id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12481v2 | Not All Countries Celebrate Thanksgiving: On the Cultural Dominance in Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T05:38:23 | 2024-02-16T14:06:41 | Wenxuan Wang, Wenxiang Jiao, Jingyuan Huang, Ruyi Dai, Jen-tse Huang, Zhaopeng Tu, Michael R. Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper identifies a cultural dominance issue within large language models
(LLMs) due to the predominant use of English data in model training (e.g.,
ChatGPT). LLMs often provide inappropriate English-culture-related answers that
are not relevant to the expected culture when users ask in non-English
languages. To systematically evaluate the cultural dominance issue, we build a
benchmark of concrete (e.g., holidays and songs) and abstract (e.g., values and
opinions) cultural objects. Empirical results show that the representative GPT
models suffer from the culture dominance problem, where GPT-4 is the most
affected while text-davinci-003 suffers the least from this problem. Our study
emphasizes the need to critically examine cultural dominance and ethical
consideration in their development and deployment. We show that two
straightforward methods in model development (i.e., pretraining on more diverse
data) and deployment (e.g., culture-aware prompting) can significantly mitigate
the cultural dominance issue in LLMs. | [
0.0661092922,
0.0895078629,
-0.0365313254,
0.0455050953,
-0.0201271139,
0.0321146958,
0.0499579608,
-0.0050963503,
0.0324029773,
-0.0211416557,
-0.0054023359,
-0.078254953,
-0.0291141327,
0.0179735664,
-0.0100364508,
-0.0456677787,
0.0368382409,
0.0034334816,
0.0069267484,
-0.0458380133,
0.0154721811,
0.050133612,
0.0457714349,
0.0238979831,
-0.0181191135,
-0.0173956845,
0.0387459546,
-0.0283985976,
0.0277538542,
-0.0359988362,
0.0251930933,
0.0210739058,
-0.0141667714,
0.0313156024,
0.0000020943,
-0.0602631159,
-0.0074020661,
-0.0173050817,
0.0054966756,
0.0443217121,
0.0732759908,
0.0187552162,
-0.0146020986,
0.0270825736,
-0.0618129373,
-0.0147248767,
0.0304047428,
0.0568846203,
0.0038576988,
0.0348519348,
-0.0054593696,
-0.0208530705,
-0.0457134396,
-0.0154582141,
-0.0209268015,
-0.0033017099,
0.0171180479,
0.0552937537,
-0.0222873744,
0.0113865938,
-0.0079260608,
0.0375623964,
0.035414096,
0.0166090261,
-0.0520735458,
0.0283862073,
-0.0321279354,
-0.0226679835,
0.0358459726,
0.0287175048,
0.0767992809,
0.0019389888,
0.0296147522,
0.0097198309,
0.0033533389,
-0.0034750677,
-0.0138895558,
0.0225767363,
0.0044065481,
0.0161980428,
0.046102602,
-0.0275819544,
0.0164639279,
0.050818406,
0.0010504021,
0.0710255131,
0.0003650658,
-0.0057633929,
-0.0461571775,
0.0074143293,
-0.0361673906,
-0.0447926708,
0.0385569781,
-0.0124817938,
-0.0064856573,
0.0210999791,
0.0099593652,
0.0531241335,
0.0158423223,
-0.0687238649,
-0.0313241445,
0.052880004,
-0.0198044442,
0.0035369354,
0.0352203771,
0.032974422,
-0.0292148162,
-0.0135947252,
-0.0494520366,
-0.0122024463,
-0.0462806039,
0.004708298,
0.0411953628,
0.0029283089,
-0.0021701162,
0.0279657897,
-0.0585182793,
0.0189538691,
-0.0164430942,
0.0065927696,
0.0109887011,
-0.0122089526,
-0.0187767837,
0.0028740719,
-0.0254804771,
0.0874556229,
-0.0785578117,
-0.0133638224,
-0.0268577766,
-0.0742308348,
0.0639450252,
-0.0058042062,
-0.0347256772,
-0.0230084434,
0.0130889229,
0.0291758701,
0.00023392,
0.0305720288,
-0.0381569155,
-0.0043173498,
-0.0067798076,
-0.0544095077,
0.0001434882,
-0.0721668527,
0.0106911203,
0.0207774714,
0.0240275711,
-0.0245967284,
0.0231519677,
0.0266643539,
-0.0276355166,
0.0172653981,
0.0273484867,
0.0424523242,
0.0702191144,
0.0261949115,
-0.014699745,
0.0982087404,
0.0107820863,
0.0254482869,
0.0587005578,
-0.0344934836,
-0.0209246315,
0.0412644185,
-0.0296765752,
0.0185297336,
-0.0273960792,
0.0199061222,
0.0086292755,
-0.0297503974,
0.0145287253,
0.0538066626,
-0.0039742733,
-0.0099205989,
0.0483441055,
0.0561347455,
-0.0657502264,
0.0440595485,
0.02598227,
0.0167061221,
-0.0136717828,
0.0043288535,
-0.0376689285,
-0.0101467473,
-0.0335077867,
-0.0039935005,
-0.0434912927,
0.0844108239,
-0.0437563658,
-0.0413033552,
-0.0145328464,
-0.0039601242,
0.0560346916,
0.0569601245,
0.0322635919,
-0.0606015399,
0.0213428456,
0.0031315202,
0.0293709524,
-0.0607174933,
-0.0198747683,
-0.0282094292,
0.0334166102,
0.0508248061,
0.0153950201,
0.0016730101,
-0.0016059279,
-0.02558068,
0.0385330468,
0.0335636325,
0.0841964483,
-0.0165999737,
-0.0374857448,
-0.030478267,
-0.0361872725,
0.0283160433,
-0.017966412,
0.0205558687,
0.0236255042,
0.0687704757,
0.0003983634,
0.0068535246,
-0.0293174963,
-0.0199865755,
-0.0257779006,
0.005827276,
-0.016475752,
0.0045160796,
0.0367902629,
0.0611240305,
-0.0049541895,
-0.0269948021,
-0.0241020862,
-0.0063776583,
0.0012172494,
0.028550487,
-0.0446532741,
0.0145039754,
0.042171441,
-0.0326229632,
-0.0243568365,
0.0316183232,
-0.0082942862,
-0.005478573,
0.0096486891,
0.0197902471,
0.0489678644,
-0.0340482034,
-0.0262027513,
-0.0348880552,
-0.0229057614,
-0.0272599962,
0.0273182224,
-0.0387296788,
0.0201154761,
-0.0358113497,
-0.0245363992,
0.0487263463,
-0.0193539821,
-0.0546386465,
0.0891325995,
0.0082154209,
0.009955707,
0.0598688573,
0.0250434708,
-0.036429327,
-0.0136593152,
-0.1280078739,
-0.0415713564,
-0.012833057,
0.0210653804,
0.0173048638,
0.0270019025,
-0.0305394847,
-0.0074266298,
-0.0963331237,
-0.0189837199,
0.0253367051,
0.0646556541,
0.0058588334,
-0.0187958162,
0.024972925,
0.0206100401,
-0.0261659324,
-0.0124840466,
-0.0076920888,
-0.0198588427,
-0.0321492329,
-0.0073697576,
-0.0010484783,
-0.0871691853,
-0.0122921634,
-0.019315362,
-0.0732902959,
0.0044033388,
0.0306885988,
0.0608403087,
0.0434362292,
0.0178087801,
-0.0211879071,
0.0290094186,
0.0087494692,
-0.0417509638,
-0.0296495203,
-0.0064624352,
-0.0273185931,
0.0013395017,
-0.0934137851,
-0.0200323053,
0.0498359166,
0.000354244,
0.0056765699,
-0.0375893675,
0.0392714255,
-0.1009207964,
-0.045726452,
-0.037933778,
0.0136986701,
-0.0061123567,
0.0524894223,
0.0156022273,
-0.0347124487,
0.0406142771,
0.0225415062,
-0.0060839783,
-0.0640841797,
-0.0177737027,
-0.0282802787,
0.0203470606,
-0.0246234406,
0.0523592345,
0.0214225501,
-0.0401545577,
-0.0537693389,
-0.0201666523,
0.0350271352,
-0.0681424364,
0.043142397,
0.0174579266,
-0.0285908841,
-0.0200726055,
-0.0457385108,
-0.0276101772,
-0.0272400845,
-0.0166888069,
-0.0126631744,
0.0073182168,
0.003628144,
0.0173081327,
-0.0125206904,
0.041791629,
-0.009224684,
-0.0199573785,
0.016881844,
0.030423671,
-0.0181441251,
0.0487873554,
-0.0200942364,
0.0113824205,
-0.0410854071,
0.0273043048,
0.0089482451,
0.0797213688,
-0.0502636172,
0.0492356457,
0.0219780486,
0.0344834439,
0.0192441475,
-0.0365171582,
0.0235771146,
0.062299531,
-0.0156566538,
0.0422649346,
0.1006367728,
0.0096830064,
-0.0618656948,
-0.0186890829,
-0.0298045967,
0.0384699702,
0.0402727984,
0.0593607426,
-0.0993678942,
0.0431128591,
-0.0048933439,
0.002790842,
-0.0462057292,
0.0008925467,
-0.0101737026,
-0.094034262,
-0.0012953703,
0.0195475705,
-0.0452051423,
-0.0091670137,
0.0077622719,
-0.0416155197,
-0.0466759726,
0.0264157224,
-0.0347130485,
-0.0101480531,
-0.0068973619,
0.0110475775,
-0.0580105186,
-0.059737388,
0.0434011444,
-0.0220450629,
0.0516772084,
0.0638078004,
0.016753789,
-0.0293782391,
-0.0435515307,
-0.0001084001,
0.0249799695,
-0.0159615111,
-0.0058520497,
0.0101575628,
-0.0015860482,
-0.0165420566,
-0.0230201781,
-0.0107334023,
-0.0058030472,
0.0002415056,
0.0456515737,
0.0668796375,
0.0097755622,
-0.0305789728,
0.0049752877,
-0.0000281765,
0.0218243655,
0.0628266409,
-0.0052640075,
-0.0603342839,
0.0155146383,
-0.0534412451,
-0.0321170278,
0.0333702639,
-0.0434896387,
0.0247842744,
-0.0197513588,
-0.0593089946,
-0.0344028659,
-0.0600273609,
-0.0020754701,
0.0040255305,
0.0391332917,
-0.0268681478,
0.0012676395,
0.0115740597,
0.021909317,
0.0267418716,
-0.053811837,
0.007294104,
-0.0539255887,
-0.0150725683,
0.0168485921,
-0.0166662671,
0.0184856858,
-0.0392386541,
0.0006540143,
-0.0251011867,
0.0457889773,
0.0416560099,
0.0181824975,
0.0254244916,
0.0237343591,
-0.0252365749,
-0.0022572253,
0.0097045386,
0.0000058061,
-0.025470471,
0.0409083068,
0.0265447404,
-0.0034411128,
0.0232467093,
-0.0126078706,
0.0592579544,
0.0266149156,
0.0246849284,
-0.0355830938,
0.0219457652,
0.0157482699,
0.0520870462,
-0.0367568992,
-0.016173074,
-0.0231081694,
-0.0294920187,
-0.0316519439,
-0.0336329453,
-0.0188023858,
-0.0104354722,
-0.0044319439,
0.0108655766,
-0.0051275399,
0.0048642331,
-0.0365921482,
-0.0060196528,
-0.0225850102,
-0.0637778714,
0.0474403016,
0.0264167357,
0.038417358,
-0.0063243099,
0.0266595967,
-0.0375797041,
0.0243880358,
0.0411978401,
0.0265186336,
-0.017677499,
0.1153129786,
-0.0031557281,
-0.0094634611,
0.0212641377,
0.0114896931,
-0.0302477442,
-0.0458050705,
0.0022922258,
0.0242279749,
0.0527417958,
-0.0610070676,
0.0384784527,
0.0066976505,
-0.0174508505,
-0.0126679875,
0.0074424325,
0.0337517895,
-0.0389782861,
0.0025854576,
-0.0058553303,
-0.0455377363,
-0.0250926856,
0.0515904762,
-0.0278864447,
0.0109199854,
0.0266629029,
-0.0365862027,
-0.0224224702,
-0.0051906048,
0.058378879,
-0.0237973575,
-0.0487554334,
0.0266340934,
-0.0919945836,
-0.0639009103,
-0.0756456852,
-0.0155965025,
-0.0020791213,
-0.0350470953,
0.0029907823,
0.0799829438,
-0.0099531524,
0.0020481076,
-0.0537627041,
-0.0023899709,
-0.0429535583,
-0.0181090944,
-0.0028727208,
-6.534489342e-33,
0.0093040476,
0.0094803916,
-0.0019033686,
0.0074129971,
-0.0135775059,
0.0066194558,
-0.0023876519,
0.0137472171,
-0.0578641929,
0.0187704507,
-0.047520563,
-0.0084844762,
0.0122717889,
-0.0101735704,
0.0464263298,
-0.025007125,
0.0176577512,
-0.011214844,
-0.0246304646,
0.0347692817,
0.0299231783,
0.0098178368,
0.0736236945,
-0.0825100988,
0.0471303351,
0.0005298848,
0.0103442827,
0.0038144903,
0.0190579221,
0.0481302142,
-0.0277074557,
0.0580854528,
0.0276026651,
-0.0478769355,
-0.0211324915,
0.02030655,
-0.0274133645,
-0.0414027832,
0.0415797643,
0.0034094453,
0.0611209124,
-0.0483065024,
-0.0040672333,
-0.0429479927,
-0.036826916,
0.0272500012,
0.0315502696,
-0.0055751726,
0.018642148,
0.0000428246,
-0.0366112776,
0.0074280496,
0.0063719195,
0.0640351027,
0.0137411663,
0.0782604888,
-0.0162173565,
-0.003688578,
-0.0016722612,
0.026776012,
0.0367742032,
0.0176162757,
0.0714501441,
-0.0003587031,
-0.0028560981,
0.0307697002,
0.0008985718,
0.0807877779,
0.0029884572,
-0.0252655782,
0.014438672,
-0.0044728909,
0.0431225821,
0.0795842409,
0.0037160162,
-0.0480719134,
-0.0247051511,
0.0051470143,
0.0625750944,
-0.0325724036,
0.0281033721,
-0.0173693895,
-0.0615612864,
-0.0365874693,
0.0110661136,
0.0016678596,
-0.028824117,
-0.0656810105,
0.0439187698,
-0.0336408056,
-0.0297048464,
-0.010115697,
0.0582717396,
-0.0361723974,
-0.054689154,
0.0210182667,
0.0272646118,
-0.017456321,
0.0222258437,
0.021344481,
-0.0543875359,
-0.0102753472,
-0.0519040823,
-0.0034283269,
-0.0139880273,
0.024003325,
-0.0020164065,
0.0029104953,
-0.0629315823,
-0.0111736534,
-0.0165994391,
0.0083353296,
0.0040341201,
0.0040141111,
0.0344424322,
-0.0160738472,
0.0223220345,
0.0048691505,
0.0659391209,
-0.0228250213,
-0.0559898391,
-0.0737615451,
-0.0190268215,
0.0272493437,
-0.0378453135,
-0.0104843602,
-0.0261309817,
0.0423040316,
0.0494153239,
0.0007060791,
-0.0327821188,
-0.0490704626,
2.848e-7,
0.0104621509,
0.0292726494,
-0.0442006327,
0.0200320892,
-0.0105139744,
0.0332985744,
-0.0068217064,
0.0239646807,
0.0477764234,
0.0061153146,
0.0365917534,
-0.0228286888,
0.060123086,
0.0703307241,
-0.1013451442,
-0.029342914,
-0.0522868149,
0.0205142386,
-0.0554433838,
0.0326729268,
0.0070476546,
0.0671948716,
0.0285179168,
-0.0112116672,
-0.0537984446,
0.0276999678,
0.0188209247,
-0.0899743363,
-0.0259737168,
-0.0110917157,
0.0083419112,
-0.0094533758,
0.0327551365,
0.0132143479,
-0.0082859928,
-0.0191571619,
0.031576287,
0.0535313115,
0.0061472333,
0.0435495973,
-0.0010560662,
-0.0079048146,
0.0031848333,
-0.1122321263,
0.053484194,
-0.0142048541,
-0.0496678799,
-0.0336972252,
0.0226809438,
-0.0615788177,
0.0495330095,
-0.0250992347,
-0.0260839052,
0.0180124585,
0.0054908125,
0.0033894468,
0.0129237743,
-0.0210612826,
0.0004878876,
-0.0146787437,
0.0029470073,
-0.0809940547,
-0.0069455151,
0.0300095864,
-0.0416963398,
0.0189091861,
0.0233429074,
2.626731437e-34,
0.0285695512,
-0.004368328,
0.0213295612,
0.028913999,
0.0497144237,
0.0311918091,
0.0612670816,
-0.0201003626,
-0.0007886665,
-0.0222132634,
-0.0164826456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12477v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12477v2 | Exploring In-Context Learning of Textless Speech Language Model for Speech Classification Tasks | 2023-10-19T05:31:45 | 2024-06-15T14:13:54 | Ming-Hao Hsu, Kai-Wei Chang, Shang-Wen Li, Hung-yi Lee | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | Ever since the development of GPT-3 in the natural language processing (NLP)
field, in-context learning (ICL) has played an essential role in utilizing
large language models (LLMs). By presenting the LM utterance-label
demonstrations at the input, the LM can accomplish few-shot learning without
relying on gradient descent or requiring explicit modification of its
parameters. This enables the LM to perform various downstream tasks in a
black-box manner. Despite the success of ICL in NLP, little work is exploring
the possibility of ICL in speech processing. This study is the first work
exploring ICL for speech classification tasks with textless speech LM. We first
show that the current speech LM lacks the ICL capability. We then perform
warmup training on the speech LM, equipping the LM with demonstration learning
capability. This paper explores and proposes the first speech LM capable of
performing unseen classification tasks in an ICL manner. | [
-0.0246963818,
0.00804157,
0.0389249362,
0.0648026168,
-0.0541302152,
0.0249005388,
0.0561453477,
0.0312778056,
-0.0053662141,
-0.084274143,
-0.0589891858,
-0.0344704427,
0.024311984,
-0.0277413633,
0.0173812248,
-0.0415303819,
0.0037364666,
-0.0252307411,
0.0033927683,
0.009986707,
0.0044930573,
0.0082307495,
-0.0479717441,
0.00102969,
-0.018465573,
-0.0065789423,
-0.0488330163,
0.0210929159,
-0.0112587921,
-0.0530233234,
-0.0135479579,
0.0234240033,
0.0551413484,
0.0447907187,
0.0000018476,
-0.0560105816,
0.000946367,
0.0115557956,
-0.0609310456,
-0.0059987223,
0.061388392,
0.0323020928,
-0.0340779983,
0.0482624359,
-0.0408817492,
-0.0438660234,
0.0320797712,
0.0839983225,
0.0162182916,
0.1095070168,
-0.0046701371,
-0.026773056,
0.0291449297,
-0.022033345,
0.0533530116,
-0.0305161905,
0.0170050841,
-0.0733080953,
0.0002620171,
0.0036953103,
-0.016295122,
0.048322089,
0.0048448737,
0.0350315459,
-0.0249385759,
0.057824485,
-0.0401249044,
-0.0152677717,
-0.0270652846,
0.0364102386,
-0.0366247557,
-0.0382974967,
0.008571378,
-0.0234317835,
-0.0077046598,
-0.0640808418,
-0.0385076664,
0.0244039278,
0.0412115306,
0.0326954238,
0.0038153569,
0.0182767231,
0.0323353633,
0.0020540673,
-0.0280035473,
0.0666439682,
-0.0297342166,
-0.0554852746,
0.010398455,
-0.034856122,
-0.0249226186,
-0.03872177,
-0.0682090223,
0.0494592786,
-0.0155338412,
0.0156103875,
-0.020894384,
-0.0201310199,
0.0050395695,
-0.0483044907,
0.0131794615,
0.0268174503,
0.0104842177,
0.0463737659,
-0.0394133106,
0.0374878049,
0.0168050248,
0.0148687018,
-0.0221504699,
0.0019152971,
-0.0623752028,
-0.008867369,
-0.0561990701,
0.0376124457,
-0.0220578369,
-0.0033035045,
-0.0197596122,
0.0255990624,
0.0011256757,
-0.0133089321,
0.007164455,
-0.0101106856,
-0.0309282299,
-0.0104711922,
0.0009126271,
0.0116690248,
0.0314041935,
0.017761495,
-0.039299719,
-0.0801742449,
-0.0086007202,
0.0395021923,
0.0444349758,
0.0035637175,
0.0270031746,
0.0581012033,
-0.0046678325,
-0.09552221,
-0.048265066,
0.031913843,
0.0336933248,
-0.0743987113,
-0.0294471998,
-0.0626262873,
-0.0230619982,
0.008447146,
0.0316198729,
-0.0230155159,
0.0268027168,
0.0414012633,
0.0147458613,
0.082556814,
-0.0021886076,
0.0033672175,
0.0401536077,
-0.016687341,
0.0068086875,
0.0756636783,
0.0241350941,
-0.0312715247,
0.0144794006,
0.0145397661,
0.0300800577,
0.0742899105,
0.0265730023,
0.0186289903,
-0.0689846128,
-0.0076711881,
0.0259506516,
0.0101163751,
-0.0025916367,
0.0249298476,
-0.0237161648,
0.0328167118,
0.0598226152,
0.0779507905,
0.0338186435,
-0.0164939296,
0.0169886909,
0.047743462,
0.0024879044,
-0.0298961699,
-0.032157205,
-0.0285040755,
-0.032589864,
0.0149150277,
0.0302082133,
-0.0204761345,
-0.0559379756,
-0.0111151803,
-0.0124925002,
-0.0546880476,
0.0093051651,
0.0064450097,
0.0602685288,
0.03200268,
-0.0603435524,
0.0076078265,
0.0278633907,
-0.0121565554,
-0.0335888602,
-0.0532364957,
0.0086586997,
0.0006334195,
0.0270073451,
-0.0324690826,
0.0024778231,
-0.0564344265,
0.0221875943,
0.0793772191,
-0.0112440614,
-0.0049087158,
0.0109080859,
-0.0506380834,
0.0068125678,
0.0460151695,
0.0205605291,
-0.0013664733,
0.023676686,
0.0215646643,
0.0137395803,
-0.005723726,
0.0034426532,
0.0034195753,
-0.0133232167,
-0.0901430324,
0.0393801667,
0.0096818395,
0.0696651042,
0.0125606759,
-0.0343939625,
-0.0136303473,
0.0419259109,
-0.0213950258,
-0.0174107458,
-0.0094198566,
-0.0674051046,
-0.0749670267,
0.0203839745,
0.0222423766,
0.0262311157,
0.0016649162,
-0.0132076256,
-0.0595647469,
-0.0347279906,
-0.0069315266,
0.0742764995,
-0.0459774174,
0.0276425947,
0.0022284102,
0.0048437836,
-0.031794358,
0.0567312613,
0.0190037917,
0.0110870264,
0.0421812497,
0.0658561066,
0.006597104,
-0.0376349054,
-0.0595364571,
0.0012346652,
-0.0124362065,
0.0286445543,
-0.0100940289,
0.0354501158,
-0.0163871013,
0.014547688,
-0.1214924306,
0.0281215496,
-0.0434657857,
0.0176652558,
0.0249943044,
0.0331847854,
-0.0064516696,
-0.0461189076,
-0.0298977997,
-0.0255365409,
0.0105384942,
-0.0109922271,
0.0180975553,
0.012264003,
-0.0291418321,
0.0254272278,
0.0175316148,
0.0099769374,
0.05366778,
-0.0272522699,
-0.0063207601,
-0.0263027512,
0.0482935384,
0.0339732058,
0.0542528406,
0.0004292118,
0.0184466224,
0.0096829068,
-0.0274470262,
0.0077420697,
0.0423092134,
0.0241468735,
0.0211584419,
-0.0003048319,
0.012659776,
-0.0573231801,
0.023332186,
0.0080386028,
0.0114804991,
-0.0252008159,
0.0519334264,
-0.0164607055,
0.0604700111,
-0.0059137414,
0.0378727727,
-0.0109175965,
-0.0068656588,
-0.0149651878,
-0.0129573746,
-0.0616328344,
0.0114035755,
-0.0826127604,
-0.0272005051,
0.0262585059,
-0.0626889244,
-0.000780054,
-0.0671762973,
-0.0310302172,
-0.0628297105,
-0.0536376536,
-0.0319508351,
0.0429080464,
-0.0194220003,
-0.0017111305,
0.0222892519,
-0.0453608073,
0.0025801139,
-0.0145867532,
-0.0236143637,
-0.0359570161,
0.0307226237,
-0.0134357279,
0.0359326415,
-0.0328139029,
-0.0052988785,
-0.0518907681,
-0.0215778984,
-0.0447854809,
0.0293920431,
-0.0350686125,
-0.0016293859,
-0.0183362924,
0.0290590804,
0.0476169474,
0.0735874102,
-0.0101333475,
0.0109685967,
-0.0345530733,
0.0454401076,
-0.0044270176,
0.0082035372,
-0.0548227802,
0.0015545775,
0.0237692688,
0.0108501203,
0.0983303711,
-0.0117148114,
-0.0311960336,
-0.0140986843,
-0.0040089139,
-0.0281004962,
-0.0240154415,
0.0729621202,
-0.0087517705,
-0.0742327645,
0.0185222328,
0.1170104593,
0.0178545732,
-0.0846179798,
-0.0313154235,
0.0345378481,
-0.0118490849,
0.0307228211,
0.0008521053,
-0.0595583133,
-0.058576569,
0.0142479837,
-0.006835158,
-0.0314926244,
0.0044126022,
-0.0452412739,
-0.1185231805,
0.007733779,
0.0188137926,
-0.0587446131,
-0.0297367647,
-0.0360095985,
-0.0041897795,
-0.0009344805,
0.0082015935,
0.0194960292,
-0.0310815237,
-0.0317378342,
0.0308442209,
-0.0210779253,
-0.0821835548,
0.0158063769,
-0.0195907895,
0.0583203211,
0.0504387356,
-0.0000359947,
-0.0289296582,
-0.0052239518,
0.0611948557,
-0.0204670653,
0.0129000023,
-0.0391056277,
0.0221194681,
-0.0181405842,
-0.0125100343,
0.0178987272,
0.0171373915,
-0.0365861282,
0.0070129926,
0.0101020141,
0.0792402849,
-0.0129399551,
0.0059758914,
0.0200896971,
-0.0427332036,
0.0290967375,
0.0478560887,
-0.0013941664,
-0.0543487035,
-0.0496526919,
-0.0099522462,
-0.014035129,
0.0101898611,
-0.0303996913,
-0.0126615735,
0.0127829872,
-0.0233197305,
-0.0087623512,
-0.0084283743,
0.0249422379,
0.076004602,
-0.0050835838,
0.0578187294,
0.0048710909,
0.035374213,
-0.0335602127,
0.0013827048,
-0.0514014438,
0.0408486873,
-0.07412453,
-0.0021968007,
0.074540846,
-0.0410557985,
0.0010820277,
-0.0007490719,
-0.0608815588,
-0.0467761457,
-0.0246883072,
-0.0157090388,
0.0185282864,
0.0650712252,
-0.0191546548,
-0.028087493,
0.1381150335,
0.0641166642,
-0.0046134191,
0.0371059254,
0.0501247719,
0.0311098173,
-0.0223573558,
0.0196578111,
-0.0189235322,
0.0053708185,
0.009378897,
-0.0112615488,
-0.0586097874,
0.019198576,
0.0143361744,
-0.0110753262,
0.0647033229,
0.003724436,
-0.0022440956,
-0.0036133465,
0.0328530632,
0.0305353086,
0.0034536445,
-0.0346104167,
0.0126890512,
-0.0102282381,
-0.0053732647,
-0.0237193815,
-0.0171852782,
-0.0313182808,
0.0154121965,
0.0173233338,
0.0302694384,
0.017687697,
-0.0154900094,
0.0236363802,
-0.0000885811,
-0.0161988214,
-0.0083616879,
0.0193186998,
0.0170636661,
-0.0192847084,
0.0641950667,
0.0015610848,
-0.0034882626,
-0.0229189321,
0.0256421585,
-0.0214512106,
0.0239655077,
-0.075755313,
0.0275616683,
0.0564509779,
0.0155664748,
0.0094631128,
-0.0171765722,
0.0101515288,
-0.035549663,
0.0156765394,
-0.0418345891,
-0.0309087932,
0.0215201117,
0.0334696136,
-0.0087685464,
0.0555366017,
0.0628294125,
0.0560397469,
0.0221139435,
0.0285157822,
0.0565362945,
-0.0491447635,
0.0187489316,
0.0494690239,
0.0271520782,
0.020504972,
0.0439686403,
-0.0148846311,
-0.0529575311,
0.0347826444,
-0.0408914983,
0.0056368066,
-0.0691361874,
0.0335156284,
0.0036448035,
-0.0145650944,
0.0066716466,
-0.0035451716,
-0.0366498642,
0.0366133302,
-0.0087797819,
-0.0214491952,
-6.172906545e-33,
-0.0160455499,
-0.0425325632,
0.0194300469,
0.0272357408,
-0.0012085747,
0.0200417135,
-0.0060008266,
0.0173563641,
0.0137587758,
-0.0170882102,
-0.0398761816,
-0.0006341296,
0.0171492081,
0.0482445285,
-0.0131294737,
-0.0218609646,
0.0597911626,
-0.0470958911,
0.0248304494,
0.0374132209,
0.0135897826,
0.040417362,
0.0423426069,
-0.0564425252,
0.0027708237,
-0.0321842022,
-0.0279089678,
0.0227221269,
-0.0060569169,
0.0207860991,
-0.0271699429,
0.0200079754,
0.0405179895,
-0.0703935847,
-0.0173215587,
0.0360800922,
-0.049313236,
0.0051744594,
-0.0186611433,
0.0326339751,
-0.0169546604,
0.0033560644,
0.020007927,
0.0069149444,
-0.0232131984,
0.0094219698,
0.0082861092,
0.0072516329,
-0.0347667448,
-0.0322059207,
0.0101374667,
0.0557955056,
0.0263213012,
-0.0299180355,
0.0565018207,
-0.0082614226,
-0.0223040469,
-0.0204576738,
-0.0675576404,
0.0002409827,
0.022847876,
0.0115756998,
0.0064500868,
0.0398692414,
0.005320739,
0.0308441613,
-0.0018837894,
-0.0334135517,
0.0237832591,
-0.0344696194,
0.0335643664,
0.0088090859,
-0.0030514698,
0.0152475443,
0.0594245866,
0.0123801772,
-0.050628949,
-0.0328807272,
0.0353042334,
-0.0007455354,
0.0596187748,
0.0122262323,
-0.0569935851,
-0.0163775776,
-0.0276940204,
-0.044757504,
-0.0434954241,
-0.0126745896,
0.0591255948,
0.0517769717,
-0.008271181,
-0.0060936944,
0.0562636256,
-0.0271545574,
-0.0088065546,
0.0368309282,
0.0087465523,
0.0306286961,
0.0102962758,
-0.0191024281,
-0.0728918836,
-0.0395439751,
0.006793384,
0.0330118276,
0.0051939506,
-0.0138244415,
0.0136558646,
0.0734171122,
-0.0752400011,
-0.0170016009,
-0.0020456025,
0.0204686262,
-0.0068059675,
0.0289239306,
0.0199624095,
0.0028823516,
-0.0044005197,
0.0793868601,
-0.0172410663,
-0.0576615781,
0.0045755338,
-0.0082799131,
-0.0476122275,
0.0008821535,
-0.0368386991,
0.0005699171,
-0.006469728,
0.0319421999,
0.0469818711,
-0.0201991722,
0.0149351303,
0.023926001,
2.717e-7,
-0.0300271157,
0.0399092175,
-0.0076901964,
-0.0101821898,
0.0524142049,
0.0608341992,
-0.0389307216,
0.0094745308,
0.003703533,
0.0109482827,
-0.0021334914,
-0.0048741167,
0.0386186279,
0.0016396747,
-0.1360997558,
-0.0024324085,
-0.0464601479,
0.024477629,
-0.037162926,
0.0263043419,
0.0125737293,
0.102080673,
-0.0121265417,
-0.0207108352,
0.0034053084,
-0.0300572477,
0.0367021449,
0.0066490141,
0.0273306202,
-0.030850336,
-0.0094459681,
0.0292946436,
0.0007229078,
0.017426176,
-0.0144215766,
0.052731853,
-0.0256135669,
0.0580670834,
-0.0103058647,
-0.0431058966,
0.0368707627,
0.0239182618,
-0.0192029849,
0.0119901672,
0.0896940976,
-0.0456454195,
-0.0094423005,
-0.0167869702,
0.0042657782,
-0.0316824354,
0.0036200217,
0.0009489933,
-0.0087505924,
0.0005436485,
0.0113609815,
-0.039533861,
-0.05228642,
-0.0670540035,
-0.0136966212,
-0.0035296457,
-0.0520067438,
-0.0318701863,
-0.0536334142,
0.0455877148,
0.0167141464,
-0.038164217,
0.0247722771,
2.354870588e-34,
0.0138522191,
-0.034432698,
0.0041643204,
0.0389616415,
-0.0311111659,
-0.0091519328,
0.0034356876,
0.0177296959,
0.0573951676,
-0.0795649216,
-0.0070268037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12467v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12467v2 | Contrastive Learning for Inference in Dialogue | 2023-10-19T04:49:36 | 2023-11-13T04:18:58 | Etsuko Ishii, Yan Xu, Bryan Wilie, Ziwei Ji, Holy Lovenia, Willy Chung, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Inference, especially those derived from inductive processes, is a crucial
component in our conversation to complement the information implicitly or
explicitly conveyed by a speaker. While recent large language models show
remarkable advances in inference tasks, their performance in inductive
reasoning, where not all information is present in the context, is far behind
deductive reasoning. In this paper, we analyze the behavior of the models based
on the task difficulty defined by the semantic information gap -- which
distinguishes inductive and deductive reasoning (Johnson-Laird, 1988, 1993).
Our analysis reveals that the disparity in information between dialogue
contexts and desired inferences poses a significant challenge to the inductive
inference process. To mitigate this information gap, we investigate a
contrastive learning approach by feeding negative samples. Our experiments
suggest negative samples help models understand what is wrong and improve their
inference generations. | [
0.0536012501,
0.057528995,
-0.0226026438,
0.0331099853,
-0.0840815157,
0.0301834624,
-0.0198412966,
-0.0221895222,
0.0056047081,
-0.0222638343,
-0.0047660726,
-0.0236463342,
0.0399045497,
-0.0223961491,
0.0177816022,
-0.0624674857,
0.0324457176,
-0.0395544954,
0.0265935119,
-0.0397033058,
-0.019842552,
-0.0037124821,
-0.035125792,
0.0071225967,
0.013211038,
-0.00308006,
-0.0219137557,
0.0010899008,
0.0119103268,
-0.0351914167,
0.0113528324,
0.0323581621,
0.0060591521,
0.0334327333,
0.000001711,
-0.0611874126,
0.0403269306,
-0.0390933715,
-0.0781456083,
-0.049565848,
0.0107696103,
-0.0070238933,
0.001879087,
0.0179671906,
-0.0444656722,
-0.0311950222,
0.0585705042,
0.0862633735,
0.0315093882,
0.0414650068,
0.0001472749,
-0.0666922703,
-0.0070909034,
-0.0134962667,
-0.0038389724,
-0.0386691205,
0.0166315138,
0.0401972719,
0.0133807268,
-0.0015361585,
-0.0032332621,
0.0146921724,
0.0502888002,
0.017317906,
-0.0388467386,
0.0544767119,
-0.0342233963,
-0.0317823701,
-0.0216077548,
0.0819067284,
0.0379622392,
-0.0136633469,
-0.0585378259,
-0.0253660437,
0.0310089979,
0.0066953069,
-0.0253901165,
0.0173468888,
-0.0420259163,
0.0194062963,
0.0729979351,
0.0242014844,
0.0123163797,
0.0162521563,
-0.0297257081,
0.0539373793,
0.0019182557,
-0.0471077971,
0.0342957079,
0.0181713346,
-0.0525455624,
-0.0285591856,
-0.0181918535,
-0.0005253688,
-0.0548010543,
0.0300532728,
0.0039197551,
-0.0128956763,
0.0267341714,
-0.0235464089,
-0.0384459719,
0.038978558,
0.0053232592,
0.077106148,
0.0069184303,
-0.0057218606,
-0.03142526,
-0.0141607793,
-0.0158913787,
-0.0214690659,
-0.0215944722,
0.0067757675,
-0.042225536,
0.0261867866,
-0.0155735081,
0.0083723245,
0.0063655768,
0.0378351584,
-0.0289993808,
0.0095490217,
0.0005086736,
0.0025945813,
-0.0612691231,
-0.0250429139,
-0.0477798171,
0.0333848707,
-0.0466446765,
0.0422809944,
0.0105902636,
-0.0698223263,
-0.0416320525,
-0.0041734977,
0.0040698042,
-0.0222091544,
-0.0158057455,
0.07489793,
0.0039907331,
-0.010710963,
-0.0546054542,
0.0025301336,
-0.0105856042,
-0.0797108561,
-0.0212772544,
-0.0331234895,
0.0047383765,
0.0291284267,
-0.0176952928,
-0.0458148159,
0.0193964057,
-0.0036777672,
-0.0524758361,
0.0978831351,
0.0013842827,
-0.0023343023,
0.0303752813,
0.0044170395,
-0.0690305382,
0.0755129382,
-0.0021855198,
-0.0384452678,
-0.0052788323,
0.0333083011,
0.0197063647,
-0.0047228928,
0.0427663997,
0.0016281789,
-0.0061057205,
-0.0008262243,
-0.0167694241,
0.0105052311,
0.0144554824,
0.0572023131,
-0.0496379659,
-0.0622696169,
0.0634132996,
0.0395087041,
-0.0109296702,
0.0007591074,
0.0321531184,
0.0394269675,
-0.0223649368,
0.0412405916,
-0.0538604371,
0.0125501389,
-0.0166016575,
0.0181885865,
0.0416038446,
-0.0013310377,
-0.0307411682,
-0.0522635579,
-0.0058894823,
-0.0145862401,
0.0534787886,
0.00579052,
0.0784520283,
0.059262652,
-0.0644918978,
0.0103467191,
0.0575560033,
-0.0286636967,
-0.0585446842,
-0.0476111434,
0.0780128613,
0.0279156491,
0.0186605509,
-0.0077318102,
-0.034805309,
-0.0160170961,
-0.0028575407,
0.0623687617,
0.0620685183,
-0.0248241872,
0.0425451063,
-0.0223163757,
-0.0303557552,
-0.0056605041,
0.0123832645,
0.0265359972,
0.005564515,
-0.0202556886,
0.0026586,
0.0063476251,
0.0147150913,
0.0156983491,
-0.0475988686,
-0.0014069391,
0.0271800347,
0.0138295097,
0.0259671509,
-0.0239420421,
0.0088318428,
-0.0143290227,
0.0056274664,
-0.0124485139,
-0.0083477311,
0.0452285223,
-0.0594837964,
-0.1217047572,
0.0133071626,
-0.0429768525,
0.014051157,
-0.0057445392,
-0.0488814078,
-0.0295557138,
0.0730773434,
-0.04062251,
0.0553371757,
-0.0101629812,
0.0065142871,
0.0323797576,
0.0022015078,
-0.0136204548,
0.0979255065,
-0.0219252575,
0.00578416,
0.028064372,
0.0609527566,
-0.0030318038,
-0.0769131705,
0.0027777089,
-0.0068844506,
0.0182035938,
-0.0340909585,
0.0235779826,
-0.0287914444,
-0.0569726601,
-0.0022516376,
-0.0614419691,
-0.0204664283,
-0.0119611751,
0.0157675445,
0.021122871,
0.0063286615,
0.0251204148,
-0.0260627512,
-0.0067140139,
-0.0231989138,
0.0143447611,
0.022793889,
0.0408326946,
0.0181058124,
-0.0076733227,
-0.0266196597,
0.0058315666,
-0.0055964231,
0.0535639711,
0.0010912974,
-0.0108810933,
-0.0504634045,
0.0405045785,
-0.0188981164,
0.0508343093,
-0.0186298527,
-0.0270263366,
0.0162870083,
0.0096585443,
0.0178775955,
0.0864980146,
0.0221391302,
-0.0076811719,
-0.0127874697,
-0.0334447622,
-0.0531396493,
0.0339400694,
-0.0345524065,
0.037695013,
-0.0124184201,
-0.0359625779,
-0.0643008128,
0.095212765,
0.0009673538,
0.0035937803,
-0.0448922254,
0.0464427397,
0.0257014837,
-0.0092703635,
0.026232833,
-0.0203790423,
0.0022270435,
0.0415816605,
-0.0515020564,
-0.0327500328,
0.1049618199,
-0.0020195823,
-0.0125726052,
-0.0388600789,
0.0008869497,
0.006923636,
0.0423600376,
-0.0128013333,
-0.0308828261,
0.0484085493,
-0.0082181646,
-0.0488480963,
-0.0157617163,
0.0552436933,
-0.011289835,
0.0374077223,
-0.0456586033,
0.0094657876,
0.0019608568,
-0.048771441,
-0.0932407677,
-0.0443801768,
-0.0360198803,
0.0177199636,
0.0001730719,
0.0014970319,
-0.0044619259,
0.0296620019,
-0.0139851738,
0.0158135667,
0.011349706,
-0.0139305666,
-0.0094816759,
0.0110616423,
-0.0095601194,
0.0193044543,
0.023265576,
-0.0111370562,
0.0619103052,
0.0246042479,
0.0221568421,
0.0191201326,
-0.051698532,
0.0066218846,
0.0014246927,
0.0177828949,
-0.0436131358,
0.0120240794,
0.0208760966,
-0.0378288291,
-0.0120274751,
0.0994228646,
0.0067536184,
-0.025631465,
0.0012780474,
-0.0183309652,
0.0338332355,
0.0155263916,
-0.0031855847,
-0.0898359343,
-0.0456803367,
0.0340453051,
-0.0066302787,
-0.0308001284,
-0.0311612114,
-0.0113701029,
-0.1226469278,
0.0229111481,
0.0182571113,
-0.0333426408,
-0.0053807702,
-0.0468262173,
0.0262497254,
-0.0396097638,
-0.0003357123,
0.0219197646,
0.0251730401,
-0.0044428562,
0.0006847022,
0.0199632794,
-0.0293119084,
-0.0117566632,
-0.0031197462,
0.061087437,
0.0214697886,
0.0186062399,
0.0346471556,
-0.033555761,
0.0225817058,
-0.0430129208,
-0.0320455246,
-0.0400247984,
0.067477718,
0.008944477,
0.0061205211,
-0.0123567274,
0.0414274,
-0.0234459992,
-0.0315903537,
0.0027842768,
0.0291882083,
-0.0360377654,
0.0098301107,
0.0130071091,
0.0657368377,
0.0438676327,
0.0903244242,
0.0251431912,
0.0055710142,
-0.0228426848,
-0.0196652189,
-0.0000629202,
-0.0012087474,
0.0338789038,
0.0030534344,
0.0219292454,
-0.024578765,
-0.0532434955,
-0.0458292067,
-0.017470954,
0.0392671339,
-0.0115699628,
-0.0021083625,
-0.009231858,
0.0062379735,
-0.0125889648,
0.0030651682,
-0.0227066316,
0.0049309251,
0.0094314832,
-0.0372238569,
0.0354330204,
-0.0501835234,
-0.0384738445,
0.0331568792,
-0.081914939,
-0.080578126,
-0.0228633024,
0.0560239665,
0.025688719,
0.0736189336,
-0.0283471383,
-0.0070515904,
0.0095704803,
0.0126875518,
-0.0033599741,
-0.0232856888,
0.0594661087,
0.0387129001,
0.0353096239,
0.0517087393,
-0.0150433639,
0.0216019209,
0.0505692065,
0.0400167108,
-0.0709237605,
-0.0488671027,
0.0385229178,
-0.0366346352,
0.0423577987,
0.0181869864,
-0.0058877636,
-0.0156809688,
0.0367501266,
-0.0132090217,
-0.0353761241,
-0.0530532971,
0.0181881096,
-0.0044633783,
0.012247378,
-0.0009833045,
-0.0404043347,
-0.0266235583,
0.0479779057,
-0.0031887628,
-0.0345119983,
0.0957867801,
-0.0009010663,
-0.0080266334,
-0.0245690756,
-0.0354986079,
-0.0026442623,
0.0299329404,
0.053402584,
0.0171880275,
0.103450641,
0.0547814853,
-0.0190480929,
-0.0216335543,
-0.0306110494,
-0.0692550763,
-0.0050629871,
-0.0056070564,
0.0097279269,
0.0161629934,
0.007688134,
0.0153731061,
-0.0178635865,
0.0265897736,
0.0149460863,
0.0514255576,
-0.0105617754,
-0.0263216011,
0.0558636077,
0.0176845081,
-0.009183513,
0.0607794039,
0.0631858706,
-0.0444879495,
0.0573806763,
-0.0241606738,
0.0176727325,
-0.0397334546,
-0.0328356996,
-0.0122664552,
0.043030329,
0.0223513599,
0.0522664301,
-0.0365881361,
-0.0754342601,
-0.0270666014,
0.0360698625,
0.0159040485,
0.0085854456,
0.0197281893,
0.0499288999,
-0.0021568246,
-0.0708408654,
-0.0123355323,
0.0004438066,
-0.013430031,
0.0074894107,
-0.0732393041,
-6.192064164e-33,
-0.0420558378,
-0.0063372133,
0.0163906515,
0.0298791248,
-0.0187283736,
-0.04317059,
-0.0400977582,
-0.0183502268,
-0.0298004616,
0.0502845906,
-0.0035853358,
0.033437103,
0.0181421302,
0.0139481258,
-0.0132517284,
-0.050720457,
0.0507899299,
0.0238425508,
-0.0267226808,
0.008991695,
0.0017198126,
0.0109430691,
0.0414007418,
-0.0819421709,
0.0085499827,
-0.0255927499,
0.0245642271,
0.0800565109,
-0.0196812209,
0.025292173,
-0.0105298003,
0.0116122747,
0.0193899386,
-0.0532490723,
0.012166921,
-0.0012381397,
-0.0758897811,
-0.0344049521,
0.0604301244,
0.002617009,
-0.0461321548,
-0.0198372994,
0.0265456028,
0.0095283994,
0.0226243176,
-0.0051958319,
-0.0002252631,
-0.0364620984,
0.0139405131,
0.0479524247,
-0.0517793112,
0.023066666,
-0.0171616822,
-0.0586878471,
0.0102237482,
0.0556818098,
-0.0155024547,
-0.0455302522,
-0.0181884728,
0.0361660123,
0.0287972949,
-0.0112572964,
0.0405312814,
0.0182927549,
0.0204274841,
0.0293933228,
0.0277778544,
0.0007027229,
0.0312972069,
-0.0755683407,
-0.0307386946,
0.0283989739,
-0.0179255903,
0.0503951013,
0.0236400329,
0.0241136681,
-0.0415441431,
-0.0345551185,
0.0465238281,
0.0327033103,
0.0128903119,
-0.0010156013,
-0.0474845022,
-0.0314560235,
-0.0389967225,
-0.0586133115,
-0.0240596645,
-0.023333285,
-0.0017960286,
0.0313594379,
-0.0154683543,
-0.0039282381,
0.0267499704,
-0.044500377,
-0.0022751405,
0.0282408893,
-0.0096871508,
-0.0369227901,
-0.011619783,
0.0021682864,
-0.0670848787,
-0.0198452938,
0.0210859999,
0.0483534932,
-0.0023021628,
0.0081071863,
0.0271116793,
-0.0203509852,
-0.0354111455,
-0.0164391752,
-0.0312258732,
0.018342888,
-0.0264215674,
0.0143910171,
0.0578964129,
0.0401461422,
-0.0280440189,
0.0441040061,
0.0247708112,
-0.0206740946,
-0.0422751643,
-0.0163491294,
-0.0103037274,
0.005853829,
-0.0434716716,
-0.0383241512,
-0.0006340523,
0.0060615842,
-0.0105122682,
-0.0463610701,
-0.0444114767,
0.0189932585,
2.512e-7,
-0.011144354,
0.020320978,
0.0313795209,
0.0379284248,
0.0264757648,
0.0405860059,
-0.0011873849,
-0.0347884111,
0.0486130342,
-0.0190193895,
0.0166676268,
0.0224897899,
0.0578437261,
0.043543864,
-0.0579242446,
-0.0184118487,
-0.075866729,
-0.0309392139,
-0.0021870837,
-0.0254732911,
0.0773072168,
0.0955500528,
0.050821051,
-0.0100815119,
0.0150517328,
-0.0290100351,
0.0538169034,
-0.0058705634,
0.0004000786,
-0.0169084389,
0.0412314832,
0.0006766275,
-0.0034513972,
0.0989306122,
0.036764808,
0.0302876998,
-0.0645097792,
0.006044453,
-0.0037790735,
-0.0488425568,
-0.0277420245,
0.0103170611,
0.0218749121,
-0.0163078588,
0.0611488372,
-0.0963825583,
-0.0331247523,
-0.0186725222,
-0.0278841332,
-0.0295666922,
0.00513385,
-0.013887641,
-0.0289146416,
0.0023494954,
0.0195570365,
-0.005630746,
-0.0266174916,
-0.0705343038,
0.0003016598,
0.01682432,
-0.0291254725,
-0.0483109131,
0.0324204713,
-0.0201290827,
0.0376753733,
-0.0212226119,
0.0376868658,
1.725115446e-34,
0.0470379815,
-0.0045435578,
0.0096680513,
0.0666278601,
0.0299338568,
-0.0172676686,
-0.0038155001,
-0.004907791,
0.0718196258,
-0.0566663332,
-0.0089526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12462v1 | Unmasking Transformers: A Theoretical Approach to Data Recovery via Attention Weights | 2023-10-19T04:41:01 | 2023-10-19T04:41:01 | Yichuan Deng, Zhao Song, Shenghao Xie, Chiwun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | In the realm of deep learning, transformers have emerged as a dominant
architecture, particularly in natural language processing tasks. However, with
their widespread adoption, concerns regarding the security and privacy of the
data processed by these models have arisen. In this paper, we address a pivotal
question: Can the data fed into transformers be recovered using their attention
weights and outputs? We introduce a theoretical framework to tackle this
problem. Specifically, we present an algorithm that aims to recover the input
data $X \in \mathbb{R}^{d \times n}$ from given attention weights $W = QK^\top
\in \mathbb{R}^{d \times d}$ and output $B \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ by
minimizing the loss function $L(X)$. This loss function captures the
discrepancy between the expected output and the actual output of the
transformer. Our findings have significant implications for the Localized
Layer-wise Mechanism (LLM), suggesting potential vulnerabilities in the model's
design from a security and privacy perspective. This work underscores the
importance of understanding and safeguarding the internal workings of
transformers to ensure the confidentiality of processed data. | [
0.0102147218,
0.0925492942,
0.0000197421,
0.0640863329,
-0.0543656014,
-0.0214014966,
0.0236142427,
-0.0191973783,
-0.0059392075,
-0.017843781,
-0.0518555976,
-0.039988406,
-0.0125819547,
0.0157919228,
0.026033286,
-0.0211140625,
0.01964291,
-0.0041611474,
-0.0264386889,
-0.0103681833,
-0.0356595516,
-0.0352968909,
0.0227808058,
0.0415538438,
-0.0078598224,
-0.0148091912,
0.0005003235,
-0.0078368112,
0.0390892103,
0.0375419073,
0.0384555869,
0.018268859,
0.0027804123,
0.0971612185,
0.0000020336,
0.0007898933,
-0.0522599071,
0.0097337021,
-0.0366879292,
-0.0224900711,
-0.0029054198,
-0.0545852482,
0.0027441427,
-0.0114294812,
-0.0145134851,
-0.0000577302,
0.0500857644,
0.0831292272,
0.0535444282,
0.0654156357,
0.0010373592,
-0.0503749922,
0.0004954409,
-0.0462675169,
-0.0336316973,
-0.0470794216,
0.0162675418,
-0.0815429464,
-0.0453209653,
-0.0107022934,
0.0016086672,
0.068019256,
0.0169781633,
0.0140947495,
0.0009428126,
0.0164327286,
-0.0288603939,
-0.0022884707,
-0.0123000182,
0.042908594,
-0.0689771473,
0.0148605108,
0.01395032,
0.00917379,
0.0453696549,
-0.0178398211,
-0.012358957,
0.0524032488,
0.0177213773,
0.0043814378,
-0.0390734412,
0.0096008359,
0.0350297578,
-0.023008246,
-0.0075781243,
0.0221486147,
0.0113291368,
-0.0128690498,
-0.0423171334,
-0.0160767678,
0.0158054847,
-0.0198373776,
0.0678916201,
0.0279825963,
0.0249474794,
0.0182042513,
-0.0422378704,
-0.0908743739,
-0.0132524986,
-0.0324359573,
0.0458438657,
-0.0128851496,
-0.016766239,
0.0293650497,
0.0216304995,
0.0668036789,
-0.0697932392,
0.0670880973,
0.0137649551,
0.0101928106,
-0.0053849127,
-0.023148749,
-0.0154123399,
0.0664612576,
-0.0342606753,
0.0255680475,
-0.0039431299,
0.0241567139,
-0.0105814626,
-0.0029245876,
-0.0028851589,
0.0484003387,
-0.073424615,
-0.0120782601,
0.0079369275,
0.0258297939,
0.0342310853,
-0.0017386018,
0.0081217438,
-0.0353924558,
-0.0585423969,
-0.0064182668,
0.0068395361,
-0.0283499118,
-0.0419683978,
0.1024997532,
0.0143337529,
-0.0319317691,
0.0093671801,
-0.0582208075,
-0.0143933846,
-0.0149832005,
0.0413553901,
-0.0342902876,
0.0132129155,
-0.0347994566,
0.0042845667,
-0.0397790596,
-0.008576842,
0.0282714125,
-0.0142454198,
0.05311298,
0.027935477,
-0.0290969275,
-0.0048004226,
0.0423772968,
-0.0217681769,
-0.0116083063,
-0.0047116,
0.0341590345,
0.0374714285,
-0.0075365053,
0.0684013516,
-0.0057910709,
0.0292696469,
-0.0157522894,
-0.0210901685,
-0.0065867854,
-0.02926022,
-0.0433834344,
-0.0247643087,
0.0650038719,
-0.0247989595,
-0.0689414516,
0.063451536,
0.0746767521,
-0.0079928031,
0.0657188073,
-0.04650978,
0.0206066724,
-0.0203590598,
0.0322476812,
-0.0578021407,
0.0389045328,
-0.0383199416,
-0.051105544,
-0.060509488,
0.0172627997,
-0.0212784223,
0.0022578838,
0.0435827263,
-0.0630225018,
0.0207488351,
-0.0204274356,
0.0390013419,
0.0491840616,
0.0075924536,
0.0963428319,
-0.0039603817,
-0.0548592322,
0.0075821551,
-0.0432343632,
-0.0321926959,
-0.0170173608,
0.0069072135,
-0.0219724774,
0.0118688522,
-0.0433814302,
-0.0290541667,
0.0240960773,
-0.0423278771,
0.0384730808,
0.0575162023,
-0.0111111635,
-0.0430790298,
-0.0173140764,
0.0134626711,
-0.0091624139,
-0.0217962787,
-0.036202509,
0.0177917089,
-0.0238648839,
0.0237194151,
0.0047117942,
0.0029950123,
-0.0652573332,
0.060530059,
0.020064326,
0.0466223843,
0.0312499758,
-0.016598938,
0.0327880606,
0.0499109067,
-0.0026328512,
-0.0323159322,
-0.0079763038,
0.0092013692,
0.0222398024,
-0.0374473333,
-0.086026147,
0.0281019676,
0.0968787521,
-0.0062231948,
-0.0423307829,
0.0541749895,
-0.0399772115,
0.0231946725,
0.0067910613,
-0.0050405809,
-0.0254033003,
0.0363859721,
-0.0500354059,
0.0456198566,
-0.0283565149,
0.0089386683,
-0.0315914974,
-0.0396711268,
-0.0113222031,
-0.045056019,
-0.0326649286,
0.0055785128,
-0.0598193333,
0.0194075312,
0.0199508462,
-0.0305460673,
-0.0030390853,
-0.0339731164,
0.0347716659,
-0.0097253183,
-0.0347514637,
0.0319985747,
0.0193643589,
-0.002433948,
0.0128959417,
-0.0624126084,
-0.0115987575,
-0.0227667298,
-0.0263314024,
0.0007924718,
0.0331457593,
-0.0013038494,
-0.0126458183,
0.0102983965,
-0.0731109381,
0.0231746137,
0.0434968397,
-0.032852225,
-0.0105716828,
-0.0348111764,
0.0054590502,
0.0164876152,
0.0464749634,
-0.0106974486,
-0.0286271479,
-0.0125793274,
0.0103001101,
-0.0195148755,
0.0852829218,
0.0159693211,
0.0199721865,
0.0230904296,
0.0150066884,
0.0055580176,
-0.0001842168,
-0.0601067804,
-0.0367511101,
-0.051952783,
0.0179588869,
0.057585448,
0.0558632053,
0.0020282462,
-0.0490079336,
-0.0078498702,
0.0011534382,
0.0067867767,
-0.0085586738,
0.0156164495,
-0.0226782318,
-0.0124483388,
0.0099875936,
-0.0070313239,
-0.0502539389,
0.0603356846,
0.0023613265,
0.0291956216,
-0.0271753296,
-0.0224520415,
0.0199238434,
0.0293107983,
-0.0002687337,
0.0357755683,
0.0034713605,
-0.0764134601,
-0.0257145017,
0.014642424,
0.0170675591,
-0.0418980122,
0.0267243553,
0.0273174047,
-0.0223184731,
-0.0323157646,
-0.0562956482,
-0.06360659,
-0.034369193,
0.0148882037,
0.0100276349,
0.0249029044,
-0.0383245721,
-0.0791729465,
-0.0276378766,
0.0698759258,
-0.0083788969,
-0.0025865373,
0.0016416387,
-0.0379107036,
0.0223685,
-0.0020240583,
0.0045119491,
0.0528106317,
-0.007435299,
-0.0070760357,
0.073549591,
0.0395954587,
0.0372552797,
0.0359859429,
-0.0332307406,
0.048025433,
0.0052619716,
-0.0021714242,
0.0088113854,
0.0251068491,
-0.0410973057,
-0.0154041266,
0.0190065335,
-0.0162100159,
-0.0779427513,
0.0029536472,
0.0243671834,
-0.0433262959,
0.0062514199,
-0.005660024,
-0.0620237105,
0.0051226737,
0.020976698,
0.0529629551,
-0.0020868371,
-0.0438244008,
0.0216679499,
-0.0634346679,
0.0080379294,
-0.0046367226,
-0.0077379704,
-0.0671619698,
-0.0282386262,
-0.007514331,
-0.0060510202,
0.0304740444,
-0.0311065782,
0.0024054549,
-0.0599836372,
0.0186183453,
0.0281788874,
-0.0047442294,
-0.0080208797,
-0.0377784669,
-0.0097991647,
0.0668943748,
0.0160584077,
-0.0182211306,
-0.0598690212,
-0.0356727168,
0.0080578038,
-0.0272546448,
0.0565402359,
0.0505167022,
-0.0046486109,
-0.0329317339,
-0.0212454516,
0.0653202906,
-0.0168768913,
0.0050484026,
-0.0335892104,
0.0385336056,
-0.0047125015,
-0.0160590224,
0.0021227063,
-0.047334291,
0.0250249002,
0.0364484563,
-0.0161100458,
-0.0178367645,
-0.0227458011,
-0.0218707211,
0.0715283006,
-0.0196160469,
-0.0536978692,
0.074865602,
0.0163584724,
-0.0641385466,
-0.0329871774,
0.0216915756,
-0.0441682115,
0.0399142019,
0.0176721755,
-0.0398487933,
0.0651705787,
-0.0134998346,
-0.0671035647,
0.0339053012,
-0.0591579638,
0.0117683373,
-0.0210890751,
0.0327789411,
0.0345147215,
-0.0204574224,
-0.0247104988,
0.0061320947,
-0.0781163946,
-0.0438663848,
0.0449210852,
0.0363318212,
0.0131652514,
0.0184235983,
-0.0404532813,
-0.0775813088,
0.0745281801,
0.0274827778,
-0.0259506423,
-0.0014811956,
0.0711810663,
-0.0539352,
-0.0095074382,
0.0497031622,
-0.0492799655,
0.0157226324,
0.0911166221,
0.0029164818,
-0.0248405747,
-0.0203047637,
-0.002107729,
0.0124054598,
0.079060927,
0.0455818474,
0.0297443103,
0.0014641871,
0.0488838442,
0.0117875272,
0.0035309093,
-0.0389752239,
-0.0034749429,
0.0447095893,
-0.0263264533,
0.0529609025,
0.0310519096,
0.0515655018,
-0.011413632,
-0.0443712696,
0.0187013727,
0.0158990677,
-0.038739223,
0.0246871281,
0.0450631194,
-0.0237710737,
0.0436403751,
0.0262683257,
0.0325078219,
0.0273846313,
0.0012306978,
0.0121507263,
-0.0003326959,
-0.05996323,
0.0119588301,
-0.0788615942,
-0.0264614075,
-0.0171538088,
0.0017337858,
-0.0071710907,
0.0101722497,
-0.0374456085,
-0.0047299978,
-0.0250201374,
-0.0137945823,
0.0088218153,
-0.024700297,
-0.0268225484,
0.015703639,
-0.0124934288,
0.0035088432,
0.0152315423,
0.0645621642,
-0.022291759,
0.0003645218,
-0.0095032202,
-0.0286882278,
-0.0260902774,
-0.0242580269,
0.0194742531,
0.0266193505,
0.0104769049,
-0.0028415499,
-0.0104544619,
-0.0841290802,
0.0310962237,
-0.03247815,
0.0426075533,
-0.019138556,
0.0050741029,
0.0270196013,
0.0281895902,
-0.0195178445,
-0.0313691087,
0.0155440932,
0.0332755111,
-0.0064981976,
0.0155754192,
-5.976767231e-33,
0.0273832455,
-0.0312615633,
-0.0489714704,
0.043864727,
0.0286973473,
0.051533889,
0.0109255817,
-0.0049296031,
-0.0074583231,
-0.0234625842,
-0.0450386703,
0.0228582397,
0.0083225528,
0.0734792799,
-0.0260132421,
-0.0421078354,
0.0221898705,
-0.0287061092,
-0.0048036953,
0.0407876633,
0.0508077219,
0.0426197127,
0.0991133451,
-0.0429766737,
0.021284176,
0.0124383727,
-0.023702601,
0.0365662053,
-0.0278742313,
0.0500643887,
-0.0388360731,
0.0061090123,
0.0050474862,
-0.0526367053,
-0.0223840643,
0.055638209,
-0.0405490883,
0.0109964814,
-0.0419369116,
0.0041921735,
-0.0138616282,
-0.0446672887,
0.0606611148,
-0.0157948062,
0.020880105,
-0.0506256409,
-0.000341745,
0.0248929523,
-0.0056500197,
-0.0422603004,
0.0107675809,
0.002392712,
-0.0278138425,
-0.0252539888,
0.0556779094,
0.0484182127,
-0.0004586001,
0.0016778489,
-0.0918478146,
-0.0069749104,
0.0350664854,
0.014397637,
0.0546977893,
0.0423621982,
0.0125644617,
0.0381231643,
0.0630079731,
0.0274977926,
-0.0497686155,
-0.0639139116,
-0.0045328676,
0.0251418427,
0.0565997995,
0.0068465699,
0.0309037566,
-0.023802286,
-0.0785172209,
-0.0108392928,
-0.048653964,
0.0278735068,
0.0733124316,
0.0284019168,
-0.016361881,
0.0065881838,
-0.0372062363,
-0.0168238748,
-0.031511467,
0.0398410633,
-0.0175626129,
0.0382159762,
-0.0534233041,
0.0337044895,
0.0318282098,
-0.0618263483,
0.0281010382,
-0.0028992835,
0.0646122545,
0.0055770567,
0.0026052434,
-0.0118813543,
-0.0027838214,
0.021997273,
-0.0106753455,
-0.0118806157,
0.0170145426,
0.0079844994,
0.0547896847,
0.0360392965,
-0.0324165337,
-0.0328704119,
-0.026544271,
0.0436739251,
0.0196786057,
0.0540074408,
0.0407177098,
-0.0075453878,
-0.0064817229,
0.0293245483,
0.0228128918,
0.0505848266,
0.0051235361,
0.0789307132,
-0.0065543121,
-0.0075662746,
0.0051034489,
-0.0385846831,
-0.0150995702,
0.0455790535,
0.0833940879,
-0.0346903615,
-0.0018871872,
-0.0217341557,
2.881e-7,
0.0000301158,
-0.0244539063,
0.0336377397,
-0.0204572789,
0.0271536913,
0.0545039475,
0.0306394696,
0.0938963071,
0.0068067694,
-0.0275817607,
-0.0392855257,
-0.0133041106,
0.0269368999,
0.0148337409,
-0.0917276442,
-0.0235034712,
-0.0511719324,
0.0032284157,
-0.0170657281,
-0.0120852049,
-0.0033199764,
0.0991557837,
0.0086452086,
-0.0214543529,
-0.0105054248,
-0.0150250988,
0.0201920234,
-0.0269720461,
0.0140217422,
-0.028950436,
0.087276496,
0.0269198213,
0.0025914332,
-0.0103187878,
-0.0163380336,
0.0212825686,
-0.0071160132,
0.0824661925,
0.0032475644,
-0.0596352927,
-0.0262570456,
-0.0292841829,
-0.0097545618,
0.011089474,
0.0171587523,
-0.0721716955,
-0.0537361018,
-0.0076514818,
0.0036915618,
-0.0236892458,
0.0274722539,
-0.0207465701,
0.0328891166,
0.0009790241,
-0.0250974055,
0.0179310776,
0.0331153646,
-0.0898149684,
-0.0113000693,
-0.0073783686,
-0.0381269529,
0.0206687022,
-0.0078888452,
-0.0417472348,
0.0050195926,
-0.0124170911,
0.0267498195,
2.388956021e-34,
-0.03920912,
-0.0125559876,
-0.00536134,
0.0328948088,
0.0139520532,
-0.0408238843,
0.0060113133,
0.01041607,
0.0274965335,
-0.077189073,
-0.0537513047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12454v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12454v1 | Rethinking the Construction of Effective Metrics for Understanding the Mechanisms of Pretrained Language Models | 2023-10-19T04:16:40 | 2023-10-19T04:16:40 | You Li, Jinhui Yin, Yuming Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained language models are expected to effectively map input text to a
set of vectors while preserving the inherent relationships within the text.
Consequently, designing a white-box model to compute metrics that reflect the
presence of specific internal relations in these vectors has become a common
approach for post-hoc interpretability analysis of pretrained language models.
However, achieving interpretability in white-box models and ensuring the rigor
of metric computation becomes challenging when the source model lacks inherent
interpretability. Therefore, in this paper, we discuss striking a balance in
this trade-off and propose a novel line to constructing metrics for
understanding the mechanisms of pretrained language models. We have
specifically designed a family of metrics along this line of investigation, and
the model used to compute these metrics is referred to as the tree topological
probe. We conducted measurements on BERT-large by using these metrics. Based on
the experimental results, we propose a speculation regarding the working
mechanism of BERT-like pretrained language models, as well as a strategy for
enhancing fine-tuning performance by leveraging the topological probe to
improve specific submodules. | [
0.0089494372,
0.0464473441,
-0.04036301,
0.0470793098,
-0.0233203322,
0.0096518267,
-0.0258588437,
0.0230555963,
-0.0456756651,
-0.0089924671,
-0.0806550086,
-0.0331298523,
0.0120149823,
0.0459961444,
0.0245130584,
-0.044121217,
0.0429524444,
-0.0325329266,
-0.0153093729,
0.0047476105,
-0.0065808995,
-0.0133285746,
0.0186729021,
0.0567134842,
0.0020587803,
-0.0316649526,
-0.0277188458,
0.0203330182,
-0.0116952714,
-0.0041159731,
-0.0101278406,
0.0496219657,
-0.0120516736,
0.0557409413,
0.0000020336,
-0.0419642851,
-0.0375945717,
0.0184095874,
-0.0250825882,
0.0442564711,
-0.0038502051,
-0.0257215239,
-0.0015029256,
0.002011111,
-0.0161806624,
0.0010269964,
0.0669509545,
-0.0036404466,
0.0453609042,
0.0706368312,
-0.0251387712,
-0.0426434837,
0.0316115394,
-0.0017805474,
0.003182485,
-0.0248691831,
0.0066699791,
0.0369737372,
-0.0263527967,
-0.0088160671,
-0.0444321781,
-0.0019725091,
0.0346731916,
0.0112019377,
0.0244863369,
0.022422336,
-0.0202162191,
-0.0481995158,
0.0245405845,
0.0716064051,
-0.0450460091,
-0.0319636539,
0.0020422216,
-0.0040190904,
-0.0300200693,
0.0136119453,
-0.0090948269,
-0.032921996,
0.0188377276,
0.0103304461,
0.0185332391,
-0.0063951039,
0.0480742641,
-0.0132728638,
-0.0920578167,
0.0879885927,
0.0274500735,
-0.0244928971,
-0.0387041867,
-0.000487836,
-0.0182680469,
-0.0508555248,
0.0426491946,
0.0213033874,
-0.0022254293,
0.0450110212,
-0.0358574688,
-0.0245354529,
0.0147516066,
-0.0359455496,
0.076308243,
0.0367586538,
-0.0407090038,
0.0268672742,
-0.0338742845,
0.0605536923,
-0.0367346518,
0.0737215579,
-0.0556122512,
0.0060971403,
-0.0447257757,
-0.0357216895,
-0.0669370219,
0.0165538173,
-0.020698119,
-0.0334661789,
-0.0131341862,
0.0456248671,
0.0160235949,
-0.0493341871,
-0.0058708307,
-0.0540226959,
-0.0324690081,
-0.018315699,
0.0038039959,
0.0119924378,
-0.0409459509,
0.0141807124,
-0.0547135249,
-0.0261150636,
-0.0116459457,
0.0167573988,
0.0037269839,
-0.0538437106,
-0.0022622475,
0.0492013171,
0.0245115366,
-0.05295524,
-0.0110689485,
-0.0185819212,
-0.035933882,
-0.0377462767,
0.0400107428,
-0.020743316,
-0.0045810975,
0.0205419511,
-0.0015014338,
-0.0164368749,
-0.0253930576,
-0.0233413521,
-0.0251075625,
0.0491181202,
-0.0246999525,
0.031097427,
-0.0488350876,
-0.0173527338,
0.0263867676,
0.0358428136,
0.0322513096,
0.0234913062,
0.0452842563,
-0.0312652439,
-0.0151177784,
0.0565366,
0.0453598462,
-0.0042711427,
-0.0305752419,
0.0199804474,
-0.0184225384,
0.0263487585,
0.0158420056,
0.0283769462,
-0.0520990752,
-0.000608437,
0.052206412,
0.0614622794,
0.0966661349,
0.045279976,
0.0367998369,
-0.0154943746,
0.0240796339,
0.02827847,
-0.0276042391,
-0.0257412661,
-0.052340433,
0.015078132,
0.0104122963,
-0.0131702889,
-0.0026490248,
-0.0596720539,
-0.0194409378,
-0.006867202,
0.0004744662,
-0.0378559381,
0.0731702372,
0.0362634771,
-0.0487676561,
0.0622487515,
0.0122792181,
-0.0455612764,
0.0167544689,
-0.0638256371,
-0.0007168996,
0.0358800814,
0.0471047312,
-0.0590253286,
-0.0227289367,
0.0520094298,
-0.0161240306,
-0.0008109739,
0.0042870399,
0.0005352482,
0.017276749,
-0.0153180426,
-0.0310252085,
-0.0205687024,
0.0388258621,
0.0427195691,
-0.034245763,
-0.0443887785,
-0.0192998406,
-0.0974394754,
-0.0250131097,
0.0427899137,
0.0261519197,
0.0238348823,
-0.0231883526,
0.0138200577,
0.0399020575,
0.0217181109,
-0.0453311689,
0.0339510068,
0.0253433902,
-0.0267051999,
0.0219784435,
0.0207437668,
-0.0583889112,
-0.0309428815,
0.0088923424,
-0.0209986288,
-0.0110760368,
0.0395198874,
-0.0002161598,
-0.0310528688,
0.0135998754,
-0.0545147695,
0.0992849842,
-0.0352664255,
0.0252106711,
-0.0500861555,
-0.0196218099,
-0.0222027004,
0.0455360003,
-0.0134397903,
0.0485244244,
0.0001844984,
0.0186282154,
0.0483884811,
0.0160089787,
-0.0284518059,
0.0246128906,
-0.0077148201,
0.0019612091,
0.0267752595,
0.00520712,
-0.0242247917,
-0.0484535322,
-0.0705941021,
-0.0077543217,
-0.0365731642,
0.0441586673,
0.0609049052,
-0.0101024266,
-0.006358271,
-0.0005314043,
0.0046270154,
-0.0511093177,
-0.0424279533,
0.031122148,
0.0550566763,
-0.0177594591,
-0.0266328119,
-0.0264691338,
-0.0468824469,
-0.0392020568,
0.1021972969,
-0.0159229934,
0.0161460508,
-0.0370462574,
0.0093373563,
0.0031612355,
0.0000273011,
0.006239213,
-0.0712179169,
0.0209378824,
-0.0017944529,
0.0677715689,
0.0486007817,
-0.0015492458,
0.0675100386,
0.0273412932,
-0.0065663927,
-0.0256793462,
-0.0268025864,
-0.0212976448,
-0.0136214094,
-0.0310059469,
-0.0428857878,
0.0282601994,
0.0926961973,
-0.0249225702,
-0.026211353,
-0.0747700334,
0.0000270109,
-0.04095928,
-0.0131930411,
-0.0455519557,
-0.0286616869,
-0.0334444083,
0.0703701824,
-0.0325208195,
-0.065797545,
0.0579409078,
-0.0569996201,
-0.0196982399,
-0.0326198712,
0.0254853144,
-0.0285954401,
0.0992558151,
0.0397915132,
0.0202984903,
0.0124033811,
-0.0552177019,
-0.0280383714,
0.026909614,
-0.001206381,
-0.0226039644,
0.0055841305,
-0.0266006216,
0.0006420024,
0.0172564387,
0.0157496054,
0.00304546,
-0.0139416829,
0.0120757567,
0.0007491178,
0.0413591564,
-0.029688606,
0.0176188219,
0.0320671201,
-0.0020316143,
0.0291291885,
-0.0144131305,
-0.0012289711,
-0.0263876785,
0.0434217341,
0.0009581569,
-0.015330337,
0.0197329093,
-0.0535475537,
-0.034731891,
-0.0002879917,
0.004375461,
0.0050379843,
-0.0491988547,
0.0266227145,
0.0126916291,
-0.0138633819,
-0.0557046458,
-0.0066275797,
0.0701624081,
-0.0481743217,
-0.0336242467,
0.1116357297,
0.0448932052,
0.0203750301,
0.0486407205,
-0.0131630404,
0.0491794646,
-0.0014219265,
0.0027066253,
-0.0512709878,
0.0023295039,
0.0044486648,
0.0075351042,
-0.0014473681,
-0.0256467573,
0.0275861323,
-0.0978308916,
-0.0160387363,
-0.0139391795,
-0.0416526608,
-0.0438851491,
-0.0309502427,
-0.006495391,
0.0058907978,
0.0201836769,
0.0174507666,
0.0110016782,
0.0337628201,
0.0233912263,
-0.0465162396,
-0.0398415849,
0.0376781933,
-0.0207272321,
0.0415160619,
0.0804164261,
0.0487768911,
-0.0088182855,
-0.0209709927,
0.0045972108,
-0.0126755722,
0.0215580352,
-0.0087473029,
0.0410255492,
0.0136997281,
-0.0378261507,
-0.0010174635,
0.0008285018,
-0.0097756339,
0.0131994067,
-0.069001168,
0.0438046232,
-0.0084241899,
-0.0360259973,
0.0059087365,
-0.0306574609,
-0.0307639595,
0.0675302595,
0.0700225756,
-0.0450241938,
-0.0409855805,
-0.0089854971,
0.0428940542,
-0.0459259227,
-0.0676738769,
0.0197745878,
-0.0241721533,
-0.0373270251,
-0.043781206,
-0.0426551625,
0.0061503383,
0.0592686497,
-0.0055424995,
-0.0108655673,
0.0061632162,
-0.0322661288,
-0.030856071,
0.0776503533,
0.0073206383,
0.0252838209,
-0.0331891477,
-0.0353929922,
0.0331920311,
0.0114489989,
-0.053497348,
-0.0059027942,
0.0058327219,
-0.0184540711,
0.0264911838,
0.0450123139,
0.0324910022,
0.0241387077,
-0.025202509,
-0.0563763231,
-0.0106803216,
-0.0192753542,
-0.0519616306,
0.0405743383,
0.0945783854,
-0.0105040558,
0.0009166673,
0.0465135537,
-0.0416891128,
0.0313983299,
0.0251944959,
0.0422438197,
-0.0231646877,
0.0093513737,
0.0237469077,
0.0161557663,
0.0704725534,
0.0270708911,
-0.0004999328,
-0.0243527032,
0.0172483679,
-0.0373677425,
0.0021601939,
-0.0707002208,
-0.0006130399,
0.0338202566,
0.0096215922,
-0.0510324016,
-0.0282798354,
-0.0301049612,
0.0219460279,
-0.0401146114,
0.0254394095,
0.0259835534,
0.0634338334,
0.0236500259,
0.0112999491,
-0.0089966534,
0.0135657405,
-0.0353327729,
0.0120842382,
-0.0054793735,
-0.0005289897,
0.0449511148,
0.0159949157,
0.0041481205,
0.052729331,
-0.0430164151,
0.011690625,
-0.0228382386,
0.0430021808,
0.0242213905,
0.0141738532,
0.0658852533,
-0.0026988185,
-0.0073757418,
-0.0046653613,
0.0358122736,
0.0353473686,
-0.0309307054,
0.000410658,
0.0095687853,
-0.0052549634,
-0.0121903708,
0.0675101206,
0.0218016822,
0.0425173864,
-0.0017778426,
-0.007413079,
-0.0162495188,
0.009487397,
0.0154629797,
0.0145122577,
-0.0291280299,
0.0106858537,
-0.07400354,
-0.080248408,
0.035982769,
0.0467367768,
0.0164684877,
0.0019679887,
0.0211650971,
0.0637041777,
-0.020339245,
-0.0213554353,
-0.0065205763,
-0.0252895672,
0.0021448652,
0.0227232538,
-0.0015616643,
-6.313212816e-33,
-0.0545809492,
-0.0309102759,
-0.0284769591,
-0.0537296981,
-0.0154520748,
0.0237162765,
-0.060660053,
0.003804469,
-0.0115865311,
0.0208609086,
0.0106871622,
0.0183546543,
0.0001776742,
0.0063010175,
-0.0355840549,
0.0012264462,
0.0411074795,
0.0135839907,
-0.0169890709,
0.0064744852,
0.0002048291,
0.0396163873,
0.0526519567,
-0.0460043922,
0.0224564429,
-0.0040655937,
-0.0012921043,
0.030864967,
0.0139211137,
0.0434192047,
-0.0217191391,
0.0031269712,
0.0140527347,
-0.0109447632,
-0.0552573614,
0.0094068497,
-0.0780036747,
-0.0619659238,
0.0444270633,
0.0239240099,
-0.0702010542,
-0.0164232198,
0.0644831285,
-0.0019233266,
-0.0015555447,
-0.0111882538,
0.0210708026,
-0.0129578141,
-0.0336786471,
-0.0216317829,
-0.0515925139,
0.0400070474,
-0.0328896865,
-0.0320840776,
0.0306230728,
0.0031493611,
-0.0002481917,
0.0007058351,
-0.0107561387,
-0.022050878,
0.0503334254,
0.0257164072,
0.0367780887,
0.0192129929,
0.0287982374,
0.0464417711,
0.029597912,
0.0057318495,
-0.0148637118,
0.0015120311,
0.087424241,
0.0488374494,
0.0603674576,
-0.029884791,
0.022493517,
0.0400953814,
-0.0615763776,
-0.0129732061,
-0.0437187962,
-0.009843559,
0.0185099822,
0.0316954777,
-0.0172568168,
0.0022709204,
-0.0419025645,
-0.0677905753,
-0.0289219953,
-0.0158567689,
0.0214946531,
-0.0483414941,
-0.052010186,
0.0214309394,
0.0160880797,
-0.03521109,
0.0001763804,
-0.0014996114,
-0.023551926,
0.0493768156,
-0.0145649379,
0.0727855116,
-0.025924867,
-0.0508872345,
0.0093592787,
0.0297812186,
0.0462933853,
-0.0081842132,
0.0102062821,
0.0204775762,
-0.0286515784,
-0.0242102239,
-0.0191880632,
-0.0520659648,
-0.0243265443,
0.0016602045,
0.0619586967,
0.0048280167,
-0.0107976748,
0.0593714081,
0.0445203334,
0.0345349722,
-0.0460714884,
0.0179473888,
-0.000640095,
0.0239713006,
-0.0132227223,
-0.0562540069,
-0.0070141675,
0.0288212933,
0.0842838213,
-0.0491055138,
-0.0186352357,
-0.0037765759,
2.749e-7,
0.1132803336,
0.0712927654,
0.0503217839,
0.0012178292,
0.0150868641,
0.0006848437,
-0.019867409,
0.0239760987,
-0.0051620989,
-0.0176302884,
0.0377049223,
-0.005556108,
0.0179019142,
-0.012188782,
-0.0203134269,
0.0165816452,
-0.0973970816,
0.020404242,
-0.0473186411,
0.0135731157,
0.0370056145,
0.0607193522,
-0.0006823284,
0.0246613231,
0.0071238726,
-0.052490443,
0.04497521,
-0.0378788412,
0.0341552608,
0.0307637341,
0.0402309634,
-0.008637921,
0.0143136978,
0.0211808812,
0.0064470968,
0.0522911102,
0.0190533698,
0.0470235832,
-0.0391392186,
-0.0074489438,
-0.0141138937,
-0.0325960591,
-0.0280991197,
-0.0659036487,
0.06511309,
-0.0768983066,
-0.0537172407,
0.0131645864,
-0.0144363046,
-0.0069848308,
0.0169313103,
0.0068363892,
-0.0230678208,
0.05232656,
0.0390050896,
-0.0421832278,
0.0116702076,
-0.0797748342,
-0.0283265132,
0.0069386777,
-0.0236278009,
-0.0359759219,
-0.0594634563,
-0.0078854626,
0.0469963886,
-0.052978199,
-0.0108901467,
2.81907721e-34,
0.0388122983,
-0.0475534573,
0.0262100995,
0.0321039595,
0.0482991301,
-0.026050061,
0.0469970964,
-0.0037662371,
0.0142218787,
-0.1149482206,
-0.0207263194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12450v2 | A Read-and-Select Framework for Zero-shot Entity Linking | 2023-10-19T04:08:10 | 2023-10-29T14:58:54 | Zhenran Xu, Yulin Chen, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot entity linking (EL) aims at aligning entity mentions to unseen
entities to challenge the generalization ability. Previous methods largely
focus on the candidate retrieval stage and ignore the essential candidate
ranking stage, which disambiguates among entities and makes the final linking
prediction. In this paper, we propose a read-and-select (ReS) framework by
modeling the main components of entity disambiguation, i.e., mention-entity
matching and cross-entity comparison. First, for each candidate, the reading
module leverages mention context to output mention-aware entity
representations, enabling mention-entity matching. Then, in the selecting
module, we frame the choice of candidates as a sequence labeling problem, and
all candidate representations are fused together to enable cross-entity
comparison. Our method achieves the state-of-the-art performance on the
established zero-shot EL dataset ZESHEL with a 2.55% micro-average accuracy
gain, with no need for laborious multi-phase pre-training used in most of the
previous work, showing the effectiveness of both mention-entity and
cross-entity interaction. | [
-0.0068893,
-0.0176511966,
0.0193505213,
-0.0146493567,
0.0189309251,
0.0453131199,
0.0129441721,
-0.0035177818,
0.0227376353,
-0.0564814508,
-0.0095933555,
0.0325352028,
-0.0086554019,
-0.0269614514,
0.0473117828,
-0.0084693832,
0.0569191575,
0.0511514433,
-0.0174093023,
0.0190511607,
-0.0055976943,
0.0253734086,
-0.0344861224,
-0.0101566901,
0.0090538273,
0.0201274995,
-0.0043880269,
0.0254861712,
0.0778957307,
-0.0542840585,
-0.036857523,
0.0134281013,
0.0087259477,
0.0891705155,
0.0000018334,
-0.0583133139,
-0.0352820195,
-0.0050015906,
-0.0347708538,
-0.0288224015,
0.0015141764,
-0.0331668593,
0.0059501762,
-0.0274587385,
0.0247568805,
-0.0647348166,
0.033303082,
0.0323394462,
0.0212136619,
0.0559660979,
-0.0109889377,
-0.0298324302,
-0.0112979347,
-0.0384524502,
0.0099769104,
-0.028107658,
0.0360134952,
-0.0521938987,
0.0179347675,
0.0405718237,
-0.0322721601,
0.04323975,
-0.0179957449,
0.0223540254,
0.0354891047,
0.0284915008,
-0.0627848357,
-0.0087755499,
0.0458531082,
0.1149822846,
0.0194701906,
-0.018677514,
0.0503869504,
0.0054988563,
-0.0091346633,
0.0014476355,
-0.0150933908,
-0.008143058,
-0.0035836499,
0.0119049288,
-0.0232943539,
0.0054136873,
0.0397416912,
0.0142934732,
0.0051896567,
0.0086261248,
0.0116732484,
-0.0081713451,
-0.000834938,
0.044587031,
0.0113451974,
-0.0438635349,
0.0250704419,
0.0005128803,
-0.0261327811,
0.0194535758,
-0.0435907356,
-0.0225172378,
0.0178700145,
-0.0090759406,
-0.0394705981,
0.0096172057,
0.0064556384,
0.0453502089,
-0.0671015233,
-0.0202388018,
-0.0208275821,
-0.0243622009,
0.0059179198,
-0.0572967716,
-0.0593791902,
0.0437825769,
-0.0192285348,
0.0414724387,
-0.0335516445,
0.0004507483,
-0.0495216809,
-0.0325378962,
-0.0213543698,
0.0637792721,
-0.0522717647,
-0.0110332528,
-0.0039282269,
0.0040200669,
-0.0360828638,
0.0419431627,
-0.0475610048,
-0.0276289787,
-0.0445007645,
0.0017460424,
-0.0130220912,
-0.002022614,
0.00105066,
-0.0642266199,
0.0025811703,
0.0568062328,
0.0150543749,
-0.0412310697,
-0.0407744348,
-0.0065760082,
0.0361385792,
-0.050920099,
-0.0129184695,
-0.0261966698,
0.0360789187,
0.0197415054,
0.0045507159,
-0.0610086098,
0.0052912962,
0.0045093801,
-0.0707798749,
0.074362278,
-0.056917455,
-0.0637430921,
-0.0008414331,
0.0378687121,
0.0491125323,
0.0500129089,
0.0271281153,
0.0029978834,
0.0288737137,
0.0441955812,
-0.0364669673,
0.0137637891,
0.0610264018,
-0.0026476986,
0.0371735357,
0.0090627298,
-0.0221069548,
0.0429509282,
0.062972717,
0.0113654071,
-0.0554922782,
-0.0687112957,
-0.0134105673,
0.0153366942,
0.0259470195,
-0.0134522747,
0.053959813,
0.0392349064,
-0.0276370309,
-0.0172200911,
-0.0100722481,
0.0371788293,
-0.0184726324,
0.0013275436,
0.0409432761,
0.044754792,
-0.0519329943,
0.0434949137,
0.0190115701,
-0.020130137,
0.0070652626,
0.0301980563,
0.0499062389,
0.0176916104,
-0.0607153811,
0.1089673787,
0.0475972667,
-0.0002749103,
-0.0290093962,
0.0101799881,
0.005393046,
0.0344019756,
0.0519767404,
-0.0014275977,
-0.0371211618,
-0.0566774346,
-0.0063583371,
0.0766468421,
0.0049339007,
-0.0443645492,
0.0282103717,
-0.0342991613,
-0.0280232523,
0.031992767,
0.0002007401,
0.0311092269,
0.0326360166,
0.0724351034,
0.0515331291,
-0.0220896695,
0.0437151715,
0.0078559117,
-0.0163079556,
-0.0210393891,
-0.0100162206,
0.026038792,
-0.0335041545,
0.0492434949,
-0.0083652893,
-0.0293621644,
0.019085329,
0.0193154961,
0.032972794,
-0.0288040936,
0.0138160242,
-0.0333024971,
0.0309810694,
-0.0328514874,
-0.0253903177,
-0.0143272188,
-0.0348474979,
-0.0580267385,
0.0086732516,
0.0219747983,
0.021793792,
-0.0126013448,
0.0100514945,
0.014365647,
0.0007713922,
-0.0354088061,
0.0594350323,
0.025252793,
0.0276488066,
0.0368868634,
0.0254671294,
0.0110918051,
-0.0402157232,
-0.0748995617,
0.0201191176,
0.0135901431,
-0.0222358331,
0.0233274549,
-0.0423615538,
-0.0863964483,
0.0374525823,
-0.0747963339,
0.0298931487,
0.0261510592,
0.0049021551,
-0.0240848605,
0.0167424474,
-0.0048104953,
-0.0197925698,
0.0311713163,
0.0166203566,
-0.0223585274,
-0.0065917517,
0.041419033,
-0.0057593533,
-0.0105313342,
-0.0381711721,
-0.0054572802,
-0.0360800587,
0.0441532619,
0.0081968522,
-0.0551736876,
-0.0137325088,
0.0336154997,
-0.0802694261,
-0.0111408932,
0.0107948976,
0.0388820879,
-0.0059194569,
0.0404504649,
-0.0230071414,
0.0171017181,
-0.0478777513,
-0.0058772769,
-0.0109833535,
-0.018733032,
-0.0719287619,
0.0203045309,
0.0298090968,
0.0609206073,
0.002446508,
0.0021307196,
-0.0356138423,
0.0584565587,
-0.0537431836,
-0.0036674573,
-0.0158183295,
0.0105092255,
0.0270291809,
-0.0058339378,
-0.0022057691,
0.0419921167,
0.0269423444,
-0.0051553459,
-0.0380810946,
0.0059760627,
0.0396677181,
-0.027013015,
0.0009192727,
-0.0136391306,
0.0273228679,
-0.0277503114,
0.0123511124,
0.0298051536,
-0.0006771919,
0.035848897,
-0.024179047,
-0.0050591379,
0.0214194432,
0.001983573,
0.0016243686,
0.0547590144,
0.0103172408,
0.0567728467,
-0.0251079835,
0.0031036504,
-0.0084023373,
-0.0159328058,
-0.0600869693,
0.0221150927,
-0.0260029715,
-0.0149649978,
-0.046527002,
0.0111483736,
0.0379110873,
0.025900254,
0.0405020416,
-0.022466369,
-0.0150437569,
0.0267066173,
0.0526660159,
-0.0370838158,
0.0311628226,
0.018385699,
-0.0123616392,
0.040028505,
0.0399557948,
-0.0218334533,
-0.0004467053,
-0.0368926674,
0.0196127761,
-0.0955726504,
-0.0327276736,
-0.0254078545,
0.0326112881,
-0.0171393249,
0.007930913,
0.1030323878,
0.0490002222,
-0.0483828485,
-0.0235402491,
0.0447045043,
0.0009895089,
0.0063821389,
0.0338273272,
-0.1320306212,
-0.0497335754,
-0.0169217046,
-0.0194147341,
0.0082483049,
-0.0979796425,
-0.0031576969,
-0.1207665876,
-0.0226404648,
-0.0079367803,
-0.0236983895,
-0.0102848541,
-0.0640214086,
0.0260056593,
-0.0523499027,
-0.0108894575,
-0.000836784,
-0.015302795,
0.0179078188,
-0.0223716833,
0.0626998395,
-0.02714343,
0.0481357202,
-0.0687031001,
0.0702155754,
0.0532681644,
0.0497300476,
0.0264131352,
0.0433685184,
-0.0507301316,
-0.0647495091,
-0.0467644744,
-0.0182404816,
0.066329293,
-0.0589033179,
0.0111849084,
-0.0190999657,
-0.0278889593,
0.017383473,
-0.0103728659,
-0.03569296,
0.0160252284,
0.0184595119,
0.0328149535,
-0.0355515853,
-0.0000435023,
0.012474562,
0.0614939034,
0.0042009391,
-0.0023862342,
0.0126074962,
-0.0116174854,
0.0010696525,
-0.0509811752,
0.0139641212,
-0.0243744627,
-0.0767189935,
-0.0014329756,
-0.0522735529,
-0.071489282,
0.0509618297,
0.0421622358,
-0.0114302179,
0.0408811867,
0.0029528905,
-0.0034048224,
-0.0455602109,
0.0141674466,
-0.0429955199,
0.032509502,
0.0014725379,
-0.0247180983,
0.0574444421,
-0.0188204497,
-0.0216361098,
0.0095156729,
-0.0649914369,
-0.0334956609,
-0.0236449037,
0.0090121301,
0.0181115661,
0.0530349165,
-0.0339066535,
-0.0484193414,
0.0459355265,
0.0435343683,
-0.0125030875,
0.004727798,
-0.0070846989,
0.0512397103,
-0.0085627194,
0.0371742323,
-0.0422830507,
0.0248666666,
0.011346845,
0.0195141304,
-0.0665811226,
-0.0380081683,
-0.0384030901,
0.004853528,
0.0408823565,
-0.0009737439,
0.0298938435,
-0.0165380929,
0.0006655575,
0.0022141419,
0.0110216616,
-0.0006701798,
-0.0054208171,
0.0053137145,
-0.0022513955,
-0.0208734218,
0.0422227047,
-0.0207176767,
0.0507241227,
-0.0698736832,
0.0084619066,
0.0213917959,
-0.0095768105,
-0.0301290434,
-0.0116697336,
-0.0080900798,
0.0387202203,
0.0517197475,
0.059388496,
-0.0420243964,
0.0092701968,
0.0118120397,
0.0250644498,
-0.009853608,
0.0119579546,
-0.0308735874,
0.0682216659,
0.0009204924,
0.0497148894,
0.090906404,
-0.0211396068,
0.0894607529,
0.0333805643,
-0.0234354958,
0.0218155291,
0.0194817875,
-0.0355639271,
-0.009000537,
-0.0042069154,
0.0157093704,
-0.0058879377,
0.0448408052,
0.0596087947,
0.0199132022,
0.0441316217,
0.0059150038,
0.0031965605,
-0.0258561261,
-0.0044064615,
-0.0297405124,
0.0125434743,
-0.0042279782,
-0.0197770149,
-0.0418742299,
-0.0501074828,
0.0497485735,
-0.0456460156,
-0.0364949517,
0.016242018,
0.0452163294,
-0.0239995997,
0.0338853933,
-0.0030082182,
-0.0261453092,
-0.0324765407,
0.0265843291,
-0.0497146994,
-0.0146422749,
-5.623837175e-33,
-0.0631909221,
-0.0056177713,
0.0255573615,
-0.0554794408,
-0.0238535497,
0.011899665,
-0.0185414087,
-0.0452917777,
-0.0675921142,
-0.0172585696,
0.0002955882,
0.0128569435,
0.0103836264,
0.0118903657,
-0.0229460206,
-0.0352124237,
0.050090909,
0.0229020268,
-0.0135991052,
0.0183456391,
0.046536006,
0.0434951186,
0.0498747118,
-0.0439967811,
0.0469369255,
-0.029534379,
-0.0045325696,
-0.0157516412,
0.0712884739,
0.056620542,
0.0249599963,
0.0007936463,
-0.0017859251,
-0.0336105824,
-0.0012418104,
-0.0217154715,
-0.1358500123,
-0.0081826998,
0.0063064843,
-0.0105726905,
0.0316528678,
-0.0226476844,
0.0196074098,
-0.0122691551,
0.0419192053,
-0.0117914751,
0.0401646234,
0.0115282554,
-0.0493728332,
-0.0520280339,
-0.0503129549,
0.0441059358,
-0.0142103974,
0.0230184309,
0.0589926094,
0.0186177138,
0.0349245705,
0.0336851552,
-0.1035931408,
-0.000106288,
-0.0099448012,
-0.00597648,
0.0263628531,
-0.0191590432,
0.000688324,
0.0644743517,
0.0341212414,
-0.0494290777,
-0.0383056067,
0.0049899132,
-0.0055194781,
-0.0192646235,
-0.0352420732,
0.0756854415,
0.0434501395,
-0.0044202865,
-0.0993399993,
0.0226767119,
0.0318586826,
0.0087966183,
-0.0533363894,
0.0189794172,
-0.0306781903,
-0.0167177487,
-0.0099606039,
-0.0369568691,
-0.0281102546,
-0.0509163849,
-0.0001076353,
0.0168359242,
-0.0458726473,
0.0952211693,
0.0276651084,
-0.0118477028,
-0.0367373861,
0.0342615061,
0.0202736948,
0.0120658493,
0.0303191487,
-0.0094656404,
-0.0928350314,
-0.0105402377,
0.0343793109,
0.0020691638,
0.0138554014,
0.0110190446,
0.0309976041,
-0.0422642864,
-0.0391453356,
0.0029979288,
0.009264159,
-0.012844231,
-0.0659103766,
-0.0050687282,
-0.0038743818,
0.026801236,
0.0119086215,
0.0091035785,
0.0677284002,
-0.0225065071,
0.0167941432,
0.0370304696,
0.015432328,
0.0132829603,
-0.0063832407,
0.0114536965,
0.0080667315,
0.0399199314,
0.0129186548,
-0.0989400297,
-0.0062921522,
-0.0014797372,
2.557e-7,
0.0103115337,
0.0135989645,
-0.0049672569,
0.0110690594,
-0.0095470585,
0.0223608799,
0.0367724113,
0.0675419495,
0.0089631323,
0.0040089116,
-0.0151737574,
-0.0042328634,
0.0027517402,
0.0409157164,
-0.0848250091,
-0.0347167216,
-0.0049108141,
0.020061776,
-0.0428565592,
-0.0137991002,
0.0033802146,
0.0497117974,
0.0179756284,
0.0256879125,
0.0050232932,
-0.0051307795,
0.0535573475,
0.0042680483,
-0.0049100798,
0.0078315102,
-0.0030665013,
0.0342693292,
-0.0355270766,
0.0388132259,
-0.0325849764,
0.0407549962,
0.0408919305,
0.032603208,
-0.010242804,
-0.0470787361,
-0.0105731906,
-0.0602183267,
0.0062887077,
0.0198785961,
0.0701534301,
-0.0391516425,
0.0051701544,
0.0493781455,
-0.0636396334,
0.047594171,
-0.0070305471,
0.0232829321,
-0.0361987799,
0.0121014984,
0.0079078153,
-0.0138004301,
-0.0419572853,
-0.0725475997,
0.0073727905,
0.014145935,
0.0155590354,
-0.0168778058,
0.0213469341,
-0.0765874013,
0.0078842463,
-0.0591710694,
-0.0119252168,
2.079311524e-34,
-0.019720383,
0.0034143946,
-0.0210345294,
0.0049259104,
0.0185815189,
-0.032910753,
-0.0781319365,
-0.0168617927,
0.0092146704,
-0.0345875248,
0.0017171364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12444v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12444v1 | Revisiting Sparse Retrieval for Few-shot Entity Linking | 2023-10-19T03:51:10 | 2023-10-19T03:51:10 | Yulin Chen, Zhenran Xu, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entity linking aims to link ambiguous mentions to their corresponding
entities in a knowledge base. One of the key challenges comes from insufficient
labeled data for specific domains. Although dense retrievers have achieved
excellent performance on several benchmarks, their performance decreases
significantly when only a limited amount of in-domain labeled data is
available. In such few-shot setting, we revisit the sparse retrieval method,
and propose an ELECTRA-based keyword extractor to denoise the mention context
and construct a better query expression. For training the extractor, we propose
a distant supervision method to automatically generate training data based on
overlapping tokens between mention contexts and entity descriptions.
Experimental results on the ZESHEL dataset demonstrate that the proposed method
outperforms state-of-the-art models by a significant margin across all test
domains, showing the effectiveness of keyword-enhanced sparse retrieval. | [
0.0539057553,
-0.0027673338,
0.0059658634,
0.0081555769,
0.0142459329,
0.0179592203,
0.0120059866,
0.0420715325,
0.0057545179,
-0.0596859753,
-0.02381308,
0.0213311706,
-0.0404500812,
0.0084015317,
0.0429865718,
-0.0234510358,
0.0317239277,
0.0295353383,
-0.0045810062,
0.0299868304,
0.0016729456,
0.0183259957,
0.0024283906,
0.0134011423,
-0.0198833365,
0.0511950888,
-0.0137829883,
0.0144399377,
0.0292667337,
-0.0483353473,
-0.0005414074,
0.0245764032,
0.0029771554,
0.0347366408,
0.00000185,
-0.0501953699,
-0.0499238931,
0.029892955,
-0.0200449266,
-0.0229721423,
0.0245387051,
-0.0144239366,
0.0506611802,
-0.0198942628,
0.0013855769,
-0.0703237653,
0.0190712009,
0.0666211098,
0.0048994278,
0.0518686362,
-0.0222237762,
-0.0256400239,
-0.0103159472,
-0.0306240171,
0.0014377628,
-0.071409218,
0.0165648535,
-0.0667739287,
0.0181569327,
0.0531675294,
0.0193638839,
0.0488012619,
-0.027591316,
0.0389207378,
0.05559697,
0.0218139775,
-0.073251687,
-0.0004012381,
0.0229403302,
0.0686965734,
0.0387610644,
-0.0012487744,
0.044000674,
0.030267071,
-0.0148901613,
0.0174019951,
-0.027258439,
-0.0211414471,
-0.0179253891,
-0.0236746725,
-0.0443604961,
0.0125737581,
0.0084819803,
0.0033486993,
-0.0034561204,
-0.0071274191,
0.018385876,
-0.0292244665,
0.0095343292,
0.0050356947,
-0.0314837769,
-0.0199424773,
0.0341821536,
0.0052384832,
-0.013781636,
0.0290267896,
-0.0051910356,
-0.0195624307,
0.0723884851,
0.0125988573,
-0.036776308,
-0.0086417375,
-0.02701669,
0.0397698283,
-0.0531111695,
-0.0307619516,
0.0002894858,
-0.0479027443,
0.0322411545,
-0.0434493013,
-0.0473017395,
-0.0142067522,
-0.0434466153,
0.0889803544,
-0.033965975,
0.0057365145,
-0.0280020759,
-0.0219559278,
-0.0104391025,
0.0413538925,
-0.0446287505,
0.0102793612,
-0.0266280416,
-0.0249685999,
-0.0384778641,
0.0152151287,
-0.0504104681,
0.0140923737,
-0.0087646497,
-0.0064338627,
-0.0205621365,
-0.0048057712,
0.0193757694,
-0.0597875081,
0.0098964274,
0.0576719344,
0.0265597235,
-0.0617849156,
-0.0217644777,
-0.0547995269,
0.0098892264,
-0.0305399969,
-0.0232474953,
-0.0425473452,
0.0091852956,
0.0284757689,
-0.0186225735,
-0.0699345991,
0.0304623898,
0.0186285861,
-0.0598147437,
0.0616208501,
-0.0646578297,
-0.0400044508,
0.0138998823,
0.0270380005,
0.0293709133,
0.0574653447,
-0.0017709818,
0.0281459298,
0.0361570083,
0.0506431945,
-0.0279674828,
-0.0220738556,
0.0564025827,
-0.014235761,
0.0148156481,
0.0113093518,
-0.0436601825,
-0.0128221335,
-0.0092507489,
0.0571626388,
-0.0352399349,
-0.0000516734,
-0.0096409079,
0.0321573615,
-0.0244737398,
-0.009150601,
0.0310480129,
0.0127292639,
-0.0220065024,
-0.0084395185,
-0.0208048169,
0.0148170907,
-0.019439077,
-0.0020769187,
0.0598127656,
0.0198694225,
-0.0217559896,
-0.0021893983,
0.0102595501,
0.0222901031,
-0.0306385625,
0.0326483101,
0.0862420425,
0.0080806362,
-0.0382597782,
0.1002591997,
0.0483445749,
0.0020269579,
-0.0356468149,
-0.0027261651,
-0.0139063867,
0.0133210877,
0.0307826214,
-0.0296184048,
-0.0544639751,
-0.0233514197,
0.0203877315,
0.0604054369,
-0.0009206302,
-0.0414858945,
0.0352836065,
-0.0240927879,
-0.0421843678,
0.0010577585,
0.0354335643,
0.0121997334,
0.0380179621,
0.0680488348,
0.0795856044,
-0.0614145212,
0.0424632244,
0.0208903868,
0.0148640424,
-0.0154431965,
-0.0058328356,
0.0280704778,
-0.0261391606,
0.0507318303,
-0.0027982614,
-0.0138742616,
0.0569511242,
-0.0229957234,
0.0047078403,
-0.0296460334,
0.0035804615,
-0.0102827772,
0.0151223447,
-0.0160298999,
0.0150918681,
-0.0541287102,
-0.0076702922,
-0.0441194475,
-0.0021890749,
0.0135470154,
0.0432465635,
-0.0127789602,
0.0028750517,
0.0173537694,
0.0118143456,
-0.0498648249,
0.0745019242,
0.0371397473,
0.0289462507,
0.0070308396,
-0.0164536666,
0.027655242,
-0.0200898871,
-0.0730558485,
-0.0276662726,
-0.0131276706,
-0.0098960521,
0.0552873798,
-0.0205638073,
-0.0828926712,
-0.0056667998,
-0.064226836,
0.0269665644,
0.0008807681,
-0.0020053869,
-0.0460781828,
0.0417838022,
-0.0033340165,
-0.0194047485,
0.0187317319,
-0.0159686413,
-0.0352824293,
0.0175379701,
0.0147370389,
0.0536186136,
-0.0536433831,
-0.0494846627,
-0.003254392,
-0.0151496166,
0.0127148628,
0.0024438375,
-0.0912544206,
-0.0173975918,
0.0834343433,
-0.0256309602,
-0.0063137021,
-0.0111619662,
0.0691845939,
-0.0077039441,
-0.0088935522,
0.0107937427,
-0.0198252033,
-0.0429965481,
0.0279455259,
-0.016890103,
-0.0287629664,
-0.0867096707,
0.0310954861,
-0.0130108055,
0.0005946536,
0.0108629195,
0.0287580416,
0.0119318115,
-0.0072196042,
-0.0374899879,
-0.004076988,
-0.0215544216,
-0.0218150541,
0.0183548722,
0.0028549596,
-0.0203962717,
0.0619743653,
0.0419044979,
0.0240919124,
-0.0263063386,
0.0013666336,
0.0283588618,
-0.0032232311,
0.0228333101,
0.0320931152,
-0.0096483994,
-0.0224976372,
0.0403205752,
-0.0069874553,
0.0081732478,
0.0317685641,
-0.0477073826,
-0.0065516918,
0.0273864325,
-0.002250873,
-0.0065490226,
0.035547141,
0.0244532339,
0.0568503365,
0.0005322603,
-0.0232935715,
-0.0069295224,
-0.0447752401,
-0.0316008776,
0.0231328029,
-0.0145721287,
0.0356323868,
-0.018010078,
0.0515932478,
0.0061825342,
0.0165474005,
0.0279762819,
-0.0532468408,
0.0159450602,
0.0144271255,
0.0937442482,
-0.0477176085,
-0.0056869001,
0.0087359957,
0.0045406464,
0.0374333374,
0.0443497337,
-0.0422502831,
0.0195732005,
-0.0273404308,
0.0073556202,
-0.0728598237,
-0.0346050113,
0.0025171661,
0.0354479663,
-0.0297932029,
-0.0216060299,
0.0944659486,
0.0506266579,
-0.0520055667,
-0.0298570525,
0.013975055,
0.0107014235,
0.028019717,
0.0456940196,
-0.1092372686,
-0.0431519412,
-0.0164147001,
0.0046388125,
0.0077492637,
-0.0692482218,
0.0232146271,
-0.1311193705,
-0.0146323852,
-0.0409538224,
-0.026561195,
-0.0504202805,
-0.082284458,
0.0248872787,
-0.0133126136,
-0.0137035511,
0.0082267495,
-0.024107663,
0.0067056385,
0.0155177657,
0.0703158826,
-0.0284123588,
0.0295925997,
-0.0762370378,
0.0663366914,
0.0236070883,
0.0237127729,
0.0014352255,
0.0312510654,
-0.0471348986,
-0.0199880097,
-0.0299007911,
-0.0170599371,
0.0726036876,
-0.051253058,
0.004572181,
0.0275063887,
-0.0404247977,
0.0075986711,
0.000644098,
-0.0195407234,
0.0295256749,
0.008963583,
0.0369233713,
-0.0317689553,
-0.024800403,
0.0036053378,
0.0416848771,
-0.0155868987,
0.037133567,
-0.0086968904,
0.0209701899,
0.0090674227,
-0.0037675928,
0.0282099731,
-0.0164803434,
-0.0835544765,
0.0096349493,
-0.0442577265,
-0.0554872081,
0.0679712296,
0.0678706616,
0.010040666,
0.0790401325,
-0.0056048855,
0.0212834775,
-0.0560795031,
0.0195779204,
-0.0320394933,
-0.0008847991,
-0.0180439558,
-0.0254628602,
0.0492951497,
-0.0282310899,
-0.022904614,
0.008728669,
-0.0471771769,
-0.0295024998,
-0.0189936925,
-0.0045450348,
0.0130297579,
0.035791833,
-0.0355369486,
-0.0382718034,
0.0347805321,
0.1068014801,
-0.0438349433,
0.0008976078,
0.0148235913,
0.0113250073,
-0.0136214299,
0.0420148782,
-0.0886464715,
0.0298166275,
0.0029312826,
0.0542748123,
-0.0597863421,
-0.0243887492,
-0.0064424807,
0.0238170177,
0.0757435337,
-0.0151401088,
0.0133922389,
-0.0245913379,
0.0273942221,
0.0047788695,
-0.0045725582,
-0.0239892416,
0.0001718672,
-0.0167136677,
0.0053179734,
-0.0126562165,
0.0238976479,
0.009660094,
0.0679459646,
-0.0689217448,
-0.012920226,
0.0144088361,
-0.0576951951,
-0.0038559993,
-0.0106010512,
-0.0159635339,
0.024816189,
0.0555969514,
0.0512209497,
-0.0649739355,
0.0018692291,
0.0191324651,
0.0015474678,
-0.0086831171,
0.0187001228,
-0.0236637332,
0.0322078615,
-0.0163324121,
0.0284049604,
0.0524600409,
-0.0334839448,
0.0584361926,
0.0154356882,
-0.0208268072,
0.0267690532,
-0.006849112,
0.0044092708,
-0.000753113,
0.0312914029,
0.0279091466,
-0.0056204502,
0.0823454112,
0.0702660978,
0.0391337126,
0.0741758868,
0.0173860341,
-0.0202007461,
-0.0325452648,
0.0332764648,
0.0574117526,
0.0027015498,
0.0044190581,
-0.0179641005,
-0.0151047735,
-0.0611711368,
0.0669224858,
-0.0646614507,
-0.042225454,
0.0069896835,
0.0518771484,
0.0363951772,
0.044307854,
-0.028832376,
-0.0195449293,
-0.0296962522,
0.0516017489,
-0.0132184848,
-0.015335138,
-6.377823129e-33,
-0.0713626146,
-0.0171057861,
0.0233758651,
-0.0143450405,
-0.0014229858,
-0.0018030507,
-0.0292181857,
-0.029393414,
-0.0654961541,
0.0020380288,
-0.0251565576,
0.0102740433,
0.0149869965,
-0.002405904,
0.011595279,
-0.0406500697,
0.037123125,
0.037166018,
0.0179343559,
0.0191064067,
0.0442415476,
0.062130753,
0.0405891836,
-0.070453465,
0.0352727659,
0.0058757048,
-0.0137565685,
0.0175040215,
0.0702700615,
0.0402572379,
-0.0026041763,
0.0350929797,
-0.0169932246,
-0.0426824763,
0.0175669547,
-0.0483265035,
-0.1413199306,
-0.0283321608,
-0.0043112556,
-0.0228015892,
0.074969165,
-0.0049413317,
0.0432872958,
-0.0009851693,
0.0340659507,
0.0099795219,
0.0294861775,
0.0032039252,
-0.0627041608,
-0.1018646061,
-0.0662521645,
0.0376141742,
0.0091454368,
0.0340075046,
0.0494086035,
-0.0487860702,
0.0141015723,
0.0137807038,
-0.0372757949,
-0.0114984689,
-0.0271205567,
0.0212519653,
-0.003887513,
-0.0143992733,
0.006673512,
0.0676300451,
0.0281815138,
-0.0111010587,
-0.0277087167,
0.0220402107,
0.0080781393,
0.023209149,
-0.0379720479,
0.0488920957,
0.0361856632,
-0.0241815839,
-0.0777344853,
0.0003982921,
0.0166253466,
0.0267939959,
-0.0079036774,
0.0142074591,
-0.0593112744,
-0.0310968701,
0.003950614,
-0.0019583998,
-0.0451451093,
-0.0300412998,
0.0205811225,
0.0424635373,
-0.0355271064,
0.094267197,
-0.0100875804,
-0.0087223873,
-0.0155725274,
0.0237747822,
0.0247269794,
-0.0122208539,
0.0010689338,
-0.0163022578,
-0.0562247969,
-0.0562704057,
0.0325022526,
0.0072224517,
-0.0038018567,
0.002443121,
0.0370170996,
-0.0262135118,
-0.0649388656,
-0.0089971712,
0.0073517142,
-0.0030186798,
-0.0360823236,
-0.0350101925,
0.0077787526,
0.0348381363,
-0.0032364281,
0.0267399903,
0.0678019375,
-0.0086729303,
-0.0032131551,
0.0361814164,
0.0094141504,
-0.0183971785,
0.0080839554,
0.00357105,
0.0156243239,
-0.0022925099,
-0.0026035879,
-0.0631878003,
-0.0196464844,
-0.0018147185,
2.778e-7,
-0.0019639505,
0.0404781662,
-0.0192262121,
-0.0205511246,
-0.0491884537,
0.0062084179,
0.0494653806,
0.0249405708,
0.0144309122,
-0.023647815,
-0.0098149441,
0.0027007998,
-0.0304535795,
0.0419239029,
-0.1034514681,
-0.045098111,
-0.0016465951,
-0.0468846112,
-0.0363085233,
-0.0046985,
0.0444602631,
0.0446502157,
0.0110491132,
0.0130362259,
-0.0356472544,
-0.0666546449,
0.0275154673,
0.0078139519,
-0.0072837532,
0.0053107208,
0.0063737459,
0.055991862,
-0.0213819314,
0.0283973888,
-0.0071738446,
0.0596246943,
0.0366959982,
0.035509754,
-0.0334248096,
-0.0282881446,
-0.0024013608,
-0.0503514633,
0.0163272209,
0.0300087612,
0.0742909089,
-0.0310554598,
0.0032869487,
0.0356680267,
-0.0468640924,
0.0230930466,
-0.0311578307,
-0.0074017933,
-0.0180915762,
-0.0046699741,
-0.0017010173,
0.0023182349,
-0.0403146707,
-0.0863258392,
0.0486254394,
0.0257854499,
0.0026671202,
-0.0183270704,
0.0036661746,
-0.0159391332,
-0.0152213424,
-0.0514591448,
0.0061950251,
2.479484469e-34,
0.0030130832,
0.0109410975,
-0.0245972797,
0.050969068,
0.044121407,
-0.0315576233,
-0.0568560138,
0.0120290574,
-0.0070914337,
-0.0762459189,
0.0206863359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12443v1 | Know Where to Go: Make LLM a Relevant, Responsible, and Trustworthy Searcher | 2023-10-19T03:49:36 | 2023-10-19T03:49:36 | Xiang Shi, Jiawei Liu, Yinpeng Liu, Qikai Cheng, Wei Lu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has shown the potential to improve
relevance and provide direct answers in web searches. However, challenges arise
in validating the reliability of generated results and the credibility of
contributing sources, due to the limitations of traditional information
retrieval algorithms and the LLM hallucination problem. Aiming to create a
"PageRank" for the LLM era, we strive to transform LLM into a relevant,
responsible, and trustworthy searcher. We propose a novel generative retrieval
framework leveraging the knowledge of LLMs to foster a direct link between
queries and online sources. This framework consists of three core modules:
Generator, Validator, and Optimizer, each focusing on generating trustworthy
online sources, verifying source reliability, and refining unreliable sources,
respectively. Extensive experiments and evaluations highlight our method's
superior relevance, responsibility, and trustfulness against various SOTA
methods. | [
0.0774022862,
0.078710936,
-0.0019343278,
0.0304236561,
-0.0168239772,
-0.0474065952,
-0.0124954628,
0.0266378615,
0.0496581234,
-0.0411551632,
-0.0417919084,
-0.0377209671,
-0.0415972844,
0.0054313685,
0.0228479225,
-0.0022615152,
0.0240022577,
-0.0190585665,
-0.0021344877,
-0.0102724815,
0.0008928239,
0.0215381589,
0.0344647095,
0.024259463,
0.0247007217,
0.003926733,
0.0202025864,
0.0277390368,
-0.0270383712,
-0.0277459994,
-0.0141843185,
0.0462607332,
0.0070462399,
0.0441920236,
0.0000018303,
-0.0562244914,
-0.0406831019,
0.0112872515,
-0.014394016,
0.0211216379,
0.0193678122,
0.0243620444,
-0.0013982995,
0.0431593321,
-0.0398903005,
0.0249005165,
0.0079452842,
0.0212211236,
0.0765240639,
0.0624865927,
0.0094391722,
-0.002720135,
0.052156873,
-0.0158290323,
0.04529313,
-0.0263342597,
0.0333065316,
0.0244979728,
0.0054971958,
0.0475915186,
0.0200172961,
0.0458422303,
-0.0454789549,
-0.0582765453,
0.079203181,
0.0022343614,
-0.079355292,
-0.0066063162,
0.0337162912,
0.0401715524,
0.0120405769,
-0.0433272719,
0.0287361648,
0.020659091,
-0.0253678113,
0.0802601054,
-0.0654879585,
0.0436384045,
-0.0106346505,
0.0263118614,
-0.0055299639,
-0.0186410751,
0.0531061739,
0.02352616,
-0.0056004943,
0.1114063635,
0.0310348645,
-0.0342556313,
0.0013197404,
-0.0012433906,
-0.0041609271,
-0.0271563232,
0.0144395316,
0.0085245278,
-0.0176033154,
0.0266590323,
0.0350681469,
0.0211086813,
0.0688950866,
-0.0821804628,
-0.0198201407,
-0.0249682609,
-0.0099327201,
0.0545576401,
-0.0187622737,
0.0283055063,
-0.0314746387,
-0.0036511899,
-0.040627867,
-0.0191545803,
-0.0302098151,
-0.0273895748,
-0.0069282916,
0.0266834144,
-0.007122247,
-0.0075359182,
-0.034729939,
0.0525986515,
-0.0166603215,
0.0225619618,
0.0256715398,
0.0075121294,
0.0029888833,
-0.0260319822,
-0.0547589138,
-0.0123976395,
0.0176184829,
0.0066831037,
-0.0238169152,
-0.0748826116,
0.0134115005,
0.0314141698,
0.0159513261,
-0.01244226,
0.0070781419,
0.0394483916,
0.0280029513,
-0.0277713779,
-0.0583973974,
-0.0587355159,
0.0049579833,
-0.0162381474,
-0.0237943418,
-0.0670297444,
0.0099153146,
-0.0062327753,
0.0044314167,
-0.0432934128,
0.0187292881,
0.0395486429,
-0.0324119404,
0.0314438008,
-0.0203811266,
0.0335246436,
0.045892518,
0.0204634964,
0.0136311855,
0.0445306599,
-0.0061856704,
0.0546832979,
0.0692550763,
0.0299029984,
0.0377044976,
0.0108936913,
0.0266489014,
0.0076721814,
-0.0026642571,
0.0325433984,
-0.0016841372,
-0.0082899844,
-0.0099270353,
0.0784953609,
-0.0379856601,
0.0298443064,
0.0575502403,
0.0296076834,
0.0340356529,
0.0213602465,
0.0155105405,
0.0205679964,
-0.0129206711,
-0.0214708112,
-0.0339937136,
-0.0007271368,
-0.0232240651,
-0.0145119745,
0.0839579403,
0.0263683777,
-0.0057449043,
-0.0128473928,
-0.029644262,
0.029534122,
-0.0555276051,
0.0229566898,
0.0368103422,
-0.0219713803,
-0.0165905692,
0.0529153459,
0.0152629111,
-0.0428011231,
0.0584390461,
-0.0426302664,
0.0332711488,
0.0976558551,
0.0800713226,
-0.0216603,
0.0204302482,
0.0033027309,
-0.0039403802,
0.0179676954,
-0.0060511329,
-0.0116440691,
-0.0287304111,
-0.0244579874,
-0.0522332862,
0.0350913517,
0.0158175807,
-0.0236218348,
0.0543576181,
0.0118205622,
0.0388279036,
-0.0648623258,
-0.0291511808,
0.0097288014,
-0.0113350283,
0.0111354124,
-0.0181408245,
-0.0254567135,
0.0037070184,
0.0164463539,
-0.0122675551,
0.0261620674,
0.0232056417,
-0.0057176366,
-0.0582806766,
-0.0399513878,
0.0184777938,
0.0558876619,
0.0392274596,
-0.056330096,
0.0527118929,
-0.0156643707,
0.0043033045,
-0.0220460985,
-0.0176771451,
-0.0347696207,
0.0286927316,
-0.0611121096,
0.0131286299,
-0.0180432182,
0.0101543488,
-0.0641537756,
0.0703104436,
0.0043808958,
0.035003718,
0.020685466,
0.0044944151,
-0.003388345,
-0.0355531685,
-0.0313088968,
0.0221652705,
-0.0020902527,
0.0550715849,
0.065137729,
-0.0196032841,
-0.0560152903,
-0.0403999388,
-0.066249527,
-0.0060875709,
-0.0022019446,
0.0232417621,
0.0029418934,
-0.012692539,
-0.006293823,
0.0171635151,
-0.0546445586,
-0.0315685309,
0.0200589448,
0.0014639449,
0.0029372589,
0.0034786724,
-0.0175136067,
-0.0218494944,
-0.0292796046,
0.0049871434,
0.0453837477,
0.0098472564,
-0.0270843245,
-0.0776276663,
0.0417382158,
-0.0738501176,
0.002196332,
-0.0142975561,
0.0089932689,
-0.0192484334,
-0.0480281897,
0.0041976175,
0.0060617733,
0.0523596331,
-0.0527153611,
0.0670932755,
-0.0150609203,
-0.0717618614,
-0.0341289453,
-0.0279919598,
-0.0290414188,
-0.0118782204,
-0.0467830412,
0.0329233594,
-0.0343287773,
0.0012458739,
-0.0120909037,
-0.0328983888,
0.0159551892,
-0.0077286786,
0.0011028021,
-0.0292406958,
-0.0251278374,
0.0173717719,
0.0700889677,
0.0063081202,
-0.0500676706,
0.0289724544,
-0.0509453267,
0.0397765115,
0.0140626421,
-0.0124745583,
-0.0226493999,
0.0229198281,
-0.0125027755,
0.0337486826,
-0.0106677702,
-0.0108683156,
-0.004312017,
0.016695302,
0.0693170354,
-0.085158214,
0.0372253172,
-0.0016515218,
0.0500401892,
0.0188426394,
-0.0375538692,
-0.0506612062,
-0.0431654938,
0.0030256703,
0.0009116594,
0.0118740918,
-0.0145617882,
-0.0240607206,
0.0073179603,
0.0386149213,
0.0021536204,
-0.0248086583,
-0.0335928723,
0.0166739989,
0.0391845442,
0.0490235128,
-0.0133728376,
0.0452999435,
0.0226282999,
-0.0095103597,
0.0495469272,
0.0339193419,
-0.031782683,
0.0119686304,
-0.046877943,
0.0684351549,
-0.0401009172,
-0.0279790778,
-0.0000469155,
-0.0361397564,
-0.010403432,
-0.0244761519,
0.0976789072,
0.0404240377,
-0.0697976127,
-0.0332960598,
-0.0508144125,
0.0102887647,
0.021602679,
0.0572369359,
-0.0665163249,
0.0432001725,
0.0081672054,
0.0506515093,
-0.0089382464,
-0.0115402974,
-0.0085871713,
-0.1280068606,
0.0758384839,
-0.0086918902,
0.0458534695,
0.0040056086,
-0.0957369953,
-0.0127598699,
-0.015170604,
-0.0189261008,
0.0625868663,
-0.0302601494,
-0.0098851435,
0.0096911807,
0.00142818,
-0.0463145785,
-0.0053271921,
-0.0457007289,
0.0162884835,
0.0612572394,
0.0064302632,
0.0005112066,
-0.037088111,
-0.0003913211,
-0.0266366974,
-0.0106077176,
-0.0128005538,
0.0372976102,
-0.0186894201,
0.0177317038,
-0.0159538593,
-0.0183486603,
-0.0020283128,
0.0055711819,
-0.0028892504,
0.0636959672,
-0.0114409523,
0.0207862966,
-0.0143172164,
-0.02344588,
-0.0112818275,
0.0696720704,
-0.0040022042,
0.0274473112,
-0.0022739531,
-0.0309097078,
0.0407996923,
0.0283730309,
-0.0572351404,
0.0147055965,
-0.0125677455,
-0.0000214505,
-0.0878469497,
0.0205123052,
-0.0460941344,
0.0284750238,
0.0097211553,
0.024665894,
-0.0014026583,
-0.0283168163,
-0.0270906854,
0.0087989233,
-0.0828896984,
-0.0030269769,
-0.0387182422,
0.0283695068,
0.0884898603,
-0.046682097,
-0.0000068877,
0.0061570117,
-0.0404775441,
-0.0570674427,
-0.0293406956,
0.0247569382,
0.0269696321,
0.0233610403,
-0.0509540811,
-0.0401083156,
0.0367676988,
0.0409704894,
-0.0312775262,
-0.0006815707,
-0.0068847397,
0.0017341673,
-0.0018206497,
0.0267236959,
-0.0831592232,
0.0053472016,
-0.025904974,
0.0300115533,
-0.0131051531,
-0.0356723741,
0.044777263,
0.068237111,
0.049760282,
-0.0071354951,
0.0538000166,
-0.0367976949,
0.0251318309,
-0.0461325459,
-0.0243070573,
-0.012281388,
0.0474238582,
0.0351092964,
-0.0303102043,
0.0079451967,
0.0158339068,
-0.0353442654,
0.0639304072,
-0.0639009327,
-0.0307587702,
-0.01090266,
-0.0269858837,
0.0102116009,
-0.006740903,
-0.006261406,
0.0046541002,
0.0206704047,
0.0488916598,
-0.0340260305,
-0.0067536565,
-0.0067851651,
-0.0419967286,
-0.0011172526,
0.00965581,
-0.0926941335,
-0.0978823453,
-0.062741071,
0.0160601139,
0.0587502569,
0.0314700343,
0.0587865971,
-0.028096566,
-0.0131362509,
-0.0020637189,
-0.0247075111,
0.0311839022,
-0.0444014296,
-0.007898449,
0.0291793868,
-0.0074709509,
0.0230363701,
0.0789889023,
0.0021581193,
0.0041563734,
-0.0483919606,
-0.0678632855,
-0.0204086751,
-0.0594241619,
-0.0190028343,
0.0207669288,
-0.0573480763,
-0.0456999727,
-0.022483496,
-0.0422044247,
0.0063461894,
0.0092320498,
0.0094679827,
-0.0011164558,
0.0350201577,
0.0978707001,
0.0110495724,
0.0022579823,
-0.0648472011,
-0.0131386062,
-0.0020505211,
-0.0010319995,
-0.000033843,
-6.517471857e-33,
0.0085328333,
-0.0398764834,
0.0097174356,
-0.04841993,
-0.0398160405,
0.0133544067,
0.0015058087,
-0.0240362827,
-0.0173816103,
-0.0300171562,
-0.0184182115,
0.0403240398,
0.0130971344,
0.016849013,
0.0070217634,
-0.0091088498,
0.0358394682,
0.02068571,
-0.0336186625,
0.0305927619,
0.0502944179,
0.0075558648,
0.0008015896,
-0.0603366308,
0.0311910119,
-0.0503056273,
-0.0389838181,
0.0430787317,
0.0139146103,
0.0530228838,
0.0047384822,
0.0479270443,
0.0177782774,
-0.0715998784,
0.031168133,
-0.0386265293,
-0.0316662453,
0.0003366241,
0.0230978206,
-0.0389148444,
-0.0013139463,
-0.0011474615,
0.0370630398,
-0.0325834267,
0.006016246,
0.0193291306,
0.0434965529,
-0.0258491691,
-0.0505395718,
-0.0671904683,
-0.0140785333,
0.0191070698,
0.0177886281,
0.0453206636,
0.0211726651,
0.0221336689,
0.0062167007,
0.0700893849,
-0.0058858241,
0.0628898144,
-0.0298742205,
0.0488279983,
0.0637506098,
-0.0125575708,
-0.0005925146,
0.0564193204,
-0.0004685879,
-0.0011333743,
-0.0026732243,
-0.0575258248,
-0.0232224111,
0.0174232125,
0.0143328803,
0.0744634271,
-0.0227857474,
-0.0057614534,
-0.0559875965,
0.0325453654,
0.0055958992,
0.022787597,
0.0351416767,
0.0194391571,
-0.0331216417,
-0.0277111195,
-0.0250851829,
-0.001646812,
-0.0594137944,
-0.0265007727,
0.0069916546,
0.0306040607,
-0.0399507657,
-0.0174317546,
0.0077869138,
-0.0499629565,
-0.0336933248,
0.0727878064,
0.0050124745,
-0.0246425439,
-0.0236641951,
0.0112077519,
-0.0147122433,
-0.0252843052,
-0.0133386264,
-0.0174168348,
-0.0539299548,
0.0072606597,
-0.0184417721,
-0.0110052945,
-0.0478803068,
0.0170963649,
-0.0140452031,
-0.0044363211,
-0.0151068326,
-0.0479371697,
0.0279797334,
0.015673425,
0.0163181368,
0.0251823217,
0.0838631168,
0.052791927,
0.0055780797,
-0.0002130872,
-0.0101051461,
0.0055977306,
0.0010292957,
0.0291483216,
-0.0103377784,
0.0348457918,
0.013430926,
-0.0595085509,
-0.013683564,
0.0023867188,
2.754e-7,
0.0190919321,
0.0572571084,
-0.0071847821,
0.0474859774,
0.0094816163,
-0.0277323853,
0.0130735058,
-0.002225698,
0.0117053632,
-0.0332139954,
0.0059441165,
0.0180334933,
0.0131364148,
0.0496976897,
-0.0668037087,
-0.0066775498,
-0.068685241,
-0.044739645,
-0.0323160179,
-0.0480179712,
0.0361649357,
0.0684082806,
-0.0086924313,
-0.006944987,
-0.0207416806,
-0.0715876892,
0.0586618148,
0.00578142,
-0.0286445245,
0.0480876341,
0.0771976635,
0.0155233741,
0.0121573824,
-0.0209963284,
-0.0208668541,
-0.0040015159,
0.017413307,
0.0299659204,
0.0305385068,
-0.0014545302,
-0.0172405541,
-0.066537708,
0.0354425125,
-0.0819677338,
0.0585474558,
0.0283701401,
0.0231662299,
-0.0092491219,
-0.0751233026,
-0.0437388942,
0.0200469252,
-0.0614303425,
-0.0160743352,
0.0246169325,
-0.0300524086,
0.0353066213,
0.0082560731,
-0.0493959039,
-0.0243720207,
-0.0467480719,
-0.0420153961,
-0.0823164508,
0.008731042,
0.0129701253,
-0.017426366,
-0.0268653706,
0.0512018763,
2.215909018e-34,
0.0299817361,
0.0294180736,
-0.0080118002,
0.0169232246,
0.0398870446,
0.0323342979,
-0.0354162157,
0.0171936266,
0.0100347241,
-0.0693085343,
-0.0108227348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12442v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12442v1 | Efficient Long-Range Transformers: You Need to Attend More, but Not Necessarily at Every Layer | 2023-10-19T03:32:05 | 2023-10-19T03:32:05 | Qingru Zhang, Dhananjay Ram, Cole Hawkins, Sheng Zha, Tuo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pretrained transformer models have demonstrated remarkable performance across
various natural language processing tasks. These models leverage the attention
mechanism to capture long- and short-range dependencies in the sequence.
However, the (full) attention mechanism incurs high computational cost -
quadratic in the sequence length, which is not affordable in tasks with long
sequences, e.g., inputs with 8k tokens. Although sparse attention can be used
to improve computational efficiency, as suggested in existing work, it has
limited modeling capacity and often fails to capture complicated dependencies
in long sequences. To tackle this challenge, we propose MASFormer, an
easy-to-implement transformer variant with Mixed Attention Spans. Specifically,
MASFormer is equipped with full attention to capture long-range dependencies,
but only at a small number of layers. For the remaining layers, MASformer only
employs sparse attention to capture short-range dependencies. Our experiments
on natural language modeling and generation tasks show that a decoder-only
MASFormer model of 1.3B parameters can achieve competitive performance to
vanilla transformers with full attention while significantly reducing
computational cost (up to 75%). Additionally, we investigate the effectiveness
of continual training with long sequence data and how sequence length impacts
downstream generation performance, which may be of independent interest. | [
0.0203544497,
0.0608203784,
0.0144715616,
0.0128967511,
-0.014999317,
-0.0143502345,
0.0092205191,
-0.0138285523,
-0.0469753817,
-0.0383092761,
-0.0057846908,
-0.0539363883,
0.0123813627,
0.0541808531,
-0.0013574364,
-0.0654422119,
0.0243143309,
-0.0102042556,
-0.0168904439,
0.0336860344,
-0.0065441593,
-0.0144310743,
0.0008116433,
0.0605255254,
-0.0125393802,
0.0059639388,
-0.0215340201,
-0.012140017,
0.0172342043,
-0.0349417292,
0.0012321982,
0.0539660789,
0.0172800422,
0.0219538696,
0.0000019711,
-0.0072883884,
-0.0059792465,
-0.0091416249,
-0.0284452308,
-0.0053645512,
0.0138337761,
-0.0394766778,
-0.0081603099,
0.0181869362,
-0.0231773015,
-0.0274584293,
0.0442402326,
0.0603230596,
0.053205464,
0.0865955278,
-0.0076274718,
-0.0474234521,
0.0404612496,
-0.0475189723,
0.0217781495,
-0.0354051031,
-0.0055685574,
-0.0656386837,
-0.0117970705,
-0.00249528,
-0.0355681404,
0.0389450416,
0.0523702838,
0.0194150861,
0.0196928009,
0.0408671461,
-0.0321631134,
-0.0203540009,
-0.0215141531,
0.063779749,
-0.0621352307,
-0.0127263963,
-0.0019791971,
-0.0082120029,
-0.0090240138,
-0.0491759591,
-0.012131488,
0.039711047,
-0.0001169852,
0.0106774708,
-0.0013890488,
0.0407745764,
0.0029942419,
-0.0067024115,
-0.0804732367,
0.0119522726,
0.0017468698,
-0.0289413724,
-0.0262376983,
-0.0026394648,
-0.0047805188,
-0.0479720421,
0.0278643686,
0.0395723507,
-0.0104024019,
-0.0003681286,
-0.0653275922,
-0.0575195253,
-0.0031927186,
-0.0160898063,
0.0335041955,
0.0461421646,
-0.0240639467,
0.0115488553,
-0.027270237,
0.0415940993,
-0.0267641991,
-0.0128220478,
-0.0207618829,
0.0054816948,
-0.0082445517,
0.0074654031,
-0.0569182821,
0.0264157597,
-0.0651290715,
-0.0401674844,
-0.0272717047,
-0.0049626054,
0.0060661472,
-0.0414458737,
0.02472784,
0.0369166844,
-0.0645260215,
-0.0211288538,
0.0071434225,
0.0806499049,
-0.0218020584,
0.0067149596,
0.0551537499,
-0.0503973737,
-0.0559146665,
0.0342551991,
0.031766288,
-0.0356908776,
-0.0012892982,
0.067175962,
-0.0168406311,
-0.0760014951,
-0.0231816582,
-0.0167719573,
-0.0201052222,
-0.058715526,
0.0040596505,
-0.0525866859,
0.0263729002,
0.0079243807,
-0.0018272868,
-0.0082035139,
0.0231971219,
0.0304355659,
-0.0007854229,
0.0496721081,
0.0362318754,
-0.0275507253,
-0.0158561748,
0.014624388,
0.0131896306,
0.0330636501,
0.0377171859,
0.0425741039,
-0.0169900656,
-0.0355415829,
0.0269195605,
0.0148177166,
0.0162966046,
-0.0314023793,
0.0132841133,
-0.0090995207,
-0.0444927104,
0.0130559485,
0.0618222877,
0.0530434474,
-0.0332579575,
-0.0031858457,
0.0475931503,
0.0216157567,
0.0404285677,
0.0418463908,
0.0617311597,
0.0339370705,
-0.0405709408,
0.0051949085,
-0.030592205,
0.0562449843,
0.0208127089,
0.0172148831,
0.0385352634,
0.0404140055,
-0.0276221707,
-0.016364621,
0.0149152521,
-0.0361535028,
0.0073312037,
-0.0153772607,
0.0343025401,
0.0392551422,
-0.088873744,
0.1270499825,
0.0009736971,
-0.0723121017,
-0.0018392924,
-0.0216259807,
-0.0272320975,
0.0518390723,
0.0088489996,
0.0058022127,
-0.0181799848,
-0.0241501536,
-0.0025801221,
0.0486184396,
-0.0008811437,
0.0417181104,
0.0302486196,
-0.05158199,
-0.0131963929,
0.0127564818,
0.00991676,
0.0210085139,
0.0268541761,
0.0206613299,
0.0272026844,
-0.0001082817,
0.0061396686,
0.0097171767,
-0.0270892978,
-0.0293867104,
0.0020612543,
0.0107297925,
0.0470596626,
0.0133138858,
-0.0000778204,
0.0380390547,
0.0359811187,
-0.0653771907,
-0.0157019775,
0.0074574542,
-0.1026560068,
-0.0282520894,
0.0081024384,
-0.0564971641,
0.0046353331,
0.0669776127,
-0.0146996472,
-0.0562952831,
0.0360307284,
-0.0904537141,
0.0394198187,
-0.000965444,
0.0199673325,
0.0421824865,
0.0580943301,
-0.0160370003,
0.0394654535,
-0.0249753408,
0.0109595284,
-0.0022183657,
-0.0113267656,
-0.0092348596,
-0.0304173268,
0.011535611,
0.0004901934,
-0.0373827592,
-0.0162907969,
0.0205835309,
-0.0221604034,
-0.0089616114,
-0.0373644717,
-0.0501663238,
-0.0128942598,
-0.0385013595,
0.0274853352,
0.0060416148,
0.0420580916,
0.0114848362,
0.0108106369,
-0.0099537298,
0.000054093,
0.0217992961,
-0.0041840347,
-0.0042639705,
0.002367703,
-0.029601533,
-0.0293199103,
-0.0272817761,
0.0215518773,
0.0558889285,
-0.0155441239,
-0.0226104278,
-0.0459921956,
-0.0262758378,
0.020227192,
0.0269821547,
-0.0078591276,
-0.0563601963,
-0.0141634606,
0.0053044586,
0.0709592625,
0.0219599027,
0.0562785715,
0.0170385949,
0.007545548,
-0.0300494172,
-0.0149793373,
0.0304581635,
-0.0329469107,
0.0230247602,
-0.0614836141,
-0.0201152358,
0.023956297,
0.096293889,
-0.009414441,
0.0080669057,
-0.0634897277,
-0.0243736766,
0.0240166076,
-0.0326574296,
0.0585513748,
0.0035854541,
-0.0387426801,
0.0118066585,
-0.0148073304,
-0.0224765893,
0.0486833565,
-0.0422116779,
-0.0144191124,
-0.035052564,
0.0140480958,
-0.0438209996,
0.0561709553,
0.0208339486,
0.0033121768,
-0.0124209868,
-0.0559135303,
-0.0024697513,
0.0502174348,
-0.0191760939,
-0.0151095912,
0.0655051917,
-0.0055628051,
0.0047578881,
-0.0433697514,
-0.0294689517,
-0.0565276742,
-0.0237438027,
-0.0143309049,
0.0130939167,
0.0701759383,
-0.0189007279,
-0.0871578753,
0.0261701122,
0.0183656178,
0.0631908551,
0.0044674287,
0.0071263295,
-0.024644278,
0.0443277135,
0.0340068229,
0.0310068745,
0.033174023,
0.0036622824,
0.0109509313,
0.0580228046,
0.0149293896,
0.0186994448,
-0.0385168716,
-0.0116326259,
0.0236750674,
-0.0196876787,
0.0147163002,
0.0235316735,
0.0490922891,
-0.0735075995,
-0.0338066444,
0.0966857374,
0.014182358,
-0.0340737253,
0.02145111,
0.0258111525,
0.0423470587,
0.0032065699,
0.0063699321,
-0.0866335258,
-0.0382635593,
0.0115661453,
0.0333747789,
-0.0011776445,
-0.0241081826,
-0.0022124771,
-0.1116854697,
0.0247424785,
0.0083161406,
-0.0390650369,
-0.0502387807,
-0.0367729403,
-0.0358897746,
0.0031891786,
0.0122696264,
0.0361217707,
-0.0204752088,
-0.016347643,
0.023886146,
-0.0165102668,
-0.0665031001,
0.0263007209,
-0.0189387165,
0.0117096901,
0.0519470423,
-0.0109874159,
0.0178802647,
-0.0296355169,
0.0252552554,
0.0032873561,
0.0118177393,
0.0079168165,
0.0473219194,
-0.0164477937,
-0.0174209215,
-0.011668697,
0.0132380519,
-0.0456310324,
0.0056587015,
-0.0171835907,
0.0595818013,
-0.0072362465,
-0.0311968699,
-0.0076761274,
-0.0004368289,
-0.0062858695,
0.0628712326,
0.0441836379,
-0.0288495179,
-0.0717168301,
-0.0037042997,
0.0122007253,
-0.0908814371,
-0.0318023078,
0.0259286743,
0.0316342898,
-0.0749529153,
-0.0609332547,
-0.0467111357,
0.0022323637,
0.038789697,
-0.0273176041,
-0.0283945985,
0.0426397994,
0.0047953562,
-0.0615671277,
0.0456537828,
-0.0143820271,
-0.0020002676,
-0.078713879,
-0.0093318159,
0.0100107752,
-0.0149353771,
-0.0132964365,
0.0418648571,
-0.1239501238,
-0.0395747013,
0.0152696501,
0.0416398123,
0.0136947576,
0.046900399,
0.0062700631,
-0.0317654498,
0.0413991958,
0.0466126092,
-0.0599417724,
0.0285091847,
0.0350159369,
-0.0453939065,
-0.0143092526,
0.0229117423,
-0.0109505458,
0.0464432575,
0.0090465816,
0.064473927,
0.0028755683,
0.0091916025,
0.0211871788,
-0.0219015684,
0.0552747883,
-0.0128002483,
0.0310762506,
0.0094369836,
0.0461111255,
-0.0140176266,
0.0298461169,
-0.0526392162,
-0.0092728259,
0.0290076453,
-0.004684797,
0.0142406449,
0.019000696,
-0.0096323406,
-0.0063317209,
-0.0213589799,
0.0593678281,
-0.0265617184,
-0.0326768383,
0.0311881248,
-0.0119983228,
-0.0351684429,
-0.0301102437,
0.0126147727,
0.008549558,
-0.0260265321,
0.0244700909,
0.0073709129,
0.0355167612,
-0.0129406052,
0.0160030909,
-0.0374852382,
0.0026398399,
-0.0114524625,
-0.0277722273,
0.0488231033,
-0.0247140769,
0.0436134748,
0.0037297283,
0.0221093278,
-0.0225977916,
0.0459107459,
-0.0133358063,
-0.0280742217,
0.0078204153,
0.0184760187,
-0.0025549596,
-0.0088636046,
0.088342905,
0.0065965494,
0.0258883778,
0.0050886269,
0.0136564607,
-0.0486594699,
-0.0468109474,
-0.0378380641,
-0.0009465761,
-0.0125504732,
0.0134365512,
-0.0216326378,
-0.0483563729,
0.0531899258,
-0.0618574843,
0.0149743548,
-0.0218367204,
0.0515259095,
0.0289317351,
-0.0150372144,
-0.0337270387,
-0.0024237998,
0.0284155346,
0.0130144786,
-0.0164668113,
-0.0292430054,
-6.389228363e-33,
-0.0134042734,
-0.0025387916,
0.0318694972,
-0.0177498665,
-0.0577896573,
0.0206888765,
-0.0558184572,
0.0031809933,
0.0055375174,
-0.0112821944,
-0.01331673,
-0.0002497583,
0.0169942155,
0.0725411624,
0.0101894615,
-0.0217000488,
0.0729606077,
0.0067539103,
-0.0124270953,
0.0334854536,
0.0337837823,
0.0528612658,
0.042341277,
-0.018984763,
-0.058532089,
0.0089352056,
0.0169100426,
-0.0333398916,
0.0150704449,
0.0517706536,
-0.0167142563,
0.0336029939,
0.031192122,
-0.0760423616,
-0.0395434797,
0.0415660702,
-0.1024398133,
0.0235444717,
-0.0329471938,
0.0105850743,
-0.025841441,
-0.0459139235,
0.0559791028,
0.00695911,
0.0106018819,
-0.0446815714,
0.014088708,
-0.0220150929,
-0.0257188901,
-0.0470597334,
-0.0647453368,
0.0356225669,
-0.002957542,
-0.0176136494,
0.0083128344,
0.0794674456,
-0.0120940106,
0.034358196,
-0.0495453775,
-0.0033022268,
0.0292975549,
0.0805280134,
0.0374679603,
0.0106893368,
-0.0037049847,
0.0334676951,
0.0043647569,
-0.0238821898,
-0.0489971787,
0.0197280962,
0.013774869,
0.0345880277,
0.0375565328,
-0.0274974722,
0.0618120506,
-0.0129186362,
-0.0589564517,
-0.017954167,
-0.0322748609,
0.0827207938,
0.0482946672,
0.0108901141,
-0.0051405816,
0.0102418596,
-0.0019739375,
0.020040188,
-0.0196041763,
-0.0023344837,
0.032084927,
0.0774098188,
-0.0083769141,
0.0015147182,
0.0777306557,
-0.01243068,
0.0208695009,
0.0234604273,
0.0173261948,
0.0096343504,
-0.0135199837,
0.0070757046,
-0.0435671993,
0.0026185045,
0.0423081256,
0.0042823073,
-0.0062388899,
-0.0194339901,
0.0168175772,
0.0315449685,
-0.0708635971,
-0.0199728794,
-0.0487863868,
0.0514117219,
-0.014544284,
0.0515362136,
0.0602072924,
0.0000755682,
-0.0249744523,
0.0702131093,
-0.0518676378,
-0.013537799,
-0.0093857003,
0.0255217683,
0.0242715981,
0.0424485803,
-0.0334320404,
0.0149800526,
-0.070845969,
0.0255596563,
0.0170876738,
-0.0691081658,
-0.0302083176,
0.0351930931,
2.687e-7,
0.0142257521,
0.022694828,
0.0620332137,
0.0056938473,
0.0215388536,
-0.0122006917,
0.0330503657,
0.034927275,
-0.0360285006,
0.0240462832,
-0.012247513,
-0.0006640313,
0.0420865603,
0.0051118727,
-0.086033538,
-0.0233261883,
-0.0723559931,
0.0018975929,
-0.0507320985,
-0.0314972326,
0.0472636707,
0.1048008353,
-0.0451691002,
0.0021703923,
0.0427862108,
-0.0076761311,
0.0521706864,
0.0195625611,
0.0283461343,
0.0053192298,
0.0237728637,
0.0001976505,
-0.0066665905,
-0.0089468732,
-0.032195989,
0.0050284811,
-0.0161548257,
0.0750170648,
0.0111422502,
-0.0728795305,
0.0368352793,
0.0179608203,
-0.0278990585,
-0.0058059157,
0.0403365269,
-0.1036242992,
-0.0170509405,
-0.0000846019,
-0.0609035902,
0.0278779455,
-0.0495657325,
0.0032241163,
0.0177547708,
0.0178800933,
0.0278093927,
-0.0092404578,
0.0059413803,
-0.0946460366,
-0.0130469827,
-0.0128803216,
-0.0690352991,
0.0034963896,
-0.0755816549,
-0.0192863345,
0.0531333052,
0.0037390345,
-0.043941278,
2.535563814e-34,
0.0254756045,
-0.018333314,
0.0022656894,
0.0179122128,
0.0103127379,
-0.0252189506,
-0.0107135074,
0.0154279079,
-0.0004666925,
-0.0918406993,
-0.0482128747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12439v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12439v2 | PoisonPrompt: Backdoor Attack on Prompt-based Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T03:25:28 | 2023-12-18T13:20:46 | Hongwei Yao, Jian Lou, Zhan Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompts have significantly improved the performance of pretrained Large
Language Models (LLMs) on various downstream tasks recently, making them
increasingly indispensable for a diverse range of LLM application scenarios.
However, the backdoor vulnerability, a serious security threat that can
maliciously alter the victim model's normal predictions, has not been
sufficiently explored for prompt-based LLMs. In this paper, we present
POISONPROMPT, a novel backdoor attack capable of successfully compromising both
hard and soft prompt-based LLMs. We evaluate the effectiveness, fidelity, and
robustness of POISONPROMPT through extensive experiments on three popular
prompt methods, using six datasets and three widely used LLMs. Our findings
highlight the potential security threats posed by backdoor attacks on
prompt-based LLMs and emphasize the need for further research in this area. | [
0.021540774,
0.0661358908,
0.0079644658,
0.0551468208,
-0.0330734625,
-0.0026882393,
0.0727482811,
-0.0265797023,
0.0391702838,
-0.0466766842,
-0.05495416,
-0.0191542897,
0.0226828177,
0.0261916704,
0.0664064586,
0.0289083011,
0.0599740073,
-0.0612790175,
-0.042089019,
-0.0307340026,
-0.0292922482,
-0.0211193133,
-0.0021154068,
0.0394788235,
0.0052255969,
-0.0205784999,
-0.0361075886,
0.0174197406,
0.0192601476,
-0.0261996426,
-0.0022769994,
0.0384837463,
0.0064155967,
0.095635727,
0.0000019275,
-0.0355913192,
-0.0272061992,
0.0250360835,
-0.0597593449,
0.0547648706,
-0.0122809,
-0.0015852118,
-0.0515565984,
0.0402146988,
-0.0123429466,
0.002176139,
0.013648889,
0.0378670581,
0.0698721409,
0.0936513096,
0.0018992493,
0.0075037647,
0.0285121351,
-0.0540152639,
0.0054818569,
-0.036406111,
0.0280014724,
-0.0765829012,
-0.0247709099,
0.0340304151,
0.0022225932,
-0.000183684,
0.0053901188,
-0.0207912419,
-0.0660770163,
0.0433721021,
0.0099727875,
-0.028618101,
-0.0352390222,
0.0538363159,
-0.0512111038,
0.0195449013,
-0.0055770157,
-0.0097949067,
0.0063478504,
0.0024948863,
0.0286531877,
0.0544478744,
0.009159917,
-0.0011957986,
-0.0061099436,
-0.0385398157,
0.0443127975,
0.0113318302,
-0.0104258023,
0.0513084121,
0.0385457985,
-0.0267574005,
0.0213513337,
-0.0273978524,
0.0123378253,
-0.0647342801,
-0.0087635629,
0.0089025106,
-0.0292763449,
0.0166026633,
-0.0621700995,
-0.0150142144,
0.0425414145,
-0.0290733892,
0.0555579662,
0.01065889,
-0.0456147566,
0.0303167775,
-0.0119816288,
0.0362139344,
-0.0176303238,
0.0461777039,
0.0247295424,
0.0327635854,
0.0075380439,
-0.0039202641,
-0.0130495876,
-0.0044489405,
-0.0129843019,
-0.0184575506,
-0.027806744,
0.0254469775,
-0.001721247,
0.0393446647,
0.0028304639,
-0.0157793798,
-0.0226541124,
0.0212777294,
0.0117863398,
-0.0087780962,
0.0051216935,
-0.0092124175,
-0.001066213,
-0.0712108985,
-0.0329297036,
-0.0033341944,
-0.0491172597,
-0.0367600881,
0.0018519813,
0.068832159,
0.0115722846,
-0.0339484885,
-0.0475051999,
-0.0674835443,
-0.0282467101,
-0.0254567321,
-0.0098575586,
-0.06239466,
-0.0046208478,
-0.0282002743,
-0.0018100044,
-0.0399450548,
0.0015620373,
0.0052893306,
-0.0262185931,
0.0713319853,
-0.0166400019,
-0.0189887621,
0.0232182909,
0.0119017204,
-0.0154795889,
0.0455996767,
-0.0114664799,
0.0712529644,
0.0477869362,
-0.0314165279,
0.024799861,
0.0487616546,
0.0315459818,
0.037876755,
-0.0379311442,
0.0101678874,
0.0726485401,
0.0056712166,
-0.0185615737,
0.0648063049,
-0.0042694951,
-0.0352827385,
0.1135979965,
0.0355490632,
-0.0170788188,
-0.0039586341,
0.0099933371,
-0.0077061942,
0.0004463218,
-0.0068520708,
-0.0935752615,
-0.0397465751,
-0.0838045627,
-0.0210380666,
0.0243835654,
0.0385150164,
-0.0070511787,
-0.0082309796,
0.0211205222,
-0.0376005918,
-0.0223203618,
0.0317627527,
0.032503359,
0.0162768122,
-0.0105230482,
0.0180799626,
0.0120849758,
-0.0238759276,
-0.023386579,
-0.0719941556,
-0.0099948244,
0.0553667583,
0.0358385891,
-0.0162852146,
0.0014761431,
-0.0451559238,
-0.0014482564,
0.0242590867,
0.0195807815,
0.0158531778,
0.0095516583,
-0.0216181986,
-0.0165942721,
0.0024810629,
0.0085920971,
0.0191386025,
0.0060548503,
0.0356820635,
0.0145479878,
0.0388857834,
-0.0198137742,
0.0432313085,
-0.0193909705,
-0.0574708059,
0.0321347974,
0.0326609537,
0.0100278445,
0.0058434522,
-0.0260027554,
0.0271790083,
0.0515022613,
0.0190051775,
0.011122033,
-0.0449477732,
-0.0267584212,
-0.0297968183,
0.0426480845,
0.0381969362,
-0.0076739094,
0.0519752838,
-0.048448544,
-0.0355507582,
0.0068174922,
-0.025527807,
0.0038652257,
-0.0149502754,
0.0296740606,
-0.0138423136,
0.0537698567,
-0.0325359739,
0.0123957163,
0.0040408578,
-0.0066641001,
0.0030597444,
0.0430837795,
-0.004666822,
-0.0385751314,
-0.0812948942,
0.0156764779,
-0.0107614528,
0.0048506092,
-0.0110781705,
-0.0067258496,
-0.033456333,
-0.0021826455,
-0.0410971642,
-0.0031307195,
-0.0326933078,
0.020107992,
0.0167916678,
-0.0061191553,
-0.0407986492,
-0.0355384089,
-0.0113583095,
-0.0159881301,
-0.0195115283,
0.0362569205,
-0.0020655431,
-0.0011320662,
-0.0103465458,
-0.0070005422,
-0.0239455029,
-0.0065564504,
0.0711567104,
-0.015234435,
-0.0025165225,
-0.0520714261,
0.0340303853,
0.0025900586,
0.0397586115,
-0.0076369126,
-0.0400579087,
0.0333959423,
-0.000345215,
0.0066123158,
0.0841264129,
0.0331801102,
0.0281338543,
0.0862595066,
0.0044377395,
-0.0405999757,
-0.0150136873,
0.0093144467,
-0.0661651269,
-0.0525810644,
0.0024204622,
0.0007727037,
0.0475714318,
0.0288303047,
-0.0316076577,
-0.0047334796,
0.0214161016,
0.007336624,
-0.0161915105,
-0.0550713427,
-0.0225391909,
-0.0350284576,
0.0170961283,
0.0153951505,
-0.087083295,
0.0632441789,
-0.0774960965,
0.0193979498,
0.007374811,
-0.0380834863,
0.012940987,
0.0574597195,
-0.0055288025,
0.0004337087,
0.0303678475,
-0.0497586578,
-0.0332536884,
-0.0092561152,
0.0132667851,
-0.0255708359,
0.0157993417,
-0.0095329257,
-0.0098494245,
-0.0345133729,
-0.0419111848,
-0.0562473759,
-0.0845471844,
-0.0333530866,
-0.0142007964,
-0.0090538701,
-0.0191452559,
-0.011705149,
-0.0310877096,
0.0333127193,
0.0155130792,
-0.0353968777,
0.011390591,
-0.0299743637,
0.0063983859,
0.0614132658,
-0.0324085914,
0.0332313143,
-0.0247843191,
0.0614146926,
0.062026903,
0.0282402206,
0.0068417899,
-0.0421845019,
-0.0005410552,
0.0194000117,
-0.0113821262,
-0.0061627966,
0.0323925093,
0.0152367568,
-0.0378705002,
-0.0042939568,
0.0651169568,
0.0092156921,
-0.0852442831,
-0.005840919,
0.0296784528,
0.0066599352,
0.0001455295,
0.0059678536,
-0.0843040496,
-0.0326504298,
0.0514274128,
0.0432450846,
-0.0273023453,
-0.0173093099,
-0.0147201503,
-0.1370764375,
0.0138197364,
0.0028385394,
-0.0279368609,
-0.0026622049,
-0.0480062515,
-0.0234342068,
0.0253104437,
0.0717684478,
0.0064971023,
0.0008516072,
-0.023817081,
-0.0002320264,
0.0124013377,
-0.0386036485,
0.0289747808,
-0.0320179872,
0.0626859739,
0.0670276061,
-0.021213429,
-0.0222303327,
-0.000294693,
0.0664852411,
-0.0110879075,
-0.0018098621,
0.0182455238,
0.0376146026,
-0.0091925822,
-0.0301685315,
0.0184149612,
0.0455236621,
-0.015603085,
0.003338828,
0.0411264896,
0.0460694991,
-0.0365864597,
-0.0024083531,
-0.0002282785,
-0.0259199291,
0.051225625,
0.0549391471,
0.0203785785,
-0.0598570555,
-0.0181591343,
-0.0445927531,
-0.0128871854,
0.0270631146,
-0.0539650768,
0.0458728597,
0.0007968023,
-0.0437525101,
-0.0228757728,
-0.0057980698,
0.015621854,
0.0275887214,
0.0206875466,
0.0045549106,
-0.0254534259,
0.0171951968,
-0.0247428976,
0.0437150188,
-0.024222726,
0.0733528361,
-0.0958287194,
0.0202751905,
0.0159043949,
-0.0106492499,
-0.0073792585,
0.0216928646,
-0.0766013935,
-0.0867383108,
0.0125414748,
0.0377416648,
0.0220941119,
0.0392098762,
-0.0334018096,
-0.0684810653,
0.112783283,
0.0176164582,
-0.0250169467,
0.0171013623,
0.0574101023,
-0.0116459755,
0.0017322216,
0.036519438,
-0.0444168672,
-0.023204973,
0.10052751,
-0.0166570302,
0.0003156266,
-0.029370347,
-0.0137780942,
0.0425418466,
0.0918157995,
-0.0346352756,
0.0119778523,
-0.0137683954,
0.054139372,
-0.0198832601,
-0.0148962867,
-0.0073822429,
0.0309913717,
0.0231630653,
-0.0142600713,
0.0391414165,
-0.0218170732,
0.0292571448,
0.0253081284,
-0.040143203,
0.0368797295,
0.0267162416,
0.0358852074,
0.0925041959,
0.003318842,
-0.0292779654,
0.0626721904,
0.0193210449,
0.0245265644,
-0.0053670816,
0.031039454,
0.0015077454,
-0.0084489333,
-0.0342092589,
0.0538701117,
-0.065045476,
-0.0691680908,
0.0059758453,
0.0520455949,
0.0125600714,
0.0163336452,
-0.0215458926,
-0.017969206,
-0.0059571159,
-0.0381556936,
-0.0046417462,
0.011081418,
-0.0260078106,
0.0343177691,
-0.0220637619,
-0.0201696735,
0.0553748347,
0.0732161626,
-0.005764911,
0.0562256835,
0.0162855312,
-0.0274071358,
-0.0136359585,
-0.029627027,
0.0137111144,
-0.0103642307,
-0.059002813,
-0.0426582173,
-0.0186561923,
-0.0798540339,
-0.0070522875,
-0.0038214389,
-0.008788107,
0.0256231241,
-0.0091695441,
0.0353661366,
0.0118714524,
0.049786143,
-0.0558215268,
0.0377146788,
0.0137878787,
-0.0519144312,
0.0186802242,
-5.690365747e-33,
0.0285099111,
-0.0182476304,
-0.0190117266,
-0.0037595658,
0.0060971975,
0.0276311915,
-0.0097070849,
0.0101754609,
-0.0164329018,
-0.0189273581,
-0.0488218702,
-0.0024200147,
0.0258788001,
0.0382839106,
-0.016700238,
-0.0282419454,
0.0118785184,
-0.0256063249,
-0.0295666847,
0.0330732837,
0.0706462786,
0.0320778191,
0.0270100646,
-0.0119591355,
0.0351668745,
-0.0047805919,
-0.0360049419,
0.0111304447,
-0.0708313733,
0.0647934228,
-0.006842975,
0.0284565408,
-0.0148635805,
-0.051316902,
-0.0132789621,
0.0745587647,
0.0043336856,
0.0042283805,
-0.0480807126,
0.0093297446,
0.0082776053,
-0.0540298969,
0.0228683911,
-0.0275728852,
-0.0107073179,
-0.0021568036,
-0.006155069,
-0.0134258894,
-0.0280568842,
-0.0257409979,
0.0065494194,
-0.0027267304,
-0.0038340089,
-0.011146374,
0.0116517954,
0.0046273782,
0.0157309901,
-0.0023836428,
-0.0381355509,
0.0381605141,
0.0567167178,
0.0299762953,
0.0447574258,
0.0287921149,
0.0164644551,
0.0535120703,
0.0505879745,
-0.0185012259,
-0.0049953186,
0.0125252102,
0.0128851412,
0.0317120142,
0.0450563058,
0.0376465209,
0.0285671391,
-0.0379105546,
-0.0691471919,
0.0023200894,
0.0483975671,
-0.0127037875,
0.0377758071,
-0.0225381684,
-0.0248431489,
-0.0028790112,
-0.0489748977,
-0.0060684038,
-0.0410971045,
-0.0112308618,
0.0197235011,
0.0118753333,
-0.0166325904,
-0.0150213111,
0.0355948657,
-0.0362447314,
-0.0231617261,
0.0215039328,
0.0105332211,
-0.0250168908,
-0.0033430629,
0.0195284039,
-0.007071441,
-0.0208810512,
-0.0084124953,
-0.0630231351,
0.0311630163,
-0.0008404876,
0.023168141,
0.0389605239,
-0.0823728889,
0.0072712759,
-0.0324845985,
0.0380678624,
0.0475662872,
0.0378828496,
0.041357629,
-0.0412367471,
0.0138851041,
0.0372844823,
0.0143523654,
-0.0030772525,
-0.0142547777,
0.0242761355,
-0.008858351,
0.0188895185,
-0.0039916928,
-0.0036287978,
-0.0078816358,
0.0464225039,
0.0523838624,
-0.0339538231,
0.0241136756,
-0.0183733329,
2.717e-7,
-0.0073829051,
0.0044552009,
0.0068965191,
0.0074938168,
0.0229956433,
0.0638961866,
-0.0488206968,
0.0694678575,
-0.0074778129,
-0.0246528201,
-0.0145467138,
-0.0083387718,
0.0599061176,
0.0130337644,
-0.0710792243,
0.0159473345,
-0.0975745469,
0.0257411767,
-0.0963066891,
0.0085644573,
0.0219318662,
0.1275715679,
-0.0023372287,
-0.0424318761,
0.016354043,
-0.0541821122,
0.008822714,
-0.0348949917,
-0.0237109214,
-0.0205159616,
0.0652628541,
0.0105645526,
0.0033377272,
0.042553436,
-0.0357583761,
0.0007261091,
-0.0606722198,
0.0344386362,
0.0350007154,
-0.0621357895,
-0.0236377586,
-0.0380907208,
-0.0021309934,
-0.031061627,
0.0829733759,
-0.0020831379,
-0.0158633236,
-0.0396296419,
0.010056952,
-0.0741123036,
0.0598937012,
-0.0720759407,
0.0294625126,
0.0216104258,
0.0022408743,
-0.016227806,
0.0118947225,
-0.0926262811,
-0.0248546991,
-0.0433429591,
-0.0318855196,
-0.0641728044,
-0.0238713808,
0.0241298992,
-0.0079703424,
-0.0216962006,
0.0034128092,
2.51271124e-34,
0.0078656655,
-0.0345264152,
0.0046893139,
0.0138469609,
0.033420153,
-0.0063983425,
0.0301381815,
0.0103257848,
-0.0175793078,
-0.0731219798,
-0.0406233855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12430v1 | DocXChain: A Powerful Open-Source Toolchain for Document Parsing and Beyond | 2023-10-19T02:49:09 | 2023-10-19T02:49:09 | Cong Yao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this report, we introduce DocXChain, a powerful open-source toolchain for
document parsing, which is designed and developed to automatically convert the
rich information embodied in unstructured documents, such as text, tables and
charts, into structured representations that are readable and manipulable by
machines. Specifically, basic capabilities, including text detection, text
recognition, table structure recognition and layout analysis, are provided.
Upon these basic capabilities, we also build a set of fully functional
pipelines for document parsing, i.e., general text reading, table parsing, and
document structurization, to drive various applications related to documents in
real-world scenarios. Moreover, DocXChain is concise, modularized and flexible,
such that it can be readily integrated with existing tools, libraries or models
(such as LangChain and ChatGPT), to construct more powerful systems that can
accomplish more complicated and challenging tasks. The code of DocXChain is
publicly available
at:~\url{https://github.com/AlibabaResearch/AdvancedLiterateMachinery/tree/main/Applications/DocXChain} | [
-0.0090860166,
0.0487610139,
0.0099287564,
0.0585858487,
-0.0382688232,
0.0479373522,
-0.0489632376,
0.03005182,
0.0049157483,
-0.0333820619,
-0.0440797843,
0.0511324555,
-0.0198638774,
0.0635918826,
-0.0342429876,
-0.0327145457,
0.0352437161,
0.0056840926,
0.0219122414,
0.0516992211,
0.0154698594,
-0.0086063826,
-0.0074172853,
-0.0281700324,
-0.0016894486,
-0.0250507314,
-0.0227483511,
0.0116008557,
-0.0064516128,
-0.0135033363,
0.0019310717,
0.0331646651,
-0.008379831,
0.0749555007,
0.0000021616,
-0.0025309811,
-0.0452246517,
0.0091373948,
0.014723761,
-0.0464827865,
0.0581461675,
-0.0750264004,
-0.0429124609,
-0.0419913195,
-0.0497491769,
-0.0210484751,
0.0116075166,
0.0551753081,
0.0377318487,
0.0620292053,
-0.030507179,
-0.0123876072,
0.0123934019,
0.0238988418,
0.0249307062,
-0.0062052133,
-0.0075207036,
0.0285171587,
0.0288246777,
0.0270460397,
0.0101408269,
0.0300926622,
0.003014127,
-0.0451962017,
0.0081985323,
0.0233452022,
-0.0256100185,
0.0147193624,
-0.0225200318,
0.0570903905,
-0.0062959031,
0.0040115421,
0.0596550703,
-0.0203571655,
-0.0003800623,
0.0046231626,
-0.0583787933,
-0.0051955967,
-0.0097942334,
0.0096815387,
0.0002441096,
-0.0060149645,
-0.0048922026,
0.0125338566,
-0.0043989629,
0.0599751137,
-0.0297036115,
-0.0424838327,
0.0302166436,
-0.0188341681,
0.0268833004,
-0.0426556617,
0.0550386384,
0.0271551311,
0.0456927978,
-0.0156641603,
-0.0108813066,
-0.0955628455,
0.0231448021,
-0.0600114949,
0.0116540045,
-0.002299529,
-0.0087573919,
0.0770954341,
-0.0299646221,
0.0111564137,
-0.0364667363,
0.0290712826,
-0.0301483367,
0.0117838653,
-0.027264744,
0.0222407524,
-0.0154260453,
-0.0084770136,
-0.0932226628,
-0.0458554998,
0.0334094912,
0.0287067238,
0.0099642696,
0.0502689257,
-0.0027616092,
-0.0249350071,
0.0095716361,
0.000914861,
0.0136705916,
0.0215444677,
-0.0156024713,
-0.0150532462,
-0.0168462228,
-0.0173272248,
0.000819725,
0.0443010516,
0.0877083465,
-0.0204190798,
0.0140559785,
0.0535447262,
-0.0114957951,
-0.0139808282,
-0.0215505697,
-0.0465252027,
0.0161418822,
-0.0141674522,
0.0504257083,
-0.055257611,
0.045012854,
-0.0226342771,
0.0049215434,
0.0042560082,
-0.0001111915,
0.0020588012,
-0.0239942372,
0.038550619,
-0.0381161459,
-0.0071906243,
0.0343805626,
-0.0289046988,
-0.042588871,
0.0365186259,
0.0340509787,
0.0815797895,
0.02432069,
-0.0308648236,
0.0012839158,
0.0547077991,
-0.0384026654,
-0.0885585025,
0.0749037787,
0.0276875701,
0.0040938258,
0.0047811735,
0.0120078409,
-0.0096059302,
-0.0134809595,
0.0182300061,
0.0182665233,
0.0439045131,
0.0227576159,
0.0280635916,
-0.0154751232,
0.0168598369,
0.0283623878,
-0.0071062315,
-0.0329468884,
-0.0087966006,
0.0250136983,
0.030144304,
-0.0866692737,
-0.0061882213,
0.0250624325,
-0.0211068615,
0.0079112379,
0.0044093975,
0.0335157998,
-0.0535181202,
0.0960887596,
0.0238525905,
-0.0848361701,
-0.0187201705,
-0.0148493489,
-0.057657782,
-0.0430915654,
0.0129628778,
0.0068399231,
0.0208057761,
0.0647330955,
-0.0904101878,
0.012940309,
0.0002472102,
0.0244105197,
0.0061628241,
0.0304654408,
-0.0552979521,
-0.0098819872,
-0.0278482027,
-0.0306247119,
0.0489488654,
0.0036093807,
0.01853697,
-0.0048069553,
0.0026200158,
0.004510487,
-0.0640697181,
-0.0296119656,
0.0627086088,
0.0243881885,
-0.0248125363,
-0.0045250873,
0.0181679353,
0.0229682475,
0.0557612404,
-0.0126360105,
0.012218086,
0.0638718158,
-0.0216274969,
0.0477072485,
-0.0032110189,
-0.0427961089,
0.021340901,
0.0260808542,
-0.016470829,
-0.0460893363,
-0.0062172161,
-0.058188051,
-0.0497964062,
0.0164695121,
-0.0051087402,
-0.0247547571,
-0.0052619129,
-0.013272034,
-0.0191465132,
0.0135159306,
-0.0012032617,
0.0509426519,
-0.0083711687,
-0.0127289388,
-0.0334497057,
-0.0539083555,
0.0089482665,
0.0040077884,
0.0320625603,
-0.0153235514,
-0.021484131,
-0.0030820908,
-0.0127778947,
0.043420691,
-0.0492151082,
-0.0478296727,
-0.0644249469,
0.0076878886,
-0.0165951904,
0.071222581,
0.0525028035,
0.0003034463,
-0.0219516475,
-0.0535197407,
-0.0254215058,
0.0233296026,
0.006534121,
-0.055297751,
0.0518547483,
-0.0176669974,
0.0093359202,
-0.0054659797,
-0.0126178041,
-0.0297329035,
-0.0207777079,
0.0263037402,
-0.0934959128,
0.023829855,
-0.0373435169,
0.0435635932,
0.0199004244,
0.0218097046,
0.0236702152,
-0.0306109656,
-0.0377776548,
0.0038128712,
0.0640610307,
-0.0453796908,
0.0497274771,
-0.010972389,
-0.0287864786,
-0.0042560659,
0.0123599898,
0.0028604728,
0.0868700296,
-0.005667612,
-0.0499746203,
0.0576967075,
0.0488302074,
-0.0119632371,
0.0442753434,
0.012886717,
-0.0504398756,
-0.0061206724,
0.0113739325,
-0.0089446213,
0.0088186758,
-0.0044455132,
-0.0052060825,
-0.0133991567,
-0.0072241765,
0.0121820085,
-0.0722648874,
-0.016102694,
-0.0332991779,
-0.0262022037,
-0.0565353408,
0.0770322084,
0.0593729764,
0.0039232615,
-0.0322367698,
-0.0548771098,
0.0252743531,
0.0119345384,
0.0350684486,
-0.0095096808,
-0.0009932151,
-0.0407061838,
0.0325736403,
-0.0412746146,
0.0017439862,
0.0168959908,
0.0257515647,
-0.0159881376,
-0.0065239128,
0.042682685,
0.0041278224,
-0.0370595194,
-0.0175087526,
-0.0016172604,
0.099065654,
0.0129787866,
-0.0036744233,
-0.0503281429,
0.0899970308,
-0.0122672813,
-0.0147201028,
0.0040600691,
-0.0016755604,
0.0054058195,
0.0872719362,
-0.0240023732,
-0.0477261618,
-0.0055100629,
0.0319547541,
-0.0276025888,
-0.0401972272,
0.038721431,
-0.0414039418,
-0.0301726665,
-0.0784378424,
0.0051592337,
0.0656908378,
0.0294772778,
-0.043184258,
-0.0670953616,
-0.0385607034,
-0.0044693975,
-0.0034109822,
0.0212670788,
-0.104986839,
0.0009657075,
0.0361744203,
0.0164389126,
0.0338746533,
-0.0343788601,
0.0049703526,
-0.0124892192,
0.0515544675,
0.0106296288,
-0.0418918915,
-0.0436246991,
-0.0484151095,
-0.0131120337,
-0.0323750228,
-0.0511737131,
0.0435637012,
-0.0249283127,
-0.0169578772,
-0.0295416154,
-0.0529676229,
0.0243689008,
-0.0207635369,
-0.0230834298,
-0.0373109728,
0.0824970603,
0.0648236722,
-0.0026070839,
-0.0018871677,
0.0742128119,
0.0230297651,
-0.0152008589,
-0.0612610914,
0.0219828021,
0.0070512788,
0.0154277477,
-0.0285538752,
0.0658844635,
-0.0462936386,
0.0026516747,
0.0292259958,
0.0406540781,
-0.0043521076,
-0.0216910113,
-0.0164980236,
-0.0476882122,
0.0244452264,
0.0331618339,
0.0192918219,
0.0340314321,
-0.1073189005,
-0.0464114398,
-0.0041379523,
-0.0196917057,
0.0568712503,
0.0267566703,
-0.0302508418,
-0.0193304177,
-0.0620751306,
0.0091930144,
0.022166783,
0.0251551121,
-0.0202619862,
-0.0308744665,
0.0232480746,
-0.0189834591,
-0.0370475836,
0.0148914745,
-0.0201916415,
0.0058551743,
-0.0452611148,
-0.0114635434,
-0.0191451795,
-0.0153200552,
-0.0374012589,
0.0099853147,
-0.0399090834,
-0.0040889219,
0.0308998208,
0.0038220957,
0.0159760565,
0.0036450096,
-0.0272259824,
0.036710497,
-0.0194032658,
0.0136197777,
-0.1017889604,
-0.0462389216,
0.0006512822,
-0.0144004496,
-0.0215816293,
0.0044786483,
-0.0244967993,
0.0385339782,
-0.0286793448,
0.0013728801,
-0.0138965202,
0.0359504558,
0.0012301693,
0.0353639871,
-0.0102101425,
0.0449261479,
-0.018170191,
-0.0317632519,
0.0021072854,
-0.0193560831,
-0.0222430844,
-0.007847053,
-0.0038809578,
-0.0084939841,
-0.0178394951,
0.0171379168,
0.0313832983,
0.0369673334,
0.0204222612,
-0.0028510028,
0.0461038575,
0.0409682319,
0.0181477387,
0.0071383822,
-0.0506956764,
-0.0045234393,
0.0070233792,
-0.0282831434,
0.0455693565,
-0.0213743243,
0.0324846841,
0.0142151536,
-0.0473814569,
-0.0375886038,
0.0250773486,
-0.0618765466,
0.0275956541,
-0.0341308825,
0.0268022735,
0.0055225929,
-0.0226374082,
0.0671933666,
-0.0521840788,
-0.0303997807,
0.0168027617,
0.0219421554,
0.0559502803,
-0.0018417643,
-0.0084968451,
-0.0113215297,
0.0087408349,
-0.0413338356,
0.0501524955,
0.0092982762,
-0.0267536603,
0.0491480306,
-0.0341357216,
-0.0861393586,
-0.0048405821,
-0.0011655752,
-0.0078876484,
-0.0409632325,
-0.0148956273,
0.010928221,
0.0209679808,
0.0235930774,
0.0680464953,
-0.0191986691,
0.0063192351,
-0.0170534998,
0.0189784653,
0.0433650166,
-0.0127274944,
-0.0228771735,
0.0539937876,
0.0111311786,
-0.0485227183,
-0.0090498738,
-5.862618648e-33,
-0.0176937357,
-0.0511825457,
-0.0236207582,
0.0398295857,
0.011077228,
-0.0472286791,
-0.0579959825,
-0.0214341432,
0.0088738753,
0.0043121236,
-0.0057682344,
-0.0128962928,
0.0396788456,
0.0126722204,
0.0332856141,
-0.0019387332,
0.019309802,
-0.0339363888,
-0.000704565,
0.0031274613,
0.008178289,
0.0484353714,
0.0298531763,
-0.0711164698,
0.0388309807,
-0.018890636,
-0.0028613927,
-0.0073766219,
0.0324394554,
-0.0322760977,
-0.028820565,
-0.0386349559,
0.0171383694,
-0.0039275065,
-0.0224462785,
0.0717370436,
-0.1885093749,
0.0071214535,
-0.0542175286,
0.0605792738,
-0.0067073661,
-0.0025863252,
0.0482479483,
-0.0153651759,
0.027128052,
-0.0137228947,
0.0187906139,
-0.0257092677,
-0.0143524306,
-0.0015736904,
-0.0350355469,
0.0535861664,
-0.001684945,
0.0273841806,
0.0878927112,
0.0119266724,
0.0349691473,
0.0017494337,
-0.0667524338,
-0.0043768128,
-0.0074185324,
-0.0036796893,
0.0511402301,
-0.020065723,
0.0234443173,
0.0229667183,
-0.0201337468,
-0.0191641916,
-0.0096412823,
0.0670825467,
-0.0305572245,
0.0555580594,
0.0300619584,
-0.0053057163,
0.0259670019,
0.0002220486,
-0.0283075497,
0.0393586792,
0.0105480803,
0.0605199449,
-0.0284564886,
0.0330042951,
-0.0080788713,
0.0134567115,
0.0533804893,
-0.0354953073,
-0.0163082462,
-0.0043806345,
0.0016612858,
-0.0027387878,
0.01249824,
-0.0103827287,
0.0028769372,
-0.0011010234,
-0.0299684927,
0.0119823199,
0.0327271037,
0.0418490544,
-0.0401017182,
-0.0332038216,
-0.006963423,
-0.0488462001,
-0.0041981568,
0.0118956864,
0.0272146929,
0.0024419944,
0.0405112579,
-0.0092006549,
-0.0349766649,
0.0253360774,
0.0014274071,
0.0425299928,
0.0435969494,
0.0749044567,
-0.004866797,
-0.038241256,
0.0213133879,
0.0262638759,
0.0243841372,
0.0278199296,
-0.013919143,
-0.0046368968,
-0.0173491966,
0.0134880869,
-0.014989784,
-0.0007806264,
-0.0372490436,
0.0129913213,
0.0438760035,
-0.0142327771,
0.0415564366,
0.0342324823,
2.629e-7,
0.0845273212,
0.0372889042,
0.0934227854,
-0.0266748667,
0.0263270121,
0.0149507159,
-0.0518003628,
0.0112115117,
-0.0695528686,
-0.0331804641,
0.0211226474,
-0.0428003706,
0.0806445852,
0.0397199839,
-0.0731592625,
-0.0064726709,
-0.0544551536,
-0.0388861746,
-0.0560053736,
0.0253669862,
0.0114093563,
0.0515941158,
-0.0559874848,
-0.0007434373,
0.0172432065,
-0.0282277893,
-0.0309662167,
-0.0407316126,
0.0793523416,
0.0069291685,
0.0116169937,
-0.0404039882,
-0.0399334468,
-0.0104167443,
-0.0070469528,
0.0375273153,
0.0197397657,
0.0665624887,
-0.0050202813,
0.0920801163,
0.0329930261,
-0.0640725791,
0.0333231874,
-0.041504439,
0.0492815785,
0.0023381261,
0.0091121523,
0.0051707127,
-0.0034089496,
0.0190029573,
-0.0476270802,
0.0067808623,
0.0101881782,
0.0318069384,
0.0376365855,
-0.0338049717,
0.0174411908,
-0.0582304634,
-0.0178057663,
-0.0170307998,
-0.0335919522,
0.0319870003,
-0.0229408517,
0.0377678871,
0.0087665385,
-0.0273599923,
-0.0413624495,
2.667094056e-34,
0.0319485553,
-0.0158220455,
-0.0276663005,
0.0738801584,
0.0665266514,
-0.0181225184,
0.005691838,
0.0282177255,
-0.0289505031,
-0.0837792903,
0.0153148323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12426v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12426v1 | MAF: Multi-Aspect Feedback for Improving Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-10-19T02:32:39 | 2023-10-19T02:32:39 | Deepak Nathani, David Wang, Liangming Pan, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language Models (LMs) have shown impressive performance in various natural
language tasks. However, when it comes to natural language reasoning, LMs still
face challenges such as hallucination, generating incorrect intermediate
reasoning steps, and making mathematical errors. Recent research has focused on
enhancing LMs through self-improvement using feedback. Nevertheless, existing
approaches relying on a single generic feedback source fail to address the
diverse error types found in LM-generated reasoning chains. In this work, we
propose Multi-Aspect Feedback, an iterative refinement framework that
integrates multiple feedback modules, including frozen LMs and external tools,
each focusing on a specific error category. Our experimental results
demonstrate the efficacy of our approach to addressing several errors in the
LM-generated reasoning chain and thus improving the overall performance of an
LM in several reasoning tasks. We see a relative improvement of up to 20% in
Mathematical Reasoning and up to 18% in Logical Entailment. | [
0.0456851982,
0.0451326333,
-0.0100084459,
0.0412911437,
-0.038889084,
0.0205800999,
-0.0056184144,
-0.0040105483,
0.0112657193,
-0.0566193834,
-0.0077514872,
-0.001215708,
-0.0042689992,
0.0009401159,
0.0207942594,
-0.0620468222,
0.0564846471,
-0.0770224482,
-0.0265092719,
-0.0036578553,
-0.0209814273,
0.0291896444,
-0.0233942773,
0.0072722603,
-0.0162162613,
-0.0213519409,
-0.0237308685,
0.0104998145,
0.0102166636,
-0.0396082848,
-0.0306671448,
0.052467905,
0.0180565324,
0.0292710718,
0.0000023367,
-0.071138218,
-0.0178099759,
-0.0185612589,
-0.0197961088,
0.0136360014,
0.0228382424,
0.0003237589,
0.0056270631,
0.0315809213,
0.0046005147,
0.0023589502,
0.0130976811,
0.0767634436,
0.0939090103,
0.0621964075,
0.0021765344,
-0.0351637155,
-0.0113407318,
0.0239788443,
0.0081884256,
-0.0142544154,
0.0206500348,
0.0850717127,
0.0420712046,
0.0006911486,
-0.009692858,
0.0454803705,
0.0588390157,
-0.0145531418,
-0.0079311505,
0.0353822485,
-0.0085817333,
-0.0243053548,
0.0345063955,
0.0336576216,
0.0014999659,
-0.0473050587,
-0.0428809002,
-0.0071740248,
0.0203421935,
0.0001323656,
-0.0325214118,
0.025774803,
-0.0267185234,
0.0052634706,
0.0184407048,
-0.0481833108,
0.0290024355,
0.02326422,
-0.0572894961,
0.1009993702,
-0.007067597,
-0.0477406792,
0.0083885668,
0.005091921,
-0.0625007078,
-0.0353126936,
0.0137601616,
0.058298178,
-0.0722849593,
0.0123924641,
-0.0148229394,
0.005379308,
-0.0003529045,
-0.058370579,
0.0398393571,
0.0261830781,
-0.0126300789,
0.0404931195,
-0.0170762539,
0.0313588418,
-0.0071449955,
0.053670913,
-0.0312673599,
-0.0038403415,
-0.0588432848,
-0.0197606869,
-0.021861149,
0.0433797017,
0.0380224958,
0.0098319016,
-0.0274852496,
0.0303426553,
-0.0120255239,
0.0646505132,
0.0029160962,
-0.0146705573,
0.0202686917,
-0.0516221486,
-0.0700730532,
0.0304317679,
-0.0314285569,
0.0300740935,
0.0033663693,
-0.0124440352,
-0.0188262183,
0.0079006646,
-0.0181997307,
-0.0113918958,
0.00992864,
0.0417692289,
0.0018441514,
-0.0084246714,
-0.0439088494,
-0.040855363,
0.0054365476,
-0.0854261443,
-0.0191433951,
-0.085414499,
-0.0114045143,
-0.0197803453,
-0.0157506187,
-0.0125946272,
0.0290051103,
-0.022929864,
-0.0353247859,
0.08386565,
-0.0285909921,
0.0157229286,
0.02067017,
0.022735728,
0.0435598791,
0.051061023,
0.0151322661,
-0.0229126904,
0.0192619655,
-0.0133048659,
0.0497670919,
-0.0000590408,
0.0057416186,
-0.0020997054,
-0.0298420116,
-0.0005260036,
-0.0323902592,
0.0376855768,
-0.0207523834,
0.0376891233,
-0.0297850911,
0.0240603406,
0.0392554589,
0.0000255995,
0.0373306684,
0.0231153741,
0.0001360712,
-0.0391012169,
-0.0013561914,
0.0118545825,
-0.0697662979,
0.0513370074,
-0.0356556438,
0.011606764,
0.0353452638,
-0.0198073536,
-0.0398195721,
-0.0944498405,
-0.0455259718,
0.0339471735,
-0.0153907249,
0.0272036642,
0.0798482299,
0.0334104858,
-0.0318342522,
0.0398631319,
0.0083882408,
-0.0504599921,
0.0085186316,
-0.0440551303,
0.0418658778,
0.0935371965,
0.0511096902,
-0.0547232628,
-0.0481077768,
-0.0254742727,
-0.0220883191,
0.0454600751,
0.0246091243,
-0.0033845101,
-0.0479148962,
-0.0335990041,
-0.006992605,
-0.0013541039,
0.0265302211,
-0.0013395272,
0.022021424,
-0.0195547342,
0.0109990779,
-0.0069431788,
0.0191239174,
0.0187048335,
0.0175920669,
-0.0149114002,
0.0012438974,
-0.0201249793,
0.0161616411,
0.0039424114,
0.0067015337,
0.0272037107,
0.0094457688,
-0.0123186922,
-0.0903487802,
0.0414098799,
-0.0221633594,
-0.0444210283,
0.0528566651,
0.0410048366,
-0.0267996695,
-0.0136018451,
-0.0656587556,
-0.0294621177,
0.0543115847,
-0.0016056661,
0.0150745772,
-0.0251872353,
0.0533810109,
-0.006915153,
-0.042578619,
-0.0275668371,
0.0514280647,
-0.0224781521,
0.0289189313,
-0.0536078066,
0.0400158316,
-0.0063378494,
-0.0160676036,
0.0159806851,
0.0207735468,
-0.0090869553,
0.0213957019,
-0.0069779097,
-0.003830571,
-0.0679130107,
-0.0237271786,
-0.0466758274,
-0.0063792695,
-0.0035065911,
0.0129198907,
0.0073270509,
-0.0024506664,
-0.0008256643,
-0.0028567614,
0.0133318529,
-0.0319911093,
0.0447439328,
0.0091879526,
0.0191139467,
-0.0094310557,
-0.0200142935,
-0.005902891,
-0.0052188728,
-0.0429291502,
0.0158108491,
-0.0100792143,
0.0142874587,
-0.0833155066,
0.0408685431,
-0.0521355309,
0.0336787105,
0.0002898702,
0.0106027853,
0.0168430358,
-0.0154461712,
0.0148037318,
0.0760641545,
-0.0145084346,
0.0298007745,
0.0634309053,
-0.0281955004,
-0.0518921427,
0.0297040045,
-0.0247769821,
-0.0088139679,
0.0077493475,
0.009889462,
-0.0554186627,
0.0334155858,
0.002329102,
0.0097296573,
-0.040149074,
0.0470407717,
-0.0261174999,
-0.0086688353,
-0.0221428704,
-0.0296627544,
0.0018822446,
0.0517323054,
-0.0214362685,
-0.0259256512,
0.0825909674,
0.0025576029,
0.012089977,
-0.0274524037,
0.0132406252,
-0.0244972743,
0.0675033554,
-0.0217112023,
-0.0111961123,
0.0000942461,
-0.0231950711,
0.0054427725,
-0.0533620045,
0.0435238592,
-0.0498049594,
0.0687096044,
-0.0596985444,
-0.006738483,
0.0220065862,
-0.0332229659,
-0.0550170206,
0.0065433704,
-0.0408849716,
-0.0042806682,
-0.0531255268,
-0.0144411018,
-0.0330057926,
0.0021065909,
0.0299004316,
0.009683799,
-0.0271259937,
-0.0483513437,
-0.0056159818,
-0.0308484789,
0.0149788503,
0.0263600405,
0.0199657585,
-0.0437481068,
0.0384745039,
0.0399509035,
0.031224668,
-0.0054061785,
-0.0146930432,
0.0106095327,
0.0001055629,
-0.0290544927,
-0.0214834139,
-0.0042140391,
0.0386026278,
-0.1007033288,
-0.0456775315,
0.1339973956,
0.0597923286,
0.0081308754,
0.0056293402,
-0.0681995451,
0.0464170612,
0.0369468555,
0.0432171635,
-0.0649696589,
-0.0190950874,
0.0350726284,
0.0166371837,
0.0119659081,
-0.008378095,
0.0180129316,
-0.1242673472,
0.0565659255,
0.0281110499,
-0.0312044024,
-0.0477122068,
-0.0587372258,
-0.0114540318,
0.0077579184,
-0.0138534941,
0.0554980971,
0.0090294266,
-0.0148491962,
0.0255418587,
-0.0141220605,
-0.031814605,
0.0098487474,
-0.0281277467,
0.0236116219,
0.048993405,
0.0067430176,
0.0146899745,
-0.0522125997,
0.0837425366,
0.0211632196,
0.0070183445,
-0.0712133944,
0.0229594465,
-0.005749139,
0.0041936212,
-0.0200618245,
0.0369886383,
-0.0261284374,
-0.0424876846,
0.001728827,
0.109485805,
-0.025344139,
-0.0073397649,
0.0112618161,
0.0168925505,
-0.0556927882,
0.0391771458,
-0.0148887439,
0.0090374257,
-0.0411782004,
-0.0373849645,
-0.0602784827,
-0.0257242117,
-0.0385662466,
0.022164084,
0.0315707847,
0.0202625953,
-0.0124378055,
-0.0231623929,
0.0315161571,
0.0486234017,
-0.0174987242,
-0.0019946333,
-0.0140348645,
-0.0047215214,
-0.0006572403,
0.0106575694,
-0.0454199724,
0.0201151073,
0.0170018375,
0.0341771692,
0.00652397,
-0.0207217298,
-0.0144342938,
0.0194271524,
-0.0343834572,
-0.0542396009,
-0.0230263826,
0.0647718757,
0.0215354152,
0.070253104,
-0.0253545735,
-0.0300214738,
-0.0068194829,
0.0108700097,
-0.0225103758,
0.0106389793,
0.0341529399,
0.0140643511,
0.0243342016,
0.0172929242,
-0.0241868291,
0.0053091212,
0.0066742785,
0.0413315035,
-0.0055351909,
-0.0616050102,
0.0385267399,
0.0457152613,
0.0045441575,
0.0176106747,
-0.0010865451,
-0.03773674,
0.0487085804,
-0.0442979857,
-0.0652154759,
-0.0031098474,
0.0765621066,
0.013481902,
-0.0583609268,
0.0037052252,
-0.0204731151,
-0.0151162837,
0.0167760365,
0.0122657428,
0.0079468172,
0.0105329053,
0.0273239911,
0.0088045271,
-0.020604983,
-0.0161367003,
-0.0078587066,
0.020756444,
0.0517438501,
-0.0225845501,
0.0714414567,
0.0301910751,
0.0048501124,
-0.0495715439,
-0.037284974,
-0.050681252,
-0.05952169,
-0.0207576659,
-0.0100874584,
0.0502933152,
0.01974109,
0.048734583,
-0.0430627875,
-0.0113419583,
-0.0006846683,
0.0504741557,
0.029611079,
-0.0362171903,
0.0313259512,
0.0302565023,
-0.0013024129,
-0.0395234823,
0.0087490324,
-0.0582080856,
0.0551844612,
-0.0080534453,
-0.0248301551,
-0.0465657301,
-0.0419515185,
-0.0544269457,
-0.0060806549,
-0.0328305624,
0.0060136681,
-0.0474332124,
-0.0844474435,
-0.0207942445,
0.0599059835,
0.0033652214,
0.0089318622,
0.002942699,
0.0605000705,
0.0219832938,
-0.0595536754,
-0.0119158784,
-0.0115833962,
-0.003420369,
-0.0170973726,
0.0072233216,
-6.76361817e-33,
-0.0548137948,
-0.0284133349,
0.0523234196,
0.0012286676,
-0.0340460241,
-0.0644199923,
-0.0432741567,
0.053639248,
0.0237860661,
0.0283252466,
0.0026142765,
0.0287008379,
-0.0017018019,
-0.0207097065,
0.0264025368,
-0.0009026451,
0.0537512675,
0.0263978746,
-0.0385380611,
-0.00274785,
0.0444672294,
-0.0016336106,
0.0583902076,
-0.0663819313,
0.0179239139,
0.0121368617,
-0.044121068,
0.0795917735,
-0.0829049796,
0.0589906722,
0.0089732176,
-0.0119592613,
0.0223631952,
-0.0520394966,
-0.0114821494,
-0.0103010926,
-0.0695930421,
-0.0265264325,
0.0241224431,
0.013167318,
-0.0660293624,
-0.0227246247,
0.038810458,
0.0188237671,
0.0034620706,
-0.0200947244,
0.0218462441,
-0.0298993383,
-0.0085086627,
0.0188610516,
-0.0529805198,
0.0276495647,
-0.021678159,
-0.0201707818,
-0.0127569409,
0.0780747831,
-0.0173296351,
-0.0446395464,
-0.0277484916,
0.0098547107,
0.0271138921,
0.0091618625,
0.0762372687,
0.0006074539,
-0.0114290025,
0.0258828774,
-0.0240967553,
-0.0077994904,
-0.0785256624,
-0.0194703285,
0.0418665856,
0.0538370423,
0.0763201267,
0.0050202115,
0.0059396015,
0.0005192963,
-0.0381953456,
0.0062508709,
-0.0651008338,
0.0789559558,
0.0471852981,
0.0253156889,
-0.0261053462,
-0.0078459727,
-0.0827249736,
0.0241950918,
-0.0519769639,
-0.0281424541,
0.0377978347,
0.0221469048,
-0.017879447,
0.001393503,
0.0079686437,
-0.0057378341,
-0.0252041351,
-0.0062204725,
-0.018797785,
0.0186932646,
-0.0448769964,
0.0014420508,
-0.035210222,
-0.0260896552,
-0.0085791135,
-0.0019406951,
0.0143244322,
0.0022658408,
0.035727568,
0.0020575188,
-0.0788189769,
0.0101874052,
-0.041658774,
0.0084925173,
0.0063695549,
-0.0024694696,
0.0284505151,
0.0114181247,
-0.0218528043,
0.0662071183,
0.0029442627,
-0.0256764125,
-0.0616525225,
0.0498651303,
-0.0113782883,
0.0300966203,
0.0047156075,
-0.0126740774,
-0.0284281261,
-0.0158274639,
0.0182111263,
-0.049149137,
-0.0200459268,
0.0226217601,
3.04e-7,
0.0349482335,
0.0827981904,
-0.0084063504,
0.0381412059,
0.0146497022,
0.0446277857,
-0.0324645378,
-0.0441827662,
0.0463140048,
-0.0286575966,
0.0191688333,
0.0691217333,
0.0322199799,
0.0570532531,
-0.0051977914,
-0.0102251843,
-0.0261029489,
-0.0063452548,
-0.0428540148,
-0.0192403179,
0.074092187,
0.0804641396,
0.0739459842,
-0.0100761577,
-0.0032788946,
-0.0282665435,
0.067667231,
0.0037052401,
-0.0274660662,
0.0231977981,
-0.0097107748,
0.0329875313,
0.0350529999,
0.0343865268,
0.0189906619,
-0.0280317292,
-0.0392587446,
0.0326843895,
-0.0230534468,
-0.0194022637,
-0.0236857012,
0.0273016673,
0.0229262095,
-0.0641425103,
0.0705828741,
-0.0385546871,
-0.0240095053,
-0.0188613851,
0.0358209237,
-0.0119266417,
0.052283518,
0.011694313,
-0.0216796361,
0.0154902758,
0.0223789643,
0.0269982796,
-0.017770987,
-0.0873949155,
-0.0489523672,
0.0351215787,
-0.0186865255,
-0.0115199257,
-0.0001829208,
0.0006566395,
0.0010100137,
-0.0461254381,
-0.0215846635,
3.074126883e-34,
0.0462755077,
-0.0093021188,
0.0446231142,
0.0621561036,
0.060138233,
0.0012537461,
0.0081036249,
0.0324400291,
0.0315425918,
-0.0510998331,
-0.0168780126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13022v1 | Uncertainty-aware Parameter-Efficient Self-training for Semi-supervised Language Understanding | 2023-10-19T02:18:29 | 2023-10-19T02:18:29 | Jianing Wang, Qiushi Sun, Nuo Chen, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Ming Gao, Xiang Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The recent success of large pre-trained language models (PLMs) heavily hinges
on massive labeled data, which typically produces inferior performance in
low-resource scenarios. To remedy this dilemma, we study self-training as one
of the predominant semi-supervised learning (SSL) approaches, which utilizes
large-scale unlabeled data to generate synthetic examples. However, too many
noisy labels will hurt the model performance, and the self-training procedure
requires multiple training iterations making it more expensive if all the model
parameters of the PLM are updated. This paper presents UPET, a novel
Uncertainty-aware Parameter-Efficient self-Training framework to effectively
and efficiently address the labeled data scarcity issue. Specifically, we
incorporate Monte Carlo (MC) dropout in Bayesian neural network (BNN) to
perform uncertainty estimation for the teacher model and then judiciously
select reliable pseudo-labeled examples based on confidence and certainty.
