id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.03365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.03365v1 | Leveraging Generative AI: Improving Software Metadata Classification with Generated Code-Comment Pairs | 2023-10-14T12:09:43 | 2023-10-14T12:09:43 | Samah Syed, Angel Deborah S | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In software development, code comments play a crucial role in enhancing code
comprehension and collaboration. This research paper addresses the challenge of
objectively classifying code comments as "Useful" or "Not Useful." We propose a
novel solution that harnesses contextualized embeddings, particularly BERT, to
automate this classification process. We address this task by incorporating
generated code and comment pairs. The initial dataset comprised 9048 pairs of
code and comments written in C, labeled as either Useful or Not Useful. To
augment this dataset, we sourced an additional 739 lines of code-comment pairs
and generated labels using a Large Language Model Architecture, specifically
BERT. The primary objective was to build classification models that can
effectively differentiate between useful and not useful code comments. Various
machine learning algorithms were employed, including Logistic Regression,
Decision Tree, K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN), Support Vector Machine (SVM),
Gradient Boosting, Random Forest, and a Neural Network. Each algorithm was
evaluated using precision, recall, and F1-score metrics, both with the original
seed dataset and the augmented dataset. This study showcases the potential of
generative AI for enhancing binary code comment quality classification models,
providing valuable insights for software developers and researchers in the
field of natural language processing and software engineering. | [
0.0707328692,
0.0591057576,
-0.028553078,
0.0339432955,
0.0112968506,
0.0096113514,
-0.0275102053,
0.0098105092,
-0.0035811586,
-0.0617830455,
0.0152735645,
0.0103181442,
0.0103379153,
0.0038831879,
0.0159119722,
-0.0369819663,
0.0188487098,
0.0179907214,
-0.0064819269,
0.0396770649,
-0.0006547031,
0.0259375293,
-0.0147297103,
0.0941286907,
-0.0402269885,
-0.0333460718,
0.0403094552,
0.0151150674,
0.004377367,
-0.0319857784,
0.0291165113,
0.0398255214,
-0.0248947572,
0.0143460566,
0.0000019443,
-0.036402829,
0.0141200386,
-0.0123306988,
-0.0113732964,
0.0444581546,
0.0099253124,
-0.0081179878,
-0.0083927484,
0.0156230079,
-0.0497381501,
-0.0611676276,
0.0567261167,
-0.0084599704,
0.0431798585,
0.0382048003,
0.0023208614,
-0.0057477141,
0.004506961,
0.0042063985,
0.0557214059,
-0.0149078537,
-0.0009248854,
0.0520474538,
-0.0177582577,
0.0383268781,
0.0162140746,
0.0056737317,
0.01140875,
-0.0254280977,
0.1010358557,
0.0611917265,
-0.0339805819,
0.0091358861,
0.022685675,
0.0342971794,
-0.0227873754,
-0.0303016827,
-0.0017483985,
-0.0247259084,
-0.0128275612,
-0.0150151383,
-0.0018060914,
-0.0023095899,
-0.0019521838,
0.0044773258,
0.009197019,
-0.0322922543,
0.0216698777,
-0.0258478578,
0.0181614552,
0.0022977786,
-0.0159041639,
-0.0160277467,
-0.0016089107,
-0.0138707375,
-0.033301875,
-0.0735007897,
-0.0252582543,
0.040756423,
0.019938454,
0.0155257704,
-0.0212217476,
-0.0555787496,
0.0417077839,
-0.0482561439,
-0.0081868945,
0.0132216169,
-0.0621076487,
0.0006187742,
-0.0591251701,
0.0193244908,
0.0314341635,
-0.0180360787,
0.0040617287,
-0.0097809546,
-0.0832639411,
-0.0187557153,
-0.0343391038,
0.0730114728,
0.0201215055,
0.0198555086,
-0.0191769712,
0.0496846847,
-0.0068868357,
0.0627574474,
0.0207970273,
0.0145181138,
-0.0163752679,
0.0491961017,
0.0019661649,
-0.0712511688,
-0.0579010472,
-0.0286586098,
-0.049564112,
-0.003260039,
0.0127845882,
0.030160157,
-0.0243954863,
-0.0007297177,
0.0033296125,
0.0415238068,
0.0695458278,
0.0074356268,
-0.0450431481,
-0.0065397108,
-0.0067302496,
0.0509387031,
-0.0319069587,
-0.0692009032,
-0.0737088546,
0.0119589549,
0.0050396607,
-0.0322588645,
-0.0134172672,
-0.009987385,
0.0173816625,
0.0487811752,
-0.1127082631,
-0.0053987512,
0.0544385538,
0.0208624844,
0.004351797,
0.0063589755,
0.0320827439,
0.0031650953,
0.0660661086,
-0.0417434499,
0.0460057855,
-0.0146897864,
-0.0296993125,
-0.0417508334,
-0.0062623946,
0.024507856,
-0.0101824179,
-0.0335638188,
-0.0156967826,
0.0055118212,
-0.0091553275,
-0.0156903695,
-0.0301001929,
0.038867943,
0.0095962677,
0.0634348243,
0.0607022084,
0.0462797731,
-0.0261125602,
-0.0550302789,
0.0101688346,
0.0440709293,
0.0028610097,
-0.0249367543,
0.0021044808,
-0.0026773396,
-0.0182967093,
-0.0978491232,
-0.013386935,
-0.0380155817,
0.0082398672,
-0.0234572906,
0.0287322234,
0.0002776907,
-0.0440348275,
-0.0033280381,
0.0460615866,
-0.0294845421,
-0.0335120596,
-0.0450076833,
0.0568058155,
0.0637236834,
0.0527606271,
-0.0849064887,
-0.0377633423,
-0.0149842771,
-0.0039000649,
-0.0305628963,
0.0382501893,
-0.0383995324,
0.0184346717,
-0.063404806,
-0.0211804193,
-0.0535192788,
0.0093845446,
0.0324012153,
0.0025374864,
-0.0219332259,
0.0536198057,
-0.0154854488,
-0.0522628725,
0.034276396,
0.0438886955,
-0.0199374668,
0.0598637126,
0.006059905,
0.0085647739,
0.0009802994,
-0.0528732911,
0.0115739238,
0.0502551682,
-0.0196403358,
-0.0291663501,
-0.0037579655,
-0.0184595156,
-0.0269351695,
0.01332903,
-0.0406328514,
-0.0080528166,
0.0127772819,
-0.0330068804,
-0.010005896,
0.0297698174,
-0.0711169988,
0.0744782314,
-0.0196954943,
-0.0202642549,
-0.0382500552,
-0.0222086236,
-0.038826216,
0.050878603,
0.0187003929,
0.0289305579,
-0.0098181013,
0.0490051582,
0.0742050633,
0.0358498245,
-0.0356730595,
-0.0193165056,
-0.0387426168,
0.0389626287,
0.0376350097,
0.0433288664,
-0.0048211124,
-0.0078341383,
-0.1351693273,
-0.0228554346,
0.0028679857,
0.0180801395,
0.0026135975,
-0.0125627462,
0.0184236504,
-0.0278314259,
-0.0344638303,
-0.0431501381,
-0.046171654,
-0.036982879,
0.0635484532,
-0.0005914085,
-0.0325571112,
-0.0193133894,
-0.000509226,
-0.0489504822,
0.0406461544,
0.021395253,
-0.0204510074,
-0.0732507929,
0.0247748867,
-0.0129651036,
0.0027275553,
-0.0086204261,
-0.0161885433,
0.0245269034,
-0.0114973215,
0.0582531095,
0.0333790481,
0.0114089409,
0.0215888564,
0.0322030671,
0.0317375138,
-0.0612080358,
0.0182653703,
0.0519137494,
0.0153432852,
0.0277890936,
-0.033427,
0.0533175021,
0.0378788002,
0.0119440723,
-0.0210317876,
-0.0462097079,
-0.0034541956,
-0.0071732691,
0.0092683705,
0.016870223,
-0.0340736993,
0.0189373139,
0.0318636037,
-0.020923486,
-0.0836696997,
0.0771435201,
-0.0312889628,
-0.0252182912,
-0.0577622205,
-0.0125009231,
-0.0448846631,
0.0533220023,
-0.0154184457,
0.0210053418,
0.0014132006,
-0.0244651027,
0.0095671648,
-0.0018898657,
-0.023768492,
-0.0006896708,
0.0231087375,
-0.0653325617,
0.0109193483,
0.0334967487,
0.0015707004,
-0.0423078425,
-0.0243293606,
-0.0062114056,
-0.0269802399,
0.0564936325,
0.0033478779,
0.0614335798,
0.0130330659,
-0.016173631,
0.0392763391,
0.0584616847,
-0.0586656258,
0.0039506219,
-0.0175649114,
-0.0157152079,
-0.0447579026,
-0.0157401878,
0.0042529167,
-0.0380741172,
0.0094889775,
0.0365245007,
0.0437363274,
-0.0892902315,
-0.0471975841,
0.0059435661,
-0.0349591486,
-0.0378928035,
0.0338445939,
0.0146549474,
-0.0101568894,
-0.0115329921,
0.0972541794,
0.0707745776,
-0.0406927988,
0.0179132838,
-0.0097404299,
0.0225010868,
0.059068732,
0.016203355,
-0.0677864999,
-0.0321637467,
-0.033029791,
0.0287351068,
-0.020321589,
-0.0032791211,
0.0170202162,
-0.092444934,
0.009949388,
-0.0127864415,
0.0068533556,
-0.0335920081,
-0.0283127427,
-0.0224039443,
-0.0051533305,
-0.0564785376,
-0.0411366485,
0.0146271978,
0.0305177793,
0.0371452942,
-0.0751425773,
0.0083615631,
0.0450180508,
-0.0160824973,
0.068101272,
0.1126126051,
0.0351558402,
0.0143890036,
-0.0054443651,
0.0681171045,
-0.0164813958,
0.0187791791,
-0.0123109445,
0.0587468147,
-0.0019493521,
-0.007604009,
0.038677685,
-0.0347646698,
-0.0476061665,
0.0019776202,
0.0681991279,
0.0459487662,
-0.0244851448,
-0.0139174191,
-0.0430880934,
0.0168207306,
-0.0021423446,
0.0350973271,
0.0793127567,
-0.043317236,
-0.0062910197,
-0.0460754,
0.0405447781,
-0.0538129732,
0.0408892296,
-0.0290973932,
-0.002533793,
-0.0329326205,
-0.0970963016,
-0.0317264125,
0.0071916953,
-0.0021266113,
0.0410280265,
-0.0075528938,
0.0051332,
0.014984604,
-0.0470343493,
-0.0016130903,
0.0144985039,
-0.0020564049,
-0.0335650556,
-0.0439628325,
0.0441213585,
-0.001912598,
-0.0383210443,
-0.0231376439,
-0.0373761989,
-0.0137646794,
-0.075026162,
0.0710606351,
0.0097895628,
0.0189278517,
-0.060247153,
-0.0643429682,
-0.0300490558,
0.0650687367,
-0.0082184328,
-0.0213233866,
0.0532908179,
0.0068889414,
0.0014135331,
-0.0030491496,
-0.0588886291,
0.0315735489,
0.0016182227,
-0.0532863587,
-0.0513110198,
-0.000952423,
0.0149646513,
0.001187025,
0.0366104133,
0.0372969285,
-0.0323568881,
-0.0204306543,
0.0208584033,
0.0123162186,
-0.0071089994,
-0.0267735273,
0.0472688004,
-0.0139679592,
-0.0111085242,
-0.0100299213,
0.0318991616,
-0.0556045659,
0.0381540656,
-0.0072046597,
0.0620581768,
0.0134563576,
0.0947289392,
0.0061464417,
0.0034135773,
-0.0368073285,
-0.0182193257,
0.0186438151,
0.0173054468,
-0.0053106877,
0.022032097,
0.0137610687,
0.0369611643,
0.027498832,
0.0169109236,
-0.017632395,
-0.0445167795,
-0.014593007,
-0.0203498825,
0.0123344585,
0.0213078354,
0.0309200156,
-0.0034770549,
0.0151499473,
-0.015354123,
0.0743046477,
-0.0002959678,
-0.0472970679,
-0.0051973592,
0.0235344395,
-0.0484235212,
-0.0409576632,
0.0731318817,
-0.0207966082,
-0.0012420778,
-0.0206230674,
-0.0336188152,
-0.0587992035,
0.025029853,
0.0588246211,
0.0153304031,
-0.031043699,
0.018558478,
-0.0144529464,
-0.0540223792,
-0.0050360989,
0.0367961563,
0.0487105399,
0.0240909029,
0.0321462229,
0.0832768306,
0.0024113564,
-0.0188444257,
-0.0309510492,
-0.0210213121,
-0.0081751095,
-0.0465649106,
-0.0650769025,
-5.145790071e-33,
0.0014261093,
-0.0343004428,
-0.0394511111,
0.0519920439,
0.0320135057,
0.0115057379,
-0.075360328,
-0.0047167526,
-0.0082298042,
-0.025988644,
0.0262267105,
0.0237637386,
-0.0172640868,
-0.0262084398,
0.0460339263,
0.0151040498,
0.0374640003,
0.0443586558,
-0.0285176821,
0.0956153348,
-0.0135756591,
0.0099903308,
0.0012847604,
-0.1107330248,
0.0263033528,
-0.0123305228,
0.0304295458,
-0.0101783313,
0.0282530766,
0.0759347975,
-0.0064353868,
0.0354156606,
0.0161124654,
-0.0123897763,
-0.0165584441,
-0.0244310722,
-0.0244922079,
-0.0421299972,
0.0006612205,
-0.0410893857,
0.0144125521,
-0.0497099124,
0.0624608323,
0.0099619776,
0.0037962897,
0.0379700102,
0.1117542386,
0.003511725,
-0.0150235072,
-0.0736654922,
-0.0687953234,
0.0320437998,
-0.0792859495,
0.003657551,
-0.0158565659,
0.0341061279,
0.0360224955,
0.0561350584,
0.0082021495,
-0.0121207442,
0.0013201942,
0.0155542539,
0.0368638448,
0.0016924429,
0.0059659113,
0.011588308,
0.0328339376,
0.0189110115,
-0.0142927542,
-0.0252338704,
0.0407914855,
0.0147671094,
0.0362678021,
0.0156559721,
0.0655190349,
-0.0516028591,
-0.0299737398,
0.0348408483,
0.0100689493,
0.0008109622,
0.0095383162,
0.0314589962,
-0.0502234437,
0.0079095224,
-0.0010356177,
-0.0164281055,
-0.014453155,
-0.0351096056,
0.0145324087,
-0.0079669049,
-0.0250148438,
0.0197861008,
-0.0180471148,
-0.0461486802,
0.0187122095,
0.0212258194,
-0.0183546152,
0.0119349444,
-0.0117253717,
-0.0191954821,
-0.0219865516,
-0.0142848408,
0.0356684402,
-0.0233577341,
0.0896610767,
0.0136972452,
0.0627167672,
-0.0106483577,
-0.064346768,
0.0107102962,
-0.0263873599,
-0.0131841032,
-0.0569012351,
0.039700035,
-0.0271490104,
0.0237958152,
0.0136876618,
0.0148742562,
-0.0089847483,
0.0193410572,
-0.0702554807,
-0.0103183882,
-0.023208119,
-0.0086898319,
-0.0245747864,
-0.0323193483,
-0.002608041,
0.0352450758,
0.0217621736,
-0.0384173878,
-0.0393032283,
-0.0003925036,
2.537e-7,
0.0302651655,
0.0495126881,
0.0337655842,
-0.0392398313,
-0.000290775,
0.0469573885,
-0.0174795017,
0.0151293436,
0.0086731296,
0.0110278353,
0.0001102922,
-0.0158107318,
0.0314821452,
0.0468601398,
-0.0468062833,
-0.0001195397,
-0.0188207719,
0.0137072103,
-0.0454728045,
0.0222057179,
0.0733138174,
0.0608591735,
0.002196834,
0.0079519348,
0.0070200884,
-0.0305176284,
-0.0066147801,
-0.0383989401,
0.0771767125,
0.0413659625,
0.0149161965,
0.0270039886,
-0.0040734066,
0.012594087,
-0.0324135423,
-0.0282975696,
-0.0059095011,
0.0129621327,
-0.021727819,
0.0023412257,
0.0327851325,
0.0139344297,
0.0290583149,
-0.0523339882,
0.0163783468,
-0.0243267883,
0.0206360705,
0.0168065187,
-0.0103875902,
0.0152916154,
0.017222384,
-0.0092009502,
-0.0191003326,
-0.0027204535,
0.0036726908,
-0.0595518984,
-0.0078936405,
-0.0826816782,
-0.0104838153,
0.0256453343,
-0.0351533517,
-0.0189026967,
-0.0220796485,
0.0390186831,
0.0312999003,
-0.0014913438,
0.0693249628,
2.242651744e-34,
0.0478488393,
-0.0417324267,
0.0068354555,
0.0056703519,
0.0505236909,
0.0030341663,
-0.0163211357,
0.0111931702,
0.017408289,
0.0113961007,
-0.0184851512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13714v1 | A study of the impact of generative AI-based data augmentation on software metadata classification | 2023-10-14T10:47:10 | 2023-10-14T10:47:10 | Tripti Kumari, Chakali Sai Charan, Ayan Das | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents the system submitted by the team from IIT(ISM) Dhanbad in
FIRE IRSE 2023 shared task 1 on the automatic usefulness prediction of
code-comment pairs as well as the impact of Large Language Model(LLM) generated
data on original base data towards an associated source code. We have developed
a framework where we train a machine learning-based model using the neural
contextual representations of the comments and their corresponding codes to
predict the usefulness of code-comments pair and performance analysis with
LLM-generated data with base data. In the official assessment, our system
achieves a 4% increase in F1-score from baseline and the quality of generated
data. | [
0.0505269244,
0.0548670404,
-0.0305170678,
0.0431091115,
0.0089627542,
0.0047494606,
-0.0261193328,
0.0054780999,
-0.0199955646,
-0.0757883266,
-0.0086313877,
0.0330287479,
0.0067781443,
0.0140087912,
0.0221782923,
-0.0250506159,
0.0279803667,
0.0008844478,
-0.0430530012,
0.0373029783,
0.0016538659,
0.0055790874,
0.0087786093,
0.0571421497,
-0.0539856367,
-0.0221051201,
0.0317373052,
0.0065343645,
-0.0154760741,
-0.0475178994,
-0.0092019662,
0.0360459127,
-0.0131900636,
0.052121222,
0.0000021138,
-0.0571911037,
-0.0031329538,
0.0151052698,
-0.0420746543,
0.0511294454,
0.0269725006,
0.0069504874,
-0.0030238959,
-0.0064703678,
-0.046320647,
-0.0553163141,
0.0331882462,
-0.0030776453,
0.043577347,
0.0457261279,
-0.0005027959,
-0.0336237587,
0.0405873321,
0.0097907688,
0.0709419474,
-0.0202020016,
-0.0066411402,
0.0864755362,
0.0204573348,
0.0536328368,
0.0133382631,
0.00413677,
0.0226584021,
-0.0098837381,
0.0825191364,
0.0598141067,
-0.0284779295,
0.0461931266,
0.0351238474,
0.0286221225,
0.0363833234,
-0.0375411995,
-0.0098359669,
-0.0210742243,
-0.0137473932,
-0.0250512995,
-0.0210098773,
0.0040098564,
0.0315844007,
0.0033081877,
0.0488950685,
-0.0082180109,
0.0305857565,
-0.0022417994,
0.020391481,
0.062709339,
-0.0155006712,
-0.0165988933,
-0.0075981109,
-0.02537385,
-0.012216541,
-0.0666872337,
-0.0377399214,
0.0454385057,
0.0307287797,
0.0237875599,
-0.0220505875,
-0.0833739713,
0.0396940522,
-0.0405197814,
-0.0208331831,
0.0250969287,
-0.0693012476,
0.0123609081,
-0.066587165,
0.0432747677,
0.0038054644,
-0.0212174077,
-0.0038587572,
-0.0278226398,
-0.0725333542,
-0.015437969,
-0.0078049712,
0.0871744454,
0.0364774168,
0.034070991,
-0.0469730049,
0.0483235531,
-0.0222432092,
0.0322437361,
0.0328404605,
0.0021256111,
-0.014818782,
0.0375602357,
-0.0345347039,
-0.058229167,
-0.043906033,
-0.0133977775,
-0.0297475103,
-0.0318251587,
0.027411174,
0.0174029991,
-0.021623604,
-0.0165417567,
0.022215737,
0.0343509316,
0.058537595,
0.0086001558,
-0.053036917,
-0.0137247043,
0.0220350008,
0.0152242407,
-0.0013472845,
-0.0864660591,
-0.0470021255,
0.0096424622,
0.0109690223,
-0.0236281957,
-0.013834592,
-0.0226840395,
0.022715332,
0.0549345389,
-0.1121835113,
0.0100033069,
0.0593052953,
0.0162459947,
-0.0036074955,
0.0175959039,
0.037270043,
-0.0079551982,
0.0400324166,
-0.0285722278,
0.0371716917,
0.0040006349,
-0.0347634628,
-0.0319429561,
-0.0282643121,
0.0334130824,
0.0135663068,
-0.0373367853,
-0.0188073944,
-0.000067259,
-0.0181378946,
-0.0021687637,
-0.0248645823,
0.0418836139,
0.0231414512,
0.0600964315,
0.053146828,
0.0352787785,
0.0051007289,
-0.0383273214,
0.0057666311,
0.0610498749,
-0.0022225308,
0.0181421377,
0.0054730745,
-0.0110167544,
-0.0126864184,
-0.0905943364,
0.0048901201,
-0.058233913,
0.0019811122,
-0.0177505668,
0.0354836695,
-0.0010817942,
-0.0130404504,
-0.0198350307,
0.0488954633,
-0.0054007396,
-0.0143264309,
-0.0628773272,
0.0275037307,
0.0677647516,
0.0655754507,
-0.0874036178,
-0.0367011987,
-0.0144962464,
-0.0003093422,
-0.0113421706,
0.0303934719,
-0.0286805592,
-0.0138172265,
-0.0477937721,
-0.0325529128,
-0.0679356232,
0.007854661,
0.0423243381,
-0.0095113758,
-0.0437171534,
0.0477001667,
-0.0037833718,
-0.071971029,
0.0308196768,
0.0018009618,
-0.0250404626,
0.0227363557,
-0.0097400052,
0.0123444274,
0.016819248,
-0.035437271,
0.0085874032,
0.0620146021,
-0.0037022349,
-0.0094375061,
-0.0221895799,
-0.0127336327,
0.0074290438,
0.0358493775,
-0.0207176693,
0.0162533,
-0.0072679999,
-0.0237849224,
-0.0435629264,
0.0103431987,
-0.0387563556,
0.0590924099,
0.0029242416,
0.0092652934,
-0.0353216939,
-0.0037951579,
-0.0312168542,
0.0459921695,
0.0372864008,
0.0348887257,
-0.0019915972,
0.0554695241,
0.0759424269,
0.043294277,
-0.0399207734,
-0.0315373391,
-0.0425784253,
0.0428632013,
0.0253363494,
0.0183223784,
-0.0350751169,
-0.0033378017,
-0.1264710724,
-0.0256955307,
0.0114350636,
0.0053749071,
0.0049918061,
0.012985968,
0.018648291,
-0.022254698,
-0.0243326016,
-0.0362615921,
-0.0392121188,
-0.0427735448,
0.054323338,
0.0144107118,
-0.0156035684,
-0.0159432907,
-0.0055479659,
-0.0463162176,
0.0489227027,
0.0528482869,
-0.037341591,
-0.0760788992,
0.0432552099,
-0.0163422283,
0.0100293569,
-0.025013132,
-0.0063637807,
0.008541801,
-0.0229446143,
0.0447717942,
0.0079262657,
-0.0234697908,
-0.023667451,
0.0479725339,
0.0325221606,
-0.0546149947,
0.0081740618,
0.0574356802,
0.0010649967,
-0.0077811475,
-0.0212155804,
0.0320940353,
-0.0170680322,
-0.0245582704,
-0.00758562,
0.0045814151,
-0.0220476445,
-0.0091437465,
0.006003344,
0.0250309128,
-0.0239306372,
-0.0101217795,
0.0406138822,
-0.0014386639,
-0.0735417977,
0.0475682355,
-0.0660319626,
-0.0231519956,
-0.0596845411,
-0.0092949169,
-0.0688325986,
0.0802366212,
0.0038423031,
0.0046640374,
-0.0034954241,
-0.0162365083,
-0.0224677883,
0.007505131,
-0.049325075,
-0.0166258141,
0.0310235657,
-0.0274751,
0.0190622322,
0.0246987119,
0.0319788493,
-0.0436022878,
0.0029561103,
0.0105749359,
0.0001676914,
0.0223502368,
0.0212716796,
0.079560183,
-0.0039708293,
0.002719989,
0.0619009882,
0.0298327301,
-0.0441839918,
0.0007120015,
-0.0174390804,
0.0176594034,
-0.0410241,
-0.0254920162,
0.0133429822,
-0.0311740544,
-0.0157883,
0.0510125607,
0.0025595627,
-0.090144068,
-0.0442783795,
0.0157658663,
-0.0195363555,
-0.0274853539,
0.0567703545,
-0.0099507868,
-0.0459865481,
0.0007045139,
0.106626749,
0.0556974113,
-0.0599337034,
0.0093859313,
-0.0110296784,
-0.0211114511,
0.0768040121,
0.0398074538,
-0.0864059776,
0.0035513064,
-0.0322278738,
0.0179084819,
-0.03602897,
-0.0092090908,
0.0048901537,
-0.0815890804,
0.0177979916,
-0.0191044789,
-0.0068646697,
-0.0170702878,
-0.0242630411,
-0.0139558595,
0.0101475986,
-0.0349173509,
-0.0290020406,
0.0168808401,
0.0245668422,
0.0417615026,
-0.0512352102,
-0.0109011177,
0.0284474138,
-0.0291458573,
0.0910476968,
0.1066340506,
0.021819694,
-0.0293136686,
-0.0112519199,
0.0716110542,
0.0091521535,
0.0256633982,
-0.0155012636,
0.0695761889,
0.0102580935,
-0.0030043654,
0.0592169948,
-0.0270724352,
-0.0411993302,
0.0195497051,
0.0589237958,
0.0718492568,
-0.037243098,
0.0341658555,
-0.0274148546,
-0.0266724806,
-0.037067093,
0.0274878051,
0.0642695278,
-0.0216233507,
0.0177009087,
-0.051317282,
0.0210363045,
-0.0507154316,
0.0331120454,
-0.0114427162,
-0.0228868742,
-0.0490663573,
-0.0696565509,
-0.0391245075,
0.0019803499,
0.0002102028,
0.0262089837,
0.0451764539,
-0.0119964397,
-0.0101628359,
-0.0313045308,
0.0008976571,
-0.0111671882,
0.0139039289,
-0.0355910733,
-0.0554289259,
0.0609889179,
-0.0137087451,
-0.0394645035,
-0.0206376165,
-0.0595076419,
-0.0055948715,
-0.0329621918,
0.0900521278,
0.0134235295,
0.0325989686,
-0.0537692159,
-0.0511531383,
-0.0172887202,
0.0345848277,
-0.0487339459,
-0.0164981354,
0.0281647407,
-0.0121786436,
-0.0113336015,
-0.015726218,
-0.0602337755,
0.043481458,
0.0251915101,
-0.0348497443,
-0.0011041883,
0.0121201165,
0.0410430357,
0.0434065983,
0.0305398162,
0.0208979975,
-0.0268067867,
0.0116259344,
0.0172530152,
-0.0138977431,
-0.0327595435,
-0.0145944487,
0.0253904089,
0.0165448245,
0.0099162264,
0.0110294037,
0.0136125321,
-0.0233810544,
0.0361916572,
-0.0006939666,
0.0559089817,
-0.0178787205,
0.0891565904,
-0.0054052118,
0.0049622157,
-0.0326325893,
-0.0152267609,
0.0221577771,
-0.0022534237,
-0.0267170444,
0.0237631686,
0.0030346185,
0.0252757501,
0.0113170389,
0.0327746831,
-0.0310859382,
-0.0206675082,
-0.0132920472,
-0.0076063806,
0.0117660863,
0.0225213002,
0.0369387083,
-0.0221410319,
0.0329566933,
-0.0371119827,
0.055690255,
-0.0165785272,
-0.0377580598,
0.0075499364,
0.0209616683,
-0.0527365431,
-0.0315841064,
0.0793596953,
-0.0136748217,
-0.0157606788,
-0.0093155671,
-0.033498656,
-0.0416727141,
0.0006608104,
0.0176907759,
0.0007176793,
-0.0373708643,
0.0103760846,
-0.011236323,
-0.0607801117,
-0.0229449533,
0.0277597159,
0.0419585519,
-0.0040223598,
0.0229656361,
0.0795574486,
0.0075323,
-0.0130252372,
-0.0343974084,
-0.0146369273,
-0.0179523118,
-0.0350957252,
-0.0399587005,
-5.554383458e-33,
-0.0171046872,
-0.0135415578,
-0.0028017447,
0.0541237257,
0.001648063,
0.0228677336,
-0.0601415001,
-0.0204125121,
-0.0095555764,
-0.0452118143,
-0.0026943018,
0.0339155495,
-0.011845543,
-0.0086141303,
0.0574392118,
-0.0131338267,
0.0445219576,
0.0186737906,
-0.0121577997,
0.0646676049,
-0.0192163084,
0.0079275751,
0.0106892204,
-0.1075409129,
0.0315808691,
-0.0262238737,
0.0505024046,
-0.0360574573,
0.0183819458,
0.0948090553,
-0.0037401235,
0.0207751337,
0.0272357315,
-0.0535469875,
-0.0120888967,
-0.0592861623,
-0.0497845933,
-0.0299205557,
-0.0009424033,
-0.0047558695,
0.0390887372,
-0.0457555391,
0.0765192136,
0.0088003194,
-0.0060247914,
0.0183386058,
0.0830997452,
-0.0210286528,
-0.0183983427,
-0.081436418,
-0.0708840266,
0.0361819379,
-0.0492286421,
0.052904807,
0.020751277,
0.0214498695,
0.0213600639,
0.0502421819,
-0.0045668846,
-0.0233879425,
0.0134140495,
0.0427088663,
0.0684522241,
0.0248731393,
0.0292399134,
-0.0055567538,
0.0211428553,
0.0512361899,
0.0284293778,
-0.0164967757,
0.03221412,
0.0287402868,
0.0153560024,
0.0159118902,
0.0653987527,
-0.035283681,
-0.0238410104,
0.0460567661,
0.0133071635,
0.0175198689,
-0.012224664,
0.0317775793,
-0.0698223785,
-0.0066776411,
0.0099781631,
0.0075247488,
-0.0098092929,
-0.0607260279,
-0.0027575546,
-0.0295653157,
-0.001294687,
0.039083004,
-0.0201419871,
-0.0675618947,
0.0147030763,
0.0158802886,
-0.0170116518,
0.0413731784,
-0.0033240404,
-0.0053822412,
-0.011788886,
-0.0111383703,
0.0307810139,
-0.0078121969,
0.074239485,
0.0108390292,
0.0715998635,
0.0116226003,
-0.0591791645,
-0.0109929638,
-0.0348448902,
-0.0510962084,
-0.0244883299,
0.015663689,
-0.0057274741,
0.0380853228,
0.0007381924,
0.0229197964,
0.0067691943,
0.0135249384,
-0.0458615683,
-0.0490224957,
0.002602444,
-0.0212093294,
-0.0314482152,
-0.0249974765,
-0.0251626745,
-0.0064666546,
0.0583195761,
-0.0296829045,
-0.0415806472,
0.0102860555,
2.793e-7,
0.034812253,
0.0567223914,
0.0108659873,
-0.034799438,
-0.0022468586,
0.0225737467,
-0.06762705,
-0.0068015857,
0.0162123684,
0.0357279778,
0.0075016352,
-0.0294962674,
0.0444234423,
0.0314431377,
-0.051092498,
-0.006883868,
-0.0272464659,
-0.0221981406,
-0.0545326956,
0.0300664846,
0.0467079841,
0.0786133781,
0.0300251637,
0.0057492419,
0.0056341626,
-0.0096780797,
-0.0087010274,
-0.0467424691,
0.0551553555,
0.063275449,
0.0110011352,
0.0354277566,
-0.0163323656,
0.0162984803,
-0.0169697478,
-0.0173595306,
0.0026756297,
0.0014210746,
-0.0147355767,
0.0327553228,
0.0435452387,
-0.0138322674,
0.0178608168,
-0.0678467229,
0.0256898701,
0.0068167937,
-0.0239579678,
0.0117650591,
-0.0576454625,
0.0270442236,
-0.0271928925,
-0.0081361495,
0.0135682365,
-0.0171264429,
-0.0070287059,
-0.0684912205,
-0.0325792022,
-0.0566023923,
-0.010010588,
0.0260805544,
-0.0235175751,
-0.0387363322,
-0.0417716019,
0.0074045379,
0.0369107239,
-0.0283155851,
0.0670107752,
2.544916801e-34,
0.0413113199,
-0.028930096,
0.0066359248,
-0.000106409,
0.0293689538,
-0.0116960686,
-0.0183430165,
0.0233754087,
-0.016569566,
-0.0211008731,
-0.0254414286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09550v1 | Can Large Language Model Comprehend Ancient Chinese? A Preliminary Test on ACLUE | 2023-10-14T10:06:39 | 2023-10-14T10:06:39 | Yixuan Zhang, Haonan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable capabilities in
understanding and generating language. However, their ability in comprehending
ancient languages, particularly ancient Chinese, remains largely unexplored. To
bridge this gap, we present ACLUE, an evaluation benchmark designed to assess
the capability of language models in comprehending ancient Chinese. ACLUE
consists of 15 tasks cover a range of skills, spanning phonetic, lexical,
syntactic, semantic, inference and knowledge. Through the evaluation of eight
state-of-the-art LLMs, we observed a noticeable disparity in their performance
between modern Chinese and ancient Chinese. Among the assessed models, ChatGLM2
demonstrates the most remarkable performance, achieving an average score of
37.4%. We have made our code and data public available. | [
0.0220708754,
0.0563588515,
-0.016492039,
0.0561117567,
-0.029065799,
0.0240571592,
0.0324025154,
0.0227402449,
0.018515382,
-0.035987258,
-0.0535967983,
-0.0895681381,
0.0507517792,
0.0040842667,
0.0182836652,
-0.0333148055,
0.0429738052,
-0.0172477663,
-0.0169345867,
0.0167818181,
-0.0246107485,
-0.0114953853,
0.0140434941,
0.0274865814,
0.0263237748,
-0.0390893817,
0.0088683916,
0.0204273555,
0.0032705883,
-0.0289097615,
-0.0533170439,
0.0046526836,
0.0017726358,
0.0669132993,
0.0000019468,
-0.0524320826,
0.0192592014,
-0.0260436814,
-0.0378251523,
0.0570546947,
0.0576175265,
0.0035226748,
-0.0304866303,
-0.0125254383,
-0.0334093012,
-0.020203976,
0.0344559774,
0.046209842,
0.0069725132,
0.0707883984,
0.002223816,
-0.0265289526,
0.0251583084,
-0.0485980734,
-0.0145282354,
-0.0656470805,
0.0180121306,
0.0642928854,
0.0118087353,
-0.0155563364,
-0.0631467402,
0.0431605913,
0.0094476035,
0.0115022939,
-0.0521999709,
0.0317145325,
-0.0195403546,
-0.0088616125,
-0.0088721653,
0.0299042035,
-0.0121624814,
-0.0028660554,
-0.029777335,
0.0252001304,
-0.0327558294,
-0.0270987879,
-0.0600577854,
0.0336425714,
-0.0107191494,
0.0341857336,
0.0446663238,
-0.0503013618,
0.0554476082,
0.017469041,
-0.0376990438,
0.0393540822,
0.0437988676,
-0.0097781438,
-0.0093388176,
-0.001743398,
-0.0048180348,
-0.0295449179,
-0.0095737102,
0.0653057247,
-0.0456861295,
0.0357202925,
0.0374820195,
0.0291642062,
-0.0114453156,
-0.0503222719,
0.0468135364,
0.0537208878,
-0.0200534742,
0.0580862761,
-0.0514789633,
0.0637112558,
0.0028639399,
0.0001681442,
-0.0478447713,
-0.0139061837,
-0.026014233,
-0.0231543612,
-0.0359208472,
0.0224031154,
-0.0454223454,
-0.0313568711,
-0.0082722083,
-0.0002455488,
0.0245875269,
-0.0260910857,
-0.0180170797,
-0.0168403797,
-0.0423101336,
-0.0172860175,
-0.0338969678,
0.0217395127,
-0.0045697461,
0.0184616596,
-0.0095970193,
-0.074629955,
-0.0029518411,
0.000842307,
-0.0055709374,
-0.0238960274,
0.0026124713,
0.0791134164,
-0.0155859264,
-0.0104649821,
-0.0368118063,
0.0146759702,
-0.0355809256,
-0.0837946981,
0.0052150567,
-0.0350564308,
0.0020544014,
0.0004260293,
0.0426113009,
-0.0228376072,
0.015180802,
-0.0056918156,
-0.0210899562,
0.003329691,
0.0253839884,
0.0226060078,
-0.0068507181,
0.0142915966,
-0.0074958825,
0.0495735072,
0.0549075119,
0.0065215137,
0.0244683959,
0.0024342679,
-0.0480618253,
0.0164272171,
-0.0178092048,
-0.0162876714,
-0.0548144393,
-0.0223813374,
0.0393208824,
0.0304830577,
-0.0004902674,
0.0722060874,
-0.0102403546,
-0.0121281054,
0.0596320182,
0.0302044116,
0.0155662335,
0.0374470279,
0.036160402,
-0.0426897146,
0.0451509096,
0.0083096903,
-0.0484940261,
0.0038446777,
-0.016064452,
0.021954935,
0.003535135,
0.0321541429,
-0.0230101831,
-0.0472925231,
-0.0394922271,
-0.0050613098,
-0.0084357699,
-0.0030966345,
0.0553036369,
-0.0042575309,
-0.0190257244,
0.0166861117,
0.040999379,
-0.0248203781,
0.0371972173,
-0.0433372855,
0.0462133698,
0.0882595554,
0.0440020263,
0.0004801526,
-0.0048020869,
0.0329601988,
-0.0014161972,
0.0843657926,
0.0658077449,
-0.0111847604,
0.0159017704,
-0.0355674662,
0.0079925461,
0.0014932355,
0.0184348859,
0.0152890999,
-0.0074623595,
0.033973638,
0.0142144412,
-0.0404077731,
-0.0308365002,
0.0442523547,
-0.0880330503,
-0.0087130768,
-0.0347778648,
-0.012489344,
0.0143493218,
0.0189274009,
-0.034738224,
0.0168990493,
0.0198565666,
-0.0503797531,
-0.015920762,
0.0282015875,
-0.0714344159,
-0.0581263788,
0.0800513551,
-0.0284931939,
-0.029953558,
0.0335713141,
-0.0205849931,
-0.048528146,
0.0427463278,
0.0016455543,
0.0574518889,
-0.0568265319,
0.0517373495,
-0.012999773,
0.0235952809,
-0.0146119324,
0.0968796536,
0.0210784748,
0.0362348631,
0.0255878922,
0.0101239299,
0.0217165519,
-0.0387700275,
-0.0565435886,
-0.0067395372,
0.0195356049,
-0.0051176907,
-0.007229154,
0.0216323528,
-0.0314387642,
-0.0341597237,
-0.0736084282,
0.0239754058,
-0.0441071801,
0.0032299906,
0.02763661,
-0.0192649737,
-0.0040962608,
0.0015147721,
-0.0393081307,
0.0217681453,
-0.0245226156,
-0.0157517344,
0.0077548353,
-0.0330907591,
-0.0391630828,
-0.0279919114,
0.003153957,
0.0063082599,
0.0329653956,
0.0337549038,
-0.0168569498,
-0.0165703874,
-0.0069092573,
-0.0357034802,
-0.0019007603,
-0.0194824524,
-0.0203047693,
-0.0043143104,
-0.0342403799,
0.0276088137,
0.0214598645,
0.005834823,
0.0298363641,
0.0272735357,
-0.016347073,
-0.0153032141,
-0.0085249348,
0.0003873573,
-0.0331095308,
-0.078423582,
-0.024810385,
-0.0679402053,
0.0893759355,
0.0282092765,
0.0247511268,
-0.0349619463,
-0.0261265561,
-0.0407527722,
0.0062384428,
-0.0126127684,
0.0399388708,
-0.0417428017,
0.0263077188,
-0.0742858276,
-0.018487053,
0.0510380268,
-0.0354558453,
-0.0181717239,
-0.0185770784,
0.0128808618,
-0.064199701,
0.0992420465,
0.0037610345,
0.0311216954,
-0.0063294438,
-0.0325578041,
-0.0468392558,
0.0524013378,
0.0002171612,
-0.0487240888,
0.0250704605,
-0.0245000329,
0.0136282919,
-0.0335333496,
0.0033686676,
-0.0282784607,
0.0036648409,
-0.0584197566,
0.0623977408,
0.0406951755,
0.0038279376,
-0.0323464312,
0.0442202203,
-0.0257731006,
-0.0141634205,
-0.0114870761,
0.0262210201,
-0.0162330177,
0.004969487,
0.0303580109,
0.074672848,
0.0070638661,
-0.0482303798,
0.0800443441,
0.0441860594,
0.035727337,
0.0085359281,
-0.0110022724,
0.0294857081,
0.0309393015,
-0.0275205895,
-0.0256687813,
-0.0129409656,
0.024259951,
-0.0692806542,
0.0137675991,
0.1047983989,
0.0223285984,
0.0121640814,
0.0399266444,
-0.0139492862,
-0.0019654839,
0.030406829,
-0.0382807739,
-0.1083322391,
-0.0329665728,
0.0004581329,
-0.01068349,
0.0406497419,
-0.0240551811,
0.0083981697,
-0.1510399431,
0.0362193435,
0.0286244247,
-0.0629100427,
-0.0176440291,
-0.0110549387,
-0.0015307744,
-0.0044033336,
0.0345404334,
0.0570471026,
-0.0188758969,
-0.025835162,
0.0099825617,
-0.011414527,
-0.0389317535,
0.0546306819,
-0.0343220532,
0.0590641312,
0.0319654793,
0.0629279986,
0.003185838,
0.0135356672,
0.0325626545,
0.0147515992,
0.0231213104,
-0.0057207127,
0.048207961,
0.019834483,
-0.0186749306,
0.0073436988,
0.0003114339,
-0.0298270732,
-0.0076333131,
0.0312501825,
0.0511227697,
-0.0031848834,
-0.0349317864,
0.0411478914,
0.0108097959,
-0.0414289087,
0.1186139956,
0.0348983668,
-0.0267472882,
-0.0582404919,
-0.020665722,
-0.0352645889,
-0.0391328521,
-0.0397650376,
0.0556926057,
0.002291197,
-0.0129953055,
-0.1018741056,
-0.0400886275,
0.0081691463,
0.0086827995,
0.0438114218,
0.0167946555,
-0.0115409363,
0.010645492,
-0.0487047918,
-0.0013467495,
-0.0217322484,
0.0188754685,
-0.0592109896,
-0.0239934605,
0.0158178583,
-0.0538921393,
0.0000835679,
0.0366538018,
-0.0596287772,
-0.0405135602,
0.0073289894,
-0.0048646056,
0.0225634575,
0.0227850266,
-0.0100640776,
0.0002038281,
0.0199260432,
-0.009185737,
-0.0209714286,
0.0218286831,
-0.0026443365,
-0.0129603026,
-0.0018599909,
0.0407894105,
-0.0331218541,
0.0178932901,
0.0261036493,
0.0658634529,
0.0016727505,
-0.0195461269,
0.0356831439,
0.0364254452,
-0.0074695977,
-0.0304782819,
0.0013594321,
-0.0301246811,
0.033690162,
-0.0400563776,
-0.0123761529,
-0.0370287262,
-0.016744066,
0.057142362,
0.0031282676,
0.0082155894,
-0.0161097459,
0.0253658481,
0.0322397426,
-0.025826212,
0.010632487,
-0.0056189094,
0.009051444,
-0.0245313309,
0.0103200972,
-0.0192783363,
0.0123752998,
-0.0231574196,
0.051722832,
-0.0036129171,
0.0415137075,
-0.0018031871,
0.0205081608,
0.0013989422,
-0.0252849236,
-0.0742683411,
-0.0878445059,
0.0024100482,
0.050388217,
0.0889260694,
-0.0054796049,
0.071648024,
-0.0486376174,
-0.0083551658,
-0.0530397631,
0.0197252966,
0.0278931372,
-0.0420686752,
-0.0126158791,
0.0137540465,
-0.0194045063,
-0.0091334721,
0.0704474524,
0.0081394417,
0.0493503399,
0.0281671397,
0.0083195716,
-0.0288181808,
-0.034241017,
0.0185535084,
-0.024947064,
-0.0227874555,
0.0134263756,
-0.0856887251,
-0.0778001621,
-0.0179640818,
0.0332602337,
0.0153136393,
-0.0077191587,
-0.0171100385,
0.0306120738,
0.007719731,
0.0044819294,
-0.0733542517,
0.0119725959,
-0.0057724612,
0.0159365591,
-0.0128929764,
-6.453298682e-33,
-0.0488651171,
0.0080379555,
0.0415240042,
-0.0117197055,
-0.0133680534,
-0.0019827886,
-0.0927081034,
0.0266648084,
-0.0531803407,
0.0025070112,
0.0100729764,
-0.009716793,
0.0034011798,
0.0215053968,
-0.0128191942,
-0.0081731239,
0.0238227248,
0.0024962961,
0.0074446425,
0.0153822498,
0.0777673125,
0.0521283858,
0.056969434,
-0.0200485326,
0.0070973211,
0.002223752,
0.0167239662,
0.004173995,
-0.0282313805,
0.0745825917,
-0.028736921,
0.0181278139,
0.0443613939,
-0.0137991952,
-0.031154057,
-0.0464428775,
-0.1043830663,
-0.0042607775,
0.0289346445,
0.0390039235,
-0.0013824393,
0.0156627893,
0.001652391,
0.0023143035,
0.0067058611,
-0.0354683958,
0.0265056938,
-0.062405549,
-0.0202107541,
-0.0030191687,
-0.0615116097,
0.0538609885,
-0.0087977778,
-0.0264716893,
-0.00425715,
0.0036040556,
-0.0274200253,
0.0226385631,
-0.0146060055,
-0.0081247687,
0.0184070822,
0.0486888364,
0.053344097,
0.0454376414,
0.0067831674,
0.0580560751,
0.0255730171,
-0.0276591759,
-0.0134465285,
0.0120769544,
0.048794359,
0.0471669361,
-0.0065988093,
0.0367613398,
0.037007492,
-0.0171413887,
-0.0780039281,
-0.0204677898,
0.0660118163,
0.025440935,
0.0221182443,
0.0126931332,
-0.0150093762,
-0.0072123818,
-0.0341078378,
-0.003944057,
-0.0291030277,
-0.0210836101,
0.0246452335,
-0.003919723,
-0.0007219302,
-0.0261372719,
0.0337076411,
-0.0845012516,
-0.0246073455,
0.0228175726,
-0.012470928,
-0.0195376668,
-0.016394699,
0.0323578306,
-0.057384342,
-0.0686564595,
0.0099671707,
0.0127394758,
-0.0223934893,
-0.0228069127,
0.0145595307,
0.0175388679,
-0.0375840031,
0.0007422587,
-0.0385937206,
-0.0565045066,
0.0194442682,
0.0234554354,
0.0587048717,
-0.0159354396,
-0.0037715062,
0.0028826597,
0.0076190052,
-0.0010937942,
-0.0335739404,
0.0123841269,
-0.0197398048,
-0.0070077963,
-0.0177497547,
0.0050761988,
-0.0235975124,
0.0067255404,
0.0503156446,
-0.0464827232,
-0.0029853776,
0.0216009989,
2.656e-7,
0.0753860548,
-0.0111230612,
0.0402495116,
0.053155005,
0.017860366,
-0.0067832768,
-0.0795887411,
0.0101539809,
-0.0070752497,
0.0005323649,
0.0211890768,
0.0585200861,
0.1006869227,
0.0156110404,
-0.0569031164,
0.0355165377,
-0.0585721172,
-0.0229945239,
-0.0325636975,
0.0233858693,
0.0093460893,
0.1136221066,
-0.0403950661,
-0.0255666059,
0.017813025,
-0.0626545921,
0.0521045551,
-0.0143709844,
-0.008013133,
0.0533157326,
0.0200551301,
0.0113589177,
-0.0080685327,
0.0207440201,
-0.0065032514,
0.0398947224,
0.0288925935,
0.0853483006,
0.0166034717,
-0.0118661802,
0.0004206791,
-0.0016073228,
0.0052096723,
-0.0605591498,
0.0612026863,
0.0209264327,
-0.0418137051,
-0.0099286819,
-0.0111468788,
0.0257456657,
-0.0188923571,
0.0015350793,
-0.0076687471,
0.0286170039,
0.0231416337,
-0.0362444967,
0.0020583505,
-0.0557440743,
-0.0481413044,
0.0116633484,
-0.0622363016,
-0.0772303566,
0.0194255132,
-0.0321592055,
-0.0052169068,
-0.0280629769,
-0.0409686752,
2.014392782e-34,
0.0304721035,
-0.0463378504,
-0.0027662152,
0.0642111227,
0.0375135802,
-0.0263378732,
0.0199960079,
-0.0024223719,
-0.0250770021,
-0.0376194604,
-0.0230650026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10729v1 | Chatbot-supported Thesis Writing: An Autoethnographic Report | 2023-10-14T09:09:26 | 2023-10-14T09:09:26 | Nicolas Schwenke, Heinrich Söbke, Eckhard Kraft | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, 97U50 (Primary), 68T50 (Secondary), I.2.7; I.2.1; K.3.1 | The release of the large language model based chatbot ChatGPT in November
2022 has brought considerable attention to the subject of artificial
intelligence, not only in the public. From the perspective of higher education,
ChatGPT challenges various learning and assessment formats as it significantly
reduces the effectiveness of their learning and assessment functionalities. In
particular, ChatGPT might be applied to formats that require learners to
generate text, such as bachelor theses or student research papers. Accordingly,
the research question arises to what extent writing of bachelor theses is still
a valid learning and assessment format. Correspondingly, in this study, the
first author was asked to write his bachelor's thesis exploiting ChatGPT. For
tracing the impact of ChatGPT, methodically an autoethnographic approach was
used. First, all considerations on the potential use of ChatGPT were documented
in logs and secondly, all ChatGPT chats were logged. Both logs and chat
histories were analyzed and are presented along to the recommendations for
students regarding the use of ChatGPT suggested by Gimpel et al. (2023). In
conclusion, ChatGPT is beneficial in thesis writing during various activities,
such as brainstorming, structuring and text revision. However, there arise
limitations, e.g., in referencing. Thus, ChatGPT requires a continuous
validation of the outcomes generated fostering learning. Currently, ChatGPT is
to be valued as a beneficial tool in thesis writing. However, writing a
conclusive thesis still requires the learner's meaningful engagement.
Accordingly, writing a thesis is still a valid learning and assessment format.
With further releases of ChatGPT, an increase in capabilities is to be expected
and the research question needs to be reevaluated from time to time. | [
0.0752148032,
-0.0543348677,
-0.0378210768,
-0.0536076128,
-0.0679167435,
0.0030921386,
0.0481181368,
-0.0071355547,
0.0759072229,
-0.0744706914,
-0.0008975296,
0.0114541976,
-0.0141901746,
0.0268353559,
0.014066088,
-0.028800685,
0.0252467003,
0.0185062028,
-0.0068606171,
0.0187056456,
0.0500691161,
0.0146845235,
-0.0194301438,
0.0690523386,
-0.0455418341,
-0.0393008702,
-0.0376930945,
-0.028067939,
-0.0088578295,
0.0098090628,
0.0312985443,
0.0689235851,
-0.0088172946,
0.0707823485,
0.000002413,
-0.035579402,
-0.0205724612,
0.0103969006,
-0.0084718913,
-0.0047676107,
0.0603529029,
0.0941849649,
-0.0205929745,
0.0241701063,
-0.0428630263,
0.071611546,
0.0498938113,
0.0054630358,
0.0330743194,
0.0278502945,
-0.0038385158,
-0.0073371879,
0.0490749478,
0.0453740098,
0.026633393,
0.0445643365,
-0.0158351827,
0.0673613846,
0.060699936,
0.0303259101,
-0.0053306194,
0.0443919264,
-0.0009978189,
-0.0805617198,
0.0461949743,
0.0191949215,
-0.0268496051,
-0.0534645431,
0.0310766883,
-0.0024974507,
0.0480512269,
-0.0329995602,
0.0161113571,
0.0111286817,
0.014716397,
0.053258948,
-0.0522714518,
0.0144506022,
-0.0209374465,
-0.0344475135,
0.0359436534,
-0.0576439835,
-0.0244017299,
0.0093418015,
0.0545909591,
-0.0340363793,
-0.0073799803,
-0.0432667956,
-0.0026704122,
0.0081039891,
0.0333514847,
-0.0473826118,
0.0093506081,
0.0740585998,
-0.0137756001,
0.0048440779,
-0.0044887308,
-0.0590411462,
0.0171192978,
-0.0717220828,
-0.0180479735,
0.0413272679,
0.0168811642,
-0.0030153356,
0.002473451,
0.0565074086,
0.0265551284,
0.0366505235,
-0.0190093722,
0.0305353999,
-0.0793158486,
-0.052376017,
-0.0557073653,
0.0608923472,
0.0150057869,
-0.0088887624,
-0.0458221324,
0.0316746905,
-0.0030905898,
0.0180006474,
-0.0428814478,
-0.0035615219,
-0.0470643193,
0.0406038426,
0.0049391198,
0.0095173726,
0.0101317614,
-0.0187455863,
-0.006697332,
-0.0203440282,
0.0382787175,
0.0228638053,
-0.0104225511,
-0.017449962,
0.0024777001,
0.0334853306,
-0.0269425586,
-0.0188725553,
0.0096052485,
-0.0469885767,
0.0101969754,
-0.0390263572,
0.0119337318,
-0.062049713,
-0.0181851853,
0.0309177879,
-0.0298022963,
0.0186365843,
0.024790708,
0.023925595,
0.0198110081,
0.0001996816,
-0.0342849679,
0.0027646141,
0.0627065003,
0.0139405746,
-0.0099173151,
0.0072463518,
0.0260399636,
0.0206682645,
0.0028806075,
-0.0296769217,
0.0538234785,
0.0158709846,
-0.0243571121,
-0.0075399885,
0.0090040136,
-0.0061348733,
0.0470378995,
0.0212445296,
-0.0643929467,
0.0305818617,
-0.0169426426,
0.0796006843,
0.0686795115,
0.0479921401,
-0.0012785378,
0.0503731407,
-0.0174845643,
0.0193532985,
0.0542292967,
0.0332284346,
0.0132498937,
0.0352536067,
-0.0180103239,
-0.0164170098,
-0.0030129044,
-0.0087566124,
0.0069010048,
-0.0762915686,
-0.0239292365,
-0.0050249114,
-0.0025983253,
0.0027172286,
0.0227633659,
-0.0299863666,
-0.0035360621,
-0.0025308293,
0.0043994286,
-0.0521818921,
-0.004374973,
-0.0397479422,
0.0410609096,
0.0705200806,
0.0866330639,
-0.0494933315,
-0.0341029689,
-0.0428214483,
-0.0293463115,
0.0425192825,
0.017733153,
-0.0048780609,
-0.0649318397,
-0.023374211,
-0.0058349064,
-0.036455594,
-0.0303352904,
-0.0265888926,
-0.0121859042,
0.0264824014,
-0.0065811281,
0.0240406692,
-0.0598142035,
0.037133351,
-0.0481431819,
-0.0116122942,
-0.0435193591,
-0.016182242,
-0.0057657696,
0.0386457257,
-0.0294058938,
0.0172822904,
-0.0071671591,
0.005371972,
-0.0296134893,
0.0231685843,
-0.0040178527,
-0.006041667,
0.0387666151,
-0.0747337118,
-0.0064119608,
0.0185804442,
0.0169585384,
-0.0104474202,
0.0036797053,
-0.0489214808,
0.011269385,
-0.0015560937,
0.0043565882,
-0.0644846112,
-0.0226866249,
-0.0255119894,
-0.01960182,
0.0407342762,
0.0239034146,
0.0349174179,
0.0254619308,
0.0172689706,
0.0135939,
-0.0361655727,
0.0456939451,
0.0130102029,
0.0298464131,
0.0393310376,
0.0155271553,
-0.0646115541,
-0.0437922664,
-0.1353950202,
-0.0103939055,
0.0038655938,
-0.0173194073,
0.0304908101,
-0.0310222935,
-0.0131712221,
-0.0000287703,
-0.0178884659,
-0.0084603177,
-0.0115152039,
-0.002685026,
0.0546968281,
-0.0136935525,
0.0245853886,
-0.0472281389,
-0.0072908741,
-0.0218739137,
-0.0067735631,
0.1251031309,
-0.0503876098,
-0.0059199343,
0.0584550872,
-0.014004508,
-0.0433415435,
0.0013065926,
-0.0571356043,
0.0248240456,
0.0223892573,
0.0626228526,
0.0722598583,
0.0329288729,
0.0472435802,
0.0601978786,
0.0059633222,
-0.0059132609,
-0.0106827738,
0.0156337805,
0.0018753881,
0.0012280634,
-0.0650250465,
-0.0130275907,
-0.0244878419,
0.0195205752,
-0.0181735195,
-0.0245825052,
0.0550410748,
-0.0586104542,
0.0216542035,
-0.0271501951,
-0.0263219271,
-0.029079698,
0.0071426043,
0.0129871024,
-0.0245908815,
0.0278118402,
0.0062482031,
-0.0090469113,
-0.067114614,
-0.0303954035,
-0.0192033332,
0.0630027726,
-0.0198678728,
0.012979676,
-0.0165990051,
0.0128108626,
-0.0775315911,
-0.0292381421,
0.0322978646,
-0.0205272213,
-0.0266091451,
-0.0184358712,
-0.0066028074,
-0.0317517743,
0.0198121592,
-0.0119670518,
-0.0276461933,
-0.0271767303,
0.027131483,
0.0215756465,
-0.0139199868,
-0.0223936401,
-0.0099151516,
0.0594934672,
0.033434879,
-0.0347924419,
-0.014714364,
-0.0105039822,
-0.0347947106,
-0.0031817649,
-0.0545897931,
-0.0088527352,
-0.0035864073,
0.0835143179,
0.0604599267,
-0.0241079926,
0.0091358731,
-0.0160214789,
-0.0663398206,
-0.003360959,
-0.033898849,
-0.0500663519,
-0.0299834386,
0.0274070464,
-0.0553026609,
-0.0253785215,
0.0887894928,
0.0006661717,
-0.015608985,
-0.0230508558,
-0.0804119259,
-0.0048311069,
-0.0012197463,
0.0587143004,
-0.0517115928,
0.0435869768,
0.0010838446,
0.0205588154,
-0.0715627,
-0.0309380125,
0.0127771627,
-0.0482981801,
0.0737343207,
-0.0020141324,
-0.0127540603,
0.0215089507,
-0.030496126,
-0.0160052069,
0.0002895028,
-0.0210579019,
0.0094970586,
0.0011371161,
0.0402328782,
0.0605956018,
-0.1043213904,
0.0214448813,
0.0076640425,
-0.0164488908,
0.0524143279,
0.0084474673,
0.0658416003,
-0.0096700862,
0.0295771398,
0.0538715422,
0.0506750904,
-0.008139235,
-0.0119103137,
0.0347721204,
-0.0183166768,
0.0127534568,
-0.0352744609,
-0.0164591856,
0.013605915,
-0.0261832401,
0.0570459589,
0.0618202016,
-0.0481325425,
0.0097630536,
-0.0509236641,
0.0302038919,
-0.0087874178,
0.0013839279,
0.0238842703,
-0.031865757,
-0.0282081068,
-0.0301468372,
0.0509262867,
0.0217342619,
-0.0349683017,
-0.0413662121,
-0.0362994,
-0.0073300083,
-0.0354078785,
-0.1194851175,
0.0467109345,
0.0447792299,
0.0381660573,
0.041222889,
0.0229587387,
0.0104586566,
-0.0288558137,
-0.014123505,
0.0118051134,
-0.0090411538,
-0.0311614294,
-0.0459691286,
-0.0088140406,
-0.0359600224,
0.0018797229,
-0.0395603701,
0.0054331562,
-0.0277014915,
0.0243037902,
0.0263349544,
0.0206677932,
-0.0080097606,
0.0011896488,
-0.041805312,
0.0114631681,
0.0277874339,
0.0362957567,
0.0268602706,
0.0157251842,
0.0421787426,
0.0040899864,
-0.0291515235,
-0.0032864511,
-0.0414596163,
-0.0152145103,
-0.0072361524,
-0.0092895189,
-0.0245323665,
0.0231718384,
0.0654736683,
0.0005929515,
-0.018346617,
-0.0006230219,
-0.0532319658,
-0.0041754269,
-0.0365792252,
-0.0266589951,
-0.0412848108,
-0.0009020129,
0.0118235033,
0.0166085809,
0.0212633219,
-0.0069816336,
-0.0671032444,
0.0146474568,
0.0208648443,
0.0512829386,
-0.0258653667,
0.0661726594,
0.0222700853,
-0.0097385338,
-0.0431621,
-0.0092240404,
0.0005369128,
0.0282843728,
-0.001227753,
0.0534693003,
-0.0024408924,
-0.0195127819,
0.073083438,
0.0298761744,
-0.0688927025,
-0.0761058033,
-0.0268810727,
0.0378831029,
0.0153261116,
0.0156923197,
0.0133797172,
-0.0713398084,
0.0144785726,
-0.0320968628,
0.0613761321,
-0.0050941608,
-0.0285847094,
-0.0435787141,
-0.0257120784,
-0.0030578058,
-0.0234169085,
0.0280431584,
-0.0289025065,
0.0284012984,
0.0162160285,
-0.0368215367,
-0.0164024234,
-0.0307046529,
0.0307385866,
-0.0279316735,
0.0365894251,
-0.0270712674,
-0.0295957737,
-0.027912315,
0.0064607635,
-0.006781525,
0.0002446187,
-0.0601886362,
0.0474815853,
0.0479316004,
-0.0043883529,
0.0155474851,
-0.0631758124,
0.0704990551,
0.0027913614,
-0.0007623589,
-0.0054665073,
-5.838066979e-33,
-0.0178421792,
-0.077488184,
0.0603983216,
0.0178074855,
-0.0477238074,
-0.019979585,
-0.0171938296,
0.0378212668,
0.0212456584,
0.0220428873,
-0.0516699441,
0.0150182853,
-0.0035577684,
-0.0183224082,
0.0440639444,
0.0029487435,
0.0583021641,
-0.0201277547,
-0.0020829134,
0.0210882649,
-0.0015903852,
0.0121303173,
0.0398111269,
-0.045981843,
0.0572982095,
-0.0553870574,
0.0117759723,
-0.0403772369,
-0.0145962713,
0.0300327148,
-0.000437936,
0.0248420276,
0.025675945,
0.0178036243,
-0.0087934928,
0.0524365231,
0.0064905365,
-0.0628918037,
0.0157294143,
0.0515491702,
0.0103791347,
-0.044887498,
0.035778366,
-0.0447075292,
-0.0404526107,
-0.017432712,
0.0414604992,
0.0022712683,
-0.0321677402,
-0.0052901823,
-0.0738525912,
0.0245100912,
-0.0460835621,
-0.0165358838,
-0.0254996289,
0.0696278289,
0.0064137583,
-0.0605604462,
-0.0123313442,
0.0263004974,
-0.0220878888,
0.0154373283,
0.034631934,
-0.005371972,
-0.0074432287,
0.0460572019,
0.0295896493,
0.059431836,
-0.0165674482,
-0.0348270312,
0.027657235,
0.0108202966,
0.0814732984,
0.0284743365,
-0.0292745084,
-0.0259800535,
-0.0113031846,
-0.0019598205,
0.0528945588,
-0.0135014411,
0.0233328734,
-0.038852863,
-0.0401237458,
-0.0422217809,
-0.0209829118,
0.010134967,
0.0216915309,
-0.0379258953,
-0.0022560148,
-0.0604024492,
-0.0004895261,
-0.0636910871,
0.0064683575,
-0.03316769,
0.0239321534,
-0.0142906709,
-0.0387108736,
0.0681501776,
-0.0204900093,
0.0008214816,
-0.0313530006,
0.0188877024,
-0.0019862175,
0.0320618227,
0.0378034748,
0.0348481201,
-0.0144255701,
0.0301734395,
-0.0141677521,
-0.0225336496,
-0.0342290215,
0.0146283414,
0.0295998901,
-0.0643701106,
-0.0113956472,
0.0274177492,
0.0043417905,
0.0267159529,
0.0324605852,
0.0208098032,
-0.0509387702,
-0.0162863284,
-0.0216849148,
-0.0401257649,
-0.0010980464,
0.0152554391,
-0.0481662601,
0.0819372237,
0.0259846225,
-0.0501453839,
-0.0063956687,
-0.0404567979,
3.096e-7,
0.0398026221,
0.061606966,
-0.0175425597,
-0.0063949595,
-0.0010734028,
0.0356242023,
0.0039866385,
0.0003189939,
0.0432097837,
0.0587243289,
0.0283700954,
0.010828821,
0.0173064414,
0.0419543386,
-0.061822854,
-0.0600253791,
-0.0731897503,
-0.0638593286,
-0.0499814637,
0.0525604114,
0.0668573231,
-0.0289608259,
0.0194793809,
-0.0096249552,
-0.057835158,
-0.0251141805,
0.034999378,
-0.0052480279,
-0.0205266699,
0.0505571738,
0.0601423234,
0.0351347029,
0.0483579002,
0.0312642269,
0.0264544133,
-0.0544205941,
0.016938094,
0.0215166379,
0.0130167035,
0.0172498692,
0.0687877908,
-0.0011554001,
-0.0070566735,
-0.0787836984,
0.0492254086,
-0.0146954153,
-0.0039471327,
-0.0492428616,
-0.023298407,
-0.0358139761,
0.0573182441,
-0.0164328441,
-0.011938964,
0.0310583282,
-0.0331336707,
-0.0137515152,
0.0155503536,
0.0132467793,
-0.0066854525,
-0.0111258095,
-0.0261702277,
-0.0738885179,
-0.0145810619,
-0.0108631523,
0.0061533418,
-0.0236182138,
0.0240487717,
2.800704601e-34,
0.0071733692,
-0.0244042519,
0.0334478356,
0.0630576909,
0.0202294495,
0.0364081599,
0.0469003059,
0.0225783922,
0.0234381948,
0.0057930239,
-0.0356655605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09536v1 | CarExpert: Leveraging Large Language Models for In-Car Conversational Question Answering | 2023-10-14T08:46:24 | 2023-10-14T08:46:24 | Md Rashad Al Hasan Rony, Christian Suess, Sinchana Ramakanth Bhat, Viju Sudhi, Julia Schneider, Maximilian Vogel, Roman Teucher, Ken E. Friedl, Soumya Sahoo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance by
following natural language instructions without fine-tuning them on
domain-specific tasks and data. However, leveraging LLMs for domain-specific
question answering suffers from severe limitations. The generated answer tends
to hallucinate due to the training data collection time (when using
off-the-shelf), complex user utterance and wrong retrieval (in
retrieval-augmented generation). Furthermore, due to the lack of awareness
about the domain and expected output, such LLMs may generate unexpected and
unsafe answers that are not tailored to the target domain. In this paper, we
propose CarExpert, an in-car retrieval-augmented conversational
question-answering system leveraging LLMs for different tasks. Specifically,
CarExpert employs LLMs to control the input, provide domain-specific documents
to the extractive and generative answering components, and controls the output
to ensure safe and domain-specific answers. A comprehensive empirical
evaluation exhibits that CarExpert outperforms state-of-the-art LLMs in
generating natural, safe and car-specific answers. | [
0.0481277034,
0.0317974128,
-0.0022780253,
0.0485972166,
-0.0098084174,
-0.0022839806,
0.0235415082,
-0.0071046464,
0.0105920043,
-0.0612330288,
-0.0225457195,
-0.0414469764,
-0.0311722923,
0.0176596846,
0.029469965,
-0.028742699,
0.0089900112,
-0.0789831728,
0.0057810703,
-0.0202230159,
0.0162603948,
0.0233447812,
0.0026076413,
0.0293373391,
-0.0332573242,
-0.0307828505,
0.0212584697,
-0.0072779167,
0.0309600383,
-0.026859533,
0.0604365245,
0.0351503901,
0.0634561628,
0.0267367046,
0.0000018538,
-0.0286051165,
0.0273608156,
0.0036942516,
-0.0108773159,
-0.0246800501,
0.0104188407,
0.0576087609,
0.0128496271,
0.0578942262,
-0.0531233996,
-0.0195520855,
-0.013311089,
0.0394846089,
0.0773181021,
0.0751526728,
-0.0112899439,
-0.0012729357,
-0.0002994709,
0.016642984,
0.0203434844,
-0.0341703929,
0.0183282681,
0.0390479714,
0.0363784432,
0.0133435102,
0.0147207938,
0.0577763207,
0.0322562195,
-0.0151440604,
0.0106070843,
0.0147982622,
-0.0301909242,
-0.0146980537,
-0.0132179037,
0.0974680185,
-0.0122889811,
-0.0284431893,
0.0050698221,
0.0233843233,
-0.0184802338,
-0.0394906066,
-0.0613857359,
0.0151779223,
-0.0013319947,
-0.0143858558,
-0.0193848237,
0.0180587973,
0.0086677792,
0.0182132106,
-0.0127173634,
0.0661039799,
0.0374222882,
-0.0540762506,
0.0148137929,
0.008159278,
-0.0223920867,
-0.0696975738,
-0.012008613,
0.0638286173,
-0.0500552244,
0.0044103442,
0.0084739923,
-0.0057512913,
0.0171786398,
-0.0636481717,
0.017321948,
-0.0052556628,
-0.0320178531,
0.0558485873,
0.0292261988,
0.0266625285,
0.0008849744,
-0.0406117029,
-0.0665920377,
-0.0459856167,
0.0011745375,
-0.0223779995,
-0.0527913272,
0.0229902063,
-0.0505766496,
0.0028984495,
0.0060433373,
0.056703832,
0.032123521,
0.0027120269,
-0.0117477849,
0.0748022944,
-0.0108967815,
-0.0279106945,
-0.0048706559,
0.0129045481,
-0.0438757949,
0.0567074753,
0.0192195699,
-0.0545332506,
-0.0018565775,
0.0278216898,
-0.006614883,
-0.0259344205,
0.0180023089,
0.0563422032,
-0.0225170869,
-0.0276836287,
-0.0228970964,
-0.0457253456,
-0.0286017042,
-0.0790700316,
-0.0133343423,
-0.0766018629,
0.0261073019,
0.022947602,
-0.0504870079,
-0.0254349057,
0.0358636193,
0.0435483158,
-0.0199263003,
0.0191297531,
-0.0079868697,
0.0380678736,
0.0692963079,
0.0442026034,
-0.0146464426,
0.0571470708,
0.0341221578,
0.0308256187,
0.0550330319,
-0.0050263628,
0.0449494161,
0.0252410788,
0.0104327779,
0.023876356,
0.0077267233,
0.0662538335,
0.0018632261,
0.0284686815,
-0.0004951736,
0.0638100058,
-0.022852717,
0.0310559366,
0.0685085133,
0.0539133921,
-0.0043557286,
0.0136932302,
0.0008007225,
0.0299751274,
-0.0114143994,
-0.0388441794,
-0.029353505,
0.0280563813,
-0.0388926789,
0.0070442166,
0.0587106533,
0.0492206216,
-0.048154138,
-0.0034633935,
0.0112105701,
-0.0084839892,
0.009257623,
0.0148344105,
0.0024932812,
-0.0058962619,
-0.0227639209,
0.0474283956,
-0.0039267153,
0.0007111495,
0.000970432,
-0.0288218595,
0.0586470477,
0.0508197434,
0.0436219685,
0.00704868,
-0.0243482701,
-0.0335731879,
0.0465406142,
-0.0001655013,
-0.0069512464,
-0.0218369346,
0.0121397562,
-0.0375876315,
-0.0215841886,
0.0258452985,
-0.0061667892,
-0.0227483436,
0.0533662401,
0.0627041608,
0.05365422,
-0.0355467536,
0.0266682263,
0.0006481652,
-0.0027924066,
-0.0495092608,
0.0152912484,
-0.0002699645,
-0.0133633539,
-0.0061238292,
-0.0265517924,
0.0104385484,
0.0225479864,
-0.0201841518,
-0.0234400444,
-0.0000124832,
-0.0597406514,
0.0045017796,
0.0228578579,
-0.0237570871,
-0.0147102987,
0.0231951177,
-0.0283376444,
-0.0338285789,
-0.0561399944,
-0.053469453,
0.0127609828,
-0.056313768,
-0.002788601,
0.0637578964,
0.0190027729,
-0.028758876,
0.047990974,
0.0176376626,
0.0069220182,
0.0457353294,
0.0166017748,
0.0154338581,
-0.031632904,
-0.004961093,
0.0003283227,
-0.0324923173,
0.036518801,
0.01444468,
-0.0065911855,
-0.0586305,
-0.0225705821,
-0.0670144781,
0.0239236485,
-0.0380976573,
-0.002151086,
0.0068756808,
0.050151512,
-0.0191460587,
-0.0266621001,
-0.0610668957,
-0.0019252461,
0.0748223141,
0.0072035817,
0.0015774406,
0.0016765442,
-0.0138029158,
-0.0288921818,
0.0101678157,
0.0039672279,
0.0168933943,
-0.0057417336,
0.0034653686,
-0.08134792,
0.002583361,
-0.0292940196,
0.0447200127,
0.0017722779,
-0.0347508714,
-0.0193039197,
0.0045112711,
0.0173311327,
0.0577838235,
0.0651552305,
-0.0588101484,
0.0008445167,
-0.0288222935,
-0.0627621934,
0.0137886666,
-0.0315936916,
-0.0579895191,
-0.0275205281,
-0.0056755436,
0.0133573301,
0.0017215685,
-0.0077196816,
0.0151534351,
-0.0161088984,
0.0357696749,
-0.0051745423,
-0.0387570262,
-0.0477056727,
-0.0081944205,
-0.0121737439,
0.0447765701,
0.0094383368,
-0.0156613756,
0.0551870465,
-0.0039719143,
0.0090536391,
-0.0529569685,
-0.0100892298,
-0.0188899357,
0.0381390266,
-0.0248963609,
0.0217581633,
0.0205872953,
0.0105443476,
-0.0264921524,
-0.0173971038,
-0.0346158706,
-0.0414987057,
0.040052373,
-0.0415292569,
0.0350799039,
-0.0297921672,
-0.0914057866,
-0.0810661986,
-0.0931932628,
-0.0319286212,
0.0090097897,
0.0132282972,
-0.0301029216,
-0.0307262167,
0.0293861125,
0.0195320062,
0.0193519238,
-0.0136232199,
-0.00643093,
-0.0060047898,
0.0384752415,
0.1318907142,
0.0574796274,
0.0071841814,
0.0042073242,
0.0429345332,
0.0713236853,
0.0334995389,
-0.0011474142,
-0.0335962363,
-0.0066113817,
0.0298641287,
-0.0110006994,
0.007678567,
0.0233010836,
0.0291937739,
-0.0449792556,
-0.0366043523,
0.0847372264,
0.0236773081,
-0.0182612967,
0.0088853333,
-0.0205231942,
0.0270008128,
-0.0220932905,
0.0644389614,
-0.0851154327,
-0.0336319134,
-0.0039848834,
0.0225723572,
-0.0051036123,
0.0179433562,
0.0164568108,
-0.1117792055,
0.0423073173,
0.0065087886,
-0.0360745825,
-0.0222815778,
-0.0228519682,
-0.0279091001,
0.0141295921,
0.031707067,
0.0371467806,
-0.0417701229,
-0.0296269804,
0.005749159,
0.002522035,
-0.0369544923,
0.0602891967,
-0.0170153007,
0.033671435,
0.0712976679,
-0.0064241821,
0.0213329531,
-0.0502176359,
0.0143568106,
-0.0193278771,
0.0052285683,
-0.0193662662,
0.0244495813,
-0.0282120351,
-0.0107626738,
-0.0457135774,
0.0578776523,
-0.0209506024,
0.0084711388,
0.0241975822,
0.0537373312,
-0.0313080326,
0.0047864099,
-0.0418372005,
0.0278148614,
0.034016639,
0.0679567456,
-0.0101870745,
-0.0466664322,
-0.017636558,
-0.0068453527,
-0.0248556398,
-0.016132487,
-0.0121660875,
-0.0384482704,
0.043281205,
0.0387796424,
-0.052594509,
-0.0402855314,
0.0226687435,
0.0087853875,
-0.0057030232,
-0.0005663453,
-0.0036127903,
0.0169832911,
-0.036741741,
0.0275889672,
-0.026758749,
0.0253929477,
-0.0258947052,
0.0216351729,
0.0516964719,
-0.034079738,
-0.0501935184,
0.0284333192,
-0.0494495928,
-0.0515691936,
-0.0005628241,
0.0614994615,
0.0216055308,
0.0377139412,
-0.0178335253,
-0.0756544098,
0.0567219779,
0.0347602181,
-0.0617922954,
0.0092904866,
-0.0149273491,
0.0062507452,
0.0107524348,
0.0491543114,
-0.0914084315,
0.0137009993,
-0.003805567,
0.0330753997,
-0.0230548773,
-0.0406352319,
-0.0000372648,
0.0086306157,
0.0078543965,
0.016040368,
0.0518850908,
-0.0149004171,
0.0766586065,
0.0193247534,
-0.0152219711,
-0.046678111,
0.0413435809,
-0.0176767129,
-0.0196020491,
0.0014611779,
-0.0199541822,
-0.0066153291,
0.0109500503,
-0.033155933,
-0.0178724416,
0.0350105353,
-0.0459808297,
0.0246821698,
-0.0241935961,
-0.0360978059,
0.0177257415,
0.0371861942,
0.0603487082,
-0.0220576394,
0.1027819067,
0.0013118353,
-0.0386285596,
-0.0167713817,
0.0257289931,
-0.0467193015,
-0.0717563927,
-0.0602340475,
0.052931603,
0.035609968,
-0.0041653612,
0.0121300248,
-0.0353767127,
-0.0182786677,
-0.039733354,
-0.0109228622,
0.0188995134,
-0.0222787354,
0.0720371753,
0.0033663111,
-0.0353724249,
0.0194707327,
0.0758377612,
0.0045595509,
0.019130772,
0.0120803937,
0.0089085642,
-0.0355982482,
-0.0312597118,
0.0099173887,
-0.0090796417,
-0.0165124722,
0.0013302288,
-0.0281579364,
-0.0463670418,
-0.015837932,
0.0038348166,
-0.0539774261,
-0.0209147707,
0.0366481505,
0.0249397568,
0.0326795653,
-0.059860941,
-0.0065378943,
0.0151472474,
-0.0528956093,
-0.0312807783,
-0.0387243591,
-6.789502556e-33,
-0.0178699978,
0.015063893,
0.0278927181,
-0.0092159798,
-0.0115099372,
-0.0395198576,
-0.0056800749,
0.012402866,
-0.0117597617,
-0.0113891046,
-0.0195394028,
-0.0013509031,
0.00508457,
0.0469954126,
-0.0020735539,
-0.0446577817,
0.0222061463,
0.0037812258,
-0.016506765,
0.0579604208,
0.0396836363,
0.060221903,
0.0003422781,
-0.0725644082,
-0.0188463405,
-0.083673574,
0.0198936593,
0.0544256158,
0.0003482259,
0.0641782582,
-0.025632143,
0.0491032228,
0.0174685232,
-0.036623776,
-0.0006894962,
0.0803705379,
-0.0592100844,
-0.005275988,
0.0462836288,
-0.0145883607,
-0.0286134183,
-0.0351209454,
0.001021738,
-0.009723804,
0.0095489956,
-0.0075892224,
0.0425730348,
-0.0199008025,
-0.0087402984,
-0.026849376,
-0.0545218401,
-0.0015096779,
0.0174349416,
-0.0590559244,
0.0055019441,
0.0601014905,
0.0035380237,
0.0048825531,
-0.0117900297,
-0.0136796301,
0.0168974642,
0.0564732589,
0.0544655658,
0.0135379061,
-0.0050667282,
0.0379245989,
-0.0045314636,
-0.0213837437,
-0.0386670046,
-0.0492844842,
-0.0618727207,
0.0516009927,
-0.0067012943,
0.0409392603,
-0.0133098084,
-0.004516473,
-0.0696885884,
0.0208235458,
-0.0256552435,
0.0407810062,
0.0446183197,
-0.0421131551,
-0.0559527911,
0.0092252484,
-0.0353723168,
0.0742243305,
-0.0553292744,
-0.0334847793,
0.068339318,
0.0277480185,
-0.0125776501,
-0.0078272391,
0.0469563194,
-0.0572971329,
0.0024670013,
0.0198074952,
-0.020503154,
-0.0459186025,
-0.0180223417,
0.0502320491,
-0.0534099266,
0.0108134123,
0.0157952122,
0.001652985,
-0.033385437,
0.0177516919,
-0.0204069857,
0.002868755,
-0.0642229319,
0.009136538,
-0.0282449163,
0.0430716313,
-0.0303804111,
0.0181642696,
0.0324833393,
0.0573699437,
-0.022126209,
0.0294895452,
-0.0135064581,
0.0052680648,
-0.0307086203,
-0.0560907908,
0.0061986158,
0.0007037829,
-0.0289839637,
0.0509045757,
-0.0182889383,
-0.0039141853,
0.0044138115,
-0.0422454737,
0.0041489443,
-0.0001181898,
2.52e-7,
0.0107076969,
0.0131803006,
-0.0077691618,
0.0349139534,
0.0280305129,
0.0433857888,
0.0003957374,
0.0405281894,
0.0575860143,
-0.0041066282,
-0.0419733599,
0.0308571793,
0.0655728728,
0.0234438237,
-0.0584745929,
0.0190011505,
-0.0893513709,
-0.006837287,
-0.0596914478,
-0.0516234599,
0.0563758872,
0.1098077372,
-0.0693338215,
-0.0307088457,
-0.0004128248,
-0.0475361496,
0.0691192597,
-0.0212759729,
-0.0371170901,
0.0170340631,
0.0272827577,
0.0630795509,
0.0055760918,
0.0158828925,
-0.0073186839,
0.0200214852,
0.0009857388,
0.0830811858,
0.0237947032,
-0.0762971193,
-0.0188046414,
-0.0368175544,
0.0239600129,
-0.0501957573,
0.0638572797,
-0.0685225055,
0.005757147,
-0.04914698,
-0.0462415889,
-0.0264385529,
0.0083891358,
-0.0326998197,
0.0082073295,
0.0051194136,
0.0226562154,
-0.0043372847,
0.0071854852,
-0.0834465325,
-0.0189242959,
0.0049634078,
-0.0312307719,
-0.0467491411,
-0.0376562923,
0.0591258705,
0.0007183699,
-0.0163354967,
0.0168410204,
1.766041591e-34,
0.0135822026,
-0.0151845179,
-0.0109192953,
0.054241661,
0.0155383488,
0.0210519563,
0.0245671701,
-0.0074739815,
0.0045497548,
-0.093024388,
-0.0050574178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09520v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09520v4 | Reward-Augmented Decoding: Efficient Controlled Text Generation With a Unidirectional Reward Model | 2023-10-14T07:19:47 | 2024-01-02T00:04:13 | Haikang Deng, Colin Raffel | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models have proven effective in a huge range of
downstream applications, they often generate text that is problematic or lacks
a desired attribute. In this paper, we introduce Reward-Augmented Decoding
(RAD), a text generation procedure that uses a small unidirectional reward
model to encourage a language model to generate text that has certain
properties. Specifically, RAD uses the reward model to score generations as
they are produced and rescales sampling probabilities to favor high-reward
tokens. By using a unidirectional reward model, RAD can cache activations from
prior generation steps to decrease computational overhead. Through experiments
on generating non-toxic and sentiment-controlled text, we demonstrate that RAD
performs best among methods that change only the generation procedure and
matches the performance of state-of-the-art methods that involve re-training
the language model. We further validate that RAD is effective on very large
language models while incurring a minimal computational overhead. | [
0.0434834883,
0.0726960525,
0.0081309499,
0.0029698187,
-0.0278270524,
0.0216808543,
-0.0161900371,
0.0052863914,
-0.0152980862,
-0.0224908646,
0.0032392272,
-0.001457868,
-0.0238575116,
0.0539836176,
-0.0014977565,
-0.0425133668,
0.0288896319,
-0.0009363543,
0.0431225263,
-0.0073439786,
0.0067121196,
0.0168747511,
0.0192369949,
0.0350250117,
-0.0273701418,
-0.0100110564,
0.0167479571,
0.0197856724,
0.0141548729,
-0.047089994,
0.0172008332,
0.0143985208,
-0.0163031984,
0.032551866,
0.0000020806,
-0.0190662853,
-0.0362113155,
-0.003843083,
0.0126375714,
-0.015357432,
0.0950123966,
-0.0267808829,
-0.0374494046,
0.0392335393,
-0.033546485,
0.0007776407,
0.0669315159,
0.0516399778,
0.0451167934,
0.0639076084,
-0.0107775312,
-0.0099080727,
0.015955776,
-0.0189342722,
0.0447705463,
-0.0080469828,
-0.0016611238,
-0.0103786038,
-0.0343042985,
-0.0073114261,
-0.0158598088,
0.0430161953,
0.0394884013,
-0.0239764862,
0.0429567322,
0.0439702868,
0.0453479625,
-0.0182726253,
-0.0243148804,
0.000744834,
-0.0328677781,
-0.040734984,
0.0009538023,
-0.0093415286,
-0.0190425385,
-0.0546234585,
-0.0141985333,
0.0552850254,
-0.0098404381,
0.0440208167,
0.057865601,
0.0432726443,
0.0292782988,
0.0273637511,
0.0128778359,
0.0191422459,
0.0173476133,
-0.0432172157,
-0.0209143516,
0.0334254168,
0.0043389001,
-0.0469032191,
0.0243437402,
0.0147035513,
-0.0185902622,
0.0261743981,
-0.0617165752,
-0.059561763,
0.0133680617,
-0.0382754914,
0.0302574318,
0.018995991,
0.0078734867,
0.0242262781,
-0.0483615398,
0.0052714301,
0.0126162013,
0.0191014931,
-0.0285746548,
0.0149736684,
-0.0034507306,
-0.0325399302,
-0.0276247282,
0.0456187278,
0.0018399978,
-0.0193387289,
-0.0618957244,
0.0353379026,
0.0002442246,
-0.0035220713,
0.0167448167,
0.0330850296,
-0.0526904762,
0.0153520331,
-0.0052984399,
0.0049066325,
-0.0274521019,
-0.0223027281,
0.0397454314,
-0.0050041806,
-0.0177057087,
0.0103551652,
0.0027026706,
0.0021987725,
-0.0087194517,
0.0862533748,
-0.0226185676,
-0.0231859758,
-0.034906961,
-0.0458020903,
-0.0106755523,
-0.0229562186,
-0.009243953,
-0.0581717342,
-0.0085526146,
-0.0018931367,
-0.028834777,
-0.0348497219,
0.0397969708,
0.0051440005,
-0.0201599505,
0.0315791778,
0.0014156239,
-0.0248620156,
0.0191422142,
0.005892477,
0.0176551361,
0.0699253753,
0.0428965613,
0.096864298,
0.0192161538,
0.026576357,
0.0066606649,
0.0200512912,
0.0694534406,
0.0216003992,
-0.0289415903,
-0.0324197188,
0.0029498667,
0.0169664584,
0.0328016132,
0.0487567931,
-0.0399283096,
0.0360374041,
0.0807538107,
0.007230008,
-0.0403306969,
0.0046542264,
0.0230738297,
-0.0136838388,
-0.0548562482,
-0.0137194702,
-0.0294464733,
0.0400032923,
-0.0169717018,
-0.0089754211,
0.0417045802,
0.0057937657,
-0.0246727169,
-0.0503515191,
0.0113628712,
-0.0344877578,
0.0715131387,
-0.0020920208,
0.0437931418,
0.0579149164,
-0.0807755813,
-0.0001497745,
0.0313763283,
-0.0666266084,
0.0409503691,
-0.0584755056,
0.0439060703,
0.1026745364,
0.0794794559,
0.0185068194,
0.0401391275,
-0.0122794444,
-0.0249592736,
0.0789560676,
0.0191295166,
-0.001821331,
-0.012721614,
-0.0394213721,
-0.0212877784,
0.0055123284,
0.0179066658,
0.0156084029,
0.0240633655,
0.0062629567,
-0.0059406809,
0.0256351586,
-0.069774121,
0.0355729572,
0.0112774484,
-0.0373684317,
0.0489912182,
-0.0022271867,
0.0246416964,
-0.001924122,
-0.0165607147,
0.0165994074,
0.0157130379,
-0.0453346111,
-0.0695953071,
0.015041261,
-0.0527191199,
-0.050638739,
-0.0169835165,
-0.0192523319,
0.0148451244,
0.0458480529,
-0.0145307314,
-0.018936608,
0.0481951497,
-0.0841552094,
0.0606513396,
-0.0408096686,
0.0099067092,
-0.0099320151,
-0.011859227,
-0.0289817806,
0.0443705171,
-0.0269820616,
-0.0106805349,
-0.0389600247,
-0.0096617062,
-0.0101599451,
-0.0109712742,
-0.0051757032,
-0.0074797715,
-0.0136242267,
0.0198095534,
0.0532737039,
0.0415538736,
0.0028592637,
-0.0744471177,
-0.0285585821,
0.0064818491,
-0.0227917302,
0.0092366831,
0.0380061641,
0.0066715293,
0.0171106216,
0.0034012257,
-0.0623589531,
-0.0114406254,
0.0450279489,
0.0262494907,
0.0141061358,
-0.0048847608,
0.0004046844,
-0.0125920102,
-0.0069158212,
0.0219897255,
0.0364588238,
0.02886484,
0.0059846798,
-0.0426605903,
0.0462417081,
-0.0194758493,
-0.0058526299,
0.0226353537,
-0.0542264394,
0.020209752,
0.0147192292,
0.0476522259,
0.0543152094,
0.0419777334,
0.0498191305,
-0.0119418344,
0.0204408057,
-0.0533810593,
-0.0117908483,
-0.0617581829,
-0.0240522679,
0.0052798679,
-0.0689851642,
0.0340013467,
0.0646920726,
0.0369118974,
0.0106785782,
-0.0942157954,
0.0482133739,
-0.0305939857,
-0.072440438,
-0.0118440902,
-0.0092954701,
-0.0111476788,
0.0117527656,
-0.0352941565,
-0.0761770532,
0.0828218684,
0.0039862194,
0.0231655594,
-0.0587508194,
0.015805671,
0.0074740271,
0.0391016342,
-0.0012274339,
0.0550342016,
-0.0017818876,
-0.0249737687,
-0.0032493405,
0.0076825563,
0.027978152,
-0.0446657352,
-0.0078333775,
-0.013937437,
-0.0143424347,
0.0070750783,
-0.0528451428,
-0.0583866015,
-0.0185336005,
0.0364285111,
-0.0118723968,
0.0477826744,
-0.0182473231,
-0.0048444672,
0.0025300481,
0.0324809216,
0.0033365698,
-0.0472343415,
-0.0183633417,
-0.0126633262,
-0.0008865825,
0.0736174658,
-0.0606002808,
0.0255746208,
-0.0514951944,
-0.0125660393,
0.0762321278,
0.000297729,
0.0106740566,
0.0137632098,
-0.0020917333,
0.0239403807,
-0.0012497327,
0.003898331,
0.0231844522,
0.0173464902,
-0.0445869081,
-0.0431867689,
0.0619620569,
0.0428127795,
-0.0571459718,
0.0153171942,
-0.0002441897,
0.0491431653,
-0.0036076447,
-0.0009433883,
-0.0907405987,
-0.0145853758,
0.0028049531,
0.0562652647,
-0.0456390679,
-0.0099396501,
0.0038313526,
-0.1044341996,
0.0084037371,
0.0119454646,
-0.0246021226,
-0.0308375116,
-0.0087784259,
-0.0613960735,
0.0212745871,
-0.0182640459,
0.0274443533,
0.0276815407,
0.0093121082,
0.0099576069,
0.0099926181,
-0.0244301073,
-0.0176505558,
-0.0210765265,
0.054063227,
0.1249255463,
0.0197748709,
0.0160599258,
-0.0267477594,
-0.0230148304,
0.0005342831,
-0.0172921214,
-0.0322616249,
0.0270028245,
-0.002114957,
-0.010543244,
-0.0429532789,
0.0352995917,
-0.0151316533,
0.0037588133,
-0.0122043844,
0.0397146009,
-0.003561235,
-0.0213438831,
-0.029248463,
-0.0066927895,
0.0597865023,
0.0796467662,
0.0267457217,
-0.090238288,
-0.0580015033,
-0.0515002236,
0.0076744966,
-0.1136417314,
-0.0167092886,
-0.0226362739,
-0.0001881987,
-0.0464556292,
-0.1292544901,
-0.0250309911,
-0.0257960968,
0.0062706866,
0.0012620781,
-0.0200200155,
-0.0236171056,
-0.0326168872,
-0.0643837824,
-0.0353602692,
-0.0283912327,
-0.0000714031,
-0.0330220647,
-0.0276119076,
-0.0140725961,
-0.0575103201,
-0.0094266478,
0.0251569171,
-0.0486172959,
-0.0541827157,
0.0051750671,
0.0700741038,
0.0156350117,
0.0238906145,
-0.0134923458,
-0.0484327264,
0.0636735633,
0.0640658587,
-0.0487110466,
0.0186360274,
0.0288744327,
0.0378994606,
0.0069980738,
0.0264105294,
-0.0531526841,
0.0446953475,
0.028550012,
0.0307127461,
0.0225729421,
0.0303552393,
0.0394320413,
-0.000956393,
0.0048087249,
-0.0546773821,
-0.0230749846,
-0.0163541827,
0.0044033681,
-0.0440043248,
-0.0165061764,
-0.0366508663,
0.0154913468,
0.0185361076,
0.0024200189,
-0.0175998677,
0.0116736786,
-0.003490201,
0.0387404636,
-0.0151157957,
-0.0054527703,
-0.0335734673,
0.0310199317,
0.04900489,
0.0167742856,
-0.0404591747,
0.0039090859,
-0.0064508449,
0.0039133527,
-0.0387305655,
0.0226862635,
0.0394942015,
0.0014301237,
0.0013915224,
0.0280954316,
-0.0162542742,
0.0365875289,
-0.0307134949,
-0.0155326799,
0.0502528399,
0.0428696014,
0.0785339326,
-0.0536855422,
0.0056524384,
0.0024629503,
0.0175118465,
-0.0021497954,
-0.0718499646,
-0.0150477765,
-0.0156769529,
-0.0152404336,
-0.056565661,
0.0582975931,
-0.0298195556,
0.0298083965,
-0.0221702401,
0.0107593359,
-0.0323174521,
-0.0133430269,
0.0356477536,
-0.0056490749,
-0.0196082052,
0.0154127069,
-0.0315570906,
-0.0358174331,
-0.004236049,
0.0378169678,
0.0440305658,
-0.0212506503,
0.0554024987,
0.0292299557,
-0.0358349755,
0.0003211221,
-0.0684439987,
0.0210327543,
-0.0268178899,
-0.0346076302,
-0.0270599518,
-6.693238385e-33,
-0.0045620259,
-0.0260531846,
-0.000423597,
0.0256981105,
-0.0205640122,
0.0074496237,
-0.0542363785,
-0.0033335856,
0.0568941757,
0.0080158375,
-0.0143502224,
-0.0117609343,
0.0068035186,
0.0475075841,
-0.009316531,
0.0095843989,
0.0791237056,
-0.0285209082,
-0.0595165007,
0.0741049126,
0.0706238747,
0.0152102476,
0.014177666,
-0.0552760065,
0.016764285,
-0.007372431,
-0.0545586124,
-0.0111613255,
0.0331828669,
0.030702576,
-0.027995117,
0.05202673,
0.0100934487,
-0.0506306663,
-0.0222721677,
0.0145224677,
-0.0496968962,
0.0039022816,
0.0020540433,
-0.0085855303,
-0.0547370426,
-0.0539458245,
0.0345540941,
0.001127603,
-0.0376757793,
0.0325023048,
0.0042376174,
-0.0184875652,
-0.004039932,
-0.0681935921,
-0.0744328275,
0.014933099,
0.0199578982,
-0.0226398595,
0.0096637132,
0.0092933541,
-0.0036261647,
0.0325249434,
-0.0626863986,
0.0487827137,
0.0168669596,
0.0440009199,
0.0320446193,
0.012509916,
0.0121899806,
0.0635283515,
0.0118135056,
0.0275222436,
-0.0249864142,
0.0372963957,
0.0287100952,
-0.0171188861,
0.0597619116,
0.0370552987,
0.0390751883,
-0.0622193627,
-0.0501843654,
0.0173994452,
0.0189058818,
-0.0222384334,
0.0708837062,
0.0097831562,
-0.0207382478,
-0.0183703117,
-0.0438391902,
-0.0073315315,
-0.024588434,
-0.0489724018,
0.0315141492,
0.0704785883,
-0.0542970635,
-0.0391179398,
0.0108725941,
-0.0237364992,
0.0060356027,
0.0416722819,
-0.0161390062,
0.0112364069,
-0.0338033363,
-0.0154158296,
-0.0647212192,
0.0067028338,
0.0285837241,
-0.0194331873,
-0.0044150054,
0.0340585113,
0.048836071,
0.0298733562,
-0.0798074305,
0.031529706,
-0.0434177555,
0.0934572071,
0.0276668519,
-0.0006260188,
0.0044800234,
-0.0078994771,
-0.0068392563,
0.0096805869,
0.0230874717,
0.0136163943,
-0.0454821996,
0.003766509,
-0.0031634581,
0.0339363068,
-0.0397209786,
0.0195107386,
-0.0449244566,
0.0228716675,
0.0241746884,
-0.0763116628,
-0.0173768159,
0.0152809406,
2.808e-7,
-0.0010746038,
0.0621062182,
0.0271002185,
0.0157940052,
0.0515192226,
0.0553332604,
0.0405963399,
0.036027357,
0.0043593668,
0.0117198955,
-0.0546805337,
0.0226011649,
0.044982668,
0.03106701,
-0.0781520307,
0.0400519185,
-0.0636096001,
0.020657463,
-0.017593544,
-0.0186214801,
0.0604389273,
0.0546762608,
0.0099086752,
-0.0123916809,
0.0251594931,
0.0094284536,
0.072067976,
-0.0072275209,
-0.0217065234,
0.0018026351,
-0.0290723797,
-0.0023400593,
-0.0013284603,
-0.0382762551,
-0.0296559148,
-0.0416842476,
-0.0319859385,
0.0378332548,
-0.0059535215,
-0.0415739901,
0.014224356,
0.0168725364,
-0.0106918411,
-0.0313099623,
0.0336584188,
-0.0471783876,
-0.0147654703,
-0.055847127,
0.0164289903,
-0.0009558636,
0.0058811279,
-0.0513708554,
-0.0575094372,
0.0274668653,
0.0111723123,
0.0585890561,
0.0082950285,
-0.0574950241,
-0.0486903749,
-0.0345438458,
-0.0251026805,
-0.0468252636,
-0.0615422502,
0.0807589665,
-0.013581275,
-0.0774551332,
0.0150664253,
2.870327386e-34,
0.0419182181,
-0.0508778431,
-0.0059351567,
-0.0249192212,
0.0236553513,
0.0215646103,
0.009531348,
0.018104028,
0.044907365,
-0.0114460969,
-0.0277466252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09518v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09518v4 | Instruction Tuning with Human Curriculum | 2023-10-14T07:16:08 | 2024-06-16T22:46:38 | Bruce W. Lee, Hyunsoo Cho, Kang Min Yoo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this work, we (1) introduce Curriculum Instruction Tuning, (2) explore the
potential advantages of employing diverse curriculum strategies, and (3)
delineate a synthetic instruction-response generation framework that
complements our theoretical approach. Distinct from the existing instruction
tuning dataset, our generation pipeline is systematically structured to emulate
the sequential and orderly characteristic of human learning. Additionally, we
describe a methodology for generating instruction-response datasets that
extensively span the various stages of human education, from middle school
through the graduate level, utilizing educational subject catalogs.
Before training, we meticulously organize the instruction data to ensure that
questions escalate in difficulty regarding (A) the subject matter and (B) the
intricacy of the instructions. The findings of our study reveal that
substantial improvements in performance can be achieved through the mere
application of curriculum ordering to instruction data (achieving gains of
+4.76 on TruthfulQA, +2.98 on MMLU, +2.8 on OpenbookQA, and +1.28 on ARC-hard)
compared to random shuffling. This enhancement is achieved without incurring
additional computational expenses. Through comprehensive experimentation, we
observe that the advantages of our proposed method are consistently evident
across nine benchmarks. | [
0.0497788899,
0.0052190535,
-0.0439962372,
0.0183106624,
-0.014670575,
0.0291977916,
0.0298852418,
-0.0411863662,
-0.0014817322,
-0.0430573262,
0.0097776698,
-0.0064473799,
-0.0182256196,
-0.020165015,
0.0125483498,
-0.0859744698,
0.0146577228,
-0.0240515266,
-0.0239983164,
0.0082451301,
-0.0344367176,
-0.0079997908,
-0.0567677915,
0.0151476376,
0.0363913476,
-0.0155299576,
-0.0467401817,
0.0109802568,
0.0367609635,
-0.0227437168,
0.0426959768,
0.0603187345,
-0.0037151773,
-0.0452368632,
0.0000022395,
-0.0526758209,
-0.0162401646,
-0.0242943019,
-0.0241665449,
0.0187559761,
0.0360399857,
0.0648895651,
0.0003039722,
0.0383621156,
-0.0309331082,
0.0302615389,
0.0040925718,
-0.0246434193,
0.0662642494,
0.0472796299,
0.0224776808,
-0.0355499536,
-0.0032622791,
0.0119438795,
0.0237187743,
-0.0121135684,
0.0055841813,
0.0255766753,
0.0328988135,
0.063955389,
-0.0529847704,
-0.0301627368,
0.0387071222,
0.0119080404,
0.0212679449,
-0.0014442214,
-0.0541527681,
0.0199791808,
-0.0208338536,
0.0941516832,
0.0065771379,
0.0002208067,
-0.0016225867,
-0.0177145768,
0.0596068837,
-0.0000322447,
-0.0444980972,
0.0363446288,
-0.0434714966,
-0.0341133438,
0.0238573458,
-0.0181504022,
-0.0599972308,
-0.0061299978,
0.0054009361,
0.0062978189,
0.0068992036,
-0.0264807232,
-0.0125820795,
0.0171941984,
0.0144820549,
-0.0033348778,
0.0023603577,
0.0450761057,
-0.0395453013,
0.0158385318,
-0.0512920395,
-0.0177650284,
0.0095073497,
-0.0114906244,
0.0688609332,
0.0589641072,
-0.0095172357,
0.0148346666,
0.0143111432,
0.0977645516,
0.0388658345,
0.0130638471,
-0.0647098869,
0.0488182046,
-0.0689793378,
0.0162212141,
-0.0347321481,
0.0239844285,
-0.0516661927,
0.0408895016,
-0.0659249201,
0.02768155,
-0.0218112245,
0.0007463734,
0.0014466012,
0.0187964793,
-0.0513724163,
0.0244656615,
-0.020612089,
-0.0007991026,
-0.0374845751,
-0.0106423087,
0.0158042703,
-0.0053761965,
0.0080524143,
0.0136371925,
-0.0164589118,
0.001744728,
0.0303495787,
0.0218751356,
-0.05427517,
0.0231594443,
-0.0242641699,
-0.043055553,
0.0038393692,
-0.012126632,
0.0352953225,
-0.0679348558,
0.00924112,
0.0095210755,
-0.0250758808,
0.0161980949,
-0.0037212952,
0.0261007901,
-0.0247897636,
0.0188202001,
0.0592993312,
-0.0024454552,
0.046007175,
0.0257154666,
0.0155347446,
0.040337652,
0.0187208895,
0.0158695579,
0.0409773067,
-0.0326602608,
0.0097976867,
0.0120687122,
0.0120831281,
-0.0116477935,
0.0204604566,
0.0218110755,
0.0259871837,
0.0329617225,
0.0131938551,
0.012863759,
-0.0214239694,
-0.0321346112,
-0.015951613,
0.0223051887,
-0.0271041933,
0.0028813831,
0.0592114851,
0.0689928606,
0.0596413985,
0.0784598067,
-0.0539209209,
0.0325036608,
0.0026702094,
-0.013507192,
0.021602843,
0.0112297805,
-0.0245387647,
-0.0861097649,
0.0151829319,
0.0221822932,
-0.0188137442,
0.0167735796,
-0.0054652831,
-0.0092858458,
-0.0500758439,
-0.0207136478,
0.0503476672,
-0.0343296118,
0.0150902113,
-0.0340419412,
0.008021987,
0.1026549339,
0.0542794392,
-0.0268818755,
-0.0963704064,
0.0221294239,
0.0560277551,
0.0366584659,
0.0582116805,
-0.0610170998,
0.006760099,
-0.0578192659,
-0.0496352389,
-0.007346177,
-0.0051744138,
0.0497381762,
0.0472063795,
-0.0237343945,
-0.0212597102,
0.0072430554,
-0.0481300876,
0.0384376869,
-0.0681651235,
-0.0760017857,
0.009538006,
0.0090998281,
0.0239397082,
0.0129823145,
0.0043819728,
-0.0114542767,
0.0272062998,
-0.0023064297,
0.0164677165,
-0.0409405716,
-0.0770902708,
-0.0176562946,
0.0437769257,
-0.0343445987,
-0.0405906104,
0.0269383471,
-0.0555590577,
-0.0323724449,
0.0304593686,
-0.0068223821,
-0.0014210762,
0.0090538654,
0.0284577031,
0.009352237,
-0.0093608974,
-0.0402651131,
0.0337592438,
-0.0035170245,
0.0290777832,
0.0397309475,
0.0114692403,
0.0121095236,
-0.0156381149,
0.0266124662,
-0.0272465851,
-0.024814561,
0.0084519237,
-0.0019873956,
0.0299809314,
-0.0845643803,
-0.0214469917,
-0.0614569038,
0.0192371551,
-0.0055608652,
0.0116601074,
0.0269798096,
-0.0309136063,
-0.0260966327,
-0.0123603549,
-0.0596701503,
0.0007432965,
-0.0190528445,
0.0088074366,
0.0205499493,
0.0133562395,
-0.020016741,
-0.0263104234,
-0.0177949406,
-0.0295453072,
0.0010520706,
0.0295101348,
0.0898420066,
-0.0432943888,
-0.001214321,
0.0000998149,
0.005907956,
-0.0096034277,
-0.0464270003,
0.0172510725,
0.0151605979,
0.09432289,
0.0817983076,
0.0432949401,
0.05596729,
0.0193144567,
0.0129200108,
-0.0530544482,
0.0380058363,
-0.0301335957,
-0.0387113914,
-0.0185364354,
-0.0677985549,
-0.0293790735,
0.0293688718,
0.0286981929,
-0.0134081272,
-0.0509785376,
-0.001485607,
-0.0052605481,
-0.0280103274,
-0.0609519333,
0.001581851,
-0.0122926896,
-0.0059459913,
-0.0219274722,
0.0221240614,
0.077499114,
0.0279512852,
0.0333029106,
-0.0876312852,
0.0280677807,
0.0072284765,
-0.0010878894,
-0.0052491878,
-0.0077179102,
-0.0311794579,
0.0135095036,
-0.1114001274,
0.0080557093,
0.0601330549,
-0.0578694455,
-0.0041824696,
-0.0824747235,
-0.0781359002,
-0.0199566726,
-0.0106189121,
-0.0723546147,
0.0070976126,
0.0785562247,
-0.0008203296,
0.0534115769,
-0.024686506,
-0.022841638,
-0.0713354796,
0.0063826619,
0.0242136586,
-0.035534054,
-0.0073101474,
0.0056035616,
0.0336625949,
0.0433985554,
-0.0014802342,
-0.0148639213,
-0.0549752302,
0.0385797434,
0.0624136478,
0.0759159103,
-0.0329041667,
0.036919944,
0.032348752,
0.0287067369,
-0.0375453904,
0.0165393148,
0.0609326027,
0.0337246619,
-0.0281435046,
-0.0217469912,
0.0911650732,
0.0419017598,
-0.0271900911,
-0.0026362566,
-0.0099215116,
0.0035053922,
0.0322150774,
0.0549576692,
-0.0466014966,
0.0052576321,
-0.0454982035,
0.0918902829,
-0.0072415299,
-0.0407509618,
0.0006586961,
-0.0880436674,
0.0420229994,
0.0140078068,
-0.0287758801,
0.0004235591,
-0.0389603488,
-0.0204456504,
0.0026618221,
0.0070356345,
0.0100853881,
-0.004257299,
0.028554773,
0.0699272305,
0.0204575174,
-0.0238510408,
0.0399900191,
0.0208268352,
0.052335728,
0.003994137,
0.0088511668,
-0.0015511526,
-0.011039543,
0.0196672417,
-0.0036445991,
-0.0153585076,
0.0274193287,
0.0406935923,
-0.0177822132,
0.0263108592,
-0.0355272777,
0.0483714864,
-0.0035914928,
0.0036490585,
0.0701976717,
0.0506081022,
-0.0028703427,
0.0150226699,
-0.0663719848,
0.007466034,
0.0242521577,
0.0596922152,
0.0329779983,
-0.0898987427,
0.0325847603,
-0.0448835567,
0.0132174846,
-0.0783784315,
-0.0106069632,
0.0298825391,
-0.0364729725,
0.0029709935,
-0.0712646171,
-0.0406765491,
0.0219112113,
0.0297918431,
-0.0018120905,
-0.0347773097,
0.0338890143,
0.0028549824,
-0.0760136396,
0.0010565927,
-0.0039099446,
-0.0251464825,
-0.1062621251,
-0.097593382,
-0.0142775811,
-0.0555413663,
-0.016229026,
0.0402431041,
-0.0581750236,
-0.0437760949,
0.0415496342,
0.0445022583,
0.0066917581,
0.0606616959,
0.0476995707,
0.0237507876,
0.0274866335,
0.0151375169,
-0.000042973,
0.0170210507,
-0.0013939386,
0.0081078233,
-0.0127861304,
-0.0181688592,
-0.043439161,
0.0376628302,
0.0355968513,
0.0175745003,
-0.0232840218,
-0.0044064415,
0.0294035897,
0.0037899255,
0.0278463736,
-0.0321514942,
-0.0459620617,
-0.0388568193,
0.0395193063,
-0.0297159478,
-0.026879508,
0.0030036489,
-0.0174217056,
0.0205289982,
-0.0190131664,
-0.0004400609,
-0.0166880284,
-0.0039271764,
0.0250807013,
-0.0410936922,
0.0149154458,
-0.032873366,
0.0397459716,
0.0097759347,
-0.0050018653,
-0.0201041382,
0.0133973463,
0.0150880711,
0.0755576342,
0.0109426146,
0.0848978087,
0.0054794038,
0.026297031,
0.0235759299,
0.0162937045,
-0.0373288132,
0.0120319817,
-0.0470897704,
0.0237403717,
-0.0020546315,
-0.0065428088,
-0.0175135974,
-0.0136952503,
0.0108302105,
-0.0009938807,
0.0032352938,
-0.0129737789,
-0.0323874988,
-0.0194537267,
0.0397002399,
0.0561626554,
-0.0070933942,
0.0403411798,
0.0130202686,
0.0268865637,
0.0011103903,
0.0105867917,
-0.0621331334,
-0.0200047288,
0.0231862664,
0.0380158387,
0.0271971133,
0.0488297194,
-0.0530189984,
-0.0260808673,
-0.0155824972,
0.0491903722,
0.0352717452,
-0.0091833714,
0.0521539152,
0.0467781499,
-0.0602270737,
-0.0176879447,
-0.0294898618,
0.0452442318,
-0.0239770636,
-0.0637684911,
-0.0172247775,
-6.100892455e-33,
-0.0437329747,
-0.0280091707,
0.0409872346,
0.0266618039,
0.0486987978,
-0.0259173159,
-0.0334512927,
0.0404822044,
-0.0169935282,
0.0006333583,
-0.0044167759,
0.01047289,
-0.0046317233,
0.0310337674,
0.0256185178,
0.0001114828,
0.0170807,
-0.043258585,
-0.0344708003,
0.0611398108,
0.0361778773,
-0.0284047518,
0.0404538438,
-0.0256756973,
-0.0090800524,
-0.0344313718,
0.0433551557,
-0.010972931,
-0.0361635797,
0.061997477,
0.0020101871,
0.0476440489,
0.0136331944,
-0.0308789071,
0.0100059407,
-0.0361477584,
-0.0594377257,
-0.0840938017,
-0.0017796721,
-0.0007271111,
-0.0123825725,
-0.0642174482,
0.0014824765,
0.0016823539,
-0.0582315698,
-0.0606048256,
0.0579841174,
-0.0111901853,
0.0171576515,
-0.0295261126,
-0.0559115112,
-0.0054573049,
-0.0413410291,
-0.0537028462,
-0.0669705793,
0.0476065092,
0.0108545236,
-0.0405104533,
-0.0177384391,
0.0640761927,
0.0320658907,
0.0457449146,
0.0398344845,
0.0206256378,
-0.0265575219,
0.019937437,
0.0239235368,
0.0462032594,
0.0058810166,
0.0114868851,
0.0077229193,
0.0170173366,
0.0238315128,
0.0487443544,
0.0316672213,
-0.0003092891,
-0.0507687703,
0.0857870057,
0.0226040222,
-0.0154653881,
-0.0112200435,
-0.0556454919,
-0.0746247992,
-0.0124705248,
-0.0102714458,
0.0318459086,
-0.0073735663,
0.0239906386,
0.0573971309,
-0.027097838,
-0.0491721071,
-0.0333340876,
0.0184587203,
-0.0200970806,
0.0266401768,
0.0234933458,
-0.0268113278,
0.004608273,
0.0034260815,
0.019555226,
-0.060471788,
-0.0461276732,
0.0661879107,
-0.0389677919,
0.0178099722,
0.0259535518,
0.0318642817,
0.0126260733,
-0.0274504963,
-0.0112176687,
-0.0379157662,
0.0457532294,
0.0325872004,
-0.0273428541,
-0.0083619766,
0.0240383241,
-0.0115202861,
0.0224686675,
0.0103138778,
-0.0544249006,
-0.0321159065,
-0.0430697612,
0.0088874018,
0.0279104635,
-0.0017842491,
0.0230519567,
-0.0355203524,
-0.0195849352,
-0.0229593348,
-0.0588547066,
-0.0191343594,
0.0124219228,
2.669e-7,
-0.0064151119,
0.0397408567,
0.0343635753,
0.0081750974,
0.0038343554,
-0.0065943343,
-0.0064385086,
-0.0024544536,
0.0393083133,
-0.0147936335,
0.0186869279,
0.0496603996,
0.0060425312,
-0.0011149935,
-0.053392645,
-0.0350097194,
0.0248925816,
-0.0072746119,
-0.054341618,
0.0163840335,
0.0783324391,
0.0208199471,
0.0085110879,
-0.0044885166,
-0.0185531192,
0.0700044557,
-0.0101014832,
0.0139222872,
0.0134747783,
0.0022325262,
-0.033574719,
-0.0044630412,
0.0026203978,
0.0479844622,
-0.0323223583,
-0.008048946,
-0.0357671306,
0.0522160232,
0.0102550555,
-0.0504396856,
0.0223347992,
-0.0256721769,
-0.0205715988,
-0.0269480031,
0.0042253048,
-0.0072623389,
0.0295930374,
0.0685688034,
-0.0719461367,
0.0153369131,
-0.0383969434,
-0.0120737981,
0.0192395337,
-0.0083616646,
-0.0022331986,
-0.0333359055,
0.0527845956,
-0.0186481085,
0.0170837995,
0.0241612121,
-0.0124961687,
-0.069032073,
-0.0202972181,
-0.0142658837,
0.0174913146,
-0.0284169354,
-0.0150676398,
2.330654256e-34,
0.0188936964,
0.0060187508,
0.0521259382,
-0.047298871,
-0.0214832798,
-0.0258247368,
-0.0120233623,
0.0270882882,
0.0567890219,
-0.0576865561,
-0.0661080703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09512v1 | Attentive Multi-Layer Perceptron for Non-autoregressive Generation | 2023-10-14T06:44:24 | 2023-10-14T06:44:24 | Shuyang Jiang, Jun Zhang, Jiangtao Feng, Lin Zheng, Lingpeng Kong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Autoregressive~(AR) generation almost dominates sequence generation for its
efficacy. Recently, non-autoregressive~(NAR) generation gains increasing
popularity for its efficiency and growing efficacy. However, its efficiency is
still bottlenecked by quadratic complexity in sequence lengths, which is
prohibitive for scaling to long sequence generation and few works have been
done to mitigate this problem. In this paper, we propose a novel MLP variant,
\textbf{A}ttentive \textbf{M}ulti-\textbf{L}ayer \textbf{P}erceptron~(AMLP), to
produce a generation model with linear time and space complexity. Different
from classic MLP with static and learnable projection matrices, AMLP leverages
adaptive projections computed from inputs in an attentive mode. The
sample-aware adaptive projections enable communications among tokens in a
sequence, and model the measurement between the query and key space.
Furthermore, we marry AMLP with popular NAR models, deriving a highly efficient
NAR-AMLP architecture with linear time and space complexity. Empirical results
show that such marriage architecture surpasses competitive efficient NAR
models, by a significant margin on text-to-speech synthesis and machine
translation. We also test AMLP's self- and cross-attention ability separately
with extensive ablation experiments, and find them comparable or even superior
to the other efficient models. The efficiency analysis further shows that AMLP
extremely reduces the memory cost against vanilla non-autoregressive models for
long sequences. | [
0.004149057,
0.0666182861,
-0.0066181193,
-0.0142898494,
-0.040100012,
-0.0184739269,
0.0300292298,
-0.0294602551,
-0.0311584584,
-0.0238340758,
-0.0078624012,
-0.0505389273,
0.0206446089,
0.0610961691,
0.0549945794,
-0.0326200314,
0.0100767044,
-0.0122739701,
0.0012693503,
0.0012521596,
-0.0252742134,
-0.013142297,
-0.0136735784,
0.0649509728,
-0.0176865831,
0.0165156648,
-0.0619648434,
-0.0153215323,
-0.0174633432,
-0.0642299652,
-0.0406740569,
0.036291223,
-0.0014883127,
0.0126959682,
0.0000021852,
-0.0014324228,
0.0009148648,
0.0027581083,
-0.0011830605,
-0.0142549248,
0.0295893587,
0.0045648124,
-0.0072576762,
0.0407766178,
-0.0019989507,
-0.0332601368,
0.0591381043,
0.0281205121,
0.0353955068,
0.0877693146,
-0.0135154044,
-0.0317466483,
0.0234503057,
-0.0499209203,
0.0229694117,
-0.025147792,
-0.0054782014,
-0.0937288105,
-0.0020614655,
-0.0082712667,
-0.0366079286,
0.0505017564,
0.0251014549,
-0.0123207737,
0.0450822264,
0.0453758053,
-0.0073036714,
-0.0725815594,
-0.030395221,
0.0545870028,
-0.02924769,
-0.0119839823,
0.0389771685,
-0.0035875337,
-0.0005122788,
-0.0359604917,
0.0076371315,
0.0162239149,
-0.0084984889,
0.0211601555,
0.0142962188,
0.0323488526,
0.0247358456,
-0.0380039811,
-0.0084992638,
0.0058528311,
0.0265901275,
-0.030699363,
-0.0268419497,
0.0055504474,
0.0207693763,
-0.043480657,
0.0446942039,
0.0450683497,
-0.0018666739,
0.0335130692,
-0.0849143192,
-0.0513768494,
-0.0186998565,
-0.0357179046,
0.0671041906,
0.0350216515,
0.0166814867,
-0.004160637,
-0.0891914144,
0.0662785992,
-0.0007996479,
-0.0421396829,
-0.0113901505,
0.0193261299,
-0.0023622599,
0.0210367851,
-0.0381562412,
0.0523380265,
-0.0359354988,
-0.0556392483,
-0.070082508,
0.0258703418,
0.0154438168,
-0.0093583902,
-0.0191630814,
0.0265999809,
-0.0491561145,
0.0084836138,
-0.0130805634,
0.0182197094,
-0.0012370226,
-0.0352407619,
0.0185329858,
-0.0543276407,
-0.03497402,
0.0376668423,
0.024534842,
0.0140438806,
-0.0012715932,
0.1019343585,
-0.0486267991,
-0.0422926471,
-0.0381911956,
-0.0366960503,
-0.0180406366,
-0.0278032329,
0.0046685967,
-0.0445483811,
0.0613824241,
-0.0131900394,
-0.0576810241,
-0.030895846,
0.042972602,
0.0281819329,
-0.002120167,
0.0218818747,
-0.0035267526,
0.0007077854,
0.0340327471,
-0.01579847,
0.0027622553,
0.0498518609,
0.0663754642,
0.0319992416,
-0.0180043038,
0.0080741867,
0.0122364974,
0.0222929325,
0.0549836904,
-0.020070225,
-0.0315784886,
-0.0395080969,
-0.0269177295,
0.0407791324,
0.0546576567,
0.0729140714,
-0.0121142277,
-0.013130716,
0.0269210804,
0.037827339,
0.0288858581,
0.0751332566,
0.0717497841,
-0.0203168616,
-0.0345855393,
-0.013680364,
0.0100224046,
0.0838393867,
0.0088361353,
0.0130228261,
0.0843514055,
0.0136417542,
-0.0384770632,
-0.0297686998,
0.0310679823,
-0.0113175418,
-0.026570674,
-0.0113297878,
0.0240525603,
0.0074113351,
-0.0980653912,
0.0353204273,
-0.0348887928,
-0.0574482009,
0.0146345468,
-0.0336438306,
-0.0063322615,
0.0449295342,
0.0307755917,
0.0068618148,
-0.0261349957,
-0.022824822,
-0.0401210934,
0.088944152,
-0.00332072,
0.0231764596,
0.0289914235,
-0.0517125167,
-0.0323446058,
0.0064615873,
-0.0111929346,
0.0711492002,
-0.0107636321,
0.0368276499,
0.0553327091,
0.0063754739,
-0.009605228,
0.0126904305,
-0.0625693798,
-0.0377766155,
0.0271090344,
0.026161734,
0.070587188,
0.0184654631,
0.0118303709,
0.0551252998,
0.0106615238,
-0.0757586807,
-0.0202031601,
0.0210416038,
-0.105558902,
-0.0483383499,
0.0180892926,
-0.0423467867,
0.0258293413,
-0.0077478192,
0.0313224681,
-0.1054279879,
0.0609909669,
-0.1017525941,
0.0502165779,
-0.0290397368,
0.0281088464,
0.055809509,
0.0189547818,
0.0089714359,
0.0027398847,
-0.0346409939,
-0.006750294,
0.057782691,
0.0196644925,
0.0287197605,
-0.0316116586,
-0.0106768506,
-0.0151976906,
0.0032637462,
-0.0068926443,
0.0347854346,
0.0087690391,
0.0003100041,
-0.0574419014,
-0.0030842419,
-0.0285622329,
-0.0111182369,
0.0176531412,
-0.0086589912,
0.0270872563,
0.0279181991,
-0.0100731608,
-0.0721085519,
-0.0002055875,
0.0367801264,
0.0042302296,
0.0163828526,
0.017451195,
-0.0461473539,
-0.0275085364,
-0.0240736306,
0.0127515448,
0.0288091581,
0.0008985645,
-0.0543779507,
-0.019935498,
-0.0191134643,
-0.0047842572,
0.0281040967,
-0.0039214389,
-0.0301520769,
0.00650367,
-0.0156620163,
0.0491358116,
0.0208383277,
0.0202532262,
0.0298281945,
0.007651248,
-0.0159882475,
-0.0237700343,
0.0431836098,
-0.0297202896,
0.0366441831,
0.0184387118,
-0.0268905666,
0.028014563,
0.0554231554,
0.0243725181,
0.0131417857,
-0.0935154483,
-0.0180700738,
0.0391031094,
-0.1005762145,
0.0193142369,
-0.0270988941,
-0.0249188151,
0.007283851,
-0.0145067172,
-0.0352017842,
0.0435268879,
-0.0541356541,
-0.0122090885,
-0.0015233357,
-0.0059734476,
-0.0041389056,
0.0307098329,
0.0188431907,
0.0267701689,
-0.0284506362,
-0.0511016622,
0.0001778073,
0.0315225311,
-0.019265851,
-0.0252574719,
0.0497359745,
-0.0325484984,
0.0016608114,
-0.004731169,
-0.0324991159,
-0.029669093,
0.0191904381,
0.0226478241,
0.0223232433,
0.0041899048,
-0.0233875625,
-0.0513758361,
0.0518616587,
0.0341730155,
0.0360548608,
-0.007779663,
-0.0127788763,
-0.0082608145,
0.0153803779,
0.032856673,
0.0022802323,
-0.0228252523,
-0.0161967315,
0.0165911969,
0.0296106096,
0.064601317,
0.0135218883,
-0.0063454658,
0.0074482667,
0.001119243,
0.0074985935,
-0.0285090804,
0.0364465527,
-0.0070696347,
-0.0309827812,
-0.0279881284,
0.0932202637,
-0.0213603936,
-0.0320569202,
0.007873985,
0.0457061641,
0.0569558926,
0.0070810043,
0.0208062883,
-0.0490319692,
-0.0246768687,
0.0038936562,
0.0499517284,
-0.0087955315,
-0.0336512476,
-0.0415195785,
-0.0952573419,
0.0068704183,
-0.0066072368,
-0.0557088852,
-0.0737177655,
-0.0252634194,
-0.0235509593,
-0.0019979852,
0.0012433795,
0.0544414967,
0.0099138143,
0.0089903018,
0.0272638425,
-0.0350311249,
-0.0026146644,
-0.0424197353,
-0.0085715996,
0.0452923067,
0.0628029853,
0.0371187963,
0.0157546103,
-0.0546875149,
-0.0012681442,
-0.0019191968,
0.0465838686,
-0.0203824155,
-0.010627416,
0.0047022672,
-0.0301475264,
-0.0017539406,
0.0302070603,
-0.0226380434,
0.0390942916,
-0.0093306405,
0.0590116531,
-0.0054263719,
-0.0081434175,
-0.0377622582,
0.0314699896,
0.0003335577,
0.0478427783,
0.0214010216,
-0.037214756,
-0.0799752623,
-0.0149969347,
0.0107556581,
-0.1025768742,
0.0007507346,
-0.0091220764,
0.0062453211,
-0.0614980422,
-0.0424256884,
-0.044188112,
0.0059288028,
0.0957511142,
-0.0067412714,
-0.0059740441,
0.0266193058,
-0.0039718309,
-0.0297999475,
-0.0559718348,
0.0063246703,
-0.0283362046,
-0.0611225441,
-0.0154844504,
-0.0131446868,
-0.0152321132,
0.0197767038,
0.0458147712,
-0.0670633838,
-0.0704605579,
0.0053068912,
0.0563924722,
0.0119902166,
0.0226917565,
0.0299055371,
0.0069305552,
0.0889833346,
0.0397847891,
-0.0051412364,
0.0324570648,
0.0195283517,
-0.0005934217,
-0.0304350369,
0.0191384628,
-0.0438086689,
-0.0038081054,
-0.0076548001,
0.0737909228,
0.0148020685,
-0.0533625819,
0.0130468141,
0.0275691617,
-0.0031790214,
-0.0550004616,
0.0472408496,
-0.0029640612,
0.008191268,
-0.0076875077,
0.0554117337,
-0.0700009689,
0.0502717011,
0.0249779262,
0.0108722029,
0.0109447222,
-0.0437965989,
0.0099582728,
0.0206602383,
-0.002931348,
0.0237833038,
-0.0229767244,
-0.0275740679,
0.0122047774,
-0.0169116259,
-0.0359372236,
0.0228567049,
0.0039651166,
0.001469963,
-0.0410747379,
0.020902412,
0.0251368526,
0.0548497438,
0.0134718325,
0.0143184867,
-0.0398819558,
0.026944099,
-0.026840182,
0.0211291965,
0.0676823854,
0.0127245095,
0.0530049242,
-0.0302875135,
0.0255391803,
-0.0244624354,
0.0563783087,
-0.0155754518,
-0.0210932028,
0.0036063339,
0.0077992622,
-0.0050316253,
-0.0279316641,
0.0837339163,
0.0100547383,
0.0219264105,
0.0041656531,
0.0100033134,
-0.0574284196,
-0.0352844335,
0.0205736998,
-0.0122794937,
-0.0111156162,
0.0195320826,
0.0018885378,
-0.0344048403,
0.0349579379,
-0.0199722983,
0.0231392626,
-0.0152728185,
0.0484134927,
0.0373717546,
0.0017272418,
0.0018364458,
-0.0265763719,
0.0030710206,
-0.0112466812,
-0.0258541759,
0.002604133,
-6.634472484e-33,
-0.0442719087,
-0.04479938,
-0.0015800809,
-0.0115854805,
-0.0394457392,
0.001410596,
-0.0269010328,
-0.005980805,
0.0392003655,
-0.0378818847,
-0.0259743724,
-0.01027577,
0.0080039073,
0.0396178514,
0.0545496978,
0.0149975494,
0.0744829699,
-0.0119693549,
0.0047582085,
0.057927426,
0.0161993355,
0.0524490923,
0.0030833893,
-0.0153173283,
-0.0277720354,
0.0294378437,
0.0149492742,
-0.0569183864,
0.0173892863,
0.020275902,
-0.0216966979,
0.0137443831,
0.0108538987,
-0.0650951639,
-0.0398286991,
0.0054873279,
-0.0599454381,
-0.0341039784,
-0.0209859461,
-0.0196504965,
-0.0208771601,
-0.0301380306,
0.0619307011,
-0.000788579,
-0.0268633589,
0.0012108632,
0.0186668951,
-0.0100620463,
-0.0611288399,
-0.0531706475,
-0.0310910586,
0.0352005102,
0.0045966255,
0.0023214624,
0.0408909209,
0.0741577372,
-0.0340270959,
-0.0132403364,
-0.0546966195,
0.0281488411,
0.0141337393,
0.085728921,
0.0342770107,
0.0534447245,
0.0396882109,
0.00393026,
0.0675555691,
0.0022831522,
-0.0156550035,
0.0343503654,
-0.0011965218,
-0.011167245,
0.0325339846,
0.0051642573,
0.0229936019,
0.0011539075,
-0.0166209042,
0.0019161727,
0.0373231024,
0.0215816479,
0.0462733842,
0.0006223856,
-0.0145371016,
-0.0040721698,
-0.0193024147,
-0.0084986454,
-0.0143256383,
-0.0248331632,
0.0404472463,
0.0615972392,
0.0315681547,
-0.0172603689,
0.0511897616,
0.0287363566,
-0.0053063249,
-0.0048195026,
-0.0006822939,
-0.0231708493,
-0.0001392378,
0.025375722,
-0.0593960248,
-0.0153709659,
0.0284397528,
0.0172608141,
0.010890631,
-0.0201179814,
-0.0356681496,
0.058945857,
-0.0812715963,
-0.025996631,
-0.0379154384,
0.0513320751,
0.0167294741,
-0.0116374912,
0.0330225527,
-0.0707606673,
-0.0067321262,
0.0389138386,
-0.0417812653,
-0.0136284912,
0.014101088,
0.0062368987,
0.0379689299,
0.0404875167,
-0.0507549122,
0.0253809672,
-0.0594304688,
0.05821703,
0.0112266485,
-0.0737008601,
-0.0395592451,
0.0317477509,
2.993e-7,
-0.0314701088,
0.0075965454,
0.0844087303,
0.0177659057,
0.0121022658,
0.0231524576,
0.0010099554,
0.0450180471,
-0.0382479839,
0.0263730567,
0.0170594808,
-0.0203876346,
0.0448514,
-0.0059977677,
-0.0927895829,
-0.0027137075,
-0.0894664526,
0.0408617258,
-0.0429825895,
0.0041404297,
0.046819292,
0.019918967,
-0.0443541557,
-0.0229897723,
0.017795654,
-0.016489381,
0.0354585871,
0.0356670022,
-0.0043397113,
-0.0329106934,
0.0535140112,
-0.0119142951,
-0.0294081029,
-0.0148780523,
-0.0280602444,
0.0059619835,
0.009992104,
0.0527034067,
0.0100435615,
-0.0862799361,
0.0885808244,
0.0195313543,
-0.0278950781,
-0.0017227702,
0.005641114,
-0.0060398472,
-0.0085972548,
0.0203695558,
-0.0227692369,
0.0397443324,
-0.0086917514,
-0.0376769416,
0.0060303709,
-0.0108953351,
0.0263566468,
-0.0120628048,
0.023941718,
-0.0405139774,
0.014339488,
-0.0124510704,
-0.054158695,
-0.0023625223,
-0.1036991104,
0.0289145,
0.0490666665,
0.0114247845,
-0.0614977404,
2.662673095e-34,
0.0224998686,
-0.0559849925,
0.0009861172,
-0.0069238856,
0.0136624537,
-0.0337699093,
0.0054873307,
0.0197362341,
0.0081790118,
-0.058996778,
-0.093365185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09501v1 | DepNeCTI: Dependency-based Nested Compound Type Identification for Sanskrit | 2023-10-14T06:11:53 | 2023-10-14T06:11:53 | Jivnesh Sandhan, Yaswanth Narsupalli, Sreevatsa Muppirala, Sriram Krishnan, Pavankumar Satuluri, Amba Kulkarni, Pawan Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-component compounding is a prevalent phenomenon in Sanskrit, and
understanding the implicit structure of a compound's components is crucial for
deciphering its meaning. Earlier approaches in Sanskrit have focused on binary
compounds and neglected the multi-component compound setting. This work
introduces the novel task of nested compound type identification (NeCTI), which
aims to identify nested spans of a multi-component compound and decode the
implicit semantic relations between them. To the best of our knowledge, this is
the first attempt in the field of lexical semantics to propose this task.
We present 2 newly annotated datasets including an out-of-domain dataset for
this task. We also benchmark these datasets by exploring the efficacy of the
standard problem formulations such as nested named entity recognition,
constituency parsing and seq2seq, etc. We present a novel framework named
DepNeCTI: Dependency-based Nested Compound Type Identifier that surpasses the
performance of the best baseline with an average absolute improvement of 13.1
points F1-score in terms of Labeled Span Score (LSS) and a 5-fold enhancement
in inference efficiency. In line with the previous findings in the binary
Sanskrit compound identification task, context provides benefits for the NeCTI
task. The codebase and datasets are publicly available at:
https://github.com/yaswanth-iitkgp/DepNeCTI | [
0.0003886901,
0.01064183,
-0.0326637104,
0.0954259709,
-0.0228821803,
0.0282948427,
-0.0150061036,
0.055233866,
0.0156810973,
-0.0419615395,
-0.0246810652,
-0.0330294929,
0.017507419,
0.0003216528,
0.047034014,
-0.0300105587,
0.0495885052,
-0.0193618778,
0.0332822204,
0.0405628011,
0.0626560822,
0.0257539302,
-0.0356983468,
0.0054123844,
-0.0571632572,
-0.0403120629,
0.0231211185,
0.013089573,
0.0600205548,
-0.0552881397,
0.0126387291,
0.060918387,
0.0091842711,
0.0667610317,
0.0000014882,
-0.0561822765,
-0.0564561374,
-0.0226754211,
-0.0163433664,
-0.0330313332,
0.0488076508,
-0.0322100408,
0.0034365896,
-0.0148398168,
0.0217870325,
-0.004909365,
0.0777922571,
-0.0109605575,
-0.0226662736,
0.0456660129,
-0.0250893477,
-0.0485726222,
0.0210856944,
0.0112906685,
-0.0302667655,
-0.0207152888,
0.0302255675,
0.0041344808,
-0.021010939,
0.0025762867,
-0.0305479094,
-0.0251003914,
-0.0354834497,
0.0141580151,
0.0024462221,
0.0132067725,
-0.0718031079,
0.0094790496,
0.0431397632,
0.0697529167,
-0.0346937403,
-0.0163196679,
0.0205740351,
-0.0111648208,
-0.0813438818,
-0.0489267558,
0.0024407844,
0.021574026,
-0.0750833377,
0.0285461564,
0.0992950574,
0.0348383971,
-0.0092086177,
0.0233285949,
0.0430382229,
0.0122941956,
0.0363901071,
-0.0049278555,
0.0106781693,
0.0112201609,
-0.0387859009,
-0.0271103624,
0.0232490022,
-0.0248133093,
-0.0106197307,
0.0656974986,
-0.0039979788,
-0.0758790672,
-0.0034687493,
-0.0126592759,
-0.0155047188,
0.0203385111,
-0.0058505302,
0.0070039327,
-0.0468302257,
0.0016389544,
0.0095961988,
-0.0277956408,
-0.0186276026,
-0.0043920893,
0.0178230014,
-0.0399249122,
-0.0646656975,
0.0310613252,
-0.0125329643,
0.0066965637,
-0.0339624844,
-0.0057557379,
0.0016383989,
-0.0203898083,
-0.0137660876,
-0.0557863116,
-0.0548382401,
-0.0138146589,
0.0181927402,
0.0193929467,
-0.0156786069,
0.0395796001,
-0.0247836299,
-0.0608065724,
-0.0101258811,
0.0288484935,
-0.0067008794,
-0.0384345837,
-0.0209262874,
0.014522369,
-0.0087879654,
-0.0626897812,
-0.0736811012,
-0.0217591487,
-0.0092977472,
-0.0400756672,
-0.0072759981,
-0.0610386357,
0.0527775325,
-0.0059162257,
-0.0123402476,
-0.0562777258,
0.0319158137,
-0.0169160366,
-0.0136926081,
0.1112047061,
-0.0025493649,
-0.0486160852,
-0.02527765,
0.0304270554,
0.0606873371,
0.017968487,
0.0196127966,
0.0482114777,
0.0542549863,
-0.0026876368,
0.0005318419,
0.0114770057,
-0.0182300434,
0.0336106569,
-0.0286054276,
-0.0159802269,
0.0133615565,
0.0194260925,
-0.0373589806,
0.0291473083,
0.0088351034,
0.0381108299,
-0.0050490135,
0.0413534716,
0.0239007976,
0.0246690307,
0.0115812412,
-0.0017694312,
0.029692281,
0.0040757046,
-0.0058576926,
-0.0124264639,
-0.0024360733,
0.018635219,
0.0276398864,
-0.0153878238,
-0.0158591531,
0.01601886,
-0.0555989631,
-0.0512863286,
-0.0316020474,
-0.0589699522,
0.0699157268,
0.012296143,
-0.0803892836,
0.0640436336,
0.0607930981,
-0.0464345142,
0.0270058475,
-0.0137686543,
0.0493469983,
0.0051852153,
0.015656855,
-0.0809157342,
-0.0209009964,
0.0529151857,
-0.0156187629,
0.0375657342,
-0.0385200493,
-0.0416038856,
0.0279959459,
-0.0362849683,
0.0219266191,
0.0319360383,
0.0008329637,
0.0251242332,
-0.0273788981,
0.0114038764,
-0.0115715778,
-0.0368567035,
0.0411806218,
0.0560718626,
0.014288649,
-0.0315939821,
0.0242579672,
0.0267302319,
0.0608043931,
0.0326163284,
0.0177912768,
-0.0156067442,
-0.0009387628,
-0.0353871807,
0.0112280902,
-0.0157077424,
0.0343678035,
-0.0706341267,
0.0048014997,
-0.0436368957,
-0.0083837779,
-0.0044962824,
-0.0296832956,
-0.0341976061,
0.0300378557,
0.0093305511,
0.0064549739,
-0.0202773977,
0.0044247801,
0.0357101113,
0.0360080749,
-0.0198642965,
0.0849193856,
0.0213786829,
-0.0008280934,
-0.0120624369,
-0.0024033578,
0.0370666832,
-0.0228535682,
0.003473846,
0.0096919937,
0.0162712131,
-0.065688014,
-0.0322364978,
-0.0187454149,
-0.0665675476,
-0.0051023983,
-0.0231322516,
0.0027673782,
-0.0117642721,
0.0541968606,
-0.0144449836,
0.0382102616,
-0.0216712207,
-0.0028751963,
0.0163005106,
-0.0039647347,
-0.0002691211,
-0.0061869589,
-0.0015165416,
-0.0179282445,
-0.026044786,
-0.0307875201,
-0.0329951383,
-0.0670813173,
0.0258741919,
-0.0091065746,
-0.080841653,
-0.024374526,
0.0095779803,
-0.0174334459,
0.0048888037,
-0.0053215357,
0.0038509439,
-0.0267174132,
0.0013956815,
0.036046315,
0.0081379432,
-0.0204500165,
-0.019826347,
0.018800484,
-0.0397389196,
0.0203374196,
-0.015018601,
0.0108499294,
0.0372486115,
0.0188890025,
0.0183664691,
-0.0113618625,
0.0557496324,
-0.0078285802,
0.0114200739,
-0.021395158,
-0.0268544145,
-0.0588133708,
0.023098886,
-0.0002042309,
-0.0017874895,
-0.0465852581,
0.0353638865,
-0.0019552624,
-0.0347249545,
0.0781842172,
-0.0509653725,
0.0038152265,
-0.0654314235,
0.0214807745,
-0.0492402837,
0.0257827193,
-0.0266098287,
-0.0056512491,
0.064395003,
-0.0795181394,
-0.0245973524,
0.0493085161,
-0.0079842545,
-0.0231434461,
0.0391717069,
-0.0634412467,
0.0410503373,
-0.0627505109,
-0.0068386625,
-0.001084123,
-0.0075779506,
-0.0215805024,
0.0192683563,
0.0090905,
0.0069888141,
0.0633793548,
0.0680490807,
-0.0542008802,
-0.0270090401,
0.0121966964,
0.0346835777,
-0.0244953074,
0.0735260844,
0.0462521724,
-0.0304623861,
0.0283126254,
0.0149957798,
0.0168196969,
-0.0100927949,
0.0471470021,
-0.0053694448,
0.0023618608,
0.0003693007,
0.0232778825,
-0.0136704836,
0.021120498,
-0.01195144,
-0.0190369152,
-0.0023161133,
0.0049739708,
0.0708822384,
0.0587670319,
-0.0284359008,
0.0267566219,
-0.0235843901,
-0.0053271381,
0.0041277488,
-0.0103426836,
-0.1499083191,
-0.0332940668,
0.0398076437,
-0.0422731303,
0.0347704254,
-0.065970391,
0.0065948749,
-0.1046910286,
-0.0158125497,
-0.0121368021,
-0.0200547352,
0.0224213246,
0.0051196674,
0.0108327046,
-0.0437823161,
-0.0093375472,
-0.0157093834,
-0.0283983983,
-0.0026408706,
0.0161816515,
-0.0001155481,
-0.0153809404,
0.0440437645,
-0.0215093065,
-0.0148248803,
-0.0111948494,
0.0027501343,
-0.0321550742,
0.0240387414,
0.02590416,
-0.1004825383,
-0.0501597635,
-0.0148237711,
0.0219468344,
-0.0326340385,
-0.0014751715,
0.0002333971,
0.0392906405,
-0.0582409836,
-0.0444631726,
0.0145851234,
0.0612964928,
0.0345489308,
0.0246120617,
0.0108007463,
-0.0143881775,
0.0206956286,
0.0330518596,
-0.0177106839,
0.0266218837,
-0.0101075014,
-0.0073617501,
0.0239077136,
0.0181160457,
-0.0516763851,
-0.0008817322,
-0.0363456458,
0.0047348524,
-0.0383201316,
-0.0378922932,
0.0579092577,
0.0060898042,
-0.0021297974,
0.0697753355,
-0.0053455164,
0.0191414114,
-0.0440052636,
0.0142666092,
-0.0035461797,
0.0682711154,
-0.037630178,
0.0188338943,
0.00769745,
0.0207723435,
-0.0222515333,
0.0149038099,
-0.0364973173,
-0.0290929973,
0.0201993473,
-0.0112932837,
0.0122082597,
-0.0049462477,
-0.0610693991,
-0.0160627477,
-0.0218495633,
-0.0060247867,
-0.0347493663,
-0.0086840782,
0.0134572359,
0.0171842929,
-0.0188115649,
0.062264394,
-0.0310106613,
0.0121591575,
0.0013797595,
0.0299386326,
0.0222802479,
-0.0048287236,
0.0558159761,
0.0190591719,
0.0613466874,
-0.0787697956,
0.0060785399,
-0.0457479395,
0.0163130313,
-0.0039509847,
-0.0288239326,
-0.008482025,
0.0018209142,
0.0203661956,
0.0094823008,
-0.0379822291,
0.0260923617,
0.01758085,
0.0238108262,
0.0479292981,
0.0398951881,
0.0484923236,
0.0558168143,
0.0092445379,
-0.0145303626,
0.0171501059,
-0.0414793417,
-0.0238275751,
0.0145250177,
-0.057654351,
0.0473999344,
-0.0104962094,
-0.0068252445,
-0.028466057,
0.033072073,
0.0859033018,
0.0766320378,
0.0020921128,
-0.0228274446,
0.0433799848,
-0.0335494429,
0.0439797752,
-0.032428503,
0.0110634649,
-0.0223384015,
0.0280865338,
-0.0314222015,
0.0023581178,
0.0583122745,
0.0242559332,
-0.0095846457,
0.0196676962,
0.0951262265,
-0.0259087235,
0.0263696276,
0.0121067325,
-0.0115508018,
0.0019278905,
-0.0177788176,
-0.0541540012,
0.0359974839,
0.0004477668,
0.0142633235,
-0.0803177878,
-0.0592093207,
-0.0154510718,
-0.0242091846,
0.0360459313,
0.0030935442,
0.0122717023,
0.0226217397,
0.0657861978,
-0.0463405661,
-0.0362037756,
-0.0002802509,
-0.0232887119,
-0.022695411,
-0.0159484297,
-4.837297374e-33,
-0.0438997112,
-0.009098459,
-0.0255042929,
0.0064661275,
-0.0161544606,
0.0538228936,
-0.0740483031,
-0.0137662645,
0.0188431945,
-0.0008386085,
0.000238752,
0.0170465633,
0.0253660604,
-0.0197912697,
0.038766142,
-0.0198880695,
-0.0170301162,
0.0281391442,
-0.0006070008,
-0.0070343106,
0.0742624402,
0.0194272939,
0.1078636497,
-0.0442633368,
0.0147970486,
-0.0170707032,
0.0084353983,
0.0373054333,
-0.00124861,
0.0828605667,
-0.0645883232,
0.0231138784,
0.0171391983,
-0.0222673435,
0.0079806894,
0.0378852859,
-0.1115711182,
-0.0059571164,
0.029154554,
0.019846471,
-0.0450194478,
-0.0483309701,
-0.0306533761,
0.0095637813,
-0.0323502347,
0.0018258834,
0.015526983,
-0.0257412493,
0.0272815768,
-0.0497829467,
-0.1146585345,
0.0648468956,
-0.0223953426,
0.0422429442,
0.0307248812,
0.0013753152,
0.040192131,
0.0549171977,
-0.0367274396,
0.0126154954,
-0.0364920795,
0.0300753321,
0.0244826358,
0.0425909311,
-0.0454090014,
-0.0051177782,
0.0485657342,
-0.0771942064,
0.0252202936,
0.0489469394,
-0.0104039069,
0.0280113276,
0.0290855225,
0.0336994417,
0.0488623194,
0.0095406771,
-0.0538127162,
-0.0168908276,
0.0189230293,
0.0307285804,
-0.0319684707,
0.0000454152,
-0.0549109876,
-0.0203057509,
0.0361037403,
-0.0250586998,
-0.034163449,
-0.0280759465,
0.0376549214,
-0.0168892182,
-0.0106007876,
0.0604299419,
0.0345777236,
-0.0532470383,
0.0090433806,
-0.0155678578,
0.0073497389,
0.0442289375,
-0.0066394727,
0.0381739773,
-0.0567401685,
-0.0523548797,
0.0199741442,
0.0055931224,
0.0237255897,
-0.0208181832,
0.0610892363,
0.0142771062,
-0.0341753028,
0.0148556167,
-0.0063547622,
-0.0058716969,
-0.0131001826,
0.0554287694,
0.0098758312,
0.0316136852,
0.0236166604,
0.029695252,
0.0747179613,
0.02774111,
-0.0004949372,
0.0091483481,
0.0003887636,
0.0242866743,
0.0128321201,
-0.0189723112,
-0.0127910739,
-0.0387790948,
0.0797777176,
-0.0237106737,
0.019465439,
0.024748588,
2.397e-7,
0.0376786515,
0.0063619474,
0.0468508713,
-0.0456954949,
-0.0126597807,
0.0051039392,
-0.0336962678,
0.0152896093,
-0.0678802878,
0.0211990997,
0.0244345032,
-0.0294972733,
0.0463432446,
0.0278330389,
-0.0713196695,
0.0495464578,
-0.061984092,
-0.0645103753,
-0.0920805931,
0.0152572114,
-0.0242067929,
0.1184292063,
0.0123318611,
-0.005839407,
-0.026712792,
-0.0016693996,
0.0044665956,
0.0270990357,
0.0006238224,
0.040444769,
-0.0448592305,
-0.028917836,
-0.0026838565,
0.010129164,
-0.0172834955,
0.039653305,
0.0454882309,
0.050495401,
-0.0320341922,
0.0358018391,
0.0128974188,
-0.0124114929,
0.0306016207,
0.0068758009,
0.066638954,
0.0485655963,
-0.0309724975,
0.015197251,
-0.0068571959,
0.0571929924,
-0.0098910863,
0.0357647687,
-0.0447960943,
0.0249237958,
0.018502526,
-0.0435515828,
-0.0378510058,
-0.0660853907,
0.0040881848,
0.0446585901,
-0.0014598684,
-0.0042455764,
0.0271578617,
0.0016323399,
0.0271275435,
-0.0702414885,
-0.0291737951,
2.218978849e-34,
-0.0127860159,
-0.0108003039,
0.0139010167,
0.0398710817,
0.0338551216,
-0.0290293619,
-0.0411459617,
0.0362556875,
-0.0192819647,
-0.059576802,
-0.0094782189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09499v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09499v4 | One-Shot Sensitivity-Aware Mixed Sparsity Pruning for Large Language Models | 2023-10-14T05:43:09 | 2024-04-23T06:42:45 | Hang Shao, Bei Liu, Bo Xiao, Ke Zeng, Guanglu Wan, Yanmin Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Various Large Language Models~(LLMs) from the Generative Pretrained
Transformer(GPT) family have achieved outstanding performances in a wide range
of text generation tasks. However, the enormous model sizes have hindered their
practical use in real-world applications due to high inference latency.
Therefore, improving the efficiencies of LLMs through quantization, pruning,
and other means has been a key issue in LLM studies. In this work, we propose a
method based on Hessian sensitivity-aware mixed sparsity pruning to prune LLMs
to at least 50% sparsity without the need of any retraining. It allocates
sparsity adaptively based on sensitivity, allowing us to reduce pruning-induced
error while maintaining the overall sparsity level. The advantages of the
proposed method exhibit even more when the sparsity is extremely high.
Furthermore, our method is compatible with quantization, enabling further
compression of LLMs. We have released the available code. | [
-0.0302647967,
0.0979120955,
0.0093225539,
0.0296850652,
0.0011383821,
0.0067027579,
0.0181938745,
0.0555805005,
-0.0422539189,
-0.0079325913,
-0.0186051745,
-0.0560080484,
0.0129256751,
-0.0343048461,
0.0126609104,
-0.0313988701,
0.0185629912,
-0.0142646013,
-0.0005175645,
-0.0211176481,
0.009722135,
0.0337034091,
0.0156633183,
0.037570294,
-0.0103981495,
-0.0154278865,
0.0149081303,
0.0303595141,
0.0171882827,
-0.0087610073,
0.0120188044,
0.1042929292,
0.0225515664,
0.0338999443,
0.0000022763,
-0.0158612411,
-0.0091374945,
0.0119085126,
-0.0205454677,
0.0556345098,
0.0453438126,
-0.0052553932,
0.0027110521,
0.0192273799,
-0.0081676785,
-0.0528167076,
0.0554537475,
0.0039967853,
0.0357427634,
0.0854123607,
-0.0011023054,
-0.0088945134,
-0.0057375492,
-0.0451752543,
0.005139241,
-0.0458571538,
0.0055520721,
-0.0503368415,
-0.0504859909,
-0.0179059058,
-0.0120463464,
0.0088169454,
0.0203072038,
0.0244222116,
-0.039632041,
0.0243159384,
-0.0423535407,
-0.0242618583,
0.0131448284,
0.018507801,
-0.0636167899,
-0.0571551472,
0.0042512449,
-0.0203501973,
-0.0450439192,
-0.0597066917,
-0.0380367413,
0.0137478085,
0.0113984579,
0.0325955637,
-0.0252827629,
-0.0339785777,
0.0059749414,
0.0142521886,
-0.0455156937,
0.0159704182,
0.0477092639,
0.0043043168,
-0.0393131301,
0.0263934061,
-0.0211249366,
-0.043218825,
-0.0274948776,
0.0289033037,
-0.0219784863,
-0.0223020371,
-0.0938384682,
-0.052383624,
0.0146579668,
-0.0056579784,
0.0603337735,
0.0404701531,
0.0282612238,
-0.029975364,
-0.0302275848,
0.0127439657,
0.0109997923,
0.0100915553,
-0.0187236965,
0.0064975736,
0.0176956076,
-0.0111786425,
-0.0337728411,
0.0214145146,
-0.0312263109,
0.0120738242,
-0.0525392815,
0.0005178268,
0.0041057379,
-0.0462890267,
0.0339974016,
0.0101378886,
-0.0745604634,
-0.0404431932,
0.0275635961,
0.0325385407,
-0.0122946091,
0.0192519538,
0.0024850359,
-0.0564982295,
-0.0482542962,
0.0427276492,
0.046093978,
-0.0435455106,
0.0033944526,
0.0376665182,
-0.025972439,
-0.057837002,
-0.0484682731,
-0.0002966223,
0.0052164695,
-0.0539076105,
0.0011633553,
-0.0741463974,
0.0132005708,
-0.003434303,
0.0131973578,
-0.1075519547,
-0.0166002661,
0.0202191342,
-0.043523021,
0.0273260903,
-0.0061858944,
0.0115368022,
0.0112704402,
-0.0034954934,
0.0567879565,
0.1023247987,
0.0400124229,
0.0507892817,
-0.018371176,
-0.0101815807,
-0.0216593612,
0.0308532882,
0.0527691655,
0.0197011027,
-0.0304029137,
-0.0332871452,
-0.0429329313,
-0.0024560562,
0.1000302136,
0.0660836548,
-0.0428195149,
-0.0087381555,
0.0555384383,
0.0225886256,
0.0769858733,
0.053491503,
0.0477822982,
0.015585457,
-0.0127275065,
0.0251585729,
-0.0003071102,
0.0279233865,
-0.0272058491,
0.0225723442,
0.0326589458,
0.0682273135,
-0.0436946489,
-0.0060568568,
-0.0036958391,
0.0075113308,
-0.0269520655,
0.0005856918,
0.026312992,
0.0413131379,
-0.047928784,
0.1215040013,
0.0388357379,
-0.0732289329,
0.01913446,
-0.0563274175,
-0.0441461354,
-0.000641581,
0.0238722041,
-0.0141368788,
-0.0142324641,
0.032072816,
-0.0134754637,
0.0204972122,
0.0223389976,
0.0340072364,
0.0174929127,
-0.0555136576,
0.0102160657,
-0.0217851363,
0.0383016951,
0.0453670695,
0.0182004198,
0.0312851183,
0.0489004776,
-0.0007835793,
0.0196402948,
0.0365214199,
-0.0352012292,
-0.0386353061,
0.0494235158,
-0.0052052629,
0.0166588463,
-0.0252920929,
-0.0316526182,
0.0082390225,
0.0281102844,
-0.0425582863,
0.0270817671,
-0.0492569394,
-0.015251603,
-0.0601745024,
0.0303808693,
0.0081321271,
0.0145760765,
0.0678541809,
-0.042415712,
-0.0252305325,
0.0110684754,
-0.0179679375,
0.0175346602,
-0.0667149723,
0.0257335957,
0.0185499508,
0.0667294264,
-0.0185176264,
0.0187049042,
-0.017454315,
0.025166031,
0.0127666509,
-0.0141222756,
0.0053061144,
-0.0605852641,
-0.0286682714,
-0.0129754646,
-0.0232012831,
0.0297204219,
0.0219773334,
0.0542213693,
0.0323276892,
-0.0223174095,
-0.0371965766,
0.0221337304,
-0.0392893255,
0.0333775319,
0.0222245269,
0.0549858771,
0.002246127,
0.0175792892,
0.0011175794,
0.0419022888,
0.030067496,
0.0144946976,
0.0014174111,
-0.023584865,
-0.0161094461,
-0.0131535651,
-0.0080932286,
0.0465656891,
0.0564667881,
-0.0268512815,
0.0253752675,
-0.0391679332,
0.0827771351,
-0.0244382769,
0.0155397961,
0.0149453627,
-0.0470095649,
-0.0081158411,
-0.007779296,
0.0488498546,
0.0067232857,
0.0333203152,
0.0423848629,
0.0378751308,
0.0228961464,
-0.0030844153,
0.0168071203,
-0.0418936238,
-0.0567418411,
-0.0183395986,
-0.0464072935,
0.0135790482,
0.0667292699,
0.0107379341,
-0.0282636061,
-0.0722593889,
0.0085116383,
0.0006343835,
-0.0340556242,
-0.0202481654,
0.0396108106,
-0.0320943035,
0.0352343321,
0.0101117417,
-0.0491731688,
0.0165559631,
-0.0592475757,
0.0079057561,
0.0035709254,
0.0010331657,
-0.0242726523,
0.0248802919,
0.032955423,
0.0354751945,
-0.0493975841,
-0.0041496274,
-0.0764646828,
0.0266637336,
0.01288075,
-0.0065369387,
0.0108191613,
-0.0167323593,
0.0283981804,
-0.0404795855,
-0.0175422803,
-0.0123546878,
-0.0384549722,
0.0140111558,
0.0067235427,
0.0817088708,
-0.0250731092,
0.0037172791,
0.0287127048,
-0.0133202514,
0.0504788384,
0.0053565707,
-0.0022143342,
0.001364894,
0.0457672663,
0.0674787685,
-0.0031023119,
0.017530065,
-0.0183744002,
-0.0224123225,
0.0396259204,
0.02063624,
0.0303050764,
-0.0353495814,
-0.0084522087,
0.0334796198,
-0.0027599318,
0.0159975067,
0.0185243711,
0.0511260256,
-0.0281945411,
-0.0256844964,
0.0883233696,
0.0012266287,
-0.0458417423,
0.0306803919,
0.0138434153,
0.1036330983,
0.0020811066,
0.0236560944,
-0.0617956072,
-0.0088416971,
-0.0009474615,
0.0142255556,
0.0089702746,
-0.0198934264,
-0.0286111776,
-0.0930304006,
0.0091926651,
0.0119467666,
-0.0432742983,
0.0110408552,
-0.0045181001,
-0.0013498657,
-0.010446988,
0.0148975886,
0.0134398295,
-0.0279152878,
0.0014765051,
0.0260702725,
-0.0062033148,
-0.0736603662,
-0.0327525139,
0.0271957535,
0.008251193,
0.0069333934,
0.032106854,
-0.0012806377,
0.0065269191,
0.0171836931,
0.0004035552,
-0.0274904054,
-0.0288066361,
0.0181326568,
0.0238688178,
0.0049147261,
0.0364820249,
0.0064451424,
0.0006482741,
-0.0149263246,
-0.0070095467,
0.0371298306,
-0.0038565777,
-0.0394060761,
0.0098123588,
-0.011025331,
-0.0135555798,
0.0350715891,
0.0508921631,
-0.0200170353,
-0.0353619121,
-0.0246139243,
0.0038694795,
-0.0738154575,
-0.0471496955,
-0.0076695057,
0.0057459967,
-0.092878066,
-0.0386676677,
0.025953168,
0.0029261759,
0.0369729958,
-0.062206015,
-0.0277255457,
-0.0405283272,
0.0332460441,
-0.0350885428,
0.0110649383,
-0.0204845574,
-0.0200728104,
-0.0581200197,
0.0027034455,
-0.0106851356,
-0.0041022836,
-0.0224410184,
0.0140963309,
-0.1478612274,
-0.0751921311,
-0.0286557917,
0.051049985,
0.0142922504,
0.0203220677,
0.0226616152,
-0.0587636046,
0.073472783,
0.0922670364,
-0.0593755208,
0.0818355978,
0.0312307198,
-0.0691474006,
-0.0259496029,
0.0497400016,
-0.0173409656,
0.0368083417,
0.0288317688,
0.0650159195,
0.0377598442,
-0.0456073508,
0.007256093,
0.0406668819,
0.0212593824,
-0.0594576448,
0.0024161914,
-0.0311500859,
0.0113259591,
-0.0148025528,
0.0117298737,
-0.0503175259,
-0.0113346782,
0.0051910602,
0.0072988491,
-0.031938564,
-0.0100309309,
0.0154515291,
0.0260407757,
0.0092616528,
-0.0002319814,
0.0109274704,
-0.0063503985,
0.0606260002,
0.0091060596,
-0.0246246438,
-0.0348396748,
-0.0106436489,
-0.0119943414,
-0.0352828428,
-0.0031160135,
-0.0089119542,
0.0487107411,
-0.0477374159,
0.0073649217,
-0.0042819148,
-0.0598598979,
-0.0856608599,
0.0082731871,
0.0471041501,
0.0201143697,
0.0687664598,
-0.0323468484,
-0.01172846,
-0.0420675538,
0.0351319835,
0.0139945773,
-0.0070920638,
-0.0063181808,
-0.0110733565,
-0.0189782325,
-0.0008783923,
0.116650857,
0.0322917365,
0.0320351757,
-0.0157179572,
-0.0089740083,
-0.045835875,
-0.0711097494,
-0.0086893523,
0.0112849139,
0.0273089651,
-0.0011953223,
-0.0243484452,
-0.0718943402,
-0.009317589,
-0.0137732411,
0.0014574804,
-0.0156502742,
0.0394507237,
0.0201005731,
-0.0385128632,
0.0141749652,
-0.0232099034,
-0.0193171185,
-0.00870502,
-0.0295057576,
-0.0165763646,
-6.771074478e-33,
-0.0516670346,
-0.0087918052,
0.0069117863,
-0.0099764559,
-0.030838903,
0.0022414837,
-0.0309524424,
-0.0086643705,
0.0176013485,
0.0111291762,
-0.0132382913,
-0.0208186433,
-0.0039083734,
0.0557364635,
-0.0527426116,
0.0308548994,
0.0734655559,
0.0001066253,
-0.0293199196,
0.0550625473,
0.0262655262,
0.0226355512,
0.0479494818,
0.0122149112,
-0.0724700019,
0.0017677769,
-0.036115054,
-0.0202806517,
0.0217673667,
0.0206634216,
-0.0331137739,
0.0491988286,
0.0060141971,
-0.0353601277,
-0.0011766872,
-0.017276315,
-0.0534307845,
-0.0266403519,
0.0163604114,
-0.015779065,
0.0423068218,
-0.0339866877,
0.0099259736,
0.0077529168,
-0.0188068952,
-0.0671912059,
0.000941358,
0.0019488746,
-0.0552397966,
-0.0862805918,
-0.0603657551,
0.0331943221,
-0.0010044804,
-0.0221316796,
-0.0093701696,
0.0377519242,
-0.0344712324,
0.0213711672,
-0.0166631788,
-0.0148313455,
0.0463869534,
0.0851337463,
0.0440319441,
0.0214635152,
0.0020557304,
0.0033400368,
-0.0455238707,
0.009258505,
-0.0064507057,
0.0507903136,
0.0536536425,
0.0091490075,
0.0084120659,
0.0631934851,
0.042287007,
-0.0340450853,
-0.0974582583,
0.0297960248,
-0.0509832352,
0.0430078879,
0.0578072332,
0.0373141728,
0.0454538427,
-0.0203225743,
-0.0235825125,
0.0031185239,
-0.0220664293,
-0.0262721274,
0.022466369,
0.0359775387,
-0.0448354222,
-0.0323793925,
0.0438111313,
-0.0316343829,
-0.0036007834,
0.0329783559,
-0.0412012972,
-0.0007035309,
-0.0115472497,
0.0290756226,
-0.000689539,
-0.0345463715,
0.017634308,
-0.0090656728,
0.003658388,
-0.0180657972,
0.0254133698,
0.0363307931,
-0.0676428527,
-0.0065868194,
-0.032721024,
0.032426551,
0.0227396116,
0.0649524927,
0.0167346541,
-0.024899587,
0.0088059371,
0.0579770952,
0.0068058646,
-0.011056548,
-0.0169803314,
-0.005359726,
0.0343258679,
0.0552102923,
-0.0375373922,
0.0085088024,
-0.0092238961,
-0.0079578934,
0.0492724925,
-0.0563527904,
-0.0402038619,
-0.0130803706,
2.891e-7,
0.0354629084,
-0.0123938425,
-0.0220856573,
0.0058578853,
-0.0173266698,
-0.0146146948,
0.0258531179,
0.0323843099,
-0.0189554859,
0.029061988,
0.0489391871,
0.0037432092,
0.0675703287,
0.0102909962,
-0.0608945861,
0.0085849734,
-0.0667496249,
0.0114699984,
-0.0470717028,
-0.0451247469,
-0.0090783834,
0.0698548332,
-0.025393581,
-0.011316848,
0.0202698763,
0.0032359043,
0.053126134,
-0.02325093,
0.0142898485,
0.0301344171,
0.0792089999,
-0.0245738178,
0.008540865,
-0.0554860979,
-0.0216910131,
-0.0041445387,
-0.0225428008,
0.0850143805,
-0.0160051994,
-0.0350700691,
0.0506550968,
0.0051903073,
-0.0174535625,
-0.0509128831,
0.0419545919,
-0.0437055677,
0.0007068759,
-0.0190574434,
0.0039723506,
-0.0096596265,
0.0021574968,
-0.0553561188,
0.0089088734,
0.0236613601,
0.0468017086,
0.0145187639,
-0.0276065096,
-0.0585678704,
-0.0070289336,
0.0443612784,
-0.0745711774,
-0.0443428718,
-0.0343549252,
0.0079412069,
0.0377396643,
-0.0283024609,
0.0072453716,
2.723700997e-34,
0.016335465,
-0.0102729006,
-0.0141088534,
0.0090807527,
0.0430534072,
-0.011480324,
0.0458645187,
0.0309585892,
-0.0264693238,
-0.0770094395,
-0.0450898968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09494v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09494v1 | Computational analyses of linguistic features with schizophrenic and autistic traits along with formal thought disorders | 2023-10-14T05:05:11 | 2023-10-14T05:05:11 | Takeshi Saga, Hiroki Tanaka, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL, J.4; J.3; I.2.1; I.2.7 | [See full abstract in the pdf] Formal Thought Disorder (FTD), which is a
group of symptoms in cognition that affects language and thought, can be
observed through language. FTD is seen across such developmental or psychiatric
disorders as Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) or Schizophrenia, and its related
Schizotypal Personality Disorder (SPD). This paper collected a Japanese
audio-report dataset with score labels related to ASD and SPD through a
crowd-sourcing service from the general population. We measured language
characteristics with the 2nd edition of the Social Responsiveness Scale (SRS2)
and the Schizotypal Personality Questionnaire (SPQ), including an odd speech
subscale from SPQ to quantify the FTD symptoms. We investigated the following
four research questions through machine-learning-based score predictions: (RQ1)
How are schizotypal and autistic measures correlated? (RQ2) What is the most
suitable task to elicit FTD symptoms? (RQ3) Does the length of speech affect
the elicitation of FTD symptoms? (RQ4) Which features are critical for
capturing FTD symptoms? We confirmed that an FTD-related subscale, odd speech,
was significantly correlated with both the total SPQ and SRS scores, although
they themselves were not correlated significantly. Our regression analysis
indicated that longer speech about a negative memory elicited more FTD
symptoms. The ablation study confirmed the importance of function words and
both the abstract and temporal features for FTD-related odd speech estimation.
