0.0149372434,
-0.0477945022,
-0.0119096637,
-0.0351950638,
0.0413145833,
-0.0008195987,
-0.0073149349,
0.0418204479,
-0.0420452543,
-0.09235356,
0.0065943757,
0.0073997434,
0.0348802768,
0.0002517981,
-0.0096449312,
0.0495005921,
-0.0246623103,
-0.0299148168,
-0.0095999958,
-0.034789335,
0.0322732441,
0.0022691402,
-0.0158226881,
0.0081446674,
0.0403758474,
-0.0417110585,
0.0143745644,
-0.0550497808,
-0.010315164,
-0.0234494228,
0.0642762929,
0.0117915422,
0.0649032891,
-0.0122646056,
-0.0374896415,
0.0025889874,
-0.0266580954,
0.0446964689,
-0.0403445773,
0.0285233352,
0.0692061558,
0.0417339206,
-0.0386180654,
-0.0949475095,
0.0497298501,
0.043912068,
0.0548077226,
-0.0015612807,
-0.0210975911,
-0.0428280346,
-0.0306112077,
-0.0165475719,
-0.009954799,
-0.0277961977,
-0.0381701626,
-0.023795614,
-0.0291339606,
0.0315033086,
0.0584567897,
0.0056282724,
0.0160917602,
0.0437249392,
0.0194483958,
0.0075696767,
-0.0457906015,
0.0329037383,
0.0114591634,
0.0310279485,
-0.0831588358,
-0.0312465057,
-6.079833107e-33,
0.0034751224,
-0.050673902,
0.0379038975,
-0.01063901,
-0.0013162338,
0.0012721716,
-0.0829800442,
-0.0049678534,
0.0554850847,
0.0336940028,
0.0095693134,
-0.0073294863,
-0.0027669715,
-0.0342134163,
0.0301550813,
-0.020721456,
0.0149386935,
-0.0424122214,
-0.0253279842,
-0.0096005136,
0.0364531502,
0.0154154329,
0.0120395487,
-0.0029924102,
0.0099528199,
0.0380552001,
0.003088353,
0.0097774109,
-0.0486018173,
0.0573735386,
-0.0200089104,
0.0052283718,
-0.0018088914,
-0.007148915,
-0.0292047486,
0.0373100638,
-0.0181222409,
-0.0492791198,
0.0525866449,
-0.0520889424,
-0.0620800108,
-0.0429422744,
0.0558740906,
-0.0250068139,
-0.0613631792,
0.0159496721,
-0.00683309,
0.0008507284,
-0.0298223011,
0.0078192633,
-0.0576369241,
0.0165993348,
-0.019039318,
-0.0129394811,
0.0465235896,
0.0019778432,
0.0009300968,
-0.025772756,
0.0372567475,
0.0490563139,
0.0193234943,
0.0022940733,
0.0452689305,
-0.0137963938,
0.0246912092,
0.0466542169,
-0.0076641105,
-0.0042269528,
0.000358259,
0.0116018755,
0.0125103351,
0.0267348047,
0.054478921,
0.014461684,
0.0077756178,
0.0369870625,
-0.0762533844,
0.0471720621,
-0.0141625851,
-0.034245804,
0.0199092682,
0.0116578499,
0.022899298,
-0.0286953244,
-0.0251693968,
0.0290407985,
-0.0184455905,
-0.0424933583,
0.0129633853,
-0.0423829295,
-0.0263624508,
0.012665459,
0.0416158363,
-0.0257797968,
-0.0163002033,
-0.0248869453,
-0.0099300668,
0.0267481469,
0.0016800651,
0.0327663384,
-0.0273101553,
-0.0393353365,
0.0159900784,
-0.0044747265,
0.0481559709,
0.0031921957,
-0.0349768139,
0.0166757703,
-0.0270316582,
0.021209782,
-0.0336972289,
-0.0157102458,
0.0233549289,
-0.0120268958,
0.0169844385,
0.0308139268,
0.0101007717,
-0.0072170175,
-0.0078716269,
-0.0632925779,
-0.0262253247,
0.0642324612,
0.0078416234,
0.0372308716,
-0.0307277031,
-0.0225496646,
-0.0568284765,
0.0457740389,
-0.0146215269,
-0.0061456906,
-0.0195986461,
0.0262872092,
2.627e-7,
0.0724969357,
0.0613138117,
0.0450850651,
0.0359413214,
0.0020873724,
-0.0342209451,
-0.0306932312,
0.0091372188,
-0.0404858515,
-0.0987073779,
0.0200834442,
-0.0183948707,
0.0248394161,
0.0228630006,
-0.0715309232,
-0.0516972728,
-0.0441193879,
-0.0406364836,
-0.0553869531,
-0.0303432476,
0.0756821334,
0.0330858342,
-0.0108557437,
0.0268321745,
-0.0059702825,
-0.0023354734,
0.023251269,
-0.0196945313,
0.0241892952,
0.0428562127,
-0.0444707647,
-0.0168590043,
0.0243809987,
0.0597222522,
0.0002710413,
-0.0437035896,
-0.0196089745,
0.0772148743,
-0.0307599939,
-0.0128900623,
0.0502098352,
-0.0257743075,
0.0413806178,
-0.0450101197,
-0.0019129334,
-0.0645959899,
-0.0373066589,
0.0200612973,
0.0190769248,
-0.0201812722,
0.0272906218,
-0.0245992523,
0.0359842591,
0.0523307286,
-0.0385920368,
0.0184325408,
0.0081415037,
-0.0369633362,
-0.0203722995,
0.0316020474,
-0.0467560254,
-0.051054962,
-0.0333124734,
0.005806095,
0.0074371267,
-0.0698570982,
0.0078758383,
2.41666279e-34,
0.0607945956,
-0.0106959883,
0.0125041725,
0.038984444,
0.0234484449,
-0.0114707127,
0.0080372272,
0.0263011046,
0.0039739441,
-0.0588719808,
-0.01206306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10631v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10631v3 | Llemma: An Open Language Model For Mathematics | 2023-10-16T17:54:07 | 2024-03-15T19:14:39 | Zhangir Azerbayev, Hailey Schoelkopf, Keiran Paster, Marco Dos Santos, Stephen McAleer, Albert Q. Jiang, Jia Deng, Stella Biderman, Sean Welleck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | We present Llemma, a large language model for mathematics. We continue
pretraining Code Llama on the Proof-Pile-2, a mixture of scientific papers, web
data containing mathematics, and mathematical code, yielding Llemma. On the
MATH benchmark Llemma outperforms all known open base models, as well as the
unreleased Minerva model suite on an equi-parameter basis. Moreover, Llemma is
capable of tool use and formal theorem proving without any further finetuning.
We openly release all artifacts, including 7 billion and 34 billion parameter
models, the Proof-Pile-2, and code to replicate our experiments. | [
-0.0412993282,
0.1368567497,
-0.0044946428,
0.0691567361,
-0.0180851538,
0.0183559936,
-0.0129515287,
-0.0053126621,
-0.0373402871,
0.0059413188,
-0.0046747867,
0.0175119005,
-0.0283765141,
0.0443334654,
0.0242314171,
-0.0408270024,
0.0118655059,
-0.0575900301,
-0.0187512692,
-0.0241193343,
-0.0308080688,
-0.0282679796,
-0.0153366914,
-0.0208728705,
-0.0013258867,
-0.0650248602,
0.0090059433,
-0.0503253266,
-0.0228965636,
-0.0008784315,
-0.0302017331,
0.0530866571,
-0.0146472715,
0.0756228715,
0.0000020849,
-0.0560301468,
0.0063721668,
0.0465085022,
-0.0604289845,
0.054264348,
-0.0255104788,
-0.0307530668,
0.0003028371,
0.0001488974,
-0.0470280796,
-0.0028417148,
0.0313275754,
-0.0134218633,
0.0624199323,
0.048033569,
0.0165960323,
-0.0885882825,
0.0572544262,
-0.0257879552,
0.0239828285,
-0.0449710824,
0.0224329252,
-0.0078411698,
0.0391816907,
0.0218716878,
0.001358754,
0.0331935175,
0.0393797308,
-0.0114004901,
-0.0095759556,
0.0186966024,
-0.022378346,
0.022191612,
0.002308392,
0.0685912594,
-0.0031792161,
-0.0549815111,
-0.0128986239,
0.0190870706,
-0.0444670543,
0.0177022647,
-0.0692588761,
0.0645642653,
0.0310244132,
0.0005791309,
0.0099600917,
-0.0192603581,
0.0530435182,
0.0142081967,
-0.0186199881,
0.114834331,
0.0455811024,
-0.0245834328,
-0.0289000161,
-0.0066149128,
-0.0486985371,
-0.0648667291,
0.0138949705,
0.039690081,
0.0400631242,
0.0111031076,
-0.0413276814,
-0.0455679968,
0.0049054902,
-0.0539254993,
0.042515669,
0.0565976799,
-0.0043758997,
0.0424469709,
-0.0087139402,
0.0019537159,
-0.0426994115,
0.0312463567,
0.0039008928,
0.0208111089,
0.0187580176,
0.0211497042,
0.0050265947,
0.0366563499,
0.0172639769,
0.0344691053,
-0.0338083282,
0.0378979705,
-0.0384564027,
0.0467486456,
-0.022734385,
-0.0520747378,
-0.0048033916,
-0.0240944047,
-0.0082591008,
-0.0488131456,
-0.0332106948,
0.0022725912,
-0.006042819,
-0.0488543548,
-0.0432157218,
0.0314729773,
-0.0419017896,
0.0040413127,
0.0049300897,
0.0719486177,
0.0486342758,
0.0256124828,
0.0045112232,
-0.0333528817,
0.057620272,
-0.0629603639,
-0.0068600946,
-0.1297245026,
0.0454943292,
0.0298444461,
-0.0054965122,
-0.0320366472,
-0.0292036384,
0.0173685774,
0.0076330402,
0.047349941,
-0.0384397283,
0.0055689514,
0.0275348164,
0.0118420068,
-0.0456047095,
0.0040401327,
-0.0001692649,
-0.0169074684,
0.0300351568,
-0.0056453031,
0.0261664148,
0.0460603535,
0.0156050865,
-0.0039549624,
-0.0084894197,
0.056335859,
0.0493810512,
0.0581488945,
-0.0179690626,
0.0552053005,
-0.0532860272,
-0.0399143808,
-0.0239582341,
0.0626429394,
0.0036676908,
0.031878382,
0.0107427957,
-0.0274695139,
0.0858690068,
-0.0338481516,
-0.0436141863,
0.0189178493,
-0.0290014837,
0.0156830382,
0.0211646855,
-0.0178288985,
-0.0181308035,
-0.0452824645,
-0.0224422216,
-0.0277264919,
-0.08358372,
-0.0390943252,
0.0582616068,
-0.0218359474,
0.0310321171,
0.0566025153,
0.0138314208,
-0.057287693,
-0.036422234,
-0.0261737816,
0.0965874344,
-0.0439465865,
0.0551138371,
-0.093084164,
0.0096990364,
-0.0461209454,
0.0268791877,
0.0443227477,
0.0134296445,
-0.0085501485,
-0.0221141744,
-0.0088200374,
0.0246328246,
-0.0299050398,
0.0284904428,
-0.0106051601,
0.0296272077,
-0.0106111523,
0.0132219158,
-0.015515076,
-0.0153754894,
0.0259880722,
-0.0417277627,
-0.0475612357,
-0.0082646841,
-0.0223315079,
0.0540835187,
-0.0214785989,
-0.0187748671,
0.0518457964,
0.046273049,
-0.0092338491,
0.0037423144,
-0.0322647542,
-0.0140134962,
0.0008528241,
0.0697113872,
-0.0542293079,
-0.0028347538,
0.0210388191,
-0.0559089109,
0.0011263154,
0.0885873139,
0.015492647,
0.0288153104,
-0.0267121922,
0.0133781275,
-0.0069802753,
-0.003557811,
0.03173583,
0.0267118346,
-0.0102671441,
0.0162030999,
0.0457399078,
-0.0238180608,
0.0061930669,
0.016268447,
-0.0288653001,
0.0108521441,
-0.0038625419,
0.069027923,
-0.0475754589,
-0.0030656124,
-0.0072087762,
-0.0218138732,
-0.0113490764,
0.0308685396,
-0.015031497,
0.0642256513,
0.0306813624,
-0.0246904176,
-0.0185461994,
-0.0088635348,
0.0121621592,
-0.0271156095,
-0.0101451781,
-0.0232325364,
0.0281345695,
-0.0004474809,
-0.0226782653,
-0.0458540395,
-0.0365971327,
-0.0309927519,
0.0613545924,
-0.019604912,
0.0343366414,
-0.0131158624,
0.0123543246,
-0.0365274958,
0.0244746134,
-0.0169844646,
0.0373623371,
0.0371482447,
-0.0417044684,
0.021814324,
0.0407727361,
-0.0254818965,
0.0191307031,
0.017081026,
-0.0192913655,
-0.0233126767,
-0.0220465139,
-0.0116590541,
-0.038443096,
0.0033616524,
0.0063055824,
-0.0015597801,
0.070218645,
-0.0614643395,
-0.0374655239,
-0.0063113109,
0.0465141162,
0.0055974103,
0.0358643122,
-0.0024134195,
0.011174446,
-0.0191121288,
0.0146795977,
-0.0074685304,
-0.061061617,
0.0056267316,
-0.044749476,
0.0002419408,
-0.0331181437,
-0.0007405105,
-0.0997887775,
0.0110173132,
-0.0064474503,
-0.0155392159,
-0.00737142,
0.0309704039,
0.0131984167,
0.0061672288,
0.0094209071,
-0.0142429527,
0.0417167805,
-0.0404751338,
0.0405235775,
-0.0121779442,
-0.0280206893,
-0.0237876289,
0.0180118177,
-0.0328641608,
0.0297067687,
-0.0544797257,
-0.056042511,
-0.0292635951,
-0.0246607717,
0.0163028389,
0.0155240288,
-0.0056630615,
0.0032020235,
-0.0215518009,
-0.0425769277,
-0.0230964441,
0.0279765707,
0.022740487,
-0.0669369772,
-0.011836282,
0.0382278375,
0.0097506521,
0.0078303404,
-0.0267175473,
-0.0107607674,
0.0156446528,
-0.0461240001,
-0.0549365804,
0.0258236807,
-0.0355765186,
-0.0350297578,
0.0120819788,
0.0888982788,
0.0200620294,
-0.0333825499,
-0.0046814946,
-0.0554091148,
0.0301690903,
0.0264695734,
0.0148156723,
-0.1237756088,
-0.0051342035,
0.0007999038,
-0.002403192,
0.0348630659,
-0.0128482524,
0.0041930391,
-0.1018789411,
0.0357337929,
0.0446817912,
-0.0280208774,
0.0421635285,
-0.0256105419,
0.0141013609,
-0.0031396414,
-0.0400700308,
0.0380739123,
-0.0122737288,
0.0455930345,
-0.0042394116,
0.0227820072,
-0.0337990858,
0.0233208258,
-0.0385121815,
-0.0033474453,
-0.0375933461,
0.0174042415,
-0.0374031104,
-0.0861570463,
0.0408673994,
0.0429076292,
-0.0646321252,
-0.0011237446,
-0.019708056,
-0.0007732103,
-0.0156506896,
-0.0020268997,
0.0571935885,
-0.062104322,
-0.0193458963,
0.0426021665,
0.1051079184,
0.0118932165,
-0.004964001,
-0.0276889261,
-0.0265003666,
-0.0533310622,
0.0339541398,
0.0106029892,
0.0220700521,
-0.0270828605,
-0.0643056929,
-0.037560802,
0.0130207185,
-0.0272103306,
-0.0287719369,
0.0271142721,
-0.0377234146,
-0.0147915399,
0.0264439713,
0.0337676965,
0.0291999318,
0.0167735275,
-0.0303625055,
0.0063959435,
-0.0447974093,
-0.0430069454,
0.0514080301,
-0.0613172427,
0.0529945642,
-0.0800141692,
0.0268786959,
-0.0001270094,
0.0168673601,
-0.0400642827,
0.0170434788,
-0.0903799608,
-0.0522705279,
-0.0170216952,
0.079795368,
0.0232378654,
0.0012825258,
-0.0067956476,
-0.0388487205,
-0.0124980425,
0.0077825906,
-0.0416821912,
0.0615488589,
0.0567617789,
-0.0309218094,
0.0177393593,
0.0183672961,
0.0322413296,
-0.0063415025,
0.0001526787,
-0.0036359734,
-0.0048008598,
-0.0312868133,
-0.0116614765,
0.0591788143,
-0.0149373952,
0.0489657857,
-0.012138606,
-0.0088106645,
0.0302644689,
-0.0212542284,
0.0159412827,
-0.0398897752,
0.0256857555,
-0.0043902495,
-0.0099562611,
-0.0050406251,
0.0018011078,
0.0076887948,
0.041290272,
0.0247554164,
0.0619491264,
0.0049822838,
0.043835219,
0.0728399381,
-0.0267181806,
0.0064863935,
-0.0048718164,
-0.0536114462,
0.0482747518,
-0.0194605794,
-0.0131686507,
0.0202285424,
0.0489460975,
0.0077601904,
-0.0014225522,
-0.0250425469,
-0.1130611002,
0.0002278523,
0.0569716766,
0.0224068183,
0.0588566028,
0.0053670253,
-0.0405909382,
-0.0067660883,
-0.024717886,
0.0584917255,
-0.0051138881,
-0.0123329107,
0.0442682058,
0.0293877516,
0.0065649846,
-0.0305714943,
0.0481328107,
-0.0099193286,
0.0332758315,
0.0154268816,
0.0525715612,
-0.0355920084,
-0.001942722,
-0.0013680269,
0.0221162401,
-0.0099770213,
-0.0127968611,
-0.0450774767,
-0.0560129397,
0.0446861163,
0.0273036044,
-0.0450091884,
0.0069484287,
0.0292046964,
0.0663150772,
-0.002288281,
0.0038315805,
0.0037604105,
0.0185235571,
-0.0170718152,
-0.0807368308,
0.0092718489,
-5.780345799e-33,
-0.0046716915,
0.0137956776,
0.023407029,
0.0441031754,
0.0125645548,
-0.0194113329,
-0.0266561937,
0.0250534695,
-0.0139497146,
-0.0038806938,
-0.0042292532,
0.0603994541,
-0.0009955898,
-0.0110710831,
0.0145651959,
0.0056042327,
0.0079372786,
-0.0212927982,
-0.0280725844,
-0.0147802141,
0.0059689074,
-0.0027471392,
0.0936712474,
-0.0510676093,
0.0284605063,
-0.0234714523,
0.0018980154,
0.0065741022,
-0.0689085871,
0.0824338794,
-0.0376116857,
0.0248959213,
-0.022438379,
0.0157552082,
-0.0165723357,
-0.0148854647,
-0.0205185283,
-0.038700901,
0.0251348931,
0.0075539816,
-0.0400557667,
-0.0688942,
0.0342805572,
0.0291321799,
-0.0375954434,
-0.0238299761,
0.0110754445,
-0.025614962,
-0.0234253015,
0.0230221562,
-0.0214482974,
0.0389471874,
-0.000062863,
0.0031464363,
0.0048508951,
-0.0505613834,
-0.0160499495,
-0.002519941,
0.0013899268,
0.0155047756,
0.0373806693,
0.0226462688,
0.0350606553,
-0.0545558408,
0.0213555247,
0.014160757,
0.0147735635,
-0.0156968962,
-0.01127527,
0.0135088405,
0.0280978512,
0.0979185551,
0.0452732667,
0.0122883786,
0.0260020159,
0.0528645292,
-0.0420281105,
0.0004437541,
0.0125370445,
0.0309332311,
-0.0145225599,
0.0123505788,
-0.0175904203,
-0.0093926312,
-0.0424535647,
0.0060230503,
-0.0433139764,
0.0082210684,
-0.0022598221,
-0.0045961938,
-0.0211247895,
-0.004960692,
-0.00168656,
-0.0554311424,
-0.0384762324,
0.0089272996,
-0.002754112,
0.0116300825,
0.0046162461,
0.0314014442,
-0.0739641488,
-0.0191305671,
-0.0370134823,
-0.0077572986,
0.0269870367,
0.0178750586,
0.0065146242,
0.0491506569,
-0.0296668448,
-0.0044730511,
-0.0386537425,
-0.0246086232,
0.0506590158,
0.0689462721,
0.0381555893,
0.0267663337,
0.0371862836,
0.042867519,
-0.0242499728,
-0.012474725,
-0.0311194267,
0.0459381379,
0.0198327098,
0.0327374935,
-0.002898775,
-0.0213285238,
-0.0335600637,
-0.0031866173,
0.0545270443,
-0.0731573924,
0.0049539041,
0.0182574112,
2.792e-7,
0.0483188778,
0.0125512658,
0.0387232974,
0.0614560246,
0.0166007243,
0.0136391893,
-0.0520983227,
0.012795222,
-0.0048811501,
-0.0098053925,
-0.0240658596,
0.0310324077,
0.0267219096,
0.0104211867,
-0.0534782335,
0.0097321048,
-0.0432951413,
-0.011025073,
-0.0523977093,
-0.0700505152,
0.0191309638,
0.0606392175,
0.052521158,
0.0233786553,
-0.026414562,
-0.0435871519,
0.0697894394,
0.0007739312,
0.0005995379,
0.0309229903,
-0.0039935359,
0.0166936722,
0.0013809077,
-0.0327287465,
-0.0023100409,
0.0329630114,
0.0056565432,
0.0816470608,
0.0428994931,
0.0643133223,
-0.0067211948,
-0.08111725,
-0.0128653282,
-0.0148167554,
0.0519887246,
0.0056489264,
-0.0431549586,
-0.0309652258,
-0.0176575705,
-0.021885626,
0.0344213247,
-0.0238153748,
0.0556053855,
-0.0115440777,
0.0153850783,
-0.0202320516,
-0.0065989089,
-0.0492737405,
-0.0584055968,
-0.001296471,
-0.0499692149,
-0.0447144024,
-0.0270278882,
-0.0081640454,
0.0130281886,
-0.0332189016,
-0.0075871418,
2.830291013e-34,
0.070244506,
-0.0040416247,
0.0340806358,
0.0627425164,
0.0136869177,
-0.0210061688,
0.0126204574,
0.0007170507,
0.0215765182,
-0.0680693239,
-0.0223247055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10628v1 | Data Contamination Through the Lens of Time | 2023-10-16T17:51:29 | 2023-10-16T17:51:29 | Manley Roberts, Himanshu Thakur, Christine Herlihy, Colin White, Samuel Dooley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent claims about the impressive abilities of large language models (LLMs)
are often supported by evaluating publicly available benchmarks. Since LLMs
train on wide swaths of the internet, this practice raises concerns of data
contamination, i.e., evaluating on examples that are explicitly or implicitly
included in the training data. Data contamination remains notoriously
challenging to measure and mitigate, even with partial attempts like controlled
experimentation of training data, canary strings, or embedding similarities. In
this work, we conduct the first thorough longitudinal analysis of data
contamination in LLMs by using the natural experiment of training cutoffs in
GPT models to look at benchmarks released over time. Specifically, we consider
two code/mathematical problem-solving datasets, Codeforces and Project Euler,
and find statistically significant trends among LLM pass rate vs. GitHub
popularity and release date that provide strong evidence of contamination. By
open-sourcing our dataset, raw results, and evaluation framework, our work
paves the way for rigorous analyses of data contamination in modern models. We
conclude with a discussion of best practices and future steps for publicly
releasing benchmarks in the age of LLMs that train on webscale data. | [
-0.0008795326,
0.1205462813,
-0.0297299251,
0.0364860669,
-0.044747889,
-0.0077459533,
-0.0270763543,
0.0165968612,
-0.017556956,
-0.0124200201,
-0.0002875283,
-0.003075409,
0.0157960411,
0.0242211483,
0.0221906435,
-0.0085160593,
0.0515135452,
-0.0309537705,
-0.0412019603,
-0.007570059,
-0.003806965,
0.0036691225,
0.0165354516,
0.0403861962,
0.0099015292,
-0.0420379341,
0.0088990675,
-0.0317284316,
-0.0276516192,
-0.0428960174,
0.0047694915,
0.0354158282,
0.0064351996,
0.0724436864,
0.0000020009,
-0.0303055514,
-0.0067986893,
0.0426947884,
-0.0308538731,
0.0617436022,
-0.0118133565,
0.0064605693,
-0.0127307335,
0.0395053923,
-0.0264509898,
-0.0090919686,
0.0369707718,
-0.0240814611,
0.0604173206,
0.0416696854,
0.0093050571,
0.0362787172,
0.0532287247,
-0.0119680585,
0.0427869894,
-0.0074115,
0.0062754052,
0.0150847677,
0.0187761392,
0.0075145601,
-0.0288262386,
0.0403084531,
0.0275487266,
0.0443054996,
-0.015289492,
0.0573106855,
-0.0753985867,
0.0050014975,
-0.0001591811,
0.0429870039,
-0.0272227544,
-0.0291767176,
0.0076996833,
-0.0261414032,
-0.0336999036,
0.0084687453,
-0.0364906415,
0.0266590323,
0.0036221796,
0.0178878382,
-0.0096073002,
-0.061008893,
0.0673864335,
-0.0090482263,
-0.013094509,
0.1030260175,
0.0234432574,
-0.0338411219,
0.0066442606,
0.0051735728,
-0.0218967423,
-0.0384028964,
-0.0071163476,
0.0007654359,
0.0305501707,
0.029720189,
-0.0486275591,
-0.0165832918,
0.0309366696,
-0.0162074436,
0.0244902875,
0.0313709043,
-0.0084918374,
0.0338215232,
0.0031750272,
0.0555542335,
-0.0193987936,
-0.0008031165,
-0.0031230249,
0.0257011615,
-0.0244130976,
-0.0082972012,
-0.0190987699,
0.039841231,
0.028296072,
0.016253667,
-0.0123301204,
0.0515723154,
-0.0154968761,
0.0259148739,
-0.0273790695,
-0.0170784201,
-0.0325555317,
0.0076470198,
-0.0199436769,
-0.0248650797,
-0.0353568383,
0.009418725,
-0.0030149459,
-0.0869415924,
-0.0227747224,
-0.0102018537,
-0.0226599313,
-0.0647482798,
0.0208690707,
0.0568334162,
0.0258020256,
-0.0019882412,
-0.0381131507,
-0.0359026231,
-0.0086204745,
-0.026880201,
-0.0011432505,
-0.0711896271,
-0.018587118,
0.0365390666,
0.0027236643,
-0.0449029095,
-0.0220597554,
0.0324269421,
-0.0435590856,
0.0481050126,
-0.0361033157,
0.0135796294,
0.0007817188,
0.0073057115,
-0.0337906927,
0.0552660525,
0.0395066068,
-0.01449979,
0.0300466791,
-0.0442229994,
0.0366680548,
0.0562847815,
0.0333562531,
0.0318067484,
-0.0045005786,
0.0302761532,
0.0564028881,
0.0221722461,
-0.0068071731,
0.0725072995,
-0.0263559241,
-0.0068393443,
0.0574018396,
0.0398268513,
-0.0158626251,
0.0179242678,
0.0046695299,
0.0191191845,
0.0258119833,
0.0000297888,
-0.0762792677,
-0.027118843,
-0.0238216426,
0.0104787573,
0.0108272666,
0.0236092042,
-0.01784949,
-0.0405559801,
-0.0194268487,
-0.0085985977,
-0.0287662633,
0.0038570426,
0.0612067431,
-0.0190285631,
-0.0462297946,
0.0404339097,
0.0047725416,
-0.0425906032,
0.0013362664,
-0.043627277,
0.0225741621,
0.0286978129,
0.0723154694,
-0.0358716212,
-0.0184685774,
-0.0200034324,
0.0288538057,
-0.0409874171,
0.0288566723,
-0.0014457018,
0.0380028859,
-0.0253927056,
-0.0271156132,
-0.0346511342,
-0.0014960894,
-0.0036762406,
0.0540083051,
0.0182934701,
0.015799202,
-0.0485831313,
-0.0442691147,
0.0457530208,
-0.0302628595,
-0.0025011478,
-0.0225817133,
-0.0220650062,
0.0193836726,
-0.0275971908,
-0.0472276211,
0.0050099422,
0.0344434194,
0.021332562,
-0.0011161815,
-0.0379702076,
-0.0034932066,
0.0298797376,
0.0523674898,
-0.0660172105,
-0.0236214381,
0.0508651733,
-0.0544845685,
-0.0086753815,
0.030355379,
-0.0087227542,
0.05786971,
0.0055028461,
0.0354427211,
-0.0395995751,
0.0073537054,
-0.0150346719,
0.0316998102,
0.0032499179,
0.0444658138,
-0.0069810385,
0.040328905,
0.0239062663,
-0.0108991507,
-0.0618356355,
0.0216447264,
-0.0192103684,
0.0431859158,
0.0153946765,
0.0092797587,
-0.0558462702,
-0.0319412872,
-0.072301127,
0.0045419037,
-0.0053387554,
0.0514000654,
0.0000793405,
-0.0161509663,
-0.0310892332,
-0.0038155722,
-0.0128792385,
-0.0383043997,
-0.0086621745,
0.0414237902,
0.0377787389,
0.0007806317,
-0.0219725203,
-0.0510166213,
-0.0307601653,
-0.0443490259,
0.0570465438,
-0.0164647028,
0.001298312,
-0.0398302525,
0.0748717189,
-0.0383525081,
0.0301886201,
-0.0325824432,
-0.0095952125,
0.0400658101,
-0.0063609933,
0.0530066192,
0.0447301082,
-0.0082438029,
-0.0034031738,
0.0523972064,
-0.0136455856,
-0.0575493313,
0.0024190154,
0.0207946319,
-0.0653584972,
-0.0288217738,
-0.0374784321,
0.0221956372,
0.0556318648,
-0.030791726,
-0.0328068174,
-0.0391169749,
0.0370103233,
-0.0446206816,
0.0025748056,
-0.0011016857,
0.0004481839,
-0.0351012163,
0.0109750312,
-0.0202671736,
-0.1096810326,
0.0286879204,
-0.0307480358,
0.0026489734,
-0.0082622543,
-0.0174327996,
-0.0356296338,
0.0500209071,
0.0129612191,
-0.0030147845,
0.007355127,
-0.0214945078,
-0.0451544933,
0.0184169523,
0.0189097803,
-0.049900949,
0.053303849,
-0.0407561474,
0.020401204,
0.0018691292,
-0.0548120439,
-0.0109333489,
-0.0323908702,
-0.0078238705,
-0.0276059918,
0.0275363456,
-0.0172863118,
0.0185941253,
-0.0230426285,
-0.0113755129,
0.0382417105,
0.0152051682,
-0.030582767,
-0.0113819828,
-0.0132068675,
0.0226209294,
-0.0642954707,
0.0234892685,
-0.0503825918,
-0.0229349826,
0.0383086503,
0.1149594858,
0.0227527618,
-0.056192331,
-0.0000358791,
0.0171101894,
-0.026069928,
-0.0396253131,
0.0607194602,
0.0148578454,
-0.0602668151,
-0.0008122229,
0.0827437788,
0.0286230519,
-0.0401377492,
0.005638442,
0.0172917899,
0.0471243896,
0.0470477305,
0.0030704332,
-0.0905027464,
0.0112600885,
0.0248086508,
0.0337294415,
-0.0131671391,
-0.0384778418,
-0.0262658857,
-0.1375970244,
0.0121426024,
0.0212758407,
-0.0328072794,
0.0189095046,
-0.0570630953,
-0.0208640266,
-0.0318580531,
0.0182942301,
0.001384421,
-0.0214571059,
0.0416023172,
0.0100462465,
-0.053127259,
-0.0486667566,
0.0507320203,
-0.0234454386,
0.0536012352,
0.036705099,
0.0102883205,
-0.043557521,
-0.0077444734,
0.0776565522,
0.0031108896,
-0.0241911151,
0.001120632,
0.0742855221,
-0.0007736012,
-0.0197129343,
0.0289364494,
0.0034338338,
-0.0489280224,
0.0139459306,
0.0345737934,
0.0872336179,
-0.0012764313,
-0.040252313,
-0.0131097557,
-0.0574068502,
-0.0231269822,
0.0677910894,
-0.0034389221,
-0.0204546452,
-0.0250813067,
-0.046248056,
0.03265284,
0.0198665131,
0.012419085,
0.0112991044,
0.0141590089,
-0.0011993165,
-0.0162242614,
-0.0492308959,
0.0313268676,
0.0368117765,
0.026527008,
0.0309201088,
-0.0120384349,
0.0089742625,
-0.046893049,
0.0686139092,
-0.0408988185,
0.0315978713,
-0.090913184,
0.0227704626,
-0.012492328,
0.023762431,
-0.0325350463,
0.0266828313,
-0.1365836263,
-0.0760837644,
-0.0093606357,
0.0467786901,
0.0343619809,
0.0236477852,
-0.0076954882,
-0.0355566442,
-0.0215226673,
0.0169584844,
-0.0482413433,
0.014020266,
0.0218209717,
-0.0483179875,
0.0302421693,
-0.0038164291,
-0.0520382784,
-0.0344194733,
0.0156926345,
-0.009684396,
-0.0133860642,
0.0547423549,
0.024774095,
0.033043921,
0.04566269,
0.0158463251,
0.0086980658,
-0.0111603579,
0.0048691025,
0.0054325918,
-0.0039329464,
-0.0440444052,
-0.0095041078,
0.0293535609,
0.0128905755,
-0.0141968876,
0.0302855615,
0.0145340124,
0.0709197447,
-0.0580643862,
0.0218971409,
0.024736464,
0.0313418731,
0.0952226222,
-0.0096171489,
0.0035938814,
0.0014419111,
-0.0180807468,
0.0407087915,
0.0076074493,
0.020337157,
0.0015129808,
0.0406334251,
0.0419692174,
-0.0003343544,
-0.0793681145,
-0.0945303813,
-0.0105350967,
-0.0077263825,
0.0367905088,
0.0231283307,
0.0297877025,
-0.0071145929,
0.0057123639,
-0.0358017869,
-0.0102312425,
-0.0100160819,
-0.0304703861,
0.0185281578,
0.0149597451,
-0.0328423232,
0.0305419974,
0.1050280035,
0.0333662257,
0.0634296015,
-0.0123210698,
-0.0058803256,
-0.0058990768,
-0.0088138422,
0.0359899998,
0.0033451628,
-0.0050376323,
-0.0578707159,
-0.0383062996,
-0.1025258452,
-0.0178323574,
0.0153001882,
0.0147593739,
-0.0139330374,
0.0238231588,
0.0882757455,
-0.0236835275,
-0.0008879273,
-0.0163621772,
-0.0014904911,
0.0248983037,
-0.0438325405,
-0.0171814207,
-5.905587375e-33,
0.0248552896,
0.0118165407,
0.0091510294,
0.0272367299,
-0.0192722138,
0.0426713452,
-0.0204941593,
0.0083561139,
-0.0411533006,
-0.0315286443,
-0.0335980393,
0.0572009459,
0.0010485443,
-0.0077954913,
0.0362541452,
-0.0123761436,
0.0348912403,
-0.0073610134,
-0.0449632406,
0.0313148946,
-0.0312708914,
0.02580739,
0.0603741519,
-0.0547695197,
0.0040468876,
-0.0131688705,
-0.0024017692,
-0.0056294203,
0.0001620442,
0.050789088,
-0.0010764919,
0.0355563425,
0.0021295839,
-0.0398071781,
-0.03067437,
-0.058254391,
-0.0105747944,
-0.012402365,
-0.0023738281,
0.0054990388,
0.0011823268,
-0.0259319115,
0.0569697544,
0.0066028829,
-0.0361371227,
-0.0081801498,
0.0123765022,
-0.0099975923,
-0.045369111,
-0.0059222756,
0.001015094,
0.0341475122,
-0.0271160323,
0.0427878462,
0.0364349745,
0.000472605,
0.0172031447,
0.0569304414,
-0.0065308139,
0.0086257225,
0.0578179285,
0.0412459932,
0.072104089,
-0.0134011116,
0.0206475314,
0.0620553978,
0.0540579706,
0.0253330786,
0.0392195135,
-0.0152118029,
0.046540536,
0.0408445001,
0.0161318965,
0.0023430486,
0.0712188855,
-0.0113731865,
-0.037993513,
-0.0056350599,
0.0057846881,
0.0021155691,
0.0040947688,
0.0091088666,
-0.0646750256,
-0.0203806851,
-0.0599644482,
-0.0076615489,
-0.0199966356,
-0.0279087815,
0.0422378555,
-0.0044811703,
0.0084827198,
0.0026480809,
0.0017307302,
-0.0466269664,
-0.0619458221,
0.0130786495,
-0.0358961076,
0.042481292,
-0.0007656569,
0.0652568564,
-0.0631706938,
-0.0148111824,
-0.0263917278,
0.0053940928,
0.0698307678,
-0.0102382153,
0.0083140284,
0.0365187116,
-0.0931257978,
-0.0013351905,
-0.0524644069,
-0.0058885473,
0.0223157816,
-0.0038910378,
0.057276886,
-0.0191553198,
0.0314602666,
0.0136466054,
0.0250458438,
0.0099752275,
-0.0678953826,
0.0139885135,
-0.01661391,
-0.0204409305,
0.0267900396,
-0.0661821663,
-0.0343513191,
0.0564632863,
0.066482082,
-0.0578980818,
-0.0368744172,
0.0063348133,
2.718e-7,
0.0244038589,
0.0404375084,
0.0149497846,
0.0327289216,
0.0176081024,
0.002676903,
-0.0524123944,
0.000257721,
0.0131055126,
0.0134563651,
-0.0164671708,
-0.0037854186,
0.0448951647,
0.0503423624,
-0.0637918487,
-0.0077553764,
-0.0568328723,
-0.0125155272,
-0.0994939953,
0.0051655495,
0.0013680719,
0.0844297186,
0.0276532862,
-0.005985959,
0.0106028691,
-0.0707282424,
0.0403615162,
-0.0489255488,
-0.0068336339,
0.0465091951,
-0.0348849148,
0.0430876315,
-0.0114729721,
-0.0050791344,
-0.015176272,
-0.0178025868,
0.0116360113,
0.0174868964,
0.0156944729,
0.0385452099,
-0.0027431617,
-0.0396946333,
-0.0343852639,
-0.0638875291,
0.0781217217,
-0.0022538998,
-0.0222532451,
-0.027202623,
-0.0299421679,
-0.0718858093,
0.0537356436,
-0.0049352073,
0.0286539961,
-0.0075908871,
-0.0172507502,
-0.0175777394,
-0.0261746515,
-0.0386812426,
-0.02021005,
0.003612201,
-0.0292715169,
-0.0785128474,
-0.0687744319,
0.0291400496,
0.0082284538,
-0.028904181,
0.0347409658,
2.810401511e-34,
0.05181095,
-0.0711439922,
0.0432104357,
0.0139038125,
0.0525974631,
0.0061638514,
0.0243103523,
-0.0127931116,
-0.0346519798,
-0.0321431495,
-0.0188990422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10627v1 | Factored Verification: Detecting and Reducing Hallucination in Summaries of Academic Papers | 2023-10-16T17:51:17 | 2023-10-16T17:51:17 | Charlie George, Andreas Stuhlmüller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hallucination plagues even frontier LLMs--but how bad is it really for
summarizing academic papers? We evaluate Factored Verification, a simple
automated method for detecting hallucinations in abstractive summaries. This
method sets a new SotA on hallucination detection in the summarization task of
the HaluEval benchmark, achieving 76.2% accuracy. We then use this method to
estimate how often language models hallucinate when summarizing across multiple
academic papers and find 0.62 hallucinations in the average ChatGPT (16k)
summary, 0.84 for GPT-4, and 1.55 for Claude 2. We ask models to self-correct
using Factored Critiques and find that this lowers the number of hallucinations
to 0.49 for ChatGPT, 0.46 for GPT-4, and 0.95 for Claude 2. The hallucinations
we find are often subtle, so we advise caution when using models to synthesize
academic papers. | [
0.0050094766,
0.0502397865,
0.022367442,
0.0242105462,
-0.0206631646,
0.0223709159,
-0.0253314581,
0.0095744766,
-0.0195706487,
-0.0468420908,
0.001217389,
-0.0271571614,
0.0170318708,
-0.0179462787,
0.0329826996,
-0.0335859098,
0.0525743626,
-0.0308896117,
-0.0009924201,
-0.0079066558,
0.0193486474,
0.0003965907,
0.0071320557,
0.0248466246,
0.0375559069,
-0.0489394963,
0.0078866715,
0.0035288427,
0.0195939336,
0.0091794785,
-0.0059555816,
0.0900666341,
-0.0416192338,
0.0699923709,
0.0000020002,
-0.0744198561,
-0.0322909728,
0.0090271467,
0.0317246504,
0.0821101442,
0.0542413779,
0.0013776533,
-0.0171514545,
0.0119679011,
-0.0144748613,
0.0024679867,
-0.014940341,
0.0876817033,
0.0273617059,
0.0603901818,
0.0019000372,
-0.0276827347,
0.0708624348,
0.0271246415,
0.0140039027,
0.0076818494,
0.0289108027,
0.0213219989,
0.0001919006,
-0.0053574978,
0.0193907376,
0.0213004164,
-0.0041508041,
-0.0226667561,
-0.0115553113,
-0.0158119593,
-0.0870960802,
0.0141525576,
0.0259933416,
0.0187211204,
0.0094097266,
-0.0494289249,
0.042407006,
0.0148435012,
-0.0107128089,
0.0383578688,
-0.0507044196,
0.0393126495,
-0.040679872,
-0.0183278341,
0.0736720711,
0.0023214254,
0.0317934863,
0.0259518698,
-0.046773389,
0.0568425432,
0.0046479418,
-0.0600488372,
0.0262483768,
0.0051828749,
-0.0231313556,
-0.0476957522,
-0.0064856219,
0.0246793609,
-0.0074880933,
-0.0430248529,
-0.0175182745,
-0.0252404753,
0.0533890128,
-0.0609790012,
-0.0361338817,
-0.0087019643,
-0.0250594411,
0.018397063,
0.000573711,
0.0007874324,
-0.0043666246,
0.04624011,
-0.0060576582,
0.0419233479,
0.0014232916,
0.0122729633,
-0.0371064171,
0.0295751523,
-0.0074028792,
-0.0198365729,
-0.0437037349,
-0.0116464449,
-0.021748703,
0.0459928364,
-0.0387873426,
-0.0239349417,
0.0016750304,
-0.0268874764,
0.0248608235,
0.003265687,
-0.0125154722,
-0.0250150543,
0.0053238235,
-0.0421278439,
-0.0275621172,
0.0348442867,
-0.016165508,
0.0064651361,
-0.0047278642,
0.0107638044,
0.0174467117,
0.0004608863,
0.0033652694,
-0.052591268,
-0.0049352725,
-0.0636975616,
0.0242553651,
-0.0699957013,
-0.0138183348,
0.0067199189,
0.0056824978,
-0.0114884712,
-0.0076780845,
-0.0077135907,
-0.0248117615,
0.0441920571,
-0.064896524,
-0.0013890383,
0.0114206979,
0.0320233554,
-0.0330142863,
0.0357446223,
0.0234273206,
-0.0014525931,
0.0562448017,
-0.0096452506,
0.0796557143,
0.0450977422,
0.0005550453,
0.0291316472,
0.0332095288,
-0.0303810295,
-0.0018623424,
-0.0187502932,
0.0162289143,
0.0741481557,
-0.0284367744,
0.0194803327,
0.032845702,
0.0521822907,
0.0035179749,
0.0189959183,
-0.0216244869,
0.0289362893,
0.0720039979,
0.10285905,
-0.0309518576,
0.0174685139,
-0.0516595244,
0.0588794984,
0.0968794078,
0.0021567924,
-0.0058402233,
-0.051127404,
-0.0361858755,
0.0349095315,
-0.0176816918,
-0.0420404077,
0.0163443498,
-0.0005902356,
-0.0455229096,
0.0302519165,
0.007701965,
-0.0587324351,
0.0070722043,
-0.020357132,
0.0100909146,
0.0311613809,
0.100628905,
-0.0384312645,
0.0306735709,
-0.029687589,
0.0079117129,
0.0666250736,
0.0452644676,
-0.0000297328,
-0.0230611823,
-0.0439221114,
0.0155076422,
0.0047063227,
0.0547493398,
-0.0442707315,
-0.0176528729,
-0.0140061257,
0.0070038983,
-0.0095214313,
-0.078892462,
0.0285676643,
-0.0201187711,
-0.0107520474,
-0.0601652414,
-0.0380177051,
0.0237980951,
0.0038862163,
-0.0374488682,
0.0579275079,
-0.0055776942,
-0.0241132621,
-0.0099440292,
0.0262695141,
0.0126158809,
0.0144133195,
0.0428672545,
-0.0673220605,
0.0036566826,
-0.002365072,
0.0043517253,
-0.0270501524,
0.0127317002,
-0.0543854833,
0.0243478455,
-0.0336486511,
0.0669009909,
-0.0214485414,
0.0197206121,
-0.0001910491,
0.0437378772,
-0.017200226,
0.0573040545,
0.0410565287,
-0.0556750894,
-0.0106686121,
-0.0052016126,
-0.0207853466,
-0.006240109,
0.0224307291,
0.0214131586,
0.0261321962,
-0.0218423307,
-0.0251224339,
-0.0553731136,
-0.055817496,
0.0116094882,
-0.0254925955,
0.0272177141,
0.0449596532,
-0.0460075885,
-0.0109787257,
0.0340049118,
0.009117011,
-0.0314147212,
0.0189331938,