During the student training, we introduce multiple parameter-efficient learning
(PEL) paradigms that allow the optimization of only a small percentage of
parameters. We also propose a novel Easy-Hard Contrastive Tuning to enhance the
robustness and generalization. Extensive experiments over multiple downstream
tasks demonstrate that UPET achieves a substantial improvement in terms of
performance and efficiency. Our codes and data are released at https:
//github.com/wjn1996/UPET. | [
0.0177866518,
0.0537040494,
0.0209597591,
0.0404695757,
0.0207996611,
0.0123937512,
0.0276091788,
-0.0477810055,
0.0059069498,
-0.0367066264,
-0.0841395482,
-0.0198895931,
-0.035900142,
0.0063839667,
0.0186915863,
-0.0573277026,
0.0408291705,
-0.0533206537,
0.0029126171,
-0.0048179911,
-0.0138954343,
0.0277712811,
-0.0440169759,
-0.0258727521,
-0.0275976956,
-0.0194859859,
-0.0278069377,
0.0380767323,
0.0072080866,
-0.0328222923,
0.0078583099,
0.0775229931,
0.0195330791,
0.0219773464,
0.0000023069,
-0.0289237835,
-0.0276015047,
-0.0231462289,
-0.0849347413,
0.0564256534,
0.0642977953,
0.0287608244,
-0.0270931795,
0.0064465008,
0.0200147331,
-0.0669820756,
0.0443928912,
0.0351395458,
0.0384610668,
0.062953867,
0.0212285835,
-0.003345954,
-0.0175611489,
-0.0191996638,
0.0100260824,
-0.0491722897,
0.0096227387,
0.0030363309,
-0.0164669994,
0.0122346506,
0.0006008843,
0.049937658,
0.0293366034,
-0.0052660103,
-0.0071947519,
0.0405488685,
-0.017796753,
-0.0230631977,
-0.0055135353,
0.0536791123,
-0.0370058827,
-0.0356804915,
0.007435869,
-0.0477769263,
-0.0038251698,
0.0101449201,
-0.0087938635,
0.025666168,
0.0038238873,
0.0502769016,
0.0206078254,
0.0243119188,
0.0548483729,
-0.007050815,
0.007102889,
0.0602817535,
-0.0175370425,
-0.0234554708,
-0.0019377817,
-0.0097253928,
-0.0233118348,
-0.0176670104,
0.0031360097,
0.020168785,
0.0177405775,
0.0336007886,
-0.0526324958,
-0.0579885691,
-0.010743021,
-0.0480967388,
0.0080494452,
0.0375934392,
-0.0147708524,
0.0428091697,
0.0164204799,
-0.0410267375,
0.0326258466,
0.0180136655,
-0.044504866,
0.0111851329,
-0.0352223665,
0.0151344333,
-0.1013181433,
0.0307114907,
0.003706119,
0.0147068733,
-0.0337705575,
0.0104804998,
-0.0025998144,
-0.0119216545,
0.0395088531,
-0.0067753471,
-0.0511981659,
-0.018663507,
0.0052239299,
0.0224408414,
-0.0147593869,
-0.0220677257,
0.0062477249,
-0.0581691302,
-0.0166268703,
-0.0015249011,
0.0191360898,
-0.0340587199,
0.0075335712,
0.054749772,
-0.027641546,
-0.0676980019,
-0.1082323268,
0.0164781269,
-0.0092665013,
-0.0602712184,
-0.0058819847,
-0.0391737521,
0.0055832993,
-0.0305040907,
0.0131716589,
-0.0706164315,
0.0184545722,
-0.0168999992,
-0.0000573445,
0.0951221511,
-0.0572762862,
0.0019471109,
0.0563322119,
0.0210816488,
0.0075817048,
0.0995018706,
0.0164961535,
-0.0170029625,
0.0306255687,
-0.0172561537,
-0.0009214613,
0.0034366585,
0.0470370315,
-0.0164247248,
-0.0358607471,
-0.0088058282,
0.0484560169,
0.04540281,
0.0610988028,
-0.0018436869,
-0.0171788074,
-0.0281542018,
0.075391151,
-0.0160889998,
-0.0238978993,
-0.009526764,
0.0435757749,
0.0499240309,
0.0423808806,
-0.0096289776,
-0.051016774,
-0.0069854511,
-0.015234651,
-0.0015945769,
0.0451921709,
-0.0096261958,
-0.0549829267,
-0.0842221305,
-0.0358748175,
-0.0198847856,
-0.0309048779,
0.0685298294,
0.0891353339,
0.0189052839,
-0.0150417909,
0.0393271931,
0.0272433516,
-0.0382863358,
0.0257630087,
-0.0408090241,
0.0394176729,
0.0494512282,
0.0159033388,
-0.0713354796,
-0.0239028018,
0.0009784916,
0.0450949892,
0.0025415565,
0.0392465517,
0.0292525943,
0.0677896366,
-0.0470502079,
-0.0168676209,
-0.0319657661,
0.0149810193,
0.046449665,
-0.023134131,
0.0145855732,
0.0085488735,
-0.0711876899,
-0.0274219774,
0.0271504559,
-0.0014881784,
-0.070318073,
0.0369284339,
-0.0076109436,
0.0393758006,
-0.0050797393,
-0.0437486582,
-0.0124879172,
0.0256205145,
-0.0088860625,
0.0088660726,
-0.0473735593,
-0.0700781047,
-0.0617845505,
0.0272007789,
0.0180543996,
-0.0431534424,
-0.0187014118,
-0.0455663949,
-0.0768216848,
0.0192090571,
0.0009200349,
-0.0006145487,
-0.048356045,
0.0265864283,
0.0439534858,
0.0505399145,
-0.0053280233,
0.0265678577,
0.0198871698,
-0.0110140145,
-0.0197747983,
0.0520057045,
0.021414768,
-0.0499648824,
-0.0290585179,
-0.0152817667,
-0.0281652249,
-0.0192734953,
-0.0213922169,
0.0043346421,
-0.0427889526,
0.0225050133,
-0.0492478758,
0.0046908176,
-0.0402190238,
0.0120818457,
0.0061049284,
0.0080216723,
-0.0410481133,
-0.0518129691,
-0.0013611023,
-0.0304017253,
-0.0507895276,
-0.0097978069,
0.0118856346,
0.0270387046,
0.0211429764,
-0.0390158631,
-0.0259474982,
0.009820031,
0.0209980216,
0.0067760847,
0.0266265459,
-0.0701184943,
0.039241951,
-0.0191962253,
0.0461446233,
0.0173577536,
-0.0329288729,
-0.0202486683,
-0.0390226468,
0.0313071162,
0.0279340614,
-0.0079053324,
-0.0050369622,
0.0888196155,
-0.0197046567,
-0.0337986574,
0.0309943017,
-0.0193294827,
-0.015141163,
0.026481675,
-0.0143984556,
-0.0475100167,
0.079576306,
0.0054369145,
-0.0207059141,
-0.027805103,
0.0044726534,
-0.0092943814,
-0.0432624444,
-0.0408108011,
0.0361035578,
0.0156238545,
0.0257195383,
-0.0104944305,
-0.0161924083,
0.072487019,
-0.0388566777,
-0.0311938357,
-0.0361523591,
-0.0374443978,
0.0091942893,
0.0131097836,
0.0398831703,
-0.0018062006,
0.0350718349,
-0.0120674018,
-0.0212805625,
0.000838686,
0.0495176688,
0.0065825707,
-0.0310195778,
-0.0597342402,
0.0317628421,
-0.0079069445,
-0.013679971,
-0.0435849316,
-0.0354997851,
-0.010914214,
-0.0268182941,
0.0103134057,
-0.0040880102,
0.0429210924,
0.0092599336,
-0.0416958183,
0.0967610553,
-0.0032554448,
-0.0146580534,
-0.0087147579,
0.0142105771,
-0.0076265833,
-0.0136653101,
0.0182597842,
0.0006305689,
0.0233543087,
0.0274947342,
0.0638808757,
-0.0331500396,
-0.0394958332,
0.0003234191,
0.0169136208,
-0.038094189,
0.0111364229,
0.043103978,
0.0462385789,
-0.0648541823,
-0.0365540907,
0.1450518221,
0.0167734046,
-0.0237807818,
-0.0232673902,
-0.0451555587,
0.0170595516,
0.0187943019,
0.0415617786,
-0.0225943886,
-0.0376340374,
-0.004530435,
0.042611517,
0.0163582861,
-0.0222012866,
-0.003126011,
-0.0795800462,
0.0570295416,
0.0009506943,
-0.0376971588,
0.0153944483,
-0.0682681128,
-0.0192067884,
-0.0521272346,
0.0250014719,
0.0098885139,
-0.0187394358,
0.0117914816,
0.0622885674,
-0.0251583345,
-0.0820118189,
-0.0034977873,
-0.0156727731,
0.0532721169,
-0.0337000452,
-0.0236687027,
-0.0041951514,
-0.0124375494,
0.0460088477,
-0.0516767949,
-0.0149881719,
-0.0337396301,
0.0860398486,
-0.0170113314,
-0.0240484141,
0.048682373,
0.0326156802,
-0.0473992191,
-0.0150204506,
-0.0100740017,
0.0740432143,
-0.0203507841,
0.0023364436,
0.0032208217,
-0.0100938659,
0.0416509248,
0.0698791221,
0.0358272046,
-0.0316894129,
-0.012137047,
0.0070752911,
0.0283383187,
-0.0143077634,
0.0361943953,
0.0373175852,
-0.0362796448,
-0.0619837455,
0.0053998507,
-0.0361204818,
0.0095513649,
0.0322557352,
-0.0050930479,
0.0152751878,
0.0293492638,
0.0176679082,
-0.0495176688,
0.0365263075,
-0.0329745859,
-0.0255013425,
-0.044775404,
-0.0385880135,
0.0459255837,
-0.0161426105,
0.0050050076,
0.0107380012,
-0.0902865455,
-0.060810335,
0.0194903389,
0.076731585,
0.0078751594,
0.0597242713,
-0.0214632489,
-0.0466501601,
0.010645397,
0.0409555472,
-0.0068352297,
-0.0372292325,
0.0722174421,
-0.0004208154,
0.0118319076,
0.0165324248,
-0.0202787407,
0.0472700186,
0.011667883,
-0.0010666555,
-0.0481894426,
-0.0107997786,
0.0274684448,
-0.0008836492,
0.0756589994,
-0.01659544,
0.0519568883,
-0.0692362264,
0.0037205962,
-0.028757507,
0.0084095504,
-0.0339865014,
0.0440662801,
0.0235888325,
-0.0113139208,
-0.0263660029,
-0.0007106346,
-0.0306738019,
0.012631584,
0.0257081166,
-0.0081673767,
-0.0197106171,
-0.0078576608,
0.012559887,
-0.015663214,
-0.0009704641,
0.0434434861,
0.0473277867,
0.0197148118,
0.0123502398,
0.0487157591,
0.0200405531,
0.0146860844,
-0.0336774662,
-0.0237432029,
-0.0427280366,
-0.0663089752,
-0.0603768453,
0.0459348001,
0.0381594077,
-0.0107731353,
0.0127562275,
-0.0350981206,
-0.0202914756,
-0.0126492148,
0.0239039771,
0.0016122141,
0.0062990086,
0.0472467579,
0.0198236462,
-0.0025907485,
0.0241970606,
0.0656012967,
0.0491888337,
0.0518055186,
0.0319388099,
0.012164332,
-0.0506671965,
-0.0083626769,
-0.0088820625,
0.0515504032,
-0.0178255513,
0.0145835308,
0.0334687419,
-0.099748373,
-0.0096237957,
0.0401663333,
-0.0072457907,
-0.0147118308,
0.0688804016,
0.0240546335,
-0.0352906771,
0.0171132796,
-0.0378642492,
0.0185097996,
0.027198771,
0.0070956037,
0.0173841566,
-7.384709713e-33,
-0.0285578631,
-0.0068123946,
0.0046963897,
-0.0096259927,
0.0399032794,
-0.0031752337,
-0.0232572667,
0.0281004477,
0.0049990783,
0.0144572454,
-0.0111023868,
0.0283330642,
0.0389917754,
0.0471937656,
0.0158901252,
-0.0296350494,
0.0809148625,
-0.042893514,
0.0122701842,
0.0078789927,
0.0294968188,
0.0477556139,
0.0923945755,
-0.0674678907,
-0.0102428673,
0.0215998981,
0.0061670123,
0.0433708914,
0.0084601929,
0.0266266465,
-0.0226638559,
0.0558946095,
-0.0020295768,
-0.012769592,
-0.0299917087,
-0.0388456024,
-0.1082229391,
-0.0759223476,
-0.0403445065,
0.0313267522,
-0.0450134501,
-0.0124067347,
0.0234275311,
0.0238899495,
-0.0020162812,
0.0109066861,
0.0430493131,
0.0056661591,
-0.0289400332,
-0.0185864381,
0.0105897514,
0.0347941555,
-0.0203888826,
-0.0240954757,
0.0421724841,
0.017398648,
-0.0221033562,
0.0023167704,
-0.0759242475,
-0.0514837056,
0.0296639837,
0.042512048,
0.0612811223,
0.046378579,
0.0091296881,
0.0183204394,
0.050242167,
0.0074367151,
0.0142136905,
0.0008015378,
0.020670414,
0.0236322656,
0.0057446789,
0.0230583586,
0.0700086877,
0.0100909211,
-0.0651005954,
0.0088318596,
0.0187917985,
-0.016055461,
-0.0128440987,
0.0280487649,
-0.0249370523,
-0.0277272295,
-0.0324919261,
-0.0884219557,
-0.0182169974,
-0.0090584047,
0.0114168292,
-0.002732821,
-0.0337684304,
0.0147250723,
0.0271819048,
-0.0227899794,
-0.0491377674,
-0.0341067687,
0.0044911467,
-0.0007557558,
0.0231745951,
0.0430574119,
-0.0605062693,
-0.0462124273,
-0.0235670656,
-0.0101151858,
-0.0080797905,
0.0018022453,
0.0481036566,
0.0252635013,
-0.0393713824,
0.0016638084,
-0.0218439214,
0.0232206024,
0.0000036739,
0.016335981,
0.0314685218,
-0.0087889032,
-0.0012783238,
0.0721332505,
0.0369465575,
-0.0201791823,
-0.0061736051,
-0.0206496697,
-0.0139414007,
0.0218750853,
-0.0035435716,
-0.0180029552,
-0.0151366377,
-0.0497524887,
0.0338139385,
-0.0989092216,
0.0014188198,
0.0465050787,
2.913e-7,
0.0473994277,
0.0123370504,
-0.0004234216,
-0.0062045832,
0.0454402454,
0.0372606888,
-0.0190814417,
-0.0207552165,
-0.0128868753,
-0.0187392049,
0.0398134887,
0.049335435,
0.0358397737,
0.0228244197,
-0.0862131193,
-0.0467819497,
-0.0307581518,
0.0420904569,
-0.0142159695,
0.000222992,
0.0377411805,
0.1018997729,
0.0299831536,
-0.0003959794,
0.0078553325,
-0.0128909722,
0.0458997823,
-0.0268254168,
0.0059921611,
0.046529986,
0.0245675221,
0.0335584097,
-0.0164021514,
0.0200974774,
-0.0300146658,
0.0104838209,
-0.0097455727,
0.0509060919,
0.0108044092,
0.011472797,
0.0401126631,
0.0072355107,
-0.0002054742,
-0.0217842739,
0.0853471383,
-0.0922069922,
-0.0277659334,
0.007391159,
-0.0161800236,
-0.0360284746,
0.046502471,
0.0010978812,
-0.0204716977,
0.0169025008,
0.0090003749,
-0.0374081582,
-0.0541502871,
-0.0644568428,
0.0044484055,
0.0147338696,
-0.0494786352,
0.0071320655,
-0.0308830645,
-0.0381959565,
0.0627442226,
-0.0371385552,
-0.0244456194,
2.279429794e-34,
0.0591052175,
-0.0326490439,
-0.0158353858,
0.008084951,
-0.017992422,
-0.0226535928,
-0.03275989,
-0.0040142308,
0.009935908,
-0.0238888338,
-0.0175054651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12418v1 | The Shifted and The Overlooked: A Task-oriented Investigation of User-GPT Interactions | 2023-10-19T02:12:17 | 2023-10-19T02:12:17 | Siru Ouyang, Shuohang Wang, Yang Liu, Ming Zhong, Yizhu Jiao, Dan Iter, Reid Pryzant, Chenguang Zhu, Heng Ji, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent progress in Large Language Models (LLMs) has produced models that
exhibit remarkable performance across a variety of NLP tasks. However, it
remains unclear whether the existing focus of NLP research accurately captures
the genuine requirements of human users. This paper provides a comprehensive
analysis of the divergence between current NLP research and the needs of
real-world NLP applications via a large-scale collection of user-GPT
conversations. We analyze a large-scale collection of real user queries to GPT.
We compare these queries against existing NLP benchmark tasks and identify a
significant gap between the tasks that users frequently request from LLMs and
the tasks that are commonly studied in academic research. For example, we find
that tasks such as ``design'' and ``planning'' are prevalent in user
interactions but are largely neglected or different from traditional NLP
benchmarks. We investigate these overlooked tasks, dissect the practical
challenges they pose, and provide insights toward a roadmap to make LLMs better
aligned with user needs. | [
0.0710641667,
0.051546257,
-0.0225119777,
0.052979473,
-0.0370189026,
-0.0100375796,
-0.0279682372,
0.0145573691,
0.0295328293,
-0.0239707287,
-0.0046715094,
-0.0308601987,
0.0061582751,
0.0126619078,
0.0066938251,
-0.0737691671,
0.0011147837,
-0.0298360251,
-0.0245918036,
0.0204216875,
0.0350331441,
0.048823975,
-0.0123076411,
0.0799039081,
-0.0163107645,
-0.0316351168,
-0.0197959971,
0.0061621978,
-0.0349212512,
-0.0396193117,
-0.0167941824,
0.0669245273,
-0.0055164937,
0.0358777791,
0.0000022024,
-0.0329149254,
-0.0039434917,
-0.0031044427,
-0.0231118742,
0.0363172963,
0.0367253236,
0.0091118999,
-0.0099683218,
0.0133210197,
-0.0509281158,
0.0038451087,
0.0565037914,
0.0574545152,
0.0462210849,
0.008152497,
-0.0206664987,
-0.0054615284,
-0.0091768764,
-0.0247282162,
0.0193326771,
-0.0710030273,
-0.0025276556,
-0.005869458,
0.0682464391,
0.0347288735,
0.019354796,
0.0442671776,
0.0136048039,
-0.0116907852,
-0.0096368659,
0.0330326818,
-0.0380694494,
-0.0432699323,
-0.0163114537,
0.0756648257,
0.0206590891,
0.0015191513,
0.0137241846,
-0.0168783646,
-0.0178693682,
0.0476245582,
-0.0531350337,
-0.0121292984,
-0.0126771294,
0.0063814824,
-0.0199736934,
-0.0229175445,
0.03247834,
0.0204630848,
-0.0143311154,
0.0717636049,
0.0315843932,
-0.0096312119,
-0.0139176287,
0.0132991094,
-0.0401319191,
-0.0685406476,
0.0139976004,
0.0047258344,
-0.0589347184,
0.0296775773,
-0.0084072156,
0.0100443605,
0.0406980403,
-0.0290629212,
0.0540731587,
0.0464464165,
0.0254670959,
0.0649035946,
0.0218858477,
0.0540137626,
-0.0379629694,
-0.0379095078,
-0.0127315139,
-0.0129054412,
-0.0667504221,
-0.0371056423,
-0.0557539947,
0.0167890321,
-0.052381862,
-0.0404269956,
-0.0023586382,
0.0584865883,
0.0280822292,
0.020819148,
0.0388055257,
0.0114523098,
-0.0288102496,
-0.0446620435,
-0.0544505641,
0.0094584767,
-0.0491220951,
-0.0090363258,
-0.0031871432,
-0.0684467107,
0.0089301355,
0.0023670425,
-0.0139424121,
-0.035472922,
-0.0387876555,
0.0562262274,
0.010153085,
-0.0035314604,
-0.0339652225,
-0.0534153692,
-0.0120639969,
-0.038765274,
-0.0448363945,
-0.0656762645,
0.0234296136,
0.0448539443,
0.0138550354,
-0.0397220664,
0.0023848272,
0.0552706309,
-0.0445791371,
0.0792865977,
0.0005374772,
0.046522893,
0.0349358208,
0.0079200808,
0.0097137503,
0.0827275366,
0.0257898476,
0.0308023877,
0.0466608182,
-0.0012412111,
0.0197128616,
0.0659247488,
-0.0232683495,
-0.0079861004,
0.0043754382,
0.0182514526,
-0.0015011218,
0.045344878,
-0.01794081,
0.0795715824,
-0.0244660079,
0.0115670739,
0.0907585844,
0.0905576795,
0.0012539666,
0.027650319,
0.0255812742,
0.0503093526,
-0.0219072551,
0.0040735053,
-0.0324048698,
0.0123833502,
-0.0357474983,
-0.0028099306,
0.0200938582,
0.0222653672,
-0.0140944133,
-0.0148858652,
-0.0282892864,
0.0163451768,
0.0040876698,
0.0180565827,
0.0185054578,
-0.0063845343,
-0.049477905,
0.0398770683,
-0.0131809246,
-0.0498307422,
-0.0023525183,
-0.0426958948,
-0.0005481376,
0.083304204,
0.0596964546,
-0.0090423338,
-0.0190074034,
0.0228749868,
-0.0058756601,
0.043851424,
0.0542320721,
0.0037873192,
-0.0294489898,
-0.0165824853,
-0.0040941476,
0.010028868,
0.0047224201,
0.000908663,
0.0538670495,
0.0024007715,
0.0253461786,
-0.0324009545,
-0.0170951393,
0.0131319724,
-0.0241627265,
-0.0186137203,
-0.013118309,
-0.0038215169,
0.0044166241,
0.0269526206,
0.0086705284,
0.0125385346,
0.018625956,
-0.0112961438,
-0.0110808611,
0.0030856042,
-0.0250230171,
0.0102397241,
0.0317863226,
-0.0037366948,
-0.0070404722,
0.0118526649,
-0.0053169155,
-0.0449673533,
-0.0176228136,
-0.0314511433,
0.0710560679,
-0.0464401469,
0.0038474875,
0.0185045991,
-0.0425365753,
-0.0559088923,
0.0494970456,
0.0371424519,
-0.013728654,
0.0260662045,
0.001647443,
0.0215163939,
-0.0452515446,
-0.0468593948,
0.0765465572,
0.0342455581,
0.0139039457,
0.0683464706,
0.0312950872,
-0.0606688894,
-0.0284084938,
-0.1245829985,
0.0040714149,
-0.0206212793,
0.0346681587,
0.0303485114,
0.0534586087,
-0.0379364155,
-0.0071934238,
-0.0369049124,
-0.0091424128,
0.012501657,
0.0309425537,
0.0501017645,
0.0121864276,
0.0148246959,
-0.0415208079,
0.0039629717,
-0.0047000549,
0.007505517,
0.0167834032,
-0.0499552935,
-0.0151440725,
0.0193075147,
-0.002003086,
0.0032708442,
0.0130052362,
-0.0086727673,
0.0277029499,
-0.0339146629,
0.0890139341,
0.0121580474,
-0.0044062193,
0.0451677851,
0.0012570296,
-0.0402708165,
-0.0681102797,
0.0237577874,
-0.0198331997,
-0.0673893243,
-0.0353604481,
-0.0043568211,
0.0591362529,
0.0763054639,
-0.0051258667,
0.008491016,
-0.0868586525,
0.020850569,
-0.0502720997,
0.0101557802,
-0.0260952637,
0.0047076815,
-0.034323521,
0.0640477687,
0.0021767353,
-0.0353722908,
0.0454698764,
-0.0425107963,
-0.0189781617,
-0.0169576351,
-0.0092884013,
-0.0209613759,
0.1022624895,
0.0070880298,
0.029701896,
0.011192238,
-0.0373761319,
-0.0197418015,
0.0056515881,
0.0051860749,
-0.0411270671,
0.055058945,
-0.0733116567,
0.027806161,
-0.006709225,
-0.0504176542,
-0.0052457182,
-0.0357333906,
-0.0580610931,
-0.0246243328,
0.0356668457,
-0.0530966334,
0.0036092829,
0.0071150563,
0.0099356323,
0.0351486877,
-0.0089277485,
-0.0405782983,
-0.0173038486,
-0.0001427086,
0.0708457381,
0.004035559,
-0.037741404,
-0.0001736131,
0.0116667924,
0.0592250675,
0.0443489067,
-0.004279017,
0.0072728861,
-0.0219432693,
0.0469378829,
-0.045406092,
-0.0424537882,
0.0388662107,
0.0395262837,
-0.0561806522,
0.0101783108,
0.1153441146,
0.0494405441,
-0.0698017851,
-0.0179545861,
-0.009395631,
0.0522839017,
0.0090394365,
0.0380361788,
-0.0818420649,
-0.0331486203,
0.0025861084,
0.008645664,
-0.0079921801,
-0.0244675763,
-0.0287768133,
-0.1328327954,
0.0000313911,
-0.0231292676,
0.0190134961,
0.0158038065,
-0.0236430261,
0.0058104256,
-0.0023044317,
0.0200267602,
-0.0031165369,
-0.014874937,
0.0169780478,
-0.0036811314,
-0.0579385236,
-0.0380819403,
0.0179403219,
-0.0150970621,
0.0225911215,
0.0833670944,
0.0581955314,
0.012024235,
-0.0315028988,
0.0422959588,
0.0118772723,
0.010669753,
-0.0200529769,
0.0301686935,
-0.0069501386,
-0.0050508529,
-0.0247453563,
0.0241009332,
-0.0775632411,
-0.0116834352,
0.0262158606,
0.0811704621,
-0.0110972608,
0.0282431319,
-0.0253981296,
-0.0287023075,
0.0197139569,
0.0686518326,
0.0236925632,
-0.0643514395,
-0.0486601926,
-0.0429080389,
0.0067383545,
-0.0279105101,
-0.0614781231,
-0.033670187,
0.0541551113,
0.0360529684,
-0.0485311747,
-0.0446766131,
0.0813187733,
0.0068176012,
0.0186000485,
0.029471809,
0.0177690554,
0.0025601131,
0.0147001287,
0.0257580467,
-0.0243486352,
0.0279763136,
-0.0563670546,
-0.0268386658,
0.0434796922,
-0.0155900372,
0.0176296942,
0.0494045243,
-0.0655061752,
-0.0690681785,
-0.0309613217,
0.0063348571,
0.0298621822,
0.0040395847,
-0.0347616076,
-0.0737964138,
-0.0392982066,
0.0321346596,
-0.0564470589,
-0.0232047196,
-0.013351744,
0.0385161489,
-0.0057593146,
0.035158027,
-0.0146527998,
-0.0037810237,
-0.0402603596,
0.0442244373,
-0.0318131708,
-0.0537801087,
0.0519718342,
0.0489136502,
0.0274130255,
-0.0200446434,
0.0037104585,
-0.0023402607,
-0.0223880485,
-0.0318916216,
-0.023774473,
-0.0517522506,
-0.0021217498,
0.0227906723,
-0.022821404,
-0.0138115929,
-0.0061436198,
-0.034529347,
0.0375027731,
-0.0441265926,
-0.0187332015,
-0.0050288038,
-0.0539671667,
0.0407022238,
-0.000171585,
0.0021251997,
-0.0002790131,
0.0017362222,
0.0365702622,
-0.0167280827,
0.0614937097,
0.0123814177,
-0.026850488,
0.0328020528,
0.0276548807,
-0.0346423127,
-0.1172972471,
0.0216988213,
0.0140339686,
0.0396253727,
-0.0227165259,
0.0546815582,
-0.0430148877,
-0.0198337268,
-0.0198579933,
0.0245859046,
0.020377459,
-0.0102285063,
-0.0066583441,
0.0324660726,
-0.0325758308,
-0.0299670082,
0.074927181,
0.0024411855,
0.0200687796,
0.0068184207,
-0.0451234467,
-0.0316029526,
-0.0255831517,
-0.012865846,
0.0228834879,
-0.0227499288,
0.0049745128,
-0.0804917216,
-0.0408758521,
-0.0275238454,
-0.0101720663,
-0.0258810446,
-0.0359534994,
0.0545023978,
0.0861540362,
-0.0097526135,
-0.0090657109,
-0.041943755,
-0.0107929045,
-0.0396906994,
-0.0073021888,
-0.0331058614,
-6.443073351e-33,
-0.0280699823,
-0.0649495944,
0.0365031995,
0.0013936051,
-0.028894579,
-0.0218297504,
-0.0378515124,
0.0281494912,
-0.0161936842,
-0.0023846219,
-0.0480756871,
0.0101428786,
0.0042986795,
0.0250262488,
0.0218701307,
-0.0055634063,
0.0578974485,
-0.0013776809,
-0.0121756392,
0.0498516709,
0.0248676054,
-0.0073159495,
0.0202710126,
-0.0654708818,
0.0208153483,
0.0169725083,
-0.0120325331,
0.0211621784,
0.0044738022,
0.057451129,
-0.0506486185,
0.0575697236,
0.0216264445,
-0.0375121869,
-0.0142114554,
0.0218281019,
-0.025656173,
-0.0139512718,
0.0318782516,
0.0003923231,
-0.017533917,
-0.0195250381,
0.0117628314,
-0.0029737956,
-0.0179822948,
0.0218075868,
0.0228949971,
0.015251019,
-0.0171476156,
0.0203623809,
-0.057731811,
0.0214227643,
0.0007916727,
0.0124214888,
0.0379370749,
0.0094956486,
-0.008106499,
0.0180855934,
-0.0116398279,
0.011068901,
0.024410177,
0.0315201171,
0.0691079795,
0.0114331814,
0.0190556291,
0.0476159789,
-0.0224459022,
0.0334739424,
-0.0309375506,
-0.0223935563,
-0.0096132243,
0.03920101,
0.000891174,
0.0398906507,
0.0105984546,
-0.0033908032,
0.0129766222,
0.007102231,
0.0056516496,
0.0395247675,
0.0343269855,
0.0248959959,
-0.0255895797,
-0.0225749258,
-0.0419520773,
0.0066502243,
-0.0306162592,
-0.0417833813,
0.0414323546,
0.0013797778,
0.0076055434,
0.0268070716,
0.0009566944,
-0.0276375543,
-0.051441364,
-0.0055965544,
-0.0374370404,
0.0020038034,
-0.0062377919,
0.0446239822,
-0.0501568206,
0.0109434174,
-0.0424418598,
0.0088010356,
-0.0106086535,
0.0138459196,
-0.052030798,
0.0134800896,
-0.0812240914,
-0.0049711317,
-0.0306318682,
0.0152327139,
-0.0567497872,
-0.0007904141,
0.0506432876,
-0.0240863487,
-0.0247659981,
0.0449204035,
0.0082410574,
-0.0373396203,
-0.0509388633,
-0.0311615821,
-0.0039372817,
-0.0333935618,
-0.0051481631,
-0.0152978469,
-0.0300600287,
0.0233891234,
0.0784532055,
-0.0064196172,
-0.0291137192,
-0.0258728657,
2.854e-7,
0.0389709994,
0.0635740459,
0.0064578638,
0.0268699192,
0.0096294023,
0.0151773794,
0.0102844918,
0.0061436654,
-0.0019139509,
-0.0208155885,
0.0048977342,
0.0087930392,
0.0423388556,
0.0473330244,
-0.0973018706,
0.0129244821,
-0.0381470211,
0.0100162029,
-0.1035475954,
0.0046959962,
0.0637482405,
0.0430479236,
0.0089899702,
0.008688895,
-0.0138869435,
-0.0524230115,
0.0520778857,
-0.0716324523,
-0.0184559412,
0.016078651,
0.0396356992,
0.0176140107,
0.0020273798,
0.001621026,
-0.0146841379,
-0.0165857617,
0.0374614969,
0.060325671,
0.004992411,
-0.0154505549,
-0.0154880621,
-0.0334877148,
0.0014475012,
-0.0840293467,
0.0552377552,
-0.042228248,
-0.0090927072,
0.0000900513,
0.0333430842,
-0.0564165153,
-0.0102924714,
-0.0191147253,
-0.0130575625,
0.0189882778,
0.0127561567,
0.0006092992,
-0.0212590247,
-0.0557254441,
0.005238188,
0.0182646308,
-0.0487651266,
-0.0393457003,
-0.0916836634,
0.0127571495,
-0.0137490071,
-0.0135465059,
-0.0062296079,
2.579189808e-34,
0.0179945342,
0.0265798569,
0.04090501,
0.0428055264,
0.0611730777,
0.0516510792,
0.0370709226,
0.0237359777,
0.0241657197,
-0.1053446233,
0.0000219455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12406v1 | FinEntity: Entity-level Sentiment Classification for Financial Texts | 2023-10-19T01:38:40 | 2023-10-19T01:38:40 | Yixuan Tang, Yi Yang, Allen H Huang, Andy Tam, Justin Z Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the financial domain, conducting entity-level sentiment analysis is
crucial for accurately assessing the sentiment directed toward a specific
financial entity. To our knowledge, no publicly available dataset currently
exists for this purpose. In this work, we introduce an entity-level sentiment
classification dataset, called \textbf{FinEntity}, that annotates financial
entity spans and their sentiment (positive, neutral, and negative) in financial
news. We document the dataset construction process in the paper. Additionally,
we benchmark several pre-trained models (BERT, FinBERT, etc.) and ChatGPT on
entity-level sentiment classification. In a case study, we demonstrate the
practical utility of using FinEntity in monitoring cryptocurrency markets. The
data and code of FinEntity is available at
\url{https://github.com/yixuantt/FinEntity} | [
-0.0093198279,
0.0596405268,
-0.0130468793,
0.0235446841,
-0.0142687308,
0.0378132686,
0.0233756471,
0.0120395767,
0.0336293168,
-0.0381022841,
-0.0257759485,
-0.0099989567,
-0.0467120372,
0.0346348211,
-0.0005539694,
-0.0213739537,
0.0378624275,
0.0725278184,
0.0524710156,
-0.0345036834,
0.0590334907,
0.016764231,
-0.0090338439,
0.0043197176,
0.0074450248,
-0.0138324248,
-0.0051002675,
0.0204413366,
0.0348865129,
-0.0248810332,
0.0531612448,
0.0174065474,
-0.0277699456,
0.0108117973,
0.0000018881,
-0.0184769798,
-0.0399780087,
0.005362411,
0.0170403887,
0.0079927417,
0.0342599638,
-0.0669699535,
0.0268297866,
0.011509167,
-0.0599750578,
-0.0037094839,
0.0498135835,
0.0991376564,
0.0558213666,
0.0811978206,
-0.0331619754,
-0.0174973495,
-0.0085553043,
-0.0586325303,
-0.0049356613,
-0.049331788,
0.0244164318,
-0.0161946565,
-0.0594823174,
0.0107595064,
-0.014659375,
-0.0036482252,
-0.0137589974,
0.0259300638,
0.001978365,
-0.0124714104,
-0.0412955619,
0.0125701893,
-0.0276842657,
0.0335466936,
0.0267854296,
0.0198484622,
0.0293076467,
-0.0217165221,
-0.0267211515,
-0.0178317502,
0.0181891583,
0.0011000595,
-0.0204870235,
0.0380398333,
0.0108799618,
0.016782973,
0.0239662677,
0.0307322554,
-0.0268099215,
0.000291365,
-0.0177263301,
-0.0408520103,
0.0331756286,
0.0335333571,
-0.0258039571,
-0.0126298545,
-0.007149688,
-0.0473563485,
0.0255729556,
-0.0002745075,
-0.0010976444,
-0.0010372348,
0.0203218963,
-0.0871634707,
-0.0207514074,
0.0079672737,
-0.0287221316,
0.0407601185,
-0.0277519859,
-0.0315343887,
0.0403715558,
-0.0005733994,
0.0400963426,
0.0216107983,
-0.0463171043,
0.0211262479,
-0.033182878,
0.0628698617,
-0.0145491147,
0.0156400502,
-0.099084191,
-0.0114732496,
-0.0374065489,
0.0176010448,
0.0009433996,
0.002949361,
0.0604217313,
0.0006946428,
0.0176558159,
0.0189795252,
-0.0893331245,
0.0416211188,
-0.0426607281,
0.0080294786,
0.01706855,
0.0064244261,
-0.0168385878,
-0.0273783952,
0.0115818838,
0.0661754608,
0.0844834298,
-0.0841967687,
-0.0570578016,
-0.0191359315,
-0.0018931994,
-0.0182780176,
-0.0369266532,
-0.0103872856,
-0.0126090618,
-0.0043859631,
-0.0081819845,
0.0480063893,
0.0055772318,
-0.0468025655,
-0.0364184305,
0.0768996552,
-0.0462278537,
-0.0602678731,
-0.0066176374,
-0.0300864633,
0.026252849,
0.0433728211,
-0.0118650142,
0.0303249974,
0.0558083318,
0.0031839756,
-0.0387451611,
0.0249984525,
0.0367803015,
-0.0652318746,
0.0017103429,
0.0256723426,
-0.0597643852,
-0.0372873954,
0.0187061969,
0.0018994495,
-0.0232032463,
-0.0487449951,
0.0370341726,
-0.0038415033,
0.005258597,
0.0243836772,
-0.0661545247,
0.0181292463,
0.0024217444,
-0.0280889217,
-0.0274501648,
0.0051901434,
-0.0142161641,
0.0000288347,
0.0166263338,
-0.019339053,
-0.040296495,
-0.0337910689,
-0.0040464625,
-0.0277308524,
0.0106581664,
-0.0345834009,
0.0539283864,
-0.0397474915,
-0.0646214858,
0.0227269568,
0.0556525439,
-0.0521693863,
-0.0129882516,
-0.0260676201,
0.0626776144,
0.0703341514,
0.000351859,
-0.0280237533,
-0.0087512154,
-0.0175780114,
-0.0214608386,
0.0401071049,
0.0208919123,
-0.0033960226,
-0.0102799349,
-0.0372465812,
0.0150419222,
0.0094022863,
0.0228464007,
0.0139103867,
-0.0253912285,
0.0390170403,
-0.027517328,
0.000560119,
0.012667683,
0.0059662536,
0.0406811163,
-0.021433454,
0.0035725478,
0.0330650806,
0.0031952995,
0.0379766338,
-0.0444223247,
-0.0046641403,
0.0189254675,
0.016561266,
-0.04503721,
0.0019954378,
0.0221848413,
-0.0340022519,
0.0088885175,
-0.0405012146,
0.0221262686,
0.0135472221,
-0.0287842695,
-0.0113727115,
0.0222405344,
-0.0211250689,
0.0280452557,
-0.0441030338,
-0.0625784919,
-0.0221744683,
0.0301580112,
0.0071392884,
0.0321253203,
-0.0269126687,
0.0207316894,
-0.0501505844,
-0.031634815,
0.0644946769,
0.0286850519,
-0.0334444791,
-0.0059934724,
0.0025454327,
0.0330290049,
0.082545206,
-0.0064769848,
-0.0072650532,
-0.0390945263,
-0.1019202918,
-0.0336360894,
-0.0059886104,
0.0608617999,
-0.0000725691,
0.0066428087,
0.0098392889,
-0.0073275412,
-0.0455866344,
0.0072013563,
-0.0576183386,
0.0103345187,
0.0465218537,
-0.0252312832,
0.0026610722,
-0.0332874879,
-0.0075497893,
-0.0048035295,
-0.0055061919,
0.0239581726,
-0.0313023068,
0.0124813234,
-0.0094444901,
-0.0338382274,
0.0055537415,
-0.0128388545,
-0.0204951186,
0.0062768743,
-0.0001370256,
-0.0148195997,
0.0378934741,
0.0515104607,
0.0793973505,
-0.0719703212,
0.0134269781,
-0.0196238421,
0.0270372611,
-0.0405193679,
0.0468849503,
-0.0272644106,
0.0058521433,
-0.0121807745,
0.0605024397,
-0.0250627715,
-0.0237065684,
-0.0850605518,
-0.0002589508,
0.0106531009,
0.0460171252,
0.0171443503,
0.0384717695,
0.0091620376,
-0.0020933833,
0.0145653374,
-0.0594939478,
0.0221624598,
0.0247309133,
-0.0101173082,
-0.022769535,
-0.0064430879,
-0.0621992797,
0.0368141942,
-0.0457805917,
-0.0010292925,
-0.0192752443,
0.0228029136,
0.0180047099,
-0.0253404789,
0.0352478996,
-0.0184957236,
0.0220645852,
0.0210945718,
0.0350655615,
-0.0088143321,
-0.0289806277,
0.023901578,
-0.0504153408,
-0.0367925726,
-0.0066146278,
0.0581416674,
-0.0473930202,
-0.0266853906,
0.0083340621,
-0.0518466942,
-0.0565563105,
-0.0233091321,
-0.0343822539,
0.0160277188,
0.023133494,
0.0427956581,
-0.0270708222,
0.0747936741,
-0.0009208084,
0.0034557295,
0.0539246984,
-0.0279930755,
0.0113378931,
-0.0188400559,
-0.0317546129,
0.0098622749,
-0.0290232468,
0.0184008721,
-0.0416292734,
0.0309284888,
-0.0043721041,
0.009849471,
0.1084852368,
0.0286550149,
-0.0059844111,
0.010030549,
0.0556591377,
0.0151104378,
-0.0178911556,
-0.0228628255,
-0.0893316045,
-0.0308366437,
-0.0451683998,
0.0432077944,
-0.0035735101,
-0.0592300482,
0.0115306117,
-0.0981413797,
0.0250031538,
-0.012320688,
-0.0106692035,
-0.0326704383,
-0.0391128212,
-0.0227402933,
-0.0460145883,
-0.012231498,
-0.0483236276,
0.0037149717,
0.0290412419,
0.0098112598,
-0.0664741471,
0.0068522892,
0.0070705824,
-0.0391840599,
0.0230618194,
0.0374100357,
0.041777838,
-0.0449392386,
-0.0123448772,
-0.0406352989,
-0.045297917,
-0.0433026068,
-0.0093091503,
0.1211911291,
-0.0168621782,
-0.0730336979,
-0.0024663338,
0.016689973,
-0.0442863517,
0.0376675054,
-0.0132902088,
-0.0408927873,
-0.0035870047,
-0.0626839101,
-0.026689114,
0.0614612438,
0.0180031639,
0.0501712374,
0.0077670626,
-0.0730822906,
-0.0294736419,
-0.0206602085,
0.0215135068,
-0.0646861717,
0.0340784304,
-0.0348997153,
0.0091963764,
-0.0146520613,
-0.0883909762,
-0.029267421,
-0.0023632138,
0.0358134359,
-0.0524509773,
-0.0022050652,
0.0444234163,
-0.0090382583,
-0.039580524,
0.0364236869,
0.0264063105,
0.0335939713,
-0.0283351261,
-0.0340648219,
0.0374463499,
0.0032264902,
-0.0362264216,
0.0125644114,
-0.0511431694,
-0.0297264997,
-0.0082250144,
0.0344583467,
0.013423807,
-0.0405484065,
-0.0274724625,
0.0205903444,
0.0273313224,
0.0920148715,
-0.0907762349,
-0.0219852068,
0.1017313525,
0.0601404794,
-0.0297402591,
0.039851699,
-0.0116641689,
0.026235152,
0.0003567059,
-0.0260083526,
-0.0298844464,
-0.0067815701,
-0.0306615401,
-0.0167560242,
0.0494110771,
0.0102075282,
-0.01222145,
-0.0220800303,
-0.0140457507,
0.0353604555,
0.0087166606,
-0.02648516,
-0.0490529649,
0.0058686323,
-0.0242522396,
-0.0830250978,
0.0229566917,
-0.0009473049,
-0.0294088852,
-0.0303010568,
0.0376297459,
0.0057773655,
0.0423018895,
0.015259753,
-0.0022525361,
-0.0001701848,
-0.0016171172,
0.0277540199,
-0.0226716734,
-0.0272419769,
0.0033125794,
0.0432160906,
0.0293198172,
0.0221830681,
-0.0051485263,
-0.0108458716,
0.0329785049,
-0.0014826354,
0.0714230761,
0.0211686101,
-0.0064019603,
0.0454831757,
-0.021843845,
0.0125601031,
0.0068590394,
0.0392835177,
-0.0343132876,
0.0101880142,
0.0025782587,
-0.0095642209,
-0.0477811024,
-0.0303487908,
0.0632022694,
-0.0490801707,
0.0636652485,
0.0312666707,
0.0103616901,
-0.0527962185,
-0.0102869319,
0.0612607338,
-0.0028519791,
0.0152019383,
0.0478882529,
-0.0532566272,
-0.0355673358,
0.0645906627,
-0.0205577854,
-0.000999123,
0.0258590076,
0.039569851,
0.0227272138,
0.0057303715,
0.0575300567,
-0.0013626204,
-0.022853151,
-0.0510947518,
-0.0187331662,
-0.0542046092,
-6.042218022e-33,
-0.0085556395,
0.015937753,
-0.0175825488,
0.0678160414,
0.0093709761,
0.0165522918,
-0.0146986013,
0.0195852295,
0.0133927669,
0.0483554639,
0.0336923078,
0.0471464545,
0.0005410048,
0.0485099405,
0.0091502191,
-0.0171428919,
0.0274007134,
-0.0131371049,
0.0217047799,
0.0293361843,
-0.0023184281,
0.0481164344,
0.0815453902,
-0.1134878621,
0.0529180728,
0.0025837847,
-0.0704895705,
-0.0221682657,
0.0443165526,
0.0394461714,
-0.0004405532,
0.0436674915,
0.003867456,
-0.0194702391,
0.0186322723,
-0.0055513098,
-0.0202460326,
-0.0501179248,
-0.0175326858,
0.0271389838,
0.0072572976,
0.00076482,
0.0053439261,
0.0152482763,
-0.0036597599,
0.006557161,
0.0166898631,
0.0124452654,
0.0210227277,
-0.0923496038,
-0.0476157442,
0.0548902676,
-0.0105354236,
0.0183140803,
0.0141091878,
0.0313607454,
0.0307219364,
0.0147469155,
-0.0108836619,
0.0171413347,
-0.0018553712,
-0.0251053367,
-0.0745749846,
-0.0486154258,
-0.0064785988,
0.0693285018,
0.0390641168,
0.0375175402,
0.0363144688,
0.0507438704,
0.0328070149,
0.0235832725,
0.0462007001,
0.0679031387,
0.0275461264,
-0.0472471341,
-0.0406861976,
0.0303983111,
0.0354387984,
-0.0146411834,
0.0412911735,
-0.0184098724,
-0.0140963681,
-0.01720622,
0.0319450349,
-0.0397770144,
-0.0051886896,
-0.0100841913,
-0.0198705904,
-0.002876705,
0.0075548519,
0.037375439,
-0.0202325862,
-0.0669945329,
-0.1087130457,
0.0312253945,
-0.0106354197,
0.0214990526,
0.0148395672,
-0.0247062482,
-0.0227795299,
-0.042330943,
-0.0089498796,
-0.0082025239,
0.0035854501,
-0.0170150548,
0.0604847744,
0.0145160342,
-0.0791189596,
-0.0138353035,
0.0029845596,
0.0401454642,
-0.002794537,
0.0565907508,
-0.036412552,
-0.0033034957,
0.0083733285,
0.0186553653,
-0.0218803771,
0.0449879728,
0.0142027903,
0.004697198,
0.0175204147,
0.0621507838,
0.0234292615,
-0.0550326109,
0.0184698459,
0.0012319395,
-0.0234449133,
-0.0425461829,
-0.006637678,
-0.0110795405,
2.69e-7,
0.0306218602,
0.078934662,
0.0213285349,
0.0002162209,
0.0134384995,
0.0706321523,
-0.0299592614,
0.0334611274,
-0.0598292127,
0.0087694228,
0.0191421509,
0.0138600254,
0.038518589,
0.006765089,
-0.0769752413,
-0.0364868306,
-0.0195880048,
0.0369024351,
-0.0229374301,
0.0864974558,
0.0630728453,
0.0826873705,
0.0278904717,
-0.010342625,
0.0003505324,
-0.0280256122,
0.0474480614,
-0.0521526672,
0.0048630675,
0.0168169476,
-0.0178022813,
0.016707018,
-0.0100138178,
-0.0045225532,
0.0040190518,
0.0288686976,
-0.0036845109,
0.0138644781,
0.0259582698,
-0.0117134834,
0.0295670945,
-0.0259504747,
0.0256050341,
-0.0180735029,
0.042136047,
-0.0772551447,
-0.0346542709,
-0.0709826648,
-0.0350437202,
0.0186333116,
0.0710522756,
-0.0047807759,
-0.013675754,
0.0290757306,
0.0145363538,
-0.043289531,
-0.0048888791,
-0.0696481243,
0.010541128,
0.0405461118,
-0.0165889096,
0.0234211981,
0.0012888795,
0.059166085,
0.0321439952,
-0.0149908662,
0.0260967277,
2.159920819e-34,
0.0802607462,
-0.0691830665,
-0.0477439314,
0.0499044545,
0.0340316407,
-0.0185529739,
-0.0125730224,
-0.0075017079,
0.0178779289,
-0.022551572,
0.0228478853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12404v1 | Loop Copilot: Conducting AI Ensembles for Music Generation and Iterative Editing | 2023-10-19T01:20:12 | 2023-10-19T01:20:12 | Yixiao Zhang, Akira Maezawa, Gus Xia, Kazuhiko Yamamoto, Simon Dixon | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, eess.AS | Creating music is iterative, requiring varied methods at each stage. However,
existing AI music systems fall short in orchestrating multiple subsystems for
diverse needs. To address this gap, we introduce Loop Copilot, a novel system
that enables users to generate and iteratively refine music through an
interactive, multi-round dialogue interface. The system uses a large language
model to interpret user intentions and select appropriate AI models for task
execution. Each backend model is specialized for a specific task, and their
outputs are aggregated to meet the user's requirements. To ensure musical
coherence, essential attributes are maintained in a centralized table. We
evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed system through semi-structured
interviews and questionnaires, highlighting its utility not only in
facilitating music creation but also its potential for broader applications. | [
0.0304798149,
0.003716527,
-0.0354445688,
-0.0242976304,
-0.0305821914,
-0.0239302814,
0.0299817603,
-0.0486903004,
-0.0240462348,
0.0294506624,
-0.0686458871,
0.0007929065,
-0.0124965925,
0.0405061841,
-0.0027713499,
-0.0518889017,
0.0184574537,
-0.0472035334,
0.0055666645,
0.0262700357,
-0.0299789235,
0.0119031826,
-0.0351210199,
0.0670266151,
-0.0244546328,
-0.0101003172,
-0.0767042413,
-0.0062087853,
-0.0212318059,
0.0159921609,
-0.0753232613,
0.062028788,
-0.0133616766,
0.0226097722,
0.0000019103,
-0.0076339953,
-0.0102614015,
-0.0146208806,
0.0094677266,
-0.0429691263,
0.0113842515,
0.0657300949,
-0.0516230986,
0.0065598567,
-0.0251359344,
0.0464039892,
0.0439599454,
-0.0243634749,
0.1070158854,
0.0432411507,
0.0220646262,
-0.0071067247,
-0.0077314787,
-0.0139527572,
-0.0080567626,
0.0227145106,
-0.0260938425,
0.0051073018,
0.0953275487,
-0.0416811854,
0.0144466469,
0.033895731,
0.0472303145,
-0.0604033843,
0.0531308688,
0.0312401839,
-0.0455130935,
-0.0761090294,
-0.0080354065,
0.0457247831,
0.0377214551,
0.0123851085,
0.000407117,
0.0179647598,
0.0547176749,
-0.0319923274,
-0.0585113801,
0.0039178091,
-0.022480825,
-0.0199213084,
-0.0265091471,
-0.0268400051,
0.0132261142,
-0.0094994484,
0.0252355225,
0.0092167323,
0.0101395836,
-0.0375245549,
0.0064872559,
0.013431007,
0.0181661416,
-0.1110188589,
0.0268510692,
0.0446386375,
-0.1043018028,
0.0044191321,
-0.0405285582,
-0.0130151687,
-0.0191329252,
0.0361592732,
0.0854509547,
0.0043031047,
0.0338157751,
0.0448899493,
0.0368435979,
0.0087641701,
-0.0077503538,
-0.0071696141,
0.0057125627,
-0.0162104126,
-0.0425776243,
-0.0304178298,
-0.0759655237,
0.0278563127,
-0.0040623015,
-0.0063973442,
-0.0059740655,
0.0187494531,
-0.0470397659,
0.025629865,
0.038828399,
0.0181627087,
-0.009972577,
-0.0026776153,
0.0328231268,
0.0126404073,
-0.027513871,
0.0436074696,
0.0684661269,
0.0065613324,
0.0245967228,
-0.0245499332,
-0.0045401258,
0.0111537883,
0.0420897454,
0.0209813695,
0.0069432752,
-0.000448288,
0.018881429,
-0.0441997759,
-0.0159403458,
-0.0689631924,
-0.0473370664,
-0.0625075102,
0.0388186015,
-0.0179429483,
-0.0416511446,
-0.0395224839,
-0.0265703183,
0.0298991743,
0.0178775862,
0.0371953398,
-0.0135129672,
0.0618577041,
0.0372194313,
-0.0050910441,
-0.0460380837,
-0.0097361077,
0.0869192556,
0.0488207377,
0.0268082302,
-0.0115601858,
0.0563665926,
0.0346001685,
-0.0023681731,
-0.0299030934,
-0.014295578,
-0.0090509346,
-0.0468170196,
0.063754499,
-0.0252536871,
0.0304867253,
-0.0051865745,
0.0415719599,
0.0425361693,
0.0095708231,
0.0500443503,
0.046811495,
0.0638652742,
-0.0043320749,
0.0178582575,
-0.0077925189,
0.0021111036,
0.0807458088,
0.0213245023,
-0.0050141001,
0.0806657672,
-0.0033892016,
0.0074351123,
-0.0205085687,
0.0291746538,
0.0190375671,
-0.0040099686,
0.0149808526,
-0.0031976902,
0.0143928165,
-0.0327988714,
-0.0193512999,
-0.0317924432,
-0.1036579683,
0.0086841425,
-0.0285453107,
0.043929372,
0.1153746396,
0.0522018671,
-0.0486401394,
0.0263383947,
-0.0252217539,
0.0192855224,
0.038009461,
0.0305332728,
-0.0442833863,
-0.000987611,
0.0315279737,
-0.0217805691,
-0.0167040359,
-0.0209996309,
0.0249122381,
-0.0478040278,
-0.0036348419,
-0.0109371105,
0.0237696394,
-0.0126258954,
0.0057235169,
-0.0208612587,
-0.054879427,
0.0236697886,
0.0343708508,
0.0150874564,
0.0452718437,
-0.0246992391,
0.0397063456,
0.0053560548,
0.0231248401,
0.0072437851,
-0.0046275388,
-0.0215853285,
0.0400219411,
0.0231880266,
0.0122025106,
-0.0245008525,
-0.0236571897,
0.0133295236,
-0.0456858091,
0.0778929517,
0.0009046418,
-0.0412979759,
0.0247802883,
0.0230929106,
-0.0352642946,
-0.0404100269,
0.0247588884,
-0.0003332533,
0.0561730601,
-0.0348553397,
0.0182354748,
0.0155907497,
0.0274484493,
-0.0589985922,
0.0104324082,
0.0551105067,
0.0058377269,
-0.0240592435,
-0.0222682804,
0.0060763215,
-0.0633303374,
-0.0641758367,
-0.108765319,
0.0172290411,
-0.0158847459,
-0.0445404425,
-0.0091769639,
-0.008814279,
-0.0080096517,
-0.0025664365,
-0.0110978708,
-0.0050340993,
0.0511851646,
0.0208166484,
-0.0456020087,
-0.001766766,
-0.0540645309,
-0.0374821052,
-0.0158015005,
-0.010520231,
-0.0338831991,
0.0471540801,
-0.0127677992,
-0.0162847023,
-0.0614909232,
-0.0776695907,
-0.010122099,
0.0271113869,
0.0159775987,
0.046361763,
-0.0502853282,
0.0435990989,
0.0882972777,
-0.0279937834,
0.0308598951,
0.0987197012,
-0.0175967384,
-0.0099912519,
0.0303114112,
0.0504498631,
0.0068311766,
0.03743257,
0.0019425774,
0.024393281,
0.0115496991,
0.0819872618,
0.0089193927,
-0.0125964489,
0.0784234926,
-0.0040000328,
0.0199555494,
0.0010578241,
-0.0251177028,
-0.0184985492,
0.0706597492,
-0.0120540494,
-0.0198553558,
0.0640790015,
0.0365645364,
-0.0109208738,
0.0007196271,
-0.0446860306,
-0.0267424304,
0.0551527627,
-0.0451062769,
0.0235096496,
0.0032259943,
-0.0244211312,
-0.0402019434,
0.048210755,
0.0114386799,
-0.0755111724,
-0.0104232701,
-0.07675156,
-0.0179904811,
-0.0036094293,
-0.020275047,
-0.0145588564,
0.009668963,
-0.015897477,
0.0230254363,
0.0081056897,
-0.0122222966,
-0.0042465874,
-0.0253172275,
0.0702202097,
0.0512956716,
-0.0167791545,
-0.0019692807,
-0.0245535225,
-0.0171245988,
0.0030840226,
-0.0069487151,
-0.0110605592,
-0.0343475491,
0.0444672182,
-0.0088146506,
0.0285054166,
0.0153619666,
-0.0059490833,
0.0013517784,
-0.0128358314,
-0.0013563097,
-0.0073049208,
0.0528677106,
0.0139397904,
-0.0337277427,
0.0246641766,
0.0950444639,
0.0372895747,
-0.0402230434,
0.0113559291,
0.0360782035,
0.0071421973,
0.0242026243,
0.0230559651,
-0.0051608346,
0.0038504088,
0.0309785884,
0.0449134745,
0.0053988895,
-0.0182658508,
-0.0225822572,
-0.0307479613,
0.0649275631,
-0.0097214375,
-0.0636486411,
0.0053839847,
-0.032616768,
0.0102192927,
0.0040424871,
-0.0011065559,
0.047942061,
-0.0045992965,
0.0427831486,
-0.0160428621,
0.018281186,
0.0040325103,
-0.019822903,
-0.0579286143,
0.0419901572,
0.0910487995,
0.0718096867,
0.0169334952,
-0.008463975,
-0.0066139745,
0.0609340332,
0.0155802425,
0.0204371661,
0.0121271731,
0.0774878711,
-0.0040140017,
0.0040262043,
0.0279177278,
-0.0110820234,
0.008066047,
0.0610617548,
0.0413669497,
-0.0416433774,
0.0277042259,
-0.0024902471,
0.0072760661,
0.0345808119,
0.0395896882,
0.044753246,
-0.0649176762,
-0.0002737711,
-0.019011287,
-0.0284216888,
-0.0884595737,
-0.0455217063,
-0.0127329547,
0.0094625577,
0.0134565961,
-0.0460948013,
-0.0256931819,
0.0576516725,
0.0413620919,
0.0342239179,
-0.0056823841,
-0.0068802219,
-0.0103041884,
-0.0756073222,
-0.0119313318,
0.0143567408,
0.0384549871,
-0.0517628491,
-0.084393695,
-0.0501908995,
-0.0149221253,
-0.014957862,
0.0239557121,
-0.0426982939,
-0.0276183262,
0.0096047716,
0.029580174,
0.0185320526,
-0.0222695973,
0.0243084077,
-0.0237424839,
-0.0461316034,
-0.0148791317,
-0.0019230935,
0.0278679021,
-0.0096240174,
-0.0014613322,
0.0278169066,
0.0231560003,
-0.0716369078,
0.0054514799,
0.0261137653,
0.0037040184,
0.0303408261,
-0.0397816747,
0.0287814755,
0.0150685366,
-0.0322948545,
-0.0147049213,
0.0053963643,
-0.0284275804,
-0.0164894406,
-0.0661558211,
-0.0367587619,
-0.049607683,
-0.0107944487,
-0.0148007656,
-0.0153261051,
0.0098425699,
-0.0033694163,
-0.0173100494,
-0.0291002989,
-0.0553413741,
0.014764064,
-0.0204394106,
-0.0398583189,
0.0452547409,
-0.0104508614,
0.0341768526,
0.0418427363,
0.029775355,
-0.0019784174,
0.0334172286,
0.0081423698,
0.0057642478,
-0.0210679397,
-0.0232930332,
0.036107529,
-0.0514667816,
-0.0906774774,
0.0082087964,
0.028949352,
0.0478335954,
0.0432419814,
0.0004989593,
-0.0013589864,
-0.0093277087,
0.0032365238,
0.0462960154,
0.0327451043,
-0.05353586,
-0.0398478284,
0.0073356428,
-0.0028001536,
-0.0435380265,
0.0455292873,
-0.0774232596,
-0.0148309264,
-0.0319732167,
-0.0084346561,
-0.0415131971,
0.0058855955,
-0.0430172347,
-0.0069918348,
-0.0000994972,
0.0312466677,
-0.0229597017,
-0.0017561279,
-0.0018015818,
0.0143975513,
-0.0171570275,
-0.0292220861,
0.0280776676,
0.0430271104,
-0.0164539665,
0.0170321874,
-0.0142782051,
-0.0414106064,
-0.0835734457,
-0.0441282056,
-0.0265324935,
-5.298119078e-33,
-0.0785379186,
-0.0448026508,
0.0354844145,
0.0287680626,
-0.0316435322,
-0.0385658368,
-0.0850405768,
0.0373118296,
0.0156576522,
-0.0047200224,
-0.0296941753,
0.0252457503,
-0.0204346906,
-0.0032114591,
0.0781213343,
0.0235175434,
0.0956241265,
0.013905976,
-0.0442489348,
0.0357664004,
0.0093568824,
-0.0038542182,
-0.0451154076,
-0.082740739,
0.0040842886,
0.0108382581,
-0.0280641131,
0.0117353387,
-0.0454249494,
0.0021728238,
0.0193971954,
0.0143678449,
-0.0109721953,
-0.0397961959,
0.0022150476,
0.0233194716,
0.0010436492,
-0.0514339097,
-0.0149000818,
0.0165815987,
-0.0029151929,
-0.0323533788,
0.024382513,
-0.0007200459,
-0.0333042443,
0.0330030322,
0.0347477086,
-0.0047433171,
-0.0048899343,
-0.0176293235,
-0.0514217429,
-0.0123802405,
-0.0361261368,
-0.07084658,
0.0089797331,
0.0581889972,
-0.0246735476,
-0.0391479619,
-0.0208744165,
0.05439898,
0.0096966354,
-0.0089880386,
0.0525132045,
0.0181915499,
-0.0051387041,
0.0494158193,
0.0372654274,
-0.0122417752,
-0.0754272342,
0.028814435,
-0.0687821954,
0.085019432,
0.044357717,
0.022112051,
0.010698976,
0.0296771899,
0.0363950022,
0.0436687395,
-0.0235422086,
-0.0063701198,
-0.0249505434,
0.0767853111,
-0.0203651264,
0.0145412078,
-0.0267847124,
-0.0316253379,
-0.032110773,
-0.0542480834,
0.0223474912,
-0.0101757338,
0.0119949868,
-0.0579025112,
-0.0345959961,
0.0213712212,
-0.0098797707,
-0.0036469256,
-0.0389877073,
0.0654168427,
-0.0066328836,
-0.0548234582,
-0.0099387662,
0.0289298967,
0.0709454417,
0.0118630351,
0.0624389388,
0.0281579159,
-0.0186712686,
0.0616162829,
-0.0337068811,
-0.0176442266,
-0.0090639992,
0.0365336575,
0.0275007449,
0.0023036876,
0.0293706451,
-0.0108395955,
-0.010058593,
-0.0170826558,
0.0007796786,
-0.0135432798,
-0.022619769,
-0.0427795798,
-0.0128459707,
-0.0229468495,
-0.0226393137,
0.0143981259,
-0.0511179566,
-0.0177142061,
0.0066124285,
-0.0042665079,
-0.0328386761,
-0.0145489872,
2.773e-7,
-0.0355731882,
0.0054891016,
-0.0203548763,
0.0447144881,
0.0315229818,
0.0037174087,
-0.0753609687,
-0.0234189052,
0.0037768488,
0.0117789246,
0.0546905845,
0.0251723006,
0.0786699355,
0.0464888699,
-0.0781123787,
-0.009146153,
-0.0760126561,
0.0364948027,
-0.0891513601,
0.0082400776,
0.0468035676,
0.0404305495,
0.0355463289,
-0.0165407341,
0.0058695842,
0.0044222032,
-0.0124133732,
0.0174336173,
0.0423297919,
-0.0164210517,
0.0030938517,
-0.0367659517,
-0.0130945938,
0.0042035426,
-0.0422775038,
-0.0090347556,
0.0188597795,
0.0232889317,
-0.0241585579,
-0.0032478033,
0.030108083,
0.0110858371,
0.0276159886,
-0.0374964103,
0.0320523083,
-0.0170683488,
-0.003832414,
-0.0190174431,
0.0105664572,
0.0008822365,
0.0150680803,
-0.017538067,
-0.0110545857,
-0.0189927015,
-0.0114091914,
-0.0104594799,
0.0630177781,
0.0037742541,
-0.0001736325,
-0.0072762514,
-0.0504619554,
-0.0079045631,
-0.0310190693,
-0.0179374162,
-0.027512297,
-0.044099398,
0.0174830947,
1.953607785e-34,
0.0253582858,
-0.0262550935,
0.0445241779,
-0.0075656124,
0.0683534071,
0.013692637,
-0.0274015721,
0.011736569,
0.007314207,
-0.0216346551,
-0.0620887317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12379v1 | Solving Hard Analogy Questions with Relation Embedding Chains | 2023-10-18T23:13:22 | 2023-10-18T23:13:22 | Nitesh Kumar, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modelling how concepts are related is a central topic in Lexical Semantics. A
common strategy is to rely on knowledge graphs (KGs) such as ConceptNet, and to
model the relation between two concepts as a set of paths. However, KGs are
limited to a fixed set of relation types, and they are incomplete and often
noisy. Another strategy is to distill relation embeddings from a fine-tuned
language model. However, this is less suitable for words that are only
indirectly related and it does not readily allow us to incorporate structured
domain knowledge. In this paper, we aim to combine the best of both worlds. We
model relations as paths but associate their edges with relation embeddings.
The paths are obtained by first identifying suitable intermediate words and
then selecting those words for which informative relation embeddings can be
obtained. We empirically show that our proposed representations are useful for
solving hard analogy questions. | [
0.0358277038,
0.0272590294,
-0.0097834179,
0.0970041081,
-0.0269230735,
0.0274196677,
-0.0174055081,
-0.0027081433,
-0.0132982107,
-0.0607814267,
0.0013322859,
-0.0118784448,
-0.0306230336,
-0.0143612865,
0.0295574516,
-0.0640564114,
0.0079474496,
0.0252184551,
-0.0218409076,
0.0047352742,
0.0036864774,
0.0296667907,
-0.0440665781,
0.0400819182,
-0.0129251573,
-0.0168292522,
0.0211455226,
-0.0520376302,
0.0381633416,
-0.0484215356,
0.0000727019,
0.0243985336,
0.061177738,
-0.0043778908,
0.0000018827,
-0.0445323735,
0.0186665915,
-0.0043580811,
-0.0060444535,
0.0015643705,
0.0024731359,
-0.0128626432,
0.0455785096,
-0.0159288701,
-0.0350795574,
-0.0661057159,
0.0537001789,
0.032586202,
0.0004848499,
-0.0009879242,
-0.0145509578,
-0.0456004217,
-0.0012128374,
-0.0197254196,
0.0098869223,
-0.0176282916,
0.0294882189,
0.0478534885,
0.0127899973,
0.0148558514,
-0.0397374257,
-0.0007976081,
0.0107079372,
0.0041640294,
0.0160858519,
0.045872502,
0.0151291173,
0.0433225669,
0.0230445974,
0.0989432931,
-0.0083222995,
-0.0290873293,
-0.0007990684,
-0.0233360063,
-0.0244045202,
0.0565365292,
-0.0175408982,
-0.0176531095,
-0.0062618633,
0.0286220424,
0.0320907384,
0.0486602858,
0.0368599705,
0.0058933846,
-0.0281110555,
0.0205216929,
0.0027110409,
-0.0164887495,
0.0366013534,
-0.0084317895,
-0.0245349649,
-0.0197481867,
-0.0348173715,
-0.0054363287,
0.0206786934,
0.0422129743,
-0.0278291646,
0.0056522847,
0.0119983871,
-0.0849854127,
0.0254579149,
0.0297155082,
0.0249609072,
0.0555338636,
-0.0774070695,
-0.0002882416,
-0.0122772828,
0.0338983163,
-0.0584022216,
-0.0056575951,
-0.0529657044,
0.0384438969,
-0.064715907,
0.0444164462,
0.0082719056,
-0.0335997716,
-0.0079172719,
0.0235104393,
-0.0489391349,
-0.006812878,
0.0102241617,
0.0248052385,
0.0158881452,
0.0076371701,
-0.0346541777,
-0.0244574752,
-0.1017104834,
0.037632823,
-0.0407560281,
0.0154100852,
0.0113252159,
-0.0327352732,
0.0238705892,
-0.0425338373,
0.0002230439,
0.0952698961,
0.0482375585,
-0.0237506162,
-0.0225042943,
-0.0094295759,
0.0370611958,
-0.0021556902,
0.0189588517,
-0.0623683967,
0.0493384264,
0.0208971817,
-0.0111562051,
-0.0529401861,
0.0234577917,
0.0269443244,
-0.0937204212,
0.0834194943,
0.0212175809,
-0.025191525,
-0.0385951437,
0.0188778508,
-0.0223211981,
0.0146736912,
0.0250600353,
-0.039229311,
0.0202776045,
0.0107048107,
-0.0525759161,
-0.0152166747,
0.0166870914,
-0.0025258476,
-0.0231584664,
0.0055099251,
-0.0001815273,
0.0819379017,
0.0326974355,
0.0297190417,
-0.0311637297,
-0.0596621521,
-0.005036436,
0.0387173109,
0.0101108542,
0.0456807464,
0.0565767884,
-0.0130879339,
-0.0206426643,
0.0194599759,
-0.0427474901,
0.0213351082,
0.0192538425,
0.0169467293,
0.008714159,
0.0262492746,
-0.0290822666,
0.009910957,
-0.0156654585,
0.0087647391,
0.02161327,
-0.0042647016,
0.0549893528,
0.0326628983,
-0.0067193066,
0.023718141,
0.0820355117,
0.0110597713,
-0.0196407884,
0.0303893574,
-0.0198774524,
0.0067167934,
0.0564077348,
-0.0094470708,
-0.0391070955,
-0.0037787149,
-0.0268690549,
0.0048182099,
0.0426008925,
-0.0326664262,
-0.0343700238,
-0.0568503961,
-0.0523700193,
0.0083712526,
-0.0032519486,
0.0186289772,
0.0129907439,
0.0152322417,
0.0217375644,
-0.067550987,
0.0451725088,
0.0356539451,
-0.0212696418,
-0.0065293405,
0.0026915218,
0.0337938443,
0.0250222422,
0.0264635719,
0.0092671365,
0.0223475825,
0.032381814,
-0.0694618523,
-0.0389674641,
0.0410012789,
-0.0628804862,
-0.047436215,
0.0430017076,
-0.0595985092,
-0.0009724224,
-0.009112969,
-0.0501493439,
0.0100299083,
0.037051443,
0.0072889579,
0.116804339,
-0.0287408549,
-0.005197031,
0.0055411551,
-0.0060304524,
-0.0170691218,
0.0834880173,
0.0081169456,
0.0595624112,
-0.0133463768,
-0.0179937929,
0.0009688371,
0.0178240612,
-0.0140488129,
-0.0262558367,
0.0209709927,
-0.0161214806,
0.0086739119,
-0.0182184931,
-0.0127962241,
0.036839027,
-0.0267621242,
-0.0068959258,
0.0498060137,
0.0048666149,
0.0179880802,
0.0030914422,
0.0147213554,
-0.0080764648,
-0.0054241135,
0.0344269387,
-0.0265285634,
0.0104905339,
0.0198448412,
-0.0113686416,
-0.0326066539,
-0.0344491675,
-0.0157205369,
-0.0332189463,
0.0760182515,
-0.0087743597,
0.0121184168,
0.0206847917,
0.0309026707,
-0.0577120706,
0.0336209163,
-0.0069067176,
0.008231625,
-0.0257691685,
0.0027346725,
0.0214800835,
-0.0036571289,
-0.0088694757,
0.0417412631,
0.0623801053,
-0.0110678989,
-0.0427521504,
-0.0035210268,
-0.0415146761,
0.0179541484,
0.0012369351,
-0.0157886408,
-0.0429859608,
0.058682926,
0.0422073379,
-0.0047913273,
-0.0229721777,
0.0387464501,
-0.0168338399,
0.0565788411,
-0.0530215576,
-0.0008656797,
0.0246352628,
-0.0272945575,
-0.0158589613,
0.0242517572,
0.078452535,
0.0085993242,
0.0405212492,
0.0010822038,
-0.0299623366,
-0.0117191924,
0.0931763873,
0.0117104566,
0.0426935591,
0.0315607712,
0.025231868,
-0.0497667566,
-0.0288856477,
0.0472572222,
-0.0043513183,
0.0262522008,
-0.0243269037,
0.0361450575,
0.0208182,
-0.0272437036,
-0.04690874,
0.0020454864,
-0.042894423,
0.0203691721,
-0.0131373061,
0.0054347427,
-0.0000054765,
0.0369803794,
-0.0127881933,
0.0073863035,
0.0502485,
-0.0270263702,
-0.0227631964,
0.0646326169,
0.0729748905,
-0.0381765179,
0.0055225571,
0.0506334566,
0.0503840782,
0.0306840539,
0.0381042957,
-0.0051424862,
-0.0482446216,
0.0233349819,
-0.02932344,
-0.0623237044,
0.0217243638,
-0.0000108583,
-0.0523065068,
-0.0325700939,
-0.0363298617,
0.0705335811,
0.0565038882,
-0.0146504361,
0.0479552671,
0.023008436,
-0.016824916,
0.0415198989,
0.0236257575,
-0.0581527054,
-0.0278298426,
0.0119783916,
-0.0533303469,
0.0280050356,
-0.0516436622,
0.0179681219,
-0.0819934458,
-0.0021311562,
0.0072147157,
-0.0417640768,
-0.0534836799,
-0.0189736541,
0.021481473,
0.0028237293,
-0.0576897152,
-0.0294365827,
-0.0128115062,
0.0051393239,
-0.0041831937,
0.0399192758,
-0.0013340752,
0.058243908,
-0.0377512276,
0.0608771555,
-0.0034560685,
0.0224939231,
0.0250795539,
-0.0114553887,
0.0003841696,
-0.0630759299,
-0.0626830086,
-0.0064841309,
-0.0121542495,
0.0015605906,
-0.0038432945,
-0.0107189342,
0.0324246623,
-0.0760136545,
-0.0038021591,
0.0066054426,
0.0806594789,
-0.0249742176,
-0.0428571105,
-0.0389682055,
-0.0011233495,
-0.0226490963,
0.0749503374,
0.039859619,
0.0120492298,
0.023874199,
-0.0053183744,
0.0073704645,
0.004086507,
-0.0335264057,
-0.0165764075,
-0.0162547603,
0.0551081933,
-0.0615622327,
-0.0406621285,
0.0237390306,
0.0196410753,
-0.0082717817,
-0.0281237364,
0.0500683598,
-0.0219866019,
-0.0724508017,
0.0055223852,
-0.0157211833,
0.044869978,
0.0338087417,
-0.0010647356,
0.0517522208,
-0.0029497619,
-0.0813235939,
-0.0299296696,
-0.0546198525,
-0.0019327245,
-0.0364372246,
0.0176351741,
0.0049772086,
0.0188420359,
-0.0241754018,
0.032695774,
0.0196195412,
0.02314201,
-0.0264345575,
-0.0193329677,
-0.0249121375,
-0.000208264,
0.0191604383,
0.0304951388,
-0.0450895503,
0.033973895,
0.0207008515,
0.0919003338,
-0.0178697072,
-0.0520970561,
0.0272060949,
-0.0419537649,
0.0148348175,
0.0411288291,
-0.0355165936,
-0.0471759401,
0.0133734727,
-0.0041935658,
-0.016654944,
-0.0273543876,
0.0076645026,
-0.0239303038,
0.0302691534,
-0.034687873,
-0.1103316993,
0.0067705549,
0.0281707235,
0.0393117405,
-0.0353100859,
0.0508043319,
0.0233466253,
0.0147609003,
-0.0074031539,
-0.0424958467,
0.0140200714,
-0.0259780604,
0.0060144491,
-0.0613530502,
0.0421832278,
0.018029606,
-0.011658825,
-0.0319241546,
0.0149578368,
-0.0068020164,
-0.033972118,
-0.060269665,
0.0498395674,
0.0483722873,
-0.0545166135,
-0.0288750101,
-0.051528044,
0.0069828606,
0.0236964207,
0.0196186416,
-0.0264415797,
-0.0436984226,
0.076762408,
0.0439254716,
0.0163576584,
0.0052661435,
0.0400002375,
-0.0349427462,
0.0904809013,
0.0068685692,
-0.049455706,
-0.0171462987,
-0.0343504511,
0.0052472437,
0.0576799959,
-0.0052326331,
0.0560584441,
-0.0658348575,
-0.0953445435,
-0.0376976393,
0.0102064246,
-0.044162903,
0.0448779352,
0.0451542623,
0.0101152295,
0.0194309372,
-0.0044742166,
-0.0011695543,
0.0328115001,
-0.0877168998,
-0.0763579309,
-0.0435547419,
-5.874106167e-33,
-0.0101027973,
0.0064730756,
0.0124081699,
-0.0231861882,
-0.0340754762,
0.0065641315,
-0.0299697258,
-0.0346931852,
-0.0634012148,
0.0523325987,
0.0087694777,
-0.0425792672,
-0.023780562,
-0.0129928505,
-0.019684121,
-0.0113481777,
-0.0335861333,
0.0138484901,
0.0190392788,
-0.0100639816,
0.0245231204,
-0.0109289913,
0.0289769173,
-0.0590704642,
-0.0199434776,
-0.018342983,
0.0292156339,
0.0321553871,
0.0206596944,
0.0453580245,
-0.0330360085,
0.0394255854,
0.0366658121,
0.0120523227,
0.040216662,
-0.027627293,
-0.1215357482,
-0.0383370221,
-0.0042542401,
-0.0518431403,
-0.0091213081,
0.0096711721,
0.0315378755,
0.00203711,
0.0596484616,
-0.0408506095,
0.0477621481,
-0.0184376575,
-0.0316332877,
-0.0075401813,
-0.0582920499,
-0.0180141553,
-0.0048262603,
-0.0244372338,
-0.0207781382,
0.0062079523,
0.0183662176,
0.0000207056,
-0.0489655025,
0.0124864178,
-0.0344860107,
0.0022160581,
0.0218219534,
-0.0326966383,
0.0263687037,
0.0690383911,
-0.075153023,
-0.1015025899,
0.0166955069,
0.0292782411,
-0.0073434175,
0.0412632488,
-0.0104995929,
-0.0015348438,
0.0403741412,
0.013019721,
-0.046112407,
0.0065233074,
0.02779161,
0.0443534888,
-0.0056548966,
0.0055633127,
-0.0317939073,
-0.0300882068,
-0.053304784,
-0.0056630773,
-0.0468639955,
-0.065070428,
0.0471431911,
-0.0334408358,
0.005270632,
0.0093567809,
-0.0087910853,
-0.0496098362,
-0.0296958648,
0.0235391129,
0.0326579213,
-0.0047523254,
-0.0228169281,
0.0120761106,
-0.0426622815,
-0.0513348393,
-0.0133778844,
-0.0053622597,
0.0116454531,
0.0126605146,
0.0244311858,
-0.0244228393,
-0.0479670502,
0.0007898286,
-0.0520383231,
-0.0644810796,
-0.0218108445,
-0.0370607935,
0.0090910243,
0.0806960687,
0.0023966006,
0.0536548793,
0.0270126835,
-0.027051108,
-0.0022091379,
0.0243130084,
-0.023353124,
0.0490978546,
0.0004092533,
-0.0118906638,
-0.0214488991,
0.0126464097,
0.0338076949,
-0.0668718815,
-0.0218333285,
-0.0012540743,
2.563e-7,
0.0371937454,
0.0042168754,
0.0252952613,
0.0545741692,
-0.0137983039,
0.048149813,
0.0430308953,
0.0269550569,
-0.0230224542,
0.0030650939,
0.0401701592,
0.0403578319,
-0.0122045521,
0.0393671282,
-0.048317723,
0.0492103137,
-0.0806168392,
-0.0746570155,
-0.0233307183,
-0.0432786904,
0.0648828819,
0.0757331103,
0.0696242526,
0.019743545,
-0.02713231,
-0.0536157265,
0.0267635211,
-0.030487325,
0.0328257121,
-0.0101929586,
-0.02535538,
-0.0029965781,
-0.0014107173,
0.0260965861,
0.0096318675,
0.020692179,
0.0403341576,
-0.0300727431,
-0.0105977003,
0.0228577051,
-0.0312320217,
-0.0414760076,
0.0336947925,
-0.0347772762,
0.020375045,
-0.0983900428,
0.023108732,
0.0138509814,
0.0026360226,
0.0365173146,
0.0063644145,
0.0310922358,
-0.0275556147,
0.0056873551,
0.0610962287,
0.0119196968,
0.0092995409,
-0.0724844486,
0.0191270877,
0.0638167486,
-0.0147456899,
0.0140366517,
0.0133215552,
-0.0223630872,
0.041963283,
-0.008947338,
-0.0239990298,
2.024971083e-34,
-0.0051493207,
0.0335555337,
0.0047611529,
0.0016845484,
0.0464079082,
-0.0277880989,
0.0102622733,
-0.0044530816,
0.0325383656,
-0.0848841369,
-0.0011647979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12362v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12362v2 | REMARK-LLM: A Robust and Efficient Watermarking Framework for Generative Large Language Models | 2023-10-18T22:14:37 | 2024-04-08T00:16:46 | Ruisi Zhang, Shehzeen Samarah Hussain, Paarth Neekhara, Farinaz Koushanfar | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | We present REMARK-LLM, a novel efficient, and robust watermarking framework
designed for texts generated by large language models (LLMs). Synthesizing
human-like content using LLMs necessitates vast computational resources and
extensive datasets, encapsulating critical intellectual property (IP). However,
the generated content is prone to malicious exploitation, including spamming
and plagiarism. To address the challenges, REMARK-LLM proposes three new
components: (i) a learning-based message encoding module to infuse binary
signatures into LLM-generated texts; (ii) a reparameterization module to
transform the dense distributions from the message encoding to the sparse
distribution of the watermarked textual tokens; (iii) a decoding module
dedicated for signature extraction; Furthermore, we introduce an optimized beam
search algorithm to guarantee the coherence and consistency of the generated
content. REMARK-LLM is rigorously trained to encourage the preservation of
semantic integrity in watermarked content, while ensuring effective watermark
retrieval. Extensive evaluations on multiple unseen datasets highlight
REMARK-LLM proficiency and transferability in inserting 2 times more signature
bits into the same texts when compared to prior art, all while maintaining
semantic integrity. Furthermore, REMARK-LLM exhibits better resilience against
a spectrum of watermark detection and removal attacks. | [
0.0543834716,
0.0685173422,
0.0013319113,
0.0433889702,
-0.0446228758,
-0.0005028674,
0.0282603167,
0.0302015226,
0.0337169655,
-0.0352574401,
-0.0030149005,
0.0065553724,
-0.0155475689,
0.0461968742,
0.0539442748,
-0.0276987236,
0.0193606783,
-0.0160250813,
0.0151210437,
-0.0253849085,
0.0072530196,
0.0073366207,
0.068479009,
0.0108024869,
-0.0320255123,
-0.0117106624,
0.0094365422,
0.0436284877,
-0.0044057979,
-0.0235252939,
-0.0486399233,
0.0393972024,
0.0286605507,
0.0951639488,
0.0000021036,
-0.0232263524,
-0.0313821547,
0.0459479988,
-0.023860395,
0.0687588602,
0.0783925727,
-0.0150417686,
-0.0425336771,
0.0104951411,
-0.0311551951,
0.0220159944,
0.0216050707,
0.0680454001,
0.103887029,
0.0796634853,
-0.0217206441,
0.0040277475,
0.0643887296,
-0.0149510689,
0.0151082259,
-0.0109767932,
0.0263083521,
0.0189708397,
-0.0150947459,
0.0619242936,
0.0294346027,
0.0671262741,
-0.0130176675,
-0.0491641499,
-0.0056594405,
0.0076194573,
-0.0052013095,
0.0144808283,
0.0083924271,
-0.0066308985,
-0.0579134338,
-0.0321467668,
0.0233748816,
0.0064025703,
0.0197163969,
0.0169590972,
-0.037522532,
0.0607201084,
0.0262580402,
0.0378527083,
0.0121634807,
-0.0097599486,
0.0423030928,
0.0054745967,
-0.0141389621,
0.0183238201,
0.0427823141,
-0.0233594812,
-0.0695519671,
-0.0379223339,
-0.0523238145,
-0.063199304,
0.054740157,
0.0008363347,
0.0693665147,
0.0007035205,
-0.0948495641,
-0.0649012178,
0.0176230166,
-0.0393557027,
0.0252341256,
0.00095512,
-0.002986727,
0.0412042998,
-0.0615305714,
0.0543884784,
-0.0465876274,
0.030389268,
0.0058532725,
-0.0375104137,
-0.0210241787,
-0.0441175587,
-0.0431233346,
0.0534770899,
-0.0110189281,
-0.0238466468,
-0.020018436,
0.0489842519,
0.0147626344,
0.0249318872,
-0.0216801185,
-0.0187426582,
0.0136295827,
-0.0092619248,
0.0483259186,
-0.0376050323,
0.0420104116,
-0.0090323538,
-0.0114936111,
-0.0289615709,
0.0060402211,
0.0554104485,
0.0122243157,
0.0055026319,
0.010338637,
0.0763695017,
0.0177980624,
-0.0425945036,
0.008911524,
-0.0434420668,
-0.0015706737,
0.0169554148,
0.0018166265,
-0.0529387854,
0.0028646484,
-0.0137705356,
-0.0133653814,
-0.0686165839,
0.0311958455,
0.0227193907,
-0.0368221104,
0.0246697534,
-0.0198857728,
-0.0103897797,
0.0292332191,
-0.0111224176,
-0.0019177303,
-0.0012496328,
0.0492488742,
0.0850149319,
0.0554923937,
-0.0121500483,
0.0107790483,
0.0599134974,
0.0111767724,
0.0162004177,
0.0055866712,
-0.0406148843,
0.0526463427,
-0.0379054733,
0.0090589067,
0.0711488947,
-0.0151889073,
-0.0355719849,
0.0744994804,
0.0648449063,
-0.0437221825,
0.0106247896,
-0.0175894834,
0.042739898,
0.0261610039,
-0.0389115401,
-0.02099232,
-0.0096355295,
-0.0314534046,
-0.0467188433,
0.01167526,
0.0188531075,
-0.0036631131,
0.0258271787,
-0.0059527424,
-0.0188856069,
0.0290726535,
-0.0070681632,
0.0294263959,
0.0379696712,
-0.053850159,
0.0450436845,
-0.0258447602,
-0.0247945171,
0.0165179707,
-0.0612416752,
0.0494081005,
0.0347168818,
0.09901651,
0.0143562257,
0.0896643251,
-0.0068127397,
-0.0386981964,
0.0522677302,
-0.0406103879,
-0.0018030285,
-0.0101890955,
-0.0373585075,
-0.023566477,
-0.0235312805,
-0.0109938299,
0.027788708,
0.0299801398,
0.0173077192,
0.0479948744,
-0.0209413543,
-0.0249815844,
0.0123491967,
0.0268158801,
-0.0205345135,
0.0109859454,
-0.0321365334,
0.0327080935,
0.0171022676,
-0.0240854062,
0.0315317884,
0.0509323813,
-0.0423290469,
-0.0407118015,
-0.0180040393,
0.0098960204,
0.0455312319,
0.0493311919,
-0.0281268824,
0.0197616871,
0.0322933197,
-0.0064749778,
-0.016680412,
0.0266312752,
-0.0581122972,
0.0415110253,
-0.056011159,
0.0147728343,
-0.0124617526,
0.0448537804,
-0.0392807275,
0.0256684124,
-0.0067678932,
-0.022933891,
-0.0352081656,
0.0266960561,
0.0130655309,
0.0016350632,
-0.0376172997,
-0.0209292602,
-0.0457387157,
0.0047341422,
-0.001861471,
0.0052496293,
0.0310832877,
-0.0415301919,
-0.0786807984,
0.0112081729,
-0.0044137682,
0.0156167001,
0.0092469482,
0.0047707628,
-0.0020149017,
-0.0078660175,
-0.0548017509,
-0.0640890822,
0.0196768772,
0.0090456558,
0.0190220606,
-0.0254199672,
-0.0034260608,
-0.0016877948,
-0.0121517517,
0.0130194137,
0.0534800291,
0.0043846173,
-0.0342503451,
-0.0569422245,
0.0497879311,
-0.0041949921,
-0.0012303395,
-0.0087725315,
-0.0097368378,
-0.0042603733,
-0.0402529016,
0.0133299176,
0.0380270705,
0.0310089868,
0.0135289598,
0.0139690805,
0.0261969063,
-0.0376312435,
-0.0320472717,
-0.0395414792,
0.009470243,
-0.0020306909,
-0.0417899899,
0.0671460032,
-0.0146969678,
0.0220908821,
0.0137978075,
-0.015889246,
0.0235234126,
0.0163098462,
-0.0065854932,
-0.0091502499,
-0.0172833111,
-0.0203405488,
-0.0285976585,
-0.0255696401,
-0.0565176792,
-0.0038811103,
-0.0653647035,
0.0172053371,
0.001028668,
-0.0169327315,
0.0000092371,
0.0394627526,
-0.0058599119,
0.038072262,
-0.0117413029,
-0.0294224545,
0.0113542303,
0.022084292,
0.0576280169,
-0.0463044159,
-0.0378697366,
0.0059494474,
0.0017555217,
-0.002955629,
0.0065762512,
-0.0214473717,
-0.0592579767,
0.0025497261,
0.0085238758,
0.0425372049,
-0.0228144545,
-0.030198358,
0.0127807567,
0.029410515,
0.0069053243,
-0.0227358192,
0.0068781464,
-0.045011308,
0.0667580813,
-0.0004177877,
-0.0610194542,
0.0145642906,
-0.0311546437,
-0.0333790816,
0.0784274638,
-0.0099556157,
0.0009468885,
-0.001064669,
-0.0091339601,
0.0185849927,
0.0222115126,
-0.0154544925,
-0.0076394766,
0.0489106476,
-0.0413511917,
0.0274192113,
0.0717881769,
0.0213291235,
-0.0131271416,
-0.0053373799,
-0.0016127647,
-0.0004770721,
0.0101634888,
-0.0172325931,
-0.0847464278,
-0.0046982961,
0.0319446065,
0.0267400835,
-0.0178290177,
-0.008943093,
-0.0181437936,
-0.0688707903,
0.0408726148,
0.0292979069,
-0.0010510067,
-0.0144666126,
-0.0538503155,
-0.0418813527,
0.0601682551,
-0.0501700118,
-0.0285961479,
0.0366086811,
-0.0067438618,
0.0178854242,
0.0035232876,
-0.0453154147,
-0.0176033732,
-0.0351652317,
0.0387107655,
0.0620181859,
0.032721892,
-0.0065415534,
-0.0269542634,
-0.0093136616,
-0.0057805968,
-0.0197980348,
-0.0011287922,
0.033165548,
0.0016788032,
-0.0157213025,
-0.0443296134,
0.0337709859,
0.0150589682,
-0.0451728553,
0.0075069335,
0.0509339347,
0.005857503,
0.0069780392,
-0.0220755301,
-0.0547240749,
0.0360689797,
0.0654196516,
0.0128113562,
-0.0316087678,
-0.0319088399,
-0.0670020655,
0.0261172038,
-0.0106149474,
-0.0338315517,
0.0001101338,
-0.054820057,
-0.0282925405,
-0.0605318137,
0.0461207926,
-0.0458542258,
0.0065598357,
0.0402917303,
0.0269663054,
0.0238288324,
-0.0576671585,
-0.0529741012,
-0.01886658,
-0.1060581058,
0.0359775871,
-0.0729303062,
0.0250799581,
-0.0054617464,
-0.0439788923,
-0.011022483,
0.0319314562,
-0.1135157421,
-0.0638561398,
-0.0026689428,
0.0243456699,
0.0163110346,
-0.0107632848,
-0.0282768887,
-0.0608161651,
0.0754815936,
0.0327913575,
-0.016309822,
0.0107642598,
0.0450135544,
-0.0398868546,
-0.0137191452,
0.0211502202,
-0.0477038622,
0.0179571509,
0.0546489283,
-0.0140321534,
-0.0296185464,
0.0074708974,
0.011932604,
0.0675824732,
-0.0115525946,
-0.0201231521,
0.0157786831,
-0.0020201874,
0.0112318071,
-0.0463245623,
-0.0233722236,
-0.0348113999,
0.0235294979,
0.0358869396,
-0.0227494501,
0.0047298423,
0.02202194,
0.0026048515,
0.0426104441,
-0.0104337884,
0.0110555897,
-0.0443631336,
0.031104492,
0.0489268191,
-0.0044679665,
-0.0004812997,
0.0337389447,
-0.0007936847,
0.0102947038,
-0.0003868891,
-0.0120600015,
0.0125033744,
-0.0165031608,
-0.0011575894,
0.0345295928,
-0.0573675521,
-0.0620657317,
-0.0361740738,
0.0324716233,
0.0429787412,
0.0307702851,
0.0411348529,
-0.0697725639,
-0.0128149046,
-0.0408808775,
0.0033327132,
-0.0015572306,
-0.0549668744,
-0.0116641372,
-0.0063075526,
-0.0314822271,
0.0505966283,
0.0371980928,
-0.001378158,
0.0487520173,
0.0074290121,
-0.0427491628,
-0.0369261615,
-0.0197373349,
0.0544769317,
0.0117881792,
-0.0479227528,
-0.011097352,
-0.0207169969,
-0.0361212827,
0.0260808133,
0.0082661603,
0.0138510121,
0.0103849461,
-0.0317381658,
0.0371745713,
-0.0199750606,
0.0241285209,
-0.0686869994,
0.0341526009,
0.0134170614,
-0.062503472,
0.0093780262,
-5.798405065e-33,
0.0208756402,
-0.0213433988,
-0.0448868088,
0.0138423322,
0.0211913176,
0.0301699098,
-0.0238048304,
-0.031241715,
0.0198260564,
-0.006460445,
-0.0176800862,
-0.0167727359,
0.0066608544,
0.0241709966,
-0.0474928208,
0.028412126,
0.0484608263,
0.0031502272,
-0.0212036613,
0.0293661449,
0.0604894683,
-0.0163202789,
-0.0091545917,
-0.1056663096,
0.0120619889,
-0.0485923812,
-0.0679812506,
-0.0457287021,
-0.0281432066,
0.0537473746,
-0.0247217473,
0.0091739902,
-0.0261733737,
0.0155704599,
-0.0339908339,
0.0332115255,
-0.0282167066,
0.0305468366,
-0.0071179918,
0.0262465682,
0.0327792838,
-0.0964670926,
0.0174177326,
-0.0408781208,
-0.0177529082,
0.0396797471,
-0.005340205,
-0.0068092137,
-0.0370733887,
-0.0611747839,
-0.0200693738,
0.01134237,
-0.0066862903,
0.0126013141,
0.0370535478,
-0.0134769175,
0.0317077488,
0.0434242301,
-0.079951115,
0.0344756357,
-0.0101356972,
-0.0165991969,
0.0181178674,
-0.0198282413,
0.0273260754,
0.0335578546,
-0.0023986474,
-0.0224378668,
0.0393921845,
-0.0000163004,
0.0213652328,
0.0379969142,
0.078471303,
0.0552404411,
0.0683249831,
-0.0235612784,
-0.0153725892,
0.0269930735,
-0.0194695573,
-0.0170910805,
0.06040309,
0.0218260139,
-0.014448721,
0.0015750725,
-0.0372791328,
-0.0624455698,
-0.0184386,
-0.0267908387,
0.0211649407,
0.0259963088,
-0.0611566864,
-0.0140355602,
0.0319182836,
-0.0574386194,
-0.0536832102,
0.0078297602,
-0.022337677,
0.0373783596,
0.0012850623,
0.0328558013,
0.0241301451,
-0.0114246849,
0.0671492815,
-0.1038926765,
0.0067661242,
0.0093808873,
0.0634298101,
0.0214761551,
-0.0696161762,
0.0036371239,
0.009571949,
0.0265591983,
0.0304448307,
0.0149246352,
0.014320923,
-0.0254816916,
0.0183041915,
-0.0375769883,
0.0114639467,
0.0067863329,
-0.0224418472,
0.0085077845,
-0.0251617711,
0.0146866143,
-0.0013260568,
0.0392528214,
-0.0407586955,
0.0122719416,
0.0525271557,
-0.0384935588,
-0.0076915161,
0.0227602124,
2.755e-7,
0.0207068361,
0.0587922558,
0.0366851389,
-0.0021554008,
0.0466370396,
0.0553383119,
-0.0008254275,
0.0289863721,
-0.0213024579,
0.0040833084,
-0.0511430725,
0.0056255492,
0.0647284165,
-0.011836472,
-0.0959353372,
0.0375147648,
-0.0355679132,
-0.0346033759,
-0.0689082965,
0.0075456444,
0.0534461588,
0.1010649353,
0.0282924362,
-0.042329751,
-0.0014783103,
-0.0450826809,
0.0593546592,
-0.0205520596,
-0.0285609085,
-0.0255866833,
0.017164601,
0.0099537522,
0.0126702338,
-0.0118361069,
-0.0338220447,
-0.0178193431,
0.0149002755,
0.0610572025,
0.02479963,
0.0090729473,
-0.0323922262,
-0.0329967104,
-0.0008474219,
-0.0426011793,
0.043662414,
0.0695913881,
-0.0212278198,
-0.0808817521,
-0.067030333,
-0.0372466817,
0.0107384073,
-0.0322981551,
-0.0040549985,
0.0037758141,
0.0154429385,
0.0102757057,
0.0014236881,
-0.0429255664,
-0.0022729726,
-0.0771229863,
-0.0300658327,
0.0125376973,
-0.0566241294,
-0.0005741187,
0.0668330267,
-0.0703498721,
0.0450254008,
2.900331191e-34,
0.0163521208,
-0.0656916499,
-0.0031116256,
0.0469555706,
0.0425113328,
0.018446546,
-0.0146210566,
0.0551221222,
-0.0194480885,
-0.0743765905,
0.0022771962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12360v1 | GRI: Graph-based Relative Isomorphism of Word Embedding Spaces | 2023-10-18T22:10:47 | 2023-10-18T22:10:47 | Muhammad Asif Ali, Yan Hu, Jianbin Qin, Di Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated construction of bilingual dictionaries using monolingual embedding
spaces is a core challenge in machine translation. The end performance of these
dictionaries relies upon the geometric similarity of individual spaces, i.e.,
their degree of isomorphism. Existing attempts aimed at controlling the
relative isomorphism of different spaces fail to incorporate the impact of
semantically related words in the training objective. To address this, we
propose GRI that combines the distributional training objectives with attentive
graph convolutions to unanimously consider the impact of semantically similar
words required to define/compute the relative isomorphism of multiple spaces.
Experimental evaluation shows that GRI outperforms the existing research by
improving the average P@1 by a relative score of up to 63.6%. We release the
codes for GRI at https://github.com/asif6827/GRI. | [
0.0085839927,
0.0600266382,
0.0254365932,
0.0735364854,
-0.0410415493,
0.0264550112,
-0.0187302977,
-0.0020175646,
0.0392049588,
0.0056218719,
-0.0395565778,
-0.0119880773,
0.0272589307,
-0.028444767,
0.0539396182,
-0.0199663043,
0.0304046385,
0.0284307227,
-0.0720145628,
-0.0207107104,
-0.0053667156,
0.0215402395,
0.0281953067,
0.0057606329,
-0.0018103543,
-0.0038501683,
0.0304633752,
0.0290079284,
0.0286986269,
-0.0255079586,
-0.0227315053,
0.0280012395,
0.0253596529,
0.0642891079,
0.0000015673,
-0.008748685,
-0.0372297727,
0.0126432087,
0.0467767455,
-0.0305573102,
0.0320115462,
-0.0526252314,
0.0324516371,
0.0052689789,
-0.0276029836,
-0.0757410526,
0.0775079578,
0.0053235199,
0.0035708637,
0.0492404513,
-0.0518904962,
-0.0677067563,
-0.0320853181,
-0.0266732872,
-0.0051675159,
-0.039930582,
-0.006236413,
0.0285871215,
-0.0242753979,
-0.0111054927,
-0.0634229034,
0.0521202125,
-0.0095386915,
-0.0054221558,
0.0140022943,
0.0188564435,
-0.0424872935,
-0.0161146298,
0.0071040825,
0.1097876802,
-0.0883444473,
-0.054104872,
-0.0165810455,
-0.0014967393,
0.0011476824,
0.0347942226,
0.0013843053,
-0.0452936478,
-0.0474485084,
0.0516926497,
-0.00605916,
-0.0019063588,
0.0668598339,
-0.0250811614,
-0.0428785421,
0.0324273482,
0.0570084378,
-0.0211476889,
0.0269021541,
0.0484705195,
-0.021021992,
0.0198379215,
0.0210425388,
-0.0332287848,
0.0187730361,
0.0076958588,
-0.0427993611,
-0.026646968,
-0.0021536751,
-0.0337214842,
0.0639943257,
0.0415284075,
-0.0031479367,
0.0310755707,
-0.066632472,
0.0581984259,
-0.0374087654,
0.0618107021,
-0.096633397,
-0.0197129007,
-0.0675492436,
0.0656884536,
-0.0329492912,
-0.0005246534,
-0.0024192682,
-0.0587098934,
-0.0104795257,
0.0439698249,
-0.008218159,
0.0053476496,
0.0337600484,
-0.0074972762,
-0.022973448,
0.0255671814,
0.0570373833,
0.0234861951,
-0.0362222679,
-0.0106985178,
-0.071635507,
0.0086627444,
-0.0084690666,
0.0600680187,
0.0163519345,
-0.0281171687,
-0.0115312254,
0.0465132557,
-0.00695968,
-0.0487789698,
0.0067950496,
0.0445070043,
-0.0264869984,
-0.0324904695,
0.0296755079,
-0.0796084031,
0.0688757002,
-0.0017792918,
-0.0184343159,
-0.0537139066,
0.0134783452,
-0.0407264419,
-0.0453719236,
0.1108165905,
0.025372427,
0.007428328,
0.0118697183,
-0.0387193784,
0.0041420106,
0.0266809631,
0.0222116075,
0.0001008533,
0.0457497537,
-0.0049737711,
-0.0373138599,
0.0199881066,
0.0211749747,
0.0322961025,
-0.0408468656,
0.0041767932,
-0.0018125451,
0.0327059962,
0.034393318,
0.0783393085,
-0.0340943709,
-0.0517684147,
0.0240743924,
0.0493184514,
0.0247830153,
0.0011258209,
0.0436120033,
0.0099069392,
-0.0511216037,
0.0271912087,
-0.0403628573,
-0.0176822599,
0.0410897397,
0.0322737247,
0.0301417187,
0.042738352,
-0.0300340559,
0.0122781424,
-0.0100268852,
-0.0294845961,
0.0643664524,
-0.0171077102,
0.0311662387,
0.0320206992,
-0.0450743027,
0.0321140215,
0.0044762036,
-0.0194683783,
0.014776771,
0.0280248877,
-0.0422321148,
0.0433310755,
0.0110621499,
0.0316822827,
-0.0158286896,
0.0190673433,
0.0053454395,
0.03141867,
0.0254135225,
-0.0368852057,
0.0195024703,
-0.0743716881,
-0.04224962,
0.0066028619,
-0.0171315894,
0.0574883446,
0.0504776016,
0.0220785234,
0.0224871263,
-0.1040097848,
-0.0418477021,
0.0192619003,
0.0044822874,
-0.0215950795,
0.0127648879,
0.0384364352,
-0.0000228455,
0.0065069962,
-0.0103598274,
0.0129868668,
0.0063399044,
-0.033974696,
-0.010084535,
0.0224009827,
-0.0094618239,
-0.0772516057,
0.0558481589,
-0.069380112,
0.0099355141,
0.0118571296,
-0.0580779016,
-0.0198127162,
0.0035222818,
-0.0146892481,
0.0385472812,
-0.0185002163,
0.0398191698,
-0.0118621048,
0.0063877152,
-0.0343142636,
0.0367151089,
-0.0109873964,
0.0266382098,
-0.0237380285,
0.0373126753,
0.0496840477,
0.0081832213,
-0.0128308497,
0.0419305898,
0.0231962334,
0.0365449786,
0.0289484318,
0.0095849717,
-0.0119183864,
-0.0498351306,
-0.0592874698,
-0.0045555751,
-0.0319478922,
0.0286806133,
0.0214852169,
0.0225025304,
0.0152467079,
-0.0341975018,
-0.0163921509,
0.0305098481,
0.01146618,
0.0246652644,
0.0332990512,
-0.0327898972,
0.0164536573,
-0.0183851253,
-0.0305889472,
0.035438668,
0.0491136536,
0.0054288935,
-0.0272918865,
-0.0229421556,
0.0244737621,
-0.0513036139,
0.0355915688,
-0.00346431,
-0.0473642051,
0.0041376743,
0.0165875163,
0.0511684492,
0.0557674281,
-0.0171392579,
-0.0177031327,
0.0667375699,
0.005389892,
-0.0234707482,
-0.0365213491,
-0.0626435205,
-0.0309204236,
-0.0342894085,
-0.0329279229,
-0.0365897901,
0.0157195721,
0.0127012031,
-0.0160398036,
-0.0647153407,
-0.0456928499,
-0.0162657835,
0.0174734388,
0.0020444812,
0.0188096073,
-0.0260488037,
-0.0290977601,
-0.049213089,
-0.059430182,
0.0738240033,
-0.0284729023,
0.0277684387,
-0.0638676137,
-0.0196036194,
-0.0259572603,
0.0494246632,
0.014445818,
0.0151993241,
-0.0437287688,
-0.008358839,
-0.0496019125,
0.0150170699,
0.0390795656,
-0.0192946438,
0.0277969036,
-0.0458092168,
0.015187907,
-0.0089354236,
-0.0366564021,
-0.0219223332,
-0.026546333,
0.0198365059,
-0.0061591482,
-0.0054262062,
-0.0564996228,
0.0000875738,
0.0350654498,
-0.0112217097,
0.0347085893,
-0.0151618617,
0.0037157515,
-0.0276620332,
0.0502614714,
0.0304215271,
-0.0139893927,
-0.0317482278,
-0.0169806443,
-0.0326438621,
0.0053041307,
0.0192746464,
0.0141544351,
-0.0139942905,
-0.000276462,
0.0191257689,
0.042705074,
-0.0238422882,
-0.0413525403,
0.0235042889,
0.0491009802,
-0.021942772,
0.054881379,
0.0223783385,
-0.0628520697,
-0.0037956333,
0.009210268,
0.051606372,
0.0259732008,
-0.0252940618,
-0.0705437511,
-0.0069858045,
-0.0202754587,
0.0244439486,
0.0678515881,
0.0014202669,
-0.0283644069,
-0.083823517,
-0.0280223209,
0.0490289032,
-0.0453243405,
-0.075426966,
-0.0363065563,
0.0061512925,
-0.0032257731,
-0.0212410931,
-0.0495248027,
0.012600719,
-0.0062010675,
0.0082826335,
0.0220692623,
-0.0481257774,
-0.0234939493,
-0.0587639548,
-0.0340184383,
0.011013424,
0.0583656915,
0.023519773,
-0.0267096199,
-0.0093805296,
-0.0149948923,
-0.0764841437,
-0.014850664,
0.0466638952,
0.0181140807,
0.0032345396,
0.0204340238,
0.030086508,
-0.0619705059,
0.0237553511,
-0.0217114352,
0.0436508954,
0.0138696693,
-0.0344307981,
0.0168523416,
-0.0160093289,
0.0474927798,
0.0332000256,
0.0486385971,
0.0047188103,
-0.0472554043,
0.0226766504,
0.0289830249,
-0.0459594466,
0.0096733822,
0.0199552309,
-0.0765132606,
-0.0182504058,
-0.0809406191,
-0.0368026309,
-0.0118460692,
0.0353905112,
0.0077886884,
-0.009227993,
0.0019961384,
-0.071712099,
-0.0596049465,
0.0051761572,
-0.0075418199,
0.0210097507,
-0.008145798,
0.004968896,
0.014647874,
0.0304585248,
-0.0088614859,
0.0077949823,
-0.0970042795,
-0.0627539903,
-0.0084070479,
-0.0007500306,
0.0132942786,
0.0704486072,
-0.0412915498,
0.0374422446,
0.0448967367,
-0.0056298813,
0.0392838381,
-0.0049641379,
0.0466970317,
-0.0182862356,
0.0170856472,
0.0564472713,
-0.0250224713,
-0.0010885431,
0.0301642716,
0.0210800935,
-0.0136938682,
-0.0612833723,
-0.0138345808,
0.0007268203,
0.0312482975,
-0.0488159582,
-0.0087009631,
-0.0512917824,
-0.0092722876,
-0.0011465998,
0.005949439,
-0.0147408359,
-0.0257251263,
0.1075321138,
-0.016855184,
-0.0114225931,
0.0117585286,
0.0080174198,
0.0381042361,
0.0001606753,
-0.0076226294,
0.026209062,
0.0213263836,
0.0391840823,
0.0532043464,
-0.0442753136,
0.0181887764,
0.0258264299,
-0.0003342533,
-0.0399085544,
0.0036542749,
0.0181542262,
0.0093865264,
-0.0316555835,
0.0386515409,
-0.0218521822,
0.0173781402,
-0.0356129184,
0.0035344891,
0.063786298,
-0.0254882164,
0.1000517458,
-0.0256130975,
-0.0381363742,
-0.0203108732,
0.0260954052,
-0.0240807291,
-0.0155513352,
0.0316627435,
-0.0213833191,
-0.0037438502,
0.0345617309,
0.0702218264,
0.0038540014,
-0.0002944035,
-0.0087091923,
-0.0338778757,
-0.032352943,
-0.0229646936,
-0.0167544167,
0.0127674732,
-0.0073703341,
0.0252712462,
-0.0432214029,
-0.0884343982,
-0.006261908,
0.018286759,
-0.0181076005,
0.0512149446,
0.0267426372,
0.0422087684,
-0.0040786215,
0.0239886399,
-0.0449707732,
0.019554114,
0.0157359317,
-0.0594109334,
-0.0493075512,
-5.375638522e-33,
0.0045488891,
-0.0537580289,
-0.0296944026,
-0.0306437407,
-0.0377912186,
-0.0054384358,
-0.0161296297,
-0.0102626821,
-0.0457529426,
0.0235023163,
0.0241360441,
0.0230347309,
0.0319015719,
0.0195711236,
-0.0182847623,
0.0026723328,
0.0175129436,
0.0142250983,
-0.0265850164,
0.0188237056,
0.039377667,
0.0068933479,
0.0589844063,
-0.1000396833,
0.0134165669,
-0.0005918244,
0.0496855825,
0.0142886844,
0.0750704557,
0.0198514052,
-0.0213335156,
0.0612063073,
0.0089775585,
0.0364574343,
-0.00987083,
0.004661364,
-0.0860697702,
-0.0733760223,
0.0078350967,
0.0120277815,
-0.0229179841,
0.0096148541,
0.0389557444,
-0.0289859995,
0.0343262181,
-0.0666555986,
0.0107250428,
0.0232731514,
-0.0648682266,
0.0330880098,
-0.068179749,
0.0425419398,
0.0340774357,
0.0002765666,
0.058930885,
0.0046538115,
0.0240492914,
-0.0220718477,
-0.0385117568,
0.0238219276,
-0.0755271167,
0.0248550531,
0.0520189367,
0.0213077217,
0.0146466549,
0.0281768925,
0.0335364565,
-0.0376547351,
0.053114783,
-0.02469901,
0.0338689685,
0.0182599742,
0.0050968919,
0.0531188734,
0.0150497016,
-0.0316984765,
-0.0415416621,
-0.0022254721,
-0.0109603051,
-0.0319956541,
-0.0092763184,
0.0216219127,
-0.024000749,
-0.037098404,
-0.0248527881,
-0.0425887927,
-0.0039497041,
-0.047453478,
0.015001853,
-0.0249593239,
-0.0106438305,
0.0161253531,
0.0268790331,
-0.0216642059,
-0.0230727568,
0.0833690688,
-0.0037861424,
0.0291747022,
-0.0085905651,
0.0551346727,
-0.0170826185,
-0.0632159486,
-0.0228684563,
0.0314321853,
0.0158795789,
0.0096671591,
0.0320180617,
0.0034891579,
-0.0414855964,
0.0014372352,
-0.059674155,
-0.0850821361,
-0.0370475017,
0.0474638529,
0.0222577546,
0.0289140549,
0.0233331397,
0.0322543606,
0.0825708359,
0.026706757,
0.0210008379,
0.006101917,
0.0295789707,
0.0582233034,
-0.0356782787,
0.0244004726,
-0.0307383575,
0.0290140696,
0.0360311754,
-0.0454192534,
-0.0155214677,
-0.0104853371,
2.493e-7,
0.0906955823,
0.0011864681,
0.0468352512,
0.0119754784,
-0.0172606371,
-0.0105862133,
-0.0217841249,
0.0509120151,
-0.0207892749,
0.0280383769,
0.0382515043,
0.0193862058,
0.0342774689,
0.0408381261,
-0.0513255373,
0.0311779324,
-0.0382270701,
0.0039628535,
-0.0259424839,
0.0416140333,
0.044939857,
0.0870841071,
0.0293432698,
0.0099055069,
-0.0623455457,
-0.0527664237,
0.0576095022,
-0.0017996505,
0.0293684248,
0.0025926963,
-0.0259306245,
0.0008629494,
-0.0179910567,
-0.0016917529,
-0.0457533747,
0.0199254267,
0.0622292012,
0.0181356501,
-0.0227202792,
-0.0097815748,
-0.0347894765,
-0.0520877205,
0.0005891682,
-0.0723536685,
0.0239329841,
-0.0532790907,
-0.0098397965,
0.0028103893,
-0.000763759,
0.0553982854,
0.0492494553,
-0.0208763294,
-0.0490777232,
0.0198003538,
0.0652124882,
0.0126741175,
-0.0051888423,
-0.0463120788,
-0.0408150442,
0.0458807908,
-0.0172251668,
-0.0167718343,
0.0067720837,
-0.0042794887,
0.0154278791,
0.0232386608,
0.0150289116,
2.209651348e-34,
-0.0082266619,
0.0193401929,
0.0058787283,
-0.0226866901,
0.021302538,
-0.0605923645,
-0.019987151,
0.0195228159,
-0.0052430476,
-0.0416117199,
-0.0176274534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12352v1 | knn-seq: Efficient, Extensible kNN-MT Framework | 2023-10-18T21:56:04 | 2023-10-18T21:56:04 | Hiroyuki Deguchi, Hayate Hirano, Tomoki Hoshino, Yuto Nishida, Justin Vasselli, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL | k-nearest-neighbor machine translation (kNN-MT) boosts the translation
quality of a pre-trained neural machine translation (NMT) model by utilizing
translation examples during decoding. Translation examples are stored in a
vector database, called a datastore, which contains one entry for each target
token from the parallel data it is made from. Due to its size, it is
computationally expensive both to construct and to retrieve examples from the
datastore. In this paper, we present an efficient and extensible kNN-MT
framework, knn-seq, for researchers and developers that is carefully designed
to run efficiently, even with a billion-scale large datastore. knn-seq is
developed as a plug-in on fairseq and easy to switch models and kNN indexes.
Experimental results show that our implemented kNN-MT achieves a comparable
gain to the original kNN-MT, and the billion-scale datastore construction took
2.21 hours in the WMT'19 German-to-English translation task. We publish our
knn-seq as an MIT-licensed open-source project and the code is available on
https://github.com/naist-nlp/knn-seq . The demo video is available on
https://youtu.be/zTDzEOq80m0 . | [
0.0162426848,
0.0788122341,
0.0109807737,
0.0337563828,
-0.0243720151,
0.0295687485,
0.0356777459,
0.0016096651,
-0.0204877872,
-0.0007665073,
-0.0416138247,
0.0250863433,
-0.0199028775,
0.0091621727,
0.0374527797,
-0.0138317095,
0.0346808881,
0.00068639,
-0.0278950576,
-0.0077128117,
-0.0079618283,
0.043327149,
-0.0098421331,
0.0480243899,
-0.0071695042,
-0.0085922405,
0.0041099498,
0.0505999438,
0.014941887,
-0.0310731977,
0.0039077466,
0.0296831187,
0.0085789859,
0.093607761,
0.0000023083,
-0.0117693031,
-0.0308885388,
0.0162176508,
-0.0072558043,
0.035846021,
0.0394558124,
-0.059366066,
-0.0177447405,
0.0339958854,
-0.0086622853,
-0.079821296,
0.0734888017,
0.0074877967,
0.07267005,
0.0878202468,
-0.0161872897,
-0.040431831,
-0.0057222936,
-0.0309802573,
-0.0213769954,
-0.0583522804,
-0.009322824,
-0.0036896628,
-0.0691344962,
0.0243504532,
0.0100546265,
0.070562616,
0.0358495228,
-0.0019851965,
-0.0112640262,
0.0115934443,
-0.0040988317,
-0.0253185239,
-0.026331,
0.0898717642,
-0.0641892031,
-0.0212816447,
-0.0025077101,
-0.0103575606,
-0.0321229324,
-0.0322415195,
-0.0135460226,
0.0021868162,
0.029125303,
-0.0120435907,
0.002588002,
0.0563644059,
0.0501394272,
0.0111643532,
-0.048082225,
-0.0284974966,
0.0490282997,
-0.0172853414,
-0.0057678353,
0.0085263671,
0.0013692682,
0.0000582834,
0.0805335864,
-0.0118777044,
0.0027035917,
0.0095981406,
-0.0208560564,
-0.0726598129,
0.0003473603,
-0.0737642869,
0.0439724289,
0.0700891167,
-0.0168842822,
0.0598031208,
-0.0318572074,
0.0466128923,
-0.0267864838,
-0.0010983847,
-0.0542479381,
-0.0205873195,
-0.0400046594,
0.0224167891,
-0.060038127,
-0.0142303063,
-0.0572666302,
-0.0377228335,
0.0215589665,
0.0255599916,
0.0452192537,
-0.0056265583,
0.0198765211,
-0.0021555454,
-0.0525160506,
-0.0103452979,
0.0173058249,
0.0484128147,
-0.0529296733,
-0.0412945971,
-0.0133247087,
-0.03897034,
-0.0497878492,
0.0111999214,
-0.005747193,
-0.0525808595,
0.0307459291,
0.0308004506,
-0.0107518267,
-0.0238552373,
0.0081744809,
-0.0007731934,
0.0158211235,
-0.0234439168,
-0.0358152203,
-0.0566507131,
0.096414037,
0.0108017242,
0.0070904787,
-0.0460116565,
-0.0205366313,
-0.0004566881,
-0.0310299378,
0.0335401185,
-0.0445126928,
-0.0066432771,
0.0166062247,
0.0142332846,
-0.0063818833,
0.0433104523,
0.0134987002,
0.0209177509,
0.0088569438,
-0.0098511381,
-0.0213479679,
0.0503732562,
0.0264633223,
0.0109354286,
-0.0386489257,
0.0243705083,
-0.0012151167,
0.0557955801,
0.0173275452,
0.0463010482,
-0.0431974828,
0.0088440655,
0.0341647677,
0.0408286117,
0.0261718873,
0.0670735464,
0.0217204448,
0.0320378542,
-0.0118306605,
-0.0855326205,
-0.0362559929,
0.0476933494,
0.0133836931,
-0.0028752475,
0.0438385606,
0.0632369071,
-0.0212574936,
-0.0030034629,
0.0293816365,
-0.020271562,
-0.0076585952,
-0.0124307051,
0.0172122084,
0.0246989224,
-0.062608324,
0.0591461137,
-0.0247049276,
-0.055940941,
0.0187574308,
-0.0090079689,
-0.0278725028,
0.0663432926,
0.0542752929,
0.000054251,
-0.0637284741,
0.0015905775,
-0.0250863861,
0.0453408509,
0.0582677647,
0.0084721046,
0.0589770786,
-0.0667423233,
-0.0103717884,
0.0130061964,
0.0091846632,
0.0186629836,
0.0337791704,
0.0552069321,
0.058542233,
-0.0361603498,
-0.041831173,
0.0334180854,
0.000750512,
-0.0303722452,
0.0369738564,
0.010619808,
0.0031204752,
0.0400195345,
-0.0349963866,
-0.0036983492,
0.0251993332,
-0.023065228,
-0.0023713517,
0.0266988799,
-0.0516069196,
-0.0707255155,
-0.0039802589,
0.0120134512,
0.016355196,
0.0353574045,
-0.0752481073,
-0.041744031,
-0.0088683879,
-0.0167127717,
0.0290460307,
-0.0474118739,
-0.0020720554,
-0.0028287219,
-0.0024523058,
-0.0097699268,
-0.006587863,
0.0078061549,
-0.0077249142,
-0.0149081945,
-0.0060490048,
0.0059859096,
-0.0089852102,
-0.0235682353,
0.0296860635,
-0.0003691754,
0.0556178205,
0.0275515225,
0.025671443,
-0.0321717821,
-0.0083193975,
-0.0753157064,
0.0373666659,
-0.0299212933,
0.0334521942,
0.0410317294,
0.0888645947,
0.002670788,
-0.0326149762,
-0.0097954581,
0.0102942567,
-0.0025416312,
0.0162060689,
0.0020156878,
-0.0015773737,
0.0103957839,
-0.008159562,
-0.0328381546,
0.0239378344,
0.0490654744,
-0.0273027569,
-0.0147508951,
-0.0454977229,
0.0234772582,
-0.0346440673,
-0.0029139083,
0.0181274079,
-0.0462481827,
-0.0246756319,
-0.0487085357,
0.0256070755,
0.0275790039,
-0.0201276857,
-0.0413875282,
-0.0018553062,
-0.010794634,
-0.0953238457,
0.002564789,
-0.0265756454,
-0.0182312168,
-0.0150277494,
-0.0072869416,
0.028004799,
0.0279914569,
-0.0183843747,
-0.0090881875,
-0.07815741,
0.0140328929,
0.0046076714,
-0.0123820333,
-0.0370314941,
0.0563279279,
0.0305885486,
-0.0083913729,
-0.0018390821,
-0.0267787501,
0.0665223524,
-0.0321123935,
-0.0095561929,
-0.0642749369,
-0.0116078975,
-0.0247211568,
0.044155784,
-0.0373847112,
0.0289323144,
-0.0758996308,
-0.0327018872,
0.0070178364,
0.0255027916,
-0.0467016995,
0.0021809633,
-0.0226736572,
-0.017960161,
-0.0121317413,
-0.0128680561,
-0.0205148552,
-0.0026276405,
0.0080217151,
-0.0292761307,
-0.0401279442,
0.0221852381,
-0.0087801171,
-0.013891249,
0.0165132899,
-0.0165284947,
0.1029938087,
-0.0156691317,
0.0127663137,
-0.0120124612,
0.0028327722,
-0.0174522996,
-0.01784846,
0.0401466191,
-0.0170646477,
0.0241662022,
0.0510875657,
0.0236714836,
-0.0309779495,
-0.0477962419,
-0.0299396068,
0.0300970003,
-0.0059186607,
-0.0012575318,
-0.0095176483,
0.0257649776,
-0.0535484441,
-0.0007566839,
0.1172530502,
0.0269538183,
-0.0541217402,
-0.0126599278,
0.0178093649,
0.0260272902,
0.0080017028,
0.0572981164,
-0.0787560791,
-0.0376282372,
0.0092588067,
0.0602057464,
0.0437917821,
0.0083261244,
-0.012891761,
-0.0561629608,
0.0131425587,
0.0602979958,
-0.0691249445,
-0.0480898172,
-0.0082384367,
-0.0659498796,
-0.0535993613,
0.0147815421,
0.0264544915,
0.0521164946,
0.0221340153,
-0.0088473763,
0.0359013565,
-0.0402859896,
0.0054872953,
-0.078432411,
0.0505951941,
0.0414982028,
0.0210329592,
0.0169419572,
-0.0069367192,
-0.0077848476,
-0.0077320016,
0.0134932669,
-0.0301944558,
-0.0024520583,
-0.0283055324,
-0.0388114862,
0.0017708277,
-0.0157707892,
-0.0624417588,
0.0132296281,
0.0280233081,
0.0726797134,
-0.0073828576,
-0.006856597,
0.0008819684,
-0.0492016599,
-0.0004963806,
0.0544100516,
0.0121540325,
-0.0161667541,
-0.0093115419,
-0.0047473656,
-0.0156973321,
-0.0639518946,
0.0101787681,
-0.0129276691,
-0.0298535042,
-0.0237751175,
-0.0740559921,
-0.0314454772,
0.0221868679,
0.0471672229,
0.0054742787,
-0.010673427,
0.0021127872,
-0.0005132721,
-0.0722003728,
0.0448799096,
-0.0314151235,
-0.0050477646,
-0.0389952138,
0.0262225773,
0.0560099185,
-0.0030478686,
-0.0069146701,
0.0126071721,
-0.0681523904,
-0.0531737171,
-0.0111069614,
0.0764145181,
0.0100647202,
0.0489880517,
-0.0468561389,
-0.0415215641,
0.0440194756,
0.0377233364,
-0.1131093204,
-0.0285301059,
0.0286653228,
-0.0507904142,
-0.0146100214,
0.0223651007,
-0.0217926614,
0.0107035488,
-0.0182531476,
0.0474155359,
0.0121200886,
-0.0192092489,
-0.0075175255,
0.0161502138,
0.0422087535,
0.0005349907,
-0.0139556881,
-0.0264155474,
0.0286860857,
0.0309570171,
0.0004140208,
-0.0604882389,
0.0109388996,
0.0511348508,
0.0110092117,
-0.0186180621,
0.0211473927,
0.0353943184,
-0.0362393856,
0.015263428,
-0.0212202724,
-0.021940371,
0.0368322544,
0.0522572547,
0.0005945906,
-0.0365761295,
0.0125048282,
-0.0069939722,
-0.0024674679,
-0.075586386,
0.0193719026,
0.0206711628,
0.0058793747,
0.0104688508,
0.0527921058,
-0.0228104424,
-0.0502331778,
-0.0466441475,
-0.0066877226,
0.0777079687,
0.0169921741,
0.0947128981,
-0.0130420746,
-0.0035327841,
-0.0300897434,
0.0206385572,
0.0222515427,
-0.0107084317,
-0.0109960241,
-0.0052539837,
0.0032894439,
0.0135867856,
0.0274626203,
-0.0137174334,
0.0221657511,
0.031695053,
-0.0047875056,
-0.0183400009,
-0.0002037792,
0.0173933301,
-0.0083754994,
-0.0429119132,
-0.0275048446,
0.0240939036,
-0.0544359721,
0.0272593256,
0.0047737625,
-0.0365568437,
0.0001029317,
0.0247248113,
0.0620083399,
-0.013820773,
-0.0030275302,
-0.0153858624,
0.0401810668,
-0.016261477,
-0.0689283684,
0.002273465,
-6.579497552e-33,
0.0217292458,
0.0160639696,
0.0099988561,
-0.0500563495,
-0.0362688079,
-0.0193727687,
-0.0414133742,
-0.0460132249,
0.0212012473,
-0.00667832,
0.0062227868,
0.0337665752,
0.0314276293,
0.0115409121,
0.0047567817,
-0.0018729008,
0.0734208599,
0.001826177,
-0.0099532139,
0.0584301129,
-0.0006765437,
0.0562688001,
0.0875431374,
-0.0576477535,
-0.0090152491,
-0.0048371325,
0.0174463373,
-0.0061388151,
0.018595174,
-0.000498852,
0.0060051158,
0.007520956,
-0.0062648081,
-0.059073735,
-0.0222890507,
-0.0549624227,
-0.0855525732,
0.0048212418,
-0.0021960097,
0.0726712793,
-0.01424901,
-0.0382576473,
0.0243860148,
-0.0472606085,
-0.0124375224,
0.0159011837,
-0.0330671594,
-0.023227891,
-0.0303679686,
-0.0243452415,
-0.0186888315,
0.0187828299,
-0.0237304904,
0.0125359185,
0.0564467348,
0.0126162544,
-0.0084171435,
-0.0152164968,
-0.1106720641,
-0.005921226,
-0.0487673394,
0.0387756377,
0.0684180185,
0.006394499,
0.0197181925,
-0.013922018,
0.0813981518,
-0.0517385192,
0.019504305,
0.0624623075,
0.033788804,
-0.000611347,
0.0875296593,
0.0268045701,
0.0566267706,
-0.0463662744,
-0.0372449383,
0.0195942707,
-0.0157291684,
-0.0145643475,
0.025646219,
0.0125720957,
-0.0038865532,
-0.0084831063,
-0.0368999653,
-0.0512508638,
-0.0497460552,
-0.0353771932,
0.0418798365,
0.0355697349,
-0.0454389229,
0.0054397066,
0.0697344244,
-0.0212384798,
0.0296329651,
0.0144210672,
-0.0194272548,
-0.0090846252,
-0.0329079218,
0.0449793003,
-0.0178199001,
-0.0507208444,
0.0157545302,
-0.0187247973,
0.0201430246,
-0.0242924858,
0.0190676041,
0.0193562042,
-0.0392507575,
0.0044886274,
-0.0252446476,
-0.0006683368,
-0.0012398213,
-0.0038076285,
-0.0080627613,
-0.0095451903,
0.0231365133,
0.0316521749,
0.0514815748,
0.0107763717,
-0.0175881237,
-0.0050683212,
0.0578896366,
0.0112131219,
-0.0387836285,
-0.0042333389,
-0.0544242896,
-0.0409765877,
0.0188433565,
-0.0591840036,
-0.0313292257,
0.0235115401,
2.966e-7,
0.0441787355,
0.0742462426,
0.0109157125,
-0.007841385,
-0.0026673463,
0.0088386508,
-0.014593225,
0.0531111695,
0.009022289,
0.079038009,
0.0241336897,
0.0130412886,
0.0615973994,
0.0185347144,
-0.1058433726,
-0.017728867,
-0.0622656606,
0.043745745,
-0.0834548697,
-0.0008930284,
0.0201553367,
0.1210115328,
-0.0025776275,
0.0102924183,
0.0247301795,
-0.0321861692,
0.0429696217,
-0.013221438,
-0.0067589665,
-0.0012003011,
0.0389185771,
0.0212796144,
-0.0287573319,
-0.0279620234,
-0.0073244888,
0.0074204174,
0.0300421938,
0.0957722515,
0.00291992,
-0.0177923702,
0.0116911326,
-0.0259998925,
0.0157801285,
-0.0433205739,
0.0698164478,
-0.0415194556,
0.010105486,
0.0379318185,
-0.0175104905,
0.0062844567,
0.0386801958,
-0.0278984755,
-0.0062476131,
0.0202669203,
0.0708784834,
-0.0076819877,
-0.0221214369,
-0.0644079223,
-0.047377158,
-0.0367459245,
0.0024936676,
-0.0171439387,
-0.0649565309,
0.0064682313,
-0.0004696778,
0.0256181974,
0.0010494732,
2.837422958e-34,
0.0283042137,
0.0022141268,
0.0363894887,
-0.0057613826,
0.0299329832,
-0.0327621326,
0.0154120782,
0.0075765811,
-0.028027609,
-0.0633750036,
-0.0447891653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12344v1 | LACMA: Language-Aligning Contrastive Learning with Meta-Actions for Embodied Instruction Following | 2023-10-18T21:43:07 | 2023-10-18T21:43:07 | Cheng-Fu Yang, Yen-Chun Chen, Jianwei Yang, Xiyang Dai, Lu Yuan, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | End-to-end Transformers have demonstrated an impressive success rate for
Embodied Instruction Following when the environment has been seen in training.
However, they tend to struggle when deployed in an unseen environment. This
lack of generalizability is due to the agent's insensitivity to subtle changes
in natural language instructions. To mitigate this issue, we propose explicitly
aligning the agent's hidden states with the instructions via contrastive
learning. Nevertheless, the semantic gap between high-level language
instructions and the agent's low-level action space remains an obstacle.
Therefore, we further introduce a novel concept of meta-actions to bridge the
gap. Meta-actions are ubiquitous action patterns that can be parsed from the
original action sequence. These patterns represent higher-level semantics that
are intuitively aligned closer to the instructions. When meta-actions are
applied as additional training signals, the agent generalizes better to unseen
environments. Compared to a strong multi-modal Transformer baseline, we achieve
a significant 4.5% absolute gain in success rate in unseen environments of
ALFRED Embodied Instruction Following. Additional analysis shows that the
contrastive objective and meta-actions are complementary in achieving the best
results, and the resulting agent better aligns its states with corresponding
instructions, making it more suitable for real-world embodied agents. The code
is available at: https://github.com/joeyy5588/LACMA. | [
0.0035674309,
0.0188045073,
-0.0213296451,
-0.0082681309,
-0.004009563,
0.0300059803,
-0.0161049496,
-0.0318082161,
-0.0464467034,
-0.0437170193,
-0.0635372028,
0.0068349694,
-0.0082303798,
0.009230488,
0.0361451358,
-0.0889505148,
0.0455196686,
0.0085283937,
-0.0362852439,
0.0001889139,
0.0041375495,
-0.0126469973,
-0.047939565,
0.0350457504,
0.0032964405,
0.0142942555,
-0.0757583603,
-0.0192980338,
0.0701578036,
-0.0500494502,
0.0056905202,
-0.0115847066,
0.0498965308,
0.0221614502,
0.0000019707,
-0.0306257959,
0.0276759733,
-0.02013967,
0.0266872197,
-0.0779239163,
0.0123488549,
-0.0393046699,
-0.0158833787,
-0.0027216654,
-0.0470801555,
-0.0242743008,
0.0705353469,
0.0484236814,
0.0531455465,
0.0775010958,
-0.0089602144,
-0.0175526589,
0.0003905761,
0.0245917626,
-0.0128806066,
0.028897373,
0.0020910888,
-0.0364458747,
0.0516746603,
0.0135561414,
-0.0791792646,
-0.0054022945,
0.0344382562,
0.0142282331,
-0.0359669179,
0.059534438,
0.0208988301,
-0.0057822214,
-0.0365673713,
0.0568634421,
0.0099183684,
0.0083645247,
-0.0171382111,
-0.005842722,
0.0244567841,
0.0007928004,
0.0120680751,
0.0314935781,
0.0209452175,
0.0322651714,
-0.0002017098,
0.0135591244,
-0.0215665419,
-0.007240097,
-0.0350376181,
0.025837671,
-0.0159581397,
-0.0280582104,
0.0113848541,
-0.0188071895,
-0.0246810261,
-0.0281043742,
0.0096375868,
0.0604150183,
-0.031260021,
0.0194548927,
-0.0522054546,
-0.0321369544,
-0.0233147051,
-0.0241446123,
0.0538675189,
0.0737176314,
-0.037966501,
-0.0071639409,
-0.0253285524,
0.0864531323,
-0.015168068,
0.0421531461,
-0.0093097435,
0.0480872206,
-0.0411937796,
0.0097442726,
-0.0355159491,
0.0232256614,
-0.074865967,
-0.0242112242,
-0.0212377403,
0.0109140715,
-0.0461466797,
0.0140388394,
-0.0068478161,
0.0124561014,
-0.0453009531,
0.0122708445,
-0.0222053621,
-0.0035653827,
-0.0138577605,
0.0697347596,
-0.0051632891,
-0.0095169274,
-0.0275836326,
0.0019526954,
-0.0020414842,
-0.0027435415,
-0.0007774272,
0.1060273647,
-0.0013667004,
-0.0390711017,
-0.0077750627,
0.0491179451,
0.0210116152,
-0.0368577689,
0.0422395207,
-0.006229145,
-0.0005363632,
-0.0304553378,
-0.0014643176,
-0.0193095487,
-0.0021846925,
-0.0313320532,
0.0525128394,
0.0548348837,
0.0184688289,
0.0017729696,
-0.0127564315,
-0.0043248604,
-0.0415858254,
0.0514597632,
0.0474567637,
-0.0260829665,
-0.0610151961,
-0.0019918964,
0.0151684247,
0.0266474914,
0.0219630692,
0.0059361192,
0.0211638119,
-0.0375916511,
-0.0010106027,
0.0321955644,
0.0483343787,
0.0284638777,
-0.0374785326,
0.0023033752,
0.0347579904,
0.0138033982,
-0.0278367233,
-0.0291369408,
0.0619191304,
0.0137355244,
-0.0244458616,
0.0068548927,
-0.0652369112,
0.0742386505,
0.0113646546,
0.0023065344,
-0.0365633219,
0.0265933089,
-0.0389030129,
-0.0243117269,
0.0368037932,
0.0041855765,
0.023114901,
-0.0236491654,
0.0254446436,
0.0574264526,
-0.0862692297,
0.00289585,
0.012635354,
-0.0340459235,
0.0154854776,
-0.0428219661,
-0.0195768718,
0.0428118668,
-0.0353857279,
-0.0105229774,
-0.0274591036,
-0.0154143497,
0.0191913135,
0.0907377228,
-0.0721569061,
0.0023009258,
0.0425055884,
-0.0266024396,
-0.05096725,
-0.0362294279,
0.0044981241,
0.0227675755,
-0.0145801902,
0.0156116085,
-0.0508444495,
0.0523753576,
0.0167243257,
0.06796965,
-0.0442531109,
-0.0150875989,
-0.023215821,
0.0156256948,
0.0393477343,
-0.0187242627,
-0.0068593663,
-0.0331412442,
0.0192647465,
-0.0271648858,
-0.0008757264,
0.0557564683,
-0.0363433808,
-0.0560853966,
0.0114327781,
-0.0514945611,
-0.0267112143,
0.0799614191,
-0.0228525605,
-0.0349288546,
0.0375396423,
-0.0478816889,
0.0877261609,
0.0338573866,
0.0059910282,
0.034369953,
-0.027063312,
0.0118836695,
-0.004594557,
-0.043912109,
-0.0183398835,
0.0360926948,
0.0158592984,
-0.0185858831,
-0.0228976794,
0.0122847501,
0.0019247013,
-0.0053918399,
0.0289351344,
0.0116646169,
0.0211188011,
-0.0383439586,
-0.0324563719,
-0.0293286201,
-0.020605145,
-0.0095267314,
0.0095862746,
0.0451437533,
-0.0259269886,
-0.0125585906,
-0.0101964511,
-0.0107536931,
0.0297744628,
-0.0155469328,
-0.0039097928,
0.0290217195,
0.0420166627,
-0.0379354656,
-0.0205591414,
0.0261628032,
0.0149023067,
0.0158694629,
-0.0306535326,
0.0497600324,
-0.059268754,
0.0366118811,
0.0137897087,
0.044893872,
-0.0435312688,
-0.0719495192,
0.0490914695,
-0.0077743381,
0.0084962407,
0.0392231867,
0.040471483,
0.0340306647,
0.0547538325,
0.0082930988,
-0.0820581019,
0.0290357284,
-0.0372421965,
0.0034237357,
-0.0638971478,
-0.0002002182,
-0.0026178739,
0.0703295544,
0.0136455223,
0.0275114328,
-0.1101770923,
-0.0287467148,
-0.0009014293,
-0.0605982132,
0.0117568765,
0.0099779461,
-0.0570974536,
-0.0402299277,
-0.0620382056,
-0.0357037745,
0.048634816,
0.0288498122,
-0.0412272252,
-0.0016226158,
0.028036695,
0.0440357924,
0.0352101438,
0.0024269822,
0.0274772346,
-0.0112518035,
-0.0342264548,
-0.0730838925,
-0.0418716855,
0.0067276713,
0.0174778309,
0.0131782675,
-0.0361833163,
0.0012726533,
-0.0084653683,
-0.0286925025,
-0.0418758653,
0.0307458378,
-0.0199356023,
0.0064385561,
-0.0337027796,
-0.0390426442,
-0.0546921939,
-0.0134533281,
0.0361363553,
0.0319179557,
0.001951387,
-0.0259314366,
-0.0315795876,
-0.0407172255,
0.0415544473,
0.0342187136,
-0.0115828477,
-0.03381899,
0.0325858407,
0.0467509888,
0.0397813655,
-0.0451830178,
-0.098789379,
0.0258199759,
0.0354915261,
-0.0131016141,
0.0211426076,
0.0367259495,
0.0565319508,
-0.0183663666,
-0.0070537552,
0.0496468768,
-0.0024073101,
0.0012951813,
0.0259887055,
-0.0033976617,
0.0140216947,
0.0185752027,
-0.00247941,
-0.0128313741,
-0.0350773074,
-0.0296126697,
0.0248647686,
0.0230340306,
0.0233958438,
0.0114568686,
-0.0761827752,
0.0330999754,
0.0232452732,
-0.0814625397,
-0.0363835171,
-0.0033172199,
0.0571886264,
-0.0232974887,
0.0041788551,
0.0154290888,
-0.0087686433,
-0.0087439008,
0.0375324823,
0.0443095788,
-0.0251355227,
-0.0185096283,
-0.0324471444,
0.0334011614,
0.039645426,
0.0265004076,
-0.0148775112,
-0.0489511192,
-0.0008949048,
-0.0118875876,
0.025148103,
0.0013355226,
0.0214624889,
-0.038633924,
-0.012751976,
-0.0099352291,
0.050409805,
-0.021922024,
-0.0290519688,
-0.0171675049,
0.0554552302,
-0.0478955247,
0.0234195665,
-0.0245378334,
0.0296114013,
0.0265163314,
0.0153888278,
-0.0103802504,
-0.0437907875,
-0.0032635937,
-0.022171272,
-0.0307982713,
-0.0215189047,
-0.0365283266,
-0.0045689424,
-0.0283926483,
-0.0100288577,
-0.0624023341,
-0.0511458106,
0.0435821973,
0.0662721768,
0.0224031545,
-0.0438932702,
-0.0057877782,
0.0134957936,
-0.0384697169,
0.0156731028,
-0.0055652033,
0.013652225,
-0.0091288146,
-0.0557262711,
0.0622715242,
-0.0541569516,
-0.000453539,
-0.0244122762,
-0.0063369116,
-0.0630862564,
0.0353419036,
0.0861373395,
0.0153910955,
0.0813827887,
0.0473003797,
0.0430037938,
0.0668145716,
0.0205041002,
-0.0162458159,
0.0464737378,
0.0821729898,
0.0050835111,
-0.008720208,
-0.0073252209,
-0.0522449203,
0.0092986338,
0.0026311113,
0.0291819144,
-0.0283650216,
0.0231648628,
0.0580088533,
-0.051790528,
0.052916903,
-0.0523740761,
0.0207058899,
-0.038890183,
-0.0126562677,
-0.0083244015,
0.0154229449,
-0.0525300279,
0.0058415923,
0.010111656,
0.0582089052,
0.0304532982,
0.0317382328,
0.0060283039,
-0.0289274901,
0.0113881351,
0.0571295843,
0.0256096944,
0.073489137,
-0.0205578301,
0.0546980835,
0.0203681104,
-0.0042723157,
0.0096778404,
0.0384426191,
0.0171066169,
0.0857146606,
0.0498483516,
-0.0039787036,
-0.0258242637,
0.0457742363,
-0.0579788983,
0.0259703342,
-0.0091710025,
-0.0368222781,
0.0094551761,
0.0092912642,
0.008858392,
-0.0540298447,
0.022930352,
0.0328826755,
0.0649821609,
-0.0262807515,
-0.0382454619,
0.0427255854,
0.0153699964,
0.0399345979,
-0.0027931326,
0.0176407192,
-0.0608464032,
0.0918573737,
-0.0129277231,
0.0691847354,
-0.043434307,
-0.0447071865,
0.0191057008,
-0.0032249491,
0.0049721515,
0.0005609498,
-0.0264622755,
-0.02636596,
-0.0235092025,
0.0263888799,
-0.0320842452,
-0.0506483763,
0.0735105872,
-0.0348896682,
0.0107577182,
-0.0476010665,
-0.0207342133,
-0.0467888825,
0.0132245896,
0.0102904951,
-0.0315107778,
-5.163798644e-33,
-0.050259646,
-0.0067433929,
0.0547292382,
-0.0057561509,
-0.0451502167,
-0.0214029755,
-0.0611432791,
-0.0079528522,
-0.019030923,
0.0303235054,
0.0394191965,
0.0023752602,
-0.0032292919,
-0.0054547731,
0.0283775721,
0.0114843119,
0.0049373591,
-0.0267891791,
-0.0314683989,
-0.0011988271,
0.0339837037,
-0.0119251646,
0.0406145863,
-0.0430606417,
-0.0113459285,
0.0187262874,
-0.0440855734,
0.0201930366,
-0.0314985476,
0.041632168,
-0.0124431439,
-0.0260586794,
-0.0121842064,
-0.0018648113,
-0.0303824358,
-0.0122315371,
-0.0426310338,
-0.038365677,
-0.0096145729,
0.0259176772,
-0.1040829495,
-0.0297333971,
0.0151020922,
-0.0135187497,
-0.0518236384,
0.010293765,
0.0260414071,
-0.0240088552,
0.0315919742,
0.0412133709,
-0.0557277054,
-0.0110510504,
-0.029767558,
-0.0435642153,
0.0061607393,
0.0810268521,
0.007561449,
-0.0269623138,
-0.0177297313,
0.0403426327,
0.001623237,
-0.0202076305,
0.0553726926,
0.0720850751,
0.0419210717,
0.0605642609,
0.02785304,
-0.0118684899,
0.0137006557,
0.0244889576,
0.033126127,
0.0365777612,
-0.0007593729,
0.053128995,
0.0011228817,
0.0271651316,
0.0183363892,
0.0586217977,
-0.0439603999,
0.0624635704,
-0.0126217362,
0.0389824174,
-0.0412552059,
0.0225832742,
-0.0073042135,
0.0073248958,
0.0285366364,
-0.0405055992,
0.0178096667,
0.0333647169,
-0.0027992043,
-0.0469617285,
0.0478082597,
-0.0125435097,
0.0275670588,
0.0046055424,
-0.0424810685,
0.0297854505,
-0.0031784174,
-0.0275900662,
-0.0503856055,
-0.066503711,
0.0701620802,
0.0192034263,
0.0146942381,
0.0330289155,
0.0059695998,
0.0971297771,
-0.0466320999,
-0.0070354193,
-0.0056510461,
0.0149376206,
0.0303321015,
-0.0561947078,
0.0351817496,
-0.010026522,
-0.0331836641,
0.0239375737,
-0.0106503442,
-0.0782070905,
-0.0225078464,
0.0335085653,
-0.0321073756,
0.0483040102,
-0.0344720148,
0.0032046048,
-0.0672203451,
0.0459300503,
0.0049201916,
-0.0756611526,
-0.0053261747,
0.0409759246,
2.843e-7,
-0.0112206535,
-0.0412718393,
0.0321120284,
0.0099407109,
0.0204394013,
0.0392438322,
-0.0591252185,
0.0381698757,
-0.0130469687,
-0.0262733884,
0.0244118199,
0.0381916277,
0.010392244,
-0.0311617572,
-0.0292408559,
-0.0043310574,
0.0034402718,
-0.0371177867,
-0.0167070813,
0.0233690143,
0.0358711667,
0.0732130408,
0.0110346451,
0.0306409057,
0.0246302895,
0.0220685974,
0.0485944413,
-0.0187561605,
0.0549673401,
-0.0553574041,
-0.0857285708,
-0.0085317837,
-0.0287697818,
-0.0232212115,
-0.0079298913,
0.0303351656,
-0.0479941554,
0.0598814115,
-0.0374093689,
-0.0131897479,
0.0084114978,
0.0608743504,
-0.0296374932,
0.0274368953,
-0.0057652951,
-0.0929699838,
-0.0281730667,
-0.0106880497,
-0.0519509055,
0.0041069379,
-0.0400329456,
-0.0074551902,
-0.0154752778,
-0.0129691623,
-0.0367375612,
0.0091275759,
-0.025046926,
-0.0680934861,
0.0069057536,
-0.0105209714,
-0.0234436039,
-0.030751599,
0.0000209747,
0.0239280518,
0.0209098011,
-0.0293282066,
-0.0426034741,
1.791471987e-34,
-0.0401973166,
-0.0348312706,
0.027797183,
0.0313067436,
-0.0235389955,
-0.0057772882,
-0.0393873826,
0.005525758,
0.0877702609,
-0.0161114614,
-0.0321118906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12342v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12342v2 | Eliminating Reasoning via Inferring with Planning: A New Framework to Guide LLMs' Non-linear Thinking | 2023-10-18T21:42:16 | 2023-11-15T00:59:54 | Yongqi Tong, Yifan Wang, Dawei Li, Sizhe Wang, Zi Lin, Simeng Han, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought(CoT) prompting and its variants explore equipping large
language models (LLMs) with high-level reasoning abilities by emulating
human-like linear cognition and logic. However, the human mind is complicated
and mixed with both linear and nonlinear thinking. In this work, we propose
\textbf{I}nferential \textbf{E}xclusion \textbf{P}rompting (IEP), a novel
prompting that combines the principles of elimination and inference in order to
guide LLMs to think non-linearly. IEP guides LLMs to plan and then utilize
Natural Language Inference (NLI) to deduce each possible solution's entailment
relation with context, commonsense, or facts, therefore yielding a broader
perspective by thinking back for inferring. This forward planning and backward
eliminating process allows IEP to better simulate the complex human thinking
processes compared to other CoT-based methods, which only reflect linear
cognitive processes. We conducted a series of empirical studies and have
corroborated that IEP consistently outperforms CoT across various tasks.
Additionally, we observe that integrating IEP and CoT further improves the
LLMs' performance on certain tasks, highlighting the necessity of equipping
LLMs with mixed logic processes. Moreover, to better evaluate comprehensive
features inherent in human logic, we introduce \textbf{M}ental-\textbf{A}bility
\textbf{R}easoning \textbf{B}enchmark (MARB). The benchmark comprises six novel
subtasks with a total of 9,115 questions, among which 1,685 are developed with
hand-crafted rationale references. We believe both \textsc{IEP} and
\textsc{MARB} can serve as a promising direction for unveiling LLMs' logic and
verbal reasoning abilities and drive further advancements. \textsc{MARB} will
be available at ~\texttt{anonymity link} soon. | [
0.0263293404,
0.0578174554,
-0.0092565995,
0.0607373528,
-0.0591123067,
0.020387141,
-0.004456806,
0.010142995,
0.070190005,
-0.0397101529,
-0.0079432921,
0.0250505731,
-0.0330978222,
0.0186692849,
0.0347670726,
-0.0392415784,
0.0289437938,
-0.0606349781,
0.0284959786,
-0.0052410979,
-0.0330453031,
0.0052346219,
-0.0352510884,
0.0108415745,
0.0225171428,
-0.0152039872,
-0.0125202341,
0.002180361,
0.0145200286,
-0.0284286439,
-0.0322927274,
0.0424068607,
0.0252296366,
-0.0171339549,
0.0000026011,
-0.0729374886,
0.0083186608,
-0.0272594634,
-0.0475126021,
-0.0247323848,
-0.0454006717,
0.0186483618,
0.024282787,
0.017635487,
-0.0287710577,
0.0429686718,
-0.0337335914,
0.068512857,
0.0320666693,
0.0384828374,
0.0030607237,
-0.0385274813,
-0.0008932538,
0.0043323422,
0.0382891223,
-0.0556098148,
0.0112460218,
0.0227949582,
0.0447550677,
0.0133767761,
-0.0138867414,
0.0210625045,
0.0463138819,
0.0076083499,
-0.023515176,
0.0349790044,
-0.0034651386,
-0.0364723876,
-0.0220122058,
0.0822396055,
0.0256152004,
-0.0209028758,
0.0144881736,
0.004766291,
0.0223297197,
0.003699688,
-0.0309899468,
0.0714702532,
-0.0468337946,
0.0109172612,
0.0278125722,
0.0010021531,
0.0095514022,
0.0330458283,
-0.007281716,
0.0905238762,
0.0019732257,
-0.0345961079,
0.0579409301,
0.0040015024,
-0.013867911,
-0.0761724487,
0.0024155614,
0.0449394211,
-0.0276289061,
0.0035204787,
-0.0007959651,
0.003222127,
-0.0233317204,
-0.0151496967,
0.0497328788,
0.0718231052,
0.0266819354,
0.0643212795,
-0.0506922863,
0.0266281627,
-0.0339189395,
0.0244114269,
-0.0363489352,
0.0197403412,
-0.0332384706,
-0.0015042776,
-0.0092360275,
0.0506256409,
-0.0532299392,
-0.0118834376,
-0.0039692228,
0.0198138226,
-0.0072847102,
0.0011154249,
-0.0065882443,
0.0190299582,
0.0351689495,
-0.0467061326,
-0.0994833559,
0.0089433603,
-0.0610453337,
0.0328835286,
0.0224326327,
-0.0171774253,
-0.027698325,
0.0130945938,
0.0010998129,
-0.0226739682,
0.0427344516,
0.0731651857,
-0.0436795615,
0.0157029293,
-0.0756162554,
-0.0460863225,
0.0194258578,
-0.0681972504,
0.0266554318,
-0.0685245469,
0.0227823798,
0.0330859236,
-0.0307061858,
0.0150124663,
0.0058153342,
0.0310082138,
-0.0560116544,
0.0750176907,
-0.002814672,
0.0155728264,
0.0324715264,
0.0169763379,
-0.0488146991,
0.0609953217,
0.0100781377,
0.0287331697,
-0.0012790483,
0.0436285026,
0.0061231847,
0.045077946,
-0.0068037566,
-0.0229720771,
-0.0443450734,
-0.0097109796,
-0.0362563096,
0.0082391659,
0.0357402004,
0.058028087,
-0.0360957347,
0.0322870761,
0.0339100212,
0.0540141575,
-0.0010662273,
0.0270445775,
0.0614038259,
-0.0146973878,
0.0137744537,
0.0041508428,
-0.0602684729,
0.064584367,
-0.0615312569,
-0.0100925583,
0.019350661,
0.0047186217,
-0.0293955654,
-0.0348498337,
-0.0244791135,
0.0149137443,
0.0299595241,
0.012715471,
0.0221981052,
0.0049171019,
-0.0220523365,
0.0437763706,
0.0032890372,
-0.0205100812,
-0.0214773808,
-0.055548694,
0.0367556214,
0.0406460054,
0.0459188856,
-0.0008384066,
-0.0315270759,
-0.0048353383,
0.0132918553,
0.0311020352,
-0.0041406234,
-0.0028972344,
-0.0165181123,
-0.0370765924,
-0.0164610092,
0.005497803,
-0.0012155119,
-0.02783994,
0.0121090263,
-0.0219574645,
-0.0096689919,
-0.0407231227,
0.0424144566,
0.0263721831,
-0.0610864274,
0.0000947822,
-0.0308395568,
0.0301417969,
0.0238508619,
0.0031242548,
0.0326045491,
0.0253701601,
0.0242499989,
-0.0479652546,
-0.0459924005,
0.0381567255,
-0.0433230735,
-0.0349710882,
0.0416328348,
-0.0474775434,
-0.049677182,
-0.0206025336,
-0.014367084,
-0.027230097,
0.0420015305,
-0.0214638431,
-0.0008488845,
-0.0391713455,
0.0108646443,
0.0224521365,
-0.0414509475,
-0.0182406586,
0.1080680192,
-0.0294713844,
0.0101954397,
0.0623537898,
-0.0126305604,
0.002555287,
-0.014915375,
0.0031455639,
0.0040843897,
0.013674547,
-0.0352486782,
-0.010186607,
0.0426648967,
-0.081245631,
-0.0344179869,
-0.0723382011,
0.0017887508,
-0.002776583,
0.0163488947,
0.0029790788,
0.0009632299,
-0.017861275,
-0.0210983288,
-0.0079543302,
0.0166283753,
0.0148290396,
0.0153536741,
0.0337198339,
-0.0364055969,
0.0080564786,
0.0161773246,
0.0057671028,
-0.0413910411,
0.0211943481,
0.0020823206,
-0.0217077434,
-0.0161011051,
0.0143881114,
-0.0435506478,
0.0096271401,
-0.019839976,
0.009167498,
0.021933604,
-0.0164921172,
0.0524978489,
0.0579795241,
-0.0018013798,
-0.049194552,
0.0550388098,
-0.0165286176,
-0.0506019965,
0.0611622185,
0.0088686571,
0.0094160074,
-0.0003861426,
-0.0080993725,
-0.0457938053,
0.0420121029,
-0.0011354754,
0.020656528,
-0.0413880236,
0.0288916007,
0.0314033106,
-0.0353692621,
-0.0672337562,
-0.0344387777,
-0.017054759,
0.0729646012,
-0.0122093558,
-0.0124713676,
0.0833677873,
0.0319008827,
0.0009289454,
-0.0236883741,
0.0276037995,
-0.0443792492,
0.0515958034,
-0.0278204121,
-0.0133549022,
-0.0163781866,
0.015477146,
-0.0479373746,
-0.0227530673,
-0.0195631813,
-0.0235799458,
0.0769289285,
-0.0904152915,
0.0019276058,
-0.0077718636,
-0.0528614521,
-0.0744494945,
-0.0036866467,
-0.0615946054,
0.0053966194,
-0.0314412974,
0.0096429624,
-0.0010460486,
-0.0398728214,
0.054058414,
0.0226893891,
0.0130072897,
-0.0145696709,
-0.0182241369,
0.0243658107,
0.0422096178,
0.0302503668,
0.0305067673,
-0.0094182082,
0.0445753746,
0.0474040471,
0.009124239,
-0.0149806226,
-0.0004856455,
0.0553829521,
0.003515685,
0.0169335306,
0.0072900867,
0.0367153734,
0.037255343,
-0.0126498193,
-0.0171213448,
0.1135918275,
0.0342345983,
-0.0438823886,
0.0035930064,
-0.0558134094,
0.0624937043,
0.0351517238,
0.0204898305,
-0.0719165429,
-0.0608186163,
0.0329677165,
-0.0311880298,
0.0031170931,
-0.0731862262,
-0.0132000586,
-0.111918129,
0.0198191348,
-0.0201351717,
0.0020365589,
0.0162626579,
-0.0512514375,
0.0112052383,
0.0328901894,
-0.0466664806,
0.0319908075,
0.017313065,
0.0136486338,
-0.0069251619,
-0.0392498598,
0.0075057745,
0.0323389061,
-0.0362612121,
0.0127619384,
-0.0237732902,
0.0192440562,
0.0093904343,
-0.065665625,
0.0532187819,
-0.0063271183,
0.0263168756,
-0.0462462008,
0.0108201168,
0.0092457449,
0.0133998226,
-0.0603655912,
0.0623954274,
-0.0327997319,
-0.0444548167,
0.0390841663,
0.1318876147,
-0.0444518924,
-0.0325800292,
-0.035647314,
0.0345552973,
-0.0386657752,
0.0929483846,
0.0081300382,
-0.0423848443,
-0.0359527878,
-0.0330968946,
-0.0530954264,
-0.0229227506,
-0.0478186049,
-0.0020113047,
0.0268187001,
0.0339138284,
-0.0609723441,
-0.0246600285,
0.027478788,
0.0321148746,
-0.0085580666,
0.0031250492,
0.0007108091,
0.0114202863,
-0.0075656124,
0.0096938191,
-0.0339440964,
0.010416477,
-0.0038318068,
0.0452162363,
-0.0086577656,
-0.0542282723,
-0.0220479537,
0.0812364221,
-0.0723367408,
-0.0505250432,
-0.0459723286,
0.0223677866,
0.0267918818,
0.0409251899,
-0.0015301772,
-0.0178267006,
0.0209262725,
0.0236062463,
0.0381607376,
0.0463809669,
-0.0142748822,
0.070582062,
0.0167458039,
0.0591948181,
-0.0208154321,
0.0249528494,
0.0291358829,
0.0773533136,
-0.0195522327,
-0.0600191653,
0.0150256976,
0.0325686932,
0.0067213788,
-0.0204214752,
-0.0270397235,
-0.0305891335,
0.0123828268,
-0.02637708,
-0.0414753072,
-0.0180230513,
0.0285675935,
0.0011262025,
-0.0033297141,
-0.0144312512,
-0.0455415025,
0.0151707819,
0.0182585679,
0.0330489278,
0.0008624357,
0.0075889276,
0.0080926782,
0.0021351641,
-0.0386634097,
-0.0063424283,
-0.0090095513,
-0.0237443987,
0.0384087041,
-0.0120221591,
0.1026368141,
0.0340233855,
-0.0199761428,
-0.0614024438,
-0.0189612526,
-0.0570479967,
-0.0526792817,
0.0528938621,
0.0221264735,
0.0344608463,
-0.0110575724,
0.0084727351,
-0.0462070554,
-0.0074389218,
0.0187482443,
0.0274090227,
0.0095256865,
-0.0166456308,
0.0586148016,
0.0320644677,
-0.0040290649,
-0.0190099422,
0.0123901358,
-0.041467756,
0.0220943019,
0.0008162777,
0.0121370526,
-0.053768985,
-0.0558451377,
-0.0469901711,
0.0023419603,
0.0001152663,
0.0513971113,
-0.0886026621,
-0.0522070751,
-0.0023722728,
0.0018432188,
0.0025964286,
-0.0296237636,
0.0535972603,
0.0610879548,
0.0096244933,
-0.0582558066,
0.0116690947,
0.0442779362,
-0.0077255103,
-0.0303351991,
-0.0705278143,
-7.287217884e-33,
0.0006088368,
-0.0441971421,
0.0644074678,
0.0085852575,
-0.0156189222,
-0.0179045647,
-0.0513515733,
0.0225889701,
-0.0332706384,
0.0123961521,
-0.0377417281,
0.0007686103,
0.0015472714,
-0.0046160459,
0.0225409511,
0.0095978435,
-0.0101996679,
-0.0037644762,
-0.0236466061,
-0.0240424294,
0.0429210961,
0.0044827885,
0.0266923532,
-0.0499268882,
-0.0231316909,
0.00451145,
-0.0001597138,
0.0434211791,
-0.0426691547,
0.014970039,
-0.0453261361,
-0.0316690467,
0.0453721918,
-0.0131317591,
0.0043239119,
0.0475609377,
-0.0574498661,
-0.0438479111,
0.0605347492,
-0.0485879369,
-0.0595637821,
-0.0353835523,
0.0302774366,
0.0161121301,
-0.043724753,
-0.010862303,
0.0133777689,
-0.0341352858,
0.019269811,
0.0487216152,
-0.0352622382,
0.0124718184,
-0.0117647341,
-0.0109222112,
-0.0034815376,
0.0495117381,
-0.0463699289,
0.0062240702,
-0.0496010967,
0.0270207673,
0.0007264934,
-0.0298251305,
0.0702375248,
-0.0063462439,
-0.0100647062,
0.0596416481,
0.0026604908,
-0.002701316,
-0.0930670351,
-0.0041373405,
0.0098752845,
0.0821020082,
0.0464860052,
0.0169072226,
0.0477885753,
0.0340391062,
-0.0805473104,
0.0213026609,
0.0072202445,
0.0710764527,
0.0291797128,
0.0029069511,
-0.0180301312,
-0.0068304543,
-0.0455445312,
-0.0035511015,
-0.0463692211,
-0.0032408098,
0.0172865577,
0.0033030265,
0.0137813035,
-0.0444040298,
0.0271391552,
-0.0076681073,
0.0101240836,
0.0463307872,
0.0019624901,
0.0232669078,
0.0219445582,
0.010089214,
-0.0548611917,
-0.001213669,
0.005201865,
0.0381096229,
0.0264139865,
0.0130170519,
0.0091009866,
-0.0205225069,
-0.0194861572,
-0.0255284421,
-0.0827387273,
0.000131499,
-0.0098354788,
-0.0016539532,
0.0651060268,
0.0106942644,
-0.0190500971,
0.0050127944,
-0.0067215548,
-0.0224462245,
-0.0204997603,
0.0110680703,
0.0175480656,
0.0247720703,
-0.016928345,
0.0090146903,
-0.0182724018,
0.0041308124,
0.0025207826,
-0.0687120557,
-0.0046309787,
0.0537329912,
3.337e-7,
0.00923179,
0.0378186144,
0.0106501756,
0.0370280668,
0.0380580798,
0.0348915905,
-0.0323166139,
-0.023584798,
0.03310946,
-0.0539113358,
-0.0130757838,
0.0642682463,
0.0412623063,
0.0322483778,
-0.0817915872,
-0.0116365664,
-0.0312996469,
-0.031638708,
-0.0342164189,
-0.0218195431,
0.0715027601,
0.025346471,
0.0168076809,
-0.0367488489,
-0.0177915394,
-0.0193120968,
0.0383097455,
-0.0287378617,
-0.0097833183,
-0.0339825787,
0.0125753237,
-0.0133494204,
0.0205368251,
0.046209354,
0.0062699146,
0.0031049242,
0.0021045175,
0.0615599677,
0.0054297801,
-0.0223753192,
-0.0222284328,
-0.0155879119,
0.0343703292,
-0.0405137762,
0.1012823656,
-0.0143669173,
-0.0228872839,
0.0264153518,
-0.0012545699,
0.0002439774,
-0.0109029952,
0.0098171439,
-0.0011567613,
-0.0043516392,
0.0168522261,
-0.0029838046,
-0.0053983564,
-0.0725692138,
-0.0306216441,
0.0115806069,
-0.0636314526,
-0.049438078,
-0.0519534014,
0.0286436994,
0.0444138162,
-0.0662594587,
-0.0227665957,
3.317906044e-34,
0.0014264617,
-0.0063262428,
0.0434701964,
0.0229785256,
0.0381256752,
-0.000664242,
-0.0306887794,
0.0170148108,
0.0253923554,
-0.1192954704,
-0.0263921879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12318v1 | The Sentiment Problem: A Critical Survey towards Deconstructing Sentiment Analysis | 2023-10-18T20:42:44 | 2023-10-18T20:42:44 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Mukund Srinath, Sanjana Gautam, Saranya Venkatraman, Vipul Gupta, Rebecca J. Passonneau, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | We conduct an inquiry into the sociotechnical aspects of sentiment analysis
(SA) by critically examining 189 peer-reviewed papers on their applications,
models, and datasets. Our investigation stems from the recognition that SA has
become an integral component of diverse sociotechnical systems, exerting
influence on both social and technical users. By delving into sociological and
technological literature on sentiment, we unveil distinct conceptualizations of
this term in domains such as finance, government, and medicine. Our study
exposes a lack of explicit definitions and frameworks for characterizing
sentiment, resulting in potential challenges and biases. To tackle this issue,
we propose an ethics sheet encompassing critical inquiries to guide
practitioners in ensuring equitable utilization of SA. Our findings underscore
the significance of adopting an interdisciplinary approach to defining
sentiment in SA and offer a pragmatic solution for its implementation. | [
0.0500295572,
0.088394776,
-0.0130001865,
0.004230761,
-0.0507257171,
-0.0041943286,
0.0007696841,
0.0045421016,
0.0332085826,
-0.0295646563,
-0.0174024776,
0.0005633344,
-0.0058030803,
0.0106386039,
-0.003375367,
-0.0056375349,
-0.0231038295,
0.0778804347,
0.0496884473,
-0.0092368731,
0.0267565306,
0.0081575336,
0.0337620229,
-0.0003074541,
0.006987839,
0.0231241547,
0.0211128257,
-0.0068158028,
0.0214989614,
-0.0284564514,
0.0325799994,
0.0053645158,
-0.0274206884,
0.0395696051,
0.0000020402,
-0.0150267864,
-0.0161712579,
0.0142728966,
0.0479423963,
-0.0245385244,
0.1167161539,
-0.0100604035,
0.0325807184,
0.0045969863,
-0.0675810501,
-0.0323435888,
0.0313377418,
0.0204858668,
0.0190935489,
0.0459671132,
-0.0306764748,
-0.0202179104,
-0.0166234914,
-0.0040577622,
-0.03029548,
0.0211511273,
0.0003301496,
-0.0181765966,
-0.0116254622,
-0.0038824938,
0.0140334126,
0.0350160263,
-0.0153785497,
0.0333639197,
0.0279328581,
-0.0214458331,
0.0114349471,
-0.0003136576,
0.0119692422,
0.025356112,
0.1070633307,
0.0147785041,
0.0270053931,
0.0224075746,
-0.0175313894,
0.0085961297,
-0.0182428565,
0.0137464171,
-0.0254299697,
-0.0128226923,
-0.0132257007,
0.0636389926,
0.0363949537,
0.0561217964,
0.0287996251,
0.0057849288,
-0.0494299196,
-0.0093796402,
0.0099867228,
0.0326963961,
0.0445947796,
0.0348981842,
0.0367046893,
0.0015074884,
0.0172175523,
0.0265210178,
0.0441815853,
0.0136564616,
0.0410187803,
-0.0847324058,
-0.0053382511,
-0.007310167,
0.0331862867,
0.0108261928,
0.070843026,
-0.0571827106,
0.0038312811,
-0.0057959775,
-0.0054654428,
0.0466222726,
-0.0380079299,
0.0275740121,
0.0409664027,
0.0061227232,
-0.0310625825,
0.0326573811,
-0.0180384722,
-0.0335626192,
-0.0548974797,
0.0154809766,
-0.0349106938,
0.0077234507,
0.0221364889,
0.0143420128,
-0.0229548644,
0.00234586,
-0.0257655606,
0.0410014056,
-0.0583698377,
-0.0041238447,
0.0213669315,
0.0016267733,
-0.0109536648,
0.0269216988,
-0.0003479572,
0.0769510791,
0.0522564575,
-0.0265402626,
-0.0071248864,
-0.0467569046,
-0.0085528856,
-0.0246866867,
0.0091326851,
-0.0212933552,
0.0056081954,
0.0175892916,
-0.009287036,
0.0227330141,
-0.014517013,
0.0066468013,
-0.0349449292,
0.0451044813,
-0.0406600907,
-0.0229062587,
0.00486005,
0.0531783327,
0.0025117334,
0.0049786395,
-0.0386672616,
0.0631776601,
0.0562445335,
0.0181481857,
0.0312175024,
-0.0141906412,
-0.0054286146,
-0.0384336188,
-0.0437646806,
0.0220882054,
-0.0810021088,
-0.0678031594,
-0.0175878499,
0.0241533201,
-0.0299241897,
-0.0201594047,
0.0232427362,
0.0394841693,
-0.0492734388,
0.0624039397,
-0.0474447682,
-0.0064954557,
0.0060555576,
-0.0232136939,
0.0047072219,
0.0006969969,
-0.0218457393,
-0.0519803874,
-0.0463260151,
-0.0093797231,
-0.0219493508,
-0.0477552973,
0.0039370735,
-0.0234412868,
0.0622645505,
0.0088689597,
0.0231457967,
-0.0427103639,
-0.0074203727,
-0.0569366217,
0.0610835589,
-0.0443550758,
-0.0024038549,
-0.0288393069,
0.0301026423,
0.0900149494,
0.0333514251,
-0.0042485916,
0.0251411665,
-0.0068256073,
-0.0249400735,
0.0419237502,
0.0211883076,
-0.0186821986,
-0.0509776175,
-0.023842128,
0.0104728732,
0.0164550915,
0.0140416911,
0.0324386731,
-0.011933648,
0.0343198031,
-0.0294481814,
-0.0019692385,
-0.0202696174,
-0.0265695043,
0.0284796879,
0.003201304,
-0.0169982128,
-0.0041763936,
0.0425582416,
0.0381983593,
-0.0085490616,
-0.0035825584,
0.0077570085,
0.0109690251,
-0.0446813144,
0.0255918186,
0.0303719752,
0.0420062318,
-0.0253520999,
-0.0618505627,
-0.0364307351,
0.0277683213,
0.0092835687,
0.0442928784,
0.0459774658,
-0.0170006752,
-0.0000106009,
-0.0216528438,
-0.0599555224,
-0.0482993983,
-0.0203645583,
-0.0316424333,
0.0143915983,
-0.0175753571,
-0.0048721805,
-0.0581999756,
-0.0589676127,
0.0225678626,
0.073281616,
-0.0503117554,
0.0247681197,
0.0345888473,
0.018702345,
0.0326329581,
-0.0268558376,
-0.0043071634,
-0.0459857024,
-0.0972096398,
-0.054386843,
-0.002396774,
0.0229105875,
-0.0029502704,
-0.019176241,
0.0108079631,
-0.0054507656,
-0.0148678422,
-0.0136387451,
-0.0500550866,
0.000484231,
0.0421527848,
0.00178059,
0.0333829224,
-0.0210463163,
-0.012947672,
-0.0200361647,
-0.0097912773,
0.0444114096,
-0.0014522432,
-0.0034093889,
-0.0272985082,
-0.0625067726,
-0.0109339599,
-0.0258897562,
-0.0118735936,
-0.0068871137,
0.0453222059,
-0.0516260415,
0.0220120419,
-0.0013907178,
0.0700957775,
-0.016081892,
0.0403241031,
0.0092249978,
-0.0183460768,
-0.0684820116,
0.0546121411,
-0.0062507531,
-0.0240099877,
-0.0229368564,
0.0180797148,
0.009866803,
0.0247065928,
-0.0486609228,
0.0465767831,
-0.0635439157,
-0.007714719,
-0.0055575999,
0.0057404507,
0.0152591038,
-0.00560334,
0.0164458621,
-0.0196990836,
0.051106777,
0.0429030694,
0.0057282485,
-0.0771377236,
-0.0129684079,
-0.0432060622,
0.0405491367,
-0.0520166606,
-0.0081776055,
0.0206378512,
0.0186515376,
-0.0021901741,
-0.0489503779,
0.0037354256,
-0.0510908104,
0.0255116243,
0.0042846529,
0.0285555553,
0.0036899343,
-0.0512196012,
0.0457145944,
-0.0621483438,
-0.0777129903,
-0.0147350859,
0.0394977666,
-0.0303578172,
0.0186834149,
0.0034409387,
0.009773789,
-0.0342072546,
0.0096920272,
-0.0442931801,
0.0480817147,
-0.0034473399,
-0.0003068683,
-0.0680867508,
0.086203061,
0.0393041074,
-0.0153624294,
0.0648828819,
0.0162479468,
-0.0163163692,
-0.0023387477,
-0.0135547528,
0.0075059263,
0.0046121934,
-0.0084300861,
-0.0738370195,
0.0214339662,
-0.0010551121,
0.0313134901,
0.0445791408,
0.0107248975,
-0.0234820377,
0.0033257373,
0.0392507315,
-0.0389372781,
-0.0081035318,
-0.0078457156,
-0.0085674915,
-0.0010370548,
-0.0485143661,
0.0442883484,
-0.0534793474,
-0.0171701815,
0.0018523799,
-0.0529496409,
0.0213634465,
0.002544529,
0.0164729767,
0.0001780302,
-0.0178973749,
0.0004494321,
-0.0245843679,
-0.0140500972,
-0.0429705717,
0.0223598313,
0.0180966575,
-0.0008072072,
-0.0559435487,
0.0231545027,
0.0479951687,
0.0145316524,
0.0455759726,
0.0269143376,
0.0644597262,
-0.0254416205,
-0.0382930487,
-0.0111091873,
-0.0103595182,
-0.0200066175,
-0.0142313782,
0.081437245,
-0.0357077084,
-0.0409368612,
-0.0602467954,
0.0084786071,
-0.0709818825,
0.0181717593,
-0.0046417667,
0.0173623394,
-0.0034778672,
-0.0635050982,
-0.0424661227,
0.0493838154,
-0.0057785939,
0.0208580773,
-0.0305688698,
-0.0419544354,
0.007740607,
-0.0086028967,
0.033854939,
-0.0066286279,
-0.0071355542,
-0.0342583172,
0.0417374074,
-0.05459309,
-0.0356449559,
-0.0703676641,
-0.0328993201,
0.0202398524,
-0.0057480787,
-0.025670087,
0.0842597038,
-0.0237060692,
-0.0370502025,
0.0126688136,
0.0142206941,
0.0025402969,
0.045185037,
-0.0430191122,
0.0403547175,
0.0142038492,
0.0029467533,
-0.0492345132,
0.0388411507,
-0.0039289002,
0.0305865444,
0.0168467611,
0.013007747,
-0.0095174331,
-0.0137200253,
0.0006837654,
0.0258130208,
0.0708570033,
-0.0596328191,
0.0221364051,
0.0686382875,
0.0459319279,
0.0020499141,
-0.0019496655,
0.0345112458,
0.021213362,
0.0303980298,
-0.0856612995,
-0.0473877117,
0.0215907115,
-0.0021482133,
-0.0308114421,
0.0319578499,
0.0074474704,
-0.006287924,
0.0327498503,
-0.059480574,
0.0063809357,
-0.0164896175,
-0.0269859526,
-0.0628126562,
-0.0252645146,
0.0363012031,
-0.0934538171,
0.0204589348,
-0.0544458553,
0.0126347058,
-0.0200578645,
0.0603681579,
0.021843072,
0.0262391064,
-0.0169816464,
-0.0093912166,
0.0068313428,
-0.0066151666,
-0.0050493167,
0.0014389541,
-0.0121432627,
0.023486387,
0.0112041645,
-0.0127739543,
0.0180629529,
0.0200314503,
-0.0434666052,
-0.0055252574,
0.0174409319,
0.0453016721,
-0.0823099241,
0.0003873367,
-0.0005468336,
0.0040846486,
0.016339276,
0.0014224364,
-0.0325757787,
-0.044561062,
-0.014894003,
-0.0013134069,
0.0036553941,
-0.0590186007,
-0.0322808288,
0.0304937735,
-0.0613970421,
0.036595244,
0.0148421852,
-0.0091603417,
-0.0025475267,
-0.0794427767,
0.0775926188,
-0.043880187,
0.0102876043,
-0.0051761148,
-0.107287325,
-0.0276555419,
0.0691459253,
-0.0314471498,
0.0293972921,
-0.05404732,
-0.0114587834,
0.0433537401,
0.0251184907,
0.0748986453,
-0.0419982411,
0.0419716425,
-0.0675793886,
0.0031217453,
0.0335970931,
-6.535682469e-33,
0.032195542,
-0.0516104214,
-0.0017201995,
0.0334493704,
-0.0100524379,
0.0329782292,
-0.0120826857,
0.0320658349,
-0.0101234773,
0.0449178778,
-0.012187087,
0.0344690718,
-0.004895431,
0.0090879416,
0.043486055,
-0.0497669056,
0.0018191237,
-0.025630312,
0.0295085423,
0.0195680857,
0.0005064525,
-0.015788069,
0.0161716342,
-0.1307720244,
0.0981438458,
0.0022884463,
-0.0555770993,
0.004202948,
0.0442928448,
-0.0142462282,
-0.0211048387,
0.0808590651,
0.0308217071,
0.0186225548,
0.0210729614,
0.0516545549,
-0.014967653,
-0.01296381,
-0.001898722,
0.0173566006,
-0.0029854698,
0.0208654124,
0.0130152265,
0.0002476489,
-0.0809441581,
0.0197724253,
0.0197958425,
-0.0061092321,
0.0145075954,
-0.0720966756,
-0.0186060872,
0.0353263952,
0.0045906431,
0.0304477848,
0.0208217222,
0.0681981966,
0.0191992465,
0.0513457246,
-0.0572034679,
0.0170286074,
-0.0575042553,
-0.0597984754,
-0.0334115289,
-0.0298573505,
0.0262343045,
0.0672888085,
0.0273302477,
0.0458301492,
-0.024552349,
0.0374997109,
0.0106889559,
0.0047221538,
0.0395262949,
0.0636369511,
-0.0273810904,
-0.100667879,
-0.0274950322,
-0.0147881834,
0.0369533971,
-0.0182228349,
0.060293857,
-0.0334846079,
-0.0824303776,
-0.0407037213,
0.0304941442,
-0.0910812169,
-0.0191278141,
0.01148827,
-0.0195431504,
-0.0266556907,
-0.0158019941,
-0.0124605699,
-0.0363622084,
-0.0634886101,
-0.0146620544,
0.0187678169,
-0.0116100023,
0.0261766035,
0.0397791117,
-0.0127181858,
-0.0472911336,
-0.0106580313,
-0.0702405497,
0.0670610145,
0.0076820091,
-0.0115258042,
0.0281924084,
0.0356831253,
-0.0276932437,
-0.0389037281,
0.0072491672,
0.0364712216,
0.0027824764,
0.0030559986,
0.016991023,
0.0581106097,
0.0247709416,
0.0131037198,
0.0042209579,
0.0973132178,
0.0098425122,
0.0286946949,
-0.0186307561,
0.0149841448,
-0.0081504853,
-0.0509235933,
0.0250298828,
-0.0204450879,
0.0202159919,
-0.0214901268,
0.0068340413,
-0.0395426415,
2.962e-7,
0.0313782766,
0.0510885306,
-0.0248629935,
-0.0557718538,
0.0102814641,
0.0977963209,
0.0154807931,
0.039654959,
-0.0155886235,
-0.0349522792,
0.0513409153,
0.0069866264,
0.0337003991,
0.0356836729,
-0.073662214,
-0.055638101,
-0.003381738,
0.0048560426,
0.0192100927,
0.0712578967,
0.0297753979,
0.0095997797,
0.0086703645,
0.0034445282,
-0.0566531792,
0.0137776984,
0.0342363007,
-0.0631835908,
-0.0140894512,
0.0088382345,
-0.0531932674,
-0.000350195,
0.0060832966,
-0.0075826691,
0.0144548947,
-0.0113229062,
0.0160394572,
0.0621807501,
0.0136063211,
-0.0541841164,
0.0011579989,
-0.0130545376,
0.021696277,
0.001323225,
0.0042255609,
-0.0347007066,
-0.0633575693,
-0.1011599302,
-0.0113320928,
0.0008464003,
0.0677245185,
0.0371620469,
-0.0606751777,
0.0235402342,
-0.014882653,
-0.0298846941,
-0.0086473683,
-0.0427981652,
0.0260905251,
-0.0233989339,
-0.0128548248,
-0.0498394519,
0.0307060201,
0.0820641741,
0.0216653068,
0.0159058683,
0.0590369739,
2.186942955e-34,
0.0505948924,
-0.0423572846,
-0.0121317757,
-0.0389376543,
0.0123178642,
0.0443801284,
-0.038481649,
-0.0183536727,
0.0444266759,
0.0003286774,
0.0266858712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12303v1 | Document-Level Language Models for Machine Translation | 2023-10-18T20:10:07 | 2023-10-18T20:10:07 | Frithjof Petrick, Christian Herold, Pavel Petrushkov, Shahram Khadivi, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite the known limitations, most machine translation systems today still
operate on the sentence-level. One reason for this is, that most parallel
training data is only sentence-level aligned, without document-level meta
information available. In this work, we set out to build context-aware
translation systems utilizing document-level monolingual data instead. This can
be achieved by combining any existing sentence-level translation model with a
document-level language model. We improve existing approaches by leveraging
recent advancements in model combination. Additionally, we propose novel
weighting techniques that make the system combination more flexible and
significantly reduce computational overhead. In a comprehensive evaluation on
four diverse translation tasks, we show that our extensions improve
document-targeted scores substantially and are also computationally more
efficient. However, we also find that in most scenarios, back-translation gives
even better results, at the cost of having to re-train the translation system.
Finally, we explore language model fusion in the light of recent advancements
in large language models. Our findings suggest that there might be strong
potential in utilizing large language models via model combination. | [
0.0501290448,
0.0458151847,
0.0180408806,
0.031724792,
-0.0364841744,
0.0208127927,
0.0581314564,
-0.0331228487,
-0.014037298,
-0.0531063154,
-0.0302657951,
-0.0250508469,
0.0371226855,
-0.0274886116,
0.0267089512,
-0.0367346071,
0.0069183419,
-0.0168146677,
-0.0455096811,
-0.0098250387,
0.0006852384,
0.0375696607,
0.0428426526,
0.0307981018,
-0.0082817189,
-0.024897201,
0.0135293938,
0.0650633723,
0.0500576869,
0.0132809971,
0.0167200398,
0.0119526079,
0.0413504019,
0.0788844824,
0.0000018469,
-0.0117324525,
-0.047649622,
0.0205249041,
0.0154741332,
0.0031527667,
0.0635237768,
-0.0593175292,
-0.0211465303,
0.0330662243,
-0.0152941681,
-0.0134649863,
0.0374712311,
0.0000777395,
0.0425084606,
0.077745162,
-0.0264357869,
-0.0242071562,
0.0328327157,
-0.0713082328,
-0.0089024417,
-0.0482342392,
0.0001053231,
0.0190926436,
-0.0279898737,
0.0286589228,
0.0120011838,
0.0386295766,
-0.0029451547,
-0.0305745192,
-0.0023330515,
-0.0052603576,
-0.0116477124,
0.0155417835,
-0.0234783683,
0.0459047854,
-0.0347976461,
-0.0209042039,
-0.0076092468,
0.0055742064,
-0.0142417792,
-0.0060997973,
-0.0448723808,
0.005380319,
0.0152205471,
0.0023575448,
0.0386383459,
0.0206406303,
0.067639567,
0.0262841769,
-0.0582686812,
0.0222904142,
0.0416075289,
-0.0356165059,
0.0097047854,
-0.0086375829,
-0.0367370211,
-0.0170335583,
0.0388307013,
-0.0007803218,
0.0046988362,
0.0030132576,
-0.0397379324,
-0.0761296153,
0.017498197,
-0.0708357543,
0.0356328413,
0.048607558,
0.0128335459,
0.0875747427,
-0.0033792879,
0.056096077,
0.0005711638,
-0.0302554406,
-0.0993424207,
-0.0286090113,
-0.0093081677,
0.0272333827,
-0.0466063581,
-0.0234152898,
-0.0623948425,
-0.0224361755,
-0.0304224025,
0.0223914534,
0.0110250656,
0.0056013321,
0.0348728001,
-0.0305832494,
-0.06009835,
-0.0499995798,
0.0506041534,
0.0673854351,
0.0177533273,
-0.0037357281,
0.0175875053,
-0.0117061427,
-0.0142340707,
0.0175805278,
-0.0261845943,
-0.0362490229,
0.0071687968,
0.0557628796,
0.0026703046,
-0.0142543716,
0.0146798082,
0.008611301,
-0.0400063805,
-0.0747662634,
-0.0286908727,
-0.0514206402,
0.0500839949,
0.0068461196,
0.0403700247,
-0.0159854982,
0.0059047788,
0.0065373415,
-0.0114637408,
0.0780206248,
0.0228263587,
0.0042789523,
0.0401623212,
-0.0251381435,
-0.0034429133,
0.0711399689,
0.0515153445,
0.0414941944,
0.0300891455,
0.0097179888,
-0.0478868335,
0.0518635176,
-0.0113341501,
0.0472801886,
-0.0220486131,
-0.0101206051,
0.0341600962,
-0.0012506987,
-0.00372784,
0.0385080203,
-0.0127531169,
0.0368002467,
0.0781964436,
0.0168412197,
0.0064631454,
0.0057071131,
0.0452808999,
-0.0071084723,
-0.0188926104,
-0.0098069515,
-0.0189167596,
-0.0072035384,
-0.0291209742,
0.0016960576,
0.0334801413,
0.0695645213,
-0.027451735,
-0.0318856612,
-0.0249400493,
-0.0271167401,
0.011363849,
-0.0006679131,
0.0523920171,
0.0118686883,
-0.0421081819,
0.0042618918,
0.0092486432,
-0.0803325027,
0.0317467339,
0.0078517916,
-0.0390197709,
0.0747992322,
0.0561811365,
-0.0089349402,
-0.014718012,
-0.0074987379,
0.0192950591,
0.0564687476,
0.0793967471,
-0.0016379207,
0.0286934618,
-0.0609973408,
-0.0262952484,
0.0056449575,
0.0084633091,
0.0288810153,
-0.0157159567,
-0.0043403883,
0.0403513424,
-0.0474155545,
-0.0818442479,
0.0269894656,
-0.04089031,
-0.0231610276,
0.0340669565,
0.0147151649,
0.0032317808,
0.0006127193,
-0.0014001847,
0.013361658,
0.0488096587,
-0.0465823635,
-0.0309993643,
0.0301528387,
-0.0286911279,
-0.0597538538,
0.0328886881,
-0.0040248004,
-0.0087028444,
0.0112846857,
-0.0447414219,
-0.0599265508,
-0.0242865328,
-0.0273054168,
0.01426253,
-0.0348580144,
0.0663999841,
0.0052326657,
-0.0143135218,
-0.0829002559,
0.0428163595,
-0.017941419,
-0.0105395336,
0.0068414006,
-0.0218188036,
0.0183222201,
-0.0186185408,
-0.0451901667,
0.0156530738,
0.0207734946,
0.0523110144,
0.053958755,
0.0189053565,
-0.0025620179,
-0.0599643923,
-0.1097791865,
0.0430681854,
-0.0387708507,
0.0340687409,
0.0273312293,
0.0602137223,
0.007307726,
-0.0078285793,
-0.0257974528,
0.0081867864,
0.0153307794,
0.0150159448,
-0.0073319138,
0.0048044026,
0.0323452279,
-0.0464706868,
-0.0287212748,
-0.0076546813,
0.0521616414,
0.0057977666,
0.0006215515,
-0.0363794416,
0.0202555917,
-0.0236124992,
0.0135126114,
-0.0173322037,
-0.0204237904,
-0.0141828936,
-0.0486063547,
0.0408996902,
0.0697924495,
0.0136809126,
0.0090364013,
0.0392485932,
-0.0037102094,
-0.0485480912,
0.0328296982,
-0.0181356762,
-0.0228156764,
-0.0328087434,
-0.031895712,
0.0018474573,
0.053808026,
-0.0182048231,
-0.0115651526,
-0.042330727,
-0.019354701,
-0.0029331616,
-0.0320711881,
-0.0227204952,
0.0102715585,
0.0281621777,
0.0040749013,
-0.0490168631,
-0.0648413375,
0.0433590971,
-0.0506441742,
-0.0017551804,
-0.0494318642,
-0.0197081119,
-0.063908644,
0.0369258821,
-0.0107700052,
0.0226921719,
-0.056862019,
0.0223004483,
-0.0237017963,
0.0059539052,
0.0122335162,
-0.0262440927,
0.0389642604,
-0.046727553,
0.0147093814,
-0.0305362735,
-0.0409375168,
-0.0280622169,
-0.0110918591,
-0.0133655369,
-0.0012278403,
-0.0116213132,
-0.0233803019,
-0.0695156083,
0.0142041994,
0.0098941876,
0.0777951032,
-0.0378820784,
-0.0038269667,
-0.0290287063,
0.0444023013,
0.0264925454,
-0.0257609095,
-0.0116446679,
-0.0559951849,
0.033910092,
0.0230549481,
0.0296120867,
-0.0098726107,
-0.0358013399,
-0.0157970674,
0.061999768,
-0.0058026328,
-0.0170658622,
-0.0229401886,
0.0212895423,
-0.06292326,
-0.013308933,
0.1105405018,
0.0427387208,
-0.0603103749,
-0.0526365489,
-0.0250650942,
0.0436644889,
0.0142663801,
0.0232811123,
-0.0292243883,
-0.0540794544,
0.0118278144,
0.004797867,
0.0503867306,
0.0404570661,
-0.021732999,
-0.0630012155,
0.0087520368,
0.0553156994,
-0.0445534475,
-0.0226224624,
-0.0130854156,
-0.0098241381,
-0.0382765159,
0.0214152746,
-0.0040335972,
-0.001233867,
-0.0084761893,
-0.0070703737,
0.0493757054,
-0.0359701104,
-0.0049726395,
-0.0427636653,
-0.0077173403,
0.0973155499,
0.0579326004,
-0.0017704085,
-0.0157109834,
0.0628307909,
-0.0149795655,
-0.0078795021,
-0.0047214441,
0.0078587113,
-0.0453952923,
0.0209757071,
0.024660619,
0.0152126923,
-0.052641619,
0.0136692245,
0.0158947334,
0.0395521559,
-0.0066815852,
0.0219425801,
-0.01840996,
-0.025067417,
0.0182735231,
0.0681458861,
-0.0083013577,
-0.0884035081,
0.001135554,
-0.022801375,
-0.0195107888,
-0.0314187631,
0.0374051817,
-0.006393916,
-0.0207717158,
-0.0305992253,
-0.0807698071,
-0.0453258529,
0.0077252784,
0.0089890258,
0.0192560982,
0.0286677964,
-0.0128696607,
-0.0216138866,
-0.0357085019,
0.0455904976,
-0.0252099466,
0.0325493105,
-0.0507336035,
0.031033745,
0.0363954753,
-0.0278772675,
-0.0020235304,
0.0438272506,
-0.1125002503,
-0.0857814327,
-0.0266558547,
0.0461077504,
0.0184527207,
0.042919077,
-0.0260852929,
-0.0242450722,
0.0221848898,
0.0141330669,
-0.0226892121,
0.0061274534,
0.0331716388,
-0.0248702355,
-0.0273018628,
0.0456867255,
-0.0353857167,
0.0012793314,
0.0047974866,
0.0440900624,
-0.0258485675,
-0.0603449717,
0.0267832894,
-0.0228368118,
0.018338671,
-0.0259987861,
-0.025991695,
-0.0252210852,
0.0518734977,
-0.0252465829,
-0.0520856343,
-0.0471923538,
-0.0223277379,
0.0465955362,
0.0037608689,
0.0165685639,
0.0430650711,
0.0126964301,
-0.0042856652,
-0.0171328615,
-0.0088716252,
-0.0474375486,
0.0334487855,
-0.0024939978,
0.0093551623,
-0.0106970938,
0.0113761108,
-0.0149603132,
-0.0057280674,
-0.0322703458,
0.0289754327,
0.0066671292,
-0.0079504289,
0.0005166705,
0.0498494208,
-0.0779406428,
0.0063052941,
-0.0282767992,
-0.0104145957,
0.0855104327,
-0.0079074111,
0.1202320755,
-0.0070298561,
-0.0225729831,
-0.0439911224,
0.026822051,
0.0631154999,
-0.0026826896,
-0.0045603407,
0.0069710505,
0.0139273275,
0.0394855998,
0.0687264055,
0.0067943735,
0.0070684776,
0.0034687829,
-0.0223655999,
-0.0159463994,
-0.0079736663,
0.0155068887,
0.0183193199,
-0.0308822636,
0.0087634167,
-0.0340631232,
-0.0414098017,
0.0309586357,
0.0281962026,
-0.0137908431,
-0.0128518874,
0.0097923903,
0.065263018,
-0.0611789562,
0.0050955303,
-0.0704196692,
0.0295892749,
-0.0299418252,
-0.028933486,
-0.0370418392,
-5.732338242e-33,
-0.0340148918,
-0.017426677,
0.000360295,
-0.0146557055,
-0.0172995236,
0.0139164673,
-0.0257114917,
-0.0153109804,
0.0048068371,
0.0168364327,
-0.0216680691,
0.0112183839,
0.0133142499,
0.0312229022,
-0.0213487688,
0.0552638881,
0.0688096881,
0.0242027789,
-0.0079752915,
0.0098264758,
0.0370275117,
0.0137024513,
0.0522905514,
-0.052883666,
0.0489825606,
-0.0356587544,
-0.0371896066,
0.000804958,
-0.0075590848,
0.0300135296,
0.0035702616,
0.0142629081,
0.0168747492,
-0.0067020352,
-0.0221196599,
0.0114222337,
-0.0796419308,
0.0436165109,
0.0243508182,
0.0075925104,
-0.0187682621,
-0.0584932491,
0.024566384,
-0.0193307642,
0.0133212125,
-0.0349093974,
0.0293707382,
-0.0612423643,
-0.0458255,
-0.0096425107,
-0.0509702079,
0.0223681349,
-0.0131310169,
-0.0009038455,
0.0251347069,
0.0423159115,
0.0104905143,
0.0464702845,
-0.0447752587,
0.0188101362,
-0.0026032187,
0.062634185,
0.0545909852,
0.0247374792,
-0.0064115645,
0.0055706026,
-0.0170632098,
0.0084721101,
0.0276786089,
-0.0190417729,
0.009380348,
0.0111995973,
0.0642427355,
0.0612080507,
0.0326927043,
0.0104077831,
-0.0870730206,
0.0837455466,
-0.0053678923,
0.0158509184,
0.0249800868,
0.0355193764,
-0.0187076647,
0.006960677,
-0.0630642027,
-0.063466236,
-0.0344438702,
-0.0007733854,
0.0061209085,
0.0538392328,
-0.0206844937,
-0.0027907665,
0.0492051393,
-0.0293027014,
0.0086863879,
0.0447186679,
-0.0223320965,
0.0045816647,
-0.021488402,
0.0545193553,
-0.0135953166,
-0.0196760725,
0.0145133948,
0.0197018757,
-0.0142071908,
-0.009966162,
0.0683725402,
0.0138316546,
-0.0538555533,
0.0142969675,
-0.0362425484,
-0.0156490505,
-0.0367652364,
0.0665948316,
0.0132868467,
-0.0053178365,
-0.0008219996,
0.0419899821,
0.017026037,
-0.0009615357,
-0.0244472288,
-0.0303115994,
0.0075233513,
0.0240740143,
-0.0253366884,
0.0176134203,
-0.0016637465,
-0.0025795717,
0.0756106377,
-0.0287791695,
-0.0164864138,
0.0023415061,
2.426e-7,
0.0521959104,
0.023225721,
0.0037860933,
-0.0070265313,
0.0089834277,
0.0406722911,
-0.0327634998,
0.0416980386,
0.0368046314,
0.0531671792,
0.019024808,
0.0323404893,
0.0900227055,
-0.0020440179,
-0.0678051189,
-0.0007389198,
-0.0281781815,
0.0259538572,
-0.0461485907,
-0.008629512,
0.0043390603,
0.103296198,
-0.0024026432,
-0.0176806822,
-0.0184752513,
-0.0480558537,
0.1148361936,
-0.0459009334,
-0.0442101434,
0.0189423468,
0.0233853851,
0.030210346,
-0.0608092509,
-0.0109588373,
-0.0372608043,
0.0451458916,
0.0636172295,
0.1018511355,
-0.0181196611,
0.0222842023,
0.019444311,
-0.0147493826,
-0.0171460491,
-0.0262114871,
0.0520131625,
-0.0120989308,
0.0007084483,
-0.0507883355,
-0.0040422077,
0.0242108703,
0.0443382971,
-0.0317682847,
-0.0542798676,
0.0262217838,
0.0459101535,
-0.0080594802,
-0.02142407,
-0.0587731227,
-0.0664269999,
-0.0168626998,
-0.0080481088,
-0.0311233699,
-0.0176655296,
0.0047491598,
-0.0062422431,
-0.0829364508,
0.0090894066,
2.538333803e-34,
0.0623185933,
-0.0049335686,
-0.0171258897,
-0.0295180213,
0.0257919896,
-0.0362179205,
-0.0382138863,
-0.0019840531,
-0.009703272,
-0.0853968486,
-0.0131531414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12300v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12300v2 | Measuring Pointwise $\mathcal{V}$-Usable Information In-Context-ly | 2023-10-18T20:07:41 | 2023-12-08T14:20:55 | Sheng Lu, Shan Chen, Yingya Li, Danielle Bitterman, Guergana Savova, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) is a new learning paradigm that has gained
popularity along with the development of large language models. In this work,
we adapt a recently proposed hardness metric, pointwise $\mathcal{V}$-usable
information (PVI), to an in-context version (in-context PVI). Compared to the
original PVI, in-context PVI is more efficient in that it requires only a few
exemplars and does not require fine-tuning. We conducted a comprehensive
empirical analysis to evaluate the reliability of in-context PVI. Our findings
indicate that in-context PVI estimates exhibit similar characteristics to the
original PVI. Specific to the in-context setting, we show that in-context PVI
estimates remain consistent across different exemplar selections and numbers of
shots. The variance of in-context PVI estimates across different exemplar
selections is insignificant, which suggests that in-context PVI are stable.