In contrast, content words were effective only in the SRS predictions, and
content words were effective only in the SPQ predictions, a result that implies
the differences between SPD-like and ASD-like symptoms. Data and programs used
in this paper can be found here:
https://sites.google.com/view/sagatake/resource. | [
0.0156634245,
0.0222606976,
-0.0471209623,
-0.0140625918,
-0.0080585368,
-0.0033323083,
0.0321288109,
0.0127245076,
-0.0140132718,
-0.0013122475,
-0.0266482364,
-0.0208463836,
0.0143194646,
0.062038023,
-0.0301204715,
-0.0586525276,
0.0323988348,
0.0021044591,
0.0785216987,
-0.0233162399,
0.0059485207,
0.0097997421,
-0.0159114674,
0.0319626555,
-0.0088454811,
-0.0134286303,
0.041976843,
-0.0175949913,
0.0158434603,
-0.034745045,
-0.0282840114,
0.0813071281,
-0.0153896399,
0.0272691455,
0.0000018923,
-0.0735101774,
0.0188753046,
-0.0252773035,
0.0372979827,
-0.009766886,
-0.0142777702,
0.0379699282,
0.0226992071,
0.0497903116,
-0.0651887506,
-0.0187837593,
0.0287091434,
0.1074920595,
0.022113258,
-0.0095006349,
-0.0281757284,
-0.0344820321,
0.0275325663,
-0.00130067,
0.003107239,
0.0205084253,
0.0330233276,
-0.0372096859,
0.0023599206,
-0.0228838138,
-0.0335184447,
0.0217880569,
-0.0247935485,
0.013209004,
0.0005981285,
-0.0584567823,
-0.0615167916,
-0.0450586565,
0.0349396951,
0.0614596717,
0.1079121679,
-0.0055444292,
-0.0056578377,
0.0321539491,
0.0014560627,
0.0189283751,
-0.0166145936,
-0.010022738,
-0.0148295891,
-0.0016977899,
0.0436091237,
0.0124563593,
-0.0255514774,
-0.039214544,
0.0357618779,
0.0851024017,
-0.0302605778,
-0.0230253302,
0.0235980675,
-0.0499306321,
-0.0388302021,
-0.0628459677,
0.0348595306,
0.01094284,
-0.0371977389,
0.0029553131,
-0.0398972295,
-0.0952535644,
0.0319736302,
-0.0447795726,
0.0241594203,
0.010452088,
-0.0370214209,
-0.0211754497,
0.0165669415,
0.0614599288,
0.0176795628,
0.0351021923,
-0.0488824472,
0.0339139178,
-0.0582300723,
-0.0142169194,
-0.0173325408,
0.024354741,
0.0411407724,
-0.0300026275,
-0.0733819455,
0.0080398628,
-0.0134889008,
-0.0446455963,
0.0099125719,
0.0130262375,
0.0375738628,
0.0424773321,
-0.0090248315,
0.0013071265,
-0.0925400406,
0.0347579382,
-0.0164162312,
-0.0132618519,
0.0574869588,
-0.0001519472,
0.0170409735,
0.0039754598,
0.0209566969,
0.0168789476,
0.0624386296,
-0.0063760146,
0.0100787291,
-0.0191846024,
-0.0641856194,
-0.0395634957,
0.0043560159,
-0.0304895267,
-0.0066242591,
0.0356162526,
-0.0212455336,
-0.0405028537,
-0.0094221067,
-0.0015768729,
-0.0052046366,
0.0138679622,
-0.0130205611,
0.0187063552,
0.0127584096,
-0.0015189047,
0.0244931076,
0.0129146362,
0.0403354503,
-0.0702902451,
0.0016537297,
-0.076774992,
0.0154754166,
0.0033608172,
0.0022534863,
-0.0494023152,
-0.0091899345,
-0.0030340133,
0.0015132132,
0.0203464571,
0.0385641791,
0.0129238721,
0.0364451446,
0.0012703902,
0.03292742,
0.0782044455,
-0.0059661367,
0.0049546361,
0.004614146,
0.0201899093,
0.0232031364,
0.0025954237,
-0.0076835672,
0.0360217765,
-0.0304590985,
0.0016680046,
-0.0048342249,
-0.0075133736,
-0.0202190727,
-0.0399899371,
-0.054170087,
0.0036539966,
0.0017076064,
0.0621686205,
-0.0090006767,
0.0055894339,
0.0239922162,
-0.0063871318,
0.011527082,
0.0080826757,
-0.0363853127,
-0.0505285114,
-0.0177887976,
0.0516415276,
0.0018104846,
-0.031863261,
0.0085034892,
-0.022466613,
-0.0375492461,
0.039485313,
-0.0133421952,
0.0230604988,
-0.0243802331,
0.0317015275,
0.0168760791,
0.0535993278,
0.0127064157,
-0.0230784658,
0.0071554617,
0.0387180559,
-0.013473914,
-0.0082148137,
-0.0022935774,
0.0255034473,
-0.0278916284,
-0.048092287,
-0.0022918654,
-0.0007583182,
0.0478590541,
0.0098423716,
-0.0063822898,
0.0191277619,
-0.0046167085,
0.0342710502,
-0.0293295272,
0.0234312043,
-0.0386496894,
-0.0152722932,
-0.0354581103,
0.0093232887,
0.0395361446,
0.0618270338,
0.0580338314,
-0.019855991,
0.046867609,
-0.0928581208,
0.0107681192,
-0.0287731458,
0.0488710217,
-0.0418081135,
0.1024142131,
-0.012157646,
0.0154885808,
-0.0105488943,
0.0321187638,
-0.0437769592,
-0.1187806427,
0.0183148831,
-0.0251567978,
-0.0531052351,
-0.0427915268,
-0.0459648483,
0.0207289699,
-0.0222816337,
-0.0429137535,
-0.0254645906,
0.0328327194,
-0.108928971,
-0.0127406744,
0.0308344252,
-0.0072782002,
-0.0390072688,
-0.0111743677,
-0.0430427752,
-0.0123833427,
0.0140853096,
0.0259173624,
0.0506119505,
0.0670345128,
-0.008461508,
0.0150468154,
-0.0673286095,
-0.0434934869,
0.0000437712,
-0.0397932082,
0.0027875826,
-0.0254581068,
-0.0429259278,
-0.0016161894,
0.0151448101,
-0.1301060468,
-0.0069816299,
-0.0164059792,
-0.0341902375,
0.0218766127,
0.0458682701,
0.0193410553,
0.0346934646,
0.0302512068,
0.0186950061,
0.0411834531,
-0.0170918126,
-0.0242383294,
-0.0167664159,
0.0059539569,
0.0296570696,
-0.0527578443,
-0.0724550709,
0.0147530958,
0.083950229,
0.0719021931,
0.0110175433,
-0.0287263859,
-0.0120134009,
-0.0080039632,
-0.0457683057,
0.065080598,
-0.0617122911,
-0.0489577614,
0.0628742203,
0.0188009199,
-0.0391415656,
0.0515649319,
-0.0131423939,
0.0024805034,
-0.00293979,
-0.0254202932,
0.0100100599,
0.0397243239,
0.0068283547,
0.026312558,
-0.000320569,
-0.0157586485,
-0.0125497738,
-0.0326101705,
0.0105099203,
-0.0542958677,
-0.0247787479,
-0.0181938149,
-0.0077857133,
0.0351420864,
0.0121202739,
-0.0324234813,
-0.0080110654,
-0.0076812999,
-0.0221208334,
-0.0164426025,
-0.037539795,
-0.0047340849,
-0.0406651981,
0.0280004293,
0.0183851328,
0.0081431018,
-0.0166967064,
0.0448576361,
-0.0188970938,
0.0718895644,
-0.0044246176,
0.024691144,
-0.0127550447,
-0.0068214592,
0.0122553892,
-0.0147070019,
0.0664857104,
0.027533412,
-0.002409247,
-0.006487106,
0.0284575857,
-0.0127975009,
0.0406026281,
0.0491895378,
0.0163476244,
-0.0027038723,
0.1104842871,
0.0481264554,
0.0134908305,
0.0207082853,
-0.0329773687,
-0.0016051307,
0.0201160591,
-0.0082489187,
0.0237860586,
-0.0019655139,
0.0103062578,
0.0152830817,
-0.0793890059,
-0.0573001467,
-0.0230491608,
-0.0035343263,
-0.0013014912,
-0.0405521058,
-0.0600676835,
-0.0136028128,
0.0041643432,
0.0278170183,
0.0687310249,
0.0127322348,
-0.0592661574,
-0.0191470701,
-0.0100623565,
-0.0069577857,
-0.1275323778,
-0.0096987551,
0.1036337465,
0.0026595015,
0.0963386968,
0.0203461107,
0.0242456179,
-0.0182893164,
-0.0418382734,
-0.0621888526,
0.0423547477,
0.0110790394,
-0.0129647078,
0.0350678116,
0.0442817807,
0.0284385532,
-0.08634267,
0.0218173359,
-0.0296877343,
0.0229179729,
-0.0074878805,
0.0830765963,
-0.0141292913,
-0.0661626533,
-0.0247471742,
0.056688264,
-0.0010393924,
0.0551035143,
0.0186139178,
-0.0799636766,
0.0057495348,
0.0465367995,
-0.000858069,
-0.0300250854,
-0.0065684039,
-0.018025022,
0.0382917598,
-0.0240263771,
-0.096688062,
-0.0650818199,
0.0227881204,
0.000339035,
0.0073420443,
-0.0119764153,
-0.0216213465,
0.0122193415,
-0.0760020763,
0.0326993056,
0.0705268681,
0.0076769884,
-0.0143705523,
0.0072556064,
0.0086854687,
-0.0171049889,
-0.0538055636,
0.0133379856,
-0.0428923331,
-0.0505249426,
0.1143409684,
-0.0316530429,
0.0128468079,
-0.0030705938,
0.0278527681,
-0.0339586176,
0.0300695561,
0.0099356808,
-0.0129619148,
0.0554727539,
0.0031280811,
-0.0148327099,
0.0108011207,
0.0510670505,
0.0233563203,
0.0216815099,
0.0175133981,
-0.0200018771,
-0.0117158452,
-0.0124757113,
-0.0168321971,
0.0234728735,
0.0456339717,
-0.0120142447,
-0.0163238551,
-0.00776006,
-0.0440649316,
0.0001386959,
0.0075875176,
-0.0168031398,
-0.0630194023,
0.0392720327,
0.025131382,
-0.0307401642,
-0.0402961187,
-0.0689751729,
-0.0338901132,
0.0238205176,
0.0088420752,
-0.0292616505,
0.0103940871,
-0.0194994062,
0.0333311483,
0.0107095297,
0.0324857086,
0.009638207,
0.009160365,
0.0220022816,
0.0719656646,
-0.0183243584,
0.013089885,
0.0117125493,
0.0131367445,
0.0157043133,
-0.0779665336,
-0.0254414976,
-0.0087804198,
-0.0458744243,
0.0243015606,
0.0158250798,
-0.009067229,
0.040942505,
-0.0391682349,
0.0360262915,
-0.034273047,
-0.0368056856,
0.0325556472,
0.0147755481,
-0.0039902795,
-0.0311980993,
0.0280579776,
-0.0070487256,
-0.0600193068,
-0.0194644798,
-0.0223048907,
-0.0369647667,
0.0023026769,
-0.0354421958,
0.0175816324,
-0.0370733291,
0.0102835484,
-0.0543584898,
-0.0828195438,
0.0479510315,
-0.0497272462,
-0.0230883006,
0.0035685557,
-0.0075159492,
0.0391059481,
-0.0329217538,
-0.0440720469,
0.000207803,
-0.035379447,
-0.0074476362,
-0.0298628137,
0.0039550653,
-5.610184543e-33,
-0.0555203967,
-0.0475042984,
0.0241204351,
0.0347456746,
-0.0118408399,
-0.0345052369,
-0.0239838082,
0.0532046482,
-0.0439348742,
0.0135144461,
0.0042782356,
0.0333324075,
0.0186796263,
0.003430468,
0.0109548764,
-0.0155531857,
-0.0198859405,
0.0060037998,
-0.0108934212,
-0.0168927778,
0.0227976665,
0.0096030375,
0.1169494465,
-0.0149418768,
0.0445452631,
0.0126152616,
0.0341602638,
-0.0255419724,
0.033121001,
-0.0014990298,
-0.0230006743,
0.049324438,
0.0435195528,
0.0319239274,
0.0147786392,
0.0208224505,
-0.0414256081,
-0.0491388775,
0.0375673883,
0.044640705,
-0.0364179574,
0.0389869399,
-0.0086923577,
-0.026724292,
-0.0465764292,
-0.0234089121,
0.067782402,
-0.0209603142,
0.0314647965,
0.015177846,
-0.0432818793,
-0.0270021148,
0.0126472674,
0.0185434427,
-0.0258424617,
0.0567766875,
-0.039610453,
-0.0084033292,
-0.0301334653,
0.0293902624,
-0.0459067151,
0.0018460293,
0.0108568296,
0.0046319109,
0.0288894828,
0.0551045649,
0.068558909,
-0.0331711769,
-0.0099928686,
0.022758726,
0.0616402924,
-0.0005697772,
0.0514332019,
0.0192706082,
0.0493032336,
-0.0510913804,
0.0021851365,
-0.0392344929,
0.0142962858,
-0.0140067646,
0.0367323793,
-0.0403896049,
-0.0340868309,
-0.011850344,
-0.0359774679,
0.0555164143,
-0.0100593138,
-0.0187863391,
0.0341498591,
-0.044858411,
-0.0004143391,
-0.0197196342,
0.0595943332,
0.0081843603,
-0.0006584638,
-0.0214001294,
-0.0044199056,
0.0389239825,
0.0304922033,
0.0087055666,
0.0417377688,
0.0219584275,
0.0353763364,
-0.0060483632,
0.0735180303,
-0.0302226134,
0.0152321002,
-0.0121762613,
-0.0495082289,
0.0132314684,
-0.0014477206,
0.023131609,
0.0122880973,
0.0366144963,
-0.0110126864,
0.0578366183,
-0.0409390777,
-0.0452990383,
0.0015580606,
0.0226903558,
-0.0848310143,
-0.0004892294,
-0.0238346551,
-0.0245576855,
0.0215233956,
-0.0243995003,
-0.0128621571,
-0.0408000462,
-0.0093158316,
-0.0378632732,
0.0069468641,
-0.0088340994,
2.831e-7,
0.016001232,
0.0880438685,
-0.0253982041,
0.0317488685,
0.0127565917,
0.0179522317,
0.0223060977,
0.0291242395,
0.0560000986,
0.0035012546,
-0.0136144003,
0.0259970017,
0.0535589643,
0.0577740408,
-0.0297750011,
-0.0153944548,
-0.0455013812,
0.0147386231,
-0.0645045713,
-0.007933571,
0.0203997456,
0.0208514575,
-0.0011696503,
-0.0523411296,
0.0267979484,
-0.0128158657,
0.0029602319,
0.0190225057,
0.0263085123,
0.026442958,
-0.0291220993,
-0.0388568491,
0.0498242043,
0.0407184847,
0.007184742,
0.0062889308,
-0.0130367801,
-0.0334829502,
-0.0549304597,
-0.0431606136,
-0.0139132468,
0.0356447585,
-0.0261351354,
-0.0177643485,
0.0377732292,
0.0129587576,
-0.0291940793,
0.0310085155,
-0.0313430242,
-0.0043321354,
0.0820622817,
-0.0000612729,
0.0410227329,
0.0223385412,
0.0343598761,
-0.0290013589,
0.0239691194,
-0.0225463323,
0.0064732893,
0.0247457456,
-0.0582543164,
0.0015229434,
-0.0039336244,
0.028323222,
0.0127111785,
-0.0626382977,
0.0432367846,
2.2723254e-34,
0.0065470906,
0.074053362,
0.0237467177,
-0.0396411084,
0.0066526043,
0.0091440305,
-0.0307615083,
0.0211506542,
-0.012608815,
-0.0571832173,
0.0176019091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10683v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10683v2 | Large Language Model Unlearning | 2023-10-14T00:32:55 | 2024-02-16T19:47:36 | Yuanshun Yao, Xiaojun Xu, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We study how to perform unlearning, i.e. forgetting undesirable misbehaviors,
on large language models (LLMs). We show at least three scenarios of aligning
LLMs with human preferences can benefit from unlearning: (1) removing harmful
responses, (2) erasing copyright-protected content as requested, and (3)
reducing hallucinations. Unlearning, as an alignment technique, has three
advantages. (1) It only requires negative (e.g. harmful) examples, which are
much easier and cheaper to collect (e.g. via red teaming or user reporting)
than positive (e.g. helpful and often human-written) examples required in RLHF
(RL from human feedback). (2) It is computationally efficient. (3) It is
especially effective when we know which training samples cause the misbehavior.
To the best of our knowledge, our work is among the first to explore LLM
unlearning. We are also among the first to formulate the settings, goals, and
evaluations in LLM unlearning. We show that if practitioners only have limited
resources, and therefore the priority is to stop generating undesirable outputs
rather than to try to generate desirable outputs, unlearning is particularly
appealing. Despite only having negative samples, our ablation study shows that
unlearning can still achieve better alignment performance than RLHF with just
2% of its computational time. | [
0.0460449755,
0.0524739325,
-0.0306966808,
0.0283598304,
-0.0645318851,
0.0202711467,
0.0023888014,
0.0160660576,
0.0026922952,
-0.0395616032,
-0.0280441958,
-0.0334489904,
-0.0126020191,
-0.0169530828,
-0.0008975639,
-0.0513546504,
0.0542744435,
-0.0354570374,
0.010023227,
-0.0189860146,
0.0482961684,
-0.0093152756,
0.0005740333,
0.0267257243,
0.00139851,
-0.0358684734,
-0.0178401936,
0.0024190189,
0.0123633537,
0.0131411888,
0.008480872,
0.0552404858,
0.0070310952,
0.0725676119,
0.0000018763,
-0.0693290234,
-0.0358891934,
-0.0008457222,
-0.0030380159,
0.047370486,
0.0424963906,
0.0152594429,
-0.033222124,
0.047499124,
-0.0119287129,
0.0184184629,
0.0566092692,
0.0394370183,
0.0680106208,
0.0697214082,
0.0098491153,
0.0040564062,
-0.0112975203,
0.0027442621,
0.0168803148,
0.0097697461,
0.0493316688,
-0.0253225658,
-0.0146395257,
-0.0523380339,
-0.0203817487,
0.0372929312,
-0.0008666731,
-0.0129355006,
-0.0094701443,
-0.0032944679,
-0.0631991252,
-0.0460486524,
0.0017985952,
0.0580305941,
-0.0179559924,
-0.04491603,
0.0292082056,
0.004703274,
0.0096224481,
-0.0049917633,
-0.0246739574,
0.0177513789,
-0.0168258063,
0.0285236649,
-0.0176753178,
-0.0530569442,
0.055075068,
0.0175227337,
0.0341246799,
0.0533332117,
0.0101729631,
-0.0560407788,
-0.00254037,
-0.0021064165,
0.0160743296,
-0.0411776379,
-0.0007834794,
0.0061408109,
-0.0406220481,
0.034684632,
-0.0349565595,
-0.0237575974,
0.0480911508,
-0.0610633492,
0.0230271127,
0.0129119717,
0.01256108,
0.0384882316,
-0.0040352345,
0.0458225571,
-0.0124522792,
0.0447060838,
-0.0150161879,
0.0261422358,
-0.0154875983,
-0.0087710973,
-0.0108821597,
0.0436462387,
0.0453583747,
0.0275025032,
-0.0378256664,
0.0307931378,
-0.0429983512,
0.0475369953,
-0.0195345636,
-0.0129022133,
-0.0235990304,
-0.0082182121,
-0.0394148603,
0.0319758467,
-0.0191030409,
-0.0065257028,
0.0080267759,
-0.0449240021,
0.0113086412,
0.0011629629,
-0.0190215576,
-0.012685122,
0.0163962506,
0.0706500858,
0.0064386637,
-0.0016776032,
-0.0371803716,
-0.0295351539,
-0.0099863997,
-0.0530623123,
-0.0197855439,
-0.0795145109,
-0.011450191,
-0.0033536891,
-0.0280569196,
-0.0655331612,
0.002149536,
0.006144946,
-0.0674889982,
0.0574763231,
-0.031223977,
0.0144526567,
0.014650221,
0.0039266543,
-0.0080682514,
0.0592156276,
-0.0105934925,
0.0277896728,
0.0296204295,
-0.0462673269,
0.0612788238,
0.0568736345,
0.0228699371,
0.0142187867,
-0.0360218212,
-0.0168959312,
0.0300702751,
0.0231562667,
0.0227709617,
0.0847847387,
-0.0104371952,
-0.0318544731,
0.0739264488,
0.0250165612,
-0.0300448276,
0.030268535,
-0.0152153736,
0.0050336216,
-0.0174493231,
0.0475622863,
-0.0760992244,
-0.0014378804,
-0.0594611801,
0.012796564,
0.0177128538,
0.0300171971,
-0.0345198959,
-0.0372843519,
-0.0321308449,
-0.013007313,
0.0357747413,
0.0268637817,
0.0543931723,
0.0174923241,
-0.0410450473,
0.0344222896,
0.0602242947,
-0.0600899048,
0.019299088,
-0.0508152321,
0.0571219921,
0.0577156357,
0.0855328888,
-0.0464806333,
-0.0038929498,
-0.0441646688,
-0.019681897,
0.0224177334,
0.0548084229,
-0.0134970676,
-0.0116697829,
-0.0469418913,
-0.040675234,
0.0538188964,
-0.01604742,
-0.0022301874,
0.021166075,
-0.0609973036,
-0.0271623265,
0.0000976417,
-0.0935446024,
0.0293912143,
0.00013147,
-0.0302800536,
-0.028821433,
0.0239785444,
0.0549857765,
0.005302045,
-0.0169218797,
-0.0100394264,
0.0332526416,
0.0047671641,
-0.0248250086,
-0.0146347769,
-0.0285961591,
0.0003541597,
0.066874072,
-0.0298096463,
-0.0152252764,
0.0841323435,
-0.0204425398,
0.0089537194,
0.0025040584,
-0.0163033679,
0.0639348775,
-0.0177245531,
0.0689194798,
-0.050887052,
-0.0309148896,
-0.0528637245,
0.0442871302,
-0.0227871146,
0.0189020056,
-0.0340121612,
-0.0512573682,
-0.0058570788,
-0.0196681414,
-0.07418859,
0.0142782703,
-0.024276603,
0.0447574332,
0.0551468432,
-0.0204245131,
-0.0468144082,
-0.0123441685,
-0.0419601798,
-0.0050812582,
-0.0153683377,
0.001792419,
0.0315608606,
0.0019406393,
-0.0016558281,
-0.0193769801,
-0.0400511026,
-0.0140445884,
0.0268140268,
0.0504263937,
0.0170340613,
-0.0127027715,
-0.0646644533,
-0.0325890183,
-0.0052467003,
-0.0066136555,
0.0129417777,
-0.0084437318,
-0.0282591134,
-0.0426473767,
0.07973966,
-0.0472762547,
0.0398009419,
-0.0012760576,
-0.0660633445,
0.0041438327,
0.008323852,
0.0161279123,
0.072240375,
0.0066652107,
0.0477777496,
0.0877762511,
0.0457103401,
-0.0733132809,
0.00062778,
-0.035511598,
-0.0731443539,
-0.0263295844,
-0.0336521901,
0.002237079,
0.0472093076,
0.02098733,
0.006565751,
-0.04566928,
-0.0091087325,
-0.0222143959,
-0.0570922494,
-0.0365065075,
-0.0712313056,
-0.0400036871,
0.0038058711,
-0.0215676297,
-0.0980902612,
0.0736185014,
0.0018955501,
0.0267142318,
-0.0264217257,
0.0075240401,
0.0168434139,
0.0248108171,
0.0021565696,
0.0529029146,
0.0092439884,
-0.0332934745,
-0.027049955,
-0.0480575636,
0.0551993847,
-0.042487625,
0.0332121812,
-0.0486661382,
0.0061692977,
-0.0025921622,
-0.0636245236,
-0.0666119978,
-0.0657639876,
0.0106371371,
-0.0330351517,
0.0025489877,
0.0053387824,
-0.0333541036,
-0.0208690576,
0.0503642224,
-0.0138857448,
0.008292906,
0.0059744585,
0.0090031875,
-0.0055526583,
0.059995912,
-0.0295156073,
0.0183312185,
-0.0381325036,
-0.0047753854,
0.081373468,
0.0596643873,
0.0031946281,
0.0323188715,
-0.0143416664,
0.0295048077,
-0.0214781966,
-0.0013293817,
0.0424191356,
0.0413159281,
-0.0124020856,
-0.0125143416,
0.0902545303,
0.0380327888,
-0.0650944039,
-0.0039545479,
-0.0117524769,
0.0527353063,
0.0104966983,
0.0074723805,
-0.0550298356,
0.0038417212,
0.0113113141,
0.0320668034,
-0.0336314924,
-0.0259180535,
0.0257422179,
-0.1384620816,
0.0020662169,
0.0472308882,
-0.0534617044,
-0.0285357311,
-0.0038628562,
0.0048265746,
-0.007357758,
0.0431889147,
0.0133921867,
0.005859158,
-0.0167338364,
0.0485310517,
-0.0471678749,
-0.0361878946,
-0.0119416723,
-0.0681816638,
0.0850505829,
0.0789589584,
0.0127537847,
-0.0169144291,
-0.0513526723,
0.0143368477,
0.0417487286,
0.0117019815,
-0.0025629248,
0.0530709438,
0.0167933237,
-0.0079179732,
-0.0415131748,
0.0419277623,
-0.0024755597,
-0.0150005026,
0.0109330928,
0.0863871947,
0.0090093138,
-0.0056797331,
-0.0052968655,
-0.0120868366,
0.0231252052,
0.0875589177,
0.0096577546,
-0.0715725124,
-0.0185408369,
-0.0222305134,
-0.0223138165,
0.0081275916,
-0.0327170156,
0.006519415,
-0.0132167712,
-0.0017376398,
-0.0531949028,
-0.0227023754,
0.0067518512,
0.02880322,
0.0425441675,
0.0142212929,
0.0064276573,
0.0147792753,
0.0048583965,
-0.020163713,
-0.0272960532,
0.0024437991,
-0.0696515366,
-0.001204184,
-0.0316095389,
0.0042490214,
0.008886192,
0.0043049315,
-0.068297334,
-0.1014076248,
0.0572186001,
0.0586311705,
0.0324323475,
0.0535143837,
0.0131467795,
-0.0647408962,
0.0313752107,
0.0505858622,
-0.0145089645,
0.0247740205,
0.0164248329,
-0.0179739632,
0.0015380161,
0.0347327292,
-0.0312412996,
-0.0223981775,
0.0738850608,
-0.0113502368,
-0.0550469458,
-0.013879437,
0.0313296206,
0.0404777266,
0.0290451106,
-0.0351450257,
-0.0141896065,
-0.0083674965,
-0.0047014933,
0.0006135575,
-0.0405585915,
0.0049553104,
-0.0024576169,
0.0394547433,
-0.0094651869,
0.006636105,
0.0128461095,
-0.0263913479,
0.018592583,
-0.0241596717,
-0.0062845093,
0.0140554467,
0.014643224,
0.0585179664,
0.0270929839,
-0.0273198597,
0.0251130126,
0.0338246115,
0.0470636636,
0.0125256348,
0.0567950681,
0.0133057144,
0.0292006787,
-0.0009562523,
0.0097066844,
-0.0087677659,
-0.0644356608,
-0.0257396065,
-0.0047233263,
0.041358389,
0.0003009505,
0.0501267463,
-0.0087509798,
-0.0164999422,
-0.0361605622,
0.0233960841,
-0.0122022908,
-0.0428979099,
0.0033435004,
0.0182842519,
-0.045003213,
0.0115747163,
0.0581842847,
-0.0383112915,
0.0296039768,
-0.0153829809,
-0.0219646655,
-0.0412161201,
-0.0217597764,
0.033665292,
-0.0041216826,
-0.0332017913,
-0.0264821574,
-0.0628260896,
-0.0654503107,
-0.0248944443,
0.0150709907,
0.0204655044,
-0.0350465588,
0.0174069144,
0.0579386279,
-0.0262325574,
0.0110172573,
-0.0530873947,
0.012950018,
-0.0191572476,
-0.0326572992,
-0.0250755008,
-5.809481896e-33,
0.0000012927,
-0.020930808,
-0.0127783958,
0.0159765389,
0.0009819202,
-0.0366505086,
0.0117128156,
0.0287405327,
-0.0113388104,
0.0066074715,
-0.0045412341,
-0.0216292925,
0.0039749672,
-0.0081710145,
0.0080381073,
-0.0159828905,
0.0552716777,
-0.0198939014,
-0.0497404225,
0.0172581933,
0.0531771928,
0.0189924743,
0.0354253203,
-0.100819543,
0.0101730777,
-0.0219990909,
-0.0365460515,
0.0378024094,
-0.031841442,
0.056181334,
-0.0151916137,
0.0438339189,
-0.0040074307,
-0.030926466,
-0.0135954721,
0.0221785791,
-0.0385385603,
0.0035348025,
0.0337387994,
0.0206943434,
-0.0148971286,
-0.0174697302,
0.0595413856,
-0.0149261141,
-0.0566976592,
0.0072030276,
0.0289279167,
-0.0001258615,
-0.0490266755,
0.0126820365,
-0.0628010035,
-0.0077332612,
-0.0140843494,
-0.0310998075,
0.005490745,
0.0303222891,
-0.0116411764,
0.0005690882,
-0.0873311535,
0.0201736782,
0.0320979543,
0.0028425825,
0.0924794003,
0.0212912653,
0.0057271887,
0.099146083,
0.0181796439,
0.0259786248,
0.0309765879,
-0.0243571252,
0.0361986123,
0.0156200202,
0.0265204348,
0.0650607869,
0.0277945511,
-0.0415416248,
-0.0260756575,
0.0266113319,
0.0040734098,
0.0222984888,
0.0341302864,
0.0367376134,
-0.0644472241,
-0.0360607579,
-0.0241212901,
-0.0137466341,
-0.0311642811,
-0.046838887,
0.0343848132,
-0.0033123156,
-0.0323739462,
-0.0176480059,
0.0255134702,
-0.0364951454,
-0.0245852619,
0.0474938639,
0.0009203394,
0.0054230331,
-0.0127271432,
-0.0270684026,
-0.0750077367,
-0.0051844129,
-0.0395188443,
-0.0222164337,
0.0229776539,
0.0095017813,
0.0667358339,
0.0460758135,
-0.0760650858,
0.0352980122,
-0.0406193398,
0.0475097634,
0.032517869,
0.001270854,
0.0381749645,
-0.0050394475,
0.0031212417,
0.0203744527,
0.0366120636,
-0.0241041128,
-0.0705938116,
0.0128824813,
-0.0154212061,
-0.0227453057,
-0.0165306218,
-0.0244110301,
-0.0025952845,
0.0329771861,
0.0621676184,
-0.0388102755,
0.0029517252,
-0.0284550376,
2.585e-7,
-0.0098886043,
0.0246710256,
0.0480335355,
-0.0043503908,
0.0150428684,
0.0747778267,
-0.0192097295,
0.0488644876,
0.0396402515,
0.0227081589,
0.0258559678,
-0.0028504801,
0.0518548116,
0.0384487994,
-0.0621052645,
-0.0111782039,
-0.07154838,
-0.0130145056,
-0.0471942164,
-0.007790545,
0.0265435278,
0.0811396837,
0.0501339324,
-0.0371407643,
0.0125866737,
-0.0362845957,
0.0407729819,
-0.0540698804,
-0.0384299792,
0.0089575127,
0.0098862834,
-0.0110942256,
0.0052639134,
-0.0097177131,
0.0032361019,
-0.0314290375,
-0.0335456058,
0.0625974461,
-0.0030074292,
-0.0425630063,
-0.0214733146,
0.0155383414,
0.000077293,
-0.0451557189,
0.0471671596,
0.0102887247,
-0.0109850792,
-0.0097360294,
0.0154080475,
-0.0511109382,
0.023146851,
-0.0027823073,
-0.0111652361,
0.0266483389,
0.0109864036,
0.0183825307,
-0.0274706222,
-0.0543983132,
-0.0317951366,
-0.0048324135,
-0.0291465465,
-0.0596950948,
0.0031521753,
0.0478019454,
-0.0227577556,
-0.0710099488,
0.0494219102,
2.344419938e-34,
0.0053898995,
-0.0296778474,
0.0448781475,
0.00066701,
0.0138389301,
0.0231502987,
0.0218526088,
0.0357376263,
0.0324412808,
-0.0306386929,
0.0093668038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09436v1 | Sub-network Discovery and Soft-masking for Continual Learning of Mixed Tasks | 2023-10-13T23:00:39 | 2023-10-13T23:00:39 | Zixuan Ke, Bing Liu, Wenhan Xiong, Asli Celikyilmaz, Haoran Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Continual learning (CL) has two main objectives: preventing catastrophic
forgetting (CF) and encouraging knowledge transfer (KT). The existing
literature mainly focused on overcoming CF. Some work has also been done on KT
when the tasks are similar. To our knowledge, only one method has been proposed
to learn a sequence of mixed tasks. However, these techniques still suffer from
CF and/or limited KT. This paper proposes a new CL method to achieve both. It
overcomes CF by isolating the knowledge of each task via discovering a
subnetwork for it. A soft-masking mechanism is also proposed to preserve the
previous knowledge and to enable the new task to leverage the past knowledge to
achieve KT. Experiments using classification, generation, information
extraction, and their mixture (i.e., heterogeneous tasks) show that the
proposed method consistently outperforms strong baselines. | [
-0.0463673063,
0.0290025007,
-0.0358728096,
0.0096180728,
-0.0361086503,
0.0053884545,
0.0066531599,
-0.0439141057,
0.0244319998,
0.0126464861,
-0.0333136916,
-0.010148176,
-0.0447657928,
0.0287098885,
0.0267053004,
-0.0264529269,
0.0581838749,
0.0038490614,
-0.0413967445,
0.022343453,
-0.0179324057,
-0.0412005186,
-0.0337883458,
0.0193785299,
-0.0161615331,
-0.038212359,
-0.0289478898,
-0.0311083477,
0.0549980253,
-0.0265495181,
0.0306513496,
-0.0183765814,
0.0453707837,
-0.0101188691,
0.0000021625,
0.0013796081,
-0.0444222502,
-0.0414313525,
-0.0559410304,
-0.0680635795,
0.0007038917,
0.0738978684,
-0.0121882632,
-0.0074443822,
-0.0552975833,
-0.0071021966,
0.0630905032,
0.0381440371,
0.0290778615,
0.0241936408,
-0.012791723,
0.0416736118,
0.0208208226,
-0.0005707675,
0.0379499756,
-0.0302629732,
0.0217144825,
0.0045345421,
-0.0219541248,
-0.0612979978,
0.0132908942,
0.0298289899,
0.0408368148,
0.0110222753,
0.0456520282,
0.0416139141,
-0.0072443392,
0.0097009782,
-0.0046715592,
0.032670673,
-0.0776100755,
-0.0158581547,
0.0354978517,
0.0084444648,
-0.0216263942,
-0.0131923389,
-0.0750661865,
-0.0129688922,
-0.0507376343,
0.0037453792,
-0.0171973761,
0.0298866946,
0.007392175,
-0.008581751,
-0.0303636659,
-0.016906023,
-0.0132402098,
0.0006110287,
0.0089609921,
-0.0153996525,
-0.0023838745,
-0.0118548293,
0.0380183645,
0.0317573883,
0.0194564611,
-0.0034300275,
-0.0383807793,
-0.0247974563,
-0.0256894305,
-0.0112539362,
0.0360594504,
0.0213245843,
-0.0343788229,
0.0213831533,
-0.1038655564,
0.0336949639,
-0.0211617071,
-0.0083116936,
-0.0194631182,
0.0384069979,
-0.1102398485,
-0.0030592987,
-0.0305724703,
0.1067898944,
0.0371323563,
0.004206317,
-0.0044979719,
0.04937464,
-0.0628137589,
0.0065085511,
-0.0108627276,
0.0111022107,
-0.0434981622,
0.0112124402,
0.0144086797,
-0.0018307744,
0.0246180985,
0.0443190895,
0.007199903,
0.0301966481,
-0.0252215937,
0.0133890873,
0.0178676527,
-0.0244722459,
0.0083589768,
0.092338644,
-0.0484299585,
-0.0173526835,
-0.0822792128,
0.0011214134,
0.0239385907,
-0.0141988499,
0.0608687252,
-0.0005968123,
0.0088024186,
-0.0394122191,
0.0036457777,
-0.0049347356,
0.0149944937,
-0.0234637354,
-0.0082872799,
0.0858104825,
0.0007987525,
-0.0300624408,
0.028560577,
0.0219434462,
-0.0683445185,
0.0235209595,
0.0062699146,
0.012261875,
-0.0072223214,
0.0288832206,
-0.0205708575,
-0.01739268,
0.0268775709,
-0.018567862,
0.0135187535,
-0.0492507778,
0.051050175,
-0.0222715605,
0.0336468853,
-0.0087473625,
-0.0313093886,
0.0403810255,
0.0595912598,
-0.014153434,
0.0128421029,
0.0665265545,
0.048214905,
-0.0295613334,
0.0083249668,
0.0606586821,
-0.0236103777,
0.0536725707,
-0.0113309789,
-0.0295407269,
-0.0551712066,
0.017453216,
-0.0307972562,
-0.0270555448,
0.0664388463,
-0.0258424245,
0.0163720716,
-0.0128218839,
0.0680552199,
0.0182172693,
-0.0401303731,
0.0173690151,
0.0050850753,
-0.0028256006,
0.0215940624,
-0.0684845597,
-0.0133011956,
0.0332450643,
0.0002205447,
-0.0727000982,
-0.0766369328,
-0.0015587731,
0.0085800197,
-0.0713307261,
-0.0532025583,
-0.0334384292,
0.0288193487,
-0.036180757,
-0.0230693743,
-0.0012619317,
-0.002367697,
0.0244783945,
-0.0165775288,
0.0226648971,
-0.0010702451,
0.0053172405,
-0.0134470919,
0.0016696437,
-0.0809452236,
-0.0157757699,
0.0278017502,
0.0125022382,
-0.0237223934,
-0.0102139292,
-0.0164730083,
-0.0052147382,
0.0402108319,
-0.0781366453,
-0.0327061228,
0.0290533956,
-0.0507699549,
-0.0183377564,
0.0132502886,
-0.0337915421,
0.0164545029,
0.0040193354,
-0.0027698888,
-0.0457935221,
-0.0098146154,
0.0442341082,
0.0401603878,
0.0072433995,
0.00488522,
0.021594191,
-0.0389706269,
-0.0249089282,
0.0609764718,
0.0162629783,
-0.0427311026,
0.0062719677,
-0.0563236997,
-0.0112394346,
-0.0868403763,
0.0332951583,
0.0216872189,
-0.0481092371,
-0.0150362011,
-0.0153580159,
0.0310643967,
-0.0385450013,
-0.0221771523,
-0.0406941809,
0.0108404346,
0.0096872123,
0.0049271733,
0.0008574442,
-0.0220657531,
0.02214358,
-0.0216265768,
-0.0249887779,
0.0665470958,
-0.0493936762,
-0.0259245653,
-0.0137988487,
0.0305023696,
-0.0141187441,
-0.0233718492,
-0.0098869242,
-0.011525142,
0.0261486918,
0.0004341619,
-0.0620509721,
-0.0145308357,
0.0647023246,
-0.0083988942,
0.0046669296,
-0.0282370765,
0.0333126225,
-0.0336010791,
-0.0000311275,
0.0292837378,
0.0787941739,
-0.0037844337,
0.0023828791,
0.0417459495,
-0.0561379083,
-0.0000354425,
0.0220429748,
-0.068360135,
-0.0179075897,
0.0112181259,
0.0307024326,
0.0241167601,
0.0161015056,
0.0271378402,
-0.0224101171,
-0.0423122123,
-0.0032001624,
-0.0474893115,
0.0175148379,
-0.0493295193,
0.0026034452,
-0.0011479163,
-0.0447499938,
-0.0159461461,
-0.0074751494,
0.0268063806,
0.0557513833,
0.0398602299,
-0.0127983755,
-0.0506994128,
0.0246078502,
0.0326035805,
-0.0136894071,
0.0353401937,
0.0595051125,
-0.0514555201,
-0.0690072775,
0.0351886861,
0.0208007991,
-0.0095754499,
0.0303534102,
-0.0393611379,
0.0142983245,
-0.0056397198,
-0.0538899601,
-0.0681921393,
0.0228379779,
0.0434252135,
0.0371563248,
-0.0064334599,
0.0015356779,
-0.0016998049,
-0.0043063969,
0.0209235717,
0.0484609641,
0.0009498438,
-0.0092913155,
-0.0238245465,
0.0498345457,
0.0101380656,
0.0232561212,
0.0055976654,
-0.0232398808,
0.009280296,
0.0306946132,
0.0842218623,
0.0167041253,
-0.0015398564,
0.0231358726,
-0.0165090077,
0.0004436775,
-0.025337385,
-0.0134936171,
0.0297649708,
-0.0456007719,
-0.0325769074,
0.0260602664,
0.0054193181,
-0.0626482666,
0.0013311086,
-0.0163914077,
-0.0374278836,
0.0237292256,
0.0201976411,
-0.0297251046,
-0.0012294743,
0.0175549444,
0.0522706956,
-0.0105136139,
-0.0611304864,
-0.000422137,
-0.0402196646,
0.0147748068,
0.0578722209,
-0.0375430174,
0.025206849,
-0.0067072436,
-0.025578374,
0.0166968498,
-0.0263237599,
-0.0141284261,
0.0019299181,
-0.0425114296,
0.0680214912,
-0.0349190682,
-0.041744411,
0.0222440008,
-0.0019580901,
0.0487427115,
0.0165743735,
0.0238259509,
0.0006510931,
-0.0261396822,
0.0647972673,
-0.015219043,
0.0109307738,
0.0017491599,
0.0505058467,
-0.0006065508,
-0.0115134735,
0.0109226732,
0.0403584428,
-0.0036717188,
-0.0524829999,
0.0233542938,
0.083070524,
-0.0058934973,
-0.0048841056,
0.0122866454,
-0.0537094064,
0.0628562048,
0.0205237232,
-0.025118459,
-0.015516215,
0.0108705759,
0.0290649775,
0.0108098928,
-0.0459832288,
0.0055840751,
0.0151501289,
-0.0751670077,
0.0069319713,
-0.0624891408,
0.0457025766,
0.0208820123,
0.0720655695,
0.0417353772,
-0.0067283791,
0.0527031235,
0.0176145975,
-0.0949085429,
-0.0535901077,
-0.0000898957,
-0.0152722234,
-0.0321327895,
-0.0252964683,
0.0388696454,
-0.0406329073,
0.0032382328,
-0.0001983759,
-0.0888572559,
-0.0277477782,
0.0157375857,
0.060478881,
0.0086259628,
0.0866373032,
0.0155118126,
-0.016568305,
0.0491725691,
0.0045119138,
-0.0262982827,
0.0032131507,
0.0540095232,
-0.0411007963,
-0.0027042953,
0.0275022201,
-0.0558218509,
-0.007855854,
0.0407804102,
0.0254289638,
0.0162311383,
0.0743139982,
0.0275947656,
-0.0341601186,
0.0311519764,
0.0106309056,
0.0152996974,
-0.0693631992,
0.021946745,
0.0447294191,
0.0144740082,
-0.0616746657,
0.020370597,
0.0194767471,
0.0486922003,
0.0384516716,
-0.0044197235,
0.0663096085,
0.0373020545,
-0.0178456828,
-0.0296039879,
-0.0110495901,
0.0408929326,
-0.0067942832,
0.0288684256,
-0.0340684764,
-0.0323369466,
0.0371677652,
0.0296076071,
-0.0298835691,
0.0176114999,
0.0414859205,
-0.0245122667,
-0.0608557612,
0.0364380032,
-0.0453702435,
-0.0457074866,
-0.0394008346,
-0.0020524282,
0.0789554566,
0.0083136419,
-0.0079242894,
-0.030751856,
0.0029136278,
-0.0323876813,
0.0269871727,
-0.0044308924,
0.0287239458,
-0.0165655911,
0.012700879,
0.0141251814,
0.0246933904,
0.0563690886,
-0.0331163965,
0.0317730233,
-0.0251097791,
-0.0084082438,
-0.0568793565,
0.0426140353,
0.038617909,
0.0511989295,
-0.007196092,
0.0012542141,
-0.0236010402,
-0.033478979,
0.0472366735,
-0.0413170755,
0.0269137956,
-0.0022416615,
0.031571053,
0.0035186785,
0.0209990237,
-0.018947266,
0.0154541424,
0.0026971309,
0.060115546,
0.0517145954,
0.0111828521,
-6.210085228e-33,
-0.0277563147,
-0.0244596787,
0.0151808737,
0.0344786607,
-0.065709345,
0.0542238876,
-0.0509365611,
-0.0074115559,
0.0285517685,
-0.0230709556,
-0.00713397,
-0.0063586542,
0.0101627205,
-0.0069836099,
0.0409520455,
-0.0166960564,
0.0488693304,
0.0205291882,
0.0030055433,
0.0635226145,
0.0999164656,
0.0664191097,
0.0384363532,
-0.0710024238,
-0.0198697131,
0.0645421296,
0.0055468557,
0.0342308432,
0.015770426,
0.0242797434,
-0.0219635572,
-0.0066266535,
0.0058406536,
-0.0253461469,
-0.0378683098,
-0.0129289115,
-0.1060281768,
-0.0303279478,
-0.0477149896,
-0.0270479973,
-0.0326300599,
-0.04349209,
-0.0020521972,
0.0046777106,
0.0096053658,
-0.0148827657,
0.0352689177,
-0.0325294398,
-0.0302149653,
-0.0343080908,
-0.03156057,
-0.0133104799,
-0.0028666877,
-0.0336872041,
0.0085767051,
-0.0191969797,
-0.0275289137,
-0.0800294653,
-0.1114322916,
-0.0083381394,
-0.0316104554,
0.0455759987,
0.0130163562,
0.0418556482,
0.0509682894,
0.0580233224,
0.0393887758,
0.0347598717,
0.0106320856,
-0.0066587604,
0.0258557498,
0.0343090333,
-0.0192018431,
-0.0716230497,
0.0460275114,
-0.0224061571,
-0.0344815515,
-0.0006580841,
0.0081060268,
0.0432018824,
-0.0034133287,
0.0309039559,
0.0140858814,
-0.0042696064,
0.0116872014,
0.0252078865,
-0.0032396656,
0.0120063089,
0.0534732156,
0.033809308,
-0.0108852172,
-0.0229056962,
0.0377726145,
-0.0343192928,
0.0267941896,
0.0033983043,
-0.0008448642,
0.0276874136,
0.0286255442,
0.0004568057,
-0.0540076308,
-0.0543686785,
-0.016138671,
-0.0017876239,
0.0257354025,
0.007893472,
0.0530327186,
0.1018268019,
-0.0055626854,
-0.0348438434,
-0.0264020953,
0.0023918438,
0.0645647421,
0.0136379255,
0.0325842537,
0.0254050698,
-0.0100478549,
0.0195224006,
0.0445349999,
-0.0471126661,
-0.009719504,
0.075628534,
0.026062075,
0.0297293756,
-0.0079983985,
-0.0121224392,
-0.0621229187,
0.0107127186,
-0.0188541729,
-0.0842546225,
-0.0069177612,
-0.0078979461,
2.91e-7,
-0.0912823677,
-0.0321089886,
0.0026076692,
-0.033477962,
0.0173981171,
0.0037275369,
-0.0402830392,
0.0155817326,
-0.030860588,
0.0435425006,
0.0189864505,
0.0236235503,
0.0094829388,
-0.0000026206,
-0.0588267408,
-0.0059137391,
0.0668554828,
0.0083555635,
-0.0464145504,
-0.0183652081,
0.0436703637,
0.0032965208,
0.0369331576,
0.0157502517,
0.0535812192,
-0.044878874,
0.0652754381,
0.0306703281,
0.0411916375,
-0.0493177213,
0.002320505,
0.0247572791,
-0.0625055805,
0.0405311733,
-0.0246666018,
0.0038634478,
0.0052172597,
0.0095006786,
-0.006684484,
-0.0307409801,
0.0304446686,
0.0354498997,
0.0366444401,
0.0207585357,
0.0695835575,
-0.0928886756,
-0.0035814424,
0.041595865,
0.0074394895,
-0.007407215,
-0.0483728684,
0.0278925058,
-0.0296595301,
-0.025992617,
-0.012002374,
0.0788966194,
-0.0216996577,
-0.0859146863,
0.0506338403,
0.0665610433,
-0.0515540466,
-0.0625910759,
-0.0209345166,
0.0034495872,
0.0391271561,
-0.0463423245,
0.0195051506,
2.59084511e-34,
-0.0523206443,
-0.011708511,
0.0109972898,
0.0564570799,
-0.0323823169,
-0.033588443,
-0.0289067589,
0.004952461,
0.0297126491,
-0.0039269296,
-0.051253289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09432v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09432v1 | Enhancing BERT-Based Visual Question Answering through Keyword-Driven Sentence Selection | 2023-10-13T22:43:55 | 2023-10-13T22:43:55 | Davide Napolitano, Lorenzo Vaiani, Luca Cagliero | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The Document-based Visual Question Answering competition addresses the
automatic detection of parent-child relationships between elements in
multi-page documents. The goal is to identify the document elements that answer
a specific question posed in natural language. This paper describes the
PoliTo's approach to addressing this task, in particular, our best solution
explores a text-only approach, leveraging an ad hoc sampling strategy.
Specifically, our approach leverages the Masked Language Modeling technique to
fine-tune a BERT model, focusing on sentences containing sensitive keywords
that also occur in the questions, such as references to tables or images.
Thanks to the effectiveness of this approach, we are able to achieve high
performance compared to baselines, demonstrating how our solution contributes
positively to this task. | [
0.0534929857,
0.0290772524,
-0.0330468267,
0.0531053804,
-0.0259395204,
0.0209674146,
0.0006207463,
0.0626673847,
0.0205392092,
-0.0783141106,
0.0040049367,
0.0017439913,
-0.0482158698,
0.0279776473,
0.0157524198,
-0.0902946442,
0.0342150033,
-0.0321862139,
-0.0066882512,
0.0100068022,
0.0467479676,
0.0077447733,
0.0294502974,
0.0297593102,
-0.0092027234,
-0.0215259902,
-0.0014086878,
0.0234530699,
0.029502904,
-0.0213567484,
0.0045049544,
0.0504112877,
0.0676756874,
-0.0120770782,
0.000001678,
0.0010663063,
-0.0201843251,
0.0070192618,
0.0296872854,
0.0389891639,
-0.0079128882,
0.0115533601,
0.0529634804,
0.0024707089,
-0.0366977267,
0.0245086793,
0.0521744527,
0.0413205214,
0.0657751262,
0.0115158558,
-0.0123966597,
0.0307889599,
0.0021042104,
0.0225100219,
0.0346959941,
-0.0261887349,
-0.0030737796,
0.001932923,
0.0223084576,
-0.0297189001,
-0.0205527507,
0.0450527035,
-0.0204556659,
-0.0378948189,
0.0610925891,
0.0403479896,
-0.0651806816,
-0.0079614455,
-0.0237586014,
0.0955685526,
-0.0183880199,
-0.011118901,
0.0195316076,
0.0067232717,
-0.0247114114,
0.0745550171,
-0.0662768334,
0.0164777655,
-0.047406055,
-0.0055754762,
-0.0256049167,
-0.0339133851,
-0.0255132616,
0.0069402843,
0.0096410206,
-0.0061156205,
0.0407678522,
-0.0341812596,
-0.0117556388,
0.0056235343,
-0.0625280961,
-0.084163785,
0.0376437753,
0.04175511,
0.0154136159,
-0.001115158,
-0.0398416631,
-0.0868894309,
-0.0009070902,
-0.0674954504,
0.0266637616,
-0.0341080651,
-0.0445347317,
0.0616011061,
-0.0095817214,
0.0591228679,
0.0061188485,
0.0102914805,
-0.040316619,
-0.0130467881,
0.0036963993,
-0.0169894453,
-0.0891952962,
0.0445435569,
-0.0827191025,
-0.0602091104,
0.0229804125,
0.0049422821,
-0.004424579,
0.0036054514,
-0.005032103,
0.0294499099,
-0.020152336,
0.0169750974,
-0.0292616896,
0.0208030455,
-0.0421025604,
-0.0095765069,
-0.0487279743,
-0.0051077604,
0.0059700604,
0.0428797565,
0.0381176919,
-0.0452663414,
0.0142533062,
0.0688590631,
-0.0306963436,
-0.022257885,
0.0038484703,
-0.011975104,
-0.0338976681,
0.006939014,
0.0720910728,
-0.0397323109,
-0.0147793572,
0.0049167001,
-0.0153493052,
0.0294305477,
0.0382678024,
0.0634905845,
-0.0516903251,
0.0494431965,
0.0118457368,
-0.0368230678,
0.0106252385,
0.0114797093,
0.0400597714,
0.0581876785,
0.0427313857,
0.0310950149,
0.0829306394,
0.0078182388,
0.0343543254,
0.050866697,
0.0103434855,
0.0034527096,
-0.0080304099,
0.0449830033,
0.0053822938,
0.0010858955,
-0.0085199568,
0.0355676077,
-0.0206281748,
-0.0142367184,
0.0567077436,
0.0524856113,
-0.0608431511,
0.0200349763,
-0.0127859609,
0.0197909754,
0.0252170805,
0.0385812856,
0.0083633494,
0.0406419896,
-0.0091017028,
-0.0147926724,
-0.0275366828,
0.0075735869,
-0.0247923844,
0.0045310338,
-0.0306086503,
0.0434922725,
-0.0060223578,
0.0145197408,
0.0411051512,
0.0449581072,
-0.0686476976,
0.0398044586,
-0.009329496,
-0.0448205583,
0.0072206887,
-0.0316399112,
0.0418426357,
0.0395922959,
0.0627245456,
-0.0436818153,
-0.0048939204,
0.0023688152,
0.029657932,
0.0438987873,
-0.0489917584,
-0.0073493109,
0.0216719937,
-0.0416926667,
-0.0374693163,
-0.0235666521,
-0.0165991653,
0.0090848152,
0.0003276796,
-0.0081791775,
-0.0016352278,
-0.0768120438,
0.027424166,
0.0697917715,
0.0711587667,
-0.0244120788,
0.000056438,
0.0280924924,
0.0032289177,
-0.013465032,
-0.0430536047,
-0.0000230933,
-0.0012313363,
-0.0485169217,
0.0240519214,
-0.016176153,
0.0248949099,
-0.0346696302,
0.0009747466,
-0.1208472997,
-0.0253783446,
0.0387974866,
-0.0420251861,
0.0002095316,
-0.0007123352,
-0.0761340335,
0.0043022144,
-0.0515316501,
-0.016427964,
0.0054470371,
-0.0046731541,
-0.0537288152,
0.0671793595,
0.0084312037,
-0.0137791364,
0.000762776,
-0.0354943722,
0.0413979702,
-0.0562487319,
-0.0099670189,
-0.0028008982,
0.0024535272,
-0.0051246416,
0.040713165,
0.0375633128,
-0.0392159559,
-0.019543387,
-0.1033580974,
-0.0060136053,
-0.018918084,
0.0032122978,
0.0093871625,
-0.0041132476,
-0.0063002273,
-0.0379877426,
-0.0261398293,
0.0056713768,
-0.0143155344,
0.0110912593,
0.0806081071,
-0.0240961649,
0.0090032127,
-0.0327292643,
-0.0278256983,
0.0024307452,
0.0765474811,
0.0569983535,
-0.0428647362,
0.0115549164,
-0.0411885045,
-0.0195514876,
0.0354802907,
0.0188749619,
-0.0181854367,
-0.0054140757,
-0.0190852918,
0.015209185,
0.0631560385,
0.0099693947,
0.0085945334,
-0.0212214366,
-0.0191330016,
-0.0271559674,
0.0248726159,
0.0107156225,
0.0137967933,
0.0374710113,
-0.0516416766,
0.0303919595,
0.0044418583,
-0.0149070332,
-0.0099364035,
-0.0242956895,
-0.0025385525,
0.032771688,
0.0224475171,
-0.086808607,
-0.0278170649,
0.0261286739,
0.0216083247,
-0.0421618782,
-0.0590257384,
0.0461518578,
-0.0168508347,
0.0000603099,
-0.0285637714,
0.0291608553,
-0.0516676605,
0.095547922,
0.0298208538,
0.0031996516,
-0.0280390717,
-0.0094339,
-0.0534724183,
-0.0294364281,
0.0356946737,
0.0007866332,
0.0226226561,
-0.0583021417,
0.0188348331,
-0.0179087967,
-0.0384700112,
-0.0337526239,
-0.0144711239,
-0.0173054598,
-0.0004629685,
-0.012376762,
-0.0115987184,
-0.0081375791,
0.0316631943,
0.0308874473,
-0.0056062276,
-0.0165361948,
-0.002166138,
-0.022727171,
0.1217689365,
0.0907432288,
-0.0088864546,
-0.0038155059,
-0.0383902118,
0.0131410751,
0.031006895,
0.0718821809,
0.0236636791,
-0.0102780396,
0.0255537611,
-0.0036169898,
-0.0197511092,
-0.0216194596,
0.0241872445,
0.0028170885,
-0.0710404292,
-0.008856304,
0.0576180331,
0.0532896146,
0.013197693,
-0.0458721854,
-0.0105282934,
0.0359752513,
0.0055755572,
0.0625191554,
-0.0672697127,
-0.0210445337,
-0.0152153717,
0.0081935814,
-0.0146074733,
0.0013177855,
0.0255063642,
-0.079058677,
0.0775612146,
-0.0366793312,
-0.0008937395,
-0.0378344022,
-0.0595553927,
0.0030665142,
0.0184961166,
0.0119080236,
-0.0170594864,
-0.0292544868,
0.0009654789,
-0.0013726623,
-0.0190284215,
0.0366792865,
0.0138813658,
-0.0682467744,
-0.0709468871,
0.0575721525,
0.0584383197,
-0.0371022001,
-0.0586430468,
0.009416936,
-0.0377135612,
-0.025930034,
-0.0305939354,
0.063779749,
-0.0077803279,
-0.0378400199,
0.0004603327,
0.0080429669,
0.0207624771,
-0.0031070844,
0.0118964352,
0.0327635482,
-0.0069784415,
-0.0284803025,
-0.0566177815,
0.0178472325,
-0.0008729377,
0.041192241,
0.0320761912,
-0.0366477929,
-0.0797916725,
0.0015262074,
0.0244770702,
-0.0734152868,
0.0277099106,
0.0007431668,
-0.0383692719,
0.0204046201,
-0.1074384823,
0.017905036,
0.059926156,
0.0707437545,
0.0012945302,
0.009978923,
-0.0057749464,
0.0390785299,
-0.056359183,
0.0623598248,
-0.0119794849,
0.0202717558,
-0.0138361361,
-0.0227081329,
-0.0127610555,
-0.0370114446,
-0.0522080325,
0.0301114134,
-0.0278876796,
0.0106754079,
-0.0193588194,
0.0593645833,
0.0136401234,
0.0036679951,
0.0132640833,
-0.0604775213,
0.0329243392,
0.0421767347,
0.022968214,
-0.0136684161,
-0.0094520105,
-0.0448123366,
0.002891683,
0.0083780959,
-0.0791392326,
-0.0149292741,
0.023343334,
0.0545985214,
-0.010569036,
-0.0044312631,
0.0087418016,
0.0336329006,
0.0368197784,
-0.0036144212,
0.0131657431,
-0.0236768425,
0.0331661999,
0.0077472753,
-0.0124694556,
-0.0804076791,
0.0237597134,
-0.0474151187,
-0.0018247551,
-0.0079918792,
0.042783238,
-0.0354340486,
0.0059566316,
-0.043265719,
0.003681551,
0.039602302,
0.020375846,
-0.0253841337,
-0.0034011125,
-0.0098719131,
-0.0008594745,
0.0052146683,
0.0418474227,
0.0157100447,
0.0634894446,
0.0201198198,
-0.0506667458,
-0.0403028317,
0.0176536366,
-0.0596350543,
0.0039244806,
-0.0364617035,
0.04877083,
0.0498160943,
-0.0373674743,
-0.0178530365,
-0.0074873366,
-0.0368871763,
0.0199753493,
0.0086602364,
0.0197174232,
-0.0319191925,
0.0538553521,
0.0158970095,
0.0109513141,
0.0209253337,
0.0632591173,
0.0357023813,
0.0272756461,
0.0083804205,
-0.0430860445,
-0.0366948731,
0.0035349859,
0.0658719763,
0.0127389869,
0.0237585735,
0.0319505185,
-0.0280688778,
-0.0361573622,
0.0416949205,
0.0168477632,
-0.0139613692,
0.0236321837,
0.0832696781,
0.0358219668,
0.0513831787,
-0.0609921776,
-0.0206490606,
0.0398068614,
-0.0320324972,
-0.0114545887,
-0.026305588,
-5.756313184e-33,
-0.0443651378,
-0.0524353497,
0.0032067352,
0.0270628277,
0.0158131085,
0.0347507894,
-0.010612675,
-0.0214748364,
-0.0136606963,
0.0051020384,
-0.0083227158,
-0.0158096962,
0.017185336,
0.0447570384,
-0.0499032475,
-0.0287468098,
0.0051926821,
-0.0218771547,
-0.0196269918,
0.0066246074,
-0.0145905828,
0.0235744063,
0.0245685335,
-0.0234185867,
-0.02758958,
-0.0175115746,
-0.0322594754,
0.0097933421,
0.0204318818,
0.0624792464,
-0.0336210318,
-0.0062742573,
0.0025081388,
0.0392514877,
0.0047608507,
0.0511739813,
-0.0987087414,
-0.0427542925,
0.0269875117,
-0.0047657364,
-0.0585595854,
0.0061808228,
0.0320694596,
-0.0157553609,
0.0505759604,
-0.015668951,
0.0982329547,
-0.0236929953,
-0.0502016023,
-0.0349794142,
-0.0259212665,
0.0031994397,
-0.0307694096,
-0.0116675692,
0.0090853041,
0.0337499045,
-0.0058329632,
0.0134315537,
0.0059271045,
-0.014977783,
0.0722878128,
0.0078887884,
0.0474338308,
0.0310628265,
0.04111626,
0.0668988898,
0.0151328854,
-0.0204239544,
-0.0287923049,
-0.0115054585,
0.0018724829,
0.0667384267,
0.0837213993,
-0.000804658,
-0.0034204859,
0.0803738013,
-0.0887323096,
0.023351552,
-0.0029947592,
0.0245514773,
-0.0223773271,
-0.0242750291,
-0.0059339921,
0.0188584123,
-0.0307282247,
-0.0136557529,
-0.0507136546,
0.0258696042,
0.0378878303,
0.026588032,
-0.0302450564,
0.0207311343,
0.0261459034,
0.0028616469,
-0.0053091883,
-0.0187083278,
0.0138269374,
0.0279979929,
0.0288609415,
0.022752231,
-0.0101938369,
-0.0023615824,
0.0513446629,
-0.0300137587,
0.0043438841,
0.0048944009,
0.0266872756,
-0.0288923159,
-0.0599902384,
0.0040345225,
-0.015481039,
-0.0209631436,
-0.0305016767,
0.0135515584,
-0.0018756227,
0.0019163766,
-0.024014527,
0.0058908202,
0.0101246899,
0.0177540574,
-0.0285774693,
-0.0105323261,
-0.0308236703,
0.0208274312,
0.0053882324,
0.0140399728,
-0.0153790396,
0.0132406652,
-0.0061201961,
-0.0730785131,
-0.0085561946,
0.035531871,
2.36e-7,
0.0395042859,
0.0617443509,
0.0288476516,
0.0237059034,
0.0051094936,
0.0106603056,
0.0141163981,
0.0298102889,
0.0328523144,
-0.0057677184,
0.0083671995,
-0.0074630799,
0.0313224234,
0.0023286364,
-0.0261814203,
0.0178666841,
-0.0409588218,
-0.0246082656,
-0.0600251183,
-0.0114832092,
0.0536395088,
0.0492691882,
-0.0133324582,
-0.0148080159,
-0.0110475672,
-0.0912965536,
0.0762024224,
-0.0195377879,
0.0100496579,
0.0009415061,
-0.0028359671,
0.0210688096,
-0.0331344679,
0.0479248166,
-0.0227828752,
0.0104926284,
0.0702156425,
0.0149975345,
-0.0329719745,
-0.0193658955,
-0.0349779911,
-0.0098304609,
-0.0079627391,
-0.0531952828,
0.1136608124,
-0.0237351265,
0.0207671914,
0.000962685,
-0.0575117283,
-0.0215775222,
0.0100020263,
-0.0497246571,
-0.0502803624,
0.0507603437,
0.0244691633,
-0.0352139287,
-0.0083739022,
-0.0492545031,
0.0087753506,
-0.0115210628,
-0.0463292561,
-0.0115209408,
-0.0642206892,
-0.0079570981,
-0.0161945466,
-0.0214482378,
-0.0396172181,
2.052750173e-34,
0.0499927141,
-0.0452484898,
-0.052696839,
0.0186887346,
0.0438193493,
-0.0206684638,
-0.0100290058,
-0.0201090369,
0.0192737561,
-0.0814624503,
0.0176042896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09430v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09430v4 | Assessing and Enhancing the Robustness of Large Language Models with Task Structure Variations for Logical Reasoning | 2023-10-13T22:29:15 | 2024-03-30T09:49:19 | Qiming Bao, Gael Gendron, Alex Yuxuan Peng, Wanjun Zhong, Neset Tan, Yang Chen, Michael Witbrock, Jiamou Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), such as LLaMA, Alpaca, Vicuna, GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, have advanced the performance of AI systems on various natural language
processing tasks to human-like levels. However, their generalisation and
robustness when performing logical reasoning has not been sufficiently
assessed. To comprehensively evaluate this ability, we develop three new
logical reasoning datasets named "ReClor-plus", "LogiQA-plus" and
"LogiQAv2-plus" that extend standard logical reasoning datasets to evaluate the
robustness of the LLM's reasoning. For each, we create three subsets: the first
with randomly shuffled options, the second with the correct choices replaced by
"none of the other options is correct", and the third with a combination of
shuffling and substitution. Experiments on these datasets show that these
simple augmentations greatly hinder the models' performance. Despite their high
performance on the original publicly available datasets, we find that all
models perform poorly on these newly constructed datasets. We also demonstrate
that introducing task variations into the training set can markedly improve the
model's performance on both the original and our developed datasets. Finally,
we show that applying logic-driven data augmentation for fine-tuning and
prompting can enhance generalisation in both discriminative and generative
models, offering a path to improving their robustness for tasks involving
logical reasoning. Source code and data are made publicly available at
https://github.com/Strong-AI-Lab/Logical-and-abstract-reasoning. | [
0.054303389,
0.0612527914,
-0.0282602273,
0.028991174,
-0.0490630195,
0.0306521468,
0.0130210491,
-0.0258333478,
0.0539573804,
-0.0308661144,
0.0021194259,
-0.014263927,
-0.0274691172,
0.0602187477,
0.0364837125,
-0.0279603135,
0.0586861931,
-0.0519629121,
0.0375741161,
-0.0070868656,
-0.002125626,
-0.0062860916,
-0.0017081562,
0.015196668,
0.0076392367,
-0.0059481175,
-0.0137546295,
-0.031964656,
0.0248957537,
-0.0161503311,
-0.0214061271,
0.0594830848,
0.013504413,
0.0283725969,
0.0000020466,
-0.0460538641,
0.0195799693,
-0.0168315191,
-0.0467040502,
-0.0190350953,
0.0140569936,
-0.0131102307,
-0.0087869614,
0.0148653192,
-0.0441822521,
-0.0194854513,
0.0403498262,
0.0578715131,
0.059852574,
0.0773111805,
0.0076897522,
-0.0550237335,
0.0377195477,
-0.0448800288,
0.0261068419,
-0.0454550609,
0.035833668,
0.018565692,
0.0356083103,
-0.0045512994,
0.0102043981,
0.0012380672,
0.0559371673,
0.0063984897,
-0.0494521745,
0.0201911479,
-0.0713589638,
-0.0276023801,
0.0036472443,
0.0832076967,
-0.0090644658,
-0.0214840882,
-0.0319603905,
0.0030500889,
0.004279159,
-0.0313189439,
-0.0321688317,
0.0376414768,
-0.0078917379,
0.0063833352,
0.064618893,
-0.0078194961,
0.0370465554,
0.0164873097,
-0.0429357886,
0.12391866,
0.009565535,
-0.0373438299,
0.0270662736,
-0.0048733964,
-0.0512004122,
-0.0646374449,
-0.0011129329,
0.0413585976,
-0.0386147015,
0.0372092724,
-0.0457454585,
-0.0126573099,
0.0323807076,
-0.0247677378,
0.023534365,
0.0424372368,
-0.022507064,
0.0518161952,
-0.0305655189,
0.0708641484,
-0.0070784143,
0.0863744542,
-0.0107490597,
-0.0314758569,
-0.0373326167,
-0.0156239197,
-0.0083260043,
0.0275610592,
-0.0259822905,
0.0137816882,
-0.0495203994,
0.0228050873,
-0.0211418904,
0.0274513848,
0.0100592207,
-0.0133243417,
-0.0284514967,
-0.0398735963,
-0.0739315674,
-0.0190614276,
-0.0510909967,
0.0604690798,
0.0361548252,
-0.0752775073,
-0.018236557,
-0.0182349719,
0.0043236441,
-0.0462905765,
0.0441785008,
0.0668709204,
-0.0075800414,
-0.0416494831,
-0.052956976,
-0.004022181,
0.0019340565,
-0.100928776,
0.0123604238,
-0.0408192687,
0.0461270884,
-0.0015410439,
-0.017611267,
-0.038230624,
-0.0000038196,
0.0219444931,
-0.0221328828,
0.1156524345,
0.0086804116,
-0.0092121297,
-0.0021263047,
-0.0081256768,
-0.0337816514,
0.0559031144,
0.0449019335,
0.0215525907,
0.0251127463,
0.0003152917,
-0.0079919752,
0.0046449737,
-0.0177849866,
-0.0203819275,
-0.0082661808,
0.0389289148,
-0.0500537679,
0.0113518564,
-0.0157836732,
0.0582206212,
-0.028772654,
-0.0261845123,
0.0430282466,
0.0245990735,
0.0143230278,
0.0120040122,
0.034137588,
-0.0441617779,
0.0097125228,
0.0170301963,
-0.0903978646,
0.0228384417,
-0.025172608,
0.0076880134,
-0.0128273964,
0.0295448545,
-0.0214072969,
-0.0752142146,
-0.0207076445,
-0.0035921792,
0.046563711,
0.0391507298,
0.0531152673,
0.0151892174,
-0.0029516777,
-0.0137951989,
0.0381543636,
-0.0490482263,
-0.0322397985,
-0.0836159289,
0.0603194758,
0.0561806634,
0.036431931,
-0.0383416004,
-0.0564205088,
0.0110758133,
0.0080826618,
0.0279819928,
0.042723272,
-0.0034857213,
0.000837695,
-0.0497142114,
-0.0068535111,
-0.024092434,
0.0233730264,
0.0353437848,
0.0202043839,
-0.0051257075,
0.0045481967,
-0.0429748408,
0.0010036138,
0.0443405248,
-0.0264962483,
-0.0216460098,
-0.0035879901,
-0.0085928682,
0.0372047462,
-0.0156271141,
0.0096250959,
0.0071065705,
0.0353521407,
-0.0329722799,
-0.0223745145,
0.0213270057,
-0.0428866334,
-0.0116853258,
0.0597100817,
-0.0077027562,
-0.0524959005,
0.0295605641,
-0.0678898692,
-0.0365260467,
0.0301253758,
-0.0155202728,
-0.0349181332,
-0.0547915921,
0.0139634265,
0.0150022302,
0.0037724911,
-0.0156986937,
0.1087075323,
0.0028297547,
0.0144368615,
-0.0077732084,
0.0550591014,
0.0278432183,
-0.091645591,
-0.0032625326,
0.0229671169,
-0.007544877,
-0.0131886285,
-0.0255052242,
0.0066663548,
-0.0450741053,
-0.0341310985,
-0.0568083189,
0.0101140589,
-0.0216345415,
0.006567203,
0.0060455743,
-0.0030724362,
-0.0165120494,
-0.0017908465,
-0.0309276283,
-0.0026399125,
0.0311758611,
0.0243216474,
0.0260316133,
-0.0096344724,
-0.0154570052,
-0.0217290446,
-0.0194098651,
-0.0141110336,
-0.0000809468,
0.0142420996,
0.0215386655,
-0.0351299047,
0.0112591088,
-0.0287152585,
0.0511496253,
-0.0323112905,
-0.0323452428,
0.0086883036,
0.0017333656,
0.0447038896,
0.1181797013,
-0.0291256495,
-0.0030205236,
0.0828371942,
0.010919529,
-0.0026904927,
0.0517213605,
-0.0120916972,
-0.0007186556,
-0.0324182771,
-0.0317900963,
-0.0283254664,
0.0383383147,
-0.0285961088,
-0.0132444967,
-0.0551569313,
0.0260416213,
0.0041218773,
-0.0300430246,
0.0069341352,
-0.0138958804,
-0.0154082393,
0.0759211034,
-0.0439113751,
-0.0218208898,
0.079836227,
-0.007843486,
0.0030969225,
-0.0825787336,
-0.0224752631,
-0.0373319834,
0.0725519881,
0.0156343766,
-0.0215058513,
0.0089852689,
0.0140972584,
-0.067612119,
-0.0308946539,
-0.0021839254,
-0.0463765375,
0.0472608246,
-0.0477245376,
0.0235054661,
-0.0191722065,
-0.0569902509,
-0.0537352152,
0.0069535021,
-0.0512604751,
0.017878091,
-0.0090196077,
-0.0091150692,
-0.018417336,
-0.0047691083,
0.0147325778,
0.0241075736,
-0.018714726,
0.0116823679,
-0.0308654066,
-0.0171098132,
0.0514256023,
0.0413573086,
0.0245643854,
-0.0056786314,
0.0104402611,
0.0102608325,
0.0157059487,
-0.0200953353,
-0.0403013267,
0.0456311665,
-0.003696464,
0.0025402633,
-0.0002364283,
0.008675267,
0.0553775877,
-0.0513087139,
-0.0280298032,
0.0875894502,
0.030327158,
0.0169845857,
-0.0030835611,
-0.0171573516,
0.0349354818,
0.0253402088,
0.0430472679,
-0.0538783483,
-0.0601547398,
0.0430390909,
0.0072872257,
-0.0287820194,
-0.0340520591,
0.0035382654,
-0.133940354,
0.0496854447,
-0.0160958748,
-0.0088740475,
-0.0578173324,
-0.0300997645,
0.0095697362,
-0.038929563,
0.0285060015,
-0.0017072904,
0.0238738991,
-0.0077339532,
0.0117722834,
0.0189680904,
-0.0353181474,
0.0350881368,
-0.0297953021,
0.0396506339,
0.0806780756,
0.0169628318,
0.0005139633,
-0.0600145422,
0.0298822932,
0.0164019465,
-0.0229700636,
0.0187134482,
0.0212829951,
0.0204385538,
-0.0066841166,
-0.016051732,
0.047489889,
-0.0282631963,
-0.0337644815,
0.026256334,
0.0777298585,
-0.0165687408,
-0.0100275986,
-0.0249019731,
0.007911101,
-0.042264875,
0.0713493153,
0.0200881325,
-0.0070724101,
-0.0615393184,
-0.0544509739,
-0.0240278002,
-0.0709670335,
0.0031368679,
0.0419161543,
-0.0088170087,
-0.0136919729,
-0.048333969,
-0.0515202396,
0.0414755009,
0.017644098,
-0.0030460279,
0.0005943823,
0.0272300132,
0.002246951,
-0.0295901857,
0.0355181731,
-0.049398195,
0.0156688392,
-0.0192199312,
0.0008498593,
-0.0056807399,
-0.035161186,
-0.0323770456,
0.064298436,
-0.0807734132,
-0.065448381,
0.0045144921,
0.0436979495,
0.0355450213,
0.0242292341,
-0.0399768241,
-0.0556715317,
-0.0032995038,
0.0293500349,
0.0161126964,
0.0190213956,
0.0194807332,
-0.0126398578,
0.0207653083,
0.0365734659,
-0.0315616988,
0.0277405493,
0.0305757858,
0.0379329883,
-0.0256329048,
-0.0033065365,
0.0313764997,
0.0326546393,
0.0006481109,
0.0231378209,
-0.0131005095,
-0.0376828462,
0.035476692,
-0.0236161668,
-0.0222925451,
-0.0125812013,
0.010340401,
0.0388367809,
-0.0179215986,
-0.0021258988,
-0.0451467894,
-0.0151903676,
0.0409335382,
-0.0200390834,
-0.0005160348,
0.0356348492,
0.0190269258,
-0.0026741466,
-0.0327697061,
-0.0140457759,
-0.0052411435,
-0.0156714674,
0.0632205829,
-0.0082329186,
0.0378416143,
0.035400968,
-0.0252869762,
-0.0325042717,
0.0231967382,
-0.0830594599,
-0.0475909337,
0.0378399007,
0.0270064976,
0.0509971492,
-0.0082890196,
0.0003876917,
-0.0358296037,
-0.0184619892,
-0.0131778717,
-0.0089745084,
0.0602965206,
-0.0147350095,
0.0453068465,
0.0251736138,
-0.0203894991,
-0.0341373011,
0.0526366159,
0.0074912147,
0.0708929598,
-0.0089315213,
0.0061725904,
-0.0291341506,
-0.0608774647,
-0.0262489375,
0.0024821027,
-0.0174835455,
-0.0046464568,
-0.0483631231,
-0.0858965218,
0.0126588894,
0.0260868184,
0.0276359078,
-0.0111925351,
-0.0037669295,
0.0608030036,
0.0205765702,
-0.0237632953,
-0.006321752,
-0.0256692637,
0.0028908059,
-0.0111233313,
-0.0324914306,
-6.198460323e-33,
-0.0203011669,
0.0016121906,
0.0365344919,
-0.0452409908,
0.0135878948,
-0.0254664756,
-0.0274282601,
-0.0200860687,
-0.0511694066,
0.009530656,
-0.0252823364,
0.0276069883,
0.0154761076,
0.0213638153,
-0.0090840189,
-0.0185683761,
-0.0110977311,
0.0187651888,
-0.0274688043,
0.0099552739,
0.0374055281,
-0.0191467926,
0.0053672479,
-0.062631689,
-0.0144424653,
0.0167725906,
-0.0190974586,
0.0311055426,
-0.0935085267,
0.0668400005,
-0.0043061036,
0.0148614049,
0.0304922238,
-0.0273150466,
0.0085996361,
0.0313121304,
-0.0869732872,
-0.0397855788,
0.0461767167,
-0.0051935622,
-0.0393108688,
-0.0415645093,
0.0352384374,
0.0028142901,
0.0053486545,
-0.0206078459,
-0.0012653653,
-0.0547208451,
0.0160816051,
0.0050090202,
-0.041471608,
0.0184047725,
0.0100227147,
-0.0246714,
-0.0384033173,
0.0282191262,
-0.005518707,
0.0312778614,
-0.0340851918,
0.014226337,
0.0444767997,
0.0010990703,
0.0517178699,
0.0072228718,
-0.0088296384,
0.0376902968,
0.0063301814,
0.0031364826,
-0.042591095,
0.0144274356,
-0.0031227281,
0.0665474236,
0.0670151189,
0.0373216569,
0.0539747551,
0.0040799864,
-0.1022225916,
-0.0121472888,
0.0251504164,
0.0507422686,
0.0528951734,
0.0118144853,
-0.0383690484,
0.0046086051,
-0.042021472,
0.0192183163,
-0.0435304902,
-0.0210803114,
0.0480851233,
0.0145553416,
-0.0107254656,
-0.0093373926,
-0.0005409004,
-0.0224495307,
0.0149172125,
0.0184860174,
-0.0162836611,
0.0003544568,
0.0044580661,
0.0241647437,
-0.0153643442,
-0.0333088338,
0.0524493232,
0.0103614917,
0.0030001232,
-0.0042162919,
0.0703905597,
0.0175118223,
-0.0350727104,
-0.0005602387,
-0.0455272831,
0.045836322,
0.0018772491,
0.0509918369,
0.0463897288,
0.0430897102,
0.0033903024,
0.0154611878,
0.0144573255,
-0.0046509574,
-0.0436573736,
-0.0047718999,
0.0013969311,
0.0244997162,
-0.0137931323,
-0.0057338057,
-0.0371601172,
-0.004539879,
-0.0337794013,
-0.0366541557,
0.0069428934,
0.0192769021,
2.846e-7,
0.0224696212,
0.036714185,
0.0176935699,
0.0684901997,
0.0151953604,
0.0352615342,
-0.032969743,
0.0066167479,
0.0245150328,
-0.0269361883,
-0.0227205977,
0.0618901998,
0.0322111882,
0.0307725798,
-0.041811619,
0.0106988242,
-0.0130497944,
-0.0271949042,
-0.0496949442,
0.0021740189,
0.1012190804,
0.1398007721,
0.0344295017,
-0.0287647098,
0.0163546298,
-0.0768819377,
0.0255727191,
-0.0015129647,
-0.0072641349,
-0.0034873197,
0.031025365,
0.0394149162,
0.0132419169,
0.051324863,
0.0032472608,
0.0116101652,
-0.0236498006,
0.0693440512,
0.0006886114,
-0.0141899614,
-0.0266725384,
-0.030524442,
0.0111109568,
-0.0501229875,
0.1194116622,
-0.0485270135,
-0.0567692593,
0.0118277362,
-0.018794138,
-0.0055449302,
-0.0047336677,
-0.020014517,
-0.0006271175,
0.0016594363,
-0.0005178436,
-0.0268574916,
-0.0074934633,
-0.0867489576,
-0.0102717159,
0.0054475786,
-0.0480917282,
-0.0297206268,
-0.0468492843,
0.0243646055,
0.0589058995,
-0.0614904761,
0.0048409933,
2.70715775e-34,
0.0222654399,
0.0052683982,
0.0126061654,
-0.0033102736,
0.0657108054,
-0.0000315196,
-0.0270066075,
0.0179717895,
0.0037616831,
-0.0694473386,
-0.0084527908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09424v1 | SALM: Speech-augmented Language Model with In-context Learning for Speech Recognition and Translation | 2023-10-13T22:07:33 | 2023-10-13T22:07:33 | Zhehuai Chen, He Huang, Andrei Andrusenko, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Krishna C. Puvvada, Jason Li, Subhankar Ghosh, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T10, I.2.7 | We present a novel Speech Augmented Language Model (SALM) with {\em
multitask} and {\em in-context} learning capabilities. SALM comprises a frozen
text LLM, a audio encoder, a modality adapter module, and LoRA layers to
accommodate speech input and associated task instructions. The unified SALM not
only achieves performance on par with task-specific Conformer baselines for
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and Speech Translation (AST), but also
exhibits zero-shot in-context learning capabilities, demonstrated through
keyword-boosting task for ASR and AST. Moreover, {\em speech supervised
in-context training} is proposed to bridge the gap between LLM training and
downstream speech tasks, which further boosts the in-context learning ability
of speech-to-text models. Proposed model is open-sourced via NeMo toolkit. | [
-0.0146475472,
0.0032799814,
0.0096245455,
0.0538088679,
0.0128694559,
-0.0059389276,
0.0314791687,
-0.0408329032,
-0.0279745925,
-0.02616244,
-0.0850899369,
-0.0151002994,
0.0164771471,
0.0108648231,
0.0440028794,
-0.0136726908,
0.0263061225,
-0.0640919581,
-0.0347322859,
0.0079150032,
0.0248562563,
0.0440632589,
-0.0242676996,
0.0195779093,
0.0207650531,
-0.0010161054,
-0.0119479755,
0.0419790894,
0.0182702783,
-0.0191393364,
-0.0000862884,
-0.0054104282,
0.0686835647,
0.0005538844,
0.0000019543,
-0.0296411812,
-0.017378848,
-0.0036826981,
-0.0229494795,
-0.0193426032,
0.0414220579,
-0.0256612264,
-0.0300887022,
0.0565935411,
-0.0075310366,
0.0202849414,
0.0387475677,
0.0203612503,
0.0157192294,
0.0733225197,
-0.0225135572,
-0.0088157607,
0.0437278673,
-0.040669892,
-0.0364275798,
-0.049459286,
-0.0235965345,
-0.0436024517,
-0.0114417728,
0.0091833072,
-0.0195455085,
0.08052136,
0.017841598,
0.000108127,
0.0138366614,
0.0002449468,
0.0063921423,
-0.0242333394,
-0.0452864841,
0.0630489811,
-0.0394976772,
-0.0387321748,
0.0193169061,
-0.0053268438,
-0.0306317583,
-0.0214474257,
-0.0262307115,
-0.0060474174,
0.0177617371,
0.0222165938,
0.0174989942,
0.0163631663,
0.0458416119,
-0.0127677731,
0.0011723944,
0.0193959419,
-0.0006892715,
-0.0280500669,
-0.0088641113,
-0.0134095307,
-0.024296945,
-0.0244391523,
0.0376931876,
0.0390811563,
-0.0485696346,
0.0218797494,
-0.0638070554,
-0.0470937639,
0.0081163207,
-0.0536630116,
0.0318143778,
0.0755924433,
-0.0559016056,
0.0309358519,
-0.0266373269,
0.0442635417,
0.0109758321,
0.0252673756,
-0.0308707673,
-0.0424959436,
-0.0229789317,
0.0040259324,
-0.0235385019,
0.0062256325,
-0.0500523448,
-0.0444543883,
-0.0042908206,
0.0482440926,
0.0123625789,
0.0181553252,
0.0361406393,
-0.0133815305,
-0.0560649,
-0.0238354988,
0.0067768693,
0.0448957942,
0.0224735066,
0.0711381361,
-0.0228758696,
-0.0273550767,
0.0034391296,
0.0327391066,
0.0300787259,
-0.0050323238,
0.0177869629,
0.0735714212,
-0.0315304883,
-0.0505059995,
-0.0257850327,
0.0282222442,
-0.0220092423,
-0.0705476329,
-0.0039844206,
-0.0481104068,
0.0070321904,
-0.001643431,
-0.0069115697,
0.0004054774,
0.0049483967,
0.0104640843,
-0.0025454473,
0.081129387,
0.0078881718,
-0.0010817818,
0.0513062254,
0.0171081722,
0.0132542253,
0.085020721,
0.0587072559,
-0.0208444055,
0.0065055699,
-0.0285300445,
-0.0242141839,
0.0843688101,
0.0023773594,
0.0192971341,
-0.0482888483,
0.0031392127,
-0.0075447126,
-0.0340131931,
0.019726662,
0.0228548404,
-0.0076818364,
0.0417915508,
0.0742045492,
0.0566680022,
0.019457452,
0.0095984163,
-0.0278066769,
0.0083367517,
-0.0282128323,
-0.0424914733,
-0.0470110029,
0.0494276285,
-0.0293445718,
0.0158799402,
0.0365805067,
0.0372851305,
-0.0270141847,
-0.0127675179,
-0.0172989704,
-0.0114552882,
0.0042037582,
0.044354178,
0.0256903674,
0.0276210681,
-0.0937075838,
0.0042686146,
-0.0339235254,
-0.0520175844,
0.0424826555,
-0.0026514789,
-0.0253720824,
0.0600657761,
0.0306914337,
-0.0206047595,
-0.0472567566,
-0.0566283241,
0.0132124918,
0.0759743154,
-0.0334121138,
0.0076258471,
0.0588612072,
-0.077746056,
-0.0163098034,
0.0095829517,
0.004347879,
0.0032721865,
-0.0130069405,
0.0415011011,
0.025697846,
0.0070685199,
0.0307131521,
-0.0000614017,
-0.0191092491,
0.0140675111,
0.0449232981,
0.00249484,
0.0309979785,
0.0123576047,
-0.0196703356,
-0.0128533887,
0.0537976287,
-0.0454996675,
0.0126734739,
0.0715285465,
-0.078367047,
-0.0326494686,
0.0227463748,
0.0129548945,
0.0310449842,
0.0099774441,
0.006457577,
-0.0865438059,
-0.0021586081,
-0.0020359994,
0.0690359771,
-0.0397616439,
0.0613506287,
0.0241114069,
0.0207852628,
0.0134292543,
-0.0029472185,
-0.0037758569,
-0.0129697891,
0.0393890068,
0.0406519063,
-0.0120197218,
-0.0444216803,
-0.0349670574,
0.0272900872,
0.016649941,
0.030148657,
-0.0109625338,
-0.0070498674,
-0.0079914154,
-0.0299984515,
-0.0880134255,
0.0280223079,
-0.0388550088,
0.0322482772,
0.025880836,
0.043912679,
0.008169407,
-0.0400057547,
-0.0173246693,
-0.0105518745,
0.0121654943,
-0.0153565733,
-0.0340048373,
-0.0007473172,
-0.0210182201,
-0.030328678,
0.0238570645,
0.028888708,
-0.0234380271,
-0.0276212581,
-0.0388737619,
-0.0462634414,
0.0283564217,
0.0267963,
0.0232084617,
-0.0331826881,
-0.0137558673,
-0.0116815669,
-0.0009553886,
0.0579128563,
0.0319904275,
0.0192212965,
-0.0197763015,
0.0279890839,
-0.0154187009,
-0.0358728953,
0.0132252965,
-0.0042547686,
0.0204331521,
-0.0274852831,
0.041906435,
-0.0162600633,
0.0345885381,
0.0096491715,
0.0424714126,
-0.0180485509,
-0.0501236133,
0.0001218277,
-0.0206170734,
-0.0378574543,
-0.0261282865,
-0.0497571938,
-0.0010863619,
-0.0389804058,
-0.0354394652,
0.0271035694,
-0.0859026238,
-0.047545664,
-0.0577889308,
-0.0561017022,
-0.0319349617,
0.0187076926,
-0.0362188034,
-0.0081348754,
-0.034311492,
-0.0317713358,
-0.0047114817,
0.0099705458,
-0.0142070856,
-0.0437026732,
0.0563449152,
-0.0317872837,
0.0192340743,
-0.0048425244,
-0.025918236,
-0.02555844,
0.013346036,
-0.0553642511,
0.0375297666,
-0.0302047096,
-0.0168631859,
-0.007941002,
0.0159788094,
0.0223437417,
0.0988350585,
0.0077801477,
0.0147512024,
-0.0544540733,
0.0124389557,
0.0512196384,
0.0409990996,
-0.0655963495,
-0.0115812607,
0.0369696915,
-0.0107617127,
0.0636271462,
-0.0517892726,
-0.0113435294,
0.0097644618,
0.0608110763,
0.0412593298,
-0.026283063,
0.0431663394,
0.0303599089,
-0.0599121153,
-0.0141997701,
0.0891802311,
0.0150513444,
-0.027939586,
-0.0306653976,
0.008576612,
0.024419209,
0.0398264937,
-0.0054315464,
-0.0535122044,
-0.0677139536,
0.0417444967,
0.0191833843,
0.0157487411,
0.0557784624,
-0.0457943939,
-0.0612813421,
0.0089204703,
0.0201249793,
-0.0623627938,
-0.0088922549,
-0.0281955935,
-0.016835941,
-0.0174876638,
0.0500551499,
-0.0138088353,
-0.0025251303,
-0.0524484999,
0.0283338539,
-0.0032514127,
-0.0523537956,
-0.0146069862,
-0.0158135258,
0.0813504308,
0.0972363204,
0.0122802574,
-0.0263914783,
-0.039105624,
0.0497329272,
0.0116240662,
-0.0032554585,
-0.0095606428,
-0.0207582451,
-0.0311671253,
-0.0118055809,
0.0065243025,
0.0448957011,
-0.043947462,
-0.007613387,
0.011988082,
0.0535774641,
-0.0226438325,
0.052586481,
0.030832123,
-0.0112105487,
0.0026582528,
0.0506257266,
-0.0286330488,
-0.0199519917,
0.0057615256,
-0.0137606533,
-0.022890836,
-0.0356434882,
0.0132809654,
-0.0311247539,
-0.0238220263,
0.0219725948,
-0.0223744083,
0.0226627085,
0.0187770911,
0.0223222505,
0.019244438,
0.0643989593,
-0.0078668026,
-0.00145659,
-0.0548856743,
-0.0016282182,
-0.026860239,
0.0461506769,
-0.0712781101,
-0.0059139431,
0.0642490387,
-0.0703297481,
0.0030032513,
0.0522431582,
-0.0758654699,
-0.0602571145,
-0.0401152,
0.016359549,
0.0158619173,
0.0899088308,
-0.0374294445,
-0.0376515426,
0.0885162577,
0.0182046853,
-0.0699079335,
0.042136278,
0.0484844446,
-0.0044179712,
-0.0018744919,
0.0086404225,
-0.0559446774,
0.0045484011,
-0.0144544626,
0.0233630184,
0.0042533069,
-0.055285953,
-0.0174095146,
-0.0140914442,
0.0171295386,
-0.0149359265,
0.0038773785,
-0.0456536636,
0.0763324723,
0.0058477041,
0.0363568626,
-0.0404292904,
0.0034081412,
0.0127874659,
-0.0091758147,
0.0189001951,
0.0676563978,
-0.0216842759,
-0.0175012294,
0.0052022021,
0.0506522804,
-0.0000786852,
0.011202733,
0.0157576296,
0.0376162827,
-0.0214482304,
0.0115516363,
0.0314347111,
0.032768961,
-0.0368906297,
0.0505592339,
-0.0290287361,
-0.0144083705,
-0.0049374993,
0.0437532738,
-0.0626225621,
-0.0001371229,
-0.0553316399,
0.0578640737,
0.0582285672,
-0.0085943732,
0.0830167979,
0.0056749661,
0.0247115754,
-0.0259562787,
0.0430995524,
-0.0331334621,
-0.026007887,
0.0274021123,
0.0025024349,
0.0000056171,
0.0584693402,
0.0393831506,
0.0169906951,
0.0536158644,
-0.011145317,
0.0420186482,
-0.033461649,
-0.0087740598,
0.0349866822,
0.0563358702,
-0.0277806409,
-0.0352545567,
0.029958928,
-0.0795992315,
0.0278172325,
-0.0185276885,
0.0001166923,
-0.0751605108,
-0.0151146632,
0.0060042385,
-0.0231582057,
-0.0087302653,
-0.0133737968,
-0.0451652482,
0.0232727062,
-0.0094719417,
-0.0027391696,
-6.533922166e-33,
-0.0336965024,
-0.001269363,
0.0371218883,
-0.0164167266,
0.0066949511,
0.0118727954,
-0.0286952928,
-0.0165181831,
-0.0050730822,
-0.062074881,
-0.012755408,
0.010521668,
0.0239469707,
0.0469777919,
-0.0384850688,
-0.0012791876,
0.0865423009,
-0.0068235938,
0.0154614467,
0.0046385997,
0.0140102515,
0.0303040016,
0.0502881072,
-0.0366911851,
0.0104366979,
-0.026634993,
-0.0281130187,
-0.0027201858,
0.014549654,
0.0466196388,
-0.0112330476,
0.0368458591,
0.0082093636,
-0.0606187247,
-0.0126352701,
0.0286129043,
-0.0854603723,
0.034890987,
0.0367538519,
0.0349979475,
-0.0234332606,
-0.0290855914,
0.0576882958,
-0.0097925859,
0.0037988061,
0.0221628305,
0.016439952,
-0.0123152044,
-0.0287324041,
-0.0040090033,
-0.0543447547,
0.0021214788,
-0.0066302489,
-0.0434378609,
0.0444571674,
0.0223615207,
-0.0113565456,
-0.0053923023,
-0.0891691744,
0.0175973754,
-0.0163857602,
0.0260088965,
0.0757358074,
0.0641168803,
-0.0357869864,
0.0331851467,
-0.0238508843,
-0.0336943902,
0.0260100309,
-0.0174665004,
0.0456647202,
0.0272970647,
0.0037947458,
0.0342505351,
0.0471786745,
-0.0205611661,
-0.0202752054,
0.0088703791,
0.0324060991,
-0.0019769205,
0.0438745059,
0.0383580141,
-0.0126422746,
-0.0087811369,
-0.0626874715,
-0.0103998324,
-0.0403914303,
-0.0212482065,
0.0738262385,
0.069887951,
0.0087701296,
0.0096761687,
0.0730629861,
-0.008821968,
0.0494768806,
-0.0058315392,
-0.015676545,
0.0027216088,
-0.0130009083,
0.0521804877,
-0.067779623,
-0.038359724,
0.0667357519,
0.0021344447,
-0.0127247619,
-0.021299351,
0.0312566683,
0.0493195578,
-0.0568194985,
0.0119278124,
-0.0034182172,
0.0274804048,
0.0279995687,
0.0516666435,
0.0177579038,
-0.0311310161,
-0.0313122645,
0.0814173743,
-0.0143342474,
-0.008397229,
-0.0220993981,
-0.0377345383,
-0.0362859666,
0.0280439798,
-0.0420147777,
0.0161313433,
0.0097972648,
-0.0467693768,
0.0311287884,
-0.0505786575,
0.0058961944,
-0.0041482281,
2.738e-7,
-0.0227338094,
0.0140256416,
-0.0006475738,
-0.0588720702,
0.0331387222,
0.0166309327,
-0.0401655845,
0.0186962616,
0.0283435732,
0.0062706959,
-0.0179290157,
0.0006491015,
0.0637952462,
0.0121350922,
-0.0705981553,
-0.0503540002,
-0.035777282,
0.0584543236,
-0.0029465053,
0.0241724811,
-0.0064139208,
0.1150181442,
-0.0201489069,
-0.0197962169,
-0.0329774059,
-0.0373254828,
0.0547332317,
-0.0152067561,
0.0040673427,
-0.0389655866,
-0.0357444212,
0.0383288264,
-0.0616484843,
0.0071420935,
-0.0482237674,
0.041769743,
0.0208247118,
0.0832043886,
0.0042544543,
-0.0746696889,
0.0015818557,
0.0456017181,
-0.0272412412,
-0.004051276,
0.0725738704,
-0.0238786805,
-0.0164190624,
-0.0379811898,
-0.0248383302,
0.0268482734,
-0.0115431072,
-0.0122838905,
-0.0164149757,
-0.0264189765,
0.0323125198,
-0.0167666096,
-0.0370599106,
-0.0614660792,
-0.029671669,
-0.0350390039,
-0.0440834016,
-0.023802517,
-0.066042386,
-0.0184571277,
0.0010571592,
-0.0585193969,
0.0083332686,
2.338598945e-34,
0.0260628965,
-0.0216418989,
0.0148297707,
0.0501152836,
0.0008909081,
-0.0199120305,
-0.0321629606,
0.0199264959,
0.0252765138,
-0.0868720785,
-0.040842928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09411v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09411v1 | Surveying the Landscape of Text Summarization with Deep Learning: A Comprehensive Review | 2023-10-13T21:24:37 | 2023-10-13T21:24:37 | Guanghua Wang, Weili Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In recent years, deep learning has revolutionized natural language processing
(NLP) by enabling the development of models that can learn complex
representations of language data, leading to significant improvements in
performance across a wide range of NLP tasks. Deep learning models for NLP
typically use large amounts of data to train deep neural networks, allowing
them to learn the patterns and relationships in language data. This is in
contrast to traditional NLP approaches, which rely on hand-engineered features
and rules to perform NLP tasks. The ability of deep neural networks to learn
hierarchical representations of language data, handle variable-length input
sequences, and perform well on large datasets makes them well-suited for NLP
applications. Driven by the exponential growth of textual data and the
increasing demand for condensed, coherent, and informative summaries, text
summarization has been a critical research area in the field of NLP. Applying
deep learning to text summarization refers to the use of deep neural networks
to perform text summarization tasks. In this survey, we begin with a review of
fashionable text summarization tasks in recent years, including extractive,
abstractive, multi-document, and so on. Next, we discuss most deep
learning-based models and their experimental results on these tasks. The paper
also covers datasets and data representation for summarization tasks. Finally,
we delve into the opportunities and challenges associated with summarization
tasks and their corresponding methodologies, aiming to inspire future research
efforts to advance the field further. A goal of our survey is to explain how
these methods differ in their requirements as understanding them is essential
for choosing a technique suited for a specific setting. | [
0.0261886343,
0.0513113998,
0.0249630772,
0.0126924124,
-0.038347356,
-0.0092335697,
-0.0114156771,
-0.0609633811,
-0.0012076166,
-0.026388403,
0.0102079613,
-0.0390880629,
0.034041509,
0.0229656324,
-0.0059828255,
-0.0869941562,
0.0071163406,
-0.0066904761,
0.0059476546,
0.0276736449,
0.010982316,
0.0190136358,
0.0211613737,
0.0346732847,
-0.0084908204,
-0.0129820695,
-0.0036150524,
-0.0114431735,
0.0383541584,
-0.0074293721,
0.0333897769,
-0.0160737894,
0.0521366596,
0.0236217547,
0.0000018343,
-0.0254824907,
-0.0287091918,
-0.0257229041,
-0.0097937705,
0.0141752949,
0.0396771133,
-0.0564496405,
0.0179992113,
0.0023291311,
-0.022760924,
-0.0076750517,
-0.0052536577,
0.0757680088,
0.0559550747,
0.0492625423,
-0.0149387615,
-0.0468809232,
0.0739495382,
-0.0260913,
-0.0542337447,
0.0019338015,
0.0100750448,
-0.0143620372,
-0.0268779472,
-0.0018195988,
-0.0011512183,
0.038910307,
0.0303088836,
-0.0100772558,
-0.0119879171,
0.0199634917,
-0.0568336435,
-0.0056654327,
0.0001118235,
0.0961854085,
-0.0456582978,
-0.0027289323,
0.019882381,
-0.0064153653,
-0.0059968345,
-0.0294266157,
-0.0522988811,
0.0695299655,
0.0146186883,
0.0562170222,
-0.0016996542,
0.0492301397,
-0.0077232267,
0.067183204,
-0.0541544408,
0.0203588922,
-0.0329605639,
-0.0123467734,
-0.0029418506,
0.0003838546,
-0.0138938343,
-0.0390749536,
0.039744731,
0.0422359295,
0.0137175042,
-0.0051688612,
-0.0479732044,
-0.0812901407,
0.0337259583,
-0.0290751159,
-0.0070576975,
-0.0100477235,
0.0173814464,
0.0555295423,
-0.036698021,
0.0033305108,
0.0146560455,
0.0007577335,
-0.0168390404,
-0.034192685,
-0.0155406622,
-0.0064952322,
-0.0248091035,
0.0589291081,
-0.0386522971,
-0.0360434949,
-0.0314262398,
0.0106995562,
-0.0054021934,
0.0245643966,
-0.0227245484,
0.0600584969,
0.0077646137,
0.0136310086,
-0.0012459154,
0.0294768084,
-0.0374108441,
-0.0143001815,
0.0496189892,
-0.0017439802,
0.0076671615,
0.0286613293,
0.0688764602,
0.004395179,
0.0403549671,
0.0305428896,
-0.0046318346,
-0.0397251807,
-0.0139369564,
-0.0323954783,
-0.0029475063,
-0.0328490697,
0.0090920804,
-0.0813328996,
0.0052687968,
-0.0416071117,
-0.0352438651,
-0.0246247761,
-0.0030453284,
0.0460898764,
-0.0562592484,
0.0315499939,
-0.0362639613,
-0.013433706,
0.0560651682,
0.012615744,
0.023125587,
0.0159272961,
0.0681225732,
0.0537255704,
0.0651943982,
0.0212872829,
0.0144974263,
0.0227517374,
0.0040854518,
-0.0208967384,
0.0298147891,
-0.0388143025,
-0.0870952085,
-0.009012959,
0.0130099691,
0.0589205883,
-0.0338046923,
0.0166342575,
0.0660469756,
0.0790423751,
-0.0083217146,
0.0421818309,
0.0202579349,
0.028144246,
0.0474036746,
0.0316053256,
-0.0154448645,
0.0117368381,
0.0029636584,
0.0517020188,
0.0658026636,
0.0250464492,
-0.0258856621,
-0.0582988262,
0.0261742212,
-0.0333940648,
0.0232822634,
0.0128096929,
0.0318388231,
0.0182043854,
-0.033444725,
0.0285021625,
0.007119162,
-0.0548009574,
0.013184607,
-0.0073959851,
0.0007216324,
0.0289412495,
0.0207634401,
-0.0625570118,
-0.0245194435,
-0.0071795625,
0.0197967645,
0.0291944519,
0.02944359,
-0.0003000737,
0.0104952808,
-0.0603739098,
-0.0301772878,
-0.0224538893,
-0.012223796,
-0.0254277196,
-0.0381075107,
-0.0069987443,
0.0389679298,
0.0141729079,
-0.0737392977,
0.030529093,
-0.014894465,
-0.0220434107,
0.0222369637,
0.0106095616,
0.014000101,
0.0554916486,
-0.0067621572,
0.0225610305,
0.0432155393,
-0.0409146734,
-0.031545002,
-0.0195757356,
-0.0603869259,
-0.0238455571,
0.0038000455,
-0.061686378,
0.0057575791,
0.0495869108,
-0.0531564802,
-0.049653776,
0.0303011443,
-0.0557081886,
-0.0100089964,
-0.0177024417,
-0.0119531294,
0.0285947546,
0.0263175629,
-0.0176246911,
0.0620326586,
0.0066456641,
-0.0202425234,
0.0419345424,
-0.0208320245,
0.0106312865,
-0.0098746624,
-0.0117778638,
-0.000979088,
-0.0200270452,
0.0035614131,
0.0565417074,
0.0176257882,
-0.0216185376,
0.0111248121,
-0.081145063,
0.0275499653,
-0.0296450537,
0.020771483,
0.0267993193,
0.0250275265,
0.00938736,
-0.0162519198,
-0.0675279349,
-0.0352581404,
0.02891233,
-0.0129351784,
0.050322596,
0.0042845621,
0.0282700434,
-0.0757735521,
-0.0468860827,
-0.0172849558,
0.0540635325,
-0.0123189343,
-0.0264689438,
0.0222533382,
-0.0125934128,
-0.0198984053,
0.0169898625,
0.0069903661,
0.0182533581,
-0.0216156524,
-0.0185757466,
0.0434521101,
0.0493841991,
0.0336792395,
0.01807498,
0.019282423,
0.0291569009,
-0.0205330513,
0.0034405387,
-0.0437305868,
0.0749866217,
0.0250372346,
-0.0134502398,
0.0242292117,
0.0517408624,
0.0141851138,
-0.0255228933,
0.0126546947,
0.028780777,
0.0118978694,
-0.0161377825,
-0.0291908626,
-0.0272789337,
0.0021546546,
0.0225798711,
-0.0429735295,
0.0013316825,
0.0429884754,
-0.003871239,
0.024001779,
-0.0713878348,
-0.0323261246,
-0.083150357,
0.0500173382,
0.04271584,
0.013138664,
-0.0035911589,
-0.0110798804,
-0.0140252765,
-0.0247289259,
-0.0180222541,
0.0049727811,
0.0820144042,
-0.0456666872,
0.0037572512,
-0.0437569246,
-0.0034926627,
-0.0132443924,
-0.025736995,
-0.0095662475,
0.0465671979,
0.0283698905,
0.0190870352,
-0.0403216891,
-0.0343066156,
0.0279533956,
0.0953018814,
-0.0225099828,
-0.0210689697,
-0.0487445444,
0.0877919123,
0.081361562,
-0.0022575965,
0.0579784065,
-0.0096699363,
0.0212979652,
0.0492666513,
0.0351156332,
0.0028984195,
-0.0209532827,
-0.0137284985,
-0.014994232,
-0.0839169472,
0.0259964652,
-0.0002093355,
0.0268371589,
-0.0665307194,
0.0152866868,
0.0886621624,
0.0193959791,
-0.0340091176,
0.0063895253,
0.0369594321,
0.0110306405,
-0.0229377281,
-0.0231906362,
-0.0475287177,
-0.0209533311,
-0.0081889443,
-0.0008114757,
0.0015730034,
-0.0321209244,
0.0139408289,
-0.0628052875,
-0.0027094539,
-0.0215616822,
-0.0663807318,
-0.0402066223,
-0.0306858793,
0.0101153161,
-0.0168231949,
0.0486137085,
-0.0278482474,
-0.0458026603,
-0.0212112889,
0.0028207295,
-0.0964057818,
0.0191684514,
-0.0091424761,
-0.0521826744,
-0.0306297597,
0.0724975988,
0.0529885441,
-0.0178858656,
0.0480590984,
0.0254967902,
-0.0402215235,
-0.0241497178,
0.0262573678,
0.0888439938,
-0.0031714942,
0.0070178597,
-0.0253264979,
0.0562886223,
-0.0549471192,
0.0137816966,
0.0168730076,
0.0157889221,
0.015169262,
-0.0595066361,
-0.0769036934,
0.0146331619,
-0.0423782393,
0.0591639504,
0.0178709496,
-0.0341327935,
-0.0547890626,
-0.0286550056,
0.0037562912,
-0.0856510848,
-0.0249468461,
-0.0117540415,
-0.014465183,
-0.0005033734,
-0.0733519122,
-0.089244239,
0.0281222071,
-0.0604209006,
-0.0056972741,
0.0049638725,
0.0298753157,
0.0135098379,
-0.018403193,
0.0103227505,
-0.0030600252,
0.0007352837,
-0.0070663211,
0.0067523816,
0.0491563492,
-0.0174937285,
-0.0340475328,
0.017794406,
-0.0586213246,
-0.0296161901,
-0.0327645577,
0.0258380342,
0.0126664676,
0.0767848417,
0.0227484498,
-0.0271331761,
0.065715827,
0.0188167263,
0.0062617487,
-0.0280107409,
0.0077482574,
0.0355873965,
-0.0354781151,
0.0200346541,
-0.0612663329,
0.0450048372,
-0.031436529,
0.0186906382,
-0.0379515849,
-0.0442068912,
-0.0081067923,
-0.0056943423,
0.0073512546,
0.0081442939,
-0.0272247083,
-0.0324763879,
-0.0193290841,
-0.0045072162,
-0.015565468,
-0.0253571142,
0.0514270999,
-0.0271770842,
0.0251743905,
-0.0274428986,
0.0494359359,
0.0576605052,
0.0166313611,
-0.0246044379,
0.0148502691,
-0.0078467038,
-0.0157531109,
-0.0775236413,
-0.0057814531,
-0.0587260835,
-0.0074306987,
-0.0594701432,
0.0068050474,
-0.0188620631,
-0.0270998739,
0.0460348055,
-0.0011230096,
-0.0122089414,
0.0478519499,
-0.1000309512,
0.0187055245,
-0.0607319586,
0.003363759,
0.066895701,
-0.073138237,
0.0520543791,
-0.0044679805,
-0.0032402521,
-0.0266037919,
0.015303609,
0.0396097861,
0.0235718414,
-0.0665868074,
0.0290409271,
0.0047973208,
0.0011982421,
0.0533658266,
0.0033622263,
0.0180320591,
0.0359896049,
-0.0286936257,
-0.0345437676,
-0.012061093,
0.0176565628,
0.0506742448,
-0.0023705594,
-0.0180715714,
-0.0028084135,
-0.0106016695,
0.0559130944,
0.018221207,
0.022367714,
-0.0175818484,
0.0406045243,
0.0096160583,
0.0149615528,
-0.0049060918,
-0.0434290729,
-0.0059193266,
0.0029604672,
-0.0039220997,
-0.0307350736,
-5.662364369e-33,
0.0089483866,
0.0065266108,
-0.0409987718,
0.0328204259,
-0.0437309332,
0.0098390179,
-0.071943678,
-0.0470019132,
-0.0217887759,
0.0002326217,
-0.0264210273,
-0.0016056031,
0.0107345562,
0.0724542812,
0.0099673728,
0.0128674237,
0.0349272229,
-0.0074218521,
0.0138809606,
0.0502306893,
0.0181153491,
0.0146397538,
0.0380239561,
-0.0415707491,
0.0190042164,
-0.0242469702,
0.0099428212,
-0.0078672832,
0.0251517612,
0.0433662683,
-0.0067544724,
0.0157299004,
0.0567388907,
-0.0269023329,
-0.0378945284,
0.0381294824,
-0.1011011451,
-0.0362812169,
-0.0428045169,
-0.0332819633,
-0.0854549184,
-0.0352125391,
0.0935473442,
-0.0054782005,
0.045888681,
-0.0392569862,
0.1001933888,
-0.0260121394,
-0.0261245295,
-0.0918304473,
-0.0390089564,
0.0255615134,
-0.0517363623,
-0.011108526,
0.0287770499,
0.0528925918,
0.0051532919,
0.0283759963,
-0.0788017586,
0.0216542799,
0.0263713486,
0.0414107181,
0.0202723574,
0.0016230523,
-0.0083412584,
0.0540148765,
-0.0155834099,
-0.0018063993,
-0.0360412337,
0.0283377096,
0.0214524753,
0.0375343189,
0.017986659,
0.0126843331,
0.0606206357,
0.0447707139,
-0.0628691688,
0.0743365139,
0.0060277483,
0.0119109936,
0.0165503155,
-0.0091857826,
0.0050227395,
0.0160590168,
-0.0246995762,
0.0102918269,
-0.0012728781,
0.001551065,
-0.0251747798,
0.0262742136,
-0.0520378277,
-0.0032639855,
0.0025478497,
-0.0528363138,
0.0083138244,
0.0288743507,
-0.0073087416,
0.0146907875,
0.0334864371,
-0.0309472904,
-0.0425962321,
0.0079689715,
-0.0024404598,
-0.0206441563,
-0.0031551989,
0.0064725522,
0.0661216453,
0.0004252098,
-0.015076505,
0.0054274034,
0.0240032356,
0.0073818299,
-0.0358180478,
0.0778576434,
-0.0160987936,
0.0042632641,
0.0132351108,
0.031735938,
-0.0053900136,
0.0061590266,
-0.0093223853,
0.0103052678,
0.0274710897,
0.0146652674,
-0.0290882327,
-0.0043464531,
-0.0482536405,
0.0108731845,
0.0483902059,
-0.0615990646,
0.0036477635,
-0.0057915272,
2.282e-7,
0.0440099202,
0.019677991,
0.0911029279,
-0.0048473701,
0.0035467299,
0.0230759326,
0.0311195403,
0.0359618813,
0.0017330601,
-0.0050890916,
0.0460827835,
0.0421938896,
0.0307230894,
-0.005714051,
-0.1117915809,
-0.0266029183,
-0.0736877695,
-0.0365135223,
-0.0423437729,
-0.0260530394,
0.0659696236,
0.0974473655,
-0.011764165,
-0.0343839154,
-0.009798266,
-0.0069320011,
0.0130643463,
0.0071701356,
0.0102832885,
0.0357491784,
0.0271813199,
0.0089309299,
-0.0421751551,
-0.030400278,
-0.0014105663,
0.0303797331,
0.054507833,
0.0417474248,
0.0167191196,
-0.0104696527,
0.0204117782,
-0.0136102838,
0.0258165095,
0.0306501556,
0.0668402389,
-0.0659700781,
0.0022538058,
-0.0158855673,
-0.0169253852,
0.0126455659,
-0.0076597785,
-0.0086984616,
-0.0292970128,
0.0564869829,
-0.0064698821,
-0.0231704675,
0.0011075344,
-0.090741381,
-0.0154308416,
0.0260808133,
0.0007343093,
0.0239183344,
-0.0315947309,
-0.0105370143,
0.024531465,
-0.0645826086,
-0.0113038523,
2.32349545e-34,
0.0594075061,
-0.0099675898,
-0.0571310557,
-0.0076942993,
0.000936888,
-0.0276307669,
-0.0314372964,
-0.0093772179,
-0.009801181,
-0.082986407,
-0.0066032046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09357v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09357v1 | A Computational Approach to Style in American Poetry | 2023-10-13T18:49:14 | 2023-10-13T18:49:14 | David M. Kaplan, David M. Blei | cs.CL | cs.CL, J.5; I.2.7 | We develop a quantitative method to assess the style of American poems and to
visualize a collection of poems in relation to one another. Qualitative poetry
criticism helped guide our development of metrics that analyze various
orthographic, syntactic, and phonemic features. These features are used to
discover comprehensive stylistic information from a poem's multi-layered latent
structure, and to compute distances between poems in this space. Visualizations
provide ready access to the analytical components. We demonstrate our method on
several collections of poetry, showing that it better delineates poetry style
than the traditional word-occurrence features that are used in typical text
analysis algorithms. Our method has potential applications to academic research
of texts, to research of the intuitive personal response to poetry, and to
making recommendations to readers based on their favorite poems. | [
0.0055504907,
0.1134573147,
-0.0456577651,
0.0260884352,
-0.0346890725,
0.0225336216,
-0.0157052595,
0.016724458,
-0.0331359357,
-0.0162012465,
0.0092129149,
-0.0076374295,
0.0604031496,
-0.0343107209,
-0.0137501191,
-0.0487455279,
-0.0439100675,
0.0299855918,
0.0698406473,
0.034106642,
0.0291472543,
0.0047965078,
-0.0148821296,
0.034173362,
0.0381543785,
-0.06019805,
-0.0148597285,
0.0264642835,
-0.0028522587,
-0.0285806078,
-0.0431647673,
0.0148381609,
-0.0423066169,
0.009297234,
0.0000016736,
-0.0178778153,
0.0225820243,
-0.0583327226,
0.0663387626,
0.0331202224,
0.0306753237,
-0.0115680397,
-0.0021824492,
-0.0202042609,
-0.0057612206,
-0.0100931516,
0.041027125,
0.0058945199,
0.0280888043,
0.058639925,
-0.0011199815,
-0.0649372116,
0.0212032311,
0.0028082624,
-0.0035552066,
0.0540651754,
0.0126070743,
0.0095695592,
0.0324366838,
-0.0106550241,
-0.0730629265,
0.0076891133,
-0.0413450226,
0.0080739101,
0.0118081197,
0.02115307,
-0.0226053167,
0.0514791384,
0.0204739999,
0.0049642962,
0.0337139107,
-0.021261692,
0.0450535566,
0.0183243752,
-0.0478658788,
0.0042209858,
-0.0428744443,
0.0076303836,
0.0001690131,
0.0092213824,
-0.0259133354,
-0.0224508159,
-0.0280321855,
0.0022979402,
0.0142801097,
0.0015596395,
0.018455198,
-0.0171975717,
-0.0043346812,
-0.0098960157,
0.0082157794,
-0.0355959833,
0.023628924,
0.0057180482,
0.0195281897,
-0.0020775048,
0.0281927381,
-0.0885740891,
0.006716467,
0.0024058495,
0.1212670207,
0.0082924571,
0.0375153162,
-0.0160822049,
0.0207673535,
0.0056046792,
0.0386209972,
-0.030323239,
-0.059394408,
0.0464980267,
-0.0323360935,
0.0068490175,
-0.0344872214,
-0.0516581051,
0.0344382934,
-0.0322244354,
-0.0224630237,
-0.0407433659,
0.0090615414,
-0.0132134464,
0.0147954449,
0.0303928684,
0.0462296195,
0.0318163484,
0.0111001395,
0.0024955606,
-0.049154494,
0.0245001633,
-0.0581516549,
0.0111857271,
0.0011492433,
0.0227220226,
0.0696187615,
-0.0207691565,
-0.0266938843,
0.0110536953,
0.0357333235,
-0.0345530137,
-0.0109254364,
-0.0056920666,
-0.0090138037,
-0.0001038446,
0.0086596636,
-0.0388375036,
0.0116763972,
-0.0207397956,
0.0494901389,
-0.0163360666,
-0.0101262322,
0.0116919987,
-0.0190074425,
0.0227149297,
-0.0159170777,
0.0167037509,
-0.0475498587,
-0.0127030928,
0.0477696843,
0.004460963,
0.0657753274,
0.0081793992,
0.0338551551,
-0.0264721867,
0.0051649306,
-0.0287576932,
-0.0340792574,
0.0018851508,
-0.0417344533,
-0.0521211587,
-0.036672052,
0.0654096678,
0.0110218097,
0.0270452108,
-0.0097982865,
-0.0261987634,
0.044069469,
0.0857385024,
0.0862645879,
0.0373075716,
0.0383976474,
0.0449510552,
0.0674320981,
0.0124258334,
0.0186057631,
0.0016876474,
0.03266396,
0.0203212108,
0.0254383218,
0.019425638,
0.0142381303,
-0.0095257536,
-0.0403262489,
0.0076241,
0.0122284414,
-0.0376762711,
-0.011546704,
0.0109803639,
0.0402282923,
-0.0480483212,
0.0385168046,
-0.0440301672,
-0.027513409,
0.0413223021,
0.0247679763,
0.1146180481,
0.0465528183,
-0.0236487761,
0.1235610619,
0.015303351,
0.0018347984,
-0.0227026083,
-0.0475924499,
0.0087935533,
0.0263133533,
0.0085200146,
0.0343047455,
0.0168958679,
0.0419969372,
-0.0088200895,
-0.0735296682,
0.0751838461,
-0.0276372116,
-0.020410737,
-0.0435841158,
0.0284163412,
0.0353446752,
-0.0441464223,
0.0444008633,
0.0154517526,
0.014959733,
0.0363547057,
-0.0408809707,
0.0368291885,
-0.0059927683,
-0.0295785647,
0.0200082641,
0.0671695396,
0.013875124,
-0.009006544,
0.0398096964,
-0.073875308,
0.0646119341,
-0.0099958414,
0.0305700786,
-0.0504137054,
0.089380756,
-0.0556650236,
0.0503936931,
-0.0092211505,
0.0138847418,
-0.0227567181,
0.021040285,
-0.0263405144,
0.0095904749,
0.0129048852,
0.0648933575,
-0.0600204356,
-0.0130308233,
0.0201959871,
0.0423447117,
-0.025220219,
-0.0240710899,
0.0390925594,
0.0117949937,
-0.0242635012,
-0.0568962507,
-0.0411493368,
-0.0356817283,
-0.0840813592,
-0.0225473773,
-0.0216158479,
0.0108300494,
0.027587682,
-0.0223081689,
-0.0591113158,
0.0139994686,
-0.0021109795,
0.0144855445,
-0.0290624164,
0.0213111322,
0.0222816523,
-0.0161676258,
-0.0320765823,
-0.0307150502,
-0.0131120663,
-0.0427526124,
0.0465109944,
-0.0206231941,
-0.0138172489,
-0.0038684905,
-0.0273365974,
0.0004205614,
-0.0547992215,
0.0209581163,
-0.037198212,
0.016335614,
-0.0538264289,
0.0238942429,
0.0434961356,
-0.0109895999,
0.0080601405,
0.0676313862,
-0.0551308133,
0.0354404077,
-0.026183581,
0.031807743,
0.0742997453,
0.0404594354,
-0.073185727,
0.021726761,
0.0096908668,
0.0272567458,
-0.0349237062,
0.028819263,
0.0827723667,
0.0129008023,
0.0240786672,
-0.0132436464,
-0.0003388717,
-0.0120131448,
0.0314960927,
0.01463171,
0.0099463696,
0.0161666181,
-0.0414980091,
0.0198698193,
-0.0452333838,
-0.007771539,
-0.0508198291,
0.0649084747,
0.0232195687,
0.0050048707,
-0.0254455023,
-0.0388534293,
0.0309546739,
0.0564488806,
0.0473784208,
-0.0219568443,
0.0372864269,
-0.013723271,
-0.039165169,
0.0078903986,
0.0209404714,
0.0255877823,
0.0074713407,
-0.0226941071,
-0.0279174969,
0.0360704213,
-0.0631801561,
0.035567645,
-0.0143965194,
-0.0257052425,
0.0142305661,
-0.0212695505,
-0.0008734419,
-0.0236138161,
0.0671636164,
0.0319535211,
-0.0185960941,
-0.0284761488,
0.0403201878,
0.0050928565,
-0.0199588723,
-0.0274368301,
0.0640880838,
-0.0322891846,
0.0231054854,
-0.0065869796,
-0.0289217234,
0.0159937367,
0.0108127072,
-0.0053914548,
-0.0231995881,
-0.0222018138,
0.0769444704,
0.0375703052,
-0.0518629104,
0.0073938104,
-0.0374253169,
-0.0076136407,
0.0181945525,
0.0311343428,
-0.0260316413,
0.0058950544,
-0.0172806568,
0.0235766843,
0.0045052981,
-0.0488423407,
-0.0292608049,
-0.0228199158,
-0.0206493121,
0.0014217894,
-0.0148474118,
0.0277814604,
-0.0006914187,
0.006057526,
0.0122715095,
-0.0851001069,
-0.0103851547,
-0.0330684148,
0.0353706554,
-0.0065927152,
-0.0240969341,
0.0232781824,
-0.0476855896,
-0.0667060986,
-0.0149054052,
0.0003704294,
0.0769508481,
-0.0213366654,
-0.0656445846,
-0.0622692443,
-0.0328754298,
0.0123736663,
0.0288372673,
0.0107623246,
0.0582459681,
0.0027864771,
-0.0470880084,
0.0043667406,
0.0006937091,
-0.014052392,
0.0576245189,
0.0047394871,
-0.0457977876,
-0.0081848353,
-0.0526045375,
0.0622848012,
-0.0000952111,
-0.0257519856,
0.0788155943,
-0.03199986,
-0.0611086935,
-0.0683074519,
0.038406074,
-0.0737178698,
-0.073093906,
-0.0272084996,
0.015103016,
-0.0331616253,
-0.0804675445,
-0.0088582365,
-0.0376499072,
0.0536327064,
0.0682120398,
0.0068198713,
0.0015800177,
-0.0283058025,
-0.0798122957,
-0.0115556289,
-0.0099753654,
0.0239132848,
0.0368929692,
-0.0348829329,
0.0164990965,
-0.0434601568,
0.0127320271,
-0.0086535867,
-0.0726317912,
-0.0248999353,
0.0150403949,
-0.0192245189,
0.0141499778,
-0.0409516804,
-0.0424399935,
-0.0652167425,
0.0002879471,
0.0305210967,
0.0476613306,
0.0429840535,
-0.0313801393,
0.0013690172,
0.0031980542,
0.0021714377,
0.0407824814,
0.0012426777,
0.0074688909,
0.019084271,
-0.006500307,
-0.0338563584,
0.0312411133,
-0.0372813493,
0.048105292,
0.0058615468,
-0.0035503316,
-0.0070451051,
-0.0607915334,
-0.0507553034,
-0.013281974,
-0.0023512591,
-0.0295920577,
0.0180401932,
0.0030765294,
-0.0626952723,
-0.0061275312,
0.0039422116,
-0.0046828119,
-0.0322772935,
0.0341237672,
0.04727301,
-0.023402039,
-0.0553703643,
-0.0078699524,
0.0095949778,
0.0143773267,
-0.0162700769,
0.0416802876,
0.0531960316,
-0.0258974526,
0.0126310121,
-0.0114333276,
-0.0376662463,
0.039525982,
-0.0736002102,
0.0093904333,
0.0221955366,
-0.0537632219,
0.0365735441,
-0.0672579929,
0.05001029,
-0.0075609647,
0.0080011338,
0.0079850089,
0.0176571831,
0.0154876327,
-0.0133040166,
-0.0421505086,
0.0403718874,
0.0178733524,
-0.0473582633,
0.0494382009,
-0.0379082263,
-0.0559071265,
0.0448011085,
-0.0589126125,
0.0107974941,
-0.0243936013,
-0.0026263536,
0.0491069704,
0.0353225358,
-0.0099491701,
-0.0425758772,
-0.022443844,
0.0296765957,
-0.0094764782,
0.0482556149,
-0.0100049302,
0.0254702363,
0.0210372601,
-0.0140557829,
0.0136588626,
-0.0594288372,
-0.0053854445,
-0.0651715696,
-0.0311098527,
0.0054245899,
-5.324132768e-33,
-0.0357557759,
-0.0473335087,
-0.0432600118,
0.0093398048,
-0.0349259526,
-0.0251789559,
-0.0465068929,
0.0399476998,
0.0033131219,
0.0191094987,
-0.0438171811,
0.0109354015,
-0.0160554647,
0.0006999921,
0.0647866949,
0.0582103506,
0.0171548128,
-0.0058824457,
-0.0305557009,
-0.0220177285,
0.0195368715,
-0.0052109193,
-0.0128506329,
-0.0559487753,
0.0349277183,
-0.0392869338,
-0.0063384157,
-0.0387429036,
0.0490252115,
-0.0050338251,
-0.0165314339,
0.0289440844,
0.0303327348,
0.0179502815,
-0.0175010525,
0.0004045614,
-0.022730507,
-0.0703249276,
0.0108904298,
0.0206455085,
0.018403966,
-0.0567340441,
0.0277185142,
-0.014442577,
-0.0153684737,
0.0015265434,
0.0404434651,
-0.0264332425,
-0.0014376354,
-0.0629825592,
-0.0028505949,
-0.0165946092,
-0.0494285375,
0.0045389342,
0.0250881445,
-0.0581198558,
0.0066477116,
0.0383749716,
-0.0344292074,
0.0378482342,
-0.0471544117,
0.019975761,
-0.0446338207,
-0.0047164094,
0.026401259,
0.054818958,
0.0334170945,
-0.0155851655,
-0.0357408896,
0.0971466675,
0.0297334362,
-0.0021079809,
0.0527335629,
0.0341805294,
0.0590031892,
-0.0138585232,
0.0190687999,
0.0121890875,
0.0121596875,
-0.0289900731,
0.0235959813,
0.0157490652,
-0.015783608,
-0.0391274914,
0.0465110652,
-0.0793070942,
-0.0083846729,
0.0208613947,
-0.0405690819,
-0.0186527595,
-0.0018753693,
-0.0005820108,
-0.0367029607,
-0.0331397019,
-0.0521171018,
0.027057223,
-0.0178224016,
0.0756011903,
-0.0132350093,
-0.0261906758,
0.0303298961,
0.0014811411,
0.0254355501,
0.0082406467,
0.0276843812,
-0.0337862112,
0.0541546158,
-0.0043548937,
-0.0629056543,
-0.022965353,
-0.0043625655,
-0.0184524264,
0.0062956274,
-0.0075453534,
0.0124756973,
0.0116610397,
0.0247656628,
0.0613490641,
0.0489388742,
0.0246807765,
0.0079124244,
-0.0170043837,
-0.0281675607,
-0.0143164583,
-0.0089352569,
-0.0164756756,
-0.0077591739,
-0.0190963391,
0.0169166625,
-0.0450644419,
-0.022955142,
-0.0153265297,
2.614e-7,
0.0429229625,
0.0337767415,
0.0707043782,
0.0341787115,
0.0480928347,
-0.0016393147,
-0.042616684,
0.0462376885,
-0.0341671556,
0.0125341099,
0.0688721165,
0.012750892,
0.0431260355,
0.0293224938,
-0.1309630573,
0.0200438481,
-0.0593813099,
-0.053597454,
-0.1014133394,
-0.0034495527,
0.0771096721,
0.0026666303,
0.0220876727,
0.0262385774,
0.0220591091,
-0.0345615447,
-0.0143040009,
-0.025192244,
0.0572266169,
-0.0142483544,
0.0060255774,
-0.0626076087,
0.0046480531,
0.0033751826,
0.0021839943,
0.0111913653,
0.0522808768,
-0.0024753767,
0.0029888258,
0.0212146696,
0.0158916339,
-0.0070559904,
0.0055173668,
0.0099092023,
0.0482699759,
0.1366643459,
-0.0328762494,
0.0083007487,
0.0162468608,
-0.0033976824,
0.0443637446,
0.0023576627,
-0.0497923717,
0.005165129,
0.0047280653,
-0.0311602764,
0.0415849313,
-0.0266776066,
-0.0125093544,
0.0088458546,
-0.0024333552,
0.0176335964,
0.0218663514,
0.0250989199,
0.0259098131,
-0.0797396451,
-0.0214095172,
2.11784432e-34,
0.0622433163,
-0.0290941,
0.0160095319,
-0.009544936,
0.0258899741,
-0.0002480863,
0.0179542154,
-0.0168420896,
0.0009638403,
-0.0544557273,
-0.0291872304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09350v1 | Unsupervised Domain Adaption for Neural Information Retrieval | 2023-10-13T18:27:33 | 2023-10-13T18:27:33 | Carlos Dominguez, Jon Ander Campos, Eneko Agirre, Gorka Azkune | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Neural information retrieval requires costly annotated data for each target
domain to be competitive. Synthetic annotation by query generation using Large
Language Models or rule-based string manipulation has been proposed as an
alternative, but their relative merits have not been analysed. In this paper,
we compare both methods head-to-head using the same neural IR architecture. We
focus on the BEIR benchmark, which includes test datasets from several domains
with no training data, and explore two scenarios: zero-shot, where the
supervised system is trained in a large out-of-domain dataset (MS-MARCO); and
unsupervised domain adaptation, where, in addition to MS-MARCO, the system is
fine-tuned in synthetic data from the target domain. Our results indicate that
Large Language Models outperform rule-based methods in all scenarios by a large
margin, and, more importantly, that unsupervised domain adaptation is effective
compared to applying a supervised IR system in a zero-shot fashion. In addition
we explore several sizes of open Large Language Models to generate synthetic
data and find that a medium-sized model suffices. Code and models are publicly
available for reproducibility. | [
0.0599853061,
0.018448595,
0.0053316415,
0.0087588094,
-0.0155352633,
0.0134908659,
0.0290961079,
0.016109366,
0.0175981633,
-0.0522789359,
-0.0674467534,
-0.0149541842,
-0.0679656416,
0.0269680545,
-0.0047405539,
0.0170284007,
0.0396712981,
-0.0024100025,
-0.0240115002,
0.0364311785,
-0.0193016808,
0.0135698402,
0.0217429399,
0.0276562627,
-0.0093261134,
0.0079493904,
-0.0196584184,
0.0304809418,
-0.0405820943,
-0.0080097113,
0.0193160102,
0.0360696986,
0.0599098727,
0.0524211787,
0.000001932,
-0.048848547,
-0.0528813861,
0.010204603,
-0.0115136532,
0.0071435235,
0.0457056463,
0.0350168943,
0.0306627396,
0.0171630941,
-0.055020161,
-0.0564518906,
0.0521415956,
0.0342818722,
0.0526603758,
0.1045241132,
-0.0115091084,
-0.0253780354,
-0.0039404342,
-0.0469742082,
-0.0015210458,
-0.0509897172,
0.0473678857,
-0.014131845,
-0.0127383992,
0.046265468,
-0.0140203452,
0.0108494405,
0.0081029497,
-0.0399280488,
0.0130387908,
0.0073101562,
-0.0604833327,
0.0162802748,
0.041273687,
0.0624387749,
-0.0210567173,
-0.0205731522,
-0.0032408875,
0.0427118391,
0.0171399955,
0.0104258424,
-0.0116759669,
-0.0286818203,
-0.0002600001,
0.0000213911,
-0.0316617191,
0.0044379719,
0.026481133,
-0.0015521237,
-0.0389135927,
0.0499535948,
0.0129726054,
-0.0127319079,
0.0045850775,
0.0000675411,
-0.0249672104,
-0.0243775379,
0.0064507667,
0.0181710124,
0.0230581947,
0.0252658185,
-0.0569422618,
-0.0193214118,
-0.0141148772,
-0.0680457652,
0.0193712786,
0.0406536274,
-0.0100314487,
0.0639222488,
-0.0305288061,
0.0255779922,
-0.0336455442,
-0.0001680275,
-0.0744952336,
-0.0408644564,
-0.0869792774,
-0.0059858947,
-0.0607404113,
0.0441104472,
-0.076149784,
-0.0014916961,
-0.0163776819,
0.0328445919,
0.0369254313,
-0.0705768764,
0.03290103,
0.0051034368,
-0.0559165701,
0.0112895416,
-0.0750295892,
0.032908313,
-0.0118328612,
-0.0214919206,
0.0123618478,
-0.0476981774,
-0.0041419459,
0.0144332154,
-0.003344608,
-0.0617107563,
-0.0030439463,
0.0578994267,
0.0058633243,
-0.0317021497,
-0.0473284125,
-0.0078627961,
0.020125825,
-0.0167534184,
0.0702869222,
-0.0274348389,
0.0344802998,
-0.0373215415,
-0.0156649109,
-0.0867241398,
0.0031385771,
0.0485212989,
-0.0209753234,
0.0554026477,
-0.0615094155,
-0.0330569558,
0.026976211,
-0.0258188695,
0.0285924394,
0.0725246519,
0.0109185157,
-0.0081618503,
0.0339345932,
0.0381730795,
0.0269762985,
-0.0045679817,
0.0231494438,
0.0015891143,
0.0114265941,
0.0426912047,
0.0166886058,
0.0428722575,
0.0504302494,
0.0162481591,
-0.0346157886,
-0.0540893488,
-0.0085529201,
0.005219474,
0.067719534,
0.0020238182,
0.0568498746,
0.0000553118,
-0.0140283201,
-0.0215856582,
-0.0340800695,
0.0357871503,
-0.0174244493,
-0.0147304693,
0.0199327469,
0.0001360647,
-0.0567512251,
-0.0505936183,
0.0085946042,
0.0381938666,
-0.0314881466,
0.0038413652,
0.0571969748,
0.0239510871,
0.0144108059,
0.0351761095,
0.0525839217,
0.0002459362,
0.0199917275,
-0.0637188852,
-0.0162324086,
0.0528117083,
0.0443462059,
-0.0685115308,
0.0060605695,
0.0063288091,
0.0394549854,
0.05959443,
0.0323698297,
-0.0192235503,
-0.0091716032,
-0.0567019805,
-0.0408063494,
-0.0059676873,
0.0075338259,
0.0087744612,
0.0042479881,
-0.0091293398,
0.0315172672,
-0.0774138123,
-0.0466326065,
0.0511390567,
-0.0345028006,
-0.0652642921,
0.0494224839,
-0.0138415582,
0.0005304355,
0.001291455,
-0.0304533187,
0.0121232094,
0.0276498664,
-0.0229645818,
-0.0311702415,
-0.0444773063,
-0.0208230149,
-0.0383639187,
0.0264686681,
-0.0429084748,
0.0539396964,
0.0028786368,
-0.0183850043,
-0.0182883814,
-0.0002759514,
-0.005400606,
0.0221547019,
-0.0525679924,
0.0112208268,
0.009132605,
0.0216398556,
-0.104676351,
0.0348832607,
0.0465857536,
-0.001651707,
-0.0313140117,
-0.0066516269,
0.0137666967,
-0.0388676599,
-0.0248981919,
0.0064803907,
-0.0093175247,
-0.0023682299,
0.0073755966,
0.0140469735,
-0.0286917891,
0.003709283,
-0.0671922192,
0.0154932095,
-0.0276161451,
-0.0043149865,
0.0257674679,
0.050753653,
-0.0037066396,
-0.0205758065,
-0.0252570584,
-0.0191176515,
-0.0408196971,
0.0433328152,
0.0376836546,
0.0265570134,
0.0100992508,
-0.0365603566,
-0.0495342202,
-0.0083568189,
0.0758562684,
0.010813551,
-0.0487040989,
-0.0545285866,
0.0178065263,
-0.0561471544,
0.0590654165,
-0.0050471164,
-0.0069103641,
-0.0189172141,
-0.0621455684,
0.0040548565,
0.0384416021,
0.0237255711,
-0.0163696017,
0.0663691834,
0.0031861486,
-0.076580748,
0.059317328,
-0.0366016999,
-0.0160866063,
-0.0074629574,
0.0073548765,
0.0597220361,
-0.0087198932,
-0.0342186354,
-0.0263216458,
-0.0395992957,
0.0527450405,
0.0012281262,
-0.0187334549,
-0.0460600965,
0.0426684916,
0.0230510738,
0.0664741918,
-0.0178718977,
0.0136280973,
0.0441039167,
0.0226656925,
0.0274238884,
-0.0959088579,
-0.0033610507,
-0.0619023852,
0.0385948084,
-0.0117807267,
0.0287614055,
0.0380941741,
0.0116166379,
-0.0107146082,
0.0110759651,
-0.0098651815,
-0.0060464754,
0.0342374444,
-0.017317757,
0.0717394575,
-0.0024324814,
-0.0359337032,
-0.028403379,
-0.050894551,
0.0255939327,
0.0041787843,
0.0242391173,
-0.0143875601,
-0.0320318751,
0.0313637443,
0.0164548326,
0.0723132715,
-0.0170908701,
-0.0482015982,
0.0209890865,
0.0022998475,
0.0471580438,
-0.0029519424,
-0.0453159697,
0.0406346545,
0.0115370033,
0.0064868997,
-0.0031702251,
-0.0277170595,
-0.0347452611,
0.0027530878,
0.0427959412,
-0.0371166505,
-0.0100454343,
-0.0047760247,
0.0175313763,
-0.0064519108,
-0.0739608929,
0.0824326128,
0.0338274986,
-0.0599077456,
-0.0232394878,
-0.0317661688,
0.0139058344,
0.0394591689,
0.0791993216,
-0.062303707,
-0.0273360722,
0.0108198207,
0.0233320892,
-0.0000420077,
-0.041910056,
-0.0142622823,
-0.1297160089,
0.0420195051,
-0.0313506015,
-0.0507402122,
-0.0376797318,
-0.0431118533,
0.0171907041,
-0.0173727442,
-0.0082162265,
0.0304762013,
-0.0066355271,
-0.0103763938,
0.02269594,
0.0170790665,
-0.0592639521,
-0.0317848995,
-0.0403819829,
0.034539707,
0.0562707931,
0.0202399287,
0.040632721,
-0.0049571097,
0.0391437039,
0.0039773514,
0.0296749435,
-0.0492171757,
0.1259042323,
0.0086389752,
-0.029236665,
-0.01540918,
-0.0257245675,
-0.0289412569,
0.029459659,
-0.015057696,
0.0425619669,
-0.0320540369,
0.0514771566,
-0.0423174277,
-0.0474161245,
-0.0233513657,
0.0557651222,
-0.000732745,
-0.006522635,
-0.0040636514,
-0.0302011147,
-0.0470716506,
-0.0528080724,
-0.0489677414,
0.0175470784,
-0.0340871029,
-0.0312620588,
-0.058102835,
-0.0317245908,
0.0114988638,
0.060585808,
0.0000099996,
0.0084292842,
0.0152787315,
0.010400367,
-0.0421595126,
0.0346153565,
-0.0762484819,
-0.0289099831,
-0.0456789993,
0.0205083173,
0.0554844886,
-0.0545897037,
-0.0394148901,
-0.0253281798,
0.0189651679,
-0.0491279215,
0.0010959528,
0.0286353789,
0.0174563583,
0.0621537641,
-0.0460232832,
-0.02426094,
0.0167966727,
0.0531964861,
-0.0222158097,
-0.0173409302,
-0.0016688999,
-0.0284592863,
0.000873036,
0.0330667347,
-0.0823177323,
0.0326759145,
0.0155862207,
0.0436761566,
-0.0049251444,
-0.0184102394,
0.0722792968,
0.0182034019,
0.0648728684,
0.0382084362,
-0.0134233758,
-0.0339596793,
0.0088404706,
-0.0375511497,
-0.0254552718,
-0.0395997651,
0.0070641953,
0.0458079353,
0.0042581093,
-0.006252524,
0.0468708761,
-0.0192310251,
0.0415197201,
0.0000937256,
-0.0431669205,
0.0006025343,
0.0504547134,
-0.0022376191,
0.0198645145,
-0.0278139021,
0.0238262732,
0.0237629805,
0.0524866842,
-0.0549045391,
0.0177566689,
0.0375693291,
0.0064202384,
-0.0195341315,
0.024100557,
-0.0738011673,
0.0077834036,
-0.0524119362,
0.0353762619,
0.0645635203,
-0.021993909,
-0.006556992,
0.0257508904,
-0.0194119718,
-0.0267932657,
0.0048071831,
0.0381730869,
0.0143311098,
0.0399345309,
0.0272477549,
-0.0265243519,
-0.0085909907,
0.0670908615,
0.0310523268,
0.053712327,
-0.0223954804,
-0.0241954122,
-0.0196932275,
0.0014416156,
0.0102946786,
0.0133185228,
-0.0209141299,
-0.0266348105,
-0.0140595445,
-0.02768909,
-0.0098625766,
-0.0101055717,
-0.0341349877,
0.0027827492,
0.0644885227,
0.0606557317,
0.0286278836,
-0.0178382415,
-0.0234422907,
-0.0257096086,
-0.0010883654,
-0.0167951193,
-0.0354530886,
-6.285735636e-33,
-0.0300639402,
0.0250801314,
0.0460084118,
-0.0235675909,
-0.0161654595,
-0.0324926265,
-0.0013988966,
-0.0515688024,
-0.0443527773,
-0.0138851581,
-0.0243479759,
0.0061798804,
0.0130838379,
0.0040602381,
-0.0175259225,
-0.028835671,
0.0707182735,
-0.0067315325,
0.0036149274,
-0.0022773042,
0.0407098532,
0.0479434803,
0.0207510032,
-0.0831704661,
-0.0156958103,
0.0139384717,
0.027891526,
0.0660115033,
0.0249214098,
0.0704986379,
-0.0106622083,
0.043438103,
0.0346689075,
-0.0438653901,
0.0283544902,
-0.0234749578,
-0.094902873,
-0.024019422,
-0.0205718037,
0.0025096023,
0.008084652,
-0.0400277153,
0.0554960035,
0.0126225669,
-0.0068880189,
0.0070197424,
0.0406303927,
-0.0174074341,
-0.0126831802,
-0.0474336371,
-0.0446175784,
0.0256893691,
0.0531660467,
-0.0212652497,
-0.0161104649,
0.0664181784,
0.0245351288,
0.0291658454,
-0.0660884976,
0.0076234178,
-0.0598556399,
0.06279888,
0.0186011437,
0.0176146906,
0.0003121771,
0.0486004613,
0.0438639149,
0.0305070486,
0.0255369768,
-0.0187511798,
0.0329203829,
-0.0043452699,
0.0323029831,
0.0569594316,
0.0635751709,
-0.0039583296,
-0.0839301571,
0.0230516624,
-0.0267600473,
0.0117276572,
-0.0073260767,
0.0262236595,
-0.0746163204,
-0.0138529185,
-0.013061475,
0.0080222059,
-0.073651202,
-0.0232892483,
0.0498983078,
0.0171986762,
0.0096718278,
0.0096204877,
0.0322813056,
-0.0092811817,
-0.0137330536,
-0.0038908394,
0.0155568607,
-0.0120349554,
0.0017222136,
-0.0081144078,
0.0017803422,
-0.0261874069,
0.0306577645,
0.0227939524,
-0.033103209,
-0.0080364104,
0.0215460174,
0.002420939,
-0.04651656,
-0.0305922814,
-0.0088534905,
-0.0095034884,
-0.0001797251,
0.0369480215,
-0.019729076,
0.0450779609,
-0.0116060879,
0.062477652,
0.0414168425,
-0.0149800153,
0.0086480053,
-0.0501318127,
0.0400583483,
0.0031313524,
-0.015138261,
0.0137598347,
0.0052522332,
0.0427872762,
0.0080955066,
-0.0800597221,
-0.0182295386,
0.0503538065,
2.799e-7,
0.0566905551,
0.046025414,
-0.0059977965,
0.0233253203,
-0.0183835924,
0.0041415985,
-0.0114987269,
0.0238513704,
0.0466472879,
0.0352878645,
-0.0098683052,
0.0126051791,
0.009550469,
0.0061980514,
-0.1159734204,
-0.0466288291,
0.0237858985,
-0.029763978,
-0.0328185447,
-0.0314310268,
0.0373919159,
0.1071469635,
-0.0068003875,
0.0016858331,
-0.0041976254,
-0.0800383538,
0.0330036469,
0.0062829065,
-0.019213384,
0.0137460344,
0.0256655123,
0.0566642694,
-0.0098856278,
0.0086509082,
0.0001767063,
0.0437165089,
0.0172455497,
0.0371253677,
-0.0354487374,
-0.0035464116,
0.017199412,
0.0001362982,
0.0179189146,
0.0023428057,
0.0630234554,
-0.067936413,
0.0175209735,
0.0399859808,
-0.0158932135,
0.0117311999,
-0.0039383527,
-0.0156117575,
-0.0251235515,
0.0043085609,
0.0141664576,
0.0075577782,
-0.0080357604,
-0.0592812337,
0.0080989869,
-0.021420069,
-0.0212000757,
-0.0035935077,
-0.0518222786,
0.0301405229,
0.0420626141,
-0.0116461264,
0.0252882373,
2.469222311e-34,
0.0193852242,
0.0195818003,
-0.0122569604,
0.0152259152,
-0.0032006651,
0.0001152771,
-0.0155332694,
0.0093623241,
0.0073346612,
-0.106545046,
-0.0166978613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09343v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09343v2 | Dialogue Chain-of-Thought Distillation for Commonsense-aware Conversational Agents | 2023-10-13T18:17:23 | 2023-10-22T09:16:52 | Hyungjoo Chae, Yongho Song, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Taeyoon Kwon, Minjin Kim, Youngjae Yu, Dongha Lee, Dongyeop Kang, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Human-like chatbots necessitate the use of commonsense reasoning in order to
effectively comprehend and respond to implicit information present within
conversations. Achieving such coherence and informativeness in responses,
however, is a non-trivial task. Even for large language models (LLMs), the task
of identifying and aggregating key evidence within a single hop presents a
substantial challenge. This complexity arises because such evidence is
scattered across multiple turns in a conversation, thus necessitating
integration over multiple hops. Hence, our focus is to facilitate such
multi-hop reasoning over a dialogue context, namely dialogue chain-of-thought
(CoT) reasoning. To this end, we propose a knowledge distillation framework