-0.0005737191,
0.0383661427,
-0.0113824448,
0.002715372,
-0.0547419265,
-0.0144205578,
-0.0347389504,
0.0390417352,
0.0183572639,
-0.0595775694,
-0.0868201107,
0.0663045794,
-0.0027390535,
-0.0261079129,
-0.0033113034,
0.0040090131,
0.0075947554,
-0.012455523,
0.0365588367,
0.032895308,
0.030004397,
0.0062206467,
0.0533176959,
-0.0131613463,
-0.0169482771,
-0.0283931643,
0.0038815439,
0.0170289464,
0.0347079672,
-0.0557106584,
0.0657479241,
0.0283406321,
-0.0176935438,
-0.0005839508,
-0.0079270266,
0.04186064,
-0.0426787101,
-0.0180848408,
0.0335149914,
-0.0166694149,
-0.0118926447,
0.0618896298,
-0.0055844965,
-0.0217662286,
0.0224965271,
-0.0536612011,
-0.0007815608,
-0.0385161489,
0.0336994044,
-0.0379350409,
-0.0093825767,
-0.0087589277,
-0.0124921193,
-0.0000256152,
-0.0234262943,
-0.0365200043,
-0.0221492331,
0.0087073008,
-0.0508991927,
0.0726965219,
-0.023785973,
0.0174336266,
-0.0154525004,
0.0114279799,
0.0129207019,
-0.0197465159,
-0.0039308551,
0.00877304,
0.0082900124,
-0.0206150953,
-0.0657945275,
0.0017880274,
0.018793216,
0.034098126,
-0.0482259467,
-0.0351307541,
-0.0119994022,
0.0194204804,
0.0631562397,
-0.0219354294,
0.0630618781,
-0.0861671641,
0.0352080837,
0.0665532798,
-0.0046825544,
0.0484940894,
0.0024291826,
-0.0566714257,
0.0157245342,
-0.0819720775,
-0.0298097692,
-0.0021542036,
0.0143228574,
-0.0361424759,
0.0032291706,
0.1226854697,
0.0057695834,
-0.0479827188,
-0.0082800994,
-0.0543015227,
0.0474920571,
-0.0113158543,
0.0110428249,
-0.0869658217,
0.0231701005,
0.0194733609,
0.0223549493,
0.0107387854,
-0.0253285579,
0.0085403183,
-0.0477893241,
0.0619480498,
0.0436362103,
-0.0429875106,
0.003441792,
0.0000047746,
0.0060269139,
-0.0046614697,
0.0133328522,
0.0348343328,
-0.0275256038,
-0.0128186056,
0.0139799342,
-0.0906923935,
0.0083600897,
-0.0260190573,
-0.0421834439,
0.015519808,
-0.0016354279,
0.030842673,
-0.0253031142,
-0.0749558583,
0.0459775031,
-0.0131696519,
-0.0293921605,
-0.0025748902,
0.0771285668,
0.0098585235,
0.0393447839,
-0.0023996895,
0.008333547,
-0.0080621196,
-0.0305750314,
0.0203478411,
0.0456460044,
-0.0198447537,
-0.0630499795,
-0.0635451302,
0.0788966343,
-0.0445402451,
0.0655815974,
0.0278711077,
0.0186711997,
-0.069126837,
-0.0256515536,
0.0221625548,
-0.0459118374,
-0.0499502309,
-0.0075368616,
0.0066435235,
-0.0053202757,
-0.0647215992,
-0.0551151782,
-0.0257455502,
0.0039222459,
0.0067622028,
0.0421441533,
-0.0256549027,
-0.0120117953,
-0.0475647897,
-0.0045991209,
-0.0317317285,
-0.0135188689,
-0.0269487277,
0.0378393084,
0.03728218,
0.0134328855,
0.0076664351,
0.0241096001,
-0.0577983744,
-0.0605103225,
0.002360265,
0.0081179002,
0.0359435342,
0.0295825023,
-0.0140696485,
-0.0212674662,
0.0377750285,
0.0260207448,
0.0239082556,
0.0554615334,
0.0129616894,
0.0039722905,
-0.0145263793,
-0.0082078278,
-0.0163262486,
0.0040472485,
-0.0336072184,
0.0096704047,
-0.0282983892,
-0.0206440631,
0.0256450791,
0.0469252653,
-0.0081990045,
-0.0206006896,
0.0281163678,
-0.0102947149,
-0.0037796677,
-0.0253991298,
-0.0137986997,
-0.0148379644,
0.0417885594,
-0.0089934999,
-0.0415779315,
0.0017338152,
0.0524157807,
-0.0418381765,
0.0108167771,
-0.0149811581,
-0.0112030413,
-0.0506266691,
0.0038951023,
-0.0038033817,
-0.0295939706,
-0.0252910089,
-0.0262576677,
-0.030218944,
0.0541488081,
0.027900923,
0.0396424867,
0.0154354321,
0.0118989097,
0.0109371245,
0.0239605773,
-0.1064362898,
-0.0617881529,
-0.0501188859,
0.0254799295,
0.0400206335,
0.000323807,
0.1148412004,
-0.0409470722,
0.008962837,
-0.040984448,
0.0398363471,
0.0572668053,
0.0091064954,
-0.0273300782,
0.0344396979,
-0.0233217068,
-0.0323973037,
0.0672896355,
-0.0190010145,
-0.0146551933,
0.024774354,
-0.0442874804,
-0.0277081877,
-0.0727814734,
-0.0512127243,
0.0115890419,
0.0079722023,
-0.0553266183,
-0.0785311982,
-0.0196716916,
0.0092496788,
0.0517484173,
0.0002594819,
-0.0139001682,
-0.0283922479,
0.0472366139,
-0.0052255942,
-0.0285085905,
-0.0293743331,
0.0183614809,
0.0165210404,
-0.0258614868,
0.0104714613,
-5.760763165e-33,
-0.0119097438,
-0.0322995894,
-0.0152863245,
0.0142668551,
-0.0318874866,
-0.0164673924,
-0.0460900031,
0.0064475783,
0.0259729028,
0.0216887426,
-0.0494726561,
0.0352451168,
0.0065920372,
-0.0197758041,
0.0246335883,
0.0408157855,
0.0551941842,
0.0095744729,
-0.0440495983,
0.0219493993,
0.0138421291,
-0.0158576798,
0.0579988211,
-0.0373918489,
0.0820403621,
-0.0561014451,
-0.0407463685,
-0.0354332924,
-0.0038601824,
0.01082158,
-0.0170572046,
-0.0255646277,
0.0225646533,
-0.0228758194,
-0.0347928517,
-0.0304820016,
-0.0412867256,
-0.0026076906,
0.0316290036,
0.0184261333,
-0.0360751823,
-0.0434666611,
0.0608908422,
-0.0191360842,
-0.0443819128,
-0.0477381237,
0.0484097041,
-0.0445988737,
-0.0507935509,
-0.0603902936,
-0.0569817759,
0.0367815048,
0.0037212172,
0.0402961709,
0.0149923796,
0.0378215164,
-0.0058594206,
-0.0055142478,
-0.0484666899,
0.0363110267,
0.0311780181,
0.0347852632,
0.0069726515,
-0.0594030917,
-0.0097805951,
0.0718190372,
0.0282677617,
0.0167101528,
-0.0085939793,
-0.0074335421,
0.0318655185,
0.0098598162,
0.0552476421,
0.0281291455,
0.1195949167,
0.0329552814,
-0.0055591557,
0.0626897439,
-0.0538281202,
0.0343197919,
0.0441333503,
-0.0213697366,
-0.0297781769,
-0.0290494896,
-0.0056733526,
0.0173237398,
-0.0046252413,
-0.0153936157,
-0.0117237223,
-0.0199912786,
-0.0323296674,
-0.0349009186,
-0.0004204244,
-0.0701222941,
0.0092175798,
0.0032509237,
-0.0337677039,
0.0438712277,
-0.0184254907,
-0.0235277079,
0.0005500631,
0.0088322209,
-0.0150301037,
0.0289317947,
0.0250158738,
0.0203969218,
0.048941236,
-0.0183477998,
-0.0605624206,
-0.0081139402,
0.0091274129,
0.0129045118,
0.0193031728,
-0.0018416626,
0.0279889349,
-0.025894139,
0.025764741,
-0.0314916223,
0.0119978348,
0.0373020284,
-0.000400812,
0.0809787065,
0.0099154795,
0.053987965,
0.0104276845,
0.009896718,
-0.0108999135,
0.0210974533,
0.0471625589,
-0.0616149567,
-0.005847021,
-0.0223507807,
2.696e-7,
0.0305815917,
0.0475539193,
0.0349941626,
0.0012890141,
0.0110699395,
0.003616997,
-0.0268646106,
0.0164401308,
0.0122370925,
-0.0175446384,
0.0253969617,
-0.0008665018,
0.0643406659,
0.0554027855,
-0.0987215862,
-0.0585097894,
-0.0634956732,
-0.024254106,
-0.0604167469,
-0.0363452397,
0.0101378644,
0.0081987726,
-0.0242701657,
-0.0100742122,
-0.0118065691,
-0.0499439724,
0.0517864414,
-0.00057803,
-0.0226904079,
0.0752653703,
0.0738628581,
-0.0080038914,
0.0171183683,
0.0086757783,
-0.0213838443,
-0.0171750225,
0.0303726532,
0.0292183738,
0.0250559058,
0.004134573,
0.0141441999,
-0.0306384843,
0.0391820595,
-0.0289508477,
0.0229006689,
0.0266526584,
0.0050253393,
-0.0647067651,
-0.0686764419,
-0.0376522467,
0.0599812567,
-0.0014600203,
-0.0056529846,
0.0603332818,
-0.0151114222,
0.0052106599,
0.00099626,
-0.0489090122,
-0.0318070315,
0.024119515,
0.0029240248,
-0.0493834279,
0.0219241194,
-0.0028334022,
-0.0164953005,
-0.1134043336,
-0.0240820553,
2.937816374e-34,
0.1123885065,
-0.0226171855,
0.0146205043,
0.0438878052,
0.0197167359,
0.0013976282,
0.0426870026,
0.0243417509,
-0.0056229951,
-0.0373990871,
0.013104097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10623v1 | Generating Summaries with Controllable Readability Levels | 2023-10-16T17:46:26 | 2023-10-16T17:46:26 | Leonardo F. R. Ribeiro, Mohit Bansal, Markus Dreyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Readability refers to how easily a reader can understand a written text.
Several factors affect the readability level, such as the complexity of the
text, its subject matter, and the reader's background knowledge. Generating
summaries based on different readability levels is critical for enabling
knowledge consumption by diverse audiences. However, current text generation
approaches lack refined control, resulting in texts that are not customized to
readers' proficiency levels. In this work, we bridge this gap and study
techniques to generate summaries at specified readability levels. Unlike
previous methods that focus on a specific readability level (e.g., lay
summarization), we generate summaries with fine-grained control over their
readability. We develop three text generation techniques for controlling
readability: (1) instruction-based readability control, (2) reinforcement
learning to minimize the gap between requested and observed readability and (3)
a decoding approach that uses lookahead to estimate the readability of upcoming
decoding steps. We show that our generation methods significantly improve
readability control on news summarization (CNN/DM dataset), as measured by
various readability metrics and human judgement, establishing strong baselines
for controllable readability in summarization. | [
0.0350515917,
0.0345202424,
0.0178171284,
0.0104930056,
0.0146997133,
0.0094141094,
-0.01780615,
-0.0025534863,
0.0031171937,
0.0068349768,
-0.0004134114,
0.0044318074,
0.0178878978,
0.0312821865,
0.0158409383,
-0.1020447388,
0.0087069608,
-0.0312443189,
0.0237884764,
-0.0009874296,
0.0418530889,
0.0147523964,
0.0044322638,
0.0256977174,
0.0313011967,
-0.0205138363,
0.0049657184,
0.0150994835,
0.0372631922,
-0.0105056604,
0.0432853848,
0.0130208572,
-0.0113330074,
0.0180283468,
0.0000017881,
0.0010623792,
-0.0264392011,
-0.0199647453,
0.0196399689,
0.0163276587,
0.06394355,
-0.0810274258,
-0.0059530241,
-0.0072592241,
0.0073516616,
-0.0118419053,
-0.0013023019,
0.0569993109,
0.0662910342,
0.0714970306,
-0.0016855074,
-0.0438054577,
0.0251631252,
-0.0258995425,
0.0212763026,
-0.0189323649,
-0.0368962809,
0.0263048764,
0.0028456834,
-0.0059851948,
-0.014063417,
0.0209530387,
0.0252478365,
-0.0200971644,
-0.0027749639,
0.0488134772,
0.0218270551,
-0.0087632881,
-0.0176135916,
0.0745555237,
-0.0168088302,
-0.0154986009,
0.0227507874,
-0.0222528111,
-0.0135386828,
0.0201314222,
-0.0455673411,
0.0474906936,
-0.0387783051,
0.023797553,
-0.0362910479,
0.0472890511,
-0.0082068145,
0.0078801345,
-0.0065065934,
0.0156132178,
-0.0232061166,
-0.0181027278,
-0.013098211,
0.0441163145,
0.0350303426,
-0.0226950701,
0.0356667824,
0.0239315908,
-0.0320522003,
-0.0122742588,
-0.0814163834,
-0.0720510632,
0.0205274969,
-0.0189441871,
0.0272953901,
0.0130069498,
0.008380604,
0.017925445,
-0.0288295392,
0.0235777814,
0.0016418535,
0.0008925783,
-0.0442507416,
0.0382406972,
0.0086860899,
0.0031196172,
-0.0290930886,
0.0177640505,
-0.0569776036,
-0.0323677287,
-0.0436893478,
0.0055356985,
0.0243481658,
0.0185548142,
-0.015237798,
0.0068828622,
-0.0442057475,
-0.0234692693,
0.0179797299,
0.0143621825,
-0.0652111024,
-0.0282958765,
0.0234376099,
0.0145127689,
0.0031961633,
0.0105673941,
0.0110882148,
0.0339212343,
-0.0244788975,
0.0517332368,
-0.0621759258,
-0.0008902195,
-0.0451769568,
-0.0391636565,
-0.0029738788,
-0.0295969024,
-0.0011195953,
-0.039842274,
-0.0245358981,
-0.0222301036,
0.010243535,
-0.036868155,
-0.013346524,
0.0348429047,
-0.0427614152,
0.028384503,
-0.0185142625,
-0.0205710772,
0.0493785255,
0.034068875,
0.0126786307,
0.0614837892,
0.0684958398,
0.0622032434,
0.0433425345,
0.0137157748,
0.0092085926,
0.0064157047,
0.0331968553,
0.0000930025,
0.0124951238,
-0.0272145309,
-0.0674562603,
0.0115511445,
0.0580355525,
0.047648862,
-0.0223430134,
0.0207054913,
0.0696405619,
0.0131242909,
0.035556335,
0.0055838693,
0.0507172048,
0.060579367,
0.0093722092,
0.0707508251,
-0.006606021,
0.0440892279,
-0.0135063231,
0.0803726092,
0.0822858959,
0.0272801984,
-0.0019286496,
-0.0694512352,
0.0500309803,
0.0100890454,
0.0216171779,
-0.0331675783,
-0.0076867952,
0.0368540473,
-0.0741132051,
-0.0236256104,
0.0148420371,
-0.0799304098,
0.0374651328,
-0.013731624,
0.0745885968,
0.0783168301,
0.0622103177,
0.0026700099,
0.026744647,
0.0223345011,
0.0318968035,
0.0907234102,
0.0069965529,
-0.0103481505,
-0.0070135128,
-0.0730897635,
-0.0301018804,
-0.0052347267,
0.0003049511,
-0.0107514821,
-0.0074279425,
0.0040901834,
0.0412414223,
-0.00445642,
-0.0851367861,
0.0262062661,
-0.0227868948,
-0.0187007897,
-0.0079098297,
0.0047080158,
-0.0104042888,
0.0351178348,
-0.0035064621,
0.0224954188,
-0.0150405429,
-0.0069329855,
0.0191789418,
0.0047413018,
-0.0160620362,
-0.0409451388,
-0.0452397093,
-0.0967312083,
0.0207751282,
0.0010034797,
-0.0216035172,
-0.0584065169,
0.0099717304,
-0.0684950277,
0.019121306,
-0.0136938309,
-0.0140036549,
0.0312063731,
0.0024064288,
-0.0216464307,
0.0540355332,
-0.0117786396,
-0.0005231457,
0.041338101,
-0.020111898,
-0.0410775468,
-0.0209512692,
0.0059846863,
-0.0000627442,
0.0150879351,
0.0007358298,
0.0552899167,
0.0430527739,
-0.0449750796,
-0.0403748527,
-0.0376439765,
0.0022191349,
-0.0066863443,
0.0059734262,
0.0384657867,
-0.0106212115,
-0.0261742156,
-0.0220113788,
-0.0321786813,
0.0017836952,
-0.0100987144,
0.0023639377,
0.0172470286,
0.0309501085,
0.0270769298,
-0.0551393665,
-0.0352368467,
0.0161993094,
0.0452345461,
0.0589700639,
0.0102148484,
-0.0700679868,
0.017984543,
0.0088437553,
-0.0542976111,
0.0109929377,
-0.0247981753,
0.0025193738,
0.0194878504,
0.0475989394,
0.0964469686,
0.0506150872,
0.0700671822,
0.0193842333,
-0.0170815196,
-0.0312601738,
0.0135042965,
-0.0449435376,
0.0104189105,
0.0057379701,
-0.0855207741,
0.0240395311,
0.0570478104,
0.0129411435,
0.0235100333,
-0.0538978465,
0.0283163209,
-0.0359275527,
-0.045792494,
-0.0309021622,
0.0176755283,
0.0026903618,
0.0178311579,
-0.0319343396,
-0.0257553644,
0.0628322363,
-0.0139615973,
0.0185977835,
-0.0579411574,
0.024910979,
-0.0335529558,
-0.0046931147,
0.0108741792,
0.0304472204,
-0.0179122742,
-0.047258161,
-0.0350515172,
-0.0058275913,
0.0286903754,
-0.0223581195,
0.0773551613,
-0.0451505557,
-0.0207369886,
-0.0210317336,
-0.0066846213,
-0.0143527361,
0.0040137405,
-0.0148139326,
-0.0333805904,
0.0638402924,
-0.0432156175,
-0.0319849327,
-0.0120348772,
0.0610652752,
0.0531742088,
-0.0390944667,
-0.0326562673,
-0.0102098258,
0.0395960286,
0.0582978129,
-0.0072184061,
-0.0048804097,
-0.0746616498,
0.014033542,
0.0508374795,
-0.0110267242,
-0.0095784916,
0.0211859494,
0.005584395,
0.0187998135,
-0.0325467773,
0.0226212088,
0.0158502683,
0.0490261801,
-0.0700142309,
-0.0046192482,
0.0702180862,
0.0042421161,
-0.0440243632,
-0.0134325325,
0.0130851539,
0.0483509004,
-0.044649139,
0.0197484586,
-0.0550371669,
-0.0168935917,
0.0031178151,
0.0952070877,
0.0042108078,
-0.014738678,
-0.01176624,
-0.055870641,
0.020181343,
0.0331655964,
-0.036330983,
-0.0412466638,
-0.0028491328,
-0.0062947543,
-0.0000313951,
0.0304978732,
0.0280094184,
-0.0231720544,
0.0155140702,
0.0191155039,
-0.0351583101,
0.015623929,
-0.0725695789,
0.0148753561,
0.0266340431,
0.0742258579,
0.015054821,
0.0008147022,
0.0177099872,
-0.0275113042,
-0.0174101871,
0.0009054148,
-0.0133946836,
0.0792829245,
-0.0261029471,
-0.0136833573,
-0.045460403,
0.0736585334,
0.0358900018,
-0.0017558277,
0.0233690217,
-0.0436838567,
0.0258861594,
-0.0602410063,
-0.0644205213,
0.0464726649,
0.0195648074,
0.0728516057,
0.0509211905,
-0.0380463041,
-0.0193103999,
-0.0581401289,
0.0191957075,
-0.146565184,
-0.0387855396,
-0.0145832943,
-0.020434903,
-0.0332713239,
-0.0884121805,
-0.0581832305,
0.0051836572,
-0.0300100259,
0.015382397,
-0.0282124113,
0.0423587933,
0.0019832703,
-0.0605474487,
-0.0337361805,
-0.0173054133,
-0.0073950114,
-0.0844363347,
-0.0388496816,
-0.0062516592,
-0.062011309,
-0.0148936715,
0.017251838,
-0.0468169115,
-0.0247478187,
-0.0235831961,
0.0482861064,
0.0177357066,
0.0619111471,
0.0225552451,
-0.0355079956,
0.0816424191,
0.0100313444,
-0.02649864,
0.0432817712,
0.0284668338,
0.0392958075,
-0.0007784279,
0.012266756,
-0.0508298352,
0.0336541906,
-0.0154978009,
0.0204897821,
-0.0174038615,
-0.0244853403,
0.0023249718,
-0.0084667066,
-0.0457171164,
-0.0513619483,
0.0166038312,
-0.0299424492,
-0.0104594463,
-0.0405713804,
0.0189207345,
-0.0583599843,
0.0420781299,
0.0000127698,
-0.005686298,
-0.0140036875,
0.0612991862,
0.0077046915,
0.0018636227,
-0.0458532609,
0.0279291999,
-0.0332187749,
0.0152510954,
-0.0087000392,
-0.0095160306,
-0.0560430177,
0.0039648819,
-0.0642813295,
0.0392702781,
0.0410001054,
0.0232837349,
0.0582810603,
-0.0265890472,
0.0225352105,
0.052395083,
-0.0528148413,
0.0431906357,
-0.0490590595,
0.0273809023,
0.0081986748,
-0.0210166499,
0.0706539452,
-0.0001843448,
0.0148529951,
-0.0194525272,
0.0277811792,
0.030033147,
-0.0296688192,
-0.0576331466,
0.0260523986,
0.0342909917,
-0.0418509804,
0.1325684041,
-0.0104410239,
-0.0214555059,
0.0017615728,
-0.0213922132,
-0.0429053418,
-0.0127520198,
-0.0076144137,
0.0396659039,
-0.0031255381,
-0.0366519019,
-0.055809956,
-0.0212266725,
0.0322578102,
0.0416728966,
0.0223112199,
0.0026097063,
0.0131317079,
0.0085029164,
-0.0233444814,
-0.0135144209,
-0.0481438674,
0.0122528095,
-0.0358990692,
-0.0147671839,
0.0082130153,
-5.681267788e-33,
-0.0365409441,
-0.0194788408,
-0.0371143483,
-0.010587249,
-0.0294751655,
0.0543434359,
-0.0872267112,
-0.0280000009,
0.0376176871,
0.0451767519,
-0.0011571107,
-0.0083586127,
0.0208827853,
0.0486479364,
-0.0137124108,
0.003117932,
0.0518287271,
-0.0120248375,
-0.0457274131,
0.0634750202,
0.0327663347,
0.0148303695,
0.0202096459,
-0.0183567703,
0.0608998053,
-0.0339345373,
-0.0301212985,
-0.0094820708,
0.0598526374,
0.027730139,
-0.0085352734,
0.0035274928,
0.0186694618,
-0.0210226886,
-0.0595630482,
0.068821542,
-0.0731529295,
-0.0205104034,
0.0257361066,
-0.0138522256,
-0.0791579857,
-0.0605113506,
0.0352568962,
-0.0258351788,
0.0164938178,
-0.0426114462,
0.0583320037,
-0.0573648326,
-0.0090516964,
-0.0608164594,
-0.0316897258,
0.0241193958,
-0.0424494594,
-0.0311902706,
0.0278038774,
0.0277559329,
0.0289572868,
0.0084598754,
-0.0307875331,
0.0536300316,
0.0426575355,
0.0541126244,
0.0387903452,
0.0135034323,
-0.0180680603,
0.038336888,
-0.0175660942,
-0.0096884277,
-0.0613330714,
0.0260595623,
0.0009884618,
-0.0145196198,
0.0116575565,
0.0494650528,
0.0412826352,
0.0071637202,
-0.0174699686,
0.0809531286,
-0.0062156417,
0.0074792514,
0.0255321376,
-0.0094591705,
-0.0480763391,
0.0057534236,
-0.0074313455,
-0.0055671623,
-0.0092693884,
-0.0242061429,
-0.0106062349,
0.0293737985,
-0.0908999518,
-0.0339701213,
-0.0103634009,
-0.0198469982,
0.0201071408,
0.0355180204,
-0.0294332914,
0.0248322394,
-0.0322220325,
-0.0368958935,
-0.0242606234,
0.0186894611,
0.0244174693,
-0.0021602933,
-0.0115727019,
0.0181470588,
0.0328605212,
0.0107959071,
-0.0377879255,
0.0081963781,
0.0063186144,
0.037275143,
-0.0074612396,
-0.0056677936,
0.0013356713,
-0.0183569845,
-0.0240476113,
0.0042946842,
-0.0333089232,
0.0099949483,
0.004275504,
0.0044808271,
0.0196307991,
0.0596286096,
-0.0381733961,
-0.027102543,
-0.0125679141,
0.0134318946,
0.0321911201,
-0.061695002,
-0.0072236299,
0.0238683969,
2.371e-7,
-0.0020353121,
0.0361107476,
0.0680992529,
0.0180414133,
-0.0129222525,
0.0171739664,
0.0457453169,
0.0324836113,
-0.0065959245,
-0.0473655574,
0.0282511022,
0.0179663673,
0.0529653504,
0.0069665778,
-0.0938223824,
-0.0353075936,
-0.0427244604,
0.0252020396,
-0.0129535198,
-0.0368309803,
0.0585498102,
-0.0130543485,
-0.0192657169,
0.007368336,
0.0558291003,
0.0025492096,
0.0079210671,
0.0015796173,
0.0167273618,
0.0325377025,
0.0873198137,
-0.0194155816,
-0.0106607145,
-0.0059582982,
-0.0522781871,
-0.0431823432,
0.0562220328,
0.0493463948,
0.0704656541,
0.0003966041,
0.0113218296,
-0.0143637257,
0.028151935,
0.0042676264,
0.0166676622,
-0.0349320769,
0.0065545342,
0.0334452689,
-0.0545547865,
-0.0170324743,
-0.0277804062,
-0.0221626963,
-0.0542262234,
0.0366891474,
0.0161939748,
-0.015004565,
0.0107756406,
-0.0361208245,
-0.0616034828,
-0.0220751707,
0.0100280698,
0.0052332445,
-0.0636243001,
-0.0127489325,
-0.0078230957,
-0.0827000514,
-0.01078624,
1.87297335e-34,
0.0661233589,
-0.0231121983,
-0.000474886,
-0.0292176045,
-0.005181469,
-0.0080539295,
-0.0026664436,
-0.0107845515,
0.0282954182,
-0.0399568118,
-0.0235602874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10605v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10605v3 | ForceGen: End-to-end de novo protein generation based on nonlinear mechanical unfolding responses using a protein language diffusion model | 2023-10-16T17:31:34 | 2023-12-16T01:39:22 | Bo Ni, David L. Kaplan, Markus J. Buehler | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cond-mat.mes-hall, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.BM | Through evolution, nature has presented a set of remarkable protein
materials, including elastins, silks, keratins and collagens with superior
mechanical performances that play crucial roles in mechanobiology. However,
going beyond natural designs to discover proteins that meet specified
mechanical properties remains challenging. Here we report a generative model
that predicts protein designs to meet complex nonlinear mechanical
property-design objectives. Our model leverages deep knowledge on protein
sequences from a pre-trained protein language model and maps mechanical
unfolding responses to create novel proteins. Via full-atom molecular
simulations for direct validation, we demonstrate that the designed proteins
are novel, and fulfill the targeted mechanical properties, including unfolding
energy and mechanical strength, as well as the detailed unfolding
force-separation curves. Our model offers rapid pathways to explore the
enormous mechanobiological protein sequence space unconstrained by biological
synthesis, using mechanical features as target to enable the discovery of
protein materials with superior mechanical properties. | [
-0.0149533618,
0.0222070199,
-0.0045317728,
-0.0101580219,
-0.0245847553,
-0.0464107208,
0.004425351,
0.0180288274,
-0.0328941606,
0.0144902309,
0.032808084,
-0.0302624833,
-0.0035454121,
0.0769886672,
0.0182134658,
0.0478060171,
-0.0170630999,
-0.0327297337,
-0.005808109,
-0.0438203402,
-0.0217471886,
-0.0361389108,
0.0118661467,
-0.0170776192,
0.0220119823,
0.0142173925,
-0.0644843802,
-0.0262397118,
0.0435343832,
0.0083369259,
-0.0288093276,
0.0488015004,
0.0250888355,
0.0195783004,
0.0000023039,
-0.001332838,
0.0280924644,
0.0305245034,
0.008289203,
0.0306612272,
0.0196983162,
-0.0823062509,
-0.0466573127,
-0.0074227876,
0.0211497378,
-0.0382112525,
-0.0042124577,
-0.02826849,
-0.045826342,
0.0039879768,
-0.0073767761,
-0.0567052737,
0.0741513148,
-0.0294980239,
0.0767269433,
0.0093154637,
-0.0113209337,
0.0018365767,
0.0334482305,
-0.0115011064,
-0.0108553059,
-0.0111955274,
0.0207295325,
-0.0542162284,
0.0495903343,
0.0109165525,
-0.01753233,
-0.0659486279,
-0.0045535751,
0.0825000554,
-0.0112905987,
-0.029170014,
-0.0543881506,
-0.0376286544,
0.0064199851,
0.0620985478,
-0.0104850931,
0.0216160119,
0.0615821406,
0.0320585817,
-0.0223146155,
-0.0019051755,
0.0255971421,
-0.0439874008,
0.0193343051,
-0.0568693057,
0.0227675829,
-0.0065178848,
-0.0021705125,
-0.0454773307,
-0.0103680138,
0.0010102226,
-0.0000993549,
-0.0001196048,
0.0427151099,
-0.0337868221,
0.0118430806,
-0.0603855997,
0.0894699693,
-0.017801309,
-0.0025240837,
0.0151255503,
0.0519414917,
0.0178228971,
-0.0701852813,
-0.0221610852,
-0.0106736263,
-0.0404312536,
-0.0388778076,
0.0119028557,
-0.0313210636,
-0.0062120324,
0.0459596217,
-0.0248230118,
-0.0552169494,
-0.0297433045,
-0.0081090406,
0.0343624838,
0.0090688709,
-0.0306108184,
0.012235241,
0.0144930417,
-0.0117025943,
-0.0085421223,
-0.045044329,
0.0083522256,
0.0094344178,
0.033101473,
0.0254362263,
-0.025274381,
-0.0299972203,
-0.0021594453,
-0.0093232943,
0.0400129966,
-0.0121048922,
0.0796718299,
-0.0496557467,
0.0233775284,
0.0139936712,
-0.0609371588,
-0.024415981,
0.0351235382,
0.0052753109,
-0.0158198345,
0.0679992661,
-0.0027689727,
-0.0189439394,
-0.0220573321,
0.0171778966,
-0.0669764504,
-0.0346848778,
0.0415322669,
-0.031586431,
0.0163458697,
0.0080850692,
-0.0018498659,
0.0250606351,
-0.0358086638,
-0.0298949387,
0.0406387076,
-0.0378169231,
0.0136687085,
-0.0063395249,
-0.0008480797,
-0.0103729321,
-0.0341360308,
-0.0101326713,
-0.0443973765,
0.0887468234,
0.0530274659,
-0.0180035066,
-0.0338362716,
-0.0047920872,
0.0019081408,
0.0112470808,
0.0445093177,
0.0140949702,
0.0403911062,
-0.0076303356,
0.0544790365,
0.0019275163,
-0.0256763976,
0.0496564172,
-0.0260624047,
-0.0106422352,
0.0360412113,
0.0529897809,
-0.0113802254,
0.0103393821,
-0.0384997539,
0.0002268286,
-0.0279730354,
0.0593083948,
-0.06568712,
0.0182768088,
0.0458503924,
-0.0249248557,
-0.0149856173,
0.0303570293,
-0.0647042468,
-0.0084279785,
0.0152313486,
0.0076341596,
0.0453274436,
0.0474071354,
-0.0622108765,
-0.0343089178,
0.0576993972,
-0.0384546332,
0.0546294637,
0.0174359996,
0.0097477483,
0.0142280106,
-0.0119200759,
-0.0026461461,
-0.003344408,
0.0176701806,
0.0120806824,
-0.067180343,
0.001698827,
0.0029191873,
-0.0278974269,
-0.0308184493,
0.0324223936,
-0.0319623239,
-0.0099649327,
0.0610913709,
-0.0174333751,
0.0398991033,
-0.0097080441,
0.0236571953,
-0.0074091423,
0.1113021523,
-0.0550811216,
-0.0257248152,
-0.0482041128,
0.0245338846,
0.0053708944,
0.0508368947,
-0.0405244455,
0.0181945153,
-0.0357654355,
-0.0257679895,
-0.062602751,
0.0381822735,
0.0549408309,
0.0334490538,
0.001796613,
-0.000004439,
0.0123831639,
0.0328993015,
-0.0326771177,
0.0344567783,
0.0357614942,
-0.0221365578,
-0.0072106193,
0.0303786527,
-0.0255742986,
0.0154596856,
-0.0031374849,
0.0205621235,
0.0107343961,
-0.0036344177,
0.0637108162,
0.0265617929,
0.0084268451,
-0.0501378849,
0.0353347547,
-0.0075477501,
0.0244510192,
-0.0131596103,
0.0083259409,
-0.0384449996,
-0.026963288,
0.0407308228,
-0.0120675657,
0.0151041728,
-0.0472229943,
-0.0846641883,
0.0581481569,
-0.0133175757,
-0.0387614891,
-0.0315366723,
-0.0362417288,
-0.0630853549,
0.0367879309,
0.0481563024,
0.0461249799,
0.0062729493,
0.0198958963,
0.0100688376,
0.0244333167,
-0.0130773056,
-0.0715208352,
0.0134212803,
-0.0104652885,
0.0451526716,
-0.0319478661,
-0.01943768,
-0.0019718523,
0.0312563479,
0.0393300466,
0.0128718968,
-0.0054810583,
-0.0178322364,
0.0272572432,
0.0149800805,
-0.0268072356,
0.0232426524,
0.0456410386,
-0.0085450551,
0.0008175424,
-0.0494034998,
-0.025457494,
0.0690191612,
-0.0397260748,
0.068901442,
-0.0336872563,
0.0144541329,
0.0243785717,
0.0274894107,
0.0426503457,
0.0394039117,
-0.0227529127,
0.0529793389,
0.0079162233,
0.0060680029,
0.0039122375,
0.098074235,
0.040439494,
0.0060220389,
0.0771760717,
0.0479116216,
0.0413859896,
0.0522552319,
0.0267654434,
-0.0198607221,
-0.0182937142,
0.0029339262,
-0.0169929843,
0.0074014096,
-0.0443132706,
0.0078902729,
0.0802684575,
0.010187868,
0.016998494,
0.0169187263,
-0.0465814173,
-0.0039274073,
-0.0191303082,
0.0011284587,
-0.00481669,
-0.0100261346,
0.0536139235,
-0.0814607963,
0.0140752885,
0.0124340523,
0.0043513705,
-0.0283051115,
0.0059383051,
0.0512776263,
0.0109378677,
0.0028106144,
0.0099234739,
-0.0466198474,
0.0240613874,
0.0157158729,
0.0121252835,
0.0238087755,
0.0034115193,
-0.0297061335,
-0.0268516615,
0.016034916,
0.0040211971,
0.0286637284,
-0.0231608544,
0.0272381119,
0.0360693447,
0.0761187747,
-0.0167016331,
0.0155944405,
-0.0509817377,
-0.0762702078,
-0.0306150578,
-0.0215801541,
0.0047169728,
0.0023320066,
0.0186348055,
-0.0005029399,
0.0739259869,
0.0122383991,
-0.0152620729,
-0.0303279795,
-0.0597601645,
-0.0466874279,
-0.0363997817,
0.0141102709,
0.0683487654,
0.0236194357,
0.0369488001,
-0.0159856044,
0.0180065539,
-0.0684117004,
0.0257338155,
0.0304309819,
-0.0218652282,
0.0372847132,
0.0244803037,
-0.0331349373,
-0.0625207424,
0.0796902925,
0.0526633002,
0.0358609632,
-0.036688894,
-0.0072954227,
0.0642208755,
0.0018206367,
-0.0332121998,
0.0433800742,
-0.056695994,
-0.0649522841,
-0.0410149358,
0.0635784939,
0.0247289781,
0.0267839283,
-0.0710701197,
-0.0893775895,
-0.0661243424,
0.0571447834,
0.0132990181,
-0.0653421432,
-0.0742976591,
-0.0518133529,
0.0552668087,
0.006324884,
-0.0473440066,
-0.0486347303,
0.0089426646,
0.0002333635,
-0.0260225274,
0.0042679324,
0.0292460453,
0.009358583,
0.0198040307,
0.0180462319,
0.0366258807,
-0.031358052,
-0.0702884346,
-0.0254225526,
0.0437744148,
-0.0247109663,
0.0191841573,
-0.0413948186,
0.0682206005,
0.0053940001,
-0.020961348,
0.0530033894,
0.041717995,
-0.05865952,
-0.0465077683,
0.0260822885,
0.0174147096,
-0.0293115396,
-0.0369987227,
-0.0077760024,
0.0858744085,
0.0934178978,
-0.0345734395,
-0.0534131825,
0.0133107835,
-0.0472607464,
-0.014441967,
-0.0206695087,
0.015230285,
-0.0267413985,
-0.0437600166,
0.0260788184,
0.0570873879,
-0.0420195311,
0.0473463759,
0.0085766753,
0.0006644664,
-0.0206905659,
-0.011035257,
-0.0162011776,
-0.0011599718,
0.0370437242,
0.0197737217,
-0.0238278415,
0.0209394209,
0.0656386688,
-0.029623637,
0.008191172,
0.0055766157,
0.013801652,
0.0185069237,
-0.0005829267,
0.0460761636,
0.0274379142,
0.0722169429,
0.0556744486,
-0.0571681298,
-0.0027616834,
0.0135436244,
-0.087476708,
0.0162725914,
-0.0446780249,
-0.0042451574,
-0.0259460118,
0.0722467005,
-0.0073391479,
-0.0026654601,
-0.0267110392,
-0.0262903757,
-0.0599612668,
-0.0250106379,
0.0195898227,
0.0077942344,
0.0425249301,
0.0029949322,
-0.0173243489,
-0.0009149059,
0.0176387932,
-0.028142225,
-0.028785469,
0.0187431853,
0.0192276593,
-0.0228546541,
-0.033730071,
0.0737737119,
-0.0122878291,
-0.0120532867,
-0.010530876,
-0.0131109562,
-0.0201727096,
-0.01921908,
-0.0092947483,
-0.0093226023,
-0.0251159631,
-0.0393148661,
-0.0304083265,
-0.0008327789,
-0.0013967901,
0.0624632873,
-0.0079421131,
0.0432393551,
-0.0047933003,
0.0496409982,
-0.0367971547,
-0.0692180544,
0.0091864094,
-0.0083117066,
0.002845919,
-0.0273632519,
0.0293511078,
-6.275375857e-33,
0.0217372496,
0.0547641255,
-0.0769957006,
0.0029407088,
0.0017944855,
0.0101794899,
-0.0527610891,
-0.0165865179,
0.0079617929,
0.0780119151,
-0.007758195,
-0.0041720136,
-0.0170743112,
-0.0310758632,
0.0354843251,
-0.0128677692,
0.0067347931,
-0.0131145772,
0.0220262464,
0.0110321287,
-0.0336910486,
0.0134111447,
-0.0229725353,
0.0468968041,
0.0280133113,
0.0006412071,
-0.0180491824,
-0.0511215776,
-0.0018397704,
-0.0029885853,
-0.0312387273,
-0.0150228851,
-0.0695712566,
-0.0348307528,
-0.0311388299,
-0.0324806422,
-0.0096296044,
0.0216255374,
-0.0452544726,
-0.0423667654,
-0.0038227993,
0.0272990763,
0.0283819139,
0.0252076741,
-0.0763420835,
0.0060750074,
0.0377511792,
-0.0509416126,
-0.0295648798,
-0.0150098344,
-0.0441469997,
-0.0223604441,
0.0268865973,
0.0106630092,
-0.0030165259,
0.0133642126,
0.0197200179,
-0.0127673382,
-0.0222676676,
0.0364162661,
0.0262716096,
-0.0000216369,
0.0346214399,
-0.0336115249,
0.0416752771,
0.0353703611,
-0.0020695282,
0.0037756988,
-0.0125590935,
0.0128238266,
0.0303645134,
0.0512432046,
0.0554147996,
-0.019214185,
0.0437774472,
-0.0030429307,
-0.113929674,
-0.0026077076,
-0.003633067,
-0.0272237975,
0.0076738466,
0.0439435132,
0.0530301556,
-0.0103572095,
-0.0084557002,
-0.0048645823,
0.0320525877,
-0.0257585123,
-0.0340313166,
0.0012615754,
-0.0151675483,
-0.057550706,
-0.0083739571,
-0.0026461594,
0.0021168129,
0.0343664475,
-0.0144453663,
0.0329150967,
-0.0476237796,
-0.0042595007,
-0.0054873968,
-0.0216458868,
-0.0054277997,
0.0012088961,
0.0096037174,
-0.0454424769,
-0.0296271555,
0.0385420769,
0.0116543826,
0.0298695024,
-0.071109131,
0.0110659255,
0.0284305159,
0.016305238,
0.0353194736,
-0.0245246105,
-0.0317535885,
0.0007050956,
-0.0108199855,
0.069089666,
0.0057698418,
0.0913139731,
0.0075423596,
0.0357161798,
-0.0983649641,
-0.0549683012,
0.008946158,
0.0414537787,
0.0107160918,
-0.0792758241,
-0.0399849489,
0.0287649203,
2.904e-7,
0.0205691587,
0.0797105357,
0.0225503463,
-0.0037896517,
-0.0363827422,
0.0532494448,
-0.0059546498,
-0.0514016673,
-0.0524173826,
-0.0638352409,
0.0629268885,
0.0268383827,
0.0102394642,
-0.0259844027,
-0.0543574579,
0.0383332856,
-0.0011015044,
-0.029326506,
-0.0152554298,
0.03823632,
-0.0495988764,
0.0869148374,
0.0147831012,
0.0170516036,
0.0548488908,
-0.0432774611,
-0.0238614529,
-0.0461294279,
0.0638859123,
0.0149424328,
-0.0531400926,
-0.0437837914,
-0.0505091697,
-0.0228662752,
-0.0421254635,
-0.0319667421,
0.0279457178,
0.0125995884,
0.0088189933,
0.0164231174,
0.0365742519,
0.0369580798,
0.0033246789,
0.0126976641,
-0.0199282393,
0.003556109,
-0.0113884574,
-0.0099815829,
0.0127685266,
0.032101851,
0.0244104471,
0.0040816395,
0.0852559283,
0.020312475,
0.0032062205,
0.0072158538,
0.0008928909,
-0.0202948451,
-0.0433564149,
0.0205357745,
-0.0757704377,
0.0766851753,
-0.026422726,
-0.0013592629,
0.0348703526,
0.0113368686,
-0.02142765,
2.676417425e-34,
0.0810614973,
-0.0128385434,
0.0067965402,
0.0312700272,
0.0013499097,
0.0352763012,
-0.0090654371,
0.0058466368,
-0.0277628154,
-0.0118792355,
-0.045140177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10594v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10594v2 | Motion2Language, unsupervised learning of synchronized semantic motion segmentation | 2023-10-16T17:16:32 | 2023-12-13T17:29:15 | Karim Radouane, Andon Tchechmedjiev, Julien Lagarde, Sylvie Ranwez | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this paper, we investigate building a sequence to sequence architecture
for motion to language translation and synchronization. The aim is to translate
motion capture inputs into English natural-language descriptions, such that the
descriptions are generated synchronously with the actions performed, enabling
semantic segmentation as a byproduct, but without requiring synchronized
training data. We propose a new recurrent formulation of local attention that
is suited for synchronous/live text generation, as well as an improved motion
encoder architecture better suited to smaller data and for synchronous
generation. We evaluate both contributions in individual experiments, using the
standard BLEU4 metric, as well as a simple semantic equivalence measure, on the
KIT motion language dataset. In a follow-up experiment, we assess the quality
of the synchronization of generated text in our proposed approaches through
multiple evaluation metrics. We find that both contributions to the attention
mechanism and the encoder architecture additively improve the quality of
generated text (BLEU and semantic equivalence), but also of synchronization.