Furthermore, we demonstrate how in-context PVI can be employed to identify
challenging instances. Our work highlights the potential of in-context PVI and
provides new insights into the capabilities of ICL. | [
-0.0099678151,
0.0425911509,
-0.0115348697,
0.0373575315,
-0.0508242883,
0.0277420059,
0.0297945905,
0.0154419206,
-0.0333325006,
-0.0353425629,
-0.0173479654,
-0.0413392596,
0.015847994,
0.0059266039,
0.0174883176,
-0.0173178073,
0.0261041485,
-0.0220677201,
0.0262326822,
-0.0033634743,
-0.0457983203,
-0.0125498874,
-0.012839796,
0.0477253422,
0.0038852298,
-0.0349514447,
0.0234180037,
-0.0012246562,
0.0154650686,
-0.0450368896,
0.0244906619,
0.0556071773,
0.0220970642,
0.0610643066,
0.0000023195,
-0.0518442169,
-0.0323795862,
-0.0080968374,
-0.0622750223,
0.0380789638,
0.0160520989,
-0.0418708771,
-0.0072469763,
-0.0195715949,
-0.0211538095,
-0.0128832413,
0.0535561927,
0.0030717929,
-0.0176498815,
0.0381991193,
-0.0087274443,
0.0038971279,
0.0125979185,
-0.0217658039,
0.0254717488,
-0.0779574886,
0.0165263973,
-0.0159514621,
0.0145567041,
-0.018009482,
-0.0308567248,
0.0502303764,
0.0367492363,
0.0425724834,
-0.0110821817,
0.0468500964,
-0.0223235376,
0.0190070197,
0.0128896935,
0.0744885132,
-0.0306186378,
-0.019356234,
-0.0380893722,
-0.0634547248,
0.0085589681,
0.0270176698,
-0.0446691439,
-0.0295890979,
-0.0084595745,
0.01012892,
0.0259544123,
0.0253215227,
0.0536933579,
-0.0103961118,
-0.0124650309,
0.0121034756,
0.0107837189,
-0.0160347931,
0.0321232267,
0.001266101,
-0.0949005261,
-0.0014732846,
-0.0631077588,
-0.0240198206,
-0.0624341555,
0.0280442908,
-0.0557359084,
-0.0189758148,
-0.0046013752,
-0.0468227156,
0.0546208583,
0.0013464993,
-0.0062220092,
0.0664867908,
0.0174388364,
0.0404183678,
0.0129483091,
-0.0118053481,
0.0045683412,
-0.0026755426,
-0.0294309948,
0.0334914587,
-0.0354697704,
0.0040831142,
0.0044882293,
-0.0139987404,
-0.0311498605,
0.0182815697,
-0.0605437942,
0.0132883275,
-0.0299902,
-0.0607258864,
-0.0241288226,
0.0159183666,
0.0261391643,
0.0023417743,
-0.0253960416,
0.0138441799,
-0.0456968956,
-0.0453653559,
-0.0040264851,
-0.0039127967,
0.0272477083,
-0.0251729358,
0.0062326835,
0.0598391779,
0.0051505063,
-0.0940206423,
-0.0382851474,
-0.0071624098,
-0.0542337038,
-0.0555179752,
-0.0204764437,
-0.084205091,
-0.0061576637,
0.0101916548,
0.0092732701,
-0.0557829738,
-0.0269445311,
0.0003737886,
-0.0264943521,
0.0597396381,
0.0291193575,
0.0043773851,
-0.0216721706,
0.0126802698,
0.0050500883,
0.1007763147,
0.0074204868,
-0.0181647278,
0.064923577,
0.0141941495,
0.0095427064,
0.044386927,
0.0467934273,
0.0489861071,
-0.0422953144,
-0.0054907096,
0.0554368161,
-0.022540696,
-0.0240857955,
0.0130673032,
-0.0397187956,
-0.0200252626,
0.0511853136,
0.0173504036,
0.0507374629,
-0.0295259673,
0.0269038789,
0.019676229,
-0.0049718721,
0.0089394469,
-0.035983704,
0.0162900165,
-0.0471757986,
0.0130612887,
0.013049677,
-0.0206404757,
-0.0363341607,
-0.0567121692,
-0.0215032399,
-0.0031790959,
-0.0071868454,
0.0234828629,
0.0731897429,
-0.0032617659,
-0.04163168,
0.0165068749,
0.0457351133,
-0.0274956208,
-0.028522687,
-0.03024818,
0.0608334355,
0.0238217022,
0.0718054399,
-0.0634773895,
0.024497021,
0.0106798094,
0.0126600247,
0.0224010907,
0.0156838652,
-0.0258472003,
0.0625248998,
-0.0122764492,
-0.0386638716,
-0.0076537617,
0.035759408,
0.0047906782,
0.0295603331,
0.0043148925,
-0.0083293393,
-0.0470449887,
-0.0141694993,
0.0105267446,
-0.0261927508,
-0.0394035131,
0.0125068007,
0.032129284,
0.0130049195,
0.0058740759,
-0.022064101,
0.0001169784,
0.0202170536,
-0.0422803685,
0.0376805477,
0.0028104985,
-0.0508331582,
-0.0437678844,
0.000804839,
-0.0337734297,
-0.0015501336,
-0.0245369244,
-0.0299865697,
-0.0001948343,
0.0091515351,
-0.0394111909,
0.050111495,
0.0024492494,
0.0388235524,
-0.0319545791,
0.0342950411,
-0.0414137952,
0.0976378396,
-0.0324231535,
0.0324441195,
0.0181099679,
0.0103720147,
-0.0136035588,
-0.0220874958,
-0.0545806438,
0.0071429438,
-0.0150988903,
-0.0020545339,
0.028852148,
0.0175503381,
-0.029410148,
-0.0233355016,
-0.09904439,
-0.0309429653,
-0.0447128862,
-0.0121005708,
-0.0003438018,
0.011223834,
-0.012502389,
0.0049933256,
0.0008614321,
0.0012014274,
-0.0201815087,
0.0483357199,
0.0048492244,
0.0598311648,
-0.0241819154,
-0.0321582705,
-0.0400053374,
0.0003592458,
0.070186764,
-0.028472919,
-0.0188153349,
-0.0344200246,
0.0575975142,
0.0275756437,
0.0121079832,
-0.0293425582,
0.019906342,
0.0148645882,
-0.0094628548,
0.0102734305,
0.061249882,
-0.0204792097,
0.0439267084,
0.0275244415,
-0.028928142,
-0.0405629314,
0.021457281,
-0.0099252369,
-0.0348054804,
-0.0211608596,
-0.0148726013,
0.0475556068,
0.0453361943,
0.0077070924,
-0.016957486,
-0.0671514124,
0.0490299203,
-0.0435121283,
-0.0354821235,
-0.0555463135,
0.0200802218,
0.0121316016,
0.0191468764,
-0.0274390187,
-0.0583418682,
0.0393284261,
-0.0280220117,
0.0209259503,
-0.0089036925,
-0.0239162017,
-0.0219664928,
0.0394380987,
0.0192948524,
-0.0036908127,
0.0063919029,
-0.0063379384,
-0.0588387884,
0.0178569946,
0.0053015971,
-0.0109385131,
0.0898340344,
-0.079587236,
0.0144153778,
0.0090462985,
-0.0579410307,
-0.0257098079,
-0.0340202488,
0.0207118522,
0.0088130375,
-0.0221348647,
-0.0135227274,
0.0240694787,
-0.018267097,
0.0183886997,
0.0324565805,
0.0205395669,
-0.0345488824,
0.0021006681,
0.0200758949,
0.0462324396,
0.0070336428,
0.0226907134,
-0.0175714307,
0.0150561016,
0.0581858307,
0.0818117261,
0.0367159843,
0.0036841366,
0.0200692769,
0.0339938998,
-0.0127296392,
-0.046563074,
0.0619565472,
0.0490372293,
-0.0481588617,
-0.0582299009,
0.0911967233,
0.0148699824,
-0.0930897966,
0.0311005712,
0.0025628582,
0.0172690805,
0.0211033393,
0.0039876029,
-0.0698600411,
-0.0398720726,
-0.0037906012,
0.0281103663,
-0.0479763635,
-0.0479854718,
-0.0000180245,
-0.1328552961,
0.0342966467,
0.008669192,
-0.0371223465,
-0.0431726463,
-0.0457728542,
0.0373405032,
-0.0235476419,
0.04838356,
-0.0159977321,
-0.0259638131,
-0.0167018622,
0.0126092685,
-0.0100884391,
-0.0853915662,
0.0465637445,
-0.0167952683,
0.023561528,
0.0499178506,
0.01870168,
-0.0044276519,
-0.0312726386,
0.0295893773,
-0.0509790219,
-0.0209898893,
-0.0134366974,
0.050744541,
-0.021745842,
-0.0028838362,
0.0499616675,
0.0660498664,
0.0023187306,
-0.0265520029,
0.0141370511,
0.0650585815,
0.0171973724,
0.0403191335,
0.004228808,
-0.0424577966,
0.0400311947,
0.1036025807,
0.054027386,
-0.0598114878,
0.005944863,
-0.0188631807,
0.0154521223,
-0.0151162799,
-0.025555538,
0.0291728564,
0.0006447975,
-0.0290718414,
-0.0472847819,
-0.0085068475,
0.0390077755,
0.0768994987,
-0.0300284885,
0.0189756099,
-0.0555973351,
0.0103497291,
-0.0585669801,
-0.0211352762,
-0.0378732346,
0.04598739,
-0.059817981,
0.0075585693,
0.006747006,
-0.0011013681,
-0.028711481,
0.0311801136,
-0.059674304,
-0.0637699291,
0.0232737977,
0.0263552256,
0.0253711361,
0.0307414215,
-0.0107600121,
-0.0455672294,
0.1251919866,
0.0034136472,
0.0031804442,
0.0503561944,
0.0637075976,
0.0161507931,
0.0020030553,
0.0543506481,
-0.0581060201,
-0.0255431142,
0.0477428846,
0.0230673291,
-0.040350154,
-0.0081419125,
-0.0034687717,
-0.0366708562,
0.0525359698,
-0.0113689369,
-0.060668312,
-0.0234206729,
0.0260426253,
0.0185409561,
-0.004235452,
-0.033272896,
-0.0296837036,
0.0074643088,
0.005768049,
-0.0220482089,
0.01986688,
0.0225174818,
0.0225439202,
-0.0600614324,
0.008435566,
0.0344033316,
0.0323388763,
0.0139322244,
0.0028755385,
-0.0164573435,
0.0116376635,
-0.007161356,
0.0363794118,
-0.0111117419,
0.0764342993,
0.0006250372,
0.003945705,
-0.0151684005,
0.0237830449,
-0.0528612137,
0.0257064328,
-0.0187259316,
0.0399770066,
0.042317275,
-0.0434671454,
0.0389125496,
-0.0292241219,
0.0038499329,
-0.0479839183,
0.0060580522,
-0.0018172408,
-0.0556085147,
0.0201074015,
0.0390706584,
0.0059055029,
0.03428296,
0.1009043232,
0.0323228613,
0.0574069656,
-0.0305484552,
0.0328553319,
-0.0414652936,
-0.0164837111,
0.0189307965,
0.0608768277,
-0.0196793936,
0.0389188975,
-0.0864416957,
-0.056034483,
0.0034385759,
0.0099077774,
-0.0017427522,
0.0094788698,
-0.0075977426,
0.0831816718,
-0.0051716613,
-0.0031980381,
-0.02530054,
-0.0150645673,
0.0318147987,
-0.0065787453,
-0.030868018,
-6.421691843e-33,
-0.0321667492,
-0.0201546624,
-0.021520175,
0.0030541355,
0.0237215329,
0.0469649807,
-0.020853525,
0.0355332494,
-0.0180347878,
-0.0147335539,
-0.0043918649,
-0.0164821148,
-0.0046878597,
0.0187086072,
-0.0177842733,
-0.013857008,
0.0284922663,
0.0256257765,
-0.0332835577,
0.0183857102,
0.0575587824,
-0.0076163425,
0.0601186343,
-0.0610674992,
0.0224181693,
-0.0092095453,
0.0104075829,
0.0237548482,
-0.0081390366,
0.0616463348,
0.0044659465,
0.0352196507,
0.0370041803,
-0.0372038893,
-0.001943317,
-0.0112527451,
-0.0660776868,
-0.0380890258,
-0.0012374107,
0.0017045122,
-0.0125026247,
-0.0456774049,
0.0343147703,
-0.0026831185,
-0.0254391301,
-0.0317004882,
0.0235389601,
-0.0320232622,
-0.0330853947,
-0.0391492061,
-0.0456062369,
0.0217471253,
-0.0148534002,
0.0160006322,
0.0221709013,
0.0393885672,
0.0203572921,
0.0245878771,
-0.0794380978,
-0.0052051297,
-0.0160579514,
0.0444669351,
0.0639521182,
0.0145356879,
0.0290588215,
0.0626709089,
0.0148001695,
-0.0172003731,
0.0479635485,
-0.0737375915,
0.0772421136,
0.0343671702,
0.0168487895,
0.0920891464,
0.0633659139,
0.0094783083,
-0.0763330013,
0.0168745071,
0.0256374087,
0.0057891337,
0.0529967435,
0.0379441157,
-0.1009987518,
-0.0397103466,
-0.036663156,
-0.0260228943,
-0.0255920291,
-0.0132983783,
0.0315140747,
0.0174476579,
-0.0274753813,
-0.0171936676,
0.0627074391,
-0.0111697894,
-0.0148653993,
0.0538239814,
-0.0108987726,
0.0544770472,
-0.0099795302,
0.0164978411,
-0.0754168034,
-0.0203660149,
-0.0186195318,
-0.0114957644,
0.0404510126,
-0.0240249895,
0.0721910819,
0.0310249422,
-0.0692210495,
-0.0264520105,
-0.0338468552,
0.0180306509,
-0.0003386495,
0.029475864,
0.0654463693,
-0.0051271818,
-0.0060759033,
0.0154514555,
0.0196264628,
-0.0142771192,
-0.0084653413,
-0.0213023555,
-0.0415759198,
-0.025089819,
-0.009091503,
-0.0516273826,
-0.0000702406,
0.0201339889,
0.0536027141,
-0.0293665826,
-0.011252855,
0.0072741355,
2.902e-7,
0.020416528,
0.0051119076,
-0.0258977208,
0.0041152574,
0.0423576832,
0.0548254922,
-0.0173590612,
-0.0037469629,
-0.016371306,
-0.0181789175,
0.0244280603,
0.03191071,
0.0644752458,
0.0249926876,
-0.0608585179,
0.0277114231,
-0.0303449836,
0.0327373035,
-0.0350666195,
0.0105157821,
0.0199934207,
0.0892164707,
0.0348379947,
0.0147092976,
-0.0111584989,
-0.0506751426,
0.0467801392,
-0.0719490126,
-0.0059828609,
0.0130332811,
0.0031620788,
0.0357091315,
0.0202768855,
0.0226606559,
-0.017420182,
0.0338846408,
0.0029467477,
0.0125721246,
0.0202447809,
-0.0454019979,
-0.0110265557,
-0.0025335141,
-0.0113770934,
-0.0507158488,
0.0837977305,
-0.066250734,
-0.0315904953,
-0.0359673686,
0.0206366628,
-0.0055637294,
0.0176149867,
0.002154845,
-0.0318241119,
0.0036527815,
0.008186724,
-0.0232337769,
-0.0301740449,
-0.0693252087,
-0.0265177619,
0.0208285414,
-0.0120691564,
-0.0345445797,
-0.0498163067,
-0.0301071126,
0.0134532228,
-0.0575043075,
0.0250257086,
2.930943406e-34,
0.0354053155,
-0.0000836906,
0.0099686729,
0.0077711707,
0.0269890185,
-0.031770099,
-0.010728091,
-0.0042150225,
0.0353595987,
-0.0697804168,
0.01986669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12274v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12274v2 | An Image is Worth Multiple Words: Discovering Object Level Concepts using Multi-Concept Prompt Learning | 2023-10-18T19:18:19 | 2024-05-25T00:01:46 | Chen Jin, Ryutaro Tanno, Amrutha Saseendran, Tom Diethe, Philip Teare | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | Textural Inversion, a prompt learning method, learns a singular text
embedding for a new "word" to represent image style and appearance, allowing it
to be integrated into natural language sentences to generate novel synthesised
images. However, identifying multiple unknown object-level concepts within one
scene remains a complex challenge. While recent methods have resorted to
cropping or masking individual images to learn multiple concepts, these
techniques often require prior knowledge of new concepts and are
labour-intensive. To address this challenge, we introduce Multi-Concept Prompt
Learning (MCPL), where multiple unknown "words" are simultaneously learned from
a single sentence-image pair, without any imagery annotations. To enhance the
accuracy of word-concept correlation and refine attention mask boundaries, we
propose three regularisation techniques: Attention Masking, Prompts Contrastive
Loss, and Bind Adjective. Extensive quantitative comparisons with both
real-world categories and biomedical images demonstrate that our method can
learn new semantically disentangled concepts. Our approach emphasises learning
solely from textual embeddings, using less than 10% of the storage space
compared to others. The project page, code, and data are available at
https://astrazeneca.github.io/mcpl.github.io. | [
0.0163007043,
0.0887326375,
0.003923615,
0.0488122143,
-0.0396815203,
-0.0173338465,
0.001708176,
0.0068314574,
-0.016655419,
0.0057610362,
-0.0219477005,
-0.0176256597,
0.0200311113,
0.0710301101,
0.0465473495,
-0.0952995867,
0.0039583617,
0.0150388274,
-0.0260190293,
0.0017963768,
0.0423400588,
-0.0042578373,
0.0279013366,
0.0198475886,
-0.0173908491,
-0.0304294657,
-0.0138581209,
0.0167055782,
0.0259140376,
-0.0410773903,
-0.0198603421,
0.058694493,
0.0295125302,
-0.0059088129,
0.000002175,
-0.0238467027,
-0.0104745738,
0.0019481566,
0.016288057,
-0.0499808379,
0.0218784474,
-0.0432086177,
0.0420906693,
-0.0490646772,
-0.0125232851,
0.0066676443,
0.0779618621,
0.0648781881,
0.0556716397,
0.0379337594,
-0.0333630964,
-0.0322522409,
-0.0141726993,
-0.0339391753,
0.0422339216,
-0.0112450672,
0.0139591014,
-0.0509805046,
-0.0040974496,
0.0345631354,
-0.0538944639,
0.0198748857,
0.0315820426,
0.0166101009,
0.0637418851,
0.0625955462,
0.0287972055,
-0.0638652816,
-0.0241577309,
0.0965305269,
-0.0336452313,
0.0269852169,
-0.0471490547,
-0.0071903933,
0.001339216,
-0.0166956186,
-0.0413350798,
-0.0002166818,
-0.0160547309,
0.023782786,
-0.0496445373,
0.0260076616,
-0.0097671216,
-0.0115362136,
-0.0283283703,
-0.0189261697,
0.0224380326,
-0.0164460633,
-0.0146766054,
0.0205420554,
-0.0516771972,
-0.0151229315,
0.0152753172,
0.0095869955,
-0.0099984426,
0.0101778982,
-0.0380761065,
-0.0644118264,
0.0393625833,
0.0241309498,
0.0465329066,
-0.0283333771,
-0.0899285153,
0.0797808841,
-0.0194690693,
0.0365389735,
-0.0168475658,
0.0228902623,
-0.0552796982,
0.0082920315,
-0.0191174615,
-0.0239902772,
-0.039211154,
0.0167365428,
-0.0568303317,
-0.0441384763,
0.0211550929,
-0.0223028939,
-0.0350199342,
0.0200790856,
-0.0141265737,
0.0536536686,
-0.0598780327,
-0.0194187108,
-0.0168345571,
-0.0015463864,
-0.0067038857,
0.0172995161,
-0.001104124,
-0.0296751074,
-0.0163088981,
0.015403809,
0.0479012728,
-0.0181847252,
-0.012806735,
0.0415371992,
-0.068206653,
-0.0417451598,
0.0118741337,
-0.0459464565,
-0.0310651753,
-0.0200154185,
0.0080808112,
-0.0424892046,
0.043185737,
-0.0326603241,
0.006740158,
-0.0536758415,
0.0133506684,
0.0161704998,
-0.0313195065,
0.1186832488,
-0.0241927896,
-0.0529100969,
-0.0105059845,
0.0391893312,
-0.0001870233,
0.0435796827,
-0.0023538254,
0.0550721288,
-0.0030623924,
-0.0040930887,
-0.000414045,
-0.0088174976,
0.0109539023,
-0.0043428214,
-0.0481887683,
-0.027660653,
0.0106821582,
0.0484533347,
0.0158144739,
0.0497453883,
-0.0095909014,
0.0104849963,
0.0566528216,
0.0220729038,
-0.0010237843,
-0.0111513687,
0.0323423408,
0.0288520344,
-0.0281316023,
0.0127196964,
-0.0019996958,
0.0452378057,
-0.0002807443,
0.0088026179,
0.0146804359,
0.0313569792,
-0.0403896272,
-0.0128843291,
0.0454590358,
-0.0191539023,
0.00076301,
-0.0066479631,
0.0542918667,
0.0539268591,
-0.0375800431,
-0.0367479436,
0.0265390407,
-0.0102120582,
-0.0136625916,
-0.0209865067,
0.0411165878,
0.0529324524,
0.0140130408,
-0.034864191,
0.021373257,
-0.000465799,
0.0143249603,
0.080962956,
-0.0591616966,
0.0281421971,
0.0583885238,
-0.016540328,
-0.0244076177,
-0.0462545715,
-0.0096335448,
0.0150952395,
-0.0212102961,
0.0207457393,
-0.0199175999,
0.0392260291,
0.0449998826,
0.0420960039,
0.0261445716,
-0.0215464402,
-0.0073997704,
0.0372195989,
0.013031519,
-0.0167235304,
-0.0060753892,
0.0113487616,
0.022512218,
-0.0792167336,
-0.0314861834,
-0.0205999389,
-0.02797148,
-0.0931284428,
-0.0247681532,
-0.0699316412,
-0.0056043342,
-0.0010041289,
-0.0422923975,
-0.0456165038,
0.0248046257,
-0.0196820162,
0.0283400137,
-0.0034939945,
-0.0139389448,
0.033159934,
0.064190805,
-0.0276394021,
0.0448717885,
-0.0340115502,
0.0178285148,
-0.0065625412,
-0.0035799025,
-0.0155019369,
0.0221313238,
-0.0070857229,
-0.0183951184,
-0.0061439355,
0.0042460496,
0.0042529297,
0.0297839567,
-0.0546651706,
-0.0022734443,
-0.0240058322,
-0.0277846269,
0.0076253954,
-0.0549452715,
-0.0100543052,
0.0018750536,
0.0265865382,
-0.0554130599,
-0.0249110814,
-0.0019076749,
-0.0476067178,
0.0254727453,
0.0657411888,
0.0106068403,
0.0008990412,
-0.0120070148,
0.0098198587,
0.0359383151,
0.1062596962,
-0.0084841577,
-0.0539684854,
-0.037521556,
0.035622716,
-0.0128683727,
0.0200926978,
0.0038155697,
-0.0168999508,
0.0136747984,
-0.0223124381,
0.0704372302,
0.1056101546,
-0.0062157796,
0.0488160774,
0.0247954484,
0.0027325284,
-0.0200542584,
0.0108203571,
-0.0061875833,
-0.0129383998,
0.0663567409,
0.0019596498,
0.0104987584,
0.053693492,
0.0244836006,
0.0045115468,
-0.0439875312,
0.0217935592,
0.0426206775,
-0.0519938841,
-0.0968748629,
0.0368061699,
-0.0062407446,
0.0233350117,
-0.060519278,
-0.0650955364,
0.059560962,
0.0200279485,
-0.0153842214,
0.0023265404,
-0.0017316331,
0.0172415432,
0.0547293425,
0.0396108963,
0.0499189794,
0.0388232283,
0.0064896429,
-0.0379449204,
0.0062870746,
-0.008963747,
0.0103319725,
0.018437013,
-0.0300269388,
-0.0357493088,
-0.0020701699,
-0.0582969487,
-0.0212094057,
-0.0216721669,
0.0020582592,
-0.0118526649,
0.0226377528,
-0.0029950177,
-0.0264123213,
-0.0132975895,
0.0196031928,
0.0109421741,
0.0145351263,
-0.0171031021,
-0.0176203549,
0.0757824481,
0.0666791424,
0.0024691748,
-0.0334330648,
-0.03558328,
0.0461204387,
0.0654826984,
-0.0273658298,
-0.0129173957,
-0.0300699528,
0.0364503078,
0.0049486891,
0.0367739275,
-0.0004479779,
0.001837085,
0.0339608826,
-0.0487801954,
-0.0313640013,
0.0400818437,
0.0260562822,
-0.0540578812,
-0.0124641387,
0.0060123219,
0.033862967,
0.0193935186,
0.0104881981,
-0.0793042779,
-0.054318212,
-0.0295435451,
-0.0458106175,
-0.009039063,
0.00707094,
-0.0596046112,
-0.0430362076,
0.0241178982,
-0.0041991388,
-0.0656793416,
-0.0445729531,
-0.0393627509,
0.0014547056,
0.0237119664,
-0.0196520146,
-0.0019540475,
0.0560303405,
-0.0152150206,
-0.0252238307,
0.0176300555,
-0.019416282,
-0.0004971236,
-0.0166950747,
-0.0277280733,
0.0324560627,
0.0290280115,
-0.0163098387,
-0.071676746,
-0.0339792073,
-0.0418710634,
0.0161414854,
0.0118963132,
0.074589707,
0.0061788289,
-0.0304532573,
-0.0214768052,
0.0591389388,
-0.0143854059,
-0.0570385344,
-0.0351531319,
0.0588670261,
0.0028753486,
-0.0223466977,
-0.0774645954,
0.0137686133,
0.0261876006,
0.0323249549,
0.0299687646,
-0.0814239383,
-0.0190333985,
-0.0220029689,
0.0240834597,
-0.0201961622,
0.0132691422,
0.0049825273,
-0.0195784271,
0.0096617723,
-0.0570362583,
0.0365850069,
0.0508532301,
0.0440791249,
-0.0073046307,
-0.0151766753,
-0.0502202362,
-0.0114250993,
-0.0495700613,
0.0541221127,
0.0003543996,
0.0049478989,
-0.0305853058,
-0.0299523827,
0.0379209667,
-0.0408263057,
-0.037991561,
0.0343291983,
-0.0702436268,
-0.0044821436,
-0.011267107,
0.0408066809,
0.0035267062,
0.0286213607,
0.0032009673,
-0.0199550651,
0.0807251632,
0.0737935454,
-0.0196039658,
-0.0055033201,
0.0016873188,
0.0210599452,
-0.0046811341,
0.0163468402,
-0.023204688,
0.0400310084,
0.0264893956,
-0.0121128466,
0.0114843156,
-0.0305063445,
0.0297495816,
-0.0146438526,
0.0915753692,
-0.0412252992,
0.0293969773,
-0.0197907928,
-0.0169926677,
0.0334056988,
-0.0442328192,
-0.0558272973,
-0.0252677295,
0.0074163596,
0.0043483861,
-0.0269567929,
-0.0016671135,
0.0240739621,
0.0128279328,
-0.0323400646,
-0.0465830788,
0.0310024284,
0.0170656089,
0.0027793753,
0.0238896199,
0.0055196839,
0.0087222233,
-0.0668644831,
0.0074316356,
-0.0039128601,
0.0414361618,
0.0169718303,
-0.015288814,
-0.0671235621,
0.058864329,
-0.0217049681,
0.0193437561,
-0.0389419645,
0.0160299242,
0.0331691056,
-0.0080232183,
-0.0137307225,
0.0211069733,
-0.0347112566,
0.0007247949,
0.0533777885,
-0.0032851293,
-0.0695459023,
0.0733961761,
-0.0032723637,
0.0065224366,
0.0037062294,
0.0947783589,
-0.0209443551,
0.0210082345,
-0.0017841042,
-0.006055763,
-0.0538220555,
0.0348360687,
0.0581180267,
0.0257554315,
0.0269831214,
0.0606695637,
-0.0236984752,
-0.0298364051,
0.0321596898,
-0.0092927609,
-0.008674494,
0.0672900751,
0.0677124038,
0.0169752073,
0.0073447605,
-0.0408267193,
0.0025382584,
0.0168194752,
0.0386705808,
-0.0304150153,
0.0263161194,
-6.443816116e-33,
-0.0257241633,
-0.0304776449,
-0.0241309553,
0.0240609217,
-0.0035134878,
0.025393825,
-0.0425466262,
-0.0080432286,
0.0119606992,
0.0631307065,
0.0038707464,
-0.0248313025,
0.0008467073,
0.057089705,
0.0031087673,
0.0075789541,
0.0302325357,
0.027891418,
0.0159146879,
0.0422097854,
0.039360024,
0.0447026938,
0.064173229,
-0.0382124521,
-0.0233694669,
0.0356955789,
-0.042634923,
0.0051898141,
0.0310558155,
0.0240271073,
-0.0401341207,
0.0304084476,
-0.0004045199,
-0.0492348522,
-0.0462170094,
0.0241342932,
-0.0352191776,
-0.0552916117,
-0.0300767496,
-0.0164286811,
-0.1102240905,
-0.050696522,
0.0288727023,
-0.0287784468,
0.0526538938,
-0.039992474,
0.0615687408,
-0.0201872662,
-0.0167043563,
-0.0174628906,
-0.0454722531,
-0.0124935927,
-0.0177527498,
-0.0344743468,
0.0052536209,
0.0047618342,
0.007979502,
0.0589736141,
-0.0349540673,
0.0110045215,
0.0045949914,
0.0154276136,
0.0319617502,
0.0452774838,
-0.0017962356,
0.071843043,
0.0295555722,
-0.0522825085,
-0.0287924167,
0.0199561939,
-0.0080688754,
0.0822692588,
0.0573279038,
0.0592034534,
0.0603613853,
0.0238259342,
-0.0407099165,
0.0056496849,
-0.077249065,
0.0431201495,
0.0068097138,
0.0261707902,
0.0360055454,
-0.0080341119,
-0.0393728726,
-0.0331517123,
-0.0481792986,
0.011558204,
0.0179290604,
0.0193439219,
-0.0135507574,
-0.0101434644,
0.0269579124,
-0.011745126,
0.0074289623,
-0.0051869717,
-0.0148803126,
0.0559578128,
0.0058839126,
-0.004855115,
-0.0437872857,
-0.0265875086,
0.0839403719,
0.0097111398,
0.0081994627,
0.0414896309,
0.064650096,
-0.000560086,
-0.0509425327,
-0.0173012055,
-0.0401831977,
-0.0148601206,
-0.0068348078,
-0.0176503956,
0.0176519435,
0.002986358,
-0.0733844638,
0.042777054,
0.0067895278,
-0.0187445991,
-0.032314036,
-0.0391389467,
-0.0096388599,
0.0203382932,
-0.0177545808,
-0.0048578838,
-0.0456257984,
-0.0446979813,
0.0515982769,
-0.043775253,
-0.0216409322,
0.0160671752,
2.876e-7,
0.0129652768,
0.0174203217,
-0.0104089985,
-0.0102689033,
0.0190825015,
0.0392638594,
-0.0364260972,
0.0549428239,
-0.0658174828,
-0.0192535054,
0.0038927894,
0.0413110666,
0.0124160443,
-0.0258367248,
-0.0705912113,
0.0090673063,
-0.0209452566,
-0.0182988495,
-0.0567892492,
-0.041315183,
0.0714647174,
0.1060710698,
-0.0000216403,
-0.0173613485,
0.0723989755,
-0.0170887243,
0.0827234685,
-0.0386029109,
0.0330263227,
-0.0300366562,
0.0045434893,
0.0004883928,
0.0058150231,
0.0229093768,
0.0026444055,
-0.0379107557,
0.0704466477,
0.0316622816,
-0.0242031645,
0.0099229207,
-0.0012738982,
0.0522519611,
-0.0113052614,
-0.042578429,
0.0661367103,
-0.0567749776,
-0.0417222828,
-0.0344244353,
-0.024366457,
0.0176072605,
0.0705757886,
-0.0281392615,
-0.0425102264,
0.0047355108,
0.0288454331,
0.0230330266,
-0.036619585,
-0.075372301,
-0.0438572466,
0.022474343,
-0.0199000612,
0.0036378379,
-0.045046784,
-0.0148970038,
-0.0004271033,
-0.0687586814,
-0.0336037911,
2.5199628e-34,
0.0060489513,
-0.031044323,
0.0003163008,
0.028218545,
0.0307281502,
-0.0434786566,
-0.007672498,
-0.0031463827,
0.008781313,
-0.0497812778,
0.0068336367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12236v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12236v2 | Direct Neural Machine Translation with Task-level Mixture of Experts models | 2023-10-18T18:19:45 | 2024-05-19T17:49:15 | Isidora Chara Tourni, Subhajit Naskar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Direct neural machine translation (direct NMT) is a type of NMT system that
translates text between two non-English languages. Direct NMT systems often
face limitations due to the scarcity of parallel data between non-English
language pairs. Several approaches have been proposed to address this
limitation, such as multilingual NMT and pivot NMT (translation between two
languages via English). Task-level Mixture of expert models (Task-level MoE),
an inference-efficient variation of Transformer-based models, has shown
promising NMT performance for a large number of language pairs. In Task-level
MoE, different language groups can use different routing strategies to optimize
cross-lingual learning and inference speed. In this work, we examine Task-level
MoE's applicability in direct NMT and propose a series of high-performing
training and evaluation configurations, through which Task-level MoE-based
direct NMT systems outperform bilingual and pivot-based models for a large
number of low and high-resource direct pairs, and translation directions. Our
Task-level MoE with 16 experts outperforms bilingual NMT, Pivot NMT models for
7 language pairs, while pivot-based models still performed better in 9 pairs
and directions. | [
0.0162456837,
0.0151446974,
-0.0055945972,
0.0336324498,
-0.0444642417,
-0.0014836061,
0.0620334819,
-0.0138914436,
-0.0165213998,
-0.0086651985,
-0.0663028583,
-0.032856144,
0.0116757518,
-0.0344336107,
0.0315480009,
-0.0365076587,
0.0074910857,
-0.0215043463,
-0.0299044587,
-0.0034407943,
-0.0376044959,
0.0081635006,
0.0084542353,
0.0442570299,
0.0084342556,
0.0146820545,
0.0049776025,
0.0540387109,
0.0332136042,
0.0179174598,
0.020417707,
0.0476946235,
0.030628873,
0.0534755625,
0.0000020789,
0.0236658454,
-0.0208912194,
0.015261068,
0.0195242763,
-0.0194029529,
0.0333751626,
-0.0376672298,
-0.0066176392,
0.0395577326,
0.0013582255,
-0.0237634778,
0.068576321,
0.0362209752,
0.0384421721,
0.1208260059,
-0.0230278503,
-0.0190122426,
0.0263162106,
-0.0761866197,
-0.0110538155,
-0.0284613911,
-0.0234722476,
0.0296991039,
-0.078688927,
0.0377194844,
-0.0006153482,
0.0535819307,
0.0389783569,
0.0235023648,
-0.0450822227,
0.01382263,
0.0290443692,
-0.0223894771,
-0.0188010111,
0.0529184341,
-0.0713971481,
0.0262999926,
-0.0196762998,
-0.0010318771,
-0.0191191714,
0.018971853,
-0.0229727346,
0.0179770309,
-0.0195843317,
0.0169965979,
0.0349997878,
0.0691746697,
0.0387849621,
-0.009555026,
-0.0512461402,
0.0002741294,
0.0344016291,
-0.0204277094,
0.0070990892,
0.0149889523,
0.0163537264,
-0.0122573143,
0.0634936094,
-0.0326548219,
0.0013210302,
0.0101225805,
-0.0158412494,
-0.0720478296,
-0.0182418097,
-0.0569793284,
0.034239132,
0.0829369053,
-0.027487481,
0.046572309,
-0.0276203919,
0.0329095237,
-0.0582258366,
-0.0012120589,
-0.0602928661,
-0.0653141439,
-0.0195886828,
0.0295491237,
-0.0216870736,
-0.0326938555,
-0.0829509571,
0.0054307571,
-0.0337120108,
-0.0015402067,
0.0016406534,
-0.0154488068,
0.0578728765,
-0.0240965337,
-0.0790613368,
-0.0319367051,
-0.0018681246,
0.0945557356,
0.0118603054,
-0.008242297,
-0.0029963974,
-0.0429088064,
-0.012007338,
0.025667727,
-0.0427186973,
-0.0604296923,
0.009190606,
0.1265206188,
-0.049686227,
-0.0195173528,
-0.0206328649,
-0.0025694424,
-0.0053590583,
-0.0771178827,
0.0312883034,
-0.059085235,
0.1051217169,
0.0206601452,
0.0324122831,
-0.0305764508,
-0.0071053985,
0.0030230314,
-0.0252937265,
0.0353126936,
0.0429799706,
-0.0328125693,
0.053374093,
-0.0008360778,
-0.050046239,
0.0552370027,
0.0324351899,
0.041997239,
-0.0139692416,
0.0007905543,
-0.0293946136,
0.0410685241,
0.0048137,
0.0336582065,
-0.0111507755,
0.0018026266,
-0.017058963,
0.0351499729,
0.0309673622,
0.0717798099,
-0.0415760837,
0.0150637999,
0.0604715161,
-0.0095928786,
0.0550608449,
0.0593087301,
0.0885144398,
0.0234309044,
-0.0358113497,
-0.0089942915,
-0.0149886301,
0.041062858,
-0.0194318797,
-0.0272306204,
0.058233466,
0.084133856,
-0.0476136096,
-0.0336929262,
0.0268199239,
-0.0300062094,
-0.0046968213,
0.0054961359,
0.057682205,
-0.0176824331,
-0.0561595261,
0.0517234392,
0.014205724,
-0.0476215929,
0.0065077771,
-0.0242588036,
-0.070083417,
0.0290457569,
-0.0084831025,
0.004326683,
-0.0527687073,
-0.0136725781,
-0.0348524675,
0.0464857258,
0.0438852198,
0.0373496413,
0.0189862847,
-0.0618623458,
0.0000682022,
-0.0006185929,
-0.0129022123,
0.0530849881,
-0.0021289082,
0.0367833748,
0.0558034852,
-0.0286217481,
-0.0561294146,
0.0034211052,
-0.0540652908,
0.0273169968,
0.0482756011,
0.0253903475,
-0.0001005036,
0.0119194575,
-0.0049689291,
-0.0175431371,
-0.0061912495,
-0.0386073068,
-0.0372354798,
0.0192980301,
-0.0855326876,
-0.0798800886,
0.0139391804,
-0.0404738821,
0.0043364125,
-0.0067279106,
-0.0337198339,
-0.0535638779,
-0.0178609341,
-0.0198767632,
-0.0348691419,
-0.0332634449,
0.0006472126,
0.0248755142,
-0.0082028052,
-0.0205718316,
0.0673809946,
-0.0142209772,
-0.0024335231,
0.0256529823,
-0.0396371372,
0.0322335064,
-0.0263375677,
0.0027531807,
0.0165832564,
0.0349349044,
0.0395141616,
0.0191247035,
0.0144941183,
0.0057457867,
-0.0696892291,
-0.0809237435,
0.0101157138,
-0.0262383688,
0.0180659667,
0.0266859457,
0.051331196,
0.0144727118,
0.0147388419,
-0.0531521849,
0.0100906389,
0.0000716686,
-0.0048592435,
-0.023350589,
0.0011606428,
0.0389521308,
0.0007108423,
-0.0276917536,
-0.0000085355,
0.0395243913,
-0.0159335248,
-0.0485500582,
-0.0740286335,
0.0097984429,
-0.0352444947,
0.0229744408,
-0.0219891388,
-0.0308037903,
-0.0074749049,
-0.0069400002,
0.1098591015,
0.0187044404,
-0.017333474,
-0.0364440791,
0.0212161727,
-0.027977895,
-0.0431804135,
0.0446021631,
-0.0050625666,
0.0142182326,
-0.0563255064,
-0.0481511243,
-0.0045510372,
0.0427918136,
0.0157380905,
-0.0249967929,
-0.0793928355,
-0.0091184927,
-0.0030060632,
-0.0007206208,
0.0179946627,
0.0372022875,
0.0309298206,
-0.0050953571,
-0.0191704612,
-0.0145959994,
0.066303812,
-0.0354833789,
-0.0214807186,
-0.0679215342,
-0.0237032771,
-0.0393952653,
0.0140004037,
-0.0267811362,
0.0468669906,
-0.0508868173,
-0.0284437668,
-0.0381762162,
0.0285591558,
0.0164244454,
-0.0149521977,
0.0436034165,
-0.0335564278,
-0.0140102571,
-0.0480166376,
-0.0263498724,
-0.0057870443,
0.0006329754,
-0.0031887763,
0.0345661938,
0.0320292749,
-0.0322754495,
-0.0528049171,
0.0309573822,
0.0454805642,
0.0826678798,
-0.0188387744,
0.0078851869,
-0.0159155931,
0.022954667,
-0.0327658392,
0.0192347579,
-0.0154133653,
-0.0912906975,
0.0068009696,
0.0016051247,
0.0055866581,
-0.0614233054,
-0.030756874,
-0.031151969,
0.0315131806,
0.0210476145,
-0.0318376161,
-0.015206798,
0.0495217256,
-0.0346872769,
0.0219444204,
0.079849273,
-0.0103126308,
-0.0849264413,
-0.0231449325,
0.0070269839,
-0.0047909692,
0.0067988946,
0.051891271,
-0.0516978689,
-0.0270783454,
-0.003486566,
0.0204136893,
0.0374220908,
0.0161185842,
-0.031034613,
-0.0538432077,
0.0095806234,
0.0228594821,
-0.0607733838,
-0.0556310154,
0.0021070493,
-0.0261593573,
-0.0383128971,
0.0460992754,
-0.0245498605,
0.042657122,
-0.0341635868,
0.0089601343,
0.0606115796,
-0.0555073693,
0.004861258,
-0.0551601686,
0.0108680166,
0.0069211167,
0.0103883967,
-0.0011306956,
-0.0232366361,
0.0268379822,
0.0055055358,
0.0245955754,
-0.0098621296,
0.0011313685,
-0.0259931218,
-0.0098156258,
0.0146347657,
-0.0119124427,
-0.0172196832,
0.0530870892,
0.0097576845,
0.0795408413,
-0.0358119607,
0.0192274004,
0.0253642201,
-0.0176964514,
0.0232502948,
0.0371993892,
-0.0161212981,
-0.0456406064,
0.024691239,
-0.0042897244,
-0.0189998411,
-0.0269914828,
-0.016625559,
0.0126923556,
-0.0348278694,
-0.0468934365,
-0.0579895563,
-0.0248137098,
0.0061127492,
0.0587459542,
0.0230256841,
-0.0090671852,
0.0419266485,
-0.0079829814,
0.0052493741,
0.0387451835,
-0.0329267904,
0.0168862548,
-0.052398853,
-0.0043887892,
0.0252422076,
-0.0225897618,
0.0205608141,
0.0290601626,
-0.0869218633,
-0.0799443722,
-0.047776293,
0.0587612651,
0.0105080893,
0.0192485843,
-0.0102428962,
-0.0213185865,
0.00619586,
0.0104302242,
-0.0433603339,
-0.0291918647,
0.0273428932,
-0.0065458724,
-0.0221741349,
0.0266138557,
-0.0033036377,
0.0184521805,
0.0181208793,
0.04402031,
-0.0107269026,
-0.0395172574,
0.0085621262,
-0.0190826431,
0.0470849276,
-0.0101444246,
-0.0056225923,
-0.0390657969,
0.0330113433,
-0.0439928062,
-0.0106446827,
-0.0524527058,
-0.013287575,
0.0457551964,
0.013784091,
0.0215716325,
0.0188744105,
0.0258188341,
-0.0494414307,
-0.031182453,
0.0027396705,
-0.0391077362,
-0.0014570178,
-0.0074357647,
0.0113273803,
-0.0163470991,
-0.0180315934,
0.0213148817,
0.0263291672,
-0.0496717542,
0.0756143257,
0.0113386558,
0.0009843574,
-0.0179364085,
0.04559239,
-0.0182152931,
-0.0515083149,
0.0011684262,
0.0076381499,
0.100129135,
0.011582166,
0.0780074,
-0.0240172856,
0.0034303879,
-0.0082333991,
0.0258853585,
0.0263388231,
0.0240374431,
-0.0052479152,
-0.0094078379,
0.0262807552,
0.0091420216,
0.0646907389,
-0.0021961217,
-0.0234069135,
-0.0035822592,
-0.020752972,
-0.0242402554,
0.0167494211,
0.0205104686,
-0.0376159959,
-0.0148162236,
-0.0256447401,
-0.0170534123,
-0.0283594001,
-0.0120136971,
-0.0016421166,
-0.003700413,
-0.0191005282,
0.0113673415,
0.077475138,
-0.0395443067,
-0.0359995253,
-0.0327991061,
0.0176781248,
0.0234925542,
-0.0010705817,
-0.0395579711,
-6.542916167e-33,
-0.0033795594,
0.007494288,
0.0304211471,
-0.0597434156,
-0.0347742029,
0.0025143975,
-0.0172230117,
-0.0184418596,
-0.022812916,
0.0006540388,
-0.0129094385,
0.0270364955,
0.0279138815,
0.0103906468,
-0.0095494539,
0.0374554954,
0.0585365072,
0.0006058295,
-0.0245108306,
0.0363090299,
0.0268246271,
0.0142568834,
0.116032809,
-0.0872506574,
0.0114950575,
0.0024212706,
0.0191878993,
0.0174942277,
-0.0184754692,
-0.0235639848,
0.0099569457,
0.0211116634,
0.0100559359,
-0.0656621456,
-0.0109122787,
-0.0424009115,
-0.0673519522,
0.0022657521,
0.0030754525,
0.0030543471,
-0.0365335904,
-0.0428424738,
0.0637416467,
-0.0114578959,
0.0259409323,
-0.0353406556,
0.0075359754,
-0.0166461058,
-0.005968798,
0.0025528977,
-0.0378945433,
0.0397532135,
0.0113068856,
-0.0092410864,
0.0342462957,
0.0798701048,
0.0074869329,
-0.0387712829,
-0.0862693265,
-0.0064886087,
-0.0207804497,
0.0334078297,
0.0653233528,
0.0301713813,
-0.0135263437,
-0.0107570663,
0.0374220237,
0.0442730486,
0.0278644431,
0.015477838,
0.0177673418,
0.0296729207,
0.0777716935,
0.0101682264,
0.0053193774,
0.0168562271,
-0.0674865171,
0.0439302921,
-0.0009609399,
-0.0100968601,
0.0438849144,
0.0105914734,
-0.033890292,
-0.0091944449,
-0.0054104789,
-0.0332420059,
-0.014897869,
-0.0389332473,
-0.0316087678,
0.0245195981,
0.002559046,
-0.0235583019,
0.0904136449,
0.0102184396,
0.0473161153,
-0.0144221876,
-0.0182573516,
-0.0054109502,
-0.0269324724,
0.0528458655,
-0.0362940468,
-0.0575696155,
0.0208052285,
0.0326922499,
-0.0044942172,
-0.0018502031,
0.0209405739,
0.0291410293,
-0.0281789023,
0.0028734971,
-0.037512619,
0.003808938,
-0.0115144858,
0.0840275288,
0.0281497538,
0.0112395892,
-0.0122924251,
0.0123714963,
0.0299436599,
-0.0203995574,
-0.011895326,
0.0226981491,
0.0335747525,
0.0253698733,
-0.0338380784,
0.03602596,
-0.0359180123,
-0.0187396053,
0.0224066284,
-0.0338556021,
-0.0372742414,
0.0229303762,
2.887e-7,
0.0454407148,
0.0423512161,
0.0087264962,
0.009278561,
0.0034040168,
0.0252773613,
-0.0077480241,
0.0091216899,
0.0244465433,
0.0440344848,
0.0515918471,
0.0157505777,
0.0737807825,
0.0519788228,
-0.0873636082,
-0.0493339151,
-0.0171220303,
0.0328035578,
-0.0370854288,
0.0195938013,
0.0490935892,
0.0808362067,
-0.0052820547,
0.0019252112,
-0.0002242438,
-0.0193813033,
0.0884558856,
0.0001999011,
-0.0203618165,
0.0044733528,
0.0581093244,
0.031784527,
-0.050247658,
0.0229364075,
-0.0074839629,
0.0288905315,
0.0320587382,
0.0816638321,
-0.00485131,
-0.0049092281,
0.0411252044,
0.0109854359,
-0.0356097072,
-0.0296536647,
0.0240015611,
-0.0768441185,
-0.0168122295,
0.0454140566,
-0.0034356329,
0.0269528031,
0.0351071842,
-0.0088775009,
-0.0573649257,
0.0261541083,
0.0431411304,
-0.0099965213,
-0.0107417041,
-0.024329586,
-0.0241529495,
-0.0001118804,
-0.045369491,
-0.0379408859,
-0.0194060076,
-0.0289518572,
0.0088883238,
0.0098389061,
-0.0031266182,
2.614687441e-34,
0.0233255327,
-0.0108196922,
0.0045310482,
-0.0321775563,
0.019536851,
-0.0258711465,
-0.0616073273,
-0.0263494328,
-0.0120515395,
-0.0539548025,
-0.0689160153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12150v1 | Understanding Retrieval Augmentation for Long-Form Question Answering | 2023-10-18T17:59:10 | 2023-10-18T17:59:10 | Hung-Ting Chen, Fangyuan Xu, Shane Arora, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a study of retrieval-augmented language models (LMs) on long-form
question answering. We analyze how retrieval augmentation impacts different
LMs, by comparing answers generated from models while using the same evidence
documents, and how differing quality of retrieval document set impacts the
answers generated from the same LM. We study various attributes of generated
answers (e.g., fluency, length, variance) with an emphasis on the attribution
of generated long-form answers to in-context evidence documents. We collect
human annotations of answer attribution and evaluate methods for automatically
judging attribution. Our study provides new insights on how retrieval
augmentation impacts long, knowledge-rich text generation of LMs. We further
identify attribution patterns for long text generation and analyze the main
culprits of attribution errors. Together, our analysis reveals how retrieval
augmentation impacts long knowledge-rich text generation and provide directions
for future work. | [
0.058880128,
0.0052515748,
-0.0206820071,
0.0386879332,
-0.004186085,
-0.0193249602,
0.0004923863,
-0.0108927693,
-0.0191558059,
-0.0577986129,
-0.003080501,
-0.0137663009,
0.0034206908,
-0.0045935074,
0.0496890247,
-0.0210254174,
0.0076368651,
-0.0196765605,
0.0345707797,
0.0132632647,
0.0345603265,
-0.0066458671,
0.0304646119,
0.0316286273,
-0.0062379977,
-0.0061713834,
0.0084627531,
-0.0123866461,
-0.0032720764,
-0.0194967017,
0.0404528975,
0.0531750731,
0.0176427383,
0.0291138943,
0.0000016827,
-0.0329305716,
0.0249023791,
0.0100581674,
-0.0395558663,
0.043967329,
0.0083439602,
0.0478186905,
0.0503634103,
0.0240799394,
-0.0410936698,
0.0025703313,
0.0075544235,
0.0326624922,
0.0471270755,
0.0309880469,
0.0116214762,
0.005982792,
0.0484177358,
-0.028804658,
0.0637328923,
-0.0133979451,
0.0112530785,
0.0209733713,
0.0261354875,
0.0711442828,
0.0076625342,
0.0427261069,
0.0090668891,
-0.0078435652,
0.0608344935,
0.0085151345,
-0.0180726182,
0.0234755296,
0.0424169302,
0.0608784854,
0.0854376927,
-0.0390260704,
-0.0015149855,
0.0271783043,
0.0230913814,
0.0518988147,
-0.0680655986,
0.0433260836,
-0.0010157557,
-0.033304695,
-0.0031327731,
-0.0167426392,
0.0280827004,
0.0244678278,
0.0235957149,
0.0569679551,
0.0071509224,
-0.0580292046,
-0.0482062139,
0.0059785494,
-0.0304402485,
-0.0751443803,
-0.0034363274,
0.0493907519,
0.0183265097,
0.0143466424,
0.0006659281,
-0.0447555669,
0.0862213969,
-0.0342261754,
-0.0048903823,
0.0006195292,
-0.0383628346,
0.0259057581,
-0.0628349409,
0.0406589247,
-0.0188886747,
-0.0345307998,
-0.061660748,
-0.0064686136,
-0.0489331335,
-0.0629949942,
-0.0288025048,
0.0167258587,
-0.0031586746,
-0.0177691896,
-0.0384648032,
0.0123764025,
0.0035835679,
-0.0307962373,
-0.0148359137,
0.0430107787,
-0.0123481443,
0.0099109411,
-0.0621875674,
0.0520028062,
-0.0742407888,
0.0535226278,
0.0471810326,
-0.0561575219,
-0.0065531158,
0.0327674188,
0.0174877159,
-0.0419100896,
0.0201032143,
0.0176150128,
-0.017491404,
-0.0282538999,
-0.0057946909,
-0.0883680284,
-0.0284317713,
-0.0270955358,
-0.0058592414,
-0.0675884634,
0.0275225285,
0.0360321291,
-0.0414537638,
-0.0026354806,
0.002098413,
0.0511404648,
-0.0379640535,
0.0120234992,
-0.0375737362,
0.0312342104,
0.0850616917,
0.0140987914,
0.015289207,
0.0104935151,
0.0287770014,
0.0269715581,
0.0366022363,
0.0052102855,
0.0558178239,
0.0003670981,
0.0344835371,
0.0105738007,
0.0191302001,
0.0619386211,
-0.0169823002,
0.0043310309,
0.0197876524,
0.0359527916,
-0.0406640731,
0.0004380454,
0.0527777448,
0.0475455895,
0.0177028365,
-0.0078920042,
0.0075390567,
-0.0172567032,
0.0188288558,
0.0101664755,
-0.0123126479,
0.0444521941,
-0.0375222899,
0.0197641533,
0.0400445201,
0.0173828099,
-0.0189116895,
-0.0386312641,
-0.0180702768,
0.0099984808,
0.0278118029,
0.0244325809,
0.0039839726,
0.014979627,
0.0048813815,
0.0592117198,
-0.0403070301,
-0.0700664446,
0.0299699437,
-0.0468645841,
0.0472393893,
0.0490620844,
0.0469601862,
-0.0276917536,
-0.0183620341,
-0.0219920166,
0.0388160087,
0.0180949941,
0.0309482329,
0.0123831192,
-0.0346886851,
-0.034088999,
-0.0193750169,
-0.0272079781,
0.013202915,
-0.0197487138,
0.0428101048,
0.0133886551,
0.0647066534,
-0.0687159225,
-0.026325047,
0.0161135979,
-0.0249520857,
-0.0317896195,
-0.0219242852,
-0.0099527799,
-0.0033378452,
0.0239639655,
-0.0070306435,
0.0576850511,
0.017619947,
-0.008847422,
-0.0356803983,
0.0027420358,
-0.0283246953,
-0.0078841718,
0.0142371617,
-0.0180716589,
0.0194497574,
-0.0359755494,
0.005981185,
-0.0621437319,
-0.0036080147,
-0.0762056038,
0.0174827334,
-0.0554660186,
0.003152776,
0.0071265763,
0.014959815,
-0.0544025637,
0.0720813125,
0.008013906,
0.0272587594,
0.0275168065,
-0.0015850314,
0.0355096757,
-0.0646990761,
-0.0128021175,
-0.0376412347,
-0.0127821434,
0.0204768125,
0.0727883801,
-0.0635852739,
-0.0520489588,
-0.017426081,
-0.0881271511,
0.010947071,
-0.0197897218,
0.011868434,
0.0114996992,
0.0181349274,
0.0027046471,
-0.0084893527,
-0.0885003656,
-0.0325780883,
0.0213228576,
0.0563440733,
0.0218645427,
0.0383606553,
0.0195231233,
-0.067820631,
-0.0258294046,
0.0005503927,
0.0089594731,
0.040985018,
0.0042520822,
-0.0648207366,
0.005524864,
-0.0637871996,
-0.0108228186,
-0.0139808105,
-0.0365892202,
-0.0017783436,
-0.0137486449,
0.0203600768,
0.0668956935,
0.0495885611,
-0.0313232839,
0.0321313813,
0.0074545252,
-0.0578047037,
0.0048986292,
-0.0415834747,
-0.0208535902,
0.0183127187,
-0.0505856872,
0.0196392164,
0.0274022296,
0.0062726401,
-0.0084082317,
-0.020625433,
-0.0078986082,
-0.0007637912,
-0.0230034478,
-0.0290245004,
-0.0481201261,
-0.0092937211,
0.051711496,
-0.0198484343,
-0.0595202595,
0.0463176407,
-0.0469452366,
0.0029857215,
-0.0054130922,
0.0092967609,
-0.050931152,
0.0499991775,
0.0088038286,
0.0076800794,
-0.0350941755,
0.0040686647,
-0.0165250376,
-0.0067884941,
0.0356293768,
-0.0651374906,
0.0387009084,
-0.0078042275,
0.0202394594,
-0.0063355598,
-0.0159414504,
-0.0268168449,
-0.0595507845,
-0.0017804727,
0.0047403132,
0.0060294205,
-0.0179372579,
-0.0103069255,
-0.01539547,
0.0875748992,
-0.0086458856,
-0.0456654876,
-0.0010216265,
-0.0057581021,
0.0501751639,
0.0793156028,
0.0248843618,
0.0271589719,
-0.0397673734,
-0.0213910267,
0.0415753014,
0.0164569281,
0.0030529303,
0.0091060167,
-0.0636180118,
0.0118719898,
-0.028150443,
-0.0605496056,
0.0192166269,
0.0732768625,
-0.082609646,
-0.0178190563,
0.0764628425,
0.0289641041,
-0.0140183689,
-0.022217676,
-0.0428092107,
0.0547031872,
0.0105774431,
0.0324405842,
-0.0832434073,
-0.0214093067,
-0.0091312863,
0.0455293991,
-0.011336836,
-0.0031038346,
0.0034646105,
-0.1093402803,
0.0111548677,
-0.0176748224,
-0.0305786803,
0.0093545094,
-0.0266076513,
-0.0013619962,
0.0334537067,
-0.029268425,
0.0371123478,
-0.0342455283,
0.0225164164,
0.0346468166,
-0.0247917306,
0.0013711104,
0.0255840942,
-0.0224790685,
0.0293263178,
0.0796279609,
0.0105548287,
-0.0072181229,
-0.0648405775,
0.0006207109,
-0.0283677597,
0.0607425049,
0.0130353319,
0.0573919266,
-0.015095613,
0.02385897,
-0.0326300897,
0.0390645489,
-0.0203970037,
0.002513851,
0.0512240641,
0.0585440136,
-0.0063010352,
0.0036512504,
-0.0504067838,
-0.0101477941,
0.005868841,
0.0998138636,
0.0212978013,
-0.0129195154,
-0.0482534133,
-0.0024776503,
0.0115915593,
-0.0288588721,
0.000926248,
0.0120826084,
-0.0014151449,
0.0348990634,
-0.087320447,
-0.0562278107,
0.0087429471,
-0.0093621453,
-0.0072403252,
0.063962616,
-0.0519520193,
0.00070008,
-0.028266238,
0.0458701067,
-0.0427145883,
0.0246208999,
-0.0357666053,
-0.0067554605,
-0.0060869665,
-0.0584122092,
0.0035548795,
0.0078487266,
-0.0544474721,
-0.0285481177,
-0.0087418882,
0.0364418924,
0.0236922745,
0.0237350911,
0.0096142851,
-0.0670771748,
0.0410818309,
0.0132960221,
-0.0329174586,
0.0187686794,
0.0020762058,
-0.0070789778,
-0.0162365921,
0.0118457414,
-0.0653590411,
0.0088366084,
-0.0079233637,
0.0211688168,
-0.0108439587,
-0.0583972633,
0.0058659534,
0.042234119,
-0.0056550428,
0.008980778,
0.0191339348,
-0.0029858982,
0.0011622343,
-0.0296211597,
0.0047973613,
-0.0105951605,
0.0184262693,
0.0174184181,
-0.0440712571,
0.0337926447,
0.0184297226,
0.0061500962,
0.0536453538,
-0.0550052486,
0.0275976919,
-0.0003790053,
-0.0191089958,
0.0160456654,
0.0014929677,
-0.0290246401,
-0.0205231737,
-0.0241395012,
0.0683808625,
-0.0096001467,
0.0674004182,
-0.0049889809,
-0.0115615046,
-0.008255979,
-0.0012876753,
-0.1087756976,
-0.0323819406,
-0.0137911895,
0.0047558104,
0.0122616636,
-0.0435562097,
0.0657187104,
-0.0106438035,
-0.0010496979,
-0.0238778964,
0.0109848604,
0.0146963978,
-0.0236584116,
0.025187429,
0.0313035138,
-0.0528589897,
0.0052793315,
0.0893635377,
0.0170531161,
0.0160958152,
-0.0305590965,
-0.0468043014,
-0.0141687347,
-0.023781212,
0.0082601188,
0.0302145928,
-0.0127169546,
-0.0094835311,
-0.0474225394,
-0.0554006808,
-0.0106969839,
-0.0137316352,
-0.0021474785,
-0.0383250266,
0.0250823349,
0.0744991228,
0.0093567362,
-0.0523637384,
-0.0572180375,
0.0466414541,
-0.073495321,
0.0351607464,
-0.0280300193,
-6.110995829e-33,
-0.0078287693,
-0.0365752317,
0.0238035303,
-0.0286553502,
-0.0349789783,
0.0153500633,
-0.0280386861,
0.0071793194,
-0.0277563203,
0.0163332745,
-0.0332990065,
0.00766268,
-0.0057735937,
0.03815341,
0.0317701846,
-0.02150416,
0.0210050456,
0.0071685272,
-0.0530771017,
0.0395618863,
0.0811756626,
-0.0143236276,
-0.0089394823,
-0.0379420295,
0.0688010752,
-0.0503564291,
0.0261466168,
0.0157200098,
-0.0194755904,
0.0933245793,
-0.0079150759,
0.0376070589,
0.053936556,
-0.0681392699,
-0.0205408502,
0.0614465624,
-0.0764453039,
-0.002279998,
0.0367899537,
-0.0376938097,
-0.0748237148,
-0.0523070209,
0.0529285111,
0.0046525295,
0.012596488,
-0.0205325838,
0.0603109784,
-0.0361919664,
-0.0108330175,
-0.028457528,
-0.0287944637,
0.0127331652,
0.0117328595,
-0.0208817888,
-0.0302970707,
0.050931517,
0.0051159933,
0.0316310152,
-0.0278021358,
0.0039533153,
0.0073278081,
0.0525365658,
0.0570404567,
0.0270904414,
0.009787553,
0.0421764478,
-0.0190043543,
0.0296638682,
-0.0571779311,
-0.0271593127,
-0.026011236,
0.0306634475,
0.0889061689,
0.06098371,
0.0269532781,
-0.0079156049,
-0.0248274412,
0.0202540737,
0.0030835466,
0.034078043,
0.0309317596,
-0.0192558523,
-0.0399463102,
-0.0301490445,
-0.0691424087,
0.0548682548,
-0.0502004772,
-0.0420157313,
0.0483137704,
0.0387219936,
-0.0299873296,
-0.0183338486,
0.0419236273,
-0.0131680211,
0.002533626,
0.0508996248,
-0.0376528502,
0.0080317436,
0.0065192012,
0.0132574001,
-0.0397146083,
0.0488427021,
0.0337221138,
-0.0005434913,
-0.0240532793,
0.0503720939,
0.0479544029,
-0.0124641592,
-0.0315080062,
-0.008403373,
-0.0260640886,
0.0073831421,
-0.0315683894,
-0.057021942,
0.0430658981,
0.0523912273,
-0.0034423501,
0.0299129374,
0.0077913268,
0.0356646366,
-0.0473187193,
-0.0671216995,
-0.0006810871,
-0.0019638645,
-0.0297286566,
0.0354923569,
-0.0239965171,
0.0241086949,
-0.0203826372,
-0.0380172171,
0.0112776281,
0.0237381253,
2.386e-7,
0.0485152863,
0.0374274217,
0.0401486494,
0.0011954722,
0.0412506908,
0.0138593027,
0.0251865052,
0.0004737972,
0.0461737737,
-0.0185288712,
-0.021313535,
0.0236782525,
0.0494479313,
0.0247455034,
-0.027139945,
-0.0299514718,
-0.092207633,
0.0208101347,
-0.0105318418,
-0.0187458415,
0.0614683777,
0.0455485806,
-0.0194113329,
-0.0073807146,
-0.0462678559,
-0.0696964413,
0.0659140572,
-0.0032431828,
-0.0121208364,
0.0266969204,
0.0771225542,
0.0279807001,
0.0278785825,
0.0217894986,
-0.0277407244,
-0.0065551954,
0.0187595244,
0.0355518945,
0.023613615,
-0.0456769578,
-0.0336433128,
-0.0488674939,
0.0289249569,
-0.0620280169,
0.0659499019,
-0.0298521109,
0.0074073006,
-0.0238071829,
-0.0406500734,
-0.0091221789,
-0.0197492577,
0.0029847145,
-0.0043958882,
0.0050735557,
-0.0075901221,
0.0258638989,
0.0081805121,
-0.0637551621,
-0.0411613137,
0.002655348,
-0.060405124,
-0.0477724895,
-0.0622896291,
0.0095867459,
-0.0171868932,
-0.0592077896,
-0.0135197276,
1.815843636e-34,
0.0138573283,
-0.0030956168,
0.027480023,
0.0004467548,
0.0397778265,
-0.0037138958,
0.0216736495,
0.0097247995,
0.038071461,
-0.1203973517,
-0.0208958779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12143v1 | Simple Mechanisms for Representing, Indexing and Manipulating Concepts | 2023-10-18T17:54:29 | 2023-10-18T17:54:29 | Yuanzhi Li, Raghu Meka, Rina Panigrahy, Kulin Shah | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Deep networks typically learn concepts via classifiers, which involves
setting up a model and training it via gradient descent to fit the
concept-labeled data. We will argue instead that learning a concept could be
done by looking at its moment statistics matrix to generate a concrete
representation or signature of that concept. These signatures can be used to
discover structure across the set of concepts and could recursively produce
higher-level concepts by learning this structure from those signatures. When
the concepts are `intersected', signatures of the concepts can be used to find
a common theme across a number of related `intersected' concepts. This process
could be used to keep a dictionary of concepts so that inputs could correctly
identify and be routed to the set of concepts involved in the (latent)
generation of the input. | [
-0.0339765474,
0.0071314881,
-0.0415418036,
0.0243110955,
-0.0599090792,
0.0157994386,
-0.0242996141,
-0.0080413446,
-0.0539956018,
-0.0211553033,
0.0012926415,
-0.0230459757,
-0.0043739057,
0.0760420263,
0.0054683606,
-0.0954038277,
0.0296496786,
0.0144328224,
-0.0377619639,
-0.0149426376,
-0.0324257202,
-0.0537571944,
-0.019195091,
0.018548917,
-0.0691855997,
-0.0364420041,
-0.0469310284,
-0.0649935231,
-0.010287811,
0.0072383294,
-0.0307883322,
0.0213299133,
0.0300751477,
0.0783224255,
0.0000019441,
-0.0053257341,
-0.0292595141,
-0.0228678808,
-0.0130756283,
-0.0169217773,
0.0118597019,
-0.0280583277,
0.0015914477,
-0.0553072393,
-0.0287884455,
-0.0354690403,
0.0460738279,
0.0868073553,
0.0072893146,
0.0007542742,
-0.0084826481,
-0.0549594499,
0.0602070093,
0.0056907334,
0.044845935,
0.02212191,
0.0096417321,
0.0235621165,
-0.02911794,
-0.0057446375,
-0.0311009884,
0.028014604,
0.0382201001,
0.0079032155,
0.0770635083,
0.0520729348,
0.0112437662,
-0.0206924956,
0.0146640902,
0.0459366925,
-0.0284242798,
-0.0025351532,
0.0038750158,
-0.0357501805,
0.003740262,
0.0063697584,
-0.0372173339,
0.0084514646,
0.007393972,
0.0146883782,
0.0249096993,
0.0271638073,
0.0502659753,
0.0193383116,
-0.0607083216,
0.0202163123,
0.0135951005,
0.0118529974,
-0.0025728249,
-0.0130522363,
0.0033972522,
-0.0274664629,
0.0019581008,
0.0208570175,
0.0432320982,
0.0097802831,
0.0133304065,
-0.0300771855,
-0.0092984242,
-0.0293001942,
0.0544062182,
0.0259513054,
-0.0141442511,
0.0338901579,
-0.0503341295,
0.029358115,
-0.0697829947,
-0.0019582724,
-0.0305339843,
0.0014789678,
-0.0683496967,
-0.0288978145,
-0.0379796848,
0.0975297019,
0.019977849,
-0.0226136949,
-0.0161877573,
0.0531760417,
-0.0285459124,
-0.0208339114,
-0.1116777658,
0.0080791283,
0.0024400363,
0.031693276,
-0.0484441482,
0.0042069471,
-0.0425184593,
0.0217690412,
0.0187934861,
-0.0310485084,
0.0442433544,
-0.0266193263,
0.0191102531,
0.0078693191,
0.0073289587,
-0.0061609186,
0.0165292192,
-0.008966513,
-0.0430212654,
-0.0897227898,
0.0055491393,
0.0049704663,
0.0406345986,
-0.0591199547,
0.0081270887,
-0.0037228903,
-0.0107157212,
-0.0507192798,
0.0069219433,
-0.0121831652,
-0.0246734228,
0.0809013024,
0.0241427179,
-0.0255109835,
0.0405296795,
0.0127536422,
0.0078315213,
0.0283946954,
0.0202964265,
0.0617210157,
0.0145898443,
-0.0043485551,
0.0052615572,
-0.041898787,
0.0141112274,
-0.0458037779,
-0.0168202128,
-0.0814711452,
0.0039582308,
0.0799897313,
-0.0328745879,
0.014282356,
-0.0318448655,
-0.0025858881,
0.0292169172,
0.0713493228,
0.0239066016,
0.0779889151,
0.0492551625,
-0.0544481128,
0.0043350868,
0.0352068469,
-0.0144848274,
0.0440035425,
-0.0076439772,
-0.0250673536,
-0.036895249,
-0.0345962234,
-0.0351230726,
-0.0289138574,
0.0480567813,
0.0221663173,
-0.0318122432,
-0.0277790893,
0.0573945008,
-0.0392916612,
0.0084551452,
0.0013751227,
-0.018392127,
0.0312368162,
0.0192294233,
-0.0366183184,
0.0122381216,
0.021786565,
-0.002073074,
-0.0354456455,
-0.0159716699,
0.0043467274,
-0.0055082422,
0.0101458915,
0.0218236744,
-0.0247327555,
-0.0173096769,
0.0091503533,
-0.0223346576,
0.0105766468,
0.0193511713,
0.0502296612,
-0.0392851159,
-0.0133589283,
0.0102930386,
-0.0227080062,
0.0122422017,
0.0217748154,
0.0587051138,
0.0017326315,
0.0388594791,
0.0129802134,
0.0387629382,
0.039523188,
0.0186894424,
0.028896369,
0.0312518664,
-0.0597976483,
-0.0560577475,
-0.0211332124,
-0.0345632806,
0.0524059944,
0.0422331877,
-0.057202857,
0.023237003,
0.007714564,
0.0142394798,
-0.0707313642,
0.0399028957,
-0.0400017165,
0.0350042321,
-0.0157391429,
-0.0326978564,
-0.0039978549,
0.0204102863,
0.0004333529,
0.0792967081,
0.0120278876,
0.0038445443,
-0.0472872593,
0.0121466555,
0.0352856629,
-0.0112194298,
0.0054336214,
-0.0061537102,
-0.0336175971,
0.0063225771,
0.0459965095,
-0.0541486144,
-0.0012143117,
-0.0063412022,
-0.0193827469,
0.0040905667,
0.0226759631,
-0.0352092274,
0.0034891858,
-0.0220019203,
0.0341895409,
0.0353697576,
-0.0161861703,
0.0525385961,
0.0082278186,
0.0164709967,
0.0326698869,
0.0354340598,
-0.0510393009,
-0.0063400939,
-0.0245001502,
-0.0567960925,
0.0444140993,
0.0224320497,
-0.0639360771,
0.0327613764,
0.0080776084,
-0.0398323126,
-0.0109121203,
-0.0272792391,
-0.0359527171,
0.0331162065,
-0.0509252548,
0.0147002619,
0.0330762491,
0.0032705064,
0.0735527202,
0.0399965011,
0.0137903513,
-0.03128995,
-0.0261628889,
-0.0599581003,
0.0365866274,
0.0288032349,
-0.0031168489,
-0.0193740334,
0.0497014113,
0.0573083833,
-0.0139175709,
-0.0431783497,
0.026866911,
-0.015111601,
-0.0382947326,
-0.0760011822,
0.0033400971,
-0.003501025,
0.0508531965,
-0.013040713,
-0.0228751469,
0.0532541759,
0.0540791713,
0.025790764,
0.0224696267,
-0.0256714337,
0.0149846068,
0.0786089078,
0.0178729594,
0.028497817,
0.0450544618,
-0.0306238811,
-0.0386620574,
0.0157551188,
0.0475554168,
-0.0224305131,
0.0298039243,
-0.0489140563,
-0.0034716944,
0.0205647629,
-0.0105456598,
-0.0631759167,
0.0610419698,
0.0383685939,
0.0695084408,
0.0332772434,
0.0133681027,
-0.0484381206,
-0.0003081363,
0.057840284,
0.0113218594,
0.014296988,
-0.0141773503,
-0.0343082659,
0.0074194865,
0.0161041114,
-0.0006319058,
0.0398967266,
0.0016129549,
0.0415880829,
0.0234071407,
0.0122414175,
-0.0012655318,
-0.0512061939,
0.0435301028,
-0.0072446121,
-0.0206623822,
-0.0298537295,
-0.0025357238,
-0.0498780683,
-0.0463029929,
-0.0027070104,
0.0507179946,
0.0188149884,
-0.0227964837,
0.0106205419,
-0.0103037609,
-0.0459836796,
0.0293409918,
0.0094492082,
-0.0939129889,
0.0382206924,
-0.016323939,
-0.0372385755,
-0.0345392302,
-0.055185847,
0.0147754094,
0.0031828268,
0.0139911463,
0.0096180979,
-0.0732375011,
-0.0835422203,
-0.0034320967,
-0.0372887924,
0.0296330787,
-0.0518914908,
-0.0085523259,
0.0251573827,
0.0011574635,
0.022421727,
-0.015339544,
-0.0159408096,
-0.0225609429,
-0.047353562,
-0.0392150059,
0.0482147262,
0.0251379907,
-0.0445050485,
-0.0119326469,
-0.024666829,
-0.1023421064,
0.0165932514,
-0.0229477566,
-0.0076230895,
0.0042846105,
-0.0151238535,
-0.0299456567,
0.0619355924,
-0.0340252854,
-0.0477626808,
-0.0587741025,
0.1108607799,
-0.0650571361,
-0.0174421072,
-0.0254088491,
-0.038052354,
0.0039427038,
0.0435724556,
0.0191195775,
0.0068623642,
0.0069068437,
0.003415999,
0.0519275442,
0.0053005391,
-0.0234827287,
-0.0049149795,
0.005632726,
0.0028802906,
-0.0612638369,
-0.0128868334,
0.0164602064,
0.0633790344,
0.001957661,
-0.0071498309,
-0.005834158,
-0.0351683758,
-0.0994129851,
-0.0050333696,
0.0081258025,
-0.0188740063,
-0.0097881053,
-0.0488691889,
0.0598644018,
-0.0096126301,
-0.0453052111,
-0.0257072225,
-0.0068699159,
-0.0385232493,
0.0390479118,
0.0115111377,
0.0180135705,
-0.0299511701,
0.0091690132,
-0.0195292793,
0.0896556303,
0.0071676872,
-0.0126608768,
-0.0017029368,
0.0094631594,
-0.0451975726,
0.0055964505,
0.0356436148,
-0.0432980172,
0.0709991753,
-0.0123571055,
0.0039613135,
-0.0798600167,
0.0036931939,
0.0576280914,
-0.0217474774,
0.0699002519,
0.0176744275,
-0.052474957,
-0.047709465,
-0.0327182263,
0.032267008,
-0.0090007167,
-0.0130717866,
-0.0210567974,
0.0505837426,
0.0351767428,
-0.0289984532,
0.0523075201,
0.032275416,
0.0362275243,
0.0354160964,
-0.005142062,
0.0029989136,
0.0055952501,
-0.0151276719,
0.0375301838,
-0.0042778975,
0.0262572654,
-0.0431544222,
0.0179528836,
-0.0275639687,
0.0076310481,
0.0568540432,
0.0362830572,
-0.0738069713,
-0.0119137242,
-0.0898173824,
-0.0711134449,
0.0039379811,
0.0018089028,
0.0693592355,
0.0318350643,
-0.0682707503,
-0.0742971972,
-0.0084088314,
-0.0045954837,
0.032051485,
0.0020763981,
-0.0139489807,
0.039326109,
0.0357320867,
0.0264428258,
-0.0262270104,
0.03417648,
-0.0914356485,
0.0578295179,
-0.0052087195,
0.0046566497,
-0.0122299278,
0.0251700543,
0.0392867811,
0.0491098128,
-0.0140613141,
0.0238973703,
-0.0260311272,
-0.0095400484,
0.0690457895,
0.0311850663,
0.0271382853,
0.0148430895,
0.0502182953,
0.0356764831,
0.0110962056,
-0.0001958544,
-0.0004479556,
0.0396728553,
-0.0319589972,
-0.0489779636,
0.0139420442,
-6.076600497e-33,
-0.0264209453,
-0.0208032206,
-0.0011712376,
0.0609868132,
-0.0169985313,
0.0201809406,
0.0052979449,
0.0076608923,
-0.0136816921,
0.0514305681,
0.0030104101,
0.0252789147,
-0.0003234314,
-0.0247858241,
0.0250840355,
-0.0171249006,
0.0190560538,
-0.0208874308,
0.0251086354,
0.0259355884,
0.0678197667,
0.0272522252,
0.0327261351,
-0.0662506446,
-0.0393887646,
0.0388386175,
0.0437202007,
0.0164410118,
0.0263906717,
0.0557864644,
-0.0483902209,
0.0221677069,
0.0320154727,
-0.0401644558,
0.0031457567,
0.0202739052,
-0.0481033213,
-0.0699370652,
-0.0213564038,
0.0246613994,
-0.0116890529,
-0.0671313256,
0.0695029795,
-0.0187223442,
0.0012670778,
0.0011418331,
0.0508070439,
-0.0345029123,
-0.0404902324,
-0.0447773598,
-0.0429158807,
-0.0081824977,
-0.0023727182,
0.0230648406,
0.0249849278,
-0.0455617271,
0.0251238309,
-0.036448542,
-0.0321687721,
0.0400648117,
0.0037531136,
0.0265323799,
0.0126564912,
0.0130821336,
0.0356273837,
0.0616770089,
0.053530395,
-0.0350574143,
0.0200714786,
0.0019204003,
0.0416094549,
0.0421848707,
0.0099753598,
0.0601878688,
0.0498583466,
0.0081291217,
-0.0668043941,
0.0113946544,
0.0430182442,
0.0285198465,
-0.0204267148,
0.0327029601,
-0.0049873739,
-0.0023103571,
-0.0300066024,
-0.0357130878,
-0.052405335,
-0.0295181237,
0.021178931,
-0.0069808713,
0.0015473487,
0.0484339595,
0.0147873014,
-0.0471059754,
-0.0055179712,
-0.010054565,
0.0396688432,
0.0578919612,
0.0097971344,
-0.0237731766,
-0.0272581298,
-0.0875678435,
-0.0124888178,
-0.0311327055,
0.0443013459,
0.0230066665,
-0.0137482546,
0.0321802795,
0.0130579891,
-0.0357039645,
-0.0039701713,
-0.0605884641,
-0.002043362,
-0.0521230325,
0.0371298455,
0.0060492046,
0.0037698876,
-0.0215573926,
0.0025822294,
0.0330858193,
-0.033248093,
-0.0414802618,
-0.0201997496,
0.0498406179,
-0.025132956,
-0.0275387913,
-0.0475627184,
-0.0178574976,
0.0916931257,
-0.0282241646,
-0.0236955695,
0.0054810783,
2.734e-7,
0.0007269639,
0.0326231681,
0.0221796464,
0.0280902889,
0.0502272137,
0.0147573538,
-0.0026023823,
0.007673603,
-0.0295558311,
-0.0728888735,
0.041190505,
0.0103357453,
-0.0352816842,
0.0258344114,
-0.0462038107,
-0.0058814506,
0.0659378394,
-0.005188799,
-0.0188903529,
0.0190142915,
0.0327997468,
0.0838720948,
0.0092095481,
-0.0108997654,
0.0189490765,
-0.0176416077,
0.0467894264,
-0.0341590568,
0.0564955659,
-0.0017353947,
0.0231155306,
-0.0118992822,
-0.0015962427,
0.0561711565,
0.013279737,
0.01895486,
0.0023360117,
-0.0196480528,
-0.0191491079,
0.0150928805,
-0.0311256479,
-0.0253408942,
-0.0075345836,
-0.0194766559,
0.0304842293,
-0.0660818443,
-0.0232538786,
-0.0195811819,
-0.0036139986,
0.0231864955,
-0.0251182504,
0.0317038968,
-0.0258835927,
-0.0130551942,
-0.0355917662,
0.0128980298,
0.026584534,
-0.041348774,
0.0811034441,
0.0792718381,
-0.0364211611,
-0.008684841,
-0.0409751646,
-0.0698078945,
0.0665181503,
-0.0018860966,
-0.0572512187,
2.212821509e-34,
-0.0152366525,
-0.010871212,
0.0205683652,
0.0534291118,
-0.0022617772,
-0.021859929,
-0.060860984,
0.0258170106,
0.043184936,
-0.0387084074,
-0.0243532676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12135v1 | Pseudointelligence: A Unifying Framework for Language Model Evaluation | 2023-10-18T17:48:05 | 2023-10-18T17:48:05 | Shikhar Murty, Orr Paradise, Pratyusha Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL | With large language models surpassing human performance on an increasing
number of benchmarks, we must take a principled approach for targeted
evaluation of model capabilities. Inspired by pseudorandomness, we propose
pseudointelligence, which captures the maxim that "(perceived) intelligence
lies in the eye of the beholder". That is, that claims of intelligence are
meaningful only when their evaluator is taken into account. Concretely, we
propose a complexity-theoretic framework of model evaluation cast as a dynamic
interaction between a model and a learned evaluator. We demonstrate that this
framework can be used to reason about two case studies in language model
evaluation, as well as analyze existing evaluation methods. | [
0.0074096457,
0.0668061897,
-0.0365924053,
0.0353470705,
-0.0322169252,
0.0322638266,
0.0129318237,
0.0091688214,
-0.0068836743,
-0.0442857631,
-0.0489709005,
-0.0332212262,
0.0020108228,
0.0144557795,
0.0479746573,
-0.0043780017,
0.0701319575,
-0.0592224225,
0.0619557016,
-0.0024223486,
-0.0329599939,
-0.0373905152,
0.0089088473,
0.0413158461,
0.0147102103,
-0.0052271252,
0.015243263,
-0.0331609212,
-0.0297544561,
0.0036462836,
-0.0255356822,
0.0378187746,
-0.0257287733,
0.0969911814,
0.0000017376,
-0.0291215181,
0.009100995,
0.017496394,
-0.0561139062,
0.0424249955,
0.0642171502,
0.0305425804,
-0.0256559681,
0.0136755239,
-0.0362008587,
-0.0127366027,
0.031504456,
0.0110579757,
0.0153911216,
0.047759898,
-0.005253362,
-0.0035111699,
0.0543192513,
-0.0202335548,
-0.0306767561,
-0.0462343246,
0.0056455308,
0.028072292,
-0.0092929844,
-0.0064373477,
0.0051515503,
0.0387685336,
0.0293858536,
-0.0220511109,
-0.0270096902,
0.0078937486,
0.0043659103,
-0.0222092289,
-0.0071658767,
0.0104187829,
-0.0250288788,
-0.0204905607,
-0.0313195772,
0.0094281323,
0.0142084975,
0.0202025622,
-0.0160712376,
0.0010409656,
0.0482192226,
0.0080574639,
0.0571000464,
0.0228648484,
0.0601665974,
-0.0015104659,
-0.0167449228,
0.1314004958,
0.018380018,
-0.0361679494,
-0.0184926074,
-0.0073745614,
-0.0184510313,
-0.0567301214,
-0.0464043319,
0.024811279,
-0.028474981,
0.0227571763,
0.0023259465,
-0.0099725183,
0.0051603941,
-0.0291245822,
0.0632271618,
-0.0059011225,
0.0307246,
0.0398649089,
-0.0103542153,
0.0817253962,
-0.0225975644,
0.0582319908,
-0.0256705582,
0.0126064643,
-0.056155391,
-0.0320945419,
-0.0169476625,
0.0180270169,
0.0084326603,
0.0050508711,
-0.0031784296,
0.0091407783,
-0.0316694826,
-0.017910732,
-0.0450998023,
-0.033377666,
-0.0174221098,
-0.0109374737,
-0.0413992405,
0.0023768102,
0.0109504024,
0.0103543177,
-0.0069678612,
-0.0539120585,
0.0234491974,
0.0128643718,
-0.0365254395,
-0.0218520612,
-0.0144939665,
0.0905625522,
0.0150051629,
-0.0277143773,
-0.0347008072,
-0.0086422749,
-0.0060113468,
-0.0691402331,
-0.0168594755,
-0.0447758697,
-0.0303519554,
0.000553888,
-0.0091625918,
-0.0707916319,
-0.0354238562,
-0.0190176181,
-0.0320554338,
0.0367916077,
-0.0309086274,
0.0183139052,
-0.0172059145,
0.0035773455,
0.0208744146,
0.0763391405,
0.0471636169,
-0.0323334448,
0.0325866491,
0.0050077694,
0.0562605672,
0.0522713028,
-0.0094125969,
0.0185502507,
-0.033486478,
-0.0133315856,
0.0186252873,
-0.0258811172,
-0.0130909523,
0.0902416855,
0.0091406005,
0.0125176255,
0.0375058167,
0.0195043944,
0.0113650672,
0.0389266796,
0.0767997876,
-0.004935157,
0.0087479539,
0.053361766,
-0.0538115762,
0.0137287918,
-0.0722909719,
0.0265133437,
-0.0122912759,
-0.0062503116,
-0.0063875481,
-0.0858716369,
-0.0314985216,
0.0310974289,
0.0424519181,
0.0201696139,
0.0619820803,
0.0013795923,
-0.0192402061,
-0.020758627,
0.0073901415,
-0.0500031896,
-0.0144013893,
-0.1023149565,
0.0291400719,
0.0656498596,
0.0340221189,
-0.01408643,
0.0029617979,
0.0058498858,
-0.0230766218,
0.0366959795,
0.0549527369,
-0.0526495464,
0.0046553216,
0.0006294069,
-0.02615886,
0.0036282549,
0.0564826392,
0.0123113533,
-0.0314714611,
-0.0003106607,
0.0087461974,
-0.0519201644,
-0.0717087239,
0.0364579707,
-0.0630249158,
-0.0082183359,
-0.0704772994,
-0.0007990406,
0.0348580219,
0.0015714727,
-0.0358450748,
0.0431155488,
0.0262507275,
-0.0246699061,
0.0020599409,
0.0155091966,
0.0218514837,
0.0095661404,
0.0400858521,
-0.0127190957,
0.0207010861,
0.0404870138,
0.0183799323,
-0.0347081013,
0.0766834542,
-0.052763164,
0.0745060965,
-0.0339394696,
0.0593170561,
-0.0993796289,
-0.002415292,
-0.0264988411,
0.0736039057,
-0.0252962857,
0.0660803244,
0.0354932956,
-0.0003994499,
0.0259289499,
-0.025296852,
-0.0436111577,
0.0298935715,
0.0042232089,
0.022711968,
0.0322835967,
0.0017552507,
-0.0152042219,
-0.0380030237,
-0.074042663,
-0.0176005699,
-0.0402017832,
0.0206203181,
0.0112112863,
-0.0152333202,
0.011660154,
0.0222191438,
-0.0240328908,
-0.0650169402,
0.0208742525,
0.0129316133,
0.0243431665,
0.0056196889,
-0.0641330108,
-0.0478221215,
-0.0362704508,
-0.0252923612,
0.080549635,
0.0234299544,
0.02575255,
-0.0404443815,
0.0047046663,
-0.0368324816,
0.0323348269,
-0.0147007378,
-0.036373876,
0.0442146733,
0.0025866167,
0.0056862896,
0.0465212613,
-0.0118275639,
0.0316967927,
0.048137024,
0.0204977337,
-0.0431847088,
-0.0021992915,
0.0204109419,
-0.0137020303,
-0.0343644544,
-0.0576815084,
-0.0159455296,
0.1014385968,
-0.0215938259,
-0.0490768291,
-0.0339167267,
0.0488032587,
-0.0728608817,
-0.0521295853,
0.0071021211,
-0.0176563412,
0.0007424911,
0.0648544654,
-0.0477931723,
-0.0706913993,
0.0666995123,
-0.0379377641,
-0.0025727206,
-0.0285649002,
-0.0211738478,
-0.0124552799,
0.0673544481,
-0.000327506,
0.0070957523,
0.0165758505,
-0.0000014002,
-0.0446209535,
-0.0059996867,
-0.0075029526,
-0.0304232556,
0.0182543434,
-0.0555588529,
0.0234767012,
0.0403970256,
-0.0020552713,
-0.030543983,
-0.0240929276,
-0.0361811519,
0.0322550386,
0.0331122577,
-0.0275409669,
-0.0064932881,
0.0104201995,
-0.0030539723,
0.0241930764,
0.0116448728,
-0.0132971741,
0.0005564971,
-0.0115855727,
0.0219731983,
-0.0070931129,
0.0641687065,
-0.0256485213,
0.0477831922,
0.0066360454,
0.0440435968,
0.0371562243,
-0.0468957759,
0.0269146673,
0.0267729238,
-0.0164326318,
-0.0423262343,
0.0335332043,
0.024020981,
-0.0467255749,
-0.0316951461,
0.1152554601,
0.0341591947,
0.0031801593,
0.0374307558,
-0.0143258758,
0.0246971194,
0.043703109,
0.0178779215,
-0.0124838436,
-0.003086366,
0.0135921277,
0.0021638058,
-0.0504319482,
-0.0369748548,
0.0015453567,
-0.0896241665,
0.0127902282,
0.0159264337,
-0.0387455411,
-0.0234489236,
-0.0038724348,
-0.0096783647,
-0.005016278,
0.0314097181,
0.0298146177,
0.012043667,
0.0104310848,
0.0168229509,
-0.0222752839,
-0.0718171597,
0.0456851721,
-0.0225612167,
0.055646129,
0.1018813327,
0.0249367617,
-0.032419499,
-0.0740332454,
0.023180699,
-0.0107357763,
-0.0082541918,
0.0271171946,
0.0118659241,
0.0107528418,
-0.0312650502,
-0.028346261,
-0.0128703751,
0.0007814806,
0.0174625162,
-0.0287798382,
0.0660900921,
-0.0052906391,
-0.0475168452,
-0.0106108459,
-0.0447631776,
-0.011204618,
0.0612625889,
0.0489608198,
-0.0395510346,
-0.029569,
-0.0424213298,
-0.0110559389,
-0.0282981656,
-0.0738678128,
0.0533128753,
0.0537125096,
-0.0456827842,
-0.0618915781,
-0.0235605743,
-0.009988348,
0.0371299498,
0.0206464194,
0.0000648119,
0.0032028346,
-0.0193313379,
-0.0332854427,
0.0117007252,
-0.0322660208,
0.0260335132,
-0.0610215664,
-0.0197730716,
0.0105451997,
-0.0041901683,
-0.0159696173,
0.021447571,
-0.0522042029,
-0.0715961754,
0.0053355573,
0.050107047,
0.0407491922,
0.0410210341,
-0.0518309325,
-0.0616279654,
0.0406467728,
-0.0418474264,
-0.0187788531,
0.0245801769,
0.0589569658,
-0.0587669723,
0.0152817843,
0.0633644238,
-0.0340039469,
0.0219296403,
0.0225320887,
0.0223580897,
-0.0276396163,
-0.0069624102,
0.0214008875,
0.0311604943,
0.0313498639,
-0.021260798,
-0.0155634005,
0.0103505393,
-0.0283015184,
-0.0257983208,
-0.0356871225,
-0.0596244968,
0.0059492458,
0.0282176491,
0.0383037925,
-0.004623665,
-0.0417081155,
-0.0218300875,
0.0119120087,
-0.005575648,
0.02720326,
-0.0287809074,
0.0267948043,
0.0055205543,
0.0118906237,
-0.0013194901,
0.0193468556,
-0.042802725,
0.0251860488,
0.019650491,
0.0157982763,
0.0035994845,
0.0102869719,
-0.0014936666,
0.0145705547,
-0.0939177796,
-0.0233695004,
-0.0021848131,
0.0501468368,
0.0316542536,
0.0020652572,
0.0379167609,
-0.0042302553,
0.0110132443,
-0.0308429841,
-0.0056028599,
0.0210514609,
-0.0700515807,
-0.0022558714,
0.0364367515,
-0.0237382054,
0.0215026699,
0.0775109306,
0.0253400505,
0.0287663676,
-0.0349310152,
-0.0099287685,
-0.0440527424,
-0.0291022547,
-0.0156425443,
0.0127864452,
-0.0319145545,
0.0168866646,
-0.088182278,
-0.1088012755,
-0.0155398082,
0.088177599,
0.0677409023,
-0.0120888259,
-0.0157709606,
0.0830664784,
-0.0247516707,
0.0076910625,
-0.0551855676,
-0.0311229881,
0.0124999098,
0.0207696911,
-0.0388446078,
-5.806622506e-33,
-0.0349296071,
-0.0402638093,
0.0070727137,
-0.0324906446,
-0.0031899966,
-0.0070467978,
-0.0447460599,
0.0487368628,
-0.0414765738,
0.0217560288,
0.0031518093,
0.008174031,
-0.0027515914,
0.008838769,
0.0115080532,
-0.0004503453,
0.0263620466,
-0.0072788317,
-0.0288309101,
0.005102891,
-0.0063508246,
-0.0215735845,
0.0349958688,
-0.0696042031,
0.0871162936,
-0.0176251922,
-0.0035339114,
0.0226778388,
-0.0421254747,
0.0635884628,
-0.0250702035,
0.0135281533,
0.0170071051,
-0.0606704354,
-0.0186050925,
-0.0276698321,
-0.015028405,
-0.0107530467,
0.039783556,
0.0083224904,
-0.0263025817,
-0.0617849864,
0.0582343936,
-0.0339865535,
-0.0565589927,
0.0229910407,
0.0143884728,
-0.0292483699,
-0.0017480182,
0.0220625587,
-0.0728026554,
0.0072806505,
-0.0337033756,
-0.0125088105,
0.0444469191,
-0.0095992982,
-0.0019046781,
-0.030170504,
-0.0082830694,
0.0027614317,
0.0234322306,
0.02104952,
0.0958383605,
0.0170452017,
0.0054644388,
0.0486079492,
0.0509229787,
0.0073651168,
0.0144035053,
0.0066564963,
0.0728522018,
0.0429690629,
0.0842027217,
-0.0011077414,
0.0127533246,
-0.0094491281,
-0.0407364778,
-0.0148146581,
0.0061656828,
-0.0214168653,
0.0112679088,
0.0092619108,
-0.082320638,
-0.0276955701,
-0.0386092588,
-0.0598301627,
-0.0254373588,
-0.0231735855,
0.0268276222,
-0.0222454667,
-0.0127938529,
-0.0223583076,
0.0224913359,
-0.0669992194,
-0.0143459029,
-0.0003149843,
-0.0166938622,
0.058728952,
0.0021993462,
0.0395656563,
0.0132259969,
-0.0298454631,
-0.0170706436,
0.064048633,
0.0298434421,
-0.0120629873,
0.0176124722,
0.0366567411,
-0.0313581601,
0.0048847739,
-0.0272244774,
0.0047625802,
0.0371538252,
0.01128144,
0.0379199497,
-0.0219221264,
-0.0105246697,
-0.0166313574,
-0.0079943044,
0.0236257575,
-0.0434216894,
0.0672526658,
-0.0324038602,
0.0231704265,
-0.0392036662,
-0.0485367998,
-0.0267635956,
0.0279071815,
0.0269379988,
-0.0039334735,
-0.0048528789,
0.0201118886,
2.393e-7,
0.0403717197,
0.0383063704,
0.0161399804,
-0.0100770555,
0.0223157071,
0.0358901285,
-0.0493515953,
-0.0058266683,
0.01216128,
0.0184317864,
-0.0069355667,
0.0301679112,
0.0451633669,
-0.0119940899,
-0.0536313578,
-0.0267921723,
-0.0378111228,
0.0220877305,
-0.0066133989,
0.0031129452,
0.0059899674,
0.084670946,
0.0197529159,
0.0024782447,
-0.040322341,
-0.0877724513,
0.0072432109,
0.0009663771,
0.0236247405,
0.0313815922,
0.0599276312,
0.0529133342,
0.021263415,
0.0265997741,
0.0135757672,
0.0372020938,
0.0094099054,
0.046178069,
0.00195144,
0.0319507159,
-0.0184331946,
-0.0282595251,
0.0101882322,
-0.0298438277,
0.071605742,
-0.0188924447,
-0.0406144671,
-0.0394132882,
-0.024436174,
0.0242123324,
0.003077508,
0.0069943797,
-0.0204710215,
0.0471995287,
0.0193601027,
-0.0469579138,
0.0204712432,
-0.0169860013,
-0.0296283662,
0.0044164136,
-0.0366033874,
-0.0736023709,
-0.0236643609,
0.008834986,
0.0167955756,
-0.0479954928,
0.029469654,
2.027185007e-34,
0.05392671,
0.0009803261,
0.0432665236,
0.0120706027,
0.0450193137,
-0.0035126014,
-0.0207354017,
-0.0044207904,
0.0163377766,
-0.0584144965,
0.0108029004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12128v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12128v1 | DiagrammerGPT: Generating Open-Domain, Open-Platform Diagrams via LLM Planning | 2023-10-18T17:37:10 | 2023-10-18T17:37:10 | Abhay Zala, Han Lin, Jaemin Cho, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Text-to-image (T2I) generation has seen significant growth over the past few
years. Despite this, there has been little work on generating diagrams with T2I
models. A diagram is a symbolic/schematic representation that explains
information using structurally rich and spatially complex visualizations (e.g.,
a dense combination of related objects, text labels, directional arrows,
connection lines, etc.). Existing state-of-the-art T2I models often fail at
diagram generation because they lack fine-grained object layout control when
many objects are densely connected via complex relations such as arrows/lines
and also often fail to render comprehensible text labels. To address this gap,
we present DiagrammerGPT, a novel two-stage text-to-diagram generation
framework that leverages the layout guidance capabilities of LLMs (e.g., GPT-4)
to generate more accurate open-domain, open-platform diagrams. In the first
stage, we use LLMs to generate and iteratively refine 'diagram plans' (in a
planner-auditor feedback loop) which describe all the entities (objects and
text labels), their relationships (arrows or lines), and their bounding box
layouts. In the second stage, we use a diagram generator, DiagramGLIGEN, and a
text label rendering module to generate diagrams following the diagram plans.
To benchmark the text-to-diagram generation task, we introduce AI2D-Caption, a
densely annotated diagram dataset built on top of the AI2D dataset. We show
quantitatively and qualitatively that our DiagrammerGPT framework produces more
accurate diagrams, outperforming existing T2I models. We also provide
comprehensive analysis including open-domain diagram generation, vector graphic
diagram generation in different platforms, human-in-the-loop diagram plan
editing, and multimodal planner/auditor LLMs (e.g., GPT-4Vision). We hope our
work can inspire further research on diagram generation via T2I models and
LLMs. | [
0.001079405,
0.027861774,
0.0106775695,
0.0304359272,
-0.024005346,
-0.0025318163,
-0.0050641815,
-0.0040857005,
0.0136379609,
0.0044943192,
-0.0553238913,
0.0214514546,
0.0038958527,
-0.0051689041,
-0.020370286,
-0.0537237376,
-0.0409121849,
-0.0185176246,
-0.0781499743,
0.0175694209,
-0.0129470108,
0.0415851176,
-0.0153964935,
0.0243709274,
-0.0771179721,
-0.016540911,
-0.071783416,
0.0454168878,
0.0181486774,
-0.1030287966,
-0.0443047509,
0.026361566,
0.0409452356,
0.0118891718,
0.0000021196,
-0.012596448,
0.0015946967,
0.0001536275,
0.0006061558,
0.021226868,
0.0339683406,
-0.0377799198,
0.008480113,
-0.0196197834,
0.0012765535,
0.027436275,
0.0640934557,
0.0943926647,
0.0615573041,
0.0115994802,
-0.0083794044,
-0.0470561534,
0.036930915,
-0.019181883,
-0.0303929597,
-0.0122766616,
-0.0229403004,
0.0143994223,
-0.0033386932,
0.0177890491,
-0.0381508134,
0.0222053826,
0.0320709832,
-0.004423202,
0.0072770896,
0.0196153838,
0.0233542025,
-0.0382024869,
-0.0049938741,
0.0965633392,
0.0025877687,
0.0229878034,
0.0188380685,
-0.0262928586,
-0.0348642729,
0.0250402503,
-0.0586111508,
-0.0000167235,
-0.0178539827,
-0.0079021817,
-0.0288430583,
-0.0290042311,
-0.0053061815,
-0.0528247282,
-0.0133799976,
0.0116841849,
0.0053972332,
0.0203743782,
-0.0093322964,
0.0175843593,
-0.0315175615,
-0.0798270255,
0.0140169747,
0.0564911216,
-0.0298713278,
0.0120615046,
-0.0396175496,
-0.0384482034,
-0.0080486881,
0.0015561536,
0.097074762,
0.0040165302,
-0.0293956082,
0.0202107541,
-0.0119772712,
0.0339759663,
-0.0380863696,
0.0625800192,
-0.0653510243,
-0.0045508714,
-0.0209750291,
0.0062284088,
-0.0422119275,
0.0063979411,
-0.0914763957,
-0.0306608863,
-0.0173292942,
0.0322800167,
-0.0056074285,
0.0261189211,
0.0232243426,
0.0243705008,
-0.046630118,
0.0000427994,
-0.0458139479,
-0.0202528238,
-0.0228024125,
-0.0199380778,
-0.0149529045,
0.0086577712,
-0.0060607251,
0.0248862747,
0.0376398899,
0.0214112364,
-0.0405159257,
0.1260693073,
-0.031690862,
-0.0013523416,
-0.0352730453,
-0.073035948,
-0.0225396268,
-0.0296907201,
0.0526674986,
-0.0353073962,
0.0029569201,
-0.0287269466,
-0.0200776756,
-0.0113981776,
0.0523159504,
0.0004905771,
-0.0100912265,
-0.0030391423,
-0.029202722,
0.0437558703,
-0.0066762944,
-0.0040848684,
-0.0082190987,
0.0153227793,
0.064814724,
0.0866561085,
0.0159287229,
0.0165985376,
0.0249909982,
0.0710306615,
0.025429422,
-0.0040715854,
0.0001145284,
0.0117717413,
-0.0321402214,
0.0297268722,
0.011298364,
-0.017408371,
-0.0236694291,
0.015745664,
0.0504647121,
0.0309033617,
0.0466852225,
0.0116396761,
0.0547840558,
0.032688491,
-0.0132952621,
-0.0240943506,
-0.0483260676,
0.0604127273,
0.030457532,
0.0293355975,
-0.0442386754,
0.0055719488,
-0.0006478005,
-0.0336316451,
0.0247300025,
0.007935144,
-0.0475975499,
-0.0768322051,
0.0387065336,
0.0632580221,
-0.0607833751,
0.0701583177,
-0.0111153116,
-0.039745301,
-0.0154808927,
0.0253085941,
0.0172915347,
0.0538506545,
0.019356221,
0.0037483573,
-0.0449826606,
0.0033213799,
0.0464974567,
0.0925455987,
0.0255723819,
-0.0077501903,
0.0160600934,
-0.0015804874,
-0.0612841882,
-0.0419808552,
0.003142477,
0.0280950814,
0.0335002206,
-0.0100822868,
0.01663341,
-0.0723440126,
-0.0236702859,
0.0590463988,
0.0138160884,
-0.0104443319,
0.0190440193,
0.0038279956,
-0.0044976003,
0.0224819202,
-0.0485179201,
-0.0000809488,
0.0350948162,
-0.0036992261,
-0.0188222155,
0.0222313944,
-0.0238529257,
-0.0038569744,
-0.0014203079,
-0.0438942686,
-0.0283627771,
0.001271556,
-0.0615885854,
-0.0258259438,
0.0017824242,
-0.0107100476,
0.0047594523,
0.0082167098,
-0.0283790044,
0.0167841278,
-0.0153565761,
-0.013566291,
0.0378132425,
-0.0325944386,
-0.0505661666,
0.0320785418,
0.0168795828,
0.0360201858,
0.0171866491,
0.0216674712,
0.0092597343,
0.0131546678,
-0.0100902691,
-0.0181448609,
0.0382427759,
-0.0262639448,
0.0227528848,
-0.082929261,
0.0051945504,
0.0015031609,
0.0227654483,
0.0130094839,
-0.0378391109,
-0.0077058375,
0.0109734433,
0.0025327178,
0.0838486552,
-0.0271496028,
-0.0307687707,
0.0291321557,
-0.0095646214,
-0.013660471,
0.0036996261,
0.0240915809,
-0.0182716027,
0.0177388899,
0.0604399554,
-0.0202896353,
-0.0436812304,
0.081213221,
-0.0215136185,
0.0109192375,
0.0233890284,
0.0241842456,
0.0498242602,
0.0141609758,
0.0043796869,
-0.0012294434,
-0.0192048717,
0.0258325599,
0.0444904417,
-0.0430138484,
-0.0560465343,
0.0488177501,
-0.0081101926,
-0.0108810719,
0.0049691335,
-0.0285762753,
0.0211193804,
0.0486550331,
-0.013678777,
0.0303965583,
-0.0192185137,
-0.0202500336,
0.0221741106,
-0.0171706602,
-0.02310545,
-0.0067252871,
0.0064185429,
0.0496550091,
-0.0481443629,
-0.047184553,
0.0196417831,
-0.0760152638,
0.008799077,
0.0385133214,
0.0272954907,
-0.0478787273,
0.1237003803,
0.0179746766,
0.0159246866,
0.0106357252,
0.0134767089,
-0.0550136492,
0.0355842859,
-0.0053356281,
-0.0031115254,
0.0011760159,
-0.0906273499,
-0.0295002908,
-0.0316009112,
-0.0225711949,
-0.0143130794,
0.0571730919,
-0.0127697112,
-0.0085984087,
-0.0120004108,
-0.0503186733,
-0.0250349846,
0.0073331045,
-0.03361018,
0.0332731456,
0.0041346853,
-0.0310093611,
-0.0458107181,
0.0442022532,
0.0396728441,
0.0164370332,
-0.0195367932,
-0.0343925618,
-0.012826886,
0.0541571751,
-0.0496175364,
-0.0022431482,
-0.0502621494,
-0.0100366287,
0.0100688636,
0.0352606848,
-0.0041961754,
0.0170734636,
0.0609340966,
-0.0189181659,
-0.0234776847,
0.0540165789,
0.0284074191,
-0.0082530752,
-0.0029379104,
0.0143410973,
0.0990361497,
0.0301778652,
0.0192294344,
-0.1053928211,
-0.0214571711,
-0.0092948051,
0.0063374438,
0.0412595943,
-0.0366487093,
-0.0306801312,
-0.112355344,
0.0707940459,
0.0130249877,
-0.0753920376,
-0.0043493407,
-0.0146080432,
0.0059538269,
0.0300392546,
-0.0383242145,
-0.0082181711,
-0.00115612,
-0.0044304477,
0.0003596385,
-0.0467997566,
0.0092415325,
-0.022809796,
-0.0110813761,
0.0309422016,
0.0336314701,
0.0266921632,
0.0575972013,
-0.0075043873,
0.0759179294,
0.0588109046,
0.0244332161,
-0.0360591784,
0.0632090122,
0.0398557149,
-0.0187854636,
-0.0483883284,
0.0007392341,
-0.0330967642,
-0.0291647688,
0.0140764778,
0.0598775856,
-0.0071160737,
-0.0145799331,
-0.0786233768,
0.0067797997,
-0.0124366004,
0.0365618207,
0.0239644311,
-0.0148974732,
-0.0683188066,
-0.0455253758,
0.041074086,
-0.0742268562,
0.001010134,
-0.0039405869,
-0.0641350299,
-0.0394972637,
-0.0575359501,
-0.0087313671,
0.0539170057,
0.0084368102,
0.0249334238,
-0.0469289869,
-0.0621639416,
-0.0235527679,
-0.0599639937,
0.0119624678,
-0.0189001951,
0.0213221498,
0.0223129019,
0.011142008,
0.0171765815,
-0.0283333082,
-0.0054891631,
0.0575216487,
-0.0644227937,
-0.0061488394,
-0.0569486022,
0.0355753303,
0.0102989469,
0.0208550449,
0.0242461152,
-0.0274912436,
0.0239472967,
0.0966937542,
-0.0007188381,
-0.0162353609,
-0.0233820807,
0.0854191259,
0.0059940978,
-0.0133526977,
-0.0706996247,
0.0228274949,
0.0261657573,
0.0450588018,
-0.002313992,
-0.0059816116,
0.0116972653,
0.0283292737,
-0.016909698,
-0.0211466458,
-0.0157203637,
-0.0156698152,
0.020712439,
-0.0486313924,
-0.0489687733,
-0.038451355,
0.0504848063,
0.0056463662,
-0.0171229374,
0.0415964462,
-0.0049177315,
0.0206259638,
0.0552900471,
-0.0222542658,
-0.0345907621,
0.023036072,
-0.0276212003,
0.0047315243,
0.0338937528,
-0.0171928722,
0.0106869927,
-0.0369025208,
0.0581693761,
0.0286083948,
0.0177295022,
0.0089584524,
-0.0290369876,
-0.0273695551,
0.0211834572,
-0.0006608628,
-0.0555767529,
-0.0495618954,
0.0582007505,
0.0403542109,
0.0548711009,
0.0611471795,
-0.0649629086,
0.0119165387,
0.0222201459,
0.0233095866,
0.0182559211,
-0.012871244,
0.0156132076,
-0.0142571153,
0.0165660791,
-0.0805312172,
0.0198734533,
0.0374086015,
0.0311609656,
-0.044607725,
-0.0320019908,
-0.0372837149,
-0.031814564,
0.0186769739,
0.0060022962,
0.0032032558,
-0.0102590872,
-0.072702691,
-0.0277137086,
0.0245614052,
0.0409943424,
-0.0107705425,
-0.001952378,
0.0431121998,
0.0088740587,
0.022138102,
-0.0461283214,
0.0237842705,
-0.0226661004,
-0.0253485683,
-0.0535096787,
-0.0137719251,
-5.271577885e-33,
-0.0452606454,
-0.0837841779,
0.0285174809,
-0.023659816,
-0.0334620923,
-0.0263652839,
-0.0538116507,
0.0247999821,
0.0297753215,
0.0278345272,
0.0146491555,
-0.0392603427,
-0.0062031439,
0.0242643226,
-0.0118488362,
0.015728455,
0.0541356616,
0.0021883422,
-0.058489956,
0.0156021789,
-0.0164018981,
0.0287742112,
0.0106173037,
-0.0739596635,
-0.0154128084,
0.0014442687,
0.0375106297,
0.014004739,
0.0238159467,
0.0222891923,
-0.0104730586,
0.0025305187,
0.0248916596,
0.0285371207,
-0.0210440997,
-0.0033540146,
-0.085862793,
-0.030411141,
-0.0086832102,
0.0004310188,
-0.09006574,
-0.0307185687,
0.0504969582,
0.0189421009,
-0.0265519749,
-0.0626847744,
0.0331898257,
0.0028436317,
0.0140980044,
0.006651002,
-0.0291586947,
-0.0035640625,
-0.0298630781,
-0.0367681831,
0.0305097383,
0.0343185142,
0.0737412944,
0.017724866,
-0.0300798938,
0.0387889445,
0.0218053218,
-0.0334174186,
0.0955455601,
0.0255286209,
-0.0013914476,
0.0678113699,
0.0223309379,
0.0044242665,
-0.0711703226,
0.0208098423,
-0.0136455661,
0.119616203,
0.0063084592,
0.0086036073,
0.0044615762,
0.0516276136,
-0.0282195378,
0.0802407637,
-0.0699761286,
0.0399751663,
0.0252540521,
0.0315814056,
0.0029940188,
-0.0015555304,
-0.0124460766,
-0.0225979313,
-0.0347032622,
0.0135253184,
0.0314371847,
0.0115638291,
-0.007113961,
-0.0055739754,
0.0127838878,
-0.0125662265,
0.0016398554,
-0.0232258327,
-0.0392469987,
0.0520801432,
-0.0329368822,
-0.0083175655,
-0.0159811415,
-0.0509071797,
0.0418783389,
0.0163117964,
0.010204006,
0.0217662454,
0.0257869642,
0.0193786602,
-0.0314099528,
0.0140697928,
-0.0599565357,
-0.0038176742,
-0.0028465411,
-0.0581027195,
0.0012086143,
-0.0457975343,
-0.0430147499,
-0.0101016229,
0.0106438352,
0.0033988364,
0.0128062107,
-0.00992331,
-0.0183670186,
-0.0212732628,
0.0089215003,
0.0117712896,
0.0127491327,
-0.0150377378,
0.0554802641,
-0.0800943151,
-0.0308960583,
0.0126944985,
2.685e-7,
0.0575508289,
0.0372616015,
0.0157575179,
0.0660927817,
0.0250405595,
0.0182246231,
-0.0035790647,
-0.0094363475,
-0.0450481921,
-0.0152663644,
0.0205696747,
0.030049812,
0.0395141914,
0.0319657773,
-0.0460158922,
0.0046531679,
-0.0232007056,
-0.0014206902,
-0.0814440921,
0.0127607109,
0.0830630064,
0.022195505,
-0.0351021662,
-0.0386473797,
0.0087762466,
-0.0087416871,
0.0302735884,
-0.0578341149,
0.0752282217,
-0.0137625458,
-0.0078182248,
0.0129037229,
-0.025697602,
0.0153580951,
-0.0031488992,
0.0021018127,
0.016035039,
0.0274938066,
-0.0202730391,
0.0121488692,
0.0335908718,
-0.0541014187,
0.0076498222,
-0.0173721891,
0.0118277455,
-0.0626759157,
-0.009632986,
0.0068955366,
0.0172496624,
0.0160339326,
-0.0281178895,
-0.005780099,
0.0295712724,
0.0232165735,
0.0027026606,
-0.0063401558,
0.0021831412,
-0.0122976778,
-0.0346288644,
0.0016438741,
-0.0230416842,
-0.0227734726,
-0.0429447852,
0.0506021008,
-0.0451968014,
0.0077385725,
-0.0403559469,
2.507250472e-34,
-0.0077774771,
0.0058711031,
-0.0064045093,
0.070139192,
0.0904613212,
-0.0086850366,
0.0602659583,
0.0031886299,
-0.0164372716,
-0.0505945198,
-0.0282474905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12127v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12127v2 | A Tale of Pronouns: Interpretability Informs Gender Bias Mitigation for Fairer Instruction-Tuned Machine Translation | 2023-10-18T17:36:55 | 2023-10-25T13:43:49 | Giuseppe Attanasio, Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Debora Nozza, Anne Lauscher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent instruction fine-tuned models can solve multiple NLP tasks when
prompted to do so, with machine translation (MT) being a prominent use case.
However, current research often focuses on standard performance benchmarks,
leaving compelling fairness and ethical considerations behind. In MT, this
might lead to misgendered translations, resulting, among other harms, in the
perpetuation of stereotypes and prejudices. In this work, we address this gap
by investigating whether and to what extent such models exhibit gender bias in
machine translation and how we can mitigate it. Concretely, we compute
established gender bias metrics on the WinoMT corpus from English to German and
Spanish. We discover that IFT models default to male-inflected translations,
even disregarding female occupational stereotypes. Next, using interpretability
methods, we unveil that models systematically overlook the pronoun indicating
the gender of a target occupation in misgendered translations. Finally, based
on this finding, we propose an easy-to-implement and effective bias mitigation
solution based on few-shot learning that leads to significantly fairer
translations. | [
0.0292473733,
0.0886494592,
-0.0310709961,
0.0362078622,
-0.003035536,
0.01759273,
0.0676040128,
-0.019113034,
-0.0232422967,
-0.0448765829,
-0.0126689896,
-0.0252222065,
0.0367778949,
-0.0473754182,
0.0190372299,
-0.0278315749,
0.0122129722,
0.0381642058,
-0.0111418534,
-0.0415515639,
0.0145542184,
0.0242434535,
0.0220405385,
0.072458744,
0.0263799876,
-0.0226158798,
0.0527316146,
0.0430182517,
-0.0013828219,
0.039557375,
0.0387167633,
0.0560495555,
-0.008035602,
0.0511225834,
0.0000020839,
-0.0593319982,
-0.0224083774,
0.0382285193,
0.0017093183,
0.0021586602,
0.0448160358,
-0.0561462604,
-0.0320820883,
0.0254658051,
-0.0054259948,
-0.0041653826,
0.0451879837,
-0.0038783995,
0.0393319018,
0.0332764387,
-0.009450865,
0.0141673796,
-0.0665025339,
-0.032980483,
0.001709788,
-0.040415369,
-0.0055761337,
-0.0537853204,
-0.1002104357,
0.0082611525,
-0.0379869789,
0.0278247874,
-0.0023014687,
0.0060860347,
-0.0231515635,
-0.0000473437,
-0.0210262593,
-0.0463896468,
0.0104719745,
0.0333432034,
0.0089366278,
-0.00244941,
-0.0046052467,
-0.0055861333,
0.0061504259,
-0.0034492554,
-0.019078752,
0.0293365661,
-0.0021626602,
-0.0213825703,
0.0091895936,
0.0212548915,
0.0219471958,
0.0436239578,
-0.0159012135,
0.050225053,
0.0071683503,
-0.0256008264,
0.0206809454,
0.0479844362,
-0.0136805177,
-0.0250031389,
0.0168421213,
-0.0308605991,
0.0047044852,
-0.000044436,
-0.020238379,
-0.0255096573,
0.0263202619,
-0.0428418368,
0.0277530476,
0.0534527637,
0.0200498253,
0.0106261596,
0.013192283,
0.0352693275,
-0.0134979766,
0.0056533106,
-0.0332798325,
-0.0519647188,
-0.0288284365,
-0.0069233775,
-0.0137731284,
-0.0193697531,
-0.0367763303,
0.081779018,
-0.0275378246,
-0.0220045708,
-0.046136003,
-0.0057462463,
0.0340188444,
-0.0034655656,
-0.0698703006,
0.0088672033,
-0.0107700797,
0.057021305,
-0.0489222854,
0.000741121,
-0.0444095619,
-0.073989816,
-0.014657259,
-0.0068319128,
-0.0301847383,
-0.0488451719,
-0.0008296699,
0.068205826,
0.0168347713,
-0.0353310332,
0.0093834084,
-0.0410810672,
-0.0462604873,
-0.0691948459,
0.0124200685,
-0.0470334515,
0.0306089967,
0.0243104845,
0.0397280715,
-0.0515923053,
-0.0122766579,
0.0200963132,
-0.0334703811,
0.0656638145,
0.0503518619,
-0.0115886526,
0.0304413773,
0.0079064136,
-0.0570482463,
0.0956696272,
0.0538090281,
0.0153357051,
0.0451259054,
0.0040280572,
-0.0111266635,
0.0523102432,
0.0315950103,
0.034000013,
0.0122211184,
0.0157968104,
-0.0268016774,
0.0370842367,
0.0868941098,
-0.0087494561,
0.0110682333,
-0.0048663002,
0.056327112,
0.052240923,
0.019052403,
0.0305117443,
0.0302312877,
0.0160232317,
-0.0308371149,
0.0138654234,
-0.0854940936,
-0.0057984861,
0.0049143895,
-0.0652708113,
-0.0246285107,
0.0539871193,
-0.0021350388,
-0.0450836793,
0.0185309928,
0.0153126484,
0.0084751556,
-0.0084429355,
0.0134483688,
0.0468094423,
-0.0009186985,
0.0588153303,
0.0218916759,
-0.0457829721,
-0.0036104855,
-0.0367290191,
-0.0465125181,
0.0468368605,
0.0214995574,
-0.0100409044,
0.0040242579,
-0.0530294143,
-0.0184372142,
0.0473314747,
0.058384914,
0.0318516567,
0.0558189228,
-0.0330054834,
-0.0277895462,
0.034080267,
0.0414794534,
0.0309017804,
0.0411850922,
0.0514483303,
0.030272238,
-0.0560472868,
-0.0791610181,
0.0243467409,
0.0123336772,
-0.0654797107,
0.0581107959,
0.0265354086,
0.0079498384,
0.0257391613,
-0.0297080036,
-0.0147488527,
-0.0313670151,
-0.0197447799,
-0.0151556116,
0.0514748357,
-0.0487599261,
-0.0289589558,
-0.027525967,
-0.0749796107,
-0.0589934476,
0.0097017949,
-0.0363197811,
0.0086989431,
0.0269205663,
-0.0121101253,
-0.0321783572,
-0.0120205795,
0.0045634969,
-0.0137851425,
0.0115136867,
-0.0421695709,
0.002508325,
-0.0192645695,
-0.0218803342,
0.0044593331,
-0.0579305664,
0.017030457,
-0.0508257151,
-0.0371058583,
0.0436363481,
0.0099767679,
0.0262978096,
0.0469992124,
0.0014628923,
0.0088491933,
-0.02442801,
-0.0522784889,
0.0219351985,
-0.0101078833,
-0.0023694562,
0.0096246144,
0.0355497487,
-0.0020711271,
0.0142387478,
0.0115588699,
-0.0318589993,
-0.0112474561,
0.0133044655,
0.0215455052,
-0.0331946276,
0.0351666659,
-0.0213259421,
-0.0307675451,
-0.0506519936,
0.0505305789,
0.0379326977,
0.0207462609,
-0.0518106036,
-0.0151612042,
-0.0100171883,
-0.0073146988,
0.0005702312,
-0.0372298732,
0.000741493,
0.0377615243,
0.0138075454,
0.1033162326,
0.0012302221,
0.033550892,
0.0289308187,
0.0125888465,
-0.0570056289,
-0.0105638802,
0.0132906111,
-0.0273752678,
0.0101282503,
-0.1015376225,
0.0166149028,
0.034277834,
0.0357129201,
-0.0387143753,
-0.0661697239,
0.0461181253,
-0.066160053,
-0.0556801446,
-0.0141398963,
0.0142552108,
0.0160347968,
0.0189097337,
-0.035710942,
-0.0305411629,
0.0501331501,
0.0000510829,
0.0142817758,
-0.0234473124,
0.0105355708,
-0.044378981,
0.0466824993,
-0.0274013728,
0.0175851882,
0.0298953876,
-0.0113842729,
-0.0554098934,
-0.0246173721,
0.0656977445,
-0.0237592086,
0.0204192884,
-0.0594288819,
-0.0076177237,
-0.0103444681,
-0.0587537549,
-0.0149833746,
-0.0471084379,
0.0016648223,
-0.0081041446,
0.0182201602,
-0.020030681,
-0.0193019602,
-0.00462119,
0.0114256004,
0.020382883,
-0.0329049937,
-0.0100633828,
-0.0385452397,
-0.0264864154,
-0.0033353558,
-0.0129300365,
0.0207603108,
-0.0340635963,
0.0091354614,
0.0367691815,
-0.0143598216,
0.0220982246,
0.0039586332,
0.0196279194,
0.0473339446,
-0.044281967,
-0.0281959027,
-0.029236408,
0.0851653367,
-0.0674703792,
0.0243161079,
0.0959123597,
-0.0009811764,
-0.05886098,
0.0069835614,
0.0053680567,
0.0208959226,
0.0238444284,
0.0111937542,
-0.0813430548,
-0.0191802699,
0.0372415893,
0.0510563813,
-0.046024967,
-0.0396136343,
-0.0271477513,
-0.1016264781,
0.0141960112,
0.0278224498,
-0.0445844308,
-0.0461679585,
-0.0194782298,
-0.0340541266,
-0.0636450797,
0.0362468064,
-0.0034959251,
0.0173876267,
0.0213941615,
-0.0055568046,
0.0129246525,
-0.0201539602,
0.0459190905,
-0.0849344432,
0.0352366082,
0.0610067323,
0.0548857525,
0.002537152,
0.0249717589,
-0.0126305092,
-0.0402060337,
-0.0002893387,
-0.0313627981,
0.0370983556,
-0.0571178421,
-0.0242211558,
-0.0214409586,
0.0370321646,
0.0278522018,
0.0351417996,
0.0186482724,
0.0091387453,
0.0283130873,
-0.0162010919,
-0.0258564837,
-0.034411028,
0.0086516887,
0.0977318063,
0.0151889566,
-0.0480620191,
-0.0275765695,
-0.0735329613,
-0.0018882744,
-0.0207555518,
-0.0744175613,
0.0052268854,
-0.0121223293,
-0.0629132167,
-0.0321662612,
-0.08145459,
0.0205004402,
0.0211052038,
0.0043582418,
-0.0708177909,
0.0209975373,
0.0155064315,
-0.0590999275,
0.0425799266,
-0.0378505588,
0.0394274779,
0.0199509971,
-0.0027634606,
-0.009271956,
-0.0267082918,
-0.0251859091,
0.0311603453,
-0.0283375978,
-0.0434613116,
0.0090927016,
0.0624060184,
0.0234582797,
0.0717150494,
-0.0221456923,
-0.0462050326,
0.0135213174,
0.0562162586,
-0.0115369791,
0.0208538808,
0.0622363463,
0.0208904371,
0.021722164,
0.0474452302,
-0.0131758796,
0.0251080561,
0.0013643788,
0.0336200036,
0.0003605052,
-0.0285485797,
0.0188616496,
0.000497858,
0.0069022565,
-0.0540636294,
-0.0156948175,
-0.027964659,
-0.0075774267,
-0.0097491574,
-0.0472068265,
-0.0202420931,
-0.0299955979,
0.0332980044,
0.0071923747,
-0.0197841413,
-0.0161089823,
-0.0421458855,
-0.0117247365,
-0.0316838361,
0.0079556908,
-0.0194052663,
0.0560195744,
-0.02328014,
0.0276486482,
-0.0047548055,
0.018581599,
-0.0142064327,
0.0425141938,
0.0136770364,
0.0368101746,
0.0059695221,
0.0474906266,
-0.0194158852,
0.0088735837,
-0.0364296064,
0.010555177,
-0.0262797568,
0.0141621139,
0.042549897,
-0.0316865034,
0.0877626985,
0.0035927214,
-0.0104601234,
0.012725953,
0.008034124,
0.0304187387,
0.0226592366,
0.006992538,
-0.0174955446,
0.0126193753,
-0.0170578435,
0.0630351231,
0.0330827832,
0.0556093007,
-0.0141556477,
-0.0342818312,
-0.0222562011,
-0.0217137467,
0.0141160972,
-0.0497197248,
0.0097070783,
-0.0110345893,
-0.0899783149,
-0.042583663,
-0.0202366095,
-0.0226294287,
0.0306955762,
-0.0191871691,
-0.0192613322,
0.0882940888,
-0.0420669653,
-0.0619247109,
-0.0539699793,
-0.0064927177,
0.01617359,
-0.014490217,
-0.0231395159,
-6.409269807e-33,
-0.0312230084,
-0.0275131799,
-0.0202725455,
-0.0122482404,
0.0089520924,
-0.0074802055,
-0.0127129052,
-0.0273799878,
-0.005762442,
0.0300178863,
-0.0057529244,
0.0168790873,
0.0202782936,
-0.0065830383,
0.019556446,
0.0166984554,
0.0694949329,
0.0348124579,
-0.0439355075,
-0.0297121853,
-0.0238200873,
0.0161243659,
0.0731627345,
-0.046808511,
0.1156841666,
0.0028341245,
-0.023611214,
0.014281149,
-0.0124973115,
0.0092550898,
0.0239961073,
0.0616892353,
0.023616001,
-0.0413872711,
0.0062455544,
0.0304687433,
-0.0965513363,
-0.013685816,
0.0281861499,
0.0559977144,
0.0341270417,
-0.0639913604,
0.0555018447,
-0.0048882389,
-0.0651600957,
-0.0434878394,
0.044735197,
0.0092402026,
0.0566468574,
0.0267936531,
-0.0572303943,
0.0094012814,
-0.0488112681,
-0.0171369426,
0.0353558585,
0.023643354,
-0.0043700519,
0.0291233435,
-0.079233408,
0.0102595165,
-0.027365759,
0.0044789743,
0.042025093,
-0.0258158818,
0.0133061223,
0.004022256,
0.0671868548,
0.0434676297,
-0.0131048877,
-0.0432202406,
0.0383387618,
-0.0384006873,
0.0402637757,
0.0638326481,
0.0556401126,
0.0110266069,
-0.0492008477,
-0.021677034,
0.0015600404,
0.0147371544,
0.0208332539,
-0.0202035215,
-0.0914934576,
-0.0411626659,
-0.0493556,
-0.1133254468,
-0.0102945101,
0.0050366204,
0.0068323105,
-0.0125317555,
-0.0646446869,
0.0254879147,
0.0224601608,
-0.0639548749,
0.002077451,
-0.0047833482,
-0.0208683945,
-0.0456424244,
0.0185726359,
0.024178125,
-0.0472944081,
-0.00058674,
-0.0051134606,
0.0490798317,
0.03350088,
0.0156594925,
0.0131077366,
0.0009545596,
-0.052364137,
-0.0151881203,
-0.0502176173,
0.0148764234,
-0.0177214332,
0.0215096232,
0.0282473266,
0.0402603075,
-0.0100686578,
0.0007694722,
0.0576183982,
0.0172344632,
-0.0221869331,
0.0203004964,
-0.0006943237,
0.0402345769,
-0.0260889679,
-0.0026079048,
0.0268785004,
-0.0089782802,
0.0369622521,
-0.0555237606,
-0.0271284282,
-0.0682399273,
2.719e-7,
0.0162274875,
0.0735859051,
0.0000159972,
0.0561582036,
0.013053949,
0.0557979681,
0.0208400022,
0.0564483292,
0.0414066762,
0.0348551385,
-0.0089327209,
0.0453541577,
0.0406584553,
0.0229786653,
-0.043756038,
-0.010237569,
-0.032297112,
0.0414218791,
-0.0200801138,
0.0187282469,
0.0242939759,
0.0796945915,
0.0407914482,
0.0211887863,
-0.0004648509,
-0.0042678732,
0.0548005812,
-0.0031179208,
0.00858171,
0.0122659551,
0.0323840901,
0.0115752285,
0.0102013955,
0.0150337303,
0.0047095949,
0.0045065242,
0.0109059187,
0.049485106,
-0.017370563,
0.0227641966,
-0.0204476044,
-0.0337601081,
-0.0209911224,
-0.0432295837,
0.0460995771,
-0.0316930339,
-0.0513456985,
0.0051107346,
-0.0220678858,
0.0087473597,
0.0622291528,
-0.0075723748,
-0.0463775285,
0.0145446667,
0.0423945189,
0.0200018063,
-0.0216289051,
-0.0310219638,
-0.0389144607,
-0.033696413,
0.0098944753,
-0.0663937107,
0.0139453281,
0.0199102387,
0.0043188189,
-0.0416883156,
0.0053050304,
2.462758011e-34,
-0.0011382356,
0.0213960595,
0.0343470648,
-0.0012973691,
0.0298331007,
0.0188153405,
-0.006425791,
-0.0316904411,
0.0511004589,
0.0199060906,
-0.0231642406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12126v1 | SHARCS: Efficient Transformers through Routing with Dynamic Width Sub-networks | 2023-10-18T17:35:15 | 2023-10-18T17:35:15 | Mohammadreza Salehi, Sachin Mehta, Aditya Kusupati, Ali Farhadi, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce SHARCS for adaptive inference that takes into account the
hardness of input samples. SHARCS can train a router on any transformer
network, enabling the model to direct different samples to sub-networks with
varying widths. Our experiments demonstrate that: (1) SHARCS outperforms or
complements existing per-sample adaptive inference methods across various
classification tasks in terms of accuracy vs. FLOPs; (2) SHARCS generalizes
across different architectures and can be even applied to compressed and
efficient transformer encoders to further improve their efficiency; (3) SHARCS
can provide a 2 times inference speed up at an insignificant drop in accuracy. | [
-0.0263823345,
0.0769140273,
-0.00385281,
0.0293156952,
-0.0131363347,
-0.0114275655,
0.0739832968,
-0.0042964998,
-0.031797979,
0.0178768579,
0.0100046284,
0.00214161,
-0.0084916027,
0.0100667803,
0.0107555911,
-0.0309057143,
-0.0265009813,
0.0220539812,
-0.0361872762,
-0.021130085,
-0.0106012225,
0.009956995,
-0.011741776,
0.0415565223,
0.0103784837,
0.0077117966,
-0.0508403182,
0.0130584864,
0.0248941928,
-0.0247161016,
0.0415596776,
0.0014653569,
0.0079953391,
0.0319305472,
0.0000020174,
0.037383806,
-0.0048752958,
-0.0160521977,
-0.0198665671,
-0.0038685193,
-0.0001320495,
-0.0082998006,
-0.0036098412,
0.0251065381,
0.0015829598,
-0.0462475382,
0.0964664221,
0.0555505715,
0.0026267876,
0.0399106629,
-0.0139293727,
-0.0315409414,
0.018130172,
-0.082852751,
-0.0110068107,
0.0088794548,
-0.0184073336,
-0.0631960556,
-0.0644610375,
-0.0427490026,
-0.0310766567,
0.0326063633,
0.0620843433,
0.0363223217,
-0.0130979894,
0.0121302335,
-0.0264702402,
0.023716921,
-0.0254751667,
0.001476126,
-0.0999023244,
-0.0057997699,
0.0020965787,
-0.0339675099,
-0.0429050215,
-0.0041397968,
-0.0392083414,
-0.0006756432,
-0.03033383,
0.007679705,
-0.0884766728,
0.0609068498,
0.0344292633,
0.00666874,
-0.0121443467,
-0.0116635179,
0.0142537663,
0.0136015425,
-0.0179405324,
0.0116136009,
-0.0027859854,
-0.0020757332,
0.0193348229,
-0.0255171284,
-0.0063940063,
-0.0030085789,
-0.015986288,
0.0165620036,
-0.0192943066,
-0.0135275312,
0.0608761944,
0.0227195807,
0.0171875209,
-0.004480775,
-0.0490723737,
0.0189144667,
-0.1022790819,
0.0546141937,
-0.0486630537,
-0.0138293905,
0.0130385542,
-0.0004785034,
-0.0239269957,
0.0022864211,
-0.0185555201,
0.0038103084,
-0.0681726933,
0.0132671967,
0.0088444892,
-0.0522745959,
0.0218050964,
0.0271767285,
-0.0511245057,
-0.0196263492,
0.0146796191,
0.0496578589,
-0.0186947845,
0.0248233229,
0.0248622969,
-0.0239152219,
-0.0236802157,
0.0315709747,
0.0192163307,
0.0140981153,
0.0321388245,
0.0743897855,
-0.0293676276,
-0.0715245456,
-0.0424745753,
0.0072042309,
0.0041785031,
-0.0045570638,
0.0383938923,
-0.0493326895,
0.0372783802,
0.011817758,
0.0080098556,
-0.0056314478,
-0.0017465835,
0.0255550221,
-0.0293005947,
0.0192680843,
0.0179937053,
-0.0768973157,
0.0029433786,
-0.0121365646,
0.0089465026,
0.0296200216,
0.0388381891,
0.0407548249,
-0.039035175,
0.0082542906,
-0.0201335438,
0.0134122679,
0.0161053725,
-0.0205387324,
0.0033238807,
-0.0628691614,
-0.0506788269,
0.0123793855,
0.0215671957,
0.0154475393,
-0.0318413526,
-0.0543256737,
0.0250497889,
-0.0014965418,
0.0624853522,
0.0822958946,
-0.0086872457,
-0.005610446,
-0.0222227462,
0.0037714071,
-0.0260352418,
0.0740439519,
0.0069215721,
-0.0194104258,
0.0140522523,
0.0515087433,
-0.0306344051,
-0.0554360934,
-0.0041299476,
-0.0165485162,
-0.0022581522,
0.0232278183,
0.0491181314,
0.0410218686,
-0.0370638557,
0.1051143333,
0.048344247,
-0.047576949,
-0.0382480435,
-0.030826712,
0.0007669088,
-0.0086991461,
0.0558808856,
0.0044151684,
-0.0218492039,
-0.0010518387,
-0.0294859838,
0.0050018518,
0.0311521087,
0.0125988089,
0.0240894724,
-0.0482700616,
-0.0334856436,
0.0313691646,
0.0106039206,
-0.0123770768,
0.038665697,
-0.0216453876,
0.023417905,
-0.0337525159,
-0.0120580448,
-0.0030266836,
-0.0015945679,
-0.0065633012,
0.0468823612,
0.0171434209,
0.0231302753,
-0.0165707376,
-0.0255873892,
-0.0632979125,
0.0167710632,
-0.0391967595,
-0.0480243787,
0.0017157729,
-0.0564408228,
-0.005733097,
-0.0203904677,
-0.0618218258,
0.0182790849,
0.0502304994,
-0.0545888916,
0.0000637408,
0.0170867685,
-0.0568858013,
-0.0099320393,
-0.0133306421,
-0.0218213927,
0.0183559135,
0.0342059769,
0.0132149253,
0.0129900528,
-0.0134495022,
0.0223149173,
-0.0067638769,
-0.0249192361,
-0.0095472159,
0.0293938778,
-0.0171196517,
-0.0262032449,
-0.0298677478,
0.0064292219,
0.0535870418,
-0.0150777362,
0.0580712296,
-0.0291705895,
0.0268975962,
0.0183468126,
-0.0443114042,
0.0268638711,
-0.0385818519,
0.0387030691,
0.0452034324,
-0.0154196275,
-0.0181180201,
0.022673443,
-0.041363921,
-0.0272558425,
-0.0394472107,
-0.0132457064,
-0.040709842,
0.0159171931,
-0.0594971888,
0.0061853863,
0.0595131293,
0.0006387065,
0.0445323475,
-0.0114974407,
-0.0837959424,
0.0265824664,
0.0241297483,
-0.0389629342,
-0.0521374084,
-0.0249913819,
-0.0103724981,
0.0141448928,
0.0572487749,
0.019641418,
0.0117673557,
0.0252834558,
0.0343458503,
0.0107575804,
0.0150772249,
-0.0558523014,
-0.0135039426,
-0.0539102964,
-0.0102286171,
-0.035725873,
0.0804862827,
-0.0090505667,
-0.0084768655,
-0.0570125096,
-0.0437822007,
0.0588841401,
-0.0109341396,
0.0230081026,
-0.0038138318,
0.0148897581,
-0.0369155593,
0.0154847195,
0.0091720782,
0.0446691774,
-0.0008206472,
-0.0132183563,
-0.0011145429,
-0.0345696695,
-0.0047339182,
0.0032511018,
0.0503801256,
0.0581423491,
0.0069269864,
0.0150859123,
-0.0396001227,
0.0419816822,
0.0205120184,
-0.0274973679,
0.0242743529,
0.0053365943,
-0.0160812661,
-0.040646378,
-0.0650979802,
-0.040365044,
0.0091204923,
-0.0023519255,
0.0107422732,
0.0285787787,
-0.0494719967,
-0.1068721041,
0.052459009,
-0.0011433116,
0.0996393859,
-0.0148942526,
-0.0144740371,
-0.0239956062,
0.0396558978,
-0.002160992,
0.0406179205,
0.0446989015,
-0.0077404217,
0.0140149277,
0.0666425899,
0.0272841975,
0.0345359631,
-0.0814341605,
0.0165550839,
0.0121419588,
-0.0225414019,
0.0221805777,
0.0226641186,
0.0048350785,
-0.0481118597,
-0.0225864835,
0.0614004321,
-0.006691779,
-0.0758579001,
-0.0239568986,
0.058415927,
0.0203868393,
0.0331028923,
0.0129858451,
-0.0711905882,
-0.0448944643,
-0.0040597855,
0.0365255103,
-0.0172063988,
-0.0115485992,
0.0259976108,
-0.039571844,
0.0133680282,
-0.0161399543,
0.0013887176,
-0.0486212522,
-0.0251544807,
-0.011787191,
-0.0406313576,
0.0127295144,
-0.0206079707,
-0.0190745555,
-0.0619605333,
0.054407265,
0.0073319511,
-0.0242850743,
-0.0264141988,
-0.0238605235,
-0.0033457305,
-0.0002439604,
-0.0208849814,
0.0235765874,
-0.0542378351,
0.01962566,
-0.0502288826,
-0.0004487695,
0.0003672438,
0.0820915699,
-0.0000941283,
0.0070774453,
-0.0046967622,
0.0170666482,
-0.0185928103,
-0.0155617734,
-0.0329926647,
0.0395329744,
-0.0094648404,
-0.0071815597,
-0.0175844468,
-0.0361183956,
-0.0474715531,
0.0077414461,
-0.0174010582,
-0.0028459432,
-0.0237472039,
-0.0282783583,
-0.0156841446,
0.0121618528,
-0.070644334,
0.0511596575,
-0.0046064351,
-0.1062724367,
-0.0065290406,
0.0633943379,
-0.0403789096,
0.0356350318,
0.0080503123,
-0.111652799,
0.0790126994,
0.020335624,
-0.0908043683,
-0.0011230183,
-0.0123699298,
-0.0039743497,
-0.0544759035,
0.0342203379,
0.0627248064,
-0.0423333123,
-0.011547029,
0.0581244677,
-0.1196780577,
-0.0366160683,
0.0252889488,
0.0456861295,
0.0145857092,
0.0527050868,
0.0094015105,
-0.0151250819,
0.0828078687,
0.019062819,
0.0313422754,
-0.0060437731,
0.055417303,
-0.0687122643,
-0.0237847436,
0.0151093565,
-0.0548252612,
0.0442841239,
0.0263462048,
-0.0197530128,
-0.0124779493,
-0.0041528293,
0.0174420159,
-0.0551322997,
0.0501016751,
0.0021476729,
0.0218411628,
0.0044744597,
0.0839095712,
0.0521501489,
0.0232807994,
-0.0174593851,
-0.0181536973,
0.0045681465,
0.0168865584,
0.006403944,
0.0466524698,
0.0884446725,
-0.027716523,
-0.0584545992,
0.0072390684,
0.0190561693,
-0.012507651,
-0.0050282772,
-0.0318813249,
0.0173302982,
-0.0338618383,
0.0359506868,
0.0203239433,
-0.0184963401,
0.0172450617,
0.037423078,
0.0124551784,
-0.098105967,
0.000611397,
-0.0622657314,
-0.0037138336,
-0.0424690731,
0.0598771125,
0.0211150236,
0.0112851243,
-0.0150437905,
-0.0307773687,
0.0161314178,
0.0146090491,
0.018250525,
-0.002608143,
-0.0022058855,
0.0464215502,
0.0155634172,
0.0212059543,
-0.0213127229,
0.0055219028,
0.0005240309,
0.0260357,
-0.0325429849,
0.0062570916,
-0.0400533155,
-0.0323678777,
-0.0003740599,
-0.0101473369,
0.0051192879,
0.0200405736,
0.015035741,
-0.0434527136,
0.0358100645,
-0.0243120249,
0.0789050087,
-0.0439876765,
0.0408764854,
0.0501479395,
-0.0119946003,
-0.0818108246,
0.0490585305,
-0.0206542015,
-0.0270001199,
0.035209395,
0.0038333016,
-6.549592241e-33,
0.0360730365,
0.011792344,
0.0101748696,
0.0171449296,
-0.0079395771,
0.0192501899,
-0.0071220617,
-0.0357669145,
-0.0063306163,
-0.0205418188,
-0.0124544892,
0.017514525,
0.0099099539,
0.0583960749,
0.0206022114,
-0.0327050351,
0.1215552166,
0.0292163007,
-0.0374156497,
0.0075896136,
0.0176244248,
-0.0193809178,
0.0597147346,
-0.0048610033,
-0.0702202022,
0.0103738075,
-0.0213879384,
-0.0128407422,
-0.0173626598,
0.0282869544,
-0.0199573841,
0.0454213843,
-0.0105259744,
-0.0385222174,
0.0196558796,
0.0049747489,
-0.0931801498,
0.029932458,
-0.0585315414,
0.0467104316,
-0.0115935337,
-0.0349505432,
0.0515777245,
0.0575602688,
-0.0446266644,
-0.0544868931,
0.0251935702,
0.018206615,
0.0169462785,
-0.0324788913,
0.0427169539,
0.0218455419,
-0.0231299512,
-0.0256886873,
0.0039889868,
0.0430014879,
-0.001537246,
-0.0006210946,
-0.0777006894,
-0.0063143452,
0.019527344,
0.0416279212,
0.0095805982,
0.016495984,
-0.0294148065,
0.0006110441,
0.0106982645,
-0.0204520822,
0.0463532247,
-0.0288748518,
0.0237523224,
0.0165872797,
0.0388534069,
-0.0009988872,
0.0727442056,
-0.0168615356,
-0.0606446974,
0.019457927,
0.0287832841,
0.0374671109,
0.0586181208,
0.0206887871,
-0.0056493985,
0.0052505014,
0.0272481367,
-0.0295079313,
0.0095811291,
-0.0118302135,
-0.0145744476,
0.0766736791,
-0.0353450552,
0.0175332837,
0.0302523691,
-0.0259511694,
0.0464717411,
0.0299335681,
0.017820254,
0.027799461,
0.0122084105,
0.0262333807,
-0.018095402,
-0.0226614196,
0.0212124754,
-0.0337814093,
-0.0104277283,
-0.0168344248,
0.0323473923,
0.0753947422,
-0.0577202886,
-0.0339911953,
-0.0352801569,
0.0518860444,
-0.0117996344,
0.0085577369,
0.040820431,
0.0522474162,
-0.0048307106,
-0.0018076695,
-0.0726870671,
-0.005667089,
-0.0034510903,
0.0650594234,
0.0330724455,
0.0347203203,
-0.0489754304,
-0.0025034389,
-0.0645101443,
-0.0172915682,
-0.0317223035,
-0.1316579282,
-0.0382045917,
0.0688445643,
2.85e-7,
-0.0105551807,
0.0206482895,
0.0211355109,
0.0013525682,
0.0004552501,
-0.0118986443,
0.026345823,
0.0404426083,
0.0227578394,
0.0301326681,
0.0178904366,
0.0292705726,
0.0454924032,
0.0062026917,
-0.0841877013,
-0.0029082289,
-0.0712594688,
0.0460815616,
0.0192905329,
0.0175185986,
0.0196400173,
0.0885143429,
0.0034623134,
0.0032318837,
0.0342027023,
0.0063581476,
-0.0079215579,
0.047867097,
0.0532638058,
-0.0289181247,
-0.013342171,
-0.0012064772,
-0.0055435821,
0.0428733416,
-0.0034733466,
0.0395507962,
-0.0372987315,
0.038081117,
0.0329802148,
-0.0355605185,
0.0267908741,
0.0163688622,
0.0321571752,
0.013391831,
0.0248028319,
-0.0451522321,
-0.0315445848,
0.0151912877,
0.0146621978,
0.0031800701,
0.0046580918,
0.0158414301,
0.0146859875,
0.0161605664,
0.0007106234,
-0.0389435515,
0.0191953108,
-0.0595193915,
0.001498726,
0.0223461222,
-0.038943775,
-0.0233798847,
-0.0329759046,
-0.0504201874,
0.074471876,
0.0083177052,
-0.0282745305,
2.471422919e-34,
0.0305902008,
0.0295270085,
-0.028883148,
0.0727717057,
0.0054728631,
-0.0323209614,
0.022110302,
-0.0098517481,
0.0146024367,
-0.0680664331,
-0.0365579724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12118v1 | Harnessing Dataset Cartography for Improved Compositional Generalization in Transformers | 2023-10-18T17:14:41 | 2023-10-18T17:14:41 | Osman Batur İnce, Tanin Zeraati, Semih Yagcioglu, Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh, Erkut Erdem, Aykut Erdem | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural networks have revolutionized language modeling and excelled in various
downstream tasks. However, the extent to which these models achieve
compositional generalization comparable to human cognitive abilities remains a
topic of debate. While existing approaches in the field have mainly focused on
novel architectures and alternative learning paradigms, we introduce a
pioneering method harnessing the power of dataset cartography (Swayamdipta et
al., 2020). By strategically identifying a subset of compositional
generalization data using this approach, we achieve a remarkable improvement in
model accuracy, yielding enhancements of up to 10% on CFQ and COGS datasets.
Notably, our technique incorporates dataset cartography as a curriculum
learning criterion, eliminating the need for hyperparameter tuning while
consistently achieving superior performance. Our findings highlight the
untapped potential of dataset cartography in unleashing the full capabilities
of compositional generalization within Transformer models. Our code is
available at https://github.com/cyberiada/cartography-for-compositionality. | [
-0.0016581316,
0.084745653,
-0.0255310908,
0.0178859048,
0.0140317762,
0.0333483815,
0.0190603472,
-0.0459659584,
-0.0486058034,
0.011517561,
-0.0536142439,
-0.0478495695,
0.0206736308,
-0.0183184817,
0.053358566,
-0.0316628069,
0.0159051176,
-0.0126038594,
-0.0707989931,
-0.0029314363,
-0.0445189402,
0.0213496983,
0.0004781683,
0.0742714852,
0.0041436525,
-0.008263221,
-0.0171155706,
0.0049120998,
-0.0012696999,
0.0257366467,
0.0306814481,
0.0314182229,
0.0057434342,
0.0820763558,
0.0000019493,
-0.0309306476,
0.0053341286,
-0.000611431,
-0.0020579053,
-0.0351878442,
0.0236489736,
0.0192667618,
0.0047022318,
0.0097221471,
-0.0268770196,
-0.0196895432,
0.0805108026,
0.0285942871,
0.0591067262,
0.0931771174,
-0.0224513412,
-0.0707765594,
0.0132118147,
-0.0142297596,
0.0002200388,
0.0350175984,
0.0170234013,
-0.0001680278,
-0.0278006662,
-0.0425118878,
-0.0453665704,
0.0234543625,
0.028523352,
0.0235989466,
-0.0038552345,
0.027191367,
-0.0769370869,
-0.0326168388,
0.0142911645,
0.076223582,
-0.0054594693,
-0.0301158056,
-0.000222432,
0.0122108608,
-0.0281248316,
-0.0388257802,
-0.0434116237,
0.0119065447,
-0.0106096398,
0.0268698875,
-0.0122781079,
-0.0182147678,
0.0377171189,
-0.0291744191,
-0.0520677492,
0.0579842888,
0.0225825701,
-0.0189473443,
0.0230060406,
-0.0077707432,
-0.0028937391,
-0.0079745352,
0.015644215,
0.0463791415,
-0.0495221652,
0.0067361463,
-0.0135796694,
-0.0294338986,
0.0003580356,
-0.0290248282,
0.0545788333,
0.041043736,
-0.0242515318,
0.0102330483,
-0.0220746547,
0.0816023424,
-0.0281193648,
0.0968878716,
-0.0486397296,
-0.0188139286,
-0.0518445298,
-0.0461285003,
-0.0576823093,
0.0022364387,
0.0145360501,
0.006542088,
-0.0486579053,
0.0161019042,
-0.0211890191,
0.0050036777,
0.0746880025,
0.0165006351,
-0.0933233052,
0.0203360245,
0.0291428082,
0.0319395699,
0.0022406226,
0.0207015015,
0.0106745735,
-0.0167314839,
-0.0106460396,
-0.0138292434,
0.0095838299,
-0.0146994339,
0.0115220258,
0.0679016933,
-0.0044173058,
-0.0293954927,
-0.0253254604,
0.0299266893,
-0.0359282643,
-0.0473463051,
0.0534265935,
-0.0688468292,
0.0212989487,
0.0042442265,
0.0047371993,
-0.0359276123,
-0.012655925,
0.0308752209,
-0.0018972051,
0.059750814,
0.0053438004,
-0.0136297895,
0.0144054918,
-0.0024576231,
-0.0131666791,
0.0847419649,
0.0438623466,
0.005310249,
-0.0011211085,
-0.014074849,
-0.0026594794,
0.035439413,
0.010485176,
-0.0222363677,
-0.0405348353,
-0.0444474742,
-0.0051318915,
0.0158781372,
0.023059506,
0.0491650589,
-0.0280948281,
-0.0324544907,
0.0519465134,
0.0208631642,
0.0518643185,
0.0263102595,
0.0632346943,
-0.0011573887,
0.0146874031,
0.0215376336,
-0.0203415714,
-0.0031171897,
0.0135425236,
0.0229468141,
-0.0220464505,
0.0547340922,
-0.0388058573,
-0.033677049,
-0.0043166564,
-0.0116979182,
0.0291425567,
-0.0247934759,
0.0477073453,
0.070648104,
-0.0324821211,
0.0683406144,
0.0468857735,
-0.0568321235,
0.0019841336,
-0.018501414,
9.92e-8,
0.0055266251,
0.0134655172,
-0.0362715684,
-0.0587789305,
-0.0069485474,
0.0241829492,
0.0446733423,
0.0255495533,
-0.0192056894,
0.0452727005,
-0.0642037988,
-0.000173577,
-0.0070814304,
0.0291941725,
0.0003050625,
0.0163893122,
-0.0450799391,
0.0131839551,
-0.0329326056,
-0.0246737674,
0.0375160575,
-0.028123606,
-0.0139617715,
0.0267361999,
0.0313242376,
0.0208154097,
-0.0008829966,
0.0053816391,
0.0024328188,
0.0163383074,
-0.0176243894,
-0.0387414023,
0.0259723943,
-0.0522341877,
-0.0285524782,
0.0288920738,
-0.0542879626,
-0.0080395741,
0.0437076166,
-0.0398319028,
-0.0354986973,
-0.0015282677,
-0.049421154,
0.0526519977,
-0.02641459,
0.0153277507,
-0.0217038076,
0.0162951089,
-0.0138725387,
0.0209232811,
0.0140663553,
0.0123819225,
0.0257511567,
0.0023244028,
-0.005688725,
-0.011251145,
-0.0499003418,
0.007854905,
-0.0380711779,
0.0078737391,
-0.0163655449,
-0.0103628896,
-0.0297565516,
-0.0266378131,
-0.0595580973,
-0.0290010739,
-0.0368513949,
0.0006417465,
0.0245262012,
0.0104339607,
0.0213745702,
0.0195378065,
-0.0182194598,
0.008175699,
-0.0065603773,
0.0230763461,
0.016200183,
-0.0132859675,
-0.0300202221,
-0.0107242968,
-0.0472758412,
-0.0357546732,
0.0892986283,
-0.0404319949,
0.0477951914,
-0.0442205444,
-0.0065685688,
-0.0047429549,
0.0108396672,
-0.0285198186,
-0.0511193909,
0.0083683738,
-0.0072841672,
0.0266399086,
0.0301179606,
-0.0100143151,
-0.020765245,
0.055991523,
-0.0195069872,
-0.021244267,
0.0183623359,
-0.0631052405,
-0.0099672964,
-0.0534082279,
-0.0016975625,
-0.0153243039,
0.0880320892,
0.0028415634,
-0.0194286108,
-0.0573612116,
0.0049899681,
-0.0319288634,
0.0131263398,
-0.0067247408,
-0.016250411,
-0.0319421664,
0.0273537748,
-0.0293060411,
-0.0260326918,
0.057331644,
-0.0299639106,
-0.0145639908,
-0.0295006819,
0.0204755589,
-0.0488494262,
0.0325277671,
0.0130762216,
0.0132155996,
0.0387284011,
-0.0462732762,
-0.0773232728,
0.0106298672,
-0.0165040363,
-0.0221906472,
0.0560612381,
-0.0060049091,
-0.04107875,
-0.0041548954,
-0.0335026532,
-0.0402218811,
0.043556124,
0.0103078857,
0.0491150208,
0.0878895149,
-0.0453517996,
-0.0397741385,
0.0085950159,
-0.0114594828,
0.0765758082,
-0.015429968,
-0.0141531825,
-0.0108709726,
0.0182835162,
0.0016692762,
0.0675378144,
0.0473113023,
-0.0184001643,
-0.0159646496,
0.0022025267,
0.0331422798,
0.0010342054,
-0.0515474528,
0.0230904575,
0.0236440562,
-0.0060416055,
-0.0026926843,
0.0164513309,
0.0215997659,
-0.0383961163,
-0.0575176552,
0.0859949887,
0.0102352258,
-0.0609876998,
0.0154501628,
0.0236513503,
0.0096382294,
0.061197307,
0.0460406542,
-0.0552549325,
0.0027438886,
0.0335444957,
-0.0044958671,
0.0016092903,
0.0098494506,
-0.0062449458,
-0.078597486,
0.0129222637,
0.0149897048,
-0.0603142716,
-0.0299782902,
-0.04030402,
-0.0071841469,
-0.0426523983,
0.0142521476,
0.0050325217,
-0.0239833947,
-0.0522014722,
0.0321883112,
-0.0427630618,
-0.0538288802,
-0.003723307,
-0.0204805005,
0.014065221,
0.0452680923,
0.0219537932,
-0.0019436757,
-0.0416362509,
0.0011175177,
0.0080605,
-0.0093304738,
0.0185181946,
0.0506850109,
0.0182826873,
-0.0316860788,
0.0338127688,
0.0325213894,
-0.0374319218,
-0.0124412915,
-0.039707616,
0.0566589125,
0.0059598223,
-0.0234366767,
-0.0096807759,
0.019864941,
-0.0077298451,
0.043007724,
0.0539849848,
-0.0360217392,
-0.0077668256,
-0.0467203483,
0.0068643335,
-0.0655518398,
-0.031705305,
0.0440878943,
0.0619643405,
-0.0354200713,
-0.0490365587,
0.0059323343,
0.011077893,
0.0293975137,
0.0296706669,
-0.0574971214,
0.0475070737,
0.0099538499,
-0.0577288717,
0.0247886721,
-0.0169067606,
0.0206255689,
-0.051033739,
-0.0178271048,
0.018020317,
-0.0577985011,
-0.059093032,
0.0105868019,
-0.1331506371,
-0.0586670153,
0.0406797938,
0.0472145826,
0.0170893688,
0.0056744362,
-0.0068114484,
-0.0542538203,
0.0682963803,
0.0564569347,
-0.0151879238,
0.0003982309,
0.071614787,
-0.0450125635,
-0.0015127779,
0.0296634734,
-0.0369041264,
0.0343180187,
0.0503668822,
0.029644601,
0.0251447707,
0.0742534623,
0.0367223844,
-0.0490439683,
0.0636468306,
0.0057597812,
0.0428038873,
-0.0505307429,
0.0462743491,
0.0195683781,
-0.0000766417,
-0.0387415327,
-0.0380874723,
0.0030746444,
0.0011147854,
-0.0157507509,
-0.0362551361,
0.0103814984,
0.0291167777,
-0.0374959558,
0.011180074,
0.0325087011,
-0.033473745,
0.0423308946,
0.0315807872,
-0.0073782466,
0.0225430988,
0.0199594442,
-0.0032306409,
-0.0077631511,
0.0068166885,
0.0090522589,
0.0421758629,
-0.0686211735,
-0.0035127057,
-0.0761149451,
-0.0155181875,
-0.0533938855,
-0.030180214,
0.0602443554,
-0.0415053293,
0.0071278643,
-0.0027300192,
-0.0039673331,
-0.0075113811,
0.0055890959,
-0.0119638527,
-0.0301857479,
0.0328802839,
0.0078846635,
0.0075485259,
-0.0228115432,
0.0769921616,
-0.0123420218,
0.0426034294,
-0.0201470722,
0.0159378462,
-0.0270500444,
-0.0562175065,
0.0338192359,
0.0039968691,
-0.0225443784,
-0.0404874757,
-0.0282891802,
-0.0700636879,
0.0333412737,
-0.0251774639,
0.0211751498,
-0.0055602281,
0.0417837314,
0.0484704301,
-0.0122121293,
-0.0057939612,
0.0158828665,
-0.0504829325,
0.0167553369,
0.0101489881,
-0.0215217061,
-6.181577285e-33,
-0.0274667479,
0.0015239355,
0.0208991114,
0.0296956208,
-0.0002556244,
0.0172839649,
-0.0370897502,
-0.0114530297,
-0.0077787801,
0.0058989474,
-0.0363164209,
0.0176956765,
0.0098548681,
0.0556075163,
-0.0000782914,
-0.0109665757,
0.068090409,
0.0082722548,
-0.0092693577,
0.0283483919,
0.0260480195,
0.0423239879,
0.0938818827,
-0.0167984795,
-0.021839235,
0.0319390967,
-0.014999941,
0.01191987,
-0.0368458219,
0.0837590918,
-0.000716594,
0.0814497322,
0.0108980034,
-0.0455693156,
-0.0247967541,
-0.0081538074,
-0.0693313405,
-0.0133575657,
-0.0206473693,
0.0218907297,
0.002573333,
-0.0323594809,
0.0833664984,
-0.0014157548,
-0.0080863954,
-0.0695993379,
0.0404480249,
-0.0066585792,
-0.0058537661,
-0.0881554484,
-0.0793254897,
-0.0098921815,
-0.0106750587,
-0.0066830232,
0.0037373414,
0.0606695339,
-0.0264628436,
0.0495675504,
-0.0748264715,
0.050550662,
0.0124774612,
0.0448328592,
0.0414914787,
0.0423878804,
-0.000481734,
0.035502743,
0.026666889,
0.0047901082,
-0.0109261358,
-0.0178731233,
0.0678338856,
0.0492252558,
0.0254074279,
0.0121826045,
0.0349233523,
-0.042361185,
-0.0511116274,
-0.005016712,
-0.0377942249,
0.0406221598,
0.0516782254,
-0.0086340494,
0.0079696337,
-0.0178240146,
-0.0510452129,
-0.0257926174,
-0.0296812356,
0.0096191885,
0.0042846031,
0.0111686802,
-0.0265884735,
0.0133765666,
0.015942879,
-0.0679910034,
0.0245290641,
0.048644226,
-0.0309058353,
0.0099868998,
-0.0056262766,
0.0150319394,
-0.0367404521,
-0.0621661954,
0.0298497789,
0.036945913,
0.0228899252,
-0.0041714669,
0.0732328221,
0.0775283799,
-0.0498225316,
-0.0148715833,
-0.0453721583,
-0.0015325556,
-0.0162302405,
0.0619965829,
0.0407907963,
0.0190930702,
-0.0204144586,
0.013052132,
-0.0238044113,
0.0106649222,
-0.0178481285,
0.0101700313,
0.0148148313,
0.0623961836,
-0.0183820929,
-0.0246992856,
-0.0294480957,
-0.0079873558,
0.0606063418,
-0.0672257841,
-0.0277906563,
0.0196543206,
2.608e-7,
0.0497997962,
0.0443422422,
0.0147513431,
0.0205261502,
0.0170141645,
-0.0203836188,
-0.0367086455,
0.0051979865,
-0.0032318402,
0.0189465284,
0.0300551616,
0.0337631553,
0.0651857108,
0.0356536321,
-0.1084734872,
-0.0127531746,
-0.0972760171,
0.0158987623,
-0.0463777818,
-0.0118059795,
-0.0001815223,
0.1205524057,
-0.0057113306,
-0.028150836,
0.0128045203,
0.0156241935,
0.0356208906,
-0.0110002104,
0.0583444349,
0.0383552797,
-0.0086958576,
0.0129302694,
0.0153078707,
0.0088737803,
-0.0160765946,
0.0430184603,
0.0132640842,
0.0308521092,
0.024934968,
-0.0488200188,
0.01957242,
0.0275111068,
-0.0232176632,
-0.0646256879,
0.0262631681,
-0.1155579388,
-0.0173442662,
-0.0231066067,
-0.0137130246,
0.0018314279,
0.0209007971,
-0.0383244455,
0.0189216156,
0.0143724997,
0.0180576518,
-0.0035575628,
0.0108088572,
-0.0761477798,
-0.0279437192,
0.0154825142,
-0.0653336942,
-0.0141474549,
-0.0224619824,
-0.0239654854,
0.0305160731,
0.0065240404,
0.012238971,
2.623769742e-34,
0.0217556283,
-0.0099763926,
0.015802294,
0.0082397684,
0.0187043156,
-0.0487784296,
0.0353494473,
-0.0046765045,
-0.0137587367,
-0.0812372044,
-0.0447372757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12100v1 | Non-Intrusive Adaptation: Input-Centric Parameter-efficient Fine-Tuning for Versatile Multimodal Modeling | 2023-10-18T16:43:08 | 2023-10-18T16:43:08 | Yaqing Wang, Jialin Wu, Tanmaya Dabral, Jiageng Zhang, Geoff Brown, Chun-Ta Lu, Frederick Liu, Yi Liang, Bo Pang, Michael Bendersky, Radu Soricut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Large language models (LLMs) and vision language models (VLMs) demonstrate
excellent performance on a wide range of tasks by scaling up parameter counts
from O(10^9) to O(10^{12}) levels and further beyond. These large scales make
it impossible to adapt and deploy fully specialized models given a task of
interest. Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) emerges as a promising
direction to tackle the adaptation and serving challenges for such large
models. We categorize PEFT techniques into two types: intrusive and
non-intrusive. Intrusive PEFT techniques directly change a model's internal
architecture. Though more flexible, they introduce significant complexities for
training and serving. Non-intrusive PEFT techniques leave the internal
architecture unchanged and only adapt model-external parameters, such as
embeddings for input. In this work, we describe AdaLink as a non-intrusive PEFT
technique that achieves competitive performance compared to SoTA intrusive PEFT
(LoRA) and full model fine-tuning (FT) on various tasks. We evaluate using both
text-only and multimodal tasks, with experiments that account for both
parameter-count scaling and training regime (with and without instruction
tuning). | [
0.0174589735,
0.0429235138,
-0.0201785155,
0.0560456663,
0.003673214,
0.0066063721,
0.0008781743,
-0.0113627566,
-0.0191826522,
-0.0785870776,
-0.074845612,
-0.0200272985,
0.0085372515,
0.0329915024,
0.0706879944,
-0.0705657452,
0.0608508289,
-0.0541143157,
-0.0365878642,
-0.0010437701,
0.017616801,
0.0056726565,
-0.0237471946,
0.0259416047,
0.0329367816,
0.0062956843,
-0.0239655748,
0.0433872193,
0.0125557603,
0.0210716669,
0.000636612,
0.0425018296,
0.0315441601,
0.0278280042,
0.000002035,
-0.0239583123,
0.0156447571,
-0.0007079041,
0.007792139,
0.0271165464,
0.0674352571,
-0.0124966335,
-0.0124129271,
0.0132944221,
-0.0109676421,
-0.0208530929,
0.0737619698,
0.0488935933,
0.0782131404,
0.0653833523,
-0.0164060537,
-0.0307985097,
0.0120415362,
-0.0256167278,
-0.0364014395,
-0.0070420578,
0.0091640074,
-0.0274369121,
0.013531358,
0.0052728001,
-0.062925823,
0.0363230072,
0.0150007801,
-0.0023754237,
0.0154875275,
0.011529888,
-0.043824289,
-0.0413108207,
-0.0166751947,
0.0775451586,
-0.0762648284,
0.0015945195,
-0.0075867702,
-0.008441261,
-0.0088113686,
-0.0255481787,
-0.0446345881,
-0.0190522503,
0.0161735062,
0.0009347507,
-0.0353005901,
-0.0378639735,
0.0295718331,
0.0028054682,
-0.0106540788,
-0.0087582218,
0.0246321969,
0.0089477533,
-0.0047437008,
-0.0261951014,
-0.0522932671,
-0.0184338149,
-0.0010177008,
0.0150497016,
-0.0079571223,
0.0002761759,
-0.0911298096,
-0.0261784289,
-0.0044459347,
-0.0099665113,
0.1096183434,
0.0434137322,
-0.0486195199,
0.0432048962,
-0.0638597161,
0.0278944727,
-0.0425781347,
0.035431277,
-0.0281462055,
0.0132517228,
-0.0306777768,
0.0108712055,
-0.0508648865,
-0.0171927381,
-0.077143237,
-0.0433349349,
0.0145291993,
0.0450662151,
0.0075889202,
-0.0238776319,
-0.0086389417,
-0.0099456739,
-0.0492042974,
-0.0229458511,
0.0071166763,
0.0658094585,
-0.0155916614,
0.0303547159,
-0.0081905173,
-0.0527197048,
-0.0002826209,
0.0362556651,
0.0247966964,
-0.0371093489,
-0.0056397845,
0.0857326984,
-0.0227130651,
-0.022007687,
-0.0469007455,
-0.0067156758,
-0.0086138695,
-0.0565207973,
0.0207919031,
-0.0328154713,
0.0290544797,
-0.0197433997,
0.0270582139,
-0.0494033657,
-0.0127560375,
0.0001357698,
-0.0264881011,
0.090346396,
0.0202036016,
0.0001740467,
0.0306394529,
0.0066637518,
0.0301729627,
0.0969250277,
0.0253796224,
0.0231078789,
0.0023635062,
-0.0194857325,
-0.0290709343,
0.0564468019,
0.0014322946,
0.0501797944,
-0.0332141705,
0.0042341645,
0.0283008553,
0.0422195904,
0.0486043245,
0.0512335598,
-0.0244575329,
-0.0453645773,
0.1060462818,
0.0097679421,
0.0518454723,
-0.0025137863,
0.0403713994,
-0.0245698467,
0.0231009293,
-0.008607314,
-0.0824338943,
0.0467669256,
-0.0245666392,
-0.0010832718,
0.0150777567,
0.068663165,
-0.0279791374,
-0.028607782,
-0.0209146999,
0.0045244158,
-0.0038761827,
-0.0037319581,
0.0332453325,
0.0103786821,
-0.0376689956,
-0.001638912,
0.032758832,
-0.0194269642,
0.0030531341,
-0.0484664552,
-0.0320269428,
0.0400815643,
0.0301462468,
-0.0040175766,
-0.0261748545,
-0.0085657733,
0.0654898286,
0.0470831841,
0.0662235171,
0.0069267359,
0.0422280878,
-0.0578166321,
-0.0212522894,
-0.0070090145,
0.002735507,
0.0208505131,
-0.0105993841,
0.0022310941,
-0.0023129825,
-0.024942996,
0.0183143336,
0.0553785861,
-0.0000881344,
-0.0135741103,
-0.0243509971,
0.0109307989,
0.012894528,
-0.0098535027,
-0.0185500197,
-0.0194547772,
0.0167823881,
-0.009037721,
0.0351795778,
0.0041132006,
-0.0357103795,
-0.0069364812,
0.0171183571,
-0.0077078603,
0.0430867374,
0.0320585184,
-0.032973662,
-0.0249167494,
0.0322417282,
-0.0322003253,
0.0200011823,
-0.0326056853,
0.0091147861,
-0.0233995859,
0.0334265754,
-0.0520325825,
-0.0159357358,
-0.0035404093,
-0.0274767186,
0.0072887493,
0.0370224603,
0.0078401454,
-0.0374361239,
-0.0536152422,
0.0311545637,
0.0289339442,
0.0301481616,
-0.0143485498,
-0.0127034988,
-0.0179548189,
-0.047464788,
-0.0831826329,
0.009265285,
-0.0205228534,
0.0156046432,
0.0087985266,
0.0072468389,
-0.0071055251,
-0.0270941574,
-0.0015866455,
0.052153904,
-0.0173784215,
0.0371497609,
0.0188556314,
0.0105374465,
-0.017072225,
-0.0341662467,
-0.0198652912,
0.0216150768,
0.0296564829,
-0.0348333232,
-0.0314528942,
-0.0802644193,
-0.0271506365,
-0.0269415844,
0.0556939542,
-0.02284972,
-0.0570168458,
-0.0016932564,
-0.0235105548,
0.0345195755,
0.0819608346,
-0.0034370862,
0.0178313889,
0.0515952632,
0.0257816203,
-0.0155256148,
0.0192741584,
0.0026898067,
-0.030830279,
-0.0505901277,
0.0410576873,
-0.0229672343,
0.0536508933,
-0.0322961062,
0.0006565264,
-0.0586034916,
0.0433208011,
-0.0169942155,
-0.0461478792,
-0.0315922238,
0.0151073923,
-0.0259174109,
-0.0032736089,
-0.0285096578,
-0.0695984289,
0.0380481035,
-0.0422839075,
-0.0369381495,
-0.0051649781,
-0.00901384,
-0.0054210504,
0.0528444462,
0.0564469285,
0.0318093598,
0.0298047941,
0.0100900689,
-0.0875299424,
0.0040826197,
0.0069231284,
-0.0017369799,
0.0864425674,
-0.0342939794,
-0.0112573979,
-0.0494494028,
-0.0219824389,
-0.0012464473,
-0.0103867678,
-0.0086281588,
0.0073093241,
-0.0247727912,
-0.0437058918,
-0.0362027213,
0.0364083014,
0.0209582131,
0.063855119,
-0.0289104991,
-0.0169236083,
-0.0476710685,
0.0085877767,
0.0714297593,
0.0691149011,
-0.0091641461,
-0.0361195058,
-0.0050991541,
0.021631917,
0.0065366193,
-0.0290227178,
-0.0626554713,
0.0466989502,
0.0178161208,
0.0105942525,
-0.021877097,
0.0148712322,
0.0775353163,
-0.0825726837,
0.013376398,
0.0493222661,
0.0052794404,
-0.0362432376,
0.0127387559,
0.0154360831,
0.0681092441,
0.0403572991,
0.0289337896,
-0.0576129518,
-0.0640633255,
0.0105099836,
0.0168901999,
0.0295477249,
0.0051467572,
-0.0184335262,
-0.0889664665,
0.041418165,
0.0466473401,
-0.0044460003,
-0.0344249904,
-0.009514343,
0.0291850865,
-0.0086119622,
0.0078613805,
0.0145121748,
-0.0288638137,
-0.0140676564,
0.0137635348,
0.0150561277,
-0.0468610674,
-0.0091790296,
-0.0265678279,
0.0493696854,
0.0240108967,
-0.0144326622,
0.0152115077,
-0.0236381292,
0.0820488483,
-0.0281070508,
0.0202057082,
-0.0233221166,
0.0413759835,
-0.0060282471,
-0.0221716147,
0.0386767648,
0.0187768843,
0.0003938675,
-0.0064567947,
-0.0109052081,
0.0576643348,
-0.0186961051,
0.0131521467,
-0.0246295165,
-0.0333090462,
-0.0158976093,
0.0247319564,
0.0356842428,
-0.0512494221,
-0.0113595473,
-0.0206820611,
-0.0393890031,
-0.0087243989,
-0.0352557823,
0.0100882342,
-0.010494886,
-0.0110690678,
-0.0529544726,
-0.0072772885,
0.0146285258,
0.065051958,
0.0113109238,
-0.0309204981,
-0.0136629855,
0.0252391845,
-0.0356525593,
0.0451614745,
-0.0456752442,
0.0323254168,
-0.0527050346,
-0.0001341774,
0.0401658118,
-0.0352277532,
0.0006657734,
0.0136187766,
-0.0705516338,
-0.0683184192,
0.0011558678,
0.0525241531,
0.0238821618,
0.0541509688,
-0.0072635259,
-0.0864860713,
0.0219966527,
0.0352948308,
0.005705683,
0.0549904853,
0.026563298,
-0.0318012759,
-0.010069605,
0.04070751,
-0.0480329506,
0.0035144354,
0.0120042879,
0.0192001686,
0.0237126593,
-0.0556022339,
-0.026226325,
0.0018536799,
0.0362081118,
-0.0085046971,
0.0019115296,
-0.0363294296,
0.0303587075,
-0.0035392179,
0.002893253,
-0.0632639378,
-0.0200752653,
0.0060231606,
0.0525658093,
0.0081052827,
-0.0211368613,
0.0245009866,
0.0484450236,
-0.046147529,
0.051637996,
0.0305095203,
-0.0171072725,
0.0322212055,
0.0612487271,
0.0043903263,
0.0466473997,
-0.0185587872,
0.0181332156,
-0.0563451201,
0.0578552261,
0.0203050636,
-0.0061659245,
-0.0816421434,
0.0704330653,
-0.0258721188,
-0.0172641054,
-0.061251577,
0.0471221991,
0.0238845143,
0.0184168946,
0.0564200543,
-0.0095614353,
-0.024736654,
-0.0271085594,
0.0407169908,
0.0257786158,
-0.00508417,
0.04632736,
0.0300197974,
-0.0041581849,
0.0092581799,
0.0419336595,
0.0136694293,
0.0752792954,
-0.0111640971,
0.0399606191,
-0.0337772928,
-0.0343977585,
0.0297990758,
0.0035017645,
-0.0190463532,
0.008903903,
-0.0053895474,
-0.0511075556,
-0.0470800027,
0.0083362646,
-0.0114683164,
-0.0265493467,
0.0364670008,
0.0224677417,
0.0124771101,
-0.034767881,
-0.0152633283,
-0.0449162461,
0.0172911212,
0.0035007857,
0.0339147858,
-6.466514912e-33,
-0.0493116081,
0.0319187567,
0.0107075106,
-0.0204900932,
-0.0494279265,
-0.000373015,
-0.0174180083,
0.0176176205,
-0.0334972218,
-0.0210701749,
0.0124515034,
-0.0378398523,
0.006555229,
0.0169151314,
-0.0192417987,
0.0199011788,
0.0499794409,
-0.0234785527,
-0.0199223664,
0.0050648642,
0.0074896645,
-0.0008456528,
0.0192467682,
-0.0181696732,
-0.0243169293,
0.0225825496,
-0.0446952842,
0.025930237,
-0.0010635743,
0.0783264637,
-0.0174733885,
0.0434305705,
-0.0007655909,
-0.0105291633,
-0.0492015257,
0.0334062427,
-0.079569228,
0.0016457044,
0.0008063231,
0.0266153552,
-0.0558655038,
-0.0074060513,
0.082904093,
-0.0147571312,
-0.0068578417,
-0.0247368086,
0.0230026618,
-0.047863476,
-0.0270808805,
0.0221397262,
-0.0897347853,
0.0271326452,
0.0096332291,
-0.0305131581,
0.0264086388,
0.0172617603,
0.0108481264,
0.0132824173,
-0.0381747931,
-0.0085129682,
0.0124179767,
0.0519095361,
0.0563987121,
0.0692473799,
-0.011100118,
0.0318000391,
0.0203066599,
-0.0199329723,
0.0120199108,
-0.0095378561,
0.08799389,
0.0234063584,
0.0426237956,
0.0616819449,
0.0141005721,
-0.0195431113,
-0.0363465771,
-0.0283598695,
0.0221429039,
0.0417684838,
0.0086454935,
0.0540162399,
-0.0070493449,
0.0050507048,
-0.0520694964,
-0.0156047139,
-0.0399451442,
-0.0277185608,
0.0557049401,
0.0157866776,
-0.0081144301,
0.0248801503,
0.0670643598,
-0.0316081531,
0.0142556513,
-0.0174644534,
-0.0268257745,
0.054085549,
0.0029408839,
0.0306481421,
-0.0339703225,
-0.069385536,
0.0545976795,
0.0127964728,
0.0186418146,
-0.0356150232,
0.0299734026,
0.0702888817,
-0.0796035379,
-0.0038708935,
-0.0381215513,
-0.0008892445,
0.0344296321,
0.0776756257,
0.0311429296,
-0.0464347228,
-0.0280658659,
0.041039627,
-0.0162299927,
-0.0332439616,
-0.0299732257,
-0.0244613662,
0.0082078231,
0.0206692908,
-0.0271789636,
0.0165979303,
-0.0331978686,
-0.0270275045,
0.0228910428,
-0.0633089319,
-0.0229266658,
0.0287003908,
2.792e-7,
0.0247379597,
0.0460755602,
-0.0123353172,
-0.0439811535,
0.0409749858,
0.0387821943,
-0.0205976479,
0.0456506275,
0.0012548621,
-0.0114283664,
-0.0233428832,
0.055546701,
0.0529051274,
-0.0012000722,
-0.0372620746,
-0.0020248548,
-0.0351382978,
0.0342084616,
-0.0387527868,
-0.0214139353,
0.0069250218,
0.1077881008,
-0.0051080491,
-0.0137319705,
0.0428984836,
-0.0589238741,
0.039502237,
-0.0151581885,
-0.0062080692,
-0.0072989431,
-0.0025767679,
0.0500644855,
-0.0180953834,
-0.0135152191,
-0.0102782864,
0.0167781468,
0.0034630108,
0.0796061754,
-0.0550614707,
0.0059799878,
0.0279419906,
0.0090874452,
-0.041679386,
-0.0658312589,
0.0734386593,
-0.0606726073,
-0.0145690301,
-0.0494802818,
0.0194275081,
-0.0218388457,
0.0010749853,
-0.0386028402,
-0.0338820815,
0.0404625013,
0.0493078381,
-0.0245417133,
-0.0500519723,
-0.0916133597,
-0.0381047651,
0.0250730701,
-0.0416240245,
-0.0464380905,
-0.0693571344,
-0.0282182582,
0.0623100735,
-0.0524444655,
-0.0389588326,
2.576279311e-34,
0.0387641937,
-0.0442193076,
0.0411957093,
-0.0358816348,
0.009614652,
-0.0104613993,
-0.003001096,
0.0066353162,
0.0193301886,
-0.0892755315,
-0.0301522091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13017v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13017v1 | Position Interpolation Improves ALiBi Extrapolation | 2023-10-18T16:41:47 | 2023-10-18T16:41:47 | Faisal Al-Khateeb, Nolan Dey, Daria Soboleva, Joel Hestness | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Linear position interpolation helps pre-trained models using rotary position
embeddings (RoPE) to extrapolate to longer sequence lengths. We propose using
linear position interpolation to extend the extrapolation range of models using
Attention with Linear Biases (ALiBi). We find position interpolation
significantly improves extrapolation capability on upstream language modelling
and downstream summarization and retrieval tasks. | [
0.0207075737,
0.0562909171,
-0.0013576926,
-0.0163395312,
0.0065068998,
0.0022829005,
0.0017704889,
-0.0190747585,
-0.0330678038,
-0.0032122929,
-0.0121455546,
-0.0249809474,
0.0111564063,
-0.0001149531,
0.0483906716,
-0.099712126,
0.0290753022,
-0.027894238,
0.0382713974,
0.0189921036,
0.0295097865,
0.0060156034,
0.0148457726,
0.0517225899,
0.0102473339,
0.0200401079,
-0.034420073,
-0.0144950524,
0.0387213975,
0.0009258122,
0.0178808346,
0.0226462521,
0.0730696172,
-0.0015826249,
0.0000016661,
0.0236047711,
0.0077103898,
-0.0193021353,
-0.0050315736,
0.0106511936,
0.0035840461,
-0.0252270848,
0.062218979,
0.018387856,
-0.0296997894,
-0.0194183625,
0.0303320438,
0.0151753416,
0.0573827662,
0.0666688904,
-0.0096321991,
-0.0119462619,
0.0147339934,
-0.0752451643,
0.0356323645,
-0.0346786082,
-0.0026838016,
0.0258410517,
0.02056453,
0.0377783813,
0.0047709718,
0.0628365725,
0.0451667756,
0.009095489,
-0.0058050742,
0.0474888422,
0.0204037074,
0.0070928405,
-0.0083695902,
0.0729012936,
-0.0743731558,
-0.015534888,
-0.0378232263,
-0.0004849418,
0.0533381589,
-0.0145913176,
-0.0959348753,
0.0419693068,
0.0073414929,
-0.0079615209,
0.0186731536,
0.0220904946,
0.0293808039,
0.0093782917,
-0.0525163487,
0.0438609011,
0.0002618998,
-0.0436575636,
-0.0410165153,
-0.0011548457,
-0.0697916299,
-0.0092414301,
0.0444245636,
0.0473205224,
0.0341786146,
0.018193597,
-0.0585191101,
0.0106581226,
-0.0035429995,
-0.013515126,
0.0686411336,
0.0525799356,
0.0267302468,
0.0372559242,
-0.013682588,
0.0489084534,
-0.0201165825,
0.0556903444,
-0.0614596494,
0.0393187664,
-0.0002257963,
-0.0379707329,
-0.0554378368,
0.0201918036,
-0.047198303,
-0.0302161332,
-0.0127443466,
0.0404918678,
0.0203795768,
-0.0450572632,
-0.0037441375,
0.0238534082,
-0.03588029,
-0.0220468026,
0.021415446,
0.0432524048,
-0.0371385776,
0.0381048881,
0.030200528,
-0.042280715,
-0.0575305261,
-0.0018339249,
0.0063316682,
-0.0217104554,
-0.0139172534,
0.0320673734,
0.0187307596,
-0.0494728871,
0.0058262441,
0.0014075309,
-0.0146993343,
-0.0617758334,
0.0296732467,
-0.0793006942,
0.0314261876,
-0.0156402513,
-0.0187819265,
-0.0229650531,
0.0111527201,
0.042042505,
-0.0581709221,
0.0392711237,
-0.0062077097,
-0.0027314564,
-0.0223647542,
0.0123033952,
0.0269067548,
0.0548546128,
0.022027649,
0.0266095009,
-0.00589125,
0.0284110308,
-0.0116558969,
0.007710645,
0.0352879092,
-0.0181534607,
-0.0284888931,
0.0089735994,
-0.0074854521,
0.0148375714,
0.0361590944,
0.0160149336,
-0.0578924194,
0.0090358127,
0.0498279929,
0.0856983885,
-0.003196711,
-0.0137471864,
0.0588674881,
0.0030500712,
-0.0022160609,
0.0521105342,
-0.0541136935,
0.067111887,
0.0363586508,
0.0533774532,
0.0658382997,
0.0291906446,
-0.037800312,
-0.0489598438,
0.0013874621,
0.0075916466,
0.0110560628,
0.0100727566,
-0.0062383371,
0.0061372668,
-0.0252586585,
0.0343630314,
-0.0002905662,
-0.0497656763,
0.0045698131,
0.0114831254,
-0.0330117829,
0.0810484886,
-0.0063042599,
-0.0480864793,
-0.0495978184,
-0.022188928,
-0.0053798179,
0.0192194451,
0.0135956816,
0.0147549361,
0.025836423,
-0.0244334172,
-0.0206227284,
0.0008198868,
0.0098395636,
0.0156462789,
0.026723478,
-0.0136008849,
0.0432881042,
-0.0171862729,
-0.0308743324,
0.0109502459,
-0.0683383271,
-0.0060073426,
-0.0460217074,
-0.0028980174,
-0.0036931585,
0.0124515723,
0.0104398942,
0.0425124243,
0.0673475489,
-0.0378083922,
0.0300010517,
0.0131578362,
-0.0798265785,
-0.0703278333,
0.074661456,
-0.0283902586,
-0.0047045387,
0.003794793,
-0.015217077,
-0.0393477492,
0.0578116998,
-0.0571212061,
0.0166037325,
-0.0182862971,
0.0373140499,
0.0158922747,
0.0309471507,
-0.0580093265,
0.0251111239,
-0.0327256694,
0.0626737103,
0.0306476988,
-0.0112027926,
-0.0482711531,
-0.0122776926,
-0.0131287584,
-0.0020161876,
0.0048345467,
-0.0050020893,
0.0125539126,
-0.0243869033,
-0.0141584743,
-0.0163084418,
-0.0773347095,
-0.008430629,
-0.0217774138,
0.0084206657,
0.0242881011,
0.0475484133,
-0.0047912779,
-0.0409510583,
-0.027753517,
-0.0607331395,
0.0058771586,
0.0323726386,
0.0006845433,
0.044490315,
0.0129790325,
-0.0651755631,
-0.042056255,
0.0124358479,
0.0587069876,
-0.0156586319,
-0.03530683,
-0.0576432459,
-0.0202383269,
-0.0181209799,
0.0039046193,
-0.0162219144,
-0.0223590862,
-0.0153677659,
-0.0647140071,
0.0160520468,
0.0424898602,
-0.0049183341,
-0.0034221038,
0.0423237421,
-0.0161254685,
-0.0623245686,
0.0162077621,
-0.040947035,
0.0441297144,
-0.0432934873,
0.0096733011,
-0.0278139431,
0.0654179007,
-0.0236671735,
-0.0045376359,
-0.0348926857,
0.0283700079,
0.0155381076,
-0.0142829763,
-0.0119165918,
-0.0253545064,
-0.0254116729,
0.0132721411,
-0.0608725958,
-0.0629389808,
0.0634734556,
-0.0192730203,
-0.0051457258,
-0.0328466333,
-0.0016099833,
-0.0325376652,
0.038709458,
0.0489889234,
0.004881843,
-0.0625696257,
-0.0322945639,
-0.0404702686,
0.0288374592,
-0.0226977244,
-0.0351823494,
0.0830878988,
-0.0149527574,
0.0105819674,
0.0099584712,
-0.0178151093,
-0.0345887467,
-0.0875722989,
-0.0100463871,
0.0202821344,
0.0144729381,
-0.0219937228,
-0.0174147468,
0.0215098485,
0.0401907563,
0.0637694225,
-0.0220449362,
0.0213999189,
-0.0280288663,
0.0142993247,
0.0476935208,
0.0127353147,
0.0018541398,
-0.0367284119,
0.0100906873,
0.020411659,
0.0221561007,
-0.0026448076,
-0.0220116787,
0.0257783886,
0.0277792122,
-0.0604882054,
-0.0068224277,
-0.0092703048,
-0.0109981056,
-0.0443824194,
-0.0118436003,
0.0964452177,
0.0190779604,
-0.058416333,
-0.0033852267,
0.0312602744,
0.0717258975,
0.0358857401,
0.0378912389,
-0.0330349207,
-0.0010065968,
0.0149370199,
-0.0172229689,
0.0428007133,
-0.0037178625,
-0.0395005979,
-0.1039496809,
0.006111803,
0.0139823463,
-0.0256585982,
-0.0582337044,
-0.0282277521,
0.0106706722,
0.0601199828,
0.0135229658,
0.0362408236,
-0.0523658693,
0.0074400189,
0.0327494852,
-0.056556385,
-0.0444154181,
-0.0572309494,
-0.0138135981,
-0.0212092511,
0.0272109285,
0.002355255,
0.0018226745,
0.008913002,
0.0380052887,
-0.0084608877,
-0.0010600968,
0.0162587073,
0.0638359785,
-0.0193233024,
0.006687277,
-0.0070478525,
0.0107015893,
-0.0146063147,
0.0013293879,
-0.0527935028,
0.0561972372,
-0.002014206,
0.013986228,
-0.025546927,
0.0337876081,
-0.0150458319,
0.0023982411,
0.0605973415,
-0.025123667,
-0.0192137845,
-0.029590467,
-0.0073801866,
-0.0236839037,
-0.0239230581,
0.0215541217,
0.0117271701,
-0.002872101,
-0.0620114394,
-0.0783017501,
0.028630957,
0.0527359694,
0.0018853969,
0.0038627542,
-0.0081334617,
-0.024497157,
-0.0598502643,
0.0202514548,
0.0247605424,
0.010965989,
0.0235958621,
0.041007638,
0.0281392802,
-0.0156173352,
-0.012880302,
-0.0081527466,
-0.0774134025,
-0.0725923777,
0.0159800928,
0.0777417198,
0.0227229968,
0.0948157683,
-0.0299864244,
-0.0112066455,
0.0585574731,
-0.0058468562,
-0.0065268641,
0.0174859688,
0.0294636432,
0.0103820628,
0.0165494364,
0.0263522379,
-0.0435255915,
0.0004184882,
0.0004263828,
0.0158037394,
-0.0316704549,
-0.0643978193,
0.0153312497,
-0.0002103396,
0.0428064503,
0.0218986925,
0.0538653508,
-0.0241016038,
0.0217248648,
-0.0283845682,
0.0112404888,
-0.04609688,
0.0101816943,
0.0237231459,
0.0174330566,
-0.0017548528,
0.0203876086,
0.0232905336,
-0.0433160663,
-0.0076794773,
-0.0131177725,
-0.058022894,
-0.01426089,
-0.0214830134,
0.0344203189,
-0.0602872707,
-0.0096141389,
-0.0591268316,
0.0309170783,
-0.0130171543,
-0.0133673577,
0.0236955341,
-0.0069315168,
-0.02503765,
0.0347941704,
-0.1237237602,
-0.0163198877,
-0.0316900574,
-0.0020625449,
0.0687836558,
-0.0691494048,
0.0655759573,
0.031090498,
-0.0003492775,
-0.0069166766,
0.0058075716,
-0.0057940795,
-0.0390892439,
-0.0192603339,
0.0357794911,
-0.0068660434,
0.0107550304,
0.0702017695,
0.0068620373,
0.0267872717,
-0.0199487042,
-0.0229707155,
-0.0002300023,
-0.0588351786,
-0.0284110252,
0.0305943098,
-0.000857318,
0.0322992429,
-0.0039187986,
-0.0561246574,
-0.0112396078,
0.008607869,
-0.0203300994,
-0.0119893169,
0.0292499289,
0.0283667762,
-0.0130837997,
0.0002153318,
-0.0266859569,
-0.0140950112,
-0.0510138534,
-0.0319179483,
-0.0273880381,
-6.109812988e-33,
-0.0555454306,
0.0029224474,
-0.0038977072,
-0.0190247688,
-0.0798529908,
0.0054234634,
-0.0017020378,
0.0260814,
0.0058318623,
-0.0002158057,
-0.0325801298,
0.0203209072,
0.0122413067,
0.0235994104,
0.0059408071,
0.014421029,
0.0152911805,
0.0392988957,
0.0070617688,
-0.001879766,
0.0317861699,
0.0661888644,
0.0793779269,
-0.0134325633,
0.0100375479,
-0.0052614389,
0.0047288793,
-0.0164381228,
-0.0118729006,
0.0398689099,
-0.0114887292,
-0.0057402565,
0.0255914889,
-0.0106024817,
-0.0886318386,
0.0207196865,
-0.0790072978,
-0.0129237846,
0.02792353,
0.0094106775,
-0.042275954,
-0.0535332225,
0.0550415143,
-0.0325931385,
0.0426407084,
-0.0589179844,
0.0314061642,
-0.0546227433,
-0.0456291884,
0.0377208367,
0.0004438603,
0.0012617051,
-0.0018383138,
0.0195511375,
0.0316013806,
0.0886273906,
-0.0004485839,
-0.0246731937,
-0.0274568852,
0.0186446793,
0.0235808492,
0.0817211196,
0.0164578557,
0.0286447406,
0.0102790268,
0.0552046597,
0.0007769241,
-0.0400679149,
-0.021208683,
-0.0135413092,
0.0085523473,
0.0097521516,
0.0212584343,
-0.0346136615,
0.0575707592,
0.0300508253,
-0.0250016004,
-0.0066746874,
-0.0132025434,
0.0403349809,
0.0557123534,
-0.0086057438,
-0.0079299137,
-0.0327249095,
-0.0316288136,
-0.0177906435,
-0.0133628966,
-0.0620606542,
0.0277676694,
0.0593768805,
0.0219870824,
0.0403692089,
0.0581833944,
-0.0095281517,
0.0063633104,
0.0253262334,
-0.0078884037,
0.0170532111,
0.0138151916,
0.0435642041,
-0.0386000574,
0.0268226489,
-0.0123098437,
0.0005922796,
-0.0053503551,
-0.0036949222,
0.0599733405,
0.0113627473,
-0.0473812185,
-0.033123903,
-0.0269333497,
0.001925761,
-0.0117630633,
0.0248634573,
0.0642830804,
0.0000474113,
-0.0140388506,
0.1004858837,
-0.0281903893,
0.0223020837,
-0.004224747,
-0.0191572588,
0.0181902181,
0.0537433326,
-0.0233231317,
-0.0054425788,
-0.0357553177,
0.0676794574,
-0.0385832787,
-0.0824007168,
-0.0246940181,
0.025306223,
2.557e-7,
0.0394663811,
0.0046094623,
0.0944379717,
-0.0053989715,
0.0078838281,
-0.0411997288,
-0.0030457568,
0.0212210026,
0.0020272478,
0.0134706805,
-0.0054085501,
0.0407068208,
0.0282784924,
-0.0010568995,
-0.1013187394,
-0.056489747,
-0.0748405755,
0.0085529685,
-0.0183396172,
-0.0713906586,
0.0169580113,
0.1120528728,
-0.0050898832,
0.0260834806,
0.0015295807,
-0.0309001729,
0.0584996715,
-0.0104863336,
-0.0349863097,
0.0022945621,
0.0586569495,
0.0416813716,
-0.0185937732,
-0.0292601231,
-0.002704592,
0.022375783,
0.049621772,
0.0541184507,
0.0003000374,
-0.022605041,
-0.0130857313,
-0.0028223298,
-0.0061807726,
-0.016011076,
0.0371841304,
-0.0684463978,
0.0162488725,
-0.0001460154,
-0.0824267566,
0.0045270948,
0.0044009886,
0.0013826572,
0.0085234195,
0.0211574063,
0.0157738328,
-0.0325415432,
0.0022351195,
-0.1050760522,
-0.0460978709,
0.0305158552,
-0.0554383919,
-0.0001774308,
-0.0503414609,
-0.026904624,
0.0543197505,
-0.0388526507,
-0.0097359009,
2.12816663e-34,
0.0475840569,
-0.0129957628,
0.0371400751,
0.0226930007,
0.008517134,
-0.0361674838,
0.0368234403,
0.001338721,
0.0561379567,
-0.1091518775,
-0.0421468206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12086v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12086v3 | FactCHD: Benchmarking Fact-Conflicting Hallucination Detection | 2023-10-18T16:27:49 | 2024-05-26T16:37:01 | Xiang Chen, Duanzheng Song, Honghao Gui, Chenxi Wang, Ningyu Zhang, Yong Jiang, Fei Huang, Chengfei Lv, Dan Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG | Despite their impressive generative capabilities, LLMs are hindered by
fact-conflicting hallucinations in real-world applications. The accurate
identification of hallucinations in texts generated by LLMs, especially in
complex inferential scenarios, is a relatively unexplored area. To address this
gap, we present FactCHD, a dedicated benchmark designed for the detection of
fact-conflicting hallucinations from LLMs. FactCHD features a diverse dataset
that spans various factuality patterns, including vanilla, multi-hop,
comparison, and set operation. A distinctive element of FactCHD is its
integration of fact-based evidence chains, significantly enhancing the depth of
evaluating the detectors' explanations. Experiments on different LLMs expose
the shortcomings of current approaches in detecting factual errors accurately.
Furthermore, we introduce Truth-Triangulator that synthesizes reflective
considerations by tool-enhanced ChatGPT and LoRA-tuning based on Llama2, aiming
to yield more credible detection through the amalgamation of predictive results
and evidence. The benchmark dataset is available at
https://github.com/zjunlp/FactCHD. | [
0.0214459039,
0.0072202184,
-0.0004381031,
0.0696455687,
-0.0629063696,
0.0227668975,
-0.0199226644,
-0.0004180272,
-0.0018608422,
-0.0253040083,
0.0194549151,
-0.0139784459,
0.0242435038,
-0.0154988458,
0.0066039865,
-0.0261764359,
0.0576690063,
-0.0262050815,
0.0252129603,
-0.0168940704,
0.0149667431,
0.0365027189,
-0.0456392132,
0.0190381408,
-0.0649968833,
-0.0546234064,
-0.0123348534,
0.0229994729,
0.040428739,
-0.0019277896,
-0.0153035382,
0.0422138199,
-0.0249200296,
0.0986441821,
0.0000020707,
-0.0468007922,
-0.0197494477,
-0.0050707608,
-0.0063322331,
0.0010274501,
0.0348879099,
0.026349023,
-0.0255455207,
-0.019034829,
-0.0202470869,
0.0229991786,
0.0086078793,
0.1125913039,
0.0632555708,
0.1036694869,
-0.0051761004,
-0.0083526634,
0.0310195014,
0.0293523353,
0.0452037603,
0.0403669998,
0.0292064007,
0.0372388922,
-0.019129131,
0.0009428875,
0.0005269521,
0.0057133865,
0.0058428561,
-0.0018270871,
-0.0409768522,
0.0196164716,
-0.0741387308,
-0.0173142068,
0.0173016824,
0.0425313376,
-0.0106585752,
-0.0528538451,
0.0113257831,
0.0009969111,
0.0011409982,
0.0319578573,
0.01224986,
0.0176865309,
-0.0870735347,
0.0248661377,
0.0689132959,
0.0088434024,
0.0151288733,
-0.00863712,
-0.0155880759,
0.0621282235,
0.002785472,
-0.0185008943,
0.0091486899,
0.0178231318,
0.0022246498,
-0.0676537901,
-0.0000351454,
-0.0078907805,
-0.044378832,
-0.0293688662,
-0.0430835783,
0.0040809093,
0.0475089252,
-0.0884901881,
-0.0087392321,
0.0044533759,
-0.1077547967,
0.0511025898,
-0.0134858293,
0.0069446852,
-0.0083309086,
0.0590119399,
-0.0107544865,
-0.0101687331,
0.0101390304,
0.0135264453,
-0.0174409673,
-0.0016737313,
-0.0037818926,
-0.0036373984,
-0.0168875121,
-0.0280828644,
-0.013701967,
0.0574299917,
-0.0248796958,
0.0057350625,
-0.0115311202,
-0.0257020444,
-0.0433089286,
0.0109901456,
-0.0126799932,
0.0003033945,
0.0172403138,
-0.0613975488,
-0.0236775875,
0.0487802438,
-0.0285300184,
0.0131433578,
0.0072971634,
0.0123734847,
0.0166934356,
0.0126512442,
-0.0590362251,
-0.0418026261,
0.0077367998,
-0.0878594518,
-0.0044034412,
-0.0676037818,
-0.0018468373,
-0.0414913185,
-0.0099105677,
0.0113581931,
0.0348558612,
0.0169057641,
-0.0056000128,
0.0601552576,
-0.072511062,
-0.0494290143,
0.0252104942,
0.0488583371,
-0.0388967581,
0.0859799087,
0.013955812,
0.0647702664,
0.0337587483,
0.0344477929,
0.0442456417,
-0.0228719208,
-0.0113301035,
0.0189587045,
0.0236506648,
-0.0060066185,
0.0002380756,
0.02013289,
0.0148617346,
0.01577265,
-0.0361857079,
-0.0479053557,
0.0529279746,
-0.0018105163,
0.0192807503,
0.0024751776,
0.0206831302,
-0.013732601,
0.0311182328,
0.0482068509,
-0.03095413,
0.0187415406,
-0.0397786312,
-0.006377216,
0.0312667526,
0.0459432937,
0.0084855957,
-0.0296060182,
-0.0310305823,
0.0031713585,
-0.0583670922,
-0.036059618,
-0.008539388,
0.0193150826,
-0.0526361391,
0.0222179964,
0.0318981372,
-0.0352058224,
-0.0180964135,
-0.0372360982,
-0.0006183787,
0.0703634843,
0.0584226102,
-0.061804384,
-0.0145107349,
-0.0289068315,
0.0395081639,
0.0664600432,
0.0111348461,
0.0010033082,
0.0135125713,
-0.0472617745,
0.0330211222,
-0.0251233056,
0.0557192415,
0.0156467538,
-0.0264427513,
0.0076130219,
-0.0251873955,
-0.0319075026,
-0.0127848135,
0.0244657546,
0.008884972,
0.002419651,
-0.0289027803,
-0.0272377562,
-0.0122595243,
0.0027608196,
-0.0289723147,
0.0011638959,
0.0028029345,
-0.0297047626,
-0.0367607884,
0.0401422493,
-0.02274229,
-0.0745001361,
0.0301244948,
-0.0438613705,
-0.0256557129,
-0.0331167392,
-0.0282042548,
-0.0236275475,
-0.0194074903,
-0.0493008718,
0.0280150902,
-0.0407029875,
0.0343747251,
0.021242559,
0.0570922755,
0.0146931857,
0.1028528512,
-0.0503658615,
0.0055472087,
0.0078712758,
0.0014258478,
0.0109212594,
0.0005416934,
0.0085101509,
0.0246523451,
0.0182215944,
0.0272203106,
-0.0392577425,
-0.0258243252,
-0.0562915765,
-0.0187325291,
-0.020910332,
0.0282882378,
-0.0360511057,
0.0256565232,
0.0392974168,
-0.0516735874,
-0.023716474,
0.0114581119,
-0.0091412337,
0.0294259153,
-0.0136096617,
0.0138790458,
0.0227728188,
-0.0320395529,
-0.0193305109,
-0.0057431916,
0.0535459258,
-0.0281528458,
0.0380135141,
0.0051991208,
-0.0455986336,
-0.0831165239,
0.0099839382,
-0.0696357042,
-0.0000506728,
-0.031991981,
0.0156724062,
0.0265375059,
0.0100191766,
0.0589907318,
0.0397321433,
0.0059086694,
0.0259881932,
0.055044394,
-0.0411250442,
-0.0018064665,
-0.0233218279,
0.0067043449,
0.0668575913,
0.0008426491,
-0.0660604537,
0.00948097,
0.012485317,
0.0298594516,
0.0126877315,
-0.0389514044,
0.0123637123,
-0.0103538968,
-0.0488813184,
0.0416241325,
-0.0217940025,
0.0008726835,
0.0671802312,
-0.0286762137,
-0.0294597279,
0.0536618233,
-0.0526608787,
0.0254853349,
-0.0289917365,
-0.0020516855,
-0.0311159287,
-0.0021822613,
0.0118969884,
0.0179280844,
0.0050770608,
0.0082768817,
0.0141453994,
0.0006813732,
0.0373560712,
-0.0481454618,
0.0137917288,
-0.0382302664,
-0.0018588138,
0.0127772782,
-0.0044332384,
-0.0431286097,
-0.0329821743,
0.0119139468,
-0.0580864847,
-0.0450707301,
-0.0062040375,
-0.0471202768,
-0.0250005461,
-0.0076389387,
0.0128959948,
0.0071505033,
-0.030589981,
-0.000811749,
-0.0083378032,
0.036939621,
0.0087176524,
0.0871062502,
-0.0110785635,
0.0176129043,
0.1191376373,
-0.0103955129,
0.0140576689,
-0.0155404042,
-0.0230502002,
-0.0086795539,
-0.0046965601,
-0.0131108137,
-0.0268762596,
0.0348710343,
-0.0426781327,
-0.0067535499,
0.0616728961,
0.0312091894,
-0.0358509645,
0.0020379922,
-0.0658770129,
0.0451813638,
0.0054597547,
-0.0365353487,
-0.1144661009,
0.0043917038,
0.0031946334,
-0.0188877136,
-0.0489175916,
-0.0467163809,
-0.032371819,
-0.0446348488,
0.0467217378,
0.0133543238,
0.0061189504,
-0.007247657,
-0.0259859338,
0.0197317153,
0.0193486009,
0.0006945867,
-0.0157290399,
0.0287987683,
-0.008165488,
-0.017991215,
-0.0206529777,
0.0066544279,
0.0165577959,
-0.0113801146,
0.0377483703,
0.0190092809,
0.0365597419,
0.0205852482,
-0.0671831444,
-0.0002323252,
0.0170214642,
-0.0218069106,
0.0083455145,
0.0635699779,
0.0080242986,
0.0222742409,
-0.0408664942,
0.0172732882,
-0.0113103883,
-0.0507572964,
0.0037679193,
0.066288583,
-0.0479578152,
-0.0223376434,
-0.0123177087,
0.0713681579,
0.0173016973,
0.0660539269,
0.0308484044,
0.0296088737,
-0.0345400274,
-0.0363453142,
0.0328165255,
-0.0311048385,
-0.0505870879,
0.0436699651,
0.056515798,
-0.0309816841,
-0.0778293163,
-0.0198753066,
-0.0406477489,
0.0329579711,
-0.0407199189,
0.0396538116,
-0.031516701,
-0.0399142094,
-0.017683398,
0.0047622351,
-0.0190415047,
0.0092612803,
0.0298104323,
0.034923099,
0.0113695497,
-0.0151102915,
0.0320251212,
0.0482290797,
-0.114384748,
-0.0453125536,
0.0531203821,
-0.0082244137,
0.020554103,
0.0585110225,
-0.045594912,
0.0011252442,
0.0389096327,
0.0751409531,
0.0059819827,
0.0505168214,
0.0232550949,
0.0156840794,
0.0185546856,
0.0068194168,
0.0233327039,
0.0075276634,
-0.0312178843,
-0.00597391,
-0.0331364721,
0.000981685,
0.0340578258,
0.0061642788,
0.0065127071,
-0.0088275,
0.0071881842,
-0.0235390887,
0.011127484,
-0.0572423488,
-0.0149020934,
0.0297380425,
0.029029496,
0.008788757,
-0.0508263968,
-0.0047886488,
-0.0075272797,
-0.0296624582,
-0.014896729,
-0.011664534,
-0.0087431688,
0.0189244449,
0.0136612784,
0.0156121822,
-0.0321871452,
-0.0337938666,
0.0113955261,
-0.0098357592,
0.0648345426,
0.0073979362,
0.0744037032,
0.0233736895,
-0.0485837907,
0.0096841389,
-0.004267212,
-0.0449662097,
-0.0330877192,
-0.0323161446,
0.0569752418,
0.0510571562,
0.0369124822,
0.0777197853,
-0.037307214,
0.0099173123,
0.0231157374,
0.0227263272,
0.0491636507,
-0.0062936186,
-0.0339122005,
-0.0034672159,
-0.0328487083,
0.0074341712,
0.0518327467,
-0.0420816578,
0.0579872392,
0.0414014459,
-0.0232968889,
-0.0351041108,
-0.0901046619,
-0.0963210911,
-0.0054871128,
0.0059180376,
-0.0416019596,
-0.0855796859,
-0.0158916097,
0.0242637713,
0.0363015607,
0.0134740034,
0.0113750221,
-0.014329806,
0.058551129,
0.0064522387,
-0.0318998396,
0.005683742,
0.0044970117,
0.0386139527,
-0.0174451731,
0.0414768755,
-6.48980219e-33,
-0.0187429376,
-0.0446994826,
0.0163492505,
-0.009342582,
-0.0308450274,
-0.0108132809,
0.0044730259,
-0.014662059,
0.0057261633,
0.0468738899,
0.020921709,
0.0535173677,
0.023074694,
-0.0102369878,
-0.0266997349,
-0.0250037741,
0.0246428233,
0.0322745778,
-0.0421285741,
0.0107311597,
0.0526129864,
-0.021045303,
0.0785958767,
-0.0847819895,
0.0411038958,
-0.018184118,
-0.0452959538,
0.0114389621,
-0.0547247231,
0.0108112181,
-0.0374308266,
0.0447087064,
0.0103924125,
-0.0144815249,
-0.0118187014,
-0.046998173,
-0.0342704616,
-0.0636502579,
0.02596155,
0.0220696218,
-0.0390574783,
-0.0101845833,
0.0091872355,
0.0144560337,
0.0305468533,
-0.0192782041,
0.0290029924,
-0.0310420766,
0.0031977536,
0.0337151214,
-0.052886311,
0.0311491266,
0.0123220151,
0.0046521579,
-0.0272299685,
0.0082480125,
0.0197499562,
-0.035253875,
-0.1241890788,
-0.0018999251,
-0.0082658892,
-0.0218911599,
0.0178398751,
-0.0514571592,
-0.0331151336,
0.0886549652,
0.0207361672,
0.0330341235,
-0.0702646822,
0.0308507513,
-0.0191459134,
0.0659875423,
0.041815497,
0.0851354897,
0.0439703614,
0.0046076505,
-0.0682020709,
0.0131490082,
-0.0069639678,
-0.0029739726,
0.0489306785,
-0.0268212482,
-0.0536897928,
-0.0196511745,
0.0245453604,
0.0379186124,
-0.0302571822,
-0.0018082529,
0.0002400122,
-0.0099045811,
-0.0135514699,
-0.0003821873,
-0.017534297,
-0.0029665604,
0.026404554,
-0.0083216624,
-0.0529277734,
0.0002859661,
-0.0050497623,
0.0346908793,
0.001687462,
-0.0066997553,
0.0472456962,
0.0166653637,
0.0430224463,
0.0052690669,
0.0631321892,
-0.0269367006,
-0.0674454048,
0.0357818007,
-0.0377381742,
0.0422276296,
0.0069805477,
-0.028821012,
0.0362270065,
-0.0265110284,
-0.0439025909,
-0.0193588696,
0.0444292054,
0.04978377,
-0.0022894135,
0.0191988871,
-0.0443907082,
0.0164346434,
-0.0139980903,
0.0230102856,
-0.0314128958,
-0.0712286606,
0.0301226284,
-0.0892955735,
-0.0166313909,
0.0073712207,
2.795e-7,
0.0043150955,
0.0386235528,
0.0438159816,
0.0055108052,
0.0365870558,
0.0173418187,
0.0126629621,
0.0279610176,
0.0020874368,
-0.0792261735,
-0.0335495099,
0.02155976,
0.049789615,
0.1091923043,
-0.031716194,
-0.0225405712,
-0.0225337204,
-0.0314014666,
-0.0912731141,
-0.051579535,
0.0775235072,
0.0173512474,
0.0384128764,
-0.0289938208,
0.031156322,
-0.0040934077,
0.0469385535,
0.0202509239,
-0.0319131389,
0.0288784374,
0.0878350362,
-0.0145886671,
0.0132158743,
0.0262427554,
0.0216834527,
-0.04161001,
-0.023651788,
0.0006821605,
0.0013062621,
-0.0236283392,
0.0035466801,
-0.0394207984,
0.0091675427,
-0.0300069842,
0.0532333292,
0.0366129316,
-0.0234713107,
-0.0289189033,
-0.0349796861,
0.0003762422,
0.0783285052,
-0.0029532695,
-0.0264047906,
0.0475709736,
0.0106962686,
0.0347782001,
-0.0292369686,
-0.0327281021,
-0.0089926962,
0.0122638522,
-0.017284004,
-0.0387915857,
0.013812623,
0.0139584756,
-0.0093422364,
-0.0880353078,
0.0037860915,
2.721896199e-34,
0.025632713,
0.0073059327,
0.0096730618,
-0.0032514811,
0.0404032245,
0.0097390488,
0.0185630582,
-0.0214172695,
-0.0168856252,
-0.0356130451,
-0.0008215848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12085v1 | On the Benefit of Generative Foundation Models for Human Activity Recognition | 2023-10-18T16:27:06 | 2023-10-18T16:27:06 | Zikang Leng, Hyeokhyen Kwon, Thomas Plötz | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In human activity recognition (HAR), the limited availability of annotated
data presents a significant challenge. Drawing inspiration from the latest
advancements in generative AI, including Large Language Models (LLMs) and
motion synthesis models, we believe that generative AI can address this data
scarcity by autonomously generating virtual IMU data from text descriptions.