that leverages LLMs as unreliable teachers and selectively distills consistent
and helpful rationales via alignment filters. We further present DOCTOR, a
DialOgue Chain-of-ThOught Reasoner that provides reliable CoT rationales for
response generation. We conduct extensive experiments to show that enhancing
dialogue agents with high-quality rationales from DOCTOR significantly improves
the quality of their responses. | [
0.02615159,
0.062767148,
-0.0006072376,
0.0013104422,
-0.0241873283,
-0.0021974137,
-0.0029925592,
-0.0138156936,
0.0444407836,
-0.028637616,
0.0224961545,
0.0208922159,
-0.004751449,
0.0410627797,
-0.0099157123,
-0.0609969646,
0.0219818223,
-0.0366461836,
0.0363867581,
-0.0141935525,
0.0107232826,
0.0405875593,
-0.0297076739,
0.0421505086,
-0.0012326925,
-0.0431223586,
-0.0345116816,
0.0071334904,
0.0360550322,
-0.0100642545,
-0.0165085513,
0.0196383931,
0.0279309675,
0.0121391285,
0.0000020926,
-0.0203376785,
-0.0068582613,
0.008949521,
-0.0515871048,
-0.0247582998,
-0.0337844454,
0.0212778132,
0.0205386132,
0.0190518443,
-0.0486642905,
0.0701736733,
0.0269963667,
0.0430019386,
0.0847122669,
0.055196844,
-0.0065235463,
-0.0082650622,
0.0206776597,
0.0096299071,
0.0044377535,
-0.0593998432,
-0.0046534059,
0.0531079136,
0.0216831155,
0.0242867395,
-0.010443829,
0.0110915527,
0.022770308,
-0.0507887863,
-0.0039300038,
0.0334479697,
-0.0279119872,
-0.0375515819,
-0.0061170841,
0.0914629847,
0.0445294715,
-0.0237071831,
0.0144604091,
0.0104165375,
0.0263442975,
0.0241928026,
-0.0572002493,
0.0139715439,
-0.0129740108,
0.0336940773,
0.0200184081,
0.0076442384,
0.00514775,
0.0241969004,
-0.0494553708,
0.0209320355,
-0.0241927225,
-0.0178316366,
-0.0098309107,
-0.0031700577,
-0.0075394637,
-0.0892705172,
0.0048272721,
0.0834352225,
-0.0674739555,
0.0139597803,
-0.0185823124,
0.0354878828,
0.0105184689,
-0.0126902824,
-0.043300759,
0.0514223464,
0.0086687673,
0.04956799,
-0.0272360872,
0.0304966923,
-0.0046270578,
0.0339650176,
-0.0131720873,
-0.0434168912,
-0.0815232843,
-0.0167347044,
-0.0108628422,
0.0522770584,
-0.0494448207,
-0.0145386867,
0.0045141014,
0.0166508723,
-0.035549812,
0.0232077055,
0.0320928283,
0.033620514,
-0.0066125812,
-0.0280075017,
-0.0513703562,
0.0789312497,
-0.0491487496,
0.0166792963,
0.0783180147,
-0.0334489718,
-0.040711619,
-0.0032824387,
0.0185305532,
0.0027639305,
-0.0110607473,
0.0358757935,
-0.0283935852,
0.0014823742,
-0.0121574113,
-0.0513387136,
-0.0358241349,
-0.0699688196,
-0.0464427806,
-0.0448781587,
0.0141893113,
0.01075939,
-0.0101889605,
-0.024892984,
0.0176634341,
0.0236823056,
-0.0485627167,
0.0489997864,
-0.0345672071,
0.014052812,
-0.0094594946,
0.0251871031,
-0.0342607237,
0.0356675088,
0.0203390829,
0.0042252536,
0.0252535343,
-0.0060867453,
-0.0088378675,
-0.0519237258,
0.0335682966,
-0.0064798812,
0.0319764949,
0.0131971082,
-0.0570701696,
0.0367489345,
0.0311344936,
0.0424856059,
-0.0510640778,
0.0304994192,
0.0644308999,
0.0487166606,
0.0020271866,
0.0128149856,
0.0249086898,
0.0215694029,
-0.0051103197,
0.0384459756,
-0.0491583012,
0.0346845314,
0.0154812662,
-0.0077226283,
0.039766971,
0.0453047045,
-0.0253705438,
-0.0514936298,
0.0287966076,
0.014479572,
0.0429593287,
0.0129447961,
0.0164179206,
0.0102702389,
-0.0203778073,
0.0676092356,
0.0300166216,
-0.0657078549,
-0.0274861977,
-0.0468560755,
0.0167914089,
0.0518037416,
0.0460961685,
0.006946486,
-0.0557904616,
-0.0197767802,
0.0102177244,
0.0328443237,
0.0194408689,
-0.025733389,
0.023351267,
-0.0501671657,
-0.0268835109,
-0.0048196819,
0.0123350741,
-0.0057902755,
0.0003014293,
0.0152289122,
-0.0026413503,
-0.0205620509,
0.0184772592,
-0.0028770324,
-0.0004765347,
0.0051813452,
-0.0115410732,
0.0092091132,
0.0489007309,
0.0297841635,
0.0173457805,
0.0051278574,
0.015214324,
-0.0125515331,
-0.0318581052,
0.0460351072,
-0.0573963672,
-0.0816860348,
0.0523766503,
-0.0231615063,
-0.036765676,
-0.0110885901,
-0.0294739064,
-0.0646639839,
0.0092891697,
-0.0175792594,
0.0259286389,
-0.0320117027,
-0.0037147116,
0.0413362347,
-0.0019349041,
-0.0083771516,
0.0705241412,
-0.0200111363,
-0.046151001,
0.012422828,
0.0004895,
-0.0027586294,
-0.0238937326,
0.0485325381,
0.0174866412,
-0.0060493392,
0.0075557041,
0.0181894246,
0.0195639413,
-0.0286531001,
-0.0222182889,
-0.0895029902,
-0.0196376629,
0.0017689202,
-0.0173648689,
-0.0029477908,
0.009587422,
0.0333492048,
0.003350398,
-0.0559896082,
0.0384766608,
0.0286120735,
0.0050712219,
0.0482475795,
-0.0072867153,
-0.018780591,
-0.0012119921,
0.021948332,
-0.0094362805,
0.0245589055,
-0.0205553267,
0.0383915305,
-0.0247307029,
-0.0157021098,
-0.0606753416,
0.0167206358,
-0.0100047924,
-0.0423468314,
0.0475511178,
0.0014053198,
-0.001079659,
0.0665211082,
0.0219079573,
0.0250214543,
0.0272140149,
-0.0325221531,
-0.0681602582,
0.0497635901,
-0.0153661938,
0.0354387425,
-0.0282075759,
-0.0125735793,
-0.0055878251,
0.0612879246,
-0.0104845511,
0.0050805206,
-0.0928983092,
0.0127431983,
0.0524286292,
-0.0194397215,
-0.0345457233,
-0.0185594261,
-0.0176014937,
0.0572392717,
-0.0173502471,
-0.0151113309,
0.1005420461,
-0.0464729033,
0.0197296944,
-0.0262025949,
-0.0229471996,
-0.0237470437,
0.0274227392,
-0.0483033992,
0.0067047463,
-0.0144572929,
0.011392598,
-0.0361898057,
-0.02527605,
0.0377539583,
-0.0342251919,
0.0581703447,
-0.0647832528,
0.0055512683,
-0.0000175854,
-0.0585016645,
-0.0539289415,
-0.0421575122,
-0.0410449468,
0.0038749739,
0.0064863726,
-0.0195830241,
-0.0484880172,
0.003377036,
0.0235351399,
0.0450569019,
0.0148818968,
-0.0036341529,
-0.0224972311,
0.029708162,
0.0391545929,
0.0505348928,
0.0365287475,
0.0186764766,
0.0855427086,
0.0728446692,
0.0152907185,
-0.0275562592,
0.0080148932,
-0.0026404706,
-0.0081750527,
0.0204637405,
-0.0029983472,
0.0033848509,
0.0865699649,
-0.0379126593,
-0.0285236631,
0.1062251553,
0.0134637449,
-0.0105559379,
0.0044701854,
-0.0268540196,
0.0764990002,
-0.0072930111,
-0.0047637373,
-0.0621100366,
-0.0619993173,
0.0195138101,
0.0009232386,
-0.0139227444,
-0.0687624365,
-0.0005692508,
-0.0804052278,
0.0259158481,
-0.0029503037,
-0.0076070493,
-0.0562010556,
-0.0298265796,
0.0142758703,
0.0050895368,
0.0128543349,
0.0198868439,
0.0244924463,
0.0052740085,
0.009118638,
-0.0059525077,
-0.0164920148,
0.0261552129,
-0.0125418976,
0.0501612537,
0.0323338844,
0.0733916685,
0.0599891916,
-0.0575570278,
-0.0231747963,
-0.0388975777,
0.0076935817,
0.0007912889,
0.0118009942,
-0.0085702753,
0.0126566952,
-0.0282414649,
0.0809318349,
-0.0524866469,
-0.0457867905,
0.0054339855,
0.0626158491,
-0.0311289988,
-0.0019506274,
-0.0236072447,
0.0278059188,
0.0215887912,
0.0949275345,
0.0431733169,
0.0076945755,
-0.0448986702,
-0.0289635062,
-0.0382041633,
-0.0165518057,
0.0013567377,
0.0075149923,
0.0030282072,
0.0241026413,
-0.07764934,
-0.0379083827,
-0.0036895024,
0.0296527576,
-0.0499812104,
-0.0061311303,
0.0205527674,
0.0233687758,
0.0162848532,
0.0258518066,
-0.0265478846,
-0.0151380636,
-0.0032254544,
0.0184367243,
-0.004868417,
-0.0449320003,
-0.0186837483,
0.0522661991,
-0.0452548787,
-0.0499114729,
-0.0299277492,
0.0498414412,
0.0272898693,
0.0595124885,
-0.0156803597,
0.0143736387,
0.0213016868,
0.0098897088,
-0.0293614194,
-0.0155459959,
0.048904933,
0.0438752472,
0.0159059893,
0.0736649036,
-0.0393442027,
-0.0080165789,
-0.0422364064,
0.0760938972,
-0.0452776924,
-0.0335919484,
0.0400005057,
0.000556342,
0.0235646274,
0.0027832517,
0.0196791515,
-0.0073661287,
0.0304751564,
-0.040828906,
-0.0203815531,
-0.0573224351,
0.0264411215,
0.0025234593,
-0.0346947946,
0.0115944939,
-0.0309468899,
-0.027786985,
0.0114956414,
-0.0008219515,
-0.0341010429,
0.0166485608,
-0.0102915131,
0.0268802196,
-0.0432243682,
-0.0046074535,
0.0048899804,
-0.023122184,
0.0239704363,
-0.0072222478,
0.1059879735,
0.0398210399,
-0.0271815304,
0.0049250596,
0.0080644283,
-0.1059904471,
-0.0414961502,
0.0210901275,
0.0212347209,
0.0118718045,
0.0265881307,
0.0695349276,
-0.03727879,
-0.0135764629,
0.0264901593,
0.069054544,
0.0278271735,
0.0022599173,
0.0107502863,
0.0161208119,
-0.0212214552,
0.0008601477,
0.0771126747,
-0.0662304312,
0.0087547572,
0.0008359213,
-0.0245340485,
-0.0418856591,
-0.0670392215,
-0.0487003885,
0.0568083078,
0.0274964254,
0.0087302392,
-0.0678210333,
-0.0447502509,
-0.0421430916,
-0.0072213067,
-0.0020314029,
-0.0333816931,
0.005091948,
0.0586120002,
-0.008109591,
-0.0334647521,
-0.02094502,
0.0167340767,
-0.0588775314,
-0.0069879349,
-0.0234292299,
-6.613298157e-33,
-0.021980539,
-0.0276875887,
0.0233264193,
0.000938885,
-0.0411036536,
-0.0074994611,
-0.0679810792,
-0.035330873,
-0.0333146565,
0.0666181147,
-0.0268543512,
0.0448406488,
0.0019157701,
0.0290894005,
-0.0185060073,
-0.0197714865,
0.0400717668,
0.0448626839,
-0.0342822596,
0.0380931981,
0.065838106,
-0.028349895,
0.0079103587,
-0.0484099723,
0.0128569445,
-0.0027770228,
-0.0068796538,
0.0390559211,
-0.0331063308,
0.0331320167,
-0.0037945497,
0.041613467,
0.0102989515,
-0.0200959779,
-0.0019330923,
0.0240344722,
-0.0828042701,
-0.0304255784,
0.0497860834,
-0.0447431244,
-0.0482292771,
-0.0412670411,
0.017693961,
0.004994879,
0.0190775078,
-0.0293619744,
-0.0073518124,
-0.0141004408,
-0.0039412193,
-0.0003940445,
-0.0294160657,
0.0250498895,
-0.0541769937,
-0.0830547512,
-0.0374007374,
0.0262377448,
0.0050153723,
-0.0058036246,
-0.026756363,
0.0133676631,
0.0146123264,
-0.0173204001,
0.0718561411,
-0.0292047244,
0.003159181,
0.064260684,
-0.0345534943,
-0.0149000557,
-0.0730254203,
-0.0004623246,
-0.0334090367,
0.0568355061,
0.0229318831,
0.0668012574,
0.0152353197,
0.0245521665,
-0.0646677315,
0.0320148133,
-0.0236056894,
0.0697542652,
0.0004241613,
0.0206704829,
-0.0213664062,
-0.0031536727,
-0.0277725849,
-0.029683169,
-0.0073244185,
-0.0123362849,
-0.0061493637,
0.0051502567,
-0.0272405129,
-0.0312142074,
0.0366577581,
-0.038486626,
0.0289787631,
0.0427979901,
-0.0307990219,
-0.0238843057,
0.0022122082,
0.0082402825,
-0.0283526648,
0.0257470608,
0.0476298369,
0.0256622601,
0.0078016808,
0.0468918048,
0.0208087247,
-0.0228647795,
-0.0044466038,
-0.0075118588,
-0.04945473,
0.0409419052,
-0.0674133375,
0.0145716416,
0.0485568643,
0.0253494866,
-0.0261691026,
0.0518600233,
-0.0169328433,
0.004288346,
-0.0182199311,
0.0120287333,
0.010190255,
-0.0120998612,
-0.0225468576,
-0.0030283516,
-0.0278879125,
-0.0529725589,
0.0104987593,
-0.0502797291,
-0.0195869338,
0.0244217273,
2.774e-7,
-0.0152819147,
0.030068174,
0.0277525578,
-0.0206139721,
0.0254208613,
0.0517614335,
0.0173523147,
-0.0142875966,
-0.0027745366,
-0.0962327942,
0.0019237107,
0.0608647279,
0.069456622,
0.0504511297,
-0.0510292426,
-0.0431607254,
-0.0865021199,
-0.085919641,
-0.0244102869,
-0.0125407353,
0.0823822394,
0.0504247509,
0.0188194122,
-0.0166464169,
0.0478643775,
-0.0059733726,
0.0201627668,
-0.0045291353,
0.0147793246,
0.0071163266,
0.0307049304,
-0.0512461923,
0.0245396048,
0.0426360741,
0.0114821391,
0.0302888434,
-0.0347691588,
0.0688931718,
-0.011505466,
-0.0505635254,
-0.0388753973,
-0.0265134033,
0.0415242761,
-0.0822685659,
0.071708031,
-0.0479671359,
-0.0341145098,
-0.0203938931,
-0.0449271575,
-0.0319507383,
-0.0017185229,
0.0185750257,
-0.0087868599,
0.0321437456,
-0.0041974676,
0.0068257563,
0.0017492712,
-0.0931648314,
-0.0246174838,
-0.0021107735,
-0.0412990004,
-0.0548969656,
-0.0002147159,
-0.0587513149,
0.0456481911,
-0.0605039075,
-0.0033108508,
2.50353917e-34,
0.0189753156,
0.0022112995,
0.0213718861,
0.0282365829,
0.0703430548,
0.005482438,
-0.0269385315,
-0.0096699363,
0.0602000616,
-0.0767547861,
-0.0003211311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09342v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09342v3 | Ranking LLM-Generated Loop Invariants for Program Verification | 2023-10-13T18:13:52 | 2024-02-12T20:25:31 | Saikat Chakraborty, Shuvendu K. Lahiri, Sarah Fakhoury, Madanlal Musuvathi, Akash Lal, Aseem Rastogi, Aditya Senthilnathan, Rahul Sharma, Nikhil Swamy | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Synthesizing inductive loop invariants is fundamental to automating program
verification. In this work, we observe that Large Language Models (such as
gpt-3.5 or gpt-4) are capable of synthesizing loop invariants for a class of
programs in a 0-shot setting, yet require several samples to generate the
correct invariants. This can lead to a large number of calls to a program
verifier to establish an invariant. To address this issue, we propose a {\it
re-ranking} approach for the generated results of LLMs. We have designed a
ranker that can distinguish between correct inductive invariants and incorrect
attempts based on the problem definition. The ranker is optimized as a
contrastive ranker. Experimental results demonstrate that this re-ranking
mechanism significantly improves the ranking of correct invariants among the
generated candidates, leading to a notable reduction in the number of calls to
a verifier. The source code and the experimental data for this paper are
available in \url{https://github.com/microsoft/NeuralInvariantRanker}. | [
-0.0350637957,
0.0446878374,
0.0135885766,
0.0549392216,
-0.0263696816,
0.0041602706,
-0.0582700409,
-0.003665009,
0.0507562794,
-0.0225979984,
0.0129280584,
0.0468879119,
0.0130024701,
-0.0328820124,
0.0462024622,
0.0196531657,
0.0455578677,
-0.0468291193,
-0.0494462103,
-0.0118305469,
-0.0483469032,
-0.0029575352,
-0.0300486833,
0.0153515348,
0.01863507,
-0.0555894077,
0.0170325786,
0.0381870195,
0.0081839003,
-0.0528991967,
-0.0011887468,
0.0379556753,
-0.0282180049,
0.0377444401,
0.0000021604,
-0.0190293901,
-0.0108905789,
0.0344433114,
-0.0147515982,
0.0350221656,
-0.0427665077,
0.0291210394,
-0.0110704061,
0.0270846039,
0.013386501,
-0.0279194266,
0.0227088742,
-0.0077067367,
0.0778014883,
0.0624756776,
0.0153326727,
0.0116543947,
0.0358408988,
0.0222851951,
0.0126457065,
-0.0343078822,
-0.0136668375,
0.0076184217,
-0.0096070841,
0.0040037278,
0.0140577275,
0.0012231624,
0.0486770347,
0.0067854747,
-0.045732215,
0.0125454394,
-0.0593730547,
0.0043496587,
-0.0201536249,
0.0296163298,
-0.0692117885,
-0.0853586197,
-0.0104968399,
-0.0255637057,
-0.0035772778,
0.0060739317,
-0.0287417322,
0.0249623153,
-0.022151988,
0.0091935946,
0.0221333709,
-0.004186892,
0.0404336005,
-0.0426068082,
-0.0532251783,
0.0820518136,
0.0397901088,
-0.0519952551,
0.0057813544,
-0.0111327879,
-0.0197885167,
-0.0529700592,
-0.0166169833,
0.0375857912,
-0.054608915,
-0.0275095366,
0.0022372196,
0.0301618632,
0.0408541337,
-0.0282157827,
0.0087092053,
0.0299961064,
-0.0312501825,
-0.014817806,
-0.0855148137,
0.1262795627,
-0.0514289252,
0.0507666431,
-0.0017014344,
0.0068092546,
-0.0184426215,
-0.0072356621,
-0.0243345983,
0.0678694472,
0.0941337571,
0.0705967173,
-0.0570083447,
0.0499626845,
-0.0219902638,
0.1117622629,
-0.0801418349,
-0.039036829,
0.0027351507,
0.0007636838,
0.0067269197,
-0.0181697384,
-0.0201706551,
-0.0459742211,
-0.0520593859,
-0.0561043434,
-0.0205818862,
0.0304247178,
-0.0509779193,
-0.0112215327,
0.0333514288,
0.0532288514,
0.0449212268,
0.0099686235,
-0.01872449,
-0.0125009399,
0.0395730622,
-0.0486328006,
0.0163673963,
-0.0883365497,
-0.0193628073,
-0.0018021928,
0.0075418488,
-0.0274597034,
-0.0227550101,
-0.0043896646,
0.0125470487,
0.064093858,
0.0334285386,
0.0098603349,
-0.0390120856,
0.0012457665,
-0.0117429728,
0.0186489914,
0.0512852482,
0.0334218256,
0.0134477234,
-0.0461280309,
0.0603492595,
0.0296097305,
-0.0087008737,
-0.0041907453,
-0.0022067525,
0.0059958133,
0.0249319281,
-0.0107668871,
-0.0474619418,
0.0565704778,
-0.0061538834,
0.0119859288,
-0.0235699378,
0.0604692213,
0.0370421596,
0.0119332951,
0.0333146751,
-0.0128998188,
0.0115048308,
0.0555955917,
-0.0946235731,
0.0269763712,
-0.0284574069,
0.0223587416,
-0.0059814667,
0.022449661,
-0.021501543,
-0.053148441,
-0.0330151059,
0.0221827682,
-0.0331291445,
-0.0063558067,
0.0258809365,
0.0028179986,
-0.0525033325,
0.0536504276,
-0.0174115542,
-0.0604299754,
-0.0677294955,
-0.0728725642,
0.0438322239,
0.0383434519,
0.0482736528,
-0.0498626344,
-0.024095932,
0.0345317945,
0.0112270555,
0.003589855,
0.0379142836,
-0.00216627,
0.007857929,
-0.0276835412,
-0.024043696,
-0.0026839913,
0.005846607,
0.0317874774,
0.027465716,
-0.0105387187,
0.0143334568,
-0.0463056229,
-0.0320983008,
0.0269827489,
0.0392833017,
-0.059406545,
0.0227354039,
0.0170170013,
0.0406613275,
-0.0234114937,
-0.0273457784,
0.0216356739,
0.0434685834,
0.0002291682,
-0.0088629927,
-0.0435955673,
0.004440092,
-0.0149690909,
0.0410695635,
-0.0664697811,
-0.0271591358,
-0.0071100281,
-0.0949064046,
-0.004415012,
0.0578334332,
0.0015474523,
-0.0142285284,
0.0162415653,
0.0361157209,
-0.0172187947,
-0.0203333199,
-0.0203884449,
0.0284725316,
0.0202370174,
0.0219569467,
0.018815076,
0.0390641056,
-0.0024408728,
-0.0125422869,
-0.0109290434,
0.0254724119,
-0.0139575088,
0.0183774084,
0.0041822675,
0.0563775487,
0.0192714073,
-0.0716548786,
-0.0789032131,
0.0506874211,
0.0068729017,
0.0347362943,
0.0036909459,
-0.0014287281,
0.0240268912,
-0.002108203,
-0.0147833414,
-0.0171866436,
0.0168586057,
0.0187661164,
0.0265806597,
-0.0580381975,
-0.0905945227,
-0.0136707248,
-0.0034241527,
-0.06103158,
0.0507522598,
-0.0294407737,
-0.0426049046,
-0.0757647753,
0.0056487964,
0.0072265533,
0.0207373481,
-0.0243790261,
-0.0024896304,
0.0478336029,
0.0018532302,
-0.0010001634,
0.0430260636,
0.0006605441,
-0.0101666478,
0.0379673578,
0.006708825,
-0.0834642276,
0.0175910387,
0.0346978456,
-0.0698308125,
0.0626789555,
-0.0196786523,
0.0381317213,
0.0289712455,
-0.0081308782,
-0.0174965989,
-0.0198729876,
0.0002270848,
0.0371715203,
0.0317104012,
0.01310906,
-0.0430372544,
-0.0298976991,
0.0291838534,
-0.0221267734,
-0.0980992243,
0.0420961641,
-0.0709448159,
0.0147053897,
-0.0147060808,
-0.0017342448,
-0.0367867611,
0.0120506501,
0.0231101587,
-0.0143970102,
0.0040747393,
-0.0018983433,
0.0036579203,
-0.0023982232,
0.0107628908,
-0.0398151167,
0.0759929568,
-0.0218537748,
0.0271958038,
-0.0077466243,
-0.0138726663,
-0.0663466752,
-0.0084580695,
0.0102448883,
0.0109423259,
-0.0541076846,
-0.0089226961,
0.0583022721,
0.0175625272,
-0.0002715806,
0.0245637652,
-0.0108651575,
-0.0111314273,
-0.0146156978,
-0.0360672511,
-0.0602553934,
-0.0358091518,
0.0296007898,
-0.0055335034,
0.0042602527,
0.0112971701,
0.0178007782,
0.0484141856,
-0.0699472725,
-0.0087520089,
0.0272790529,
-0.0606267191,
-0.0186354797,
0.0356550403,
-0.0015378617,
-0.0487569645,
-0.0113699408,
0.0800099745,
0.014441506,
-0.0314256437,
0.0396511219,
-0.0026664343,
0.0297162924,
0.0455188639,
0.0543880463,
-0.1029404104,
-0.0171993617,
0.0144635094,
0.0192225017,
-0.0261900201,
0.0135510881,
-0.0257062018,
-0.0816633776,
0.0558327995,
0.0375223532,
-0.0120604364,
-0.0246564709,
-0.0045165843,
-0.0470244996,
0.0126350159,
-0.024213003,
0.0312849246,
0.011064114,
0.000468784,
-0.0005333888,
0.024902055,
-0.0141215613,
0.0313955024,
-0.0165530946,
-0.0099336207,
0.061552275,
-0.0257215295,
-0.0209734272,
-0.0995664969,
0.0885339752,
0.0229308493,
-0.0014695771,
-0.0240738112,
-0.0020602113,
0.0080459239,
0.0021162678,
0.0254334696,
-0.0238942727,
-0.0355247483,
-0.0179155413,
0.0368239954,
0.0576244369,
-0.0250816178,
-0.0437544137,
0.0165410303,
-0.023009032,
-0.0287795849,
0.0161704794,
0.0375647321,
0.0581125617,
-0.0285091959,
-0.062438421,
-0.0204589237,
-0.053871993,
-0.0297527183,
-0.0057717068,
0.0056581874,
0.0122615267,
-0.0017312878,
0.0518787354,
0.0068387771,
0.0488147177,
0.0011748872,
-0.0692496076,
0.0075829127,
-0.0354623273,
-0.0673230514,
0.0479293875,
-0.0310358368,
-0.0011597784,
-0.0519463457,
0.0292599443,
0.0436502509,
0.007082691,
-0.0226592124,
0.0465313569,
-0.0669295862,
-0.0480196103,
-0.0256766938,
0.0875127539,
0.019618012,
0.0334479548,
-0.0523990244,
-0.0045408718,
0.0334648006,
0.0422415994,
0.043822851,
-0.0055079036,
0.0029181403,
-0.0411259122,
0.0108180931,
-0.0258547068,
-0.0605536364,
0.0180421714,
0.0460988842,
-0.0312099662,
0.0318766572,
-0.0315068327,
0.0315663181,
0.096440427,
0.0173293576,
-0.0016321152,
0.0201166403,
-0.0071320077,
0.0441983715,
0.0109278597,
-0.0035243575,
-0.0426536128,
0.0649637058,
-0.0189999081,
-0.0431042947,
-0.0067568258,
-0.0269770697,
-0.04553473,
0.0492777079,
-0.0156012541,
0.0044267736,
-0.0473089069,
0.0325472653,
0.0108521385,
-0.0261430927,
-0.0243878737,
0.0494164191,
0.0202908143,
0.0660367236,
-0.0220399257,
0.009716155,
0.0329306386,
0.0681438074,
-0.0688180253,
0.0550299659,
-0.0280233584,
-0.0696931928,
-0.0483585596,
0.0291353036,
0.0621488355,
0.0609476827,
0.017422948,
-0.0011846726,
0.0186530203,
-0.0115152244,
0.0188080724,
0.0152770793,
-0.0335752331,
0.0248395316,
0.0692056268,
0.0338508412,
-0.0419480316,
0.0578835607,
0.0058696805,
0.005917978,
0.0066946489,
-0.0082524046,
-0.050703533,
-0.0216829292,
-0.047336787,
-0.0044400785,
0.0009200474,
-0.0345659293,
-0.0348049849,
-0.0437448397,
-0.0138298022,
0.0476698652,
0.0374532603,
0.0046601268,
-0.0254181717,
0.0532356538,
0.0188814532,
-0.0512055233,
0.024211254,
-0.0582349822,
0.0274845324,
-0.0562834963,
-0.022734629,
-5.835800112e-33,
-0.0596295968,
-0.0514495075,
0.0147761945,
0.0081924004,
0.004328337,
-0.0274381023,
-0.015758764,
-0.0231891312,
0.0322153829,
-0.0104151526,
-0.0043116729,
0.0058195498,
0.006805642,
-0.057390105,
0.0174804702,
0.0018028918,
0.0512764081,
0.0184413437,
-0.0936941355,
0.0041194214,
-0.0481382012,
-0.0334843844,
0.0775300488,
-0.0488189124,
-0.0043281685,
-0.000679068,
0.0032931298,
0.0233942624,
-0.0756512657,
0.02625685,
0.0430433378,
0.002284491,
0.0160578731,
-0.0588973425,
-0.0097640213,
-0.044241894,
0.0004522876,
-0.0616195947,
0.0278207529,
0.0177748557,
0.0053589651,
-0.0620026663,
0.0828121528,
0.0224394053,
-0.0433733091,
0.0118509568,
-0.0200323872,
0.009119113,
0.0188743379,
-0.0206548814,
-0.0243283305,
0.0310557,
-0.0159059707,
-0.0235478207,
-0.0137730427,
-0.0183324479,
-0.0282393638,
0.0547963008,
0.0007562237,
0.0064230985,
0.0348244198,
0.018755177,
0.0867324173,
-0.0142985219,
-0.0195108857,
0.0084581925,
0.0326635465,
0.0174620152,
-0.0296361055,
-0.0008057671,
0.0020929207,
0.0205965955,
0.0553509258,
0.0073816711,
0.0659932271,
0.0454122685,
-0.0218268316,
0.0252464954,
0.0016115677,
0.0167329926,
-0.0052009798,
-0.0109900823,
-0.0641443953,
-0.0149570573,
-0.0437872894,
-0.0478576012,
-0.0573576652,
-0.0188938174,
0.0441835225,
-0.0146573307,
-0.0290281903,
-0.021392595,
0.007866961,
-0.0166545566,
-0.0029170103,
0.0093212165,
-0.0172620658,
0.0098912297,
-0.0153937889,
0.0138405561,
0.0376534425,
-0.0102569908,
-0.0076733623,
0.0009697578,
0.1060278788,
0.010662877,
0.0008139796,
0.0283220708,
-0.0521903262,
0.018766189,
-0.0456966944,
-0.0318194702,
-0.001907789,
0.0001809056,
0.0058853338,
-0.0088414708,
0.0071726488,
0.0872814208,
-0.0136153549,
-0.0498124287,
0.0070994762,
0.0439228378,
0.0154377688,
0.0696798787,
-0.0033091283,
0.001005367,
0.0190534014,
0.0611787401,
-0.0190671273,
-0.0023740293,
-0.0216330178,
0.0160521846,
2.988e-7,
-0.031402275,
0.041339267,
0.0389316678,
0.0537951924,
-0.0080937948,
0.0268982891,
-0.0039337999,
-0.016983401,
0.0069460138,
-0.0043263668,
0.0061975643,
0.0339556038,
0.0230706912,
0.0316278972,
-0.0118528791,
0.018271856,
-0.011264124,
0.038208846,
-0.0193669982,
-0.018960733,
0.0509869009,
0.0209614411,
-0.0054667802,
0.0081934286,
0.0107840002,
-0.0654905587,
-0.0083091771,
0.0230111051,
-0.0167862289,
0.0362203419,
0.0381266512,
0.0099798134,
0.0402178504,
0.0255409405,
0.0164578389,
0.0016260101,
-0.0191482175,
0.0401400067,
-0.0076040393,
-0.0091244113,
-0.0023795324,
-0.0279920157,
0.0173626784,
-0.046813935,
0.0447518528,
0.002738107,
0.0011548626,
-0.0490008816,
-0.02997531,
-0.0685555562,
-0.0005905484,
-0.0232400857,
0.0124683306,
0.0309386943,
0.0096658813,
0.0000843907,
-0.0315207355,
-0.0115376851,
-0.0566051081,
-0.0089036189,
-0.028054731,
-0.0360076837,
0.0158677176,
0.0082891239,
-0.002441576,
-0.0130641423,
0.003555696,
3.190769672e-34,
0.0401039869,
-0.0327741466,
0.0611930713,
0.0386088081,
0.029396208,
0.0058249133,
-0.0356249362,
0.0030535781,
0.0026777736,
0.005866372,
-0.0184241384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09266v2 | User Inference Attacks on Large Language Models | 2023-10-13T17:24:52 | 2024-02-23T20:25:17 | Nikhil Kandpal, Krishna Pillutla, Alina Oprea, Peter Kairouz, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Zheng Xu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning is a common and effective method for tailoring large language
models (LLMs) to specialized tasks and applications. In this paper, we study
the privacy implications of fine-tuning LLMs on user data. To this end, we
consider a realistic threat model, called user inference, wherein an attacker
infers whether or not a user's data was used for fine-tuning. We design attacks
for performing user inference that require only black-box access to the
fine-tuned LLM and a few samples from a user which need not be from the
fine-tuning dataset. We find that LLMs are susceptible to user inference across
a variety of fine-tuning datasets, at times with near perfect attack success
rates. Further, we theoretically and empirically investigate the properties
that make users vulnerable to user inference, finding that outlier users, users
with identifiable shared features between examples, and users that contribute a
large fraction of the fine-tuning data are most susceptible to attack. Based on
these findings, we identify several methods for mitigating user inference
including training with example-level differential privacy, removing
within-user duplicate examples, and reducing a user's contribution to the
training data. While these techniques provide partial mitigation of user
inference, we highlight the need to develop methods to fully protect fine-tuned
LLMs against this privacy risk. | [
0.0391668975,
0.0932363644,
-0.0426826701,
0.070529744,
-0.0334929638,
0.0069997213,
0.0608933568,
-0.0157315806,
0.0084234858,
-0.0273428578,
-0.0445031151,
0.0058471775,
-0.0014150869,
-0.0131660867,
0.0677349791,
-0.0003387342,
0.0212804452,
-0.0527022555,
-0.0124274427,
-0.0362866744,
-0.0110092498,
-0.0004481947,
0.0296386015,
0.0417567082,
0.0061525228,
-0.0139001142,
0.013027356,
-0.0026663297,
0.0064008464,
0.0259057973,
-0.0022652112,
0.0813135877,
0.0183115024,
0.0543449931,
0.0000018385,
-0.0259855613,
-0.0351740643,
0.0271172486,
-0.0565588102,
0.0217398293,
0.0081810011,
0.0180972256,
0.0197791029,
0.0156558827,
-0.0338111967,
0.021214366,
0.0240422133,
0.0200554933,
0.0528180934,
0.0839744806,
-0.0077761333,
-0.0179923847,
-0.0412256867,
-0.0511336811,
-0.0082210731,
-0.0385107957,
0.0249782167,
-0.0428901725,
-0.0376128852,
0.0030699261,
0.0081476672,
0.016200155,
-0.0068331906,
0.0383311026,
-0.0455440693,
0.0131291933,
-0.0527654923,
0.0062898239,
0.0324488208,
0.0584547445,
-0.0276882667,
-0.0096160369,
0.0259957481,
0.0130352024,
0.040225409,
0.0343814306,
0.0120504489,
0.0223679394,
-0.0281909462,
-0.0004048873,
0.0205332227,
-0.0147122825,
0.0489090458,
0.0275714863,
-0.012106766,
0.0297265314,
0.0147223743,
0.017113978,
-0.0242146403,
-0.0396336727,
-0.0185577422,
-0.06481345,
0.0025247524,
-0.02117466,
0.0054415115,
0.0044198926,
-0.1004369706,
-0.0498936623,
0.0092571462,
-0.0306757353,
0.0372111537,
0.0157612171,
0.0096420748,
0.0486641712,
-0.0041971733,
0.0116989389,
-0.010939816,
0.0284295585,
0.0256550256,
0.0040482655,
0.002451834,
0.0076295068,
-0.0072352039,
0.0228361115,
-0.0199509822,
0.0230988935,
-0.0457485393,
0.0346117541,
-0.0207577515,
0.0362935178,
-0.043328926,
-0.0131783029,
-0.0342620537,
-0.030018162,
0.0000117251,
-0.0325901397,
-0.0327493623,
0.0245943479,
-0.0146086095,
-0.0773108006,
-0.0288227666,
-0.0009921046,
-0.0103670666,
-0.0284152068,
-0.0148512926,
0.0719038621,
0.0338301137,
-0.0277722199,
-0.0255852435,
-0.1021342874,
0.0286140312,
-0.0437831469,
-0.0513457358,
-0.088683486,
-0.0001699393,
0.0232541785,
0.0093808351,
-0.0784879848,
-0.0307608843,
0.0023899819,
-0.053285636,
0.0618458241,
-0.0028293987,
0.0097811408,
0.0011327879,
0.0215170514,
-0.036153648,
0.0682983845,
0.0049610082,
0.0414400436,
0.0456170253,
-0.0191361215,
0.0415877849,
0.0281830337,
0.0216020066,
0.0078489408,
-0.0187655073,
0.0264792126,
-0.0004790617,
-0.0385891497,
-0.0121259121,
0.0430197082,
-0.0263759904,
-0.0520597212,
0.1042730361,
0.0846086517,
-0.0109694367,
0.0380881429,
-0.0273260176,
0.0092858598,
-0.0062005813,
0.0068835816,
-0.0885319635,
-0.0231112521,
-0.0616474338,
-0.0509731583,
0.0153530352,
0.0194830541,
-0.0059297713,
0.0045898734,
0.0220076609,
-0.0504504628,
0.0126698222,
0.0513400026,
0.0226191301,
0.0182884,
0.0400340371,
0.0543418713,
0.0218655877,
-0.0312639736,
0.0087770289,
-0.0613530204,
-0.0157381278,
0.0567177609,
0.0375876427,
-0.003996273,
0.0386866033,
-0.0330882445,
0.0161935575,
-0.0178596154,
0.0431166403,
0.0027631097,
0.0472437404,
-0.0144355521,
-0.0381583087,
-0.0013471178,
0.0161937866,
0.0116986064,
0.0307067093,
-0.0200131405,
0.0166400801,
-0.0508010685,
-0.0244375318,
0.0059694056,
-0.003549031,
-0.0395084843,
0.0216799341,
0.0307374317,
0.0049379813,
-0.0022168434,
-0.0030397843,
0.0019851555,
-0.0052908524,
0.0353475772,
0.0331177972,
-0.0334706865,
0.0196922477,
0.0173711348,
-0.0039231111,
-0.0329868831,
0.0018099142,
0.0401198342,
-0.026586432,
-0.0165722109,
0.0313323587,
-0.0114805577,
0.0394069515,
-0.000969199,
0.0073686154,
-0.0175042488,
0.0437580124,
-0.0227934811,
0.0365157947,
-0.0081454571,
-0.0019890231,
-0.0350697376,
-0.0218089428,
0.0193678737,
-0.0452990271,
-0.0645245761,
-0.0158883967,
-0.0077327811,
0.0249926355,
0.0249442887,
-0.0357255563,
-0.018912239,
0.0053763906,
-0.0352861471,
-0.0030596051,
-0.0321050771,
0.0493169799,
0.0087436466,
0.0320260599,
-0.0438815095,
-0.0622248314,
-0.0199038088,
-0.031851083,
-0.0572215654,
0.0496956073,
0.0257466696,
0.0140904225,
-0.0336218886,
-0.0220532008,
-0.0288186986,
0.0079334304,
0.0523060709,
-0.0211171433,
-0.0150031578,
-0.0330872312,
0.0185437258,
-0.0237738322,
0.0594401583,
-0.0289458167,
-0.0155859711,
0.001663306,
0.0000489059,
0.0004287967,
0.079778254,
0.0089756213,
0.0107556507,
0.0774853379,
0.0179995727,
-0.0375445113,
-0.0293875262,
-0.0026232663,
-0.0581234246,
-0.0574813709,
-0.0009107157,
0.0096688187,
0.0103543596,
0.0366467759,
-0.0422477238,
-0.0213685837,
0.0493304729,
0.0011945652,
-0.0191545822,
-0.0055394797,
0.0036162278,
-0.0026648203,
0.0307516679,
0.0180111639,
-0.0866343677,
0.1054207906,
-0.0100148981,
0.0568456389,
0.0108525967,
-0.0542455427,
0.0280473772,
0.0497468226,
0.0147481784,
0.0430490822,
0.0269448943,
-0.0308043193,
-0.056291528,
-0.0122363288,
0.0596647449,
-0.0442826785,
0.0456336699,
-0.0166717935,
-0.0049915579,
-0.0013295739,
-0.0551184975,
-0.0487519316,
-0.1006342024,
-0.0279527493,
-0.022674894,
0.0052711666,
-0.0659235641,
0.0005124874,
-0.048501607,
0.0256522316,
0.0158349462,
-0.0292451847,
0.0034587455,
-0.0212215334,
-0.0271643177,
0.0469294004,
-0.0268266592,
-0.0178611483,
-0.048293557,
-0.0137662003,
0.0639508963,
0.0654675514,
0.0186096523,
-0.0000946612,
-0.0287802909,
0.0513411872,
-0.0080368239,
-0.0217773132,
0.0533621795,
0.0552254543,
-0.0344635397,
0.0083818398,
0.0716435984,
0.0033206546,
-0.0595142841,
0.0025236718,
0.03002798,
0.0260534734,
0.0047267121,
0.0294999201,
-0.1165909246,
-0.0279925037,
0.0200446248,
0.0687380955,
-0.0331009664,
-0.05620002,
-0.0319394358,
-0.0850225389,
-0.0101153916,
0.0271339044,
-0.0127817579,
-0.0020803784,
-0.0217091721,
0.0169649161,
-0.0051561166,
0.0098303016,
-0.0505933613,
-0.0060395054,
-0.0041787303,
0.0136171859,
-0.0117658209,
-0.0845674574,
0.0020302378,
-0.0606487393,
0.0447216593,
0.0255391821,
-0.0147564905,
-0.0040773796,
-0.0036621175,
0.0202767774,
0.011547205,
0.0071619735,
0.0157682505,
0.0752812847,
-0.0239227694,
-0.0167372599,
0.0098858681,
0.0565284379,
0.0136963855,
0.0018815425,
0.0241960548,
0.0173205454,
-0.0380624533,
0.0085725626,
0.0206297077,
-0.0500310063,
0.0375472568,
0.0588850491,
0.0234082062,
-0.0405309312,
0.0099616805,
-0.0622217357,
0.0146890627,
0.0046634516,
0.0016270872,
0.0166772492,
-0.0050660968,
-0.0604589209,
-0.0160013847,
0.0074914256,
0.0163739156,
0.0188450348,
0.0222301409,
0.0255478658,
0.0134812715,
-0.0108163217,
-0.0102007966,
0.0362402089,
-0.064180553,
0.0449852012,
-0.0408180803,
0.0004480197,
0.0096292887,
0.0068551241,
-0.0066938545,
0.0151392948,
-0.0857936665,
-0.0981934294,
0.0132155949,
0.0444479361,
0.0195016135,
0.0575750731,
-0.037856821,
-0.1277375072,
0.0439997166,
0.0481073447,
-0.024866119,
-0.0076050074,
0.0581287332,
-0.0550003983,
0.0071893148,
0.0652833208,
-0.0413259454,
-0.0334661454,
0.092865482,
-0.0610376447,
-0.0513964891,
-0.0367658883,
-0.0095638717,
0.0327094384,
0.0605902709,
-0.0106189977,
0.0363378637,
0.0009289269,
0.0271127447,
-0.0032932695,
-0.0320892483,
0.0018332155,
-0.024175236,
0.025092572,
0.0062548318,
0.0410257019,
-0.024653174,
0.0167679712,
0.0316141583,
-0.0643104836,
0.024992086,
0.0219998341,
0.0095856674,
0.0516055487,
0.0068419478,
-0.0195239019,
0.0630693287,
0.0335116684,
0.0525266528,
-0.0176550336,
0.0339134522,
0.0067833951,
0.0133957472,
-0.0287224781,
0.0325176567,
-0.0333538204,
-0.0761310458,
0.0130242528,
0.0146023268,
0.0009080348,
-0.0062254975,
0.0040098596,
-0.0214486029,
-0.0000978413,
-0.0266003218,
-0.0000408343,
-0.0196858272,
-0.0326622725,
-0.0009930115,
-0.0098629585,
-0.0128904963,
0.0544509925,
0.0952520221,
0.0126065845,
0.0470837392,
-0.0486530215,
-0.0548309386,
-0.0247781649,
-0.0046604797,
0.0079527656,
0.0352844335,
-0.0275683999,
-0.0209642258,
-0.0377662182,
-0.0962227955,
-0.0534863472,
-0.0131445788,
0.0123745305,
0.0124454452,
0.0025960642,
0.045759961,
-0.0091923969,
-0.028749153,
-0.0801333338,
0.0106365113,
0.0391052738,
-0.0236665476,
0.0108602457,
-5.775142767e-33,
0.0127754882,
-0.0096837524,
-0.0419843495,
0.0110306693,
0.0524865836,
0.0098269098,
0.0102061098,
0.010775893,
-0.0541345216,
-0.0502834134,
-0.0369479246,
0.0081281951,
0.0030882461,
0.0300675202,
-0.015691556,
-0.0170989204,
0.0363680162,
-0.0086902138,
-0.0408313088,
0.0258082878,
0.0719772503,
-0.0003701265,
0.0453574993,
-0.0759941563,
0.0283610225,
-0.0139037296,
-0.031667266,
0.0109610986,
-0.053152252,
0.0486305468,
0.0075679068,
0.0192723759,
-0.0122921579,
0.0083403857,
-0.0251646023,
0.0016512061,
-0.0179561377,
-0.026430672,
-0.0095340312,
0.0081784781,
0.0487617664,
-0.0489547923,
0.067624867,
-0.0309052635,
-0.01263618,
-0.0073230271,
0.0016155703,
-0.0053457129,
0.0028543423,
-0.008912866,
0.0197356697,
0.0181304403,
-0.0061869081,
0.0041191243,
0.0405048281,
-0.0042876513,
0.0113410773,
-0.0444768108,
-0.0243112296,
0.0495596416,
0.0580493435,
0.0129259983,
0.0761674792,
0.0340481959,
0.0172987171,
0.0392788872,
0.0298606623,
0.0375382788,
0.0222621448,
-0.0245677009,
0.0002512174,
0.0284468103,
-0.0154672023,
0.0585202388,
0.0276655816,
-0.0258198474,
-0.0253361147,
0.0097028194,
0.0019073233,
0.0025287247,
0.0676058084,
-0.0066504092,
-0.0875803232,
-0.0404628552,
-0.0591646172,
-0.0097466558,
-0.0406104326,
-0.0092794364,
-0.0037691465,
0.0056583285,
-0.0205504503,
0.0042173793,
0.0204998385,
-0.0541499294,
-0.0419969633,
0.010207247,
0.010613909,
-0.0293559041,
-0.004688289,
-0.0079791192,
-0.0078500593,
-0.0151697919,
0.0023572652,
-0.0649111569,
0.0289797448,
-0.0032584034,
0.0502509996,
0.0322598852,
-0.0674550384,
-0.0072312946,
-0.0153899835,
0.0192004647,
0.027317442,
0.028554406,
0.0708049014,
-0.0003495034,
0.0070289648,
0.016540898,
0.0273848847,
0.0024369869,
-0.0407620519,
0.0155310873,
-0.019224178,
-0.014970826,
0.0102797542,
-0.0123528475,
0.0167512223,
0.0269801039,
0.0850679725,
-0.0125315841,
0.0074487631,
-0.0352061838,
2.672e-7,
0.008534912,
-0.0019312544,
-0.0369771905,
0.001167655,
0.0068046427,
0.0819655657,
0.0162778459,
0.0787238106,
0.0008608296,
0.0072937221,
-0.005875852,
0.0038096176,
0.0531107225,
0.0265836269,
-0.0409718789,
0.0277741645,
-0.0265612267,
0.036326278,
-0.0731035173,
-0.020611655,
0.028719712,
0.0956491753,
0.052888006,
-0.0180822331,
-0.0095842155,
-0.0746027529,
0.0195631143,
-0.0558440536,
-0.0299184266,
-0.0163351838,
0.0541645177,
0.0662112534,
0.0191115737,
0.0342273377,
-0.0390916318,
0.0231336877,
-0.0519881584,
0.0742778853,
0.0222695377,
0.0318921767,
-0.0192847773,
-0.0417180359,
-0.021598421,
-0.0379252583,
0.0515634418,
-0.0345748328,
-0.0373004451,
-0.0225952007,
0.0312135499,
-0.0720414147,
0.0184271112,
-0.0321104974,
0.010966192,
0.0155676203,
0.0144841317,
-0.0052725268,
-0.003778605,
-0.0801384971,
-0.0251967385,
0.0015517656,
-0.0272288639,
-0.0390157662,
0.0181221068,
0.0141033139,
0.0094407797,
-0.0042161387,
0.0553074554,
2.250956428e-34,
-0.0178179555,
0.0097348988,
0.0031653245,
-0.0034834694,
0.0457987189,
0.0093242619,
0.0088526364,
0.0120445983,
0.0330086835,
-0.0576034337,
-0.0343113504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09265v1 | PromptRE: Weakly-Supervised Document-Level Relation Extraction via Prompting-Based Data Programming | 2023-10-13T17:23:17 | 2023-10-13T17:23:17 | Chufan Gao, Xulin Fan, Jimeng Sun, Xuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Relation extraction aims to classify the relationships between two entities
into pre-defined categories. While previous research has mainly focused on
sentence-level relation extraction, recent studies have expanded the scope to
document-level relation extraction. Traditional relation extraction methods
heavily rely on human-annotated training data, which is time-consuming and
labor-intensive. To mitigate the need for manual annotation, recent
weakly-supervised approaches have been developed for sentence-level relation
extraction while limited work has been done on document-level relation
extraction. Weakly-supervised document-level relation extraction faces
significant challenges due to an imbalanced number "no relation" instances and
the failure of directly probing pretrained large language models for document
relation extraction. To address these challenges, we propose PromptRE, a novel
weakly-supervised document-level relation extraction method that combines
prompting-based techniques with data programming. Furthermore, PromptRE
incorporates the label distribution and entity types as prior knowledge to
improve the performance. By leveraging the strengths of both prompting and data
programming, PromptRE achieves improved performance in relation classification
and effectively handles the "no relation" problem. Experimental results on
ReDocRED, a benchmark dataset for document-level relation extraction,
demonstrate the superiority of PromptRE over baseline approaches. | [
0.0703704432,
0.0342268087,
0.026437778,
0.0734593049,
0.0045395051,
0.0445679128,
-0.0019289536,
-0.0161740389,
0.0359713398,
-0.0358338952,
-0.0555060022,
-0.004523098,
-0.0291494261,
-0.0096259685,
0.0009212716,
-0.0398386307,
0.0216066856,
0.014100655,
0.0330745503,
0.0508527197,
0.0135901822,
0.0243909638,
-0.0045036618,
-0.0157936141,
-0.054445684,
-0.0393389948,
0.0118602943,
0.0016523444,
0.0199959204,
-0.0392754376,
0.0491815247,
0.0478508919,
0.0190313254,
-0.0232628956,
0.0000016771,
-0.0590870194,
-0.0204974283,
0.0073692556,
-0.0369883254,
-0.05426329,
-0.005543347,
-0.0613969304,
0.0411505736,
-0.0101514244,
-0.0434900559,
-0.0847915187,
0.0002055368,
0.0720053613,
0.0303331763,
0.0630680248,
-0.0402702801,
-0.0419692323,
0.0290858001,
-0.0566895492,
0.010613393,
-0.0328162797,
0.0205601919,
-0.0428150818,
-0.0213618502,
0.0274052527,
0.0126526179,
0.0115947369,
0.0154854665,
-0.0535707101,
0.0368780047,
0.0409241058,
-0.0518765487,
-0.0220164284,
-0.0259799361,
0.103002362,
0.0661614314,
0.0366392024,
0.0391397625,
0.0183050297,
0.0158006027,
0.0306556001,
0.0214310847,
-0.0203522425,
-0.0344559997,
-0.013172904,
0.0231232196,
0.0209491234,
0.0261884518,
0.0131656947,
0.0145743135,
0.0232758336,
0.0025804034,
-0.0726816505,
0.0667240173,
0.0249009337,
-0.0030117542,
-0.0364776962,
0.0150711397,
0.038241405,
-0.0043151337,
0.0301000029,
-0.0425907746,
0.0031223581,
-0.0132246204,
-0.0366970487,
-0.0227781907,
-0.0388606302,
-0.0248747524,
0.0708114877,
-0.0298918374,
-0.0008375263,
-0.0022164397,
-0.0337348804,
0.0067570489,
0.0108877551,
-0.0262763221,
-0.0009995415,
-0.0455189869,
0.0399421901,
-0.0294333436,
-0.0164212342,
-0.0145849101,
0.0044142921,
-0.0070215394,
0.046476312,
-0.0156080015,
-0.0000222737,
-0.0498623848,
0.0101812985,
-0.0155264121,
-0.0093026524,
-0.0485919081,
0.0057421015,
-0.0276172031,
-0.0047889627,
-0.0109917168,
-0.0124689573,
0.0373620465,
-0.0859188959,
-0.0029068524,
0.0710664839,
-0.002680575,
-0.0576131158,
-0.0338021964,
-0.0375677943,
0.0308892503,
-0.0579778291,
0.0015476317,
-0.000961998,
0.0635886118,
0.0328463763,
-0.0229587629,
-0.0153755127,
0.0459990092,
-0.0301920958,
-0.0695744306,
0.0620888695,
-0.0347886421,
-0.0189953297,
-0.0028032544,
0.0087368032,
0.0158770829,
0.0615350306,
0.0161492284,
0.0015134604,
0.0475650467,
0.0191186983,
-0.0076206159,
0.006577034,
0.0010691009,
-0.0287928358,
0.0257461425,
0.0320769399,
0.0250926539,
0.0015357139,
0.0262224432,
0.027837256,
-0.020245498,
-0.0144954827,
-0.0146143641,
-0.0059603578,
0.0049579605,
0.0262491349,
0.0566825382,
-0.014787103,
0.0206950251,
0.0237406809,
-0.0831609815,
-0.0105162477,
0.0045501622,
0.0117355762,
-0.0365120471,
0.0135690318,
-0.0071305619,
0.0102488548,
0.0066910349,
-0.0311980098,
-0.0235837456,
-0.0111100031,
0.0966297388,
0.0529067479,
-0.0193288103,
0.046120733,
0.0384257734,
-0.0174140651,
-0.0273553096,
0.0129588107,
0.0093882019,
0.0024899964,
0.023489818,
-0.0639767945,
-0.0390117019,
-0.0260155536,
0.0351902731,
0.0352897272,
0.0646728277,
-0.067721419,
0.0448240973,
-0.0288100261,
-0.0297138095,
0.0112484349,
-0.0042956169,
-0.0268868934,
0.0354104601,
0.0149352392,
0.0298631024,
-0.0081541557,
0.0156725515,
0.063753657,
-0.024415914,
-0.0469436869,
0.0088092871,
0.0431820527,
-0.0022349895,
0.0369172208,
-0.0067480025,
-0.0250461921,
0.0632626414,
-0.0299609248,
0.0215457752,
-0.0223476663,
-0.0440820977,
-0.0633159056,
0.0084049301,
0.0340044573,
-0.0669269115,
-0.0240323674,
-0.0469096489,
-0.015608347,
-0.0345087349,
0.0436138771,
0.0481843501,
-0.0134913484,
-0.0142738037,
0.030977875,
0.0003416484,
-0.0346947201,
0.08644595,
0.0323306434,
0.0138671305,
0.0460913852,
-0.0222478919,
-0.0132416412,
0.0155576365,
-0.0036398401,
-0.0055861459,
-0.0186828393,
-0.0445979387,
0.0121102957,
0.0407916792,
-0.071447432,
-0.029521428,
-0.0446616337,
0.0180702191,
0.015838271,
0.0476831794,
0.0100012776,
0.0323539339,
-0.0015464734,
-0.0409422666,
-0.0193485674,
0.0145619195,
-0.0379614532,
0.0012991573,
0.06960807,
0.0181891304,
-0.0017035925,
-0.0276740324,
-0.011445879,
-0.0429055281,
0.0544739179,
0.0422684178,
-0.021773776,
0.0007515349,
0.0641333088,
-0.0184375439,
0.0349797048,
0.0084773768,
0.0181580782,
-0.0121753914,
-0.0071152528,
0.0386873931,
0.0230279192,
-0.0143831829,
0.067698665,
-0.0256448854,
0.0002785561,
-0.0219076369,
0.0541909076,
-0.0258999523,
0.0180656854,
-0.006674753,
-0.0000292487,
-0.0376061797,
0.0668960959,
-0.007612613,
0.005314141,
0.0076734177,
0.0042117075,
0.0303405132,
-0.0018519313,
-0.0218937565,
0.0382772014,
0.0404880159,
-0.0107424064,
-0.0669079497,
0.0014269049,
0.0672337711,
-0.0129325762,
-0.0182032995,
-0.005842288,
-0.0030164246,
-0.0331504084,
0.0671992153,
-0.0144328726,
0.0076530203,
0.0026971027,
-0.0351735912,
-0.025166085,
-0.0376639552,
0.0016415478,
0.0161429308,
0.0206772145,
-0.0289959684,
0.0238482766,
-0.0146300178,
-0.035829708,
-0.0541532002,
-0.0408687927,
0.0051768236,
0.0135398945,
-0.0083186682,
0.0118262228,
0.0394188352,
0.0005908334,
-0.0028937999,
0.0437933132,
-0.0134213055,
-0.0358728953,
-0.0057124053,
0.0950615406,
0.0566996969,
0.0028325899,
-0.0385096781,
0.00072604,
0.0295983162,
0.0233777985,
-0.0165450517,
-0.0160142444,
-0.0082673589,
0.0286787879,
-0.0157492943,
-0.0214522798,
0.0232622102,
-0.0295087155,
0.0183059648,
-0.0725247636,
-0.0474677198,
0.0957708955,
0.0342719927,
-0.0362174623,
-0.0097671226,
0.0254737176,
0.0055762497,
0.0542427264,
0.0430800989,
-0.0526906736,
-0.030242607,
-0.0223879796,
-0.0028153467,
0.0293087997,
-0.0629658923,
0.002603861,
-0.0713594109,
-0.0085823108,
-0.0401050262,
-0.0410883538,
-0.0135128638,
-0.0755362362,
0.0098504014,
0.0068495888,
-0.0296451617,
0.0028442766,
-0.0457608849,
0.0002672496,
-0.0154264793,
0.0128419213,
-0.040751379,
0.013840124,
-0.019336326,
0.0103699611,
0.0463030934,
0.0415660962,
-0.0259801652,
0.0623756237,
0.0418788344,
-0.0102216639,
-0.0302851368,
-0.046072606,
0.0804022104,
-0.045342084,
-0.0073041315,
-0.0394242294,
0.0215549581,
-0.0667970777,
0.0129952235,
0.037547458,
0.0429944247,
0.0090588834,
-0.032881394,
-0.0041480507,
-0.0433259867,
0.0292073376,
0.0556932092,
0.0189655013,
-0.0124024954,
-0.0330679342,
0.0110260444,
0.0212854072,
-0.002494347,
0.0461569317,
-0.0089417007,
-0.0615662821,
0.0136889946,
-0.0537944362,
-0.0886133984,
0.0488626622,
0.0057788272,
0.0138557088,
0.0056684772,
0.019545909,
0.000198901,
-0.06329678,
0.0254559107,
0.0066978661,
-0.0095227137,
-0.0061725737,
-0.036701031,
0.0167556778,
-0.0179433618,
-0.0279373061,
-0.023452254,
-0.0416991711,
-0.0131452363,
-0.0295637045,
0.0142434631,
0.010001679,
0.073911801,
-0.0069332221,
0.0185876749,
-0.0101002753,
0.082825914,
-0.0758631229,
-0.0154350065,
0.024379259,
-0.0233882163,
0.0101997275,
0.0385472961,
-0.0522875674,
0.0164559782,
0.0446143597,
0.0370922275,
0.0049560084,
-0.0397106446,
0.0109069813,
-0.0030122625,
0.072980918,
0.016725976,
0.0051058964,
-0.0597510524,
0.0284705162,
-0.022317918,
-0.046848163,
-0.0296842624,
0.0386437327,
0.0080135874,
0.0305763017,
-0.0151092857,
-0.0368517004,
-0.0117348647,
0.0620990992,
-0.0055863201,
-0.001640326,
0.0571722686,
-0.003662176,
0.022192264,
-0.0248628017,
-0.0096998466,
0.0293934755,
0.0228705928,
0.009070606,
-0.0324444994,
0.0302974582,
0.01885291,
-0.0066367709,
0.0104551492,
-0.0128066735,
-0.0169172846,
0.0498826653,
-0.0263518579,
0.0392146148,
0.0332816131,
-0.0515879467,
-0.0011639345,
-0.0183568634,
0.0038203092,
0.0381287113,
0.0337020494,
-0.0082815904,
0.0154748708,
0.0148442239,
0.0219199806,
-0.0374325551,
0.0544823632,
0.0540317707,
0.0023002676,
0.0488339067,
0.0227374956,
-0.0312475562,
-0.0527177751,
-0.0005708546,
0.039143946,
0.0007046831,
-0.0141482931,
0.0243671183,
-0.0332617201,
-0.0457763895,
0.021174863,
-0.0547908433,
-0.0389832072,
0.0417179689,
0.0210003015,
0.0522771478,
0.0189420693,
-0.0511533841,
-0.0528643429,
0.0320580117,
-0.016553022,
-0.0391448662,
-0.0271520652,
-5.895372696e-33,
-0.059146177,
-0.0265815053,
-0.0011857986,
-0.006487851,
-0.0236285627,
0.0612246096,
-0.0390118286,
-0.049948886,
-0.0123367924,
0.0493899249,
-0.0355348885,
0.0110476101,
0.0057054679,
0.0051525431,
-0.009809386,
-0.0213565063,
0.0215979908,
0.0103351949,
0.0292482357,
0.0222137123,
0.0306433495,
0.0683670714,
0.0604102835,
-0.114689149,
0.0399373546,
-0.0154235559,
0.0023111389,
0.0220040865,
0.0250387788,
0.0286520999,
-0.0511696748,
-0.0102883736,
0.0313350782,
-0.000087006,
0.0450700186,
0.0465600863,
-0.1829549521,
-0.0310960095,
-0.0348447375,
-0.0196625181,
-0.0337719992,
-0.0035559649,
-0.0097408937,
0.0066994824,
0.0603711046,
-0.0200634059,
0.0515295826,
-0.0214916058,
-0.0019721906,
-0.0799874738,
-0.0769219771,
0.0115917278,
0.0257014055,
0.0099585624,
0.0087431371,
0.0060180314,
0.0136427078,
0.0007990065,
-0.0096827094,
-0.0536449254,
0.0070723542,
0.0183221493,
-0.0108984653,
0.0143867424,
-0.0192681495,
0.0271235891,
0.0036143367,
-0.0002015468,
0.0230195243,
0.0139150573,
-0.0079842573,
0.0416290164,
-0.0593833253,
0.0444802381,
0.0452493206,
0.0267167464,
-0.0968738943,
0.0060896715,
0.0490924008,
0.024935063,
-0.0444666259,
-0.0359635539,
-0.038725771,
-0.0065137041,
0.0104539972,
0.0021682947,
-0.0277419183,
-0.0377960205,
0.0232007708,
0.0069170152,
-0.0135896206,
0.0491685122,
-0.0143948663,
-0.024368627,
-0.0626238659,
0.0410585478,
0.001514043,
-0.0059210588,
-0.003752552,
-0.0310593769,
-0.0534609444,
-0.0782224759,
0.00834422,
-0.0043536825,
0.0371100083,
0.0328245573,
0.0780182406,
-0.025674453,
-0.0494837984,
-0.0266913883,
-0.0258738156,
0.0225868803,
-0.0188261978,
0.0385507233,
-0.0334971175,
0.0297830924,
-0.0254260246,
0.0653529093,
0.0529961549,
0.0014689568,
-0.0445503965,
0.0150225647,
-0.0130943777,
0.0269178469,
0.0316735469,
-0.0381990336,
-0.0010778457,
0.0174449533,
0.0202424582,
-0.0600294769,
0.0022762944,
-0.0192881543,
2.424e-7,
0.0337057188,
0.026066009,
0.0558138713,
0.0177117232,
-0.0108068176,
0.0178459231,
0.0137086771,
0.0441200547,
-0.0178577024,
-0.0097812396,
0.014418955,
-0.0091962405,
-0.0040943599,
0.0500679277,
-0.0917299986,
-0.0218461063,
-0.0838164538,
-0.0774957836,
-0.0742377937,
-0.012740531,
0.0874628574,
0.0575198345,
0.037700098,
-0.010304898,
-0.0742234215,
-0.0501331314,
0.0392817818,
-0.0170326959,
0.0072572324,
0.0508898199,
0.0064678215,
0.005654797,
-0.019998353,
0.0573633276,
-0.0255508833,
0.0346766114,
0.0135325668,
0.0708593801,
-0.0311955158,
0.0378486924,
0.0370355025,
-0.0053637465,
0.0302311853,
0.0239608753,
0.0566134304,
-0.0615679882,
0.0118134012,
-0.0128897531,
-0.0065698503,
-0.0252086055,
-0.0303226132,
0.001925781,
0.0148255359,
0.0487689264,
0.0232138056,
-0.0171085559,
-0.038889695,
-0.0735754594,
0.0065208231,
0.0721876398,
0.0250789728,
-0.016637763,
0.0065833214,
0.0219317432,
-0.0142606907,
-0.0240432378,
0.00062674,
2.20101376e-34,
-0.0286441054,
0.0283427592,
-0.0193893816,
0.0283870287,
0.0496124849,
-0.0470363013,
-0.0470065363,
0.0118386829,
-0.0100640357,
-0.0555327684,
0.0298289079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09263v1 | Table-GPT: Table-tuned GPT for Diverse Table Tasks | 2023-10-13T17:20:56 | 2023-10-13T17:20:56 | Peng Li, Yeye He, Dror Yashar, Weiwei Cui, Song Ge, Haidong Zhang, Danielle Rifinski Fainman, Dongmei Zhang, Surajit Chaudhuri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Language models, such as GPT-3.5 and ChatGPT, demonstrate remarkable
abilities to follow diverse human instructions and perform a wide range of
tasks. However, when probing language models using a range of basic
table-understanding tasks, we observe that today's language models are still
sub-optimal in many table-related tasks, likely because they are pre-trained
predominantly on \emph{one-dimensional} natural-language texts, whereas
relational tables are \emph{two-dimensional} objects.
In this work, we propose a new "\emph{table-tuning}" paradigm, where we
continue to train/fine-tune language models like GPT-3.5 and ChatGPT, using
diverse table-tasks synthesized from real tables as training data, with the
goal of enhancing language models' ability to understand tables and perform
table tasks. We show that our resulting Table-GPT models demonstrate (1) better
\emph{table-understanding} capabilities, by consistently outperforming the
vanilla GPT-3.5 and ChatGPT, on a wide-range of table tasks, including holdout
unseen tasks, and (2) strong \emph{generalizability}, in its ability to respond
to diverse human instructions to perform new table-tasks, in a manner similar
to GPT-3.5 and ChatGPT. | [
0.0424377359,
0.0828440934,
-0.0117772901,
0.0225455724,
-0.034731511,
0.0548527576,
-0.0352999158,
0.0413520969,
-0.0116166128,
-0.0142744957,
-0.0673674569,
-0.0275897775,
-0.0211483706,
0.0166208185,
0.0371687636,
-0.0177253187,
0.0448105223,
0.0164738894,
-0.0313123949,
0.0461752042,
-0.0004687516,
-0.0160131939,
-0.0187998749,
0.0179549735,
-0.023432333,
-0.0122768125,
-0.0428647958,
-0.013393769,
-0.0406830385,
0.0079925098,
0.0053103124,
0.1075784862,
0.0385334194,
0.0423199572,
0.0000019926,
0.0402318761,
-0.0450093076,
-0.0172706079,
0.0109271863,
-0.0186231118,
0.038643457,
-0.0696158856,
-0.0211519245,
-0.0257976837,
-0.0506277345,
-0.0424092971,
0.0168655403,
0.077977933,
0.0089684455,
0.0530627668,
-0.0029206118,
-0.0254166201,
0.013419806,
-0.032361038,
0.0849397629,
-0.0451679155,
-0.0204922017,
0.0242626201,
0.0021066761,
0.0015957102,
0.0016611732,
0.0284956209,
0.0376169942,
-0.0025315648,
-0.0088343024,
0.0502372943,
-0.0577255227,
0.0299531277,
-0.0047326973,
0.0729371905,
-0.0159190614,
-0.0153411087,
0.0217238832,
0.0014108962,
0.0361261442,
-0.0366016515,
-0.0495190695,
-0.0302359443,
0.0055025527,
-0.0113120852,
-0.0094520058,
-0.0231440235,
0.0127434237,
-0.0061887894,
-0.0038861372,
0.0573621318,
-0.0143909361,
-0.0255462211,
0.0017027975,
0.0026581883,
-0.0285348892,
-0.0047277035,
0.0076506538,
0.0182948634,
-0.0216879603,
0.0230656751,
0.0177963339,
-0.0169430617,
0.0140917404,
-0.0241682809,
0.025264211,
0.0775771961,
-0.0098981466,
0.002275845,
-0.028879473,
0.0316682644,
-0.0156105487,
0.0457415953,
-0.0274090674,
0.0037984771,
-0.0556662604,
-0.0006861188,
-0.0511761494,
-0.0034530037,
-0.0578104965,
-0.0318646654,
0.0109928632,
0.0139034363,
0.010325986,
0.0318996385,
0.0334471054,
0.0297279824,
-0.0418422967,
-0.0100008659,
-0.0113010127,
0.001262144,
-0.0235058703,
-0.0152086383,
0.0039599393,
-0.0827813148,
-0.0218876824,
-0.0351681672,
0.0154656861,
-0.0389237218,
0.0432428829,
0.0815646201,
-0.0616377555,
-0.0101468209,
-0.0206063893,
0.0087979259,
-0.0272121616,
-0.0727986023,
0.0219935738,
-0.0280680377,
0.0614774488,
0.0094190808,
0.0138845854,
-0.0439736918,
-0.004688534,
0.0354703516,
-0.0116728768,
0.0710413679,
0.0335635133,
0.0087437788,
0.0052331854,
-0.0147285452,
-0.0437147804,
0.0812168419,
0.0463027321,
0.0035542171,
-0.0311399084,
-0.027402347,
-0.0213182904,
0.0513031483,
0.0099046659,
-0.0023987114,
-0.0129336175,
0.0417007431,
0.0367799997,
0.024873836,
0.0046575028,
0.0160944927,
-0.0199402217,
0.0340465531,
0.0567086861,
0.0236091539,
-0.0031450044,
0.1069070324,
0.0262846444,
-0.0207931604,
0.0183387417,
0.0547109023,
-0.067027092,
0.043863818,
0.0143129081,
0.0023034583,
0.0061890758,
-0.0232943241,
-0.004971432,
-0.037284825,
0.0197771415,
0.0133387782,
0.0217748843,
-0.0364412256,
0.0265277717,
0.0184404664,
-0.0777559653,
-0.0166704319,
-0.0209180359,
-0.0649263561,
-0.027107168,
-0.0152861746,
0.0131985266,
0.0601728521,
0.0397662707,
-0.074384734,
-0.0276360475,
0.0072355769,
0.0166990925,
0.0353657231,
0.065018557,
-0.0088895187,
0.006966156,
0.0006583023,
-0.0140998755,
0.0341583677,
0.0395521186,
-0.0020127194,
0.03999703,
0.0039526876,
0.0122353574,
-0.0705503002,
-0.0342776887,
0.0263310783,
0.0396811217,
0.0068576029,
-0.0305282362,
-0.0015232017,
-0.0054231049,
0.002901054,
0.0041124942,
0.022660207,
0.0320998579,
0.0020521861,
0.0288819373,
-0.0061399597,
-0.0464816205,
0.024186248,
0.0115833748,
0.0345043391,
-0.0682319477,
-0.0145782987,
-0.0304904748,
-0.0278334767,
0.0158378854,
-0.0133613609,
-0.0082318624,
-0.0399041921,
0.017542433,
0.0074588172,
0.0139607508,
0.0216271728,
0.0720162913,
-0.0064860405,
0.0230626054,
0.0013232755,
-0.0839663297,
0.0229309034,
-0.0266302731,
0.0256250221,
-0.0015489009,
-0.0057007489,
0.0312568322,
0.0306604113,
0.0516599938,
-0.0702312142,
-0.0423937626,
-0.0918245763,
0.0398963392,
-0.0487562306,
0.0365078337,
0.0224110316,
-0.0137100788,
-0.0297777746,
-0.027238179,
-0.0462056138,
0.0150031531,
-0.0020910883,
-0.0136791868,
0.0724048465,
-0.0256182235,
0.0053858203,
-0.0419643559,
-0.0255693868,
-0.0305940639,
-0.0035785767,
-0.0264363214,
-0.038299676,
0.0166329946,
-0.0120386668,
0.0151997237,
0.0388953164,
0.0203080196,
-0.0251380187,
0.0086668171,
-0.0263956301,
0.0451854393,
0.0653282404,
-0.028610643,
0.0478510596,
-0.0065926351,
-0.011498943,
-0.0233730134,
0.0391544364,
-0.00532752,
0.0006570998,
0.0035300537,
-0.0292151831,
0.0186092686,
0.0499552116,
-0.0447419956,
0.0151004782,
-0.0693961605,
-0.0012022818,
0.0063285702,
-0.0029037998,
-0.0583126582,
0.0694280341,
-0.0042480421,
-0.014370501,
-0.0448090546,
-0.0015651693,
-0.0033089821,
-0.0341866463,
-0.0063485368,
-0.0246212762,
0.0104539124,
-0.0431986041,
0.0991553143,
0.0346025974,
-0.0059514837,
-0.0003323713,
-0.0360369608,
-0.0766299888,
0.0207172129,
0.0101384306,
-0.0166505426,
0.0945819393,
-0.059406925,
0.0227825996,
-0.0239802916,
-0.0327678621,
-0.0074480218,
-0.0196447223,
-0.0215384644,
0.0383202732,
0.0257229097,
-0.0504656918,
-0.043196395,
-0.0136671821,
0.0243356489,
0.0821392387,
-0.0118874693,
-0.0214271396,
-0.0461876839,
0.007994405,
0.0452832766,
0.0379467644,
-0.0712264776,
-0.0130643696,
0.0022519096,
0.0468646772,
0.0058609545,
-0.0446022227,
-0.0134247988,
0.0490009226,
0.0072959238,
-0.0304078497,
-0.0323372521,
0.0239814464,
-0.0334378108,
-0.0647242367,
-0.0250449162,
0.0875995532,
0.0113062244,
-0.0159007441,
-0.0238514859,
0.0232487787,
0.0595682859,
0.0072133555,
0.0266399477,
-0.1065223739,
-0.030193463,
0.0029971099,
-0.0456045158,
0.0206374787,
-0.0386588387,
-0.0547809675,
-0.0947866142,
0.0347355381,
-0.0128024472,
-0.0846634507,
-0.0709913746,
0.0119618103,
0.006545167,
-0.0346494205,
0.0509091914,
0.0428774096,
-0.0200548302,
0.0304113869,
0.0131463893,
-0.0325276293,
-0.0309265181,
-0.0071478994,
-0.0538846105,
0.0289338157,
0.0519735552,
0.043997284,
-0.0187785514,
-0.0024025571,
0.0226490535,
0.024647953,
0.0305931587,
0.0006939162,
0.0634135455,
-0.0063219853,
-0.0043754936,
0.0079430221,
-0.0116352392,
-0.0278891828,
0.00364977,
0.0125435553,
0.0459193662,
-0.025025161,
-0.020147413,
0.0461923108,
-0.0275976807,
0.0025966554,
0.0660417527,
0.037345361,
0.0019852507,
-0.0662454739,
-0.0410339311,
-0.0315252617,
-0.0613878518,
0.0368137807,
0.0251483191,
-0.0010370043,
-0.0223166551,
-0.0362147838,
-0.0287385695,
0.0587871335,
0.0033517748,
0.0139439348,
0.0539936237,
-0.0345016904,
-0.0138846757,
-0.0530618876,
-0.0027478768,
-0.0563594848,
0.0072365655,
-0.0301477909,
-0.055759754,
-0.0041368152,
-0.0179020781,
-0.0027954176,
0.0232227445,
-0.056148503,
-0.0141491033,
-0.0105705159,
0.0100903325,
0.0232822727,
0.015677508,
0.0023620492,
-0.0049825562,
-0.0604921244,
0.0058341459,
-0.0861524269,
-0.0269699655,
0.0117416307,
-0.0564745069,
-0.0031712123,
0.0464307256,
-0.0070961853,
0.0095456243,
0.0002718492,
0.022673646,
0.0161180999,
0.0279169511,
0.0448509008,
-0.0194534976,
0.0008134643,
0.0398597755,
-0.0344780497,
-0.0271849688,
0.0178131182,
-0.0495613851,
-0.016753681,
-0.015760405,
-0.0031950257,
0.0243482087,
0.0248226523,
-0.0442513563,
-0.0041483021,
0.0216874126,
0.0322277024,
-0.0439805575,
-0.0082219532,
0.0235194508,
-0.0597775728,
0.0214366969,
-0.0295887962,
0.0058713406,
-0.0076982845,
0.0172951389,
0.0154175237,
-0.0154962735,
0.03469662,
0.0264697839,
-0.0539787002,
-0.0294609182,
0.0655409396,
-0.0513808355,
-0.0350672565,
-0.0193560179,
0.0324665681,
0.0319731049,
-0.0074196639,
0.0136087826,
-0.0373169892,
-0.0186910294,
0.0231338441,
0.0248071495,
0.0617434792,
0.0043072188,
-0.00030027,
0.0018977645,
-0.0063518607,
-0.0554495342,
0.0721125156,
0.0413481928,
0.0271389578,
0.0005283952,
-0.0110590421,
-0.0574079007,
0.0105849728,
-0.0079883374,
-0.0322142318,
-0.0215192754,
0.0008710703,
-0.0099380128,
-0.0421153754,
0.0025930365,
0.0482517853,
-0.0352424569,
-0.0201585833,
0.0279963631,
0.0488724187,
0.0122691654,
-0.0219957922,
-0.0312688462,
0.0037798947,
0.0183049794,
-0.0205756053,
-0.0305758249,
-6.315706334e-33,
-0.0406512357,
-0.0050147548,
0.0207456034,
-0.0362658761,
-0.0065568872,
-0.0332805142,
-0.0536310934,
-0.0152804265,
0.0050301068,
0.00404531,
-0.0509644337,
0.0643857867,
0.0187313966,
-0.0292340592,
0.0337305516,
-0.0771636963,
0.0348190665,
-0.0259411111,
-0.0107927127,
0.0137350177,
-0.0255871806,
0.02968877,
0.0645977557,
-0.0081521096,
0.0472068042,
0.0076162592,
-0.0189247187,
-0.0264970437,
-0.003876454,
0.0231422074,
-0.0432898179,
0.0103760706,
0.0382375643,
-0.0653455704,
-0.0393309668,
0.0184972361,
-0.1588154137,
-0.034576457,
0.0100147761,
0.0392935723,
-0.0121017247,
-0.0197058357,
0.0072231041,
-0.0244831759,
-0.0201530214,
-0.0145296305,
0.0152690783,
-0.028823385,
0.0078889085,
0.0465598814,
-0.0229904875,
0.0169073194,
-0.0061774827,
0.011861925,
0.0812540054,
0.0139538208,
0.0303865187,
-0.0458941013,
-0.0272399951,
0.006406066,
0.0052269679,
0.0389236361,
0.0318887383,
-0.0324778967,
0.0055950428,
0.0348066315,
0.0230509806,
0.0323215984,
-0.0270752441,
-0.0209898036,
-0.0185582098,
0.060903769,
0.0416922644,
-0.0136736566,
0.0568052195,
-0.0046582241,
-0.0256855804,
0.0630779266,
0.0082906866,
0.0114167947,
-0.0257741716,
-0.0012584217,
-0.0162583422,
-0.0136243766,
0.0002236847,
-0.0035530007,
-0.0302988961,
-0.0217226967,
0.0200644638,
-0.0079866871,
0.0444761291,
0.0026454814,
0.0102096181,
0.0160557646,
-0.038799569,
0.0505348332,
-0.0293284338,
-0.0006793168,
0.0188305322,
0.0098234043,
-0.0031716048,
-0.0570050068,
0.0346799269,
0.0135655301,
0.0372847132,
0.0457566828,
0.0702066869,
0.0453144722,
-0.0757049322,
-0.014863017,
-0.0492357686,
0.0574884079,
0.0068406737,
0.0255274698,
0.0084410142,
0.0024849491,
0.0019424009,
0.0276188869,
0.0373780914,
0.0040197149,
-0.030601237,
0.0519039668,
0.0008647509,
0.0092294654,
0.0364916734,
0.0071752728,
-0.0328862146,
-0.0060708406,
0.0400374606,
-0.018913446,
0.0141136255,
0.001793429,
2.451e-7,
0.0731053278,
0.0078992127,
0.0711272731,
0.031503994,
0.0021180829,
0.0029935807,
-0.0307332464,
0.004886359,
-0.0329606049,
-0.028286688,
0.063090615,
0.0135356989,
0.0695699453,
-0.0058156657,
-0.0460182428,
-0.0173865799,
-0.0760116056,
0.0020575419,
-0.0496820323,
0.0152525157,
0.0162816327,
0.0908085108,
-0.0775475651,
0.0051243603,
-0.0290803853,
-0.0239897855,
0.0389861204,
-0.087385118,
0.0596074648,
0.0234529655,
0.0407688767,
0.0116275596,
-0.0015950173,
0.0731751397,
-0.02495078,
0.0008382297,
0.0320064723,
0.0509481244,
-0.0175840184,
0.066402249,
0.0088957651,
-0.047898937,
0.0164946876,
-0.0692142025,
0.0915140584,
-0.0511248298,
0.0191310048,
0.0932238922,
0.0208667498,
0.0196322836,
0.0039298427,
0.0114932787,
-0.0155102285,
0.0185415428,
0.0448588058,
0.00359767,
-0.0025917382,
-0.0538007692,
-0.0285505131,
0.03277817,
-0.0248061232,
-0.0123220626,
-0.0340432711,
-0.039570488,
-0.0338344797,
-0.031076787,
-0.0460320823,
2.07550081e-34,
0.0361932181,
0.0059605939,
0.0395623446,
0.0340686329,
0.0710724294,
-0.0336484015,
0.0429647304,
0.0251509771,
0.0013209102,
-0.0627485067,
-0.0299554598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09256v1 | Political claim identification and categorization in a multilingual setting: First experiments | 2023-10-13T17:13:00 | 2023-10-13T17:13:00 | Urs Zaberer, Sebastian Padó, Gabriella Lapesa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The identification and classification of political claims is an important
step in the analysis of political newspaper reports; however, resources for
this task are few and far between. This paper explores different strategies for
the cross-lingual projection of political claims analysis. We conduct
experiments on a German dataset, DebateNet2.0, covering the policy debate
sparked by the 2015 refugee crisis. Our evaluation involves two tasks (claim
identification and categorization), three languages (German, English, and
French) and two methods (machine translation -- the best method in our
experiments -- and multilingual embeddings). | [
0.015358258,
0.0766327754,
0.012274812,
0.0940252244,
-0.0455912165,
0.0137170535,
0.0143447779,
-0.0317095779,
0.0181736127,
-0.025514612,
0.041743882,
-0.042720139,
-0.0018168385,
-0.0018498999,
0.0152630955,
-0.0493488722,
0.0335198157,
0.0375157185,
0.065646261,
-0.0272014532,
0.0072447211,
0.0115324399,
-0.0199909061,
0.0496791229,
-0.0425064713,
0.0311681349,
0.0097658942,
-0.0308982916,
0.0701025575,
-0.0199723449,
0.0031426663,
0.0362396091,
0.0169525482,
0.0753113627,
0.0000011176,
-0.0339618511,
-0.0053366204,
0.014624754,
0.0436495915,
-0.0346714482,
0.0724221766,
-0.0401884168,
-0.0060357624,
0.0049932278,
-0.0053926068,
-0.0199054461,
0.062160816,
0.0406478122,
0.0427885354,
0.0652072206,
-0.000474139,
-0.0642762035,
-0.0288032871,
-0.0132437684,
-0.0279134996,
-0.0238394979,
-0.0039587542,
-0.0160926115,
-0.046980232,
0.0135117462,
-0.0085546318,
0.038026657,
0.0186604299,
0.0029695346,
-0.0693537369,
-0.0104211411,
-0.035606496,
-0.0364507549,
0.0211115368,
0.0107474094,
0.0231844652,
-0.0388074294,
0.0221830029,
0.0026445615,
-0.0162193999,
0.0523845069,
-0.0079529714,
0.0471588597,
-0.0249071736,
0.0181048252,
0.1021551117,
0.0453901589,
0.0045476258,
0.0047276835,
-0.035993848,
0.0399000496,
-0.0365606584,
-0.0183242075,
0.0203828029,
0.0315004364,
0.0218662079,
-0.0376565754,
-0.001769334,
-0.0119314212,
-0.006407287,
0.0336512849,
0.0183902979,
-0.0428881608,
0.0141263204,
-0.0653804392,
0.010211179,
-0.0004755073,
-0.0501193181,
0.085745059,
-0.0159455854,
0.0022401176,
-0.0213936176,
-0.009897192,
-0.0108926855,
-0.0584191009,
-0.0394700803,
0.012209733,
-0.0161107518,
0.007308498,
-0.0321210474,
0.0189086068,
-0.0316415802,
-0.0375357978,
-0.0220210887,
0.0259523429,
0.0022669656,
-0.0357709825,
-0.0035929501,
-0.0040062051,
-0.0645252243,
0.0569791384,
-0.0362416692,
-0.0032465386,
-0.0378964767,
-0.0235808659,
-0.0030101459,
0.0382071324,
-0.0236934181,
-0.0163767114,
0.0006491028,
0.0066205757,
-0.0187370405,
0.0284056589,
-0.0015455229,
-0.0369527489,
-0.0187913999,
-0.0694915727,
0.0419076607,
-0.0686713606,
0.0391202681,
-0.0132002616,
0.0055134036,
-0.0393544696,
0.0089065637,
0.0065269042,
-0.0511127822,
0.0339471251,
0.0071793818,
0.0013723129,
0.0277860425,
0.0139029231,
-0.0210416261,
0.0691502318,
-0.0176909603,
0.0250265487,
0.0359194949,
0.0031828324,
0.0063001625,
0.031843435,
0.014667795,
0.0215896592,
0.0062602819,
0.0056515625,
-0.0209451001,
-0.0196889862,
-0.0090124514,
0.0133979432,
0.0007165399,
-0.0117959799,
0.023374401,
0.0922492966,
-0.0033973265,
0.0083037084,
-0.0153975431,
-0.0099709406,
0.0129379639,
0.0197215416,
0.0223836992,
0.0188173037,
0.0076298551,
-0.0431091897,
0.0070953448,
0.0398001969,
0.0127470279,
-0.0523679815,
0.0010307446,
0.0142912026,
0.021237094,
-0.0174354091,
0.0263596363,
0.0109984744,
0.0171318073,
0.0155967837,
0.0092848008,
-0.031019574,
-0.0128152678,
-0.0300736986,
0.0386048295,
-0.029961111,
-0.0289467406,
-0.0442131385,
-0.0058427192,
-0.0316182859,
0.0769748837,
0.0744601861,
0.120548442,
-0.0297509395,
-0.01088914,
0.0215023328,
-0.0312784389,
-0.0108359102,
0.0346639417,
0.0607299283,
0.0051717041,
0.0248971395,
-0.0012985376,
0.0003165152,
-0.0336062312,
0.0200821832,
0.0247513838,
0.0215280429,
0.0301954653,
0.0333641954,
0.0031359994,
0.0496193618,
-0.0093442425,
-0.0309291873,
0.0355934501,
-0.044315245,
-0.0161079764,
0.0501177013,
0.0434278324,
-0.0129722264,
0.0077066892,
-0.0661983937,
-0.0556295253,
-0.0092290575,
-0.058116436,
0.0076870061,
0.067296721,
-0.0035542131,
-0.0278349482,
-0.0154917911,
-0.0409920365,
-0.0361429825,
-0.0149803823,
-0.0276102815,
0.088170357,
0.0189599227,
0.0594990477,
0.0090541728,
-0.0348091871,
0.072407268,
-0.0036307648,
-0.0183941349,
0.0639707297,
0.0104846805,
0.0432976708,
0.0620920546,
-0.0615360513,
0.0121802632,
-0.001380529,
-0.0319858082,
0.0200957824,
-0.0488602072,
0.0571355149,
0.0223484784,
-0.0538690835,
0.0082409382,
-0.0051091039,
-0.0439157523,
-0.0472769141,
0.0022044054,
0.01511457,
0.0328941606,
-0.0125099039,
0.0334322266,
0.0030928426,
0.0300451554,
-0.0233750157,
0.0368539467,
0.0189342238,
-0.033978425,
-0.0238236226,
-0.0240486749,
-0.0878110081,
-0.000218284,
-0.0374089368,
-0.0070763854,
0.0195377525,
0.0331972241,
0.0058010756,
-0.0032685751,
-0.0012953541,
0.0419582836,
0.0122900289,
0.0415777527,
-0.0436392948,
-0.0438674577,
-0.0396529511,
0.013771412,
-0.0212229639,
-0.0324922167,
0.0350707769,
0.0554031245,
0.0114278262,
-0.0111690843,
-0.0248436462,
0.050084915,
-0.052971594,
-0.0130202128,
-0.0163740162,
0.0191700011,
0.0166201349,
0.0597462244,
-0.0095452815,
-0.0016374177,
0.0385617241,
0.0066359234,
0.0406405702,
-0.0445876867,
-0.044882156,
-0.0118030217,
0.0691025704,
0.0070927185,
0.0384290442,
-0.0343820043,
0.0057745934,
0.0042818231,
-0.0418672338,
0.0815197378,
-0.0306310542,
0.0165194795,
-0.0539596677,
0.0017616544,
-0.0440623201,
-0.0189681519,
-0.0378893539,
-0.074684076,
0.0082625691,
0.0053299116,
-0.0190759208,
-0.0123758856,
-0.0502928644,
0.0062851459,
0.0498839989,
0.0169202015,
0.0312437434,
0.0280887876,
0.0068829013,
0.0324553065,
-0.0433111079,
0.0086995075,
0.0405524485,
0.0084076626,
-0.0182718877,
0.0562123992,
-0.0546185113,
0.0269749276,
-0.0186942648,
-0.0430305041,
-0.0146045424,
-0.0346072875,
-0.0177184362,
-0.0618181862,
0.0212364234,
-0.0440692939,
0.0542591661,
0.0403021239,
0.0362510569,
0.0047098263,
-0.0153441234,
-0.0289286785,
-0.0274840388,
0.039337378,
0.0145725058,
-0.1043590531,
0.0567223318,
-0.0099550439,
-0.0290347338,
-0.0657532364,
-0.0066025979,
-0.0293387305,
-0.068392165,
0.0303699374,
0.012235431,
-0.0340301841,
-0.0310660619,
-0.0610857271,
0.0087921405,
-0.0148339365,
-0.0460209921,
-0.0302765798,
0.0649784654,
-0.0068756621,
-0.0022230956,
-0.0509437136,
-0.0401788019,
-0.0255691465,
-0.0311525799,
0.0102450838,
-0.0226037316,
0.0721717849,
-0.0190915707,
-0.0074983328,
0.0254582707,
-0.0221640579,
-0.0801110789,
-0.0050644539,
0.0223340094,
0.0119153569,
-0.0312870368,
0.040662501,
0.019110648,
0.006183296,
-0.0226828121,
0.0184521824,
0.061420545,
-0.0193861779,
-0.0221758932,
0.037943121,
0.0129803568,
0.0452952757,
0.0533079095,
-0.0020626374,
0.0351201147,
-0.0006649261,
-0.0803955495,
-0.018727228,
-0.0504858047,
-0.0373541452,
0.0343408398,
-0.0290039424,
-0.0397143066,
-0.0404590778,
-0.0410880595,
-0.0174539592,
0.0150213232,
0.0041509005,
0.0096787699,
0.0373993441,
-0.0214804467,
-0.0507030264,
0.0330114029,
-0.0124363778,
0.0276694763,
0.0557658747,
-0.0129435463,
0.0191846341,
0.0247237645,
-0.0476137362,
0.0256978087,
-0.0104238065,
-0.0637686327,
-0.0433836393,
-0.0370164104,
0.0182878803,
0.0274548698,
-0.0166385993,
-0.0237107854,
0.0099734031,
0.0179587398,
0.0251219794,
-0.0255260952,
0.0256307889,
-0.006586717,
0.0084717171,
0.0191027652,
0.029498104,
0.0453099385,
0.0206899997,
-0.0259158928,
-0.0692598224,
-0.004095369,
0.0221157912,
0.012613765,
0.0334431566,
0.0031732139,
-0.0633725747,
-0.0755612478,
-0.0288586859,
-0.0072892285,
-0.0459464677,
0.0018589152,
-0.0227127261,
0.0215563495,
-0.0428797752,
-0.0215717293,
0.01412562,
-0.0319839902,
0.0105981724,
-0.0090061752,
0.0383300781,
0.0178311523,
0.0340335816,
-0.0158083308,
0.0144125512,
-0.0058248215,
0.0339157395,
0.0189768039,
0.0519073568,
-0.0334952474,
-0.0074267681,
0.0036363669,
-0.0050205635,
0.0544630103,
-0.0235053208,
-0.0263292529,
-0.0209070034,
-0.0265865009,
0.0183298029,
0.0179388691,
-0.0154415872,
0.0331097506,
-0.0111672301,
-0.0359490179,
-0.0016856192,
0.0191588663,
-0.0136693288,
-0.0390767455,
0.0142049473,
-0.0123461736,
-0.0414719693,
0.0297642928,
0.0361179821,
0.0133214863,
0.0133351367,
0.0220008045,
-0.0483190119,
-0.0223249197,
-0.0663555637,
0.0165348798,
-0.0299177375,
-0.0319033563,
-0.0458136313,
-0.0655395985,
-0.0624957867,
-0.0025372191,
0.0287177134,
0.0076858816,
0.0257926956,
-0.0244347472,
0.0649278313,
-0.0013244887,
0.0469980426,
-0.0609539822,
0.0314556584,
-0.0223482512,
-0.0188640207,
0.0096561359,
-4.736944687e-33,
0.013414056,
-0.0467620008,
-0.0056281323,
-0.0198500641,
0.0260013007,
0.0170712452,
-0.0273468532,
0.0102246841,
-0.0297172684,
0.0553582013,
0.0330856405,
0.0008774764,
0.0409355462,
-0.024474455,
-0.01204402,
-0.0139595577,
0.0151432119,
0.0027625994,
-0.0335183032,
-0.0048439717,
0.0327023454,
-0.0356198885,
0.0884966701,
-0.0783409178,
0.0708566085,
0.0407827348,
0.0006129039,
-0.0072893775,
0.0259602703,
0.0531789549,
-0.0174353849,
0.0347449072,
0.0297251288,
-0.0455260016,
0.0213894472,
0.0443444476,
-0.0462932959,
-0.0181730054,
0.0329012349,
0.0114685195,
-0.0070610768,
-0.0326787047,
-0.009527009,
-0.0088371523,
-0.0199339539,
0.0156357549,
0.0377636515,
-0.0199827533,
0.0220808666,
-0.0163653195,
-0.079995513,
0.0388676189,
-0.0202604607,
0.0337322764,
0.031415008,
0.0317533948,
0.037664447,
0.0708192512,
-0.0821229666,
0.0146922348,
-0.11019364,
-0.0113110757,
0.0374092683,
-0.0695352331,
-0.0317010023,
0.0422345214,
-0.0031234231,
0.0420404077,
-0.0210820902,
0.0176487565,
-0.0110863196,
0.013850945,
0.0944427103,
0.0871531889,
0.045223292,
-0.0025182955,
-0.1029133126,
-0.0077915769,
0.0480617508,
-0.0268844087,
0.0121250125,
-0.0252341367,
0.0183279552,
0.0152642708,
-0.0718801916,
-0.0698895603,
-0.0261068512,
-0.0115803005,
-0.0191113744,
0.0174998995,
-0.0398244932,
0.0579361767,
0.071337074,
-0.050564982,
0.0115340305,
-0.0148744369,
-0.0001358575,
0.0261315349,
0.0015167275,
0.0696188956,
-0.0449569412,
-0.0130535187,
-0.0326550044,
0.0540389344,
0.0619275831,
-0.0258013085,
0.0672504082,
-0.0467157811,
-0.0485539846,
0.0154739982,
-0.0427059159,
-0.0000854043,
-0.0373206027,
0.0847485065,
0.0196254291,
0.0099727595,
0.0170959756,
-0.019937899,
0.0217523873,
-0.0119892284,
0.0091934903,
-0.0139535544,
-0.0521623679,
0.0094227521,
-0.0284517445,
-0.0153834429,
0.0007197504,
0.0532510988,
0.0315304361,
-0.0411670357,
0.0058618193,
-0.0024659075,
1.977e-7,
0.0547808371,
0.0315820277,
-0.021721907,
0.012776345,
0.0227380469,
-0.0117568998,
0.0028611398,
0.0336389616,
-0.033442881,
-0.061294008,
-0.0356417298,
0.0171674248,
0.0802239627,
0.0714403689,
-0.0784673914,
-0.0589032657,
0.0017852515,
0.0120553691,
-0.0451233946,
0.0506944023,
0.0259574614,
0.0673391744,
0.0174214616,
0.0260110758,
-0.0484705977,
0.0063103326,
0.073481068,
-0.0047861296,
-0.0878683329,
0.0230075549,
0.0586173348,
-0.0052612908,
0.0194427818,
0.0117507754,
-0.0100580873,
0.003813372,
0.0138160093,
0.033850871,
0.0411822945,
0.0021298944,
-0.0564284213,
-0.0353505649,
0.0063638776,
-0.0296573602,
0.0248569697,
-0.0617929511,
-0.0055799126,
-0.050455831,
-0.0158064868,
-0.0068807625,
0.0772997066,
-0.0085584149,
-0.0204320718,
0.0426954478,
0.0175570864,
0.0118220793,
0.0291072577,
-0.0408585481,
-0.0267109443,
0.0130089587,
-0.0350789763,
-0.0338625275,
0.0671096295,
0.0121810259,
0.0307585876,
-0.0224965997,
0.0242027007,
1.293135966e-34,
0.0418402217,
-0.0093120607,
-0.0315684266,
-0.0536671467,
0.0788246691,
0.0026375761,
-0.0183769241,
-0.0124718621,
-0.0161505882,
0.0091237212,
0.0224102512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09247v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09247v1 | Hypernymy Understanding Evaluation of Text-to-Image Models via WordNet Hierarchy | 2023-10-13T16:53:25 | 2023-10-13T16:53:25 | Anton Baryshnikov, Max Ryabinin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Text-to-image synthesis has recently attracted widespread attention due to
rapidly improving quality and numerous practical applications. However, the
language understanding capabilities of text-to-image models are still poorly
understood, which makes it difficult to reason about prompt formulations that a
given model would understand well. In this work, we measure the capability of
popular text-to-image models to understand $\textit{hypernymy}$, or the "is-a"
relation between words. We design two automatic metrics based on the WordNet
semantic hierarchy and existing image classifiers pretrained on ImageNet. These
metrics both enable broad quantitative comparison of linguistic capabilities
for text-to-image models and offer a way of finding fine-grained qualitative
differences, such as words that are unknown to models and thus are difficult
for them to draw. We comprehensively evaluate popular text-to-image models,
including GLIDE, Latent Diffusion, and Stable Diffusion, showing how our
metrics can provide a better understanding of the individual strengths and
weaknesses of these models. | [
0.0322727859,
0.0591040179,
-0.0005249592,
0.0849085227,
-0.011086626,
0.0089872237,
-0.0192890298,
0.0339083746,
-0.035859853,
-0.0440411232,
-0.015419757,
-0.0528019965,
0.0489405952,
-0.0166880805,
0.0318750665,
-0.0974333063,
-0.0017445094,
0.013135409,
-0.0695394501,
0.0026776472,
0.022945229,
0.0305390134,
-0.0062464238,
0.0353475846,
-0.0348632932,
-0.0122539317,
0.0372505113,
0.0369105898,
0.0324255638,
-0.0163993705,
-0.0520201139,
0.034090735,
0.0488831699,
0.019673869,
0.0000018649,
-0.0324696675,
0.014853457,
0.0033224076,
0.0309040546,
-0.0093949232,
0.1075709909,
-0.0404894091,
0.0111794285,
-0.0391745903,
-0.0009343272,
0.0353127606,
0.0871886685,
0.0552592501,
0.0362668075,
0.0245643668,
-0.0283300467,
-0.0445037521,
0.0518440083,
-0.0336976908,
0.0232760329,
-0.0298239142,
-0.0137067772,
0.0433499999,
-0.0489162244,
-0.0037697975,
-0.0422929674,
0.0555610098,
-0.0054645264,
0.0099063823,
0.0122592049,
0.0476944149,
0.0059600174,
-0.0344256759,
-0.0152804907,
0.0810904056,
-0.0516575202,
0.0039161718,
-0.0014713102,
-0.0136197247,
-0.0257108994,
0.0951978713,
-0.0165516082,
0.0106544774,
0.0135830157,
0.0227516424,
-0.0431305021,
0.0161436368,
0.0144552542,
0.0130844107,
0.0010440993,
0.0304766502,
0.0393495373,
0.038232483,
-0.0177976992,
0.0149485962,
-0.0200407337,
-0.0525273755,
0.0119551588,
0.0148297194,
0.0462523028,
0.0375718847,
-0.0235198736,
-0.0349348299,
-0.0126118436,
-0.0728288442,
0.0382374153,
-0.0085929055,
-0.0272841658,
0.0314894617,
-0.0419080816,
0.0321647972,
-0.0114437947,
-0.0026498828,
-0.0521398447,
0.0057947403,
-0.0401629433,
-0.0138471872,
-0.0673187301,
-0.0107449908,
-0.00461266,
-0.070909448,
-0.0385183394,
-0.0190066174,
0.0080751255,
0.0119721191,
0.0362334698,
0.0180135686,
-0.056562759,
-0.019419767,
-0.0498468131,
-0.0015232711,
0.0028327401,
0.0400458798,
-0.0078167645,
0.0319366865,
0.0306068696,
0.0207135081,
0.0097565018,
-0.0008492533,
-0.0039970465,
0.1029809937,
-0.0340279415,
-0.030282801,
-0.0184241477,
-0.0404601581,
-0.027670525,
-0.0448787138,
0.040260274,
-0.0762790442,
0.0091654016,
-0.0266638752,
0.0144128827,
-0.0448723771,
0.011354614,
0.0008005662,
-0.0513555333,
0.0930403993,
-0.0291197337,
-0.0134899626,
0.0263210889,
0.0024697715,
-0.0089508453,
0.057130836,
0.0595554933,
0.0338492878,
0.0506435744,
-0.0067244833,
-0.032283254,
0.0243082996,
-0.0034188961,
-0.0112349726,
-0.0509082302,
-0.0347654186,
-0.0190644432,
0.0203496218,
0.0272132941,
0.0564278737,
-0.0333622694,
-0.0093868049,
0.0677812845,
0.065508835,
0.0223212466,
0.0234630834,
0.0716921464,
-0.0071158167,
0.0012143746,
0.0191257503,
-0.0343960077,
0.0282794666,
0.0043736314,
0.0232298896,
-0.0190678723,
0.0310537834,
-0.0203364231,
-0.0635109842,
-0.0082902368,
-0.0095732296,
0.0095277717,
-0.0501672365,
0.0487729199,
0.0520207137,
-0.0460321195,
0.0544365197,
0.0307420827,
-0.0455639064,
0.0008294506,
-0.0286713112,
0.0302871428,
0.0817601383,
0.019667061,
-0.0056439196,
0.037036825,
0.0112285456,
-0.0023002378,
0.0621978231,
-0.0493226983,
-0.0040354114,
0.009779647,
-0.0331212431,
-0.0081725456,
0.0198236126,
0.0161910523,
0.0406900384,
-0.0284833983,
0.0231285784,
0.038884677,
-0.0480839685,
-0.0368990414,
0.0555791147,
0.0233179405,
0.0108778067,
-0.0416898318,
0.0175993163,
-0.0156741384,
0.0026587262,
-0.0459013917,
0.0063440027,
-0.0188624524,
-0.0481733307,
-0.0387935489,
-0.0083414316,
-0.0104985731,
-0.0511837266,
-0.0081814341,
-0.0872961208,
0.0153029645,
0.021314038,
-0.0364058502,
-0.0188423209,
-0.0026908766,
0.0027353701,
0.0505788177,
-0.0274942536,
0.0000202933,
0.0282752551,
0.0204662718,
0.0113867326,
0.0619414598,
0.0047431285,
0.0382347293,
-0.0409370735,
0.0081818085,
0.000824446,
0.0151310964,
-0.0146036176,
0.0267971754,
0.00091098,
0.0214753412,
-0.0050779404,
0.0310330205,
-0.0184155405,
-0.0131662982,
-0.039156083,
-0.0131146554,
-0.0049426835,
0.0004318486,
-0.0019054714,
-0.041366864,
0.0184055138,
0.0017494314,
-0.0073277955,
0.0738033429,
-0.0590613894,
-0.0290104132,
0.0504457839,
-0.0120077673,
-0.0315218456,
-0.0493086129,
-0.0342351533,
0.0201634187,
0.0894800499,
0.0300145838,
-0.0053803655,
-0.0125215631,
0.0385060273,
-0.0768563375,
-0.0075056413,
-0.0082610045,
-0.0603741147,
0.0211985968,
-0.0007806268,
-0.0112772807,
0.0431113504,
0.0319051221,
0.0001021985,
0.0173736624,
0.0109849153,
0.0019785082,
-0.0498068258,
-0.010304193,
-0.0176247712,
0.0203966368,
-0.0375868008,
-0.0343869366,
0.0755395219,
0.0144360987,
-0.00399131,
-0.0513566025,
0.0216820799,
-0.0547941513,
-0.0189458095,
-0.0524432585,
-0.0001417359,
0.0181925856,
0.0048147724,
-0.0446345583,
-0.0581164658,
0.0268160161,
-0.0650272518,
0.017510796,
0.0252286717,
-0.0009485493,
0.0178174525,
0.0534380414,
0.0108900573,
0.0727717653,
0.0129356803,
-0.0040594414,
-0.0595781542,
-0.0484113693,
0.0212395005,
-0.0089876354,
0.0565789007,
-0.0497711487,
0.0164452288,
-0.006303452,
0.011993493,
-0.022670256,
-0.0013568038,
-0.0139315333,
0.020058427,
-0.022720255,
-0.0292316545,
0.0507807247,
0.0418205746,
-0.0134687116,
-0.0034830207,
0.018105004,
-0.0365284756,
-0.0180794019,
0.0953900889,
0.0495784804,
-0.0222853292,
-0.0102891941,
0.0004598817,
0.0012516122,
0.0201579239,
-0.0032228387,
0.0092314715,
-0.0531192757,
0.0275237337,
-0.0202081595,
0.0303336997,
-0.0259893276,
0.0181475915,
0.0335061178,
-0.0493341908,
0.0102740526,
0.0748953596,
0.032607343,
-0.0033827133,
0.0118694482,
0.0403004922,
0.0373672508,
0.0128830997,
-0.0209990516,
-0.0529181063,
-0.0241174996,
-0.0217968896,
-0.0305608585,
0.0167443119,
-0.0068404838,
-0.0039697448,
-0.052674029,
0.0178331994,
0.0123425946,
-0.0281612128,
0.0243437849,
0.0270647798,
0.0022066138,
0.0126677677,
-0.0276336931,
-0.0358420312,
0.0037222884,
-0.0302616376,
0.0017568299,
0.0131885242,
-0.0257411543,
0.0254232883,
-0.024158366,
0.001525394,
0.0278575551,
0.0850567669,
-0.0232135504,
-0.061605569,
0.0108042648,
-0.0169836376,
-0.005080427,
-0.0009187358,
0.0662552491,
0.0008632288,
-0.0291403085,
0.0203823373,
0.022823412,
-0.0081949346,
-0.0123978136,
-0.0480562858,
0.0131662469,
0.0096755261,
-0.0343759581,
-0.0452130176,
-0.0025545009,
0.0152200507,
0.0604972355,
0.0196942519,
-0.0444635972,
-0.0064697876,
-0.014557424,
0.0135624781,
-0.0119324885,
-0.0553190298,
0.0212539509,
-0.0284828171,
-0.0337907374,
-0.1114170253,
0.0036830402,
-0.0258645806,
0.0468640327,
-0.0031367361,
-0.0103650391,
0.0157888662,
0.0111035788,
-0.0358409733,
0.0575017743,
0.0151047958,
0.0391379036,
-0.0162511505,
0.0040258048,
0.0731789544,
-0.0057651373,
-0.0721969903,
0.0591505952,
-0.056229718,
-0.0131010069,
-0.0272776857,
0.0394727737,
0.0258573182,
-0.0091875009,
-0.014608969,
-0.0448643714,
0.0374789014,
0.0268702917,
0.0585675724,
0.0021631496,
0.0079810387,
0.0299348701,
-0.0094639231,
0.0477934889,
-0.0384961441,
0.0553845465,
0.0188473631,
0.0083532436,
0.0055396911,
-0.0405423231,
-0.0148769272,
-0.0372794345,
0.0115738334,
-0.0480122566,
0.0187615287,
-0.0626267418,
-0.0098165711,
-0.0256533679,
-0.0062752119,
-0.0831834003,
0.0022459419,
0.0358412117,
0.0072593638,
-0.0318432413,
-0.0319265835,
-0.004128383,
0.0359630808,
-0.0008425484,
-0.0101987273,
0.008742935,
0.0327685401,
0.0091413446,
0.0069992226,
-0.0125717754,
-0.0223858953,
-0.0463888198,
0.0104611041,
-0.0226634964,
0.0291059949,
0.0191084743,
-0.0200123489,
-0.0674239695,
0.0381155647,
-0.0345718302,
0.0072394353,
-0.0657402724,
0.0517813042,
0.0302944425,
-0.0291165393,
0.0520788357,
-0.0507956035,
-0.0143840676,
0.0194048639,
0.025049556,
0.008671103,
-0.0376187712,
0.0709838495,
0.0016006194,
0.01361374,
-0.0033654424,
0.0605706796,
-0.0059740054,
0.0060815467,
-0.0227895081,
-0.030008601,
-0.0174659435,
-0.0152882086,
0.0305321403,
-0.0065711453,
0.0211340263,
0.0294008292,
-0.0755699798,
-0.1023964062,
0.0112963207,
0.0595149025,
-0.0122878263,
0.0305088963,
0.0573613048,
0.0400113538,
0.0073195626,
-0.0041508935,
0.0094071422,
-0.0164522436,
-0.0402381197,
0.011894485,
-0.0167543497,
-5.903313895e-33,
-0.0693402663,
-0.0429273508,
-0.0074968203,
-0.0217747074,
-0.0503525138,
0.0173494238,
-0.0283142366,
-0.0011276527,
-0.0165893007,
0.0663768351,
0.0272343084,
-0.0027384043,
0.0102468412,
0.0255019143,
-0.0258267131,
0.0430695191,
0.0237700958,
-0.0177604482,
-0.0274739023,
0.0227786563,
0.03750249,
-0.008684746,
0.063683413,
-0.0613013916,
-0.0034061603,
0.0076624975,
-0.009142397,
0.0184581131,
0.0599601902,
0.0402782783,
-0.0245589707,
0.0410704799,
0.0233191047,
-0.0136205619,
-0.0023412083,
0.0397765078,
-0.0654114187,
-0.0479399525,
0.0233134367,
-0.0122196563,
-0.0756173506,
-0.0157344341,
0.0663752854,
-0.0228896644,
-0.0163255762,
-0.0431662723,
0.072029829,
-0.0323855206,
-0.014941358,
-0.0257204007,
-0.0919480696,
0.0015737433,
-0.034521956,
-0.0264682546,
0.0128000993,
-0.020666955,
0.0013881148,
0.0201346707,
-0.0602629147,
-0.0048075775,
-0.0095623611,
0.0286414847,
0.0623597056,
0.0638653934,
0.00603155,
0.0559232533,
0.0012102434,
-0.0056463075,
0.0372186974,
0.024211973,
0.0491031744,
0.0774010941,
0.0507659242,
0.0273922309,
0.0004473006,
-0.0111594973,
-0.0347902961,
-0.0003542652,
-0.0828413218,
0.0155833578,
0.016525602,
-0.0061011543,
-0.0001649703,
0.0169876665,
-0.072534889,
-0.0606183857,
-0.0202716421,
-0.0365683287,
0.0195959099,
-0.0108235329,
-0.0043190024,
0.0339727625,
0.0390798748,
-0.0334534757,
-0.0647477359,
-0.0042644152,
-0.0224654768,
0.0636843964,
-0.0096950987,
0.0248513594,
-0.0192912687,
-0.0487109125,
0.0269740149,
0.0744514391,
0.0202999525,
-0.0097478256,
0.0324163847,
-0.0258876812,
-0.0352551527,
-0.0083718337,
-0.0366623439,
-0.0455291308,
-0.0079936758,
0.0124547528,
0.0302316733,
0.0011012156,
-0.0524144992,
0.0046160384,
-0.0141131803,
-0.0502139255,
0.0275616944,
0.0200472269,
-0.0095708864,
0.0223992709,
-0.0607024394,
0.0127262902,
-0.0232189372,
-0.0062692994,
0.0934377387,
-0.0571345463,
-0.0311254542,
0.0357553214,
2.582e-7,
0.0635399073,
0.0272808392,
0.0037144548,
0.0126752863,
0.0234756004,
0.0210807845,
-0.0352687165,
0.0424418971,
-0.0351385772,
-0.0581084117,
0.0032504785,
0.0534246303,
0.0487281159,
-0.0077052796,
-0.0078836493,
-0.00500882,
-0.016263878,
0.0063680541,
-0.0522142202,
0.0318919085,
0.1194294244,
0.0690226853,
-0.0021887212,
-0.0278088655,
0.0077480273,
-0.0694156438,
0.0651142225,
-0.0310368426,
0.0314429104,
0.0123623479,
-0.0078935903,
0.0019745899,
-0.0154375918,
0.0113307387,
-0.0052052033,
-0.0079686716,
0.0924447849,
-0.0040451596,
-0.0587990619,
-0.0024118703,
-0.0223749671,
-0.0130213788,
0.0019195598,
-0.085154742,
0.0747198835,
-0.0580420159,
-0.0048660026,
-0.0248645134,
0.0100722425,
0.0301164836,
0.0284873471,
-0.0090673408,
-0.0517949723,
0.0263604131,
0.046586059,
0.0110832723,
-0.0251988545,
-0.0813545659,
-0.0124820722,
0.0156424288,
-0.014488372,
-0.0433922149,
-0.0222803149,
-0.0011677762,
0.0128349615,
-0.0153515181,
-0.0368967168,
1.833433462e-34,
0.0131490612,
0.0022492043,
-0.0001789889,
-0.0051271683,
0.0349455252,
0.0044960892,
-0.0016059137,
0.001349345,
-0.0196644329,
-0.0995415971,
0.0100753941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09241v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09241v1 | Precedent-Enhanced Legal Judgment Prediction with LLM and Domain-Model Collaboration | 2023-10-13T16:47:20 | 2023-10-13T16:47:20 | Yiquan Wu, Siying Zhou, Yifei Liu, Weiming Lu, Xiaozhong Liu, Yating Zhang, Changlong Sun, Fei Wu, Kun Kuang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Legal Judgment Prediction (LJP) has become an increasingly crucial task in
Legal AI, i.e., predicting the judgment of the case in terms of case fact
description. Precedents are the previous legal cases with similar facts, which
are the basis for the judgment of the subsequent case in national legal
systems. Thus, it is worthwhile to explore the utilization of precedents in the
LJP. Recent advances in deep learning have enabled a variety of techniques to
be used to solve the LJP task. These can be broken down into two categories:
large language models (LLMs) and domain-specific models. LLMs are capable of
interpreting and generating complex natural language, while domain models are
efficient in learning task-specific information. In this paper, we propose the
precedent-enhanced LJP framework (PLJP), a system that leverages the strength
of both LLM and domain models in the context of precedents. Specifically, the
domain models are designed to provide candidate labels and find the proper
precedents efficiently, and the large models will make the final prediction
with an in-context precedents comprehension. Experiments on the real-world
dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our PLJP. Moreover, our work shows a
promising direction for LLM and domain-model collaboration that can be
generalized to other vertical domains. | [
0.0482960194,
0.0535875894,
-0.0164523683,
0.0284651741,
-0.0702239051,
0.0053717103,
0.017886987,
0.0153983822,
-0.003529459,
-0.0763378814,
-0.0496367291,
-0.0494788028,
-0.0459945612,
0.0320522413,
-0.0435127579,
-0.058216501,
0.0292107798,
0.0071108458,
0.062634401,
0.0075897477,
0.0130416295,
0.0121674743,
0.0157615487,
0.0223412421,
-0.0451260954,
-0.0296542086,
-0.0076021021,
-0.0262895003,
-0.0027642155,
-0.0246413946,
0.0396134444,
0.0600666739,
0.0617176555,
0.001870747,
0.0000018964,
-0.0585810058,
0.0080596181,
-0.0315371901,
-0.0033822993,
0.0198272932,
-0.0104887243,
0.0015495984,
-0.0211184788,
-0.0105241761,
-0.0688527972,
-0.0347348303,
-0.0118526993,
0.0470813699,
0.0080639152,
0.074055396,
0.0139524946,
-0.058848802,
0.0469042249,
-0.0718423724,
0.0074808598,
-0.0731824711,
0.0382536761,
0.0120593132,
0.006337401,
-0.0037460069,
0.0157628115,
-0.0075935358,
0.0508713387,
-0.008193979,
-0.0412555113,
0.0182478633,
0.0333801471,
0.0044165212,
-0.0053240289,
0.0713991076,
0.0486733019,
-0.0225314554,
-0.0032513791,
-0.0123039447,
0.0487791374,
0.0059691826,
-0.0049841823,
0.0941348746,
0.0061031943,
0.0380485542,
0.0585471243,
0.0389181823,
0.0127013223,
0.025213195,
-0.0054244706,
0.0803971738,
-0.007705614,
-0.0399359725,
0.0058694449,
0.0181355532,
0.0239834413,
-0.0478255488,
0.0422927924,
0.0308691505,
-0.0215413533,
0.0369304568,
-0.0244707856,
0.0084717413,
0.0512259491,
-0.0489501208,
0.0019500984,
0.005474552,
-0.0328159854,
0.0841718689,
-0.035805814,
-0.011917294,
-0.0090126954,
-0.0164354146,
-0.0028939305,
-0.0495530292,
-0.0402760431,
0.0153633142,
-0.0131712286,
0.0701093078,
-0.0664682463,
0.0162910018,
-0.01935344,
0.0056863814,
-0.0468059815,
0.0112192621,
0.0315309837,
0.0251260828,
-0.0044920747,
-0.0319279954,
-0.0792455599,
-0.0458912104,
-0.0389295928,
0.0566721335,
-0.0115130981,
-0.0075510629,
0.0321791843,
-0.0052335048,
-0.0179919861,
-0.0120049166,
0.0258129388,
0.1428616196,
0.004614668,
-0.0239295214,
-0.0731294602,
-0.0634302348,
-0.0090776281,
-0.0627776235,
-0.0286138635,
-0.0640666112,
-0.0063603031,
-0.0280759484,
-0.0285217632,
-0.0876282156,
0.0232980512,
0.0442153923,
-0.0100769904,
0.0614574812,
0.026196003,
-0.0427071676,
-0.0197018981,
0.031286709,
0.0021656118,
-0.0091153421,
-0.0016256713,
0.0368053205,
0.0007563701,
0.0112976227,
0.0136139439,
0.0252654143,
0.021825958,
0.0233112313,
-0.0122077009,
0.0045315414,
-0.0088237552,
0.024236396,
0.0220981445,
0.0431645997,
0.0213130433,
-0.0431272909,
0.0154337594,
0.0240475908,
0.0154789668,
0.0746058896,
0.0486801341,
-0.0330244228,
0.0074032811,
0.0036691194,
-0.0686768219,
0.0115165543,
-0.0012754425,
-0.001437919,
-0.0739453733,
0.0090897726,
-0.0525472052,
-0.0540458672,
0.0412343293,
-0.0144589096,
0.0122375796,
0.015275172,
0.0319650993,
0.0364049561,
-0.0458554514,
0.0354341157,
0.0596631728,
-0.0027064756,
-0.028006671,
-0.0332975164,
0.0292996373,
0.0074408385,
0.0342124738,
-0.0374154225,
-0.0173345972,
-0.0148385502,
-0.0240608696,
0.0266243331,
0.0365712047,
0.000856727,
-0.0124032069,
-0.0219581984,
-0.0341589004,
0.0053465934,
0.031692028,
0.0495741926,
0.0049704029,
0.0248298403,
0.0478136465,
-0.0539281331,
0.0324484259,
0.0423893221,
-0.037164811,
-0.0379642136,
0.0611330569,
0.0102368984,
0.0416155681,
0.0315900035,
0.021396609,
-0.0257103331,
0.0250513349,
-0.004282759,
-0.0255775582,
-0.0017257399,
-0.0442358181,
-0.0107512055,
0.0416799486,
-0.0517081991,
-0.0241849925,
-0.0105491374,
-0.0425774232,
0.0032965664,
-0.025542194,
0.0232142694,
0.0073900777,
-0.0619082861,
-0.0174119994,
0.0224879384,
-0.0094956607,
-0.0170729123,
0.0653132498,
-0.017012056,
-0.0706331357,
-0.006915139,
0.0097627556,
0.0275676847,
-0.0068668555,
-0.0088435384,
-0.0689802617,
-0.0330210291,
0.0135866366,
0.0201896001,
0.0227614194,
-0.0396109298,
0.0071062529,
-0.0378743671,
0.0156647842,
-0.0347327441,
-0.0176953431,
-0.0208388083,
-0.0279861763,
0.0012703155,
-0.022660844,
-0.0420101508,
-0.0107357576,
-0.0153025435,
-0.0115119917,
0.0348655134,
-0.0033571073,
-0.0045376397,
-0.0413266048,
-0.0159711726,
-0.0221075341,
0.0401566774,
-0.0042810803,
0.0025289094,
-0.0191480573,
0.1078579724,
-0.0172110964,
0.0228129867,
-0.0260384306,
0.0192610323,
-0.0219713002,
0.0071585574,
-0.0041300002,
0.0257052612,
0.0202868562,
0.0129658021,
0.032439474,
0.0096260654,
-0.0644248948,
0.0110190809,
-0.0350740291,
0.0298444126,
-0.0402360968,
0.0035496559,
-0.0037370441,
0.0228067134,
0.0113425301,
-0.0083989017,
-0.0052346047,
-0.0109492773,
0.01629439,
-0.0296830703,
-0.0103906281,
0.0013629243,
-0.0016551653,
0.0197897963,
0.0190499891,
-0.0735854581,
0.0799814761,
0.0428116284,
0.0568129569,
-0.02197209,
-0.0170329157,
-0.0771755129,
0.0971114039,
0.0003993072,
-0.0277792197,
-0.0337545872,
-0.0557766743,
0.0056946259,
-0.009829767,
0.0200251117,
-0.0085227303,
0.094618611,
-0.025572639,
0.022651216,
-0.0119547024,
-0.0390052572,
-0.0676526353,
-0.0140523277,
-0.0179663785,
0.0176807307,
-0.0022811398,
0.0162603091,
-0.0309690256,
-0.0185759254,
-0.040932849,
-0.0040117623,
0.036304526,
-0.0048802481,
-0.0427590273,
0.0123304827,
-0.0050197821,
-0.0374239758,
-0.0008696215,
-0.0114139589,
-0.0180449374,
0.026713619,
0.00030282,
-0.0041274531,
-0.0235495511,
0.0100479061,
0.0052690855,
-0.0574172027,
-0.0053053191,
0.0521726534,
-0.0098760882,
-0.0691033378,
0.0417032614,
0.0869221836,
0.0053329929,
-0.0550051481,
-0.0069519929,
0.0177766122,
0.001860369,
0.0276000183,
0.0106578553,
-0.1024978533,
-0.0313981697,
0.0017551139,
-0.0713169202,
-0.0115743801,
-0.044255618,
-0.0071444558,
-0.1006746665,
0.0511104241,
0.0099195326,
0.0218044929,
-0.0213540215,
-0.0340197459,
0.0177122205,
-0.0183126871,
0.003676204,
-0.0080183623,
-0.0213760026,
-0.031160377,
-0.0037772942,
-0.0572845638,
-0.0104767969,
0.0683367997,
-0.0571766347,
0.0517870262,
0.017901551,
0.0169280004,
-0.0186638776,
-0.0221378151,
0.0014025423,
-0.0325090997,
0.0283739287,
0.0009357613,
0.0328237116,
-0.010476945,
0.0087518292,
-0.0323151313,
0.0485419743,
-0.0325679816,
-0.0303982385,
0.0432267971,
0.0611127131,
-0.064271532,
-0.0328192487,
-0.0340952538,
-0.0139818322,
0.0127481893,
0.0687174052,
-0.0014495937,
-0.029054489,
-0.0442508422,
-0.0090843979,
-0.0437001958,
-0.0321452394,
-0.004812235,
-0.0111817187,
-0.0227115862,
0.0158082321,
-0.0161280446,
-0.0022741235,
-0.0046251388,
0.0121928751,
0.0277629867,
0.0272042137,
0.0233777948,
-0.0013288329,
-0.0550842769,
0.0254287105,
-0.0489403307,
0.0236486215,
-0.0331589207,
0.0319885164,
0.0552184917,
-0.0094330618,
-0.0259099212,
0.0302984528,
-0.0219903458,
-0.0070956275,
-0.0054746573,
0.0123664998,
0.0099783922,
0.0242180713,
-0.0302320234,
-0.0194222387,
0.0633251294,
0.0289469436,
0.0248993356,
-0.0216486137,
0.0626257882,
-0.052384045,
-0.0136400834,
0.0057258573,
-0.0131251421,
0.0591239035,
0.0404527001,
-0.0101988595,
-0.0413237624,
-0.0343401656,
0.0137625048,
-0.0141921537,
0.058960855,
0.0084273238,
-0.0307971761,
-0.0302663613,
-0.0025746152,
0.0049891067,
0.0120805465,
-0.0312228333,
0.0031335079,
0.0305074677,
0.0056488258,
-0.0387133807,
0.0511777215,
-0.0068637109,
0.0186671242,
-0.0271780584,
0.037787348,
0.0313942134,
0.0333057493,
0.0034029009,
-0.0279575903,
0.0019667947,
0.0214978326,
-0.0019734111,
0.0441941507,
-0.0070467107,
0.0236725044,
0.0086095128,
0.0325101689,
-0.0224602968,
-0.0103922421,
-0.0175673105,
-0.0017224469,
-0.0224181172,
0.0224285424,
0.0788860619,
-0.0136138126,
-0.0506447442,
-0.0431066193,
0.0121033881,
-0.0076943156,
0.0439692102,
-0.0244307593,
-0.0191943515,
0.0410345681,
0.0088324845,
-0.0082705319,
0.0290287286,
0.0204438288,
0.0127027305,
0.0457453914,
0.0006253234,
-0.0128720608,
-0.0328822844,
-0.0412059762,
0.0041565867,
0.0103264945,
-0.02431917,
-0.0388648063,
-0.0686107874,
-0.0296786334,
-0.0040689986,
-0.0051436969,
-0.0085562142,
0.0327707939,
0.0167531613,
0.0565447584,
0.0321056545,
-0.005628434,
-0.0408170521,
0.0095946556,
-0.0042929794,
-0.0356892347,
-0.0336241163,
-5.567207367e-33,
-0.014162018,
-0.0452380963,
0.011217243,
0.0367604457,
-0.0275541581,
-0.0158479344,
0.0015976469,
-0.0213648938,
-0.0368898883,
0.0454359986,
-0.0108187152,
0.0120019736,
0.0169390664,
0.0019260125,
-0.0010439605,
-0.0387028567,
0.018813666,
0.0068842112,
0.037667606,
0.0331785642,
-0.0083365934,
0.0380659513,
0.0380320698,
-0.1286619902,
0.0220078528,
0.020823542,
-0.0182634313,
-0.0053823194,
-0.0601750724,
0.0458691493,
-0.0080534332,
0.0488514043,
0.0378384851,
-0.0701976046,
-0.0153345931,
0.0450099222,
-0.0929428115,
0.0095768236,
0.0041903509,
-0.0369394571,
0.0016381157,
-0.0223789979,
0.0215038173,
0.04274299,
-0.0131213563,
0.006170176,
0.0470493585,
-0.043591354,
-0.03455019,
-0.0710963011,
-0.0543034412,
0.0343352817,
0.0053937389,
0.0080230972,
0.0250592995,
-0.0028338674,
0.0057500568,
0.0299452767,
-0.0846037939,
0.0195953324,
-0.0346523933,
-0.006482454,
0.0176932029,
-0.0613688156,
-0.0339288786,
0.0755702853,
-0.0111433985,
0.0044807252,
-0.0483759157,
-0.0257661939,
0.0153805688,
0.1138117686,
-0.0032428596,
0.0568286814,
0.0310095605,
-0.0482972562,
-0.0949939489,
0.0022344668,
0.0247591566,
0.0191069283,
0.013317313,
-0.0410188474,
-0.0365821347,
0.0085801817,
-0.0446657501,
-0.0210574064,
-0.0077708466,
0.007315408,
0.0133697344,
0.0098560145,
0.05784918,
-0.0149868317,
0.0056301965,
-0.045974046,
0.0199772418,
0.059441328,
-0.0079763588,
-0.0016431139,
0.0005902122,
0.0238479991,
-0.0489357039,
-0.0653863549,
-0.00654979,
-0.0388366841,
-0.0058846907,
-0.0069143185,
0.0586351752,
-0.0134131853,
-0.0404964425,
-0.0046209786,
0.0245310161,
0.0280272458,
0.0460520685,
0.0376012884,
-0.0034233329,
0.023893103,
0.0167878643,
0.0657868162,
0.0154958721,
0.0155208427,
-0.0272845402,
-0.0208608881,
0.0292737745,
0.0178185757,
-0.0048664836,
-0.0373586491,
-0.0001271407,
0.0204846635,
0.059640076,
-0.0235137623,
0.0141399857,
0.0564779565,
2.548e-7,
0.0456671752,
0.0368298963,
-0.0084896227,
0.0107489871,
0.0088306395,
0.064058505,
0.0158224348,
0.0556889065,
0.0306097046,
-0.0481788293,
0.0521946661,
0.0282122362,
0.0356430337,
0.0268091839,
-0.075066559,
-0.0057341326,
-0.0331341662,
-0.0527454093,
-0.0602887236,
0.0187907089,
0.0324398354,
0.1177753955,
0.052768331,
-0.0428547524,
0.0241108947,
0.0082194852,
0.0662492737,
-0.0182273965,
-0.0354323611,
-0.0007707948,
0.0618127398,
-0.0283344295,
-0.0300820693,
0.0552488267,
0.0038884548,
0.0748768151,
-0.036640048,
0.0405320041,
0.0292249341,
0.0295703467,
-0.0091036716,
-0.0037189743,
0.0344193876,
0.0222127941,
0.0490045212,
-0.046377413,
-0.0069188764,
-0.0253570601,
-0.0169986486,
-0.0045850724,
0.0089549208,
0.032155104,
0.0102401022,
-0.031927105,
0.0136816557,
-0.0176631343,
-0.0268943217,
-0.1027684435,
-0.0061856043,
0.0279100388,
-0.0366529115,
0.0168162994,
0.0163649265,
-0.067277357,
0.0862159729,
-0.0908888504,
0.0427051969,
2.018979276e-34,
0.0576462485,
-0.005006318,
-0.013700515,
0.0170135945,
0.0302620586,
0.0386083201,
-0.0219488628,
0.0063265143,
-0.0050731758,
-0.0586290471,
0.0304395668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09238v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09238v2 | BanglaNLP at BLP-2023 Task 2: Benchmarking different Transformer Models for Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Social Media Posts | 2023-10-13T16:46:38 | 2023-10-18T03:51:38 | Saumajit Saha, Albert Nanda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Bangla is the 7th most widely spoken language globally, with a staggering 234
million native speakers primarily hailing from India and Bangladesh. This
morphologically rich language boasts a rich literary tradition, encompassing
diverse dialects and language-specific challenges. Despite its linguistic
richness and history, Bangla remains categorized as a low-resource language
within the natural language processing (NLP) and speech community. This paper
presents our submission to Task 2 (Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Social Media
Posts) of the BLP Workshop. We experiment with various Transformer-based
architectures to solve this task. Our quantitative results show that transfer
learning really helps in better learning of the models in this low-resource
language scenario. This becomes evident when we further finetune a model which
has already been finetuned on twitter data for sentiment analysis task and that
finetuned model performs the best among all other models. We also perform a
detailed error analysis where we find some instances where ground truth labels
need to be relooked at. We obtain a micro-F1 of 67.02\% on the test set and our
performance in this shared task is ranked at 21 in the leaderboard. | [
0.0496101864,
0.0712705776,
0.0004649974,
0.0347656049,
-0.0499422364,
0.0075415396,
-0.0305915605,
-0.0475629829,
-0.0174411312,
-0.0261646286,
-0.0337088369,
-0.0282759517,
0.0026187464,
0.0470588468,
-0.0301054623,
-0.0603837036,
0.0156227173,
0.0277186744,
0.0253892094,
0.0043242374,
0.003012225,
0.0206426177,
0.0084751416,
-0.0093634203,
-0.0553404391,
0.0160789136,
0.0188197009,
0.0107015483,
-0.0027514412,
-0.0065463069,
0.0064439443,
0.0346648134,
-0.0317275971,
0.0128370728,
0.00000202,
-0.0138977161,
-0.0512694605,
0.0064450586,
0.0070064273,
-0.0429080091,
0.0949331373,
-0.0614345074,
-0.0244552474,
0.0252994709,
-0.0463877358,
-0.0307202823,
0.0851583257,
0.1007494479,
0.057236135,
0.1066745669,
-0.0402627364,
-0.0585496649,
0.0272897016,
0.0028060705,
-0.0129514178,
-0.0302849207,
0.0144529203,
-0.0362266079,
-0.0103849042,
0.0114717018,
-0.0391831137,
0.0260224584,
-0.0100887408,
-0.0185606871,
0.0017114072,
-0.0376299098,
-0.0300757326,
-0.0312752053,
0.0020210368,
0.0339396261,
-0.0252793413,
-0.0191876926,
-0.0035248955,
-0.0001675742,
0.0100060422,
-0.0131915091,
-0.0224698614,
0.0101589048,
0.0064872284,
0.0563437566,
0.0126958247,
0.0552363656,
0.007777215,
0.0078856433,
-0.018745305,
0.0414327197,
-0.0162500776,
-0.022943031,
-0.0031618951,
0.0736639276,
0.0051823366,
0.0376199074,
0.0228680223,
-0.0132702366,
-0.0090734148,
0.0271570049,
-0.0079800999,
-0.0179074574,
-0.037416555,
-0.0396907777,
0.0015801729,
0.0119884526,
-0.0159236696,
0.0311196223,
-0.0255579818,
0.0006169949,
-0.0098996619,
-0.0036834641,
0.0017564043,
-0.0613154583,
-0.0603176281,
0.0110207964,
-0.0115103312,
0.037895795,
-0.0219085757,
0.0091824401,
-0.0622379072,
0.0162147693,
-0.028424209,
-0.0332018286,
0.0338173881,
0.0148853427,
0.0053569186,
-0.016086027,
0.0093204957,
0.0826513693,
0.0113494536,
0.0140875326,
-0.0104221953,
-0.0983107463,
0.02924609,
0.038338989,
0.016179828,
-0.0352828875,
-0.0047330982,
0.0264845267,
0.0156826489,
-0.0388585962,
-0.0694955587,
0.043713592,
-0.0323443152,
-0.0515869446,
-0.0084468676,
-0.0638290644,
0.0595622957,
0.0145402793,
0.0114842793,
-0.002931596,
0.0034070876,
0.0078275036,
-0.0514736734,
0.0588302538,
-0.0011332451,
0.0120768193,
0.0046460438,
0.0138489464,
0.0173302703,
0.066168949,
0.0110465912,
0.051107388,
0.0515438393,
-0.0446035564,
-0.0071798242,
0.0127682034,
-0.0063938657,
-0.026133528,
-0.0185457934,
-0.0117540248,
-0.0505726412,
-0.0106203537,
-0.0066369111,
0.0595019832,
0.0351581722,
0.0144060208,
0.0578207634,
0.013901229,
0.0012443275,
0.0553704686,
-0.0144242356,
0.022277737,
-0.0128958952,
-0.0150125744,
-0.0262790862,
0.0318007171,
-0.0145325512,
-0.0465779379,
-0.0052887634,
0.0308695436,
-0.0268097352,
-0.0162220728,
0.0088123865,
-0.0495200306,
-0.0058771013,
-0.0272804983,
0.0640133545,
0.0371096991,
-0.0366212763,
0.0745205581,
0.0491421372,
-0.0683946386,
-0.0112995198,
-0.0351529047,
0.0136833889,
-0.0106295953,
-0.0246895198,
-0.0109064551,
-0.0082657551,
-0.0198252555,
0.0028033101,
0.0529194772,
0.0357548036,
-0.0008903581,
0.000199535,
-0.0288694147,
0.0403541997,
0.0390001461,
-0.001959793,
-0.011790582,
-0.0161390044,
0.0502631664,
-0.0098248869,
-0.0049033333,
-0.0368256979,
-0.0084721567,
0.0229056831,
-0.001265051,
0.0389941931,
0.0147581687,
0.0283072181,
-0.0038267386,
-0.0141426167,
-0.0300579909,
0.0079575777,
-0.0300314985,
-0.0515240543,
0.0351979136,
-0.0289057437,
-0.0336587243,
0.0076551787,
-0.0743461326,
0.0102065373,
0.0727132037,
-0.0495900251,
-0.0334599689,
0.054636687,
-0.0409407914,
0.0303202141,
0.0105861099,
0.0325792357,
-0.0543141477,
0.025946511,
0.0019751503,
0.0277371071,
0.004922688,
-0.0259974822,
-0.0421982557,
-0.027372472,
0.0349913165,
0.0059430227,
-0.0463609621,
0.0237235818,
-0.0096538784,
0.0170405079,
0.029812023,
-0.0012956965,
-0.0204155613,
-0.0595993996,
-0.0841121301,
-0.0260237474,
-0.0156367607,
0.0239334796,
0.0155354347,
0.0593636967,
0.0020690905,
0.0043168631,
-0.038161505,
0.0353202894,
0.0353545956,
0.0220819376,
0.0406365357,
-0.0275974777,
0.051581081,
-0.026226107,
-0.0190596506,
-0.001007689,
0.0355187804,
0.015216927,
-0.0338394828,
-0.0107781189,
-0.0104091745,
0.0192619786,
0.0030521112,
0.0027302548,
-0.0413422883,
-0.0221612193,
-0.0336953886,
0.0022383453,
0.0148753589,
0.0275286362,
0.0258400235,
-0.0346457176,
-0.0040648794,
-0.005856663,
0.0025908463,
-0.0427523218,
0.0038625444,
-0.0270547885,
-0.0292495154,
0.0048528458,
0.0703548715,
-0.014425505,
0.007954509,
-0.048834648,
-0.003083576,
-0.0399727225,
-0.0050264685,
0.004398651,
0.0540627576,
-0.0035462745,
0.034393426,
-0.0038472568,
-0.0182987191,
0.0341525823,
-0.0082447389,
0.0085395323,
-0.0692756474,
-0.0083248308,
-0.0357782431,
0.0197522547,
0.008686183,
0.0167306941,
-0.0033164404,
0.001964927,
-0.0133525301,
-0.0069111111,
-0.0102581279,
-0.0298097935,
0.0345863886,
0.0117628146,
0.0120002469,
-0.0111809513,
-0.0532256439,
0.0083967643,
-0.0686391219,
-0.0302027967,
0.0089548361,
0.0342939235,
-0.0428619832,
-0.0284568816,
0.0182928741,
-0.0165774617,
-0.0549803898,
-0.001243653,
-0.0286246128,
0.0288943201,
0.041187048,
0.0559026673,
0.0118604889,
0.0574554354,
0.0398166664,
-0.0309788566,
0.0300351828,
-0.0043849493,
0.0124181351,
-0.0468447953,
-0.0384970233,
0.044465661,
-0.0187431201,
-0.0079533765,
-0.0493543074,
0.0560342818,
0.0006541013,
-0.0127812782,
0.1070927531,
-0.000319295,
-0.0212975759,
0.0020795192,
-0.0219558459,
-0.0167571902,
-0.012677704,
0.040694315,
-0.0481735542,
-0.0230905749,
-0.0220928155,
0.0077111032,
0.0006769862,
-0.0227323007,
0.0077391495,
-0.1311313659,
0.0084856143,
-0.0309240445,
-0.0032670002,
-0.0485850759,
-0.0447840616,
-0.0005198144,
-0.0597141385,
0.0305796396,
-0.0556224361,
-0.0203938037,
-0.0153102139,
0.0381420366,
-0.0476197824,
-0.0586070307,
0.0228298306,
-0.0113786831,
0.0257650632,
-0.0008626218,
0.0319869071,
-0.0541743636,
-0.0310624801,
-0.0139565952,
0.00700795,
-0.0045252074,
-0.0045878789,
0.0591317043,
0.0022681989,
-0.0417030007,
-0.0125644822,
-0.0263366606,
-0.0704773664,
0.0130218938,
-0.029348366,
0.0878603384,
0.0319416784,
-0.0437994786,
-0.016374357,
0.0177221894,
0.0323889889,
0.043531917,
0.0138900951,
-0.072618112,
-0.04079156,
-0.0056326352,
-0.0216900706,
-0.0400408432,
-0.0555772409,
0.0104170647,
-0.0147096748,
-0.0639252141,
-0.0498052947,
-0.0400716662,
0.0016291222,
0.0548262037,
-0.021438865,
-0.0225867014,
0.0473097526,
-0.0166479032,
-0.0242876057,
0.0177281853,
-0.0209102947,
0.0235370733,
-0.0577847138,
0.0045193285,
0.0747167617,
0.0244500153,
-0.006735235,
-0.0407480858,
-0.0533469692,
-0.0241869427,
0.025478879,
0.0426971838,
0.0155190015,
-0.0118438378,
-0.0371008366,
-0.044373028,
0.020353809,
0.075292021,
-0.0457701534,
-0.0032053438,
0.0591487698,
0.0280384365,
-0.0003220801,
0.051328633,
-0.0025939278,
0.0396293998,
0.0212770049,
-0.025883859,
-0.0135999164,
-0.0144480523,
-0.0116322208,
0.0105754621,
0.073053278,
0.0318273641,
-0.0494142734,
-0.010468985,
-0.0194273796,
0.0312727019,
-0.0270617884,
-0.0342813358,
-0.0443232805,
0.0700023696,
0.0444135219,
-0.0436003506,
0.0069042379,
-0.0102677401,
0.0061499523,
-0.0360368043,
0.0872153342,
0.0555594377,
0.0196782928,
0.0143751586,
0.0362829939,
0.0045739934,
-0.0491151214,
0.0620265752,
0.0238443036,
-0.0206852816,
0.0183455255,
-0.0039885486,
0.0409831479,
0.0287983362,
0.0296896901,
-0.0018151482,
0.020142829,
0.0006618549,
-0.0371525139,
0.0119124642,
-0.0623751618,
0.0801674873,
0.0083068982,
0.0043870229,
-0.0240575168,
0.0338804312,
-0.0379254855,
0.0178101268,
0.0359750427,
-0.0270101372,
-0.017870849,
0.027780395,
0.0343876705,
-0.0537977368,
0.0131455427,
0.0577393472,
0.0103449989,
-0.0303406585,
-0.011422364,
0.0057023559,
-0.0271802023,
0.0363964848,
0.0492146462,
-0.0558368638,
-0.0536996275,
0.0466081686,
-0.1079152077,
0.0353807844,
-0.0079000983,
0.0151810395,
0.0399117842,
0.0485868976,
0.064775832,
-0.0630801544,
-0.0040636226,
0.005992875,
-0.0219102427,
0.0041463063,
-6.733111153e-33,
-0.0017994092,
0.0084020868,
-0.0475344956,
0.004345038,
-0.0097800996,
-0.0049218521,
-0.0142619014,
0.0095721623,
-0.0423160493,
0.030969223,
-0.0373286866,
0.0114023555,
0.0134975184,
0.0721551627,
0.0368496254,
0.0005202655,
0.0416435525,
0.044290144,
0.0069281622,
0.0378553942,
0.0411896184,
0.0464399345,
0.072808437,
-0.1044626758,
-0.012403057,
0.0081624668,
-0.0186228193,
0.0220745262,
0.0445166267,
0.0491838679,
0.0005208377,
0.0646529645,
0.0583479702,
-0.0499759279,
-0.0082106274,
0.0356876254,
-0.0596836247,
-0.0046261367,
0.0009089949,
0.0797059387,
0.0048863539,
-0.0060409801,
0.0353406891,
-0.0084296782,
-0.0150905782,
-0.0150053436,
0.0029671362,
0.004686872,
-0.0018256769,
-0.0164529346,
-0.0900259688,
0.0454876721,
0.0092841452,
0.0157133136,
0.0345237032,
0.0537660718,
0.001155306,
0.0103426734,
-0.063401103,
0.0016009562,
-0.0003264392,
0.0381938629,
0.0259169582,
-0.0145431766,
-0.0524512641,
0.0156930573,
0.0258784313,
-0.031787917,
0.0065684575,
0.0169954617,
0.0137929935,
0.0445694104,
0.0242538005,
0.0736895129,
0.0255619958,
-0.0572083816,
-0.0160937384,
-0.001237981,
0.0632416159,
0.0487536602,
0.0379183814,
0.0088158138,
-0.034774702,
-0.0432218909,
0.0381525792,
-0.0401886255,
-0.0300951954,
-0.0132150557,
0.003730051,
-0.0175943188,
-0.0153205339,
0.0461639352,
0.0228324402,
-0.0939660743,
-0.0066415472,
0.0159354024,
-0.042876143,
0.0489767641,
0.0005889147,
0.0182536226,
-0.0691301972,
-0.044807978,
-0.0225982796,
0.0587655827,
0.0067114551,
0.018039763,
0.0538780876,
0.0480696037,
-0.093736656,
-0.0126404557,
-0.0448171571,
0.0445594527,
-0.0315792263,
0.0892363638,
-0.0176704358,
0.0011145467,
-0.0379792117,
0.0335744545,
-0.001935208,
0.0505042337,
0.031834729,
0.0234895349,
0.0017483511,
-0.0363220833,
-0.0378973968,
-0.0414052866,
-0.0237796623,
0.0064486372,
0.0003809869,
-0.0499635302,
-0.0145555325,
-0.0053996895,
2.909e-7,
0.047036428,
0.0719586313,
-0.0019971158,
-0.05365403,
0.0185339469,
0.0410279073,
-0.0102849426,
0.0197937377,
-0.015000823,
0.0305552911,
-0.0058634481,
-0.0005713331,
0.0404781587,
0.0429486595,
-0.1135578826,
-0.0097930441,
-0.066770792,
-0.0214491691,
0.0103541268,
0.0255426299,
0.0364519469,
0.1073028967,
0.0139615135,
-0.051891055,
-0.0365429781,
-0.000406735,
0.0417964198,
-0.0427910686,
0.0036679571,
0.0303132944,
0.0199233983,
0.0298570301,
-0.0098459516,
-0.0354027972,
-0.0142161809,
0.0096436543,
0.0027864368,
0.0494799688,
-0.0010621226,
-0.0215930045,
0.0445224717,
0.015539797,
-0.0001697307,
-0.0365761332,
0.0527423136,
-0.0721326619,
-0.0903950855,
-0.0559551008,
-0.0223594792,
0.0408580452,
0.0138964113,
-0.0172124673,
-0.0204384606,
0.004452066,
0.0431395099,
-0.0352014527,
-0.0892532915,
-0.0618250407,
0.0490682907,
0.0291535314,
0.000789676,
-0.0116065703,
0.0019955593,
0.0181145947,
0.0351618715,
-0.0159562584,
0.0389808305,
2.238557029e-34,
0.0461125635,
0.0121288272,
0.0236819722,
-0.0121755768,
0.0034533555,
0.0105187232,
-0.0118804062,
-0.0097149359,
0.0159355458,
-0.061847575,
0.0136283822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09233v1 | AgentCF: Collaborative Learning with Autonomous Language Agents for Recommender Systems | 2023-10-13T16:37:14 | 2023-10-13T16:37:14 | Junjie Zhang, Yupeng Hou, Ruobing Xie, Wenqi Sun, Julian McAuley, Wayne Xin Zhao, Leyu Lin, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recently, there has been an emergence of employing LLM-powered agents as
believable human proxies, based on their remarkable decision-making capability.
However, existing studies mainly focus on simulating human dialogue. Human
non-verbal behaviors, such as item clicking in recommender systems, although
implicitly exhibiting user preferences and could enhance the modeling of users,
have not been deeply explored. The main reasons lie in the gap between language
modeling and behavior modeling, as well as the incomprehension of LLMs about
user-item relations.