Our code is available at
https://github.com/rd20karim/M2T-Segmentation/tree/main | [
-0.019599501,
0.0513374358,
0.0130549017,
0.0545416363,
-0.015478746,
0.0051230532,
0.0119155971,
-0.013476355,
-0.0516661704,
-0.0434895493,
-0.0215219148,
-0.0400824919,
0.0305891819,
0.0385890007,
-0.004852924,
-0.0742487237,
0.0224408358,
-0.0163202658,
-0.0273445416,
-0.0116354022,
-0.0041110604,
0.0265802369,
-0.0140808951,
0.0042599132,
-0.018436484,
0.0212178174,
-0.0085995663,
-0.0224015266,
0.0874674395,
-0.0342048295,
-0.0257488564,
0.009516608,
0.0530103035,
0.0326539725,
0.0000020348,
-0.0177286752,
0.04893234,
-0.0003606459,
0.0450121909,
-0.051553186,
0.0288760886,
-0.0326466225,
0.0067734495,
0.0012467621,
-0.005384394,
-0.020572409,
0.0549338274,
-0.0062325634,
0.0791029185,
0.0320842117,
-0.0374360122,
-0.0645078644,
-0.0267040916,
-0.0401565991,
-0.0035565523,
0.0195294768,
0.0106595177,
-0.0099034496,
0.0081626121,
0.0101111764,
-0.0718845278,
0.0359673612,
0.0164660774,
-0.0051298384,
0.0211721919,
0.0448110811,
-0.0054905307,
-0.0371312276,
-0.0053747604,
0.0802379251,
-0.0108753936,
0.0158836357,
0.0067555583,
-0.0025461658,
0.0061436971,
-0.0302992817,
-0.0678637102,
0.0585223958,
0.0154131381,
0.0006618183,
-0.0379015654,
0.0269292742,
0.0351850279,
-0.0494079255,
0.0261871517,
0.012819997,
0.0413363688,
0.0221864451,
-0.040978767,
-0.0001760759,
0.0172472913,
-0.071092017,
0.0506063066,
0.0169104841,
0.0143858017,
0.0075413361,
-0.0529217832,
-0.0178234838,
-0.0515341312,
-0.0257101618,
0.0110330693,
0.0373046957,
0.0255555455,
0.0457807146,
-0.0059690098,
0.0816286281,
-0.0321759097,
0.0476417802,
-0.0575437956,
-0.0017554357,
-0.020476114,
0.0258363746,
-0.0266106203,
-0.011452022,
-0.0589794852,
-0.0233012512,
-0.019823039,
0.0217501167,
-0.0173360389,
0.0301569384,
-0.0359769873,
0.0061983503,
-0.0388296731,
-0.0103622302,
-0.0073571294,
0.0054262187,
-0.0167525616,
0.0005781516,
0.0189737454,
-0.0417221636,
-0.0445201509,
0.0373789333,
0.0114885541,
-0.0275125615,
-0.0292620696,
0.0481079556,
-0.0372970924,
-0.0310760606,
0.0452446267,
0.0355365053,
-0.0234116893,
-0.0361841992,
0.0284475554,
-0.0586081035,
0.0725229084,
-0.0294290613,
-0.0036159926,
0.0038185935,
0.0062103732,
-0.0053268149,
-0.0051223012,
0.0400882103,
-0.0386132561,
0.0165701993,
-0.0045480812,
0.0137902433,
0.0677753091,
0.0285757072,
0.069689557,
0.014848372,
-0.0005634113,
0.0402713083,
-0.0245129894,
0.0550924055,
-0.0404203981,
-0.0093367444,
-0.0157328304,
-0.0219847038,
0.0509615391,
0.0662077516,
0.0726915821,
0.0223944914,
-0.0315659083,
-0.0078655202,
0.0298211034,
0.0285966378,
-0.014846513,
0.0254305061,
0.0804077834,
0.0033364799,
-0.0443641432,
-0.0013479015,
-0.0098551419,
0.0669167563,
0.0590799078,
0.0041985409,
0.0020432272,
0.0317455232,
-0.0552018546,
-0.0370672159,
-0.0007661471,
-0.0128893219,
0.0185628086,
-0.0067092665,
0.0308666639,
0.0412300751,
-0.011411651,
0.0818416029,
-0.0284944419,
-0.0426262245,
0.0692925677,
0.0145028243,
-0.0044889464,
0.0752925873,
-0.0069253766,
0.0008817575,
-0.0178840011,
-0.0170367993,
0.0183800235,
0.0698030815,
-0.0152053218,
-0.023576634,
0.051322408,
-0.0784719661,
-0.0445722677,
-0.0485536531,
-0.0087822909,
0.0089143114,
-0.0609980673,
0.040768303,
0.0226259995,
-0.0024959738,
-0.0470449701,
0.0378843546,
-0.0083200121,
0.0061884774,
-0.0141984755,
-0.0145653514,
0.0493108183,
0.0132729616,
-0.0038967021,
-0.0190685838,
0.0381245352,
-0.0237614848,
0.0334144086,
0.1102496386,
-0.0361005366,
-0.0459915735,
0.0105443923,
-0.0392322503,
-0.0247238744,
0.0293032154,
-0.0468729585,
-0.0663199946,
0.0148406532,
-0.0501709841,
-0.0226284992,
0.0004111154,
-0.0111036254,
0.0365659855,
-0.004611596,
-0.0255011208,
0.0252274312,
-0.0528151169,
-0.00082979,
0.0577838048,
0.0057026218,
0.0071522375,
-0.0355051756,
-0.0280150808,
0.0638553873,
0.0048419181,
-0.0168690104,
0.0173094179,
0.00847195,
-0.0431499183,
0.0002154555,
-0.0475637279,
0.0001204965,
-0.0282836054,
0.0299168807,
0.0418458544,
0.0085065374,
0.0024513339,
-0.0322237015,
-0.0473923311,
0.0252954829,
0.012968801,
-0.0032638509,
0.0425118767,
0.0134461634,
-0.0262698941,
-0.0008064384,
0.0098167565,
0.0344349407,
0.0256205201,
0.0314068086,
-0.0105804577,
-0.0401903279,
-0.015703788,
-0.0268218685,
0.0140308337,
-0.0128805377,
-0.0279601105,
0.0183477271,
-0.0044218646,
-0.0042773057,
0.0381197967,
0.004887112,
0.0061824443,
0.0769016445,
-0.0465809181,
0.0185843352,
0.0293422155,
-0.0201157387,
0.0082490416,
-0.0239491295,
-0.0201835055,
0.0166355558,
0.0552110113,
-0.0062025124,
0.0395880416,
-0.0736110434,
-0.057940565,
0.0221670475,
-0.0180505309,
-0.0015334091,
0.0273764208,
-0.0345408134,
0.0130713023,
-0.0446999781,
-0.0510850884,
0.0024065338,
-0.0427207202,
-0.0630729571,
-0.0602749325,
0.0523348227,
0.0048953388,
0.047189109,
0.0514234342,
0.0237323474,
-0.0579185411,
-0.0224136207,
-0.0480560251,
0.0006813966,
0.0360443518,
0.0222899076,
0.0014527779,
-0.0608031079,
-0.0085289227,
-0.0222446565,
-0.0032754277,
-0.0257087648,
0.009790075,
-0.0304998104,
0.0085638482,
-0.0406385213,
-0.0347057357,
0.0234965961,
-0.0115693239,
0.0259926785,
0.0647835061,
-0.0010283833,
0.0041929553,
-0.0317901224,
0.0482191183,
0.0681312308,
0.0648333356,
-0.0658826157,
-0.0351380855,
0.0184127837,
0.0534752719,
0.0476970598,
-0.011082178,
-0.0594429858,
0.0224186089,
0.0291142799,
-0.0154901901,
0.0042502671,
0.0182008445,
0.0339267142,
-0.042915836,
-0.0381114893,
0.0694135502,
-0.0108786859,
0.0117828306,
0.0045910496,
0.0203241091,
0.0095277512,
0.0194666106,
-0.0295548588,
-0.0217554029,
-0.0348439775,
-0.027037641,
-0.0132177789,
0.0861784294,
0.0236456227,
-0.0208913591,
-0.081346862,
0.0361801833,
0.0379589535,
-0.0591883808,
-0.0664779618,
-0.0032502993,
0.0221365672,
-0.0026412758,
-0.024031695,
-0.0091027301,
0.0194145497,
-0.0012544371,
-0.0173212774,
-0.0471411385,
-0.0567022972,
0.008690618,
-0.027564818,
-0.0068251044,
0.0710582584,
0.0448714197,
-0.0306105632,
-0.0288382247,
0.0237399172,
-0.0617047958,
-0.0066592451,
0.0095324004,
0.0135830045,
-0.0334646516,
-0.0193866082,
-0.0018151521,
0.0416997336,
0.0176944491,
-0.0287855603,
0.0075297873,
0.0584709905,
-0.020013934,
-0.007136988,
-0.0240665339,
0.0381694473,
-0.0204190444,
0.0235896241,
-0.0002126336,
-0.0265778024,
0.0232345015,
0.0186484847,
-0.0148800258,
-0.0416321047,
0.0111008827,
-0.0057824729,
-0.0032861992,
-0.0257361587,
-0.0706216767,
-0.0654083937,
0.0272942707,
0.0386611335,
0.003196995,
-0.0283442829,
0.0067413189,
-0.020130733,
-0.075528495,
0.0587178357,
-0.0243349168,
-0.0039616176,
0.0037823573,
-0.0092556393,
0.0117357997,
0.0320538655,
0.0032768017,
0.0226466898,
-0.113498874,
-0.0618506819,
-0.0134889521,
0.0865101293,
0.0117880926,
0.1057520509,
-0.037993677,
0.0113285938,
0.0172933824,
-0.0294946842,
-0.0128606595,
0.0140145458,
-0.0095348088,
-0.0074112667,
-0.0319193937,
0.0046643456,
-0.0434170552,
-0.0070214579,
0.0001069152,
0.0218852218,
-0.0618558228,
-0.0251155011,
-0.0084522497,
-0.0106930826,
0.070990175,
-0.0270521529,
0.0287696403,
-0.0189002119,
-0.0271145944,
-0.0055849398,
0.0010828216,
-0.0898234472,
-0.0111997835,
0.0414667092,
0.0247811992,
0.0122526465,
0.0413157903,
0.0060349936,
-0.0936661884,
0.0274694208,
-0.0143899126,
-0.0074893902,
0.0144840935,
-0.0099360254,
0.0361957997,
-0.0150038414,
0.0124024376,
-0.0293977298,
0.0158602912,
0.0153886471,
0.0626893193,
0.0615616143,
0.01258408,
0.0233594086,
0.0542762838,
-0.0191979259,
-0.0005803301,
-0.0420416519,
0.0243178979,
0.0621043779,
-0.0582018867,
0.0561924018,
-0.0134924985,
0.004171099,
-0.0359624289,
0.0619625598,
0.0045625418,
-0.0953147858,
0.0299282111,
-0.011615701,
-0.0164217614,
-0.0062865862,
0.0318500176,
-0.0405030437,
0.0000742005,
0.0095145218,
0.0365035422,
-0.0419884138,
-0.0062191938,
-0.0122318845,
-0.0256686937,
-0.0185520984,
-0.0001999638,
-0.0075084385,
-0.0293950718,
0.0250865724,
-0.0179839041,
0.0172086954,
0.0047794115,
0.0955230594,
0.0174596552,
-0.0278972052,
-0.0020685853,
0.0097195106,
-0.0282292925,
-0.0180509724,
-0.0420611463,
-0.0540764146,
-5.5184868e-33,
-0.0608653873,
-0.0322688147,
0.0207307674,
-0.0280147791,
-0.0784473419,
-0.0117806876,
-0.0737157613,
-0.019672608,
0.0054773293,
0.0309092849,
0.0445081517,
0.0116512896,
0.0064336052,
0.0372078642,
0.0247242805,
-0.0491850525,
0.0525915287,
-0.0272240937,
-0.0478406362,
0.0068723951,
0.0562251508,
-0.0088803461,
0.0659156889,
0.0361798741,
-0.0144961271,
-0.031198319,
-0.0323458873,
0.0156747922,
-0.0035958504,
-0.0076355962,
-0.0049358294,
0.0136742434,
0.014497254,
0.0207014512,
-0.0562314838,
-0.0110926116,
-0.0399073996,
-0.0311895106,
-0.0072956593,
0.0573936664,
-0.0942547098,
-0.0099268835,
0.0499559715,
-0.0074584186,
-0.0131073501,
-0.0438343994,
0.0404602513,
-0.0336952396,
-0.0147452652,
0.0053777867,
-0.0372683294,
0.0027079117,
-0.0253557414,
-0.0345400274,
0.0729742199,
0.024819728,
0.0203126464,
-0.0609386936,
-0.0569546409,
0.0125108305,
-0.0335507579,
0.0589875616,
0.1003168151,
0.0128819766,
0.0137444381,
0.0493185595,
-0.0095896367,
-0.0613183118,
-0.010534591,
0.1135069951,
-0.0012569138,
0.0330103226,
0.057898432,
0.0387437195,
0.0112274652,
0.0305899996,
-0.0400622599,
0.0211917348,
-0.0548465662,
0.0907851681,
-0.033599101,
0.0432780795,
0.020938687,
-0.0336480364,
-0.0114377048,
0.0069308574,
0.0017182301,
-0.0127890669,
0.0261991043,
-0.0113926204,
0.0389932953,
-0.0334938057,
0.0592865981,
0.0306753647,
0.0410549678,
-0.0042929212,
-0.0527794063,
0.0439332128,
0.0226077884,
0.0119917504,
-0.0460696667,
-0.0013841692,
0.034313079,
0.0609954931,
0.0145280594,
0.0414418057,
-0.0192119144,
0.0327090807,
-0.0046461797,
0.0029101649,
-0.0347942784,
0.014537625,
-0.0169680584,
-0.0175506026,
0.0363887958,
-0.0264451019,
-0.0490231551,
0.0793141946,
-0.0396764167,
-0.0245223027,
0.0036521535,
0.0295395367,
-0.0157437753,
0.0483454652,
-0.0336002558,
0.049294658,
-0.0117420275,
0.0008036061,
0.0251051839,
-0.0251439996,
-0.0320716202,
0.0461579151,
2.687e-7,
-0.0091606742,
-0.0218052492,
0.0479433797,
-0.0091715865,
0.005303686,
0.0152744008,
-0.0266198311,
0.0604326651,
-0.0018242494,
0.0067515243,
0.0215138029,
0.0275307037,
0.0743821934,
-0.0153360032,
-0.0533983,
0.0335681215,
-0.0673774257,
0.0068442854,
-0.0373648889,
-0.0210296512,
0.0418737307,
0.0300212149,
-0.0072659734,
0.0580489151,
0.0232941937,
-0.0398700424,
0.0645598844,
-0.0263857003,
-0.0192227736,
-0.0022125796,
-0.0056587188,
-0.0072361864,
-0.0673888475,
-0.0061814305,
-0.0381309465,
-0.014339827,
0.0554927513,
0.0595215447,
-0.0306996014,
0.0252547115,
-0.0015086916,
0.0176979769,
-0.0267948154,
-0.0223288182,
0.0392130762,
-0.0624676161,
-0.0274314191,
0.0045778449,
-0.0182302855,
0.0472787134,
0.0079847984,
-0.0036198888,
-0.05576903,
-0.0159757491,
0.045115795,
0.0256397203,
-0.0110414485,
-0.0581222028,
-0.0034582899,
-0.0411487594,
-0.0631273836,
-0.0044080899,
-0.057703808,
0.0258492734,
0.0185442548,
0.0102628088,
-0.0565643869,
1.733953809e-34,
0.0055961157,
-0.0064505562,
0.018245928,
-0.0310764797,
-0.0113616856,
-0.0249013491,
0.0118620899,
0.0195467491,
0.0294357818,
-0.020681465,
-0.0244434197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10590v1 | Mastering the Task of Open Information Extraction with Large Language Models and Consistent Reasoning Environment | 2023-10-16T17:11:42 | 2023-10-16T17:11:42 | Ji Qi, Kaixuan Ji, Xiaozhi Wang, Jifan Yu, Kaisheng Zeng, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li, Bin Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open Information Extraction (OIE) aims to extract objective structured
knowledge from natural texts, which has attracted growing attention to build
dedicated models with human experience. As the large language models (LLMs)
have exhibited remarkable in-context learning capabilities, a question arises
as to whether the task of OIE can be effectively tackled with this paradigm? In
this paper, we explore solving the OIE problem by constructing an appropriate
reasoning environment for LLMs. Specifically, we first propose a method to
effectively estimate the discrepancy of syntactic distribution between a LLM
and test samples, which can serve as correlation evidence for preparing
positive demonstrations. Upon the evidence, we introduce a simple yet effective
mechanism to establish the reasoning environment for LLMs on specific tasks.
Without bells and whistles, experimental results on the standard CaRB benchmark
demonstrate that our $6$-shot approach outperforms state-of-the-art supervised
method, achieving an $55.3$ $F_1$ score. Further experiments on TACRED and
ACE05 show that our method can naturally generalize to other information
extraction tasks, resulting in improvements of $5.7$ and $6.8$ $F_1$ scores,
respectively. | [
0.037073765,
0.0812112764,
0.0383109413,
0.0596560426,
-0.0736909136,
0.0273448583,
-0.0055785868,
0.0396841764,
0.0044554393,
-0.0534741245,
-0.0311028585,
0.0048320503,
-0.028262075,
0.028486792,
-0.0087276762,
-0.0005408464,
0.0247813426,
-0.0267324857,
0.0084943911,
0.0300172698,
-0.030835228,
0.0140716098,
0.0006696183,
-0.0091085657,
0.0181535762,
-0.0228099488,
0.0229337681,
-0.0262207389,
0.0148756374,
-0.0159573536,
-0.0034512298,
0.0169334933,
0.0232260823,
0.0235217977,
0.0000020488,
-0.0633107424,
-0.0271742344,
0.0290298294,
-0.0674149469,
-0.0051363213,
0.0176325236,
-0.0042194352,
0.0061246869,
0.0073849424,
-0.0231617596,
-0.0556501932,
0.0025912228,
0.0471917875,
0.0368156657,
0.0805976987,
-0.0063354964,
-0.0562151372,
0.0294831358,
0.00738309,
0.0209702421,
-0.0116943391,
0.0654361993,
0.0297577213,
0.014185586,
0.0006412592,
0.0221765116,
0.0198719297,
0.0276506282,
0.0028885233,
-0.0090208678,
0.053503789,
-0.0485179201,
-0.009019888,
0.0035867984,
0.1118429974,
-0.012041118,
-0.0031881472,
0.0057276082,
-0.0031906799,
-0.0310413465,
-0.0007380389,
-0.0531531461,
0.0879969969,
-0.0559300818,
0.0450075381,
0.0515699275,
0.0042419527,
0.0236182697,
0.024228245,
-0.0524363182,
0.1015134081,
-0.003798547,
-0.0598379038,
0.0635099337,
0.0101691317,
-0.0377107784,
-0.038674783,
-0.0192343146,
0.0137812691,
0.020214105,
0.039945107,
-0.0193650499,
-0.0440197513,
-0.0071590021,
-0.0475522429,
0.0268540923,
0.0230589695,
-0.0420499817,
0.0864024162,
-0.037991263,
0.0399295576,
-0.0343012996,
0.0494556054,
-0.0043066922,
-0.0208919719,
-0.053351365,
0.0309238043,
0.0065443339,
0.0269060563,
-0.0564761162,
-0.0094239488,
0.0222425424,
0.0165568683,
-0.0056223916,
0.0472305492,
0.0261862297,
-0.0023771429,
0.0111728301,
-0.0246404298,
-0.035776943,
-0.0306103621,
0.0095922574,
-0.0252182968,
-0.003777209,
-0.0194962081,
-0.0479068048,
0.0414270833,
0.0202222057,
-0.0163691491,
0.0051519717,
0.0468729101,
0.0163261481,
-0.0267166588,
-0.0342398286,
-0.0358788595,
-0.0002957239,
-0.0639880374,
-0.0043473667,
-0.0427129306,
0.0200359784,
0.0238514617,
-0.0262266286,
-0.0542671494,
0.0345142297,
0.0219832417,
-0.0619841665,
0.057359606,
-0.0323927402,
-0.0493190475,
-0.0075627468,
0.010201999,
-0.0129639069,
0.0500660203,
0.0205904227,
0.0149180917,
0.0584981628,
0.0624773689,
-0.005756571,
0.0275967475,
0.0143584339,
-0.0200081114,
0.0178931411,
0.0467588529,
0.0421644412,
0.0388930812,
0.0236733761,
0.0525729693,
-0.0132031981,
-0.0061704842,
0.0447458252,
-0.0109422561,
0.0165710598,
-0.0150074139,
0.0294832774,
0.005838023,
0.035165567,
-0.0047397655,
-0.0401387587,
-0.0267895125,
-0.0477873012,
0.0597619377,
0.0179083794,
0.0117112398,
0.0265015755,
-0.0243952535,
-0.0681410953,
-0.0322949328,
-0.0188667458,
0.0011149282,
0.0915847719,
-0.0064767627,
-0.0565074198,
0.0320038088,
0.0756183341,
-0.0378634408,
-0.0029437141,
-0.0267155245,
0.07135465,
-0.0120862331,
0.0498033725,
-0.0513420962,
0.0133556249,
-0.0357862674,
-0.0046024062,
0.0165976826,
0.0169968046,
-0.0344427451,
0.0102595408,
-0.0511998385,
-0.0319681466,
-0.0203437451,
0.0269701518,
-0.0345382616,
0.0447737202,
-0.0049560438,
0.0248296671,
-0.0289988797,
-0.0192243215,
0.0516648144,
-0.0309382509,
-0.0794741958,
0.0045293779,
0.0013455661,
0.0217451006,
-0.0007046814,
-0.0423872247,
-0.0095095923,
0.0377912782,
-0.0276229847,
0.0073529645,
-0.0207742825,
-0.0364538357,
-0.0271655936,
0.0057172785,
0.0384048335,
-0.0274926983,
0.0117398463,
-0.0440196842,
0.0121027976,
-0.0548065715,
0.0503525175,
0.0470477305,
-0.0275930818,
0.0068948497,
0.0241551455,
-0.0132758496,
-0.0440735035,
0.1117868647,
0.010210502,
-0.0171629861,
0.0348488204,
-0.0280774739,
0.0171404332,
-0.0165985525,
0.0057204142,
0.0256048683,
0.0009054164,
-0.0153377727,
-0.0080689611,
0.0188368745,
-0.0696186572,
-0.0287437737,
-0.0739193708,
0.0421550497,
-0.0351131596,
0.0475715585,
0.0407587923,
-0.0114188045,
-0.0165514424,
0.0080009028,
-0.0077295434,
-0.0032843307,
-0.0170394462,
-0.0152873425,
0.0543808751,
0.0643075407,
0.0049690157,
-0.0120794037,
0.017728867,
-0.0324585065,
0.0866728276,
0.01087486,
-0.0021073315,
-0.0298935696,
0.0765845552,
0.0004271479,
0.0415020473,
-0.0012419595,
0.036667008,
-0.0169888046,
-0.0297505669,
-0.0014352769,
0.087765269,
-0.0158725753,
0.0253470372,
0.0218653679,
-0.0068860641,
-0.0356385782,
0.0027706539,
-0.018675046,
-0.0097552855,
-0.020286696,
-0.0116216075,
0.0261528734,
0.0408079438,
0.0124848234,
0.0208729282,
-0.0094771488,
0.0301484689,
-0.0143009042,
-0.003282683,
-0.0590660796,
0.0022057795,
-0.020903375,
0.0383532718,
-0.0527166985,
-0.0190983769,
0.0613201149,
-0.0094168354,
0.0259529967,
-0.0443075337,
0.0195220727,
-0.0716072097,
0.0580358692,
-0.0226065349,
0.0062138089,
0.0731370524,
-0.0032644616,
-0.0160761531,
-0.0178639907,
0.0054927431,
-0.0151572321,
0.0334217325,
-0.0759173557,
-0.0107683213,
0.0093061337,
-0.0454876125,
-0.0585109144,
-0.0513913967,
-0.021302864,
0.0368409827,
0.0041851033,
-0.011953108,
-0.0270060189,
-0.0145548247,
0.0100214267,
0.0304560941,
-0.0074664843,
-0.0145091591,
-0.0218712613,
0.026311988,
0.0490473546,
-0.0106073096,
0.0301556531,
-0.0462637842,
0.0130921705,
0.0618216395,
0.0112816663,
0.0205756947,
0.0098145939,
-0.0032912348,
-0.0069002309,
-0.0467735752,
-0.0023477781,
-0.0075253928,
0.0114779416,
-0.0614098795,
-0.0412988104,
0.1423548907,
0.0446256287,
0.0032029515,
-0.0131929722,
-0.019951826,
0.0036436687,
-0.0140719255,
0.0062762592,
-0.0961486101,
-0.045989681,
-0.0046339533,
0.0211319234,
-0.0064308587,
-0.0445965417,
-0.0098769749,
-0.1145912036,
0.0234845467,
-0.010269179,
-0.040696051,
-0.0413343608,
-0.0192862004,
0.0352111049,
-0.0627591535,
0.0097393692,
0.0368971676,
-0.0315795913,
0.0180753339,
-0.0021007766,
0.0075071189,
-0.0536364354,
0.0273174997,
-0.0688252598,
0.0250548143,
0.0263984278,
0.0052874894,
0.0182362888,
-0.0160815399,
0.0128121655,
-0.0270651355,
-0.0197531879,
-0.0287752487,
0.0749876201,
-0.027367007,
-0.0027891591,
-0.0248364899,
0.0354188606,
-0.0470138118,
0.003496574,
0.0054378547,
0.0714483187,
0.0207941178,
-0.0046838769,
0.0226234868,
-0.0304088444,
0.0099625401,
0.0974039882,
-0.0095934561,
-0.0188859887,
-0.014734528,
-0.0131194107,
-0.0436130613,
-0.0357099548,
0.0016366511,
0.0223995522,
-0.0118335178,
-0.0061700079,
-0.0654315129,
-0.0261018444,
0.0422888882,
0.0411931574,
-0.0046099154,
-0.0128751546,
-0.0166651364,
-0.0050192615,
-0.0152072776,
0.0438496545,
-0.0416881442,
-0.0334423743,
-0.0569632053,
0.0115453871,
0.0083436836,
-0.0370964967,
-0.0547403544,
0.0336558409,
-0.0723436251,
-0.0448834598,
0.0265744831,
-0.005034165,
0.0217896681,
0.0555503331,
-0.0076084239,
-0.0032510185,
0.0452004522,
0.0099468818,
-0.0388132147,
0.0006915213,
0.0476629846,
-0.0145081216,
0.039346654,
0.0278278422,
-0.0453319475,
-0.0280123036,
0.0275130253,
0.0087661147,
-0.0137234693,
-0.0601418577,
0.0500850603,
0.0442636386,
0.0606985092,
0.0279630795,
-0.0371637605,
-0.0638004765,
0.0228444356,
-0.0383157544,
-0.0333144702,
-0.0302842483,
0.0377205424,
0.0190371443,
-0.0173074771,
-0.0135903927,
0.0389619768,
0.0011834041,
0.0640361309,
-0.060869541,
-0.0265197959,
0.009573156,
0.0225296468,
0.0211576652,
-0.041408442,
-0.0339485668,
0.0115846721,
-0.0158674698,
0.037974596,
-0.0304239281,
0.0688353777,
0.0137355346,
-0.0220139083,
-0.0049197599,
0.0054330924,
-0.0591670386,
0.0185391009,
-0.0259120092,
0.0484118499,
0.0330736488,
-0.0215319749,
0.0250285715,
-0.0659750402,
-0.0252581574,
0.0115756057,
0.0251846611,
0.0005132913,
0.0099230055,
0.0311969202,
0.0124137094,
-0.0297812056,
0.0035582974,
0.0330417156,
0.0021154142,
0.0467165001,
-0.0057718917,
-0.0063873883,
-0.0290128775,
0.0083709182,
0.0319041908,
0.0281783659,
-0.008360141,
0.0047670882,
-0.0458702557,
-0.0178913381,
0.0314541571,
0.038780801,
-0.0295840576,
0.0257891621,
0.0076392861,
0.0675317496,
0.0217820928,
-0.0639896691,
-0.0395588502,
-0.0093785496,
0.0014218296,
-0.0573013425,
-0.0077783568,
-6.719054445e-33,
-0.0293064751,
0.0071830857,
0.0061670998,
0.0082999943,
-0.0111846374,
-0.0007288724,
-0.018877279,
-0.02157446,
-0.0457210094,
0.011994007,
-0.0179332476,
-0.0156067032,
0.0216739941,
0.030662708,
-0.0337703452,
-0.0155099034,
0.0041900533,
0.0035203991,
-0.0239350367,
-0.0050026029,
0.0695894733,
0.0378460623,
0.0547514595,
-0.0808313116,
0.047863055,
-0.0082020741,
0.0081955576,
0.0288196094,
-0.0013054932,
0.0556478538,
-0.0143559128,
0.0371995009,
0.004104842,
-0.0105591789,
0.0223194249,
0.005682312,
-0.1245921552,
0.0040878383,
0.0235803146,
-0.0118514206,
-0.062909767,
-0.0082325973,
-0.0006767635,
-0.0224024374,
0.0427692384,
-0.0219054967,
0.006626585,
-0.0383992419,
0.0199257154,
-0.005434196,
-0.0539592989,
0.0434723832,
0.0301004872,
0.0032390789,
0.0305557642,
0.012106874,
0.0193946939,
0.0176650584,
-0.0258831456,
-0.0283594243,
0.0035762743,
0.0062280353,
0.0516685545,
0.0254241806,
0.0165627245,
0.0567559712,
-0.0391706936,
-0.0153843891,
-0.0501071587,
-0.0278393216,
-0.0086108809,
0.0730738565,
-0.0043062889,
0.0371143743,
0.021180382,
0.0289854314,
-0.1247279271,
0.0120296041,
0.0165531151,
0.0155582931,
-0.0052121342,
0.002288653,
-0.0904488489,
0.0187962558,
-0.0153819034,
0.0171380006,
-0.0283071846,
-0.012231444,
0.0227969177,
0.0009844316,
-0.0392132103,
-0.0120303687,
0.0163552109,
-0.038707301,
0.0408008322,
0.0198632609,
0.0044816788,
0.0121214241,
-0.0400511473,
0.0077253063,
-0.0923516825,
-0.0363941789,
-0.0017010496,
0.0202355124,
0.0159460884,
0.0254882481,
0.0347888619,
0.0018639601,
-0.0575268641,
0.0001984998,
-0.0685457811,
0.0247943159,
0.0141957477,
0.0138317393,
0.0177561883,
0.0255489629,
0.0048170113,
0.061645478,
0.0546772107,
-0.0006786793,
-0.0149083911,
-0.0339790881,
0.0126703288,
-0.0276865885,
-0.0053152731,
0.0173841473,
0.0360069908,
-0.0041744285,
-0.0175431725,
-0.0258575324,
0.0258978102,
0.0524905138,
2.687e-7,
0.0657097772,
0.0337403826,
-0.0032754189,
0.0640064478,
-0.0357529856,
0.0248494204,
0.004690221,
0.0025939073,
-0.0128841186,
-0.0663823858,
-0.008813886,
0.0093617197,
0.0165240746,
0.0319852605,
-0.0700952709,
-0.0125135444,
-0.0193490051,
-0.0729054064,
-0.0568946302,
-0.0365273058,
0.094726339,
0.0847623572,
0.0233943388,
-0.0010985325,
-0.031605076,
-0.0566771403,
0.0487792045,
-0.0150940372,
-0.0319509469,
0.0146079911,
0.0389847755,
0.0042322706,
-0.0210802034,
0.0380164646,
-0.0021025583,
0.0174940992,
-0.0056211455,
0.0591414049,
0.0262626912,
0.0053697089,
-0.0127231162,
-0.0566990115,
0.0226600897,
-0.0550419316,
0.1119818985,
-0.0442470014,
-0.0160505492,
0.0005283128,
-0.0208194405,
-0.0224552043,
-0.0240117684,
-0.0155998031,
0.0207495578,
0.0233902335,
-0.0071846084,
-0.0168015528,
-0.040832404,
-0.0860659108,
-0.0256990194,
0.0104531236,
-0.0069830897,
-0.0429216698,
0.0347222984,
-0.0160992984,
-0.0032799316,
-0.0816447884,
0.0031950967,
2.838946509e-34,
0.0055511482,
0.0214755889,
-0.0218904801,
0.0283476263,
0.050654415,
0.0139161842,
-0.0375964753,
-0.0352352001,
-0.0233091433,
-0.0816090256,
0.0160609223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10586v2 | VidCoM: Fast Video Comprehension through Large Language Models with Multimodal Tools | 2023-10-16T17:05:56 | 2024-04-27T08:41:37 | Ji Qi, Kaixuan Ji, Jifan Yu, Duokang Wang, Bin Xu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Building models that comprehends videos and responds specific user
instructions is a practical and challenging topic, as it requires mastery of
both vision understanding and knowledge reasoning. Compared to language and
image modalities, training efficiency remains a serious problem as existing
studies train models on massive sparse videos paired with brief descriptions.
In this paper, we introduce \textbf{VidCoM}, a fast adaptive framework that
leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to reason about videos using lightweight
visual tools. Specifically, we reveal that the key to responding to specific
instructions is focusing on relevant video events, and utilize two visual
tools, structured scene graph generation and descriptive image caption
generation, to gather and represent the event information. Thus, a LLM enriched
with world knowledge is adopted as the reasoning agent to achieve the responses
by performing multiple reasoning steps on specific video events. To address the
difficulty of LLMs identifying video events, we further propose an
Instruction-oriented Video Events Recognition (InsOVER) algorithm. This
algorithm locates the corresponding video events based on an efficient
Hungarian matching between decompositions of linguistic instructions and video
events, thereby enabling LLMs to interact effectively with extended videos.