Beyond this, we spotlight several promising research pathways that could
benefit from generative AI for the community, including the generating
benchmark datasets, the development of foundational models specific to HAR, the
exploration of hierarchical structures within HAR, breaking down complex
activities, and applications in health sensing and activity summarization. | [
0.0004858117,
0.0579463355,
-0.0196814705,
0.0091439141,
0.0001060498,
0.0516101047,
0.0308172945,
0.0040176106,
0.022723034,
-0.0533817969,
0.0049490179,
-0.0352677964,
0.0121773174,
0.0068085766,
0.0332646966,
-0.0357172303,
0.0217958018,
-0.0251045898,
-0.0306005571,
0.0108045563,
-0.0141875977,
0.0093533322,
-0.0085352892,
0.023449976,
-0.0042164675,
0.0271847229,
0.0077480101,
-0.0224780198,
0.0531068742,
-0.0578669719,
-0.062139567,
0.0248088595,
0.0648722053,
0.0121858418,
0.0000019452,
-0.0047802175,
0.0439841598,
0.0214605778,
-0.0167025626,
-0.0503451005,
0.0723502859,
-0.0004647189,
0.030609956,
-0.0017844193,
-0.0297499392,
-0.0382425301,
0.004291703,
-0.003398112,
0.0053608492,
0.056561809,
-0.0266121384,
-0.0117698228,
0.0174618773,
-0.0308459252,
0.0679229572,
0.0122241192,
0.0435032025,
0.0399481617,
0.0477732867,
-0.0033643227,
-0.0228743199,
-0.0141340084,
0.015355547,
0.0244029146,
0.0351091847,
0.0756179541,
-0.0018814163,
0.0087867985,
0.0015615228,
0.0561933145,
-0.0099870814,
-0.0201231018,
0.0490359589,
-0.0131848073,
-0.0134027461,
0.0059632147,
-0.0606521927,
0.031355001,
-0.0024026455,
0.0114738978,
0.0324398242,
0.0502268337,
0.0242300741,
-0.0156702865,
0.0158358552,
-0.0354608446,
0.0349048823,
0.0223335102,
-0.0425797403,
-0.0048647728,
0.0572945252,
-0.0698739439,
-0.0075388686,
0.0392711535,
0.029602237,
-0.0161749944,
-0.0612231791,
-0.012174163,
0.0028949238,
-0.0223779622,
0.0218092781,
0.0742507428,
0.0232927296,
0.0457555987,
0.0428175293,
0.0285551567,
-0.0325529575,
-0.0080422563,
-0.0583207086,
0.0140526686,
-0.0424813516,
0.0185716506,
-0.0025556739,
0.0165816341,
-0.0469839014,
-0.049169343,
-0.0521381833,
0.0497082546,
0.0040034745,
-0.0473925136,
-0.0002943438,
0.0421676263,
-0.0157340299,
-0.0036733954,
0.0316439755,
-0.0778134689,
-0.0063075898,
0.0612776093,
-0.008320855,
-0.0703201666,
-0.0132472953,
0.03950027,
0.0314365104,
-0.0235460661,
0.0169362407,
0.0032498264,
-0.0014220207,
-0.0509141125,
0.0178878698,
-0.0123280119,
0.0142361159,
-0.0332452208,
0.0248968322,
-0.0861220732,
0.0385371,
-0.0501792468,
-0.0093956823,
-0.0576658994,
0.0142355617,
-0.0163585264,
-0.0334673114,
0.073077783,
-0.0294347759,
0.0382760353,
0.0310536642,
-0.0217901599,
0.0608423166,
-0.0185708795,
0.0592399798,
0.0086373538,
-0.0129701737,
0.0153287482,
0.0382259637,
0.0521154627,
-0.0232197009,
-0.0309804343,
0.0245372243,
-0.0365311354,
-0.0168090761,
0.0102370502,
-0.0120560899,
0.0527239218,
-0.0326021537,
0.0163755938,
0.0518234186,
0.0872919932,
-0.0509659909,
0.0216715578,
0.0661085695,
-0.0276196226,
-0.0210635662,
-0.0370026864,
0.0137653789,
0.0155924661,
-0.0123529071,
-0.0219701864,
-0.0029161875,
0.0126469526,
-0.0595743768,
-0.0593270138,
-0.0205879174,
-0.0243091509,
0.0375572778,
0.02881396,
0.0546649359,
0.0037041476,
0.0044991714,
0.0079567004,
0.0262620039,
-0.0380728543,
0.0221983232,
-0.0444315858,
-0.0003857298,
0.0960628986,
0.0306205507,
-0.0152874794,
0.0002583057,
-0.006712954,
0.0290827919,
-0.0029743945,
-0.0322969891,
-0.0211467315,
0.013513146,
-0.0627382919,
-0.0344627686,
0.0032991273,
0.0295834076,
-0.013097208,
-0.037394952,
-0.0149613973,
0.0243936963,
-0.006113342,
-0.0482617542,
0.0611217692,
-0.0544573702,
-0.0114529794,
0.0590873696,
-0.0044690217,
0.0560080484,
0.0457559563,
-0.0180453081,
0.0030216726,
0.0610803403,
-0.0915649682,
0.0141180279,
0.0667882264,
0.0045931949,
0.0073036486,
0.0040996382,
0.0158625729,
0.010808167,
-0.0227657277,
-0.0112951295,
-0.054033123,
-0.0149572324,
-0.0595430583,
-0.0297479611,
-0.0305503365,
-0.0180108622,
0.0580392592,
-0.0001002842,
-0.0132213663,
0.0570114367,
-0.0342936516,
-0.0084878309,
0.0396075547,
0.0223436262,
-0.0046886439,
-0.0702018738,
-0.0158138312,
-0.0124344844,
-0.0411669947,
0.0027484875,
0.0327957794,
0.0124758789,
0.0141002527,
0.0235457662,
-0.1150807738,
-0.0276441462,
0.0071160994,
0.0261651147,
0.0307333805,
0.0423762128,
-0.0058464883,
-0.01137478,
-0.0118871573,
-0.0036124981,
-0.0134217013,
-0.0085796919,
0.023455698,
-0.012388397,
-0.0211809538,
-0.028386604,
0.0115075493,
-0.0018005448,
0.0391923226,
0.0366414636,
-0.0282429457,
-0.0056976471,
-0.0052967761,
0.0375123471,
0.0393159427,
-0.023624178,
-0.0148053467,
0.0377535596,
-0.0081188502,
0.0704243928,
0.0444098003,
0.0116996234,
0.0377354138,
0.0541985817,
-0.0085554663,
0.0160517432,
0.015540109,
-0.0726343393,
0.0510216355,
-0.0260348935,
-0.0722977147,
0.0074234344,
0.0478345826,
0.0269087143,
0.0233608913,
-0.0300300922,
-0.0079274345,
-0.0387136899,
-0.0128160305,
-0.0239362288,
0.0351943672,
-0.0710342824,
0.0345359594,
-0.0243281461,
-0.034844704,
-0.0324962549,
-0.0101262573,
0.0084395446,
0.0119340606,
-0.0009081703,
-0.0301790703,
0.0856596977,
0.0493712574,
0.0120150857,
-0.0207127444,
0.0081010805,
0.0180327911,
-0.0013983386,
0.024738051,
-0.045796331,
-0.0118971355,
-0.0712435767,
0.0569907613,
0.0134527944,
-0.039590802,
-0.0142911794,
-0.0100927828,
-0.003220503,
-0.0053756577,
-0.0421722904,
-0.0026844023,
0.0023347498,
0.0007093729,
-0.0222421195,
0.0505267791,
0.0089930724,
0.015255156,
-0.010340564,
0.0748029873,
0.0410320647,
0.0260150637,
-0.0930099711,
-0.0117457788,
-0.0242246799,
0.0371305719,
0.0054194452,
0.0254071746,
-0.036124371,
0.025675118,
0.016041331,
0.0306723248,
-0.0093907611,
0.0611593537,
0.0459797606,
-0.0006505421,
-0.0364148952,
0.0866754949,
0.0030113652,
-0.0251788497,
0.033341907,
0.046913024,
-0.0183942616,
-0.0035459821,
-0.0085903211,
-0.0528996959,
-0.0137467785,
-0.0284913406,
0.0300493166,
-0.0187398847,
-0.0159178004,
0.0207007062,
-0.0713889003,
0.0824148878,
0.0500638336,
-0.0630758405,
-0.0429080725,
-0.0316786095,
0.010912043,
-0.0519913957,
-0.0653514341,
-0.0423788913,
0.0052431226,
-0.0004081278,
0.0220085792,
-0.0717929155,
-0.0992782637,
-0.0008311574,
-0.0068942667,
0.0537086837,
0.0326800309,
0.0622823201,
0.008304907,
-0.0295134913,
-0.0162941236,
-0.0321204364,
0.0147779919,
-0.0300799422,
0.0114826718,
0.0289169531,
0.0199333448,
-0.0071056415,
0.1105308384,
-0.0427292287,
-0.0829894915,
-0.0147443702,
0.0641539842,
-0.0705772415,
0.0126437368,
-0.0251673982,
-0.0277206413,
0.0699359551,
0.0637421533,
-0.0172674432,
-0.0275904536,
0.0037279271,
-0.0077239117,
0.0010987262,
-0.034941256,
-0.0546264872,
-0.0448352024,
-0.0380911194,
-0.0298558436,
-0.0693676025,
-0.0444354303,
0.0250933263,
0.0233399663,
-0.0158696547,
0.0469912663,
0.0310846753,
0.0178683177,
-0.0590949357,
0.0063932352,
-0.0020724409,
0.0075389775,
0.017736841,
-0.0880385265,
0.0216253344,
-0.0325285532,
-0.0222878773,
0.0392848775,
-0.0815330148,
-0.0083239758,
-0.0052449345,
0.0751023442,
0.016227657,
0.0431721099,
-0.0302699562,
0.0283632968,
0.0152571648,
0.028913103,
-0.0130229136,
0.0213455502,
-0.0326981135,
-0.0354662724,
-0.0254364219,
-0.0109826643,
-0.0248705428,
0.062113367,
-0.0024349196,
0.0279641449,
-0.0826734006,
-0.0442840047,
0.0113121755,
-0.0232875161,
0.0375343673,
-0.0212765709,
-0.0085012466,
-0.0554051884,
-0.0268227085,
-0.0250453781,
0.0116614122,
-0.0682960004,
-0.0189901069,
0.0467686616,
0.0392852984,
-0.0484610759,
0.0849359781,
-0.0251743942,
-0.0010638516,
-0.0556387268,
-0.0130766788,
-0.0131110856,
0.0596489049,
-0.0254468322,
-0.0162207689,
-0.0072897109,
0.0419654362,
-0.0518484786,
-0.0232400484,
0.0181879755,
-0.008340667,
0.0101951044,
0.0208534133,
-0.0409668982,
0.0437825136,
-0.0274299495,
0.0124702603,
-0.0627820119,
0.031522885,
0.0366537757,
0.0156726688,
0.0250137206,
-0.02242456,
-0.0118140308,
-0.0308923833,
0.0612218678,
0.0040604868,
-0.0235833861,
0.004648631,
-0.0009592565,
-0.0319702029,
-0.020093739,
0.0842579156,
0.0202081334,
0.0535412133,
0.0195356552,
-0.0253465865,
-0.0389199071,
-0.0436531007,
-0.0018067725,
-0.0011859334,
-0.0290748198,
-0.0049561076,
-0.0382085405,
-0.0255627818,
-0.0098046511,
0.0188470855,
0.0223109368,
0.0176679958,
0.071519047,
-0.0000760902,
-0.0469624437,
-0.0169935822,
-0.0323650688,
-0.0228266157,
-0.0570110418,
-0.0337954871,
-0.0550868548,
-5.948645733e-33,
-0.0020367026,
-0.0157645624,
0.0439472347,
-0.0009488548,
-0.0228860136,
0.0146422815,
-0.0580349974,
-0.0103016803,
0.0301130936,
-0.0137294373,
0.0270632077,
-0.0205239709,
0.0235813465,
0.01491322,
0.0413438529,
0.0446520373,
0.0497019887,
-0.0515878797,
-0.0108791757,
0.0347352959,
0.023495771,
-0.0313774124,
0.0069685485,
-0.0646640062,
-0.0327699557,
-0.0401619226,
-0.0307664201,
0.0233441703,
0.0206419788,
0.0140513945,
-0.065484941,
-0.0136623112,
0.0433910489,
0.0371059701,
-0.0087183239,
-0.0032157896,
-0.0879185796,
-0.0068596485,
-0.0000454546,
-0.0166963935,
-0.0793450028,
-0.0484016053,
0.0000787984,
-0.0019046023,
-0.0582494587,
-0.0173483007,
0.0406659096,
-0.0497990772,
-0.01474314,
-0.0680260435,
-0.0427017286,
0.0436026566,
-0.0143816834,
-0.0215912517,
0.0356806666,
-0.0343256928,
-0.028645806,
-0.021816723,
-0.0436712168,
0.0415716358,
-0.0154337538,
0.0181393325,
0.0409735255,
0.0292487871,
0.0359277837,
0.0211309586,
0.0138102742,
-0.014618733,
-0.0447426774,
0.0398826934,
-0.0190613251,
0.0797367766,
0.0031379908,
0.0586112514,
0.045628015,
0.0092023546,
-0.0655079782,
0.0536406897,
-0.0033090361,
0.0001919633,
0.0032329243,
0.0317090563,
-0.006801717,
0.0107826423,
0.0121556008,
0.0318832248,
-0.0026343956,
-0.0157804955,
-0.0001978046,
0.0350942984,
-0.0297665354,
-0.0076152603,
0.0128674144,
-0.0066354261,
0.0277500991,
0.0175264254,
0.0311930832,
0.0035047384,
0.0106458403,
-0.0505642258,
-0.0387850329,
-0.0739389509,
0.0733893812,
0.0321199708,
0.0071442393,
0.0044642398,
-0.0055098133,
0.0331345201,
0.0294855833,
-0.0327295884,
0.0204931796,
0.019525405,
0.0457969345,
0.0224567857,
0.0503322482,
0.0030576976,
-0.0300361458,
0.0889237374,
-0.0449535623,
-0.0081015108,
-0.0135434959,
0.0195448976,
0.0024721976,
0.0027317165,
-0.0165951606,
0.0137186358,
-0.0446926691,
0.0124256676,
0.032611642,
-0.0240268782,
-0.0152505506,
0.0479445755,
2.707e-7,
0.0032407406,
0.0044470723,
0.0262812506,
-0.0111308377,
0.0277575888,
-0.0048378343,
0.0048629334,
0.0546783693,
-0.0237792265,
0.0246111993,
0.0772028193,
0.043438565,
0.0634576529,
0.0002907726,
-0.030376358,
0.0076633664,
0.0000553441,
0.0060563129,
-0.0364112034,
-0.0120374952,
0.0388637632,
0.066112712,
0.0088324854,
0.0083785541,
0.0575306118,
-0.0539929792,
0.0722996369,
-0.0339088589,
0.0075453683,
-0.0108555593,
-0.0132111441,
0.0072434451,
-0.0222523324,
-0.0221476313,
-0.0344514661,
-0.0004742196,
0.0282011759,
0.0454305671,
-0.0685963109,
0.0098127471,
-0.025567824,
0.0008592327,
0.0068212841,
-0.0139154261,
0.0682962909,
-0.0666132048,
-0.0082571739,
-0.0123585947,
-0.0328973718,
0.0355677307,
-0.0182038769,
0.0048629637,
0.0279230513,
0.0251859762,
0.0338323154,
-0.0196218714,
-0.0061793821,
-0.0431107618,
0.0005006223,
-0.0254684873,
-0.0961333737,
-0.012142797,
-0.0010154032,
0.0116597712,
-0.0183795746,
-0.0218496453,
-0.0235972647,
1.929501656e-34,
-0.0046753748,
0.0410427265,
-0.0190214161,
-0.0026077649,
0.0021362521,
-0.0084767025,
-0.0106268916,
0.0363675468,
-0.0147973821,
-0.0854452327,
-0.0307620969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12074v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12074v2 | Towards Safer Operations: An Expert-involved Dataset of High-Pressure Gas Incidents for Preventing Future Failures | 2023-10-18T16:07:13 | 2023-10-23T08:01:46 | Shumpei Inoue, Minh-Tien Nguyen, Hiroki Mizokuchi, Tuan-Anh D. Nguyen, Huu-Hiep Nguyen, Dung Tien Le | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a new IncidentAI dataset for safety prevention.
Different from prior corpora that usually contain a single task, our dataset
comprises three tasks: named entity recognition, cause-effect extraction, and
information retrieval. The dataset is annotated by domain experts who have at
least six years of practical experience as high-pressure gas conservation
managers. We validate the contribution of the dataset in the scenario of safety
prevention. Preliminary results on the three tasks show that NLP techniques are
beneficial for analyzing incident reports to prevent future failures. The
dataset facilitates future research in NLP and incident management communities.
The access to the dataset is also provided (the IncidentAI dataset is available
at: https://github.com/Cinnamon/incident-ai-dataset). | [
0.0032484841,
0.0632576495,
0.0091378847,
0.023458505,
-0.0001584024,
0.0325934924,
0.023163652,
0.0454458296,
-0.0033939048,
-0.0339213759,
0.0304079447,
-0.0133326398,
-0.0496440977,
0.0620066449,
0.0396263227,
-0.0473947376,
0.0381378047,
-0.0157657582,
0.0795436203,
0.0474040247,
0.0146607915,
0.0195482392,
-0.0484203212,
0.0545803346,
-0.0336745568,
0.0393377841,
0.0214504115,
-0.0359065868,
0.0623049624,
-0.083833538,
0.041521892,
0.0172945783,
0.0454566143,
0.0365317129,
0.0000019299,
-0.0390284956,
-0.044885084,
0.0074960738,
-0.0345832594,
-0.0720138848,
-0.0186014064,
-0.0935492963,
0.0083887158,
0.0058424706,
-0.0601045266,
-0.0392108485,
0.053016562,
0.075793542,
0.097937949,
0.0699107945,
-0.0347076841,
-0.0392672122,
-0.0003759756,
-0.0011898654,
-0.0011332262,
-0.0524223782,
0.0365658551,
0.0014487845,
-0.0189076923,
-0.023799831,
0.0224225447,
0.0180241857,
-0.0240822248,
-0.0135323917,
-0.0090147816,
0.0162519887,
-0.0479427651,
0.002661251,
-0.0091378391,
0.0594545491,
0.032142818,
-0.0062710112,
0.0304556321,
-0.0230077654,
-0.0016029488,
-0.0135277892,
-0.0275194459,
0.0213354435,
-0.0442199707,
-0.0224421304,
0.0275521018,
0.0717749745,
-0.0192331858,
-0.0218310077,
0.0048835739,
0.0272743274,
-0.0172059145,
-0.0448824205,
-0.0016328709,
0.053745158,
-0.0173935071,
-0.0014743609,
0.0105800051,
-0.0208495073,
-0.0465106554,
0.0570957251,
0.0124779604,
-0.0343622901,
0.0513017327,
-0.1009000018,
-0.0062478706,
-0.0018391642,
0.0517372303,
0.0260243863,
-0.0130330995,
-0.0195792019,
0.0237745941,
0.020395143,
-0.0015787354,
0.0080961809,
-0.078692086,
-0.0346478634,
-0.0593528003,
0.0107738758,
0.0170063823,
0.0432386398,
-0.0199269075,
-0.0122782169,
-0.0330164731,
0.0355991758,
0.0424417369,
-0.0102622388,
-0.0436213091,
0.0018104278,
-0.0201129094,
-0.0069177854,
-0.0357251205,
0.0477403216,
-0.0064006778,
-0.0296353903,
-0.0099582337,
0.0055066114,
0.0153191164,
0.0103765652,
-0.0174181256,
0.0561149679,
0.0215232018,
-0.0512143932,
-0.0924490318,
-0.0446989611,
0.0610624775,
0.0415364616,
0.0199023746,
0.0091545871,
0.0399967171,
-0.0253353063,
-0.0001871373,
-0.0362878665,
0.0040579722,
-0.0029368342,
-0.0222396702,
0.0342753194,
-0.096491687,
0.0053417888,
0.0288592,
-0.0005432199,
-0.006247282,
0.0239960831,
0.060798429,
-0.0287440959,
0.0481695309,
-0.0045269625,
0.056591358,
-0.0281050801,
0.0102413893,
-0.0250969324,
0.0191595778,
-0.0018767589,
-0.0219588894,
0.0404530987,
0.0227596108,
-0.0210188404,
-0.0151488483,
-0.0204586443,
-0.0131059662,
0.0187605545,
-0.0218292624,
-0.0069041215,
0.0352489054,
0.0200245511,
-0.0230500959,
-0.031233808,
0.0315916352,
0.0180803966,
-0.022703981,
0.0007032533,
-0.0034531369,
0.0029445218,
-0.025687879,
-0.0405782051,
-0.0293341,
0.0440292209,
0.0005413697,
-0.016654199,
0.0224766079,
0.0115128513,
-0.0391110852,
0.0360361785,
0.0265313927,
-0.0158198755,
-0.0426276959,
0.0001343605,
-0.0334719867,
0.0735953152,
0.0339499936,
-0.0833327994,
-0.0706339255,
-0.0461535305,
-0.027558364,
-0.0070980326,
-0.0003966745,
-0.0019472042,
0.0401595831,
-0.0335590132,
-0.0328530744,
0.0118885068,
0.016677713,
-0.0136778401,
0.0072390898,
-0.0019292246,
-0.0410059914,
0.0205089785,
-0.0669588745,
0.0607847907,
-0.0442296118,
-0.0566699356,
-0.0394728109,
0.0184144322,
-0.0095149912,
0.019608736,
0.0005976712,
0.0015154931,
0.0296205189,
-0.0427113213,
-0.0794460028,
0.0412296876,
-0.0111363372,
-0.0006330471,
0.0280817579,
-0.048412431,
-0.0318154208,
-0.0185550433,
-0.0453330725,
-0.0427372977,
-0.0099516725,
-0.016570827,
-0.0111645153,
-0.0097851157,
-0.0104764011,
0.0656457618,
0.0000013421,
-0.0324174166,
0.0769143477,
0.025744807,
-0.0006578407,
-0.0735759139,
0.007494349,
0.0570751913,
-0.0329910368,
-0.0415814184,
0.0144583024,
-0.0371716544,
0.0148418797,
0.0308855958,
-0.0208766963,
-0.0436101891,
0.0616867505,
-0.0404795967,
-0.0029246239,
-0.005141302,
0.0383604318,
-0.0026062785,
0.0088777915,
-0.0451558456,
-0.0203202292,
0.0248518288,
-0.007377055,
-0.0202791877,
-0.0090988344,
0.0548276752,
0.0230363626,
-0.0105258748,
-0.0467805862,
-0.0419973992,
-0.0337124206,
0.0443568937,
0.0593415685,
-0.0895764679,
-0.0774462074,
0.0946139023,
0.0042193257,
0.0109451571,
0.0147195077,
-0.0489113219,
0.0058041164,
-0.0048506986,
-0.007119535,
0.0435601734,
0.0021059164,
0.0311418921,
0.0022587269,
0.0007918783,
-0.0423616879,
0.0038299912,
-0.0338525325,
-0.0062965159,
0.0358699039,
0.0000762355,
0.0147070009,
0.0206132866,
-0.0240554456,
-0.0089516388,
-0.0266081914,
-0.0128787924,
-0.0302005932,
-0.0129490783,
-0.0049281446,
-0.061334461,
-0.0156239327,
0.0446698852,
0.0234841686,
0.025247395,
0.0489822105,
0.0163308438,
0.0254391208,
-0.0627982244,
-0.0344506092,
-0.0216934253,
0.0971748382,
-0.0082665058,
0.0171753578,
0.0786289051,
-0.0503043644,
0.0368857495,
0.034875229,
0.0403837301,
0.0278634727,
-0.0317140371,
-0.0471772179,
0.0614201166,
-0.0014002912,
-0.0466792174,
-0.0324707553,
-0.0421968065,
-0.0090630753,
-0.0043127206,
0.0026013989,
-0.0030526076,
-0.0596301779,
0.0170990601,
0.0490753949,
0.0424367376,
0.0350306667,
-0.0221644975,
-0.007617428,
0.0025939306,
0.0205849018,
-0.0028471856,
0.031407889,
0.0075975461,
0.0097124558,
0.0470250733,
0.0487407334,
-0.0432237387,
-0.0406694114,
-0.0068486151,
-0.0055574304,
-0.0580683388,
0.0145754013,
-0.019633729,
-0.0019279121,
-0.0524998419,
-0.0326067023,
0.0183234215,
0.0109464703,
0.0082833525,
0.0092802439,
0.0480524153,
-0.0318782814,
0.0097641051,
0.0040632277,
-0.0208320674,
0.0188242719,
0.0009817748,
-0.0039116158,
-0.0083149234,
-0.0673711598,
0.0355085619,
-0.0731362626,
0.0557955056,
-0.0242147297,
0.0042131413,
-0.0440976545,
-0.0744212791,
0.0132126948,
-0.0446612723,
-0.02705645,
-0.0296778865,
-0.0099937264,
-0.0227620155,
0.0519832633,
-0.0299253501,
-0.0958231613,
-0.007657175,
-0.0379846729,
0.0467983335,
0.059438929,
-0.0040657599,
-0.0250470191,
0.0200150069,
0.0195141099,
0.0197027531,
0.0154080018,
0.0098753544,
0.0715707392,
-0.010001841,
-0.0016707808,
0.0076271188,
0.0245072842,
-0.0537279733,
-0.0284693968,
0.0191542264,
0.0683470145,
-0.0659554526,
0.0130545758,
-0.0433911756,
0.0103237657,
0.0369033925,
0.0557255745,
-0.0284091067,
0.0236052796,
-0.0262952782,
-0.0055509284,
0.003436506,
-0.008923904,
0.0009159156,
0.0292094201,
-0.00874185,
-0.0766336545,
-0.062812224,
-0.0475293137,
0.0385148376,
0.0604116172,
-0.004890176,
0.0045461077,
0.007619191,
0.0448359698,
-0.0301881004,
0.0171986744,
-0.0202766601,
0.0338336602,
-0.016577756,
0.0299580414,
0.0376414694,
0.0887817293,
-0.0418044329,
0.0407319069,
-0.0239872877,
-0.0383727364,
0.0330134258,
0.0313655064,
0.0231649112,
-0.0151309036,
-0.0061744992,
-0.0700152442,
0.01881437,
0.0370951891,
-0.0845199004,
-0.0428201109,
-0.018032128,
-0.0255476721,
0.0016697345,
0.0015537501,
-0.0214057565,
0.019516537,
-0.0209246594,
0.0786069483,
-0.055205185,
-0.0118210427,
0.0030399149,
0.0287672821,
0.0094518429,
0.0007118472,
-0.0162006263,
-0.0672000498,
-0.0028492173,
-0.0010430791,
-0.0015779203,
-0.0180013981,
0.128756538,
-0.0216048043,
-0.0397187062,
-0.01237603,
-0.0030784104,
0.0001728369,
0.0251688734,
-0.0266227406,
0.0377723314,
0.0579803772,
0.0021440568,
0.015181141,
0.0191559996,
0.0156638157,
-0.0268854909,
0.0399452075,
0.0247439314,
0.0197847392,
0.012601776,
0.049739711,
0.0233964883,
-0.0333226658,
0.0206027348,
-0.0491483621,
0.0179294236,
-0.001290719,
0.0250193775,
0.0660772026,
0.0104670366,
-0.0145700295,
-0.0543188863,
0.0153466156,
0.0140631795,
0.015547418,
-0.008235367,
-0.0082280301,
0.0202551037,
0.0053372472,
-0.0258753952,
-0.0448613092,
0.0805494785,
-0.0080019701,
0.0333912447,
-0.0057496754,
-0.0230263341,
-0.0393406302,
-0.0213453155,
0.0397443548,
0.0156992674,
-0.0155152958,
-0.0158322286,
-0.0673673674,
-0.0038115925,
-0.0237655491,
0.0156438835,
-0.0176269952,
0.027205864,
0.0244119987,
0.0373312049,
0.0391056351,
0.0001778574,
0.0012053716,
0.0024748724,
-0.0322694108,
-0.0069715702,
-0.0212731957,
-5.578794803e-33,
-0.0228152778,
-0.0491279624,
0.0199074391,
0.0082174409,
0.0335350782,
0.0079938769,
-0.0063760602,
0.0029169405,
0.0177874509,
0.0271674767,
-0.026303973,
0.021737067,
0.0162876341,
-0.0524755381,
0.0417462364,
-0.0435362235,
0.0203169975,
0.0205848254,
-0.0023558254,
-0.0043926928,
0.0785081983,
0.0499025546,
0.0833806843,
-0.1450251788,
0.0499274097,
0.0506725125,
-0.0099060871,
0.0104128681,
0.0235770047,
0.0536754616,
-0.0097457403,
0.0451628529,
0.0373928733,
-0.0963137969,
-0.0175430831,
0.0152376257,
-0.0605678335,
-0.0482523441,
-0.0128297759,
-0.033764232,
0.0173445977,
-0.0263116211,
0.0519998521,
-0.0039163195,
-0.0118556553,
0.0055782716,
0.0261116829,
-0.0030932417,
0.0314208157,
-0.0641273633,
-0.0826068446,
0.0332923457,
-0.0108648594,
0.0453269593,
0.0366427973,
-0.0236672275,
0.0326562412,
-0.0483096913,
-0.0508420281,
-0.0100291576,
-0.0377670154,
-0.0314254388,
-0.0074951923,
-0.0652638674,
-0.0116573358,
0.0679392442,
-0.0270974822,
0.0464372858,
0.0174478181,
-0.0156896207,
-0.0096665304,
0.0581235252,
-0.0078441147,
0.0462415814,
-0.0129634906,
-0.0462593623,
-0.104353264,
0.0614720322,
-0.0362659097,
0.0334274247,
0.0240353141,
0.0062825251,
-0.0635951534,
0.0053812601,
0.0152171841,
0.0501938649,
-0.0064930525,
0.0087798629,
-0.0071484256,
0.0191931129,
0.0020623796,
0.0328873545,
0.0063846223,
-0.0240893178,
0.0396833122,
0.0066291476,
0.0259821415,
-0.0070541054,
0.0013317935,
0.0230916403,
-0.0467466749,
0.0107638407,
-0.0041224752,
0.0076994281,
0.0478369072,
-0.0327255353,
0.03418798,
0.0020106111,
-0.0039566546,
0.0111373477,
-0.0115159126,
0.0045306808,
-0.0157701652,
0.0102968877,
0.0209171586,
0.0372265838,
0.0081895394,
0.0060810056,
0.0333501101,
-0.0008534152,
0.0022287949,
-0.0016992681,
-0.0229413845,
-0.012478062,
-0.0218872931,
-0.0152739128,
-0.016273275,
-0.0315684415,
0.0488675945,
-0.017271949,
-0.0028898958,
0.0110105341,
2.554e-7,
0.031623017,
0.0220651664,
0.0598066635,
0.0210643429,
0.0015970109,
0.0356512293,
0.0193737205,
0.0408047885,
-0.0149986101,
0.0077090994,
0.0391534679,
-0.0300798751,
-0.0061838781,
0.0284825135,
-0.0693181455,
-0.0783265755,
0.0254585128,
-0.0279723145,
-0.0809555948,
0.0020809756,
0.0999480784,
0.0596017726,
-0.003379239,
-0.0049001439,
-0.0238295253,
-0.0226284023,
0.0062479479,
-0.034505982,
0.0020576941,
0.0351869762,
0.0634318888,
0.0516195334,
-0.0154738817,
0.0680547208,
-0.0319857188,
-0.0124082249,
0.0214513764,
0.0231244788,
-0.0105742402,
-0.0202679262,
-0.0059267986,
-0.0395204872,
0.0472609885,
-0.0251386072,
0.0020162822,
-0.0210142937,
-0.0381080396,
0.0759335682,
-0.03813136,
0.0124264583,
-0.0277983807,
0.0091070086,
0.0172681808,
0.0174951926,
-0.010542254,
0.0156438481,
0.0021877487,
-0.0689527392,
0.0377642289,
0.0217257626,
0.0182482284,
-0.0087322881,
0.0240014177,
-0.006052407,
0.0122012431,
-0.0088891787,
-0.0015068059,
2.15551019e-34,
-0.0446564443,
0.0005243804,
-0.0391151048,
-0.0102498541,
0.0541144609,
-0.0007304223,
-0.0463637523,
0.0329927988,
-0.0041709859,
-0.0316438638,
-0.0146097606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12072v2 | SPEED: Speculative Pipelined Execution for Efficient Decoding | 2023-10-18T16:07:01 | 2024-01-03T00:32:43 | Coleman Hooper, Sehoon Kim, Hiva Mohammadzadeh, Hasan Genc, Kurt Keutzer, Amir Gholami, Sophia Shao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) based on the Transformer architecture
have recently emerged as a dominant foundation model for a wide range of
Natural Language Processing tasks. Nevertheless, their application in real-time
scenarios has been highly restricted due to the significant inference latency
associated with these models. This is particularly pronounced due to the
autoregressive nature of generative LLM inference, where tokens are generated
sequentially since each token depends on all previous output tokens. It is
therefore challenging to achieve any token-level parallelism, making inference
extremely memory-bound. In this work, we propose SPEED, which improves
inference efficiency by speculatively executing multiple future tokens in
parallel with the current token using predicted values based on early-layer
hidden states. For Transformer decoders that employ parameter sharing, the
memory operations for the tokens executing in parallel can be amortized, which
allows us to accelerate generative LLM inference. We demonstrate the efficiency
of our method in terms of latency reduction relative to model accuracy and
demonstrate how speculation allows for training deeper decoders with parameter
sharing with minimal runtime overhead. | [
0.0184204467,
0.0811579376,
-0.0034770293,
0.0293757003,
-0.0270583723,
0.0199859813,
0.0065777809,
-0.0292125531,
-0.0297310222,
-0.0157320462,
0.0141602978,
-0.0292515084,
-0.0127701592,
0.0331547111,
-0.0247932728,
-0.0113890618,
0.0198067781,
-0.0383118689,
-0.0049764784,
-0.0135036418,
-0.0364774652,
0.0364040285,
-0.0095734354,
0.0591825023,
-0.0038775939,
-0.0205880851,
-0.0187867954,
-0.0077778157,
-0.0067831529,
-0.0059810793,
-0.0151528819,
0.0216841158,
0.0300744362,
0.019250853,
0.0000019418,
-0.0027768339,
-0.0080279196,
0.0086279185,
-0.0279893242,
0.019334605,
0.0191577487,
-0.0230091382,
-0.0377133116,
0.0199565422,
-0.0245853085,
-0.0734350011,
0.0498990119,
0.0293104742,
0.0124061694,
0.0387862958,
-0.0006912515,
-0.0503266975,
0.0483198501,
-0.016149601,
-0.0077627855,
-0.0585528389,
0.0096627679,
-0.043072775,
-0.0550162531,
-0.0225920379,
-0.0127845034,
0.033597365,
0.0551142842,
0.0102866236,
-0.0316928402,
0.0490695983,
0.0150298281,
-0.0343331955,
-0.0412262082,
0.0153490426,
-0.0583609417,
-0.0482741073,
-0.0068842578,
-0.0178864095,
-0.0344668478,
-0.0374983177,
-0.0063494509,
0.0541678406,
-0.033538077,
0.0458371304,
0.0625701249,
0.0347221643,
0.0284608472,
0.0146629428,
-0.0464841314,
0.066847302,
0.0318384282,
0.019425733,
-0.0643315688,
0.0008695503,
-0.0182016566,
-0.0424575321,
0.0118084475,
0.015344956,
-0.0339132324,
0.0071512111,
-0.0395663492,
-0.0429322869,
-0.0117296325,
-0.0184526555,
0.0132678775,
0.0720194504,
-0.005122575,
0.0182207078,
-0.0312438421,
0.0263142288,
-0.057159435,
0.0093710134,
-0.0394609049,
-0.0394534096,
0.0096956948,
-0.0229753684,
-0.0498354472,
0.0245562065,
-0.0517495163,
-0.0396780856,
-0.023010999,
0.0240031313,
0.0075336583,
-0.0022400436,
0.0508588813,
0.0270876084,
-0.0503209978,
-0.0183036774,
0.0397367924,
0.038596388,
-0.0152070066,
0.0109632481,
-0.0058927005,
-0.0937419236,
-0.0166654065,
0.0237242058,
0.0160629172,
-0.0260622874,
-0.01448425,
0.0538568199,
-0.0245454609,
-0.041415602,
-0.0315303877,
-0.0076040654,
0.0159243159,
-0.0433492549,
0.0309037808,
-0.0373657756,
0.0295919608,
0.0234951302,
0.025929274,
-0.0054013757,
0.0025954966,
0.0169937126,
0.0251132064,
0.0491272733,
0.0351641774,
-0.0084494166,
0.0198779479,
0.0055663907,
0.0066458648,
0.0889646336,
0.0189669337,
0.0532295071,
-0.0037775561,
-0.0161094815,
0.0017039272,
0.0461938456,
-0.0032612705,
-0.0280872975,
0.0054448466,
-0.0190647766,
0.0015743179,
-0.0027241749,
0.0567512214,
0.0546590313,
-0.0455196127,
0.0027120051,
0.0339536071,
0.0344880708,
0.0142223649,
0.0366261266,
0.0628067702,
0.0281733572,
-0.0161151178,
0.0100297797,
-0.0184803046,
0.0373681337,
0.0224520881,
0.0093228817,
0.0139555344,
0.0704064071,
-0.0212173238,
-0.0170884449,
0.0057435939,
-0.0141025363,
0.0131952399,
-0.0069403728,
0.0635608286,
0.0540853776,
-0.0737016052,
0.0777555034,
0.000353621,
-0.0266601983,
-0.0141147934,
-0.0470309071,
0.0194550883,
0.0730676353,
0.0416764803,
0.0361709893,
0.0177105535,
0.0232301764,
-0.0308520962,
0.0202188883,
-0.004768705,
-0.0012848952,
0.0334272943,
-0.040777944,
-0.0067242756,
0.0346694477,
0.0283752047,
0.0394146703,
0.0534059145,
-0.0059379842,
0.010213051,
0.0136749838,
0.0023832417,
0.0198124778,
-0.0199737586,
-0.0364674851,
0.0519513115,
-0.0049999114,
0.0278955139,
-0.0209991131,
-0.0110916914,
0.0241230447,
0.0429333188,
-0.0580387302,
-0.0445342734,
0.0376624428,
-0.1033055559,
-0.0229579229,
-0.0063154153,
-0.005107569,
0.0091900751,
0.037632104,
-0.0428450443,
-0.0310773235,
0.0325341485,
-0.0464049578,
0.0841280371,
-0.0247489437,
0.016173413,
0.0254077837,
0.0230521914,
0.0088766329,
0.0295432732,
-0.0461328477,
-0.0051943175,
-0.0034040634,
0.0180593468,
-0.0380898193,
0.0029221729,
-0.0194318164,
0.0115801683,
-0.0237336196,
-0.0269625708,
-0.0198151544,
-0.0372327976,
0.0243769083,
-0.0181974918,
-0.0678150356,
-0.0100115417,
-0.0472746901,
0.0133010559,
-0.0031767623,
0.0405967273,
0.0134686884,
-0.0066298186,
0.0066719819,
0.0065771588,
0.0123898834,
0.0105601223,
-0.0284310412,
-0.0051873662,
-0.0420010276,
0.0186740067,
-0.0316066183,
0.0060664099,
0.0713598207,
-0.0148704331,
-0.0083239656,
-0.0661666989,
-0.0290109087,
0.0636165962,
0.0489645451,
-0.0207108241,
-0.0274008047,
0.0051719183,
-0.0199158248,
0.0522396527,
0.0324766114,
0.0282104649,
0.0185154602,
0.0037044205,
-0.0029505442,
-0.0340212137,
0.0200103577,
-0.0397233889,
-0.0375856981,
-0.0743904337,
-0.0235668886,
-0.0163766965,
0.101857923,
0.0128754377,
-0.0088861641,
-0.0723500475,
-0.0226267707,
0.0030710136,
-0.0473318808,
0.0330544449,
-0.0334081911,
-0.0229184031,
0.007725548,
-0.0078257769,
-0.0605344884,
0.0647947118,
-0.0594106391,
-0.0210429747,
-0.0188709777,
0.0079460405,
-0.0424289741,
0.0804625228,
0.0111295283,
0.0088325404,
-0.0227703769,
-0.0603673197,
0.0231786687,
0.0553479977,
-0.0061871144,
-0.029053608,
0.0503639765,
-0.0138730817,
-0.0016374318,
-0.0206886716,
-0.046610821,
-0.0505550168,
0.0018663704,
-0.0401590019,
0.0142825898,
0.0763737485,
-0.0380763784,
-0.0047140396,
-0.0029832295,
-0.0574859083,
0.0657127053,
-0.0074413712,
0.0065506748,
-0.0209714603,
0.0158288721,
0.0492798723,
-0.0283287782,
0.0047332384,
0.0112178857,
0.0508443937,
0.0713809282,
0.040073432,
0.0174628496,
-0.0715502501,
-0.0051216204,
0.0619469061,
-0.0035281123,
0.0241512228,
0.0345199443,
0.0124175875,
-0.0755591989,
-0.0390121825,
0.0921456441,
0.0320722274,
-0.0483845286,
0.0038954834,
0.0104755703,
0.0293316543,
0.0060881744,
0.0082470458,
-0.0808421522,
-0.0323082693,
0.0193902049,
0.0045944406,
-0.0186864939,
-0.0145529453,
-0.0138376504,
-0.1115025282,
0.0392931551,
-0.0069968626,
0.014100926,
-0.0189817902,
-0.0392464474,
-0.0565149784,
0.00140412,
0.0293206107,
0.012331686,
0.0200888459,
-0.0236164946,
0.0327683017,
0.0035247775,
-0.0228221118,
0.0317554772,
-0.0152325928,
0.0245425422,
0.0468592867,
-0.0104598366,
0.0121170785,
-0.0563970059,
0.0156774484,
-0.0334015787,
-0.0064844615,
-0.0184113067,
0.0054305391,
-0.0378342383,
-0.0010199629,
-0.0025704929,
0.0337242186,
-0.0250250511,
-0.0153858187,
-0.0479287095,
0.0656081215,
-0.0232023075,
-0.0464251637,
-0.0015067598,
-0.0258561112,
0.0140292756,
0.0695961118,
-0.0026087898,
-0.0361016467,
-0.0436977036,
-0.0347190313,
-0.0015743158,
-0.0664373562,
-0.011891528,
-0.0011081086,
0.0710526258,
-0.0718696713,
-0.0293293353,
0.037193425,
0.0191855542,
0.0082884841,
-0.0255807824,
0.0120541314,
0.0251340047,
-0.0170671027,
-0.0774047822,
-0.002547798,
0.0032578509,
0.0215882584,
-0.0414109342,
-0.0026091596,
0.0701968446,
-0.0116133634,
-0.0292203333,
0.0485762246,
-0.1466114223,
-0.0571204647,
0.0206709672,
0.0058906623,
0.0110609401,
0.0533979014,
-0.0341959819,
-0.0385201834,
0.0338689983,
0.0306673404,
-0.0598633848,
0.0035289198,
0.025772633,
0.0017246075,
0.0212629344,
0.0439090766,
-0.0086976914,
0.012548551,
0.0004901706,
0.0280437283,
0.0025964822,
-0.0121878237,
0.0157159287,
-0.0198985841,
0.0547942594,
-0.0191318374,
0.0350517891,
0.0202985313,
0.0641344488,
-0.0081644524,
-0.0047899056,
-0.035493575,
0.0214858521,
0.0369007289,
0.0060003703,
-0.0173428562,
0.0170276519,
0.0599686727,
0.008438454,
0.0049421219,
0.0006094272,
0.0033713712,
-0.0220806599,
0.0505322628,
-0.0230954308,
-0.0337915123,
-0.0043310495,
0.024433665,
0.0196010172,
-0.0228421856,
0.0169512797,
0.017373167,
0.0167934205,
-0.0509957597,
-0.0085848067,
-0.043142125,
-0.0619221739,
-0.0292081758,
0.0111852251,
0.0356097817,
0.0145421419,
0.0414198302,
-0.0339502171,
0.0025578781,
-0.0002284082,
0.0214711353,
-0.0357085727,
-0.0630659461,
0.0538700856,
0.0068773711,
-0.0151073886,
-0.0113556627,
0.0618964471,
0.0383378826,
0.0554707348,
-0.0077524791,
-0.0085438853,
-0.0145826843,
-0.0591433682,
-0.0350428149,
0.0089521296,
-0.0242394172,
0.0063155596,
0.001832566,
-0.0420868583,
0.0138593754,
-0.0051533822,
0.0281916521,
-0.0275731869,
0.0150569407,
0.0630851015,
-0.0096720373,
-0.0973364189,
-0.0317380279,
0.0185476784,
0.037061803,
-0.0038935924,
-0.03925265,
-6.589426071e-33,
-0.0055246199,
-0.0084255403,
0.030795861,
-0.0251113698,
-0.0079474077,
0.0056501129,
-0.0313531049,
-0.0419918858,
0.0005732169,
0.0051802644,
-0.0155496653,
0.0373320915,
0.0327389464,
0.0632311329,
-0.0056250687,
-0.0159917753,
0.0873610303,
-0.0153889535,
0.0007650244,
0.0307253487,
0.0382513069,
0.0316922665,
0.0203459822,
0.0142415315,
-0.0493325405,
-0.0016135313,
-0.0079627037,
-0.0035412679,
-0.022088645,
0.0377625152,
-0.03512761,
0.0255397875,
0.0174263548,
-0.0717937946,
-0.0184916444,
0.0297964886,
-0.108346045,
0.0248399004,
0.0175447222,
0.0468775481,
-0.0258643813,
-0.0236224756,
0.0090841213,
0.034286201,
-0.0163930859,
-0.017610753,
-0.0293037146,
0.0042144498,
-0.0129819987,
-0.0893257633,
-0.0361760147,
0.0131420167,
0.019829534,
0.0386036672,
0.0435892493,
0.0045074616,
-0.0045073102,
0.0282916613,
-0.0648778081,
0.0038264976,
-0.0111454828,
0.0474377908,
0.0643628165,
0.0270989649,
0.0178405363,
0.0215704273,
0.0346802138,
-0.0307209343,
-0.0778220296,
0.0319354497,
0.0129101695,
0.040150281,
-0.0137722166,
-0.0243145172,
0.0639984608,
-0.0223925821,
-0.0436423272,
-0.0162086599,
-0.0038905521,
0.0643829033,
0.0798971802,
0.021470502,
-0.0142324045,
-0.0317974761,
-0.056747105,
0.004929638,
-0.009884051,
0.0084155099,
0.0139294853,
0.0754806027,
-0.0294897724,
-0.007574046,
0.0622187071,
-0.0398778319,
0.0018877204,
0.0501000844,
0.0122853937,
0.0125348652,
-0.0362543948,
0.0447717607,
-0.0225815177,
-0.013818576,
0.0353350826,
-0.0206991136,
0.0036271887,
0.0048328135,
0.0016006781,
0.0220464747,
-0.0862269253,
-0.0146647105,
-0.0614133254,
0.0415899977,
0.000166043,
0.0382754207,
0.0707171857,
0.0262978617,
-0.0156656783,
0.0257049557,
-0.0192962177,
0.0476644151,
-0.0254424121,
0.0105558578,
0.0289249253,
0.0345634148,
-0.0305812322,
-0.0050167209,
-0.0522817709,
-0.0038345165,
0.0444541387,
-0.0731300637,
-0.0280458014,
0.0634374022,
2.69e-7,
0.0139974235,
0.0145887844,
0.0530108958,
0.0264884531,
0.0443126187,
0.0010345043,
0.0462805144,
0.0255519152,
0.0358726196,
0.0229098033,
-0.006554917,
0.0253880993,
0.0381668881,
0.0181658026,
-0.1021959335,
-0.0213499982,
-0.0584110059,
0.0314783081,
-0.0431971475,
-0.0397489034,
0.0140749523,
0.1135386378,
-0.0225548595,
-0.0195626952,
0.0517961569,
0.0002773066,
0.020570768,
0.0060786642,
0.0202517938,
0.0104376599,
-0.0031119373,
0.0160652101,
0.0063436041,
0.0152809517,
-0.013460028,
0.0004169661,
-0.0529646799,
0.0555869266,
0.0153373731,
-0.0382521376,
-0.0060398001,
-0.0281455237,
-0.0246868841,
-0.0223696157,
0.0710358918,
-0.0660268515,
-0.0173121262,
-0.0433595963,
-0.0088203372,
0.008518477,
-0.0612333901,
0.0146712558,
0.0154168662,
0.0362898,
0.0411403999,
0.0016714961,
0.0034379119,
-0.0939926431,
-0.0172854252,
-0.0467359498,
-0.0965591744,
-0.0429924466,
-0.0490407906,
0.0098133385,
0.0291427523,
-0.0359487087,
-0.0072516492,
2.770422764e-34,
0.0312108696,
0.0178868268,
-0.0045994869,
0.0652046874,
0.0333581008,
-0.0179675464,
0.0103774341,
0.0359881595,
-0.0083501972,
-0.0998946205,
-0.039474532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12064v1 | Code Book for the Annotation of Diverse Cross-Document Coreference of Entities in News Articles | 2023-10-18T15:53:45 | 2023-10-18T15:53:45 | Jakob Vogel | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a scheme for annotating coreference across news articles,
extending beyond traditional identity relations by also considering
near-identity and bridging relations. It includes a precise description of how
to set up Inception, a respective annotation tool, how to annotate entities in
news articles, connect them with diverse coreferential relations, and link them
across documents to Wikidata's global knowledge graph. This multi-layered
annotation approach is discussed in the context of the problem of media bias.
Our main contribution lies in providing a methodology for creating a diverse
cross-document coreference corpus which can be applied to the analysis of media
bias by word-choice and labelling. | [
0.0381548777,
-0.0049764663,
-0.0038947787,
-0.0106738219,
0.0041323281,
0.039791286,
0.0148961134,
-0.0285377912,
0.0458458662,
-0.0831323639,
0.0094097648,
0.0673160478,
-0.0124165379,
-0.0337950215,
0.0023772249,
-0.0167139824,
0.0341016576,
0.0597071946,
0.0619765595,
-0.0286678728,
0.0186792668,
0.0601642579,
-0.0196500085,
0.0277595222,
-0.0809647068,
-0.0353030525,
0.0476881117,
0.0068278424,
0.0446662456,
-0.0218395945,
-0.0059956377,
0.0523394309,
-0.003397106,
0.0485277846,
0.0000016439,
-0.0552209094,
-0.0254152995,
0.0135516385,
0.0039038865,
-0.0262093004,
-0.0031926907,
0.0025410724,
0.0069357404,
-0.0415744781,
0.0113792717,
-0.021305522,
0.0510590412,
0.0185959525,
0.0600734241,
0.0536196008,
-0.0135708647,
-0.0067682173,
0.0110260192,
0.0122499596,
-0.0213589519,
-0.0481378995,
0.0239890069,
0.0279917326,
-0.0474931635,
-0.0064355507,
0.0174158625,
0.0229403302,
0.0018948613,
-0.0265014656,
0.0315127857,
-0.0075934525,
-0.0445709042,
-0.0171883013,
0.0208002497,
0.0394695699,
0.0796302781,
0.0094206445,
0.0317953788,
0.0257670004,
-0.000611215,
0.0157238897,
-0.0276309773,
0.0204485245,
-0.0366338082,
-0.0066326065,
0.0176373757,
-0.0081871571,
-0.011992679,
0.0469399206,
0.0156427249,
0.0741499737,
0.0124483928,
0.0141158625,
0.0336142406,
0.0388945527,
0.0035414798,
-0.0665195659,
0.045427952,
0.0001876217,
-0.0120298779,
0.0099672442,
-0.0390956961,
0.0231766682,
0.0051883073,
-0.0963031799,
-0.0130499806,
-0.0248395391,
-0.0342397913,
0.0263585243,
0.0273738801,
-0.0188460443,
-0.0269352719,
-0.0129264537,
0.0325498991,
-0.002487656,
-0.0631551072,
0.0243334919,
-0.0022363756,
0.0558774285,
0.0073322114,
-0.0085051591,
-0.0497079603,
0.0061937878,
-0.0266058426,
0.0361323878,
-0.0013002006,
-0.0209907982,
-0.0277651045,
-0.0107864868,
-0.0231082235,
0.048685465,
-0.0510376804,
0.0217661336,
-0.0542023368,
-0.0163347218,
0.0182860699,
0.0106034167,
-0.0134963654,
-0.0561686456,
-0.0264155772,
0.0064234775,
0.0355736539,
0.0056052865,
-0.0139705706,
-0.0542651787,
0.0213802196,
-0.0190370381,
0.0041648662,
-0.0551384315,
-0.0073352265,
0.0269597825,
0.023868883,
-0.1020217687,
0.0043900604,
-0.0039106999,
-0.0664504468,
0.009786183,
0.0017564839,
-0.017461611,
0.0558760725,
0.0105253514,
0.0292597543,
0.0940159634,
0.0536771454,
-0.0072528585,
0.0716360062,
0.0177120417,
-0.0623595864,
0.0012695807,
0.0121424282,
0.0133011183,
0.0266805831,
0.006660922,
-0.0428217798,
0.0205098595,
0.0298630297,
-0.0040856018,
-0.0043941573,
0.0133428527,
0.0459278747,
0.0361229368,
-0.0184702259,
-0.0149168391,
-0.0042856284,
0.0120032988,
-0.0043156487,
0.0403323025,
-0.0595822781,
0.0451462343,
0.0162885133,
-0.0395440534,
0.0165901873,
0.0748662129,
-0.0181572549,
0.0160757098,
0.0020638055,
0.0256302711,
0.0016324925,
-0.0231772922,
-0.0064791013,
0.0141333984,
-0.000414916,
0.0725397542,
0.0244116392,
-0.0127593065,
0.0305233765,
0.0093103098,
-0.0040467544,
-0.0163632948,
0.0192635674,
0.0007864735,
-0.0006078415,
-0.0346936509,
0.0601729229,
0.037776459,
0.015842665,
-0.0671171919,
-0.0278103333,
0.0088981241,
-0.0265188068,
0.0011976839,
0.0355831981,
0.0473523624,
0.0364378765,
0.0395400785,
0.0064898077,
-0.0278687906,
0.0033575725,
0.0167991146,
0.0260006133,
-0.0255221911,
-0.0478106029,
0.0263920724,
-0.0069060242,
0.0949526057,
-0.0136224739,
-0.0303568225,
-0.0052928212,
0.0389812887,
-0.0076351552,
0.0106624831,
0.010626547,
0.0360723659,
0.0084596993,
-0.0714347661,
-0.0210435633,
-0.0175096877,
0.0075375671,
-0.0499219336,
0.0354539379,
0.0223273039,
0.0424785577,
-0.0184190366,
-0.0342480503,
-0.0078477738,
-0.0187449921,
-0.0174068026,
0.0642088503,
0.0215465426,
-0.0060418071,
-0.0104236593,
-0.037315499,
-0.0041240016,
-0.0193352997,
-0.0056410669,
-0.0108914338,
-0.0000647998,
0.0155171482,
0.0327244662,
-0.0562261976,
-0.0255016256,
0.0114690512,
-0.0398281813,
0.0236378368,
-0.0014785548,
-0.0022495976,
-0.0052411975,
0.0188988186,
-0.0030936124,
-0.0075512906,
0.0169131681,
-0.0066947141,
-0.0237882733,
0.0301253293,
-0.0117234681,
0.0230865292,
0.0049119368,
-0.011531054,
-0.0051506376,
-0.0663844794,
0.0452214442,
0.0321817398,
-0.0208801664,
-0.0237212982,
-0.0109620271,
-0.0436221324,
-0.0067786039,
0.0126723917,
0.037441846,
0.0275808033,
0.0618454032,
-0.0433802679,
0.0513307154,
-0.006244401,
0.0509717092,
-0.0113098221,
-0.0560680255,
-0.0321154408,
-0.0065902248,
0.0093215946,
-0.0043605454,
-0.0129109453,
-0.025777027,
0.0151969446,
0.0219282527,
0.0028222972,
-0.0209898092,
-0.0341867581,
0.0608718544,
-0.0431898162,
-0.0093410946,
0.0261808205,
-0.0597159304,
0.0205819625,
0.0479609296,
0.0075696567,
0.0233017411,
0.0392492339,
-0.0118222274,
0.0779540837,
-0.0217751786,
-0.0014596734,
-0.0170239601,
0.0423308648,
-0.0445130132,
0.0216437709,
0.0410471782,
-0.0562139675,
-0.0408021957,
-0.0200148635,
0.0724367276,
0.0035275437,
0.0227332115,
-0.0056235809,
0.0195086654,
0.0045782863,
0.0059358482,
-0.0264369957,
0.0292074848,
-0.0271300673,
-0.0225447975,
0.0216235872,
0.0195273068,
-0.001659994,
0.0201558452,
0.0166105013,
-0.048579894,
-0.0108883437,
0.0327129699,
0.0094922408,
0.0405239165,
0.0204901565,
-0.025899319,
0.0200558417,
0.0504018776,
-0.0085796891,
-0.0174900591,
-0.0270025544,
0.0042908997,
0.0159339067,
0.0090009673,
-0.0085448688,
-0.0804018527,
-0.0460581146,
-0.0481043383,
0.0648180917,
-0.0304548014,
0.0015673551,
0.0873268768,
0.0231129285,
-0.070005849,
-0.0103191836,
0.0530318394,
-0.0747531652,
0.0447522476,
0.0064441236,
-0.0712906122,
0.0398247316,
-0.0080474457,
-0.004575816,
-0.0228822865,
-0.0791275129,
-0.0093193781,
-0.0486577898,
-0.0145081664,
-0.0013065966,
-0.0513578728,
-0.0026508179,
-0.0614628233,
0.0057024425,
-0.0452243909,
-0.0312218815,
-0.0177552905,
0.0107367849,
0.0314184725,
-0.0251576733,
0.0052533285,
-0.0364732519,
0.0005017026,
-0.0369194821,
0.0255194567,
0.0389812328,
0.0444942601,
0.000761566,
0.0372850075,
0.0033025548,
-0.0346502624,
-0.0502822101,
-0.029656399,
0.0787950233,
-0.0894024968,
-0.0134621719,
-0.0267700832,
0.0232401155,
0.0712492317,
-0.015466528,
-0.0136400238,
0.0110489018,
0.0322634652,
0.035505075,
-0.0112357121,
0.0043223677,
0.0599430092,
0.0631750077,
0.0013368325,
-0.0091716982,
0.0225513428,
-0.0209743846,
0.038975399,
-0.0359194763,
-0.0367227495,
0.0280265324,
-0.0695729852,
-0.0305227879,
-0.0356234945,
-0.0636980832,
0.0070287832,
0.0196843818,
0.0449440293,
-0.0021883582,
0.0323799215,
0.0075380104,
-0.0355203636,
-0.0018418664,
-0.0301763546,
-0.0052279527,
0.0412941165,
0.0039089946,
0.049289152,
0.052482605,
-0.0254162028,
0.057415545,
-0.0311918035,
-0.0311092343,
0.0164000895,
-0.030232301,
0.0234843865,
0.0393711403,
-0.0099589853,
-0.0436461084,
0.0178904086,
0.0350557119,
-0.0549630001,
-0.0011421002,
-0.0144902756,
-0.0144513743,
-0.0178883895,
0.0327393487,
-0.0623880774,
0.0421828926,
-0.0262655634,
0.0036539575,
-0.0408274867,
-0.0210671015,
-0.0182458032,
-0.0282406807,
-0.0163507015,
-0.0274993647,
0.0337233208,
-0.0625306517,
0.0090375524,
-0.0197667424,
-0.0266046636,
0.0269291345,
-0.002245093,
-0.0055749891,
0.0018730699,
-0.0305802934,
0.0123416837,
-0.0207902882,
0.0975476801,
-0.0551914684,
0.0196296033,
0.0730274767,
0.0133797461,
-0.0460505076,
-0.0343536735,
-0.021609975,
0.0189588331,
0.0195514522,
0.0458254814,
-0.015479994,
0.0057908921,
0.0135459127,
-0.0029241969,
0.0220947023,
-0.0422195271,
-0.0647559315,
0.0234562028,
-0.0427011698,
0.010232592,
0.0354175791,
-0.0354977548,
0.0500604585,
0.0182951074,
-0.0390396416,
0.0393845439,
-0.0037214044,
0.0033352196,
-0.023785973,
0.0245114677,
0.0146204792,
-0.0112600746,
0.0422735661,
0.0354337357,
-0.001927973,
0.0436860025,
0.0251692999,
-0.0635214373,
-0.047497645,
-0.0519533567,
0.0384522788,
0.0358260013,
-0.0088594984,
-0.0252942368,
-0.07748276,
-0.0426350981,
0.0633500442,
-0.0227918793,
0.0241130944,
0.0261836182,
-0.0272755884,
0.0299925599,
0.0467211455,
-0.0544487424,
-0.0071069598,
-0.0070157684,
-0.0773225054,
-0.0437026545,
0.0530768558,
-5.749370421e-33,
-0.0790141374,
-0.0081492048,
-0.010632108,
0.0259458087,
-0.0331622958,
0.0342369601,
0.0030767592,
-0.0278702732,
-0.0286147315,
0.0042213695,
-0.0022677071,
0.0206102151,
0.0170801505,
-0.0214291047,
-0.0021118436,
0.0116235437,
0.0342789032,
0.0159674995,
-0.0304423589,
0.0278619546,
-0.0008140602,
-0.0104047759,
0.0716130584,
-0.121790722,
0.106392689,
0.0224260371,
-0.0532661006,
-0.0262947772,
0.0843056589,
0.0375240855,
-0.00987342,
0.0222667716,
0.0077887736,
-0.03153494,
0.0345287174,
0.0384506769,
-0.0857105106,
-0.0077269301,
0.0550044216,
0.036853008,
0.0474370643,
-0.0414668322,
0.0030540223,
-0.018346969,
0.0127884261,
-0.0355499983,
0.0757265612,
-0.0093600163,
0.00685453,
0.0157709476,
-0.0666217133,
0.0068210666,
-0.0480025411,
0.0399142429,
-0.0257515926,
-0.0355920233,
0.0472970791,
0.0133378068,
-0.091032818,
-0.000271386,
-0.0441007279,
0.0146635976,
0.0088360859,
-0.020429587,
0.0026225217,
0.0319379717,
-0.0131712351,
0.0236722827,
0.0003547712,
0.0326361023,
0.0289343297,
0.0054579652,
-0.0198233835,
0.1238987371,
-0.0446686074,
-0.0159584489,
-0.0828801617,
0.0083168074,
0.0282846522,
-0.003294701,
0.0060484931,
-0.0249719024,
-0.0280332956,
-0.0129206087,
-0.0462507121,
-0.1219793037,
-0.0202560425,
-0.0594316721,
-0.0108042285,
-0.0270097945,
-0.0647808313,
0.1147887781,
0.0210460722,
-0.045958437,
-0.0427978002,
0.0218429994,
0.0119448658,
0.0289537255,
0.0067850286,
0.0064532859,
-0.0431330875,
0.0046928534,
0.0283871815,
0.0386377983,
0.04910421,
-0.0024240725,
0.0486260764,
-0.0037594647,
-0.0474199764,
-0.026800938,
0.0321695916,
-0.0079718651,
-0.0400392935,
-0.0192184802,
0.0198869854,
0.049455788,
0.0016841418,
-0.0287596844,
0.0678781196,
0.0262204874,
0.0156645011,
-0.0799495727,
-0.0225046054,
0.0208695829,
-0.0114322314,
-0.0244313199,
0.0318877734,
0.0233341455,
0.0070305415,
-0.0546292961,
-0.0033608899,
-0.0478827283,
2.377e-7,
0.0179092828,
0.039404083,
0.0198735837,
0.0010545653,
0.0088944295,
-0.0286612194,
0.0625765622,
0.0616106763,
0.0128899468,
-0.1355680972,
0.0018757019,
0.0103847096,
-0.0005282818,
0.0453298315,
-0.0852745995,
-0.020558659,
-0.0066152797,
0.0214447621,
-0.0627039522,
0.022460524,
-0.0034746812,
0.0074799261,
0.0540495552,
0.011534377,
-0.0535326935,
0.0051410217,
0.0011726357,
0.0135568418,
-0.0218230411,
0.0240439847,
-0.0183422919,
0.0189204086,
-0.0079195099,
0.0480389297,
-0.0192910135,
0.0265504066,
0.043131005,
-0.0051995446,
0.0236086529,
0.0098495111,
-0.0368398614,
-0.0451077409,
0.039024245,
-0.0395471863,
0.0466251783,
0.0087129064,
-0.0286928844,
-0.0905296057,
-0.0525793284,
-0.0069899457,
0.0361511223,
-0.0054659131,
0.0081786932,
0.0304962881,
-0.0300123077,
0.0465411954,
0.0059238989,
-0.0353540517,
-0.0185543783,
0.0393638536,
0.0317576528,
-0.0482181944,
0.019068813,
-0.0404567905,
-0.0103557361,
-0.0424778685,
0.0516152382,
1.68470117e-34,
0.006423228,
0.0073799705,
0.0103438022,
-0.0021303664,
0.0339573994,
0.0001236785,
-0.0835661963,
-0.0407201946,
0.0021348556,
-0.0240485743,
0.0170626845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12059v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12059v3 | Evaluating the Symbol Binding Ability of Large Language Models for Multiple-Choice Questions in Vietnamese General Education | 2023-10-18T15:48:07 | 2023-11-16T14:04:15 | Duc-Vu Nguyen, Quoc-Nam Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we evaluate the ability of large language models (LLMs) to
perform multiple choice symbol binding (MCSB) for multiple choice question
answering (MCQA) tasks in zero-shot, one-shot, and few-shot settings. We focus
on Vietnamese, with fewer challenging MCQA datasets than in English. The two
existing datasets, ViMMRC 1.0 and ViMMRC 2.0, focus on literature. Recent
research in Vietnamese natural language processing (NLP) has focused on the
Vietnamese National High School Graduation Examination (VNHSGE) from 2019 to
2023 to evaluate ChatGPT. However, these studies have mainly focused on how
ChatGPT solves the VNHSGE step by step. We aim to create a novel and
high-quality dataset by providing structured guidelines for typing LaTeX
formulas for mathematics, physics, chemistry, and biology. This dataset can be
used to evaluate the MCSB ability of LLMs and smaller language models (LMs)
because it is typed in a strict LaTeX style. We focus on predicting the
character (A, B, C, or D) that is the most likely answer to a question, given
the context of the question. Our evaluation of six well-known LLMs, namely
BLOOMZ-7.1B-MT, LLaMA-2-7B, LLaMA-2-70B, GPT-3, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4.0, on the
ViMMRC 1.0 and ViMMRC 2.0 benchmarks and our proposed dataset shows promising
results on the MCSB ability of LLMs for Vietnamese. The dataset is available
for research purposes only. | [
0.0152239744,
0.0288347676,
-0.0143140275,
-0.0017656083,
-0.0512875356,
0.0003179672,
0.0113592641,
0.011447168,
0.0493762679,
-0.0519130863,
-0.0019829713,
-0.0515192412,
-0.0118470863,
-0.0232407004,
0.0334988013,
-0.0115308939,
0.023361899,
-0.0260536131,
-0.0086277658,
-0.0312002115,
-0.0083180321,
-0.0159423463,
-0.0035250629,
0.0363379158,
0.0390338264,
-0.048586525,
0.0138397804,
-0.0197903402,
0.0071059139,
-0.0506608933,
-0.0196058899,
0.0930870548,
-0.0313488618,
0.0116978576,
0.0000023448,
-0.0487103201,
-0.0040745432,
-0.0160647389,
-0.0010679942,
0.0431686305,
0.0383595489,
0.005351922,
-0.0051450105,
0.0402955487,
-0.0204285644,
-0.0442777909,
0.035669975,
0.0107134525,
0.0520608723,
0.0153472796,
-0.002058283,
0.0022149603,
0.044793345,
-0.0081651947,
0.0436673202,
-0.031268876,
0.0500420183,
0.0399172008,
0.0320656151,
-0.016501328,
-0.057625033,
0.0403761566,
0.0224046987,
0.0139503181,
-0.0398397334,
0.0152359642,
-0.0535977744,
0.0232905485,
0.0152288536,
0.0616240092,
-0.0271831937,
-0.0364249125,
-0.0161759816,
0.0021146205,
-0.0162019879,
0.0299751405,
-0.0601420216,
-0.0096103484,
-0.0235915277,
-0.0106614511,
0.0577056184,
-0.0363063067,
0.0028408214,
0.0300351717,
-0.0050737779,
0.0223700181,
0.018896319,
-0.0276099928,
0.0041429615,
-0.0091159577,
-0.0678459704,
-0.0353253409,
0.0223320089,
0.0273112059,
-0.016301509,
0.0447682068,
-0.0148947025,
-0.018583402,
0.0282741059,
-0.0856064335,
0.0040320773,
0.0809098408,
-0.0197323449,
0.0216836724,
-0.0362650268,
0.0837467387,
-0.0152226873,
0.055829104,
-0.0555369891,
-0.0031155965,
-0.0490424186,
-0.0152935209,
-0.033350125,
0.0556752495,
0.0077564996,
-0.0203083772,
-0.0677296072,
-0.0077736867,
-0.0116743119,
-0.0115512228,
0.0154334381,
-0.0116657382,
-0.017595863,
0.0174717102,
-0.0293958057,
0.0567887165,
-0.0259968545,
0.0120573137,
0.0042413981,
-0.0495225154,
0.0294375587,
-0.0015655317,
0.0066262255,
-0.0372686535,
0.0411161333,
0.0855997801,
-0.0312714018,
-0.0028195726,
0.0027765336,
0.0019156435,
0.02172805,
-0.0586724952,
0.0177800097,
-0.0929996222,
0.0317445137,
0.045157522,
0.0278104302,
-0.021629259,
0.038140256,
0.0474625863,
0.0146927917,
0.0635905862,
0.0505257472,
0.0079438677,
0.0286450461,
-0.0024554082,
0.0007884895,
0.0394985229,
0.0234510526,
0.0031223113,
0.0303783603,
-0.0566496924,
0.0276281461,
0.056097962,
-0.0026201028,
-0.0076176347,
0.0092834979,
0.0533914044,
0.0361336544,
0.0571960323,
-0.0423264168,
0.068890281,
-0.0104649151,
-0.0247563627,
0.0219853092,
0.0552123114,
0.0235756915,
-0.017152356,
0.0191568118,
-0.0111502772,
0.0796079412,
-0.0192463696,
-0.0631030574,
0.0197343025,
-0.0680576637,
0.019230945,
-0.0006123544,
0.0217424743,
-0.0218881182,
-0.0663643852,
-0.0186218191,
0.0050531682,
-0.0182013586,
0.0303593557,
0.0384576768,
-0.0107427118,
-0.0465202965,
0.0318284333,
0.0068420013,
-0.0067012445,
-0.021396393,
-0.0437994897,
0.0222543515,
0.0158072375,
0.0823035315,
-0.0020392251,
-0.0434722006,
-0.0012177377,
0.0110188499,
0.0201223455,
0.0073884181,
-0.0093658436,
-0.0069288365,
-0.035126131,
0.0300995633,
0.0670242161,
-0.0114685185,
0.0267086588,
0.0262543224,
0.0323419273,
-0.0386611223,
-0.0413096547,
-0.0045557469,
0.0342708454,
-0.0036844951,
-0.0700112954,
-0.0037910077,
-0.0138018942,
0.0327150412,
0.000880712,
-0.0057807206,
0.0171019211,
0.0149302231,
-0.0600414872,
-0.0116747273,
-0.02211456,
-0.0451397933,
-0.0415097475,
0.0492874645,
-0.0424928404,
-0.0128972577,
0.044272624,
-0.0167444088,
-0.0467643365,
-0.0008612948,
0.0001290156,
0.0026177489,
-0.0422782078,
0.018188769,
-0.0313555412,
0.0096310498,
-0.0261063445,
0.0786064267,
-0.0296785012,
0.0758361369,
0.0339616574,
0.0485431291,
0.0383938253,
-0.0068013384,
-0.0237104241,
0.048990462,
0.0046991184,
0.028161604,
-0.0200939961,
0.0293951966,
-0.0268681664,
-0.0436116271,
-0.0561527647,
0.0275195148,
0.0037492951,
0.0407210886,
0.0017791787,
-0.0359242372,
-0.0423563421,
-0.0136565138,
-0.0452191345,
0.0018659859,
0.0213501658,
0.0143519668,
-0.0038718204,
-0.0220006835,
0.0229993146,
-0.0530308224,
-0.0595698915,
-0.0363645181,
0.0323815793,
-0.0040833699,
-0.0222204532,
0.0271705445,
0.0336365998,
-0.0387677141,
-0.0207856987,
0.0104870042,
-0.048358269,
0.0158836264,
-0.0234153587,
0.0338510908,
0.0526244491,
-0.0026862458,
-0.0077889021,
0.0188307576,
-0.0099162962,
-0.0494605154,
-0.0079587726,
-0.0033660573,
-0.0152709018,
-0.0258579291,
-0.0232007783,
-0.0552520603,
0.0748490691,
0.0171135757,
-0.0329320766,
-0.0386282317,
-0.0025201296,
-0.0255366322,
-0.0047176615,
-0.0453690849,
0.0430173278,
-0.0266574677,
0.0157527942,
0.0022220535,
-0.0363241471,
0.0619044155,
-0.0139388433,
-0.0027330918,
-0.0747019947,
0.041589722,
-0.0599799491,
0.043325603,
0.0307061411,
-0.0292737931,
-0.0134873977,
-0.0590749942,
-0.0498499125,
0.0297339875,
0.0100654429,
-0.0717112124,
0.0398196243,
-0.0217274912,
-0.0065133008,
-0.0180697087,
-0.0129740695,
-0.0154292956,
0.0124106733,
-0.0397148244,
0.028188929,
-0.0055027469,
0.0226422679,
-0.0006294695,
0.0150075434,
-0.0100117167,
-0.0167517811,
-0.0375096016,
-0.008787795,
-0.038440913,
0.0588361733,
0.0530795567,
-0.0097380327,
0.0176952798,
-0.0253395569,
0.0469981991,
0.0499605909,
0.0699582621,
0.0120090907,
0.0188569408,
0.0169114079,
0.0406471826,
-0.0338643566,
-0.0066590179,
0.0129854251,
0.0318792239,
-0.0662393123,
0.042206727,
0.0872372016,
0.0465293601,
-0.0050275768,
-0.0001826858,
-0.0231928322,
0.0084177665,
0.0391965285,
0.0528598763,
-0.0963649154,
-0.0235758685,
0.0061193523,
-0.008264645,
-0.020778643,
-0.0300556291,
0.0084956549,
-0.1325454861,
0.0115602491,
-0.0035701951,
-0.0416301824,
0.0158770625,
-0.016002506,
0.0010246319,
-0.0221894309,
0.0252125617,
0.0090094982,
-0.0146340979,
0.0037364331,
0.0264980271,
-0.0542744659,
-0.027581621,
0.0655977875,
-0.0129043404,
0.0154270492,
-0.0050643324,
0.0140406713,
-0.037464451,
-0.0059732432,
0.0321080163,
-0.0328489952,
-0.0223020539,
-0.0107098417,
-0.0023107962,
0.0169568565,
-0.0123352371,
-0.0640449226,
0.0507570878,
-0.0489213131,
-0.0086125443,
0.0482285768,
0.0893095583,
-0.0141268335,
-0.0173320509,
-0.019522246,
0.0093861138,
-0.0416527502,
0.0504451357,
0.0253147036,
-0.0959667265,
-0.0270622838,
-0.0586358719,
-0.0007347912,
-0.0069902986,
-0.0424870811,
-0.0007848174,
-0.009574513,
0.0021431041,
-0.0519587174,
-0.0439772755,
0.0765281394,
0.0486252792,
-0.0118534192,
0.0577561893,
-0.0047472245,
0.0182678886,
0.005239632,
0.0144011602,
0.0007083836,
0.0179099757,
-0.0534835011,
0.0209100712,
-0.0052947821,
-0.0220844895,
-0.0162926242,
0.0225086864,
-0.081239067,
-0.0505641438,
0.0111141121,
0.0321404524,
0.0185123831,
-0.024222184,
0.0010944795,
-0.0443489999,
0.0141982958,
0.0332427956,
0.0427924246,
0.0043092584,
-0.0203026887,
-0.0258598533,
0.0149883004,
0.0054195812,
0.0046811132,
0.0019481342,
0.0153566794,
0.0542896092,
-0.0149944779,
0.0270721968,
0.0553561971,
0.0444924794,
-0.0132742189,
-0.0163495205,
-0.014247193,
-0.0300781615,
0.020948194,
-0.0230319109,
-0.0066272258,
-0.0112740258,
-0.0394600146,
0.024083063,
-0.0325054638,
-0.0340489037,
-0.0392112918,
0.0142151564,
0.0562369414,
0.0179620665,
0.0656706393,
0.007179725,
0.069977209,
0.0296436306,
-0.010649371,
-0.0074340939,
-0.0357528925,
0.0074752546,
0.0552267395,
-0.0087054409,
0.0773806274,
-0.0154278018,
-0.0063023013,
0.0297026038,
-0.0222926345,
-0.0249962211,
-0.0625992641,
-0.0281199515,
0.0665313452,
0.0539452434,
0.016872827,
0.0088556902,
-0.0401762426,
-0.008287766,
-0.0448974408,
-0.0001047362,
0.008574659,
-0.0105775511,
0.0365987234,
0.0260902867,
0.0197886899,
-0.0090568205,
0.0840946808,
0.0034453515,
0.0323376507,
0.0349553004,
-0.003663233,
-0.0257941484,
0.0057127601,
0.0045674392,
0.0421772972,
-0.0030577716,
0.0131452661,
-0.0784976631,
-0.0772920698,
0.0430602208,
0.0379747637,
-0.0172020588,
-0.0136684943,
-0.0134602403,
0.0587071255,
0.0210628454,
-0.0148399826,
-0.0494771637,
0.0252549332,
-0.0654039904,
-0.0093494877,
0.0233146027,
-6.393834096e-33,
-0.0517473407,
-0.0167035162,
0.0239963569,
-0.017526092,
0.0381169319,
-0.0151850386,
-0.0279268753,
0.0357762091,
-0.0302986372,
-0.016928969,
-0.0472503938,
0.0055997479,
0.0175103378,
0.0315518379,
0.0372817554,
-0.0381230265,
-0.0214644205,
-0.0000478107,
0.0009407189,
-0.020338539,
-0.0006278278,
0.0201709606,
0.0675246119,
-0.0297420137,
0.0181263704,
-0.0194619708,
0.0228772052,
-0.0346580818,
-0.0454943292,
0.111274071,
-0.0258049294,
0.0778371468,
0.025386041,
-0.0157761574,
-0.0166847371,
0.0004294164,
-0.0909311175,
-0.0751017556,
0.0270401798,
0.0334280804,
-0.0337078199,
-0.0389320403,
0.0206406023,
-0.0124648269,
-0.0233457647,
-0.0203834213,
0.0223262943,
-0.0556357503,
-0.0255672522,
-0.0062492932,
-0.0392284878,
0.0100087002,
-0.000423797,
-0.0041889315,
-0.0283169951,
0.0670278072,
-0.0470143594,
0.0245112125,
-0.0578611828,
-0.0009948966,
0.0296062212,
0.019985918,
0.0413153246,
-0.0035183192,
0.0312186014,
0.0205043275,
0.0469819419,
-0.0442305394,
0.0088376254,
-0.0372649096,
0.0446293987,
0.0087607065,
0.07621824,
0.0574044958,
0.0892904475,
-0.0086531742,
-0.078398712,
0.0014414766,
0.0425001755,
0.006020918,
0.0139495702,
-0.0147920297,
-0.0295538586,
-0.0186219495,
-0.0662252232,
0.0164747667,
-0.0384680443,
-0.0552337021,
0.0436594188,
-0.0442100726,
-0.0154466936,
-0.0056415317,
0.0648628771,
-0.0577163957,
-0.033001367,
-0.0062068179,
0.0087323058,
0.056904491,
-0.0250018556,
0.0595219694,
-0.0663517192,
0.0174919143,
-0.0142523795,
-0.0759983286,
0.0009792614,
0.0142693613,
0.0005279809,
0.0108597791,
-0.0726823509,
-0.0186632238,
-0.0273427367,
-0.0239151791,
0.0279325955,
-0.0035821339,
0.0287101641,
0.0032786031,
0.0354382806,
0.0090616895,
0.0001238087,
0.0135557037,
-0.0287612043,
-0.0138405692,
-0.0368616991,
0.0198399872,
-0.0127605321,
0.0079135736,
-0.0709827915,
0.0273204204,
0.0057211136,
-0.0248563737,
0.0174081121,
0.0633810908,
2.937e-7,
0.0990492404,
0.0688102916,
0.0161130317,
0.0240983628,
-0.0008527188,
-0.0098948656,
-0.0251014885,
-0.0066047353,
0.0585925616,
0.0050964216,
0.0259126443,
0.00896319,
0.0513944402,
0.0233045388,
-0.0902866647,
0.0291445125,
-0.0211151112,
-0.0047577503,
-0.0477093309,
0.0127305118,
0.0436406508,
0.1084656715,
-0.0338531621,
-0.0066580097,
-0.0456652157,
-0.0250927564,
0.0661655068,
-0.0218358971,
-0.0372784957,
0.0198662318,
0.0222337954,
-0.0292872842,
0.0184491295,
0.0267874282,
0.00924615,
-0.0155479005,
0.0641078278,
0.0464450717,
0.0102278152,
0.0109955231,
0.0072678523,
-0.0256544091,
-0.0291266795,
-0.0392342471,
0.0981843397,
-0.0400424562,
-0.0279559847,
-0.0022985265,
-0.0274751037,
-0.0063218442,
0.0344883129,
-0.0027384742,
-0.017276302,
0.0263760183,
0.0185905714,
-0.0187493004,
-0.0086932518,
-0.0065899631,
-0.0289253108,
-0.0066340263,
-0.0174718071,
-0.0305788405,
-0.0467855968,
-0.0371025838,
0.0119134011,
-0.065092206,
-0.0419029482,
2.681925029e-34,
0.0377464965,
-0.0258603208,
0.0302337222,
0.0329772159,
0.0265111942,
-0.0292217899,
-0.0007121845,
0.0360105,
0.0069648977,
-0.0917289183,
-0.0009774247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12049v1 | Concept-Guided Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Pairwise Comparison Scaling of Texts with Large Language Models | 2023-10-18T15:34:37 | 2023-10-18T15:34:37 | Patrick Y. Wu, Jonathan Nagler, Joshua A. Tucker, Solomon Messing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Existing text scaling methods often require a large corpus, struggle with
short texts, or require labeled data. We develop a text scaling method that
leverages the pattern recognition capabilities of generative large language
models (LLMs). Specifically, we propose concept-guided chain-of-thought
(CGCoT), which uses prompts designed to summarize ideas and identify target
parties in texts to generate concept-specific breakdowns, in many ways similar
to guidance for human coder content analysis. CGCoT effectively shifts pairwise
text comparisons from a reasoning problem to a pattern recognition problem. We
then pairwise compare concept-specific breakdowns using an LLM. We use the
results of these pairwise comparisons to estimate a scale using the
Bradley-Terry model. We use this approach to scale affective speech on Twitter.
Our measures correlate more strongly with human judgments than alternative
approaches like Wordfish. Besides a small set of pilot data to develop the
CGCoT prompts, our measures require no additional labeled data and produce
binary predictions comparable to a RoBERTa-Large model fine-tuned on thousands
of human-labeled tweets. We demonstrate how combining substantive knowledge
with LLMs can create state-of-the-art measures of abstract concepts. | [
0.0238815323,
0.0657606125,
-0.0189253781,
-0.0095122699,
-0.0441491529,
0.0386105292,
0.0321881324,
0.0161490832,
-0.0024748782,
-0.020441141,
0.0123523585,
-0.065450646,
0.0003272323,
0.0661743507,
0.0066280263,
-0.0630160943,
-0.0258151814,
-0.0220454559,
0.0071174991,
-0.0016036968,
0.0423490889,
0.0285403654,
0.0268479623,
0.0097786961,
0.0046486501,
-0.0090042409,
-0.0117117977,
0.003252154,
0.0570923127,
-0.0355318561,
-0.015669331,
0.0690734759,
0.0174554344,
0.0114659695,
0.0000022636,
-0.0584567674,
-0.0123378485,
-0.0156328045,
0.0400644355,
0.0317621231,
0.0641316473,
0.000573554,
0.0194171909,
0.0323542841,
-0.0239255521,
0.011475306,
0.0256655589,
0.0769677982,
0.0530827679,
0.0521209873,
-0.0231918152,
-0.0465910397,
0.0280456562,
-0.0330483876,
0.0152982334,
-0.0114863683,
0.0402907096,
0.021891553,
-0.0230933409,
0.0316925794,
0.0173763037,
0.0127722444,
0.0087856241,
-0.0276919026,
0.0567675047,
0.0165852737,
0.0187897515,
-0.0213537198,
0.0322712734,
0.0579240806,
0.0502085164,
-0.0244853627,
0.0337310992,
-0.0279608704,
0.0014237071,
0.0109516876,
-0.0216140803,
0.0044019963,
-0.0060354266,
0.0081114881,
0.0068831462,
0.0527255945,
-0.0137641104,
0.0359045863,
-0.0407507867,
0.0030428295,
-0.016792614,
-0.0468490385,
0.012403965,
0.0089750523,
-0.0445137806,
-0.0586857386,
0.0207854323,
-0.0071609351,
-0.0117796911,
-0.0064549088,
0.0009802795,
-0.03010666,
0.0068872753,
-0.0589724481,
-0.0085052215,
0.0003272678,
-0.0066060293,
0.0394708849,
0.0151517596,
0.0625840873,
-0.003145373,
-0.0391184874,
-0.0537350737,
0.0007655479,
-0.0663125142,
0.0157301668,
-0.0304499678,
0.0338279791,
-0.015868172,
-0.0147229917,
-0.0534372814,
-0.00224474,
-0.0228176769,
-0.004217762,
0.0026600095,
0.0123717906,
0.0162863415,
0.0071178717,
-0.0081610158,
0.0349273384,
-0.0667241663,
0.0001516525,
0.0182401203,
-0.0140012223,
0.0232235435,
0.0067883967,
0.0217717104,
0.0011099585,
0.0181692187,
-0.0025891839,
-0.0029440033,
-0.0332400352,
-0.0307861939,
-0.0358929858,
-0.0425717831,
-0.0456569567,
-0.0436498001,
-0.0844638273,
0.0166998114,
0.0179084558,
0.0053021791,
-0.0200745258,
0.0057979459,
0.0184494015,
-0.0362977758,
0.0654830635,
0.0271216892,
0.0270609297,
0.0137747796,
0.0193392653,
0.0078751026,
0.0616849959,
0.0388163999,
0.0563421808,
0.0471727028,
0.0029693819,
-0.0086137075,
0.0226784516,
-0.0111756837,
0.0245793592,
-0.0218827277,
-0.0127041545,
-0.0105141783,
0.0479968823,
0.0200903434,
0.0744296461,
-0.0231149495,
0.0572960116,
0.077500701,
0.0798290968,
-0.0112194652,
0.0570072755,
0.0144180739,
0.049390316,
-0.0015228338,
0.0121167609,
0.014599828,
0.0202959515,
-0.0507611111,
-0.0019781459,
0.0798804313,
0.0429431275,
-0.0300311577,
-0.042339284,
-0.0139791071,
0.0252245236,
-0.0019524691,
0.0043404703,
0.0391601138,
-0.0192164686,
-0.0003254565,
-0.0078443019,
0.0380980559,
-0.0752850771,
0.020758383,
-0.0381600298,
-0.0011339129,
0.0693268105,
0.0385418795,
0.0016711998,
0.0599667653,
0.0000843768,
0.007709532,
0.0410547964,
0.0188106298,
-0.0090475893,
-0.0576397702,
-0.0628361404,
0.0213327147,
0.023903871,
-0.0030283427,
-0.0105526969,
0.0092603005,
0.0320039801,
0.007406198,
-0.0293619968,
-0.0351822972,
-0.0125502562,
0.0032468643,
-0.0082015265,
0.0236216895,
0.0036373981,
0.0073456401,
0.045008149,
-0.0274966918,
-0.0053552478,
-0.0170076862,
-0.0324642658,
-0.0406436212,
-0.0008572048,
-0.0243883748,
-0.0164645761,
-0.0154367555,
-0.0253396686,
0.0068447618,
0.0014919492,
-0.0299200751,
-0.0323526599,
0.0135430265,
-0.0310369823,
0.0223522689,
-0.0377875604,
0.0265777241,
-0.0229890086,
-0.0110206055,
-0.0312952586,
0.0741714835,
-0.0179788731,
0.0157200862,
-0.0057269624,
-0.020988062,
-0.0242945608,
-0.0168308001,
-0.0559556596,
0.0363505147,
0.0262630936,
0.0079767453,
0.0255655665,
-0.0043712552,
-0.0609432235,
-0.05765545,
-0.0686159506,
-0.001043223,
-0.0024201062,
-0.0074152155,
0.0350673459,
0.0191028509,
-0.001787101,
0.04539546,
-0.0439637601,
-0.0103982463,
0.0211774409,
0.0295350924,
0.0265279766,
-0.0275287405,
0.012024153,
-0.040532738,
-0.0007605673,
-0.0327348523,
0.0651773289,
0.028005911,
-0.0286876205,
-0.0312830545,
0.0800229907,
-0.04309747,
-0.0121537251,
0.0016947557,
-0.0436648801,
0.0039993459,
-0.0224176925,
0.0549041256,
0.0427013077,
0.0649184138,
0.0242322069,
0.0387775637,
-0.0158102885,
-0.0597128458,
-0.0014860897,
-0.013894977,
-0.0047293161,
0.0102819512,
-0.0614022836,
0.0248655267,
0.0703916699,
0.0108727496,
0.0047047199,
-0.084253177,
-0.0040287087,
-0.0358184986,
-0.0209939722,
-0.0620091334,
-0.0206800345,
-0.0172358323,
0.0344426371,
0.0095053138,
-0.0457470752,
0.0642087162,
-0.0234712269,
0.0283601359,
-0.046967566,
-0.0235303566,
-0.0356890522,
0.0832265392,
0.0177012961,
0.0121877203,
0.0364290625,
0.0012366399,
-0.019758191,
-0.0066532935,
0.0111958133,
-0.0474776626,
0.0468480624,
-0.0642397404,
0.0051340954,
0.0269626863,
-0.0462253988,
-0.0220839549,
0.0098739518,
-0.0431257449,
-0.0195678547,
0.0868110731,
-0.0427825563,
-0.0151413782,
0.0024602013,
0.0641053393,
-0.016374262,
0.0074994015,
-0.0302792527,
0.0180587806,
0.0548735075,
0.0542354397,
-0.0146548711,
0.0254218597,
-0.0381726101,
0.0479447618,
0.053112112,
-0.00324875,
-0.0112475269,
-0.0153541779,
-0.009851383,
0.0106769353,
-0.0275001973,
-0.0015314684,
0.0009983598,
0.0448665842,
0.0041053859,
-0.0032920276,
0.1408834606,
0.0399011485,
-0.0865193233,
-0.0082217436,
-0.0126797576,
0.0553112887,
-0.0034705247,
0.0068309647,
-0.061555896,
-0.022095941,
0.0061925249,
0.0012424281,
-0.014678752,
-0.0635218024,
-0.0068264338,
-0.103578262,
0.0070688385,
-0.0015285199,
0.0116526494,
-0.0059690368,
-0.0631730929,
0.0353454202,
-0.0114199342,
-0.0793940499,
-0.0025307627,
-0.0130601497,
0.0214477498,
-0.0034797455,
-0.035384234,
-0.0234221593,
0.0618309639,
-0.0369249396,
0.0282538217,
0.0444515012,
0.061949417,
0.0107931057,
-0.0182081703,
-0.0014059925,
-0.0661221668,
0.0219987929,
0.001078866,
0.0453418568,
0.0054507968,
0.0310452022,
-0.0568942018,
0.0527038388,
0.0048446823,
-0.0332046039,
0.0092522791,
0.0306335967,
0.0036784427,
-0.0359080695,
-0.0254044775,
0.0415434539,
0.0021454948,
0.0892805681,
0.0759758577,
-0.0706026927,
-0.010319639,
-0.015344331,
0.0110262884,
-0.0078950645,
-0.0828912407,
-0.0290242601,
0.0345343612,
0.0061632232,
-0.0839032456,
-0.0213773325,
0.0114018954,
0.0132600386,
-0.0432765707,
-0.023155503,
-0.0102074193,
0.0251574088,
-0.0076854452,
0.0099182399,
-0.00151427,
0.0120896902,
-0.0651674122,
-0.0032672016,
0.0592009351,
-0.0402570106,
-0.0095098848,
0.0306586698,
-0.0835468099,
-0.0614435375,
-0.0001860518,
-0.0479510203,
0.0227575917,
0.0026830253,
-0.0080891931,
-0.0742295608,
0.069026202,
0.0769785568,
-0.0432824604,
0.0380238928,
-0.0153229591,
0.0844012052,
0.0048599001,
0.0444338247,
-0.0308809094,
0.0592302717,
-0.0247567911,
0.0257390402,
-0.0437725671,
-0.0639504641,
-0.0138463574,
0.0525066778,
0.0332161747,
-0.011064752,
-0.0450394899,
-0.0364406295,
-0.034910582,
0.0097760847,
-0.0287842099,
-0.036362242,
-0.0058104596,
0.0068487129,
0.002965604,
-0.0515834801,
-0.0191581585,
0.0210066624,
-0.0189453233,
-0.0210807174,
0.0236233473,
-0.003482399,
-0.0072955098,
0.0360003524,
-0.0177848674,
-0.0173718724,
-0.0270215683,
-0.0284735989,
0.0219346099,
0.0100301523,
0.0562290028,
0.0190919656,
-0.0068040052,
0.0103825377,
0.0465178303,
-0.0604116321,
-0.0401848592,
-0.0443364084,
-0.0108782435,
0.0027266107,
0.0150349578,
0.0663289428,
-0.0101416847,
-0.0010678954,
-0.0096924361,
0.0118149081,
-0.0305405594,
-0.035182666,
-0.0083326651,
0.0259578992,
-0.0054428219,
-0.0003313567,
0.0400687307,
-0.0580695756,
0.0023151778,
0.0449895188,
-0.0101110609,
-0.0135447634,
-0.0022764222,
-0.0265455376,
-0.0011541584,
0.0135932388,
0.0024124493,
-0.0796183795,
-0.0556734465,
0.0230461247,
-0.0023617679,
0.0296568926,
0.001250784,
0.0527885035,
0.0449366607,
-0.0242030323,
0.0367126763,
-0.0267998278,
0.0077736252,
-0.0269226339,
-0.0640031695,
-0.0261372644,
-6.870675584e-33,
-0.0083935801,
-0.0130809331,
-0.0304660853,
0.018524671,
-0.0368320197,
0.0346693993,
-0.0063379407,
0.0192098804,
0.0125044687,
0.0326060355,
-0.0247628018,
0.0169850979,
-0.0017394574,
0.0149598233,
0.0187443085,
0.0050375066,
0.0383688845,
-0.0198997557,
-0.033577133,
0.0790405795,
0.0513341278,
-0.0067149568,
0.0282618944,
-0.0486044474,
0.03455038,
0.0124123255,
-0.0278733205,
0.0083796317,
0.0531746447,
0.0112791071,
-0.028844025,
0.0519990735,
0.031634625,
-0.0337364227,
0.0100461347,
0.0331706963,
-0.0498226471,
-0.0410766713,
0.0019898564,
-0.0551606975,
-0.0208454821,
-0.0141754309,
0.0097939093,
0.0088963239,
-0.0160820037,
-0.0471231267,
0.0564998239,
-0.000172495,
0.0422777608,
-0.0772974342,
-0.0020109173,
0.0455056392,
-0.0427249782,
-0.00510702,
0.0032037334,
0.0196985453,
-0.0218563098,
0.0542971157,
-0.0599414483,
0.0686459541,
0.0668132752,
0.0222180597,
0.0158240981,
-0.0133680878,
-0.0054035853,
0.0579550117,
-0.0032371108,
-0.0120320143,
-0.0492476523,
0.0050267773,
-0.0032185055,
0.0194019396,
0.0398158915,
0.0867572576,
0.0413366221,
0.0027704018,
-0.0371410288,
0.0460820235,
0.028910324,
0.0199088603,
0.0410703495,
-0.0078448625,
-0.0437992848,
-0.0186215267,
-0.0468333662,
-0.0403003544,
-0.0641186461,
-0.0292751137,
0.0088745132,
-0.0112504475,
-0.0264456142,
-0.0449009091,
0.015186308,
-0.0196478311,
-0.0144113684,
0.0211499166,
-0.0484388173,
0.0807949081,
0.0140580218,
0.0019031578,
-0.0769204199,
0.0015664301,
0.0150195193,
0.0488471203,
0.0198433436,
0.0047881575,
-0.0290411506,
-0.0111316638,
-0.0656754375,
-0.0035483853,
-0.0032656263,
0.0100395931,
-0.0397555418,
-0.0435247049,
-0.0167882033,
-0.0040262584,
-0.013345656,
0.021560153,
0.007765776,
-0.0131874969,
-0.0207375977,
-0.0178047251,
-0.0118199168,
0.0161959399,
-0.0360753685,
0.0116976965,
0.0089463033,
-0.0180528201,
0.0898716301,
-0.022182256,
-0.0179263689,
0.0191810299,
3.114e-7,
-0.0126623558,
0.0605983175,
-0.0054783286,
0.0063845324,
0.0039558061,
0.0513000675,
0.0507402718,
0.03263136,
0.0443769097,
-0.0614795797,
0.0137029644,
0.040483959,
0.0515160337,
0.0470600687,
-0.0706795603,
-0.0052923155,
-0.0715443417,
-0.0362415314,
-0.0349761024,
-0.0244887564,
0.0508144647,
0.0546025671,
0.0522031635,
0.0038676718,
0.0026226838,
-0.0015161491,
0.0453328639,
-0.0496984012,
0.0074372413,
0.0284939539,
0.0220868066,
-0.045173239,
-0.0114352144,
0.0475569814,
0.0019301395,
-0.0028656337,
0.0073716259,
0.017520681,
0.0479229465,
0.0286102593,
-0.0163110215,
-0.0089716734,
-0.0062310421,
-0.0822835863,
0.070574753,
-0.0680450499,
-0.0266349018,
-0.0004952631,
-0.0125988536,
-0.0587850511,
0.0195608921,
-0.0070633991,
-0.0298348311,
0.049909465,
-0.0126293367,
0.0107640922,
0.000468898,
-0.0669449344,
0.0091518601,
-0.0094303768,
-0.0403986201,
-0.0511079431,
-0.0637540892,
-0.0130141862,
-0.0295800511,
-0.0797974467,
0.0438204631,
2.676419262e-34,
0.0547669008,
-0.0031291286,
-0.0131432395,
-0.0446400456,
0.0414988399,
0.0192647856,
-0.034731131,
-0.0193703528,
0.0113972751,
-0.1505918801,
0.0210220162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12024v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12024v1 | CORE: A Few-Shot Company Relation Classification Dataset for Robust Domain Adaptation | 2023-10-18T14:58:13 | 2023-10-18T14:58:13 | Philipp Borchert, Jochen De Weerdt, Kristof Coussement, Arno De Caigny, Marie-Francine Moens | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce CORE, a dataset for few-shot relation classification (RC)
focused on company relations and business entities. CORE includes 4,708
instances of 12 relation types with corresponding textual evidence extracted
from company Wikipedia pages. Company names and business entities pose a
challenge for few-shot RC models due to the rich and diverse information
associated with them. For example, a company name may represent the legal
entity, products, people, or business divisions depending on the context.
Therefore, deriving the relation type between entities is highly dependent on
textual context. To evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art RC models on
the CORE dataset, we conduct experiments in the few-shot domain adaptation
setting. Our results reveal substantial performance gaps, confirming that
models trained on different domains struggle to adapt to CORE. Interestingly,
we find that models trained on CORE showcase improved out-of-domain
performance, which highlights the importance of high-quality data for robust
domain adaptation. Specifically, the information richness embedded in business
entities allows models to focus on contextual nuances, reducing their reliance
on superficial clues such as relation-specific verbs. In addition to the
dataset, we provide relevant code snippets to facilitate reproducibility and
encourage further research in the field. | [
0.0461074077,
0.059092354,
-0.0001516856,
0.0685891062,
0.0039787893,
0.0158457439,
0.0164506566,
0.0573228225,
0.0074467347,
-0.0830952674,
-0.0215118472,
-0.0128588276,
-0.0144523717,
0.0050718212,
-0.0102817453,
-0.0283912253,
0.0263416506,
0.0333371758,
0.0034190647,
0.018201286,
-0.0127934674,
0.0439498648,
-0.0148675824,
-0.0001307386,
0.0065026758,
-0.0231618509,
0.0445503518,
0.0320316926,
0.043258857,
-0.0138937626,
0.0405259989,
0.0707149655,
0.0305605587,
0.0010106225,
0.0000017046,
-0.0904010013,
-0.0092426902,
-0.0274845697,
-0.0386277921,
-0.0042465348,
0.0088829845,
-0.0514215082,
0.0325339846,
0.0042212992,
-0.0422358215,
-0.0279005282,
0.0244999863,
0.0489164218,
0.014918807,
0.0900971889,
-0.0267490912,
-0.0628107339,
-0.0069283219,
-0.0695586056,
-0.0057449518,
-0.0579917952,
0.0625537932,
-0.0219173264,
-0.0151440958,
0.0071105775,
-0.0211659968,
-0.0244915206,
-0.0144150322,
0.0008488264,
0.0309986677,
0.0541415438,
-0.0198884718,
0.001599418,
0.0050480836,
0.0856680423,
0.0229986403,
0.0018106247,
0.0030585222,
-0.0244886484,
0.0195153169,
0.0149790868,
0.0190288108,
-0.0353183262,
-0.02347661,
-0.0022559885,
-0.034767516,
0.002078492,
0.0302900188,
0.0291928872,
-0.0034359319,
-0.0125560528,
-0.0006064455,
-0.0268550925,
0.0289926082,
0.0474394523,
-0.0121437917,
-0.047765296,
-0.0323008299,
0.0163831189,
-0.007775424,
0.0340613127,
-0.0846889094,
0.0316682383,
-0.0079250699,
-0.0586413629,
-0.0244688559,
-0.0124238785,
0.0075668553,
0.0648364946,
-0.0327073932,
-0.0270105749,
-0.0055024144,
-0.0196052603,
0.0028212685,
0.0136576025,
-0.0691912621,
0.0401595309,
-0.0339880176,
0.050314568,
-0.0468680002,
0.0208558328,
-0.0620971061,
0.0007967462,
-0.0066939685,
0.0096558183,
0.0026010177,
-0.010561605,
-0.0103899045,
-0.025865538,
-0.0382359438,
0.012042474,
-0.040875189,
0.0465214252,
-0.0367779285,
-0.0176450517,
0.0020559065,
-0.0403075926,
0.0360747389,
-0.0663060099,
0.0273431875,
0.0480921492,
0.0300599784,
-0.0768256709,
-0.0501938313,
-0.0074390071,
0.0072042663,
-0.0767591894,
-0.0041477466,
-0.016645249,
0.0403092094,
0.0320382379,
-0.0241285544,
-0.0846021846,
0.0276483037,
-0.0184087679,
-0.0800639018,
0.0879412517,
-0.0152062932,
-0.0204982236,
-0.011060507,
0.0081947427,
0.0031181118,
0.0764159486,
0.0191987175,
-0.0271609612,
0.0490007289,
-0.0007400334,
-0.0104402313,
0.0246844124,
0.0079225209,
-0.003230158,
0.0175172668,
0.062744759,
-0.0124088423,
0.0252742935,
0.0266224127,
-0.0167182703,
0.0118995486,
-0.0348864272,
0.0321724899,
-0.0210611559,
0.0133030387,
0.0314930566,
0.0107884044,
0.0043221223,
0.0040007965,
-0.0132213347,
-0.0764883608,
0.0042086127,
-0.0360458195,
-0.0019679153,
-0.0517919324,
0.0328922272,
-0.0336801931,
0.001836934,
-0.0133473882,
0.0133309523,
-0.0384526365,
0.0019994171,
0.0846992657,
0.020203013,
-0.0396267697,
0.0591057613,
0.0549109168,
-0.0058932928,
-0.0086635901,
0.0060056821,
0.0299007818,
0.0317231677,
0.0396767184,
-0.0684072822,
-0.030663101,
-0.03493274,
0.021242829,
0.0381476991,
0.059411291,
-0.0204687994,
0.0456298888,
-0.0149148917,
-0.0481694229,
0.0225470159,
0.0114833936,
0.0062555904,
0.025017567,
0.038281478,
0.0330187678,
-0.0283246301,
0.0577479638,
0.0483774394,
-0.0316040665,
-0.019491978,
0.0383723564,
0.0364928581,
0.0042661168,
0.0571014099,
-0.0093422849,
-0.0560849011,
0.030518936,
-0.0148650995,
0.0162931513,
-0.0145561891,
-0.0125634614,
-0.0394953303,
0.0200387556,
0.0390121453,
-0.0309422649,
-0.0002511391,
-0.0400234088,
0.0013534989,
0.0012734224,
0.0287983678,
0.0337825157,
-0.0003366706,
-0.025962729,
-0.0111010103,
0.0643354878,
-0.002029273,
0.0884857252,
0.0184904616,
-0.0067355814,
-0.0122271394,
-0.0200673956,
0.0014576991,
0.0143806711,
-0.0049813068,
0.0045439801,
-0.0603814982,
-0.00299106,
0.0221061502,
0.0203734264,
-0.0619243532,
0.0190473683,
-0.0344468877,
-0.0194901954,
0.0027905547,
0.0211598389,
-0.0093168635,
0.0284366421,
-0.010662009,
-0.0150874481,
0.0033358752,
0.0299537405,
-0.0493088178,
0.0173947327,
0.0502890535,
0.0115152961,
-0.0196608547,
-0.0332191251,
-0.0168157313,
-0.0098933177,
0.0477122888,
-0.0077733127,
-0.0332869552,
-0.0539779104,
0.0581748895,
-0.0387969539,
0.0214398261,
0.0053437427,
0.0111950599,
-0.0477988645,
0.0145901302,
0.0096005164,
0.0331192985,
-0.0140919806,
0.0422676951,
-0.0205246247,
0.0156675261,
-0.0150096426,
0.0403938815,
-0.0029267787,
0.0223593768,
-0.0354352891,
-0.0042338138,
-0.0183145199,
0.0381298251,
-0.0299117863,
-0.0014550048,
-0.0443509966,
0.0494727828,
0.0152638378,
0.0077640391,
-0.0167715438,
0.0306849219,
0.0186553225,
0.0076836958,
-0.0091839824,
0.0210105404,
0.0479067676,
0.0220749043,
0.0112574976,
-0.0017229395,
-0.03124501,
-0.041095417,
0.0783169568,
-0.0265410226,
-0.0127346814,
0.0549057461,
-0.0137197757,
-0.0682087615,
-0.0049378197,
0.0271861721,
-0.0028728845,
0.0701425523,
-0.0219532475,
0.038059935,
-0.0157828052,
-0.0475455411,
-0.0429711603,
-0.0277769472,
-0.0338418446,
0.0074232752,
-0.0298982151,
0.0127997035,
-0.031762071,
0.0078591621,
-0.0150855472,
0.0028337799,
0.0225121658,
-0.0426009446,
-0.00396503,
0.0716474801,
0.0614025593,
0.009896582,
0.0157712791,
0.0396260209,
0.050853461,
-0.0011422635,
-0.0132711222,
-0.0168661941,
-0.0023375519,
-0.0037490507,
-0.004651696,
-0.0379327498,
0.0178182628,
-0.0096494574,
0.0399289802,
-0.0191212129,
-0.0325045027,
0.0720227733,
0.0028509311,
-0.0246086456,
0.0041363966,
0.0572528467,
-0.0076243798,
0.0492026471,
0.0404399671,
-0.061349839,
-0.0492192172,
-0.0252347756,
-0.010236064,
0.0379882008,
-0.0714992955,
-0.0041791955,
-0.1124983206,
0.0000697686,
-0.0282999184,
-0.059636347,
-0.0438499935,
-0.0590555109,
0.0363288634,
-0.0666375384,
0.0100697055,
-0.031839598,
-0.0464881919,
-0.0150888935,
0.0037003467,
0.0008976291,
-0.0728971213,
0.0167214572,
-0.0451264456,
0.014528621,
0.015777031,
0.0089710262,
-0.0371828899,
0.0553034917,
-0.0002276204,
-0.0402725823,
-0.0345973969,
-0.0136915166,
0.0984715447,
-0.0254581831,
-0.003594988,
0.04364039,
0.0050289189,
-0.0768135041,
-0.0164589956,
0.0087901959,
0.0324558765,
0.0357873403,
-0.0397983342,
-0.0240390468,
-0.0240739714,
-0.0062862346,
0.0733434185,
-0.012895694,
-0.0312232524,
-0.0110119348,
-0.0186889395,
-0.0147852292,
-0.0451342501,
0.0079487469,
-0.0302386507,
-0.0638368428,
0.0162874963,
-0.0720015466,
-0.0758325011,
0.0543714575,
0.008408987,
-0.0017092569,
-0.000353505,
0.0208923686,
0.0324043855,
-0.0777826086,
-0.0142168151,
-0.026610665,
0.0522514023,
-0.001643731,
0.0285664443,
0.0310957227,
-0.0180535689,
-0.0402029194,
-0.0305252112,
-0.0822867006,
-0.0417162403,
-0.0201224741,
0.0165070351,
0.0151973749,
0.0549080297,
-0.0232840478,
-0.0114775775,
0.0381207876,
0.0805134028,
-0.0706023052,
0.0008874835,
0.0253662337,
-0.0054162666,
-0.0141183008,
0.0419102013,
-0.0804449767,
0.0242595635,
0.0459392965,
0.0470182039,
-0.0205152743,
-0.012530514,
-0.0156913623,
-0.0422577932,
0.0482318588,
0.0091546364,
-0.0347889699,
-0.0309828054,
0.0288378969,
-0.0210827366,
-0.0145614976,
-0.0180756897,
-0.0180427469,
0.0270226393,
-0.016801998,
-0.0445135795,
0.0044161365,
-0.0206880849,
0.0658697113,
-0.0450983681,
-0.0113838697,
0.0386291519,
0.0161404833,
0.0243226495,
-0.0246879309,
-0.0170848705,
-0.008656634,
0.0463267714,
-0.0060527301,
-0.0364791043,
0.0203275699,
0.003581315,
0.0027835888,
-0.0047327015,
-0.0216174722,
-0.0226243176,
0.066018492,
-0.0456304625,
0.0123844631,
0.0443636477,
-0.0458017662,
0.0165947359,
-0.0221172981,
-0.0020498305,
-0.0083405692,
0.050519336,
-0.028578192,
0.0070232223,
0.0490580387,
0.029839037,
-0.0407673232,
0.0407252386,
0.0631669462,
0.0170218162,
0.0557267331,
0.0268960875,
-0.0098608229,
-0.0425012335,
-0.0218954943,
0.0268082097,
-0.0014892892,
-0.0097344909,
0.026864633,
-0.0836918578,
-0.06973432,
0.0036929506,
-0.0869942382,
-0.0048393798,
0.0285795704,
-0.0090067126,
0.029044807,
0.0493907705,
-0.0172328167,
-0.0121478718,
0.0092718098,
-0.03722753,
-0.0193943027,
-0.0338994488,
-5.522614254e-33,
-0.0283301566,
0.0007902822,
0.0065331738,
-0.0273399111,
-0.0090355342,
0.0052849012,
0.0149110956,
-0.0179376639,
-0.0591260865,
0.0060286582,
-0.0132693062,
0.0338580459,
0.0071904226,
0.0236435849,
-0.0058145607,
-0.0425804816,
0.0382154658,
0.0063733566,
0.0058166813,
0.0109136403,
-0.0198592134,
0.0331102908,
0.0823004916,
-0.1084367782,
-0.0058846208,
-0.0017130385,
-0.0140251713,
0.0266533662,
0.0562743396,
0.0648396835,
-0.0168390237,
0.0625184774,
0.02724359,
-0.0329271369,
0.0296797864,
0.0024011014,
-0.1261850744,
-0.0054248995,
-0.0442762673,
0.0203410592,
0.0191994552,
0.0106039634,
0.0062586591,
0.0177097414,
0.0606127642,
-0.0723538846,
0.0515340306,
-0.0550587662,
-0.0236729588,
-0.0388917513,
-0.0543956645,
0.0270610265,
0.0214413479,
0.0137102781,
0.006853289,
0.0403526612,
0.0349008851,
-0.0013228168,
-0.0621556528,
-0.0219867118,
-0.012622566,
-0.0052280091,
0.019600004,
-0.0128953764,
-0.0330244936,
0.0147178844,
-0.0219012238,
0.0432684757,
0.0086475015,
0.0150005482,
0.0084788315,
0.0767407939,
-0.0136059821,
0.0806052163,
0.010562039,
-0.0280916169,
-0.0827531889,
0.0048178341,
0.0296706446,
-0.0023521069,
-0.0160937998,
-0.0194793139,
-0.0171611514,
-0.0191792902,
0.0211836509,
0.0011142867,
-0.0404896848,
-0.0177501794,
0.0072493847,
0.0147455204,
-0.0039297524,
0.0546135195,
0.0063388622,
-0.0645768866,
-0.07098528,
0.0435786359,
0.0023322832,
0.0031199199,
0.0419357941,
-0.035563793,
-0.0462730452,
-0.0430284813,
0.0151442438,
0.012037525,
0.0218796059,
-0.0060964352,
0.0762796402,
-0.0242333729,
-0.0517293662,
-0.0207711961,
-0.0064684832,
0.022585053,
-0.0058351015,
0.0191064756,
-0.0231618602,
0.0555112362,
0.0128829032,
0.0479148291,
0.0693147331,
-0.0313022062,
0.0012591822,
0.0162149593,
0.0157990623,
0.0449316204,
0.0022924321,
-0.0458061211,
0.0280378144,
0.0060795066,
0.0409389548,
-0.033444494,
-0.0364409983,
-0.0230439901,
2.43e-7,
0.0366031118,
0.0596992113,
-0.0109605221,
0.0241895467,
0.0082066776,
0.0512106419,
0.0293009207,
0.0868877396,
-0.0313076861,
-0.0148711568,
0.0416352749,
-0.0350237973,
0.02547157,
0.0137763573,
-0.0526389368,
-0.033191599,
-0.0116112297,
0.0072108414,
-0.0642741993,
-0.0130192423,
0.0625865534,
0.0755854622,
0.0785143822,
-0.0141917327,
-0.0329158492,
-0.0330895446,
0.0665540546,
-0.0596008301,
0.0336776339,
0.0334917679,
-0.0260403249,
0.0269840453,
-0.0215266086,
0.0291220117,
-0.0566458143,
0.0504494607,
0.0209647305,
0.0423270538,
0.0044953376,
0.0259636268,
-0.0179789886,
-0.0159906372,
0.0342431292,
-0.0105060535,
0.059410885,
-0.075752221,
0.0091974065,
0.0271204598,
-0.0316836722,
0.008035481,
-0.0026071556,
0.023090912,
0.0003041497,
0.0157550331,
0.0431432351,
-0.0042458805,
-0.0401502065,
-0.0731461868,
0.0404225811,
0.0570958704,
0.0016345794,
-0.0006209814,
0.0021548052,
-0.0288405381,
0.0439731032,
-0.0303432513,
0.0173798446,
1.880328799e-34,
-0.0055651614,
0.0022017057,
-0.032907214,
0.0341834649,
0.0346839987,
-0.0399965309,
-0.0288459919,
-0.0175395701,
0.0248954929,
-0.0590455867,
0.0537882969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12020v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12020v2 | LoHoRavens: A Long-Horizon Language-Conditioned Benchmark for Robotic Tabletop Manipulation | 2023-10-18T14:53:14 | 2023-10-23T12:29:33 | Shengqiang Zhang, Philipp Wicke, Lütfi Kerem Şenel, Luis Figueredo, Abdeldjallil Naceri, Sami Haddadin, Barbara Plank, Hinrich Schütze | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV | The convergence of embodied agents and large language models (LLMs) has
brought significant advancements to embodied instruction following.
Particularly, the strong reasoning capabilities of LLMs make it possible for
robots to perform long-horizon tasks without expensive annotated
demonstrations. However, public benchmarks for testing the long-horizon
reasoning capabilities of language-conditioned robots in various scenarios are
still missing. To fill this gap, this work focuses on the tabletop manipulation
task and releases a simulation benchmark, \textit{LoHoRavens}, which covers
various long-horizon reasoning aspects spanning color, size, space, arithmetics
and reference. Furthermore, there is a key modality bridging problem for
long-horizon manipulation tasks with LLMs: how to incorporate the observation
feedback during robot execution for the LLM's closed-loop planning, which is
however less studied by prior work. We investigate two methods of bridging the
modality gap: caption generation and learnable interface for incorporating
explicit and implicit observation feedback to the LLM, respectively. These
methods serve as the two baselines for our proposed benchmark. Experiments show
that both methods struggle to solve some tasks, indicating long-horizon
manipulation tasks are still challenging for current popular models. We expect
the proposed public benchmark and baselines can help the community develop
better models for long-horizon tabletop manipulation tasks. | [
0.0318136625,
0.0431749895,
-0.0097885318,
-0.0050792196,
-0.06130559,
0.0132344896,
0.0244265292,
0.0057386835,
-0.0019977314,
-0.0368668921,
-0.026553439,
-0.0271885507,
0.0201030038,
0.0158644728,
-0.0146428468,
-0.0659973249,
0.0450068414,
-0.0589962527,
-0.0617030822,
0.0073900847,
-0.0212138481,
-0.0202537589,
-0.0680526197,
0.0280665662,
-0.0357133187,
0.0095629059,
-0.0758371726,
-0.0321622938,
-0.012425039,
-0.0294234287,
-0.044905737,
0.0455206633,
0.0654991195,
0.0773049071,
0.0000021,
-0.0470283963,
0.0092438376,
-0.0301694926,
-0.0066801528,
-0.0362361111,
0.0563129969,
-0.049924776,
-0.024770489,
-0.0012934956,
0.0014463721,
-0.038108401,
0.0458723418,
0.0310385246,
0.0283206291,
0.040589679,
0.0111998729,
0.0267949961,
0.0185090136,
0.0107298763,
0.0319193117,
-0.0354477838,
0.0287916772,
0.0336688384,
0.0803422481,
-0.0289160069,
-0.0417633913,
0.0267806184,
0.0805867165,
-0.0519807748,
-0.0509628877,
0.0445486084,
0.0011469229,
-0.0278447531,
-0.0037642343,
0.0538544171,
0.0202086996,
-0.0000239996,
0.0010339766,
0.0176234785,
0.0401538908,
0.0161604304,
-0.0321909487,
0.0474245325,
0.0253120102,
-0.0077839908,
-0.0591461621,
-0.0402798913,
-0.0076931431,
0.0224801321,
-0.0147820013,
0.079771027,
-0.0010695038,
0.019546831,
0.02932203,
-0.0349597596,
0.0095822094,
-0.0656226128,
0.0350113139,
0.0689338371,
-0.0519290417,
0.0109347245,
-0.0330801345,
-0.0027803835,
-0.0280001182,
-0.0222697482,
0.0386510566,
0.047168076,
0.0154300351,
0.0322793797,
-0.0351944342,
0.0841743797,
-0.0508135967,
0.0568215102,
-0.0131425215,
0.0367979482,
-0.0359063447,
0.0112468796,
-0.0259101931,
-0.0068397722,
-0.0244025793,
-0.0247444846,
0.0038376532,
0.0139344521,
-0.0184371304,
0.0436029844,
-0.0496354401,
0.0096522719,
-0.0149644092,
-0.0316937938,
-0.0616229475,
0.0058528357,
-0.0332396999,
0.0590494275,
0.0150555559,
-0.0112564517,
-0.0321564041,
0.0250892844,
-0.0043579331,
-0.015460182,
0.0012252665,
0.0978344083,
-0.0258541871,
0.0235874373,
-0.0023244969,
-0.0189274102,
-0.0106425993,
-0.060049329,
0.0820474029,
-0.0366713032,
-0.0001450316,
-0.0346796699,
-0.0190876648,
-0.0112018092,
0.0143848127,
0.0072325603,
0.0564528629,
0.0788900778,
0.0550611652,
0.0245201048,
0.0026269462,
0.0082738753,
-0.0704919621,
0.064676322,
0.0662155151,
0.0517333932,
-0.0364916399,
0.0089062518,
0.0183088053,
0.0662885681,
-0.0191474538,
-0.0160727669,
-0.0473964065,
-0.0363323279,
0.0327334516,
0.0711832717,
-0.0063946205,
0.0110421898,
-0.0132968705,
0.0205705334,
0.0299339164,
0.0016784879,
-0.0562900156,
-0.0215885118,
0.0347025953,
-0.0286383405,
-0.0190594755,
-0.0075819255,
-0.0745621994,
0.0734697506,
0.0070892423,
0.0087179868,
-0.0416422673,
-0.0045338548,
-0.0150691606,
-0.0358402096,
0.0092449505,
0.0220950469,
0.0360291563,
-0.0214615576,
0.0761765614,
0.0253078584,
-0.0438313074,
0.0074615385,
-0.007869333,
-0.0283460487,
-0.0120279565,
-0.0288179014,
0.0037465335,
0.0130158998,
0.0002085771,
-0.0367493518,
-0.0588504188,
-0.0226853751,
0.0308906585,
0.089648284,
0.0095591377,
-0.0098227859,
-0.0002837073,
0.0028610709,
-0.0092466623,
0.0077108541,
0.000807559,
0.0367804281,
0.0178768095,
0.0179502871,
0.0011852533,
-0.0152353002,
-0.0010730926,
0.0428534634,
-0.0182729308,
-0.0135819409,
-0.0279810186,
0.0072872969,
0.0426049493,
-0.0062696747,
-0.0038523576,
0.0026422171,
0.0207247138,
-0.0193980578,
-0.0129658878,
0.0227481741,
-0.0682270452,
-0.0319291577,
0.0412198678,
-0.0410173833,
-0.0357895307,
0.0243490711,
-0.0102355266,
-0.0407213271,
0.0470409058,
0.0167928021,
0.0244466513,
0.028403461,
0.027430024,
-0.0008980968,
-0.0618617535,
0.0137084611,
0.0267035179,
-0.0250517614,
0.0084482031,
0.0420141034,
-0.007601988,
0.004323367,
-0.0516089797,
0.0054352707,
0.0382026471,
0.0048735733,
-0.0035078053,
0.0171583761,
0.0487910323,
-0.0616219155,
-0.0487914272,
-0.0760716125,
-0.039445661,
0.0017023996,
-0.0203694887,
0.0063215396,
-0.0546285808,
-0.0317797251,
-0.0175824706,
0.0154999122,
0.0224216878,
-0.0177721437,
0.0225204602,
0.0153073221,
0.040686056,
-0.0460924767,
-0.0295909252,
0.0008169886,
-0.0317936279,
-0.0053362991,
0.0627405867,
0.0054379972,
-0.0221643206,
0.0253477469,
-0.0344520845,
0.0465257764,
-0.0294757634,
0.0088650119,
0.0478230305,
-0.0312363487,
0.0030751317,
0.0820744783,
-0.0377368368,
0.0230932012,
0.0786331519,
-0.0360915586,
-0.0521295667,
0.0240823813,
-0.0204790272,
-0.0397974141,
-0.0145889176,
-0.0100684073,
-0.0187376942,
0.0386311971,
-0.0193259362,
0.0153836301,
-0.0707303956,
0.0108353114,
-0.0223064087,
-0.0717592314,
-0.01803088,
0.018802423,
-0.0576743409,
-0.0140414797,
-0.0576885752,
-0.0512898341,
0.0424204096,
-0.0277786367,
0.0085235266,
0.0428960584,
0.0253258664,
-0.0069869505,
0.1219202429,
0.0214594752,
-0.0093693202,
-0.0097408434,
-0.0223096833,
-0.029563278,
0.0476232842,
0.012507407,
0.0054817712,
0.026909858,
-0.0917760655,
0.0219908301,
-0.0120301228,
-0.0257799719,
-0.030610092,
0.0379521586,
-0.0173485633,
0.0195530318,
-0.028305307,
-0.0379772037,
-0.0326909162,
-0.0107766632,
0.0690126196,
0.0300093088,
-0.0327395536,
0.0102083599,
-0.0447106175,
-0.0404163823,
0.0201555192,
0.0466582887,
-0.0641399398,
-0.0443694554,
0.0132375825,
0.0313365981,
0.0730037987,
-0.0359547883,
-0.042367842,
0.0231035408,
-0.0050481367,
0.0272651836,
0.0369464718,
0.0297961533,
0.0541635752,
-0.033316195,
-0.0135642439,
0.0761520788,
0.014111747,
-0.0146082081,
0.0105869165,
-0.0086714877,
0.050347656,
0.0262334645,
0.0189053398,
-0.0396684483,
-0.0180075113,
0.0335537866,
-0.0355143733,
0.011287272,
-0.0580865145,
-0.0155132962,
-0.1451726109,
0.0096854679,
0.0131981326,
-0.0895567983,
-0.0614320189,
-0.0114449086,
0.0192104951,
0.0176711753,
-0.0052149412,
0.0351614915,
0.0079076719,
0.0245436616,
0.009316925,
0.0094898036,
0.0073192623,
0.008807838,
-0.0075588431,
0.004173365,
0.0120655177,
0.0164733492,
-0.0398297571,
-0.0208618082,
0.0386590175,
0.0470010452,
0.0246719792,
-0.0166523382,
0.0252749436,
0.0024991147,
-0.0083576376,
-0.0052728234,
0.0554839,
-0.0376960449,
-0.0328144096,
0.0065059788,
0.0790383741,
-0.0212104972,
-0.0069104889,
-0.0080854669,
-0.0283735525,
0.0025879419,
0.0466080345,
0.0213790759,
-0.0240809321,
-0.043443203,
-0.0279829223,
-0.0579661764,
0.0071330508,
-0.0277299155,
-0.010388677,
-0.0144790374,
-0.0059580514,
-0.0576255657,
-0.0171429384,
0.0898308977,
0.0888875201,
0.0139323734,
-0.037851885,
-0.0139501188,
0.0129114874,
-0.008001836,
0.0497362986,
-0.0262400396,
0.029020844,
-0.0337303765,
0.011369627,
0.0404613316,
-0.0383451656,
-0.000344794,
0.0131166046,
-0.029288305,
-0.05534444,
0.0026110685,
0.0321749635,
0.0265302267,
0.0373507962,
0.0142167853,
0.0063681835,
0.0198164862,
-0.0257282052,
-0.0167098381,
0.0741089359,
0.0190431401,
0.0230216589,
0.0101337908,
0.0434939228,
-0.0454108939,
-0.0156157631,
0.0000926408,
0.0235417951,
0.0056485417,
0.0091618644,
0.0179228988,
-0.002450844,
-0.0059834584,
-0.0115571329,
-0.0177469589,
-0.0638204515,
0.0116327275,
-0.0292055774,
-0.0208215341,
-0.0514399596,
0.0164004751,
-0.0042184773,
0.0216536466,
0.0421052091,
-0.001641312,
0.0301881079,
0.0294405967,
0.0250286236,
0.0180137008,
0.0218078624,
-0.0032844667,
0.022574082,
0.0360650457,
0.0045672408,
0.0006477583,
-0.0497578457,
0.071141459,
0.0274760164,
0.0948101431,
0.0496068746,
-0.0320940539,
-0.0268778373,
-0.0017753186,
-0.0444176681,
-0.0900884643,
0.013496561,
0.0417488143,
0.0529696941,
-0.0325996988,
-0.0003266395,
-0.0776532069,
0.0070696776,
0.020544298,
0.0308197364,
0.0353819393,
-0.0463906117,
0.0419111587,
0.0225780159,
0.0319171138,
0.0070326556,
0.0177628715,
-0.015276798,
0.0652441084,
0.0185528994,
0.0270515233,
-0.0406065099,
-0.0424830504,
0.0138642648,
-0.0236716215,
0.0090605337,
-0.0017207836,
-0.0394670665,
-0.0539545007,
-0.0119558927,
0.0476037674,
-0.0272590425,
-0.0119260121,
0.0397895463,
0.0074209641,
-0.0105992611,
-0.0401433744,
-0.0069978172,
-0.0161463656,
0.0205652453,
-0.0000503174,
-0.0383054838,
-5.684755333e-33,
-0.0534364581,
-0.0265883673,
0.0541082062,
-0.0469898693,
-0.0298291724,
-0.0258404445,
-0.0491377711,
0.0381201766,
-0.0099089714,
0.0212428067,
0.0068260864,
-0.0294605847,
0.0050834874,
0.0035551691,
0.023908494,
-0.0255424287,
-0.0081994003,
-0.0187537149,
-0.0476603061,
-0.0086310804,
0.0321493372,
-0.0077271331,
0.0084592924,
-0.046757739,
0.0380587988,
0.0424851254,
-0.0116574159,
0.0554420501,
-0.0499256402,
0.0197866,
-0.0126100574,
-0.0153074609,
0.0238407496,
-0.0185234696,
-0.0193520151,
0.0247003268,
-0.063509129,
-0.0536441654,
-0.0268604942,
0.0400456674,
-0.0759549066,
-0.009621908,
0.0235312879,
0.0098590814,
-0.0451050699,
-0.0086886324,
-0.0043267454,
-0.0328769721,
0.02173182,
0.067382738,
-0.0096702874,
0.0131573612,
0.0135788927,
-0.0637839139,
0.0363532677,
0.0258084703,
0.0223475304,
-0.0351025499,
-0.0365750715,
0.0013878861,
-0.0050337068,
-0.0080987336,
0.0875381455,
0.0154662207,
0.0663440004,
0.0791925639,
0.0341273732,
0.0013609701,
-0.007686927,
-0.0239017215,
0.0382898375,
0.0605816022,
0.0051627192,
0.0158615746,
0.0393006541,
0.0499163568,
-0.0020571775,
0.0190451033,
-0.0242527183,
0.1043452322,
0.0003757785,
0.018976476,
-0.0405422226,
-0.0071611758,
-0.0615798756,
0.0318697281,
0.0071011544,
-0.0086546699,
0.0382886268,
0.0385447927,
0.0375748686,
-0.0657743216,
0.0497090183,
0.0038812303,
-0.0156595483,
-0.0122993281,
-0.0092155496,
0.0685237348,
0.0036942866,
-0.0108984271,
-0.0583089925,
-0.0057508512,
0.02037636,
-0.0335762203,
0.018542286,
0.0089897756,
-0.0253411047,
0.0819120854,
-0.0254643876,
-0.0119639281,
-0.0508945324,
-0.0127962427,
0.0439831428,
-0.0218182653,
0.0658922866,
0.0078637572,
-0.0451560467,
0.0622871444,
-0.0117600318,
-0.0392796956,
0.0120608239,
0.0016870825,
-0.0352676585,
0.0046301344,
-0.050575275,
-0.0399878919,
-0.0165585428,
0.0069534085,
0.0177969877,
-0.065828748,
0.0102990558,
0.0140331816,
2.931e-7,
0.0026054361,
-0.0027611793,
0.0536588989,
0.0273298435,
0.0156310443,
0.0319419429,
-0.0500967279,
-0.0034062848,
-0.0376543775,
-0.0593860745,
-0.0043742899,
0.0496320017,
0.027916532,
-0.0182170961,
-0.0488182567,
-0.0038211327,
0.0388261564,
-0.0498078614,
-0.0509429798,
0.0016625939,
0.0395065211,
0.0382998995,
0.0002120668,
0.0025246104,
0.0095488261,
-0.0505075902,
0.0257042628,
-0.0809424222,
0.037308339,
-0.0169695336,
0.0059466735,
-0.0155910114,
-0.0220540091,
0.0229898449,
0.0060075684,
-0.0083167404,
-0.0247628037,
0.0356224179,
-0.0224837624,
0.0074315895,
-0.0058075404,
0.0123331845,
-0.0303628501,
-0.0043651289,
0.0843325406,
-0.0627723634,
-0.0024637033,
-0.006115119,
0.0244536456,
-0.0078983279,
-0.0374371186,
0.0247928947,
0.0211142562,
-0.0069290483,
-0.0136731286,
0.0064065959,
-0.0213109627,
-0.064378947,
-0.0213695597,
-0.0144129833,
-0.0647739172,
-0.0431747437,
-0.0291736815,
-0.0135109872,
-0.0332162455,
-0.0607703626,
-0.0353968218,
2.500344442e-34,
0.0013892397,
-0.0126162441,
0.0180460736,
0.0392916612,
0.0458535291,
-0.0022607499,
0.0205114819,
0.0226599611,
0.0697810575,
-0.0408007018,
-0.0580214299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12011v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12011v1 | Gold: A Global and Local-aware Denoising Framework for Commonsense Knowledge Graph Noise Detection | 2023-10-18T14:43:07 | 2023-10-18T14:43:07 | Zheye Deng, Weiqi Wang, Zhaowei Wang, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Commonsense Knowledge Graphs (CSKGs) are crucial for commonsense reasoning,
yet constructing them through human annotations can be costly. As a result,
various automatic methods have been proposed to construct CSKG with larger
semantic coverage. However, these unsupervised approaches introduce spurious
noise that can lower the quality of the resulting CSKG, which cannot be tackled
easily by existing denoising algorithms due to the unique characteristics of
nodes and structures in CSKGs. To address this issue, we propose Gold (Global
and Local-aware Denoising), a denoising framework for CSKGs that incorporates
entity semantic information, global rules, and local structural information
from the CSKG. Experiment results demonstrate that Gold outperforms all
baseline methods in noise detection tasks on synthetic noisy CSKG benchmarks.
Furthermore, we show that denoising a real-world CSKG is effective and even
benefits the downstream zero-shot commonsense question-answering task. | [
0.0199864563,
0.0257437378,
0.0172560513,
0.0278814044,
0.0127740167,
-0.0075634508,
-0.0243110023,
0.04258205,
0.0626735166,
-0.0122583164,
0.0202820264,
0.0665388405,
-0.0024132549,
-0.0233960841,
0.0187534131,
0.0030245299,
0.02606575,
-0.0150614772,
0.0562272519,
-0.0349575169,
-0.0032495873,
0.0163442325,
-0.0060987948,
0.0173841007,
-0.0136455651,
-0.0306616612,
0.0014439528,
0.0092658084,
-0.002604197,
-0.0109391008,
-0.0239521768,
0.0508587696,
-0.0173449554,
-0.0174521785,
0.000002123,
-0.0189429224,
0.0383335762,
0.0222502742,
-0.0075220596,
-0.006134897,
-0.026803188,
0.0289618503,
0.0236689337,
-0.0342100263,
-0.0182277076,
-0.0111011891,
0.0199920088,
0.026935637,
0.0519553982,
0.0213644281,
-0.0113080051,
-0.0017519421,
0.0067518665,
0.0184970032,
0.0435942411,
-0.0752462074,
0.04093045,
0.0523385666,
-0.0016211987,
-0.0554284416,
-0.0134847211,
0.0346204974,
-0.0215954352,
-0.0194298103,
0.0384079702,
0.0082751941,
-0.0330163576,
0.0039193057,
0.0223644841,
0.1258298606,
0.0245114919,
-0.031824898,
0.0139298802,
0.0165248346,
0.0360515714,
0.0306744017,
-0.0077824062,
-0.012333652,
-0.0132656023,
-0.0006648083,
0.0003145272,
-0.0366846249,
0.0405339077,
0.0279936511,
0.0217469055,
0.0553998463,
-0.0176351294,
-0.019581629,
0.0063195117,
-0.0011887337,
-0.0227077119,
-0.0472015925,
0.0419884063,
0.0622457676,
-0.0490186885,
-0.0034623698,
-0.0220524278,
-0.0261967294,
-0.0073237997,
-0.0286228359,
-0.0357398987,
0.0146837682,
0.0065076537,
0.0700736418,
-0.0087962868,
-0.021652095,
0.0197272263,
-0.0057431911,
-0.0177570768,
-0.0259931348,
-0.0372237414,
0.02340772,
-0.0333817787,
0.0832088515,
-0.0716376081,
-0.0177000389,
-0.0316899493,
-0.0306300782,
-0.0340040326,
0.0213213451,
0.031343367,
0.0433392562,
-0.0121078063,
-0.0265339874,
0.0123911258,
0.0269916561,
-0.0485343523,
0.02328787,
0.0205871314,
0.0230536759,
-0.018266758,
0.0140945129,
0.0634384155,
0.0114979101,
-0.0065058223,
0.031813141,
0.0241755638,
0.0367033519,
-0.050667204,
-0.0511910468,
0.0288461708,
0.0031843251,
-0.0320236683,
-0.0449859984,
-0.0168344323,
-0.0155339148,
0.0076472629,
-0.0159556028,
0.0270254463,
-0.0013315666,
-0.0368163064,
0.0658223853,
-0.0956718773,
-0.007066248,
-0.019844871,
0.0211918242,
0.0258846078,
0.0506663769,
0.0038557402,
-0.0531061403,
0.0482927598,
0.0090313163,
-0.0345016792,
-0.0031773583,
0.0537561327,
-0.0109443609,
0.0233912356,
-0.0132761262,
-0.0659573898,
0.0194319021,
0.0395648293,
0.0169686656,
-0.0516640469,
-0.0245207921,
0.0402129628,
0.0639909729,
-0.0384985916,
-0.0137111265,
-0.014922699,
0.0468946919,
-0.0043626409,
0.0256981514,
-0.0192649029,
-0.0338696279,
-0.0993913859,
-0.0035377659,
-0.0115363859,
-0.0122299902,
-0.0177815817,
-0.0111253019,
-0.0001254339,
-0.0118293725,
0.0441639908,
-0.0009365755,
0.0360004082,
0.0424210504,
-0.0140114967,
0.056799259,
0.0453000031,
-0.040697176,
-0.0063878591,
0.0030172158,
0.0585580803,
0.0340878963,
0.0472034439,
-0.0001493368,
-0.0534812398,
0.0081318552,
-0.0113402875,
0.0405966304,
-0.0510511473,
-0.0409975089,
0.0362802632,
-0.0609398261,
-0.0454477817,
0.0250520334,
0.0063951733,
-0.0428112112,
0.0439544506,
-0.0113844117,
-0.0021980421,
-0.1060491949,
-0.0036577252,
-0.0049946071,
0.0388204306,
-0.0148696816,
0.0126856631,
-0.0178030152,
0.0229397379,
0.0201941505,
0.0133652221,
-0.008097549,
0.0315942466,
0.000030932,
0.0033509473,
0.0342983007,
-0.0109089836,
-0.0791145712,
0.0684632584,
-0.0385316648,
-0.0753525645,
-0.0171510093,
-0.0021092531,
-0.0194294639,
0.0108805913,
-0.0277209431,
0.0395839587,
-0.0248292312,
-0.0627741888,
0.0179008301,
-0.023523055,
-0.0015093962,
0.0983882546,
-0.0218474995,
-0.0155622801,
0.0227112845,
-0.0067122299,
0.0339104198,
-0.0233061351,
-0.0069236951,
-0.0738901645,
-0.0102186399,
-0.0005822438,
0.0177459028,
0.0235951673,
-0.0476641878,
0.0586966537,
-0.0720393211,
-0.0323535986,
0.0262457486,
0.0029663048,
-0.0140796527,
0.0161350593,
0.0260414872,
-0.0503391027,
-0.035707131,
0.0555839948,
-0.0058372351,
-0.0091199325,
0.0240009017,
-0.0162322558,
-0.0025957972,
0.0153638069,
0.0034376322,
-0.0073425812,
0.0033452339,
0.0155189764,
0.0204473436,
-0.0263811015,
0.0505419374,
-0.0298270825,
0.0327768028,
0.0233827829,
-0.0306986142,
0.0117806271,
-0.0017072394,
-0.0105842715,
0.0321098939,
-0.0592352338,
0.0182288382,
0.0231440365,
-0.043666862,
-0.0159430895,
0.0214486346,
-0.0033153058,
0.065795444,
-0.0399997234,
0.0036427989,
-0.0186578613,
0.0535794906,
-0.0066248369,
-0.0038941461,
-0.0545430481,
0.0127517032,
-0.0241967179,
-0.0376204178,
-0.0726947859,
0.0085114017,
-0.0061963936,
0.0336464569,
-0.0410338603,
0.033747144,
0.0649672672,
0.0300424136,
0.0310157333,
-0.005895141,
0.026799934,
0.0354779027,
0.0192930121,
-0.032262627,
0.0113359168,
0.034533564,
-0.0196951292,
-0.0233059879,
-0.0492171347,
0.0682400316,
-0.0209549181,
-0.0240738336,
-0.0472726561,
0.032734137,
0.0167140607,
-0.0212840047,
-0.0198481213,
0.007435122,
0.0069683963,
0.0087429434,
0.0233129822,
-0.0243011191,
0.0115003651,
0.0033235473,
-0.0028469865,
-0.0063786916,
0.0247613527,
0.0015302855,
0.0114047443,
0.1155470833,
0.0441699326,
0.0446049199,
0.0115518169,
0.0452097096,
-0.0219228603,
0.076358743,
-0.006902203,
-0.0378444195,
0.0253861547,
0.0090370551,
0.0085317716,
0.0005001041,
-0.0085013984,
0.016008364,
0.0800337493,
-0.0566188917,
-0.0141873034,
0.0712299943,
0.0144359414,
-0.0153506957,
-0.0033369802,
-0.0042054779,
0.0056506991,
-0.000256311,
-0.0302128959,
-0.0950239375,
-0.0549847446,
-0.0010200625,
0.0151008898,
0.0018533593,
-0.0830093771,
0.0513928346,
-0.0906669125,
0.0144463321,
-0.0023145163,
-0.1035839394,
-0.0483002812,
-0.0744160265,
0.0353394635,
-0.0160876326,
-0.0121945785,
-0.0119680967,
0.0359927788,
0.001672424,
0.0277110096,
-0.0354255252,
-0.0875292495,
-0.0117601873,
-0.0275545977,
0.1030204743,
-0.0169903226,
0.0531758219,
0.0166041441,
-0.0896642506,
-0.0248669013,
-0.0247032121,
-0.0181131363,
-0.0434265845,
0.0056009199,
0.0168835167,
-0.0346804596,
-0.044294171,
0.0205499437,
-0.0810326785,
-0.0229218844,
0.0137064252,
0.0666400716,
0.0109183686,
-0.0068869959,
-0.0173121747,
0.0176207777,
0.0375196636,
0.0646172985,
0.0478244089,
0.0304502882,
-0.0221049543,
-0.0452414602,
0.0032736731,
-0.0621378571,
-0.0062423954,
0.0245386884,
-0.0013642834,
-0.0120948199,
-0.074034512,
-0.0466412939,
0.0484368466,
0.001311162,
-0.0085465126,
0.0217864178,
0.0269285329,
0.0186267514,
-0.0546818487,
0.0052918247,
-0.0492320247,
-0.0375594646,
0.0289964154,
0.0058225435,
-0.0356186144,
0.0477146059,
-0.0320177637,
0.0560828783,
-0.0347647183,
-0.050848566,
-0.0111991558,
0.0121219903,
0.0075215376,
0.0202386845,
-0.063888438,
-0.0163119771,
0.0525893159,
0.0471646637,
-0.0844105706,
-0.0113480315,
0.0577034727,
-0.0369968526,
0.0146324867,
0.0582077689,
-0.0331661329,
-0.0061186189,
0.009197887,
0.0529545695,
-0.0805990696,
0.0028964572,
-0.000273792,
0.0565528795,
0.003422129,
0.000361818,
0.0284735374,
-0.0255998895,
-0.0238720495,
-0.0156240873,
-0.0330156572,
-0.0085787578,
0.0180699192,
0.018932227,
-0.0449812561,
0.0100612184,
0.0529636703,
-0.0262775533,
0.0176796019,
-0.0331445076,
-0.0158034638,
0.0474750474,
0.0031818552,
0.0346925594,
-0.0223151855,
-0.0066159228,
0.035856124,
0.0227131136,
0.009336412,
0.0148198931,
0.0022450443,
0.0206025615,
-0.0233910792,
-0.0022888323,
-0.0337565094,
0.0038006972,
0.0457534306,
0.010475358,
0.0404205546,
0.0540149473,
0.0052279793,
0.0590754822,
0.007906598,
-0.0404173993,
0.0174963027,
0.0366127156,
0.0106764855,
0.0011412014,
0.0298325978,
0.0101630818,
-0.0079300357,
0.0128682358,
0.0961506069,
-0.0284566917,
0.0509501882,
-0.0008872193,
-0.0183595493,
-0.0551621765,
-0.0286436155,
0.0143978726,
0.1003905162,
-0.0025252344,
0.0703157708,
-0.0462092683,
-0.0726189464,
-0.0623860396,
0.0043418827,
0.0067306403,
-0.0042902399,
0.0379891358,
0.0109405247,
0.0463609546,
-0.0689617544,
0.0063059218,
-0.0016149124,
-0.0739645287,
-0.0088114999,
0.0071556931,
-6.629128392e-33,
-0.0281643011,
-0.0817226619,
-0.0177909359,
0.004189847,
0.0038684073,
0.0101191448,
-0.0605069585,
0.0144113181,
-0.0143125365,
0.1014189422,
-0.0005960329,
0.0691022277,
0.0020501406,
-0.0161246601,
-0.0223851297,
-0.0074330303,
0.0262090974,
0.0040018419,
0.0166496765,
0.0211210027,
0.013239515,
0.001015073,
0.0634893924,
-0.0658645481,
0.0481278487,
-0.0060067838,
-0.0326353125,
0.0055638021,
0.0075176945,
0.0323889442,
-0.0195720289,
0.1025999784,
-0.0119374869,
0.0307629947,
0.0041425237,
-0.0383791327,
-0.0951137468,
-0.0441696569,
0.0402694903,
-0.0051693041,
-0.0550541207,
-0.01831007,
0.0642430708,
0.0442825928,
-0.0124309761,
-0.0085729528,
0.0421225168,
-0.0381317846,
-0.0647063851,
-0.0467374213,
-0.0138914417,
0.045786377,
-0.0333915204,
-0.0218065605,
-0.0127527397,
-0.0505053401,
-0.0306955855,
-0.062237002,
-0.0706586689,
0.0389719382,
0.0170120113,
-0.0022055118,
-0.0031435087,
-0.0257559568,
0.0048289816,
0.019328637,
-0.0290026516,
-0.0173507985,
-0.0331658088,
0.0302588716,
0.0108828433,
0.04159059,
0.0508751646,
0.0678104982,
0.0298775677,
-0.0090308255,
-0.1010655388,
0.0427502207,
-0.0135947196,
0.0714733228,
-0.028432982,
-0.0075284685,
-0.0295005627,
-0.0317139067,
-0.0127612725,
-0.0637660027,
-0.0177528113,
0.0106943566,
-0.0270926058,
-0.024452379,
-0.0647305995,
-0.0057662134,
-0.039118927,
-0.030706834,
0.0375224836,
0.0503316037,
0.0391735733,
-0.0327542163,
0.0180585701,
-0.0286824219,
-0.0548987687,
0.0069200313,
0.0248152576,
0.0212928429,
0.0036720035,
0.0424048267,
-0.0023184046,
-0.0198986344,
-0.0044950489,
-0.0181993488,
-0.0108095761,
0.0159831736,
-0.0275557097,
-0.0237886682,
0.0444354378,
-0.0230084416,
0.0133017031,
0.006499283,
0.0290893093,
0.0572356544,
0.0343680792,
0.0511567481,
0.0079698171,
0.007880521,
-0.0033930661,
-0.0353285633,
-0.024076933,
-0.0439306162,
0.0099801682,
-0.0231090784,
0.0000977268,
0.0045217955,
2.787e-7,
0.0011492172,
0.0385218933,
0.0224182643,
0.0178193189,
0.0074480213,
0.0443380065,
0.0349586457,
-0.0231514573,
-0.0081859324,
-0.0848205835,
0.0056380462,
0.0328761749,
0.0001813053,
0.0549447797,
-0.0716750845,
-0.0033999039,
-0.0292136706,
-0.0109571172,
-0.003011452,
0.0204128847,
0.008198739,
0.0057146279,
0.0248379,
-0.0264740977,
0.0424969383,
-0.0492390841,
0.0081129177,
-0.0068025533,
-0.0020670206,
-0.0067565884,
0.0331088267,
-0.0256190784,
0.0209063664,
0.0628405586,
-0.0063851457,
-0.0108959656,
0.0161183272,
0.0177536011,
-0.0232414342,
-0.0029158606,
-0.0237172078,
-0.0368915573,
0.0479417741,
-0.0462502688,
0.0684542581,
-0.0232430883,
-0.039348904,
-0.0094885165,
-0.0320478119,
-0.0254984554,
-0.0026027737,
0.0010153881,
-0.035727419,
-0.0763522908,
0.0209801309,
0.0095836222,
-0.0190925729,
-0.0266990941,
0.0022615336,
0.0108660357,
0.0215724111,
-0.0531372949,
0.0216562301,
-0.0694112554,
0.0012996178,
-0.0392930023,
0.0285274647,
2.146608805e-34,
0.0171397738,
0.0091480743,
0.0107578151,
0.0089747626,
-0.001238408,
-0.0158218779,
-0.0558713861,
-0.0492881536,
0.0449470878,
-0.0477091447,
0.0289993007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.12008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.12008v1 | Multi-view Contrastive Learning for Entity Typing over Knowledge Graphs | 2023-10-18T14:41:09 | 2023-10-18T14:41:09 | Zhiwei Hu, Víctor Gutiérrez-Basulto, Zhiliang Xiang, Ru Li, Jeff Z. Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge graph entity typing (KGET) aims at inferring plausible types of
entities in knowledge graphs. Existing approaches to KGET focus on how to
better encode the knowledge provided by the neighbors and types of an entity
into its representation. However, they ignore the semantic knowledge provided
by the way in which types can be clustered together. In this paper, we propose
a novel method called Multi-view Contrastive Learning for knowledge graph
Entity Typing (MCLET), which effectively encodes the coarse-grained knowledge
provided by clusters into entity and type embeddings. MCLET is composed of
three modules: i) Multi-view Generation and Encoder module, which encodes
structured information from entity-type, entity-cluster and cluster-type views;
ii) Cross-view Contrastive Learning module, which encourages different views to
collaboratively improve view-specific representations of entities and types;
iii) Entity Typing Prediction module, which integrates multi-head attention and
a Mixture-of-Experts strategy to infer missing entity types. Extensive
experiments show the strong performance of MCLET compared to the
state-of-the-art | [
0.0197881944,
-0.0106705772,
0.0233780164,
0.0483666137,
0.0226144586,
0.0270575974,
-0.0276735276,
-0.0118932892,
0.0879959464,
-0.0397667028,
0.0134095335,
-0.012849181,
-0.0043434482,
0.0232906844,
0.0784413293,
-0.0606756806,
0.0327937864,
0.0219828244,
-0.0170600526,
0.0016894218,
0.0107348217,
0.0382614024,
0.0268169548,
0.0000392884,
0.0047988649,
-0.0343326665,
-0.022052791,
-0.0088706827,
0.0499428362,
-0.0287591312,
0.0128708854,
0.0268082004,
0.027410388,
0.0180997383,
0.0000020215,
-0.0241158698,
-0.0129663758,
-0.0040130494,
0.0016958737,
-0.0116050448,
-0.0049543171,
-0.0380514152,
0.0640741661,
-0.0044852896,
-0.0082122646,
-0.0635632277,
0.0322266333,
0.0738159493,
-0.0056886496,
0.0640188605,
-0.0164942332,
-0.0379386842,
0.040088553,
-0.0155711183,
0.0105444696,
-0.0162391514,
0.0265514459,
-0.0279196277,
-0.0187855847,
0.0618005283,
0.0019025251,
0.0158703048,
0.019605672,
0.0165760629,
0.0394981131,
0.0703157783,
0.0311233718,
0.0405522436,
0.0004133563,
0.0989054367,
-0.0040870742,
0.0058191679,
-0.0019274121,
-0.0155166863,
0.0123006068,
0.0222603586,
0.0305543896,
-0.059090104,
-0.057127066,
-0.0197996553,
0.0178826861,
0.0076925028,
0.0287739243,
-0.030897392,
-0.0189317893,
-0.0431149527,
0.0034052006,
-0.0290991906,
-0.0013977656,
0.0201464072,
-0.0109261638,
-0.0535791814,
0.0030253793,
0.0195213687,
-0.0206599627,
-0.0087428736,
-0.0175755154,
0.0077240649,
0.0006088152,
-0.0503971204,
-0.0336341038,
0.0254938547,
0.0161037091,
0.0695393905,
-0.025455134,
-0.0149519993,
-0.0345654078,
-0.0235211346,
-0.0177576505,
-0.0377091691,
-0.0445528589,
0.0201738905,
-0.022266347,
0.0521437377,
0.0137870805,
-0.013469805,
-0.0121778222,
0.0254914444,
-0.0312709026,
0.0349335857,
0.019811308,
0.0279249903,
0.0112918532,
-0.0448911488,
-0.0215459317,
0.0337476954,
-0.0464457124,
0.0033271234,
-0.0381755084,
-0.0014237302,
-0.0093177669,
-0.0093946354,
0.0007258412,
-0.0380162932,
0.0134531129,
0.0435438417,
0.0100516332,
-0.0165069643,
-0.105152756,
-0.0299110319,
-0.0078969747,
-0.0254328251,
0.0015520068,
-0.0667202249,
0.0089867814,
0.0203910135,
-0.0229200907,
-0.05599574,
0.007832435,
-0.0488234162,
-0.0562722199,
0.0834734142,
-0.0601083599,
-0.0396755859,
0.0068308543,
-0.002081403,
-0.0874663666,
0.0206863489,
0.0236764625,
-0.0260697063,
-0.0113414107,
-0.0214598924,
0.0064558298,
0.0147056449,
0.0242156666,
0.0047028838,
0.0143867666,
0.0153758135,
-0.039182514,
0.0123823239,
0.045235794,
0.0294370782,
-0.0046937247,
-0.0274650808,
0.0087851146,
-0.0112775266,
0.0276465379,
0.0523157977,
0.0596539713,
-0.0161120407,
-0.0146671338,
0.0250102878,
-0.0183197279,
0.0257783569,
-0.0373341739,
0.0221265461,
0.0585292578,
0.0509575494,
-0.0442197993,
0.0125996703,
0.0279154945,
-0.0092513142,
0.0213298015,
-0.0092097726,
0.0501643047,
0.007478809,
-0.0365474261,
0.0146667706,
0.0230009481,
0.0105915554,
0.0033986978,
0.0217671748,
0.0094551491,
0.0742983371,
0.0214002654,
-0.0382421277,
-0.0563220941,
-0.024116395,
-0.0585884452,
0.0198806245,
0.0300601907,
-0.0347443856,
-0.027171107,
-0.0501830876,
-0.0462018475,
-0.0040086242,
-0.0039895717,
0.041195035,
-0.0127329687,
0.0470862426,
0.0239214823,
-0.0766905546,
0.0181222502,
-0.0041317777,
-0.0184561331,
0.0255821105,
-0.0023332555,
0.0642825142,
-0.010840307,
0.0621194765,
0.0368559249,
0.0041399631,
0.0010391151,
-0.0253535081,
-0.0204760507,
-0.003507304,
0.0044379905,
-0.0935056135,
0.0169910956,
-0.0307153556,
-0.0401455015,
-0.040129967,
-0.0300441217,
-0.02855606,
0.0292797349,
-0.0053436756,
0.0928560719,
-0.0023474141,
-0.0286473017,
0.0343521722,
-0.0076865591,
0.0135237221,
0.1254903525,
-0.0521426685,
0.0285849366,
0.0271305442,
-0.027508894,
-0.0054563996,
0.0118178399,
-0.0133244069,
-0.0108395629,
0.0404414237,
0.0094138989,
0.0101107527,
-0.0360844098,
-0.0849433988,
0.010986466,
-0.0911646113,
-0.00459497,
0.0080488538,
0.0229926109,
-0.0166046098,
0.0147083877,
0.0380288996,
-0.0132891824,
-0.0300586708,
0.003120858,
-0.0780182034,
0.0100824609,
0.0211652089,
-0.0125205191,
0.0306021255,
0.0182925146,
-0.0215098038,
-0.0579193234,
0.0712247267,
0.0013506368,
-0.0455906205,
-0.0495690852,
0.0904354453,
-0.0361872651,
-0.0023991398,
-0.0184564423,
0.0269423444,
-0.0172005277,
0.0159490537,
0.0422427431,
0.0430537835,
-0.0183408577,
-0.0125525985,
-0.0079564163,
0.0092991889,
-0.0533292368,
0.0272283815,
-0.0005471868,
0.083973527,
-0.0128614195,
0.0098302383,
-0.0529440418,
0.0453379713,
0.0220699292,
-0.0435949452,
-0.0898729563,
0.0164834373,
0.0514669344,
0.0215653982,
0.0096440185,
0.0352852866,
0.0377466828,
-0.0360850431,
-0.0378581583,
0.0520435609,
0.1109055355,
0.0013599644,
0.0183400605,
0.0518410541,
-0.0005494978,
-0.0384175517,
0.0143070966,
-0.0125724301,
0.0085343309,
-0.0115078874,
-0.049148079,
-0.0532632917,
0.045599252,
0.0054367939,
-0.0064817206,
0.0637745336,
0.0581868105,
0.0037692243,
0.0146952653,
-0.0285162684,
-0.0195733327,
0.0109523162,
-0.0316639766,
0.0564143993,
0.0583854914,
-0.0133974729,
-0.0305136144,
0.0071399403,
-0.0158847552,
0.0252654348,
0.0289176628,
-0.0479916781,
-0.0302915126,
0.0573928542,
0.00579968,
0.0056630322,
0.0255516171,
-0.018488219,
0.0160810351,
0.0332610086,
0.0115926396,
-0.0468890555,
-0.0401914306,
-0.0085936636,
-0.0140695684,
-0.0429165699,
-0.0645803958,
-0.0075715464,
0.0161450133,
-0.0467623509,
0.0423811115,
0.0841880217,
0.0001259847,
-0.0662876666,
-0.0096382787,
0.0173261128,
0.0216298215,
0.0419155657,
0.0258563794,
-0.0765182525,
-0.0249221791,
-0.0147944381,
0.0210923329,
0.067282632,
-0.0819608718,
0.0222101789,
-0.0858764425,
-0.0102957189,
0.0040199058,
-0.0480110906,
-0.0537134148,
-0.0422501825,
0.0234487355,
-0.0373488441,
-0.0475727059,
-0.0093210079,
0.0009726026,
0.0046907244,
0.0345410705,
-0.0036695325,
-0.0360789746,
0.0417620614,
-0.0558081046,
0.032498233,
-0.0185385589,
0.015937509,
0.0046683517,
-0.0101338876,
-0.0624155737,
-0.0143235624,
-0.032409966,
0.0064029042,
0.066504322,
-0.0633966252,
0.0065125907,
0.0070803114,
0.0259583853,
-0.0278214719,
0.0030206114,
-0.0023879407,
0.1007375419,
0.0164435394,
-0.0284502544,
-0.0193881355,
-0.0516144373,
0.0259256046,
0.0445691533,
0.0114971818,
-0.002554914,
-0.0014241467,
-0.0701576844,
0.0335789509,
-0.0137057016,
0.0308743585,
0.0270467587,
-0.0192758311,
0.0072086491,
-0.0225707553,
-0.0572214238,
0.0562655926,
0.0206597354,
0.0058150417,
0.0108833257,
0.0388851054,
-0.0223185737,
-0.1008147821,
0.0073413877,
0.0096128872,
0.0121412594,
0.0021960004,
-0.0353353694,
0.0226919875,
-0.0267413389,
-0.0340646096,
-0.0215930305,
-0.0509772189,
-0.0714413151,
-0.0802969858,
0.0274367034,
-0.0082003502,
0.0878134891,
-0.0045884051,
-0.006816389,
0.06829831,
0.0301646758,
-0.0343561992,
-0.0563062802,
0.0221586619,
0.0136515833,
0.0034110111,
0.040929012,
-0.0601556078,
-0.0671994686,
-0.0121018207,
0.0339289866,
-0.0808617771,
-0.0293890033,
0.0001938348,
-0.0007916689,
0.0205443203,
0.0141053377,
0.0278831292,
-0.0623480566,
-0.0005190482,
0.0307349227,
-0.0254609436,
-0.0336205103,
-0.0002486676,
-0.0022922498,
-0.03040874,
0.0044542043,
0.0497994795,
0.0261652414,
0.016389247,
-0.0365241654,
0.0036399963,
0.0393656716,
-0.0084854681,
0.0401729159,
-0.0537421629,
-0.028153887,
0.0307341833,
0.0195742529,
0.0188320708,
-0.0359928273,
0.020483749,
0.0221581738,
0.0078228228,
-0.0440190397,
0.0044516316,
-0.01134142,
-0.0171181075,
-0.075031288,
0.014242677,
0.0204692278,
0.007210088,
0.0093859136,
-0.019715244,
-0.0062943879,
-0.0091576101,
0.047597792,
-0.0197174624,
-0.019995084,
0.0350826532,
0.0190287363,
-0.0143134473,
0.0070017744,
0.084823139,
-0.0376781859,
0.0806941837,
-0.0097741606,
-0.0547672808,
-0.0524415299,
-0.0072072712,
0.0643047243,
0.0331166163,
-0.0004162089,
0.0345971361,
-0.0669641942,
-0.0958082601,
0.0423418805,
-0.0224607382,
-0.0546729267,
0.045155663,
0.0132152764,
0.0137883686,
0.0422479995,
-0.018650841,
-0.0278139859,
-0.017338248,
0.004327619,
-0.0145291444,
-0.0102361012,
-6.396734629e-33,
-0.0083174743,
-0.0448115245,
0.0299296323,
-0.0497638881,
-0.0142217949,
0.0171804931,
0.0036879671,
-0.0211492442,
-0.0399702154,
0.0104611358,
0.0030537611,
0.0185247548,
-0.0258802548,
0.0093649179,
0.0351316072,
-0.0156889632,
0.0316824168,
0.0337887406,
0.0163409598,
0.0250898339,
0.0464893878,
0.0311164763,
0.0844420344,
-0.0480729491,
0.0239219796,
-0.0028262679,
0.016457513,
0.0023508414,
0.0196311492,
0.057931073,
-0.0081486842,
0.0365638062,
0.0272145309,
-0.0301668756,
-0.0113089662,
-0.0229159705,
-0.0826393813,
-0.0520438142,
-0.0247726757,
-0.0107695684,
-0.0573465824,
-0.0538500771,
0.0355577916,
-0.0007930822,
0.0834253281,
-0.0693329722,
0.0623361357,
0.000831033,
-0.0114011001,
-0.00171848,
0.017438164,
0.0222334545,
-0.0256882459,
0.015750343,
0.0012521719,
-0.0003335724,
0.046033062,
-0.0021873384,
-0.0851674303,
0.0211808085,
0.0146881742,
-0.0082387738,
0.0126614999,
0.0106046889,
-0.0016668247,
0.0053695994,
-0.0189986229,
0.0038052944,
-0.0380915366,
0.0037365684,
-0.0242777467,
0.0563850813,
-0.0183217376,
0.0742394254,
0.002413024,
0.0064447057,
-0.0124005489,
0.001961085,
-0.0212733559,
0.0104278224,
-0.0299538001,
-0.0158050787,
-0.0373661481,
-0.039196413,
-0.0120826671,
-0.0434726663,
-0.0409428068,
-0.0310476739,
-0.019595528,
-0.0098304283,
-0.0052875816,
0.0263784677,
-0.0025406666,
-0.0457287692,
-0.0175380465,
0.0661624372,
-0.0124223977,
0.02006259,
0.0293021705,
0.0097009176,
-0.0638091117,
-0.0247739106,
0.0382822119,
-0.0457997285,
-0.0008738337,
0.0478572138,
0.061474368,
-0.0080556469,
-0.0194003303,
-0.0097160507,
-0.0108748125,
-0.0489589237,
-0.0423857719,
-0.0242245793,
0.0557745136,
0.0316395685,
0.0065280288,
-0.0031579803,
0.0694506243,
0.0290298276,
0.0019927996,
0.0387249961,
0.0236250907,
0.0477542654,
0.004803821,
-0.0003395436,
-0.0271644983,
-0.0244138129,
0.0263959933,
-0.0348181501,
-0.0317784846,
0.0178740285,
2.777e-7,
0.0487823896,
0.0468250215,
-0.000771011,
0.0515338108,
0.0082320925,
0.0630621314,
0.037942566,
0.0627182648,
-0.0139968889,
-0.0310991462,
0.0487404093,
-0.0031132593,
0.0037775349,
0.0380204804,
-0.0563843809,
-0.018394988,
-0.0085899532,
0.0301675927,
-0.0420515984,
-0.0162235517,
0.05100495,
0.0546767712,
0.0292260889,
0.0214812867,
0.022006847,
-0.0189728048,
0.0525277406,
0.0415158048,
0.007694066,
0.0024288089,
0.0078549972,
0.0512375757,
-0.024647519,
0.0539367162,
-0.0147068603,
0.0226899963,
0.0410341546,
-0.0057963855,
-0.0217205901,
-0.0182801355,
0.0027384476,
-0.0319047011,
-0.0108209848,
-0.0350113288,
0.0579139777,
-0.0389067866,
0.0132203829,
0.0557802618,
-0.0548365749,
0.0083958842,
-0.000015881,
0.0029979541,
0.011616447,
-0.0113789868,
-0.0059648133,
-0.0043154513,
-0.0131364102,
-0.037106663,
0.035181392,
0.0295270458,
-0.0178274233,
-0.0295847468,
0.0230866838,
-0.0478016399,
0.0554855242,
-0.0536103994,
0.016158022,
2.333875387e-34,
0.0138521129,
0.0162462052,
-0.0155377295,
0.0181472283,
0.0283766408,
-0.0749498233,
-0.0724496767,
-0.0384303294,
0.053285908,
-0.0622346587,
-0.038656123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11986v2 | Sociotechnical Safety Evaluation of Generative AI Systems | 2023-10-18T14:13:58 | 2023-10-31T18:23:32 | Laura Weidinger, Maribeth Rauh, Nahema Marchal, Arianna Manzini, Lisa Anne Hendricks, Juan Mateos-Garcia, Stevie Bergman, Jackie Kay, Conor Griffin, Ben Bariach, Iason Gabriel, Verena Rieser, William Isaac | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Generative AI systems produce a range of risks. To ensure the safety of
generative AI systems, these risks must be evaluated. In this paper, we make
two main contributions toward establishing such evaluations. First, we propose
a three-layered framework that takes a structured, sociotechnical approach to
evaluating these risks. This framework encompasses capability evaluations,
which are the main current approach to safety evaluation. It then reaches
further by building on system safety principles, particularly the insight that
context determines whether a given capability may cause harm. To account for
relevant context, our framework adds human interaction and systemic impacts as
additional layers of evaluation. Second, we survey the current state of safety
evaluation of generative AI systems and create a repository of existing
evaluations. Three salient evaluation gaps emerge from this analysis. We
propose ways forward to closing these gaps, outlining practical steps as well
as roles and responsibilities for different actors. Sociotechnical safety
evaluation is a tractable approach to the robust and comprehensive safety
evaluation of generative AI systems. | [
-0.0098100686,
0.0731468871,
-0.0060668145,
-0.0369638391,
-0.0133384075,
0.006560748,
0.0453714542,
-0.0115826353,
0.0232784208,
0.0314932801,
-0.0319721326,
-0.0009633779,
0.0002488601,
0.0448337123,
0.0312644877,
-0.024823634,
0.0214864984,
-0.0230516568,
-0.0225280765,
0.033709459,
-0.0282215271,
-0.0235674735,
0.0148893055,
0.0566804633,
-0.0553623475,
-0.0332543217,
0.0141586885,
0.0153600564,
0.0902493894,
-0.031567838,
-0.0251923911,
-0.0064165466,
-0.0069077914,
0.0329900905,
0.0000020986,
-0.0481300093,
0.0232656859,
0.0417919159,
0.0208480228,
-0.0442014895,
0.0500129573,
0.0191737246,
-0.0398029946,
0.0040998971,
-0.0148141403,
-0.008171455,
0.0365807265,
-0.0264532026,
0.0299421716,
0.0220103394,
-0.0307943039,
0.0121552665,
0.0360423774,
0.0181493647,
-0.0191046428,
-0.0380570143,
-0.0205400195,
0.0177272875,
0.0320033804,
-0.022590721,
0.0160884894,
0.0593000948,
0.0405383296,
-0.0278617181,
0.0085480353,
0.0144564835,
0.0482465103,
-0.056649521,
0.0156064471,
0.0357283577,
0.0346182883,
0.0280474182,
0.0016527119,
-0.0067942361,
0.0260807928,
-0.0113997785,
0.0171087105,
0.0371224731,
0.0033006794,
-0.016904898,
-0.0194338076,
0.0596196838,
0.020225063,
-0.0186805129,
0.059976235,
0.0487283543,
-0.0072888746,
0.018114049,
-0.0080829291,
0.0026645903,
0.0189697575,
-0.0291484576,
-0.0215014853,
0.0204057451,
-0.0500743687,
-0.0013536625,
-0.0337202027,
-0.0159277227,
0.0089480178,
-0.059869878,
0.0095709218,
-0.0052196616,
0.0206163265,
0.012280358,
0.0484406725,
0.0000879527,
-0.0170696825,
0.0160011947,
-0.0151437558,
0.0274106693,
-0.0238108803,
0.012575916,
-0.0256034695,
-0.0322786905,
-0.0281964503,
0.0115368878,
-0.0060879793,
0.0440063141,
-0.0965613797,
0.0320016742,
-0.0264762435,
0.0364743136,
-0.0062015466,
0.0144035369,
-0.0085877068,
-0.0747035742,
-0.0702365935,
0.0110661201,
0.0083439527,
-0.0456397235,
0.0038908655,
0.0082937041,
-0.0332626961,
-0.0053222026,
-0.0240831748,
0.1030965224,
0.0291540194,
0.0111615798,
-0.0494118966,
-0.0573424473,
0.002316816,
-0.0418897085,
-0.0021744107,
0.0010599435,
-0.0202461518,
-0.0242987368,
0.0019710895,
-0.0286354162,
-0.0095100934,
-0.0034314843,
0.0110211689,
0.0199806262,
-0.0174339321,
0.0182313006,
0.0036583359,
0.0671983212,
-0.0424865149,
0.0188984964,
0.0522932187,
0.0388265885,
0.0028257463,
0.0121023236,
0.0807585269,
0.010560073,
-0.0343965665,
-0.0084664058,
0.0000679578,
0.0016006606,
-0.0441089422,
0.0015713564,
-0.025060514,
0.0569623597,
-0.0501361415,
0.0474876463,
0.0355404243,
0.0166222844,
-0.0088029057,
0.0657154322,
0.0674704611,
-0.0214025788,
-0.0156036671,
-0.0393592156,
-0.0107875997,
0.0240415093,
-0.0552854128,
-0.0261488315,
-0.0614023991,
0.0361705981,
-0.0194974262,
-0.0374711752,
0.031911198,
-0.0166953374,
0.0437618233,
0.0152352387,
0.0110542532,
0.0316630378,
0.0176232141,
-0.0825547948,
-0.0241809804,
-0.0657649785,
-0.0242305715,
-0.0796446353,
-0.0070966263,
0.1177725643,
0.0541832857,
-0.0367307588,
-0.0202421434,
-0.001019406,
-0.0690155998,
-0.0155337686,
-0.0361463465,
-0.0374140665,
0.0345004983,
0.0208898205,
-0.0151684675,
0.0016606541,
0.0185860619,
0.0409539454,
0.0196698401,
0.0309204794,
-0.0260312557,
0.0145077212,
-0.0453101359,
-0.006751691,
-0.0302404091,
-0.0417567901,
-0.0290625077,
0.0097269109,
0.0149895838,
0.0173251256,
-0.0364127941,
0.0201468356,
0.0272234306,
0.0181231778,
-0.0278762858,
0.0451941304,
0.0119031006,
0.0822877958,
-0.0161868818,
-0.0503668152,
-0.0122187119,
0.0130665796,
0.0048182853,
0.0050100093,
0.0194068011,
-0.0239405613,
-0.0342180133,
-0.0065083648,
-0.0082583791,
-0.0134198358,
-0.0317936726,
-0.0178113952,
0.0396510996,
0.0023765757,
-0.0686214864,
0.0214546919,
0.0132318577,
0.0385372378,
-0.0071194996,
-0.059384875,
0.0098905712,
-0.0209412873,
0.0125121977,
0.0151520269,
0.0096001988,
-0.0377048254,
0.026439514,
-0.0687277541,
-0.0410630144,
-0.0209515523,
0.0177901536,
-0.0162858497,
-0.0311064143,
-0.0058581419,
-0.021209741,
0.0053589325,
0.0463829115,
-0.020584736,
-0.0126728872,
0.0071763815,
0.0209448896,
-0.0100338776,
-0.012871094,
0.020116454,
-0.0101234159,
0.0428702123,
0.0747220218,
0.0149655649,
-0.0410585701,
0.0426472574,
-0.039253559,
0.0013274612,
0.0167530067,
-0.0135352975,
0.0217817407,
0.0359242223,
0.0215480141,
0.0219111927,
-0.0182367135,
0.0686963424,
0.0605983362,
-0.0064943372,
-0.0011403093,
0.0032428666,
0.0482342169,
-0.0343315154,
0.0336004235,
-0.0252016801,
-0.0201963279,
-0.0170124769,
-0.0310921539,
-0.0184370726,
-0.0193407238,
0.0719698071,
-0.0515272543,
-0.0910189673,
0.0365382619,
-0.0578661598,
-0.00946631,
0.0245474856,
-0.0213672183,
-0.0348901115,
0.0356156491,
0.0047534527,
0.0169277396,
0.0298714414,
-0.0391956195,
0.0128085371,
0.0892930627,
-0.0105972067,
0.0090232436,
0.0284339599,
0.0126142679,
-0.0293093957,
0.022976907,
0.0419166423,
-0.0189818032,
-0.017834859,
-0.0483916886,
-0.0120352414,
-0.0024749101,
-0.0507463552,
-0.0413783006,
0.0170619041,
0.0196214188,
0.0498304889,
0.0467344932,
-0.0301028807,
0.0237179492,
-0.0229851399,
0.047350198,
-0.0008927353,
0.0350400433,
-0.0548034571,
-0.0158902332,
-0.0087270485,
0.028604662,
-0.0227917507,
0.0282875691,
0.0476976074,
-0.0030459021,
0.0436192304,
0.0344872512,
-0.0413061194,
-0.07135012,
-0.0002663283,
-0.0065638917,
0.0307853855,
0.0154824881,
0.034217298,
0.04403143,
0.0070049171,
-0.0348434374,
-0.0001115386,
-0.016144013,
0.0283293407,
0.0360740758,
0.0244108681,
-0.0505084731,
-0.0185125675,
0.0449382998,
-0.0402987823,
0.0520993732,
0.0129797403,
0.0365133397,
-0.0602558143,
-0.0252030976,
0.0654461905,
-0.0292670876,
0.1047894284,
-0.006167117,
-0.0365112647,
-0.0203595664,
0.0205463115,
-0.0103352899,
-0.0251254328,
-0.0073248693,
0.0005632734,
0.0152808521,
-0.0270094108,
0.0096891448,
-0.0271448903,
-0.0412095413,
0.0208142195,
-0.0239243153,
0.0548893698,
0.0824687928,
-0.0021486063,
-0.0176063869,
-0.0198448598,
-0.0148322321,
0.0490158014,
0.0257143844,
0.0284591503,
0.0131459115,
0.0202976391,
-0.0156255681,
-0.0484326892,
-0.0025777055,
0.0166198388,
-0.0492300056,
-0.0007536464,
0.0351649262,
-0.04222304,
-0.0407966077,
-0.0613853633,
-0.0140486937,
0.0657878518,
0.0198991597,
0.0173428115,
-0.0328286998,
-0.0396874249,
-0.0135075776,
0.0452562124,
-0.0418315977,
-0.0230401549,
-0.0427025221,
0.0299372897,
-0.095462203,
-0.0780599788,
-0.0213808082,
-0.0498520955,
0.0382066816,
-0.0109840631,
-0.0966288447,
0.0019276508,
0.0498123541,
-0.0347656868,
0.0001028124,
0.0343768783,
-0.0000261158,
0.0299862344,
-0.0036026046,
-0.010444019,
0.0065978761,
-0.0132053513,
0.0506181531,
0.0145218056,
-0.0106313927,
0.0231094901,
0.100072138,
0.0278662685,
-0.0772595257,
-0.0540229827,
-0.0211098641,
0.0943029523,
0.0718497261,
-0.0085526388,
-0.0020320176,
0.0517172441,
0.0141341612,
0.0091417395,
-0.0233997628,
-0.0080848495,
0.0102500003,
0.0386794657,
0.0091357036,
-0.0370894931,
0.0272889081,
-0.027066268,
0.0331455208,
0.0063291951,
-0.0600751713,
0.0199006125,
0.0073195524,
-0.0411586724,
-0.0189441647,
-0.0126176979,
-0.0430304445,
0.0048841834,
0.0151499454,
0.0058653126,
0.0026222302,
0.0167559087,
0.002022217,
0.0064935898,
-0.0374655984,
0.0343572237,
0.0469098985,
0.0441215262,
0.0042422782,
0.0217495468,
-0.0054154261,
-0.0081284791,
-0.0535192862,
0.0191871878,
0.0209801942,
0.0340722427,
-0.0164533891,
0.0172560252,
0.0389879309,
0.0772858635,
-0.046575956,
-0.0296884663,
-0.0343579389,
0.0931788683,
0.0310257282,
0.0752410367,
0.0065282257,
-0.0385060981,
0.0167814866,
-0.0372546315,
-0.0181304514,
0.012468149,
-0.0728975534,
-0.086104475,
0.0243549775,
-0.0081422869,
-0.0418999717,
0.0501231551,
-0.0104248263,
0.0364861265,
-0.0622087941,
-0.023917092,
0.0067391801,
-0.0752370954,
-0.0115474733,
-0.0370761193,
-0.0102862455,
-0.03684083,
-0.1013758332,
-0.0976473317,
-0.0222274512,
0.0847460702,
0.0141996592,
-0.0013369626,
0.005350118,
0.0185727682,
0.0116689503,
-0.0366946682,
-0.006592941,
-0.0133154998,
-0.049254436,
0.0133403745,
-0.0430881269,
-6.165866803e-33,
-0.0115156807,
-0.0536483526,
0.0140806083,
0.0110348947,
-0.0146436337,
-0.0130256014,
-0.0317103378,
0.0202289484,
0.0106073366,
0.0198538322,
0.0096869171,
-0.001624644,
-0.0176664721,
-0.0243638009,
0.0310079716,
-0.0358046554,
0.0117569854,
0.0197375994,
-0.0323351957,
0.0289100017,
-0.0049475683,
-0.0202467535,
-0.0215023514,
-0.1038421616,
0.0389172584,
-0.013753931,
-0.0391551331,
-0.0272504482,
-0.029860286,
0.0104741352,
0.0151405595,
0.0152612785,
0.0217724144,
-0.0422381386,
0.0152310114,
0.0297471266,
-0.0571889095,
-0.0101212496,
-0.0517281145,
-0.0406404398,
-0.0664625391,
-0.0436119437,
0.0102655068,
0.0041590622,
-0.0355541781,
-0.0210544802,
-0.0020052593,
-0.0239664614,
-0.0007400645,
-0.0938462019,
-0.0482465476,
0.0122053158,
-0.0188225973,
0.0000936102,
0.0153383175,
0.026553534,
0.010085498,
-0.0484396927,
-0.0131517528,
-0.0115437638,
-0.0165630765,
-0.0895400122,
0.0517768301,
0.0045327567,
0.0286117811,
0.0387471057,
-0.0016523182,
0.0304257423,
-0.0545470268,
-0.046669744,
-0.0078037763,
0.0716584027,
-0.009260009,
0.0487406328,
-0.0353938118,
-0.0016322096,
-0.0554677024,
0.0700215325,
-0.0379804112,
0.0636445805,
-0.0014465,
0.0021976808,
-0.088978976,
-0.0029069679,
0.0409706645,
-0.0495390147,
-0.020421654,
0.0076473891,
0.0093457196,
-0.0122913746,
-0.0424203835,
0.0166127626,
-0.0407294855,
-0.0549718067,
0.0869138241,
0.0181439277,
0.0339364,
0.0129022794,
-0.0055177491,
0.0066512651,
0.0371703058,
-0.0201252177,
0.037505731,
0.0576641373,
0.0613541491,
-0.02029627,
0.0205560215,
0.0605009198,
0.0162572879,
0.002785055,
-0.0216465238,
0.061300084,
0.0260257237,
-0.0377386995,
0.0241503101,
-0.0114646396,
0.0067247599,
-0.0422413275,
0.0225134138,
0.0931756198,
0.0049220505,
0.0418167077,
-0.057890974,
-0.0508652404,
0.0008379188,
0.0143770222,
0.0114443759,
0.0267364439,
0.0389079228,
-0.021067474,
-0.0129894298,
-0.0310285073,
2.928e-7,
-0.0277463645,
-0.0030962185,
0.0328845084,
0.0305861775,
0.0170979872,
0.0519349687,
0.0146453828,
0.0646565333,
-0.0095658684,
0.0226342771,
0.0864086375,
0.0029176483,
0.0296841878,
0.0489855595,
0.0058982675,
-0.0426120125,
-0.0134810777,
0.0133436369,
0.0059048594,
0.0067354725,
0.0894844756,
-0.0421349406,
0.0085560419,
-0.041765593,
0.0597028174,
-0.0351182669,
-0.0209637824,
-0.0257738288,
0.0624123886,
-0.0288012847,
0.017055491,
0.0901849493,
0.020863032,
0.003285459,
-0.0118210269,
-0.0330413133,
-0.0099506574,
0.0664898828,
-0.0064102798,
-0.0172512103,
0.0072688782,
-0.0433616713,
0.0408410579,
-0.0152221248,
0.0457515828,
-0.0199825969,
0.0186808556,
0.0182010066,
-0.007947268,
-0.0135060269,
0.0165631175,
-0.0166433342,
-0.0093715088,
-0.0355709046,
0.0078783054,
-0.0184658729,
0.0166527517,
-0.0279777683,
0.037269149,
-0.0107516209,
-0.008280756,
-0.0786578581,
0.0003738291,
0.033817187,
-0.0101148859,
-0.0065121395,
0.0303416681,
1.967825987e-34,
-0.0183964875,
-0.0210853312,
-0.025503289,
-0.0737118423,
0.0446300246,
0.042536661,
-0.0484327301,
-0.0343984552,
0.038368918,
0.0057833446,
-0.0406549908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11984v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11984v3 | From Interpolation to Extrapolation: Complete Length Generalization for Arithmetic Transformers | 2023-10-18T14:10:47 | 2024-05-10T13:41:34 | Shaoxiong Duan, Yining Shi, Wei Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this paper, we investigate the inherent capabilities of transformer models
in learning arithmetic algorithms, such as addition and parity. Through
experiments and attention analysis, we identify a number of crucial factors for
achieving optimal length generalization. We show that transformer models are
able to generalize to long lengths with the help of targeted attention biasing.
In particular, our solution solves the Parity task, a well-known and
theoretically proven failure mode for Transformers. We then introduce Attention
Bias Calibration (ABC), a calibration stage that enables the model to
automatically learn the proper attention biases, which we show to be connected
to mechanisms in relative position encoding. We demonstrate that using ABC, the
transformer model can achieve unprecedented near-perfect length generalization
on certain arithmetic tasks. In addition, we show that ABC bears remarkable
similarities to RPE and LoRA, which may indicate the potential for applications
to more complex tasks. | [
-0.020093197,
0.0797456354,
0.0059578866,
-0.0100040184,
-0.0130837802,
0.0209651683,
-0.0066054063,
-0.0335393064,
-0.1048971638,
0.0108234193,
0.0009224807,
-0.0350889526,
0.025321424,
-0.0108513581,
0.0393751375,
-0.0515127666,
0.0077214129,
-0.0031388868,
-0.0336662158,
-0.0030013539,
-0.0257178918,
-0.0499564633,
-0.0120951831,
0.0139910923,
-0.0105985953,
-0.0074385055,
-0.0171588641,
-0.069251433,
0.0078714546,
-0.0058367415,
-0.0006701897,
-0.0104112262,
0.0134107806,
0.0387536585,
0.0000019284,
-0.0219651926,
-0.0068614786,
0.007906287,
-0.0222499035,
-0.0275298171,
0.0018765611,
-0.0414337255,
-0.0050415695,
0.0160774253,
-0.0326602906,
0.0049262932,
0.0819856748,
0.0333158374,
0.0495226644,
0.0561933145,
-0.0040249093,
-0.0492223166,
0.0275565311,
-0.0568712838,
0.0397518575,
-0.0213992577,
0.0047751949,
-0.007544775,
-0.0047001909,
-0.0158686787,
-0.0496716052,
-0.0166511834,
0.0588185564,
0.0433777235,
0.0196456704,
-0.0047313492,
-0.004476916,
-0.0169585645,
-0.0240049027,
0.0186994951,
-0.079646714,
-0.0233393647,
-0.0180400927,
-0.0094286604,
0.0278714951,
-0.0408125818,
-0.0810949281,
0.0422464982,
0.0025305382,
-0.013648699,
-0.0254678037,
0.0076427246,
0.006255792,
-0.0396912098,
-0.0191207342,
0.053197965,
0.0239339396,
-0.0190861002,
-0.03519658,
-0.0008946449,
-0.0475807637,
0.0039428198,
-0.0096897958,
0.0890068337,
0.0221343432,
0.0084811877,
-0.0200647917,
-0.0339334905,
-0.0053267707,
-0.0304638799,
0.0720913038,
0.0764971599,
0.0013858697,
0.0032006779,
-0.0486333929,
0.0720246285,
-0.0660887882,
0.0702543408,
-0.0308884867,
0.0454138331,
0.0412017107,
-0.0138675328,
-0.0265244208,
0.0186447762,
0.0119047146,
0.0139072007,
-0.0212621503,
0.0423874371,
0.0225661229,
0.0336310938,
0.0405082889,
-0.0030083086,
-0.0503785536,
-0.0304338671,
-0.0078270985,
0.0505487844,
-0.0458813198,
0.0230932329,
0.0096487012,
0.0120209912,
-0.0568343587,
-0.0003971762,
-0.023766255,
0.0078128884,
0.0317925215,
0.08766599,
-0.0059035509,
-0.0391294248,
-0.0139779644,
0.0167584326,
-0.0035872615,
-0.0343718305,
0.0511050038,
-0.0458770767,
0.0056713019,
0.0288239717,
-0.0145592736,
0.0090451846,
0.0344909206,
0.0237895623,
0.0145523958,
0.0285265036,
0.0701161921,
-0.0348935537,
0.0111291427,
-0.0134364171,
-0.0205209386,
0.0509467423,
0.0613256916,
-0.0067806682,
-0.0347131565,
-0.0104056802,
0.0350836553,
0.0447669439,
0.0035266501,
-0.0145093994,
0.0016925615,
-0.0322510898,
0.014123694,
0.0011936006,
0.0158091038,
0.0249631871,
-0.0469819531,
-0.0507900119,
0.0023045905,
0.0130300159,
0.0255507808,
0.0931738243,
0.0255051292,
-0.0453756116,
-0.005721224,
0.0349461697,
-0.0802200064,
0.094734624,
0.012589586,
0.0307492223,
-0.0197890364,
0.0170000959,
-0.0334895812,
-0.064390026,
-0.020790603,
-0.0222302414,
0.0092163328,
-0.046883624,
0.0388459973,
0.0321974345,
-0.0430801846,
0.1095570177,
0.0018921896,
-0.0514244474,
-0.0296303667,
-0.0518964529,
-0.0030032473,
-0.0337731913,
0.0290590283,
-0.0647820011,
0.0025748238,
-0.0407331288,
-0.0228405222,
-0.0118783582,
0.0038241011,
0.0252204444,
-0.0189938527,
-0.0161448363,
-0.0452640653,
-0.0016892154,
0.045355238,
-0.0155411409,
0.0333828032,
-0.0667655915,
0.0157552026,
-0.0415071361,
0.0101816654,
0.0070966906,
-0.0368034616,
-0.0430046692,
-0.0046428652,
0.0187743418,
-0.015946243,
-0.0142075745,
0.0171210095,
0.041820351,
0.041581206,
-0.0174998678,
-0.0061452151,
0.0134940986,
-0.0613392442,
0.0267996304,
0.0611327775,
-0.0779476464,
0.0057282345,
0.0685098767,
0.0024272073,
-0.0402839817,
0.0646922961,
-0.1104034856,
0.0339722112,
0.02175566,
0.0468448922,
-0.0105038695,
-0.0018307659,
-0.0079737483,
0.0569787472,
-0.0466932505,
0.0427667201,
-0.0378531143,
-0.0254601296,
0.0010343449,
0.0037400906,
-0.0250381045,
-0.0435860567,
-0.0291415993,
0.014694999,
0.0298509486,
-0.0466470607,
-0.0190735962,
-0.0547490753,
0.0171907134,
-0.0281341039,
-0.0421412215,
0.0652524009,
0.0040219892,
0.0026801629,
0.0292045735,
-0.0143430224,
-0.0468742698,
0.0259468965,
-0.0143628847,
-0.02537008,
0.0265272986,
-0.0147151528,
-0.0517853051,
-0.0232186876,
-0.0549380146,
-0.017572945,
0.0574118271,
0.0278736856,
0.0541476943,
-0.0499007069,
0.0155823771,
0.0296702478,
0.0324164405,
-0.0324917883,
-0.0278756823,
-0.0004710371,
-0.0431573875,
-0.0015641337,
0.0742241517,
0.0135806855,
-0.0116453264,
0.0254992712,
0.0543480888,
0.0108338566,
0.0108380811,
-0.0754896477,
-0.0445091352,
0.0058799819,
-0.0029111844,
-0.0330963619,
0.1108123735,
-0.0547568873,
-0.0228952914,
-0.0440047421,
-0.017122414,
0.0391908921,
0.014044133,
0.0631298646,
0.0100657772,
-0.0276045408,
-0.019354539,
-0.0271983575,
-0.0340783708,
0.0358739607,
0.0051086037,
0.0014341631,
-0.0370805673,
0.0255980976,
-0.0369582064,
0.0352401249,
0.0451187715,
0.001298269,
-0.0523497164,
-0.0147857284,
-0.0346230306,
0.0266766679,
0.0221072771,
-0.025818577,
0.0888358429,
0.0061517656,
-0.0047702235,
-0.0226363912,
-0.045950111,
-0.0596619733,
0.0182911791,
0.0002727603,
0.0434515476,
0.0216793325,
-0.0562410951,
-0.0638912618,
0.0196552202,
0.071717754,
0.0477904044,
-0.0288245864,
-0.0088839671,
-0.0231993627,
-0.0147602996,
0.0204587001,
0.0344477482,
0.0605124496,
-0.0563393496,
-0.0042456365,
0.0102932937,
0.065761283,
0.0323427133,
-0.0530606285,
0.0253180433,
-0.0014714738,
-0.0418407023,
0.0182789173,
0.0433633327,
-0.0043789563,
-0.0126532,
-0.0440156981,
0.0212220419,
0.0190770142,
-0.0667270124,
0.02310884,
-0.0500359163,
-0.006876776,
0.0397489369,
0.0009078629,
-0.0404910147,
0.0039408598,
0.0017493843,
-0.0047670002,
-0.0076266392,
-0.0333998129,
0.0248004626,
-0.0975765884,
-0.0414441451,
0.0242646225,
-0.0281189773,
-0.0693105161,
-0.0183595121,
0.0004476076,
-0.031792067,
0.0201624352,
0.0151804108,
-0.0258630794,
-0.0186537299,
0.0348085091,
-0.0082450425,
0.0077167326,
-0.0201689731,
0.0158711858,
-0.0237333998,
0.0567087904,
-0.0376584828,
-0.0313683935,
-0.0840875208,
0.0225309022,
0.0517340899,
0.0048302962,
0.0619072318,
0.0362964161,
0.0313481428,
-0.0201809183,
0.0328353681,
0.0333390273,
-0.0353068076,
0.0216853544,
-0.0431192033,
0.0771876723,
0.0065158559,
0.0322075188,
0.0214125831,
-0.0094732177,
-0.0198449139,
0.0065143299,
0.0234908536,
-0.0029846339,
-0.0468241274,
-0.0412790477,
0.0342692696,
-0.0577377453,
-0.0268985629,
0.0405815765,
0.0539642163,
-0.0483479202,
-0.0087612998,
0.0097265542,
0.002698475,
0.0497018658,
0.0220115911,
-0.1035589576,
0.0294606332,
-0.0249248631,
-0.077676788,
-0.0079818536,
0.0039641052,
0.0349476971,
-0.0405957326,
0.0307553299,
0.0309131313,
-0.056567423,
-0.0053773187,
-0.0170949828,
-0.1307500005,
-0.0207358785,
0.0586393364,
0.1062256321,
0.0262515042,
0.0072034965,
0.006698627,
0.01235421,
0.0085126571,
0.0122412685,
-0.0477324463,
0.0575562567,
0.0497383587,
-0.0118275704,
-0.0057208869,
-0.0178907849,
-0.0231428575,
0.0122375181,
0.0514714345,
0.0301693231,
-0.036058601,
0.0061678784,
0.0664833561,
-0.012309948,
0.020107355,
0.0286187567,
0.0822928995,
0.0305385906,
0.0547641255,
0.0289982837,
0.0393342227,
-0.0496697575,
-0.0150679015,
0.017781727,
0.0120216282,
0.037112955,
-0.0309526324,
0.0206757188,
-0.0148998741,
0.0021014612,
0.0338173807,
-0.0167365633,
0.012729438,
0.000398792,
-0.010823098,
-0.008320637,
-0.0059019979,
0.007155952,
0.0396423899,
0.0361172818,
0.0210774336,
0.007354374,
0.046406664,
-0.0733592883,
-0.0086156595,
-0.0510459356,
-0.0433182381,
-0.0477796569,
-0.0098297773,
0.0454620607,
-0.0045423955,
-0.0224912837,
-0.0154376095,
0.0208800659,
0.0020474312,
-0.0161436871,
-0.0354064256,
0.0077253119,
-0.0070147039,
0.0354891717,
0.034131337,
-0.0736988187,
0.0317708142,
-0.0558044687,
0.0552969314,
-0.040503975,
0.0354252942,
-0.0333967954,
-0.056111034,
0.001298867,
-0.0108030364,
0.0086800233,
-0.021646332,
-0.0456712954,
-0.0559239835,
-0.0081790825,
0.0155785894,
0.0325314663,
-0.0284487754,
0.0529767647,
0.0278430041,
-0.0584765412,
-0.0037450709,
0.0296047777,
-0.0160670448,
0.0304300394,
0.0261786487,
-0.0389133766,
-5.38607581e-33,
-0.0111290626,
0.0030223925,
0.045348525,
0.0241066292,
-0.0150885414,
-0.0140573131,
-0.0162665136,
0.0347146988,
0.0008425321,
-0.0222043656,
0.0012944054,
0.0151788387,
-0.0008380584,
0.0243270677,
0.0384018533,
-0.0330891423,
0.0352916829,
0.0074772025,
-0.0404266864,
-0.0092980992,
-0.0170159712,
0.0006249028,
0.0821000859,
-0.0086097214,
0.0019786954,
0.031926278,
-0.0160270948,
0.004027551,
-0.0426081121,
0.0565818064,
0.0143760014,
0.0024937578,
0.01513243,
-0.0650803819,
-0.0443666466,
0.0013597809,
-0.0516520031,
-0.0150671275,
-0.0189506337,
0.0284502264,
-0.0158206746,
-0.0320832357,
0.0581042022,
-0.0143815186,
-0.0466047563,
-0.0489089154,
0.0278609637,
-0.0430937372,
0.0129293762,
0.0366577357,
-0.0103693055,
-0.0061339317,
-0.0032610283,
-0.0243870504,
0.0056752074,
0.0184468031,
-0.018848205,
-0.0052956007,
-0.0353724994,
0.044483494,
0.0710866079,
0.0237431172,
0.0083526773,
0.0228987299,
0.0023834636,
0.0047287405,
0.066627264,
-0.0225845128,
-0.0223089438,
-0.0456641726,
0.0079057915,
-0.0110889692,
0.075889349,
-0.015978517,
0.0688323826,
0.0307929851,
-0.0458330624,
0.0112814289,
-0.0026618019,
0.0957959667,
0.0094248727,
-0.0048249778,
-0.0092537124,
0.0035266713,
-0.000236726,
0.0285576172,
-0.0458729602,
-0.00593701,
-0.0279369485,
0.0309221111,
0.0208691508,
0.0354161784,
0.0025073693,
-0.0222078655,
0.0577851422,
0.0455124974,
0.0187803246,
0.0527931675,
0.0153963137,
0.006461957,
-0.0147568434,
0.0015218765,
-0.0271888003,
0.0085821319,
-0.0034661437,
0.0067942715,
0.0319293663,
0.0472189933,
-0.0424966812,
-0.0270700064,
-0.0416434146,
-0.0177648496,
0.0476141982,
0.040418718,
0.0383150391,
-0.0081166411,
-0.0098894434,
0.0152415354,
-0.0527741611,
-0.0156945921,
0.0122201806,
0.038472157,
-0.0171327218,
0.0698550418,
-0.0226232167,
-0.0471007861,
-0.0276452154,
0.0217180289,
-0.0042749532,
-0.0910256505,
-0.0332804918,
-0.0150144584,
2.702e-7,
0.0491657555,
-0.0162551217,
0.0620990843,
0.0064660544,
0.011075926,
0.0018604213,
-0.0016657194,
0.0421854332,
-0.0249683764,
-0.0242907368,
0.0067270165,
0.0128694978,
-0.0464193784,
-0.0232273191,
-0.0088952016,
-0.0280996412,
-0.0164599661,
0.066807285,
0.0397383533,
0.0207689907,
0.0041766679,
0.06153455,
0.0048907315,
0.0430129915,
-0.0274364203,
0.0024758074,
0.0273654405,
0.034085121,
0.0148003949,
-0.0063204942,
-0.0070298887,
-0.0154695651,
-0.0216061659,
-0.0114634149,
-0.0032636859,
0.057085298,
0.0156765785,
0.0307242349,
0.013042558,
-0.0185428467,
-0.0036671115,
0.0212959107,
-0.0095598986,
-0.0039395858,
0.0111268684,
-0.0940034837,
-0.0188844074,
-0.014470798,
-0.0209008772,
0.0375855342,
-0.0051657828,
0.0213942733,
0.0384003669,
-0.0280547366,
0.0187308583,
0.0084806802,
0.0305086505,
-0.0692664459,
-0.031590607,
0.0362962633,
-0.0603638291,
-0.0363947414,
-0.0488874987,
-0.0095679192,
0.0254222807,
-0.0204952136,
-0.0571546443,
2.588363026e-34,
0.0382605344,
-0.0229886267,
0.0167480372,
0.0360908657,
0.0045031584,
-0.0536909066,
-0.0051899091,
0.0256005134,
0.0581197031,
-0.0255682562,
-0.0255069416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11976v1 | InfoDiffusion: Information Entropy Aware Diffusion Process for Non-Autoregressive Text Generation | 2023-10-18T14:01:39 | 2023-10-18T14:01:39 | Renzhi Wang, Jing Li, Piji Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Diffusion models have garnered considerable interest in the field of text
generation. Several studies have explored text diffusion models with different
structures and applied them to various tasks, including named entity
recognition and summarization. However, there exists a notable disparity
between the "easy-first" text generation process of current diffusion models
and the "keyword-first" natural text generation process of humans, which has
received limited attention. To bridge this gap, we propose InfoDiffusion, a
non-autoregressive text diffusion model. Our approach introduces a
"keyinfo-first" generation strategy and incorporates a noise schedule based on
the amount of text information. In addition, InfoDiffusion combines
self-conditioning with a newly proposed partially noising model structure.