To address this issue, we propose AgentCF for simulating user-item
interactions in recommender systems through agent-based collaborative
filtering. We creatively consider not only users but also items as agents, and
develop a collaborative learning approach that optimizes both kinds of agents
together. Specifically, at each time step, we first prompt the user and item
agents to interact autonomously. Then, based on the disparities between the
agents' decisions and real-world interaction records, user and item agents are
prompted to reflect on and adjust the misleading simulations collaboratively,
thereby modeling their two-sided relations. The optimized agents can also
propagate their preferences to other agents in subsequent interactions,
implicitly capturing the collaborative filtering idea. Overall, the optimized
agents exhibit diverse interaction behaviors within our framework, including
user-item, user-user, item-item, and collective interactions. The results show
that these agents can demonstrate personalized behaviors akin to those of
real-world individuals, sparking the development of next-generation user
behavior simulation. | [
0.0587284863,
-0.0021672011,
-0.0304180998,
0.0362649262,
-0.007523838,
0.0027287358,
0.0284196977,
-0.0035779241,
0.0775684491,
-0.0234737117,
-0.0362219214,
0.0078864098,
-0.0510990173,
0.0298339557,
-0.0083404928,
-0.0414061807,
-0.0056108045,
-0.027856702,
0.0053443243,
-0.033997234,
0.0117280241,
0.0251761712,
-0.0147225577,
0.0167962164,
0.0206844211,
0.0057934639,
-0.0348090529,
-0.0141191063,
-0.0025338356,
-0.020557249,
0.0096675744,
0.0149691189,
0.0336806104,
0.0011951809,
0.0000020804,
-0.0415030457,
0.0135615617,
-0.0433953367,
-0.0278398581,
-0.0238747708,
0.0568057895,
0.1064814478,
0.0120061254,
-0.0257064328,
-0.0683635697,
0.0340428613,
-0.0048415069,
0.0303355344,
0.0162989963,
0.0197930075,
-0.0059725135,
0.0456593409,
-0.0213034898,
-0.004166265,
0.0539943948,
-0.0147725604,
0.0093804393,
-0.0305130146,
0.0541678593,
0.0007054369,
-0.0022279478,
-0.0238812137,
0.0171172991,
-0.0137396716,
0.0454598069,
0.0279134214,
-0.0068395054,
-0.0527349189,
0.009113906,
0.0857604668,
0.0414301157,
-0.0092296964,
0.0033541305,
0.0109452987,
0.0036709551,
0.0632199496,
-0.015623711,
-0.0176190976,
-0.0311820209,
0.0183928628,
-0.0015388603,
0.0031997692,
0.0312927812,
0.0356811471,
0.0246918835,
0.1061541885,
-0.0104384348,
-0.0249692854,
0.023938993,
-0.021985719,
0.0436773784,
-0.0420654453,
0.0455946513,
0.0215906538,
-0.0756131411,
0.0067455964,
0.0011248186,
0.0816745684,
0.0218094401,
-0.0485593788,
0.0603660755,
0.0266616661,
-0.0020055566,
0.0473096706,
0.0070258277,
-0.0040284931,
-0.0012552051,
0.020681072,
-0.039562609,
0.0305774268,
-0.0226709694,
-0.0026511955,
0.0009215717,
0.0465381853,
-0.031763196,
-0.0247258898,
-0.0395994037,
0.0536427796,
-0.0352991298,
0.0464892983,
-0.0090363929,
0.0742350519,
-0.0123712746,
0.01710172,
-0.125236094,
-0.0314135887,
-0.050912708,
0.027340332,
0.0011086382,
0.0180114992,
0.0457952693,
0.0027723766,
-0.012107579,
-0.0362272486,
0.0144085698,
0.0593830086,
0.0002916324,
-0.0166674629,
-0.0070569431,
-0.0367179252,
0.0451677963,
-0.0467548855,
-0.033343453,
-0.0447639786,
0.0603991449,
0.0188351348,
0.0066131572,
-0.0558994189,
0.0087884543,
0.0041701733,
-0.0114362426,
0.1081355065,
0.006546679,
-0.0296939742,
0.0393922254,
0.0336482003,
-0.042707134,
-0.0127951875,
0.0222513583,
0.0720716342,
0.0452852398,
0.0174883809,
0.0269073937,
0.0080017019,
-0.0169299673,
0.0414212234,
-0.0430976674,
0.0152041968,
-0.0336379781,
0.0254903529,
0.0487672314,
0.0509056933,
-0.0729698464,
-0.0536602847,
0.0711409003,
0.0576514341,
-0.0124349063,
0.0460372828,
0.0639015064,
0.0496235266,
-0.001502182,
0.0309691075,
-0.0006410136,
0.0661473125,
0.00756376,
-0.0398612097,
-0.0099322079,
0.0048671123,
-0.0473860838,
-0.010797726,
0.0415388346,
-0.0436917022,
0.0810876936,
0.0031897044,
0.0072677271,
-0.0091065317,
-0.0173833538,
-0.0137029607,
0.0311912168,
-0.0257752761,
0.0145855052,
-0.0511303842,
0.0665553361,
0.131077379,
0.075071156,
-0.0234666076,
0.0063187266,
-0.0190388262,
-0.0211982448,
0.0138549749,
0.0328962654,
-0.0588116311,
-0.0319846161,
-0.0228618663,
-0.0368077308,
0.0314183049,
-0.0311525371,
0.02938696,
-0.0109840287,
-0.019465344,
-0.0029192395,
0.0175614022,
-0.0043213353,
0.0004679027,
-0.0529613793,
-0.0130236838,
0.0171800125,
0.0162258968,
0.0606234372,
0.0006009085,
0.0462506115,
-0.0356514007,
0.0197076779,
0.0206053723,
-0.0493543372,
0.0155628882,
0.0168535709,
-0.0009802958,
0.034186285,
-0.0172838811,
0.008525853,
0.0345427692,
0.0287783016,
-0.0090191085,
0.0104644904,
0.0116702886,
0.0261505004,
-0.05297672,
0.0094113117,
0.0288396217,
0.0137491887,
-0.0010888365,
0.0261515044,
0.0031585526,
-0.010353284,
0.029167125,
0.0167423952,
-0.0202926714,
-0.0515034646,
0.006891326,
-0.0015594934,
0.0446577966,
0.0351908244,
0.0292596109,
-0.0066813063,
-0.0456747301,
-0.0114886519,
-0.032600861,
-0.0184972938,
0.0156012122,
-0.0304606799,
-0.0200549718,
0.012508722,
-0.0192487985,
-0.0415062718,
-0.0303873587,
0.0381250344,
-0.0241994187,
0.0037859187,
0.0175073221,
0.0221911315,
-0.0342857465,
-0.0580732264,
0.0258526523,
-0.0241985656,
0.0111204889,
-0.0089012794,
0.0456813462,
-0.0624383017,
-0.0355924182,
-0.0486775786,
0.0056632073,
-0.0377243236,
0.0027609654,
0.0140384827,
-0.0258184541,
-0.0108738234,
0.0193546098,
0.0087688407,
0.0880938694,
0.0592456274,
-0.008654925,
-0.1187458932,
0.039296668,
-0.0292736553,
0.0318804346,
-0.0807613432,
-0.0230192468,
0.0127581051,
0.0192376971,
-0.0179298241,
0.0239537079,
-0.0257716235,
0.0207860824,
0.0267757624,
-0.0634800866,
-0.0152014242,
-0.0436365157,
-0.0484672338,
0.0570674315,
0.0309243668,
-0.017462017,
0.1020758972,
-0.0042922152,
-0.0032034735,
-0.0383559205,
-0.0402052626,
-0.0305697005,
0.0036502618,
0.0342005827,
0.0029123127,
-0.0250775386,
0.0212760679,
-0.0352272913,
-0.000721034,
0.0437450074,
-0.0170757081,
-0.0053050895,
-0.0230116639,
-0.0091536883,
0.0194676127,
-0.0177987553,
-0.0444787703,
-0.0656040534,
-0.0017353292,
-0.0397574604,
-0.0257398766,
-0.0138897961,
-0.0389004163,
-0.0187682938,
-0.0053314613,
0.0261858702,
0.0112834163,
-0.0479494967,
-0.0009458323,
0.0067492803,
0.053884469,
-0.0367771052,
-0.0529531054,
-0.0133969206,
0.0495178923,
0.0476355813,
0.033650253,
-0.0505789891,
-0.0450249277,
0.0155866593,
0.0445584282,
-0.0245082695,
0.0339137949,
0.0538012534,
-0.0388692059,
0.0111017823,
0.0136816716,
0.0843198895,
0.0550262854,
-0.1245431304,
0.0274659153,
-0.0244614352,
0.0114518376,
0.0216490943,
0.0630115271,
-0.0372345559,
-0.0026437347,
-0.0052842055,
0.0415282808,
-0.0097144507,
-0.0477340966,
0.0010925005,
-0.0582503043,
0.0408514664,
-0.0042897267,
0.0435438305,
0.0512686335,
-0.0793247968,
-0.0043635839,
-0.0244544707,
0.0156652927,
-0.0084143812,
0.0149724185,
-0.0019396869,
-0.0085272156,
0.0052563879,
-0.0042589856,
0.0527561009,
-0.025436921,
0.062288478,
0.0417787731,
0.0346250907,
-0.0083807716,
-0.0211647917,
-0.0398497507,
0.0405900478,
0.0101861265,
-0.0044627339,
0.0207529534,
-0.0064430675,
0.024810344,
-0.0354029834,
0.0267767031,
-0.0360808447,
-0.0396073945,
0.0134596303,
0.0605593473,
-0.0507290885,
-0.0162061676,
-0.0249527711,
0.0271803439,
0.0370311327,
0.0315414071,
0.005042938,
-0.0922178403,
0.0128426766,
-0.0511605702,
-0.0430372693,
0.008401541,
-0.0551573187,
-0.0049451366,
0.0041228267,
0.0146807665,
-0.0401384868,
-0.0701268464,
0.0089751771,
0.0004808939,
0.0076210042,
0.0255158618,
0.0144262183,
-0.0363042578,
0.0469569005,
0.0022841822,
-0.0048455643,
0.0410728119,
0.0023076418,
-0.02649609,
0.0363751389,
-0.0677499548,
0.0215951055,
-0.0147822266,
-0.0253364071,
-0.0366496295,
-0.0111082066,
0.0658260807,
0.0238881502,
0.0660727471,
-0.0224168655,
-0.0660542697,
0.0045777173,
0.0214503873,
-0.0604124628,
-0.0196758173,
-0.0152278682,
0.0345476419,
-0.0011696528,
0.0223481487,
-0.0264519043,
-0.0163855646,
-0.0544607826,
0.0039190566,
-0.096168071,
-0.0774267688,
0.0298560765,
-0.0186040904,
-0.0086509325,
-0.018991245,
0.0360138342,
-0.0007747813,
0.02761456,
0.0084444499,
-0.0163444914,
-0.0167079754,
-0.0316014327,
0.0329173952,
-0.0083342707,
0.0024058938,
-0.02450867,
-0.0309657622,
0.0241777916,
-0.002924114,
0.0441662744,
0.006692016,
0.0074930522,
0.0227673128,
0.0237733871,
0.008489293,
-0.0094929459,
0.0331651047,
0.0537934862,
0.01296556,
0.085929215,
-0.0179075301,
-0.0257871766,
-0.0127653694,
0.018090548,
-0.0267069247,
-0.0312584117,
0.0291857142,
0.0112884147,
-0.0233838912,
-0.0235818699,
0.0197148863,
-0.0788586065,
0.009767497,
-0.0074816379,
-0.001931175,
-0.0326347053,
-0.0188066438,
0.0208486449,
0.0485292301,
-0.0047629694,
0.0421925448,
0.0463221781,
0.0124536296,
0.0040011364,
-0.0236273129,
-0.0576941073,
-0.0508998111,
-0.0205491763,
-0.01086275,
0.046665661,
-0.070867382,
-0.0140263699,
-0.033922758,
-0.0521531887,
-0.009380132,
-0.0155049795,
0.0339215919,
-0.095415011,
0.0345749632,
0.0369891785,
-0.0101281051,
0.0372690037,
-0.0611748286,
-0.0095367022,
-0.0260096341,
-0.0245000143,
-0.0418077335,
-5.623765543e-33,
0.0145803485,
-0.0579985343,
0.0481415391,
0.0531570725,
0.0039846003,
-0.0507443137,
-0.0123147182,
0.0017056791,
0.0559133291,
0.0040011634,
-0.0230234489,
-0.0143117355,
0.0136525547,
-0.0371471196,
0.0143455379,
0.0133507326,
0.0333111584,
-0.0086721741,
-0.0183356162,
0.0021707551,
0.0050924788,
0.0202166755,
-0.0425360277,
-0.0799535662,
0.0335245468,
-0.0202349126,
-0.0270171128,
-0.0054632938,
-0.0108873993,
0.0675933287,
-0.0339602828,
0.0230603591,
-0.0062005054,
0.0068637026,
0.0180760622,
-0.0355734453,
-0.0720108449,
0.0042984514,
0.0253202952,
0.0160381924,
-0.0232361462,
0.0077444622,
-0.0153776137,
0.0149611868,
-0.0257435143,
0.03920535,
0.039999418,
-0.0283074044,
-0.0306023918,
0.0050257142,
-0.0275178533,
0.0126359314,
-0.0135869542,
-0.0200377721,
0.0359871536,
0.0534255803,
-0.0279783458,
0.0216868147,
-0.0726313218,
0.0366454422,
-0.0404084846,
-0.0177551657,
0.0267271977,
-0.0246327352,
-0.0253649373,
0.0746575445,
0.0521683618,
0.0021218853,
-0.0211604051,
0.00386415,
-0.0320070982,
0.0691332892,
-0.021628486,
0.0865929648,
-0.0150731346,
-0.0187697634,
0.0190143604,
0.0898707435,
0.0697566494,
-0.0017263771,
0.0475041978,
0.0473346375,
-0.0139394449,
-0.0149940439,
-0.0072336127,
0.0044310698,
-0.0408015959,
-0.086773172,
0.011800169,
0.0324372053,
-0.0168669876,
-0.0322268419,
-0.0067571616,
-0.0270595197,
-0.039776329,
-0.0423878171,
-0.0183143355,
-0.0092625199,
0.0148895653,
-0.0155594489,
-0.0497361571,
-0.0317403525,
-0.0278884321,
-0.0589236841,
-0.0222943053,
0.0338635519,
0.0116824638,
0.0384916104,
-0.0178402551,
-0.0082728798,
0.0045196805,
-0.0342371799,
0.0297293514,
0.0090219211,
0.0092924293,
0.0051094163,
-0.0482282005,
0.0313760974,
-0.0131432014,
-0.0184733216,
-0.0138054825,
-0.0388242491,
-0.013932921,
-0.0123724248,
-0.0282062404,
-0.0289255586,
-0.0631242841,
0.0280475914,
0.0489291102,
-0.0667965934,
-0.0043196967,
-0.0131945433,
2.757e-7,
-0.0290687401,
0.0349978097,
-0.0123261623,
0.0007510137,
0.0183073003,
0.0692892596,
-0.0314941332,
0.0492500588,
0.040964812,
-0.0196372699,
0.0483762026,
0.0368866622,
0.0017609025,
0.0486482494,
-0.0902742073,
0.0214326512,
-0.0072179171,
-0.0013584901,
-0.033866629,
-0.0422235988,
-0.0212122854,
0.0132198464,
0.0608368777,
-0.0100317178,
0.0121047162,
-0.0028888145,
0.0508748479,
-0.069625549,
-0.0503617339,
-0.0194652323,
0.0017947706,
-0.0279876329,
-0.0200562496,
0.0276685413,
-0.0161025412,
-0.0023165876,
-0.0160299297,
0.0267193187,
-0.0011331915,
-0.057781022,
0.0009767087,
-0.0203151256,
0.0363568999,
-0.0212755185,
0.0219067633,
0.0112284292,
-0.0108352778,
0.0370939225,
-0.0261387434,
0.0044965292,
0.0002759151,
-0.0611175373,
-0.0264411159,
-0.0034895006,
-0.0183842815,
0.0019846417,
-0.012229125,
-0.0398656204,
-0.0000751977,
-0.0491355248,
-0.0501130857,
-0.0499642082,
-0.0170894843,
0.0495079793,
-0.0155755728,
-0.0001918599,
0.0449585691,
2.029629898e-34,
0.011910772,
0.0861684158,
-0.020274356,
0.0156955142,
0.0389815047,
0.0178639218,
-0.0037603781,
0.0466767065,
0.0739155188,
-0.0173976682,
-0.0410081148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09223v1 | Automated Claim Matching with Large Language Models: Empowering Fact-Checkers in the Fight Against Misinformation | 2023-10-13T16:21:07 | 2023-10-13T16:21:07 | Eun Cheol Choi, Emilio Ferrara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | In today's digital era, the rapid spread of misinformation poses threats to
public well-being and societal trust. As online misinformation proliferates,
manual verification by fact checkers becomes increasingly challenging. We
introduce FACT-GPT (Fact-checking Augmentation with Claim matching
Task-oriented Generative Pre-trained Transformer), a framework designed to
automate the claim matching phase of fact-checking using Large Language Models
(LLMs). This framework identifies new social media content that either supports
or contradicts claims previously debunked by fact-checkers. Our approach
employs GPT-4 to generate a labeled dataset consisting of simulated social
media posts. This data set serves as a training ground for fine-tuning more
specialized LLMs. We evaluated FACT-GPT on an extensive dataset of social media
content related to public health. The results indicate that our fine-tuned LLMs
rival the performance of larger pre-trained LLMs in claim matching tasks,
aligning closely with human annotations. This study achieves three key
milestones: it provides an automated framework for enhanced fact-checking;
demonstrates the potential of LLMs to complement human expertise; offers public
resources, including datasets and models, to further research and applications
in the fact-checking domain. | [
0.0407727994,
0.0779606774,
0.0159845371,
0.0131301302,
-0.0425235853,
0.0107188504,
0.0047404803,
-0.0271115247,
0.0289191436,
-0.0539745726,
0.021074757,
-0.0170594379,
-0.0177596379,
0.0265526231,
0.0209574569,
-0.0136008598,
0.0392639488,
0.0458750911,
0.0610010177,
0.0026563115,
-0.0029336323,
0.0589395873,
-0.0344063565,
0.0382745042,
-0.0545881987,
-0.0002704734,
0.0585901737,
-0.0087251319,
0.0566380918,
-0.0541955084,
0.0252714772,
0.0571421832,
0.0324072577,
0.108653143,
0.000001612,
-0.0362379886,
0.0059300475,
0.0337811895,
-0.041771546,
0.0245269667,
0.0228864681,
-0.0239056759,
-0.0281424262,
0.034820199,
-0.0273870323,
-0.0384918749,
0.058924824,
0.0551727638,
0.0885886326,
0.1024560407,
-0.0212240051,
-0.0260030087,
0.029966563,
-0.0125413146,
-0.0182879865,
-0.0345979109,
0.0854152218,
0.0283452459,
-0.0288290512,
0.0184846874,
0.0436187387,
0.0289719924,
0.002284334,
-0.028087182,
-0.039176669,
0.0267818831,
-0.0346576013,
-0.022911584,
-0.0035611952,
0.042822212,
-0.0129325949,
-0.0657223761,
0.0189468283,
-0.0220100787,
-0.0122220367,
0.0580821522,
-0.0216163937,
0.0585138202,
-0.0306777339,
0.0217800476,
0.0100490768,
-0.0096665379,
0.0353663191,
0.0467137806,
0.027042849,
0.0439627282,
0.0046656653,
-0.0560666546,
0.0141126607,
0.0201527569,
-0.0140521973,
-0.0659499094,
0.0306931175,
-0.0060473653,
-0.0029673357,
0.0160489511,
-0.0306146462,
-0.0478370301,
0.0606247596,
-0.0681006014,
-0.0041305004,
-0.007339281,
-0.0493236221,
0.0647203773,
-0.0245194305,
-0.008473116,
-0.0223114379,
-0.0068713953,
0.0263131112,
-0.0199049488,
-0.0255416725,
0.0113961212,
-0.0341531858,
-0.0115910238,
-0.0243359264,
0.0352958031,
-0.0476432666,
-0.019610323,
-0.0217997152,
0.0112872226,
0.0159091875,
-0.0123589067,
-0.007066254,
-0.0313705169,
-0.054544162,
0.0531344898,
0.008387995,
0.0463658497,
-0.0053325691,
-0.0441611409,
-0.0127543882,
0.0226477273,
0.0198753234,
-0.0197514147,
-0.0063134618,
-0.0263503827,
0.0032694326,
0.0158118922,
-0.0359885432,
-0.0182612333,
-0.0126692001,
-0.05192836,
0.0034624331,
-0.0668018907,
0.0334633626,
-0.0224047583,
-0.0155158136,
-0.0281456895,
0.0019575069,
0.0437076762,
-0.027595656,
0.0284098014,
-0.0152765401,
0.0133815743,
0.0621453337,
0.0049944371,
0.0240514819,
0.0452923402,
0.0186942052,
0.0446537398,
0.0366661921,
0.0128160063,
0.0248051789,
0.0124878371,
0.0472922958,
0.0218817405,
0.0729272515,
-0.0025013173,
0.005554629,
0.005085201,
0.0010005848,
0.0587549172,
-0.0149566997,
-0.0301005989,
0.0886567533,
0.005456693,
-0.0187234189,
-0.0066358591,
0.0617056452,
0.0211311206,
0.0182729103,
-0.025374731,
-0.0453915708,
0.0180661865,
-0.056663692,
-0.0359426588,
0.0027471641,
0.0863384232,
-0.0029009487,
-0.0097995298,
-0.0125645883,
0.0101356888,
0.0140337674,
0.0013069502,
-0.0083298376,
0.0371441282,
-0.044613678,
0.0434410907,
0.036244303,
-0.0367377959,
-0.0400142223,
-0.0770457983,
0.01888071,
-0.0120551335,
0.0376453586,
0.005097474,
-0.0185383242,
-0.0502034314,
0.0502915308,
0.0559818521,
0.0774957761,
-0.0183268134,
-0.0333736613,
0.0074352385,
-0.0098329056,
-0.0108207082,
0.0290407371,
-0.0107635036,
0.0783072114,
0.0168285836,
0.0226680208,
-0.0074561355,
-0.0578320064,
0.0357404128,
0.0004582717,
0.0030940063,
0.0025145232,
0.0181830339,
0.0163450744,
0.0171283521,
0.0043787537,
-0.0091451611,
0.024090033,
0.0059714615,
-0.0374956392,
0.0176717043,
0.0298852231,
-0.0013754173,
0.0313233547,
-0.034390904,
-0.0680939779,
0.0469212383,
-0.0661875531,
0.0065823849,
-0.0123721091,
-0.0232588053,
-0.0074182414,
-0.041877903,
-0.0197669938,
-0.0049527022,
0.0090945726,
0.0167281386,
0.071345523,
-0.0114341378,
-0.0282276999,
-0.0367498845,
-0.0151561331,
0.0097411899,
-0.0240767729,
0.0011478589,
-0.0019289247,
0.0041077752,
0.0185424089,
0.0355115943,
-0.0473726615,
-0.0124018947,
0.0099549172,
-0.0643740371,
0.0150133669,
-0.0137416944,
0.0058675837,
0.0287800729,
-0.0173345096,
-0.0134000117,
0.0076508042,
-0.0217384286,
-0.0191950351,
0.0428400449,
0.0306008942,
0.0291508306,
-0.0243370645,
0.01029668,
-0.0298468284,
0.0245325882,
-0.0388742313,
0.0054467595,
0.0651724488,
-0.0472042561,
-0.0454217456,
-0.0038957193,
-0.0464149117,
0.0192569103,
-0.0032213829,
-0.0142482063,
0.0187860131,
0.0385093577,
0.0141448686,
0.0073121306,
0.0304312203,
0.0113542946,
0.0413002186,
0.0352219529,
-0.0137338825,
0.009526669,
-0.0412463136,
-0.0271657947,
-0.0046260841,
-0.0523905642,
0.0363035016,
0.063047193,
0.010766861,
-0.021433033,
-0.0252138805,
0.0458665639,
-0.0125830481,
-0.0005990589,
0.0441794246,
-0.0249330122,
-0.0019134037,
0.0234693289,
-0.041691374,
-0.0204581302,
0.0825062543,
-0.0217626896,
0.0473528914,
-0.0383491069,
-0.0222661253,
-0.0087278448,
-0.00275281,
0.0152301379,
0.025438264,
0.0185405351,
0.0275477562,
0.0295500383,
-0.0169152208,
0.0531045012,
-0.0132872155,
0.0212758146,
-0.0429466031,
0.0489985161,
0.0110949893,
-0.0397222973,
-0.0335894227,
-0.1034466773,
-0.0333303586,
-0.0227591917,
-0.0289555974,
-0.0250909347,
-0.1033486053,
-0.0203668065,
0.0372263268,
0.0626493916,
0.0220998246,
-0.0010630384,
0.0121818762,
0.0066919504,
0.0304834954,
0.0193146747,
0.0386837982,
0.0087563256,
-0.0325347893,
0.0575805306,
-0.032099586,
0.0125953667,
-0.0358521305,
-0.0645255148,
-0.0362624303,
-0.0485527329,
0.037755888,
-0.0271033812,
0.0430702977,
-0.0368991382,
0.0277678482,
0.0711975768,
-0.0017052836,
0.0193887018,
-0.000570928,
0.0296835583,
-0.0405229256,
0.021842692,
0.0131842354,
-0.1235354692,
0.0067311917,
-0.044123631,
-0.0287814979,
-0.0381016172,
-0.0292858481,
-0.0252606831,
-0.1009723917,
0.0525542349,
-0.00189722,
0.026583137,
-0.032422822,
-0.0628963411,
0.0126596242,
-0.0137292054,
0.0003467512,
-0.0118891336,
0.0261078607,
-0.0226558764,
-0.0049655885,
-0.0276663527,
-0.0609719157,
0.0434557833,
-0.0289813895,
0.0378036499,
0.0342970826,
0.0503661297,
-0.0071050236,
-0.0309542157,
0.0033632617,
0.0263224412,
-0.0598544367,
0.0235792585,
0.0575472936,
-0.0161709674,
0.0041721738,
-0.0256172419,
0.0301562529,
0.0195478126,
-0.0473012663,
-0.0101349121,
0.0838131085,
0.010343398,
-0.0555052571,
-0.0253569372,
0.0334428661,
0.0506707765,
0.0699831024,
-0.0028097113,
0.0388625786,
0.0017834161,
-0.027744798,
-0.0111249015,
-0.0452418178,
-0.0488777198,
0.0530449934,
-0.0047603641,
-0.0411971323,
-0.065638788,
0.032596875,
0.0082450723,
-0.017818246,
-0.0205212254,
-0.0465945341,
0.0623077676,
-0.0106211388,
-0.031407401,
0.0489043184,
-0.0497410633,
0.0569156744,
-0.0049573127,
-0.0361131169,
0.0455379561,
-0.0073082671,
-0.0083208997,
0.054499492,
-0.084401615,
-0.0617233403,
-0.0157392025,
-0.0146336546,
0.0167692937,
0.0455397777,
-0.0353188068,
-0.0237963758,
0.0266413502,
0.0687722415,
-0.0350703187,
0.0022631644,
-0.0103061739,
-0.0232455041,
0.0091447178,
-0.0081619024,
-0.006097876,
0.0413556919,
0.0035865309,
0.0024162212,
-0.0535673052,
-0.0291974656,
0.0551094301,
0.0310793929,
0.0641953871,
-0.0110694962,
0.0284331162,
-0.0532490388,
-0.0308865514,
-0.022423299,
-0.0350934193,
0.0036179614,
0.01155705,
0.0166331865,
-0.0148911187,
-0.0335392728,
0.00484885,
-0.0484510772,
0.0308726449,
-0.0633582696,
0.0015539222,
-0.0348193012,
0.0168930721,
0.0158754699,
-0.0271093026,
-0.0200683605,
-0.0011232144,
-0.0036172986,
0.0361998267,
-0.0005158557,
0.0136220269,
0.0113493316,
0.0113500729,
0.0200463943,
-0.0359374173,
-0.0459319688,
-0.0195946824,
-0.0671916455,
-0.0078678979,
0.0307828281,
-0.0158218928,
0.0508758053,
-0.026960751,
-0.0572530739,
0.0108905863,
-0.0148602398,
-0.0230973922,
-0.0133696161,
0.025699947,
-0.0035475213,
-0.0357632153,
0.0163902491,
0.0420745015,
0.0178313144,
0.0774823502,
0.0303988829,
-0.0574377067,
-0.0287684016,
-0.0753150955,
-0.0557297915,
-0.0088632368,
-0.0012161821,
-0.0209611226,
-0.056409549,
-0.0561699271,
0.014202645,
0.0099381413,
0.0124845942,
0.0237167887,
-0.0206003692,
0.0558692329,
0.0047531351,
-0.0290779173,
-0.034232907,
0.0228201244,
0.0061911847,
-0.0223516431,
-0.0162320938,
-6.197843923e-33,
-0.0036414098,
-0.0694390386,
0.0131646534,
-0.0090143923,
-0.0124821765,
0.0035004795,
-0.0244303904,
-0.0466078185,
-0.0209418628,
0.0710249394,
0.0285224412,
0.0355548598,
0.0019366009,
0.0057973606,
-0.0143742943,
0.0164999627,
0.0620842949,
0.0031587805,
-0.0384522416,
0.0286291819,
0.0192513559,
-0.0283659883,
0.0368380547,
-0.1003561988,
0.0346631669,
-0.007597236,
-0.0389544033,
0.0036864555,
-0.0253924001,
0.0406834707,
0.0032021613,
0.0414119773,
0.0348549262,
-0.0377480611,
0.0171739496,
0.0327214077,
-0.0625470057,
0.0198063944,
0.0378622077,
-0.0321413763,
-0.0067295767,
0.0039229356,
0.0313032083,
-0.0129246842,
-0.0176962391,
0.0111194365,
0.0145856626,
-0.0231022518,
0.0478576683,
-0.0374469049,
-0.0840062797,
0.0304315239,
0.006004272,
0.0034964874,
-0.0447660461,
0.0220311191,
0.0025639334,
0.0411112271,
-0.0812943652,
0.0322667472,
-0.0090425368,
-0.0201575607,
0.0255457535,
-0.0588069893,
-0.0340325758,
0.0439480804,
-0.0486862734,
0.0142822517,
-0.0651223361,
0.039457202,
-0.047577586,
0.0357812345,
0.0346015319,
0.1007512957,
0.0278850179,
-0.0473492593,
-0.0855674446,
0.0303185005,
0.023699794,
-0.0035676504,
0.0124007827,
-0.0329067446,
-0.0000065772,
0.0127824852,
-0.0272350796,
0.009483831,
-0.0315106921,
0.0151203312,
-0.0267471727,
0.0374798626,
-0.0195912253,
0.0748963207,
-0.0163342077,
-0.0446472429,
0.0213366579,
-0.0003320272,
-0.0191795677,
-0.0192765351,
-0.0033894556,
0.0327211581,
-0.0786530375,
0.0355018079,
0.0317377448,
0.0339636244,
0.0190302767,
0.0063156504,
0.0629169047,
-0.0057917018,
-0.0623286292,
0.0316679478,
-0.0248414315,
0.043442402,
-0.0129261762,
-0.0165636688,
0.0300911851,
0.0311326459,
0.0040358957,
-0.0041228705,
0.0087368255,
0.0106903547,
-0.015903024,
0.0029233473,
-0.0016147074,
0.0187384263,
-0.018098183,
-0.0011358543,
-0.0201301929,
0.0062135751,
0.0051606246,
-0.1003437266,
0.0207517669,
0.0093675079,
2.54e-7,
0.0433524214,
0.0705584213,
0.0025039022,
-0.0122197317,
0.0320743062,
0.0151125025,
0.0253475774,
0.0069209193,
0.0031476973,
-0.0699794516,
-0.0293965787,
0.0338390544,
0.0268302243,
0.0393321514,
-0.0187136047,
-0.0011719567,
-0.0703917518,
-0.0240402333,
-0.0690854862,
-0.0194194224,
0.0019287148,
0.03056743,
0.0253193621,
-0.0103759598,
-0.0175670385,
-0.0103334039,
0.080927901,
0.0381595194,
-0.0500067212,
0.0175711066,
0.0590661764,
0.0098487502,
0.0155001543,
0.0301031116,
-0.0518337414,
0.0036245426,
-0.0098046213,
0.0625664368,
0.0172676127,
0.0083051091,
-0.0392018557,
-0.0267771073,
0.0221955124,
-0.0476741493,
0.0387956947,
-0.0782679468,
-0.0368853509,
-0.0625847802,
-0.0477288067,
0.0301818773,
0.0047640381,
-0.024693897,
-0.0139779495,
0.0187728498,
-0.0015884929,
0.0438408554,
-0.0180252232,
-0.0461347252,
0.0050791758,
0.0185376797,
-0.0682032704,
-0.045614332,
0.0323713124,
-0.0254757088,
0.0347653478,
-0.0438936241,
0.059205994,
2.064203437e-34,
0.0286214612,
0.0082829427,
0.0048980587,
-0.0775673911,
0.0654848665,
0.0475704633,
-0.0259358305,
0.0147913434,
-0.0146902837,
-0.0250113197,
0.0090114567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09219v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09219v5 | "Kelly is a Warm Person, Joseph is a Role Model": Gender Biases in LLM-Generated Reference Letters | 2023-10-13T16:12:57 | 2023-12-01T19:21:20 | Yixin Wan, George Pu, Jiao Sun, Aparna Garimella, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as an effective tool to
assist individuals in writing various types of content, including professional
documents such as recommendation letters. Though bringing convenience, this
application also introduces unprecedented fairness concerns. Model-generated
reference letters might be directly used by users in professional scenarios. If
underlying biases exist in these model-constructed letters, using them without
scrutinization could lead to direct societal harms, such as sabotaging
application success rates for female applicants. In light of this pressing
issue, it is imminent and necessary to comprehensively study fairness issues
and associated harms in this real-world use case. In this paper, we critically
examine gender biases in LLM-generated reference letters. Drawing inspiration
from social science findings, we design evaluation methods to manifest biases
through 2 dimensions: (1) biases in language style and (2) biases in lexical
content. We further investigate the extent of bias propagation by analyzing the
hallucination bias of models, a term that we define to be bias exacerbation in
model-hallucinated contents. Through benchmarking evaluation on 2 popular LLMs-
ChatGPT and Alpaca, we reveal significant gender biases in LLM-generated
recommendation letters. Our findings not only warn against using LLMs for this
application without scrutinization, but also illuminate the importance of
thoroughly studying hidden biases and harms in LLM-generated professional
documents. | [
0.0737861618,
0.0499132462,
-0.0132574551,
0.0148924561,
-0.0258256234,
0.0120295342,
0.0438357405,
0.0176147055,
0.0137203736,
-0.0753025487,
-0.0048396369,
-0.024307346,
0.008187932,
-0.0224179402,
0.0157870073,
-0.0249234233,
0.020597741,
0.0281353611,
0.0487010777,
-0.0291894395,
0.0315611884,
0.0455097444,
0.0305962618,
0.062706925,
0.0220728423,
-0.0309684239,
0.0719083622,
0.0355179943,
-0.0179545972,
-0.0038339864,
0.0290954728,
0.0792048723,
-0.0385094993,
-0.0073086945,
0.0000020716,
-0.0689245015,
0.010784152,
0.0271754749,
-0.0199744068,
0.0082088495,
0.0977378339,
0.0381962135,
-0.0241212845,
0.0362175032,
-0.0193777904,
0.0019297301,
0.008762842,
0.0026023174,
0.0418297052,
0.0196119566,
-0.001661415,
0.0011297459,
-0.0327326916,
-0.0046368157,
0.0280769151,
0.0020543577,
0.0230787564,
-0.0373341106,
-0.0101676434,
0.00307789,
0.0150623722,
0.0138454717,
-0.0406562649,
-0.0216627549,
0.0569421314,
0.0029760387,
-0.0358973555,
-0.0327996612,
0.0092836395,
0.0324451104,
0.0485130437,
0.0057995128,
0.0065564928,
-0.0208166465,
0.064285554,
0.055494912,
-0.0270083416,
0.0518983863,
-0.0278231446,
-0.0263355207,
0.001828161,
-0.0143136643,
0.0187292602,
0.0498790964,
0.0366754271,
0.063971296,
0.0109452792,
-0.048895549,
0.0478411429,
0.011332972,
0.1104741096,
-0.0587979294,
0.0177030098,
-0.0163126849,
0.0356979221,
0.0097681936,
0.0045296866,
0.0266266204,
0.0831122324,
-0.1040985361,
0.0494531728,
0.0002452784,
0.0229111519,
-0.0029148117,
-0.0076629673,
0.0143223647,
-0.007964286,
0.0302760191,
-0.0155924736,
0.0245811772,
-0.0205769632,
-0.0350762121,
0.0038994378,
-0.0015570766,
-0.0127772223,
0.0649186298,
-0.0712253898,
-0.0184095763,
-0.0726885125,
0.019409731,
0.0132905394,
0.0300452299,
0.0162697341,
0.0047452254,
-0.0501980074,
-0.01231826,
-0.0385289788,
0.0134057021,
-0.0473730154,
-0.0965396315,
0.0393097587,
0.0061760154,
-0.0053953896,
-0.0164312758,
-0.0088972319,
0.0447968245,
0.0406498536,
-0.031037135,
-0.0120297009,
-0.0366182923,
-0.0140818246,
-0.0346591882,
0.0083295871,
-0.0659312457,
-0.0148580978,
0.0475747883,
0.0038172931,
-0.0603498854,
0.0030031542,
0.0308287274,
-0.0591936037,
0.0319265015,
0.0010304229,
0.012195305,
0.0528673083,
0.0337435864,
-0.0097136674,
0.046894867,
0.0339444205,
0.0178452078,
0.0340857059,
-0.005126778,
0.0581102744,
0.0377331413,
-0.0294867102,
0.0398910642,
-0.0236354992,
0.0351355709,
-0.0078080203,
0.0164810456,
0.0533472523,
0.0051099979,
-0.0153261553,
0.0261171013,
0.0726715028,
0.0472048558,
0.0393804237,
0.0516774431,
0.0017936853,
0.0235095657,
-0.0132753886,
0.0043913326,
-0.0643538907,
0.0084174722,
-0.0252783503,
-0.0258709155,
-0.0184802897,
0.0086105475,
-0.0190176684,
-0.0489732623,
-0.0196091644,
0.0098860674,
-0.0073721507,
0.0043319222,
-0.0170717351,
0.0334976055,
-0.0263267159,
0.0650666356,
0.0287067816,
-0.065501295,
-0.003546993,
-0.0254204329,
-0.0054889042,
0.1120285392,
0.0269406587,
0.0005237953,
0.0107712839,
-0.0543690063,
-0.0217699818,
0.0415929817,
0.0616661161,
0.0227024984,
-0.0254010502,
-0.0434718058,
-0.0255971588,
0.0262098797,
0.0190543849,
0.0051324037,
0.0203119311,
0.0442771018,
0.0299917124,
-0.0196774863,
-0.0875842273,
0.0165073983,
-0.0098390328,
-0.0434239581,
-0.0043276241,
0.0015605619,
-0.0008551134,
0.012323929,
-0.0301236715,
0.0247392338,
-0.0163921453,
-0.0199522767,
0.0045294408,
0.0137123307,
-0.0185417645,
0.0758014396,
-0.0106420321,
-0.0619392619,
-0.0537058339,
-0.0005837487,
0.0120364549,
0.035752248,
0.0298626777,
0.0138812307,
0.0173988566,
-0.0245508291,
-0.0028028046,
-0.0245006494,
0.0042373328,
-0.0344509706,
-0.0048140604,
-0.0270207077,
0.0001162229,
0.0073686023,
-0.0322811119,
-0.0393001437,
-0.0651621521,
-0.0152550004,
0.0273793489,
0.0181684475,
0.0090753883,
0.0076738908,
-0.0128663247,
-0.0324641652,
-0.0640330464,
-0.0447546728,
-0.0163817294,
0.0045714919,
-0.0128585445,
-0.0189272258,
-0.0028410347,
-0.0279994886,
0.007536944,
-0.0168753248,
-0.0661790669,
0.0018589505,
0.019563619,
0.0339460187,
-0.0249327924,
-0.0189117268,
-0.0493177325,
-0.0376876779,
-0.0364275314,
0.0337342881,
0.064154841,
0.0297225006,
-0.0762772188,
0.0086345607,
-0.0190864522,
-0.0527083203,
0.0039400482,
-0.0077501913,
0.0182192829,
0.0247193165,
0.0150041459,
0.035923887,
0.0362394042,
0.0089635281,
0.0793845728,
0.0148055525,
-0.0345685743,
-0.0337497666,
0.0492908955,
0.0297936238,
0.017510809,
-0.1040757,
-0.006587733,
-0.0311129726,
-0.008287048,
-0.0073025133,
-0.0103585776,
0.0937354192,
-0.031279318,
-0.051332172,
-0.008995763,
-0.0546326675,
-0.0184952784,
0.0251172278,
-0.0006269375,
-0.0636163056,
-0.0247739255,
-0.0096817454,
0.017770743,
-0.0018133861,
-0.0080342926,
-0.0193730909,
0.0315356739,
-0.048579637,
0.0246012844,
0.0069221319,
0.0032032602,
-0.0485046804,
-0.0590800866,
0.0431129672,
-0.0504454933,
0.0132596707,
-0.0179713201,
0.0077088266,
0.0021781728,
-0.0088531375,
-0.0386249684,
-0.0626575425,
-0.022790933,
-0.0060030851,
-0.0165146124,
0.0364916362,
-0.0263497699,
0.012216744,
-0.0086005395,
0.003545244,
-0.0224330574,
-0.0107522206,
0.0031273859,
-0.0333522074,
0.0062020738,
-0.0316099375,
0.0396866538,
-0.0395236351,
-0.0266322754,
0.007084901,
-0.0231529437,
0.0294812843,
0.0012467181,
-0.0033343912,
0.0429605506,
-0.0649622828,
-0.0444479845,
-0.00284003,
-0.0009784965,
-0.0425967686,
0.0219836272,
0.0947677717,
-0.0012762249,
-0.0953326747,
-0.008011248,
-0.0333858468,
0.0401653536,
0.0278410576,
0.0162791852,
-0.0726964548,
0.02908534,
0.0262426417,
0.0255482662,
-0.0676632226,
-0.0344169401,
-0.0274033379,
-0.0999337211,
0.0520072915,
0.0249273442,
0.0188945625,
-0.0163547657,
-0.0054206778,
-0.0235519372,
0.0175498053,
-0.0027303337,
-0.0001448633,
-0.0391775928,
0.0175296832,
-0.0102050919,
-0.0838324055,
-0.0004765362,
0.0180049669,
-0.077760689,
0.0343058072,
0.0462455899,
0.0485773832,
-0.016838897,
-0.0156507399,
0.0205412935,
0.008134217,
-0.0013327536,
0.007951648,
0.0058909613,
-0.0413713977,
0.0121588046,
-0.0549274646,
-0.0014569239,
-0.011241491,
0.0237971209,
0.0317064598,
0.0195249896,
0.012800796,
-0.0411181822,
-0.071284987,
0.02770916,
0.0242476482,
0.0646016002,
0.0133548183,
-0.0535686053,
-0.0207923092,
-0.0436057672,
0.0416708551,
0.0584419183,
-0.0702122077,
0.0078266645,
-0.0153969266,
0.0104318801,
-0.0198952239,
-0.0677881166,
-0.0211995784,
0.0002328493,
0.0210411921,
-0.0281999968,
-0.0018504079,
-0.0067627681,
-0.0005931826,
0.0121418685,
-0.0319629312,
0.0359117761,
0.0019355295,
-0.0101450337,
-0.028331887,
-0.0087244567,
0.0069753495,
0.0170773454,
0.0190434027,
-0.0148271397,
0.0471021384,
0.0381214805,
0.0343810357,
0.0197004154,
0.0137328329,
-0.0600321218,
0.0216006842,
0.0476313643,
0.0103101097,
0.051262483,
0.0192711968,
-0.0048688473,
0.0144587914,
0.0139805162,
-0.0393064953,
0.0185470376,
0.0121567752,
-0.0304069798,
0.0022462271,
-0.0516379364,
0.0043400112,
0.0151466383,
-0.0356063209,
-0.0254217889,
0.0394388512,
-0.0291270465,
-0.0044678585,
-0.0372186862,
-0.0374603234,
-0.0116833355,
-0.0399822146,
0.0255379453,
0.0389652289,
-0.016634237,
-0.030718632,
-0.0822191834,
0.0305374917,
-0.0214218907,
0.0658447593,
0.0110693248,
0.0443811826,
0.0013719852,
-0.0326903984,
-0.0035007985,
0.0050905352,
-0.0255175252,
0.0305614956,
0.0233661644,
0.0184718091,
-0.0045612128,
0.029944364,
-0.0387356877,
0.0291313212,
-0.0293933842,
-0.061271172,
0.0044590035,
0.0119979726,
-0.0121213049,
-0.0423457809,
0.0419151895,
-0.0140278945,
0.0158328526,
0.0020637123,
-0.0047654989,
0.0133703453,
-0.0062200865,
0.0295162313,
0.0173677914,
-0.0121737616,
-0.0246850736,
0.0158224627,
0.0522227436,
0.035505794,
-0.0494224019,
-0.0413070321,
-0.0147628058,
-0.0578965433,
0.0080451174,
-0.002712575,
0.0007043498,
-0.0468166284,
-0.1323536783,
-0.0366589502,
0.0277650319,
-0.0479393303,
0.039717298,
-0.0471360683,
-0.006662284,
0.0588640608,
-0.0036625632,
-0.0518898517,
-0.0270434748,
-0.0061940714,
0.0053212037,
-0.0083040157,
-0.0165941175,
-6.108153337e-33,
-0.0034383668,
-0.0455166101,
-0.013214807,
-0.0240188967,
-0.0143774981,
0.0072448906,
0.0342993289,
0.00366482,
0.0076211169,
0.0138904154,
-0.0591663048,
0.0126131484,
0.0107856598,
-0.01457188,
0.0429812931,
0.0099454662,
0.0549854077,
0.0088212378,
-0.0154852504,
-0.0315063335,
-0.0360851027,
0.0111168688,
0.0232520476,
-0.090858154,
0.1263653338,
-0.055558458,
-0.02289051,
-0.0219149664,
-0.0106652286,
0.0242433082,
0.0148719009,
0.0516877212,
0.0116715217,
-0.0054808538,
0.0114630191,
0.0633319095,
-0.0241561793,
-0.0160308518,
0.0338837914,
0.0156310592,
0.0503829382,
-0.0442398377,
0.0560168214,
0.0352872312,
-0.0792472288,
-0.0164466742,
0.0685359389,
-0.0039447141,
0.0241681449,
0.0328817442,
-0.0445302688,
0.0166802201,
-0.0390817448,
0.0600500554,
-0.0120695764,
0.0252641011,
-0.0118111623,
0.0430924185,
-0.0668148175,
0.024977399,
-0.0187265482,
-0.0120931007,
0.032525029,
-0.0025029746,
-0.0045334375,
0.0510606728,
0.0548068695,
0.0760801435,
-0.0115405144,
-0.0845912173,
0.0108473739,
0.010863346,
0.0078451019,
0.0713581517,
0.0467702337,
-0.0200315118,
-0.0012212646,
-0.029593192,
0.0279014017,
0.0162649788,
0.0339486599,
-0.0332518891,
-0.0658066124,
-0.0644655451,
-0.0200484376,
-0.054804761,
-0.0148880119,
-0.0238544997,
0.0291150343,
-0.0225624498,
0.001570956,
-0.000550654,
-0.0519653857,
-0.0497541502,
-0.0382888801,
-0.0086155664,
-0.0200373214,
-0.0248631686,
0.0143637136,
-0.0226184316,
-0.0575948358,
0.0172000881,
-0.0380051136,
0.023300061,
0.0207790677,
0.0439133532,
-0.0072388533,
-0.0267969407,
-0.0935772583,
-0.0317084603,
0.0021166301,
0.0173423868,
0.0394427143,
-0.0079897493,
0.0316034257,
-0.0070031281,
0.0117037697,
0.0194166023,
0.0521797389,
0.0401649065,
-0.0158220027,
-0.0394632071,
-0.0238055773,
0.0143798543,
-0.0196536109,
-0.0095743323,
-0.0168074928,
0.0178224035,
0.0884617418,
-0.0483926646,
-0.0085148709,
-0.0635524094,
2.739e-7,
0.0247248951,
0.0634267107,
-0.0183769763,
0.0211040881,
0.0060302899,
0.0273125898,
0.0360719785,
0.0556199737,
0.0621466227,
0.0303919148,
-0.0099118147,
0.0074735279,
-0.0104228025,
0.0188783351,
-0.0910883769,
0.0101532778,
-0.0774528459,
0.0148051716,
-0.0184797104,
0.0071167909,
0.0028187043,
0.0102278953,
0.0419775136,
-0.0200398676,
-0.0630562305,
-0.0178152844,
0.0400797911,
-0.0543849766,
0.0232685693,
0.0300830137,
0.0653086156,
-0.0256603584,
0.0155798718,
0.0476366132,
0.0144521082,
-0.0022193862,
0.0201934893,
0.0532132499,
-0.0033633765,
0.0359932631,
0.0333894305,
-0.0183381103,
-0.006399869,
-0.0481041484,
0.0383024327,
0.0617317595,
-0.0095870076,
-0.0607201084,
-0.0694920495,
-0.0162021257,
0.0839871094,
0.0046430123,
-0.0376880839,
0.0360241495,
0.0037466171,
-0.0292495228,
-0.0116299177,
-0.0359219834,
-0.0042803618,
-0.0516823567,
0.0238467976,
-0.0621350557,
-0.0057613649,
0.0469429903,
0.0064549171,
-0.0470673852,
0.0371831171,
2.396031487e-34,
0.0085623022,
0.0284051765,
0.0391405337,
0.0256314408,
0.0334958993,
0.0440213643,
0.0336625688,
0.0215586852,
0.0273043737,
0.0020056849,
0.0226405095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09168v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09168v3 | Explore-Instruct: Enhancing Domain-Specific Instruction Coverage through Active Exploration | 2023-10-13T15:03:15 | 2023-10-24T06:55:17 | Fanqi Wan, Xinting Huang, Tao Yang, Xiaojun Quan, Wei Bi, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuning can be substantially optimized through enhanced diversity,
resulting in models capable of handling a broader spectrum of tasks. However,
existing data employed for such tuning often exhibit an inadequate coverage of
individual domains, limiting the scope for nuanced comprehension and
interactions within these areas. To address this deficiency, we propose
Explore-Instruct, a novel approach to enhance the data coverage to be used in
domain-specific instruction-tuning through active exploration via Large
Language Models (LLMs). Built upon representative domain use cases,
Explore-Instruct explores a multitude of variations or possibilities by
implementing a search algorithm to obtain diversified and domain-focused
instruction-tuning data. Our data-centric analysis validates the effectiveness
of this proposed approach in improving domain-specific instruction coverage.
Moreover, our model's performance demonstrates considerable advancements over
multiple baselines, including those utilizing domain-specific data enhancement.
Our findings offer a promising opportunity to improve instruction coverage,
especially in domain-specific contexts, thereby advancing the development of
adaptable language models. Our code, model weights, and data are public at
\url{https://github.com/fanqiwan/Explore-Instruct}. | [
0.0383003317,
0.0314313769,
-0.0444807298,
0.0221946295,
-0.0074665188,
0.0209609363,
0.0021307431,
-0.0222162046,
-0.0152715463,
-0.0295500532,
-0.0281124469,
-0.0453335717,
-0.0046519069,
0.0244667158,
0.00907024,
-0.0430503488,
0.0680626854,
-0.0449141115,
-0.0573171079,
0.0173230059,
-0.0376161821,
0.0147691742,
-0.0250074584,
0.0583031215,
0.0441365726,
-0.0306245722,
-0.0360293537,
0.0366153866,
-0.0027838692,
-0.014572327,
0.0441581756,
0.0428526402,
0.0791024342,
-0.0079028299,
0.0000023547,
-0.0278208964,
-0.0165910535,
-0.0190080814,
0.0002248237,
0.0451009832,
0.0494163036,
0.0364307761,
0.0035045422,
0.0281247403,
-0.0111047607,
-0.0057600918,
0.0306332577,
-0.0280721616,
0.030127028,
0.0471901745,
0.0236267373,
0.0052550114,
-0.0448564067,
-0.0130430339,
0.0393762589,
-0.0481349528,
0.0041367207,
0.0156528614,
0.060037639,
0.013175793,
-0.0485675894,
0.0227048751,
0.0308624767,
-0.0065047829,
0.0017990951,
0.0076892227,
0.0262634605,
-0.0182742793,
-0.0235679541,
0.0349860899,
-0.0097815963,
0.0156865139,
-0.0059216004,
-0.0208682586,
-0.0034432677,
0.0314227715,
-0.0286186244,
0.0144431312,
-0.0028582208,
-0.03337235,
0.0207096525,
-0.0321919322,
0.0131505951,
0.0212721899,
-0.0118490281,
0.0475077443,
0.0225769691,
-0.0365066156,
0.0088991849,
0.0130418558,
-0.0258098766,
-0.0117975604,
0.0043029259,
0.0396229699,
-0.0650403202,
0.0393340513,
-0.0239908285,
-0.0174391996,
0.0164141413,
0.0204788111,
0.0888454691,
0.0593987145,
-0.019945167,
0.0229971074,
0.0161357187,
0.0215375796,
0.0037795724,
-0.0371691808,
-0.0402765572,
0.015474597,
-0.0691217333,
0.0023395179,
-0.0467393622,
0.0153814359,
-0.0575134791,
-0.0024695212,
-0.0201712362,
0.0667097643,
0.0120523684,
-0.0335542485,
0.0237642825,
-0.0088397162,
-0.0626104921,
0.0229954068,
-0.0093243206,
0.0045000305,
-0.0575024225,
0.0202500354,
0.0152500803,
-0.0394181311,
0.0056008734,
-0.0133266635,
-0.0375913605,
-0.0505482294,
0.018179452,
0.0747979283,
0.001563727,
-0.0349030048,
-0.0326783434,
-0.018008193,
0.0057135746,
-0.0322699174,
0.0206548143,
-0.0614634119,
0.0005347477,
0.0148557751,
0.0153770205,
-0.0183282141,
-0.0181896053,
0.0349497274,
-0.0004924971,
0.0327640101,
0.0343460776,
0.0395829454,
0.047381375,
0.0186759252,
0.0085368082,
0.0946061835,
-0.0187503938,
0.0021884611,
0.0255302694,
-0.0177524332,
-0.0021083525,
0.0386409946,
-0.0063016061,
0.0203152709,
0.0441132486,
0.0070688035,
0.0166498013,
-0.0047522807,
0.0079637468,
-0.0140124205,
-0.0083200466,
0.0305645429,
0.0163041949,
0.0253467485,
0.0096502397,
-0.0230976548,
0.0859342068,
0.0255000219,
0.0026366704,
-0.0302037876,
-0.0544259176,
0.0100095151,
0.0038205176,
-0.00015171,
-0.023979459,
0.0395138934,
-0.0197015274,
-0.0358954556,
0.0010494431,
0.0147190075,
0.0087998109,
0.041198615,
0.0554136224,
-0.0088351173,
-0.0451175645,
0.0369984396,
0.0486742854,
-0.0394994542,
0.0146426829,
-0.0546103232,
-0.012090832,
0.0627827495,
0.0565504022,
-0.0524218008,
-0.0719189867,
0.0203956235,
0.0818602517,
0.0258061253,
0.0350956246,
-0.0141139477,
0.0178209078,
-0.0557923056,
-0.0655387715,
-0.0397302397,
0.0244036224,
0.0309668723,
0.0428134762,
-0.0340553597,
0.0063052955,
-0.0603245161,
-0.0724283904,
0.0367261805,
-0.0589381345,
-0.0113393525,
-0.0098822014,
0.0277094934,
0.0006445667,
0.0100637088,
-0.0066618966,
-0.0157404635,
0.0195554979,
-0.0094736814,
0.0132664526,
-0.0327613391,
-0.03945769,
0.0081915073,
0.0071950811,
-0.0382360481,
-0.0293874945,
0.0079546599,
-0.0282744281,
-0.0224180445,
0.017280532,
-0.0468635522,
0.007171615,
0.0092753191,
0.0561625846,
-0.050363753,
-0.0455332994,
-0.050808005,
0.043718528,
-0.0094860895,
-0.0154669695,
0.0423430838,
0.0143288868,
-0.0010340051,
-0.0031418328,
-0.0238360912,
-0.0288375318,
-0.0413015522,
0.0117296595,
0.0195105411,
0.034950491,
-0.0403019004,
-0.0238491017,
-0.0824695453,
0.0323414691,
-0.0176746808,
0.0251297951,
0.0536813699,
0.0567377098,
0.0006823233,
0.007005929,
0.0323996097,
-0.0291359965,
-0.0086137708,
0.0269177053,
-0.016418511,
0.0269367173,
-0.0520752296,
-0.0395657532,
-0.0162167735,
-0.0386429057,
-0.0094686206,
-0.0257222261,
0.0358948708,
-0.0625286102,
0.0559300631,
0.0143371699,
0.0186144896,
-0.0173888635,
-0.0425770469,
0.0071058548,
-0.0015224766,
0.0186860096,
0.0851718336,
-0.01793986,
0.0471131392,
0.0589909703,
-0.0368640311,
-0.0622377694,
0.0379486643,
-0.0129262768,
-0.0497989096,
-0.048183091,
-0.0522577614,
0.0198339783,
0.0953882858,
-0.0097507648,
-0.0058844448,
-0.0651319996,
-0.0530036837,
-0.0621519461,
-0.0181956608,
-0.0256360583,
0.0158470105,
-0.0081030605,
-0.0009591174,
-0.0309469588,
-0.058373332,
0.0894147679,
0.0131590888,
-0.0019182304,
-0.0861951634,
-0.0122165699,
-0.0345406383,
0.0255749319,
-0.0155065088,
0.0080983834,
-0.0043196771,
-0.0319312438,
-0.0805431381,
0.0335269086,
0.031811405,
-0.0140795503,
0.0895743072,
-0.0884188935,
-0.0259952825,
0.0117705567,
-0.0229471643,
-0.032364063,
0.0053802668,
0.022561539,
0.0009067247,
0.0532966554,
-0.0290328469,
-0.0706851333,
-0.0321709551,
0.0230644103,
0.0312156957,
-0.0105594117,
-0.0120102465,
-0.0293231793,
-0.0774122104,
0.0439723842,
-0.0242480841,
-0.0321415775,
-0.0681092888,
0.0111124087,
0.0085925106,
0.00941147,
-0.047160916,
0.0226640534,
0.033532992,
0.0490067601,
-0.0492087454,
-0.0124480287,
0.0692950115,
0.0823834687,
-0.0657588318,
-0.0311268698,
0.1004390568,
0.0447882451,
-0.0580620505,
0.0052274964,
-0.0369805731,
0.01947462,
0.0517712161,
0.0621770956,
-0.0601512976,
-0.0175220668,
-0.0159915909,
0.0506619327,
0.0059256558,
0.0094043249,
0.0025191505,
-0.1123739704,
0.0082350867,
-0.0029863652,
-0.0277776886,
-0.0245664176,
-0.0376197435,
0.0172185581,
0.0110274795,
0.0350791141,
0.0109587507,
-0.0397012532,
0.0027872932,
0.0308404528,
0.018313935,
-0.0955375656,
0.0521008931,
-0.016872216,
0.0321421884,
0.0776992962,
-0.0044973795,
0.0067346296,
0.0118231662,
0.0190326795,
0.0081946598,
0.0331418961,
-0.0346372388,
0.0470490567,
-0.0057485667,
0.0073119435,
0.0137006659,
0.0331783444,
-0.0278864205,
-0.0153926378,
0.0638746768,
0.0786217675,
-0.0214143787,
0.0296924673,
-0.0445008539,
-0.0310364496,
0.0394628607,
0.0591738522,
0.0302230492,
-0.0732259974,
0.0065339264,
-0.0333035588,
-0.0447103567,
-0.0777083188,
-0.0203907862,
0.0181298275,
-0.0560013801,
0.002804372,
-0.0125133842,
-0.0188845806,
0.0733149648,
0.0276760515,
0.0407155342,
0.0049801301,
0.0038735026,
0.0077336086,
-0.0558164753,
0.0396945663,
-0.0293747727,
0.0476019606,
-0.0998962149,
-0.0617480502,
-0.0209690798,
-0.0245001335,
-0.0029899208,
0.0206420235,
-0.0474986508,
-0.0664015338,
0.0175055601,
0.0425157994,
0.0140370224,
0.0385086276,
-0.0023093102,
-0.0532914884,
0.0085218279,
-0.0077542895,
-0.0147348195,
0.0087616583,
0.0303418711,
-0.0551427603,
-0.0137178302,
0.0033893918,
-0.0618689172,
0.0184798148,
0.0436307974,
0.0412797481,
0.0249407291,
0.0073292591,
0.0092270961,
-0.0279431529,
0.0249813348,
-0.0053486596,
-0.0222678892,
-0.0385276712,
0.0244689435,
-0.0099333804,
-0.0022394818,
-0.027087545,
0.0113560641,
0.0034923677,
-0.0077922838,
0.027705403,
0.0211751983,
-0.0080369757,
0.0379222818,
-0.0741079673,
0.0782618299,
-0.0269520395,
0.0273587629,
0.0479023978,
0.0276087616,
0.0024773111,
-0.0142951878,
-0.0027320459,
0.04175115,
0.0191172697,
0.073128067,
-0.0047667064,
0.0208347533,
-0.0138589824,
0.0263188276,
-0.0242004078,
-0.0402558558,
-0.0237604752,
-0.0171707757,
0.0377743617,
-0.0271979775,
0.0108588487,
-0.0171787832,
0.008731843,
-0.0071065906,
0.0039158328,
0.0106760655,
-0.018125033,
0.0024662316,
0.0461317711,
0.0236348659,
-0.042611558,
0.0681164265,
0.0213975925,
0.0876750425,
-0.0208855085,
-0.0127437813,
-0.0245390534,
-0.0010446643,
0.0643183142,
0.0350541212,
-0.0520139858,
0.0183773283,
-0.0352613255,
-0.0639455616,
-0.0417300053,
-0.0054249144,
-0.0158213656,
-0.0077403821,
0.0521327183,
0.0641992688,
-0.022714287,
-0.0243706238,
-0.0455458835,
0.0150346737,
-0.017692402,
-0.0129333436,
-0.0143074654,
-6.235161461e-33,
-0.0341301486,
0.0056836242,
0.0337645113,
-0.0260814168,
0.0072529046,
0.0165764578,
-0.0347139426,
0.0088138115,
-0.0253097583,
-0.0075331801,
0.0109447306,
0.0296995807,
0.005450435,
0.0177739989,
0.0489903167,
0.037348032,
0.0454941317,
0.0258582924,
-0.0428990833,
0.0362206809,
-0.0029083104,
0.0128739048,
0.0644424558,
-0.0525818802,
-0.0077925306,
0.0170968436,
0.0204559676,
0.0188235287,
-0.018012559,
0.0612532534,
0.033697512,
0.035895329,
0.0071932874,
-0.0405738279,
-0.0377199687,
-0.0131616602,
-0.036299821,
-0.0450971611,
0.0537297279,
0.01020688,
0.0009300606,
-0.0540851243,
-0.0070860898,
0.0097957309,
-0.0311818849,
-0.0237603392,
0.0410231724,
-0.00517081,
0.0070172329,
0.0094057471,
-0.0899836868,
0.0018604022,
-0.0081949597,
-0.0413423888,
-0.0133671239,
0.0505836681,
-0.0001471982,
-0.006073107,
0.0154313231,
0.0596270375,
0.0446032174,
0.0775957778,
0.098820895,
0.0501984209,
0.0052051246,
0.0195405725,
-0.019743029,
0.0598540157,
0.0166060012,
-0.0127262073,
0.0231573377,
0.0387825854,
-0.0337806977,
0.005842227,
-0.0065357331,
0.0085608,
-0.0279782228,
0.0226502288,
0.0252452772,
0.0373346582,
0.0283481292,
0.0067159785,
-0.0588372797,
-0.0024213367,
-0.0343090147,
0.0658321008,
-0.0200497136,
-0.0522931851,
0.0625228807,
-0.0006037412,
-0.0493998155,
-0.0219161604,
0.034928266,
-0.0347653106,
-0.0071173902,
0.0124815647,
-0.0184063315,
0.0215213709,
-0.002908102,
0.0199627001,
-0.0261195805,
-0.1014536619,
0.0046604434,
-0.0283485614,
0.0305545032,
0.0010579405,
-0.0234396085,
0.0328159556,
-0.0418313518,
-0.0136557072,
-0.0524929129,
-0.0056452737,
-0.0013246366,
0.0408541225,
0.0274284128,
0.0168044455,
-0.0269744452,
0.0722801834,
0.0226307455,
-0.0787943378,
-0.0508609079,
-0.0460380018,
-0.0099155977,
-0.0034424246,
-0.0297544878,
-0.0130050648,
-0.0554608554,
-0.0211977381,
0.0088236816,
-0.0454421267,
-0.0322442949,
-0.0090708463,
2.969e-7,
0.0338251851,
0.0539784133,
-0.0422856659,
0.0544598177,
-0.005676154,
-0.0019091024,
-0.0055065397,
-0.0177340023,
0.0332621112,
0.0039331126,
-0.00642236,
0.0249624811,
0.0202267766,
-0.0089630997,
-0.071541056,
0.0077256626,
0.0303325485,
0.0210418608,
-0.0743941963,
0.0172744468,
0.0082622562,
0.0732128546,
-0.00851392,
0.0072806715,
-0.0001500826,
-0.0136234527,
-0.0036296276,
-0.0221193749,
-0.0112815453,
0.0460261144,
-0.0323494859,
0.0244406536,
0.0115051419,
0.0285198204,
-0.0553833172,
0.022946313,
-0.0178780351,
0.0758155584,
-0.0115822637,
0.0319601446,
0.0097642085,
-0.0370338969,
-0.0206399951,
-0.0437798649,
0.0359738991,
-0.0505321063,
0.0016701798,
0.0094108479,
0.0029923499,
0.0136186006,
-0.0217537712,
-0.0346313566,
0.0297595877,
-0.002776111,
-0.0033356172,
-0.020397421,
-0.0270551629,
-0.0361915193,
0.0006838833,
0.0370195732,
-0.0422637165,
-0.0546191111,
-0.0726967156,
-0.0004810789,
-0.0007786885,
-0.0413985178,
0.0087763332,
3.13480558e-34,
0.0264825299,
-0.0099023078,
0.051996544,
0.0288161337,
0.0246708877,
0.0008233245,
-0.0305341873,
0.0448387638,
0.0280899778,
-0.069321461,
-0.0296298414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09166v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09166v2 | Developing a Natural Language Understanding Model to Characterize Cable News Bias | 2023-10-13T15:01:17 | 2023-10-17T22:37:58 | Seth P. Benson, Iain J. Cruickshank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Media bias has been extensively studied by both social and computational
sciences. However, current work still has a large reliance on human input and
subjective assessment to label biases. This is especially true for cable news
research. To address these issues, we develop an unsupervised machine learning
method to characterize the bias of cable news programs without any human input.
This method relies on the analysis of what topics are mentioned through Named
Entity Recognition and how those topics are discussed through Stance Analysis
in order to cluster programs with similar biases together. Applying our method
to 2020 cable news transcripts, we find that program clusters are consistent
over time and roughly correspond to the cable news network of the program. This
method reveals the potential for future tools to objectively assess media bias
and characterize unfamiliar media environments. | [
0.0268659033,
0.0616640076,
0.0136242621,
-0.0105933864,
-0.0053322562,
0.0506878234,
0.0080486685,
-0.0096496576,
0.0087790545,
-0.090311572,
0.0152818868,
0.0185206477,
-0.0211472008,
0.0085319644,
-0.0172100682,
-0.0357161053,
0.0297431182,
0.0690099001,
0.0936013535,
-0.0108427759,
0.0555643402,
0.0683740228,
-0.0265251081,
0.0138345212,
-0.0243782494,
-0.0223776214,
0.0150671778,
-0.0091469148,
0.0444861725,
-0.0127672441,
0.0026937879,
0.060160622,
-0.0057845814,
0.030737767,
0.0000014268,
-0.0675859004,
-0.003068055,
-0.0439833365,
0.0070285629,
-0.0019033508,
0.0606984496,
-0.0452602431,
-0.0121500995,
0.0066256314,
-0.0109338444,
-0.0094796084,
0.0363019481,
-0.0086396579,
0.0688895732,
0.0665567666,
-0.0071625588,
0.0086382246,
-0.0381992832,
0.0085106883,
-0.002761184,
-0.0405407436,
0.0501446538,
-0.0164790638,
-0.080123052,
-0.0204110797,
-0.0027741548,
-0.0000278392,
0.0092603555,
0.0058683897,
-0.0114288442,
-0.0062536239,
-0.0220451821,
-0.0123883132,
0.0042002676,
0.0251520406,
0.0474257804,
-0.0308688805,
0.0320479944,
-0.0049759401,
0.0053825537,
0.0266996268,
-0.0016252283,
0.0248930361,
-0.0279827248,
0.0162420776,
0.0214160476,
-0.0135985455,
0.0050802669,
0.043632973,
0.0067258272,
0.0737139136,
0.0151763335,
-0.001630969,
0.0070522535,
0.0308552179,
0.0570536926,
-0.0466155261,
0.0316048302,
-0.0202195533,
-0.0028261833,
0.0345555432,
-0.0103452057,
0.0044614081,
-0.0151581224,
-0.0779695436,
-0.0440220833,
-0.0015348088,
0.0080458168,
0.0422650054,
0.0444883145,
-0.0630026311,
0.0127272876,
-0.0155650843,
-0.0096758576,
0.0322879292,
-0.0604622811,
0.0349128768,
0.01958647,
0.0517768934,
-0.0161113515,
0.011607443,
-0.0227971207,
-0.0061997222,
-0.0273898803,
-0.0037065509,
-0.0430534109,
0.0014020224,
0.0162512884,
-0.0043393173,
-0.0436960831,
0.0466768853,
-0.0732107908,
0.0203077011,
-0.0203481093,
-0.0223517437,
0.0065415935,
0.0258962568,
0.001230596,
-0.0160694383,
-0.0258825701,
-0.0009957053,
0.025687689,
-0.0127557935,
-0.0126432274,
0.0085410336,
-0.0127963647,
-0.0286964402,
0.0051583708,
-0.0411623381,
0.0171411876,
0.0006543407,
0.0080229724,
-0.0297308806,
-0.0364717953,
0.0163068809,
-0.0394443981,
0.0386589207,
0.0511695035,
0.0187329613,
0.0796998739,
0.033788573,
0.0504682846,
0.0871085003,
-0.0322897024,
0.0157762244,
0.0714633763,
0.0019659358,
-0.0256696194,
0.0295598917,
0.0306640379,
0.0073426832,
-0.0485521033,
0.020992104,
-0.0467587523,
0.0020496154,
0.0195214543,
-0.0118898209,
-0.0033877508,
-0.0098213553,
0.0642080083,
0.0606692433,
-0.0472027138,
0.0086374665,
0.0177716389,
0.0300015155,
0.0049719354,
0.0400952324,
-0.0274037626,
0.0144704552,
-0.0127129219,
-0.0299789924,
0.0266670026,
0.0220665541,
-0.0397804715,
-0.0334189497,
-0.0026772642,
0.0215705764,
0.0156904068,
0.0008289075,
0.0130171953,
-0.0041052164,
-0.0369303599,
0.0708227679,
0.0335439555,
0.0031258287,
0.055970937,
-0.0162357092,
0.0535345823,
-0.0038337603,
-0.0046289884,
-0.0088265873,
0.0353986435,
-0.0245214384,
0.0319637246,
0.0352671891,
0.060772568,
-0.0263359156,
-0.0273874458,
-0.0065751318,
-0.011326788,
-0.016259484,
0.0475437194,
0.0734634325,
-0.0376564227,
0.0312866569,
-0.0306735318,
-0.0090709124,
0.0066349693,
0.0289376415,
0.0326475091,
-0.0425077341,
-0.0252139326,
0.0357910208,
0.0149462484,
0.0592461117,
0.0085255057,
-0.0452179611,
0.0019302436,
0.0326723158,
-0.0053790477,
-0.0335141346,
-0.0394314788,
-0.0070465566,
-0.0459829383,
-0.0605674908,
-0.0621763915,
0.0380163081,
-0.0059600682,
0.008814076,
0.0417818539,
-0.0127014229,
0.0097162519,
-0.0249496195,
-0.0456354022,
-0.040998105,
-0.0098017445,
-0.0373841003,
0.0803651512,
-0.0028909422,
0.0069593727,
0.0331305601,
-0.0475593582,
0.0006038646,
-0.0298261344,
-0.0025342896,
-0.0046552988,
-0.0096829766,
-0.0187467188,
0.0610392913,
-0.0715448856,
-0.0391920321,
0.0068651508,
-0.0201327838,
-0.0001233398,
-0.0355474129,
0.034258388,
0.0624753609,
-0.0059377044,
-0.0220714845,
0.0288723428,
0.011493762,
-0.0950653851,
-0.0344389156,
-0.0008082032,
-0.0141227059,
-0.015652407,
0.0054848092,
-0.0088630188,
-0.0111751128,
-0.0656074509,
0.0477529019,
0.0300186742,
-0.0369296074,
-0.0591949672,
0.0065838578,
-0.0243119206,
-0.0455274098,
0.0026147193,
0.0198495332,
0.019684691,
0.0544099435,
-0.0345636941,
0.0579477213,
0.04892103,
0.0715451911,
0.0251236092,
0.0189649276,
-0.0322651006,
-0.0204067845,
-0.0358314663,
0.0291239861,
-0.0333019532,
-0.0387397371,
0.0668588877,
0.0590369031,
0.0367956907,
0.0181433242,
-0.0319624841,
0.0617772676,
-0.0422884002,
-0.021737434,
-0.0044065886,
-0.0431105383,
-0.003145779,
0.0453135483,
-0.0029661902,
-0.0270033441,
0.0537815131,
0.0077144834,
0.0653022379,
-0.065448679,
-0.0274289101,
-0.0143492538,
0.0206085406,
-0.0009614715,
0.0399372689,
-0.0041099689,
-0.063259609,
-0.0438491553,
-0.0203679446,
0.0433602035,
0.017933704,
0.0513961613,
-0.009783986,
0.01209109,
0.0483585298,
0.0126748402,
-0.0359781012,
-0.0218659975,
-0.0120341843,
-0.0203222912,
0.0663184375,
0.0130164055,
-0.0313879885,
0.0344787911,
-0.0068157287,
-0.0659448504,
0.0107843764,
0.00297336,
0.0253742691,
0.0244964808,
0.029888371,
-0.0172927976,
0.0042154924,
0.0393080488,
-0.0054549072,
0.0134086749,
0.015680911,
0.0600275509,
-0.0058291252,
0.0197966546,
0.0099256095,
-0.069770053,
-0.0004830199,
-0.0219344981,
0.0482835807,
0.0241870675,
0.0264105033,
0.1160460338,
0.0205615032,
-0.07715711,
-0.012423899,
0.0442415625,
-0.0586854443,
0.044731535,
0.0173189621,
-0.1067693383,
0.0202694777,
0.0050348653,
0.0345785804,
-0.0149890883,
-0.0527674407,
-0.0286696032,
-0.0933468863,
-0.0079128323,
-0.0290320367,
-0.0538630448,
-0.0190596078,
-0.0911080167,
0.0007914841,
-0.0724338517,
-0.0225376394,
-0.0225847401,
0.0303197633,
0.0136051634,
-0.0102567831,
-0.0456591882,
-0.043941915,
0.0302737188,
-0.0206599068,
0.0607804209,
0.01321082,
0.0288803484,
-0.0125125479,
0.0159116574,
0.0156492218,
-0.047761295,
-0.0359871499,
-0.0171036869,
0.0479337685,
-0.0679318607,
0.0026077651,
-0.0419964679,
0.0620172732,
0.0340473466,
-0.0109857041,
-0.0114192199,
0.00807257,
0.0288313013,
-0.0194136649,
-0.0264235642,
0.0363024436,
0.0474104956,
0.0496328883,
0.0201752111,
-0.038676545,
0.048397027,
-0.0370968506,
0.0432469994,
-0.0007237004,
-0.0415666439,
-0.0034622524,
-0.0297413971,
-0.0135396551,
-0.0014196653,
-0.0233322419,
-0.0226055831,
0.0340671204,
0.0058012684,
-0.0091749281,
0.0481899641,
-0.006147767,
-0.0075006783,
0.0397993252,
0.0260560997,
-0.0262362789,
0.0259541739,
-0.063946493,
-0.0261968095,
0.0224759113,
-0.0623861887,
-0.0081797857,
-0.033380188,
-0.0324097574,
0.0260948166,
-0.0022593986,
0.0187946334,
0.0357803293,
-0.0124311261,
0.0089912433,
0.0362981185,
0.0522002503,
-0.056249436,
-0.0144829797,
-0.0340410434,
0.0042839018,
-0.0008093828,
0.0067112814,
-0.0423699208,
0.0386516899,
0.0022843995,
-0.0205029715,
-0.0739959329,
-0.0213579927,
0.0031120174,
-0.0328306034,
0.080424346,
0.0147175929,
-0.0301954485,
-0.0800292045,
-0.0461951829,
0.0066675595,
-0.0250441507,
0.0471809246,
-0.0188975725,
0.0068139136,
-0.0081028761,
-0.0772381872,
0.0427714474,
-0.0661638826,
0.0606658794,
-0.0361456536,
0.0384458452,
0.0253335834,
0.026534833,
-0.0363199376,
-0.0263624191,
-0.0120545058,
0.0488037951,
-0.0008105162,
0.0132638551,
-0.0031087396,
0.0308314469,
0.0223431922,
0.043960508,
0.0387145095,
-0.0238274019,
-0.0213160254,
0.0178387184,
-0.0275550373,
0.0147463242,
0.0078719575,
-0.0676650256,
-0.0146335056,
0.0503497235,
-0.0225987993,
0.0168357026,
-0.0085693682,
-0.0051592384,
-0.0232131407,
0.0425052121,
0.0328813642,
-0.0296003819,
0.0276660882,
0.0209180638,
0.0128562171,
0.0228811391,
0.0430334695,
-0.0662987828,
-0.033613883,
-0.030005021,
0.0408901498,
0.0212218724,
-0.0314853936,
-0.0057775774,
-0.0484940894,
-0.0469014384,
-0.0290917512,
-0.0369211547,
0.0563828647,
0.0042907987,
0.0048519657,
0.0614752881,
-0.018460447,
0.022497898,
0.0016150899,
-0.0085440287,
-0.0678844303,
-0.0473264828,
0.0134673687,
-5.336328522e-33,
-0.0055254963,
-0.0152591094,
-0.0398376286,
-0.0087504145,
0.0346410796,
0.0123200258,
-0.0082194908,
0.0068285735,
-0.0168228522,
-0.0019369065,
0.0470350906,
0.0448938496,
0.0122463303,
-0.0210463088,
-0.0083667925,
-0.0319873504,
0.0097119631,
-0.0201195776,
-0.0508808941,
-0.0145518724,
-0.0229049418,
0.0300084315,
0.0238692556,
-0.0638231114,
0.0672497675,
-0.0031626171,
-0.0122081432,
-0.0333339162,
0.0621462092,
0.0414710678,
-0.0066981916,
0.0164085571,
0.036203105,
-0.1060236618,
0.0264724586,
0.0887035578,
-0.0617912039,
-0.0204247665,
0.038374871,
-0.0034030119,
0.0117841801,
0.0093069952,
0.000195918,
0.0449862182,
-0.044987984,
-0.002910048,
0.0686335191,
0.0127430335,
0.0361163393,
0.0075397687,
-0.0190846696,
-0.0045489301,
-0.081286028,
0.0180213805,
-0.0425215103,
-0.0266437121,
0.0335798115,
0.0652736723,
-0.0553760678,
0.0061576557,
-0.0676941276,
0.0238390826,
0.0505673327,
-0.0280479714,
-0.0175965894,
0.0671865195,
0.0558635741,
0.0002206442,
-0.0784827322,
-0.0020706628,
0.0347848013,
-0.0211584941,
-0.0212563928,
0.0603611432,
0.0178844351,
-0.024637958,
-0.088111788,
0.0192334969,
0.0493054613,
0.0071691941,
0.019162083,
-0.0285830703,
-0.0094511826,
0.0019852349,
-0.0378797166,
-0.115489468,
-0.0262429696,
-0.0324663036,
-0.008641948,
-0.0014755385,
-0.059102606,
0.0403125957,
0.0010675886,
-0.0328960232,
-0.0040499899,
0.0609351024,
-0.0264946613,
-0.0163714886,
0.0138117112,
0.030487312,
-0.0924938992,
0.0403194763,
0.0178570859,
0.0298977923,
0.0440930389,
-0.0444799215,
-0.0142379617,
0.0034272443,
-0.0474834442,
-0.0065220986,
0.0217913426,
-0.0007519544,
-0.0283518378,
0.0587891862,
0.0222580247,
0.0212275945,
0.0185215138,
0.0216438621,
0.0026259143,
0.0136648677,
0.0299142711,
-0.014120847,
-0.0418933444,
0.0150168985,
-0.0325892866,
-0.0477056615,
0.0346754752,
0.036434859,
0.0169651583,
-0.045338925,
-0.023758851,
-0.0380382538,
2.212e-7,
0.0306267533,
0.0807641298,
-0.0242534,
0.0057324306,
0.0355724022,
0.0457047969,
0.011476865,
0.0595125519,
0.0095924279,
-0.1143603995,
-0.0002821197,
0.0137295453,
-0.0115231201,
0.024129048,
-0.0906435624,
0.0179531816,
-0.0478246398,
0.0564800799,
-0.0390704386,
0.0059015285,
-0.0037333306,
0.0564056411,
0.026576262,
-0.0044815,
-0.0094647324,
-0.0026088441,
0.0050637205,
-0.0116209583,
-0.0383229814,
0.025829548,
-0.0084600663,
-0.0090615591,
-0.0145544158,
0.0434090048,
-0.0061473525,
0.0059146602,
0.0168842934,
0.0460300446,
0.0253931396,
-0.0433897376,
-0.0321740843,
0.0154274115,
-0.0037768288,
-0.024226306,
0.0492352061,
-0.0396906547,
-0.0413914509,
-0.0732516795,
-0.0432543531,
-0.0040143323,
0.0349130519,
0.0269019436,
0.0083739925,
0.0197599847,
-0.0313622132,
0.0145589979,
0.0144167868,
-0.0560919046,
0.0161898267,
0.0199136119,
-0.0303651951,
-0.0358914807,
0.0257910546,
-0.0076405606,
0.040343076,
-0.0334771648,
0.0457069129,
1.432981797e-34,
0.0150173111,
0.0100798421,
-0.033238478,
-0.0511474535,
0.0033544526,
0.0084816143,
-0.0484197028,
-0.04408364,
0.0127192326,
-0.02816342,
0.017942125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09151v1 | BibRank: Automatic Keyphrase Extraction Platform Using~Metadata | 2023-10-13T14:44:34 | 2023-10-13T14:44:34 | Abdelrhman Eldallal, Eduard Barbu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic Keyphrase Extraction involves identifying essential phrases in a
document. These keyphrases are crucial in various tasks such as document
classification, clustering, recommendation, indexing, searching, summarization,
and text simplification. This paper introduces a platform that integrates
keyphrase datasets and facilitates the evaluation of keyphrase extraction
algorithms. The platform includes BibRank, an automatic keyphrase extraction
algorithm that leverages a rich dataset obtained by parsing bibliographic data
in BibTeX format. BibRank combines innovative weighting techniques with
positional, statistical, and word co-occurrence information to extract
keyphrases from documents. The platform proves valuable for researchers and
developers seeking to enhance their keyphrase extraction algorithms and advance
the field of natural language processing. | [
0.0663339049,
0.0155077847,
-0.0188262016,
-0.0058268919,
-0.0507825688,
0.0285936557,
-0.0012110379,
0.0097385608,
0.0567283481,
-0.0517506897,
-0.0050786333,
0.0707955882,
-0.0360028856,
0.0478659049,
0.0016233512,
-0.0824746564,
0.0233506933,
0.008348722,
0.0514726639,
0.0290140789,
0.0192745309,
0.0143739935,
-0.0077675246,
0.0299032535,
0.0593458079,
-0.0302885938,
0.0473550558,
-0.0379482843,
0.0449396744,
-0.0246427692,
0.0291928798,
0.0221686885,
-0.0406403169,
0.0170775559,
0.0000020094,
-0.0312410779,
-0.0346327163,
-0.0209543668,
0.0034919779,
0.0283180531,
0.0957103223,
0.0344456509,
0.0102162035,
0.0088817151,
-0.051545389,
0.000053618,
0.0311207939,
0.0329478718,
0.0491542742,
-0.0109780822,
-0.0161564033,
-0.0629094765,
-0.0143702058,
0.0000205437,
-0.0136261014,
-0.0140267462,
0.0199220497,
0.0029535636,
0.0023947649,
0.0492932349,
0.0089579802,
0.0066055222,
-0.0460543819,
0.020570429,
0.0815140158,
0.0296324398,
-0.0637139529,
-0.0224043913,
-0.0171337128,
0.0543099493,
0.0019857006,
0.0159489326,
0.0662036538,
-0.0141210323,
0.007223974,
0.0476818979,
-0.0806106776,
-0.0111531615,
-0.0224911757,
-0.0385952331,
-0.0130792335,
-0.0177719779,
-0.0190083701,
-0.0094404155,
-0.0074801771,
0.0467495583,
0.0042230086,
-0.0180799272,
-0.0077233883,
-0.0177064482,
-0.0329295024,
-0.041198235,
0.007949532,
-0.0293963142,
0.0565158091,
0.018588718,
0.0085799228,
-0.0109168002,
0.0909394622,
-0.0982641056,
-0.0402610078,
-0.067262575,
-0.0543641746,
0.0585984401,
0.0189650971,
-0.0265468135,
-0.0081925383,
-0.024300294,
-0.0097953435,
0.0327741019,
-0.0531154759,
-0.0131818615,
-0.0085540954,
0.0625652745,
0.036852058,
-0.0380844958,
-0.0610993877,
-0.0092011411,
-0.015034657,
0.0398402698,
-0.0152167277,
0.0512452908,
0.0146186715,
0.0123834424,
0.0065823514,
-0.0218328312,
-0.0350497328,
0.0230554435,
-0.0103960633,
0.0176942032,
0.0061726007,
-0.0120743588,
0.0807233229,
-0.0268305261,
0.050817579,
-0.0292806402,
0.0380229317,
-0.0244309362,
0.0056590117,
-0.0466710515,
-0.0057032229,
0.0137098143,
0.0013549363,
-0.0525919311,
0.0486344062,
0.038654685,
-0.0117489463,
-0.0304397605,
0.0010860361,
0.0393289365,
-0.0593015328,
0.0211756416,
-0.0477808304,
-0.0213605221,
0.04384505,
0.0132715302,
0.0033284058,
-0.0022438611,
-0.0134680709,
0.066822432,
0.1025093943,
-0.0222018771,
0.0103352563,
-0.001974056,
0.0019347699,
0.0051490115,
0.0344832055,
0.0429884829,
-0.0077368217,
-0.0150289824,
-0.0529108606,
-0.0235236995,
-0.0422628149,
0.0236452557,
0.0361390226,
0.1192727685,
-0.0100731216,
0.0165760498,
-0.0249538589,
0.0480815433,
0.0345204845,
-0.0261855051,
0.0120668039,
-0.0176889878,
-0.0011960106,
0.0275481157,
0.0395486094,
0.0626550317,
0.0251264088,
-0.0208116174,
-0.0182544235,
0.0238586068,
-0.0059308987,
-0.0171592776,
0.0512462035,
-0.0237803813,
-0.0249956176,
0.1096133366,
0.0110526579,
-0.0376197957,
-0.0598275214,
0.001051302,
-0.0170850027,
0.0129827801,
0.0714248717,
-0.0831436664,
0.0181623511,
-0.016670296,
0.0279897023,
0.0023218752,
-0.0296579618,
-0.0020891004,
-0.0254119262,
-0.0594252832,
-0.0418032296,
0.0281579252,
0.0198581833,
-0.0392239243,
-0.0064431466,
0.0321356095,
0.0064306078,
-0.0130704073,
-0.0125489114,
0.0371298231,
0.0413888469,
-0.0370383449,
-0.0237525851,
-0.0466769263,
0.0348880962,
0.026077928,
-0.0108234035,
0.0094191404,
0.0587092303,
-0.0131068984,
0.0051261778,
0.0491920449,
0.051455915,
0.0613103844,
0.0232305024,
-0.0385147743,
0.0247596111,
0.0091448054,
-0.0081239343,
-0.0093983607,
0.052197244,
0.0083321389,
0.008070997,
-0.0101607358,
0.003843013,
-0.0529187955,
0.0545938462,
-0.0345679075,
0.078989841,
0.0341594033,
0.0005712992,
-0.0643909201,
-0.1119138077,
0.015765151,
0.0106971702,
-0.0060703903,
0.0376344621,
-0.006890798,
-0.0156761706,
0.021135835,
-0.0344789028,
-0.033558026,
-0.0111367675,
-0.0609875992,
0.0358081795,
0.0297711492,
0.0269061569,
0.0003943983,
0.0255485252,
-0.0206760801,
-0.0034006983,
0.0269633997,
-0.0123307742,
-0.0233725496,
-0.0163154062,
0.0284371749,
0.0168512464,
0.0062837233,
-0.0335578732,
0.0018652823,
-0.0293475911,
0.0443281122,
0.0487838946,
-0.0175574999,
0.0142825535,
0.0208155829,
-0.0090622846,
-0.04344007,
0.0066771726,
-0.0075576426,
-0.0074746329,
-0.0068075028,
0.0194698293,
0.0623443425,
0.0397737101,
-0.0223399661,
-0.0074958075,
-0.0404537395,
-0.0322337598,
-0.0338898338,
-0.0012645544,
0.0376438387,
0.0317680463,
-0.0328731313,
0.0705717653,
-0.0155103272,
0.0048743319,
0.0096930368,
0.0154494811,
0.0260875747,
0.0142142037,
0.0221600067,
-0.0410944894,
-0.0274121184,
-0.002216666,
0.0164115746,
-0.0002215859,
-0.0128982291,
0.0132673588,
0.0101001579,
-0.0088769356,
-0.0560121536,
0.0048668752,
-0.0537623949,
0.0573474169,
-0.0150847929,
-0.0049945503,
0.017949285,
-0.011873492,
0.041638203,
-0.0320993066,
0.041312471,
-0.0697346404,
-0.0133678159,
-0.0256390311,
-0.0069272714,
-0.0224053655,
0.02301226,
0.002939095,
0.0022760595,
-0.0259966329,
-0.0563319921,
0.0379581451,
-0.0070265215,
-0.0135713518,
-0.0019155465,
0.0453085862,
0.0360160694,
0.0058770296,
0.0011242542,
0.0195799898,
0.0150301615,
0.0338366777,
-0.0476359501,
0.0122624263,
0.0201200508,
0.0110123642,
0.0422075242,
0.0407866314,
-0.0375521295,
-0.0032699073,
-0.0245292354,
0.0151842367,
-0.0664158538,
-0.0110356547,
-0.0379401594,
-0.0328308716,
-0.0232723039,
-0.010006248,
0.0774950534,
0.0651474968,
-0.0642715022,
-0.0128511833,
-0.055690337,
-0.0320938937,
0.0037285895,
0.015266642,
-0.0542464629,
-0.023573786,
-0.0340058319,
0.0211276934,
-0.0079355938,
-0.0494639389,
0.0116053624,
-0.0542307347,
0.0439633504,
-0.0175967608,
0.0377798826,
-0.0426295549,
-0.0623791888,
-0.0333099812,
-0.0615944676,
-0.0760919005,
-0.0076596197,
-0.0644072294,
0.0338233896,
-0.0153237712,
-0.0951806828,
-0.0268391762,
0.0521317609,
-0.0469508544,
-0.0113246413,
0.0644323528,
0.0620132126,
-0.0612199008,
0.045928441,
-0.0149340266,
-0.0278485194,
-0.0721662715,
-0.0110637899,
0.0530655831,
-0.0118034678,
0.0077341264,
-0.0182875302,
0.0189060178,
-0.0394304022,
-0.021272406,
0.1251475811,
0.022580374,
0.0010769488,
0.0061304155,
-0.0754258782,
0.0267881695,
-0.0094703138,
0.0520495698,
0.0159852803,
0.0011653716,
-0.0071888189,
0.0028178429,
0.0189884752,
-0.0729403049,
-0.0387637727,
-0.0470515788,
-0.0313104726,
0.0206641536,
-0.0889521837,
-0.028115917,
0.007148027,
-0.0206979774,
0.0092375269,
0.0583569556,
0.0093844067,
0.0097356336,
-0.073464632,
0.0032663713,
0.0326995589,
-0.0389853232,
-0.0217253808,
-0.0212685727,
0.0718073174,
-0.0161865763,
-0.0544151068,
0.0187149215,
0.0249731429,
-0.0172583926,
0.0460080579,
0.0199184716,
0.0156737994,
-0.009824344,
-0.0281475075,
-0.0038012785,
0.0561834797,
0.0750543401,
-0.0394971929,
-0.021917114,
0.0193017479,
-0.0095387893,
-0.0079378774,
-0.0026565446,
-0.037865974,
0.0089131054,
-0.0351701379,
0.0015593704,
-0.0752500892,
-0.0412382148,
-0.0126054538,
0.0259724017,
-0.0029506772,
-0.0162377562,
-0.0187685601,
-0.0321326293,
-0.010168639,
0.0159011371,
-0.0187614989,
-0.0284117032,
0.0630197823,
-0.0202816688,
-0.0391381942,
-0.0258394629,
0.0691978931,
-0.0369439945,
0.0076665166,
-0.0036111672,
0.0461703427,
-0.0176747106,
0.0320757143,
-0.0273367316,
-0.0373383909,
0.0049140216,
-0.0432281494,
-0.0293660071,
0.0205654185,
0.0094982814,
0.0154233957,
0.0079662818,
-0.0520466827,
-0.0159868263,
0.0889465138,
-0.0769305378,
0.022657292,
-0.0096579185,
-0.016140582,
0.0305853263,
-0.0272141788,
0.035578005,
-0.0283326413,
-0.0405470617,
0.0088165244,
0.0456451811,
-0.0091679608,
0.0254307315,
-0.0373359919,
0.0198685788,
-0.048853457,
0.0043900744,
0.0424604267,
0.0172852594,
0.0059533357,
0.0088249501,
-0.0705853254,
-0.019287942,
-0.0089276545,
0.0449546613,
0.0328357555,
0.0061222618,
-0.0158838239,
-0.0350965895,
0.0212537888,
0.0662301034,
0.0314184465,
0.0191577449,
-0.0171033889,
0.0158727951,
0.0766722262,
0.0219148267,
0.0026414192,
-0.0550564975,
0.0591242835,
-0.0511943735,
0.0024663741,
0.0051809712,
-6.39125756e-33,
0.0019871548,
-0.0151467295,
-0.0175051764,
0.0442849509,
0.0005852734,
-0.0033294861,
0.0045779501,
-0.0332647488,
-0.0129889855,
0.0087414496,
-0.0344564691,
0.012988748,
0.0173084531,
-0.0220354442,
0.0659141317,
0.0080898283,
-0.0091212187,
0.0206262637,
-0.0235770606,
0.0497833528,
0.0143407751,
0.0246897563,
0.0575689897,
-0.0776454434,
0.038306199,
-0.0496363193,
-0.0144876791,
-0.0451115444,
0.06021294,
0.0688176602,
-0.0116042206,
0.0323543027,
-0.0071356348,
-0.0606672689,
0.0141878659,
0.0181787089,
-0.052538529,
0.0029028601,
-0.0070567313,
-0.0251382831,
0.0443526879,
-0.0314717069,
0.0148405079,
-0.0015749763,
-0.0236976705,
0.0023698963,
0.084621653,
-0.0489443541,
-0.0366660357,
-0.0323124006,
-0.0046832287,
0.0332665741,
-0.0077769961,
0.0571561567,
0.0107767852,
0.0175506398,
-0.0073613562,
0.063797906,
-0.0428511724,
0.0236479491,
0.0370792821,
0.002394032,
0.0017809375,
0.0192728937,
0.0434255265,
0.0211438928,
0.0104084937,
-0.0703013688,
0.0477731638,
0.0554293022,
-0.0009187168,
0.0440996811,
0.0234805103,
0.0663932413,
0.0531445034,
0.0000713421,
-0.0228299443,
0.072019361,
0.0126564531,
0.0034550817,
0.0213240124,
-0.0046227565,
-0.0202278085,
0.0310858227,
0.0293081049,
0.000858736,
-0.0216461737,
-0.0152693707,
-0.0196089689,
-0.0031345419,
-0.1062816828,
0.0687239245,
-0.0131664099,
0.0033064459,
-0.0386228412,
0.0160240978,
0.0256190002,
0.0270023309,
0.0029652501,
-0.008468668,
-0.027972756,
-0.0013243853,
-0.0033456567,
0.0286538359,
0.0504593551,
-0.0373015851,
0.0124824392,
-0.0144356163,
-0.0310852341,
-0.0044974382,
0.0455143563,
-0.0134444786,
-0.0486106165,
-0.001607744,
-0.0379668064,
0.0343855284,
0.0162604935,
0.0103522064,
0.0459332764,
0.0071965917,
-0.018733792,
-0.0468290485,
0.0250220206,
0.0321097486,
-0.003438598,
-0.0019712083,
-0.0085616978,
-0.0114817545,
0.0037136283,
-0.0084336074,
-0.0227014702,
-0.0283206776,
2.797e-7,
0.0350524224,
0.0672226027,
0.0208150856,
-0.0342491344,
-0.0181222316,
0.0643724799,
0.0009580757,
0.0404646806,
0.0051411511,
0.0076362882,
0.0578971505,
0.0415870063,
-0.0125137325,
-0.0061417813,
-0.0833996683,
-0.0685882196,
-0.0482792109,
-0.0500441492,
-0.0707514137,
-0.0188989993,
0.0108173825,
0.0065323082,
0.0067681279,
-0.0008317188,
-0.0187025536,
-0.0284217894,
-0.019789258,
-0.0516046099,
0.0147806201,
0.0268161707,
0.0204239357,
0.0293718744,
-0.0303775463,
-0.0163973682,
-0.0178355221,
0.0067414967,
0.078659609,
0.0140394103,
-0.022629356,
-0.0058123344,
-0.0103641395,
-0.0431852899,
0.0216940679,
-0.0259430781,
0.0687594041,
-0.0132916514,
-0.0163062532,
-0.0641633868,
-0.0918137357,
0.0013800048,
0.0050526564,
-0.0309410766,
-0.0525248647,
0.0161279086,
-0.0169329699,
-0.0161351971,
-0.0204145927,
-0.0537899435,
0.0368677005,
0.0366332084,
-0.0036079488,
0.0004529922,
-0.0305852685,
0.0313172899,
-0.0282294657,
-0.0641572326,
0.0385352075,
2.436592011e-34,
0.0104620699,
0.0035927019,
-0.018338792,
0.0388759784,
0.0281067602,
-0.0271805245,
-0.0450265855,
-0.0039693159,
-0.0110210842,
0.0066436674,
0.0255058613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09141v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09141v2 | PuoBERTa: Training and evaluation of a curated language model for Setswana | 2023-10-13T14:33:02 | 2023-10-24T16:01:46 | Vukosi Marivate, Moseli Mots'Oehli, Valencia Wagner, Richard Lastrucci, Isheanesu Dzingirai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural language processing (NLP) has made significant progress for
well-resourced languages such as English but lagged behind for low-resource
languages like Setswana. This paper addresses this gap by presenting PuoBERTa,
a customised masked language model trained specifically for Setswana. We cover
how we collected, curated, and prepared diverse monolingual texts to generate a
high-quality corpus for PuoBERTa's training. Building upon previous efforts in
creating monolingual resources for Setswana, we evaluated PuoBERTa across
several NLP tasks, including part-of-speech (POS) tagging, named entity
recognition (NER), and news categorisation. Additionally, we introduced a new
Setswana news categorisation dataset and provided the initial benchmarks using
PuoBERTa. Our work demonstrates the efficacy of PuoBERTa in fostering NLP
capabilities for understudied languages like Setswana and paves the way for
future research directions. | [
0.0474127866,
0.0510270856,
0.0052439789,
0.0482581817,
0.0114616798,
0.0533791371,
0.0072867819,
0.0008570651,
0.0227714498,
-0.0403995439,
-0.027690392,
-0.0766709894,
0.0110635161,
0.0404472649,
0.0218173712,
-0.0672227293,
0.0528330915,
-0.0255479477,
-0.0034442926,
0.0124751963,
-0.0003860876,
0.0214528665,
0.0198512748,
0.0107453084,
0.0176510606,
-0.0019734276,
-0.012704243,
-0.0015579951,
-0.0186777636,
-0.0710607991,
-0.0070848707,
0.0421448722,
-0.0451579653,
0.041801028,
0.0000019824,
-0.0731187165,
-0.0389879197,
-0.0155661907,
-0.0326838121,
0.0258222464,
-0.010209308,
-0.0158245675,
-0.0477588214,
0.0450615026,
-0.0169866122,
-0.0348297879,
0.0406171456,
0.008729225,
0.0284853838,
0.0985032097,
-0.0106716203,
-0.01052495,
0.027697308,
-0.0390298739,
-0.0514925011,
-0.013382555,
0.0100754201,
-0.023331644,
0.0068031414,
0.0253656954,
0.0035502168,
0.0109419273,
-0.0130966222,
0.0013004426,
0.0154852169,
0.0128727611,
-0.0567290783,
-0.0680670217,
0.0256963316,
0.0028572686,
-0.025641473,
-0.0001544175,
-0.0032303857,
0.0024479891,
-0.0293433443,
-0.0041340301,
-0.0086693373,
0.0023972869,
-0.0302889962,
0.0204883758,
0.0385994799,
0.0245756377,
0.0444300473,
0.0193204843,
0.0017116911,
0.0003281463,
0.0086003924,
-0.0126626985,
0.0256489329,
-0.0206026472,
0.0097038355,
-0.0752368793,
0.000239487,
0.011051083,
0.0171762444,
0.0081665842,
0.0150138978,
-0.0169467926,
0.0454674028,
-0.0665221512,
-0.0256360788,
0.0098912446,
-0.0235492662,
0.0459334552,
-0.0351567678,
-0.0309386272,
0.0023013873,
0.0082317526,
-0.001430836,
-0.0297240969,
-0.0469799377,
-0.0483645871,
-0.0509161167,
0.0339719802,
-0.0471342802,
0.0175234657,
-0.0077968938,
-0.0519551821,
0.0090475902,
-0.0012033696,
-0.006850447,
-0.0414988175,
-0.0202995222,
-0.0172816124,
-0.0134797376,
0.0185071658,
-0.0205288716,
0.0047507221,
-0.0276348889,
-0.0522560813,
0.016580401,
-0.0285510626,
-0.0385624208,
-0.0125956098,
0.0396623425,
0.0244567972,
-0.0324785821,
-0.06955681,
-0.0817241445,
0.0079635587,
-0.0241053309,
-0.0151631944,
-0.0354396291,
-0.0728238076,
0.0045832307,
0.0144676222,
0.068234399,
-0.046161294,
0.0114395637,
-0.0128232464,
0.0192557462,
0.0777929053,
0.0079410104,
-0.0182563551,
0.0530622639,
0.0257693045,
0.0750834867,
0.0612420365,
0.0227306988,
0.0145822586,
0.0485071316,
0.0025354286,
-0.0587096699,
0.0678895786,
-0.0219766479,
0.0205068346,
-0.0036356,
-0.0108722765,
0.0176612735,
-0.0283897594,
0.0165695846,
0.0332153924,
0.0238192137,
0.0066894935,
-0.0158102047,
0.0105831949,
-0.0121037941,
0.0610832721,
0.0085882414,
-0.003978184,
0.0332683958,
-0.043157097,
0.035785161,
-0.0265071969,
-0.0063427906,
-0.0034598827,
0.0070581869,
0.0532663502,
-0.011234547,
0.002066626,
-0.0022380853,
0.0001085786,
0.0129885208,
-0.0096718408,
0.0440133177,
0.0149063095,
-0.0497983992,
0.0117960665,
0.0350112282,
-0.0390007123,
0.0472023934,
-0.029140573,
0.0269438177,
0.0405656584,
0.0279870592,
-0.0144978995,
0.0090402681,
-0.0143888742,
-0.0047364496,
0.0878769085,
-0.0018411712,
-0.0466782488,
-0.0087478003,
-0.040785145,
0.0247635841,
0.0117657036,
-0.0031452603,
0.0582263805,
0.0047696149,
0.0817923248,
0.0126938038,
0.0151963746,
-0.0234582275,
0.0487203263,
-0.0661081001,
-0.045039326,
0.008658981,
-0.0091858171,
0.0424278937,
0.0567827299,
-0.0034630841,
0.0193739515,
-0.0324790627,
-0.0487199873,
0.0131794717,
0.040845193,
0.0080539947,
-0.0299099721,
0.0105151217,
-0.0313918255,
-0.0002933398,
0.0777979344,
0.0265720747,
-0.038059514,
-0.0156426728,
0.0278645717,
-0.0139750428,
-0.0469988398,
0.020134557,
0.0061811488,
0.020946851,
-0.0324041285,
0.0406147353,
-0.015120104,
-0.0243681669,
0.0012792008,
-0.0443932787,
0.0552940629,
0.0067171822,
-0.0375185832,
0.0603323653,
0.0004381582,
-0.0453423336,
-0.0189434029,
0.015143008,
-0.0306962375,
-0.00827948,
-0.0991836637,
0.0360065885,
-0.0235952865,
0.0424013399,
-0.0235977024,
0.0677867383,
-0.027280394,
-0.0038126856,
0.0256646182,
-0.0394746922,
0.0183242522,
-0.0008529019,
-0.0183654185,
-0.0254633762,
0.0138908643,
-0.0497568734,
-0.003597684,
0.00750532,
0.0517421253,
-0.0180753302,
-0.0663185492,
-0.0479023717,
0.0154175144,
0.0117090587,
-0.0000793107,
-0.0109324967,
-0.0028124272,
-0.0211070906,
-0.0194420945,
-0.0108334385,
0.0242329091,
-0.0094789807,
-0.0020739958,
0.0126513587,
0.001839195,
-0.0095643997,
0.0042256317,
-0.0394161828,
0.0125018302,
-0.0117722508,
-0.0274252314,
0.050447423,
0.0983719677,
-0.0224647038,
0.012588324,
-0.0239863675,
-0.0506543666,
-0.0484725721,
-0.0496296473,
-0.0297710951,
-0.0226730909,
0.0170997828,
0.0151838874,
-0.0422649868,
-0.001589608,
0.0755476728,
-0.0328852721,
-0.0060834517,
-0.0729778707,
0.0020526485,
-0.0604532473,
0.0461900979,
-0.0164156593,
0.0069341874,
0.0288588274,
-0.0286305789,
-0.0029385041,
0.0268529654,
0.0191853624,
-0.009714677,
-0.0046498729,
-0.0301710609,
0.0022792479,
-0.0115662022,
-0.0474558063,
-0.002029998,
-0.0285085905,
-0.0282223411,
0.0248218533,
0.0260986555,
0.0325378999,
0.0092728017,
0.059087161,
0.0101329423,
0.023183316,
0.0258762576,
-0.0040021786,
0.0133544188,
0.047015328,
0.0168988388,
-0.0150343711,
0.0099230371,
-0.0189271625,
0.0358535759,
-0.0097787092,
0.0117031299,
0.0138510382,
0.0426229276,
-0.0001335269,
0.0292196441,
-0.054735586,
-0.0490638465,
-0.0360702835,
0.0537388176,
-0.0190025903,
-0.0254778173,
0.1046232656,
0.0573055558,
-0.0095049553,
-0.0177549589,
-0.0716840848,
0.027914675,
0.001566103,
0.0256597605,
-0.0510379411,
-0.0042185634,
0.024684798,
0.0157701261,
-0.0082747694,
-0.0288013648,
0.0283999313,
-0.1469492763,
0.0018772061,
0.0060272412,
-0.0332163163,
0.0254151039,
-0.0674614608,
-0.0557651818,
-0.0089083556,
-0.0428909436,
-0.0045992751,
0.0057083555,
0.0149399806,
0.0825027674,
-0.0031363054,
-0.0407777764,
0.0112589374,
-0.0277413148,
0.036287915,
0.00630457,
0.005258373,
-0.0392129906,
0.033174932,
0.0158385802,
-0.0445181988,
-0.0336229987,
-0.0448214449,
0.0127314245,
-0.0018354132,
-0.0318721905,
0.0081016636,
0.0098528666,
0.0256926212,
-0.014423769,
-0.008350837,
0.0277074166,
0.0303899478,
0.0096087931,
-0.0245683789,
-0.0558574423,
0.023188699,
0.0248192772,
0.0134936795,
-0.002256298,
-0.0067177382,
-0.0322764404,
0.0506817922,
-0.0051519684,
-0.04913361,
0.0602082051,
-0.0114145763,
-0.0814220309,
-0.0602624565,
-0.0933824927,
0.0461341627,
-0.0060968399,
0.0206086375,
-0.0163464919,
0.0243286882,
0.0017643084,
-0.069282271,
0.0420277677,
-0.0053039836,
0.0346291885,
-0.0792069286,
-0.0368675515,
0.0403260402,
0.0072050937,
-0.0290705077,
-0.0114497216,
-0.0082560163,
-0.0405044556,
0.0294306315,
0.0348078981,
0.0191884749,
-0.0010573464,
-0.0025178569,
-0.0858159065,
0.010471629,
0.0177560877,
-0.0301576369,
0.0000598254,
0.0260870475,
0.009820709,
-0.0207168292,
0.0124257682,
-0.0096323108,
0.0599457473,
-0.0215177201,
0.0179539789,
-0.0141008925,
0.0162577368,
-0.0391233265,
-0.0266539697,
0.0561495274,
-0.0826101005,
-0.0367603637,
-0.0607979186,
0.009988022,
0.0256197378,
0.0053010024,
-0.0033512188,
-0.044677522,
0.066766873,
0.0028176957,
-0.0307886004,
0.0860395432,
-0.0189755224,
0.0122132562,
0.0052367146,
0.0527138487,
0.0860864148,
0.0386547036,
-0.0215880387,
-0.0036135369,
0.0007725017,
0.0018997996,
0.0081351073,
0.0299821813,
-0.0224285983,
0.0073458781,
-0.0174957514,
-0.0071321498,
0.0237982683,
0.016677808,
0.0069208983,
0.045653142,
-0.03575214,
0.0096320976,
0.0424871407,
-0.050079301,
0.0799881443,
0.0150038647,
-0.0020473488,
-0.0246156584,
0.0066222628,
-0.0324799232,
-0.0388539471,
0.0276075937,
0.0134034716,
-0.0102756703,
0.042160403,
0.035380464,
0.0683396757,
0.0373693481,
0.0397381634,
-0.0032513903,
-0.0249155313,
-0.0204782821,
0.024821382,
0.0059769014,
-0.0240762774,
0.0175123233,
-0.0631254762,
-0.0502439216,
0.0262789521,
0.0089764968,
-0.0000358228,
0.0301259588,
0.011047286,
0.0063373297,
0.0044349814,
0.0090519609,
-0.0452920645,
-0.0231595747,
0.0112548731,
0.0119290026,
0.0393722542,
-6.064930777e-33,
-0.0413986854,
-0.0028472603,
0.0042807269,
0.0290438943,
0.0286674574,
-0.0135124326,
-0.0406974778,
0.01255883,
-0.0227355659,
-0.0235941354,
-0.0315340906,
-0.0068944125,
0.039224714,
0.0204619244,
0.0134775061,
0.0201811548,
0.0610785708,
0.0364157744,
-0.0303492881,
0.0002632982,
0.0512385592,
0.0718324408,
0.0685529113,
-0.0410378538,
0.0516383536,
0.0013792248,
-0.0310836211,
-0.0147604868,
0.0539180525,
0.0595039763,
-0.0566979535,
-0.0060465848,
0.0140706487,
-0.004473493,
0.0288911257,
0.0312267654,
-0.1195878834,
-0.0164025351,
0.0117624449,
0.0356173776,
0.011963916,
-0.0309005026,
0.0206061788,
0.0259468686,
0.0122358818,
0.0215181354,
0.0271868706,
-0.0293828119,
-0.0089121172,
-0.0255099591,
-0.0805634707,
0.0576036088,
0.0140726445,
0.0058781919,
0.0479859039,
0.0059815673,
-0.004482517,
-0.0315424576,
-0.0310278963,
-0.0165572371,
0.0312452335,
0.0501568504,
0.0549020916,
0.0491106585,
-0.0690674335,
0.0486740172,
0.0389940329,
-0.0410469994,
0.023307858,
0.063550882,
0.0612558238,
-0.0116605107,
0.0296679046,
0.0582073405,
0.0206686873,
-0.0562971272,
-0.1040498167,
0.0413453057,
-0.0045316606,
0.0192135219,
-0.0291224048,
-0.0179266073,
-0.0457342565,
-0.0284707248,
-0.0174781214,
-0.0338397324,
-0.0287612528,
-0.004021775,
0.05906073,
0.0071854601,
-0.0574921221,
0.0878573507,
0.0205309857,
-0.0121660559,
-0.05805948,
-0.0211203266,
0.0072097019,
0.0721064359,
0.0065210802,
0.0116093541,
-0.0872343481,
-0.0402723067,
-0.0147077655,
0.02001445,
-0.002300109,
-0.0380592719,
0.0314773023,
0.0171030145,
-0.0923779756,
0.0465482026,
-0.0072822538,
0.0551283807,
-0.0348357968,
0.0640196055,
-0.0098429089,
-0.0174290817,
-0.0096392985,
-0.0168583822,
0.0420391746,
-0.0337715968,
-0.0401565507,
0.0156830046,
0.0082491506,
0.017420087,
-0.0244599152,
0.0139884008,
-0.0000279698,
0.0485494062,
0.0351360627,
-0.0282692518,
0.0300947987,
-0.0042443625,
2.662e-7,
0.0176241137,
0.0425109379,
0.0331784338,
-0.0160872992,
-0.0102765961,
0.0141004417,
-0.0054682414,
0.031196855,
-0.0191388819,
0.0185674857,
-0.0474446453,
-0.0051102121,
0.0446156599,
0.062767379,
-0.1164376885,
0.0225152709,
-0.0104274834,
-0.0017511083,
-0.0796453953,
-0.0219183788,
-0.0453275554,
0.1328083873,
-0.0139356758,
-0.0241459962,
-0.0523503162,
-0.0210136995,
0.0654984638,
-0.0129522309,
-0.030030271,
0.0072861924,
0.0354782641,
0.1084948629,
0.0053988728,
-0.0387938134,
-0.0426927768,
0.0304439645,
0.0182631351,
0.0672584847,
-0.0385392532,
0.0268486142,
0.0028490361,
0.0028281889,
-0.0495797843,
-0.0458896384,
0.0711888,
0.0537010357,
-0.0140746022,
-0.0094702374,
-0.0104993135,
0.0018330014,
0.0112009943,
-0.0477697626,
-0.0473971628,
0.0289259031,
0.0214024205,
-0.0723788291,
-0.0095478762,
-0.0222912114,
-0.0399560072,
-0.0139146438,
-0.0069913571,
0.0056288498,
-0.0292635392,
0.0192456972,
-0.0172635615,
-0.0485215522,
0.0357600339,
2.418044455e-34,
0.0152786169,
0.0026333423,
-0.0219268985,
0.0462785065,
-0.0174420401,
-0.0235478338,
-0.0102208611,
0.018134471,
-0.0082009733,
-0.0259255152,
0.0270444956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09139v1 | The Consensus Game: Language Model Generation via Equilibrium Search | 2023-10-13T14:27:21 | 2023-10-13T14:27:21 | Athul Paul Jacob, Yikang Shen, Gabriele Farina, Jacob Andreas | cs.GT | cs.GT, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | When applied to question answering and other text generation tasks, language
models (LMs) may be queried generatively (by sampling answers from their output
distribution) or discriminatively (by using them to score or rank a set of
candidate outputs). These procedures sometimes yield very different
predictions. How do we reconcile mutually incompatible scoring procedures to
obtain coherent LM predictions? We introduce a new, a training-free,
game-theoretic procedure for language model decoding. Our approach casts
language model decoding as a regularized imperfect-information sequential
signaling game - which we term the CONSENSUS GAME - in which a GENERATOR seeks
to communicate an abstract correctness parameter using natural language
sentences to a DISCRIMINATOR. We develop computational procedures for finding
approximate equilibria of this game, resulting in a decoding algorithm we call
EQUILIBRIUM-RANKING. Applied to a large number of tasks (including reading
comprehension, commonsense reasoning, mathematical problem-solving, and
dialog), EQUILIBRIUM-RANKING consistently, and sometimes substantially,
improves performance over existing LM decoding procedures - on multiple
benchmarks, we observe that applying EQUILIBRIUM-RANKING to LLaMA-7B
outperforms the much larger LLaMA-65B and PaLM-540B models. These results
highlight the promise of game-theoretic tools for addressing fundamental
challenges of truthfulness and consistency in LMs. | [
0.0578308478,
0.0906565413,
-0.000171559,
0.044068262,
-0.0305191502,
-0.0111799957,
-0.0251261834,
-0.0147010116,
0.0003077474,
-0.0430254228,
0.0031958485,
-0.0218309667,
0.0229164399,
-0.0085384147,
0.0228102095,
-0.0121992473,
0.0301299132,
-0.0136283962,
0.0112241982,
-0.008041082,
0.0161351636,
0.0025487503,
-0.0024771891,
0.0583589561,
0.0000360068,
-0.0011912498,
0.0006235684,
-0.0182888508,
0.0185042918,
0.004725433,
0.0155862924,
0.0529680774,
0.0086634355,
0.0098249754,
0.0000021338,
-0.0243542921,
-0.0065407478,
-0.0321208425,
-0.0193300936,
-0.0052910214,
0.0198343154,
-0.0371996202,
0.0313966535,
0.0270053353,
-0.0427385941,
0.004748222,
0.0347833186,
0.0125986077,
0.0885518193,
0.0531685054,
0.0253460389,
-0.0321690701,
0.0338244103,
-0.0183031224,
-0.0004584671,
-0.0669825003,
0.0116649307,
0.0620968454,
0.0080902437,
0.0263308361,
-0.0167836174,
0.068930462,
0.0167774223,
-0.0005497593,
-0.0041736937,
0.0604629591,
-0.0037937784,
-0.0095279422,
-0.0023874745,
0.0738470256,
0.0142103042,
-0.0607625991,
0.0203660466,
-0.0055428804,
0.0067455699,
0.0176917389,
-0.0291991122,
0.0601166412,
-0.0054405276,
0.0399724878,
0.0832379833,
0.015032961,
0.0281210598,
0.0194491688,
0.0046009221,
0.0913119316,
-0.0072826627,
-0.0325929374,
-0.0289985836,
0.0272624381,
-0.0730109438,
-0.0696146041,
0.0209087189,
0.0402372815,
-0.0403872579,
0.0373260491,
-0.0555018522,
-0.0381654873,
0.0099417334,
-0.0277517755,
0.0155289788,
0.0435189269,
0.0422685072,
0.016619388,
0.0260512102,
0.0687652081,
-0.0002294571,
0.0069956426,
-0.0842003524,
-0.0029088624,
-0.0029953625,
-0.0506826825,
-0.0147170741,
0.0453970954,
-0.0318565704,
-0.0171154309,
-0.0341734961,
0.0184329133,
0.0054772464,
0.0054651988,
0.0266120117,
0.0408965312,
-0.0357537717,
-0.0056711193,
-0.0190195404,
0.01576427,
-0.0281463806,
0.0322629735,
0.0283101797,
-0.0707514957,
-0.0316972546,
0.018384207,
-0.0097206803,
-0.0096139228,
-0.0117622828,
0.0405547433,
-0.041090928,
0.013847284,
0.0071639004,
-0.0385150015,
-0.0119321169,
-0.0540435836,
-0.0241571851,
-0.0639389381,
0.0569976009,
0.0210728049,
0.0013755205,
-0.02899771,
0.016367089,
0.0291545242,
-0.0106151477,
0.0421036445,
0.0249820016,
0.0067923297,
0.0588207655,
0.00901864,
0.0105348779,
0.0741731972,
0.0315348916,
-0.0042291824,
0.0324897766,
0.021960238,
0.0065925634,
0.040655829,
0.0211016275,
-0.0157274399,
0.0353758708,
0.0173449684,
-0.0084367953,
0.0425356589,
0.0153174791,
0.0407193229,
-0.0619322397,
-0.0481447875,
0.0606338233,
0.0528532527,
-0.0150723327,
-0.0082154591,
0.0128236962,
0.0096658636,
-0.0056666145,
0.0355009101,
-0.0032808057,
0.0043610986,
-0.0629343465,
0.0212232154,
0.0277915802,
0.0010936739,
-0.0083630811,
-0.0534037501,
-0.0127829015,
-0.0103477463,
-0.0173596237,
0.0238706768,
0.0054294406,
-0.0066071716,
-0.0400385298,
0.0835147798,
-0.002743182,
-0.0378442109,
0.0330591314,
-0.0358336829,
0.0533011444,
0.0401155613,
0.0767268762,
0.0033728615,
-0.0428966098,
0.0049127964,
0.0000756858,
0.0721828416,
0.0290585756,
-0.0279618073,
0.0044386028,
-0.0652587488,
-0.0011055891,
0.0123368995,
0.0234377682,
0.0031999603,
0.0000156108,
0.0043650023,
0.0290539321,
-0.0354506001,
-0.0053766179,
0.0458780341,
-0.0384061523,
-0.0489385761,
0.0113209747,
-0.0191014428,
0.0378586799,
-0.0151043972,
-0.0092824874,
0.0437402837,
0.0234115925,
-0.0544571206,
-0.0078315409,
0.0232008379,
-0.0620274842,
-0.0667994991,
0.0185589679,
-0.0119657423,
0.0066423798,
0.0503043756,
-0.0406047888,
-0.0338551253,
0.0151641304,
-0.0449415818,
-0.0251849201,
-0.0417707972,
-0.0113324272,
0.0208114609,
-0.0178056844,
-0.0700126141,
0.0833075121,
-0.0429883189,
0.0187688842,
0.0100029837,
-0.0415972732,
-0.0006669122,
-0.0747644454,
0.0106895482,
0.0237807631,
-0.004848693,
0.0167908818,
0.0338850655,
0.0210489426,
-0.0126056047,
-0.0542530194,
-0.067563504,
0.0126573537,
-0.0173331778,
0.032154277,
0.0480983555,
-0.0309073534,
0.0174505766,
0.0162945054,
-0.0573556274,
-0.002745819,
0.0791215226,
-0.0146113755,
0.0443082824,
0.0187410321,
-0.0079291556,
-0.0431177206,
-0.0124333212,
-0.0136050433,
0.0581663251,
0.0199725591,
0.0158230327,
-0.0937552452,
0.0194072016,
-0.0567617752,
0.000081113,
-0.0096251704,
-0.0253113136,
0.010618872,
0.0058929445,
0.0251014885,
0.0461453348,
0.0297933724,
0.0298059843,
0.0380720049,
0.0087872166,
-0.0805498436,
-0.0064368737,
-0.0360715501,
-0.0074358308,
-0.0239044689,
-0.098422125,
0.0482739322,
0.1065253094,
0.0455006659,
-0.0095403222,
-0.0763209984,
0.0190835726,
-0.0210238434,
-0.0507233366,
-0.0551999137,
-0.0176831353,
0.0051583704,
0.0401895158,
-0.036117658,
-0.0412800349,
0.0848149285,
-0.039149303,
0.0323709324,
-0.0615491942,
0.0092732236,
-0.0342032015,
-0.0013847203,
0.0047826427,
0.0149324732,
0.0111647574,
-0.0164938271,
-0.0391914546,
-0.0063742553,
0.0525620207,
-0.0662543178,
0.0257932674,
-0.065288417,
0.0170805957,
-0.0156538505,
-0.0600943044,
-0.0571350753,
-0.0410304368,
-0.0159570668,
0.0121265957,
0.0510943793,
0.033776287,
-0.0264371019,
0.0082649756,
0.0126138087,
-0.0027468475,
-0.0196634047,
0.0016431478,
-0.0205684584,
0.1010183245,
0.0750319585,
0.0356819928,
0.0488182046,
-0.0461501107,
-0.0064352131,
0.0633061528,
0.0228893999,
0.0263255183,
0.0016637598,
-0.0148287602,
0.0480971485,
-0.0207014438,
-0.0206618588,
0.0238942355,
0.0141951088,
-0.033186581,
-0.0514252782,
0.1159879565,
0.0525250658,
-0.0022933867,
0.006429804,
-0.0185050927,
0.0610069223,
-0.0174889416,
0.0214985143,
-0.0867307559,
-0.0355102345,
0.0037437771,
0.0328109898,
-0.0101759341,
-0.0306078475,
-0.0146259284,
-0.0864821374,
0.0089252181,
0.0280592423,
-0.0335518271,
-0.0155983036,
-0.0109934695,
-0.025318604,
-0.0156464912,
-0.0115978429,
0.0429447629,
0.0407141298,
0.0413585901,
0.0326453336,
0.0207922813,
-0.0355709605,
-0.0200483818,
-0.019711215,
0.0435973555,
0.0621623881,
0.0310147349,
0.0109982789,
-0.034091983,
0.0433391482,
-0.0292633958,
-0.0335851163,
-0.0221999213,
-0.00539453,
-0.0337642357,
0.0109350365,
-0.0269268844,
0.0271844622,
-0.0434774682,
-0.00623105,
0.0024847635,
0.0499993265,
0.0031575644,
-0.0257647596,
-0.0034885879,
0.0337643102,
0.0061624055,
0.089249745,
0.0212275572,
-0.0287413802,
-0.0181633793,
-0.0416387655,
0.060264077,
-0.0771271512,
-0.0319623984,
-0.0038274378,
0.0912614018,
0.0235283226,
-0.101140514,
-0.0447876528,
-0.0227961391,
0.0005775966,
-0.0089801485,
0.0031050823,
0.0303667765,
-0.0183910578,
-0.0149837248,
-0.0041449796,
-0.0392915346,
-0.0246440936,
-0.0431221761,
0.005845909,
0.0033162907,
-0.0560485497,
-0.0413382053,
0.0443297885,
-0.0741704404,
-0.0742817074,
-0.0366730131,
0.0509922244,
0.0181676727,
0.0069628716,
-0.0028388372,
-0.0475631766,
0.0017265935,
0.0458456911,
-0.0114512946,
0.0396804102,
-0.0015415343,
-0.0246884916,
0.0098411972,
0.0435756408,
-0.03460126,
-0.0138490945,
-0.0132243102,
0.080569379,
-0.0095187658,
-0.0662339404,
0.05600648,
0.0258970093,
-0.0418567508,
-0.0204069857,
0.0044728345,
-0.0300978422,
0.0120587172,
-0.0054322788,
-0.0382678062,
-0.0336944833,
0.0051984116,
0.0347790048,
-0.0284361113,
0.0085520158,
0.0002572447,
0.0237379763,
0.0774698332,
-0.0215557665,
-0.0308369808,
-0.0046957475,
-0.0110598942,
0.0012942856,
-0.039691221,
-0.0259903111,
0.0004280476,
-0.043904677,
0.0640648976,
-0.0007488375,
0.0359340012,
0.0284007043,
-0.0269596037,
0.0131673329,
0.0192629471,
-0.0398763902,
-0.0258210152,
-0.0194928721,
0.0415334105,
0.0508188866,
0.0285084061,
0.047331553,
-0.0273070298,
-0.0076197907,
-0.0172552671,
-0.0008849984,
0.0213728789,
-0.0314421356,
0.0450173505,
0.0217993688,
-0.0062851384,
-0.0340101011,
0.1115087569,
0.0098774508,
0.0245213825,
-0.0102076,
-0.0161951371,
-0.0417480767,
-0.0330464989,
-0.028243605,
0.0089857616,
-0.0328476764,
0.0076080081,
-0.031223055,
-0.0358096361,
-0.0047977492,
0.0488946885,
-0.0006160008,
-0.0149044376,
0.0215725992,
0.0748546496,
-0.010614234,
-0.035871245,
-0.0451888964,
0.0357173011,
-0.0864697844,
-0.0134632923,
-0.0537993945,
-6.776107063e-33,
-0.0478389859,
-0.0333744697,
0.0201768968,
-0.0298953634,
0.0061865929,
-0.0098614497,
-0.0431056693,
-0.0148069104,
-0.0105425091,
0.0049125431,
0.0039513139,
0.0059092441,
-0.0031032751,
0.0360869616,
-0.0264882538,
-0.0298270397,
0.0083411448,
-0.0170262903,
-0.0722244903,
0.0079523129,
0.0341567211,
-0.0095085651,
0.0298187267,
-0.0074376166,
0.0094444118,
-0.0403382219,
0.0009513655,
0.0484109968,
-0.0445025973,
0.0512892678,
-0.0367341936,
0.0193162356,
0.0363742821,
-0.0428045243,
0.0003381619,
0.0205318294,
-0.0605188906,
-0.0145377442,
0.0590460859,
-0.0123796696,
-0.0476570353,
-0.0355865173,
0.0156183299,
-0.0117379492,
-0.019863667,
0.0124477306,
0.0008366208,
-0.0277048852,
-0.0152578084,
-0.0200557131,
-0.0083127962,
0.0158161372,
-0.0195985232,
-0.0198046472,
-0.0069266628,
0.0791304186,
-0.0227605384,
0.0345878042,
-0.030162083,
0.0289360713,
0.0511964485,
0.0463750623,
0.074668698,
0.0275807902,
0.0046505728,
0.0539622307,
-0.0223407075,
-0.035272114,
-0.040906325,
-0.0267067458,
-0.0222596787,
-0.0004779698,
0.035893824,
0.0261724703,
0.006931283,
-0.0027261584,
-0.0722520873,
0.025684718,
0.0168097056,
-0.0131144589,
0.0300974119,
-0.0054261191,
-0.0470730588,
-0.0266917348,
-0.0624600388,
-0.0087384004,
-0.0231969617,
-0.0112023149,
0.0545924827,
0.0243404657,
-0.0384018533,
-0.025977632,
0.0413153358,
-0.0293558259,
-0.0099478438,
0.0542365909,
-0.004419574,
0.0042030499,
-0.0079681287,
0.0255489238,
-0.0707317963,
0.0221795682,
0.0142167509,
-0.0037512907,
-0.0132253934,
0.0408527926,
-0.0196447857,
-0.0180729888,
0.0032393138,
0.0240921788,
-0.0511415042,
0.0307115801,
-0.0328633711,
-0.0105569949,
0.0511119664,
0.0067577576,
-0.0136057753,
0.0044998471,
0.0055700894,
0.0005839297,
-0.0180017911,
0.0358167402,
-0.0311011635,
0.0282487385,
-0.0116508892,
0.0210812762,
-0.0182222351,
0.04070016,
-0.0194104631,
-0.0299934726,
-0.0065465248,
0.0280830376,
2.772e-7,
0.0389761776,
0.0388906449,
0.0181526579,
0.0272542387,
0.0030359088,
0.0432203859,
-0.0012947582,
0.0238186009,
0.0340529867,
-0.0525640771,
-0.0036051502,
0.0324319303,
0.0423616208,
0.0353243761,
-0.0594715811,
-0.0086608371,
-0.0638553128,
0.0013770747,
-0.0059008729,
-0.0656482503,
0.0666381344,
0.0667510852,
-0.046111308,
0.0114385169,
-0.0032101537,
-0.0352176651,
0.0771539584,
-0.024402909,
-0.040703401,
0.034207385,
0.0535026751,
-0.0519609973,
0.0244058296,
0.0238534827,
0.0005007723,
0.0037144152,
0.0037512966,
0.0557396598,
0.019421069,
-0.0446778908,
-0.0455849245,
-0.0206281468,
0.0066275978,
-0.0810500011,
0.065546155,
-0.0537756346,
-0.0257406794,
-0.028449798,
-0.0298501402,
-0.0199591536,
0.0051670196,
-0.0220941938,
-0.0409501642,
0.0232936293,
0.0181094892,
0.0108804721,
0.0134472586,
-0.0128537845,
-0.0376512595,
0.0082660401,
-0.059326604,
-0.024185136,
-0.0429346487,
0.0047702733,
0.0009691551,
-0.0798897296,
0.0046275994,
2.625755455e-34,
0.0096353572,
-0.0024253072,
0.0264099054,
0.0390311927,
0.0356793739,
-0.0035736628,
-0.0000720943,
0.0260479208,
0.0332319662,
-0.076352872,
-0.0196228735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09135v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09135v2 | HierarchicalContrast: A Coarse-to-Fine Contrastive Learning Framework for Cross-Domain Zero-Shot Slot Filling | 2023-10-13T14:23:33 | 2023-10-20T11:29:53 | Junwen Zhang, Yin Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2; I.2.7 | In task-oriented dialogue scenarios, cross-domain zero-shot slot filling
plays a vital role in leveraging source domain knowledge to learn a model with
high generalization ability in unknown target domain where annotated data is
unavailable. However, the existing state-of-the-art zero-shot slot filling
methods have limited generalization ability in target domain, they only show
effective knowledge transfer on seen slots and perform poorly on unseen slots.
To alleviate this issue, we present a novel Hierarchical Contrastive Learning
Framework (HiCL) for zero-shot slot filling. Specifically, we propose a coarse-
to fine-grained contrastive learning based on Gaussian-distributed embedding to
learn the generalized deep semantic relations between utterance-tokens, by
optimizing inter- and intra-token distribution distance. This encourages HiCL
to generalize to the slot types unseen at training phase. Furthermore, we
present a new iterative label set semantics inference method to unbiasedly and
separately evaluate the performance of unseen slot types which entangled with
their counterparts (i.e., seen slot types) in the previous zero-shot slot
filling evaluation methods. The extensive empirical experiments on four
datasets demonstrate that the proposed method achieves comparable or even
better performance than the current state-of-the-art zero-shot slot filling
approaches. | [
0.016025776,
0.0660279989,
0.0179494936,
0.0225520115,
-0.0116357962,
0.0135814361,
-0.004040448,
-0.0241818465,
-0.0416994207,
-0.0631490946,
-0.0310857762,
-0.0376515388,
0.0161101017,
0.0453054942,
0.0203785095,
-0.0551391952,
0.0148296589,
-0.0055899774,
0.0020131622,
0.0366972312,
-0.0162766576,
-0.0014431977,
-0.0657541454,
0.0547885634,
-0.0155866975,
-0.0349199697,
-0.0231104251,
0.0263224207,
0.0261390414,
-0.02222481,
0.026106108,
0.0304697957,
0.027163947,
0.0169095434,
0.0000021036,
-0.0296450015,
-0.0010083973,
-0.0316207446,
-0.0568012632,
-0.0215292778,
-0.0090361154,
-0.0146833789,
-0.0182524174,
0.0140364058,
-0.0120563312,
-0.0686808079,
0.0479962006,
0.0648122653,
0.0205361322,
0.0426771231,
-0.0283806976,
-0.0298547484,
0.0153005011,
-0.0416658446,
0.0284055248,
-0.0761158764,
0.0202618577,
0.0056935265,
-0.0106448298,
0.0176313147,
-0.0150524415,
0.0121436147,
0.0364889316,
-0.0240905043,
0.0285128579,
0.0254668687,
-0.0731909871,
0.0213981587,
-0.0138367657,
0.1187912896,
0.003997677,
0.0172587335,
-0.0189713165,
-0.0357358344,
0.0100020142,
-0.0295419693,
-0.0348008126,
-0.0073616151,
-0.0035071461,
0.0030413663,
-0.0034790817,
0.0241006538,
-0.0007111774,
-0.0070074638,
-0.0036113148,
0.0250438247,
0.0097754514,
-0.0341332927,
-0.0134498579,
-0.0221479516,
-0.007105703,
-0.0666269287,
-0.0277425777,
0.0188042279,
-0.0626342818,
0.0051992009,
-0.0513543226,
0.0045488221,
0.0039349482,
0.0369341224,
0.0299190562,
0.0524656959,
-0.0664161518,
0.0521162674,
-0.0087903123,
0.0195346233,
-0.0353273302,
-0.0098548122,
-0.0363046154,
-0.0178137105,
-0.0593856573,
-0.009577658,
-0.0218459833,
0.0256447513,
-0.0287792124,
-0.0391249098,
-0.0201491956,
0.014843828,
-0.015193738,
0.0393356346,
0.0091876704,
0.0202087499,
-0.044921767,
0.0009852112,
-0.0325983837,
0.072083734,
-0.0235913191,
0.0324945338,
-0.0022014829,
-0.0193272438,
-0.0353153571,
0.0239232648,
-0.0034650259,
-0.0383205861,
-0.0090411212,
0.0850092396,
-0.0148469713,
-0.0136512844,
-0.037696939,
0.0168780927,
-0.0161286015,
-0.0701059476,
-0.011252095,
-0.0405335985,
0.0273658708,
-0.0007666984,
0.0082150828,
0.0002809295,
0.0038656557,
0.0075674974,
-0.0232356098,
0.0757265463,
0.0019633221,
-0.0390836,
0.0170960575,
0.0022788534,
-0.0132841226,
0.065764904,
0.0195091106,
0.0093967421,
-0.0170951281,
0.0029867019,
0.0113656055,
-0.0021966395,
0.0145846056,
-0.0145422313,
-0.0007452518,
0.0172575619,
0.0392347611,
0.0327223428,
0.0483739004,
0.0139738545,
-0.064178355,
-0.0284527969,
0.0142265353,
0.0404061116,
0.0217695143,
-0.0426344015,
0.0611934997,
0.0409722887,
-0.0328150094,
0.0229227897,
-0.0329988375,
0.0427956395,
0.0404191203,
0.0032888909,
0.0560883619,
-0.0147598172,
-0.0378345139,
-0.0235076007,
0.0071012629,
-0.028669944,
0.003563927,
-0.0316407196,
0.050838802,
0.010815599,
-0.0732848123,
0.055491332,
0.0530837923,
0.0160772577,
-0.0318993106,
-0.0129473787,
-0.0147982333,
0.0453542694,
-0.001581414,
-0.0435657725,
-0.0714116618,
-0.0675628409,
0.0141920615,
0.0354756154,
-0.0234135669,
-0.0153848538,
0.0628037974,
-0.058361996,
-0.0457596369,
-0.03999459,
0.0057266387,
0.0369851217,
-0.0228488222,
0.0126965623,
0.016991239,
-0.0081610903,
0.0854670107,
-0.0140454406,
0.0114413351,
-0.0210412107,
0.0471200943,
0.0404423289,
0.0232969038,
0.0216284003,
-0.0191507097,
-0.0427273847,
-0.0106611736,
-0.0318148583,
-0.0334035344,
-0.0175620206,
-0.0823245943,
-0.0336699672,
0.0325593241,
-0.0539355986,
-0.0243237279,
0.0018235709,
-0.0572134629,
-0.0451439694,
0.0388264209,
0.0221805498,
0.0230460111,
-0.0390539579,
-0.015794564,
0.0426221713,
0.020936491,
-0.0057111559,
0.0676927045,
0.0115020098,
-0.0084473593,
0.0573779717,
0.0332447588,
0.0532954745,
-0.0430168733,
0.0194465108,
-0.0100981528,
-0.0577106103,
-0.0053393566,
-0.0262176786,
0.0027759299,
-0.0518420748,
-0.000518751,
-0.0800575987,
0.0317835473,
0.023557663,
-0.0116305845,
0.0102931131,
-0.010750697,
0.0105140982,
-0.0158128086,
-0.0228027347,
-0.0240416788,
-0.0236922074,
-0.0164750107,
0.0229277574,
0.0101745659,
-0.002840498,
-0.0195136815,
0.0524160564,
-0.0210950114,
0.0225373749,
-0.0477779545,
0.0051841768,
-0.0060967859,
0.0261348654,
0.0081120525,
0.0241026096,
-0.0031315521,
-0.0382468179,
0.0100534447,
0.0423174202,
-0.0446505882,
0.0774183944,
-0.037038289,
0.0018294861,
-0.0161357075,
-0.0258494578,
-0.0364897847,
0.0511197075,
0.0243440438,
0.0171160903,
-0.0183094386,
0.0597236603,
-0.0331233405,
0.0691791624,
0.0209370442,
0.0460495874,
-0.0537983663,
-0.002723875,
-0.0008426187,
-0.0285941064,
-0.012760831,
0.0116800144,
-0.0271156784,
0.001410622,
-0.0427587554,
0.0025410953,
0.0369312391,
-0.0237816274,
-0.0229933523,
-0.0293955673,
-0.0033273979,
-0.0316847302,
0.0187118165,
-0.021128295,
-0.009247615,
0.093282029,
-0.053602498,
-0.0239979569,
-0.019742351,
0.0031298737,
0.0163903143,
0.0058436571,
-0.008097305,
-0.0062350496,
-0.040039558,
-0.0669383034,
-0.046230562,
-0.0421858132,
-0.0395235047,
0.0445581973,
0.0016329585,
-0.0421627574,
-0.0430393778,
-0.0010365263,
0.0008836046,
0.0467832685,
0.0139706433,
-0.0039419541,
-0.0245232601,
0.0586373322,
0.0545796081,
0.0317216553,
-0.0535534024,
0.0377693698,
0.0451405309,
0.0395362675,
-0.0006679703,
0.0363604091,
-0.020441113,
0.0224880558,
0.016644137,
0.0190892164,
-0.0137356911,
-0.0103957886,
0.0430477336,
-0.0383911952,
0.0503238924,
0.1014789566,
0.0143214045,
-0.0194889978,
-0.0180388,
-0.0004356964,
0.0093697822,
0.0214479696,
0.0088502029,
-0.1552343965,
-0.0688435882,
0.0240575653,
-0.011310908,
0.0033174388,
-0.0342538245,
-0.0065988372,
-0.1304425746,
0.0432572924,
-0.0175952408,
-0.0855827332,
-0.0056479662,
-0.0111209443,
0.0538482964,
-0.0004186998,
0.0021861016,
-0.0300426651,
0.0130383102,
-0.0279892795,
0.0270800348,
0.015749881,
-0.0566302575,
0.02342695,
-0.0323068164,
0.0837394521,
0.0080604656,
0.0534732714,
0.0246044528,
0.0137454504,
-0.0161547381,
-0.0288923308,
-0.0243035201,
-0.0249413196,
0.0631933585,
-0.041079741,
-0.0323894694,
0.0228751302,
0.0472715348,
-0.0179086532,
-0.0320953019,
-0.0159174241,
0.0582098737,
0.0088536711,
0.0534409359,
-0.0173969865,
0.0013076491,
0.0705727115,
0.0735500604,
0.0305768475,
-0.0274807177,
-0.0054942803,
-0.0342023708,
-0.0098202331,
-0.0674537793,
0.0307105817,
0.0263749994,
0.0241693128,
-0.0248797499,
-0.0315106362,
-0.0292153563,
0.0514837876,
0.0348911583,
-0.0004322543,
0.0179220308,
-0.0136217438,
-0.0194980018,
-0.0371036418,
-0.0165398847,
-0.0256293807,
0.0240805447,
-0.0391060114,
-0.0370912217,
0.0406591892,
-0.0296092741,
-0.0309771951,
-0.0002118583,
-0.0553052388,
-0.0437129885,
-0.065093413,
0.0295049511,
0.0110901892,
0.0371998213,
-0.0194543377,
-0.0110324798,
0.048655495,
0.0314571485,
-0.0558433123,
-0.0262527373,
0.0586215816,
0.0250726901,
0.0157929324,
0.0273424871,
-0.055084303,
0.0120630031,
0.0303359106,
0.0219156872,
-0.0093199546,
-0.0217310749,
0.0090585547,
-0.0483310446,
0.0547305904,
0.0129133165,
0.01235874,
-0.0142360898,
0.0639359504,
-0.0397139192,
-0.0109381145,
-0.0618609935,
0.0049870377,
0.009086566,
0.0017370821,
0.0178397764,
-0.0277503915,
-0.0085904645,
0.0716679916,
-0.007898232,
-0.0180481654,
0.0535849892,
-0.0170100853,
-0.0046952073,
0.0077354801,
-0.0029630009,
-0.0068422365,
0.038999036,
0.0366642661,
0.0052027358,
0.0743502975,
0.0337287486,
-0.0030586882,
0.004274263,
0.0232569501,
-0.0030646238,
-0.021295378,
-0.0095127402,
-0.0167132467,
0.0476859622,
-0.0164986458,
-0.0188270584,
0.0112714758,
-0.0012583343,
0.0040054405,
0.0518975146,
-0.0273538381,
0.0052448516,
0.0283397455,
0.0234873649,
-0.029244015,
0.0370457023,
0.0769926831,
0.0168226119,
0.0398305878,
0.0023754502,
0.058793053,
-0.0437992886,
0.0143981706,
0.0367215164,
0.0601831116,
0.0148939034,
0.0460929573,
-0.0423345789,
-0.0687429979,
-0.006350867,
-0.0111384569,
-0.0242565461,
0.05884948,
0.0127104959,
0.0168311056,
-0.0083270436,
-0.0379342288,
-0.0095417369,
-0.0509467199,
0.0298724901,
-0.0231657792,
-0.0497993454,
-6.333813355e-33,
-0.0266311411,
0.0072348891,
-0.000685869,
0.0058434745,
-0.0081694396,
0.0132459207,
-0.0060789399,
-0.0170538742,
-0.0183287244,
0.0212223828,
0.0110748578,
0.0018141604,
0.0188172385,
0.0416043103,
0.0071269399,
-0.0163150765,
0.042634476,
0.0033732671,
-0.0151865957,
0.0023029784,
0.0239745937,
0.0275038704,
0.0503723882,
-0.0775615796,
-0.0245699398,
0.0221190955,
0.0074171429,
0.0580997095,
0.0463362522,
0.0513285622,
-0.0088859247,
0.0193071198,
0.0037502197,
-0.0767460614,
0.0167696141,
0.0439261794,
-0.0960791707,
-0.0357853174,
0.0334140994,
0.0018510198,
0.0078858426,
-0.0306502897,
-0.0285527129,
0.0213018656,
0.0263938084,
-0.0621932521,
0.0085383542,
-0.0133873504,
-0.0003288717,
-0.0152539378,
-0.0766352341,
0.0277781766,
-0.0296844523,
-0.0871665478,
0.0080500524,
0.0620272718,
0.0302117765,
-0.0178492405,
-0.0705486163,
-0.0085709915,
-0.0436013155,
0.0053705121,
0.0281493012,
0.024093844,
0.0030315276,
0.0697701648,
0.0302962773,
0.001553787,
0.0108907027,
-0.0408240557,
-0.0211107172,
0.0270038806,
-0.0356833525,
0.0328870453,
0.0676414296,
0.0165112782,
-0.0632688403,
0.0082478896,
-0.0263222996,
0.066706419,
-0.0174900535,
0.0468855351,
-0.0466486253,
-0.009516336,
-0.011024273,
-0.0223869774,
-0.0320464224,
-0.0499701723,
0.0429218635,
-0.0065075764,
-0.0013275665,
0.0279160477,
0.0632311478,
-0.0373533741,
-0.0175594259,
0.0474847332,
0.0085250037,
0.0135595882,
-0.0076484042,
-0.0091401683,
-0.062761046,
-0.0561091453,
0.0674112141,
0.0462841541,
0.0465196818,
0.0045852964,
0.0445979796,
0.0162872486,
-0.0537263937,
-0.0065450766,
-0.0262235273,
0.0159293823,
-0.02361417,
0.0582422726,
0.0104871308,
0.0337487422,
-0.0216233749,
0.0790091753,
0.0017845799,
-0.021060396,
-0.0068794116,
0.0008187761,
0.0005650131,
0.0062693544,
-0.0121047813,
-0.0049691843,
-0.0041228351,
-0.0314152576,
0.0138694625,
-0.0384642556,
0.0065349387,
-0.0164545029,
2.926e-7,
-0.0212366916,
0.0037857532,
0.0007802546,
-0.0129117193,
0.0217796899,
0.0698196217,
-0.0050652232,
0.0404362939,
0.0287574511,
-0.0387799144,
0.0087787434,
0.0109671885,
0.0490522608,
0.0324690826,
-0.1413312107,
0.0292901713,
-0.0349423401,
-0.0377974771,
-0.034087956,
0.0224789698,
0.0663501397,
0.1037566513,
0.0286604222,
-0.0157011319,
0.0442857966,
-0.0271263272,
0.000729702,
0.0205258317,
-0.0060427957,
0.0067865476,
-0.0279563367,
0.0311374161,
-0.0102639413,
0.0814025402,
-0.0109127294,
0.0364579633,
0.0126482686,
0.0305175018,
-0.0005955462,
-0.0512458012,
-0.0357905813,
0.0020902681,
0.012066355,
-0.0320914909,
0.0727645829,
-0.1088450551,
-0.0366479829,
-0.0313371904,
-0.0580240712,
0.019094117,
0.0276592094,
0.0221459717,
0.004615128,
-0.0116105573,
0.0291972384,
-0.0095234588,
-0.0306311436,
-0.0667768046,
-0.0107856533,
0.0343454555,
-0.0343387537,
-0.0245560221,
0.0132958824,
-0.1016352102,
0.0291650686,
-0.0098981224,
0.0057704309,
2.301507736e-34,
0.0300134439,
-0.0194274522,
0.0389554016,
0.047225073,
0.0290447008,
-0.0023924934,
-0.0452693738,
-0.0086491797,
0.0336927138,
-0.0330063328,
0.0104730213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09119v1 | A Frustratingly Easy Plug-and-Play Detection-and-Reasoning Module for Chinese Spelling Check | 2023-10-13T14:03:01 | 2023-10-13T14:03:01 | Haojing Huang, Jingheng Ye, Qingyu Zhou, Yinghui Li, Yangning Li, Feng Zhou, Hai-Tao Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Chinese Spelling Check (CSC) has been greatly improved by
designing task-specific pre-training methods or introducing auxiliary tasks,
which mostly solve this task in an end-to-end fashion. In this paper, we
propose to decompose the CSC workflow into detection, reasoning, and searching
subtasks so that the rich external knowledge about the Chinese language can be
leveraged more directly and efficiently. Specifically, we design a
plug-and-play detection-and-reasoning module that is compatible with existing
SOTA non-autoregressive CSC models to further boost their performance. We find
that the detection-and-reasoning module trained for one model can also benefit
other models. We also study the primary interpretability provided by the task
decomposition. Extensive experiments and detailed analyses demonstrate the
effectiveness and competitiveness of the proposed module. | [
0.0319899991,
0.0011902876,
0.0211748276,
0.0061709643,
-0.0224307626,
0.0412213393,
0.0091479495,
-0.0010413518,
0.0554919206,
-0.0425365083,
-0.0295204464,
0.0069057718,
-0.000998435,
0.0459430516,
0.0226453729,
0.0080389222,
0.0630884096,
-0.0312126242,
0.007072432,
0.0129512837,
0.023467999,
-0.0097493092,
-0.0104426406,
0.0460516103,
0.001174613,
-0.0404264629,
-0.0169741791,
-0.0083884671,
0.0184738636,
-0.0053848736,
0.018383665,
0.0581322089,
0.0071590268,
0.0530721396,
0.0000021592,
-0.0384773165,
-0.0494408719,
0.0034096281,
-0.068122983,
0.0101372786,
-0.0068910103,
0.0160920676,
-0.0271866154,
0.0568113402,
-0.0293302797,
0.0155163119,
0.0442132503,
0.055832956,
0.0559630655,
0.0707539096,
-0.0057559838,
0.0055795959,
0.0145343617,
-0.0229588877,
0.004298077,
-0.0384311192,
0.0204502065,
0.0000954319,
0.0072836136,
-0.0370285362,
-0.0472178087,
0.0336978883,
-0.0003063017,
-0.0200818144,
0.0019085368,
-0.0036317063,
0.0316584781,
0.0041904226,
-0.0141188735,
0.0368097872,
-0.0412754864,
-0.0369350091,
0.0228608325,
0.0223722383,
-0.0338138975,
0.006142654,
-0.0090284636,
0.0056963451,
-0.0301409755,
-0.0030862917,
0.0865651593,
-0.0138012618,
0.0101134591,
0.0275531076,
-0.0215882249,
0.0596247688,
-0.0099058291,
-0.0524748489,
-0.0035322669,
0.0305162407,
0.0233821888,
-0.0623311773,
0.0503240339,
0.029626688,
-0.0479138233,
0.0010676237,
0.0095759165,
-0.0198731758,
-0.0328972638,
-0.0043372754,
0.0422302037,
0.0332111046,
-0.0380280018,
0.0365153924,
-0.0550552346,
0.0605239831,
-0.0122927343,
0.0151872514,
-0.0177729782,
-0.0137691051,
-0.0780409649,
-0.0161975343,
-0.0499201603,
0.0354832709,
-0.0129659912,
-0.0085827252,
-0.0511100069,
-0.0092647569,
-0.0325100049,
0.0143421683,
0.0523929633,
-0.023665335,
-0.0338250101,
-0.0196340997,
-0.0240906291,
0.0218228772,
-0.0133576086,
0.0089906473,
-0.0119972108,
-0.01260236,
-0.0158978757,
-0.0045579467,
0.047743611,
-0.0255980827,
0.0145977493,
0.008407644,
-0.0219983961,
-0.058459945,
-0.0584584437,
-0.0122596249,
-0.0179328229,
-0.055383414,
-0.0303302798,
-0.0154581051,
-0.0212153886,
-0.0232725088,
0.0377675965,
0.0051484704,
-0.00513128,
-0.0036221163,
0.0206755344,
0.1061129421,
-0.0065127141,
-0.0017207519,
-0.0251920708,
0.0003038359,
0.0251938757,
0.0723451599,
0.0018183703,
0.0218553916,
0.0463055111,
-0.003866425,
0.0467416644,
0.0158671886,
-0.0223442074,
-0.0194045622,
0.0154538574,
0.011443099,
-0.0325911269,
-0.0156747419,
0.0120749418,
0.0164984297,
-0.0085126488,
0.0617658757,
0.0361204259,
0.059145093,
0.0616023093,
-0.0168503895,
0.0144024678,
-0.0191079956,
-0.0075503425,
0.0177514479,
-0.0329788737,
0.0506754555,
-0.0738083348,
0.009183892,
-0.0081388941,
0.0110901073,
-0.052520372,
-0.0749706998,
-0.0291659385,
0.0003512925,
0.0234327558,
0.0700158849,
0.0618957952,
-0.0012398754,
-0.0228325743,
0.0238189735,
-0.0157117881,
-0.0559536591,
-0.000518692,
-0.1037865058,
0.0656562373,
0.0881530792,
0.0718317628,
-0.0174221937,
-0.0039116465,
-0.0083600152,
-0.030958686,
0.0457876325,
0.0115657942,
-0.0218530204,
-0.0073989341,
-0.0557397865,
-0.0498710386,
0.0411588289,
0.0312923864,
0.0003601313,
0.0566664524,
0.0083012618,
0.0124852862,
-0.0113827614,
-0.0565312654,
0.0179079808,
-0.0361426137,
-0.0294768717,
-0.0279371366,
0.0495833717,
-0.0174443051,
0.0163066927,
-0.0163685307,
0.0168915484,
-0.0310541019,
-0.0584619939,
-0.0167481583,
0.012109668,
-0.0227247421,
-0.0420890227,
0.01517196,
-0.0354039967,
-0.0252411906,
0.0635661259,
-0.0231161714,
-0.071464546,
0.0042670141,
-0.0402189977,
0.0141371954,
-0.0838259831,
0.0068006348,
0.0226584226,
0.0050173523,
-0.0032351865,
0.0709728375,
-0.0008345276,
0.0112662716,
-0.0198471267,
0.0079866918,
0.0214697383,
-0.0350964218,
-0.0610606447,
0.0042855171,
0.0002043933,
0.002031089,
0.0229308438,
0.0122725377,
-0.0211932939,
-0.0246397536,
-0.0582339913,
0.0009762384,
-0.0543943085,
0.0131849088,
0.0321359076,
0.0112931682,
0.0030233134,
-0.0147667816,
-0.025752075,
0.0484879427,
0.0179232173,
0.020558523,
0.0215745997,
-0.03099682,
-0.0034897584,
-0.0455933399,
-0.0210316032,
-0.029802056,
-0.0237239376,
0.0032044777,
-0.0607880913,
-0.0755210221,
0.0184313208,
-0.0192114413,
0.0341352746,
0.0005481613,
-0.0696494207,
0.0083140368,
-0.0415011048,
0.0293705352,
0.0873637572,
-0.0116640143,
-0.0048370347,
0.0469358787,
-0.0224208087,
-0.0174612608,
0.029243743,
0.0187147222,
0.0055275951,
0.0194680337,
-0.02691992,
0.0016208279,
0.1150590405,
-0.0258010328,
-0.046057567,
-0.0677615702,
-0.0466657095,
-0.0359716825,
-0.0092110857,
-0.0664980263,
-0.015171038,
-0.0087624621,
0.0383118987,
-0.0433281772,
-0.0367743671,
0.0820275322,
-0.0074107954,
-0.0144890789,
-0.0518727154,
-0.0262379795,
-0.0439970978,
0.0444991551,
-0.0346110798,
0.0069367005,
0.0106124245,
-0.0487171113,
-0.0382139198,
-0.0113432854,
0.0431345329,
-0.052614633,
0.0564726591,
-0.0396979563,
0.0482969992,
-0.0076022851,
-0.01338505,
-0.0151138688,
0.0117272781,
-0.0564161502,
0.0007424968,
0.0367262438,
-0.0190594681,
0.0335661247,
0.0728799328,
0.0136098433,
0.0783747435,
-0.005895189,
-0.0163800139,
-0.0150279198,
-0.0130914962,
0.0615717247,
0.0359295383,
0.0361646451,
-0.0376020595,
0.0660831258,
0.0404657125,
0.0233709179,
-0.0565773509,
0.0041244291,
0.008373322,
0.0403987579,
-0.0445927083,
0.0049868142,
0.0109322565,
0.0289464258,
-0.0782732666,
-0.0455128029,
0.0973303765,
0.030001387,
-0.0267576538,
-0.0200994723,
0.0173277184,
-0.0197359938,
0.0095765209,
0.0273509864,
-0.0621911995,
-0.0424138531,
0.0410796106,
0.0041625947,
0.0030983123,
-0.0494621359,
-0.0044634631,
-0.1054136157,
0.0619333945,
-0.0168881752,
0.0151015045,
-0.0417132787,
-0.0144136949,
-0.0242359545,
-0.0390229933,
-0.0222832263,
0.0127000278,
-0.0072293901,
-0.031032104,
0.0111957742,
-0.0317094624,
-0.0342941284,
0.036541637,
-0.04233272,
0.0163693111,
0.0860209391,
0.0171387177,
0.0343551934,
-0.0331386514,
0.0046595931,
-0.0141749494,
0.0074901469,
-0.0193460528,
0.035901282,
0.0363055095,
-0.0367984325,
-0.0328573026,
0.008864711,
-0.0412924364,
0.0228181351,
0.0112367338,
0.0699376464,
-0.0390086547,
-0.0088062165,
0.022071572,
-0.0088487808,
0.0198491365,
0.1154322997,
0.00214521,
-0.0216307975,
-0.0612484775,
-0.0187098961,
-0.0284089129,
-0.0794520304,
-0.0335931592,
0.0232937485,
-0.0429203212,
-0.0324799418,
-0.0778447017,
-0.0540913269,
0.0217632856,
0.0549557284,
-0.0115153762,
0.0186382532,
0.0041154455,
0.0305329654,
-0.0503142849,
0.0004504034,
-0.0262789987,
0.0273764841,
-0.0488515832,
0.0130299916,
-0.0043371138,
-0.0284225363,
-0.0007638182,
0.0042126165,
-0.081852451,
-0.020950187,
0.0254451446,
0.0150016993,
0.027690798,
0.0343190096,
-0.0446491688,
-0.0284278113,
0.0272973869,
-0.0211226959,
-0.0090218605,
-0.0175950322,
0.0338068083,
-0.0546154678,
-0.0014077199,
0.0409778878,
-0.0225657504,
0.0233482439,
-0.0145488922,
0.0534300953,
-0.0376216806,
0.0402804688,
0.0432962775,
0.0140743507,
0.0626143292,
-0.0157002863,
-0.0043606209,
-0.0893844962,
0.0114503754,
0.0038005349,
-0.029756004,
-0.0338119455,
0.0187108219,
0.0170094315,
-0.0179191884,
0.0098587666,
0.0721811205,
-0.0033004649,
-0.0129144834,
-0.0175559241,
0.0086066592,
0.000457232,
0.0240140576,
-0.0040918738,
-0.0001966978,
-0.0104843061,
0.0438712165,
0.0597740635,
0.021293655,
0.0108257085,
0.0551544912,
-0.0100148078,
0.0329120867,
0.014281651,
0.0242489558,
-0.0786818117,
-0.0031979496,
0.0150160892,
-0.0040707048,
0.0749333575,
-0.0489110835,
0.0505848713,
-0.0379737243,
0.0065793875,
-0.0183115639,
0.0178102124,
0.0193255935,
0.0089406753,
0.0106523586,
0.0201506969,
0.007556255,
-0.0928333104,
0.0858724639,
-0.0146976579,
0.041692771,
0.0001484781,
-0.0513732694,
-0.0420769751,
-0.0517729819,
-0.0147135165,
0.0065992693,
-0.0404005162,
0.0149584515,
-0.046683792,
-0.0723776147,
-0.0263463017,
0.0148566347,
-0.0185110942,
0.0482073389,
0.0126356864,
0.0446861908,
0.0334824957,
0.0099156089,
-0.0443217531,
-0.0336598121,
-0.0075992942,
-0.0162859578,
0.0438619629,
-6.800851219e-33,
-0.020172542,
-0.0176327582,
0.0403399691,
-0.0511935987,
0.0361031853,
0.0643361881,
-0.0491504036,
0.0006376484,
-0.0385455079,
0.0164389592,
-0.0331146605,
0.0442919917,
0.0234431457,
0.013701315,
0.0253887065,
0.005120324,
0.0523448251,
0.0334274508,
0.0170639157,
-0.0171339177,
0.081321694,
0.0519698113,
0.0761719868,
-0.0163370892,
0.0222886428,
0.0437654741,
-0.0185637306,
0.013834917,
-0.0069412417,
0.0659276545,
-0.0058106999,
0.029701991,
0.0349255763,
-0.001077964,
-0.0193676967,
0.0139408428,
-0.1197921559,
-0.0511595719,
0.0063504465,
0.0143914605,
-0.0427018888,
-0.0098936427,
0.0122036953,
-0.0257186145,
-0.0014825946,
0.0138062574,
0.0189169571,
-0.039373152,
0.0408806205,
-0.0113048125,
-0.0334522501,
0.0163196195,
0.023249913,
-0.0229012147,
0.0334972851,
0.0588061959,
-0.0141948834,
-0.0105146412,
-0.065376088,
0.0300968494,
0.0332019292,
0.0653485507,
0.0415955037,
0.0390450731,
-0.015864037,
-0.0049435422,
-0.0108773652,
-0.0215612985,
-0.0431942604,
-0.0009185797,
0.0413604416,
0.0201975405,
0.0795395151,
0.0363463089,
0.0662277415,
-0.0061176363,
-0.0493597724,
0.0274361186,
0.0513605475,
0.0502885804,
0.0140313823,
-0.0126978178,
-0.0743344575,
-0.0471942127,
0.0212379321,
0.0321456827,
-0.0459220484,
-0.0019665367,
0.0594323799,
0.0641286671,
-0.0082188267,
-0.0144055663,
0.0081426827,
-0.0244254377,
0.0143102771,
0.0294676311,
0.0512071438,
-0.0377273895,
0.0091480967,
0.0222038403,
-0.0598654412,
-0.0254746582,
-0.0128922835,
0.0024021207,
-0.0344825238,
0.0028815563,
0.0208342001,
0.0553620383,
-0.0668622032,
0.0043161027,
-0.0404476672,
0.042780038,
0.0387726799,
-0.0012277369,
0.0296107661,
-0.0256813467,
0.004577423,
0.0376708433,
0.0188192315,
0.01097346,
-0.0113617284,
-0.0045606303,
-0.0089314235,
0.0417255275,
0.0027481013,
0.016819723,
-0.0582066365,
0.0157622043,
0.0211181305,
-0.065148361,
0.0123274857,
0.0368118174,
2.833e-7,
0.0327828042,
0.0125487018,
0.0131092519,
0.0328637585,
0.0145435063,
0.0155600086,
-0.0314909257,
-0.0194992777,
-0.0358991809,
0.0353788175,
0.0235035308,
0.0357382707,
0.0781425238,
0.019318372,
-0.0343090333,
-0.040134009,
-0.0089770118,
0.0152405789,
-0.0154850734,
0.0056221853,
0.0283169877,
0.0624982417,
-0.0037534134,
-0.0166393649,
-0.0011975481,
-0.0707955211,
0.0219954122,
0.0291538462,
0.0277889408,
0.0092815319,
0.0500712395,
0.0461872146,
-0.0069286483,
0.0278731361,
-0.0232738182,
-0.0113034509,
0.0144806895,
0.0213274211,
-0.004198472,
-0.0247269832,
0.0007316615,
-0.0117215877,
-0.0043856171,
-0.06364353,
0.0831734538,
-0.0082838451,
0.0130788349,
-0.0186206065,
0.0014000317,
0.0011313307,
-0.0297620371,
-0.0146591812,
-0.0057215933,
0.0229931585,
0.0093759811,
-0.0197596326,
-0.0092126234,
-0.067144841,
-0.0150237856,
0.0247067753,
0.0162337702,
-0.0274110325,
-0.0428626016,
-0.0194620993,
0.0069357925,
-0.0565374307,
-0.0491299145,
2.705942307e-34,
0.0160425454,
-0.0024515735,
0.0134341866,
0.0111020878,
0.0218491815,
-0.0027146968,
-0.0485019311,
-0.0268752631,
0.0216171183,
-0.0804975107,
-0.0583272614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09107v1 | GLoRE: Evaluating Logical Reasoning of Large Language Models | 2023-10-13T13:52:15 | 2023-10-13T13:52:15 | Hanmeng liu, Zhiyang Teng, Ruoxi Ning, Jian Liu, Qiji Zhou, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, large language models (LLMs), including notable models such as
GPT-4 and burgeoning community models, have showcased significant general
language understanding abilities. However, there has been a scarcity of
attempts to assess the logical reasoning capacities of these LLMs, an essential
facet of natural language understanding. To encourage further investigation in
this area, we introduce GLoRE, a meticulously assembled General Logical
Reasoning Evaluation benchmark comprised of 12 datasets that span three
different types of tasks. Our experimental results show that compared to the
performance of human and supervised fine-tuning, the logical reasoning
capabilities of open LLM models necessitate additional improvement; ChatGPT and
GPT-4 show a strong capability of logical reasoning, with GPT-4 surpassing
ChatGPT by a large margin. We propose a self-consistency probing method to
enhance the accuracy of ChatGPT and a fine-tuned method to boost the
performance of an open LLM. We release the datasets and evaluation programs to
facilitate future research. | [
0.0242978111,
0.0656993389,
-0.0025417036,
0.065561071,
-0.0740751699,
0.0266942047,
0.0290267244,
-0.004815999,
0.0362275615,
-0.0036391472,
-0.0292812157,
-0.0110198045,
-0.0229249801,
0.0246967487,
0.0032951436,
0.0052157566,
0.0740830749,
-0.0422614329,
-0.0143495407,
-0.0176941641,
-0.010881599,
0.0126697309,
0.0086229658,
0.0113738095,
0.0296554994,
-0.024717031,
-0.0026213757,
0.0003000353,
0.0373792425,
-0.0172077715,
-0.0287582297,
0.0625844225,
0.0363673605,
0.0730890334,
0.0000019436,
-0.0674773008,
0.004444499,
0.0018303847,
-0.0606717356,
0.0247826576,
0.0050325287,
0.0175397433,
0.0188782252,
0.017504571,
-0.0203604363,
0.0152945314,
0.0025608733,
0.035702236,
0.0695844069,
0.0428561494,
0.0026037656,
-0.0524529964,
-0.0333028883,
-0.0326698646,
0.0048371381,
-0.0611268431,
0.0234344564,
0.0531961545,
0.0141471066,
-0.005123198,
0.005743932,
0.0458423756,
0.0462225415,
0.0167123731,
-0.0398320816,
0.0419270173,
-0.0844660476,
-0.0319510438,
0.0326691307,
0.0733946636,
0.0298744738,
-0.0282514524,
-0.0187836997,
0.0150566092,
-0.0253736004,
0.0245065335,
-0.0160699505,
0.0273479987,
-0.0189203322,
0.0171245653,
0.0352019332,
-0.0110323625,
0.0439870991,
0.0285561513,
-0.0581814051,
0.1544415504,
0.0107088033,
-0.0087640798,
0.0244952142,
-0.005840749,
-0.0639110878,
-0.0327921398,
-0.0098108854,
0.0319198407,
-0.0261770915,
0.0277836155,
-0.0015999272,
0.0313221551,
0.0384184048,
-0.0184379146,
0.0089194896,
0.0510367155,
-0.0297957566,
0.097256422,
-0.028261099,
0.047296945,
-0.0103225391,
0.0753496364,
0.007189332,
-0.0211652536,
-0.0599032566,
-0.0191832092,
-0.0204296242,
0.0152624762,
-0.009711042,
-0.0012354321,
-0.0498876683,
-0.007142697,
-0.0150684752,
-0.0001872576,
0.0396550745,
-0.0008353519,
-0.0023062446,
-0.057347402,
-0.0501257852,
0.0094654625,
-0.048469644,
0.0086953444,
-0.0055425428,
-0.0535745732,
-0.0365082249,
-0.0053126775,
-0.0117161153,
-0.0407267474,
0.0208694059,
0.0457858518,
0.0202945583,
-0.0337573849,
-0.0302394908,
-0.0092415763,
-0.0152582759,
-0.1108419001,
-0.0117701534,
-0.0569377691,
0.0228917692,
0.0305501111,
-0.0225338247,
-0.0334353521,
-0.0076280138,
0.0003488984,
-0.0200069267,
0.0923899785,
-0.0162044801,
0.0165900327,
0.0240011793,
0.0164645519,
-0.0137772867,
0.0607201345,
-0.0025307476,
-0.006028282,
0.0173582621,
0.0002328584,
-0.0116326772,
0.0228543971,
-0.0004428757,
-0.0311065502,
-0.0148632666,
0.0709743798,
-0.0211841278,
0.0413382538,
-0.0021536539,
0.0446841866,
-0.0277561117,
-0.0568661541,
0.0333437175,
0.0488129929,
0.02550295,
-0.0082975822,
0.0107532497,
-0.009145299,
0.01666422,
-0.0136335697,
-0.0772736669,
0.0181737244,
-0.0242536608,
-0.0215147827,
0.0118736001,
0.0226969458,
-0.0158860274,
-0.0384724438,
-0.0377744399,
0.0281572212,
0.0072370097,
0.0122561101,
0.0660581961,
-0.0303063449,
0.001000633,
0.0515623391,
0.0466758534,
-0.0381044187,
-0.0020716453,
-0.0664310232,
0.0479138717,
0.0291148406,
0.0470502749,
-0.0249488577,
-0.0434631072,
0.0112841371,
0.0161816068,
0.0316788182,
0.0298839658,
0.0230610259,
0.0059169778,
-0.0338134542,
-0.0016164709,
-0.0149718672,
0.0162543468,
0.044958774,
0.0175121743,
-0.0094973724,
0.0086490829,
-0.0588436425,
0.009048054,
0.013361224,
-0.0129478406,
-0.0067042592,
-0.0134488782,
-0.0077217617,
0.0210923329,
-0.0107966503,
-0.003981126,
-0.0078780772,
0.0078004575,
-0.0047751744,
-0.0308121964,
0.0146951424,
-0.0529431589,
-0.0354943164,
0.0531275943,
-0.0309554655,
-0.0803708434,
0.0479859039,
-0.05626617,
-0.0312453564,
0.0376154706,
0.0108783785,
-0.0184205379,
-0.0931601375,
-0.0053523453,
-0.0143086854,
0.0039736675,
-0.0160730314,
0.0885887668,
0.0041422197,
0.0043286029,
0.0006227459,
0.0378979705,
0.0517033264,
-0.0609221011,
-0.0201525502,
0.014699664,
-0.0220686756,
-0.0139281563,
-0.0105714798,
-0.0011404447,
-0.0798354819,
-0.0264968276,
-0.063494958,
0.0112804361,
-0.0272470489,
0.0138882166,
0.0337155759,
-0.0359230116,
-0.0147458771,
-0.0142640742,
-0.0207729544,
0.0013816594,
0.0377969258,
0.0036173726,
0.0403491482,
-0.0175544247,
0.0018062156,
-0.0153523926,
-0.0071097836,
-0.0343169235,
0.0194786768,
0.0264119748,
0.0311686136,
-0.023058679,
-0.0055970517,
-0.0645892471,
-0.0032519952,
-0.0097139319,
-0.0437778756,
0.0350130871,
-0.0080268029,
0.0004879163,
0.0765648782,
-0.0167789217,
0.0046986742,
0.0629871711,
-0.0060046576,
-0.0220953915,
0.0286295824,
-0.0225692838,
-0.0127772149,
-0.0195333716,
-0.0115132332,
-0.0426556021,
0.0602146871,
-0.0114418669,
-0.0086527523,
-0.055917386,
0.029337801,
-0.0272309948,
-0.0043271817,
-0.0512872934,
0.0030775089,
0.0110841524,
0.0601847246,
-0.0571480393,
-0.0205354262,
0.0710826814,
-0.0235462021,
0.0054431302,
-0.0334922411,
0.0009873321,
-0.0478910133,
0.0654825568,
0.0078003472,
0.0018309468,
-0.0109502841,
-0.0221807528,
-0.0343118347,
-0.0041265795,
0.0368076898,
-0.0240729563,
0.038615156,
-0.0442806482,
0.0191927683,
0.0151126431,
-0.0372897685,
-0.0348729342,
-0.02242475,
-0.0608955026,
0.0023097801,
-0.019346308,
-0.0130290734,
-0.029744627,
0.0106007531,
-0.0130877448,
0.0090413997,
-0.0095561827,
0.0010563682,
-0.0208071452,
0.0073139439,
0.0389651358,
0.0591644049,
0.0148208383,
-0.025565885,
0.015767796,
0.0408882648,
-0.0012658733,
-0.0140655339,
-0.0319562033,
0.0314155892,
-0.0107658906,
-0.0133569026,
0.0059904652,
-0.0094519444,
0.0582761541,
-0.0400497094,
-0.0154975755,
0.1483327299,
0.0355925933,
-0.0010238686,
-0.0260378141,
-0.0419460051,
0.0503229052,
0.0420506746,
0.0171105117,
-0.0698126182,
-0.0627206042,
0.0249141604,
0.0057821805,
0.0204378609,
-0.0475650951,
-0.0132473717,
-0.0842713937,
0.0620926805,
-0.0190201551,
-0.0381537899,
-0.0094336942,
-0.0560717098,
0.029289335,
-0.0502324142,
0.0198260713,
0.0273533724,
0.018415099,
0.0109241437,
0.0072872583,
-0.036365103,
-0.0410592929,
0.0878584757,
-0.0328974389,
0.0618435852,
0.0308794137,
0.0241026226,
-0.0074005439,
-0.046775315,
0.0260600261,
-0.0000248472,
-0.0109972535,
-0.022030998,
0.0423620939,
0.0081809545,
-0.0089919688,
-0.0268843733,
0.0268047713,
-0.0370382816,
-0.0134892184,
0.0197870396,
0.0739257112,
-0.0060266126,
-0.049144078,
0.0099624516,
0.0238041747,
-0.0563716069,
0.0936753899,
0.0193896051,
0.0242930576,
-0.0636241212,
-0.0077860556,
-0.0372601524,
-0.032823883,
-0.0255835894,
0.039004609,
0.0563737154,
-0.0310868416,
-0.0121325497,
-0.0315552764,
0.0401579216,
0.0185816418,
-0.0172723345,
-0.0024129963,
0.0165893193,
0.0115848966,
-0.0336108245,
0.0561560318,
-0.0752189755,
-0.0039668283,
-0.0481064953,
0.0353306457,
-0.0061016507,
-0.0317851193,
-0.0411136597,
0.0401955768,
-0.0862951651,
-0.0642914027,
0.0131615931,
0.0150084989,
0.0340718292,
0.0333211571,
-0.0514299124,
-0.0355392508,
-0.0260748975,
0.0238636956,
-0.0279348027,
0.0195966382,
0.0195433125,
-0.0149322776,
0.0096514802,
0.0478828102,
0.0056333365,
0.0221027788,
0.0173395276,
0.0309063997,
-0.0122350482,
-0.0204776451,
0.0434241593,
0.0490704998,
0.0452245772,
0.0240273159,
0.0233461279,
-0.0407403298,
0.0045574028,
-0.0313100368,
0.0025641709,
-0.0149921747,
-0.0039492911,
0.0386607759,
-0.0535464324,
-0.0233263411,
-0.0524149165,
-0.035114903,
0.0131196082,
-0.0361392424,
-0.0037453752,
0.0196823981,
0.0219486766,
0.014491112,
-0.034459468,
-0.0073273927,
-0.0057732868,
-0.0242153537,
0.0633164048,
-0.0134460749,
0.065568842,
0.0470526032,
0.0097211674,
0.0050315256,
0.0034655971,
-0.0868182927,
-0.0428308621,
0.0457769297,
0.032693848,
0.0446455032,
0.0037800565,
0.0128023494,
-0.0231357571,
-0.0181981996,
-0.0129440352,
0.0221443791,
0.0282486547,
-0.021156285,
0.0275713932,
0.0261383057,
-0.0145680299,
-0.0117596192,
0.0395746194,
0.0039853239,
0.0229743924,
0.0263963118,
-0.0105396574,
-0.0337039381,
-0.0393543839,
-0.044983156,
0.012346711,
-0.0180107132,
0.0255249329,
-0.0637343898,
-0.0989774391,
0.0051069716,
0.0670442209,
0.0035463129,
0.0225626267,
-0.0053703161,
0.085972771,
0.0011663506,
-0.0358595289,
0.0019014772,
-0.0120040253,
-0.0414453186,
0.0068869418,
0.0126214493,
-6.710078076e-33,
-0.0280830581,
-0.0271120984,
0.0353745036,
-0.0464140885,
0.0012032849,
-0.0218027886,
-0.0513992943,
0.0060472786,
-0.0377914645,
0.025808515,
-0.0162775666,
0.0390253924,
0.0143793151,
0.00600038,
-0.0105812149,
-0.0334405378,
-0.0003732933,
0.0268908385,
-0.0139998514,
0.0033029162,
0.011035068,
0.0082822042,
0.0365334973,
-0.0337079726,
0.012021591,
0.015434592,
-0.0199560896,
0.0478115566,
-0.0727379993,
0.0490713455,
-0.0255636126,
0.0091845021,
0.0322465897,
-0.0241320673,
0.0255161412,
-0.0127051789,
-0.1057438701,
-0.0512658097,
0.0476015322,
-0.0220856518,
-0.0677499324,
-0.0046601952,
0.0099237766,
0.0044413018,
0.0107970284,
-0.0332181863,
0.011201065,
0.0019314738,
0.0174786448,
0.0444579124,
-0.020296149,
0.0487605147,
-0.0230644587,
-0.0070169903,
-0.0050729434,
0.0054143597,
-0.0230870936,
0.0330943987,
-0.0453642868,
-0.0018159063,
0.0129798697,
-0.0051420163,
0.0761447474,
0.0100471294,
-0.0060003381,
0.0594048537,
-0.0050733374,
-0.002978636,
-0.0720213056,
-0.007864764,
0.0296945442,
0.0774527788,
0.064419724,
0.0282089636,
0.0248682741,
0.0202457476,
-0.0976674184,
0.0086111361,
0.0095685087,
0.0296484102,
0.0314420499,
0.0056510642,
-0.0176063571,
0.0130325258,
-0.0556819886,
0.0073302099,
-0.0561924577,
-0.0202138759,
0.0453479625,
-0.037810225,
-0.0307508744,
-0.0302355643,
0.0140463365,
-0.0346201658,
-0.001607841,
0.0121246958,
-0.0069758832,
-0.0326921195,
0.0088227186,
0.0782254711,
-0.0261787996,
-0.0049429252,
-0.0022038459,
0.0337298363,
0.0021098668,
-0.0191241354,
0.0362105891,
-0.0058625271,
-0.0303025246,
-0.0166388676,
-0.0598448962,
0.014506029,
-0.0368998237,
0.0043353462,
0.0438131541,
0.0358337425,
0.0067597902,
0.0270536374,
0.0170167442,
0.0025693607,
-0.0406242125,
0.0321092717,
0.0060173087,
0.0082243616,
-0.0008731964,
0.0012966888,
-0.0212131981,
-0.0019255282,
-0.0055043525,
-0.0312270708,
0.0091868825,
0.0344063081,
2.68e-7,
0.0539815314,
0.0624999925,
0.0028572178,
0.0570666492,
0.0132204937,
0.0169563722,
-0.0375715941,
-0.0126709379,
0.0190131515,
-0.062233638,
0.0049454952,
0.0924589857,
0.0422847718,
0.0409405008,
-0.0234121606,
0.0260171182,
-0.0551213399,
-0.0312320981,
-0.0419971198,
0.0094957035,
0.0826601237,
0.0720107183,
0.0167398881,
-0.0236659236,
0.0237468146,
-0.0418866277,
0.0407033302,
-0.0245921034,
-0.009018667,
-0.0113512138,
0.0313259326,
0.0295302253,
0.0246156044,
0.0421811529,
0.0193423629,
-0.0006359848,
-0.0113349659,
0.0582863316,
-0.0088822376,
-0.007197768,
-0.0346797928,
-0.0272802003,
0.0082598384,
-0.0945336297,
0.1141097248,
-0.0711528361,
-0.0497183055,
-0.0005210206,
-0.0067368932,
-0.0469029322,
0.0465248413,
0.0074480558,
-0.0182334911,
0.0117534911,
0.0087771462,
-0.0459267944,
-0.0161716323,
-0.08870814,
-0.0172564816,
-0.0076304981,
-0.055222366,
-0.0100312298,
-0.0307725482,
-0.0027001002,
0.064850077,
-0.0371756293,
-0.0024065657,
2.181734964e-34,
0.0466356687,
-0.0003628752,
0.0085563436,
-0.0386172235,
0.0804574341,
0.0073125018,
-0.024444893,
-0.0028206513,
-0.0139481826,
-0.0865904838,
0.0052264114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.11465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.11465v1 | BaitBuster-Bangla: A Comprehensive Dataset for Clickbait Detection in Bangla with Multi-Feature and Multi-Modal Analysis | 2023-10-13T13:25:16 | 2023-10-13T13:25:16 | Abdullah Al Imran, Md Sakib Hossain Shovon, M. F. Mridha | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This study presents a large multi-modal Bangla YouTube clickbait dataset
consisting of 253,070 data points collected through an automated process using
the YouTube API and Python web automation frameworks. The dataset contains 18
diverse features categorized into metadata, primary content, engagement
statistics, and labels for individual videos from 58 Bangla YouTube channels. A
rigorous preprocessing step has been applied to denoise, deduplicate, and
remove bias from the features, ensuring unbiased and reliable analysis. As the
largest and most robust clickbait corpus in Bangla to date, this dataset
provides significant value for natural language processing and data science
researchers seeking to advance modeling of clickbait phenomena in low-resource
languages. Its multi-modal nature allows for comprehensive analyses of
clickbait across content, user interactions, and linguistic dimensions to
develop more sophisticated detection methods with cross-linguistic
applications. | [
0.0775450617,
-0.0080378419,
-0.0507215559,
0.0138919214,
-0.0426905081,
0.0170133952,
-0.0309738517,
0.0339054614,
0.0198687203,
-0.0136045665,
-0.0091116428,
-0.0231319312,
0.0317805968,
0.0725599304,
0.0204315986,
-0.0638600439,
0.0163537003,
0.0235007051,
0.0339153931,
0.0378229953,
0.0274774153,
0.0291982591,
0.017337108,
0.0195302591,
-0.0289179236,
0.0016118974,
0.0162474997,
-0.0026099624,
0.0043256138,
-0.035888385,
0.0359532721,
0.0550352633,
0.0208930653,
0.0217586216,
0.0000016477,
-0.044027295,
0.0276705157,
-0.0001452519,
-0.0054376735,
0.0416796058,
0.0429199263,
-0.0173266642,
-0.0107679032,
0.0338114202,
-0.0218815263,
0.067959629,
0.069009155,
0.0145148616,
0.037086349,
0.0438319333,
-0.0212109946,
-0.0236567799,
-0.0291355122,
-0.0018966281,
0.0487332605,
0.0449162126,
0.0187237542,
-0.0312392991,
0.0387795679,
0.033959873,
-0.0291889645,
0.0265900958,
-0.0251582712,
-0.0427694097,
-0.0770197362,
-0.0048559578,
-0.0204305369,
-0.0625994727,
0.0551447682,
0.0022186374,
-0.0665602162,
-0.0278367698,
0.0165179875,
0.027208712,
0.016098164,
0.0042323004,
-0.053253416,
0.0522791333,
0.0140288211,
0.0000806351,
-0.0036842264,
-0.0119954599,
0.0151515361,
0.0136822974,
0.0734384507,
-0.0375855006,
0.0128854755,
-0.0259332322,
-0.0159827508,
-0.0272463169,
0.052445028,
-0.0128565207,
0.0294927433,
-0.0074849413,
0.0154529698,
0.006373812,
-0.0383283831,
-0.0623983443,
0.02749121,
-0.0675795004,
-0.0260617323,
0.0210531801,
-0.0554504432,
0.0184251592,
0.010990127,
-0.0134649416,
-0.0002052813,
0.0097930506,
0.0311132502,
0.0430790074,
-0.0176491179,
-0.0196072478,
0.0258468185,
0.0004425881,
0.0080500152,
0.0223251265,
-0.0723595619,
0.047798533,
-0.0251732562,
-0.0136266863,
-0.0645784363,
0.0178541187,
0.021909222,
-0.0064028176,
0.0274028536,
0.0328867733,
-0.0182650834,
0.0259526521,
0.0156928021,
-0.1074818894,
-0.0194835793,
0.0171309467,
0.0200453755,
-0.0429974496,
0.0434437841,
-0.0188237075,
0.0075879688,
-0.0501871258,
-0.0911385417,
-0.0439249203,
-0.0519989133,
0.0024317082,
-0.0396579877,
-0.0942522436,
0.0790724382,
0.008269907,
-0.0267031789,
0.0096804928,
-0.0058506913,
0.0513503328,
-0.0178916417,
0.0604141876,
0.0337907635,
0.0033107584,
0.0363466926,
0.0504031703,
0.0511021577,
0.0477836169,
-0.0654105842,
0.1005179659,
0.0686365068,
0.0140581038,
0.0223592911,
0.0472643785,
0.0057990504,
0.0169348065,
-0.0091999639,
-0.0057947761,
-0.0369272083,
-0.0167567637,
-0.0176590588,
0.0081995502,
0.0037802912,
0.005294451,
0.0685130805,
0.0301177353,
-0.0659207478,
0.0207537841,
0.0578140914,
0.049186103,
-0.003302912,
0.0062495065,
-0.0095590651,
0.0010714628,
-0.0043643275,
-0.0213736687,
0.0327584408,
0.0694508106,
-0.0050232969,
-0.0104448674,
-0.0040959567,
-0.0097008245,
-0.0061534457,
-0.0558978729,
0.0432110764,
0.0212930907,
-0.015566187,
0.0241943803,
0.0237635747,
0.0015889179,
0.0533814244,
-0.0250553861,
0.0313474312,
-0.0467987619,
0.0276461672,
0.0078223273,
-0.0017329461,
-0.0571645088,
-0.001706233,
-0.0050213211,
-0.0261368025,
-0.0181922819,
-0.0534216762,
0.0086349025,
-0.0284106545,
-0.0030556044,
0.0186078437,
0.0195949189,
-0.0295582097,
0.044415921,
0.0280908048,
0.0129465722,
0.0058552953,
0.0022892943,
0.0580505058,
0.0029067395,
-0.0218914673,
0.0205938779,
0.0776505694,
0.0175915379,
-0.0143896192,
-0.0400750004,
0.0293086935,
0.0130837159,
0.0041074073,
0.0440281965,
0.0739315301,
-0.0296188816,
0.0180802997,
-0.113132529,
0.0042862748,
0.0687220022,
0.0178773571,
-0.0025147491,
0.065508604,
-0.0407031439,
0.0267964378,
-0.0438694879,
-0.0014183917,
-0.0284016337,
0.0390119404,
0.042877052,
0.0434849113,
0.0114659369,
0.0289212689,
0.0529592596,
0.001497747,
0.0464360602,
-0.0178475603,
-0.020692721,
0.0135838604,
-0.0480329357,
-0.0016493173,
-0.0018634266,
-0.0120583288,
-0.0314618796,
0.008615966,
-0.0676601008,
-0.0343224145,
-0.0052954848,
0.0116314841,
0.040593531,
0.0357458666,
-0.0289537366,
-0.0102077089,
-0.0217409749,
-0.1022045463,
0.0019580612,
0.018265022,
-0.0243610628,
-0.033320602,
0.02354558,
0.0355806686,
0.0119857071,
-0.0002991275,
0.0375356749,
0.0620513558,
-0.0591780692,
0.0421602502,
-0.0458188169,
-0.0067455764,
-0.0346364193,
-0.0186456162,
-0.0392624289,
-0.0453765765,
0.0202565175,
-0.0012398682,
0.0440925099,
0.0500957556,
0.0263337903,
0.015798213,
0.0206149295,
-0.0085684257,
-0.03215345,
-0.0280895904,
0.001587323,
-0.0166382715,
-0.0653175414,
0.0549339131,
-0.0356187448,
0.0279507842,
0.0492720269,
-0.0137787862,
0.0304332562,
-0.0096342536,
0.0102227442,
-0.0654912367,
0.0066147614,
-0.0351856612,
0.0329655521,
-0.0035642474,
-0.030787725,
0.0471870415,
-0.0080592996,
-0.0170710552,
0.0173084196,
0.0024765849,
-0.0043157889,
0.012932457,
-0.0116081098,
0.0473731048,
0.0095714871,
-0.0696367398,
-0.0105584767,
0.0449792817,
0.060054902,
0.0046230303,
0.0043621105,
0.0040973956,
-0.0119567197,
0.0057578748,
-0.0387196802,
-0.0236392301,
-0.0960550234,
0.0070821093,
-0.0490483977,
0.0231226441,
-0.0097635249,
-0.0114865107,
0.0392525606,
0.018160319,
-0.0550784245,
-0.0148264738,
0.0093657197,
0.0490884483,
0.0667733327,
0.0311900303,
-0.0301647019,
-0.0363812149,
0.0195688941,
-0.0413835533,
0.0214929525,
-0.0188597627,
-0.0224365667,
0.0285960827,
0.0131689915,
0.0252739359,
-0.0066017248,
-0.0092315031,
-0.0213463791,
-0.0401223302,
-0.0169162955,
-0.0272133909,
0.0423743501,
0.010408055,
-0.0166088436,
-0.0112756677,
-0.028132394,
-0.0191724673,
-0.0104300668,
0.0196866412,
-0.0706307068,
-0.0042981361,
-0.0190729704,
-0.0045625167,
-0.0294614974,
0.0129633183,
-0.0193056148,
-0.1063989624,
0.0183731988,
0.000097242,
-0.0179225747,
-0.0673377514,
-0.0539712459,
-0.0187080596,
-0.0118690096,
-0.0026736571,
0.0023615705,
-0.0223622955,
0.0081085116,
0.0202946365,
-0.0008239449,
-0.0893634036,
0.0163420495,
-0.0167035777,
0.0503851362,
0.0001626916,
0.0435444489,
-0.0792543516,
-0.0086610373,
-0.027796451,
-0.0652341098,
-0.0534327514,
-0.0153285321,
0.0613804236,
-0.0282634534,
-0.0056459694,
0.0054729786,
0.0302655976,
0.0288649611,
0.0221636556,
-0.0112543935,
0.047879748,
0.0337128155,
-0.0409362353,
-0.0589075312,
-0.0011643138,
-0.0005050875,
0.0343746953,
0.0515300184,
-0.0429549888,
0.0320477858,
-0.0083090682,
-0.0693070069,
-0.0305601824,
-0.0751370862,
-0.0176763069,
-0.0527982228,
-0.0769461915,
-0.0259464551,
-0.0214160327,
-0.0134927146,
0.0044704103,
0.0409874506,
0.031921573,
-0.0355860591,
-0.0074789589,
-0.0498999543,
-0.0065027685,
0.0149304429,
0.0231431406,
-0.028665062,
0.021564519,
0.0408570394,
-0.0512577146,
-0.0181064848,
-0.0118179899,
-0.0643444136,
-0.0377080254,
-0.0075852447,
0.0301986337,
0.0180198234,
0.0365494192,
-0.0227381643,
-0.0224635005,
0.0509543903,
0.0570811518,
0.0168679673,
-0.0247007664,
0.0125567419,
0.0307793189,
0.0109819332,
0.0262248423,
-0.0318594724,
0.0175295435,
0.0077154944,
-0.0852939337,
-0.0582483262,
0.0341189168,
0.0034684096,
0.0099535277,
0.0263154246,
-0.040005181,
-0.0144443512,
-0.0388152078,
-0.0652628615,
0.0238034446,
-0.0231822375,
-0.0214044303,
0.0247702282,
0.0369410701,
0.0480655991,
-0.0089370478,
0.0022980808,
-0.0493347272,
-0.0420689024,
-0.0241939314,
0.0063762758,
0.0096559506,
0.0201927219,
0.0368064567,
0.0180481505,
0.0185638703,
0.0056798542,
0.0125458064,
0.0301942565,
-0.0043248911,
0.0295486823,
0.0206553955,
-0.0252017342,
0.0785214528,
0.0580249503,
0.0553918593,
0.0685780942,
-0.0190542024,
-0.0252325814,
0.0434196964,
-0.0702896491,
0.0227931384,
-0.0359287299,
-0.007218176,
0.0085022002,
0.0301390346,
-0.0679336041,
-0.086881347,
0.023242401,
-0.0034140972,
-0.0351316892,
-0.0137397749,
0.0535571091,
-0.0284507759,
-0.0118475705,
0.0674743429,
-0.0559006855,
-0.013260263,
0.0027136381,
0.0448969528,
0.0569640137,
0.0004974446,
0.0032822171,
-0.0602486581,
-0.0614447705,
-0.0427485779,
-0.0413949862,
0.0503154956,
0.0469618365,
0.0182827413,
0.0590340123,
0.0240907185,
0.0546071194,
-0.034535978,
-0.0191731155,
-0.035357967,
-0.0295667816,
0.0098521765,
-5.678621089e-33,
0.0294796228,
-0.0675646365,
-0.0582728162,
0.0098567028,
-0.0177167058,
-0.0035064374,
-0.0154023357,
0.0120537719,
-0.0104532652,
-0.0089925257,
-0.0044962168,
0.0394796394,
0.0070050955,
0.0138936341,
0.0330913328,
-0.0246409327,
0.0276975948,
0.018154623,
-0.0298942905,
-0.0027041247,
0.0526399128,
0.0080432687,
0.0285918452,
-0.0537990108,
0.0493502617,
-0.04486138,
-0.0730141178,
0.0164305698,
0.0318483301,
0.0685864538,
0.0112346727,
0.0636087358,
0.0432131328,
0.0189456046,
0.0028590641,
0.0373893939,
-0.0118863201,
-0.006094961,
0.0542095453,
0.0475285724,
0.0001506114,
-0.0025416953,
0.0861494094,
-0.0312346481,
-0.0150958644,
0.0276788492,
0.0408901758,
-0.0267176516,
0.0259716772,
0.0257465951,
-0.0307159554,
0.0192256961,
-0.0218003355,
0.005956084,
0.028644003,
0.069102928,
0.0419782475,
-0.012217789,
-0.0540800057,
0.045829244,
0.0045377379,
0.0282380264,
0.0582850501,
0.0069811093,
0.0145621439,
0.036436554,
0.0130332271,
-0.0479381531,
0.0115884263,
0.0293155741,
-0.0034628538,
0.0447349623,
0.009619086,
0.0694804564,
0.0345702767,
-0.0821437165,
-0.0154735567,
0.0213028118,
0.0778627992,
-0.0145356376,
-0.002259769,
-0.0269973073,
-0.0617492348,
-0.0149781611,
0.0230491795,
-0.0354095362,
-0.0354619734,
-0.0659724623,
0.0194710027,
-0.0151476571,
-0.0325276926,
0.015744606,
-0.0074228812,
-0.023679046,
0.03156415,
-0.0148963686,
-0.021596957,
0.025574524,
0.0299415551,
0.0218429975,
-0.0112087782,
0.0010494044,
-0.0118969521,
-0.0035908455,
-0.0022671993,
-0.0039192531,
0.0310469214,
0.0612297356,
-0.0658774674,
0.0035171639,
0.0064300178,
-0.0065788263,
-0.0224081669,
0.0407855399,
0.0174131542,
-0.0037760958,
-0.0568453744,
-0.0545435585,
0.0752458572,
0.0362201072,
0.0123933386,
-0.0347768255,
-0.0507671908,
0.0111618284,
-0.0067661395,
-0.0305449385,
-0.0121804429,
-0.041372776,
0.0168121774,
-0.0700586587,
-0.0058614495,
-0.037280187,
2.559e-7,
-0.0116227223,
0.0466717072,
-0.0174012892,
-0.0210191291,
0.0182088446,
0.0557925776,
-0.0179024991,
0.0191076845,
-0.0024946469,
0.0036054759,
0.0044650789,
-0.0619220175,
-0.0143301729,
-0.0067341309,
-0.118720524,
0.0240751617,
-0.057111036,
-0.0293037854,
-0.0451764949,
-0.0284181759,
-0.0258458983,
0.0621237867,
0.0496128201,
-0.0464283451,
0.0120048914,
-0.0300089382,
0.0095181745,
0.0149422176,
-0.0394238308,
0.0060088965,
0.031612955,
0.0179321785,
-0.0071988562,
-0.0108455,
-0.0373860523,
-0.0128929848,
0.0513529703,
0.0331682526,
0.0326562785,
0.020270573,
-0.0224269256,
-0.0247420389,
-0.0067699337,
-0.0754350647,
0.0474328622,
0.0435423926,
-0.0630042106,
-0.0454925112,
-0.023630539,
-0.0261604041,
0.0317086205,
-0.0350666568,
-0.019342687,
-0.0267943274,
-0.0000244694,
-0.0082059847,
-0.0284224972,
-0.0431535766,
0.0279057454,
-0.0130620962,
-0.046982877,
-0.0161456056,
-0.0052653761,
0.0118996566,
0.0410529859,
-0.0250850804,
0.0247846562,
2.149644427e-34,
0.0370365605,
-0.0261400789,
0.0226242878,
-0.0555492863,
-0.0184643716,
0.0364194736,
0.0297586266,
0.0078923954,
0.0335240476,
0.0086887013,
-0.0117478389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09089v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09089v2 | Qilin-Med: Multi-stage Knowledge Injection Advanced Medical Large Language Model | 2023-10-13T13:17:03 | 2024-04-17T15:18:54 | Qichen Ye, Junling Liu, Dading Chong, Peilin Zhou, Yining Hua, Fenglin Liu, Meng Cao, Ziming Wang, Xuxin Cheng, Zhu Lei, Zhenhua Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Integrating large language models (LLMs) into healthcare holds great
potential but faces challenges. Pre-training LLMs from scratch for domains like
medicine is resource-heavy and often unfeasible. On the other hand, sole
reliance on Supervised Fine-tuning (SFT) can result in overconfident
predictions and may not tap into domain-specific insights. In response, we
present a multi-stage training method combining Domain-specific Continued
Pre-training (DCPT), SFT, and Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). In
addition, we publish a 3Gb Chinese Medicine (ChiMed) dataset, encompassing
medical question answering, plain texts, knowledge graphs, and dialogues,
segmented into three training stages. The medical LLM trained with our
pipeline, Qilin-Med, shows substantial performance improvement. In the CPT and
SFT phases, Qilin-Med achieved 38.4% and 40.0% accuracy on the CMExam test set,
respectively. It outperformed the basemodel Baichuan-7B (accuracy: 33.5%), by
7.5%. In the DPO phase, it scored 16.66 in BLEU-1 and 27.44 in ROUGE-1 on the
Huatuo-26M test set, bringing further improvement to the SFT phase (12.69 in
BLEU-1 and 24.21 in ROUGE-1). Additionally, we have further enhanced the
model's performance through the Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) approach.