Extensive experiments on two typical video comprehension tasks show that the
proposed tuning-free framework outperforms the pre-trained models including
Flamingo-80B, to achieve the state-of-the-art performance. Our source code and
system will be publicly available. | [
0.0285890065,
0.02922667,
0.014283957,
0.0602613501,
-0.0029702515,
0.0309897903,
-0.0051210076,
-0.0136087723,
0.0116373822,
-0.0724514276,
-0.0006813814,
-0.0095380377,
-0.0296032261,
0.0158039629,
-0.002769639,
-0.0667477697,
0.0494003035,
-0.0458365194,
0.0052181589,
0.0212494265,
0.0296825636,
0.0239227116,
-0.0213852711,
0.0315257683,
0.0052289544,
-0.0046289964,
-0.0264112577,
0.0003971033,
0.0500689335,
-0.0381808728,
-0.0425702482,
0.0125803752,
0.0756617412,
0.0048777368,
0.0000017601,
-0.021406509,
0.0305823926,
-0.0196675379,
-0.0206407271,
0.0306052119,
0.0066824113,
-0.0380300209,
0.0419580154,
-0.0011907702,
-0.0312046017,
-0.0355556235,
0.0361194536,
-0.0003728791,
0.068514064,
0.0411479436,
-0.0306850132,
-0.0460164808,
-0.0050412221,
-0.0065732538,
0.0473892912,
-0.0617391132,
-0.0058893911,
0.0451468565,
0.0417679586,
0.0145469839,
-0.0592070334,
0.0459492505,
0.0105264895,
-0.0213937704,
0.00741314,
0.0361497775,
-0.0345719978,
-0.0444183834,
-0.035968516,
0.0739821792,
0.0128160268,
0.0182322171,
0.0015630332,
0.0356716402,
0.010275173,
0.0171298385,
-0.074271895,
0.0444622077,
-0.0101635577,
0.0004783662,
-0.0162664987,
-0.0257472489,
0.0205424875,
0.0104576247,
0.0181672722,
0.0177794863,
0.0320388041,
0.0492989607,
-0.0336103067,
-0.0160444472,
-0.0575489849,
-0.0705208704,
0.0008826196,
0.0942245126,
-0.0423199609,
0.0087651713,
-0.0380428769,
0.019550439,
-0.04329459,
-0.0712776035,
0.0475249961,
0.0399264283,
-0.0158241428,
0.1023440659,
-0.0455480926,
0.062094368,
-0.0294396952,
0.027683761,
-0.0393563323,
-0.0088476017,
-0.053840518,
0.0132895801,
-0.0220950656,
0.0079143876,
-0.0580528677,
-0.0442666747,
-0.0081558814,
0.0373132266,
-0.0064211739,
0.0305453725,
-0.0328924283,
0.0320408642,
0.009679311,
-0.0210188404,
-0.0420146957,
0.0354863666,
-0.0562228709,
0.0386364833,
-0.0156786572,
-0.0149464933,
-0.0177454017,
0.036551863,
0.0206840131,
-0.0100822262,
0.033862073,
0.0697488859,
-0.0618697815,
-0.0076587219,
-0.0242908429,
0.0070270658,
-0.0097681247,
-0.0304738171,
0.0426632017,
-0.0505183861,
0.0385255814,
0.0136424964,
-0.0015476793,
-0.0134252626,
0.0371863022,
0.0007742803,
-0.0575517379,
0.0732953623,
-0.0141545376,
0.0194218699,
-0.0008085866,
0.0312085394,
-0.0004950385,
0.0313151106,
0.0127905421,
0.0434466302,
0.0316325314,
0.0195576232,
0.0326435678,
0.0245023407,
-0.02728552,
0.0200901832,
-0.0787675604,
0.0384159312,
0.0035928951,
0.0304848775,
0.0416905247,
0.0492434353,
-0.0292352252,
-0.0440361947,
0.0522064269,
0.0292268898,
-0.0354306959,
-0.0225111581,
0.0541148447,
0.0144978585,
0.0014404703,
0.0059902705,
-0.0598453097,
0.0701431856,
-0.0206650086,
0.0022398317,
-0.0031971012,
0.0012170078,
-0.0727110282,
-0.0289664101,
-0.0228858758,
-0.0062544574,
0.0351253748,
0.0540320426,
0.0335970372,
0.0048571131,
-0.0583763942,
0.0241041891,
0.0072708023,
-0.0032793756,
0.0235040821,
-0.0403731465,
0.0280132592,
0.0771539584,
-0.0022284021,
0.0074218395,
-0.0515786223,
0.0232764222,
0.0587957017,
0.0038401994,
-0.0110185342,
-0.0266217571,
0.0384492017,
-0.0706600323,
-0.0376014709,
-0.0239212774,
-0.0072844303,
0.0366356671,
0.0006876153,
-0.0109778661,
0.004573564,
-0.0265283007,
-0.0313438103,
0.0472216047,
0.0581020005,
-0.0503891483,
-0.0255137142,
-0.0014090837,
-0.0022645828,
-0.0004845663,
0.0012029695,
-0.0284710433,
0.0173413213,
-0.0199687984,
0.0256339032,
0.0273057651,
-0.0359010547,
-0.0732723922,
0.0465801433,
-0.0510205626,
-0.0170918759,
0.0234049913,
-0.0370795764,
-0.0385518149,
0.0400774404,
-0.0076381345,
0.0041812025,
-0.0556929335,
-0.0085883802,
0.0264907032,
-0.0080806185,
-0.015902197,
0.040422745,
0.0017623501,
-0.0215201117,
0.0287678335,
0.0128550818,
0.0021295997,
-0.0311681312,
-0.0199202597,
-0.0081532709,
-0.0110687632,
-0.0057267207,
-0.0001549498,
0.0080906898,
-0.0580166653,
0.0023888992,
-0.0961665437,
0.0200211573,
-0.0131640872,
-0.0231577456,
0.0023179303,
0.0043368838,
0.0109077496,
-0.0495857187,
0.00130078,
0.0198101532,
0.0172775183,
0.0152743151,
-0.0020540964,
0.0469771288,
-0.0254801027,
-0.0278183203,
-0.0048453794,
0.0139639098,
0.0523474291,
0.0319391042,
0.0017153011,
-0.0231376477,
0.0028620102,
-0.0170953665,
0.0496313311,
-0.0505375266,
-0.0240064133,
0.0234203842,
-0.0207700171,
0.0036796089,
0.0772508755,
-0.0065705422,
0.0425597057,
0.0239513163,
-0.0201207232,
-0.0185625069,
0.0277413093,
-0.0004874258,
-0.0594531111,
-0.0526402295,
-0.0088329501,
-0.037801072,
0.0254440513,
-0.0389773138,
0.0255533643,
-0.0610269904,
-0.0284543093,
0.038167797,
-0.0061231945,
-0.0562748574,
-0.019341303,
0.0101095708,
0.0298561435,
-0.0433708653,
-0.026734611,
0.0442872457,
-0.0381650068,
-0.0339134634,
0.0140785603,
-0.0061425841,
-0.0234059356,
0.0925761387,
0.0234793238,
0.0284864847,
-0.0610674918,
-0.0215794053,
-0.0544833951,
-0.0423192903,
0.0368409753,
0.0123380674,
0.037291564,
-0.0661703125,
0.0045737452,
-0.0188866388,
0.0072363336,
-0.0522778407,
-0.0182538666,
-0.0358869731,
-0.0161345787,
-0.0528919771,
0.0082114143,
-0.0307714194,
0.0225664675,
0.0394448303,
0.0193785299,
-0.0136900479,
0.0152570801,
-0.0180113371,
0.0338396393,
0.0719111338,
0.0092761442,
-0.0558604524,
-0.0798410326,
0.058368586,
0.0500802994,
0.0446308106,
-0.0368687585,
-0.0516647287,
0.0566334352,
0.0319960192,
0.019822957,
0.0014444549,
0.0442358665,
0.0821183696,
-0.0634459928,
0.0221864469,
0.0948683172,
0.0025946219,
-0.0536683276,
-0.0182799194,
0.0216858611,
0.0164657459,
0.0768967047,
0.0234786104,
-0.0894187689,
-0.0596232004,
-0.019700598,
-0.0146732656,
0.0314784124,
-0.0045933863,
-0.0443917848,
-0.0643012896,
0.053709127,
0.0377393886,
-0.0011366667,
-0.0313278139,
-0.0095789339,
0.0182150621,
0.0104226787,
-0.0240362622,
0.0069077844,
-0.0205525067,
0.0076022306,
-0.0012406637,
0.0291607622,
-0.0225617364,
0.0406169444,
-0.0401981995,
0.0120420652,
0.0023316692,
-0.0105037913,
0.0034169995,
-0.0425241143,
0.0227542911,
0.0172624271,
0.0195099637,
-0.0115580922,
0.0253598876,
-0.0296695232,
-0.0325063951,
-0.0102590583,
0.047664389,
-0.0015184276,
-0.0573300645,
0.0084861135,
0.0762570649,
-0.0320339166,
-0.0018903851,
-0.0308101121,
0.0098417457,
0.0201299693,
0.0670763925,
0.0175092742,
-0.0139358761,
-0.0147276036,
0.0178942848,
-0.0688278154,
-0.052252844,
-0.0277019385,
0.0125828311,
0.027654428,
-0.0142430859,
-0.01840703,
-0.0138166733,
0.0830432475,
0.0447422341,
-0.0157920737,
0.0068088579,
0.0127450339,
0.0451613776,
-0.0734739006,
0.087989144,
-0.0235840958,
-0.0062964819,
-0.0332420133,
-0.0147811994,
0.0174913611,
-0.0170923099,
-0.0091725057,
0.0389669985,
-0.0544174202,
-0.0471477211,
-0.0260620899,
0.042983178,
0.0204185508,
0.0956258774,
0.0324818194,
-0.021669317,
-0.0263165776,
-0.0110540707,
0.0033469533,
0.0116967745,
-0.0143795544,
-0.0421927273,
-0.0215257332,
0.0234183986,
-0.0336227305,
0.0346987993,
0.0051598866,
0.0403298065,
-0.0484762937,
-0.0233274251,
0.0190634299,
-0.0254682526,
0.0122304354,
-0.0317388624,
-0.0114612114,
-0.014835285,
0.0003640496,
0.0228117444,
0.022510821,
-0.0671540722,
0.0032432505,
0.0249758102,
-0.0140526984,
0.013981225,
0.0009249308,
0.0014679582,
-0.0122168744,
-0.0270828977,
0.0007546897,
-0.0094890893,
-0.0148499878,
0.0201433282,
0.0269879978,
0.0108462563,
0.0393964015,
0.0136058843,
0.0339374542,
0.0097454432,
0.0910128281,
0.0136856567,
-0.0217721518,
-0.048169516,
0.0025327366,
-0.0219618231,
-0.0428769402,
-0.0073221414,
0.0502143651,
0.0539438166,
-0.0306782294,
-0.0448435917,
-0.0183970723,
-0.0172298718,
-0.0321107581,
0.0657530129,
-0.0143037327,
-0.0777360946,
0.0635413975,
0.0330887623,
0.0015472565,
0.0027579002,
0.07239528,
0.0417714529,
0.0279715322,
0.0215426944,
-0.0084969494,
-0.0277049877,
-0.0407406166,
0.023592161,
0.0124596087,
-0.0311988592,
0.0451454483,
-0.0008839276,
-0.082626693,
-0.0411231555,
-0.0149902105,
-0.0239947475,
0.0040306738,
0.0345631763,
0.0341107845,
0.00850257,
-0.0335017443,
-0.0078675691,
0.00346732,
-0.043043945,
-0.015209768,
-0.0166283771,
-5.590425217e-33,
-0.0395052992,
-0.0537505932,
0.0466526821,
-0.0082031153,
0.0148001732,
-0.0188884176,
-0.0349910334,
0.036273621,
-0.0365865119,
0.0259481259,
0.0228272639,
0.0260160919,
0.0073777689,
0.0413203426,
-0.0014374896,
-0.0358918682,
0.0302909687,
-0.0111194802,
-0.0177597869,
0.0142987669,
0.012609018,
0.0170026533,
0.0310386829,
-0.0728726909,
-0.0218984224,
-0.0089185312,
-0.0171594247,
0.0383552387,
0.0248654522,
0.0670155063,
-0.0277483426,
-0.0134790754,
0.0165061187,
-0.016466612,
-0.0104556689,
0.004577836,
-0.0695985332,
0.0128530245,
0.0631907731,
0.0311251301,
-0.0858310238,
-0.024066316,
0.0330004804,
-0.0030828959,
-0.0002208468,
-0.0462980792,
0.0362513885,
-0.0200835392,
0.0064070476,
0.045108594,
-0.034886647,
0.0072453134,
-0.0349654034,
-0.0779755488,
0.0429740176,
-0.0089222649,
0.0062518609,
-0.0174011923,
-0.0042574536,
-0.0132759223,
-0.0203135461,
0.0317942798,
0.0842117444,
0.0582895689,
-0.0095023867,
0.0413924344,
-0.0023090423,
-0.0543921888,
-0.024989672,
0.011392422,
0.0038480735,
0.0860716477,
0.0053277677,
0.0219953563,
0.0125346323,
0.0214019101,
-0.0856692716,
0.0242984705,
-0.0410507843,
0.0828818679,
-0.0057906806,
0.0243977215,
0.0160067752,
0.0020853712,
-0.0309977997,
0.0298105534,
-0.0356735811,
0.0086948685,
0.0309839062,
0.0216504522,
0.0026999998,
0.0018579025,
0.0800050646,
-0.0484466702,
0.0314911716,
0.0327871777,
-0.0109642381,
0.0486457944,
0.0142798796,
0.0577524193,
-0.0152259925,
0.0059590745,
0.0353071615,
-0.0241161324,
0.0012200229,
0.0228546727,
0.0074514677,
0.0374447145,
-0.0153013403,
-0.0148540651,
-0.0437276065,
-0.0067947116,
-0.0263856072,
0.0474454537,
0.0235507749,
0.0278459173,
-0.0554521941,
0.0479108356,
-0.0644273013,
-0.001134309,
-0.0060254727,
-0.0517905168,
0.0059406497,
0.0208273251,
-0.0407152958,
0.0170593429,
-0.0576998666,
-0.0265753251,
-0.0074572535,
-0.0508062132,
0.0006668348,
0.0527527854,
2.604e-7,
0.0012920215,
0.0158910956,
-0.0127468603,
0.0243934896,
-0.0033982475,
0.0404671617,
-0.0209165085,
0.0286255497,
0.0381104052,
-0.051060874,
0.0256016254,
0.0915626362,
0.0139191216,
-0.0104247993,
-0.0263620783,
-0.0119645027,
-0.0237850472,
-0.0112414975,
-0.0755607933,
0.0125339925,
0.0471489727,
0.0887536928,
-0.002303933,
0.0055812532,
0.0548846945,
-0.0708092004,
0.0803408399,
-0.0072716884,
-0.0288833268,
0.0050311461,
-0.011596838,
0.0257107746,
-0.0466646552,
0.0121926572,
-0.0028943715,
-0.0043174825,
0.0179743469,
0.0729449093,
-0.0435557291,
-0.0274031814,
-0.0433631912,
0.0210801009,
-0.004370729,
-0.0228577852,
0.0827888399,
-0.0308791045,
-0.0192181915,
-0.0212892629,
-0.0119272601,
0.0034694271,
-0.0499953777,
0.016770158,
-0.0106005585,
0.00176705,
0.028696809,
-0.0390170291,
-0.030822888,
-0.1193378866,
0.0055149067,
0.0046900925,
-0.0515732318,
-0.0024816734,
-0.0525036864,
-0.0056563844,
0.0539930053,
-0.0134595679,
-0.049629271,
1.869744184e-34,
0.0135371098,
0.005631357,
-0.0172119532,
-0.0073710466,
0.0325413868,
-0.0111131901,
-0.063799262,
0.0244347155,
0.0336282514,
-0.075108014,
-0.0273256004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10583v1 | Who Are All The Stochastic Parrots Imitating? They Should Tell Us! | 2023-10-16T16:57:55 | 2023-10-16T16:57:55 | Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E. Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Both standalone language models (LMs) as well as LMs within downstream-task
systems have been shown to generate statements which are factually untrue. This
problem is especially severe for low-resource languages, where training data is
scarce and of worse quality than for high-resource languages. In this opinion
piece, we argue that LMs in their current state will never be fully trustworthy
in critical settings and suggest a possible novel strategy to handle this
issue: by building LMs such that can cite their sources - i.e., point a user to
the parts of their training data that back up their outputs. We first discuss
which current NLP tasks would or would not benefit from such models. We then
highlight the expected benefits such models would bring, e.g., quick
verifiability of statements. We end by outlining the individual tasks that
would need to be solved on the way to developing LMs with the ability to cite.
We hope to start a discussion about the field's current approach to building
LMs, especially for low-resource languages, and the role of the training data
in explaining model generations. | [
0.0373146944,
0.077158682,
-0.0270622037,
0.0277793668,
-0.0600221939,
0.0062996931,
0.0033662911,
-0.0128136547,
0.001725139,
-0.0809822902,
0.0100912517,
0.0034749964,
0.0133942757,
-0.0052359235,
0.0555571467,
-0.0344149396,
0.032930918,
-0.03567129,
0.0183834136,
-0.0189699885,
-0.0062444308,
0.0160311982,
0.005092531,
0.0459743291,
-0.0051300582,
-0.0423565246,
-0.0049855812,
-0.0178572163,
-0.0332188718,
-0.0159172062,
-0.0261452142,
0.03632221,
-0.0190500654,
0.0368225276,
0.0000022741,
-0.0389837399,
0.0137820086,
0.0114913238,
-0.0863102749,
-0.0027549253,
0.0041834922,
0.0013410083,
-0.0264544971,
-0.0069330879,
-0.048683092,
-0.0312161874,
0.04325312,
0.0383215025,
0.0484185033,
0.0447967798,
0.0063436464,
0.0188370571,
0.0123652974,
-0.0022785536,
0.0018250823,
-0.0041672932,
0.0161243267,
0.0178087242,
0.0062464932,
0.0297623407,
0.0172219314,
0.0625589415,
0.0148309106,
-0.0239196289,
-0.0152471643,
0.0350055136,
-0.0183914546,
-0.0129194725,
-0.0316567756,
0.020584153,
-0.0154054426,
-0.0567680448,
-0.0077016689,
-0.0110686952,
0.0015839761,
0.0039421055,
-0.0417905785,
0.0831972733,
-0.0152389966,
0.0204457957,
0.0443634875,
-0.0470810868,
0.0519269966,
0.0127218235,
0.0017908911,
0.0681448057,
-0.0154411336,
-0.0303197112,
0.0167496633,
0.0308257863,
-0.0073997793,
-0.0942046046,
-0.0226397775,
0.0214089416,
0.0196410362,
0.0517450385,
-0.0342158303,
0.0198978577,
0.0233199988,
-0.0485733673,
0.0414641313,
-0.0144438045,
-0.025541475,
0.0280910954,
-0.0308047775,
0.0301350653,
-0.0108212568,
-0.0115905767,
0.0047772685,
0.0079926001,
-0.0606045835,
-0.0242596231,
-0.0263138991,
0.0528184846,
-0.0269244425,
0.0090417117,
-0.0011143509,
0.0487009063,
-0.0478358865,
0.0290818438,
0.0068195984,
0.0146136228,
-0.0170040857,
0.0104271285,
-0.0495672412,
-0.0022438683,
0.0236292649,
0.0231573414,
0.0016909391,
-0.1341380477,
-0.0107420217,
0.0092095202,
-0.0266901255,
0.0089133494,
-0.0271312892,
0.0969004631,
0.0272731651,
0.0066177193,
-0.0742568299,
-0.0591777675,
-0.0465790257,
-0.0696405247,
-0.0178417116,
-0.0864871591,
-0.0108979726,
0.0170808528,
0.0106324116,
-0.0596814565,
0.0208041947,
0.0422483347,
-0.0486249328,
0.071131222,
-0.0310032628,
0.0345955044,
-0.0207303837,
-0.0285470784,
0.0031490661,
0.0769925937,
0.0561215281,
-0.0098082637,
0.0565358587,
0.0175443459,
0.0096816244,
0.0141369365,
0.028972283,
0.0115363169,
0.0067951134,
-0.0088449679,
-0.0038523038,
-0.0233515035,
-0.0017446078,
0.0896376893,
-0.0145609658,
0.031245647,
0.1033487841,
0.013465778,
-0.0123702046,
-0.0011980177,
0.0679187253,
0.0097148875,
0.0063376767,
0.0397367552,
-0.0467016101,
-0.0039585056,
-0.017123295,
0.0179279782,
-0.0058149118,
0.016146142,
-0.0085896365,
-0.0583644323,
-0.0619598813,
-0.011863078,
-0.0245041959,
0.0218922738,
0.035440702,
0.0475643538,
-0.0137772057,
0.0678056404,
0.0177964177,
-0.0355473235,
-0.0035979496,
-0.0669513866,
0.022352919,
0.0227325354,
0.0458216779,
0.0387912691,
0.0088023767,
-0.0429484956,
0.0021865412,
0.0644564629,
0.0269776564,
-0.0256739222,
0.00793349,
0.0030816421,
-0.0102226799,
-0.0168497711,
0.0331076868,
-0.0279554538,
0.0205713473,
-0.0075789504,
0.0069647795,
-0.0446916446,
-0.0828654841,
0.0662842691,
-0.0453414991,
-0.049784258,
-0.0208735503,
-0.0079537584,
0.0221723858,
0.0273040868,
-0.0012320611,
0.0341854617,
0.0382425524,
0.0056371954,
0.0011531137,
0.0396737941,
-0.0109640099,
-0.0168206003,
0.0343985073,
-0.0095499158,
-0.0093294708,
0.0093333488,
-0.009447542,
-0.0461230539,
0.0047741863,
-0.0577297322,
0.0195466392,
-0.0405650623,
0.0268815421,
0.0102045881,
-0.0076659513,
-0.0328685679,
0.044842191,
-0.0001581463,
0.0178355444,
-0.0206611641,
0.0166024379,
0.0275298823,
-0.0641237125,
-0.0443213098,
0.0211858451,
0.0063992431,
0.0288906414,
0.0230902713,
0.0049986844,
-0.0093776556,
0.0046508289,
-0.0473859124,
-0.0163055677,
-0.0181870777,
0.005212279,
-0.0013338237,
-0.0336748473,
-0.0010819057,
-0.0120933987,
0.008423279,
-0.0185591783,
0.0147458306,
0.0314350501,
0.0488024391,
0.0151142646,
0.0139592681,
-0.0363892019,
0.012114848,
-0.0021318251,
0.0438726321,
0.0292979199,
-0.0008946459,
-0.0921785384,
0.0386714526,
-0.0208633356,
0.0264176149,
0.0097986292,
0.0357086621,
0.0422982126,
0.0056805913,
0.0287926085,
0.028112445,
-0.0265088808,
0.0263476092,
0.0629362464,
-0.0107372291,
-0.082148239,
0.0055333097,
-0.0197860282,
-0.0501612537,
-0.0232802499,
-0.0434175096,
0.026449427,
0.0601739213,
0.0147514017,
-0.028021317,
-0.0259067472,
0.0386881866,
-0.0288042892,
-0.0282557532,
0.0102926753,
-0.0428714342,
-0.0401625857,
0.0305170789,
-0.0040106154,
-0.0750384778,
0.0692962408,
-0.0645149872,
0.0247987173,
-0.0309846383,
-0.0314654559,
0.0029041492,
0.0520862006,
-0.0043763029,
-0.0051072924,
0.0669162497,
0.0103027876,
-0.0218943693,
0.005464294,
0.0444908515,
-0.0219568834,
0.0488156639,
-0.0563116111,
0.0279058795,
0.0050666765,
-0.0448697768,
-0.0543926954,
-0.031220397,
-0.0651915744,
-0.0005067642,
-0.0128639266,
0.0206542592,
0.0021788939,
-0.0031453357,
0.049941659,
0.0066665965,
-0.0171505548,
-0.026177898,
-0.0241455361,
0.0044113803,
0.0429810919,
-0.0131525639,
0.0534352623,
-0.0348003022,
-0.0054885,
0.0564303398,
0.1008536145,
0.0148426397,
-0.0414342619,
-0.0556660481,
0.0262957308,
-0.0316080004,
-0.0570104308,
0.0269861445,
0.0197313577,
-0.0764565468,
-0.0225625187,
0.1019819155,
-0.0000575869,
-0.0145389903,
0.0168013573,
-0.0155901993,
0.0021565163,
0.0125367362,
0.0189949814,
-0.0763843209,
-0.0091031278,
0.0312230326,
0.0348657481,
-0.0295103882,
-0.0223152414,
-0.024815537,
-0.129233256,
0.0523189902,
-0.0082244072,
0.0035322539,
-0.0141158858,
-0.0631244555,
-0.0148917362,
-0.0051279156,
0.0192258134,
0.0238490663,
-0.0451262705,
0.0230366066,
0.0436365977,
-0.0518105924,
-0.0495320484,
-0.0060765776,
-0.0450202934,
0.0785929188,
0.0444498584,
0.0208850205,
-0.0089372555,
-0.0182161611,
0.0218662154,
-0.0362666883,
-0.0016540962,
-0.01780493,
0.0321710259,
-0.0190144237,
-0.0030606196,
-0.013480993,
-0.0062176106,
-0.0218147375,
-0.0115779368,
-0.0220355727,
0.0775206089,
-0.0400395244,
-0.0275283568,
0.0042864271,
-0.0021634048,
0.0401747897,
0.0920248777,
0.0316257775,
-0.014010489,
-0.0542621575,
-0.0453288294,
-0.0102437744,
-0.0343197733,
-0.0372975282,
0.0344065838,
-0.0127603849,
-0.0168669913,
-0.0751805454,
-0.059160389,
-0.0013046385,
0.040467713,
0.0213687848,
0.0177921243,
0.0517843366,
-0.0099977236,
-0.0082143322,
0.0173651334,
-0.0631115139,
0.0011211119,
-0.0275764298,
0.001829599,
0.0400022343,
-0.0087447139,
0.0210827421,
0.0129814399,
-0.0528194048,
-0.0614734255,
0.0122868326,
0.0597206019,
0.0300026294,
0.0258823782,
-0.0174568947,
-0.0468824096,
0.0428929515,
0.0252988469,
-0.0325237177,
0.0230496116,
0.04645193,
-0.0188845042,
0.0153917437,
0.0520730354,
-0.0280816834,
0.0008162808,
0.0062320489,
0.0212815944,
-0.0307114702,
-0.0255652331,
0.0373866893,
0.0233510062,
0.0664347485,
-0.0171231683,
-0.0068960865,
-0.0293603819,
0.0037056736,
-0.0150215356,
-0.0116185416,
-0.0411262549,
0.0254061967,
-0.018471444,
0.0354021862,
0.0017967236,
0.005635215,
-0.0209018253,
0.0842883438,
-0.0094929682,
-0.005517384,
0.0361684076,
0.0070122071,
-0.0045965672,
-0.0054073576,
-0.023851607,
0.0208390225,
-0.0204028096,
0.0311841536,
0.0119546261,
0.0089041656,
0.028762199,
-0.0210265759,
0.0382857472,
-0.0124870325,
-0.0597050637,
-0.0343619175,
-0.004034502,
-0.0420964733,
0.0662335604,
-0.0020042334,
0.0992008299,
-0.0383636467,
-0.0052062273,
-0.0240525249,
0.0000836639,
0.0327826291,
-0.0317853056,
0.0288815349,
0.0225735903,
-0.0592247844,
0.0121887466,
0.0682403147,
0.0520219579,
0.0569846183,
-0.0099915359,
-0.0106607974,
-0.0321217701,
-0.0391731709,
-0.0600015186,
-0.0014371898,
-0.0083484529,
-0.0147328693,
-0.0671991259,
-0.0973621905,
-0.0001171522,
0.0413999781,
0.0029528497,
-0.0318866558,
0.017420873,
0.0619020388,
0.0428539552,
-0.0053131795,
-0.0730524734,
0.0316404253,
0.0125304665,
0.0014302803,
-0.0304613505,
-6.585483022e-33,
-0.0229203999,
-0.057007812,
0.0114733847,
0.0217030887,
0.0300802812,
0.005974811,
-0.0416370146,
0.0179310702,
-0.0559773408,
0.0341209732,
-0.0227511562,
-0.008547809,
0.0286152754,
0.0009439396,
0.0278036203,
0.0153194685,
0.0573559627,
-0.026671065,
-0.0017939807,
-0.0149714807,
0.0661072657,
-0.0072881225,
0.0650954992,
-0.1034205928,
0.0924276039,
-0.0423120521,
-0.0284016356,
0.0183184445,
-0.0209714733,
0.0643042102,
-0.0089320559,
0.058702372,
0.0127594769,
-0.0677930415,
-0.0291714482,
-0.0286689028,
-0.0690331981,
-0.0217849314,
0.0453116894,
-0.0037909024,
-0.033334408,
-0.0027624075,
0.0375799313,
-0.0114203263,
-0.0425113924,
0.0347403102,
0.0192983765,
-0.0433470607,
-0.0095819328,
0.0097515332,
-0.0438664816,
0.0234687645,
0.0517129004,
0.0223905016,
0.0241555423,
0.0315353386,
-0.0301114619,
-0.0380458869,
-0.0647097304,
0.0208540522,
-0.0020190182,
0.0294220261,
0.0873864219,
-0.0122270212,
0.0113293556,
0.0458876975,
0.0134783899,
0.0091271745,
-0.0169482827,
0.0087731965,
0.0228546951,
0.0559662059,
0.0422971956,
0.0435152873,
-0.017092824,
0.0110402936,
-0.0361602493,
-0.0121877138,
0.02915987,
0.031719368,
0.0361344665,
-0.0123314746,
-0.0682585984,
-0.0286984537,
-0.0441321321,
-0.0359066688,
-0.0014698828,
-0.0331886113,
0.001587776,
0.0321749523,
-0.0220344029,
0.0382850654,
0.0124393506,
-0.0427780002,
-0.0454529226,
-0.0059479773,
0.0033724639,
-0.0067765354,
-0.0068768919,
0.0007069802,
-0.0648082644,
0.0049589667,
-0.0156472195,
0.0151412701,
0.0298045911,
0.0463475734,
0.0308019817,
0.0293193646,
-0.0648986027,
0.0193190593,
-0.0397904925,
0.0542461351,
0.0045441049,
0.0055747,
0.0572994165,
-0.0052260803,
-0.0163061898,
0.0513243936,
0.0068404847,
-0.0235632509,
-0.0291777588,
0.0493918881,
-0.0080275033,
0.0172866881,
-0.0164377093,
-0.0265384093,
-0.035846509,
0.0630762279,
0.0333584733,
-0.0211333726,
0.0017689046,
0.0295891967,
2.974e-7,
0.0289669614,
0.0289649293,
0.0178788118,
-0.0037928405,
0.0228557549,
0.05228284,
-0.0013881306,
-0.014895699,
-0.0184264239,
-0.0504633598,
-0.0725161508,
0.0184249338,
0.0550838858,
0.0592284836,
-0.0689430982,
-0.0247390084,
-0.0477691144,
0.0029916211,
-0.0311250556,
-0.0212335009,
0.0046336744,
0.0704343244,
0.0285827313,
0.0012370091,
-0.0444466323,
-0.0555907562,
0.0379322991,
0.009626165,
-0.0346690267,
0.0217716992,
0.0633662716,
0.0364327803,
-0.0095376531,
0.0140483119,
-0.0266032722,
-0.0049859448,
-0.0473655351,
0.0573125705,
0.0133112371,
-0.0381399356,
-0.0194668211,
-0.0242418479,
0.0191991068,
-0.0519864671,
0.0585169271,
-0.0269687939,
-0.0327608362,
-0.044231642,
-0.0207328424,
0.0094687669,
-0.033739619,
-0.0034025307,
-0.0194219202,
0.0125794094,
-0.0136583224,
0.0120918192,
-0.0238129962,
-0.0478517525,
-0.0245903898,
-0.0066316142,
-0.0076448373,
-0.0678766221,
0.0126925763,
-0.0112300301,
0.034910772,
-0.0820709318,
0.0030393307,
2.889555673e-34,
0.0050723925,
0.0074094092,
0.0291843675,
0.0234448239,
0.0076625878,
0.0364347883,
-0.0080016004,
0.0066554975,
0.0161935035,
-0.0129867317,
-0.0362320729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10571v1 | Emerging Challenges in Personalized Medicine: Assessing Demographic Effects on Biomedical Question Answering Systems | 2023-10-16T16:45:52 | 2023-10-16T16:45:52 | Sagi Shaier, Kevin Bennett, Lawrence Hunter, Katharina von der Wense | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | State-of-the-art question answering (QA) models exhibit a variety of social
biases (e.g., with respect to sex or race), generally explained by similar
issues in their training data. However, what has been overlooked so far is that
in the critical domain of biomedicine, any unjustified change in model output
due to patient demographics is problematic: it results in the unfair treatment
of patients. Selecting only questions on biomedical topics whose answers do not
depend on ethnicity, sex, or sexual orientation, we ask the following research
questions: (RQ1) Do the answers of QA models change when being provided with
irrelevant demographic information? (RQ2) Does the answer of RQ1 differ between
knowledge graph (KG)-grounded and text-based QA systems? We find that
irrelevant demographic information change up to 15% of the answers of a
KG-grounded system and up to 23% of the answers of a text-based system,
including changes that affect accuracy. We conclude that unjustified answer
changes caused by patient demographics are a frequent phenomenon, which raises
fairness concerns and should be paid more attention to. | [
0.108714357,
0.0604903437,
-0.0105807865,
-0.0087019987,
0.0044267559,
0.0230147261,
0.0335685089,
0.0239938889,
0.0142887216,
-0.0384917818,
0.0112730814,
-0.0116485003,
-0.0053347163,
-0.0384445861,
-0.0149826072,
-0.0218806546,
-0.0028537239,
0.0606954247,
0.0569987297,
-0.0498031005,
-0.0077654622,
0.0144979665,
0.0279659834,
0.0278684832,
0.0425925106,
-0.0272860136,
0.0798767582,
-0.0145563567,
0.0157867465,
-0.0201253984,
0.0287363883,
0.0503527783,
-0.0627387241,
-0.0128270108,
0.0000017992,
-0.0879157335,
0.001923238,
0.0362024009,
-0.0733611435,
-0.0192982648,
0.0153897386,
-0.0025938358,
0.0192626119,
0.0249894746,
-0.0643832907,
0.0078610796,
0.0093985219,
0.0042105718,
0.0108349007,
-0.0131858084,
-0.0028416221,
0.0181193203,
-0.0525333174,
-0.0024848061,
0.035010457,
-0.0180042125,
0.026650805,
0.0089267194,
-0.0079584541,
-0.0370694399,
-0.0007163503,
0.0417280532,
-0.0031053664,
0.0454320237,
0.0557639599,
0.0215410478,
-0.0003307372,
-0.0004192228,
0.0189439431,
0.0572579466,
0.047713656,
0.0352256596,
-0.0049197385,
0.0120906401,
0.0306484587,
0.035823334,
-0.0552810058,
0.0059302705,
-0.0439359657,
-0.025411332,
-0.0266087037,
-0.0251137018,
0.0273850486,
0.0280360747,
0.0133276125,
0.0586432293,
0.017273616,
-0.0080966223,
-0.009600753,
0.0200271346,
0.0198906213,
-0.0345944762,
0.0531389937,
0.0361087844,
-0.0063691605,
0.0025240553,
0.0206857286,
0.0047431402,
0.0856990591,
-0.0502358787,
-0.0123333391,
0.0201760475,
0.0232603885,
0.0143094426,
0.0219122209,
0.0093264068,
0.0011228296,
0.0283810366,
-0.0643055141,
-0.0024048549,
-0.026924355,
-0.026108522,
0.0096253706,
0.0098946001,
0.0202294067,
0.0629551113,
-0.0601630732,
-0.0168633591,
-0.0403572991,
-0.0163772926,
0.0032863454,
0.0727134943,
-0.0119330855,
0.0071342369,
-0.0614190102,
0.0271698814,
-0.0514593609,
0.0175168887,
-0.0126845958,
-0.0600884929,
0.0245491564,
-0.0427373946,
0.031553138,
-0.0080743153,
0.0212742463,
0.0294599663,
0.0158510786,
-0.0082639446,
0.0008860257,
-0.0459405333,
-0.0158124082,
-0.0135299861,
-0.0073258351,
-0.0537614338,
0.0446506552,
0.0511534214,
0.0076710177,
-0.0291423313,
0.0032721155,
0.040450938,
-0.0900419578,
0.0658473074,
0.0189287886,
0.0287146512,
0.0566972755,
0.040114928,
-0.024843676,
0.025969144,
0.0257864799,
-0.0693453401,
0.0600884072,
-0.0284497943,
-0.0296135694,
-0.016503999,
0.0485309437,
-0.0148661863,
0.0465561561,
0.0838018209,
-0.0122591974,
0.0404413007,
-0.0112770954,
0.0274504423,
-0.0024865139,
-0.0674265176,
0.0070259911,
0.0866209939,
-0.0022924505,
0.046932634,
-0.0194446594,
-0.0472147241,
-0.0033476963,
0.0074782437,
-0.0373610444,
-0.0152408928,
-0.0215069372,
-0.032030113,
-0.0373549573,
0.0163996033,
-0.0464653187,
-0.0062870639,
-0.035416048,
0.0094846869,
0.0419417396,
0.0278047044,
-0.0109797483,
-0.0079326956,
0.0229897518,
0.0645257756,
0.0419781581,
-0.0179312658,
-0.0028961205,
-0.06245891,
0.0026586601,
0.058418449,
0.0279329438,
-0.0182411373,
-0.0374962911,
-0.006031876,
-0.0451454185,
-0.0125806015,
0.046555806,
-0.0421796851,
-0.016546946,
-0.019231664,
-0.015721444,
0.0180162117,
-0.0011669243,
-0.0133273024,
0.0595776029,
0.0699755698,
-0.027804736,
-0.0582987741,
0.0009780427,
0.0256516859,
-0.0449413806,
-0.0192687567,
0.0150594944,
-0.0106502585,
0.0523332804,
0.0430573039,
0.0230684951,
0.0409262404,
-0.0208016485,
0.0128630782,
-0.0131268566,
-0.0252598971,
-0.0302588586,
-0.0119676758,
0.0109797334,
-0.005213147,
-0.0363546126,
0.0025118859,
-0.0122176064,
0.0060847197,
0.025035264,
-0.0412632041,
-0.0195769779,
0.02981719,
-0.0328718051,
0.0153423157,
-0.0114572626,
-0.068091549,
0.0001168938,
-0.0373273194,
-0.0003379264,
0.0066017243,
-0.059747383,
-0.0105865141,
-0.0492921956,
-0.0020398523,
0.0145859942,
0.0014521314,
-0.0181146767,
0.0019320151,
-0.0370883122,
-0.0532525107,
0.0382607169,
-0.0913088694,
-0.0186974425,
0.0064683319,
0.0270226523,
0.0051419614,
0.0256349575,
-0.002333909,
-0.0661991388,
-0.0466099232,
-0.0088769998,
0.0391318649,
0.0605803952,
0.0050811986,
0.0354241692,
0.046390444,
-0.0271242987,
-0.0466303788,
-0.0401269682,
0.0334582664,
0.0288316086,
0.0215616766,
0.000151816,
-0.0527463071,
-0.0954249725,
-0.001844181,
0.0045595765,
0.0047104922,
0.0204325896,
0.0402304567,
-0.012701639,
0.0614402741,
0.0187612474,
-0.0017806769,
0.0320444927,
0.0235789847,
-0.0203175601,
0.001617567,
-0.023470195,
-0.0084044607,
0.0390064865,
-0.0859736726,
-0.0101364488,
0.0349958353,
0.0550425053,
-0.0254859086,
-0.046952609,
0.0343649536,
-0.0706010088,
-0.0133392205,
-0.0735605359,
0.0123283518,
-0.0058501516,
0.0274581965,
-0.0112122707,
-0.0079652835,
0.0863323435,
0.0591931529,
0.0346989185,
-0.0700184107,
-0.0061191483,
-0.0670148432,
-0.0057382178,
-0.0157610998,
0.0294180475,
0.02948731,
0.0039056388,
-0.0461639091,
-0.0607903227,
-0.0037736986,
-0.0764242858,
0.0470520481,
-0.0343345255,
0.012321163,
-0.0038722106,
-0.0474401377,
-0.0518565886,
-0.039670486,
-0.0365540832,
0.0071799168,
-0.0033151102,
-0.0023578505,
0.0129316365,
-0.0079489052,
0.0101602981,
0.0443061627,
-0.0079181343,
-0.0274253357,
0.0412346832,
0.0155635886,
0.0305096861,
0.0296475664,
0.0444972292,
0.0051638624,
0.0269102976,
0.0692852736,
0.0182356443,
-0.0225045159,
0.0559882708,
0.0040208097,
0.0030351207,
-0.0415885076,
-0.0111098066,
-0.0043845936,
0.0321909115,
-0.040171437,
0.0324598365,
0.0573159866,
0.0189786498,
-0.0202746075,
0.0236232206,
-0.0510907918,
-0.0458753966,
-0.0011379438,
0.0258355606,
-0.0792120621,
0.0046589235,
-0.020813724,
0.0652721226,
-0.0465813354,
-0.0340123661,
-0.0084709004,
-0.0394878276,
0.0048505496,
-0.0125240274,
-0.0453031212,
-0.027901439,
-0.026279809,
0.0139261354,
0.000103283,
-0.0033880032,
-0.0159982406,
0.0074190712,
0.0249503497,
0.0036940065,
-0.0738044754,
-0.0065527265,
0.0593756475,
0.002534718,
0.0102350973,
0.0302598123,
0.0389814749,
0.0075076157,
-0.0190949682,
-0.0294304285,
-0.0176473968,
0.011827399,
-0.0396232754,
0.0539066382,
0.0081128748,
0.032133434,
-0.0936864763,
0.0459554903,
-0.0346503705,
-0.0045020934,
0.0095144575,
0.0349601321,
0.0035460473,
-0.0551583618,
-0.0658494756,
0.0265763476,
-0.0167004652,
0.048172079,
-0.0109229535,
-0.0015553088,
-0.0135558201,
-0.0374834873,
0.0393961519,
0.008757324,
-0.0327434763,
0.042768769,
-0.0070507359,
-0.0075911102,
-0.0270736031,
-0.0495877936,
0.0373543389,
-0.0527839586,
-0.0104198763,
-0.0128597021,
0.0370055325,
-0.0122684408,
-0.0577502809,
0.0568582192,
-0.0177834835,
0.0079414491,
0.0161364656,
-0.0515935011,
0.0071800943,
-0.0159566924,
-0.029229857,
-0.0331460461,
0.0263786111,
0.0190978963,
0.0353984609,
0.0393389724,
0.0162464939,
0.0055471212,
0.003324019,
-0.0125643881,
0.0599948689,
0.0254964381,
0.0030657805,
0.004608701,
-0.0256209671,
0.0416807532,
-0.0207478777,
0.0096669188,
-0.0264519919,
0.0067720572,
0.0333579779,
-0.017525319,
-0.048024036,
-0.0247598514,
-0.0095103914,
0.0280837212,
-0.0279423576,
0.0200453848,
-0.0170736499,
0.023515977,
0.0001775675,
0.0034228975,
0.0109927095,
0.0278064068,
-0.0862973779,
-0.0003233863,
0.004428152,
-0.0406182967,
-0.0188210253,
-0.0501291268,
-0.0128321834,
-0.0512954481,
0.0107571948,
0.0359190218,
0.0109836711,
0.0224384815,
-0.0114427963,
-0.0054961378,
-0.000640731,
0.0031207881,
0.0422685258,
0.0264670942,
0.053198874,
-0.0201211907,
-0.0145160006,
-0.0408109128,
-0.0110101309,
-0.0836480707,
-0.0496019199,
-0.0012520233,
0.0173815098,
-0.0155163938,
0.0080449162,
-0.01989864,
0.0233797915,
-0.0170202348,
0.0099002225,
-0.0597702079,
0.0229247492,
0.0340432636,
0.0896572694,
0.0086816158,
0.0109724049,
-0.0040372871,
0.0573416203,
0.0408813804,
0.0757499188,
-0.0554393083,
-0.0664846301,
-0.0193054304,
-0.011044045,
0.0171297248,
-0.0043644593,
-0.0415772386,
0.0068805385,
-0.0990128219,
-0.0197651889,
0.0122134807,
-0.0196956228,
0.0136570456,
-0.0286154039,
0.0346202441,
0.0506452471,
0.0157128964,
-0.0924051106,
0.005129152,
0.0940319672,
-0.0854757354,
-0.0110695371,
0.0009877543,
-5.723679257e-33,
-0.0001284724,
-0.0452136546,
-0.0163121093,
-0.0458112061,
0.013035465,
0.0088244751,
-0.0082522687,
-0.02198123,
-0.0220520012,
0.0302951951,
-0.0200018175,
0.0272223838,
-0.0025188064,
0.0055745565,
0.0153060239,
-0.0782961175,
0.0342386626,
-0.0148677342,
-0.0136973327,
0.0167807415,
-0.0341016091,
0.0499568209,
0.0056918403,
-0.0484531783,
0.0653480366,
-0.0084425639,
0.0672659129,
0.0192023702,
-0.048428569,
0.0429606512,
-0.0088752983,
0.0804074705,
0.0597904548,
-0.015462961,
0.0310380589,
0.0396061465,
-0.0904641747,
-0.0304943752,
0.0087187476,
0.00615473,
-0.0333757624,
-0.047169026,
0.0577495173,
0.0405449234,
-0.0423578396,
-0.0503664985,
0.0468937792,
-0.0026432215,
0.0403564237,
-0.010248444,
0.0100265332,
0.0135407355,
-0.0036658389,
0.0270362683,
-0.0843856409,
0.0305878893,
-0.0458700024,
0.0342115387,
-0.0283566453,
-0.0081410436,
0.0135104377,
-0.0386197865,
0.0164477099,
0.0030781033,
0.001769004,
-0.006936721,
0.0206275266,
0.0304204319,
-0.065284349,
-0.059288431,
-0.0661213994,
-0.0277916137,
0.0459013879,
0.0371840522,
0.0103292307,
0.006632708,
-0.0841570795,
-0.0021461179,
-0.0249496009,
0.0423870981,
0.0285957921,
-0.031592004,
-0.0799875185,
-0.0226612072,
-0.0274057705,
-0.0120637026,
-0.0304918084,
-0.0162582286,
0.0077551268,
0.0018931727,
-0.0442046858,
-0.0022788886,
-0.019922426,
-0.0464148745,
-0.0073083956,
-0.0134991501,
0.0244968683,
-0.0425880514,
0.0227211788,
-0.0004866551,
-0.0483327061,
0.0832410231,
0.0103568714,
-0.0445636213,
0.0334791131,
0.035396371,
-0.0131918238,
-0.058134336,
-0.0325002521,
-0.0183314402,
0.0243817065,
0.0257284548,
0.0089775156,
0.0115905339,
0.0304585509,
0.085905008,
0.0189765804,
0.0470873863,
0.04529294,
0.0547766648,
-0.0424839109,
-0.0291425101,
-0.0168308448,
0.0155284954,
-0.0424799249,
0.0217564404,
-0.0044467775,
0.0591718704,
-0.0218228363,
-0.0252385456,
-0.010304532,
-0.0471946485,
2.411e-7,
0.0783047602,
0.0405918658,
-0.0114252139,
-0.0245417338,
0.0625946671,
0.0279844329,
0.0440691821,
0.0186099578,
0.0671395883,
-0.0022485945,
0.0072200922,
0.0184048079,
-0.0122306896,
0.0624632537,
-0.0194014609,
-0.0384496301,
-0.0622737557,
-0.0132593121,
0.0070112748,
0.0211004317,
-0.0000021044,
0.021652909,
-0.0092368294,
-0.0216699094,
-0.0263365861,
0.0155254761,
0.0185415316,
-0.0015191591,
0.0058897189,
0.025140496,
0.0355785601,
-0.0179471672,
0.030932473,
0.0994054675,
0.0047171302,
-0.0136664072,
0.0036821438,
0.0398465879,
-0.0776726976,
-0.0039095827,
-0.0049742199,
-0.0188595243,
0.0342088975,
-0.0701991916,
0.0591168813,
-0.0031740614,
-0.0678511932,
-0.0476594679,
0.009909722,
-0.0142976008,
0.0773188248,
-0.0009872295,
-0.0489315242,
-0.008039034,
0.0323482417,
0.0414452814,
0.0225670468,
-0.0317634977,
0.0126875937,
0.0033642801,
-0.0260532387,
-0.0722841024,
0.0275594257,
0.0091249943,
-0.0202955101,
-0.0253924727,
0.0303745642,
1.615149097e-34,
-0.0250256658,
0.0623342432,
0.0256941244,
-0.0444770679,
0.0010393373,
0.0062116021,
0.0192220826,
-0.0168198571,
0.0567897968,
-0.032651864,
-0.0122745754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10570v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10570v5 | On Context Utilization in Summarization with Large Language Models | 2023-10-16T16:45:12 | 2024-06-14T07:26:19 | Mathieu Ravaut, Aixin Sun, Nancy F. Chen, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) excel in abstractive summarization tasks,
delivering fluent and pertinent summaries. Recent advancements have extended
their capabilities to handle long-input contexts, exceeding 100k tokens.