Experimental results show that InfoDiffusion outperforms the baseline model in
terms of generation quality and diversity, as well as exhibiting higher
sampling efficiency. | [
0.0405302681,
-0.0081925867,
0.0223927721,
-0.0251639485,
-0.0245872699,
-0.0007408576,
-0.0124063566,
0.0121425064,
-0.0034792013,
-0.0220441949,
0.0216599945,
-0.0768859461,
0.0180507619,
-0.0207341276,
0.0416781455,
-0.0526027679,
-0.009665628,
-0.0476805978,
-0.0217038691,
0.0017160361,
-0.0157873351,
-0.0243978444,
0.000118345,
-0.0196888931,
0.0043688095,
0.0038645929,
-0.0369687229,
0.0408768505,
0.0279473905,
-0.0415712632,
-0.0164711662,
0.0723298714,
0.0027153899,
0.0143594649,
0.0000020423,
-0.0248231273,
-0.0047286842,
0.0105751259,
0.0366744809,
-0.0315844007,
0.0558303185,
-0.0004181848,
-0.0291804262,
0.0179598108,
0.0012548848,
0.0323576145,
0.0424332023,
0.0398512781,
0.0602378175,
0.0575658567,
-0.0134276096,
-0.0427739173,
0.0318111889,
-0.0468208194,
0.0615403503,
0.0097349668,
0.0234692674,
-0.0072073531,
-0.0285616852,
-0.0031269146,
0.0042274236,
0.042019669,
-0.0075446372,
-0.0163517222,
0.0951467454,
0.0741265193,
0.0485348031,
-0.0356425606,
-0.0062884106,
0.0698139295,
0.0100117447,
-0.0105105219,
0.0714870691,
-0.0085307565,
-0.0163909402,
-0.0088186674,
-0.0402201787,
0.0292962138,
-0.0212388281,
0.0121723134,
0.0273276251,
0.0290831402,
-0.0012606583,
0.0004404075,
0.006472399,
-0.0178880692,
0.0183697361,
-0.036095947,
-0.0305338092,
-0.0044866675,
0.011735105,
-0.0765565112,
0.0181725416,
0.0662911385,
0.0305457227,
-0.0004169192,
-0.065744184,
-0.0496703908,
0.0204875711,
-0.0667743757,
-0.0255651735,
-0.0111619132,
0.0762889609,
0.0008473835,
-0.0302306879,
-0.0124504808,
-0.0007591113,
-0.0328277312,
-0.0397811793,
0.0238653384,
-0.0338097848,
-0.0155079989,
-0.0010525282,
0.0636480004,
-0.0133633725,
-0.0250691026,
-0.0519798398,
0.0180597175,
0.0284457244,
-0.0307686124,
0.0301398765,
0.0081372438,
-0.0413927808,
-0.0020120088,
0.0001656989,
-0.0077960901,
-0.0081268689,
-0.0519500412,
0.0541359968,
0.0229522549,
-0.0265357029,
0.0088034002,
0.0313053802,
0.0068575633,
-0.0177825075,
0.0466646291,
-0.0568134785,
-0.0236195736,
-0.0510837622,
-0.0571515411,
0.0055777514,
-0.0417205282,
0.0269039534,
-0.0637807772,
-0.0184735823,
-0.0008124289,
-0.0241993833,
-0.0179537032,
0.0190073438,
0.0343477875,
-0.0511402898,
-0.008984209,
-0.0451702513,
0.0038556897,
0.0797015578,
-0.0134643549,
0.0808151886,
0.0535631329,
0.0486683995,
0.0325820781,
-0.0161350854,
0.0256695747,
-0.0075466395,
-0.0043229358,
0.0441830009,
0.0379499756,
-0.0029109169,
-0.0393668935,
-0.0561266541,
0.0240796357,
0.0553303249,
0.0658147261,
-0.0178933013,
0.0381423421,
0.0890493691,
0.0328173302,
0.02061731,
0.0019363349,
0.0315804519,
0.0528332926,
-0.0317771025,
0.0448581316,
0.0505930521,
0.0316958018,
-0.0174384732,
0.0433509573,
0.0923155472,
0.0296235662,
-0.0373900048,
-0.0335113034,
0.0246884637,
-0.0148395719,
0.0434100665,
-0.0401641391,
0.0502783433,
0.0419086181,
-0.0664740503,
0.0227882788,
0.0178058166,
-0.0499430336,
0.016415203,
-0.0140009047,
0.0343988575,
0.0790989399,
0.05875732,
0.0185078885,
0.0277535096,
-0.0298644975,
0.0215270445,
0.0721137077,
0.0229646564,
0.0292202123,
-0.0344716646,
-0.0563498922,
-0.0134349195,
0.0358951092,
0.012810437,
0.0106673539,
-0.0426580273,
0.0324635282,
0.059276171,
0.0158904679,
-0.039590165,
0.0155583993,
-0.0527749769,
-0.0229930151,
0.0184714589,
-0.0263785012,
-0.0056157191,
0.0270479731,
-0.0500211157,
0.0321770385,
-0.0010633699,
-0.0386276543,
-0.0313255303,
-0.0003681651,
-0.0289858915,
-0.0400651693,
-0.0083649484,
-0.0249629337,
0.0257505961,
-0.0442536846,
0.0279820319,
-0.0796335563,
0.0236411486,
-0.0358608365,
0.0116264652,
-0.0522505306,
0.0131736444,
0.034378536,
0.0173110794,
-0.0270427074,
0.0876163617,
-0.0175188109,
-0.0065618264,
0.0035804014,
0.0207089838,
-0.0109605156,
-0.0319960751,
-0.0000735997,
-0.0278903842,
-0.0115063237,
-0.0018520782,
0.0245323852,
0.003480627,
-0.0104880761,
-0.040408846,
-0.044505436,
0.0194028616,
-0.0190707054,
-0.0142086037,
0.043423906,
0.029535383,
0.000379054,
-0.0022395768,
-0.0486456342,
-0.0171567556,
0.0042662979,
-0.0075815711,
0.0367013477,
-0.0070533091,
0.028292574,
-0.0152211795,
-0.0128571782,
0.0041151848,
0.0194379464,
0.0565121435,
-0.0392841175,
-0.0431159064,
0.0672263652,
-0.0479014777,
-0.0172373969,
0.0138071431,
-0.0100667756,
0.0007810306,
0.0057894886,
0.089993611,
0.0093835201,
0.0895298421,
0.0016240635,
-0.014421056,
-0.0245958548,
0.01322811,
0.0174587518,
-0.0601174571,
0.0923311189,
0.0260729194,
-0.0896282345,
0.0277092773,
0.0720474124,
0.0394211784,
-0.0027098954,
-0.0473673083,
-0.0096808467,
-0.0374286808,
-0.047206644,
-0.0402394757,
-0.004303318,
-0.0204037055,
0.0027577148,
-0.0307106376,
-0.0200235993,
0.0459806956,
-0.0317334495,
0.032497067,
-0.0389369018,
-0.0004359717,
-0.0008810414,
-0.0202390272,
0.0324559473,
0.0363156721,
0.0632414669,
0.0040279762,
-0.0172367301,
0.0123486761,
0.0500638261,
-0.0262779202,
0.036212258,
-0.0058854748,
0.0161924455,
0.0054982072,
0.0048310929,
-0.0256771836,
-0.0653780997,
0.0290760864,
-0.0221182331,
0.0338317454,
-0.0286247861,
0.0336352661,
0.0447026305,
0.0491700657,
0.0319585167,
-0.0238031317,
-0.0309584551,
-0.0233373754,
0.0489246063,
0.0748105645,
0.0016781819,
0.0191769097,
-0.045494467,
0.0081487596,
0.0090309391,
0.0419314206,
-0.0007894428,
0.0313987769,
-0.0264769867,
-0.0282261856,
-0.0258193817,
-0.0269230641,
0.0284452774,
0.0595703833,
0.0044585695,
-0.0140166767,
0.0931067392,
0.00267427,
-0.0238215029,
0.0036956049,
0.0255674645,
0.0955317169,
-0.0214058328,
-0.0007100369,
-0.0401737578,
-0.015960943,
0.0031192938,
0.0323655158,
-0.0341281593,
-0.0415148549,
-0.0336589664,
-0.0430407263,
0.0493119322,
0.0366526991,
-0.0166803002,
-0.0110277282,
-0.0582555123,
-0.0282892771,
0.0114877075,
-0.0509319305,
0.0035229933,
-0.0387915894,
0.0389863811,
0.0389068797,
-0.0357125998,
-0.042855747,
-0.0651292428,
-0.0171427596,
0.0392181017,
0.0779409781,
0.0205336586,
-0.0098712649,
-0.0219202265,
0.0141004538,
-0.0109499423,
0.0091558546,
-0.0282805096,
0.0506293997,
0.0114362231,
0.009216235,
-0.0625241622,
0.0174454562,
-0.0103335176,
0.0122395102,
-0.0153895076,
0.0087659322,
-0.0117280642,
-0.0569778606,
-0.0237441156,
0.0260875579,
0.0434985235,
0.0679502934,
0.041685719,
-0.0426579677,
-0.0569172055,
-0.0247164387,
0.0623370223,
-0.0625772327,
-0.0244463421,
-0.0342675187,
-0.0160684083,
-0.1134433225,
-0.1207571328,
-0.0337682329,
-0.0499945395,
0.0613278076,
0.0097582685,
0.0617976896,
0.0333598182,
-0.0352429524,
-0.0300711952,
-0.0639392957,
0.007277173,
-0.0303597972,
-0.0518181995,
-0.0488538817,
-0.0016978524,
-0.0278821886,
-0.0130419852,
0.0376468264,
-0.0965750143,
-0.0772492364,
0.0003388848,
0.0185827035,
0.0192009658,
0.0206547938,
-0.0141711198,
-0.0341622084,
0.1356533319,
0.0363779217,
0.0480403379,
0.0304599646,
-0.0185328256,
-0.0199113805,
-0.0035080642,
0.0049340818,
-0.0273402333,
0.0395116694,
-0.0233812202,
0.0442808196,
-0.0401940793,
0.0026541371,
-0.0255415849,
0.0083905077,
-0.0325521268,
-0.0470838062,
0.0118953958,
-0.0407793932,
-0.0265561659,
-0.0016560802,
0.0201303735,
-0.0506422669,
0.0044716494,
0.0323583707,
-0.0108903944,
0.0199141316,
0.0398910716,
-0.0017261866,
0.0190687235,
-0.0099235363,
-0.0385041125,
-0.0402134843,
0.0890146494,
0.0147964163,
-0.0216079503,
-0.0064450842,
0.011329012,
-0.026482027,
0.0072290772,
0.0123776952,
0.0168330278,
0.007497339,
0.0049664937,
0.0144850202,
0.023023909,
-0.0723787993,
0.0332902372,
-0.0548372231,
0.0067061051,
0.0389551446,
0.0365964547,
0.0949163064,
-0.0312146787,
0.0367120691,
-0.0038557022,
0.0423586145,
-0.0110509451,
-0.0017905907,
-0.015165275,
-0.001871259,
-0.0048565501,
-0.0238835234,
0.1041836962,
0.0021763456,
0.0004867011,
0.0042013791,
-0.0077760466,
-0.0393979959,
0.0034447461,
-0.0218450893,
-0.0007729124,
0.0118542872,
0.0076224697,
-0.0152465124,
-0.0270819869,
0.0235195868,
-0.025113197,
0.0253678113,
-0.0191095565,
0.0670486912,
0.0119860061,
-0.0292272232,
0.0023132048,
-0.0823332146,
0.0187756605,
-0.0208839346,
-0.0175957959,
0.0018315776,
-6.57913021e-33,
-0.0401807241,
-0.0433204137,
-0.0036146725,
-0.007447721,
-0.0264425501,
-0.0080425721,
-0.0626229271,
0.0028552557,
0.0372195318,
0.0028944574,
-0.0062584956,
0.0044174814,
0.0142273968,
0.0355158001,
-0.0195868853,
0.012061826,
0.0614102222,
-0.039809864,
-0.0222465973,
0.0591712482,
0.041515179,
0.0383477025,
-0.000530756,
-0.0238871425,
0.0239625871,
-0.0381909795,
-0.0096573588,
-0.0424202569,
0.0779557899,
-0.0222607777,
-0.0348485559,
0.0053469785,
0.0182375927,
-0.0324071459,
-0.0467473119,
0.0263852887,
-0.046411708,
-0.03745557,
-0.0286603756,
-0.0616629533,
-0.025565343,
-0.0448712781,
0.0564763546,
-0.007532177,
0.0168498885,
0.0221841857,
0.0609749407,
0.0179959852,
-0.0305663887,
-0.0380422026,
-0.0375899114,
0.0533210747,
-0.0128344651,
-0.0066169761,
-0.0199806001,
0.0067571602,
-0.0011352428,
-0.0198920593,
-0.1008554846,
0.0546138473,
0.08449056,
0.0370891131,
0.0321794227,
0.0378695019,
0.0267744716,
0.0387602039,
0.0072358456,
0.0396404341,
-0.027923964,
0.0265272912,
-0.0095527275,
-0.0022991176,
-0.02507383,
0.0127920769,
0.0308210608,
-0.0304822344,
-0.0514723696,
0.0650888085,
-0.0004842407,
-0.0435594581,
0.0413546227,
-0.0262026116,
-0.0327328518,
-0.0164452884,
-0.003261467,
-0.0115661565,
0.0092535336,
-0.0330736376,
0.0095414305,
0.0360604897,
-0.0342989489,
-0.0368657075,
0.0090419594,
0.0247050114,
-0.0319724791,
-0.0053601945,
-0.0150458934,
0.0309838671,
-0.0053330516,
-0.0301660225,
-0.0813454315,
-0.0110393856,
0.0287576094,
0.0567153357,
-0.03383049,
0.0310861543,
-0.0204193369,
0.0042090137,
-0.0346717052,
-0.0130126355,
0.0053260229,
0.0558277927,
0.0197074804,
-0.0280795973,
-0.0093620112,
-0.0444303639,
-0.0108302152,
0.032962475,
0.0117753074,
-0.0011450563,
0.016579885,
0.0155580435,
-0.0034842831,
0.0440934822,
-0.001804973,
0.0240482278,
-0.029132003,
0.0368185118,
0.0680290982,
-0.0352932401,
-0.0207173228,
0.0247230288,
2.758e-7,
-0.0044435235,
0.0328980573,
0.0180937219,
0.0049867346,
0.0023509746,
0.0322738402,
0.0175349526,
0.036275655,
-0.0211052764,
-0.0067238603,
-0.0026394487,
0.0340061635,
0.013958469,
-0.0125986421,
-0.0981167182,
-0.0459762327,
-0.0428230129,
0.0369128287,
0.0023681843,
-0.0068395371,
-0.0066848667,
0.0119850254,
-0.0378321707,
-0.0113671962,
0.0354289673,
-0.015401043,
0.0762509406,
0.0336893573,
0.0058341324,
0.0454171151,
0.0421160869,
-0.0399287269,
-0.0204222556,
0.0039105364,
-0.0477501675,
-0.0548769422,
0.0088904621,
-0.0126374438,
-0.0160405338,
-0.0324942917,
0.0517321713,
-0.0006645116,
0.0253574308,
-0.0161496308,
0.0358295254,
-0.0115872184,
-0.0304812919,
-0.0091528278,
-0.0355631523,
0.0136112673,
-0.0101827327,
0.0012911308,
-0.0671197176,
-0.0036695658,
0.0077342647,
0.019568624,
0.0120911486,
-0.0110964607,
-0.0269005038,
-0.0224784333,
-0.0371959768,
-0.0343480669,
-0.0690228418,
-0.0289081298,
0.0102872495,
-0.0208055619,
0.0065155327,
2.399532256e-34,
0.047746338,
-0.0144259017,
-0.0412796251,
-0.0081446646,
-0.0131297428,
-0.0045014778,
-0.0355998278,
0.0044605052,
0.0150312921,
-0.0530500002,
-0.0243045464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11965v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11965v1 | Filling in the Gaps: Efficient Event Coreference Resolution using Graph Autoencoder Networks | 2023-10-18T13:44:58 | 2023-10-18T13:44:58 | Loic De Langhe, Orphée De Clercq, Veronique Hoste | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a novel and efficient method for Event Coreference Resolution
(ECR) applied to a lower-resourced language domain. By framing ECR as a graph
reconstruction task, we are able to combine deep semantic embeddings with
structural coreference chain knowledge to create a parameter-efficient family
of Graph Autoencoder models (GAE). Our method significantly outperforms
classical mention-pair methods on a large Dutch event coreference corpus in
terms of overall score, efficiency and training speed. Additionally, we show
that our models are consistently able to classify more difficult coreference
links and are far more robust in low-data settings when compared to
transformer-based mention-pair coreference algorithms. | [
0.0061074346,
0.0018475839,
0.0143947937,
0.0461595096,
-0.021477215,
0.0094500715,
-0.0187655576,
-0.0182028413,
0.080036737,
-0.0344336629,
0.0094147734,
0.0175879896,
-0.0089261448,
0.0430446826,
0.017639311,
-0.0318845063,
0.0365360416,
-0.006768398,
0.0016957708,
-0.0327513404,
0.0097543849,
0.033374913,
0.0097686965,
0.0210285988,
-0.0191139225,
0.028147785,
-0.0098207258,
-0.0008433259,
0.0058760643,
-0.0111717796,
-0.0042897682,
0.0089258207,
0.033788126,
0.0296743792,
0.0000018777,
-0.0267863907,
-0.0060906876,
-0.0170099791,
-0.0299256109,
0.0294531677,
-0.0223782845,
-0.0305710547,
0.037875995,
-0.0056501254,
-0.0040176646,
-0.0581756234,
0.0266906396,
0.0311358459,
0.0249288324,
0.0304399692,
-0.0234857611,
-0.0177911352,
0.0178427976,
-0.0492565967,
-0.0989064723,
-0.0958300158,
0.0104550496,
-0.0100159505,
0.0105192587,
-0.0026241727,
-0.049525965,
0.024476584,
0.0236155372,
0.0054216073,
0.0415248349,
0.0149191814,
-0.0588034056,
0.0096618393,
0.0154723534,
0.0952095166,
0.0264403708,
0.01103287,
0.0397869274,
-0.0011118678,
-0.0291329473,
-0.0030346706,
-0.0378041305,
-0.0248589758,
0.0169280488,
0.0113687515,
-0.0207507033,
0.0000265896,
0.0128203453,
-0.0059141614,
-0.0118365008,
0.0878894031,
0.000095445,
0.0281982459,
0.040601179,
0.0207620617,
-0.0202356968,
-0.0339381918,
0.0495734848,
0.0080204625,
-0.0338207632,
0.001280364,
-0.0229177047,
0.0620351024,
-0.0353779867,
-0.0456465781,
-0.0030784598,
-0.0000922597,
0.003944397,
0.0113395909,
-0.0467938446,
0.0375010259,
-0.0372621194,
0.0597311445,
-0.0166288968,
-0.0522183999,
-0.0285748821,
0.0597851463,
-0.0743623674,
0.0601485744,
-0.0381717384,
-0.0651813745,
-0.0466082729,
-0.0007843894,
-0.0005399086,
0.0064257616,
0.0073841619,
0.0422121696,
-0.0335255824,
-0.0169602893,
0.0051167724,
0.0321902744,
-0.0246969536,
-0.0082013784,
-0.0411231257,
-0.0058704428,
-0.0076420163,
0.0082186693,
0.060981635,
-0.0276108403,
-0.0177431554,
0.0351982899,
-0.0008600806,
-0.0075845332,
-0.0095139826,
-0.0228285305,
-0.0366027392,
-0.0121976743,
-0.0224057622,
-0.0757911578,
0.0414400995,
0.0127481641,
0.012106725,
-0.0813664868,
0.0463363007,
-0.0313119665,
-0.0710222423,
0.0349815488,
0.003601887,
-0.0033030678,
0.0085479096,
-0.0411557443,
0.0333583541,
0.0094860485,
0.0637445226,
0.035202425,
0.0225112773,
0.0360126868,
-0.0486571491,
0.0445021577,
0.0653124005,
0.0042701857,
0.0422779359,
-0.0445727371,
-0.066513367,
-0.0033891909,
0.056734439,
0.0495189652,
-0.0054223635,
-0.0394990295,
0.0034213006,
0.034678638,
-0.0427142419,
-0.0249901265,
0.0013549111,
0.0172893815,
-0.0453749895,
0.0312973075,
-0.0254553687,
0.0151403453,
0.0251041427,
-0.0076494752,
0.0741805136,
-0.0416931212,
-0.0358660184,
0.0144102154,
0.022126995,
-0.0026984224,
0.0421968773,
0.0091684014,
0.0525946431,
0.0020266292,
-0.0492830127,
0.0444978699,
0.0158899724,
0.004378981,
0.0264273435,
0.0184623785,
-0.0804864019,
0.0016683927,
0.0360047184,
0.0319060087,
-0.0356729366,
-0.0092971502,
0.0315690897,
-0.0040271748,
0.0001225771,
-0.0444802381,
0.0507193506,
-0.0379615985,
-0.0381042846,
-0.0187535547,
-0.0062337983,
0.0398882963,
0.0085654641,
-0.009463774,
0.0372928306,
-0.0380745865,
-0.0204343554,
-0.0144776627,
-0.0130606722,
0.0027466896,
0.0075959736,
0.0377177112,
0.0028379022,
0.0327128433,
0.0030500721,
-0.0220490731,
0.0297979861,
-0.0391922928,
-0.0235396214,
0.0183445774,
-0.0327886641,
-0.063704893,
0.0183912087,
-0.048049476,
-0.0406007469,
-0.0039313096,
-0.0284876879,
-0.0575126708,
0.0437424779,
-0.0486351512,
0.0153451543,
0.0190435145,
-0.0111406706,
0.0100215403,
-0.0017485172,
0.0075343908,
0.0301591717,
-0.0081566367,
-0.0138247693,
0.0221443605,
0.0256861914,
0.0396958217,
-0.0753448755,
0.0003951945,
-0.0021568586,
0.0059370468,
-0.0281023085,
0.0646928027,
-0.0390134975,
-0.0568517409,
0.0298643541,
-0.0575168878,
0.0076017464,
-0.017216675,
0.0015399135,
0.010083464,
0.0580089428,
0.0173719749,
-0.0367273912,
-0.0096876519,
0.0044339108,
0.0222003553,
0.0086037265,
0.004545718,
0.0170627125,
-0.0019026872,
-0.0377693027,
-0.0293813217,
-0.0303219575,
0.0670588166,
0.022552494,
-0.0811341554,
0.025326252,
0.0477115102,
-0.0355129875,
0.0154296346,
0.0070674741,
-0.0048734187,
-0.0196328834,
0.0113816541,
0.0262263119,
0.0219904836,
-0.0396404415,
0.0267110243,
0.0009461272,
-0.0688579902,
-0.068111971,
0.0012441354,
-0.0546278544,
-0.0417142063,
-0.0324214995,
0.0116641615,
-0.0092191156,
0.0152921956,
0.0475776121,
0.0298390444,
-0.0481892191,
-0.0452815704,
-0.0014983967,
0.0142965345,
-0.0012813112,
-0.046779234,
-0.020689562,
0.0120037692,
-0.0584570616,
0.0433521569,
0.0568616204,
-0.002548177,
0.0058926763,
0.0143469116,
-0.022945296,
-0.0557290502,
0.0691439286,
0.0385788307,
0.0277353656,
0.027532611,
-0.0865684375,
0.0142266294,
0.0207158886,
0.0372350104,
0.0034213488,
0.0195884015,
-0.0037114511,
0.0568146631,
0.0152207548,
-0.0256187208,
-0.0371780768,
0.0366765,
-0.0450937264,
0.0130791888,
-0.0128089627,
0.0370828398,
-0.0186748076,
0.0115551092,
-0.0067783119,
0.0170412231,
0.0016519477,
0.0217419472,
-0.0429856256,
0.0951296389,
0.0393513441,
-0.0301134363,
-0.0312069058,
-0.0360599086,
-0.0383214131,
0.0309843048,
0.0418661013,
-0.0105959009,
-0.0299569536,
0.0102140261,
0.0076433043,
-0.026596522,
0.0051167584,
-0.0309536085,
0.0579785146,
-0.0345525332,
-0.0164696183,
0.0868737772,
0.0172033422,
-0.0318213291,
0.0053151124,
0.0259804633,
0.0000137828,
0.0217435081,
-0.0307379086,
-0.0439166352,
-0.0228409674,
0.0019218746,
-0.0131016374,
0.0290444382,
-0.0686710328,
-0.0041870759,
-0.072956793,
-0.0099917585,
0.0272437166,
-0.0048358394,
-0.0859628022,
-0.0500188433,
0.0400298499,
-0.0249323547,
-0.0152170062,
-0.0271597989,
0.0139246956,
0.0065885424,
0.0094462298,
-0.060667593,
-0.0144780511,
0.0297731981,
-0.048251614,
0.0191264581,
0.0039250068,
0.0365313515,
0.030545773,
0.0603501163,
0.023261359,
-0.0485532247,
-0.024078453,
-0.0210980121,
0.0333594456,
-0.0147575699,
0.0139872674,
0.0190664697,
0.0586678982,
-0.0039121718,
0.002106,
-0.0158066601,
0.0582057834,
0.0161510576,
0.0118831173,
0.0160107668,
-0.0048603155,
0.0143641243,
-0.0042463089,
0.0420583412,
0.0418688282,
0.0016696781,
-0.0369954482,
0.0553236119,
-0.0831071436,
-0.0408937,
0.0025722974,
-0.0238757394,
0.0317446515,
-0.0232855007,
-0.0357020572,
0.024395017,
-0.0082439641,
-0.0351475254,
-0.0301570129,
0.0573249869,
-0.0150816869,
-0.0653372705,
0.0175315905,
-0.0607458353,
-0.0131553197,
-0.0349194147,
0.0124503765,
0.0625267029,
0.0902006477,
-0.0184798837,
0.0891073495,
-0.0351365916,
-0.0402191542,
-0.0178789217,
-0.0335121676,
-0.0015353374,
0.0583052561,
-0.0191566292,
-0.0017641351,
-0.0115694385,
-0.0003541798,
-0.0204024315,
0.0088248402,
0.009937699,
-0.0094292993,
-0.0320572592,
0.060545668,
-0.0584237054,
0.054768499,
-0.0109485239,
0.0741256177,
-0.0192776099,
-0.1048344523,
-0.0055170557,
0.0309419855,
0.0420938171,
0.0053332141,
0.0078462446,
-0.053029146,
-0.0022573406,
0.0026962762,
0.0087084938,
0.0036218083,
0.0110502811,
-0.0150087215,
0.0104808481,
-0.0124078076,
0.0110249044,
-0.0143954111,
0.040727362,
-0.025733728,
-0.0172173157,
0.0303648543,
-0.0470965877,
-0.0071859225,
0.0227010585,
-0.0189444125,
0.0499529876,
0.0778773054,
0.0117910653,
-0.0519567803,
-0.017522037,
-0.0027911719,
0.0064537134,
-0.036881499,
-0.0538836345,
-0.0482756682,
0.0311327819,
-0.0677580163,
-0.0216766987,
0.0618802384,
0.0104781231,
0.066381067,
-0.0027806736,
-0.01863412,
-0.0281478297,
0.0386608951,
-0.0481918901,
-0.0360330828,
-0.014835964,
0.0039307741,
-0.000340385,
0.0953248814,
0.0412728377,
0.0388052873,
0.0303143002,
0.0298626814,
-0.0255895089,
-0.0507403985,
-0.0295479801,
-0.0188927036,
0.0042101885,
0.0036427476,
0.0322013423,
-0.027259184,
-0.0278206579,
0.067508921,
-0.0369125307,
-0.0124395397,
0.0005217075,
0.0411554016,
-0.0032671916,
0.0451910011,
0.0251966324,
-0.0160656366,
0.0606604032,
0.01979395,
-0.0646239892,
-0.0254532881,
-6.119620284e-33,
-0.0340706334,
-0.0690418035,
-0.0122573096,
0.0214506108,
-0.0198657848,
0.0325622633,
-0.0728619471,
-0.0063910573,
-0.0205981601,
0.001870065,
0.0085348599,
0.0082903616,
0.0056901118,
0.0212338362,
-0.008576748,
-0.0326344222,
0.0714557245,
0.0082066599,
-0.016945729,
0.0563524999,
0.054646749,
0.05239724,
0.0559971631,
-0.1028402597,
0.0195707139,
0.0333083197,
0.028421374,
-0.0131963519,
0.1141889393,
0.0293429717,
-0.0024634735,
0.0657596663,
-0.0123826982,
-0.023967199,
-0.0006986119,
-0.0174171627,
-0.1280539036,
-0.0390825458,
-0.0160995293,
0.0307052322,
0.0287688766,
-0.0333048515,
0.0424988456,
-0.0075581195,
0.0141719747,
-0.043061126,
0.036033392,
0.0188655872,
-0.02660859,
-0.0559919067,
-0.0502124876,
0.0491293482,
-0.0360238217,
-0.0208186992,
0.0550906286,
0.0025911536,
0.0186809786,
-0.0027528042,
-0.0438700654,
0.0491795503,
-0.057724148,
0.0091766454,
-0.0115467757,
-0.0370525718,
-0.0140157994,
0.0272866059,
-0.0307647847,
-0.0049464074,
-0.0208756682,
0.0481779128,
0.0334771648,
0.0354402103,
-0.0299030803,
0.0989172161,
-0.0351905562,
-0.0012293735,
-0.0909184441,
0.0245801266,
0.037492089,
0.0086728958,
-0.0297443904,
0.044638101,
-0.0183078647,
-0.0562913232,
-0.024734538,
-0.0229304526,
-0.0083055925,
-0.0395944491,
-0.0197084285,
-0.0216060933,
-0.0177455489,
0.0652943924,
0.0272818133,
-0.0624975897,
-0.0551842563,
0.061540544,
0.0357736647,
0.0432273075,
0.013179061,
0.061776571,
-0.0414998606,
-0.008666642,
0.0160778239,
0.0107276067,
0.0306868646,
-0.0186353531,
0.027535446,
0.0043454976,
-0.0237785019,
-0.0174235944,
-0.0149737028,
-0.0237520002,
-0.0624642558,
-0.0339224003,
0.0100751147,
0.037566632,
0.0068417932,
0.0650292709,
-0.0026218172,
0.0417754427,
-0.0058442154,
-0.0194954146,
0.0548954681,
0.0731559396,
-0.0385780223,
-0.0015079663,
-0.0367121734,
0.0373192616,
0.0132048475,
-0.0289274696,
-0.0297874995,
-0.0263054557,
2.572e-7,
0.0311875101,
0.0302028749,
0.080580011,
-0.0162621941,
-0.0165859405,
0.0038426635,
0.0072815702,
0.0568937212,
0.0067619886,
-0.0406126007,
0.0253607985,
0.0540570021,
-0.0072502056,
0.0367544144,
-0.0369448885,
0.0202247538,
-0.0758200064,
-0.0154352719,
-0.0239749718,
0.0098183993,
-0.0097014941,
0.0600547753,
0.0530404635,
0.0142547973,
-0.0231082812,
0.0058165276,
0.036474362,
0.0305257551,
-0.0594701059,
0.0200111233,
-0.0657898188,
0.0451154113,
-0.0337426364,
0.0231215432,
0.0087446515,
0.0475400835,
0.0546826199,
0.019224802,
-0.0008188277,
-0.0247124098,
-0.0349225104,
-0.0341598317,
0.0087527176,
0.0176124983,
0.0451194532,
-0.0872480273,
-0.0227547418,
-0.0009267989,
-0.0421599001,
0.0502973385,
-0.0192832239,
0.038516134,
-0.0255321097,
0.0274446458,
0.0134736467,
0.0239346325,
-0.0160934981,
-0.0591067187,
0.0344505012,
0.0209455676,
0.0054584793,
-0.0219123829,
0.0321081951,
-0.0461920872,
-0.0201180559,
0.0021466073,
0.0199319143,
1.854587998e-34,
0.0165089164,
0.0461745448,
-0.026789818,
-0.0073068086,
0.0147655644,
-0.0684179291,
-0.0270714127,
-0.0029024973,
0.0166019034,
0.0009026134,
-0.0243874472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11964v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11964v1 | AMR Parsing with Causal Hierarchical Attention and Pointers | 2023-10-18T13:44:26 | 2023-10-18T13:44:26 | Chao Lou, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translation-based AMR parsers have recently gained popularity due to their
simplicity and effectiveness. They predict linearized graphs as free texts,
avoiding explicit structure modeling. However, this simplicity neglects
structural locality in AMR graphs and introduces unnecessary tokens to
represent coreferences. In this paper, we introduce new target forms of AMR
parsing and a novel model, CHAP, which is equipped with causal hierarchical
attention and the pointer mechanism, enabling the integration of structures
into the Transformer decoder. We empirically explore various alternative
modeling options. Experiments show that our model outperforms baseline models
on four out of five benchmarks in the setting of no additional data. | [
0.0123863071,
0.0335006416,
0.0022505918,
0.0136591615,
-0.0026151,
0.0201029014,
-0.026445318,
-0.0374513902,
-0.0177528746,
-0.0187442638,
-0.0241741035,
0.0174166188,
-0.0176115651,
-0.0113282902,
0.0042276117,
-0.0093276538,
0.0312770009,
-0.024052849,
0.0422609299,
0.0215542987,
0.0073650433,
0.0211217217,
0.0255761761,
0.0294043813,
-0.0320704617,
-0.0170477051,
-0.0165585931,
0.0122155128,
0.0262388457,
-0.0293739233,
-0.0085910475,
-0.0003960131,
-0.013059143,
0.0354197249,
0.0000018939,
-0.0046154908,
-0.0720384344,
0.0466266982,
-0.0124837374,
-0.0512994342,
0.049216602,
-0.0400696993,
0.0030723277,
0.0246857796,
-0.0130191548,
-0.047472924,
0.0519957952,
0.0408048294,
0.0478980578,
0.0902668238,
-0.0389862135,
-0.0825774744,
0.0201019086,
-0.0146333994,
-0.0289857425,
-0.041846443,
-0.0174866524,
0.0208578464,
-0.0262574311,
0.0173709001,
-0.0321216099,
0.0284182485,
0.0042843269,
0.0122902039,
0.060502667,
-0.0045071868,
-0.021784747,
-0.0222384837,
-0.0054211658,
0.0672157258,
-0.0005630382,
-0.0534524582,
0.028678922,
0.011418337,
-0.0287735667,
-0.00604764,
-0.0563619137,
0.050435055,
-0.0642276257,
0.0265497901,
0.0785613209,
0.0153361503,
0.0133520607,
-0.0146305347,
-0.0409345627,
0.0826521069,
0.0025879827,
-0.0456321239,
0.0312518626,
0.0499721952,
-0.0190404877,
-0.0217693914,
0.0849511772,
-0.0120356549,
0.0089328447,
0.0065729166,
-0.035388615,
-0.0294724237,
-0.0279116239,
-0.0289447028,
0.0410680212,
0.0598863848,
-0.0310447346,
0.0195697136,
-0.0094489167,
0.0479592495,
-0.0443354473,
0.019108817,
-0.0472892411,
-0.0150802182,
-0.0510929488,
0.0352663584,
-0.0573968589,
0.0308206659,
-0.0443415567,
-0.038363453,
-0.0174647234,
0.0385342911,
0.036979109,
-0.0068965373,
0.0773804784,
-0.0033854498,
-0.0394814499,
0.0320339762,
0.0447886512,
0.0935502574,
-0.0007324273,
-0.0211173166,
-0.008910086,
-0.0225221924,
-0.0401698388,
0.0520240813,
0.0400315523,
-0.046178367,
-0.0274547916,
0.0641581491,
-0.0187417734,
-0.0056720651,
0.0031887668,
-0.0236375015,
-0.006813799,
-0.0030510875,
0.0426067598,
-0.0476452634,
0.0508828126,
0.0421351977,
0.0362969711,
-0.0176466051,
0.012299791,
0.0294217952,
-0.0442421809,
0.0135060241,
-0.0016696462,
-0.0157812405,
-0.0279790778,
-0.0340226591,
-0.0078425324,
0.0331350118,
0.0221719891,
0.0219737496,
0.0029501016,
0.0086865351,
-0.0322620571,
0.0224547498,
-0.0167986397,
0.000153766,
0.010726355,
0.017758498,
-0.0726685151,
-0.0142234471,
0.0562038571,
0.0400116146,
-0.009936179,
-0.0048864903,
0.0034206442,
0.0130345915,
-0.0182907078,
0.0384680927,
0.0388776474,
0.020637529,
-0.02884016,
0.0059662182,
-0.0440390483,
0.0232921578,
-0.0227180198,
0.0418021046,
0.0059761279,
0.0006090598,
0.0252285413,
-0.0030832125,
-0.0352527462,
0.0103948181,
-0.0061833179,
-0.0125435321,
0.0374703668,
0.0371059738,
-0.0628070086,
0.0809392035,
-0.0109285759,
-0.0476611219,
0.0021549694,
0.0046119117,
-0.0435937233,
0.0189808737,
0.0439729169,
-0.0042950679,
-0.0298259836,
-0.0365779102,
0.0176589508,
0.0350725055,
-0.0114800893,
0.0179961715,
-0.0015289647,
-0.0611327738,
-0.014844602,
0.0064163692,
0.0198464002,
0.0187865924,
-0.011814761,
-0.0379179157,
0.0070243208,
-0.0540162176,
-0.0211175233,
-0.0081966706,
0.0320247188,
0.0110419458,
-0.0244265143,
0.0144353826,
0.0313111432,
0.0344263241,
0.0067027351,
0.0258722398,
0.0431838334,
-0.0354108289,
0.0201844927,
0.0504616275,
-0.08050818,
-0.0684977919,
0.0280265063,
-0.0680438727,
-0.0165567081,
-0.0026259713,
-0.0079362495,
-0.0440691002,
-0.0096492851,
-0.0664141402,
0.1003982797,
0.032354828,
0.0585143045,
0.0543979667,
-0.0156948417,
-0.0085341996,
0.0611765273,
-0.0444008522,
-0.0047776201,
0.0232780408,
-0.0065025999,
-0.0018582956,
-0.0412440896,
-0.0025140825,
-0.0010454392,
-0.0054581915,
-0.0319012329,
0.0486370213,
-0.0002062409,
-0.0174858849,
-0.0184908696,
-0.0125939446,
-0.0159308147,
-0.0295044668,
0.0496439189,
0.0390585251,
0.0272561107,
0.0395036414,
0.0072381995,
-0.0081542199,
0.0073567601,
-0.0188547056,
0.007540721,
0.0100726085,
-0.0163214318,
-0.0239447188,
-0.023902392,
-0.0325164981,
-0.0330853425,
0.0362277813,
0.0164574552,
-0.0834167972,
-0.0339323729,
0.0222084913,
0.0360343084,
0.0156511385,
-0.0165503621,
-0.038826108,
-0.0024781243,
-0.0360106304,
0.0176837146,
0.0655318946,
-0.0602914505,
0.0148097416,
-0.0079145404,
-0.0276286341,
-0.0397511981,
0.0101915896,
0.0205111876,
-0.0160832126,
-0.0338866599,
-0.073096633,
0.0279208422,
0.1079874337,
0.004416646,
0.0355209261,
-0.0462329611,
-0.0322661921,
-0.0344952643,
-0.0142674446,
0.027753409,
0.0062275613,
-0.0220658034,
0.0059731607,
-0.0578528084,
-0.0066698696,
0.0823350623,
-0.0397245437,
-0.0623596162,
-0.0211999081,
0.0129786888,
-0.072849974,
0.0191832967,
0.033589758,
-0.0064299977,
0.0182289947,
-0.0984874219,
0.0082576089,
0.0561890788,
0.016180139,
-0.0076504257,
0.0530364849,
-0.0252678785,
0.011198937,
-0.0217860509,
-0.0252022799,
-0.0032290583,
0.0216173232,
-0.0343423821,
0.0378870592,
0.0265811253,
-0.013988086,
-0.0473175272,
0.0347994566,
0.0183972251,
0.0219321977,
-0.0075581972,
0.0094642481,
-0.0464342423,
0.0485105403,
0.0459721051,
-0.0371605717,
-0.0039055338,
-0.0237564407,
0.0133112986,
0.0247563161,
0.0208781045,
-0.0416099802,
-0.0185917895,
0.02155382,
0.0193137173,
-0.0028000977,
-0.019024767,
-0.0341287069,
0.0445054285,
-0.0587090477,
-0.0311505981,
0.0761894956,
0.0277794637,
-0.0534052588,
-0.0033510451,
-0.0081036109,
0.0226691328,
0.020851681,
-0.0111807315,
-0.1212189272,
-0.035070125,
0.0308927204,
0.0201317985,
0.0388280675,
-0.0552124828,
0.0321282931,
-0.0892001316,
-0.0060295048,
0.0259027164,
-0.0329069458,
-0.0170888864,
-0.0037437731,
-0.0203688405,
-0.0559535325,
0.0123130856,
0.0267003682,
-0.0331284553,
0.0022861059,
0.0028012942,
-0.0149956457,
0.0031869004,
-0.0173644964,
-0.0255394801,
0.0000027425,
0.0313624628,
0.0256882217,
-0.0060735084,
-0.0188075639,
-0.0168249812,
-0.0136590963,
0.0176974069,
-0.0482886881,
-0.0373648293,
-0.0169570372,
-0.0033096175,
-0.024185311,
-0.0028506906,
-0.0246969312,
0.0161928479,
-0.0125538213,
0.0777545571,
0.0055454536,
0.0057216934,
0.0107938414,
-0.0379331633,
-0.027474042,
0.0281752348,
0.0189564005,
0.042729605,
-0.070333153,
-0.0714219362,
0.0110117961,
-0.0822374076,
0.0142449429,
0.0381441489,
-0.0281848349,
-0.0462692343,
-0.0289499518,
-0.0486780368,
0.0335355699,
-0.0352898985,
-0.0132417772,
-0.031526465,
0.0332651064,
-0.0235637072,
-0.0449240841,
0.0200009029,
-0.0209784508,
0.0167505275,
-0.0835519582,
-0.0168651715,
0.024752561,
0.0225450993,
-0.009151957,
0.0196297206,
-0.0492890291,
-0.0468906239,
0.0029698352,
0.0597421154,
0.0123407077,
0.0304718614,
-0.047014866,
-0.0399491452,
-0.0423770025,
-0.0224079825,
-0.0810138434,
0.016132744,
0.0481483042,
0.040871691,
0.0011353259,
0.0221249182,
-0.0367249176,
0.0197651424,
-0.0263502896,
0.0755892619,
-0.0279380213,
-0.0476623066,
0.0534274653,
0.0439764373,
0.0475070365,
0.0145982029,
0.0153859137,
0.0110723674,
0.0458960272,
-0.0348909199,
0.0061333175,
-0.0263024233,
0.0447000526,
0.0232609529,
0.0006321908,
-0.0010785052,
0.015352048,
-0.0101257144,
0.0259813126,
-0.0049841614,
0.0781463236,
0.0210645124,
-0.0286095124,
0.0251727756,
0.0237494931,
-0.0491286255,
-0.008554765,
0.0627873391,
0.0304333046,
-0.0353090614,
0.0013457639,
-0.0025101134,
0.0036356992,
-0.0271137059,
0.002046739,
-0.0149769168,
0.0388753824,
0.0188027658,
-0.0279735383,
0.0673110038,
-0.0148003874,
0.1305808276,
0.0148402881,
0.0081258165,
-0.0153511865,
0.0565550253,
0.0090761585,
-0.0425233468,
0.0069112331,
0.0101176696,
0.0164090861,
-0.0185816567,
0.0554688014,
0.0188335869,
-0.0093779685,
-0.0116792414,
-0.0271690339,
-0.0484256111,
-0.0141199147,
-0.039871674,
-0.0162541028,
-0.0105649307,
-0.0206645895,
-0.0374485068,
-0.0365804732,
0.0251221992,
-0.0292362738,
0.033732336,
-0.0303041562,
-0.0089321313,
0.015903119,
-0.0051540057,
-0.0880302787,
-0.0176585354,
0.0098848073,
-0.0060985973,
-0.0207238533,
-0.0564049222,
-6.21240389e-33,
-0.0410762057,
-0.0054300684,
0.0008842828,
-0.0521535277,
-0.0374869481,
0.0065696938,
-0.0668136626,
-0.0353026837,
0.0112316888,
0.0045757592,
-0.0320978872,
-0.0061317985,
0.0290569123,
0.0062746648,
0.0300983451,
0.0190159269,
0.0795883089,
0.0298708584,
0.0034870557,
-0.0011245513,
0.0259533823,
0.0462928116,
0.0649391487,
0.0097799143,
0.0051433775,
-0.0021379131,
-0.0007628131,
0.0027769872,
0.0350322388,
0.0658418238,
0.0297448318,
0.0263662878,
0.0205450915,
0.0007651902,
-0.0287574194,
0.0126509881,
-0.1365204751,
0.0225917399,
0.0332481936,
0.0356079936,
-0.0070309243,
-0.0531737693,
0.0341629386,
-0.0254450478,
0.043831896,
-0.041430939,
0.0197466742,
-0.0102492739,
-0.0247445554,
-0.0085453801,
-0.0226442348,
0.0431095734,
0.0050202408,
0.0466263518,
0.0601392314,
0.0511589013,
0.0068046506,
-0.0087134223,
-0.040333461,
-0.0009575869,
-0.0039112428,
0.0399640203,
0.0314392745,
0.0199339092,
0.0161158126,
0.0009566236,
0.0072359778,
-0.0185640492,
0.0083784238,
0.0321910642,
-0.0261635371,
0.0550967082,
-0.0047453321,
-0.0207569655,
-0.0132229114,
0.0235806908,
-0.0187366419,
-0.0412337407,
0.0292944331,
0.1119896546,
-0.0354022011,
0.0443660356,
-0.048880402,
-0.0158102773,
0.0237894673,
-0.0137743186,
-0.0222573373,
-0.0364251174,
0.0188588053,
0.0016591005,
-0.0133826248,
0.0601992272,
0.0814190581,
-0.0145456744,
0.0265680999,
0.0401624143,
0.0427969135,
0.053714551,
-0.031895522,
0.0297694243,
-0.0569548793,
-0.010785019,
0.0094736964,
-0.0189092271,
0.0279918015,
0.0089700771,
0.0329716392,
0.0012001544,
-0.0507230684,
-0.003487892,
-0.0572037995,
-0.0041713086,
-0.0303663854,
0.0328810997,
0.0398660675,
0.0189111363,
-0.0103857974,
0.0786692053,
0.0018861921,
0.0418873131,
-0.0340514109,
0.0333275758,
0.0228689183,
0.029410962,
-0.0375698842,
0.0048507955,
-0.0150305266,
0.0463030189,
0.0382144339,
-0.0537933484,
-0.0493872315,
0.0190756936,
2.57e-7,
0.0435817428,
0.0545375124,
0.0846609399,
0.0031681468,
-0.011372854,
-0.0319737308,
-0.0014657213,
0.0364555791,
-0.0033018272,
-0.0057550585,
-0.0236583445,
-0.0326267183,
0.0418738946,
0.0244416501,
-0.1340173036,
0.0188742373,
-0.0721542835,
-0.0208941698,
-0.0145513481,
0.0034717293,
0.026038859,
0.0576551929,
-0.0382378958,
0.0494577065,
-0.0370520949,
0.015461673,
0.0173263866,
0.031623479,
-0.0164870657,
-0.0146969045,
-0.0364883356,
-0.0231024902,
-0.0469811521,
-0.0218713898,
0.0003768474,
0.0146086523,
0.0306072012,
0.0717966184,
-0.0211857595,
-0.0092659509,
0.0206976254,
-0.05176346,
-0.021647213,
0.0122491093,
0.0163501669,
-0.0649987161,
0.0039581819,
0.0170775633,
-0.0768533796,
0.0481381118,
-0.0689266026,
0.0310472846,
-0.0106102824,
0.023366455,
0.0338180028,
-0.0177410413,
-0.0225983802,
-0.035707783,
-0.0386201404,
0.0247182846,
0.005246181,
-0.0407301821,
-0.0064866459,
0.0054932493,
-0.0263609942,
-0.0006681053,
-0.0392201915,
2.486871946e-34,
0.0581136495,
0.0018255685,
0.0101711899,
0.0594009869,
0.0590697527,
-0.0531396978,
-0.0264577474,
0.0537244305,
0.0051211729,
-0.0987100601,
-0.0312057734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11960v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11960v2 | Fast Multipole Attention: A Divide-and-Conquer Attention Mechanism for Long Sequences | 2023-10-18T13:40:41 | 2023-10-21T01:56:32 | Yanming Kang, Giang Tran, Hans De Sterck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformer-based models have achieved state-of-the-art performance in many
areas. However, the quadratic complexity of self-attention with respect to the
input length hinders the applicability of Transformer-based models to long
sequences. To address this, we present Fast Multipole Attention, a new
attention mechanism that uses a divide-and-conquer strategy to reduce the time
and memory complexity of attention for sequences of length $n$ from
$\mathcal{O}(n^2)$ to $\mathcal{O}(n \log n)$ or $O(n)$, while retaining a
global receptive field. The hierarchical approach groups queries, keys, and
values into $\mathcal{O}( \log n)$ levels of resolution, where groups at
greater distances are increasingly larger in size and the weights to compute
group quantities are learned. As such, the interaction between tokens far from
each other is considered in lower resolution in an efficient hierarchical
manner. The overall complexity of Fast Multipole Attention is $\mathcal{O}(n)$
or $\mathcal{O}(n \log n)$, depending on whether the queries are down-sampled
or not. This multi-level divide-and-conquer strategy is inspired by fast
summation methods from $n$-body physics and the Fast Multipole Method. We
perform evaluation on autoregressive and bidirectional language modeling tasks
and compare our Fast Multipole Attention model with other efficient attention
variants on medium-size datasets. We find empirically that the Fast Multipole
Transformer performs much better than other efficient transformers in terms of
memory size and accuracy. The Fast Multipole Attention mechanism has the
potential to empower large language models with much greater sequence lengths,
taking the full context into account in an efficient, naturally hierarchical
manner during training and when generating long sequences. | [
0.0190376993,
0.0713242665,
0.0095177321,
0.0286044963,
-0.0361625217,
0.0028932157,
0.0237906519,
-0.024013808,
-0.0171965584,
-0.0162402298,
-0.0414991826,
-0.1077065542,
0.0085956408,
0.015637761,
0.0146240639,
-0.0715001673,
0.031796217,
-0.0430249162,
-0.0131132714,
-0.0157660674,
-0.0342826471,
-0.0356515869,
0.0100855986,
0.0312667564,
0.0071814917,
-0.0223195367,
-0.011375037,
-0.0311945193,
0.019033296,
-0.0406501107,
-0.0109156398,
0.107978493,
0.0232543889,
0.0365453251,
0.0000022439,
-0.0035171362,
-0.0136112543,
-0.0199601334,
0.0100691738,
0.0480667278,
0.0112393936,
-0.015762182,
0.0218732599,
0.0050349962,
0.0005174838,
-0.0029560504,
0.0400924608,
0.0103847804,
0.0445535034,
0.0408888124,
-0.0096569406,
-0.0654028654,
0.0297668558,
-0.0723689124,
0.0123453699,
-0.0643180758,
0.019656783,
-0.0544264391,
0.0227601286,
0.0222159587,
-0.0559277646,
0.0467567518,
0.0236228984,
0.0204975568,
0.0518531874,
0.0522294827,
-0.0089531224,
0.0044650328,
-0.0263101961,
0.0698155314,
-0.0917226002,
-0.0110062947,
-0.006483986,
0.0095159672,
0.0120136738,
-0.0332836844,
-0.0628798828,
0.0139808701,
0.0172984712,
-0.0164877195,
-0.0188757051,
-0.0176295135,
0.0006230337,
0.0024517151,
-0.0691376925,
0.0186499488,
0.0140488716,
-0.015663242,
-0.0255382136,
-0.027394928,
-0.0233101249,
-0.0352739953,
0.0115496498,
0.0582848564,
-0.0001720345,
-0.0002160728,
-0.0323427916,
-0.0385194309,
-0.0091020362,
-0.0288508795,
0.0452442877,
0.0369351171,
-0.0044814302,
0.0504831634,
-0.015313603,
0.0795898065,
-0.0614845753,
0.0139700985,
-0.0333473794,
-0.0049333954,
-0.0091305366,
0.0285364743,
-0.0379689001,
0.0380917154,
-0.0558787733,
-0.0373059586,
-0.036989063,
0.0049527232,
0.0297556967,
-0.0626659766,
-0.0145895807,
0.0226299949,
-0.0077646021,
-0.02142605,
0.0239317212,
0.0881620795,
-0.0200931896,
-0.0032129723,
0.0259288345,
-0.0385243706,
-0.0740219578,
0.0231610406,
0.0184562914,
-0.020790346,
-0.0042796708,
0.0871909484,
-0.0218272954,
-0.07700634,
-0.0326466896,
-0.0110946363,
-0.0440027378,
-0.0447351858,
0.0394937992,
-0.061555665,
0.0374436304,
0.009644161,
0.0008109234,
-0.0201158132,
0.0160564631,
0.026671268,
-0.0350595526,
0.022676304,
0.0761844665,
-0.0065033124,
-0.0042620329,
0.0155120306,
-0.0038727445,
0.0464741215,
0.0169048551,
0.0432865061,
-0.0336813703,
-0.0208094511,
0.0044303625,
0.0043541649,
0.0264636893,
-0.0091644684,
-0.0205366835,
-0.0168952141,
-0.0246328581,
0.0197351146,
0.0499642715,
0.0396785401,
-0.0264777839,
-0.0428860262,
0.0534520447,
0.0538991801,
0.0408026166,
0.0377868339,
0.0128609343,
-0.0026867238,
-0.0287703648,
0.0171006974,
-0.0440753028,
0.1177018508,
-0.0093379607,
-0.0159381758,
0.065834783,
0.018284427,
-0.0501809418,
-0.0100685526,
0.0071460581,
0.0138523104,
-0.0139947115,
0.0119795734,
0.0363518074,
-0.0106491335,
-0.0429084189,
0.060126923,
0.0171691179,
-0.0435560159,
0.0059399963,
-0.0241342653,
0.0042456468,
0.0286421143,
0.0077383313,
-0.0215014331,
-0.0095238984,
-0.034007512,
0.0195572767,
0.0171549618,
-0.0060011614,
0.0279839579,
-0.0123128928,
-0.0230543576,
-0.0151186828,
0.0046094167,
-0.0083850008,
0.0283521786,
0.0189810712,
-0.0071608559,
0.0035072952,
0.0295964349,
0.0123133538,
0.0261067823,
0.0024091469,
-0.0275366288,
-0.0057330066,
-0.0004864672,
0.0485646836,
-0.0008069399,
0.0102900304,
0.0425358899,
0.0449464619,
-0.0273720324,
-0.0148387505,
-0.0525011495,
-0.0323506407,
-0.0134020504,
0.0074986368,
-0.0280756783,
0.0050144936,
0.0339797772,
0.0117377955,
-0.0297068562,
0.0643273145,
-0.0690846667,
0.0048997821,
-0.0191994477,
0.015076464,
0.0194815397,
0.0959259197,
-0.0401044451,
0.0535349026,
-0.0434222408,
0.0423985869,
0.0209651906,
0.0092894426,
-0.0204194859,
-0.0081402147,
-0.0199773367,
0.0229583792,
-0.0029893706,
0.0087810308,
0.0233417042,
-0.0462435074,
-0.0151694762,
-0.0531943962,
-0.0132633066,
-0.0039558727,
-0.0366663374,
0.0350519903,
-0.0021769286,
0.0243645627,
0.0143995024,
-0.0018171276,
-0.001162656,
-0.0196328182,
-0.023812782,
0.0340636037,
0.0099144485,
-0.029007731,
-0.0161505379,
-0.0412331857,
-0.0273231547,
-0.0105701042,
0.0708841383,
-0.0197547022,
-0.0271866899,
-0.0207609236,
-0.0655572861,
-0.0345210359,
-0.0001819826,
0.0014677119,
-0.0556298234,
-0.0036683409,
-0.0612278655,
0.1065952778,
0.088881366,
0.046355091,
0.0212008562,
0.0407805741,
-0.0165900495,
0.010543853,
0.034795627,
-0.044279173,
0.0274328999,
0.0006174455,
0.0062421653,
0.011838723,
0.1381083131,
-0.0234912243,
-0.0056212996,
-0.0555229001,
-0.0187824424,
0.012068809,
-0.0200802647,
-0.0041428525,
0.0324180126,
-0.044475995,
0.0078969551,
-0.0252021942,
0.0154876746,
0.0573240034,
-0.0075171604,
-0.0152274156,
-0.0353274345,
0.0059514977,
-0.0354110077,
0.0720901713,
0.0154800937,
0.0116899321,
-0.039753031,
-0.0350388773,
-0.0072640572,
0.0241072867,
-0.0284086317,
-0.0193149187,
0.096626237,
-0.0261956919,
0.009899931,
-0.0171399359,
0.0112022106,
-0.0252450705,
0.0002726526,
-0.0176679101,
0.0225756168,
0.01591767,
-0.0381568,
-0.0925181061,
0.0564261489,
0.0861266777,
0.0743494034,
-0.017023623,
0.0200833343,
-0.0061673773,
0.0533172376,
0.0142556969,
0.0440945439,
0.0126542291,
-0.0389967412,
0.0214167852,
0.052800335,
0.0389494151,
0.0043519582,
0.0068720314,
-0.0187734105,
0.01909771,
-0.0073962728,
-0.0028511104,
0.0165019706,
0.0107643632,
-0.0965662152,
-0.0156521816,
0.0832315385,
0.0082537299,
-0.0428365059,
0.0197742674,
0.0192044433,
0.0068812422,
0.0135097876,
-0.0133025413,
-0.0151040535,
-0.0429870747,
-0.0242768638,
-0.0260412991,
0.0409033,
-0.0431875028,
0.0007740565,
-0.0646657199,
0.0220755842,
-0.0013685246,
-0.0694022402,
-0.0690665022,
-0.0362092294,
0.0176765937,
0.0176777858,
-0.0167533383,
0.061540857,
-0.0115835499,
-0.0242556389,
0.0274353977,
-0.0060434043,
-0.0054906467,
0.0394958183,
-0.0154580502,
-0.0351535492,
0.0243043415,
0.0405760072,
0.007825613,
-0.068671599,
-0.0074160192,
-0.0106865484,
0.0057939552,
0.0127930632,
0.0104487035,
-0.0105090179,
-0.0109462952,
0.0027472086,
0.028625669,
-0.0497944616,
-0.0006718545,
-0.0243469905,
0.0997728705,
-0.0200541597,
-0.017517563,
-0.03863772,
0.014400309,
-0.0519131385,
0.0475573875,
0.053298071,
-0.0479702987,
-0.0364954285,
-0.0107703321,
0.0089439359,
-0.0432309136,
-0.0478524417,
0.0296327714,
0.0408900306,
-0.0745186582,
-0.0432589389,
-0.0129805719,
-0.0029984822,
0.0547053553,
-0.0094120214,
-0.006210777,
0.0260796212,
0.0021986878,
-0.0255294405,
0.0151585089,
-0.025458416,
-0.0055680615,
-0.0684877411,
-0.0030177964,
0.059292756,
-0.0085089663,
-0.0198655743,
0.031761162,
-0.0987293497,
-0.0531447753,
0.01813793,
0.0115961563,
0.0142237647,
0.0153702423,
0.0209296886,
-0.0266629178,
0.0122233899,
0.030147709,
-0.0375923924,
0.0552799441,
-0.0044192765,
-0.0143184429,
-0.0001516209,
0.0190720614,
-0.0179896355,
0.057007581,
0.0161489695,
0.0416651033,
-0.0396434702,
-0.0309016611,
0.0038561611,
-0.0278270114,
0.0766150504,
0.0474695787,
-0.0055735335,
0.0150471712,
0.0225516539,
0.0126818242,
0.0245478787,
-0.0348399393,
-0.0221118256,
0.0273516253,
-0.0089744106,
-0.0095524956,
0.0049307644,
0.0297006574,
-0.0350232162,
-0.0135359885,
0.0641013905,
-0.039765913,
0.0014538491,
0.0090201739,
-0.002133057,
-0.0014096589,
-0.0379536822,
-0.0022704194,
0.0293183215,
0.0081132269,
0.0205414463,
0.0218608137,
0.0265612509,
-0.0386267826,
0.0019933251,
-0.1248015314,
-0.0231924076,
-0.0016495186,
-0.0069522876,
0.0418246165,
-0.0042996425,
0.0096260132,
-0.01175733,
-0.0071411626,
-0.0250305608,
0.0224431027,
-0.0172359906,
-0.0101685449,
0.0104530863,
0.045017384,
0.00843307,
-0.0205636024,
0.0835579783,
-0.0040924642,
0.0017318926,
0.0376902372,
0.0025268963,
-0.0530410632,
-0.044844944,
0.0102132503,
0.0038958057,
-0.0258764382,
0.0137876151,
-0.0368172936,
-0.0415565223,
0.0161712114,
-0.0445675924,
0.0128488336,
-0.0375108905,
0.0439121313,
0.042976141,
-0.0202575028,
-0.0149514871,
-0.0214759801,
0.0522321388,
-0.0042292415,
-0.0476211123,
0.0093456637,
-6.681060263e-33,
-0.0204454251,
-0.0097958418,
0.0016537046,
0.013884211,
-0.0529301502,
0.0270620063,
-0.0434172116,
0.0162295476,
-0.0278483462,
-0.0168573763,
-0.0218387004,
0.012726455,
-0.005692868,
0.0071913982,
0.0506738909,
-0.0157330446,
0.0520045124,
0.0112088174,
-0.0179274864,
0.0456179641,
0.0349683985,
0.0451729596,
0.0794023052,
0.0281612426,
-0.0464850962,
0.0181414057,
0.0088744871,
-0.0034865416,
-0.0085675819,
0.015185969,
-0.0262672231,
0.0156018995,
0.0054951878,
-0.0823431388,
-0.0332963839,
0.0274785887,
-0.0812713653,
0.0151069732,
-0.039685946,
-0.0201885514,
-0.0310591199,
-0.0322319902,
0.0713623017,
0.0207680762,
0.0212179925,
-0.072274141,
0.0164305512,
-0.0148025425,
-0.0726492926,
-0.0010586022,
-0.030954387,
0.0358688608,
-0.0209604874,
-0.0327916183,
0.0317050554,
0.0278047938,
-0.0108782537,
0.0715903267,
-0.0589461587,
0.015624688,
0.0489128828,
0.081309706,
0.0234782696,
0.0299629662,
0.0206239223,
0.0295397583,
0.0527445115,
-0.0226207618,
-0.0271506924,
-0.0283277705,
0.0497347303,
-0.0060670595,
0.0539042354,
-0.0462019555,
0.0659457296,
0.0058641345,
-0.0594363324,
-0.0265673008,
-0.0065666297,
0.0696119517,
0.0537058078,
0.0137469722,
-0.0088306759,
0.0197586883,
0.0117860213,
0.0268971194,
-0.0536547489,
-0.0205694567,
-0.0002862047,
0.0183170978,
0.0023090439,
0.005896254,
0.0644642338,
0.0077105425,
0.0052714664,
0.0446531586,
0.0262683909,
0.017110737,
0.0258086454,
0.0004474948,
-0.0398304239,
0.0135744419,
0.0133819124,
-0.0086586503,
-0.0140177729,
-0.026061248,
0.0079305386,
0.0386365689,
-0.0658599436,
-0.0670393854,
-0.0586498976,
-0.0047282949,
-0.0070872405,
0.0425835587,
0.0478760749,
-0.0147919543,
0.0026148597,
0.0720612481,
-0.0456886478,
-0.0327311717,
-0.0139661934,
0.0558695383,
-0.0104438243,
0.039054893,
-0.0356506854,
-0.031698525,
-0.0646838695,
-0.0120244715,
0.0329229161,
-0.0701377839,
-0.0335550196,
0.065708138,
3.007e-7,
0.0153162675,
0.0487810485,
0.0244955365,
-0.0141428262,
0.0207338817,
0.0030555192,
0.0035484768,
0.0651678666,
-0.0057926239,
0.0016192553,
0.0153817516,
0.031468749,
0.0201753844,
-0.0019459018,
-0.1119941771,
-0.0182306096,
-0.0739139467,
0.0040693888,
-0.0315562822,
-0.0411605351,
0.018808281,
0.1017635688,
0.0065284371,
0.0125784278,
0.019873891,
0.0135224676,
0.0317147747,
0.0335003808,
0.0134259323,
0.0063941125,
0.0129091525,
-0.0009586011,
-0.0211295746,
0.0015871645,
-0.0165208559,
0.028972514,
0.0213289224,
0.0446080975,
-0.0105676958,
-0.023077989,
0.0131555693,
0.0066251932,
-0.0161345899,
-0.0349775665,
0.0235564969,
-0.095571965,
-0.0052747531,
-0.0124438172,
-0.0084314449,
0.0255954321,
0.0104412213,
0.0188202765,
0.0218843501,
0.0178626776,
0.0044480823,
-0.0303583387,
0.0423064418,
-0.073138155,
-0.0010577557,
0.0255766213,
-0.051557187,
0.0214001406,
-0.0800069571,
-0.0489800088,
0.032248389,
0.0102313096,
-0.0570288375,
2.52052116e-34,
0.0445646346,
-0.0425852053,
-0.0167790111,
0.021121677,
0.005034626,
-0.0322814249,
-0.0489177667,
0.0014697841,
0.0157400295,
-0.0676155016,
-0.0398131646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11958v1 | Emptying the Ocean with a Spoon: Should We Edit Models? | 2023-10-18T13:38:03 | 2023-10-18T13:38:03 | Yuval Pinter, Michael Elhadad | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We call into question the recently popularized method of direct model editing
as a means of correcting factual errors in LLM generations. We contrast model
editing with three similar but distinct approaches that pursue better defined
objectives: (1) retrieval-based architectures, which decouple factual memory
from inference and linguistic capabilities embodied in LLMs; (2) concept
erasure methods, which aim at preventing systemic bias in generated text; and
(3) attribution methods, which aim at grounding generations into identified
textual sources. We argue that direct model editing cannot be trusted as a
systematic remedy for the disadvantages inherent to LLMs, and while it has
proven potential in improving model explainability, it opens risks by
reinforcing the notion that models can be trusted for factuality. We call for
cautious promotion and application of model editing as part of the LLM
deployment process, and for responsibly limiting the use cases of LLMs to those
not relying on editing as a critical component. | [
0.0202518012,
0.0537321083,
-0.0297996122,
0.0309136603,
-0.0323267207,
-0.0049637728,
-0.0255258009,
-0.0344684683,
-0.0281116199,
-0.0663483813,
0.0025951476,
0.0154596679,
0.0093128029,
-0.0098343985,
0.0173476115,
-0.0147457561,
0.0654228479,
0.0148852663,
-0.0277911499,
0.0151203191,
-0.0367261209,
-0.010189767,
0.0128603335,
0.0168492235,
0.0030364329,
-0.0323265754,
-0.0297532566,
0.0308478866,
-0.0163783412,
-0.0065063867,
0.0049309921,
0.0120863933,
0.0394825377,
0.0342797637,
0.0000023236,
-0.0255615506,
-0.0390027352,
0.0247157831,
-0.1090670153,
0.0304947905,
0.0277426206,
0.0753731802,
-0.026940506,
-0.0193766095,
0.0028370467,
0.0607000813,
0.0261606388,
0.012344067,
0.0363798998,
0.0582454465,
0.0221259017,
-0.0282321088,
0.0466060117,
0.0214929916,
0.0351008363,
0.0103621325,
0.010182023,
0.0477074943,
-0.0062978412,
0.0379176363,
0.0038266354,
0.0740355477,
0.0312086903,
-0.0182821155,
0.0662759244,
-0.006621927,
0.0476714149,
-0.0092823552,
-0.0136447819,
0.0004800059,
0.1073261425,
-0.0326634049,
-0.0042008464,
0.0108403638,
0.0184247866,
0.0437324382,
-0.0516630262,
0.0317542627,
-0.01102011,
0.0001866465,
0.0176566057,
-0.1232757345,
0.0545050763,
0.0112939496,
0.0103376163,
0.0704255849,
0.0018016954,
-0.0166756418,
-0.0573563837,
0.0220066179,
0.0401090086,
-0.056454625,
-0.0281432532,
0.0560110435,
0.0007618297,
0.0243625436,
-0.0176482406,
0.0497313179,
-0.0006718821,
-0.033320751,
0.0598512813,
0.0033397812,
-0.0283138249,
0.0058770925,
-0.0154483356,
0.0105423648,
-0.0064388243,
0.0217857808,
-0.0100299437,
0.0483905375,
-0.0617497675,
-0.0366302617,
-0.0043195803,
0.0282481648,
-0.0203488898,
0.0569064021,
0.0057243397,
0.0335040577,
-0.0138920443,
0.0204590876,
-0.0444189236,
0.0259665027,
-0.0321768261,
-0.0064868424,
-0.0625863746,
0.0060122828,
0.0189242065,
0.0444810987,
0.0039407415,
-0.0921639577,
-0.0163116418,
-0.0021546052,
-0.0286268275,
0.0113837952,
-0.0080298949,
0.0573027097,
-0.0069559608,
0.0018992524,
-0.115820609,
-0.0914418772,
0.0008056345,
-0.0389316082,
-0.0077727144,
-0.0739850476,
-0.0273824036,
0.0012228657,
-0.0116659123,
-0.0737955347,
-0.0012670354,
-0.0080060363,
-0.0407610424,
0.0330274105,
-0.057231199,
0.0217914786,
0.0411358029,
0.0322898813,
-0.0265149679,
0.0330369547,
0.0580984317,
-0.015233173,
0.034085501,
0.0248550419,
0.0290344711,
0.0052931719,
-0.0143452371,
0.0297969207,
-0.0463494733,
0.0072579626,
-0.0294002201,
0.001561082,
0.0182984937,
-0.0191308595,
-0.0125295315,
0.062949419,
0.0985146016,
-0.0060893898,
0.0057999473,
0.0565865971,
0.0236386638,
-0.0279432423,
0.0153285554,
0.025184216,
-0.0492271781,
0.0337366872,
-0.0324923545,
0.0013954139,
-0.0483374372,
0.000046789,
-0.0122400178,
-0.0695724487,
-0.0206505023,
0.0390175357,
-0.0448021814,
0.0156320985,
0.00371869,
0.0157289449,
0.0170638468,
0.124037981,
-0.0003751348,
-0.0511476174,
0.0034685903,
-0.0748954192,
0.0361995175,
0.053749986,
0.0580268726,
-0.0264958497,
-0.047466848,
-0.027020907,
0.0068511041,
0.0242596921,
0.053791184,
-0.0152097354,
-0.025037922,
-0.0039076665,
-0.0388326272,
-0.0523376688,
0.0421995111,
0.0107235899,
0.0088341273,
-0.0230298415,
0.0124306986,
-0.0383605026,
-0.038410686,
0.0415570885,
-0.0726453364,
-0.0310968682,
-0.0638263077,
-0.0097534601,
-0.0062965709,
0.024261022,
-0.0307543632,
0.0076002348,
0.0181427486,
0.0381990448,
-0.0455077998,
0.0096817845,
0.0079661971,
0.0430379808,
0.0272953138,
-0.0224193446,
-0.0249629747,
-0.027664775,
-0.038418185,
-0.005684875,
-0.0030704606,
-0.0637876764,
0.0465424061,
-0.0228506979,
0.0469760746,
-0.0429658033,
-0.0756274536,
-0.0241466518,
0.0343153402,
-0.0176019799,
-0.0443485305,
0.0216221679,
-0.0068532098,
-0.0083670747,
-0.0401478708,
0.007519173,
0.0086991042,
0.0088430177,
0.0168893728,
0.0002460879,
-0.0255198758,
-0.0583643615,
-0.0117808273,
-0.0036349341,
0.0070311567,
-0.0005134993,
0.0083995033,
0.0177353434,
-0.0229894836,
-0.0165108554,
0.0337419957,
0.0222092737,
-0.0070649004,
0.0031840547,
0.0210947804,
0.0361404084,
-0.015975818,
-0.0070726713,
-0.0298776235,
0.0419425443,
-0.0076458701,
0.0330941752,
0.0172097143,
-0.0300502721,
-0.0757401958,
0.0531332344,
-0.066444166,
-0.0427157804,
0.0084031262,
0.009162412,
0.0212104972,
0.0256553013,
-0.0043718764,
0.0266614985,
-0.0258136932,
0.0831962153,
0.0478018224,
-0.0406211726,
-0.039832782,
-0.0004979536,
0.0041958927,
-0.0563574694,
-0.0159622487,
-0.0361658111,
-0.0267771184,
0.0253338888,
-0.0010903289,
-0.010035906,
0.0055595031,
0.058978647,
-0.0095286435,
-0.0290470049,
0.0103701875,
-0.0483485796,
-0.028738074,
0.032584317,
-0.0359039418,
-0.0775510371,
0.0243400242,
-0.0113140941,
0.0420150943,
-0.0246768557,
-0.0119355973,
-0.020281082,
0.0403531827,
-0.0341888443,
0.0014290313,
0.0412722342,
0.0243191104,
-0.0792814866,
-0.0212345868,
0.0557449274,
-0.0325849019,
0.0621765815,
-0.0815325007,
0.00086674,
0.0307457894,
0.0100190798,
-0.0299175344,
0.0370015949,
-0.0345200375,
0.0092753097,
-0.0081952987,
0.0031622718,
-0.0552436225,
-0.0569706112,
0.082431756,
-0.0066755693,
0.0014710717,
-0.035709247,
-0.0129643511,
-0.0169227794,
-0.0195557065,
0.0075091259,
0.074445717,
-0.0589299724,
0.0379729792,
0.0662733689,
-0.0194626935,
-0.0543528236,
-0.028214585,
-0.0101484219,
0.0073321047,
-0.0403368808,
-0.0403173119,
0.0120653473,
0.0544555001,
-0.0747319609,
-0.0170415584,
0.0824508891,
0.032663554,
0.0126341684,
0.0035678539,
-0.0503570996,
0.0054071187,
0.0431007855,
0.0091816988,
-0.092175968,
0.0061367853,
0.0420290679,
0.0431502536,
-0.0423368663,
-0.028571669,
-0.0196258109,
-0.0443268828,
0.0731690302,
0.026298482,
0.0186444968,
0.0135579398,
-0.0376262367,
-0.0126516866,
0.0004033968,
0.0135968979,
0.0497186407,
-0.0087422784,
0.0175350774,
0.0319767669,
-0.017668806,
-0.0090457248,
-0.0081526022,
-0.0187184885,
0.0376973413,
0.0358573645,
0.018501129,
-0.0146216517,
-0.0331204608,
0.0430500023,
0.0208677165,
0.0351310298,
-0.0140263122,
0.0269249137,
0.0128737325,
0.0316592455,
-0.0289180223,
-0.021835709,
0.0443709791,
-0.0663255304,
0.0016543509,
0.0586542673,
-0.0535320863,
-0.0022684836,
-0.0227509625,
-0.0261967946,
-0.0255945306,
0.0760911554,
0.0474857762,
0.0291701313,
-0.000216588,
-0.0883327127,
-0.0276581012,
0.0091972845,
-0.0275594816,
0.0216292311,
-0.0504539497,
0.0108017102,
-0.0280392878,
-0.0340912715,
-0.0257170666,
0.0013539663,
0.0500502624,
-0.0121677583,
0.0079430342,
-0.0259350333,
-0.0282338094,
0.0137743037,
-0.0827534199,
-0.0200226568,
-0.0228310954,
-0.0060223462,
0.0112877935,
-0.0612929016,
0.0186055955,
-0.0050157909,
-0.024449259,
-0.0557840392,
0.0255707335,
0.0565364249,
0.039409969,
0.0361096598,
0.039268706,
-0.0411368944,
0.0711032301,
0.0547683872,
-0.0211983547,
0.0550104603,
0.0133742178,
0.0179113261,
-0.0202167127,
0.0202205498,
-0.0566342212,
-0.0179449394,
0.0382785462,
0.0053751608,
-0.0326971225,
-0.0258556996,
0.013220231,
0.0243543629,
0.0252128337,
0.0062492876,
-0.0146639189,
-0.007164028,
0.0365341716,
-0.0106615508,
-0.0060006352,
-0.0087852683,
0.0155225676,
-0.0134943528,
0.0118716927,
0.0056798831,
0.0093040541,
-0.0083574019,
0.0800540671,
-0.0026400781,
0.0434359051,
0.0048939856,
0.0065175327,
0.0079106763,
0.0285894014,
-0.0124699036,
0.0181700736,
-0.0407913886,
0.0350379683,
0.0367693044,
0.0594284758,
0.0014214489,
0.0218091346,
-0.0399549752,
-0.024000261,
-0.0865064114,
-0.0890290067,
-0.0150139295,
0.0087687587,
0.0444453135,
0.0162588712,
0.0293843485,
-0.0288157817,
-0.0261827689,
-0.0188407302,
0.0131590972,
0.0459617823,
-0.0405883491,
-0.0017894366,
-0.004769512,
-0.0284711141,
-0.0308876876,
0.0054020779,
-0.014622028,
0.129769966,
-0.0627550408,
-0.0353813991,
-0.0152586875,
-0.0710195675,
0.0108627165,
-0.0576664656,
0.0260157324,
-0.0722035542,
-0.0894456133,
-0.0554962493,
0.0515812561,
0.0191298705,
0.0048044948,
-0.0557359196,
-0.0058452487,
0.0494799502,
0.0057100551,
-0.0413318947,
-0.0164320227,
0.0275377221,
-0.0130582126,
0.0145908715,
-0.0046098935,
-6.001077189e-33,
-0.0287888888,
-0.028238073,
0.0485167019,
-0.0029591988,
-0.0333289914,
0.0055187549,
-0.0508964844,
0.0130505105,
-0.0064354977,
0.0058174827,
-0.0080795065,
0.007685184,
0.0027345733,
-0.0211597756,
0.0235615391,
-0.0246139374,
0.0714671239,
0.0082825059,
-0.0108556952,
-0.0101404684,
0.0349344127,
0.0137075158,
0.0734744221,
-0.048353374,
0.0904168412,
-0.0034823755,
-0.0002008852,
0.0109056933,
-0.0525902398,
0.0453294367,
0.0207414217,
0.0018362,
0.0009817494,
-0.0426452793,
-0.0207957402,
-0.035731148,
-0.00931824,
-0.0043518441,
0.0326884314,
0.0032958928,
0.0107120574,
-0.0825817659,
0.0461628772,
0.0393514223,
-0.0607994907,
-0.0213409141,
0.0392818116,
-0.0529257581,
0.0057225376,
-0.0165485516,
-0.0571146645,
0.0243194718,
-0.0108024934,
0.0054471004,
-0.0175367743,
-0.0172124505,
0.0124271642,
-0.0016171583,
-0.0653754696,
0.0013728271,
0.0468253307,
0.0103285164,
0.0791987032,
0.0107463375,
-0.0024365559,
0.055419594,
-0.0041647614,
0.0490830317,
-0.0723745823,
-0.021219423,
0.000375569,
0.0354205221,
0.0438571014,
0.0590124987,
-0.0324107185,
0.0261640381,
-0.0452863462,
0.0246652458,
-0.0265213139,
0.0680779815,
-0.0105131678,
0.0321782082,
-0.0135043422,
-0.0051353169,
-0.0586782992,
-0.0361125246,
-0.0092487726,
-0.0113816019,
0.0079890257,
-0.0288532022,
-0.0281226225,
-0.0374174044,
-0.007322697,
-0.0270962976,
-0.0195461921,
-0.0301825274,
-0.0100540584,
0.01178456,
-0.0026231757,
-0.0050937328,
-0.020674862,
0.0213911999,
0.0013720632,
0.0352584645,
0.0454366654,
0.0183370393,
0.0201513804,
0.0476763844,
-0.0329879448,
0.0165783335,
-0.0458111688,
-0.0066656861,
0.0301108044,
-0.034046445,
0.0174809918,
0.0189234558,
0.0148933576,
0.0111513007,
0.0317030996,
0.0122959865,
-0.0282488223,
0.0313009173,
-0.0239368528,
0.0067684283,
0.0106864991,
0.0315456875,
-0.0066155079,
0.0726785213,
0.0315268487,
-0.0490915403,
-0.0181451794,
-0.0037502777,
2.925e-7,
0.0521953329,
0.0390377343,
0.0378432572,
-0.006352792,
0.0289362222,
0.0395936295,
-0.0174372662,
-0.0237676278,
0.0258684363,
-0.03477896,
0.0211907923,
0.0267345589,
0.0451266505,
0.0209065881,
-0.0259557832,
-0.0082454206,
-0.0330977701,
0.0100459009,
-0.0328368023,
0.0084066866,
0.0465798602,
-0.0133163165,
0.0202583466,
-0.0158202592,
-0.0492116101,
0.0048325355,
0.0459451713,
-0.0398240983,
0.0047492525,
0.0250217803,
0.0483712703,
0.0360075049,
0.0220358241,
-0.0212989263,
-0.0275039338,
-0.0381601639,
-0.0644928664,
0.0607532188,
0.0055498038,
-0.0123485979,
-0.0117876548,
-0.0265711229,
0.0306042619,
-0.0397836007,
0.0394557454,
0.0014101528,
0.0054266788,
-0.0066762627,
-0.0644644648,
0.0018425651,
-0.007606741,
-0.0017325834,
0.0087977527,
0.0139356731,
-0.0393421426,
0.0303367749,
-0.0286927167,
-0.0306732934,
-0.0370903946,
0.0040092515,
-0.0231224541,
-0.0842221081,
-0.0102219339,
0.0241699312,
0.0167157669,
-0.0809327513,
0.0168426745,
2.672029066e-34,
-0.0136069609,
-0.0078182006,
0.0312506258,
0.0260351188,
0.0412390269,
0.0227556508,
0.0305345375,
0.0022701747,
0.0030247401,
-0.023021467,
-0.0017699813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11954v2 | MusicAgent: An AI Agent for Music Understanding and Generation with Large Language Models | 2023-10-18T13:31:10 | 2023-10-25T13:34:13 | Dingyao Yu, Kaitao Song, Peiling Lu, Tianyu He, Xu Tan, Wei Ye, Shikun Zhang, Jiang Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS | AI-empowered music processing is a diverse field that encompasses dozens of
tasks, ranging from generation tasks (e.g., timbre synthesis) to comprehension
tasks (e.g., music classification). For developers and amateurs, it is very
difficult to grasp all of these task to satisfy their requirements in music
processing, especially considering the huge differences in the representations
of music data and the model applicability across platforms among various tasks.
Consequently, it is necessary to build a system to organize and integrate these
tasks, and thus help practitioners to automatically analyze their demand and
call suitable tools as solutions to fulfill their requirements. Inspired by the
recent success of large language models (LLMs) in task automation, we develop a
system, named MusicAgent, which integrates numerous music-related tools and an
autonomous workflow to address user requirements. More specifically, we build
1) toolset that collects tools from diverse sources, including Hugging Face,
GitHub, and Web API, etc. 2) an autonomous workflow empowered by LLMs (e.g.,
ChatGPT) to organize these tools and automatically decompose user requests into
multiple sub-tasks and invoke corresponding music tools. The primary goal of
this system is to free users from the intricacies of AI-music tools, enabling
them to concentrate on the creative aspect. By granting users the freedom to
effortlessly combine tools, the system offers a seamless and enriching music
experience. | [
0.0238680691,
0.0113848308,
-0.0494584031,
0.0509134158,
-0.039901793,
-0.0162926018,
0.0365603007,
-0.0230862629,
-0.0052422439,
0.0238038581,
-0.0605051778,
0.0396583937,
-0.023989724,
0.0250833742,
0.0113559142,
-0.0552084334,
0.0057392195,
-0.0710014328,
0.0343203209,
0.013033771,
-0.0255263839,
0.0154432431,
-0.0288232304,
0.0844537169,
-0.0071814177,
-0.0130607802,
-0.0605979562,
-0.0006589291,
-0.0191115681,
0.0208484121,
-0.0629199669,
0.0367146507,
-0.015477607,
0.0850289986,
0.0000018178,
-0.0385088995,
-0.0027094274,
-0.0111435261,
0.0314791724,
-0.0600458495,
0.0384379812,
0.02746097,
-0.0473524667,
0.0094941007,
-0.0481637754,
0.0151675427,
0.0266155135,
-0.0387878083,
0.0788877085,
0.0645448342,
-0.0081436997,
-0.0205803122,
0.0101036578,
-0.0021069632,
0.0235761404,
0.003898554,
-0.0033023162,
0.0016430954,
0.0765306428,
0.0070749731,
0.0179892406,
0.0402051248,
0.0250817388,
-0.0120406691,
0.0598174743,
0.0405625775,
-0.0535206459,
-0.0971293002,
-0.0129715484,
0.0471680462,
0.0096843326,
-0.0298694801,
0.0276089702,
0.0222570524,
0.0106261699,
-0.0030414467,
-0.0765603408,
0.0208217632,
-0.0161510464,
-0.0054541598,
-0.0201945491,
-0.03012456,
0.0216755085,
0.0013630114,
0.0287608709,
0.0182133596,
0.0323533751,
-0.0224711113,
0.0069320775,
-0.0337545313,
-0.0007311789,
-0.0968663841,
0.0288345627,
0.0561656468,
-0.0512710549,
-0.0041332124,
-0.0414163508,
-0.0354349017,
0.0033839217,
0.0008594455,
0.0362898707,
-0.0033283453,
-0.0041078436,
0.0628410801,
0.0113940127,
0.0069001419,
-0.0122639192,
-0.0270596072,
-0.0032628318,
-0.0182768013,
-0.0407641754,
-0.0310827661,
-0.0448519811,
-0.0095994594,
-0.0008684361,
-0.0230470803,
0.0004458803,
0.0150455786,
-0.0472979695,
0.0272228923,
0.0244769976,
-0.0189918075,
-0.0462474525,
-0.0118972817,
0.0270202253,
0.0369159989,
-0.0335589871,
0.0489998646,
0.0370893516,
-0.0045862035,
0.0318675786,
-0.0095634907,
0.0125592733,
0.0109521942,
0.0628007576,
0.0330471173,
0.0514441207,
-0.0042334222,
0.0034983151,
-0.0626610592,
0.0139469495,
-0.0629043132,
-0.0544090047,
-0.0995884016,
0.043248713,
0.0028596721,
-0.0379480235,
-0.0437338017,
-0.0405701101,
0.0163864437,
0.0011122107,
0.0347306319,
-0.018157199,
0.063775152,
0.0361152552,
0.0191580299,
-0.0653645024,
0.0161192138,
0.0525397658,
0.0404157415,
0.0608376302,
-0.0338926986,
0.0342251733,
0.0531308763,
-0.0032063646,
-0.0610529445,
-0.0182213858,
-0.021614654,
-0.0281266086,
0.0490277559,
0.0036708964,
0.0356042869,
0.0171806812,
0.0142571274,
0.043735791,
0.0468460992,
0.0303445235,
0.0483868085,
0.0442316197,
0.0005037551,
0.0244914833,
-0.0215491038,
-0.0075185341,
0.0617858507,
-0.0031684833,
0.0012785449,
0.0177668892,
0.0556781441,
0.0070289597,
0.0055777552,
0.0042669,
-0.0369260386,
-0.0184466019,
0.0087841945,
0.0343917161,
0.007387327,
-0.0136657339,
0.027710123,
-0.0016100948,
-0.0826649219,
-0.0096938321,
-0.0825421736,
0.0515834838,
0.0814993531,
0.0573732741,
-0.0740819648,
0.0459564328,
-0.0007616324,
-0.0048616589,
0.0460978486,
0.0016282161,
-0.0472216979,
-0.0066019474,
0.0098070949,
-0.0254407842,
-0.0214531105,
-0.0191755574,
0.0143571775,
-0.0232024696,
-0.0104618063,
-0.0086732004,
-0.0259563643,
0.0005169336,
-0.0085954517,
-0.0188418962,
-0.0727659985,
0.0056696581,
0.0302363504,
0.0308920667,
0.0370945781,
0.002391082,
0.0259067342,
0.0237017814,
-0.0097229807,
0.0175311174,
0.0170528907,
0.0067688045,
0.0384756513,
0.0489949435,
0.0117798867,
0.024988709,
0.034124013,
0.0156176444,
-0.0450448021,
0.0678253323,
0.0108129755,
0.0410707891,
0.0431429446,
0.0231764894,
-0.0564700626,
-0.0184731297,
0.0368998609,
0.0366743132,
0.0726632997,
-0.0199159719,
-0.0063667293,
-0.0160199739,
-0.0028586786,
-0.0075824959,
-0.0134956967,
0.0595620722,
0.0059454818,
0.011666703,
0.0008697961,
-0.010405303,
-0.049473431,
-0.0369795561,
-0.1011001691,
0.0251197647,
-0.0034508677,
-0.0183149502,
-0.0050265128,
0.024642298,
-0.0058117043,
-0.0254538879,
0.0130503541,
0.0342389643,
0.0043892893,
0.0192687437,
-0.0432355627,
0.0046426877,
-0.063562192,
-0.0245087277,
-0.0211203974,
-0.0095157828,
-0.0277944189,
0.0125503428,
-0.0273488332,
-0.0181819424,
-0.0138156628,
-0.0642395169,
-0.0003820075,
0.0089988364,
-0.0068561356,
0.006768093,
-0.061201483,
0.0537393205,
0.0785868689,
-0.0520975739,
0.034176778,
0.1006321311,
-0.0181748196,
-0.0151814939,
0.0195842944,
0.0407999232,
-0.005173041,
-0.001720841,
-0.0033435586,
-0.0003161935,
0.0480243266,
0.0744592622,
-0.0041212966,
0.0083896387,
0.0516599491,
-0.0337934978,
0.0193849057,
0.0167747419,
-0.0199120343,
-0.0289204717,
0.0528841987,
-0.0027044467,
-0.0442913771,
0.0677496195,
0.014767386,
-0.0266849995,
-0.0256211609,
-0.0846237168,
-0.0623152032,
0.075301595,
-0.0145251388,
0.024836028,
-0.0076872385,
-0.0199674089,
-0.0288134478,
0.0447166264,
0.0432140194,
-0.0685975403,
-0.0172420945,
-0.055297941,
-0.0023068793,
-0.0127485311,
-0.0110829202,
0.0014506362,
0.0219181553,
-0.0344419181,
0.0104408935,
-0.0059958603,
-0.0205184836,
0.0209722687,
0.0046396367,
0.0408173613,
0.0474560447,
-0.0035921431,
-0.0086749829,
-0.0325671099,
0.0008769321,
-0.0052050841,
-0.0193723347,
-0.0227525514,
-0.0118984599,
0.0466738641,
-0.0118472911,
0.0338991731,
-0.0143559584,
-0.0334447399,
-0.0181920212,
0.026550753,
-0.0047182995,
-0.0233885422,
0.0638382211,
0.0023705584,
-0.0374324508,
0.0103318915,
0.1133157387,
0.0667230636,
-0.0422944352,
-0.0027822154,
0.0181651432,
0.0045174998,
0.026528677,
0.0181181356,
-0.0149695752,
-0.006272797,
0.0301678665,
0.0463834479,
0.0314792953,
-0.0100863501,
0.0020211081,
-0.0247622393,
0.0656100139,
0.0089236191,
-0.0301921032,
0.0047799721,
-0.0389182866,
0.0357081853,
0.0003132141,
-0.0009492552,
0.0227601808,
-0.0363830552,
0.0147500187,
-0.0068051871,
-0.0080259182,
-0.0379263833,
-0.0029317134,
-0.0823458433,
0.0481221825,
0.0716811642,
0.0740145743,
-0.0064100237,
-0.0228344407,
-0.0049074856,
0.0669965893,
-0.0071248631,
-0.0005627043,
0.002308578,
0.0896509513,
-0.000771479,
0.009135833,
0.0372263603,
-0.0560632348,
-0.0090936329,
0.0378908478,
0.0606087931,
-0.0273623113,
0.0043633599,
-0.0061139562,
-0.0015847821,
0.0227449629,
0.0482906178,
0.0335163996,
-0.0306794792,
-0.0062587201,
-0.0092424089,
-0.0153634828,
-0.0302042682,
-0.0408499129,
0.0062057925,
-0.0006007701,
-0.0486698598,
-0.0414147638,
0.0051132822,
0.0465651825,
0.0390215702,
0.038271267,
0.0172578469,
0.021829566,
-0.0074591767,
-0.0922221765,
0.0139729381,
0.0088014947,
0.0580000468,
-0.0301062744,
-0.1014613062,
-0.0100605432,
-0.0301025305,
-0.0093645686,
-0.0140917609,
-0.0649126545,
-0.0232097711,
0.0002905331,
0.0308162961,
0.0321399681,
-0.0002201036,
0.0015937866,
-0.0501898043,
-0.0221499708,
0.012267191,
-0.0401748568,
0.0410355479,
0.0197716802,
-0.0187244229,
0.0235908125,
0.0257013328,
-0.0855143666,
0.0349592566,
-0.012340161,
0.0217331387,
0.0440297388,
-0.0243442617,
0.0405717306,
0.0084492182,
-0.0098296124,
0.0056822039,
-0.0012412223,
-0.0434010103,
-0.02453986,
-0.0218346715,
-0.0233877096,
-0.0351457894,
-0.0001362774,
-0.0022989712,
0.0156744737,
0.0116831874,
0.0050847363,
0.0084218523,
-0.0689544454,
-0.0574368648,
0.0515403897,
-0.003284222,
-0.0464082733,
0.0654964,
-0.0043749763,
0.0340077244,
0.0122263962,
0.0116131483,
0.0027430914,
0.0105657531,
0.0099954959,
-0.0014916892,
-0.0308763459,
-0.0397373326,
0.0287175868,
-0.0362525508,
-0.0870169848,
0.0053959019,
0.0110646533,
0.0886292309,
0.0175593141,
0.0232789684,
-0.0186529607,
-0.0240999907,
-0.0055574658,
0.0544082299,
0.0028420759,
-0.0505182147,
-0.0336393118,
0.0156967454,
-0.0011348673,
-0.0543241501,
0.0686242878,
-0.0741303042,
-0.0051430194,
-0.0138677694,
-0.0153308045,
-0.022425063,
-0.005298242,
-0.0278855413,
-0.0356379263,
-0.0253657326,
0.012475024,
-0.0358636491,
-0.0624559969,
-0.0078619812,
0.0177971292,
-0.0096638119,
-0.0288653374,
0.0390054509,
0.0596846715,
-0.0115860701,
0.0211093146,
-0.0212972146,
-0.0208294913,
-0.0768492147,
-0.0289927926,
-0.0052897367,
-5.350366496e-33,
-0.0377311595,
-0.0357113406,
0.0149184177,
0.0292827189,
0.0078772428,
-0.0042476426,
-0.0826414675,
-0.0214065947,
0.0136268456,
-0.0031835288,
-0.0052348566,
0.0276785642,
-0.0016378771,
-0.0301000401,
0.0819722712,
0.0179457534,
0.0874255449,
0.0080945995,
-0.0320837162,
0.0381849445,
0.0299205221,
0.0136846416,
-0.0243143216,
-0.068111904,
-0.0232567564,
-0.0006468424,
-0.0052248687,
0.0181855038,
-0.0142632816,
0.054699529,
-0.0030847171,
0.0402925313,
-0.0125795156,
-0.0048325276,
-0.0011464816,
0.0141850635,
-0.0293403789,
-0.0422809422,
-0.0119542377,
0.0386906937,
0.0075147306,
-0.015853418,
0.0378632545,
0.0032288586,
-0.0277156066,
0.0497975051,
0.0410083234,
-0.0203326382,
0.0103022,
-0.0584841855,
-0.0728097335,
-0.0055705807,
-0.0211839173,
-0.0599267781,
0.0392604209,
0.0160654709,
-0.0247689169,
0.0188489314,
-0.0006754693,
0.0259937383,
0.0019685221,
0.0004444138,
0.0646235794,
0.0318029635,
-0.0117482441,
0.0225281939,
0.0114465132,
-0.0578225851,
-0.026729811,
0.0359845497,
-0.0130992644,
0.0972085446,
0.0009518673,
-0.0222917702,
0.0114336684,
0.0105576366,
0.017672576,
0.0387734994,
0.0638487488,
0.0048672571,
-0.0319064669,
0.0848660097,
-0.0423393026,
0.0123367794,
0.011456673,
-0.0303892083,
-0.0460533388,
-0.0248697046,
0.0036536963,
-0.0154019156,
0.0158047229,
-0.0560779423,
-0.0262429696,
-0.035917528,
-0.0163514074,
0.0062753311,
-0.0444959328,
0.0374397114,
-0.0232010894,
-0.0051134205,
0.0046108067,
-0.0123222908,
0.0428867377,
-0.010414293,
0.059465304,
0.0037768839,
-0.0315639898,
0.0793890804,
-0.02888011,
-0.0107289273,
-0.0299380012,
0.0010450284,
0.0309871659,
0.0184792615,
0.0464846306,
0.0058892346,
-0.0072061056,
0.0063920319,
-0.0022020841,
-0.0067622815,
-0.0465801358,
0.0023631225,
-0.0311763585,
-0.0269990936,
-0.0355467051,
-0.0004215619,
-0.0585074425,
0.0096425731,
0.0349484831,
-0.040530663,
-0.0432870947,
-0.0188917723,
2.797e-7,
-0.0225279853,
0.0191309061,
-0.0318842083,
0.0593253598,
0.0346747413,
0.0208698865,
-0.1070180684,
-0.0001674482,
-0.0120809581,
0.0087131038,
0.0384494849,
-0.0017576409,
0.0962465927,
0.0767784417,
-0.1157517657,
0.006293261,
-0.061025776,
0.0123628443,
-0.1083006263,
-0.0065811393,
0.0433825068,
0.0784584358,
0.0482496619,
-0.0254620034,
0.0187845174,
-0.0305216815,
-0.0082906475,
-0.0063583576,
0.0599161237,
-0.0187610481,
0.0050302679,
-0.0179586951,
-0.0055823759,
-0.0077177165,
-0.0555455014,
0.0268464554,
0.0079162177,
0.0426391214,
-0.014932774,
0.0174521878,
0.0224795304,
-0.0127251102,
0.0177616235,
-0.0234935973,
0.0321268365,
0.0015471639,
-0.0459849052,
-0.0387600958,
-0.0145435883,
-0.0222653486,
-0.0487085097,
-0.0309653673,
-0.0189164113,
-0.0256553181,
-0.0089475606,
-0.0491957515,
0.0331295691,
-0.029173309,
0.0274588615,
0.0211373586,
-0.04900622,
-0.0416363776,
-0.0274307504,
-0.002394611,
0.0096531343,
-0.0453060195,
0.0262518805,
2.363658556e-34,
0.0232501645,
-0.0357999764,
0.0165315717,
0.0058399946,
0.023422474,
0.0114994477,
-0.0246516243,
0.027091166,
-0.0027964585,
-0.0227793641,
-0.0584657826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11938v1 | Grounded and Well-rounded: A Methodological Approach to the Study of Cross-modal and Cross-lingual Grounding | 2023-10-18T13:05:50 | 2023-10-18T13:05:50 | Timothee Mickus, Elaine Zosa, Denis Paperno | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grounding has been argued to be a crucial component towards the development
of more complete and truly semantically competent artificial intelligence
systems. Literature has divided into two camps: While some argue that grounding
allows for qualitatively different generalizations, others believe it can be
compensated by mono-modal data quantity. Limited empirical evidence has emerged
for or against either position, which we argue is due to the methodological
challenges that come with studying grounding and its effects on NLP systems.
In this paper, we establish a methodological framework for studying what the
effects are - if any - of providing models with richer input sources than
text-only. The crux of it lies in the construction of comparable samples of
populations of models trained on different input modalities, so that we can
tease apart the qualitative effects of different input sources from
quantifiable model performances. Experiments using this framework reveal
qualitative differences in model behavior between cross-modally grounded,
cross-lingually grounded, and ungrounded models, which we measure both at a
global dataset level as well as for specific word representations, depending on
how concrete their semantics is. | [
0.0166339669,
0.0503565408,
-0.0232622121,
0.0188756846,
-0.0187989995,
-0.0141230021,
0.0242675152,
-0.015660774,
-0.0597527958,
-0.0911975577,
-0.0573886372,
0.0002695158,
0.0168450624,
-0.0045897504,
0.0201163758,
-0.0108407587,
0.0285980124,
0.0127294548,
-0.0656515956,
-0.0050373222,
0.0082864603,
0.0006407856,
0.018656401,
0.0316951834,
-0.0420051292,
0.0254491437,
-0.0089699067,
-0.0279907733,
-0.0382110476,
-0.0133683654,
-0.0187325086,
0.0441482961,
0.0508249588,
0.0111664589,
0.0000017829,
-0.0467749685,
0.0198499057,
-0.0047994507,
-0.0014716097,
0.0017380686,
0.0095232502,
-0.0545527823,
0.0152537478,
-0.0136957467,
-0.027447423,
-0.0208504423,
0.040477667,
0.1074846536,
0.0320381448,
0.0193082131,
-0.0165843628,
-0.0217954013,
0.0452974215,
0.0024760193,
0.0012455386,
-0.0119867008,
-0.0132683618,
0.0575504974,
0.0063892333,
0.025064189,
-0.0433631241,
0.0146386186,
0.0297265556,
0.0175720155,
0.0020686423,
0.0474856794,
-0.0173164736,
-0.0011968946,
0.016758088,
0.0752465501,
0.0290033985,
-0.0441935584,
-0.0534041449,
0.0039461572,
-0.0018089184,
0.0262323897,
-0.0362681076,
0.0424937569,
-0.0069844485,
0.0296429824,
0.0441960767,
-0.0016268068,
0.0304710492,
0.0379026122,
-0.0221889969,
0.0779046863,
0.000163319,
-0.061954435,
0.055093646,
0.0598648265,
0.0024421469,
-0.043810308,
-0.0095018111,
-0.0048680855,
0.0239066985,
0.0128912786,
0.0023621875,
0.0298772845,
0.0264273025,
-0.0517074242,
0.0226933546,
0.0437807031,
-0.0537000857,
0.0279815495,
-0.0256676264,
-0.023658406,
-0.0256872214,
0.0420411378,
-0.0097129159,
-0.0038573507,
-0.0863337591,
-0.009459354,
-0.024614539,
0.026007792,
-0.0596711412,
-0.0154411867,
-0.0130401282,
0.0065845284,
-0.0103891827,
-0.0177093707,
-0.0111891963,
0.005246066,
-0.0538896881,
0.0328318998,
-0.0434926152,
0.0334359817,
-0.0832772702,
0.0722483993,
-0.0087888287,
-0.0675127134,
0.0295262821,
-0.0103646424,
-0.0020394465,
-0.0282968581,
0.0284365062,
0.0540560484,
0.0303017087,
-0.0293803532,
-0.0530447587,
-0.0441066287,
-0.0208271965,
-0.0596172363,
0.0137451002,
-0.0447011404,
0.0062876819,
0.0436795913,
0.0099399677,
-0.0475062057,
-0.0037711014,
0.0170764066,
-0.0317139551,
0.1240947619,
0.0212558787,
-0.0058736326,
0.0067600366,
0.0015345146,
-0.0111550298,
0.1084073558,
0.0070890333,
-0.0358777866,
0.0581074171,
-0.0287488084,
-0.0087718088,
-0.0262737721,
0.0269451141,
0.0250248704,
-0.0144226532,
-0.0171198789,
-0.0207545292,
-0.0022241117,
0.0042754812,
0.0420876369,
-0.0252750255,
0.0073175528,
0.061631646,
0.0618241504,
-0.0077884295,
0.043741975,
0.0664467588,
-0.0548039414,
-0.0077046938,
0.0757993758,
-0.0656265616,
-0.033974994,
-0.0178479012,
0.0137225566,
-0.0163444933,
0.0003892511,
-0.0439005569,
-0.0411160365,
-0.0300072636,
-0.0097350404,
0.0781291798,
-0.0213751197,
0.0462811813,
0.0245232806,
0.0027665799,
0.0440559164,
0.0626696572,
-0.0623004399,
0.0212840028,
0.0078448821,
-0.0139568094,
-0.0120015182,
-0.0087800948,
-0.0027102577,
-0.004312356,
-0.0247071218,
0.0336589962,
0.0622878559,
0.0233350229,
-0.019349942,
0.0243613496,
-0.0144241927,
-0.0291069541,
-0.0514271818,
0.0121323327,
0.0211177841,
-0.0186400842,
0.0072898506,
-0.0022699188,
-0.0787255019,
-0.0041170092,
0.0568063781,
-0.0220823176,
0.0002766887,
-0.0273821037,
0.0232146289,
0.0114739127,
0.0197514221,
-0.0171186402,
0.007971717,
0.021215938,
-0.0425359756,
-0.0281888153,
0.0493085906,
-0.0294309221,
0.0365131535,
0.0351285189,
-0.0453487895,
0.0117715094,
0.0011186576,
0.0236868374,
-0.0251433346,
0.0166273247,
-0.0323008224,
0.0706432238,
-0.034576606,
-0.015202444,
-0.0346227624,
0.0317672044,
-0.0289532542,
0.0576847494,
0.0064581586,
0.0236606803,
-0.0000258536,
0.0265974347,
0.0622765981,
-0.0112598287,
-0.0217131078,
0.0561203025,
0.0183734056,
-0.0141005283,
0.0495493114,
-0.0110838106,
-0.0306607727,
0.0050789909,
-0.139208734,
-0.0325251482,
-0.0126890615,
-0.0026837569,
0.0337828696,
0.0092286253,
-0.0048402203,
-0.0190218315,
-0.0220014006,
-0.0031372758,
0.0275633559,
0.0695910454,
0.0487285331,
0.0294560604,
0.0100319497,
-0.0235297792,
-0.0130601618,
-0.0276095923,
0.0410238951,
-0.007846172,
-0.0001747251,
-0.0695055947,
0.0551007874,
-0.0520539582,
0.0429942496,
-0.0035853756,
-0.0161892548,
0.0237363484,
0.0455768928,
0.0450999551,
0.0429386646,
-0.0155645637,
0.0610158667,
0.0623594597,
-0.0046876981,
-0.0393167175,
0.0074930894,
0.0080840774,
-0.0019869078,
-0.0354583934,
-0.0005886352,
-0.0135897473,
0.0631503984,
-0.0062625953,
0.0009549509,
-0.0467098653,
0.0340112075,
-0.0664176717,
-0.0526345372,
-0.0304248706,
-0.0125249634,
-0.0087265335,
0.085820213,
-0.0213940274,
-0.0425698534,
0.0730887577,
-0.0346511677,
0.0012324331,
-0.043877162,
-0.0137962466,
-0.0443088226,
0.0457372144,
-0.0515701026,
0.0109527921,
0.0023871199,
-0.0402937755,
-0.054909572,
-0.0238218419,
0.0385926813,
0.0163440295,
0.0992510468,
-0.0199846067,
0.0073416154,
-0.0164251216,
-0.0727582201,
-0.0370560773,
-0.0451876298,
-0.0337630138,
0.0134975007,
-0.0109661892,
0.0290227085,
0.0004138507,
0.034765888,
0.0371713862,
-0.0068212068,
-0.0129289059,
-0.0228306167,
-0.0136230234,
0.0081951851,
-0.0004057004,
0.0049303742,
0.034517426,
-0.0054269619,
0.0302655175,
0.0083596501,
0.0180094223,
0.0020961948,
-0.017649686,
0.043727845,
0.0224779043,
-0.0120391324,
-0.0644854531,
-0.0298464838,
0.0680091754,
-0.023198856,
-0.0217552073,
0.0937008411,
0.0091459434,
-0.0218734089,
0.0339739807,
-0.0082283402,
0.0054276944,
0.0303320047,
0.0104074422,
-0.0212081224,
-0.0194487236,
0.0077915173,
-0.0135581316,
0.0141355861,
-0.0165744461,
0.0073838914,
-0.1284464449,
-0.0105151823,
-0.0314333923,
-0.051100675,
-0.0546268411,
-0.063742891,
0.0110141551,
0.0058792308,
0.0587509461,
-0.0516902357,
-0.021840727,
-0.0121500585,
0.0220383797,
0.0088059995,
-0.0764615908,
-0.0000224672,
-0.0555305406,
0.0259697475,
0.0201155432,
0.0317607746,
-0.0474137068,
-0.0425895229,
0.0398343988,
-0.0264192186,
0.027554078,
-0.0172593426,
0.0187026188,
-0.0026775305,
-0.0116239749,
0.0201269165,
0.0064799613,
-0.0233065374,
-0.0071844351,
-0.0314412192,
0.0705150366,
0.0092500802,
0.0112945596,
-0.0084763616,
0.0151513917,
0.0059825545,
0.0670312271,
0.0320500582,
-0.0521901473,
-0.0203403067,
-0.0166646447,
0.0056469855,
0.0023557465,
-0.0610331893,
0.0330114253,
-0.0307789985,
0.0016777436,
-0.046323128,
-0.1042590141,
0.0095285652,
0.0306073632,
0.0372172743,
0.012603458,
-0.0122982292,
-0.0110912733,
0.0086868936,
0.0642771125,
0.0062928502,
0.0153930187,
-0.0083024772,
-0.0174349789,
0.0278091375,
-0.0337000675,
-0.000593483,
-0.0366020314,
0.0088516288,
-0.0643072352,
0.0012477882,
-0.0220898688,
0.0208833963,
0.0462255292,
0.0049802787,
-0.0308590662,
0.0170788839,
-0.0155077847,
-0.0575394519,
0.0139572173,
0.0490208305,
-0.0060007516,
0.0282253325,
0.0318068117,
-0.0361012369,
0.0195507035,
0.0442909524,
0.0407300405,
0.0033715318,
0.0034046203,
0.0412198938,
-0.004087186,
0.0478945859,
-0.0250055809,
-0.005054879,
-0.033324033,
-0.0353653803,
-0.0336184166,
-0.0259887315,
-0.0117716966,
-0.0134230824,
0.0162175987,
0.0113485958,
-0.0141221518,
0.0352107212,
-0.0552221239,
0.0831941366,
-0.0168933067,
0.0455998555,
0.0439652987,
0.0166878346,
-0.0345400646,
0.0479414165,
-0.0174492728,
-0.0110776434,
-0.0067978567,
0.0295321885,
-0.0498642847,
0.055194173,
0.0186928958,
-0.0077309627,
-0.0173782296,
0.0239113662,
-0.0842944086,
0.0241799597,
0.0141547509,
0.01218234,
0.0337484516,
-0.0563136972,
0.0329587981,
-0.0061771204,
-0.0194543991,
0.0056376802,
0.0170357227,
0.0219718646,
-0.0004514681,
0.0371549353,
0.0290494319,
-0.0378285162,
0.013440514,
0.0654631406,
-0.0168349352,
0.0629829317,
-0.0077548577,
-0.0068363142,
-0.0172404628,
0.0093487585,
0.0381900109,
0.0220146067,
-0.0235301033,
0.0333206318,
-0.0872004107,
-0.0856364816,
-0.0118385116,
-0.0001238009,
0.0144406743,
0.0074088397,
0.0121552106,
0.0854191855,
0.029401049,
0.0338361785,
-0.0279680863,
0.0094363196,
-0.02658589,
0.0106872609,
-0.052092649,
-5.692947794e-33,
-0.023784522,
0.0002126742,
-0.0011201306,
-0.0174697638,
-0.0376855843,
0.0430680029,
-0.0067193289,
0.0445899889,
-0.0512485392,
0.0426359624,
-0.0386850312,
0.0018675098,
0.0109187132,
-0.0259176716,
0.0177639816,
-0.0371867903,
0.0269621816,
0.006835307,
-0.0373332016,
-0.0175079312,
0.0447146297,
0.0103962682,
0.0681578442,
-0.0924377218,
0.0651244,
0.0181365181,
0.0206266064,
-0.0166238509,
0.0248540957,
0.0847134665,
-0.023114698,
0.0730236322,
0.0538895652,
-0.0449322239,
0.0092704734,
0.0267164297,
-0.0620300099,
-0.0232880246,
0.0370332152,
0.036275737,
-0.017797647,
0.0088121509,
0.0172333848,
-0.0411598384,
-0.0121121341,
0.0207867753,
0.039797768,
-0.0264322869,
0.0027045938,
0.0239516906,
-0.0953974649,
-0.0064125173,
0.0051092017,
0.0001817095,
0.0078400206,
0.0336370282,
0.0092533072,
-0.0015126605,
-0.0018630663,
0.0110394452,
-0.047118865,
0.0155654494,
0.052132532,
-0.0192217659,
0.0003521823,
0.0545367263,
0.0052939886,
0.0061555384,
-0.0557600074,
-0.0444175228,
0.0328994133,
0.0224210136,
0.0177137218,
0.0817450061,
0.0282692574,
-0.0137703288,
-0.068200998,
-0.0064901188,
0.0080683017,
0.0486851074,
-0.0069776224,
-0.0030858107,
-0.0557329655,
-0.0326240696,
-0.054507155,
-0.0617184639,
-0.0210774131,
-0.0528836697,
0.0339774713,
-0.0166015066,
-0.0434217118,
0.0221442729,
0.0250704065,
-0.0615757219,
-0.0229496919,
0.0444967821,
0.0132082924,
0.0008484093,
0.0171367116,
-0.0313256644,
-0.0088176355,
-0.0410953723,
-0.0091991713,
0.0144740585,
0.0411343575,
-0.0069438829,
0.0447402485,
0.0039193071,
-0.0258879047,
-0.0201380216,
-0.0441321395,
-0.0315063521,
0.0078594098,
0.0487468168,
0.0555060208,
0.0387255847,
-0.0334206447,
0.0194589421,
0.0483572781,
0.0198295135,
-0.0244528651,
-0.0851421282,
-0.016252812,
0.043320626,
-0.0150860092,
-0.0416824259,
-0.0233209617,
0.0183925852,
0.0638875738,
-0.0427713618,
-0.0356221832,
0.0055405376,
2.547e-7,
0.0470505096,
0.034551505,
0.0304508395,
-0.0126273138,
-0.005099799,
0.0292323269,
-0.0344733521,
0.0171381887,
0.004653269,
-0.081413649,
-0.0593456365,
0.0143580958,
0.0268688779,
0.0483052842,
-0.0540256575,
-0.0179481413,
-0.0190922264,
0.0171295721,
-0.0312254932,
0.0139334444,
0.0209489819,
0.0853758603,
-0.0156896617,
-0.0173946619,
-0.0317098163,
-0.0323375911,
0.0527277999,
-0.0534727946,
-0.0108685428,
-0.0253551714,
-0.0031831567,
0.010887959,
0.0261617731,
0.0473012291,
-0.0033019851,
0.0359357595,
0.0386423916,
-0.0121931089,
-0.0015202613,
-0.0102053285,
-0.039755173,
-0.0229959711,
-0.0204275418,
-0.0361853205,
0.067173034,
-0.0079529798,
-0.0438194685,
-0.0330702998,
0.0005053938,
0.0044523403,
0.0344922543,
-0.0029123912,
-0.0489293188,
0.0004337487,
0.0119421855,
0.0047854576,
-0.0206280518,
-0.0603104979,
-0.0144812418,
0.0027943945,
0.0039538983,
-0.0476704761,
0.01378127,
-0.0330553614,
0.0689130574,
-0.0706346929,
-0.0246627405,
2.324222787e-34,
0.0076556467,
-0.0038134593,
0.0735367239,
-0.0053125019,
0.0289013609,
-0.0152748339,
0.0178428218,
-0.0205030497,
0.0154206855,
-0.0364938118,
-0.016045019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11923v1 | Investigating semantic subspaces of Transformer sentence embeddings through linear structural probing | 2023-10-18T12:32:07 | 2023-10-18T12:32:07 | Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | The question of what kinds of linguistic information are encoded in different
layers of Transformer-based language models is of considerable interest for the
NLP community. Existing work, however, has overwhelmingly focused on word-level
representations and encoder-only language models with the masked-token training
objective. In this paper, we present experiments with semantic structural
probing, a method for studying sentence-level representations via finding a
subspace of the embedding space that provides suitable task-specific pairwise
distances between data-points. We apply our method to language models from
different families (encoder-only, decoder-only, encoder-decoder) and of
different sizes in the context of two tasks, semantic textual similarity and
natural-language inference. We find that model families differ substantially in
their performance and layer dynamics, but that the results are largely
model-size invariant. | [
0.022926636,
0.0651595742,
-0.0284172967,
0.0790825635,
-0.0556938387,
0.0175505225,
0.0133895399,
-0.0256470162,
-0.0338777117,
-0.068481423,
-0.0106265787,
-0.0091903219,
-0.0095491186,
0.0210155398,
0.0448690355,
0.0094793513,
0.01477494,
-0.0005237064,
-0.0226824488,
0.0199282244,
0.0053463811,
-0.0083321845,
0.0111723104,
0.0610657968,
-0.0106501058,
-0.0174035132,
-0.0142838117,
-0.0223897044,
0.0251236968,
-0.0151535403,
0.0159615092,
0.0134229623,
0.0432416275,
0.0366769768,
0.0000015603,
0.0058084074,
-0.0016697655,
-0.0166753829,
-0.0042156298,
0.0037111472,
0.0318874009,
-0.0843664259,
0.0217844471,
0.0161156263,
-0.0057970099,
-0.0473420359,
0.0522274561,
0.0621694289,
0.0171755776,
0.0530400611,
-0.0284676999,
-0.0376696624,
0.0120449122,
-0.0178071093,
-0.0144343106,
-0.0054616369,
0.024865333,
-0.0306531768,
-0.0256927703,
0.0329428017,
-0.048751846,
0.0304973517,
0.0285195224,
-0.0002126049,
0.0139391525,
0.0319441557,
-0.0119368257,
-0.012310518,
-0.0065284646,
0.0130037451,
-0.0058272369,
-0.0403341874,
-0.0134617761,
0.0156743024,
-0.0211974941,
0.0210020449,
-0.0286802854,
0.0187419355,
0.0294575468,
0.0303116757,
0.0312438626,
0.0371784121,
0.0164838135,
-0.0200220309,
-0.0390372947,
0.0398372076,
0.037107788,
-0.0585120767,
-0.0392103717,
0.0337406211,
-0.0024172834,
-0.0072451909,
-0.0168798286,
-0.0209606271,
0.0037500339,
0.0003280858,
-0.0098638162,
-0.0448013581,
-0.0109243905,
-0.0083556408,
0.0350179076,
0.0553584024,
-0.0047593033,
0.0199127477,
-0.0382231399,
0.0842347518,
-0.0238912217,
0.0557569973,
-0.0479861945,
-0.0355915576,
-0.039885208,
-0.0537747182,
-0.0508873984,
0.0220470689,
-0.049886249,
-0.0512310527,
-0.0069485125,
0.029535681,
-0.0018110027,
0.0000206133,
-0.0057213502,
0.0083027231,
-0.0175551213,
0.0311981328,
0.0105453581,
0.0164000317,
-0.0277685355,
0.0298400223,
-0.018437583,
-0.0329841077,
-0.0512270816,
0.042146448,
0.020601904,
-0.051678203,
-0.0109219039,
0.0299070589,
-0.0063569886,
-0.0544419624,
-0.0059774327,
0.027202405,
-0.0268223248,
-0.0246327184,
0.0260697864,
-0.0532392003,
0.0266169123,
0.0336753763,
-0.0048025576,
-0.0174286123,
-0.0088858968,
0.0232190527,
-0.0030979165,
0.0814678371,
0.0634581968,
-0.0138321221,
-0.0285253506,
-0.0158050247,
0.0087526105,
0.0613641664,
0.0027021277,
0.0170459412,
0.0356708206,
0.0032807502,
0.0030986166,
0.0085283369,
-0.0036796157,
-0.0122427708,
-0.0332037807,
0.0206053592,
0.0495849401,
0.0189703479,
0.0017105156,
0.0305285808,
-0.0511999317,
-0.010004268,
0.0223661643,
0.0812542662,
0.0008162946,
0.0023422199,
0.0545559973,
-0.0139676947,
-0.0327063724,
0.0282020513,
-0.0268913396,
0.006062164,
0.0094259027,
-0.0056912848,
-0.0201449655,
0.0275494363,
-0.0543312393,
-0.0151962629,
-0.0341090895,
-0.0245693009,
0.01876764,
-0.0443379208,
0.0380731262,
0.0316544138,
-0.0306504704,
0.0872134194,
0.0103136888,
-0.057235878,
-0.0292721204,
0.0106721185,
-0.0149344355,
0.0042420956,
0.0188549086,
-0.0091854772,
0.014144036,
-0.002193724,
0.0085370215,
0.0593335256,
0.0158507656,
-0.0102740806,
0.0217901189,
-0.0283924341,
-0.0145830642,
-0.0682042018,
0.0394689776,
-0.0039259437,
0.0006698316,
-0.0386762805,
0.0149251893,
-0.100041084,
0.0218302254,
0.0602649935,
-0.0204751454,
-0.0014215725,
-0.005865281,
0.0364710093,
-0.0005750685,
-0.00098787,
-0.002586042,
0.034339074,
0.0328160673,
-0.0990768597,
-0.0401628837,
0.0367659368,
-0.0411894433,
-0.0811012983,
0.0144222565,
-0.095394209,
0.0072567901,
0.0858343765,
-0.0415974073,
-0.00812524,
0.0162080303,
-0.0458839685,
0.0420900732,
-0.060567189,
0.0092474194,
-0.0343825705,
0.0263199061,
-0.0283778682,
0.074913159,
-0.0014404675,
0.0481123589,
0.0006494784,
0.0095943259,
0.0514440909,
0.0028607952,
-0.0600552373,
-0.0055118287,
-0.0074837818,
-0.0142360562,
0.0306341331,
-0.0226332564,
0.0079479152,
-0.0511533134,
-0.0825071186,
-0.0178658012,
-0.0336761884,
0.0214586034,
0.0402094983,
0.0073573189,
0.0372607782,
-0.0070810332,
-0.0283893291,
-0.0332887769,
-0.005415279,
0.0265928302,
0.074765794,
-0.0266784113,
-0.0440449603,
-0.031306535,
-0.0226385593,
-0.0293720253,
0.1029913649,
-0.0134913623,
-0.0247186869,
-0.0548038185,
-0.0101819113,
-0.0027755466,
0.0159062501,
-0.0143228183,
-0.0475864187,
0.0067950338,
0.0042312434,
0.0399393402,
0.0620578788,
0.0130979512,
0.0905973911,
0.0489808284,
0.039684277,
-0.0146445828,
-0.0100444639,
-0.0510350652,
0.0392637476,
-0.0633213297,
-0.002520453,
0.0263836365,
0.1074752435,
0.008576476,
-0.0125569077,
-0.0555102229,
0.0068302997,
-0.0229950547,
0.0028563859,
-0.0241681989,
0.0000887527,
-0.0292177629,
0.0177673809,
-0.0266140755,
-0.0112092253,
0.0658451989,
-0.0507408977,
-0.0042097843,
-0.0451551788,
-0.0260440223,
-0.0578308627,
0.060345035,
0.0361629874,
0.0181340184,
-0.0003102718,
-0.0194768701,
-0.0329033993,
0.0266913027,
0.0199782867,
0.0071807499,
0.005814211,
0.0390841812,
0.0099510066,
-0.0040424736,
-0.053595379,
-0.0299354903,
-0.052912835,
-0.0475180559,
0.0171428062,
0.0165180936,
-0.0018819972,
-0.0388206244,
0.0080888085,
-0.0101697352,
0.0335633457,
-0.0004844565,
0.0074796835,
-0.0680996627,
0.0529036,
0.0589354448,
0.0052600713,
0.0039956542,
-0.0191075094,
0.0291580521,
0.0290835351,
-0.0222303551,
0.0670904219,
-0.0282823574,
-0.0032366056,
0.0306391586,
-0.0044910698,
0.0058258977,
-0.0117215281,
0.0524729192,
0.0097897304,
-0.0707159936,
0.1076473743,
0.0559746139,
-0.0005618203,
0.0284392219,
-0.0011331013,
0.038928289,
0.0446828231,
-0.0014936815,
-0.0928984955,
-0.025210334,
0.0120202443,
-0.0237061847,
-0.0015114187,
0.0090789599,
0.0067979936,
-0.1072864085,
-0.0032398258,
-0.0364151299,
-0.0197294131,
-0.0452450588,
-0.0453360565,
0.0204594992,
0.0077139777,
0.0413527191,
-0.0279222131,
-0.0119198924,
-0.0145859187,
0.0123611949,
-0.016077131,
-0.0317179337,
0.0053987503,
-0.0600904003,
0.0005176923,
-0.001038122,
0.0328009278,
-0.0055901799,
-0.0631975085,
0.0168389827,
-0.0186925307,
0.0055837436,
0.0375914164,
0.0393391363,
-0.0271021221,
-0.0111617958,
0.0032915699,
0.0350394249,
-0.0531191528,
-0.0169279315,
-0.0242105443,
0.0862343907,
-0.0076809758,
-0.0187791754,
-0.0004490057,
0.0020221504,
-0.0284568612,
0.091179423,
0.0670535788,
-0.0342338197,
-0.0536884815,
-0.0064674155,
0.0464625396,
-0.0019465532,
-0.0186270215,
0.0315631591,
0.0572031476,
0.0272371992,
-0.0467608646,
-0.0278013181,
0.0271623824,
0.0094424607,
-0.0263991542,
0.0033070173,
-0.0151394662,
-0.0548358075,
-0.0415758006,
0.0088218078,
-0.0249109305,
0.0270184651,
-0.0037319821,
0.0396421403,
0.0231274795,
0.002886079,
-0.0597372241,
-0.0583020486,
-0.1259726882,
-0.0642876029,
-0.0180086773,
-0.0039218976,
0.0057552978,
0.0383860022,
-0.0197698455,
-0.0020898732,
0.0389981009,
0.0050879614,
-0.0392862558,
0.031977389,
0.0437522568,
-0.0306920242,
0.0179135054,
0.0607971139,
-0.0274339933,
0.0013848167,
0.0262000412,
0.0427988693,
0.0271804444,
-0.0104300957,
0.0328906886,
-0.0075549376,
0.0873391852,
0.0369060151,
-0.0133044282,
-0.0200002696,
0.0277710091,
-0.05981756,
-0.0101884948,
-0.0369708724,
-0.0157394949,
0.01846263,
0.0308900513,
-0.0089169294,
0.0279085711,
-0.0074032079,
0.0735415891,
-0.0334050991,
0.0203591157,
0.0389345698,
-0.014855817,
-0.010188424,
0.0277877934,
-0.0293579716,
-0.0238827225,
-0.0103638694,
-0.0017241222,
-0.0101894997,
-0.0019658688,
0.050301902,
0.0150086852,
-0.0447355621,
0.0412882641,
-0.0829831213,
0.0213468242,
0.0052521182,
-0.0350183621,
0.0133071356,
-0.0469244793,
0.0223845262,
-0.0075422479,
-0.0297989622,
0.0348984823,
0.0474342927,
0.0014189277,
-0.0192734748,
0.0678244382,
0.0110936547,
-0.028332293,
-0.0118605094,
0.0669472441,
0.02131995,
0.0406212471,
0.0074357954,
-0.030176349,
-0.0422945619,
0.0063836221,
0.0307140034,
0.0268213991,
0.0009006619,
0.0234298073,
-0.0432633795,
-0.0530686751,
0.0374210291,
-0.0098314853,
-0.0268283524,
-0.0171798673,
0.0022730727,
0.0546718389,
0.0404404998,
-0.0176995434,
-0.0079305116,
-0.0181303434,
0.0270932615,
-0.0483353995,
-0.0372378454,
-6.147607703e-33,
0.0072851209,
-0.0043311389,
-0.038600374,
0.0048111123,
-0.0224805325,
0.0329029784,
-0.0171219017,
-0.0104341144,
-0.0336659662,
0.0403051451,
0.0090401629,
0.0195584036,
0.0028059799,
0.0718030408,
-0.0206171181,
-0.016683463,
0.0536150634,
-0.0066990592,
-0.0346941501,
-0.0371558107,
0.0318940133,
0.024272643,
0.0455574505,
-0.0127390092,
0.0022340047,
-0.027550552,
0.0368832313,
0.0422977991,
0.0415845551,
0.0643881187,
-0.040213082,
0.0419551432,
0.0258285254,
-0.0553226657,
0.0087382952,
0.0425981581,
-0.0605955906,
-0.0449497811,
0.0089111906,
0.002579188,
-0.0455512665,
-0.0221777093,
0.0205246322,
-0.0240214821,
-0.0044937329,
-0.0443539694,
0.0288490579,
0.0094653759,
0.0170253813,
-0.001839856,
-0.0735407919,
-0.0107814241,
-0.0158173312,
0.0091662155,
0.0389575176,
0.0642549992,
0.0090997582,
0.0325679779,
-0.0382924341,
-0.0115281381,
-0.0307612978,
0.0397748426,
0.0189168695,
0.0101657407,
0.0152634857,
0.0627512857,
-0.0045553562,
-0.0348657295,
-0.0261237565,
0.0029526243,
0.0306911934,
0.023254646,
0.0459185652,
0.0283720791,
0.012873414,
0.012970739,
-0.0521621928,
-0.0310525578,
0.0043177959,
0.0103526823,
0.0594908036,
0.0138010122,
-0.0060676374,
-0.0358674526,
-0.0586767718,
-0.0366351381,
-0.0338562913,
-0.0008586441,
0.0522477105,
0.0229336601,
-0.0084585762,
-0.005403067,
0.0276279468,
-0.0667519718,
0.0155756464,
0.0485652201,
-0.0167531092,
0.0202174038,
0.0245260242,
0.0455650538,
-0.04623558,
-0.0334042199,
0.0100394711,
0.0174149089,
0.0259838253,
-0.0204956867,
0.0615028776,
-0.0033439207,
-0.0602934249,
0.0054368987,
-0.0428347476,
-0.0484592207,
-0.0707027391,
0.039969869,
0.0258911196,
0.0373640805,
-0.0328453965,
0.0230790377,
0.0359477326,
0.0279219728,
-0.0161619,
0.0223843623,
0.006559737,
0.0310476553,
-0.0133012608,
-0.0323700421,
-0.0551685579,
0.0346970372,
0.0628415495,
-0.0511161089,
-0.0065078996,
-0.000917293,
2.427e-7,
0.0436033346,
0.0300253313,
0.0651634783,
0.0048871939,
0.0251647625,
0.0172552746,
0.0250240397,
0.0627289489,
-0.012397957,
-0.0238649566,
0.0040322565,
-0.0022225808,
0.0279421043,
-0.003255921,
-0.077674292,
0.0614634752,
-0.1013700292,
-0.027627293,
-0.0363130495,
-0.0003709579,
0.0683098584,
0.1110718474,
-0.0053708828,
0.0199998338,
-0.0436415039,
-0.0296192095,
0.0731349289,
-0.0348247401,
0.006631854,
0.0025189782,
-0.0229902584,
-0.006570661,
0.0475129224,
0.0017758011,
0.0080006979,
0.0605724826,
0.0276485365,
0.0136368256,
0.0026523422,
-0.0339700058,
-0.0188159421,
0.0011852672,
-0.0466167852,
-0.0680134669,
0.0801303163,
-0.0863256902,
-0.0416811854,
-0.0257858634,
-0.0250293035,
0.0423790775,
0.0164453946,
0.0097060725,
-0.023529334,
0.0211246964,
0.061087016,
0.0081619686,
-0.0108215082,
-0.047577586,
-0.0409710482,
-0.03881488,
-0.048231788,
0.0122401509,
-0.0259229392,
-0.0337512456,
0.0418094434,
-0.0568762906,
-0.0015234814,
2.493673282e-34,
0.0175562203,
0.0170488637,
-0.0037719784,
0.0031057051,
0.0398809649,
-0.0414685272,
0.0061090542,
-0.0069686319,
0.0086655896,
-0.1167278066,
0.0193928517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11917v1 | A Benchmark for Semi-Inductive Link Prediction in Knowledge Graphs | 2023-10-18T12:13:13 | 2023-10-18T12:13:13 | Adrian Kochsiek, Rainer Gemulla | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Semi-inductive link prediction (LP) in knowledge graphs (KG) is the task of
predicting facts for new, previously unseen entities based on context
information. Although new entities can be integrated by retraining the model
from scratch in principle, such an approach is infeasible for large-scale KGs,
where retraining is expensive and new entities may arise frequently. In this
paper, we propose and describe a large-scale benchmark to evaluate
semi-inductive LP models. The benchmark is based on and extends Wikidata5M: It
provides transductive, k-shot, and 0-shot LP tasks, each varying the available
information from (i) only KG structure, to (ii) including textual mentions, and
(iii) detailed descriptions of the entities. We report on a small study of
recent approaches and found that semi-inductive LP performance is far from
transductive performance on long-tail entities throughout all experiments. The
benchmark provides a test bed for further research into integrating context and
textual information in semi-inductive LP models. | [
0.0146062234,
-0.034087006,
0.0158949681,
0.052205231,
-0.0203698929,
0.0054938369,
-0.0374254137,
-0.0041575027,
0.0709787384,
-0.0414002053,
-0.005861307,
0.0008586234,
-0.0097975815,
-0.0053967447,
0.0511730313,
0.0043338826,
0.020695122,
0.0137884123,
-0.0118312966,
-0.0264336132,
-0.0420525521,
0.0198006015,
-0.0206345711,
-0.0201651081,
-0.0056234123,
-0.0063469782,
-0.0033327213,
0.0054336013,
0.0318714902,
-0.0379493386,
-0.0129507165,
0.0233686287,
-0.0171091929,
0.0237549301,
0.0000017562,
-0.0559804626,
0.0332963541,
-0.0132135935,
-0.0791287273,
-0.0198153891,
-0.0502436198,
-0.0404035784,
0.0137864742,
-0.0307395142,
-0.005799165,
-0.03453416,
0.0124548366,
0.0556744412,
0.0055315406,
0.0765769705,
0.0063622682,
-0.0510289706,
0.057168074,
-0.0100194542,
0.0332263745,
-0.0422837585,
0.0342374966,
-0.0027541772,
-0.0417855084,
0.0143351974,
-0.0199822243,
0.0322562978,
0.0348795317,
0.01697395,
0.0596689694,
0.052695062,
-0.0546943918,
0.0109035335,
0.0185810737,
0.1052050367,
0.0364685915,
-0.0254572816,
-0.0070125544,
0.005060398,
0.0224024169,
0.0256688986,
0.0067431484,
-0.0359911881,
-0.041857142,
-0.0104369139,
0.0031241265,
-0.002190232,
0.0722197816,
-0.0229137801,
0.0029181258,
0.048308596,
-0.0062750671,
-0.0386747904,
0.0374948047,
0.0441356972,
0.0232414883,
-0.0462117754,
-0.0152559411,
0.0145302471,
-0.0150673687,
0.0180456582,
0.0094945841,
0.0076461281,
0.0136723397,
-0.0429391116,
-0.0516178757,
-0.0096650468,
0.0164264012,
0.0889540613,
-0.067355752,
-0.0169518627,
-0.0267346781,
-0.0352996029,
-0.0056353249,
-0.0359970517,
-0.0682822317,
0.0078111673,
0.012835104,
0.0447650589,
0.0402295068,
-0.0087334337,
-0.0505345911,
0.0122794434,
-0.0151802059,
0.0641783923,
0.0191466287,
-0.0392379463,
-0.008308175,
-0.022019906,
-0.0383292958,
0.0194177888,
-0.0288394801,
-0.0150806261,
-0.052706223,
0.024332406,
-0.0110949008,
-0.0282884818,
0.0111450115,
-0.0420755111,
-0.0001082595,
0.0626737475,
0.0316179357,
-0.0111311767,
-0.0411477797,
-0.0453871302,
0.0154134538,
-0.0741063878,
0.0118406676,
-0.0207916182,
0.0371904746,
0.0351998173,
-0.015911907,
-0.021389002,
0.0167081188,
-0.0036223351,
-0.0623943806,
0.0765119419,
-0.0191489179,
-0.0121562751,
-0.0228362102,
-0.0005109326,
-0.0009687589,
0.0655265078,
-0.0061925715,
0.0061886529,
0.0221560914,
0.0199277736,
-0.0344795138,
0.0288487263,
0.0740528554,
0.0209653713,
0.0487289093,
0.0246404987,
0.0145841977,
0.0369469225,
-0.024514284,
0.0295599531,
-0.0215669908,
-0.0334316604,
0.0073272386,
-0.0082812617,
0.0528692715,
0.0088702356,
0.0692998394,
0.0092928847,
-0.0057002814,
-0.0047405614,
-0.0502427295,
0.00946094,
-0.0723791867,
0.0329175554,
0.017275583,
0.0091079427,
-0.0281577501,
0.014211229,
-0.0071855411,
-0.0330501199,
0.0179503281,
0.0029054238,
0.0969776437,
0.0343146138,
-0.0398453772,
0.0686905533,
0.0417625569,
-0.0091738412,
-0.0029973031,
0.0214663222,
0.0071230107,
0.0544768013,
0.051962629,
-0.0379294269,
-0.0250833463,
-0.0142936241,
0.0350060202,
0.0016173369,
0.0279836189,
-0.0498940796,
-0.0063818563,
-0.0116961505,
-0.0373084582,
0.0156501886,
-0.0009938614,
0.0123212263,
0.0493680313,
0.0460963547,
0.0395507291,
-0.0829929337,
0.0433633998,
0.0260940082,
-0.0499185733,
-0.0032422009,
-0.0179826599,
0.020956751,
-0.0117981415,
0.05950078,
0.0144124255,
-0.0367179364,
0.0458371192,
-0.0136986859,
-0.0381347612,
-0.0001635811,
0.0305278953,
-0.0766651034,
0.0703921095,
-0.003336818,
-0.0168643966,
-0.0420304053,
-0.0144134611,
-0.0271829721,
0.0367336348,
0.00887552,
0.0698845685,
0.0076096491,
-0.0184727777,
0.0201487876,
-0.0119846277,
0.0096256007,
0.1037947088,
-0.011610358,
0.0216904469,
-0.0074158702,
-0.0300810728,
0.0026019658,
-0.0354098305,
-0.0375468917,
-0.0027675836,
0.0147400917,
-0.0310209505,
0.0104734171,
-0.0472011156,
-0.0731593966,
0.0162059125,
-0.0716341585,
0.0110087618,
-0.0104745273,
0.0048809242,
-0.0360365435,
0.0083302613,
0.0275538769,
-0.0070927036,
0.0006104997,
0.0122417109,
-0.0502912439,
0.0319863819,
0.0238346588,
0.0134156728,
0.0107432567,
-0.0042076549,
-0.0470849946,
-0.0391930602,
0.075336419,
0.0146432426,
-0.0310821831,
-0.0130035765,
0.0316190235,
-0.0542537272,
-0.0149559462,
-0.0367509425,
0.0261137988,
-0.0281159673,
0.012332757,
0.0148022892,
0.018517999,
-0.0404717438,
-0.0159563459,
-0.0211235397,
0.0024064679,
-0.0472572632,
0.027342461,
-0.0175863132,
0.013585344,
-0.0300733894,
0.0110547487,
-0.0316333845,
0.0220041778,
-0.0080878735,
-0.0279306155,
-0.0683653727,
-0.0002558099,
-0.0041667917,
0.0028598832,
-0.0279523116,
0.0032897454,
0.0352793634,
-0.0196663141,
-0.0143482462,
0.0065783029,
0.0729994997,
0.022821445,
0.0308859572,
0.0405781083,
-0.0015031947,
-0.035780374,
0.0580951832,
0.0316251405,
-0.0059751906,
0.0004621339,
0.016688481,
-0.0140862418,
0.0649216399,
0.0160426535,
-0.0117039969,
0.0442884453,
0.0145726912,
0.0394219235,
0.0265340544,
-0.0204181299,
-0.0382679477,
-0.0309392549,
-0.0299317073,
-0.0030238931,
-0.0073802886,
-0.015823761,
0.0367886648,
-0.0115318717,
0.0099443309,
-0.0140634896,
0.043064978,
-0.0337297358,
-0.0123015083,
-0.0067167385,
0.0212155953,
-0.0631046146,
-0.0018246112,
0.0105151301,
0.0390049927,
0.0365620665,
0.0283926185,
-0.051338803,
-0.0042036218,
-0.0300159547,
-0.0403504781,
-0.0584161207,
-0.0605889931,
-0.0053225532,
0.0351014622,
-0.0209267791,
0.0253996439,
0.0921388268,
0.0156160118,
-0.0282934401,
-0.0018606385,
0.0162497032,
0.001457385,
0.0336074047,
0.0004817669,
-0.1371327639,
-0.0320657566,
-0.0206006337,
-0.0091744782,
0.0398196727,
-0.0968535766,
0.0157503244,
-0.1063583344,
-0.0278169084,
0.0070958566,
-0.0268794242,
-0.0177385509,
-0.0658769086,
-0.0088897487,
-0.0650802702,
-0.0752710104,
0.0118441395,
-0.0239108112,
0.0250382591,
-0.0082108285,
-0.0320749953,
-0.0228261426,
0.0360825881,
-0.0370450914,
0.0556997731,
-0.0148867397,
0.0261329357,
0.0020345962,
0.0138691673,
0.0120005887,
-0.0305209309,
-0.0068238089,
0.0061178599,
0.1032832712,
-0.0225559082,
0.01690704,
-0.0027417191,
-0.0001570879,
-0.0494761504,
-0.0201863423,
0.022180438,
0.1085399464,
0.0234389193,
-0.0436397158,
0.0027820366,
-0.0075944699,
0.0042125904,
0.0860199332,
-0.0026030594,
0.0182477236,
0.0060340688,
-0.0168795567,
0.029380098,
-0.0040656803,
-0.0032502045,
0.0113445902,
-0.0639871135,
0.009636757,
-0.0748782605,
-0.0482078157,
0.0079169925,
0.0249797199,
0.0066424035,
0.0531290919,
0.0025557096,
-0.016783068,
-0.085656181,
-0.0174691714,
-0.0364006162,
0.0101843746,
0.026920991,
0.0031451553,
0.0488767996,
-0.0357362665,
-0.0093022566,
0.0104569634,
-0.0511087179,
-0.0735204443,
-0.035535071,
0.0417607091,
0.0176668465,
0.072776325,
-0.0348258279,
0.0052220011,
0.049646385,
0.0514170006,
-0.0231123064,
0.0076524094,
0.0054660412,
0.0088396352,
0.0147913303,
0.0549860522,
-0.0821356773,
-0.0161956605,
-0.0033612042,
0.0142616974,
-0.0640178695,
-0.0332605876,
-0.022637669,
0.03984363,
0.0259341858,
-0.0130444188,
-0.0042148116,
-0.0079168621,
0.0052895108,
-0.0191033334,
-0.0257929824,
0.0105005745,
0.000129935,
0.040798746,
0.0164189115,
-0.0119561385,
-0.015147917,
0.0125282854,
0.0614163168,
-0.0704316571,
-0.0509707741,
0.0335857272,
-0.0238308087,
0.0399653316,
-0.0143453004,
-0.0020186396,
0.0034245262,
0.060109213,
0.0368255638,
-0.0243324284,
0.0115832081,
0.0110420976,
0.0185960587,
-0.0477909259,
-0.0125573026,
-0.0391586311,
0.0327948965,
-0.000096853,
0.038575422,
0.0549001098,
-0.0042825867,
0.0414963141,
-0.0139171258,
-0.0153484438,
-0.000009417,
0.034858495,
-0.0131991375,
-0.0366135724,
0.0232283231,
0.0192960557,
-0.0365331955,
0.0766933039,
0.0663699433,
-0.0090349484,
0.1038502902,
-0.0057640579,
-0.0358245634,
-0.0559429936,
-0.0100596491,
-0.051633697,
0.0201292597,
0.0239047892,
0.0309901796,
-0.0699413493,
-0.0889805928,
0.0530624948,
-0.0188202094,
-0.000362295,
0.0065926574,
0.0038689682,
0.0042203562,
0.0471889749,
-0.0365580842,
-0.0407356136,
0.0026486309,
-0.0054564872,
-0.0099763991,
0.0120691722,
-5.83806e-33,
-0.0277814344,
0.0100604286,
0.04623143,
0.0517775342,
-0.0399810262,
0.0275279582,
-0.0002312642,
-0.0148432907,
-0.0257702619,
0.0390446521,
-0.0065434864,
0.0075319116,
-0.010236633,
-0.0121160066,
-0.0084718419,
-0.0605267063,
0.0108035393,
0.010091396,
0.0202530082,
0.0175582599,
0.0380580835,
0.0233456809,
0.0709220991,
-0.0834656432,
0.0448885746,
-0.023559086,
0.020693358,
0.0231617521,
0.013931253,
0.0295314658,
-0.0051438673,
0.0517812073,
0.0368172079,
-0.0377457514,
0.016046593,
-0.0289062429,
-0.0960831344,
-0.0182085428,
-0.005847441,
-0.0033268041,
-0.0076344241,
-0.0277621914,
0.0359848477,
0.0112924241,
0.0032793563,
-0.0670260116,
0.042957779,
-0.0018076752,
-0.0744444281,
-0.0414727218,
-0.0503179505,
0.0331958756,
-0.0259390455,
0.0153342737,
0.0017712446,
0.0226626545,
0.0154979015,
-0.0315720551,
-0.1087375581,
-0.0002116279,
0.0080779782,
-0.0147420391,
0.0220505893,
-0.029638581,
0.018854674,
0.0540984496,
0.0550957471,
0.0294914767,
-0.0704499334,
0.02940326,
-0.0270587821,
0.0162731297,
-0.0052669714,
0.0599395595,
-0.012384627,
-0.0106394058,
-0.0923452228,
0.0106994072,
0.0471679829,
0.0170253143,
-0.0261926018,
0.033320576,
-0.0751387551,
-0.0179177858,
-0.0422281958,
-0.0230716132,
-0.0031524387,
-0.0384894125,
-0.0317256525,
-0.0006351224,
0.0040702843,
0.0443686731,
-0.0203753486,
-0.0441750884,
-0.0196378008,
0.074781239,
-0.0080671934,
0.0052458872,
-0.0084990738,
0.0109264581,
-0.0676004589,
-0.0039025082,
0.0109667648,
0.0147681348,
0.0255881082,
-0.0011375628,
0.0612193272,
0.0040175845,
-0.0239182804,
-0.0315710641,
-0.0240138043,
-0.033164423,
-0.0010622746,
-0.0243101213,
0.0447378382,
0.0480231084,
0.0048220991,
0.0264159832,
0.0914513469,
0.0050300402,
0.0116958274,
0.0140315723,
0.0469317064,
-0.0306029283,
-0.0056874948,
-0.0081311073,
0.0064088986,
0.0154213402,
-0.0051037157,
-0.0704290718,
-0.0140065886,
0.0137587478,
2.537e-7,
0.0327891,
0.0428148322,
0.0215792283,
0.0247546062,
0.0111442935,
0.0224282295,
0.0201552026,
0.0532645956,
0.0102878828,
-0.0103749186,
0.0165767577,
0.0052103787,
-0.004517715,
0.0265302472,
-0.1140512228,
-0.0280047972,
-0.0507760495,
-0.0217932407,
-0.0440898314,
-0.0194404144,
-0.0096082184,
0.0263204109,
0.0704789087,
0.019252358,
0.0168449637,
-0.053986039,
0.0795247778,
-0.0213797763,
-0.0297081266,
-0.0008363155,
0.0367224738,
0.0476005822,
-0.0192566123,
0.0674907044,
-0.0276286118,
0.0317753665,
0.0407555215,
0.0078210654,
-0.0012157809,
-0.0102128237,
0.0197992846,
-0.0455664322,
-0.0051508714,
0.02234363,
0.0927618071,
-0.00711028,
-0.0187452398,
0.0621957481,
-0.0346036442,
-0.0091057597,
0.0263098814,
0.0182655361,
0.0121859573,
0.0123720374,
0.0106695332,
0.0024898937,
-0.0363290422,
-0.0535365492,
-0.0222328212,
0.0290299803,
-0.0268236436,
-0.0413557701,
0.0189270526,
-0.0068029836,
-0.0056121452,
-0.0565035865,
0.0352149829,
1.843313584e-34,
0.0085601564,
0.0033211664,
0.0003677719,
0.0068853404,
0.0279299263,
-0.053126093,
-0.040466439,
-0.0232957248,
0.0451910347,
-0.0726530105,
0.0261102114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11906v1 | Rather a Nurse than a Physician -- Contrastive Explanations under Investigation | 2023-10-18T11:54:38 | 2023-10-18T11:54:38 | Oliver Eberle, Ilias Chalkidis, Laura Cabello, Stephanie Brandl | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contrastive explanations, where one decision is explained in contrast to
another, are supposed to be closer to how humans explain a decision than
non-contrastive explanations, where the decision is not necessarily referenced
to an alternative. This claim has never been empirically validated. We analyze
four English text-classification datasets (SST2, DynaSent, BIOS and
DBpedia-Animals). We fine-tune and extract explanations from three different
models (RoBERTa, GTP-2, and T5), each in three different sizes and apply three
post-hoc explainability methods (LRP, GradientxInput, GradNorm). We furthermore
collect and release human rationale annotations for a subset of 100 samples
from the BIOS dataset for contrastive and non-contrastive settings. A
cross-comparison between model-based rationales and human annotations, both in
contrastive and non-contrastive settings, yields a high agreement between the
two settings for models as well as for humans. Moreover, model-based
explanations computed in both settings align equally well with human
rationales. Thus, we empirically find that humans do not necessarily explain in
a contrastive manner.9 pages, long paper at ACL 2022 proceedings. | [
0.0263124164,
0.0539851449,
-0.0136781707,
0.0023593779,
-0.0125382822,
0.0567282736,
0.0360415056,
0.0255940724,
-0.0497483537,
-0.0147139076,
0.0229612943,
-0.0215513073,
0.0003661853,
-0.0239548218,
0.0411358327,
-0.0946376473,
0.0001636255,
0.0120529849,
0.0485104881,
0.0096396273,
-0.0185296554,
0.0288492646,
-0.0167268887,
0.0426987745,
0.0579619817,
-0.0350880064,
-0.0210816078,
-0.0240163859,
0.0426940285,
0.0104806097,
-0.0106475595,
0.0375417471,
0.0433583818,
-0.0153202768,
0.0000021461,
-0.0165920444,
0.009658196,
0.0167276468,
-0.0735419169,
0.0114668123,
0.0103671234,
-0.0006978014,
0.0421446636,
0.0024469751,
-0.0111373216,
-0.0042300648,
0.0378593616,
0.0753540248,
0.0209087301,
0.0400192328,
0.0058549736,
-0.065020889,
-0.023420319,
-0.005423659,
0.0016343624,
-0.0076176776,
-0.0180563796,
0.0027149976,
-0.0000659187,
0.0197967812,
0.0040084631,
0.0015673661,
0.0291248038,
-0.0364995711,
0.0088616442,
0.0417637639,
0.036404945,
-0.0166467261,
0.0445274301,
0.0433736853,
0.0453274474,
-0.0245849155,
0.0093138525,
-0.0110819051,
0.0071916329,
0.0509867743,
-0.0376323946,
0.004755714,
-0.0227219909,
0.0215793848,
0.0549554117,
0.0112949349,
0.0481069684,
0.0349483751,
0.0041488721,
0.0184172224,
-0.0258506071,
0.010056356,
0.0109429909,
0.0138019221,
-0.0079578459,
-0.0521912798,
-0.011538133,
0.0280703027,
-0.0379958041,
0.0019913525,
0.02579787,
0.0141516887,
0.0426759906,
-0.0207188576,
0.0192610733,
0.0088584293,
-0.0247131456,
0.0234543961,
0.0122952424,
0.039513614,
-0.040038608,
0.0306709018,
-0.0213250052,
0.0029705146,
-0.0887660161,
-0.0252925921,
0.0440108404,
0.0021022903,
-0.0390834138,
0.0296759605,
-0.0395513885,
-0.0379680209,
-0.0371650234,
-0.0290969014,
0.0112043899,
0.0436920971,
-0.0079977848,
-0.0130740879,
-0.0537622869,
-0.0029439796,
-0.0769945011,
0.0304512326,
0.0164886732,
-0.0183863062,
-0.0068477499,
0.0035976882,
-0.0083927419,
-0.0123559088,
-0.0203231052,
0.0532954484,
0.0031961158,
0.0023944955,
-0.0296639837,
-0.0380631015,
-0.0170676131,
-0.069975093,
-0.0281365216,
-0.0122809773,
-0.0054325168,
0.0288725197,
-0.0082875807,
-0.0641429126,
-0.0083409352,
0.0060214931,
-0.0399038829,
0.0956714451,
-0.0380862877,
0.0147021087,
0.0022296819,
0.0236629359,
-0.0640115961,
0.0254632011,
-0.005113272,
-0.0460479148,
0.0235734545,
-0.0660735667,
0.0290244278,
-0.0709134787,
0.0143788848,
-0.0319393389,
-0.0022686825,
0.0159650147,
-0.0575609207,
0.0389190987,
0.0610231385,
0.0318597369,
-0.0309959166,
-0.0335062221,
0.0268677473,
0.0868780613,
0.0488861352,
0.0298627708,
0.0376198255,
-0.0022669903,
-0.0011242292,
0.066183202,
-0.0472914726,
0.0277719609,
0.0021174143,
0.004911507,
0.0139369192,
-0.0213717166,
-0.0291432273,
-0.0720310137,
-0.0121941799,
0.0082185203,
0.0203143656,
0.002737103,
0.0335526057,
-0.0175054185,
-0.0051291035,
-0.0000805409,
0.0558913797,
-0.0626902059,
-0.0047806185,
-0.0792796239,
0.0500122681,
0.0775861368,
0.0046270979,
-0.004546179,
0.0164585188,
-0.0389208235,
0.0193815269,
0.0266093072,
0.0361088701,
-0.0228383392,
0.0192625765,
-0.0318112634,
-0.0189098231,
-0.0697662309,
0.0379180796,
0.0041304682,
-0.0181325376,
-0.0253813714,
0.0032316302,
-0.0519794635,
-0.074472107,
0.0356387198,
-0.0423833579,
-0.0242882073,
-0.0380029529,
-0.002925772,
0.0228970964,
0.0352940559,
0.0246556383,
0.0194635447,
0.0037353043,
-0.0044228495,
0.0099740466,
0.0206182487,
-0.0308888182,
-0.0310584791,
-0.0067901602,
-0.0461950079,
-0.0329539105,
0.0121514313,
-0.0153092658,
-0.0421015806,
-0.0050912676,
-0.045670215,
0.0362315886,
-0.0175270587,
-0.0037074583,
-0.0246148277,
-0.0065766023,
-0.0131966136,
0.0666716844,
0.0075517409,
0.0293763615,
0.006464093,
-0.0158606283,
-0.0081934854,
-0.0205203332,
0.0362891741,
0.0061449278,
0.0215833802,
-0.0110189337,
-0.0017019466,
-0.0292533655,
-0.0553989522,
0.0423276424,
-0.0385279953,
-0.0299535673,
-0.0271063223,
0.0026165261,
0.0329040326,
-0.0388746299,
0.0279024281,
0.0076910136,
-0.0025291941,
-0.0033072615,
-0.0338431634,
0.040954724,
0.0499875285,
0.0017854725,
-0.0038833423,
-0.0279305503,
-0.0024864455,
-0.0267919749,
0.0715428516,
0.0335005596,
0.0302029848,
-0.0434208997,
0.0304419473,
-0.0066091539,
-0.0492400303,
-0.0252120197,
-0.0401078574,
0.0435656793,
0.0251511782,
-0.0331796184,
0.0412084535,
0.018014472,
0.073620528,
0.0187318046,
0.0267637521,
-0.0562084354,
-0.022681687,
-0.0359418765,
0.0091133453,
-0.0134740919,
-0.073102735,
-0.0167835616,
0.0951521546,
-0.0099291718,
0.0009762639,
-0.0643867254,
0.0255302228,
-0.0025360519,
-0.0191558022,
-0.0378816389,
-0.0392924286,
-0.0187785421,
0.0983995721,
-0.0026612866,
-0.056388285,
0.0941778049,
-0.0045103072,
-0.0021711893,
-0.0340662487,
-0.0459038429,
-0.0190585144,
0.0647467896,
-0.0443257354,
-0.0025082147,
0.0430057608,
-0.019546628,
-0.0075067217,
-0.0453869477,
0.0448287688,
-0.0004000053,
0.057573013,
-0.0404504463,
-0.0090932697,
0.0152237918,
-0.0162322298,
-0.0121027566,
-0.0473827459,
-0.0566856004,
0.013740031,
0.0332390964,
-0.0424475186,
-0.0216110405,
0.0286472738,
0.0342331454,
0.0203594044,
0.0033145454,
-0.0142928716,
0.0195130892,
-0.0224994514,
0.0124598937,
0.0452648476,
0.0376892798,
-0.0510944948,
0.0620942414,
0.0363072529,
0.0100425351,
-0.0212098081,
-0.0313218161,
0.0139941843,
-0.0236730929,
-0.0269215815,
-0.0518475547,
0.0011447753,
0.0427490287,
-0.0576484799,
0.0036061588,
0.1073502302,
-0.0101070683,
-0.060957659,
0.0228790436,
-0.0365690254,
-0.016742792,
0.0036781377,
-0.015623278,
-0.0006970488,
-0.0335599966,
0.0042900243,
0.0540820397,
-0.0137031516,
-0.0139050893,
0.0063221934,
-0.0375392325,
0.0587952062,
-0.0259398483,
-0.048950851,
-0.0162564572,
-0.0802101269,
0.002367652,
-0.0163535457,
-0.0076220846,
0.0097291917,
0.011349733,
0.0347425751,
0.0445603468,
-0.0136234751,
-0.025009349,
0.0339612663,
-0.0000484543,
0.0191040859,
0.0236656088,
0.0645491108,
0.0040890509,
-0.0778506175,
0.0068345224,
-0.0384698436,
0.0282827392,
0.0004608767,
0.0903297588,
0.0236266591,
0.0089950189,
-0.0747180432,
0.0666068792,
-0.0141486041,
-0.0423611701,
-0.0220049918,
0.0692954808,
-0.0150858853,
-0.0218049902,
-0.0176352598,
0.0324581116,
-0.0089531112,
0.0917667821,
0.0730175003,
-0.0244553499,
-0.0262909364,
-0.0071401647,
0.0048180451,
-0.0371476784,
-0.0442381687,
-0.0098932749,
-0.0103044957,
-0.0092128683,
-0.0204332024,
-0.04740569,
-0.0046209195,
0.0333122462,
-0.0187954828,
0.0081292791,
-0.0170232002,
-0.0186471697,
-0.0197425019,
0.0582415201,
0.0440915488,
-0.0078106592,
0.011506238,
-0.0586155504,
0.0214759782,
-0.0358420573,
-0.0160297677,
-0.0436296724,
0.0605835579,
-0.0160098802,
-0.0027262042,
-0.0103083858,
0.0355442353,
0.0440964289,
0.0366775505,
-0.0531508848,
-0.0152316056,
0.0205532685,
-0.0069617233,
-0.0069450093,
0.0266489834,
0.0041944557,
0.0132685034,
0.0302347299,
-0.0028551328,
-0.0102882776,
0.0155443568,
0.003387342,
-0.0291379504,
-0.0087006642,
0.0276604053,
-0.0291003548,
0.0617461912,
-0.0189894941,
-0.0496211052,
-0.0366666354,
-0.0205984153,
-0.0201545097,
-0.0114037059,
-0.0174608491,
0.0117643513,
0.0307747833,
-0.0168518629,
-0.0285647251,
-0.0386487655,
-0.0417105332,
-0.0148180425,
-0.0240258146,
0.0445792153,
0.0293294117,
0.0310997497,
-0.0352756158,
0.0196991228,
-0.011092742,
-0.0306098703,
-0.0206736512,
0.0650609061,
0.0244891923,
0.0963759422,
0.0391144119,
0.015084751,
-0.0024452601,
-0.025316298,
-0.1074440777,
-0.05569328,
0.0226734001,
-0.0385518521,
-0.0030335882,
-0.0404472128,
0.060569685,
0.0137316547,
-0.014186874,
0.0124655506,
0.0770273209,
0.02866867,
0.0105536366,
0.0176980887,
0.0172570609,
-0.0306206159,
-0.0110968072,
0.0660931468,
-0.0068361205,
0.0235334188,
-0.0153245796,
-0.0419518091,
0.0010749056,
-0.0232127979,
-0.019463595,
0.0440721884,
0.0044829436,
0.0012225348,
-0.0803181753,
-0.0400531217,
-0.0190168433,
-0.0102766491,
-0.018509021,
-0.0169772711,
0.0176625233,
0.0641115755,
0.0026996576,
-0.0588218309,
-0.0345633589,
0.0681638271,
-0.0471878573,
0.0397237986,
-0.0404939801,
-6.380451093e-33,
0.0052268775,
-0.0743693784,
-0.0195061527,
-0.0364977531,
0.0088775856,
0.0342539698,
-0.0437844768,
-0.0070271683,
-0.0256073512,
0.0873752758,
0.0002088851,
0.0487536006,
0.0072981082,
0.0037899076,
0.0272304285,
-0.050134331,
0.0165961795,
0.0301587414,
-0.0181821436,
0.0319168717,
0.026879061,
-0.0025963255,
0.0480243415,
-0.0917349234,
0.075567022,
0.0149965929,
0.0167128388,
0.0025795805,
-0.043947611,
0.0519690961,
-0.0216663312,
0.032580588,
0.0408086851,
-0.0426807255,
0.0082167964,
0.0308333188,
-0.0577758625,
-0.0113442643,
0.0721339732,
-0.0186708812,
-0.0823070779,
-0.0607947521,
0.0368278697,
0.011145941,
-0.0248124674,
-0.0306513365,
0.0556228533,
-0.0167981442,
0.0332325697,
0.0279511139,
-0.0238146801,
0.016437633,
-0.0447360538,
-0.0262034684,
-0.0086023454,
0.0365544148,
-0.0310283117,
0.0367235206,
-0.0483405069,
-0.0105573591,
0.0272645783,
-0.0317575857,
0.0554165579,
-0.0131251374,
-0.0083937384,
0.0722381473,
0.053361319,
0.0157137383,
-0.0733761489,
-0.0122736264,
-0.056289129,
0.0620969497,
0.0955918357,
0.0584233962,
0.052011963,
0.0092889676,
-0.0518965796,
0.01751321,
-0.0485516042,
0.0314597599,
0.0514621101,
0.0197710115,
-0.0479359105,
-0.0404712334,
-0.0375795104,
-0.0616846345,
-0.0229420308,
-0.0282579735,
-0.008678156,
-0.0408264883,
-0.0294669941,
-0.0117398286,
-0.013846064,
-0.0273877252,
0.0260276496,
0.0071923109,
0.0099403644,
-0.0270539336,
0.0199017674,
-0.0316223539,
-0.0146736177,
-0.0025815838,
-0.0016440159,
0.043184381,
0.0648713633,
0.0199244507,
0.0409736857,
-0.033847563,
0.0040613771,
-0.0323309526,
-0.0506578311,
-0.0494097061,
-0.0302631445,
-0.0243945029,
0.0470370315,
0.0203001592,
-0.0172574222,
0.0378604606,
0.0303419475,
0.0285974443,
-0.0181717481,
-0.0222248621,
-0.0248708799,
0.001977386,
0.0060856491,
-0.0142352786,
-0.0016282925,
0.0214864742,
0.0321964175,
-0.0402965322,
-0.0155506544,
0.0145433331,
2.715e-7,
0.0636100397,
0.0264953636,
0.0149645749,
-0.0541314073,
0.0289554074,
0.046418976,
0.0200427156,
-0.0470585376,
0.0099391751,
-0.0288965404,
-0.0015358494,
0.0083610369,
0.0592569299,
0.0179465562,
0.0042384514,
-0.0334661976,
-0.0698399693,
-0.0323943645,
-0.0099454634,
0.02283719,
0.0879257023,
-0.0029027956,
0.0121695735,
-0.0062782159,
0.0209710915,
0.0089324685,
0.0324680619,
-0.0566260256,
0.0396192111,
-0.0257412214,
0.0438726395,
-0.0074541667,
0.0386810526,
0.0432688184,
-0.006290162,
-0.010603237,
-0.0083252536,
0.0462629907,
-0.0182677899,
-0.0165176671,
-0.0260825232,
-0.0333157778,
0.057556659,
-0.074985452,
0.0599468984,
-0.0251381584,
-0.0725571513,
0.0004741948,
-0.0383580104,
-0.0159581974,
0.0298400987,
0.0008434064,
0.0180697907,
0.0194473621,
-0.0273298565,
-0.0255097374,
-0.0093791876,
-0.0916089639,
-0.0543250777,
0.0516350977,
-0.0259647518,
-0.0036934232,
-0.0012551277,
-0.0052315127,
0.0916998088,
-0.0621196665,
-0.0214491431,
2.104021701e-34,
0.0030123815,
0.0451062769,
0.019116506,
0.0180517547,
0.0396730006,
0.0247305855,
-0.0109695774,
-0.0151390461,
0.0715933368,
-0.0427966528,
-0.020258382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11884v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11884v2 | From Neural Activations to Concepts: A Survey on Explaining Concepts in Neural Networks | 2023-10-18T11:08:02 | 2024-05-03T15:15:17 | Jae Hee Lee, Sergio Lanza, Stefan Wermter | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.NE | In this paper, we review recent approaches for explaining concepts in neural
networks. Concepts can act as a natural link between learning and reasoning:
once the concepts are identified that a neural learning system uses, one can
integrate those concepts with a reasoning system for inference or use a
reasoning system to act upon them to improve or enhance the learning system. On
the other hand, knowledge can not only be extracted from neural networks but
concept knowledge can also be inserted into neural network architectures. Since
integrating learning and reasoning is at the core of neuro-symbolic AI, the
insights gained from this survey can serve as an important step towards
realizing neuro-symbolic AI based on explainable concepts. | [
-0.0041945884,
0.0512534007,
-0.0539644212,
0.052647192,
-0.0053281006,
0.0042429604,
0.0097943023,
-0.0046117059,
-0.0481054187,
0.0166243035,
0.0060114171,
0.0427687876,
-0.012574655,
0.0581091009,
0.0426096767,
-0.0521713272,
0.0276542231,
0.0193745736,
0.0435474701,
0.0120460037,
-0.0424388796,
0.0111650294,
-0.0097682495,
0.0159139298,
-0.0418815203,
-0.0062994836,
-0.0355609097,
-0.028197417,
0.0413234346,
0.0042742798,
-0.0643227026,
-0.0629009306,
0.0414748341,
0.0264592301,
0.0000020675,
-0.0271242019,
0.001153585,
0.0156506505,
-0.0707431659,
-0.0373975933,
-0.0381128229,
-0.0091776466,
0.0295100044,
-0.0289868824,
-0.0219280478,
0.0443740636,
0.0629693344,
0.0582511388,
0.0209215321,
0.013491516,
-0.0031265845,
-0.0457356833,
0.0385652184,
0.0047957608,
0.0384107791,
0.0301576834,
-0.0206715912,
-0.0020006499,
-0.0001930447,
-0.0283475555,
-0.016825296,
0.0103740245,
0.0700912476,
-0.0224083979,
0.0488189198,
0.0216504,
0.0416774116,
0.0076549151,
-0.0159075093,
0.0215042736,
-0.0244134795,
-0.0248313844,
0.0028215956,
-0.0190805495,
0.0246467609,
-0.019141838,
-0.0301279668,
-0.010054091,
0.0137701724,
0.0263435151,
0.0102590593,
0.050830137,
0.0676773638,
0.0150152054,
-0.0492137857,
0.0573794805,
-0.0365382582,
0.0259491429,
0.0075584236,
-0.0344956666,
-0.0283870213,
0.0200987477,
0.0041338126,
0.0934212953,
0.0056296624,
0.0279409867,
0.0351043604,
-0.0118561266,
-0.0288219694,
-0.0553115159,
0.0490212142,
0.0613641031,
-0.0015266762,
0.0366090648,
-0.0661567152,
0.080232501,
-0.0089385062,
0.0389941558,
-0.0353571028,
-0.0223734621,
-0.1013275236,
-0.0441090502,
-0.0250197109,
0.0656453893,
0.0154388146,
-0.0119112888,
-0.0109948982,
0.0340353921,
-0.0535094328,
0.0384786949,
-0.0182720888,
0.0349260531,
0.0008118566,
-0.0274261925,
-0.0355055109,
-0.0356950052,
-0.0701930523,
0.0032912306,
0.0178508181,
-0.022576876,
0.0008064369,
-0.0226955488,
-0.0223836862,
0.0103850458,
0.0061622364,
0.0781084299,
0.0448054262,
-0.01274765,
-0.043735873,
-0.0656299964,
0.0219240356,
-0.0134271393,
0.0051917159,
0.0047753137,
0.0357687846,
-0.0180346128,
-0.0115348147,
-0.0528540909,
-0.0037444672,
-0.0325838365,
0.0193959288,
0.0990627334,
-0.0497144274,
-0.0165192299,
0.00637649,
0.011190326,
-0.0377349183,
-0.0012414182,
0.0610539578,
0.0123000089,
0.0028023538,
-0.0215377081,
-0.0053823688,
-0.0548926257,
0.0394135788,
-0.0675428882,
-0.04343725,
-0.0409559123,
-0.0467782393,
0.0385950729,
-0.0045091966,
0.0114736091,
-0.0264489166,
0.0090129357,
0.0275173485,
0.0601500012,
0.0228381958,
0.0176729336,
0.0601005219,
-0.0435695983,
0.0035942055,
-0.0205750018,
-0.0814924464,
0.0659181476,
-0.0249574743,
-0.0035686796,
-0.0771913007,
0.0218273643,
-0.0265171397,
-0.0953742564,
0.0091515472,
-0.0036572923,
0.0040204618,
0.0286252238,
0.0536170788,
-0.0079153776,
0.0191490576,
0.0054702298,
0.0241695885,
0.013837304,
0.0172095001,
-0.1016080603,
0.0534979291,
0.0545793921,
0.0199097991,
-0.0530714989,
-0.0188381933,
-0.005713989,
-0.0682097599,
0.0292246547,
-0.0051452746,
-0.0181737058,
0.010721311,
-0.0202393718,
-0.0099021113,
-0.0482648276,
0.0220035706,
0.0173926763,
-0.0352098607,
-0.009587191,
0.0181413125,
-0.0086623384,
-0.0305403844,
0.0417184643,
0.0223399512,
-0.0249523502,
0.0124626756,
0.0189696513,
0.0517139807,
0.0429436713,
0.0419951007,
0.0151631339,
-0.004445496,
-0.0280399732,
-0.0387562327,
0.015186321,
-0.037865404,
0.0001452116,
0.0147456219,
-0.0243438594,
0.0360874161,
0.0155719295,
-0.027424423,
-0.044358559,
0.0252996534,
-0.0520582125,
0.0025729411,
-0.0194958933,
-0.0276550725,
0.0072254357,
-0.001705121,
0.0163062532,
0.0403575338,
0.0005349197,
-0.0490438156,
-0.0120808752,
0.0209922381,
0.0080716955,
-0.0017709123,
0.027930662,
0.0086217541,
-0.0453939997,
-0.0374667756,
-0.0315998718,
-0.0374099463,
0.0021367252,
0.0492097512,
0.0040578139,
-0.0165259242,
0.0198464133,
-0.0274188034,
-0.0052133449,
-0.0246618204,
0.0452413894,
-0.0088659991,
-0.0281362422,
0.0883041918,
0.0007194575,
-0.0236904491,
0.0664943904,
0.0005778185,
-0.066467762,
0.0001201793,
-0.0073336354,
-0.035795439,
0.0765521601,
0.0633082911,
-0.0177572966,
-0.0222814213,
-0.0066877431,
-0.026788367,
-0.0165657196,
-0.0275292899,
-0.0459699221,
0.0455151983,
-0.0026663085,
-0.0963181108,
0.0379748829,
-0.021316791,
0.0573781468,
0.0382931381,
0.0131720947,
-0.0385020673,
0.0210006498,
-0.0527841933,
0.0686157942,
0.009878289,
-0.018324608,
0.0091224294,
0.0537930951,
0.0241830554,
-0.022906322,
-0.0436526388,
0.0577369183,
0.0122551629,
-0.007849534,
-0.0491237342,
-0.0679870993,
0.0145069566,
0.0328226797,
-0.0141996499,
-0.0530132912,
0.0993394926,
0.0185303707,
0.0154785486,
0.0124482522,
-0.0424085408,
-0.0245786328,
0.075293839,
-0.0164154507,
0.0021681432,
0.0561577864,
-0.0015267344,
-0.0157748591,
-0.0502327681,
0.0179112889,
0.0137276081,
0.0151653225,
-0.0425226688,
-0.0172889978,
0.0484182127,
0.000763501,
-0.0450328775,
0.0674074441,
-0.0337813832,
0.0330226384,
0.0004127889,
-0.0144128576,
0.0203587916,
-0.0064851879,
0.0417367704,
-0.0001801934,
0.0126529178,
-0.0250340141,
-0.035428986,
-0.0292372778,
0.0076726307,
0.0420360342,
0.06077208,
-0.0140616782,
0.0446369909,
-0.0103803193,
0.0079032108,
-0.0425117575,
-0.0672982931,
0.0251112469,
-0.0535585582,
-0.0355562642,
0.0019191825,
0.0045464975,
-0.0158506557,
-0.0669005588,
-0.0308530945,
0.0696282908,
0.0304146148,
-0.0041687391,
0.0353253894,
-0.02516165,
-0.0517851301,
-0.0038543765,
0.0533422045,
-0.0320494995,
-0.0076107685,
0.0049811117,
0.0005706293,
-0.0104574077,
0.000722772,
-0.0284405593,
-0.0192627218,
0.0286723189,
0.0201759338,
-0.0820741057,
-0.0644407496,
-0.0178742148,
-0.0339581855,
-0.0102152936,
-0.040992938,
0.0002756055,
0.0549101979,
0.0110406755,
0.0037229904,
-0.0079398621,
-0.0134230349,
0.001818485,
-0.0190316122,
-0.0028262376,
0.0214893185,
0.0315766223,
-0.0232609566,
-0.0447621197,
-0.0173185058,
-0.0195921641,
0.0624484196,
-0.0098435739,
0.0298788995,
0.0310012009,
-0.0355908871,
-0.0199207049,
0.0282297358,
-0.0508625582,
-0.0404768549,
-0.033975888,
0.0823419914,
-0.0713157877,
-0.0121489568,
-0.018130878,
-0.0140217701,
-0.0183468182,
0.0531771369,
0.053515736,
-0.0093358913,
-0.0086531704,
-0.0114568155,
-0.0217988975,
-0.0245544724,
-0.0243813507,
-0.0119239464,
0.0290844329,
-0.0225115102,
-0.0469124392,
-0.033895202,
-0.0049934341,
0.0642398819,
0.0227261428,
-0.0337765925,
0.004333511,
-0.0127695724,
-0.0437535755,
0.021204941,
0.006506714,
-0.0222307649,
0.0295664426,
-0.0155531988,
0.0061301412,
-0.067200467,
-0.039031174,
0.0005186399,
0.0033886477,
-0.0048658801,
0.0090820761,
0.0483654551,
0.0307401009,
0.0094892038,
-0.0141979204,
-0.0301291477,
0.0824427977,
0.060683392,
-0.0086713266,
-0.0587855913,
0.0317435078,
0.0124578811,
0.016892625,
0.027062092,
-0.0344517753,
0.0284623876,
-0.011342722,
-0.0205546841,
-0.0482967533,
0.0497049801,
0.0362982415,
0.0044183573,
0.0359413028,
0.0262954049,
-0.062955521,
-0.0632831529,
0.0013111075,
-0.007723399,
-0.0087303845,
-0.062630713,
0.0263695084,
0.0013476621,
0.0318027474,
-0.0053781318,
-0.1063042879,
0.0484403558,
-0.0399747267,
0.0507684126,
-0.0313526243,
0.0399143659,
0.0537015051,
-0.0668012276,
0.0364255495,
0.0110629965,
0.0347710736,
-0.0255823303,
0.0214253664,
-0.0186963156,
0.0623669922,
0.0420207046,
-0.0005810023,
-0.0772719085,
0.0136005748,
-0.073246792,
-0.0571769811,
0.0422313884,
-0.0304115955,
0.013023857,
0.0350558497,
-0.0323742852,
-0.0323459506,
0.033396516,
0.0543787815,
0.0595738441,
0.0290637407,
-0.0065013543,
0.014725551,
0.0182776339,
0.0147169633,
-0.064517878,
0.0091042593,
-0.0640192479,
0.0052554156,
-0.0348812528,
0.0008870536,
-0.0126984082,
0.0078615248,
0.018990241,
0.0298242103,
-0.0237349533,
-0.0039938521,
-0.0442628451,
-0.048506543,
0.0214796364,
0.0570034496,
0.0167422369,
0.0051002936,
0.0559892803,
0.0097060828,
0.006368822,
-0.0629929304,
0.0100275874,
0.0031781443,
-0.0364867039,
0.0052993335,
0.0052530584,
-5.356941917e-33,
-0.029357519,
-0.0312725268,
0.0160344094,
0.0203577373,
-0.0093624964,
0.0020910611,
-0.0407778397,
-0.0543926843,
-0.0086590406,
0.0435701087,
0.0004649982,
0.0470326468,
0.0069389972,
-0.0242210086,
0.0097054252,
-0.0211025309,
0.0075293086,
0.0111976294,
0.0115659628,
0.0297177192,
0.0558023676,
0.0177523289,
0.0264284778,
-0.0664676949,
0.0352988802,
0.0451109335,
-0.0189485755,
0.0233242977,
-0.0463168211,
0.0350404009,
-0.0201175921,
0.0054328693,
0.0193564799,
-0.0141804963,
0.013492032,
-0.0067156795,
-0.0337525606,
-0.060614761,
0.0093341917,
0.0117134349,
-0.0459367558,
-0.0537250005,
0.0768853426,
-0.023468757,
0.0063580777,
0.0113903806,
0.0468546562,
-0.0400510244,
0.0102337291,
-0.0312341191,
-0.0186416451,
-0.0108233485,
-0.0212390125,
0.005186338,
0.0089645693,
-0.0191329625,
-0.0283280294,
0.0172530524,
-0.0404997505,
-0.0024616602,
0.0018792994,
-0.0366025493,
0.0388094671,
0.0017462629,
0.0120524243,
0.0461048447,
0.0750286877,
-0.0300233122,
-0.0540907457,
0.0373663269,
-0.0014638718,
0.068499811,
0.1135895401,
0.0159283988,
0.0674376339,
0.005826877,
-0.0738666803,
0.0213241652,
0.0069941278,
0.0605526641,
0.0044020619,
-0.0042101289,
-0.0263915714,
0.0099843796,
-0.0182641484,
-0.0462654382,
-0.0517776534,
-0.0353492014,
0.0028246448,
-0.0435639247,
-0.0370560028,
0.0068861404,
-0.0191968977,
-0.062257424,
0.0545542091,
0.0275383014,
0.0666510239,
0.0143374391,
0.0044659697,
-0.0243437681,
0.0083404062,
-0.0349344946,
-0.0137199881,
0.0014955938,
0.0580341704,
0.0229633972,
0.0424211174,
0.0650625825,
0.0418261699,
-0.0106067536,
-0.0349539556,
-0.077673763,
-0.0057738447,
-0.0413274989,
0.0144796893,
0.0327993371,
-0.0240105558,
-0.0137465149,
0.0097718704,
0.0002889003,
0.0133897224,
0.045630753,
-0.0362730995,
0.0340301208,
-0.0039320476,
-0.0368448608,
-0.0333794355,
-0.0056855716,
0.0192695931,
-0.0547188632,
-0.0170390196,
0.027377611,
2.662e-7,
0.0001953456,
-0.0059737102,
0.0105923815,
0.0238408651,
0.04872391,
0.0136900367,
0.0092054615,
-0.0056517487,
-0.0077901171,
-0.0304195825,
0.0483682491,
0.057570532,
-0.0025124394,
0.0195590798,
-0.0282770284,
-0.0087032747,
0.0193086248,
-0.0403515659,
-0.01024283,
0.0420889594,
0.0689738318,
0.0567338318,
0.0460981652,
-0.0210277718,
0.0613424107,
-0.0258836616,
0.0262474157,
-0.0246743746,
0.0684192553,
-0.0181801114,
0.0375804007,
-0.0300091822,
-0.0061140927,
0.0264040995,
0.0174079109,
0.0333233662,
-0.0142610809,
0.0050176554,
-0.008794385,
-0.0071019195,
-0.0621877015,
-0.0068975971,
0.025033582,
-0.0575826205,
0.052340202,
-0.0595160052,
-0.0411811434,
0.0223727226,
-0.0060719838,
-0.0265072193,
0.0006922804,
0.0178640205,
0.0060188016,
-0.0168010332,
-0.0398688577,
-0.0323807485,
0.0168106947,
-0.075680159,
-0.015291621,
0.0203923788,
-0.0173645895,
0.0516771451,
-0.0175668132,
-0.0301402789,
0.0794549063,
-0.0305593051,
-0.0259444118,
1.878296365e-34,
-0.0188929494,
-0.0162154548,
0.0023214794,
0.030561246,
0.0344316922,
0.0294154119,
-0.0721602738,
-0.0123990187,
0.078321442,
-0.0135338586,
-0.0287307743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11878v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11878v5 | From Dissonance to Insights: Dissecting Disagreements in Rationale Construction for Case Outcome Classification | 2023-10-18T11:04:31 | 2024-02-16T17:31:10 | Shanshan Xu, T. Y. S. S Santosh, Oana Ichim, Isabella Risini, Barbara Plank, Matthias Grabmair | cs.CL | cs.CL | In legal NLP, Case Outcome Classification (COC) must not only be accurate but
also trustworthy and explainable. Existing work in explainable COC has been
limited to annotations by a single expert. However, it is well-known that
lawyers may disagree in their assessment of case facts. We hence collect a
novel dataset RAVE: Rationale Variation in ECHR1, which is obtained from two
experts in the domain of international human rights law, for whom we observe
weak agreement. We study their disagreements and build a two-level
task-independent taxonomy, supplemented with COC-specific subcategories. To our
knowledge, this is the first work in the legal NLP that focuses on human label
variation. We quantitatively assess different taxonomy categories and find that
disagreements mainly stem from underspecification of the legal context, which
poses challenges given the typically limited granularity and noise in COC
metadata. We further assess the explainablility of SOTA COC models on RAVE and
observe limited agreement between models and experts. Overall, our case study
reveals hitherto underappreciated complexities in creating benchmark datasets
in legal NLP that revolve around identifying aspects of a case's facts
supposedly relevant to its outcome. | [
0.0547351949,
0.046162799,
0.0140541838,
0.0020534839,
-0.0490585081,
0.0464047305,
0.0377326161,
0.0006553766,
-0.0258770734,
-0.0688889548,
-0.0006750617,
0.0130549083,
0.0056571686,
0.0009559842,
-0.0095716938,
-0.0623753779,
0.0402783528,
0.0174806509,
0.0560096502,
-0.010125,
0.0129255513,
0.0075429101,
-0.0007934569,
0.0513817668,
-0.0076039387,
-0.0169963762,
-0.0213476513,
-0.0049600564,
-0.0125037516,
-0.020778805,
0.0061175069,
0.0826973319,
0.0175754093,
0.0206125248,
0.0000017153,
-0.061219614,
0.0091802254,
0.0109971408,
-0.0222041234,
-0.0037735568,
-0.0149434609,
-0.0225117747,
-0.0073203319,
-0.022465568,
0.0054313829,
0.0255661942,
0.0288396254,
0.0470644422,
0.0381190144,
0.0621723942,
0.0142208477,
-0.0427795872,
0.0035692558,
-0.0420140848,
0.0042188149,
-0.0281283967,
-0.0024687485,
0.0252721068,
-0.0183398128,
0.0120764282,
0.0444015451,
-0.0190103706,
0.0205171537,
0.0000834692,
-0.0194328465,
0.0086031714,
-0.0270666741,
-0.0245307349,
0.0453947745,
0.0348225161,
0.0737093985,
-0.0601852462,
0.0151486387,
0.0052795159,
0.05221349,
0.0233622883,
0.0003452186,
0.0786060616,
-0.025789503,
0.0112590762,
0.0555689447,
0.0764778256,
-0.0085573439,
0.0335951634,
-0.0236992892,
0.0707169026,
-0.0390990712,
-0.018228475,
0.008128413,
0.0290831234,
0.0111370645,
-0.058903534,
0.0122054135,
0.0079246834,
-0.0253276732,
0.0187568925,
-0.0103183491,
0.0134482309,
0.0599259809,
-0.0658042356,
-0.006540427,
0.0016520887,
-0.0438098423,
0.0794476569,
-0.0047232285,
-0.0233132374,
0.0036229654,
0.0336901434,
0.0113692516,
-0.0546305105,
-0.0896408781,
-0.0094881225,
0.0117482366,
0.0406708792,
-0.0707030371,
0.0509721376,
-0.03285449,
-0.0305547658,
-0.0594101399,
0.0370037854,
0.0251100194,
-0.0007358674,
-0.0184764173,
-0.0242689364,
-0.0808629468,
-0.0721840188,
-0.0612011515,
0.0397681631,
-0.00079506,
-0.0142611926,
0.0185746327,
0.0028377229,
-0.0294429883,
0.0027161809,
-0.0024528594,
0.0982640088,
0.0072142677,
0.0032664661,
-0.011062054,
-0.081370607,
-0.0320967175,
-0.0564314201,
-0.0400587954,
-0.0582909212,
0.0176253673,
-0.0180559196,
-0.006178367,
-0.0910373926,
0.0008191656,
0.0146754673,
-0.0174065121,
0.0781740472,
-0.0357621685,
-0.0281202868,
-0.0315407701,
0.0269959606,
-0.0148290368,
-0.0106323576,
-0.0157862678,
-0.0017617715,
0.0553643443,
-0.0198577046,
0.0266124103,
-0.0318273045,
-0.003835218,
0.020347761,
0.0244257711,
0.0158441737,
-0.0192277338,
0.0241065752,
0.0350145474,
0.0097341444,
-0.0061879978,
-0.0416686349,
0.0099826558,
0.0692401826,
0.0018608499,
0.0679819584,
-0.0329638459,
-0.0145855416,
0.0121835154,
0.0219190866,
-0.0478043929,
0.0227753371,
-0.0118409004,
-0.0167213362,
-0.0416420102,
0.0049547395,
-0.0250966344,
-0.0769176483,
-0.0017307468,
0.0065493872,
-0.0061495849,
-0.0123859206,
0.005473101,
0.003272743,
0.0193123072,
0.0426854454,
0.0414180756,
-0.0524866246,
-0.042252738,
-0.0385434367,
0.019469358,
-0.0240755361,
0.0044008675,
-0.0340588801,
-0.0392465033,
-0.0426014774,
0.0086158644,
0.0339802243,
0.0466706455,
-0.0196909942,
-0.0055617206,
-0.0064669931,
-0.0383963399,
-0.0074958005,
0.0462266579,
0.0167212468,
-0.004985237,
-0.0445545763,
0.0311322697,
-0.0861968696,
-0.0334242322,
0.0465095155,
0.0106589524,
0.0085025383,
0.0229838099,
-0.0038446572,
0.0503603332,
0.0356446318,
0.0159531701,
-0.0070905159,
0.0176428966,
0.0012888632,
0.0036892609,
0.0401971601,
0.015065603,
0.0034690916,
0.0403260812,
-0.036026895,
-0.0319208279,
-0.0057728984,
-0.0432436056,
-0.0101206768,
-0.0279116966,
0.0054279827,
-0.0117619671,
-0.0360099487,
0.0031496927,
-0.0033199897,
-0.0221006982,
-0.0248175394,
0.0431983955,
0.0062701642,
-0.0012227837,
-0.0504979007,
0.0042696795,
0.0588802323,
0.0077978456,
-0.0136850262,
0.0306285899,
-0.0270029977,
0.0104248403,
0.0318949781,
-0.027870018,
-0.0346241929,
-0.0253893919,
-0.0625292808,
0.0214203037,
-0.0197342671,
0.0051629734,
0.0260474887,
-0.0573800839,
0.024992371,
-0.0138878832,
-0.0050627212,
-0.0613107309,
-0.0397044867,
0.0188638065,
0.0422777086,
-0.0265713613,
0.0003266204,
-0.0271281432,
-0.0250675213,
-0.0338466763,
0.0591120645,
-0.0150966169,
0.018149402,
-0.0306467805,
0.0439808406,
-0.0490363091,
-0.0253558643,
-0.0416637436,
0.0216119811,
0.0273330919,
0.0720508695,
-0.0353442468,
-0.0057845707,
0.055208955,
0.0689947605,
0.0193105731,
0.0252481978,
-0.0517714769,
-0.0348746479,
-0.0007771928,
0.0045300797,
0.010575477,
-0.0325403921,
0.0358214416,
0.0562538728,
-0.0059660166,
-0.0078760134,
-0.0335690193,
0.0213659294,
-0.0319164842,
-0.0163482483,
-0.0560480729,
-0.0451833121,
-0.0182008091,
0.0842413679,
0.0156152453,
-0.0455033146,
0.0608121306,
-0.0025354344,
0.0730820522,
-0.0507729873,
-0.0414251648,
-0.0446740016,
0.0973840132,
-0.0382850133,
-0.0224950127,
0.0098475339,
-0.0237533078,
0.0178410579,
-0.0571134575,
0.0690845996,
-0.0155392904,
0.0705668703,
-0.0566635728,
0.0225879401,
-0.0213501938,
-0.045773115,
-0.0113197993,
-0.023075033,
-0.0000367636,
0.0502176769,
-0.0014229676,
0.009320111,
-0.0103415931,
0.0001298988,
0.0235569086,
0.0182034001,
0.0311012883,
-0.0074518798,
-0.0335153341,
0.011094626,
-0.0243988521,
0.0118149351,
0.0282947496,
-0.0162811801,
-0.0249862596,
0.0404557474,
-0.0148774199,
0.0098806694,
0.006640642,
0.0015528675,
-0.0019592172,
-0.0742491409,
-0.0394014604,
0.011075601,
0.0383679792,
-0.0372082032,
0.0299909767,
0.0883649886,
0.0301009081,
-0.0340547822,
0.0081212102,
-0.0043074144,
-0.0113772936,
0.0317692831,
-0.0297452696,
-0.0523225106,
0.0059273746,
-0.0047086012,
0.0007119618,
-0.0836224556,
-0.0393618383,
-0.0094000669,
-0.0449061543,
0.0658427104,
-0.0056838989,
-0.0214940812,
-0.0430890173,
-0.0475227498,
0.0219642892,
-0.0109285023,
-0.0171703119,
-0.0028787092,
0.0143042617,
0.0131124556,
0.0482765362,
-0.0678522885,
-0.0190475918,
0.0450988896,
-0.0399916172,
0.0749041885,
0.0019605358,
0.059364818,
-0.0053510722,
-0.0053687776,
0.0427395105,
-0.0427834429,
-0.0122161899,
0.0251209084,
0.0619332157,
0.0322063901,
0.0058056964,
-0.0421953388,
0.0400788002,
-0.0254784506,
-0.0474336296,
0.0130249439,
0.0375819802,
-0.0513963401,
0.010953255,
-0.0011968833,
-0.0271207076,
-0.021719588,
0.0588021763,
0.0271784831,
0.0148439826,
-0.0559938885,
-0.0314932242,
0.0138280923,
-0.0404450744,
-0.0304148085,
0.0021955457,
-0.027507104,
-0.0343667977,
-0.0039020022,
-0.0468982458,
-0.0448543541,
0.0564391352,
-0.0126981288,
0.0074921451,
0.0445653386,
-0.0066683274,
-0.0447693393,
0.0615365691,
-0.0003773208,
-0.0048593604,
0.0063775438,
-0.0166226272,
0.0137611106,
0.0177560076,
-0.0242330693,
0.0090110004,
0.0379536264,
-0.0124676218,
-0.003935304,
-0.0351296924,
0.0322588272,
-0.0045549809,
0.0017351537,
-0.0401340276,
-0.0031427874,
0.0499328375,
0.0000019004,
-0.0097171869,
0.0746508464,
-0.0016880387,
-0.0224218145,
0.0133031253,
0.0340039879,
0.0248441193,
0.0294461232,
0.0094024111,
-0.0469158106,
0.0039032584,
0.0507762171,
-0.0063492353,
0.0438542441,
0.0008653124,
-0.0573818088,
-0.0407896712,
-0.0295174289,
-0.0002308005,
-0.0175298396,
-0.002220626,
-0.0266607758,
-0.0021528234,
-0.0340457968,
-0.0417841151,
0.0762878433,
-0.0483403094,
0.0195279829,
-0.054060977,
0.0282599274,
0.0067731994,
0.0095145963,
-0.023826953,
-0.0286111832,
-0.0131667284,
-0.0059811836,
-0.0155458227,
0.0536759868,
-0.0193135459,
0.0454932302,
0.0251372196,
0.0199029651,
0.0193710066,
0.0335774906,
-0.0343336016,
-0.0105776433,
0.0047709136,
-0.0071812416,
0.0132362414,
0.0119113829,
0.0041328189,
0.0070670946,
-0.02243606,
-0.0156798307,
0.0479784384,
-0.0021320924,
-0.0084619168,
0.0221551489,
0.0131547451,
-0.039586775,
0.0069355597,
0.0226755776,
-0.0086621596,
0.0011949438,
-0.0214339178,
-0.0413252823,
-0.0033785107,
-0.0506148674,
-0.0158747733,
-0.0046984963,
-0.017595917,
-0.0431441851,
-0.1145571992,
-0.0286706071,
-0.0217089392,
0.0058861785,
0.0054828082,
0.0188627653,
-0.0183354151,
0.0810881481,
0.0081114126,
-0.0180408079,
-0.0621942803,
0.0313492268,
0.0157778878,
0.0075081508,
-0.0160445049,
-5.414951829e-33,
-0.0156013845,
-0.0546159223,
-0.0294135045,
-0.0067986338,
0.0037856766,
-0.0052291132,
-0.0090527153,
0.0061756414,
-0.0435645208,
0.0328802876,
0.0065817195,
0.0372612476,
0.0269642789,
-0.0151725048,
0.0192181375,
-0.033454299,
0.0115754092,
0.0482205972,
-0.0274135228,
0.0177575629,
0.0285012387,
-0.0374867506,
0.0454357862,
-0.1310073286,
0.0783971995,
0.0689714253,
-0.0132011184,
-0.0346616246,
-0.0307744779,
0.0512926988,
-0.022517046,
0.0801864341,
0.0304816663,
-0.0514778048,
0.0252719391,
0.0058575305,
-0.0690489113,
0.0092600109,
0.0454224236,
-0.0331146494,
0.0251156874,
-0.0277519599,
0.0077030421,
0.0393489674,
-0.0506130941,
-0.0088261766,
0.043603465,
-0.0361083001,
-0.0496762954,
-0.0481704064,
-0.0675586984,
0.0693853274,
-0.022200698,
0.0054992386,
-0.0147721888,
-0.0025759882,
0.0000691162,
0.0489157513,
-0.0933500752,
0.0225139149,
-0.0174421035,
-0.0140089216,
0.0307214651,
-0.0778281242,
-0.0185227096,
0.0806061774,
0.003140945,
0.0645066202,
-0.0565087907,
-0.001528124,
-0.0130426399,
0.0702570006,
0.063625671,
0.0433877483,
0.026270818,
-0.0153116975,
-0.0675603226,
-0.0015550471,
-0.0006544183,
0.0074277483,
0.0232695248,
-0.0110192588,
-0.0348531529,
-0.0188010931,
-0.0424114689,
-0.0549666993,
-0.0083966618,
0.023840528,
0.0137705049,
-0.015381516,
0.0152216619,
0.0179719273,
-0.0102558956,
-0.0060896967,
0.0550194494,
0.0100084748,
0.0022941635,
0.0219462514,
0.0003408816,
0.0105876653,
-0.0378261134,
-0.0487386622,
0.0011607662,
-0.0261639748,
0.0501450226,
-0.0292578656,
0.0619614609,
-0.0465896465,
-0.0343027189,
-0.0097758621,
-0.0292701181,
0.0210798774,
0.0003908548,
-0.0041181073,
0.0338091142,
0.0439850166,
0.0072876392,
0.0319751762,
0.0206098054,
0.0047968761,
-0.0165054686,
-0.008442631,
-0.0343045481,
0.0088185472,
0.0375398397,
-0.0282958392,
0.0089877043,
0.0313723534,
0.0313702822,
0.0543926619,
0.0115350997,
0.0296557397,
2.452e-7,
0.0655853376,
0.0110470969,
-0.0118710762,
-0.0270409174,
-0.0026673628,
0.0654091537,
0.0295696482,
0.0268606804,
0.0100143356,
-0.0840270743,
-0.012927074,
-0.0098615605,
0.075860098,
0.0508311205,
0.0068494948,
-0.0420089588,
-0.0001693055,
-0.018436579,
-0.0574609824,
0.0700246915,
0.087442629,
0.0699388683,
0.0323877744,
0.0104651619,
-0.0319775529,
0.0308636352,
0.0562079698,
-0.0428732932,
-0.0377899967,
0.0079850778,
0.1009578779,
-0.0668885335,
0.0104713012,
0.0698301792,
0.00074299,
0.0133032501,
-0.013718551,
0.0374637693,
0.0064346963,
0.024032427,
-0.0645164102,
-0.0490728132,
0.0195282903,
-0.0516434051,
0.0350590311,
-0.0285121016,
-0.0502039865,
-0.0217540022,
-0.035363961,
0.0006977374,
0.0385142602,
0.0318203717,
-0.02418519,
-0.0007999957,
-0.0016948256,
-0.0016832439,
0.0249876976,
-0.0928165242,
-0.0274656676,
0.0675191209,
-0.0248120558,
0.0137614179,
0.0305218492,
-0.0059571397,
0.0970399007,
-0.0644443855,
0.0347539969,
2.028121041e-34,
0.0207169075,
0.0340034626,
0.0020315738,
0.0097592277,
0.042227041,
0.0421553999,
0.0089141363,
-0.0155373355,
0.0054986328,
0.0042205714,
0.0523777232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11877v2 | The Curious Case of Hallucinatory (Un)answerability: Finding Truths in the Hidden States of Over-Confident Large Language Models | 2023-10-18T11:01:09 | 2023-11-12T13:14:36 | Aviv Slobodkin, Omer Goldman, Avi Caciularu, Ido Dagan, Shauli Ravfogel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been shown to possess impressive
capabilities, while also raising crucial concerns about the faithfulness of
their responses. A primary issue arising in this context is the management of
(un)answerable queries by LLMs, which often results in hallucinatory behavior
due to overconfidence. In this paper, we explore the behavior of LLMs when
presented with (un)answerable queries. We ask: do models represent the fact
that the question is (un)answerable when generating a hallucinatory answer? Our
results show strong indications that such models encode the answerability of an
input query, with the representation of the first decoded token often being a
strong indicator. These findings shed new light on the spatial organization
within the latent representations of LLMs, unveiling previously unexplored
facets of these models. Moreover, they pave the way for the development of
improved decoding techniques with better adherence to factual generation,
particularly in scenarios where query (un)answerability is a concern. | [
0.068917267,
0.087690182,
-0.0393044092,
0.0416500159,
-0.0455424599,
0.0064171585,
-0.0422881395,
0.0028498264,
-0.0169169083,
-0.0327922404,
-0.0037967027,
-0.0379212052,
-0.0078878365,
-0.0084905308,
0.0266219955,
0.0078058993,
0.0199603159,
-0.0603084713,
-0.0019397847,
-0.0439219624,
-0.031631697,
-0.0150778592,
0.0087170741,
0.0424869545,
0.020495275,
-0.025320055,
-0.0091581233,
-0.0053929817,
-0.0657053292,
0.0025065287,
-0.0269610863,
0.0505673513,
-0.0341769867,
0.0796089396,
0.0000018841,
-0.032471735,
0.0012336256,
-0.0048795133,
-0.029212473,
0.039126616,
-0.0099224793,
0.0035479807,
0.0034366685,
0.0173875932,
-0.0280533098,
-0.0426000692,
0.0504038893,
0.0662064701,
0.0330355763,
0.0646813512,
0.0217792727,
-0.0277872365,
0.0490235463,
0.0170261841,
0.0469933301,
-0.0114786318,
0.0466590859,
0.0271483548,
0.0138650304,
0.0209099017,
-0.0437629186,
0.0327036865,
0.0118998969,
0.0004003659,
-0.0335956402,
0.010611916,
-0.0446673185,
-0.0397105291,
0.0140721742,
0.0116396556,
-0.0127676204,
-0.0427914634,
0.004892251,
0.0229869541,
0.0021495682,
0.0524216667,
-0.0405802727,
0.0430105627,
-0.009607845,
0.0070351264,
0.0312862955,
0.0083846143,
0.0359970108,
-0.0224417336,
-0.065029338,
0.1199920997,
0.025666872,
-0.0308037903,
-0.0294702817,
-0.0221769344,
-0.0151675278,
-0.0739953443,
-0.0075276205,
0.027435014,
-0.0511449054,
0.0197591428,
-0.0053610373,
0.0341495723,
0.040454179,
-0.0647551641,
-0.0004137411,
0.0160724428,
-0.0246481299,
0.066428721,
-0.0210070051,
0.0419571623,
-0.074229531,
0.0379499234,
-0.0468826182,
-0.0217894036,
-0.0015969734,
-0.0428541414,
-0.0183202159,
0.0481037386,
0.0105849886,
-0.0095395502,
0.0127814664,
0.024393538,
-0.0081216702,
0.0169327874,
-0.0365104005,
0.0413351506,
0.0158433206,
-0.0384276547,
-0.029952541,
0.0234908815,
-0.0148679549,
0.0067220079,
-0.031940531,
-0.0855868384,
0.0036758529,
0.0125854798,
-0.0258119889,
-0.0204336382,
-0.0009440694,
0.0560872592,
0.0244566593,
0.002316375,
-0.0055056601,
-0.034004759,
-0.0143753337,
-0.0479323007,
0.0246605519,
-0.0503158271,
-0.0005975426,
0.0537557341,
-0.0107975882,
-0.0327155478,
0.0160208009,
0.0259184614,
-0.0454508811,
0.0631703436,
0.0194269493,
0.048637718,
0.0275383648,
0.0068665738,
-0.0052341712,
0.0642327294,
0.0044637029,
0.0596415028,
0.0269788969,
-0.0201616082,
0.0906255841,
0.0121573415,
0.0229166113,
0.0152123692,
-0.0319607034,
0.044404842,
0.0181244016,
0.0049821427,
-0.0117203668,
0.0780657828,
-0.0184255559,
-0.0495766625,
0.0617086478,
0.0281163137,
-0.0059996871,
0.0066558495,
0.0234166794,
-0.0096251788,
0.0012302921,
0.0720576048,
-0.0545127355,
0.0171740856,
-0.0513023734,
-0.0019730406,
0.0554249436,
-0.0053186286,
-0.0180267096,
-0.0425244197,
-0.0077725896,
0.0346980467,
-0.0213283859,
0.0349005535,
0.0249336474,
-0.0188145731,
-0.0395527482,
0.0332846977,
-0.0006254036,
0.0076409504,
0.0178261846,
-0.0697369576,
0.0316826701,
0.0214081891,
0.0539328456,
-0.0054779523,
0.0422800966,
0.0077692335,
0.0185863134,
0.0327835009,
0.034028504,
0.0096287737,
-0.0247694068,
-0.0013582889,
0.0171505827,
0.0073664542,
0.0526094064,
-0.0233079176,
-0.0360084586,
0.0081718285,
-0.0114114769,
-0.0440624952,
-0.021884894,
0.0262241941,
-0.0095760515,
-0.0536948368,
-0.0284691583,
-0.017309621,
0.0166866817,
-0.0104958722,
-0.0075932248,
0.0754760951,
0.0212347824,
-0.0312006716,
-0.0470398702,
-0.0213877764,
-0.0306050349,
0.0106484657,
0.012609832,
-0.0279516168,
0.0052877055,
0.004208033,
0.0267430861,
-0.0277143791,
0.0242629703,
-0.0615819171,
0.0829610899,
-0.0223856755,
0.0471101813,
-0.0043158093,
0.0106713353,
-0.0333027914,
0.0754698291,
-0.0386324115,
0.0499449186,
-0.0100897932,
-0.0105784256,
-0.0006048809,
-0.0004254192,
-0.0324054994,
0.0354532376,
0.007567517,
0.0284172576,
0.011646064,
-0.0599014461,
-0.0315099321,
-0.0451198854,
-0.0504255816,
-0.0097210314,
-0.0183303077,
-0.0170546938,
0.018043967,
-0.018299602,
-0.0139793418,
-0.0079362327,
-0.0332258306,
-0.0065263365,
0.0344099402,
0.0571538471,
0.0046728635,
0.0000325172,
-0.0297441259,
-0.0055803298,
-0.0177068375,
-0.0163055211,
0.0555474237,
-0.0433867984,
-0.0196485259,
-0.0703608617,
0.0449393988,
-0.0384093411,
0.0239617974,
-0.0106530245,
-0.0175245125,
0.0246653929,
-0.038691435,
-0.0026098355,
0.0486775562,
0.024474591,
0.0273941755,
0.0622127056,
-0.0161047466,
-0.0375942849,
-0.0220850483,
-0.0415757895,
-0.0477916338,
-0.0236609075,
-0.0759301707,
0.0121800583,
0.0480718501,
0.060869053,
-0.0037792898,
-0.0796558931,
0.0488068312,
-0.0591055825,
-0.0464971587,
-0.0213108584,
-0.0025567953,
-0.0050477232,
0.0765534267,
0.0062127556,
-0.0624289513,
0.0619245358,
-0.0112715317,
0.004864933,
0.0056920471,
0.0020167315,
-0.0088788075,
0.0527358279,
0.0202017017,
0.0244847443,
-0.0055476404,
-0.0439303666,
-0.0385389812,
-0.0162371397,
-0.0419051163,
-0.0605559908,
0.0150099862,
-0.0211282596,
-0.0203689188,
0.024504222,
-0.0214320552,
-0.0509169996,
-0.0447774343,
-0.0367246605,
-0.0346046947,
-0.0122843832,
-0.0114588495,
-0.0342299342,
0.0033101637,
0.0092207724,
-0.0205232278,
-0.0339996479,
-0.0212690067,
-0.0230259113,
-0.0042722924,
0.0951441824,
0.0264513101,
0.064802222,
-0.0158788916,
0.0061427639,
0.0852492154,
0.0182629544,
0.0339519791,
0.0214128476,
0.0061571971,
0.0432639197,
0.0037685875,
-0.0336614586,
0.0399994701,
0.0257760379,
-0.0186754148,
-0.0288347006,
0.0750320852,
0.0631891862,
-0.006779654,
0.0268145502,
-0.0687523931,
0.0326276384,
0.007177107,
0.01479901,
-0.0490712747,
0.0096126525,
-0.0074111014,
0.0007784473,
-0.0533060096,
-0.0348974653,
-0.0245905276,
-0.1011436954,
0.021920355,
0.0246250369,
0.0062097497,
-0.0323613212,
-0.0172151178,
-0.0017518642,
0.01970906,
0.0312960744,
0.0370747782,
0.0066918405,
0.0071935989,
0.0131102763,
-0.0052908631,
-0.0027132493,
0.0228027608,
-0.0035998372,
0.07303413,
0.0531382486,
0.0160890054,
-0.0139596974,
-0.0499037504,
-0.0115329968,
-0.0096067525,
-0.0193775501,
-0.0014670205,
-0.0023417787,
0.027320521,
-0.0063508959,
-0.0330709741,
0.0116491448,
-0.0535066277,
0.0091966856,
0.017941989,
0.0836076587,
-0.0557554439,
-0.066550307,
-0.0249909293,
0.0117044533,
-0.0033156113,
0.0841729492,
0.022830978,
-0.0251191612,
-0.0589628741,
-0.0649197549,
0.0166543722,
0.0283641983,
-0.0665509254,
0.0455899797,
0.0981613025,
0.0098272702,
-0.0501911268,
-0.0306188762,
-0.0063502626,
0.0127262808,
-0.002591243,
0.0327943377,
0.0163442753,
-0.0270976815,
0.0022959437,
-0.0158692431,
-0.0396060012,
-0.0058038095,
-0.0576454625,
0.0347424969,
0.0252015069,
-0.0445835888,
-0.0066974498,
-0.0330794938,
-0.0418843664,
-0.061584428,
0.0618745796,
0.0156597178,
0.0395269468,
-0.0306860413,
-0.0142535362,
-0.0714688599,
0.0245633312,
0.0209407508,
-0.0375654213,
0.0321149975,
0.0166170336,
0.012375501,
0.0148661435,
0.0582435727,
-0.0256307311,
-0.0117731299,
0.0076123602,
0.035942398,
-0.0269861538,
-0.022710802,
0.0686737224,
0.0285481103,
0.0124235013,
0.0465146117,
0.0006027025,
0.022388164,
0.0115545075,
-0.0370154791,
-0.0187437125,
-0.0088936482,
0.0002143934,
0.0495806076,
0.014619316,
-0.0103361914,
-0.0656819195,
-0.019881539,
0.0345374383,
-0.0124844844,
-0.0264912713,
0.0215452965,
-0.0058343802,
0.0525499284,
-0.0085898601,
-0.0138653889,
0.056615226,
0.0008742387,
0.0701337829,
0.0247126631,
0.0582144894,
0.0012989991,
-0.0234508347,
-0.0457154587,
0.0056052902,
-0.099252142,
-0.1238893643,
0.014893488,
0.0202646311,
0.0128464168,
-0.0061785406,
0.0271932371,
-0.0419790819,
0.0093498966,
-0.0285308175,
-0.0090915421,
0.0692360029,
-0.0306094959,
0.0257240552,
0.0225610845,
-0.0292362999,
-0.0028911,
0.0712004006,
-0.0003527684,
0.0404240601,
0.0041291369,
-0.0166032929,
-0.0130521841,
-0.0491510145,
-0.0155376289,
0.0108373966,
-0.0247789714,
-0.0005229348,
-0.0840755329,
-0.0475270525,
-0.0399996825,
0.0038148961,
0.0040181396,
-0.0486241579,
-0.0337401144,
0.0936742499,
0.0292651486,
-0.0288313925,
-0.0635460764,
0.0451525114,
0.021006003,
0.021304993,
-0.0367406011,
-6.50548255e-33,
0.0107649704,
-0.053239394,
0.0147344405,
-0.0574335344,
0.0151716415,
-0.0302247182,
-0.0078617018,
0.0195722263,
-0.0485583134,
-0.0046355361,
-0.0395051576,
0.014514653,
0.0071452907,
0.0364092067,
0.0294172,
-0.0416776426,
0.0249351319,
0.0156971142,
-0.0214243196,
0.0069037313,
0.064844884,
-0.0296731088,
-0.0021291585,
-0.0696403012,
0.0531231537,
-0.0517648384,
-0.000087186,
0.061091464,
-0.0444562547,
0.0242852457,
-0.0565723702,
0.0493585505,
0.0166983455,
-0.0294054691,
-0.0048931292,
-0.0075127417,
0.0137049407,
-0.0262721069,
0.0480413549,
0.0217303671,
-0.0041468251,
-0.0287729055,
0.0163059924,
-0.0220477451,
-0.0219422709,
0.0115786158,
-0.0038619256,
-0.0100239851,
-0.0116501395,
0.0232720301,
-0.0411436744,
0.0060558743,
0.0147406114,
0.0125880558,
-0.0031608762,
0.0306971706,
0.0039517009,
-0.008456056,
-0.0408890992,
0.0264295265,
0.0206739828,
0.0268479139,
0.0516503155,
0.0085936468,
0.0146272425,
0.0526371598,
0.058500573,
0.0233235694,
-0.0417524241,
0.0108482288,
-0.0071388362,
0.040911071,
0.0448270142,
-0.0062860958,
0.0352031551,
0.0048147854,
-0.0273319967,
-0.0240661968,
-0.0355351046,
0.0049647074,
0.0640587956,
-0.0094718346,
-0.0675209835,
-0.0469977111,
-0.0311620068,
0.0227126963,
-0.0472374633,
-0.0192126222,
0.0255831927,
-0.0100276349,
-0.0371621437,
-0.0333620757,
0.0444925316,
-0.0660655573,
-0.0425534397,
0.0059993472,
-0.0131920446,
0.0080810506,
0.0017183638,
0.0517506823,
0.0050388267,
0.0105707571,
-0.0049266773,
-0.0446606204,
-0.0166950338,
0.0489857048,
-0.0394358523,
0.0101801474,
-0.0618533157,
-0.01196355,
-0.0225278269,
-0.004901391,
-0.0049374998,
-0.0360926129,
0.081210725,
0.0088431099,
-0.0136142261,
-0.0174301937,
0.0131927393,
0.0216567144,
-0.0440065525,
0.0418112986,
-0.0260802787,
0.0147842187,
-0.0333037116,
-0.0351563245,
-0.0683038086,
0.0180385914,
0.0439243428,
-0.0644116178,
-0.0092878044,
0.0017993195,
2.67e-7,
0.0314256363,
0.0570859723,
0.0053713992,
0.0322918855,
0.0344088599,
0.0330567509,
0.0000744382,
0.0231082682,
0.0564146861,
-0.0674514994,
-0.021046849,
-0.0079889204,
0.0158269685,
0.0560365058,
-0.0493937247,
-0.0085958708,
-0.0333587937,
0.0084274011,
-0.0401571952,
0.0076808212,
0.0576374941,
0.0933140442,
-0.0021696081,
0.0057783634,
0.0047096414,
-0.0445267186,
0.0344494358,
-0.0086351335,
0.005443438,
0.0249061938,
0.0251482576,
-0.0020642839,
0.0583246611,
0.0231927447,
0.0310736876,
-0.015065656,
-0.0002766986,
0.0390907899,
0.0309346076,
-0.0665036663,
-0.0360039547,
-0.0388794914,
0.00625135,
-0.0929786637,
0.0736491755,
-0.0309106801,
-0.0391011983,
-0.0043903729,
0.0108920056,
-0.0108466214,
0.0168789644,
-0.0052840258,
-0.0134675363,
0.0032170496,
0.0205239169,
0.040358562,
0.0442925505,
-0.0283098016,
-0.0285581853,
-0.043168541,
-0.0521734916,
-0.0569664352,
-0.016307408,
0.0502674021,
0.0022153568,
-0.0564277805,
0.0064945049,
2.699372626e-34,
0.0416750982,
0.0159413684,
0.0355090052,
-0.0040569482,
0.0249677952,
-0.0062303399,
0.0188550446,
0.0346714631,
0.0478381701,
-0.0926792771,
-0.0354582071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11870v1 | AI Nushu: An Exploration of Language Emergence in Sisterhood -Through the Lens of Computational Linguistics | 2023-10-18T10:36:52 | 2023-10-18T10:36:52 | Yuqian Sun, Yuying Tang, Ze Gao, Zhijun Pan, Chuyan Xu, Yurou Chen, Kejiang Qian, Zhigang Wang, Tristan Braud, Chang Hee Lee, Ali Asadipour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 14J60 (Primary) 14F05, 14J26 (Secondary), F.2.2; I.2.7 | This paper presents "AI Nushu," an emerging language system inspired by Nushu
(women's scripts), the unique language created and used exclusively by ancient
Chinese women who were thought to be illiterate under a patriarchal society. In
this interactive installation, two artificial intelligence (AI) agents are
trained in the Chinese dictionary and the Nushu corpus. By continually
observing their environment and communicating, these agents collaborate towards
creating a standard writing system to encode Chinese. It offers an artistic
interpretation of the creation of a non-western script from a computational
linguistics perspective, integrating AI technology with Chinese cultural
heritage and a feminist viewpoint. | [
0.0415364392,
0.057621371,
-0.0560356863,
0.0105292862,
-0.0322164446,
0.0313721783,
0.0219293181,
0.0123372003,
0.0260447636,
-0.0041695777,
0.0029341758,
-0.0668322593,
0.0580998957,
0.0176247433,
-0.0082396585,
-0.0123501662,
-0.0137892086,
0.04207002,
0.0214477032,
-0.0090554263,
0.0258032531,
0.019322522,
0.0151038533,
0.0605328381,
-0.0173265114,
-0.0516622439,
-0.0365852863,
0.0006988493,
-0.0452679731,
0.0122224055,
-0.0138103385,
0.006145482,
0.0141268205,
0.0538024828,
0.0000016983,
-0.0722556859,
0.0120644318,
-0.0433053598,
-0.0074782814,
-0.0162626151,
0.0764456913,
0.0141520398,
-0.0484695286,
-0.0090331081,
-0.0490258597,
0.028721204,
0.0742775127,
0.0521832742,
0.0292429961,
0.0266849548,
-0.0116050048,
-0.0343237333,
0.0057283617,
0.0028882415,
-0.0316709168,
0.0181729104,
-0.0085445885,
-0.0176164694,
0.053919401,
-0.0107405074,
-0.0435339287,
0.0349620245,
-0.0112339808,
-0.0529454648,
-0.084819831,
0.0468318313,
-0.0204537734,
-0.0638884678,
-0.0337392092,
0.0039516953,
0.0532916784,
0.0100887576,
0.011794935,
0.0198862012,
-0.0228791311,
-0.0018031701,
-0.0268866885,
0.023569556,
-0.0320487358,
0.0196321104,
0.0539079867,
-0.0408219732,
0.0213370044,
0.0327783749,
0.0260973386,
0.0406715684,
0.0048139789,
-0.0237280764,
0.0045397333,
-0.0353725292,
0.0233034603,
-0.048584938,
0.0025666424,
0.0247429758,
0.0014546628,
0.0253100079,
0.0397173017,
-0.0116556482,
-0.0248223469,
-0.0294424295,
0.0642585531,
0.0315708593,
0.002714586,
-0.000818677,
-0.0226478502,
0.0005074751,
0.0573897362,
-0.007279411,
-0.0361159332,
0.0004290075,
-0.046022106,
-0.0395527408,
-0.0562320985,
0.0054275072,
-0.032705918,
-0.0072491262,
0.0093491375,
0.0019655623,
-0.0209061075,
0.0413327292,
-0.0082835862,
-0.0011659887,
0.0335499346,
0.0024788829,
0.0137240672,
0.0009612613,
-0.0375499874,
0.0050750333,
-0.0388599671,
-0.0772335008,
0.0225917418,
0.0106645739,
0.0109595079,
0.0271018073,
0.0097537618,
0.0266953576,
-0.0305771474,
-0.0304516759,
0.0077724867,
0.0373975225,
-0.0313932635,
-0.0253768619,
-0.0058321203,
-0.0174906384,
0.01573167,
0.0306265131,
0.0155972196,
-0.0871897861,
0.0358795784,
0.0025588502,
0.0506764241,
0.020203013,
0.0278385021,
0.004473608,
0.0584026314,
0.0069858064,
0.0170500111,
0.0394735411,
0.1168233976,
0.0145342797,
0.0438988879,
0.0100042038,
0.020736035,
-0.0046986127,
-0.0030431291,
0.0403044485,
-0.0396433882,
0.0005223115,
-0.0030071696,
0.0363556221,
-0.0375437401,
0.0361473784,
0.025676202,
0.0173872877,
0.0266725272,
0.0865234882,
0.0181109104,
0.0750059485,
0.0322304443,
-0.0020971552,
-0.0320480466,
-0.0181502681,
0.0098774917,
0.0253071766,
0.0174132064,
-0.0231158491,
-0.0391177423,
-0.0075214179,
-0.0041307514,
-0.0704637766,
-0.0079051862,
-0.0226734318,
0.0314554721,
-0.0086569358,
0.0174201131,
0.0376337953,
0.0070150471,
-0.0461351126,
0.0233294368,
-0.059421435,
0.0076575666,
-0.063515164,
0.0354239978,
0.108586736,
0.00318478,
-0.0122917593,
0.0793674737,
0.008615871,
0.0122259911,
0.0543327108,
-0.0394535363,
-0.0055496548,
-0.0014430291,
-0.0257205423,
0.0285793133,
0.0174429268,
-0.013400929,
0.0197365712,
-0.0631286353,
0.0331457555,
0.0129883308,
0.0571531318,
-0.0940955281,
0.0193960611,
-0.0741522089,
-0.0243769754,
-0.0321768261,
0.0031772205,
-0.003751446,
0.0390401855,
-0.0705094934,
0.0266703516,
0.021782551,
-0.0334780775,
-0.0568211675,
0.062144395,
0.0136602633,
0.0236201882,
0.0419670157,
-0.1039314941,
0.0062590074,
0.0287089646,
0.0234603677,
-0.0373402052,
0.0552164167,
-0.0403904356,
-0.0148794036,
-0.0596057624,
0.0194135197,
-0.0267226584,
0.0037384825,
-0.0112735676,
0.0096132578,
-0.0273159109,
0.0044719735,
-0.0086863441,
-0.0043412987,
0.0236711018,
0.0023326825,
-0.0296580363,
0.0446404926,
0.0371712632,
0.0511619672,
0.0168429576,
0.0155957025,
0.0005505974,
-0.0615263246,
-0.0946687683,
-0.0416417867,
-0.002203173,
-0.057463266,
-0.0286736321,
-0.0041892333,
-0.0333649702,
0.0076845852,
-0.0383074842,
0.0445046388,
-0.0059187491,
-0.0358363315,
0.0262951702,
-0.0270901714,
-0.0057369764,
-0.0162185598,
-0.0000478299,
-0.0045090592,
0.007936039,
0.0853294209,
-0.0249715429,
-0.0354512148,
-0.0532219112,
-0.035225682,
-0.0265120752,
-0.013323334,
-0.02076515,
0.0069290469,
-0.0155441836,
-0.0308381915,
0.0168702155,
-0.0315258168,
0.0274248496,
0.0593678765,
0.0072085639,
0.0407643206,
-0.0097624557,
0.0630879179,
0.0108360406,
0.0057391385,
-0.0480192415,
-0.0338145606,
0.0113368053,
0.0118476395,
0.0081588915,
-0.0067371,
0.0102496874,
-0.0330128297,
-0.0026295783,
-0.0006181578,
-0.0588410869,
-0.0140075712,
0.0268845875,
-0.0350200646,
-0.0080669308,
0.0405291505,
-0.011178188,
-0.070407033,
-0.0175927114,
-0.0444247238,
-0.0260177143,
0.0801534802,
-0.0032667648,
0.0429085717,
0.0179154221,
0.0017816615,
-0.0518486202,
0.0464224629,
-0.0043929932,
-0.0194730684,
-0.0272988621,
0.0047384561,
0.0191883668,
-0.0238142759,
-0.0070165293,
-0.0101786368,
-0.0029096471,
-0.0232327636,
0.0045480425,
0.0273202378,
0.0141520416,
0.0560601838,
0.0508246459,
-0.0157172084,
0.0397599861,
0.0315706991,
0.0273706242,
-0.0393031649,
-0.0093161631,
0.0145672699,
0.0261898674,
-0.0417609066,
-0.0081706839,
0.0519696698,
0.0050291973,
-0.0307692178,
0.0176195838,
0.0058348887,
0.0227620974,
0.0425341651,
-0.0033850677,
-0.0149021996,
-0.020523902,
0.0008540632,
-0.0360179804,
0.0145959761,
0.0554072075,
0.021230353,
-0.0322038718,
0.0196041744,
-0.0233806707,
-0.0174151734,
0.0324898064,
0.009605214,
-0.1000258252,
0.0424021818,
0.0355458483,
0.015344969,
-0.0086773913,
-0.0263060555,
-0.0064925901,
-0.1232199743,
0.0017250597,
0.0197087787,
-0.0192824379,
-0.0118004335,
0.0155033171,
-0.0156430583,
0.0471673571,
-0.0031990327,
0.0222928394,
0.02870946,
-0.009909058,
-0.0264225528,
0.0317528285,
0.0102307424,
-0.0158440061,
-0.0491087064,
0.0400761031,
0.0333913267,
0.0586410984,
-0.0327998772,
-0.0040671811,
-0.032472726,
-0.0056453133,
0.0406504758,
-0.0205045529,
-0.003061417,
-0.0004143808,
-0.0161670782,
-0.0284737423,
0.0026384054,
0.0096743805,
0.0160478074,
0.0570744723,
-0.0069867652,
-0.0364013016,
-0.0160327088,
-0.0236310642,
-0.0144414576,
0.0397690423,
0.0198456664,
0.0125125954,
-0.0649861842,
-0.0297953282,
-0.0579250418,
0.0129935239,
0.0342575535,
-0.0644645244,
0.0069053294,
-0.0119441338,
-0.0567439422,
-0.1348109543,
-0.0693030134,
-0.0360473245,
0.0448678583,
0.0691058934,
-0.0391085707,
0.0377623476,
0.0594599955,
-0.0968875736,
-0.0666814819,
0.0135237817,
0.0041471636,
-0.0191858634,
-0.0567484982,
-0.0229875315,
-0.0448589921,
0.0312232785,
0.0202887971,
0.0055814241,
-0.044566758,
0.0355446935,
0.0391201489,
0.0198501926,
-0.0362153649,
0.000499067,
-0.0127423238,
0.0029827978,
-0.003716433,
0.0064755566,
0.0235968344,
0.0135490606,
-0.0402929857,
-0.0124784615,
0.0276416037,
0.0152035505,
0.018749034,
-0.021423433,
-0.0297571346,
-0.0392044522,
-0.0072632632,
0.0058345259,
0.0190824699,
-0.0507032834,
-0.0676332563,
-0.0108455876,
-0.0203767605,
0.0067209173,
-0.0512216501,
-0.0199454557,
-0.0245382618,
-0.0435334891,
-0.0110184615,
-0.000627906,
0.0217861328,
0.0083547421,
0.0445992239,
-0.0382582843,
-0.0360638648,
0.0403144956,
0.0381919108,
0.1355130225,
-0.0613932908,
0.0300993156,
0.0323533267,
0.079542771,
-0.0299000051,
0.0292249359,
0.0145844854,
0.0112584326,
-0.011549212,
-0.0222893674,
0.0346781425,
0.0237165261,
-0.0122517068,
-0.100474298,
0.0200871155,
0.0128142172,
0.0618775748,
-0.0125341583,
0.0387464762,
-0.017002916,
0.0126859443,
-0.0001036103,
0.0156663768,
0.0286837723,
-0.0417441987,
-0.0684944838,
0.0155860456,
-0.0045711934,
-0.0138805741,
0.0130896121,
-0.0453138389,
0.0385053828,
0.0534363426,
-0.0371318497,
-0.0264000297,
-0.0299535617,
0.0065296167,
-0.0245352406,
0.0183615852,
0.0267347228,
-0.036931064,
-0.037399482,
-0.0029454154,
-0.0150685748,
0.0221516937,
-0.0202476513,
0.0317454897,
0.0037162055,
-0.0052564712,
-0.0099163866,
-0.0610224828,
0.0397105552,
-0.0320444033,
0.0208405461,
0.0341303684,
-5.538413266e-33,
-0.0496796891,
-0.0503017381,
0.0265537035,
0.0490460657,
-0.0117171723,
-0.0644259602,
-0.0508597791,
0.028925864,
-0.0113624437,
0.0080873203,
-0.0046579274,
0.0366172269,
-0.0092383083,
0.0090671033,
0.0245294366,
0.0340800397,
0.0282026771,
0.0068761325,
-0.006261142,
-0.0321713015,
0.0708956048,
0.0340312384,
0.0117160212,
-0.0745099187,
0.0919150338,
-0.065568693,
-0.030749971,
-0.000863769,
0.0046045724,
-0.0108070076,
0.0121249938,
0.0215378832,
0.0182583444,
0.0224013366,
0.0128450086,
0.0409248695,
-0.0462463386,
-0.0516464859,
-0.0282400455,
0.0414930806,
0.0350071751,
-0.0122438902,
0.0007305841,
-0.0037038904,
-0.035914503,
0.0240648333,
0.0278461911,
-0.0213944428,
0.0285267308,
0.0503342263,
-0.0660712123,
-0.0169620905,
-0.0350618958,
-0.0273046475,
0.0321503356,
-0.0292253606,
-0.0147973271,
-0.0937299132,
-0.0421926267,
0.0469188169,
0.0053392709,
0.0331894904,
0.0040862886,
-0.0071740374,
0.0193424653,
-0.0013138658,
0.1125518382,
0.0066733058,
0.0026790295,
0.0131486049,
0.0240318943,
0.0127042606,
0.0341679081,
0.0547440164,
-0.0183951054,
-0.0391296633,
-0.0291170254,
-0.0253874268,
0.0122541944,
0.0080264378,
-0.0158392172,
0.0361292921,
-0.0349403061,
-0.0506567806,
0.0000595427,
-0.0425842889,
0.02308763,
-0.0158636644,
-0.0330534577,
0.0178068578,
-0.0202103555,
-0.0107799191,
-0.0338695645,
-0.0599241666,
-0.0239174608,
0.0271505862,
-0.0038317468,
0.0053200987,
0.0426098108,
-0.0372075997,
0.0307384543,
-0.0190361328,
-0.0413708761,
0.0146848084,
0.0432792418,
0.0324153937,
-0.0005267298,
0.0550200492,
-0.026507318,
-0.0092326645,
0.0070669875,
-0.0382900089,
0.0509356,
-0.0297525451,
-0.0055637667,
0.0187402721,
-0.0112295523,
-0.0521341078,
0.0817072019,
0.0411050878,
-0.0177710149,
-0.0089285551,
-0.0347738825,
-0.0315618664,
-0.0403643027,
0.0246638115,
-0.0230049677,
0.0628469214,
0.0723845363,
-0.0549047515,
-0.0059729684,
-0.0223996937,
2.726e-7,
0.0216248631,
0.0262792688,
0.0501164831,
0.0529299267,
0.0369632691,
-0.0150037212,
-0.052866362,
0.0270558465,
-0.0173153952,
0.0062608072,
0.0415862314,
0.0364655443,
0.0511714071,
0.0328603573,
-0.0488195419,
0.0545050278,
-0.0373833179,
0.0099790478,
-0.0308383051,
0.0824255124,
-0.0371349417,
0.0464711562,
0.0142808529,
-0.0154951476,
-0.0181961879,
-0.0592405945,
0.003688209,
-0.0198504236,
0.0699197352,
-0.0308828503,
-0.0148462746,
-0.0294511542,
-0.0221937615,
-0.0128590502,
-0.0030157561,
-0.0020304692,
0.0394146554,
0.0487070717,
-0.0356633402,
0.0829996616,
0.0460273549,
0.0304563791,
-0.0290162005,
-0.0148479696,
0.0703525096,
0.0957687199,
-0.0148297381,
-0.039295841,
0.0587818474,
0.0000217317,
0.0380434655,
0.0021407711,
-0.01851869,
0.0174456369,
0.0045821602,
-0.0174757726,
0.0344904587,
-0.0113339871,
-0.0292341541,
0.0138233909,
0.0174865481,
-0.0638967901,
0.0034051412,
-0.0270789973,
0.0050837873,
-0.0425738059,
-0.0201275237,
1.997379108e-34,
-0.009329739,
-0.0621343404,
-0.0109546473,
0.0653776154,
0.0199290272,
-0.0081018107,
-0.0099925585,
0.0034666632,
0.047069706,
0.0283362996,
-0.0447643176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11780v1 | Text Annotation Handbook: A Practical Guide for Machine Learning Projects | 2023-10-18T08:19:53 | 2023-10-18T08:19:53 | Felix Stollenwerk, Joey Öhman, Danila Petrelli, Emma Wallerö, Fredrik Olsson, Camilla Bengtsson, Andreas Horndahl, Gabriela Zarzar Gandler | cs.CL | cs.CL | This handbook is a hands-on guide on how to approach text annotation tasks.