Experiments demonstrate that Qilin-Med-RAG achieves an accuracy rate of 42.8%
on CMExam. These results highlight the contribution of our novel training
approach in building LLMs for medical applications. | [
0.066801317,
0.0362883322,
0.0176033136,
-0.0129501903,
0.0272401273,
0.0115770027,
-0.0286455024,
0.0146299573,
0.0291531421,
-0.0335552767,
-0.0587637611,
-0.0542189404,
-0.0240734071,
0.0281171128,
0.0294186156,
-0.022151798,
0.0560748875,
0.0519471839,
0.0028250543,
-0.0096271932,
0.0018195781,
0.0088914204,
-0.0025005608,
0.0184751991,
0.0409543738,
-0.0086295819,
0.0261754505,
0.0024710172,
0.0237467065,
-0.0623537228,
0.0391011201,
0.04696358,
0.016651893,
0.0038346355,
0.0000022754,
-0.0760871843,
-0.0421693213,
0.0145664476,
-0.0599964522,
-0.0103829866,
0.0168308467,
-0.0107344454,
0.0165788867,
0.0301300269,
-0.053245727,
-0.0309369545,
0.0093702413,
0.0708037838,
0.0606426075,
0.0814498812,
-0.0018149219,
-0.0046699126,
0.0411918089,
-0.0396136194,
0.0142833134,
-0.0693960041,
0.054316055,
0.0082735047,
0.0258686356,
0.0149966152,
0.0110745728,
0.0428145714,
-0.0014573412,
0.050067775,
0.0426382311,
0.0451889448,
-0.0254533216,
0.0081576174,
-0.0168435462,
0.0907083303,
-0.0038735024,
0.0002601018,
0.006107599,
0.0076174703,
-0.0102550499,
-0.0171435066,
-0.0417536944,
-0.0218165945,
0.0017272466,
0.0094750468,
0.004911345,
-0.0383354388,
0.0477887467,
0.0260087233,
-0.0465393513,
-0.0026577655,
0.0162859615,
-0.0331511162,
0.0228616875,
-0.0319210663,
-0.0329666287,
-0.013125618,
0.0148862088,
0.0532390215,
-0.0422649123,
0.0212263186,
0.0110883573,
-0.0076393778,
0.0729590654,
-0.0544466749,
0.0104421992,
0.0180498417,
-0.0118938312,
0.0360952802,
-0.018206317,
0.0070238914,
-0.0276591368,
0.0199562851,
-0.0680651888,
0.0118130613,
-0.0519864522,
-0.0331966355,
-0.0187654775,
0.043400865,
-0.0140472213,
-0.0175043344,
-0.0868289918,
-0.0076076314,
0.004162298,
-0.0063419878,
0.0299881585,
0.0729438812,
-0.0290139336,
-0.0102768783,
-0.0266299471,
0.0542436168,
0.007543664,
0.0363900289,
-0.022343684,
-0.0387016423,
-0.0070353649,
0.0109778196,
0.0072536743,
-0.0282273982,
0.0233810861,
0.0638060123,
-0.0196363088,
-0.0313897058,
0.0092863822,
-0.0389981344,
-0.0319236889,
-0.032379657,
0.0295856763,
-0.0598278753,
0.0235854276,
-0.0068118111,
0.0142391762,
-0.0348134935,
0.0386931933,
0.0272369832,
-0.062790893,
0.0480159149,
-0.0336130559,
0.0060580159,
0.0066676242,
0.0432273932,
-0.0039032439,
0.0461826809,
-0.0019628799,
-0.0404452048,
0.0175018962,
-0.021170551,
-0.0241002664,
0.0016195183,
0.0417423211,
-0.0219744202,
0.0159248337,
0.0442691296,
0.0090381103,
0.0603464097,
-0.0338379145,
0.042032104,
-0.0191275831,
0.0034901523,
0.0114048356,
0.0224687476,
0.0383583568,
-0.0177314281,
-0.0164919477,
-0.0156164765,
0.0139808133,
-0.0231522042,
-0.0213701669,
-0.0007047812,
-0.0126248542,
0.011972528,
0.0151359001,
0.0124737425,
-0.0411624834,
-0.0271495208,
-0.0166882593,
-0.0208805669,
-0.0305656772,
0.0049885572,
0.0493085533,
0.0084436256,
-0.030886218,
0.0570390821,
0.0528080203,
-0.0236270074,
0.0018531703,
-0.0479255393,
-0.0210918207,
0.0722364113,
0.057148356,
-0.0557552688,
-0.041851189,
0.0021145206,
-0.000660402,
-0.0043861913,
0.034636721,
-0.0297107249,
-0.0030244128,
-0.071620591,
-0.014581752,
0.0170448627,
0.0110527202,
-0.0159549788,
0.0347683057,
0.0328372382,
0.013656579,
-0.0196456164,
-0.0041775741,
0.0217274539,
-0.0693582743,
-0.0444711037,
0.0065228762,
-0.0090496838,
0.0348141417,
0.0333223231,
-0.022556683,
0.046978496,
0.047019314,
-0.0297412965,
-0.0452899523,
-0.0061377333,
-0.0683891699,
-0.0524710603,
0.0501470938,
0.017711293,
-0.0115481466,
-0.0114441607,
-0.0514290109,
-0.048669789,
-0.0331372917,
-0.0032474741,
0.0473030545,
-0.0395673551,
0.0187794939,
0.0265591741,
-0.0046121278,
-0.0669748262,
0.0466103107,
-0.0120270066,
0.0102805523,
0.0260767248,
-0.0123639246,
-0.0015927354,
-0.0140884435,
-0.0118685598,
0.0173379835,
-0.0003308364,
0.0322591886,
0.0011789931,
0.0245580692,
-0.0492478795,
-0.0221261848,
-0.1044030041,
0.023248665,
-0.0050655156,
0.0032666486,
0.0408481285,
0.0381243862,
0.0035659308,
-0.0107853515,
-0.0576379038,
-0.0040950072,
0.0234844927,
0.0119218798,
0.011566068,
0.0429102108,
0.0454469919,
-0.0254737698,
-0.0007666588,
-0.0353971906,
-0.0082432069,
-0.0366533361,
0.0029297981,
0.0290141683,
0.0154845929,
-0.0297026094,
-0.0066744075,
-0.0260317996,
-0.0351567902,
-0.0258993264,
-0.0306728277,
0.0102263503,
0.0323549584,
0.0050735893,
-0.0085988613,
0.0207787957,
0.0113632428,
-0.0450323597,
0.0202102903,
-0.0453553721,
-0.0479501486,
-0.0008721641,
-0.012690559,
-0.0129789021,
0.0623397529,
0.0193451755,
-0.0113914879,
-0.0394975133,
-0.0199268311,
-0.0109618148,
0.0069742943,
-0.0387797393,
0.0467675515,
-0.0400239415,
0.02230905,
-0.0071041416,
-0.0159263369,
0.0799221322,
0.0045487778,
0.0278973933,
-0.103668794,
-0.0177798513,
-0.0487892777,
-0.0249627698,
-0.0151314195,
0.013191212,
-0.0137928622,
0.0018712172,
-0.0494613014,
0.0148463417,
-0.0351760797,
-0.0759228989,
0.0588608496,
0.0164641533,
0.0152422646,
-0.0102290381,
-0.0462183021,
-0.0560538135,
-0.0235322006,
-0.0289604869,
0.0160911027,
0.0049999594,
0.0153216748,
-0.0177315418,
0.0113802124,
-0.0047509195,
0.0536868274,
-0.0065702121,
-0.0030136285,
-0.0084629292,
0.0262315068,
0.0595021397,
0.0322086625,
-0.0000376945,
-0.0134015828,
0.0607322268,
0.0779888332,
0.0407734625,
-0.0092269387,
0.0402011797,
-0.0027287295,
0.0138999112,
-0.0310838986,
-0.0031044341,
0.0143223358,
0.0294865835,
-0.0594870076,
-0.0003028916,
0.1240208149,
0.0216393676,
-0.0527134463,
0.0106439451,
0.0010218555,
-0.0006787946,
0.0174704771,
0.0250347946,
-0.0932235941,
-0.0490277596,
-0.0211760644,
0.0422622524,
0.007553739,
0.0003985485,
0.0202016253,
-0.0999534354,
0.0045816768,
0.0061309543,
-0.0193353128,
-0.0325178802,
-0.0323175602,
0.0016320711,
0.0070438217,
0.0111472597,
0.0114245033,
-0.0326855369,
-0.0068465639,
0.0126959244,
-0.0054445476,
-0.0919380039,
0.0459338427,
-0.0122663472,
0.0358049385,
0.0760952905,
0.0266206842,
-0.0015941048,
0.014832126,
0.0223924108,
-0.0111062666,
-0.0014837926,
-0.0210779309,
0.0682172701,
-0.0039317803,
0.0138059463,
-0.0288199335,
0.0388215594,
-0.0466109663,
-0.0230155271,
0.0130793117,
0.0739771873,
-0.0249785259,
-0.0150213679,
-0.0296924785,
0.0347651988,
-0.0036103204,
0.0553898625,
-0.0139525477,
-0.0036732205,
-0.0140106184,
0.0197603572,
0.029079292,
-0.0109392004,
-0.0148969805,
0.0506942086,
-0.0327612944,
0.0247737914,
-0.0867863148,
-0.0309552141,
0.0227604415,
-0.0128846234,
0.0056866519,
0.049411159,
-0.0009349733,
0.0030709209,
-0.0626697391,
0.0479833558,
0.0071399193,
0.0001635558,
-0.0608543195,
-0.0479727611,
0.0602702834,
-0.0384669825,
-0.0049994253,
-0.0125947408,
-0.0143070044,
-0.0357115641,
-0.0180024896,
0.0404057689,
0.0076290718,
0.0459621549,
-0.0213200934,
-0.0048724976,
0.0546541512,
0.0372095481,
-0.049214758,
-0.0223286003,
0.0219852459,
-0.0256609172,
-0.0205445271,
0.0165336076,
-0.0208318178,
0.0045972029,
0.0128795058,
0.0582243539,
-0.0097554512,
-0.0354912095,
0.0304387528,
0.0180755164,
0.0140928533,
-0.0010852398,
0.0110303769,
-0.0419635512,
0.0530120693,
-0.0170836039,
-0.0004773196,
-0.0312124938,
-0.021977026,
0.0373504162,
-0.0200059917,
-0.0048345542,
0.0055331723,
-0.017525984,
-0.0173758157,
-0.0359542631,
0.0179521386,
0.0160511434,
-0.0055073365,
0.041247867,
-0.0190188717,
-0.0059214025,
0.0360318199,
0.0089309523,
0.0388735197,
-0.0390882157,
0.0740697309,
-0.0017259793,
0.0067006922,
0.0064169681,
0.0367467441,
-0.069736883,
-0.0735566095,
-0.0238364059,
0.0066126739,
0.0696801916,
-0.0268597938,
0.0433688089,
-0.0137672247,
-0.0182827804,
-0.0420628227,
-0.0016692148,
-0.046263162,
0.0269270297,
0.0408743545,
0.0332221538,
-0.0067687635,
0.0026235559,
0.1052037254,
0.0207635015,
0.0701647997,
-0.0019571311,
-0.031845849,
-0.0356744565,
-0.0287791938,
0.0536006391,
0.0504474975,
-0.0641584396,
0.0274156258,
-0.0510215461,
-0.070075579,
0.008464193,
-0.0370145813,
-0.053988222,
-0.0052171601,
0.0671650469,
0.0429133847,
0.0048325793,
-0.0226723086,
-0.0507714376,
0.0304175187,
-0.0442246124,
-0.0060530622,
0.0488281734,
-7.005025037e-33,
0.0037202537,
-0.0012126871,
0.0345948674,
-0.0548798963,
-0.0078778695,
0.0132468427,
-0.0274432451,
-0.0269520599,
-0.0548647903,
0.0044055642,
-0.0256991908,
-0.0009065913,
0.0034770069,
0.0506784283,
0.0054197717,
-0.003944037,
0.0160519928,
0.0091332952,
0.0014376703,
0.0393218435,
0.0147026917,
0.0875733942,
0.0371130221,
-0.0424172468,
-0.0245431513,
0.0104911709,
0.0506394058,
0.0300164912,
-0.0473804474,
0.0648901537,
-0.0405238569,
0.0373011343,
0.0388733596,
-0.0196237639,
-0.0118843783,
-0.0060146125,
-0.1021864936,
-0.0166797284,
-0.0137052666,
-0.0173557755,
-0.0213485248,
-0.0271211863,
0.0260088518,
-0.0328882262,
0.0217824075,
-0.0132890334,
0.0228219256,
-0.0286106858,
-0.0136260185,
-0.0623329505,
-0.0285117477,
0.042909719,
0.0279299393,
-0.0120433392,
-0.0572170205,
0.0135964984,
-0.0232370123,
0.0800643563,
-0.0589111522,
-0.0062577459,
0.023777822,
0.0631294325,
0.0122582922,
0.0158473942,
-0.0049477033,
0.0330280662,
0.0021508604,
-0.0132969953,
0.0007761266,
0.0089618145,
-0.0255348925,
0.0331065059,
0.0150217246,
0.0206901766,
0.0117877182,
-0.0297972988,
-0.1048068777,
0.0374970511,
-0.0482756123,
0.0557928719,
0.0114817154,
-0.0117637459,
-0.0263319481,
-0.0184967108,
-0.0189043786,
0.0568122603,
-0.0235395953,
-0.0328985155,
0.0260725431,
0.020838676,
-0.0173162613,
-0.0033556458,
0.019365672,
-0.0450120866,
0.0219572112,
0.0136478283,
0.0025367003,
-0.0164298601,
-0.0410140641,
0.0407299735,
-0.0930988342,
-0.0070888614,
0.0184598081,
-0.0450614691,
-0.0097064106,
0.0298880674,
0.0206706952,
-0.0269761328,
-0.0462677069,
-0.0070954631,
-0.0000062711,
-0.0264014658,
0.0222774725,
0.0492496639,
0.0141540971,
0.0467735268,
0.0127080875,
0.0692803711,
0.0440896228,
0.0153466929,
-0.0749828145,
-0.0682319179,
0.0132380091,
-0.0054958411,
-0.0320945494,
0.0453035906,
-0.0553782173,
0.0463584252,
-0.0075115012,
-0.0590349063,
-0.0189332571,
0.0079361266,
3.112e-7,
0.1001268551,
0.0389772281,
-0.0055615501,
-0.0087622358,
0.0036753258,
0.0199109279,
-0.0125218034,
0.0196374655,
0.0156937446,
0.007827579,
0.0419701599,
0.0297009572,
0.0280013699,
0.0155208036,
-0.0870895982,
-0.0208569001,
-0.0706389993,
-0.0450548604,
-0.0208273046,
-0.0451510511,
0.0375252478,
0.1184104979,
-0.04479165,
-0.0290743522,
0.0095621608,
-0.0145264696,
0.0606903285,
0.0053426493,
-0.022120757,
0.0717059448,
0.0036815908,
0.0348003581,
-0.0179264024,
0.0210311543,
-0.0432269536,
0.0174802504,
-0.0021585913,
0.1085759774,
-0.0405777432,
-0.0403036512,
0.0225636549,
0.006485376,
0.0280236956,
-0.054971762,
0.0738335848,
-0.060116332,
-0.0524869785,
-0.0127143227,
-0.0138275549,
-0.0281640254,
0.0676485896,
-0.0301042944,
-0.0197092015,
0.0287914984,
0.0046726489,
0.0304697007,
-0.0382528156,
-0.0886602625,
-0.0273372065,
0.0521210656,
-0.0432829373,
-0.064899683,
0.0316841863,
-0.0231142547,
-0.0194351003,
-0.0594039969,
0.0069899466,
2.979686932e-34,
0.01404576,
0.0013740609,
0.021128282,
0.0304617044,
0.0297401808,
-0.0169987995,
0.0122055439,
0.0312206149,
0.0314040743,
-0.0930550322,
-0.01727226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09088v1 | Dialect Transfer for Swiss German Speech Translation | 2023-10-13T13:16:57 | 2023-10-13T13:16:57 | Claudio Paonessa, Yanick Schraner, Jan Deriu, Manuela Hürlimann, Manfred Vogel, Mark Cieliebak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates the challenges in building Swiss German speech
translation systems, specifically focusing on the impact of dialect diversity
and differences between Swiss German and Standard German. Swiss German is a
spoken language with no formal writing system, it comprises many diverse
dialects and is a low-resource language with only around 5 million speakers.
The study is guided by two key research questions: how does the inclusion and
exclusion of dialects during the training of speech translation models for
Swiss German impact the performance on specific dialects, and how do the
differences between Swiss German and Standard German impact the performance of
the systems? We show that dialect diversity and linguistic differences pose
significant challenges to Swiss German speech translation, which is in line
with linguistic hypotheses derived from empirical investigations. | [
0.0237733629,
0.0331620462,
-0.0056466069,
0.0256567653,
-0.0559694655,
-0.0266638231,
0.0364154018,
-0.0453765765,
-0.0555096082,
-0.0223345738,
-0.0429056063,
-0.054445859,
0.0555910505,
-0.0197004788,
0.0183505621,
-0.066675514,
0.052522026,
-0.0439562388,
-0.0240891762,
-0.014199351,
0.0121612055,
-0.037483722,
0.0364324972,
0.0146215511,
0.0355163924,
0.0483876653,
0.0317872949,
0.0869753212,
0.0093980413,
0.0079029119,
-0.029460704,
-0.0488128625,
0.0289742965,
0.0661681443,
0.0000014708,
-0.0582800694,
-0.0137829902,
-0.0110062426,
-0.0011568567,
0.0610710196,
0.0429011323,
-0.0356378183,
-0.033884041,
0.040585503,
-0.001056605,
0.0139424317,
0.0249267202,
-0.0158840269,
0.0076658297,
0.0371199138,
-0.036317993,
-0.0294400491,
-0.0525133759,
-0.0093116798,
-0.0546196215,
0.0067929579,
-0.0375596993,
-0.0035912069,
-0.0221958179,
-0.0210969299,
-0.0415314808,
0.089182578,
-0.059938468,
0.0098076575,
-0.0250990707,
-0.0501360409,
-0.0327242203,
-0.0167444628,
0.0003223685,
0.0432871319,
0.0135695525,
0.0060874084,
-0.0142999478,
0.028475251,
0.0243419223,
0.0274264757,
-0.0570455156,
-0.0012994845,
-0.0009140042,
-0.0140696829,
0.0234594829,
0.0405856706,
-0.0453283302,
-0.0596110485,
-0.0038848373,
0.0148219736,
0.0462404005,
-0.03191128,
-0.0005427548,
-0.0017442872,
0.0012146807,
-0.0015136251,
0.0193927288,
-0.0069718431,
0.0159147028,
0.0213732533,
-0.0251101926,
-0.0202416684,
-0.0140621271,
0.0003895748,
0.018926315,
0.0433697253,
-0.0359468684,
-0.0061661275,
0.0134550119,
0.0253143217,
-0.0013694785,
0.006290609,
-0.0875686184,
-0.0419492573,
-0.0473183729,
0.0617723428,
-0.0687540099,
-0.0056899022,
-0.0327303112,
0.0172852054,
0.0007588637,
-0.0087812617,
0.0500804596,
0.0006454386,
0.0335872918,
-0.0191358794,
-0.085292168,
-0.0270264205,
-0.0251858346,
0.1178102791,
-0.0196598675,
0.0041431403,
-0.0436984375,
-0.0469600707,
-0.0034192947,
0.0328081809,
0.0040977807,
-0.0436101295,
-0.0278870836,
-0.0126698855,
-0.0374951437,
0.0109296264,
-0.0535883419,
0.0166098345,
-0.0415301844,
-0.0237140208,
-0.0249538403,
-0.0618707463,
0.0108339014,
0.0270762555,
0.0375568494,
-0.0326306038,
-0.029583009,
-0.0469864458,
-0.0413529016,
-0.0169235244,
-0.0268952604,
0.0332139842,
0.0458531529,
-0.0313888043,
-0.0270790625,
0.0455753095,
0.0158116724,
-0.033367876,
0.0144378236,
-0.0482717976,
-0.0138762109,
0.0484805964,
-0.0124797281,
0.0417317003,
-0.0850689411,
0.0027110975,
-0.0093718283,
-0.0020862343,
0.0615676269,
0.0826660767,
0.0005951183,
-0.0033421947,
0.0915309489,
0.0531358123,
0.0372538902,
-0.013392929,
0.0227456596,
0.0180786587,
-0.0024775048,
0.0010115869,
0.0363827944,
-0.0449349731,
-0.0259338096,
0.0152809229,
-0.0631946772,
0.0775051787,
-0.0109794904,
0.0311563574,
0.0046090782,
-0.0037131258,
0.0386673473,
-0.0353480317,
0.028915327,
0.0514196791,
-0.0207953155,
0.0562544242,
0.0106771383,
-0.0264912862,
0.0277684163,
-0.0158850271,
-0.0684732348,
0.0541872568,
0.0401548445,
0.0318182111,
0.0279338174,
-0.0401271768,
0.0135237006,
0.0217102859,
0.1233866364,
0.0019402007,
0.0328253284,
-0.0433239751,
0.032249514,
0.0160023198,
0.0074647488,
0.0649233758,
-0.0601311885,
0.0357498564,
0.0157597624,
-0.0234839655,
-0.028434597,
-0.0212269519,
-0.0426127911,
0.0133647351,
0.0200433526,
-0.013917299,
-0.0235543456,
0.0245066695,
-0.0390833877,
0.0227552988,
-0.0199785419,
-0.0511690192,
0.0685839355,
0.0686552897,
0.0267321561,
-0.0209277291,
-0.0074459896,
-0.0450348444,
0.0447556823,
-0.0238588322,
0.0217691045,
-0.0900240988,
0.052067019,
-0.0664020702,
0.0861936286,
0.0222849082,
0.041009631,
-0.0144725107,
-0.0135850338,
-0.0396259427,
-0.0048301122,
0.0371791199,
-0.0492366441,
-0.0106815584,
-0.0079459921,
0.0362299792,
-0.0555518866,
0.0067957537,
0.0315988362,
-0.0393977016,
0.0208443999,
0.0071898536,
-0.031961292,
0.0156526696,
-0.0008995136,
-0.0485156998,
0.0125733986,
-0.0396823399,
0.034560211,
0.037194293,
0.0556102693,
0.019806508,
-0.0145435575,
-0.0050555361,
0.0251532253,
0.0083173402,
-0.0120477481,
-0.0452484787,
0.0087085878,
-0.0135783721,
-0.0304212328,
0.0181424655,
0.0487038568,
0.0400885008,
-0.0159870926,
-0.0520801656,
-0.0260735974,
0.0360824727,
-0.0140246628,
0.0140010994,
0.0216129348,
-0.0305999722,
-0.026193548,
-0.0054841116,
0.0421349294,
0.0118629746,
-0.0062214732,
-0.022647826,
-0.0303599108,
-0.0535909124,
-0.0590642802,
-0.0159833059,
0.000538777,
-0.0280716158,
-0.0762872025,
-0.0351279043,
-0.0071311551,
0.0274866726,
0.0324608311,
0.0169818886,
-0.0305552855,
-0.0266716611,
-0.0383555852,
0.0217687488,
-0.0155525999,
-0.0191366971,
-0.0087629035,
0.0301916245,
-0.0080826841,
0.0011511163,
-0.0010718204,
-0.0513560213,
-0.0195459146,
-0.0400410853,
-0.049843777,
-0.0167630184,
0.0060845739,
-0.040058963,
0.0218797736,
-0.0238466784,
-0.0028473386,
-0.0298226476,
-0.0178179182,
0.0365960672,
-0.0136742331,
0.0340927653,
-0.0466874726,
0.0109437304,
-0.0005667305,
-0.008891616,
0.0079814335,
-0.0117656179,
-0.0463640578,
0.0103412718,
0.0522985943,
-0.0109927664,
-0.012140993,
0.051937677,
0.0166018736,
0.0651111528,
-0.0040058717,
0.0087718414,
-0.008545679,
0.0152375018,
0.0124442633,
0.0416209251,
0.0364442952,
-0.0511771627,
0.0459605306,
-0.0454656631,
0.0445737913,
0.0212298371,
-0.0046120239,
-0.0384603851,
0.0197372437,
-0.0144154141,
-0.0603087321,
-0.0146896131,
0.0784951672,
0.0408696681,
-0.0137223219,
0.0718218237,
0.0045878752,
0.0084547577,
-0.0077647883,
-0.048522003,
0.0783060715,
0.0144006303,
0.0175091997,
-0.0138858678,
0.0095404154,
0.0269345641,
0.0621494427,
-0.0136625385,
0.0405013785,
-0.0333528407,
-0.0851327106,
0.03072384,
0.073040776,
-0.0529295504,
-0.0056616073,
0.0285744518,
-0.0535110012,
-0.0109850056,
0.0593033284,
-0.0098191155,
-0.0406264178,
-0.0269093141,
0.0364190117,
-0.0438470356,
-0.0494136773,
-0.003963849,
-0.0230482779,
0.0900272131,
-0.0383046269,
0.0060554827,
-0.0457794853,
-0.0520618111,
0.0286667533,
-0.0024583985,
0.0283274278,
0.0233192798,
0.0193091258,
0.0175443459,
0.0017146314,
-0.003584703,
-0.0153678199,
-0.0218353439,
-0.0088348845,
0.0148086008,
0.0103708124,
-0.0278288312,
0.0139688104,
0.0499353185,
0.0211714469,
0.0246798657,
0.0520509519,
0.0230242163,
-0.060221035,
0.0167227946,
-0.0021226818,
-0.007177298,
-0.0358371511,
0.0038111343,
0.0552000254,
-0.0450073853,
-0.0572573729,
-0.034157943,
-0.0163638741,
-0.0196743328,
0.0843546018,
0.0416922383,
0.0171083864,
0.04588015,
0.0070846234,
0.0046809497,
0.0273573045,
-0.0076338938,
0.0040898751,
-0.0602156892,
-0.0181628782,
0.0356379077,
-0.0647717714,
-0.0097176256,
-0.0665053651,
-0.0261384789,
-0.0473952852,
0.0293460973,
-0.026707679,
0.0329300053,
0.0390682705,
-0.0147845279,
-0.0281102061,
-0.0060489867,
-0.0625891685,
-0.0052488954,
0.0120961042,
0.0422491096,
-0.0409287699,
-0.0162483491,
0.0109734638,
0.0100617819,
0.0287770219,
0.009139658,
0.0125469025,
-0.0461995453,
-0.0399111584,
-0.0100192381,
0.0429754183,
-0.0215099417,
0.0065792347,
-0.0158594977,
-0.0145216817,
0.0115072234,
0.0121897981,
0.0508639477,
-0.0378527381,
-0.0324269272,
0.0703419149,
0.0275641344,
0.0344261043,
-0.0172917452,
-0.04966693,
-0.0032459716,
0.0407841541,
0.0036218299,
0.0251900312,
0.0563058294,
0.0174231064,
0.0333449841,
0.002350868,
0.0940983742,
0.0182788521,
0.0477682427,
-0.0174329467,
0.0335084572,
-0.0231560245,
0.0281239767,
0.0407229066,
-0.0433204323,
-0.0362100862,
-0.0305254608,
-0.0589990541,
0.0016700974,
0.019542601,
0.0360077396,
0.1500552595,
0.0017819237,
0.0352195874,
-0.0185584854,
0.0030555758,
-0.0066340864,
0.0097867073,
-0.0477914587,
-0.0350203328,
-0.0359057188,
0.0500039347,
0.0174965914,
0.0268039182,
0.0046699354,
-0.0294634569,
-0.000393957,
-0.0069001736,
-0.0354663432,
0.0567668602,
-0.0181306582,
-0.0229758099,
-0.0120924581,
-0.0541481338,
-0.0064832,
0.0023584391,
0.0162832569,
0.0069484627,
-0.0350161046,
-0.0059772008,
0.026223287,
-0.0395824425,
0.0052709691,
-0.0391067266,
0.0018708296,
0.0267921928,
-0.0281457752,
0.0105455788,
-5.277349195e-33,
-0.0233794991,
0.0287746321,
-0.0108419135,
-0.0438222289,
-0.0042584739,
-0.0511676893,
-0.0137254484,
0.0121115819,
-0.0318306535,
-0.0119228736,
0.0229701307,
-0.0282068457,
0.0251058713,
0.0133371186,
0.0150993913,
0.0071812766,
0.039758727,
0.0194768645,
-0.0077474844,
-0.0263662748,
0.0360552482,
0.0050165113,
0.0518037677,
-0.0401800163,
-0.0236279722,
-0.0169273689,
0.0018874489,
-0.0224818904,
0.0367591269,
0.0138419783,
0.0063218479,
0.0263519026,
-0.0166775435,
-0.0185535699,
-0.0228850748,
0.0246230587,
-0.0391801372,
0.0016191419,
0.0480491742,
0.0893067494,
0.0408645198,
0.0011533363,
0.0106330682,
0.0033208572,
-0.0262026023,
0.0106555466,
0.0044934177,
-0.0207525976,
-0.0259782486,
-0.0132482192,
-0.0870967656,
0.0146708274,
0.0098776156,
0.0215506759,
0.0517339557,
0.0824284554,
-0.0442535691,
-0.081173718,
-0.0360908285,
0.0213770662,
0.0304190964,
0.0007896468,
0.0355861261,
-0.0162998419,
-0.0576425493,
-0.0356793515,
0.0471923091,
0.0034564591,
0.0838476345,
-0.0303069521,
0.0850305334,
-0.0002147255,
-0.0080667716,
0.032008402,
0.0318776891,
-0.0504841395,
0.0105839111,
-0.0191525351,
0.0135181453,
-0.0529288948,
-0.0067729335,
0.0216872524,
0.0087179355,
-0.0007375033,
-0.0312961303,
-0.0360458978,
0.0167036839,
-0.0085793231,
0.0488207191,
0.0009661417,
-0.0007933048,
0.0046423031,
0.1253321916,
-0.0130682671,
-0.0085446034,
-0.0596733876,
-0.023078138,
0.0189630147,
-0.073916778,
0.0403664596,
-0.0043705162,
-0.0805109963,
0.0117200902,
0.0460025109,
0.0047877687,
-0.0157588907,
0.0382550359,
-0.0038018271,
-0.0264023393,
0.0013764837,
-0.0054444433,
0.0297151264,
-0.0389347076,
0.0044763545,
-0.0009323654,
0.0064753923,
0.0256703999,
0.0070963353,
-0.0009539519,
-0.0309144426,
-0.0151172867,
0.0248498097,
0.0319329575,
0.0616834685,
-0.0412027761,
0.0221026111,
0.011669348,
-0.0362271331,
0.0386676528,
0.0302837994,
-0.0140476096,
-0.0161526743,
2.348e-7,
0.0402419716,
0.0472028591,
-0.0380297638,
-0.0630445853,
0.0372105353,
-0.01047453,
-0.0102383625,
0.0382218845,
0.0232318882,
0.0057865242,
0.0135098649,
-0.0036024291,
0.0764581561,
0.0460918173,
-0.0230436455,
-0.0797715709,
-0.0575890131,
0.0322487019,
-0.0285070259,
0.0197570994,
0.048486013,
0.0499512851,
-0.0350337662,
-0.0139066037,
-0.0010897769,
0.0022451994,
0.0470246412,
-0.0130261471,
-0.0361188464,
0.0413000397,
0.0244188383,
-0.0031467672,
-0.0511687472,
0.030210536,
-0.0001792937,
0.024365548,
0.0284406152,
0.069883503,
-0.0462498777,
-0.0545849055,
-0.006376972,
-0.0180907268,
-0.0371449664,
0.0168926045,
0.0017102043,
-0.0066719977,
0.0335249417,
0.0298825782,
-0.023315018,
0.0617088601,
0.0174431503,
-0.0268603601,
0.0290548522,
-0.0172025394,
0.0646428913,
0.0053948364,
-0.0558946803,
0.0070331888,
-0.014956031,
0.0632368103,
-0.008776553,
-0.0663073286,
0.0132093383,
0.0393296145,
-0.0240473747,
-0.0358900279,
0.016784301,
1.845255331e-34,
0.053840179,
-0.0234496538,
0.0279659275,
-0.0444845185,
0.0369837359,
-0.0242737718,
-0.0547246262,
0.0108470805,
-0.0416651517,
0.0110023133,
-0.0194021184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09044v1 | KCTS: Knowledge-Constrained Tree Search Decoding with Token-Level Hallucination Detection | 2023-10-13T12:12:34 | 2023-10-13T12:12:34 | Sehyun Choi, Tianqing Fang, Zhaowei Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable human-level natural
language generation capabilities. However, their potential to generate
misinformation, often called the hallucination problem, poses a significant
risk to their deployment. A common approach to address this issue is to
retrieve relevant knowledge and fine-tune the LLM with the knowledge in its
input. Unfortunately, this method incurs high training costs and may cause
catastrophic forgetting for multi-tasking models. To overcome these
limitations, we propose a knowledge-constrained decoding method called KCTS
(Knowledge-Constrained Tree Search), which guides a frozen LM to generate text
aligned with the reference knowledge at each decoding step using a knowledge
classifier score and MCTS (Monte-Carlo Tree Search). To adapt the
sequence-level knowledge classifier to token-level guidance, we also propose a
novel token-level hallucination detection method called RIPA (Reward Inflection
Point Approximation). Our empirical results on knowledge-grounded dialogue and
abstractive summarization demonstrate the strength of KCTS as a plug-and-play,
model-agnostic decoding method that can effectively reduce hallucinations in
natural language generation. | [
0.0260164123,
0.0394323692,
0.0107882461,
0.0240309499,
-0.0144072995,
0.0226158183,
-0.0721559301,
-0.0019780549,
-0.0120189376,
-0.0461591668,
-0.0108282547,
-0.0277534034,
0.008816991,
0.0149798477,
0.0004011244,
-0.0432997979,
0.0390993878,
-0.0380438492,
0.0242613517,
0.0018581952,
0.0057429587,
0.0396937616,
-0.0153313298,
0.0609550476,
-0.0404300801,
-0.0406067409,
-0.0134703517,
0.0298261568,
0.0127277682,
-0.0274225902,
0.0102173751,
0.0408370234,
0.0190728754,
0.0531937517,
0.0000021164,
-0.0261529777,
-0.0438898914,
-0.0202657375,
-0.0309535451,
-0.0111772595,
0.0179973096,
-0.0222492479,
0.0066139507,
0.0187136699,
-0.0162278581,
0.0115250302,
0.0374259204,
0.0868128985,
0.0714010373,
0.0895336643,
0.0090366583,
-0.0267355759,
0.0198394898,
0.0173645057,
0.0164558329,
-0.0312397368,
0.0106127039,
0.0456032343,
-0.0178427473,
-0.0340946056,
0.0219694264,
0.0472954698,
0.0180432312,
-0.01018833,
-0.0046661124,
0.0534331463,
-0.0581694953,
-0.0126679335,
-0.0132628456,
0.0650727004,
-0.0229454655,
-0.0666015148,
0.0282129925,
-0.0039468487,
0.006540393,
-0.0471297391,
-0.0177561454,
0.045040004,
-0.0296858139,
0.0232562162,
0.0359561555,
-0.0087179253,
0.0355406031,
0.0108990986,
-0.0302121323,
0.0683662966,
-0.0035775425,
-0.0445930064,
0.0257789381,
0.0030482281,
-0.036816489,
-0.0423785001,
0.0148001285,
0.0341535211,
-0.0851313621,
0.0009199881,
-0.0704057813,
-0.0191073921,
0.0049775583,
-0.0435320549,
0.0103173228,
0.0270477943,
-0.0109897731,
0.0175472796,
-0.0075832233,
0.0532572381,
0.0145424465,
0.0239285976,
-0.0385788642,
0.0034443981,
-0.0433230996,
-0.057255052,
-0.0696578994,
0.0325279608,
-0.0644736961,
-0.0183890443,
0.0041013784,
0.0222519431,
0.0001296171,
0.02169987,
0.0007138309,
0.032449469,
-0.0251480173,
-0.0211853143,
0.0230018478,
0.0201893095,
-0.0142853875,
-0.0210212376,
0.0580251589,
-0.0288777668,
-0.0511957854,
0.0457156003,
0.0020779811,
0.0086018117,
0.0023899849,
0.021514602,
-0.0386835672,
-0.0087951673,
-0.0033989267,
-0.0565624349,
-0.0621515475,
-0.0677957907,
-0.0091044158,
-0.0412055589,
-0.0070453621,
-0.0015653409,
-0.0065287468,
-0.0223974138,
0.0271523856,
0.0094770296,
-0.0265023932,
0.0407240503,
-0.0191858374,
-0.0026741726,
0.052399639,
0.0199333411,
-0.0136939269,
0.0806789175,
0.0222593453,
0.0434810258,
-0.0051810131,
0.0101658292,
0.0194403715,
0.0082419887,
0.0139415208,
-0.0046482189,
0.0149391014,
-0.005671869,
-0.0163528584,
0.0252368059,
0.0383360386,
0.0540661551,
-0.0409289971,
0.0473674871,
0.0645669699,
-0.009016701,
-0.0328512229,
0.010880461,
0.0290041454,
0.042095039,
-0.0175195392,
0.0292134304,
-0.0364652723,
0.0242629312,
-0.0398466811,
0.0437423363,
0.0491965823,
-0.002312626,
-0.0272998717,
-0.0208719932,
0.0164471846,
0.0021116955,
-0.004177893,
0.0011270739,
-0.0075141308,
0.0458486043,
-0.0944297537,
0.0824800655,
-0.0148938689,
-0.0346039832,
0.0209281258,
-0.0332511999,
-0.0011501311,
0.0851930529,
0.058799766,
-0.0236748829,
-0.017064523,
-0.014602947,
0.012935997,
0.0749280751,
-0.0038969608,
-0.013793841,
-0.0035326511,
-0.0506160483,
0.0034782407,
-0.0186414588,
0.062579751,
0.0041484758,
-0.0197444316,
0.0099391118,
0.0433945172,
-0.0208615456,
-0.0329386108,
0.0318502001,
-0.0057430686,
-0.0047446028,
-0.0074964385,
-0.0204881132,
0.0125788329,
0.0152285732,
-0.0235706009,
0.035532739,
0.0152263511,
-0.0570732467,
-0.0440476201,
0.0388201922,
-0.0702709481,
-0.0808588937,
0.0001832102,
-0.0176632311,
-0.0094199292,
0.0102787754,
-0.0078000054,
-0.059449587,
0.0065106913,
-0.0598176382,
0.0596342161,
-0.0570256449,
0.0515075997,
0.023134049,
0.0008818841,
-0.0059346161,
0.0935185179,
-0.0375088453,
-0.0110499039,
0.0487520956,
-0.037103571,
-0.0308606029,
-0.0360362008,
0.002933803,
0.0034568692,
-0.0035872313,
0.0167735536,
0.0048108152,
0.0268104579,
-0.0385142714,
-0.0323417187,
-0.0872202888,
0.0193305407,
-0.0467848405,
0.0141412877,
0.0347857401,
-0.0003898022,
-0.0060727685,
0.015778264,
-0.023614632,
-0.0079397364,
0.041287031,
-0.0213388298,
0.0065760287,
0.0194845367,
-0.0114159295,
-0.0069547463,
0.0429045632,
0.0118206553,
0.0385021791,
-0.0294085797,
-0.0363072865,
-0.0783882663,
0.0679024905,
-0.0131339962,
-0.014942335,
-0.0012369971,
-0.0068631666,
0.0133311031,
0.0189654082,
0.0726313218,
0.0426378399,
0.022294458,
0.0334483646,
0.0397343151,
-0.0282365493,
-0.0278856326,
0.0279498212,
-0.0071139853,
0.0176460687,
-0.0185990408,
-0.0186864845,
0.0579950921,
0.0670044571,
0.0365456901,
0.0329648182,
-0.0835192129,
0.0112116486,
-0.020093102,
-0.0698753968,
-0.0110642482,
-0.022665685,
-0.0299753156,
-0.0048523895,
-0.0396680608,
-0.0248756576,
0.0651602671,
-0.0429876484,
0.0018282052,
-0.0206544977,
0.0098160421,
-0.0121723702,
0.043561358,
-0.0038614227,
0.0325060338,
-0.00525284,
-0.0428858213,
-0.0263244715,
0.004063034,
-0.0167594869,
-0.0368314981,
0.0245390423,
-0.0479836538,
0.0015688932,
0.0105404016,
-0.0249183886,
-0.0410776027,
-0.0212826282,
-0.0076345997,
-0.0080784224,
0.0329711363,
-0.0143263768,
-0.0234516114,
0.0106298588,
0.017786622,
0.0316376165,
-0.0222325027,
-0.0172036737,
-0.0280219987,
0.0483590439,
0.0802688077,
0.0110827172,
0.0182747673,
-0.0499476679,
0.0446031168,
0.0631028414,
0.0280695166,
0.0372496881,
0.0152349062,
-0.0081521617,
0.0157236196,
-0.0160452239,
-0.0316033363,
0.0235870481,
0.0571802594,
-0.0552712865,
-0.0463153794,
0.1083110794,
0.036318399,
-0.0272530485,
0.005569926,
-0.0316127092,
0.1104967669,
-0.0071757836,
0.0020404966,
-0.0632121712,
-0.032935746,
0.0119654154,
0.0333388299,
-0.0276404098,
-0.0125776418,
-0.0246184077,
-0.0799686387,
0.0186473988,
0.0380011722,
-0.0766382813,
-0.0563344434,
0.0045201369,
-0.0600776486,
0.0420168787,
0.0318344198,
0.0292721428,
0.0143054547,
-0.0049646818,
0.027803205,
-0.0607133172,
-0.0310367811,
-0.012899016,
-0.0133975334,
0.0476409979,
0.1118862405,
0.064201273,
0.0250612684,
-0.0073901811,
0.0009117191,
-0.0157172494,
0.0065513426,
-0.0113886707,
0.0014272877,
-0.0156596284,
0.011733545,
0.0001906931,
0.0286088455,
-0.0323843211,
-0.0120674828,
0.0096790744,
0.0605871119,
-0.0460364297,
-0.0450594909,
0.0175371505,
0.0152784763,
0.0323297903,
0.1021410897,
0.0227128286,
-0.0000298491,
-0.0630205944,
-0.032467436,
0.0537581854,
-0.0801924393,
0.0056075486,
0.0538022406,
0.0248369053,
0.0111245736,
-0.0975441113,
0.0008893131,
0.0183425732,
0.025495572,
-0.0178054702,
0.0377883129,
-0.035770677,
0.0080847982,
-0.030522503,
-0.0155627169,
-0.0599492639,
-0.0171292443,
-0.0197891723,
-0.0072285933,
0.0101474943,
-0.0447767004,
0.0024869931,
0.0542615056,
-0.0713120326,
-0.0740457401,
-0.03578116,
0.021515213,
0.021361649,
0.0927637666,
0.0043422827,
-0.0308529548,
0.0632825866,
0.0508553125,
-0.0223744605,
0.0406792201,
0.001008709,
-0.0032158475,
-0.0119262571,
0.0273367781,
-0.0620608032,
-0.0171614215,
-0.0244626794,
0.0648136958,
-0.0155351432,
0.0020798801,
0.0512381308,
0.0098593617,
-0.0418616757,
-0.0341406912,
-0.002259854,
-0.0084801605,
0.0105508976,
-0.019376792,
-0.026356956,
-0.0515306108,
0.0013752986,
0.0380717665,
-0.0145373791,
0.0108366776,
-0.000569546,
0.0134423655,
0.0286846347,
-0.011130685,
-0.040141549,
0.0075022229,
0.0144718355,
0.0459853858,
-0.0477720872,
-0.0489807799,
0.0002510868,
-0.018866891,
0.0275731757,
-0.0032193174,
0.062952809,
0.0029891487,
-0.0347005092,
0.0130559932,
0.0228355471,
-0.039695207,
-0.066257745,
-0.0451231338,
-0.0090494594,
0.0710442886,
0.0116069354,
0.0973888114,
-0.0602755211,
0.0326951221,
-0.0198462512,
0.0302811302,
0.0545851737,
-0.0597027168,
-0.010427976,
0.0196007062,
-0.0339540243,
-0.0119799348,
0.0919046998,
0.0223871153,
0.0443343781,
-0.0055923602,
-0.0239848327,
-0.0483878925,
-0.0516695082,
-0.0349598005,
0.0092687458,
-0.0211311914,
-0.0258645639,
-0.0394153856,
-0.0365819111,
0.0038653982,
-0.0027657368,
0.0080466364,
-0.0283246804,
0.0365370549,
0.0408590697,
-0.040198572,
-0.0508144349,
-0.0267183241,
-0.0134239774,
0.0150198638,
0.006021515,
-0.041260004,
-6.51528103e-33,
-0.0276202299,
-0.032313481,
0.0197577365,
-0.0222979244,
-0.0473794192,
-0.0126201473,
-0.0538658872,
-0.0080537796,
0.0502493456,
0.0059238379,
0.0102425013,
0.0116807297,
0.0115864389,
0.0411415882,
-0.0267690979,
-0.0038864336,
0.0628016889,
-0.0056743897,
-0.0281861071,
0.0650453344,
0.0610593371,
0.0319084674,
0.0172408298,
-0.0161247291,
0.0249631982,
-0.040404506,
-0.0388183333,
0.0146213779,
0.0129603362,
0.0005478412,
-0.0363587327,
0.0240059104,
0.0233188402,
-0.047224842,
-0.0464907326,
-0.0043753986,
-0.0519744679,
0.0161646232,
0.0023837038,
0.0090236943,
-0.0237132646,
-0.0486695543,
0.0478849597,
-0.0022210653,
0.0282519255,
0.0187414084,
0.0037501887,
-0.0397508778,
-0.0266010594,
-0.036762096,
-0.063518472,
0.0052711335,
-0.0220571719,
-0.0229019821,
-0.0160916168,
0.0605789125,
-0.004204087,
-0.0289853588,
-0.0482437871,
0.0284332391,
0.0018797377,
0.0232925899,
0.0566545352,
0.034891814,
-0.007457702,
0.0762828514,
0.0176541898,
-0.0073695839,
-0.035249114,
0.0152407493,
-0.0041169375,
0.0476180837,
0.0003257623,
0.0151533112,
0.0393993966,
-0.0211359803,
-0.0322920717,
0.0209795702,
-0.045014061,
0.0263438653,
0.0647358298,
0.0017711343,
-0.0472294949,
-0.0364422463,
-0.0226451606,
0.0239456929,
-0.0091825174,
-0.0138408337,
0.0569212027,
0.0559484959,
-0.0078063123,
-0.0452905633,
0.0359362625,
-0.0109568667,
0.0481673405,
0.0367842317,
-0.031796243,
-0.0042249924,
-0.0270716492,
0.0088204257,
-0.0278828386,
-0.0349399783,
0.0510897078,
-0.0203665718,
0.0208520982,
0.0246769451,
-0.0002642774,
0.0027778514,
-0.0437391698,
0.0154132582,
-0.0162832811,
0.0519956984,
-0.0126418406,
0.0137250721,
0.0532107353,
-0.0224169418,
-0.0191345848,
-0.0112359347,
-0.0045540226,
0.0026443219,
-0.0103092398,
0.0066260314,
-0.0251736566,
0.0149857402,
-0.0212957859,
0.0126313018,
-0.0097129643,
-0.040157035,
-0.0095497901,
-0.072996363,
-0.0117866416,
0.0020120654,
2.835e-7,
-0.0154687641,
0.0460842662,
0.0239734296,
0.0125859547,
0.0265917201,
0.0201825108,
0.0102138994,
0.0140610989,
0.0047047343,
-0.0615732335,
0.016299095,
0.0086961789,
0.0945196971,
0.0212461762,
-0.1501484513,
-0.0171076078,
-0.0501103401,
0.0003287217,
-0.0563938729,
-0.0578584075,
0.0514526553,
0.0455125608,
-0.0407582521,
-0.0088635106,
0.0277170166,
-0.0463471636,
0.0709928498,
-0.0010060609,
0.0109075876,
0.0162274782,
0.0569856986,
-0.0022212013,
-0.0123852277,
0.0524805672,
-0.0185076129,
-0.0233675372,
0.0178509671,
0.0323765874,
0.0325244255,
-0.0696891025,
0.00426553,
0.0169261787,
0.0022598598,
-0.0574975275,
0.0620951839,
-0.0329332165,
0.0040020803,
0.0140827447,
-0.0258670859,
-0.0139414435,
-0.0119783171,
-0.0065290015,
-0.0112115266,
0.0232515391,
0.0058039767,
0.0263538174,
0.0215842631,
-0.049836766,
-0.0266746767,
0.0012415427,
-0.0379855223,
-0.0310168173,
-0.0461309105,
0.0191364549,
0.0004491739,
-0.0884513184,
-0.0024153215,
2.926289871e-34,
0.0369287096,
-0.0422297269,
0.02703478,
0.0441837646,
0.0347161666,
0.0158166084,
0.0361128524,
0.0138477487,
0.0118442634,
-0.0488228165,
-0.0091752335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09036v1 | MM-BigBench: Evaluating Multimodal Models on Multimodal Content Comprehension Tasks | 2023-10-13T11:57:04 | 2023-10-13T11:57:04 | Xiaocui Yang, Wenfang Wu, Shi Feng, Ming Wang, Daling Wang, Yang Li, Qi Sun, Yifei Zhang, Xiaoming Fu, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | The popularity of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) has triggered a
recent surge in research efforts dedicated to evaluating these models.
Nevertheless, existing evaluation studies of MLLMs primarily focus on the
comprehension and reasoning of unimodal (vision) content, neglecting
performance evaluations in the domain of multimodal (vision-language) content
understanding. Beyond multimodal reasoning, tasks related to multimodal content
comprehension necessitate a profound understanding of multimodal contexts,
achieved through the multimodal interaction to obtain a final answer. In this
paper, we introduce a comprehensive assessment framework called MM-BigBench,
which incorporates a diverse range of metrics to offer an extensive evaluation
of the performance of various models and instructions across a wide spectrum of
diverse multimodal content comprehension tasks. Consequently, our work
complements research on the performance of MLLMs in multimodal comprehension
tasks, achieving a more comprehensive and holistic evaluation of MLLMs. To
begin, we employ the Best Performance metric to ascertain each model's
performance upper bound on different datasets. Subsequently, the Mean Relative
Gain metric offers an assessment of the overall performance of various models
and instructions, while the Stability metric measures their sensitivity.
Furthermore, previous research centers on evaluating models independently or
solely assessing instructions, neglecting the adaptability between models and
instructions. We propose the Adaptability metric to quantify the adaptability
between models and instructions. Our paper evaluates a total of 20 language
models (14 MLLMs) on 14 multimodal datasets spanning 6 tasks, with 10
instructions for each task, and derives novel insights. Our code will be
released at https://github.com/declare-lab/MM-BigBench. | [
0.0147906039,
0.0510893315,
-0.0165601876,
0.0482059233,
-0.0482382514,
0.0199219473,
0.0382550694,
-0.0213193018,
0.0040497668,
-0.0657891408,
-0.0637601465,
-0.0371723436,
0.0259132683,
0.0214705747,
0.0264616162,
-0.0506771654,
0.0234448407,
-0.0568686984,
-0.0432234593,
0.0117148086,
-0.0024264951,
-0.0025950475,
-0.0390105881,
0.0505471714,
-0.0010802048,
-0.039177265,
0.006770479,
0.0146180661,
0.0172629561,
-0.0221299473,
-0.0229637902,
0.0253467709,
0.0381355919,
0.0146386493,
0.0000020308,
-0.0261398554,
0.015433724,
-0.0069375974,
0.0321075432,
0.004197761,
0.0436272398,
-0.0442516319,
0.0196848381,
-0.034763623,
-0.0061094183,
-0.0065157833,
0.0599949509,
0.0072294907,
0.0718402788,
0.0229551066,
-0.0151523286,
-0.0322894678,
0.0005517356,
0.004051439,
0.0280727819,
-0.0642260164,
0.014567663,
0.0895792097,
0.015061724,
0.0025557263,
-0.0851095766,
0.0630466789,
0.0385551006,
0.0074934093,
-0.0246892329,
0.0210871063,
0.0480638631,
-0.0451903082,
-0.0198904201,
0.1006336063,
-0.0046603894,
0.0026269883,
-0.0317835324,
0.0017946715,
0.0049183825,
0.0335786343,
-0.0750552043,
0.0230492316,
-0.0057809218,
-0.0113474987,
-0.0443453901,
-0.0269635245,
0.0446401127,
0.0104275281,
-0.0028799202,
0.0448785797,
0.0138180181,
0.0025917629,
0.0111020273,
-0.0258722343,
-0.0488641597,
-0.0056062946,
-0.0028400563,
0.0454903096,
-0.016638631,
0.0147283776,
-0.0386810414,
-0.0359617993,
0.011864976,
-0.0317498893,
0.0727590173,
0.0397031307,
-0.0565770827,
0.1098383069,
-0.0355817638,
0.0462772176,
-0.030741537,
0.0403484553,
-0.0256433971,
0.0033903117,
-0.0418548808,
0.0127841868,
0.0008013879,
-0.0212413259,
-0.0520568378,
-0.0803742856,
0.0018205417,
0.0298530534,
0.0115667935,
0.0107457759,
-0.0108959023,
-0.0103349024,
-0.0069773458,
-0.0069492869,
-0.0008157485,
0.0523791201,
-0.0376597457,
0.0233372245,
-0.0010397702,
-0.0470610373,
0.0209410693,
0.0410799943,
-0.0166608393,
-0.0429692566,
-0.016076576,
0.0939408913,
-0.0196090061,
-0.0392304175,
-0.0205505602,
-0.0325711183,
-0.0195389278,
-0.0578641035,
0.0354456119,
-0.0214220006,
0.0363714248,
-0.0116224363,
0.0251601543,
-0.0168057494,
-0.0329100527,
-0.0102800792,
0.0088779349,
0.0983431712,
0.0111569697,
0.0249533467,
0.0378280245,
0.0362962224,
-0.0420766436,
0.0703133196,
0.0146734314,
0.0183113571,
0.0618816204,
-0.0190828238,
-0.0287341364,
0.0492830053,
-0.0225431733,
0.0009870387,
-0.0126596894,
0.0081622768,
0.0226151254,
0.0392936245,
0.0149741275,
0.0322593115,
-0.037714418,
-0.0579681173,
0.0987781212,
0.0084583191,
0.028872354,
-0.030060729,
0.031216519,
-0.0184442382,
0.0060076984,
0.0076175896,
-0.0472378097,
0.0487181284,
-0.0285778847,
-0.0027690406,
0.0491587743,
0.0334510282,
-0.0147218183,
-0.0265557393,
-0.0007949105,
-0.0035222359,
0.0395534113,
0.0417672731,
0.0645416975,
0.0113635454,
-0.0424274653,
-0.011243701,
0.0093346005,
-0.0263752975,
0.0069095143,
-0.0342981592,
0.0517360531,
0.0340947919,
0.0596227422,
-0.0145941423,
-0.0208737236,
0.0135095874,
0.0454971083,
0.0084607927,
0.0091145104,
-0.0009828322,
0.0541322678,
-0.0655983016,
-0.0428544655,
0.0030071544,
-0.0002040881,
0.0365286954,
-0.0030151755,
-0.0180085152,
0.0017558549,
-0.0499163084,
0.0416670702,
0.0215655975,
-0.0065711546,
0.0262022931,
-0.037654575,
-0.0006653594,
0.0177556276,
0.0156212831,
-0.0130827464,
-0.0134689836,
0.0001158979,
-0.033804968,
0.0144022144,
0.0237612091,
-0.0510575883,
-0.0222814102,
0.0249374267,
-0.0492448807,
-0.007622079,
0.0472965464,
-0.002479227,
0.0115319425,
0.0311326012,
-0.0224892348,
-0.0031051473,
-0.050801903,
-0.0321456902,
0.0007065625,
0.0300528165,
-0.0402097292,
0.0175985452,
-0.0381161273,
0.0225310326,
0.0166406743,
0.0018595989,
0.0052584773,
0.0042300434,
-0.0417311825,
0.0223416127,
-0.0116527248,
0.0033320673,
-0.0042658742,
-0.0073637497,
-0.0490853414,
-0.01582551,
-0.1022847965,
-0.0249732435,
-0.0291421171,
-0.0256168544,
0.0124899643,
0.0155302137,
-0.0054143793,
-0.0229318812,
0.0147072487,
0.0213594344,
0.0019010137,
0.0352682732,
0.0038639426,
0.0197292343,
0.0080357883,
-0.0253364537,
-0.0294286292,
0.0238224585,
0.0934488028,
0.0208442993,
0.0102917766,
-0.048287876,
-0.0169631466,
-0.0534980446,
0.0106163276,
-0.0316905789,
-0.0325546004,
0.030005211,
-0.0349915475,
0.0442659818,
0.0756281167,
-0.0139724966,
0.0273523312,
0.03916087,
-0.0369185954,
-0.0311176628,
0.0040098303,
0.0187407844,
-0.0203103833,
-0.026196681,
-0.0340380855,
-0.0365448594,
0.0634311363,
0.0214959998,
-0.0076532844,
-0.041815117,
0.004588251,
-0.0273623522,
-0.072899811,
-0.0502877422,
0.0212535225,
0.0177254677,
0.039160911,
-0.0378969051,
-0.0361567959,
0.047522787,
-0.050685253,
-0.017051382,
0.0130539387,
0.0137485527,
-0.0300263911,
0.0900874883,
0.0217733346,
0.0408782363,
-0.0325547494,
-0.0097943181,
-0.027894875,
-0.0165387336,
0.0496363267,
-0.0008651371,
0.0471637584,
-0.0582667813,
-0.0024357243,
-0.0072772116,
0.0021611124,
0.0183274094,
-0.0190214645,
-0.008055754,
-0.0256312657,
-0.0197001267,
0.0104509862,
-0.0334845372,
0.0517260805,
0.0413517468,
-0.0040745679,
-0.005564393,
-0.0222435724,
-0.0124814995,
0.0142489476,
0.0389605798,
0.0480300114,
-0.0264390595,
-0.0849606842,
0.0064178784,
0.0325135849,
0.0115979156,
-0.0123695815,
-0.0755434558,
0.0639502257,
0.0277037583,
0.0301928278,
-0.0051194918,
0.0179337021,
0.0790684596,
-0.0566226505,
0.0282756817,
0.0740924105,
-0.0152493557,
-0.0335521214,
-0.0095671527,
-0.0122248996,
0.0315402299,
0.0268361587,
-0.0192441382,
-0.0731998235,
-0.0745561123,
-0.0071416404,
0.0028181588,
0.0440469235,
-0.0247166995,
-0.0069123753,
-0.0754109621,
0.0445114337,
-0.0066980356,
-0.0512477867,
-0.0412956476,
-0.0405378304,
0.0336705893,
-0.0045784106,
0.0008140794,
0.0290276632,
0.0059677651,
-0.0099007916,
-0.0117282048,
0.0087643201,
-0.0440015197,
0.0248151049,
-0.0295393132,
0.0164297689,
0.0340350829,
-0.0147585105,
0.0134855043,
-0.0217711776,
0.0679833144,
0.0037283094,
0.0080688,
-0.0253275372,
0.0206188187,
-0.0242040455,
-0.0269870907,
-0.0040075895,
0.0198302045,
0.0104773715,
-0.0289624799,
-0.0018615483,
0.0634520575,
0.0032329536,
-0.0135095995,
-0.0614174791,
0.0309837367,
-0.0055473233,
0.0416931771,
0.0477505252,
-0.0604321323,
-0.0220668353,
0.0060008503,
-0.0077974657,
-0.025271887,
0.0115817171,
-0.0017576843,
0.0183869526,
0.0269323513,
-0.0414013825,
-0.0298693012,
0.0129056508,
0.0556355305,
0.0058024875,
-0.0014414026,
-0.0130838817,
0.0181346405,
-0.0229480397,
0.0538447872,
-0.0013490596,
0.0499768145,
-0.0481035076,
0.0234941691,
0.0152444839,
-0.0548034273,
-0.0238054302,
0.0317047313,
-0.0812518299,
-0.0245148484,
-0.0293857623,
0.0512584001,
0.021595858,
0.013095947,
0.022600174,
-0.0765011013,
-0.022477109,
-0.0099661984,
-0.0240422264,
0.0395843685,
0.0126523143,
0.0080702584,
-0.0010711207,
0.0109802168,
-0.0469372422,
0.0100668976,
0.0009628212,
0.0637966171,
0.0038707096,
-0.0279612262,
-0.0179868098,
-0.0043609873,
0.0094066262,
-0.0149677312,
-0.0147680938,
-0.0174442995,
-0.0038934257,
0.0137909455,
-0.0056058862,
-0.0662654713,
0.0218962859,
0.0384787917,
-0.002405477,
-0.0074252733,
0.0004999826,
0.0293133631,
0.0413745381,
-0.0443420336,
0.0516152121,
0.0042184778,
-0.0364100523,
-0.0096777212,
0.0252736285,
-0.02027403,
0.0045999736,
-0.0426969863,
0.020588832,
0.0245738532,
0.1193112284,
0.0335694514,
-0.022534309,
-0.0074080126,
0.0574473403,
-0.027345458,
0.0025301829,
0.0045264536,
0.0522515289,
0.0544445403,
0.0287988838,
0.036223311,
-0.0026051514,
-0.0191083681,
-0.0425519384,
0.056090001,
0.0047448934,
-0.0464351438,
0.0533472188,
0.0304943472,
0.0468476005,
0.0152474986,
0.0566480532,
-0.0238146875,
0.0233099926,
0.0076968502,
0.0231061354,
-0.055137787,
-0.0276096351,
0.0178856235,
0.0424016304,
-0.021614261,
0.0333584026,
-0.0176157914,
-0.071406424,
-0.0243868269,
0.0500059091,
0.0025989623,
0.0227057207,
0.0172132701,
0.08058092,
0.006549553,
-0.0167048555,
-0.0426010862,
-0.0058566756,
-0.0108672073,
0.0143147828,
0.014718526,
-6.133039287e-33,
-0.0241655111,
-0.0138545409,
0.0156248147,
-0.0160905495,
-0.0253672916,
-0.0102665266,
-0.0479223132,
0.0259802453,
-0.0074749878,
-0.0074738171,
0.0465472713,
-0.0264824945,
-0.0122213829,
0.0246349983,
-0.0257302225,
-0.0179297458,
-0.0088441782,
0.0009958326,
-0.048256807,
-0.008926888,
-0.0025673397,
0.0227837991,
0.0162701998,
-0.0336192548,
0.0282225795,
0.0279237628,
-0.0283074658,
0.0162563063,
-0.0004364296,
0.0860292315,
-0.054122515,
0.0211420488,
0.0354553238,
-0.0196530968,
-0.031265974,
0.0237751063,
-0.0915939733,
0.0131920977,
0.044986207,
0.0326979756,
-0.1035670266,
0.0156751107,
0.0555424616,
0.0021470888,
-0.0048955143,
-0.0542459562,
0.0354675688,
-0.0304025952,
-0.0161903128,
0.0249566697,
-0.0296289083,
0.0306510814,
-0.0395361781,
-0.0533474796,
0.0324902795,
0.0653484836,
0.021452548,
0.0439757779,
-0.0247912742,
0.017117111,
-0.0365930833,
0.0056156088,
0.0997143462,
0.0287926365,
0.0158248991,
0.0479003787,
0.0227133911,
-0.0381230228,
-0.0262414031,
-0.0149502102,
0.0393268317,
0.0467690788,
0.0152776362,
0.0615584366,
0.0001911756,
0.017882444,
-0.0369282253,
0.0290829502,
-0.01284198,
0.0467705317,
0.0518386103,
0.0216794647,
-0.013440121,
0.0096042166,
-0.0748294443,
0.0116969831,
-0.0629756674,
-0.0101682302,
0.0700186044,
-0.0177853145,
-0.0251601096,
-0.0058928486,
0.0938328728,
-0.0639675334,
-0.0200559571,
0.0184234343,
-0.0197924264,
0.0723325387,
0.0069281138,
0.0447341092,
0.0011815097,
0.0030383174,
0.036160849,
-0.0185010489,
0.0263089687,
-0.0369704403,
-0.0218040235,
0.0568097979,
-0.0314749852,
-0.0322548859,
-0.0280188192,
0.0069794571,
-0.0077660922,
0.0343707465,
0.0298750978,
-0.0050745183,
-0.0787195861,
0.0425722338,
-0.0183329303,
0.0023489632,
-0.0231475215,
-0.0562273078,
-0.0261747222,
-0.0004582143,
-0.046008449,
-0.0121310493,
-0.017712405,
-0.0596868321,
0.0004961989,
-0.058433339,
-0.0062393295,
0.0601037331,
2.692e-7,
0.0391058996,
0.0479597449,
-0.0306578819,
0.0212646499,
0.0225821808,
0.0378240719,
-0.040575292,
0.0295844153,
0.0090254173,
-0.0692390725,
-0.0238148198,
0.0518177785,
0.0372948796,
-0.005105013,
-0.0080456305,
-0.0066563967,
-0.0087358467,
0.0245723929,
-0.0395219401,
0.0279720984,
0.0595894791,
0.0412312038,
-0.0320033841,
-0.0339457132,
0.028672846,
-0.0390508585,
0.0709790587,
-0.0601657704,
-0.0210003685,
-0.023677554,
0.050466042,
0.0165720955,
0.0176709592,
0.0102109965,
0.0321358256,
-0.0511255376,
0.0626939908,
0.0358406119,
0.0221319757,
-0.0339413993,
-0.006814986,
0.0197035447,
-0.0299403854,
-0.0721906424,
0.0881515741,
-0.0388413779,
-0.0566939972,
-0.0328190327,
-0.0326433443,
-0.0396421738,
0.0318853036,
-0.0158008449,
-0.0403701738,
0.0066870847,
0.0322913937,
-0.0238314047,
-0.0331067257,
-0.074616611,
-0.0289275944,
-0.0149486382,
-0.0743777752,
-0.030930819,
-0.056503538,
-0.0326209031,
0.0227566715,
-0.0835583732,
-0.0696154311,
1.926847611e-34,
0.0453371443,
-0.0468258671,
0.0207664333,
-0.0202590507,
0.0230051558,
-0.0281261038,
-0.0336104445,
-0.0196696315,
-0.0188854728,
-0.095382601,
-0.0144795608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.09017v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.09017v3 | Dont Add, dont Miss: Effective Content Preserving Generation from Pre-Selected Text Spans | 2023-10-13T11:28:02 | 2024-02-25T14:45:00 | Aviv Slobodkin, Avi Caciularu, Eran Hirsch, Ido Dagan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recently introduced Controlled Text Reduction (CTR) task isolates the
text generation step within typical summarization-style tasks. It does so by
challenging models to generate coherent text conforming to pre-selected content
within the input text (``highlights''). This framing enables increased
modularity in summarization-like tasks, allowing to couple a single CTR model
with various content-selection setups and modules. However, there are currently
no reliable CTR models, while the performance of the existing baseline for the
task is mediocre, falling short of practical utility. Here, we address this gap
by introducing a high-quality, open-source CTR model that tackles two prior key
limitations: inadequate enforcement of the content-preservation constraint, and
suboptimal silver training data. Addressing these, we amplify the
content-preservation constraint in both training, via RL, and inference, via a
controlled decoding strategy. Further, we substantially improve the silver
training data quality via GPT-4 distillation. Overall, pairing the distilled
dataset with the highlight-adherence strategies yields marked gains over the
current baseline, of up to 30 ROUGE-L points, providing a reliable CTR model
for downstream use. | [
0.028962316,
0.0693251789,
0.0345479213,
-0.0157485865,
-0.0213866178,
-0.0126675284,
0.0017428232,
0.0228412841,
-0.0571687706,
0.011744353,
0.0122044804,
0.0090581141,
0.0240202248,
0.0242536198,
0.0093493825,
-0.0554356128,
0.0200846717,
-0.0027970141,
-0.0103096934,
0.0171351265,
0.0255109221,
0.008765691,
0.034715794,
0.010598884,
-0.006655463,
-0.0040380843,
0.0051760506,
0.0005451118,
0.0266153105,
-0.0253839456,
0.0196498185,
0.0728455707,
0.0282730944,
0.0083392812,
0.0000023318,
-0.0399845354,
-0.0663430095,
0.0118249794,
0.00323365,
0.0333830602,
0.0609406717,
-0.050761871,
0.01212247,
0.0196021684,
-0.0119888205,
0.0519616157,
0.0229424872,
0.0735627487,
0.066217415,
0.0526805669,
-0.0158508345,
0.003601725,
-0.0079081245,
-0.0469931103,
-0.0133096855,
-0.0034276303,
-0.0049615344,
0.0254358258,
-0.0061522704,
-0.0002016266,
-0.0247456692,
0.0460750535,
0.0198200736,
-0.0096713416,
-0.0187310521,
0.0371437259,
-0.067591086,
-0.0231491644,
0.0164079852,
0.0338488966,
-0.0139253372,
-0.0545258597,
0.0339216441,
0.0027320599,
-0.0372809507,
-0.0658861175,
-0.0695180297,
0.0539307855,
-0.0126927914,
0.0567936152,
-0.0346689187,
0.0169679597,
-0.028507432,
0.0183726326,
-0.0018500646,
-0.0202183984,
0.0122861834,
-0.0320278518,
-0.0234184302,
0.0317422971,
-0.0472802371,
-0.0409620292,
0.0456426106,
0.0178863686,
0.0020519618,
-0.0318164825,
-0.090313904,
-0.0544404127,
0.015669547,
0.0155506348,
0.0201264378,
0.029406745,
0.0051857298,
-0.0011972935,
-0.0371909253,
0.0310766008,
0.022190107,
0.0236646347,
-0.0239379145,
-0.0095534204,
-0.008037148,
-0.0051598065,
-0.0506196879,
0.0422415808,
-0.0445077531,
-0.0496551916,
-0.0273668543,
0.006055092,
0.0045151091,
0.0156914815,
0.0025281713,
0.0236296989,
-0.0518639423,
-0.0121003333,
0.0475072674,
0.0264917146,
-0.0004572009,
-0.0185531434,
0.0355170891,
-0.0130146574,
-0.0226700343,
0.0365341231,
0.0380533971,
-0.0170705765,
0.0009898511,
0.0244506113,
-0.0546898581,
-0.0392122939,
-0.0176619366,
-0.0224035792,
-0.0365154296,
-0.0290899873,
-0.0057173274,
-0.0535740219,
0.0126181347,
-0.0258808099,
-0.0283781234,
-0.0626873448,
0.0124782184,
0.0392204374,
-0.0397786833,
0.0208898596,
-0.0642511398,
-0.0289342608,
0.0150523558,
0.0076663676,
0.0454826392,
0.0231142957,
0.0279438086,
0.070206739,
0.0205791127,
0.0033161037,
0.0081555415,
0.0231346581,
0.0431662351,
0.0015768452,
-0.0268941205,
-0.026384782,
-0.0208309181,
-0.0119848065,
0.07656385,
0.073575139,
-0.0373383798,
-0.0011337738,
0.1019506082,
0.0360954031,
-0.0165378675,
0.0341245718,
0.0191913247,
0.0491774306,
0.0141940229,
0.080525361,
-0.0331056714,
0.017101502,
-0.0278888419,
0.0201937277,
0.075128518,
0.0276002698,
-0.0164593644,
-0.0281108487,
0.0189785119,
-0.0112462854,
0.0218972936,
-0.0312345698,
0.0075626532,
0.027557252,
-0.0600715652,
0.0444629788,
0.0280636083,
-0.0617587268,
0.0356188342,
-0.0431894735,
0.0399890691,
0.0105457287,
0.0588602796,
-0.0077662123,
-0.0211448409,
-0.0199169405,
0.028954694,
0.0651135445,
0.0245025381,
0.0265164524,
0.0188472774,
-0.0743415952,
-0.0404292122,
-0.0306611806,
-0.0024218576,
-0.0023759853,
0.0040914081,
-0.0156189036,
0.0289677922,
0.0417780913,
-0.0532603264,
0.0455669127,
0.0243744068,
-0.0395930372,
-0.0023360613,
-0.0233380832,
0.0028636253,
-0.0017259116,
-0.0303241778,
0.0055219308,
0.0319089331,
-0.0328816362,
-0.0047023753,
-0.0046303784,
-0.0492700897,
-0.0611153618,
0.0071224552,
-0.0652540103,
-0.0061233528,
0.0805747509,
-0.0188084226,
-0.0419981964,
-0.0173987336,
-0.042010244,
0.0100591853,
-0.0528768115,
0.0027282357,
0.0405366868,
0.008554358,
-0.0352036059,
0.0558559708,
-0.0152078774,
-0.0190978404,
0.0393510647,
-0.0237183906,
0.0104535567,
-0.0612463988,
0.0118305627,
-0.0180657115,
-0.0233852193,
0.0127647705,
0.0737625659,
0.061206311,
-0.01466427,
-0.0047390391,
-0.0371596739,
0.0200997032,
-0.0449743606,
0.0086070979,
0.061985407,
0.0192826614,
-0.0087852059,
0.0152925728,
-0.0186955724,
-0.0621181428,
0.0522344671,
-0.0132621014,
0.0265113488,
-0.0049786037,
0.0527530126,
-0.0450597703,
-0.0281257965,
0.0435046032,
0.0192233156,
0.0002696853,
-0.0421010852,
-0.0188132077,
0.0491285212,
-0.027386358,
-0.0144795747,
0.0205562338,
-0.0255895369,
-0.0330020972,
-0.0113854911,
0.0035772715,
0.0304439161,
0.0596553423,
-0.0002107467,
0.0091649825,
0.0150924865,
-0.0034793727,
0.0242971778,
-0.0572535694,
0.0210356116,
0.0160035323,
-0.0363526642,
0.0703964308,
0.0593450703,
0.0289874058,
0.030642584,
-0.0675248504,
-0.0226664748,
-0.0026415449,
-0.0357651934,
-0.0118374908,
0.0045597134,
-0.0253896508,
0.004235886,
-0.066026561,
-0.0445385017,
0.0221622195,
-0.0251537319,
0.0210666973,
-0.0553289615,
-0.0017189168,
-0.0396775566,
0.0019830866,
0.0373395346,
0.0385397039,
0.0131292557,
-0.0007408437,
-0.0534012169,
-0.0024176929,
0.0217704475,
0.005764748,
0.0282976571,
-0.0545503385,
-0.0080699474,
-0.0295860302,
-0.015159132,
-0.0001132403,
-0.0368410088,
0.0254681148,
0.0293464027,
0.0714652091,
0.0023781566,
-0.0188421961,
0.0111963023,
0.0373640098,
0.0754873157,
-0.0282182079,
0.0063384227,
-0.0350756012,
0.0621394254,
0.0687534735,
0.0017721561,
0.0375689566,
-0.0506128706,
-0.0072365142,
0.0802824646,
0.0115989549,
0.0032900264,
0.0355698094,
0.0102851717,
0.0144572556,
-0.0310348496,
-0.0098353559,
0.0026911558,
0.0723123252,
-0.0484008938,
-0.0207671784,
0.0897511616,
0.021564424,
-0.0600042008,
-0.0353551395,
0.0174339917,
0.0624152608,
-0.0181461126,
-0.0029304049,
-0.0817722231,
-0.0181283318,
0.0143128354,
0.0416742265,
0.0369368754,
-0.0206901431,
-0.041574508,
-0.0753180683,
0.0292379465,
0.0137176188,
-0.0431455709,
-0.0144689344,
-0.0056515611,
-0.0008609181,
-0.0076854839,
0.0260220561,
0.0346629359,
-0.0199098941,
-0.0005296883,
0.0347507559,
-0.0733948052,
-0.0389658809,
-0.0629371926,
-0.0058638239,
-0.0192650836,
0.1022332087,
0.0398612879,
0.0080446592,
0.0137631139,
0.0416779481,
-0.0469277501,
-0.0219725352,
-0.0395001993,
0.0805251598,
0.0094966833,
0.0239639636,
-0.005189924,
0.0784942806,
0.0250615012,
-0.0325198248,
0.0093869399,
0.004169445,
0.0207787603,
-0.0567429103,
-0.0226811785,
0.0216370057,
-0.0016982021,
0.0803269893,
0.0605268031,
-0.0253120214,
-0.0688311383,
-0.0342556201,
0.0267550126,
-0.1068483368,
-0.0170206279,
-0.011420629,
-0.0271884203,
-0.013064051,
-0.0721907616,
-0.0393773131,
0.0270519461,
0.0026866356,
-0.036924459,
0.0099877948,
-0.0402712002,
-0.0298411697,
-0.0393167809,
-0.0130674234,
-0.0544897169,
-0.0347490348,
-0.0579073876,
-0.0156270731,
-0.0267541874,
-0.0591651462,
-0.0157627221,
0.034987282,
-0.0786985904,
-0.0355428793,
0.0017148231,
0.0680980012,
0.0222822092,
0.0488289408,
0.0271701645,
-0.016682893,
0.0561653636,
0.0018858841,
-0.0164440479,
0.0546921082,
0.0062506394,
0.0099584702,
-0.0169806294,
0.0204552971,
-0.0279339217,
0.0439990014,
0.0035094663,
0.0472126827,
0.0313120373,
0.0048729577,
0.0419450179,
0.0016882897,
-0.0051715472,
-0.0273891464,
0.037859723,
-0.009377907,
-0.0158861224,
-0.0108900536,
0.0004721214,
-0.0508096404,
0.0446626954,
-0.0129137691,
0.040872097,
-0.0162972677,
0.0587165765,
0.0018235659,
0.0404353216,
-0.0998422727,
-0.0180009436,
-0.038769871,
-0.0078898743,
-0.0048585464,
0.0186815541,
-0.0375597887,
-0.0025567133,
-0.0397168919,
0.0068634367,
-0.0269805435,
0.0066366913,
0.0296708327,
0.0254906528,
-0.0003246062,
0.0483065322,
-0.0661771372,
0.0202507749,
-0.0797152072,
-0.0134139126,
0.0487396605,
-0.0300887227,
0.0723383948,
-0.0160491783,
-0.0262797326,
-0.0351568796,
0.039196834,
0.0461296029,
0.0032289315,
-0.0616736859,
-0.0107579762,
-0.0005178063,
-0.0231350865,
0.0939198509,
-0.0044460665,
0.0153610585,
0.0036121486,
-0.0244074948,
-0.0392520875,
-0.0139787495,
-0.015800735,
0.0249566343,
0.0105773509,
-0.0549166687,
-0.018393172,
-0.0325299203,
0.0652850717,
0.0100235948,
0.0473821498,
-0.0110084405,
0.049599614,
-0.0066632587,
-0.0145116085,
-0.0097706988,
-0.0112096798,
-0.0316472389,
0.022176493,
-0.0036589014,
-0.0039937869,
-6.798209296e-33,
-0.0209533349,
0.0011681775,
0.0114038186,
0.0086886473,
-0.0494257845,
0.0392415151,
-0.0872068256,
-0.0504495911,
0.0532661676,
-0.0023434155,
-0.002253342,
-0.0180347245,
0.0057195425,
0.0661984235,
-0.0267494973,
0.0390358754,
0.0822632909,
-0.0112459315,
-0.0459056161,
0.0553953908,
0.0411061831,
0.0316090398,
0.0105788745,
-0.0275655407,
-0.0259972084,
-0.0110849906,
-0.0265094563,
-0.0477404259,
0.0259361919,
0.03297396,
-0.0224750303,
-0.00042031,
0.0283230729,
-0.020056786,
-0.0630861968,
0.0290427171,
-0.0960802287,
-0.022924995,
-0.0128559917,
-0.0535103194,
-0.0764793828,
-0.0367670208,
0.0235051829,
-0.0259675067,
0.0126656117,
-0.0216996297,
0.0287967231,
-0.0256018359,
-0.0250290148,
-0.0898010358,
-0.0442101732,
0.0267894845,
-0.0226647072,
-0.0181269702,
0.0379924178,
0.0388988182,
-0.0016049097,
0.0169895086,
-0.0147931986,
0.0190996993,
0.0417716056,
0.0536337718,
0.0381522886,
0.0020046136,
0.0021280276,
0.0478901826,
-0.0389614999,
-0.0135697713,
-0.0275722872,
-0.0014558899,
0.0039358083,
0.0355501473,
0.0331367776,
0.0103283562,
0.0260176212,
-0.0348835886,
-0.0654981732,
0.0629035011,
-0.0438619927,
0.0197268315,
0.016624853,
0.0136466846,
0.0376245454,
0.0003313373,
-0.0260752402,
-0.0038653079,
-0.0070753838,
-0.0009596092,
0.0326067507,
0.0710082054,
-0.0859519988,
0.0068758298,
0.0276739635,
-0.0016035857,
0.0166681148,
0.0515673086,
-0.0495829731,
0.0222696401,
0.0217920672,
-0.0186583456,
-0.0590138175,
0.0251529738,
0.0246353857,
-0.0398189574,
-0.023697339,
0.0122874314,
0.051972311,
0.0326669328,
-0.0370603986,
0.0284905788,
-0.0145214759,
0.0447865613,
0.0160332602,
-0.0126029616,
-0.0024946122,
-0.0183594041,
0.0154600404,
0.0163222663,
0.0114294048,
0.0013513035,
-0.0116195204,
-0.003726179,
0.0314326547,
0.0168222226,
-0.0014956221,
0.0162385665,
-0.0158173405,
0.0323831253,
0.0291996989,
-0.0356574245,
-0.0117277615,
-0.0120192319,
2.783e-7,
0.0302477647,
0.0330984294,
0.0739423856,
-0.0242210031,
-0.0097135566,
-0.0232165586,
-0.0113445166,
0.0503518023,
-0.0202471334,
0.0229119491,
0.0189662948,
0.0044930279,
0.0748688728,
0.028553661,
-0.0448256508,
0.0260424949,
-0.0399960317,
-0.0308494773,
-0.0333458073,
-0.0252620429,
0.0623978712,
0.0461574756,
-0.0505905561,
-0.0147913825,
0.0136260567,
0.0180063043,
0.0538299866,
-0.0240219999,
0.0115118483,
0.0026138138,
0.035433799,
-0.0271325447,
-0.0418858752,
-0.0456642024,
-0.0389569476,
-0.0215997547,
0.0222753063,
0.0712016374,
0.0383236445,
-0.018279558,
0.0277393535,
0.011774106,
0.0155418515,
0.0026511401,
0.0611794107,
-0.0398611352,
0.0204723217,
-0.0127122244,
-0.0568711869,
-0.000263924,
-0.0218604133,
-0.0090605058,
-0.0302515756,
0.0290886853,
-0.0122858873,
0.0536623821,
-0.0504978262,
-0.080435209,
-0.0325573124,
-0.0074952189,
-0.0439170897,
-0.017533442,
-0.0563359968,
0.0058714394,
-0.0025899217,
-0.087926127,
0.008589589,
3.251606555e-34,
0.0452324748,
-0.0301832929,
-0.0287791807,
-0.0271438826,
0.0190091766,
-0.0334192961,
0.026327204,
0.0228341874,
0.0095746377,
-0.0722694024,
-0.0209661778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08992v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08992v3 | CodeChain: Towards Modular Code Generation Through Chain of Self-revisions with Representative Sub-modules | 2023-10-13T10:17:48 | 2024-03-14T03:29:09 | Hung Le, Hailin Chen, Amrita Saha, Akash Gokul, Doyen Sahoo, Shafiq Joty | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have already become quite proficient at solving
simpler programming tasks like those in HumanEval or MBPP benchmarks. However,
solving more complex and competitive programming tasks is still quite
challenging for these models - possibly due to their tendency to generate
solutions as monolithic code blocks instead of decomposing them into logical
sub-tasks and sub-modules. On the other hand, experienced programmers
instinctively write modularized code with abstraction for solving complex
tasks, often reusing previously developed modules. To address this gap, we
propose CodeChain, a novel framework for inference that elicits modularized
code generation through a chain of self-revisions, each being guided by some
representative sub-modules generated in previous iterations. Concretely,
CodeChain first instructs the LLM to generate modularized codes through
chain-of-thought prompting. Then it applies a chain of self-revisions by
iterating the two steps: 1) extracting and clustering the generated sub-modules
and selecting the cluster representatives as the more generic and re-usable
implementations, and 2) augmenting the original chain-of-thought prompt with
these selected module-implementations and instructing the LLM to re-generate
new modularized solutions. We find that by naturally encouraging the LLM to
reuse the previously developed and verified sub-modules, CodeChain can
significantly boost both modularity as well as correctness of the generated
solutions, achieving relative pass@1 improvements of 35% on APPS and 76% on
CodeContests. It is shown to be effective on both OpenAI LLMs as well as
open-sourced LLMs like WizardCoder. We also conduct comprehensive ablation
studies with different methods of prompting, number of clusters, model sizes,
program qualities, etc., to provide useful insights that underpin CodeChain's
success. | [
0.0100288428,
0.0585872047,
-0.0459150597,
0.0043146838,
-0.0308384132,
0.0117693963,
-0.0151497405,
-0.0060704951,
0.0294563454,
0.0049069012,
-0.017505046,
0.0669050589,
-0.002579272,
0.0035536354,
0.0149353901,
-0.0420103371,
0.0390054956,
-0.0488966145,
-0.0405317917,
0.0054361178,
0.0033555506,
0.0082932431,
-0.0036117197,
0.0581337623,
-0.0096300654,
-0.049682945,
-0.0251427423,
0.0161394272,
-0.0245305523,
-0.004922641,
-0.0005479297,
0.0423149168,
-0.0110540139,
0.024797095,
0.0000023759,
-0.0331857316,
-0.0113131301,
0.012778637,
-0.0048693279,
0.0489446409,
-0.0034919654,
0.0330706313,
0.0142579842,
0.0282201171,
-0.0413046367,
-0.0116186757,
0.0168011263,
-0.0347492695,
0.0581181943,
0.0264219735,
0.0163056459,
-0.0062075262,
0.0021697204,
0.0267096478,
0.0076512452,
0.0048137275,
-0.0206510611,
0.0469297208,
0.0447402634,
-0.0057630599,
0.0027046565,
0.0036325108,
0.0611024611,
-0.0045190202,
0.0301873051,
0.0440826602,
-0.0098259002,
0.0063830437,
0.0006460795,
0.0191891938,
-0.0219963342,
-0.0618759505,
0.0124850469,
-0.0238631107,
-0.0210150629,
0.0074579972,
-0.0454506688,
0.037516851,
0.0023351656,
-0.0117992349,
0.0385408923,
0.0055756685,
0.0159701388,
-0.0145042539,
-0.0325996466,
0.076411888,
0.0218458194,
-0.0013646192,
-0.0592655987,
-0.0167903937,
0.0254334807,
-0.0486674495,
-0.0078802118,
0.0502521694,
-0.0013658543,
-0.0156047344,
-0.0269194003,
-0.0317986459,
0.0224273689,
-0.0236124657,
0.0374509394,
0.0373695157,
-0.0348833986,
-0.0092161093,
-0.054365769,
0.0511750765,
-0.0345269926,
-0.0204521213,
-0.0502255224,
0.0075294166,
-0.0651153401,
0.0007525618,
-0.060000103,
0.06457524,
-0.0052452642,
0.0572032146,
-0.044575464,
0.0877458826,
-0.017954817,
0.0487621091,
-0.0217895322,
-0.0149082281,
-0.0255524609,
-0.0181854237,
0.0113880876,
0.0042855167,
-0.0384904891,
-0.0591782369,
0.0254382174,
-0.0483563878,
-0.0111809662,
0.0306851473,
-0.0388295092,
-0.0201765709,
0.0071800873,
0.0597564429,
-0.0035476934,
0.0352522731,
-0.0421118289,
-0.0465116389,
0.0009359936,
-0.0272401199,
-0.0063120658,
-0.1163833961,
-0.03161107,
0.0092142588,
-0.0180938058,
-0.0168818701,
-0.0162769929,
-0.025385607,
0.0182450414,
0.0092261704,
-0.0482296869,
0.0332606398,
0.0300563592,
0.0284365378,
-0.0333815664,
0.0439509191,
0.0496096462,
0.0348658562,
0.0138711454,
-0.0132358931,
0.0867378414,
0.0354339071,
-0.034117084,
-0.0074774027,
0.0310912821,
0.0249699578,
0.0238924623,
-0.0208159741,
-0.0364982896,
0.0174171608,
-0.003214262,
0.0553441457,
0.0112009309,
0.0178701933,
0.0130452374,
0.0280987378,
0.0591499172,
-0.0136251682,
0.026072789,
0.0435525477,
-0.0445468239,
0.0747802705,
-0.0468946211,
0.0067232316,
0.0023934981,
0.0398922935,
-0.0124226203,
-0.0773498714,
-0.0277577527,
0.0055256844,
-0.0002353443,
0.0031974239,
0.0362879075,
0.0023723729,
-0.012555222,
0.0276188403,
0.0129203396,
-0.0763374791,
-0.0267409422,
-0.0822211206,
0.0674044639,
0.0281113777,
0.0687292516,
-0.0690879002,
-0.0196720418,
0.0136834839,
-0.0000618673,
-0.0234656334,
0.0331937745,
-0.0283736531,
0.0079840207,
-0.0423573144,
0.0058576968,
-0.0225330926,
0.0167381372,
0.0259473361,
0.0516619273,
-0.0558730923,
0.0040261699,
-0.0397306085,
-0.0242578946,
0.0473898016,
-0.0128612146,
0.0174772516,
0.0523811914,
0.0030472351,
0.0413942896,
-0.0421911143,
-0.033468429,
0.0110581294,
0.0440213829,
-0.0131229106,
-0.0279059205,
-0.0258356687,
-0.0616648644,
-0.0331858583,
-0.0073147886,
-0.0344956368,
-0.0390392803,
-0.0045187469,
-0.0432056934,
-0.0164943878,
0.0736212879,
0.006327692,
0.0023096995,
-0.0001836166,
0.0333921537,
-0.0271066092,
-0.0304497685,
0.0052292496,
0.0313635729,
0.0123992907,
-0.0336588919,
0.0145059489,
0.035710264,
0.0324259326,
0.0411603637,
-0.0226657502,
0.0037784616,
-0.0299267583,
0.0299752671,
-0.00045072,
0.0359927602,
-0.0205905717,
-0.0749807358,
-0.1099255383,
0.0290410556,
-0.0221486948,
0.0196964741,
0.0216251481,
0.0419345535,
0.0090419101,
0.0068224403,
0.018285051,
0.0225647558,
0.0141943563,
0.0271518547,
0.011358249,
-0.0313329995,
-0.0497196093,
-0.0241685268,
-0.0057483241,
-0.0362350419,
0.0400425121,
-0.0351684988,
0.0258329343,
-0.0635730177,
0.0083855195,
-0.0157996248,
0.0159892663,
-0.0102577442,
-0.0367899723,
0.0324711986,
-0.0439752117,
0.0959106758,
0.0393596068,
-0.0432408601,
0.004815992,
0.0783595964,
-0.0097943153,
-0.028681837,
0.0328711607,
0.0261573792,
-0.0098838527,
0.0120010516,
-0.0548901334,
0.0379627123,
0.0676767454,
0.0124158785,
-0.0431307442,
-0.0405717753,
-0.0271226279,
0.0102431765,
0.0047387276,
0.047565192,
-0.0524485037,
0.0010008748,
0.0445651263,
-0.0091681089,
-0.101861842,
0.0748590752,
-0.0445742421,
-0.0208178144,
-0.0036158359,
-0.0479432568,
-0.0674735233,
0.1096970886,
0.0090340935,
-0.0121966312,
0.0158582386,
-0.0037551811,
-0.0369529352,
0.0290429518,
-0.0069536283,
-0.0087052304,
0.0867926553,
-0.0747070387,
0.012775884,
0.0016269734,
-0.0154736359,
-0.0651125908,
0.0629355535,
-0.0096406471,
0.0076242015,
-0.0065399762,
0.0079847574,
0.0046638958,
-0.0029963474,
0.0192529373,
0.0530717298,
0.0191200264,
-0.0291010924,
-0.0161776561,
0.0041037272,
-0.0372093543,
-0.0419168957,
0.0149272624,
-0.0419376232,
0.036637865,
0.0391834527,
0.0482961126,
0.0058933357,
-0.0773116723,
-0.0253447201,
0.0086355917,
-0.0305882785,
-0.0019560258,
0.0707365274,
0.0621748604,
-0.0513752401,
-0.0417787321,
0.0646521971,
0.0359169878,
-0.0414630398,
0.0008995194,
-0.0104076555,
0.0809923485,
0.0571188815,
0.0650071949,
-0.0747933164,
-0.0120645184,
0.0256838799,
-0.0044096718,
-0.0137576507,
-0.0116039924,
0.0020587044,
-0.0811154321,
0.0652035698,
0.0141900554,
-0.0386478901,
0.0098459842,
-0.0102370931,
-0.0207648352,
0.0286420919,
-0.0628690049,
0.0501683839,
-0.0058304858,
0.024026813,
-0.010893926,
-0.0811581314,
0.0308347195,
0.0119279912,
-0.0281956363,
0.0255246777,
0.0414297618,
-0.0201422796,
0.0286321249,
-0.0006141719,
0.0323972255,
-0.0519448183,
0.0203322973,
-0.047262881,
0.006069738,
0.0285928529,
0.0065983636,
0.0278967936,
0.0103435805,
-0.0431101508,
-0.045515608,
0.0637743995,
0.0667599142,
-0.0283065923,
-0.0464502163,
-0.0477115251,
0.0016560098,
-0.0398674682,
0.0309083946,
0.054608196,
0.0081526944,
-0.0124347275,
-0.0606132299,
-0.0540599413,
-0.0185845774,
0.0246226881,
-0.0184741635,
-0.0094818054,
0.0408413112,
-0.046896141,
0.0371954441,
0.0440980196,
0.0327300988,
0.0266609658,
-0.0304226074,
0.0207205154,
-0.0228428077,
-0.0685726628,
-0.0164287724,
-0.0434986316,
-0.0164290834,
-0.0364609994,
-0.0159727279,
0.0166305806,
-0.0396519303,
0.0030039649,
0.0281575769,
-0.1009256244,
-0.0567832924,
-0.040500652,
0.0911630392,
0.0224732626,
0.0229179114,
-0.0462345891,
-0.0521198809,
-0.0458746739,
0.0015330564,
-0.0370071456,
0.0138334613,
-0.0175930429,
0.0014528832,
0.0218839273,
-0.0094137844,
-0.0499703959,
0.0250204168,
0.0223109741,
-0.0114365658,
0.0065276353,
0.0137329185,
0.0330317095,
0.0334060714,
-0.0282721464,
0.0209977869,
-0.0108784363,
-0.0282589234,
0.0154180015,
-0.0071668313,
-0.0263885818,
-0.0535013862,
0.044513315,
-0.0253706127,
-0.013093723,
0.0433785692,
0.0545430593,
-0.0274099708,
0.0824690685,
0.0218589529,
0.0265650917,
-0.0266528632,
0.0458937474,
0.0479902402,
0.0014043257,
-0.0154963238,
0.0067650331,
0.0108275739,
0.0275961254,
-0.0174886715,
0.0541241653,
-0.0073328209,
0.0576971136,
-0.0275123958,
0.0111058597,
-0.0737376362,
-0.0759221092,
0.0075313286,
0.0536519252,
0.0051431237,
0.0588922165,
0.0161319654,
-0.0444851853,
0.0151691167,
-0.0132494299,
0.0675872713,
-0.0091516478,
-0.0355126858,
-0.0070949006,
0.028048519,
-0.0039440608,
-0.0398724265,
0.0860474706,
-0.0180768166,
-0.0095751686,
-0.0055572279,
-0.0071549886,
-0.035990566,
-0.0330709144,
0.0395321883,
-0.010584807,
-0.0378456786,
-0.0354520939,
-0.0367300473,
-0.0361182839,
0.0042984388,
0.0517695807,
0.0369072556,
-0.0039819945,
0.028250169,
0.0798782483,
0.0287649613,
-0.0455672927,
0.0102791432,
0.0000877528,
0.0228124764,
-0.0506875403,
-0.0059587234,
-6.229765207e-33,
-0.0232554041,
-0.0104804765,
0.050139688,
0.0054837693,
0.0061767818,
-0.0280733407,
-0.0581393503,
0.0307488833,
0.0207099654,
-0.0381363109,
0.0082517453,
-0.0046312069,
-0.0136434045,
-0.027297657,
0.0665363297,
0.0367097594,
0.0595491268,
0.0206032582,
-0.0646718219,
0.0180462636,
-0.0398678593,
0.0079223067,
0.0037645469,
0.0061175446,
-0.0545527674,
-0.0085189715,
0.032389313,
-0.0184298512,
-0.0437220857,
0.0356555022,
0.0005101192,
-0.0152694592,
0.0194495041,
0.0030227676,
-0.0318875052,
-0.0425305218,
-0.0081514511,
-0.0326343998,
0.0187895801,
-0.0169288069,
-0.0526645407,
-0.071585238,
0.0701568052,
0.0194137618,
-0.0334239304,
0.0084814997,
0.0229118671,
-0.0068258154,
0.017898323,
0.0182209089,
-0.0618175864,
0.0099702422,
-0.0404079184,
-0.007628195,
-0.0314644985,
0.0225812886,
0.0010102402,
0.0416506343,
0.0234222542,
0.0317342542,
0.0356848389,
0.0508198962,
0.0663330778,
-0.0391597711,
-0.006209034,
-0.0037803478,
0.0647527128,
0.0290698744,
-0.0459728949,
0.0133265909,
0.0234267414,
0.0658621117,
0.0591531396,
0.0178571437,
0.0191000234,
0.0168211088,
-0.0357161611,
0.0247684326,
0.0048721563,
0.017918583,
-0.0013197982,
0.018305527,
-0.0038367496,
0.0065423097,
-0.0372481681,
-0.0025144981,
-0.0294621494,
-0.0334169455,
0.0337142199,
-0.0013403127,
-0.0346378759,
-0.0176488105,
0.0240997616,
-0.0224873573,
0.0049923388,
-0.013316893,
-0.0466019064,
0.071352005,
-0.0016685415,
0.0241480526,
-0.0083483271,
-0.0184144154,
0.0245724544,
-0.0253673624,
0.0561004728,
0.0345367454,
0.0162396822,
0.0291808844,
-0.0544487461,
0.0225150306,
-0.0785029083,
-0.0034461175,
0.0059091705,
0.0292757135,
-0.01110972,
0.0264393277,
0.0194957126,
0.0141137019,
-0.0281189308,
-0.0484919399,
-0.0662080199,
0.0350313447,
0.036849916,
0.0288321525,
-0.0118380468,
-0.0110464785,
-0.0797225833,
-0.0034763371,
0.0107656438,
-0.0295875706,
-0.0581658594,
0.0633819178,
3.119e-7,
-0.0331137478,
0.0291437823,
0.0109603899,
0.0052670422,
0.0359939747,
0.0303427894,
-0.0518944301,
-0.0347621366,
0.0318160318,
-0.0145839099,
-0.0232275184,
0.0371692516,
0.0436876416,
0.0540808998,
-0.0342470035,
0.0486313477,
0.0042967992,
-0.0067702052,
-0.0492646135,
-0.0253594443,
0.0141657805,
0.03471132,
0.0363102406,
0.0219367761,
0.0236379486,
0.0106241796,
0.0056467419,
0.0268444102,
-0.0108228642,
0.0495780297,
-0.0786387548,
0.0415489674,
-0.0222364217,
-0.026077956,
0.0058669909,
-0.0497211069,
-0.0242881067,
0.0445106402,
0.0186889153,
0.0431683362,
0.0555507615,
-0.0049765427,
-0.0110374121,
-0.0587020069,
0.0362100378,
-0.0109397862,
0.0287062228,
-0.007605528,
0.0072737262,
0.0082938299,
-0.0120096719,
-0.0130520863,
0.0225676671,
0.0287132114,
0.0007020682,
-0.0150371417,
-0.0488027483,
-0.013875925,
-0.0167489927,
-0.0461079776,
-0.0514921546,
-0.0318663046,
-0.0636843592,
0.0372663848,
-0.0036904179,
-0.0538445748,
-0.0057552317,
3.310982796e-34,
0.0115766199,
-0.0347794853,
0.026042534,
0.0420543849,
0.0377863646,
-0.0203120615,
-0.0579929017,
0.0182218347,
-0.014057829,
-0.0319697559,
-0.0627984405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08975v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08975v2 | ChatKBQA: A Generate-then-Retrieve Framework for Knowledge Base Question Answering with Fine-tuned Large Language Models | 2023-10-13T09:45:14 | 2024-05-30T12:39:51 | Haoran Luo, Haihong E, Zichen Tang, Shiyao Peng, Yikai Guo, Wentai Zhang, Chenghao Ma, Guanting Dong, Meina Song, Wei Lin, Yifan Zhu, Luu Anh Tuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) aims to answer natural language
questions over large-scale knowledge bases (KBs), which can be summarized into
two crucial steps: knowledge retrieval and semantic parsing. However, three
core challenges remain: inefficient knowledge retrieval, mistakes of retrieval
adversely impacting semantic parsing, and the complexity of previous KBQA
methods. To tackle these challenges, we introduce ChatKBQA, a novel and simple
generate-then-retrieve KBQA framework, which proposes first generating the
logical form with fine-tuned LLMs, then retrieving and replacing entities and
relations with an unsupervised retrieval method, to improve both generation and
retrieval more directly. Experimental results show that ChatKBQA achieves new
state-of-the-art performance on standard KBQA datasets, WebQSP, and CWQ. This
work can also be regarded as a new paradigm for combining LLMs with knowledge
graphs (KGs) for interpretable and knowledge-required question answering. Our
code is publicly available. | [
0.0613397881,
0.017403964,
0.004481744,
0.0752959251,
-0.0295805689,
0.009569915,
-0.0270915832,
0.0077220853,
0.0567144342,
-0.0583948009,
0.014529678,
0.0327292718,
-0.0759826303,
0.035441339,
0.0148188733,
0.0084011955,
0.0310682654,
0.0001600553,
0.0039595747,
-0.0202158745,
-0.0077158022,
0.0344718322,
-0.0066363737,
-0.0108983144,
-0.0052649803,
-0.0201688018,
-0.0037164085,
0.0134245045,
-0.0079115108,
-0.0076379441,
0.0207863357,
0.0231284723,
0.033954341,
-0.0061060064,
0.0000017751,
-0.0557022318,
-0.0254383851,
0.0163497273,
-0.0601592697,
-0.0048528388,
-0.0084504681,
0.0107985185,
0.024876114,
0.0096793752,
-0.0674595311,
-0.0196860209,
0.0020089315,
0.054904405,
0.0639580563,
0.0703944936,
0.0088801123,
-0.0542317703,
0.0028353033,
0.0140719339,
0.0259974338,
-0.0656471476,
0.0350147784,
0.0432284474,
0.0165484063,
0.008192285,
0.0112099275,
0.0180156399,
0.0024326358,
0.0180874057,
0.022703873,
0.0064405617,
-0.0299273208,
0.0112975538,
0.0174245648,
0.1129648313,
0.0376061089,
-0.0120635349,
0.0432742909,
0.0466482788,
-0.0097158626,
0.0225028209,
-0.0364261866,
0.0330044143,
-0.0180875082,
-0.0163276084,
-0.0056886938,
-0.0318184048,
0.0288632885,
0.0083274748,
-0.050959006,
0.0898668244,
0.0264320802,
-0.0275175795,
0.0012966119,
-0.0073561468,
-0.0202001873,
-0.0553899072,
0.0073728398,
0.059391804,
-0.0519039109,
0.026102921,
-0.0001022858,
0.0324673019,
0.02718959,
-0.0463030003,
-0.0178872086,
0.0202902183,
-0.0019307538,
0.0695854798,
-0.0570090413,
0.047001794,
-0.0223383997,
-0.0065661841,
-0.0489835851,
-0.0348089561,
-0.0642861128,
-0.0260902122,
-0.0280775148,
0.0520453863,
-0.0630852729,
-0.039189931,
0.0007272339,
0.0439883322,
-0.0020523984,
0.0274062324,
0.0392560624,
0.0484746061,
-0.0020332669,
-0.0259592924,
-0.0581464097,
0.0625025332,
-0.0484789424,
0.0067914668,
0.0095130978,
-0.0355233625,
-0.0093833571,
-0.0062120873,
0.0334210396,
-0.0292591117,
0.0110733975,
0.0688064918,
0.0198429767,
0.0130243655,
-0.0628903881,
-0.0589869358,
0.0061834399,
-0.038097851,
0.0131315831,
-0.0616508946,
0.0466818847,
0.0149399163,
-0.047305461,
-0.0332259946,
0.0367226526,
0.0193040129,
-0.0284362808,
0.0286181439,
-0.0360037684,
0.0075559434,
0.0101954788,
0.0103458948,
-0.0213223454,
0.0676139742,
0.0250909813,
0.009435324,
0.0536103696,
0.0050888266,
-0.0395136625,
0.0208241623,
0.0441068709,
0.0229099616,
0.0045525916,
0.0628948957,
-0.0283160526,
0.0216577798,
0.0376240946,
0.0399628617,
-0.0218612067,
0.0081342515,
-0.0133755114,
0.0137704816,
0.0133512365,
0.0249576997,
0.041805435,
0.0497862846,
-0.0121203205,
-0.0069481744,
-0.0333666839,
0.0202816576,
-0.045993004,
0.0161395762,
-0.0155302063,
0.0362198614,
-0.0072708186,
0.0013227053,
0.0233758576,
0.0107856197,
-0.0110985171,
0.053352084,
0.0527439006,
0.0417883433,
-0.0165867582,
0.114423804,
0.0260013789,
-0.0533815026,
0.0075756339,
-0.0307943095,
0.0429373607,
0.0761154369,
0.0325823203,
-0.0076956511,
-0.0499544293,
0.0247062929,
-0.0179087054,
-0.0005271898,
-0.0039737904,
-0.0161555205,
-0.0116503891,
-0.0392573737,
-0.0260377191,
-0.0037416667,
0.0060863025,
-0.0240151975,
0.0349816531,
0.0041627972,
0.0428819098,
-0.0800244138,
0.025617931,
0.0079718493,
-0.0276610143,
-0.0071708271,
0.0017141864,
0.0095285363,
0.0107718091,
0.0348290317,
0.0058862888,
0.0380504876,
0.0544192009,
-0.0278586335,
-0.0561285131,
-0.0237948112,
0.0006047937,
-0.1099138781,
0.0416080914,
0.00872711,
-0.0207209308,
-0.0229587574,
-0.0561236702,
-0.0449926928,
-0.0073417248,
-0.0230033491,
0.0392674133,
-0.0529379174,
-0.0610069111,
0.0484953634,
-0.0580765195,
-0.0643021464,
0.0926126242,
0.0138363047,
0.0169343166,
0.0174738131,
0.0064847567,
0.0067447769,
-0.0518435277,
0.0200006701,
-0.0230482593,
-0.0095249396,
0.0095455255,
0.0046858145,
-0.0049564317,
-0.0885746032,
-0.0240710303,
-0.079291068,
0.0558010526,
-0.0010875369,
0.026387766,
0.0270005614,
0.0251245983,
0.0034738486,
-0.0053532431,
-0.0637356117,
0.0085390024,
0.0432217792,
0.0094515216,
0.0146070085,
0.0174134802,
-0.0261388421,
-0.0057809795,
0.0016149838,
0.0009948782,
0.0431238897,
-0.0269852467,
0.008620251,
-0.0195202958,
0.0301137231,
-0.0574404746,
0.017085148,
0.0077873264,
-0.0008467234,
-0.0231522098,
-0.0548939779,
0.0052314568,
0.0460973084,
-0.0087083885,
0.0016084971,
-0.0077638049,
-0.0313937366,
-0.0604649857,
0.0269997641,
-0.016631607,
-0.0185845755,
-0.0329730473,
-0.02403103,
0.0017836579,
0.0113090109,
0.0123132719,
-0.0175879262,
-0.0359236784,
0.0418834835,
0.0351603739,
0.0216486789,
-0.0531760715,
0.0436690636,
0.0154097974,
0.040571399,
-0.0224226937,
0.0223797131,
0.0361938067,
0.0019770197,
-0.0059943735,
-0.0019932988,
0.0157140661,
-0.0445859917,
0.0701052323,
-0.0137306666,
0.0286831949,
-0.0322129503,
-0.0208635293,
-0.0538868941,
-0.0001046959,
0.0137360161,
-0.0601193868,
0.0147233531,
-0.0261399802,
0.0474891588,
-0.0026116844,
-0.0158482138,
-0.0341544002,
0.0063401344,
-0.0306745823,
0.0087024774,
-0.0189419258,
0.0127141438,
0.0091981022,
-0.0145336585,
0.0075317267,
-0.0541235544,
-0.0062019182,
0.0138622615,
-0.0246547516,
0.063651748,
0.0927939042,
0.0479385965,
0.0290264692,
0.0290417299,
0.0094565656,
0.0717282742,
-0.0033132767,
-0.0001792546,
0.0102144089,
0.0144065935,
0.0209887102,
-0.0249128956,
0.0052231653,
0.0044207703,
0.0315163694,
-0.0550755188,
-0.0205407497,
0.1103078499,
0.0123296743,
0.0433230214,
-0.0171857104,
-0.001958817,
0.0214677304,
0.0176428817,
0.0406403914,
-0.0921811014,
-0.0446926765,
0.0089586945,
0.0291435923,
0.0122517738,
-0.0507409051,
0.0211994704,
-0.1018696427,
0.0326832682,
-0.0073701115,
-0.0232624169,
-0.0315086469,
-0.0194458179,
-0.0156318732,
-0.0058190972,
-0.0230026897,
0.0540492013,
-0.0242902916,
0.030993361,
-0.0169542376,
-0.0023077419,
-0.0281055551,
0.0537136234,
-0.0496228859,
0.0175396148,
0.0639361814,
0.0129998196,
0.0073812031,
-0.0235244837,
-0.0356183611,
-0.0123664783,
-0.0131640183,
-0.0152498381,
0.0047749481,
0.002551201,
-0.0216288026,
-0.0727729276,
0.0246690456,
-0.0555510297,
0.007456657,
0.0431433544,
0.0643612817,
-0.0163417887,
-0.0044934903,
0.0050094831,
-0.0085951621,
0.0039840275,
0.0989166722,
0.0059886137,
0.021824671,
-0.0393843874,
-0.0174575839,
-0.0165946167,
-0.0467804074,
-0.0318749472,
0.0477664061,
-0.0221227854,
0.0563322231,
-0.0795251653,
-0.0184673015,
0.0443913713,
0.0312848091,
-0.0219292156,
0.0007107832,
0.0310656279,
0.0015161561,
-0.0539712347,
0.0305753779,
-0.0610678531,
-0.008030477,
-0.0130197229,
-0.0052366732,
0.0313005261,
-0.0238785539,
-0.0386336073,
-0.0216725301,
-0.0320350528,
-0.0437847413,
-0.0294276662,
0.0322343744,
0.0155321527,
0.0178881362,
0.0027978052,
0.00518016,
0.0338588953,
0.0363527127,
-0.0653455555,
0.0029726045,
-0.0201144293,
0.014334715,
-0.0085648214,
0.052457653,
-0.1013516113,
-0.0180820879,
-0.0127176289,
0.1093341261,
-0.0205266774,
-0.0589178801,
0.0270068031,
0.0529662482,
-0.0245049037,
0.0318553038,
0.0061465222,
-0.0250111967,
0.0101066744,
-0.0256241634,
-0.0431532897,
-0.0710059255,
0.0067611681,
0.0021236876,
-0.0371632762,
0.0260898378,
-0.0204951465,
-0.0004853453,
0.0498344004,
-0.0236653369,
-0.0275921319,
0.0261751264,
-0.0284757167,
0.0697775111,
-0.0492180251,
-0.0381177887,
0.0226476211,
0.0073628705,
0.0341029502,
-0.0288002118,
0.0517566316,
0.0244324282,
-0.0275591649,
-0.0601237752,
-0.0162763633,
-0.0262614153,
-0.0963632315,
0.022405304,
0.0343361162,
0.0721792057,
0.0205631051,
0.0224587303,
-0.0016479447,
-0.0405943058,
-0.0113544706,
0.0106862197,
0.0151401144,
-0.0147533854,
0.0552777611,
0.0191253182,
-0.0288421102,
-0.0272236522,
0.0561403073,
0.0144512905,
0.0641502216,
-0.0010841963,
-0.0186614711,
-0.0375959501,
-0.069644101,
0.0024848252,
0.014034817,
-0.0076756254,
0.0001659705,
-0.026329821,
-0.0635262802,
0.031558916,
-0.0185582731,
-0.0528844893,
-0.0171181988,
0.0595315881,
0.0534046143,
0.0393922627,
-0.0620527416,
-0.0349909738,
0.0402220003,
-0.0604596362,
-0.0274162572,
0.0030327532,
-5.985826619e-33,
-0.0380223319,
-0.022200577,
0.0572640859,
-0.0311585311,
-0.0537927449,
-0.0255296677,
-0.0341546722,
-0.0403323881,
-0.0175386686,
0.015019875,
0.0135740256,
-0.0000061063,
-0.0139289619,
0.0653915629,
-0.0173239503,
-0.0351659618,
0.0004258571,
0.0255983993,
0.0148085421,
0.0238102991,
0.064911373,
0.0478583947,
0.0027479031,
-0.0050136368,
-0.0167305022,
-0.03480459,
0.0184568167,
0.0603024177,
-0.0360527411,
0.0497737154,
-0.0026336038,
0.0356685519,
0.0172148701,
-0.0074336906,
0.0173309259,
0.0118619362,
-0.0901214406,
-0.005752367,
0.0196860097,
-0.0186844282,
-0.045199696,
-0.0190894455,
0.045817811,
-0.007400909,
0.0501387231,
-0.03262344,
0.0047782911,
-0.0368712358,
-0.0180560909,
-0.0659869835,
-0.0213928744,
0.0075667338,
0.0020930073,
-0.0040059411,
-0.0424493663,
-0.0097716739,
-0.0007751817,
-0.0015835207,
-0.0334404223,
-0.0005026255,
-0.0050276346,
0.017753372,
0.0161972456,
0.0167639758,
0.0247655194,
0.019546587,
-0.0005934768,
-0.0249775182,
-0.0359749384,
0.0248341635,
-0.0357407294,
0.079077594,
-0.0101267816,
0.0558711179,
-0.0241290461,
-0.002371928,
-0.1087773293,
0.0265448522,
-0.0251298845,
0.0574976541,
-0.0089741061,
-0.0049795983,
-0.0033697851,
-0.035680756,
-0.0474443063,
0.0733676106,
-0.0254281256,
-0.0106234467,
0.0435121842,
-0.0149107967,
-0.0074310992,
-0.0325630978,
0.0149970548,
-0.0565364175,
0.0191643778,
0.0359173939,
-0.0046214922,
-0.0348323397,
0.0026035851,
0.0501962416,
-0.0183854662,
-0.0182677787,
0.0238839686,
-0.0578580238,
-0.0330801718,
0.0441065431,
-0.0173737854,
-0.0241253544,
-0.0255759973,
0.0063898177,
-0.0444757342,
0.0023435066,
-0.0468663611,
-0.0077900854,
0.0186278708,
0.0339739099,
0.0031502363,
0.0277917981,
0.0149206389,
0.0112069417,
-0.0136448424,
0.0024902902,
0.0269066151,
0.018131312,
-0.027705824,
0.0384514257,
-0.0441192687,
0.0191823486,
-0.0347130932,
-0.0370312259,
0.0016857607,
0.0072779963,
2.567e-7,
0.0346055627,
0.0047800383,
0.0049714176,
0.0581191294,
0.0175124314,
0.0179965664,
0.029432537,
0.0148872379,
0.0367982127,
-0.0541105606,
-0.0077454862,
0.0420081317,
0.0016051251,
0.0277405009,
-0.0789527372,
0.0307558607,
-0.01604449,
-0.0553601943,
-0.052097626,
-0.0058733523,
0.0805461183,
0.0346752256,
-0.0118832355,
-0.0021226548,
0.0259861946,
-0.0586344339,
0.0661473498,
0.0068610786,
-0.0138676176,
0.0110940803,
0.0150813805,
0.0047090822,
0.0226444788,
0.0285109244,
0.0051502702,
0.0248703882,
-0.0014565475,
0.0788619667,
0.0119467322,
-0.0025132962,
-0.0201659836,
-0.0820271596,
0.0434952639,
-0.0261881351,
0.0915791094,
-0.0746184587,
0.0162873957,
0.0075702383,
-0.0658255592,
-0.0441783555,
-0.0645517185,
-0.0281152893,
0.01883398,
0.0010487044,
0.0204496961,
0.0047978852,
0.0257003307,
-0.054806821,
0.014746272,
0.0289005339,
-0.0427333526,
-0.0463232547,
0.0017731122,
0.0145928208,
-0.0085745407,
-0.043396268,
0.0058751423,
2.329586898e-34,
-0.0020270115,
0.0341489427,
0.0158430152,
0.0222548805,
0.0557163134,
-0.0124296658,
-0.0457745343,
-0.0023235728,
0.0006676858,
-0.1010686979,
0.0055011287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08967v1 | Towards Example-Based NMT with Multi-Levenshtein Transformers | 2023-10-13T09:18:57 | 2023-10-13T09:18:57 | Maxime Bouthors, Josep Crego, François Yvon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Machine Translation (RAMT) is attracting growing
attention. This is because RAMT not only improves translation metrics, but is
also assumed to implement some form of domain adaptation. In this contribution,
we study another salient trait of RAMT, its ability to make translation
decisions more transparent by allowing users to go back to examples that
contributed to these decisions.
For this, we propose a novel architecture aiming to increase this
transparency. This model adapts a retrieval-augmented version of the
Levenshtein Transformer and makes it amenable to simultaneously edit multiple
fuzzy matches found in memory. We discuss how to perform training and inference
in this model, based on multi-way alignment algorithms and imitation learning.
Our experiments show that editing several examples positively impacts
translation scores, notably increasing the number of target spans that are
copied from existing instances. | [
0.0426135585,
0.0442699641,
-0.0181339029,
-0.002965274,
-0.0195400789,
-0.0093134977,
0.0135650299,
0.0247019827,
-0.0638201609,
-0.0566994809,
-0.0332812704,
-0.0335238911,
-0.021440303,
-0.0436017066,
0.0659978092,
-0.021813767,
0.0585541688,
0.0419756472,
-0.0297934301,
0.0201854687,
0.0116206072,
0.0005416792,
0.0168784503,
0.0260513369,
0.0067597427,
0.0412889607,
0.0035218638,
-0.001393984,
0.0682919398,
0.0087771779,
-0.0355491638,
0.0284045879,
0.0372506268,
0.0524579622,
0.0000019306,
-0.026715029,
-0.0599398203,
0.0165907852,
-0.0024376612,
-0.0115520963,
0.0386873595,
0.0060671065,
-0.0144255338,
0.0137224039,
0.0057835733,
0.0320575237,
0.0992665067,
-0.0104620019,
0.0921735913,
0.1048448235,
-0.0213571154,
-0.0354210325,
0.0005158979,
-0.0398071371,
0.0806352124,
-0.0226790104,
0.0006787832,
-0.0092664193,
-0.0263189636,
-0.0258220397,
0.0243243687,
0.0641034767,
-0.0248430185,
0.0252392702,
-0.0395705737,
-0.009811569,
-0.0433310866,
-0.0233743209,
0.0121440105,
0.0452727303,
-0.053541176,
-0.0191669483,
-0.0181981977,
0.0115057798,
-0.00270413,
0.0209092814,
-0.0380802155,
-0.0307550207,
0.0031210098,
0.0105132973,
0.0077607189,
0.0215252992,
0.031468451,
0.0074548768,
-0.0510887727,
-0.0260981489,
0.0199421886,
-0.0384406149,
-0.0375826545,
0.0148083363,
-0.0415658578,
0.0097779064,
0.0768051296,
0.0016013805,
0.0277073737,
0.0256853029,
-0.0442115702,
-0.0628125146,
0.028873397,
0.0261934549,
0.0380566604,
0.0812054798,
0.0014784357,
0.0028371082,
-0.0594511032,
0.0342628658,
-0.0398014784,
0.0069505125,
-0.0678101331,
-0.0265286397,
-0.0567944124,
0.0179693587,
-0.0560055748,
-0.0117398323,
0.0073835878,
0.0369210206,
-0.055405993,
0.0193820931,
0.0362988338,
0.0266704522,
0.0001077476,
-0.0337688252,
-0.0922426954,
-0.0076067001,
-0.0544584766,
0.059380278,
0.0044285683,
-0.0387171432,
0.0293111932,
-0.0537316538,
-0.0308486931,
-0.0038693524,
0.0163764656,
-0.0578291267,
-0.002978303,
0.0976156592,
-0.0309367329,
-0.0703803375,
-0.0014215891,
-0.0118385246,
0.019607855,
-0.0064326078,
0.0233045779,
-0.0442607254,
0.0569674373,
-0.0097740032,
0.0055317264,
-0.0217688177,
0.0244458094,
0.0059884326,
-0.0050527332,
0.0848875195,
0.0233857781,
-0.0248490553,
0.0086474251,
-0.0171657931,
-0.0235275086,
0.0144722862,
0.0196750127,
0.0030169417,
0.0247014016,
0.009557981,
0.0399734974,
0.0533044748,
0.0488870069,
-0.0056658848,
0.0037273744,
0.0041850638,
-0.0163519997,
0.0650871992,
0.0211465564,
-0.0004759273,
-0.0331591703,
0.0009649778,
0.0527761877,
0.0627389997,
0.0638747662,
0.0481017679,
0.0319074653,
-0.0000324379,
-0.0309733897,
0.0119103659,
-0.031318333,
0.0695157722,
-0.0341119021,
0.0633647591,
0.022049645,
0.0547895357,
0.0088612726,
0.0021397264,
0.0051608793,
-0.0145135066,
0.0014264249,
0.0016402627,
0.0143046826,
0.0081847925,
-0.042189043,
0.055881463,
-0.0140681472,
-0.0712694526,
0.000695911,
-0.0370779447,
-0.0450937785,
0.0419199392,
0.0594836436,
-0.0523556098,
-0.0489322618,
-0.0200101286,
-0.0697424859,
0.0452653132,
0.0767228082,
0.0205118898,
-0.0038162898,
-0.0664930418,
-0.0140829301,
0.0347988978,
-0.0052814605,
0.0460986085,
0.0015637958,
0.0142367147,
0.027692467,
-0.0194204971,
-0.0227679126,
0.0256556943,
-0.0018957702,
-0.008059971,
-0.0226051901,
0.0142371627,
0.0301502533,
-0.0047767218,
-0.0299422387,
0.0249761306,
0.0023783867,
-0.0068805455,
-0.0314894952,
0.0038784754,
-0.0270083342,
-0.0496260487,
0.0045312885,
-0.0557355024,
-0.0548319519,
-0.0178762898,
-0.022485286,
-0.0483425148,
-0.0056958552,
-0.063867107,
0.0078994567,
-0.0328686535,
0.0339096934,
0.0048159729,
-0.0204877872,
-0.0475466028,
0.0456190258,
0.0116676744,
0.011189484,
-0.0070034624,
-0.05511171,
0.0012135975,
-0.0567916445,
0.0076606637,
-0.0234792959,
0.0291335303,
0.0249157697,
0.0368543044,
0.006976583,
0.0032775721,
-0.0453532487,
-0.0053240163,
0.0145253502,
-0.014901937,
0.0282596275,
0.0279078539,
0.046909254,
0.0070149135,
-0.0104973214,
-0.0359788798,
0.0237930287,
-0.0107932249,
0.0254377984,
0.0366576426,
0.0161467772,
0.0081323003,
-0.0510994606,
-0.0107371146,
-0.0241955519,
0.0429459698,
-0.0200170334,
-0.0530086868,
-0.0525316298,
-0.0138146142,
-0.0773709118,
0.0077820229,
0.0064718323,
-0.0263723265,
0.0054524792,
-0.0209757611,
0.0466845557,
0.0271964241,
0.0082235914,
-0.0075828694,
0.0428309515,
-0.0119220866,
-0.040681608,
-0.0005158069,
-0.0173144005,
-0.0090532815,
0.0012629365,
-0.0298959091,
0.0346799903,
0.0034245572,
0.000970945,
-0.0102941757,
-0.0436854027,
0.0226468239,
0.0387364179,
-0.0173394997,
-0.0170975607,
0.0094731487,
-0.0160290543,
0.0472689681,
0.0033698042,
-0.0234433785,
0.1202692315,
-0.0177723691,
-0.0141988983,
-0.0584801175,
0.0049912916,
-0.0094145443,
0.0040019779,
0.0108014429,
0.0306115597,
0.0143660624,
-0.0265659299,
-0.0450105369,
0.0162646472,
0.0438518412,
-0.0494169965,
0.0660636052,
-0.0430041701,
-0.0141327372,
-0.0185233485,
-0.0370514952,
-0.0013711759,
0.0148022976,
-0.0052023781,
-0.007672064,
0.0060749664,
-0.0316861123,
-0.1202344149,
0.0167868026,
0.0690122917,
0.0832687318,
-0.0079059349,
-0.007641986,
-0.0270829964,
0.010949811,
0.0250187572,
0.0124253267,
0.0215764344,
-0.0287158284,
-0.0084115174,
0.0249626953,
0.0148759522,
-0.0555580407,
0.017885102,
-0.0005538762,
0.0096193627,
-0.0541387051,
-0.0021129872,
-0.0021733879,
0.0409541093,
-0.0482449904,
-0.0057690428,
0.0889893994,
0.0456937589,
-0.025335921,
-0.0033868279,
-0.0285925046,
-0.0032592355,
0.0387785323,
0.0700221881,
-0.1054432392,
-0.0608721934,
0.0026720457,
0.0286606215,
-0.0208084844,
-0.0109466948,
-0.0124073923,
-0.0587277934,
0.0081563098,
0.0478125028,
-0.0702412277,
-0.0393798649,
0.0119862789,
-0.006024709,
-0.0357850417,
0.0084082987,
0.016788438,
0.031163767,
0.0176594201,
-0.0184187647,
0.059504807,
-0.0525874384,
-0.0265726112,
-0.0514886864,
0.0243759509,
0.05884289,
0.0138887782,
0.0187688321,
-0.0642149076,
-0.0130243106,
-0.0409976579,
0.0316078626,
-0.0024282236,
0.0502879284,
0.0209054202,
-0.0337494873,
-0.0191812404,
0.0093528191,
-0.0083310325,
-0.0106758103,
-0.0177668836,
0.0671215504,
-0.0144440262,
0.0298930742,
0.01142722,
-0.0387426987,
-0.0223506466,
0.0294681303,
0.0327674001,
-0.0145367403,
0.0146630593,
-0.0207916107,
0.0043061753,
-0.0262909513,
-0.0643726662,
-0.0296163522,
-0.0680676922,
0.0186240114,
-0.0747051015,
-0.0321368724,
0.0272484683,
0.0538278148,
0.0309217051,
-0.0377143286,
0.0402058661,
-0.00442906,
-0.0208518356,
0.0611279123,
-0.0122521576,
0.0061754584,
-0.0188391898,
-0.0006047928,
0.0458931662,
-0.0338245817,
0.0021143763,
0.0418235622,
-0.0015725493,
-0.0525082536,
-0.03050364,
0.039406959,
0.0262767971,
0.0498714596,
-0.0022826181,
0.0070477799,
0.0344391391,
0.0354419947,
-0.0246986095,
-0.0371968485,
0.0420760326,
-0.0121929934,
-0.0104574515,
0.0269074719,
-0.0090986406,
-0.0145463878,
-0.0346056446,
0.0421979353,
-0.0111879902,
-0.0212654714,
0.0637015998,
0.0269142054,
0.0746000707,
-0.020933643,
0.0520539209,
-0.0264976453,
0.0171357635,
-0.0229237676,
-0.0179955363,
-0.0196158383,
-0.028578246,
0.0365110263,
-0.0016108862,
0.0005330246,
-0.0187849663,
-0.0136307366,
0.0170756504,
-0.0316333659,
-0.0142510068,
-0.0491450317,
0.0397470891,
-0.0246201772,
0.0070024026,
-0.0067604794,
0.03438247,
0.0126653919,
0.0520198569,
-0.0624706671,
0.0573418811,
0.0083565284,
0.000418636,
-0.0263172891,
0.0479614809,
-0.0506129377,
0.0283381492,
-0.0441964492,
0.0117892968,
0.058995232,
-0.0303831287,
0.0952830762,
-0.0144688431,
-0.0206966382,
0.0168877244,
0.0263927951,
-0.0294830184,
-0.0018926885,
0.0280063171,
0.0176767129,
0.0061372272,
-0.0283871312,
0.0263285805,
-0.0934851617,
0.022896342,
-0.048845388,
-0.052827727,
-0.0241382271,
-0.0126202004,
0.0217086338,
-0.0256430861,
-0.0174922161,
-0.0502875745,
-0.0402102582,
-0.0284902994,
-0.0006406233,
0.0144270482,
0.0020199062,
0.00341748,
0.0511132143,
0.0674044415,
-0.020774249,
-0.0332937241,
-0.0049727098,
0.0070667313,
-0.0059545655,
-0.0334804356,
-0.0027632162,
-6.249382738e-33,
-0.0445525721,
0.0009581911,
0.0189672634,
0.0009763383,
-0.0355372243,
-0.0181665812,
-0.0335307233,
-0.0106970342,
0.0057548499,
-0.0124966651,
0.0055900128,
-0.0212510601,
0.0134173743,
-0.0335715488,
0.0032252707,
0.0159704108,
0.0484762453,
0.0228793658,
-0.0356885977,
-0.003862957,
0.0229856409,
-0.0003265786,
0.1162778139,
-0.0323067307,
-0.0078434218,
0.0540711321,
-0.0035078712,
0.0057590045,
-0.0382344499,
0.0311318375,
0.0044928384,
0.0152728762,
-0.0106996987,
-0.0306006707,
-0.0374010876,
-0.0385933295,
-0.0524988323,
-0.0050706924,
0.0004361104,
0.025450917,
0.0053860382,
-0.0431425944,
0.0484209694,
-0.0496669412,
-0.0082798023,
0.0288677756,
0.0008001181,
-0.0480302386,
-0.0244589895,
-0.0016954368,
-0.0494738631,
0.0170218628,
-0.006322931,
0.0022251706,
0.0288107395,
0.0744381472,
0.0021106072,
-0.0078139612,
-0.0611128882,
0.0093851257,
-0.0097060418,
0.0697888359,
0.0571498275,
-0.0424607955,
-0.0227075815,
0.0226616636,
-0.0058923815,
-0.0456690788,
0.0500277802,
0.0162628908,
0.0027937465,
-0.0065423935,
0.0801526234,
0.0497484691,
0.0327701047,
0.0072653685,
0.0057836319,
0.0654799193,
-0.0131637026,
0.0367595516,
-0.0100887604,
0.051588472,
-0.001193256,
0.0350648463,
-0.0310173072,
-0.012844719,
-0.0494435392,
-0.0202036742,
-0.017779218,
-0.017211426,
-0.0562359989,
0.0531086698,
0.069738701,
0.033397872,
0.0202777907,
-0.0657793507,
-0.0231643524,
0.0146285277,
-0.0338567905,
-0.0030427224,
-0.001575418,
-0.0596986786,
0.0658950806,
0.0149433604,
0.0061370637,
-0.0046035075,
0.0425655693,
0.0533417724,
-0.0679695085,
0.0157485586,
-0.0263417158,
-0.0129902326,
-0.0315556824,
-0.0627329126,
0.0097843958,
0.0079671443,
0.0052076653,
0.0150263915,
0.0466073155,
-0.0688697845,
-0.0548491105,
0.0398504734,
0.0197418649,
0.0229996797,
-0.063720189,
0.0350041874,
-0.0421711542,
0.0306032095,
0.0440421887,
-0.07155817,
-0.0327477753,
0.0229871497,
2.879e-7,
0.0575834252,
0.0736273751,
0.0490514152,
0.0224122554,
0.0231287517,
0.0357901789,
-0.0315325223,
0.0378028937,
0.0306622572,
0.0489380173,
0.0716345608,
-0.0379098281,
0.017955685,
0.0311871693,
-0.0394080319,
-0.031539727,
-0.0482192039,
-0.00035952,
-0.0477760211,
-0.0045498712,
0.0472520664,
0.0925897956,
0.0155714927,
0.009944276,
0.0156975053,
-0.0553410053,
0.0661547706,
0.005531006,
-0.0199731681,
0.0042320397,
0.0457935594,
-0.0020355573,
-0.0190016832,
-0.0014350489,
-0.0312288981,
0.0215752032,
0.0300670229,
0.0290447455,
-0.0068042479,
-0.0232330561,
0.0169187356,
0.007811015,
0.009650819,
-0.0247570872,
0.009464182,
-0.0780787915,
-0.0206122175,
0.0382543281,
-0.0364927389,
0.0275595784,
0.0059291688,
0.0056579164,
-0.0382459164,
0.0463876985,
0.017318422,
0.0642418265,
-0.032579612,
-0.0327738114,
-0.0363873877,
-0.0423409827,
-0.0256341435,
-0.0240931083,
-0.0358214192,
-0.0090806084,
-0.0050094165,
-0.0602864362,
-0.0608051233,
2.853725136e-34,
0.0157816336,
-0.0090946211,
0.0075512491,
0.0200852677,
0.0531204715,
-0.0163247008,
-0.0374790691,
0.0136699937,
0.0099277124,
-0.0442232154,
-0.0747108832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08958v1 | xDial-Eval: A Multilingual Open-Domain Dialogue Evaluation Benchmark | 2023-10-13T09:07:13 | 2023-10-13T09:07:13 | Chen Zhang, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Chengguang Tang, Ke Shi, Guohua Tang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in reference-free learned metrics for open-domain
dialogue evaluation have been driven by the progress in pre-trained language
models and the availability of dialogue data with high-quality human
annotations. However, current studies predominantly concentrate on English
dialogues, and the generalization of these metrics to other languages has not
been fully examined. This is largely due to the absence of a multilingual
dialogue evaluation benchmark. To address the issue, we introduce xDial-Eval,
built on top of open-source English dialogue evaluation datasets. xDial-Eval
includes 12 turn-level and 6 dialogue-level English datasets, comprising 14930
annotated turns and 8691 annotated dialogues respectively. The English dialogue
data are extended to nine other languages with commercial machine translation
systems. On xDial-Eval, we conduct comprehensive analyses of previous
BERT-based metrics and the recently-emerged large language models. Lastly, we
establish strong self-supervised and multilingual baselines. In terms of
average Pearson correlations over all datasets and languages, the best baseline
outperforms OpenAI's ChatGPT by absolute improvements of 6.5% and 4.6% at the
turn and dialogue levels respectively, albeit with much fewer parameters. The
data and code are publicly available at https://github.com/e0397123/xDial-Eval. | [
0.0075884019,
0.0321974941,
0.0152483098,
0.0578001216,
-0.0334146395,
0.011044682,
0.0066989227,
-0.0017175539,
0.037940599,
-0.0358199365,
-0.1176658943,
-0.0280777123,
0.0165331904,
0.0115835173,
-0.0255937539,
-0.0368615165,
0.0304488558,
-0.0169996358,
0.0389753021,
0.0133774402,
-0.0091458792,
-0.010470055,
-0.0431746915,
0.0784068853,
0.0010642427,
-0.0290385019,
-0.027314024,
0.0054602893,
0.0383956581,
-0.0093713328,
0.0082215695,
0.0547472797,
-0.0054065064,
0.0545988902,
0.0000017382,
-0.0279322341,
0.0201021805,
-0.0248306412,
-0.0367984809,
0.0249262527,
0.0056177112,
0.0249013398,
-0.0093404911,
0.0270602666,
-0.0420491621,
-0.0393192321,
0.0396952443,
0.0591226928,
0.0936991721,
0.0812395215,
0.0033936168,
-0.0267037507,
-0.0069425064,
-0.0327164419,
-0.0395518504,
-0.0772382244,
-0.0260552522,
0.0178046376,
-0.0219264925,
-0.0074769142,
-0.0136400498,
0.0235924628,
0.0343704559,
-0.0504382513,
-0.0446603857,
0.0318803452,
-0.0830456167,
0.0035629545,
-0.0237941351,
0.1330005825,
0.020545952,
0.0238189287,
-0.0288298149,
-0.0053353966,
0.0123587195,
-0.043502979,
-0.0295151658,
-0.0010429191,
0.0400710776,
0.0014908554,
-0.0311631225,
0.0399010815,
0.0003119779,
0.0072870636,
-0.0034344874,
0.0410021394,
0.0122724194,
-0.02737871,
0.0041617458,
-0.014380591,
-0.0095439702,
-0.0363711268,
-0.0233770423,
0.0015377121,
-0.0512088053,
0.0119871609,
-0.0280377045,
0.003890851,
0.0172205996,
-0.060927622,
0.0259733386,
0.0365039743,
-0.0321225859,
0.0629277304,
0.0147229619,
0.0807157904,
-0.0067154788,
0.0319241695,
-0.0307995472,
-0.0033799424,
-0.0348295942,
0.0395446196,
-0.0608817413,
-0.0006473511,
-0.0611344874,
-0.0477126129,
-0.019085722,
0.0165819917,
0.0023057172,
0.0106373234,
0.0481672399,
0.0035515928,
0.0130820852,
0.0072205979,
-0.0186866857,
0.0492160022,
-0.0290758815,
-0.0116394283,
0.0210352335,
-0.0753956139,
-0.0287089832,
0.0344816335,
-0.0058432617,
-0.0225882772,
-0.0173121784,
0.0845651552,
-0.0025184187,
-0.0481202751,
0.0211389549,
0.0098209912,
-0.0590169765,
-0.0791712254,
-0.0233118329,
-0.0248061214,
0.0446817242,
-0.0207201988,
-0.0016329385,
0.0090549514,
0.0194457415,
-0.0004851769,
-0.0020847779,
0.0355713218,
0.0334743373,
0.0042325286,
0.0133530609,
0.0011560498,
-0.0061587035,
0.0680536851,
0.0465394743,
-0.0014854477,
0.0564548932,
-0.0031285419,
0.0147200236,
0.0634323508,
0.0325929336,
0.0053896382,
0.051913891,
0.0419910774,
-0.0071876552,
0.0455470383,
-0.0022054971,
0.0328754298,
-0.0525193997,
-0.0449720174,
0.0422443822,
0.0240346156,
-0.0042442591,
0.0000999175,
0.0422222428,
0.0261795279,
0.0398016497,
0.0060140784,
-0.0284754597,
0.0265951268,
0.0293893497,
-0.0141155049,
0.0595558509,
-0.0223923977,
-0.0362645835,
-0.058179412,
0.003486166,
-0.0002718384,
-0.0015053651,
-0.0126758171,
0.0131671531,
0.0181468241,
-0.0635683611,
0.0713269636,
-0.0064289682,
-0.0692069083,
-0.0448343977,
-0.0347449221,
0.0079773283,
0.0217107851,
0.0373355746,
-0.0087371897,
-0.0626027286,
-0.0274445619,
-0.0005009921,
0.0598640628,
0.0590765551,
-0.0182394907,
0.0809531957,
-0.0667176172,
-0.0119406311,
-0.0397826396,
-0.0027080842,
0.0410580672,
-0.0058784261,
-0.0031466598,
-0.0035168973,
-0.0465843789,
-0.0083847214,
-0.0111305453,
0.0044532837,
-0.0398770683,
0.0358077884,
0.0136272674,
0.0529506207,
0.0224863254,
-0.0337177813,
0.0008729813,
0.0421192423,
0.0032940942,
-0.0013296959,
0.0264730304,
-0.0499959663,
-0.0820905864,
0.0145582492,
-0.0251320545,
-0.0310700778,
0.0186305605,
-0.0544758886,
-0.0518321507,
0.0208658371,
-0.0385967419,
0.0701960027,
-0.0321561731,
0.0275461283,
0.0232346933,
0.027596958,
-0.008187918,
0.0235323217,
-0.0111743277,
0.0232574493,
0.0533073694,
0.0397899188,
0.0693339854,
-0.0392864645,
-0.016727265,
0.0190298203,
-0.0407399461,
0.0094136791,
0.0233466327,
0.0396481864,
-0.0520343073,
-0.0454907604,
-0.1328959465,
0.0171616804,
-0.0323185921,
0.0148608843,
0.0282877181,
0.0060458337,
-0.002518239,
-0.0249026325,
-0.0262919404,
-0.0411085077,
0.0332609341,
0.0025375241,
-0.004784978,
0.0318229534,
0.0034978024,
-0.0231679175,
0.0014486436,
0.0202042181,
0.0557118282,
-0.0254174173,
0.0424963087,
0.001251076,
-0.019757431,
-0.0513642915,
0.0069109751,
-0.0131353168,
-0.0778136924,
0.0225167684,
0.0256252382,
0.0262247212,
0.0280008297,
0.011699684,
0.0064680171,
-0.0057950667,
-0.0409649275,
-0.043555785,
0.0319304764,
-0.0115181096,
-0.0328768156,
-0.027274821,
0.0172711648,
0.0182924513,
0.0306910463,
0.0116691142,
0.0294304211,
-0.0637146235,
-0.046549011,
-0.0034284981,
-0.0555744432,
-0.0103647541,
0.0092770811,
-0.0417332761,
0.0187614877,
-0.0348117538,
-0.0342692584,
0.0566292033,
-0.0529673584,
-0.0325913131,
-0.0672172755,
0.0198019072,
-0.0318013281,
0.0487411283,
-0.0395496339,
0.0073114065,
-0.0221364237,
-0.0409420244,
-0.0040232781,
0.0000239497,
0.0126575176,
-0.0370595455,
0.0454555713,
-0.0190188158,
-0.0075168558,
0.0028607335,
-0.0441572592,
-0.0537065864,
-0.0188809112,
-0.0084968582,
-0.0016063655,
0.016778212,
-0.0472804271,
-0.0203173272,
-0.0010989818,
-0.0169497374,
0.0366802886,
-0.0102234539,
0.0217849258,
0.0067683528,
0.0629081354,
-0.0030719968,
0.0074398923,
-0.0003424372,
-0.0033561753,
0.0761177018,
0.019210685,
0.02219503,
-0.0108384583,
-0.0200671311,
-0.0091334293,
0.0159323383,
-0.0176299866,
0.0009968992,
0.0027073177,
0.0490348414,
-0.018548619,
-0.0255254917,
0.1212052256,
0.0176992137,
-0.0127315782,
-0.0236408953,
-0.0366617963,
0.0283839982,
0.0056313239,
-0.0015700099,
-0.0824545249,
-0.0365632847,
-0.0107775452,
0.0087614879,
0.0205715448,
-0.024127895,
0.0025179822,
-0.1188518107,
0.0241480451,
-0.0247065239,
-0.0762318224,
-0.0171599276,
-0.0187102165,
-0.0019462302,
-0.0535410345,
0.0323432498,
-0.0108693605,
0.0172767006,
-0.0103032039,
0.0084259408,
-0.0166903418,
-0.0079462267,
0.0609382875,
-0.0084477961,
0.0383271128,
0.0543579012,
0.0904914513,
0.0315969959,
-0.035827443,
0.0362555869,
-0.0173579585,
-0.0229619425,
-0.0057963682,
0.0710251331,
-0.0043819794,
-0.0393196084,
-0.0122511312,
0.0070662214,
0.0121251578,
-0.018299412,
0.0059594437,
0.009173248,
-0.0340399779,
0.0196377262,
0.0129916752,
0.0422264747,
0.0176267102,
0.0721311569,
0.0274101719,
-0.0392315201,
-0.0114999432,
0.002453381,
-0.0101951146,
-0.0708619058,
-0.0113394996,
-0.005647074,
0.0232077073,
-0.0179160405,
-0.0781204849,
-0.0537117459,
0.0060669617,
0.013797042,
-0.0041469201,
-0.0252399407,
-0.0224513356,
0.0215202235,
0.0151728392,
0.0399316177,
-0.0209140424,
0.0246427637,
-0.080050379,
0.0049585993,
0.0475014597,
0.0045361281,
-0.020000428,
0.0516202264,
-0.052385889,
-0.0383340567,
-0.0244884286,
0.0666578338,
0.0077375369,
0.0395585634,
-0.030825112,
0.0135647869,
0.0086555714,
-0.015141068,
-0.0167524666,
-0.0289317947,
0.0749335662,
0.0508710854,
-0.0250113644,
0.0476192385,
-0.0153227849,
0.0013356956,
-0.0021001941,
0.0421445407,
-0.037936911,
-0.108048968,
-0.0090299184,
-0.0048875469,
0.0813943073,
-0.0005610279,
-0.0255456176,
0.0015907577,
0.0356966928,
-0.0163453072,
-0.0127464896,
-0.0716670677,
-0.00166647,
0.0199316833,
-0.0283536501,
-0.0163516738,
0.0327979773,
-0.0484182052,
0.0052537452,
-0.0266325418,
0.0146027934,
0.0549556129,
0.0048284922,
-0.0267347377,
-0.0020151529,
-0.03319088,
-0.0026832863,
0.0066989702,
0.0228648558,
0.0188256595,
0.1031528562,
0.0141465878,
-0.0076125651,
0.0815765262,
0.0573074892,
-0.0547200851,
-0.0097801033,
-0.0198925938,
0.0225516744,
0.0338574238,
0.0036071446,
0.0764127299,
-0.0065712617,
0.002648114,
-0.0111352084,
0.0568417758,
-0.0095828753,
-0.0338871703,
0.0321695358,
0.0038379882,
-0.0037329653,
0.0372596942,
0.0503384061,
-0.0281056948,
0.0249533504,
0.0255665611,
0.0215380564,
-0.0564181022,
-0.0612056889,
-0.0012197733,
-0.0034900093,
-0.0109114423,
0.0108027169,
-0.023978658,
-0.0469060913,
-0.0200372301,
0.0533752218,
-0.0056578172,
0.0421328172,
0.0447587334,
0.0427612551,
-0.0260190181,
0.0077464869,
-0.0491564944,
-0.0009279061,
0.0032087553,
-0.0117822019,
-0.0339310132,
-5.374474048e-33,
-0.0270153321,
-0.0104980236,
0.004943213,
-0.0020093701,
-0.0490839817,
-0.0147829,
-0.0352870449,
0.0382067226,
-0.0415266864,
0.0300382376,
-0.002574224,
0.0230060108,
0.0202439111,
0.0325966701,
-0.0261014383,
-0.0540471077,
0.0289309882,
0.0106377555,
-0.0392454863,
0.0449328087,
0.0126120253,
-0.0047250637,
0.0709614828,
-0.0914710984,
0.036241021,
-0.0137385083,
-0.0244624335,
0.0236097574,
0.0064077578,
0.0588815175,
-0.0030562868,
0.0179097671,
-0.002083044,
-0.0617734045,
-0.0022020242,
0.0138966702,
-0.0420321003,
-0.0142735438,
0.0304382071,
0.0309304707,
-0.0196892358,
0.0091829281,
-0.0315420479,
-0.0020526522,
-0.0186889302,
0.0030990369,
0.0027077866,
-0.0115291355,
-0.0032463586,
0.0192614403,
-0.0330938362,
0.0338225141,
-0.0437641479,
-0.095790796,
-0.0149917994,
0.0829714388,
0.0061898343,
-0.0330619402,
-0.0292103868,
0.0212057624,
-0.0316509828,
-0.0081474055,
0.0294772703,
-0.0014984806,
-0.0026819045,
0.0459307246,
-0.0002005183,
-0.0028517889,
0.0103778318,
-0.0516062789,
0.0146924201,
0.0578157715,
0.0353746079,
0.0547922924,
-0.028210178,
0.0369976722,
-0.0400249921,
0.0399390161,
0.0137301991,
0.0350658037,
-0.0334806405,
-0.0076487497,
0.0065023466,
0.0186520815,
-0.0469545461,
-0.0143047888,
-0.0249672364,
-0.0119138416,
0.0340606757,
0.0048672603,
-0.0013438733,
-0.025237577,
0.0674219653,
-0.0348964483,
-0.0030599472,
0.0560271628,
-0.0141575355,
0.0107263122,
-0.0216882266,
0.0250018053,
-0.0283395909,
-0.0044794506,
0.0485956892,
0.0355719402,
0.0231044348,
-0.0113780955,
0.0357527211,
0.00805532,
-0.0500143915,
0.0179992318,
-0.0258886311,
0.0374205783,
-0.0632292554,
0.0618677326,
0.0154612549,
-0.0182562061,
-0.0413514264,
0.0781960264,
-0.0135363899,
0.0201400984,
-0.0193445701,
-0.0561359227,
0.0422180444,
-0.0008892372,
-0.0539289489,
0.0114974994,
-0.0015156011,
-0.0026111617,
-0.0157581978,
-0.0257931761,
-0.0107265534,
0.0193456691,
2.358e-7,
0.0148431836,
0.0060191443,
0.0408906601,
0.0376950689,
-0.0059455861,
0.0416762345,
-0.0357088037,
0.0093156658,
0.0154792508,
0.0209246688,
0.0141666578,
-0.0013566542,
0.0720827952,
-0.0136363152,
-0.1090010181,
-0.0341642611,
-0.1076698378,
-0.0155496886,
-0.0167725403,
-0.0175042171,
0.0350284204,
0.0936224982,
0.0080767283,
0.0231328811,
-0.0177114252,
0.0024478214,
0.0539695956,
-0.0354060233,
-0.0257830638,
0.0261963531,
0.0322355814,
0.0079214666,
-0.0090168994,
-0.0038252985,
-0.0294462666,
0.0325927846,
0.0418551676,
0.0701642558,
0.0176444929,
-0.0905746669,
0.0061373767,
-0.011597611,
0.0003276594,
-0.0322173946,
0.054583773,
-0.0243919343,
-0.0204994623,
-0.0065170303,
-0.0252234582,
0.011422487,
0.0876068994,
-0.0343308784,
-0.0267822593,
0.048692096,
0.0245580077,
-0.0302908309,
0.0175459813,
-0.0602956004,
-0.0347407945,
-0.0203812066,
-0.023308808,
-0.0278005097,
-0.0083696963,
-0.0298153069,
0.0001339158,
-0.0214343052,
0.0099108629,
1.576070798e-34,
0.0473058298,
-0.0346425213,
0.0356645696,
0.0206234753,
0.0249197446,
-0.0175211802,
0.0304255188,
-0.0392652489,
0.0288188718,
-0.0625109151,
0.0099850642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08954v1 | Textual Analysis of ICALEPCS and IPAC Conference Proceedings: Revealing Research Trends, Topics, and Collaborations for Future Insights and Advanced Search | 2023-10-13T08:55:19 | 2023-10-13T08:55:19 | Antonin Sulc, Annika Eichler, Tim Wilksen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we show a textual analysis of past ICALEPCS and IPAC
conference proceedings to gain insights into the research trends and topics
discussed in the field. We use natural language processing techniques to
extract meaningful information from the abstracts and papers of past conference
proceedings. We extract topics to visualize and identify trends, analyze their
evolution to identify emerging research directions, and highlight interesting
publications based solely on their content with an analysis of their network.