However, in question answering, language models exhibit uneven utilization of
their input context. They tend to favor the initial and final segments,
resulting in a U-shaped performance pattern concerning where the answer is
located within the input. This bias raises concerns, particularly in
summarization where crucial content may be dispersed throughout the source
document(s). Besides, in summarization, mapping facts from the source to the
summary is not trivial as salient content is usually re-phrased. In this paper,
we conduct the first comprehensive study on context utilization and position
bias in summarization. Our analysis encompasses 6 LLMs, 10 datasets, and 5
evaluation metrics. We introduce a new evaluation benchmark called MiddleSum on
the which we benchmark two alternative inference methods to alleviate position
bias: hierarchical summarization and incremental summarization. Our code and
data can be found here: https://github.com/ntunlp/MiddleSum. | [
0.0334460773,
0.0327960066,
0.0299811158,
0.0355237983,
-0.0219169762,
0.0104988096,
-0.0239181723,
-0.0563482232,
-0.040015541,
-0.0593407154,
-0.0046669547,
-0.0220340192,
0.0145774772,
-0.0241683647,
0.0162089933,
-0.0804494619,
0.0280753002,
-0.0378374495,
0.006534637,
-0.0154558439,
0.0098875817,
0.0053894231,
0.0129960477,
0.031077709,
0.011239429,
-0.0189276822,
0.0161616318,
0.0078976722,
0.0503032729,
-0.0026226034,
0.0096530225,
-0.0058943951,
0.0148332231,
0.0189357679,
0.0000017101,
-0.0577647053,
-0.0115484558,
-0.0038083475,
-0.0177330486,
0.0622873269,
0.0322746523,
-0.0249162279,
0.0325702243,
0.0262202322,
-0.0080500282,
0.0146065429,
0.0097689861,
0.0420584977,
0.061079558,
0.0573965162,
0.0178655777,
-0.0461004637,
0.0120872976,
-0.0123659475,
-0.0243289024,
-0.0602403097,
0.0068549868,
0.0370187946,
0.0112748565,
0.0108613297,
-0.0075383442,
0.0416575074,
0.0326741189,
0.0153651796,
-0.0227205511,
0.0430837348,
-0.0571648516,
0.0361532681,
0.0267729759,
0.0624686033,
0.0062992568,
-0.0104733156,
0.0083912145,
0.0087608797,
0.0194763225,
-0.0206804536,
-0.0893164203,
0.0705950633,
-0.0178072099,
0.0138629787,
0.0354081132,
0.0235477723,
0.0047413609,
0.0482343994,
-0.0600841194,
0.0536812656,
0.0242765937,
0.0032155579,
-0.0247417651,
0.0062040756,
-0.0559356175,
-0.0646828488,
-0.0001879805,
0.0532868803,
-0.0377723165,
0.0021879305,
-0.0511395819,
-0.0254209694,
0.0351694562,
-0.0348508619,
-0.0294581614,
0.0137361884,
0.0001802684,
0.0547697619,
-0.0151485484,
0.0337367654,
0.0014179943,
-0.0076497085,
-0.0772701725,
-0.0541914068,
0.0210108869,
-0.0027807702,
-0.0277981516,
0.0323364809,
-0.0363853015,
-0.035038922,
-0.0411954708,
0.0478192307,
0.0141655067,
-0.0157696903,
-0.0150916846,
0.0155357616,
0.0117513994,
0.0135153858,
0.0054216716,
0.0358524024,
-0.0689420551,
0.0053700204,
0.0250770599,
-0.0196586624,
-0.0153586054,
0.0353280455,
-0.0042014569,
-0.0169982221,
-0.0000496003,
0.0349637419,
-0.0155732492,
-0.03012353,
-0.0108435117,
-0.025012251,
-0.0157451723,
-0.0397107229,
-0.0298794974,
-0.0845624134,
-0.0121982181,
0.0251700506,
-0.019463243,
0.0100245373,
-0.0049363263,
0.0300117172,
-0.0368710719,
0.0219745599,
0.0140207037,
0.0073514124,
0.0475880988,
0.01733239,
0.0120438905,
0.0713246912,
0.0348351225,
0.0321099237,
0.0674978793,
0.0244206581,
-0.0237345994,
0.0204649046,
0.0194709282,
0.0252397694,
0.0138157299,
0.0386714488,
-0.0087957308,
0.0081206001,
0.066048421,
0.0525044948,
-0.040590398,
-0.0017824071,
0.0397317894,
0.0671108961,
-0.0115463464,
-0.0270557851,
0.0185067281,
0.0128640896,
0.0233773347,
0.0421355292,
-0.0443563946,
0.0152501669,
-0.0352950208,
0.0726498365,
0.1115541905,
0.0356336311,
-0.0204242878,
-0.0333825126,
-0.0111158714,
0.0073680561,
-0.0234255772,
0.0396159627,
0.0063311169,
-0.0011164894,
-0.0088716736,
0.0790739581,
0.0022531913,
-0.0451870076,
0.0123602189,
-0.0112487152,
0.0289125573,
0.0187504645,
0.0153629677,
-0.0564753115,
-0.0327869765,
0.0091101779,
0.037722569,
0.0058258497,
0.0258986317,
-0.0237444639,
0.0260330252,
-0.0141473291,
-0.0073777349,
-0.0290923771,
0.0131205283,
-0.0129987551,
0.0242322125,
-0.0063151792,
0.0468736663,
-0.0629706755,
-0.0043134796,
0.0184573885,
-0.0143440608,
-0.0171948317,
-0.0069675893,
-0.016167935,
0.0131644206,
0.0241471957,
-0.0180553943,
0.0303349495,
0.0314057097,
-0.0480938256,
0.0053097745,
0.0044757831,
-0.0572189912,
-0.0543797724,
0.0669002458,
-0.0556269921,
-0.0266817287,
0.0082592312,
-0.0557107218,
-0.0456485711,
0.013841087,
-0.0438822731,
0.0207098182,
-0.0275107343,
-0.001061557,
0.0221796092,
0.002724434,
-0.0480916277,
0.0814785883,
-0.0064703729,
0.0241526235,
0.0684152395,
-0.000516722,
0.0099315532,
-0.0317876823,
0.0006178124,
-0.0080845794,
0.0068946085,
-0.0055714659,
0.0563637726,
-0.0050682519,
-0.0389510728,
-0.0219595097,
-0.1289204359,
0.0266647842,
-0.0451490209,
0.0272762962,
0.0607424565,
0.0396143831,
-0.0244346224,
-0.0186062474,
-0.0490281731,
-0.0534381717,
0.018747855,
0.0472995192,
0.0218093432,
0.0255607218,
0.0283959098,
-0.0662289709,
-0.0224701148,
-0.0051662852,
0.0568673834,
-0.015451245,
0.0109161325,
-0.0465398245,
-0.0011153457,
-0.0125936363,
-0.02042735,
-0.0076470571,
0.0218438059,
-0.019393906,
0.0012656152,
0.0582912974,
0.0517201498,
0.0328589417,
0.0055933199,
0.0486440845,
0.0024547549,
-0.0400218144,
-0.0204796679,
-0.0004679266,
0.0068803863,
-0.0122072008,
-0.0432532318,
0.0238886308,
0.0394497253,
0.0099426331,
-0.0198242143,
0.0186220072,
0.0231592413,
-0.0255953614,
-0.0009911119,
-0.0581770018,
-0.0229177084,
-0.016568318,
0.0452053919,
-0.0260089133,
-0.0096863471,
0.0577777736,
-0.0469153561,
0.0185035728,
-0.0566048622,
-0.0024691517,
-0.0839241445,
0.047415521,
0.0152428485,
0.0214447193,
-0.0492366999,
-0.030577099,
-0.0486190617,
-0.0090086795,
0.0239727162,
-0.0153335873,
0.0896395892,
-0.054286018,
0.0078164386,
-0.0440930948,
-0.0260206331,
-0.0291746818,
-0.0551232845,
-0.0318205878,
0.0561977029,
-0.0001727027,
0.0018064923,
-0.0227172077,
0.0043650847,
0.0497433953,
0.0594481193,
-0.0352507159,
-0.0005482474,
-0.0242113397,
0.0896402523,
0.1017973348,
0.0355831794,
0.0581558719,
-0.0262207761,
0.0169440992,
0.0621060468,
0.0552304834,
0.0061179851,
0.0058680805,
-0.0344525762,
0.0088263303,
-0.0752124488,
0.0215919949,
-0.0110034272,
0.0860025063,
-0.0331466682,
-0.0058718757,
0.1223926917,
0.0218472239,
-0.0341597162,
0.0131068891,
0.0010311089,
0.044348076,
0.0148857469,
0.0181519911,
-0.087726593,
-0.0332607739,
0.0046444088,
0.0211661644,
0.0232230034,
-0.0248655006,
0.0138749201,
-0.1034386456,
0.0004729311,
-0.0091459807,
-0.1083978191,
-0.0480430871,
-0.0262165386,
0.0293750707,
0.011903761,
0.0377108492,
0.0362814404,
-0.0443005823,
0.0127918329,
0.0147330267,
-0.0468422286,
0.0098492503,
-0.0051894449,
-0.0544977076,
-0.0081682699,
0.0219956897,
0.0164965801,
-0.0014700245,
0.0552201942,
0.0768985003,
-0.072213918,
-0.0206988137,
0.0155943558,
0.0383521765,
-0.0141470805,
0.0156533904,
-0.0144916689,
0.0452169105,
0.0004893301,
0.0008181432,
0.0451255031,
0.0259302575,
0.0211508516,
-0.003944145,
-0.0516321436,
0.0282835308,
-0.031917274,
0.0810398087,
0.0653825849,
-0.0027068635,
-0.0458176956,
-0.0342508741,
-0.022116296,
-0.0289315525,
0.0005850054,
-0.0037192102,
-0.0141518395,
0.0168529339,
-0.0813321173,
-0.05786217,
0.025076516,
-0.0127224233,
-0.0236011595,
0.0230001342,
-0.036637187,
-0.0112112099,
-0.0356625356,
0.0187880024,
-0.0126087479,
0.0331622213,
-0.0269734003,
0.020491302,
0.0256298631,
-0.0250308327,
-0.0308429543,
0.0338990986,
-0.0868149921,
-0.042944748,
-0.0318236761,
0.0295087546,
0.0166169778,
0.0669035763,
-0.0000339673,
-0.0317848027,
0.0539244674,
-0.0098059168,
-0.0081221964,
0.0422189832,
0.0025724366,
0.0527529642,
0.0047262497,
0.0337185264,
-0.075093247,
0.0032567028,
0.0003487846,
0.0622987747,
-0.02685057,
-0.0646270812,
-0.0008535275,
0.0183862504,
0.0097711356,
-0.0126122925,
0.0231374167,
-0.0098592183,
0.0170981921,
-0.0284935273,
-0.0336516052,
-0.0020439315,
0.0405228585,
-0.0051742112,
-0.011772926,
0.0002795244,
0.0376918279,
0.0241509601,
0.0257402193,
-0.0300818793,
0.0105144158,
0.0047469391,
-0.0193235967,
-0.0325263366,
-0.0075275013,
-0.0666121542,
-0.047848586,
-0.0258884635,
0.0506002717,
-0.0138888005,
0.0155371139,
0.0305667091,
-0.0192822274,
-0.0180976335,
0.0329690762,
-0.118584469,
0.0001905687,
-0.0136864372,
0.0176234208,
0.0525297746,
-0.0525948294,
0.0722587183,
0.0042864615,
-0.0236807968,
-0.0372324847,
0.02145073,
0.0118090343,
-0.0172892455,
-0.0116311135,
0.0319526084,
0.0002716702,
0.0298652891,
0.0886772349,
0.006168256,
0.021312708,
0.00932974,
-0.0056169541,
-0.0186173581,
-0.0302428752,
-0.0378842801,
0.0446026064,
-0.0123300841,
-0.0071563069,
-0.05344221,
-0.0487155877,
0.0008053292,
0.0122548202,
-0.0094615882,
-0.0316536576,
0.0317396,
0.045784995,
0.0216908008,
-0.036637105,
-0.0464260094,
0.0219055451,
-0.0234687105,
-0.0081641376,
-0.0328911915,
-6.118974864e-33,
-0.0326981172,
-0.0065441383,
-0.0089989286,
0.0016246958,
-0.0445297733,
0.0240678359,
-0.0463267006,
-0.0012413722,
-0.024165092,
-0.0092391837,
-0.0291643552,
0.0143549833,
-0.0006845506,
0.0490510762,
-0.0252195485,
-0.0073245345,
0.0181152374,
0.0269691218,
-0.0636996925,
0.0264735259,
0.0269948188,
0.0004458239,
0.0435746983,
-0.0128698805,
0.0100764837,
-0.0142669715,
0.0127034197,
0.0059213354,
0.0100349374,
0.0334263258,
-0.0006388533,
0.0209682714,
0.0385260433,
-0.0370983221,
-0.0364954695,
0.0298075844,
-0.090347141,
-0.0244469512,
0.0495326072,
-0.0176587366,
-0.0543545485,
-0.0556423441,
0.0370291509,
-0.0037123333,
0.0144572137,
-0.052135922,
0.0364885926,
-0.0418595187,
-0.0570473485,
-0.0629001781,
-0.0340762958,
0.0383262448,
-0.0250508413,
-0.0059780381,
-0.0185622331,
0.0451292619,
0.013700706,
0.0240199286,
-0.0162787382,
0.003927072,
0.0336620733,
0.0451502874,
0.0374571756,
0.0343809426,
0.0079868371,
0.0599745698,
0.0009847978,
-0.0255340114,
-0.0296401735,
-0.021365054,
-0.0201398619,
-0.0192406531,
0.0113115935,
0.0127928704,
0.0387587287,
0.0573461987,
-0.0691995397,
0.0501652882,
0.0045026247,
0.0325793438,
0.027710272,
-0.0155601911,
-0.0032483332,
-0.0246981941,
-0.0636603683,
0.0339840837,
-0.0230241213,
0.0150195044,
0.0053119021,
-0.0030567129,
-0.0242438745,
-0.020278044,
0.0398113579,
-0.052882161,
0.0001196093,
0.0496557392,
-0.0012111032,
0.0126820048,
0.0112024937,
0.0254808106,
-0.027449742,
0.0497079603,
0.0045427312,
-0.0148221878,
-0.0068173492,
0.0001227848,
0.0473813452,
-0.0190823954,
-0.0381011888,
0.0178845301,
-0.0291017927,
-0.0009375739,
-0.0704635084,
0.0232650638,
0.0151684247,
0.0215357654,
0.0239455178,
0.0508729219,
0.0112113636,
0.0120440889,
-0.0180318989,
0.0042631817,
0.0089911195,
0.0187437739,
-0.0257051736,
0.0218490306,
-0.0196863692,
0.046860747,
0.0001458331,
-0.0554862581,
-0.0081374384,
0.0217253119,
2.328e-7,
0.0843387023,
0.0251511447,
0.0545826741,
0.0217740089,
-0.0080522522,
0.0086550293,
0.0090131517,
0.0209658686,
0.0484556854,
0.0194651186,
-0.0065864916,
0.0253867544,
0.0429364629,
0.027927706,
-0.1145918965,
-0.0110646607,
-0.0991944522,
-0.0440253988,
-0.0333577469,
-0.0160933286,
0.0396996625,
0.1004928574,
-0.0482713059,
-0.0053139417,
-0.0172434524,
-0.0471106507,
0.0324478634,
-0.0162094403,
-0.0267689992,
0.0136988182,
0.0300616082,
0.0072078044,
0.0234253854,
-0.0255127009,
0.0141198626,
0.0046555791,
0.0362227298,
0.0442959294,
0.0268436559,
-0.049392499,
-0.0224706065,
-0.0433715843,
0.0277424324,
-0.034079764,
0.0688431188,
-0.0486010052,
-0.0015577755,
-0.0551963523,
-0.035992641,
-0.005445105,
0.0005435607,
0.0029235429,
-0.0279502477,
0.0427359752,
0.0036306591,
-0.0215591229,
-0.0026033644,
-0.0907896608,
-0.0734899864,
0.0208502915,
-0.0217703376,
-0.0386271216,
-0.0064100577,
-0.0034668257,
0.0139148962,
-0.0525001138,
-0.0077141728,
2.195249246e-34,
0.0702357963,
-0.0254477337,
-0.0199114792,
0.0277484711,
0.0309840273,
-0.0235205553,
-0.0154350698,
-0.0152831897,
0.0080789095,
-0.0943486467,
-0.0066191037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10567v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10567v2 | RegaVAE: A Retrieval-Augmented Gaussian Mixture Variational Auto-Encoder for Language Modeling | 2023-10-16T16:42:01 | 2023-10-23T12:16:44 | Jingcheng Deng, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented language models show promise in addressing issues like
outdated information and hallucinations in language models (LMs). However,
current research faces two main problems: 1) determining what information to
retrieve, and 2) effectively combining retrieved information during generation.
We argue that valuable retrieved information should not only be related to the
current source text but also consider the future target text, given the nature
of LMs that model future tokens. Moreover, we propose that aggregation using
latent variables derived from a compact latent space is more efficient than
utilizing explicit raw text, which is limited by context length and susceptible
to noise. Therefore, we introduce RegaVAE, a retrieval-augmented language model
built upon the variational auto-encoder (VAE). It encodes the text corpus into
a latent space, capturing current and future information from both source and
target text. Additionally, we leverage the VAE to initialize the latent space
and adopt the probabilistic form of the retrieval generation paradigm by
expanding the Gaussian prior distribution into a Gaussian mixture distribution.
Theoretical analysis provides an optimizable upper bound for RegaVAE.
Experimental results on various datasets demonstrate significant improvements
in text generation quality and hallucination removal. | [
0.03786337,
0.1057274267,
0.006536671,
0.0024312853,
-0.0335464664,
-0.0166221447,
-0.0340887979,
0.0121603888,
-0.0380721875,
-0.041365087,
0.0315916575,
-0.0919150859,
0.0122136585,
0.0595971458,
0.0503186621,
-0.0673983917,
0.0121897021,
-0.0109536452,
-0.0075435224,
-0.0135911778,
0.0203195568,
0.0057603754,
0.0215551443,
0.0514586121,
-0.0534241796,
0.0073761274,
-0.00198564,
0.0066570714,
0.0181661937,
0.0303616915,
0.0312308911,
0.0527941138,
0.0486931093,
0.0066485512,
0.0000021696,
-0.0188086443,
-0.0237664133,
-0.0116726756,
0.0119597781,
-0.0132777374,
0.0750757232,
0.0018793381,
-0.0201374423,
0.0384348333,
-0.0137159741,
-0.0258973818,
0.0358164646,
0.0482488163,
0.0568239801,
0.0789322034,
-0.0229988303,
-0.0407550819,
0.0490204766,
-0.0364530273,
0.0889795199,
-0.0104305539,
0.0461112186,
0.008996903,
0.0045929099,
0.0314914547,
-0.0066143172,
0.0563297309,
0.0225649606,
-0.0228564031,
0.0526801646,
0.05036911,
-0.0070857448,
-0.0303944163,
-0.0210894067,
0.0249678437,
-0.0188808646,
-0.0736151263,
-0.0001641334,
-0.0125480304,
-0.0377918743,
0.0241265818,
-0.0396005884,
0.0277911667,
0.0258274302,
0.0160317775,
0.0135302832,
-0.0037106995,
0.0275847856,
0.016623063,
-0.0217532609,
0.0257827807,
0.0559141412,
-0.0312471949,
-0.0340068787,
-0.0031070691,
-0.0020255675,
-0.0224261414,
0.0129325008,
0.0246276613,
-0.0188629199,
0.0069037052,
-0.0557141937,
-0.0482735783,
-0.0018598324,
-0.0201199688,
-0.0192346871,
0.0289280452,
-0.0314772092,
0.033802066,
-0.0141878389,
0.0195647385,
-0.0079062656,
-0.0209837053,
-0.0490973666,
-0.0196566023,
-0.0063996981,
-0.0214910526,
-0.0362056084,
0.0134376399,
-0.0378991105,
-0.0226980094,
-0.0213633645,
0.011473014,
-0.0105053755,
-0.0120682521,
-0.025882287,
0.0631818995,
-0.0400422215,
-0.0289242752,
0.0082046017,
-0.0200121459,
-0.0193018001,
0.0044796411,
0.0366451666,
-0.0581429712,
-0.0337252021,
0.0433896706,
0.0331173725,
-0.007017504,
-0.0109447679,
0.0096568763,
-0.0326563157,
-0.0165970512,
-0.0242227465,
-0.0208311696,
-0.0319665521,
-0.0478320457,
0.0053326921,
-0.0527800061,
0.0330262184,
0.000992274,
-0.0209117942,
-0.030945247,
-0.0027227108,
0.0327710025,
-0.0298864152,
0.0447107181,
-0.0044982,
0.0190772228,
0.0953833312,
0.0068622609,
0.0191323757,
0.0560258143,
0.0198048297,
0.0498098359,
-0.0028775616,
0.0307034869,
0.0442457348,
0.0416191742,
0.0317606665,
0.0109089389,
-0.0515908077,
-0.0181047991,
-0.0367440507,
0.0050990926,
0.0317182504,
0.084499307,
-0.0282860622,
0.0152681591,
0.0349061675,
0.0076939352,
-0.0019463946,
0.0022549662,
0.0385701247,
0.0290408339,
-0.0264868923,
0.0003860554,
-0.0088179195,
0.0382191129,
-0.0380582064,
0.0233904161,
0.0718268976,
0.0289698057,
-0.0332374722,
-0.0407504514,
0.0029396636,
-0.0247155707,
0.005792988,
-0.027718896,
0.0390090421,
0.0284320656,
-0.0902446285,
0.032352373,
0.0152619155,
-0.0474683419,
0.0509845056,
-0.0309085585,
0.0270770639,
0.0569915734,
0.091277577,
-0.0121478997,
0.0286124349,
-0.0127571616,
-0.0222969316,
0.0360166468,
0.0104369959,
0.0055192788,
-0.0087624826,
-0.0733988136,
-0.0423526578,
0.0000496317,
0.0321324915,
0.0222364124,
0.0026305127,
-0.0046631414,
0.0696751475,
-0.0118549643,
-0.0086073522,
0.0334574394,
-0.0254559796,
0.0025463509,
0.0002627039,
-0.0103139915,
0.0077706128,
-0.0041372329,
-0.0068642139,
0.0428407416,
0.0311451983,
-0.0494608805,
-0.0575198419,
0.0112001887,
-0.0654669181,
-0.0348889269,
0.0132898241,
-0.0075089308,
0.0315562785,
0.0054363455,
-0.0100465268,
-0.0818757564,
0.0467400998,
-0.0496948697,
0.0361591242,
-0.0740615875,
0.0168769434,
0.0345950946,
0.0273720082,
-0.0148425307,
0.0697727799,
-0.0376607291,
-0.0013521052,
0.0505710319,
0.0375125855,
0.0098103359,
-0.0188909192,
-0.0242666267,
-0.032225091,
-0.0126069365,
0.0416898876,
0.0651421323,
-0.0262023918,
-0.0218914524,
-0.036357332,
-0.057929758,
0.0003742302,
-0.0551578104,
-0.0363810211,
0.0185429715,
0.0438202359,
-0.001710508,
0.0093191676,
-0.0256354306,
0.0144341793,
0.0432398617,
0.0121725025,
-0.0015991225,
0.0075792507,
0.0118835689,
-0.0484345034,
0.00540862,
0.01873645,
0.053809002,
-0.0227084365,
-0.0258894917,
-0.0275131594,
0.0260072723,
-0.0567702837,
0.0109439399,
-0.0213717669,
-0.0191176049,
-0.0121514853,
-0.0406217352,
0.1273595989,
-0.0268616136,
0.0548688956,
0.0310700741,
0.0445582829,
-0.0168356206,
-0.0278210174,
0.0082775196,
-0.0703349113,
-0.0263494067,
0.0284893364,
-0.0333657041,
0.0184577405,
0.0196723975,
0.0466064885,
0.0006915333,
-0.0795389116,
0.0231198799,
-0.0090498514,
-0.0330287218,
-0.0263778511,
-0.0146579752,
-0.0375557393,
0.0231022388,
-0.0386808254,
-0.0587595813,
0.0572491549,
-0.0284857284,
0.0001189333,
-0.0122572612,
0.0179120861,
0.0159285646,
-0.0028653941,
0.0324321464,
0.0302281883,
-0.0299653988,
-0.0158924535,
-0.0347415283,
0.0403345786,
-0.0065771611,
-0.0483895279,
0.0202634744,
-0.0209490098,
0.0345276333,
0.042666059,
0.0069388966,
-0.0702180117,
-0.0321707316,
0.0522078164,
0.0005387508,
0.0237756874,
0.0064087459,
-0.059168607,
0.0028858362,
0.0099630887,
0.0414422192,
-0.0348695926,
-0.0135444254,
-0.0075467885,
0.0475843698,
0.0982734188,
-0.018146513,
-0.0196676161,
-0.0311455596,
-0.0424204282,
0.0494681038,
0.0397918858,
-0.0059235175,
-0.0007262547,
0.0049814391,
0.0160890035,
0.0221906602,
0.0015429404,
0.0496462546,
0.0471800268,
-0.0151255326,
-0.0559462756,
0.0878194049,
0.021451043,
-0.0589679591,
-0.015817767,
-0.0203001723,
0.0797829479,
-0.0061302716,
0.0057930248,
-0.0235186201,
0.0089421477,
0.0080561703,
0.0251070205,
0.0021822883,
0.0078504151,
-0.0174867008,
-0.0835352913,
0.0298315901,
0.0504551902,
-0.0179465394,
-0.0320556685,
-0.0405105501,
-0.0148769049,
0.014525014,
0.0297739133,
0.0213859249,
0.0241335742,
0.0135562411,
0.0132232653,
-0.019649582,
-0.070898056,
-0.042575378,
0.0070945974,
0.046374891,
0.1016933396,
0.0255600028,
0.0185745712,
-0.0517630652,
0.0059859967,
-0.0554307662,
-0.0201459844,
-0.0020463765,
0.0644894168,
-0.0136415269,
0.0244457256,
0.0151918409,
0.0304429401,
-0.0113755325,
-0.0454369187,
-0.0259432532,
0.0386566296,
-0.0290452242,
-0.0155250458,
-0.0508318804,
0.0090960097,
0.0324524306,
0.0711005479,
0.0324220806,
-0.0088274833,
-0.0112755205,
-0.0303146094,
0.0797717795,
-0.0257950313,
0.014008821,
-0.0130761471,
0.0400034301,
-0.062064521,
-0.0991904959,
-0.0337512009,
-0.0108593702,
0.0106166163,
-0.0104379039,
0.018202303,
-0.0254248064,
-0.0461281985,
-0.058444839,
0.0069190203,
-0.0193257406,
-0.0248303544,
-0.0174729507,
-0.027102001,
0.0019091432,
-0.052961316,
-0.0166009404,
0.0118663618,
-0.1117351726,
-0.0804007128,
-0.0167811271,
0.0504915677,
0.0172265042,
0.0606195964,
-0.0176940225,
-0.0583580546,
0.0726208091,
0.0128570003,
-0.0171847679,
0.0246125497,
-0.0223656632,
-0.0082838396,
-0.0060579642,
0.011351536,
-0.0481991954,
0.0123140626,
-0.0217218399,
0.0264737383,
0.0166186076,
-0.0245912243,
0.0272717811,
-0.0245308895,
0.0129122715,
-0.0580473915,
0.0039162291,
-0.0529869162,
-0.039980419,
-0.0255925804,
-0.0059494632,
-0.0456373468,
0.0354285315,
0.0351310186,
-0.0067992839,
-0.0060440837,
-0.0033807142,
-0.0280474387,
0.0469597913,
-0.0270930231,
-0.0605836287,
-0.0191944297,
-0.0050423746,
0.0501063019,
-0.014243139,
0.0010519379,
-0.0076031522,
-0.0131896809,
0.0166686475,
-0.0270958729,
0.03824028,
0.0051683043,
-0.0148356659,
-0.0028627508,
0.0182454977,
-0.0624104142,
-0.0514273979,
-0.0734477341,
0.0326388478,
0.0340710543,
-0.0114353215,
0.1001990885,
-0.0337101184,
0.0154287443,
-0.0374013372,
0.0399400443,
0.0406896919,
-0.0708685368,
0.004871475,
0.0057254047,
-0.0384497829,
0.0249881689,
0.07167276,
0.0032343112,
0.0299724862,
-0.0322870351,
0.0085227117,
-0.0397213511,
-0.0100794146,
-0.0206856839,
0.0367902443,
-0.0220765565,
-0.0039329627,
-0.0055609494,
-0.0455027372,
0.026702594,
0.0000478862,
-0.030947851,
0.0083173746,
0.0282214805,
0.0659391955,
-0.0455809422,
0.0005472196,
-0.0511671901,
0.0081386194,
0.0335704759,
-0.0141599467,
-0.0327674337,
-7.070671989e-33,
-0.0245020445,
-0.0209052786,
0.0056301691,
-0.0814018697,
-0.0245261826,
-0.003783782,
-0.0717652142,
-0.0157099571,
0.0298590027,
0.0003465959,
0.0052620121,
0.0080796899,
0.0029986731,
0.0580475815,
-0.0083254343,
0.0117142117,
0.0643061921,
0.0166022927,
-0.0222820286,
0.0569402389,
0.0380649008,
0.0311986227,
0.0282263495,
-0.038385652,
0.0231817849,
-0.0386377238,
-0.0344648696,
0.0034687864,
0.0337104388,
0.0189986713,
-0.050103195,
0.0581342205,
0.0105447397,
0.0067246831,
-0.0417473651,
-0.0124840923,
-0.0318685956,
-0.014191567,
-0.0189281963,
-0.0073546306,
-0.0264929961,
-0.0127971424,
0.0659456775,
-0.0170859434,
0.0009280568,
0.0218911506,
0.050445877,
-0.0308928862,
-0.0274610892,
-0.0270508397,
-0.0497021712,
0.0225031581,
-0.0029000526,
-0.0155946864,
0.0075271307,
0.0318665877,
0.0243773535,
0.0045500961,
-0.0683364943,
0.037544027,
-0.014498028,
0.0684209391,
0.0468737483,
0.017925797,
0.0034776626,
0.0583437011,
0.0159834884,
-0.0234106593,
-0.0620043129,
-0.0135438563,
0.0427896008,
0.0065056421,
-0.0050383178,
-0.0001866382,
0.0291058756,
-0.0347034372,
-0.019623382,
0.0674289092,
-0.0482325666,
0.0449705534,
0.0399087071,
0.0365596339,
-0.0246169455,
-0.0414410122,
-0.0121455118,
-0.004703579,
-0.0265143774,
-0.0320743546,
0.027917577,
0.0549273677,
-0.0226084068,
-0.0481563956,
0.0326095857,
-0.0139466282,
-0.0037627674,
0.0691784322,
-0.0629357025,
-0.0043693138,
-0.0164528508,
0.0430087745,
-0.0400001295,
-0.0029286765,
0.0649841204,
-0.0183924492,
-0.0468771271,
0.0265877172,
-0.0345103294,
0.0512519106,
-0.0591402687,
0.0030770886,
-0.05550256,
0.0132544218,
0.0076857726,
0.0084983315,
0.0323736183,
0.0089830486,
-0.0067886482,
0.0411374755,
0.019650314,
0.0116677256,
-0.0037366028,
-0.0187126547,
0.0224562641,
0.0170811601,
-0.0486075245,
0.0317655727,
-0.0329849981,
0.0017640094,
0.0688913018,
-0.0476784781,
-0.0130580459,
0.0021970004,
2.831e-7,
0.0390103497,
0.0293112341,
0.0356039293,
-0.0033451892,
-0.003271675,
0.0166679323,
0.0089017339,
0.0100470604,
0.0260704271,
-0.0155473799,
-0.0003945186,
0.0219779536,
0.0554848649,
0.0102706496,
-0.0434905961,
-0.0016359225,
-0.0836590081,
-0.0044049127,
-0.0336990282,
-0.0220825113,
0.0645422637,
0.0864282101,
0.0188098922,
-0.0104549332,
0.0062675709,
-0.0397991203,
0.1027241722,
-0.001256451,
-0.0545789897,
0.03030614,
0.0703172088,
0.0417535566,
0.0080937725,
-0.0272458214,
-0.0474621989,
-0.0035222315,
0.0148653733,
0.0331188031,
-0.0190932732,
-0.0698579401,
0.0031477809,
0.0350456201,
-0.0147660729,
-0.0261135977,
0.0522839352,
-0.0071148239,
0.0231905524,
-0.0213414114,
-0.0580948293,
0.04857352,
0.0170898866,
-0.0104750702,
-0.0655166283,
0.0172990542,
0.0147453025,
0.0644895583,
-0.0138969943,
-0.083671689,
-0.0215959288,
0.0072003468,
-0.0492959842,
0.0042579863,
-0.0391914174,
-0.0067315027,
0.0115237087,
-0.0483451262,
-0.0017156684,
2.818000439e-34,
0.0470190272,
-0.0015250403,
-0.016824631,
0.0131458752,
0.0137573369,
-0.0141064106,
0.0236845817,
0.0333497971,
-0.0400092266,
-0.0633966252,
-0.0504411496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10707v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10707v2 | Demonstrations Are All You Need: Advancing Offensive Content Paraphrasing using In-Context Learning | 2023-10-16T16:18:55 | 2024-06-09T18:22:33 | Anirudh Som, Karan Sikka, Helen Gent, Ajay Divakaran, Andreas Kathol, Dimitra Vergyri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Paraphrasing of offensive content is a better alternative to content removal
and helps improve civility in a communication environment. Supervised
paraphrasers; however, rely heavily on large quantities of labelled data to
help preserve meaning and intent. They also often retain a large portion of the
offensiveness of the original content, which raises questions on their overall
usability. In this paper we aim to assist practitioners in developing usable
paraphrasers by exploring In-Context Learning (ICL) with large language models
(LLMs), i.e., using a limited number of input-label demonstration pairs to
guide the model in generating desired outputs for specific queries. Our study
focuses on key factors such as - number and order of demonstrations, exclusion
of prompt instruction, and reduction in measured toxicity. We perform
principled evaluation on three datasets, including our proposed Context-Aware
Polite Paraphrase (CAPP) dataset, comprising of dialogue-style rude utterances,
polite paraphrases, and additional dialogue context. We evaluate our approach
using four closed source and one open source LLM. Our results reveal that ICL
is comparable to supervised methods in generation quality, while being
qualitatively better by 25% on human evaluation and attaining lower toxicity by
76%. Also, ICL-based paraphrasers only show a slight reduction in performance
even with just 10% training data. | [
0.0859637484,
0.0378084742,
-0.0096182311,
0.050355792,
-0.0517785549,
0.0024281878,
0.0426998325,
0.0221761875,
0.0046740235,
-0.0677122697,
-0.0285815261,
0.0096122408,
-0.0107459351,
-0.0396172926,
0.0226719771,
-0.0845149904,
0.0123429252,
0.0012322331,
0.0105921803,
-0.0054155798,
0.038763579,
0.0290558189,
0.0082000587,
0.0540704578,
-0.0368152931,
0.0004295136,
0.0178101547,
0.0622181669,
0.0153750395,
-0.0024217372,
0.0451450571,
-0.0000236999,
0.0196640994,
0.0352712013,
0.0000016172,
-0.0397091061,
0.0106838578,
0.0108204857,
-0.0178585108,
0.0365246646,
0.1283344924,
-0.0143351741,
0.0144077661,
0.0436587296,
-0.0301067811,
0.0177897234,
0.0316062942,
0.0479286984,
0.1179051697,
0.0515952483,
0.0043208897,
-0.0420401953,
-0.0328528397,
-0.0044445829,
-0.0073088752,
-0.015830759,
0.0279821102,
-0.0289485641,
0.0060932334,
0.0113826338,
-0.005851964,
0.0559320524,
0.0283829663,
0.0055815172,
-0.0099997902,
-0.0121184094,
-0.032779675,
-0.00427145,
-0.0158353131,
0.0857141763,
-0.0087587945,
-0.0152073214,
-0.0012031484,
-0.0081353076,
-0.0026223452,
-0.016246222,
-0.0580067523,
0.0145915281,
-0.0006693435,
0.0154591184,
-0.0453973748,
0.0153342066,
-0.0036720722,
0.0757508874,
0.0250501223,
-0.0144648422,
-0.0071041663,
-0.0454997756,
-0.0259726532,
-0.0200836938,
-0.0271275006,
0.0088914689,
0.0239888281,
0.0124771511,
-0.0492551699,
0.0415843874,
-0.0676748902,
-0.0592613183,
0.0562667437,
-0.0643376932,
0.0159727056,
0.0032047662,
0.0023004024,
0.0304669142,
-0.0010136955,
0.0780514702,
-0.0169522092,
0.0967567787,
-0.0308560077,
-0.0132179726,
-0.0294269454,
0.0006217343,
-0.0600740574,
0.0081340047,
-0.0466098785,
-0.0019675551,
-0.0342616215,
-0.0076555572,
-0.0074058878,
-0.0287499148,
0.0143931201,
0.0448623262,
-0.0418624394,
0.0081806509,
0.0088563887,
-0.0066505191,
-0.0237756204,
0.0220165309,
0.0010787606,
-0.0707995072,
-0.019222144,
0.0160742663,
0.0023888836,
-0.0172910597,
0.0267624408,
0.0719546005,
-0.021214392,
-0.0451611131,
-0.029218344,
-0.0357577354,
-0.0493200719,
-0.0516886674,
-0.0249052737,
-0.045496989,
0.0480280407,
-0.0174270775,
-0.037526235,
-0.0684894696,
0.0175421145,
0.0552634709,
-0.0669529215,
0.040279638,
0.0025793433,
-0.0164424647,
0.0384322368,
0.0390866622,
-0.0295527913,
0.0315116011,
0.0681740269,
0.0015373023,
0.0596783683,
0.0278701726,
-0.0009167321,
0.0110006528,
0.0561338998,
0.0283717588,
-0.0511959866,
0.0309189707,
-0.0146732796,
0.0317802727,
0.0048283911,
0.1065703034,
-0.0418221578,
-0.0414139852,
0.0704179108,
0.0426080637,
-0.0652243495,
0.0077145495,
0.074129194,
0.0783976689,
0.0113261566,
-0.0105253784,
-0.0437144116,
-0.0389490724,
-0.0013322382,
0.0117887789,
0.035957586,
0.0212294627,
0.0053341165,
-0.0488010868,
-0.0183531586,
-0.0119083365,
0.0350811668,
-0.0016036428,
0.0027098148,
0.0449968874,
-0.0632119328,
0.0072121164,
0.0092779864,
-0.0572036617,
-0.0109904315,
-0.0316846035,
0.0073092291,
0.0932621062,
0.0838435069,
-0.0150445262,
-0.0000234332,
-0.0692443922,
0.0494590923,
0.0351259671,
0.0050007552,
-0.0073946067,
0.0342573971,
-0.0526137762,
-0.014624618,
-0.010620675,
-0.0056537832,
-0.0505497679,
0.0815086439,
0.00425831,
0.036472939,
-0.0138325058,
-0.0734548122,
0.0403951332,
0.0087943645,
-0.0470928401,
0.0197813362,
0.0041106525,
0.0512012914,
0.0243151151,
-0.0213956758,
-0.0390966721,
0.0216258559,
-0.0181042235,
-0.014385283,
0.0177175272,
-0.0680144355,
-0.0601852201,
0.0073626516,
-0.034464106,
-0.0097070206,
0.0174786244,
-0.0318020508,
0.021776868,
-0.0065369736,
-0.0555313453,
0.0245238226,
-0.0499106422,
0.0124875242,
-0.0553654768,
0.0146867894,
-0.0326476768,
0.0346418694,
-0.0052029118,
-0.0260817967,
0.0738246143,
-0.0357021503,
0.011317784,
0.0055086343,
-0.0511778034,
-0.0224063322,
0.0027041049,
0.0319945589,
-0.0273495428,
0.048334863,
-0.0400381126,
0.002625417,
-0.0975225121,
0.0076131602,
-0.0178660359,
-0.0445780456,
0.0286950693,
0.0065022344,
-0.0103614777,
-0.002726566,
0.0218200348,
-0.0591531098,
0.0257952102,
0.0030293406,
0.0333245434,
0.0176971238,
-0.0337628871,
-0.0323495753,
0.0088906325,
-0.0057806745,
0.0563159399,
-0.0053276792,
0.0103280386,
0.0059252251,
0.0164729822,
0.0084344214,
0.0140115395,
0.0014859375,
-0.0528797247,
0.003530968,
0.0255569499,
-0.0091840252,
0.0778427571,
0.0630531237,
0.0443707705,
-0.0052853413,
0.0235163309,
-0.0720837563,
0.0120135956,
-0.0004889042,
-0.0377980694,
-0.0195938963,
-0.054172378,
0.0189247038,
0.0115993069,
0.0589392856,
0.0495358184,
-0.0643538907,
0.0233957581,
-0.0230221674,
-0.0672426522,
-0.0307193119,
-0.0649344251,
-0.037303254,
-0.0416130275,
-0.0298999604,
-0.0556637645,
0.0898610204,
-0.0262693185,
-0.0212089811,
-0.0461927056,
0.0018946733,
-0.0053881248,
0.0415698476,
-0.0316054113,
0.0619125515,
-0.0140323415,
-0.0174794365,
-0.0085333725,
-0.041356314,
0.0352863073,
-0.0385707691,
-0.0015217504,
-0.0918477774,
-0.0090245632,
0.0313150883,
-0.0654447973,
-0.0635965466,
-0.0893163681,
-0.0093303705,
-0.0053679082,
0.0054476415,
0.0125526628,
-0.0036719572,
-0.0109405424,
0.0353722014,
0.0043770294,
0.0020417646,
0.0024313757,
-0.0081388038,
-0.030910315,
0.0505073257,
0.0241082255,
0.0013894194,
-0.0174683649,
0.0081152869,
0.0412697345,
0.0134657826,
-0.0218095966,
0.0097120283,
-0.0099097416,
-0.0254040528,
-0.0027633952,
0.0042291055,
0.0092584807,
0.052577626,
-0.0224763807,
-0.0139290458,
0.0852879956,
0.0098972796,
-0.0193171296,
0.0071292152,
0.0194104873,
0.0036402275,
-0.0023755627,
-0.000186743,
-0.0739669725,
-0.038220264,
-0.0162049048,
0.0640928149,
-0.0386864953,
-0.011570435,
-0.0260585491,
-0.0911741927,
0.0216484219,
0.0059147542,
-0.0329858735,
-0.0505757667,
0.0254288204,
-0.0169377811,
0.0226688478,
0.0464906953,
0.0046739657,
-0.023742456,
-0.0028830769,
-0.0007455645,
-0.0034629647,
-0.058461275,
-0.0090774763,
-0.0319140851,
0.029045539,
0.0363305062,
0.0410043374,
0.0270299613,
0.0018461499,
0.0290622115,
-0.0263949689,
0.0007793476,
-0.0272574667,
0.0648893267,
-0.013146651,
-0.0092471074,
-0.0168570019,
0.0381225608,
0.0099931434,
-0.0117029147,
0.0273258798,
0.0079787346,
0.028715454,
0.0058265962,
-0.0258162003,
0.0399975851,
0.0403828584,
0.1092915311,
0.0517315306,
-0.0381951146,
-0.0244849417,
-0.003784202,
-0.0096700676,
-0.0394446179,
-0.0332565457,
-0.008936177,
-0.0370274968,
0.0312832594,
-0.0753876269,
-0.0200485643,
0.0306280646,
0.0316761658,
0.0072534839,
0.0029561524,
-0.0237212405,
0.0253441855,
0.0091623198,
-0.0340059474,
-0.0351101868,
0.038846951,
-0.0301111937,
-0.0099568376,
-0.0010696666,
-0.0211624131,
-0.0258545149,
0.0323765427,
-0.0551500916,
-0.0546098575,
0.0327358954,
0.0768802762,
0.0142278783,
0.0514097214,
0.0226140469,
-0.0199322142,
0.0618504882,
0.0787326917,
-0.0366968401,
0.0257895887,
0.0467932634,
0.0229252893,
0.0006868814,
0.0302541759,
-0.0268321298,
-0.0119003961,
0.0191679336,
0.0295747165,
-0.0413097814,
-0.0560905896,
0.0187763497,
0.0008450093,
-0.0027624771,
-0.0107427556,
-0.0516256392,
0.0048879199,
0.0331579112,
-0.0001594659,
-0.0305885971,
-0.0338050537,
0.023973465,
-0.0080210753,
0.0002086915,
-0.032508675,
-0.012746728,
-0.0382117666,
0.0302996542,
-0.0204414539,
0.0114019997,
-0.0157768745,
-0.0373312682,
0.0108685661,
0.0160861686,
-0.052631598,
0.0174160413,
-0.037205331,
-0.0096044429,
0.0074746506,
0.0605988391,
0.032831125,
-0.0359823406,
-0.0223305169,
0.0312964767,
-0.0261383504,
-0.0098808818,
-0.036678493,
0.0371701941,
0.0073712151,
-0.0049737832,
0.0699103326,
-0.0132288923,
-0.004334108,
0.0005001729,
0.0293923784,
-0.0286527164,
-0.0502125099,
0.0273156539,
0.0118724918,
0.0043991045,
0.0271158479,
0.0576829761,
0.0070266798,
0.0402406231,
0.0098061878,
-0.0306218527,
-0.0431675874,
-0.0429399945,
0.0583608672,
0.0355301239,
0.0114348605,
0.0030259653,
-0.040827442,
-0.0173459481,
-0.0022349758,
-0.0038231355,
0.0003416759,
-0.0567951985,
0.0605972335,
0.0592000671,
-0.0003467836,
-0.0312597938,
-0.0129650757,
0.0307627693,
0.0410165004,
-0.0546534434,
-0.0576167032,
-5.20606134e-33,
-0.0178578869,
-0.0050364663,
-0.0204946566,
0.0329184756,
-0.0242115874,
-0.0325553082,
0.0010300834,
-0.0211843085,
0.0020086931,
0.0077400468,
-0.0224385466,
-0.0016622138,
0.0053035161,
0.0208066516,
-0.0061225621,
-0.0492892787,
0.0604068749,
-0.0184628069,
-0.0319168195,
0.0300043281,
0.0105616907,
0.0197468009,
0.0161880944,
-0.1132229045,
0.0039229323,
-0.0378927141,
-0.0424834862,
-0.0083142165,
-0.003329389,
0.0521991514,
0.0067302212,
0.0912710503,
0.0129779447,
0.0080445791,
-0.0102897584,
0.0122230323,
-0.0655845553,
0.058321882,
0.0393218435,
0.0107043339,
-0.0197473075,
-0.035358645,
0.0752585232,
-0.0193748586,
-0.0144360894,
0.0096598892,
0.0343809575,
-0.02769503,
0.0207546484,
-0.0404725634,
-0.0447524488,
-0.0070455726,
-0.0257474631,
-0.032768786,
-0.0439306945,
0.0473784208,
-0.0255596694,
0.039930407,
-0.0423860699,
0.0059580957,
-0.0009607822,
-0.0129073039,
0.0043430766,
-0.0247688424,
0.0277660955,
0.0477969088,
-0.0266671665,
0.0281961393,
0.025871126,
-0.0332157947,
0.0205333643,
0.0259081367,
0.0161939207,
0.0955496132,
0.0262901094,
-0.0417595021,
-0.0142674232,
-0.0134685151,
0.0216949731,
0.0054765157,
0.0294067375,
-0.0058574993,
-0.056190595,
-0.0416831933,
-0.0144433333,
0.0104774972,
0.004154304,
-0.0555178225,
0.0612437315,
0.0346748084,
-0.0429979526,
-0.0244798586,
0.014678156,
-0.0466011167,
0.0003174417,
0.0064005819,
-0.0147655113,
0.0087945163,
0.0046236808,
0.0021420552,
-0.0349126458,
-0.0005761061,
0.022425266,
0.0020431224,
0.0223189425,
-0.0128211631,
0.0752016902,
0.0380822308,
-0.0572014153,
0.0403259993,
-0.0098669278,
0.0328228176,
-0.0389788076,
-0.0560009219,
0.0034127652,
0.063942872,
-0.0166022833,
0.0095932353,
0.0066757556,
-0.0449001603,
-0.0256580282,
-0.0241831876,
0.0088539664,
-0.005723909,
-0.0409797058,
0.0047228374,
0.0077635348,
0.0016332947,
-0.0103067532,
-0.0689360797,
0.0087181637,
-0.0138368513,
2.394e-7,
0.0139083602,
0.0365412235,
0.0342758149,
0.0171977002,
0.0113150487,
0.0293539073,
0.0526651554,
0.0197461378,
-0.0008424946,
-0.0011581453,
0.0313774198,
0.0365064926,
0.0441396087,
-0.009150316,
-0.1183023602,
-0.0111398315,
-0.0908278301,
0.0047107125,
-0.0569231398,
-0.0236713085,
0.0649421439,
0.0628938377,
0.0304240678,
-0.0158770122,
-0.0265003145,
-0.0496573299,
0.0373978652,
-0.0550236255,
0.0076927915,
-0.0102729201,
0.0206742194,
0.0025716524,
0.0217774361,
0.0043240739,
0.0336318687,
-0.0056129326,
0.0182278417,
0.0611951984,
0.034338925,
-0.0121936779,
-0.0043288795,
-0.0360585973,
-0.0039153998,
-0.0585289784,
0.047662098,
-0.0249709282,
0.0291065723,
0.0227993596,
-0.0129826833,
-0.0274642836,
0.010517587,
-0.0566255674,
-0.025223162,
-0.0019866428,
0.0293000937,
-0.0040466548,
0.0326476172,
-0.0511674099,
-0.0038337088,
-0.0184451118,
-0.0458686501,
-0.0331149697,
-0.0158668663,
0.0201968215,
0.0069082915,
-0.011351889,
0.049586758,
1.973003442e-34,
0.0272222813,
-0.0168240331,
0.0379002392,
0.0200179107,
0.0200161729,
0.0416242778,
0.0350564308,
-0.0044017611,
0.0300171897,
-0.0121543016,
-0.0188950393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10543v1 | ViPE: Visualise Pretty-much Everything | 2023-10-16T16:14:20 | 2023-10-16T16:14:20 | Hassan Shahmohammadi, Adhiraj Ghosh, Hendrik P. A. Lensch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Figurative and non-literal expressions are profoundly integrated in human
communication. Visualising such expressions allow us to convey our creative
thoughts, and evoke nuanced emotions. Recent text-to-image models like Stable
Diffusion, on the other hand, struggle to depict non-literal expressions.