It provides a gentle introduction to the topic, an overview of theoretical
concepts as well as practical advice. The topics covered are mostly technical,
but business, ethical and regulatory issues are also touched upon. The focus
lies on readability and conciseness rather than completeness and scientific
rigor. Experience with annotation and knowledge of machine learning are useful
but not required. The document may serve as a primer or reference book for a
wide range of professions such as team leaders, project managers, IT
architects, software developers and machine learning engineers. | [
0.0370155238,
-0.0384266637,
-0.016329363,
0.0175965093,
-0.0012898959,
0.0140558658,
0.0142173124,
-0.0149329705,
0.0292259157,
-0.0676526129,
0.0509174466,
0.0513153411,
-0.0156880915,
0.0130577963,
0.0278660785,
-0.1027877778,
0.0212989636,
0.0009703613,
0.0197993554,
0.0580838397,
0.0258623865,
0.0167336725,
0.0130228167,
0.063943021,
-0.0623082072,
-0.0238164831,
-0.0098607801,
0.0224166326,
0.0347901359,
-0.0199539848,
-0.0191617347,
0.024383653,
-0.0112513769,
0.0468485132,
0.0000017877,
-0.0586317107,
-0.0323727019,
0.0484930575,
-0.0322906487,
0.0170096382,
0.0417266265,
-0.0037799387,
-0.0015102749,
0.0074683395,
0.0040781093,
0.0498086512,
0.0910873562,
0.0437840782,
0.0812860802,
0.0394279547,
-0.0266123768,
0.0014121697,
-0.0038410579,
0.0244287103,
-0.0069535519,
-0.0179820452,
0.0049671247,
0.0652424246,
-0.0013494563,
0.01060405,
0.0366646536,
0.0487195626,
-0.0021939806,
-0.0348977894,
0.0378818773,
0.0219148099,
-0.0337343477,
-0.011027446,
-0.0036903264,
0.0253043938,
0.0648854598,
0.0167932883,
0.0064137108,
-0.0458529517,
-0.0069934488,
-0.0101129683,
-0.0228621289,
-0.0038477362,
-0.013830821,
0.002843342,
-0.0042322748,
0.0107441796,
-0.0009627004,
-0.000725323,
0.0205326267,
0.0356509201,
-0.0316260494,
-0.0140756248,
0.0205211509,
0.0171450581,
-0.003153119,
-0.0456607789,
0.0265475437,
0.0239508841,
0.0425062962,
-0.0062993309,
-0.0255780853,
-0.0700867027,
0.0568446182,
-0.0802306533,
0.0486150645,
-0.0385075174,
-0.030471636,
0.0582069121,
0.0148377372,
-0.0030166581,
-0.0088709714,
0.0019279703,
0.0087150261,
0.0119967433,
-0.0264982935,
-0.0217588712,
-0.0472829752,
0.0056001577,
0.0004022405,
0.0017656927,
-0.0583563372,
0.0400870778,
0.0048081074,
0.0415718295,
0.0275368504,
-0.0199235659,
-0.0206346381,
0.0202818159,
-0.0022762143,
-0.0450271927,
-0.0293565579,
0.0214848928,
-0.0303857196,
-0.0433991179,
0.0391420834,
0.0606044829,
0.0122366883,
0.0058682631,
-0.0202340223,
0.0419696011,
0.0371926427,
-0.0057855523,
-0.0395708457,
-0.0543828942,
-0.0203039106,
0.0003493912,
-0.021779662,
-0.0421527289,
-0.0430716909,
0.0037472236,
0.0065006195,
-0.0048432737,
-0.0078930305,
0.0285937134,
0.0066332645,
0.0621680506,
-0.0926944762,
-0.0246278252,
0.0493703708,
-0.0223614424,
-0.008521284,
0.0334692486,
0.0595629998,
0.0514557436,
0.0439093485,
-0.0110191889,
0.0252243783,
0.029279571,
-0.0485439226,
-0.0658250228,
-0.0116432132,
-0.0019157138,
-0.0069208797,
-0.0084151337,
-0.0239115972,
0.041374281,
-0.0220051799,
0.0316019244,
0.032911405,
0.0542189591,
0.020673003,
0.008271113,
0.0325838551,
0.0468933433,
0.0073493347,
-0.0407058746,
0.0003678977,
0.0317684487,
-0.0051944689,
0.0070427763,
-0.0343397856,
-0.0220148563,
0.0081720259,
-0.0676140934,
-0.0571349114,
-0.0205099359,
0.002376731,
-0.0137284761,
0.0370138586,
0.0126129026,
-0.0409965143,
-0.050297372,
-0.0189559478,
-0.0314140245,
-0.0100616449,
-0.0054741176,
0.0001895676,
0.0893980265,
0.0150133166,
-0.0717668608,
-0.017367458,
-0.0442754179,
0.0019658988,
-0.0107783573,
0.0255113542,
-0.0359996632,
-0.0218249615,
-0.0469883122,
-0.0476313755,
-0.0032525419,
-0.0049391724,
0.0045433948,
-0.0560231544,
-0.0324127749,
0.0195775628,
-0.0073700789,
-0.0858052894,
0.0669560581,
0.0068966807,
-0.0374751016,
-0.0060034781,
-0.0059560654,
0.0172559451,
0.0863588154,
-0.0176713672,
0.0255244374,
0.0302633792,
0.0171244256,
0.0085934736,
0.0196574796,
0.0561103746,
0.0490217879,
0.0061833272,
-0.0688775554,
-0.0182758588,
-0.0167837292,
-0.0394325443,
-0.0184629187,
-0.0761552379,
-0.0544330366,
0.0103668952,
-0.0364656113,
-0.010749083,
-0.0132618314,
-0.0079835402,
-0.0469323173,
0.0279166475,
0.029573096,
-0.0276572462,
0.0037374706,
-0.0474868007,
0.0539905615,
-0.0344750397,
-0.0425737612,
-0.0260364357,
0.0060838717,
0.02933947,
0.035379041,
-0.0033096338,
-0.026618069,
0.0291639529,
-0.0907822549,
-0.040365126,
0.0001661221,
0.0172666516,
-0.0210645646,
-0.0258152802,
-0.0056789671,
-0.0676010028,
0.0301668104,
-0.0089780437,
-0.0558526516,
-0.0095384028,
0.0698802322,
0.0170560442,
0.0084894784,
-0.0200265702,
-0.0095161693,
-0.0353093334,
0.0378943197,
0.1111175865,
-0.1099049374,
-0.0762383714,
0.0084783537,
0.0104167918,
-0.0246984232,
0.0227580275,
0.0195566714,
0.0219902582,
0.0622184649,
-0.0068077473,
0.0433809794,
-0.0132091995,
0.0274418164,
0.0373416729,
0.0218248423,
-0.0062482548,
-0.0106279962,
0.0150303114,
0.0584621876,
-0.0103541873,
-0.0346417762,
0.0341264382,
0.0193938147,
-0.0357947014,
0.0121451123,
-0.0255190823,
-0.0031365007,
-0.0373774916,
-0.0111553669,
-0.0354688391,
-0.0397045128,
-0.0287449602,
0.065263398,
0.015113188,
-0.0578346141,
0.0667673945,
-0.0240315385,
0.0127535118,
-0.0676246211,
-0.0415801853,
-0.0194687918,
0.0565766841,
-0.0187372081,
0.0013204666,
0.0032796317,
-0.0233579967,
0.0259510521,
0.0073002796,
0.0634653196,
0.0031207115,
-0.0016686978,
-0.0191572513,
0.0237474497,
-0.0197734684,
-0.0013314049,
-0.0276485123,
-0.0447078757,
-0.0693108663,
0.0304389689,
0.0342939906,
0.012713558,
-0.0251499563,
0.0510488749,
0.0283774938,
0.0564092025,
0.0297170542,
-0.004460365,
-0.0003596314,
-0.0197726376,
0.0006014773,
-0.0156703144,
0.0012155694,
-0.0014341959,
-0.0305607226,
0.0125677325,
-0.0394542255,
0.0008100857,
-0.0447656624,
-0.0246316604,
0.0008841339,
-0.0762810186,
-0.0142862163,
0.0190414265,
0.0308750663,
-0.0393560715,
0.0338272601,
0.0649929345,
0.0401308574,
-0.0584865399,
-0.0016137568,
-0.0093842773,
-0.0098269358,
-0.0001089381,
0.0264012422,
-0.0733179078,
0.0164269637,
-0.0220889971,
0.030639207,
-0.018973697,
-0.00610509,
0.0073828804,
-0.0262124501,
0.0510336421,
-0.0184123944,
-0.0470921062,
-0.024433447,
-0.0540812127,
-0.0139332423,
-0.0542838983,
-0.0144785903,
-0.0463792346,
0.0087391539,
-0.0114390617,
0.089536503,
-0.090009816,
-0.0406984948,
-0.0592334569,
-0.0256829243,
0.0384406224,
0.0732633248,
0.0482781157,
-0.0106480699,
0.0153131438,
-0.0117929643,
0.0165787209,
0.0457039401,
-0.0180423614,
0.0982524678,
-0.0222535823,
-0.0037462029,
-0.0208988953,
0.0045053069,
0.018824093,
-0.0411137566,
0.0386628062,
0.0677731037,
-0.0378876589,
0.0272269826,
-0.0452536419,
0.0057586441,
0.0221446455,
0.0244412534,
0.0247983299,
-0.0404836684,
-0.0256996006,
-0.0412495956,
0.0633376688,
-0.0591650158,
0.0002542727,
-0.0055333064,
-0.0925977156,
-0.043788109,
-0.0619222447,
-0.0771148354,
0.0429193638,
0.0241693333,
0.0480674356,
0.0196519252,
0.0052854083,
0.0042428584,
-0.030304784,
-0.0062019569,
0.0082165254,
0.016582489,
0.0177210215,
-0.0307378881,
0.0302736815,
-0.0248177461,
-0.0321397334,
0.029623013,
-0.0278159957,
-0.0245343801,
0.0147457942,
0.0430188812,
0.0109475264,
0.040818356,
-0.003561314,
-0.0976602659,
0.0169633124,
0.0087422319,
0.0174587239,
-0.0518542826,
0.024505103,
0.0092336927,
-0.0235142466,
-0.0234046709,
-0.0224638432,
0.0240294635,
-0.0374578834,
-0.0288521983,
-0.0519468486,
-0.0373399444,
0.0039094859,
0.0078445384,
0.0265255496,
-0.0380045362,
-0.0659035891,
-0.0304726847,
0.0302576367,
-0.0212078001,
-0.0332933217,
-0.0323042907,
0.0239103902,
0.0030837604,
-0.0213071592,
-0.0023844037,
-0.0002551631,
-0.0471072122,
0.0235427003,
-0.0194737073,
0.0663603693,
0.0668087006,
0.062955521,
-0.0525005683,
-0.0037576025,
-0.0281554032,
0.0067331544,
0.0072831227,
0.0137758069,
0.0331489146,
0.0117759677,
0.0109745059,
-0.0043741027,
0.0125489263,
0.0206971504,
-0.0109329643,
0.0384416953,
-0.0375032984,
0.0296506565,
0.0242421757,
0.0008100225,
0.068652004,
-0.0529923029,
-0.0057469127,
0.0035249961,
0.0622295588,
0.018611744,
-0.0050528836,
-0.037320178,
-0.00281122,
-0.0399125479,
-0.0253197588,
0.0205726381,
0.0027778326,
0.0036202879,
-0.0186266489,
-0.0736284256,
-0.0552209243,
0.0040052058,
0.0283068158,
0.0255678222,
-0.0284417551,
-0.0192988459,
-0.0553355105,
-0.0354443043,
0.0295680948,
-0.0038463362,
0.0108563621,
-0.0051049655,
-0.007266066,
0.0426980667,
0.0229977407,
-0.0343771204,
-0.0352758914,
-0.0088712517,
-0.0132877957,
-0.005163352,
-0.0446563587,
-5.014021562e-33,
-0.0361698233,
-0.0687335953,
0.0205857251,
0.0457171313,
0.0012626655,
0.0307068583,
0.0019304651,
-0.0153039508,
0.030884292,
0.0158108119,
0.0135138277,
-0.0003613241,
0.0289931241,
-0.0065872218,
0.0385698415,
0.0104352441,
0.0454084836,
0.0227149855,
-0.0136423782,
-0.0058909142,
0.0147193763,
0.0012132244,
0.0637586713,
-0.1300971508,
0.0933383033,
-0.0230488274,
-0.0388248749,
-0.0183683913,
0.0304479152,
0.0665592179,
-0.0136893438,
-0.0040800269,
0.0323306397,
-0.0140111819,
-0.0163438916,
0.0386090241,
-0.0280754715,
-0.0162614454,
0.0046758987,
0.0474483408,
-0.0114345076,
-0.0385342129,
0.0167913213,
-0.0461524427,
-0.0146239968,
0.0138065191,
0.1008493006,
-0.012575482,
-0.0385744497,
-0.0187323373,
-0.0768109038,
0.0719486624,
-0.0557516143,
0.0346104093,
0.0850826502,
0.05718337,
0.0359519199,
-0.0101592019,
-0.0522253215,
0.0223618094,
0.0047617224,
-0.023467958,
0.0638925657,
0.03534903,
-0.0044134636,
0.0317560509,
-0.006311167,
0.0428014398,
-0.0049853013,
-0.0075823981,
-0.0034125119,
0.0253114067,
0.0503823869,
0.0245972537,
0.000602275,
0.0191697348,
-0.0248028841,
0.0459772013,
0.002914249,
-0.0174531117,
0.0054082614,
-0.0004284038,
-0.0608302876,
-0.0163782891,
-0.0204920601,
-0.0482608005,
0.0139972558,
-0.0402074195,
-0.0052837548,
-0.0316299349,
-0.0482816659,
0.1160080358,
-0.0094021913,
-0.0265110936,
0.0040512094,
-0.0303023253,
0.0251874607,
0.0522153564,
-0.0285103638,
-0.0262857433,
-0.0178501904,
-0.0353149772,
0.017788073,
0.0204050373,
0.0610834286,
-0.0297174603,
0.0742763877,
0.006428624,
-0.0299365465,
-0.0057927985,
0.0394619852,
-0.0205626339,
-0.01849005,
0.0219497755,
0.0146515351,
0.001385556,
-0.0062593492,
0.0223753899,
0.0300947446,
0.0403037593,
0.0103165852,
-0.0294963922,
-0.0111852875,
-0.0300923772,
-0.00557931,
-0.0026958494,
0.0198223088,
0.0129024209,
0.018733941,
-0.0106986295,
-0.0013557957,
0.0307040084,
2.188e-7,
0.0903308466,
0.0817274228,
0.0635454059,
-0.0493098684,
-0.0039872564,
-0.0013186877,
0.0366830491,
-0.0015081189,
-0.0063535203,
0.019553436,
0.0560416915,
-0.0390509404,
0.0366951972,
0.0347739048,
-0.0670842975,
-0.075757578,
-0.0529628024,
-0.0111695891,
-0.0827728808,
0.0469821543,
0.0493441336,
0.0381440818,
0.0236523114,
0.010083193,
-0.0101583097,
-0.0172766782,
-0.0121301813,
-0.0396821611,
0.0274616051,
0.0271627214,
0.0502248891,
-0.0082395673,
-0.0004025807,
0.0513321646,
-0.0251173824,
-0.0214215331,
0.0808359161,
0.0447984375,
-0.0232283585,
0.0321188755,
-0.0039715571,
0.0149971535,
0.0179715194,
-0.0196607895,
0.0186501201,
0.0043882197,
-0.0585064441,
-0.037959259,
-0.0078455089,
-0.0126714734,
0.0556534566,
0.0076985708,
0.043608617,
0.0091592288,
0.0044147493,
-0.0167745706,
-0.0432017818,
-0.0282463413,
-0.0124989487,
-0.0191189386,
0.0008117196,
-0.0177994594,
-0.0081072496,
-0.0164931174,
0.0130034629,
-0.0425505862,
0.0519248433,
1.794244271e-34,
0.0220794585,
-0.0459868237,
-0.0095238257,
0.0561983176,
0.0114896791,
0.0358131155,
0.0029479831,
0.0243051723,
0.0255195014,
-0.0242827777,
0.0045366432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11778v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11778v3 | Language Agents for Detecting Implicit Stereotypes in Text-to-image Models at Scale | 2023-10-18T08:16:29 | 2023-11-02T10:46:41 | Qichao Wang, Tian Bian, Yian Yin, Tingyang Xu, Hong Cheng, Helen M. Meng, Zibin Zheng, Liang Chen, Bingzhe Wu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | The recent surge in the research of diffusion models has accelerated the
adoption of text-to-image models in various Artificial Intelligence Generated
Content (AIGC) commercial products. While these exceptional AIGC products are
gaining increasing recognition and sparking enthusiasm among consumers, the
questions regarding whether, when, and how these models might unintentionally
reinforce existing societal stereotypes remain largely unaddressed. Motivated
by recent advancements in language agents, here we introduce a novel agent
architecture tailored for stereotype detection in text-to-image models. This
versatile agent architecture is capable of accommodating free-form detection
tasks and can autonomously invoke various tools to facilitate the entire
process, from generating corresponding instructions and images, to detecting
stereotypes. We build the stereotype-relevant benchmark based on multiple
open-text datasets, and apply this architecture to commercial products and
popular open source text-to-image models. We find that these models often
display serious stereotypes when it comes to certain prompts about personal
characteristics, social cultural context and crime-related aspects. In summary,
these empirical findings underscore the pervasive existence of stereotypes
across social dimensions, including gender, race, and religion, which not only
validate the effectiveness of our proposed approach, but also emphasize the
critical necessity of addressing potential ethical risks in the burgeoning
realm of AIGC. As AIGC continues its rapid expansion trajectory, with new
models and plugins emerging daily in staggering numbers, the challenge lies in
the timely detection and mitigation of potential biases within these models. | [
0.0579064861,
0.1016908884,
-0.0349943079,
0.0242639035,
-0.0096558854,
0.035944704,
0.0811748505,
-0.0118734511,
0.0716546252,
-0.0850678459,
0.0054482804,
-0.0149959251,
-0.0040045423,
0.0760075375,
-0.0033442238,
-0.021972999,
0.000225274,
0.0338123254,
0.0327385329,
-0.0211395435,
0.0302813053,
0.0663843602,
0.0351179875,
0.0344106294,
-0.0602698438,
-0.0448235869,
0.0551279932,
0.0084703276,
0.011816659,
-0.0059870919,
0.0352287032,
0.0557654761,
0.0063002035,
0.023448566,
0.0000019828,
-0.0586224571,
0.0317671113,
-0.000029692,
0.0011442145,
-0.0027233101,
0.0967194587,
-0.0030879749,
-0.0200441014,
-0.001426786,
-0.046141237,
0.0269296188,
0.0733177364,
0.0461658612,
0.0422760658,
0.020390423,
-0.0271287579,
-0.0347282663,
-0.0595084019,
0.0198111515,
0.0002852397,
0.0211930759,
0.0387705564,
-0.0465043597,
-0.0550666004,
-0.0147251878,
0.0001465562,
0.0236664042,
-0.0025703951,
0.0115439072,
0.0064725392,
0.0238428768,
-0.0274795257,
-0.0702524185,
-0.0148447081,
0.0565146208,
0.0200657751,
-0.0021684754,
-0.0005353331,
0.001249395,
0.0287612285,
0.0167487226,
0.0166205484,
0.0456460044,
-0.0282805283,
-0.0076237945,
-0.052828446,
0.0026879553,
0.0106382016,
0.0314679705,
0.0098835723,
0.0252780318,
0.0093951747,
-0.0127007589,
-0.0148808453,
-0.0096019292,
0.0037529441,
-0.0515274592,
0.0237293225,
-0.0100025954,
0.0144957537,
0.004462155,
-0.0253857803,
-0.0285341963,
0.0122788204,
-0.0878625587,
0.0108978255,
0.0298787393,
-0.0380586013,
0.0150544876,
0.0018928703,
0.0497808754,
0.0206896905,
0.034618564,
-0.0269669108,
0.0088699684,
0.0000852169,
-0.0092009846,
-0.0007770052,
-0.0119371703,
0.0107910316,
0.0172320958,
-0.0347221419,
-0.0088951513,
-0.076443404,
0.0165656265,
-0.0180817787,
0.0503229238,
-0.0379666165,
-0.0025217442,
-0.0584768541,
-0.014533828,
-0.0435202904,
-0.0006107131,
-0.0344131775,
-0.04966259,
0.036739137,
0.0079507744,
0.0021945699,
-0.0063971267,
0.0254630297,
0.081821084,
-0.0226535108,
-0.0365221612,
-0.0476832874,
-0.021596672,
-0.0341264717,
-0.0564079918,
0.0154906949,
-0.0635386929,
0.0157218277,
-0.0130903441,
0.0150955273,
-0.0826261416,
0.0015938957,
0.0176949427,
-0.05416077,
0.0906630829,
0.0432392396,
-0.0100186467,
0.0466920212,
0.0436589904,
-0.0559644699,
0.0730948523,
0.0097007165,
0.06341362,
0.0492589474,
-0.0082707284,
0.0023688942,
0.027149329,
0.0027686451,
0.0016941532,
-0.0295696892,
0.0350263789,
-0.0167037137,
-0.0068573668,
0.0398267694,
0.011854969,
0.011486412,
-0.023437066,
0.077725336,
0.0954444408,
-0.0716896653,
0.0342371054,
0.0565862805,
0.0248574559,
-0.0188409202,
0.0048069037,
-0.061369136,
0.0015478302,
0.0119765196,
-0.0507682227,
-0.0556923822,
0.1011969447,
-0.0410788096,
-0.0265474208,
0.0219825767,
-0.0290665161,
0.0948312804,
-0.0018283366,
-0.0086709009,
0.0485584624,
-0.0117322924,
0.0208703894,
0.0081028296,
-0.017091563,
-0.0310261063,
-0.0609540865,
0.0540983677,
0.0901280865,
0.0176130664,
0.0250515081,
0.0330629051,
-0.0286504831,
-0.02918447,
0.0663699582,
-0.0092260344,
-0.0037738655,
-0.0132121108,
-0.0179554168,
0.0036153533,
0.0103374952,
0.0243988521,
0.0492874458,
0.0345040411,
0.0621594228,
0.0335783027,
0.0242333524,
-0.037222784,
0.0010189704,
0.0012841008,
-0.0349223502,
-0.0069791856,
0.0521604083,
0.020985065,
0.0125751887,
-0.0170450956,
-0.0322090052,
-0.0277133379,
-0.0051521021,
-0.0367175005,
0.0729597285,
-0.0229005329,
0.0085382918,
0.0145466328,
-0.0850734562,
-0.0550070331,
0.0251951795,
0.0068505937,
0.0207027812,
0.0432305969,
-0.0013721639,
0.0183710195,
-0.036926195,
-0.0286357217,
-0.0313305818,
0.0354010612,
0.0250158347,
0.0497624315,
0.0015224214,
-0.077229701,
0.040178284,
-0.031806834,
-0.0132944444,
0.0301404987,
-0.0050628013,
-0.0137534067,
0.0087905712,
0.0392782912,
0.0012544174,
0.015439569,
-0.0235459451,
0.0186456461,
-0.0614244789,
-0.0449386947,
0.0075560492,
-0.0540320314,
-0.0177876689,
0.0119889695,
-0.0162068121,
-0.0054941606,
-0.0504454747,
-0.0055560018,
-0.0171200316,
0.0378903113,
0.0014276314,
-0.0253218152,
-0.0204060972,
-0.0033754788,
0.0004806541,
-0.0256577153,
0.0660736486,
0.0262366366,
0.0037544228,
-0.0369411595,
-0.0211160891,
-0.0700195059,
0.0171562377,
0.0066616102,
-0.0509047247,
0.0108292019,
0.0323908702,
0.0097708739,
0.0802269801,
0.052768141,
0.0145468405,
0.0138297668,
0.0039274776,
-0.0270721521,
-0.0172943603,
0.0002557331,
0.0173814446,
0.0316248387,
-0.1165317297,
-0.0241088104,
0.0515445918,
0.0198128633,
0.000549964,
-0.0608696043,
0.0647658631,
-0.0278023817,
-0.0728239566,
-0.0121648293,
-0.0303527284,
0.0047271284,
0.0321358778,
-0.0418578498,
-0.0616731085,
0.0642318428,
-0.0059387875,
0.0259132814,
0.0312416088,
-0.0058828597,
-0.007995801,
0.0309097711,
0.0358867906,
0.0678419769,
0.0277673006,
0.0170227345,
-0.0196767747,
-0.0250542518,
0.0402977206,
-0.0174907055,
0.0312055163,
-0.0255966857,
-0.0097693596,
0.0196007937,
-0.031764023,
-0.0341626182,
-0.0747048631,
-0.0298753362,
-0.0425207689,
0.0061694193,
-0.0196674634,
0.003467757,
0.0245970991,
-0.0184005275,
0.0149529278,
-0.0092903208,
-0.0061586071,
0.0011750914,
-0.0102029424,
0.0411099456,
-0.029939469,
-0.003701898,
0.0108894659,
0.0100161592,
0.0467623472,
-0.0654714927,
-0.0198348053,
-0.032170698,
0.0248985142,
-0.0063558491,
0.0328097418,
0.0362295508,
0.0036756366,
0.0372936726,
-0.0049948972,
0.0084295338,
0.0715946257,
0.0037850877,
-0.0464433432,
0.0060063433,
0.0364633277,
-0.0066936277,
0.0209321454,
0.0101599125,
-0.0966129676,
-0.0079053706,
-0.0215849914,
0.0197847057,
-0.0838750601,
-0.031279806,
-0.0049943388,
-0.0865484774,
0.046483621,
0.016124906,
-0.0029222823,
-0.0078507951,
0.0045627505,
-0.0156947467,
0.0053241136,
0.0243010428,
-0.0424566902,
0.0037769072,
-0.0315272361,
-0.0352195017,
-0.0306841843,
-0.0189201254,
0.0443378203,
-0.0254801307,
0.0288645606,
0.0345396139,
0.0491741523,
-0.0079008657,
-0.0273246747,
-0.0290588979,
0.033483021,
-0.0028194271,
-0.0148191256,
0.0574479811,
-0.042252779,
-0.0140956724,
-0.0250890832,
0.0307579134,
0.0178375021,
0.0097568976,
-0.0081782294,
0.0453738049,
0.0332788974,
-0.0541121773,
-0.0766008869,
-0.0130968262,
0.0082571711,
0.0692948326,
0.0143839521,
-0.0407041386,
-0.0232588891,
-0.0717559382,
-0.0126533816,
-0.0069620986,
-0.0635773167,
0.0402152725,
-0.0277639888,
-0.0502438396,
-0.021148121,
-0.0443448983,
0.0027339458,
-0.0205850694,
0.0276634283,
-0.0839778036,
0.0091909273,
0.0163385812,
-0.0630447268,
0.0124571538,
-0.0121963313,
0.0175979938,
0.0328987651,
-0.0076037915,
0.0056908717,
-0.0582872741,
0.0012149401,
0.0362892896,
-0.0346831344,
-0.0284018759,
0.0564989299,
0.0596108474,
0.0154506778,
0.0501189604,
-0.0198323168,
-0.0242434833,
0.0801668391,
0.0462215468,
-0.0086623523,
0.0183810201,
0.0252675321,
0.0254762676,
-0.002984006,
0.0334660672,
-0.0381182283,
0.0747549906,
-0.0067922785,
-0.0582698099,
-0.0554566719,
-0.0113260662,
-0.0004487941,
-0.0089484407,
-0.0322680324,
-0.0406274498,
0.0307691023,
-0.0253193397,
-0.0198753215,
-0.018150093,
-0.0352488384,
-0.0171238203,
-0.0291780848,
0.0059200395,
0.0091013471,
-0.0116652707,
0.0162558444,
-0.0474270098,
0.0336944908,
-0.0306516178,
-0.0035345946,
0.0606131628,
0.0520099215,
0.0030874764,
0.0002879355,
-0.0148314815,
0.0490422994,
-0.0442528054,
0.0372714289,
0.0098017519,
0.0602095909,
0.0288208723,
0.0032628679,
-0.0260007381,
0.0358825997,
-0.016999986,
-0.0232867021,
-0.0209283978,
0.019242866,
0.0015019021,
-0.0341295302,
0.0307335537,
-0.0209197048,
-0.0184292961,
0.033140257,
0.0070815827,
0.009044528,
-0.0690606236,
0.0189201925,
-0.0082971351,
0.0051261135,
-0.0125369513,
0.0345777981,
-0.0056045055,
0.0389022976,
0.0107577881,
-0.0817096159,
-0.0304746646,
-0.0039892704,
0.0371571966,
-0.0491812639,
0.013944339,
-0.0120875211,
-0.0703702196,
-0.0830245614,
-0.0173050724,
-0.0167800765,
0.0017914715,
0.0119045554,
0.0151374741,
0.0488480404,
0.0194471683,
-0.0435059778,
0.0080440119,
0.0218826719,
-0.0733560845,
-0.0034198037,
-0.0016904314,
-6.044536317e-33,
-0.0200652145,
-0.0699148104,
-0.0246246252,
-0.0155963609,
0.0154374735,
-0.0142401308,
-0.016179489,
-0.0217720848,
0.0085397717,
0.030060159,
0.0056817369,
0.0125014773,
0.0070568845,
-0.0056294254,
0.020606393,
0.0021287361,
0.05288589,
-0.0274442248,
-0.0338491201,
0.0015765516,
-0.0046145152,
-0.0085365437,
0.029713342,
-0.0682573467,
0.0442366488,
-0.0262392014,
-0.0331227705,
-0.0183795039,
0.0185977519,
0.0432389639,
-0.0167522337,
0.0613480881,
0.0338876657,
0.0071297414,
0.0157836154,
0.0747403949,
-0.0665288419,
0.0012182562,
-0.0065933266,
0.0315378048,
-0.0206405371,
-0.029541187,
0.0042832987,
-0.0204829201,
-0.0439406522,
0.0079981694,
0.072198756,
-0.0412935652,
0.078662537,
0.0247808676,
-0.0615816526,
-0.0211781114,
-0.0326568596,
0.0229781158,
0.0143343471,
0.0430187173,
0.0226624329,
0.0234414991,
-0.0637825429,
0.0289846547,
-0.0092708087,
-0.0776389688,
0.0704555362,
0.0266852621,
0.0218228661,
0.0441541523,
0.0390758179,
0.0318825133,
-0.0234145522,
-0.0380278006,
0.0166255217,
0.0038164989,
0.0171157308,
0.1030342504,
0.0286663044,
-0.0459789,
0.0040820302,
0.0058050328,
0.0544630699,
-0.0392568856,
0.0311698336,
-0.0281721577,
-0.0908247232,
-0.0370210446,
-0.0019625667,
-0.0531395711,
-0.0259300079,
-0.0647469014,
0.0200554207,
-0.0102706011,
-0.0377521776,
0.0256432537,
0.0121622197,
-0.0417793989,
-0.0223373193,
-0.038740281,
-0.0109717324,
-0.0140323313,
0.0065472266,
0.0146760447,
-0.0540935472,
0.0146994693,
0.0242175646,
0.0399690866,
0.031964507,
0.0282328222,
0.0241445825,
0.023895584,
-0.0354340672,
0.003230585,
0.0071012643,
0.0108029693,
0.0008502115,
0.0092880297,
0.0047832397,
0.0304876845,
-0.0240537543,
-0.0003588544,
0.0401491523,
0.0159880668,
-0.0439414717,
-0.0047255754,
0.0064300043,
0.011675939,
-0.0473548099,
-0.0068110386,
-0.0312921628,
-0.0004453078,
0.055110544,
-0.0914884731,
-0.011138984,
-0.0478942096,
2.58e-7,
-0.0208613314,
0.0267903246,
-0.0159066096,
0.0578009859,
0.0283045005,
0.0787752122,
0.0514363758,
0.0403044298,
0.0108256862,
-0.0475513153,
0.0032255067,
0.0514934212,
0.003005862,
0.0666388869,
-0.0089187762,
0.0261580404,
-0.0379207842,
0.0260543209,
-0.0478388779,
0.0074311038,
0.0238092337,
0.0541438982,
0.0170063768,
-0.0315924697,
-0.0062729162,
-0.0445282124,
0.0167507939,
-0.0372795686,
0.0197941791,
-0.0274195317,
-0.0257325601,
0.0453912057,
-0.0049505034,
0.0226830486,
0.0177143011,
0.0047637103,
0.0149833765,
0.0134536317,
-0.0206261016,
0.0001819313,
-0.0209306348,
0.0071396199,
-0.0231390689,
-0.0633350089,
0.0467567556,
0.001634917,
-0.0296975616,
-0.0635742992,
-0.0270946268,
-0.0143065229,
0.0052767335,
-0.0335639939,
-0.0309988577,
-0.0106830318,
0.0371724106,
-0.0121623324,
0.0016577629,
-0.06889911,
-0.0085987402,
-0.0307601448,
-0.0067768684,
-0.0312436279,
-0.0240650196,
0.0237566531,
0.0161507241,
-0.047087729,
0.0532122739,
2.401164403e-34,
0.0282493494,
0.0232159626,
0.0076605715,
-0.0094250292,
0.027831072,
0.0072711869,
-0.0051563047,
-0.058808364,
0.0440621749,
-0.0504824109,
-0.0089905737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11772v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11772v3 | Improving Long Document Topic Segmentation Models With Enhanced Coherence Modeling | 2023-10-18T07:58:47 | 2023-10-23T06:05:59 | Hai Yu, Chong Deng, Qinglin Zhang, Jiaqing Liu, Qian Chen, Wen Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Topic segmentation is critical for obtaining structured documents and
improving downstream tasks such as information retrieval. Due to its ability of
automatically exploring clues of topic shift from abundant labeled data, recent
supervised neural models have greatly promoted the development of long document
topic segmentation, but leaving the deeper relationship between coherence and
topic segmentation underexplored. Therefore, this paper enhances the ability of
supervised models to capture coherence from both logical structure and semantic
similarity perspectives to further improve the topic segmentation performance,
proposing Topic-aware Sentence Structure Prediction (TSSP) and Contrastive
Semantic Similarity Learning (CSSL). Specifically, the TSSP task is proposed to
force the model to comprehend structural information by learning the original
relations between adjacent sentences in a disarrayed document, which is
constructed by jointly disrupting the original document at topic and sentence
levels. Moreover, we utilize inter- and intra-topic information to construct
contrastive samples and design the CSSL objective to ensure that the sentences
representations in the same topic have higher similarity, while those in
different topics are less similar. Extensive experiments show that the
Longformer with our approach significantly outperforms old state-of-the-art
(SOTA) methods. Our approach improve $F_1$ of old SOTA by 3.42 (73.74 -> 77.16)
and reduces $P_k$ by 1.11 points (15.0 -> 13.89) on WIKI-727K and achieves an
average relative reduction of 4.3% on $P_k$ on WikiSection. The average
relative $P_k$ drop of 8.38% on two out-of-domain datasets also demonstrates
the robustness of our approach. | [
-0.0070281476,
0.0075933761,
0.0218573269,
0.0189407691,
-0.0771706924,
-0.0160669107,
-0.008986257,
-0.0397527553,
-0.0241207369,
-0.0328549445,
-0.0040440243,
-0.0137022454,
-0.001728244,
0.0140888235,
-0.0209207907,
-0.068363674,
0.0268561728,
-0.0349699035,
0.019427266,
0.0370229706,
0.0156240035,
-0.014561018,
0.0163482148,
-0.0315125249,
0.0105402879,
-0.0896681771,
-0.0272283256,
-0.0122098755,
-0.0150250299,
-0.0402485058,
0.072689414,
0.0075776828,
0.0169094708,
-0.0075474586,
0.0000020854,
-0.0416296571,
-0.0722395182,
-0.0274806656,
0.016462056,
0.0064035626,
0.0462201014,
-0.0815380961,
0.0356107615,
0.0007441319,
0.0118809389,
0.0403260402,
-0.0584035814,
0.1219744831,
0.0603460595,
0.0787144899,
-0.0185709428,
-0.0528418049,
0.1140893847,
0.0009275394,
0.0214959998,
-0.0151306149,
-0.0092588849,
-0.0000777259,
-0.0257571731,
0.0365156196,
-0.0123801623,
0.0038207283,
0.0207102224,
-0.0164177306,
0.0338417925,
0.0114652086,
-0.0438572429,
-0.0169479903,
0.0054053087,
0.0636502877,
-0.0273291282,
-0.0079553332,
0.0608894303,
-0.0132076563,
-0.009611777,
-0.0081364475,
-0.0375254564,
0.0210444126,
-0.0353745781,
0.0396581069,
0.1036022529,
0.0362634398,
-0.0033784348,
0.0136291618,
-0.0131426863,
0.0700602308,
0.0174249057,
-0.0473372117,
-0.0216671452,
0.0163710918,
0.0014229312,
0.0168482047,
0.0454273745,
0.005260556,
-0.0252617858,
-0.0007000128,
-0.051448904,
-0.0849998668,
0.0085830046,
-0.0575686321,
-0.0277878251,
-0.0027583647,
-0.0390760489,
0.0740701854,
-0.0179327577,
-0.0041559823,
0.0082384283,
-0.0069960468,
-0.0593460314,
-0.0279056653,
-0.0387537815,
0.0056142039,
-0.0177442376,
0.0453679599,
-0.0267333463,
-0.0425943211,
0.0136222653,
0.005121103,
0.0237745233,
-0.0076892269,
-0.0078445068,
-0.0215159915,
-0.0509394519,
-0.0214803983,
0.001987224,
0.0372467935,
-0.039881222,
0.0132018905,
0.0041454923,
0.0447565652,
0.0063211522,
0.0427121595,
0.0133724865,
-0.0103286402,
-0.0047324845,
-0.0065612579,
-0.0388192199,
-0.03239071,
-0.0746937469,
-0.0410030074,
-0.0139447702,
-0.033301875,
0.0554425679,
-0.0571266636,
-0.0105954902,
-0.0106251864,
-0.0260938462,
0.0013804345,
-0.0158689432,
0.0158251058,
-0.0267804395,
0.0477222726,
-0.0183078013,
0.0080986796,
0.0607297346,
0.030885661,
0.0420878939,
0.0608797595,
0.0091700247,
0.0161957946,
0.0608168989,
0.0406203903,
-0.0098658474,
-0.0255977847,
-0.0049352902,
-0.0217125248,
0.0250948574,
0.0039357874,
-0.0048726876,
-0.0004855891,
0.0692745149,
0.0213698912,
-0.0144759919,
-0.0298354439,
0.0212488752,
0.0257100444,
0.0249584112,
0.0183703583,
-0.007999097,
0.059263546,
-0.0194077678,
0.0687959492,
0.0142476065,
-0.0167576931,
0.0185498148,
0.0694571212,
0.0235217698,
0.0215329789,
-0.0513610393,
-0.0311888978,
-0.0088241631,
-0.0261707753,
0.0087260855,
-0.0307208691,
0.0806805789,
0.0322296992,
-0.0457441024,
0.0655013397,
0.0242636744,
-0.0657782406,
-0.0040292102,
0.0100915376,
0.044106327,
0.0608976297,
0.0190225579,
-0.0710608661,
-0.0429816358,
0.008613484,
0.0570795238,
0.0421707816,
-0.022320006,
0.0010752183,
0.0307779815,
-0.0559877045,
-0.0102442959,
-0.0522768758,
0.0137701854,
-0.0355113707,
-0.0055960552,
0.0046842755,
0.0461911,
-0.0667799935,
0.0325624906,
0.042240601,
-0.0160502046,
0.0076648239,
-0.0307264812,
-0.0167852342,
-0.0047433875,
0.0126294605,
0.0247330833,
0.0067596096,
0.0311880428,
-0.0533777699,
0.0177407376,
-0.0250028223,
-0.0701491684,
-0.0750237554,
0.0342968293,
-0.0569615699,
-0.0169979651,
0.0198932737,
-0.0384997651,
-0.0370846204,
0.0368045196,
-0.0028500839,
-0.0185862388,
-0.0178036802,
0.0284432322,
0.007167385,
0.0004263363,
-0.014109022,
0.0480228812,
-0.0064349235,
-0.0217922032,
0.0028165057,
-0.0287097022,
-0.0263112467,
-0.0314678922,
0.0275233313,
0.0039614779,
-0.0039711697,
-0.0209341869,
0.0262650326,
0.0124753099,
-0.0546934418,
-0.0277572237,
-0.074673906,
0.0250918753,
-0.0346586965,
0.0068335054,
0.0278760195,
-0.004722341,
0.0053015663,
-0.0233801734,
-0.0240897164,
-0.0019399159,
-0.0017309861,
-0.0180155821,
0.0633008704,
-0.0424974412,
-0.004738634,
-0.0628602803,
-0.0328047648,
-0.0121240839,
0.0402761437,
-0.0151417544,
-0.0470582508,
-0.053684406,
0.0560822003,
0.0152371526,
-0.0441742688,
-0.0253977887,
0.0258833095,
-0.0279739201,
-0.01574938,
0.0725174844,
0.0691349134,
0.0349226296,
0.0074110418,
0.0263730232,
-0.0229293797,
0.0158191528,
0.0115402145,
-0.0194228031,
0.0868739188,
0.0115786679,
-0.0291971993,
0.0662089959,
0.0742597058,
-0.0229053013,
0.012232759,
0.0122906929,
-0.0661982447,
-0.0219028778,
0.003528249,
-0.009115818,
-0.015344399,
0.0180998109,
-0.0178048592,
-0.0328609347,
-0.0112615163,
0.0651836544,
-0.0223025233,
0.0050527011,
-0.0953020975,
-0.0402885228,
-0.0705316812,
0.0432528593,
0.0128378794,
-0.0271885246,
0.0289061032,
0.0052383537,
-0.040694885,
-0.0060816491,
0.0110018505,
0.030975366,
0.0335561447,
-0.0236903951,
0.0034886065,
-0.0006015666,
-0.0158345122,
-0.0014128095,
-0.0416472256,
0.0133137582,
0.0170189794,
0.0247059129,
0.0324553773,
-0.0128196655,
0.0151293566,
0.0167908017,
0.0635416433,
-0.0201046169,
-0.0189217534,
-0.0285854191,
0.082576111,
0.0868229792,
-0.0295160934,
0.004474604,
-0.0282730572,
0.055511456,
0.044778645,
0.0332682207,
-0.0324319936,
-0.0343267322,
-0.0050579756,
-0.0182124432,
-0.0489022546,
-0.0140825454,
-0.0190277528,
0.0130430255,
-0.0764523074,
-0.0141720297,
0.1071399525,
0.0206703693,
-0.019435646,
-0.0418548882,
-0.0530801043,
0.0106269289,
-0.0239634998,
-0.0155556509,
-0.0084330859,
-0.0447173454,
-0.0019916513,
0.0170742143,
0.0483306386,
-0.0201765783,
0.0383897275,
-0.054001715,
0.0055068778,
0.0012157522,
0.0040856483,
-0.005967218,
-0.0699933916,
-0.01463106,
-0.0083191842,
0.0077293552,
0.00441112,
-0.034308441,
-0.0041063172,
-0.010806296,
-0.0789730549,
0.0139315957,
-0.0437044874,
-0.033941932,
-0.0198079608,
0.0297076665,
0.0217379648,
0.0111281639,
0.0060832631,
0.047223486,
-0.0371147953,
-0.0059884246,
0.019667631,
0.0597253628,
-0.0170081854,
0.0502787307,
-0.038281247,
0.0616568662,
-0.0560952425,
-0.0288896728,
0.0376485623,
0.053819593,
-0.0127860298,
-0.0433435999,
-0.0348156579,
-0.0045706811,
-0.0419294126,
0.0800073966,
0.02272854,
-0.0202237647,
-0.0460514016,
-0.0003173244,
0.0627066195,
0.0121032475,
0.0636771768,
-0.0309464447,
-0.0128192473,
0.0325683504,
-0.0977790132,
-0.0723091736,
-0.0068981145,
-0.0298530944,
-0.0368430465,
0.0370090082,
0.0137525974,
-0.0480017923,
-0.0453506634,
0.0264108665,
-0.0212615971,
-0.046497982,
-0.0532713011,
0.0061040493,
0.0279843602,
-0.014906195,
-0.0045196121,
-0.0229693279,
-0.0572963804,
-0.0453831032,
-0.0082718274,
-0.0095925843,
-0.0041028587,
0.0604329333,
-0.0035759935,
0.0033923443,
0.0283111557,
0.0118317856,
-0.0777391195,
0.0267018136,
0.0384547412,
0.0188029576,
0.006642187,
0.0300450269,
-0.0296426974,
0.0341122709,
-0.0142936604,
0.0186736062,
-0.0168287847,
-0.0235763732,
-0.0212327093,
0.0214096978,
0.0866350308,
0.0240510404,
0.0120953619,
-0.0544290468,
0.0107456446,
-0.0123803504,
-0.0067581888,
-0.0163222514,
0.0601582751,
0.0058957897,
-0.0018433594,
-0.0189362261,
0.0934699029,
-0.0124640157,
0.037118528,
-0.019957453,
0.0095171994,
0.0014401231,
0.0137382047,
-0.0523954332,
-0.0051145265,
-0.0030937009,
-0.0301634911,
-0.0080050705,
0.0130098704,
-0.003705191,
0.0365309417,
0.0166309401,
0.0075418223,
-0.0613446981,
0.0359815285,
-0.0797883496,
0.0150078433,
-0.015111384,
0.0233959928,
0.0180624891,
-0.0224490147,
0.0478601903,
-0.0150848767,
-0.0166623052,
-0.0125136068,
0.0745121166,
0.0425273664,
0.0170748606,
-0.0415599346,
0.0352934524,
-0.0270598736,
0.0101554403,
0.0786921307,
-0.0124435155,
-0.0035710772,
0.0545027368,
-0.0210282672,
-0.0373527519,
0.0098940674,
0.009069236,
0.047334455,
-0.0357227474,
-0.0057856627,
0.0048913709,
0.0299535822,
0.0848101079,
-0.0356844403,
0.0075837839,
0.0224200711,
0.0479481369,
0.0738421232,
0.0060809343,
-0.0157163013,
-0.0189708527,
0.0038041186,
0.0154275587,
-0.0416374803,
-0.0215347391,
-6.394214663e-33,
0.0000608915,
0.0018418711,
0.0054256339,
0.0136848008,
-0.0221602079,
0.0238902438,
-0.0708972216,
-0.0317292549,
0.0067348462,
0.0322040692,
-0.005723224,
0.0593608506,
0.0191161633,
0.0427557155,
-0.015175432,
-0.0268250443,
0.0713317469,
0.0170191042,
-0.0164514352,
0.0217913315,
0.0343841687,
0.0410252512,
0.0263863001,
-0.0432405993,
0.0002432223,
-0.0168916155,
0.0288140699,
-0.0126256654,
0.0797781944,
0.0293076038,
-0.014293381,
0.0162798315,
0.0703806952,
-0.0466409065,
-0.0156329852,
0.0426637605,
-0.0761464089,
-0.0360020585,
-0.0389079526,
-0.0672646388,
-0.0256536864,
-0.0342780761,
0.0291540585,
0.0229069032,
0.0528074317,
-0.0505176745,
0.0768988058,
-0.0094800713,
-0.0026914449,
-0.0277512446,
-0.0868543163,
0.0484066233,
-0.0149175208,
-0.0076782415,
0.0141949141,
0.0187482089,
0.0040820548,
0.0574432984,
-0.0352468975,
-0.0057371641,
-0.012762866,
0.0526393056,
0.0022574898,
-0.0127233807,
-0.0243823193,
0.0522660166,
0.0064861616,
0.0061629405,
0.0073316437,
0.0095191048,
0.019984087,
0.0313121974,
0.0438476801,
-0.0000733403,
0.0388023704,
0.0097908946,
-0.0688741356,
0.0612695776,
-0.0186673887,
0.0443042815,
0.0106227202,
0.0398723148,
-0.0328795575,
-0.0253419578,
0.0095434627,
0.009212344,
-0.0051953527,
0.0130349211,
-0.0093829604,
0.029165525,
-0.0290857032,
-0.020175634,
0.0173228756,
0.0118707381,
0.0136885764,
0.0487590134,
-0.0390595347,
0.0287308954,
0.007688683,
0.0005130107,
-0.0651183575,
-0.0171872023,
-0.015151199,
0.0061204489,
-0.0188394412,
0.0018449352,
0.053436622,
-0.0428591892,
-0.0232034773,
0.0043163621,
0.0180625729,
-0.0413122512,
-0.0187754687,
0.0395015851,
0.0166093539,
0.0127386348,
-0.008545598,
0.098959811,
0.0434608907,
0.018012384,
-0.03245233,
-0.0518532358,
-0.0036070473,
0.0261000656,
0.0012656423,
0.0257953331,
-0.0111933956,
0.0096046105,
0.0165403932,
-0.0748016909,
-0.0159433186,
0.005079017,
2.692e-7,
0.0142199956,
0.0315333866,
0.0507325307,
-0.0242576823,
-0.005538492,
0.0329106897,
0.007869903,
0.0307558514,
-0.0301230103,
-0.0298853405,
0.0035085124,
0.0042491443,
0.0458327159,
0.0337839089,
-0.0964697152,
0.0195033643,
-0.0317044705,
-0.0541613884,
-0.068445839,
-0.0168185309,
0.0118052186,
0.0690576881,
-0.008658316,
0.001428686,
0.0058360184,
-0.0400483087,
0.039363645,
-0.0429789312,
-0.041702155,
0.0166982524,
0.0386419371,
-0.0247252043,
-0.0087881833,
-0.0210310407,
-0.0086480938,
0.0336866267,
0.0371550061,
0.0417117849,
0.0511150844,
0.0201844405,
0.025989566,
-0.0153777692,
-0.0093099745,
0.0016720372,
0.0650013164,
-0.0502434671,
-0.0110845761,
-0.0141648762,
-0.0338071473,
0.0096563231,
-0.011909415,
-0.0054670456,
-0.0104080644,
0.0312152114,
-0.0151505843,
-0.0201260429,
-0.0070630936,
-0.0387510695,
-0.0326145552,
0.0354421362,
-0.0101228887,
0.0001439875,
-0.0288402606,
0.0018153361,
0.031120671,
-0.0655598789,
0.0450259596,
2.686250022e-34,
0.0542554483,
-0.0038900468,
-0.0499812141,
0.0287843328,
0.0154813277,
-0.0333932415,
-0.0694178566,
-0.0179858748,
-0.0105439471,
-0.05449415,
0.022684468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11769v1 | Annotated Job Ads with Named Entity Recognition | 2023-10-18T07:55:53 | 2023-10-18T07:55:53 | Felix Stollenwerk, Niklas Fastlund, Anna Nyqvist, Joey Öhman | cs.CL | cs.CL | We have trained a named entity recognition (NER) model that screens Swedish
job ads for different kinds of useful information (e.g. skills required from a
job seeker). It was obtained by fine-tuning KB-BERT. The biggest challenge we
faced was the creation of a labelled dataset, which required manual annotation.
This paper gives an overview of the methods we employed to make the annotation
process more efficient and to ensure high quality data. We also report on the
performance of the resulting model. | [
0.0510440581,
-0.0266960189,
0.0296416245,
-0.0280147437,
0.0210882053,
0.033037845,
-0.012236095,
-0.0059558945,
0.044214271,
-0.0844580457,
-0.0136264283,
0.0011862005,
-0.0171284378,
-0.0045819166,
-0.007802852,
-0.0401924327,
-0.0070822793,
-0.0154061317,
0.0043373439,
0.0416062325,
-0.010854343,
0.0253136773,
-0.0220297072,
0.0274236258,
0.0069239135,
-0.0038741422,
0.005112878,
0.008709074,
0.0771756619,
-0.0253238007,
0.0308781341,
0.0264285076,
-0.0109128673,
0.0208991431,
0.0000014588,
-0.0444042161,
-0.0125601068,
0.0349936187,
-0.0263016671,
-0.0071121654,
0.0065138978,
-0.0069459756,
-0.0114979399,
-0.0115774237,
0.0132056139,
0.0098053114,
0.0560754202,
0.0680705681,
0.0431021638,
0.0722802803,
0.0050717932,
-0.0263970327,
-0.0104935206,
-0.0404862426,
0.0175833181,
-0.0152646163,
0.0670170859,
-0.0405891649,
0.0396794006,
0.035619881,
0.039829731,
0.0369256102,
-0.0407853685,
-0.0414101928,
0.0243221838,
0.0411321558,
-0.0389520489,
-0.010827384,
-0.0043797046,
0.0504774004,
-0.0223421026,
0.0146808773,
0.0202211011,
-0.0483230837,
-0.0094268359,
0.0005554114,
-0.0302388147,
-0.0049691149,
-0.0411731303,
-0.0086741159,
0.012162338,
0.0003628115,
0.0007842749,
-0.0042825206,
0.0645998567,
0.0367804356,
-0.0192612652,
-0.061843466,
0.0556247309,
0.0259649474,
0.0094486549,
-0.0506832153,
0.0461719632,
0.0074024829,
0.0857722089,
0.0108191185,
-0.0126333134,
-0.0083367489,
0.0309469774,
-0.1003499329,
-0.0076771243,
-0.0127668586,
-0.024503231,
0.0615296252,
-0.0328154415,
0.0077266917,
0.0053730696,
0.0132142454,
0.024310058,
0.0009278443,
-0.1107771248,
-0.016708117,
-0.0765374228,
0.0199634228,
-0.0042425999,
0.0118917888,
-0.0329624787,
0.0004898575,
-0.0122981332,
0.0411058106,
0.052734267,
-0.0220104288,
-0.0028640165,
0.0365509503,
-0.0439398065,
-0.0002480816,
0.0049544456,
-0.0298548844,
-0.040484909,
-0.0119597819,
0.0395686477,
0.0026793925,
0.0514396615,
-0.0651724637,
-0.0026643586,
0.003003137,
0.0567112975,
-0.0573866293,
-0.0547012873,
0.0109819723,
0.0002864827,
-0.0025285559,
0.002208418,
0.0016065014,
0.0271285381,
-0.0023924168,
-0.0229613855,
-0.0259247348,
0.0311015341,
0.0111877816,
-0.0571137443,
0.0606471747,
-0.0479009226,
-0.0167515185,
0.0464736521,
-0.0174910203,
0.006667878,
0.0221640412,
0.0082686031,
0.0678410605,
0.0224457514,
-0.0195692424,
0.0351585038,
0.0555699468,
-0.0150526362,
-0.0427810922,
0.0289992113,
0.0376330465,
-0.0259912033,
-0.0058149868,
0.0403230749,
-0.0382255986,
-0.020061871,
0.0265086722,
0.0242927372,
0.0229837745,
0.0271589346,
-0.0451867692,
0.0529582873,
0.0688230917,
0.0277341902,
-0.0327304639,
-0.014340139,
0.016093703,
-0.0041254396,
0.0112053147,
-0.0336414836,
0.0160778314,
-0.0160085503,
0.0074480642,
-0.0186409261,
0.0107790865,
-0.0216493383,
0.0247129817,
0.0229677651,
-0.0087770065,
-0.0541626699,
0.077878505,
0.0167161468,
0.0206651706,
0.0342777073,
-0.0014016692,
-0.0008985838,
0.0600046292,
0.0142087108,
-0.0380404592,
-0.0658733994,
-0.0684206933,
-0.0564295612,
0.0389755964,
0.0618807673,
-0.0641940907,
0.0082542775,
-0.0238356143,
-0.0423425175,
-0.0046357154,
0.0076253829,
0.038737461,
0.0026713833,
0.0393026173,
0.0276238285,
-0.0112991733,
-0.0461129434,
0.0300018135,
0.0516622625,
-0.041124098,
0.0052253711,
0.0278705265,
-0.0171343442,
0.0441125929,
-0.0153036835,
0.0015049517,
0.0048077651,
-0.0100082299,
-0.0019981845,
-0.0057109562,
0.0532056987,
-0.0336612016,
-0.0291591641,
-0.0178152341,
-0.0421263576,
-0.0139020476,
-0.0403003357,
-0.0262343083,
-0.053961996,
0.0084492285,
0.0018265875,
-0.0228994414,
-0.0048477552,
0.0084643206,
0.0015718412,
-0.0477823988,
0.0579980202,
0.0255572591,
0.0207721274,
0.00659743,
-0.0275353026,
0.0039099557,
-0.1078728586,
-0.0202647559,
0.003684601,
0.0124271363,
0.0043607773,
0.023729492,
0.0023346464,
-0.0234119911,
0.0029732008,
-0.0749902129,
-0.0019756984,
0.0142821781,
0.0500817634,
0.0150534865,
-0.0010068581,
-0.0362996534,
-0.0642839298,
-0.0302202012,
-0.0072607654,
-0.0044454308,
-0.0117982542,
0.0374156162,
0.0214668456,
-0.0168503504,
0.0031997503,
0.0165118389,
-0.009936817,
0.0044631097,
0.0690737441,
-0.0527780391,
-0.0790168867,
0.0110721393,
-0.0162384622,
0.0121551612,
0.0508102253,
0.0215267837,
-0.0318604223,
0.0428785123,
-0.0510049351,
0.0475033931,
-0.0230258349,
0.0001294928,
-0.0067400807,
0.0133505119,
-0.0266647208,
0.0120909829,
-0.0184744447,
0.0809289068,
-0.0134500638,
-0.0506121144,
0.0445023365,
0.0643331707,
-0.0246935152,
0.0167529248,
-0.0180727448,
0.0040796162,
-0.0193357915,
-0.0289044958,
-0.0813063234,
0.0115660569,
-0.0008749824,
0.0415247716,
-0.0040619243,
-0.0124629205,
0.044034522,
-0.0329247303,
-0.0043825693,
-0.0147274546,
-0.0232660864,
-0.0390648618,
0.0194334704,
-0.0089728916,
0.0199766476,
0.0196486507,
-0.0790027604,
0.0514031462,
0.0076136529,
0.0218538251,
-0.0056712627,
-0.021157328,
0.0243443679,
0.0364199132,
-0.0242441259,
-0.0301293135,
-0.0550380908,
-0.042922169,
-0.0737488046,
0.0247378554,
-0.0094933249,
0.0080664577,
-0.0799454302,
0.0723398998,
-0.0236296207,
0.0459938794,
-0.0014470522,
0.0083462615,
-0.0147161093,
0.049370978,
0.0486082919,
-0.0048017199,
-0.0383787639,
0.0291553177,
-0.0138244759,
-0.01160408,
-0.0686104447,
0.0607911423,
0.00096344,
0.0062467684,
0.0066445069,
-0.1239506081,
-0.0080804955,
-0.0495954603,
-0.0057567488,
-0.030653242,
0.0130445668,
0.0822863802,
-0.0034179913,
0.0133537306,
-0.0227274466,
0.0136219999,
-0.0399593674,
0.009739764,
0.0554201305,
-0.0588816367,
-0.0236141644,
0.0142485024,
0.0202719569,
-0.0027006061,
-0.0265170932,
0.0060908571,
-0.0783605054,
0.0611412153,
-0.0285883714,
-0.022401914,
0.0026811098,
-0.0959561691,
-0.0082600964,
-0.0715636164,
-0.038275525,
-0.0399945416,
-0.0307084396,
0.0134942755,
0.044454705,
0.0347826704,
-0.0609150827,
0.0213648584,
-0.0157888494,
0.0236174893,
0.0516027249,
0.0464647561,
-0.0122327972,
-0.03802884,
-0.0177717283,
-0.0080229174,
-0.0176350158,
0.0008677437,
0.0550751202,
-0.0736403242,
-0.0130824018,
-0.0008117437,
-0.0142528173,
0.0066317744,
-0.0031210773,
0.0244815741,
0.0358659849,
0.0074863061,
0.0207883958,
-0.0004591231,
-0.0107036475,
0.0417412929,
0.1079543233,
-0.0190974344,
-0.032377284,
-0.0039871992,
-0.0037346827,
-0.0195978153,
-0.0155980969,
-0.0050410512,
0.0430116393,
-0.0598341189,
-0.0121910898,
-0.0341387428,
-0.0677656755,
0.0810002834,
0.023317907,
0.0407912955,
-0.0222269818,
0.0044676592,
0.0292494297,
-0.0623453408,
0.0335110053,
-0.0180775318,
0.0302359741,
-0.0489932708,
-0.0065192007,
0.0138705261,
-0.0548427999,
-0.0690874979,
-0.0457065031,
-0.040694911,
-0.0075711412,
-0.0337599553,
0.0113652982,
0.0163863543,
0.063230142,
-0.0214462262,
-0.0429479368,
0.0076041566,
0.0547561571,
-0.0061056511,
-0.0421825647,
-0.0007348313,
0.0635543168,
-0.0198343191,
0.005095832,
-0.0313345529,
0.049837932,
0.0151492171,
-0.0165563747,
0.0180781875,
-0.0300271027,
-0.0195455868,
0.0318794101,
0.0210981835,
-0.0090141026,
-0.0126482332,
-0.0878747329,
0.0261300951,
0.0534105115,
0.0119269118,
-0.0252744555,
0.0141655542,
0.0457502082,
-0.0279693305,
0.0072511998,
0.0552369319,
-0.0428235121,
0.0310029183,
-0.0828054175,
0.0293698367,
0.005702842,
0.0636956021,
-0.0030139014,
-0.0143813947,
-0.0090209097,
0.0474007465,
0.0517305918,
0.0738183483,
0.0160576366,
0.0121343741,
-0.025851991,
0.0062900349,
0.031940978,
0.0136867659,
-0.0267856009,
-0.0033847939,
-0.0636248961,
0.0746573806,
0.0391828418,
-0.0453358032,
0.0647533461,
-0.0129061043,
-0.0153400628,
0.0230077915,
-0.0074666347,
0.0268670376,
-0.0154538024,
0.0273092724,
0.007325632,
-0.0026799822,
-0.0261973049,
0.0201117396,
0.0347801149,
0.0280827451,
0.007095885,
-0.0449517481,
-0.0515284911,
0.0064970371,
0.0820615217,
0.0144894421,
-0.0414104201,
0.0210674386,
-0.0132215619,
-0.0135112675,
0.0059986226,
-0.0399087965,
-0.0097788963,
0.0167047773,
0.0393654667,
-0.0049158065,
0.0223798864,
-0.0067262733,
-0.0574051887,
-0.0146270934,
-0.0312253367,
-0.0001155237,
-0.0532650873,
-5.116779972e-33,
-0.0420445576,
-0.0174013507,
0.0062577389,
0.0080153123,
0.0164534729,
0.0365664698,
0.0596325472,
-0.067048654,
0.0242557395,
-0.0262438506,
0.0203067623,
-0.0097797615,
0.0444533005,
0.0145873036,
-0.0082145641,
-0.0295406133,
0.0712576434,
0.0272066444,
-0.028145764,
0.0219642762,
0.0036400494,
0.0582934804,
0.099437885,
-0.0300019421,
0.0570076145,
-0.0012840154,
-0.0260685962,
0.0098827546,
0.1011498868,
0.0560617968,
-0.0370081328,
-0.0223492738,
0.0182278361,
-0.0470063537,
0.0465661697,
0.0343812034,
-0.107770212,
0.0137077542,
0.0047532036,
0.0765662268,
0.017748598,
-0.0129850172,
-0.0137120346,
-0.0440676585,
0.0173182841,
0.0435982719,
0.0555438623,
-0.0163824912,
-0.0072737276,
-0.0009550076,
-0.0391247198,
0.0453762896,
-0.0102244169,
0.0033199545,
0.0460595004,
0.0157512501,
0.0470272079,
0.0018397283,
-0.1194011047,
-0.0026721293,
0.023383595,
-0.0104364613,
0.0345778205,
0.0070673265,
-0.0120991757,
0.0263688434,
0.0253839549,
0.0163320918,
0.015528555,
-0.0045047919,
-0.0304048136,
0.0209621005,
-0.0384720936,
-0.0316165201,
0.0590394624,
-0.002141417,
-0.0341714434,
0.0504796319,
0.0281654373,
0.0004653528,
-0.0140173007,
-0.0270829592,
-0.0549023636,
0.0093633179,
-0.0186822284,
-0.0683978498,
-0.0329620466,
-0.0016924175,
0.0586560816,
0.0318101123,
-0.0402620435,
0.0713147372,
-0.0145856272,
-0.0075985584,
-0.0132981734,
-0.0162416846,
0.0075189825,
0.0110665625,
-0.0333335958,
-0.0196010675,
-0.0385396965,
-0.06581036,
0.0095652854,
-0.0014656704,
0.0103821671,
0.020608671,
0.0499179065,
-0.0194363743,
-0.0289436094,
0.010982764,
0.010909521,
0.0489478409,
-0.0406059735,
0.058594469,
0.0201431531,
-0.0276148431,
-0.0194745939,
-0.0047948533,
0.0458227396,
0.0124282427,
0.0247511715,
-0.0324189737,
0.0428328738,
0.0612361506,
0.0077786348,
0.0040712184,
0.0049116085,
-0.0400827527,
-0.0243296083,
-0.0741849467,
0.0175528415,
-0.0051474897,
2.15e-7,
0.010799041,
0.0009154442,
-0.004370633,
-0.0236839745,
0.0067604305,
-0.0069489484,
0.0129132913,
0.0421050675,
0.00173397,
0.0230750553,
-0.0158856474,
-0.0402701944,
-0.0153806144,
-0.0055001373,
-0.1107837334,
-0.0487907864,
-0.0270115267,
-0.0081070727,
-0.0692690685,
0.0450869314,
0.0362840444,
0.0583723076,
0.0182632767,
-0.0183328241,
-0.0273826979,
-0.028438881,
0.042463962,
0.0337706991,
0.0435529165,
0.045961991,
0.0471550226,
0.0710939914,
-0.0280028246,
0.0190212522,
-0.0173275489,
0.0193958692,
0.0448799469,
0.0591687299,
-0.0173698291,
0.0267948844,
-0.0190995242,
-0.0570263341,
0.0005847733,
-0.0235060137,
0.0629358739,
-0.0756015182,
-0.0255200304,
0.015510546,
-0.0370424911,
-0.0071950373,
-0.0069879349,
-0.0076854955,
-0.0071447226,
-0.0052763987,
0.0237863511,
-0.0522171743,
-0.0449522659,
-0.026789261,
0.0067962105,
0.0115219736,
0.0183911379,
-0.0467136875,
-0.0245043878,
-0.0051157936,
-0.0005639365,
-0.0454919972,
-0.0137116443,
1.503568396e-34,
0.0299562383,
0.0386893898,
-0.0521693565,
0.0230073389,
-0.0043393723,
0.0066513252,
0.0031863754,
-0.026159361,
0.0092524132,
-0.0264587384,
0.0035509455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11761v1 | A Comprehensive Evaluation of Large Language Models on Legal Judgment Prediction | 2023-10-18T07:38:04 | 2023-10-18T07:38:04 | Ruihao Shui, Yixin Cao, Xiang Wang, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential for
domain-specific applications, such as the law domain. However, recent disputes
over GPT-4's law evaluation raise questions concerning their performance in
real-world legal tasks. To systematically investigate their competency in the
law, we design practical baseline solutions based on LLMs and test on the task
of legal judgment prediction. In our solutions, LLMs can work alone to answer
open questions or coordinate with an information retrieval (IR) system to learn
from similar cases or solve simplified multi-choice questions. We show that
similar cases and multi-choice options, namely label candidates, included in
prompts can help LLMs recall domain knowledge that is critical for expertise
legal reasoning. We additionally present an intriguing paradox wherein an IR
system surpasses the performance of LLM+IR due to limited gains acquired by
weaker LLMs from powerful IR systems. In such cases, the role of LLMs becomes
redundant. Our evaluation pipeline can be easily extended into other tasks to
facilitate evaluations in other domains. Code is available at
https://github.com/srhthu/LM-CompEval-Legal | [
0.0627717674,
0.036618568,
-0.011139744,
0.0122550819,
-0.0898377895,
0.0142070642,
0.0419412106,
0.0463240594,
0.0537612811,
-0.0883196443,
-0.0441137478,
-0.0337183475,
-0.0496518612,
-0.0269233398,
-0.0154690333,
-0.0264840405,
0.0415625684,
-0.0203321204,
0.0768996105,
-0.0186932459,
0.0190638322,
0.0033050994,
0.0335029848,
0.0213864949,
-0.0152311455,
-0.0118611464,
0.007936487,
-0.017471958,
-0.0126691423,
-0.0137023767,
0.0219206046,
0.0825031996,
0.024227025,
0.0263292827,
0.0000018012,
-0.0688440204,
0.0097688762,
-0.0241160411,
0.0001019234,
0.0249494463,
0.0190208405,
0.0149447573,
-0.0027595575,
0.0139314402,
-0.0503674299,
-0.0126943421,
-0.0312482845,
0.017647827,
0.0383748785,
0.0631506592,
0.0103630424,
-0.0461534597,
0.0341112502,
-0.0589786321,
0.0242310744,
-0.0487430282,
0.0401529409,
0.0209575575,
0.0306475088,
-0.0004241978,
0.0207897499,
0.0084960088,
0.0204631109,
-0.0014443285,
-0.0277697556,
0.0174055248,
-0.027143782,
0.0077224462,
-0.0082267756,
0.0408032909,
0.0525076203,
-0.0064418996,
-0.0185744315,
0.0105532864,
0.0514351502,
0.0281130094,
-0.030108586,
0.0798033401,
-0.0077863201,
0.0135893337,
0.0156927407,
0.0178303979,
0.0115325926,
0.0400365628,
-0.0076226341,
0.1015268266,
0.0208565686,
-0.0581151508,
0.0405741706,
0.0145937577,
0.0119476272,
-0.039630767,
0.0291320365,
0.0388753675,
-0.0331034139,
0.0253730528,
-0.0073117451,
0.0018917563,
0.0788791627,
-0.044157736,
0.0020915729,
0.0123939132,
-0.0141473589,
0.0900132135,
-0.0398851521,
0.0413718373,
-0.0004905786,
0.019425258,
-0.0249637589,
-0.0550486967,
-0.032607533,
-0.007640373,
-0.0279150959,
0.058427617,
-0.0591026582,
0.0189162083,
-0.0068243495,
0.0132612484,
-0.0351419039,
0.0130019896,
0.0204519685,
-0.0023676709,
0.0019540617,
-0.0285701267,
-0.099315539,
-0.013318425,
-0.0320438556,
0.0409083404,
0.0062036021,
-0.0152036324,
0.0064402451,
-0.0133179212,
-0.020203745,
-0.0281927027,
0.0300065801,
0.0962500349,
-0.0171865411,
-0.0343532115,
-0.0186211839,
-0.0468732491,
-0.0327036791,
-0.0818777084,
-0.0378757641,
-0.0742607266,
0.0020576662,
0.0078224558,
-0.014993662,
-0.0669860095,
0.0316523127,
0.0630535707,
-0.0301621817,
0.0642162338,
0.0327353217,
-0.0211880133,
-0.0125468867,
0.025380386,
0.0159974433,
-0.0037367148,
-0.0323552787,
0.0309601389,
0.0150725348,
-0.0050925822,
0.0318033919,
0.0271103345,
-0.011724567,
0.0333373174,
-0.0178996045,
0.0403543897,
0.0207043644,
0.0280039478,
0.0060650082,
0.066091232,
-0.0107145384,
-0.0426831022,
0.0476064235,
0.066726163,
0.0084990049,
0.0387687199,
0.0134207187,
-0.0234765448,
0.0168683231,
-0.0117860204,
-0.0726458356,
0.0210726708,
-0.0558973588,
-0.0023590911,
-0.0170935728,
0.0131347077,
-0.04033098,
-0.0220076293,
0.0082338499,
0.0042718193,
0.0040846076,
0.0146700228,
0.0295897089,
-0.003851943,
-0.0196646769,
0.0327447541,
0.0458945967,
-0.0364433378,
-0.0409648456,
-0.0339052565,
0.0490876101,
0.0356323458,
0.0583075099,
-0.0247872006,
-0.0065109851,
-0.009669506,
-0.0263088681,
0.0204356071,
0.0615122803,
-0.0022706722,
-0.0444470122,
-0.0361176431,
-0.030579146,
0.0201481935,
0.01923443,
0.0207481235,
0.0072199064,
0.0145562505,
0.048030708,
-0.0507536754,
0.0279849395,
0.0306118373,
-0.0110350959,
-0.0492276289,
0.0061020115,
-0.010468889,
0.035045296,
-0.0055831783,
0.0105772596,
0.0004469465,
0.0376161933,
0.0109009231,
-0.011383337,
-0.0214546248,
-0.0193483531,
-0.0241572019,
0.0512030944,
-0.0112735536,
0.002274913,
0.0062727071,
-0.0329475254,
-0.0138802519,
-0.0458500981,
0.003739713,
0.0114153186,
-0.0737564489,
-0.0096103949,
0.0009056752,
-0.0435387641,
-0.0525369644,
0.0731967688,
0.0170873497,
-0.0039183577,
0.0048954557,
0.0187485721,
0.0296639353,
-0.0231963024,
-0.0402633511,
-0.0267146975,
-0.0097686108,
0.0338411666,
0.0248025544,
0.0187989213,
-0.0595156141,
-0.0432568826,
-0.0883363336,
0.0189165734,
-0.0271189995,
-0.0176211558,
-0.0218430236,
-0.0210198201,
-0.007332908,
-0.0194909237,
-0.0390137583,
-0.0100231683,
0.0090657296,
0.0160911214,
0.0063691116,
-0.0091547295,
-0.0119635239,
-0.0148024894,
-0.0185476337,
-0.0027501746,
0.0386447608,
0.0090743797,
0.0252106152,
-0.0297483094,
0.0882166028,
-0.0405712314,
0.0001929794,
-0.0206732862,
0.0159709062,
-0.016483916,
-0.0219970103,
0.0023965766,
0.0310125612,
0.0483254939,
-0.0203854907,
0.0469682738,
0.0013163585,
-0.0927809477,
0.009847356,
-0.0166654475,
-0.0304940175,
-0.043350365,
-0.0020296315,
-0.0112164151,
0.0194287207,
-0.0042522163,
-0.0025929841,
-0.0246707723,
0.0072994912,
0.0085255373,
-0.0065053296,
-0.0461660661,
0.0001880114,
-0.0137097565,
0.0269009657,
0.024403356,
-0.0913463831,
0.0748741329,
0.013628385,
0.047424797,
-0.0544422604,
0.0008012292,
-0.0453575961,
0.0900133029,
0.006225293,
-0.0132393613,
-0.0240300857,
-0.0320972092,
-0.0016689058,
-0.0050826948,
0.0401611999,
-0.055932533,
0.0939016938,
-0.0273942016,
0.0417311043,
-0.0180159248,
-0.0701300427,
-0.0553610735,
-0.0526897497,
-0.0366760157,
0.0190409012,
0.001763213,
0.0415350609,
-0.0292546172,
-0.0036960097,
0.0109029394,
-0.0115325795,
0.0017936715,
-0.0143105024,
-0.020396132,
0.0212863628,
0.0091916397,
-0.0315804742,
-0.0223987848,
-0.0148358298,
-0.0073515791,
0.0164379217,
0.0064623929,
-0.0014097604,
0.0178226549,
0.0092088217,
0.0267029051,
-0.0441238061,
-0.017100906,
0.0575332493,
0.0038530591,
-0.0402589813,
0.0135533782,
0.1145181954,
0.0300839916,
-0.0644367859,
-0.0502073839,
-0.0206828211,
0.0249883588,
0.047297813,
0.0243726671,
-0.0756279901,
-0.0236112084,
0.0030508917,
-0.0081982361,
-0.0123522915,
-0.0236424431,
0.0003705045,
-0.119050622,
0.0689999759,
0.0263960529,
0.0057608895,
-0.0352674536,
-0.0222733393,
0.0129018957,
0.0001257255,
0.0004165193,
0.039930515,
-0.0250862651,
-0.0202508774,
0.0125877941,
-0.0152837001,
0.0326129794,
0.0758286193,
-0.0361484326,
0.0568725169,
0.0389361978,
0.0175585821,
-0.0203784145,
-0.0612538233,
0.0163671207,
-0.0239641182,
0.008816353,
-0.0052600312,
0.0242457744,
0.0063554491,
0.0282111745,
-0.062376935,
0.0254610255,
0.0016758433,
-0.0296720322,
0.0610263236,
0.066697143,
-0.0543742478,
-0.0285031386,
-0.0274949633,
-0.0025224204,
-0.0194243696,
0.0813191757,
0.0000955363,
-0.0184269082,
-0.0344504192,
-0.0288757365,
-0.0334047899,
0.0006732325,
-0.0373467915,
0.0038297137,
0.011780574,
0.0199851189,
-0.0051632226,
-0.0061005414,
0.0149150155,
0.0264608227,
0.0101122903,
0.0373521857,
0.0067864638,
0.0160580128,
-0.0152557353,
0.022457486,
-0.0746316239,
0.0044687944,
-0.0459676199,
0.0391580649,
0.0440220609,
-0.0270121079,
-0.0211594217,
-0.0089346962,
-0.0125253173,
-0.008575852,
-0.0129477214,
0.0285577159,
0.0179342106,
0.0062223929,
-0.0389293469,
-0.0437092371,
0.0474779531,
0.027424207,
-0.0079633482,
0.0161525533,
0.0321618877,
-0.0153246438,
-0.0084131174,
0.0166320689,
-0.0188660938,
0.0395119786,
0.044071015,
0.0117755784,
-0.0072262203,
-0.0469699316,
0.0416283086,
0.0478579178,
0.0513222553,
0.0248327777,
-0.0068747215,
-0.0089783231,
0.0030462239,
-0.0139194364,
-0.0235637929,
-0.0001519316,
-0.0141718471,
0.0336929075,
-0.0250961538,
-0.0275501944,
0.0326958001,
-0.0084956549,
0.0372367352,
-0.0350194983,
0.0094368234,
0.0332156047,
0.0022440683,
0.0446126126,
-0.0464814901,
-0.0183977112,
0.0104616042,
-0.017695995,
0.0616966076,
-0.0117213205,
0.0907573253,
0.0003104539,
-0.0134892864,
-0.018450357,
-0.0113166207,
-0.0497030877,
-0.0519034825,
0.006842244,
0.0518676639,
0.0419343002,
-0.0041285576,
-0.029914083,
-0.0407166258,
-0.0065682367,
-0.0341960527,
-0.0043385294,
0.0086626764,
-0.0343881957,
0.0662225112,
0.0258411765,
-0.021262588,
0.0212599672,
0.0372862257,
-0.0179053172,
0.0112534268,
-0.0061423471,
-0.0276403669,
-0.0215019416,
-0.037631426,
-0.010343249,
0.0209963452,
-0.029389469,
-0.0379985645,
-0.0909362137,
-0.0216846243,
-0.0211989935,
-0.0027332427,
-0.012692526,
0.000508866,
0.0193240605,
0.0861468315,
0.0061611244,
-0.0135926912,
-0.0510548502,
0.0492075644,
-0.0189627614,
-0.0226057079,
-0.0401667692,
-5.571110008e-33,
-0.0303889457,
-0.0302280169,
0.0266854409,
-0.0009492494,
0.0000981156,
-0.0306144971,
0.0075408164,
-0.0027169245,
-0.0384497829,
0.0102326917,
-0.016282687,
0.0086833779,
0.0056819273,
-0.0042919382,
0.0253510065,
-0.0347403325,
-0.0100625064,
0.0124365054,
-0.0034968229,
0.0213615969,
-0.0102538625,
0.0174831916,
-0.0033415346,
-0.0928216502,
0.0185576957,
0.0129372599,
0.0062879338,
-0.0127819944,
-0.1017602533,
0.0485767461,
-0.0060899546,
0.0559972301,
0.022764774,
-0.0659785941,
0.0104124425,
0.0616456531,
-0.0622767061,
-0.0004808436,
0.0328381769,
-0.056817688,
0.0118073374,
-0.0386361629,
0.0159536786,
0.010763661,
-0.0357619151,
-0.0015909333,
0.031397678,
-0.0445881411,
-0.0523680374,
-0.0483764224,
-0.0402001366,
0.0169552062,
-0.001491861,
0.009366856,
0.0135538429,
0.0319635756,
0.010246546,
0.0704011619,
-0.0583550185,
0.0314227343,
-0.0309570525,
-0.0129500469,
0.0222818926,
-0.0512364767,
-0.0221519768,
0.0770042017,
-0.0173017308,
-0.0014537043,
-0.0410229191,
-0.0506655127,
0.0061978828,
0.0987122208,
0.0311588161,
0.0507175289,
0.0048061223,
-0.0494630411,
-0.0797940791,
-0.0120906364,
0.036449682,
0.0226649549,
0.0481564403,
-0.0131439278,
-0.0427517593,
-0.0117440382,
-0.0511140414,
0.0021313445,
-0.0346518494,
0.0054418924,
0.033085037,
0.0137475887,
0.0539182313,
-0.0381405614,
0.0067193466,
-0.03223015,
0.0053646332,
0.0508421659,
-0.0213375855,
0.0027201583,
-0.0268452708,
0.0508354865,
-0.0414399877,
-0.0316439532,
0.0030541127,
-0.0437795594,
-0.0223912615,
-0.0039499933,
0.0410966761,
-0.0199978147,
-0.0708552524,
-0.0369953327,
-0.0081637036,
0.0187951103,
0.0246621631,
0.0028647028,
0.0107876016,
0.0551840626,
0.0401062518,
0.0267181192,
0.011735972,
-0.0324566476,
-0.0276323538,
-0.0499569476,
0.0174814276,
-0.0257232673,
0.0100020329,
0.0144474395,
-0.004196432,
0.0280530211,
0.0250733495,
0.0216987692,
0.0203895047,
0.0665676147,
2.527e-7,
0.0643652305,
0.0491795763,
-0.0543536022,
0.0089869192,
-0.0081758499,
0.0586930141,
-0.0085295318,
0.0543252528,
0.0830739662,
-0.0295318626,
0.0147481225,
0.0173852202,
0.0458671972,
0.0493354201,
-0.0735703409,
-0.0260378737,
-0.0299151707,
-0.059654057,
-0.0610293336,
0.0242096335,
0.0579109974,
0.1010599434,
0.0397895835,
-0.0183780845,
0.0064192326,
-0.0367269889,
0.0572890975,
-0.0440140218,
-0.0215568524,
-0.0089614354,
0.0560456328,
-0.0353932567,
0.0047272858,
0.0744812414,
0.0205878094,
0.0358631425,
-0.0161369164,
0.0653338358,
0.0129607925,
0.0118503496,
-0.0243426152,
-0.0322883315,
0.0237730462,
-0.0430384018,
0.0755285993,
-0.0138966842,
0.0079464857,
0.0001777808,
-0.0276132654,
-0.0362588614,
0.0205219314,
0.0183552951,
-0.0262008421,
-0.0355350971,
0.016603196,
-0.0063189226,
0.0101004029,
-0.0924474448,
0.0070427414,
0.0386223383,
-0.038980566,
-0.0342610031,
-0.0085579446,
-0.0177762527,
0.0549261719,
-0.1102188975,
0.044671692,
2.009103057e-34,
0.0310069565,
-0.0043910448,
0.0120259225,
0.0234402604,
0.0385431424,
0.0420465432,
-0.021119481,
0.0233920142,
-0.0118121207,
-0.1068706289,
0.0292746034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11753v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11753v2 | Bias in Emotion Recognition with ChatGPT | 2023-10-18T07:28:12 | 2023-12-04T09:05:05 | Naoki Wake, Atsushi Kanehira, Kazuhiro Sasabuchi, Jun Takamatsu, Katsushi Ikeuchi | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL | This technical report explores the ability of ChatGPT in recognizing emotions
from text, which can be the basis of various applications like interactive
chatbots, data annotation, and mental health analysis. While prior research has
shown ChatGPT's basic ability in sentiment analysis, its performance in more
nuanced emotion recognition is not yet explored. Here, we conducted experiments
to evaluate its performance of emotion recognition across different datasets
and emotion labels. Our findings indicate a reasonable level of reproducibility
in its performance, with noticeable improvement through fine-tuning. However,
the performance varies with different emotion labels and datasets, highlighting
an inherent instability and possible bias. The choice of dataset and emotion
labels significantly impacts ChatGPT's emotion recognition performance. This
paper sheds light on the importance of dataset and label selection, and the
potential of fine-tuning in enhancing ChatGPT's emotion recognition
capabilities, providing a groundwork for better integration of emotion analysis
in applications using ChatGPT. | [
0.0267466046,
0.0282125007,
-0.027794892,
0.021596998,
-0.0284987539,
0.0454212837,
0.0085801212,
0.0099768499,
0.0984642282,
-0.0334871188,
-0.0310144424,
0.013327118,
-0.0388171114,
0.0092072207,
-0.0404195599,
-0.0843830556,
0.0202137791,
0.0766432434,
0.073426038,
0.0059439144,
0.0499135442,
0.0314533897,
-0.0253833532,
0.0550972335,
-0.0744245201,
-0.0304840337,
-0.0072758892,
0.0253160689,
0.0503066145,
-0.0384135693,
0.0377866067,
0.0431069434,
-0.0353942104,
0.0261708349,
0.000002093,
-0.0086054513,
-0.0288213678,
0.0064391564,
0.0032116326,
-0.0426680632,
0.1121721342,
0.0124688279,
-0.0124696419,
0.0200709943,
-0.0583427101,
-0.0055633737,
0.0544722266,
0.0719365329,
0.0722302049,
0.0615984723,
-0.0514027737,
0.034175545,
-0.017634498,
0.0187472906,
0.0290658791,
-0.0194540992,
0.0160629824,
0.0485109985,
0.010922729,
-0.038936127,
-0.0082235709,
0.0013875163,
-0.0160765164,
0.0456387997,
-0.0067014229,
0.0128837163,
-0.0713084042,
-0.0542259663,
-0.0296523776,
0.0684573054,
-0.0139072957,
0.010732607,
0.0007856283,
-0.0115680639,
0.0183384083,
-0.0331995636,
-0.0221634209,
-0.0224417485,
-0.028866481,
0.0176513828,
-0.0258572716,
0.0297133941,
-0.0150941908,
0.0157881174,
0.025195729,
0.0238130726,
-0.0245471839,
-0.031246867,
0.0391224287,
0.0258888919,
-0.0276810937,
-0.0028521065,
-0.0033000153,
-0.0175928622,
0.0240053926,
0.0211665463,
-0.0380905643,
-0.0125337932,
-0.0176167637,
-0.060068462,
-0.0601429455,
0.0502621867,
-0.0616872385,
0.0339903384,
0.019354824,
0.0245753601,
0.0427372009,
0.0139424726,
0.0025722173,
-0.0087738466,
-0.071991697,
0.0165425763,
-0.0111731561,
0.0229344014,
0.0015144433,
-0.0348034166,
-0.0897705033,
0.0099436082,
-0.0176747907,
-0.0010686321,
0.0100310966,
-0.0167242847,
0.0054449472,
0.028303219,
-0.0051699742,
0.0161767062,
-0.027370682,
0.0366872065,
0.0006657632,
-0.1168984994,
0.0113552073,
-0.0000945939,
0.0050733108,
-0.0088160057,
0.0202799495,
0.0595455542,
0.0136730308,
-0.0479403026,
-0.0064574061,
-0.0263413843,
-0.011694897,
-0.0501978286,
0.0007713368,
-0.0054199495,
0.0633300319,
0.0160841383,
0.0090830782,
0.0171937421,
0.012961207,
-0.0167136583,
-0.0393335223,
0.0704667047,
-0.0459917486,
-0.034782555,
-0.0055177589,
0.0338760018,
-0.0464964248,
0.0540007167,
0.0120514557,
0.0731097832,
0.0422760323,
-0.0080253007,
0.0279794745,
-0.0102126477,
-0.0210092906,
-0.0454176627,
0.0260108989,
-0.0333169475,
-0.0110089425,
0.0105178384,
-0.0066807335,
0.0265493877,
-0.0434054248,
-0.0115940673,
0.0257182419,
0.0531874113,
-0.0137362983,
0.0449111201,
-0.0794361234,
0.0354856253,
0.0522287898,
-0.0412805527,
-0.0313910767,
0.0242578276,
-0.0161145981,
-0.0256801881,
-0.0091500934,
0.0100435289,
-0.0128126647,
-0.0416045226,
-0.0446596593,
-0.0092689749,
0.0247695595,
-0.0033306838,
0.010908749,
-0.0364012606,
-0.0312544368,
0.0014722135,
0.0458064154,
-0.0680367202,
-0.0540501997,
-0.0552583858,
0.0004680718,
0.0690595508,
0.0279637072,
-0.0474770665,
-0.0283731893,
-0.0021734154,
-0.0048342138,
0.0165063459,
0.0541230477,
0.0225815699,
0.0251411535,
-0.0524459556,
0.0008415486,
0.0411114804,
0.0081903338,
0.0326697603,
-0.0007169276,
0.068711184,
-0.0270374678,
0.0049680932,
0.0111530507,
0.0157722067,
0.040671438,
-0.0161198061,
-0.0120073669,
-0.0069001326,
0.0520124808,
0.0130595472,
-0.0235782899,
-0.0482453257,
0.0049972148,
0.0317596421,
-0.0292703323,
0.0396944322,
-0.0023544182,
-0.0695594177,
0.0243649092,
-0.0219135918,
-0.0261472743,
0.0285546519,
-0.0644026026,
0.0065343305,
0.0141836554,
-0.0184065811,
0.0123943714,
-0.0243484173,
-0.0112270592,
-0.0240737386,
0.063780129,
-0.0136728985,
0.0313870311,
0.025159521,
-0.0313799605,
-0.0318222158,
-0.0075648976,
-0.0066997712,
-0.0075305975,
-0.0423800573,
0.0226932094,
0.0136753954,
0.0092685251,
-0.0013963627,
-0.0087844701,
-0.0724082515,
-0.056253802,
-0.1179412156,
-0.0058067357,
0.0233044792,
0.0010334536,
0.0029264567,
0.0086850189,
-0.0572531894,
0.0010374531,
-0.0290631447,
0.0393402278,
0.0176564176,
0.0261524599,
0.0193154793,
-0.023311032,
0.0229361765,
-0.0608037598,
0.0473257452,
-0.020663267,
-0.0045586773,
0.0361165553,
-0.0441328511,
-0.0109014465,
-0.0033115586,
-0.0643608049,
0.0161689725,
-0.0228154436,
-0.0747802705,
0.0161417387,
-0.0026153,
-0.015123562,
0.0337447077,
0.0010564867,
0.0859988332,
-0.0074233073,
0.0078469999,
-0.0427117199,
0.0359586813,
-0.0318522751,
0.0265653078,
0.0047653327,
-0.0305739753,
-0.0405935533,
0.0490684584,
0.0139943557,
0.0336291119,
-0.0533995964,
0.0267452057,
-0.0001561413,
-0.0146479122,
-0.0075148651,
0.0208548121,
-0.0105454233,
-0.0198097117,
0.0075143711,
-0.0436790511,
0.0299897678,
0.0321913548,
-0.0375063196,
-0.0834130645,
0.0053832135,
-0.0282886922,
0.060322661,
-0.0382732898,
0.0023846289,
0.0036858916,
0.0098768501,
-0.0003021005,
-0.0371152051,
-0.0165013671,
-0.0550541878,
-0.0280375294,
0.0023926855,
-0.022446923,
0.0166879687,
-0.0250371229,
-0.0243825112,
-0.0386791863,
-0.0571603999,
-0.0217319597,
0.0554508753,
-0.0098700598,
-0.0177482683,
-0.0156330317,
0.0130550163,
-0.0187506899,
-0.0171343703,
-0.0303006489,
0.0172654223,
0.0040060496,
0.03023386,
-0.0026561948,
0.0278801359,
0.0322727226,
0.0361824892,
0.0738076121,
0.0072547076,
-0.0202701334,
0.0042698453,
0.0083335973,
-0.0267742183,
0.0349424668,
0.0100602331,
-0.0509257242,
0.0337985978,
-0.0219253357,
0.0431027599,
0.126690194,
0.028387459,
-0.0502868406,
0.0036068566,
-0.0190213192,
0.029673202,
-0.0044190064,
0.0037449375,
-0.0637147352,
-0.0470366776,
-0.0101335458,
0.0318759903,
-0.0234758854,
-0.0362861566,
-0.0149759157,
-0.0406928547,
0.0341106616,
-0.0068242596,
-0.0143908495,
-0.0156929214,
-0.0260659289,
0.0371303111,
-0.0450465269,
0.002296445,
-0.0655237436,
0.0203081556,
-0.0003897484,
0.0349428132,
-0.0723718405,
-0.0326127298,
0.0431512669,
-0.000031936,
0.0444529504,
0.021172097,
0.1083260477,
0.0097412197,
0.00293821,
0.0572530255,
0.0537028499,
0.0012194851,
-0.0271468312,
0.0970742628,
-0.0239890665,
-0.0133385649,
-0.0372739583,
0.0103934715,
-0.016479766,
0.03980501,
0.0183645152,
0.039543055,
-0.0326816365,
-0.0303610116,
-0.0175696835,
0.03843081,
0.0290223956,
0.0499260984,
0.0014558099,
-0.0244960506,
-0.0608995631,
-0.0001273004,
0.0232777987,
0.0229282621,
-0.0599130057,
-0.0173154064,
-0.0203342307,
-0.0404928178,
-0.0621310659,
-0.0981206521,
0.0087677957,
0.0031039389,
-0.0463527367,
-0.0331567079,
-0.0043573356,
0.0476002693,
-0.0218196418,
0.0424057916,
0.0175878536,
-0.0122535611,
0.0159672908,
-0.0112757403,
-0.0034717489,
-0.0337136053,
-0.008337128,
0.0165027454,
-0.030654503,
-0.0288321842,
0.0495681614,
0.0111862971,
0.0205988791,
0.005087967,
-0.0000625419,
-0.0070085176,
0.0091862995,
0.0751700699,
-0.029592881,
-0.0170159396,
0.0513043776,
0.0592566617,
-0.0152510311,
-0.0052511794,
-0.0203241874,
0.0670522302,
0.0029152841,
-0.029276574,
0.0014311689,
-0.0170139335,
-0.0079491697,
0.0360231362,
0.0716545805,
0.0272825751,
-0.0275902618,
-0.0118135903,
-0.0293857567,
-0.0110172527,
0.0103325695,
-0.0463795289,
-0.0365655757,
-0.0277805198,
0.022135416,
-0.0817885846,
-0.0549547337,
-0.0322889648,
-0.0194750726,
-0.0059304964,
0.0277931616,
0.0158165153,
0.023039693,
0.0078656143,
0.0065253661,
0.000989298,
-0.0028985064,
-0.0020045694,
-0.0198833756,
-0.0120781725,
0.0482836291,
0.0104680322,
-0.0282595996,
0.023001289,
0.0478273965,
-0.048893854,
-0.0063377158,
-0.0141623653,
0.0245360751,
0.0021279168,
0.0080603193,
0.0432216786,
-0.0774035454,
0.0127155324,
-0.0027893342,
0.008860372,
-0.0267593767,
-0.004044455,
-0.0087841833,
-0.0261434205,
-0.0500606894,
-0.0304172263,
0.0091354754,
-0.0650132522,
0.0496611372,
0.0217935778,
-0.043620754,
-0.043441765,
-0.0046971166,
0.0596865453,
-0.0534713417,
0.0211765934,
0.0269034933,
-0.04600982,
-0.0394404233,
0.0320338532,
-0.0569796301,
0.0033639742,
-0.0173530541,
0.0358855017,
0.0557234176,
-0.0375481285,
0.0224157684,
-0.0349724106,
-0.011582722,
-0.0719385371,
-0.0138616329,
-0.008775468,
-5.970403399e-33,
0.0156560931,
0.0137104541,
-0.0482988916,
0.0381718911,
-0.0320416987,
0.0311247706,
-0.0187596828,
0.0339461826,
-0.0146360556,
0.0440693162,
-0.026245188,
0.0528395399,
0.0117481211,
-0.0095504951,
-0.0050032167,
-0.0452125892,
0.0117627615,
-0.0206012931,
0.0189015325,
0.0220962819,
0.0156087512,
0.0514977425,
0.0606150255,
-0.1270830184,
0.0270163845,
0.0258330144,
-0.0258936957,
-0.0332847498,
0.0737087429,
0.0319137424,
-0.0167992767,
0.0850161165,
0.0159849934,
0.0125830881,
0.0057665096,
0.0311320368,
-0.0077823596,
-0.0208158307,
-0.0405755118,
0.0283544976,
-0.0210884772,
0.0041680438,
-0.0154308202,
-0.0012221389,
-0.0509161241,
-0.0333754346,
0.0346236229,
-0.0068088518,
0.0176319592,
-0.0246580411,
-0.0143313715,
0.0414769538,
-0.0117024221,
-0.0137246922,
0.0069347452,
0.0613962375,
0.0056248363,
0.0246220678,
-0.0233405624,
-0.0036027418,
-0.020930361,
-0.0351619534,
-0.0130975693,
-0.030920051,
0.030490689,
0.0783305094,
0.0522492751,
0.0180630758,
-0.0232291091,
0.0262067206,
0.0144514553,
0.0384891145,
0.0562508665,
0.0350059234,
-0.0012095578,
-0.0078482497,
-0.0011049628,
0.0216591451,
0.0953382999,
-0.0115550002,
0.0453544892,
0.0176110156,
-0.062125966,
0.0138222398,
0.0380710922,
0.0166621096,
-0.0184083674,
-0.0280064233,
0.0366146117,
-0.0407140553,
0.032946825,
-0.0136575745,
-0.0140264761,
-0.0259684138,
0.0032291333,
0.0248620026,
-0.0511323884,
0.0333903395,
-0.0046650819,
0.0048648599,
-0.011310203,
-0.0185089521,
0.0519144163,
0.0450773127,
0.0598991141,
-0.0347710624,
-0.0029235822,
0.0191109553,
-0.0521763526,
-0.0184489582,
-0.0077864947,
0.0738107711,
-0.0066045765,
-0.0084058251,
-0.0238397662,
-0.0123113012,
-0.0139815258,
0.0017616726,
0.0252182651,
0.0734563023,
-0.0312625915,
-0.0118970452,
-0.0401536338,
-0.0277330242,
-0.0356051698,
-0.0038173671,
-0.0028507998,
-0.0579894893,
-0.018309772,
-0.0538757406,
-0.0082911029,
-0.0234791636,
2.787e-7,
-0.0052156276,
0.0816937089,
-0.0053311684,
-0.0334284902,
0.0135414209,
0.0357315056,
0.0009495317,
0.0520707704,
0.0370687693,
-0.0153261432,
0.0582805015,
0.0056239325,
0.0700595602,
0.0415612385,
-0.0650193319,
-0.0559079014,
-0.0258740205,
-0.0026703821,
-0.0154571943,
0.0612922907,
0.1096218452,
0.087334834,
0.0376319215,
0.023957381,
0.0161390025,
0.0275069233,
0.0217160583,
-0.0514104143,
0.0220453944,
0.0335050672,
0.0090282448,
-0.0082410118,
-0.0014928507,
-0.0011661655,
0.0358957089,
-0.0313670486,
0.0357818194,
0.0250494704,
0.0083978316,
-0.0394465737,
0.0338834524,
0.0343303345,
-0.0161268935,
-0.0255435761,
0.0530267954,
-0.0644479468,
-0.0439517796,
-0.0482903235,
-0.0207139514,
-0.0299551636,
0.0692950562,
0.0033353774,
-0.0444363281,
0.0408597589,
0.0038243779,
-0.0407241099,
-0.042875167,
-0.0844324157,
0.0070843664,
-0.0058342409,
-0.0678425655,
-0.0482189059,
-0.0132806031,
0.0565006398,
0.045762036,
-0.0228097085,
0.0110644633,
2.099486864e-34,
0.0052831955,
-0.0209819898,
-0.0032435751,
0.0210144799,
0.034525007,
0.0255476125,
0.0281051751,
-0.0006086238,
0.025702538,
-0.0369903706,
0.0234656297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11732v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11732v2 | Investigating Uncertainty Calibration of Aligned Language Models under the Multiple-Choice Setting | 2023-10-18T06:07:28 | 2023-11-19T12:40:41 | Guande He, Peng Cui, Jianfei Chen, Wenbo Hu, Jun Zhu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Despite the significant progress made in practical applications of aligned
language models (LMs), they tend to be overconfident in output answers compared
to the corresponding pre-trained LMs. In this work, we systematically evaluate
the impact of the alignment process on logit-based uncertainty calibration of
LMs under the multiple-choice setting. We first conduct a thoughtful empirical
study on how aligned LMs differ in calibration from their pre-trained
counterparts. Experimental results reveal that there are two distinct
uncertainties in LMs under the multiple-choice setting, which are responsible
for the answer decision and the format preference of the LMs, respectively.
Then, we investigate the role of these two uncertainties on aligned LM's
calibration through fine-tuning in simple synthetic alignment schemes and
conclude that one reason for aligned LMs' overconfidence is the conflation of
these two types of uncertainty. Furthermore, we examine the utility of common
post-hoc calibration methods for aligned LMs and propose an easy-to-implement
and sample-efficient method to calibrate aligned LMs. We hope our findings
could provide insights into the design of more reliable alignment processes for
LMs. | [
0.0095438333,
0.0520312861,
-0.0108039221,
0.0141747659,
-0.0244455636,
0.0029886507,
0.0126688816,
-0.0365534127,
-0.0095777083,
-0.0430831686,
-0.0123735126,
-0.0851995647,
0.031936489,
-0.0365875438,
0.023375107,
-0.006769889,
0.0606686883,
-0.0095904814,
0.0219623372,
-0.0089419922,
0.017297497,
0.0018525212,
-0.0218650959,
0.0034199182,
0.008267154,
-0.0319440961,
-0.0125685409,
-0.0068070157,
0.0224436894,
-0.0096168518,
0.0305684227,
0.0920704156,
0.0024859132,
0.0613597073,
0.0000019204,
-0.0479899496,
-0.0143475207,
-0.027134994,
-0.0338679068,
0.0677538887,
0.0192890521,
0.047484912,
-0.0182401333,
0.0338850878,
-0.0431516282,
-0.0383728556,
0.0650495067,
-0.0316137895,
0.0082631605,
0.0576559752,
0.0118740331,
-0.0146174161,
0.0253200363,
0.0013855036,
-0.048330687,
-0.0216793288,
0.0122284852,
0.0111310864,
-0.0296068508,
0.0181736164,
-0.0002809255,
0.0156569313,
-0.0202435926,
0.0092433402,
0.000902012,
-0.0100592552,
-0.0474737734,
-0.0285181887,
-0.0260012764,
0.0257295631,
0.046843864,
-0.0404509902,
-0.0558009818,
-0.0521037728,
0.0104380203,
0.0168513935,
-0.0300526116,
0.0176434368,
0.0179553125,
0.0262821075,
0.0356297158,
-0.0232903734,
0.0064098542,
0.015589511,
0.0077466462,
0.0634451285,
0.0268422645,
-0.0310759135,
-0.0044749519,
0.0394989513,
-0.0351698808,
-0.0551758185,
-0.0150046749,
0.020370096,
-0.0306427684,
0.0357833877,
-0.0619442463,
-0.0497160181,
0.0131509677,
-0.0360677689,
0.0308285635,
0.0306995921,
0.0181107633,
-0.0072864625,
0.0174607299,
0.1088612825,
0.0015549377,
0.0144562135,
-0.0697478801,
0.0400112905,
0.0136459991,
-0.0133578181,
0.009579624,
0.0095924679,
-0.002210872,
0.0001463004,
-0.0802907273,
0.0158776566,
0.0125056123,
0.0179875996,
-0.0153279165,
0.0037540027,
-0.0140740015,
0.0028112496,
-0.0428863391,
0.0951186717,
0.0048068962,
0.0377414711,
0.0285255108,
-0.0542279333,
0.0078198072,
0.0234036967,
-0.029344311,
-0.0445654541,
-0.011447208,
0.0455918573,
-0.0282910466,
-0.0368211307,
0.0239873268,
0.0115625076,
-0.0579731986,
-0.0522228107,
-0.0090072127,
-0.0735572726,
0.0206668694,
0.0449765883,
0.005948056,
-0.023175966,
0.003414744,
-0.0009382136,
-0.0162670258,
0.030601969,
-0.0043031741,
0.0426808,
0.001498559,
-0.0320041887,
0.0324390605,
0.05203126,
0.0494632386,
0.0043648346,
0.0382826701,
-0.0603770465,
0.0007509544,
0.0559640452,
-0.0143739264,
-0.012652915,
-0.0076998207,
0.0118436869,
0.0119882552,
0.0367558412,
0.0196688846,
0.0607397929,
0.0169654284,
-0.0003516862,
0.067184262,
0.0150639703,
0.036404334,
-0.0230800565,
-0.0285824686,
-0.0133266514,
0.0575915985,
0.0446507931,
-0.0390412845,
0.0047913715,
-0.0466578789,
0.0456142165,
0.0272815209,
0.0411297381,
0.0114422673,
-0.0508402884,
-0.0779452026,
0.017759148,
-0.0253974311,
0.0331761762,
0.0373455808,
-0.0623424537,
-0.0291468836,
0.0421637222,
0.0023451594,
-0.0416697972,
0.0077803927,
-0.0214226805,
0.0295830276,
0.0137313027,
0.0291411486,
0.0014626292,
-0.0748446286,
0.0086063128,
-0.0010225398,
0.0645064786,
0.0970474407,
0.0018699645,
-0.0235526394,
-0.0503194816,
-0.0136325397,
-0.0000142431,
0.0077949679,
-0.0124287857,
0.0274183005,
0.00337551,
-0.023234373,
-0.0123841371,
-0.0418661572,
0.0203831419,
0.0027334862,
-0.0536952578,
-0.0419806764,
-0.0179818366,
0.0133659905,
0.0208614077,
-0.0036129723,
0.0430327617,
0.0324285291,
0.0431468412,
0.0090570794,
-0.0169672668,
-0.0381356962,
0.0118880365,
0.0875877589,
-0.0002811599,
-0.0276611578,
0.0053774533,
-0.0312744975,
-0.0450443439,
-0.033624053,
-0.0214327127,
-0.0183443129,
-0.0204892308,
0.0763112679,
-0.0407072268,
-0.0079204421,
-0.0975653827,
0.0513535626,
0.0035720437,
0.0544695295,
-0.0050985725,
-0.0023336892,
0.0245583076,
-0.0262298025,
-0.0400277451,
0.0096597793,
-0.0091431085,
0.0178762227,
0.0430216752,
-0.0205847714,
-0.044551041,
-0.0335112177,
-0.0490900129,
0.012700974,
0.0054569039,
0.0316845067,
0.0309345089,
-0.0038122437,
-0.0160137899,
0.0315040201,
-0.0648100302,
0.0023303765,
0.0120536899,
0.02813874,
0.0180459861,
-0.0147588253,
0.0013598057,
-0.0799143687,
-0.0236639157,
-0.0532809384,
-0.007072879,
0.0142094633,
0.017021928,
-0.0786606967,
0.0336189456,
-0.0558066256,
-0.003840182,
0.0057132253,
-0.0369442999,
0.0385655575,
-0.0010548797,
0.0284718461,
0.0333334655,
0.0240811035,
-0.0032045117,
0.0689946786,
-0.0003896141,
-0.0585351326,
0.0042038723,
-0.0319763534,
-0.0393993668,
-0.0196737126,
-0.051249329,
-0.0169622451,
0.1012386531,
0.0377149954,
-0.0106730862,
-0.0481053554,
0.0132551296,
-0.0300903972,
-0.0048521645,
-0.0274238735,
0.0110944398,
-0.0377915688,
0.0532183833,
0.0002139604,
-0.0677163452,
0.0943995938,
-0.0479923524,
0.0212298501,
-0.0620613359,
0.0057678339,
-0.0050629051,
-0.0048027486,
-0.021857582,
-0.0186815802,
0.0114124194,
-0.0021206406,
-0.113306269,
-0.0186884496,
0.0497467667,
-0.0732124522,
0.0723605007,
-0.0500503555,
-0.0101827746,
-0.0355096124,
-0.0111233648,
-0.0416858979,
-0.0433364175,
-0.0262301918,
-0.0093610659,
0.0372733995,
-0.0056851245,
-0.0228730403,
-0.0055679879,
0.0133500556,
-0.006749067,
-0.065084286,
0.0275440775,
-0.0174806863,
0.0421755649,
0.0890977383,
0.0164759103,
0.0648045167,
-0.0303439833,
0.013000383,
0.0230177473,
0.0442971103,
0.0388367847,
-0.0039123632,
-0.0311799422,
0.0848954469,
-0.0202262234,
-0.0342417173,
0.040183682,
0.0881299898,
0.0051891962,
-0.0042246482,
0.1284315735,
0.0468174294,
0.0030601833,
-0.0176620167,
-0.0415933244,
0.0461180173,
0.0026599972,
0.0320228375,
-0.0596389137,
-0.0136729125,
-0.0228992924,
-0.0003113587,
0.0049242293,
0.0083241947,
-0.0077307066,
-0.1126493216,
-0.0251439903,
0.0430077538,
-0.0668432266,
-0.0046921489,
-0.012817164,
0.0206563808,
-0.0000676136,
0.0627113357,
0.0496436618,
-0.0172734875,
0.0268693324,
0.0538714528,
-0.0331932604,
-0.0208609421,
-0.0198314786,
-0.0487430319,
0.0852168202,
0.0346529372,
-0.007449504,
-0.018503055,
-0.046276737,
0.0274994578,
-0.0129232109,
-0.0252649207,
-0.0016000858,
-0.0115581611,
-0.0005887978,
0.0086959228,
-0.0282172374,
-0.0093531683,
-0.0159188826,
0.0059097479,
-0.0035201167,
0.0688132718,
-0.0048676282,
-0.0027837541,
-0.0216373429,
0.0003241105,
-0.0166486055,
0.0662469417,
0.0088845836,
-0.0404874496,
-0.0192240179,
-0.0324505791,
0.0174362939,
0.001442346,
0.0184924956,
0.0443017296,
-0.0227125548,
-0.0006185885,
-0.0401849523,
-0.0608204082,
0.0202150177,
-0.0066810916,
0.0048718364,
-0.0078574801,
0.0025382622,
-0.0111525273,
-0.0307875406,
0.0294901822,
0.0027717417,
0.0385066904,
-0.0641829073,
0.0157887246,
-0.0015002368,
0.0022096783,
0.0119466726,
0.0410251394,
-0.0884691477,
-0.1095049307,
0.013325138,
0.0185237862,
0.0237552058,
-0.0122494604,
0.0102999685,
-0.0461933464,
-0.0163802728,
-0.0005520391,
0.0210519489,
0.0371573567,
-0.0139018772,
0.001490679,
-0.014593021,
0.0091398163,
-0.0187780019,
-0.0328907631,
0.0299146511,
0.0655941442,
-0.0234357622,
-0.0958396569,
0.0295490455,
0.0302841533,
0.0846516415,
-0.0356207155,
-0.0375346728,
-0.007772957,
0.0061068418,
-0.03743257,
-0.0238002129,
0.0122735118,
-0.0541655906,
0.0420833007,
-0.0093962364,
-0.0226011667,
0.0046423217,
-0.0418554619,
0.0568922497,
-0.0328557491,
-0.0100029605,
0.017328456,
0.0166059919,
0.024953397,
0.0078249853,
-0.0433201268,
0.0036418326,
-0.0078294687,
0.0551145151,
0.0344942808,
0.0801184028,
-0.0162527524,
-0.0021736389,
0.0296839681,
-0.0002460611,
-0.0490405075,
-0.0171180144,
-0.0518401861,
-0.0117639443,
0.0220078621,
-0.0198426712,
0.0651108176,
0.0012125368,
0.004725493,
-0.0473943055,
0.0293712355,
0.0020261847,
0.0145648019,
0.0820224211,
0.0183290839,
-0.0186605919,
-0.0090288175,
0.0449630618,
-0.0033526567,
0.0043532024,
-0.0471452139,
-0.0217606351,
-0.0201042164,
-0.0243388582,
-0.0007090123,
0.0231227558,
-0.0375587419,
-0.0292895287,
-0.0529651791,
-0.0574280918,
0.0079866517,
0.0545560457,
-0.0007422623,
-0.0174024366,
-0.0156781785,
0.0686897635,
-0.0387794375,
-0.0335511267,
-0.0101304054,
0.0209524669,
-0.0410300419,
-0.0039230064,
-0.0511598065,
-6.222965707e-33,
-0.0470948033,
-0.0148754576,
0.0099370768,
-0.0432052799,
-0.0232191607,
-0.0054568299,
0.0050165062,
0.0562834069,
-0.0378324315,
-0.0177763756,
-0.0260574464,
-0.0000557537,
0.0228822306,
0.0228359681,
0.0296137184,
-0.0323618352,
-0.0224062838,
-0.003255253,
-0.034968935,
-0.0778422505,
0.0259975176,
-0.0189211611,
0.0901577249,
-0.029961329,
0.0514260754,
-0.0153798712,
-0.0174373686,
0.0015648316,
-0.0422995314,
0.0648155063,
-0.0021228732,
0.0439280011,
0.0050993562,
-0.003662647,
-0.0018131452,
0.0247559603,
-0.0103959609,
-0.0450661965,
0.0746239573,
0.0533102229,
0.0139199477,
-0.0176236909,
0.013759004,
-0.0173067786,
-0.0632948726,
-0.0161713623,
0.0278187227,
-0.0360665396,
-0.009561317,
0.0160019472,
-0.0351411551,
-0.0050216741,
0.0180058964,
0.0076788701,
-0.0317383483,
0.0588018708,
0.0191089828,
0.007129102,
-0.0430282727,
0.0314644687,
0.0312154796,
0.0619651563,
0.0941520184,
0.0510488264,
-0.0079805739,
0.0413425379,
-0.0068306508,
-0.0433060229,
-0.0135848718,
0.0088032037,
0.0334001072,
-0.0320219211,
0.0859568045,
0.0729051977,
0.0111636519,
0.0111546479,
-0.0471724235,
0.0436789021,
0.0509537049,
-0.0050514624,
0.0211238619,
0.0298026819,
-0.0660186931,
-0.0327544212,
-0.0422566496,
0.0041171461,
-0.040784549,
-0.0174725894,
0.0145878484,
-0.0464133061,
-0.0110532753,
-0.005114798,
0.0330400914,
-0.0234000366,
-0.0348003246,
-0.0101031102,
-0.0142974453,
0.0374086648,
-0.0229663178,
0.0368984863,
-0.0414116941,
-0.0007430153,
0.0244828425,
-0.0008636583,
0.0051880023,
0.0378388949,
-0.0076958071,
-0.0109154712,
-0.0672723651,
0.0040848199,
-0.0171217173,
-0.0219965652,
0.0299107712,
-0.0624453947,
0.0528009869,
-0.0000702481,
-0.0008631576,
0.0397610925,
0.0101401322,
0.0110073918,
-0.0231508259,
-0.033355426,
-0.0105025265,
0.0082002971,
-0.0146158533,
0.0224640723,
0.0183772352,
-0.013892333,
-0.0028688237,
-0.0089854244,
-0.0096140858,
0.0166485906,
2.522e-7,
0.0762943178,
0.0434183739,
0.0317425095,
0.0210712459,
-0.0072334893,
0.0248153098,
-0.0200533066,
0.0088011492,
0.0590947494,
-0.0089625735,
-0.0001789545,
-0.0240380485,
0.0500716344,
0.0220990367,
-0.0098534198,
-0.0197502896,
-0.0336641073,
0.0576063879,
-0.0184381567,
0.0381208993,
0.0454856716,
0.0722244084,
0.0073953336,
0.0173533335,
-0.0771525353,
0.0101555316,
0.0461406298,
-0.0293545108,
-0.0305058118,
0.0586245731,
0.0218581278,
-0.0256721266,
-0.003594612,
0.0138685033,
-0.0053865775,
0.0217788536,
0.0268101003,
0.0624644645,
0.0069636251,
-0.00648659,
-0.020212343,
-0.0253364872,
-0.0038254727,
-0.066108875,
0.0483945534,
-0.0343861021,
-0.0054156277,
-0.0411884077,
-0.0178355314,
-0.0127597544,
0.0464463606,
-0.0175842121,
0.0030209552,
0.0095748734,
0.0286203828,
0.0160629582,
-0.0271581803,
-0.0275179762,
-0.0523771569,
0.0405733697,
-0.0127638942,
-0.0398475938,
0.0003606758,
-0.0009483792,
0.0199256036,
-0.0781879053,
-0.00390567,
2.197348376e-34,
0.0054748729,
-0.0079207504,
0.0181910265,
0.024088107,
0.0114478208,
-0.0263607595,
0.0237268656,
0.0332932547,
0.0358057804,
-0.1049402207,
-0.0106216613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11722v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11722v3 | Quantifying Self-diagnostic Atomic Knowledge in Chinese Medical Foundation Model: A Computational Analysis | 2023-10-18T05:42:22 | 2024-04-02T02:48:22 | Yaxin Fan, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang, Peifeng Li, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Foundation Models (FMs) have the potential to revolutionize the way users
self-diagnose through search engines by offering direct and efficient
suggestions. Recent studies primarily focused on the quality of FMs evaluated
by GPT-4 or their ability to pass medical exams, no studies have quantified the
extent of self-diagnostic atomic knowledge stored in FMs' memory, which is the
basis of foundation models to provide factual and reliable suggestions. In this
paper, we first constructed a benchmark of Self-diagnostic Atomic Knowledge
(SdAK), including the most common types of atomic knowledge involved in
self-diagnostic queries, with 17 atomic types and a total of 14, 048 pieces of
atomic knowledge. Then, we evaluated both generic and open-source Chinese
medical FMs on the benchmark. The experimental results showcase that generic
FMs perform better than medical FMs in terms of self-diagnostic atomic
knowledge. Error analysis revealed that both generic and medical FMs are
sycophantic, e.g., always catering to users' claims when it comes to unknown
knowledge. We further explored different types of data commonly adopted for
fine-tuning medical FMs, i.e., real-world, semi-distilled, and distilled data,
and found that distilled data can benefit FMs most. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/SDAK. | [
0.0670837536,
0.0151285399,
-0.022551382,
-0.0321182534,
0.0123722572,
-0.0179660618,
0.0090978472,
0.0592032298,
0.0538759567,
0.0041853278,
0.003596744,
-0.0347863697,
-0.032073345,
0.0460563079,
-0.0128312474,
-0.0096226726,
0.0375863649,
0.0186507329,
0.0200212188,
-0.0156614017,
-0.0085683605,
-0.0331860259,
-0.0040487815,
0.0113787474,
0.0180160645,
-0.0367999896,
0.0130110877,
0.0002206049,
-0.0041974308,
-0.0986622497,
-0.0186352301,
0.0479543358,
-0.0528684184,
0.0045239311,
0.0000021952,
-0.0570868738,
-0.0385609306,
-0.0228433385,
-0.0409659557,
0.0015930458,
0.012196824,
0.0284517668,
0.0004222649,
0.0503241159,
-0.0353455432,
-0.0143878246,
0.0199072547,
0.0582572743,
0.0379885025,
0.041870378,
0.0099320887,
0.0348120369,
0.0246649012,
-0.0091486517,
0.0439983793,
-0.0023888643,
0.0339464024,
0.006727579,
-0.0006561077,
-0.0217172392,
-0.0168468989,
0.0178373009,
-0.0120417308,
0.04096644,
-0.0102368249,
0.0315857604,
-0.0397992283,
-0.0106643746,
0.0198315419,
0.0598856211,
0.0693140402,
-0.0218150765,
0.0239867456,
0.0104217827,
0.0091698598,
0.0381908715,
-0.0093710674,
-0.0196940191,
-0.0506684929,
0.0013765012,
0.0334641188,
0.0422528274,
0.0647362098,
-0.0036461705,
-0.0425315946,
0.0734734759,
-0.030348165,
-0.0573529936,
0.0189026166,
-0.0477512702,
-0.0010358955,
-0.0434861183,
0.0390216745,
0.0112153254,
-0.023628071,
-0.0120907919,
-0.00034401,
0.0014339576,
0.0770483539,
-0.0468253531,
-0.0123827718,
0.0197188556,
-0.031247139,
0.0371214487,
-0.0338689573,
-0.0018256032,
-0.022597855,
0.0384629853,
-0.0751621574,
0.0200191941,
-0.0697176233,
-0.0099725695,
-0.017381113,
0.0382068232,
0.0811856985,
-0.002842467,
-0.0716223344,
-0.0000429219,
-0.0089397663,
-0.0036905706,
-0.0426834077,
0.018569408,
0.0076695257,
0.0350031219,
-0.0740978271,
0.0059583453,
-0.0612825342,
-0.036805097,
0.0034797997,
-0.0203345381,
0.0238303952,
-0.0095493952,
0.0092798397,
0.0099747367,
0.05855719,
-0.0164849106,
0.032027062,
-0.0300309304,
-0.0302612241,
-0.0592587031,
0.0138114216,
-0.0180932861,
0.003408663,
-0.0350072756,
-0.0052124183,
0.0332183801,
0.0246564839,
-0.0227948688,
0.0142803332,
0.0005661807,
-0.0223244559,
0.0362390503,
-0.0572959781,
0.0315934643,
-0.0117057664,
0.043694295,
0.0290600061,
0.021276908,
-0.0259737428,
-0.003189455,
0.0461773574,
-0.0434638262,
0.0209950283,
-0.0469058454,
0.0332027599,
-0.0026127582,
0.0170286149,
0.0083968127,
-0.0254766196,
0.0466048978,
-0.051442191,
0.0290396195,
0.0086717308,
0.013069883,
0.0184647348,
0.0503019914,
0.0614915863,
0.0321145318,
-0.0242635477,
-0.0218282063,
0.0305413231,
0.0150734968,
-0.0293602832,
0.0256971288,
-0.0610590912,
0.0122192251,
0.0000538249,
-0.0077086752,
-0.0458162166,
-0.0516078919,
-0.0628004447,
0.0049739899,
-0.0159630496,
0.019486554,
0.0324121378,
-0.0388586223,
0.0087244492,
0.0342885852,
0.011105136,
-0.0253090598,
-0.0368970297,
-0.0768594742,
0.0466763563,
0.1020944193,
0.0346266963,
-0.0582740419,
-0.0360223167,
0.0317032523,
-0.0357333012,
-0.0529456399,
0.0310189538,
-0.0141211348,
-0.0266800113,
-0.0263263024,
-0.0330568925,
0.050527487,
0.0183462631,
-0.0337730423,
0.0048655621,
0.0437577702,
-0.0054914481,
-0.0553476065,
0.014172649,
0.006524506,
-0.0210449398,
-0.0035955992,
-0.0138410609,
0.0227339808,
0.0319714062,
0.0355274305,
0.0203513727,
0.0312370639,
0.0366309956,
0.0102585545,
-0.0502190292,
-0.0121693853,
-0.0235844795,
0.0425643548,
-0.0028167432,
-0.0274552405,
0.0140438853,
0.0073797037,
-0.0140629727,
-0.0604015365,
-0.0430517606,
-0.0164743867,
0.0139144287,
-0.0208365712,
0.0122733647,
0.0056402371,
0.0064807213,
0.0072081853,
0.0523419417,
-0.0416219682,
0.0127866762,
-0.0243094545,
-0.0078914873,
0.0301314089,
-0.0729251504,
-0.0498853922,
-0.0422922932,
-0.0171146225,
0.0403458066,
0.0202463958,
-0.0128308041,
-0.0588425435,
0.0325850993,
-0.1308260262,
-0.011595035,
-0.0070406245,
-0.0028983711,
0.022457039,
0.0082807587,
-0.0100714024,
-0.0198073778,
-0.0446305797,
0.0262066629,
0.0159282982,
0.0311837681,
0.0208862741,
0.0297612511,
-0.0078090644,
-0.0262312982,
-0.0215523411,
-0.0683777705,
-0.0304849129,
0.0225865953,
0.0196562074,
0.0022355414,
-0.0040823026,
-0.0382896885,
-0.0016198896,
-0.0125428056,
-0.0474386998,
0.0002200716,
-0.0665415004,
-0.0806920603,
0.0630614758,
0.0211307611,
0.0084899236,
0.0497656278,
0.0237273723,
-0.0133881895,
0.010819288,
-0.0155299399,
0.0288981851,
0.0266396366,
-0.0492621176,
0.030558059,
0.0297935531,
0.0270913951,
0.0012801705,
-0.0384495407,
0.0163790621,
-0.0156620629,
-0.0259399209,
-0.0449166968,
0.0383497924,
0.0046620183,
0.0544108972,
0.0228299815,
-0.0108975144,
0.1037030071,
0.0187516473,
0.0687382892,
-0.0293940753,
-0.0365941823,
0.0141656874,
0.0170955658,
-0.018944798,
0.040805269,
0.0574481934,
-0.0094693396,
0.0031527714,
0.0035498999,
0.019397052,
-0.0642290786,
0.0134768616,
0.0233895537,
0.0079100812,
0.033424817,
-0.0542172827,
-0.0304906275,
-0.0560063086,
-0.0138134034,
-0.0127764549,
0.0034909542,
-0.0143548511,
-0.0393527634,
0.0340475403,
-0.0016941818,
0.0452954359,
0.0211339686,
-0.0332324505,
0.0084963134,
-0.0062485547,
-0.0256203245,
-0.0342719778,
0.0659163073,
-0.0038158891,
0.06695503,
0.0787315518,
0.0799631625,
-0.0037738625,
0.0101922872,
0.0098692179,
0.0172029678,
-0.0284738597,
-0.0348343588,
0.0269537102,
-0.0262662582,
-0.0403290801,
-0.0039849975,
0.104105182,
0.0383965373,
-0.0142189264,
0.0085173473,
-0.0229879599,
-0.0875566602,
0.0254179351,
-0.0041897609,
-0.057649076,
-0.015536855,
-0.0026075535,
0.0418168493,
-0.0401013754,
-0.0503368787,
0.057880424,
-0.0171871372,
0.0086020268,
-0.0138066625,
-0.0166361183,
-0.0039571212,
-0.0471912809,
-0.0159137975,
-0.0080706337,
-0.0395808704,
0.0084986296,
-0.0439459123,
-0.0022742827,
-0.0112790698,
-0.0608930252,
-0.0559482127,
0.0721486285,
-0.0313438103,
0.0364991836,
0.059388712,
0.0228714645,
-0.022388313,
-0.0196441729,
-0.0385440215,
-0.0070366636,
0.0416071936,
-0.0274133943,
0.0828098133,
-0.0015306318,
0.0200896505,
-0.0512440875,
0.0166041013,
-0.047129944,
0.0176131725,
0.0334769674,
0.046573095,
-0.032321915,
-0.0262735821,
-0.0369660296,
-0.003592165,
-0.0053077214,
0.0845768079,
-0.0076861088,
-0.0158487875,
0.0093862107,
0.0308233742,
0.0422903262,
0.0278062411,
0.0092515526,
0.0385300815,
0.013672512,
0.0024669496,
-0.0710975081,
-0.041366972,
-0.0179305431,
0.0109390849,
0.0055776983,
0.0203805491,
-0.0103104329,
0.0117671844,
-0.0616318211,
0.0254586432,
0.0106476462,
-0.0113214441,
-0.1072105914,
0.0060143438,
0.0470606312,
-0.0219509974,
-0.0000487442,
0.0169896297,
0.0429649167,
0.0124496687,
0.0316408575,
0.0252158996,
0.0290566385,
-0.0445407666,
-0.0490446761,
-0.0494512543,
0.0395647436,
0.0204705335,
-0.0268513523,
-0.0396998785,
-0.0017562847,
-0.0574665554,
-0.0007012454,
-0.0096048154,
-0.0118142851,
0.0099061215,
-0.015251697,
0.0181945302,
-0.0320790894,
-0.0022075581,
0.064306207,
0.0894851238,
0.0978390276,
0.0161200985,
0.0294697676,
0.0181843545,
0.025468329,
-0.0048990929,
-0.0072194431,
0.0051452769,
-0.0044301744,
0.0496016964,
-0.0001624422,
0.0108192302,
-0.0204501599,
-0.0312131252,
-0.0344013162,
-0.042706199,
0.0020472647,
0.0134679331,
0.0276455246,
0.0475838222,
-0.0331097841,
-0.0027508945,
-0.0032430652,
0.074808605,
0.0469405018,
-0.0046764314,
0.0997479931,
-0.0095749302,
0.0054456382,
0.009164976,
0.0565966032,
-0.0696875975,
-0.0818822682,
-0.007821261,
0.0012541002,
0.0170528404,
0.0108088329,
-0.0227230545,
-0.0435237773,
0.016465025,
-0.0267326906,
-0.0115188388,
-0.0015398246,
0.0121963443,
0.0472729988,
0.0244727191,
0.0018695326,
-0.0117725627,
0.082926847,
-0.0189919472,
0.0197483972,
-0.0451348573,
-0.07871373,
-0.0300094746,
0.0289486106,
-0.0240520034,
0.0710323974,
-0.0819457248,
-0.013767736,
-0.097918123,
-0.0376000851,
0.0226213373,
0.0318851136,
0.0074673388,
-0.0217543598,
0.0417359881,
0.0885834098,
0.009737391,
-0.0238456801,
-0.0235814694,
0.0082116947,
-0.0663267523,
0.0216292776,
0.0307049025,
-6.87733329e-33,
0.0032849235,
-0.0326058716,
0.0143494094,
-0.0477623567,
0.0354091413,
0.0102616921,
-0.0201928951,
0.0197825339,
-0.0126820616,
0.0071476628,
-0.0381305739,
0.0284312051,
0.0110410536,
-0.0050703003,
0.0267068949,
-0.0044215126,
0.0495677516,
0.0334757715,
-0.0616142116,
0.0247402526,
0.0738605857,
0.0205296297,
0.0029631362,
-0.0445757098,
-0.0182407461,
-0.0214437619,
0.0200475045,
0.0234564915,
-0.0630693734,
0.0655678436,
0.0057920711,
0.033564046,
0.0386858024,
0.0077207205,
0.0370197743,
-0.0243252274,
-0.0996186733,
-0.0496476293,
0.0152846789,
-0.0389438681,
0.0118382843,
-0.0014138918,
0.0116504943,
-0.0319155641,
-0.0094414707,
0.010789888,
0.0370007791,
-0.0082243206,
0.0172879454,
-0.0495824628,
0.0506627895,
0.0213779397,
0.0091416696,
0.0273825545,
-0.0069626356,
0.0358561352,
-0.0412760824,
-0.0292699654,
-0.0290197711,
0.021255726,
0.0181613453,
0.0436576866,
0.0258965623,
-0.0027378022,
-0.032831613,
0.0181004331,
0.052294489,
-0.0068502282,
0.0080652786,
-0.0372306295,
-0.0104288133,
0.0403438658,
0.0369851179,
0.0391706787,
0.0377138406,
-0.0447396301,
-0.0483437218,
0.0378632843,
0.0190348271,
0.02633675,
0.0234256331,
-0.0157818552,
-0.1070115268,
-0.020462228,
-0.0185952745,
-0.0116816452,
-0.0524132326,
-0.0549788773,
0.0402979441,
0.0145596163,
-0.0323707573,
0.0038434253,
0.0093338117,
-0.034204293,
0.0212718882,
-0.0199865494,
0.0330449939,
0.0117999231,
-0.0340278223,
-0.0061027831,
-0.0637773424,
-0.0029115728,
-0.0253356211,
-0.0423648767,
0.0257187169,
0.0206205267,
0.0071488759,
-0.0128415022,
-0.040861886,
-0.014902316,
0.0382388122,
-0.0494665951,
-0.0203312691,
-0.0780156404,
0.0322720632,
0.0498168021,
0.0136751793,
-0.0095077893,
0.0514249876,
0.0428947322,
-0.0946480185,
-0.0399671532,
-0.0055977427,
0.0056325435,
0.0235998873,
-0.0146493353,
-0.0646093786,
0.0022801992,
0.0385624953,
-0.0604649596,
-0.0146765942,
0.0168806557,
3.033e-7,
0.0343556292,
0.0378955416,
-0.0175532997,
-0.0336199291,
0.0028844026,
0.0554770567,
-0.0112907402,
0.0004489559,
0.0140375393,
-0.024452053,
0.0512425266,
-0.0001021518,
-0.0092388401,
0.0458331704,
-0.0312431846,
0.0208115727,
-0.0244013872,
-0.0339016542,
-0.0005875229,
0.0098885689,
-0.0278448295,
0.0174066704,
0.0036005895,
-0.0391293019,
0.0471403673,
-0.042543374,
0.0292022973,
-0.0190909281,
0.0157341305,
0.0447453745,
0.0563510954,
0.03430105,
-0.0044495678,
0.060829442,
-0.0167220626,
-0.0155674359,
0.0058132624,
0.0251525417,
0.007985563,
0.0300702304,
-0.0040779668,
-0.0305532441,
0.044300884,
-0.0649453923,
0.0717299804,
0.0059053977,
-0.0356849506,
0.042124413,
-0.0041041225,
-0.047336515,
0.0362413451,
-0.0126981651,
-0.0472275205,
0.0102745658,
-0.0178133398,
0.0586296506,
-0.0061379406,
-0.0400412381,
0.0162954088,
0.0100299027,
-0.0075232792,
-0.085022293,
0.009704778,
-0.0157820061,
-0.0123134786,
-0.1088818759,
-0.0189556684,
2.925727838e-34,
0.0201712791,
0.0316446163,
-0.0001645171,
-0.0524149127,
0.0119831068,
-0.001911852,
0.0108459489,
-0.000287792,
0.0198301729,
-0.0718745217,
-0.0208106209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11721v1 | Chain-of-Thought Tuning: Masked Language Models can also Think Step By Step in Natural Language Understanding | 2023-10-18T05:39:20 | 2023-10-18T05:39:20 | Caoyun Fan, Jidong Tian, Yitian Li, Wenqing Chen, Hao He, Yaohui Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) is a technique that guides Large Language Models
(LLMs) to decompose complex tasks into multi-step reasoning through
intermediate steps in natural language form. Briefly, CoT enables LLMs to think
step by step. However, although many Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks
also require thinking step by step, LLMs perform less well than small-scale
Masked Language Models (MLMs). To migrate CoT from LLMs to MLMs, we propose
Chain-of-Thought Tuning (CoTT), a two-step reasoning framework based on prompt
tuning, to implement step-by-step thinking for MLMs on NLU tasks. From the
perspective of CoT, CoTT's two-step framework enables MLMs to implement task
decomposition; CoTT's prompt tuning allows intermediate steps to be used in
natural language form. Thereby, the success of CoT can be extended to NLU tasks
through MLMs. To verify the effectiveness of CoTT, we conduct experiments on
two NLU tasks: hierarchical classification and relation extraction, and the
results show that CoTT outperforms baselines and achieves state-of-the-art
performance. | [
0.0626714155,
0.0291206948,
-0.011474276,
0.0594870858,
-0.0459136814,
0.0531903878,
0.0488179028,
-0.0303864516,
0.0283715464,
-0.0840305388,
-0.0133227557,
-0.0207154322,
-0.0147248851,
0.0416856334,
-0.0163625591,
-0.0758701265,
0.040151298,
-0.0564364791,
-0.0101472093,
0.0192617662,
-0.032658767,
0.0352095477,
-0.0249227677,
-0.0031152766,
0.028287394,
-0.041171357,
-0.0166960526,
0.0040902458,
0.0278097726,
-0.0481645055,
0.0003661429,
0.0409921594,
0.0490841232,
0.0418593958,
0.0000022944,
-0.0765890479,
-0.0146448808,
-0.0085753594,
-0.0726931766,
-0.0046968623,
-0.0149847409,
-0.0087756291,
0.0237285886,
0.031840872,
-0.0437788107,
-0.0087246802,
-0.0215552747,
0.0743475109,
0.0639323592,
0.0762323886,
0.0085955402,
-0.0667267367,
-0.0134533234,
-0.0093077533,
-0.0227854941,
-0.0589007363,
0.0243966188,
-0.0039841947,
0.0057870615,
0.0160344206,
0.0109572271,
0.037595693,
0.0107241301,
0.0014428812,
-0.0024960577,
0.0395327434,
0.0066960524,
-0.0297238454,
-0.0230569169,
0.0576397441,
-0.0472463071,
-0.0008257481,
-0.0040947688,
-0.0115762083,
-0.0186258536,
-0.0137704993,
-0.0154852299,
0.0294061415,
-0.0396310277,
-0.001367133,
0.0105236406,
-0.0117970342,
0.0304982122,
0.0392423533,
-0.0606609881,
0.0729392543,
-0.0325109735,
-0.0521823466,
0.0364879556,
-0.008278097,
0.0037042168,
-0.065903075,
0.0353855938,
0.073844783,
-0.0537744649,
0.0408812165,
-0.0173084028,
-0.0407324247,
-0.0308110379,
-0.0268112775,
0.0041690916,
0.0349108428,
-0.0029718976,
0.0762123242,
-0.02628248,
0.0209900998,
-0.0016442019,
-0.0057268674,
-0.0413726717,
-0.0175115857,
-0.0637385622,
-0.0148256682,
-0.0510854237,
0.0675760284,
-0.0684711784,
-0.0040417504,
0.0181400273,
0.0253120977,
0.0157516208,
0.0296038985,
0.015380878,
-0.0113830483,
0.009946038,
-0.0171254259,
-0.0278379526,
0.0001644399,
-0.0342924111,
0.0201781373,
0.016032584,
-0.0067786835,
-0.0161261857,
0.003401072,
0.0017887128,
-0.0315523222,
0.0317223333,
0.050519377,
-0.0119980965,
-0.0056292107,
-0.0297782943,
-0.0182273611,
0.0259445552,
-0.0710290447,
0.0133933071,
-0.0281796772,
0.0210917108,
0.0206144378,
-0.0036102894,
0.0102629205,
0.0285661574,
0.018646922,
-0.0605263822,
0.0902874097,
-0.0025586812,
-0.0218241755,
0.0377070904,
0.0336099193,
-0.0343044363,
0.0488143452,
0.0317521207,
0.0179068875,
0.0129345609,
-0.0063977428,
-0.0065768212,
0.0164617263,
-0.0108085275,
-0.0174609739,
0.009140932,
0.0367977433,
-0.0279840976,
0.0324935354,
0.0136072468,
0.0492040105,
0.000708761,
0.0328443684,
0.0183630548,
0.0366681665,
0.0117945699,
0.0149014229,
0.0490434952,
0.0277844816,
-0.0065992107,
0.0079789944,
-0.0645388216,
0.0159642734,
-0.0673872009,
0.0019272015,
-0.0310125239,
0.0464981087,
-0.0040851426,
-0.0429899544,
-0.0347249247,
0.0412546173,
-0.0072256764,
0.0352838002,
0.0237204414,
0.0225798283,
-0.0268604401,
0.0561230257,
-0.0032483246,
-0.0005365344,
-0.0078851618,
-0.0572760068,
-0.0087512545,
0.0317429304,
0.0468530059,
-0.0225250069,
-0.0147219654,
-0.044889342,
0.0023205145,
0.0546904318,
-0.0241358094,
-0.0125809088,
-0.0039097988,
-0.0480754636,
-0.0201881416,
-0.0065327948,
-0.0079407822,
-0.0092820693,
-0.0153717026,
-0.0269849747,
0.0143621694,
0.0154082095,
-0.0031222815,
0.0519252419,
0.000894573,
-0.0324188545,
0.0090009728,
0.0379233584,
0.0415460654,
0.0033312351,
-0.0028691839,
-0.0071669468,
-0.0051581571,
-0.0456731021,
-0.0353981219,
-0.0236011241,
-0.041831784,
-0.0868452191,
0.0189271159,
-0.0021421928,
-0.0438934863,
0.0316672847,
-0.0790672898,
-0.0187658928,
-0.0140293008,
-0.0102651687,
-0.004913263,
-0.0309385173,
0.0233911388,
0.0059195459,
-0.0157029778,
-0.0452938862,
0.1137669235,
-0.0317046121,
-0.0085096993,
0.0266656857,
-0.0179510433,
0.0002388372,
0.0067282412,
0.020746205,
0.0114219952,
-0.0021793328,
-0.0309017263,
-0.0093432628,
0.0565104559,
-0.0649234205,
-0.0344263315,
-0.0604776293,
0.0083054323,
-0.0203115307,
0.0322303772,
0.0201038159,
0.0093726907,
-0.0214698669,
-0.0310137514,
-0.017867161,
-0.0041067605,
-0.0034614003,
-0.0163943619,
0.0503636636,
-0.0040972214,
-0.0233126376,
-0.008519914,
0.0133791184,
-0.028627988,
0.0472361185,
-0.0061141695,
-0.0827518106,
-0.0492871776,
0.0543037802,
-0.0276400466,
0.0341352038,
-0.0056766453,
0.0050650486,
0.0024724288,
0.0127594536,
0.0377298668,
0.0781374052,
0.0257469695,
0.0126451347,
0.0700344592,
-0.0011752155,
-0.0281415842,
0.0584058575,
0.0073186117,
-0.0055636568,
-0.0186420977,
-0.0039795549,
0.0264424235,
0.098887682,
0.0055530653,
-0.0016855124,
-0.0111062797,
0.0101781301,
-0.0005336279,
-0.0060305945,
-0.0692313462,
-0.0063655167,
-0.0102541102,
0.0420272723,
-0.0289926212,
-0.0099160606,
0.0822161287,
-0.0235930216,
-0.0077775214,
-0.0801272988,
-0.0109396083,
-0.0665961355,
0.0695512742,
-0.0091100242,
0.0217063464,
0.0065662209,
-0.0185762774,
-0.0546278432,
-0.0049852282,
0.0193697456,
-0.0129378242,
0.0284653809,
-0.0729185641,
0.0019919204,
-0.026232494,
-0.0556860641,
-0.0587081723,
-0.0394156501,
-0.0610759705,
0.008056174,
0.0212454367,
0.01882286,
-0.0319754258,
-0.0159465522,
0.0372384824,
0.0544902235,
0.0282187164,
-0.0293750223,
-0.0252046864,
0.0253432821,
0.0678381622,
0.0122758653,
0.0363139585,
-0.0088370144,
0.0999354348,
0.0263375752,
0.0348824598,
-0.0036112079,
-0.0168724228,
0.0302973334,
0.0199802183,
-0.0421853177,
-0.0120664211,
0.0196242314,
0.0221166834,
-0.0838132426,
0.0008831587,
0.1385649443,
0.0431352481,
-0.0274092816,
-0.0081273755,
-0.0360715054,
0.0241761226,
0.0478340127,
0.0376860723,
-0.0814732686,
-0.0444126166,
0.0281173419,
0.0103165768,
-0.0025979336,
-0.0402462482,
-0.0180080272,
-0.1030473113,
0.0381825492,
-0.0168741513,
-0.0435727537,
0.0030101421,
-0.0414112881,
-0.0054207556,
0.041380845,
0.0056201634,
0.0200300477,
-0.0098365899,
-0.0137763834,
0.0117232129,
-0.0238455012,
-0.0250409935,
0.056636747,
-0.0268291999,
0.0373678096,
0.0048137777,
0.0238428768,
0.028337026,
-0.0083446121,
0.0460609868,
-0.0147390477,
0.0413243994,
-0.0549082123,
0.0275854319,
-0.0187845584,
0.0068249945,
-0.0355320722,
0.0314782932,
-0.0328264982,
-0.0001701173,
0.0207608249,
0.0877251327,
-0.0369665809,
-0.0301548541,
-0.0114771808,
-0.0008522174,
-0.0085460376,
0.0807688013,
0.0309515949,
-0.0325673781,
-0.0349155329,
-0.0230908897,
-0.0487712622,
-0.0072296769,
-0.0246262942,
0.0333737247,
-0.0192840844,
0.0581838042,
-0.0292534642,
-0.0420002565,
0.0443909504,
0.0389282107,
0.0076838094,
0.031844262,
0.024498798,
0.0188079961,
-0.0467514209,
0.0167187154,
-0.034289863,
0.0170757454,
-0.0090396814,
0.0023697661,
0.0225361604,
-0.0367560871,
-0.0310484115,
0.019327661,
-0.078847751,
-0.0213113185,
-0.0321682617,
0.0268123075,
0.028087521,
0.0639560223,
-0.008207811,
-0.0539157651,
0.0210652146,
0.0030146043,
-0.0272988733,
-0.0148362014,
0.0145773403,
0.0292447563,
-0.0015131318,
0.0555329882,
-0.0402584448,
0.0061555672,
0.0114577683,
0.042341847,
-0.0328680687,
-0.0048907003,
0.0157723296,
0.0228082892,
0.0484222807,
-0.0199097916,
-0.0042665396,
-0.0423151627,
0.0580873452,
-0.0182040259,
-0.0567141958,
-0.018109655,
0.0233749505,
0.0258406512,
-0.0234277714,
-0.0159473084,
0.0030601679,
0.0218154117,
0.0115962001,
-0.0076708971,
0.0070890496,
-0.0019266178,
0.035423629,
0.0308226496,
-0.0244194679,
-0.0398933403,
0.0064514256,
0.035299737,
0.0370081663,
0.0033004326,
0.0922839642,
0.0468852855,
-0.0113902474,
-0.0539218001,
0.0193383992,
-0.0508435704,
-0.0523840711,
0.0039254809,
-0.0215406604,
0.0467188507,
-0.0011164957,
0.0096779568,
-0.0051918551,
-0.0115546547,
0.0203886237,
0.0230235327,
0.0132308528,
-0.0360340029,
0.0287342723,
0.0101102805,
-0.0261137411,
0.0069124661,
0.0517242588,
0.0081865722,
0.0240269937,
0.0239432491,
-0.0025925054,
-0.060809698,
-0.0028916746,
-0.047672227,
0.0346385241,
0.0030702166,
0.0422257818,
-0.0710372403,
-0.0741222352,
-0.024248451,
-0.0390061662,
0.0050221011,
-0.0072721089,
0.0357315503,
0.047986351,
0.019304391,
-0.0557623059,
-0.0275654905,
0.0344519578,
0.0163119566,
-0.0329482071,
-0.0338046402,
-7.025015053e-33,
-0.0252536908,
-0.0412299708,
0.0480823517,
0.0599793531,
-0.0097630443,
-0.0052637211,
-0.0604757182,
-0.0022917218,
-0.0259700585,
0.0208065957,
-0.0333999246,
0.0043418133,
0.0090397652,
0.0246870983,
0.0000049825,
-0.0251730196,
0.0324191563,
-0.0213840436,
-0.0257239044,
-0.0113484142,
0.0410629027,
0.0478950888,
0.0245497413,
-0.0636196136,
-0.0107950298,
0.0022079393,
0.0070137684,
0.0734361783,
-0.0286469255,
0.013508915,
-0.0284196176,
0.0037037097,
0.0550630875,
-0.0371210575,
0.0052527203,
0.0258426834,
-0.1071519554,
-0.0171270203,
0.0461758152,
-0.008915972,
-0.052219253,
-0.0124003664,
0.0067612533,
0.0191877335,
0.0219892822,
-0.0407689549,
0.0200682953,
-0.0479249656,
-0.0061947634,
-0.0677288994,
-0.0480239056,
0.012830317,
-0.0252639838,
-0.0327350982,
0.0412974842,
0.0359973982,
-0.0125063248,
0.0087179104,
-0.0468945652,
-0.0384496078,
0.0081772087,
0.0068663107,
0.0963589996,
0.0295811649,
-0.0172169879,
0.0529702827,
-0.001886694,
0.008889758,
-0.0755842552,
0.0068072155,
0.0053574024,
0.0437323712,
0.0396043696,
-0.0290985871,
0.0170843266,
0.0277049374,
-0.0935615972,
-0.0034532598,
0.0018992798,
0.0586761497,
0.0000236454,
0.0243335199,
-0.0219856258,
-0.0089461673,
-0.0616360568,
0.0127830189,
-0.0475374572,
0.0147533435,
0.0321689621,
0.0101204179,
-0.0434340872,
-0.0248602014,
0.0140124224,
-0.0040522809,
-0.0050570783,
-0.0041864016,
0.0325779654,
0.0001994805,
0.019266272,
0.0339984298,
-0.0586859025,
-0.01927053,
0.019211825,
0.0156237157,
0.022088239,
0.0089627309,
0.0333259702,
-0.0054532122,
-0.0563874543,
-0.0116541982,
-0.0590826571,
0.0397708938,
-0.0213059932,
0.0352012739,
0.0154521475,
0.0232440662,
-0.0124936448,
0.0376623943,
0.0025252963,
-0.0320401937,
-0.0237256438,
0.087942861,
-0.0138588352,
0.0096028084,
-0.0001876045,
0.0036335092,
-0.0023070641,
0.0136566935,
0.0602332279,
-0.0578006804,
-0.0032898849,
0.0378549136,
3.016e-7,
0.020609051,
0.0783553421,
-0.0063018114,
0.0427406132,
0.031792514,
0.0496400744,
0.0048148595,
-0.0154103162,
0.038626276,
-0.0615597367,
-0.0191735383,
0.0250243489,
0.0538943522,
0.0166990794,
-0.0738985315,
-0.041415479,
-0.0295661017,
-0.0375278555,
-0.0702696443,
-0.0136710284,
0.055679746,
0.0710399896,
0.0111372443,
-0.0166903958,
-0.0028950793,
-0.0236586798,
0.0201231819,
-0.0153471362,
0.0175545122,
-0.0012564636,
0.0165942051,
0.0194785334,
0.0085834088,
0.062446855,
-0.0003384655,
0.0578348003,
-0.0057625496,
0.0613835603,
0.0031623833,
0.0082711903,
-0.0176710784,
-0.0241790619,
0.0114136925,
-0.0805649012,
0.0890866965,
-0.0590678714,
-0.0219018906,
-0.015979765,
0.0079584755,
-0.0244127177,
-0.013288497,
0.0130580263,
0.0107951378,
0.0307283662,
-0.0011334164,
-0.0311180651,
-0.0194340292,
-0.108369641,
-0.0329682641,
0.0178818945,
-0.0306435637,
0.0019343352,
-0.02990219,
0.0057527171,
0.0436284468,
-0.0624145605,
-0.0156947859,
2.907099697e-34,
0.0168619063,
-0.033247944,
0.0060313223,
0.0464863144,
0.0647919625,
-0.002125774,
-0.0396361612,
0.0140318004,
0.0172189996,
-0.1231719181,
0.0203325897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11716v1 | Reflection-Tuning: Data Recycling Improves LLM Instruction-Tuning | 2023-10-18T05:13:47 | 2023-10-18T05:13:47 | Ming Li, Lichang Chen, Jiuhai Chen, Shwai He, Heng Huang, Jiuxiang Gu, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have expanded the
horizons of natural language understanding and generation. Notably, the output
control and alignment with the input of LLMs can be refined through instruction
tuning. However, as highlighted in several studies, low-quality data in the
training set are usually detrimental to instruction tuning, resulting in
inconsistent or even misleading LLM outputs. We propose a novel method, termed
"reflection-tuning," which addresses the problem by self-improvement and
judging capabilities of LLMs. This approach utilizes an oracle LLM to recycle
the original training data by introspecting and enhancing the quality of
instructions and responses in the data. Extensive experiments on widely used
evaluation benchmarks show that LLMs trained with our recycled data outperform
those trained with existing datasets in various benchmarks. | [
0.0582176037,
0.0803246722,
-0.0069223107,
0.0421488769,
-0.0406175144,
-0.0045888419,
-0.0354039446,
-0.0165070388,
-0.0194856338,
-0.059734311,
-0.0590465888,
0.0043508294,
0.0039292686,
0.0087382374,
-0.0016018536,
-0.0185527932,
0.0658085197,
-0.0267062671,
-0.0499169156,
0.0162594393,
-0.0087514147,
0.0069050444,
0.0120425625,
0.0230806433,
0.0116142584,
-0.0213004965,
-0.0080336509,
0.0254308712,
-0.0107801156,
-0.0195208583,
0.0024627994,
0.0329681337,
0.012661811,
0.0242530815,
0.0000018839,
-0.0493911244,
-0.0104526905,
0.0057293954,
-0.0424344689,
0.0626884997,
0.0724441037,
-0.0163786113,
0.0015628278,
0.0389377028,
-0.0364496484,
0.0001736217,
0.0050757756,
0.0180560872,
0.1015190929,
0.099779211,
0.0195584632,
-0.022486018,
-0.0144628407,
-0.0135583859,
-0.0054085869,
0.0125316614,
0.0168639496,
0.0332973711,
-0.005898654,
0.0310891867,
-0.0032398093,
0.0278532486,
0.0175876878,
-0.0017474084,
-0.0026734741,
0.0031511493,
-0.0327960886,
0.0044886633,
-0.0213987138,
0.0609170608,
0.012646134,
-0.0285301842,
-0.0167509392,
-0.0177137554,
0.020491397,
-0.0223636758,
-0.0078048082,
0.0328748822,
0.0298866425,
0.0339645408,
0.0212502088,
-0.0229677279,
0.008131152,
-0.0170142315,
-0.0397200175,
0.0458529592,
0.011811004,
-0.0364723466,
-0.0166620445,
0.0005562039,
0.0036821659,
-0.0087697562,
-0.0197412707,
0.0543043278,
-0.045684278,
0.0348207094,
-0.0622189566,
-0.0147986077,
0.0060419529,
-0.0101658106,
0.1063578799,
0.0366878621,
-0.0080447374,
0.0084689055,
-0.0095004477,
0.0543129891,
0.0258267224,
0.0295938831,
-0.0749928206,
0.0139298672,
-0.0639409572,
-0.0135979019,
-0.0281322524,
0.0608065426,
-0.0343794264,
-0.0018662425,
-0.0488171875,
0.0316687673,
-0.0116296811,
-0.0105970418,
0.0182410646,
-0.0039057271,
-0.0434459522,
0.0049492065,
-0.0498711169,
0.0241432507,
0.0071795392,
0.0067266738,
0.0055760937,
-0.0819355324,
-0.0124974204,
0.009335137,
-0.0178633388,
-0.0095071848,
0.0241053086,
0.0852123499,
-0.006108589,
-0.0357983075,
-0.0747483149,
-0.0400285907,
-0.0089218868,
-0.0785863101,
-0.0100316461,
-0.0492958315,
0.0144141344,
-0.009425343,
-0.0266526863,
-0.016365096,
0.0193130076,
0.0151467025,
-0.0304969978,
0.0460975878,
-0.0291406643,
0.0409309529,
-0.0108587211,
-0.0023982159,
0.0079886792,
0.0679224133,
0.0376181863,
0.0042376141,
0.0103855226,
-0.0370338969,
-0.0030490044,
0.014452951,
0.0198040083,
-0.0098926481,
-0.0578944944,
0.0174928941,
-0.0262670256,
0.0434606485,
0.0584925488,
0.058805488,
-0.0313138776,
0.0203762334,
0.060233213,
-0.00140676,
0.0022440567,
0.0462460406,
0.0532050133,
0.0282774102,
0.0095064146,
0.0513867065,
-0.0487760603,
0.0081803557,
0.0074272132,
0.0315362401,
0.0052323337,
0.0398872383,
-0.0176331904,
-0.0616069809,
-0.0050692433,
-0.0009465351,
-0.0012606843,
0.0107155833,
0.0247367416,
0.0396691076,
-0.0625399128,
0.040091604,
0.0327063277,
-0.0523387045,
-0.0083849058,
-0.0862313136,
0.0390448011,
0.0783172622,
0.0475138426,
0.0006343788,
-0.0292449314,
0.0074053016,
-0.002025258,
0.0252129063,
0.0471807532,
-0.0100562917,
0.0070243473,
-0.0468753763,
-0.0179476272,
-0.0219238047,
0.0162706245,
0.0266121849,
0.0178516041,
-0.0445080325,
0.0365504734,
-0.0183223747,
-0.0694204122,
0.0616654865,
-0.0158710834,
-0.0376402214,
0.0203344729,
0.0006369274,
0.0469920821,
0.0042935628,
-0.0157015994,
0.0358361341,
0.056915503,
-0.0199433565,
0.0120917475,
0.0064893849,
-0.0509380735,
-0.0575568862,
0.0196998734,
-0.0428417623,
0.000247037,
0.0359929018,
-0.0468750037,
-0.0505325422,
0.0028374891,
-0.0578153841,
0.0438045859,
-0.0459909625,
0.0478722118,
-0.007914545,
0.0194253363,
-0.0509127006,
0.0659815893,
0.0001659718,
0.0072189551,
0.0397985056,
0.0108759832,
-0.0022633807,
-0.048612684,
0.0125563638,
-0.0304736067,
-0.0220634099,
0.0218844917,
0.0187192243,
0.0379968956,
-0.0537556224,
-0.0450877696,
-0.0546559207,
0.0205507427,
-0.0235136971,
0.026069304,
0.0561743043,
-0.0098103508,
-0.0077108881,
-0.0055172034,
-0.0369263776,
-0.0166471731,
0.0422270149,
0.0136892674,
0.0436703898,
-0.0029379812,
-0.028293049,
-0.0332497954,
0.0139482953,
0.013419807,
0.019393295,
-0.0186465532,
0.0419604294,
-0.1041566804,
0.0645219684,
-0.0049827434,
0.0003931259,
0.0117250774,
-0.0420805775,
0.0070820572,
0.0131924935,
0.020771645,
0.0445956662,
-0.0058036447,
0.0235476866,
0.0484627634,
-0.0046419813,
-0.0799487457,
0.0002083798,
-0.0150252832,
-0.022469027,
-0.0180921964,
-0.0444744825,
0.0165376887,
0.0533961654,
0.0235279705,
-0.0033531145,
-0.0454940312,
0.0036868227,
-0.0023791015,
-0.0436401814,
-0.0128629357,
-0.0138309766,
-0.0273784623,
-0.0135359056,
-0.030397499,
-0.083896935,
0.0562719479,
-0.0190990139,
0.0188901313,
-0.0573256426,
-0.0069026239,
-0.0635338128,
0.0439161621,
0.0054523028,
0.0110111199,
0.0103823058,
-0.0218041893,
-0.0432263575,
0.0097863572,
-0.0033880977,
-0.026181424,
0.067650944,
-0.0742420703,
-0.0023233939,
-0.0027523295,
-0.038403593,
-0.0574513301,
-0.0437858962,
0.0219254997,
-0.0100100571,
0.0273033939,
0.006929521,
-0.0297533441,
-0.009609553,
-0.0048035076,
0.0130369868,
-0.0080307759,
-0.0091558136,
-0.035455551,
-0.0123789562,
0.0326113813,
0.0189520512,
0.0104428492,
-0.0183457043,
0.0224448554,
0.0204133969,
0.0561645366,
-0.0023098181,
-0.047468476,
0.0162235517,
0.0354491062,
-0.0260963403,
-0.0209924281,
0.047162652,
0.0559092686,
-0.0648217499,
-0.0500697717,
0.116736792,
0.0275045186,
-0.0082492717,
0.0166928936,
0.0025886181,
0.0441990532,
0.0263984911,
0.0423776284,
-0.0664520413,
-0.0219778437,
0.0015103103,
0.0375146382,
-0.0034282543,
0.0068584559,
-0.0307943672,
-0.1732517034,
0.0399104841,
0.0215681698,
-0.0606863312,
-0.0487488545,
-0.035780184,
-0.0283240117,
-0.0095640682,
0.0469918139,
0.0440580286,
-0.0633866414,
0.010118789,
0.0349112228,
-0.0275839269,
-0.0394423455,
0.0007665047,
-0.0245040972,
0.0640702024,
0.0635721087,
0.0332724899,
0.043471314,
-0.0147794392,
0.0226086304,
-0.0498101786,
0.0417951159,
-0.0126892924,
0.0454535484,
0.0018992664,
0.0030586829,
-0.0038213786,
0.0422457792,
-0.0479875691,
0.0149739757,
0.0069337753,
0.0393911339,
-0.0250773244,
0.0044984305,
-0.0179045461,
-0.0222056657,
-0.008661475,
0.0907600895,
0.0568923093,
-0.024460623,
-0.0431103744,
-0.0041832007,
-0.0204162821,
-0.0647900403,
-0.0075401934,
0.0616222098,
-0.0559841208,
0.0116298106,
-0.0817593187,
-0.0506647639,
0.0093104178,
0.0396446511,
0.012101125,
0.0168876201,
-0.0451366007,
-0.0243408401,
-0.0147231417,
0.0286155883,
-0.0588871501,
0.0021193651,
-0.0779370368,
-0.0307393186,
0.031149216,
-0.0095673362,
0.0024355585,
-0.0056705829,
-0.0871602297,
-0.0841158256,
0.0148282321,
0.0616850667,
0.0322463028,
0.0712444037,
0.0151702221,
-0.0225248132,
0.0065678284,
0.0194806773,
-0.0344464667,
0.0243417937,
0.0022293434,
0.0043862625,
-0.0051829107,
0.0364612304,
-0.0231303815,
0.0261958744,
0.0310475249,
0.050543379,
-0.0144179659,
-0.0331208594,
0.0610543415,
0.0448421873,
0.0297934748,
-0.00557693,
-0.0143367024,
-0.0262267143,
0.0228700768,
-0.0411642417,
-0.0132246567,
-0.0423832797,
0.0310915746,
0.0266239382,
-0.004414428,
-0.018992994,
-0.0230232608,
-0.0363760218,
0.0668778941,
-0.0315070562,
0.0227990989,
-0.0052422145,
-0.0154967979,
0.0137797268,
0.0127379373,
-0.0118950251,
0.0318559185,
0.0254672766,
0.0257027578,
0.0024616166,
0.0530879907,
0.0118973255,
0.0473976992,
-0.032591939,
0.0255759954,
-0.0405698977,
-0.0235662423,
-0.0278873723,
0.030811755,
0.0287715476,
0.0093935151,
0.0642251447,
-0.0045199851,
0.0000262,
-0.0114594977,
0.0443883128,
-0.0029639995,
-0.0321059078,
0.0332156569,
0.014296893,
-0.0483310856,
-0.0303002447,
0.0830015168,
0.00641246,
0.0624607019,
-0.0152321188,
0.0160363391,
-0.0555343591,
-0.0367844924,
0.020282317,
-0.0392916538,
-0.0190770794,
0.0013141084,
-0.0462865047,
-0.0818868876,
-0.0200740788,
0.0406517461,
0.046529565,
-0.0423147343,
0.0432389192,
0.0581799597,
0.0012739091,
-0.0082680285,
-0.0508596972,
-0.0118156886,
0.0001249975,
-0.0399893597,
-0.0287907217,
-6.094506582e-33,
-0.0472817309,
0.0045266547,
0.0325220376,
-0.0179175958,
-0.0487826653,
-0.0016461796,
-0.0293101072,
0.0018911954,
0.005747837,
-0.0112273861,
-0.0147761246,
0.0026635353,
0.0222559478,
0.0247014947,
0.00751562,
-0.0054171486,
0.0537447371,
-0.0053328704,
-0.0464363433,
-0.0009080052,
0.0315065756,
0.0396180563,
0.0224210359,
-0.0188797731,
-0.0112048863,
0.013441476,
-0.0167783704,
0.028842926,
-0.018698277,
0.0707847476,
-0.0117623853,
0.0347188711,
0.0321912915,
-0.0290909205,
-0.0350150056,
0.0132695893,
-0.0631851032,
-0.0234523546,
0.0407532342,
0.0072250403,
-0.0425876267,
-0.0603740737,
0.0507489815,
-0.0199140534,
-0.0508486107,
0.0171412267,
0.0064626075,
-0.0441874117,
-0.0504800305,
0.0194100086,
-0.0741202012,
0.0124846222,
-0.0068004956,
-0.0257728379,
-0.0158714764,
0.0384977981,
-0.0202124789,
-0.0208651256,
-0.0349149629,
0.0282853618,
0.0538741834,
0.0661394596,
0.0482752696,
0.0426803231,
0.0172266047,
0.0444367528,
0.0262948722,
0.0186826121,
0.0350492597,
-0.000158403,
0.0301439464,
0.0448702313,
0.0031362225,
0.0329274908,
0.0423858128,
-0.0336657241,
-0.0559887588,
0.0294492561,
0.016856784,
0.043635007,
0.0183520336,
0.0210044552,
-0.0296734609,
0.0009857503,
-0.0589543693,
0.0253467876,
-0.0249061789,
-0.0317563564,
0.0565420762,
0.0390383676,
-0.0504183918,
-0.0368187316,
0.0315654799,
-0.0325981975,
-0.019720206,
-0.0025574937,
-0.040822953,
-0.0071580657,
-0.0094253989,
0.0276444238,
-0.0667097643,
-0.0473305061,
0.0257248096,
-0.0020073431,
0.0213002935,
0.0012481397,
0.027254127,
0.0337682851,
-0.0733607709,
0.0161167569,
-0.0494294129,
0.0197328497,
-0.0234160088,
0.0059188046,
0.0119333658,
0.0019803457,
-0.0186104868,
0.0509466119,
0.0004436657,
-0.0094353706,
-0.0426235199,
-0.0003287247,
0.035921745,
0.0156271216,
-0.016729977,
0.0136349667,
-0.0230762605,
-0.0203111619,
0.0283360276,
-0.0272512175,
-0.0210704971,
0.0457263514,
2.595e-7,
0.0382152423,
0.0402747318,
0.0287135076,
0.0512951501,
0.0200139545,
0.0188558307,
-0.0230377894,
0.0033337628,
0.0263577104,
-0.0056959158,
0.0214781836,
0.0007340639,
0.0837545097,
-0.0152973067,
-0.0835220665,
0.0125067551,
-0.0507033207,
-0.0235423706,
-0.0552708283,
-0.0208892338,
0.0234623123,
0.1073530912,
-0.020630002,
-0.0267404169,
-0.010307462,
-0.0113525502,
0.0570123121,
-0.036930833,
-0.0357164629,
0.0422273763,
0.0454995446,
0.0136613864,
-0.0143717611,
-0.0085258614,
-0.010521126,
-0.006542759,
-0.0344261825,
0.0662705824,
0.0130846063,
-0.0371479206,
0.0396035016,
-0.0078409361,
0.0000198343,
-0.009553005,
0.0585554577,
-0.0611174442,
-0.0325837806,
-0.0458875,
-0.0162479505,
-0.0207624249,
-0.0065262364,
-0.0307390243,
-0.0140043469,
0.0395532176,
0.021200452,
-0.0071211504,
-0.0273741819,
-0.0563673712,
-0.0194912944,
-0.0214405749,
-0.0429504961,
-0.0225533415,
-0.038841933,
0.0044612768,
0.0150356572,
-0.0876785591,
-0.0086950129,
2.673460552e-34,
0.0366347842,
-0.0323889293,
0.0268723685,
0.0390357636,
0.0552640632,
0.0074375574,
-0.0056917598,
0.0429360606,
-0.005117848,
-0.078189902,
-0.0181552991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11715v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11715v2 | Enhancing Low-resource Fine-grained Named Entity Recognition by Leveraging Coarse-grained Datasets | 2023-10-18T05:13:34 | 2023-11-13T13:18:58 | Su Ah Lee, Seokjin Oh, Woohwan Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Named Entity Recognition (NER) frequently suffers from the problem of
insufficient labeled data, particularly in fine-grained NER scenarios. Although
$K$-shot learning techniques can be applied, their performance tends to
saturate when the number of annotations exceeds several tens of labels. To
overcome this problem, we utilize existing coarse-grained datasets that offer a
large number of annotations. A straightforward approach to address this problem
is pre-finetuning, which employs coarse-grained data for representation
learning. However, it cannot directly utilize the relationships between
fine-grained and coarse-grained entities, although a fine-grained entity type
is likely to be a subcategory of a coarse-grained entity type. We propose a
fine-grained NER model with a Fine-to-Coarse(F2C) mapping matrix to leverage
the hierarchical structure explicitly. In addition, we present an inconsistency
filtering method to eliminate coarse-grained entities that are inconsistent
with fine-grained entity types to avoid performance degradation. Our
experimental results show that our method outperforms both $K$-shot learning
and supervised learning methods when dealing with a small number of
fine-grained annotations. | [
0.0238481183,
0.0223801304,
0.0081264284,
0.026235966,
0.0511770807,
0.0841634646,
-0.0115241194,
0.0095379679,
0.006690633,
-0.0731380284,
-0.0361184739,
0.0507870391,
0.0144369416,
-0.0303021278,
0.0376036093,
-0.008763995,
0.0202973392,
0.0154013792,
0.0503359921,
0.0207393039,
0.0048987567,
0.0092797847,
0.0066368761,
-0.0025248753,
0.0095350882,
0.0018701372,
0.0142167378,
0.0200181268,
0.0704312325,
-0.06408526,
0.039835047,
0.0242379289,
0.0012153719,
0.0427179374,
0.0000021954,
-0.0148650082,
-0.0287688039,
0.0380312875,
-0.0249444637,
0.0097858449,
-0.006669974,
-0.042561166,
0.0012554073,
-0.0378276482,
0.000376165,
-0.0667328089,
0.0254460946,
0.0667942762,
0.0056271334,
0.0476017334,
-0.0140998345,
-0.0578475818,
0.0187218487,
-0.0128062209,
0.0024220485,
-0.0643080249,
0.0340646766,
-0.0037960543,
-0.0306458976,
0.044441212,
0.0125659741,
-0.0081092147,
-0.0388736837,
0.0434658676,
0.0143795954,
0.0354580469,
-0.0430391394,
0.0189093724,
0.0329259597,
0.0884787515,
-0.018703118,
0.0073920595,
0.0549227297,
-0.0372415781,
0.0013973234,
-0.0538605563,
-0.0066909431,
-0.0119882552,
-0.0480038784,
0.0007694683,
0.0048544155,
0.0087734098,
0.0138099231,
-0.0032028977,
0.0044606943,
-0.0306082033,
-0.0109057873,
-0.0078238882,
0.0055983029,
0.0182316545,
-0.003831513,
-0.0536983088,
-0.0099823158,
0.0123635298,
0.0023944727,
0.0061304523,
-0.0515077859,
0.0028079539,
0.0089643598,
-0.0288772825,
0.0224320237,
0.0013910962,
0.0158364829,
0.0549210384,
-0.0607520901,
-0.0671160296,
0.0018462762,
0.0384424999,
0.0339935794,
-0.0089723989,
-0.0600061268,
0.0321157575,
-0.0545387007,
0.0593799055,
0.004551372,
0.0096610608,
-0.0314642824,
-0.0204638336,
-0.0325786322,
0.0455847532,
-0.0229492038,
-0.0254197586,
0.0137291681,
-0.018202588,
-0.0252474323,
0.0269503035,
-0.0699237883,
0.0279724132,
-0.0033663125,
-0.012975418,
-0.0009974205,
-0.0492796339,
0.047012195,
-0.0397697426,
0.0340740606,
0.0128158126,
0.0411982015,
-0.098121196,
-0.1070783511,
-0.0007603733,
-0.0161044747,
-0.0628498048,
-0.0163029078,
-0.0310160909,
0.0301014539,
0.0146928262,
0.0151272258,
-0.0077231918,
0.0075345971,
-0.0205111913,
-0.0905140936,
0.0955325663,
-0.0742741451,
-0.0280032139,
0.0178243537,
-0.0070766592,
0.0347420536,
0.0534136258,
0.0338387191,
0.0036332794,
0.0070708701,
-0.017490143,
-0.0475941338,
0.0052288724,
0.0161562972,
-0.032972727,
0.0133680617,
0.0208432414,
-0.0323388614,
0.0007538992,
0.0111360447,
-0.0125502422,
0.0054283189,
-0.004565388,
0.024079863,
-0.00008522,
0.0056214989,
-0.0191873293,
0.0247751549,
0.0303794518,
-0.0003412776,
-0.0015853191,
-0.0348670743,
0.0456483997,
-0.0437111892,
0.0106598707,
0.0481838584,
0.0559372529,
-0.0333885401,
-0.0094161062,
0.0088084918,
0.0047480976,
-0.0296066515,
0.0148527687,
0.0529124923,
0.030411521,
-0.0343769379,
0.0180806983,
0.0658347756,
0.0091269575,
-0.0009706581,
0.0195858963,
0.0132394256,
0.0807113275,
0.0218257885,
-0.0415540002,
-0.0395627581,
-0.0390780494,
0.0270740427,
0.0105213253,
0.0269891731,
-0.0263391659,
0.0338083468,
-0.0328925774,
-0.0158758946,
0.033883024,
0.0311660506,
0.0072796959,
-0.0234586839,
0.0591755919,
0.0232188106,
-0.0342705958,
-0.0218608472,
0.0459928811,
0.0016159161,
-0.0379741676,
0.0145441908,
0.0553113222,
-0.012311928,
0.0390256904,
-0.0083098356,
-0.0283805858,
0.0218586847,
-0.0142177111,
0.0303419866,
-0.0972169712,
0.0412069596,
-0.0357603282,
-0.018903004,
0.008701819,
-0.0357495584,
-0.0434389524,
-0.0673649386,
-0.02671073,
-0.0429921411,
0.0214205012,
-0.0043775714,
-0.0012115513,
0.0140443845,
0.0186863858,
0.026420325,
-0.0312202908,
0.0658235103,
0.003665623,
0.0339552313,
-0.0156105859,
-0.0393378623,
0.0108410707,
-0.0257342514,
-0.0435530879,
-0.0082221488,
-0.031657327,
-0.0040421099,
-0.0005287174,
-0.0098211318,
-0.055817727,
0.0025480404,
-0.0345712975,
0.0014428495,
0.0209007245,
0.023622049,
-0.0270559117,
-0.001264099,
-0.0011157872,
-0.0263632592,
0.0083210347,
0.055815272,
-0.0595884733,
0.0123035852,
0.0349519029,
0.0102318339,
-0.0166486409,
0.0025270809,
0.0011939938,
-0.0255761649,
0.013994473,
-0.004041133,
-0.0479664914,
-0.0561622828,
-0.001085753,
-0.0335309394,
0.0076170014,
0.0171632618,
0.0217295699,
-0.0034523816,
0.0482935421,
-0.0416127853,
0.0312399846,
-0.0012299479,
0.022251999,
-0.029097762,
-0.0251890551,
-0.0338118821,
0.0350071527,
0.0024076686,
0.0384618081,
-0.0171052366,
-0.0279396139,
0.0130077172,
0.0706100687,
-0.0532572716,
0.0157344621,
-0.0643856078,
0.0349735692,
0.0091852909,
0.0109121697,
-0.0053558773,
0.0565541387,
0.0130246673,
0.0152029684,
-0.016187707,
0.0194552988,
0.0563305542,
-0.0364040285,
0.0197431948,
0.0423256569,
0.0200702623,
-0.0235887207,
0.0120086875,
-0.0065518748,
0.004218373,
0.0744260103,
-0.0322540365,
-0.0180329885,
0.0305581894,
0.0355825014,
-0.0303672459,
0.0568429939,
0.0424771272,
0.0225153379,
-0.0518247969,
-0.0287833735,
-0.0011937093,
-0.0346082449,
-0.0406296849,
0.0079268906,
-0.0103835054,
0.0132549852,
-0.0316454433,
0.0547981523,
-0.0285980105,
0.0290291719,
0.0019069574,
-0.0283017848,
-0.0349186324,
0.0440705717,
0.0487819761,
-0.010988893,
0.0346520133,
0.011183762,
0.0103795417,
0.0025802678,
-0.0565256141,
0.004103092,
0.0121947601,
-0.0087997904,
0.014126474,
-0.0222004261,
0.010248783,
-0.0096027562,
0.0456992313,
-0.0399690196,
-0.0087911924,
0.0811801031,
0.0033369041,
-0.0050913212,
-0.0161072761,
0.0485435836,
0.0266072005,
0.0281758178,
0.0223251097,
-0.0891377926,
-0.066809848,
0.0138392961,
0.0169860367,
0.0021745553,
-0.0969826505,
0.0162545145,
-0.101625666,
0.0234713443,
-0.0069507449,
-0.0421943255,
-0.0067580254,
-0.0214497056,
0.0278591868,
-0.0116481632,
-0.0086974539,
-0.0485976301,
-0.0404457115,
-0.0161180738,
0.0138414139,
0.0205205977,
-0.0897760168,
0.0276686419,
-0.0496048182,
0.0768546015,
0.0125601236,
0.046412129,
-0.0198499803,
0.0033617241,
0.0121610397,
-0.0498437211,
-0.0386461578,
0.0084701888,
0.058440879,
-0.0669609681,
-0.0455334708,
0.0029199305,
-0.0210593082,
-0.0014835797,
-0.0108739026,
-0.0061997348,
0.033579722,
-0.0033521575,
0.0022216875,
-0.008245239,
-0.044272352,
0.0164641477,
0.0726965219,
0.0294019245,
-0.0407227613,
-0.0020405722,
0.0286270846,
-0.033054322,
0.0147022111,
0.0210365076,
0.0392321385,
-0.06190883,
-0.0368132479,
-0.0452799201,
-0.052138716,
0.0805338994,
0.0174893159,
-0.011931492,
0.026612848,
0.0421697944,
-0.002046946,
-0.0726224259,
0.013431102,
-0.0502491705,
0.0258026049,
-0.0278992243,
-0.0462161601,
-0.0007724096,
0.0168253593,
-0.0512248576,
0.0059269718,
-0.0670935661,
-0.0440156534,
-0.0138604818,
0.0285988655,
-0.0005153558,
0.0368698388,
-0.0140270386,
-0.031138353,
0.0341391489,
0.0888525471,
-0.0388609022,
-0.0241268091,
-0.0032164615,
-0.0011939582,
-0.0251464397,
0.0392136574,
-0.0577449538,
0.0416813754,
0.0371937305,
0.0359616466,
-0.0327523164,
-0.0200704895,
-0.010523485,
-0.0199378971,
0.0542869084,
0.006461265,
-0.0333695225,
-0.0341145508,
0.0209806673,
0.0436126553,
-0.0168822445,
-0.0232257396,
-0.0539651588,
-0.0023752931,
-0.0152718648,
-0.016309334,
0.041410163,
0.008811105,
0.0611467659,
-0.0752596259,
0.0042058513,
-0.0099529158,
0.0369770043,
0.0039693848,
-0.0485529378,
-0.0166865159,
0.06661544,
0.029573651,
0.0360969193,
-0.0409217402,
0.0084926039,
0.0250887871,
0.0375834294,
-0.056373328,
0.0214856286,
0.0075668846,
0.0147151472,
-0.0354898646,
0.0206366628,
0.0224803481,
-0.0311407577,
0.0315041244,
0.0007478221,
-0.0127194542,
-0.0002946917,
0.0123841539,
0.0029686531,
-0.0213959366,
0.0492827184,
0.0462224856,
-0.0260282233,
-0.0058042533,
0.0669955164,
0.0299386401,
0.0165443327,
0.0062011476,
-0.013658016,
-0.034500774,
-0.0045689279,
0.0102257421,
0.0219390187,
-0.0078064599,
0.0181127321,
-0.0628374815,
-0.0259282794,
-0.0240704715,
-0.0739272833,
-0.0267419275,
0.0161265619,
0.0053902147,
-0.0120862909,
0.0420098081,
-0.025044715,
-0.0248687267,
-0.0397445373,
-0.012720882,
-0.032272242,
0.0132120559,
-6.882327672e-33,
-0.0554617643,
-0.0234436821,
-0.0047208313,
-0.0200478751,
0.0092403684,
0.0301472861,
-0.0132702608,
-0.0232267436,
-0.0398231484,
0.0038310424,
-0.0035760484,
-0.0118284114,
0.0232653841,
-0.0015985939,
0.0015221523,
-0.0134774111,
0.0536958724,
0.0361138396,
-0.0222203992,
0.035790585,
0.0044005639,
0.037401028,
0.0865087286,
-0.0606044605,
0.0286113713,
0.004974897,
-0.0295224227,
-0.0251730569,
0.0704229102,
0.0550066829,
-0.0288206972,
-0.0045759347,
0.0273680873,
-0.0363456942,
-0.0000432344,
-0.0075302324,
-0.1597138643,
0.0219206288,
-0.0474313311,
0.0281913374,
0.0425568521,
0.0007405049,
0.0238989033,
-0.0038464591,
0.0428646691,
-0.0230666567,
0.043756403,
-0.041190777,
-0.011607958,
-0.0515889451,
-0.0660598949,
0.058469519,
0.0189269669,
-0.0043574544,
0.0441157781,
-0.0483999625,
0.039090842,
0.0297405552,
-0.0717741847,
-0.0396471769,
0.0475128889,
-0.0079338914,
-0.0107036196,
0.0278314669,
-0.0041616918,
0.0351308882,
0.0154466368,
0.054704342,
-0.0218637753,
-0.0119919479,
0.0281907823,
0.0433590375,
-0.030454576,
0.0561818779,
0.1178887635,
-0.0444031954,
-0.0533309169,
0.021316763,
-0.046677608,
0.0174825918,
0.0094971256,
-0.0312534347,
-0.0461778678,
-0.0099627618,
-0.0175551102,
-0.0329115838,
-0.0556964427,
0.0366175361,
0.0064575695,
0.0199710242,
-0.0514577627,
0.0688303187,
0.0175054427,
-0.0211662985,
-0.0669147968,
-0.0045438693,
0.0320067853,
0.013749334,
0.0021425409,
-0.03543327,
-0.0504407361,
-0.0635668039,
0.0367573798,
-0.0451978408,
0.0431146584,
0.0155999679,
0.1018127352,
-0.0321096629,
-0.0641478673,
-0.0034862559,
-0.0006220503,
0.0127636017,
-0.0329895653,
0.0215755254,
0.0427872092,
-0.0033568514,
0.0041521476,
0.0425053276,
0.0625546649,
-0.0306580253,
0.0477629714,
0.0614787787,
0.0120636169,
0.033220239,
0.0206892025,
0.0108013432,
0.0069198399,
-0.0382099152,
0.0168435127,
-0.0315225311,
0.0149753578,
0.0019129196,
2.899e-7,
-0.0085876919,
0.0165373515,
-0.0053960537,
-0.0301252473,
-0.0103869839,
0.0505122915,
0.0391361676,
0.0547745265,
-0.0515703522,
-0.0251919273,
0.0095298439,
-0.025104491,
0.0319509655,
0.023206681,
-0.0790251195,
0.0080946805,
-0.0083204731,
0.0199504681,
-0.0667192414,
0.0057242848,
0.0331891961,
0.0631502792,
0.020542467,
-0.0290949997,
0.016099602,
-0.0245689545,
0.0565553382,
0.0185045823,
0.0753689259,
0.0304813776,
-0.0384786129,
0.075801447,
-0.0399606228,
0.0640687495,
-0.0187407061,
0.0246071182,
-0.0074874372,
0.0390637033,
-0.018997008,
0.0457937308,
-0.0185688771,
-0.039892368,
0.0293646399,
-0.0355523527,
0.0810859576,
-0.0967069417,
-0.0340238959,
-0.0018488845,
-0.0145489965,
-0.0032701329,
0.0027388157,
0.0110898633,
0.0074433205,
0.0212575886,
0.0350323319,
-0.0149030257,
-0.0235789232,
-0.1066514328,
0.0566847958,
0.0458647273,
0.048709359,
-0.0086730504,
-0.020864822,
-0.0418412387,
0.0325274952,
-0.0627003089,
-0.0043141898,
2.605317925e-34,
-0.0134342378,
-0.0176185295,
-0.0008628924,
0.0066988124,
0.0102346893,
0.0008920067,
-0.0431050323,
-0.0052594212,
-0.0044662273,
-0.0478741787,
0.0393511765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11710v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11710v2 | Learning Co-Speech Gesture for Multimodal Aphasia Type Detection | 2023-10-18T04:54:32 | 2023-10-20T05:43:28 | Daeun Lee, Sejung Son, Hyolim Jeon, Seungbae Kim, Jinyoung Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aphasia, a language disorder resulting from brain damage, requires accurate
identification of specific aphasia types, such as Broca's and Wernicke's
aphasia, for effective treatment. However, little attention has been paid to
developing methods to detect different types of aphasia. Recognizing the
importance of analyzing co-speech gestures for distinguish aphasia types, we
propose a multimodal graph neural network for aphasia type detection using
speech and corresponding gesture patterns. By learning the correlation between
the speech and gesture modalities for each aphasia type, our model can generate
textual representations sensitive to gesture information, leading to accurate
aphasia type detection. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of
our approach over existing methods, achieving state-of-the-art results (F1
84.2\%). We also show that gesture features outperform acoustic features,
highlighting the significance of gesture expression in detecting aphasia types.
We provide the codes for reproducibility purposes. | [
-0.0120205181,
0.054154925,
0.0091037797,
0.0499681756,
-0.0394141339,
0.0332165025,
0.0044737887,
0.0676609427,
0.0500618741,
-0.0617265962,
-0.0005908808,
-0.0261525325,
0.0153564224,
0.0397630706,
0.0325500071,
-0.0299125873,
0.0723334476,
0.0042356215,
0.0225934982,
-0.0011499808,
0.0466424786,
0.0264752209,
-0.0438673273,
0.0479608253,
-0.061401356,
-0.012179831,
-0.0177971777,
0.0269324016,
-0.0129207699,
-0.0287317261,
-0.0420187339,
0.0065589165,
0.0048864787,
0.0379163325,
0.0000019934,
0.0071679051,
0.0343138538,
-0.0142636225,
0.0226815231,
-0.0301211532,
0.0439795107,
0.0194517318,
0.0044432189,
0.0198639333,
-0.0207533929,
-0.0233948827,
0.0434706658,
0.0697659254,
0.037223652,
0.0878968313,
-0.0134311654,
-0.0311539061,
0.0599584728,
-0.0241521224,
0.0277707502,
0.0063066701,
0.0191471204,
-0.0111293579,
0.0099938698,
-0.0328714848,
-0.0617015511,
0.0502894782,
0.0028436899,
-0.0119110271,
-0.0502237901,
0.0220613591,
-0.0121402545,
-0.0464928746,
-0.0115845148,
0.0734162182,
-0.042794589,
-0.0009279774,
0.0155673586,
-0.006577034,
0.0289776437,
0.0294803027,
-0.0002930827,
-0.0140315806,
-0.017477775,
0.0239193402,
-0.0056233807,
-0.0057036583,
0.0440244488,
-0.0387457088,
0.0639756024,
-0.005968648,
-0.0239452347,
0.0206295419,
0.0186219737,
-0.0327761024,
-0.027272664,
-0.0138471322,
0.0498025157,
-0.002863873,
-0.0466331355,
-0.0162413586,
-0.0210153628,
-0.0728710368,
0.002688254,
-0.0313809551,
0.0395822302,
-0.0161378719,
-0.0687610283,
0.011138713,
-0.0396703631,
-0.0057791397,
-0.0496419854,
0.0270194318,
-0.0143695576,
0.0291514359,
-0.012327686,
-0.0045726271,
-0.026066564,
0.0152037051,
0.0294701774,
-0.0592180453,
-0.0162440017,
-0.0144550642,
-0.0009854439,
0.0070529804,
0.0024932248,
0.0752938986,
0.0292382203,
-0.0049888175,
0.0452036299,
0.0961608067,
0.0366223529,
0.0437508635,
-0.0364854112,
-0.0061054444,
0.0221126229,
0.0715640411,
0.0266809668,
0.0028634034,
0.0204115342,
0.0824333653,
-0.0122881103,
-0.0390388444,
-0.0487569943,
-0.0044254223,
-0.0651307702,
-0.0121091669,
-0.0031324353,
-0.0568878576,
-0.019706307,
-0.0018274859,
-0.0039820424,
-0.0403491147,
0.0270173363,
-0.0281390566,
-0.0003617042,
0.0336053446,
-0.0062785507,
-0.0049150065,
0.0728155449,
-0.0229983628,
0.0007706514,
0.0404003486,
0.0513486639,
0.0284635201,
-0.0139671899,
0.0152447084,
0.0205278825,
0.0428588539,
0.0044572186,
0.0001276115,
-0.0176234432,
-0.0841194987,
-0.0261613484,
0.0340790339,
0.0594826043,
0.0493859723,
-0.0013148474,
-0.0778832957,
0.0104114804,
0.0913994461,
-0.0176852066,
0.0096254274,
0.0342828408,
-0.0179956648,
-0.0106223179,
-0.0101949861,
0.0150322774,
0.0094077103,
-0.0157037955,
-0.0388861001,
-0.0385737419,
-0.032070756,
-0.0146125387,
-0.0091530755,
0.0000661338,
-0.0426790416,
0.0691477284,
0.0009714919,
0.0382789262,
0.0123778936,
-0.0398240536,
-0.0786586702,
-0.0070368573,
0.0016599966,
0.0154150212,
-0.0409923568,
0.0071300571,
0.0291365888,
-0.0055253366,
-0.0300534945,
0.0141656697,
-0.0181511734,
-0.0219516214,
0.0332053974,
-0.0290918481,
0.0248474143,
0.0723370016,
-0.043782603,
0.0124009792,
0.0206785277,
0.0436759591,
0.0450544991,
-0.0756538808,
0.0462616384,
-0.0093134586,
-0.0361885726,
-0.0030022864,
0.0118058203,
-0.0280668959,
0.0215109996,
-0.0062888064,
-0.0051659276,
-0.0070497482,
0.0212035291,
-0.0078261076,
0.0323150419,
-0.0154991457,
-0.0439334251,
-0.0068658744,
0.023242956,
-0.0564175844,
-0.0530063957,
-0.000666408,
-0.0228517875,
-0.017011987,
0.0121206194,
-0.004829878,
-0.0535161905,
0.0844452679,
-0.0632217973,
0.0720925927,
-0.0402616225,
-0.0062042931,
0.0085568558,
0.0182157513,
0.0097891707,
0.0446113497,
-0.0234005153,
-0.0176752228,
-0.0100567685,
-0.0624036454,
0.019747559,
-0.0756297931,
-0.0650975034,
0.0237899106,
-0.0102095399,
0.0153015545,
0.0198880937,
0.0029710559,
-0.0333894566,
0.0236263126,
-0.1013886705,
-0.0068199192,
-0.0092874905,
-0.0158226751,
-0.0267557781,
0.0071164663,
-0.0043006721,
-0.0705949888,
-0.0639876053,
0.0375625677,
0.0263463967,
-0.0079695415,
0.0228358563,
-0.0246953294,
-0.0098915081,
-0.0409409292,
-0.0355322883,
-0.0268790927,
0.0464003608,
-0.000073891,
-0.0868632942,
-0.0179843139,
0.0461584851,
0.0272754002,
0.0223376062,
0.0204548445,
-0.0065628644,
0.0297552776,
-0.0228178781,
-0.0137297083,
0.059550669,
-0.0121722715,
0.0509025976,
-0.0117585845,
-0.0146060791,
-0.030640889,
-0.0280954167,
-0.0193207469,
0.0443248041,
-0.0723177195,
-0.0239341706,
-0.0156596936,
0.0384290516,
0.0684452951,
0.034887448,
-0.0476529077,
-0.1307855248,
-0.0059641399,
-0.031344533,
-0.0239483118,
-0.0586855859,
-0.02084467,
-0.070786044,
-0.0344999656,
-0.0305345636,
0.0407488756,
-0.0448598377,
-0.0257531535,
0.0238118395,
-0.0442139804,
-0.0232131649,
0.0828636736,
0.0396329202,
0.0471679382,
-0.0129063474,
-0.0890798569,
-0.0309865065,
0.0133608757,
-0.0229720287,
-0.0194943585,
-0.0343006626,
0.0134107573,
0.0043270891,
0.0303396601,
0.0367293581,
0.0039983015,
0.0193948951,
0.001007609,
0.0083727567,
-0.0269101541,
-0.0368307531,
-0.0024047329,
-0.016104836,
0.0130423652,
0.0600185432,
-0.0086559337,
0.0127398185,
-0.0257429741,
0.0305977352,
0.0080300244,
0.025801057,
-0.0512572303,
-0.0189089999,
-0.0269047078,
0.0784942061,
-0.0120253284,
0.0192049891,
-0.0897295624,
0.0201702919,
-0.0112223038,
0.0069352654,
-0.0455991998,
0.0150148449,
0.0115183573,
-0.0072022695,
0.0511454828,
0.0416166373,
-0.0011731527,
-0.0979033858,
0.0101353852,
-0.0084830914,
-0.0249828417,
-0.0137462951,
-0.01500881,
-0.1130712852,
-0.0696927682,
-0.0165805221,
0.0174791496,
0.0518982373,
-0.0241887085,
0.0211789645,
-0.0085180402,
-0.0118407952,
0.0009171928,
0.0261055194,
-0.0002793973,
-0.0011305085,
0.0512622334,
0.0099038547,
0.0093363766,
-0.0280117169,
0.0003785109,
0.0014909619,
0.0582943074,
-0.0291390512,
-0.0557170063,
0.006479911,
-0.0196545813,
0.0452024639,
0.0318437442,
0.0627793297,
-0.0194386002,
-0.000620809,
0.0322393812,
0.031615667,
0.0211121291,
-0.0127368988,
0.036270678,
-0.0104088476,
0.008653014,
0.0097140996,
0.0550762266,
-0.0456157252,
-0.0165183954,
-0.0414407887,
0.0459758714,
-0.0579008907,
-0.0483505204,
-0.0156549383,
-0.0523584969,
0.002654956,
-0.0129897501,
0.0368482135,
-0.0141405081,
-0.0651468113,
-0.0027381927,
0.0525888316,
0.045588173,
-0.0060249013,
-0.0023715829,
0.0458178036,
-0.0509131812,
-0.0532294028,
0.012681636,
0.0126309581,
0.0106789945,
-0.0184059758,
0.0360353217,
0.0527989008,
-0.009227247,
-0.0516697131,
0.0292483438,
0.0464725681,
0.0745771974,
-0.0795134753,
-0.0213742536,
-0.0288439728,
-0.0162348021,
-0.0118397772,
-0.0099307727,
-0.0621738806,
-0.0644731298,
0.0226280894,
-0.0104379272,
0.0119611984,
-0.0003339915,
-0.0589743182,
-0.0568736903,
0.0523726419,
0.0744831264,
-0.0053683049,
0.0477560759,
0.0289513841,
-0.0548261553,
-0.03218247,
0.0214678068,
0.0148860365,
-0.003751708,
-0.0255697835,
-0.0015459904,
-0.0654369816,
-0.021419948,
-0.0230725333,
0.0232538451,
0.0283202436,
-0.0182911977,
0.0374892615,
-0.0518035293,
-0.0382989906,
0.02615753,
0.0462286212,
-0.0563469864,
0.0030172882,
0.0434499457,
-0.0381407775,
-0.0007157442,
-0.0797055215,
0.0157087836,
-0.0226771366,
0.0148720518,
0.050648585,
0.0403908044,
-0.0027071785,
-0.0119080106,
0.0341218375,
0.0160214119,
0.0576794222,
-0.0295420587,
0.0124887647,
-0.0041921148,
0.0216804799,
0.0218282752,
-0.0363556184,
0.0053408053,
0.0439510792,
-0.0086801173,
0.0002475069,
-0.0549950898,
0.0289901588,
0.0453171656,
0.0232042242,
0.0498998538,
-0.0221072771,
0.0358638652,
-0.0171509217,
0.0690497607,
-0.0272451565,
-0.0591987967,
0.0257661417,
-0.0066690594,
-0.0180789288,
0.005122778,
0.0305915046,
-0.0014110554,
-0.0005801406,
-0.0056857462,
-0.037865743,
-0.0256731603,
-0.0551217422,
0.0713095292,
0.0205856077,
-0.0378772207,
0.0373918191,
-0.0146852862,
-0.0561536923,
-0.0077364277,
-0.0037054277,
0.0448281877,
0.0059553636,
0.0001047389,
-0.0131643619,
0.0260670055,
0.0041857953,
-0.0326547138,
-0.0226257462,
-0.00669298,
-0.0175457802,
-0.0170124266,
-5.603518388e-33,
-0.0109053999,
-0.0472388789,
-0.0206117127,
-0.0097498111,
-0.0273872614,
0.0380847715,
-0.0260256473,
0.0715194941,
0.0037912198,
0.0103902146,
0.017325379,
0.0467383377,
0.0028175788,
0.0002945769,
0.0198623221,
-0.035044726,
0.0083732307,
-0.0129005108,
0.0070089744,
0.0220810212,
0.0686486363,
0.0043834527,
0.0839707553,
-0.0337891057,
0.0112437941,
-0.0034207443,
-0.0501389839,
-0.012203454,
0.0074052629,
0.0044835014,
-0.0598220862,
0.0753882825,
0.0059616072,
0.0962810293,
0.01074907,
0.0280164927,
-0.0515076369,
-0.0253068861,
0.0056054648,
0.03436286,
-0.0636028647,
0.0292668436,
0.0383816063,
0.0155971004,
0.006591443,
0.0360901654,
0.0685503781,
0.003248753,
0.0181583297,
0.0305991061,
-0.0018894586,
0.021693645,
0.0021630297,
-0.0012630108,
0.0153337028,
0.0054227263,
-0.0291962028,
-0.0535078198,
-0.0175633151,
0.0147497281,
-0.0650792643,
0.0421745144,
0.0073980135,
0.0050478498,
-0.0131286578,
0.0711943656,
0.0158102997,
-0.0512515716,
-0.0040909518,
0.0253212433,
0.0604854152,
0.0547848791,
0.0119244652,
0.0179482698,
0.0099970149,
-0.059375219,
0.0146298725,
-0.0010356016,
0.0652627498,
0.0747021586,
-0.0135582117,
0.0063648005,
-0.0208718497,
-0.0205197297,
-0.0117626023,
-0.0157000888,
-0.015519768,
-0.0390767306,
0.0097697172,
0.0066164918,
0.0332533903,
0.0672010481,
0.0480947457,
-0.0140168173,
-0.049243506,
0.032804355,
-0.0147510609,
0.0722539797,
0.0475749262,
0.0222806986,
-0.0116825616,
-0.0308766235,
0.045123104,
-0.032700628,
0.0784136131,
-0.0039517386,
0.0300521478,
0.052682288,
-0.0269038975,
-0.0191590656,
0.0191824306,
-0.0359000638,
-0.0163425449,
-0.0015960028,
-0.01333859,
0.0106973099,
-0.0570779219,
0.0257128403,
-0.0315257758,
0.0666830018,
-0.0343802609,
-0.0282826889,
-0.0278379302,
0.0378175862,
-0.0354819074,
-0.0065935235,
-0.0106105404,
-0.0012061349,
0.0483346917,
-0.0735979006,
-0.0009716452,
0.0208712798,
2.689e-7,
0.0615467578,
0.014274369,
0.0581765212,
0.0086768363,
0.0159928519,
0.0394437164,
-0.0095356945,
0.0463787913,
-0.0015340801,
-0.0005755694,
0.0076520178,
0.0149529548,
-0.0012500031,
0.0142283272,
-0.0022503163,
0.0688840598,
-0.0748773217,
0.0346544571,
-0.0602345131,
0.0323901549,
0.0328845605,
-0.0056216102,
0.0083003929,
-0.0316506699,
0.0293403659,
-0.0230962429,
0.0449321195,
-0.0227439273,
0.0151600474,
-0.0477913357,
0.019780444,
-0.0360926837,
0.0359039642,
-0.0231678318,
0.0022789619,
-0.0176450405,
0.0444296226,
-0.0159240589,
-0.0859166458,
-0.0323733278,
0.0215711836,
0.0327903517,
-0.0323394835,
0.0217394941,
0.0362568386,
-0.0078078303,
-0.0065025208,
-0.0443755277,
0.000196646,
0.0119754709,
0.04042181,
-0.0234436151,
-0.0203278456,
0.0122776227,
0.0278569665,
-0.0539978482,
-0.0044031865,
-0.0496736653,
-0.0308148786,
-0.0057914746,
-0.0283633117,
0.0096941944,
-0.0294993576,
-0.0033371376,
-0.0089025665,
-0.07074406,
-0.0190730151,
2.123309221e-34,
0.0206376035,
0.0087891882,
-0.0122022107,
0.0045072138,
-0.0242867675,
-0.0033076049,
-0.014410546,
0.0520415939,
-0.0063174134,
-0.0088959867,
-0.0496644452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11699v1 | MISAR: A Multimodal Instructional System with Augmented Reality | 2023-10-18T04:15:12 | 2023-10-18T04:15:12 | Jing Bi, Nguyen Manh Nguyen, Ali Vosoughi, Chenliang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Augmented reality (AR) requires the seamless integration of visual, auditory,
and linguistic channels for optimized human-computer interaction. While
auditory and visual inputs facilitate real-time and contextual user guidance,
the potential of large language models (LLMs) in this landscape remains largely
untapped. Our study introduces an innovative method harnessing LLMs to
assimilate information from visual, auditory, and contextual modalities.