Additionally, we will provide an advanced search tool to better search the
existing papers to prevent duplication and easier reference findings. Our
analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the research landscape in the
field and helps researchers and practitioners to better understand the
state-of-the-art and identify areas for future research. | [
0.0454142578,
-0.0093536107,
-0.0292385276,
0.0256080516,
-0.0730878636,
-0.0353986584,
-0.0056986627,
0.033720687,
-0.004680255,
-0.0657714829,
0.0088659599,
0.01898087,
0.0019336593,
0.0698445141,
-0.022430364,
-0.0481143631,
0.0336864702,
0.0151160201,
0.033759471,
0.0702138916,
0.0227878056,
-0.0045812409,
0.0119726788,
0.0342774913,
0.0401652046,
-0.0145644499,
-0.0169539377,
-0.0158644803,
0.0136846593,
-0.0866148323,
0.0126122935,
-0.0106169684,
-0.0020760673,
0.0117143719,
0.0000020868,
-0.0635023713,
-0.0881486237,
0.0228857361,
0.0567862354,
0.0579642504,
0.0532700531,
0.0087962076,
0.005361774,
0.0158159006,
-0.0325757079,
-0.0047230334,
0.0173284579,
0.068533197,
0.0224398337,
0.0500164889,
-0.0377478376,
-0.0190460011,
-0.0087035429,
0.0138073396,
-0.0668576881,
-0.0372430645,
0.0260882024,
-0.0276740603,
0.0470781513,
0.0302457176,
0.0487809516,
0.0094963517,
-0.0673770308,
-0.0348630659,
0.0480988771,
0.0412312597,
-0.0616666824,
-0.0179373622,
-0.0407072268,
-0.0238750223,
0.0264827032,
-0.0170229841,
0.0748344883,
-0.0151384184,
-0.0394162834,
0.0389000922,
-0.0466624424,
-0.0085707903,
-0.0316488817,
0.0092382291,
0.0064814561,
0.0489206277,
-0.0396442674,
0.0030381931,
0.0021702426,
0.0452459157,
0.0031061328,
-0.0640657395,
-0.006495608,
-0.0062517291,
0.0635943934,
-0.0649051294,
0.0802795514,
0.0243962836,
0.0358755998,
0.0051867026,
0.0255950019,
-0.0403720848,
0.0256713387,
-0.0850911364,
-0.0323924534,
-0.029243229,
0.0361843184,
0.0524480939,
0.0156494435,
-0.0553023629,
-0.0269824807,
-0.0303596035,
0.001919609,
0.0247014109,
-0.0468767472,
-0.0068316883,
-0.0259339511,
0.0443960279,
-0.0231588911,
-0.0049341144,
-0.0105204443,
0.0014643448,
0.0173474476,
0.0217618309,
-0.0043845777,
0.0153574469,
-0.0103181675,
-0.0039889864,
-0.0172418747,
0.0123309121,
-0.0366351008,
0.0018924577,
-0.0379724763,
0.0009872303,
0.0165033359,
0.0375215933,
0.0544963554,
0.0358884819,
-0.0255782939,
0.0530917309,
0.0218017511,
-0.0519999899,
-0.02313371,
-0.0564397722,
-0.0030562298,
-0.0022131063,
-0.0093045132,
-0.0494758189,
-0.0157983005,
-0.0087189712,
0.0097231008,
-0.0047523691,
-0.004140947,
0.017945502,
-0.0253095385,
0.023843918,
-0.0445120148,
-0.0202342495,
0.0430954508,
-0.0035638192,
0.0359816998,
0.0107302079,
-0.0052307919,
-0.008349617,
0.0603224821,
-0.0010509703,
0.0127242329,
0.0083176987,
-0.0299639404,
-0.0500545874,
0.0258944631,
0.003784602,
-0.0049051312,
-0.0234827716,
-0.0542234667,
0.029653579,
-0.0139469402,
0.0208455436,
0.0266674254,
0.0974444821,
-0.0047154087,
0.010247089,
-0.0283291321,
0.0528572574,
0.0372911729,
-0.0390603542,
0.0331726298,
-0.0196549091,
0.0030011619,
-0.0072635575,
0.0041163182,
0.0305648986,
0.0140831135,
-0.0628982186,
-0.0304611959,
0.0185011216,
-0.0125299869,
-0.0483182445,
0.0582648702,
0.0026725025,
-0.0183118694,
-0.0475598052,
-0.0002495407,
-0.0299204141,
-0.0081787584,
-0.0105208913,
0.0011037198,
0.0328750759,
0.0532801934,
-0.0544520132,
0.0184042063,
-0.0091593778,
-0.0163527895,
0.0436969362,
0.004576528,
0.0142806852,
-0.0184261054,
-0.0227664802,
-0.0153024411,
0.0750771388,
0.0062124659,
0.012284046,
-0.0267796554,
0.0309623145,
-0.0225723349,
0.0209789537,
-0.0123442141,
0.028918203,
0.0168969594,
0.0293930005,
-0.0036345189,
-0.0176394414,
0.0297843087,
0.05624507,
-0.0102796946,
0.0139872022,
0.0554767661,
-0.0323553905,
-0.0269743837,
0.0533289462,
0.0546126217,
0.0757722929,
0.0031461853,
-0.1167198122,
-0.0043847603,
-0.0273331888,
-0.0067112646,
-0.0053617782,
0.054732088,
0.0056933132,
0.0654077753,
0.0162461959,
0.0163016599,
-0.0121778082,
0.0057274182,
-0.0391636752,
0.0792157874,
0.0368023366,
0.0196872465,
0.0373619795,
-0.0804043487,
0.0463868529,
-0.0167740751,
0.0152289066,
0.0032361317,
-0.0197762996,
-0.0279664937,
0.0655011982,
-0.0076951059,
-0.0144390659,
0.0096512968,
-0.0632449836,
0.0097490177,
0.012464826,
0.0437575988,
0.0461858846,
0.0095636547,
-0.0073011098,
0.0048783268,
0.0058698878,
-0.0309584811,
-0.0155370701,
-0.0590462759,
0.0509551242,
0.0272828508,
-0.0175611209,
-0.0480228402,
-0.0106047448,
-0.0504044294,
0.0495358407,
0.0693633109,
-0.0934856236,
-0.056212049,
0.0412736423,
0.0026623188,
-0.0052042585,
-0.0472921096,
0.0111878105,
-0.0188967828,
-0.0058827512,
-0.0237917621,
0.0342903621,
0.0115288254,
0.0224463809,
-0.0006018894,
-0.0300776158,
-0.0522153862,
0.0032645713,
-0.024630703,
0.093374446,
-0.006055125,
-0.0218785685,
0.1127363145,
0.0523251034,
0.002781719,
0.0039564008,
0.0123795336,
-0.0430652052,
-0.0564447641,
0.0193001926,
-0.0418152325,
-0.07064794,
0.0019619851,
0.0521345586,
0.0476499423,
-0.0142641971,
0.0296282656,
-0.0419853032,
0.0199208204,
-0.1143821478,
-0.0719534755,
-0.0500139408,
0.0191416442,
-0.0165386386,
0.0173136946,
0.0304887798,
-0.0274825469,
0.0307662413,
-0.0173420385,
0.0266553592,
-0.0256376304,
0.0038634432,
-0.023433771,
0.0153524233,
-0.0115566887,
0.0067150113,
-0.00222961,
-0.0281153731,
0.0099235047,
-0.0295263212,
0.0773195103,
-0.0428098366,
-0.0405917279,
0.0586492531,
0.0021744329,
-0.0066408501,
-0.0031471059,
-0.0374267027,
-0.0005538578,
0.0581300259,
0.0043599033,
-0.0490576103,
0.0285332408,
0.0430572964,
-0.0216745641,
0.061290767,
0.0115672722,
0.0175522696,
-0.0292492248,
-0.0012627814,
0.0030854966,
-0.0905755907,
-0.0021508732,
0.0008090104,
-0.0177633502,
-0.033324562,
0.0215358604,
0.0804370269,
0.0500445329,
-0.0938226655,
-0.0252396744,
-0.0207972005,
-0.0227341726,
-0.0150501505,
0.0332567282,
-0.0481156595,
0.0526446328,
-0.0100434897,
0.0097799543,
-0.0401824601,
-0.0533742383,
-0.0049068667,
-0.04597532,
0.04894232,
-0.0157857798,
-0.0148889106,
-0.026685046,
-0.0887793899,
0.0093611758,
-0.0074534011,
-0.0413663574,
-0.0093158167,
-0.0243193842,
-0.0245927423,
0.0212417524,
-0.1623525918,
-0.0655470863,
-0.0282384641,
-0.0098820366,
0.0173688494,
0.0420401096,
0.0731540695,
-0.0329842269,
-0.0007601436,
0.0288385488,
-0.0791475698,
0.0079776784,
-0.0406876877,
0.0194420163,
-0.0126728592,
0.019298844,
-0.0073841494,
0.0182895232,
0.018183697,
-0.0054877014,
0.0618168227,
0.0526727811,
-0.0399632715,
0.0029047425,
-0.0571765341,
0.0184324291,
0.0151909431,
0.0289340373,
-0.0003870693,
0.0008184115,
-0.0438714921,
-0.0445518382,
0.0576542243,
-0.0170367546,
-0.0283664726,
-0.0164343584,
-0.0132849989,
-0.0518344715,
-0.0665858611,
-0.0161635205,
0.0074469987,
0.0149044953,
0.0219081771,
0.0346285291,
0.0600536875,
-0.0034446137,
-0.0398070849,
-0.0130936503,
-0.0093927197,
0.002058317,
-0.0050649503,
0.0070137181,
0.026988849,
0.0390074179,
-0.0595564432,
0.0372808315,
-0.0173250176,
-0.0707963929,
-0.0125654703,
-0.0205201823,
0.034185458,
0.0224704407,
-0.0330757275,
-0.028165279,
0.0231898017,
0.014848426,
0.008620413,
-0.0555639043,
0.003988279,
-0.0091338158,
-0.0036470066,
-0.0398673527,
-0.018458873,
0.0264951494,
-0.0597436838,
-0.0041810866,
-0.0316044167,
-0.0252002422,
0.0180692319,
0.0084330635,
0.0419775844,
-0.0130563574,
-0.0204423107,
0.0003556222,
0.0149671771,
-0.0276166722,
-0.0015578897,
0.0048157363,
-0.0234685112,
-0.0527599342,
-0.0064297668,
-0.0056334175,
0.0771805421,
-0.0480362698,
0.0116672777,
-0.031991519,
0.0719186738,
0.0006094392,
0.024607338,
-0.0132271294,
-0.0181483421,
0.011776153,
-0.002338391,
-0.0223839432,
0.0384222493,
-0.0265487097,
-0.0007890335,
0.0194401536,
-0.004768501,
-0.0243325159,
0.0393886194,
-0.0922254398,
0.010967264,
0.0043162992,
0.0399717651,
0.0173734073,
0.0158605147,
0.0349222943,
-0.0623127893,
0.0140792644,
0.028532749,
0.0311396755,
0.0043291659,
0.0134960348,
-0.009052177,
0.0105902813,
-0.0190104749,
0.0435291938,
0.0517249703,
-0.0233513787,
-0.0368291102,
-0.0096978219,
-0.0483064428,
-0.0416931957,
-0.0011290509,
0.032199692,
0.0545886792,
-0.0128505966,
-0.0303690378,
-0.046314694,
0.0301150959,
0.0698096752,
0.0033299911,
0.0129609331,
-0.0458654463,
0.0275388286,
0.0481019989,
0.0641471744,
-0.0092955008,
-0.0144130616,
-0.0068278122,
-0.0210202225,
-0.0286234934,
-0.0394417048,
-6.63685286e-33,
-0.0126617393,
-0.0424076393,
-0.0148812942,
0.062222559,
-0.0095635951,
0.0124869328,
-0.0262875035,
-0.023122346,
0.0106574697,
-0.0062512611,
-0.0372729041,
0.0141368983,
0.030491313,
-0.015913194,
0.0300483555,
0.0288548954,
0.0315099768,
0.0066693537,
-0.011055747,
0.0119345412,
0.0156244216,
0.0160875898,
0.0544309504,
-0.0744948983,
0.0613892414,
0.0198983233,
-0.0063111084,
-0.0255895536,
0.0726241693,
0.039570909,
-0.0267251488,
-0.0003481192,
0.0293841176,
-0.0228049494,
-0.0101395808,
0.0332728997,
-0.0682158992,
-0.0182466786,
0.0054310006,
0.0039863018,
0.0107037192,
-0.0075529101,
0.0734840408,
0.0193365067,
-0.0187084489,
0.0376078822,
0.0889836103,
0.0077643474,
-0.0388497189,
-0.0236206148,
-0.0107119661,
0.0377435051,
-0.0541447215,
0.097387135,
0.0353709236,
0.0459031239,
-0.0188793875,
0.0572803691,
-0.0558987968,
0.0336486585,
-0.0231428742,
0.0489574745,
0.0059642708,
-0.0533779077,
0.0225001723,
0.0265253987,
-0.0417346098,
-0.0098714661,
0.0308185704,
-0.0121154245,
0.0194783956,
0.0305790529,
0.0114508821,
0.025080435,
0.0178613178,
-0.0092002396,
-0.0436135493,
0.0525120683,
0.0226027705,
0.0286837406,
-0.0016906698,
-0.0067231804,
-0.0314488932,
-0.0157080125,
0.0545452274,
0.0013381214,
0.0177737176,
-0.0381094776,
-0.0036216045,
-0.0217886511,
-0.0422735363,
0.071962066,
0.0186143033,
-0.0139791612,
-0.0558934025,
0.0178154893,
0.034716934,
0.0448933318,
-0.0038894198,
0.0122049795,
-0.0743585527,
-0.0304299686,
-0.0372622795,
0.0196269937,
0.0172145553,
-0.0588580407,
-0.018125087,
-0.0005004832,
-0.064205572,
0.0026596433,
0.0441493094,
0.0036768958,
-0.0144861042,
0.0315761492,
0.0082341032,
0.0095250458,
0.0287432913,
0.0040259026,
0.0093786763,
0.0183546916,
0.0121293515,
-0.0010723326,
-0.0155089628,
0.0022662696,
0.0020057121,
0.0005231706,
-0.0317799076,
0.0377139933,
0.0264643878,
-0.0302922558,
-0.0130338864,
-0.0243820753,
2.843e-7,
0.0361900888,
0.0863603875,
0.0109523814,
0.025411047,
0.0430900231,
-0.0172794126,
0.0090042436,
0.0088218357,
0.0226873849,
0.0147234816,
0.0211340915,
-0.0272693932,
0.0021660649,
0.0292781331,
-0.0827867389,
-0.0304531604,
-0.0424778163,
-0.0414328016,
-0.0887625888,
0.0122857103,
0.0708152428,
0.0336303115,
-0.0090865009,
0.0449587405,
-0.0226540677,
-0.0384863392,
-0.0057959915,
-0.0369209722,
-0.0049420716,
0.0119387042,
0.0210759956,
0.0056453785,
-0.0225065257,
0.0196376946,
-0.0373552032,
0.0322764069,
0.0022126932,
-0.0013425024,
-0.000829169,
0.0610175282,
0.0237732362,
-0.0317450166,
-0.0077327727,
-0.011417293,
0.0530704968,
-0.0362613574,
-0.0086134272,
-0.0277287625,
-0.0457661338,
-0.051537931,
0.0141032869,
0.0196021181,
-0.0384749025,
0.043330282,
-0.0354036354,
-0.0299840979,
-0.0295131207,
-0.0592115,
0.0307554174,
0.0046985443,
0.0009598447,
-0.0177855156,
-0.0118627232,
0.0113763455,
0.0491614006,
0.0114770513,
0.0326727629,
2.821042031e-34,
0.0281251166,
-0.0144636771,
-0.0306785088,
0.0778380409,
0.0205013957,
-0.0078386087,
-0.0220813286,
0.0369295552,
-0.0281449147,
-0.0569580495,
0.026093265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08949v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08949v3 | EasyGen: Easing Multimodal Generation with BiDiffuser and LLMs | 2023-10-13T08:38:56 | 2024-05-17T08:30:18 | Xiangyu Zhao, Bo Liu, Qijiong Liu, Guangyuan Shi, Xiao-Ming Wu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We present EasyGen, an efficient model designed to enhance multimodal
understanding and generation by harnessing the capabilities of diffusion models
and large language models (LLMs), Unlike existing multimodal models that
predominately depend on encoders like CLIP or ImageBind and need ample amounts
of training data to bridge modalities,EasyGen leverages BiDiffuser,a
bidirectional conditional diffusion model, to foster more efficient modality
interactions. Easygen achieves text generation by training a projection layer
linking BiDiffuser and an LLM, and facilities image generation by training an
adapter to align the LLM's text space with the BiDiffuser's image space,
Comprehensive quantitative and qualitative experiments show that EasyGen excels
in data-efficient training, high-quality image generation, and extendibility,
effectively addressing the challenges in multimodal generation. The source code
is available at https://github.com/zxy556677/EasyGen. | [
-0.0131190289,
0.0539295375,
0.002218199,
0.0236531086,
-0.0044745631,
-0.0228562485,
0.0447494797,
-0.0086807022,
-0.0260618627,
-0.0440478697,
-0.0447963513,
-0.0645189434,
-0.0139343403,
0.0248678047,
0.0464746095,
-0.0815404058,
0.0132618677,
-0.0245003849,
-0.0777199194,
-0.0021383225,
0.0217201002,
0.0117064761,
-0.0327923372,
0.0412373058,
-0.0267173927,
-0.0044640494,
-0.0552537777,
0.0390334837,
0.015961621,
-0.0444735512,
-0.010749667,
0.0502523519,
0.0474657938,
-0.0046956092,
0.0000022146,
-0.0003111746,
0.0092180176,
0.0073126876,
0.0646050796,
-0.0190825555,
0.0791239142,
-0.0140520241,
0.0053166407,
-0.0054776506,
-0.0174804907,
-0.0108169205,
0.0589886568,
0.0304803289,
0.0802985355,
0.008417625,
-0.0174131524,
-0.0561672188,
-0.0493578725,
-0.0256381072,
0.0648196265,
-0.0273940787,
-0.0183266103,
0.0179703329,
0.0242807698,
-0.0017644023,
-0.0368914679,
0.0289280973,
0.0178435277,
-0.0061878748,
0.0278558061,
0.0587483943,
0.0628630146,
-0.0672643036,
-0.0430893302,
0.1000436842,
0.0115385912,
0.0231220555,
0.0124986432,
-0.0116704805,
0.0093920194,
0.0470737591,
-0.0528206341,
0.0084183151,
-0.0123569435,
0.0034791231,
-0.0548521653,
-0.0204689316,
0.0141364634,
0.0088323494,
0.0165887363,
-0.0006288499,
0.0475067571,
0.0257594939,
-0.0517163984,
0.0037329455,
-0.0054314369,
-0.0579017289,
0.0295390356,
0.0549313948,
-0.0167696383,
0.018137427,
-0.0603814274,
-0.0608272739,
0.0206508357,
0.0041339304,
0.0455504842,
0.0254895072,
-0.0296416208,
0.0106554218,
-0.0417207219,
-0.0242742542,
-0.0194973554,
-0.0052111051,
-0.0256940164,
0.0187043604,
-0.0088953599,
-0.0355377086,
-0.0456315689,
-0.0093391016,
-0.084592469,
-0.0558542684,
-0.0526449159,
0.0344003178,
-0.0108499844,
-0.0153780021,
0.0252928305,
0.0439726226,
-0.0724663362,
0.0007324512,
-0.0215171222,
0.0553764962,
-0.0216445755,
0.0244213194,
0.0290606301,
-0.0169157572,
0.0073991548,
0.0397583954,
0.0206824783,
0.0010162832,
-0.0512503982,
0.1071035415,
-0.0579984821,
-0.005898193,
-0.0256678332,
-0.0675819218,
-0.0286864694,
-0.0426804386,
0.0333407447,
-0.0509408154,
0.0253631659,
-0.0087138442,
-0.0028959434,
-0.0154426657,
0.0321433768,
-0.0073130517,
0.0129037015,
0.0563440099,
-0.0094873691,
0.0247162804,
0.0470051318,
0.0225779898,
-0.0068748794,
0.0553340204,
0.0335026495,
0.0328066833,
-0.0041967779,
0.0049466034,
0.000112987,
0.0441921875,
0.0146774631,
-0.0048542148,
0.0071664639,
-0.0469727442,
0.003573156,
0.0487988107,
0.0392308645,
0.0415260717,
-0.0458990373,
0.0206204113,
0.0791030005,
-0.0043555242,
0.0319828279,
-0.0037992874,
0.0640706941,
0.0170989744,
-0.032867793,
-0.0019719163,
-0.0045453971,
0.0730118454,
0.0278387181,
0.0166730359,
0.0360374637,
0.0489004664,
-0.0300585777,
-0.0179104414,
0.03614337,
-0.0310886223,
0.0317715704,
-0.0358034857,
0.0512031876,
0.0188006982,
-0.0657483339,
0.0667425469,
0.004011699,
-0.0955601856,
0.0340129174,
-0.0360420048,
-0.0003965198,
0.047937829,
-0.005740541,
0.0275761373,
-0.0033582735,
-0.0089445189,
0.0144881802,
0.063360244,
0.0429046676,
-0.0016497688,
0.0253819413,
-0.0541802198,
-0.0252682548,
-0.0200830232,
0.0223820023,
0.0327974595,
-0.040744599,
0.0075624497,
0.0219471902,
-0.0102802012,
0.0247561429,
0.0364370756,
-0.0343242139,
0.0119467955,
-0.0261254348,
0.0066854181,
-0.0012036159,
-0.0095424391,
-0.0184136778,
0.0137089053,
0.0087523498,
-0.0132973604,
0.0015597686,
0.0729792491,
-0.0512705371,
-0.0192943793,
0.0197646264,
-0.0632708967,
0.0214507375,
-0.0273800548,
-0.0162438229,
-0.0257398281,
0.013310831,
-0.0260673929,
0.0433933549,
-0.0372956172,
0.0020565703,
0.0419995636,
0.005442386,
-0.0050074053,
0.0546884835,
-0.0271759145,
-0.010178267,
0.0410891175,
0.0487774871,
-0.012772182,
0.0192031302,
0.0005455504,
-0.0195702836,
-0.0159738399,
0.0134771252,
-0.0030005858,
0.0071789371,
-0.0472565815,
-0.0229446422,
-0.1093561128,
-0.0183102153,
-0.0123191299,
-0.0201433487,
0.0316584222,
0.0315299258,
-0.0043014307,
0.0045945346,
-0.0303862896,
0.0526970811,
0.0289845243,
-0.0142143127,
0.0103882104,
0.0048873979,
0.0288601052,
-0.018501075,
0.0199448206,
0.0198637322,
0.0363395996,
0.0217491668,
-0.0127669042,
-0.0319062918,
0.0099833934,
-0.0247647408,
-0.0047360263,
-0.0128748147,
-0.0342594758,
0.0439479165,
-0.0043345401,
0.0759944469,
0.0011308989,
0.0462221093,
0.0521758571,
0.0111396601,
-0.0457715578,
-0.0401083231,
0.0221817512,
-0.0170643907,
-0.000539105,
-0.0154414419,
-0.0339955054,
-0.0061295521,
0.0565484315,
0.0260787979,
0.0206269789,
-0.0479571782,
0.0264848042,
-0.0063095675,
-0.0742308497,
-0.0018912612,
0.0144823901,
-0.0315725617,
0.0025856469,
-0.047680866,
-0.0495666303,
0.0269276891,
-0.053085696,
-0.0217104089,
-0.0024223493,
0.0248850156,
0.0211627055,
0.0370355807,
0.0188690722,
0.0506858788,
-0.0109128095,
0.0105133764,
-0.030794695,
0.0185821075,
0.0176216401,
-0.0248325896,
0.0121511556,
-0.069629848,
-0.0052696709,
-0.0148885157,
-0.0350434892,
-0.0201783646,
-0.0161505621,
0.009738151,
-0.0381893739,
0.0161377806,
-0.0231600143,
0.0050844979,
0.0195923634,
0.031539686,
0.0036781696,
-0.0236926898,
-0.0234230589,
-0.0381227545,
0.0595045537,
0.0497452244,
0.0365667678,
-0.0569876954,
-0.0840081498,
-0.0387495868,
0.0522218347,
-0.0070673879,
-0.0052341688,
-0.0457703471,
0.0293878894,
0.012336486,
0.0344063565,
-0.007717499,
0.0524124354,
0.1428386718,
-0.0381185189,
0.0186398048,
0.0564008243,
0.0134941703,
-0.0269970912,
-0.0033457763,
-0.003527855,
0.0574296638,
0.0001634975,
0.0029030929,
-0.1021736115,
-0.065751791,
-0.0058981222,
0.0050656805,
0.0273034126,
-0.0087626409,
-0.0095083835,
-0.0680724978,
0.0626923591,
0.0182108954,
-0.0337957144,
0.0052646562,
-0.0120410332,
0.0121730268,
0.0604077354,
-0.0224643517,
0.0122511564,
-0.0244739112,
0.0143354777,
0.0311550554,
0.0379191488,
-0.0570849851,
-0.0602080524,
-0.034026131,
0.0428836495,
0.0467285961,
0.0253553744,
0.0123622846,
-0.0592186227,
0.02260378,
0.0258985385,
0.0226264652,
-0.0168387555,
0.0296897627,
0.0105298739,
-0.0041037067,
-0.0506683625,
0.0575039871,
0.0101470314,
-0.0257307179,
-0.0236138571,
0.0292113796,
-0.0295520499,
-0.0181783922,
-0.0590723194,
0.0457962677,
0.0424997956,
0.0312657282,
0.0275114961,
-0.0380422808,
-0.041810181,
-0.0283272695,
0.0357606672,
-0.0684311166,
-0.0416618064,
-0.0060337046,
-0.0149741368,
-0.0390361808,
-0.060716901,
-0.0292688813,
0.0149322869,
0.051762592,
-0.0155901629,
0.0117292553,
-0.0200274121,
0.0047187111,
-0.0458726212,
0.0247630533,
0.0005484291,
0.019678168,
-0.0183159374,
-0.0398953855,
0.049492266,
-0.0590332337,
0.0088246502,
0.0529116504,
-0.0830643624,
-0.0651190355,
-0.0450887978,
0.0772877783,
0.0262732282,
0.0385016575,
0.0247266833,
-0.0286070332,
0.0536370464,
0.0697384849,
-0.0133964373,
0.0223530885,
-0.0010708289,
-0.0074808435,
-0.0011635312,
-0.0063139726,
-0.0379122831,
-0.008684325,
-0.039195668,
0.0585523844,
-0.0083279377,
-0.0194554627,
0.0091990475,
-0.0333784558,
-0.0180552769,
-0.0706560761,
-0.0065091201,
-0.0462572239,
-0.0338553339,
-0.0172997713,
-0.0042781113,
-0.0606680103,
0.0192703046,
0.0090931673,
0.0084079942,
0.0278994944,
-0.0093773268,
0.0242891014,
0.0499638245,
0.0127710849,
0.0308622811,
0.0103649627,
-0.0181153454,
0.0278340634,
0.0221539792,
0.00651338,
0.0185227804,
-0.036796771,
0.0163080748,
-0.0219875574,
0.0962254778,
0.0039669042,
-0.0241933018,
-0.0074777151,
0.0467554815,
0.0188021716,
-0.0107014114,
-0.0521095656,
0.076303497,
0.0500486195,
0.03228686,
0.055551175,
-0.0350390002,
0.0039655534,
-0.0061950991,
0.0714036077,
-0.0053060493,
-0.0397290736,
0.0510957278,
-0.0039577885,
0.0121648666,
-0.0404730774,
0.0716792643,
-0.0469545759,
0.02782874,
-0.0221765731,
-0.0163596645,
-0.0451285057,
-0.0315004997,
0.0519975349,
0.0154612055,
-0.0109428931,
0.0170508493,
-0.0358569808,
-0.0334897749,
-0.0318190455,
0.0419576652,
-0.0323846675,
-0.0046203085,
0.0527127795,
0.0626050979,
-0.0159476493,
-0.0239054896,
-0.0458137356,
0.0168877635,
-0.0097822184,
0.0008318666,
0.0062127458,
-6.241690597e-33,
-0.0567612574,
-0.0513448827,
0.050605882,
-0.0577031374,
-0.0591404922,
-0.0256763455,
-0.0414930359,
0.032303378,
0.027750317,
-0.0010560855,
0.0388401821,
-0.0393785276,
0.0073564923,
0.0363292955,
-0.0128895156,
0.0185449906,
0.0445206128,
-0.0033056457,
-0.0328841656,
0.021779554,
0.0169521254,
0.0376132131,
-0.0075087571,
-0.0361893363,
-0.0059393537,
-0.0068883258,
-0.0300665256,
-0.0006639921,
0.0033818565,
0.0244831219,
-0.0447983593,
0.0000183293,
0.011662079,
0.0069447351,
-0.0275460314,
0.0464530624,
-0.0453306697,
0.0044704978,
0.0028367774,
0.0166592691,
-0.1172652841,
-0.0335562192,
0.0580793954,
-0.0180508047,
-0.0098489802,
0.0066619138,
0.0467426293,
0.0096892351,
0.0039045378,
0.0133357951,
-0.0756347328,
0.0251477566,
-0.0006608976,
-0.0466500036,
-0.0000315432,
0.0386725925,
0.0177071057,
-0.0156844445,
-0.0603096522,
0.0336099751,
-0.0025011294,
0.0145324329,
0.0740992874,
0.0492033996,
0.0144591331,
0.059164349,
0.03652234,
-0.0562698692,
-0.0131664248,
0.007802783,
0.0346901603,
0.054605078,
-0.0310951397,
0.0622460842,
0.0282465033,
-0.0105825784,
-0.0156355016,
0.0558523796,
-0.0002752236,
0.0021653143,
0.0225481875,
0.0286393929,
0.0539353192,
0.0228907261,
-0.0342863463,
-0.0323327035,
-0.0191931743,
-0.0580211654,
0.0178828724,
0.0212570671,
-0.0021937985,
-0.0297017302,
0.0902856886,
0.0250750966,
-0.0349910781,
-0.0302403364,
-0.0302216746,
0.0573511831,
-0.0219801702,
-0.0063093705,
0.0023866165,
-0.0325212628,
0.0350750573,
0.0058299643,
0.0184739195,
0.0421098806,
-0.0232891459,
0.0347875431,
-0.0152392285,
0.0001536073,
-0.0572021864,
0.0112774409,
0.0055264183,
0.0295022987,
0.0245423783,
-0.0241808444,
-0.0751182884,
0.0195282288,
-0.0217467006,
0.0221114941,
-0.0252881218,
-0.0692417324,
-0.0211256314,
0.0245288741,
-0.0437758975,
0.0182323586,
-0.0646381229,
0.0030204533,
0.0482753254,
-0.0907703042,
-0.0307345446,
0.0190656316,
2.888e-7,
0.0330936871,
0.0045561534,
-0.0106243277,
0.0027270461,
0.0189026408,
0.0325780883,
-0.0298802778,
0.0396434292,
-0.0037913029,
-0.0516800284,
-0.0088333422,
0.0437246598,
0.0322516784,
0.0248418748,
-0.0366604105,
-0.0288821496,
-0.0087621342,
0.0085190693,
-0.0222741459,
0.0137237161,
0.0779726431,
0.02502813,
-0.0347221158,
-0.0170681365,
0.0609460771,
-0.0059007681,
0.0943945199,
-0.0072575957,
-0.0057399822,
0.0022552318,
0.0143969208,
-0.0303890444,
-0.0213526059,
-0.0308355074,
-0.0221642088,
-0.0396209061,
0.0195747614,
0.0339895375,
-0.0106332861,
-0.0287259035,
0.0209424999,
0.0077934801,
-0.0171009507,
-0.0153708747,
0.0420731753,
-0.0568307973,
-0.0078239888,
-0.0271092691,
-0.0438591093,
0.0118693514,
-0.0153469313,
-0.0393458642,
-0.0483842231,
0.030359054,
0.0153804142,
-0.0081646619,
-0.043160595,
-0.0570280738,
-0.0347265229,
-0.0265801027,
-0.0852052346,
-0.0482959822,
-0.084613204,
-0.023192618,
0.0129598686,
-0.0300644878,
-0.0370749906,
2.404031048e-34,
0.0052124425,
-0.0070793205,
0.0056987195,
-0.0051601003,
0.0350960754,
-0.0004714154,
-0.0001244194,
0.0136601487,
-0.0032897727,
-0.0307920929,
-0.0353671871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08944v1 | CAMELL: Confidence-based Acquisition Model for Efficient Self-supervised Active Learning with Label Validation | 2023-10-13T08:19:31 | 2023-10-13T08:19:31 | Carel van Niekerk, Christian Geishauser, Michael Heck, Shutong Feng, Hsien-chin Lin, Nurul Lubis, Benjamin Ruppik, Renato Vukovic, Milica Gašić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Supervised neural approaches are hindered by their dependence on large,
meticulously annotated datasets, a requirement that is particularly cumbersome
for sequential tasks. The quality of annotations tends to deteriorate with the
transition from expert-based to crowd-sourced labelling. To address these
challenges, we present \textbf{CAMELL} (Confidence-based Acquisition Model for
Efficient self-supervised active Learning with Label validation), a pool-based
active learning framework tailored for sequential multi-output problems. CAMELL
possesses three core features: (1) it requires expert annotators to label only
a fraction of a chosen sequence, (2) it facilitates self-supervision for the
remainder of the sequence, and (3) it employs a label validation mechanism to
prevent erroneous labels from contaminating the dataset and harming model
performance. We evaluate CAMELL on sequential tasks, with a special emphasis on
dialogue belief tracking, a task plagued by the constraints of limited and
noisy datasets. Our experiments demonstrate that CAMELL outperforms the
baselines in terms of efficiency. Furthermore, the data corrections suggested
by our method contribute to an overall improvement in the quality of the
resulting datasets. | [
0.0244855806,
0.0987808704,
0.0234495476,
-0.0124066267,
-0.0007439692,
0.0144786891,
0.0163642559,
-0.053156998,
0.0490042232,
-0.0442047529,
-0.0448222794,
-0.0523199774,
-0.0110777533,
0.0621944666,
0.0235537905,
-0.034462411,
0.0663832948,
-0.0139175132,
0.0864778534,
-0.0089636901,
0.0100635923,
-0.0146150077,
-0.0622990318,
0.0546807423,
-0.0458515435,
0.015531525,
-0.0190009791,
-0.0121578528,
-0.0178722702,
-0.0443986468,
0.0314975083,
0.0854691491,
0.01783395,
0.0414249264,
0.0000018927,
-0.0176746882,
-0.0091838948,
-0.0212652329,
-0.029262878,
0.0260149539,
-0.0604734197,
0.0580887087,
0.0143296067,
-0.0269431397,
-0.0348021314,
-0.023680592,
0.0388609581,
0.0369015746,
0.0819690228,
0.0551356599,
-0.0020017615,
0.0181103535,
0.0184001159,
-0.0514702648,
0.0112774819,
-0.1038606018,
0.0353417695,
0.0028355026,
-0.029691197,
0.00675458,
0.0542467237,
0.0506220907,
0.0254132599,
-0.0350856632,
-0.0075659431,
-0.0127347317,
-0.0392113253,
-0.0826711059,
-0.0326848552,
0.049745407,
0.0627253279,
0.0121748587,
-0.0103820115,
-0.0514146686,
0.0312423427,
-0.0170495138,
-0.0354921445,
0.0031341189,
-0.034665525,
0.0216335244,
-0.0654827207,
0.0105846962,
0.0033453808,
-0.0111311665,
0.014265582,
0.0278449599,
-0.0370994993,
-0.0314251408,
0.0326342173,
0.0541765988,
-0.031847585,
-0.055068627,
0.0408949591,
0.0316641144,
-0.0581294484,
0.0001813694,
-0.0438620113,
-0.0013149622,
0.0090120845,
-0.0369282477,
-0.0014556176,
-0.0026166243,
-0.0180085674,
0.0620273948,
0.0360347368,
0.017740801,
-0.0023612063,
0.0143727856,
-0.001759566,
0.0110193808,
-0.0459071361,
0.0167654697,
-0.0500413962,
0.0318342037,
0.0219293553,
-0.0257403515,
-0.0899533033,
0.0156135997,
-0.0237181578,
0.0632318854,
0.0120108174,
0.0318832211,
-0.0345833749,
-0.0084453896,
-0.0123242447,
0.0415161736,
0.0207073037,
0.027085647,
0.0232670214,
-0.0515331961,
-0.0025952163,
0.0290861242,
-0.0036823766,
0.00305445,
-0.025504712,
0.0493167676,
-0.0061006919,
-0.055461444,
-0.0321546532,
-0.0007858344,
-0.0088177854,
-0.0299847443,
-0.0148095712,
-0.0300442073,
0.0082193995,
-0.04744583,
0.0166810974,
-0.0656095967,
0.0069730761,
0.0092475014,
-0.0060382695,
0.0230818745,
-0.0296262838,
-0.0300452076,
0.0127556734,
0.0037661633,
-0.0262110271,
0.0447288752,
0.0184255727,
0.0416781977,
0.0664262995,
0.003082592,
0.0250375532,
-0.0006476762,
0.0390890911,
-0.0413570255,
-0.000353329,
0.0293817576,
-0.01670436,
-0.019282259,
-0.052144032,
0.0328440443,
-0.0251660366,
-0.024859881,
0.0926282257,
-0.0097147897,
-0.0618358254,
-0.071616888,
0.0363544002,
0.0361047685,
0.086687021,
0.0036618593,
-0.0489427447,
0.0112283006,
0.0136014866,
-0.021330826,
0.0238832105,
0.0074193655,
-0.0214842893,
-0.0593010969,
-0.0030270095,
-0.0199505948,
-0.0458438732,
0.0349311531,
0.0376456901,
0.0064454973,
-0.0257819332,
0.0221261829,
0.0125423819,
-0.0215538815,
-0.0551049598,
-0.015039687,
0.0296452921,
-0.0004832668,
0.0017956822,
-0.0421279296,
-0.081828855,
-0.027379876,
0.0310469791,
0.0217551682,
0.0423368216,
-0.0406159237,
0.0163087435,
-0.0517066978,
-0.0596355163,
0.0385367647,
0.0365618095,
0.0160652474,
0.0270754248,
-0.0371734053,
0.0014333456,
0.0347689651,
-0.0007129131,
0.0399106666,
0.0273805615,
-0.0334553085,
0.0045296154,
-0.0109819937,
0.0834141523,
0.0147927338,
-0.0168203041,
0.0089928973,
0.0422958173,
0.0529024936,
-0.0376523212,
0.0120912064,
-0.0459843352,
0.0062818471,
0.0493791252,
0.0185331218,
-0.0953311622,
-0.0064669359,
-0.0400518067,
-0.0402140804,
-0.0708556622,
-0.0420481749,
-0.0624151267,
-0.0500053614,
0.0282491837,
0.021011278,
-0.0102933934,
-0.0455489829,
0.0455725007,
-0.0201787986,
-0.0271603595,
0.0440813676,
-0.0076066097,
0.0310934018,
-0.0690066069,
-0.0302509107,
-0.0093909381,
-0.0067442833,
-0.021641627,
0.0566422865,
-0.0021581557,
-0.0562506951,
0.0222531632,
-0.0410696715,
-0.0167047959,
-0.0017889818,
-0.0038968311,
0.0067597739,
-0.0157290362,
0.0010521961,
-0.0486808717,
-0.0304713733,
0.0085292971,
0.0024842215,
0.0180727374,
0.0113684162,
0.0284371432,
0.0046781665,
-0.0599419959,
-0.0015948041,
0.0045834091,
0.0060107163,
0.0168951005,
-0.0448977314,
-0.0245995745,
-0.0360734724,
-0.0387426689,
0.0408330373,
0.0013556576,
-0.0199889634,
0.0477584377,
-0.0370775871,
-0.0577805266,
0.0110328747,
0.0351569578,
0.0212130956,
0.0081074927,
-0.0305403024,
-0.0245744456,
0.033196345,
-0.0520323589,
0.0116025861,
-0.0119361822,
0.0073856665,
-0.0157067515,
0.0538236126,
-0.0162357017,
0.0241221227,
-0.054951746,
-0.0055402704,
0.014520607,
-0.059640944,
-0.0246974248,
-0.006961918,
-0.0148932524,
0.0289100911,
-0.0229023453,
-0.0545245297,
0.0677935779,
-0.0220280532,
-0.0367529988,
-0.0203643031,
-0.0140525317,
0.0254981015,
0.0244034119,
0.036195375,
-0.0194698703,
0.0360502377,
-0.000559346,
-0.0326975361,
-0.0184979308,
0.0369819738,
-0.0359990522,
-0.0058736512,
-0.0562606342,
0.0258835647,
0.0285889935,
-0.0313895829,
-0.093284145,
-0.0425290838,
-0.0208582431,
-0.0025916097,
0.0085201869,
-0.041452501,
-0.0156309213,
-0.0003333294,
0.0226340052,
0.0635556877,
0.0049666748,
-0.0000403256,
-0.028922068,
0.03136307,
0.0232845154,
0.0007940799,
0.0148698138,
-0.0338114128,
0.0176031031,
0.0746387467,
0.0376245379,
-0.0191764012,
-0.0037268484,
0.0057185786,
0.0274468549,
-0.0349503681,
0.0121305203,
0.0366947949,
0.0681255534,
-0.0332274921,
-0.0136647355,
0.1144762561,
0.0255400985,
-0.0617682077,
-0.0311480481,
0.0467527993,
-0.0009055129,
0.0292481817,
-0.001170514,
-0.0237445459,
-0.024785798,
-0.0013712099,
0.0811554939,
0.0191164874,
-0.045757696,
-0.0151751703,
-0.0672678277,
0.0436519496,
-0.006451542,
-0.0562392808,
0.0037646904,
-0.0338545926,
0.0295569673,
-0.03233153,
0.0004559433,
-0.0071432879,
0.0227604229,
0.014081819,
0.064961046,
-0.0360076502,
-0.0356366262,
-0.0239416156,
-0.0049233693,
0.0767254233,
0.0335284062,
-0.006963653,
0.0154990489,
-0.0227819942,
0.0618078485,
-0.0349420868,
-0.0253323186,
0.0169946626,
0.0796696097,
-0.0226251148,
-0.0286444966,
-0.0036156627,
0.0120552182,
-0.0245403461,
-0.0179674514,
0.0117722759,
0.0143766971,
-0.0380520895,
0.0133829648,
-0.0137584098,
0.0302927103,
0.0269234776,
0.0348882452,
0.0151375663,
-0.0116980178,
0.0139317559,
0.0120370435,
-0.0027374486,
-0.0125548104,
-0.0348409489,
0.0583972447,
-0.0287942551,
-0.0569402166,
-0.0640277714,
-0.0672363862,
0.0403700285,
0.0933805481,
-0.0153589817,
-0.0140464278,
0.0528095588,
-0.0029169258,
0.0212965291,
0.0243188906,
0.0002368811,
-0.0139132701,
-0.0656719953,
-0.0568144731,
0.0201022699,
0.0180969667,
-0.0088956328,
0.0482045785,
-0.0761772469,
-0.0473990478,
0.0436864682,
0.1149832606,
0.0203167871,
0.0528744459,
-0.000106497,
-0.0044472283,
-0.0399299674,
0.0202461835,
-0.0122117838,
-0.0035711473,
0.0601979606,
0.0038041947,
-0.0386247076,
0.0182200056,
-0.0204905104,
0.0596001931,
0.0174616203,
0.0365011543,
-0.0768850818,
-0.1004754379,
0.0482572392,
-0.0138855558,
0.0878035203,
-0.0054341564,
0.0133778471,
-0.0138743008,
0.0359419584,
-0.0040122247,
-0.0459205396,
-0.0640117824,
0.0327636003,
-0.0180023331,
0.0060027642,
-0.0143051557,
-0.0048762741,
0.0193921104,
0.039264556,
-0.0490263626,
-0.0130334049,
0.0347641259,
0.0085047595,
-0.0262704268,
-0.0222791731,
-0.0146977603,
0.0558167621,
0.0164003856,
0.0406647138,
0.0431976579,
0.0666576996,
0.0253146533,
0.0226628724,
0.0101495571,
0.026370449,
-0.0833923295,
-0.0362749435,
-0.0481896661,
0.081712313,
0.030194981,
-0.0205634441,
0.0366502255,
-0.0106784971,
-0.0195391439,
-0.0089219213,
0.0271375682,
0.025852358,
0.0039955145,
-0.0040794327,
0.0422909036,
-0.0175578594,
0.0101844305,
0.0599108823,
-0.003658362,
0.0386678316,
-0.0065671741,
-0.0140807899,
-0.0561045036,
-0.0439158641,
0.0104028452,
0.0330378041,
-0.010618045,
-0.0008668246,
0.0053235106,
-0.0521001108,
-0.0010053642,
0.0097446311,
0.0067370837,
0.0131211057,
0.053348206,
0.0495917238,
-0.0086774649,
0.0111691831,
-0.021682173,
0.0022260367,
0.051643759,
0.0141140046,
0.0190323498,
-5.856270979e-33,
-0.0405113362,
-0.0456222482,
0.0007567203,
0.0101354746,
0.0179012567,
0.0109013626,
-0.0346897207,
0.0044784117,
0.029724244,
0.0373667292,
0.0227479693,
0.0116697093,
0.0326906219,
0.0132340174,
0.0385223925,
0.0027951188,
0.0567191616,
-0.0219679512,
-0.0001904651,
-0.0075097866,
0.0301026497,
0.0256424118,
0.0236926228,
-0.1310839206,
0.0458542258,
0.0081475656,
-0.0150893005,
0.0175556373,
-0.0035933231,
0.0362160169,
0.0196818616,
-0.0158309955,
-0.0163167026,
-0.0506893545,
-0.0248349328,
-0.0301185809,
-0.0630520135,
-0.0078048198,
-0.0372991897,
0.0478356332,
-0.0347001404,
0.0546817482,
-0.0197431296,
-0.0411888659,
0.0291508604,
0.0519114397,
0.0220744926,
0.0080540422,
-0.0336473137,
-0.0356509089,
-0.0117771467,
0.0359253064,
-0.0454502963,
-0.0094712367,
0.0043793782,
0.0549494326,
0.0053322781,
-0.0387431569,
-0.0364794359,
-0.019505756,
-0.0549730659,
-0.0120396856,
-0.0078408737,
0.0050782845,
-0.0067996653,
0.0537311547,
0.0601288415,
-0.0256509613,
-0.0148743568,
0.0116654756,
-0.037936978,
0.0128181754,
0.0478871241,
0.0298993289,
-0.0250828099,
0.0373455137,
-0.0519333854,
0.032571312,
0.0464981683,
-0.0005411816,
-0.0025720063,
0.0200716984,
-0.0227428954,
0.0212334879,
0.008888348,
0.0057098186,
0.0039723362,
0.0102448538,
0.0157779176,
0.0268636737,
-0.0579300933,
0.0437222607,
0.0491785407,
0.0172546227,
-0.0325384587,
-0.0030422611,
-0.0002014825,
-0.0042915731,
-0.0084485263,
0.0163645726,
-0.0639603436,
-0.0163332522,
0.0346122123,
0.0059461556,
0.0031758428,
0.0286666751,
0.0331636369,
0.010265233,
-0.0245103426,
0.0006224657,
-0.016443396,
0.0354862437,
0.0028710335,
0.0421178676,
0.0468663611,
-0.0294771977,
-0.0414394587,
0.0658155382,
-0.0222969279,
-0.0219166707,
0.00407079,
-0.0277516432,
0.0200373083,
-0.0012734799,
0.003094794,
-0.03544816,
-0.0167294163,
-0.0232290383,
-0.0342261456,
-0.0339646339,
0.0166124776,
0.0132719809,
2.568e-7,
0.0037108453,
0.0071155629,
0.0392887592,
-0.011206938,
0.0200706534,
0.0497887731,
-0.0469583534,
-0.0227004029,
0.0486225933,
-0.0238497108,
0.0430671908,
0.0329449773,
0.0157888252,
0.04059745,
-0.0761713684,
-0.0960957184,
-0.0515604801,
0.0223896783,
-0.0144768534,
0.0155934654,
0.0284062885,
0.0717609823,
0.0384067185,
-0.017749602,
0.0204310305,
-0.0345801823,
0.027997084,
0.0216451492,
0.0099255014,
0.0064807744,
0.0457472205,
-0.0339789763,
-0.0298642125,
0.0502262525,
-0.0074997721,
-0.0045987656,
0.0356044061,
0.0603654794,
-0.0069007776,
-0.0320892297,
-0.0145178717,
0.0299250502,
0.0683961287,
0.0147547042,
0.0494026281,
-0.0582226925,
-0.0444823056,
-0.0183480885,
-0.0518760607,
-0.0428329147,
0.0463770479,
0.0604468696,
0.0024824305,
0.0148972357,
-0.0130236903,
0.023022972,
-0.0596844889,
-0.0808331966,
0.0041600084,
-0.0686958805,
-0.0329241194,
-0.0301037915,
-0.0285347532,
0.0049527269,
-0.0344686061,
-0.0256794691,
-0.0041529397,
1.946821142e-34,
0.0284141526,
-0.0207237862,
0.0185523499,
0.0324912481,
0.001346319,
-0.0065171425,
-0.0256614871,
0.0039694007,
0.0275667831,
-0.0292662214,
-0.0026342806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08943v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08943v2 | Multi-level Adaptive Contrastive Learning for Knowledge Internalization in Dialogue Generation | 2023-10-13T08:16:27 | 2023-10-17T12:53:58 | Chenxu Yang, Zheng Lin, Lanrui Wang, Chong Tian, Liang Pang, Jiangnan Li, Qirong Ho, Yanan Cao, Weiping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-grounded dialogue generation aims to mitigate the issue of text
degeneration by incorporating external knowledge to supplement the context.
However, the model often fails to internalize this information into responses
in a human-like manner. Instead, it simply inserts segments of the provided
knowledge into generic responses. As a result, the generated responses tend to
be tedious, incoherent, and in lack of interactivity which means the
degeneration problem is still unsolved. In this work, we first find that such
copying-style degeneration is primarily due to the weak likelihood objective,
which allows the model to "cheat" the objective by merely duplicating knowledge
segments in a superficial pattern matching based on overlap. To overcome this
challenge, we then propose a Multi-level Adaptive Contrastive Learning (MACL)
framework that dynamically samples negative examples and subsequently penalizes
degeneration behaviors at both the token-level and sequence-level. Extensive
experiments on the WoW dataset demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach
across various pre-trained models. | [
0.0261965543,
0.0769716427,
0.0004487252,
0.0201315545,
-0.0248772316,
0.0013069093,
-0.0127103627,
-0.0213856325,
0.0007171201,
-0.0495276302,
-0.0241593327,
-0.0220075734,
0.0353517272,
0.0309986826,
0.0375910141,
-0.0872448161,
0.0180480164,
-0.0022315434,
0.0224097166,
-0.0201848298,
0.0159689263,
0.0036937627,
-0.0185286626,
0.0350033008,
-0.010308953,
-0.0175122805,
-0.0216416232,
0.0150015596,
0.0224792622,
-0.0258905143,
0.0409745462,
0.0425050929,
0.0069827111,
0.0267936755,
0.0000018891,
-0.0359319225,
-0.0005796773,
-0.0320623517,
0.0192125998,
-0.0210612528,
0.0320022553,
-0.0064620296,
0.033377979,
0.0155489212,
-0.0345354937,
-0.005367625,
0.0156504959,
0.0715537965,
0.0736010745,
0.0514015332,
-0.0092174513,
-0.0142871588,
0.0051730177,
-0.0096350703,
0.0099139754,
-0.0244849324,
0.0023683468,
0.0259418432,
-0.0097385682,
-0.0169472806,
0.0150712105,
0.0356582105,
0.0245969761,
-0.0122319115,
-0.0065971594,
0.0397898853,
-0.0125802215,
0.0250769965,
-0.0204360988,
0.1008019149,
0.0132374931,
-0.0004483929,
0.008772837,
-0.0290782563,
0.0355748162,
-0.0234348159,
-0.0275300704,
0.0311625544,
-0.0236297213,
0.0253296103,
0.0252675395,
0.0579156056,
-0.0128083788,
0.0039914642,
0.0140877711,
-0.0192667376,
0.0123712486,
-0.0348499045,
-0.0201327,
0.0174530279,
-0.0307821147,
-0.0553117171,
0.0175782777,
0.0147000002,
-0.0335998237,
0.0243409462,
-0.0801766366,
-0.0126018943,
0.0241079424,
-0.0267556775,
0.0166708175,
0.0209673215,
-0.0197842754,
0.0169413108,
-0.0215769485,
0.0293292757,
-0.00434278,
-0.0346399955,
-0.0133024119,
0.0197596867,
-0.0369421951,
-0.0211290848,
-0.0399367437,
0.0590994768,
-0.0456727594,
-0.0177912246,
-0.0137111042,
0.0082105547,
-0.0153085664,
-0.0046664937,
-0.0365233161,
0.0368970148,
-0.0478828736,
0.0092297085,
-0.0213307291,
0.033075653,
-0.0384927131,
0.0056535359,
0.0409596227,
-0.0303148869,
-0.0057599824,
0.0442296974,
0.0203329772,
-0.0115619423,
-0.0191211216,
0.0556244627,
-0.0506583378,
-0.0037791759,
-0.0570161305,
-0.0716262385,
-0.0529539138,
-0.0322803445,
-0.0258049648,
-0.0130356289,
0.0195600111,
-0.0254020058,
-0.0292818025,
-0.0472695231,
0.0111898826,
0.0194140524,
-0.0372990146,
0.043796815,
-0.0367883183,
-0.0440186746,
0.0311206188,
0.0224272814,
-0.0193780027,
0.0281210821,
0.0402598642,
-0.0057379412,
-0.0045534046,
0.0371248834,
-0.0076438594,
-0.0045418455,
0.0551225767,
0.0097726863,
-0.0474930294,
-0.0037592957,
-0.0402583294,
0.0452883095,
0.0583702736,
0.0763862431,
-0.049745746,
-0.0116976975,
0.0806976631,
0.0021195188,
-0.0195100717,
0.0471535549,
0.0549744256,
0.0400954261,
-0.0317641981,
0.0783128738,
0.0081414515,
0.0140210418,
-0.0101151448,
0.0421349071,
0.0584606007,
0.0037010908,
-0.0296322312,
-0.0376111418,
0.041799169,
-0.0047743241,
-0.0064685312,
-0.0412866808,
-0.0037640017,
0.0611831807,
-0.0747909173,
0.0148142036,
0.0120890997,
-0.0678010136,
0.0054698414,
-0.029046407,
0.0336282738,
0.0475219339,
0.0545242503,
0.0101059489,
-0.0652163103,
-0.0196237955,
-0.0353249088,
0.0986029282,
0.004290597,
-0.0330990776,
0.0322512947,
-0.0562341064,
-0.0336999558,
-0.0254341941,
-0.0048049539,
0.0458637625,
-0.018843567,
0.0039453707,
0.0231360365,
0.0007649264,
0.0070690997,
0.0219464526,
-0.049044434,
-0.0335834101,
0.0127727883,
0.0046688318,
0.0276833866,
0.0102715101,
-0.008449289,
0.005609761,
0.0025306237,
-0.0416776277,
-0.0479498915,
0.0325607173,
-0.1149640605,
-0.0960245207,
0.0063449186,
-0.0390891656,
0.0170395579,
0.0051104329,
-0.017310733,
-0.0547068827,
0.0324457511,
-0.0255651008,
0.0477076732,
-0.0390189216,
-0.0135811074,
0.0419168286,
0.0118047567,
-0.0289999731,
0.0977762491,
-0.0234611109,
-0.0219074283,
0.0668275729,
0.0108832708,
-0.004708143,
-0.0292426739,
0.0103281224,
-0.0380915441,
-0.0136297876,
0.0228612497,
0.0346236974,
0.0275212601,
-0.0625251308,
-0.0060670166,
-0.0492484793,
0.0037890121,
-0.003696078,
-0.0082990788,
0.0496308692,
-0.0088123372,
0.0029099963,
-0.0135557614,
-0.0604986697,
-0.0082590077,
0.014377512,
-0.0107099377,
0.0545778312,
0.0299967602,
0.0148921199,
-0.0205672886,
0.0325616039,
0.0295912344,
0.0386383198,
-0.0028607054,
0.010223764,
-0.0491203628,
0.0582391508,
-0.0285619982,
0.0241844263,
0.0053823073,
-0.0278023742,
0.0142332995,
0.0432855152,
0.0589770004,
0.0567337051,
0.0367827751,
0.0259537492,
-0.0119421044,
-0.0275375266,
-0.05720089,
0.0382349864,
-0.0030399116,
0.0393183008,
0.0144762322,
-0.0227570049,
0.0157931875,
0.0731192827,
0.0462040938,
0.0515218824,
-0.0691655576,
0.0185750797,
0.0212410819,
-0.0677805096,
-0.004372031,
-0.0114836609,
-0.0379792824,
-0.0211924389,
-0.0401606262,
-0.0087525574,
0.0752878189,
-0.0183762312,
0.00105878,
-0.0209138896,
0.0190888345,
0.0075011984,
0.0202231258,
-0.0460245945,
0.0231706984,
0.0595985614,
-0.0272970572,
-0.0802256614,
-0.0290074628,
-0.0056304876,
-0.0112345433,
0.0560765639,
-0.0420344137,
-0.0181113891,
0.0019457696,
-0.0628300533,
-0.0712748021,
-0.0265675448,
0.0159977078,
0.0169721153,
0.0053904527,
-0.0244554784,
-0.0154939611,
0.0205404367,
0.020183716,
0.0663442388,
-0.0244058222,
-0.0204896405,
-0.0354777537,
0.1123580113,
0.0604807772,
0.0144162402,
0.0179744922,
-0.0333977491,
0.0531419702,
0.0478685908,
0.0277249645,
-0.0038271863,
-0.0077023297,
-0.0025849745,
0.0170375705,
-0.002909634,
-0.0327593796,
0.0067478805,
0.0502241403,
-0.0434032157,
-0.0336718112,
0.0944707543,
-0.0088013643,
-0.0348633826,
-0.0031895333,
-0.014199161,
0.0729617178,
-0.0008314541,
-0.0161043853,
-0.0670705065,
-0.0623699017,
-0.0219231993,
0.0440445319,
-0.008936611,
-0.049899336,
-0.0057788207,
-0.1077464595,
0.0006554514,
0.0140177468,
-0.0480899177,
-0.0171457995,
0.0463254377,
0.0009085854,
0.0201439951,
0.0413089916,
0.0031594122,
0.0104977023,
0.0213745013,
0.0336006433,
-0.0068576918,
-0.037637122,
-0.0334364064,
-0.0227083527,
0.0621548072,
0.0568533503,
0.0594420135,
0.0438420698,
-0.0066105118,
0.0136338519,
-0.0698973238,
0.014700423,
-0.0154940747,
0.0473528914,
-0.0159227252,
-0.000944184,
-0.0332396775,
0.0442855842,
-0.0246468429,
-0.0223602913,
0.0072653322,
0.0305593014,
-0.0153162312,
0.0048101172,
-0.00758817,
0.0497876406,
0.0479838364,
0.0939604416,
0.0656522661,
-0.041825451,
-0.0057331761,
-0.0303291399,
0.0452930182,
-0.0921594873,
0.0221360698,
0.008910262,
0.012651179,
0.0411054529,
-0.1276219189,
-0.0422667265,
-0.0168159828,
0.04649207,
-0.0122396173,
-0.0062882579,
-0.0341966935,
-0.0260871816,
-0.0201467108,
-0.0073752762,
-0.0315842479,
-0.0178158227,
-0.0253359433,
-0.0450540483,
0.0139476145,
-0.067130357,
-0.0052932422,
0.0484160632,
-0.0320492461,
-0.0795564875,
-0.0069798888,
0.0869046599,
0.0208226368,
0.0740898475,
0.0359170958,
-0.0222224835,
0.0695267022,
0.0202105027,
-0.0041478816,
0.0044413297,
0.0403517932,
0.0450591855,
-0.0054515051,
0.0457444564,
-0.0136107057,
-0.0213235579,
0.0222909264,
0.0487621352,
-0.0309477355,
-0.0617541522,
0.0265116654,
-0.0295054652,
0.0008315202,
-0.0404963009,
-0.0089726625,
-0.0072854785,
0.0080551021,
-0.0204500388,
-0.0281189419,
-0.0838038325,
0.0166133754,
-0.0021045867,
0.0203276947,
-0.0004792081,
-0.03052379,
-0.0252379961,
0.0572165102,
-0.05310883,
-0.0121974302,
0.0165370535,
0.026296664,
0.0105456077,
-0.0023139871,
-0.0294400491,
0.0262875054,
-0.0261016749,
0.0324958414,
-0.0096842665,
0.081755355,
0.0181499925,
-0.0143347085,
0.0215402115,
0.0209378265,
-0.0173885133,
0.011253356,
-0.0340987667,
-0.0208691712,
0.0358362012,
0.0225588046,
0.0622464903,
-0.0257246289,
0.0289189629,
0.0035821886,
0.0526413582,
-0.020481566,
-0.0632003173,
0.0132667134,
0.0209278017,
-0.0152262524,
0.0220534988,
0.1115877479,
-0.0471962951,
0.0408853181,
-0.0136990715,
0.0398329496,
-0.0759669617,
-0.0189852342,
0.0649415553,
0.036709059,
-0.0029394396,
0.0240269657,
-0.0536921173,
-0.0583467782,
0.0087380372,
0.0076247971,
0.0252773352,
0.0022315807,
0.0568852499,
0.0040519773,
-0.0336070992,
-0.0145044168,
-0.0349415466,
0.0362568237,
-0.0358502194,
-0.0024449248,
-0.0293531101,
-6.415546946e-33,
-0.0490413792,
-0.0375109687,
0.0052192425,
-0.0332238935,
-0.0247611701,
0.0109533267,
-0.0567923933,
-0.005764585,
0.0264939182,
0.0191335436,
0.0170844663,
-0.0194299594,
0.0006567588,
0.0581004694,
-0.0171050429,
-0.0069068195,
0.0645975992,
-0.0093985712,
-0.0438477881,
0.0614795722,
0.0572865494,
0.032372348,
0.0250927377,
-0.0394028276,
-0.0044439747,
-0.0212839693,
-0.0297314487,
0.0224598441,
0.026795879,
0.0474098921,
-0.0316444412,
0.0150399758,
0.0116173057,
-0.0203731656,
-0.0304800477,
0.0261522457,
-0.0529452078,
-0.0276656728,
0.0080535701,
-0.0222681072,
-0.0662146881,
-0.0515428446,
0.0142101375,
-0.0042964071,
0.0213010814,
-0.0072124419,
0.0121425241,
-0.019549489,
-0.0089863306,
-0.0163551681,
-0.0601892807,
0.0291737895,
-0.0168537535,
-0.0496412478,
-0.0463588387,
0.0632328168,
0.0107764192,
-0.0241419282,
-0.0334468782,
0.0075326837,
-0.0050879647,
0.0069479253,
0.0468696952,
0.0303225182,
-0.0181018412,
0.0866602436,
0.0151605783,
0.0134991743,
0.0417327285,
-0.0440913029,
-0.0224548616,
-0.0012715105,
0.0107380552,
0.0709204823,
0.0256622452,
0.0304318629,
-0.0161389522,
0.0327595919,
0.0161121599,
0.0083013773,
0.0065167737,
0.0028454119,
-0.006865785,
-0.0077946009,
-0.0176523943,
-0.0312615484,
-0.0076211747,
-0.0236494374,
0.0187950972,
0.0370357409,
-0.0109246131,
-0.0149243083,
0.0323304385,
-0.0020304003,
0.0291395131,
0.0287066735,
-0.0468871035,
-0.0077526737,
-0.0146506801,
-0.0030192179,
-0.0670169964,
-0.0320730396,
0.0492609292,
0.0187740009,
0.0098060276,
0.0453386679,
0.0430796184,
0.0118162567,
-0.0669259951,
0.0136017343,
-0.0229384787,
0.0555025227,
-0.0210848618,
-0.0052989703,
0.0286807735,
-0.0246552993,
-0.0266685765,
0.0288025662,
0.0219882559,
-0.035643626,
-0.0315934382,
-0.0323951989,
0.0004236102,
0.0217532329,
-0.0343082473,
-0.0183757599,
-0.0085549979,
-0.0261248741,
-0.0029357779,
-0.0498114042,
-0.0181206279,
0.0055818711,
2.646e-7,
-0.0240015872,
0.0048677698,
0.0466533862,
-0.0009600545,
0.0201585516,
0.0673739314,
-0.0079781786,
0.0318322554,
-0.0082899062,
-0.0049133259,
0.0228036623,
-0.033213228,
0.0627723411,
0.0144773116,
-0.1112959608,
-0.0082747089,
-0.095786199,
0.0021489654,
-0.0179226846,
-0.0084954472,
0.0717939585,
0.0267993826,
-0.0261444282,
-0.0190424565,
0.0076106545,
-0.0367940813,
0.068388015,
0.0210333373,
-0.0118322289,
-0.0113700945,
0.0299685765,
-0.0426131114,
-0.0286615919,
0.0404743887,
-0.0259043761,
0.0183158871,
-0.0150785092,
0.0437428914,
0.0282325819,
-0.0770469606,
0.0154037587,
0.0129801584,
0.0123259565,
-0.0374161713,
0.0207414627,
-0.055399511,
-0.030772537,
-0.013802045,
-0.019006297,
-0.0057160514,
-0.0062960074,
-0.0257113371,
-0.0647000745,
0.0121016391,
0.0106857121,
0.034637168,
-0.0151968151,
-0.056452997,
-0.014732426,
0.0062957355,
-0.0405375361,
-0.023949692,
-0.0448726602,
-0.0208514389,
0.0054694642,
-0.0584582686,
0.0229794122,
2.439691919e-34,
0.0219532251,
-0.0320779905,
0.0049958667,
0.0442237779,
0.0243764017,
-0.0161518678,
-0.0194371697,
0.0134598659,
0.0683623329,
-0.0473685451,
-0.0214288756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08923v1 | Towards Informative Few-Shot Prompt with Maximum Information Gain for In-Context Learning | 2023-10-13T07:49:11 | 2023-10-13T07:49:11 | Hongfu Liu, Ye Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language models (LLMs) possess the capability to engage In-context
Learning (ICL) by leveraging a few demonstrations pertaining to a new
downstream task as conditions. However, this particular learning paradigm
suffers from high instability stemming from substantial variances induced by
factors such as the input distribution of selected examples, their ordering,
and prompt formats. In this work, we demonstrate that even when all these
factors are held constant, the random selection of examples still results in
high variance. Consequently, we aim to explore the informative ability of data
examples by quantifying the Information Gain (IG) obtained in prediction after
observing a given example candidate. Then we propose to sample those with
maximum IG. Additionally, we identify the presence of template bias, which can
lead to unfair evaluations of IG during the sampling process. To mitigate this
bias, we introduce Calibration Before Sampling strategy. The experimental
results illustrate that our proposed method can yield an average relative
improvement of 14.3% across six classification tasks using three LLMs. | [
0.0013392831,
0.0067356215,
0.000613767,
0.0220403653,
-0.0401835404,
0.0294737127,
0.022039175,
0.0063080899,
-0.0128043285,
-0.0598609373,
-0.0633134767,
-0.064403303,
0.0095703639,
-0.0240302514,
0.0417715572,
-0.054141961,
0.0223349668,
-0.0687014684,
-0.0053886925,
-0.0033274265,
-0.0262234733,
-0.00319034,
-0.0230946057,
0.0267288033,
0.0054033725,
-0.0157224201,
-0.0060330504,
0.0248796474,
-0.0022918284,
-0.0577000976,
0.0151821971,
0.0573501997,
0.0235367529,
0.03892681,
0.0000022048,
-0.0553667508,
0.0012424435,
-0.0028903545,
-0.0682528839,
-0.0128856013,
0.0385656059,
0.0016126139,
0.0046931389,
0.0347198918,
-0.0121232374,
-0.0278342757,
0.0289882384,
0.0222751796,
-0.0063397088,
0.0591812171,
0.010870344,
0.0129449954,
-0.003570203,
-0.0451420285,
0.0472152643,
-0.0214161109,
0.0232467204,
-0.0338316858,
0.0037775722,
0.0336192958,
-0.020397583,
0.0231840201,
0.01989007,
0.0005877657,
0.0032314761,
0.045896735,
-0.0070797279,
-0.0080428282,
-0.0298630316,
0.0718996078,
-0.0090540871,
-0.0093880733,
-0.0298301391,
-0.0546251684,
0.0481039435,
0.005833616,
-0.0597989969,
0.0010429218,
0.0085619725,
0.0317397341,
0.0149844633,
0.0420727618,
0.0477260761,
0.0065989285,
-0.0035592131,
0.0254580248,
0.0004371515,
-0.0514033996,
0.0214623436,
0.0083200149,
-0.0258803442,
-0.0401666686,
-0.0448138639,
0.0176621601,
-0.0715338662,
0.0195914228,
-0.0341194496,
-0.0323398858,
0.0071864952,
-0.0175081529,
0.0617517792,
0.0188634731,
-0.0175227467,
0.0609423816,
-0.0009024447,
0.0254123919,
0.0097382292,
0.0294412002,
-0.0494385026,
0.0024029086,
-0.0381021835,
0.0148236193,
-0.0244934838,
0.0142822862,
-0.0185206365,
-0.0114921378,
-0.0371402986,
0.0508936606,
-0.0052063703,
0.0039807763,
-0.0187878981,
-0.0082024895,
-0.0221934523,
0.0196071547,
-0.0168959722,
0.0164626818,
-0.0093694292,
0.0174650382,
0.0162699018,
-0.0902434066,
-0.015998587,
0.0150030544,
-0.0017043524,
-0.039252203,
0.0118944515,
0.0692098439,
-0.0119715305,
-0.0968503654,
-0.0216885973,
-0.005620393,
-0.0146693699,
-0.0568685941,
-0.0103330472,
-0.0569906384,
0.01291411,
0.0244112052,
0.0131105008,
-0.0081612207,
-0.006334994,
0.0084083928,
-0.0079383319,
0.0656114891,
-0.0069936961,
0.0039914157,
0.0259956922,
-0.0135767432,
0.0118702119,
0.1068233848,
-0.0011344325,
0.0080454051,
0.0398096628,
0.0064644711,
0.0298846234,
0.0548618324,
0.0426879674,
0.0448951572,
-0.0250527151,
0.0082698734,
0.0475863814,
0.0245872196,
0.0252439044,
0.0161700398,
-0.0407701284,
0.0210572351,
0.0896942765,
0.0297626536,
0.0038629586,
-0.0484265275,
0.011426514,
0.0229132324,
-0.0101868855,
0.0063079628,
-0.0619355403,
0.0077256486,
-0.0123237502,
0.0052953078,
0.0426301844,
-0.0029764597,
-0.0449046902,
-0.020124495,
-0.0195036363,
-0.0109057585,
-0.0396988057,
0.064036563,
0.0537869409,
0.0239648819,
-0.0276619736,
0.0570252351,
0.0497518666,
0.0012254833,
0.0071596904,
-0.0354990736,
0.050983578,
0.0363787264,
0.0338638015,
-0.0357365385,
-0.0037937909,
-0.0376385562,
0.0291295145,
0.0135348877,
0.0538453124,
-0.0305848662,
0.0425673723,
-0.031194035,
-0.0386780314,
0.0162818823,
0.0149872871,
0.0358206034,
0.0160672069,
-0.0034752742,
0.0023195415,
-0.0330218561,
-0.0154552385,
0.0305618215,
-0.0175608564,
-0.0779594705,
0.0237364639,
0.0089287367,
0.0447147675,
-0.0120905982,
-0.0265323948,
-0.0087337056,
0.0131970374,
-0.0254241768,
0.0239868369,
0.0019949288,
-0.0841823816,
-0.0752581879,
-0.0020114281,
0.0239366759,
0.0017136817,
-0.026569834,
-0.0506075136,
-0.046345152,
-0.0344601497,
-0.0111703584,
0.048571974,
-0.0362056419,
0.0202872586,
-0.0161918346,
0.0172318257,
-0.0556192398,
0.057721056,
-0.0056621418,
0.0224896558,
0.0481728055,
0.0337810963,
-0.0098281447,
-0.0399920866,
-0.0237982012,
-0.001533973,
-0.0021579971,
-0.0151670231,
0.0199326742,
0.0072681769,
-0.0351771004,
-0.0029744583,
-0.1130989045,
-0.0137889991,
-0.0467478894,
0.0111754974,
0.0060902569,
0.0204787515,
-0.0257335491,
-0.0477872416,
-0.0274753943,
-0.031255763,
-0.0164994672,
0.0501044467,
0.0202455949,
0.0504251607,
0.0006988927,
-0.0176926423,
-0.0030184621,
0.005166172,
0.0851955712,
0.0090932986,
-0.0073586972,
-0.068452619,
0.0256983154,
0.0390716977,
0.01578434,
-0.0154923592,
0.0261399262,
0.0098370342,
-0.0256572757,
0.0137310084,
0.0642296746,
0.0125252958,
0.0234262813,
0.0276751239,
0.0424217582,
-0.0804428309,
0.0009050322,
-0.023740232,
-0.0152517753,
-0.0286625121,
0.0139037883,
0.0240890309,
0.0410672836,
0.0194746684,
0.0018198177,
-0.0314836204,
0.0191814303,
-0.0127604939,
-0.0428335071,
-0.0943473503,
0.007682981,
-0.0442683212,
0.0210033152,
-0.0084984358,
-0.0646688491,
0.0524831414,
-0.0237446092,
0.0116976919,
-0.0276243314,
-0.0023947021,
-0.0175263453,
0.0363765694,
0.0067592971,
-0.0218487997,
0.0204660613,
-0.0261912309,
-0.0615603179,
-0.0309898555,
0.0175945219,
-0.0182369761,
0.0420902185,
-0.0448320918,
-0.0015044117,
-0.0208298061,
-0.0622017942,
-0.0539981537,
-0.0657818541,
-0.0033728327,
0.0211158376,
-0.0112039261,
0.0184647106,
0.0178284217,
-0.0231095236,
0.0274369549,
0.0620876104,
-0.0272023641,
-0.0250519551,
-0.0197537448,
0.0495709293,
0.0290849935,
-0.0131937601,
0.0068101641,
-0.0433627665,
0.0416215584,
0.0250697546,
0.0741477162,
0.02724424,
-0.0176585093,
-0.0059546083,
0.0266771428,
-0.0087201428,
-0.0188466627,
0.0645265728,
0.0574517883,
-0.05024717,
-0.0147692617,
0.1202362925,
0.0024510447,
-0.0995962322,
-0.0082665365,
0.0154515877,
0.0052872216,
0.04090349,
0.0223379508,
-0.0669650361,
-0.0429599099,
0.009391021,
0.0248534642,
-0.0192174427,
-0.030136764,
0.01086477,
-0.1354713291,
0.0387572534,
-0.0018776999,
-0.0541302338,
-0.0158551596,
-0.0506515168,
0.0364198498,
-0.0088971248,
0.0482283346,
0.0158664398,
-0.020997595,
-0.006528181,
0.0563715212,
0.0163052827,
-0.0911567211,
0.0258804131,
-0.0285387319,
0.0476385318,
0.0661319271,
0.0048673837,
-0.0145835532,
-0.0019455085,
0.0346463211,
-0.0385030136,
0.0157930516,
-0.0050433446,
0.0670283288,
0.0003403036,
-0.0058059404,
0.0158855598,
0.0450941175,
-0.0046830513,
-0.01350962,
0.0096525503,
0.0599175468,
-0.0181790795,
0.016052831,
0.005889412,
-0.070067212,
0.0681946501,
0.0761211589,
0.0487294123,
-0.0776470304,
0.0154180098,
-0.0151781309,
0.0045598736,
-0.0194213726,
0.0270526391,
0.006753529,
0.0016287738,
-0.0303872023,
-0.057836853,
-0.0137398243,
0.0290069468,
0.0752270967,
-0.0010626827,
0.0317557268,
-0.0329269208,
0.0123205408,
0.0059002573,
0.0162941385,
-0.0334247015,
0.0264326278,
-0.0733535886,
-0.0004482569,
0.0321248733,
-0.0483672805,
-0.024246417,
0.0242736731,
-0.0942562222,
-0.0588189326,
0.0099335322,
0.0356799662,
0.0162571874,
0.0926592276,
-0.009965525,
-0.0529685207,
0.1128339767,
0.0565900467,
0.016992392,
0.0189903397,
0.0056910836,
0.0205131304,
-0.02314521,
0.017506985,
-0.0653918236,
-0.0064371736,
0.0593990348,
-0.0237445962,
-0.0343619436,
-0.0125967693,
0.0093204807,
-0.015195447,
0.0729265362,
-0.0511340573,
-0.0207853541,
-0.0014151537,
0.0482864566,
0.0331109948,
-0.0118523873,
-0.0258052293,
-0.0144318147,
0.0215961784,
-0.0210436136,
-0.0024956856,
0.0115827415,
0.0113715976,
0.0466331467,
-0.0485475175,
-0.0299510024,
-0.0113188317,
0.0138096074,
0.0401682481,
0.013505456,
-0.0296957009,
0.0232890919,
0.0113238543,
0.0260657184,
-0.0121316947,
0.0812205523,
0.0245597549,
-0.0188827887,
0.0025446799,
0.01030776,
-0.0777762383,
-0.0054008937,
-0.061424274,
0.0389630459,
0.0411762632,
-0.0268219076,
0.0009185832,
-0.0195298418,
-0.0000523101,
-0.0417937227,
0.0117177377,
-0.0084631899,
-0.0419975743,
0.0392363705,
0.0287224092,
0.0092412466,
0.031207433,
0.0800108612,
-0.0053457385,
0.0473078862,
0.0115002869,
0.023262864,
-0.0235933382,
0.0194126535,
0.0399621762,
0.0386341996,
-0.0244355425,
0.0223657545,
-0.0373735651,
-0.0406797566,
0.0055260048,
0.0058325455,
-0.0036343285,
-0.0135796368,
0.0454075299,
0.0567405373,
-0.0246507619,
-0.0143761896,
-0.0414315611,
-0.0091832606,
0.0051165861,
-0.000484161,
-0.0348116606,
-6.841425611e-33,
-0.0176594798,
-0.0011757896,
-0.0248923469,
-0.0032480892,
0.0228031743,
-0.0030452656,
-0.0094688246,
-0.0028892339,
-0.0144575741,
-0.0004744468,
-0.0520678982,
-0.0038934853,
0.0244202372,
0.0493330248,
0.0123076653,
-0.0325264297,
0.0643122345,
-0.016273845,
-0.0332648233,
0.0369865,
0.0272642877,
0.0260021035,
0.0618972778,
-0.0230880566,
0.0242446028,
-0.0130470349,
0.0013130386,
0.0201401003,
-0.0342747495,
0.0519185513,
-0.0004668499,
0.0607508682,
0.0198207106,
-0.0637680069,
-0.0380802937,
0.0110402573,
-0.0491020307,
-0.0394622162,
-0.0013837268,
0.0459343232,
-0.0124435276,
-0.0157019217,
0.0078541432,
-0.026509773,
-0.0211888738,
-0.002712616,
0.01153618,
-0.0280953422,
-0.0634292513,
-0.0438072495,
-0.0045515541,
0.0122823315,
0.0002526633,
-0.0297528151,
0.0233650953,
0.038320452,
-0.0036314554,
0.0085910819,
-0.0557723194,
0.0092684682,
0.0300432686,
0.0363701656,
0.0388499722,
0.0599666685,
0.0180590637,
0.069327347,
0.0159684643,
-0.0060674446,
0.0261303987,
-0.06698443,
0.0212588087,
0.0052693733,
-0.0075889961,
0.0620445907,
0.0619564615,
0.0118138501,
-0.0575085245,
0.0115518393,
0.0556580685,
0.0063987095,
0.0620529279,
-0.0069189384,
-0.0571664497,
-0.0481616855,
-0.063107498,
-0.0420201197,
-0.0264710952,
-0.0108914366,
0.0451789834,
0.0434243269,
0.0109676635,
-0.0100366194,
0.0633516535,
-0.0409783423,
-0.0518676974,
0.0300959144,
-0.0140013471,
0.0300751813,
0.0031982374,
-0.0250004679,
-0.0666192025,
-0.0272064563,
0.0151635734,
0.0044436716,
-0.0003934498,
-0.0081589445,
0.0712016299,
0.0346975774,
-0.0714483932,
-0.0159430411,
-0.0268504918,
0.0297592338,
0.0343575664,
0.0029124345,
0.0511550643,
-0.0165356714,
-0.01823074,
0.0556855798,
0.0140039138,
-0.0408758037,
-0.000466442,
-0.0331426226,
-0.0484779775,
0.0041405573,
-0.0336764604,
-0.0121869408,
-0.0064815707,
-0.0104452288,
0.031730447,
-0.0147477509,
-0.0115858931,
0.0345167443,
2.852e-7,
0.0135911042,
0.0312844627,
-0.0273160841,
-0.0061996803,
0.0392482392,
0.0542601459,
-0.0219885744,
0.0282313768,
0.0147289047,
-0.0097164186,
-0.0078614587,
-0.0038692248,
0.0427812263,
0.0146589903,
-0.1153039113,
0.013011626,
-0.0527351834,
0.0357080363,
-0.0247531813,
-0.0001395524,
0.0120095005,
0.1082670242,
0.0147101674,
-0.0333295949,
0.0087664863,
-0.0272306036,
0.0491483361,
-0.0709594563,
0.0006909656,
0.0236084294,
0.0216330178,
0.0233231224,
0.0265035201,
0.0419189781,
-0.027153194,
0.0197810177,
-0.0542505942,
0.0254437253,
0.0112263123,
-0.0087896036,
-0.0197075717,
0.0145815806,
0.0117415553,
-0.0550865158,
0.0907838047,
-0.0925068557,
-0.0033133978,
-0.0658282116,
-0.0080555808,
-0.051947698,
0.0236583054,
0.0006340596,
-0.0085582193,
0.0042367722,
0.0073373527,
-0.0053534,
-0.035426788,
-0.0677130744,
-0.0302925166,
0.0108697666,
-0.0329881497,
-0.0638362914,
-0.0356180891,
-0.0244894568,
0.0089020152,
-0.0656656548,
0.0259542447,
2.554571925e-34,
0.0328417979,
0.0092758574,
0.0132390028,
0.043272689,
-0.032090079,
-0.0218174513,
0.0039437735,
-0.0011025356,
0.0505974926,
-0.053459201,
0.0098157478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08917v1 | Relation-aware Ensemble Learning for Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-10-13T07:40:12 | 2023-10-13T07:40:12 | Ling Yue, Yongqi Zhang, Quanming Yao, Yong Li, Xian Wu, Ziheng Zhang, Zhenxi Lin, Yefeng Zheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Knowledge graph (KG) embedding is a fundamental task in natural language
processing, and various methods have been proposed to explore semantic patterns
in distinctive ways. In this paper, we propose to learn an ensemble by
leveraging existing methods in a relation-aware manner. However, exploring
these semantics using relation-aware ensemble leads to a much larger search
space than general ensemble methods. To address this issue, we propose a
divide-search-combine algorithm RelEns-DSC that searches the relation-wise
ensemble weights independently. This algorithm has the same computation cost as
general ensemble methods but with much better performance. Experimental results
on benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method in
efficiently searching relation-aware ensemble weights and achieving
state-of-the-art embedding performance. The code is public at
https://github.com/LARS-research/RelEns. | [
0.021252973,
-0.00939456,
0.0105491988,
0.093700625,
-0.0148205459,
-0.0027184854,
-0.0584172532,
-0.0272839684,
0.0469419882,
-0.0232940298,
0.0510757938,
-0.0037644398,
-0.0205872823,
-0.0126634017,
-0.0088145798,
0.0079226391,
0.0219383799,
0.0595395155,
-0.0053575551,
0.0107060475,
-0.0208759736,
0.0240722001,
-0.0212103892,
0.0143100452,
-0.0236362871,
-0.000773063,
0.0096118497,
0.0034781429,
0.0270952564,
-0.0286359452,
0.0033354613,
0.0216038413,
0.0324269384,
0.0172374509,
0.0000017476,
-0.0234166328,
-0.0274186227,
0.0044020102,
-0.0416224599,
-0.0236484222,
-0.0212086402,
0.0098528881,
0.044072751,
0.0182907842,
-0.0619568489,
-0.0541912243,
0.0347631574,
0.0677599162,
-0.0244113244,
0.0717424676,
-0.0141586466,
-0.030143505,
0.0062611378,
-0.0058247214,
-0.0014098398,
-0.0089732297,
0.0414038152,
-0.010519214,
0.0066607557,
-0.0255756881,
-0.0233326852,
0.033145126,
0.0153513988,
-0.0157916863,
0.0659555644,
0.039876502,
-0.0546487644,
0.0195310991,
-0.0158366114,
0.1096638665,
-0.0012024137,
0.0250850376,
-0.0206295848,
0.0096063949,
-0.0081836712,
0.0537840463,
0.0171308443,
-0.0520359352,
-0.0267437417,
0.0277804546,
-0.0308672078,
0.0251615979,
0.0731240883,
0.0089084525,
-0.0329086706,
0.1046775877,
-0.0211466067,
-0.0324284546,
0.0142819211,
0.0140752411,
-0.0371850841,
0.018141536,
-0.0167042725,
-0.0058383066,
-0.0285798162,
0.0646904856,
0.0022857757,
-0.0301344711,
-0.0313457549,
0.0072447928,
-0.0028808897,
0.005347033,
0.0427161902,
0.0568066351,
-0.0534120239,
-0.0065727206,
0.0200904496,
-0.0215189774,
-0.0283361319,
-0.0172367357,
-0.0758371726,
0.0037346485,
-0.0362041667,
0.0398811884,
-0.0111707039,
-0.041073855,
-0.0539593585,
0.0387222841,
-0.0219910219,
0.0241121668,
0.0466094054,
0.0461822674,
0.057214994,
0.02405289,
0.0051250397,
0.0200131536,
-0.0179038104,
0.0067865248,
-0.0179215353,
0.0052679079,
0.0123366751,
-0.0346449353,
0.0204113256,
-0.0116823846,
-0.0324944817,
0.0470857993,
0.0396356285,
-0.0443568863,
0.0411241613,
-0.030647343,
-0.011457718,
-0.0137948468,
-0.0087818457,
-0.0331395492,
0.0612077676,
-0.0026725887,
0.0194787625,
-0.0379639566,
0.0315033756,
0.0015491063,
-0.0492187552,
0.0851227865,
-0.0194453634,
0.0075661805,
-0.0346368477,
0.0238503087,
-0.0365604945,
0.0620801002,
0.038508486,
-0.0037649593,
0.0486816242,
-0.00964408,
-0.030231148,
-0.0261396505,
0.0168610718,
-0.0306898914,
0.0138119161,
0.0122909853,
0.0043746252,
0.0546619631,
0.0123964297,
0.0147738708,
-0.0198514313,
-0.040518187,
-0.0253926013,
0.011535015,
0.0309309103,
0.0098502431,
-0.0057821367,
0.0237176828,
-0.0254337788,
-0.0034965214,
-0.0430816263,
0.0095266579,
-0.0584148504,
-0.0000146975,
0.0072959368,
0.0230141208,
-0.0039966558,
0.0112630837,
-0.0090992637,
0.0088441931,
-0.0121748792,
0.0313867405,
0.0390802734,
-0.013909135,
-0.0172772389,
0.0041208207,
0.0695454925,
-0.0401798189,
-0.0079640523,
0.0328739695,
0.0092785126,
0.0745313242,
0.060653396,
-0.0689151734,
0.0176666025,
-0.0090320492,
-0.0118453884,
-0.0203447249,
0.0221473891,
-0.0325692333,
0.0398469791,
-0.0710870177,
-0.0925408974,
0.0302967038,
-0.0019736127,
0.0021116086,
0.0415662602,
0.0471737199,
-0.0045676688,
-0.0343636386,
0.0031795369,
0.0284090042,
0.0015551464,
0.0095379641,
0.0517886281,
0.0246202815,
0.0362505801,
0.0439969972,
-0.007701938,
0.003224557,
0.0628695711,
-0.0367080048,
-0.0850286186,
-0.0106050335,
-0.0606732182,
-0.1398389339,
0.0521568656,
-0.0486734211,
-0.0110011995,
-0.0375871398,
-0.0534204245,
-0.0358730331,
0.0207346771,
-0.0174547583,
0.0705645308,
-0.0212800354,
-0.025403263,
-0.0149993189,
0.0051298556,
-0.0369255878,
0.1034445539,
-0.0212249197,
0.0032136347,
-0.0532503277,
-0.0563156791,
-0.0051396899,
0.0111537054,
-0.0580210462,
0.0005235244,
0.0001485122,
0.0013524267,
0.0072235703,
-0.0547425263,
-0.0406404398,
-0.0099930931,
-0.0694228932,
0.0107951602,
0.0230862312,
-0.0059649511,
-0.0166061744,
0.0115695111,
0.0102844397,
0.0133514144,
-0.0186229367,
-0.0055490476,
-0.0477042943,
0.0008890549,
-0.0068123122,
-0.0025118454,
-0.0384985358,
0.0075645018,
-0.0261986218,
-0.0164485052,
0.0738092735,
-0.0293493439,
-0.0107045732,
0.0208282508,
0.0251122918,
-0.0427106693,
-0.0330443159,
-0.0135392509,
0.0232677627,
-0.0409912691,
0.0123355296,
0.0046204128,
0.0215327553,
-0.0157150235,
0.0694390386,
0.0586023889,
0.0205506403,
-0.0345472954,
0.0213191267,
-0.0206319392,
0.0692186654,
0.0099346302,
-0.0081058461,
-0.0137274787,
0.0094035547,
0.0065976428,
-0.0262044407,
-0.0318593048,
-0.019289609,
-0.0156159801,
-0.0408733785,
-0.0536847785,
0.0101996791,
0.0316054188,
-0.0573856905,
-0.0224263519,
-0.0052626864,
0.0837557092,
0.0313109569,
-0.0049214265,
-0.0467598811,
-0.0266193077,
-0.01470064,
0.0529769734,
-0.0366706625,
0.0158061851,
0.0433885977,
0.0271597374,
-0.0105895288,
-0.0147341844,
0.0572665296,
-0.0191647951,
0.023050651,
0.0271285921,
0.0295628421,
0.0076715644,
-0.0175216459,
-0.0339097492,
-0.0215986352,
-0.0413315557,
0.0256665405,
-0.0106109371,
-0.0348019451,
-0.0332269073,
-0.0089641195,
0.0084826127,
-0.0401800424,
0.0200925507,
-0.0258464329,
0.0193033144,
0.0606759265,
0.0381702483,
-0.0188831966,
0.0289561376,
0.0281390194,
0.0559520349,
0.0380464047,
0.0094676819,
-0.0262367539,
-0.042452652,
-0.0215580761,
-0.0280567762,
-0.0391948782,
0.0025573496,
-0.0153264329,
0.005699195,
-0.0250640195,
0.052882988,
0.0831319466,
0.0374750495,
-0.026950933,
0.0084881578,
0.0271131769,
0.0313945189,
0.0557083376,
-0.0065011247,
-0.0524195023,
-0.041163139,
-0.0081335781,
-0.0191939082,
0.0109263351,
-0.0971226692,
0.0094618276,
-0.0529652908,
0.0149420071,
0.0029984815,
-0.0374961011,
-0.0274645835,
-0.0537151955,
0.0172440335,
-0.0155725414,
-0.0455339886,
-0.0374031439,
-0.0027585684,
0.0097965794,
-0.0106088351,
-0.0197504163,
-0.0567309223,
0.0141934454,
-0.0747765228,
0.0343701057,
0.0401392877,
0.0372504257,
-0.005342301,
0.0135190673,
-0.0729300603,
-0.0338077098,
-0.0441132113,
-0.0104964832,
0.0312664807,
-0.0145354113,
0.0135478163,
-0.0239586886,
-0.0206145328,
-0.1144566163,
0.0309866946,
0.0472869277,
0.1347639412,
-0.0118103512,
-0.0414207913,
-0.0428283513,
-0.0520376526,
0.04867924,
0.0869354978,
0.0093476931,
0.0259745084,
0.0192865599,
-0.0071751485,
0.017540697,
-0.0161111988,
0.0454059727,
0.0193424895,
0.0209559519,
0.06305857,
-0.0500178337,
-0.0213334542,
0.0811934099,
0.0387676172,
-0.0168474261,
0.0604028031,
0.0008043449,
0.0093827583,
-0.0950951129,
-0.0235439483,
-0.0247051716,
0.0462189838,
0.0313555337,
-0.0062931962,
0.0110311564,
0.0270785876,
-0.0103816446,
-0.0540170521,
0.0022431244,
-0.0548318662,
-0.0457819514,
0.0107683344,
0.0016074517,
0.0185986571,
-0.008051048,
0.0110398578,
0.0918299332,
0.0674564615,
-0.0174731538,
-0.0015110802,
-0.0077028852,
-0.0575498678,
-0.0019086021,
0.0674604177,
-0.0245305914,
-0.0049955864,
-0.0099609541,
0.0559584685,
-0.0391022936,
-0.0119793164,
0.00886067,
-0.0174712837,
-0.0064834873,
-0.0047812411,
-0.0265762657,
-0.0543036237,
0.009780243,
-0.0413766541,
-0.0094993971,
-0.0419746637,
0.0156497471,
0.0270530395,
-0.0299100578,
0.0049290988,
0.0336000212,
0.0453080609,
0.0157544035,
0.0171226673,
0.0278147627,
0.0538254082,
-0.0143823689,
0.0412789807,
0.0366019197,
-0.0039286502,
0.0225419104,
-0.0028195321,
-0.0128072025,
0.0109220045,
-0.0180211645,
0.0146655077,
-0.0344326608,
-0.041623719,
0.017509779,
-0.0458087996,
0.0244789403,
0.0053175217,
0.0183536224,
0.0952272937,
-0.028444441,
-0.0036840478,
-0.004011869,
-0.0038035773,
-0.0239215028,
0.0301309936,
-0.0472215042,
-0.0219999235,
0.0725087672,
0.036845006,
-0.0420448557,
0.0321589932,
0.0642455071,
-0.0333148055,
0.0711357445,
0.0086564524,
-0.0545133464,
-0.0485622697,
-0.021393016,
0.0475277752,
0.0528785288,
-0.0337228626,
0.064001061,
-0.0287365336,
-0.0453763902,
0.0041750637,
-0.0682124794,
-0.0536503382,
0.0000916973,
0.0293632559,
0.0039290092,
0.0509896316,
0.0136106517,
-0.0183911342,
-0.006451414,
-0.1038949564,
-0.0451993756,
0.0020800445,
-5.655481115e-33,
-0.0016132089,
-0.0404913463,
-0.0163944997,
-0.0465129204,
-0.0141019812,
0.0394123606,
-0.0069951839,
-0.0329419971,
-0.0375101566,
0.0581058599,
-0.007916986,
0.0121519705,
-0.0132732596,
0.0094277635,
-0.0189608745,
-0.0082393605,
-0.0044186227,
0.0087655205,
0.0225353893,
0.0065185488,
0.0514393151,
0.0478257313,
0.0313901305,
-0.0640305132,
-0.0322650783,
0.0010172138,
0.0257027391,
0.0304604806,
0.0172226019,
0.037762437,
-0.0088906735,
0.0483042374,
0.0181096923,
0.0258173142,
0.0059671844,
-0.0256350413,
-0.0827144384,
-0.0388451219,
-0.0300199874,
-0.0061687701,
-0.033715412,
0.0310270414,
0.0297812093,
0.0192051549,
0.0864741951,
-0.0761979222,
0.0382406898,
-0.0264180563,
-0.0825838596,
-0.0599981397,
-0.003510209,
0.0209394712,
0.013428133,
-0.0187779814,
0.0371333659,
0.0081341444,
0.0529388264,
-0.0448620096,
-0.0269197468,
-0.0192599688,
-0.0447148196,
-0.0030507718,
-0.0039069611,
0.0108604506,
0.0096791564,
0.0647867918,
-0.0060431859,
-0.0363328382,
0.0001345137,
-0.0165388938,
-0.0097510219,
0.0414770171,
-0.0101918429,
0.0096001187,
0.0086758584,
0.0098649068,
-0.0673283786,
0.0000540131,
0.0719555914,
-0.0037509757,
0.0138121061,
0.0553303398,
-0.0634120852,
-0.0243782587,
-0.0146815991,
-0.0041480949,
-0.0070895432,
-0.0572463572,
-0.0078475494,
0.0115732523,
0.0091225337,
0.0124687692,
-0.0190094821,
-0.0802050754,
-0.005032232,
0.0484203696,
0.014900988,
-0.0223677382,
0.0352940895,
-0.0174695682,
-0.0451316833,
0.0040142341,
0.0170684773,
-0.0404664651,
-0.025045095,
0.0189715847,
0.0614894815,
-0.0009478272,
-0.0221235435,
-0.0233872738,
-0.0154397311,
-0.0257134289,
-0.0294898544,
0.0350807197,
0.0159352403,
0.0764601603,
0.0024579624,
-0.0010504966,
0.0385559164,
0.0176398456,
-0.014268972,
0.0446515195,
0.020750707,
0.0249633081,
0.0100910608,
-0.0283553861,
-0.0148011958,
-0.022402579,
0.0350114442,
-0.0311650895,
-0.0253932904,
-0.0485715531,
2.525e-7,
0.0226711631,
0.0064255567,
0.0243107453,
0.0096887974,
0.016905617,
0.0344951674,
-0.0019466366,
0.043774195,
-0.0481931865,
-0.0309078339,
0.0461762436,
0.0101608457,
0.0008714848,
0.023067411,
-0.0806966797,
-0.0124309761,
-0.046031747,
-0.0500666425,
-0.0231916923,
-0.0420684591,
0.0530055016,
0.0818398744,
0.076198332,
0.0065526334,
-0.0502622947,
-0.0109058879,
0.0378852487,
-0.0070376806,
0.0598656498,
-0.0247223601,
0.0176118985,
0.0154024363,
-0.018038664,
0.0621729381,
-0.0210722703,
0.0633425564,
0.0121989138,
0.0157185066,
-0.0194431692,
0.0262892637,
-0.0154330824,
-0.020709591,
0.0202843174,
-0.01089219,
0.0373559296,
-0.0438110754,
-0.0070918687,
-0.001118009,
0.0199864544,
-0.014791497,
0.0265187025,
0.0431907736,
0.0272325445,
0.0205917731,
0.0085934848,
-0.0344180577,
-0.0032178836,
-0.0926207826,
0.0022908798,
0.0275693275,
-0.0334546603,
0.0120247072,
-0.0119704306,
-0.012224514,
0.0220352486,
-0.0097349519,
0.0205360241,
2.243136636e-34,
0.0039116535,
0.0185090043,
-0.0135207055,
0.016110139,
0.0229721777,
-0.0630531684,
-0.0269449595,
-0.0185579658,
0.0364794135,
-0.0623111539,
0.0364252515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08908v1 | Human-in-the-loop Machine Translation with Large Language Model | 2023-10-13T07:30:27 | 2023-10-13T07:30:27 | Xinyi Yang, Runzhe Zhan, Derek F. Wong, Junchao Wu, Lidia S. Chao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The large language model (LLM) has garnered significant attention due to its
in-context learning mechanisms and emergent capabilities. The research
community has conducted several pilot studies to apply LLMs to machine
translation tasks and evaluate their performance from diverse perspectives.
However, previous research has primarily focused on the LLM itself and has not
explored human intervention in the inference process of LLM. The
characteristics of LLM, such as in-context learning and prompt engineering,
closely mirror human cognitive abilities in language tasks, offering an
intuitive solution for human-in-the-loop generation. In this study, we propose
a human-in-the-loop pipeline that guides LLMs to produce customized outputs
with revision instructions. The pipeline initiates by prompting the LLM to
produce a draft translation, followed by the utilization of automatic retrieval
or human feedback as supervision signals to enhance the LLM's translation
through in-context learning. The human-machine interactions generated in this
pipeline are also stored in an external database to expand the in-context
retrieval database, enabling us to leverage human supervision in an offline
setting. We evaluate the proposed pipeline using GPT-3.5-turbo API on five
domain-specific benchmarks for German-English translation. The results
demonstrate the effectiveness of the pipeline in tailoring in-domain
translations and improving translation performance compared to direct
translation. Additionally, we discuss the results from the following
perspectives: 1) the effectiveness of different in-context retrieval methods;
2) the construction of a retrieval database under low-resource scenarios; 3)
the observed domains differences; 4) the quantitative analysis of linguistic
statistics; and 5) the qualitative analysis of translation cases. The code and
data are available at https://github.com/NLP2CT/HIL-MT/. | [
0.058171723,
-0.0149058448,
-0.0391117297,
0.0190154184,
-0.0548562929,
0.0233677346,
0.0051829657,
-0.0075541902,
0.002697685,
-0.0321617611,
-0.0390116498,
-0.0518728942,
0.0064921058,
-0.0095694745,
0.0393430889,
-0.0549901314,
0.0304383673,
-0.0243070591,
-0.0334338136,
0.0156330522,
-0.0078791436,
0.0129760616,
0.028038526,
0.058813598,
0.020124726,
0.0150282038,
0.0042350595,
0.0733611509,
-0.0014028571,
-0.0187945291,
-0.0047737183,
0.0429084674,
0.0639524832,
0.0625666827,
0.0000022449,
-0.0574366786,
-0.0326793604,
0.0004042408,
0.0060587111,
-0.0198925491,
0.0696405396,
-0.0403432213,
-0.0525408424,
0.0184305403,
-0.0298562031,
-0.0075684497,
0.029298164,
-0.0271733627,
0.0512582771,
0.0755749568,
-0.0140380766,
-0.0063849599,
-0.0060454621,
-0.0268256981,
-0.0201728158,
-0.0596647561,
-0.0104789576,
-0.0167058092,
-0.000019864,
0.0361764915,
0.0214784406,
0.0409550369,
0.0291761309,
-0.019878244,
-0.0222671181,
0.0107371667,
0.0020864333,
-0.0508656316,
-0.0222509205,
0.0688450783,
-0.0069919722,
-0.0160854589,
-0.0081167277,
0.0017295611,
0.0102688083,
0.0075919568,
-0.0510096438,
0.0361869782,
-0.0215181708,
-0.0193639882,
-0.022478098,
0.010984947,
0.0022838521,
0.0004963452,
-0.0269394964,
0.0197711904,
0.0294317063,
-0.02609374,
0.0020759404,
0.0219815355,
-0.0410301164,
-0.026776012,
0.0346895382,
0.0207688957,
-0.0575187132,
0.0192005225,
-0.023449976,
-0.0573484302,
0.0229295101,
-0.0516575426,
0.0357943587,
0.0621798113,
-0.0155858928,
0.0454267301,
-0.0066061807,
0.0751405433,
-0.0292608254,
-0.0119630415,
-0.0682223216,
-0.0140256323,
-0.0636697561,
0.0049927365,
-0.0680522174,
-0.0060787555,
-0.0559102744,
0.0022609194,
-0.0428037867,
0.0487818569,
0.0136364941,
0.0342328325,
-0.0143298693,
-0.0430142879,
-0.0956886113,
-0.0226538088,
-0.0149078872,
0.0511958003,
-0.0031992614,
-0.0421793796,
0.0035579589,
-0.0481849723,
-0.0138623165,
0.011547857,
-0.0379893221,
-0.0363513976,
-0.0144004794,
0.0548317917,
-0.0248354338,
-0.0351855122,
-0.0115790628,
-0.0325081795,
0.0023193285,
-0.0701357201,
-0.0215619504,
-0.0505512692,
0.0354190096,
0.037735559,
-0.0096592838,
-0.0483981483,
-0.0006131366,
0.0416189432,
0.023061553,
0.0127787748,
0.001611131,
0.044915624,
0.0606079474,
-0.011582423,
-0.0584596433,
0.0719744638,
0.024170151,
0.0504529811,
0.0356717221,
0.0063630631,
-0.002526819,
0.0646707714,
0.0065479963,
0.030829709,
-0.0346978679,
0.0210513137,
0.0243638325,
0.0318183415,
0.0259170942,
0.0405883528,
-0.0204801783,
0.0722055063,
0.0854526833,
0.0424340554,
0.0190670025,
0.0214146469,
0.062844269,
0.0617396906,
0.0036579247,
-0.0166369732,
-0.0287272763,
0.0161039177,
-0.0214361567,
0.0241142455,
0.0017377819,
0.0441901982,
-0.0010738494,
-0.0168994851,
0.0115210116,
0.010269477,
-0.0000268712,
0.0063435161,
0.0816675425,
0.0160548054,
-0.0747286752,
0.0069308253,
0.0047514159,
-0.0340969376,
0.0096452776,
-0.0344207846,
-0.0255999416,
0.0832763761,
0.0610322431,
-0.0047088638,
-0.0029508418,
-0.0280923583,
0.006434781,
0.0461497456,
0.0420223102,
0.0073022312,
-0.0362357497,
-0.0260573886,
-0.0202807393,
0.0218526628,
0.0021997178,
0.0150349485,
0.0623124279,
0.0142366542,
0.0384838209,
-0.0301071629,
-0.0398225524,
0.0230581444,
-0.0370897539,
-0.0073150275,
0.0000712637,
0.0202269722,
0.0095189568,
0.0185385793,
-0.0199865531,
0.0053998167,
0.0101724686,
-0.033070378,
-0.0249925032,
0.0239701681,
-0.0483621247,
0.0052226176,
-0.0006673831,
0.0152987065,
-0.0377115533,
-0.0390538946,
-0.0144617287,
-0.0266967863,
-0.0392695293,
-0.0348047204,
0.0150740184,
-0.0591604635,
0.0286822077,
-0.0039938856,
-0.0267223082,
-0.0735966042,
0.0481579155,
0.0290993731,
-0.0229850877,
0.0378593169,
0.0257473346,
0.0063968501,
-0.0327891484,
-0.0079918066,
0.0467315465,
-0.0021359378,
0.0178344492,
0.0535679311,
0.0150954938,
-0.0420465171,
-0.0380604528,
-0.0968015268,
0.0212508552,
-0.0379871503,
0.0144616077,
0.0418341346,
0.0448359996,
-0.0108139906,
-0.0084817261,
0.0399120972,
-0.0078774896,
0.0229463317,
0.0418606028,
0.0008112623,
-0.0052000741,
0.0006310522,
-0.0100956531,
0.0103093563,
0.0227789469,
0.021093484,
0.0465273969,
-0.0358320139,
-0.0768280998,
0.0318702795,
-0.0066689504,
-0.0069249859,
0.005755181,
-0.0295544546,
0.0114131086,
-0.041690249,
0.1141360775,
0.0464246906,
-0.0023065731,
0.0144393547,
0.0198971517,
-0.0069656135,
-0.0623585582,
0.008064827,
-0.0337851904,
-0.0957448334,
-0.0138024297,
0.0113755008,
0.0340943933,
0.009611126,
0.0041641602,
0.0133074997,
-0.0657239333,
-0.0101532433,
-0.0506537445,
-0.003509165,
-0.0597681627,
-0.0010355157,
-0.021013191,
0.0606202893,
-0.0193087254,
-0.0731275156,
0.0705210418,
0.0090704346,
-0.0092303287,
-0.054440368,
-0.0166428424,
-0.0277454481,
0.0891452804,
-0.0316072367,
0.0110967234,
-0.0328835808,
-0.0235073101,
-0.0526200607,
0.04102071,
0.0218590349,
-0.0336418785,
0.0199642014,
-0.0890029967,
0.0142474705,
-0.0293630455,
-0.009522832,
-0.0211912002,
0.0109852795,
-0.0337878801,
-0.0074218968,
0.0036610642,
-0.0063757994,
-0.0072172754,
0.0022103274,
0.0490591191,
0.0678174868,
-0.0070816134,
-0.0255059376,
-0.0222223625,
-0.0031165853,
0.0044300547,
-0.0114244707,
-0.016955236,
-0.0549140833,
0.0509011447,
0.032745,
0.0364991762,
-0.0428122506,
-0.0144616496,
-0.0301801581,
0.0375759639,
-0.0245558657,
-0.016910864,
0.0443063714,
0.0444274619,
-0.0652620271,
-0.0305891745,
0.0968088582,
0.0198674258,
-0.0945141539,
-0.0173068084,
-0.0104363728,
0.0219811145,
0.0198333226,
0.0508378074,
-0.048824627,
-0.0318954065,
0.0434740148,
0.0383519903,
0.0045154733,
0.014186603,
-0.0192731917,
-0.1076197922,
0.0623024106,
0.025550222,
-0.0466142669,
-0.0358148329,
-0.0269178972,
-0.0152086597,
0.0052930419,
0.0099220406,
0.0246434268,
0.0138029754,
0.0038032145,
-0.0237632468,
0.0469829105,
-0.0570595823,
0.0296152607,
-0.0471052304,
0.0080157341,
0.1007254943,
0.020137148,
0.0349403471,
-0.0078876847,
0.0665355697,
-0.0284652542,
0.0453725643,
-0.0240356065,
0.0185921751,
-0.0026098418,
0.0178497359,
-0.0265070274,
0.0155000575,
-0.0445178039,
0.004388669,
0.0465068184,
0.0756159425,
-0.0314510129,
0.0314747319,
-0.001373572,
-0.0335705392,
0.0290967617,
0.0552168861,
-0.0069321762,
-0.0734835193,
-0.0120765278,
-0.007486695,
-0.0110681616,
-0.0308466461,
-0.0183150545,
-0.0206303801,
-0.0413308293,
0.0054462692,
-0.0605154447,
-0.0386861451,
0.0218404066,
0.0518129729,
0.0346483588,
0.0246003438,
0.0339566991,
0.0156966243,
-0.0248670708,
0.04405801,
-0.0341873839,
0.0386396311,
-0.0654847398,
-0.0171377864,
0.0332682319,
-0.0481771789,
0.0016357843,
0.0544683747,
-0.0726417825,
-0.059874218,
0.0005663896,
0.0254949797,
0.0255296193,
0.0414938591,
0.0005547914,
-0.0380223691,
0.0119408919,
0.0171565041,
-0.0670868754,
0.0060000657,
-0.0138328783,
0.0297651123,
-0.0326636098,
0.0341654345,
-0.0306564439,
0.0005356221,
0.0154135721,
0.0654359758,
0.0164124407,
-0.0670569018,
0.0363190621,
0.0128502697,
0.0164030474,
-0.0253470056,
-0.0549688898,
-0.0299826656,
-0.0079571214,
0.0135438936,
-0.0191260986,
-0.0546777546,
-0.0111764269,
0.0120538902,
-0.0428763814,
0.0245587323,
0.0056482106,
-0.0022954277,
0.0102183176,
-0.0070870416,
-0.0268662199,
-0.0238362737,
0.0580604896,
0.0372439772,
0.0295118038,
-0.0068466333,
0.0240829904,
-0.0118516721,
0.0286974683,
-0.0293353125,
0.1043784395,
0.0144183645,
-0.0131991133,
0.010471453,
0.0344269946,
-0.0426312089,
-0.0070115677,
-0.0076963878,
0.0204308238,
0.0783815533,
0.0201994963,
0.0880818591,
-0.0539746135,
-0.0132006034,
-0.0156038813,
0.0299819987,
-0.0136353774,
-0.0129710734,
-0.0202395841,
-0.0071085189,
0.003735672,
0.0427593328,
0.0425140783,
-0.0081729069,
-0.0046515218,
-0.0044712871,
-0.0070274323,
-0.0283219051,
-0.0112430463,
0.0099401837,
-0.0185102187,
-0.0234141294,
-0.0080305841,
-0.0611273721,
-0.0311668143,
-0.0257172305,
0.0089403577,
-0.0240112506,
-0.0435414016,
0.0156049076,
0.1014780849,
-0.0487643182,
-0.0288423356,
-0.0496698655,
0.041014269,
-0.0181435514,
-0.0313660838,
-0.0444367863,
-6.414209087e-33,
-0.0405282341,
-0.0674729124,
0.0400918648,
-0.0216245577,
-0.0286138151,
-0.0254700091,
-0.0446814261,
-0.0106191654,
0.0254637487,
-0.0003514666,
-0.0374170803,
-0.0107153123,
0.0163111519,
-0.0118979858,
0.0255139209,
0.0303611662,
0.0560851842,
-0.0036085651,
-0.0268119387,
0.049999401,
0.0301212277,
0.0316772275,
0.0295921974,
-0.0592545271,
0.0452391282,
-0.0370087177,
0.0008660294,
0.0336120352,
0.0109845744,
0.0080191828,
0.024059549,
0.0265212152,
0.013151342,
-0.0767536983,
-0.0188243911,
0.0259202365,
-0.0812025666,
0.0069391998,
0.0009145574,
0.0220501162,
0.0189499613,
-0.0413488001,
0.0437162109,
-0.0486034118,
-0.027266223,
0.0039305836,
0.0077599203,
-0.0128996884,
-0.0513666868,
-0.0286569204,
-0.0865437388,
0.0185776446,
-0.0040586544,
-0.0038019461,
0.0182036273,
0.0557165183,
-0.0165463723,
0.0202584434,
-0.0886162743,
0.0264592692,
-0.0375471711,
0.0085795,
0.0706774071,
-0.0058091576,
0.0036428459,
-0.0114366906,
0.0258252975,
0.0547078289,
0.0063073416,
-0.02220059,
0.0357410274,
-0.0061228899,
0.0241657589,
0.0523949638,
0.0184102524,
-0.0171373468,
-0.0131354174,
0.0435837023,
-0.0196102317,
0.0324095339,
0.0574130602,
0.0191273671,
-0.0428856052,
-0.0010667845,
-0.0307502169,
-0.026188409,
-0.0267380774,
-0.0432491787,
0.048475489,
0.0255664382,
-0.0108290836,
-0.0431670472,
0.0772479251,
-0.0089683635,
0.0398440473,
-0.0220936928,
-0.0357697308,
0.018945327,
-0.015089279,
0.0293800365,
-0.0135747353,
-0.0334399603,
0.0089676529,
0.0455862656,
-0.0071907523,
-0.0070500299,
-0.0041928166,
0.0184202977,
-0.0319978409,
0.020149583,
-0.0420410521,
0.0225068741,
-0.0261554439,
-0.0160473678,
0.020170074,
0.0026605211,
-0.0113303689,
0.0635905042,
0.0367925912,
-0.0306864176,
-0.0317718163,
0.0196689349,
0.0102888932,
0.013036727,
-0.0351987556,
0.0306679439,
-0.0140993232,
0.0182490759,
0.0509638451,
-0.0138695985,
-0.0125421435,
-0.0037759372,
3.036e-7,
0.0097107468,
0.068657659,
-0.008241633,
0.0016970036,
0.0032416049,
0.0425758027,
-0.0227234848,
-0.0275658797,
0.0705230832,
0.0268538129,
0.0455815829,
0.0325842351,
0.0747731701,
0.0224430747,
-0.0831065699,
-0.0197241958,
-0.0012299597,
0.0572575927,
-0.0637194291,
0.0224526618,
0.0563063808,
0.051582057,
-0.0140336873,
-0.0103965681,
-0.0171958972,
-0.0377999842,
0.0762491152,
-0.0281655397,
-0.0181793291,
-0.001622492,
0.0234967973,
0.0410893708,
-0.0174637306,
0.0140653318,
-0.0169257019,
-0.0083808023,
0.0273025148,
0.0753973871,
0.0087951766,
0.0069657071,
0.0043696361,
-0.0143694514,
0.0057771262,
-0.0813246891,
0.0215461124,
-0.1045620292,
0.0046381829,
0.0105824778,
-0.0087467162,
-0.024217207,
0.00144455,
-0.0290617701,
-0.0046581961,
0.0307922512,
0.0457741246,
0.0144671267,
-0.0223240554,
-0.0248024184,
-0.0100724548,
-0.0163421668,
-0.0236665346,
-0.0540997125,
-0.0623174571,
0.0306260996,
-0.026529979,
-0.0054180888,
0.0063616293,
2.925279451e-34,
0.0164313205,
-0.0122749582,
0.0349735133,
-0.004694846,
0.0491430238,
0.0054079043,
-0.0028529363,
0.0227818023,
0.0005292073,
-0.064718619,
-0.0401691459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08903v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08903v2 | SeqXGPT: Sentence-Level AI-Generated Text Detection | 2023-10-13T07:18:53 | 2023-12-15T03:03:16 | Pengyu Wang, Linyang Li, Ke Ren, Botian Jiang, Dong Zhang, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Widely applied large language models (LLMs) can generate human-like content,
raising concerns about the abuse of LLMs. Therefore, it is important to build
strong AI-generated text (AIGT) detectors. Current works only consider
document-level AIGT detection, therefore, in this paper, we first introduce a
sentence-level detection challenge by synthesizing a dataset that contains
documents that are polished with LLMs, that is, the documents contain sentences
written by humans and sentences modified by LLMs. Then we propose
\textbf{Seq}uence \textbf{X} (Check) \textbf{GPT}, a novel method that utilizes
log probability lists from white-box LLMs as features for sentence-level AIGT
detection. These features are composed like \textit{waves} in speech processing
and cannot be studied by LLMs. Therefore, we build SeqXGPT based on convolution
and self-attention networks. We test it in both sentence and document-level
detection challenges. Experimental results show that previous methods struggle
in solving sentence-level AIGT detection, while our method not only
significantly surpasses baseline methods in both sentence and document-level
detection challenges but also exhibits strong generalization capabilities. | [
0.0246434547,
0.0448292606,
0.0162994284,
0.0648767725,
-0.0350614339,
0.0020508401,
0.0096187107,
0.0007457593,
0.0546063557,
-0.0518864058,
-0.0533246249,
-0.0147645809,
-0.0383944139,
0.0395517834,
0.0453823619,
0.0171959195,
0.0482659601,
-0.0154751558,
0.0308323279,
0.0221129693,
0.0220119953,
0.0203097705,
0.0200850498,
0.0292393211,
-0.0226377025,
-0.0383105464,
0.0007819535,
0.0505086631,
0.0402118899,
-0.0305177737,
0.018832041,
0.0480973981,
-0.0160434879,
0.0705591217,
0.0000019889,
-0.0329164714,
-0.017430529,
-0.0342057645,
-0.0197127908,
0.0256439522,
0.0069657229,
0.0011727111,
-0.0442287959,
0.0323475935,
-0.0229099505,
0.0340902209,
0.0000762531,
0.0810646787,
0.0376523882,
0.1094078347,
-0.0262442119,
-0.0012628788,
0.0383267924,
-0.0208212417,
0.0717665851,
-0.0535424426,
0.0311009977,
-0.0292547718,
-0.0023889458,
0.0069553405,
0.0051650684,
0.0414768644,
0.0440150052,
-0.0370791368,
-0.0009272096,
0.0147314612,
-0.0501178429,
0.0095708882,
-0.0390757695,
0.0550787523,
-0.0499376096,
-0.0504918359,
0.0240208674,
-0.0214104056,
0.0327332728,
-0.0500194617,
-0.0057474962,
0.0230165124,
-0.0498759076,
0.0306302253,
0.010024786,
0.0112690581,
0.0244569834,
0.0366318002,
-0.0111778807,
0.0597830452,
0.0193310939,
-0.0428587049,
-0.0024623175,
0.002031035,
-0.0325494409,
-0.0433165543,
0.0648445114,
0.0158910714,
0.0164558087,
-0.0244840644,
-0.0889567956,
-0.0577172749,
0.0190207083,
-0.0317753293,
0.035980802,
-0.0086497627,
-0.0261308011,
0.0899055526,
-0.0495460294,
0.079464823,
-0.047776103,
0.0185772032,
-0.0384905525,
0.0250972863,
0.0169939194,
-0.0206945278,
-0.0619742908,
-0.0080141146,
0.0073519088,
-0.0548357368,
-0.0172772314,
0.0055795638,
0.027482247,
-0.0107758725,
0.0107725943,
-0.0052628703,
-0.0359768681,
-0.0400250852,
0.046818193,
-0.0276534017,
0.0125378463,
0.0151147181,
0.0044367826,
-0.0346438847,
-0.0357807279,
0.0697980076,
0.0332985371,
-0.0173344724,
0.0021624125,
0.0170952119,
-0.0138577893,
-0.0666336343,
-0.0505696051,
-0.0144975111,
-0.0571857318,
-0.0456759073,
-0.00003043,
-0.047562547,
-0.0091287401,
-0.0521780439,
-0.0008109903,
-0.0046373494,
0.0113958921,
0.0206108168,
0.0086414358,
0.0440505445,
0.0052819611,
0.0011897795,
0.0426149294,
0.0064895796,
0.0263443012,
0.0592780598,
0.0513000637,
0.0772901922,
0.034192726,
0.0063511664,
0.0495002605,
0.0742750764,
-0.0014696326,
0.0118493028,
0.019944882,
-0.0281425677,
-0.0488285348,
0.0055751218,
0.030011015,
0.0445471518,
-0.0009497406,
-0.0375575908,
0.0725304484,
0.0369776301,
-0.0049748444,
0.025630163,
0.0475787073,
0.0606805161,
0.013491896,
0.0234680548,
-0.0005384574,
-0.0053819758,
-0.0146070011,
-0.014805913,
0.0433731824,
0.0214304887,
-0.0157117881,
-0.0298620723,
-0.0089713261,
-0.0056493557,
-0.0047051385,
-0.0314319804,
0.0512231216,
0.0412739366,
-0.0447226316,
-0.0409663729,
-0.0151618263,
-0.0345314071,
-0.0035441578,
-0.0486202389,
0.0611084253,
0.0392659977,
0.0541297644,
-0.019194128,
0.0415624529,
-0.0238989946,
0.0070013129,
0.0660069585,
0.0309473015,
0.0376435481,
-0.0193706322,
-0.0370671824,
-0.0149801318,
0.0001227816,
0.0246449579,
0.0332947262,
0.0280511845,
0.0202346016,
0.0276799332,
-0.0357816182,
-0.037377324,
0.0348362327,
-0.0089292461,
-0.0545867532,
0.0200063717,
-0.0111107323,
0.0335386805,
0.0235644486,
-0.0150548816,
0.033904817,
0.0309267417,
-0.06557706,
-0.0621697232,
-0.0092518739,
-0.0362525359,
-0.0313293114,
0.0152333593,
-0.0363301523,
-0.0079564508,
0.0335201956,
-0.0317807831,
-0.0461055189,
-0.0027563113,
-0.0582004935,
0.0054093632,
-0.0498766191,
0.0023431249,
0.0564006753,
0.0453391746,
-0.0173913706,
0.0331764556,
0.0009706466,
-0.0277421009,
-0.0047012125,
0.0157572757,
0.0268311277,
-0.0676038563,
-0.0191444829,
-0.0003420545,
-0.0246410426,
0.0329137556,
0.041611664,
0.027652109,
-0.0217596497,
-0.0188481919,
-0.105464913,
0.0085511813,
-0.0323505364,
0.0151543655,
0.0330404937,
-0.0105072623,
-0.0366814099,
-0.0305548031,
-0.0231194776,
-0.0355515741,
0.0315522701,
-0.0172265787,
0.0236668959,
-0.0371534079,
0.0211954191,
-0.0425441377,
-0.0107231792,
-0.0307642948,
0.0304074008,
0.0280353855,
-0.0568864793,
-0.0652936921,
0.0274898205,
0.03153117,
0.0194232091,
-0.0027895358,
-0.051417172,
-0.0153816091,
-0.0259313155,
0.0440997668,
0.1184518784,
0.0425906666,
-0.0213315096,
0.0067072008,
0.0237407051,
-0.0175504424,
0.0521983951,
0.0018708858,
0.0218828283,
-0.0091683511,
-0.0351208784,
0.0675485656,
0.0746914968,
0.0181340035,
0.0048460043,
-0.0283787958,
0.0113974102,
0.006136064,
-0.0446085036,
-0.0268980842,
-0.0233673528,
-0.030025797,
-0.0014897533,
-0.0295471027,
-0.0523391888,
0.0193102695,
-0.0567373745,
-0.000921738,
-0.0584746636,
-0.0329020657,
-0.0253494941,
0.0420545116,
0.0392219611,
0.0166100375,
0.0065849954,
-0.0062442026,
-0.0286059231,
0.0120558664,
-0.0006500402,
-0.0171831958,
0.0017682075,
-0.0093530817,
0.0163280871,
-0.0080865705,
-0.0282205548,
-0.0507843234,
-0.0465653948,
-0.0384225585,
-0.0315688811,
0.01617717,
-0.0329394676,
-0.0164431799,
0.0090103438,
0.0014806747,
0.0855696127,
-0.0545934997,
0.0084978612,
-0.0399648622,
0.0785963014,
0.0618907772,
-0.0212270208,
0.0224978011,
-0.0213164166,
0.0009564735,
0.0666222647,
-0.0146010322,
0.0462199561,
-0.0029369041,
-0.0283043198,
-0.0014938711,
0.000287225,
-0.0075129303,
-0.0144782206,
0.0355582647,
-0.0876487866,
-0.0080161998,
0.0992723331,
0.0150572211,
-0.0498165973,
-0.0326670185,
-0.0040960768,
0.0196838602,
0.006123112,
-0.0036124645,
-0.0871839374,
-0.0571425073,
0.0235696919,
-0.0154363019,
-0.002804029,
0.017048059,
-0.0212121122,
-0.0586113743,
0.0329115614,
0.0221096687,
-0.0081980499,
-0.0341373757,
0.0097224582,
0.0137140257,
0.0049855476,
-0.0215614792,
-0.002219354,
-0.0192886982,
-0.0032934207,
-0.0088222139,
-0.0322337784,
0.0041254256,
0.0011949433,
-0.0211795494,
0.0096712131,
0.0887148529,
0.0444097742,
-0.0216866061,
-0.0331142172,
0.0636452809,
-0.0200391859,
-0.0346145853,
0.033280652,
0.0192859787,
-0.0509065464,
0.0036392091,
0.0034425233,
0.0728656352,
-0.0413452424,
-0.0008456381,
0.0529805236,
0.0390993729,
-0.0104290778,
-0.0810759068,
-0.050421793,
0.0126847802,
-0.0008439296,
0.0996012539,
0.0276896395,
-0.0517928638,
-0.066139698,
-0.0213662516,
0.0265065376,
-0.0430230163,
-0.0431857333,
0.0128725329,
0.0163583066,
-0.0213392936,
-0.0619209968,
-0.0350246169,
-0.0187001061,
-0.0230981372,
-0.0193649493,
-0.0024927619,
-0.0076483889,
-0.011118331,
-0.0115081696,
0.0091200061,
-0.055746153,
0.0097543355,
-0.0690348148,
0.0382323265,
0.0074814758,
-0.0595489852,
-0.0332962796,
0.0402329937,
-0.1225815564,
-0.0266424082,
0.0062532155,
-0.0024632746,
0.0125309033,
0.0079932055,
-0.0513484925,
-0.0244467612,
0.0564000383,
0.0412112735,
-0.0325098895,
0.0291716233,
0.0203039963,
-0.0190670621,
-0.0270600412,
0.0307446253,
-0.0139393779,
0.0422769785,
0.0031057093,
0.0073637557,
-0.0228896253,
-0.0478852168,
0.0083070202,
-0.0012810034,
0.0230560452,
-0.0164811946,
0.0259997807,
-0.0413677022,
0.0060724239,
0.0302417688,
0.0016875619,
-0.0589876883,
0.0292662699,
0.0270262249,
-0.0108810039,
-0.0105748735,
0.0180661548,
-0.0126750525,
0.0021215982,
-0.0298206154,
0.003298776,
0.0026686639,
0.0220668186,
0.0074275588,
-0.0532212555,
0.0151540758,
0.0569328405,
-0.0126905991,
0.0191225018,
0.0164315868,
0.054910142,
0.0241291076,
-0.0569495074,
0.0126993386,
0.0247712769,
-0.0715292096,
-0.0077976189,
-0.0644094646,
0.03300073,
0.0744559392,
-0.0080797886,
0.0342620201,
-0.0436751619,
-0.0239786915,
-0.040814545,
0.0065169954,
0.0228045937,
0.0184970256,
-0.00514215,
0.0081429891,
-0.0363008268,
0.0079378728,
0.0569175668,
0.0407152101,
0.034580674,
0.037697643,
-0.0312310457,
-0.0515073203,
-0.0249461979,
0.0138822095,
-0.0021500031,
-0.0170970373,
0.0236088112,
-0.0164342336,
-0.0402532667,
0.0442897715,
0.0122698201,
-0.003724288,
-0.0050785807,
0.0026572393,
0.0499906801,
-0.037131235,
0.0198325347,
-0.0028001242,
-0.0007253992,
-0.0178862605,
-0.0398881473,
-0.0147874188,
-6.133917602e-33,
-0.0038842007,
-0.0640417337,
-0.0302987378,
0.011191139,
0.0050812638,
0.0330635011,
-0.0124211246,
-0.0081340633,
0.0272711534,
0.0330283567,
-0.0195104945,
0.0431373268,
0.0201308038,
0.033172857,
-0.0355212279,
-0.0184223205,
0.0681989938,
-0.040280655,
-0.0266111027,
0.0235904194,
-0.0137198484,
0.0198078305,
0.0467045456,
-0.0607751757,
-0.0061313887,
-0.026694091,
-0.0434395596,
-0.0106803114,
-0.036914181,
0.0584392957,
-0.026360685,
0.0150362691,
0.0264007449,
0.0095716584,
-0.0085741207,
0.0840246305,
-0.040678896,
0.0070680669,
-0.0424142107,
-0.0134012643,
-0.0274602324,
-0.0585037805,
0.0330558084,
-0.0234780014,
0.0074647921,
0.0016685515,
0.045434244,
-0.0228625219,
0.0197993703,
-0.0368391797,
-0.0421938188,
0.0433382168,
-0.0023579127,
-0.00308083,
0.0128797852,
0.0428903997,
-0.0117500573,
0.0209419709,
-0.0397554599,
0.0075129657,
0.0063229287,
0.0360194445,
0.0177426152,
-0.0150234737,
-0.0319671966,
0.019184934,
0.0261754747,
-0.0028482573,
-0.0525734015,
-0.0426624008,
0.0020290255,
-0.0063080559,
0.0647048876,
0.0608692057,
0.0390953943,
0.0072538112,
-0.052730564,
0.0044696988,
0.0169800986,
0.0205296744,
0.0512647182,
0.0080057401,
-0.0571166016,
0.0232292321,
0.0002202225,
-0.059653122,
-0.018405294,
0.015014655,
0.0417685099,
0.045652248,
-0.0034710593,
-0.0385215431,
0.0224671867,
-0.0339842588,
0.0175581556,
0.0318682268,
-0.0277257804,
-0.0028926572,
0.0192825235,
0.0442807376,
-0.0406421907,
0.0138213746,
0.0541588627,
0.0269702766,
-0.008699188,
-0.0069160787,
0.0441047065,
0.0097062839,
-0.07467895,
0.0112294219,
-0.0216719825,
0.0329004563,
-0.0175825432,
0.0262287837,
0.0214703586,
-0.0360671505,
-0.000841452,
0.0433625616,
0.0072322683,
0.0136757558,
-0.0379913487,
-0.0132153928,
-0.0246338602,
0.0283778813,
-0.0267878752,
0.017865466,
-0.0225718953,
0.0072693345,
0.0286888052,
-0.06711483,
0.0352050811,
0.0176168606,
2.578e-7,
0.0282627419,
0.0065641277,
0.0386088677,
0.0077912314,
0.0459920205,
0.0412612632,
0.0135022998,
0.0402338691,
-0.0167010147,
0.0298132412,
0.0119144544,
0.0301357023,
0.0799370632,
-0.0190617032,
-0.108987309,
0.0206378233,
-0.0893144533,
0.0098649925,
-0.0626497716,
-0.055900462,
0.0350926369,
0.0963318795,
0.0153070912,
-0.0133142518,
0.0499658585,
-0.0907239094,
0.0509140193,
-0.0063403533,
0.0248078555,
0.0230331831,
0.0554143675,
0.0213661212,
-0.0017245449,
-0.0093333432,
-0.0016317025,
0.0109901829,
0.0481387079,
0.0872764364,
0.016675055,
0.0108868899,
-0.0060854708,
0.0168037582,
0.0166742206,
-0.0556968451,
0.0704659075,
-0.0249164961,
-0.0008495952,
-0.0624504201,
-0.0010764109,
-0.0285059158,
0.0451976098,
-0.0317644328,
-0.0128102582,
-0.0049881376,
0.0430311188,
-0.0117680971,
-0.015900664,
-0.074179545,
-0.0341095626,
-0.019458469,
-0.0565569662,
0.0228828546,
-0.0994551629,
0.0219063144,
0.0230668485,
-0.0728366226,
0.0137218544,
2.471867862e-34,
0.0297110789,
-0.0225451365,
-0.0197901055,
0.0063706017,
0.0257845018,
0.0005040258,
-0.0094080372,
-0.0183356758,
-0.0086205015,
-0.0577334426,
0.001281132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08901v1 | Welfare Diplomacy: Benchmarking Language Model Cooperation | 2023-10-13T07:15:32 | 2023-10-13T07:15:32 | Gabriel Mukobi, Hannah Erlebach, Niklas Lauffer, Lewis Hammond, Alan Chan, Jesse Clifton | cs.MA | cs.MA, cs.AI, cs.CL | The growing capabilities and increasingly widespread deployment of AI systems
necessitate robust benchmarks for measuring their cooperative capabilities.
Unfortunately, most multi-agent benchmarks are either zero-sum or purely
cooperative, providing limited opportunities for such measurements. We
introduce a general-sum variant of the zero-sum board game Diplomacy -- called
Welfare Diplomacy -- in which players must balance investing in military
conquest and domestic welfare. We argue that Welfare Diplomacy facilitates both
a clearer assessment of and stronger training incentives for cooperative
capabilities. Our contributions are: (1) proposing the Welfare Diplomacy rules
and implementing them via an open-source Diplomacy engine; (2) constructing
baseline agents using zero-shot prompted language models; and (3) conducting
experiments where we find that baselines using state-of-the-art models attain
high social welfare but are exploitable. Our work aims to promote societal
safety by aiding researchers in developing and assessing multi-agent AI
systems. Code to evaluate Welfare Diplomacy and reproduce our experiments is
available at https://github.com/mukobi/welfare-diplomacy. | [
0.0473279245,
0.1098859683,
-0.0224718563,
0.0262606889,
-0.0657499805,
-0.0238667186,
0.0345622636,
-0.013701478,
0.0154296411,
0.0033061085,
-0.0039377599,
-0.0311768278,
0.0182338972,
0.0431472287,
0.013116465,
-0.0038375775,
0.0402129963,
-0.0213994607,
0.0419730395,
-0.017743811,
-0.0017416708,
-0.0252782404,
-0.0308729112,
0.0580846667,
-0.0193199757,
0.0188960228,
-0.0335649513,
-0.0430481918,
0.015856741,
-0.0126301255,
-0.0092157573,
0.0113337878,
0.0088426322,
-0.0049991556,
0.000001992,
-0.0492843576,
0.002752902,
-0.0068746489,
0.019047901,
-0.0302766096,
0.0865586326,
-0.0100201517,
-0.0136296572,
0.0190498866,
-0.0719098151,
-0.000136054,
0.0218079481,
-0.0252812058,
0.0645842329,
0.0588263646,
0.0282711461,
0.0298535824,
0.0160043128,
-0.0121414,
-0.0723368376,
-0.0777891874,
0.0079719005,
-0.0246700179,
-0.0056156372,
-0.0189715195,
0.0223347805,
0.036822252,
-0.0044473438,
-0.0182247125,
-0.036505077,
0.0468612351,
-0.020674957,
-0.0103453081,
-0.0271525849,
0.0320835672,
0.0583059266,
0.0021979134,
0.00944045,
0.0253586769,
0.0546480976,
-0.0052873739,
0.0045913393,
0.0401552804,
0.0201445743,
-0.0140334154,
0.0456809998,
0.0190645531,
0.0027608362,
0.0042804377,
0.0054209605,
0.0985526219,
-0.031107733,
-0.0141878659,
-0.0015909037,
0.003452406,
0.0059064371,
-0.0704180449,
-0.0144191412,
0.0535379946,
-0.0597756095,
0.0074823108,
-0.051706966,
-0.0203455072,
0.0148262819,
-0.0257504918,
0.0120298648,
0.016187571,
0.0154238474,
0.0378131941,
0.0402341671,
0.024666341,
0.0392832458,
0.0362137333,
0.0139489891,
-0.009486977,
-0.0506847315,
-0.0059812726,
-0.0583034754,
0.0362223908,
0.0155589851,
-0.0041819373,
-0.0143258851,
0.0015946272,
-0.0911489725,
0.0778570548,
-0.0135835698,
0.0071818782,
-0.0325118452,
-0.0216729417,
-0.0289422572,
-0.0152628878,
-0.0622289404,
0.0133349774,
-0.0010633395,
-0.0848604366,
-0.0247693956,
-0.0126615148,
-0.016433442,
-0.0196475238,
0.0262061786,
0.0836906731,
0.0234460458,
-0.0320316851,
0.0233890973,
-0.0261809789,
0.0270310547,
-0.0432500653,
-0.0212165043,
-0.0810921565,
0.0173249841,
-0.0178977791,
0.0068002772,
-0.0649784282,
-0.0009426733,
-0.0392872356,
-0.0442174226,
0.0688388348,
0.0025947299,
0.0495131277,
0.0058494597,
0.0048973756,
-0.0472110957,
0.0764812157,
0.0803232938,
-0.0067677312,
0.0491772965,
0.0305222012,
0.0385411121,
0.0368151367,
-0.0117062852,
0.0340347812,
0.0025479549,
-0.0043103043,
0.0214605797,
0.0259209257,
-0.0353837647,
0.0101125697,
0.0079767536,
-0.0322588459,
0.0777349621,
0.0863199383,
-0.0340844505,
0.0130042061,
0.0193587523,
0.0308640394,
-0.0209286604,
-0.0280167423,
-0.0460456461,
-0.0011433768,
-0.0335068367,
-0.0227012262,
-0.0196608137,
0.0318648703,
-0.0153667768,
-0.0288263746,
0.0430914052,
-0.0450678691,
0.0737336576,
0.032734409,
0.0291675292,
-0.0140980901,
-0.0497587807,
-0.0337514021,
0.0318415985,
-0.0552906767,
-0.0002594728,
-0.0845313221,
0.0007557675,
0.0252852514,
0.0531336591,
-0.0383906439,
-0.0132522043,
-0.0133726457,
0.009029543,
0.040707197,
0.060259562,
-0.0294164829,
0.0580256619,
-0.0131750498,
-0.0318526104,
-0.0065927822,
0.028391052,
0.0462394394,
0.0088441903,
-0.0039685867,
-0.0354719497,
0.0104028983,
-0.0125712184,
0.0271604713,
0.0325271003,
0.0177769512,
-0.0197217017,
0.0215411037,
0.0396826454,
0.0174335912,
-0.0541415326,
0.0198587906,
0.0327670239,
-0.0230932962,
-0.0173575133,
0.0183751751,
0.017145548,
0.0670620874,
0.0153949391,
-0.0201582462,
-0.001305873,
0.0596353784,
-0.0014511022,
0.0117874742,
0.0716872886,
-0.0035131497,
0.0092960615,
0.0178385936,
0.032141801,
-0.0748790056,
-0.0167141128,
-0.0231855977,
0.0176020227,
0.0060077207,
-0.0436931066,
-0.015428083,
-0.0099570882,
0.0296483226,
-0.0273356661,
-0.0021973611,
0.0422779843,
-0.0082351044,
0.0201966036,
0.0803893283,
0.0177250039,
-0.0286884755,
-0.0462383516,
-0.0971491337,
0.0012108573,
-0.032073088,
-0.0025936496,
0.0119031053,
-0.0302957129,
0.0035201339,
0.0520653091,
-0.0262968652,
0.0401447564,
0.0148330079,
0.0279829558,
0.0110943587,
0.0300013218,
-0.0385985002,
-0.0316157937,
0.0222894624,
-0.024228707,
-0.0044340771,
0.025406342,
0.0143368971,
-0.0311802775,
0.016895188,
-0.0434169918,
0.0331911109,
-0.0303244274,
-0.0944263861,
0.042385038,
-0.0147457439,
-0.0390356369,
0.0621478744,
0.0083017666,
0.0488009043,
0.108569026,
-0.0132170552,
-0.0621828251,
0.0174035504,
-0.0176546052,
-0.0268241968,
-0.057912346,
-0.0308092125,
-0.0084557775,
0.0464712232,
-0.0057497653,
0.0104768137,
-0.0580050424,
0.0232970119,
-0.0250442103,
-0.0476169325,
-0.0120547321,
-0.0328886658,
0.0057000057,
0.0191944111,
-0.0371512286,
-0.0045555984,
0.0738813952,
-0.008703216,
-0.0031628686,
0.0286900811,
-0.0088105351,
-0.0340968668,
0.0650296286,
-0.0243044924,
-0.0042485795,
-0.0014960066,
0.0077225314,
-0.0422254391,
-0.0415637158,
0.0265915748,
-0.0296773314,
-0.006385393,
-0.0620205626,
-0.0045181336,
-0.0033301993,
-0.0124719152,
-0.0165639836,
-0.0172583908,
-0.0418658443,
0.0346125029,
0.0267777219,
-0.0282970872,
-0.009629162,
-0.0097565195,
0.0745375156,
0.0081079165,
0.0306416024,
-0.0127347112,
-0.044383496,
-0.0624330975,
0.0308839064,
0.0190537367,
-0.0004980264,
-0.0231005158,
0.0120783662,
0.0253165979,
0.0133202104,
0.0017328021,
-0.004012133,
-0.0093957186,
0.0283501465,
-0.0013923,
0.0235790256,
0.0232113544,
0.0206114613,
-0.0241108164,
-0.0090926448,
0.0713067651,
0.0127933789,
-0.0135347871,
0.0355023593,
-0.007024786,
0.0205547903,
0.011108377,
-0.0030812901,
-0.0678381398,
-0.0026797431,
0.0103622889,
-0.0085136136,
-0.0295215789,
-0.0538575649,
-0.0024404994,
-0.1218849346,
-0.0003619753,
-0.0113004567,
-0.016857855,
-0.0161099546,
-0.0288810655,
0.00234286,
-0.0096540935,
-0.0425439924,
-0.01156912,
0.059311647,
-0.01673829,
-0.0102933357,
0.0182321034,
0.0136594009,
-0.0100366464,
-0.0695457682,
0.0898794606,
0.0852684677,
0.0611223765,
-0.0242381152,
-0.0175084267,
-0.012189365,
0.0612340011,
-0.0024348469,
0.0427693054,
0.0431288779,
-0.0009495739,
-0.0120247928,
0.0455026068,
-0.0230433922,
-0.0078543881,
0.0098455399,
0.061844036,
0.0239944868,
-0.0129153915,
-0.0353474468,
0.0294608101,
0.0137288403,
0.0688859597,
0.0545063652,
-0.0238822307,
-0.034483172,
-0.0311208311,
-0.0125828134,
-0.0165733341,
-0.0702061877,
-0.0679647624,
-0.0046162126,
0.038301643,
-0.0703592226,
-0.0582314245,
-0.1058593392,
0.0139565449,
-0.0165399257,
0.0190472417,
-0.0128763504,
0.0039259982,
0.0636226237,
0.0249466058,
-0.0092977667,
-0.0295226425,
0.0205216259,
-0.046539437,
-0.0342830941,
-0.041434221,
-0.0357992537,
0.0066399542,
-0.001124643,
-0.0168732852,
-0.0706685558,
0.0198362544,
0.0508411974,
0.0188424643,
-0.0043503032,
-0.008830497,
-0.0091605457,
0.013959595,
0.0488927215,
-0.0218331534,
0.0349099264,
0.0654346719,
-0.0593067184,
0.0287671424,
0.0387251265,
-0.0484169088,
-0.0036853703,
0.019553164,
0.0387573391,
-0.0166508388,
-0.0126523161,
0.025068922,
-0.0249050856,
0.0037178791,
-0.0199776441,
-0.0183703844,
0.0076847658,
-0.0114421351,
-0.0369314551,
-0.0212510135,
-0.0187025145,
-0.0174991861,
-0.005720275,
-0.0031599069,
0.0490284711,
0.0363733657,
-0.0227058679,
0.0086573195,
0.0304899365,
0.0409114063,
-0.0374597758,
0.0571056902,
0.0233733598,
0.0077012395,
-0.0044475691,
0.0344403386,
-0.0122394599,
0.0139793791,
0.0172443055,
0.0240004603,
0.0227376837,
-0.0155925145,
0.0186603926,
0.0492062941,
-0.0395447277,
-0.0776817501,
0.0769669712,
0.0773427859,
0.0819659159,
0.0286686625,
0.0440444574,
-0.039195627,
0.0173890814,
-0.0070965877,
-0.02882329,
-0.0110103684,
-0.099353075,
-0.0205962677,
0.0181257203,
0.0132344849,
0.0519574769,
0.057522431,
-0.0538857505,
0.0805506259,
0.0175885744,
0.0222594272,
-0.0042803194,
-0.0616711937,
0.0101898247,
0.0168220308,
-0.0506119505,
0.0340336077,
-0.0615476929,
-0.0387736857,
-0.0433333851,
0.0671429038,
-0.002699937,
0.0060104458,
0.0087238671,
0.0178406201,
-0.0072595421,
0.027891485,
-0.0771546811,
0.0030408553,
-0.0493634939,
-0.0100525636,
-0.0149202161,
-5.67949022e-33,
0.0063328454,
-0.0286885239,
0.0420654565,
0.0083072623,
-0.0046682758,
-0.0362218283,
-0.0310019255,
0.0234818235,
-0.0591880977,
0.016219344,
-0.0107834563,
-0.0093522565,
0.0146121364,
-0.04430319,
-0.0033255278,
0.0081004659,
-0.0094503751,
-0.0069860225,
-0.0606328472,
0.0136596337,
-0.0119454134,
-0.0155183682,
0.027460685,
-0.0642585158,
0.045189213,
0.0119519476,
-0.0319840424,
0.0307154004,
-0.0139422817,
-0.0003564121,
0.0259210318,
0.0095519684,
0.0104708951,
-0.0186266024,
0.0178486221,
0.00612118,
0.005992807,
-0.0145728681,
-0.0176050141,
-0.0411783308,
-0.0200622994,
-0.0507319756,
-0.0320664458,
0.0045655952,
-0.0538777784,
0.0000012558,
0.0143939042,
-0.0167248305,
0.0284575298,
0.0404940918,
-0.0505326167,
0.0027165194,
-0.0668048635,
-0.0397320688,
0.0004852728,
0.0256955493,
0.0198407769,
0.0085664578,
0.000177485,
0.0699032694,
-0.014229456,
-0.0040940573,
0.0530553088,
-0.0410940088,
0.0267008357,
0.0286427252,
0.0014189138,
0.0586246736,
-0.001676303,
-0.0764668956,
0.0566350929,
0.0248226766,
0.059691146,
0.0624050945,
-0.0031317146,
-0.0230739471,
-0.0263286252,
0.0149261905,
0.0649743527,
0.0449530296,
-0.0141775589,
-0.0012327454,
-0.0615357421,
-0.0127902003,
-0.0409589112,
-0.0458390824,
-0.0174036007,
-0.0352921002,
0.0225910228,
0.0109165497,
-0.0158576202,
-0.0261171274,
0.0251124073,
-0.029910963,
0.0056159105,
0.0405291207,
0.0165854972,
0.0301761162,
-0.0184785705,
-0.0229078922,
-0.0415744707,
-0.0212375037,
-0.0184792057,
0.0049206223,
0.0636886805,
0.0374953225,
0.0029376037,
0.0214973483,
0.0150407916,
-0.0120676002,
-0.0373749509,
0.0330509618,
0.0183922108,
-0.0504657701,
0.0021543193,
-0.0187337715,
-0.0008074878,
-0.0211274326,
0.0095076635,
-0.0534433089,
-0.050351873,
0.0373945907,
-0.0470758341,
-0.007461871,
-0.0203094613,
-0.0137822591,
-0.070656687,
0.0483231582,
0.0215407275,
0.0193982553,
-0.050860133,
-0.0932147205,
2.695e-7,
-0.0354356952,
0.0493638925,
0.0162816122,
0.0599056892,
-0.0524090603,
0.0868380219,
-0.0496217683,
0.0819346085,
-0.0159537774,
0.0005536971,
0.0254476722,
0.0410123989,
0.0483449921,
0.0351994112,
-0.0384563617,
0.0046753446,
-0.0317136198,
-0.0228816774,
-0.0453354791,
-0.0108077498,
0.0467996374,
-0.0254041422,
0.0503609814,
0.004810181,
-0.007693042,
-0.0277138185,
-0.005396449,
-0.0603684187,
0.0036748268,
0.0267960113,
-0.0315363333,
-0.0269592274,
-0.0148574254,
0.0190144125,
0.019730188,
0.0171683505,
-0.030284632,
0.0842504427,
-0.0171118062,
-0.0296930633,
-0.0290428028,
-0.0180197917,
-0.0166775286,
-0.0088471463,
0.0367078558,
-0.0274631958,
-0.0301660411,
-0.0150070582,
0.0217232332,
0.026831219,
-0.0242486261,
-0.0035330339,
-0.033742629,
-0.0218067728,
0.0174765661,
-0.003989954,
0.0225572698,
-0.0237204321,
-0.0107857678,
-0.0393302701,
-0.0013948496,
-0.0829209611,
0.0095667802,
0.0588086918,
-0.0323669277,
-0.0056584515,
0.024228137,
2.210224171e-34,
-0.0314879417,
-0.0219933596,
0.0260757357,
-0.0076670633,
0.093822062,
0.0251927543,
-0.0321832485,
0.0104415966,
0.0331786573,
-0.0110860635,
-0.005528139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08899v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08899v2 | Exploration with Principles for Diverse AI Supervision | 2023-10-13T07:03:39 | 2023-11-23T06:08:59 | Hao Liu, Matei Zaharia, Pieter Abbeel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Training large transformers using next-token prediction has given rise to
groundbreaking advancements in AI. While this generative AI approach has
produced impressive results, it heavily leans on human supervision. Even
state-of-the-art AI models like ChatGPT depend on fine-tuning through human
demonstrations, demanding extensive human input and domain expertise. This
strong reliance on human oversight poses a significant hurdle to the
advancement of AI innovation. To address this limitation, we propose a novel
paradigm termed Exploratory AI (EAI) aimed at autonomously generating
high-quality training data. Drawing inspiration from unsupervised reinforcement
learning (RL) pretraining, EAI achieves exploration within the natural language
space. We accomplish this by harnessing large language models to assess the
novelty of generated content. Our approach employs two key components: an actor
that generates novel content following exploration principles and a critic that
evaluates the generated content, offering critiques to guide the actor.