Recent works primarily deal with this issue by compiling humanly annotated
datasets on a small scale, which not only demands specialised expertise but
also proves highly inefficient. To address this issue, we introduce ViPE:
Visualise Pretty-much Everything. ViPE offers a series of lightweight and
robust language models that have been trained on a large-scale set of lyrics
with noisy visual descriptions that represent their implicit meaning. The
synthetic visual descriptions are generated by GPT3.5 relying on neither human
annotations nor images. ViPE effectively expresses any arbitrary piece of text
into a visualisable description, enabling meaningful and high-quality image
generation. We provide compelling evidence that ViPE is more robust than GPT3.5
in synthesising visual elaborations. ViPE also exhibits an understanding of
figurative expressions comparable to human experts, providing a powerful and
open-source backbone to many downstream applications such as music video and
caption generation. | [
0.0008862835,
0.0572686605,
-0.0083300387,
0.029055031,
0.0069212387,
0.0065084975,
-0.0355586223,
0.001776422,
-0.0285267308,
-0.00650603,
-0.0162074082,
-0.0102662724,
0.0155858044,
0.0505565815,
0.0476368815,
-0.1267366111,
-0.029965153,
-0.0032162932,
0.0012924597,
-0.0180793572,
0.0248260405,
0.031528756,
-0.0097978525,
0.0470049568,
-0.0592487603,
-0.026167389,
-0.0344277248,
0.0582688078,
0.0202415735,
-0.0281355679,
-0.0923627913,
0.0413550101,
0.0667432994,
-0.0210185964,
0.0000019434,
0.0232399665,
0.0300061032,
0.000171067,
0.0508505516,
0.0289908964,
0.0609647594,
-0.0423056483,
-0.0043348619,
-0.0099655315,
-0.0318327211,
0.0084613888,
0.0743685067,
0.0357360505,
0.1096920371,
0.0518011749,
-0.0142417569,
-0.0302157123,
-0.0040284814,
-0.0508375838,
0.0412324294,
-0.0312013756,
0.0273461901,
0.0216031838,
-0.0090788091,
0.0029478765,
-0.066835545,
0.066976361,
0.0337921642,
-0.0107759861,
0.0194063839,
0.0565969013,
-0.03419495,
-0.0260448083,
-0.0128416605,
0.0807020962,
0.006184306,
-0.0022801468,
-0.0218273345,
0.0058048777,
-0.0146384388,
-0.0101734959,
-0.0427973382,
0.0201424509,
0.0402287021,
0.0330028571,
-0.0828848854,
0.0001560335,
0.0058125779,
-0.0166157428,
0.0414733365,
-0.0671142489,
0.0140187582,
-0.0060091936,
-0.0086700218,
0.0101296045,
-0.0884456411,
-0.0530100577,
0.0076283519,
-0.0139135681,
0.0469553135,
0.0179846678,
-0.0414240733,
-0.0402774028,
-0.01837915,
-0.0314003527,
0.0762735531,
0.0150747029,
-0.0246424191,
0.0642702579,
-0.0006774089,
-0.0099153621,
-0.0312846862,
0.0331191905,
-0.0284858923,
-0.0064218375,
-0.0200424585,
-0.0210207254,
-0.0658616051,
-0.0337868072,
-0.0397358313,
-0.0658924431,
-0.0401086695,
-0.0091645652,
-0.0202404894,
-0.0155360838,
0.0188752301,
0.0539286695,
-0.0401232168,
0.0033661306,
-0.0062446916,
-0.0236448757,
-0.0197347961,
0.0212834254,
-0.0221754052,
-0.0356038995,
-0.0235665161,
0.0377439447,
0.0344185606,
-0.0025520206,
-0.0116490284,
0.0607778504,
-0.0007111224,
-0.0227902923,
-0.0113377748,
-0.0233123954,
-0.0431079827,
-0.0271592345,
-0.0083020348,
-0.0454006791,
0.0484704636,
-0.0504872948,
0.0038663936,
-0.073970899,
0.0182399265,
0.0284152851,
-0.0264079049,
0.0678919852,
-0.0156764966,
0.0274612904,
-0.0410193019,
0.0216211323,
-0.0303519461,
0.0330191925,
0.0698403195,
0.051906839,
-0.0120014763,
-0.0282494202,
0.0216876008,
0.021615399,
0.0257761218,
0.026637841,
-0.0922189951,
-0.025802806,
-0.03914297,
0.0651063323,
0.0563233234,
0.0747319385,
-0.0164499246,
-0.0204042699,
0.0813982487,
0.04101469,
-0.0244487114,
0.0109456852,
0.0781457201,
0.0614815764,
0.009537315,
-0.0114611173,
0.001695206,
0.0702529848,
0.0538996868,
0.026227612,
0.0480940267,
0.0201275218,
-0.0259581003,
0.0029823217,
-0.0361706205,
-0.0035089836,
0.0072281919,
-0.0024595603,
0.0047185384,
0.0394415036,
-0.036823485,
0.0408433862,
0.0107267099,
-0.0531150922,
-0.0197331998,
-0.0171771068,
0.0295365416,
0.0823604614,
0.0285740625,
0.0117159495,
0.0601189286,
-0.0098010991,
0.019637689,
0.0870767012,
-0.0092723016,
0.0277779568,
0.0232457984,
-0.0257984549,
0.0063840891,
-0.0169252995,
0.0115544591,
0.0057359324,
-0.0187515989,
0.0423249118,
-0.0002107413,
-0.0444653146,
-0.0204595774,
0.0203334149,
0.0283164941,
-0.0145025505,
0.0275144894,
0.0286388714,
-0.0021827228,
0.0186042245,
-0.0405180641,
0.013132073,
0.0119124576,
-0.0149108749,
-0.013560106,
0.0596522279,
-0.0232889224,
-0.0214592647,
0.0290309656,
-0.0714863837,
-0.0289009158,
-0.0038121431,
-0.0295585003,
-0.0342680812,
0.0553962104,
-0.0515258759,
0.0066289846,
-0.0341608934,
-0.0251000468,
0.0167566352,
0.0538038984,
0.0427016728,
0.0303395186,
-0.0023727568,
-0.0257804673,
-0.0173401348,
0.0208641794,
-0.0117597226,
0.007219906,
-0.0319950692,
-0.0152199278,
0.0341734886,
0.0264713299,
-0.0352976173,
0.0129067628,
-0.0472271405,
-0.0286505595,
-0.1004531533,
-0.0169146787,
-0.0010717212,
-0.0517603233,
0.013515655,
-0.0059080748,
-0.0242496599,
-0.0203266032,
-0.0333622396,
0.0283419508,
-0.0298332423,
-0.002016779,
0.0057174838,
-0.0164502654,
-0.020363491,
-0.0404499546,
0.0078781713,
-0.0009231907,
0.0247380082,
0.0008927426,
0.0085152397,
0.0263492055,
0.0051868875,
-0.0386330411,
-0.0059572747,
0.0174318571,
-0.0241038911,
0.0037742942,
-0.0238440856,
0.0521096475,
0.0469891392,
0.0231952462,
0.0381521657,
0.0320011824,
-0.0280709732,
-0.0105572939,
0.0102210641,
0.006470378,
0.0153503045,
-0.0036659029,
-0.0504639111,
-0.0269977767,
0.0329116248,
0.0544594601,
0.0298664123,
-0.0777157322,
0.0438341498,
-0.0073826173,
-0.022645887,
-0.0387474298,
0.0282063521,
-0.0330888666,
0.0026934503,
-0.0397588871,
-0.03572933,
0.0619143769,
-0.0346375853,
-0.0406683609,
0.0085254069,
-0.0301172454,
-0.0243710782,
0.0695463568,
-0.0208842345,
0.0180885177,
-0.0024376709,
0.0175200589,
-0.0163850635,
-0.0188784879,
0.0224268995,
-0.0328453295,
0.0274430718,
-0.042920433,
-0.0093857562,
-0.0060174204,
0.0102812732,
0.0078006508,
-0.0681490675,
-0.0221538655,
-0.0248784684,
-0.0252843034,
-0.0299413335,
0.0247838162,
0.0056252945,
0.0170752462,
-0.0154558867,
-0.0121239834,
-0.0115157887,
-0.0386618301,
0.017982902,
0.0773708746,
-0.019630501,
-0.0521295443,
-0.0389610268,
0.0171703212,
0.032423269,
-0.0228534658,
0.0132878944,
-0.0641757622,
0.0256178658,
-0.0348193794,
0.0562651344,
0.0054657096,
0.0287914183,
0.057306733,
-0.0214934498,
-0.0058620018,
0.0738007799,
-0.0084301475,
-0.0231557172,
0.0221568123,
0.0321869366,
0.0608348474,
0.0265930444,
-0.0032960235,
-0.0854532346,
-0.0387841798,
-0.002699567,
0.0183357894,
0.0506427735,
0.0005492081,
-0.0358410701,
-0.0641908571,
0.0693303347,
0.0100062499,
-0.0026237019,
0.0079313032,
0.0219990369,
0.0026586163,
0.0109932562,
0.0032727264,
-0.0332907103,
-0.0005842934,
0.0281301085,
0.0100154569,
0.0367114358,
-0.0425187014,
0.0185428765,
-0.0305925142,
0.0098156529,
0.0102630947,
0.0584080182,
-0.0121282479,
-0.0629566237,
0.0128071327,
0.0174561907,
0.0056909141,
0.0301887356,
0.0602327771,
0.0234473739,
-0.0255742073,
0.011476418,
0.030644631,
-0.0253017303,
-0.0029975586,
-0.0042929063,
0.0421864539,
-0.0215117764,
-0.0227936208,
-0.0441273674,
0.0429096632,
0.0015650117,
0.0665262714,
0.0773973763,
-0.071969308,
-0.022948971,
-0.0273718033,
0.0155735193,
-0.0414709151,
-0.0983610973,
-0.0209172312,
-0.0045045614,
-0.0453734994,
-0.045914147,
0.0032785928,
0.037459258,
0.0241388474,
0.0038199897,
-0.0082041416,
-0.0454231687,
-0.0363497548,
-0.0670404509,
0.0623407252,
-0.0370240919,
0.0386245511,
0.0162448287,
-0.0294010136,
-0.0092561534,
-0.011729518,
-0.0101208929,
0.0317202397,
-0.097919926,
-0.0509750694,
-0.0252096206,
0.0278490391,
0.0144922854,
0.0231314115,
-0.0040650759,
-0.0476650558,
0.0509193838,
0.0430192724,
0.0372275449,
0.0311078764,
0.0065196743,
0.0090081263,
0.0182647891,
0.0206396356,
-0.032121934,
0.0352598689,
-0.01620882,
0.040461164,
0.0244098734,
0.0001548422,
0.015486354,
-0.0317739584,
0.0180274248,
-0.016685551,
-0.0161027573,
-0.0122896964,
-0.0399752967,
-0.026945414,
-0.0152609581,
-0.0637672991,
0.0127428016,
0.0598464534,
0.0416608788,
-0.0399574302,
-0.0302853324,
0.012335225,
-0.0070541697,
-0.0100021129,
-0.0101788547,
0.0432303473,
-0.0453463644,
0.0007083677,
0.0167022366,
0.0051682033,
-0.0083496589,
-0.0372428522,
-0.0015946741,
0.0382758863,
0.0051729367,
-0.0074486812,
-0.0425136983,
0.0041476102,
0.0218039639,
-0.013151804,
-0.0529144444,
-0.0112990336,
0.0304614846,
0.05647742,
0.0176691469,
0.0592676736,
-0.03183778,
-0.0073046098,
0.0032848248,
0.0313787684,
-0.0217608009,
-0.0474102497,
0.0405905657,
-0.0069064326,
0.00331872,
-0.0149773909,
0.0345614441,
-0.0510581061,
0.0287817232,
-0.0124203339,
-0.0114135481,
-0.017449094,
0.0228445865,
-0.0182120129,
-0.0073205722,
0.0287000202,
0.0616160929,
-0.0562079586,
-0.106870532,
0.0304172505,
0.0088798329,
-0.0061648996,
0.0001186041,
0.059988752,
-0.0010126153,
0.0051747132,
0.0399201401,
-0.0168177094,
-0.0036751062,
-0.0390163772,
-0.0082515599,
-0.0271240976,
-5.937693432e-33,
-0.0435297191,
-0.0233647656,
-0.0221281722,
-0.0222727936,
-0.064571552,
0.0059857313,
-0.0838239118,
0.0237245336,
0.0129982112,
0.0457741283,
0.0259111449,
0.0319959074,
-0.0108292699,
0.0409133211,
0.0230898838,
0.024531154,
0.0285991654,
-0.0147508625,
-0.0297601689,
0.033334773,
0.0264802296,
0.0029921536,
0.0314702764,
-0.0930429399,
-0.0071403217,
0.0358578414,
-0.0361272097,
0.0214848369,
0.0408494808,
0.0480378903,
-0.0434216969,
0.0534044504,
-0.0094056055,
0.0369859301,
-0.0330113396,
-0.0072452198,
-0.0020314259,
0.0002592911,
0.0060092779,
0.0123073477,
-0.0757252127,
0.0092563918,
0.0568262748,
-0.0355288498,
-0.013303129,
-0.0042882022,
0.0603058413,
-0.024180375,
0.0080449609,
-0.0466132574,
-0.0181329902,
0.0047303978,
-0.0517399199,
-0.0430007614,
0.0203269329,
-0.0092553487,
0.0239190292,
0.0507541932,
-0.042217575,
0.0233500637,
-0.0489123575,
-0.0076948483,
0.0338547081,
-0.0064079263,
0.0351968296,
0.0816807598,
0.0108670918,
-0.0495352969,
-0.0303980988,
0.0280689783,
0.0092803361,
0.0643878803,
0.0292109549,
0.0234671701,
0.036857862,
0.0004119305,
0.0232180897,
0.0109030781,
-0.0455976538,
0.0086343335,
0.0407386869,
0.0361873806,
-0.0237796139,
0.0147105064,
-0.0239862241,
-0.0668212399,
-0.0275325384,
-0.0413559899,
0.030812379,
-0.0139415246,
-0.0255674887,
0.0079858694,
0.0072954074,
-0.0159139056,
-0.0125954626,
-0.0201100055,
-0.0687753633,
0.0582974553,
-0.0025584768,
0.0126978075,
0.0146535113,
-0.0300747193,
0.068289116,
0.0247576348,
0.0309013408,
0.0247315262,
0.0388881564,
0.0342636295,
-0.0560368262,
0.0043145022,
-0.0271697864,
0.0010005289,
-0.0250837188,
-0.0204940811,
0.0258856546,
0.0132917166,
-0.0564355925,
0.0209147837,
0.0072872294,
0.034001451,
0.0171543621,
-0.016031079,
-0.0048537776,
0.0101978192,
-0.0262599178,
0.028502401,
-0.0097164828,
-0.0605171658,
0.0499157645,
-0.0666202232,
-0.0326495357,
0.032548368,
2.707e-7,
0.0385698862,
0.0015035369,
0.0408796705,
0.0582142398,
0.0366802923,
0.0436775386,
-0.0478032716,
0.0208499357,
-0.0186870489,
-0.0531363823,
0.0257104486,
0.0458109975,
0.0650339648,
-0.0078761289,
-0.0830737352,
0.0394591466,
-0.0794057474,
0.0051948261,
-0.0499445908,
-0.0212876741,
0.0940755829,
0.0732023567,
0.0237648319,
-0.0068584951,
0.0262852311,
-0.0335058309,
0.0918531418,
-0.0330046043,
0.02588786,
-0.0577934459,
-0.0155885154,
0.0033068554,
-0.0093760919,
-0.0233923811,
-0.0180244055,
-0.009916001,
0.0625433996,
0.0358077586,
-0.0232082102,
-0.0432354473,
-0.0194969401,
0.0102051087,
0.0197100583,
0.00451629,
0.054626029,
-0.0247876197,
-0.0494325235,
-0.0136776846,
-0.0050176093,
-0.0007854011,
0.0469860397,
-0.0211748797,
-0.0696931183,
-0.0147794439,
0.047694996,
-0.0210894421,
-0.0214198381,
-0.0601470284,
-0.0400698185,
-0.0244304314,
-0.0462488458,
0.0172890909,
-0.0407385789,
0.0352081992,
-0.0037493347,
-0.0157599859,
-0.0509450138,
2.228847721e-34,
0.0689301044,
-0.0232496895,
0.0299686138,
0.0030603507,
0.0301421266,
0.0281238984,
0.029697001,
-0.0349831358,
0.0024364188,
-0.0448315963,
-0.0526350588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10532v1 | One For All & All For One: Bypassing Hyperparameter Tuning with Model Averaging For Cross-Lingual Transfer | 2023-10-16T15:50:34 | 2023-10-16T15:50:34 | Fabian David Schmidt, Ivan Vulić, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual language models enable zero-shot cross-lingual transfer
(ZS-XLT): fine-tuned on sizable source-language task data, they perform the
task in target languages without labeled instances. The effectiveness of ZS-XLT
hinges on the linguistic proximity between languages and the amount of
pretraining data for a language. Because of this, model selection based on
source-language validation is unreliable: it picks model snapshots with
suboptimal target-language performance. As a remedy, some work optimizes ZS-XLT
by extensively tuning hyperparameters: the follow-up work then routinely
struggles to replicate the original results. Other work searches over narrower
hyperparameter grids, reporting substantially lower performance. In this work,
we therefore propose an unsupervised evaluation protocol for ZS-XLT that
decouples performance maximization from hyperparameter tuning. As a robust and
more transparent alternative to extensive hyperparameter tuning, we propose to
accumulatively average snapshots from different runs into a single model. We
run broad ZS-XLT experiments on both higher-level semantic tasks (NLI,
extractive QA) and a lower-level token classification task (NER) and find that
conventional model selection based on source-language validation quickly
plateaus to suboptimal ZS-XLT performance. On the other hand, our accumulative
run-by-run averaging of models trained with different hyperparameters boosts
ZS-XLT performance and closely correlates with "oracle" ZS-XLT, i.e., model
selection based on target-language validation performance. | [
-0.02035526,
0.077379778,
0.0134125724,
0.0218918175,
-0.0237841271,
0.0265239794,
0.037861228,
0.0062369714,
-0.0370270424,
-0.0299268421,
-0.0679436252,
0.0018329585,
-0.0029901795,
0.0089181969,
0.0254854001,
-0.0316598192,
0.0653911531,
-0.0149241844,
-0.0168292616,
-0.0129568586,
-0.0322703645,
0.0157241598,
0.0033941262,
0.0183316581,
-0.0196617395,
-0.0126640052,
0.0176017191,
0.0003052246,
0.0221739132,
0.0032020758,
-0.0032986512,
0.0381133296,
-0.0104467543,
0.0472791642,
0.0000019416,
-0.0552067533,
-0.0439616069,
0.0129043674,
-0.0268213525,
-0.0047121164,
0.0388025641,
-0.0358758792,
-0.0008275406,
0.0027534133,
0.0196342245,
-0.0505998544,
0.0557560474,
0.0493737571,
0.0299615152,
0.0692912638,
-0.0114588104,
0.016491631,
0.015690621,
-0.0397066735,
-0.0195148215,
-0.0866917074,
0.0242653433,
-0.0135632642,
-0.0350826234,
-0.0017617324,
-0.0085681612,
0.0311877895,
0.0052176546,
0.0080183977,
-0.0157462545,
0.0307461228,
-0.0718130544,
0.0253113117,
-0.0168185327,
0.0641520768,
-0.0788355768,
-0.0123759657,
-0.0056128763,
-0.0028831924,
-0.0230073873,
-0.0308296122,
-0.0696214139,
0.0098769674,
0.0177587848,
0.0168944243,
0.0364561006,
-0.0288491864,
0.0436210185,
0.0208365209,
0.0013076226,
0.061398387,
0.0331879146,
-0.0094729988,
0.0682619959,
0.0542142279,
0.0057154684,
-0.048641827,
-0.004594354,
0.0015568936,
-0.0624624304,
-0.0043383166,
-0.0288010892,
-0.0462966897,
0.0149102891,
0.0122126918,
0.067613624,
0.0341163315,
-0.0281618256,
0.0480355695,
-0.0322220027,
0.0259051062,
0.0102086803,
0.0493241511,
-0.0308905467,
-0.0499819182,
-0.0702640861,
0.0109329019,
-0.0256282724,
0.0502851158,
-0.0215219762,
0.0317538008,
-0.0597892851,
-0.0063985968,
-0.0094741751,
-0.0197103396,
-0.0003289028,
-0.0466846339,
-0.0474703461,
0.0372833349,
0.0225655846,
0.0573541597,
-0.0261968803,
0.0069302195,
0.0071177566,
-0.0535077713,
-0.0570030808,
0.0278140586,
0.0001143409,
-0.0610598922,
0.028632151,
0.1106653288,
-0.0309978966,
-0.018260479,
-0.0347637236,
-0.0046647643,
0.0056587132,
-0.0751571804,
0.015599071,
-0.042135179,
0.0556109436,
-0.0013032247,
0.037720643,
-0.0005959909,
-0.0468114838,
-0.0075930022,
-0.010463981,
0.0530081093,
0.0275603049,
-0.0244125798,
0.0015634741,
-0.0195083581,
-0.0274210125,
0.0960220024,
0.0054183849,
0.0243442282,
0.0607143007,
-0.0139601314,
-0.0004153248,
0.0530864783,
0.0346664973,
0.0316018164,
-0.0385126807,
-0.0055172364,
0.0619400814,
-0.0183570739,
0.0388417691,
0.0003299084,
-0.037524119,
0.0057358891,
0.0320445821,
0.0434853882,
0.0253262315,
0.0029397677,
0.0627016574,
-0.044215221,
-0.0256809816,
-0.0012100107,
-0.0385363214,
0.0229552556,
0.000289121,
-0.0053088493,
0.0257672649,
0.0482642613,
-0.0465003327,
-0.0116867898,
0.0075563639,
-0.0062750662,
-0.0384498872,
-0.0072994218,
0.0734116584,
0.0033373088,
-0.0014278698,
0.0795379579,
0.0639603809,
-0.0417297222,
0.027018588,
-0.0378773063,
0.0082183303,
0.0160841737,
0.0034669978,
-0.0247017518,
-0.001213147,
-0.0178163592,
0.0385115258,
0.0148913125,
0.0546990894,
-0.0233465694,
0.0848640874,
-0.0327957049,
-0.0479674339,
-0.0070941746,
0.0082433149,
0.0514386371,
-0.0156497732,
0.0717726946,
0.0126573443,
-0.0549070239,
-0.0476380661,
0.0302658789,
-0.042628482,
-0.0456093661,
0.0405322872,
0.0162075106,
0.0516837277,
-0.0080011543,
-0.0236050729,
-0.031460125,
-0.0182757601,
-0.0252281576,
-0.0182364099,
-0.0051186634,
-0.0171469357,
-0.0460926965,
0.0041114134,
-0.0184236728,
0.0060178097,
0.031163834,
-0.0692532584,
-0.0461648144,
0.0233866312,
0.0279634502,
0.0148833748,
-0.0384932198,
-0.0000021238,
-0.007550512,
0.0347280875,
-0.0070726182,
0.0243926048,
0.0531108007,
-0.0011967553,
-0.0108306818,
-0.0410907716,
0.0287832022,
-0.0305999164,
-0.0126478523,
0.0581173524,
-0.0291997157,
0.0281871483,
0.016711697,
0.0357274562,
-0.0445319489,
-0.0109386723,
-0.0807998255,
0.0255241003,
-0.0367414579,
0.034633223,
0.0008423163,
0.0093137547,
-0.0043592891,
-0.0072212694,
-0.0406638794,
0.016399214,
0.0115167387,
0.0416169614,
0.0204429328,
-0.0005206476,
0.0260412842,
-0.0454978049,
-0.0243002754,
0.0053027719,
0.0771367401,
-0.038291201,
0.0118675148,
-0.031412404,
-0.0014600718,
-0.0526417941,
-0.0049814899,
-0.0078375777,
0.0018780271,
-0.0178235807,
0.0078097181,
-0.0335831605,
0.0592375025,
-0.0368696786,
-0.0287832785,
0.0237179436,
-0.0143172238,
-0.0836265534,
0.0271134321,
0.0147620002,
-0.0306803975,
-0.0178040545,
0.0041573648,
0.0087986831,
0.0613051541,
-0.0286976919,
-0.0333181135,
-0.0465704501,
0.0204564743,
-0.0293220617,
-0.0179225784,
-0.0496685468,
0.0325046554,
0.0141646843,
0.024963703,
-0.0230278112,
-0.0437721312,
0.0541615151,
-0.0141381109,
-0.0066184239,
-0.0477370769,
-0.0008484555,
-0.0535524897,
0.0112680392,
-0.0300409626,
0.010509016,
0.0205755066,
-0.019019803,
-0.0251931921,
-0.041663371,
-0.0126917399,
-0.0037462893,
0.0370538868,
-0.0285488553,
0.02274777,
-0.0096187508,
-0.0482993834,
-0.0122371735,
-0.0089417119,
-0.0153792752,
0.051908534,
-0.0217920188,
-0.0102843456,
-0.0549689047,
-0.011260245,
0.0193585139,
0.0742627531,
-0.0293833148,
-0.0134331509,
-0.0069250516,
0.0105996737,
0.0147162341,
-0.0248034224,
-0.0036752559,
-0.0353505462,
0.0178760849,
0.0394649394,
0.0506688841,
0.0102892453,
-0.0063160565,
0.0391699672,
0.0322411358,
-0.0346576422,
-0.0451323949,
-0.0344125628,
0.0398766883,
-0.0178648438,
-0.0057610832,
0.0749649629,
-0.0128439702,
-0.0426407196,
-0.0030234484,
-0.007872805,
0.0570793711,
0.0071203648,
0.0423826426,
-0.0690528452,
-0.0321343839,
0.0061948891,
0.0319096334,
0.0200067703,
-0.0234007053,
-0.0035893156,
-0.1100806147,
0.0257011689,
0.0062280037,
-0.1080528349,
0.0397318304,
-0.0481450744,
0.0182809643,
-0.0674380064,
0.0491802096,
-0.0286105797,
-0.0118579036,
-0.0010779549,
0.0234573986,
0.0301033389,
-0.0476937443,
0.0471621528,
-0.0476251319,
0.0100315446,
0.0236478765,
0.0270545334,
-0.015282766,
-0.0359779783,
0.0417984426,
-0.03199834,
-0.0105344476,
-0.0349236801,
0.0783265531,
-0.0114998883,
-0.0337504633,
0.0584412068,
0.0003665255,
-0.0210025366,
-0.0019512819,
0.0193449482,
0.0802626833,
0.0515430458,
-0.0166801177,
0.008839394,
-0.0496967994,
0.0074468092,
0.0691260919,
0.0102424845,
-0.0313471705,
-0.0316092186,
-0.0018527834,
-0.0275059454,
-0.0771709085,
0.0125414114,
0.010607549,
-0.0709019303,
-0.0596825369,
-0.0479557179,
-0.0759496465,
0.0406249873,
0.0639229119,
-0.0033414422,
0.0074199792,
-0.0542897694,
0.0022087744,
-0.0082769552,
0.0480490848,
-0.0506687462,
0.020503385,
-0.0266224798,
0.0112487534,
0.0379010551,
-0.0023974311,
-0.0285475161,
0.0021352759,
-0.0384909436,
-0.070302926,
-0.0381465927,
0.0499602593,
0.0105524175,
0.084948197,
-0.0192813165,
-0.0397141092,
0.0479908548,
-0.0037713621,
-0.0098969545,
-0.0147148399,
0.0654946864,
-0.0216148421,
-0.004362483,
0.0469288602,
-0.0588412657,
0.0368313044,
0.0745125264,
0.0160200596,
-0.0194657985,
-0.0077965059,
-0.0080728075,
0.0120222336,
0.0485787056,
-0.013049718,
-0.0148679586,
-0.0132433092,
0.0240433197,
-0.0142730875,
0.0022821571,
-0.0412567928,
0.0124052772,
0.0264722798,
-0.0103360005,
-0.0165355504,
0.0409633182,
-0.0201711077,
0.038060762,
-0.03535432,
-0.0177908074,
-0.0327115469,
0.0246989373,
0.0087864175,
0.0117532695,
-0.0119594615,
-0.0241125692,
0.0476686098,
0.0460510701,
-0.067656517,
0.0129917255,
0.0301920772,
0.0513707362,
-0.002142899,
0.0117804306,
-0.0446476452,
-0.0190680604,
-0.0255963691,
-0.0150077967,
0.0621188208,
-0.043169979,
0.0836509392,
0.0176260341,
-0.0321273543,
-0.0283896439,
0.0027571355,
-0.0015011897,
0.0058888798,
0.0020480407,
0.0187906343,
-0.0096115563,
0.0064269505,
0.0745800883,
-0.0004854932,
0.0200318247,
-0.009296855,
0.0182071086,
-0.0295511242,
0.0216145683,
0.0401926115,
-0.032534726,
0.0024133064,
-0.0202918723,
-0.0085225645,
-0.0876215249,
0.0502808541,
-0.0265379082,
-0.0028293827,
0.0332446881,
-0.0003439857,
0.0876210332,
-0.0217526481,
-0.0199628789,
-0.0351354778,
-0.0487243645,
0.0540105887,
-0.0168466456,
-0.003126607,
-6.45689496e-33,
0.0061347433,
0.0518996492,
0.0033987029,
-0.020277435,
-0.0220083725,
-0.0019567634,
-0.0227261074,
-0.0226283576,
0.0020954078,
0.0282394346,
-0.0324507542,
-0.0170653407,
0.0392418094,
0.0389725901,
0.0323999077,
-0.0061842841,
0.055352062,
-0.0054501733,
-0.0491668433,
0.0245848633,
0.0466912799,
0.0340106003,
0.1148301065,
-0.038016852,
0.007928092,
0.0483867303,
0.0235020276,
0.0121937068,
0.0221869666,
0.0326227918,
0.0125257932,
0.0500238054,
0.0240221061,
-0.0887981653,
-0.0040219957,
-0.0173284411,
-0.0750290751,
-0.0558360592,
0.0351396017,
0.0273907334,
0.0000212618,
-0.0379515179,
0.0065671662,
-0.0134441946,
-0.0053735166,
-0.0427869558,
0.0131701808,
-0.0250275061,
-0.0339338891,
-0.02958747,
-0.060524974,
0.0221241228,
-0.0168420449,
0.01770344,
0.0574977472,
0.0680361837,
0.0074191992,
0.0225251522,
-0.0632451773,
-0.0069596265,
-0.006951787,
0.0186356772,
0.0813362151,
0.0389221162,
-0.0321586281,
0.0454826728,
0.0413668007,
-0.0038334993,
0.0278133098,
0.0167627763,
0.0295801423,
0.0119581623,
0.0219161548,
0.0276346356,
0.0289928727,
-0.0285910312,
-0.109113805,
0.0303496942,
-0.0177926607,
0.009802606,
-0.0093339989,
0.0174815636,
-0.0271178335,
-0.0172686223,
-0.0469151549,
-0.0496126749,
-0.0365338512,
-0.0328848362,
0.0412971377,
0.0017211225,
-0.02489377,
0.0028662377,
0.0489289872,
-0.0060694697,
-0.0515820161,
0.0125036696,
-0.0068115508,
-0.0072904062,
0.0110579263,
0.0217282511,
-0.0559628755,
-0.0564304553,
-0.0051050386,
0.0407590121,
0.0437559448,
-0.0136501193,
0.0778638422,
0.0135111874,
-0.0625836849,
0.0050689154,
-0.0357837342,
0.0380920358,
0.015197577,
0.0747517198,
0.0178312976,
0.0139102936,
0.0029964808,
0.0437661,
0.021548437,
-0.0416087955,
0.0002823668,
0.0113313152,
0.0211081579,
0.0213682279,
-0.0155081935,
-0.0140815424,
-0.0147737497,
-0.0307725053,
0.0402589962,
-0.0452757254,
-0.0052460581,
0.0266953371,
2.696e-7,
0.0106740538,
0.0242127161,
-0.0131895561,
-0.0296239126,
-0.0066127405,
0.0375788435,
-0.046931155,
0.0335670672,
0.0143059492,
-0.0026678497,
-0.0349240378,
0.0376465134,
0.0847134292,
0.0387044847,
-0.0644382238,
-0.0254845433,
-0.0478436351,
0.0252413861,
-0.0443698205,
-0.0102976169,
0.0203526933,
0.0929672867,
0.0065844469,
-0.0291389506,
-0.0014820623,
-0.0328476913,
0.0441309288,
-0.0181588754,
-0.0214843974,
0.0470083766,
0.0052915234,
-0.0065431632,
0.0157282501,
0.0575010926,
-0.0474138409,
0.0349193662,
0.0335915312,
0.0680908039,
-0.0220991652,
-0.0452308357,
-0.0047307224,
0.0025953988,
0.0110953255,
-0.0426448658,
0.0884388238,
-0.047688473,
-0.012129467,
-0.0388321504,
-0.0246284697,
0.0201070923,
0.0817951784,
-0.0137617663,
-0.0121319648,
0.0453220792,
0.0352825262,
0.0104172891,
-0.0512086004,
-0.0481196567,
0.0040633129,
0.0308658835,
-0.0134182908,
-0.0459928364,
-0.0039660838,
-0.0224920828,
-0.0030893672,
-0.0344990827,
0.0090165511,
2.233512505e-34,
0.0319845602,
-0.0392227843,
0.0419623442,
-0.0155382873,
0.0075088972,
-0.0231795609,
-0.0324757323,
-0.015618613,
-0.0185494199,
-0.0336889029,
0.004493475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10520v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10520v3 | Semantic Parsing by Large Language Models for Intricate Updating Strategies of Zero-Shot Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-10-16T15:38:02 | 2023-11-25T02:09:35 | Yuxiang Wu, Guanting Dong, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Zero-shot Dialogue State Tracking (DST) addresses the challenge of acquiring
and annotating task-oriented dialogues, which can be time-consuming and costly.