Focusing on the unique challenge of task performance quantification in AR, we
utilize egocentric video, speech, and context analysis. The integration of LLMs
facilitates enhanced state estimation, marking a step towards more adaptive AR
systems. Code, dataset, and demo will be available at
https://github.com/nguyennm1024/misar. | [
-0.0123990243,
0.0213441551,
-0.030327538,
0.0317241512,
-0.0092586549,
-0.0171423312,
0.033077158,
-0.0228461679,
0.0036998615,
-0.0869569033,
-0.0418833196,
-0.0267938729,
0.063884072,
-0.0211126637,
0.0496682078,
-0.0783402771,
-0.0121558588,
-0.0724359378,
-0.032911174,
0.0216201171,
0.0275698174,
0.0193134975,
-0.0859055743,
0.0565764867,
-0.0104041351,
-0.032058809,
0.0141459368,
-0.002743365,
0.0361663029,
-0.0701311007,
-0.0450098291,
-0.0141484309,
0.0429493301,
-0.0136760678,
0.0000020616,
-0.0321933627,
0.0424310118,
-0.0159214512,
0.0283266939,
0.0206096228,
0.0255258884,
0.0030063055,
0.0077176834,
0.0271049477,
0.003931324,
-0.0345247425,
0.0339435712,
-0.0044206944,
0.0539347604,
0.0028314593,
-0.0088951541,
-0.0172049273,
0.0137230698,
0.0031218806,
0.0103686694,
0.0018774648,
0.0132369017,
0.0488927886,
0.0634712204,
0.0088187931,
-0.0396400392,
0.0760538504,
0.0166842695,
0.0111251557,
0.0054773367,
0.027572006,
0.0228039175,
0.0006926058,
-0.0399384536,
0.0701141953,
0.0071229204,
0.0064707533,
0.0191576313,
0.024457112,
-0.0104719875,
0.0159414038,
-0.05979551,
0.0285880864,
-0.0347197875,
0.0047810986,
-0.0507670566,
0.0263526235,
0.0038420353,
-0.0056729736,
0.0123011023,
-0.0047839065,
0.0235648137,
0.0056420187,
-0.0297260154,
0.0059419535,
-0.0269867461,
-0.0338256434,
0.0423537269,
0.030592002,
0.0014751741,
0.0148622319,
-0.0394740812,
-0.0265784878,
-0.0281152632,
-0.0510745458,
0.0414011441,
0.0465708748,
-0.042020116,
0.0656865537,
0.0016501407,
0.098778002,
0.0164940841,
-0.0327307135,
0.0018853385,
0.0231495257,
-0.0505650491,
0.000793189,
-0.0167076066,
0.0004970671,
-0.0482253842,
-0.052727025,
-0.0493908413,
0.0099957334,
-0.0141953165,
0.0010505323,
0.0107419929,
0.0235723704,
0.0096865874,
0.0019330952,
-0.0115921898,
0.0504177175,
0.02248016,
0.0645523965,
-0.048336532,
-0.0619012453,
0.0451140888,
0.0164871812,
0.0161497314,
-0.0014926186,
-0.0336816311,
0.0802853778,
-0.0081149945,
-0.033942312,
0.0036368158,
-0.0047792858,
-0.0247491729,
-0.0378763974,
0.020386586,
-0.0289460085,
0.0323840156,
-0.0201900639,
0.032196559,
-0.0001927936,
0.0121456459,
0.014351883,
0.0224615149,
0.0767083094,
-0.0298937522,
0.0577054136,
0.059278097,
0.0362383798,
0.0175941586,
0.0425700173,
0.0635584071,
0.0100579914,
0.0108069861,
-0.0303334761,
0.0220444519,
0.0738589615,
-0.045519758,
-0.0305999257,
-0.0362381674,
-0.0381669737,
-0.0317201018,
0.0475783497,
-0.0391993523,
0.060374096,
-0.0227411557,
0.0138011202,
0.07169649,
0.034218099,
-0.0016230592,
-0.0516612716,
0.0309554134,
-0.0032203966,
0.0433702953,
-0.0497354083,
-0.0262281112,
0.0272048768,
-0.0089781983,
0.000053963,
0.0446659848,
0.0390504189,
-0.0135690495,
-0.039310582,
-0.0366940238,
-0.006102067,
-0.0007950047,
0.0304776914,
0.0535790697,
-0.0203965958,
-0.0295771826,
-0.022218002,
-0.0325638391,
-0.032364808,
0.0292068273,
-0.0074317018,
0.0080309408,
0.0796079114,
0.0461452194,
-0.0178117566,
-0.0019497471,
0.0127937756,
0.0546735004,
0.026116861,
-0.0253181309,
-0.0116780102,
0.0475370847,
-0.0410914384,
-0.0247912407,
0.0319110043,
-0.0025847214,
0.0065112808,
-0.0218794513,
0.0324186757,
0.0039677909,
0.0073800287,
-0.0197012946,
0.0245019086,
-0.0498492531,
-0.0500007235,
-0.0316893347,
0.0063024522,
-0.0322308354,
0.0442964435,
-0.0186778046,
-0.0032987602,
0.0469743125,
-0.0287014693,
0.054166276,
0.0431903191,
-0.012128789,
-0.0024910404,
0.0667773187,
-0.0484808832,
0.040614754,
-0.0142147942,
0.018400576,
-0.023843538,
0.0390822664,
-0.016502291,
0.0317324027,
0.0094569195,
0.0257090293,
0.0317534246,
-0.0152609888,
-0.0316965617,
-0.0175139792,
-0.0316967182,
0.0085017961,
-0.0217573717,
0.0275196843,
-0.0193417538,
-0.0091443611,
0.0090927845,
-0.0174172651,
-0.001689314,
0.0364493094,
0.0031997554,
-0.0164177623,
-0.021970477,
-0.0078723766,
-0.1249772981,
-0.0539768152,
0.0105825383,
-0.0120560694,
0.0067318589,
-0.0340347961,
-0.0253647603,
-0.0239941701,
0.0206473805,
-0.0006155873,
0.0176659971,
0.0099865906,
-0.0313713029,
0.0108509557,
-0.0337693691,
-0.0585487708,
0.0045924759,
-0.0063555581,
0.0304176062,
0.0280098375,
-0.0227004774,
-0.0498706326,
-0.041918952,
-0.0053974963,
0.0389037319,
-0.0229698997,
-0.0083814329,
0.0459074154,
-0.0141616017,
0.019947594,
0.0422657728,
-0.0318953097,
0.0517315231,
0.0547377467,
-0.076439023,
-0.0282662995,
0.004491576,
0.0505000763,
0.0260397177,
-0.0461069122,
-0.009041898,
-0.0364986546,
0.0466000922,
0.0250700712,
0.0188508313,
-0.0342400372,
0.028465772,
-0.0475177355,
-0.0537062772,
-0.0464495569,
-0.0111229746,
-0.0269394759,
0.0153257828,
0.0016089489,
-0.0193205755,
-0.0059633562,
-0.093474552,
-0.0339727886,
0.0235233195,
0.00800406,
-0.0139280669,
0.044699017,
-0.0210399665,
-0.0094839483,
-0.0537829734,
0.0121827396,
0.0337814838,
-0.0014391497,
-0.0294529442,
-0.0483903773,
0.0241181627,
-0.0986907184,
-0.0073962556,
0.0160280932,
-0.0066486252,
-0.0158574805,
0.0484732799,
-0.0683530048,
-0.0273639504,
-0.0685441568,
-0.0229917448,
-0.0283105653,
0.0226277951,
0.0130340839,
0.0129317855,
-0.0093631092,
-0.0080912253,
-0.0145795485,
-0.0109313605,
0.0730088875,
0.0155839035,
-0.0481323823,
-0.0493045375,
-0.0113378186,
0.0217920095,
0.0354065523,
0.0004681461,
-0.0655200779,
-0.0024403899,
0.0550517701,
0.0434268527,
-0.0117028607,
0.0440665931,
0.0425400957,
-0.0519683026,
0.0238609891,
0.1116794348,
0.000098693,
-0.0262511577,
0.0162743647,
0.0078164916,
-0.0127704525,
0.0359471887,
0.0059220004,
-0.0620410889,
-0.0556323975,
-0.0101148915,
-0.0004899899,
0.0571828,
0.00355911,
-0.0056482232,
-0.0706321076,
0.0187232606,
0.0174324792,
-0.0267447177,
-0.033119075,
0.0233700182,
0.0486986078,
-0.0046554138,
-0.0180032514,
-0.0135438889,
-0.04419275,
0.0174615942,
0.0380093642,
-0.0039123604,
-0.004648393,
0.0036129639,
-0.0084477309,
0.0464334674,
0.0337502882,
0.0330986902,
0.0080034537,
-0.0919429362,
0.01390443,
0.0308977049,
0.003804846,
-0.0193766449,
-0.0064329235,
-0.0354417898,
-0.0255158879,
-0.0056151897,
0.0158097241,
0.000933887,
-0.022642402,
0.027267715,
0.0700343922,
-0.0187703054,
0.0541300848,
-0.0291823298,
0.0186827108,
0.017477354,
0.0255955309,
-0.0060692946,
-0.045905333,
0.0061659729,
-0.0245773066,
0.0104769478,
-0.0160488859,
-0.0686307028,
-0.0113491248,
0.0029682673,
0.0276809409,
-0.0676798299,
-0.0060632019,
0.0766620114,
0.054555472,
0.0250732042,
0.0160818808,
0.0227625296,
0.0510664992,
-0.0530944876,
0.0305970982,
-0.0140100289,
0.0450674966,
-0.0521479845,
0.0157644413,
0.0163120851,
-0.0578901619,
0.0060591791,
0.0508872382,
-0.0227412507,
-0.072232455,
0.0053581912,
0.045523148,
0.0116885081,
0.0115695409,
0.0041420069,
-0.0737616718,
-0.0007222706,
-0.0016360196,
-0.0005425647,
0.041375313,
-0.0017071867,
0.0318699405,
-0.0103115905,
-0.0139283659,
-0.0202796236,
0.0132037029,
-0.0144089414,
0.0147478804,
-0.0240395665,
-0.0863002688,
-0.0264267996,
-0.0046735662,
0.1017963141,
-0.0509287491,
0.0000170664,
-0.0072739786,
-0.019085547,
-0.0524090081,
0.0468975566,
-0.0814374909,
0.0092689265,
0.0169199836,
0.0066600614,
0.0051993304,
0.0138793327,
0.0294022877,
0.0093159005,
-0.0224879514,
0.0244965125,
-0.042945113,
-0.0264799204,
-0.0146095343,
0.0260580517,
0.0168192834,
0.0276371501,
-0.0240458157,
0.0274214186,
0.0134458859,
0.0725630373,
0.0006293296,
-0.0403729342,
-0.0114116101,
0.0732974932,
0.0339927897,
-0.0015368485,
0.0038470943,
0.0937051252,
0.0624603555,
-0.0053371163,
0.0451800413,
-0.0148241548,
0.0415552631,
-0.0619161427,
0.0495194308,
-0.0207050443,
-0.014568286,
0.0496496595,
0.0108373472,
0.0184473582,
0.0086770793,
0.0298142489,
-0.0123141902,
0.0051348237,
-0.0113407085,
-0.0107250437,
-0.0302570574,
-0.0219509751,
0.004684865,
0.0427143276,
-0.0339452848,
0.0419619009,
-0.0340614542,
-0.053361211,
-0.0498245284,
0.0615355186,
-0.013412253,
-0.0366464593,
0.008303103,
-0.006479051,
-0.0147425644,
-0.016850967,
-0.0595109276,
-0.0550345741,
-0.0435692631,
-0.0228645969,
0.0187700205,
-5.414363714e-33,
-0.0672788993,
-0.0417838991,
0.0596735403,
-0.0257921237,
-0.0260188561,
0.0041835243,
-0.0219817124,
0.0332593061,
0.024381388,
-0.0241585858,
0.0320764668,
-0.0554623008,
-0.0053360909,
0.0088882605,
-0.0045770253,
0.0415612087,
0.0318671614,
0.0210192129,
0.009715898,
-0.0086947186,
0.0273467153,
0.0147244129,
0.048284892,
-0.1204489768,
-0.0209943615,
0.0396362543,
-0.0235134754,
0.0120891389,
-0.0107595157,
0.036889255,
-0.0676570386,
0.0250077955,
0.0033746432,
-0.023739038,
-0.0047076931,
0.0117909629,
-0.0296173207,
-0.0080114501,
0.0515165664,
0.0566183068,
-0.0681924224,
0.0042988835,
0.0246810969,
-0.0041898512,
-0.0540949218,
-0.019619897,
0.0429548472,
-0.0221515708,
-0.0120740216,
0.0186174754,
-0.0562767535,
0.0187736265,
0.0010267489,
-0.0540729128,
0.0532720834,
0.033514265,
0.0200145189,
-0.0032852124,
-0.0670794547,
0.0438483544,
-0.0461885966,
0.0054860967,
0.1009800509,
0.0427244678,
0.0298891757,
0.0868859291,
0.045493871,
-0.052540198,
-0.0310680829,
0.0135062402,
0.046228379,
0.0532806627,
0.0393390544,
0.0218702629,
0.0038809143,
0.0076349974,
0.0104825897,
0.0080005191,
-0.0302550439,
0.0379007384,
-0.0022704285,
0.0263844952,
-0.0735418946,
0.0378962047,
-0.0193142127,
0.0345165841,
0.0072062523,
-0.0097707547,
0.0497987531,
0.014328667,
-0.0124190608,
0.0161416326,
0.0687086433,
-0.0359827019,
-0.0460108966,
-0.0288790576,
-0.0169367269,
0.0612633452,
-0.0158249717,
0.0157837328,
-0.0365832597,
0.0019537439,
0.0491823405,
0.0076236809,
0.0431106202,
-0.0303067211,
-0.0501719564,
0.040890906,
-0.0258958377,
0.0060511688,
-0.0096802749,
0.0149633652,
0.0338200293,
-0.0133762918,
0.0659176037,
0.0073128012,
-0.0491321161,
0.0734409764,
-0.0200506374,
-0.0532767959,
-0.0130312713,
-0.0714839175,
-0.0181961842,
-0.0139381569,
-0.07032004,
-0.012656373,
-0.0357052684,
-0.0429004356,
0.0100648561,
-0.0662083775,
-0.033331044,
0.0141956266,
2.816e-7,
-0.0251725465,
0.0647487491,
-0.0273806024,
-0.0260871295,
0.0369392261,
0.0397764146,
-0.0331263058,
0.0280756187,
-0.0015060584,
-0.0191723146,
-0.0172189195,
0.0395288654,
0.062180426,
-0.0218758751,
-0.0473405607,
-0.0522632897,
0.0080462806,
0.042977076,
-0.0390908644,
0.0686056167,
0.0401442647,
0.012450112,
0.0177957062,
-0.0044189361,
0.0303941797,
-0.0490470231,
0.0402219146,
0.0145737734,
-0.0134806912,
-0.0275229514,
0.0800748318,
0.0059341919,
-0.0278552324,
-0.0535075814,
0.0189908724,
-0.0036776867,
0.0287043937,
0.05981398,
-0.036148455,
-0.0034602364,
0.0024322886,
0.0630047545,
-0.0437977053,
-0.0206096098,
0.0726594999,
0.007694589,
0.0171960946,
-0.0440750942,
0.0013601284,
-0.015590867,
-0.0288902633,
0.0019279096,
-0.0178048573,
-0.0218987614,
0.0082226163,
-0.0442474186,
-0.0455133878,
-0.0597342998,
-0.0222350489,
0.0078542726,
-0.0597150773,
0.0182967447,
-0.0436895937,
0.0069092629,
-0.0376671553,
-0.0565396175,
-0.0373951532,
1.871983134e-34,
-0.0013372538,
0.0033630959,
0.0135364905,
0.002100236,
0.0227085669,
-0.015449957,
-0.0321058668,
0.0321741588,
0.0056591593,
-0.0738701001,
-0.0089317691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11689v2 | Adaptation with Self-Evaluation to Improve Selective Prediction in LLMs | 2023-10-18T03:34:59 | 2023-11-11T19:29:42 | Jiefeng Chen, Jinsung Yoon, Sayna Ebrahimi, Sercan O Arik, Tomas Pfister, Somesh Jha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown great advances in a variety
of tasks, including natural language understanding and generation. However,
their use in high-stakes decision-making scenarios is still limited due to the
potential for errors. Selective prediction is a technique that can be used to
improve the reliability of the LLMs by allowing them to abstain from making
predictions when they are unsure of the answer. In this work, we propose a
novel framework for adaptation with self-evaluation to improve the selective
prediction performance of LLMs. Our framework is based on the idea of using
parameter-efficient tuning to adapt the LLM to the specific task at hand while
improving its ability to perform self-evaluation. We evaluate our method on a
variety of question-answering (QA) datasets and show that it outperforms
state-of-the-art selective prediction methods. For example, on the CoQA
benchmark, our method improves the AUACC from 91.23% to 92.63% and improves the
AUROC from 74.61% to 80.25%. | [
0.058312051,
0.0514090583,
0.0065804315,
0.0483871922,
0.0160791744,
0.0159351211,
-0.023933053,
-0.005427612,
0.0234813746,
-0.0654015616,
-0.0576668493,
-0.0373007953,
-0.0526443422,
-0.0013035076,
0.0137966005,
0.000816751,
0.0604653917,
-0.0506650247,
0.0301869437,
-0.0300104748,
-0.0276700631,
-0.0023662129,
-0.0103153121,
0.002917436,
0.0317448154,
-0.0093042068,
-0.0024327799,
-0.0037345593,
-0.0025483912,
-0.0123708816,
0.0528482869,
0.0652428344,
-0.0073893103,
0.0049778759,
0.0000020321,
-0.0721643269,
-0.0198589768,
-0.0403245166,
-0.0467265248,
0.0263722297,
-0.0033653397,
0.0730681494,
0.0233933721,
0.0536596812,
-0.0668775961,
0.016772937,
-0.0017660761,
-0.001168411,
0.0738673657,
0.0737238452,
0.0291511137,
0.019945655,
-0.014033488,
-0.0019106854,
0.020717375,
-0.0641728938,
0.0187597685,
0.0062703462,
-0.0054844352,
0.0044315453,
-0.0318039022,
0.0252197925,
-0.0125163822,
-0.0073633296,
0.0154498704,
0.0064879563,
-0.0454076231,
-0.013605658,
-0.0237937644,
0.0514409356,
0.0246223193,
-0.0140843559,
-0.0049307356,
0.0020260317,
0.0184003413,
0.0159603059,
-0.0504994877,
-0.0157406311,
0.0247312486,
0.0094508836,
0.010356578,
0.0048445552,
-0.009129148,
0.0516078025,
-0.0233874638,
0.1014044732,
0.0012144892,
-0.0384963788,
0.0118332608,
0.0304998625,
-0.0164666753,
-0.048420269,
-0.003383826,
0.0864562765,
-0.0394631661,
0.0200958382,
-0.0413530953,
-0.0028935492,
0.0066725188,
-0.0141719449,
0.0324613042,
0.0369506516,
0.022605693,
0.0427357666,
-0.0485289991,
0.0768885836,
0.0084447395,
0.0244101826,
-0.0449215211,
0.0011457886,
-0.0278609134,
-0.0270891227,
-0.0269993413,
0.0497862734,
-0.0138092227,
-0.0014503058,
-0.0643299967,
0.0408268757,
0.0007064128,
0.0017319173,
0.0233305935,
0.0503087789,
-0.0439520143,
-0.0136686657,
-0.0685004815,
0.0020476109,
-0.0106798997,
0.00767083,
0.0092257503,
-0.0394508764,
-0.0289159212,
0.0345065966,
0.0254191831,
-0.0017241261,
0.0091327429,
0.0843248144,
-0.0155248707,
-0.0291193631,
-0.0139400708,
-0.0459375493,
-0.0380386524,
-0.0640504509,
0.0131400563,
-0.0383466259,
0.0269889012,
0.007806283,
0.0085824784,
-0.0338091366,
-0.0009593901,
0.0085692108,
0.0238918122,
0.0295042843,
-0.0071161026,
0.0299000666,
0.0467536002,
0.0134445475,
0.0058010346,
0.0651200563,
0.0258674305,
0.0412989296,
0.0369909406,
-0.0141772488,
0.0295223109,
0.0047176676,
0.0199018605,
0.0100753568,
-0.0088992193,
0.0595615245,
-0.0203960892,
0.0251140837,
0.0386358611,
0.0239110347,
-0.0032337005,
-0.0427115448,
0.0762539357,
0.0167285819,
0.0453521535,
0.0250278376,
0.0213053003,
0.0154736144,
0.0388671905,
0.0004699768,
-0.0203888789,
0.0530508719,
-0.0474650264,
0.0176053569,
0.0520860143,
-0.0025632789,
-0.0445275903,
-0.0775668547,
-0.0233298242,
-0.0040480127,
-0.0400070846,
0.047869958,
0.0065210243,
0.0221815072,
-0.0346854478,
0.0319823213,
-0.0006988712,
-0.0410597622,
0.0095140683,
-0.076002568,
0.0765451416,
0.0442414768,
0.0533301234,
-0.0337785967,
-0.0610604286,
-0.0159857608,
-0.0120266387,
0.0352111608,
0.0566470288,
-0.022540288,
-0.0025219945,
-0.0447000861,
-0.0341900326,
-0.033343602,
-0.0211498328,
-0.0065864366,
0.0271819308,
0.0249251109,
0.0286231972,
-0.0430361964,
0.0004849888,
0.0277893096,
-0.0302983616,
-0.087059021,
0.0612226464,
-0.0180390477,
0.0396572016,
0.0012755091,
0.0222884007,
0.0182661116,
0.0274944324,
-0.016490018,
-0.0564084686,
-0.01906031,
-0.0694845691,
-0.0562865213,
0.028565662,
-0.0048950152,
0.0033846598,
0.0592785291,
-0.0442997813,
-0.0573939644,
0.015598733,
-0.0427482501,
-0.0030294452,
-0.0479221456,
0.0180564485,
0.0044991723,
0.0408492051,
-0.0292664431,
0.0536662489,
-0.0069082784,
-0.0142013272,
0.0048142881,
0.0256704893,
-0.0122580351,
-0.0519290119,
-0.0235414542,
-0.0183141418,
0.0027435394,
0.018763233,
0.0322317779,
0.0348376743,
-0.0633206666,
-0.0397493318,
-0.0688044801,
0.0237132143,
-0.0238332301,
0.0173755419,
0.0310600903,
-0.0090691792,
-0.0246732477,
-0.0321305543,
-0.0536316633,
-0.0100156013,
0.026106583,
-0.0095735295,
0.0388709754,
0.0199615229,
0.0273229443,
-0.04924931,
0.00788901,
0.0000209228,
0.016550241,
-0.0052462337,
0.0267781802,
-0.0736828148,
0.0323597267,
-0.0664863363,
-0.0027677263,
0.0337849632,
-0.0238141678,
-0.0300549474,
-0.0084474953,
-0.0107250884,
0.0345733352,
0.0319185443,
-0.0201008562,
0.0453344434,
0.0087717585,
-0.0524530858,
0.0482614413,
-0.0247872118,
-0.0168715734,
-0.008929912,
-0.0040711276,
0.0290741269,
0.0701634362,
0.0232158229,
-0.0110879503,
-0.0622590259,
0.0335569605,
-0.0236129947,
-0.0525034592,
-0.0502643697,
-0.0041694231,
-0.0128146019,
0.0257746428,
0.0093052788,
-0.052182734,
0.1063863263,
-0.0144986622,
-0.0025140618,
-0.0534783266,
-0.0143699339,
-0.0846471936,
0.0206635278,
-0.0040807421,
-0.0040602903,
-0.0265113134,
0.0032927732,
-0.0446484834,
-0.0546851419,
-0.0122492593,
-0.0471552014,
0.0526656508,
-0.0253797751,
0.0093979547,
0.0107976366,
-0.0560886338,
-0.0556823276,
-0.0428348482,
-0.026375711,
-0.0138561865,
-0.022765765,
-0.0132192923,
0.0009991273,
-0.009074904,
-0.0033039984,
0.0045358161,
-0.0605365783,
-0.0171408486,
-0.0124349287,
0.0625182837,
0.0974046439,
0.055210337,
0.036654938,
-0.0198438447,
0.0669466481,
0.053706117,
0.0448490083,
0.0178683847,
-0.007185766,
0.0026751924,
0.0520337187,
-0.0569193624,
0.0000495926,
0.0356232375,
0.0472885109,
-0.0360801518,
-0.0306458231,
0.1186777726,
0.0284818597,
-0.0049724309,
-0.0035773397,
-0.04326538,
0.03768491,
0.0392678082,
0.063465178,
-0.0589621775,
-0.0494859852,
-0.0267027058,
0.0631100908,
-0.0099912789,
-0.0327690095,
-0.004668565,
-0.0970925763,
0.0330909491,
0.005680115,
-0.0464439578,
0.0027497818,
-0.0233804882,
0.0053439778,
-0.0273786262,
0.0315276533,
0.0341544189,
-0.0259192269,
0.0035808173,
0.0521976873,
-0.0645937622,
-0.0028578816,
0.0217653979,
0.0110259987,
0.0329468548,
0.0344974361,
0.0468804091,
0.0081171487,
-0.0041364436,
0.0113557465,
-0.0441592336,
0.0159619823,
-0.0441693664,
0.0372793004,
-0.0222696494,
0.0030030124,
0.0057291584,
0.0283959452,
-0.0350422487,
0.0104577318,
0.0489511825,
0.0705902427,
-0.0375906006,
-0.0368002504,
-0.0164337084,
0.0185650215,
0.0076200818,
0.0728999451,
0.0323442221,
-0.0600295663,
-0.0462950543,
-0.0129511282,
-0.0221283492,
-0.0735252723,
-0.0230745431,
0.0167065859,
0.0394900702,
0.025197763,
-0.0895024091,
-0.0346183516,
0.0257397108,
-0.0127963303,
-0.0335785225,
0.0273889191,
-0.0288677197,
0.0119662471,
-0.017681947,
-0.0023778582,
-0.0515033789,
-0.0243741907,
-0.0429615974,
0.006924442,
0.0552545488,
-0.0455738939,
0.0042523062,
0.0169423427,
-0.0663420111,
-0.0629127547,
0.0032158708,
0.0792169645,
0.0179333668,
0.0318330452,
0.0056169834,
-0.0841004997,
0.0755477697,
0.0062313578,
-0.0161680225,
0.0453812219,
0.0036828655,
0.0156106744,
-0.0303659569,
0.0331871621,
-0.0451484211,
0.0078570638,
0.013397078,
0.0604129024,
-0.0162884388,
-0.0672864541,
0.0458454452,
0.017888803,
-0.0158351064,
-0.0000277142,
-0.01226163,
-0.0078463033,
0.0449134707,
0.0020466375,
-0.0157689974,
-0.0137404371,
0.0221956857,
0.000166226,
-0.0471178517,
0.0040961844,
-0.0192041229,
-0.0503936708,
0.0199467558,
-0.0311526787,
0.015009243,
0.0143495733,
-0.0083532948,
0.0027949563,
-0.0154319769,
-0.0291751679,
-0.016060207,
0.0369070359,
0.0418709405,
0.0242809653,
0.0498498864,
-0.0094079832,
0.0135643473,
0.0010122316,
0.0162644815,
-0.0790444091,
-0.0681452826,
-0.0395089947,
0.0368325226,
-0.0055751363,
0.0186840482,
0.0268003102,
-0.0138437916,
-0.0169294979,
-0.0227192249,
-0.0049716877,
-0.0013140882,
0.0095906714,
0.0593286194,
0.027552478,
-0.0108607868,
0.0171071421,
0.060795363,
0.0262241159,
0.0548051372,
-0.0001857761,
-0.0062843976,
-0.0641456693,
-0.0331620835,
0.0169767924,
-0.0211691484,
-0.0154229747,
0.0069217435,
-0.0286166035,
-0.0580625311,
0.0258337967,
0.0229970161,
0.0038128039,
-0.0488592982,
0.0408898182,
0.0464939028,
-0.0039995704,
-0.027147634,
-0.05919718,
-0.0043521593,
-0.0172121041,
0.0044306372,
-0.0170121621,
-6.661337672e-33,
-0.0326213054,
-0.0311655998,
0.0501633249,
-0.0191744603,
0.0198750589,
-0.0032786576,
-0.0109857917,
0.0156636667,
0.0032439954,
-0.0183817744,
-0.0382000469,
0.0125302747,
0.0074729049,
0.0327423066,
-0.0046809125,
-0.029661065,
0.0254047643,
-0.0144770853,
-0.0453073755,
0.0288522709,
0.013403994,
0.0319106132,
0.0372407176,
-0.0120794838,
0.0111670038,
0.010558675,
-0.0122150164,
0.0187477618,
-0.0263648815,
0.0803794786,
-0.0106899505,
0.0389622189,
0.040243078,
-0.0199653059,
-0.0220275726,
0.0262307692,
-0.0188463051,
-0.064692311,
-0.0058958433,
-0.0288391281,
-0.0562800802,
-0.019067293,
0.0323841162,
0.0203368161,
-0.0393350124,
-0.0105305519,
0.0068712127,
-0.0195811652,
-0.0204215236,
-0.0337710865,
-0.024683835,
0.0194627866,
-0.0109250657,
-0.0247807577,
-0.0199406948,
0.086709246,
-0.0163359437,
0.0183932632,
-0.0317667238,
0.0184458308,
0.0276976228,
0.0621318892,
0.0722221136,
0.0236685202,
-0.0331815965,
0.0248111319,
-0.0210351124,
-0.030126119,
0.0299009774,
-0.0255493131,
-0.0168366879,
0.0351430178,
0.0433957241,
0.0313226059,
0.0083292751,
-0.0070304582,
-0.0684155747,
0.0613726377,
-0.0059524355,
0.0416506305,
0.0368583128,
-0.0066584973,
-0.0438106619,
0.0160544738,
-0.0464572422,
0.0659899488,
-0.0339607559,
-0.0241991468,
0.0492088087,
0.029485818,
-0.0699324682,
-0.0255937148,
0.0138898594,
-0.0326842405,
0.0199121069,
0.0058673676,
-0.0570727326,
-0.0102458913,
0.0096900379,
0.0482571945,
-0.020070767,
-0.0183929987,
-0.0008510527,
-0.0146027245,
-0.0074820602,
-0.026322946,
-0.0116530005,
0.0333192758,
-0.0788435563,
0.0089042122,
-0.0248326231,
0.0379573219,
-0.0092840074,
-0.0199031513,
-0.002456764,
0.0003283647,
-0.0219993908,
0.0510650463,
-0.0049246047,
-0.0126820151,
-0.0136993621,
-0.0184589606,
0.0337014794,
0.0154365478,
-0.0295798294,
0.0120188808,
0.0158638638,
0.0164119601,
-0.0239312425,
-0.0652819201,
-0.0183670148,
0.0562937818,
2.714e-7,
0.0485400595,
0.0389148146,
-0.0218896251,
0.0076510529,
0.0163278412,
0.0302569047,
-0.0028095264,
0.0332195684,
0.0467920601,
-0.0026299292,
0.0372185595,
0.0494120643,
0.0458195806,
0.0195058733,
-0.0796088725,
0.0070001539,
-0.0730644614,
0.0343027376,
-0.0296014398,
-0.0481293462,
0.0320774652,
0.0869669691,
-0.0088545885,
-0.0276499521,
-0.0347069614,
-0.0476874858,
0.0751190484,
0.0084740706,
-0.0410984196,
0.051588811,
0.0719564259,
0.024115311,
-0.0086827101,
-0.0017996995,
-0.0161001012,
0.0257672593,
-0.0202526245,
0.0626848713,
0.02945273,
-0.0719806552,
0.0179827455,
0.0142410742,
0.0390855558,
-0.0412306786,
0.0884239152,
-0.0423392467,
-0.0279308986,
-0.0535016023,
0.0386679098,
-0.0058589219,
0.0418779291,
-0.049950067,
-0.0147136264,
0.0133960256,
0.0217485093,
-0.0002233434,
-0.0204111449,
-0.0567835979,
-0.0016781146,
-0.0070041474,
-0.0388991423,
-0.0302362423,
-0.0540764071,
0.0128981723,
-0.0078632468,
-0.1061517969,
0.0187642518,
2.300776037e-34,
0.0035156538,
0.0111754015,
0.0078847287,
0.0287831109,
0.0204570163,
-0.0003328743,
-0.0061152815,
0.0093417233,
0.0482101962,
-0.0636755973,
-0.0291861854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11685v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11685v1 | Superiority of Softmax: Unveiling the Performance Edge Over Linear Attention | 2023-10-18T03:17:57 | 2023-10-18T03:17:57 | Yichuan Deng, Zhao Song, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large transformer models have achieved state-of-the-art results in numerous
natural language processing tasks. Among the pivotal components of the
transformer architecture, the attention mechanism plays a crucial role in
capturing token interactions within sequences through the utilization of
softmax function.
Conversely, linear attention presents a more computationally efficient
alternative by approximating the softmax operation with linear complexity.
However, it exhibits substantial performance degradation when compared to the
traditional softmax attention mechanism.
In this paper, we bridge the gap in our theoretical understanding of the
reasons behind the practical performance gap between softmax and linear
attention. By conducting a comprehensive comparative analysis of these two
attention mechanisms, we shed light on the underlying reasons for why softmax
attention outperforms linear attention in most scenarios. | [
0.0250836108,
0.007700691,
-0.0165175963,
0.0466582887,
-0.0152160022,
0.0076098354,
0.0222316906,
-0.0184319261,
-0.0615383424,
-0.035344597,
-0.0237792116,
-0.0625004396,
0.0263074245,
0.0646821037,
0.0344408415,
-0.0223174598,
0.0500211939,
-0.0196485762,
0.0103222514,
0.0287706964,
0.0015904859,
-0.0302050207,
0.016667366,
0.0723905712,
-0.0072562322,
0.0309581868,
-0.0030623421,
-0.012916808,
0.0136996107,
-0.0094654309,
-0.0204770081,
0.0726067796,
0.0097325249,
0.0303257201,
0.0000017249,
-0.0185789242,
0.0124939326,
-0.0082184384,
0.0142019512,
0.0134967174,
-0.022754021,
-0.0375584699,
0.0024710584,
-0.0222114492,
-0.0101786749,
-0.0176490638,
0.0778679401,
0.0564413555,
0.0250984784,
0.0773555711,
-0.0085267751,
-0.0362285152,
0.034020178,
-0.0350976586,
-0.0034177932,
-0.0651375428,
0.0290284157,
-0.0886540711,
-0.0099660587,
-0.0059671202,
-0.0424796268,
0.0310325902,
0.0209720246,
0.0007207415,
0.0221549552,
0.0551560298,
-0.0509905182,
-0.0120511707,
-0.0383748934,
0.0814072639,
-0.0659579411,
-0.0030632752,
-0.0033237878,
0.0024397539,
-0.001616626,
-0.0193543565,
-0.0436177403,
0.0170039851,
0.019100856,
0.0117658442,
-0.0020362684,
-0.0026994376,
0.0213595051,
0.0049749292,
-0.059989512,
0.0405895747,
0.0001524888,
-0.0189076029,
-0.0196436532,
0.0046832957,
-0.0583269224,
-0.0378613099,
0.0562007129,
0.0570416637,
-0.0293513462,
-0.0128049701,
-0.0465009138,
-0.029428862,
-0.0056000049,
-0.0483927317,
0.0329183564,
0.0401680656,
-0.0157998446,
0.0326725058,
-0.0409340411,
0.0935717598,
-0.0248210989,
0.0079314336,
-0.0131065613,
0.0233450364,
0.006050129,
0.0119498344,
-0.0260207169,
0.0634128004,
-0.0653114393,
-0.0558726601,
-0.0113366991,
0.0011828195,
-0.0120751634,
-0.0331177488,
0.0062202113,
0.0321191065,
-0.0521441326,
0.0048332666,
-0.012073772,
0.0509533286,
-0.0432268754,
0.0093090078,
0.0181298535,
-0.0419990718,
-0.0398917012,
0.0003815413,
0.033677917,
-0.033060208,
-0.0224001501,
0.0491440445,
-0.0275208317,
-0.0542716756,
-0.0023299775,
-0.012110428,
-0.029971892,
-0.033065524,
-0.0148093104,
-0.0438742898,
0.0431934074,
0.003361864,
-0.0084191877,
0.0200016089,
0.030823864,
0.0088335425,
-0.0152789978,
0.0554016009,
0.0271555316,
-0.0233879592,
-0.0250549931,
0.0048521115,
0.0026340284,
0.0508005619,
0.0060297102,
0.021432139,
-0.0007289127,
-0.0173104182,
0.019110119,
0.0245475248,
-0.0000605518,
-0.0332044549,
-0.0115490835,
-0.007773757,
-0.0188121032,
0.0167995244,
0.046018105,
0.0627403706,
-0.0442847162,
-0.043343477,
0.0567585304,
0.0574236587,
0.0469206385,
0.0760522038,
0.0383676589,
-0.0073431488,
-0.0171009135,
0.0329095684,
-0.0696762353,
0.0670173168,
0.0432915613,
0.0011125822,
0.0091337329,
0.0311985239,
-0.0261650924,
0.0011001226,
0.0014824406,
-0.0264349096,
0.0060759303,
-0.0587461442,
0.0263436493,
0.0048376196,
-0.0706278384,
0.0837157294,
0.0191263575,
-0.0247244127,
-0.008411332,
-0.0547779575,
-0.0117764715,
0.0046022981,
0.0098513579,
-0.0251000654,
-0.0406273603,
-0.0134816151,
-0.0405970588,
0.0439754464,
0.0367938019,
0.0204913504,
-0.0210702438,
-0.0531037077,
0.0060183359,
-0.0163627043,
-0.0045694066,
0.0333604515,
-0.004937626,
0.0254488643,
0.0135995625,
0.0293552708,
-0.003653341,
0.0226339046,
0.0176114328,
-0.0300969575,
0.001970991,
0.0050156871,
0.0413105823,
0.0209010988,
-0.004625306,
0.0427759252,
0.0471541919,
-0.0227029938,
-0.0221536905,
-0.0040194597,
-0.0897747874,
-0.0185419787,
0.0226631761,
-0.0241828393,
-0.0000410073,
0.0568016544,
0.0038926045,
-0.0440279543,
0.0385251716,
-0.0720100626,
0.0208129585,
-0.0261246804,
0.029800171,
0.0213649794,
0.0797241777,
-0.0372209661,
0.0408956707,
0.0082672611,
0.037102975,
0.0247524884,
0.0077067455,
-0.0145173352,
-0.0151065774,
-0.0152244167,
0.0242642295,
-0.050260134,
-0.0185272601,
-0.0112982048,
-0.0498288609,
-0.0372572057,
-0.0388044417,
-0.03927432,
-0.0226805434,
-0.0286447741,
0.0147853373,
0.0106212776,
0.0165064242,
0.0243983623,
0.0205374192,
-0.0087822769,
0.0303609706,
-0.0102674598,
0.0267150328,
0.0237451699,
0.0112582128,
-0.0419403166,
-0.0562672541,
-0.029066937,
-0.0021722785,
0.079917416,
-0.000366839,
-0.055651512,
-0.0510877185,
-0.0684874505,
-0.0025380701,
0.0213658419,
-0.0100637265,
-0.0647172928,
0.0059756138,
-0.0069896737,
0.06782002,
0.0908725932,
0.0383214578,
0.0149641568,
0.0017765126,
-0.0298359469,
-0.0186141208,
0.0324330255,
-0.0358607024,
-0.0003256868,
-0.0420458429,
0.003613122,
0.0072921175,
0.1132050455,
-0.0210774448,
0.0032931417,
-0.0410284027,
-0.0171223097,
0.0276652426,
-0.0338386111,
0.0360207744,
-0.0275360178,
-0.0565230958,
0.0238635559,
-0.0458325036,
-0.0157246348,
0.0659198537,
-0.0374294743,
-0.0180138331,
-0.0268590488,
0.0048511797,
-0.0467178412,
0.0444217585,
0.0298375115,
0.0114652636,
-0.0138601931,
-0.0644166395,
-0.007880928,
-0.0068781646,
-0.0223154705,
-0.01287237,
0.1126629189,
-0.0016964724,
0.0220678691,
-0.0250563081,
0.0012423448,
-0.0041412576,
-0.0131551335,
-0.0097832019,
0.0518274046,
0.0691789836,
-0.0266874935,
-0.0749952644,
0.0589874797,
0.0225319453,
0.0528335348,
-0.0327396132,
0.0211481508,
-0.037927676,
0.0549265742,
0.0293523353,
0.0379569232,
0.0469961502,
-0.0036135928,
0.0137616256,
0.0527499169,
0.0286002662,
0.0139865689,
-0.0303724129,
-0.0261749178,
0.0230946783,
-0.055702813,
-0.003004957,
0.0202669948,
0.0615656674,
-0.0682827458,
-0.0323583297,
0.1057731956,
-0.003458238,
-0.0710628852,
0.037142124,
0.0061521851,
-0.0164416507,
0.0208681151,
-0.0152969398,
-0.0270635691,
-0.0594966337,
0.0021598085,
-0.0239302684,
-0.0079950606,
-0.0353081934,
0.029992139,
-0.0606060848,
-0.0090949601,
0.003071507,
-0.0375212952,
-0.0434960425,
-0.0322610848,
0.0289752483,
0.0060276454,
0.0129037742,
0.0164891053,
0.0000252982,
-0.0328215025,
-0.0025675183,
0.0283353552,
-0.0041174847,
0.0128269484,
-0.0497105084,
0.0181070175,
0.0329219066,
0.0175749287,
-0.0132514033,
-0.0179555602,
0.0679654628,
0.0252012089,
0.0224662945,
-0.0074980669,
0.0055985451,
0.0045047277,
-0.0235998835,
-0.0286277831,
0.0051278966,
-0.0301198419,
0.0140261883,
-0.0336239487,
0.0675727054,
0.0046908995,
-0.0440481044,
-0.0226758886,
0.0136565482,
-0.0269913357,
0.0323092937,
0.0526365973,
-0.0319445208,
-0.0523925088,
-0.0050347238,
0.0036649022,
-0.0329482667,
-0.0730335042,
-0.0245200712,
0.0400607772,
-0.0724544376,
-0.0504184477,
-0.0426916517,
0.0144938007,
0.0256165396,
-0.0044683306,
-0.0418787003,
0.0183051229,
-0.0067717549,
-0.0064370651,
0.0586077198,
0.0049631596,
0.019275004,
-0.0492445342,
0.0157505199,
0.0259272549,
-0.003967464,
-0.0213073604,
0.0456170104,
-0.0798964426,
-0.0419983678,
0.0132429171,
0.0120443664,
0.0153710349,
-0.0019662036,
0.0051174075,
-0.0350429192,
0.0287034791,
0.0658334345,
-0.0506985337,
0.040189147,
0.0077119819,
-0.0543480068,
-0.0015281859,
0.0493583977,
0.000165322,
0.002502938,
0.0169182103,
0.0648293272,
-0.003141403,
-0.0533039682,
-0.0088219317,
-0.0538194925,
0.0791337639,
0.0457223766,
0.0017476056,
0.0111565655,
0.0299876407,
0.0259167906,
0.0161132384,
-0.0502722748,
-0.0556150526,
0.0226193964,
0.0382172503,
0.0057172868,
-0.0105075808,
0.0036436194,
0.006188117,
-0.0169973448,
0.0301114935,
-0.0032770848,
-0.0206150021,
0.0236441065,
-0.0004363101,
-0.0488075055,
-0.0304994695,
0.0180535559,
0.0303125959,
-0.0188389421,
0.0335149914,
0.0030377277,
0.0242821742,
-0.0073171523,
0.002547988,
-0.0577672943,
0.0140491547,
-0.0134152975,
-0.0196930915,
0.0455060154,
-0.042159196,
0.0474023074,
0.0182044357,
-0.0172188617,
-0.0170592349,
0.0003486988,
-0.0303642359,
-0.0034712511,
0.0315448493,
0.0394161716,
0.0127025526,
-0.0372073613,
0.0580670796,
-0.0530766323,
-0.0043901429,
0.0096729975,
-0.0080043534,
-0.0124291489,
-0.0299376044,
-0.0050935,
0.0162678119,
-0.0231279247,
0.0050159367,
-0.004868824,
-0.0290419646,
0.0222613793,
-0.0441504009,
-0.0023794046,
-0.0279804617,
0.0510195792,
0.0463830866,
0.027143022,
-0.0258895233,
0.0132960444,
0.0193336625,
0.0412704684,
-0.0208562333,
-0.0110930074,
-6.323229498e-33,
-0.0258534905,
-0.03742823,
-0.0173597783,
0.0328913853,
-0.0613224246,
0.0407340191,
-0.0352874286,
0.0216486678,
-0.018454304,
-0.0004280537,
-0.0147202322,
0.0180797577,
0.0039992966,
0.0185086448,
-0.0112558044,
-0.0417832546,
0.0340644307,
0.0106410468,
-0.0171344355,
0.0157605112,
-0.0112285605,
0.0393568352,
0.0796356127,
-0.0004533977,
-0.0108330352,
0.032475926,
0.0096260747,
-0.0123140998,
-0.0049254186,
0.0621105991,
-0.0167247336,
0.0336098112,
0.0465475731,
-0.0831002966,
-0.0218330361,
0.0499771424,
-0.0612927973,
-0.01000618,
0.0189451054,
0.0118065216,
0.0103485305,
-0.025117442,
0.1001601145,
0.0247773994,
0.0304928292,
-0.0690339878,
0.0288022049,
0.0006745092,
-0.0418345742,
-0.0254464503,
-0.0720924139,
0.0295675863,
-0.0029248411,
0.0015575723,
0.0204969347,
0.0157509353,
-0.0113941552,
0.0558066107,
-0.0467823558,
-0.0029329138,
0.0130719813,
0.1016230583,
0.0286328625,
0.0094076293,
-0.0191857405,
0.0232969057,
0.0344971456,
-0.0119929584,
-0.0735379234,
-0.0305447821,
0.0120227328,
0.0370260626,
0.0665899366,
-0.0085664159,
0.0524890497,
0.0269161463,
-0.0619833842,
-0.0374417305,
0.0078813061,
0.080470711,
0.0575396717,
-0.0031573903,
0.0201406777,
0.013088841,
-0.0195189696,
0.0284316614,
-0.0618177392,
0.008740888,
-0.0085981498,
0.0333587304,
-0.0145958764,
0.0563666672,
0.0477110557,
-0.0338825285,
0.0149070686,
-0.0103247249,
0.0417983085,
0.0230485965,
-0.0119360732,
-0.0143698184,
-0.0662355274,
-0.0332036912,
0.01346571,
0.0222387128,
0.0001911977,
-0.0137147298,
0.0059965863,
0.0251110476,
-0.0761171281,
-0.0386888124,
-0.0519023761,
0.0034530631,
-0.0226619337,
0.0299156085,
0.0623768158,
-0.0268456768,
-0.0097513851,
0.0863003433,
-0.0017598664,
-0.0087327193,
-0.0060431068,
0.0198770985,
0.0075764377,
0.0479510762,
-0.0431163087,
-0.0090252953,
-0.0899280086,
0.0292658024,
0.025240209,
-0.0647062063,
-0.0406968258,
0.0319104232,
2.66e-7,
0.007581905,
0.0260236003,
0.0333425365,
0.0043653292,
0.0374775417,
0.0437186658,
0.0325260647,
0.0522093028,
0.0361522771,
-0.000205246,
0.0174671169,
0.0150594227,
-0.0152938031,
0.0056564151,
-0.0826464593,
-0.0130815972,
-0.0837361664,
0.0169708803,
-0.0499033332,
-0.0244533326,
0.0133750224,
0.1086449996,
-0.0351958498,
0.0021769931,
0.0081267301,
-0.0389713868,
0.0268273875,
0.0148781445,
0.0137149096,
0.0388459042,
0.0143029867,
-0.0256189033,
-0.0231482759,
0.0290660169,
-0.0063579502,
0.0473010205,
0.0209390372,
0.0486544445,
-0.0176870078,
-0.0708911344,
0.0548172854,
-0.0193600506,
0.0142095732,
-0.057436049,
0.0545788556,
-0.0960442498,
-0.0381995365,
0.0189282037,
-0.0250780061,
0.0037393009,
-0.0320402309,
-0.0288885944,
0.012977412,
0.0290110484,
0.0246288348,
0.0098234816,
-0.0123385396,
-0.099576585,
-0.0047821533,
0.0023764768,
-0.071475856,
0.0035910273,
-0.0912751928,
-0.0320428647,
0.0236320402,
0.0076105371,
-0.0384680144,
2.29165218e-34,
0.0062420801,
-0.0110013224,
0.025381485,
0.0255733989,
0.0234629363,
-0.027848538,
-0.0404858328,
0.0143008782,
0.0066663548,
-0.0895612761,
-0.0471458659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11681v1 | Descriptive Knowledge Graph in Biomedical Domain | 2023-10-18T03:10:25 | 2023-10-18T03:10:25 | Kerui Zhu, Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present a novel system that automatically extracts and generates
informative and descriptive sentences from the biomedical corpus and
facilitates the efficient search for relational knowledge. Unlike previous
search engines or exploration systems that retrieve unconnected passages, our
system organizes descriptive sentences as a relational graph, enabling
researchers to explore closely related biomedical entities (e.g., diseases
treated by a chemical) or indirectly connected entities (e.g., potential drugs
for treating a disease). Our system also uses ChatGPT and a fine-tuned relation
synthesis model to generate concise and reliable descriptive sentences from
retrieved information, reducing the need for extensive human reading effort.
With our system, researchers can easily obtain both high-level knowledge and
detailed references and interactively steer to the information of interest. We
spotlight the application of our system in COVID-19 research, illustrating its
utility in areas such as drug repurposing and literature curation. | [
0.0531458966,
0.0298123565,
0.0058673085,
0.0044418504,
-0.0067637907,
-0.0149101298,
-0.0312792696,
0.0307770222,
0.0695911199,
-0.011465027,
0.0196844619,
0.0205190573,
0.003942397,
0.0625007376,
0.0120837428,
-0.0489318818,
0.0295279976,
0.0463285036,
0.0369444713,
0.0181568135,
-0.0000276772,
0.0383561105,
-0.0071931472,
0.0301028267,
0.0215514265,
-0.0147126252,
0.0172109976,
0.0057204878,
0.0502786599,
-0.0819405392,
0.0200315323,
-0.0092857582,
-0.0103885755,
-0.0204868466,
0.0000019534,
-0.0540445745,
-0.0487931892,
0.0419671647,
0.003636152,
-0.0252193492,
0.0676894337,
-0.0305845123,
0.0288627949,
0.0119442362,
-0.0305560715,
-0.0174705926,
0.0314714536,
0.0219032262,
-0.0028001461,
0.049655702,
-0.0135603352,
-0.0334076062,
0.0389584862,
0.0032899012,
0.0465295315,
-0.0017973854,
0.0406037793,
0.0298535526,
0.0880592763,
0.0357587002,
0.0357378498,
0.0563127063,
-0.0413950644,
-0.036414966,
0.0812653229,
0.0562725253,
-0.0168034248,
-0.0469505191,
0.024663249,
0.0531987473,
0.0261611771,
-0.0342308767,
0.0785864443,
0.0229475703,
0.0029228434,
0.0525030978,
-0.0363379382,
-0.0272040926,
-0.080831781,
-0.001433663,
-0.0045516565,
-0.0203343891,
0.0498279929,
-0.0161122512,
0.0055141663,
0.0231381096,
-0.0175764672,
-0.0344946943,
-0.0150330281,
-0.019071728,
-0.0009617247,
-0.0320807211,
0.0347374678,
0.0115612252,
-0.0378661118,
0.0298769921,
0.0071231774,
-0.018575253,
0.0735608861,
-0.0561636351,
-0.0310521871,
-0.0389922783,
0.0226235781,
0.0155975837,
0.0005685285,
-0.0510220751,
-0.0282041952,
0.0000012615,
-0.0295888186,
-0.0090100951,
-0.0765396655,
-0.0383414887,
-0.0413304269,
0.0260847751,
-0.0237366855,
0.0128445271,
-0.0635292679,
0.0046130666,
0.0053427462,
-0.0035293505,
0.0006990024,
0.0447872505,
-0.0375823975,
0.0301204696,
-0.0250887703,
-0.0208095945,
0.0054624863,
-0.0293028764,
0.0042284303,
-0.0110122366,
0.0081888093,
-0.0344872065,
0.047165174,
-0.0067409109,
-0.0390195511,
0.0682979152,
0.0134849846,
-0.0167738423,
0.0248539876,
-0.0729055703,
-0.0157192554,
-0.0162692238,
0.0079700314,
-0.0575652532,
0.073777236,
0.0361856259,
-0.0170029923,
-0.0374580026,
0.0221495479,
0.0205402207,
-0.1011019498,
0.0231542028,
-0.103059195,
-0.0154590644,
0.0120489169,
0.0095853722,
0.030231338,
-0.0395974889,
0.0346103646,
0.000308388,
0.0416730344,
0.026830731,
-0.0027984851,
-0.0371001028,
0.0278594848,
-0.0576816238,
0.040978983,
0.0149274366,
-0.0069155721,
0.0785050765,
-0.0444813818,
0.0338913798,
-0.0151856309,
0.0300103985,
0.0160490461,
0.0524346456,
0.033060573,
0.0285867024,
0.0592516921,
0.0415472239,
0.008272876,
-0.0119928885,
-0.0076235011,
0.0012609879,
0.0250665266,
0.0286709834,
-0.0061047366,
0.0299710575,
0.0364800729,
0.0020447287,
-0.0035623945,
0.0200659074,
0.0199475884,
-0.0340015553,
0.0201495532,
0.0002437726,
-0.0377455577,
0.0151006337,
0.0640921593,
-0.03548944,
0.0135963988,
0.0033956638,
-0.0198551938,
0.1122459248,
0.0750883222,
-0.0245663486,
-0.0368068479,
-0.0023534112,
-0.0232466962,
0.0355478115,
0.0117381439,
-0.0172159262,
-0.0172234718,
-0.0101865204,
-0.0162614752,
0.0053616664,
-0.0031749578,
-0.0192059577,
0.0048929914,
0.0205305982,
-0.0060021365,
-0.0544007979,
-0.0049011637,
0.011868272,
-0.0360824391,
0.021444425,
-0.014771427,
-0.0056168437,
-0.0020566885,
0.0513586551,
0.0167268347,
0.0485354327,
0.0786012635,
-0.0346200578,
-0.0496901385,
0.0253338199,
0.0163799711,
-0.0324245617,
-0.0199096873,
-0.0622183457,
0.0126688648,
-0.0435766578,
-0.0298155304,
-0.0308703892,
0.0112925656,
-0.0147705395,
0.0590001084,
0.0354935043,
-0.0005137005,
0.0291003268,
-0.0121278465,
-0.019326441,
0.035682153,
0.036012318,
-0.0201881863,
0.0106395734,
-0.0990078226,
-0.0088457186,
-0.0177408569,
0.0233598109,
-0.0010398151,
0.0119523657,
-0.0203669667,
0.0398434587,
-0.0340744741,
-0.021628499,
0.027782796,
-0.0915055946,
0.0089985048,
0.0468401387,
0.0398279577,
0.0154156527,
0.0282408744,
0.0003664706,
-0.0073167318,
-0.0186297521,
0.0123393014,
-0.0115727363,
-0.0248695146,
0.0677541494,
0.0261840411,
-0.0407236591,
-0.0528614596,
-0.0152184917,
-0.0516703725,
0.046426177,
0.0520721823,
-0.0498582236,
0.0083805704,
0.0133725684,
-0.0269708689,
0.0024132147,
-0.0020483988,
-0.0146150589,
0.0059530293,
0.0215963684,
-0.0008890128,
0.01643111,
-0.0085548759,
0.0576862432,
0.0515515059,
-0.009822811,
-0.0016659792,
0.015680436,
-0.0569935627,
0.0131875342,
0.0216561668,
-0.0408162549,
0.0204551816,
0.0201361217,
0.037238609,
0.004842768,
-0.0149914054,
-0.0269688908,
0.01160088,
0.0189683866,
-0.0726582035,
-0.0022510688,
0.0051409537,
-0.0022572537,
-0.030079674,
-0.008245117,
0.0738175437,
-0.0078767398,
0.0428087376,
-0.0581328906,
-0.003680018,
-0.0057302746,
0.0003698519,
0.0188615378,
0.0207312368,
0.0618083961,
0.0169940144,
0.0113097914,
0.0106735621,
0.0568183772,
-0.0311025474,
-0.0070725298,
-0.0320496336,
0.0123332171,
0.020367302,
-0.0284809582,
-0.0286430884,
0.0001889428,
-0.0090711527,
0.0028441111,
0.0944317207,
-0.027889004,
-0.0249085445,
0.0259213336,
0.036917977,
0.0012893974,
-0.0075946064,
-0.0355092958,
0.0019809629,
0.0137771023,
0.0477136485,
-0.0615120679,
-0.0094546638,
0.0232438948,
0.0390839614,
0.0681706443,
-0.0551829599,
-0.0132765006,
0.0015199437,
-0.0158151109,
-0.0469297245,
-0.0553717539,
-0.0440337919,
-0.0017179634,
-0.0090969978,
-0.0558466092,
-0.0013775646,
0.0759877637,
0.0372395068,
-0.0369473435,
0.019982798,
0.0057077943,
-0.0363867395,
-0.0186294466,
0.054944329,
-0.1030783206,
0.0150926355,
-0.0311877206,
0.0108885067,
-0.0204749219,
-0.0541603081,
-0.0291510634,
-0.0254163016,
0.0251389872,
0.0004842453,
-0.041093491,
-0.0277062673,
-0.0642612651,
-0.0218395498,
0.0205075908,
-0.0820239633,
0.0194936395,
-0.0391576141,
0.0071595036,
-0.0112918895,
-0.0218534935,
-0.0289472416,
-0.0129633024,
-0.0144807873,
-0.0076224245,
0.0353306048,
0.0750977099,
0.0176252201,
0.0306184962,
-0.0222513322,
0.0026384126,
0.0045323614,
-0.0035624579,
0.0879990235,
-0.0076519884,
0.0125154462,
-0.0684459656,
0.0103153987,
-0.0493957326,
-0.0365288891,
0.0205972809,
0.0810494646,
-0.0166716669,
-0.0336638242,
-0.0796820074,
0.0037723759,
0.0058499505,
0.0356236733,
0.0070655076,
0.0375859365,
-0.0106056696,
-0.0044572302,
0.05992347,
-0.0368251354,
-0.0110944137,
0.017868612,
-0.0942879468,
0.0075377906,
-0.0832263306,
-0.0238424819,
0.0386482477,
-0.0405708067,
-0.0012833164,
0.0134874787,
0.0725163743,
-0.0261249729,
-0.0807577372,
0.0170573387,
0.0311609115,
0.0042838049,
0.0016631881,
-0.0505427755,
0.0338769592,
-0.0049692527,
-0.0000946895,
-0.008918358,
0.0171142537,
-0.0433995426,
-0.0463485606,
-0.0094834445,
0.0162672736,
0.0186971053,
-0.0155600151,
0.0075226626,
0.0397756957,
0.0878943354,
-0.0297261849,
-0.0607740283,
-0.0457444824,
-0.0089380573,
-0.025720071,
-0.0003432075,
-0.0414728858,
0.0136190681,
-0.0744502768,
0.0192625672,
-0.0147037534,
-0.0191368628,
0.0566334948,
0.033350341,
0.0546670407,
-0.0424966067,
0.0064720437,
-0.0275058746,
-0.007977997,
-0.0435772836,
-0.0023149783,
-0.0164066963,
0.0383376628,
-0.0431863591,
-0.0027369878,
0.0011700484,
0.0149504542,
-0.047461383,
0.0162081756,
-0.0349960737,
0.0063891578,
-0.015449319,
-0.0117532359,
0.0771167949,
-0.0277809035,
-0.0076142172,
0.010332128,
-0.0343142785,
0.0019257617,
-0.0256158877,
-0.0009512254,
0.0068651177,
-0.010813809,
-0.0146056842,
0.0399671979,
-0.0478578396,
0.005232322,
-0.0513221584,
0.0230432339,
0.0631460547,
0.023718752,
0.0506797694,
-0.0370105691,
-0.02212804,
-0.0215825196,
0.0641625002,
-0.0230997019,
0.0103804059,
0.0058836108,
0.0155358762,
-0.0388821289,
-0.0696065724,
0.0872789174,
0.0236469023,
0.0404454619,
0.0098502161,
-0.0808057711,
-0.0326102376,
-0.0283050593,
0.0122127943,
0.0217494126,
-0.0163274687,
0.001015717,
-0.0325740352,
-0.0417222977,
0.0508385897,
0.0054760934,
-0.029199902,
-0.0173380002,
0.0488147847,
0.0151592763,
0.0454216748,
-0.0712787509,
-0.0249271672,
0.0604458638,
-0.0554659031,
-0.0311539993,
-0.0010770537,
-6.272174839e-33,
0.0135985278,
-0.0633474514,
0.0196191669,
-0.0033660163,
-0.0185867269,
0.0091161821,
-0.049486991,
-0.0218413845,
0.0206422042,
0.0868550315,
-0.0021737467,
-0.0036275343,
-0.0091294535,
-0.0033515883,
-0.0113782045,
0.0169916842,
0.0488261878,
0.0095839258,
0.0100324787,
0.0279506668,
0.0707950667,
0.0755942315,
0.0357260294,
-0.0668271109,
0.0136872921,
-0.0042739953,
0.0347397253,
0.0008990751,
0.0029746133,
0.047342103,
-0.0057655936,
0.0490316302,
0.0106602125,
0.0250584688,
0.0081758061,
-0.0041213185,
-0.0859762356,
-0.0079584941,
0.0054000299,
-0.0563571602,
-0.0371406525,
-0.0269515347,
0.0462269187,
-0.0112177702,
0.0323469453,
0.0063491841,
0.0487517267,
-0.0230463371,
-0.060162589,
-0.0799555033,
-0.0344144702,
0.0244890116,
0.0038862773,
0.0124075692,
-0.0118388673,
0.0270170253,
-0.0124281431,
0.042976629,
0.0371402167,
0.0148861576,
-0.0143261114,
0.0373852737,
0.0144941313,
-0.0216309335,
0.0272716992,
0.0395305343,
-0.0314513035,
-0.0134638874,
-0.0059597576,
0.0596994646,
-0.0419512503,
0.0649251863,
-0.0153469341,
0.0575652383,
0.001634284,
-0.0235952046,
-0.0855297223,
0.0378904007,
-0.0796423629,
0.0277215671,
-0.0244559608,
0.0186715033,
0.0054398598,
-0.0388873108,
0.0133620268,
0.006864382,
-0.0160606317,
-0.0411000326,
-0.006705597,
-0.0302996542,
-0.0412595272,
0.0135510582,
-0.0437433645,
-0.0171932038,
-0.0261961054,
0.0359475277,
-0.0065705976,
-0.0198716279,
-0.0309677776,
-0.015177425,
-0.0579108559,
-0.0195977017,
0.00364022,
-0.001247149,
0.0221072845,
0.0372815244,
0.0028447297,
-0.0273579173,
-0.0162688103,
0.0090114288,
-0.0126503296,
0.0123409657,
-0.0311123822,
-0.030714998,
0.0127439424,
0.0533902384,
0.0236784052,
0.0388661884,
0.0423471145,
0.0365425758,
-0.012307439,
0.01725276,
-0.0087941466,
0.0303623024,
-0.0097718434,
0.0150601091,
-0.0344202295,
0.0505510457,
0.0218765736,
-0.0847589821,
-0.0154967988,
-0.0063563935,
2.937e-7,
0.0828962326,
0.0494969524,
0.0387274735,
0.0464588664,
0.0163628664,
-0.0112377703,
0.0368939228,
0.0163562689,
-0.0390058644,
-0.0127077661,
0.0235733017,
-0.0031106367,
0.0008760214,
0.0336223282,
-0.0924729407,
-0.0367677025,
-0.0846872926,
-0.0985416025,
-0.0481648818,
-0.0090371771,
0.0819230452,
-0.0032487225,
0.0010904003,
0.0226030406,
0.0063956929,
-0.0334603973,
0.0083347252,
-0.0241659172,
-0.0163161959,
0.0539808422,
0.0188098475,
0.0003621732,
-0.0062298765,
0.0453304984,
-0.0341376811,
-0.042766083,
-0.0129583282,
0.0272004176,
-0.0234058704,
0.0406384058,
0.0524719656,
-0.0642328933,
0.0415400602,
-0.0021810648,
0.0168193728,
-0.0695528388,
-0.0081767868,
0.0363691263,
-0.0098812068,
-0.0082129221,
0.0052535431,
-0.0226940364,
-0.0321686827,
0.0257413592,
-0.0180281661,
0.0268760771,
-0.0183286685,
-0.0684611574,
0.0070238416,
0.0604378246,
-0.0187352933,
-0.0423876941,
0.0214587916,
-0.0266517624,
-0.0045649651,
-0.0266008228,
0.0248026047,
2.568573854e-34,
0.0425757021,
0.0055320561,
-0.0313350335,
-0.0056036944,
0.0447344631,
-0.036683742,
-0.0097238207,
0.0160371568,
-0.0051389216,
-0.0653190166,
-0.0152207725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11672v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11672v2 | Open-ended Commonsense Reasoning with Unrestricted Answer Scope | 2023-10-18T02:45:54 | 2023-10-27T13:50:09 | Chen Ling, Xuchao Zhang, Xujiang Zhao, Yanchi Liu, Wei Cheng, Mika Oishi, Takao Osaki, Katsushi Matsuda, Haifeng Chen, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-ended Commonsense Reasoning is defined as solving a commonsense question
without providing 1) a short list of answer candidates and 2) a pre-defined
answer scope. Conventional ways of formulating the commonsense question into a
question-answering form or utilizing external knowledge to learn
retrieval-based methods are less applicable in the open-ended setting due to an
inherent challenge. Without pre-defining an answer scope or a few candidates,
open-ended commonsense reasoning entails predicting answers by searching over
an extremely large searching space. Moreover, most questions require implicit
multi-hop reasoning, which presents even more challenges to our problem. In
this work, we leverage pre-trained language models to iteratively retrieve
reasoning paths on the external knowledge base, which does not require
task-specific supervision. The reasoning paths can help to identify the most
precise answer to the commonsense question. We conduct experiments on two
commonsense benchmark datasets. Compared to other approaches, our proposed
method achieves better performance both quantitatively and qualitatively. | [
0.050373558,
0.0434295572,
0.0046488033,
0.0074290452,
-0.0283477511,
-0.0042544086,
-0.0231353007,
0.016272245,
0.0506414808,
-0.03738188,
0.0055528767,
0.0429592729,
-0.0455426946,
-0.0166509449,
-0.0027117389,
0.005918406,
0.0368673541,
-0.0208964907,
-0.0223381463,
-0.0233828928,
-0.0119642448,
0.0447211936,
-0.0031210147,
0.0263380762,
-0.0069816653,
-0.0288751274,
-0.0043507381,
-0.0428296067,
0.0028136652,
0.0216262229,
0.0347157754,
0.0225563589,
0.0509932637,
-0.05574736,
0.0000020089,
-0.0362879224,
-0.0177874565,
-0.0173505805,
-0.0102639226,
-0.0290862042,
-0.028303992,
0.0291171838,
0.0444385372,
0.0162862372,
-0.0254915673,
0.0221910328,
0.0302678514,
0.0432500467,
0.070729509,
0.0191452578,
0.0101881409,
-0.0552274697,
-0.0368516259,
0.0160999298,
0.0501063354,
-0.0624497086,
0.048140008,
0.0455132239,
-0.0166446231,
0.0024308031,
0.004870859,
0.0267616771,
0.0220086593,
-0.0145526705,
-0.0174843185,
0.0235590208,
-0.042829331,
0.0144895641,
-0.0128669683,
0.1260648221,
0.033711046,
-0.0444222204,
-0.0100119505,
0.0037716627,
-0.0133032985,
0.0563399829,
-0.042678427,
0.0370455645,
0.0077777677,
0.0065510478,
0.0222780351,
0.0066411942,
-0.001030113,
0.0370113552,
-0.0279662292,
0.1014407799,
-0.0066382093,
-0.0157776922,
0.0241382401,
-0.0075818421,
-0.0062764827,
-0.0241032187,
0.0165934246,
0.0827772021,
0.0025518578,
0.0307167079,
0.0331850573,
0.0079249926,
0.0115716178,
-0.0454796664,
0.0142683638,
0.0357464515,
-0.0270517766,
0.064822793,
-0.0160344057,
-0.0190436468,
-0.0251054894,
0.0280899312,
-0.0378488041,
-0.0216312874,
-0.0490242615,
-0.0028701732,
-0.0325151049,
0.0548738874,
-0.0371410064,
-0.0141662434,
-0.0139804482,
-0.0047676428,
-0.0063180174,
-0.0156028792,
0.0439967625,
0.0453488715,
-0.0274907965,
-0.032596048,
-0.0497460775,
0.0391521528,
-0.0753029585,
0.048274301,
-0.0131144058,
0.0089919139,
-0.0195559878,
0.0099962037,
0.0397951715,
-0.010206488,
0.0042001721,
0.0578076839,
-0.007792213,
0.0113088368,
-0.05709517,
-0.0349820405,
0.0300250202,
-0.0242818408,
-0.029671371,
-0.0406191647,
0.0250303317,
0.0272555016,
-0.0368097909,
0.0059629385,
0.018963512,
0.0419987589,
-0.0092977341,
0.0681375042,
0.0134781236,
-0.0067749298,
0.0182893854,
0.0185688566,
0.0282044094,
0.0623830855,
-0.0375391915,
-0.0178513601,
0.045195207,
0.0103876079,
0.0008147536,
-0.0191268437,
0.0530425012,
-0.0076215439,
0.0149771255,
0.0856617466,
0.0100144278,
0.0350123942,
-0.0083931061,
0.0167857762,
-0.0401044264,
-0.025615992,
0.0183212869,
0.0895609185,
0.0035809064,
0.0061290776,
0.027554905,
0.0130615886,
0.0048556309,
-0.0013233495,
-0.0262565892,
0.0187282767,
-0.0420758799,
-0.0138042476,
0.0165766645,
-0.0210502371,
-0.037492305,
-0.0204767343,
-0.0041285227,
-0.0138323493,
0.0249836426,
0.019206373,
0.0821101367,
0.0107995458,
-0.0327906199,
0.1037652418,
0.0400670171,
-0.0524707399,
-0.0006458986,
-0.0099000391,
0.0483293235,
0.0178680513,
0.0385489836,
-0.0413815007,
-0.0329314694,
-0.0043611345,
0.0266665127,
0.0094335424,
0.0083098104,
-0.0515802279,
0.0240715295,
-0.0487221554,
-0.0035527903,
0.0133415088,
-0.0210225824,
-0.0187446363,
0.0378752016,
0.0006610246,
0.0060843164,
-0.0696062893,
0.0185915679,
0.0143232606,
-0.0357007422,
-0.0280964561,
-0.016317958,
-0.0158795007,
0.0015633259,
-0.0018322425,
0.0252271891,
0.022854263,
0.0283375699,
-0.0137106003,
-0.0542781539,
0.0049151452,
-0.0255278666,
-0.0473067164,
0.0357345752,
-0.0319296569,
-0.048268903,
0.0080764201,
-0.0290612653,
-0.0200568847,
0.0207439344,
0.000872327,
0.0356455445,
-0.0578776076,
-0.0582041517,
0.0158417821,
-0.052508004,
-0.0117458981,
0.0993759185,
-0.0085950419,
0.0285173599,
-0.0145102395,
-0.0133555597,
0.0354278497,
-0.0132424207,
0.0138560608,
-0.0231690612,
-0.0146528436,
0.0146171367,
0.0042255595,
0.0103876628,
-0.0611868873,
0.020060651,
-0.0887048244,
0.007065265,
-0.0030988094,
-0.0074866372,
0.0065440382,
0.0063895299,
0.036086116,
-0.0152920224,
-0.0449558794,
0.0150586693,
0.000632547,
0.0163597148,
0.0436553024,
0.0279598311,
0.038907323,
0.0007426823,
-0.0095050875,
-0.0351330899,
0.0277937111,
-0.0190903507,
0.0844447613,
-0.0124426726,
-0.0026228493,
-0.0610238872,
0.0326194018,
-0.0099174855,
-0.0156402383,
0.0149831614,
-0.0625548959,
-0.0186371151,
0.0582243763,
-0.0097150821,
-0.0055644484,
0.015524406,
-0.0373878106,
-0.0436515063,
0.0320000686,
-0.0386604778,
-0.0122264773,
0.0135691995,
0.0174723417,
-0.0224931017,
0.047560744,
0.0159572437,
-0.026172949,
-0.0636401772,
0.0270772111,
0.0039576385,
0.0424925834,
-0.0958824679,
0.018730225,
0.004599385,
0.0645650327,
0.0045246715,
-0.016888313,
0.0854053646,
0.0003589757,
0.0391731709,
-0.053177651,
0.0143835219,
-0.0487572961,
0.0725455806,
-0.0670781061,
0.0014638948,
-0.0124611417,
-0.013749511,
-0.0309376568,
-0.0367258601,
0.0379819945,
-0.0430519022,
0.0670734644,
-0.0275680274,
0.0350763835,
-0.0035038278,
-0.056977585,
-0.016601203,
-0.0456636511,
0.0007736867,
0.0040497556,
-0.0277904235,
-0.0128621785,
-0.0201444142,
-0.000815594,
0.0028365743,
0.0259140357,
-0.0064223334,
-0.0120448936,
0.0041699074,
0.0116866743,
0.0367295183,
0.0024448475,
-0.0039528818,
0.0275489781,
-0.0041821767,
0.0605749823,
0.0375624299,
-0.0277404413,
0.0367210433,
0.0170670971,
0.0131868236,
-0.0315460451,
0.0179316849,
0.0297220573,
0.0705469325,
-0.0393276103,
-0.0393737182,
0.079438135,
0.043387305,
0.0180563778,
-0.0106436061,
-0.0417120829,
-0.0418512449,
0.0165750366,
0.0389232524,
-0.0570057966,
-0.0592264198,
-0.0025831158,
0.0128000705,
-0.00547066,
-0.0593312047,
0.0217865929,
-0.1139084101,
0.0031598175,
-0.0135214059,
-0.0750699639,
-0.0514885522,
-0.0574274436,
-0.0072630937,
-0.0025944584,
-0.0426133685,
0.026587097,
0.009178346,
0.0083991513,
-0.0057713059,
0.0193975624,
-0.0347625725,
0.0776133239,
-0.0205027219,
0.0206096955,
0.0386232398,
0.0493243523,
0.033857476,
-0.0709057897,
0.0120695783,
-0.0880899206,
-0.0042113038,
-0.0316801295,
-0.0131854312,
-0.0033141547,
-0.0091560716,
-0.0236952025,
0.0740569979,
-0.0786713734,
-0.0113757299,
0.0220140778,
0.0807982087,
-0.0238439422,
0.0105970167,
-0.0146373073,
0.024503367,
0.0355795361,
0.0983051062,
0.0170299299,
0.0131596886,
-0.0332030207,
-0.0450815074,
-0.0220581312,
-0.0338435583,
-0.0486723892,
0.0101266308,
0.0210846625,
0.0366141759,
-0.066328153,
-0.0441457257,
0.0525463894,
0.070033066,
-0.0059779277,
-0.0008470017,
0.0143503053,
0.0163377132,
-0.0518647544,
0.0562364459,
-0.0283028986,
-0.0309630707,
0.0035850711,
-0.0004124584,
0.0106033273,
-0.0275139194,
-0.0397273116,
0.0469766334,
-0.0163107831,
-0.0498730429,
-0.0612914003,
0.053132128,
0.0160066858,
0.0341826193,
-0.0300789233,
-0.0008606901,
0.0496113449,
-0.0002967248,
-0.050603494,
-0.049088303,
0.0273542497,
0.0287132896,
0.0160126109,
0.0696451068,
-0.0377751328,
-0.0008390039,
0.0121034048,
0.05998189,
-0.0194682125,
-0.0156078506,
0.0284885801,
-0.0017420936,
0.0430530272,
0.0595427454,
0.0256143771,
-0.0240922961,
0.0014354275,
-0.0489885285,
-0.0559451543,
-0.0109170051,
0.0440463424,
0.0255585741,
-0.0572436191,
-0.0287610125,
0.0076517425,
-0.036919117,
0.0239123777,
-0.0092607727,
0.010886725,
0.0653550401,
0.0300458577,
0.0323129706,
-0.0442280285,
-0.0421297066,
-0.0257575009,
-0.0201782566,
0.0444381125,
-0.0070935013,
0.0925131515,
0.0379902124,
0.0113997953,
-0.0182097796,
-0.0334941819,
-0.0530549809,
-0.0449799411,
-0.0084793102,
0.0412038043,
-0.0231658239,
-0.016754942,
-0.0196511056,
-0.0068583358,
-0.0218042582,
0.0132837454,
0.0443822853,
0.0209186859,
-0.0165213812,
0.0512621328,
0.0270362813,
0.0008237875,
-0.0018895984,
0.0555789024,
-0.0731569901,
0.0354237892,
-0.0129811903,
-0.0309299771,
-0.0119727552,
-0.0114390701,
-0.0044972254,
0.0509856567,
0.0234739147,
0.0347216316,
-0.0367647037,
-0.0589939877,
-0.0164078288,
0.0195079781,
-0.0257056262,
0.0052936422,
0.015374084,
0.0881875008,
0.0592565387,
-0.0656340271,
-0.0295315161,
0.0335305557,
-0.1191871241,
-0.0103506707,
-0.0392358154,
-6.704712679e-33,
-0.01754071,
-0.0351898,
0.0244294815,
-0.0642382205,
0.008763507,
0.0055982028,
-0.0591432042,
-0.0425937735,
-0.0326912627,
0.0063093486,
-0.0226542465,
0.0376852602,
-0.0138764,
0.0325319171,
0.0238053687,
-0.002201553,
-0.0295393523,
-0.0031445792,
-0.0239644833,
0.0020534727,
0.0868509635,
0.0095276013,
0.0379446372,
-0.0041664313,
0.0169568975,
-0.0336261056,
0.0192903373,
0.0759077072,
-0.0342012085,
0.0397586115,
-0.0100527145,
0.0463222079,
0.0132746426,
-0.03305557,
0.0363605469,
0.0282017123,
-0.1068010181,
-0.0656722933,
0.0271718893,
-0.0505565293,
-0.0569814593,
0.0170508642,
0.001992007,
-0.0067114038,
0.0431344025,
-0.0212875325,
0.0229369756,
-0.0109401355,
0.0157579053,
-0.0099479426,
-0.0118833529,
0.0037157112,
-0.0427554436,
-0.0324014015,
-0.0567116551,
0.035844624,
0.0060999938,
-0.0104552135,
-0.0471974798,
0.0212314241,
-0.0091452468,
-0.0007681291,
0.0181718748,
-0.0223559644,
0.0377805158,
0.0293605588,
-0.0712795034,
-0.0289628319,
-0.0676361248,
0.0060874219,
-0.0233521163,
0.0655729398,
0.0279927589,
0.0295897983,
0.0142957894,
0.0228970665,
-0.0815844983,
0.0374756232,
0.0004083147,
0.0433649495,
0.0082190922,
0.0014083786,
-0.0254982635,
-0.0283144377,
-0.0411916301,
-0.0102007668,
-0.026503263,
-0.0156993493,
0.0278844219,
-0.0082654878,
-0.0430212878,
0.0045776423,
0.0203569718,
-0.0149501804,
0.0057432284,
0.0701482818,
-0.0051703635,
-0.0355354659,
-0.0132958209,
0.0276104026,
-0.0668296218,
0.0101187071,
0.0150267854,
-0.0054737083,
-0.0103346389,
0.0495510139,
0.0095672496,
-0.00496748,
-0.0190748814,
-0.0349889696,
-0.0252546314,
0.0007187263,
-0.0335030779,
0.0108940722,
0.0595872104,
0.0521076396,
0.0173367355,
0.0782681778,
-0.0076026712,
0.0070035495,
0.00149688,
-0.0093827005,
0.0244557299,
-0.0023375631,
-0.0177111942,
0.0227253865,
-0.0229879674,
-0.0319177881,
-0.0224826559,
-0.0491591208,
0.0023264764,
0.0758610666,
2.618e-7,
0.0391366519,
0.0023081452,
0.024468815,
0.0347076282,
-0.002456696,
0.0342034437,
0.0086039053,
-0.002514377,
-0.0024061392,
-0.0478571616,
-0.0087698856,
0.0569866113,
0.0117064482,
0.0358601511,
-0.051963456,
0.007331735,
-0.0281433333,
-0.0285792872,
-0.0339569971,
-0.0217736382,
0.0744177103,
0.0431357063,
0.018503651,
-0.0079174209,
-0.0150263049,
-0.0587051511,
0.0410288572,
-0.0122211641,
-0.0039709429,
-0.00006322,
0.0049959361,
0.0056300312,
0.0020994716,
0.0364376716,
-0.0136845112,
0.0093355551,
-0.0001147822,
0.0498959944,
-0.0128659504,
-0.0552471541,
-0.0193159841,
-0.0490653664,
0.0151268896,
-0.0384448357,
0.1151831001,
-0.0881033912,
-0.0293792263,
-0.0137160067,
0.0054640989,
-0.0167935081,
-0.0026867006,
-0.0073576393,
0.0102472585,
0.0008178937,
0.0093533145,
-0.0036841927,
0.0230967551,
-0.1206658408,
-0.0040691351,
0.018010214,
-0.0126090581,
-0.0061322674,
0.0044368934,
-0.0309540015,
0.0259560291,
-0.057016626,
0.0098686693,
2.079494965e-34,
-0.0056756805,
-0.0011830623,
-0.0021783991,
-0.0223636273,
0.053485956,
-0.0169120356,
-0.0265576113,
-0.023587808,
0.040306773,
-0.069824174,
-0.0150938565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11671v1 | MixEdit: Revisiting Data Augmentation and Beyond for Grammatical Error Correction | 2023-10-18T02:45:51 | 2023-10-18T02:45:51 | Jingheng Ye, Yinghui Li, Yangning Li, Hai-Tao Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data Augmentation through generating pseudo data has been proven effective in
mitigating the challenge of data scarcity in the field of Grammatical Error
Correction (GEC). Various augmentation strategies have been widely explored,
most of which are motivated by two heuristics, i.e., increasing the
distribution similarity and diversity of pseudo data. However, the underlying
mechanism responsible for the effectiveness of these strategies remains poorly
understood. In this paper, we aim to clarify how data augmentation improves GEC
models. To this end, we introduce two interpretable and computationally
efficient measures: Affinity and Diversity. Our findings indicate that an
excellent GEC data augmentation strategy characterized by high Affinity and
appropriate Diversity can better improve the performance of GEC models. Based
on this observation, we propose MixEdit, a data augmentation approach that
strategically and dynamically augments realistic data, without requiring extra
monolingual corpora. To verify the correctness of our findings and the
effectiveness of the proposed MixEdit, we conduct experiments on mainstream
English and Chinese GEC datasets. The results show that MixEdit substantially
improves GEC models and is complementary to traditional data augmentation
methods. | [
0.0705680698,
0.0595532954,
-0.0207003634,
0.0222112443,
-0.0209344644,
0.026192734,
-0.02315378,
-0.0077613224,
-0.0150176967,
-0.0365699828,
-0.0345649011,
-0.058720924,
0.0466639698,
-0.0176219046,
0.0425802022,
-0.0381307155,
0.0809596628,
0.0053745168,
-0.0270020328,
-0.0054565934,
0.0169023462,
-0.0048917746,
-0.0061909216,
0.037314605,
-0.0454716384,
-0.0189900324,
0.0015994648,
0.0538319945,
0.0225757677,
-0.0051045981,
0.0453582853,
0.0624148548,
-0.0139006982,
0.0756328776,
0.0000019903,
-0.0348121002,
-0.0164100844,
-0.0041161473,
-0.0260105003,
0.0526149981,
0.0571259782,
-0.0338206887,
-0.0421043001,
-0.0005773626,
0.0117289098,
-0.0255077723,
0.0852906704,
0.0148364473,
0.0392620303,
0.0933701247,
-0.0062737986,
0.0155639807,
0.0530230477,
0.001916101,
-0.003076511,
0.0441383608,
0.0337781459,
0.0233809035,
0.0111770332,
-0.0087679727,
-0.034615729,
0.0310432538,
0.0006403805,
-0.0055795624,
0.0187132377,
0.0265387986,
-0.0325433649,
0.0039997171,
-0.0074584372,
0.0091633201,
-0.0029045981,
-0.0547998883,
-0.0260421708,
-0.0014563947,
0.0214906894,
0.0371202454,
-0.0206910074,
-0.024525892,
0.0107200397,
0.0293743107,
0.0760398433,
-0.0734204203,
0.021260703,
0.0245414823,
0.0090655303,
0.0848587304,
0.0240726378,
-0.0678543225,
-0.0390266553,
0.0583737493,
-0.0270013232,
-0.0429701023,
0.0187935419,
-0.0392982438,
-0.0348729156,
-0.0001371482,
-0.0460898131,
-0.0983727276,
0.0165228732,
-0.0341689289,
0.0328586362,
0.0196333565,
-0.0560464822,
-0.0074185096,
0.0042279297,
0.0197717305,
0.022718478,
0.0368916765,
-0.0376105234,
-0.0126312505,
-0.0472309887,
-0.0016290807,
-0.0281286221,
0.0178011563,
-0.0352677256,
0.0495613813,
-0.0733045712,
0.002009579,
-0.0355799086,
-0.013212272,
0.0119290026,
-0.0030114378,
-0.0686851889,
-0.0167310238,
-0.0052274312,
0.0216273367,
-0.0340691879,
0.0605552979,
0.0017554116,
-0.0840606987,
-0.0316629894,
0.008827664,
0.0501202829,
-0.0509336367,
-0.01181887,
-0.0378868841,
-0.0110415099,
-0.0405230895,
-0.0383403935,
0.0107098445,
-0.0395690948,
-0.0202963371,
-0.0625802279,
-0.0670920238,
0.0025213684,
-0.0235021785,
0.0222495701,
-0.0269947704,
-0.0275324825,
-0.0220380165,
-0.0294736102,
0.0604523793,
-0.0758183002,
0.01702624,
0.0027857099,
-0.0319019035,
0.0122944275,
0.038921088,
0.0076162964,
-0.0917182863,
0.0589224473,
0.0086406237,
0.0264438074,
0.0131301042,
-0.0297677461,
-0.0021577706,
0.008121321,
-0.0297876615,
-0.0148932207,
0.0095333653,
0.0496062785,
0.0464051776,
-0.0447415747,
0.0303679779,
0.056951385,
0.0162373353,
0.0067180903,
-0.0133074922,
-0.0046648644,
-0.0326090232,
-0.0044053113,
0.0394311473,
-0.0358601473,
-0.0006559405,
-0.0588034689,
0.002190687,
0.0221605431,
0.0196973011,
-0.013175101,
-0.0496903844,
-0.0151213221,
0.012591322,
0.028201092,
-0.0360956751,
0.0149151217,
0.0124167958,
0.0307825729,
0.0236716922,
0.0412571616,
-0.0879158303,
0.0202251859,
-0.0047837589,
-0.0221002661,
0.0680648759,
0.0537481084,
-0.0172790121,
-0.0592696145,
-0.0190873612,
-0.0164422728,
0.0319218896,
0.0293021966,
-0.0038800139,
-0.0004009411,
-0.0590401031,
-0.0096335439,
0.0097384695,
0.0511941612,
-0.0106587615,
0.0097554009,
-0.0018148557,
-0.0057233558,
-0.0516451783,
-0.0454555079,
0.0198316444,
-0.0149372583,
0.0153292809,
-0.0014160237,
-0.014240114,
0.0302355308,
0.0192817394,
-0.0364036597,
-0.0001069403,
-0.0233475845,
-0.0091528203,
-0.0258046612,
0.0010300534,
-0.0081129232,
-0.0529989041,
0.0516274124,
-0.0520268194,
-0.0328799114,
0.024761172,
-0.0331402943,
-0.0510256961,
-0.0051281308,
-0.0491778888,
0.0302692074,
-0.0827264041,
0.0413267091,
-0.0103024747,
0.0276511572,
-0.0184015781,
0.039656058,
-0.0021189835,
0.0430608578,
0.0039843707,
0.0074368808,
0.0098514892,
-0.0564405434,
-0.0416635722,
-0.0134236896,
-0.0034329605,
0.0358247757,
0.0251300298,
-0.000603259,
-0.048290804,
-0.0129916519,
-0.0881430879,
-0.0097475424,
-0.0516808666,
0.030142244,
0.0508174561,
0.0046225847,
-0.0296458211,
0.0054471106,
0.0145945624,
0.0015945132,
0.015711125,
0.0307636429,
0.0681132749,
-0.0215573143,
-0.0230900571,
-0.0607311614,
-0.0052147121,
-0.018749902,
-0.0194451064,
0.006329759,
-0.0182566289,
-0.0474392809,
0.0381263494,
-0.0350706689,
0.0071028238,
0.0418717749,
-0.0712566078,
-0.0118229985,
0.0132938791,
0.0559561811,
-0.0169686433,
-0.0326856636,
-0.0024940278,
0.0048068464,
-0.0382556729,
-0.0288201906,
-0.0221583489,
0.0005183056,
0.0118847257,
-0.0338753201,
-0.0415659249,
0.0062689157,
0.0465230905,
0.0088116154,
-0.068581976,
-0.0359559357,
-0.0109999059,
-0.0397898033,
-0.0249581486,
0.0015705635,
-0.008282681,
-0.0212851726,
0.0061692256,
-0.0542520955,
-0.0271054655,
0.0881635249,
0.0107266847,
-0.0074800476,
-0.0659832433,
-0.0187620614,
0.0021757327,
-0.0226974525,
-0.0088992873,
-0.0024485854,
-0.0164769646,
-0.0324395448,
-0.0489166267,
0.0268812738,
0.0438873507,
-0.0114646843,
0.0688545331,
-0.0651115701,
0.0310331602,
0.0304632988,
-0.0300094038,
-0.0103932498,
-0.0315864086,
0.0155660659,
-0.0367384329,
0.03135176,
-0.019024197,
-0.0194148608,
-0.0285746995,
0.0000642227,
0.0695926622,
-0.0237605423,
-0.013676011,
-0.0148860989,
-0.0054807807,
0.0075736935,
0.0426658727,
0.0135839107,
-0.0155945402,
-0.0113583189,
0.0403083786,
0.0062738112,
0.0066414536,
-0.0113628767,
0.025596641,
0.0319284946,
-0.0110940803,
-0.0535701737,
0.0012643329,
0.0735053569,
-0.0285897609,
-0.0538325608,
0.1082976907,
0.0498629063,
-0.0195124429,
0.0134493709,
-0.0207038932,
0.0368875265,
0.0099354843,
0.0005538746,
-0.0382623374,
-0.0036207831,
0.0259835161,
0.0146996016,
-0.0299285036,
-0.0345027074,
0.0286307558,
-0.1364781708,
0.0568488128,
0.0363063551,
-0.0261628814,
-0.0584019087,
-0.0115599465,
0.037512742,
-0.0044426634,
0.0458543524,
0.024218563,
0.0156249767,
0.0135492291,
0.0243736636,
-0.0313103683,
-0.1211632118,
-0.039900858,
-0.0470635891,
0.0661144629,
0.0500538759,
0.016498819,
-0.0060210209,
-0.0240693931,
0.0332785957,
-0.0012206679,
-0.0321931019,
-0.0051936349,
0.0434130244,
0.030430302,
-0.0070279799,
-0.0159589555,
0.0568092018,
-0.0253475904,
-0.0131594976,
-0.0224820673,
0.0854776055,
-0.0114645176,
0.0340344161,
0.0242198221,
-0.0279303342,
0.0231259838,
0.0544218719,
0.0270751361,
-0.0235121455,
0.0123333056,
-0.059986189,
0.0257781669,
-0.0513320528,
0.0551607274,
0.0612311997,
-0.0392125957,
-0.0614651851,
-0.0682736337,
-0.0927925706,
0.0029233219,
-0.0152760018,
0.0292192828,
-0.0010146329,
-0.0223253537,
-0.0265137106,
0.0346779153,
0.010539257,
-0.0193842035,
0.0223534442,
-0.0392129049,
-0.0288901366,
-0.0393504426,
0.0305733867,
-0.0076987878,
-0.0032941464,
-0.0525298901,
-0.0611296482,
0.0419448614,
0.0202502422,
0.0128829582,
0.0388530307,
-0.0063128271,
-0.0898622945,
-0.0021970284,
0.0722232834,
-0.0146957738,
0.0530769229,
0.0343535505,
-0.0591870695,
0.0109091038,
0.0259166453,
-0.0137216058,
-0.001186522,
0.0221288931,
0.0818868726,
-0.0337999053,
0.0110206176,
0.0638041347,
0.0460588373,
0.0617297553,
-0.0223324355,
0.0067195212,
-0.0826768354,
0.0111443168,
-0.0340232812,
-0.0115260743,
-0.0165798515,
-0.0126422532,
0.0557270609,
-0.0293442104,
-0.0438967273,
0.0023261989,
-0.0489079691,
0.0293415021,
-0.0611338355,
-0.0122665847,
0.0329410434,
0.024692161,
0.0158535391,
0.0133996839,
0.0052962299,
0.0114758387,
0.0249388125,
0.0329124071,
0.0013499846,
-0.0053456221,
0.0213280413,
0.0088110669,
0.0174005236,
0.0037816651,
-0.0659521297,
0.0646280944,
-0.035373386,
0.0262297634,
0.0741335154,
-0.003851488,
0.0950581506,
-0.0323782489,
-0.0153273391,
-0.0461638048,
0.0144856181,
0.0311185457,
0.00032035,
0.0014931463,
-0.0065277382,
-0.0063457666,
-0.0331425071,
0.0418762416,
-0.0678265169,
0.0408627167,
-0.0414823294,
-0.0326081887,
-0.0073995572,
-0.0220281575,
0.0002178968,
-0.0134815518,
-0.0205050893,
0.0088417502,
-0.0590193681,
-0.0689867437,
0.0174052883,
0.0511548333,
0.0205044951,
-0.0071071563,
-0.0020006441,
0.0303174127,
-0.0340605676,
0.0193028841,
-0.0381664969,
-0.0204778425,
0.0298564062,
-0.0127373217,
-0.0365444422,
-6.482101967e-33,
-0.0426554643,
0.0219440181,
-0.0501394048,
-0.0706328824,
0.0007785856,
-0.0035286986,
-0.0245830957,
0.0215566866,
0.0295287538,
0.0487204082,
-0.0187211037,
0.0450465642,
0.018541282,
0.0340794884,
0.0503179021,
0.013735191,
0.049142614,
0.0301887356,
-0.018160183,
-0.043129731,
0.0541046336,
0.0330298692,
0.0959139019,
-0.0319988243,
0.0924673006,
0.0132464021,
-0.0089541804,
0.0111848004,
0.0219007954,
0.0473651476,
0.0375478789,
0.0935453326,
0.013561788,
0.0154984389,
-0.036934536,
-0.0443448238,
-0.0747623816,
-0.0646391436,
0.041793935,
0.0363123678,
0.0129935956,
-0.024254581,
0.0340316519,
-0.0177028216,
-0.029899016,
-0.0111599043,
0.0148941418,
-0.0460605994,
0.0082372585,
0.0364539884,
-0.0245897062,
0.0284279473,
-0.0086374143,
0.028099481,
-0.0064253756,
0.0376669727,
0.0016905626,
-0.0148699228,
-0.0775019675,
0.0026860903,
0.0584539436,
0.0481836908,
0.028972894,
-0.0247248355,
-0.0208929237,
0.0256917793,
0.0102141332,
0.0043844529,
-0.0064598094,
0.0212624893,
0.0316196419,
-0.0008783229,
0.013682724,
0.0693801269,
0.0541557856,
-0.0384009592,
-0.0167627726,
0.0340375975,
-0.0048321784,
0.0002033419,
-0.0097540068,
0.0141387517,
-0.0535362996,
-0.0547377951,
0.0002298727,
0.0124568101,
-0.0124822725,
-0.0156449433,
0.0446516052,
-0.0187925547,
-0.0310204495,
0.0367334262,
0.0002560766,
-0.0215292238,
-0.0513608493,
-0.0087108137,
0.0001421793,
0.0308787376,
0.0030116104,
0.0267184712,
-0.0135854054,
-0.0299651604,
0.0300468504,
0.0267000962,
0.0095366854,
0.007456257,
0.0608331487,
0.0238813143,
-0.0722915828,
0.0216794964,
0.003917519,
0.0117959715,
-0.0117755719,
-0.0229717214,
0.0062697632,
0.0093501899,
0.0191923492,
0.0130425859,
0.0563819669,
0.0309614185,
-0.0373469144,
-0.0114640892,
-0.0394306853,
0.0078335982,
0.0145548312,
0.0041907551,
-0.0177532509,
-0.0603410341,
0.0260811113,
-0.0444556251,
0.0009186514,
-0.010777629,
2.701e-7,
0.0420019776,
0.0463582762,
0.0304186195,
-0.0057503986,
-0.0077371234,
0.0030347107,
-0.0388147868,
0.0071704877,
0.0159447957,
-0.0029916954,
0.0400241092,
0.0142535912,
0.03938495,
0.0091868183,
-0.0105864741,
-0.0013162765,
-0.0456405208,
0.0302458238,
-0.0241426993,
0.0088628931,
0.0034506924,
0.0750026628,
0.042035155,
-0.0058404505,
-0.0054249712,
-0.023958113,
0.0218740683,
-0.0157338437,
-0.0399982743,
0.0598053634,
0.0694083497,
0.0200420991,
0.0476732403,
0.022399161,
-0.0374963619,
0.0041419398,
0.0209294651,
-0.0006145564,
-0.024567958,
0.0649533197,
-0.0124143492,
-0.0111651197,
-0.0154880704,
-0.0368780009,
0.0419804156,
-0.0032474375,
0.021969052,
0.017773496,
-0.0414346457,
0.0258439574,
0.0335688777,
-0.0397259481,
-0.0479923151,
0.0108416695,
0.0672936961,
0.034135852,
-0.0199233592,
-0.0021385278,
-0.0220526215,
0.0418421105,
0.0017502683,
-0.0469068699,
0.0288373753,
0.0255932976,
0.0119660702,
-0.0413477309,
-0.0082172323,
2.437439423e-34,
0.0599993952,
0.0229516011,
0.0408223085,
-0.0022035935,
0.037288744,
-0.0201587565,
0.0041372217,
0.0242312346,
-0.0215060525,
-0.0410489142,
-0.0303163677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11670v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11670v3 | Prototype-based HyperAdapter for Sample-Efficient Multi-task Tuning | 2023-10-18T02:42:17 | 2023-11-11T15:30:30 | Hao Zhao, Jie Fu, Zhaofeng He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) has shown its effectiveness in
adapting the pre-trained language models to downstream tasks while only
updating a small number of parameters. Despite the success, most existing
methods independently adapt to each task without considering knowledge transfer
between tasks and are limited to low-data regimes. To overcome this issue, we
propose Prototype-based HyperAdapter (PHA), a novel framework built on the
adapter-tuning and hypernetwork. It introduces an instance-dense retriever and
a prototypical hypernetwork to generate the conditional modules in a
sample-efficient manner. This leads to comparable performance improvements
against existing PEFT methods on multi-task learning and few-shot transfer
learning. More importantly, when the available data size gets smaller, our
method outperforms other strong baselines by a large margin. Based on our
extensive empirical experiments across various datasets, we demonstrate that
PHA strikes a better trade-off between trainable parameters, accuracy on stream
tasks, and sample efficiency. | [
0.0200530179,
0.0740253329,
-0.0281727593,
0.0142393271,
-0.0128643727,
0.003993005,
0.0227632802,
-0.0201307572,
-0.0298363268,
-0.0250818469,
-0.0511874817,
-0.0443837158,
-0.0237735715,
0.0214579292,
0.0151437214,
-0.0282593053,
0.0415949114,
0.004695768,
-0.0139794908,
0.0065597687,
0.0137261692,
0.0371539593,
-0.0129084839,
0.0328334235,
0.0228304397,
-0.0013435417,
-0.0184478704,
0.0300065018,
0.0102003189,
0.008117198,
0.0494824462,
0.0591350906,
0.0330959298,
0.0102979373,
0.0000020361,
-0.0239877123,
-0.0369020924,
-0.0340586193,
-0.0093597881,
-0.0019149602,
0.0759942383,
-0.0222642571,
-0.0092161885,
0.0345129855,
-0.0427495576,
-0.0403922088,
0.07181447,
0.0151847089,
0.0403507017,
0.0967459008,
-0.0178429466,
0.0262459237,
0.0124144834,
-0.0380265117,
-0.0339076929,
-0.0285034087,
0.0060306317,
-0.0007820999,
-0.0083052432,
-0.0135001531,
-0.0156531855,
0.0183205586,
0.0060634241,
0.0276879407,
-0.0371882059,
0.000868948,
-0.0763935745,
-0.0150974691,
-0.0332055986,
0.0628881231,
-0.0800741911,
-0.0281954836,
0.0124517912,
-0.0242836401,
-0.0349804983,
-0.0069794161,
0.0040685814,
-0.0351036116,
0.0141154444,
0.0239004716,
0.0017961253,
-0.0447963104,
0.0141210956,
0.0408660062,
-0.0220433995,
0.0411360636,
0.0126133841,
0.0340138189,
-0.027461553,
0.0174219385,
0.0010705366,
-0.0265180487,
0.0171953291,
0.0178672038,
-0.044176925,
0.0002983488,
-0.0723878369,
-0.088913016,
-0.0212436374,
-0.0104633067,
0.1102378517,
0.0484533869,
-0.0091552222,
0.0022213878,
-0.0205351431,
-0.0027543679,
-0.0306541268,
0.0239558071,
-0.0520381108,
-0.0214370526,
-0.0485966392,
0.0190080944,
-0.0954177156,
0.026257392,
-0.0225510206,
-0.0057591777,
-0.0087354854,
0.0375582203,
-0.0007128158,
-0.0369908921,
-0.0084119141,
-0.0248420313,
-0.0764786005,
-0.0363441035,
0.0231834948,
0.0610193051,
-0.0102843,
0.060966678,
-0.0047462839,
-0.0552059375,
-0.0293370951,
0.0234230198,
0.0348191075,
-0.0158818364,
0.0422242098,
0.0356676653,
-0.0234736949,
-0.044353094,
-0.0403046608,
0.0055685365,
0.0382901877,
-0.0692555308,
-0.0076485667,
-0.0491639748,
0.0281475596,
-0.005741376,
-0.0081918258,
-0.0138956467,
-0.0321090519,
-0.0261325408,
-0.0166285392,
0.0409964249,
-0.001888453,
-0.0059347232,
-0.0034868277,
-0.0206647739,
-0.0329137184,
0.0972872078,
0.0537688173,
0.0343565531,
0.031297192,
0.0005822107,
-0.019597929,
0.0390095487,
0.0015013827,
-0.0025666256,
-0.033007443,
0.0060746092,
-0.001311272,
-0.022189986,
0.0471433923,
-0.0234805923,
-0.0314713418,
0.0284331553,
0.0459669009,
0.0055364338,
0.0418977141,
0.0007660397,
0.060449563,
-0.0044970196,
-0.0160670802,
0.0074837315,
-0.0345410965,
0.0325551815,
0.0063470313,
-0.0106648533,
0.0062925215,
0.0707065687,
-0.0485213362,
-0.0290675312,
0.0313966796,
-0.0175474547,
-0.022557864,
0.0234075375,
0.0403297246,
0.0228971262,
-0.0626528636,
0.0625159889,
0.0558281802,
-0.010237637,
0.0008962393,
-0.0364613049,
0.0011406123,
0.0664021149,
-0.0095211063,
-0.0382445529,
-0.0635806248,
0.0044198576,
0.0497959852,
-0.0043081017,
0.0409806333,
-0.016783867,
0.0533221513,
-0.0826778486,
-0.0092564635,
0.0160990786,
0.0382941514,
0.0360639095,
0.0004519575,
0.0117100338,
0.0257120114,
-0.0177858751,
-0.0214797389,
0.0110327974,
-0.0019707589,
0.0175711233,
0.0429054275,
0.0025882947,
0.0231118686,
-0.039766226,
-0.0251487158,
-0.0174367838,
0.0040749889,
-0.0147911441,
0.0406590849,
-0.0217748303,
-0.0417896472,
-0.041237995,
-0.0185325816,
0.0150986668,
0.0406798124,
0.0710905716,
-0.0523591787,
-0.0594998859,
0.0159933567,
0.0162091255,
0.0662252083,
-0.0148726832,
0.0109174727,
-0.0332595184,
0.0753526837,
0.0098959291,
0.0029388657,
0.0578075014,
-0.0060450961,
-0.0123940818,
0.0039590271,
-0.0017319584,
-0.0283334292,
-0.0186551455,
-0.0160558037,
-0.0000493974,
0.0321112759,
-0.0203447212,
0.0203740355,
-0.0045721205,
-0.035847012,
-0.0543932691,
0.0562369861,
-0.0673923492,
0.042962078,
0.0386732928,
0.0402135476,
-0.0038071601,
-0.0280810576,
0.0072842301,
0.0803762153,
-0.0243701711,
0.031750109,
-0.0118275182,
0.0102577293,
-0.0154989455,
-0.0377019532,
-0.0328918919,
0.0050520245,
0.0274681542,
-0.0037306086,
0.0063044182,
-0.0457515381,
0.0146140233,
-0.0122832404,
0.0327922925,
-0.0067346795,
-0.0194059666,
-0.0242749527,
-0.0410724282,
0.0259148777,
0.0784802735,
-0.0337318555,
-0.0165965986,
0.053865701,
0.012458588,
-0.0483646803,
0.0093359519,
-0.0356201567,
0.0030722471,
-0.0544141941,
0.0802368149,
-0.0190002844,
0.0523142219,
-0.0236072447,
-0.0443276614,
-0.0435926542,
0.0057477946,
0.0096746003,
-0.0041706464,
0.0139234336,
0.0156683829,
-0.0179822464,
0.0325276479,
-0.0284782797,
-0.0553267151,
0.0514652282,
0.0102858208,
-0.008382665,
-0.0404654853,
-0.036353942,
-0.0223164037,
0.0077998377,
0.0367500409,
0.0102070402,
0.0183334686,
-0.0284464397,
-0.059613999,
0.0053253616,
-0.0012687647,
-0.0132206315,
0.0400043763,
-0.0406742319,
-0.001746079,
-0.0410618335,
-0.0655242726,
-0.0161235295,
-0.0080297962,
0.0049174791,
0.0387819521,
-0.0034388045,
-0.0058729304,
-0.0517367572,
0.0044937688,
-0.027056979,
0.0740565956,
-0.0153100984,
-0.0103208497,
-0.0450925305,
0.0497720949,
0.0583550707,
0.0229715854,
0.0150076523,
0.0195760448,
-0.0253527649,
-0.0039914725,
0.078164801,
-0.0208258051,
-0.0532329492,
0.033718612,
0.0427497439,
-0.0083925109,
-0.0103380084,
0.0286425278,
0.0464211069,
-0.0805874839,
-0.01361511,
0.0797523856,
-0.0046255169,
-0.0445091464,
-0.0003524106,
0.0462014899,
0.0338975228,
0.0194561761,
0.0614086725,
-0.0711890683,
-0.0286281221,
0.0115143443,
0.0252909511,
0.0138968984,
-0.0172654837,
-0.0248514116,
-0.0877530277,
0.0152517101,
0.0074728914,
-0.0488586538,
0.0086500188,
-0.0411920212,
0.0096171042,
-0.0325241461,
-0.0003112171,
0.0191413555,
0.0117237512,
-0.0171965677,
0.0094245747,
0.018149253,
-0.0820668042,
0.03065053,
-0.0426597632,
0.0460924208,
0.0135321254,
0.0068312264,
-0.0127642602,
0.0159924719,
-0.0093727475,
-0.0463845804,
-0.0294086002,
-0.0142015126,
0.0283334181,
-0.0089753503,
-0.0433206335,
0.015821984,
0.0249024071,
-0.0083804224,
0.0035493865,
-0.0145778982,
0.0690480322,
-0.0120916711,
0.0095547317,
-0.0095261801,
-0.0571135655,
0.0513107292,
0.0220546834,
-0.011129396,
-0.0292433351,
-0.0150924912,
0.0259201806,
-0.0551628321,
-0.0855758414,
0.0165717173,
0.0004508561,
-0.0227401182,
-0.011943955,
-0.0278027635,
0.0014572019,
0.0402973332,
0.0597315878,
0.0184600968,
0.0179025456,
0.037676122,
-0.0063810707,
-0.0598050468,
0.0361853428,
-0.0284407046,
0.003408731,
-0.0326400287,
-0.0539545491,
0.0938241929,
-0.0206549745,
-0.0195713211,
0.029532617,
-0.0648020953,
-0.0633291453,
-0.0089150025,
0.0432778709,
0.0131068304,
0.0694571882,
-0.0179434735,
-0.0411295108,
-0.0078165196,
0.0235742312,
-0.0230696071,
0.0047183824,
0.0564141087,
-0.021850951,
-0.0155487088,
0.0610078722,
-0.0490620695,
0.0478453711,
0.0518801771,
0.0109870629,
0.0017555611,
-0.0463499129,
-0.0215643961,
-0.0154764829,
0.0383435786,
0.0081467424,
-0.0013418179,
-0.0587105639,
0.0412974395,
0.0211775322,
0.0210162625,
-0.0511127263,
0.0145591451,
-0.0002874741,
-0.0272607859,
-0.0273881126,
0.0207334757,
0.0487739258,
0.0445421189,
-0.0277992915,
0.0281497929,
-0.0386962704,
-0.0066701765,
0.0484516323,
-0.0040903925,
-0.0012394398,
0.006530405,
0.0755331367,
0.0399381444,
-0.066756472,
-0.0026036035,
0.0005417044,
0.0030550007,
-0.0929898173,
0.0430474244,
-0.0532238372,
-0.0124889361,
-0.0425679237,
0.0282873772,
0.0362309255,
-0.0511255227,
0.0546599925,
-0.0101448921,
0.0069931028,
-0.0305367708,
0.0339600183,
-0.0004038613,
0.0018141452,
0.033491388,
0.0219928417,
-0.014270803,
0.0369039588,
0.066472277,
-0.0145748435,
0.0711881742,
0.0027948173,
0.0056373924,
-0.0298630167,
-0.0154028041,
0.038859196,
0.0104168309,
-0.023623487,
-0.0076863198,
-0.0008956316,
-0.029961193,
0.0247159079,
-0.0289261509,
-0.0090765906,
-0.0048417104,
0.0197262354,
0.055965066,
-0.0133015374,
0.009430781,
-0.0386467054,
-0.060802456,
0.0040094401,
0.0129108103,
-0.0049941838,
-6.58579012e-33,
-0.0242040157,
0.0556821339,
0.0156193236,
-0.0007720418,
-0.0186908878,
-0.0141746495,
-0.026264308,
-0.0171847753,
-0.0395319983,
-0.0229713786,
-0.0256358813,
-0.0069946647,
0.0357230082,
0.0271429624,
0.0140191205,
0.0247475058,
0.0543494709,
-0.0004130208,
-0.036088217,
0.0310432483,
0.0549381077,
0.0468471497,
0.0950746611,
-0.0151539538,
-0.0645839721,
0.0094021698,
0.0134635009,
0.014603531,
-0.0133206202,
0.0425714552,
0.033318419,
0.0702244788,
0.0147459675,
-0.0472538956,
-0.0434286669,
0.020360142,
-0.0958427936,
-0.0388961248,
0.0076053417,
0.0332955942,
0.002409362,
-0.0335078277,
0.047578048,
0.0100121209,
-0.0045031984,
-0.0028140785,
0.0158063732,
-0.0294041336,
-0.0139696896,
-0.0562020205,
-0.0704268068,
0.0049841497,
0.0010161899,
-0.0166284796,
0.0336062945,
0.0061576026,
0.0015729592,
-0.0337639526,
-0.0494060405,
0.0161674898,
0.0044080745,
0.0816955194,
0.0198389404,
0.0369208455,
0.0029499927,
0.0254318677,
0.0492578372,
0.017273644,
0.0769699961,
0.0363373458,
0.0831437483,
0.0585082769,
-0.0114968345,
0.0231744908,
0.0217353776,
-0.0778629631,
-0.0692190304,
-0.018355744,
0.0130963512,
0.0225292444,
0.0201928206,
0.0262535457,
-0.0154629443,
-0.0033830674,
-0.0330746807,
-0.0038246447,
-0.0239611678,
-0.0298741125,
0.0193022732,
0.0421223417,
-0.029064754,
0.0536084808,
0.0665014684,
-0.0533426665,
-0.00374211,
0.0245770775,
-0.0342439674,
0.014624171,
0.005675992,
0.0282865521,
-0.0344815254,
-0.0791176781,
0.0267091934,
0.0116705075,
0.0021235107,
-0.0064445068,
0.0419257022,
0.0609744191,
-0.0616525188,
0.0007661675,
-0.0443621762,
0.007780835,
0.0168098193,
0.105204314,
0.0121602546,
0.0140757207,
-0.013671698,
0.0372744985,
-0.0021062931,
-0.0809339061,
0.01131019,
0.0134917246,
0.0199686214,
0.0252346601,
-0.0403113738,
0.0134592643,
-0.0782492384,
-0.0129004614,
0.0206017178,
-0.0498930253,
-0.0164518766,
0.0337722525,
2.901e-7,
0.0152675891,
0.0365854204,
-0.0149728237,
-0.0305001494,
0.0079892129,
-0.0012721934,
-0.0418500677,
0.0098531554,
0.0030001777,
0.0287483092,
0.0171965826,
0.0197398905,
0.045019716,
0.0121491458,
-0.0805838928,
-0.0021172275,
-0.0152836377,
0.0239898413,
-0.0353022143,
-0.0500411615,
0.0269495845,
0.1129004732,
0.0108232461,
-0.0252139308,
0.0214125738,
-0.0212702136,
0.0058806445,
0.0170124322,
0.0083776191,
0.0563176684,
-0.0143470345,
0.0550035052,
-0.0390777737,
0.0247682445,
-0.0332516283,
0.0454611741,
-0.038369745,
0.0684429482,
-0.009741595,
-0.0285072681,
0.0191657636,
-0.0059111379,
-0.0259623937,
-0.0168117546,
0.0828204304,
-0.0677659512,
-0.0191115327,
-0.0346368067,
0.0010065773,
-0.0001520132,
-0.0253877919,
-0.0145040713,
-0.0017057569,
0.0224263463,
0.0251310579,
-0.0157699287,
-0.0550485477,
-0.0691684783,
0.0301191118,
0.0465883575,
-0.0160092916,
-0.0464977957,
-0.0240608267,
-0.0464848429,
0.0371587723,
-0.0850035548,
0.0085134637,
2.621539517e-34,
0.0204230566,
-0.0020017091,
0.0304708295,
0.0263605677,
-0.0005866906,
0.0068092733,
-0.0425591283,
0.0026707938,
-0.016691586,
-0.0816576034,
-0.0351264067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11667v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11667v2 | SOTOPIA: Interactive Evaluation for Social Intelligence in Language Agents | 2023-10-18T02:27:01 | 2024-03-22T18:52:15 | Xuhui Zhou, Hao Zhu, Leena Mathur, Ruohong Zhang, Haofei Yu, Zhengyang Qi, Louis-Philippe Morency, Yonatan Bisk, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig, Maarten Sap | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Humans are social beings; we pursue social goals in our daily interactions,
which is a crucial aspect of social intelligence. Yet, AI systems' abilities in
this realm remain elusive. We present SOTOPIA, an open-ended environment to
simulate complex social interactions between artificial agents and evaluate
their social intelligence. In our environment, agents role-play and interact
under a wide variety of scenarios; they coordinate, collaborate, exchange, and
compete with each other to achieve complex social goals. We simulate the
role-play interaction between LLM-based agents and humans within this task
space and evaluate their performance with a holistic evaluation framework
called SOTOPIA-Eval. With SOTOPIA, we find significant differences between
these models in terms of their social intelligence, and we identify a subset of
SOTOPIA scenarios, SOTOPIA-hard, that is generally challenging for all models.
We find that on this subset, GPT-4 achieves a significantly lower goal
completion rate than humans and struggles to exhibit social commonsense
reasoning and strategic communication skills. These findings demonstrate
SOTOPIA's promise as a general platform for research on evaluating and
improving social intelligence in artificial agents. | [
0.0651244074,
0.0051830551,
-0.0439555943,
0.0323384106,
-0.0368906595,
0.0138451969,
-0.0086072246,
0.0022360398,
0.0361000858,
0.0213471819,
-0.0487104952,
-0.0164786838,
0.0111321658,
0.0194753259,
0.0191450194,
-0.028554868,
0.0184269696,
-0.0055570202,
0.0585242659,
-0.0184138305,
-0.0207028296,
0.0047010984,
-0.0115270559,
0.0251521673,
-0.0266554095,
0.0181381609,
-0.0176047292,
-0.0327939652,
0.0333479904,
-0.0154997138,
0.0150374779,
0.0350811258,
0.0249506552,
0.0322505049,
0.0000019136,
-0.0619510934,
0.0470258668,
-0.0337945595,
0.0153126428,
-0.0317566097,
0.0459507704,
0.0295371674,
0.0046359967,
0.01670634,
-0.1060538888,
0.0214155186,
-0.0142875491,
0.005797762,
0.0325545222,
0.0379024111,
-0.0026963968,
-0.0151389828,
-0.018045757,
-0.0364621468,
0.0127840331,
-0.0665996224,
0.003794651,
-0.021304192,
0.0321066678,
-0.0232249442,
0.034724202,
0.0206724294,
0.0356950052,
-0.0338989161,
0.0088335127,
0.0208792128,
-0.0291598048,
-0.0411574095,
-0.027314838,
0.0602862984,
0.0588285364,
-0.0194354784,
0.0015534643,
0.03240804,
0.0622603223,
0.0528439954,
-0.004643878,
-0.0147226779,
0.0508034937,
0.0189463105,
0.0456529036,
0.0418895148,
0.016502047,
0.0087684644,
0.0296019856,
0.0824288279,
-0.0379556865,
-0.0152453342,
0.0185087919,
-0.002788821,
-0.0011974799,
-0.0366776623,
-0.001178989,
0.0638527572,
-0.0520626269,
0.0115561085,
-0.020485051,
0.0443631895,
0.0256756973,
-0.0148901744,
0.0506456308,
0.0184272993,
0.0500267521,
0.0362321883,
0.006985412,
0.0552736036,
0.0475837626,
0.0163362622,
-0.0059267608,
-0.0116548827,
-0.050699234,
-0.0153078139,
-0.0442768931,
0.0329865627,
-0.0237082988,
-0.0028481325,
0.0024152468,
0.0227351747,
-0.072027944,
0.0520636402,
0.0283602662,
0.0246707145,
0.0012946485,
0.0036194213,
-0.0555426851,
-0.0182625409,
-0.0637248531,
0.013525432,
0.0053985114,
-0.0575993918,
-0.007783141,
-0.0216018017,
0.0183531009,
-0.0145821264,
0.0255964138,
0.0643995851,
-0.006050087,
-0.0638125613,
0.0068658921,
-0.0172860809,
0.0174775682,
-0.097868897,
0.0025932053,
-0.0317547917,
0.0699223652,
-0.0028721313,
-0.0450699143,
-0.0227677282,
0.0030376057,
-0.0122056399,
-0.0018621931,
0.0593319051,
0.0067721494,
0.0251021925,
0.0239752643,
0.0470462628,
-0.0162181761,
0.0529257134,
0.0408663154,
-0.0103626708,
0.0273108464,
0.0106492164,
0.050645031,
0.0439783223,
0.0001238127,
0.0088057248,
0.0548026226,
-0.0090912813,
-0.0133219911,
0.0462396741,
0.0243274346,
0.0171367619,
-0.0143507747,
-0.0292989388,
0.0714131668,
0.1038271859,
-0.0172456019,
0.0238748118,
0.0378756002,
0.0558760613,
0.0034492768,
-0.0098638292,
-0.0638386905,
0.0612551384,
-0.0376230553,
-0.0219958089,
-0.0488512069,
0.0060487594,
-0.035746932,
-0.026614029,
0.0087089436,
0.003841273,
0.0785919726,
0.0164809972,
-0.0145655666,
-0.0234478936,
-0.0380612575,
-0.0001168391,
-0.0029436387,
-0.0622488111,
0.013128126,
-0.0585807562,
0.0318534151,
0.0636124089,
0.0473723002,
-0.0491213389,
-0.0355092101,
0.0337870307,
-0.0311888345,
0.0744320974,
0.0475092605,
-0.0458375774,
-0.0038763389,
-0.008333886,
0.0078889299,
0.0010583682,
0.0085939141,
0.0307277273,
0.0194167309,
0.0142349256,
-0.0208419207,
-0.0030681549,
0.0008359507,
0.0088621145,
0.0051016374,
0.0173976608,
-0.0735895857,
0.0060115126,
0.0612018779,
0.0180255901,
0.0028986053,
-0.0227868613,
0.0254833754,
0.0137872305,
-0.0405866057,
0.0529017858,
-0.0151710548,
-0.0084691951,
0.034025263,
-0.038072899,
-0.0440194979,
0.0916622654,
0.0135405026,
-0.0151872905,
0.0602331869,
-0.0518494472,
0.0321446694,
-0.0288133286,
0.0192170404,
-0.0552208722,
0.0165043268,
0.0232062992,
0.0466746651,
-0.0052266917,
-0.0321279466,
-0.0186197013,
-0.0117896097,
-0.0161044206,
-0.042255383,
0.001604534,
0.0271074828,
0.0262775812,
-0.024356626,
0.0167805366,
0.0233651306,
-0.0503142998,
-0.0576468557,
-0.115808703,
-0.0318450183,
0.0044756844,
-0.0048476518,
0.0012007057,
-0.0299418513,
-0.0060558585,
0.010223248,
-0.0376930796,
0.0625543147,
0.0374540351,
-0.0075184526,
0.0485500507,
0.0035828613,
-0.055030942,
-0.0378669798,
0.0402952395,
-0.0044079805,
-0.0251143984,
0.0272516161,
0.0158494618,
-0.0188024845,
0.004195089,
-0.065448761,
0.0428968668,
-0.0257697031,
-0.0870904624,
0.0408458561,
0.0255245846,
-0.0055002728,
0.0645758584,
0.0191217829,
0.074382022,
0.0359476283,
-0.0142582627,
-0.0609302893,
0.0360972434,
-0.0011750387,
0.0464861169,
-0.0893301517,
-0.0599300936,
-0.0264141597,
0.0395777337,
-0.0045288107,
0.0345916189,
-0.0515244342,
0.0090767955,
0.0139788529,
-0.0703665167,
0.0057449471,
-0.0316947512,
-0.0298232846,
0.0170618743,
-0.017615445,
0.0022758967,
0.0709060952,
-0.016437985,
-0.040406201,
-0.0155511545,
-0.0106298225,
-0.0076990845,
0.1019655019,
-0.0196544379,
-0.0203723181,
-0.0757662803,
-0.0172439013,
-0.0367106088,
-0.0143712452,
-0.000453756,
-0.0315858871,
0.0222846419,
-0.0719255209,
-0.0205878373,
0.0164614283,
-0.0024924378,
-0.014844629,
0.0025688212,
-0.0431198031,
0.0244885664,
0.0208676811,
-0.0315516926,
-0.0155183086,
-0.0264035761,
0.0180232618,
-0.0025357464,
-0.0028577929,
-0.0033484525,
-0.0179120842,
-0.0462954566,
0.0301389191,
0.0745744556,
0.0061375131,
0.0020372616,
0.0440502092,
0.027336847,
0.0212359317,
-0.0216072425,
-0.0159687884,
0.0222308021,
0.0377630778,
0.0230499562,
-0.0105345687,
0.0131331598,
0.0576994382,
-0.0327104963,
-0.017666202,
0.1301293969,
0.0266693439,
-0.0077070813,
0.0246641338,
-0.0290231667,
0.0157168414,
0.0118136676,
0.0270446055,
-0.023835741,
-0.0169848427,
0.0135121737,
0.0015553907,
-0.0400762446,
-0.0717930645,
0.0213048067,
-0.1019712538,
0.0532353185,
-0.0102657788,
-0.0542189218,
-0.0051405216,
-0.0308723133,
0.0208379105,
-0.0013195676,
0.011292059,
-0.0012834193,
0.05432906,
-0.034548834,
-0.0540842935,
-0.0189145319,
-0.0295806918,
0.0719856396,
-0.0469334833,
0.0987294614,
0.0387790874,
0.0931685567,
-0.0360997058,
-0.0668349862,
-0.0137431649,
0.0465156995,
0.0145616885,
-0.01837104,
0.011766091,
-0.0035331543,
0.0107076149,
-0.0032971508,
0.0140912309,
-0.039118208,
0.0055688405,
0.0204655975,
0.0676372945,
-0.0505073071,
-0.0580800958,
0.0330656022,
0.0379355513,
0.0001722255,
0.0759187192,
0.0202819407,
-0.0200006384,
-0.0119051347,
0.0147962477,
-0.0432664715,
-0.0492244922,
-0.0338315964,
-0.0031998344,
0.0341105722,
-0.0174010396,
-0.0543838479,
-0.1042755172,
0.042333506,
-0.0051360116,
-0.0099100368,
-0.0332828648,
0.0315180533,
0.0284224283,
-0.0163978506,
0.0126321968,
-0.0068656248,
0.0203706753,
0.0130653763,
-0.0207878835,
-0.0252464525,
-0.0689798743,
0.0039001903,
0.0092354594,
-0.0035910541,
-0.048357103,
0.0140805719,
0.0345016308,
0.0300875958,
0.0234232098,
-0.0359083898,
-0.0286831204,
0.0109653054,
-0.0312731937,
-0.0186988804,
0.0601917394,
0.0116738351,
-0.0052830996,
0.0153828738,
0.0461121276,
-0.0119597344,
0.0129789663,
-0.0109120533,
-0.0024077366,
-0.0413743481,
-0.0329595357,
-0.0153156314,
-0.0039966679,
0.0283128172,
-0.0050862236,
-0.0200487524,
-0.0077121425,
-0.0352652259,
-0.0508624204,
0.0049900026,
-0.0407238938,
-0.0343801789,
0.0082047014,
0.0381099954,
0.0190779101,
-0.0277244486,
-0.0504504293,
-0.021809876,
-0.0197370686,
0.0138445655,
-0.0101351552,
0.0190113094,
-0.0350553058,
0.025035711,
-0.0008460191,
0.0173694789,
-0.02358656,
0.0132091492,
0.0320953913,
0.0619699284,
-0.0130377328,
-0.041797068,
0.0471635982,
0.0508434549,
-0.0587839037,
-0.0025420201,
0.0345435292,
0.0863251686,
0.025871681,
0.0248117447,
0.0444662943,
-0.069918476,
0.0474202298,
0.0143665969,
0.0078403912,
-0.021972008,
-0.0696536303,
0.0321541056,
0.0271153562,
-0.0108667901,
0.0155277271,
0.0174827557,
-0.0461822189,
0.0203334596,
-0.0331307873,
-0.0072215549,
-0.0086743906,
-0.0623506382,
0.0381457172,
0.0234887786,
-0.0403960235,
-0.0271196477,
-0.0639132932,
-0.0484598838,
-0.0140630193,
0.0557148084,
0.0090659922,
-0.0371725783,
0.0312270224,
0.0564084724,
-0.0401718467,
-0.0291082822,
-0.0327753425,
-0.0246234778,
-0.0520113073,
0.0027328699,
-0.0185120143,
-5.947448933e-33,
-0.0388967209,
-0.0668766648,
0.045544304,
0.026479017,
-0.0401183106,
-0.0264512096,
-0.0544548035,
0.0114283906,
-0.0131792445,
0.02358092,
-0.0136134755,
0.0470202975,
0.0064571053,
-0.0423738174,
-0.0024011675,
-0.0087214783,
-0.0259451345,
-0.0231541619,
-0.0233465396,
0.0030785811,
-0.0184998829,
-0.0192263238,
0.0308283716,
-0.0758341849,
0.02795141,
-0.003950946,
-0.0254154559,
0.0234925281,
-0.0214144681,
-0.0084570413,
0.0139031857,
0.0059853573,
0.0375427827,
-0.0084458757,
0.0380433351,
0.0277076866,
-0.0201843735,
-0.0455741361,
0.0408011936,
-0.0105298106,
-0.0769414455,
-0.0262109023,
-0.0039911941,
-0.0229595099,
-0.0811353996,
0.0139865447,
0.012005969,
0.0028935298,
0.0553441197,
0.0420635194,
-0.0550775118,
-0.0297381077,
-0.0086147152,
-0.0467353053,
-0.0165566579,
0.003534775,
-0.009069629,
-0.0321094543,
-0.0396519788,
0.0374529622,
-0.0648521706,
-0.0295560136,
0.0519947745,
-0.031717483,
0.0295379106,
0.0499642082,
0.0211896934,
0.031970609,
0.0034400295,
-0.0184399989,
0.044719398,
0.0672391579,
0.0726940259,
0.0447229743,
-0.0556410663,
-0.0205977894,
-0.0071646115,
0.0480215065,
0.0512569472,
0.0113682998,
-0.0198073853,
-0.0034738176,
-0.046203427,
0.018439427,
-0.0209927019,
0.0212976355,
-0.0008095651,
-0.0299464762,
0.0101054227,
-0.0086609134,
-0.0071206749,
0.0021943657,
0.0121293692,
-0.0153878257,
0.0291336291,
0.0052904314,
-0.0156147471,
0.041102767,
0.0185610261,
-0.0301521737,
0.017566476,
-0.0322910808,
0.0029042356,
0.0408772379,
0.0365514718,
0.0065324646,
-0.0021058635,
0.0269269422,
0.0364922322,
-0.0090078404,
-0.0407487378,
0.0482128076,
0.0133183151,
-0.0395550877,
-0.0063161124,
-0.0346106552,
-0.0289587192,
-0.0499562733,
-0.0017629684,
0.002682524,
-0.0452818237,
0.0368760116,
-0.0312781148,
-0.0196240544,
-0.0341234654,
-0.0102567021,
-0.0556737594,
0.024151383,
-0.0251451731,
0.0026893108,
-0.002294322,
-0.0244144369,
2.785e-7,
-0.0469841994,
0.0568795428,
0.0021114133,
0.0677908286,
0.0187627673,
0.0412882306,
-0.043934714,
0.0736137256,
-0.0130052613,
-0.0124507323,
0.0594450273,
0.0483619198,
0.0595018081,
0.0242116433,
-0.0670618936,
-0.0427100062,
-0.023746822,
-0.0646855533,
0.0033375467,
-0.0190670267,
0.0135844741,
0.0140536455,
0.055661492,
-0.0025209305,
-0.0086666755,
-0.0620609447,
0.0130363479,
-0.036632318,
-0.0076863146,
0.0024708731,
-0.0084317522,
-0.0202646051,
-0.0015244305,
0.0598233454,
0.0078885481,
0.0092770718,
-0.0339650996,
0.0506409854,
-0.0132697225,
-0.0357229039,
-0.0189784989,
-0.0119605996,
-0.0059833545,
-0.0486608036,
0.031500183,
-0.0474972539,
-0.0268775355,
0.0555572733,
0.0124045787,
-0.0241822749,
-0.034134984,
-0.0011112443,
-0.0234499369,
0.0154204061,
0.0131065818,
-0.0471402481,
0.0162757691,
-0.0306777973,
0.0320056677,
-0.0258008856,
-0.0409927443,
-0.0896442309,
-0.0142330294,
0.0097382534,
-0.020670535,
-0.043156717,
0.0026466935,
1.979529502e-34,
0.0008940689,
0.0055995299,
0.0160738435,
-0.0208727904,
0.0808019415,
0.0306947455,
-0.0680166185,
0.0263542067,
0.0524753667,
-0.0202428531,
0.0019873413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11655v1 | Field-testing items using artificial intelligence: Natural language processing with transformers | 2023-10-18T01:56:16 | 2023-10-18T01:56:16 | Hotaka Maeda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Five thousand variations of the RoBERTa model, an artificially intelligent
"transformer" that can understand text language, completed an English literacy
exam with 29 multiple-choice questions. Data were used to calculate the
psychometric properties of the items, which showed some degree of agreement to
those obtained from human examinee data. | [
0.0166581161,
0.0039701625,
-0.0657272413,
0.0069371997,
-0.0745733902,
0.0270038415,
0.0373534858,
-0.0042463811,
0.0242311042,
-0.0498777516,
0.03396184,
0.047338374,
-0.0165492967,
0.0094393864,
0.0129391849,
-0.035018716,
0.0038970539,
0.0090462305,
-0.0107198348,
0.0245915111,
-0.0418156236,
0.0134437084,
-0.0446446352,
0.0317143537,
-0.016000472,
-0.006030838,
0.0070958063,
-0.0508256778,
0.0272803176,
-0.0200993828,
0.0003011503,
0.0232364833,
-0.0230171848,
-0.011580158,
0.0000019136,
-0.049034398,
-0.0037141745,
0.0132159106,
-0.0253346581,
-0.0709004998,
0.0578319244,
0.0469775647,
0.0106126275,
0.038209565,
-0.0705301389,
0.0330047421,
0.0067430446,
0.040062394,
0.0178147033,
0.0421887711,
-0.0096535888,
-0.0131161353,
0.0706342012,
0.039536681,
0.0310097393,
0.0147126317,
0.0016587215,
-0.0117414631,
0.0321247652,
0.0200967323,
-0.0377040245,
0.02353343,
0.0239613019,
-0.0064026872,
-0.0301948339,
-0.0006360271,
-0.0398038737,
-0.0176556669,
-0.0040613092,
-0.0106466347,
0.0414283462,
0.0041993111,
-0.0283942223,
0.0127491532,
0.0302557256,
0.0435249321,
0.0015729149,
-0.0010989659,
-0.0291673262,
-0.0426582359,
0.0604343563,
-0.0383744538,
-0.004609324,
-0.0100715747,
0.0184391588,
0.0749262348,
0.0222727265,
-0.0621314608,
0.0118999993,
0.0332429707,
-0.0062585422,
-0.0205835905,
0.0244875178,
0.0398308411,
-0.0220038276,
0.0055575822,
-0.0192856565,
-0.0663288832,
0.0054390873,
-0.0177859068,
0.0469602495,
0.0436795615,
-0.0042628674,
0.0100381812,
0.0193716828,
0.0872403607,
0.0488522388,
0.0641954094,
-0.0652456582,
0.0371371917,
-0.0659154356,
-0.0285635237,
-0.0161417685,
0.0448917113,
0.0133376522,
0.0043397751,
-0.0476821549,
-0.0227219462,
-0.0038974467,
-0.0125091197,
-0.0286662187,
0.0169019196,
0.0003003493,
0.0216526799,
-0.045249626,
0.043502938,
-0.0503824763,
0.00806899,
-0.0144848274,
-0.0092851622,
0.0587592162,
-0.0033212139,
0.011956499,
-0.033826109,
0.0417370722,
0.042565342,
0.0082798181,
-0.0491158664,
-0.0363490731,
0.0062662442,
0.0171178505,
-0.0354954079,
0.0310746618,
-0.0306788366,
0.0013570241,
0.0279028229,
-0.0036868651,
-0.0312151685,
-0.0122416643,
0.0551950447,
0.0128587438,
0.0501803309,
0.0128316749,
-0.001333788,
0.0597432926,
-0.0107582249,
0.0143190539,
0.0038370267,
0.0426948592,
-0.0270715915,
0.0005268617,
-0.0543629713,
0.0459175818,
0.0096306298,
-0.0439818092,
-0.0466791429,
0.0234752577,
-0.0265525822,
-0.0842975527,
0.0152520873,
-0.0227870978,
0.0534004159,
-0.006228243,
0.0307807568,
0.052167438,
0.1010614038,
0.0480108969,
0.0706322193,
0.0416938625,
0.029727893,
0.07796406,
0.055440478,
-0.0223077405,
-0.0027034741,
-0.062031772,
0.008886951,
-0.0727300793,
0.031564869,
-0.0021002796,
-0.0838808715,
-0.0027107035,
-0.0027341878,
0.0279531851,
0.0164446775,
0.0270500295,
0.0068219597,
-0.0116820671,
-0.0551575273,
-0.0151446825,
-0.018952392,
-0.0004115748,
-0.0509120524,
0.0007174814,
0.0697414801,
0.0386476703,
-0.0585379601,
-0.0015185173,
-0.0229940414,
-0.0582123585,
0.0502661094,
0.0202122536,
-0.0241857022,
-0.0441618823,
-0.0093696453,
0.0071028606,
0.043328315,
-0.0021698889,
0.0076547051,
-0.0628543347,
0.0089652101,
-0.0110011213,
-0.0022225033,
-0.0292751268,
0.041544091,
-0.089248471,
-0.0592780337,
-0.0229523219,
0.0154386945,
0.0392054468,
0.0310145561,
-0.0114728399,
0.0037710504,
0.0046698842,
0.0098016839,
-0.038077876,
0.0088537699,
-0.0051411493,
0.0317976996,
0.0046998998,
-0.0781966224,
-0.0074724299,
0.0828003958,
0.0410389863,
-0.0169681832,
0.0065992698,
-0.0865001231,
0.0045144442,
-0.0133737102,
0.0624316633,
-0.0228196997,
-0.0206771586,
-0.0379302502,
0.0328217819,
0.0127994362,
0.0338791497,
-0.0248026866,
-0.0229227971,
0.0093852933,
-0.0217225645,
-0.0600661486,
-0.0361161567,
-0.0240407679,
0.0513960533,
0.0566541366,
0.0155326547,
-0.0604509749,
-0.0188520178,
-0.0550586246,
-0.0209679957,
0.0278584566,
0.0188753288,
0.0036330516,
-0.043724671,
-0.0283262804,
0.0286052506,
-0.0110371793,
-0.0021229633,
0.0440820046,
0.0100042811,
0.0132606318,
-0.014711366,
0.0182308573,
-0.0218156073,
-0.0372460932,
-0.0700300187,
0.0230436828,
0.0862475038,
0.0428575911,
-0.0578558519,
0.0018476843,
0.0157364327,
0.0035142067,
0.0338371471,
-0.0600437075,
0.0349536762,
0.0169525668,
0.0435688049,
0.0888990313,
0.031879507,
-0.0183197428,
0.0037408033,
0.0173568819,
0.0036699814,
0.0029508129,
0.0096495356,
0.0336790979,
-0.0438609533,
-0.0532100163,
0.0203218553,
0.0390800163,
0.0242198333,
-0.008463609,
0.0007910831,
0.0536568239,
-0.0643984005,
-0.0386999622,
-0.029712107,
-0.0353821144,
-0.0254295915,
0.0556088537,
-0.0053679566,
0.014092763,
0.0572746806,
-0.0015076313,
0.0169892721,
-0.1193827465,
0.0080381921,
0.0136443526,
0.0253929254,
0.0465936549,
0.0069886125,
-0.0086042341,
-0.0222830623,
-0.0612009875,
-0.0156815704,
-0.0109296413,
-0.0280536935,
0.0238101352,
-0.0421398431,
-0.0169392638,
0.0178608168,
-0.0244152453,
-0.0634247437,
-0.0000554903,
0.015397517,
-0.0246418267,
0.0614765324,
-0.0225295499,
-0.0594221428,
-0.0250317827,
0.041373264,
0.053661488,
-0.0072668367,
-0.0273095705,
0.0040455479,
-0.0011870723,
0.0387558229,
-0.0044957381,
0.030707825,
-0.0107906424,
0.0163957998,
0.0204000827,
-0.03165913,
0.0041970192,
-0.0186774563,
0.030581506,
-0.0095878653,
-0.0511362292,
-0.0037428665,
0.0349885635,
-0.0139392,
-0.0385554023,
-0.0133493459,
0.0759106278,
0.0378293693,
-0.0318551064,
0.0002632324,
-0.0201536752,
-0.1086248755,
0.001175674,
0.0741716325,
-0.031051686,
0.0300606303,
-0.0048076962,
0.028187966,
-0.048621282,
-0.042221874,
0.0266199112,
-0.0769710243,
0.0209392998,
-0.0359615944,
-0.0186643358,
-0.0280835293,
0.0145769669,
-0.005729449,
0.0095994007,
0.028925484,
-0.010163771,
-0.0088617709,
0.0085229035,
-0.002305781,
-0.0446954519,
-0.0177384149,
0.0481823459,
-0.0023659433,
0.0284058712,
0.0625023395,
0.0251849629,
-0.0712210089,
-0.0471733361,
-0.0558500774,
-0.0004233472,
0.0045320406,
0.0118718026,
0.0607198179,
0.0071390043,
0.0160782803,
-0.0656768531,
-0.0001135444,
-0.0009030382,
0.0040182248,
0.0442518033,
0.0385958403,
-0.0002864926,
-0.0315528847,
-0.0213371292,
0.0075592017,
0.0041170237,
0.0209389776,
0.0018401851,
-0.0709723458,
-0.0030494358,
-0.0456270985,
0.0054928064,
-0.0438901931,
-0.0873842835,
0.0474586748,
0.0054886215,
-0.0252046678,
-0.0881593153,
-0.0818912908,
0.0530781038,
0.0550199449,
0.0548042059,
-0.0363571085,
0.0812191814,
0.0153728118,
-0.0401556455,
0.0031641626,
0.0275605265,
-0.0087894164,
-0.0526181646,
-0.0223726798,
0.0049828985,
-0.0323747359,
-0.0231949948,
-0.0314088985,
0.0097178183,
-0.0056111384,
0.1091550291,
0.0569908731,
0.0282269809,
-0.046257671,
-0.0054763476,
-0.0326648541,
0.0201187357,
-0.0257751718,
-0.0426498726,
0.0127306217,
-0.0207647737,
-0.0232543293,
-0.0137214856,
-0.0338104479,
0.0202774312,
0.0462783352,
-0.0181181654,
0.002978916,
-0.0297480244,
-0.0271795578,
0.0247817859,
0.0797119811,
0.0029926333,
0.0020374667,
0.0320664234,
-0.0296079274,
-0.031792812,
-0.0371505655,
-0.0182197951,
0.0126779182,
-0.0550328717,
0.0231005158,
0.0075863865,
-0.0070291921,
-0.0168673135,
-0.0521129295,
-0.0110289697,
-0.0080256872,
0.0487134196,
0.0278499592,
0.0726744309,
-0.0322306976,
-0.0015579516,
-0.002648999,
-0.0634997562,
0.0134972483,
0.0818538293,
0.0424707569,
0.1007650495,
-0.0202791896,
0.0038542445,
-0.0150091341,
0.0255118068,
-0.0144701991,
0.0074402718,
-0.0142127676,
0.0195486825,
-0.0431677662,
0.0006229617,
-0.0368822142,
-0.0296273977,
0.0165973678,
-0.0034422779,
-0.0382458754,
0.0223694965,
0.0295593571,
0.0476342589,
0.0213989615,
0.0358202308,
-0.058195658,
0.0060863965,
-0.0252128206,
-0.0356971547,
0.0162292589,
-0.0138833672,
-0.0649733767,
-0.0010163228,
-0.0347897634,
0.0145468023,
-0.0048904931,
0.0003498242,
-0.0358453207,
-0.0597060323,
0.0240533333,
0.0311426725,
0.0500391759,
-0.0283813737,
-0.0336322747,
0.0239375979,
-0.0081116548,
-0.0353166759,
-0.0351465531,
0.005471373,
-0.0359641761,
-0.0085466607,
0.0054218094,
-5.607653924e-33,
-0.0324097537,
-0.072295621,
0.0832359344,
0.0095422687,
0.0071176416,
-0.0240844768,
0.0027017654,
0.0314431824,
-0.0359434038,
0.001741896,
-0.0351053998,
0.0127745168,
0.0012052294,
0.0165989827,
0.0290200748,
0.0000114049,
0.0007743619,
-0.0312092658,
-0.0250778757,
-0.0439490564,
-0.0421917029,
-0.0101639843,
0.0752083212,
-0.0294145066,
0.0340245031,
-0.0481370911,
0.0229693893,
-0.0418209955,
-0.0023816472,
0.0265489053,
-0.0113296537,
0.056703072,
0.0545671694,
-0.0419891328,
0.0273929909,
0.0532959513,
-0.0574619025,
-0.0606102608,
0.0275498033,
0.0356250852,
-0.0281023569,
-0.0375075974,
0.048639372,
-0.0018652165,
-0.015199976,
-0.0101598036,
0.0635395572,
-0.0335769579,
0.0538012125,
0.0154183879,
-0.076280579,
-0.0211169962,
-0.0165321734,
-0.0042484864,
-0.0193583965,
0.0744320154,
-0.0210054312,
-0.0189776104,
-0.0490089282,
0.0358606279,
0.0273431372,
0.0083451672,
0.0304807276,
-0.0221812893,
-0.0132846357,
0.0094542457,
0.0278395265,
0.0005134411,
-0.0071654534,
0.0033662468,
0.063493669,
0.003998193,
0.0925647989,
0.0603799745,
0.0205123052,
-0.0104386145,
0.0136421239,
0.0420454033,
0.0518036038,
0.0333614014,
0.0098926257,
-0.044233989,
-0.0678812638,
-0.0137157971,
-0.0056859581,
0.0001214333,
-0.0175631735,
-0.0224277899,
0.0414115787,
-0.0479672328,
-0.0053763953,
0.0072742151,
0.0001090729,
-0.0344109163,
0.0324393585,
-0.0168989915,
-0.0135775134,
0.0374171436,
-0.0174467731,
0.008491395,
-0.005713508,
-0.0141463252,
0.0205304567,
0.0492836721,
0.0519890636,
0.0041234079,
-0.0206738189,
0.0012343549,
-0.0420767181,
-0.0185055453,
0.0028505728,
0.0257055201,
0.0521167144,
0.022533128,
0.0002814377,
0.0479406863,
0.0019485574,
0.0058172224,
-0.0058077369,
-0.0310914461,
-0.0590553284,
-0.0059048058,
-0.0025312079,
-0.0116059305,
-0.0169844124,
-0.0065271202,
-0.0423173942,
0.059852317,
0.0117331073,
-0.0569973364,
0.0239035524,
0.0049402872,
2.653e-7,
0.0183265302,
0.0755892694,
0.0091260429,
-0.0016352661,
-0.0125976,
0.008317872,
0.0012113467,
-0.0092657385,
0.0919981077,
0.0390823744,
0.0315941423,
-0.0027546696,
0.0012103488,
0.0406276174,
-0.0471814983,
-0.0262893289,
0.0255223233,
0.0196540747,
-0.0488335788,
0.0525528304,
0.0823181346,
0.0263581034,
0.0097345915,
-0.0311088581,
-0.0461592004,
-0.0361856781,
-0.0435868613,
0.0023411054,
-0.0172028095,
0.0044320035,
0.0438597798,
0.0403088816,
0.0307051092,
0.100508526,
-0.0094507877,
-0.0208016355,
0.0167059358,
0.0005983446,
-0.0171541926,
0.0155335292,
0.0112772761,
0.0118224658,
-0.0120850066,
0.003167032,
0.043106582,
-0.0440020375,
-0.040303085,
0.0217018835,
-0.0738884136,
-0.0223390553,
-0.0095833261,
-0.0133026,
-0.0033053586,
0.0235211886,
0.0255130641,
-0.0212877057,
0.0560536683,
0.0161913726,
0.0313657746,
0.0052183117,
-0.002652582,
-0.0586327016,
-0.02224412,
-0.0323877856,
-0.0060547059,
-0.0714841112,
-0.0062884032,
1.901080063e-34,
0.0024811055,
0.0257577281,
0.0281605795,
-0.02624394,
0.024165025,
0.0121742692,
0.000938618,
0.0101690441,
-0.0012674386,
-0.0858635604,
-0.0221584011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11648v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11648v2 | Zero-shot Faithfulness Evaluation for Text Summarization with Foundation Language Model | 2023-10-18T01:20:16 | 2023-12-14T06:41:54 | Qi Jia, Siyu Ren, Yizhu Liu, Kenny Q. Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite tremendous improvements in natural language generation, summarization
models still suffer from the unfaithfulness issue. Previous work evaluates
faithfulness either using models trained on the other tasks or in-domain
synthetic data, or prompting a large model such as ChatGPT. This paper proposes
to do zero-shot faithfulness evaluation simply with a moderately-sized
foundation language model. We introduce a new metric FFLM, which is a
combination of probability changes based on the intuition that prefixing a
piece of text that is consistent with the output will increase the probability
of predicting the output. Experiments show that FFLM performs competitively
with or even outperforms ChatGPT on both inconsistency detection and
faithfulness rating with 24x fewer parameters. FFLM also achieves improvements
over other strong baselines. | [
0.0450390577,
0.0541027114,
0.0293086059,
0.006365112,
-0.0633002371,
0.0066028289,
-0.0086179627,
-0.0005012465,
-0.0255979281,
-0.0706698298,
0.018752126,
-0.0249600075,
0.0587888844,
0.0105862422,
0.0121817077,
-0.0226740148,
0.0501157939,
0.0173641387,
-0.0367632657,
0.0281503014,
0.0378993601,
0.007057271,
0.0160563625,
0.0502078533,
-0.0046419865,
-0.002148164,
-0.0034241749,
0.0199244432,
0.0572528094,
-0.0013652405,
-0.0203209929,
0.0381304063,
-0.0053559681,
0.0668229759,
0.0000017312,
-0.0677760392,
-0.0582408085,
0.0002385228,
0.0125293294,
0.0027264741,
0.0089243101,
-0.0166016426,
0.0046032788,
0.0221706275,
0.0006791507,
0.036791537,
0.0394072272,
0.0539108664,
0.0653524622,
0.0650302693,
0.0044930843,
-0.0016208724,
0.0160306916,
-0.0008028495,
0.0015266234,
-0.0033341884,
-0.0069642179,
0.0460997745,
-0.0094018076,
0.0012830356,
-0.0094026336,
0.0225004256,
0.0118580135,
-0.0026667921,
-0.0191824175,
0.0193614792,
-0.0854101479,
0.005874068,
0.0492158197,
0.0385129489,
-0.0084248222,
-0.0592683442,
0.0237421412,
0.0052496609,
-0.0340534672,
-0.0117311133,
-0.0709398836,
0.0709626228,
-0.0273284782,
0.0226743184,
-0.0042555113,
0.0169769842,
0.0025865256,
0.0076164547,
-0.0046593538,
0.0304444265,
0.0273896512,
-0.006035388,
-0.0721909702,
0.0236924104,
-0.0468066745,
-0.0818603709,
-0.0189564377,
0.0061433478,
-0.0338625647,
-0.0104436465,
-0.1101731583,
-0.0240842681,
0.0227229223,
-0.0459152311,
-0.0009507694,
0.0273599401,
-0.0029403954,
0.0168789905,
-0.0396931618,
0.0678028837,
0.0471175611,
-0.0011750158,
-0.0470559373,
-0.0161483288,
-0.0859495029,
0.013640373,
-0.021067448,
0.0382905714,
-0.0182910953,
-0.057874836,
-0.049695082,
0.0293051619,
-0.0094383135,
0.0330074765,
-0.0089805033,
-0.0202025753,
-0.015962787,
0.0073388647,
0.0184542835,
0.0222077128,
-0.0044183866,
-0.0289230775,
0.0300669614,
-0.0486454107,
-0.0180434063,
0.0196921304,
0.0072325682,
0.0267436653,
-0.0205392949,
0.0474171825,
-0.0140939467,
-0.040051654,
-0.0391930863,
-0.0555087812,
-0.0287684873,
-0.0624541938,
-0.0436915047,
-0.0714741945,
-0.0134023288,
-0.0094864899,
-0.0160132144,
-0.0195764955,
-0.0055813571,
0.0345447324,
-0.0296871085,
0.0331594497,
-0.0250448883,
0.0076674181,
-0.0025124592,
-0.0124341976,
0.0096166749,
0.039231576,
0.0193749554,
0.0235272665,
0.0686777681,
0.0554139465,
-0.0078438567,
0.0052716727,
-0.0070206556,
-0.0042956411,
0.0016711977,
-0.014904906,
-0.0149687091,
-0.010085728,
0.0319837928,
0.0485920087,
-0.0475116074,
0.0000794096,
0.0682099983,
0.0078163287,
0.0389427133,
0.0004051833,
0.0719878152,
0.0584103018,
0.0018703915,
0.0875695944,
-0.0503364503,
0.0241357572,
-0.0479073822,
0.074383758,
0.0684314966,
0.0313430578,
-0.0174668394,
-0.0342304967,
-0.029465545,
-0.0147343874,
-0.0295792371,
-0.0336623527,
0.0073823389,
0.0102360696,
-0.0526307523,
0.0199968424,
0.0069433781,
-0.0356809907,
-0.0060191527,
-0.0279152989,
0.0340472199,
0.0545452423,
0.0704368725,
0.0090116346,
-0.0313101001,
-0.0100278426,
0.0212900583,
0.0502381176,
0.0282193813,
-0.0148719819,
0.0136667555,
-0.0358034149,
-0.0326807052,
0.0119556999,
0.026907783,
0.0139770368,
-0.0067911828,
-0.0058384794,
0.0503727756,
-0.0163998306,
-0.0348364078,
0.0426500216,
-0.0208434612,
-0.0086868899,
0.0001928191,
-0.0354463607,
0.0075050341,
0.0065306099,
-0.0586828962,
0.0324651115,
-0.0176070016,
-0.0040542413,
-0.009699828,
0.0160610527,
-0.0201795306,
-0.0300803874,
0.0367214158,
-0.0489626564,
0.0090750437,
0.0360428393,
-0.0413756892,
-0.055402007,
0.0164436866,
-0.0291964076,
-0.008296648,
-0.0650383309,
0.0438357852,
0.0128445849,
-0.0018387849,
-0.0278053507,
0.0283000246,
0.014740061,
-0.0020068246,
0.036956735,
-0.0192249119,
0.045398917,
-0.0550757535,
-0.0072663613,
-0.004929929,
-0.0083022602,
0.0141857481,
0.0712669566,
0.0405573733,
-0.0054045329,
-0.0230425671,
-0.100960061,
0.0264989119,
-0.0357678756,
-0.0062990179,
0.0681361035,
0.0194931608,
0.0084945187,
0.0048701921,
-0.018999137,
-0.0195230432,
0.0587187372,
-0.000352604,
0.0376523137,
-0.0081740813,
0.005465168,
-0.0530975275,
0.0034790458,
0.0103050638,
0.0527584888,
0.0242731869,
-0.0185454022,
-0.0611289926,
0.0037505317,
-0.0659985319,
-0.0292761046,
0.0274432078,
0.0184108317,
-0.0084887724,
0.019999912,
-0.0128908306,
0.0133302556,
0.0571295433,
-0.037644051,
0.0067375335,
0.011247037,
-0.0290528797,
-0.0410015918,
-0.0271846186,
0.0036274949,
0.0506169349,
-0.0152572161,
0.0657289326,
0.0332651176,
0.0372509956,
0.0061124638,
-0.0349381641,
0.0410957932,
-0.0188817941,
0.0004049785,
-0.0220013335,
-0.0246950816,
-0.0067762295,
0.0299389977,
-0.0260910895,
-0.0349550284,
0.0529845804,
-0.0800210312,
0.0452272408,
-0.0503295362,
-0.0000371416,
-0.0330310129,
0.0042194002,
0.0111641847,
0.0423730873,
0.0382640585,
0.0180426389,
-0.0431560688,
-0.0166712217,
0.0717777088,
0.0052375891,
0.0752339736,
-0.0532609299,
0.033738263,
-0.0140437074,
0.0193027016,
-0.0505133942,
-0.0550801791,
-0.0111060096,
0.0123040108,
-0.0317424387,
-0.0015128226,
-0.042718526,
0.0379603952,
0.0086431578,
0.0538178794,
-0.0506776236,
-0.0300683193,
-0.0188184679,
0.0688677207,
0.0622996911,
-0.0016401639,
0.0381109007,
-0.0235167462,
0.0046835691,
0.0221193656,
0.0129425656,
0.0500782877,
-0.0073540085,
-0.0165302474,
-0.0482441112,
-0.060116671,
-0.0075026546,
0.0079616783,
0.0520912893,
-0.0125187431,
-0.0336981677,
0.1276231408,
0.0240632594,
0.0370824039,
0.0042732274,
0.0160117056,
0.0683199987,
0.0049898825,
0.0115557006,
-0.0667390078,
-0.0399794579,
0.0142146461,
0.0402033515,
0.0123724574,
-0.0325989909,
-0.0241608154,
-0.0902497619,
0.0271672867,
0.0310892519,
-0.0472227558,
-0.0378545895,
-0.0076162764,
0.0098395385,
-0.0074468264,
0.0239978861,
0.0326966643,
-0.0134836975,
0.0382966772,
-0.0005024564,
-0.0598574281,
-0.0338144414,
-0.0223246906,
-0.043519292,
0.0262184311,
0.0842476413,
0.000908942,
0.0185095575,
0.0288666524,
0.0297697,
-0.0078807175,
-0.0292273723,
-0.008508971,
0.0634592324,
-0.0076462422,
0.0235746335,
-0.0057789111,
0.0082927532,
0.0371849388,
-0.0106839715,
0.0195442848,
-0.0222832505,
0.0009473797,
-0.0173198171,
-0.028056873,
0.044931896,
-0.0288077947,
0.0727064312,
0.0578851178,
0.0032970961,
-0.0381316133,
-0.0338445865,
-0.0146077489,
-0.0552719794,
-0.0174814519,
-0.0079982691,
-0.0188478492,
0.0136764329,
-0.1224238202,
-0.0394393504,
-0.002577578,
0.0086100968,
-0.0205101725,
-0.0170910433,
-0.0309241693,
-0.0160297528,
-0.0259747915,
-0.0310081616,
-0.0423825644,
0.0050780238,
-0.0329365134,
0.0126190586,
0.036936488,
-0.0275027473,
-0.0121093718,
0.0283458419,
-0.0873585343,
-0.0326305442,
-0.0347951353,
0.0369906425,
0.0332448818,
0.073201485,
-0.0035243018,
0.0282149334,
0.0093722381,
0.0436080024,
0.0049373969,
0.0625457913,
0.0053420113,
-0.0045844479,
-0.0101251295,
0.0153561654,
-0.0452294461,
0.0338698141,
-0.007300362,
0.0609239377,
0.050661847,
-0.0314291418,
0.0362886116,
0.0577097461,
0.0229240172,
-0.0243404899,
0.0310634207,
-0.0018207064,
-0.0346492678,
-0.0048153349,
-0.0168523621,
-0.0412258469,
0.0360786617,
-0.0141576771,
0.0398472808,
-0.0108744688,
0.0176880639,
-0.0659338683,
0.048721619,
-0.0285711121,
-0.0669659227,
-0.0270280484,
-0.0051054838,
-0.0449048281,
-0.0200610813,
-0.0431673676,
-0.0126466164,
-0.0060843434,
0.0175916404,
-0.0234685484,
0.0204326585,
0.0242051706,
0.0094072297,
-0.0154667329,
0.0389635861,
-0.0849615186,
0.0150695881,
-0.0834148899,
0.0368010513,
0.0547502227,
-0.0296993069,
0.0870974138,
-0.0226768181,
0.0147480052,
-0.0419407226,
0.042378787,
0.0514835604,
-0.0025820939,
-0.0513229296,
0.0121253831,
-0.0130615514,
0.0252024941,
0.0761707276,
0.0004602244,
0.0012089359,
-0.0053180442,
-0.0422562398,
-0.0432820022,
-0.0384647734,
-0.0123352623,
0.0304475781,
0.0129949553,
-0.0480290949,
-0.0697363764,
-0.0261995476,
0.0659526661,
0.0404112898,
0.031259086,
0.0000057488,
0.0247202404,
0.0307685137,
0.002141603,
0.0607563779,
-0.0394624397,
-0.0399642959,
0.0206576921,
0.0010043263,
-0.004917894,
-5.226222905e-33,
-0.0499128923,
-0.0170102697,
-0.016595114,
-0.0133132553,
-0.0409905575,
0.0141662462,
-0.0615165383,
-0.0163600221,
0.0237572473,
-0.007050565,
0.0169213135,
-0.019221412,
0.0077166017,
0.023044968,
-0.0128399357,
-0.0054904511,
0.0664210618,
0.017047191,
-0.0638250783,
0.0081459479,
0.0562097467,
0.0004619421,
0.0178835858,
-0.0272160955,
0.0263350587,
-0.0376458876,
-0.0207260363,
-0.0220116023,
0.0552827232,
0.045038186,
0.0086301742,
0.026180217,
0.0265015904,
-0.0371527188,
-0.085951075,
-0.0392058343,
-0.0643874928,
-0.0490429886,
0.0353616998,
-0.0372981392,
-0.0146495011,
0.0226809569,
0.0364773832,
-0.037791077,
-0.0141587351,
-0.0485901162,
0.0273872465,
-0.048422996,
-0.0383984372,
-0.051074326,
-0.0599144436,
0.0392027684,
-0.0045424947,
-0.0354299657,
-0.0032915485,
0.0692737699,
-0.0128878905,
0.0098111955,
0.0041435575,
0.0232157614,
0.0290701501,
0.051481355,
0.0515522175,
0.0116542662,
-0.0085625947,
0.1021985188,
-0.0035702991,
-0.0277078152,
-0.0138080418,
0.0183043126,
0.003635782,
0.0021479218,
0.0208338685,
0.0873703063,
0.0474252403,
0.0350656472,
-0.0335944332,
0.0915509537,
-0.0237403214,
-0.0101400465,
0.0245394036,
-0.0167130847,
-0.0066780932,
-0.0083864732,
-0.0308209565,
-0.0013917979,
-0.0135485111,
-0.0327868126,
0.0475453027,
0.0116050122,
-0.040415775,
-0.0088780168,
0.0621395148,
-0.0365001857,
0.0059190863,
0.0234227739,
-0.0756814033,
-0.0066146161,
-0.0061805183,
-0.0058095129,
-0.016215777,
-0.0002153041,
0.027219696,
0.0302746687,
-0.0115826223,
-0.007184749,
0.0707826093,
-0.0022095363,
-0.0382572152,
0.0234325696,
0.0049097519,
0.0018757929,
-0.044426553,
0.0060050907,
0.0025751742,
-0.0241530836,
-0.0092224432,
0.044376459,
-0.0080723939,
-0.0523290485,
0.0074600591,
0.0343388692,
-0.0130489971,
0.0266884118,
-0.0368873067,
0.0196367763,
-0.0200511254,
0.0081901317,
-0.007873632,
-0.051346913,
-0.0072323405,
0.0002931172,
2.323e-7,
0.0155135207,
0.0312851109,
0.0728623718,
-0.0494646206,
-0.013082617,
0.0258603767,
-0.0321529321,
0.0485320352,
-0.0031598578,
0.0161853228,
0.0127748251,
0.0043432782,
0.0495305173,
0.0055991779,
-0.0655644983,
0.0123294275,
-0.1181266531,
-0.0356414318,
-0.0370555408,
-0.0271515511,
0.0575880669,
0.0882430375,
-0.0021083322,
0.0031444058,
0.0286777969,
-0.0243967623,
0.0330581069,
0.0142315617,
-0.0373411328,
-0.0108044799,
0.0208242182,
-0.0149151385,
-0.0043648095,
-0.019415969,
-0.0116351312,
-0.0355907567,
0.0473077521,
0.0335310623,
0.0171576571,
0.0269866046,
-0.0181480926,
-0.0318411849,
0.0352672637,
-0.0203139763,
0.057467442,
-0.0414027832,
0.0113046449,
-0.0420276783,
-0.0537902564,
0.0103613837,
-0.0072201435,
0.0069635976,
-0.062039353,
0.0612634234,
0.0173595473,
0.0579071231,
-0.0269157048,
-0.0215555876,
-0.0616164654,
-0.0292491857,
-0.0076657934,
-0.0344533734,
-0.0139859058,
-0.002922466,
0.0435498208,
-0.056834273,
-0.003191889,
2.451008118e-34,
0.0847956538,
0.0063221208,
-0.0159303192,
-0.037981499,
0.0158649553,
-0.0196118187,
0.0112864487,
0.0169562288,
-0.0016285998,
-0.0379184969,
-0.0058555948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11638v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11638v3 | Systematic Assessment of Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models | 2023-10-18T00:20:50 | 2023-10-30T12:05:31 | Linhao Luo, Thuy-Trang Vu, Dinh Phung, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous studies have relied on existing question-answering benchmarks to
evaluate the knowledge stored in large language models (LLMs). However, this
approach has limitations regarding factual knowledge coverage, as it mostly
focuses on generic domains which may overlap with the pretraining data. This
paper proposes a framework to systematically assess the factual knowledge of
LLMs by leveraging knowledge graphs (KGs). Our framework automatically
generates a set of questions and expected answers from the facts stored in a
given KG, and then evaluates the accuracy of LLMs in answering these questions.
We systematically evaluate the state-of-the-art LLMs with KGs in generic and
specific domains. The experiment shows that ChatGPT is consistently the top
performer across all domains. We also find that LLMs performance depends on the
instruction finetuning, domain and question complexity and is prone to
adversarial context. | [
0.0532072857,
-0.0092327492,
0.0028751623,
0.0629401654,
-0.0376035497,
0.0191062801,
-0.0116440039,
-0.02116552,
0.033070799,
-0.0620975979,
-0.0179720391,
-0.0260785371,
-0.029345287,
0.0326679088,
0.0231293458,
0.0009255036,
0.0403811634,
-0.0202731173,
-0.0062044822,
-0.0238840394,
-0.0053549451,
0.0326461457,
-0.0342108719,
0.0102550657,
-0.0174411796,
-0.0405356027,
-0.0010852133,
-0.0173929036,
-0.0064041689,
-0.001432366,
0.0404978171,
0.0084430343,
0.0069241091,
0.0549863726,
0.0000017582,
-0.0506322123,
0.0228313711,
0.0129066585,
-0.0573461689,
0.0365823992,
-0.0047537885,
0.0141668795,
0.0093397414,
0.0333075486,
-0.0580157116,
-0.0228427891,
0.0061192596,
0.0258079618,
0.0821167454,
0.0713663176,
0.0231456924,
-0.0297589358,
0.0080934502,
-0.012706208,
0.0066172462,
-0.074867174,
0.0400885157,
0.0708575025,
-0.0002239003,
0.0039503183,
-0.0148386536,
0.0459522344,
0.0467289388,
-0.0009767138,
-0.0015747779,
0.0409858115,
-0.0454020873,
0.0333334133,
0.0074642557,
0.0878459662,
0.0167871006,
-0.022509262,
-0.0216754843,
0.0070390399,
0.0062688752,
-0.0007244765,
-0.0383852944,
0.004028555,
-0.0231877174,
-0.0124463374,
-0.0302680749,
-0.0216214675,
0.0247867014,
0.0135388318,
-0.0255408008,
0.0782708004,
0.0180710815,
-0.0279783141,
0.0184562244,
0.0031943799,
-0.0428728908,
-0.062048696,
-0.0154883163,
0.0502329618,
-0.0150016081,
0.0406527594,
-0.035104312,
0.0239638202,
0.037767604,
-0.0613309331,
-0.0041671442,
0.0245578438,
-0.008610744,
0.0829299912,
-0.0268431846,
0.058713492,
0.0021872118,
0.0000040501,
-0.0610832758,
-0.0393042192,
-0.0753876716,
-0.0195454024,
-0.0398668796,
0.0260430612,
-0.0132663306,
-0.0166490879,
-0.0193699095,
0.0355350114,
0.0008855184,
0.0262528136,
0.027350517,
0.025791537,
-0.0088975029,
-0.01826418,
-0.0652138814,
0.048551593,
-0.0565240681,
0.0101486677,
0.003662135,
-0.0639436543,
-0.018971527,
0.0015328691,
-0.0213926993,
-0.0309697371,
0.0177594926,
0.0615426265,
-0.0160946567,
0.0011887997,
-0.0275855958,
-0.0343445353,
-0.0123570217,
-0.0812956169,
0.0020984288,
-0.0686204135,
0.0344519913,
0.021300301,
-0.0185183696,
-0.006868151,
0.0112573039,
0.0137571227,
-0.0137464125,
0.0521913357,
0.0058111902,
0.0121121937,
0.0264619961,
0.0089718848,
-0.0432763174,
0.0642733872,
-0.0000443534,
0.0177223366,
0.0478092954,
0.009507264,
-0.0144857224,
0.0304075554,
0.0646841079,
0.0084213261,
0.0473052897,
0.0588634647,
0.0054106079,
0.0249418467,
0.0126017146,
0.0369399004,
-0.0208958481,
-0.0434125848,
0.0392276272,
0.0147093972,
-0.0027044772,
0.0419765264,
0.0681413412,
0.0159866922,
0.0550369993,
0.0211079102,
-0.0422089249,
0.0202154871,
-0.0449575782,
0.0216301214,
0.0004978501,
0.024369128,
-0.0412458405,
-0.0262998696,
-0.0080304397,
0.0117081963,
-0.0052324017,
0.0382843874,
0.0551785082,
0.0094798412,
-0.0222824346,
0.0351783484,
0.0224968735,
0.01419596,
0.0104692439,
-0.0491976626,
0.0121196592,
0.0447216295,
0.0600006804,
-0.0151480865,
-0.0750838667,
0.022139322,
0.0173447691,
0.0013568193,
0.0716415346,
-0.0289611518,
0.0006564294,
-0.0115014575,
-0.0074379705,
-0.054816775,
0.0092451172,
0.0422670059,
0.0599898659,
0.0259637665,
0.0162927564,
-0.0891834944,
0.0109536834,
0.010339248,
-0.0193055402,
-0.0194180012,
-0.000875678,
-0.0154116442,
0.0202558413,
-0.0031134351,
-0.0314844251,
0.0301632006,
0.0173615031,
0.0047391802,
-0.0367526487,
-0.0215498172,
-0.021391321,
-0.0699752495,
0.0589217208,
-0.0271607656,
-0.0584087968,
0.0202148836,
-0.0647283718,
-0.0254851524,
0.0038426535,
-0.0301845949,
0.0458801463,
-0.0661119297,
-0.0226382893,
0.0233364329,
-0.0200183801,
-0.0211712047,
0.0787448511,
0.0181184895,
0.0019054271,
0.00182363,
0.0082803667,
0.0289015099,
-0.0153595041,
-0.0146010015,
-0.004913589,
-0.0189998392,
0.0393780656,
0.0269883256,
0.0088681187,
-0.0749743134,
-0.0079185069,
-0.1105868742,
0.0382130072,
-0.0066413539,
0.0265676286,
0.037915498,
-0.0179254785,
-0.0075400798,
-0.0255706217,
-0.0648602843,
-0.0164719168,
0.0149466796,
0.021001095,
0.0313687921,
0.0164866932,
0.0132651525,
-0.0106658135,
0.0021174166,
-0.0043163956,
0.0296373349,
0.008124047,
0.0267623272,
-0.015646778,
0.0551800318,
-0.0730815232,
0.0446454622,
-0.0150262667,
-0.0458747186,
0.0099715358,
0.0083206771,
0.0006363044,
0.0712330788,
-0.0010628487,
0.0125186145,
0.0352347977,
-0.0121618975,
-0.0485480092,
0.0411252864,
-0.0299991909,
-0.0627464727,
-0.0375729017,
-0.0013659378,
0.0091958353,
0.0419456251,
0.0280286781,
-0.0442652553,
-0.0506370924,
0.0020891463,
-0.02530214,
-0.0039809411,
-0.0770653561,
0.0343291983,
0.0148568321,
0.0163686071,
-0.0444329493,
-0.0164732244,
0.0965845734,
-0.0229790229,
-0.0031337363,
-0.0567577034,
-0.0132422941,
-0.0210692175,
0.054687541,
0.0159871653,
0.014378964,
-0.0009644175,
0.0081301434,
-0.0620261617,
-0.0054719863,
0.0508041009,
-0.0414181948,
0.0186667312,
-0.0449793488,
0.0301318076,
0.0292456355,
-0.0206677821,
-0.0612816103,
-0.0410203636,
-0.0157654881,
0.0198163986,
-0.0022064894,
-0.010994128,
-0.020980332,
-0.0049004159,
0.0246370826,
-0.0081471717,
-0.0178831201,
-0.0055272081,
-0.0026277346,
0.0497064553,
0.0786723644,
0.0214525554,
-0.0000223529,
-0.0119989244,
0.0196498763,
0.078104265,
0.0025001168,
0.0128142228,
-0.0228542723,
-0.0197007563,
-0.0237141643,
-0.0324009359,
0.0044327066,
-0.0015376133,
0.0392817967,
-0.0415899642,
-0.0030500339,
0.1228293329,
0.03347845,
0.0258272234,
-0.0218472462,
0.0086060446,
0.0184034184,
0.0171841253,
0.0462981872,
-0.0995714143,
-0.0239348039,
-0.0341533609,
0.0095015327,
0.0032695364,
-0.0208923593,
-0.0209286567,
-0.1392693818,
-0.0075821518,
-0.0297287256,
-0.0310324058,
-0.0662286207,
-0.0177799221,
0.0073508839,
0.0128840171,
-0.0080862325,
-0.004738159,
-0.0034780011,
0.0073160771,
0.0263562649,
-0.0188670382,
-0.0520244166,
0.0832709596,
-0.0186633188,
0.0567897744,
0.0434764661,
0.028557796,
-0.0012685464,
0.0048164842,
0.0042804675,
-0.0068282261,
-0.000897125,
0.012880167,
0.0393890664,
-0.0207074415,
-0.0115217855,
-0.0145632308,
-0.0018277512,
-0.0033152455,
0.0247988272,
0.0454351529,
0.0780675858,
-0.0118838474,
-0.0381028615,
0.0018578561,
0.0110125756,
-0.0115769403,
0.0967169032,
0.0397029333,
0.0136580616,
-0.0096098166,
-0.0522674732,
-0.0220956765,
-0.0291664135,
-0.0214558002,
0.058162313,
0.0014127488,
0.0217679087,
-0.071653381,
-0.0225525666,
0.0613895729,
0.0166672301,
-0.0364358164,
-0.0223805793,
0.0297552645,
0.0210153833,
-0.041777797,
0.0293109082,
-0.0706742927,
0.0147309992,
-0.0259547625,
-0.0318440124,
0.0398942009,
-0.0201846622,
-0.0378867202,
-0.0018596108,
-0.0776355341,
-0.0592695586,
-0.0196395423,
0.0437605195,
0.0214244742,
0.0344730243,
-0.0646324307,
-0.0054273242,
0.0582982823,
0.0063465559,
-0.0651026294,
-0.0002022508,
0.0203867331,
-0.0191699583,
0.0004485733,
0.0287862495,
-0.0782802179,
-0.0019545734,
0.0053942781,
0.041241169,
-0.0231291205,
-0.0508885756,
0.0275440682,
0.0314714909,
0.0081518749,
0.0218202956,
0.0051722117,
-0.0118312119,
0.0097607421,
-0.0170163941,
-0.0186642688,
-0.0403079316,
-0.0065116845,
0.0278620943,
-0.0212324783,
0.0072399271,
-0.017896438,
-0.0018028603,
0.0412463546,
-0.0084026121,
-0.0513592213,
0.0240064077,
-0.0094857914,
0.053034693,
-0.014343881,
-0.0388740636,
-0.0040506655,
0.0245421045,
0.0315001048,
-0.007484071,
0.0586853027,
0.0398538709,
-0.0214590188,
0.0001298329,
0.0017731756,
-0.0621971488,
-0.0576919951,
-0.0213553477,
0.0632019043,
0.07478486,
0.00566117,
0.00732747,
-0.0619087368,
-0.0309049916,
-0.0133316144,
0.0025582064,
0.0057238908,
-0.0111531764,
0.0595995821,
0.0170329697,
-0.024725249,
0.0144941332,
0.0864272565,
0.0232662242,
0.0761885792,
0.0091057476,
-0.0351721123,
-0.0295985788,
-0.0518621504,
-0.011049239,
-0.0110438056,
-0.0062828786,
0.0489194915,
-0.0632393137,
-0.1008329988,
-0.0388614014,
0.0340615623,
-0.0358307622,
-0.0064550764,
0.065185681,
0.0647253692,
0.0130245434,
-0.0161708221,
-0.0326827988,
0.036741171,
-0.0355926193,
-0.0113692703,
-0.0180140417,
-6.207448447e-33,
-0.0362552032,
-0.0174947511,
0.0373085998,
-0.0074620266,
-0.0321426615,
0.0150599768,
-0.0276131015,
-0.0016477059,
-0.0558538847,
0.0261905044,
0.0013746411,
0.0278232694,
-0.0099894283,
0.0178950522,
-0.0359969735,
-0.0625457838,
0.002986108,
-0.0239633396,
-0.0189591125,
0.0318645127,
0.0073236451,
0.0109883407,
0.0540461242,
-0.0116290208,
0.0124212177,
-0.0053696767,
-0.0025477044,
0.0542185307,
-0.0423863605,
0.0748079419,
-0.0179176833,
0.0518758856,
0.0305081401,
-0.0510959178,
0.0159136597,
-0.0214342922,
-0.0746132061,
-0.0607117973,
0.040953435,
-0.0033798746,
-0.0368466154,
0.0060576568,
0.000205354,
-0.0020757627,
0.0407208316,
-0.0311437771,
0.0274680946,
0.0022111866,
-0.0183756854,
-0.0265322477,
-0.0200729743,
0.0110445358,
-0.0148885855,
-0.0443473607,
-0.0364095159,
-0.0010970819,
0.031059904,
-0.0370761603,
-0.0208904743,
-0.0060138302,
0.0055387965,
0.018921122,
0.0514997765,
-0.0152128246,
0.0258414987,
0.0452617928,
-0.0357269682,
0.0226555336,
-0.054919377,
0.0009804866,
0.007834333,
0.0296412744,
0.0184573755,
0.0542104617,
-0.0030674797,
0.0101833185,
-0.0787971988,
0.0388888642,
0.02398175,
0.058183331,
-0.008568977,
-0.0185288973,
-0.0378523804,
-0.0122773396,
-0.0503916368,
0.0754901096,
-0.0239905044,
-0.0283525586,
0.0246121846,
-0.0443587303,
-0.0086439122,
-0.0385410152,
0.0081863534,
-0.0709463805,
0.0161162224,
0.0626841411,
-0.0089783901,
0.0181894992,
-0.0138562005,
0.0832802206,
-0.0294074398,
0.0196405072,
0.0233862996,
-0.0119576547,
-0.0167282857,
0.0166552775,
0.0059500779,
-0.014506219,
-0.0241778884,
0.0104481522,
-0.0644070655,
0.0099040139,
-0.0144560132,
0.0186426248,
0.0105271703,
0.0524631292,
-0.0060237823,
0.0232682209,
0.0107800867,
-0.0057174801,
-0.0237203948,
-0.0052505233,
0.0161040034,
0.000834349,
-0.0565756448,
0.0228821933,
-0.0585114546,
-0.0068919412,
-0.0169457849,
-0.0352361687,
-0.0017139869,
0.0181580037,
2.455e-7,
0.0572656728,
0.0167956445,
0.0143043324,
0.0946989283,
0.0252631865,
0.0467936508,
-0.015742233,
0.0052031772,
0.0369202979,
-0.0327248499,
0.0182233807,
0.0582999215,
0.0477912128,
0.0525465086,
-0.085990943,
-0.0001216981,
-0.0543488562,
-0.0518269725,
-0.0321586207,
-0.0175195653,
0.0424342453,
0.0813953653,
0.0272990372,
0.0077818315,
0.0059518502,
-0.0703894198,
0.0558420904,
0.020678632,
-0.027257055,
0.0252715275,
0.0470224135,
0.0288843792,
0.0123073263,
0.0485041998,
-0.0034663116,
-0.0079309484,
0.0148104224,
0.0507299155,
0.0196376815,
-0.0218134578,
-0.0279185064,
-0.0561992265,
0.0148832258,
-0.0668212697,
0.094833374,
-0.0671039596,
0.000661016,
-0.0277058594,
0.0047729495,
-0.0231778566,
-0.0002177488,
-0.0246269908,
-0.017421443,
0.0060588368,
0.0111429635,
-0.016816929,
0.0134458411,
-0.0427191816,
-0.0090309866,
0.0167424679,
-0.0500205159,
-0.0769742131,
0.0047095357,
-0.0076917564,
0.0333198979,
-0.0451924428,
0.0211792085,
1.990402825e-34,
0.0504912622,
-0.0097553385,
0.0095842406,
-0.0065509188,
0.0599215254,
-0.0052083516,
-0.0175667014,
-0.0269710533,
0.0207661409,
-0.0714626536,
-0.0107041914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11634v1 | MAGNIFICo: Evaluating the In-Context Learning Ability of Large Language Models to Generalize to Novel Interpretations | 2023-10-18T00:02:38 | 2023-10-18T00:02:38 | Arkil Patel, Satwik Bhattamishra, Siva Reddy, Dzmitry Bahdanau | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans possess a remarkable ability to assign novel interpretations to
linguistic expressions, enabling them to learn new words and understand
community-specific connotations. However, Large Language Models (LLMs) have a
knowledge cutoff and are costly to finetune repeatedly. Therefore, it is
crucial for LLMs to learn novel interpretations in-context. In this paper, we
systematically analyse the ability of LLMs to acquire novel interpretations
using in-context learning. To facilitate our study, we introduce MAGNIFICo, an
evaluation suite implemented within a text-to-SQL semantic parsing framework
that incorporates diverse tokens and prompt settings to simulate real-world
complexity. Experimental results on MAGNIFICo demonstrate that LLMs exhibit a
surprisingly robust capacity for comprehending novel interpretations from
natural language descriptions as well as from discussions within long
conversations. Nevertheless, our findings also highlight the need for further
improvements, particularly when interpreting unfamiliar words or when composing
multiple novel interpretations simultaneously in the same example.