Empirical evaluations demonstrate that EAI significantly boosts model
performance on complex reasoning tasks, addressing the limitations of
human-intensive supervision. | [
0.0544555485,
0.0432999656,
-0.0112920692,
-0.0006805663,
-0.0227139946,
0.0035260178,
-0.026192328,
-0.0264459644,
0.0030450083,
-0.0293007251,
-0.0239000451,
-0.0257447306,
-0.0664538741,
0.0679732189,
0.0011561598,
-0.0521270074,
0.0244757496,
-0.0574015342,
0.0301807914,
0.0158463307,
-0.0322091207,
-0.0169758759,
-0.0143237785,
0.0458066911,
-0.0394914672,
0.0090399133,
-0.0463609807,
-0.0339512639,
0.0149559658,
-0.0332262963,
-0.0116145918,
0.0450002439,
0.0501535274,
0.0589778647,
0.0000019022,
-0.0604400933,
-0.0264490526,
-0.0066695651,
-0.0025131255,
-0.039680317,
0.033316642,
0.0212289002,
-0.0033825447,
0.0033270896,
-0.0684007779,
-0.0216311216,
0.0455162264,
0.0745505542,
0.0692226887,
0.097038582,
0.0010438993,
-0.0109575372,
-0.0117566586,
-0.0287519153,
0.0161013063,
-0.019018095,
0.0074267397,
-0.0067674001,
0.0363101736,
0.0262095425,
-0.038622763,
0.0001772646,
0.0696503669,
-0.0358359292,
0.007390379,
0.0573545918,
0.0020527826,
-0.0220740661,
-0.028368013,
0.0639533475,
-0.012924266,
-0.0161009189,
-0.0217430461,
-0.0092512956,
0.0147721572,
0.023145346,
-0.020282995,
0.0392890014,
0.0037463605,
0.0204072502,
0.0105158724,
0.0037401116,
0.0140655255,
0.0156441834,
-0.015537316,
0.0445800796,
-0.0014921366,
-0.0573706664,
0.0353460982,
0.0213451739,
-0.0169892125,
-0.0482231937,
-0.0309429765,
0.0376767106,
-0.0829238296,
0.0209292341,
-0.0383047499,
-0.0308763385,
-0.0081734918,
0.0305964593,
0.0424839035,
0.0295401309,
-0.013034896,
0.0504090898,
-0.0008836782,
0.0443959162,
-0.028251145,
0.0641303807,
-0.0288698841,
0.0003326074,
-0.0685805604,
-0.02227409,
-0.0630027652,
0.039100714,
-0.0343844593,
-0.0153824715,
-0.01513403,
0.0433789529,
-0.0124491761,
0.0124032777,
0.0178511497,
0.0492500812,
-0.0379768647,
-0.0121789696,
-0.0685574487,
-0.0262474436,
-0.0672084987,
0.0099378303,
0.0282722525,
-0.0227611363,
-0.039452944,
0.0200531613,
-0.0153845511,
-0.0118581653,
0.0156755187,
0.1102682799,
-0.0225302018,
-0.0424108058,
-0.0202090703,
-0.0178221092,
0.0112354578,
-0.0538323931,
0.0544991568,
-0.0543259494,
0.0268359594,
-0.024105154,
-0.0366177075,
-0.0140030682,
-0.0020853968,
0.0228236355,
0.0137805054,
0.0422547832,
-0.0101481192,
0.0095996447,
0.0148260286,
0.0049015847,
-0.0356782079,
0.0623197295,
0.0067020226,
0.0189971738,
0.0090811877,
0.0257828329,
0.0928859413,
0.0179385357,
0.0072189034,
-0.0041175778,
-0.0035291009,
-0.0010872622,
-0.0355954319,
0.0522139147,
-0.0020927296,
0.0615021437,
-0.0402683355,
0.0219084937,
0.0378826372,
0.0478624068,
-0.0144907441,
0.0291919727,
0.0868853033,
-0.0034566747,
0.0078366157,
0.0060409815,
-0.0292372573,
0.0379327945,
0.0267842095,
-0.0067366939,
-0.0109075941,
-0.0084504476,
-0.0249820556,
-0.053996928,
0.0400877222,
0.0002697214,
0.02667417,
-0.0251789689,
0.0320438892,
0.0642112494,
-0.0368211903,
-0.0259731635,
0.0270216353,
-0.0334075056,
0.0040200069,
-0.0766997486,
0.0461454764,
0.0646165609,
0.0629494414,
-0.0482357554,
-0.0206730999,
-0.0228916034,
0.0119510582,
0.0683121532,
0.0441711098,
-0.0223833639,
-0.0140078133,
-0.0156574566,
-0.0249692891,
-0.073550716,
0.0077812299,
0.0529904217,
0.0483389087,
0.0073435558,
-0.0145612583,
-0.0408490263,
-0.0385492072,
0.0535132587,
-0.0303499904,
-0.0477257445,
0.0267172866,
-0.0076554907,
-0.0017708089,
0.0103295306,
-0.016962342,
0.0125849983,
0.0271656718,
-0.0179282464,
-0.0709815249,
0.0209324788,
-0.0395757891,
0.0062892474,
0.0048449063,
-0.1035917252,
-0.0244656596,
0.0077781859,
-0.0293516684,
-0.0355941765,
0.0290018152,
-0.0332913697,
0.0441324562,
-0.0517029464,
0.0022378659,
-0.0065588197,
-0.0169610716,
-0.0244125407,
0.0958261788,
0.0003775006,
-0.0131173162,
0.0261481479,
0.0059668799,
0.005003972,
-0.0242784638,
-0.0196102932,
-0.006129168,
-0.0035136179,
0.0178477634,
0.049617406,
0.0430489033,
-0.0469622612,
-0.0301313251,
-0.0625188723,
-0.0052507627,
-0.0384619944,
0.0037795459,
0.0152719198,
0.0038852666,
-0.0067395931,
-0.0266269222,
-0.0128330234,
-0.0459366851,
0.0366768241,
-0.0085852975,
0.0384353399,
0.0415498801,
0.0127776247,
-0.0127765425,
0.0118505573,
0.0003655171,
0.0489962809,
0.0280823819,
0.0547527298,
-0.0541982129,
-0.0119272666,
-0.0060001803,
0.0536587238,
-0.0357960016,
-0.0334708244,
0.0528399982,
-0.0331832878,
0.018589329,
0.0332706161,
0.0111579653,
0.055273436,
0.043255154,
0.0059200097,
-0.0417760536,
0.0445589349,
-0.0393965058,
-0.0065953429,
-0.0324499235,
0.0509781316,
0.0376125649,
0.0501332246,
-0.031473279,
-0.0045971284,
-0.0647085011,
0.054349836,
-0.0056423959,
-0.0794811547,
-0.0030061263,
-0.0265071131,
-0.0137553038,
0.0120663159,
-0.0259229634,
-0.0288555622,
0.1020572409,
0.0374580249,
-0.0049322047,
-0.0599323176,
0.0009444723,
-0.0379102677,
0.0659783781,
0.0040843971,
0.0274468269,
0.0039111045,
-0.0111475941,
-0.0580959395,
0.042795226,
0.0042114309,
-0.0010002645,
0.0371087119,
-0.0300223101,
-0.0092640407,
0.0506873652,
-0.0642232373,
-0.0785593241,
-0.0340645164,
0.0055062235,
-0.0108834393,
0.0541459993,
-0.0294302106,
-0.0546630509,
-0.0272081364,
0.0305626933,
0.0458789617,
-0.0003627373,
-0.0358288102,
-0.0238960944,
-0.0106154205,
0.0423166305,
0.0144537622,
0.0287477281,
-0.0538702272,
0.0457035899,
0.0529232919,
-0.0079394383,
-0.0309398081,
-0.0231281165,
0.0285476781,
-0.035097342,
-0.0287544224,
0.0134335645,
0.0185987074,
0.0328076817,
-0.0309320465,
-0.0414673351,
0.0802852288,
0.032087896,
-0.0157226026,
0.0088066133,
-0.0081846463,
0.029766785,
0.0347129144,
0.0690011457,
-0.0712642148,
0.004727107,
-0.0261930227,
0.0202107932,
-0.0191810746,
-0.0392852239,
-0.0104916245,
-0.1387941986,
0.0374405086,
-0.0311713126,
-0.0536201708,
-0.0010880785,
-0.0292394832,
-0.0016823163,
-0.0147051122,
-0.0332181789,
0.0146460589,
0.0029605953,
-0.0027021002,
0.0150219332,
0.0260083769,
-0.053048458,
0.0138574149,
-0.0321772844,
0.0238623265,
0.0641567782,
0.0012972164,
-0.0097851809,
0.000709704,
-0.013614269,
0.0167694371,
0.0355283916,
0.0228700228,
0.0621999837,
-0.0003781618,
-0.0074595106,
-0.010843141,
0.063419424,
0.0130960969,
-0.0302796476,
-0.0101818824,
0.0746980533,
-0.0333410576,
-0.0250173975,
-0.0220405646,
-0.0157402139,
0.0564578474,
0.0533955432,
-0.0055785901,
-0.0741700232,
-0.051962208,
-0.0177124068,
-0.0184042938,
-0.073653169,
-0.0347111449,
0.0124024618,
0.0411362052,
-0.0250782818,
-0.0761794075,
-0.0577125102,
0.0244984739,
0.0398477986,
0.015032392,
-0.0603043847,
-0.0334181264,
0.0220811721,
0.000938769,
0.021217946,
-0.0111665046,
-0.0249005072,
-0.0247257501,
-0.021264879,
-0.0078704311,
-0.0647263452,
-0.0299293846,
0.0191920623,
-0.0596403815,
-0.0531825349,
0.0084809978,
0.0759971589,
0.0208323281,
0.0628163517,
-0.0197795108,
-0.0222475436,
0.0732510313,
0.0369885415,
-0.0176904909,
-0.0090853842,
0.0221623164,
0.0196052175,
0.0138476742,
0.0269715153,
-0.0343892463,
0.0369218923,
0.0160146672,
0.0116610648,
-0.0006423889,
0.0106821693,
0.0546414182,
-0.0323207267,
0.0238260888,
-0.0264583956,
0.0252171457,
-0.0442941003,
-0.00929124,
-0.0278846044,
-0.0342459343,
-0.0459617116,
0.0038710325,
0.0028544723,
0.0136345988,
0.0024322735,
0.0408026241,
0.0000900759,
0.0424908325,
-0.0397280939,
-0.0145192491,
0.0460876562,
-0.0063507268,
-0.0006494385,
0.0153482025,
0.0086136153,
0.0107780853,
-0.0077837831,
0.0422093086,
-0.0064570215,
0.0638792068,
0.0594736226,
-0.0230223555,
-0.012920564,
0.0165189672,
-0.0953490287,
-0.0606113411,
-0.0137692997,
0.0867284015,
0.0327493474,
-0.0012423696,
-0.0067971158,
-0.0587355122,
0.0111601669,
0.0342902355,
-0.0024924162,
0.0010691896,
-0.0307528879,
0.0102464445,
0.0202596392,
-0.0007650307,
-0.0012058131,
0.0463725962,
-0.0224923845,
0.0642086416,
-0.0188800897,
0.0335746408,
-0.0575161427,
-0.0104167676,
0.020652473,
-0.0013949897,
0.0150777604,
0.0255197827,
-0.0296942145,
-0.0178388767,
-0.0159914624,
0.0510564968,
0.0066274828,
0.0225715637,
0.0760792345,
0.0532312058,
-0.0309736226,
-0.0204765573,
-0.0039263424,
-0.0477651544,
0.0079940641,
-0.0323781036,
-0.0193184726,
-5.884785533e-33,
0.0133098541,
-0.0353361592,
0.0483775996,
-0.0128244702,
-0.0094068693,
-0.0264196806,
-0.0231500547,
0.0063922419,
0.0090887146,
0.0425495915,
-0.0216757897,
0.0121150948,
-0.0113970861,
0.0274191704,
0.0106634982,
-0.0216741599,
0.0435283743,
-0.0031857132,
-0.0465976633,
0.0218679197,
0.0143757993,
0.0140918903,
0.0441185422,
-0.0771319643,
-0.0132893007,
-0.0002343687,
-0.0398037545,
0.0368705578,
-0.0091531537,
0.0667943135,
-0.0031568292,
0.0062007015,
0.009424557,
-0.078298986,
-0.0117025338,
-0.0056187431,
-0.0277030133,
-0.0622976907,
-0.0195547622,
-0.014462675,
-0.0711590275,
-0.0109240403,
0.0136643434,
-0.023622673,
-0.0060145063,
0.0260926988,
0.0205655452,
0.0156873837,
0.0292990208,
-0.0019199919,
-0.0705020428,
-0.0048311423,
-0.0259646848,
-0.0398929678,
0.0075632362,
0.0627208129,
0.0011028692,
-0.0268334392,
-0.0117623787,
0.0446931459,
0.0571597256,
-0.0366401523,
0.0328916982,
0.0114923138,
-0.0096868668,
0.0572304353,
0.0030297916,
0.0100739626,
-0.0588958338,
-0.0354643166,
0.0068269256,
0.0813715458,
-0.0114743877,
0.0315778628,
-0.0008047301,
0.0235398039,
-0.0286243595,
0.016819071,
-0.0181612577,
0.027141599,
0.0356863588,
0.0011658915,
-0.0516842492,
-0.0030823909,
-0.0419718996,
0.0122305742,
-0.0133125447,
-0.0419643484,
0.0328235291,
0.0509983115,
-0.0390975215,
-0.0588281713,
0.0032428671,
-0.0531669669,
0.035803061,
0.0177984405,
-0.070759967,
0.0269668885,
-0.0083638616,
-0.0168827102,
-0.0171535462,
-0.0443916917,
0.0587451272,
0.0049196356,
-0.0026296515,
0.0101452665,
0.024140697,
0.0579360649,
-0.0594542772,
0.0171039905,
-0.0252444036,
0.0612107851,
0.0229285471,
-0.0271782223,
0.0288244616,
0.0124627491,
-0.0380452983,
0.0396986343,
0.0336830951,
0.0136866234,
-0.0386385955,
0.0020539211,
0.0246485602,
-0.0159299821,
-0.0191501509,
0.0181783438,
-0.0154134054,
-0.0143170198,
-0.0139530599,
-0.0939468518,
-0.0048861033,
0.0396476872,
2.682e-7,
-0.0163119715,
0.0594624951,
0.0315682665,
0.0239292607,
0.0326589569,
0.0240412485,
-0.0080323294,
0.0155033628,
-0.0129975807,
-0.0270250402,
0.0371440016,
0.0473959818,
-0.0000287946,
0.027175894,
-0.094696261,
-0.0217471402,
-0.0893622413,
-0.0166025106,
-0.0594317839,
-0.0134744719,
0.0675175339,
0.079541631,
0.0175560322,
-0.0216760635,
0.011697839,
-0.0303808227,
0.0748593137,
-0.0006512011,
0.0151461279,
0.0155500639,
0.010507131,
0.0743329525,
0.0045803362,
0.0080998037,
-0.0108519793,
0.0340609215,
-0.0137656638,
0.0346393995,
0.0126533723,
-0.0194711927,
0.0196696259,
0.0228066389,
0.0107908426,
-0.0389318205,
0.0576108359,
-0.0877277851,
-0.0089722052,
-0.0283654593,
0.0224241707,
-0.0199234728,
0.0003018636,
-0.0463960022,
0.017500421,
0.0020508319,
-0.0042090705,
0.0214895532,
0.0079529239,
-0.0645196438,
-0.014599463,
-0.0113188159,
-0.0483890772,
0.0006069322,
-0.0230471361,
0.0096766194,
0.0153466007,
-0.0440993011,
0.0281210635,
2.211238495e-34,
0.031713739,
-0.0176703557,
0.0026565928,
-0.006710832,
0.0316898972,
0.0320308544,
0.0082650473,
-0.0138257574,
0.0256819259,
-0.039378494,
-0.048832342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08889v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08889v1 | PerturbScore: Connecting Discrete and Continuous Perturbations in NLP | 2023-10-13T06:50:15 | 2023-10-13T06:50:15 | Linyang Li, Ke Ren, Yunfan Shao, Pengyu Wang, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid development of neural network applications in NLP, model
robustness problem is gaining more attention. Different from computer vision,
the discrete nature of texts makes it more challenging to explore robustness in
NLP. Therefore, in this paper, we aim to connect discrete perturbations with
continuous perturbations, therefore we can use such connections as a bridge to
help understand discrete perturbations in NLP models. Specifically, we first
explore how to connect and measure the correlation between discrete
perturbations and continuous perturbations. Then we design a regression task as
a PerturbScore to learn the correlation automatically. Through experimental
results, we find that we can build a connection between discrete and continuous
perturbations and use the proposed PerturbScore to learn such correlation,
surpassing previous methods used in discrete perturbation measuring. Further,
the proposed PerturbScore can be well generalized to different datasets,
perturbation methods, indicating that we can use it as a powerful tool to study
model robustness in NLP. | [
-0.0047746729,
0.0924571753,
-0.0383302309,
0.0294599924,
-0.0322233774,
-0.0188976843,
-0.0344115533,
0.0248032492,
0.0060266675,
-0.0249272473,
0.0205210112,
-0.0046716286,
0.0068220273,
0.0155298021,
0.0236366559,
-0.0354529656,
0.0644711182,
0.007898516,
-0.0184294656,
0.0307538789,
0.0167014953,
-0.0302879363,
-0.0206142869,
0.0219426975,
-0.0574895591,
-0.0414666198,
0.0192545094,
0.0092983739,
0.0341627672,
-0.024270501,
0.0212206692,
0.0895201415,
-0.0033779556,
0.0161697026,
0.000001814,
-0.0349931009,
-0.0283026323,
0.0243633315,
-0.0134668611,
-0.019784769,
0.0318636708,
-0.0062525445,
-0.0219597183,
-0.0191350523,
-0.0479053222,
0.0434016809,
0.0425009951,
0.0609923601,
0.0470751077,
0.0675144941,
-0.0050592897,
-0.0057056923,
0.0279494133,
-0.0033132655,
-0.0352145657,
-0.0378013924,
0.026915662,
0.0019174912,
-0.0196673889,
0.0067929151,
-0.0239735935,
-0.0106561771,
0.0040355972,
0.0106756641,
-0.0154982768,
0.00816641,
-0.021062756,
-0.0328916684,
0.002537549,
0.0744440556,
-0.0488999113,
-0.0096489638,
-0.0119414981,
0.0050017042,
0.0265168399,
0.0196603164,
-0.0272481777,
-0.0562324598,
0.0429322012,
0.0102933571,
-0.0070781298,
-0.0138770426,
0.0261755381,
0.0258392822,
-0.0177508555,
0.0553079844,
-0.0068795807,
-0.0203205291,
-0.0330613777,
-0.0338494182,
-0.0670479909,
-0.0121074105,
-0.003614431,
0.0293713901,
-0.0196000431,
-0.0006812763,
-0.053455513,
-0.0664357096,
0.0045187613,
-0.087581329,
0.0591169707,
-0.0016850514,
-0.0158703625,
0.0405743048,
-0.0357672758,
0.0687187836,
0.0071781371,
0.0227668732,
0.0049914238,
0.0645741597,
-0.0594650097,
0.0068317801,
-0.0089601744,
0.0615170524,
-0.0079320688,
-0.0193294454,
-0.0652361661,
0.0258632284,
-0.0346735604,
0.0321651958,
-0.0154909827,
0.0243442897,
-0.0183824562,
0.0068476917,
-0.0190345589,
0.0130734611,
-0.0355249681,
0.0077779167,
-0.0113033494,
-0.0263702217,
-0.0070548337,
-0.0300481785,
0.009373798,
-0.0380318612,
-0.0152271716,
0.0877815783,
0.0374069735,
-0.0181243476,
-0.0463400073,
-0.0539343283,
-0.0308019947,
-0.0327738374,
-0.0344393291,
-0.0450090133,
-0.0081769498,
-0.0158727225,
-0.0035051543,
-0.0883855969,
0.0327512547,
-0.0100937597,
-0.0392905734,
0.1086360216,
-0.0236277655,
-0.0336374603,
-0.0664377809,
-0.0188552458,
0.0032329271,
0.0897739604,
0.0518911183,
-0.0450176597,
0.0822631419,
0.0251308233,
-0.0227117427,
0.0183262043,
0.0152638908,
-0.0226348508,
-0.093732208,
-0.037282005,
0.059531223,
-0.0356439017,
-0.0041773152,
0.0451578833,
-0.0139750345,
-0.0008433055,
0.0694969743,
0.0196030419,
0.0334404185,
0.0713050589,
-0.0290085748,
-0.0557673834,
-0.0030337076,
0.0770359561,
-0.0596874617,
-0.0199485477,
-0.0658461303,
-0.0192075595,
-0.0138558699,
0.0015863803,
-0.0089774486,
-0.0678738505,
-0.0229696371,
0.0047115977,
0.0493767299,
-0.0588999316,
0.0568953454,
-0.0098726386,
-0.0016819775,
0.0296207592,
0.0005118526,
-0.035227254,
0.0085531939,
-0.0347672142,
-0.0244615097,
0.030980939,
0.0401856378,
-0.0703305975,
0.0071369414,
-0.0033815331,
0.0014137366,
-0.0278818328,
0.035074342,
-0.0049729371,
0.0310565718,
-0.0076304507,
0.0125659183,
0.0112356022,
0.0749483034,
-0.0438703336,
0.0202007722,
0.0107124839,
0.0067223166,
0.001441226,
-0.0503505096,
0.0382371992,
-0.007062309,
-0.0054374235,
0.0343396552,
-0.0140847564,
-0.0040253932,
0.0372500308,
-0.0244413055,
0.0072765215,
0.02254311,
-0.0056899297,
-0.0133202104,
0.0112303318,
0.0235503297,
-0.0535501204,
0.0819315091,
0.0195973366,
-0.0066410722,
0.061971955,
-0.0460173711,
0.0034890608,
0.0679109469,
-0.0502399057,
0.0179395266,
0.0025942726,
0.0327603109,
-0.0194462724,
0.0688023493,
-0.0594670512,
0.0405982211,
-0.0035493823,
0.0531165935,
-0.0528961159,
0.0069118398,
0.0387721285,
-0.0069209994,
-0.0397527367,
-0.0147611275,
-0.0278348438,
0.0167599637,
0.0237766374,
-0.0311678369,
-0.0363601521,
-0.0265013594,
-0.0293693934,
-0.0375459455,
-0.0124021834,
0.0144550689,
0.0444126613,
-0.0037164176,
0.0242788307,
-0.0010719661,
0.0379146598,
-0.0087568415,
0.0080473609,
0.0254738349,
0.0616989173,
0.0027174524,
-0.0383172259,
-0.0608202145,
-0.040773835,
-0.0612225682,
0.0677316636,
0.0089529529,
-0.0714871958,
-0.0273370072,
0.0167045146,
-0.0318426862,
0.0322228074,
0.0051227077,
-0.0364940502,
-0.0042019528,
0.0016062323,
0.0785280466,
0.0718157291,
0.0068493681,
0.0499380007,
0.004437461,
-0.0202131346,
0.009573048,
-0.0064855218,
-0.0532763787,
-0.0218657088,
0.0045736544,
0.000025464,
0.016597325,
0.0334361717,
-0.0232610889,
-0.0736748278,
-0.0218041651,
0.0495838895,
-0.049747657,
0.0061753108,
0.0055996259,
0.023091713,
-0.0152884535,
0.0531393215,
-0.0162125472,
-0.0467625037,
0.0515947603,
0.0193597451,
0.0611318722,
-0.0288922116,
-0.0191473942,
-0.0172623713,
0.0391121656,
-0.0009467982,
0.009052447,
0.0160521902,
-0.0137013234,
-0.0468989648,
-0.0492773689,
0.0419577435,
-0.0458821282,
0.0539510064,
-0.0687904358,
0.038041193,
0.0089616198,
-0.0090949936,
-0.0296229627,
-0.0277876724,
0.0051822872,
0.0411956944,
0.0076282336,
-0.015732035,
-0.0361901261,
-0.0201898832,
0.0135872802,
0.0213485546,
-0.0475725569,
-0.0003722053,
-0.0095529594,
0.0523004904,
0.0537366979,
-0.0083848024,
0.0458679199,
-0.050586462,
0.0320279114,
0.0330777541,
-0.0157603398,
0.0227411762,
-0.0580704175,
0.0200624615,
-0.029630864,
-0.0265423451,
0.0004247624,
0.0244385134,
0.0025566027,
-0.0538144,
-0.0110182026,
0.075093165,
0.0338530093,
-0.0170723293,
0.0554163754,
-0.0146271763,
-0.0021991655,
0.0308141578,
0.0189845096,
-0.0050251181,
-0.0080696214,
-0.0029726871,
-0.025023045,
-0.0205928627,
-0.0494478568,
-0.0116802016,
-0.0683704987,
-0.0010656684,
0.0037837077,
-0.0084118657,
-0.0484378599,
-0.050699383,
0.0454573669,
-0.0175121445,
0.016498914,
-0.0180523135,
0.0315554775,
-0.0079323603,
0.0010268623,
-0.0053963144,
-0.0858194754,
-0.050829988,
-0.0502067581,
0.0209833346,
0.103289105,
0.0174570773,
-0.035450533,
0.0186365489,
0.0950461999,
0.027881993,
-0.0016389355,
0.0004058083,
0.0820341855,
0.0222050156,
-0.0118680233,
0.0061676935,
0.0139086908,
-0.0061516394,
-0.0021290397,
-0.0391575433,
0.0572494864,
0.0298491865,
-0.0134455031,
-0.0320069268,
-0.0138382912,
-0.0117799966,
0.0200306345,
-0.0024003405,
-0.0326151028,
-0.0336627327,
-0.0378778465,
-0.0214381013,
-0.0067025316,
-0.032615073,
-0.0637186468,
0.0110092191,
0.0296546407,
-0.0713434815,
0.0030296755,
-0.0363292694,
0.0301815066,
0.0058766343,
0.0134863863,
0.0194113106,
-0.00771234,
-0.0366008133,
0.0053719571,
0.0130205657,
0.0479883142,
-0.0467664525,
0.0170852728,
0.0716694444,
0.0574599355,
-0.0228620358,
-0.0284542888,
-0.1183845848,
-0.0854664817,
-0.0021308775,
0.0292393658,
0.0188201275,
0.0369430855,
-0.0298893489,
-0.075402528,
0.0134827867,
0.0703183413,
-0.0340481512,
0.0145708025,
0.036799565,
-0.0256878585,
-0.0065479898,
0.0405829959,
-0.0089036115,
0.0093066851,
0.0155550344,
0.0700000748,
-0.0345009863,
-0.0214812923,
0.0111499215,
-0.0025918181,
0.0364627577,
0.0361890495,
-0.0213496722,
-0.01400958,
0.0099251671,
-0.0284754559,
-0.0449924208,
-0.0365513451,
0.0445043072,
0.0174720827,
0.0338854603,
-0.0401308648,
-0.0554597229,
0.0039248667,
0.0223222543,
-0.0207759216,
-0.0070378534,
-0.026179228,
-0.0471791141,
0.0043045627,
0.022517981,
-0.0040765787,
0.0116778417,
0.0066731223,
0.0499817394,
0.0062828576,
0.0130949039,
0.0543964207,
0.0105897365,
-0.0373702273,
0.0212681219,
-0.0774822757,
0.0601218194,
-0.04759923,
-0.0154188378,
0.0377833843,
0.0126696834,
0.0208715461,
-0.013221995,
-0.0278406013,
-0.0448004156,
0.0070713866,
0.0135431839,
0.0273572337,
0.0150163872,
0.0360199399,
0.0105487276,
0.0494280867,
0.0757513568,
-0.0319498219,
-0.0221288186,
-0.0198402815,
-0.0098997839,
-0.0174108595,
0.0096504707,
-0.0136167724,
0.0221680719,
-0.0101393694,
0.0537635796,
-0.0308634285,
-0.0934032872,
0.0754266679,
0.0038797071,
0.0492035449,
-0.0015282971,
-0.007421738,
0.0198505223,
-0.0102024879,
0.040741466,
-0.0264377035,
-0.0293385033,
-0.0049190195,
-0.0185329467,
-0.0727742091,
-5.706859035e-33,
-0.0379391722,
-0.0668771118,
-0.0422491804,
0.004285024,
-0.0027726756,
-0.0274750777,
-0.0267384686,
0.0393601842,
-0.0141730923,
0.0233432408,
-0.0170758944,
0.017038919,
-0.0045448202,
-0.009369269,
-0.0095670037,
-0.0720153376,
0.020439025,
-0.0041583586,
-0.0159350168,
-0.0272328202,
-0.012228908,
0.0523740575,
0.049731493,
-0.0846500248,
0.0263972878,
0.0546090268,
-0.0185150784,
-0.0000365458,
0.0058899345,
0.0681517497,
0.0189792924,
0.0216290914,
0.0143201668,
0.0000062811,
-0.0135972435,
-0.0068946029,
-0.0649948344,
-0.0643041953,
-0.0039938223,
0.0277164988,
0.0008625265,
-0.0044876859,
0.0188318174,
-0.0237619393,
-0.0010629077,
-0.0301613417,
0.0613466389,
-0.0484432243,
-0.0122986604,
-0.0176869519,
-0.0097007686,
0.0479413457,
-0.0212854557,
0.0444928221,
0.0065349024,
0.043057207,
0.0000384783,
0.0178700443,
-0.0193131212,
-0.0047539356,
0.0371374674,
0.087279208,
-0.0013948376,
-0.0054972935,
0.0167981982,
0.029915506,
0.0017494912,
0.0041346001,
0.0051690596,
0.010397573,
0.0572123788,
0.0163160898,
0.0757143497,
0.0702195093,
0.0835363716,
0.0129243629,
-0.06594944,
-0.0081894631,
0.0147075951,
0.0067391451,
0.0497521907,
-0.0045830673,
-0.0483970605,
-0.0107970648,
-0.0263289958,
-0.0379085056,
-0.0642711893,
-0.0484984256,
-0.0036081402,
0.0165878907,
-0.0472475626,
0.0204394199,
-0.0116553959,
-0.0885288864,
-0.038256444,
-0.0060334327,
-0.014917885,
0.0208421666,
0.0240913965,
-0.0094650965,
0.0032876134,
-0.0150860734,
-0.0136876525,
0.0234088711,
0.0554974228,
-0.0194305889,
0.0704648942,
0.0017448176,
-0.0454022549,
-0.0135569833,
0.0228856392,
0.0000229399,
0.0133724054,
0.0392498672,
0.02287874,
-0.0184967872,
-0.0242286362,
0.0555539876,
0.0600822829,
0.0327829421,
-0.022083737,
0.0548433736,
-0.00122744,
0.0261982307,
-0.0137510533,
-0.0655310526,
0.0101471562,
0.0285992548,
-0.0089602051,
-0.0660579801,
-0.0236527026,
-0.0087986803,
2.637e-7,
0.0033326584,
0.0708551034,
-0.0063323029,
0.0236879643,
0.0188174658,
-0.0123601668,
-0.0356192328,
-0.007128072,
0.0187644586,
-0.0022310114,
-0.0001420421,
-0.0185466148,
0.0300168991,
0.0173406601,
-0.0206659567,
-0.0392851532,
0.0032728056,
0.0284167062,
-0.0172158275,
-0.0206458718,
0.0657443106,
0.0770244747,
0.0341447033,
0.0330599286,
-0.0264000669,
-0.0203186013,
0.044152949,
-0.0173320975,
0.0246948805,
0.0029986808,
0.0225672703,
-0.0163324345,
-0.0010820971,
0.0474123769,
-0.0510321669,
0.0711549297,
0.0048745847,
0.059822388,
-0.0303381905,
-0.0440736227,
0.0177530944,
0.0042644595,
0.0331715047,
-0.0266328976,
0.064413324,
-0.0319646932,
-0.0274307877,
-0.0015966035,
-0.009243601,
0.0018265017,
0.0405274108,
-0.0194058921,
-0.0444958247,
0.009372782,
0.0415197536,
0.0250927955,
-0.0028532916,
-0.0727573782,
-0.0249905232,
-0.0020110228,
-0.0172886346,
-0.053441681,
0.0050697178,
-0.0017304998,
0.0186456423,
-0.0125608919,
-0.0025099763,
2.750530737e-34,
0.0642354041,
-0.0168525204,
0.0271011051,
0.0305480976,
0.0455114506,
-0.009248008,
0.0393382199,
-0.0128053594,
0.0309662092,
-0.0607952364,
-0.0135514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08885v1 | InstructTODS: Large Language Models for End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems | 2023-10-13T06:36:26 | 2023-10-13T06:36:26 | Willy Chung, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Bryan Wilie, Holy Lovenia, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been used for diverse tasks in natural
language processing (NLP), yet remain under-explored for task-oriented dialogue
systems (TODS), especially for end-to-end TODS. We present InstructTODS, a
novel off-the-shelf framework for zero-shot end-to-end task-oriented dialogue
systems that can adapt to diverse domains without fine-tuning. By leveraging
LLMs, InstructTODS generates a proxy belief state that seamlessly translates
user intentions into dynamic queries for efficient interaction with any KB. Our
extensive experiments demonstrate that InstructTODS achieves comparable
performance to fully fine-tuned TODS in guiding dialogues to successful
completion without prior knowledge or task-specific data. Furthermore, a
rigorous human evaluation of end-to-end TODS shows that InstructTODS produces
dialogue responses that notably outperform both the gold responses and the
state-of-the-art TODS in terms of helpfulness, informativeness, and humanness.
Moreover, the effectiveness of LLMs in TODS is further supported by our
comprehensive evaluations on TODS subtasks: dialogue state tracking, intent
classification, and response generation. Code and implementations could be
found here https://github.com/WillyHC22/InstructTODS/ | [
0.0649309158,
0.0307860207,
-0.0062179174,
0.0250201616,
-0.0231136791,
0.0087039033,
-0.0164745543,
-0.0193839241,
0.0645162165,
-0.047867164,
-0.021220481,
-0.0537623391,
-0.0261645336,
0.0603450052,
0.002923558,
-0.0646441281,
0.0415252335,
-0.0374044105,
0.0149798207,
0.0114844711,
0.0060926168,
0.0275562387,
-0.0238536447,
0.0673909038,
0.0022860926,
-0.0312296469,
-0.0483358912,
0.0124260345,
-0.0259543676,
-0.0277487263,
0.0235964376,
0.0211800393,
0.0340275839,
0.0132369893,
0.0000019955,
-0.0625664145,
0.015367344,
-0.0218348838,
-0.0419010893,
-0.011696374,
0.0025203174,
0.0067214882,
-0.0081033353,
0.020369444,
-0.0448227637,
-0.0015644248,
0.0394299515,
0.085530825,
0.0746378675,
0.0856185704,
-0.0057842345,
-0.0147296367,
0.0307929106,
-0.0043967748,
0.0297921579,
-0.0619949214,
0.0154502634,
-0.0072465413,
0.0315198004,
0.0308974069,
0.0269966964,
0.0054608849,
0.0014511499,
-0.0353859402,
-0.0119985417,
0.010966626,
0.0264393985,
-0.0305523109,
-0.0364072472,
0.0866544768,
0.0564520024,
0.0177323204,
0.0216491967,
0.0234160591,
-0.0138812,
-0.0184887759,
-0.0545280725,
-0.0179938339,
-0.0154366456,
-0.0020769762,
-0.0068114256,
0.0365726799,
-0.0022858044,
0.0364869125,
-0.0278863274,
0.036162056,
-0.013786477,
-0.035141781,
-0.009984469,
-0.0148483338,
-0.0040558572,
-0.0945104361,
0.0054899859,
0.0428596288,
-0.0709183514,
0.0134154195,
-0.0337081663,
0.0401606821,
0.0109516112,
-0.0373297557,
0.0021145286,
0.0550873838,
-0.0083948765,
0.0637543425,
0.0234685186,
0.0376989767,
-0.0075274897,
-0.0189982578,
-0.0226679295,
-0.0346338525,
-0.0740577877,
0.0127175068,
-0.0468220823,
0.0163307488,
-0.0557374842,
-0.058312729,
-0.016382575,
0.0795656294,
0.0083015244,
0.0245191809,
0.0178068634,
0.0304758307,
-0.0329880752,
-0.0037455987,
-0.0465817973,
0.0567554235,
-0.0179049894,
0.0075625172,
0.0284326579,
-0.0274636969,
-0.0038298899,
0.0350986309,
-0.001105977,
-0.0079322159,
-0.00179732,
0.0361912772,
-0.0114893727,
-0.0314619541,
-0.0241768882,
-0.0182124153,
-0.0255523976,
-0.0779871121,
-0.0227786545,
-0.0205167513,
0.0319010727,
0.0126975505,
-0.0147006065,
-0.0376484133,
0.0210373215,
0.0373672284,
-0.0168158486,
0.056378793,
-0.0111661451,
0.0172569919,
-0.0006882995,
0.0107331583,
-0.0316453166,
0.0573935322,
0.0299806111,
0.0458843969,
0.0259412024,
0.0134411221,
-0.0092476588,
0.00495141,
-0.0226052441,
0.0196224209,
0.0198768955,
0.0607419275,
-0.0127236042,
0.0322403833,
0.0142626818,
0.0555283502,
-0.0193239897,
0.0174508952,
0.0805432498,
0.0301812664,
-0.0110071152,
0.0083590709,
0.0264566913,
0.072251983,
-0.0113664633,
-0.0429294929,
-0.0532128438,
0.034996327,
-0.0158309489,
-0.0136252949,
0.0538339242,
0.0125347823,
-0.0376589932,
-0.0366841294,
0.0128754443,
0.006772486,
0.0165778883,
0.0414551869,
0.0521261953,
-0.006578106,
-0.0874885246,
0.0063354112,
-0.0119411461,
-0.0335243531,
-0.0207842886,
-0.0377573669,
0.0477090664,
0.0903224498,
0.0485473685,
-0.015967967,
-0.0452374294,
-0.0480408445,
0.024512222,
0.0456450395,
0.0195066482,
-0.0178193916,
0.008626407,
-0.0544989556,
-0.0071952087,
0.0081833145,
-0.0132368505,
-0.0009214632,
-0.0037718122,
-0.0153844254,
0.0157468673,
-0.0220259726,
0.0150222424,
0.0042192992,
0.0260521136,
-0.0107754301,
0.0117627243,
0.0165914521,
0.031588424,
0.0372054838,
0.0146304518,
-0.0097102616,
0.0339091681,
0.0116198808,
-0.0117547931,
0.0036996428,
-0.0367107391,
-0.0382315814,
0.0196716562,
0.0206579398,
-0.0163806621,
0.0126773249,
-0.0061051487,
-0.0555505864,
-0.0054194513,
-0.0373841263,
0.0272202175,
-0.0504966751,
0.0035348362,
0.0343722068,
-0.0176903252,
-0.0338505916,
0.0166462064,
0.0181830153,
-0.0159774944,
0.0486497879,
-0.0128298337,
0.0085175121,
-0.0633221269,
0.0075509385,
0.0131139345,
-0.0097194528,
0.00247265,
0.0178644601,
0.0322008468,
-0.031062834,
-0.0313168205,
-0.1143974587,
0.0129591413,
-0.0243589301,
-0.0017135395,
-0.0124965617,
0.0338854641,
-0.0101804351,
-0.0171355233,
-0.0349365622,
-0.0035088749,
0.0605351143,
-0.0042025289,
0.0183027368,
0.0203155205,
-0.0326543003,
-0.0118067209,
0.0289213434,
-0.0011498963,
0.0089747729,
0.0022104839,
-0.0356965698,
-0.065224871,
0.0191620942,
-0.0255963746,
0.0395899862,
-0.0220131427,
-0.0339975357,
0.0158472676,
-0.0096262107,
0.0485509224,
0.0502752028,
0.0294070709,
-0.0048568235,
-0.0079819607,
-0.0357639082,
-0.0911038294,
0.0575382113,
-0.0218383577,
-0.0120115587,
-0.0584599003,
-0.0180111378,
0.0262313504,
0.0505263694,
0.021273924,
0.0026198127,
-0.0693466291,
-0.0045835287,
0.0202213656,
-0.0079631787,
-0.0159289669,
-0.0104870349,
-0.0350471884,
0.0286764931,
-0.0087125227,
-0.0270660259,
0.0761354566,
-0.0340355895,
-0.0345229618,
-0.0498284586,
-0.0126909977,
-0.0252697859,
0.0490907729,
-0.024268603,
0.0125427609,
0.060681574,
-0.0224066265,
-0.002681253,
0.0237694215,
-0.0269919094,
-0.0289916322,
0.0340488143,
-0.0366138592,
0.0290451869,
0.005216043,
-0.0346477218,
-0.0599154606,
-0.0330390334,
-0.0233550072,
0.0070345351,
-0.0003096731,
-0.0292859115,
-0.0066966028,
0.007864791,
0.0277162157,
0.019040959,
-0.0010586416,
-0.0174225047,
-0.0399840511,
0.0075518228,
0.06061434,
0.0083218459,
-0.0053395019,
-0.0186612755,
0.0561243407,
0.0460849777,
0.0468416885,
-0.03321293,
-0.0078345295,
-0.0420131125,
0.0576623529,
-0.0082704583,
-0.0041575311,
0.0414136536,
0.0852765217,
-0.0360341966,
-0.0047627962,
0.1300988644,
0.027052056,
-0.0541300513,
-0.015616945,
0.0000354356,
0.0328130312,
0.0272082835,
0.0255725086,
-0.0908971205,
-0.0689089969,
0.0194692258,
0.0281380787,
-0.0073566162,
-0.0403853208,
-0.0103008719,
-0.0954131484,
0.0349051915,
-0.0214915667,
0.0179053098,
-0.0176123269,
-0.0368304364,
0.0231730081,
0.0207942072,
0.0052115233,
0.0048802793,
0.0111173708,
-0.0202384498,
-0.0000702885,
-0.0028193961,
-0.0060290643,
0.0376029648,
-0.0252930876,
0.0811327398,
0.0785874575,
0.0443627872,
0.0480212905,
0.0024619086,
-0.0101557923,
0.0052960413,
-0.0031642327,
-0.0068878406,
0.0209286325,
-0.027810771,
0.0063517671,
-0.0394824259,
0.0367458835,
-0.0550746098,
0.0055654515,
0.0250808708,
0.0741334707,
-0.0590406694,
0.0438201353,
-0.0192576498,
0.0179671943,
0.0664317906,
0.0925708413,
0.0089961151,
-0.0589404665,
-0.032824453,
-0.043656908,
-0.0292572752,
-0.0338788964,
0.0190387443,
-0.0235880315,
-0.0181901027,
0.0277657099,
-0.0672126114,
-0.0518091321,
0.033011619,
0.0180077422,
-0.005442434,
0.0020851449,
0.0110070016,
0.0107753733,
-0.0073452727,
0.0324861817,
-0.023786461,
0.0455458574,
-0.0894261748,
-0.0114861596,
0.0481200814,
-0.0478838235,
0.0061791418,
0.0405898057,
-0.0398228914,
-0.0595921129,
-0.03922778,
0.0684856549,
0.0178868286,
0.020795593,
-0.0100067453,
-0.0315121189,
-0.0212315116,
-0.0162220616,
-0.0608784407,
-0.0200640019,
0.0356796309,
0.0951269865,
-0.0070246435,
0.0613202155,
-0.0393465385,
0.0043788836,
-0.0372867733,
0.0490929522,
-0.0322592705,
-0.099728398,
0.0095578786,
-0.003166066,
0.0352145173,
0.0121918451,
-0.0175625104,
0.0071663926,
0.0283953007,
-0.0240698643,
-0.0209056418,
-0.0696678832,
0.0254666861,
0.0047553559,
-0.0222872086,
0.0144923348,
0.0119498512,
-0.0360619575,
0.024117114,
-0.0425325446,
0.0002498056,
-0.0036604558,
-0.0028231333,
0.0499384888,
-0.0202630628,
-0.0155509841,
0.0135521311,
0.0233096909,
0.0154380342,
-0.0045588221,
0.1137774661,
0.0251044519,
-0.0415528342,
-0.0143640889,
0.0215230621,
-0.061825294,
-0.0456454009,
0.0206046086,
0.0277558565,
0.029767694,
0.0480862372,
0.0413476974,
-0.0475523099,
0.0240570698,
-0.0228778608,
0.0731638819,
-0.0074228803,
-0.0323826671,
0.0324179083,
0.0166580528,
-0.0250312891,
0.0119759561,
0.046236176,
-0.0118820099,
0.023049932,
0.0005804441,
-0.0197564978,
-0.0522719212,
-0.02520312,
0.0081447838,
0.0585507676,
-0.0195860378,
0.0274373293,
-0.0319570899,
-0.0280258656,
-0.0041613635,
-0.0216394477,
-0.035707891,
-0.0625245348,
0.0502923951,
0.0326813944,
0.0047292369,
-0.0298164301,
-0.0485566109,
0.0010235152,
-0.0192724802,
-0.0361658148,
-0.0504569747,
-5.820396361e-33,
-0.0082198521,
-0.0148846041,
0.0361213759,
-0.0022554847,
-0.0295580029,
-0.0598243289,
-0.0498652309,
-0.0075423317,
-0.0172614511,
-0.0040972289,
-0.0282672141,
0.013189448,
0.011217095,
0.0587783642,
-0.011650796,
-0.0051308791,
0.061012011,
0.0019433281,
-0.00626201,
0.0524794422,
0.0600492693,
0.0110917138,
0.0119455084,
-0.0513695851,
0.0430337414,
0.0139756212,
0.0042715212,
0.0683624595,
0.0080469446,
0.0232079607,
-0.0204052571,
0.0508750379,
0.0060053901,
-0.0498415083,
-0.0069890209,
0.0401722863,
-0.0384970345,
0.0190683976,
0.0365527794,
-0.013040754,
-0.0299092308,
-0.0209640004,
-0.0064942753,
-0.0155838951,
-0.0016355467,
0.0231018234,
0.0005569591,
-0.0015631216,
-0.001585787,
-0.0051415553,
-0.0522727109,
0.0042275256,
-0.0296821371,
-0.0910350829,
-0.0196459554,
0.0749618858,
0.0175139811,
-0.0335485488,
-0.0329467133,
0.0250859279,
-0.0141296275,
-0.0131885661,
0.0371219516,
0.0210241042,
0.0253528152,
0.0469107814,
0.0313581452,
-0.0039365506,
-0.0427695513,
-0.0156497899,
-0.0296264961,
0.0408928841,
0.0076808045,
0.0384411737,
-0.0297437459,
0.0155180292,
-0.0675201565,
0.0254297517,
0.0499268509,
0.0479984432,
0.0242547691,
0.0229761899,
-0.0680951551,
-0.009345023,
-0.0241562407,
0.0251794141,
-0.0128261084,
-0.0379073471,
0.059922386,
0.0332107022,
-0.0051970142,
-0.0180580262,
0.0649372041,
-0.0391748697,
0.010958029,
0.0365699567,
-0.0160314217,
0.0065084328,
-0.0065722098,
0.0038274243,
-0.0653275922,
0.0128165577,
0.0307399649,
-0.0188404769,
-0.0215222165,
0.0238351021,
-0.0270626098,
-0.0077606258,
-0.0413208939,
0.0024524149,
-0.0396638438,
0.0637431368,
-0.0582273491,
0.0305113755,
0.0318083279,
-0.0026241867,
-0.027491875,
0.091426447,
-0.0321324952,
-0.0258668102,
-0.0449759886,
-0.04700372,
0.0284000244,
-0.013045813,
-0.0285305753,
-0.0080624605,
-0.0251125433,
-0.024074113,
-0.023136843,
-0.0223108865,
-0.0056583071,
0.0133877872,
2.711e-7,
-0.0294196382,
0.0487604737,
0.0005587186,
0.0595394261,
-0.0050169821,
0.0615175292,
0.0032743909,
0.0160862878,
0.0359674878,
-0.0228819735,
-0.0135526722,
0.0297771748,
0.0453523546,
0.0036375932,
-0.1242772639,
-0.0312808603,
0.0044076815,
-0.006269726,
-0.055083137,
0.0171800405,
0.0767709538,
0.0591254942,
0.0015929923,
0.0151189212,
0.0237538815,
-0.0211924631,
0.0433039069,
-0.0212943368,
-0.0233724844,
0.0279335678,
0.0317697003,
-0.0550739989,
0.0005079542,
0.0084571103,
0.0103438254,
0.0449571647,
-0.0189629253,
0.0838854089,
-0.0084443735,
-0.0707054213,
-0.03042024,
-0.0049394998,
0.0184861161,
-0.0570720024,
0.0635798797,
-0.0699088052,
-0.0228150804,
-0.0034307216,
-0.0081890179,
-0.0397447385,
-0.0343156457,
-0.0041819024,
-0.0143491263,
-0.0095887193,
0.0167292077,
-0.028025791,
0.0082813641,
-0.0636373386,
0.0025558055,
-0.0126126446,
-0.0606190227,
-0.0373657346,
-0.0537636727,
0.0180136934,
0.0099940235,
-0.0442211665,
-0.0117174303,
2.412582769e-34,
0.0299838893,
-0.0124394735,
0.0177384708,
0.0365908742,
0.0458683521,
0.0022003592,
-0.0382991582,
0.0042450554,
0.0800420046,
-0.1147682667,
-0.0159416366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08877v2 | Retrieval-Generation Alignment for End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialogue System | 2023-10-13T06:03:47 | 2023-10-20T09:18:42 | Weizhou Shen, Yingqi Gao, Canbin Huang, Fanqi Wan, Xiaojun Quan, Wei Bi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Developing an efficient retriever to retrieve knowledge from a large-scale
knowledge base (KB) is critical for task-oriented dialogue systems to
effectively handle localized and specialized tasks. However, widely used
generative models such as T5 and ChatGPT often struggle to differentiate subtle
differences among the retrieved KB records when generating responses, resulting
in suboptimal quality of generated responses. In this paper, we propose the
application of maximal marginal likelihood to train a perceptive retriever by
utilizing signals from response generation for supervision. In addition, our
approach goes beyond considering solely retrieved entities and incorporates
various meta knowledge to guide the generator, thus improving the utilization
of knowledge. We evaluate our approach on three task-oriented dialogue datasets
using T5 and ChatGPT as the backbone models. The results demonstrate that when
combined with meta knowledge, the response generator can effectively leverage
high-quality knowledge records from the retriever and enhance the quality of
generated responses. The codes and models of this paper are available at
https://github.com/shenwzh3/MK-TOD. | [
0.0811010823,
-0.0015249732,
-0.0003796303,
0.051593814,
-0.0196043067,
-0.0110146804,
-0.0238341484,
-0.0207984839,
0.0137001574,
-0.0240011606,
-0.0434461534,
-0.0268480927,
-0.0477157049,
0.0234359317,
0.0027443236,
-0.0451860726,
0.0462997518,
0.007773303,
0.0200711675,
0.0008585253,
0.0076089716,
0.0067480309,
-0.051359836,
0.0577853769,
-0.0057871379,
-0.0143684875,
-0.0417332053,
0.0202907138,
0.0214619413,
-0.0200141016,
0.0331402346,
0.025665259,
-0.0022857655,
0.0350657701,
0.0000017785,
-0.0412204899,
-0.0148233222,
-0.0004535522,
-0.0450853184,
-0.0766096339,
0.0177484732,
0.0050221761,
0.0069133695,
0.0161645208,
-0.0537573136,
-0.0336143225,
0.0429279506,
0.0735796615,
0.0456381254,
0.0975763723,
-0.0017464191,
-0.0099631548,
0.0111144306,
-0.0161692165,
0.0498626195,
-0.0413659103,
0.0087641785,
0.0290256292,
0.0053551276,
0.0459352918,
0.0205193162,
0.020455718,
0.0105615845,
-0.0230919514,
0.0053603705,
0.0241264272,
0.0188164469,
-0.001038151,
-0.0207630005,
0.0869660303,
0.0577043071,
0.0230024289,
0.0031837313,
0.0027851155,
0.0199242644,
0.0151172662,
-0.0381967984,
-0.0181365479,
-0.0479013696,
-0.0060174284,
-0.0274180342,
0.0085944906,
-0.0411761813,
-0.0375257172,
-0.0235017724,
0.0160761643,
0.0102989273,
-0.0477344692,
-0.0186109859,
0.0008800102,
-0.0025905161,
-0.034202978,
-0.0079545723,
0.0234248377,
-0.045298323,
0.0226854123,
-0.0100484593,
-0.0243833456,
0.0036741754,
-0.0228508096,
0.0227778573,
0.0388298742,
-0.0157459639,
0.013025959,
0.0231282227,
0.0559261218,
-0.0346971117,
0.0003967834,
-0.0433606468,
-0.0307817664,
-0.0919075906,
-0.0019650834,
-0.0214956235,
0.0324438736,
-0.0602593534,
-0.0056795566,
-0.0341140963,
0.0504214242,
0.0126260864,
0.0035347862,
0.0233481247,
0.0329685956,
-0.0729336813,
0.0058290279,
-0.0564651601,
0.0449255146,
-0.0167907123,
0.0123001356,
0.0286194291,
-0.0317872763,
-0.0214095134,
0.0140940771,
0.0176056921,
-0.0297861379,
-0.0255840998,
0.0337422304,
-0.0152989337,
-0.0047462778,
-0.0220857933,
-0.0410578884,
-0.0445097834,
-0.0828910023,
0.0154825263,
-0.0188900474,
0.0518204011,
-0.0017867112,
-0.0528462045,
0.0131481439,
0.0165287498,
0.0105938995,
-0.0139557747,
0.0292038508,
0.000569162,
0.0056498586,
0.0066803303,
-0.0119588524,
-0.0367207825,
0.0713416934,
0.0106307445,
0.0213034879,
0.0340621211,
0.0181230474,
-0.0042138449,
-0.0165863894,
0.0201975834,
0.0042783385,
0.0570440665,
0.0363390148,
0.0048240875,
-0.0056058378,
0.0411652997,
0.0448860154,
-0.0370710529,
0.0095349867,
0.0562272705,
0.0146094803,
0.0122000808,
0.0049825436,
0.0474920422,
0.0431188941,
-0.0058559137,
0.0238150768,
-0.0220292769,
0.0232403297,
-0.0123289209,
0.0228286386,
0.0324786566,
0.018646257,
-0.0294454414,
-0.0312552154,
0.0211671665,
0.0219711233,
-0.0498596206,
0.0449774191,
0.0589384586,
0.0076915747,
-0.0668193921,
0.0099609662,
-0.002147163,
-0.0588650592,
-0.0164655801,
-0.0434561707,
0.0289756414,
0.0523148663,
0.0405401476,
-0.0170439538,
-0.0713457242,
-0.0088066626,
-0.0500892997,
0.0753799826,
0.0195832439,
-0.0342438892,
0.0263723619,
-0.0261948071,
-0.0568214282,
0.0078204265,
-0.0049673989,
0.0362649485,
-0.0108323041,
-0.0054601943,
0.0396769866,
-0.0330670513,
0.0130574321,
0.0149120521,
0.0027685198,
-0.0101230955,
0.0106307175,
0.0163423307,
0.0356300548,
0.0542764254,
-0.0127449483,
0.0158570986,
0.0489409342,
-0.0276433751,
0.0093716001,
0.0407628044,
-0.0487324521,
-0.0857168436,
0.0388520248,
0.0050669028,
0.0125373742,
-0.0083724475,
-0.0244838484,
-0.0803623274,
0.0198431928,
-0.0332938619,
0.0360806473,
-0.0583353192,
-0.0148461461,
0.0459430292,
-0.0180858262,
-0.0459345318,
0.0725979134,
0.0150660155,
0.0107686967,
0.0523863584,
-0.0190477055,
0.0393001772,
-0.0653870031,
0.026927432,
0.005077037,
-0.0082952343,
0.0094843972,
0.0524759702,
0.00556815,
-0.0525546782,
-0.0417091772,
-0.1350458413,
0.0290699471,
-0.0202977397,
0.037606582,
0.0107101463,
0.0245006718,
0.0049990672,
-0.0090084272,
-0.0607170574,
0.0050556613,
0.0464537255,
0.0042344537,
0.0215268545,
0.046919968,
-0.0053274445,
-0.0504468791,
0.0245742928,
0.0141004464,
0.0083068414,
0.0070290919,
0.0107630575,
-0.0313227996,
0.0232433993,
-0.039573539,
0.0595164448,
-0.0246877857,
-0.0087451534,
0.0330344103,
-0.0244925618,
0.0771565512,
0.0338853598,
0.0181701258,
0.0271389261,
-0.039583493,
-0.0453055911,
-0.1053434387,
0.0578242168,
-0.0305866953,
-0.0439310297,
-0.0441356078,
-0.0144078443,
0.0093406038,
0.0463986397,
0.0431884639,
-0.005641141,
-0.0653778315,
0.0006760825,
0.0346380919,
-0.020435337,
-0.0000776072,
0.0400486887,
-0.0158014204,
0.0141008627,
-0.0370529406,
-0.0085962135,
0.0599998459,
-0.0161232278,
-0.0141336648,
-0.0477341041,
0.0033228665,
-0.0099375704,
0.0566603169,
-0.0288960617,
0.0231045093,
0.0317665413,
-0.0410915092,
-0.0736604109,
0.0185447522,
0.0439311601,
-0.0436226837,
0.0134716397,
-0.036817342,
0.0303515233,
-0.0199253261,
-0.0504099876,
-0.0904534906,
0.0023960937,
0.0340493955,
0.0049177692,
0.013094726,
-0.01655774,
-0.0174562447,
0.006430163,
0.0316620767,
0.0010690222,
-0.0104648657,
-0.0185958035,
-0.0262854882,
0.0548571385,
0.0677155629,
0.0186403636,
-0.0306464955,
-0.0185061377,
0.0145216333,
0.0468225181,
0.0545710064,
-0.010769424,
0.0042178757,
-0.0449561886,
0.0239360891,
-0.0191841274,
-0.0045513734,
0.0191625524,
0.0567552857,
-0.018689787,
-0.0151283946,
0.0891546011,
0.0045792442,
-0.0127728833,
-0.040581774,
-0.0005462392,
-0.0023820493,
0.0010829655,
0.0346993543,
-0.0638408735,
-0.0214331523,
-0.0130413715,
0.0391523652,
-0.0012208893,
-0.0391482674,
-0.0083550792,
-0.1141725332,
0.0444440432,
-0.021741461,
-0.0158197749,
-0.0738913193,
0.0067435671,
0.0153659582,
0.0130947996,
0.0065147155,
0.034798868,
0.0133229448,
0.0158900321,
0.0288130995,
0.0403374657,
-0.03307027,
-0.0046158824,
-0.0260467194,
0.0537755825,
0.0790544078,
0.0333722867,
0.0615204535,
0.0136958417,
-0.0208591912,
-0.0100655798,
-0.0081078587,
0.0162720121,
0.0432587489,
-0.0247341432,
0.0148789361,
-0.0333521366,
0.0137793226,
-0.0155937988,
0.0138124321,
0.0224790815,
0.0358135477,
-0.0556707941,
0.0313179195,
-0.0171743855,
0.0197400171,
0.0658194572,
0.0786787942,
0.022734439,
-0.010429753,
-0.0251070429,
0.0115321921,
0.0096332571,
-0.0611653849,
0.031753365,
0.010528787,
-0.0140902568,
0.0133638689,
-0.0884246901,
-0.059812624,
-0.0051627755,
0.0452877767,
0.0060154237,
-0.0012794714,
-0.0167157408,
0.0074229022,
-0.0389902219,
0.0182421673,
-0.022352118,
-0.0371246673,
-0.0581376106,
-0.0494535901,
0.0382998958,
-0.0446230471,
-0.0103565576,
0.0323500112,
-0.0705152601,
-0.0576216429,
-0.0629122555,
0.0555732325,
0.0173453093,
0.0436102822,
0.0034079023,
0.0354653187,
0.0163563937,
0.0339942463,
-0.0730690062,
-0.0218927059,
0.0252083,
0.0437144488,
-0.0221800692,
0.0322756544,
-0.0692383125,
0.0213431306,
0.0077731931,
0.0638677254,
-0.0077811065,
-0.0842207298,
0.0266334191,
0.0034135573,
0.0418092757,
0.0065693576,
-0.0336568542,
-0.0472961701,
0.0094544385,
-0.0363430046,
-0.0184991602,
-0.0723745301,
0.0119827455,
-0.003927663,
-0.0322903879,
0.0336809345,
0.004403749,
-0.0448903367,
0.0727658123,
-0.0543972477,
-0.0415163264,
-0.0258695129,
-0.0231352765,
0.028312996,
-0.012894962,
-0.0331244245,
0.0158233717,
0.0564586669,
0.0351524614,
-0.0012306531,
0.0981906354,
0.0227828398,
-0.0383213423,
0.0181489363,
0.0145026036,
-0.0598733537,
-0.0395129435,
-0.0325111076,
0.0261040702,
0.0423256122,
0.0548381805,
0.0339937061,
-0.0309732202,
0.0270477608,
-0.0266293958,
0.0641179979,
0.0099040344,
-0.0023094513,
0.0271925759,
0.0125095267,
-0.0102865258,
-0.0128550334,
0.0899423361,
-0.0208654199,
0.0158670265,
-0.0155336969,
0.001289912,
-0.0837133303,
-0.0447641574,
0.0115157962,
0.0171210207,
-0.0070611271,
0.0375504196,
-0.0292273313,
-0.0363233238,
0.0026528428,
0.0160604957,
-0.0359555222,
-0.0002806063,
0.0392461829,
0.0469524264,
-0.0184875391,
-0.0703133196,
-0.0460469536,
0.0200123359,
-0.0385108069,
-0.01337949,
-0.0368395932,
-5.755814701e-33,
-0.0550347082,
-0.0216040928,
0.0403626598,
0.0019903022,
-0.0412804298,
-0.0405962951,
-0.025985416,
-0.0066606738,
-0.0230919104,
-0.0144010698,
-0.0036641622,
0.0091806939,
0.0112709589,
0.0454233848,
-0.0238218512,
-0.0225281101,
0.0477372222,
-0.0102561004,
-0.0041249665,
0.036802575,
0.070083566,
0.0258434061,
0.0478836894,
-0.0815789625,
0.0561360642,
-0.0206213072,
0.0083917584,
0.0342213139,
0.011518497,
0.0583680347,
-0.010582828,
0.0642952174,
0.0112174302,
-0.0403180607,
-0.0124376183,
0.0052947127,
-0.0688109025,
-0.0240317509,
0.0179887712,
-0.0061439509,
-0.034115646,
-0.024531113,
-0.0129734008,
-0.0174325407,
0.0151046803,
-0.0044017057,
0.0225846637,
-0.0166848544,
-0.0089684799,
-0.0206597913,
-0.0454683825,
0.0023015507,
-0.0105531029,
-0.0524652824,
-0.0019925388,
0.0789617226,
0.0294675007,
-0.0494177714,
-0.0011701772,
0.0071316389,
-0.0020398449,
0.0229256265,
0.0325261764,
0.065227814,
0.0304677449,
0.0317883343,
0.0325065441,
0.0078177694,
-0.0153660774,
-0.0615207218,
-0.0290736463,
0.0394516587,
-0.0313154198,
0.0661603957,
-0.0206546094,
0.0365016535,
-0.0511512421,
0.0522014871,
0.0266299937,
0.0520985015,
0.0047361972,
-0.0024398582,
-0.0506506525,
-0.0051999572,
-0.014800217,
-0.0044707833,
-0.0170408823,
-0.0389056355,
0.0585040674,
0.0354201868,
0.0202123094,
-0.0280775279,
0.071175158,
-0.0250285342,
0.0159729794,
0.0349454135,
-0.0268655345,
-0.0122463219,
-0.0294915605,
-0.005329872,
-0.0604402237,
-0.0242299419,
0.0599117801,
0.0017685009,
-0.0444981232,
0.0318051204,
-0.0145961046,
-0.0216987934,
-0.0409139208,
0.0042851944,
-0.0435652584,
0.0667485148,
-0.0521604009,
0.0189254023,
0.0117414119,
-0.0016139443,
-0.0231792312,
0.0645429492,
-0.0016933662,
-0.0122353444,
-0.020566158,
-0.0242793411,
0.04432467,
-0.0204700809,
-0.0107405866,
0.0456330292,
-0.0065152366,
-0.0125450268,
-0.0273802988,
0.0149489595,
-0.0000237504,
0.0257649068,
2.524e-7,
0.0037962061,
-0.0161412098,
0.0559527837,
0.0453225896,
0.0024106263,
0.0469516031,
0.039858669,
0.0182699636,
0.0406654887,
-0.0264470689,
0.0177217331,
0.0087812617,
0.0579349101,
-0.0007213149,
-0.0999074429,
-0.0269061159,
-0.01580479,
-0.0411308631,
-0.0252237599,
0.0101983128,
0.0841923729,
0.0427305736,
-0.0183098819,
0.0196776371,
0.0168831274,
-0.0177097768,
0.0728776976,
-0.0211143438,
-0.0325701945,
0.028537415,
0.0584619716,
-0.0214036219,
0.003573047,
0.0392758921,
0.0079140877,
0.02664808,
-0.0189574324,
0.048277799,
0.0002737781,
-0.0902434215,
-0.0106378123,
-0.0119126793,
0.0298745148,
-0.0200675931,
0.032276459,
-0.0590394326,
-0.0011957334,
0.0120084742,
-0.0287069231,
-0.0115866596,
-0.0507444739,
-0.0198349785,
-0.0231756549,
0.0044084764,
0.0139028728,
0.000249114,
0.0141784241,
-0.0551977679,
0.0065160864,
0.017763136,
-0.062496867,
-0.0773563907,
0.0101774829,
-0.0395993665,
0.0135443984,
-0.052894216,
0.0000349022,
2.069286991e-34,
0.0172720868,
0.0180177297,
0.0049882513,
0.0330123156,
0.032412529,
-0.0147500532,
-0.0430244692,
0.0017081861,
0.0443419926,
-0.0821653455,
-0.0303703249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08860v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08860v1 | Guiding AMR Parsing with Reverse Graph Linearization | 2023-10-13T05:03:13 | 2023-10-13T05:03:13 | Bofei Gao, Liang Chen, Peiyi Wang, Zhifang Sui, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) parsing aims to extract an abstract
semantic graph from a given sentence. The sequence-to-sequence approaches,
which linearize the semantic graph into a sequence of nodes and edges and
generate the linearized graph directly, have achieved good performance.
However, we observed that these approaches suffer from structure loss
accumulation during the decoding process, leading to a much lower F1-score for
nodes and edges decoded later compared to those decoded earlier. To address
this issue, we propose a novel Reverse Graph Linearization (RGL) enhanced
framework. RGL defines both default and reverse linearization orders of an AMR
graph, where most structures at the back part of the default order appear at
the front part of the reversed order and vice versa. RGL incorporates the
reversed linearization to the original AMR parser through a two-pass
self-distillation mechanism, which guides the model when generating the default
linearizations. Our analysis shows that our proposed method significantly
mitigates the problem of structure loss accumulation, outperforming the
previously best AMR parsing model by 0.8 and 0.5 Smatch scores on the AMR 2.0
and AMR 3.0 dataset, respectively. The code are available at
https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/AMR_reverse_graph_linearization. | [
-0.0160521064,
0.0348892473,
-0.0124470135,
0.0435556695,
-0.0262254383,
0.0300229657,
-0.0585460067,
-0.0211561993,
0.0116950916,
-0.0116731552,
0.0374528542,
0.0213509854,
-0.0089877779,
0.055591207,
-0.0060738274,
-0.0187171623,
0.0408022329,
0.0077732531,
0.0469098873,
0.0277227312,
0.0271870717,
0.0499036722,
0.0282119848,
0.0111360755,
-0.0075691012,
-0.0315382555,
-0.0165988598,
0.0321291611,
0.0295300931,
-0.0667640269,
-0.0461364053,
-0.0157561507,
0.0083228489,
-0.0135293752,
0.0000022324,
-0.0111683952,
-0.0868682191,
0.0205216166,
-0.023239715,
-0.031497702,
0.0720495805,
-0.0448869839,
-0.0003594934,
0.0174528938,
-0.0281457547,
-0.045964729,
0.0048321416,
0.0214109533,
0.0440388024,
0.0636143535,
-0.0326445512,
-0.078086555,
0.0257881787,
0.0065813451,
-0.0745827481,
-0.026467111,
-0.0103281923,
0.0521727875,
-0.0574030653,
-0.0209505018,
-0.0826884583,
0.007809523,
-0.0007219115,
0.0258153509,
0.0498876199,
0.0096249087,
-0.0308266934,
-0.0089901434,
0.0182283204,
0.0916555226,
0.0007919317,
-0.0234257616,
0.0218711644,
-0.0192929413,
-0.0176414717,
-0.0102450643,
-0.0277073979,
0.0375505909,
-0.0418300293,
0.048940748,
0.0314882584,
-0.0206720233,
0.015906617,
-0.0000548023,
-0.0456198305,
0.0632807016,
-0.0238162801,
-0.0154458275,
0.0406784639,
0.0212408826,
-0.0633961037,
0.0036532879,
0.0648585558,
-0.0319646336,
0.0126073556,
0.012062693,
-0.0354141816,
-0.0624621138,
-0.0198418479,
0.009542373,
0.0562420823,
0.0414132103,
0.0073564141,
-0.0296166204,
-0.0230726302,
0.0380742028,
-0.0001697488,
0.0539350733,
-0.0775167346,
0.0197248776,
-0.0523251593,
0.0259190258,
-0.0917475149,
0.067847617,
-0.0573976263,
-0.0554203466,
-0.0332524106,
0.0365453847,
0.0031924348,
-0.0150050372,
0.0387954898,
-0.0036690824,
0.0018516809,
0.0361505635,
0.0577265471,
0.0438040793,
0.0139263738,
-0.0400352888,
0.0068376339,
-0.0035636602,
-0.0093361922,
0.0102506774,
0.0541421846,
-0.0104131578,
-0.0083260406,
0.0564166345,
0.0148980897,
-0.0141586708,
-0.0004793275,
-0.0569002293,
0.0179128051,
0.0023890072,
0.0095829582,
-0.0362566411,
0.0478582233,
0.0206725989,
0.0184460636,
-0.0145172086,
-0.000505243,
-0.006648655,
0.0172216576,
0.0303110573,
-0.0410043262,
-0.0189564358,
-0.0236133281,
-0.0044883243,
-0.0024489276,
0.0173064861,
0.0375425369,
0.0186245572,
0.0118920589,
0.011474614,
-0.0785764903,
-0.0125331273,
0.0273393132,
-0.0079326686,
0.0171258263,
0.0095080249,
-0.0873297751,
0.0059338612,
0.0586162619,
0.0579869635,
-0.0449821986,
-0.0177210905,
-0.0124359215,
0.0252098795,
0.0015487469,
0.021801021,
0.0282371268,
0.0522636436,
-0.0167280883,
0.0063718255,
-0.0322965384,
-0.0214616917,
0.0088192672,
0.0531906635,
-0.0311270356,
-0.0150509896,
0.0289950296,
-0.0155495573,
-0.0258254502,
-0.0360471383,
0.0668820962,
-0.0192065611,
0.0300760046,
0.0413107798,
-0.0440683961,
0.0479338616,
-0.0154266991,
-0.0281685255,
-0.0105339978,
0.0217462368,
-0.0493196994,
0.046205949,
0.029094249,
0.0177074503,
-0.0214605611,
-0.0144877629,
0.0119656669,
0.0067303502,
0.002576546,
-0.0137223881,
0.0057741795,
-0.0553000085,
-0.0399483107,
-0.0125394594,
-0.011679302,
0.0060833171,
-0.0411261693,
0.0116184885,
0.0138965379,
-0.0415910892,
-0.0427187867,
0.0012169869,
0.0038011016,
0.0137056103,
-0.0172615983,
0.0187928416,
0.0292708725,
0.0313288942,
0.0027342397,
0.0329895951,
0.0385577679,
-0.0374391824,
-0.0063799964,
0.0461775586,
-0.0782197714,
-0.0759137049,
0.025522612,
-0.0303860232,
-0.0367032327,
0.0675920099,
-0.0722707883,
-0.0332028978,
0.0055592232,
-0.0494967103,
0.0783943012,
0.0066677444,
0.0351800844,
0.0401975214,
-0.0039768838,
0.0113052763,
0.0378679447,
-0.0509841442,
-0.0238495972,
-0.046889063,
0.0174744353,
0.0064694635,
-0.0286960378,
-0.005812949,
0.0079907309,
-0.0035151283,
-0.0234638583,
0.01850654,
-0.0145400781,
-0.0644873828,
0.0470653363,
0.0073494045,
-0.0169409588,
-0.0179001149,
0.0575011112,
0.0566955544,
0.0172067676,
0.0356823839,
0.0003192312,
0.00463366,
0.0451463796,
-0.0041285018,
-0.0029925823,
0.0334482379,
-0.0151391989,
-0.042758815,
0.0055453302,
-0.0205246452,
-0.0489137284,
0.0314248502,
-0.0225082301,
-0.0398455374,
-0.0296484437,
0.0248517841,
-0.0142888762,
-0.002385844,
-0.0109564811,
-0.0215767827,
-0.0104452213,
-0.0330924056,
-0.0151966978,
0.0326410085,
-0.0222190972,
0.0236296672,
0.0278320406,
0.0080516012,
-0.0062891319,
-0.0145140588,
0.0044228509,
0.0364439748,
-0.0298696216,
-0.0648154616,
-0.0083862226,
0.0592022352,
0.0262498781,
0.054822024,
-0.0277363788,
-0.0515141971,
-0.0410287455,
-0.0129007641,
-0.0019593565,
-0.017911721,
-0.0076254318,
-0.0048565073,
-0.0607085302,
-0.0056896065,
0.0789650753,
0.0158915184,
-0.0355659164,
-0.0309579447,
0.0045206957,
-0.0647654608,
0.0518686622,
0.0082795145,
0.0339279547,
0.0191999096,
-0.085678257,
0.0029326158,
-0.0241794344,
0.0313764997,
-0.035129346,
0.0230115522,
-0.0185031909,
0.0094959913,
-0.0118672783,
-0.0131566413,
0.0376298912,
-0.0040131784,
0.0028407073,
0.0199633259,
0.006144349,
0.023710167,
0.0055989651,
0.018910801,
-0.0416863784,
-0.0258129388,
-0.0003748081,
-0.007144867,
-0.0381056592,
0.0556958355,
0.0646289364,
-0.0557828918,
0.0031944439,
-0.003861913,
0.0615453348,
0.0550709777,
0.0163829904,
-0.0164610017,
-0.0545845591,
0.0211900547,
-0.0097045377,
-0.0013651378,
-0.0261513591,
-0.0383334197,
0.033890333,
-0.053942278,
-0.0067017409,
0.0589660034,
0.0212726444,
-0.0019022877,
0.0282431412,
0.0008772008,
0.0743131042,
0.0080563985,
-0.0328351334,
-0.12320856,
-0.0103001753,
0.0045479508,
0.0246122163,
0.0443026274,
-0.0507775843,
0.0216713082,
-0.0812370554,
0.0007875198,
0.0544990115,
-0.0306228809,
-0.0194797926,
-0.017562367,
-0.0521916822,
-0.0454255715,
0.0213343259,
0.018093925,
-0.033856295,
0.011599509,
0.0033474404,
-0.0425414033,
0.0126999784,
-0.0051379898,
-0.0030983097,
-0.0114805168,
-0.0046059601,
0.0396678448,
0.0080293352,
0.0087419348,
0.0454550721,
-0.0158397518,
0.009272892,
-0.0514362045,
0.0087120151,
-0.0108481422,
0.004190539,
-0.0235785618,
-0.018559806,
-0.0396728367,
-0.0212824009,
-0.0625786558,
0.0727942213,
-0.0063855164,
-0.0082828049,
-0.0056053223,
-0.0482005924,
-0.0080904821,
0.0363755077,
0.0398315527,
0.0420786254,
-0.0924906731,
-0.0299607664,
0.031947989,
-0.0552193783,
-0.0124511132,
0.0272915792,
-0.0284934416,
-0.0038352632,
-0.038140595,
-0.0570013076,
0.0049370998,
-0.0309275407,
-0.0601857528,
0.0088834679,
0.0315805338,
-0.0257189386,
-0.0853583738,
0.0167715196,
-0.0001568492,
0.0228116326,
0.0047242157,
-0.0243699551,
0.0125806006,
0.0229137745,
-0.0330908038,
0.034128204,
-0.0302287247,
-0.0566480979,
0.002637679,
0.0281806774,
0.002315124,
0.0554067083,
-0.0050996658,
0.0302994549,
0.0308460668,
-0.0473752618,
-0.0161936898,
0.0058907848,
0.0519486591,
0.0661084056,
-0.0002225769,
0.0351489708,
-0.0204198584,
0.0254291892,
-0.0241190046,
0.0901479721,
0.0121543016,
0.003695911,
0.0581293814,
0.1055504382,
0.0331728794,
0.0047899564,
-0.029980652,
0.0107068038,
0.0080356356,
-0.0422729962,
-0.0196326468,
-0.0347429514,
0.0436655469,
0.0355201401,
-0.0315638743,
-0.0261615142,
-0.0161708239,
0.0154164555,
-0.0102360928,
0.0042813299,
0.0507993698,
0.0027085999,
-0.0055850986,
0.0283985771,
0.0285714809,
-0.0326731764,
-0.0281755496,
0.0107088676,
-0.0063836891,
-0.035892874,
-0.0098850075,
0.0113114929,
0.0152958743,
-0.0616118386,
0.0514663234,
-0.0138265826,
0.0176401939,
0.0112229474,
-0.0398070067,
0.0519700758,
0.0166824143,
0.1323463619,
0.0173204038,
0.0272108708,
-0.0277541801,
0.0664622709,
-0.0076685171,
-0.0540900305,
0.0255397614,
0.0108333053,
-0.0032398913,
-0.0326275118,
0.0221432969,
-0.0048937355,
0.0317912027,
-0.0084990952,
-0.0150099648,
-0.0500228293,
-0.0082974769,
-0.0301684868,
0.0212314259,
-0.0162786413,
-0.0322662741,
-0.0235141329,
-0.0758541524,
0.0110557023,
0.0111154495,
0.0316752344,
0.0043204981,
0.020027319,
0.0145439981,
0.035192728,
-0.0798995048,
-0.017156342,
-0.017346343,
-0.0449901186,
-0.0219560955,
-0.0337071195,
-6.320302517e-33,
-0.0186418574,
0.0051239845,
-0.004887613,
0.0002674159,
-0.0775692612,
0.0071961046,
-0.0720677301,
-0.0124911005,
0.001398418,
0.008272076,
0.0213211533,
0.0092316391,
0.0104929237,
0.007952868,
0.0064948546,
0.0178369973,
0.0657710135,
-0.0167564675,
-0.0019058926,
0.0206667036,
0.057796739,
0.0555157438,
0.0474723354,
-0.0391581804,
-0.0225690901,
-0.0108699445,
0.0092610773,
-0.0257789604,
0.0143377641,
0.0445266627,
0.0245884527,
0.0485604927,
0.0412096567,
0.043048583,
-0.0623669997,
-0.0315213427,
-0.1506069303,
-0.0075126975,
0.0288514104,
0.0209714975,
-0.0527589694,
-0.0192090236,
0.0416847058,
-0.0419969745,
0.0051820269,
-0.0366278924,
0.0176109038,
0.0051237666,
-0.0138357403,
0.0011746167,
-0.0102528734,
0.023549838,
-0.0132327713,
0.0353922211,
0.0825573653,
0.0017781913,
0.0008747676,
-0.0169525836,
-0.036976099,
0.0018208744,
-0.0547908731,
0.001308869,
0.0053527472,
0.0242064726,
0.0325585417,
0.0242664497,
0.0304283313,
-0.0414053574,
0.0274731368,
0.058384344,
-0.0151783843,
0.0765209496,
-0.0396855958,
-0.0073036915,
0.0585680977,
-0.0160346124,
-0.0351433605,
-0.0350166,
-0.0166352205,
0.0908861905,
-0.0387943648,
0.0740898624,
-0.0290899966,
-0.0264711715,
0.0006277772,
-0.0312271751,
-0.0020341468,
-0.040607661,
0.0429956764,
-0.0110277068,
-0.0348011963,
0.0391995348,
0.0246503111,
-0.0424581431,
0.0178844947,
0.0314163826,
0.0030454262,
0.030480694,
-0.0145053742,
0.0131811798,
-0.0495421104,
-0.0517677143,
-0.012788712,
-0.0178395994,
0.0332145281,
-0.0023819329,
0.0564141273,
0.0051510539,
0.0022217077,
0.0219874159,
-0.0383441448,
-0.0395153761,
-0.0290880818,
0.0153387273,
0.0486651212,
0.0193532147,
-0.0141432378,
0.0217827167,
0.0286651291,
0.0620347671,
-0.029672578,
0.0691958219,
0.0167446267,
0.0469747409,
-0.0201118439,
0.0006747016,
-0.0040054438,
0.0310717728,
0.0612554923,
-0.0443951525,
-0.0445814505,
-0.0096464437,
2.855e-7,
0.0602740236,
0.0429152958,
0.0902161226,
0.0336370692,
-0.0221160911,
-0.0387025252,
-0.0322088376,
0.0395401344,
-0.0030883383,
0.0011474453,
0.0200146548,
0.0067070434,
0.0109512927,
0.0315968245,
-0.0658444688,
0.0670119375,
-0.0784460381,
-0.0260585826,
0.0012893459,
0.050492283,
0.0684811696,
0.017656412,
-0.0140894298,
0.0198282469,
-0.0264847055,
0.0042665009,
0.0068579339,
0.0156058352,
0.0432531126,
-0.0213017985,
-0.0844423547,
-0.0327025354,
-0.0200428292,
-0.021524569,
-0.004237568,
0.0094837248,
0.0055154776,
0.0415446609,
-0.0591921285,
-0.0011527899,
0.0206235908,
-0.0244835038,
0.0048988205,
0.0116329808,
0.0322581716,
-0.029475322,
-0.0492171459,
-0.0280386452,
-0.0897576213,
0.0219838694,
-0.005849923,
0.0350218788,
-0.0041158861,
0.0297582,
0.0440751277,
-0.017697921,
-0.0199853424,
-0.0555289127,
-0.0210398436,
0.0323940068,
0.0326601788,
-0.0345035978,
-0.0105616068,
0.0620494857,
-0.0041340068,
-0.0702298954,
-0.0565566495,
2.74731879e-34,
0.0371779688,
0.0062594153,
0.028422229,
0.0433828123,
0.0330382399,
-0.0433484688,
-0.0232119672,
0.04699919,
-0.0241526254,
-0.0750597939,
-0.0230203215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08840v1 | Large Language Models as Source Planner for Personalized Knowledge-grounded Dialogue | 2023-10-13T03:38:38 | 2023-10-13T03:38:38 | Hongru Wang, Minda Hu, Yang Deng, Rui Wang, Fei Mi, Weichao Wang, Yasheng Wang, Wai-Chung Kwan, Irwin King, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open-domain dialogue system usually requires different sources of knowledge
to generate more informative and evidential responses. However, existing
knowledge-grounded dialogue systems either focus on a single knowledge source
or overlook the dependency between multiple sources of knowledge, which may
result in generating inconsistent or even paradoxical responses. To incorporate
multiple knowledge sources and dependencies between them, we propose SAFARI, a
novel framework that leverages the exceptional capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) in planning, understanding, and incorporating under both
supervised and unsupervised settings. Specifically, SAFARI decouples the
knowledge grounding into multiple sources and response generation, which allows
easy extension to various knowledge sources including the possibility of not
using any sources. To study the problem, we construct a personalized
knowledge-grounded dialogue dataset \textit{\textbf{K}nowledge \textbf{B}ehind
\textbf{P}ersona}~(\textbf{KBP}), which is the first to consider the dependency
between persona and implicit knowledge. Experimental results on the KBP dataset
demonstrate that the SAFARI framework can effectively produce
persona-consistent and knowledge-enhanced responses. | [
0.0855025798,
0.0365072936,
-0.0188914295,
0.0560936518,
-0.0193382781,
-0.0356646813,
0.0186913051,
-0.0260078125,
0.0133402944,
-0.0365038551,
-0.0414862074,
0.0278944708,
-0.0246848501,
0.0333164521,
0.0263433792,
-0.046517916,
0.0395536683,
-0.0458129048,
0.0136757474,
-0.0312157627,
0.0262404438,
0.0366410054,
-0.0361861624,
0.0655132681,
-0.026003452,
-0.0369836316,
-0.0194201935,
-0.0178830009,
0.0042482573,
-0.0072097429,
0.0070195226,
0.0408606417,
0.0272910111,
0.0012339642,
0.0000019723,
-0.0381681547,
0.0293423068,
-0.0373889469,
-0.0425541997,
-0.0053327731,
-0.0300945975,
0.0300907753,
0.0331697911,
0.0107492069,
-0.0675507113,
-0.0198646225,
0.0135911824,
0.0991139412,
0.0838206038,
0.0382793956,
-0.0080355257,
-0.0395937935,
-0.0007957014,
-0.005796473,
0.0050209104,
-0.0430031158,
0.0278151259,
0.0112866508,
-0.0314277597,
0.0261219367,
0.0119298389,
0.0044300896,
0.0026384315,
-0.0648479164,
0.046671465,
0.012132966,
-0.0411257632,
-0.0163045991,
-0.0097045181,
0.1330167949,
0.0825572386,
0.0083119553,
-0.0090910522,
0.0072191912,
0.0134489872,
0.0104799448,
-0.0351393148,
0.0055964054,
-0.0043993187,
-0.0201463327,
-0.0394976512,
0.0330655351,
-0.0138847837,
0.0308632255,
-0.023609722,
0.0993089527,
-0.0039854851,
-0.0156679712,
0.0265469234,
0.0052028089,
-0.0057264501,
-0.0771385133,
-0.0246219933,
0.0521604456,
-0.0219705459,
0.0368046574,
-0.0277971774,
0.0169431157,
0.0160191748,
-0.0324038938,
0.004867136,
0.0265448801,
-0.0346988328,
0.0610165969,
-0.0022095728,
0.0373888426,
-0.0265363157,
-0.0347741134,
0.013099879,
0.0038951924,
-0.032823246,
-0.0073512788,
-0.036556825,
0.0331051797,
-0.1009756029,
-0.0159938745,
0.0114092762,
0.0521440245,
-0.0292208474,
0.015058714,
0.0335702524,
0.0366894938,
-0.0190170575,
-0.009020092,
-0.0636825934,
0.053123828,
-0.0746428147,
0.0280146617,
-0.0048282449,
-0.0329816043,
0.0013808723,
0.0267312136,
-0.0002019227,
-0.0037748071,
-0.021628784,
0.0245541185,
-0.0212395526,
0.010523241,
-0.0443295054,
-0.0462213829,
-0.0448366627,
-0.060428977,
-0.0232401751,
-0.0351910852,
0.0425588414,
0.010376568,
-0.0232885815,
-0.0583169907,
0.0360760242,
0.0065837321,
-0.0319986381,
0.0553771406,
-0.0005825378,
0.0194400623,
0.034834858,
0.0214502364,
-0.0317534097,
0.0709098056,
-0.0013369392,
-0.0109080104,
0.0276594404,
0.0086659556,
-0.0473385416,
0.0045866724,
0.0240249652,
0.0263094567,
0.0282217022,
0.0476412363,
-0.011978548,
0.0261121988,
0.0408084914,
0.0434374996,
-0.0416045375,
-0.0091094915,
0.0570980385,
0.0424729325,
-0.02995071,
0.0587322563,
0.0446203537,
0.0321896039,
0.0260045137,
-0.0048107402,
-0.0034632655,
0.0162853692,
-0.0181564875,
-0.0282695927,
0.0067424113,
0.0227847639,
-0.0456925072,
-0.0304904003,
0.0187760703,
0.0064966576,
0.0065555614,
0.0216272026,
0.0259683337,
0.0271071065,
-0.0294513199,
0.0631591231,
0.0245227162,
-0.0447297022,
-0.0262798257,
-0.0200638548,
0.0632547066,
0.0526935719,
0.0162053201,
-0.0038204782,
-0.0298110377,
-0.0127917193,
0.0090310909,
0.0590122603,
0.0148662552,
-0.0465893596,
0.0075738309,
-0.0455312915,
-0.03195462,
-0.0328297652,
-0.0213918723,
0.0423153304,
0.025667822,
0.008120643,
0.0080953361,
0.0164132398,
0.0784462765,
0.0026717801,
-0.0476865061,
0.0064005936,
0.0086032944,
0.0123542473,
0.0291496664,
0.0405918211,
0.0065676314,
-0.0081279613,
0.0545795672,
-0.0253793448,
-0.0233271178,
0.0211216845,
-0.0405833907,
-0.0421619751,
0.0408904292,
0.0079359608,
0.0025269589,
-0.0315143205,
0.000933692,
-0.0628736243,
0.0428552516,
-0.012013278,
0.0545153916,
-0.0473118499,
-0.003194625,
0.0273356307,
0.0156565849,
-0.0337612703,
0.0611715838,
0.0029595336,
-0.0148582691,
0.0483756699,
0.0206011776,
0.0184494331,
-0.0393854976,
-0.0056087961,
0.0066385977,
0.0130702946,
0.0008323467,
0.0224700384,
-0.0043094908,
-0.0500898212,
-0.0204032622,
-0.1339690387,
-0.0118897147,
-0.0030110974,
-0.0277158841,
-0.0126245273,
0.0234725513,
0.0065084244,
-0.0283088796,
-0.0586477555,
0.0252045486,
0.0317975841,
0.0013912553,
0.0233852938,
0.042289272,
0.0095554572,
-0.0206696577,
0.0313328654,
0.0184570234,
0.0405283235,
-0.0046824957,
0.0109119052,
-0.0577439032,
0.0137629258,
-0.0788561925,
0.0573958866,
-0.0194005575,
-0.0174792632,
0.0205051713,
0.0033367421,
0.0622095279,
0.0263866223,
0.0088169212,
0.043959856,
0.0202035587,
-0.0282290243,
-0.0936838314,
0.0510067008,
-0.0075273528,
-0.0109193483,
-0.0539268292,
0.0240461621,
-0.0032186711,
0.0174293909,
0.0354952551,
-0.0006791003,
-0.0774548724,
0.0470022671,
0.0347464979,
-0.0468663536,
-0.0143527947,
-0.0277907271,
-0.0128538944,
0.0521082841,
-0.0062715248,
0.0119753741,
0.0739213824,
-0.0251946487,
-0.0078499774,
-0.0028321578,
0.0234315861,
-0.038312111,
0.0395731777,
-0.0633874834,
0.0182386059,
-0.0005253548,
-0.0004326291,
-0.029372789,
-0.0094072223,
0.0022906801,
-0.0182200354,
0.0733184963,
-0.0590616427,
0.0176506024,
0.0165573303,
-0.0632092133,
-0.082861647,
-0.0400953554,
-0.0295941848,
-0.0250906423,
0.0082299784,
-0.0227249004,
-0.0300116893,
0.0069812448,
0.0453024358,
0.0064500952,
-0.0182680488,
0.0006540605,
-0.0275076292,
0.0183339082,
0.0462405756,
0.0302599519,
0.01047731,
0.0226379,
0.0632910505,
0.0410033874,
0.0165919568,
-0.0366622508,
0.0058429344,
-0.0048664263,
0.041089084,
0.0024480317,
-0.0035471891,
-0.0070815859,
0.0472928882,
-0.0034524282,
-0.0103119574,
0.1157725528,
0.0262592342,
-0.035240341,
-0.0113544473,
-0.0577512272,
0.0218555797,
0.0217712913,
0.0397580303,
-0.0529333204,
-0.0167398285,
-0.0223647505,
0.0089238957,
-0.0083673038,
-0.0638635755,
-0.0060822759,
-0.1302247047,
0.0134326844,
-0.0066200225,
-0.0241079032,
-0.0391306058,
-0.0094221504,
0.0158177298,
0.0121360049,
0.0022957793,
0.0039469008,
0.025881324,
-0.007124132,
-0.0097225467,
-0.0124503877,
-0.0395976417,
0.022433117,
-0.0037693139,
0.0584569611,
0.0428018123,
0.0529488623,
0.0369499736,
-0.0413138159,
-0.0455318913,
-0.0118856216,
0.0095269056,
-0.0118775386,
0.0227844901,
-0.0052394359,
-0.0149940215,
-0.0397463739,
0.0258370135,
-0.0476107188,
-0.0174163654,
0.0446967147,
0.0366756655,
-0.0492607504,
0.0258392468,
0.0001607885,
0.0470231995,
0.0387203842,
0.0899216905,
0.0138962129,
-0.0438703001,
0.0104239834,
-0.0179550871,
-0.0168448389,
-0.038490925,
-0.0314766355,
0.0182978455,
0.0005283643,
0.020697495,
-0.0939747691,
-0.0294372998,
0.037371058,
0.0308527518,
0.0150514217,
-0.0119770002,
0.0030643085,
0.028846683,
0.0133353118,
0.0335390866,
-0.0215742737,
0.0097702155,
-0.049529098,
-0.0396821387,
0.0614536256,
-0.0544830337,
-0.0054166494,
0.0378351286,
-0.0189833287,
-0.0731028318,
-0.0369730331,
0.0530479327,
0.0225509703,
0.0685238764,
-0.0007447315,
-0.0509346351,
-0.0038660462,
-0.0110506061,
-0.0556300879,
0.0161030106,
0.0107792877,
0.0485910065,
-0.0140947802,
0.0540709719,
-0.0344929732,
0.0173541103,
-0.0093531488,
0.035062328,
-0.0473487787,
-0.0764830559,
-0.006431086,
0.0013050179,
0.0423935279,
0.0161812566,
-0.0249957405,
-0.0288939364,
0.0217370838,
-0.0481665917,
-0.04331268,
-0.0648159757,
0.0027195849,
0.0067695482,
-0.0385346264,
0.0139957266,
-0.0319310501,
-0.0270167664,
0.0435754582,
-0.010506643,
-0.0081335055,
0.0605192296,
0.0021270006,
0.0240378827,
0.0066167633,
-0.0266783759,
0.02943944,
0.0037609057,
-0.0028006744,
-0.0110041443,
0.0963019207,
-0.0035827989,
-0.0383349806,
0.0168079119,
-0.0166732017,
-0.049039755,
-0.0329712331,
0.0145171508,
0.0336071514,
0.0300747752,
0.0363398455,
0.058165703,
-0.0270691216,
-0.0065291729,
0.0017108745,
0.0462622605,
0.0043122745,
-0.0308084637,
0.0600151345,
0.0204313044,
-0.0374224447,
0.019977659,
0.072363466,
0.0126321539,
0.044503659,
-0.0135107804,
0.0003757965,
-0.048448585,
-0.0338482596,
0.007700874,
0.0316866226,
-0.0015825867,
0.0385547131,
-0.0587786995,
-0.0343759097,
0.0186479278,
-0.0041215038,
-0.0387017578,
-0.0061855968,
0.038664721,
0.0456884615,
0.0003688953,
-0.0369587578,
-0.0518601201,
0.0551065318,
-0.0560470559,
-0.0252874196,
-0.0368097797,
-5.912023207e-33,
-0.071610488,
-0.0156449936,
0.0284134708,
-0.0175738148,
-0.041235406,
-0.0148799028,
-0.0378618799,
0.0244563613,
-0.0325630531,
0.0110597592,
-0.0281810872,
-0.0066049411,
-0.0039798305,
0.0254755728,
-0.0258726012,
-0.0119834226,
0.0446257889,
0.0004594183,
0.0135042621,
0.0669202283,
0.0602789,
0.0135997524,
0.0095406156,
-0.0844858959,
0.0250692014,
-0.0261974242,
-0.0049036229,
0.0480485186,
0.0117380088,
0.0848065093,
-0.0398473255,
0.0692165866,
-0.0066428971,
-0.0199634451,
-0.0026761382,
0.0212720893,
-0.0732879192,
-0.0310093462,
0.0688136891,
0.0081325965,
-0.014095705,
-0.0431132354,
-0.008259654,
-0.0143334381,
0.0141508579,
0.013238769,
0.0224326532,
-0.024391178,
-0.0248839185,
-0.0177582502,
-0.0378060229,
-0.0024781793,
-0.0304511748,
-0.0297572706,
-0.0222798213,
0.0493641794,
0.0122995116,
-0.06631051,
-0.0371158384,
0.0363957286,
-0.0167685784,
-0.0500617549,
0.0328406803,
0.029047383,
0.0185843613,
0.0392905101,
-0.009335991,
0.0014275562,
-0.0503980219,
-0.0465900265,
-0.020054644,
0.0562647991,
0.0052089272,
0.085350588,
-0.0799059868,
-0.0055597425,
-0.0615661964,
-0.002751915,
0.0329805575,
0.0175884403,
0.025847204,
-0.0017142429,
-0.0177683644,
-0.0164115336,
-0.0404393561,
-0.0054251417,
-0.0226302724,
-0.0190570783,
0.026529178,
0.0106807025,
-0.0178280398,
-0.0099406904,
0.0365295075,
-0.0502512902,
0.0052889325,
0.0839215592,
-0.0211732071,
0.0165487789,
-0.0041184784,
0.0137666482,
-0.0576614588,
0.0168390647,
0.0468774363,
-0.0324420482,
-0.0099772895,
0.0601578541,
-0.0089247627,
-0.0353840515,
-0.0324950181,
-0.0200330112,
-0.0308655407,
0.0396187603,
-0.0268144868,
0.031195974,
0.0080838623,
0.0249593537,
-0.0460152142,
0.0544816256,
0.0097743561,
-0.0280482061,
-0.008021554,
-0.0656605288,
0.046105966,
0.0091904998,
-0.0451113544,
0.0022511303,
0.003003248,
-0.0172456261,
0.0070357886,
-0.0276698675,
-0.0174212866,
0.0207822938,
2.614e-7,
-0.0098808035,
-0.0013141475,
0.0047903345,
0.011994997,
0.0210201368,
0.0229982026,
0.0028865947,
0.0107232844,
0.0066582728,
-0.0497437306,
-0.011642877,
0.0558082238,
0.0388996489,
0.0053690015,
-0.1176436618,
-0.0250924993,
-0.0207894705,
-0.0421749912,
-0.0553052686,
-0.0131188827,
0.0438486114,
0.0390865654,
0.0246471837,
0.0224368889,
-0.0229237042,
-0.002144279,
0.071517624,
-0.0085041858,
-0.0109361187,
0.0082560368,
0.062435016,
-0.0112947654,
-0.0078823837,
0.0475988202,
0.0119475499,
0.0459732488,
0.0000043913,
0.0817087665,
-0.0005285353,
-0.0433843993,
-0.0048189196,
0.0023034129,
0.0091282791,
-0.0396311469,
0.0726401731,
-0.024082493,
-0.0215081684,
0.023682503,
-0.012091645,
-0.035894379,
-0.0147494636,
-0.0362685136,
-0.0233164169,
0.0212161429,
0.0238995105,
-0.0295379739,
0.0104090087,
-0.0892858133,
0.0090680495,
-0.0074342317,
-0.0638108999,
-0.0511992835,
-0.0131500056,
-0.0309678651,
0.011896858,
-0.0312132854,
0.0259386767,
2.125745387e-34,
-0.0048132627,
0.0321004912,
0.0013976982,
0.0111377714,
0.0509821028,
-0.0098445537,
-0.014653679,
0.0176032148,
0.039352715,
-0.1072499529,
-0.0066001061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08797v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08797v1 | A Comparative Analysis of Task-Agnostic Distillation Methods for Compressing Transformer Language Models | 2023-10-13T01:00:15 | 2023-10-13T01:00:15 | Takuma Udagawa, Aashka Trivedi, Michele Merler, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have become a vital component in modern NLP, achieving
state of the art performance in a variety of tasks. However, they are often
inefficient for real-world deployment due to their expensive inference costs.
Knowledge distillation is a promising technique to improve their efficiency
while retaining most of their effectiveness. In this paper, we reproduce,
compare and analyze several representative methods for task-agnostic
(general-purpose) distillation of Transformer language models. Our target of
study includes Output Distribution (OD) transfer, Hidden State (HS) transfer
with various layer mapping strategies, and Multi-Head Attention (MHA) transfer
based on MiniLMv2. Through our extensive experiments, we study the
effectiveness of each method for various student architectures in both
monolingual (English) and multilingual settings. Overall, we show that MHA
transfer based on MiniLMv2 is generally the best option for distillation and
explain the potential reasons behind its success. Moreover, we show that HS
transfer remains as a competitive baseline, especially under a sophisticated
layer mapping strategy, while OD transfer consistently lags behind other
approaches. Findings from this study helped us deploy efficient yet effective
student models for latency-critical applications. | [
0.0060594259,
0.0489303134,
-0.0158706531,
0.0450102016,
-0.0427236445,
-0.0077410517,
0.0111056473,
-0.0048480956,
-0.0178380683,
-0.017529564,
-0.0174953695,
-0.0321535692,
0.0090670241,
0.0145953298,
0.0234603751,
-0.0234574135,
0.0223722216,
-0.0492122285,
-0.0538780764,
-0.0018911776,
-0.0173965879,
-0.0053448784,
0.024969833,
0.0471790358,
0.0226237867,
-0.020360902,
-0.0176848955,
0.0151310191,
0.0214153659,
0.0266246554,
-0.0099339122,
0.0485807173,
0.009240672,
-0.0030004724,
0.0000021059,
-0.0095194681,
-0.0043213824,
0.011215644,
-0.0203671101,
0.0235149506,
0.0266306922,
-0.0238361154,
-0.016638238,
0.0342687853,
-0.0241346359,
-0.013720437,
0.0790487528,
0.0207234696,
0.075975351,
0.0494135879,
-0.0165108014,
-0.038564954,
0.0280284286,
-0.0359504521,
-0.0420180075,
-0.0401932262,
0.0314703435,
-0.0125450408,
-0.0358323753,
-0.0118238088,
-0.0286647119,
0.0690221339,
0.0403852239,
-0.0140079372,
-0.0210054163,
0.0319170654,
-0.0376415923,
-0.0210725497,
-0.0275846887,
0.0721377507,
-0.0691927746,
-0.0198300052,
0.0107750921,
0.0229760967,
-0.0229450297,
-0.010412273,
-0.0519469567,
0.0161913205,
0.0169517547,
0.022362493,
0.0015927048,
-0.0031894138,
0.0239701308,
-0.0191817321,
-0.0368777886,
0.0277057104,
0.0200045891,
-0.0009989298,
-0.0143498816,
0.0094883405,
-0.027618967,
-0.0554666743,
0.0328802206,
0.0350130722,
0.0355077237,
0.0123116961,
-0.0546138808,
-0.0623814389,
-0.0221139695,
-0.0333805978,
0.0866683424,
0.0472853743,
-0.0052530589,
0.0274375062,
-0.0559987687,
0.073483713,
-0.0170347914,
0.0256501324,
-0.0201296005,
-0.0242087301,
-0.0410071425,
0.0145547511,
-0.049892813,
0.0465183035,
-0.0582762286,
-0.0497352034,
0.0159847531,
0.0116544543,
-0.0247477051,
-0.041284062,
0.0480106138,
0.0114554428,
-0.0460337996,
0.0021024016,
0.0092659751,
0.094469592,
0.0116598532,
-0.0105448626,
0.0105981231,
-0.0746154264,
-0.0537538603,
0.030300837,
-0.0060209832,
-0.01633895,
-0.0307608414,
0.0534929335,
-0.0196653865,
-0.0228252448,
-0.0205087997,
0.0307405479,
-0.0272633359,
-0.0638122335,
0.0166351553,
-0.0747931525,
0.0323612131,
-0.003338353,
0.0099243727,
-0.0664230809,
0.0116489371,
0.0165269841,
-0.0182539094,
0.0430770069,
0.0227378309,
0.030858906,
-0.0151059311,
0.015477512,
-0.0099722492,
0.0759015679,
0.0289512239,
0.0543930046,
-0.00799275,
-0.0309500992,
0.0003700888,
0.0510017425,
0.0505425744,
0.0401410349,
-0.0398677066,
-0.0254634991,
-0.0159374308,
-0.0351428948,
0.0539120585,
0.095296748,
-0.0185962468,
0.0101249907,
0.0771368667,
0.0107832653,
0.0481031984,
0.0043953359,
0.0155714005,
0.0311777145,
-0.0103363562,
0.0007339469,
-0.0390672423,
0.0433924384,
0.0110722389,
-0.0058206054,
0.0300007425,
0.0791999251,
-0.0371126644,
-0.0195066277,
-0.0084510241,
-0.0029441267,
0.0078612696,
0.0260888431,
0.0390473641,
0.042247273,
-0.0327733159,
0.1207763925,
0.0394205488,
-0.0371559225,
0.0204484928,
-0.0600184053,
-0.0356403142,
0.0331684947,
0.028213108,
0.0273402091,
-0.0002193609,
-0.0025126801,
0.0148559446,
0.0364987999,
0.022843862,
-0.0045120297,
0.0394854061,
-0.0374229588,
-0.0114005981,
0.0273116156,
0.0114024915,
0.0016620931,
0.0205157232,
0.0084544513,
0.0297159068,
-0.055076912,
-0.0230766777,
0.0184073411,
-0.0405763872,
-0.0200939886,
-0.0015856852,
0.0012621837,
0.0129149025,
-0.0193505362,
-0.008740712,
0.0016486929,
0.0294989459,
-0.0476312488,
-0.0055619259,
-0.0060229194,
-0.0285655335,
-0.0612176396,
0.0176310576,
-0.0167334229,
0.0631479993,
0.0963954628,
-0.0446284376,
-0.0543370843,
0.0176312514,
-0.0462123416,
0.0320951715,
-0.0099155465,
0.0324212201,
0.0060685859,
0.0392803736,
-0.0303955879,
0.0210593399,
-0.0353231691,
-0.0219378285,
-0.0019831685,
-0.0469294824,
-0.0247132462,
0.0069957348,
-0.0282909907,
0.03507163,
-0.0411923975,
0.0129865548,
-0.002438789,
-0.009213523,
0.0021428384,
-0.029444525,
-0.0554739051,
0.0030586401,
-0.0570164137,
0.0412831195,
0.046473369,
0.0461605601,
0.0166619625,
-0.0100748464,
-0.030839067,
0.0162755698,
-0.0176569168,
0.0200765319,
0.0016576146,
-0.0075101578,
-0.0050066272,
-0.0323824845,
-0.0414783098,
0.0245752037,
0.0488983393,
-0.073444508,
-0.0363809615,
-0.037417721,
0.0246136039,
0.0079854578,
0.040971864,
-0.0163436681,
-0.0347368605,
-0.0133920358,
-0.006486746,
0.0678072348,
0.0262323339,
-0.0076253409,
0.0235828981,
0.0459750518,
-0.002206502,
-0.0558174588,
0.0334022343,
-0.0357417352,
-0.0047289114,
-0.0489317141,
-0.0299238376,
-0.0002807525,
0.0807419792,
-0.0168277603,
-0.0180731434,
-0.0761825517,
-0.015609595,
-0.0100255189,
-0.0269087385,
-0.0018522209,
0.0345440954,
-0.0272911955,
0.0116481697,
-0.0366825685,
-0.0328412466,
0.0331377946,
-0.0462187417,
-0.0107922358,
-0.0422167517,
-0.0050506708,
-0.0171204209,
0.0426050872,
0.0018156153,
0.0168804917,
-0.0238933116,
-0.0273209251,
-0.0409621336,
0.033681035,
-0.0083919056,
-0.0290874466,
0.0845026001,
-0.0188438054,
-0.001427573,
-0.0271836296,
-0.0385693312,
-0.0239247512,
-0.020277014,
-0.0041126162,
0.0400906652,
0.0471271314,
-0.0194599759,
-0.0389130153,
0.0515727587,
0.0063577108,
0.0655784532,
-0.0209714472,
0.0056310724,
-0.0328225493,
0.0288927294,
0.075715594,
0.0326025262,
0.0297500901,
-0.0140057942,
0.0236099884,
0.0662619099,
0.0540698133,
0.0312147494,
-0.0158656128,
-0.0260788146,
0.0683394447,
-0.015906224,
-0.0196305495,
0.0223752875,
0.0546075031,
-0.0706487596,
-0.0153174549,
0.0825778916,
0.0005955496,
-0.0397201926,
0.0264796913,
0.0087333508,
0.0540790521,
0.0103493314,
0.0326343179,
-0.0656579584,
-0.0400112979,
0.010425888,
0.0177458711,
0.0390090235,
-0.011677959,
-0.0139049105,
-0.0957057402,
0.0109910639,
0.0066094506,
-0.0202289969,
-0.0435668975,
-0.0364347287,
0.033557225,
0.0034657242,
0.0153636374,
-0.0127277877,
-0.0182386208,
-0.0170630235,
0.0244221855,
-0.0213610996,
-0.0962616503,
0.0157344416,
0.0028811374,
0.0271155592,
0.0717066377,
0.0095453523,
0.0009218639,
-0.0659901351,
0.0248266496,
-0.0183145925,
-0.0048525478,
-0.0036384375,
0.0324167274,
0.0072523751,
-0.0089767752,
0.0054643615,
-0.0054033916,
-0.0417080484,
0.0062295785,
-0.0332124196,
0.0572175272,
0.011650702,
-0.0666685104,
-0.010973257,
-0.0198303405,
0.0212675333,
0.0850192755,
0.0348958597,
-0.0360528752,
-0.0513124317,
0.0051925983,
-0.0059016771,
-0.023783356,
-0.0239166804,
0.0188339837,
0.0217770413,
-0.0616606548,
-0.0396209843,
-0.0169223007,
0.0149460481,
0.0286443923,
0.0082820999,
-0.0003756607,
0.0440967083,
0.0029348396,
-0.0427970663,
0.0014247803,
-0.0279779844,
0.0073486189,
-0.0251295324,
0.0068821739,
-0.007597629,
-0.0083310939,
-0.0184888113,
0.0005066052,
-0.161049664,
-0.0611719266,
0.0192364193,
0.0439315848,
0.0211002864,
0.0307095125,
-0.0292985644,
-0.0549382418,
0.0187573098,
0.0124363182,
-0.0193673782,
0.0221642721,
0.0302811004,
-0.0646077469,
0.0079057999,
0.0539717674,
-0.0265126415,
0.0299944263,
0.035714332,
0.0751982555,
-0.0250802953,
-0.027087966,
-0.0124641117,
0.0038463315,
0.0465443879,
0.0204741787,
0.004048869,
0.0050196433,
0.0286005717,
0.0122413263,
0.0199299138,
-0.0626487806,
-0.0159455668,
0.0308091082,
0.0362778008,
0.023469083,
0.0437126458,
0.0529222675,
-0.013316853,
-0.0380030312,
0.0048587453,
0.0164444949,
-0.0289879981,
0.0588948838,
0.0337166302,
-0.0169043671,
-0.0166467335,
0.0410642363,
0.031198293,
-0.044815056,
0.0226148814,
0.0310963392,
0.0167808328,
-0.0079157539,
0.0365812741,
-0.0687927231,
-0.0498956367,
-0.02018697,
-0.0012128727,
0.0435455665,
0.0164593682,
0.0931780115,
-0.0007046615,
0.0052459156,
-0.0467486419,
0.0123048173,
-0.0066285082,
-0.0022016994,
0.0186942816,
0.0000960289,
0.0003237827,
-0.0017119286,
0.0756929293,
0.0031779539,
0.007987869,
-0.013230117,
0.025647467,
-0.016643025,
-0.0325133838,
-0.0268076286,
0.0210049674,
0.0129290093,
0.0048052818,
-0.0469295047,
-0.078028217,
-0.0118292784,
-0.0452593677,
0.0041646124,
-0.0404861197,
0.0284669157,
0.0501544066,
0.0144739253,
-0.052526895,
-0.0458086766,
-0.0267039295,
0.0069582914,
-0.0215681531,
0.0085056117,
-6.766074954e-33,
-0.0189213268,
-0.0001656231,
0.0115428083,
-0.0186384935,
-0.0372621641,
0.0305856653,
-0.0553874858,
-0.025736358,
-0.0464976206,
0.0138937701,
-0.0390500166,
0.0319364965,
0.0294589996,
0.056530159,
-0.0334777534,
0.0017155006,
0.0785055757,
0.0211379975,
-0.0332073085,
0.0416974016,
0.0158869736,
0.038275566,
0.0512152053,
-0.0195603166,
-0.0317916125,
-0.000177044,
0.0152279837,
-0.0061239237,
0.0194150098,
0.0307602268,
-0.013535874,
0.064719297,
0.0148006082,
-0.0824481994,
-0.04950165,
0.0137714818,
-0.0811598822,
-0.0233731605,
0.0356271639,
-0.0063054296,
-0.0241669882,
-0.0118909469,
0.0404152311,
0.0241329428,
0.0190242436,
-0.0400166735,
0.0089641884,
0.0134626348,
-0.0344008915,
-0.0403885245,
-0.0639983639,
0.0027830559,
0.0194049943,
-0.030534016,
0.0527308136,
0.0356377438,
-0.027970247,
0.0056610387,
-0.0952843055,
-0.0145292161,
0.0141071668,
0.0763153359,
0.1117630675,
0.0366361961,
-0.0140598658,
0.0219455287,
-0.0218084622,
0.0253351517,
-0.0699451566,
-0.0309541523,
0.0696232244,
0.0557853617,
0.0237623472,
-0.0500186197,
0.0283766873,
-0.0229158923,
-0.0290973298,
-0.0375390239,
0.0211171061,
0.0510597527,
0.037465591,
0.0102944672,
-0.0226139482,
-0.0382396728,
-0.0453140847,
0.0011032904,
-0.0069324058,
-0.0262403004,
0.0473107286,
0.0172489528,
-0.0204539951,
-0.0035481448,
0.056532789,
-0.0641707852,
0.0015839306,
0.0250793286,
-0.0152593469,
0.0330103077,
-0.008253403,
0.0216429774,
-0.081825681,
0.0003349649,
0.0140232258,
0.016184438,
-0.0047474159,
0.014424447,
0.0042924508,
0.0426669158,
-0.05394914,
-0.0216955394,
-0.0627953112,
0.0334643796,
0.0136319585,
0.0715329573,
0.0475559644,
-0.002600041,
-0.0142334066,
0.0024752205,
0.0017342773,
-0.0023251614,
-0.0025025227,
0.0425268114,
0.0303084813,
0.0256662704,
-0.0220125653,
0.0092695989,
-0.0706139952,
0.0483397953,
0.0292186271,
-0.0414573699,
-0.0316824466,
0.0312972963,
2.769e-7,
0.0259272028,
0.0215963945,
0.0081669101,
0.0139489267,
0.0167383794,
-0.0054737171,
0.0294555929,
0.0285916179,
0.0106439777,
-0.0071200491,
-0.0460207164,
0.0423050635,
0.0648117289,
0.0054890993,
-0.093381688,
-0.0392286032,
-0.0469312221,
0.0060582976,
0.0060171597,
-0.0356154069,
0.0110442592,
0.0883971006,
0.0065156454,
-0.014870055,
0.0137989679,
0.0145563046,
0.0218204781,
-0.0001127022,
0.0367170312,
0.0385120437,
0.0368921645,
-0.011820375,
-0.0109043466,
0.0094921682,
-0.0164418183,
0.0035196387,
-0.0027630138,
0.0865207165,
-0.0161231644,
-0.0443395674,
-0.0109324846,
-0.0091361776,
-0.0094861211,
-0.0701024383,
0.0644817054,
-0.064580746,
-0.0249663834,
-0.0212851036,
-0.0120282155,
0.0121335564,
-0.0373385027,
0.0058433567,
0.0140198711,
0.0196015183,
0.0223024301,
-0.010276488,
-0.0489544272,
-0.0842677206,
-0.0271201394,
-0.0182976499,
-0.0336092301,
-0.0492869541,
-0.0483046584,
-0.0572251864,
0.0225834474,
-0.0123860622,
-0.0212586429,
2.79689756e-34,
0.010424423,
0.0000903516,
0.0188804008,
0.0378059261,
-0.0231310539,
-0.0275488254,
-0.0237329658,
0.0031953622,
-0.0280153975,
-0.0953189209,
-0.0374379195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08796v1 | End-to-end Story Plot Generator | 2023-10-13T00:49:59 | 2023-10-13T00:49:59 | Hanlin Zhu, Andrew Cohen, Danqing Wang, Kevin Yang, Xiaomeng Yang, Jiantao Jiao, Yuandong Tian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Story plots, while short, carry most of the essential information of a full
story that may contain tens of thousands of words. We study the problem of
automatic generation of story plots, which includes story premise, character
descriptions, plot outlines, etc. To generate a single engaging plot, existing
plot generators (e.g., DOC (Yang et al., 2022a)) require hundreds to thousands
of calls to LLMs (e.g., OpenAI API) in the planning stage of the story plot,
which is costly and takes at least several minutes. Moreover, the hard-wired
nature of the method makes the pipeline non-differentiable, blocking fast
specialization and personalization of the plot generator. In this paper, we
propose three models, $\texttt{OpenPlot}$, $\texttt{E2EPlot}$ and
$\texttt{RLPlot}$, to address these challenges. $\texttt{OpenPlot}$ replaces
expensive OpenAI API calls with LLaMA2 (Touvron et al., 2023) calls via careful
prompt designs, which leads to inexpensive generation of high-quality training
datasets of story plots. We then train an end-to-end story plot generator,
$\texttt{E2EPlot}$, by supervised fine-tuning (SFT) using approximately 13000
story plots generated by $\texttt{OpenPlot}$. $\texttt{E2EPlot}$ generates
story plots of comparable quality to $\texttt{OpenPlot}$, and is > 10$\times$
faster (1k tokens in only 30 seconds on average). Finally, we obtain
$\texttt{RLPlot}$ that is further fine-tuned with RLHF on several different
reward models for different aspects of story quality, which yields 60.0$\%$
winning rate against $\texttt{E2EPlot}$ along the aspect of suspense and
surprise. | [
0.0073439153,
0.0382811986,
-0.0117127681,
0.0264340397,
-0.0214365926,
-0.0027142446,
-0.015993366,
0.0202371869,
-0.0232783295,
0.0153241558,
-0.0118619502,
0.0297767594,
0.0018878668,
0.1142798662,
-0.0291771796,
-0.088929832,
-0.0208095331,
-0.0176617876,
0.043936491,
0.0229049902,
-0.0240745656,
0.0254168026,
-0.0096217683,
0.0440472551,
-0.0564539544,
-0.021026032,
-0.0047490196,
0.0031502191,
0.0751039535,
-0.0585307181,
-0.0405024067,
-0.0228662416,
0.0297686774,
-0.0093957512,
0.0000020741,
-0.0558844507,
-0.0085083144,
-0.0036841792,
0.0208385531,
0.0332063213,
0.0166795384,
0.0068832384,
0.0190335922,
-0.0537667982,
0.008108153,
0.0379296057,
0.0569101833,
0.0651872456,
0.0635301918,
0.0555672348,
-0.0211100485,
-0.0618598089,
-0.0494032539,
-0.0040365844,
0.0158349704,
-0.0152712716,
-0.0357786566,
-0.0576831475,
0.0643706769,
-0.0180095397,
-0.0672184974,
0.020316964,
0.0193379521,
0.0230543744,
0.0201944225,
0.0791285187,
0.003314269,
0.0194182042,
-0.0160270836,
0.1137182862,
-0.0516939498,
-0.0025702193,
0.0149986707,
-0.027121773,
-0.0077820988,
0.0147097381,
-0.061405696,
0.0371028595,
-0.0346668251,
0.0130502265,
-0.011373735,
-0.0033234973,
-0.002523808,
-0.0532892346,
0.0102761546,
-0.0030051093,
0.0072714798,
0.0277540963,
-0.0484468229,
-0.0212813821,
-0.0406410545,
-0.0681240633,
-0.0033360189,
0.0533101112,
0.0205628891,
0.0010558423,
-0.0250533596,
-0.0053028446,
-0.0084677525,
-0.0031139154,
0.0869900212,
-0.0036350954,
-0.0307266917,
0.013532103,
0.0051422729,
0.0168478079,
0.014906927,
-0.0327873416,
0.0183236264,
0.0366655439,
-0.0425114222,
0.0431670919,
-0.0441188551,
0.006902365,
-0.0367308408,
-0.0242899191,
-0.0376484618,
-0.0053118989,
0.0207926519,
0.0167549327,
-0.0221328698,
0.0244238321,
-0.0671882257,
0.0132906307,
-0.0722548962,
0.0181282684,
-0.0830312073,
-0.0180963725,
-0.0039157118,
0.0220346209,
-0.0141751496,
-0.0156338662,
0.0518965833,
0.0137497522,
0.0384722054,
0.0605454743,
0.014071567,
0.0073337387,
-0.06633728,
-0.0683355853,
-0.0036339872,
-0.0473793149,
-0.0299933143,
-0.0520043783,
0.0429989584,
-0.0307264794,
0.0436640531,
-0.0077140993,
0.027778171,
0.0026324575,
-0.0463101901,
0.0318744406,
-0.0075507746,
0.0182783995,
0.0052296296,
0.0090502053,
-0.0385222696,
0.0252967346,
0.0974605456,
0.0602538101,
0.0315127559,
-0.0309942439,
0.0400349461,
0.0271008294,
-0.0133185098,
0.010147389,
0.0087581323,
-0.0071216668,
-0.0086334767,
0.0395965576,
0.0284660496,
0.0052307523,
-0.0421446376,
0.0153694153,
0.04464975,
0.0942835212,
0.0622095093,
0.0184417292,
0.1119656116,
-0.0097688613,
0.0081506055,
0.0129597457,
-0.0050517879,
0.0420582481,
0.0584090389,
0.0160763189,
-0.040618185,
-0.0182887726,
-0.0040517589,
-0.0178088173,
0.0403575301,
-0.0390641801,
-0.0546395667,
-0.0582017824,
0.0055874507,
0.0215343721,
-0.0532124303,
-0.0382356681,
0.0280398205,
-0.0962762535,
0.0301653706,
0.0097575784,
0.0226216726,
0.083236292,
0.0400684252,
0.0056018964,
-0.0017241082,
-0.031741783,
-0.01045305,
0.0389268436,
0.0220126212,
-0.0358737707,
0.0449266769,
-0.0663914233,
-0.0116060209,
-0.0734937415,
-0.0197132528,
0.0709721744,
0.0188920144,
0.0302083977,
-0.030044578,
-0.0350717083,
-0.0633025244,
0.0102862623,
-0.0638651028,
-0.029621534,
0.0033645709,
0.0202425476,
0.0021392086,
-0.0031819276,
-0.0396322347,
-0.0230827797,
0.025935743,
-0.0214563441,
0.0053046676,
0.045036003,
0.0003579747,
0.0127579635,
-0.0118856756,
-0.0503291488,
-0.0057784691,
-0.0329961777,
-0.0017792467,
-0.0534034297,
-0.01587658,
-0.0243533198,
0.0036325173,
0.0285330154,
0.000782306,
0.0057655484,
-0.0065425467,
-0.0381817296,
0.0463661216,
0.0154590094,
-0.0106386663,
0.0080775935,
0.0363859199,
0.0196507536,
-0.0178481005,
0.0143090207,
0.0093955044,
0.0522418022,
-0.0325029902,
-0.0001113338,
-0.0161645468,
-0.0305461828,
-0.0218207408,
-0.0641078502,
-0.0108663207,
0.054614488,
-0.0408859923,
0.0148332547,
-0.0111496793,
-0.0595965497,
-0.0007988022,
-0.0336382911,
0.0346705317,
-0.0101463366,
-0.0499392562,
0.0286242962,
0.0630929023,
-0.0199389737,
0.0189215895,
0.0466794968,
0.0035651785,
0.0163678322,
0.0935385302,
-0.0065707448,
-0.0151015976,
0.056501776,
0.0012723251,
-0.0132799577,
-0.0189697333,
-0.0182026457,
0.0151619576,
0.0166447628,
0.0028892278,
0.0129744634,
-0.0096129552,
0.0054573906,
0.0580713302,
-0.0700241402,
-0.015679637,
0.0405004099,
-0.0168414656,
0.0302374847,
-0.009652975,
-0.0397175141,
0.0463901088,
0.0686139539,
0.0295491368,
0.0347394496,
-0.0425924323,
-0.0230256524,
0.0436975472,
0.0144427419,
0.0487352945,
-0.0214042906,
-0.0096415067,
0.0434848741,
-0.0009787077,
-0.0413284153,
0.0660337433,
-0.0587558113,
0.0082958965,
-0.0381855518,
0.0203366838,
-0.0573703609,
0.0770472065,
-0.0118278107,
0.048724141,
0.0023110183,
0.0018482923,
-0.0197754614,
-0.0062880688,
0.0233757906,
-0.0270520002,
0.012906665,
-0.0212944169,
-0.0534464233,
-0.014033867,
-0.0106182396,
-0.0364145711,
0.0034738788,
-0.0174839273,
-0.0596711822,
0.0301837064,
-0.0644816458,
-0.0326768234,
0.0060147224,
-0.0360039659,
0.0113413418,
-0.0243020263,
-0.0234884322,
0.0114844488,
0.0178808346,
0.0383983143,
-0.0043845167,
-0.0609590858,
-0.0275270268,
0.0650413185,
0.0150117846,
-0.0387389176,
0.0336508118,
0.024444459,
0.024734484,
-0.0170912202,
-0.0016178733,
0.0047693257,
0.0179007743,
0.0679707453,
-0.0509715043,
-0.0191730689,
0.0895426795,
0.0380005278,
-0.0337840244,
0.0007724219,
0.0268422477,
0.0358728692,
0.0066187615,
0.004680465,
-0.0297703166,
0.0156978574,
0.0067596775,
0.0487811193,
-0.0169171598,
-0.0321326107,
-0.0314696692,
-0.0951086059,
0.0976967365,
0.0277544763,
-0.067219533,
0.0185240582,
-0.0209065042,
-0.0029678021,
0.0361441001,
-0.0474317111,
-0.0039576674,
-0.0198978651,
0.0031466815,
-0.0416550413,
-0.0389777087,
-0.0162921641,
-0.0250964947,
-0.0195135437,
0.0183754135,
0.0201281421,
0.0617791004,
-0.0057724882,
0.0384055227,
0.0018199264,
0.0713482201,
0.0468565673,
-0.0099375108,
0.1043777689,
-0.0092496797,
-0.0405829549,
-0.0170152653,
0.0518862829,
0.0466504544,
-0.0433196872,
0.0329740942,
-0.0023383491,
-0.0311245564,
-0.0378881991,
-0.0418950915,
0.0418657884,
-0.0021423961,
0.0333823971,
0.0767266676,
-0.0437479094,
-0.0364705697,
-0.0379672721,
0.0216165967,
-0.1023807675,
-0.0176281631,
-0.0003471981,
-0.0631865337,
-0.0175795052,
-0.052120626,
-0.0241716672,
0.0537129045,
0.0577199049,
0.0506918095,
0.0001025646,
-0.0209303237,
-0.0179989841,
-0.0496368296,
0.006185662,
-0.0301403105,
-0.0217637718,
-0.036470633,
-0.0262613967,
0.0343969725,
-0.0252088625,
0.0087421816,
0.0490146466,
-0.0689795539,
-0.0206322391,
-0.0327123292,
0.0129390797,
0.0135650486,
0.0357838385,
0.0245202892,
-0.0438465141,
0.0763118491,
0.0527866036,
-0.0163115487,
-0.0043182867,
-0.0358797796,
0.076098308,
-0.0123832449,
-0.0340867266,
-0.0310531631,
0.0213083252,
0.0032995816,
0.0406306759,
0.0105338925,
0.0056024357,
0.0019966671,
0.0430068299,
0.0043051415,
-0.0510492958,
-0.0418177769,
-0.0575433485,
-0.0367554091,
-0.0281623919,
-0.0283053983,
-0.0224261321,
-0.0123721771,
0.0545097031,
-0.0053694537,
-0.0085568577,
-0.0319418237,
-0.0215747636,
-0.0217676945,
-0.0566720702,
0.000493535,
0.0532710887,
-0.0506224483,
0.0316318944,
0.0247979239,
-0.0137805361,
-0.0052152211,
-0.0355738364,
0.0624275208,
0.0322113968,
0.0088699441,
0.0083917696,
0.0217402186,
0.0077094696,
0.0244641248,
-0.0506846085,
-0.048230119,
-0.0022544523,
0.0506559312,
0.0514374301,
-0.0105429729,
0.0337505676,
-0.0364780501,
0.0138418982,
0.0044749551,
0.0035161069,
0.0189769696,
0.0121729169,
-0.0103107598,
0.002057936,
-0.0218543876,
-0.034805499,
0.0460032001,
-0.0054727774,
0.055188667,
-0.0166983381,
-0.016565891,
-0.0371932499,
0.0283988528,
0.0134107862,
0.0284115877,
0.0165641215,
-0.0343657285,
-0.057721898,
-0.0559320487,
0.0730288699,
0.0158764236,
-0.0031007957,
0.0120445024,
0.0499849692,
-0.0227593873,
0.0103031024,
0.0655961335,
-0.0172410179,
0.0286327098,
0.0121277766,
-0.0557027236,
0.0081249364,
-5.171890454e-33,
-0.038866438,
-0.0599197745,
0.0037841531,
0.040486414,
-0.0311263129,
0.0045800791,
0.0031653855,
-0.0208878908,
0.0262414627,
-0.0042358963,
0.0134585714,
-0.0396603383,
-0.0141165257,
-0.0035863454,
-0.0422628596,
0.0152655523,
0.0380354971,
0.0221009161,
-0.0821842477,
0.0164192189,
0.0387401655,
0.0352468081,
0.0018639355,
-0.0427995101,
-0.0538402945,
-0.0341828875,
-0.0184689332,
-0.0315893665,
0.0293588098,
0.0272444673,
-0.0031368134,
0.0236926358,
0.0232805721,
0.0364452712,
-0.0188412108,
0.0074180216,
-0.0641623512,
-0.0587179922,
0.0022108217,
-0.0255902074,
-0.0009766432,
-0.0657873377,
0.0531082004,
-0.0153412595,
0.0047772829,
-0.0401778929,
0.0744163692,
-0.0022679521,
0.0229004044,
0.0049420116,
-0.0367315598,
0.0024497998,
-0.0221102107,
-0.0631990284,
-0.0024835784,
0.008870706,
0.0424334407,
0.0134582371,
-0.0223406199,
0.0516514741,
0.0161105823,
-0.0252809338,
-0.0103882561,
0.0109609338,
-0.0061709881,
0.0889592767,
0.0337215848,
0.0116065182,
-0.0329242684,
0.0413507186,
0.0092156278,
0.0473942831,
0.0231175125,
-0.0032021529,
0.0105948718,
-0.0327124596,
-0.0353597887,
0.0915118605,
0.0152480323,
-0.000051806,
0.0382214822,
0.0024370831,
-0.0428053141,
-0.0254017841,
-0.0324064568,
-0.0458228625,
-0.0391605049,
-0.0140140336,
0.0350069627,
0.0065418496,
0.0216490142,
-0.0178166013,
-0.0014023965,
-0.0144010689,
0.0359993353,
-0.0151630994,
-0.0401555486,
0.0594986603,
0.0016957548,
-0.0271775816,
0.0269930344,
-0.0345479958,
0.0306830332,
0.0057271984,
0.0693348199,
0.0136309303,
0.018175466,
0.0372690447,
-0.030480409,
0.0246172398,
-0.0034530221,
-0.0155913057,
0.0236238409,
-0.0310670864,
-0.0006310143,
-0.0597442836,
-0.0315636881,
0.0063597444,
-0.0150788343,
0.0275659189,
-0.0217226427,
-0.0340782553,
-0.0330852233,
-0.006063431,
-0.0336480401,
0.0323685259,
0.021821117,
0.0153249074,
-0.001550074,
-0.0616120398,
-0.0359649621,
-0.0227360837,
2.701e-7,
0.0039550103,
-0.006355592,
0.0371430777,
0.0423569046,
0.0034739752,
0.0171163026,
-0.0458433814,
-0.0023769415,
-0.0043762354,
-0.0060778405,
0.0174474511,
0.0066942759,
0.013501008,
0.0716106147,
-0.0637319833,
-0.0048895963,
-0.0281055514,
-0.0214744993,
-0.0659458786,
0.0091710398,
0.0820296407,
-0.0068420446,
0.0465265438,
-0.0192003176,
0.0377250463,
-0.0357032195,
0.0664744973,
-0.0605608411,
-0.0292023774,
0.0255151764,
-0.0798642412,
0.0338262096,
-0.0435072221,
-0.0372382402,
-0.0165993609,
0.0399902649,
0.0122265499,
0.0541986674,
-0.022489747,
0.0301728901,
0.0557649881,
0.009719884,
-0.0053541907,
-0.0270126611,
0.0317028761,
-0.0095365867,
-0.059382353,
-0.0022486898,
0.0380716324,
0.0166846942,
0.0126852915,
-0.037230216,
-0.0210366342,
0.0222096294,
0.0130921947,
0.0160933193,
0.0138290944,
-0.0203411821,
0.0029971779,
0.0102053164,
0.0061037908,
-0.0204213746,
-0.0350024886,
-0.008718824,
0.0118822725,
-0.0131158577,
-0.0012081841,
2.639399684e-34,
-0.0112437885,
-0.0195635185,
0.0013056179,
-0.0000949415,
0.0517947674,
0.000933259,
0.0423444621,
0.0175359305,
0.0330508277,
-0.0353908315,
-0.0522882268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08795v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08795v2 | Mitigating Bias for Question Answering Models by Tracking Bias Influence | 2023-10-13T00:49:09 | 2024-06-17T09:06:24 | Mingyu Derek Ma, Jiun-Yu Kao, Arpit Gupta, Yu-Hsiang Lin, Wenbo Zhao, Tagyoung Chung, Wei Wang, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Models of various NLP tasks have been shown to exhibit stereotypes, and the
bias in the question answering (QA) models is especially harmful as the output
answers might be directly consumed by the end users. There have been datasets
to evaluate bias in QA models, while bias mitigation technique for the QA
models is still under-explored. In this work, we propose BMBI, an approach to
mitigate the bias of multiple-choice QA models. Based on the intuition that a
model would lean to be more biased if it learns from a biased example, we
measure the bias level of a query instance by observing its influence on
another instance. If the influenced instance is more biased, we derive that the
query instance is biased. We then use the bias level detected as an
optimization objective to form a multi-task learning setting in addition to the
original QA task. We further introduce a new bias evaluation metric to quantify
bias in a comprehensive and sensitive way. We show that our method could be
applied to multiple QA formulations across multiple bias categories. It can
significantly reduce the bias level in all 9 bias categories in the BBQ dataset
while maintaining comparable QA accuracy. | [
0.0332003124,
0.0544969104,
-0.0115254233,
0.0176006909,
-0.0005543994,
0.0282542109,
-0.0021960689,
-0.0157942101,
0.0359584615,
-0.0633991733,
-0.0238471515,
-0.01277027,
-0.0335590653,
-0.023618646,
0.0174521748,
-0.0195036959,
0.0669410825,
0.0151360128,
0.0250069834,
0.0037744776,
0.0232107788,
0.0299002472,
-0.0138507746,
0.0306906421,
-0.0049152072,
-0.0402798019,
0.0233690944,
0.0072317594,
-0.022318,
-0.00214399,
0.083052814,
0.0774118155,
-0.0268454123,
0.0019321076,
0.0000018476,
-0.0688291565,
-0.0140695376,
-0.0135020427,
-0.0453929268,
-0.0187881235,
0.0329793245,
0.0652829558,
0.0519100092,
0.0354081243,
-0.0455967374,
0.0004027594,
0.0409784503,
0.0280328784,
0.0407590121,
0.0092864437,
0.0170349851,
-0.0177218299,
-0.0455616824,
-0.0008174434,
0.0538462847,
-0.0594517589,
0.0551450886,
-0.0236880891,
-0.0467503853,
-0.0148358867,
-0.0069581745,
-0.0010004356,
0.0000447159,
0.0456538759,
0.0195233002,
-0.0059048464,
-0.0283583086,
-0.0040213391,
-0.0158141442,
0.0817345157,
0.0104467757,
-0.0432931967,
-0.0235249829,
-0.0043765549,
0.0553027466,
0.022599265,
-0.0637820438,
-0.0200463068,
-0.0081786131,
-0.0267520975,
-0.006310672,
0.0141856987,
0.0000650239,
0.0265659261,
0.002838613,
0.0311473589,
0.0225805268,
-0.0287670624,
0.0017774255,
0.0519031435,
0.0055239419,
-0.0180237666,
-0.0014637021,
0.0200782567,
-0.0317762941,
0.0341491401,
0.0043848897,
-0.0124711515,
0.0366994888,
-0.0430276692,
0.0129525457,
0.0092922067,
-0.0117296875,
0.0455303639,
-0.0124482457,
0.020391725,
-0.0195420124,
-0.0007827393,
-0.0688372254,
-0.0251159687,
-0.0511546358,
-0.0433384515,
-0.0350033604,
0.0370371863,
0.0208173431,
0.0174772311,
-0.0082515301,
0.0210949052,
-0.0377760604,
-0.0220670346,
0.040034648,
0.0756859258,
-0.036696028,
0.0254297331,
-0.0672421306,
0.0544407852,
-0.0719555765,
0.0617628731,
-0.0235434696,
-0.0718336627,
-0.0433068313,
0.0039279689,
0.0225525778,
-0.0588747114,
0.0032264476,
0.058914315,
0.0143249352,
-0.0354249515,
-0.0084300479,
-0.0401268788,
0.0230299961,
-0.0136552928,
-0.0013910611,
-0.0319136232,
0.0512171984,
-0.0110202488,
0.0040775649,
-0.0154300854,
-0.0148555469,
0.0384981632,
-0.027248865,
0.0657329485,
-0.0057097482,
-0.017377492,
0.0399215147,
0.0151245706,
-0.0271147601,
0.1173027828,
0.0002692198,
-0.0384405293,
0.0708120987,
0.0003898948,
0.0306762923,
-0.0003575407,
0.0604188442,
0.0101504279,
0.0156509262,
0.075983882,
0.0198378526,
-0.014203215,
0.0181511957,
-0.0030849851,
-0.0047734044,
-0.024822237,
0.0214490574,
0.0079130782,
-0.027759796,
-0.011214966,
-0.0157542136,
0.0030196097,
-0.0022837673,
0.0296317935,
-0.0396082662,
0.0317014717,
-0.0174537059,
-0.0156522393,
0.0106105339,
0.0418372303,
-0.0698730201,
-0.0445033684,
0.0208331924,
0.0042264913,
-0.0261504129,
0.0408360399,
0.003170822,
0.0606534109,
-0.0108208507,
0.100423649,
0.0174755584,
-0.0145987002,
0.0292783584,
-0.0631458014,
0.0509248078,
-0.0121843703,
0.0204833243,
-0.0590878017,
-0.0454488173,
-0.0185381006,
-0.0089022061,
-0.0086774463,
0.0124531342,
-0.0528268553,
0.0508336015,
-0.0168070644,
-0.0233723652,
-0.0140099479,
0.0297085848,
-0.0158344097,
0.0539746135,
0.0035097145,
0.0128665604,
-0.0895813704,
-0.0020869826,
0.032026697,
0.0458393693,
-0.0640766248,
0.0221503191,
0.0095205661,
0.0266045425,
0.0253040902,
0.001821478,
0.0069704,
0.0315393321,
0.0154934721,
-0.0256207772,
-0.004851657,
-0.0307045393,
-0.0419313498,
0.0102470005,
-0.035815876,
-0.0164724346,
0.0528003387,
-0.0566419214,
-0.0226886198,
-0.0111578815,
-0.0243184641,
0.0001891432,
-0.0125047807,
-0.0529202744,
-0.0207146909,
-0.0140674217,
-0.0772006512,
0.0617786348,
0.0294427369,
0.0215047915,
0.0065884166,
-0.0373519175,
0.0059219692,
-0.0114619583,
0.0053012748,
-0.0130301313,
0.0068464386,
0.0079723578,
0.0542948171,
-0.0261280723,
-0.0833927318,
0.0108485678,
-0.0712268949,
0.0074754241,
-0.0219797567,
0.0257854182,
0.0589584075,
0.0268961452,
0.000555247,
-0.0548621938,
-0.0813267604,
-0.0718931109,
0.0135999639,
0.0454387777,
0.0433073975,
0.0045180451,
0.0333977863,
-0.0333083384,
-0.0178310629,
-0.0382981189,
0.053691227,
0.0077768816,
0.0099981036,
-0.0648060367,
-0.0289047416,
-0.0313218161,
0.0124213891,
0.0337387659,
0.0085171247,
-0.0025457665,
0.0186925456,
0.0002953796,
0.1031856686,
0.0273092333,
-0.0361954682,
0.0352063812,
0.0371199436,
-0.0589595102,
-0.0060328562,
-0.044682309,
-0.0014768252,
-0.0025121125,
-0.0469289608,
0.0319872759,
0.0478010513,
0.0233640336,
-0.0359378532,
-0.0339221582,
0.0784410387,
-0.0154832564,
-0.0401598662,
-0.0351098329,
0.0164765175,
-0.0063069211,
0.0283667948,
-0.0234409664,
-0.0340441093,
0.0707591921,
0.0177909154,
0.0080631096,
-0.0717448443,
0.0276337415,
-0.0611209795,
0.0084017655,
-0.0184473488,
0.0227983911,
0.0214738827,
-0.0090232948,
-0.0684475675,
-0.0474370942,
0.0115318308,
-0.0246300753,
-0.0147068333,
-0.0367690623,
-0.0124869561,
-0.011500245,
-0.0322088115,
-0.0447226465,
-0.0106572863,
-0.0166221205,
-0.001326252,
-0.000783776,
0.0226619188,
0.0205580723,
-0.00956106,
0.0148588847,
-0.0148106087,
-0.0487085804,
-0.0151490457,
-0.0103336517,
0.0728284493,
0.0896487981,
0.0255731437,
0.0274654422,
0.0226023253,
0.0221213643,
0.0646487251,
0.0626356825,
0.0330060683,
0.0174159184,
-0.0036784161,
0.0267937798,
-0.0609282926,
0.0130151687,
0.0015091002,
0.0478877388,
-0.0018903114,
-0.031768661,
0.0936786234,
0.0349783562,
-0.0535262264,
-0.0023727792,
-0.0067595532,
0.0242671333,
0.0487759896,
0.0237122569,
-0.0978443325,
-0.0557908937,
-0.0237667169,
0.0474440381,
-0.0189694576,
-0.0175978113,
0.009264919,
-0.1449058652,
-0.0217743441,
-0.0351501629,
0.002215483,
0.0078790495,
-0.0770803168,
0.0181118641,
-0.0684540346,
0.0184665881,
-0.0142021328,
0.0049305838,
0.0273317546,
0.0488674864,
-0.0028497817,
-0.0254798383,
0.0191209987,
-0.0417412259,
0.0025103944,
0.0330638811,
0.0267392974,
-0.0104739415,
0.0453901328,
0.0124910232,
-0.0692511126,
-0.0167957954,
-0.0160008967,
0.0759842098,
-0.0522706695,
-0.0058787358,
-0.0253752675,
0.0454526134,
-0.0260079019,
0.0410571098,
0.0403930545,
0.0623769015,
0.0224480238,
0.0038695412,
-0.0350296609,
-0.0613796972,
0.0024130594,
0.0725408494,
0.017315479,
-0.0413674414,
-0.0448018312,
-0.0194142796,
-0.0178320818,
-0.0240338128,
-0.0361681283,
0.0168726053,
0.0086417506,
0.0448761657,
-0.0528922454,
-0.0497954115,
0.0224365909,
0.0262839403,
-0.0213045105,
0.0180910137,
-0.0104048913,
0.0194487087,
-0.0322622471,
0.0126426993,
-0.0541404225,
0.0103785573,
-0.002133362,
-0.0212899242,
0.0357333459,
-0.019316867,
-0.0400918685,
-0.0257131979,
-0.0645536035,
-0.0232532974,
-0.0018094891,
0.080602251,
0.0160629395,
0.026110461,
-0.0225720853,
-0.0309777446,
0.02324499,
0.0156158134,
-0.0235019233,
-0.0174783636,
0.036996562,
-0.0182307251,
-0.0087405192,
0.0199294034,
-0.0725059137,
0.0052210581,
0.0022099908,
0.0193878449,
-0.0605614632,
-0.0470613502,
0.0259581115,
-0.0122693088,
0.0224823654,
0.0328782089,
0.0319729261,
-0.0242379345,
0.0101426523,
0.0117118526,
-0.0514358096,
-0.0048802695,
0.0169890597,
0.0197834279,
-0.0168046188,
-0.0167961735,
-0.0087535242,
-0.040471077,
0.0237771813,
-0.0523326322,
0.0076394523,
0.0555319302,
0.000432302,
-0.02815881,
0.0001760926,
-0.0367854051,
-0.0010692658,
0.0255557466,
0.0486474596,
0.0342320688,
0.0201556757,
0.0457365066,
0.010731169,
-0.0040060258,
0.0115993498,
-0.0985217094,
-0.0280333068,
-0.0143000325,
-0.0180011466,
0.0237012189,
-0.0471059904,
0.0183389243,
0.0486031994,
-0.0237353537,
0.0070602926,
-0.0101963412,
0.0363041498,
0.0206367709,
0.0671353489,
0.0193907209,
-0.0059713856,
0.0115506696,
0.0781276748,
0.0321882069,
0.0867236555,
-0.0326334387,
-0.0404708013,
-0.017844433,
-0.03408866,
0.0307326689,
-0.005777251,
-0.0020768661,
0.0067660813,
-0.0385268629,
-0.0525106117,
0.010671705,
-0.0337534361,
0.0235217623,
-0.0320762694,
0.049943991,
0.0506181121,
0.0076479777,
-0.0562418401,
-0.0288643688,
-0.0136870295,
-0.0778231919,
0.0125522474,
-0.004344692,
-6.342969721e-33,
-0.0140668852,
-0.0363715477,
-0.0197578222,
-0.0560982935,
0.0192364585,
0.001717011,
0.0166468397,
-0.0202528462,
-0.0827790126,
-0.0219457354,
-0.0097584585,
0.0186794233,
0.0083599156,
0.0040307981,
0.0266198721,
-0.054545138,
0.0245309696,
-0.0156763345,
-0.0350361764,
0.0232151281,
-0.0005713789,
0.0204452872,
0.0492680222,
-0.0014443904,
0.0388187394,
-0.0165855978,
0.0027114723,
0.0447109528,
-0.0205096081,
0.0538829565,
-0.012646365,
0.067007035,
0.0573320426,
-0.0527369417,
0.0117075853,
0.0468263775,
-0.0643582866,
-0.0743052289,
0.0054416824,
0.0207880493,
0.0005884772,
-0.0021659099,
-0.0080337813,
0.0322296955,
0.0015193073,
-0.0225217883,
0.0432746299,
-0.00659092,
0.0146740498,
0.0096430434,
-0.019234987,
-0.0086474903,
-0.0078307148,
-0.0084265759,
-0.0402106009,
0.1022358909,
0.0121658184,
0.0418137498,
-0.0070114858,
-0.013030082,
-0.0266859308,
0.0294616073,
0.0160428863,
0.031465549,
-0.0146981124,
0.0263436418,
0.0595983192,
0.0036501612,
-0.0123688169,
-0.0430392548,
-0.0257473774,
-0.0056121857,
0.081639573,
0.0638608932,
0.0367735401,
0.0130103044,
-0.0603153743,
0.0413803682,
0.0450036265,
0.0408703461,
0.0225885101,
-0.0206174366,
-0.0227782484,
-0.0158238616,
-0.071266219,
0.0016808789,
-0.0334549099,
0.014632809,
0.0451449081,
0.0079168724,
-0.0345382951,
0.0325274132,
0.019556636,
-0.0370917507,
0.0125978487,
0.0548638813,
-0.0274245236,
-0.0117177162,
0.0170812849,
0.0202330463,
-0.0645631403,
0.0338513814,
0.0182902366,
0.0278172567,
0.0107677439,
0.0145804565,
0.0112787345,
-0.0409611277,
-0.0454251319,
-0.0033616102,
-0.0259053241,
-0.0126720881,
-0.0118977847,
0.0365002751,
0.0344056785,
0.032787066,
0.0012314189,
0.0320097022,
0.0338832512,
0.0160163026,
-0.0326755047,
-0.0273681413,
-0.0351548232,
0.0409928411,
-0.0330639631,
-0.0289303903,
-0.0255291965,
0.0031654523,
-0.0670495182,
-0.0618206151,
-0.0249917917,
-0.0027757203,
2.477e-7,
0.0282758344,
0.0242177807,
0.0134762628,
0.0737161264,
-0.000802098,
0.0506689809,
0.0264572017,
0.0389500558,
0.0219454821,
-0.0264261048,
0.0009520162,
0.0225274712,
0.0063446267,
0.0284616537,
-0.0861565396,
-0.0339381434,
-0.0658952147,
0.0473594815,
-0.025318943,
-0.0243674312,
0.0369052216,
0.0575248972,
-0.0093067493,
0.0013190554,
-0.0377127938,
-0.023415288,
0.0421866104,
0.0084027098,
0.025328448,
0.0320444815,
0.011961638,
0.0044132047,
0.0178011786,
0.027291093,
-0.0165726375,
0.0056574196,
0.0177896041,
0.0140236346,
-0.0155197028,
-0.0401587412,
-0.0264321305,
0.0088371309,
0.0260385107,
-0.0626700968,
0.0952843428,
-0.0121836402,
-0.0167533439,
-0.0601291321,
-0.0232841503,
-0.0024278234,
0.0321451612,
0.0042386083,
-0.0106512457,
-0.019417081,
0.0121927457,
0.0210369322,
-0.0048771482,
-0.0756665096,
-0.005056554,
0.0029096995,
0.0018961707,
-0.0400725827,
0.00996585,
0.0112879556,
-0.0218968522,
-0.0642011985,
0.0199526083,
1.927969152e-34,
0.0175305232,
-0.0068480661,
0.0613313653,
0.0421023183,
0.0363223664,
-0.021534089,
-0.0186651759,
-0.0599766448,
0.0641133338,
-0.0589621216,
-0.0028638176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08780v1 | "Im not Racist but...": Discovering Bias in the Internal Knowledge of Large Language Models | 2023-10-13T00:03:37 | 2023-10-13T00:03:37 | Abel Salinas, Louis Penafiel, Robert McCormack, Fred Morstatter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention for their
remarkable performance in a continuously expanding set of natural language
processing tasks. However, these models have been shown to harbor inherent
societal biases, or stereotypes, which can adversely affect their performance
in their many downstream applications. In this paper, we introduce a novel,
purely prompt-based approach to uncover hidden stereotypes within any arbitrary
LLM. Our approach dynamically generates a knowledge representation of internal
stereotypes, enabling the identification of biases encoded within the LLM's
internal knowledge. By illuminating the biases present in LLMs and offering a
systematic methodology for their analysis, our work contributes to advancing
transparency and promoting fairness in natural language processing systems. | [
0.071008876,
0.0799803138,
-0.0414671004,
0.0663258135,
-0.012498674,
0.0208955444,
0.0310645103,
-0.0121782329,
0.0582363904,
-0.0942082852,
-0.0164090004,
0.0007871362,
0.0197074562,
0.0317463093,
0.0044414252,
-0.0268923454,
0.0513122417,
0.0187617484,
0.0340950042,
-0.0387728624,
0.0206540488,
0.0362553485,
0.0342637002,
0.0490389578,
-0.0268489365,
-0.024803197,
0.0640330464,
-0.0283454675,
-0.0258647762,
-0.0081878025,
0.0145474402,
0.0546096377,
-0.0250256136,
0.0508905277,
0.0000018551,
-0.0628728122,
0.0051055918,
-0.0098019196,
-0.0062875017,
0.0031241928,
0.0643805563,
-0.0112026464,
-0.0016120496,
0.0227918662,
-0.0402866751,
0.020784704,
0.0510095619,
0.0248537231,
0.0462739244,
0.0189507511,
0.0062342449,
-0.010139158,
-0.0631848648,
0.0101733319,
-0.0070342189,
-0.0020879938,
0.0525068119,
-0.0739890113,
-0.0616331995,
-0.0518472418,
-0.0173224714,
0.0013864809,
-0.0028006101,
0.0206681546,
0.0230721589,
-0.0061430507,
-0.0429459438,
-0.0262676105,
-0.0124903563,
0.0444694608,
0.0135858962,
0.007383307,
-0.0007409028,
-0.0040931692,
0.0217240918,
-0.0026775922,
-0.0100452453,
0.0525529012,
-0.0405158065,
-0.0099031301,
-0.0266263466,
0.0307986103,
0.0268273558,
0.0393063128,
-0.0281009972,
0.08095254,
0.0191143733,
-0.0324878916,
-0.0146136638,
0.00647762,
0.022759378,
-0.0430214144,
0.0190318171,
0.0076319366,
-0.0132216029,
0.0351012647,
-0.0061517437,
-0.0058870297,
0.0472731143,
-0.0718257651,
0.0083096409,
0.039462436,
-0.0289505012,
0.0104006473,
0.0030069486,
0.0244199783,
-0.0050260844,
0.0049285172,
0.0054127909,
-0.0307613667,
-0.0051144441,
-0.0317522809,
0.0040058703,
0.0032003317,
0.0212951656,
0.0544729047,
-0.0257702302,
0.0243344996,
-0.0731177703,
0.0079748938,
-0.0013622679,
0.0268196668,
-0.0197143964,
-0.0051412587,
-0.0593877211,
0.0010211123,
-0.0306576192,
-0.0212151408,
-0.0594811291,
-0.0940647721,
0.0093371458,
-0.0139150573,
-0.033308953,
-0.0319222584,
-0.0134035852,
0.0744075999,
0.0300331749,
-0.0200624168,
-0.038069997,
-0.0447030962,
-0.0248104203,
-0.0321654789,
-0.020881135,
-0.0441097394,
-0.0032449425,
-0.0005677238,
0.0084636277,
-0.0582741536,
0.000559248,
0.0282752253,
-0.0624249801,
0.0981260911,
-0.0086142626,
-0.0111575751,
0.0437818989,
0.0349290222,
-0.0242711194,
0.0845539719,
-0.0139084943,
0.0020616215,
0.0582882576,
-0.0067558554,
-0.0097051924,
0.0338925682,
0.0140216621,
-0.022510061,
-0.0575767234,
0.0341673829,
-0.0028793546,
-0.0099072196,
0.0413766764,
0.0553592555,
0.0267375987,
-0.037847437,
0.0393926539,
0.0843139589,
-0.0293239374,
0.0178517979,
0.0317520574,
-0.0038806854,
-0.0141344015,
0.0061551859,
-0.0801782459,
-0.0341396332,
-0.0213520844,
-0.0461944342,
0.0101650674,
0.0943741873,
0.0019319232,
-0.0197224896,
-0.0191077106,
0.0088338358,
0.0425129905,
-0.0025257161,
0.0150043787,
0.0177283529,
0.0224157572,
0.0557122305,
0.0433876663,
-0.0000863455,
-0.0002587579,
-0.0691173673,
0.0241875872,
0.0713057369,
0.012406447,
-0.0229847096,
0.0074902261,
-0.0256912243,
-0.0612390563,
0.061681442,
0.0449263528,
-0.003006642,
-0.011819833,
-0.0280210711,
-0.000518254,
0.0291027054,
0.0471940339,
0.0258045867,
0.0459325314,
0.0605215393,
0.0221870299,
-0.0110246325,
-0.0245035645,
0.0320494361,
0.0039887982,
-0.0423208959,
0.0132734617,
0.0149541758,
0.0325664692,
0.0288891587,
-0.0089380322,
-0.0042804284,
-0.0285078641,
0.0018449001,
-0.0239804406,
0.0392503627,
-0.0866817459,
-0.0155261299,
0.0400261991,
-0.0549108386,
-0.0408444516,
0.0314142182,
-0.0098977257,
0.0148721682,
0.0515906811,
-0.0049204426,
0.0418299697,
-0.0164867081,
-0.0021709905,
-0.0310966577,
0.0244661197,
-0.0294415094,
0.0462358631,
-0.0142171877,
-0.0207383521,
0.0415183529,
-0.0462511443,
0.0054440047,
-0.0103872484,
-0.0257668197,
0.0224210136,
0.0128216241,
-0.0016696719,
0.0071385102,
-0.0123113943,
-0.0197516344,
0.0253280066,
-0.0971937031,
-0.0161015783,
0.0015236886,
-0.0472873338,
0.0072015338,
0.0311178621,
-0.0216775034,
-0.0202642512,
-0.0102534154,
-0.0485700592,
0.0272331014,
0.0475954115,
0.0151678324,
-0.0278381947,
-0.0316325314,
-0.0122872824,
-0.0209113471,
-0.0420028456,
0.0676024631,
0.0180285294,
-0.0044492949,
-0.0461472496,
-0.0279639047,
-0.0436051935,
0.031191051,
0.0078141438,
-0.0194291547,
0.014948776,
0.0346038416,
-0.0027607672,
0.0563794039,
0.0497314557,
0.0323091522,
0.0570682734,
-0.0270209536,
-0.0453832932,
-0.0249381512,
0.001641195,
0.024357425,
0.0297786575,
-0.0684465021,
-0.0018097853,
0.076055333,
0.0665143728,
-0.0357256792,
-0.0422374755,
0.0584563799,
-0.0505740196,
-0.0570502281,
-0.0372728221,
-0.0639986023,
-0.0207403749,
0.0134708555,
-0.0344583131,
-0.069326736,
0.0752171278,
-0.0141948266,
0.0361064002,
-0.0182363465,
-0.0129799237,
-0.0502548628,
0.0625351667,
-0.0091576166,
0.0424012803,
0.0319747142,
-0.0251522213,
-0.0222307183,
-0.0201233402,
0.0179969724,
-0.0313031524,
0.0268190019,
-0.0419894159,
-0.0041225301,
0.0108604813,
-0.0318246894,
-0.0743564442,
-0.0580076948,
-0.0612017512,
-0.002536146,
0.0286984611,
-0.0197468009,
0.0064594503,
0.0145382686,
0.0058310046,
0.015515659,
0.0023614285,
-0.0110826725,
0.0103269294,
-0.0340325683,
0.0093535092,
-0.015090677,
0.0455867574,
0.008894084,
0.0159647763,
0.0364621617,
-0.0238620378,
0.0142292362,
-0.0017658337,
-0.0102642654,
0.019388726,
-0.0551250018,
0.0160153508,
0.0029327089,
0.0202032328,
-0.0491667576,
0.0095494166,
0.1077521145,
0.0212850329,
-0.0660719797,
0.0306159426,
-0.0105661163,
-0.021742858,
0.0436398126,
0.0004007795,
-0.1062825173,
-0.0158566572,
0.0048611267,
0.0178519636,
-0.0793756843,
-0.0662001595,
-0.0268927794,
-0.1364738643,
0.0029470758,
0.0070843915,
-0.0084588854,
-0.0026571041,
-0.0111598773,
0.0025988335,
0.0030850519,
0.0378698558,
-0.0368097089,
0.0074822409,
0.0091762329,
-0.0112236813,
-0.0827217549,
-0.0451241396,
0.0367831327,
-0.0408646949,
0.0571926311,
0.0392258652,
0.016001882,
-0.0052231848,
-0.0035148754,
0.0318904407,
-0.0152310664,
0.01653759,
-0.0511474311,
0.0289042704,
-0.0488354824,
-0.016303882,
-0.0281046331,
0.011263757,
-0.0088401083,
0.0371565185,
0.0010090619,
0.0523278229,
0.0150973573,
-0.027281465,
-0.0566958487,
-0.0191269852,
0.0072563924,
0.1147855148,
0.0208514389,
-0.022370711,
0.0097569078,
-0.0938280374,
-0.0177025255,
0.01853792,
-0.0873896703,
0.0458294638,
0.0134169376,
-0.0377732776,
-0.0341231301,
-0.0301939752,
0.0281321742,
-0.011371797,
0.0319565199,
-0.0423190258,
0.0049698306,
-0.0012673679,
-0.0809080526,
0.0244766958,
-0.0381680019,
0.0280696768,
0.0216560364,
0.0007703839,
0.0093926471,
0.0043561906,
-0.023649022,
0.0337810442,
-0.0070855827,
-0.0537870117,
0.0501888953,
0.0431516357,
0.02286545,
0.036816556,
-0.0143752983,
-0.0578475446,
0.0615169331,
0.0542634614,
-0.036534559,
0.0099655185,
0.0068755331,
0.0235134251,
0.0283361189,
0.0429818481,
-0.0313318707,
0.0395651273,
0.0064968867,
-0.0159892458,
-0.0123206722,
-0.0258238874,
0.0081813727,
0.0189020149,
0.0392346419,
-0.0262149815,
-0.0163536761,
-0.0311695971,
-0.0325070657,
-0.0335141011,
-0.0725924596,
-0.0040226858,
0.0043723336,
-0.0034571174,
0.0128243705,
-0.0401885286,
-0.0158289485,
-0.0485436395,
0.0367359333,
-0.020180935,
0.0212836582,
0.0521022305,
0.0180389881,
0.0251704045,
0.0050547994,
-0.0192616004,
0.0365415961,
-0.0234417412,
0.0243722685,
0.0296985395,
0.0272918344,
0.0271561276,
0.0092158383,
-0.015294998,
0.0032325091,
-0.0190892126,
-0.0437666811,
0.0124070821,
0.0117830997,
0.0208041929,
-0.0278975423,
-0.0014114974,
0.0164209362,
-0.0004106412,
0.0238864496,
-0.0251969658,
0.0278725661,
-0.0231078137,
0.0477129295,
-0.00523934,
-0.0346399583,
-0.0079852995,
0.0515622124,
-0.0285668857,
0.0868769214,
-0.0293760188,
-0.0648759753,
-0.0262063798,
-0.0049101012,
0.0437962525,
0.0009182382,
0.0009221309,
-0.0105592711,
-0.1033799201,
-0.0759256631,
-0.0062077641,
-0.0160537194,
0.0245430991,
-0.0114217009,
0.0169338863,
0.0636529103,
0.0237461329,
-0.0372663662,
0.0024842513,
0.0091297934,
-0.041788388,
-0.0158005841,
-0.0001518404,
-6.158764981e-33,
-0.0168759208,
-0.0578801371,
-0.0466745868,
-0.0381197371,
0.0041843625,
-0.0231433157,
-0.0051803039,
0.0042893742,
-0.0196806025,
-0.0022564244,
0.0003990459,
0.036637146,
0.012716474,
-0.0222498588,
0.032113567,
0.0245127697,
0.058138717,
-0.0178476665,
-0.0324247181,
-0.0288590714,
0.0218372289,
0.02131873,
0.03991336,
-0.0359226763,
0.0602497533,
0.0151265599,
-0.0254987907,
0.0501836278,
0.0068205371,
0.0324841589,
-0.034794461,
0.0834454894,
0.0394342281,
-0.0159688834,
-0.0091457665,
0.0671518072,
-0.0218928475,
-0.0255234819,
0.0465312488,
0.034893889,
0.034948539,
-0.0370309837,
0.0384237878,
0.0031880194,
-0.0442955829,
0.0073563061,
0.0473364778,
-0.0217967033,
0.0661158338,
-0.0003017502,
-0.0296589173,
0.0354966968,
-0.0311137736,
0.0430123843,
-0.0220557693,
-0.0154872164,
0.0302884225,
0.0136252334,
-0.0389073081,
0.0113950009,
0.0009259622,
-0.0180698354,
0.070491083,
0.0215005409,
0.0100285774,
0.0665646121,
0.0513791852,
0.05399324,
-0.0328390449,
-0.0467958264,
0.0267537683,
-0.0282534454,
0.015059934,
0.0699298978,
0.0440723523,
-0.0220578443,
-0.0032830762,
-0.0031869372,
0.0545205697,
-0.0051686619,
0.0268841293,
-0.0330442786,
-0.0877798274,
-0.0481468402,
-0.0230984092,
-0.0305813588,
-0.0219757594,
-0.0243487973,
0.0452312231,
0.004187258,
-0.0189862698,
0.0313522704,
0.0009375762,
-0.0504048988,
0.000017561,
0.0117840171,
0.0032587096,
-0.0401796773,
0.0296068862,
0.0083115604,
-0.0641177893,
0.0249524284,
-0.0249104146,
0.034636762,
0.0207014624,
0.0277544521,
-0.0147967441,
0.0075815436,
-0.0829685628,
0.0283086896,
-0.0040804832,
0.0196986645,
-0.0153242713,
0.0180330928,
0.0303248484,
0.0203903317,
-0.0157849453,
0.0098679112,
0.0417677127,
-0.0043339464,
-0.0464915521,
0.0262023117,
0.0115781017,
0.037596181,
-0.0325432606,
-0.0420827977,
0.0042490251,
-0.0051399777,
0.0521514043,
-0.0262467097,
-0.0003502652,
-0.0624142215,
2.438e-7,
0.0052145654,
0.0493155383,
-0.0218879525,
0.0438961759,
0.0314216986,
0.041750744,
0.0450403839,
0.0264008269,
-0.0194900706,
-0.0267942622,
-0.042541679,
0.0581596233,
-0.0003655237,
0.0645353571,
-0.0683752447,
-0.0062054433,
-0.0658580214,
0.0148574747,
-0.0398966409,
0.002553114,
0.0120756319,
0.0704967156,
0.0206689034,
-0.0105088195,
-0.0380239226,
-0.0610289909,
0.0053043794,
-0.0186757892,
0.0334253237,
0.0057903477,
0.0517179258,
0.0191845838,
0.0014024421,
0.0186972488,
0.0132355252,
0.0187503975,
-0.0282797124,
0.0170592964,
-0.0118467491,
0.0235395115,
-0.0280657522,
-0.0022617895,
-0.0209802128,
-0.0724296644,
0.0435399599,
0.0107346494,
-0.0350462347,
-0.0604376309,
0.0135791767,
-0.0464172587,
0.0220373869,
-0.0183277223,
-0.0151363378,
0.0069854511,
0.0156160183,
-0.0171859395,
0.0062901927,
-0.0977840796,
-0.0295670591,
-0.0398720801,
-0.0363558307,
-0.0543769002,
0.0073413784,
-0.0047566216,
0.014592181,
-0.0288774855,
0.0656726062,
2.230915398e-34,
0.0241693035,
0.0266485903,
0.0040235999,
-0.003650988,
0.0505486056,
0.005156538,
-0.0146102821,
-0.0148006147,
0.061059542,
-0.0453026965,
-0.0186390132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08764v1 | Calibrating Likelihoods towards Consistency in Summarization Models | 2023-10-12T23:17:56 | 2023-10-12T23:17:56 | Polina Zablotskaia, Misha Khalman, Rishabh Joshi, Livio Baldini Soares, Shoshana Jakobovits, Joshua Maynez, Shashi Narayan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the recent advances in abstractive text summarization, current
summarization models still suffer from generating factually inconsistent
summaries, reducing their utility for real-world application. We argue that the
main reason for such behavior is that the summarization models trained with
maximum likelihood objective assign high probability to plausible sequences
given the context, but they often do not accurately rank sequences by their
consistency. In this work, we solve this problem by calibrating the likelihood
of model generated sequences to better align with a consistency metric measured
by natural language inference (NLI) models. The human evaluation study and
automatic metrics show that the calibrated models generate more consistent and
higher-quality summaries. We also show that the models trained using our method
return probabilities that are better aligned with the NLI scores, which
significantly increase reliability of summarization models. | [
0.0507191345,
0.0452424958,
0.031282533,
-0.0004062291,
-0.014980753,
0.0128785735,
-0.0281133745,
-0.0488390513,
-0.011840621,
-0.0487877913,
0.0170916244,
-0.0154322665,
0.0667530149,
-0.0078145247,
0.0192973185,
-0.0796335265,
0.0362892225,
-0.0098527018,
-0.0091204587,
0.0233023837,
0.0176899582,
0.0135786925,
0.0022061062,
0.0681037605,
0.0330759995,
0.029782109,
0.0289256703,
-0.0109762428,
0.0697571263,
-0.0185608529,
-0.0225670021,
0.024027111,
0.0335929319,
-0.0101446295,
0.0000017511,
-0.0748944506,
-0.0132535342,
-0.0039577046,
0.0007778151,
0.0235835779,
0.0157161988,
-0.0354980752,
0.0295384973,
0.0207366347,
0.0142541314,
0.0353412814,
0.0090630529,
0.0226125438,
0.0463813841,
0.0346474722,
0.0071588485,
-0.0369051024,
0.0348846279,
-0.0209893566,
-0.0512758568,
-0.0270146541,
0.0010532027,
0.0723699555,
-0.0080576232,
-0.0173788108,
0.0333018117,
0.01724278,
0.0179718006,
0.0347461812,
0.0023636736,
0.0355028547,
-0.0406535901,
-0.0258103181,
0.0252970457,
0.0355170295,
0.0222132541,
-0.0263645966,
0.008685139,
-0.0205094609,
0.0032146394,
0.0243291277,
-0.0511335135,
0.0842475519,
-0.0338888317,
0.0263902321,
0.0386384465,
0.0591687746,
0.0174094494,
0.0419707857,
-0.0174879748,
0.0253312588,
0.019421488,
-0.0024287896,
-0.0247625168,
0.0134489406,
-0.0658089742,
-0.0558072291,
0.0363008417,
0.0152041214,
-0.0305407904,
0.0046984418,
-0.0685676262,
-0.0201166272,
0.0306760725,
-0.0528369471,
-0.0055772294,
0.0389351808,
0.0294855163,
0.0179599207,
-0.0029967241,
0.0408020429,
0.0540089682,
-0.0222258456,
-0.0540854409,
-0.0070450674,
-0.0060390295,
0.0277023111,
-0.0037916829,
0.0392848141,
-0.0363551006,
-0.0423927046,
-0.0711650774,
0.0177292917,
0.0048768055,
0.0029920705,
-0.0311666541,
0.0281331092,
-0.0163242444,
0.0131735578,
-0.0390381366,
0.0039626202,
-0.0225613862,
-0.010425088,
0.0182863213,
-0.0066275499,
0.009117621,
0.0114776958,
0.0093462812,
0.0046513332,
-0.0165275186,
0.0068655224,
-0.0272892285,
-0.0367370099,
-0.0162989143,
-0.046520967,
-0.017500259,
-0.0331382453,
-0.0436062589,
-0.0660682023,
-0.0197997894,
0.0175354425,
-0.0172308683,
-0.0209104791,
0.0053117299,
0.006161374,
-0.0372507237,
0.0340432078,
-0.0135883307,
-0.0065890718,
0.0504532084,
0.0155953802,
0.0097093284,
0.018337002,
0.0385569409,
0.0339553058,
0.0520459749,
0.0465053879,
0.0083719166,
0.0112467976,
-0.0249696597,
-0.0181421097,
0.0303327441,
-0.0024834827,
-0.057027448,
0.0141056022,
0.0341886431,
0.0496872775,
-0.0526215546,
0.017462004,
0.0565418079,
0.0425498821,
0.0137336468,
-0.0173570104,
0.0399268605,
0.0252521429,
0.0365334041,
0.0781677663,
-0.0283670761,
0.0025599399,
-0.0382101983,
0.0751118287,
0.1223501191,
0.0272387285,
0.0115907332,
-0.085331969,
-0.0146111911,
-0.0200957395,
0.0034864508,
-0.0041105007,
0.0198760647,
-0.0038215711,
-0.0429040678,
0.0379815102,
0.0223118179,
-0.0471296422,
0.0085741375,
-0.017792955,
0.0243130308,
0.046201814,
0.0495905802,
-0.0003340512,
-0.029455509,
0.0011256479,
-0.0317994095,
0.0175772253,
0.0238177199,
-0.0179330092,
-0.0030385144,
-0.0386327319,
-0.0288698841,
0.0340836644,
0.0380035378,
-0.0122899842,
-0.0002664083,
-0.0252614841,
0.057252828,
-0.0313733704,
-0.0794256628,
0.0360806324,
-0.050003197,
-0.0114609692,
-0.0133665502,
-0.0103119044,
0.032732252,
0.0343345143,
-0.0264137723,
0.0319612324,
0.0081903627,
-0.0273334384,
-0.002615198,
0.0241164546,
-0.0593891069,
-0.017106602,
0.0317798033,
-0.0624411926,
-0.0079881335,
0.0187500212,
-0.0235435255,
-0.0522789881,
0.009510926,
-0.0642657131,
-0.0229895338,
-0.0482463203,
0.0171874724,
0.0232526604,
-0.0164800417,
-0.0286188237,
0.0669876933,
-0.0082240002,
0.0313781537,
0.0755823478,
-0.0237667896,
0.015959369,
-0.0473450758,
0.0053107506,
-0.0031595698,
-0.0076390021,
0.0003639362,
0.0867550895,
-0.0095434841,
-0.0166540071,
0.0141987428,
-0.0905618817,
-0.003051752,
-0.0187887866,
0.0139878755,
0.050525181,
0.0062496187,
0.0007643267,
0.0109617859,
0.0099495621,
-0.0513227656,
0.0010372481,
0.0023352541,
0.0254541822,
0.0060197269,
0.0312991068,
-0.0922443569,
0.0017414797,
-0.0153498482,
0.0588535294,
0.0204715263,
-0.0210336,
-0.0820238441,
0.0183832478,
-0.0418949798,
-0.0312776119,
-0.0059245452,
0.0097762914,
0.02034216,
0.0395599753,
0.0507673286,
0.0475386567,
0.0532074235,
-0.0093676429,
0.0549138151,
0.0208153259,
-0.0530539677,
-0.0411506891,
-0.0233542565,
0.0250756405,
0.0257241577,
-0.0723057464,
0.0372565538,
0.0524386205,
0.0407335833,
0.0268876664,
-0.0237288307,
0.0173606481,
-0.0365524441,
-0.020406099,
-0.0273515843,
-0.0408014357,
-0.0082917837,
0.0556899495,
-0.0203176681,
-0.0269902088,
0.0855950564,
-0.0326102301,
0.0733826086,
-0.0760668218,
-0.0170248225,
-0.0282478016,
0.0184873547,
0.0316515565,
0.0149030266,
0.021620648,
0.0107148727,
-0.0566158444,
-0.0188022349,
0.0675680488,
-0.0073804972,
0.0717626885,
-0.0757180303,
0.0211508069,
-0.0266065933,
-0.0017520924,
-0.0268650204,
-0.0275518019,
-0.0294669867,
0.0193991885,
0.0065251808,
0.0167206675,
-0.0327944383,
0.0387571268,
0.0408445261,
0.0466523245,
-0.035526365,
-0.0193541124,
-0.0166981909,
0.052804932,
0.0952750221,
0.0049454765,
0.0449339747,
-0.0285946578,
0.0093608154,
0.033839304,
0.0028399166,
0.0280884653,
-0.0163972713,
-0.041928459,
0.0035872837,
-0.0788013488,
-0.0196473412,
0.0240779258,
0.0539254062,
-0.0122293569,
-0.003994063,
0.129540652,
0.0234766975,
-0.0046251887,
-0.0033757617,
0.0267468877,
0.0314304568,
-0.01126293,
-0.0238778684,
-0.0548709631,
-0.0376572534,
-0.000276912,
0.0383931026,
0.0015624674,
-0.02090987,
0.00074958,
-0.0781653374,
0.020860523,
0.0216037147,
-0.0632926524,
-0.0562108271,
-0.0632228926,
0.0356053486,
-0.0273481552,
0.0331181772,
0.0350597538,
-0.0177650265,
0.047548417,
0.0281876698,
-0.0820532888,
-0.0076133767,
-0.0270876363,
-0.0697752833,
0.0005879485,
0.0671305805,
0.0192078445,
0.0107495831,
0.0305636227,
0.0255707055,
-0.0426763706,
-0.0178182404,
0.0218674857,
0.0378629677,
-0.0081263827,
0.0534870438,
-0.0387041457,
0.0392236821,
0.0134925898,
-0.0289235972,
-0.0031785446,
-0.00217516,
0.0008160481,
-0.0295797698,
-0.0558478422,
0.0423568599,
-0.036532972,
0.0874994248,
0.0411186703,
-0.0056126942,
-0.0200747587,
-0.041358225,
0.0342348106,
-0.0200390071,
-0.0163688269,
-0.014525082,
-0.0306116622,
-0.0345335715,
-0.0918518007,
-0.0608751401,
-0.0116917258,
-0.0426560827,
0.0016370126,
0.0080081616,
0.0243390221,
-0.0132184662,
-0.0097491285,
0.0076679634,
0.0023929174,
-0.0045374152,
-0.0169334039,
0.0196681321,
0.0553198121,
-0.0210664365,
-0.0254368912,
0.0671028942,
-0.0560903586,
-0.0381492823,
-0.0499856584,
0.0497414693,
0.0275368635,
0.0530465767,
0.0189154688,
-0.0137894675,
0.0072303028,
0.0238555763,
0.021008011,
0.0198247489,
-0.0102062533,
0.0593580455,
-0.0181175191,
-0.0017818884,
-0.0602308251,
0.017377587,
-0.0436700396,
0.0597995184,
-0.0152098052,
-0.0988284573,
0.023559127,
0.0182519034,
0.0115583437,
-0.0482713878,
-0.0410245433,
-0.0233519599,
-0.0331219137,
-0.0138466908,
-0.0203004293,
-0.0074853757,
0.0582209677,
0.0059439219,
0.039975021,
-0.0290885475,
0.0414922833,
-0.0097312192,
0.0244810972,
-0.0693949759,
-0.0314338803,
0.0129707372,
-0.0032702899,
-0.0653841048,
-0.0518148802,
-0.0625560731,
-0.0462196209,
-0.0400981568,
0.0338296071,
-0.0208155718,
-0.0045816312,
0.0189244878,
-0.0050241617,
0.0078892121,
0.0314298831,
-0.0908445865,
0.0164244287,
-0.0740965605,
0.0174609069,
0.0591178499,
-0.0296139028,
0.0842399001,
-0.0243241787,
0.0065301335,
-0.0172979794,
0.0475602299,
0.0390077978,
0.0186838154,
-0.0311861243,
0.0168364085,
0.0037332189,
0.0136008793,
0.0620540679,
0.0009689308,
0.0010051155,
-0.0001753344,
-0.0516783856,
-0.034574464,
-0.0437733494,
-0.0567905717,
0.0509032421,
-0.0083029857,
-0.0393068977,
-0.0448977612,
-0.0343723819,
0.0385989808,
0.0434481949,
0.0281535666,
-0.0262631048,
0.0132795889,
0.039389383,
-0.0208773315,
-0.0121498164,
-0.0414597392,
-0.0057063662,
-0.0254425537,
0.0154209584,
-0.0667625442,
-5.802167015e-33,
-0.0290693901,
-0.0199656785,
-0.040618021,
-0.001782942,
-0.0217642821,
-0.0138747487,
-0.0728056207,
-0.0104382765,
-0.0054291468,
-0.0081065223,
0.0068498151,
0.0046208976,
0.0178437643,
0.0084820036,
0.0042056884,
0.0171027966,
0.0246798266,
0.0349633917,
-0.0783147886,
-0.0134963626,
0.0273886416,
-0.0129955634,
0.0423651934,
-0.0472272038,
0.0588769577,
-0.0122053688,
-0.00285156,
-0.0243457202,
0.0318358094,
0.0272354186,
-0.0117827104,
0.0380105712,
0.0337856449,
-0.0581565313,
-0.0339306742,
-0.0108989449,
-0.0841377378,
-0.0219515692,
0.0570129156,
-0.0466884188,
-0.0543509647,
-0.0234028734,
0.0585665442,
-0.0080965757,
-0.0298422929,
-0.0112680234,
0.0700430423,
-0.0463272855,
-0.0391783975,
-0.056351155,
-0.047717493,
0.0444641449,
-0.0192629565,
-0.0102347666,
-0.013492492,
0.0568991937,
0.0050728833,
0.0135793872,
-0.0319097489,
0.0135308243,
0.0386295952,
0.0514523014,
0.0483694263,
0.0208955463,
-0.0199270844,
0.0588980578,
-0.0169746932,
-0.0372893587,
-0.0301936604,
-0.0142654283,
-0.0261487663,
-0.0020381822,
0.0321928114,
0.0575098358,
0.0573168248,
0.0421758108,
-0.0511078611,
0.1066057533,
-0.0099636912,
0.001085999,
0.0434075631,
0.0013751172,
-0.0316027142,
-0.0249413643,
-0.0619516149,
-0.0171348602,
-0.0009536835,
0.0067082732,
-0.0075259507,
0.0088065574,
-0.0308414716,
0.0041004978,
0.014092423,
-0.0270178076,
-0.0032897957,
-0.0059379744,
-0.0112884538,
-0.0148928007,
0.0118539333,
-0.0027812566,
-0.0428560376,
0.0391567387,
0.0002976901,
0.0224660262,
0.0019568175,
-0.0067767212,
0.0395632237,
-0.0334100835,
-0.0015770573,
0.0135639384,
-0.0058676191,
-0.0151691567,
-0.0475721955,
0.011018225,
0.0258465577,
0.0178723186,
-0.0032421839,
0.0269738995,
-0.0218455028,
0.003492007,
0.0026987994,
0.0201637801,
0.0112331482,
0.0216112174,
-0.0161005128,
0.0272952896,
-0.0265444834,
0.02693679,
0.0134763801,
-0.0171378013,
-0.0261765514,
0.0271054972,
2.376e-7,
0.0544826165,
0.0269538313,
0.0448371097,
0.0006467343,
-0.0332427062,
0.0398849435,
0.0110144895,
0.0100880479,
0.0592160709,
-0.0425402969,
0.0363843776,
0.0101855583,
0.0323718823,
0.0133863306,
-0.0724228844,
-0.028347129,
-0.0834902823,
-0.005827928,
-0.0156666655,
-0.0118949739,
0.0718269199,
0.0727369785,
-0.0236365609,
0.0009319242,
-0.0001417636,
-0.0165084619,
0.0306743253,
-0.0310199112,
-0.0374700464,
0.0162697304,
0.0430146717,
0.0065115928,
0.0092419302,
-0.0190395247,
-0.0242944378,
-0.0164213423,
0.053882733,
0.0319042467,
0.0181244425,
-0.0133816889,
-0.0288429465,
-0.0158452224,
0.0566177368,
-0.0128085688,
0.0433138646,
-0.0483511351,
-0.0003629981,
-0.0399045907,
-0.0678078011,
0.0277375393,
0.0065662912,
0.0213883854,
-0.0452503674,
0.0523658469,
-0.0064409557,
0.0224887356,
-0.0179526005,
-0.0576937459,
-0.0630388707,
0.0010210747,
-0.0119368294,
-0.0188092459,
-0.0142644579,
-0.0271459967,
0.005358852,
-0.0852866024,
-0.0097339265,
2.197144731e-34,
0.0657570884,
0.008486948,
-0.0056224898,
-0.0030876107,
0.061048314,
-0.0091973767,
-0.025682414,
0.0030196896,
0.0175024252,
-0.0597836748,
-0.0121345501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08753v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08753v3 | CompA: Addressing the Gap in Compositional Reasoning in Audio-Language Models | 2023-10-12T22:43:38 | 2024-06-18T18:03:28 | Sreyan Ghosh, Ashish Seth, Sonal Kumar, Utkarsh Tyagi, Chandra Kiran Evuru, Ramaneswaran S, S. Sakshi, Oriol Nieto, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | A fundamental characteristic of audio is its compositional nature.