However, DST extends beyond simple slot-filling and requires effective updating
strategies for tracking dialogue state as conversations progress. In this
paper, we propose ParsingDST, a new In-Context Learning (ICL) method, to
introduce additional intricate updating strategies in zero-shot DST. Our
approach reformulates the DST task by leveraging powerful Large Language Models
(LLMs) and translating the original dialogue text to JSON through semantic
parsing as an intermediate state. We also design a novel framework that
includes more modules to ensure the effectiveness of updating strategies in the
text-to-JSON process. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach
outperforms existing zero-shot DST methods on MultiWOZ, exhibiting significant
improvements in Joint Goal Accuracy (JGA) and slot accuracy compared to
existing ICL methods. Our code has been released. | [
0.0036116196,
0.0603937916,
0.029129805,
0.0575463288,
-0.0142200496,
0.0073893475,
-0.0097835762,
-0.0179324634,
-0.0290628485,
-0.0874570161,
-0.020842446,
-0.0430472344,
-0.0160047971,
0.0323401354,
-0.0255602375,
-0.053819187,
0.0576111637,
-0.0282795615,
0.0018430207,
0.0396747664,
0.0109922299,
0.0292729195,
-0.0301941745,
0.0503082201,
0.0093625598,
-0.0643821508,
-0.0341713689,
0.000254851,
0.0084570907,
-0.056916438,
-0.0133308228,
0.0076414691,
0.0487524606,
0.0333814248,
0.0000018611,
-0.0562009364,
-0.0271643475,
-0.017750496,
-0.0690832511,
-0.0168995094,
0.0046872701,
-0.0337236598,
-0.0230315682,
0.0216308944,
-0.0302257985,
-0.030467499,
0.0147052193,
0.0329307057,
0.1051642373,
0.0768132955,
-0.0280606207,
-0.0385424569,
0.0214019269,
-0.0124373976,
0.0052277488,
-0.0865634829,
0.0199433975,
0.0309126507,
-0.0147466073,
0.0219149552,
-0.0142186405,
0.015473986,
0.0006142257,
-0.0448018797,
-0.0362509452,
0.0053079785,
-0.0260979664,
0.0037443978,
-0.0200718865,
0.0804944411,
-0.005011613,
0.0569006763,
-0.0116788689,
-0.0089102229,
-0.023507053,
-0.0360041521,
-0.0796797723,
0.0083626388,
0.0005040326,
0.0262131318,
-0.0050924914,
-0.0051228679,
-0.0070600603,
0.0045623523,
-0.0200402662,
0.0607884936,
-0.0012665099,
-0.0166395698,
-0.0478450693,
-0.0165283754,
-0.0011036476,
-0.0795593262,
-0.0146242473,
0.036458116,
-0.0582085624,
0.0251241457,
-0.0139528364,
-0.0178989004,
-0.0225984305,
-0.0286204889,
0.0310119074,
0.0427416824,
-0.026265353,
0.0601724796,
0.0333298184,
0.0425401442,
-0.0035609826,
-0.0469351932,
-0.0425057523,
-0.0135782687,
-0.0614455156,
0.0041051977,
-0.0228863303,
0.0474738777,
-0.056607496,
-0.0527301393,
-0.0198747572,
0.0474445038,
0.0013472547,
0.0467784554,
-0.0036458785,
-0.0108343987,
-0.0421020091,
-0.002315036,
-0.0011490264,
0.0955796018,
0.0054705865,
-0.006697455,
-0.0069821468,
-0.0117771365,
-0.0095845265,
0.0300130472,
0.037668746,
-0.014134055,
-0.0333762094,
0.0547222905,
0.0007657325,
-0.0356465764,
-0.0079126609,
-0.0217747819,
-0.0226515383,
-0.0244207792,
-0.0231563579,
-0.0222206637,
0.0342174545,
-0.0232339818,
-0.0022242053,
-0.0205963943,
0.0030471988,
0.0200370848,
-0.0031463101,
0.0733779445,
-0.0089551136,
-0.0055730427,
0.0019555364,
-0.0038093419,
0.0040093483,
0.0753626451,
0.0402750373,
0.0062077246,
0.0188049246,
0.0193259548,
0.0056716171,
0.0558377542,
-0.0161524825,
0.008826579,
-0.0246216394,
0.0310397204,
0.0222798046,
0.0299593676,
0.0439852439,
0.0157014206,
-0.0666826516,
0.002152046,
0.0499078035,
0.0510251671,
-0.0067771529,
-0.0154512953,
0.0272727143,
0.0648480505,
-0.0232127421,
-0.0178594422,
-0.0287939366,
0.0118391793,
0.0256251711,
-0.0094836159,
0.0244916212,
-0.0152970683,
-0.0137833711,
-0.0056636739,
0.0078833085,
-0.0375162587,
-0.0057986067,
0.0002541155,
0.0316839106,
-0.0020933638,
-0.0623921491,
0.0394546092,
0.0025912647,
-0.0091326274,
-0.0211520698,
-0.0145821786,
0.0029649208,
0.0734099597,
0.0301758386,
-0.0330439769,
-0.1119507551,
-0.077958636,
0.0096709188,
0.0578442998,
-0.0307019167,
-0.0423719324,
0.0481500067,
-0.0393499658,
-0.0151116597,
-0.0218052063,
-0.0047236932,
0.0088484054,
-0.0217362866,
-0.0283073802,
0.0075488305,
0.0356952846,
0.0323641561,
0.0072497465,
-0.0102841305,
-0.0162486378,
0.0220542029,
-0.0285756383,
0.0296382345,
0.0469485931,
0.0017334358,
-0.0277556032,
0.0004014058,
-0.0204626415,
-0.0048507811,
0.037731275,
-0.0611086152,
-0.0679017529,
0.0342391506,
0.0425933488,
-0.0267650597,
0.0020132407,
-0.0535821691,
-0.0638355091,
-0.0214474946,
-0.0202390179,
0.0088483989,
-0.0222434886,
-0.0016671822,
0.0438292176,
-0.0082221003,
-0.0332355089,
0.0217437614,
0.0148021122,
-0.0342528969,
0.0275344364,
0.004797901,
0.0139536113,
-0.042768307,
-0.0080161421,
0.0551182404,
0.0061027897,
-0.0230362993,
0.0139600588,
0.0136196241,
-0.0434970744,
0.0070210285,
-0.110612087,
0.0365598835,
-0.0217535198,
0.0208356082,
0.0364369154,
0.0105448198,
0.0005380782,
-0.0237825513,
-0.0346061774,
-0.0141429091,
0.0348522775,
-0.0236824192,
0.0366009325,
0.0388266668,
-0.0269013736,
-0.0459233113,
0.0278714392,
-0.025304269,
0.0521870889,
-0.0154924635,
-0.0088815792,
-0.0625168979,
0.0253995229,
-0.0051443554,
0.0419467725,
0.0036943331,
-0.0143294139,
0.0272033513,
-0.0000145383,
0.0090937009,
0.0640597194,
-0.0106357848,
0.0300530549,
-0.0173652004,
-0.0504146703,
-0.0587421432,
0.0360760763,
0.0121006705,
0.0045367819,
-0.0648097098,
0.0183825027,
0.0052158213,
0.0468954854,
0.0088513652,
0.0553805381,
-0.0418453664,
-0.0000435787,
-0.0149792694,
0.003709581,
-0.0091409506,
-0.0184370838,
-0.0507859476,
0.0244402252,
-0.0132378722,
0.0093085235,
0.029455686,
-0.0495486483,
-0.0406279899,
-0.042580355,
0.0135553051,
-0.0544948988,
0.0853182971,
-0.011304291,
0.0140338978,
-0.0116821826,
-0.048189275,
0.0029174881,
-0.0293006282,
0.0121607929,
-0.0239401869,
0.0428285003,
-0.0358384475,
0.037925899,
-0.0251807552,
-0.0466784276,
-0.0337383524,
-0.0376053303,
-0.0533274971,
0.0302732587,
-0.0233609173,
-0.0179237947,
0.0079919649,
0.0204745512,
0.0039027815,
0.0458491072,
-0.0016665513,
-0.004454765,
-0.0440073237,
0.0334678367,
0.0597703941,
0.0080257244,
-0.0424947739,
-0.006270369,
0.0747028515,
0.0565383099,
0.0264991764,
0.0309454091,
-0.0439840555,
-0.0014516512,
0.01546307,
-0.0128895026,
-0.0007741376,
-0.0192740392,
0.0660421923,
-0.0699189529,
0.011601055,
0.1484073848,
0.0275427531,
-0.0451937728,
-0.0256637502,
-0.0106299464,
-0.0389933735,
0.0244408064,
0.0194386113,
-0.1057637706,
-0.0673447177,
0.0089703668,
0.0041772602,
0.0182603579,
-0.0672257394,
-0.0082484279,
-0.1140381321,
0.0292659961,
0.0053680819,
-0.0290682651,
0.0068077268,
-0.0052068089,
0.0169169884,
-0.0157678705,
0.0361298062,
0.0158667993,
-0.0029292458,
-0.0191641469,
0.0029121838,
-0.0138681205,
-0.0295944158,
0.0366957486,
-0.0259098765,
0.0784491748,
0.0891391933,
0.0385898091,
0.0123692947,
0.0339462869,
0.0495303348,
-0.0020970998,
-0.029856557,
0.0124892751,
0.0124821812,
-0.0533072948,
-0.0352176614,
0.0055186958,
0.0371147729,
-0.017003879,
-0.0373235121,
-0.004230605,
0.0424234159,
-0.0405837893,
0.0600034595,
0.0347434692,
-0.0030813257,
0.0267039072,
0.0695394725,
0.0129910633,
-0.0369902924,
-0.0171992537,
-0.048313871,
-0.0350714736,
-0.0424118713,
0.0349956937,
0.0025598928,
0.017089773,
0.040651422,
-0.0721106082,
-0.0517113283,
0.0662448481,
0.0140236784,
-0.0165709946,
0.018684525,
0.0327010006,
-0.0106888581,
0.0047749006,
0.0042939931,
-0.0478373431,
0.0013731723,
-0.0367902294,
0.0094318585,
0.0786405653,
0.0109213358,
-0.0161104221,
0.022516299,
-0.0745453089,
-0.0332186483,
-0.0219918042,
0.0249565691,
0.0121750273,
0.0733319074,
0.0010936983,
-0.0320860371,
-0.0239150673,
0.0109377019,
-0.0309519805,
-0.003463299,
0.046702493,
0.0970052183,
-0.0239024144,
0.0337772034,
-0.0042007798,
0.0256823897,
-0.0294258371,
0.0512045994,
-0.0625348166,
-0.0532417931,
0.0183529779,
0.0039370754,
0.0365555808,
0.0161848981,
-0.0041311509,
-0.0071905656,
0.0320111103,
-0.0586280599,
-0.0137230428,
-0.0764753595,
-0.0062021906,
0.0167537276,
-0.0503359139,
0.0100924606,
0.0399330072,
-0.0257233474,
0.023665892,
-0.0271007456,
0.0095252087,
-0.0007604855,
-0.0153374588,
0.0095915366,
-0.0047026998,
-0.0220631305,
0.0178334489,
0.0115090879,
0.0381842479,
-0.0200820733,
0.0954775289,
0.0261373613,
-0.0239699446,
-0.0090818908,
0.0261240043,
-0.0388270169,
-0.0257717147,
-0.0104406858,
0.0266192388,
0.0684654713,
-0.0056530666,
0.0932818353,
-0.0082629314,
0.0177938249,
-0.0113345133,
0.0551542938,
-0.0192736313,
-0.0481345579,
0.0293896329,
0.0257452894,
-0.0165880974,
0.0264532622,
0.0700483397,
0.0076295557,
0.0316204578,
0.0139023941,
0.0122967511,
-0.0537661389,
-0.0105145518,
0.0321066827,
0.0594447628,
-0.003548288,
0.0088375863,
-0.0262706447,
-0.0387320183,
0.0170408394,
-0.019848736,
-0.0261853077,
0.0033524556,
0.0293471236,
0.0138416439,
0.0033705584,
0.0025002474,
-0.0198548175,
-0.0171966702,
0.0062345467,
-0.0220712181,
-0.0369200222,
-5.903881439e-33,
-0.0448120534,
-0.0339091197,
0.0469764471,
0.0175031405,
-0.044940386,
-0.0168653131,
-0.0464108512,
-0.0072802599,
-0.0056810989,
-0.0199667104,
0.0094839754,
0.0078542884,
0.0148841171,
0.0637642071,
-0.0050835502,
-0.051446069,
0.0522939749,
-0.0270125717,
-0.0075374651,
0.0208758749,
0.0449929908,
0.0274415445,
0.0513093397,
-0.0526262373,
0.0131005766,
0.0111307325,
0.0037340475,
0.0590287372,
0.0444392301,
0.0205151495,
-0.0190055706,
0.0066171894,
0.0232957043,
-0.0704570264,
-0.0250246413,
0.0185178574,
-0.0389082022,
0.0007980772,
0.0170965195,
0.0183704365,
-0.0160804708,
0.0023687116,
-0.0139732575,
0.0016692702,
0.0272142012,
-0.0001793189,
-0.024907222,
-0.0114329197,
-0.0130659724,
0.0106775388,
-0.0660409927,
0.0279351156,
-0.0343644172,
-0.0661303997,
0.0495080277,
0.0407137536,
0.0494318157,
-0.0105617037,
-0.0604241975,
-0.0255545713,
-0.0552299134,
0.0254857093,
0.0480286479,
0.0297482125,
0.0094168978,
0.0979666412,
0.0038543206,
0.0137069905,
-0.0131473057,
-0.012227593,
-0.010921373,
0.0212486535,
-0.0076664109,
0.0256977789,
-0.0054931007,
0.0411609486,
-0.0653568432,
-0.0127655342,
0.0192121863,
0.0631930381,
-0.0008853824,
0.040113464,
-0.0163102709,
-0.0056350399,
-0.0110892737,
0.0128133995,
-0.009757353,
-0.0223832261,
0.0303324591,
0.0002807919,
-0.0037606123,
0.0178662185,
0.0974825919,
-0.0237925164,
0.0121300267,
0.02892101,
-0.0372308232,
0.0429028124,
-0.0312622078,
0.0148555413,
-0.0236636996,
-0.0304163583,
0.0242150612,
0.0080291005,
0.0276609156,
0.0226363577,
0.0191572718,
-0.0011009218,
-0.051348418,
0.0048390706,
-0.0392273031,
0.0309389215,
-0.0612692051,
0.0493855812,
0.0279884692,
0.0101084784,
-0.0237321109,
0.1059738621,
0.0040308028,
-0.0152291358,
-0.0058324952,
-0.0244519562,
0.009560057,
-0.0180444606,
-0.0267128199,
0.0083622551,
0.0108299768,
-0.0049181492,
0.0047184429,
-0.0448461324,
0.0043914826,
-0.0015116526,
2.623e-7,
0.0219573136,
0.0577428639,
0.0385869369,
0.0075373268,
0.0496770181,
0.0558364913,
-0.0170722809,
0.0267598648,
0.0369023494,
-0.0100006321,
0.0012770606,
0.0095383869,
0.0399567075,
0.0431027338,
-0.1323022693,
-0.0395380519,
-0.0446733348,
-0.035356313,
-0.082771793,
0.0381205119,
0.0764668956,
0.0876899138,
-0.0040691933,
0.0260163248,
0.0188735165,
-0.0456841588,
0.0510090254,
0.0014969831,
-0.0261172801,
0.016035689,
-0.0376261137,
-0.007302911,
-0.0154114161,
-0.0101464493,
0.0110594742,
0.0428869538,
-0.0020335708,
0.0932639241,
-0.0010104562,
-0.0190568604,
-0.0284120757,
0.0235731155,
0.0054820641,
-0.0197709892,
0.0701131895,
-0.091079101,
-0.0334850475,
-0.0470903441,
-0.030744426,
0.006686728,
-0.0182813797,
0.010718355,
0.0043832548,
0.0073183477,
0.024367366,
-0.0094925687,
-0.0168134067,
-0.0428581983,
-0.0410413779,
-0.0069019981,
-0.054529015,
-0.0153211961,
-0.0132029532,
-0.0413682312,
-0.0089855352,
-0.0142211458,
-0.0011317062,
2.414646542e-34,
0.0309496075,
0.0021856062,
0.0166108292,
0.0609830134,
0.0316897109,
0.003518817,
-0.0363309458,
0.0296166874,
0.0241391603,
-0.080937326,
0.004611413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10501v1 | NeMo Guardrails: A Toolkit for Controllable and Safe LLM Applications with Programmable Rails | 2023-10-16T15:20:30 | 2023-10-16T15:20:30 | Traian Rebedea, Razvan Dinu, Makesh Sreedhar, Christopher Parisien, Jonathan Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | NeMo Guardrails is an open-source toolkit for easily adding programmable
guardrails to LLM-based conversational systems. Guardrails (or rails for short)
are a specific way of controlling the output of an LLM, such as not talking
about topics considered harmful, following a predefined dialogue path, using a
particular language style, and more. There are several mechanisms that allow
LLM providers and developers to add guardrails that are embedded into a
specific model at training, e.g. using model alignment. Differently, using a
runtime inspired from dialogue management, NeMo Guardrails allows developers to
add programmable rails to LLM applications - these are user-defined,
independent of the underlying LLM, and interpretable. Our initial results show
that the proposed approach can be used with several LLM providers to develop
controllable and safe LLM applications using programmable rails. | [
0.0280165393,
0.0404867567,
-0.0215996057,
0.0547391511,
-0.0086195897,
0.0054186592,
0.0107821459,
-0.0039325701,
0.0033767642,
-0.0145875877,
-0.0450721532,
0.0442027412,
-0.0515076369,
0.0303096846,
0.0174096152,
-0.0543691218,
0.0428200141,
-0.0421812609,
0.01318515,
0.0442443341,
0.0538849384,
0.0155673167,
-0.0449101664,
0.0411935858,
-0.0135106687,
-0.0356063284,
-0.0638229251,
0.0676455498,
0.0373233855,
-0.0471038222,
0.0036798862,
0.005603143,
-0.0081132585,
0.0316021144,
0.0000019381,
-0.0480380058,
-0.0280614775,
0.010067312,
-0.0323949941,
-0.0487550609,
0.0115922783,
0.0226935521,
-0.0375550687,
0.0269128196,
-0.0340967402,
0.0479506403,
0.0567949191,
0.0592552945,
0.1037984341,
0.1016692668,
0.0075880773,
0.0147222281,
0.0102202566,
0.0174259245,
0.0211785566,
-0.0411260352,
-0.0333488882,
0.0129873157,
0.0021502019,
0.0223007705,
0.0024598807,
-0.0071714711,
0.0109930262,
-0.0360190608,
0.0064092823,
-0.0157396235,
-0.0159133747,
-0.0509689152,
-0.0739695504,
0.0556274094,
0.0062811393,
0.0119612012,
0.0516107827,
-0.0166809782,
0.0332419239,
-0.0317609534,
-0.0425992943,
0.0074693193,
-0.0047098398,
0.0093207499,
-0.0349610969,
-0.0341705158,
0.0086959861,
-0.0108630965,
0.0267975964,
0.0747629404,
-0.0002943184,
-0.0160205979,
-0.003160591,
-0.0235551633,
0.0586574599,
-0.0507515036,
-0.0056361859,
0.0618429407,
-0.0732954741,
0.0357885212,
-0.0544330366,
0.0302139334,
0.0466468036,
-0.021283038,
0.0061159427,
0.0423673727,
-0.0310962684,
0.023585666,
0.0053305426,
0.0370768756,
-0.0095932214,
0.0352165774,
0.013663847,
0.0218405481,
-0.0135454061,
-0.0027322171,
-0.0259624589,
0.020929426,
-0.0545394532,
0.0087745702,
-0.0482508652,
0.1175860614,
0.0044293054,
0.0605515949,
-0.0095125167,
0.0001953831,
-0.000765648,
0.0114036864,
-0.0342636444,
-0.0252350271,
-0.0123901274,
-0.0090348739,
0.0174784288,
-0.051053986,
0.0010284306,
0.0295206234,
-0.0401120819,
0.0103049455,
-0.0055385791,
0.1085957289,
0.0083299689,
0.0079078786,
-0.0449420437,
-0.0661296025,
-0.0028641243,
-0.043230664,
-0.0043886215,
-0.0587005168,
-0.0132324891,
0.000720492,
-0.0131014399,
-0.0623950772,
0.0258326028,
0.0287175328,
0.0313130096,
0.0297742933,
-0.0149879036,
-0.0115556801,
0.0178946797,
0.0493248589,
-0.0132017694,
0.081449829,
0.0416911915,
0.0104245422,
0.0483032987,
-0.0262542628,
0.0179747585,
0.0502416454,
-0.0352067649,
-0.0139346719,
-0.019435687,
0.0071005709,
0.0173008777,
0.0080684768,
-0.0013028642,
-0.0015492224,
0.0012691009,
-0.0229363982,
0.0428349636,
0.0679946393,
0.0096363984,
0.0186047703,
0.0096018976,
-0.0005576345,
-0.0096203685,
-0.0151249757,
-0.0659702197,
0.0600819811,
-0.0547065213,
0.0153247351,
-0.0330483876,
0.0405133478,
-0.0127988532,
-0.0552116185,
0.0001353839,
0.0041254596,
-0.0010617712,
0.0073498897,
0.0061292453,
-0.0098216916,
-0.057260219,
0.0787945539,
0.0050141211,
-0.0556103624,
-0.080432564,
-0.031645827,
0.0242374018,
0.079996407,
0.0145098176,
-0.0510507599,
-0.0800932497,
-0.0247385707,
-0.0182151832,
0.0648189858,
0.0453163348,
0.0017116161,
0.0329691991,
-0.0377760753,
-0.0405212753,
-0.025180351,
0.0013265456,
0.0119360136,
-0.0112045044,
0.0141451526,
-0.0118930992,
0.0075943414,
-0.0188966878,
0.0490206927,
-0.0038113012,
-0.0439879335,
-0.0224331431,
0.0119140185,
0.0247574579,
0.0210846979,
0.0065502613,
-0.0360047668,
0.0768203735,
0.0317492746,
0.0155241322,
0.0143473735,
-0.0421294086,
0.000403254,
0.0354717299,
-0.0035497297,
-0.0298572425,
-0.0175889302,
-0.0680218115,
-0.0025519088,
0.0025741996,
0.0021685564,
0.0251220297,
-0.0200476926,
0.0473132245,
0.0256342478,
-0.0428501889,
-0.0372717641,
0.0038040602,
0.0212964863,
-0.0218088068,
0.0406885184,
0.0149704721,
0.0293917228,
-0.0522781163,
-0.0112291938,
0.0039442708,
-0.0035426579,
0.0144453095,
-0.0184934977,
0.0372948982,
-0.0529951453,
-0.0334452428,
-0.0838880688,
0.0292210784,
-0.0136244586,
0.0200993232,
-0.0014473845,
0.0108426157,
-0.0221402533,
-0.0352816544,
-0.0290637743,
0.0255841743,
0.0460174419,
-0.0222941637,
0.0365066752,
-0.006569705,
-0.0653682202,
-0.0321644135,
0.0368666127,
-0.0058807023,
-0.0073517971,
-0.02414391,
-0.0350188687,
-0.087634787,
0.0332224704,
-0.0379377455,
0.0264545884,
-0.0056411857,
-0.0163443908,
0.0398020633,
0.034540426,
-0.0280908663,
0.0267755874,
-0.0274572764,
0.0343732908,
0.0464506745,
-0.0023955561,
-0.0823404416,
0.0289626215,
0.0105996495,
-0.0473665483,
-0.0479378402,
0.0017523556,
0.0074831229,
0.0586391576,
-0.0230927821,
0.0411234051,
0.0065462762,
0.0298769362,
0.0641240105,
-0.0321962908,
0.0255955476,
-0.027864268,
-0.0450845771,
0.0473358035,
-0.0018409617,
-0.0853847265,
0.0595722087,
-0.0427591689,
-0.0536481328,
-0.0018403957,
-0.0718437657,
-0.0540324897,
0.0629545674,
-0.0612544715,
0.0003650359,
0.056341432,
-0.045286715,
-0.0062334202,
-0.0385090895,
0.0199718662,
-0.0330128111,
0.0360712856,
-0.0548453592,
-0.0153856911,
-0.0084002921,
-0.0233793166,
-0.0598564595,
0.0238312315,
-0.0537642688,
-0.0459649712,
-0.0149448011,
-0.0055606645,
-0.0146312574,
-0.0036698172,
-0.016032191,
-0.0148038976,
0.0058804555,
-0.0200030711,
-0.022414472,
-0.0356781669,
0.011514442,
0.0034387703,
-0.0105223507,
-0.0172205791,
0.0478410013,
0.0692937747,
-0.0081951981,
-0.0474783666,
-0.0414157994,
-0.0216889381,
0.0400552899,
-0.0288574733,
0.0072238967,
0.0350335799,
0.064813368,
-0.0408539735,
-0.018909378,
0.0711862743,
0.0131970607,
-0.0282313712,
0.0169269666,
-0.0699244961,
0.0654174164,
0.0396920778,
0.0366102755,
-0.0836442783,
-0.023063546,
-0.0092154443,
0.0628914163,
0.001452408,
-0.00176803,
-0.0324602127,
-0.052195169,
0.0350350998,
0.013589289,
-0.0422341563,
0.03976316,
-0.0007222102,
-0.0020820238,
0.0023401056,
0.0131347524,
0.0019568671,
-0.0057559297,
-0.0354831778,
0.0040165992,
-0.0300381556,
0.026279645,
-0.0386468172,
-0.0221407674,
0.0867965296,
0.0692424253,
0.0108985985,
0.0214093514,
-0.0409292616,
0.0534676351,
0.0082429936,
0.0414078943,
-0.0379788168,
0.0128044756,
-0.0076324381,
-0.0085453438,
-0.0304945577,
0.0028246006,
0.0185370017,
-0.0225383677,
0.073966302,
0.0423012823,
-0.0780580044,
0.0053403084,
-0.0528237335,
0.0314585306,
0.0218974464,
0.0431176238,
0.0197748598,
-0.007405282,
-0.0279107746,
-0.0528003089,
-0.0395052396,
-0.005827425,
-0.0170160048,
-0.0312005728,
-0.0212346911,
0.0198450554,
-0.0480151772,
-0.0166375339,
0.0073281936,
0.0250182133,
0.0122690741,
-0.010667135,
0.0121125095,
0.0319503695,
-0.0040837452,
0.0228701979,
-0.0044409609,
-0.0031930681,
-0.0592678823,
-0.000782799,
0.0154427988,
-0.0273753982,
0.0304395668,
0.0087966984,
-0.0348634608,
-0.0604482107,
-0.0330427848,
0.0736955628,
0.0329238661,
0.0501826927,
0.019374812,
-0.0164293405,
0.0378490128,
0.0525898449,
-0.0524176396,
0.0163879972,
0.0269223936,
0.0509336032,
0.0008582759,
0.0003504106,
-0.0829491392,
-0.0157454424,
0.0284303539,
0.0050220205,
-0.0674664974,
-0.0974411666,
-0.0256653931,
-0.0072090439,
0.0057424465,
0.012911954,
-0.0087881014,
0.0083791418,
0.0501359254,
-0.013806018,
-0.0087535195,
-0.0476770177,
0.0232417695,
-0.0419967324,
-0.0606003888,
0.0602763444,
-0.0073892525,
-0.050186865,
0.0452028215,
-0.0245047566,
0.0483479649,
-0.0051887967,
-0.0301140156,
-0.0019137156,
0.0252608638,
-0.0178577583,
0.0691438913,
0.0107462285,
0.0436083339,
0.0231674146,
0.0945524275,
0.0050561382,
0.0317050889,
0.0042477972,
0.0453341268,
-0.0449187234,
-0.0577727221,
0.0145515855,
0.0706643686,
0.0168731641,
0.0763115957,
0.0611406751,
-0.0337792821,
0.0198271852,
0.0080908779,
0.027330555,
0.0064200088,
-0.0295728799,
0.0198741127,
0.0131611833,
-0.0123907654,
-0.0565793104,
0.0168199725,
-0.0182389878,
0.0253351759,
-0.0181459691,
-0.0253280364,
-0.064506121,
-0.0337711759,
0.0779615268,
-0.0243089814,
-0.0186134987,
-0.0396217182,
-0.0529557131,
-0.0333890766,
0.0184454173,
0.0214795582,
-0.01011647,
-0.0570484214,
0.0370707922,
0.0034180756,
0.0349864662,
-0.0133448122,
0.004514155,
-0.0077611008,
0.0078389943,
-0.0204807259,
-0.050734181,
-5.357915006e-33,
-0.0613754354,
-0.0569981113,
0.0346627645,
0.037912026,
-0.0162083264,
-0.0368353464,
-0.008004467,
0.0319679789,
0.0202821288,
-0.0192226078,
0.0035515015,
-0.017346235,
0.0163101833,
-0.0340027697,
0.0073563829,
-0.025052242,
0.0302155167,
0.0208726656,
-0.0342692025,
0.0309004225,
0.0062062424,
0.0489578731,
0.0315102488,
-0.1152061149,
0.0566667803,
0.0077340933,
-0.0041750171,
0.0277936012,
-0.028255092,
0.0659243315,
0.0263766032,
0.0184434466,
-0.0202474687,
-0.0374720767,
-0.0111043993,
0.0343534537,
-0.0073198145,
-0.044412069,
0.059012413,
0.0123533048,
-0.0170635711,
-0.0539612435,
0.0626732633,
-0.0169218387,
-0.0222898535,
0.0151687963,
0.0212611109,
-0.0015972923,
-0.0083242133,
-0.0354267843,
-0.06512703,
0.0052400446,
-0.0397378467,
-0.0350578614,
0.0023134528,
-0.0161706395,
-0.0099615585,
-0.035475526,
-0.0213356782,
0.005790222,
-0.0097582405,
-0.0260169283,
0.0689964071,
0.0403740518,
-0.033211723,
0.0586149246,
-0.0085491147,
0.0127251223,
-0.0009123767,
-0.0250174124,
-0.0089567201,
0.0814755335,
0.0251045302,
0.0160660334,
-0.0255438201,
0.0216884296,
-0.0182050634,
0.0355868191,
0.0240238234,
0.0511033088,
0.0008165422,
0.0342307426,
-0.0243279263,
0.0127800284,
0.0123936068,
0.0143382372,
-0.0036671315,
-0.0551875941,
0.0376820341,
-0.007092664,
0.0021930661,
-0.0504043475,
0.0018652788,
0.008854094,
-0.0035380914,
0.0277566034,
0.0237121806,
-0.0207314007,
-0.0183426682,
-0.0057121366,
0.0051901252,
-0.0054546869,
-0.0019463786,
-0.0313653685,
0.0775493905,
-0.0101542817,
0.0208858941,
0.0168388616,
-0.064920865,
0.0335375629,
-0.0310653299,
0.0578013584,
-0.0077767284,
0.0147642214,
-0.0151588479,
-0.048968982,
-0.0199718401,
0.062410932,
-0.0119271874,
-0.0471585467,
-0.0415677652,
-0.0000987787,
0.0141948489,
0.0087349601,
-0.048093643,
-0.0121578127,
0.0241667051,
0.0330167748,
0.0364419147,
-0.032501325,
0.0084456559,
-0.0037541599,
2.669e-7,
-0.0028924558,
0.0061089122,
0.0320553295,
0.0514371991,
0.0273518506,
0.0613048263,
-0.0195586309,
0.0433485545,
0.0355269872,
-0.0301571619,
-0.0100615639,
0.0194029268,
0.0546783432,
0.0125854304,
-0.0657022968,
-0.0212409869,
-0.0218162276,
0.0096087437,
-0.0543253049,
0.0527687892,
0.0700663626,
0.0246252399,
0.0056226277,
-0.0104973596,
-0.0028156918,
-0.0052588079,
-0.0095056649,
-0.0530760959,
0.0075183273,
0.0014066865,
0.0530327819,
0.0049042376,
-0.0184148382,
-0.0104883425,
0.0104875797,
-0.0101690069,
-0.0553264581,
0.0993651152,
-0.0052034608,
-0.0460315458,
0.0128785102,
-0.0224730689,
0.0020989568,
-0.0232949015,
0.0113588357,
-0.0024656861,
0.0005339606,
-0.0323372558,
0.0048545673,
-0.0739162117,
0.002692854,
-0.0175132491,
0.0106297554,
-0.0102394279,
-0.0068964362,
-0.0246818196,
-0.0236230344,
-0.016179271,
-0.012396601,
0.0018176247,
-0.0197113287,
-0.0673673451,
-0.0429871492,
0.0409567915,
-0.0289431214,
-0.0638114884,
-0.0214832406,
2.357517976e-34,
-0.0171335675,
-0.0233854335,
0.0175225511,
0.0858650878,
0.0172515921,
0.049245771,
0.0336986966,
0.0169928838,
0.0404458269,
-0.0346760415,
-0.0200606622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10495v1 | Metric Ensembles For Hallucination Detection | 2023-10-16T15:17:22 | 2023-10-16T15:17:22 | Grant C. Forbes, Parth Katlana, Zeydy Ortiz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abstractive text summarization has garnered increased interest as of late, in
part due to the proliferation of large language models (LLMs). One of the most
pressing problems related to generation of abstractive summaries is the need to
reduce "hallucinations," information that was not included in the document
being summarized, and which may be wholly incorrect. Due to this need, a wide
array of metrics estimating consistency with the text being summarized have
been proposed. We examine in particular a suite of unsupervised metrics for
summary consistency, and measure their correlations with each other and with
human evaluation scores in the wiki_bio_gpt3_hallucination dataset. We then
compare these evaluations to models made from a simple linear ensemble of these
metrics. We find that LLM-based methods outperform other unsupervised metrics
for hallucination detection. We also find that ensemble methods can improve
these scores even further, provided that the metrics in the ensemble have
sufficiently similar and uncorrelated error rates. Finally, we present an
ensemble method for LLM-based evaluations that we show improves over this
previous SOTA. | [
0.0161722396,
0.036754176,
0.0174603071,
-0.0015711748,
-0.0399012193,
0.0469701402,
-0.0309576541,
0.0210774895,
0.0057662474,
-0.0247524623,
-0.0054587577,
-0.0744353309,
0.0530761257,
-0.0349699259,
0.027372824,
-0.0803882927,
0.0140765011,
-0.0359781943,
-0.0157325454,
-0.0051410622,
0.0080532152,
-0.0138492621,
0.0034628073,
0.0417942591,
0.0230998825,
-0.0406819731,
0.0144526707,
0.004368362,
0.0467859432,
0.0060602315,
-0.0177258793,
0.0603345148,
-0.0223123115,
0.0651525259,
0.0000019607,
-0.0476536639,
-0.0358624905,
0.0083021689,
0.0352701806,
0.0226728506,
0.0210012514,
-0.0205294434,
-0.0040555312,
-0.0212138481,
-0.0070764818,
-0.0036451772,
0.0245864969,
0.0827369541,
0.0437452868,
0.0494070463,
-0.0058932537,
-0.0356829688,
0.0505226254,
0.0178583488,
0.0005030911,
0.03576364,
0.0459726155,
0.0459392816,
-0.028085785,
-0.0440760814,
-0.0127565367,
0.0385859162,
0.0000838275,
0.0031653405,
0.0119395368,
0.0161213856,
-0.1238826513,
-0.0079478137,
0.0303222444,
0.048204273,
-0.0220102519,
-0.0439764485,
0.0386174172,
0.0265084375,
-0.0150671937,
0.0024548464,
-0.0497654863,
0.0402933434,
-0.0345852599,
0.023003513,
-0.0068212561,
0.0356452838,
0.0264310949,
0.0194350127,
-0.0410367027,
0.0632137507,
0.0107502677,
-0.0432483517,
0.0261769462,
0.0237365067,
-0.0544167198,
-0.0319253132,
0.0179385487,
0.0004505878,
-0.0194214582,
-0.0152571555,
-0.0431120284,
-0.0759093389,
0.0379375778,
-0.0590335242,
-0.0045714867,
-0.0086776074,
-0.0268779472,
0.047019016,
-0.018131122,
0.0539859682,
0.0143792937,
0.0585450865,
-0.0414492972,
0.0069965795,
-0.0107925665,
0.0163474716,
-0.0248203464,
0.0222885944,
0.0104502998,
-0.0432331003,
-0.0501086228,
0.0003321829,
-0.0114593534,
0.0247270409,
-0.0151878949,
-0.0070495359,
0.0208959691,
-0.0326797701,
0.0279474799,
-0.0126239639,
0.0032552134,
-0.0432551466,
0.0141776493,
-0.031034153,
-0.0125937825,
0.0589359179,
-0.0150315622,
0.0320584178,
-0.0029916752,
0.0136986524,
0.0160360672,
-0.0155847529,
0.0292098708,
-0.0192495845,
-0.0413944982,
-0.0533893742,
-0.0137428548,
-0.0626033545,
0.0088753197,
-0.0023139035,
0.0087228995,
-0.0129865035,
0.0074198488,
-0.0006192354,
-0.0068424311,
0.0508966297,
-0.0313396566,
0.0215125866,
0.043945048,
0.03748345,
-0.0175164174,
0.0509963892,
0.0177953765,
0.041962374,
0.0557617024,
0.0108008962,
0.0422874093,
0.0223228335,
-0.0076073133,
0.0219621062,
0.0164745953,
-0.0257974081,
0.0075163767,
-0.0127434498,
-0.0010812271,
0.0806314051,
-0.0204637498,
-0.0123812277,
0.0587676316,
0.0575663708,
0.0137506761,
-0.0163436364,
0.0123722162,
0.0208673067,
0.0297769289,
0.0877326876,
-0.0217836965,
0.0036763805,
-0.0342275873,
0.0548567511,
0.125823766,
0.0180058349,
-0.011379987,
-0.0444009118,
-0.0287561454,
0.0045110756,
-0.0186032709,
-0.0148799494,
0.0421202071,
-0.0025653192,
-0.0578891598,
0.0253413953,
0.0146445362,
-0.0507170409,
0.0282974299,
-0.0271580704,
0.0117659904,
0.0912339017,
0.0718294606,
-0.0369273834,
0.0462516323,
-0.0141759412,
0.0358661562,
0.0608327575,
0.0059592775,
0.0023384867,
0.0055303308,
-0.0529426076,
-0.007017877,
0.0343702324,
0.045400165,
-0.0228298567,
-0.0092049157,
-0.0002605954,
0.0177465715,
-0.0395975187,
-0.0946416184,
0.05658447,
0.0043977955,
0.0094660111,
-0.0419118889,
-0.0096762758,
0.0274570063,
0.0171065331,
-0.0225041285,
0.0294417832,
0.0081015006,
-0.0511454903,
-0.0384330414,
-0.0007340227,
-0.0416556224,
-0.03185701,
0.0212008301,
-0.070024088,
0.0115895802,
-0.0021841528,
0.0149268266,
-0.0593787022,
0.003357067,
-0.0875143409,
0.0164263267,
-0.0547285266,
0.0533902198,
-0.0006904086,
0.0407449193,
-0.0054959315,
0.0788207874,
-0.0350482315,
0.0406279936,
0.0173963159,
-0.036283806,
-0.0129031884,
-0.0261503067,
-0.0423400328,
-0.0115279006,
0.0156239998,
0.0269745421,
0.0034995717,
-0.0527659059,
-0.0524817966,
-0.0318927653,
-0.0915973037,
-0.0039385585,
-0.0462104455,
-0.0084435688,
0.024283085,
-0.0187353026,
-0.0040588751,
0.0115201222,
-0.0112341763,
-0.0379550681,
0.0192378182,
0.0134717198,
-0.0218229294,
-0.0046424256,
0.0077796159,
-0.0234468561,
-0.0144548751,
0.0021640318,
0.0599073581,
-0.0184131954,
-0.0847383589,
-0.0768790841,
0.028854223,
-0.0193983391,
-0.0392307378,
0.0120874727,
0.0087222345,
0.0101304706,
0.0017306166,
0.0609239601,
0.0477130301,
0.0510825105,
-0.0088089937,
0.0691342503,
-0.0187295247,
-0.0052951626,
-0.0517402478,
-0.0271965247,
0.0466028489,
0.040813949,
-0.0486535691,
0.0347572714,
0.0100425351,
0.0347940288,
0.0215095691,
-0.0637378991,
0.0174858849,
-0.038244199,
-0.0264827982,
-0.0221480597,
-0.0535959899,
-0.0164662786,
0.0361626707,
-0.0169471242,
-0.0458802544,
0.062400829,
-0.0459323153,
0.0063634608,
-0.0203100573,
0.0022021041,
-0.008971408,
0.0117703741,
0.0296550579,
0.0197381265,
-0.004193549,
-0.013279886,
-0.0106246891,
-0.0008564841,
-0.0035642914,
-0.0626422688,
0.0445214882,
-0.0357669778,
0.0053548017,
0.0108399177,
0.0312462579,
-0.0175010804,