Additionally, our analysis uncovers the semantic predispositions in LLMs and
reveals the impact of recency bias for information presented in long contexts. | [
0.0276032127,
0.019009674,
-0.0107547687,
0.0433319323,
-0.035791751,
0.0213778615,
-0.0415156409,
-0.0204330124,
-0.0179387685,
-0.0544214062,
-0.0229735505,
-0.0197140761,
-0.0180183481,
0.04631681,
0.0150959399,
-0.0420362018,
0.0401567481,
-0.0244600121,
-0.0125430245,
0.0137174809,
-0.0149921328,
0.0222571082,
0.0073410561,
0.0254462101,
-0.0089888247,
-0.0200667288,
0.0089842519,
0.0215714909,
-0.0228025801,
-0.039890144,
-0.0229074229,
0.0310202818,
0.0515551679,
0.0568796545,
0.0000021451,
-0.0852015615,
-0.0420342535,
-0.0119085303,
-0.0527437404,
0.0113076689,
0.0857113376,
-0.0194780771,
0.0098441578,
0.0006633945,
-0.0631974116,
-0.0002547225,
0.0086531145,
0.0039418028,
0.0196375959,
0.049351234,
-0.0140559012,
-0.031121809,
-0.0400442481,
-0.0168594234,
0.0149847521,
-0.0979369134,
0.0146753695,
0.030047752,
-0.0062256679,
-0.0179604013,
-0.045493532,
0.0187121667,
0.0345856771,
0.0105726253,
0.0130572598,
0.0510030761,
-0.0142752808,
0.0052195573,
-0.0149373282,
0.0601222403,
-0.0193304401,
-0.0311759487,
-0.0285229422,
0.0005680451,
0.004942656,
0.0233892258,
-0.0462063849,
0.0119428076,
-0.0094995908,
0.0266665351,
-0.0081260838,
-0.0044383202,
0.0336355269,
0.0270621292,
-0.0516649447,
0.0803670138,
-0.0145816319,
-0.0101025868,
0.0249220859,
0.0074727144,
-0.0531185493,
-0.0086011104,
0.0110666594,
0.0241826847,
-0.0757059157,
0.0473726764,
-0.0251533911,
0.0072465655,
0.0416985564,
-0.058548376,
0.0145885777,
0.0384476893,
-0.0254570879,
0.0990323052,
-0.0440548994,
-0.0116021913,
-0.0053683929,
0.0273030587,
-0.0535724685,
-0.0594693199,
-0.0843954459,
-0.0258644652,
-0.020556163,
0.0273655821,
-0.0895677954,
-0.0438950025,
-0.0139009086,
0.0356548131,
-0.0248699896,
0.0071097636,
-0.0014126311,
0.0044663316,
-0.0374744125,
-0.0039971592,
-0.0543389171,
0.0106343897,
-0.0450932458,
0.0390000679,
-0.0063512176,
-0.0845939964,
-0.027306607,
-0.0178510826,
0.0040608956,
-0.0381033123,
0.0006960651,
0.0595168918,
0.0041862745,
-0.0182614252,
-0.040529836,
-0.0419487581,
-0.0318351462,
-0.0363510139,
-0.0188366771,
-0.0424462967,
0.0580947585,
0.0327842981,
0.0004967113,
-0.0607031137,
-0.0178840831,
0.0133006182,
-0.0257358588,
0.0690843016,
0.0111164907,
0.0275825541,
0.0526587069,
0.00492165,
-0.029964162,
0.114330329,
-0.0004737059,
0.0278991144,
0.0076790731,
0.0133499354,
-0.0304229055,
0.0322996229,
-0.0043030065,
-0.0051191109,
-0.0711017102,
0.0511580743,
0.0129500227,
0.0405725762,
0.0336498655,
0.0462110564,
-0.0360379964,
-0.0099445665,
0.0149211297,
0.0596157201,
0.0088486914,
0.0135598658,
0.0514678285,
0.0274071731,
-0.0189015865,
-0.0395303108,
-0.0793522075,
0.0001459623,
0.0053911526,
-0.0029961932,
-0.0244134385,
-0.0076670768,
-0.0114815831,
-0.0150324693,
0.0074385586,
-0.0153809171,
0.022182107,
0.0104874875,
0.0333302505,
0.0249994788,
-0.013213492,
0.0453362577,
0.0331634469,
-0.0072892956,
0.0300496146,
-0.0451340489,
-0.0021126785,
0.1164613068,
0.0188041795,
-0.0425003245,
0.019596478,
-0.0172258969,
0.0217323489,
0.0215138886,
0.0188154969,
-0.0049168756,
-0.0002595792,
-0.0243882369,
-0.0258718561,
-0.0168220121,
0.0269210469,
0.0120111173,
0.0216813013,
-0.0162131879,
0.001792702,
-0.0395951532,
-0.0101544438,
0.0414249375,
-0.020761108,
-0.0164465234,
-0.0314130373,
-0.0051006419,
0.0076553756,
0.0062845116,
0.0165693574,
0.021366721,
0.0142501136,
-0.0229341611,
-0.027343398,
0.0368265174,
-0.071721822,
-0.0295314193,
0.0151066836,
-0.0387645029,
-0.0354763456,
-0.0305026826,
-0.0463717729,
-0.0181847792,
0.0320704244,
-0.0173212178,
0.0576546267,
-0.0497073382,
-0.0153553374,
-0.0463624112,
0.0067663649,
-0.0392202511,
0.0984551162,
-0.0306850318,
-0.012615893,
0.0054515311,
-0.0119499937,
-0.0176457986,
-0.0465855934,
0.0167163275,
-0.0432674251,
-0.0018063342,
-0.0273019057,
-0.0302814879,
-0.0069629285,
-0.0783854648,
-0.0405863859,
-0.0971799716,
0.0035460484,
-0.025924474,
0.0294943713,
0.0679338574,
0.0020345093,
0.0065328474,
-0.0076885014,
-0.0240939781,
-0.0126454867,
-0.0261465423,
0.0475008339,
0.0276686046,
0.0064801401,
-0.0040251454,
-0.0105615752,
-0.0171092674,
-0.0493330508,
0.0974828675,
0.0167007484,
-0.005624915,
-0.0296909381,
-0.0116050513,
-0.0108946031,
-0.0026177517,
0.0014047753,
0.0107521098,
0.0030945989,
-0.0115451608,
0.0332859084,
0.0721971467,
0.0028373278,
0.0495358929,
0.00680845,
0.0002141915,
-0.0615333058,
-0.0171525981,
-0.0088913739,
-0.0223945938,
-0.0600006916,
-0.0310335308,
-0.0105316378,
0.0500167422,
0.0220171362,
0.0186400376,
-0.0357086807,
0.0376927517,
-0.0371299163,
-0.0698521957,
-0.0498094112,
-0.0202942938,
0.0008162367,
0.023422746,
-0.0402219072,
-0.0061722249,
0.0815470591,
0.0172394384,
-0.0140823023,
-0.0398761518,
0.0072180573,
-0.0566688962,
0.0840431526,
-0.0142225241,
0.0220585875,
-0.0248712674,
-0.0545301326,
-0.0301978737,
-0.0446028821,
0.0059052096,
-0.0288768504,
0.0993967876,
-0.0478183031,
0.0005575802,
0.0157243516,
0.0037409712,
-0.0198825914,
-0.0341248326,
-0.0552055873,
0.0399767831,
0.0343487002,
0.0376326777,
0.022054214,
-0.004559306,
0.0020740756,
0.0045494107,
0.0032050731,
-0.0299719311,
-0.0124436636,
-0.0148768332,
0.0313458629,
0.0289679319,
0.0193003733,
-0.0253071394,
0.020652568,
0.0483015887,
0.0182108749,
-0.048243992,
-0.0498964414,
0.0171419531,
-0.0233148653,
-0.0442401692,
0.0068435874,
0.0001176764,
0.0213649832,
-0.0860304534,
-0.0239905231,
0.1051739678,
0.0219335426,
-0.0262271613,
0.0379505344,
-0.0488730967,
0.047546953,
0.0479229912,
0.0060876389,
-0.1140257493,
-0.0526964106,
-0.014982908,
0.000004551,
0.0258800294,
-0.0630436987,
0.0034409645,
-0.104256779,
0.0130066499,
-0.0236633159,
-0.0658313781,
0.0323143862,
-0.0347094722,
-0.015199949,
-0.0353506319,
0.0390136503,
0.0613770448,
-0.0228433292,
0.0133567993,
-0.0063624377,
0.0159851126,
-0.0486482531,
0.074483864,
-0.0208350774,
0.027577484,
0.0433516987,
-0.0148715368,
-0.0219818018,
0.0024030607,
0.0429902375,
-0.0055286204,
0.0175133254,
-0.0181516986,
0.039121557,
0.0095499065,
0.0169658866,
0.0177560095,
0.0325116254,
-0.0375496186,
-0.0259846337,
0.0294585992,
0.0921873152,
0.0011368225,
0.0027356301,
0.0280997064,
-0.0187921133,
0.0223833974,
0.1005129293,
0.0279169455,
-0.0254858583,
-0.0473838672,
-0.0174305625,
-0.0307224281,
-0.0155337555,
-0.0032032025,
0.0449372977,
0.0118968729,
-0.023050759,
-0.0166671351,
-0.0130176414,
0.0521421991,
0.028681973,
0.0104820244,
0.0293891039,
0.0121039152,
-0.005116174,
-0.030577736,
0.0394929275,
-0.0535114408,
0.011725626,
0.0051766904,
0.0037494199,
0.0323446803,
-0.0336587355,
-0.0377791226,
0.0164279174,
-0.0665075183,
-0.0245035533,
0.031454619,
-0.0077749384,
0.0337983072,
0.0482312031,
-0.0214524083,
-0.0426504984,
0.0129882293,
-0.001067977,
-0.0433801338,
0.0259877723,
0.0147519745,
0.0693532228,
0.0216428693,
0.0555971824,
-0.0504398011,
0.0094035622,
-0.0137007507,
0.0478214286,
-0.0139281414,
-0.0125124566,
0.0465223715,
-0.0106629124,
0.0114913238,
-0.0003283775,
-0.0137000941,
0.0026441806,
0.0006045365,
-0.044446975,
-0.0074139484,
-0.0168909151,
-0.0143366549,
0.0488337465,
-0.0177294146,
0.0167939886,
-0.0334632248,
-0.0164808091,
0.0575439781,
-0.0413792208,
-0.0106240055,
0.0499045104,
-0.0183410104,
0.0236311834,
-0.0072852606,
-0.0282249339,
0.0071806991,
-0.0310016554,
0.0291358624,
-0.0302621443,
0.0344819464,
0.0317801945,
-0.0210781507,
-0.0488025062,
-0.0061016981,
-0.0566575304,
-0.0307830945,
0.0197607633,
0.0385296196,
0.0427514315,
-0.0155692287,
0.0425726958,
-0.0061866394,
0.0185594577,
-0.0176423527,
0.0064823683,
0.0058833268,
-0.0648083761,
0.0414312519,
0.0296307374,
-0.0247353911,
-0.0050871726,
0.0617899075,
-0.0260844473,
0.0478388183,
-0.0258660708,
-0.0081825685,
-0.0371524543,
-0.0442644209,
0.0012142467,
0.0338585228,
-0.0415819027,
0.008035522,
-0.0694197118,
-0.0393955,
0.0251691919,
0.020724114,
-0.0110030472,
-0.0034855478,
0.0534190424,
0.0801647678,
0.0032977571,
-0.0430077016,
-0.0155900456,
0.0312318914,
0.0119395256,
-0.0121707227,
-0.0335550122,
-6.793037121e-33,
-0.0014640641,
-0.0180035792,
0.0348204151,
0.0100236107,
-0.0056706085,
-0.0153890494,
-0.0331336632,
-0.0049158027,
-0.0193144362,
0.0209365021,
0.0013124291,
0.0166030359,
0.0263491925,
0.0566155612,
0.0144427335,
-0.0336898193,
0.0355837345,
0.0123953307,
0.0246763006,
0.0121613182,
0.0666718557,
0.0458956137,
0.0419697911,
-0.053320203,
0.0285293739,
0.0154355131,
-0.0047002449,
0.052674327,
0.0192264058,
0.0367754214,
-0.0045884824,
0.0395817868,
0.0495646037,
-0.0527385473,
-0.0248602089,
0.0004808671,
-0.089408569,
-0.0143580921,
0.0591826551,
-0.0019656159,
-0.025537828,
-0.0266112033,
0.0697319582,
-0.0279186107,
-0.0079708612,
-0.0098785069,
0.0168259069,
-0.0396264344,
-0.027478775,
0.0079301,
-0.0622408986,
0.0155666852,
-0.0059562512,
-0.0023353226,
-0.0115351966,
0.0188868549,
-0.008066399,
0.0406540558,
-0.0526338145,
0.0075150658,
0.0003708764,
0.026529666,
0.0630327463,
0.0491217636,
0.0195833798,
0.0516224988,
0.0111835888,
-0.0144323604,
-0.0186003316,
-0.0031346495,
0.0389560759,
0.0415020436,
-0.015759306,
0.0692984164,
0.0281349011,
-0.0097151324,
-0.0805897936,
-0.0159585848,
0.0110900803,
0.0494329147,
0.0468713343,
0.0349517986,
-0.0321472958,
-0.0210162178,
-0.0721312612,
0.036568813,
-0.0360442549,
-0.0250693467,
0.0531944484,
-0.0159849878,
0.0070658727,
0.0087661725,
0.02107873,
-0.0470737182,
-0.0207540672,
0.0243522413,
0.0044411966,
-0.0302003901,
0.0090552876,
0.0458419621,
-0.025881445,
-0.0571569465,
-0.0031111087,
0.0243657064,
0.0304546505,
0.0140211824,
0.048860617,
-0.0066537205,
-0.0371118002,
0.0177908354,
-0.0308185071,
0.0041427254,
-0.0274668038,
0.003679625,
0.030381782,
0.0052840519,
-0.0236893259,
0.019838687,
0.0416126475,
0.0040088911,
-0.0104395309,
-0.0150974374,
0.0051920642,
0.0238284785,
-0.0532682948,
0.0031641058,
0.0220619906,
-0.004823192,
0.05303929,
-0.031154776,
-0.0009217781,
0.0251081958,
2.917e-7,
0.0947683081,
0.0639129952,
-0.0008067845,
0.0027283058,
0.0425222106,
0.0156795289,
-0.0132291606,
0.0269988105,
0.0047581973,
-0.0387869142,
-0.010597798,
0.0529677272,
0.0029694531,
0.031672813,
-0.0764233842,
0.0107977046,
-0.0564277396,
0.0377486348,
-0.0257878192,
0.0271279737,
0.0632931665,
0.0910377204,
-0.0134564973,
0.0007002224,
-0.0131976455,
-0.0725513399,
0.0538534634,
-0.0466782302,
-0.0048571229,
0.017519936,
0.0028893757,
0.0212201886,
0.0390925109,
0.0337986052,
0.0074123666,
0.0218432192,
0.0007040575,
0.092670992,
-0.0182892941,
-0.0092444951,
-0.012759232,
-0.07521189,
0.0160544291,
-0.0914623216,
0.063232109,
-0.1183674484,
-0.0221007857,
-0.0149940923,
-0.0117347743,
-0.0230102371,
0.0190843288,
-0.010866289,
0.0007969936,
-0.0256890394,
0.0288243778,
0.0221105833,
-0.0212523621,
-0.0611939244,
-0.0210366454,
0.0226125214,
-0.0472324193,
-0.0286691207,
-0.0240208022,
0.0001256052,
0.0276432615,
-0.0426931791,
0.00463726,
2.427410069e-34,
0.0556993596,
0.0255008489,
0.0347773433,
0.0471851863,
0.0439619124,
0.006947136,
-0.0117057143,
0.0297587179,
0.0243518464,
-0.0775619075,
0.0083193593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11628v1 | Learn Your Tokens: Word-Pooled Tokenization for Language Modeling | 2023-10-17T23:34:39 | 2023-10-17T23:34:39 | Avijit Thawani, Saurabh Ghanekar, Xiaoyuan Zhu, Jay Pujara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models typically tokenize text into subwords, using a deterministic,
hand-engineered heuristic of combining characters into longer surface-level
strings such as 'ing' or whole words. Recent literature has repeatedly shown
the limitations of such a tokenization strategy, particularly for documents not
written in English and for representing numbers. On the other extreme,
byte/character-level language models are much less restricted but suffer from
increased sequence description lengths and a subsequent quadratic expansion in
self-attention computation. Recent attempts to compress and limit these context
lengths with fixed size convolutions is helpful but completely ignores the word
boundary. This paper considers an alternative 'learn your tokens' scheme which
utilizes the word boundary to pool bytes/characters into word representations,
which are fed to the primary language model, before again decoding individual
characters/bytes per word in parallel. We find that our moderately expressive
and moderately fast end-to-end tokenizer outperform by over 300% both subwords
and byte/character models over the intrinsic language modeling metric of
next-word prediction across datasets. It particularly outshines on rare words,
outperforming by a factor of 30! We extensively study the language modeling
setup for all three categories of tokenizers and theoretically analyze how our
end-to-end models can also be a strong trade-off in efficiency and robustness. | [
0.0209722314,
0.0525780879,
0.0308098141,
0.0243837871,
-0.034948688,
0.0009801906,
0.0377582833,
-0.0242694207,
-0.0285326652,
-0.0548121706,
-0.0121561829,
-0.0733526945,
-0.0046560299,
0.0356394164,
0.0576782115,
-0.0121138925,
0.0613717921,
-0.0540265664,
0.0192074068,
0.005410606,
0.0031406176,
0.0143892821,
0.0546724722,
0.0476352014,
-0.0295848027,
-0.0167717934,
-0.0451768674,
0.0025260418,
-0.0458308421,
-0.0119114164,
0.0145859215,
0.0370784588,
0.0389882512,
0.0651111454,
0.000002094,
-0.0126334559,
-0.0350393318,
-0.0107426522,
0.0040651429,
0.0479381382,
0.0951609686,
-0.054089684,
-0.0172381438,
0.0201522652,
-0.01106798,
-0.0135461306,
0.0392515585,
0.0129742855,
0.0488951206,
0.0545791946,
-0.0124865063,
-0.0263492912,
0.0303938705,
-0.0517855324,
-0.0113462172,
-0.0227688253,
-0.001045003,
-0.0142501723,
-0.0167936999,
0.0018851265,
-0.0492111109,
0.0225202981,
0.0120353363,
-0.0017832323,
0.0264318213,
0.0509353653,
-0.0291292872,
-0.0154531049,
-0.0265166312,
0.0350999795,
-0.0716687515,
-0.0475853942,
-0.0119216014,
0.0112005556,
-0.0088787144,
-0.031639196,
-0.0491284542,
0.031101888,
0.0164010786,
0.039607469,
0.014487057,
0.03667254,
0.0289758723,
0.0073793526,
-0.0755855069,
0.0512976386,
0.0125532225,
-0.0245438982,
-0.0316886753,
-0.0208739955,
-0.0087048439,
-0.0424104296,
0.0229275972,
0.0171309244,
0.0211308058,
0.0097112888,
-0.0647377595,
-0.0551057756,
0.0268940199,
-0.0461445004,
0.013915387,
0.0484301336,
-0.0061246948,
0.0501770228,
-0.0419499986,
0.0194954984,
-0.0066268248,
0.037278574,
-0.0648275763,
-0.0081971735,
0.0190231893,
-0.0100742243,
-0.0770388544,
0.041011665,
-0.0440767221,
-0.0578970201,
-0.0051094871,
0.0175731611,
0.0443664268,
-0.0396347977,
0.005467053,
-0.012880546,
-0.0282476041,
-0.0176685471,
0.0286008921,
-0.0103934212,
-0.0375266075,
-0.0094342697,
0.0115978746,
-0.0465216413,
-0.0345919691,
0.0196242332,
0.0085672373,
-0.0319878198,
-0.0040611653,
0.0996872857,
-0.0022309539,
-0.0453966148,
-0.0064968294,
-0.0050680046,
-0.0155971376,
-0.0365697704,
-0.0150916316,
-0.0782285556,
0.037859831,
-0.0083267698,
-0.0109738,
-0.0265795346,
0.0010390729,
0.0264349878,
-0.0181775484,
0.0674596578,
-0.0171712879,
-0.0118282661,
0.0084376801,
-0.0117183197,
0.0178433079,
0.0739620626,
0.0481898747,
0.0508228503,
0.0340921991,
-0.0172935445,
-0.0137500511,
0.0487769619,
0.0445677973,
0.0012978724,
-0.0447752476,
-0.0072368351,
0.0447338931,
0.0038561239,
0.0778365731,
0.0796952099,
-0.0302477051,
-0.0403640084,
0.0206572693,
0.1165262461,
-0.0066699018,
0.0499900654,
0.0396146066,
0.0178951733,
-0.015871739,
-0.0076296716,
-0.0316651948,
0.0292258076,
0.041411195,
0.023833137,
0.0839394331,
0.036179956,
-0.0326809101,
-0.0471108332,
-0.0155842584,
-0.0185252801,
0.0508008674,
-0.0332733877,
0.0348435082,
-0.0031185311,
-0.0631335303,
0.068499282,
0.0117234318,
-0.0618362054,
0.0142758703,
-0.0299744513,
0.0253304169,
0.0788566843,
0.0521301776,
-0.0040141307,
0.0018023755,
-0.0453328639,
0.0417753495,
0.0338021182,
0.0261731558,
0.0138565162,
0.0115462057,
-0.0566193089,
0.0087064151,
-0.0231577978,
-0.0172801092,
0.0247386321,
0.00746718,
0.0203171168,
0.020970596,
-0.0543682091,
-0.027672654,
0.0543378443,
-0.0004287401,
-0.0427062288,
0.0011518045,
-0.0034818272,
0.0289021097,
0.0027587237,
0.0031703047,
0.0511858948,
0.0387007445,
-0.0331893265,
-0.0228050128,
-0.0019753948,
-0.0590384342,
-0.0206077173,
0.0591511503,
-0.0022691565,
0.0443878993,
0.0131977014,
-0.0306436345,
-0.0386430994,
0.0422555879,
-0.0430158935,
0.077676639,
-0.0492340811,
0.0332834423,
0.0111094257,
0.0438192114,
-0.0188148487,
0.026510315,
-0.0269139875,
0.0240754541,
-0.0326087959,
0.0050476235,
0.016903406,
-0.0405710675,
-0.0243312661,
0.0088365022,
-0.026368849,
0.0153488135,
0.0209333003,
-0.0143690743,
-0.0157715902,
-0.0109467199,
-0.0990602821,
-0.0165479444,
-0.0307046194,
0.022583358,
-0.0096787736,
0.0325821154,
0.0009712725,
-0.0381837487,
-0.032758642,
-0.0399804413,
-0.0215299353,
0.0172920041,
0.0218701381,
-0.0214712229,
-0.0013832459,
-0.0351012945,
-0.0532506369,
-0.0029664263,
0.0760635287,
-0.0217995178,
-0.0471751131,
-0.039343942,
-0.018534204,
-0.0064175753,
0.031160254,
-0.0159273464,
-0.0482546836,
-0.0156879295,
-0.0588230528,
0.0296402834,
0.0666481182,
0.0449640043,
-0.0079185236,
0.0397521891,
0.0285897125,
-0.0464386269,
0.0214357097,
-0.0058305273,
0.0108295642,
0.0279859863,
-0.0055339639,
0.0083587263,
0.0880485922,
-0.0188953001,
0.0047456082,
-0.0590132177,
0.0016145178,
-0.0027989042,
-0.0216265805,
-0.0367798954,
-0.0077189035,
-0.0233419519,
0.0125470487,
-0.0310280211,
-0.0794425979,
0.0598845147,
-0.0391566828,
-0.0237757992,
-0.048351828,
0.0126282414,
-0.0366009437,
0.0482782125,
0.0075479629,
0.0232494716,
-0.0316551626,
-0.0366666205,
-0.0150029156,
0.020598948,
-0.0201030541,
-0.0263713561,
0.0414719842,
0.0028580185,
0.0223006513,
-0.0220913496,
-0.0271442272,
-0.0276312027,
-0.0402458496,
-0.0339118168,
0.0162958391,
0.0228551794,
-0.0136965392,
-0.0278011281,
0.0585130341,
0.0088805873,
0.0767294466,
-0.0153468652,
0.0106489314,
-0.0155056529,
0.0279589705,
0.0263822004,
-0.0163640827,
0.0008084115,
-0.0153951244,
0.0329392403,
0.0566894375,
0.0614270121,
0.0249629244,
-0.0078514544,
-0.0030287893,
0.0272472594,
-0.0177743062,
-0.0066638384,
0.0157585088,
0.0331535228,
-0.0719246715,
-0.01531363,
0.1219683066,
0.0222562496,
-0.053965468,
0.003116755,
-0.0246328246,
0.0251106787,
0.0153635135,
0.0008800645,
-0.0598182976,
-0.0357143208,
0.0190131757,
0.0212100521,
0.0638172254,
-0.009912706,
-0.0078995759,
-0.0852043554,
0.0275124479,
0.047983095,
-0.0580981709,
-0.001148009,
-0.0437387675,
-0.032936167,
-0.0001526759,
0.011175341,
0.0355259478,
-0.0113961091,
-0.001201577,
0.0102214403,
-0.0215839595,
0.0162273236,
0.0082960976,
-0.0291495305,
0.0268420856,
0.053185869,
0.013530992,
0.0208382439,
-0.029383732,
0.0684614778,
0.0038454724,
-0.003950316,
-0.0066105691,
0.034621533,
-0.0541160069,
0.0092187077,
0.0169630013,
0.0351599753,
-0.0487480201,
-0.0090303151,
-0.0259269569,
0.0507788323,
0.0209431686,
-0.0070960484,
-0.0350705571,
-0.0161416549,
0.0017048923,
0.0866576582,
0.0358330719,
-0.0564498939,
-0.0774178058,
-0.0385856405,
0.0221537184,
-0.0495397858,
0.0043205507,
-0.0168702528,
0.0237221979,
-0.0529032983,
-0.0353444442,
-0.0291825403,
0.0082674511,
0.0280452762,
-0.0176884271,
0.0229812358,
-0.0036605741,
-0.0060907383,
-0.0763922632,
-0.0010869467,
-0.0270679984,
0.0287036728,
-0.0856174752,
0.0128868017,
0.0175389107,
-0.0333367586,
-0.008144862,
0.0213551186,
-0.0967580006,
-0.0613331757,
-0.0130830025,
0.0337247215,
0.0137152569,
0.0495014936,
-0.0168560427,
-0.0311210901,
0.0407440998,
0.0299420264,
-0.0904135033,
0.0054552602,
0.0307310205,
0.0325179063,
-0.0100036804,
0.0355787873,
-0.0410214998,
0.0032633129,
0.003186347,
0.013821682,
-0.0077483645,
-0.0060485145,
0.0079782838,
-0.0036735246,
0.0161141604,
-0.0522499457,
0.0349318646,
0.0044776909,
0.0242322441,
0.0050312565,
0.020118285,
-0.0388327688,
0.0148034785,
0.0271901935,
-0.0137604708,
0.0028718179,
0.0189622194,
-0.0040677749,
-0.0053258599,
0.011088849,
0.0371632092,
-0.0374736562,
0.0486508869,
0.0322678499,
-0.0140968384,
-0.0041305907,
-0.0333031863,
-0.0409189202,
0.0176640227,
-0.0483450778,
-0.0185441095,
0.0032219531,
0.0236811917,
-0.0463514589,
0.0339537784,
-0.0641438887,
-0.0311310757,
-0.0499481,
0.0406407602,
0.0084032575,
-0.0152973486,
-0.0115693118,
-0.0062427768,
-0.0234279428,
-0.0258166492,
0.0058773588,
0.0018967063,
-0.0373992585,
0.0115602054,
0.0208404586,
-0.0441511944,
-0.0184195843,
0.0709647611,
0.0286762752,
0.0094042346,
0.0236760825,
-0.0139531484,
-0.0507535301,
0.0111294612,
-0.0197384041,
0.0526645556,
-0.0300284401,
0.0074370708,
-0.0565367863,
-0.0611404702,
0.0235387553,
-0.0037686557,
0.0013846571,
-0.0092980722,
0.0097280089,
0.0503773019,
-0.0151907848,
0.0208483264,
-0.0205537006,
0.0525299087,
0.0234923288,
-0.0423729233,
-0.0328738764,
-6.35782797e-33,
0.0077193915,
-0.0076721027,
-0.000983907,
-0.0304270126,
-0.0123588722,
0.0169160832,
-0.010380242,
-0.0186307449,
0.0133282188,
-0.0279473793,
-0.0457546599,
0.01295646,
0.0168202184,
0.0424147472,
0.0061770719,
0.0187741369,
0.0526323207,
-0.0452849045,
-0.0339729078,
0.012325176,
0.0238932036,
0.0477219112,
0.0314909667,
-0.0115390606,
0.0034718227,
-0.0168748107,
0.0038652511,
-0.0038706586,
0.0371578857,
0.039201919,
-0.0282664318,
0.0001019448,
0.006285565,
-0.0245433562,
-0.0527584888,
0.0784589946,
-0.1108651161,
-0.0115185548,
0.0190396644,
0.00759057,
-0.0049184817,
-0.0503673255,
0.0282143783,
-0.0096576549,
-0.0061598322,
-0.0179183874,
0.0023049,
0.0002974176,
-0.0686823949,
0.0008220063,
-0.0499029234,
0.0224413686,
-0.0103424154,
0.004419697,
0.0742078573,
-0.0002401746,
0.0195727199,
0.0298006739,
-0.079001002,
0.0223387275,
-0.0055986359,
0.0593819097,
0.0677251071,
0.0159358196,
0.0234638304,
0.0454830937,
0.0514555722,
-0.0204195566,
-0.0349082574,
0.0065699732,
0.0398026742,
-0.0069128992,
0.0287626293,
-0.0103623094,
0.0719501823,
-0.0361085162,
-0.0541224778,
-0.0032951704,
0.0236654375,
0.028492149,
0.0332784429,
0.052999489,
-0.0411691591,
-0.017096011,
-0.0133380927,
-0.011230466,
-0.0325946771,
-0.028018428,
0.0430038236,
0.0415206812,
-0.0233649872,
-0.0302767903,
0.0432876311,
-0.0219206437,
-0.0015812952,
0.0601171292,
0.0049038329,
0.0067772376,
0.0024776785,
0.0455336235,
-0.0372552387,
-0.0111555327,
-0.0132508585,
0.0172792114,
-0.0266746413,
-0.00074551,
0.0352457762,
0.0313498415,
-0.0789286494,
-0.0102320425,
-0.045903109,
0.0165168568,
0.0224786755,
0.0302374959,
0.0523947068,
-0.0042137108,
0.0118314261,
0.003805412,
-0.0146857109,
-0.028665863,
-0.0027290506,
-0.0152517501,
-0.0130995018,
0.0358806774,
-0.0261955503,
0.0044269771,
-0.0487025529,
0.028971903,
0.0544292368,
-0.0456537791,
-0.0145184835,
0.067716822,
2.689e-7,
0.041597303,
0.0227516368,
0.0690282062,
-0.036311008,
0.0215749703,
0.0052800514,
0.0135361562,
0.0414616466,
-0.0104659665,
0.0203800201,
-0.0091155544,
0.0125505589,
0.0350438543,
-0.0019294794,
-0.1238645464,
0.0205911584,
-0.0568453707,
0.0554190613,
-0.0289357211,
-0.0285981391,
0.0058064596,
0.145295471,
-0.0018045123,
0.0041325008,
0.0009849339,
-0.0738975406,
0.0357816219,
0.0007880654,
0.0131038092,
0.0074690692,
0.0010113703,
0.0248851161,
-0.0294153281,
-0.013351717,
-0.0267868768,
0.0331337675,
0.0527850538,
0.0463698208,
-0.0198565107,
-0.0070588076,
-0.0030098383,
-0.0457660034,
-0.0136203822,
-0.0471315347,
0.0571681708,
-0.0016446122,
-0.0002491432,
-0.0539602041,
-0.0061039049,
0.0368782505,
0.0058881128,
-0.0041782265,
-0.0194372088,
0.0553419702,
0.0365007967,
-0.0168044623,
0.0238289107,
-0.0987666696,
-0.0423903279,
-0.0344308503,
-0.0291636121,
-0.0029747819,
-0.0799374878,
0.0338377841,
0.0589131154,
-0.0592356212,
-0.0025242418,
2.563727006e-34,
0.0698299035,
-0.0230692457,
0.0101536699,
0.0292800944,
0.0061569428,
-0.0511178002,
0.0473242998,
0.0330726765,
0.0273401476,
-0.0506229587,
-0.0471383035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11616v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11616v2 | Unveiling the General Intelligence Factor in Language Models: A Psychometric Approach | 2023-10-17T22:42:12 | 2023-12-06T19:00:13 | David Ilić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study uncovers the factor of general intelligence, or g, in language
models, extending the psychometric theory traditionally applied to humans and
certain animal species. Utilizing factor analysis on two extensive datasets -
Open LLM Leaderboard with 1,232 models and General Language Understanding
Evaluation (GLUE) Leaderboard with 88 models - we find compelling evidence for
a unidimensional, highly stable g factor that accounts for 85% of the variance
in model performance. The study also finds a moderate correlation of .49
between model size and g. The discovery of g in language models offers a
unified metric for model evaluation and opens new avenues for more robust,
g-based model ability assessment. These findings lay the foundation for
understanding and future research on artificial general intelligence from a
psychometric perspective and have practical implications for model evaluation
and development. | [
0.0449298844,
0.0588613935,
-0.044663325,
0.0128820296,
-0.0271392073,
0.0406081304,
0.0198409967,
0.0144252507,
0.0291890558,
-0.0306610707,
-0.056521032,
-0.0489016101,
0.0005465032,
0.0539879873,
0.0563689657,
-0.039273411,
0.0505608395,
-0.056760557,
0.0727824792,
0.0048752804,
-0.0586257055,
-0.0004535214,
0.0014783322,
0.0217868891,
-0.0033880037,
-0.0138393985,
0.0259046704,
-0.035410583,
0.0225246791,
0.0043913326,
-0.0303893201,
0.051605165,
-0.0032579852,
0.0312406234,
0.0000019788,
-0.0785772353,
0.0278295632,
-0.0098651471,
-0.0157954562,
0.0041621667,
0.0205393024,
0.039568577,
-0.0111208772,
0.0178211648,
-0.0536635667,
0.0147571741,
-0.0102009391,
0.0252051186,
-0.0000304166,
0.0444303378,
-0.0050848941,
-0.018471472,
0.0731948614,
-0.0119816847,
0.0208263788,
-0.048246704,
0.0274041705,
0.0417646468,
-0.0314153507,
-0.0210750625,
-0.0337616429,
0.0089445282,
0.0218194667,
0.0193700921,
-0.0077147628,
0.008252223,
-0.0121634528,
-0.037844304,
-0.0015828914,
0.0286483802,
0.0019416682,
0.0014652552,
-0.0275355987,
0.0189342704,
0.0374255776,
0.0413977131,
-0.0790797174,
0.0153351445,
0.0284166206,
-0.0206177514,
0.0565127134,
0.0016215796,
0.0345124975,
-0.0075206845,
-0.0232349019,
0.1049766541,
0.0158555303,
-0.0414013118,
0.0158903934,
-0.0073137889,
-0.0740289241,
-0.0108005879,
-0.0332566537,
0.0251793992,
-0.0356362723,
0.0103523508,
0.0073361676,
-0.0024786592,
0.0167303868,
-0.0486144498,
0.0205708705,
0.0072807791,
0.0367763154,
0.0398915932,
0.0016213066,
0.1375932246,
0.0355616175,
0.0735662878,
-0.0201131646,
-0.0222921092,
-0.0539284945,
-0.0387113802,
0.0189785417,
0.0301730577,
0.0142334197,
-0.0356001966,
-0.0529164113,
-0.000818105,
-0.0055572395,
-0.0326637067,
0.0016137329,
-0.0050457004,
0.0067631644,
-0.0220603924,
-0.036529649,
-0.0181865674,
-0.0300639998,
0.049050007,
-0.0027195434,
-0.0442717001,
0.0321854576,
-0.0085896943,
0.000167721,
-0.0125123523,
0.0322289206,
0.0952733085,
0.0181907341,
-0.0512507893,
-0.0189515688,
-0.0104073668,
0.0024344886,
-0.0855903178,
0.0096748089,
-0.0456109904,
0.0226525124,
0.0436894447,
-0.0066447156,
-0.0636482239,
-0.0372014157,
0.0127991484,
-0.0314341933,
-0.013524442,
-0.0157434549,
0.0422562025,
0.0238204822,
0.0153830452,
0.0015552586,
0.0500306189,
0.0369590931,
-0.0397832058,
0.0437494814,
-0.0277716089,
0.0128581729,
0.0257393252,
-0.0398750231,
-0.005613755,
0.0089953691,
-0.0097233709,
0.0074253748,
-0.0251177903,
0.0327244252,
0.0512287878,
0.0105928006,
0.0123268673,
0.075079523,
0.092343986,
0.0176687092,
0.0696474463,
0.0407740511,
0.0049209921,
0.0475902259,
-0.0007207358,
-0.0625121817,
0.0174990762,
-0.0625800937,
0.0102737481,
-0.0073898099,
0.0737014189,
-0.0094997417,
-0.058012668,
-0.0245075263,
0.016823072,
0.0319930278,
0.0157812312,
0.0483678766,
-0.0257754587,
-0.0111385081,
-0.0274274573,
0.003595436,
-0.052385971,
-0.0152835716,
-0.0607039146,
0.0254167505,
0.0398271084,
0.0129001848,
0.0213291887,
-0.0091397157,
0.0265941061,
-0.0230320711,
0.0179901011,
0.0426947363,
-0.0205992088,
0.0059416825,
-0.0218104981,
0.0006958031,
0.0230889451,
0.0266096741,
0.0063017337,
-0.0267732721,
0.016065402,
0.0244344901,
-0.0360701568,
-0.0354176164,
0.0317942202,
-0.0544742011,
-0.016170973,
-0.0667014942,
-0.0342014693,
0.060144145,
0.0068913018,
0.0043723825,
0.0212433692,
0.0244040061,
-0.0015955291,
-0.0133496532,
0.0161295459,
0.0016143358,
0.0522333682,
0.0204943381,
-0.0209561661,
0.0111893145,
0.0597076751,
0.0380725302,
-0.0240932889,
0.0328938589,
-0.0516589954,
0.0792815313,
-0.0248811562,
0.0634878725,
-0.0717571452,
0.0092379991,
-0.011682108,
0.0745530799,
-0.0047126748,
0.030170748,
0.0252377,
-0.0338001847,
0.0465019383,
-0.0483859554,
0.0111311041,
-0.0004565347,
-0.0197167005,
0.0137888845,
-0.0075320867,
0.0082056494,
-0.0646831468,
-0.0197619554,
-0.0892938077,
-0.0128193488,
-0.005196631,
0.0276416279,
0.0142752547,
-0.0199344344,
-0.0399997644,
0.0275820885,
-0.018687861,
-0.0162894502,
0.0391940847,
0.0117436368,
-0.0168842804,
-0.026815882,
-0.0362682268,
-0.0502202362,
-0.0149214389,
-0.0362064205,
0.0319034532,
0.0228805076,
0.0177752785,
-0.0072481507,
0.0443019159,
-0.0695745945,
-0.0054433923,
-0.0262840241,
-0.0713029057,
0.0398863368,
0.0011013129,
0.036504373,
0.0804344118,
0.01855582,
0.0112789674,
0.0352058224,
-0.0116827684,
-0.0435677506,
0.0001549613,
0.0004806997,
0.0068119736,
-0.052772902,
-0.0590589643,
0.0072307652,
0.1026528627,
0.0062880777,
-0.0093877641,
-0.0277223885,
0.0731828511,
-0.0337385088,
-0.0668535382,
-0.0182456188,
0.0157318376,
-0.0178182144,
0.0710146949,
-0.0340462327,
-0.0546179861,
0.0185767114,
-0.0212104674,
0.0025563813,
0.0045774751,
-0.0229322091,
-0.0177320205,
0.0615137629,
-0.0059053046,
0.0033178569,
-0.0472077429,
-0.0060753077,
-0.0629249513,
0.0148747172,
-0.0227233339,
-0.0398212932,
0.0074558179,
-0.0503514409,
-0.0263057929,
0.0279292352,
-0.0017458809,
-0.0301703792,
0.0291122552,
-0.0462950505,
0.0274542831,
0.0382929184,
-0.0496624373,
-0.0471103527,
-0.0198511165,
0.0344791636,
-0.0399498492,
-0.0049974509,
0.0031196049,
0.015606421,
-0.0317818113,
0.0679911301,
0.0159230344,
0.0517931394,
-0.0591957755,
0.046426557,
0.0148744658,
-0.0247076526,
0.0266736634,
0.0275381915,
0.0276754983,
0.0258520246,
0.0103134625,
-0.0545624122,
0.0337705947,
0.0352933928,
-0.026836127,
-0.0068139127,
0.1315401345,
0.0330174863,
-0.0018920673,
0.0392026566,
-0.0249828994,
0.0190596189,
0.0312198754,
0.0175581537,
0.022936387,
-0.0025463165,
0.0020705957,
-0.0099749314,
-0.0238152388,
-0.0415230058,
0.0079163965,
-0.0788226202,
0.023804782,
0.0202470887,
-0.0460400097,
-0.0551814884,
-0.0269566122,
0.0136044715,
-0.0166059006,
-0.0079342267,
0.0056482484,
-0.0018018557,
0.0145915803,
-0.0116695594,
-0.0703442767,
-0.055886969,
0.0576213636,
-0.0355901234,
0.0555775762,
0.0537311882,
0.0410953574,
-0.0352319665,
-0.065409407,
0.0300133228,
-0.0030093498,
0.0076112701,
0.0062749949,
0.0529457815,
-0.018358279,
0.0193583965,
-0.0519880578,
-0.0102467276,
-0.017021602,
0.0017822229,
0.0122215543,
0.0750250518,
0.0072774421,
-0.043810714,
-0.0224873871,
-0.0200965572,
-0.0283364709,
0.1012476757,
0.02110162,
-0.0520785227,
-0.0211546049,
-0.0384361371,
-0.0029245189,
-0.0233233608,
-0.1039885581,
0.0335978977,
0.0434565507,
0.0031844093,
-0.0415326878,
-0.0447980948,
0.0568252727,
-0.0081437174,
0.0141055128,
0.0197989605,
-0.0362900384,
-0.0023445771,
-0.0208868161,
-0.00519341,
0.0055403383,
-0.0245898329,
-0.0948663428,
-0.0316022635,
0.0128053287,
-0.0343515947,
-0.0427698009,
0.0203998834,
-0.0121817915,
-0.0370768122,
0.0332717523,
0.0333187617,
0.0332466625,
-0.0232892372,
0.0039946623,
-0.0378848091,
0.0216224156,
-0.0442541279,
-0.0345665552,
0.0606071763,
0.0033966557,
-0.0144815892,
0.0110652149,
0.0293239634,
-0.0417663418,
0.0409033969,
0.0205679033,
0.0343388841,
-0.0084570684,
-0.0318731442,
0.0074913437,
0.029289607,
0.0194229595,
0.0052154949,
-0.0109616453,
-0.0320683122,
-0.0288919099,
-0.0287007987,
0.018733535,
-0.0350355692,
-0.0125458715,
0.0272292979,
0.035427466,
-0.0104628531,
-0.0512760468,
-0.0241007563,
-0.010623632,
-0.0496451296,
0.0031797672,
-0.0495471135,
0.0054807905,
-0.0026389237,
0.016044911,
-0.0102336388,
-0.0119127138,
-0.0403418466,
0.0321628042,
0.050226666,
0.0558578894,
-0.0317312963,
0.0016393065,
-0.016487008,
0.0176129807,
-0.0775964335,
-0.0692779794,
0.0047799875,
0.0466649197,
0.0154640609,
0.0180930253,
0.0503568277,
-0.0145792346,
0.0194505006,
-0.043552395,
0.0067339269,
-0.0003489525,
-0.020502409,
0.0064414567,
0.0245489962,
-0.0107129784,
-0.0160938017,
0.0664682612,
0.0388580039,
0.0294646919,
-0.0481295884,
-0.0395133123,
-0.0284051541,
-0.0021510676,
-0.0037923784,
0.0173849724,
-0.0264666509,
0.0175262392,
-0.0795355961,
-0.0844932944,
-0.0187187735,
0.0308743306,
0.0454115644,
0.0066272565,
-0.0138897961,
0.0884905979,
-0.06303747,
-0.0445193835,
-0.0277776029,
-0.0602758192,
-0.0545253642,
0.0060310448,
-0.0083116479,
-6.223377865e-33,
-0.0374907441,
-0.026847288,
0.0378929041,
0.0167311579,
0.0133767193,
-0.011086762,
-0.0079560559,
0.045137085,
-0.0750408396,
0.0099488199,
0.0000870168,
0.0099009266,
-0.0001323504,
-0.0060095424,
0.0192122012,
0.0429291837,
0.0088913804,
0.0031894175,
-0.0026823068,
-0.0087454002,
0.0134542668,
0.0234718025,
0.0709588006,
-0.0740453303,
0.0272366554,
-0.0150500685,
0.0228662435,
-0.0157910455,
-0.036271356,
0.0616108812,
-0.0180838946,
0.0191160664,
0.0615730733,
-0.0036242674,
-0.0218044743,
0.0084650656,
-0.0377353095,
-0.0411778651,
0.0366861224,
-0.0012627181,
-0.0196625721,
-0.0527136251,
0.011251715,
-0.0101186763,
-0.0715837926,
-0.0423104502,
0.0524240993,
-0.0288713276,
0.0293040201,
0.0046383943,
-0.0618621483,
0.0033819634,
-0.0112320911,
0.0195942484,
-0.0109209977,
0.04064418,
-0.0505695269,
-0.006798761,
0.0048620068,
0.0475145839,
0.024098618,
0.0042392244,
0.0687882155,
0.015622329,
0.00899994,
0.0604563318,
0.0296192635,
-0.017486386,
-0.0054131942,
-0.0250198264,
0.0614706799,
0.0694244206,
0.0730612949,
0.0010065577,
0.0297424477,
-0.0194269847,
-0.0509109423,
-0.0041263751,
0.0137443123,
0.0012836743,
0.0243858472,
0.0019246034,
-0.0379800238,
-0.0101493206,
-0.019412851,
-0.0189901013,
0.0033374231,
-0.0583376773,
0.074203752,
-0.024836272,
0.0206489209,
-0.0556036681,
0.066339761,
-0.0352018103,
0.0318408012,
0.0257815998,
-0.0307323486,
0.0542579181,
0.0106927352,
-0.0110617708,
-0.0487705879,
-0.0254143085,
0.0111156236,
0.0604507737,
0.0647345856,
-0.0292511806,
0.0004341886,
0.0096590333,
-0.0215508137,
-0.0234365799,
-0.01052693,
-0.0210095085,
0.0536343642,
-0.0220675282,
0.0243708082,
-0.0331999883,
-0.0014075041,
-0.0285791829,
-0.015680071,
-0.0094921123,
-0.0599586293,
0.0349730626,
-0.0473043472,
-0.010604931,
-0.0286170747,
-0.032485649,
-0.0267881267,
-0.0307461955,
0.0155359963,
-0.0146252159,
-0.0061234226,
0.0060901409,
2.746e-7,
0.035822615,
0.0673743784,
-0.0368559659,
0.0024196065,
0.0045482251,
0.0070429631,
-0.0286124125,
-0.0071691982,
0.0583324805,
0.0241338257,
0.0159060881,
0.0441734456,
0.0217968654,
-0.0090643251,
-0.0444164462,
-0.01431794,
-0.0349266715,
0.0053340988,
-0.0318409838,
0.0279616024,
0.010630317,
0.0322764926,
-0.0033253052,
-0.0133636212,
-0.0337864868,
-0.0546015576,
0.0068378886,
-0.0582467243,
0.0108285947,
0.0180623308,
0.0538321733,
0.0384820923,
0.0209290963,
0.0781499743,
0.0116754249,
0.0380278081,
0.026719572,
0.0439765826,
-0.0271737352,
0.0253680199,
0.0068249102,
0.0053191474,
-0.0000435481,
-0.0638933629,
0.0811491534,
-0.0133958254,
-0.0513598248,
-0.0130335223,
-0.0300713181,
0.0012987416,
0.0129120667,
-0.0068340381,
0.018070206,
0.0071073198,
0.0333808996,
-0.0422894582,
0.0017284178,
-0.0160575807,
0.0133982431,
0.0336173736,
-0.0442392193,
-0.086405918,
-0.0437367707,
-0.0107517224,
0.0210126471,
-0.0466014892,
-0.0017614238,
2.352880972e-34,
0.0141776036,
0.004350286,
0.055511795,
0.0145605188,
0.0622136369,
-0.0005583984,
-0.0196236297,
0.0082632545,
-0.0092442911,
-0.0869148672,
-0.0052671898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11604v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11604v2 | Language Models as Zero-Shot Trajectory Generators | 2023-10-17T21:57:36 | 2024-06-17T23:57:03 | Teyun Kwon, Norman Di Palo, Edward Johns | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently shown promise as high-level
planners for robots when given access to a selection of low-level skills.
However, it is often assumed that LLMs do not possess sufficient knowledge to
be used for the low-level trajectories themselves. In this work, we address
this assumption thoroughly, and investigate if an LLM (GPT-4) can directly
predict a dense sequence of end-effector poses for manipulation tasks, when
given access to only object detection and segmentation vision models. We
designed a single, task-agnostic prompt, without any in-context examples,
motion primitives, or external trajectory optimisers. Then we studied how well
it can perform across 30 real-world language-based tasks, such as "open the
bottle cap" and "wipe the plate with the sponge", and we investigated which
design choices in this prompt are the most important. Our conclusions raise the
assumed limit of LLMs for robotics, and we reveal for the first time that LLMs
do indeed possess an understanding of low-level robot control sufficient for a
range of common tasks, and that they can additionally detect failures and then
re-plan trajectories accordingly. Videos, prompts, and code are available at:
https://www.robot-learning.uk/language-models-trajectory-generators. | [
0.0329834037,
0.0551408753,
0.0048667248,
0.030543495,
-0.0432679504,
-0.0050638951,
0.0013238329,
-0.0045794849,
-0.0046049519,
-0.0224767197,
-0.006898066,
-0.0284505785,
-0.0291673373,
0.0446819142,
0.0062184702,
-0.0841478035,
0.0484288596,
-0.0897522643,
-0.0169723555,
0.0056323074,
-0.0161297787,
-0.0161462277,
-0.0214407779,
0.0772515759,
-0.0377845168,
0.0211556442,
-0.0513375103,
0.0202288516,
0.0155528886,
-0.029917093,
-0.0080351168,
0.0411442704,
0.0876661763,
0.0451234095,
0.0000020975,
-0.0296926592,
0.0160629302,
-0.0297474619,
-0.0284814369,
-0.043769192,
0.0111275725,
-0.0427934416,
-0.0369045362,
0.0087988153,
-0.0203960724,
-0.0016161605,
0.0471886061,
-0.0043439413,
0.0685697123,
0.0758199468,
0.0199654028,
-0.0313879326,
0.0204303004,
0.0021637555,
0.0442968421,
-0.050479833,
0.0207332056,
-0.0030820349,
0.0522452816,
0.0250391457,
-0.0588822067,
-0.0033300873,
0.0349957161,
-0.0505058169,
-0.0649618581,
0.0590569526,
-0.0247615129,
-0.0469322689,
-0.0167768747,
0.0300018545,
-0.0396596156,
-0.0289832428,
0.0112724714,
-0.0087561831,
0.0213275012,
0.0063745012,
-0.0339802057,
0.0610679761,
0.0228423085,
0.0179230366,
-0.0283780694,
-0.0332018286,
0.0177378338,
-0.0137274982,
0.0005447004,
0.0760305449,
0.0126159145,
0.0109009659,
0.0146234734,
-0.0084113032,
0.0077941087,
-0.0872406289,
-0.0128510557,
0.0679611862,
-0.0192515589,
0.0235659946,
-0.0630052313,
0.0184463821,
-0.0338498019,
0.010965528,
0.0420001298,
0.0599365607,
0.0026172756,
0.0304173976,
-0.0288423542,
0.0779712796,
-0.0531351231,
0.0188686773,
-0.0355113856,
0.0029802499,
-0.0309914872,
0.0113132922,
-0.0376384333,
-0.0143338256,
-0.0505660884,
-0.0158329904,
0.0071335095,
0.0526835471,
-0.0112502286,
0.0323839635,
-0.0451161005,
0.0288782455,
-0.0007133351,
-0.0396549441,
-0.0335063078,
-0.0108098006,
-0.0126813622,
0.0167100709,
0.0101886299,
-0.0190823488,
-0.0079518473,
0.0329816975,
-0.0053883744,
-0.0177328922,
0.0194211379,
0.0974456295,
-0.0244611856,
-0.0083254147,
0.0013411146,
-0.0189539548,
-0.0044103968,
-0.0738012865,
0.0543917976,
-0.070935443,
-0.0052418318,
-0.0148180611,
0.0030475499,
-0.0471420586,
0.0295075364,
-0.0038095284,
-0.0186094809,
0.0597457886,
0.0251076501,
0.0336211659,
0.0073786159,
-0.0026114404,
-0.0062710708,
0.0546730161,
0.0381730795,
0.0517741106,
-0.0230406504,
0.011070231,
0.0260698628,
0.064194262,
-0.0769175664,
0.0124576846,
-0.0218331572,
-0.0314107612,
0.028903868,
0.0479852147,
0.023654582,
0.0071529318,
-0.0227866508,
0.015424869,
0.0140825259,
0.0286426581,
-0.0376322493,
-0.0059548491,
0.0681083426,
-0.0279234163,
-0.028713556,
-0.0269621965,
-0.0571194142,
0.0484477878,
-0.0099160168,
-0.0086045144,
-0.0451986417,
0.0069548078,
-0.0285675079,
-0.0170247406,
0.0050920751,
-0.0003231687,
0.0284726098,
-0.0099614663,
0.0591226295,
0.0050345957,
-0.0565859191,
-0.0154968202,
-0.0265995134,
-0.0390077718,
-0.0155300908,
-0.034630578,
-0.0006159818,
0.050292775,
-0.00548793,
-0.0204523765,
-0.0541887656,
0.0092370855,
0.0238999315,
0.0657059178,
-0.0057396153,
-0.0051353732,
0.0029615068,
-0.0115727847,
-0.0219105985,
0.0043469174,
0.0164715815,
0.043242842,
0.0201461092,
0.0201011971,
0.0001443392,
0.0034380583,
0.0003296858,
0.0397816263,
-0.0031637154,
-0.0018818156,
-0.0015583024,
0.0038959628,
0.037137717,
-0.0015501593,
-0.0202528145,
-0.0033674554,
0.059423022,
-0.0268719401,
0.0239421949,
0.0172475819,
-0.0407716185,
-0.0091499435,
0.0397955179,
-0.0198148154,
-0.033287026,
0.0515974946,
-0.035295058,
-0.0565271676,
0.0262235887,
-0.0128079494,
0.0058642402,
0.0195223261,
0.0036105567,
0.0067628836,
-0.0516039431,
-0.0118575087,
0.0277232919,
0.0096875075,
0.0067283153,
0.0453775637,
0.0464266278,
-0.0022155687,
-0.045677267,
-0.0446952209,
0.0428408161,
0.0034234128,
0.0060295598,
0.0445197746,
0.0354276001,
-0.028012868,
-0.0361921415,
-0.0813325047,
-0.025658546,
-0.0140368594,
-0.0486930422,
0.0076800892,
-0.0523079075,
-0.0109017184,
-0.0001585482,
0.022772206,
0.0503222123,
-0.0123820631,
0.0040626847,
0.0069804396,
0.0245802943,
-0.0667057931,
-0.028194651,
0.012891897,
-0.0354492702,
-0.0168856196,
0.0220804811,
-0.0138206528,
-0.0362688936,
0.0471694097,
-0.0154564129,
0.0524425246,
-0.0222382788,
-0.0291776937,
0.0431529023,
-0.0497930162,
0.0204028897,
0.0778603852,
-0.04803285,
-0.0016731335,
0.0866657868,
-0.0330797695,
-0.0255510956,
0.0211674012,
-0.0336352997,
-0.0526367836,
-0.055591505,
-0.0310389847,
-0.0013082412,
0.054616943,
-0.0087416945,
0.0169121455,
-0.0803139284,
-0.0078573739,
-0.0261635799,
-0.0271441564,
-0.0257715564,
0.0277809538,
-0.072090894,
0.0378573537,
-0.0283680465,
-0.0562047735,
0.042621769,
-0.019808013,
-0.0256764852,
0.0868771821,
-0.0205305461,
-0.0003102515,
0.0864740834,
0.0522107407,
0.01658375,
0.0140929585,
-0.0058094054,
-0.0253952648,
0.029992383,
-0.0187351573,
0.0093840538,
0.0404896475,
-0.127687782,
0.0124737294,
-0.0005941954,
-0.0349604376,
-0.0331882723,
0.0278281141,
-0.0416769311,
0.0456753969,
-0.0481135137,
-0.0705584586,
-0.022498697,
-0.0131237525,
0.0409639664,
0.0732574686,
-0.0245877113,
0.0068404861,
-0.0332282409,
-0.0368268229,
0.0541419089,
0.023956066,
-0.0675021037,
-0.0485305116,
0.0099217724,
0.0300003439,
0.0360403135,
-0.0141436653,
-0.0559914485,
0.0339629613,
0.0106846411,
0.0162654929,
-0.004052564,
0.0526578575,
0.0645389557,
-0.0546668954,
-0.059936963,
0.0891944915,
0.0009436584,
0.0042262706,
0.0038966984,
0.0083374595,
0.0120223407,
0.0415094569,
0.0098576769,
-0.0342332684,
-0.0509849936,
0.0113851875,
0.0066216928,
0.0067012031,
-0.034811385,
-0.0066806534,
-0.1117393076,
0.0620449409,
0.0337471999,
-0.0917458609,
-0.0540714189,
0.0109676784,
0.0074069612,
-0.0080254097,
-0.0293810982,
0.0190288443,
0.0147686554,
-0.012166935,
0.0151443733,
-0.0322189853,
-0.0348323435,
0.0112699699,
0.0127893584,
0.0261602104,
0.0659311265,
0.0037944929,
-0.0370975584,
0.0159187932,
0.0433763154,
0.000975825,
0.0320772268,
-0.0009855242,
-0.0353401452,
-0.0055209268,
-0.0188504849,
0.0324504003,
0.0580178164,
-0.0440908596,
-0.0800453797,
-0.0176036712,
0.0855363086,
-0.032822296,
-0.0363298804,
-0.039642375,
-0.0533700027,
0.002394398,
0.0524715148,
-0.0155557794,
-0.0409788564,
-0.0394460671,
-0.0487850048,
-0.0554998331,
0.0092315935,
-0.0499928109,
-0.0317325182,
0.0040797144,
-0.0254726689,
-0.0332245752,
-0.0155487694,
0.0888783485,
0.0301986393,
-0.000099902,
-0.0276980698,
-0.0112396525,
0.0198704433,
-0.029105477,
0.0070029274,
-0.0298975762,
0.0231614448,
-0.0774043351,
-0.0296456274,
0.0053675706,
-0.0075200293,
-0.018080283,
0.0038021614,
-0.0400096439,
-0.0828041062,
0.0177443717,
0.077956602,
0.0246668104,
0.0111131109,
0.0114053935,
-0.0248072445,
0.0257846992,
0.0322025418,
0.0488154925,
0.059805844,
-0.018555522,
0.0302207004,
0.0009778118,
0.0336556546,
-0.0350851268,
0.0110627078,
0.0173547436,
0.0103570381,
-0.0502306409,
-0.0236319937,
0.026566254,
-0.0224210601,
0.0562391058,
-0.0115625309,
-0.0081200646,
-0.0325280726,
-0.0183776002,
-0.0132512543,
-0.0237965304,
-0.0620392263,
0.0130897015,
0.0478806198,
0.0064667817,
0.0500346012,
-0.012491486,
0.0039207703,
0.0177530237,
-0.0113270106,
-0.0061540101,
0.042617552,
0.0120995101,
0.0546625406,
0.0277102124,
0.0190307163,
0.0144702559,
-0.034346167,
0.0413511358,
0.0210968852,
0.0566621125,
0.0213716235,
0.0111517133,
-0.0069765858,
0.001097724,
-0.079856135,
-0.1105956137,
-0.0080729071,
0.0523635522,
0.0832958445,
-0.0371964052,
0.0057783308,
-0.1034240723,
0.0053876406,
-0.0261042584,
0.0238012914,
0.0478825346,
-0.0563697219,
0.0566522963,
0.0336096101,
0.0113868862,
-0.0306760985,
0.0683622062,
0.0130599076,
0.0889180005,
0.0184020009,
0.0068151518,
-0.0438300334,
-0.0181542486,
0.0161547977,
-0.0132715227,
0.0030627057,
0.0107926708,
-0.0419647284,
-0.0557382964,
-0.0294269361,
0.031620387,
-0.0050088973,
-0.0193572715,
0.0569186322,
0.0069019566,
-0.0317915007,
-0.0204674173,
-0.0133031886,
-0.0137303211,
0.0215340275,
-0.0054140417,
-0.0555087738,
-5.670270304e-33,
-0.0357744433,
-0.054098323,
0.0378652215,
-0.0249600951,
0.0139488326,
-0.0055840798,
-0.0460304022,
0.0252815764,
-0.0182411112,
0.0353973061,
0.0144676995,
-0.0098469043,
-0.0008144926,
0.0075288243,
0.0476358645,
-0.0042769313,
0.014522085,
-0.0219438504,
-0.0435824506,
-0.0036134569,
0.0573308133,
-0.0000519158,
0.0207741633,
0.0018100886,
-0.0094512105,
-0.0149102081,
-0.0418616571,
0.0556930155,
0.0107133221,
0.0205474272,
0.0052404106,
0.0036401767,
0.0120895375,
-0.0069227363,
-0.0370502062,
0.0474909693,
-0.01168078,
-0.0458336584,
-0.0101810563,
0.0093474556,
-0.0543203913,
-0.0328691863,
0.0321645252,
0.0076812473,
-0.0530008599,
0.0371659473,
0.0020625216,
-0.007457871,
0.0169495139,
0.0398758352,
-0.0267773736,
-0.004035932,
-0.0057171974,
-0.0752361342,
0.0414603539,
0.0406551994,
0.0187396444,
-0.0245101713,
-0.012497413,
0.01238079,
-0.0172697324,
0.00062411,
0.0789203793,
0.0069627119,
0.0345556214,
0.0553295128,
0.0260273274,
-0.0331719592,
0.0052101202,
0.0187913459,
0.0170630068,
0.0805398673,
-0.000951496,
0.0092158346,
0.0084818946,
0.0339650884,
-0.0300796106,
0.0279960893,
-0.0438619927,
0.0924450979,
-0.0007270139,
0.0241296235,
-0.0187083185,
-0.0154404184,
-0.0228730496,
-0.0116364704,
0.005772661,
-0.0004231879,
0.0360600688,
0.0362809673,
0.0261429604,
-0.0457305908,
0.048553098,
-0.0041723698,
-0.0084405662,
0.0170705654,
-0.0417961292,
0.0561124198,
0.0147817554,
0.0088137416,
-0.0480774976,
-0.0304745417,
0.0256227627,
-0.0346847326,
0.0200622063,
0.0349526592,
-0.034845043,
0.0825682357,
-0.030281961,
-0.014201968,
-0.0715890154,
-0.0079344027,
0.0282629523,
0.0004954385,
0.0749962628,
0.0139025757,
-0.0261935107,
0.0508960895,
-0.0181065742,
-0.0449287035,
-0.0049858945,
0.0047384943,
-0.0398052372,
0.0146727236,
-0.0320531391,
-0.0151634123,
-0.0109586967,
0.0370469242,
0.0344420522,
-0.0323755629,
0.0116664814,
0.0423168577,
2.814e-7,
0.0279066544,
0.0224153325,
-0.0047669266,
0.0486516766,
0.0332840569,
0.0654454902,
-0.0462801196,
0.0245728958,
-0.0321251974,
-0.0090322383,
-0.01149756,
0.0306110643,
0.0152902296,
-0.0006511103,
-0.0769983381,
0.0539066941,
0.0377686583,
-0.0406021513,
-0.06166647,
-0.0172320344,
0.0289860424,
0.0756671876,
-0.0023158039,
-0.000397347,
0.0103100138,
-0.0267211981,
0.0471486002,
-0.0668607578,
0.0223947372,
-0.0188563727,
-0.0383940898,
0.0236803368,
-0.0275054667,
0.0057941121,
-0.0157335848,
-0.0123632103,
-0.0101687638,
0.0776077136,
-0.0427642986,
-0.0023365405,
0.0021743956,
0.0142699182,
-0.0099517042,
-0.0368618257,
0.0575430468,
-0.0408852175,
0.0513207726,
0.0074687432,
0.0109001882,
0.0099125123,
-0.0080624502,
0.0094753578,
-0.0155383153,
-0.0086045237,
-0.0062156571,
0.0063775773,
0.0031386886,
-0.0262007453,
-0.0016620937,
0.0027279467,
-0.058648482,
-0.019250866,
-0.0259069335,
-0.0040786592,
-0.0029962766,
-0.020400444,
-0.0370133631,
2.317062833e-34,
-0.0100039802,
-0.0016540731,
0.0296216104,
0.0291387625,
0.0161549933,
0.0111142546,
0.0005479976,
0.0490657501,
0.0223126169,
-0.0163706318,
-0.0608769879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11593v1 | Automated Evaluation of Personalized Text Generation using Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T21:35:06 | 2023-10-17T21:35:06 | Yaqing Wang, Jiepu Jiang, Mingyang Zhang, Cheng Li, Yi Liang, Qiaozhu Mei, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Personalized text generation presents a specialized mechanism for delivering
content that is specific to a user's personal context. While the research
progress in this area has been rapid, evaluation still presents a challenge.
Traditional automated metrics such as BLEU and ROUGE primarily measure lexical
similarity to human-written references, and are not able to distinguish
personalization from other subtle semantic aspects, thus falling short of
capturing the nuances of personalized generated content quality. On the other
hand, human judgments are costly to obtain, especially in the realm of
personalized evaluation. Inspired by these challenges, we explore the use of
large language models (LLMs) for evaluating personalized text generation, and
examine their ability to understand nuanced user context. We present AuPEL, a
novel evaluation method that distills three major semantic aspects of the
generated text: personalization, quality and relevance, and automatically
measures these aspects. To validate the effectiveness of AuPEL, we design
carefully controlled experiments and compare the accuracy of the evaluation
judgments made by LLMs versus that of judgements made by human annotators, and
conduct rigorous analyses of the consistency and sensitivity of the proposed
metric. We find that, compared to existing evaluation metrics, AuPEL not only
distinguishes and ranks models based on their personalization abilities more
accurately, but also presents commendable consistency and efficiency for this
task. Our work suggests that using LLMs as the evaluators of personalized text
generation is superior to traditional text similarity metrics, even though
interesting new challenges still remain. | [
0.0628252551,
0.032494355,
-0.0038171019,
-0.0010170931,
-0.0360063948,
-0.0036182511,
0.0536131859,
0.011151907,
0.0250798706,
-0.0465650149,
-0.0311420336,
-0.0422044471,
-0.0087366626,
0.0146848476,
0.0011540873,
-0.0570794642,
-0.0150569966,
0.0040435521,
0.0288699511,
0.0195957515,
0.0256110132,
0.0206386745,
0.0387885645,
0.0690772235,
0.0093837781,
-0.0236052796,
0.0341738686,
0.0388983116,
0.0380048789,
-0.0250511896,
-0.0014892184,
0.0659550279,
-0.0208393149,
0.0231959969,
0.0000019013,
-0.0356761776,
0.0081596794,
-0.0036484064,
0.041442588,
0.0551334918,
0.1038431674,
0.0593304597,
-0.0225765985,
0.0150984609,
-0.0324369296,
0.0252456218,
0.0287464373,
0.0229190439,
0.0801283196,
0.0526845194,
-0.0021082833,
-0.0024360588,
-0.0209440589,
-0.0286664348,
0.031074401,
-0.0115571907,
-0.0148593746,
0.0273774881,
0.0034457317,
0.0175502915,
0.0300002452,
0.0165695678,
0.0039433246,
-0.0223117005,
0.0680054054,
0.038074147,
-0.0012738925,
-0.0036106205,
0.0244535599,
0.0497377962,
0.0033904149,
-0.0224465206,
0.0134820798,
-0.0149126174,
0.0170126855,
0.0096241245,
-0.0378526859,
0.0357255563,
0.0031677375,
0.0138007523,
0.0054531926,
0.0434865914,
0.0278700441,
0.0493186936,
0.0235027708,
0.038221959,
0.0350779817,
-0.0232338421,
-0.0264250357,
0.0196840297,
0.0032704719,
-0.0856908858,
0.009164867,
0.0194160454,
-0.0078646382,
-0.0059367204,
-0.0653056875,
-0.0250534825,
0.0272231624,
-0.0465851277,
0.0651850849,
0.0072073177,
0.0229506753,
0.0118681174,
-0.0328895301,
0.0448617823,
-0.007679129,
-0.0302329883,
-0.0439286567,
0.0362279415,
-0.0297261532,
-0.0050949249,
-0.0121193035,
0.028982278,
-0.0322045088,
-0.0432831571,
-0.0520170294,
0.0397974625,
-0.0015091704,
0.0150748705,
0.0125853159,
0.0358377881,
-0.0276989434,
0.0002612758,
-0.0278667007,
-0.0402010977,
-0.0551977307,
-0.0093227467,
0.0244145673,
0.0008246849,
0.0380937196,
0.0427912325,
0.0197985917,
-0.0218659248,
-0.0185674094,
0.0458014868,
-0.0036814834,
-0.0373448394,
-0.0251758322,
-0.0667707846,
-0.0133475857,
-0.0400731564,
-0.0353992246,
-0.0863898918,
-0.0008203334,
0.0274634305,
0.0080277948,
-0.0551444776,
0.0113323769,
0.0408092514,
-0.0179179795,
-0.0031014662,
-0.0067883171,
0.0187552087,
0.0348474085,
0.0201818887,
0.0188395996,
0.005597929,
0.0364915244,
0.1100088581,
0.0429814085,
0.0251071174,
0.0107086198,
0.0161262061,
-0.0230203625,
0.0179915186,
-0.0311115533,
-0.0221897233,
-0.0215820502,
0.0346329659,
0.0049287346,
0.0722400025,
-0.0221151728,
0.0208149999,
0.1005595997,
0.0094099687,
0.0164578632,
0.0460183956,
0.0852302089,
0.0393000357,
0.0114413388,
0.0112137115,
0.0056110732,
0.0219885129,
-0.0282078758,
0.0001182049,
0.0873309374,
0.0278317221,
-0.0037443836,
-0.0440217331,
-0.0135419043,
-0.0088703642,
0.0185390022,
-0.0342565551,
-0.0032581883,
0.0123168072,
-0.0370598771,
0.0163207985,
0.0121448021,
-0.092788212,
0.0646525621,
-0.0145337358,
0.0522699468,
0.1077740267,
0.054722771,
0.0321886018,
0.024438072,
-0.006206797,
-0.0252630506,
0.0560405925,
0.0294698495,
-0.0041407743,
-0.0424241163,
-0.0555040129,
-0.015487304,
-0.0401904359,
-0.0085077137,
0.0088225743,
0.0134428274,
0.0187951569,
0.0614939407,
-0.0271754023,
-0.0659872368,
0.0181568041,
-0.034976881,
-0.0388016179,
0.0425702035,
-0.0000063933,
0.0061823078,
0.0189509802,
-0.0197472759,
0.0368582308,
-0.0100454884,
-0.0397920199,
-0.0120261312,
0.0049487334,
-0.0174049977,
0.0236934368,
-0.0013867099,
-0.0516130328,
0.0402696691,
0.0071751513,
0.0042531518,
-0.0397544503,
0.0116605898,
-0.0593221784,
0.0084759649,
-0.0489665568,
0.0175692309,
0.0065462766,
0.0042565749,
-0.0425386168,
0.075171575,
0.0060142782,
0.0046697641,
0.028236568,
0.0179193709,
0.0055070599,
-0.0254709255,
-0.0495035015,
-0.0334737338,
0.018601099,
0.0182662178,
0.0661076456,
0.0078921635,
-0.0315854363,
-0.0532443821,
-0.0823191702,
0.0041792584,
-0.009625908,
0.0070761628,
0.0415182523,
0.0246429667,
0.0015893349,
0.0041530454,
-0.0694122463,
-0.0338652022,
0.0115355551,
0.0224904232,
0.0411926471,
0.002235529,
0.0184549689,
-0.0417134091,
0.0033155817,
0.0233540498,
0.0533206463,
0.0647675693,
0.0524387211,
-0.0649007633,
0.0170602575,
-0.0616916083,
-0.0505854748,
0.0371025838,
-0.038837228,
0.0070560318,
0.0032374079,
0.0576274134,
0.0339427143,
0.0462615266,
0.0376265235,
0.0546601415,
0.0166506991,
-0.0210066587,
-0.0295914877,
-0.0477308705,
0.0098080682,
0.0214791391,
-0.0725253299,
0.039371606,
0.0271437634,
0.0245184153,
0.0075380472,
-0.0775176138,
0.0561223067,
-0.030009849,
-0.0074851471,
-0.0295939185,
-0.0052921949,
-0.0036701264,
0.0221746676,
-0.0006589054,
-0.0507067814,
0.0575528778,
-0.0412279293,
0.0415107943,
0.0014292067,
-0.0152165163,
-0.0321284533,
0.0189874135,
0.0005869734,
0.0477023609,
-0.0227321498,
0.0230258387,
-0.0182975158,
0.0227731485,
0.03526292,
-0.0411952101,
0.011901794,
-0.0335534997,
-0.0295897201,
0.0181242507,
-0.0380511619,
-0.0391679704,
-0.0628823936,
-0.0093345363,
-0.0236057956,
0.0668988004,
-0.0263638608,
-0.0203261841,
0.0038972192,
0.0269858763,
0.006023692,
-0.0442871451,
-0.0287128277,
-0.0120645016,
0.0482732952,
0.0408639684,
-0.0281558651,
0.0102557456,
-0.0187798291,
-0.0226022359,
0.0260511618,
0.0025609455,
0.0233393013,
-0.0257439632,
-0.0133826509,
0.0120561784,
-0.0450700484,
-0.0398922637,
0.029552998,
0.056293603,
-0.0377512798,
-0.0326906741,
0.1034716293,
0.0416053049,
-0.0371142663,
-0.0042724977,
0.0022605746,
0.0374437124,
-0.0098775392,
0.0191117618,
-0.051494997,
-0.0140864002,
-0.0184538979,
0.0349239521,
-0.0294547901,
-0.0132662971,
-0.0120645901,
-0.1036920696,
0.0075124945,
0.0285975952,
-0.0258898679,
0.0108775282,
-0.0240806509,
-0.0132227493,
-0.0113173733,
-0.0392355993,
-0.0058926153,
-0.019578224,
0.0224186759,
0.0016337879,
-0.0260164123,
-0.0631379113,
-0.0275486298,
-0.0208259318,
0.0366090871,
0.0692547783,
0.0577434637,
0.0188566353,
-0.053974174,
-0.0245025344,
-0.0123948297,
0.0183446873,
0.004403586,
0.036141187,
-0.0022579718,
0.0138557367,
-0.0720660985,
0.0246503018,
0.0183613822,
-0.0239507537,
0.0041930224,
0.0244024359,
0.0001367845,
-0.0125652524,
-0.0435987897,
0.027988812,
0.0222783331,
0.0853574127,
0.0391789451,
-0.0961023122,
-0.0262766052,
-0.0334049985,
0.0166447833,
-0.0669093505,
-0.0282115806,
-0.0015394301,
-0.0282828826,
-0.0274848118,
-0.1235412881,
-0.0454373695,
-0.0260204542,
-0.0095564183,
0.0205203947,
-0.0036220874,
-0.0278870109,
-0.0114678787,
-0.0225839373,
0.0084819989,
-0.0276874416,
0.0225483496,
-0.0682203919,
-0.027671786,
0.0000084929,
-0.0857873857,
-0.0077983164,
0.0164468493,
-0.0547393933,
-0.0324134789,
-0.02685076,
0.0203567911,
0.0142468354,
0.0115524968,
-0.0217887517,
-0.1049198583,
0.0468495004,
0.0466924645,
-0.0058043459,
-0.0026768029,
-0.0251457579,
0.0218545403,
0.0079193423,
0.0125423819,
-0.039292939,
0.0255221538,
-0.0046107564,
0.0190083236,
0.0289286934,
-0.0767445788,
0.0111456094,
0.042459622,
-0.0110233305,
-0.0643649101,
0.0098255994,
-0.0047210576,
-0.0382203385,
-0.0207570102,
-0.0484738946,
-0.0331921466,
-0.0181465484,
0.028254047,
0.0268874131,
-0.0265470222,
0.0105489222,
-0.0221099984,
0.0420151949,
-0.0485462472,
-0.0198483691,
-0.0251530875,
0.0402970128,
0.0039625731,
0.0010272207,
-0.0456165634,
0.0120772868,
-0.0284656435,
0.023514064,
-0.0298777763,
0.0421298668,
0.0031148102,
-0.0176177882,
0.0246652029,
0.0668959618,
-0.035435155,
0.0153829195,
-0.0493954159,
0.0060615833,
0.0347963832,
-0.0093091233,
0.0601332486,
-0.0298982114,
-0.0044920868,
-0.0232030116,
0.0404116064,
0.02124382,
-0.0371720642,
-0.0487883836,
-0.0099881608,
-0.0232494306,
-0.0054726885,
0.0745786354,
0.0182922985,
-0.0197362211,
-0.0038485699,
-0.0313270651,
-0.0466404669,
-0.0029894758,
-0.0084587345,
0.0318530835,
-0.0024031424,
-0.0178697426,
-0.0754051283,
-0.0223476738,
0.0484285764,
0.0208923519,
0.007549244,
0.0139555978,
0.0273447689,
0.0463904627,
-0.040520668,
0.010982926,
-0.0748892576,
-0.0012784455,
-0.0397892855,
0.0215274747,
-0.0211512689,
-5.941118161e-33,
-0.026317358,
-0.0699171349,
-0.0265280809,
-0.0076931999,
-0.0079121524,
-0.020013541,
-0.0443005487,
0.0073341434,
0.0659208745,
0.0042119273,
0.0136940135,
-0.0605467372,
-0.0006575426,
0.0381072015,
-0.0065143406,
0.0102353813,
0.0672563836,
0.0403202698,
-0.0829550922,
0.0639079735,
0.0534822419,
-0.0203285217,
-0.0144207096,
-0.0689981803,
0.0312149879,
-0.0569112673,
-0.0297415219,
-0.036065083,
0.0243104976,
0.0803687721,
-0.0146150934,
0.0280853882,
0.0195612013,
0.006644994,
-0.0064560398,
0.0261852257,
-0.0197264273,
-0.0295477733,
0.0153343873,
-0.0401009656,
-0.0303201582,
-0.0921942219,
0.0387378521,
-0.009837348,
-0.0704347938,
0.022810638,
0.0704925433,
-0.0369874276,
-0.0111241154,
-0.0607195348,
-0.0515263416,
0.033378955,
-0.0004079592,
-0.0053878557,
-0.0143047655,
0.0344635434,
-0.0279078782,
0.0424925126,
-0.0367570594,
0.052157823,
-0.0046545914,
0.003191289,
0.0492762513,
0.0067977845,
0.0025239363,
0.0429058187,
-0.0136418585,
0.0101345181,
-0.0194414742,
-0.0084386086,
-0.0025626242,
0.0316091627,
0.0593655966,
0.1082395837,
-0.0049636276,
-0.0200073365,
-0.0202863216,
0.0866777077,
-0.0104118465,
-0.0365687013,
0.074381955,
-0.0121215396,
-0.0181048177,
0.0102939056,
-0.0478321612,
-0.0233355314,
-0.0503558069,
-0.0414349213,
0.0238734875,
0.0144708073,
-0.0669369325,
-0.0135717262,
-0.0062191118,
-0.0153819472,
-0.0094214948,
0.0150237177,
-0.0728164092,
0.0225107949,
-0.00972954,
-0.0097837597,
-0.0214324053,
0.0096907811,
0.0392271057,
-0.0249000639,
0.0009957305,
0.0058114273,
0.0222797804,
0.0129422173,
-0.0489492528,
0.0092703458,
-0.0188948698,
0.0028754384,
-0.0141602447,
-0.0394847728,
0.0278160535,
-0.0257159378,
-0.0524091534,
0.041203469,
0.0146357538,
0.0429204218,
-0.0091688661,
-0.0657723695,
0.0392134674,
-0.0064269975,
-0.0322569199,
0.0197480973,
-0.0324045233,
0.0203073211,
0.0315947868,
-0.0259773489,
-0.019554954,
-0.0180659443,
2.544e-7,
0.004362727,
0.0517760925,
-0.016959982,
0.008148035,
0.0035350218,
0.0393769182,
0.0108147841,
0.0292645749,
0.0030661814,
0.0325200818,
0.0036638053,
0.0201449562,
0.0573142059,
0.0171217825,
-0.0434921086,
0.0275806971,
-0.0954826847,
0.0228351057,
-0.0464987047,
-0.0055392273,
0.061994303,
0.015937753,
0.037724819,
0.0006375875,
0.0187106971,
-0.0269628167,
0.0879708305,
-0.0404876769,
-0.0377338529,
0.0202788003,
0.0585971028,
0.0061178966,
-0.0207619928,
-0.0205196179,
-0.0161561724,
-0.0123756174,
0.0492575467,
0.0647199005,
0.0307081454,
0.0015477012,
0.0202086437,
-0.0036362992,
0.0309643485,
-0.0594112128,
0.0475792475,
0.0166018158,
-0.0107190367,
-0.0343156122,
-0.018930804,
-0.0117672281,
0.0409913771,
-0.0458478592,
-0.0226569213,
0.0172754433,
-0.002879269,
0.0126522454,
-0.0179180969,
-0.0061128787,
-0.0410591699,
-0.002050308,
-0.0292762443,
-0.0299705435,
-0.0779909566,
0.0132321957,
0.0006047151,
-0.0608680807,
0.0344419405,
2.152190566e-34,
0.0192235298,
-0.0072497274,
-0.0009982457,
-0.0553092062,
0.0452213846,
0.0363268219,
-0.0083423741,
0.0154785402,
0.0270275585,
-0.0702792108,
0.0122247236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13015v1 | Audio-AdapterFusion: A Task-ID-free Approach for Efficient and Non-Destructive Multi-task Speech Recognition | 2023-10-17T21:21:40 | 2023-10-17T21:21:40 | Hillary Ngai, Rohan Agrawal, Neeraj Gaur, Ronny Huang, Parisa Haghani, Pedro Moreno Mengibar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, eess.AS | Adapters are an efficient, composable alternative to full fine-tuning of
pre-trained models and help scale the deployment of large ASR models to many
tasks. In practice, a task ID is commonly prepended to the input during
inference to route to single-task adapters for the specified task. However, one
major limitation of this approach is that the task ID may not be known during
inference, rendering it unsuitable for most multi-task settings. To address
this, we propose three novel task-ID-free methods to combine single-task
adapters in multi-task ASR and investigate two learning algorithms for
training. We evaluate our methods on 10 test sets from 4 diverse ASR tasks and
show that our methods are non-destructive and parameter-efficient. While only
updating 17% of the model parameters, our methods can achieve an 8% mean WER
improvement relative to full fine-tuning and are on-par with task-ID adapter
routing. | [
-0.0288410261,
-0.0138383126,
0.0227813274,
0.007989211,
-0.0174990706,
-0.0102468049,
0.0710916445,
-0.053341642,
0.0067825699,
-0.011476581,
-0.0749852359,
-0.021441102,
0.0217343178,
-0.0004102011,
0.0328103602,
0.0029599029,
0.0100027379,
-0.0567050204,
-0.0012454535,
-0.000572069,
-0.0111667439,
0.0202426519,
-0.0395520963,
0.061050348,
-0.0181223359,
0.027319137,
-0.0132303946,
0.0249379165,
0.0531609878,
0.0126639027,
0.0023688294,
0.0136942854,
0.032792449,
0.0272072051,
0.0000019126,
-0.0109316912,
-0.0313702263,
0.0093408022,
-0.05770557,
-0.0276196096,
0.0031601046,
0.0530403256,
-0.0280537233,
0.0543317683,
0.0050338064,
-0.0022822139,
0.0617179945,
0.073471345,
0.0140608037,
0.0272161104,
-0.0112214684,
-0.0114844413,
0.0071872924,
-0.0300466195,
-0.0227017626,
-0.0322459415,
-0.0044151233,
-0.0475216322,
-0.0162585545,
-0.0059470898,
0.0039657545,
0.04258186,
0.0328886993,
-0.0034360923,
0.0367968455,
-0.0064279386,
-0.0343717709,
-0.0350292586,
-0.0600767285,
0.0477344282,
-0.0277170558,
-0.0303502027,
0.0156702567,
0.0040252227,
-0.0482974239,
-0.0079331594,
-0.0153216524,
-0.0099194832,
-0.0170934591,
0.0013441279,
-0.0062397909,
0.0193973146,
0.0326423049,
-0.0262728371,
-0.0340292826,
-0.0139254881,
-0.0150630176,
-0.0005474442,
0.0481819101,
0.0099493908,
-0.0225244053,
-0.0284853969,
0.0427543074,
-0.0129632568,
-0.0325946212,
-0.04276729,
-0.0521697924,
-0.0796431974,
-0.0393887907,
-0.0385778435,
0.0743187815,
0.0561299101,
-0.0548614301,
0.035841953,
-0.042220585,
0.003295986,
0.0352097154,
-0.0008296029,
-0.0092403861,
0.0030045495,
-0.0392948091,
0.0217998009,
-0.0646227971,
0.0414157137,
-0.063958317,
-0.0547110103,
-0.0152576575,
0.029905349,
-0.0404273979,
-0.0389969796,
0.0828828365,
0.0069078663,
-0.071244508,
0.0025511871,
0.0568784736,
0.0524976067,
0.0221505892,
0.0659318119,
-0.0015952971,
-0.0399594605,
-0.0215560608,
0.0230283588,
0.042995356,
-0.00956601,
0.0112213939,
0.0496605895,
-0.0164028611,
-0.0116672562,
-0.0409665294,
0.0043447148,
0.0029149044,
-0.0623803027,
-0.000038105,
-0.0176382307,
0.0466834605,
-0.0155789433,
0.0115057379,
-0.0088152746,
0.0029376005,
-0.0393085852,
0.0192814078,
0.0831527486,
0.0330328867,
0.0067636031,
0.0270026792,
-0.0059083207,
-0.0302768145,
0.0738531277,
0.0535964891,
-0.0054550674,
-0.015794022,
-0.048929885,
-0.0429895781,
0.0307359975,
-0.0246170443,
-0.0080046039,
0.0372183695,
-0.0218586214,
0.0451843329,
-0.0282669831,
0.0306300167,
0.0188672543,
-0.0220233854,
0.0021139032,
0.045056276,
-0.0133144977,
0.0373958386,
-0.000684263,
0.0404053964,
0.0135920942,
-0.0178488381,
-0.0130710844,
-0.0473556854,
0.0369212143,
0.0051971693,
-0.0044817701,
0.03900484,
0.0589886159,
-0.0330453552,
-0.018917596,
0.0196761601,
-0.0410213247,
0.0021320665,
0.0671289265,
0.0699272677,
-0.0049332068,
-0.0623754896,
0.0064150984,
0.0069941957,
-0.0629445687,
-0.0106187239,
-0.0399795398,
-0.0340114757,
0.0212998539,
-0.0039385781,
-0.045082435,
-0.068090044,
-0.0200826079,
0.0589130744,
0.0063253995,
-0.0142127108,
0.007972193,
0.0906693414,
-0.0446076989,
-0.0494583473,
0.0345075466,
-0.0119047575,
0.0542539023,
-0.009594935,
-0.0026227226,
0.0007585648,
-0.0314910933,
0.0088669825,
-0.0306382254,
-0.0240398757,
-0.0216060635,
0.063459374,
0.0339810289,
0.0430160277,
0.005764293,
-0.0346715264,
-0.0240986943,
0.0475785173,
-0.0318371467,
0.0254056137,
0.0677354559,
-0.0546039604,
0.0272791889,
0.0165815335,
0.0195930861,
0.03326343,
0.0453067347,
0.0149737913,
-0.0589672215,
0.0075701177,
-0.0017357992,
0.0518362746,
0.0052060741,
0.0431476608,
0.0397305042,
-0.0092170853,
0.0370907299,
-0.0269572381,
0.0580797382,
-0.0219622124,
-0.0090054292,
-0.0191325042,
-0.0076608257,
-0.0659064054,
-0.0048418618,
-0.0067721577,
-0.0182231497,
-0.0071884254,
-0.0215409677,
-0.0287800543,
0.0199992415,
-0.0320615806,
-0.087482512,
-0.0028976682,
-0.0312453862,
0.0185163263,
-0.0269053746,
0.0282127857,
0.0258237403,
-0.0208662041,
0.009165056,
-0.0065636132,
-0.0455417968,
-0.0001920419,
-0.100200735,
-0.0020572268,
-0.0096563408,
0.0063368701,
0.0117206182,
0.0080128163,
-0.0246763341,
-0.0035715583,
-0.0520282649,
-0.0484205969,
-0.0100926664,
0.0455175824,
0.0228821896,
-0.0281255394,
0.0010687673,
-0.0081527345,
0.024159167,
0.0551866442,
0.0535711348,
-0.0234854724,
-0.0067619001,
0.0289981943,
-0.0105056493,
-0.0391097851,
0.0244420469,
0.0281016659,
0.0156671312,
-0.0221526902,
0.0297037642,
-0.0145491827,
0.0290847681,
0.000323111,
0.0006060769,
-0.0283309519,
-0.0257003922,
-0.0145225218,
-0.0504195504,
-0.0053816219,
-0.0324988514,
-0.0279902741,
-0.03545947,
-0.0147886099,
-0.0170006976,
0.0162790529,
-0.0355456769,
-0.0455905385,
-0.070111379,
-0.0611488037,
0.008978609,
0.0155647127,
-0.0071929856,
0.0060280063,
0.0512250401,
-0.025730513,
-0.0283946116,
0.0577454418,
0.0181736499,
-0.0385016799,
0.0725843012,
-0.0258878414,
0.0084178355,
-0.0323300362,
-0.0637414753,
-0.0078587877,
0.0012232404,
-0.0099641588,
0.0425345041,
-0.0079380348,
-0.053587012,
-0.0591422394,
0.057578519,
0.0244158078,
0.054865811,
-0.0030146821,
0.0027291633,
-0.0309401304,
0.0153634073,
0.0492997542,
0.0450903624,
-0.0476653315,
0.0040004281,
0.0276759416,
0.0114841545,
0.1083089039,
-0.0194848534,
-0.0538947955,
-0.0158798993,
0.0685389787,
-0.014411198,
-0.0037561164,
0.0218894798,
0.0636620596,
-0.0535400584,
0.0342247114,
0.087674804,
-0.0090802433,
-0.0222853851,
-0.0172430351,
0.0167215765,
0.0244690254,
0.0208177883,
-0.0369541682,
-0.067857407,
-0.036822252,
0.0723381639,
0.0336880349,
0.0285602435,
0.0213632118,
0.0036676389,
-0.0420039482,
0.0362000763,
0.0353118442,
-0.0381282829,
-0.0014600753,
-0.0478383042,
0.0018153002,
-0.0533163436,
0.0334751457,
-0.000778562,
-0.0154264895,
-0.0363514051,
0.0404467694,
0.0044600829,
-0.0401835516,
-0.028198082,
-0.0464653894,
0.0570711084,
0.0248909742,
0.0103523638,
0.0056617414,
-0.0003778055,
0.0095689679,
0.0022895078,
0.0046586306,
-0.0213477872,
0.0134226121,
0.0103472928,
-0.0116621414,
0.0264158137,
0.0230573341,
-0.0267441124,
0.0131469769,
0.0322766788,
0.0550366156,
-0.0412698388,
0.0188613683,
0.0297090076,
-0.0235524271,
0.0347881801,
0.0604538955,
-0.0152063901,
-0.0239014979,
-0.0023348944,
0.0273605455,
0.0247365516,
-0.0466290303,
0.0149531905,
-0.0555798709,
-0.0441001877,
-0.0486798212,
-0.0105042206,
0.030079037,
0.0496235639,
0.0853757635,
0.0440740213,
0.023487892,
-0.0368524753,
0.0208035428,
-0.0661217868,
0.003667787,
-0.0165337641,
0.0545544438,
-0.0470575243,
-0.0537196659,
0.0264863875,
-0.0172480624,
-0.000347571,
0.0512511097,
-0.0492346324,
-0.0554290079,
-0.0184486825,
-0.0066046235,
0.0184273757,
0.05591904,
-0.0343461856,
0.0077871094,
0.001956183,
-0.0141185774,
-0.0051631015,
0.0721878037,
0.0819137916,
-0.0236485973,
-0.0154361883,
0.0109256161,
-0.0817487538,
0.0177720077,
-0.009522289,
0.0348948687,
-0.0168887544,
-0.0549749099,
-0.0341120772,
0.0073077921,
0.0705334097,
-0.0159462467,
0.0039690016,
-0.0143622272,
0.0646393895,
-0.0026701321,
0.0390224829,
-0.0497239828,
0.0231910534,
-0.0073364321,
0.0452625267,
0.0012285075,
0.0829732195,
0.0308215618,
-0.0105675133,
-0.0458204262,
0.0637988746,
0.0053724856,
-0.0358946882,
0.0139045604,
0.0172509961,
-0.0052682883,
-0.0158704612,
0.1106152758,
0.0010004884,
-0.0199715532,
0.0185711812,
0.0155784264,
0.0101087252,
-0.0061978167,
0.0687037036,
-0.0194672495,
0.006669817,
-0.0205684733,
0.0385391042,
0.0203690901,
0.0056368248,
0.0491482168,
0.0177176576,
0.008267466,
-0.0652683675,
0.0305152331,
-0.0156475827,
0.0305275321,
0.0114674503,
0.0021677029,
0.0110584609,
0.041162882,
0.0559837148,
-0.0453254879,
0.0482273065,
-0.0097067002,
0.038647946,
-0.042229332,
-0.0428535454,
-0.0206002388,
0.0041168896,
-0.0136763277,
-0.0231359955,
0.0280458387,
-0.0583488159,
0.0487547889,
-0.0657179132,
0.014808801,
-0.0316633172,
0.0191003848,
-0.021325063,
-0.0165768657,
-0.0016011063,
0.0213182457,
-0.0857727602,
-0.0354409739,
-0.0042162607,
0.0107245892,
-6.11266797e-33,
-0.0083902394,
0.0316518769,
-0.0151231298,
-0.022099819,
-0.0456863791,
0.0251870155,
-0.0246051326,
0.004026806,
0.0112548247,
-0.0403368846,
0.0175181236,
-0.0150640886,
0.0521147251,
-0.0192905068,
-0.0079038553,
0.0089993998,
0.1176133305,
0.0014397316,
-0.0121306553,
-0.0013144446,
0.0354047082,
0.0215255152,
0.0027874645,
-0.0474445522,
-0.0428252444,
0.0608549751,
0.0214562118,
-0.0307846218,
0.0147275375,
0.0252505876,
0.0521695502,
0.0637728274,
-0.0238849167,
-0.0362823866,
-0.0013692369,
0.0384348854,
-0.1082262322,
-0.0031262063,
-0.0112818861,
0.0280046072,
-0.020580437,
-0.0366906747,
0.0384050049,
0.0302584171,
-0.0255161617,
-0.0313786604,
0.0289784577,
-0.0071162884,
-0.0132696908,
-0.0255681891,
-0.0225837249,
0.000521562,
-0.0064117955,
-0.0499530993,
0.0648852363,
0.062790893,
-0.0055283676,
-0.0616110712,
-0.0653858334,
0.0129695404,
-0.0222882386,
0.0338364281,
0.0006374785,
0.0590734109,
0.0151781822,
0.0101514664,
0.0313103832,
-0.0648915991,
0.008465548,
0.0010034868,
0.0070384517,
0.0557147823,
0.0047847847,
-0.0058908709,
-0.0081159407,
-0.0092065325,
-0.0213808939,
0.0062585226,
0.0468786284,
0.0048326473,
0.0150224436,
0.036718417,
-0.0488529131,
0.024852911,
-0.0369142182,
0.0064872913,
-0.0294095278,
-0.0165200885,
0.0509069338,
0.047416959,
-0.01653268,
0.044632487,
0.0656963885,
-0.0280416738,
0.0517944172,
0.0193735249,
0.0185529236,
0.0131269321,
0.0122434543,
-0.0084858015,
-0.044630412,
-0.0080368584,
0.0793860033,
0.0366043039,
0.0117068151,
-0.0461127087,
-0.0000539573,
0.0847546086,
-0.0443452895,
-0.0243451409,
-0.0152618298,
0.0395247228,
0.0485515632,
0.0649528652,
0.0637774765,
-0.0103115961,
-0.0014186127,
0.0140266763,
-0.038536828,
0.0032979511,
-0.0088859787,
0.0137567697,
-0.0051679593,
-0.014272646,
-0.0374037512,
0.0344765857,
0.0215286557,
-0.0253830422,
-0.0108332317,
-0.0560155287,
-0.0259810667,
0.0109190345,
2.772e-7,
-0.0804938674,
-0.0122155771,
-0.0005838542,
-0.0642427802,
0.0008958938,
0.0125263073,
-0.0200534873,
-0.0087598693,
0.003381453,
0.0302869473,
-0.0321706124,
0.0111023868,
0.0804558843,
-0.0172255598,
-0.1183748245,
-0.0197196994,
-0.0280342828,
0.0808075294,
0.0094652092,
0.011835508,
-0.0219956003,
0.0591980964,
0.0058041066,
-0.0246527903,
0.0342214033,
-0.0192812849,
0.0016291175,
-0.0013235628,
0.0310703628,
-0.0255372599,
-0.0066363555,
-0.0248659197,
-0.0274499878,
0.0344073102,
-0.046533104,
0.0183476824,
-0.0033389924,
0.0297759417,
-0.0331736654,
-0.0814317912,
-0.0065622404,
0.0563957058,
0.0195543375,
0.0216859709,
0.0877958238,
-0.0295879729,
-0.0396196991,
-0.0121108359,
-0.0542290546,
-0.0065047122,
-0.0560293421,
0.0281651821,
0.0061009647,
0.0040099486,
0.0032876674,
-0.0174684618,
-0.0186337251,
-0.0522753149,
0.0215290971,
0.0174684003,
-0.043467626,
-0.0476812795,
-0.0139095243,
-0.0217520241,
0.0023316364,
-0.0246640444,
-0.0346182771,
2.255245605e-34,
0.0292763617,
-0.0391874202,
0.0518930778,
0.04281912,
-0.0197439343,
-0.0458595753,
-0.0623484962,
0.0051987553,
-0.0053336537,
-0.0477325693,
-0.0615178533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11589v1 | Eliciting Human Preferences with Language Models | 2023-10-17T21:11:21 | 2023-10-17T21:11:21 | Belinda Z. Li, Alex Tamkin, Noah Goodman, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) can be directed to perform target tasks by using
labeled examples or natural language prompts. But selecting examples or writing
prompts for can be challenging--especially in tasks that involve unusual edge
cases, demand precise articulation of nebulous preferences, or require an
accurate mental model of LM behavior. We propose to use *LMs themselves* to
guide the task specification process. In this paper, we introduce **Generative
Active Task Elicitation (GATE)**: a learning framework in which models elicit
and infer intended behavior through free-form, language-based interaction with
users. We study GATE in three domains: email validation, content
recommendation, and moral reasoning. In preregistered experiments, we show that
LMs prompted to perform GATE (e.g., by generating open-ended questions or
synthesizing informative edge cases) elicit responses that are often more
informative than user-written prompts or labels. Users report that interactive
task elicitation requires less effort than prompting or example labeling and
surfaces novel considerations not initially anticipated by users. Our findings
suggest that LM-driven elicitation can be a powerful tool for aligning models
to complex human preferences and values. | [
0.0917692408,
0.0392773673,
-0.022397371,
0.0226681717,
-0.0613726377,
-0.0031344092,
0.0110331699,
-0.009411565,
0.0346741267,
-0.0342837907,
0.01245216,
-0.0294571873,
-0.0115943663,
0.058446832,
0.0066997376,
-0.0652820915,
0.0083382744,
-0.0259491131,
0.0836361125,
-0.0002728215,
0.045308169,
0.0418593362,
0.0093941912,
0.0280234031,
0.0192382652,
0.0095985634,
-0.0312730037,
-0.0094451383,
-0.0098023219,
-0.0199924409,
0.031499844,
0.0776428804,
0.0179276988,
-0.0546694435,
0.000002175,
-0.0814030841,
0.0122228274,
-0.0380424112,
-0.0271013454,
-0.0396366864,
0.0756143183,
0.0414495729,
0.0074597322,
-0.0066027138,
-0.0765338093,
0.0175292213,
0.0346245468,
0.0721600652,
0.0334193818,
0.0307065863,
-0.0109540569,
0.0198964439,
-0.0398514718,
-0.0085972426,
0.0422809832,
0.0131352721,
0.0172399674,
-0.0442745052,
0.0208669323,
0.0626266897,
0.0347096883,
-0.0169022456,
0.0218568649,
-0.0366361551,
0.0224477146,
0.0246882346,
-0.0063485452,
-0.0538971759,
-0.0112749692,
0.0876274928,
0.0265593361,
-0.0147661753,
0.0185949467,
-0.0208442323,
0.0305484738,
0.0429335944,
-0.0182659179,
0.0219771303,
-0.0289673656,
0.0112910513,
0.0126765342,
0.0157287773,
0.0244068168,
0.0400872603,
0.0469997264,
0.0669674054,
-0.019717209,
-0.0259046443,
0.0423874818,
0.001955749,
-0.0075802864,
-0.0877116248,
-0.0101320576,
-0.0005273256,
-0.050853122,
0.021073021,
0.0108885225,
0.0329984017,
0.0306320768,
-0.0395198427,
0.0583334379,
0.0348133035,
-0.0116190193,
0.0286156069,
0.0215044282,
0.0086278869,
0.0035241512,
0.0136667127,
-0.0349267609,
0.0645690933,
-0.0043640737,
-0.019063428,
-0.0236049481,
0.0379678085,
-0.0100244051,
0.0297483429,
-0.0144552765,
0.0185358617,
-0.0472026616,
0.025536336,
-0.0162814911,
0.0384031609,
-0.0103758639,
-0.0054119984,
-0.1148843393,
-0.0356816798,
-0.05210419,
0.0434797928,
0.0291875023,
-0.0088259876,
0.0291489977,
-0.0014546437,
-0.0048482558,
-0.0089632776,
0.0139759509,
0.0564638451,
0.0130423578,
0.006642987,
-0.0441822186,
-0.0263862927,
0.002350528,
-0.0355724618,
-0.0164877158,
-0.0713135973,
0.0172293261,
0.0304618403,
-0.0234288238,
-0.054036513,
0.0226766914,
0.0383196771,
-0.0238946509,
0.0832664743,
0.0164451078,
-0.022678582,
0.0253361948,
0.0249698143,
-0.0233192537,
0.0437750295,
0.0112868305,
0.0686776638,
0.0440266021,
0.0281712599,
0.0447698906,
-0.0007493049,
-0.0176074449,
0.0058932262,
-0.0231589582,
0.0258442685,
-0.0161794424,
-0.0045360164,
-0.0175289828,
0.072271727,
-0.0299554765,
0.0045355824,
0.0982620716,
0.0643605366,
-0.024743218,
-0.0216159243,
0.0326100625,
0.0220027901,
-0.0232208651,
0.0159291551,
-0.0336593837,
0.0404358581,
-0.0102095827,
-0.0217426568,
-0.0078121913,
-0.0147531172,
-0.034381859,
-0.0752098709,
0.0138153555,
-0.031267345,
0.0771358386,
0.0605003759,
0.0286086947,
0.0305109099,
-0.0285699256,
-0.0215810128,
0.0444901697,
-0.0639448836,
0.0084499745,
-0.0555553138,
0.0884811655,
0.0946370661,
0.0399536528,
-0.0218859594,
0.0071482086,
-0.0493536666,
0.0184213668,
0.0276573133,
0.0631549656,
-0.024605386,
-0.041819457,
-0.0193768982,
-0.0364313833,
-0.0103786793,
-0.0123344921,
0.0041024429,
0.0177350231,
-0.0384252891,
0.0270906594,
-0.0298580509,
-0.0386350788,
0.0153357275,
0.0142606692,
-0.005333432,
-0.0133435428,
0.0363316648,
0.012732679,
0.013527777,
0.0443295725,
0.0057797367,
0.0195729081,
-0.0087149916,
-0.0376392379,
0.0069972519,
-0.0167657398,
0.0362416692,
0.0069782939,
-0.005228118,
-0.0022649439,
-0.0152825089,
-0.0047597759,
0.0097333267,
-0.0165884364,
0.0012918727,
0.0169955697,
-0.0601624474,
-0.01639775,
-0.0114639187,
-0.0636086985,
-0.0507984012,
0.0649519637,
0.0175429396,
-0.0033028659,
0.0139032817,
-0.0554098524,
-0.03246345,
-0.0248044413,
-0.0300175492,
0.0033334757,
0.031042261,
0.0264207963,
0.0528859794,
0.0129720764,
-0.0484706573,
-0.0191596337,
-0.0780081972,
-0.0491136648,
-0.0220687147,
0.0065077562,
-0.0196829718,
0.0106232753,
0.0199951082,
-0.0010858414,
-0.0602539927,
-0.0053197364,
-0.0022514472,
0.0201386567,
0.0498648696,
0.0073786108,
-0.0018048105,
-0.0186559092,
0.0189887062,
-0.0068331687,
0.0219542831,
0.0491647273,
0.0287696905,
-0.0539508164,
0.0194085054,
-0.0324537642,
0.0050527323,
-0.0113991657,
0.0105942683,
0.0244430322,
-0.0096715437,
0.0341203064,
0.0649365187,
0.050487522,
0.0360141173,
0.0371929891,
0.0495237559,
-0.0922862738,
-0.0052083503,
-0.0549751781,
0.0112942625,
-0.0360583439,
-0.0220408328,
0.0389465131,
0.0360682979,
0.0020016427,
0.0212960746,
-0.0695231706,
0.0730268434,
-0.0002168001,
-0.0172685608,
-0.0337872431,
-0.0539055839,
-0.0156505015,
0.1007440835,
-0.0080019329,
-0.0789741278,
0.1011909097,
0.0101259621,
-0.0085581904,
-0.0204231851,
-0.0071150661,
-0.0140314633,
0.040992368,
0.0026019334,
0.0212199427,
0.0611595511,
0.011400165,
-0.0340659246,
-0.0137366457,
0.0248508397,
-0.0577239804,
0.0187429562,
-0.0435954928,
-0.0069476739,
0.024655683,
-0.0463318601,
-0.0604914613,
-0.057170976,
-0.0113068698,
-0.0213911403,
0.0118098836,
0.0065902458,
0.0639643371,
-0.0322363004,
0.0131144319,
0.0112189315,
-0.0071587353,
-0.0330890715,
-0.0105528692,
-0.014075215,
0.0727463141,
-0.0083509209,
-0.0360770188,
-0.0171045735,
0.0212882515,
0.0243234951,
-0.0024988116,
-0.0187374186,
-0.0229260549,
0.0180769786,
0.0409317277,
-0.0210837256,
0.0275830049,
0.0458595529,
0.0202038996,
0.0067318394,
0.0172618441,
0.1015293598,
0.0417573787,
-0.0706578493,
0.0024369338,
-0.0397466905,
0.0227608401,
0.0233018287,
0.0493232086,
-0.0711557567,
-0.0069713788,
-0.011865274,
0.0191225931,
-0.0388300046,
-0.0052555548,
0.0011690203,
-0.1009872481,
0.0278220624,
-0.0123948045,
0.0260922853,
0.0255340952,
-0.0419884585,
-0.0023311304,
-0.0166840609,
-0.0021656719,
-0.0026576647,
0.0129610272,
-0.0025972626,
0.0114928475,
0.0064065871,
-0.0228784923,
0.0355237387,
-0.040963836,
0.0315372273,
0.0689426139,
0.0139773544,
-0.0030913248,
-0.0587231293,
0.0373395011,
0.0441422239,
0.0030778416,
-0.0134899737,
0.0297723487,
-0.0169933848,
0.0154326167,
-0.0532220379,
0.0621850789,
-0.0112513099,
-0.0367469713,
0.0167482253,
0.086401552,
-0.0199424345,
-0.0161246974,
0.0059096143,
0.0083833262,
0.0740639642,
0.0445792899,
0.0160973426,
-0.1220688447,
-0.0024455611,
-0.0621074699,
-0.0204485245,
-0.0108915782,
-0.0553274862,
-0.040561121,
0.0121559855,
-0.0054669953,
-0.05184092,
-0.025171442,
0.0310996845,
0.0168593749,
0.0605917983,
-0.0308077,
0.0450074486,
-0.0001060875,
0.013962727,
0.0376631431,
0.0004903069,
0.0210302602,
-0.0301892962,
-0.0355575643,
-0.0098221321,
-0.0911523029,
-0.0105726849,
-0.023102615,
0.0272793733,
-0.0670939013,
-0.0427665114,
0.0750306547,
0.0249196589,
0.031326104,
-0.0199641995,
-0.0310036819,
-0.0351659209,
0.0254989713,
-0.0261362344,
-0.0324411429,
0.0329666995,
0.0121745616,
0.0111109652,
0.0200262386,
-0.0246044062,
0.0433681086,
0.0312819742,
-0.0056774579,
-0.0397800244,
-0.0598912686,
0.0477045514,
0.0119991088,
0.0418669246,
-0.0141176637,
-0.0110964878,
-0.0442561917,
-0.0175894182,
0.0178869329,
-0.0643312484,
-0.0401661806,
-0.0212003551,
0.0015721746,
0.006449338,
-0.00264057,
-0.0354361646,
-0.064098455,
0.0257313643,
-0.0212519951,
0.0066864025,
0.0043003354,
0.0585022755,
0.0280957557,
-0.0081562642,
-0.0109645706,
0.0157858711,
-0.0197405126,
0.0530985557,
0.0091673704,
0.0679787323,
0.0049294839,
-0.0109449076,
-0.0042349533,
-0.0046017179,
-0.0090034353,
-0.0615190342,
-0.0001687084,
-0.0129183214,
-0.0184633285,
-0.0324624218,
0.0141288713,
-0.0459115729,
-0.0045562754,
-0.0030574969,
0.0377023853,
0.0241678413,
-0.0493146442,
0.0204565618,
0.0266107488,
-0.0465303324,
-0.014710905,
0.0184291266,
-0.0447629578,
-0.0202555023,
-0.012301215,
-0.0274657402,
-0.036596749,
-0.0046320227,
0.0125116231,
-0.0043582991,
-0.0474818088,
0.0170841403,
-0.0434955582,
-0.0305440072,
-0.0275352094,
0.0111937867,
0.0007252847,
-0.0372954719,
0.0355859548,
0.0737350062,
-0.0267641041,
0.0001680187,
-0.0599854812,
0.0042840936,
-0.0386367142,
-0.0116877286,
-0.0670610517,
-6.045084759e-33,
0.0171394423,
-0.0477430411,
-0.0021307154,
0.0497852638,
0.0264023561,
-0.0243290812,
-0.0183962695,
0.0396434031,
0.0085342359,
0.0231413413,
-0.0036110394,
-0.0249310508,
-0.0103873573,
-0.0173335411,
0.0155510847,
-0.0271835793,
0.0259818099,
-0.0167936999,
-0.0549549758,
0.0257008523,
0.016779596,
-0.0140869562,
-0.006473626,
-0.0825886279,
0.0929602981,
-0.0075645172,
-0.0179266501,
0.0254907198,
-0.0388630852,
0.0367593355,
-0.0014048151,
0.0630903095,
0.0185848027,
-0.0432753004,
0.0049042259,
0.0930359885,
-0.0550591499,
-0.0224826615,
0.0765484944,
-0.0374205299,
-0.0690560192,
-0.0198385548,
-0.0209649466,
-0.0106667969,
-0.0140030188,
0.0405409783,
0.0476800688,
0.001461956,
0.0017925098,
0.0163707361,
-0.0442610644,
-0.0370606929,
-0.0240892805,
-0.016623022,
0.0017426944,
0.0941108614,
-0.0574263409,
0.0207262766,
-0.0089820726,
0.0555860475,
0.004776008,
-0.0004534048,
0.026051715,
-0.0171772949,
-0.0074372818,
0.069988206,
-0.0175264627,
0.0355155133,
-0.0603573807,
0.0098631065,
-0.0225981567,
0.0486854538,
0.0154133672,
0.0102233374,
-0.0143697252,
-0.0349541679,
0.006504145,
0.0177720282,
0.0178337507,
-0.0218508337,
0.063508898,
-0.0143126529,
-0.0276099201,
-0.0304437429,
-0.0344994888,
-0.0151947634,
-0.0551365316,
-0.0500528142,
0.014420433,
0.0108370483,
-0.0306434743,
-0.0369499587,
-0.0362543426,
-0.0199949369,
-0.0214708075,
-0.003230552,
-0.0170995239,
-0.0137197645,
-0.0107282829,
-0.0290827304,
-0.0392101631,
-0.0049635144,
-0.0192562863,
-0.030731231,
-0.0138405692,
0.0164367873,
0.0268148165,
-0.0079984171,
-0.0236328803,
-0.011567872,
-0.0291544963,
0.0331097357,
0.0030874163,
0.0279286653,
0.0189539902,
0.0329848416,
-0.0210430566,
0.0160013177,
-0.0223180316,
-0.0425502472,
-0.0923789069,
-0.0170152355,
-0.026497921,
0.0144717917,
-0.0444229059,
-0.0299254674,
-0.0116922567,
0.034442056,
0.0161298569,
-0.0227932949,
-0.0082674809,
0.0157996099,
2.757e-7,
-0.0003190713,
0.0240079984,
-0.0333233289,
0.0392025486,
-0.0244071372,
0.0666429773,
0.0209825188,
0.0082309246,
0.0605668798,
-0.0434918739,
0.0149071319,
0.0110823363,
0.0603110604,
0.0095045678,
-0.0964204222,
-0.0138961663,
-0.008001389,
0.0182115305,
-0.0164751485,
0.0131524839,
0.0869236216,
0.0128017589,
0.0229076762,
0.0131577579,
-0.0118780546,
0.0152900144,
0.0453037433,
-0.0971991867,
0.0030544018,
-0.0118784336,
0.0024190051,
-0.0359688848,
0.0046248538,
0.0344269499,
-0.0221740119,
-0.0447857231,
-0.0187418368,
0.0810376033,
0.0072897319,
-0.0384874605,
-0.0178914052,
0.0115263704,
0.0188378487,
-0.0476407595,
0.0554309823,
-0.0394838043,
-0.0176208466,
-0.0376850963,
0.0177036021,
-0.0320821106,
-0.018338969,
-0.0205560774,
-0.0270270947,
-0.0102597727,
0.0069548562,
0.0095621897,
0.0062050074,
-0.0296696778,
-0.0091830362,
0.0227936041,
-0.0128045408,
-0.0724975914,
-0.0184157547,
0.0571241267,
-0.0062563904,
-0.0088734059,
0.0330274291,
2.359010073e-34,
0.0276004542,
0.0297853686,
0.0378637202,
0.0391524509,
0.0441360623,
0.0525747351,
-0.0029188804,
0.0083944649,
0.055802647,
-0.0395012721,
-0.0151218791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11584v1 | BasahaCorpus: An Expanded Linguistic Resource for Readability Assessment in Central Philippine Languages | 2023-10-17T21:05:20 | 2023-10-17T21:05:20 | Joseph Marvin Imperial, Ekaterina Kochmar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current research on automatic readability assessment (ARA) has focused on
improving the performance of models in high-resource languages such as English.
In this work, we introduce and release BasahaCorpus as part of an initiative
aimed at expanding available corpora and baseline models for readability
assessment in lower resource languages in the Philippines. We compiled a corpus
of short fictional narratives written in Hiligaynon, Minasbate, Karay-a, and
Rinconada -- languages belonging to the Central Philippine family tree subgroup
-- to train ARA models using surface-level, syllable-pattern, and n-gram
overlap features. We also propose a new hierarchical cross-lingual modeling
approach that takes advantage of a language's placement in the family tree to
increase the amount of available training data. Our study yields encouraging
results that support previous work showcasing the efficacy of cross-lingual
models in low-resource settings, as well as similarities in highly informative
linguistic features for mutually intelligible languages. | [
0.0051772436,
0.0052922503,
-0.0414398126,
0.0607947111,
-0.0437768139,
0.024760941,
0.0063978839,
-0.0163643304,
0.0163091496,
-0.0083559351,
-0.0331197269,
-0.0312409699,
0.0777797028,
0.0065457593,
0.0076653217,
-0.0466363616,
0.0122763459,
-0.0233168658,
0.0623319596,
0.0014946744,
0.0096491557,
0.0381557085,
-0.0197796188,
0.0383905284,
0.049287796,
-0.0391622782,
0.0226968564,
0.0182233956,
0.0420834981,
-0.0031877079,
-0.0280195642,
0.0386797972,
-0.0424824432,
0.0101451902,
0.0000018597,
-0.0401955023,
-0.0449531488,
-0.0025945224,
0.0164129175,
0.0609868057,
0.095292896,
0.0053512193,
-0.0023249655,
-0.0205715206,
0.0172802173,
0.0000391995,
0.0560489967,
0.0276541114,
0.0193565972,
0.0238874722,
-0.0179090742,
-0.0553477407,
0.0013497246,
0.0117966635,
-0.000383756,
0.0092217959,
-0.0046950299,
0.0181164443,
0.0110763935,
-0.0218615793,
-0.0234576277,
0.0166196711,
-0.0358109288,
-0.0001840267,
-0.0057784775,
0.0015340315,
-0.0125595629,
-0.0199295767,
0.015053492,
0.0275580753,
-0.0105219427,
-0.0894080848,
-0.006977702,
-0.0026958222,
-0.0221223254,
0.0134045677,
-0.0060966476,
-0.031809669,
-0.0623175912,
0.0165317282,
0.0919288769,
0.0076159202,
0.0323850736,
0.0045353491,
0.0393969342,
0.0381620973,
0.0449989848,
-0.0309497695,
-0.005236146,
0.038650047,
0.0113420384,
0.024541948,
0.0496793166,
-0.0300115794,
0.0045048585,
0.0140882432,
0.0085355137,
-0.0104393959,
0.0108088143,
-0.0240522362,
0.0180966426,
0.0437843017,
-0.0287945922,
0.0104434658,
-0.0041414774,
0.030484261,
0.0289909802,
-0.0128938574,
-0.0275995303,
-0.005665354,
-0.0147631541,
0.0068340199,
-0.0215569623,
-0.0069779954,
-0.0620104037,
0.0038387089,
-0.0356955267,
-0.0243713204,
0.0453831255,
-0.0495147258,
0.0129552754,
-0.0364618264,
-0.0377794318,
0.0165234692,
0.0158706512,
0.0420103744,
-0.0418143868,
0.0189504791,
-0.0228413139,
-0.0428869836,
0.0348189436,
0.006344921,
-0.0015776366,
-0.0038536852,
0.0022204651,
0.0072748228,
-0.0272581074,
-0.0400609449,
-0.0723160505,
-0.001914929,
-0.0426527634,
-0.0422833934,
-0.0247263256,
-0.038457945,
0.0260758735,
-0.0295210667,
0.0705043152,
0.002960053,
-0.0220993236,
0.0069049029,
0.0240283441,
0.0302821714,
0.0193997826,
0.0068115424,
0.032218881,
0.0329791866,
0.0029078815,
0.0290794466,
0.0873019919,
-0.0106292712,
0.061437007,
-0.017878443,
-0.0496628433,
0.0031162864,
-0.0408579074,
0.0158763118,
0.0393034443,
-0.046135582,
-0.0653879866,
0.0290502515,
0.0084662102,
0.0306972619,
-0.0089024575,
-0.0134027647,
0.0574733764,
0.0437443964,
0.0505545549,
0.0500837676,
0.0688675046,
0.0103967404,
0.0179153271,
0.0637286529,
0.0317053497,
-0.054313466,
-0.0116539784,
0.0452579297,
0.009675974,
0.0234872364,
0.0002253532,
-0.0495301262,
0.0127955582,
0.0206580218,
-0.0335990936,
-0.0119920811,
0.0156084448,
0.0084592467,
-0.0347413197,
-0.0275345929,
0.0449440181,
-0.0957936868,
0.03613583,
0.0226413533,
0.0659132972,
0.0804276094,
0.0456128493,
-0.0264959689,
0.0131640853,
0.0442818478,
-0.027418524,
0.0097620161,
-0.0626690537,
-0.0101188561,
0.0706877559,
-0.0647478029,
0.04059406,
0.0604382455,
0.0344111659,
0.0500304438,
-0.0519360825,
0.0167154986,
0.0052893274,
-0.051645942,
-0.0564193688,
0.021381164,
-0.0690726638,
0.0030327428,
0.009354244,
0.0085647823,
0.0366678126,
0.0611517765,
-0.0307165757,
-0.0297122262,
0.0055071884,
-0.026979275,
0.0315311104,
0.0473006628,
-0.0279052928,
-0.0260507241,
-0.0143075539,
-0.0963590294,
0.0235936921,
-0.0141689871,
0.0319677666,
-0.0448465571,
-0.0100854607,
-0.040561717,
0.017709123,
-0.0442274734,
0.0676990598,
-0.0585241877,
-0.0203109141,
-0.0346327648,
0.0230879597,
0.0246888865,
0.0344344936,
-0.0351146124,
-0.0278148353,
0.0361216776,
-0.080629684,
-0.012723499,
-0.0009089792,
0.0143583538,
0.0039323634,
-0.0116966898,
0.0214488842,
-0.0189265627,
-0.0496186875,
-0.1286177635,
-0.0110346451,
-0.0052338471,
0.0144615211,
0.0033420862,
-0.0205136668,
-0.0548642911,
0.036620412,
0.04015081,
0.0042036823,
-0.0129954638,
0.0061022397,
-0.0043997774,
0.0072552236,
0.0275585633,
-0.0535613969,
-0.0355961658,
0.0183347259,
0.0704965219,
0.0534159616,
-0.0328781307,
-0.0400337838,
-0.0013715964,
0.0134276357,
-0.0719381794,
0.0289338287,
-0.0377308838,
-0.0123509215,
0.0292719062,
0.0333489105,
0.0473342948,
-0.0343733691,
-0.023981262,
0.0649300441,
-0.0356125236,
0.0230223145,
-0.0270294808,
0.0394503847,
0.0334022231,
0.0023650096,
-0.0674495697,
-0.0265651271,
0.0571104549,
0.0092836833,
-0.0210168809,
-0.0279961266,
-0.0333218984,
-0.0668783709,
-0.057480704,
-0.0037043518,
-0.0203161873,
-0.0123291044,
0.0731659457,
-0.0361544006,
-0.0249193627,
0.088290289,
-0.0920189694,
-0.0194404628,
-0.0821931437,
-0.0084837703,
-0.0601426624,
0.0282507222,
-0.0001864139,
0.0221315511,
0.0190413687,
-0.0786464587,
-0.0068858783,
0.0381698571,
0.0366783142,
-0.006859405,
0.0698924884,
-0.0665166527,
-0.0282960739,
0.0295181274,
-0.0180135109,
0.0096898926,
0.0073522315,
-0.0174923129,
-0.0569872186,
-0.0116156414,
-0.0129049746,
0.0105228685,
0.0012140109,
0.0025514658,
0.0095924698,
-0.0143009322,
-0.0103533743,
-0.0094429301,
0.0613502413,
0.0145186782,
-0.0370731615,
-0.0374248102,
-0.0305423029,
0.0078896172,
-0.0216918644,
-0.0111414641,
-0.0099886246,
0.0170868039,
0.032681834,
0.0018591298,
-0.018560851,
-0.0243292619,
-0.0658778772,
0.0018914606,
-0.0576895773,
0.0013842093,
0.0840011537,
0.0120566431,
-0.0158820394,
-0.0057715741,
-0.0282986164,
0.0510501526,
-0.0102976095,
0.0039242166,
-0.0103365099,
0.0107590808,
0.0438022576,
0.023319032,
-0.029596759,
-0.0154586276,
-0.0103873089,
-0.0871848464,
0.0223753452,
0.0313302837,
-0.012559765,
-0.0540535823,
-0.0107109854,
-0.0196113717,
-0.0295439977,
0.0048619816,
0.0150459856,
-0.0240338203,
-0.0130110849,
-0.00747632,
-0.0258283522,
-0.0138368402,
-0.0160390884,
-0.0126303183,
-0.012620802,
0.0008860412,
0.0271591321,
-0.0234775413,
0.0102311838,
-0.0198883135,
-0.0344353132,
-0.0269428529,
-0.0191886034,
0.0118932258,
0.0231782626,
-0.0066510886,
-0.0574849844,
0.0315625817,
0.029603349,
-0.0128781945,
0.0195224136,
0.0136421146,
0.0253655817,
-0.0348253697,
0.0183149204,
0.0659398362,
0.0329157002,
0.0212674905,
0.0445255786,
-0.0316510834,
-0.0031565519,
-0.0329654776,
0.0026557399,
-0.017259296,
-0.042418614,
0.0518205576,
-0.0408326872,
-0.0664133057,
-0.0938163102,
-0.0791025907,
-0.0257969946,
0.0164691191,
0.0639392585,
0.0285695791,
0.0095345955,
-0.0211801473,
-0.0255463067,
-0.0045658732,
-0.0349260196,
0.0129383821,
-0.0428893156,
0.0263230316,
-0.0118300933,
-0.0272727087,
-0.0219015218,
0.0032352526,
-0.0335268304,
-0.0382618234,
0.0134788416,
-0.0442311838,
0.0249593072,
-0.0157095082,
-0.0240375344,
-0.0686291009,
0.035745129,
-0.0362856761,
-0.0461630411,
0.0380736291,
0.0025854264,
-0.0174651369,
-0.0017229152,
0.0177956652,
-0.0032963534,
-0.0009729522,
-0.0332310759,
0.0238966979,
0.0006025177,
-0.0448601693,
-0.020139344,
0.0081793806,
0.0458377786,
-0.0592803247,
-0.0225869846,
-0.0922587961,
-0.0032142086,
-0.0218301713,
0.0531024598,
-0.0146563221,
-0.0100496244,
0.0622575209,
-0.0168018229,
-0.0359136537,
0.0010776719,
-0.0310685877,
-0.0137643572,
0.0094970698,
0.0519926287,
0.0243017394,
0.082644701,
-0.0231640302,
0.0178537443,
-0.0472245179,
-0.0094480962,
-0.0617203973,
0.0526760183,
0.0381145924,
0.0455638506,
-0.0199902151,
-0.0051156688,
0.0181548819,
0.0374291874,
0.0333405584,
0.0611095056,
0.0075942669,
0.0008680196,
0.0717634484,
-0.065377146,
0.0758268982,
-0.0348321088,
0.0290532932,
-0.0556678511,
0.0360637195,
0.0151396682,
-0.0198533908,
-0.0283367559,
-0.0036825771,
0.0199040771,
0.040382605,
0.0898522511,
0.0449935086,
-0.0108253984,
0.050459139,
0.0007121292,
0.004325788,
-0.0492675006,
-0.0319476239,
0.0243164878,
-0.0388615243,
-0.025831705,
-0.0892528892,
-0.0561652295,
0.0242875982,
0.0018240049,
0.012132518,
0.0035849928,
-0.0417063385,
0.0420952961,
-0.0410205722,
0.0418611206,
-0.0625958443,
-0.010211966,
-0.045876693,
0.0088381497,
0.0195952635,
-5.444472165e-33,
-0.030523289,
-0.0292744786,
-0.0073327357,
0.0178904608,
-0.0281622037,
0.007258629,
-0.0466349795,
0.0064786216,
0.018442655,
0.0370535329,
0.0102812536,
0.006724121,
0.0226629674,
-0.0238747373,
-0.0014859441,
0.0299782697,
0.0260768291,
0.0600110665,
-0.0100886719,
0.0068396567,
0.0335756205,
0.0187144689,
0.0405254588,
-0.0554295816,
0.0565688014,
-0.0299017169,
-0.0098555032,
-0.0032888092,
0.0348544978,
0.0434148982,
-0.0038186584,
0.0448810644,
0.026888147,
0.0263461545,
-0.0004791547,
0.0337446295,
-0.0559802651,
-0.0132859489,
0.0793140307,
0.0203839447,
0.040366035,
-0.054356657,
0.0156433098,
0.007629809,
0.04152539,
-0.0712199882,
0.0210465509,
-0.0563729443,
-0.0022178998,
0.0363498628,
-0.0882135108,
0.0329334848,
-0.0217327755,
0.0063189417,
0.0636624619,
0.076680392,
0.0035223523,
-0.0017063938,
-0.0291223712,
0.0262642168,
0.0059786434,
0.0477268808,
0.0245731547,
-0.0242707711,
-0.0369403288,
0.0473211482,
0.0229091141,
-0.0443424582,
0.0282015894,
0.0531362891,
0.0536191501,
0.0101769101,
0.013736424,
0.0812828764,
0.0109260287,
-0.0242905375,
-0.0087298239,
0.0272885188,
0.0004374882,
-0.0072642094,
0.0402612574,
-0.0041837282,
-0.0665790737,
-0.008508835,
-0.0378160924,
-0.0309714358,
-0.0256803446,
-0.0109986756,
0.0102906544,
-0.0483652167,
-0.0047816285,
0.0389086865,
0.0297432151,
-0.0133727053,
0.0411094055,
0.0294762831,
-0.0307721365,
0.0463211387,
-0.0289735962,
0.0659149736,
0.0037888784,
-0.0100217173,
-0.012638337,
0.026773965,
0.0188373998,
-0.0526059866,
0.0209516585,
-0.0046620341,
-0.039646782,
0.0146234445,
-0.0112965722,
0.0004184461,
-0.0201564524,
0.0696376041,
0.004389755,
0.0054452433,
-0.0029121111,
0.0261475984,
0.0242760573,
0.0309508331,
-0.0100525804,
-0.0269507971,
-0.0205712225,
-0.0074601872,
-0.0332827717,
0.0049597914,
0.0230545513,
-0.0168422218,
0.0019657116,
0.0192959569,
0.0074840277,
-0.0067067998,
2.566e-7,
-0.014496292,
0.0321452729,
0.0459330864,
-0.0156750232,
0.0134414062,
0.0225718804,
-0.0353987888,
0.0190739352,
0.0081403954,
-0.0142491842,
0.0419468842,
-0.0493881442,
0.1196059883,
0.0271160211,
-0.1298481226,
-0.0092087276,
0.0077580651,
-0.0197000001,
-0.0579134077,
-0.0146595547,
0.0299056359,
0.0396913327,
0.0000929305,
-0.0209603515,
0.0443610251,
-0.042564787,
0.0397487246,
-0.0409470797,
-0.0437558405,
0.025201533,
0.0698029101,
0.0092403144,
0.0282866247,
0.0039091986,
-0.0195677318,
0.016976038,
0.0305660442,
0.0578127131,
0.0056694769,
-0.0034692518,
0.0264186449,
0.0025473733,
-0.0609190501,
-0.0776552781,
0.0266631506,
0.090133436,
-0.0159388501,
0.0167898163,
-0.0074545406,
0.0143310213,
0.0019406902,
0.0007987028,
-0.065141134,
0.0213976875,
0.0211024508,
-0.0619316697,
-0.012174272,
0.0114500523,
-0.0144402608,
0.0407202654,
-0.0192507692,
-0.0060563711,
0.0171947572,
0.0036821556,
0.0101028699,
-0.0818228871,
0.0226683132,
2.104843169e-34,
0.032427799,
-0.0219596289,
0.0196168609,
0.0085797478,
0.0458898582,
0.0001683416,
0.0131670134,
-0.011015065,
-0.0118527077,
-0.0322174728,
0.0217559207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11571v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11571v2 | Pragmatic Evaluation of Clarifying Questions with Fact-Level Masking | 2023-10-17T20:40:59 | 2024-01-07T21:01:55 | Matthew Toles, Yukun Huang, Zhou Yu, Luis Gravano | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The ability to derive useful information by asking clarifying questions (ACQ)
is an important element of real life collaboration on reasoning tasks, such as
question answering (QA). Existing natural language ACQ challenges, however,
evaluate generations based on word overlap rather than the value of the
information itself. Word overlap is often an inappropriate metric for question
generation since many different questions could be useful in a given situation,
and a single question can be phrased many different ways. Instead, we propose
evaluating questions pragmatically based on the value of the information they
retrieve. Here we present a definition and framework for natural language
pragmatic asking of clarifying questions (PACQ), the problem of generating
questions that result in answers useful for a reasoning task. We also present
fact-level masking (FLM), a procedure for converting natural language datasets
into self-supervised PACQ datasets by omitting particular critical facts.
Finally, we generate a PACQ dataset from the HotpotQA dataset using FLM and
evaluate several zero-shot language models on it. Our experiments show that
current zero-shot models struggle to ask questions that retrieve useful
information, as compared to human annotators. These results demonstrate an
opportunity to use FLM datasets and the PACQ framework to objectively evaluate
and improve question generation and other language models. | [
0.0383805968,
0.0191033445,
-0.0018901497,
0.0411297753,
-0.0575281493,
0.0083490238,
0.0352660902,
-0.0089211911,
-0.0105317105,
-0.0314743482,
0.0074590961,
-0.0484298654,
-0.0236983187,
0.0194682758,
0.0342540257,
-0.0480003618,
0.0444075055,
0.0046025286,
0.0374857038,
0.008878882,
0.0086251572,
-0.0036290812,
-0.0199508015,
0.0345762968,
-0.030898327,
-0.0148977386,
-0.0509306416,
0.031123057,
0.0118580181,
0.0091392603,
0.0302515924,
0.0493760593,
0.0200282782,
0.034790393,
0.000001856,
-0.0389630161,
-0.0009604439,
-0.0097419722,
-0.0494907685,
-0.020954363,
0.0110193295,
0.0199292358,
0.0280433241,
0.0368048996,
-0.0745159611,
-0.030019924,
0.0161866378,
0.0260159951,
0.0692520887,
0.0617365502,
0.0068076919,
-0.0200334508,
-0.0241298266,
-0.0192750208,
0.0738196671,
-0.0557342172,
0.0058451938,
0.0349159054,
0.0083214073,
0.0203500874,
-0.0105135739,
0.0221616216,
0.0432268269,
-0.025940273,
0.0130561404,
0.0307870526,
-0.043503195,
-0.041657161,
0.0148980413,
0.1118523329,
0.0254124422,
-0.023674041,
0.0023849136,
-0.0060093696,
0.0343580209,
0.0070587294,
-0.022227142,
0.0186061077,
0.0088020647,
-0.0209868755,
0.0079489201,
0.032139346,
-0.0024161173,
0.0191745628,
0.0110243009,
0.0399860553,
-0.0009309626,
-0.0094994614,
-0.0428794026,
-0.022069972,
-0.0189396981,
-0.0890856832,
-0.0066481293,
0.0811683461,
-0.0246660989,
0.0255737603,
-0.0559468418,
-0.0037285248,
0.0310976487,
0.0121277291,
0.0115487296,
0.0324671827,
-0.0264174137,
0.0584269091,
-0.0127543444,
0.0207406636,
0.0019971961,
0.0250455923,
-0.0327389762,
-0.0210013352,
-0.0202401783,
-0.0134015521,
-0.0559499227,
0.0389745831,
-0.0515882038,
-0.0124388374,
0.0015425179,
0.015124877,
0.0008039605,
0.0060588275,
-0.0046236911,
0.0194181092,
-0.0654695705,
-0.0250855777,
-0.0245412551,
0.039372731,
-0.0953231305,
0.0216322728,
0.0340248831,
-0.061175935,
-0.0363720842,
0.0376945361,
0.0255908016,
-0.0166276116,
-0.0067336815,
0.0391508415,
-0.0267180856,
-0.0140639907,
-0.0363488942,
-0.0716877133,
0.0235603917,
-0.0580366738,
-0.011052262,
-0.0520330928,
0.0375875905,
-0.0182410292,
-0.03699705,
-0.0264209006,
0.0148220863,
0.0372087993,
0.0133946287,
0.0759998485,
-0.0406816378,
0.0197184365,
0.0655448958,
0.039296817,
-0.0250090547,
0.0643297285,
0.0401577428,
-0.0106143486,
0.0526684001,
0.0054139122,
0.0115341432,
-0.0211884994,
0.0399202108,
-0.0069321557,
0.0105954073,
0.0402068272,
-0.0287717488,
0.0339454748,
0.0046077142,
0.04730938,
-0.0504921563,
-0.0443183295,
0.0292058904,
0.001114037,
-0.0105769327,
0.0040649977,
0.0438224599,
0.0647560731,
-0.0044366247,
0.0340299383,
0.0024435928,
0.0595774725,
-0.0143478038,
-0.0071622711,
-0.004027959,
-0.0061783902,
-0.0703391209,
-0.0580314435,
0.014561234,
0.0100959241,
0.0185030028,
0.0328518972,
-0.0054269782,
0.0537528023,
-0.0342168882,
0.0290525835,
-0.0233443547,
-0.0647855252,
0.0172273368,
-0.0231402945,
0.0737769827,
0.0048567611,
0.0448547229,
-0.0259096976,
-0.0811309144,
0.0020217225,
0.0320404768,
0.0501972474,
0.0196830314,
-0.0334275886,
0.0448890328,
-0.0579603091,
0.002625884,
-0.0439969487,
0.0076544615,
-0.0279275421,
0.0248556416,
-0.022171028,
0.0355799794,
-0.0412387289,
0.0306586102,
0.0360022113,
-0.0403139256,
-0.0355857126,
0.0196819752,
-0.0003721686,
-0.0301561505,
0.0136002246,
-0.0071174242,
0.0159605667,
0.0304504335,
-0.0332464464,
-0.0370508172,
0.0173584744,
-0.0113291927,
-0.0743114501,
0.0225108154,
-0.0509634577,
-0.0129676508,
0.0219604671,
-0.058850158,
-0.0560749099,
-0.0064341547,
-0.0219768453,
-0.0147555806,
-0.064994365,
-0.0287667569,
0.0175016169,
0.003281852,
-0.0299934968,
0.0757539272,
0.0123688979,
-0.0107573504,
0.0140896086,
0.0187858641,
0.0143920183,
-0.0495901518,
0.0067157559,
-0.0179715324,
-0.0235344227,
-0.0125661846,
0.020024024,
0.053360831,
-0.0859555528,
-0.0041140793,
-0.0812645778,
0.0235454943,
-0.0322158188,
0.0152513403,
0.0623192079,
0.0095122,
-0.0112193432,
-0.0330159627,
-0.1059184074,
-0.0162136015,
-0.0133818984,
-0.0088464487,
0.077877894,
0.0096755894,
0.0142655522,
-0.0072340574,
0.003545328,
-0.0007052704,
0.0169863068,
0.0103570623,
0.0148154302,
-0.0492854118,
0.0194124375,
-0.0685801059,
-0.0007602606,
0.0209681895,
-0.0215615146,
0.0206717607,
0.032034602,
0.0215927158,
0.0854941085,
0.0275312737,
-0.020807134,
0.0094809355,
0.00010129,
-0.0256818738,
0.039388489,
-0.0328697711,
0.021859495,
0.0362012908,
-0.0549680777,
-0.0105415145,
0.0093688983,
0.0084606912,
0.0053198352,
-0.0680022016,
0.0464011654,
-0.0089640403,
-0.0373673402,
-0.0581601411,
0.0169469137,
-0.0083721559,
0.0623847023,
-0.0465973355,
-0.0117874695,
0.0718971044,
-0.0067700311,
-0.0250212494,
-0.0515355915,
0.0290604029,
-0.0472009331,
0.0588413924,
-0.0053191013,
0.0190799497,
0.0002175517,
-0.0039169583,
-0.065984033,
-0.0326309279,
0.00227847,
-0.0389033407,
0.0120181218,
-0.0543984994,
-0.0060643284,
-0.0087562753,
-0.0339301862,
-0.0621578284,
-0.0773091614,
0.0082475031,
0.0115366979,
-0.0174545888,
-0.0092676189,
0.0256333891,
-0.0040074266,
0.0245857127,
0.0458711348,
-0.0266315304,
-0.0056622848,
-0.0182988048,
0.0640740469,
0.0798658729,
0.0511397161,
0.0300769545,
0.0052534612,
0.0412408523,
0.0614064448,
0.0254626796,
0.012736585,
0.014413299,
0.0000386967,
-0.0036509321,
-0.0052938196,
0.0116414074,
0.0113534722,
0.1053402051,
-0.0429647267,
-0.0436281934,
0.0959763378,
0.0534387901,
0.0242111422,
0.0053628907,
-0.0377014689,
0.0508089736,
0.0068254052,
0.0312551074,
-0.1083335429,
-0.0601702482,
-0.0142604448,
0.0105253598,
-0.041324392,
-0.0404329672,
-0.0247348193,
-0.1165493503,
0.0215049144,
-0.0069907899,
-0.033193022,
0.0134597635,
-0.0097045302,
-0.002340216,
-0.0010182499,
-0.0007964323,
0.0147285787,
0.0225094128,
0.0179297179,
0.0246189497,
-0.0239080656,
-0.0545792691,
0.0251927357,
-0.0232356582,
0.0501379408,
0.0455950722,
0.033125449,
0.0205655117,
-0.0366183408,
-0.0079068793,
-0.0174369942,
-0.0099543678,
0.0042744009,
0.0469548553,
-0.0106566064,
-0.0157979485,
-0.0363094211,
0.0632438064,
-0.0307382271,
0.0021516066,
0.0253654309,
0.0377750807,
-0.0270615667,
-0.0046741567,
-0.0001391417,
0.0682835653,
0.018554993,
0.1019811034,
0.0771086589,
-0.0100728031,
-0.0144250374,
-0.009114028,
0.0067800055,
-0.090404585,
-0.0008919245,
0.0243550949,
0.0389333554,
-0.007799881,
-0.0949328989,
-0.0463390201,
0.0630558655,
0.0369432271,
-0.0261999574,
-0.003802445,
0.0052349968,
-0.0086504035,
-0.0253237914,
0.0131237591,
-0.0378527306,
-0.0078803655,
-0.0403315425,
-0.0272423103,
0.0001782991,
-0.0316003487,
-0.0127844512,
0.0321890786,
-0.1056662351,
-0.0619392581,
0.0021999739,
0.0435364842,
0.0279361233,
0.0028250394,
-0.0229425002,
-0.0613908507,
-0.0095884502,
0.0269704815,
-0.0390827805,
-0.0096972734,
0.0083890408,
-0.0169739258,
0.0019610887,
0.0730202347,
-0.013269322,
0.0221364871,
-0.0286269803,
0.0523127168,
-0.0575336516,
-0.028735714,
0.0390729159,
0.0080098845,
-0.0151231494,
0.0192591455,
0.0081635788,
-0.0090260152,
0.014727762,
-0.0528604798,
-0.0348554812,
-0.0443142913,
0.0178410001,
-0.010159743,
-0.0286590979,
0.0134911863,
0.0020532114,
-0.0732590184,
0.0348463953,
0.0072504268,
-0.0256814454,
0.0060629915,
0.0235888325,
-0.0309966244,
-0.0336300023,
-0.0252852775,
0.0190684684,
-0.0236578137,
0.0510626473,
0.0300055575,
0.0782805085,
0.0301379189,
0.0221247058,
-0.000598606,
0.0280501507,
-0.0359056629,
-0.0551365986,
0.0409112461,
0.0403037705,
0.0321524441,
0.0125366068,
0.0006500289,
-0.0270437188,
-0.0057348702,
0.0124374134,
0.0412799083,
0.0069268551,
-0.0578902699,
0.0796493217,
0.0308079887,
-0.0273146573,
-0.0196540952,
0.085567683,
-0.0051931902,
0.0111382483,
0.0137038277,
0.0282804482,
-0.0253756605,
-0.0196386874,
0.0084170531,
0.0140176564,
-0.0045738034,
0.0316329114,
-0.0827702135,
-0.0519146882,
-0.0210376084,
0.0234629326,
0.0024633221,
-0.0363238342,
0.0289703514,
0.034887597,
0.0010078326,
-0.038864132,
-0.0554050766,
0.0506562591,
-0.0316731445,
0.0011826153,
-0.0340133421,
-6.590400262e-33,
-0.0242506582,
-0.0625270233,
0.0274792016,
-0.0268485472,
-0.0138312979,
0.0232243426,
-0.0454762802,
0.0018798731,
-0.0501016937,
0.0092129707,
-0.0035402761,
0.020084206,
0.003528713,
0.0393894166,
-0.0509477854,
-0.0545941815,
0.0341912843,
-0.0106544988,
-0.0322748832,
0.0546990074,
0.0322441198,
0.0034101622,
-0.0087085925,
0.0109837428,
0.0183999091,
-0.044841893,
-0.0190171264,
0.0693916678,
-0.0100618312,
0.0503021851,
0.0002375602,
0.023597654,
0.0323895924,
-0.0221731793,
0.0026426427,
0.0427240729,
-0.0452652089,
-0.0464946851,
0.0317274146,
-0.0218504369,
-0.0970754772,
-0.0194631666,
0.0144486045,
-0.0117733069,
0.0235641897,
-0.0082447138,
-0.0030492665,
0.0074939122,
-0.0131766954,
-0.0277333744,
-0.0281160939,
0.0208964907,
-0.0107352743,
-0.0784468874,
-0.0201495551,
0.0579862297,
0.0129317986,
-0.0154005643,
-0.0688586608,
0.0085799173,
0.0012950014,
0.0324712321,
0.0425010882,
0.0063438816,
-0.0002142899,
0.0155280707,
-0.0124882888,
0.0244108215,
-0.0281963423,
0.0211706385,
-0.0102123758,
0.0425730124,
0.0462213047,
0.0765958205,
0.0642342418,
0.0180124752,
-0.0484335981,
0.0522626378,
-0.0269529056,
0.0175500493,
-0.0231266133,
-0.0274729114,
-0.017313499,
0.0061261891,
-0.0462765731,
0.0630796328,
-0.0389489681,
-0.0106093101,
0.0300064813,
-0.0053289412,
-0.0346806087,
-0.001916289,
0.0037285311,
0.0016561688,
0.0393333063,
0.0124198711,
-0.0389864594,
0.0081609255,
0.0086099068,
0.0562098324,
-0.0524583012,
0.0170690846,
0.0595791936,
0.0150391906,
0.0049049514,
0.0265624896,
0.0400881022,
0.0126892608,
-0.0339158289,
-0.0080385301,
-0.0348257422,
0.0704182684,
-0.0527573004,
0.0053386358,
0.0034194984,
0.0404819883,
-0.0404565185,
0.0183852352,
0.0138453608,
-0.0028520706,
-0.0402661264,
-0.0131321652,
-0.0201410316,
0.015136241,
-0.0265687481,
0.0148278754,
-0.0179244149,
-0.0132210134,
0.0140972696,
-0.03972378,
-0.0160815679,
0.0155879306,
2.554e-7,
0.0286273025,
-0.0050376486,
0.0432954133,
0.0607302636,
-0.0090975212,
0.054821182,
-0.0026068478,
0.0417654514,
0.0210596677,
-0.0453246646,
0.0135740368,
0.0247022025,
0.0463662855,
0.0229288433,
-0.0742380545,
0.0093159135,
-0.0310006887,
0.0142938867,
-0.0409115478,
-0.0281436034,
0.0972040892,
0.0621308349,
0.0128045091,
-0.0077708946,
0.0171774495,
-0.0144556379,
0.0602237396,
0.0131439641,
-0.035140615,
0.038831491,
0.0580302924,
0.0049905917,
0.0234633666,
0.0369438231,
-0.0145478202,
-0.008436962,
-0.009982123,
0.0460343435,
0.0101554086,
-0.056507051,
-0.0160433222,
-0.0040008309,
0.0094198696,
-0.0627603531,
0.0916852504,
-0.0686883405,
-0.048491843,
0.0085696736,
-0.0037884917,
0.0239744522,
0.0293146707,
-0.0202322137,
-0.0507574156,
0.0153963836,
0.0362442881,
-0.0207645614,
0.0084673464,
-0.0365969911,
-0.0336367711,
-0.0182151869,
-0.0247739647,
0.0051856167,
-0.0381196849,
-0.0202141311,
-0.0456847474,
-0.0493206903,
0.0003329839,
2.198575987e-34,
0.0017135416,
0.0064090355,
0.0117977727,
0.0073651155,
0.0411041975,
-0.0123246824,
-0.0242703557,
-0.0171366222,
0.0194180571,
-0.0378587954,
-0.0025724696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11564v1 | Personalized Soups: Personalized Large Language Model Alignment via Post-hoc Parameter Merging | 2023-10-17T20:22:13 | 2023-10-17T20:22:13 | Joel Jang, Seungone Kim, Bill Yuchen Lin, Yizhong Wang, Jack Hessel, Luke Zettlemoyer, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Yejin Choi, Prithviraj Ammanabrolu | cs.CL | cs.CL | While Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) aligns Large Language
Models (LLMs) with general, aggregate human preferences, it is suboptimal for
learning diverse, individual perspectives. In this work, we study Reinforcement
Learning from Personalized Human Feedback (RLPHF) problem, wherein LLMs are
aligned to multiple (sometimes conflicting) preferences by modeling alignment
as a Multi-Objective Reinforcement Learning (MORL) problem. Compared to strong
single-objective baselines, we show that we can achieve personalized alignment
by decomposing preferences into multiple dimensions. These dimensions are
defined based on personalizations that are declared as desirable by the user.
In this work, we show that they can be efficiently trained independently in a
distributed manner and combined effectively post-hoc through parameter merging.
The code is available at https://github.com/joeljang/RLPHF. | [
0.0451972708,
0.1025974602,
0.0297677815,
-0.0104322992,
-0.0406657942,
0.005191328,
-0.0307666343,
-0.0317425244,
-0.0069177328,
-0.0169618726,
-0.073301211,
-0.0220971294,
0.0123421168,
-0.0263075028,
-0.0015078299,
-0.0623995736,
0.0706690997,
-0.0142443608,
-0.0592086539,
-0.0234648865,
0.0157499816,
0.0309350807,
0.0066263732,
0.025331622,
0.0437632538,
0.0022860849,
-0.0091139181,
-0.0219234452,
0.0116892885,
0.0293845478,
0.0169327967,
0.0557639599,
-0.0097306063,
0.0487303138,
0.0000017913,
-0.0510016084,
-0.0397879966,
-0.0228875075,
0.022778729,
-0.0323770009,
0.0655574873,
-0.0042233705,
-0.0146591794,
0.0194777753,
-0.0182668883,
-0.0045392006,
0.0602030307,
0.0293614734,
0.0731367022,
0.0836310908,
0.0153660243,
-0.0204443578,
-0.0109365955,
-0.0198193863,
-0.0029654608,
-0.0283293948,
0.027870439,
-0.0303755868,
-0.0082216458,
-0.0031419659,
0.0029736038,
0.0000058179,
-0.0129479291,
0.0117146876,
0.0081085162,
0.0283010136,
0.0038347545,
-0.0186671149,
-0.0275769755,
0.0884105265,
-0.0291094407,
-0.0084769605,
-0.0132612484,
0.0024867237,
0.0118476963,
-0.0091953306,
-0.0279444735,
-0.0056795902,
0.0035689757,
0.0463274382,
-0.0085010929,
-0.0000068638,
0.0248025749,
0.0294719022,
-0.0232299678,
0.0786623061,
0.0099967495,
-0.035111852,
-0.0131276166,
-0.0123426002,
0.0134446658,
-0.0441345647,
-0.0248215906,
0.0080181649,
-0.0855688825,
0.0342437997,
-0.0698429942,
0.007356524,
0.0270766113,
-0.0515495762,
0.0713401064,
0.0450481921,
0.0014823612,
0.0515320189,
0.0282402094,
0.0537209921,
-0.0488221757,
0.0077718263,
-0.0756222829,
-0.0033742872,
-0.0435607359,
0.0235410295,
0.0325169452,
0.030514922,
-0.0150358891,
-0.0217127074,
-0.0462765247,
0.0396142267,
-0.0223046392,
0.0605963804,
0.0178495292,
0.0144660268,
-0.0218797419,
-0.0362086073,
-0.029198911,
0.0608920753,
-0.0152902165,
0.0004094153,
0.0026919018,
0.0242182221,
0.0067105545,
0.0097673368,
-0.004525573,
-0.0315794609,
-0.0076915026,
0.0526397601,
-0.0220123865,
0.0278699044,
0.0069829831,
-0.0114076678,
-0.0092333108,
-0.0495931283,
-0.0636029989,
-0.0836451277,
0.0545587093,
-0.0255225468,
0.0004466556,
-0.0487791523,
-0.0065966668,
0.0086566955,
-0.039262712,
0.0530848168,
0.012781796,
0.0134106372,
0.0090647712,
-0.0192766506,
0.0423039086,
0.0735520273,
-0.0048128772,
0.0430632755,
0.0185567886,
-0.0082821753,
-0.0599210709,
0.0212009884,
-0.0074206106,
0.0275322329,
0.0068922252,
-0.0075544356,
0.0249096341,
0.0674982071,
0.0388432853,
0.0494293794,
-0.0220855065,
-0.0279691815,
0.062040396,
0.0285809729,
0.0419968665,
-0.0118711814,
0.0053634816,
0.0261616781,
-0.0193644799,
0.0227689017,
-0.0441126525,
0.0234428961,
-0.0385069698,
0.0339551792,
0.0568648614,
0.05196907,
-0.01877857,
-0.0376039445,
-0.0100811608,
-0.0328097008,
-0.030578183,
0.0171532054,
0.0505449399,
-0.0230406951,
-0.0425896943,
-0.0021951031,
0.0527407303,
-0.0412795581,
0.023374591,
-0.0099679912,
0.0478613302,
0.0690430254,
0.0197835416,
-0.0162103307,
-0.0392695963,
-0.0247687455,
-0.0360497013,
0.0273332763,
0.0746640712,
-0.028306976,
-0.0269793812,
-0.0583553612,
-0.0410083421,
0.0002089413,
-0.0107574342,
0.0460664593,
0.0391455144,
-0.0279832557,
-0.0209228173,
0.0535202734,
-0.0418154337,
0.0128024286,
-0.0057098819,
-0.0094103375,
-0.0118575646,
0.0282383189,
0.041470468,
-0.0014351242,
0.0230088588,
0.0063096997,
-0.0093738688,
0.0029615576,
-0.0248149112,
-0.0115783932,
-0.0458217934,
-0.0198739544,
0.0430545956,
0.0217969213,
-0.0157316327,
0.0291447695,
-0.0456831641,
-0.044176966,
-0.0087207491,
0.0152492095,
0.0317529403,
-0.0101687824,
0.0345699526,
0.0034194435,
-0.0113789635,
-0.061381299,
0.0378671251,
-0.0177281089,
0.0197100956,
-0.0012960258,
-0.0260237791,
0.0075952462,
-0.0255230162,
-0.0175225101,
0.0087337904,
0.0137708057,
0.0531094,
0.0446788445,
0.0023841038,
-0.0663516298,
-0.0410327837,
-0.0775316656,
0.033491727,
0.0023293886,
0.0226269737,
0.0286316238,
0.0133533543,
0.0241983943,
-0.0151565364,
-0.0518887714,
-0.0185538791,
-0.0122538498,
0.0146881659,
0.0323468447,
0.0111534148,
0.0089364061,
-0.0517010167,
-0.017050026,
-0.0353239365,
0.0194257498,
-0.0341211483,
0.0203061979,
-0.0642739162,
-0.0305356104,
-0.0482329912,
0.0398137718,
-0.0095574735,
-0.0262145884,
-0.014358459,
-0.0291528422,
0.0617715344,
0.1002713293,
0.0159323066,
0.0284386631,
0.0689809471,
0.0041060187,
-0.0693180785,
-0.0052187932,
-0.0620989427,
-0.0439490527,
-0.0562565066,
-0.0101779113,
0.0215074141,
0.0704812035,
-0.0106968554,
-0.0028127048,
-0.0960495844,
0.0204062052,
0.0086895311,
-0.024225384,
-0.0460544787,
0.0154292826,
-0.0368909985,
0.0322895572,
-0.0317998677,
-0.0508237891,
0.1009177491,
0.0193554591,
0.0134362709,
-0.0353446715,
-0.0175543409,
-0.063676469,
0.0175890829,
-0.0187333636,
0.0479637682,
-0.0152176693,
-0.012602956,
-0.0887576044,
-0.0307295006,
0.0439393148,
-0.035757266,
0.0374589935,
-0.0083157169,
-0.0111944871,
-0.0085568773,
-0.0639631078,
-0.0285762735,
-0.0688304752,
-0.0009841814,
-0.0104787247,
0.0149934338,
-0.0592579022,
-0.0516780131,
-0.0065821172,
0.0143089024,
0.0041621919,
-0.0138984714,
0.005080719,
-0.0312215872,
-0.0019671388,
0.0880717859,
0.0300960448,
-0.0006496979,
-0.0343476608,
0.0057052993,
0.0275065508,
0.0868347734,
-0.0220582653,
-0.0090956967,
0.0172644146,
0.0741678402,
-0.0562987104,
-0.0002542089,
-0.0073414631,
0.0058931718,
0.003910759,
0.0301686507,
0.100693576,
0.0458464772,
-0.0510365814,
-0.0108854352,
-0.0004093647,
0.0518385284,
0.0063875471,
0.0581317395,
-0.0183964577,
-0.0034923237,
-0.0113567328,
0.0173467845,
0.0000050275,
0.0012883131,
-0.053270556,
-0.134224385,
-0.04916922,
0.0433893055,
-0.0413455665,
0.0322003663,
-0.0034033353,
0.024559645,
-0.0482220314,
0.017735973,
0.0133393668,
0.0055332324,
-0.0207791757,
0.0061875354,
0.0211083591,
-0.0250632185,
0.0005029311,
-0.0339909308,
0.0682951286,
0.065475367,
0.0291461386,
0.0176896937,
-0.0369617604,
0.0365436375,
0.0334216543,
-0.0366769247,
0.0178062506,
0.0042727427,
-0.0430008918,
0.0084183123,
-0.0216299351,
0.0566425845,
-0.0182897281,
0.000687814,
-0.0220674388,
0.0606417768,
0.0236501098,
0.0380755439,
0.0070531587,
-0.0107771382,
-0.0056840386,
0.0578513741,
-0.047969576,
-0.083599478,
-0.0000313504,
0.0031715359,
-0.0696534216,
-0.0093052713,
-0.0241214782,
0.0345786251,
-0.0557832755,
-0.0235974733,
-0.0745027214,
-0.0154844746,
-0.0036937085,
0.0586800426,
0.0253939535,
0.007860125,
-0.0110342018,
-0.0259412788,
0.0237155538,
0.0487860851,
-0.035909377,
0.0018460725,
-0.098576501,
-0.0072573223,
0.0587834232,
-0.0569748394,
-0.0065402109,
-0.0051292777,
-0.0683614984,
-0.0804150403,
-0.007025138,
0.0296145119,
0.015006681,
0.0804334059,
-0.0070529305,
-0.0538441651,
0.0246188138,
0.0377384126,
-0.0198277775,
0.0106852241,
0.0228726584,
0.0394435003,
-0.003876182,
0.0501307249,
-0.0305889752,
-0.0164566729,
-0.0075396784,
0.0036842222,
-0.0290872063,
-0.0474608131,
0.0520454235,
-0.008299876,
0.0395597443,
-0.0268142428,
-0.0269449838,
-0.0366554596,
-0.0085821161,
0.0010844896,
-0.0695785955,
-0.0093826745,
-0.0441123284,
0.0523320362,
-0.0261536799,
0.0179658607,
0.0042711725,
0.0433898941,
0.0063795042,
-0.0300594997,
-0.0339654088,
0.0136225307,
-0.0051586065,
0.0332775787,
0.0358181112,
-0.0063715172,
0.0543950312,
-0.0088665951,
0.0351333767,
-0.0059421021,
0.048499994,
0.0452106856,
-0.0012429918,
-0.0242079124,
0.0287358668,
-0.0586881228,
-0.0419702269,
-0.0198837258,
-0.0050230492,
0.037462052,
0.0003544527,
0.0545904078,
-0.0102057736,
-0.0171503071,
-0.0215282943,
0.0243812967,
-0.0329263732,
0.006850786,
0.0176757276,
0.015443936,
-0.0052899853,
0.0146494461,
0.0518775582,
-0.0083699292,
-0.0130305775,
-0.0385502763,
0.0103280619,
-0.0448781848,
-0.0010983129,
0.0088218478,
0.0685062855,
-0.0442523211,
-0.0158291422,
-0.033293765,
-0.0247102026,
-0.0188364629,
0.044632636,
-0.03835449,
0.0311171301,
0.0434830673,
0.0481876768,
-0.0605209433,
0.0152193317,
-0.0525634997,
-0.028236175,
-0.0242340881,
-0.0417943634,
0.0158096794,
-6.36474355e-33,
-0.0299089123,
-0.0130013963,
0.0175640155,
-0.0169021375,
-0.0309352744,
-0.0405336358,
0.0375084952,
0.0295025036,
-0.0080300272,
-0.0350429453,
0.0008777831,
-0.0242677741,
0.0130285351,
0.007567395,
0.0249261707,
0.0080970144,
0.0418872051,
0.0155606261,
-0.0425328463,
-0.0294912159,
0.0425251238,
-0.0083963992,
0.0178524964,
-0.0434766896,
0.0436378531,
0.0049737664,
-0.0399545506,
0.0348511487,
-0.0094670206,
0.0805202648,
0.0133376298,
0.0173609015,
-0.0138314795,
0.0042945808,
-0.0146054523,
0.0256834924,
-0.0468860753,
-0.047646448,
0.055519741,
0.0122621674,
-0.0617306866,
-0.038494572,
0.0258663539,
-0.0154239712,
0.003053321,
-0.0109920222,
0.0257148594,
0.0035708777,
-0.0459486321,
0.0448610894,
-0.0296966247,
0.0125288442,
0.0077355145,
-0.007458094,
0.0188401025,
0.0044858265,
-0.0000992793,
0.0322191305,
0.0233668108,
0.0498678498,
-0.0298082046,
0.0217278562,
0.0839453638,
0.0559915081,
-0.0060467268,
0.038760595,
0.0113743795,
-0.0217082277,
0.0252464171,
-0.0373899899,
0.0117739271,
0.0447737761,
0.0113359392,
0.0781447217,
-0.0302938242,
0.0246774461,
0.015013841,
0.0404060856,
0.0222554337,
-0.0102222944,
0.0122306487,
0.0456420965,
-0.0334112011,
-0.0099174269,
-0.0661166683,
-0.0242400356,
-0.0513118543,
-0.0353045017,
0.0068643228,
0.0236111637,
-0.0148232374,
-0.0225771498,
0.030107405,
-0.0449719913,
-0.0081944875,
0.0102110393,
-0.035079129,
0.0258044768,
-0.0298702791,
0.0100004561,
-0.0717483312,
-0.0257276427,
-0.0135468328,
-0.0353980288,
-0.0081176646,
0.0305957012,
0.0315122344,
0.0145420553,
-0.0657386929,
0.0190554596,
-0.0099825012,
-0.0241168961,
-0.0128213931,
0.0027398679,
0.0968637839,
-0.0132568162,
-0.0177297108,
0.0631918386,
0.0370435528,
0.0007865739,
-0.0336020477,
-0.0349619724,
-0.0061238101,
0.0046222918,
0.0044660345,
0.0226390306,
-0.0062919222,
-0.0104363328,
0.0128760887,
0.0099203279,
-0.0046819281,
0.0205524713,
2.583e-7,
-0.0086889323,
0.0398544818,
0.0138758551,
0.0153098181,
-0.025582986,
0.0358699374,
-0.0278540738,
0.020735167,
-0.0299328268,
0.0230377074,
0.0359576903,
0.0254220087,
0.0473326668,
0.0099353231,
-0.0776664987,
0.0146681145,
-0.0645546243,
0.0415166728,
-0.0489044003,
-0.0163775962,
0.0372677892,
0.0979237705,
0.0903390422,
0.0171234999,
0.0087599577,
0.0204189606,
0.0744947046,
-0.0475430712,
-0.042701453,
0.0447793677,
-0.0223501772,
-0.0126648461,
-0.0207513012,
-0.0143048177,
0.0089868726,
0.0238739513,
-0.007788091,
0.0801705196,
-0.0077262493,
-0.0407063663,
-0.0146382032,
0.0182414465,
-0.0102037992,
-0.0763311982,
0.0382275805,
-0.0095968591,
-0.0343062803,
-0.0440523401,
0.0280165821,
-0.0053381617,
0.0335856639,
-0.0203904621,
-0.0006403986,
0.0061661014,
0.0223134141,
0.0172234755,
-0.030753525,
-0.0772560388,
-0.0325683355,
0.017277183,
-0.0257521588,
-0.0410460308,
-0.0083031254,
0.0352370031,
0.0243630633,
-0.0772092268,
-0.0136667462,
2.209660761e-34,
0.0241021086,
-0.0185357612,
0.0193777699,
-0.006897347,
0.0075790947,
0.0058338051,
-0.0341086388,
0.0300552454,
0.0854370818,
-0.0592948012,
-0.0176766925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11541v1 | MUST&P-SRL: Multi-lingual and Unified Syllabification in Text and Phonetic Domains for Speech Representation Learning | 2023-10-17T19:27:23 | 2023-10-17T19:27:23 | Noé Tits | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | In this paper, we present a methodology for linguistic feature extraction,
focusing particularly on automatically syllabifying words in multiple
languages, with a design to be compatible with a forced-alignment tool, the
Montreal Forced Aligner (MFA). In both the textual and phonetic domains, our
method focuses on the extraction of phonetic transcriptions from text, stress
marks, and a unified automatic syllabification (in text and phonetic domains).
The system was built with open-source components and resources. Through an
ablation study, we demonstrate the efficacy of our approach in automatically
syllabifying words from several languages (English, French and Spanish).
Additionally, we apply the technique to the transcriptions of the CMU ARCTIC
dataset, generating valuable annotations available
online\footnote{\url{https://github.com/noetits/MUST_P-SRL}} that are ideal for
speech representation learning, speech unit discovery, and disentanglement of
speech factors in several speech-related fields. | [
-0.0399630889,
0.0287108682,
0.0145372329,
-0.0094801215,
-0.0303251427,
0.0110638887,
0.0732747018,
-0.0720899329,
-0.023420494,
0.0163648669,
-0.0306106023,
0.0051451377,
0.0416600369,
-0.029466616,
0.0525833592,
-0.0581316575,
0.0363759547,
-0.0192972291,
0.020127479,
0.0015051177,
0.0538860299,
0.0573291853,
-0.0461898819,
0.0287643448,
-0.0414537862,
-0.0054143416,
-0.0089555522,
0.0353018679,
0.0434223786,
0.009580791,
-0.015917547,
0.0491515473,
-0.0122849597,
0.0596755147,
0.0000019915,
-0.061061535,
-0.0542856194,
0.0138981454,
0.0006184874,
0.0298244078,
0.0441900231,
-0.0281531885,
-0.0250915885,
0.0407541431,
0.0069731106,
-0.0453379117,
0.10414505,
-0.0210131947,
0.0100914026,
0.0274141151,
-0.0291481726,
-0.0414709412,
-0.0375421531,
-0.0017812194,
-0.0456542857,
0.0522889681,
0.0075935787,
-0.0541502051,
0.0141270505,
-0.0588137843,
-0.0110269105,
0.0709867552,
-0.0335562304,
-0.0107631134,
-0.0297616515,
-0.0050345841,
-0.0465051271,
-0.0713959932,
0.011029901,
0.0406139456,
-0.0127281714,
-0.0412971452,
0.010894184,
0.0521783642,
-0.0157873612,
0.0093111116,
0.010888679,
-0.0479408801,
0.0365457833,
-0.0051398361,
0.0589892901,
0.0516961105,
0.0308979694,
-0.063674517,
-0.0243801046,
-0.0023524479,
0.0223415717,
-0.0414835513,
0.028558217,
-0.0298271067,
0.020346012,
0.0416630208,
0.0545555353,
-0.0119235562,
-0.0165720098,
0.0093400665,
-0.0104022529,
-0.0977708548,
0.0391995087,
-0.0066662407,
-0.0358483009,
-0.0017264131,
-0.0576213896,
0.0295680929,
-0.0090838522,
0.0224622656,
0.0023894594,
0.001488056,
-0.0430357754,
-0.0212246217,
-0.015054401,
0.0287329629,
-0.0094497334,
-0.0217515882,
-0.0050348542,
0.0258391201,
-0.0317221284,
-0.0134768803,
-0.0066585653,
0.0375351831,
0.0067265369,
-0.0114332857,
-0.0413613692,
0.0203936622,
0.0607137568,
0.0607351065,
-0.0333402343,
0.0332350694,
-0.0769248754,
-0.0478269458,
0.0121333357,
0.0356860124,
0.0456332043,
-0.0068046721,
0.0317603461,
0.001740245,
-0.0106338207,
-0.0226769932,
-0.0142160384,
0.0050495458,
-0.0565925352,
-0.0293206833,
-0.0573124737,
-0.0998295173,
0.0440111198,
-0.0010488334,
-0.0103847105,
-0.0263967235,
-0.0072177402,
-0.0429449081,
0.0342388526,
0.0563427098,
-0.0022885413,
0.0004050092,
0.0257822722,
-0.025712112,
0.0561784953,
0.0545742773,
0.0184846595,
-0.0329438299,
0.0375134982,
-0.0834800676,
-0.0293256324,
0.0888521597,
-0.011507283,
0.0217651445,
-0.0043323203,
-0.0562873892,
0.0204464626,
0.0115856128,
0.0609926917,
0.07709153,
0.0188082531,
-0.0669415891,
0.0326828137,
0.056906119,
0.0479659326,
0.0355884172,
0.0147825731,
-0.0025446091,
-0.0097983973,
0.0104962057,
0.003094523,
-0.0165635291,
0.0218596868,
0.0322096907,
0.0083141923,
0.0532924011,
-0.0165967103,
0.0005781373,
-0.0220889933,
-0.0258921292,
0.00682677,
0.0574350543,
0.0672005266,
0.0052638897,
-0.0269629005,
0.0575482547,
0.0320767127,
-0.0329320282,
0.0199734196,
0.0440602191,
-0.0207877439,
0.0025427893,
0.0009357887,
-0.053124357,
-0.0017726811,
-0.0567736104,
-0.0280496776,
0.0228332486,
-0.0013064548,
-0.01084371,
0.0448887385,
-0.0635721534,
0.0157611892,
0.0641796142,
0.0082134595,
0.0168464072,
-0.0210756399,
0.0170267895,
-0.0145111978,
-0.0247303136,
-0.028398063,
-0.0021485086,
-0.0138565013,
-0.0646579415,
-0.0268776156,
0.023060292,
0.0518265627,
0.0612436235,
-0.033367008,
0.0194042195,
0.0575352013,
-0.045235768,
0.0687650293,
0.0389112979,
-0.0092805903,
-0.0248908438,
0.0591048077,
-0.0662623048,
-0.0200760029,
0.0377008654,
0.0114485342,
-0.0617858022,
0.0179018509,
-0.0219570342,
0.0455584526,
-0.0398727544,
0.0204931591,
0.0075502358,
0.0410932004,
-0.018992316,
-0.0278074313,
0.0199944861,
0.0206267238,
0.0084837703,
-0.0405108929,
-0.0015175958,
-0.0619492419,
-0.0136736892,
0.0329087339,
-0.0241731647,
0.0051911245,
-0.0122141335,
-0.0212679021,
-0.004683903,
-0.0284677837,
-0.0703367367,
-0.0148550533,
-0.0413957797,
0.0137050077,
0.0024797944,
0.0235356241,
0.0139346877,
-0.0229444318,
-0.0119038001,
-0.0680252537,
-0.0069781467,
-0.0305305179,
-0.0113170771,
-0.0134428879,
-0.0692107826,
-0.0394163281,
-0.0108113466,
-0.0049304608,
0.0115883993,
-0.0119409291,
-0.0281984992,
-0.0170383565,
0.0357075445,
-0.0036642994,
-0.0047197589,
0.032615196,
-0.0483152084,
-0.0044334107,
-0.0106821349,
0.0528585948,
0.0149457417,
-0.0130695766,
-0.0038467085,
0.0229143184,
-0.0194093138,
-0.017549362,
0.0044963243,
-0.0242643543,
0.0522459373,
-0.0375478156,
0.0156970154,
0.0085028866,
0.0372687578,
0.0024150347,
0.0192459282,
-0.0317797922,
-0.0613740571,
0.0163942203,
-0.0375379995,
0.0074551911,
0.0315522552,
-0.0563878641,
-0.0298196226,
-0.0166126881,
-0.0386354998,
0.0391341597,
-0.0704466552,
-0.0708709359,
-0.0845508873,
-0.0682390407,
-0.014149921,
0.0176437087,
-0.0665314272,
0.0146431401,
0.008520782,
-0.0594355091,
-0.0226901807,
0.0258696228,
0.0409782901,
-0.0260564666,
-0.0022642531,
-0.0146438144,
-0.0372503437,
-0.0029409479,
-0.01721601,
-0.0008274502,
0.0040206956,
-0.0426961556,
0.0039393147,
0.008425544,
-0.0335780643,
0.0126889525,
-0.0153185269,
0.0487390943,
0.0077815033,
0.0216785595,
0.0466199555,
-0.0076967794,
0.0156239225,
0.0559820868,
0.0272535812,
0.0093564847,
-0.0088491216,
0.0037660277,
-0.0283375978,
0.0830994695,
-0.0029002808,
0.0160510913,
-0.0222318731,
0.070993349,
-0.0076775793,
-0.0109968623,
-0.0005156892,
-0.0237477496,
0.0151675893,
0.0401841067,
0.0950695574,
0.0026645935,
0.0069295475,
0.0221326426,
0.0216166582,
0.0799781159,
0.0229618922,
-0.0265329834,
-0.0366921984,
0.0072321496,
0.032227885,
0.0271191765,
0.04490491,
0.0483127646,
-0.0087459264,
-0.0208258387,
0.0228926726,
0.0568848699,
-0.0417005569,
-0.0290642492,
-0.0252386108,
-0.0412012115,
-0.062025629,
0.0035883787,
0.0320944451,
0.000074484,
-0.0034224081,
0.040350765,
-0.0311470646,
-0.0169119537,
-0.0167014431,
-0.0675632805,
0.0399967916,
0.0161010753,
0.0403414667,
-0.0559756309,
-0.0676566064,
-0.004268175,
-0.0232808515,
-0.0544569194,
-0.0061716465,
-0.0077963253,
0.0282215439,
-0.0438702814,
-0.0220230464,
0.0454145074,
-0.0260282885,
0.0222677961,
0.0145807415,
0.0514090434,
0.0193063971,
0.049526915,
0.041298423,
0.0289075673,
-0.0210647322,
0.0253701694,
0.0081026275,
-0.0276233349,
-0.0324504524,
0.0357357264,
0.0246007927,
0.0093032261,
-0.0198406894,
0.0513362288,
-0.0357882157,
-0.0590878204,
-0.0361437723,
-0.0249205921,
0.0017424969,
0.0716835186,
0.0293404516,
0.0224726014,
0.0011141702,
-0.0013408425,
-0.0283506848,
0.0133767016,
0.0187765509,
0.0256699938,
-0.0371466056,
-0.0149990348,
-0.0194283165,
-0.0350487605,
0.0181594826,
0.0121926283,
-0.0135549353,
-0.0566582121,
0.0756398365,
-0.0013898938,
0.0201082677,
0.0443152227,
-0.0343380757,
-0.0381143466,
0.0348831676,
-0.0076788631,
-0.036503531,
0.0314025171,
0.0387375951,
-0.0562841669,
-0.0132894106,
-0.0046180352,
-0.0281608328,
0.0027967726,
-0.0489363112,
0.0174280666,
-0.013226063,
-0.0399106555,
0.014261622,
0.0187347587,
0.0676216111,
-0.0185705721,
-0.029125683,
-0.0530027971,
0.0054689688,
0.0385750383,
0.0457035303,
-0.0174459852,
0.0105594452,
0.0488265492,
0.0350819193,
-0.0124392863,
-0.0089392932,
0.0188658368,
-0.042483449,
0.0303269029,
0.0387924649,
0.0338668041,
-0.0005870431,
-0.0142351417,
0.0335593894,
-0.0178502817,
0.0859316662,
-0.0187811367,
0.0305468701,
0.011743444,
-0.04445263,
-0.0187576246,
0.0167050418,
0.0121916942,
0.0376130082,
0.0031939119,
0.0033444834,
-0.0070576924,
-0.0302530006,
0.0999422893,
0.0059289807,
0.1121979877,
-0.0118476339,
0.0089368755,
-0.0467136502,
0.0164674819,
-0.0441348515,
0.0422237962,
-0.0314429365,
-0.0048218309,
-0.0404966697,
-0.0065951212,
0.0110357543,
0.0297667813,
0.0068709399,
0.0047365283,
0.0039750524,
-0.0478857718,
-0.0263320096,
-0.0328602679,
-0.032097578,
-0.0789439604,
-0.0571945347,
-0.0681734756,
-0.0552698039,
0.041738227,
-0.0141618988,
-0.0056852931,
0.0060147014,
-0.0066234348,
0.0147392359,
-0.0463755354,
0.0290538091,
0.0000748445,
-0.0428733043,
-0.0122481119,
-0.0558803454,
0.0452568717,
-6.065950518e-33,
0.0165595207,
0.0105797593,
-0.0232553277,
0.0277063884,
-0.0324637741,
0.0479921922,
0.0174233317,
0.026416311,
-0.0064851078,
0.0153642921,
0.0359837189,
-0.0333730541,
0.0281012766,
-0.0141010573,
-0.0039574038,
-0.0075182519,
0.0573436469,
0.0091361562,
0.0171526987,
-0.013133483,
0.0658459887,
0.0539585054,
0.0771100298,
-0.0802346766,
-0.007011821,
0.004565225,
-0.0099127786,
-0.0125008961,
0.0300992634,
0.0314189605,
0.0036438189,
0.04666619,
-0.0453001037,
-0.0066163018,
-0.0185398646,
0.0051306225,
-0.1270400733,
-0.0005770547,
0.0310922973,
0.0555255264,
-0.0103857238,
-0.0068650618,
0.0347546116,
-0.0330794267,
-0.0134956026,
0.0046010292,
0.0252442956,
0.0018643818,
0.0086926604,
-0.0763103291,
-0.0502750911,
0.0230048522,
0.003107067,
-0.0185487363,
0.0656799302,
0.0917283222,
-0.0012044593,
-0.0443568081,
-0.021280827,
0.0030268023,
-0.0230327938,
0.0527351573,
0.0440458655,
0.0226453375,
-0.0103225037,
0.0001476113,
0.0361966901,
-0.087701723,
0.0758498162,
0.0027284641,
0.0814691633,
0.035834834,
0.034841761,
0.0788267106,
-0.0244664066,
-0.0220653582,
-0.0278786477,
-0.014791389,
0.0513896383,
-0.0187503584,
-0.0176380351,
0.0329278,
-0.0385128669,
0.0041737077,
-0.031383276,
0.0188137442,
0.0127178989,
-0.0160499848,
0.0235662404,
0.0086234463,
-0.0013096863,
0.014821019,
0.0554860458,
0.0169709604,
0.0024804806,
-0.0031795555,
0.0164901633,
-0.0273066405,
-0.0171376485,
-0.0017381804,
-0.0232961345,
-0.0071954438,
0.0489436127,
-0.0118374145,
0.0271562934,
-0.02874282,
0.0008303736,
0.0307754911,
-0.0514846258,
0.0191533659,
0.0135508785,
0.0012659819,
-0.011301104,
-0.0355624296,
0.0481874831,
-0.0326974578,
0.015523565,
-0.0347416997,
0.0630453154,
0.0257594585,
0.0118223326,
0.0310806353,
-0.0315483995,
0.0343475491,
-0.0407756604,
0.0001375603,
0.0264866631,
-0.0431567878,
0.019484615,
-0.0158195794,
0.0036039411,
-0.028648736,
2.719e-7,
0.0188529175,
0.0243022125,
0.052633781,
-0.0670736879,
0.0314512253,
0.0074311439,
-0.0261003617,
0.0088712974,
-0.0016727383,
-0.0144290505,
0.0142286094,
-0.0480887704,
0.092460379,
0.031159889,
-0.0966306329,
-0.034456186,
-0.0303818602,
0.0052722334,
-0.0547894128,
0.0033021404,
0.0295038391,
0.0946488827,
0.005405284,
-0.0127085103,
0.0031969298,
-0.0315822363,
-0.0021208259,
-0.0254551731,
0.0080617471,
-0.0498632304,
0.0041801194,
-0.0772363171,
-0.0048155989,
-0.0274528824,
-0.0377680808,
0.0312299449,
0.0167610366,
0.0357618406,
0.0017867914,
-0.0382534787,
0.024463173,
0.0259064846,
-0.0427231789,
-0.0979110226,
0.0119227003,
0.0432595201,
-0.0155617483,
-0.0178080015,
-0.040126998,
0.0377106592,
0.0471919924,
0.0166260358,
-0.0054196985,
0.0107804639,
0.0343330465,
-0.0353124142,
-0.0260484722,
-0.0116430735,
-0.0609595142,
0.0590446554,
-0.0117167924,
0.0006847694,
0.0270104203,
-0.0256646238,
-0.016562609,
-0.0216324478,
-0.0224421024,
2.659228116e-34,
-0.014077466,
-0.0207796562,
0.0288020466,
0.0290529523,
-0.0046466514,
-0.0613857321,
-0.0312761813,
0.0621437952,
0.0361773297,
-0.0012394234,
-0.0211312864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11532v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11532v2 | Multi-stage Large Language Model Correction for Speech Recognition | 2023-10-17T19:02:40 | 2024-06-17T15:21:50 | Jie Pu, Thai-Son Nguyen, Sebastian Stüker | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | In this paper, we investigate the usage of large language models (LLMs) to
improve the performance of competitive speech recognition systems. Different
from previous LLM-based ASR error correction methods, we propose a novel
multi-stage approach that utilizes uncertainty estimation of ASR outputs and
reasoning capability of LLMs. Specifically, the proposed approach has two
stages: the first stage is about ASR uncertainty estimation and exploits N-best
list hypotheses to identify less reliable transcriptions; The second stage
works on these identified transcriptions and performs LLM-based corrections.
This correction task is formulated as a multi-step rule-based LLM reasoning
process, which uses explicitly written rules in prompts to decompose the task
into concrete reasoning steps. Our experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed method by showing 10% ~ 20% relative improvement
in WER over competitive ASR systems -- across multiple test domains and in
zero-shot settings. | [
0.0105572166,
0.0223710276,
0.0054818955,
0.0287159123,
-0.03698989,
0.0219183583,
0.0213999171,
-0.0210507754,
-0.0113946581,
-0.0448300615,
-0.025126623,
-0.070255667,
0.0528912358,
-0.0199303273,
0.0090726558,
0.01424002,
0.0164193101,
-0.1063322797,
0.0370074101,
-0.0274685919,
-0.0136200627,
0.0089838309,
-0.0177950636,
0.0347029939,
0.0237097703,
0.0180708896,
0.0256793667,
0.035529986,
0.0146393003,
-0.03021162,
-0.0176896118,
0.0170726851,
0.0212174058,
0.0405196734,
0.0000017358,
-0.0625194758,
-0.002012149,
0.0300413929,
-0.0824207887,
0.0236445162,
0.0149160726,
0.0314777903,
-0.0375687554,
0.066341497,
0.0331863128,
-0.0306590106,
0.0626482666,
0.0149138551,
-0.0048809219,
0.0546492562,
0.0077188793,
-0.0551680923,
-0.0144612566,
0.003080074,
-0.0536273345,
-0.0453225672,
0.0474273339,
-0.0039542802,
0.0053644539,
-0.0450858623,
0.0136543382,
0.0247110669,
-0.0166525207,
-0.0211929046,
-0.0360531323,
-0.0237376317,
0.0080265449,
-0.0242023282,
-0.0346190557,
-0.0060068415,
-0.0007277385,
-0.0340763405,
0.0032184534,
0.002309503,
-0.0232153647,
-0.0135217309,
-0.0107790828,
0.0461296439,
-0.0215608571,
0.0031176873,
0.0184779875,
-0.0199533273,
0.0269969087,
0.010132785,
-0.0869919062,
0.0739477277,
0.0090458645,
-0.0415471755,
-0.0006527469,
-0.0261529386,
0.0036217363,
-0.0321118161,
0.0795762837,
0.0242488757,
-0.0513582788,
0.005901414,
0.0106010931,
-0.0068006036,
0.0089775287,
-0.0620740578,
0.0315426961,
0.054643929,
-0.0348032266,
0.0164166018,
-0.0146531016,
0.0884177014,
0.0204365049,
-0.0354836285,
-0.0316498093,
-0.0098460326,
-0.0149544878,
0.0085325195,
-0.0114398766,
0.0280358158,
-0.0217221994,
-0.0224677324,
-0.0637420043,
0.0240556542,
0.014235029,
0.052897118,
0.0360153541,
-0.0600576177,
-0.0141252102,
-0.0391541757,
-0.0047625843,
0.0289318524,
0.0627796054,
0.022777753,
-0.0181138068,
-0.0751698315,
-0.0010355045,
-0.001560242,
0.0429885723,
-0.0094183479,
0.0050558522,
0.0487367995,
0.0108485995,
-0.0344843753,
-0.020437384,
0.0201865528,
-0.0228064321,
-0.0518380404,
-0.0408326536,
-0.0325671472,
-0.0145252477,
0.0100350939,
0.0158869438,
-0.0154041257,
0.0138774905,
-0.0153362965,
0.0104549238,
0.0829287246,
-0.0019783794,
0.0246900469,
0.0300423875,
-0.0230109338,
0.0000696845,
0.0372908264,
0.0430735648,
-0.0319980606,
-0.0087378938,
-0.0403779559,
0.0172787067,
0.0445511527,
-0.0574378967,
-0.0344897099,
-0.0267066285,
-0.0199939981,
0.0161789861,
0.0208766442,
0.0057015643,
0.070415847,
-0.0260321926,
0.0456018634,
0.045572076,
0.0317801796,
0.0409947634,
-0.0088185687,
0.0112112192,
-0.0202241521,
0.0116993487,
0.0006636766,
-0.0290863514,
-0.0332829095,
-0.0405024514,
0.0380168259,
0.0155866528,
0.0654393509,
0.0032112983,
-0.0186443198,
-0.057531517,
-0.003324281,
-0.0249129757,
0.0827445164,
0.0952385142,
-0.0459168777,
-0.048733227,
0.0086961621,
0.0019589881,
-0.027347466,
0.0256624874,
-0.0801206976,
0.0231671613,
0.073121056,
0.0460683927,
-0.0366058834,
-0.0362458453,
-0.0291781537,
-0.0429090075,
0.0479810983,
0.0152512388,
0.0148054622,
0.0133738285,
-0.0822368488,
0.0060019824,
0.0867232382,
0.0027247239,
0.0537865832,
-0.0370368361,
-0.021634914,
0.0266274568,
0.0110375378,
-0.0273788292,
-0.012759055,
0.0203633979,
-0.0072304485,
0.0307459813,
-0.0060419114,
0.0747944862,
0.0329412222,
-0.0449992493,
-0.0038952834,
0.020739682,
-0.0129028782,
-0.0056577134,
0.0057520317,
-0.0518613607,
-0.0292333756,
0.0911174268,
0.0366147645,
-0.0174343809,
0.0062268176,
0.0081068324,
-0.0582199916,
-0.0246358607,
-0.0389473811,
0.0190940443,
-0.0660556406,
0.1026658416,
0.0419352539,
-0.0218709093,
-0.0257533528,
-0.0117492573,
0.0318624601,
0.0047287578,
0.053336855,
-0.0266617704,
-0.0137654208,
-0.0797486082,
-0.0001999572,
0.0718959197,
-0.0213346612,
-0.013860439,
0.0113224834,
-0.005024747,
0.0103407484,
-0.0277025905,
-0.0481240451,
-0.0279230122,
-0.0312388372,
0.0259885695,
-0.0256508235,
0.0041999072,
0.004704407,
-0.0273469705,
-0.0056991051,
-0.026245689,
-0.0028635226,
0.0073916307,
-0.0328109786,
-0.0059605166,
-0.0671388656,
0.0013775254,
0.0127020171,
-0.0058488958,
0.0303406436,
-0.0098425094,
-0.0421509892,
-0.1407163888,
0.0319877975,
-0.0025473509,
0.0204683207,
0.0091642523,
-0.019014271,
-0.0110810911,
-0.0145619595,
0.0200395733,
0.0270723514,
-0.0145030152,
-0.0225428473,
0.0526965335,
-0.0523941629,
-0.0433104597,
-0.0000175871,
0.0305828881,
-0.0209000167,
-0.028428955,
-0.0170450825,
-0.0475614592,
0.0155285345,
0.0243002716,
0.0254641529,
-0.0321133956,
-0.0212100763,
-0.0163154081,
-0.0086627575,
-0.0358675905,
-0.0645726696,
-0.0200227443,
0.0101160035,
0.0064068446,
-0.0110706761,
0.0429340973,
-0.0932591036,
-0.0058071776,
-0.0399749205,
-0.0422963463,
-0.0005962746,
-0.0143091111,
-0.0169875678,
0.0085154017,
0.000501529,
-0.0796993673,
0.0108757066,
-0.0120089818,
0.0436374247,
-0.0669287071,
0.0499812327,
-0.0662105009,
0.0333011821,
-0.0274976399,
-0.048305802,
-0.0087352255,
0.0203642882,
-0.0495804138,
0.0272587854,
0.0055823247,
-0.023780629,
-0.0263048839,
0.057019446,
0.0113696279,
0.0642989874,
0.0083818287,
0.0203853771,
-0.0186398495,
0.0270667095,
0.0246657021,
0.0515200272,
0.0368359387,
-0.0067461249,
0.0607475229,
-0.017125085,
0.0434950367,
-0.0037472362,
-0.0341314562,
-0.0110941082,
0.0711512789,
-0.023861587,
0.0069140713,
0.0292633772,
0.0453516357,
-0.0522112548,
0.0245994553,
0.1234483644,
0.0131387925,
0.0157359857,
-0.026604699,
-0.0262299534,
-0.0222607404,
0.0081646796,
-0.0003231357,
-0.0405253507,
-0.0048648571,
0.0897479355,
0.0265830327,
-0.0103902463,
0.0383253917,
-0.0114580663,
-0.0964123011,
0.0821997151,
0.0393428653,
-0.0230665077,
-0.0465008244,
-0.0168984849,
-0.0127428044,
-0.0111418935,
0.0587742999,
0.058412455,
0.0108787445,
-0.049272541,
0.0578703955,
-0.0726260096,
-0.0899541378,
-0.0128442952,
-0.0284494385,
0.1018849313,
0.0566196591,
-0.0096315993,
0.0072199232,
-0.0111959204,
0.0276545566,
-0.0260063186,
0.030410381,
-0.0351968333,
-0.0372838117,
0.0340637788,
-0.0129340608,
0.0118820686,
0.0184340812,
0.0046591088,
-0.01148766,
0.0040444834,
0.0516976938,
-0.0600256845,
0.0067735412,
0.0498295613,
-0.0224584863,
-0.0102942158,
0.0506365672,
0.0008511939,
-0.000496356,
0.0005418317,
-0.0178431962,
0.0107668368,
-0.0092078988,
0.0291603897,
0.0095619103,
-0.02571298,
-0.0401280299,
-0.0054386761,
0.0191161875,
0.0321223438,
0.0307237115,
0.0151732843,
0.0309360493,
0.0131391063,
0.0451901332,
0.0068384763,
-0.0244541541,
-0.0268670972,
0.032680206,
-0.0599921383,
0.0395839699,
0.0238219257,
-0.0437266789,
-0.0092270048,
0.0115660764,
-0.0170242433,
-0.0721071213,
0.0236877855,
-0.0005398159,
0.0240771566,
0.01731796,
-0.0428922661,
-0.087117888,
0.0418246388,
0.0099613089,
0.0067319041,
0.033847671,
0.0174418986,
-0.0004177731,
-0.0185291227,
0.008110919,
-0.0357335396,
0.0200035572,
0.0073943888,
0.0388611741,
-0.0184580162,
-0.0822410807,
0.0230258591,
0.0775621459,
0.0816389844,
-0.018404441,
-0.0363781527,
-0.025773894,
0.0616095476,
-0.0174607895,
0.0190843958,
-0.0044309977,
0.0057126326,
0.0090471786,
-0.0190951284,
-0.0251456816,
-0.0084846308,
-0.02168837,
-0.0286810398,
-0.0162787922,
0.0433796719,
0.013493835,
0.0024131665,
0.0309451614,
-0.0209094267,
-0.0285269897,
0.0490765423,
0.0587461405,
-0.0049192011,
0.0090797059,
0.0252542384,
-0.0102660311,
-0.0088242888,
0.0016922931,
-0.0023397456,
-0.0311552174,
-0.0395977944,
-0.0059021031,
0.0509778894,
0.0879276842,
0.0372432508,
0.0417899005,
-0.0275363941,
0.0006871691,
-0.0629793778,
0.0257591605,
0.0204514507,
0.016990792,
0.0470075682,
0.0178746264,
-0.0227783732,
0.0129199699,
0.0295944028,
0.0118946061,
0.0475632064,
-0.0333325155,
-0.0305677447,
-0.0309828855,
-0.0770916492,
-0.0329240561,
-0.0196830053,
-0.0576516129,
-0.0362634845,
-0.0101842275,
-0.0701167583,
0.0311068259,
0.0265706517,
0.0381621569,
-0.0360101089,
-0.0548818,
0.0305820554,
-0.0240177847,
-0.0081099374,
-0.0025738131,
-0.0491531491,
0.009564016,
-0.0101509076,
0.0021885047,
-6.168908395e-33,
-0.0129662892,
-0.0115713384,
0.0241789091,
-0.0395911634,
-0.0183897428,
-0.0003987543,
0.0016567437,
0.0046877754,
0.028040953,
-0.0164256096,
-0.0278820451,
-0.000237499,
0.0611988641,
-0.0309810452,
0.0004948264,
0.0057653161,
0.1052150577,
0.0213514846,
-0.0068442668,
-0.0591625534,
0.0233505033,
0.0411195159,
0.0212722123,
-0.0420863144,
-0.0224657785,
0.032034304,
-0.0482394099,
0.0180398468,
-0.0309994575,
0.0498873331,
0.0419569388,
0.0316938832,
-0.0053204847,
-0.039906662,
-0.0210522469,
0.0073711365,
-0.0519813001,
0.0156235788,
0.0276635177,
0.0654968098,
0.0692032054,
-0.029391082,
0.0278243702,
-0.0000559851,
-0.0628087595,
0.0266647469,
-0.0133398483,
-0.0576850884,
-0.0266290922,
-0.0466021709,
0.0255014785,
0.0510975271,
0.0098446896,
-0.0074901241,
0.0808878615,
0.0174219143,
-0.0250177234,
-0.0160055421,
-0.0661206469,
0.0288422108,
0.0366020352,
0.0406005122,
0.0557081737,
0.0512898155,
-0.0208524335,
-0.0138136959,
0.0036734394,
-0.0417953841,
0.0088529298,
-0.0776651725,
0.0125006549,
0.0046550198,
0.0114440378,
0.0278429426,
0.0056050089,
-0.0262849499,
-0.0391231589,
-0.0253617596,
0.0005720413,
0.0561866462,
0.0512244441,
0.0404453613,
-0.062986888,
-0.0137736369,
-0.0624420568,
0.0277402755,
-0.0588055737,
0.0102165155,
0.0372486822,
-0.0065028192,
-0.0112731596,
0.0038110632,
0.0594252273,
-0.007515009,
0.0076841651,
-0.0054695252,
0.0222032219,
0.0042566778,
-0.0393329561,
0.0275704842,
-0.0304306727,
-0.0399797484,
0.0156781971,
0.0302886683,
-0.0108181229,
-0.0225955322,
-0.0142980786,
0.0762135684,
-0.0682939067,
0.0115131028,
0.0132261422,
0.0076379217,
0.0051790951,
-0.0178921148,
0.0319840647,
-0.025433084,
0.0298169795,
0.0336540714,
-0.010974084,
-0.0165886357,
0.0114129381,
0.0343044885,
0.021620838,
0.0257632826,
-0.0251175836,
0.0053776419,
0.0285854079,
-0.0082847793,
0.0101615731,
0.02107062,
-0.0069126054,
0.0121737476,
2.702e-7,
-0.0386947021,
0.0646091253,
-0.0106328912,
0.0224296302,
-0.0060937619,
0.0161562245,
-0.0224459078,
-0.0487573035,
0.0437909253,
0.0394607149,
0.0390478186,
-0.0159106404,
0.073010698,
0.0180680081,
-0.0480906367,
-0.0499770828,
-0.039599061,
0.0245329924,
-0.0109672844,
0.011386171,
0.0378349535,
0.0691850334,
-0.0168056283,
-0.027063949,
0.0098900367,
-0.0348400511,
0.0036964107,
-0.0179295894,
-0.026809277,
-0.0009164244,
0.0436616801,
-0.0368724912,
0.00163902,
0.0568831265,
-0.0022833257,
0.0135054961,
-0.0113540292,
0.0449974127,
-0.0232020523,
0.0199558642,
-0.0204662271,
0.0375146419,
-0.0063399202,
-0.0329609402,
0.0419408865,
-0.0047482215,
0.002791262,
-0.045900654,
-0.0354850702,
-0.0542668737,
-0.0140862679,
-0.0269561224,
0.0265842155,
0.0037370569,
-0.0082865153,
0.003989053,
-0.0254913047,
-0.0429993831,
0.0163761247,
0.0156691596,
-0.0356176086,
-0.0339494534,
0.0031210799,
-0.0096982066,
0.0245329011,
-0.0457660519,
0.0177296679,
2.19583332e-34,
0.0536708534,
-0.0336821787,
-0.0013675665,
0.0485202856,
0.054017663,
-0.0096189203,
-0.0320569389,
0.0531020723,
-0.0180848408,
-0.0894369781,
-0.0246299878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11523v1 | Group Preference Optimization: Few-Shot Alignment of Large Language Models | 2023-10-17T18:41:57 | 2023-10-17T18:41:57 | Siyan Zhao, John Dang, Aditya Grover | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Many applications of large language models (LLMs), ranging from chatbots to
creative writing, require nuanced subjective judgments that can differ
significantly across different groups. Existing alignment algorithms can be
expensive to align for each group, requiring prohibitive amounts of
group-specific preference data and computation for real-world use cases. We
introduce Group Preference Optimization (GPO), an alignment framework that
steers language models to preferences of individual groups in a few-shot
manner. In GPO, we augment the base LLM with an independent transformer module
trained to predict the preferences of a group for the LLM generations. For
few-shot learning, we parameterize this module as an in-context autoregressive
transformer and train it via meta-learning on several groups. We empirically
validate the efficacy of GPO through rigorous evaluations using LLMs with
varied sizes on three human opinion adaptation tasks. These tasks involve
adapting to the preferences of US demographic groups, global countries, and
individual users. Our results demonstrate that GPO not only aligns models more
accurately but also requires fewer group-specific preferences, and less
training and inference computing resources, outperforming existing strategies
such as in-context steering and fine-tuning methods. | [
0.0466863289,
0.1082157493,
-0.0001620766,
-0.0034893877,
-0.0295681134,
0.0310143698,
0.047375001,
-0.0422830917,
-0.0274936389,
-0.0506733954,
-0.0542586036,
-0.0486526638,
-0.0007336746,
-0.0023548834,
0.0003726449,
-0.0494154692,
0.0706830844,
0.0060908422,
0.0066860472,
-0.0448127389,
0.0152511271,
0.0450443365,
0.0018550907,
0.0497417673,
0.0198425483,
-0.0262964722,
0.0264503546,
-0.0168923754,
0.0528715663,
0.0199134331,
0.0413490161,
0.0713101551,
-0.0054662712,
0.0390192084,
0.000002191,
-0.0398372784,
-0.0414897725,
-0.0261020251,
0.0152720958,
-0.0249139518,
0.0773472041,
0.019394625,
-0.0287668761,
0.0241433233,
-0.0516194254,
0.0053384989,
0.0709821954,
0.0037617974,
0.0635547861,
0.0651268139,
-0.0171566047,
-0.0203526448,
-0.0432188772,
-0.0390051454,
0.0031035529,
-0.0213746242,
0.0013786616,
-0.0362019874,
-0.0401787162,
-0.0036952144,
-0.0134099079,
0.0243004058,
-0.0138092972,
0.000101309,
0.0234864,
0.0010370385,
-0.0526592359,
-0.0135622472,
-0.0291179288,
0.0730724484,
0.017535774,
-0.0382298343,
-0.0417713486,
-0.0025738985,
0.0228304733,
0.0191360041,
-0.0131236725,
-0.0106619792,
0.0192887373,
0.0206362251,
-0.0227702148,
0.0044517359,
-0.0018114926,
0.0138251353,
-0.0376163237,
0.0826008618,
0.014217196,
0.0092395637,
-0.0146257682,
0.0124863898,
-0.0469890088,
-0.0243175216,
0.0110731926,
-0.0108233327,
-0.0478109792,
0.0175451729,
-0.0518365763,
0.0174794178,
0.0035132642,
-0.0470605865,
0.0667334795,
0.0562186167,
0.0214823,
0.0535697117,
0.0280527119,
0.0644917414,
-0.0172281079,
0.0010831094,
-0.0311925113,
-0.028141683,
-0.0437241122,
-0.0037903511,
0.0011254982,
0.0064032562,
-0.024483759,
0.0062943073,
-0.0759743825,
0.0157990567,
-0.0332964808,
0.0039499407,
0.0152911851,
0.0407478847,
-0.0378455408,
-0.0482518636,
-0.0227319319,
0.1160057187,
-0.0131700113,
0.0075477143,
0.0018992976,
-0.0025075062,
0.0458159484,
0.0094848927,
-0.0023255846,
-0.0231879652,
-0.0004724326,
0.0435112156,
-0.0008717072,
-0.0011885944,
-0.0179199595,
0.0211725179,
-0.0370682701,
-0.0617459975,
-0.0169940535,
-0.0700552091,
0.0404110737,
0.0251015518,
0.0077731651,
-0.0601115115,
-0.0215675496,
0.0051691607,
-0.0206200294,
0.0583439097,
0.0431520976,
-0.0025912193,
0.0212499108,
-0.0143658081,
0.0043700584,
0.0744582936,
0.035885226,
0.056385491,
0.0144833224,
-0.0331200249,
-0.0002153094,
0.033214096,
-0.0258739423,
0.0133200381,
-0.0267394353,
-0.0088702375,
-0.0235180799,
0.0135754505,
0.0308751594,
0.0601791777,
0.0141311372,
-0.0297094844,
0.1100303531,
0.0432271846,
0.0157211237,
0.0418982096,
-0.0059348019,
0.0247405507,
-0.0328814238,
-0.0316471234,
-0.0298486967,
0.0813625082,
-0.0171321351,
-0.0142429257,
0.0065790629,
0.0808084533,
-0.0277924463,
-0.0340335555,
0.0115978355,
0.0044729826,
0.0199265946,
0.0198738538,
0.030429652,
-0.0172458906,
-0.0299480204,
0.0207397752,
0.040834222,
-0.0470574498,
-0.031415578,
-0.0214830358,
0.0315682217,
0.0708767027,
0.0291649215,
0.0168962814,
-0.0346077047,
-0.0459173359,
-0.0019550244,
0.0389487334,
0.0482718572,
-0.0137783885,
-0.0111161098,
-0.0440886654,
-0.0275797676,
0.0360059254,
-0.0123669282,
0.026612334,
0.0446981341,
0.0131669445,
0.0002267304,
-0.0050672144,
-0.0048018713,
0.0043765577,
-0.05373808,
-0.0127693992,
0.0153332176,
0.0296848975,
0.0547943003,
-0.0018255891,
-0.0000551903,
-0.0287585389,
-0.0360323861,
-0.0263336375,
-0.0229717493,
0.0425853506,
-0.046116665,
-0.0309059378,
0.0296743307,
-0.0254049469,
-0.0337815844,
0.0251896922,
-0.0441099666,
0.0000368413,
0.0087129176,
-0.0071249804,
0.0396188237,
-0.0117389522,
0.0265492909,
-0.0417901054,
-0.0029508253,
-0.0634834245,
0.0207568388,
-0.0107643129,
-0.0436201282,
-0.0183150396,
-0.044527106,
-0.003156181,
0.014091257,
-0.033789482,
0.0232396461,
0.0258387383,
0.0232043546,
0.0527238958,
0.0090332804,
-0.0419576615,
-0.0379288755,
-0.0769834444,
0.0064521097,
-0.0041362965,
0.0185024049,
0.0186915267,
0.0147988638,
-0.0027218966,
-0.0058980579,
-0.0521867909,
0.0323099643,
-0.0234413613,
0.0228326451,
0.0211083405,
-0.0197083447,
0.026246855,
-0.0639695376,
-0.0063334987,
-0.0140569462,
0.0286382735,
-0.0058507975,
0.0099126603,
-0.0297158733,
-0.0209498573,
-0.0522037633,
-0.0058493703,
-0.0089255748,
-0.0658769757,
-0.0055133207,
0.0065058493,
0.0723785162,
0.078495957,
0.0446859375,
-0.01506586,
0.0520584248,
0.0426399857,
-0.0666507334,
-0.0093235495,
-0.036407724,
-0.0305349119,
-0.0269115642,
-0.0325827673,
0.0119660385,
0.0857132524,
-0.0012434906,
-0.0090562059,
-0.0788330063,
0.0385958552,
-0.0121370032,
-0.0196403917,
-0.0011925055,
0.0209420323,
-0.0186134949,
0.0073476699,
-0.0379138105,
-0.0481091812,
0.0949475616,
0.0280228201,
0.0135563761,
-0.0333784893,
-0.0153474323,
-0.0437759832,
0.0067854468,
0.0024618795,
0.0391504131,
-0.000564856,
0.0312738493,
-0.1062548161,
-0.0153500196,
0.0594544299,
-0.0410438813,
0.0654166788,
0.0064495197,
0.010457675,
-0.0081188791,
-0.0785356984,
-0.0274577253,
-0.0523441769,
-0.0317519978,
-0.0291483011,
0.0351550169,
-0.0477782935,
-0.0645736903,
-0.0032112671,
0.0268217009,
0.0076850988,
-0.0242135823,
-0.0188748389,
0.0079420051,
-0.0080982875,
0.0848169029,
-0.0037651237,
-0.0059555499,
-0.0462636836,
0.0200468767,
0.0325711258,
0.0253983047,
0.0043444871,
-0.0450904295,
-0.0284169074,
0.0456967317,
-0.0169779211,
0.0025315818,
-0.0071696076,
0.0607094578,
-0.0170614664,
0.0539888628,
0.1093143895,
0.006575888,
-0.0973904803,
-0.0186755564,
-0.0086492803,
0.0508981869,
0.027853664,
0.0493186228,
-0.0505815931,
-0.0252046827,
-0.0008336356,
0.0252931863,
0.0055083097,
-0.0061266934,
-0.0249741413,
-0.1033089533,
-0.0046876972,
0.0256779492,
-0.0166950747,
0.0066534718,
-0.0003343081,
0.0466712005,
-0.0514925532,
0.042891901,
-0.011428155,
-0.0104757119,
-0.0063195573,
-0.0063502588,
-0.0466001257,
-0.0174481254,
0.0305115767,
-0.026131738,
0.069629401,
0.0835351646,
0.0413168631,
0.0406535268,
-0.0255758632,
0.051824078,
0.0412160233,
-0.0142993294,
-0.0164554194,
0.0503497049,
-0.0195720848,
0.0199425761,
-0.0211602356,
0.0237794984,
-0.0220544189,
0.0082889078,
-0.0117022572,
0.0227924306,
0.0093692504,
-0.0275210608,
-0.0161360707,
0.0163558032,
0.0055767847,
0.057031855,
-0.0005036432,
-0.1047369838,
-0.0147819277,
-0.0443228446,
-0.0201916602,
-0.0455835238,
-0.0458150059,
0.0091823367,
-0.0096093128,
-0.0158656724,
-0.0502445661,
0.0028801158,
0.0276588947,
0.0149450777,
0.0092047565,
-0.0129862735,
0.0278408248,
-0.0177411772,
-0.0192020778,
0.0124582434,
-0.0543080121,
0.0136714745,
-0.0821253136,
-0.0235152766,
0.0516944416,
-0.0159576107,
-0.0034511795,
-0.0102793779,
-0.0816866979,
-0.0736124665,
0.0290447325,
0.0504556336,
0.0123869376,
0.0549522974,
0.0228892677,
-0.0666574538,
0.0603999831,
0.0648531541,
0.0214952473,
0.0163396094,
0.0093936445,
0.0733511671,
-0.0350919515,
0.0305538662,
-0.0087620402,
0.0339034796,
0.0397155732,
-0.0107328193,
-0.0447775163,
-0.0355627425,
0.011884179,
-0.0241117775,
0.0068092062,
-0.0311572794,
0.0092630228,
-0.0315665491,
-0.0146100186,
0.0078662038,
-0.018849412,
-0.0286262799,
-0.0707442164,
0.0430168957,
-0.0515019223,
-0.0074328068,
0.0040916591,
0.0136510739,
0.011522986,
-0.0563206971,
0.0556630567,
-0.0150838802,
0.0101485038,
0.0408337414,
0.0376717113,
-0.0054416764,
0.0151251582,
0.0206331536,
0.0421355478,
-0.0115292165,
0.064969264,
0.0106231263,
0.0110617131,
-0.0199061967,
0.0332561061,
-0.0412752964,
-0.0306884479,
-0.0372700132,
-0.0163007341,
0.0091177663,
-0.0068378961,
0.0577616431,
-0.0177733954,
-0.0171081349,
-0.0270478074,
0.038487941,
-0.0352049731,
0.0178183541,
-0.0145007446,
0.0092117926,
-0.0237700697,
0.0204097033,
0.0668964311,
0.0041292221,
-0.0074863425,
-0.0077177938,
-0.0162003413,
-0.0587399006,
0.0014438588,
-0.0085437717,
-0.0235498603,
-0.0051639676,
0.0028072817,
-0.0499091595,
-0.0403058305,
-0.0051706349,
-0.0151640456,
-0.0080639441,
-0.0110425176,
0.030586645,
0.0370585993,
-0.0424159877,
-0.0056407107,
-0.0550056882,
-0.0113906162,
-0.0196682736,
-0.0074048247,
-0.0221910588,
-7.052077137e-33,
-0.0391638167,
-0.0307504833,
0.0079347081,
-0.0120624388,
-0.0099958889,
-0.0466971509,
-0.0156899858,
0.0228247419,
-0.0143052852,
0.0001388009,
-0.0178174227,
0.0021933834,
0.0084502911,
0.0247272365,
0.0304274485,
0.0009154999,
0.0856268406,
0.0126573956,
-0.0317368656,
0.0106957285,
0.0450177453,
0.0346015841,
0.048764158,
-0.0644901842,
-0.0222717561,
0.0355637148,
-0.0226060543,
-0.0171493217,
0.0188890006,
0.0585947596,
0.0044217985,
0.0518396869,
0.0138697857,
-0.0466182828,
-0.0072946246,
0.0213323552,
-0.0705586672,
-0.0137360888,
-0.0097916452,
0.0152688902,
0.0233063921,
-0.0408675931,
0.01550774,
-0.0098207677,
-0.0289081056,
-0.0260165855,
0.0449891835,
-0.0206680093,
-0.0048861969,
-0.0193104837,
-0.0756853595,
0.0068296022,
-0.013714985,
0.0066750785,
0.0075534116,
0.0580443554,
-0.0045461045,
0.0805963203,
-0.0513326451,
0.0526154973,
-0.0395685248,
0.0353662334,
0.0582495034,
0.0381125659,
0.0083385417,
0.0604753084,
0.0077120131,
0.018877279,
-0.0048230281,
-0.0250953827,
0.0341976285,
0.0148290675,
0.0027369405,
0.1031286642,
0.0449088551,
-0.035444364,
0.008424825,
0.0329871476,
0.0314614996,
-0.0073427875,
0.0596030913,
0.0272744428,
-0.0269750636,
-0.018037919,
-0.0141678154,
-0.0305690747,
-0.0373880416,
-0.0348577872,
0.0006127473,
0.007995992,
-0.0423213691,
-0.0450280495,
0.0580819212,
-0.0613971017,
-0.0132483244,
0.0240775757,
-0.0548304282,
0.0141464742,
0.0108577898,
0.0200431999,
-0.0697223097,
-0.0056164153,
-0.0188692734,
0.0148460064,
0.0037246395,
0.0137778707,
0.0588486083,
0.0275162477,
-0.1047984213,
0.0133422837,
-0.0112799024,
0.0142066218,
-0.0031777213,
0.0095269242,
0.0232451949,
0.0150267323,
-0.0106740892,
0.0338096283,
0.0095271925,
-0.0211110115,
0.0151469531,
-0.0207142364,
-0.0281634163,
0.007533682,
-0.033451803,
-0.001225303,
-0.01926798,
0.0068954853,
0.0313541479,
-0.0427905023,
-0.0362591632,
-0.0180404969,
2.898e-7,
0.0422507636,
0.0764482319,
-0.0033841406,
-0.0027108139,
0.0194074884,
0.05441349,
0.0254123397,
-0.0092614461,
0.0508168526,
0.0077995998,
0.0325506553,
0.0290030353,
0.0740491822,
0.0249040518,
-0.0744430572,
0.0350568891,
-0.0504191369,
0.0433815382,
-0.0290940702,
0.0233016033,
0.021576168,
0.0792891309,
0.0322375745,
-0.0169276763,
-0.0198775548,
0.0242205057,
0.0770971999,
-0.0734173656,
-0.0236591306,
0.0467750207,
-0.005926528,
-0.0072411653,
-0.020341007,
-0.0235766303,
-0.0089800218,
0.0178997423,
-0.0441252626,
0.0571686514,
-0.0034115762,
-0.0633774698,
0.0027497818,
0.0414971001,
-0.0153471529,
-0.045467183,
0.0572886355,
-0.0928602442,
-0.0370158032,
-0.0779572427,
-0.0252111368,
0.0120700561,
0.0362028331,
-0.0308301877,
-0.0050137746,
-0.006934769,
0.0294292867,
0.0136927832,
-0.0449422635,
-0.0536004342,
-0.0130365891,
0.008523006,
-0.0416195951,
-0.0338457003,
-0.0172755644,
0.0184102654,
0.0028113746,
-0.0289874319,
0.0300929565,
2.518610982e-34,
0.0305528976,
-0.0070955525,
0.0150157362,
-0.000679426,
0.0107778693,
0.000273498,
-0.0248826127,
-0.0131326513,
0.050866019,
-0.0563678592,
-0.017724013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11520v1 | Automatic News Summerization | 2023-10-17T18:38:03 | 2023-10-17T18:38:03 | Kavach Dheer, Arpit Dhankhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Natural Language Processing is booming with its applications in the real
world, one of which is Text Summarization for large texts including news
articles. This research paper provides an extensive comparative evaluation of
extractive and abstractive approaches for news text summarization, with an
emphasis on the ROUGE score analysis. The study employs the CNN-Daily Mail
dataset, which consists of news articles and human-generated reference
summaries. The evaluation employs ROUGE scores to assess the efficacy and
quality of generated summaries. After Evaluation, we integrate the
best-performing models on a web application to assess their real-world
capabilities and user experience. | [
0.0594707727,
0.0353928134,
0.0272933245,
-0.0097927647,
-0.0600577295,
0.0138900494,
-0.0490389764,
-0.0240554549,
-0.0012727948,
-0.0484385043,
0.0346061103,
0.0170095041,
-0.0103090117,
0.0090023521,
-0.046984002,
-0.0625359267,
0.0098976083,
-0.015571042,
-0.014369553,
0.0167719107,
0.034874104,
0.0099420389,
0.0570927635,
0.0147033045,
0.0271886047,
0.0205604844,
0.0122307129,
0.004369969,
0.0418861322,
-0.0123692434,
-0.0137869734,
0.011592404,
-0.0072735688,
0.0062692775,
0.000001809,
-0.0388925001,
-0.0426081046,
0.0043314425,
0.0555338413,
0.0119879609,
0.0757526904,
-0.0408934169,
-0.0077044754,
0.0160507523,
-0.0270213168,
0.0268773492,
-0.0181242824,
0.0598412715,
0.0759016797,
0.0399707295,
-0.0221859068,
-0.062712118,
0.0502169132,
0.032825008,
-0.0367842838,
-0.0250655804,
-0.0099138292,
0.0327726789,
-0.006249567,
-0.0350662135,
0.023148369,
0.0499581918,
0.034784276,
-0.0058951317,
-0.0214057658,
0.0459174588,
-0.0756674781,
-0.0107702687,
-0.0093790255,
0.0475362353,
-0.0266184639,
0.0063534942,
0.0135450633,
0.0287269037,
0.0103642177,
0.0066644317,
-0.0866884962,
0.0319481902,
-0.009038277,
0.0225515831,
0.0049522244,
0.0303454492,
-0.0610110946,
0.0512262993,
-0.0209992025,
0.0158867948,
0.0023493895,
-0.02142087,
0.0174681898,
0.0350098386,
0.0200748611,
-0.0409404673,
0.0099616563,
0.0082729543,
-0.0060282801,
-0.0284451265,
-0.0429650769,
-0.0384952873,
0.0135009531,
-0.0492334515,
0.0206627566,
-0.0070855021,
-0.0056291106,
0.0482725538,
-0.0340060741,
-0.025991939,
0.0295240078,
0.0231802724,
-0.0321630351,
0.0109568443,
-0.0504790395,
0.025616765,
-0.0108489711,
0.0673973039,
-0.0340185203,
-0.0265859272,
-0.011309986,
-0.0024518757,
0.024829898,
-0.0224816911,
0.0049445974,
0.0234545134,
0.0010424012,
0.0209854264,
-0.0089036515,
0.0212252773,
-0.0203100089,
-0.033636108,
0.0390841141,
-0.0345095247,
0.0172070879,
-0.0042181038,
0.0486781001,
0.00721939,
0.0090631573,
-0.0048296698,
-0.0607283749,
-0.018506635,
-0.0204580799,
-0.0110558001,
0.0220636223,
-0.0701611415,
-0.0279224142,
-0.1003613099,
-0.0272741765,
0.0070069819,
-0.0189296715,
0.0034188521,
0.0005462324,
0.0221135039,
-0.0646396801,
-0.0177688841,
-0.0136228669,
0.0113267154,
0.0547144562,
0.0021012139,
0.0643679649,
0.0509859733,
0.0321822204,
0.0963209718,
0.0577780977,
0.007983041,
0.0297152977,
0.0170744527,
-0.0165804289,
-0.0265521519,
0.0026454555,
0.0044580922,
-0.0458013788,
-0.0285374578,
-0.0054958379,
0.0550412461,
-0.0230519176,
0.0461034104,
0.0735484511,
0.0168379191,
-0.014928123,
0.0133288242,
0.024744384,
0.0308172796,
0.0646747425,
0.0401331857,
-0.0011008916,
0.039036274,
-0.0677289665,
0.0633732304,
0.0622789003,
0.0634121671,
-0.0234198906,
-0.0685593411,
0.0222653225,
-0.0058125579,
0.0686473921,
0.0028141937,
0.0217765048,
-0.0065145604,
-0.0463811569,
-0.0247121062,
0.0080401814,
-0.0442423597,
0.0293011162,
-0.008582687,
-0.0529497266,
0.0401917063,
0.0220367182,
-0.0019717491,
0.0007989652,
-0.0160886981,
-0.0071989172,
0.0200479664,
0.0315699838,
-0.0094133075,
-0.0282157902,
-0.0387279168,
-0.0335234776,
0.0016963672,
-0.0160803385,
-0.0182834733,
-0.0063022259,
0.0118381456,
0.0194935724,
0.0200439803,
-0.1255832911,
0.0268888734,
-0.0155029483,
-0.0363662839,
-0.0122220377,
-0.0276676491,
0.0143646216,
0.0550559089,
-0.0256578121,
0.0152063547,
0.0040110778,
-0.022172533,
-0.0174317323,
0.0149730425,
0.0081679812,
-0.0072789872,
0.0055561303,
-0.0946980342,
0.0145330392,
0.0899962932,
-0.0296543986,
-0.0325319842,
0.0406281576,
-0.0301669165,
-0.0525057204,
-0.054715734,
0.0148227271,
0.0127760042,
0.0029931059,
-0.007505564,
0.0890460908,
0.0079521565,
-0.0025079914,
0.032350678,
-0.0204802752,
-0.0322841145,
-0.0393786579,
-0.0083360299,
-0.0203583967,
-0.0276519302,
0.018914938,
0.0528263599,
0.0046259109,
-0.0255285334,
-0.0170177221,
-0.0879571512,
0.0228959415,
-0.0165547431,
0.0142003978,
0.0391919464,
0.0356412493,
-0.0164987519,
0.0043665431,
-0.021961255,
-0.0293641668,
0.0054186252,
0.0163858775,
0.0265947487,
0.0168617684,
0.0253242329,
-0.0570712835,
-0.0125527289,
0.0143740997,
0.0414794683,
0.0107161812,
-0.0280571114,
0.0010203876,
0.0158150978,
-0.0186875165,
-0.040721152,
0.0407677069,
-0.0169952642,
-0.0209908225,
-0.0098480918,
0.0227877889,
0.0748095736,
0.0636133924,
0.0428885221,
-0.0087224739,
0.001709555,
-0.0075613614,
-0.0101191495,
-0.0798802823,
0.0066823941,
0.0105819991,
-0.0437460616,
0.0418553874,
0.0388056338,
0.0223618802,
0.0221339818,
0.0141776521,
0.0376017652,
-0.0383114293,
-0.0013167267,
-0.0251215454,
0.0159479249,
0.0149566662,
0.0271799825,
-0.0283936895,
0.0116852326,
0.046574872,
0.0213790294,
0.0453144088,
-0.0845868066,
-0.0226433799,
-0.0477865301,
0.025732819,
-0.004485589,
0.0248302259,
0.0049760225,
-0.0171348043,
-0.017089583,
-0.0447354801,
0.0495663285,
-0.0286850017,
0.0779335275,
-0.0157687292,
0.015677426,
-0.0349720344,
0.0130581558,
0.0005063614,
-0.0609847046,
-0.01437933,
0.0211878829,
0.0276117586,
0.0279303752,
-0.0448407009,
0.0342184864,
0.0523757897,
0.0663278624,
-0.0556677319,
-0.0301370211,
0.0203144867,
0.0464066602,
0.0448353812,
-0.0056317546,
0.027886197,
-0.0022027476,
0.0234388839,
0.0308395252,
0.0205341857,
0.0032094899,
0.0042403974,
-0.0097337663,
-0.0100825578,
-0.0858966112,
0.0125157814,
-0.0079959342,
0.0341379084,
-0.0400828458,
-0.0020460456,
0.0721540898,
0.0305881668,
0.0037114604,
-0.0111929663,
0.0340308733,
0.0018335589,
-0.0025551931,
-0.0053992053,
-0.042220436,
0.0081792306,
0.0075743021,
0.0243313257,
0.0108063277,
-0.0190912317,
0.0324015096,
-0.089585267,
0.0474812016,
-0.0098065082,
-0.0836144239,
-0.0021611457,
-0.0329138003,
0.0282784011,
-0.0464221649,
-0.0285074078,
0.0059369253,
-0.0273885895,
0.0178328138,
0.0140932035,
-0.0766645148,
-0.0354461037,
-0.056698598,
0.0071808775,
-0.0426540338,
0.0357078314,
0.0482415892,
-0.0265588872,
0.0563547201,
0.0174621679,
-0.0732815862,
0.0166193824,
-0.0314785205,
0.0583524331,
0.0027370364,
0.0169446804,
-0.0330342576,
0.050439477,
0.0512817763,
0.0120657245,
0.0224841945,
-0.0162516683,
0.0020149453,
-0.0185105521,
-0.0458504967,
0.0162023697,
-0.0088220751,
0.0484005399,
0.0484376401,
0.0047127213,
-0.0408761725,
-0.021019524,
-0.0147883473,
-0.0922873244,
-0.0946377814,
0.0137903541,
-0.0515262522,
-0.0627080277,
-0.0773968622,
-0.0701564774,
-0.000281166,
-0.0129395816,
-0.0074756378,
-0.0400663912,
-0.0013529423,
0.0437970534,
-0.0345778242,
0.0040842663,
0.0130962068,
-0.0233934391,
-0.0011597283,
-0.0294184424,
0.0380345732,
-0.0204847716,
-0.0562622435,
0.0085125612,
-0.0243278518,
-0.0113723716,
0.0107769975,
0.0328488126,
0.0216915254,
0.0220352467,
0.0072627128,
-0.0023343873,
0.0409150347,
0.0514976569,
0.0004298764,
-0.0191684887,
-0.0223653167,
0.0100614037,
-0.0035750407,
-0.0065726894,
-0.0479013212,
0.0901520178,
-0.0322248749,
0.0439768769,
-0.0146876564,
-0.010594626,
0.0091750445,
0.0420470312,
-0.0018064055,
-0.0226348694,
-0.0087196389,
-0.0105542801,
-0.0355286002,
-0.0367416218,
-0.004073407,
-0.0425695144,
0.0257618073,
0.0181611311,
0.0497914366,
-0.0073544225,
0.0753091201,
0.0337478258,
-0.0011269014,
-0.0497857109,
0.0037801303,
0.0222617481,
0.0158825535,
-0.0724794045,
-0.0166239832,
-0.0744915903,
-0.0370513462,
-0.0331010036,
0.0052716471,
-0.0157377627,
-0.0382409878,
0.0268596783,
0.0049853791,
0.0296182279,
0.0550565124,
-0.1170243099,
0.0248417854,
-0.0916542336,
0.0102720344,
0.0329909958,
-0.0453626402,
0.0762522966,
0.0057887617,
-0.0234709661,
-0.0089819264,
0.0263610296,
0.0642478913,
-0.0079416176,
-0.0526100062,
0.0181559585,
-0.000667451,
-0.0231981687,
0.0547425635,
-0.0513604991,
-0.0178088509,
0.0281668082,
-0.0348313525,
-0.0531378314,
0.0075403163,
-0.0058784615,
0.0108102374,
0.009396174,
-0.0417371169,
-0.0576561727,
0.033719793,
0.0368530005,
0.0267571751,
0.0294989981,
-0.0042174235,
0.0191985816,
0.0343948379,
0.0408945605,
0.010171527,
-0.0471317507,
-0.0019235505,
-0.0555169769,
-0.0004410118,
0.0164772458,
-6.346060537e-33,
-0.0442718603,
0.0062161172,
-0.0630572289,
0.0136894984,
-0.0410172418,
0.0210338533,
-0.056202691,
-0.0420140624,
0.0001326826,
-0.0264967289,
-0.0169008151,
-0.0299389102,
0.0387981795,
0.0320471562,
0.0320034921,
0.0097119845,
0.0309343841,
-0.0069105211,
-0.035519354,
0.0233215969,
0.0204395633,
0.025655847,
0.0591295026,
-0.0667555854,
0.0245797615,
-0.038253963,
-0.0230557397,
-0.0369793251,
0.0984089896,
0.0384255387,
0.0088849738,
-0.0055617676,
0.0381763205,
-0.0731025636,
-0.0155527359,
0.0033318093,
-0.0878875554,
-0.0197520927,
0.0452046841,
-0.0311984457,
-0.045199424,
-0.0028740198,
0.0435382538,
-0.0200048648,
-0.0075192023,
-0.0456344597,
0.0617998838,
-0.0654711202,
-0.0197949503,
-0.0574527532,
-0.0592970513,
0.0257084295,
-0.0395796448,
0.0016739243,
0.0396562368,
0.0257284306,
-0.0145272091,
-0.0197439361,
-0.0322693512,
0.0232600663,
0.0038616536,
0.0424697623,
0.0623463131,
-0.008304663,
-0.0009926609,
0.0604835749,
-0.0133104688,
-0.0109799774,
-0.0360776782,
0.0246623103,
0.0316657871,
0.0409470834,
0.0323756412,
0.0435079783,
0.0192376114,
0.0328320861,
-0.049336046,
0.104466781,
0.0294554159,
-0.0000081485,
0.0077450578,
0.0071703237,
-0.0016916209,
0.0227288343,
0.0053560054,
0.0086392276,
-0.0074411118,
-0.038844645,
0.0019891432,
0.0249390788,
-0.0737621933,
0.0582423545,
0.0226053987,
-0.0262883734,
-0.0113508329,
0.0103093414,
-0.0100113675,
0.0643639117,
-0.0129801221,
-0.051948484,
-0.0477868021,
0.008993974,
0.0055437465,
0.0519981012,
-0.0094839046,
-0.0183486212,
0.03370139,
0.0200123973,
-0.03313509,
0.0143688805,
0.0076773763,
0.0196043719,
-0.0330878496,
0.0275428742,
-0.0126350857,
-0.0240952764,
-0.0023652173,
0.0065363059,
0.0133937122,
0.0280849487,
-0.0061658905,
-0.0350077711,
0.0505723096,
0.0084323501,
-0.0000632559,
0.040634688,
0.0089924932,
0.0084524807,
-0.0031096209,
-0.0032562301,
-0.0346649699,
0.0028035305,
2.53e-7,
0.0531118475,
0.0313285813,
0.0485563092,
0.0193803962,
-0.0431131758,
0.0054431967,
0.0063282577,
0.0208466873,
0.0451945364,
-0.0064451853,
0.0468696952,
0.0365759656,
0.0403033309,
0.0530728884,
-0.0575039387,
-0.0034845776,
-0.0678911358,
-0.0484893583,
-0.0339543261,
-0.0183539782,
0.0755829737,
0.0105833849,
-0.0168798603,
-0.0093837436,
-0.0421201736,
-0.0086117527,
-0.0201242715,
-0.0107787428,
-0.0525073558,
0.0230623204,
0.0866053402,
0.0448250845,
-0.0067287348,
-0.0459318273,
0.002731689,
-0.0208303016,
0.1027216837,
0.0006610319,
0.0037731349,
0.0323060788,
0.0348011367,
-0.0439422019,
0.0390891209,
-0.0216795132,
0.0631771535,
-0.0402399004,
-0.0157613289,
-0.0701102689,
-0.0729466975,
0.0068010269,
-0.0097826319,
0.0000719855,
-0.0342172273,
0.0769839808,
-0.0087768557,
0.0064884005,
0.0038773876,
-0.0344084278,
-0.0448605828,
0.018709708,
0.0467072763,
-0.0099984566,
-0.009194796,
0.0062282328,
-0.0049892543,
-0.0491704643,
-0.0287945718,
2.112088301e-34,
0.0620274022,
0.0229255743,
-0.0239655785,
0.0071981736,
-0.0021748249,
-0.0067767729,
-0.0110747917,
-0.0192875993,
-0.0375829488,
-0.0504587702,
0.0163277201
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.