-0.005502339,
0.0076219309,
-0.0053532291,
-0.0175401494,
-0.0048076371,
-0.0674246699,
0.0509388298,
0.0154071962,
0.0267556347,
-0.0464649498,
-0.0172711648,
0.008105454,
0.0484674722,
0.0622868985,
-0.0070414804,
0.0508430973,
-0.0976005867,
0.0417537875,
0.0642462075,
0.0214499552,
0.0444354936,
0.0022471086,
-0.0497548692,
-0.0040512057,
-0.0311183222,
-0.0075322054,
-0.026442498,
0.0418936126,
-0.0394189171,
0.0043572728,
0.1047386602,
0.0090847928,
-0.0725963637,
-0.0226206612,
-0.0342321433,
0.0674115866,
-0.0299809892,
-0.0193550326,
-0.0274586044,
0.0079500685,
-0.0057254024,
0.0338121131,
-0.0151031148,
-0.0345794596,
-0.0021348025,
-0.0374615081,
0.0353116691,
0.0689753443,
-0.0698828623,
-0.0226181466,
-0.0166507531,
0.0150595428,
-0.0025853605,
0.0213657133,
0.00566353,
0.0179235823,
-0.0216588173,
0.0006725982,
-0.0882878527,
-0.0126997316,
-0.0163786802,
-0.0430872589,
0.0082954615,
0.0903527215,
0.0335993059,
0.0012094922,
-0.0431014225,
0.0097672418,
-0.0628449321,
-0.0266265851,
0.0316149443,
0.0912818536,
0.0130915316,
0.0291086677,
-0.0283768978,
0.0482012779,
0.0129732443,
-0.0106144119,
0.002050922,
0.033235833,
-0.041033607,
-0.0437236354,
-0.0475394204,
0.0414539091,
-0.0062369518,
0.1069405079,
0.0374928899,
-0.0138932038,
-0.0376248844,
-0.0039807195,
0.059256617,
-0.0688387603,
-0.0244267173,
0.0169765558,
0.0235273521,
-0.0258676037,
-0.1144704074,
-0.0195939373,
0.023081651,
-0.024215525,
-0.0046666563,
0.0553089902,
-0.0426314138,
0.0050536795,
-0.0399016514,
0.0112495804,
-0.0165062882,
-0.0261216518,
-0.0266587771,
-0.0169979669,
0.0264363568,
0.0023412351,
0.0035964097,
0.0671721697,
-0.0643728152,
-0.0518078804,
0.0166113134,
0.0146988975,
0.0187725183,
0.0479866974,
-0.0018020504,
-0.0199905038,
0.0849912986,
0.0379386283,
0.0578206554,
0.0401790477,
-0.0151766548,
0.00289528,
-0.0117723439,
0.0169548374,
-0.0347618312,
0.0032760373,
-0.0206305981,
0.0119824028,
-0.0281251632,
-0.0097445399,
0.0190203227,
0.005126873,
-0.0151699111,
-0.0351598673,
0.0021823458,
0.0066039148,
-0.0196744371,
0.0011012818,
-0.0211594719,
-0.0073490115,
0.0361223742,
0.041107472,
-0.0255366508,
-0.0017153959,
0.072133787,
-0.0175134651,
-0.0278906059,
-0.0482886955,
-0.0138174249,
-0.0265107453,
-0.0058097015,
0.0052799969,
-0.0110264011,
-0.0507970676,
-0.0323973857,
-0.0187224858,
0.0260251854,
0.0297756568,
0.0165141579,
0.013648821,
-0.0119240386,
0.0257462151,
0.0603656135,
-0.081885241,
-0.02634307,
-0.0756641328,
0.0386624336,
0.0133158024,
-0.0195443202,
0.1082561389,
-0.0366969295,
0.0150535591,
-0.0474038422,
0.0188893992,
0.0603013299,
0.0088659031,
-0.0520870723,
0.0302450266,
-0.010458326,
0.0376880094,
0.0667432174,
-0.0562741794,
0.0086781941,
0.0169995651,
-0.0352338031,
-0.0367049649,
-0.0376796313,
-0.0909714103,
0.0125539973,
-0.0288430415,
-0.0421961956,
-0.0427409112,
0.0006459046,
0.0279908609,
0.0198155958,
-0.0002909777,
0.0220447276,
-0.0036210672,
0.0276599862,
-0.0384687558,
-0.010941959,
-0.0134637421,
-0.0150859868,
0.0072772754,
0.0083059426,
0.0000435565,
-5.489277234e-33,
-0.0215955768,
-0.0485697947,
-0.0334497131,
-0.0081034051,
-0.0332449749,
-0.0288530365,
-0.0422591642,
0.0023975065,
0.0375271216,
0.0064943898,
0.011858115,
0.0186917968,
0.0183476415,
0.0183071923,
-0.0163278449,
0.0288938079,
0.0254269522,
0.0098014353,
-0.0563278943,
0.0543212332,
0.035478536,
0.002300017,
0.0263021328,
-0.0575794317,
0.0541112013,
-0.0477882624,
-0.035584826,
-0.0288664214,
0.0116280615,
0.0159256477,
-0.0440822355,
0.0182704013,
0.0196102075,
-0.0029295373,
-0.0652281716,
0.0058122859,
-0.0197765697,
0.0109521737,
-0.0073681637,
0.0054614558,
-0.0412244536,
-0.0214577001,
0.0624786839,
-0.0163502861,
-0.0040475139,
-0.0298219603,
0.0596921779,
-0.0783139989,
-0.0294956639,
-0.035325516,
-0.0369315147,
0.0353665799,
-0.0073012905,
-0.000267555,
0.0234839618,
0.0417743511,
-0.0068347896,
0.0221077539,
-0.0435577445,
0.0469262488,
0.0248087663,
0.0215219855,
0.0185192302,
0.0074546463,
0.0141989999,
0.0922249332,
0.0409367941,
-0.027025396,
-0.0333145596,
-0.0413986482,
0.0128342221,
-0.0023203646,
0.0681060478,
-0.0078166611,
0.0414476395,
0.0490942933,
-0.0081808083,
0.0638511777,
-0.0753528923,
-0.0047634006,
0.0732763037,
-0.0006187359,
-0.0379077457,
-0.0152179282,
0.0188750159,
-0.017566029,
-0.0051302374,
-0.0086316932,
0.0120209036,
-0.0153043736,
-0.0541967899,
-0.0409913361,
0.0101717692,
-0.0249201059,
0.0204594359,
0.002600448,
-0.0246623717,
0.0148344208,
0.0036635571,
-0.0276677702,
0.0139778024,
0.0268790293,
0.0366106629,
0.0384157635,
0.0123886904,
-0.0048792702,
0.0486148186,
-0.0159130301,
-0.0470624939,
0.0134263346,
0.0101810517,
-0.0184665658,
-0.0175057705,
0.0163605195,
0.0224038716,
-0.0235456564,
-0.0017718781,
-0.0031773609,
-0.0071455408,
0.0155195352,
0.0109023601,
0.0203382093,
-0.0078095593,
0.0145044625,
-0.0245610736,
0.0254505537,
0.0071324315,
-0.0133384783,
0.0385852084,
-0.0254221912,
0.0039336951,
-0.0000031646,
2.466e-7,
0.0284470022,
0.038211856,
0.0469001606,
-0.0530312769,
-0.0002316979,
-0.0167709291,
-0.0145980073,
-0.0162444059,
-0.0033030235,
-0.0582456104,
0.0207886677,
0.020204138,
0.0882923156,
0.03278758,
-0.0903091207,
-0.0016563807,
-0.0614150912,
-0.011853301,
-0.0497543029,
-0.0337920673,
0.0427914225,
0.0565413274,
-0.0174039602,
-0.0167937931,
0.0153352423,
-0.043870654,
0.0587602369,
-0.0208968688,
0.0049318001,
0.0362969115,
0.064251624,
0.0105552617,
-0.0060880589,
0.0419403799,
-0.0043218401,
-0.0552956536,
0.0762240291,
0.0074616713,
0.0154579785,
-0.0176863056,
0.0024007908,
0.0025737823,
0.0291911066,
-0.0408785678,
0.0367534719,
-0.0021307054,
-0.0014206161,
-0.0005912352,
-0.0509948097,
0.004272854,
0.0581462756,
0.0016715875,
-0.0029586561,
0.0574340113,
-0.0073707714,
0.0103687895,
0.0101428609,
-0.0485475324,
-0.0281965733,
0.0016413874,
-0.0179486014,
-0.0439720079,
-0.0158120152,
0.010991903,
-0.0403550081,
-0.0917762667,
-0.0183350351,
2.370420863e-34,
0.0738415495,
-0.0008370769,
-0.0032721139,
0.0122071924,
-0.0105504775,
-0.0430399105,
0.031957563,
-0.0096662035,
-0.0304324552,
-0.083359383,
0.0109322313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10492v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10492v2 | UNO-DST: Leveraging Unlabelled Data in Zero-Shot Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-10-16T15:16:16 | 2024-04-03T06:05:56 | Chuang Li, Yan Zhang, Min-Yen Kan, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous zero-shot dialogue state tracking (DST) methods only apply transfer
learning, ignoring unlabelled data in the target domain. We transform zero-shot
DST into few-shot DST by utilising such unlabelled data via joint and
self-training methods. Our method incorporates auxiliary tasks that generate
slot types as inverse prompts for main tasks, creating slot values during joint
training. Cycle consistency between these two tasks enables the generation and
selection of quality samples in unknown target domains for subsequent
fine-tuning. This approach also facilitates automatic label creation, thereby
optimizing the training and fine-tuning of DST models. We demonstrate this
method's effectiveness on general language models in zero-shot scenarios,
improving average joint goal accuracy by 8% across all domains in MultiWOZ. | [
-0.0076604164,
0.0547429696,
0.0309419371,
0.0237473901,
-0.0004196903,
-0.0049033687,
0.0339496545,
-0.005751844,
-0.0062066792,
-0.0747966468,
-0.0696122199,
-0.0522508472,
-0.0289527997,
0.0486174896,
0.008267561,
-0.0501433015,
0.0568068065,
-0.0392313749,
-0.019195132,
0.0248164833,
0.0155493887,
-0.0013219634,
-0.0713494644,
0.0282312594,
-0.0183707755,
-0.0284314975,
-0.0372094549,
0.0187337101,
-0.0052547855,
-0.040328145,
-0.0057792384,
0.0553762056,
0.0348854065,
0.0194097478,
0.0000019142,
-0.0467748791,
-0.018485561,
-0.0303810984,
-0.0757535249,
-0.0432797968,
-0.0263745356,
-0.0185735375,
-0.0270842519,
0.0412623771,
-0.0132329091,
-0.0233274437,
0.0339414515,
0.0176618695,
0.0650549009,
0.084678933,
-0.0065827244,
0.0035631191,
-0.001513012,
-0.0313278511,
0.0048801173,
-0.070765689,
0.0030494262,
-0.0093518263,
-0.0165137071,
0.0152674438,
-0.0197740551,
0.0195083953,
-0.0049255854,
-0.0375094786,
-0.0127482004,
0.0037163282,
-0.0441377684,
-0.0030685137,
-0.024331687,
0.1003740504,
0.0286226049,
0.0103962356,
0.015906306,
-0.0232891757,
-0.0104065714,
-0.0167916901,
-0.0659441799,
-0.0254818648,
0.0259032547,
-0.0053312909,
-0.0355919152,
0.0478653498,
0.003563178,
-0.0131950919,
-0.0107935229,
0.0551592596,
0.0057954169,
-0.0307182744,
-0.0179062597,
-0.0095478836,
0.0182140861,
-0.0794633105,
-0.0203159489,
0.0296213292,
-0.0288950372,
0.0288250353,
-0.0731390491,
-0.0192211512,
-0.0321049206,
0.0276685506,
0.0357247815,
0.0530577712,
-0.0413871184,
0.053188622,
0.0163138565,
0.0453222468,
0.0214577094,
0.0157619976,
-0.0217902176,
-0.0008508153,
-0.0883999094,
0.0170899276,
-0.0734765828,
0.0348547064,
-0.0148441298,
-0.0345277451,
-0.008145866,
0.0060121119,
-0.0054284325,
-0.0021525053,
0.0206280313,
-0.0078860838,
-0.0396961458,
-0.0357408971,
0.0157382805,
0.0968521461,
-0.0086245369,
0.0084598977,
0.0248605106,
-0.0374090634,
-0.0506460294,
0.0267047752,
0.0480840132,
-0.0231691953,
-0.0242030378,
0.0806011334,
-0.0178884827,
-0.060132686,
-0.0116830301,
0.0020358248,
-0.0378210954,
-0.0583431683,
-0.0032224341,
-0.0271177739,
0.0235492513,
-0.0088992007,
0.0194653962,
-0.0400066264,
-0.0031703941,
0.0046563526,
-0.0060668625,
0.0668223277,
-0.0373267718,
-0.0095431432,
-0.0291571859,
-0.0078102192,
0.003888482,
0.067513071,
0.0365980789,
-0.0004465643,
0.0232135616,
-0.0021477833,
0.0459836982,
0.030292483,
0.0455041267,
0.0249208957,
-0.0215475988,
0.0148823541,
0.0197551865,
0.0016234291,
0.0386780798,
0.0009947687,
-0.0355947018,
0.0060328864,
0.0575974807,
0.0294943955,
0.0337684192,
-0.0396892875,
0.0392314531,
0.0367354639,
-0.0008799036,
0.0100689894,
-0.0112288129,
0.0412552767,
0.0168079697,
-0.0073808869,
0.040259324,
-0.0186464638,
-0.05545187,
-0.0118121263,
-0.0123790409,
-0.0150219547,
-0.0121441893,
-0.0133889867,
0.0612243861,
0.0469756611,
-0.0623854734,
0.0486949161,
0.0120723601,
-0.0362427756,
-0.0240538977,
-0.0096886344,
0.0128171742,
0.0458238907,
0.0170435999,
-0.0244897585,
-0.0848733708,
-0.0592922606,
0.0347985029,
0.0435115844,
0.0248514134,
-0.0202115756,
0.0764874518,
-0.0631559789,
-0.0186997224,
-0.00810441,
0.0201456547,
0.027627537,
-0.0238978751,
-0.0113960272,
0.0113259964,
0.0020162396,
0.0601283871,
0.0034148269,
-0.0089281732,
-0.0436586402,
0.0349534079,
0.0031366525,
0.021647403,
0.0290059354,
-0.0064947992,
-0.0182561483,
-0.0011376605,
0.003143111,
0.0091795959,
0.0008494974,
-0.0714524239,
-0.0561166331,
0.0143098636,
0.0450096168,
-0.0032072046,
0.0296304394,
-0.0246754829,
-0.0915395916,
0.0187630728,
0.0179219153,
-0.0229502935,
-0.0360149406,
-0.0016464159,
0.0680869296,
0.0168301817,
-0.0154396361,
0.0073816329,
0.0364322662,
-0.0309013352,
0.0336335339,
0.0007060359,
0.0298810489,
-0.0452262796,
0.0053831371,
0.0198600255,
-0.036698468,
0.0084314523,
0.0004221565,
0.0114030922,
-0.0390368178,
0.0125613576,
-0.0558379032,
0.0280828867,
-0.0345609486,
0.0245774891,
0.0159049742,
0.0188509189,
-0.0197664499,
-0.0199973229,
-0.0320702419,
-0.01178018,
0.0222913232,
-0.0267311763,
0.0168334432,
0.0342102796,
0.0074771396,
-0.0466306135,
0.0349692665,
-0.0120009491,
-0.0042080148,
-0.0619875342,
-0.0265137106,
-0.0354509391,
0.0515037701,
-0.0091516543,
0.0342703909,
-0.0074379519,
-0.0218885373,
0.0172213074,
0.0156998336,
-0.0271956567,
0.0259749778,
-0.0371093825,
0.0174544789,
0.0003052954,
-0.0574951954,
-0.049891226,
0.0438649319,
0.0066653667,
0.0049533667,
-0.0084634926,
0.0595243648,
0.0063806134,
0.0748334676,
0.0107740993,
0.0248422921,
-0.0774948522,
0.02103379,
-0.0130801909,
-0.0244440921,
-0.0106077669,
0.0276048761,
-0.0472521,
0.0087944213,
-0.0090151513,
-0.0146397892,
0.0208399389,
-0.0536188446,
-0.0490011498,
-0.0250942279,
-0.0068737678,
-0.0120600788,
0.0312276948,
-0.0105312839,
-0.0050442936,
0.0758797601,
-0.0281041432,
-0.0218487084,
-0.0286292601,
0.0109940246,
0.0012395444,
0.0374337696,
-0.0432782546,
0.0486557819,
-0.0312979929,
-0.0290593598,
-0.0408975035,
-0.040668156,
-0.0292897634,
0.0265352055,
-0.0507225282,
-0.0242634881,
-0.0030523725,
0.0361082032,
0.0233341772,
0.0780129507,
-0.012718684,
-0.0003327303,
-0.0314573236,
0.0494062565,
0.0794542879,
-0.0180381276,
-0.0655564219,
-0.0082369829,
0.0526231416,
0.0278534368,
0.0398261733,
0.0516916923,
-0.003386409,
-0.0099875331,
0.0148659954,
-0.0163676888,
-0.0190844703,
0.0156600289,
0.0795709118,
-0.0322309248,
-0.0097394492,
0.1143113822,
0.0190441255,
-0.0347330458,
-0.0275739785,
0.002099185,
0.0004555617,
0.0216067117,
0.0171610434,
-0.1002250239,
-0.0748588666,
0.0087339832,
0.0375217684,
0.0030567537,
-0.0431748442,
-0.0412192419,
-0.1220455468,
-0.0021210404,
0.0028744536,
-0.0628553182,
0.0102342889,
-0.0046827639,
0.0449893624,
-0.0169637427,
0.0159277786,
-0.0080140848,
-0.0045466274,
-0.0114113651,
0.0425084569,
-0.0079969671,
-0.0369741879,
0.0288037974,
-0.0049932315,
0.119908452,
0.0817565843,
0.0379507653,
0.0117762424,
0.0288774688,
0.0154312942,
-0.0256802402,
-0.0045472942,
0.0044954116,
0.0500485525,
-0.0557880513,
-0.0189543329,
0.0233536791,
0.029535953,
-0.0126348687,
-0.0167729743,
-0.0060275015,
0.0223625358,
-0.0139368614,
0.0206881613,
0.0013773609,
-0.0106947822,
0.0185272601,
0.0580997095,
0.021506764,
-0.0422272421,
0.0108630378,
-0.0107333753,
-0.0074682054,
-0.0639036149,
0.0057283649,
-0.014225618,
-0.0147854518,
-0.0143453553,
-0.0718171224,
-0.0454062819,
0.0725776404,
0.0784735829,
-0.0169488881,
-0.0056483867,
-0.0073661814,
0.0127176261,
0.0209142771,
-0.0122721363,
-0.0812281817,
0.0109735178,
-0.0764868557,
-0.0227749012,
0.063439481,
-0.0009693104,
0.0131369326,
0.0231745634,
-0.0515367426,
-0.0582374744,
-0.0253926199,
0.0646702498,
0.023989141,
0.049863752,
-0.0085867783,
-0.0171898734,
-0.0269684773,
0.0284546334,
-0.0159028117,
0.0003141313,
0.0676248968,
0.0360193253,
-0.0354248732,
0.0401102044,
-0.0212359,
0.0397305526,
0.0018094468,
0.034348201,
-0.0692255571,
-0.0460344777,
0.0181767847,
-0.0376795754,
0.0765514895,
0.0229892638,
0.0097408621,
-0.0131317349,
0.0283825006,
-0.0393682495,
0.0046907417,
-0.091603294,
0.0102794273,
0.0054716212,
-0.0204871111,
-0.0067794169,
-0.0195382424,
-0.0734422281,
0.0290388707,
-0.0245426726,
-0.0384085923,
0.010930392,
0.0099207954,
-0.0178191401,
-0.0109909764,
0.0116683124,
0.0390777849,
0.064025484,
0.0312415212,
-0.00938184,
0.0878260881,
0.0118934978,
0.0033876195,
0.0296713356,
0.0252196267,
-0.0322133079,
0.0105845332,
-0.0420127176,
0.016653154,
0.0499437824,
-0.0066607823,
0.0675376281,
0.0134601546,
0.0112926438,
-0.0110177919,
0.0817848071,
-0.0040061497,
-0.0063024489,
0.0086819045,
0.0339244753,
0.001897333,
0.0118551981,
0.0849996582,
0.0456499346,
0.0266414657,
0.0178970788,
0.0458379537,
-0.0422453955,
0.0144159906,
0.026609648,
0.0300545767,
0.008884754,
0.0342588499,
-0.0419282056,
-0.0483498797,
0.0091517745,
-0.026859479,
-0.0017971483,
-0.0256896149,
0.047734037,
-0.0066693667,
-0.0462766662,
0.019697329,
-0.033421725,
-0.0590858385,
0.0447706804,
-0.0033951849,
-0.0233488753,
-6.223167745e-33,
-0.063674286,
-0.0276265517,
0.0291844774,
-0.0238019954,
-0.0283053908,
-0.016511621,
-0.0389794596,
0.0221508499,
-0.0104361726,
-0.0069288164,
-0.0190762542,
0.0139409285,
0.0244943798,
0.0242234729,
-0.0195852816,
-0.0360136479,
0.0520256646,
-0.0133948838,
-0.0422672704,
0.0073066293,
0.0377953015,
0.0320045017,
0.0657048449,
-0.0602151714,
0.0066396291,
-0.0036636316,
-0.0122023709,
0.0132239629,
0.0440016277,
0.0255674366,
0.0220919997,
-0.0008259091,
-0.002026191,
-0.0816748664,
-0.0130338166,
0.014015737,
-0.0211321767,
-0.0348746218,
0.0059903138,
0.0038780877,
0.0094162636,
0.0067092022,
-0.032767538,
-0.0098463912,
0.0160544887,
-0.0006546301,
-0.0040983777,
0.0001167118,
-0.0248725973,
-0.0005795639,
-0.0526218414,
0.0327620767,
-0.0053597968,
-0.1175117418,
0.0343194045,
0.0886502862,
0.0336910114,
-0.0638302118,
-0.0524565242,
0.0053993412,
-0.0294627938,
0.0338009484,
0.063676849,
0.0182789061,
-0.0235307273,
0.0645756423,
0.0334668607,
-0.0012474528,
0.0042393426,
-0.026775917,
-0.0015339851,
0.028992204,
0.023109125,
0.0186666492,
0.0298679154,
0.0102953073,
-0.0290231034,
0.0053659803,
0.0018465754,
0.0132559575,
-0.0246272869,
0.0350889452,
-0.0333625712,
-0.0151672512,
0.0027848925,
-0.0182362832,
-0.003945481,
-0.0398883931,
0.0485500023,
0.0230386741,
-0.0241768602,
0.0097038085,
0.0990445316,
-0.0190170575,
-0.0006789006,
0.0063633407,
-0.0249288119,
0.0321127363,
-0.0251827706,
0.0001400956,
-0.0815322623,
-0.0337895565,
0.0598693267,
0.0603155717,
0.0271547642,
0.0086102653,
0.0356655866,
0.0335055031,
-0.0506237186,
-0.023409497,
-0.0333846547,
0.0556504689,
-0.0416693389,
0.0581860691,
0.0178939477,
0.0217285901,
-0.0253428333,
0.1016237214,
-0.0024948169,
-0.083490856,
-0.0188313331,
0.0086587938,
-0.0084847845,
-0.0051634726,
-0.0337481983,
-0.0015619727,
-0.0125392508,
-0.0347115993,
0.0097881667,
-0.0338323675,
0.0006010446,
0.0086421883,
2.722e-7,
-0.0049742036,
0.0265007205,
0.0241008773,
-0.0036558216,
0.0112651708,
0.0782052353,
-0.0484892838,
0.0405028053,
0.0178426113,
-0.0266818106,
0.0117406808,
0.004788036,
0.0536712743,
0.0128034223,
-0.1168697178,
-0.047409147,
-0.0181578342,
0.0141573772,
-0.0271523949,
0.0146482084,
0.0274907332,
0.059194684,
0.0238330513,
0.0188163109,
0.0427753031,
-0.0062641487,
0.0510502048,
0.0313073099,
0.0047240919,
0.0246490911,
0.009845837,
-0.0009376651,
-0.0462596714,
-0.005568394,
-0.0135059869,
0.0343230069,
0.0096730292,
0.0772230104,
-0.0286291838,
-0.0409560688,
-0.019928392,
0.026452858,
0.0006702507,
0.0169088151,
0.0666709468,
-0.0728497729,
-0.0182806868,
-0.0173235368,
-0.0155277513,
0.0384521633,
-0.006338519,
0.0296936817,
-0.0215671528,
0.0088848667,
0.0368829221,
0.0188076459,
-0.036082264,
-0.0695197433,
-0.0205280241,
-0.0370739289,
-0.0282234233,
-0.008275223,
-0.0229208991,
-0.0566585101,
-0.0103920111,
-0.05278714,
-0.0132083977,
2.299064453e-34,
0.0247159302,
-0.0128825456,
0.0234649293,
0.0173049439,
-0.0170091856,
-0.0050379611,
-0.028725056,
0.0019590398,
0.0429673865,
-0.0381202623,
-0.0100019434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10706v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10706v2 | Harnessing the Power of LLMs: Evaluating Human-AI Text Co-Creation through the Lens of News Headline Generation | 2023-10-16T15:11:01 | 2023-10-18T00:55:57 | Zijian Ding, Alison Smith-Renner, Wenjuan Zhang, Joel R. Tetreault, Alejandro Jaimes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To explore how humans can best leverage LLMs for writing and how interacting
with these models affects feelings of ownership and trust in the writing
process, we compared common human-AI interaction types (e.g., guiding system,
selecting from system outputs, post-editing outputs) in the context of
LLM-assisted news headline generation. While LLMs alone can generate
satisfactory news headlines, on average, human control is needed to fix
undesirable model outputs. Of the interaction methods, guiding and selecting
model output added the most benefit with the lowest cost (in time and effort).
Further, AI assistance did not harm participants' perception of control
compared to freeform editing. | [
0.0567844696,
-0.0077917222,
-0.0104003157,
-0.0168235134,
-0.0533467866,
0.0201620311,
-0.0135211302,
-0.0153361373,
0.0286898147,
-0.0379029177,
-0.0476579405,
-0.0074709444,
-0.0011750495,
0.0275218282,
-0.0034496449,
-0.0241138879,
-0.0033786604,
0.0031243039,
0.0223222896,
0.0351304747,
0.0182217788,
0.032650128,
-0.0084304307,
0.0410944,
-0.0641042516,
-0.015938133,
-0.015501569,
0.0302993879,
0.0145259006,
-0.0065273149,
-0.0279670823,
0.0612583607,
0.0350818038,
0.0118431672,
0.0000017155,
-0.0365033448,
0.017856447,
-0.0121023087,
-0.0191647131,
-0.0238761939,
0.0143317459,
-0.0075506661,
-0.0338566042,
-0.0147501258,
-0.0286621191,
0.091662623,
0.0197895057,
0.0213903263,
0.0396079496,
0.0441849567,
-0.0086380085,
0.0585844554,
0.0070958696,
0.0045322976,
0.0069130543,
0.0105745364,
-0.0370749123,
-0.0162866563,
0.0444995165,
-0.0192008726,
0.0393123813,
0.045625899,
0.0273067076,
-0.083464846,
-0.0025204786,
0.0522758998,
0.0197810009,
-0.0407535322,
-0.0187794808,
0.041124329,
0.0528084151,
0.0081199473,
-0.0020573512,
-0.0347650275,
0.0394110121,
0.0671515092,
-0.0462824628,
0.0459430404,
-0.0130058276,
0.0021368377,
-0.0119617209,
-0.0486952551,
-0.0189114399,
0.0323797427,
0.0382412337,
0.0231815595,
-0.0150696272,
-0.0156979673,
0.004057778,
0.048894193,
0.0291612912,
-0.0896042511,
0.0135201616,
0.0556153879,
-0.0316319689,
0.0066938545,
-0.069192037,
-0.018752167,
-0.0234615374,
-0.0674367249,
0.0412767194,
-0.0107164588,
-0.0019383522,
0.0202451404,
0.0207899213,
0.0219055992,
0.0226227306,
0.0552534722,
0.0169681199,
0.0521720387,
-0.0135003002,
-0.0304229166,
-0.0249814373,
0.0572477318,
-0.0083626825,
-0.031872496,
-0.0266594142,
0.014166805,
0.002303829,
0.0553663447,
0.0018369789,
0.0242967326,
-0.0258707628,
-0.0189969968,
-0.0045323768,
-0.0114462934,
0.0003281596,
0.0244750734,
0.0291875564,
-0.012752803,
0.00677924,
0.0256704576,
-0.00439625,
-0.0250211786,
-0.0078796297,
0.0483602621,
-0.0557318144,
-0.032400731,
-0.0476567596,
-0.0433001705,
0.0070889918,
-0.0205625482,
-0.035504438,
-0.0299658068,
0.012336567,
0.0190290231,
-0.0364994518,
-0.069253996,
0.0143834306,
0.0237107128,
-0.0232745446,
-0.0200403482,
-0.0483051315,
0.034468513,
0.0532736704,
0.0201676171,
-0.0344681181,
0.0200533792,
0.0919482484,
0.1003766507,
0.0387925655,
0.0388769731,
0.0744832605,
0.0354221612,
-0.0422626399,
0.0113548003,
-0.0182038546,
-0.0126004908,
-0.0608586222,
0.0374161676,
0.0339517966,
0.0378143303,
-0.019478282,
0.083381258,
0.123655878,
0.0600877479,
0.0407466143,
0.0292078648,
0.0377626084,
-0.0102426382,
0.0309358966,
0.0435765907,
-0.025991343,
0.0567476377,
-0.024086833,
0.0173235815,
-0.0392142646,
0.0053859246,
0.0006532031,
-0.0495916829,
-0.0034089852,
-0.0167102627,
-0.0374157466,
-0.0299108792,
-0.0021000174,
0.0003476192,
-0.0201219395,
-0.033934135,
-0.024520224,
-0.0591880791,
0.0401280373,
-0.0314120837,
0.0462775826,
0.0901497826,
0.0475753024,
-0.0066350405,
0.0032098871,
-0.0157496147,
0.0296848509,
0.049205441,
0.0190102439,
-0.0085873073,
-0.0616914034,
0.0186352897,
0.0023658085,
-0.0425137281,
-0.0100814374,
0.0121927168,
-0.0308872797,
0.0281644166,
0.0160589572,
0.0446393117,
-0.0499774888,
0.0435151421,
-0.0645651147,
-0.0266187266,
-0.0387564041,
0.0320000723,
-0.0423230231,
0.0589608699,
-0.0521447584,
0.0362380557,
0.0121894823,
0.0070037432,
-0.0679650307,
0.0478578843,
-0.0100965863,
0.0328792334,
-0.0115071433,
-0.0134952199,
-0.0502620824,
-0.0056189033,
0.0082245544,
-0.0137423687,
0.0164990723,
-0.0352848284,
0.0003914128,
-0.0258134175,
0.0098579284,
0.0121106766,
-0.0648556948,
-0.0185784008,
0.0264550988,
-0.0256797075,
-0.0162462685,
0.0504126363,
0.0294160303,
-0.0375704616,
-0.003760851,
0.0374920852,
0.0516447015,
0.0190793127,
0.000672971,
0.0078930184,
0.0072661405,
-0.0390340723,
-0.056444779,
-0.0392107628,
-0.0027348436,
-0.023896493,
0.0068355557,
0.0232344195,
-0.029029699,
-0.0435822047,
0.0315340422,
-0.019145716,
-0.0502134599,
0.0250857361,
0.0091054682,
0.0436003618,
-0.0044346224,
0.040997114,
-0.0459229238,
0.0303413533,
-0.0002919899,
0.0065918504,
0.0999489278,
-0.0477183089,
-0.0615501814,
0.0340729095,
-0.0230350327,
-0.0423391536,
0.0070666648,
-0.0192382354,
0.0312606543,
-0.0070847631,
0.0001625999,
0.0634841397,
0.020729037,
0.0650945306,
0.0458320864,
-0.0022229333,
-0.0234779231,
-0.0137982583,
0.0219173972,
-0.0105396863,
0.0174695104,
-0.0178955551,
0.045177117,
0.0225561336,
0.0412533619,
0.0283486005,
-0.0005727759,
0.0400629863,
-0.0019982061,
-0.0227319673,
0.0356592536,
-0.0483926944,
-0.0355186984,
0.0662695542,
-0.0205189325,
-0.0554770902,
0.0375746004,
-0.0024076309,
0.0041648722,
0.0522933118,
-0.0241133664,
-0.0318418778,
0.0343843177,
-0.0617710724,
0.028591482,
-0.0450440682,
-0.0156580452,
-0.0741474181,
-0.0086645763,
0.029731391,
0.0019161381,
0.0145082744,
-0.0571399033,
-0.0050994279,
-0.0181885827,
-0.0183578152,
-0.0071719582,
-0.0060932557,
-0.0290085915,
0.0110188127,
0.0580522045,
-0.0281597283,
0.0240059216,
-0.0263167899,
0.089227207,
0.0286452994,
-0.0023153753,
-0.0189149026,
-0.0262952615,
0.0188172366,
0.0262067411,
0.0070774816,
-0.010142901,
-0.0270215105,
0.0183946211,
0.0300715547,
0.0295170378,
0.0033713102,
0.0043078088,
-0.0190516412,
0.005937973,
-0.0233199466,
-0.0377064981,
0.0064994115,
0.0490178205,
-0.003511942,
-0.0051536984,
0.108797133,
0.033700034,
-0.0196115114,
-0.0049025896,
-0.0512651019,
-0.0292678624,
-0.0051611792,
0.0186450556,
-0.0449413024,
0.0083881812,
0.0254412573,
0.0211833641,
-0.0193386637,
-0.0487141795,
-0.0054089418,
-0.0497842953,
0.047634203,
-0.0066402266,
0.0285995286,
-0.016234152,
-0.0253349412,
0.0132375313,
0.0211518854,
-0.0242602862,
0.0168019626,
-0.0283025522,
-0.0039331261,
0.0116553297,
-0.0054314872,
0.0005024781,
-0.0668778121,
-0.041919522,
0.0125412587,
0.0790546834,
0.063262336,
0.000785723,
-0.0056166993,
0.0118622044,
0.0564789623,
0.0577162839,
-0.0327410698,
0.0186480973,
-0.056239713,
0.04745166,
-0.0448018014,
0.0433484651,
0.0447598472,
-0.0209194701,
0.0028353862,
0.0251577329,
-0.049957592,
-0.0250008777,
-0.0028873351,
-0.0085296687,
0.0513034426,
0.035012953,
0.0585652702,
-0.0494185723,
-0.0225807671,
-0.0304360148,
-0.0062553538,
-0.008152917,
-0.028227007,
-0.0286223609,
-0.0441333763,
0.0139763737,
-0.0949218795,
-0.0581136905,
0.0359498858,
0.0423696674,
0.0355246179,
0.0063407444,
0.0369948447,
-0.0199621879,
-0.0086848242,
-0.0442671105,
-0.0023456281,
0.013644902,
-0.0490486622,
-0.0041784314,
-0.0097829923,
-0.0358397067,
0.0238565113,
0.0162879918,
-0.0130084809,
-0.0606461316,
-0.0027513001,
0.0377482884,
0.0292091612,
-0.0040380964,
0.0433806404,
-0.0661280602,
0.0014018561,
0.0191361438,
0.0114825042,
0.0440042615,
-0.0219560526,
0.0579836927,
-0.0174590759,
0.0119087314,
-0.0256833397,
-0.0230771881,
0.0473323241,
0.006265583,
-0.0164662898,
-0.048391778,
0.0009451322,
0.0317849703,
-0.0235609226,
-0.054580193,
0.0404784568,
-0.0742316172,
0.002187713,
-0.0805876777,
0.0011713525,
-0.054902833,
-0.0167820603,
-0.003654531,
-0.0051895916,
-0.0040049967,
0.0389043167,
-0.0606830008,
0.0404399633,
-0.0654633865,
0.0026938678,
-0.0521228425,
0.0465733334,
0.0126866652,
-0.0088454839,
-0.0140640708,
0.0457412861,
-0.0276604481,
0.0191827267,
0.0356857963,
0.0387776867,
0.0284742266,
-0.0148479361,
0.0338189304,
0.0355880558,
-0.0613043495,
-0.0755079538,
-0.0167195611,
0.0513377078,
0.0466149747,
-0.0156862531,
0.0454519875,
-0.0437752381,
0.0130492924,
0.027002614,
0.0547417216,
0.0321895406,
-0.0211604219,
-0.0302007068,
-0.0143482378,
-0.0329480208,
0.0045930794,
0.0725216344,
-0.0394464582,
0.018886039,
-0.0378988981,
-0.0499146841,
-0.0303923897,
-0.0252550691,
0.0532888584,
-0.0576629341,
0.0139082903,
-0.0335010104,
-0.078379266,
-0.0131665897,
0.0351730622,
-0.0060877409,
0.0024907873,
-0.052379135,
-0.0050358349,
0.0193954594,
0.0176895112,
0.008572503,
-0.0376336314,
-0.0034634348,
-0.038730111,
-0.0339270942,
-0.0145172942,
-5.392992492e-33,
-0.0472780615,
-0.0969969481,
0.0210231021,
0.0290844757,
-0.037211623,
-0.0184992626,
-0.0408886969,
0.0627554357,
0.0703357607,
0.0034295786,
-0.0536715798,
-0.0236738361,
-0.0006318888,
-0.0362527259,
0.030378174,
0.0061189844,
0.0351582728,
-0.025613809,
-0.0325654037,
-0.0175095927,
-0.0111176353,
0.0357811078,
0.0049835499,
-0.0555770658,
0.0457237028,
-0.0323443748,
-0.0314796157,
-0.0235325731,
0.0010087613,
-0.0159444381,
0.0309870355,
-0.044465363,
0.0426913127,
-0.0086003859,
-0.0027774815,
0.113547191,
0.0205649193,
-0.0484474413,
0.0152050499,
-0.0253737736,
-0.0242009126,
-0.033832632,
0.0198561996,
-0.0148745077,
-0.017539626,
0.0188870095,
0.0333016329,
-0.0080204774,
0.0106844893,
-0.0283331834,
-0.0712285861,
0.0002088945,
-0.0125331525,
-0.0330716334,
0.0098264469,
0.024773635,
-0.008683335,
-0.0235051401,
-0.040610522,
0.0066596321,
-0.0128980698,
0.0139778722,
0.0647435859,
-0.0221903194,
-0.0270861909,
0.0406948999,
-0.0251760725,
0.0469582938,
-0.1016110927,
0.0310836043,
-0.0132528748,
0.0743048266,
0.0401626751,
0.0695295185,
-0.0522785746,
-0.0179366525,
-0.0179689117,
0.0679247975,
-0.0184963532,
0.0122437477,
-0.0146273272,
0.0123451082,
-0.019257918,
0.0010400173,
-0.0101060178,
-0.0400518328,
-0.0249210745,
-0.0699960887,
-0.0037338247,
-0.0050068409,
-0.0135188205,
-0.0310237706,
-0.0254875459,
0.0276286509,
-0.0101193376,
-0.031137282,
-0.0401750989,
0.0533268042,
-0.0272922311,
-0.0554658435,
-0.0422059745,
0.0122798048,
0.0123883141,
0.039599508,
0.0623422675,
0.0220652688,
0.0439213216,
0.0308383126,
-0.013602607,
0.0005198312,
-0.0145633537,
0.0484017842,
0.0562352836,
-0.0581752472,
0.0164113659,
-0.0468182713,
-0.009579137,
0.0006636415,
-0.0044852896,
-0.0039799311,
-0.0274657868,
-0.0034807352,
-0.0137925176,
-0.0149054211,
-0.0495298319,
0.0072683473,
-0.0094136633,
0.0417876281,
0.0668436661,
-0.027050538,
-0.0239160247,
-0.0589682348,
2.531e-7,
-0.004477263,
0.0509525537,
0.0191205088,
0.0541266799,
0.0080966586,
0.0323498175,
-0.0202211756,
0.0358477123,
0.0069451807,
-0.0069387592,
0.0638384968,
0.0053818529,
0.0560703985,
0.0246538911,
-0.0304443054,
-0.0175009705,
-0.0679601431,
0.0207311232,
-0.0417501852,
-0.0226347614,
0.0754371658,
-0.1138268188,
0.0015562512,
-0.034382958,
-0.0225717854,
-0.0054193311,
0.0334712416,
-0.0249844603,
-0.0041564866,
-0.0021115758,
0.0669691414,
0.0003606938,
-0.0184134636,
-0.0146671785,
-0.0345085077,
-0.0441661663,
0.0410273448,
0.0718467683,
-0.0091122249,
-0.0028897638,
0.0566706471,
0.0029304274,
0.0178789161,
-0.0028750778,
0.0427833162,
-0.0292606242,
-0.0061593628,
-0.0465566181,
0.0116742533,
-0.0483575538,
-0.0044530928,
-0.0468481742,
0.0400102101,
0.0403281823,
-0.0137723451,
0.0377575122,
0.0257055182,
0.0102601415,
-0.029989861,
0.001924445,
-0.0091119595,
-0.0166967325,
-0.0537872724,
0.0017678716,
-0.048364047,
-0.0769345611,
-0.0051280134,
1.781520578e-34,
-0.0297489651,
0.006256545,
0.0057065948,
0.0504536517,
0.0677201524,
0.0504321232,
-0.0072999829,
0.016323112,
-0.0044708275,
-0.0039784228,
-0.0138252592
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.