Audio-language models (ALMs) trained using a contrastive approach (e.g., CLAP)
that learns a shared representation between audio and language modalities have
improved performance in many downstream applications, including zero-shot audio
classification, audio retrieval, etc. However, the ability of these models to
effectively perform compositional reasoning remains largely unexplored and
necessitates additional research. In this paper, we propose CompA, a collection
of two expert-annotated benchmarks with a majority of real-world audio samples,
to evaluate compositional reasoning in ALMs. Our proposed CompA-order evaluates
how well an ALM understands the order or occurrence of acoustic events in
audio, and CompA-attribute evaluates attribute-binding of acoustic events. An
instance from either benchmark consists of two audio-caption pairs, where both
audios have the same acoustic events but with different compositions. An ALM is
evaluated on how well it matches the right audio to the right caption. Using
this benchmark, we first show that current ALMs perform only marginally better
than random chance, thereby struggling with compositional reasoning. Next, we
propose CompA-CLAP, where we fine-tune CLAP using a novel learning method to
improve its compositional reasoning abilities. To train CompA-CLAP, we first
propose improvements to contrastive training with composition-aware hard
negatives, allowing for more focused training. Next, we propose a novel modular
contrastive loss that helps the model learn fine-grained compositional
understanding and overcomes the acute scarcity of openly available
compositional audios. CompA-CLAP significantly improves over all our baseline
models on the CompA benchmark, indicating its superior compositional reasoning
capabilities. | [
-0.000504524,
0.0679153055,
-0.0082441382,
0.0387435332,
-0.0150639191,
0.0063428413,
0.0310531724,
-0.0375385694,
-0.0685996488,
-0.0276035145,
-0.0462920144,
-0.0478246473,
0.0370996185,
0.0276280008,
0.0042109243,
-0.0298867729,
0.0323398449,
-0.028974209,
-0.0033372191,
0.0019293212,
-0.0034946585,
0.0150690908,
-0.0446411967,
0.0325945057,
0.005293021,
0.0181097835,
-0.0068673571,
0.0384255201,
0.0230288021,
-0.0042971065,
0.0022906256,
0.0432613678,
0.0340399295,
0.0234713331,
0.0000016077,
-0.0386637785,
0.0208724663,
-0.0018704099,
-0.0049945344,
-0.0364335924,
0.004123209,
0.0127412938,
-0.0178358871,
0.0401596725,
-0.0008292725,
-0.0093307141,
0.0326997451,
0.0437819771,
0.0589172468,
0.0817909613,
-0.0028018672,
-0.0835701153,
-0.0077598407,
-0.0392633937,
0.0319312103,
-0.0091408631,
-0.0007940225,
-0.007066207,
0.0285189617,
-0.0056899493,
-0.0187543649,
0.0491985455,
0.0244567245,
0.0287437886,
-0.0044108331,
0.0590415969,
-0.0527770035,
-0.0188576207,
0.0134498393,
0.0910599083,
0.0459999852,
-0.0163644496,
0.015011969,
0.0179762878,
-0.0184867494,
-0.076466985,
-0.0346668288,
0.032188531,
0.0149279321,
0.0223915409,
-0.0310525484,
0.0421699658,
0.0387776792,
-0.013399954,
-0.002185985,
0.0103009865,
0.0006016209,
-0.0101135783,
0.011022618,
-0.0348742008,
0.0159206297,
-0.0220331196,
0.0212845653,
0.0440332144,
-0.0129043199,
-0.0347483754,
-0.0197433289,
-0.0217779651,
0.0147263184,
-0.0182238538,
0.0257536303,
0.0355269648,
-0.0513122939,
0.1129758134,
-0.0184893738,
0.008425721,
-0.0119833248,
0.020053735,
-0.0289155059,
-0.0364063308,
-0.0692307875,
-0.026305275,
-0.0029686643,
0.0263462588,
0.0060046883,
-0.0271223746,
-0.0213680658,
-0.0457651913,
-0.0678799376,
0.0596585348,
0.0052972734,
0.0208244361,
-0.0128228273,
-0.030564243,
0.0169565342,
0.0272362214,
-0.0218660533,
0.0784964561,
-0.0211482346,
0.0081206784,
-0.0098661445,
-0.0039406917,
0.0186156388,
0.0086526508,
0.0651972666,
0.0607572794,
-0.0037322585,
-0.0280968435,
0.0039304621,
-0.0245916378,
-0.0194352604,
-0.0871049836,
-0.0110306777,
-0.0661747009,
0.045400165,
-0.007087402,
-0.0381985046,
-0.0250409618,
0.0034391074,
0.0174199957,
-0.006845972,
0.1104143336,
0.0325376056,
0.0273666568,
0.005142245,
0.0323506035,
-0.0383687615,
0.057970617,
0.0496695116,
-0.0085696001,
-0.0090909321,
-0.0070466264,
0.0235612355,
-0.016601095,
0.0209364612,
-0.0144897774,
-0.028428128,
0.004738892,
-0.0197236836,
0.0327839851,
0.0231581703,
0.0599860512,
-0.019644957,
-0.0798601657,
0.04931188,
-0.0210597068,
-0.0001483327,
-0.0022570689,
0.0368452817,
0.0039954744,
-0.0133499131,
0.0204582196,
-0.0297974851,
0.0858642384,
-0.0204356331,
0.0228544809,
0.0449071862,
0.0014957278,
-0.0339223631,
-0.0001170139,
-0.0114778876,
-0.0230744965,
0.01970708,
0.0076353489,
0.0224145334,
0.0126932859,
-0.0306751411,
0.0412728488,
0.0022742096,
-0.0232366323,
-0.0246095639,
-0.0239912234,
0.0273465347,
0.0468035936,
0.0155807212,
-0.0461877175,
-0.0297422372,
-0.0320762768,
0.0050092242,
0.0372616798,
0.0025542344,
-0.0161421988,
0.0523923263,
-0.0462793484,
-0.0101852212,
-0.0418571271,
0.0116493357,
0.0316941999,
-0.0094780391,
0.0157460868,
0.034773659,
-0.0275690388,
0.0282568038,
-0.0181790013,
0.0402051583,
-0.0290071219,
0.0008220466,
0.0396368243,
0.0208135992,
0.0202823002,
-0.0086728744,
0.040383555,
-0.0036039497,
-0.0333251134,
-0.0332432687,
0.0271175727,
-0.0920042172,
-0.058172185,
0.053209126,
-0.0506037176,
0.0054010702,
0.0236003865,
-0.0249863826,
-0.0575892478,
0.0639921278,
-0.010556343,
0.0288139265,
-0.0294277631,
0.0034816461,
0.0160095952,
0.0161221102,
0.0407904238,
0.0156618226,
0.0191492271,
-0.003093444,
0.017300589,
0.0266675204,
0.053409189,
-0.0186784826,
-0.0503223985,
0.0336910188,
-0.007764135,
0.0190267917,
-0.023480583,
-0.0352952257,
-0.0382302664,
-0.0231811181,
-0.0680992305,
0.0134763513,
-0.0210922435,
-0.0032933613,
-0.0046136118,
-0.0290582012,
0.02816635,
-0.0407720581,
-0.017795207,
-0.0254517626,
-0.0008763155,
0.0302498639,
-0.0243628621,
0.0340140276,
-0.0357228667,
-0.0231405981,
-0.0044600926,
-0.0045280335,
0.019350687,
-0.0522726476,
0.0346115306,
0.0102694305,
-0.0141867949,
-0.0243203342,
0.0044758981,
-0.0349293165,
-0.0371353067,
0.0013460071,
-0.006573265,
-0.004562289,
0.0509897768,
-0.0205723848,
0.0036928991,
0.0662761852,
-0.0032875559,
-0.0131207136,
0.0281519014,
0.0123460209,
0.0092810588,
0.0002222913,
0.0090546897,
-0.0619916245,
0.0657180771,
-0.0042728698,
0.0122438325,
-0.0551639199,
-0.006982991,
-0.0071229613,
0.0019258689,
-0.0301296394,
-0.0420136154,
-0.0469201244,
0.0333438925,
-0.0463099927,
0.0035047557,
0.0731312707,
-0.0643516034,
-0.0401163176,
-0.0438119434,
-0.0316451043,
-0.0372399725,
0.081862852,
-0.0397854112,
0.0045335339,
0.0285046808,
-0.0300535467,
-0.068474032,
-0.0194889382,
0.0592317097,
-0.0466327108,
-0.0120420177,
-0.0031288383,
0.0047223782,
-0.0340036824,
-0.0632144585,
-0.0120876888,
-0.0131885819,
-0.0319401734,
0.0461771674,
-0.0478165373,
-0.0145899141,
-0.0514657237,
0.0120572234,
0.0324345194,
0.0300707873,
0.0030965668,
0.0229056478,
0.0123181092,
0.0466406345,
0.0300423522,
0.0185415838,
-0.0246383753,
-0.0218188632,
0.0233448502,
0.0061526061,
0.0611709766,
0.0035986886,
-0.0443969183,
0.0222520232,
0.0188698974,
0.0275391303,
-0.041435618,
0.0369758271,
0.006100025,
-0.0645611882,
0.0159760229,
0.0916559696,
0.0237280857,
-0.0393603519,
-0.0176608097,
0.0276429243,
-0.0054192841,
0.0391570367,
-0.0075068548,
-0.038788341,
-0.0537077636,
0.0433818139,
0.0052376473,
0.0353029296,
0.023490604,
-0.0219158959,
-0.0994265378,
0.019082658,
0.0069681057,
-0.0736864582,
-0.054813806,
-0.0011652536,
0.0023198144,
-0.0059571466,
-0.0042824354,
-0.0094472077,
-0.0013365261,
-0.0061228471,
0.001431215,
-0.0184819922,
-0.0697069764,
0.0614835359,
-0.0392118581,
0.0638148636,
0.0402568504,
0.0359418876,
-0.0134282345,
-0.0392733626,
0.0031182859,
-0.0340231694,
-0.0053715641,
0.0307802483,
0.044079233,
-0.0154481214,
-0.0139424577,
0.0375977606,
0.0307786986,
-0.0239461064,
-0.0202924758,
-0.040572226,
0.0558439679,
0.0118144341,
0.0042515206,
-0.0455041975,
0.0687724799,
0.0087544778,
0.0862117708,
0.0411300436,
0.0307341907,
-0.0066441158,
-0.0025876977,
-0.0347415358,
-0.0806136802,
0.022794297,
0.0098834913,
0.0562844574,
0.0272033438,
-0.053770449,
-0.0086701903,
-0.010706462,
0.0390423611,
-0.0158923473,
0.0023937186,
-0.0328291878,
-0.0092702545,
-0.0808608308,
0.0267444365,
0.0003219338,
0.0659100786,
-0.0216328334,
-0.0148765733,
0.0625825897,
-0.0510908253,
-0.0459259786,
-0.0113938469,
-0.0762588158,
-0.0573278144,
-0.0278222337,
0.0325997658,
0.0215197206,
0.060363885,
-0.0219787024,
-0.0408252031,
-0.0020659219,
0.0317411385,
-0.0316669382,
0.0093679465,
0.0721076652,
-0.0306902826,
0.0020746957,
0.0252322406,
-0.072661452,
0.0281594023,
0.0285832416,
0.0406482369,
0.0202813521,
0.0215720925,
0.0048356657,
-0.0566669218,
0.027560154,
-0.0038972259,
0.034949109,
-0.0267464425,
0.031577643,
0.0116495406,
-0.0134415692,
-0.0338116661,
-0.0017075194,
0.0209273696,
0.0314696431,
-0.0334089883,
0.0022427307,
-0.0002741807,
0.02905141,
0.0270597003,
0.0446893461,
0.06650161,
-0.0820658877,
0.0101744104,
0.0010456822,
0.0062093106,
0.0275302362,
0.0300540328,
0.034478385,
0.0126970485,
0.0480439365,
0.0104345083,
0.0059315269,
-0.0295449495,
0.0205542259,
-0.0545556024,
0.0314153284,
0.0181228481,
0.0221675932,
0.0595862828,
-0.0474565625,
-0.0232315976,
0.0202819053,
-0.0036514071,
-0.0057333605,
0.035971757,
-0.0325795449,
-0.0343940482,
0.0308142416,
0.0431842394,
0.0136122312,
0.0409406573,
0.0655450001,
-0.0402621701,
0.0353786871,
-0.0300295129,
0.0343999378,
0.0011637264,
-0.0236685276,
-0.0086082341,
0.0408526547,
-0.0026309788,
0.0110343313,
-0.0531618409,
-0.089675568,
-0.0082131652,
-0.0236650221,
0.0156698022,
0.0102110198,
0.0247158799,
0.0509288758,
0.0188988391,
0.0167217776,
0.0371920317,
-0.0931597725,
-0.022021085,
0.0299981032,
0.0011812962,
-5.577042214e-33,
-0.0219784901,
-0.0036037157,
0.0039307973,
-0.018297486,
-0.0034691361,
0.0164556745,
-0.0439837575,
-0.0292919092,
-0.0200165678,
-0.001930853,
0.0110311201,
0.0133430529,
0.01616087,
0.0193781871,
0.0159029849,
-0.0235365536,
0.0606251061,
-0.0020043072,
-0.0437806323,
0.0023036886,
0.052106753,
0.035117548,
0.0107364096,
-0.0514117219,
-0.0369963534,
-0.0007564247,
-0.0205943752,
0.0194852967,
-0.0200048108,
0.0912973508,
-0.0008162058,
0.0079102563,
0.0114633366,
-0.0431348011,
0.0009032955,
-0.0034038671,
-0.0756334588,
-0.003259975,
0.0148954643,
0.0128229866,
-0.0052245236,
-0.0119445724,
0.0253570061,
-0.0042505115,
0.0139224399,
-0.066749759,
0.0198109746,
-0.0178402886,
0.0007551593,
-0.0598501824,
-0.0549943522,
-0.0030161059,
-0.0387505814,
-0.0575170368,
0.0305435564,
0.002906769,
0.0093123894,
0.0281819683,
-0.0498367473,
0.0162126869,
-0.0258778036,
0.0096576214,
0.0392104574,
0.0034867525,
-0.0458532758,
0.048869703,
0.0113186836,
-0.0270542726,
-0.0216441564,
0.00570032,
0.0125113856,
0.0538198762,
0.0551610179,
0.0408438258,
0.05373732,
-0.000893276,
-0.0059335749,
-0.0138945486,
-0.0403754376,
0.0262760948,
0.0449169911,
0.0647172108,
-0.0597348474,
-0.0081225662,
-0.0684496164,
-0.0108594215,
-0.0638352707,
-0.0169761069,
0.0325472057,
0.0254082959,
-0.0119660944,
0.0072780503,
0.0482098423,
-0.0295254923,
0.006767517,
0.0153487604,
-0.0445032232,
-0.0031370539,
0.0035525716,
0.0219407938,
-0.0554418601,
-0.0053336141,
0.1064035669,
0.0205426663,
0.0138998004,
-0.0187887121,
0.0631278306,
0.0692032278,
-0.0506198369,
-0.0095521808,
-0.0226809215,
-0.0058652405,
-0.0305341445,
0.0215991214,
0.035452541,
0.075129889,
-0.0457417406,
0.0441933721,
-0.0385230891,
0.0419678874,
-0.0447770655,
-0.0376209542,
-0.0558025204,
0.0372625627,
-0.0235431287,
0.0199095793,
-0.0081834039,
-0.0531471968,
0.0092908032,
-0.0256056041,
-0.0141417356,
0.0297408104,
2.517e-7,
-0.0019908105,
-0.0121437432,
-0.0097106192,
-0.0001898746,
0.0175243244,
0.060907241,
-0.1050141826,
-0.0124976868,
0.0079253651,
-0.0132918684,
0.0339469872,
0.0257425737,
0.0887896717,
0.0173039455,
-0.0739682838,
0.0495986305,
-0.0927452594,
-0.0315802097,
-0.051814422,
-0.0412439741,
0.0642304048,
0.1058959588,
0.025688393,
-0.0329686105,
0.021813361,
-0.0299511068,
0.0605235845,
0.0156242205,
0.0196370613,
-0.0715103298,
0.0030500037,
0.0060764961,
-0.0184859931,
0.0014598379,
-0.0359849595,
0.0156340692,
0.0314596966,
0.0402779467,
0.0345156491,
-0.0756882429,
-0.0176513046,
0.0274219494,
-0.019868046,
-0.0399886854,
0.1015276909,
-0.041839391,
-0.0440280624,
-0.0328566916,
-0.0714213699,
-0.0004631221,
0.014566863,
0.0028077206,
-0.0047358996,
-0.0211981591,
-0.0050454149,
-0.0152032441,
-0.0162904765,
-0.1191129088,
-0.0121738855,
0.0226016585,
-0.0145655638,
0.0173077807,
-0.0179490969,
-0.0015376183,
0.0470290482,
-0.0517418534,
-0.0382670276,
1.880564702e-34,
0.0591381937,
-0.0607890226,
0.0013200656,
-0.0264869202,
0.0072177784,
0.0035637137,
-0.0249829609,
-0.0183905363,
0.0244637057,
-0.0191936325,
-0.0081410483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08744v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08744v3 | Circuit Component Reuse Across Tasks in Transformer Language Models | 2023-10-12T22:12:28 | 2024-05-06T14:31:32 | Jack Merullo, Carsten Eickhoff, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent work in mechanistic interpretability has shown that behaviors in
language models can be successfully reverse-engineered through circuit
analysis. A common criticism, however, is that each circuit is task-specific,
and thus such analysis cannot contribute to understanding the models at a
higher level. In this work, we present evidence that insights (both low-level
findings about specific heads and higher-level findings about general
algorithms) can indeed generalize across tasks. Specifically, we study the
circuit discovered in Wang et al. (2022) for the Indirect Object Identification
(IOI) task and 1.) show that it reproduces on a larger GPT2 model, and 2.) that
it is mostly reused to solve a seemingly different task: Colored Objects
(Ippolito & Callison-Burch, 2023). We provide evidence that the process
underlying both tasks is functionally very similar, and contains about a 78%
overlap in in-circuit attention heads. We further present a proof-of-concept
intervention experiment, in which we adjust four attention heads in middle
layers in order to 'repair' the Colored Objects circuit and make it behave like
the IOI circuit. In doing so, we boost accuracy from 49.6% to 93.7% on the
Colored Objects task and explain most sources of error. The intervention
affects downstream attention heads in specific ways predicted by their
interactions in the IOI circuit, indicating that this subcircuit behavior is
invariant to the different task inputs. Overall, our results provide evidence
that it may yet be possible to explain large language models' behavior in terms
of a relatively small number of interpretable task-general algorithmic building
blocks and computational components. | [
0.0211841334,
0.0067898277,
-0.0342115089,
0.0682079718,
-0.0314509682,
0.0143361147,
0.0179203805,
0.004963594,
-0.01613231,
-0.0122151533,
-0.0625956282,
-0.0267724469,
0.0370759182,
0.0204568096,
0.0407629237,
-0.0263911895,
0.024155641,
-0.0338007994,
-0.0546747968,
-0.012798856,
-0.0113042118,
-0.0065661818,
0.0096684918,
0.0589412712,
0.0254163351,
-0.0068338593,
-0.0291890725,
-0.0186670981,
0.0072978185,
0.0528941005,
-0.0093505317,
0.080006808,
-0.0208181348,
0.06992919,
0.0000022957,
-0.0129683912,
-0.0251104757,
-0.0063922834,
-0.0225011185,
0.0021345112,
-0.0012790975,
-0.0237298459,
-0.0297150109,
-0.0157072749,
0.0188566837,
-0.0109008085,
0.1361060888,
0.0577341318,
0.0099612679,
0.0315732509,
0.0048324964,
-0.012624409,
0.0584426783,
-0.0100573488,
0.0582009666,
-0.0003908449,
0.002573425,
-0.0269534625,
0.0210934877,
-0.0310297869,
-0.0471092239,
0.0088695008,
0.0481743589,
0.0394822508,
0.0061035054,
0.0192464814,
-0.0335191637,
0.0010524866,
-0.0106289936,
0.0336017683,
-0.0584989674,
-0.0555997603,
-0.0101487292,
0.0114349406,
-0.0159382839,
0.0077827997,
-0.0314467065,
0.0080532813,
-0.0238701347,
0.0042441403,
0.0011331888,
-0.0238549132,
0.033567097,
-0.0364007503,
-0.0202894919,
0.050122343,
0.0056636911,
-0.0116446149,
-0.0301964991,
0.0197758954,
-0.0265860371,
-0.0244455002,
0.0172374435,
-0.0124115283,
-0.0023485087,
-0.0010929651,
0.0002934321,
-0.0283050779,
-0.0501107685,
-0.0172679219,
0.0741330013,
0.0612241477,
-0.0207883157,
0.0089212982,
-0.0157599282,
0.0852003917,
-0.0736075938,
0.0310871284,
-0.040950533,
0.0048356047,
-0.0647967532,
-0.0631031841,
-0.0171981137,
0.0135168489,
0.0150497556,
-0.0320590436,
0.0271138754,
0.030883329,
-0.0300134309,
-0.0506717451,
-0.021668382,
-0.0308561213,
-0.0498834588,
0.0018323399,
0.00960021,
0.0472911932,
0.0236645658,
-0.0055930312,
-0.0139727602,
-0.0629875362,
-0.0413596369,
-0.014282316,
0.0183911677,
-0.0220210794,
-0.0468829721,
0.0806724951,
-0.0101832971,
-0.0430968329,
-0.031471163,
-0.0227084421,
-0.0027710623,
0.0000764581,
0.0613192171,
-0.0401195586,
0.001796628,
0.0153888855,
0.0189009216,
-0.0312607139,
0.010185048,
0.003746191,
-0.0465634502,
0.072723411,
0.0065483991,
0.0188479144,
-0.0306772757,
0.0061033559,
-0.0043478454,
0.0540731736,
0.0287148394,
0.0271642972,
-0.0085469047,
-0.0575837903,
0.0304468833,
0.0377959497,
-0.0099654896,
-0.0038330569,
-0.0125475498,
-0.0730357096,
-0.0051971995,
-0.0131473234,
0.0170084499,
0.0400410853,
-0.0130860629,
-0.0029561147,
0.0613609068,
0.0154164732,
0.0148486039,
0.0387199186,
0.0150370523,
-0.0228858143,
-0.0243143979,
0.0761791617,
-0.0981441811,
0.0671808198,
-0.0477900617,
0.0055891261,
-0.0346005335,
-0.0020358006,
-0.0227327347,
-0.0150989899,
-0.0168883204,
0.0296429154,
0.0203096438,
-0.0156158451,
0.0619160458,
0.0263447296,
-0.0444857217,
0.0433558039,
-0.0080127437,
-0.0425416492,
-0.039990671,
-0.0856574997,
0.0186020564,
0.0491677374,
0.033801768,
-0.0142720938,
0.016907284,
0.0064321021,
-0.0118356887,
0.0367499217,
0.001520628,
0.0334773436,
0.0040635201,
0.0011095071,
-0.01681621,
-0.0139303273,
0.0271440484,
0.0393503346,
-0.0223706886,
-0.0563419573,
0.0108602485,
0.0046983049,
0.0098063881,
-0.0019871781,
0.015844645,
-0.0105884327,
-0.0171419252,
0.0338231996,
0.0114350729,
-0.0359725915,
-0.0140179433,
0.0132443495,
0.0105588185,
-0.0171402693,
0.027345337,
0.0291699991,
-0.0251637418,
0.0095535666,
0.0142595582,
-0.0412731357,
-0.0295640565,
0.0524040125,
0.0152319744,
-0.0402168855,
0.0657634214,
-0.0757124797,
0.0578462556,
0.0030542503,
0.0352847055,
-0.0192162916,
0.0226962846,
-0.017544277,
0.0627008453,
-0.000087655,
-0.0074829035,
0.0097875958,
-0.0226643775,
-0.0038716502,
-0.0530716628,
-0.0047024535,
0.0066134022,
0.0003008856,
-0.0019983768,
0.0149557097,
-0.0412061587,
-0.0219414346,
-0.0425825976,
-0.0255206842,
-0.0221004449,
-0.0084389551,
0.0085952133,
0.0353238247,
-0.0120833917,
0.012465667,
0.0245961268,
0.028318299,
0.0245598461,
-0.0177882481,
0.0458799005,
0.0009261503,
-0.0434844159,
-0.0505210347,
-0.0244750772,
-0.0432879813,
-0.032438837,
0.0734563246,
0.0006952624,
-0.0429552309,
-0.0817036778,
0.046836976,
0.0326562859,
0.0294524748,
-0.0011585713,
-0.0419434644,
0.0375768356,
-0.007434254,
0.087340802,
0.0840028003,
-0.0266142488,
0.0476562269,
0.0488923118,
-0.0716871321,
0.003971206,
-0.0134873977,
-0.0117837433,
-0.0091582937,
-0.0000953006,
-0.0598492622,
-0.0093513895,
0.1041857824,
0.0084411809,
-0.0008034925,
-0.0791624933,
0.0193490982,
0.0055658547,
-0.0249559209,
-0.0149919288,
-0.0598658361,
-0.0169901848,
0.034433946,
-0.0323311426,
-0.055328384,
0.0695121735,
-0.0244320799,
-0.0068772738,
0.0060257674,
0.0266480613,
0.0163527448,
0.1035672426,
0.0607580356,
0.0252333526,
0.0679189861,
-0.00386569,
-0.0567014255,
0.0501561984,
-0.0114499694,
-0.013024929,
0.0533300079,
-0.0543453023,
-0.008934469,
-0.0108210854,
-0.0324817486,
-0.0096792532,
0.0514071845,
-0.0081750862,
-0.0001558819,
0.0088941725,
-0.0271234121,
-0.0743434429,
0.0722134262,
0.0716236681,
0.0323050991,
-0.0115095144,
-0.0074507752,
-0.0357645936,
0.0001085067,
-0.0152594596,
0.0107616838,
0.0441907682,
-0.0402165093,
0.014491003,
0.0356085077,
0.0446927249,
0.0057685263,
-0.0546836741,
0.038699016,
0.0353584401,
0.0189161431,
-0.0157453064,
0.0002148614,
0.0397970378,
-0.0799753964,
-0.0494107008,
0.0636043176,
0.007502852,
-0.0761998594,
0.0138761308,
-0.0116429916,
-0.0317099355,
0.0195104387,
0.0146218836,
-0.0576869622,
-0.0212245733,
0.03191147,
-0.0065523279,
-0.0228480957,
0.0128485756,
-0.0017659036,
-0.0973070636,
0.0411924981,
0.0127876848,
-0.0688261241,
-0.0834661275,
-0.0224276539,
-0.0005490216,
-0.0018124259,
0.0075450507,
0.0294568669,
-0.0135423979,
0.0162341688,
-0.0050820499,
-0.0017944057,
-0.0114795165,
0.0021441365,
0.0235982016,
-0.0010802385,
0.0791105777,
-0.0376614258,
-0.0161195341,
-0.0262285229,
0.0232875757,
-0.0124512203,
0.0297597162,
-0.0067369114,
0.037634775,
0.0583492555,
-0.0300980676,
-0.0433890857,
0.0161433145,
-0.0327612832,
-0.0662022308,
-0.0551658496,
0.0611223094,
-0.0224397425,
-0.042137567,
0.0047248998,
-0.0137480106,
-0.031161353,
0.0508433543,
0.0739449337,
-0.0294545218,
-0.0266866386,
-0.0449828617,
0.0326515958,
-0.0291028824,
-0.0919688195,
-0.0019361421,
0.0462570824,
-0.0473342501,
-0.0079377312,
0.0153493108,
-0.0121810585,
0.015525029,
0.0207307637,
-0.0513799675,
0.0183898062,
-0.0381086431,
-0.0515027717,
0.0615427941,
-0.02026904,
0.0177617855,
-0.0774833262,
-0.0474306755,
-0.0162918866,
-0.0673532635,
-0.0423907898,
0.035618946,
-0.0659962222,
-0.0511765555,
0.0382087976,
0.0448946953,
0.0318637602,
-0.0084807137,
0.0028730736,
-0.0411481895,
-0.0704480186,
0.0013724316,
-0.0032103797,
0.0587332994,
-0.0028270695,
-0.0364529714,
-0.0069720997,
0.0138900438,
0.004607813,
0.0289565902,
0.0823593363,
0.0161995236,
-0.008539279,
0.0035150878,
0.0491210073,
-0.0042366367,
0.1012499854,
0.0630149394,
0.0541660935,
-0.0164075922,
0.00413814,
0.0442598872,
-0.0035616904,
-0.043832276,
-0.0255092047,
0.0155239608,
0.0122715915,
0.0028514473,
-0.0139257619,
0.0187115166,
0.0012155863,
-0.052751638,
0.0132708382,
-0.0037656745,
0.0093981037,
-0.0068484894,
0.0287317149,
-0.0012553458,
0.0241925865,
0.0072461478,
0.0659372956,
0.0147263603,
0.0316299349,
0.014860712,
-0.0098163197,
-0.068314299,
0.0367579833,
-0.0766875818,
-0.0593614317,
0.0155691244,
0.001469272,
0.0280135125,
-0.0421906412,
0.0308130942,
-0.0278112032,
-0.0016042151,
-0.0269344654,
0.0059589907,
0.0378685817,
0.0016199885,
0.0027911996,
0.0166467782,
0.0281951595,
-0.0661407188,
0.0638792813,
-0.0088464953,
0.0135637727,
-0.029578479,
-0.0028219279,
0.0005713255,
-0.0322655924,
-0.0002710993,
0.0025518721,
-0.0242548008,
-0.0266078133,
-0.0357712023,
-0.0517193265,
-0.004796077,
-0.0111175757,
0.0461766422,
-0.0276795458,
0.0270419717,
0.0478387922,
-0.0082827974,
-0.0591992587,
0.0276794359,
-0.0023232321,
-0.0055416059,
-0.0113457721,
-0.0059937914,
-6.65014917e-33,
-0.039108105,
-0.0220060609,
-0.013766137,
0.014325981,
0.0118963346,
0.0365120359,
-0.0859948397,
0.0206510816,
0.0159880593,
-0.0052001243,
0.0017890442,
-0.0093886349,
0.0116321677,
-0.0073515167,
0.0130279846,
0.0205643978,
0.0250371918,
0.0432405248,
-0.0324891731,
0.0063952724,
0.0543614626,
0.0011819953,
0.1009341851,
-0.0501720607,
-0.0095485654,
0.0384632647,
0.000184814,
0.0003575314,
-0.0446875095,
0.0572202466,
-0.0152861653,
0.0270576421,
0.0270138048,
-0.0532841012,
-0.0246729739,
0.0571800359,
-0.0361665897,
0.0050445297,
0.0218996387,
0.0233351905,
-0.0217044987,
-0.0552734062,
0.0732734576,
-0.0154597638,
-0.0355649628,
-0.0241079014,
0.0250088759,
-0.0364548489,
0.0223905891,
0.0600517765,
-0.0655502081,
-0.0116280029,
-0.0060125138,
-0.0202670973,
0.0402237326,
0.0337267332,
-0.0193752274,
0.0291154534,
-0.0851221532,
0.037101198,
0.0226862803,
0.0470837839,
0.0376288667,
0.0663618669,
0.0352964103,
0.0379568934,
0.0954929814,
0.010687016,
-0.0333674662,
-0.0237746723,
0.0241278857,
0.0422180183,
0.0645056814,
-0.02634646,
0.055674687,
0.0120159229,
-0.0210694596,
-0.0106903724,
-0.0211447049,
0.053180825,
0.0739862993,
0.0239647441,
-0.0336359739,
-0.0128903873,
-0.0092718136,
-0.0023689966,
-0.057477206,
-0.0189215858,
0.0179772023,
-0.0183397885,
-0.0328503177,
0.0048946193,
0.0519702099,
-0.0325714163,
0.0362753756,
-0.0086496715,
-0.0006096763,
0.0604382642,
-0.0013562634,
0.0018825503,
-0.0306826271,
-0.0275390688,
0.0080542676,
0.0196062345,
0.0053984262,
0.0250303391,
0.0010654503,
0.054209765,
-0.0323996022,
-0.0064922022,
-0.0637108609,
-0.0340072289,
0.0136284167,
0.0234644171,
0.0170997698,
0.0168795716,
-0.0061937422,
-0.0073285964,
0.0122832265,
-0.0254059006,
-0.0335906744,
0.0199313667,
-0.0546695478,
0.0160768609,
-0.0234512743,
-0.0267011318,
-0.0539350919,
0.0182463881,
0.0378065258,
-0.0191495847,
-0.0376457013,
0.0239684768,
3.11e-7,
0.0345982276,
0.0170525201,
0.0262323879,
0.0248649865,
0.0440917425,
0.0099797165,
-0.0015153623,
0.0031615568,
0.0112558473,
-0.0183140356,
-0.0182185136,
0.049187731,
0.0508570038,
-0.0033898109,
-0.040435113,
-0.0073992428,
-0.0263394993,
0.0388104878,
-0.0140377842,
0.0337775089,
-0.0227740705,
0.0703465119,
0.0057581556,
0.0112172691,
0.0020583777,
-0.0121001713,
0.0452528521,
-0.0503109396,
0.0628155246,
0.0017082299,
-0.0575923175,
0.0187905747,
-0.015510859,
0.0449753962,
0.0206596553,
0.0123841511,
0.0051305611,
0.0030381617,
-0.0330007486,
0.0145647582,
-0.0037359803,
-0.016758699,
-0.0010079648,
-0.0546492599,
0.0424125306,
-0.0521152169,
-0.0348870382,
-0.0240189638,
0.0367950946,
-0.0298787616,
-0.0167089123,
0.0027226084,
-0.0025407718,
-0.0008628409,
-0.0238243062,
0.0121593624,
-0.0301848389,
-0.02868581,
-0.0155387046,
0.0209361371,
-0.0596097782,
-0.0363115817,
-0.0746679679,
-0.040620584,
0.0291230679,
-0.0001202451,
-0.0552856699,
3.134038294e-34,
-0.0119655458,
-0.0085909693,
0.0167990383,
0.0486903414,
0.0657985955,
-0.0397037119,
-0.015355858,
-0.0026699021,
-0.004010262,
-0.0671563894,
-0.0610052869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08740v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08740v3 | A Zero-Shot Language Agent for Computer Control with Structured Reflection | 2023-10-12T21:53:37 | 2023-10-23T17:39:51 | Tao Li, Gang Li, Zhiwei Deng, Bryan Wang, Yang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SY, eess.SY | Large language models (LLMs) have shown increasing capacity at planning and
executing a high-level goal in a live computer environment (e.g. MiniWoB++). To
perform a task, recent works often require a model to learn from trace examples
of the task via either supervised learning or few/many-shot prompting. Without
these trace examples, it remains a challenge how an agent can autonomously
learn and improve its control on a computer, which limits the ability of an
agent to perform a new task. We approach this problem with a zero-shot agent
that requires no given expert traces. Our agent plans for executable actions on
a partially observed environment, and iteratively progresses a task by
identifying and learning from its mistakes via self-reflection and structured
thought management. On the easy tasks of MiniWoB++, we show that our zero-shot
agent often outperforms recent SoTAs, with more efficient reasoning. For tasks
with more complexity, our reflective agent performs on par with prior best
models, even though previous works had the advantages of accessing expert
traces or additional screen information. | [
0.0153931314,
0.0256824922,
-0.0039434177,
0.007819158,
-0.039923586,
0.0049381419,
0.0175093301,
-0.0047233473,
0.0318927839,
-0.0323730297,
-0.0097778505,
0.0062941578,
-0.0518178828,
0.0660083741,
0.0142875854,
-0.0427521728,
0.0680623427,
-0.071955584,
0.0098372465,
-0.0016190605,
-0.0167496912,
-0.0433320515,
-0.0431623869,
0.0284519829,
-0.0183160044,
-0.0153098814,
-0.0672946647,
-0.0204468928,
-0.0194756165,
-0.0127253756,
-0.039400775,
0.0002454165,
0.0523180962,
0.0472240485,
0.0000019836,
-0.0360629894,
0.0064835651,
-0.0207209587,
-0.0373203084,
-0.0246495306,
-0.0055327252,
-0.0099294409,
-0.0286441576,
0.0318254419,
-0.0492284074,
0.0272428021,
0.0287327673,
0.0198115762,
0.0626180992,
0.0731064603,
0.0193637647,
0.0202816166,
-0.0239067022,
0.0174437333,
0.0378235765,
-0.0235620961,
-0.0037316773,
0.0149721345,
0.0215476435,
0.0188013222,
-0.0264703818,
-0.0178005081,
0.008241849,
-0.0397805832,
-0.0448734984,
0.0400219746,
-0.0087654721,
-0.0243590027,
-0.0165788848,
0.0380631946,
-0.02101776,
-0.0176951643,
0.036798209,
0.0102499789,
-0.0079728607,
-0.0312766396,
-0.0178997815,
0.0361876562,
-0.0001768921,
-0.0080585759,
-0.0000090126,
-0.0135547891,
0.0020440624,
-0.0099771917,
-0.0306870844,
0.0948701501,
-0.0329105854,
-0.0339793749,
-0.026320219,
-0.007719289,
0.0502505824,
-0.0633084401,
-0.0401393287,
0.0874641836,
-0.046844136,
0.0268789679,
-0.0300711151,
-0.0062108939,
-0.039001476,
0.0115362937,
0.0768872201,
0.0570387058,
0.0270994343,
0.0577045046,
-0.0311492477,
0.0501680449,
-0.0119115934,
0.0160780083,
-0.0174099244,
0.0137973065,
-0.0883185714,
0.0119863646,
-0.0579786077,
0.0722210035,
-0.0137333106,
-0.0105301077,
-0.0084550548,
0.0554550998,
-0.0252966713,
0.0537485965,
-0.0484072454,
-0.0139729613,
0.004874344,
-0.0194413885,
-0.0674132258,
-0.0065499744,
-0.037029326,
-0.0067114444,
0.0142513271,
-0.0208508708,
-0.0154076153,
-0.0044160723,
0.0057926369,
0.0181866791,
0.0048291595,
0.1015148982,
0.0093822833,
-0.0303770099,
-0.0089268209,
-0.0130658075,
0.0060872617,
-0.0536716245,
0.0277648177,
-0.0316198543,
-0.0001634122,
-0.0100860046,
-0.0426355451,
-0.0216784365,
0.0071314713,
-0.0027868254,
0.0148126176,
0.080373548,
-0.0123421829,
0.0019454408,
-0.0107393358,
-0.0025435742,
-0.0516249202,
0.0488622673,
0.0202356819,
0.0409467928,
-0.0177614819,
0.0236980729,
0.0774636567,
0.0207492318,
-0.0060775927,
-0.0020280695,
-0.0396363698,
0.010805591,
0.005135281,
0.0339394882,
-0.0094635887,
0.0211668946,
-0.0309021343,
0.0701247305,
0.0227052197,
0.063669458,
-0.0194475986,
0.025148809,
0.0613761432,
0.0166926906,
-0.0039928183,
-0.0158782937,
-0.0461828075,
0.0555662327,
0.0024358786,
-0.0106931673,
-0.0520038344,
-0.0490243398,
-0.0292739961,
-0.0489989109,
-0.0050615915,
0.0073457165,
-0.0120575782,
-0.0008413283,
0.0409707762,
-0.0092482958,
-0.0461195298,
0.0003083298,
0.00952412,
-0.036584828,
-0.045727443,
-0.0977095813,
0.0652360171,
0.1033816487,
0.0374524817,
-0.0602808632,
-0.0393721908,
-0.0005187672,
0.0099933464,
0.0193743836,
0.0057082693,
-0.0095325829,
0.0066554355,
0.0168247521,
-0.0087369112,
-0.0233444106,
0.0228332635,
0.0505668111,
-0.0189576261,
-0.0209649298,
-0.0374124497,
0.0357627049,
-0.0020511225,
0.0250421949,
0.0241465103,
-0.0530110262,
-0.008362513,
0.003405726,
0.0204373244,
-0.0051979357,
-0.0175562091,
0.0225140564,
0.0301581379,
-0.0143094435,
-0.0379975662,
-0.0127362348,
-0.0359876789,
-0.0476109609,
0.0405205972,
-0.0373352766,
0.0111147044,
0.0400137678,
-0.0154182678,
-0.0635260493,
0.0391988233,
-0.0128428526,
0.0163063537,
0.0157812014,
0.0226228293,
-0.0284099393,
-0.0559140518,
-0.0020263572,
0.0696597993,
0.0200200733,
-0.0209382791,
0.0432453156,
-0.0115958704,
0.0069693113,
-0.038346678,
-0.0044715605,
-0.0191071089,
-0.0026211175,
0.0140444003,
0.0213394351,
0.0065379869,
-0.0364425033,
-0.0135098118,
-0.0463892668,
-0.0127297603,
-0.0182934385,
0.0005911147,
0.0191016588,
-0.0177156832,
0.0013591821,
-0.0517178439,
0.0036582479,
0.0477604419,
0.0053517823,
0.01212072,
0.0368864946,
0.0135899661,
-0.0346141644,
-0.0484814905,
0.0056678816,
-0.0334834494,
-0.0463879332,
-0.0177500863,
-0.0246601179,
-0.0551946983,
0.0729219094,
-0.0217920244,
0.0486174598,
-0.0288300551,
-0.0469261296,
0.0549338944,
-0.0588900112,
-0.0249671042,
0.0816791207,
-0.0299380217,
0.0129090622,
0.0953429937,
-0.0058306609,
-0.0516108125,
0.0376778468,
0.0078263227,
-0.0102763595,
-0.0013706571,
0.0382457152,
-0.0030904557,
0.0809453204,
-0.0126637882,
0.0280860905,
-0.0522058643,
0.0244051032,
-0.0057509113,
-0.0417549498,
-0.022638727,
-0.0059047495,
-0.0317899957,
0.0457019918,
-0.0232896246,
-0.0281778388,
0.0625068471,
0.0063581066,
-0.0077021383,
0.0327430405,
-0.0124001037,
-0.0078393659,
0.0770677105,
0.01460608,
0.0071986574,
0.0044896952,
-0.009469891,
-0.0475921407,
-0.0240379497,
0.04904183,
0.004562418,
0.0055001788,
-0.0663521364,
0.0322937593,
0.0007687763,
-0.054231666,
-0.0508647971,
-0.0268348437,
-0.0499245003,
0.0012697235,
-0.0298937168,
-0.0267211478,
-0.0174287204,
-0.0028001037,
0.0747307986,
0.0714947432,
0.0145259239,
-0.0407467373,
-0.0415920578,
-0.0723121464,
0.0341688283,
0.0109187895,
-0.0157172829,
0.0078619756,
0.106634602,
0.0446230806,
0.0810366198,
-0.0044293683,
-0.0416364893,
-0.0054991241,
-0.0080697546,
-0.0155596845,
0.00053578,
0.0455021486,
0.0536064394,
-0.0543607846,
-0.0416570641,
0.096681878,
0.0299429893,
-0.0136646675,
0.0142635889,
-0.0596581623,
-0.0150306989,
0.0412557013,
0.0621235296,
-0.0532185324,
-0.0394044258,
0.0028586923,
0.0101453178,
-0.0207814146,
-0.0569783151,
0.0153176319,
-0.1154066622,
0.0131126065,
-0.0016104891,
-0.0088876346,
0.016762903,
-0.0228944048,
0.0014290108,
-0.0022339006,
-0.0489109121,
0.0289658867,
0.0046438249,
-0.0155889736,
0.0069546951,
-0.0051415097,
-0.0176642984,
0.0527166538,
-0.007018026,
0.0460229479,
0.0839816853,
0.002974455,
0.0052911984,
0.0150737111,
0.0073219193,
0.0270416494,
0.0519247614,
-0.0123142675,
0.027992975,
0.0002613654,
-0.0188615751,
-0.0059004794,
0.0394409448,
-0.037434157,
-0.0133734932,
0.0247107577,
0.0855201259,
-0.0533313528,
0.014051646,
-0.0070075844,
-0.0496921316,
-0.0033720224,
0.0496749952,
-0.0109738074,
-0.016476769,
-0.0632376075,
-0.0291392282,
-0.0396044254,
-0.0259221569,
-0.0631000027,
0.0021408682,
0.01032886,
0.0241258331,
-0.0616949722,
-0.0665937886,
0.065455988,
0.0791403279,
0.0108457087,
-0.0578398332,
0.0081660487,
0.0114701204,
0.0024602152,
-0.0451359861,
-0.056669943,
0.0053449254,
-0.0296250843,
0.0003120663,
0.0376877859,
-0.0154300081,
0.0168869458,
-0.0370995812,
-0.0342737921,
-0.0481925346,
0.0153194051,
0.1051076651,
0.023389034,
0.0339272842,
-0.0225956328,
-0.0027041677,
0.0426520295,
-0.0206836145,
-0.0387320071,
-0.0000108596,
0.0342884175,
0.0226439908,
0.0109434435,
0.0528929234,
-0.0588212162,
0.0037553662,
0.0144543704,
0.0145363901,
-0.0689028725,
0.0096986974,
0.0504333265,
-0.0204667244,
0.0218638685,
-0.0083118984,
0.0055193044,
0.0098033203,
0.0280494578,
-0.0498105772,
-0.0162077434,
-0.0591587126,
0.0241399445,
-0.0083193779,
-0.0112704197,
0.0578351319,
-0.0241360664,
-0.0476403646,
0.0104202414,
-0.0105981315,
-0.0069815051,
-0.0009851159,
0.0290717259,
0.0228409935,
0.0345147364,
-0.0046944837,
0.0434455723,
0.0424238555,
0.0324538723,
0.0000386635,
0.0820857733,
0.0373128392,
-0.0045806575,
-0.0563022643,
0.005159833,
-0.0986497402,
-0.0596569441,
0.0771464184,
0.0828503445,
0.0731831118,
0.0205001775,
-0.0076481327,
-0.0393542163,
0.025101779,
-0.0030687423,
0.0243993346,
-0.0033972031,
-0.0498383641,
0.0043781474,
0.0539017096,
0.0262345988,
-0.0378266126,
0.0568813719,
0.0099874698,
0.0738319904,
0.0136057772,
0.0101005891,
-0.0444133542,
0.0292295851,
-0.0321263671,
-0.0071146642,
-0.0046591982,
-0.0033040787,
-0.0654726177,
-0.0424827524,
-0.0287890527,
0.0402715467,
-0.0163171049,
-0.0555031188,
0.0373253301,
0.0147543782,
0.02286404,
-0.0111442311,
-0.0267365109,
0.0010712157,
0.0290005673,
0.0015749568,
-0.0244336482,
-5.430683616e-33,
-0.0282878261,
-0.0246048719,
0.0721516982,
-0.003874525,
0.0183228943,
-0.0082680965,
-0.0327811502,
0.0336203761,
-0.0181837641,
0.0150872087,
-0.038446296,
0.0170416813,
0.0145493625,
-0.0112247216,
0.0529661812,
-0.0045192027,
0.0151340319,
-0.0187470317,
-0.057044331,
-0.0163874999,
0.0382906757,
-0.0028806331,
-0.0109549044,
-0.0086565083,
-0.0115539413,
-0.0043581547,
-0.0046285377,
0.0378632396,
0.0121263796,
0.0309225917,
-0.0034803296,
-0.0127285616,
0.0165406466,
-0.0061289165,
-0.0114095332,
0.0033519741,
-0.036270868,
-0.0730185956,
-0.0355343632,
-0.0001113048,
-0.0453950204,
-0.0085811373,
-0.0215400569,
0.0034710106,
-0.0266198087,
0.0441882089,
-0.0103192981,
0.0019775685,
0.0022944121,
0.0448896661,
-0.0601698086,
-0.0114223696,
0.0102645075,
-0.0802831352,
0.0333264768,
0.0359375626,
-0.0051126829,
-0.0546205044,
-0.0374975912,
0.0170637779,
-0.0098473867,
0.0030747768,
0.0614392795,
0.0187944956,
0.0247010849,
0.033456102,
0.0531327203,
0.0400273129,
-0.0363953896,
0.0062511042,
-0.0051197815,
0.0302267447,
0.0152527168,
0.0283947922,
0.0082029533,
0.030997673,
-0.0497747473,
0.0035185001,
0.0299037378,
0.0795682818,
0.0063286917,
0.0236491002,
-0.0424477197,
-0.0041446364,
-0.0285891779,
0.0111759976,
-0.0182631984,
-0.0276129413,
0.0376774296,
0.0389409401,
-0.0098092509,
-0.0653548688,
0.0410485081,
-0.0156773943,
-0.019264888,
-0.0220940318,
-0.0421582721,
0.0337976366,
-0.0134380776,
0.0381861925,
-0.0605676174,
-0.0399767943,
-0.005190419,
0.0313115865,
0.0309752785,
0.033296559,
-0.0021084857,
0.0874907747,
-0.0318476297,
-0.0287386682,
-0.0843594521,
-0.0209006295,
0.0168613866,
-0.0184349455,
0.0222350247,
-0.0025532993,
-0.0033986727,
0.0479738563,
-0.0092330752,
-0.086179629,
0.0129970377,
0.0218813121,
-0.0201683026,
0.0122348024,
-0.0395551845,
-0.0190673284,
-0.0729171857,
0.0613504723,
0.0194951072,
-0.0406486206,
0.0177334286,
0.0273074973,
2.809e-7,
-0.0468136035,
0.0324541256,
0.0028321987,
0.0246456768,
0.0110740392,
0.0886720866,
-0.0305598695,
0.0302979071,
-0.0235712603,
-0.0200191904,
0.0115981605,
0.047014799,
-0.0037186376,
-0.0051297941,
-0.0618615784,
-0.0260223616,
0.0335718878,
-0.0309052169,
-0.0416132696,
-0.0061747087,
0.064250052,
0.0582138747,
0.0245307833,
-0.0181372873,
0.0104736518,
-0.0439372323,
0.0470283702,
0.021779215,
-0.0199560411,
-0.0268301498,
-0.0251310859,
0.0464129671,
-0.0332566127,
0.0142826512,
0.0206849799,
-0.0027750588,
-0.0660532936,
0.0527950041,
-0.0172451977,
0.0093876068,
0.0038446866,
-0.0095101101,
-0.0049476344,
0.0273669269,
0.0726407692,
-0.0213632826,
-0.0103251273,
-0.0022406937,
0.0185016952,
0.012321258,
-0.0695191249,
-0.0037579557,
-0.0198345538,
-0.0144212665,
-0.0218183901,
0.0117581077,
-0.0196816884,
-0.0452460833,
0.0035657613,
-0.0452926308,
-0.0103967674,
-0.0119127491,
-0.0364877507,
0.0007917708,
0.0263340268,
-0.0537565015,
-0.0118537974,
2.324912931e-34,
-0.0206260215,
-0.0126526533,
0.0161275677,
0.049484577,
0.0179851316,
0.0346559696,
-0.0141266556,
0.0187890958,
0.0812141076,
-0.0188302509,
-0.0519087538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08715v1 | Toward Joint Language Modeling for Speech Units and Text | 2023-10-12T20:53:39 | 2023-10-12T20:53:39 | Ju-Chieh Chou, Chung-Ming Chien, Wei-Ning Hsu, Karen Livescu, Arun Babu, Alexis Conneau, Alexei Baevski, Michael Auli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech and text are two major forms of human language. The research community
has been focusing on mapping speech to text or vice versa for many years.
However, in the field of language modeling, very little effort has been made to
model them jointly. In light of this, we explore joint language modeling for
speech units and text. Specifically, we compare different speech tokenizers to
transform continuous speech signals into discrete units and use different
methods to construct mixed speech-text data. We introduce automatic metrics to
evaluate how well the joint LM mixes speech and text. We also fine-tune the LM
on downstream spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks with different
modalities (speech or text) and test its performance to assess the model's
learning of shared representations. Our results show that by mixing speech
units and text with our proposed mixing techniques, the joint LM improves over
a speech-only baseline on SLU tasks and shows zero-shot cross-modal
transferability. | [
-0.022331344,
0.0445574597,
0.0011673666,
0.0509620644,
-0.0292778909,
0.0308761913,
0.0444487706,
0.0027608089,
-0.04058218,
-0.0707164407,
-0.048699338,
-0.06822934,
0.0337639228,
0.048505988,
0.0108306399,
-0.0438102335,
0.0513323098,
-0.065507561,
-0.018243935,
0.0309268553,
0.0094671817,
0.0288947169,
-0.0321528986,
0.0261361841,
-0.0241931863,
-0.0124264602,
-0.0016974552,
-0.0061491514,
0.0059387526,
-0.0090990337,
-0.0366804227,
0.0101662334,
0.0597493723,
0.0369507074,
0.0000017258,
-0.02502211,
-0.013746663,
-0.004288543,
-0.0259937942,
-0.0084055392,
0.0776015073,
-0.0501770303,
0.0083489763,
0.0358210355,
-0.0336799882,
-0.0163330864,
0.0225446038,
0.0625648797,
0.0471173786,
0.0573462583,
-0.0243005753,
-0.0014060345,
0.0364826284,
-0.0115235932,
-0.0053516133,
-0.0101283509,
-0.0036064833,
0.025104776,
-0.0112612713,
0.019021228,
-0.0268053338,
0.0532482117,
-0.0100730248,
0.0000481578,
0.0022996743,
0.0386119224,
-0.0100123584,
-0.0308955275,
-0.0166461747,
0.0802159533,
-0.0374256447,
-0.0044099977,
0.0299761295,
-0.0024909086,
-0.0392631665,
-0.0026400492,
-0.0419316925,
-0.0219658762,
0.0200751089,
0.0488777496,
-0.0117603056,
-0.0249324683,
0.0438620076,
-0.0020160018,
-0.0528808236,
0.055825267,
0.014549477,
0.0043263854,
-0.0141133834,
-0.0460044146,
-0.0186285954,
-0.0517942198,
0.0218875054,
0.0375985913,
-0.0297195837,
0.0160416029,
-0.0669573396,
-0.0380703546,
-0.0091686808,
-0.0333072692,
0.0095020542,
0.0606713407,
-0.063895829,
0.056072969,
-0.0417262763,
0.0356580876,
0.0243207011,
0.0469300561,
-0.0444198325,
-0.0234211888,
-0.0666557848,
-0.0169326309,
-0.0212781187,
0.035049051,
-0.0466726795,
-0.046537146,
-0.0015321965,
0.0188501328,
0.0003332403,
-0.020494774,
0.0355141684,
-0.0167343263,
-0.0294780694,
-0.033173658,
0.0076293047,
0.0476174876,
-0.0019289858,
0.0880882964,
0.0041262479,
-0.0437437408,
-0.0277340859,
0.0332512446,
0.0022393118,
-0.0174803473,
-0.022873627,
0.0858024731,
-0.0506171472,
-0.0120644849,
-0.0134763345,
-0.0269139968,
-0.0228330269,
-0.031903401,
-0.0038879567,
-0.0697800964,
0.043223761,
0.0040599527,
0.0177108385,
-0.0121056149,
0.0069180429,
-0.0125825722,
-0.0418026447,
0.1237821504,
-0.0096390527,
0.0083207395,
0.0314228348,
0.0022225494,
-0.0024192296,
0.0769132227,
0.0576567948,
-0.0100993905,
0.0002829233,
-0.0054468657,
-0.044588469,
0.0529834665,
0.0109155439,
0.0257997047,
-0.0563222654,
-0.0200331844,
0.0391964801,
0.0229614582,
0.0497887991,
0.0628878698,
-0.0373504683,
0.0015580272,
0.0096259983,
0.0712744743,
0.0486174636,
0.0190646742,
0.0519589633,
0.0248979572,
-0.022645181,
0.0179997273,
-0.0153243188,
0.000256128,
0.0119514624,
-0.0125464424,
0.0586503595,
0.0439025201,
-0.0394327156,
-0.0176429581,
-0.0171576273,
-0.0415838026,
0.0189285465,
-0.0254556574,
0.0542854257,
0.0372562967,
-0.0365828127,
0.0578766502,
0.0293041337,
-0.0352665931,
0.0578336269,
-0.0187889487,
0.0108467238,
0.062859863,
0.0037273976,
-0.0165581536,
0.0106910374,
-0.0253329817,
-0.0032443921,
0.0240363255,
-0.0021353597,
0.0176924542,
0.0779558271,
-0.0630758256,
-0.0028351669,
0.0121931657,
0.0111539904,
0.0205936227,
-0.0757930726,
0.0232614297,
0.0235066619,
-0.0704827905,
0.0294909384,
0.0435726978,
-0.0170033798,
-0.0015793452,
0.0458211601,
-0.0091131376,
0.021474706,
0.029119892,
-0.005949337,
0.0255315416,
0.0108944625,
-0.045217894,
-0.0344548933,
0.0391218066,
-0.0529966094,
-0.0674263164,
0.0426172093,
-0.0019841823,
0.0046005398,
0.0190910231,
-0.033232037,
-0.0800844282,
0.0449535325,
-0.0027048979,
0.0453402512,
-0.050131876,
0.0137579814,
0.0378213786,
0.0286443811,
0.0036142245,
0.0026374178,
0.0121036675,
-0.0012877433,
0.0185464881,
-0.0018665625,
0.0353963003,
-0.0084346635,
-0.0133352373,
-0.0088338405,
-0.0322322473,
0.0108514167,
-0.0441998094,
-0.0225598235,
-0.0289827008,
-0.0150760878,
-0.1458023041,
-0.0183305293,
-0.0142998593,
0.0171200931,
0.0110599315,
0.0265171193,
0.0183976833,
-0.0321196765,
-0.0302131586,
-0.0258710198,
0.0198149402,
-0.0043123779,
0.0030510668,
0.0176152531,
-0.0069862884,
-0.0292007625,
0.0067348368,
-0.0193274897,
0.0514199026,
-0.0258011315,
-0.0252325889,
-0.0488170348,
0.035320498,
-0.0027401214,
0.0263185631,
-0.0072886716,
-0.0178975016,
0.002749152,
-0.0252400152,
0.0566005297,
0.0255686305,
0.0315556936,
0.011672725,
0.0380984806,
-0.0541735664,
-0.0546645522,
0.0090460712,
0.0145594366,
0.0432625152,
-0.0226594452,
0.0010332819,
0.0096479459,
0.0691516027,
0.0157146696,
0.0108561032,
-0.0383500718,
-0.0374216549,
-0.0371951349,
-0.028219834,
-0.045918107,
0.008641934,
-0.0456819423,
0.0084238797,
-0.0109665254,
-0.0109079974,
0.0485765971,
-0.1043109074,
-0.0177403633,
-0.0257478766,
-0.0323396958,
-0.0665988252,
0.0281080175,
-0.030010704,
-0.0091596469,
-0.0559297465,
-0.035526026,
-0.0371748991,
0.0429108813,
0.000651436,
-0.0266357828,
0.0490474179,
-0.0343666561,
0.0170085169,
-0.0207857639,
-0.0050826757,
-0.0247765854,
-0.0474962704,
-0.0503843278,
0.0362532064,
-0.0038925267,
-0.0015352258,
-0.0450853631,
0.0440452844,
0.0101630781,
0.0230212621,
-0.0082757175,
0.0215415396,
-0.0326931998,
0.0612164326,
0.0346325822,
0.0320395902,
-0.0554294698,
-0.0220767297,
0.0521791726,
-0.0047326065,
0.0803035125,
0.0308256391,
-0.0381877907,
0.019110268,
0.0054622646,
0.0215773508,
-0.0421213098,
0.0112906573,
0.0363651924,
-0.0430047065,
-0.0080765095,
0.1281652749,
0.0124558462,
-0.023894893,
-0.030974336,
-0.0284689832,
0.0064928108,
0.0128988568,
-8.695e-7,
-0.0677941442,
-0.0664729998,
0.0279173069,
-0.0025009317,
0.0456359945,
-0.0006187703,
-0.0342472754,
-0.0673242584,
-0.0088158837,
0.0256925095,
-0.0599148497,
-0.019845454,
-0.047740832,
0.0118477773,
-0.0021426789,
0.0479577668,
-0.0219431389,
-0.0139275203,
-0.0226453934,
0.0415404402,
-0.0475778803,
-0.050004933,
0.0060756183,
-0.0176389702,
0.0955951214,
0.0363865383,
0.0390670598,
-0.001189201,
-0.0333506241,
0.079389587,
0.0077869641,
-0.0044275047,
-0.0060247919,
0.029612612,
-0.0339319184,
-0.0069264043,
0.0480161607,
0.0331960842,
-0.0235957056,
-0.0399864912,
-0.0014645568,
0.0590736456,
-0.02092834,
0.0182019658,
0.0002185496,
0.0197117813,
0.02195956,
0.0715229213,
0.0314969942,
-0.0533118807,
-0.0113170557,
-0.006701258,
0.0052894731,
0.0016283595,
-0.0279633719,
-0.0059016333,
-0.0129857827,
0.0368968733,
-0.0276603252,
-0.0024362276,
0.0344932266,
0.0249095447,
0.0240212847,
0.0321965516,
0.007495088,
-0.0171828661,
-0.0318784155,
0.0236007255,
-0.0216921475,
0.0513052307,
-0.058313489,
0.0000112918,
0.0066744629,
-0.0467514545,
-0.0242809467,
0.0082413647,
-0.1157390773,
-0.0549895316,
0.0104135582,
-0.0232248344,
0.0224679746,
0.0433566496,
-0.0375191942,
-0.0505827889,
0.0482037626,
0.0305706989,
-0.0785029903,
0.0224806853,
0.0111087011,
0.0337570757,
-0.016933633,
0.0147491386,
-0.0496632345,
0.0092379069,
-0.0160111524,
0.0223192181,
-0.0369707085,
-0.0000155191,
-0.0201300327,
-0.0141902389,
0.0685770735,
0.0161632262,
0.0125935683,
-0.0408962071,
0.0321320035,
-0.0127362916,
0.0303113833,
-0.0576045401,
-0.0199557263,
0.0336393192,
-0.0094172359,
-0.007075611,
0.0072744521,
-0.0305159334,
0.0510878451,
0.0169615708,
0.0116009265,
0.0080740396,
0.0264108889,
-0.0031834096,
-0.0119073242,
-0.0008095031,
0.0202668291,
-0.0159089826,
0.0107855601,
-0.0224598963,
0.0350960642,
-0.0122969663,
0.0054747122,
-0.0063274796,
0.0094222687,
-0.0574443787,
-0.0574393682,
-0.0230832882,
0.004567211,
-0.0181375928,
-0.0026552526,
0.0667739734,
0.0068942881,
0.0212796461,
-0.0283035208,
0.0369127318,
-0.0267649926,
0.0071093636,
0.0505293198,
0.008644064,
-0.0227233395,
0.014762545,
0.0823230222,
0.0333396755,
0.0185961034,
-0.0303311031,
0.0328084454,
-0.0246011335,
0.0048597213,
0.0424336605,
0.0295480676,
-0.030004574,
0.0060100988,
-0.0313828252,
-0.0593436509,
0.0336410813,
-0.0127056539,
0.0044285967,
-0.0070852605,
0.0081905238,
0.007783548,
-0.0215713549,
0.0595511496,
-0.0107307509,
-0.0018606733,
0.0385170504,
-0.0052406332,
-0.0135555528,
-6.478462343e-33,
-0.0644612983,
-0.0249713641,
0.0016836224,
0.0010398969,
-0.0219433866,
0.0081315478,
-0.0118033495,
0.0179994367,
0.0128975203,
-0.0138684511,
0.0029624503,
0.0441123135,
0.0258347094,
0.0394679084,
-0.0085255699,
0.003347798,
0.06729763,
-0.04492018,
-0.0069841901,
-0.0251804516,
0.0441767722,
0.0526546501,
0.0257225186,
-0.0580974706,
0.0083033396,
0.0348325893,
-0.0149583276,
0.0272238515,
0.0281653386,
0.0448167771,
-0.033504501,
0.0147321625,
0.0265660174,
-0.0064346939,
-0.0611713603,
0.0932184085,
-0.0849640742,
-0.0059958813,
0.049551405,
0.0150115024,
-0.0434191748,
0.0085538495,
0.0165942982,
-0.0038236033,
0.0365934819,
-0.0379099846,
0.0246200953,
-0.0277587734,
-0.0167653542,
-0.022562284,
-0.0335328281,
0.0299856141,
-0.0307575446,
-0.0186190866,
0.0790614337,
0.0467936061,
-0.0177351106,
0.0093293702,
-0.0673446953,
0.0134127662,
-0.0401522815,
0.0461230688,
0.0765279457,
0.0217977632,
-0.0309762266,
0.0712358654,
0.0243583899,
-0.0464036055,
-0.0400214158,
-0.0283280965,
0.0706056431,
0.046128694,
-0.0004695605,
0.0233094189,
0.026029719,
-0.0277995281,
-0.0255438648,
0.0200604443,
0.0150889708,
0.0026249334,
0.012854198,
0.0588086024,
0.0141585674,
-0.0045234221,
-0.0730451271,
-0.0162652098,
-0.0621022768,
-0.0155926161,
0.0393031575,
0.0152272796,
-0.010376933,
-0.0515769646,
0.0691068619,
-0.0265400223,
-0.0147787258,
-0.0203688052,
-0.0023691331,
0.0073578102,
-0.0124259489,
0.0582220703,
-0.055723682,
-0.0713026077,
0.081145376,
0.0182442684,
0.0185920931,
-0.0533763021,
0.0176110137,
0.0070867692,
-0.0699615031,
-0.0166871343,
-0.0204933491,
0.0001406398,
-0.0199220777,
0.0351706222,
0.0497541353,
0.0094132489,
-0.0239950344,
0.0130242845,
-0.0381575525,
-0.0201913975,
-0.0356943496,
-0.0010841039,
-0.0221335981,
0.0308154635,
-0.0458093248,
-0.0143503128,
0.0123738293,
-0.038409248,
0.0536419228,
-0.020228168,
-0.0128498049,
0.0545196943,
2.54e-7,
0.0184583031,
0.013405934,
0.0171439648,
-0.0280695166,
0.0361312553,
0.0372243114,
-0.0471118465,
0.0233387928,
0.0228868481,
-0.0169371143,
0.0011143283,
0.0015913165,
0.0676773041,
0.0185232181,
-0.0534285903,
-0.0131255509,
-0.036798846,
0.0026926026,
-0.0378683396,
-0.0324111953,
0.0412919298,
0.0777928382,
-0.0156751927,
0.0111801215,
-0.0039937501,
-0.0257147476,
0.0879842937,
-0.0366939902,
-0.0116722314,
-0.0135192182,
-0.0060906294,
0.0055113449,
-0.003312075,
0.0165690854,
-0.0215642601,
0.0417621732,
0.0621147119,
0.052575361,
0.0030941772,
-0.0706993043,
-0.024380317,
0.0225875713,
-0.0203372724,
-0.0318320245,
0.0696778968,
-0.0503412299,
-0.0120140035,
-0.0379158556,
-0.0253022462,
0.025408376,
0.004098603,
0.0315544084,
-0.0367616862,
0.0504339114,
0.0449692309,
0.0104868682,
-0.0116817672,
-0.0750106126,
-0.0322842263,
-0.0054811821,
-0.0975718945,
-0.0045533236,
-0.0580458231,
-0.000043456,
0.0443544127,
-0.05342241,
-0.0113608176,
1.984505608e-34,
0.0300668366,
-0.0161013547,
0.0129163601,
0.023567779,
-0.0063470299,
-0.03597036,
0.0020635684,
0.0426914543,
0.0195763577,
-0.0836450234,
-0.0029951355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08678v1 | Can GPT models be Financial Analysts? An Evaluation of ChatGPT and GPT-4 on mock CFA Exams | 2023-10-12T19:28:57 | 2023-10-12T19:28:57 | Ethan Callanan, Amarachi Mbakwe, Antony Papadimitriou, Yulong Pei, Mathieu Sibue, Xiaodan Zhu, Zhiqiang Ma, Xiaomo Liu, Sameena Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-fin.GN | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on a
wide range of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, often matching or even
beating state-of-the-art task-specific models. This study aims at assessing the
financial reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We leverage mock exam questions of
the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Program to conduct a comprehensive
evaluation of ChatGPT and GPT-4 in financial analysis, considering Zero-Shot
(ZS), Chain-of-Thought (CoT), and Few-Shot (FS) scenarios. We present an
in-depth analysis of the models' performance and limitations, and estimate
whether they would have a chance at passing the CFA exams. Finally, we outline
insights into potential strategies and improvements to enhance the
applicability of LLMs in finance. In this perspective, we hope this work paves
the way for future studies to continue enhancing LLMs for financial reasoning
through rigorous evaluation. | [
0.0111142313,
0.0728474781,
-0.0132777123,
0.0189898629,
-0.0511461385,
0.0149998115,
0.0297414716,
0.0296522174,
0.0138859348,
-0.0428244136,
-0.0013885074,
-0.0585621595,
-0.0182010699,
0.0455280803,
0.0426170602,
-0.0250345785,
0.0197363496,
-0.0396566503,
0.0356649309,
-0.0023589181,
0.0197688695,
-0.0041415375,
-0.0051029949,
0.0203399919,
0.0077707591,
-0.0356429964,
-0.0202315133,
-0.0382183492,
-0.0021931357,
-0.0166513659,
-0.0226212852,
0.0493180417,
0.0173607469,
0.0676063374,
0.0000020922,
-0.0558259301,
-0.0365702435,
0.0249643493,
-0.0357020535,
0.026732089,
0.0282804985,
0.0181689244,
0.0346547328,
0.0268226229,
-0.0554602146,
0.0265054163,
0.0483102687,
0.0722663403,
0.0481078066,
0.0723068938,
-0.0074835094,
-0.0966179892,
0.0245348103,
-0.0600136481,
0.0036327422,
-0.0970442221,
0.0121912388,
0.0376275927,
0.0114009185,
0.0031223584,
-0.0246384367,
0.0338342413,
0.0106444759,
0.0157667864,
0.0228640977,
0.0179997329,
-0.0706227943,
0.0220027305,
-0.0342392139,
0.0198251251,
0.0164320208,
0.0555926971,
0.0045244354,
-0.0315976068,
-0.0031666092,
0.0128203398,
-0.0448799916,
0.0271238908,
-0.0269934386,
0.0044388049,
0.0254947785,
0.0005870764,
0.0102995299,
0.0040323185,
-0.0326932818,
0.0245399009,
-0.0282143131,
-0.0522795357,
0.0699336231,
0.0354142003,
-0.0441180617,
-0.0340908021,
-0.0010085244,
0.026690349,
0.0387345664,
0.0203441475,
0.0289944187,
0.0203276295,
-0.0072513176,
-0.0585432276,
0.0071961754,
0.0570252165,
0.0150215244,
0.0419511013,
-0.0492250286,
0.0690479502,
-0.0121923881,
-0.0314696953,
-0.0060287649,
0.0317352451,
-0.1085955426,
-0.0359974988,
-0.0406015255,
0.0995589793,
-0.0297857448,
-0.024084853,
-0.0597249493,
-0.0345314257,
-0.0235906653,
0.0016731978,
0.0089229224,
-0.008069979,
0.0018626982,
-0.0143943215,
-0.0810212418,
0.0233990978,
-0.0189741272,
0.0036293867,
-0.0105024353,
-0.0263968688,
0.0149781937,
-0.0078951018,
-0.0491447225,
-0.020876307,
0.015541696,
0.0791884065,
0.0210199915,
-0.0199382436,
-0.0500976555,
-0.0531771518,
-0.019881418,
-0.0669832379,
-0.0000528967,
-0.0327657722,
-0.0087173088,
-0.0122132991,
-0.0059750527,
0.0239087753,
0.0108648874,
0.0051786536,
-0.0218875036,
0.0874340311,
0.0420590937,
-0.0254615825,
-0.0020688518,
-0.0189713314,
-0.0041917013,
0.0716673732,
0.0003945467,
0.0113000255,
0.006220873,
-0.0177041236,
0.0033936584,
0.0419102013,
-0.0285569821,
-0.0580125973,
-0.0085591851,
0.035173256,
-0.0125402035,
-0.0002330414,
0.0148883378,
0.0409973897,
-0.0276422836,
0.0056497953,
0.0450911969,
0.0679773018,
0.0589268915,
0.0499334298,
0.0221873019,
0.0321331434,
0.0294263568,
0.0060373815,
0.0030038161,
0.0007180333,
-0.0498117805,
0.0331249386,
-0.0152193513,
0.0017922552,
-0.0159212146,
-0.0393840186,
-0.003912874,
0.0024717925,
-0.0344697163,
-0.0029294186,
0.0168011375,
-0.0762202963,
-0.0469252281,
0.0328333192,
0.0029283934,
-0.000725249,
-0.0252859034,
-0.0460548662,
0.0155619988,
0.0682783127,
0.0348089971,
-0.0004489006,
-0.0132014677,
-0.0288766138,
-0.0231887586,
0.051855728,
0.0615393035,
0.0178618655,
-0.0599216968,
-0.0390483066,
-0.0116167348,
0.0110079618,
0.0146316048,
0.0254079774,
-0.0024559826,
0.0013674968,
0.0150356684,
0.0105148936,
0.0186807457,
-0.0071200388,
0.0009520344,
-0.0531887934,
-0.0120870648,
-0.0346064381,
0.0117989983,
0.0350903459,
0.0020327182,
0.02349554,
-0.0300924797,
0.0103930933,
-0.0265875552,
-0.0086308084,
-0.0537099801,
0.010167825,
-0.0042577144,
-0.028161874,
-0.0263524093,
0.0038727347,
-0.043333903,
-0.014100912,
-0.025827948,
-0.0211192667,
0.0298174061,
-0.0552633852,
-0.01599144,
-0.0068231951,
0.0078405738,
0.0012767431,
0.0872951373,
0.0251094829,
0.0312996544,
-0.020671444,
0.0254468415,
0.0122297918,
-0.0468411967,
0.0337773375,
0.0071427333,
-0.0095133549,
0.0346944965,
0.0320779346,
0.0133993663,
-0.0252062902,
-0.0242045205,
-0.0689734146,
-0.008345766,
0.013167548,
0.0489664823,
-0.0030054271,
-0.0396342017,
-0.0242711399,
0.0113693774,
-0.0330483057,
-0.0068371617,
0.0064393352,
0.0031557232,
0.0415719301,
-0.0263244081,
-0.0201026127,
-0.0201778039,
-0.0055275713,
-0.0333929211,
0.0179637559,
0.0745254159,
-0.0377355255,
0.0035077208,
0.019532159,
-0.0134856356,
0.0061690318,
-0.0053063533,
0.0311305206,
0.023808293,
-0.0227440037,
0.0107148616,
0.0332386866,
0.0011404735,
0.0547243468,
-0.0450754613,
-0.0270175021,
-0.0217648707,
0.0302300677,
0.0065742573,
-0.0246501509,
-0.028273968,
0.0242362954,
-0.0074695912,
0.0619399324,
-0.0163832568,
-0.0031071021,
-0.0680498779,
0.067767933,
-0.0205573812,
0.0111930864,
-0.0443868674,
-0.0049502417,
0.006939848,
0.0470976755,
0.0261481497,
-0.0144420154,
0.0590142235,
-0.0135888187,
-0.0213020183,
-0.0412490219,
0.0054721115,
-0.0665104389,
0.0662346408,
-0.0178519376,
-0.0169452168,
0.0258237459,
-0.0317963734,
-0.0407292396,
-0.0476532541,
0.0117555698,
-0.0178933106,
0.0480976999,
-0.0457668863,
0.0198118463,
-0.0070908559,
-0.0034583714,
-0.0113247661,
-0.0606455617,
-0.0429483056,
0.0538083799,
0.0324220806,
-0.0256654713,
-0.0439180024,
0.0378270261,
0.0039342553,
-0.0406825803,
-0.0246655699,
-0.0392515585,
0.0078945626,
0.0360818319,
0.066971384,
-0.0159213841,
0.0397260562,
-0.0381270647,
0.0725809857,
0.0254520923,
0.0325257368,
0.021288434,
0.0025283012,
0.014954186,
-0.0162115227,
-0.0363145024,
-0.0268478561,
0.0311965887,
-0.0347121619,
-0.0623968318,
0.0049070562,
0.1296318173,
0.0197850596,
0.0163121782,
-0.0058806576,
0.0084695872,
0.0052071861,
-0.0209032651,
0.0475991368,
-0.111084491,
-0.033743754,
-0.0053921062,
-0.0057138726,
-0.0113834925,
-0.060417179,
-0.0327225775,
-0.162277028,
0.0709456056,
-0.0027920804,
0.0057355482,
0.0052344836,
-0.0154687753,
-0.0369036198,
-0.0474793129,
0.0032178292,
0.0227613561,
-0.0133924643,
0.0310226008,
0.0233215615,
-0.0779359564,
0.0131578771,
0.0525892153,
0.002586842,
-0.0367012545,
0.026729729,
0.0171005297,
-0.0340172276,
-0.0198512524,
-0.0311777629,
-0.0203182641,
0.0091299275,
0.0222411305,
0.0353716053,
-0.0108404011,
-0.015410834,
-0.0149341114,
0.0216249879,
-0.0241894685,
0.0356389321,
0.0282340851,
0.0435575806,
-0.0183700453,
-0.0408075303,
-0.0109021962,
0.028569743,
-0.0594342761,
0.073248595,
0.0071216146,
-0.0281885155,
-0.0562753826,
-0.0506524369,
-0.0177924037,
-0.0311631933,
-0.0148411077,
-0.0058096428,
0.0486638397,
0.0055555962,
-0.0502854027,
-0.0846721604,
0.0434647761,
0.0315061025,
-0.0259063188,
0.0279532801,
0.0449196696,
0.0229592025,
-0.007376974,
0.0325094163,
-0.0505719595,
0.0309999585,
-0.0276766215,
0.05477966,
0.0194662493,
-0.0163394194,
-0.0571875088,
0.0312092528,
-0.070379287,
-0.0369081832,
-0.0035857295,
0.0071671703,
0.0347904339,
-0.0328436159,
-0.0244963504,
0.0300916191,
0.0018870517,
0.0403207242,
-0.0427118503,
-0.0138771087,
0.0307273176,
0.0276759155,
0.0129855014,
0.0223726816,
-0.0083849672,
0.0212975796,
-0.0419994071,
0.0423952937,
-0.0183586441,
0.0146593265,
0.0126620382,
0.0368754826,
0.0327599756,
0.0338196307,
-0.0139646735,
0.0031689876,
-0.009755251,
-0.0170649458,
-0.0033069905,
-0.0197617598,
-0.0411710106,
0.067060262,
0.0058351303,
-0.0220379569,
-0.0404135883,
-0.0260849986,
-0.0227331184,
0.0075472579,
0.0129699018,
0.0130944364,
-0.0198424682,
0.0120521132,
-0.0574034676,
0.0014068377,
-0.0394912511,
0.0232334603,
0.0160283763,
-0.0081176851,
0.0819011852,
0.004450127,
0.0195946749,
0.0059248642,
-0.0294309985,
-0.0409555435,
-0.0679813027,
0.0069902423,
0.0541913882,
0.0059198998,
-0.0397339836,
-0.0361860096,
-0.067910552,
0.0339159146,
0.01518963,
-0.0005050601,
0.0168980733,
-0.0486584567,
0.0530250631,
0.0379007198,
-0.0391485244,
-0.052009698,
0.089486219,
0.0269123558,
0.0037222344,
-0.0408343561,
-0.0225714464,
-0.0341076963,
-0.0579160042,
0.0299924929,
0.0077778813,
0.0223592781,
0.0417063758,
-0.1220229045,
-0.0552832261,
0.0041074199,
-0.0173642617,
0.0081716329,
-0.0297797881,
0.0277034305,
0.0689085647,
-0.013156605,
0.0276811663,
0.0018672142,
0.0224167407,
-0.0267633144,
-0.0031061047,
-0.0580523945,
-6.069933975e-33,
-0.0115300659,
-0.0202373117,
0.068162106,
-0.0017530121,
0.0007665948,
0.0109070344,
-0.0193759557,
0.003129075,
0.0014749581,
-0.0023686641,
0.0065302933,
0.0319399685,
0.0131627712,
0.0069137355,
0.022765236,
-0.013392006,
0.0099826278,
-0.0292743985,
0.0178358592,
-0.0453348532,
-0.0121686095,
0.0427695774,
0.0567234866,
-0.0035992775,
0.0504565723,
-0.0077830604,
-0.0343717672,
-0.0107677532,
-0.0050089569,
0.0555814132,
-0.021916585,
0.0213270411,
0.0237008352,
-0.0934756994,
0.0067995223,
-0.0116943493,
0.0116111757,
-0.0429170132,
0.0382040963,
0.0109756514,
0.0294443779,
0.0013600464,
0.03635424,
-0.0085453866,
-0.0253908373,
-0.035539113,
0.0156748127,
-0.018589789,
0.0137425959,
0.0023816675,
-0.0718546286,
0.0400751047,
-0.0149155129,
0.0467584021,
0.0289861355,
0.0869362727,
-0.027852796,
0.0055043828,
0.0091626542,
0.0061735599,
0.0545873083,
0.0098449253,
0.0332882069,
-0.0094439005,
-0.0047629266,
0.0612318926,
-0.0078986073,
-0.0183655825,
-0.0374536477,
-0.008453032,
0.0010613899,
0.0630690157,
0.063272126,
0.0389876589,
0.0367757864,
-0.0037367155,
-0.0567841381,
-0.0006804909,
0.0043140538,
0.0554930456,
0.020065831,
0.020577129,
-0.0647800565,
-0.0469658487,
-0.01617622,
0.0022773815,
-0.0287111569,
-0.0144096995,
0.0358824804,
-0.0141312685,
0.0081951059,
0.0708616301,
0.0308408923,
-0.035363391,
-0.0472162701,
-0.0324119665,
0.0111987526,
0.0250191931,
-0.0010246496,
0.0428591855,
-0.055572819,
-0.003056776,
-0.0323749743,
0.0204841252,
0.0049367398,
-0.020469252,
0.0112365028,
0.0124218622,
-0.0357643664,
-0.0476336703,
-0.0502902418,
0.0110700019,
0.0134653347,
0.0135340346,
0.0264136698,
0.0375077948,
-0.0124606621,
0.0055353432,
-0.0124118822,
-0.018365413,
-0.0046910187,
0.0063622743,
-0.0201614238,
0.0216758549,
0.0343999863,
0.0031326378,
0.0213386007,
0.027513627,
0.0453689657,
-0.0408574864,
-0.0224903803,
0.0563391,
2.81e-7,
0.0576723181,
0.0564853139,
-0.001708294,
0.0015427693,
0.0237237178,
0.0500598177,
-0.0405677147,
-0.0164197348,
0.0159189012,
-0.0030656476,
0.0275714677,
0.0330303572,
0.0528412797,
0.0198605061,
-0.0589685366,
-0.0428053178,
-0.0501108393,
-0.008679064,
-0.0740094855,
0.0528028309,
0.0589854345,
0.0601360835,
0.0016777547,
-0.0254154354,
-0.0193750132,
-0.0798811689,
0.0662753731,
-0.0302659087,
-0.0252202936,
-0.0047143665,
0.0095530637,
0.011918324,
-0.0049270792,
0.0517754033,
0.0354534537,
0.0177151337,
0.0460100137,
0.0492785722,
0.0202191118,
0.0214771554,
-0.0078726867,
-0.0203229301,
-0.0121669201,
-0.0788331404,
0.068108283,
-0.1012838185,
-0.0516650975,
-0.018899614,
-0.0552979261,
-0.0007125166,
0.0353085659,
0.0396378897,
-0.0108407997,
0.0076148268,
-0.0094860718,
-0.0384290852,
0.0219276883,
-0.0222677924,
-0.0053897244,
0.0438099094,
-0.0437741354,
0.014004617,
-0.0473530665,
0.0093688527,
0.0458848737,
-0.0592304431,
-0.0068479227,
2.428924666e-34,
0.0720888004,
-0.0263526775,
-0.0008579937,
0.0159197338,
0.0906588659,
0.0390657894,
-0.0147114554,
0.0433951914,
-0.0049739848,
-0.0831325054,
-0.0219116937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08659v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08659v4 | LoftQ: LoRA-Fine-Tuning-Aware Quantization for Large Language Models | 2023-10-12T18:34:08 | 2023-11-28T16:06:59 | Yixiao Li, Yifan Yu, Chen Liang, Pengcheng He, Nikos Karampatziakis, Weizhu Chen, Tuo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Quantization is an indispensable technique for serving Large Language Models
(LLMs) and has recently found its way into LoRA fine-tuning. In this work we
focus on the scenario where quantization and LoRA fine-tuning are applied
together on a pre-trained model. In such cases it is common to observe a
consistent gap in the performance on downstream tasks between full fine-tuning
and quantization plus LoRA fine-tuning approach. In response, we propose LoftQ
(LoRA-Fine-Tuning-aware Quantization), a novel quantization framework that
simultaneously quantizes an LLM and finds a proper low-rank initialization for
LoRA fine-tuning. Such an initialization alleviates the discrepancy between the
quantized and full-precision model and significantly improves generalization in
downstream tasks. We evaluate our method on natural language understanding,
question answering, summarization, and natural language generation tasks.
Experiments show that our method is highly effective and outperforms existing
quantization methods, especially in the challenging 2-bit and 2/4-bit mixed
precision regimes. The code is available on https://github.com/yxli2123/LoftQ. | [
0.0118719414,
0.0726001784,
0.014900743,
0.0385307856,
0.0232155789,
0.0295030847,
-0.0225893874,
-0.0089432867,
-0.035718482,
-0.0640010089,
-0.0100951521,
-0.0410173535,
-0.0114575531,
0.0411872938,
0.0387676358,
-0.0245569088,
0.059900146,
-0.0414743312,
-0.0003414974,
-0.0185314696,
0.0107243303,
0.0199027881,
0.0221383758,
0.0175941903,
0.0526492149,
-0.0203583855,
-0.0237698872,
0.022324685,
0.0295771006,
-0.0004571571,
0.0238136463,
0.0536902547,
0.0423088558,
0.0226867143,
0.0000020569,
-0.027917996,
-0.0417046994,
-0.0150783965,
-0.018375,
0.0146402139,
-0.002910859,
-0.0237926338,
-0.0131842876,
0.0172626283,
-0.0444169976,
0.006542841,
0.0322790667,
-0.0092473356,
0.0840965211,
0.0647718683,
0.0033187908,
-0.0350437686,
0.0433792472,
-0.0339740366,
-0.0229369961,
-0.0396270864,
-0.0266140904,
0.0554938018,
-0.0120691955,
0.0009508329,
-0.0131822582,
0.007507409,
0.0173469968,
0.0160319787,
-0.0143627329,
0.0112363771,
-0.0749628544,
-0.006694987,
-0.0243056025,
0.0692449287,
-0.0679514855,
-0.0098416312,
0.0312514342,
0.0088342112,
-0.0264432412,
-0.110393405,
-0.036625132,
0.041468408,
0.0092732804,
0.0265863854,
-0.0005482922,
-0.0529196262,
0.0144463284,
0.0227739885,
-0.0443755426,
0.0591435954,
0.0315176658,
0.0120783225,
-0.0279284567,
-0.0341103077,
-0.0997750983,
-0.0733418614,
-0.0218858514,
0.0550875701,
-0.0390001647,
-0.0279592462,
-0.0710320622,
0.0138979927,
0.0227299612,
0.0165990144,
0.0338212252,
0.0660343245,
-0.0008621142,
0.0212614685,
-0.0285236947,
0.0511059798,
0.0047672261,
0.037321005,
-0.0360474922,
0.0159563851,
-0.0044557252,
-0.013005293,
-0.0446313396,
0.0366006754,
-0.0553813539,
-0.0262137484,
-0.0553708784,
0.0085769836,
0.0113747567,
0.0094753653,
0.0079736412,
0.009227789,
-0.0286965203,
0.0018098084,
0.0197106414,
0.026192937,
-0.0466203131,
0.0161297135,
0.0191083085,
-0.0602266006,
-0.0219243579,
0.0171425603,
0.01772785,
-0.0226738844,
0.0214576684,
0.019891182,
-0.0141592044,
-0.0366641656,
-0.0123645933,
-0.028360175,
-0.0051666116,
-0.0951681435,
-0.0346810147,
-0.0592330284,
-0.0247048493,
-0.0033740168,
0.0113201141,
0.0003681798,
0.0128213353,
0.0171224419,
0.0061359294,
0.0528431907,
-0.0463793091,
-0.0144001842,
0.0069913873,
0.0197433587,
0.0570042878,
0.0792197362,
0.0451301485,
0.0473886579,
-0.0151191223,
0.0135446442,
-0.0445789769,
0.0368790217,
0.0264282674,
-0.0157555118,
-0.0224877726,
0.0113162743,
-0.042637229,
0.0312515609,
0.0873047709,
0.0566889122,
-0.0571454018,
0.0204821341,
0.0135760382,
0.0162991211,
0.0560999475,
0.0159865338,
0.0342661105,
0.0074638934,
0.0061669555,
0.0101807406,
-0.0404353403,
0.0486296564,
-0.0065887207,
0.0400213897,
0.0603152514,
0.0621427335,
-0.0294161811,
-0.0510505177,
-0.0179745369,
0.012044264,
-0.0278300885,
0.0181753188,
-0.003395831,
0.0477425084,
-0.0323874094,
0.1040723473,
0.0235638842,
-0.0449682996,
0.0173956342,
-0.074282594,
0.0057128491,
0.0642822161,
0.0203858931,
-0.0204404481,
-0.035356991,
-0.012424171,
0.0009304521,
0.0259058867,
-0.0023533269,
-0.0041879867,
-0.0081145819,
-0.0626920089,
-0.0378070436,
-0.0483497158,
0.0081144366,
-0.0129146175,
0.0196262356,
0.0079525756,
0.0141312722,
-0.0279978197,
-0.006577454,
0.0213760491,
0.0135399643,
-0.0448836684,
0.0014037867,
-0.0015904328,
0.0108420318,
0.0139347343,
-0.0067863306,
0.0087517668,
0.0242167953,
-0.034539815,
0.0152401291,
-0.0571638048,
0.0080488632,
-0.0510317907,
0.059777081,
0.004113588,
0.0121942759,
0.0645816997,
-0.0794400424,
-0.042516131,
0.0160591584,
-0.0247955304,
-0.0067408639,
-0.0455642901,
0.0079519963,
0.0268127844,
0.0465942286,
-0.0615752712,
0.0344233252,
-0.0176561493,
0.0126201091,
0.0177203771,
0.012116964,
0.0045662681,
-0.0697590411,
-0.0389002971,
-0.0055241999,
0.0009973788,
0.0374585837,
0.0175668225,
0.0332295075,
-0.032443814,
-0.0244251471,
-0.0963028669,
0.0252299067,
-0.0577347986,
0.0432146825,
0.0405958407,
0.0380494036,
0.0037704546,
-0.0234217178,
-0.0601612255,
-0.0080195889,
0.019598376,
0.0107469652,
0.0173022188,
0.012434232,
-0.0226789061,
-0.0533212833,
-0.0191577692,
0.0018167415,
0.021032583,
-0.0349129736,
0.0011297044,
-0.0716356933,
0.0210204944,
-0.0494352654,
0.0122129638,
-0.0092634996,
-0.0235184357,
0.0032934083,
-0.0102323964,
0.023451969,
0.0489065982,
0.0121531459,
0.0049464018,
0.0644772649,
0.017613139,
-0.0298772175,
0.0298551563,
0.0034777452,
-0.0576434322,
-0.0139991725,
-0.0025113351,
-0.0016858547,
0.0578286797,
-0.0120168664,
0.0052024731,
-0.0266818665,
0.056229949,
-0.0299053323,
-0.0070300219,
-0.0424974486,
0.0104837446,
0.0052966392,
0.0536666624,
-0.0254544541,
-0.0292138141,
0.0448930375,
-0.0313204564,
-0.0044139,
-0.0145868193,
-0.0115630645,
-0.0640681982,
0.0306403451,
0.0083560096,
0.0486744829,
-0.047184784,
-0.0295430142,
-0.0665969551,
-0.0414372981,
-0.0065569947,
-0.0226516072,
0.0428083688,
-0.0330948532,
0.0324124247,
-0.0595484078,
-0.0396461226,
0.0045798621,
-0.0202301759,
-0.032289654,
0.0472653992,
0.0116356798,
-0.0161642097,
0.062567845,
0.0476770028,
-0.0209187176,
0.0344139412,
-0.0400698744,
0.0009628214,
-0.0485075749,
0.0654246807,
0.1046349555,
0.0215353854,
0.0404620729,
-0.0149087459,
-0.0098789865,
0.0234201737,
0.0182091426,
0.0390427262,
-0.0411415771,
0.0418709219,
0.0300815385,
-0.036553964,
-0.0069417749,
0.0125866383,
0.0756876767,
-0.0428365134,
-0.0258112885,
0.1016991064,
0.0228954013,
-0.0117535712,
0.013911251,
-0.0010732242,
0.0499655418,
0.0182178076,
0.0259906221,
-0.1248909608,
-0.0427225307,
0.0007722748,
0.0139157837,
0.0211607143,
0.0120831225,
-0.0198141262,
-0.0643168315,
0.0121654738,
0.0141390599,
-0.0275577698,
-0.032749556,
0.0202072375,
-0.0241406895,
-0.0211741365,
0.0869554058,
0.0371041186,
-0.0461954288,
0.0255798083,
0.0212191977,
0.0219277777,
-0.0285483021,
0.0220772959,
-0.0086841164,
0.0460466295,
0.0599804446,
0.0322551727,
0.0202614367,
0.0277017765,
0.0112789748,
0.0081273168,
0.0038888608,
-0.0021991972,
0.0172387045,
0.0113166766,
-0.0217435956,
0.0155470539,
0.0108637149,
-0.0018891967,
-0.0137232114,
-0.0256328396,
-0.0048996722,
-0.0065014749,
-0.0136152459,
0.0193358548,
-0.0061726118,
-0.0217518695,
0.0315189548,
0.0503751561,
0.0067065475,
-0.0822876021,
-0.0237911325,
-0.0105978828,
-0.0510522723,
-0.0386937,
-0.0080205649,
0.0031262208,
-0.0144358762,
-0.0417342298,
-0.0218092054,
0.0327434279,
0.0011776827,
-0.0536969453,
-0.0184209701,
-0.0104245432,
0.0049766744,
-0.0858947039,
0.0331488699,
-0.0376426205,
0.0115105659,
-0.0512813181,
-0.0165406242,
0.0232529417,
-0.0159008447,
-0.0312513001,
0.0054265726,
-0.1227604002,
-0.0593082197,
0.0027727748,
0.0590026677,
0.0245895833,
0.0402033217,
-0.0049044285,
-0.0775519311,
0.0561534204,
0.0512297302,
-0.0149376914,
0.0568187162,
0.0144425584,
-0.0046960893,
-0.0258148853,
0.0552167408,
-0.0461772271,
0.0351066999,
0.0007060207,
0.0742615387,
-0.0408018641,
-0.0544623509,
0.0057157823,
0.0245042667,
0.0201576389,
-0.0152015919,
0.0134595763,
0.0068027512,
0.0240634754,
-0.0014879435,
0.0037606,
-0.0429297723,
-0.00456338,
-0.0009973429,
-0.023810029,
-0.0188874584,
0.000633693,
0.0006895949,
-0.0126599008,
-0.0113687878,
-0.0074647483,
-0.0058516669,
0.0300887488,
0.0443898328,
-0.0215082821,
-0.0337875523,
0.0389271565,
-0.0059421868,
0.0486123934,
-0.0275655743,
0.005097067,
-0.0095807547,
0.0118958429,
-0.0426128246,
0.077480197,
-0.0307125598,
-0.0868230984,
-0.0463383012,
-0.003640567,
0.0733580068,
0.0317697786,
0.0738680661,
0.0453230403,
-0.030054193,
0.0135669606,
0.0168574639,
0.0200329889,
-0.0278077219,
0.0227096993,
0.0173692647,
-0.0166230686,
-0.0129684312,
0.0756333545,
0.0237867869,
0.0398689322,
-0.0034534291,
0.0153324064,
-0.0263594575,
-0.0267234333,
-0.0548357144,
0.0041711959,
0.0116399676,
-0.0033713258,
-0.0092725903,
-0.054517854,
0.0189645365,
0.0281345509,
-0.0188374799,
-0.0129541447,
0.0404471457,
0.0228055455,
0.0090828789,
-0.0527109839,
-0.0499625765,
-0.0263389405,
0.0155570433,
0.0011279274,
-0.00091391,
-6.800172371e-33,
-0.0540957488,
-0.0066774301,
0.0339867547,
-0.012346602,
-0.0181384236,
0.0078016245,
-0.0304582417,
-0.0186091196,
-0.0062055676,
-0.0263077971,
-0.0085947104,
0.0251974519,
0.0086657517,
0.0077974238,
-0.0173169337,
-0.008913273,
0.0740214959,
0.0215703603,
-0.0254761204,
0.0281508174,
0.0017662297,
0.0275313891,
0.043120563,
0.0591719896,
-0.0274735279,
0.0114063984,
-0.0337016433,
0.0071070958,
-0.0148182381,
0.0469462611,
-0.0404920094,
0.0238901097,
0.0035885577,
0.0002378521,
-0.0372090191,
-0.0065549165,
-0.0827279836,
-0.0150867328,
0.0238388963,
0.0042565269,
0.0060421741,
-0.0516104363,
0.0581854545,
-0.0127711799,
-0.0104650473,
-0.0324693359,
-0.008490148,
-0.0097287204,
-0.0144040305,
-0.0958646983,
-0.0542136356,
0.0176375397,
0.0083237374,
-0.0005257093,
0.0419177525,
-0.0050926846,
-0.0266326834,
0.0019041261,
-0.0438160785,
-0.0123676136,
0.0552939512,
0.0873099044,
0.0622689873,
0.0370469056,
-0.0123578301,
0.0346284844,
0.0080684675,
-0.0214594956,
0.0060421936,
0.0654770732,
0.0127265947,
0.0258663949,
0.0052143079,
0.0412009247,
0.0683537424,
0.0305487365,
-0.0917461067,
-0.0024470494,
-0.0371529423,
0.0466208979,
0.0081904791,
0.032612782,
0.000251522,
-0.0206270274,
-0.0514336489,
0.0056406679,
-0.0587440245,
-0.0170698725,
0.012797188,
0.0260694865,
-0.0340802372,
-0.0064655384,
0.0094325561,
-0.0415052027,
0.0031428465,
-0.0141839534,
-0.0139150387,
0.0046664733,
-0.0000658132,
0.055640582,
-0.0092977611,
-0.0257904697,
0.0326846726,
-0.0154104037,
0.0071608084,
-0.0000558038,
0.0172358695,
0.0421791822,
-0.0707172602,
0.0093502551,
-0.0235813893,
0.0439054705,
-0.0104138386,
0.0504049547,
0.0016350218,
0.0103733083,
-0.0047724294,
0.0695061907,
-0.0206589568,
0.0278067701,
-0.0160785504,
0.0082638357,
0.0309097469,
0.082407847,
-0.0409279987,
0.018788062,
-0.0322489329,
0.0408095419,
0.0146346446,
-0.0590849407,
-0.0287283044,
0.0158583075,
2.777e-7,
0.0515842587,
0.0229242463,
0.0341663174,
0.0090804519,
-0.0223135613,
-0.0163299348,
0.0190480519,
0.0372906849,
0.0097097028,
0.005020902,
0.0008893891,
0.0354751386,
0.0009349273,
0.0129560623,
-0.0589629523,
0.0352321789,
-0.0515585765,
-0.0013066554,
-0.0453949235,
-0.0441543125,
0.0183794107,
0.1116757765,
-0.0331953913,
-0.0066533834,
0.0263104625,
-0.0139112407,
0.0497362874,
0.0353966765,
-0.0299289376,
0.0604693666,
0.0516039878,
0.0197394565,
-0.0107925832,
-0.0353521481,
0.0177513827,
-0.0018365638,
-0.0157836918,
0.0784954503,
-0.0245288853,
-0.0199966822,
-0.0045497301,
-0.0141988285,
0.0098425224,
-0.0277045257,
0.0709637031,
-0.0811443254,
-0.0174284261,
-0.0866536871,
-0.0287424177,
-0.0201583989,
0.023608325,
-0.0391672924,
0.0083732558,
0.0410230123,
0.021787649,
0.0007068191,
0.0027568806,
-0.1012995094,
-0.0463079512,
0.0457602888,
0.001621305,
-0.0385883637,
-0.0426249765,
-0.0281584691,
0.0154312924,
-0.0656682327,
0.0084776795,
2.608817087e-34,
0.0389983281,
-0.0065101343,
0.0080133239,
0.0075353705,
0.0187650602,
-0.0030547101,
-0.0245716721,
0.0004661316,
0.0055010584,
-0.0749178007,
-0.0182222538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08582v1 | Tree-Planner: Efficient Close-loop Task Planning with Large Language Models | 2023-10-12T17:59:50 | 2023-10-12T17:59:50 | Mengkang Hu, Yao Mu, Xinmiao Yu, Mingyu Ding, Shiguang Wu, Wenqi Shao, Qiguang Chen, Bin Wang, Yu Qiao, Ping Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO | This paper studies close-loop task planning, which refers to the process of
generating a sequence of skills (a plan) to accomplish a specific goal while
adapting the plan based on real-time observations. Recently, prompting Large
Language Models (LLMs) to generate actions iteratively has become a prevalent
paradigm due to its superior performance and user-friendliness. However, this
paradigm is plagued by two inefficiencies: high token consumption and redundant
error correction, both of which hinder its scalability for large-scale testing
and applications. To address these issues, we propose Tree-Planner, which
reframes task planning with LLMs into three distinct phases: plan sampling,
action tree construction, and grounded deciding. Tree-Planner starts by using
an LLM to sample a set of potential plans before execution, followed by the
aggregation of them to form an action tree. Finally, the LLM performs a
top-down decision-making process on the tree, taking into account real-time
environmental information. Experiments show that Tree-Planner achieves
state-of-the-art performance while maintaining high efficiency. By decomposing
LLM queries into a single plan-sampling call and multiple grounded-deciding
calls, a considerable part of the prompt are less likely to be repeatedly
consumed. As a result, token consumption is reduced by 92.2% compared to the
previously best-performing model. Additionally, by enabling backtracking on the
action tree as needed, the correction process becomes more flexible, leading to
a 40.5% decrease in error corrections. Project page:
https://tree-planner.github.io/ | [
0.0394957438,
0.0284710303,
-0.0106563745,
-0.0188645683,
-0.0505931936,
-0.0326588415,
-0.039225366,
-0.0205773339,
-0.0070052575,
-0.0188762657,
0.0147297392,
0.0079058493,
-0.0260086395,
0.0440436378,
-0.0208077338,
-0.0495700352,
0.0401704349,
-0.0615779124,
0.0036375166,
-0.0115921143,
-0.0346818455,
0.0063782288,
-0.0214831028,
0.061788898,
-0.0203140248,
-0.0317569338,
-0.0565010831,
0.0368231162,
-0.0141810216,
-0.0416258462,
-0.0168211292,
0.0279018376,
0.011936022,
0.0035375578,
0.0000021464,
-0.048061505,
-0.0127439881,
-0.0438218489,
-0.0379725993,
-0.0249585211,
-0.0034910145,
0.0395425409,
-0.0190253146,
0.0630145893,
-0.021692317,
0.0077246032,
0.0279693697,
0.0217509847,
0.0339892209,
0.0431925692,
0.0006637573,
0.0172632858,
-0.0452597514,
0.0140164411,
-0.0212837495,
-0.0451205634,
0.0109697962,
-0.0232884474,
0.0529044829,
0.0050138021,
0.0156901665,
-0.0402391478,
0.0363741256,
-0.0426308401,
-0.0366098285,
0.0298262592,
-0.0196488723,
-0.0304982774,
-0.0120611945,
-0.0165805668,
-0.0571285523,
-0.0191497188,
0.0480243638,
-0.0165744871,
-0.0357081108,
0.0033960841,
-0.0174547583,
0.0159454271,
-0.0074407104,
-0.0111601232,
-0.009083719,
-0.0524923541,
-0.0063048224,
-0.0075717559,
-0.0310067423,
0.0927250832,
0.0015285403,
-0.0171894133,
0.0082238652,
-0.0040667863,
0.0424649194,
-0.0914341435,
0.0020930215,
0.0827243105,
-0.1545104682,
-0.0013842724,
-0.007079232,
0.0172656178,
0.000148572,
0.0113254134,
0.0242833644,
0.0580264702,
0.0035642842,
0.0197977722,
0.00643609,
0.0820635855,
0.0198211893,
-0.015798647,
-0.0463043191,
0.0024392325,
-0.0502681695,
0.0202955715,
-0.0645945445,
0.0235444512,
-0.0896946266,
-0.0190118253,
-0.0237117335,
0.0785585418,
-0.0049999417,
0.0342198797,
0.014545558,
-0.0003024718,
-0.0039632362,
0.0171577428,
-0.0384796374,
-0.0335659161,
-0.0340631045,
0.00053099,
0.0061544543,
-0.02585846,
0.0084378757,
0.010377191,
-0.0019763168,
0.0064090542,
0.0192913674,
0.0705506504,
-0.0178286918,
0.001012083,
-0.0293257162,
-0.0580886677,
0.0076803374,
-0.0406038351,
0.0083350092,
-0.0685454533,
-0.0051415809,
-0.0185719244,
-0.0242900774,
0.0197108183,
-0.0045322487,
0.0258890726,
0.0049390444,
0.0126874754,
0.0492571592,
0.0748770609,
-0.0114848195,
0.0019950252,
-0.0171108618,
0.1001425609,
0.0330048613,
0.0728539526,
0.0040159645,
0.0257634316,
0.0136470376,
0.0591255873,
-0.0370965675,
-0.0098483544,
0.0197408218,
0.0151225049,
-0.0025259315,
0.0248789787,
-0.0047031795,
0.0040962799,
0.0043733167,
0.0615298338,
0.0256142952,
0.0683099031,
-0.0127932522,
-0.0272288937,
0.0505593047,
0.0286326148,
-0.0272011328,
-0.0655860528,
-0.0594958253,
0.0280817933,
-0.0236071255,
-0.0108865285,
-0.0250257906,
0.0305125583,
-0.0191999823,
-0.0132887699,
-0.0046060239,
0.0025232043,
-0.0205236878,
0.0334196761,
0.0413713083,
-0.0106473248,
-0.0633018538,
0.0420653224,
-0.0200659428,
-0.0041577499,
-0.0436909012,
-0.0591858774,
0.0040467214,
0.0790064409,
0.0613285229,
-0.0280579161,
-0.0689296871,
0.0389763713,
-0.0073521491,
-0.0035802922,
0.0166639127,
-0.0400852524,
-0.0154466964,
0.0010791551,
-0.0699875951,
0.0171708874,
0.0012617328,
0.02716038,
0.0242263097,
-0.0238542948,
-0.0234314632,
-0.0072610658,
-0.0455317236,
0.0318843462,
-0.0041293562,
-0.0224173609,
0.0391552374,
0.0133910552,
0.0688904524,
0.0111196898,
-0.0035897442,
-0.0080305543,
0.0505341589,
-0.0011910811,
-0.0209726524,
0.0193681903,
-0.0252366029,
0.0051766653,
0.0328033529,
0.0187579598,
-0.0380015858,
0.0255951695,
-0.0535295606,
-0.0655626208,
-0.018610023,
-0.0078078602,
0.023710601,
0.0180309974,
0.0576093718,
-0.0345335901,
-0.0701337457,
-0.0145423748,
0.0193360597,
0.027602192,
-0.0249410048,
0.0231624879,
0.0304234698,
-0.0090207011,
-0.0350105464,
-0.0040252954,
0.0322410911,
0.0004894973,
-0.0084092747,
0.0232053827,
0.0819391087,
-0.0372031517,
-0.0283752996,
-0.1380895525,
0.0328454264,
-0.0368203856,
0.0042074327,
-0.0058591524,
0.0324131995,
0.0006946488,
-0.0127436137,
0.005581541,
0.0247844383,
0.0167854466,
0.0265261196,
-0.0226898268,
-0.0076984414,
-0.0465364046,
0.0133719398,
0.015804613,
-0.0300266929,
-0.0058052242,
-0.0084124627,
-0.0362555124,
-0.0406936593,
0.0451876223,
0.0042897216,
0.0213532541,
0.0095435865,
0.0130627602,
0.0251916014,
-0.0145848757,
0.0593999103,
0.0331457369,
-0.0304713249,
-0.0180350374,
0.0685818791,
-0.0116189858,
-0.0538712926,
0.0352694802,
0.0130818281,
-0.0209887475,
-0.0220759772,
0.0079827504,
0.0313590318,
0.0406566001,
-0.049289301,
0.0147243636,
-0.0307226833,
-0.0141584687,
-0.0061987224,
-0.0097451452,
-0.0061092349,
-0.0324468575,
-0.0469925888,
0.0537182875,
-0.0186361652,
-0.0432600044,
0.0372823104,
-0.0072299289,
-0.0398706235,
-0.0351512097,
-0.0248453151,
-0.0009714313,
0.0919239148,
0.0304830484,
0.0103115151,
-0.0409920029,
-0.0427686609,
-0.0341337733,
0.0137367742,
-0.0352231525,
-0.0270022098,
0.038954258,
-0.0648541301,
0.0058332938,
-0.0249790791,
-0.0526823476,
-0.0488776937,
0.0021271834,
-0.0506624654,
0.0356096588,
-0.0087254131,
-0.043001499,
-0.0192651208,
-0.0155488849,
0.0034178272,
0.0790838972,
-0.002072098,
-0.017576253,
-0.0213472694,
-0.0501209758,
0.0390014276,
0.0181958638,
-0.0174371134,
0.0139792459,
0.0271599311,
0.0445125885,
0.109044902,
-0.0020929591,
-0.0340697952,
-0.0096764313,
0.0347079523,
-0.0201837663,
0.0111081395,
0.0705663264,
0.0552568808,
-0.031123817,
-0.0329195485,
0.1036870331,
0.0151266595,
-0.0369473472,
0.0317392983,
-0.0262445994,
0.0278427191,
0.0364545062,
0.0730267167,
-0.0533132702,
-0.0249921978,
0.0443547927,
0.0462718122,
-0.0188943911,
-0.0336459838,
-0.0055007637,
-0.1166539267,
0.0443917736,
-0.0324282348,
-0.0347622335,
0.0216428675,
-0.0495344698,
0.0077064438,
0.0089651002,
0.0134323193,
0.0393579416,
0.0425126664,
-0.0213918127,
0.0086663542,
-0.0398084,
-0.0288205929,
0.0683915541,
-0.0107828593,
0.0236680359,
0.0814793631,
0.0251664594,
0.0251428429,
0.0152016999,
0.0500007346,
0.0588356704,
0.0318289101,
-0.058998283,
-0.0427299701,
0.0133432858,
0.0055336142,
0.02603966,
0.0185229983,
-0.0428655408,
-0.0443097055,
0.0559200123,
0.1295629889,
-0.0404661857,
0.0172792133,
-0.0279472079,
-0.032850448,
0.0320572741,
0.0409513339,
-0.0369033441,
-0.0646203309,
-0.0534478985,
-0.0200824831,
-0.0614693649,
-0.0664386153,
-0.0293131061,
0.0040301275,
-0.0274904966,
0.0295003895,
-0.0052279201,
-0.0037591713,
0.0765232518,
0.0781059265,
-0.0013748506,
-0.0391851142,
0.0113842562,
0.0413546562,
-0.0277989693,
-0.0096091889,
-0.0156069128,
0.0311162379,
-0.0324420072,
-0.0113424873,
-0.0031906751,
0.0056197857,
0.0100188144,
0.0050863572,
-0.0374864787,
-0.0452000871,
-0.0062956465,
0.0517877527,
0.0241224263,
0.0043468461,
-0.0077575403,
-0.0227229968,
0.0162945595,
0.0171588976,
-0.0641098842,
0.0347346663,
-0.0077040703,
0.0213425215,
0.0005221027,
0.0170219075,
-0.1031845063,
0.0309582409,
0.0008962812,
0.0253270213,
-0.0074204798,
-0.0163253807,
0.0016557802,
0.0560373403,
0.0194179248,
-0.0077224807,
-0.0220486149,
0.0084971627,
0.041845534,
-0.0218818709,
-0.0372497812,
-0.0457562469,
0.0317804739,
-0.0506353639,
-0.0233519599,
0.0566022135,
-0.0038051615,
0.0007213643,
-0.0166952703,
-0.0083253384,
0.0008786782,
0.0057819718,
0.012393794,
0.0755913556,
-0.0188154951,
-0.0092599569,
-0.0398629494,
0.0316092931,
0.0116549991,
0.0102524888,
0.0178412814,
-0.0000872358,
0.0206994265,
-0.0523807257,
-0.031693425,
-0.0424402729,
-0.0968084186,
0.0281084068,
0.0458275415,
0.0352195762,
0.0125254113,
0.0074278438,
-0.0791337118,
0.0291091818,
-0.0319210589,
-0.0317965448,
0.0087396679,
-0.0252345912,
0.0052945209,
0.0333388746,
-0.0032507589,
-0.0278113429,
0.053832192,
-0.0185044445,
0.0507437885,
-0.0038644967,
-0.0537417643,
-0.0514668338,
-0.028271364,
0.0034267311,
0.021847358,
-0.0185838398,
-0.0486441962,
-0.0542484112,
-0.0068545062,
0.0062088175,
0.035045106,
-0.0005040811,
-0.0464874618,
0.0361487828,
0.0497670472,
0.0274142902,
-0.0090329172,
-0.0232303161,
-0.0320516825,
0.0022295997,
-0.0060986616,
-0.0245882571,
-5.488098801e-33,
-0.00677882,
-0.0584041066,
0.0828247443,
-0.032483872,
-0.0010352866,
-0.0016092054,
-0.0374809951,
-0.0012909881,
0.0282557141,
0.0057608932,
-0.0500048958,
0.0048375237,
0.0285476185,
0.0092725204,
0.0739547834,
0.0547276922,
0.063218087,
-0.0043776412,
-0.0509188399,
0.0158811025,
0.0359615944,
-0.0030524116,
-0.0024627047,
-0.0235989969,
-0.0436318628,
0.0409382768,
0.0191778261,
0.0462117232,
0.0005710311,
0.0106394021,
0.0397623368,
0.0115964226,
0.0044629099,
-0.0343103297,
-0.0308034793,
0.0198804568,
-0.0231290571,
-0.0579089262,
0.0144589813,
0.0194441583,
-0.0436848477,
0.004288598,
0.0090848869,
0.0325759873,
-0.0483785495,
0.0278305653,
-0.0184489731,
0.0166166238,
-0.0324484035,
-0.001282245,
-0.0449850596,
0.0127515243,
0.0274809785,
-0.0025717341,
0.0130858943,
0.0517875887,
-0.0066946703,
-0.047607325,
0.0105520664,
0.0283721574,
-0.0266209878,
0.0078867273,
0.0496838875,
0.0384067744,
0.0101461746,
0.0464938693,
0.0441225879,
0.0279251505,
0.0114687281,
0.0218458232,
-0.0051393523,
0.0709395781,
-0.0158068947,
-0.0091857975,
0.0061970442,
0.0014137033,
-0.0389468297,
0.0047862115,
0.0368249752,
0.0671450347,
0.0578472801,
0.0159432497,
-0.0207837969,
-0.0253138263,
-0.0025745328,
0.0403279029,
-0.0166514851,
-0.0038917828,
0.0406428128,
0.037039306,
-0.0000611203,
0.0098404679,
0.0261238907,
0.0086813876,
0.0145865949,
0.0368368477,
-0.0299274232,
0.0124867624,
-0.0319101512,
0.0319890119,
-0.0149302036,
-0.0652320683,
-0.0138493264,
-0.0162917171,
0.0320934132,
0.0221761744,
-0.0302187037,
0.053893242,
-0.0622131489,
0.0154581517,
-0.0462602414,
0.0216561947,
-0.0099942293,
-0.0118007492,
0.0757970363,
-0.0359302834,
0.0155858826,
0.0170383044,
0.0164608601,
-0.1358411163,
-0.0228075273,
-0.0099850753,
0.0364401266,
-0.0169134755,
-0.0172251277,
-0.0154529531,
-0.0321060084,
-0.0064509623,
-0.0052257366,
-0.0142186843,
-0.0046162899,
0.035827484,
2.94e-7,
-0.0391059965,
0.0445530973,
-0.0375988632,
0.0437474139,
0.0140266195,
0.0035123113,
0.0292646028,
-0.0090213185,
0.0009104338,
0.021776922,
0.0267166868,
-0.0034980767,
0.0285159573,
0.0428121388,
-0.09946163,
0.0077848141,
-0.0253092907,
0.0049439566,
-0.0627926737,
0.0134666814,
0.0164818708,
0.0499896966,
0.0033665877,
-0.015474407,
0.0379087441,
-0.0460061021,
-0.0281585231,
0.0020488438,
-0.0019413738,
-0.0048563047,
-0.0036169603,
-0.0200097691,
0.0268582702,
0.0516962968,
-0.005331615,
0.010841175,
-0.0390083455,
0.088739939,
-0.0305204932,
0.0040754825,
0.0096662296,
-0.0503730774,
0.0010045926,
-0.0018649576,
0.0463811196,
0.0001265384,
0.0179530215,
-0.0225894768,
0.0354871824,
-0.0303079449,
-0.0536494888,
0.0228496362,
0.0035442077,
0.0330652148,
0.0048409551,
-0.0066400687,
-0.0187298078,
-0.0489807911,
0.0159548521,
0.0114702648,
-0.0361227766,
-0.0589421354,
-0.0458567441,
0.0390064605,
-0.0222774576,
-0.0292230286,
-0.0290763006,
3.255565125e-34,
-0.0154342493,
0.0228532143,
0.0205798708,
0.0567199178,
0.007983922,
0.0303393863,
0.0057831351,
0.0351966843,
0.0597760044,
-0.0344436765,
-0.0682529509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08577v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08577v3 | Visual Data-Type Understanding does not emerge from Scaling Vision-Language Models | 2023-10-12T17:59:30 | 2023-12-06T12:34:16 | Vishaal Udandarao, Max F. Burg, Samuel Albanie, Matthias Bethge | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in the development of vision-language models (VLMs) are
yielding remarkable success in recognizing visual semantic content, including
impressive instances of compositional image understanding. Here, we introduce
the novel task of Visual Data-Type Identification, a basic perceptual skill
with implications for data curation (e.g., noisy data-removal from large
datasets, domain-specific retrieval) and autonomous vision (e.g.,
distinguishing changing weather conditions from camera lens staining). We
develop two datasets consisting of animal images altered across a diverse set
of 27 visual data-types, spanning four broad categories. An extensive zero-shot
evaluation of 39 VLMs, ranging from 100M to 80B parameters, shows a nuanced
performance landscape. While VLMs are reasonably good at identifying certain
stylistic \textit{data-types}, such as cartoons and sketches, they struggle
with simpler data-types arising from basic manipulations like image rotations
or additive noise. Our findings reveal that (i) model scaling alone yields
marginal gains for contrastively-trained models like CLIP, and (ii) there is a
pronounced drop in performance for the largest auto-regressively trained VLMs
like OpenFlamingo. This finding points to a blind spot in current frontier
VLMs: they excel in recognizing semantic content but fail to acquire an
understanding of visual data-types through scaling. By analyzing the
pre-training distributions of these models and incorporating data-type
information into the captions during fine-tuning, we achieve a significant
enhancement in performance. By exploring this previously uncharted task, we aim
to set the stage for further advancing VLMs to equip them with visual data-type
understanding. Code and datasets are released at
https://github.com/bethgelab/DataTypeIdentification. | [
0.0139315147,
0.0674044415,
0.0007727172,
0.0668374375,
-0.0149207264,
0.0226885155,
0.0107583655,
0.0242933594,
-0.0521533526,
-0.0814196914,
-0.0455687307,
-0.0120249679,
0.0366070941,
0.0738443211,
0.0201477595,
-0.0845582485,
0.0176472273,
-0.0501790084,
-0.0144156162,
0.0263271686,
0.0166868176,
-0.013795468,
0.043684043,
0.0333649255,
-0.0006774414,
-0.0210452359,
-0.0035828007,
0.0373187065,
0.0123431776,
0.0108837876,
-0.0158692207,
0.056338042,
0.0796377659,
0.0254455861,
0.0000020155,
-0.0080705518,
0.0330994911,
-0.0003312057,
0.0290013365,
0.0041208263,
0.0522612743,
-0.0679584965,
-0.0025686556,
-0.0199857857,
-0.0131872837,
-0.0785119906,
0.0823987722,
0.0309773795,
0.0113488175,
0.0696668252,
0.0007657512,
-0.0573874637,
0.0135027925,
-0.0193942469,
0.0396721959,
-0.0009532686,
0.0438590162,
-0.0061279363,
-0.043522533,
0.0374395065,
-0.0532057881,
0.0266063642,
0.0001298708,
-0.0055482099,
0.0082928929,
0.0387389027,
-0.0491282158,
-0.0573049076,
0.0165256113,
0.0559834987,
-0.0514318943,
-0.0278837178,
-0.0094337668,
-0.001586683,
0.0074585308,
-0.0107950587,
-0.0300847217,
0.0278246794,
0.0078388285,
0.0071281847,
-0.0629320815,
0.0266425405,
0.0262852237,
0.005623118,
-0.0321578942,
-0.034228228,
-0.0088538174,
0.0396812782,
-0.0355646573,
-0.0258940179,
-0.0134684118,
-0.0482825264,
-0.0202022716,
0.0197601859,
0.023584716,
-0.0365276486,
-0.0538066849,
-0.0232063308,
-0.0013318007,
-0.0170910843,
0.0509112291,
-0.0088789836,
-0.0712327138,
0.0692002401,
-0.0120583447,
0.072370179,
-0.0119195189,
0.0447602421,
-0.0227318238,
-0.008126853,
-0.0081837028,
-0.0070810644,
-0.0040859277,
-0.0184950139,
-0.0278947148,
-0.0145966988,
0.0087481095,
-0.0137926787,
-0.0182613861,
0.0205118805,
-0.0161112659,
-0.0019582023,
-0.0414075702,
-0.0215883348,
-0.0244041122,
0.0424009524,
0.0289822984,
0.0248429533,
-0.0114044305,
-0.0582453012,
-0.0069193603,
0.0318143368,
0.0168114994,
-0.0205224063,
0.0051090633,
0.0934431255,
0.0013487495,
-0.0464030989,
-0.0431925207,
-0.0022075418,
-0.0285389107,
-0.0409369506,
0.0477175042,
-0.0606928356,
-0.0127390223,
-0.0280204136,
0.0156660359,
-0.0399412364,
0.0115085086,
0.0021976479,
-0.0434350334,
0.1257779896,
-0.0463743247,
-0.0217093509,
-0.0206667241,
-0.0123689948,
0.0115961703,
0.0561514422,
0.0156219639,
0.0457508042,
0.0184219126,
-0.026250707,
0.0421078913,
0.0172571931,
-0.0093457187,
0.0091841929,
-0.0824718475,
-0.0068263314,
0.000686194,
0.0067710476,
0.0480204411,
0.0465926938,
-0.0128881587,
-0.0864691883,
0.0877735093,
0.0184365064,
0.014025026,
0.0083609074,
0.0634998754,
-0.016554011,
0.0202074852,
0.0227958094,
-0.0422587991,
0.0422947556,
-0.0021049655,
0.0161905568,
-0.0293014832,
0.0680765286,
-0.0684188306,
-0.0560467727,
-0.0400720499,
-0.0227937512,
0.013296172,
-0.0165769719,
0.0557233393,
0.0330450535,
0.0069941231,
-0.0365752615,
0.0069969501,
-0.0002886298,
-0.024871543,
-0.0799498335,
0.0363105573,
0.0300649274,
0.021576941,
-0.0120822648,
-0.0014146077,
-0.0097494675,
0.0395695046,
0.0360199437,
-0.0041364487,
0.0016971186,
0.0234794077,
-0.0503854901,
-0.0232532974,
-0.0157544725,
0.0110896938,
-0.0046735378,
-0.0214911066,
-0.0160427801,
-0.0012302625,
-0.0596088655,
-0.0327402204,
0.0531715378,
0.0588359497,
-0.0465850607,
0.0107810674,
0.0050679836,
-0.0022594598,
-0.0209471732,
-0.0236077476,
-0.0000996311,
-0.0169148296,
-0.0213229172,
0.0097164912,
0.0438611619,
-0.0160841737,
-0.0234407336,
0.0393598527,
-0.055497814,
-0.0226895548,
0.0176002476,
-0.0316555947,
0.0061075548,
0.0548585206,
-0.0068277884,
-0.0335326977,
-0.0513212569,
-0.0059100832,
-0.0216083899,
0.0234285202,
-0.0119316243,
0.0326576978,
-0.0051770136,
-0.0291505158,
-0.0039091641,
-0.0098902453,
-0.0029923201,
-0.0121369828,
-0.011826491,
-0.0068707056,
-0.0119357137,
0.0070931944,
-0.0203872453,
-0.0126385968,
-0.0320167765,
0.0148197366,
-0.0241392143,
-0.0344227962,
-0.0372215994,
-0.018105112,
-0.014999263,
0.0069610812,
0.0182296615,
-0.0256524049,
-0.0106787439,
0.0211103614,
-0.0343094096,
0.032615006,
0.0333454385,
0.0038265879,
0.0144269867,
-0.0250479635,
-0.0100956317,
0.0223537665,
0.084221825,
0.0133881858,
-0.0368612558,
-0.0245550796,
0.0269970726,
-0.0392265171,
0.0091377012,
-0.0213629194,
-0.0226349682,
-0.0048166714,
-0.0339245535,
-0.0057106838,
0.0970594436,
0.0049564969,
0.024996141,
0.0233744141,
0.0084547251,
-0.0220389608,
-0.0157471914,
-0.0054232329,
-0.0311840642,
0.0078435913,
-0.0012307295,
-0.0216592606,
0.0469598249,
-0.0506505631,
-0.0066942172,
-0.0487348437,
0.0859239101,
0.011666948,
-0.0321916416,
-0.0601075627,
0.0297752284,
0.0129320091,
0.0219465811,
-0.0422473699,
-0.0736093894,
0.0228363164,
-0.0040185591,
-0.0128099425,
0.0250602104,
-0.0065773614,
-0.0178974587,
0.0827070624,
0.0436451584,
0.009924531,
0.0090602329,
-0.0035549479,
-0.0522647128,
-0.0132913655,
0.0109398784,
-0.0097103911,
0.0684213191,
-0.0590894446,
0.0028923643,
-0.0400862247,
-0.0260237008,
-0.028995879,
0.0267587025,
-0.0332832858,
0.0163376648,
-0.0288642049,
-0.0347180776,
-0.0407210067,
0.0201805774,
0.0302978884,
0.0362091847,
-0.023809405,
-0.0050463546,
0.0031445147,
0.0376377329,
0.0342757553,
0.022188263,
0.0051923059,
-0.0290946513,
-0.006575211,
0.0390366726,
-0.0103203608,
-0.0115476511,
-0.0799667835,
0.0453940295,
-0.0011770873,
0.0428597853,
-0.0061701471,
0.0123141529,
0.0343142338,
-0.0830594748,
-0.0142858066,
0.0533705242,
0.0074356063,
-0.057744123,
-0.0187002346,
0.0089597041,
0.008996129,
0.0334595069,
0.0119141173,
-0.0796803087,
-0.0524720214,
-0.0089397281,
-0.0190254245,
0.0191538204,
-0.0069236201,
-0.0338201262,
-0.0427328311,
0.0808187351,
0.0388483256,
-0.0525237881,
-0.0633640066,
0.0000964241,
0.0223727282,
-0.0567450784,
-0.0273439325,
-0.0257629193,
-0.0324499086,
0.0304622371,
0.0036451004,
0.0296063833,
-0.0418365262,
-0.0178467166,
-0.0258373022,
0.008678088,
0.0718373135,
0.0089723151,
-0.020693481,
-0.0668485537,
0.025220748,
0.0075326706,
-0.0119006019,
-0.0184727274,
0.0882359371,
-0.0246879365,
-0.0195321441,
0.025161108,
0.0416915976,
-0.0010623473,
-0.0158213954,
-0.0434612073,
0.009070538,
0.0022328263,
-0.05179739,
-0.0710353702,
-0.0229877438,
-0.007544749,
0.0437905639,
0.0546941198,
-0.0201146528,
-0.0190706011,
-0.0252468251,
-0.0086444644,
-0.0445844382,
-0.065438576,
-0.0040208097,
0.0431292206,
-0.030670207,
-0.0485068783,
0.0117443521,
0.0196454935,
0.0111270947,
-0.0386674106,
-0.0503488854,
-0.0038567116,
0.0171819814,
-0.1044609994,
0.0708328709,
-0.0193656925,
0.0066778287,
-0.0401312932,
-0.0213299748,
0.034971796,
-0.0336549655,
-0.0247899052,
0.0139888842,
-0.1330676973,
-0.0379891582,
-0.0067170789,
0.0736661106,
0.0186519679,
0.0263331998,
0.0556297116,
-0.0356349908,
0.0255414564,
0.1035470441,
0.0610524751,
0.0500208773,
0.0142670646,
-0.0352775194,
-0.0032820639,
0.0386185646,
-0.0356761739,
0.0444816686,
0.0468455739,
-0.0188387837,
0.0041716332,
0.0065163188,
0.0029276635,
-0.0189094469,
0.0523287803,
0.0011286986,
0.0046863309,
-0.0094580827,
-0.0025078466,
0.0518303625,
-0.0111835934,
-0.0711622536,
-0.0133832479,
0.000196745,
0.0641306341,
-0.0012162687,
0.0129307713,
0.0014079018,
0.034982264,
-0.0462553985,
0.0040902416,
0.0250244848,
-0.0222533345,
-0.0094659217,
0.0235268138,
0.0160480216,
0.081744507,
-0.0057527651,
0.0230829883,
0.0111332685,
-0.0041530081,
0.0191617291,
0.0110000474,
-0.0657684505,
0.0409603715,
-0.0253953133,
-0.0282185823,
-0.0339558572,
0.0306464732,
0.0201058649,
-0.0412646905,
0.0007622963,
-0.0012516873,
-0.0272366833,
-0.0567040704,
0.0190908741,
0.0407790653,
0.0048306431,
0.063239783,
0.0312513746,
-0.0206189174,
-0.0318403505,
0.0903059393,
0.0146109555,
0.0419021249,
-0.0034014916,
0.025935201,
0.0131992288,
-0.0072597568,
0.0243167952,
-0.0381235778,
0.0076032383,
0.0164213181,
-0.0467592925,
-0.0651731491,
-0.0028734179,
0.0212918203,
0.0183026269,
0.0336131342,
0.0262178238,
0.0208824445,
0.042705927,
-0.0127154766,
0.0018362929,
-0.0197445732,
0.0255175903,
-0.0019604643,
0.0141532263,
-5.876988699e-33,
-0.006806965,
-0.0002015382,
0.0104959691,
0.0111065414,
0.0279611163,
0.0520832129,
0.0078398343,
0.0124765215,
-0.0334059969,
0.049177736,
0.0187368635,
0.0174612459,
0.0024446831,
0.0264960285,
0.0025675183,
0.0201989282,
0.0523309372,
-0.0282080267,
0.0019743813,
-0.0061819637,
0.0197861269,
0.0061671571,
0.0290531553,
-0.070217073,
-0.0357704535,
0.0230335183,
-0.0203164648,
-0.0017182528,
0.0142889461,
0.0728335604,
0.0075782663,
-0.0021114913,
0.0258868169,
0.002891646,
-0.0742887929,
-0.0204123128,
-0.0813102052,
-0.0195947718,
0.0022827603,
0.0254069082,
-0.0856689885,
-0.0118113784,
0.0797132552,
-0.0096081039,
-0.0123826377,
-0.0589779839,
0.0369866937,
-0.0455023535,
0.0164760258,
-0.0150771383,
-0.0295377951,
0.0283773504,
-0.0002412699,
-0.0198024847,
0.0861557648,
-0.0231431965,
0.0076518618,
0.0644695684,
-0.0541659631,
0.0484722741,
0.0216744263,
0.0291231032,
0.0562486313,
0.092082113,
0.0106885945,
0.0491115227,
0.0258625187,
0.0079593761,
-0.0378850587,
-0.0116299205,
0.0514501892,
0.0492558777,
0.0298126899,
0.051726114,
0.0565536916,
0.0189545117,
-0.0311471056,
0.0039936262,
-0.0496743806,
0.0362249166,
-0.0243594609,
0.0210807342,
0.0196817853,
0.0081987465,
-0.0388772488,
-0.0332746543,
-0.063127473,
0.0096234549,
0.0326357149,
0.0188603997,
0.0040081898,
0.0180010814,
0.0376307517,
-0.0207254831,
-0.0207826626,
-0.0038463422,
-0.0168123003,
0.0614115968,
0.0306077357,
-0.0086647822,
-0.0441996381,
-0.0309172198,
0.0710639954,
0.0434849933,
0.0087505151,
0.0181166511,
0.0590263121,
0.0324196145,
-0.0236610398,
-0.01821802,
-0.0267888922,
-0.0232799686,
0.0095290486,
0.0517529286,
0.033358369,
-0.001372429,
-0.0207468681,
0.0224852134,
-0.0102506913,
-0.0236913338,
-0.0277263075,
-0.0171655267,
-0.0166195687,
0.0481948592,
-0.0194564834,
-0.0329812504,
-0.0437523536,
-0.0206032861,
0.0392880477,
-0.0470215604,
-0.0056545618,
0.0214555934,
2.703e-7,
0.0203500614,
0.0327861235,
0.0030607011,
0.0145499464,
0.0168512389,
0.0700735375,
-0.0291255321,
0.0114631206,
-0.013105344,
-0.033919163,
0.0231393445,
0.0469702408,
0.0260657016,
-0.023197623,
0.0023917982,
0.0305977054,
-0.029795954,
0.004043275,
-0.0539484397,
-0.0327351503,
-0.0106358053,
0.1132250279,
-0.0260884985,
-0.0231190398,
0.0821580961,
-0.0334851518,
0.0825974643,
-0.0326160304,
0.0348363407,
-0.0093103172,
-0.0322838649,
0.0419739559,
-0.0087112803,
0.02662481,
-0.0029017772,
-0.0260215718,
0.0392753221,
0.0258997828,
-0.0525396615,
0.0417575389,
-0.0136614339,
0.0619282983,
-0.0213596523,
-0.0601390004,
0.0704877228,
-0.0441592857,
-0.0075382385,
-0.0333193354,
-0.0077027059,
0.0192870069,
0.0254635215,
-0.0190655701,
-0.0273707099,
0.0463588275,
0.0176150259,
0.0071377056,
-0.0398740284,
-0.0800600573,
-0.0123165939,
-0.041090209,
-0.0419215485,
-0.0197513904,
-0.075076364,
-0.0055733211,
0.0488202125,
-0.0038423396,
-0.0543957688,
2.365172694e-34,
0.0343526453,
-0.0010630141,
-0.0152740506,
-0.025457548,
-0.0140457731,
-0.0226001106,
-0.0140144248,
0.003220472,
-0.0250560213,
-0.0549678728,
-0.019225182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08566v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08566v2 | Transformers as Decision Makers: Provable In-Context Reinforcement Learning via Supervised Pretraining | 2023-10-12T17:55:02 | 2024-05-26T04:55:19 | Licong Lin, Yu Bai, Song Mei | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.ST, stat.ML, stat.TH | Large transformer models pretrained on offline reinforcement learning
datasets have demonstrated remarkable in-context reinforcement learning (ICRL)
capabilities, where they can make good decisions when prompted with interaction
trajectories from unseen environments. However, when and how transformers can
be trained to perform ICRL have not been theoretically well-understood. In
particular, it is unclear which reinforcement-learning algorithms transformers
can perform in context, and how distribution mismatch in offline training data
affects the learned algorithms. This paper provides a theoretical framework
that analyzes supervised pretraining for ICRL. This includes two recently
proposed training methods -- algorithm distillation and decision-pretrained
transformers. First, assuming model realizability, we prove the
supervised-pretrained transformer will imitate the conditional expectation of
the expert algorithm given the observed trajectory. The generalization error
will scale with model capacity and a distribution divergence factor between the
expert and offline algorithms. Second, we show transformers with ReLU attention
can efficiently approximate near-optimal online reinforcement learning
algorithms like LinUCB and Thompson sampling for stochastic linear bandits, and
UCB-VI for tabular Markov decision processes. This provides the first
quantitative analysis of the ICRL capabilities of transformers pretrained from
offline trajectories. | [
-0.0069894996,
0.0525614545,
0.0040573166,
-0.0583907031,
0.023186015,
0.0233713537,
-0.0008468619,
-0.0245317668,
-0.0721770898,
0.028460823,
-0.0526525378,
0.0064536012,
-0.0357062891,
0.0022030936,
0.0025142999,
-0.031109415,
-0.00781387,
-0.0245603696,
-0.0317380689,
-0.0085901963,
-0.0157210305,
-0.0257504918,
-0.0126088541,
0.035699673,
0.0197202712,
-0.014230676,
-0.013112504,
-0.011573012,
0.0277654584,
-0.0531373583,
0.0090649957,
0.0004155058,
0.0645280704,
0.0258865394,
0.0000020575,
0.0014894371,
-0.0492860973,
-0.0476262048,
-0.0155081367,
-0.081724979,
-0.0120640351,
-0.0074467189,
0.0053007626,
0.0304781888,
-0.0476700291,
0.0028170384,
0.0327659994,
0.0650843233,
0.0241936408,
0.0519572794,
0.0116517385,
-0.00659743,
0.0144901648,
-0.0217730161,
-0.0042195017,
-0.0200376641,
-0.0104352813,
0.0016264094,
-0.0531207919,
-0.0614927784,
-0.0424150676,
-0.0316420197,
0.049828399,
0.0136556886,
0.0120986737,
0.0435272232,
-0.0401133075,
0.0076335981,
-0.0167313553,
0.0296188165,
-0.0416812748,
0.0022545489,
0.0000729062,
-0.0035347368,
0.0075859227,
0.0114123458,
-0.0055989237,
0.0307493042,
-0.0169615969,
0.0432162508,
-0.048177354,
0.0482677221,
0.006605349,
-0.0302972477,
-0.0741090849,
0.0638544708,
-0.050581906,
-0.0522681773,
0.0362244062,
0.0236930717,
-0.0196262375,
-0.0237200521,
-0.0127975438,
0.0396204665,
-0.06503506,
0.0109900422,
-0.0212666914,
0.0287424736,
-0.0718312636,
0.0441182405,
0.0931745246,
-0.0053750714,
0.0235953927,
0.0146390237,
0.0101478212,
0.0519473925,
-0.0522517189,
0.0634135976,
-0.0002732411,
0.0278082695,
-0.0783042163,
0.0375527032,
-0.0545147695,
0.0308064576,
-0.0036056757,
-0.0019931132,
-0.0429965854,
0.044497326,
-0.0302969925,
0.0199991111,
-0.0099657541,
0.0239671338,
-0.0636012703,
0.0224669911,
-0.0906622335,
-0.0174836684,
0.0067356853,
-0.0004818236,
0.0256605856,
-0.0429880954,
0.0118807638,
-0.0048250989,
-0.0201579612,
-0.0342928171,
0.0076602851,
0.1044239551,
0.0001305132,
-0.0564431474,
-0.0207676142,
-0.0007570741,
0.0305248015,
-0.0532244481,
0.03332638,
-0.0290866867,
-0.015174266,
-0.0316372588,
-0.0143681103,
-0.0030069849,
0.0048836009,
0.0033881755,
0.0298193339,
0.064495489,
0.0725098997,
-0.0106681995,
-0.0251842756,
-0.0432059169,
-0.0586068779,
0.0146488911,
0.025007233,
0.0281274151,
-0.0149555989,
-0.0113601852,
0.0874195993,
0.0058553899,
0.0273537245,
0.0205354411,
0.0039694482,
-0.0104197878,
-0.0396587439,
0.0053210226,
0.062721625,
-0.0248830616,
-0.0937463269,
0.0592457764,
0.0744993165,
-0.0008938733,
0.0664238781,
0.0083764549,
-0.0012121144,
0.026267821,
-0.0183407832,
0.0058643729,
-0.0666266605,
0.0350021645,
0.0267835967,
0.0151304239,
-0.0275764652,
0.0412407815,
-0.0255317483,
-0.0423054732,
0.0631510615,
-0.0067143422,
-0.013256548,
0.0210843496,
0.0494527929,
0.0222242717,
-0.0365187377,
0.0062485253,
0.0261160452,
0.0341208503,
-0.0142727587,
-0.063468881,
0.0146990502,
-0.0105843991,
0.0442291684,
-0.0411825478,
0.0125485351,
-0.0832637474,
-0.0391045436,
0.0032498492,
-0.0419401601,
-0.006961029,
0.0187003501,
0.0088545112,
-0.0484954938,
0.0162670389,
-0.000551882,
0.0353299677,
0.04033418,
-0.0006068417,
-0.0370038226,
-0.0240703989,
0.0076195705,
0.0216511656,
-0.0083910702,
-0.0569494963,
0.0060221436,
0.0083737392,
0.0637546331,
-0.0610574447,
-0.037185967,
-0.0153794345,
-0.002327915,
0.0295369197,
0.0032491966,
0.0264918655,
-0.0483317152,
0.0031397741,
0.0092818867,
-0.0807087347,
0.0128918691,
0.0321464539,
0.0082892068,
-0.0043685869,
-0.0488459207,
0.0002711935,
0.0428948589,
0.0024004716,
0.0216393415,
0.0074069458,
0.0157249533,
-0.0132605415,
0.0021775044,
-0.0346368812,
-0.023341123,
0.0142071377,
0.0003030587,
-0.0110659171,
-0.0410705879,
0.0266413838,
-0.0051058074,
-0.0171137564,
-0.0002341509,
0.0210053381,
0.0336832032,
0.0120836841,
-0.0172717012,
-0.0028007599,
-0.0243302882,
-0.0425491445,
0.0254721623,
0.0289790276,
-0.0467790291,
-0.0073251682,
-0.0102499416,
0.0149486894,
0.0029147363,
0.0125265298,
0.0120413583,
0.0237289835,
0.0095855435,
0.0121563906,
0.0012916967,
-0.0150753558,
0.0154774487,
0.0174651407,
-0.0082415445,
0.035823226,
-0.0322054997,
-0.0523906574,
0.0049690828,
0.0276272669,
-0.0393222533,
-0.0110694552,
0.0324979201,
-0.0180095807,
0.0111352289,
0.0863537863,
0.0020671776,
0.0586355068,
0.0656300783,
0.002654192,
-0.0140497852,
0.036701899,
-0.0592731833,
-0.0600578748,
-0.0796791762,
0.0209823307,
0.0568104796,
0.083673209,
-0.0785992742,
0.0217805579,
-0.0395741612,
-0.0330987275,
0.0199877229,
-0.0802370161,
-0.0224111564,
0.0451508388,
-0.0464741699,
0.0327762812,
0.0036238329,
-0.0302857347,
0.0589108653,
0.0395558178,
-0.0147965802,
-0.0126949232,
-0.0482717194,
0.0140210362,
-0.0003809968,
0.0342481881,
-0.0133478334,
-0.0307219345,
-0.0097215455,
-0.0569057949,
-0.0132142268,
0.04255151,
0.0011777411,
0.0287557226,
-0.0232605785,
-0.0096395127,
-0.0007378329,
-0.0466498658,
-0.039016977,
-0.0266251545,
-0.0113370921,
-0.0094899293,
0.0201923568,
-0.0577270873,
-0.0697592422,
0.0188618563,
0.0498014018,
0.0519572571,
-0.0164740365,
-0.0636996627,
-0.0138884438,
0.0260978322,
0.0241954029,
0.0201106183,
0.0445793234,
-0.0745969638,
0.0282789972,
0.0286186114,
0.0661456436,
-0.0704474151,
-0.0191388167,
0.0288192779,
-0.0021231952,
-0.0346608423,
0.0279805828,
0.0837302282,
0.0071587292,
-0.0328059532,
-0.0550233833,
0.0369257405,
-0.002797188,
-0.0432356484,
-0.0007441154,
0.0034891649,
0.0259425864,
-0.0015624041,
0.0546304658,
-0.0466144495,
-0.029799236,
0.001743319,
0.0537173823,
-0.0238684881,
-0.0414200537,
0.0122293942,
-0.078335613,
0.0102406787,
-0.0110545512,
-0.039898783,
-0.0469094589,
0.0112434691,
-0.0223225802,
-0.0775080472,
0.0031691347,
0.0159851965,
-0.0438484624,
-0.0047224523,
0.0206060912,
0.0184629578,
-0.0014806752,
-0.0211929139,
-0.0174508225,
-0.0183996595,
0.0704176202,
-0.011823873,
-0.0185224991,
-0.0084002092,
-0.0204211846,
-0.027034862,
0.0390610658,
0.0461976267,
0.0456386842,
-0.0427400693,
0.0071952399,
-0.0047647604,
0.0396885388,
0.0089881308,
-0.0367164686,
0.011719035,
0.0298597068,
-0.0438459963,
-0.0395992808,
0.0223536082,
-0.0373144783,
0.0506709442,
-0.0076970393,
-0.0367092639,
-0.0337366536,
-0.0781665817,
-0.0077486401,
-0.0174763389,
0.0177584216,
-0.0247030966,
0.0084794257,
-0.0230841637,
-0.0334830545,
-0.0289892666,
-0.0511631332,
-0.0201172847,
0.0925174281,
-0.0171262696,
-0.0802158415,
0.0475900024,
0.0682268143,
-0.0149752405,
0.0469283052,
-0.0316536725,
0.0146543514,
-0.0493752286,
0.0357859656,
0.012436863,
-0.0499645956,
-0.0436241999,
-0.0342793502,
-0.0502859503,
-0.0063338699,
0.0462842844,
0.0553173013,
0.0304872375,
0.0728123635,
0.0003817341,
-0.0055260672,
0.0963013694,
0.0016486148,
0.0029468406,
0.0195117034,
0.079345189,
0.0004294791,
-0.0091633694,
0.0071993158,
-0.0276388898,
0.0384455323,
0.0257202983,
-0.0347541198,
-0.0484915636,
0.0387816019,
0.044169195,
-0.0724920407,
0.0787604898,
0.0120151648,
0.0219577644,
-0.0011935126,
0.0398107022,
0.0822627097,
0.0102615096,
-0.0475140736,
-0.0300448649,
0.0369793437,
0.0228184983,
0.0224660523,
0.020776622,
0.0464263856,
-0.0401624441,
-0.0205822848,
-0.023672644,
0.0442798249,
0.0053395745,
0.0293349288,
0.005369449,
0.0477523468,
0.0081788376,
0.0315822586,
0.0374609679,
0.0609969497,
0.0582468845,
0.0320556685,
0.0213490389,
-0.0425630137,
-0.007733739,
-0.0946362987,
-0.0225310549,
-0.0278205331,
0.0176562779,
0.0250135679,
-0.0090521928,
-0.0206877012,
-0.046616625,
0.0201986674,
0.010415379,
-0.0096054366,
-0.0349447653,
0.0426600575,
0.0173712131,
0.0206697006,
0.0099053318,
-0.0056397519,
0.0812992007,
0.0217949972,
0.0524856113,
-0.0680316985,
0.0239461325,
-0.0336281732,
-0.0132049685,
-0.0059171235,
0.0244068019,
0.0275311824,
-0.0430587046,
-0.0285889748,
-0.013215105,
-0.0084805842,
0.0181171503,
0.0025100694,
-0.0750324205,
0.0225223526,
-0.0054964595,
-0.0085460451,
0.0080984356,
-0.0149862161,
-0.0264665391,
0.0222364794,
0.0239541288,
-0.0451602861,
-6.044721458e-33,
0.0324159749,
-0.029243106,
0.0353198238,
-0.0325939655,
-0.0329759791,
-0.0187346525,
0.003904759,
-0.0347058363,
0.0212171637,
0.0160867255,
-0.044434648,
0.033286918,
0.0273382235,
0.0205796398,
-0.0058742929,
-0.0592018329,
0.0419257097,
-0.0004506834,
-0.0541228205,
0.022240011,
0.0023635621,
0.0197855122,
0.0404152572,
-0.0325680673,
-0.0422652736,
-0.0159347598,
-0.0343889743,
0.0122839343,
-0.0170352384,
0.047491651,
0.0169559289,
-0.0367647484,
0.0021227414,
-0.0981593579,
-0.0172142461,
0.0049942913,
-0.0596633852,
0.0122686625,
-0.0744545907,
0.0019731265,
-0.0331288613,
0.0106150256,
0.0280526914,
0.0180584993,
-0.0092421686,
-0.0058488115,
0.0308204815,
-0.005280586,
-0.0185872614,
-0.0338304788,
0.0086673331,
-0.0008918956,
0.0052491203,
-0.0149125932,
0.0468184613,
0.0883484036,
0.0005718381,
0.0626103729,
-0.0392156169,
0.0445445217,
0.0305808131,
-0.0366578773,
0.0341060571,
0.0357517637,
0.0458467267,
0.0283134282,
-0.0117643112,
-0.0093197897,
-0.011727782,
-0.0610417277,
-0.0195604321,
0.0576298237,
-0.0402328186,
0.0339194015,
0.0542489849,
0.0135398852,
-0.0082216933,
0.0229379274,
-0.0062064892,
0.047385551,
0.0162331555,
-0.0065045594,
-0.0021857929,
-0.0081730494,
-0.0064057554,
-0.0434625335,
0.0313292071,
-0.0086009745,
0.0293406714,
0.0451234095,
0.0050980011,
-0.0080678938,
0.0293304902,
-0.0308510121,
-0.019559456,
0.0186087694,
-0.0068304404,
0.0315236375,
-0.0108202482,
-0.0226760637,
-0.0788751915,
-0.0607595369,
0.0104336012,
-0.0360212401,
-0.0006229749,
0.0245768465,
0.0103760287,
0.0410693102,
-0.0444389433,
-0.01023803,
-0.0231202692,
0.0554988645,
0.0430006571,
0.0228688829,
0.0878265277,
-0.0161524639,
-0.018085219,
0.0152530475,
-0.0384149812,
-0.0285562128,
0.0041413591,
0.0313598029,
-0.0121614486,
0.0136247622,
0.0029345695,
0.0192249678,
-0.0632225499,
0.0311642755,
-0.0294550657,
-0.0491147637,
-0.0041636676,
0.0346236415,
2.931e-7,
-0.0233161952,
0.02697796,
0.0290135145,
-0.0358397737,
0.0410897285,
0.0454981327,
-0.0053691138,
0.0122297034,
0.0072199372,
-0.0199969243,
0.0749619678,
0.0410366543,
0.0213046726,
-0.0053464118,
-0.0055779787,
-0.0501424596,
-0.0421987586,
0.0135108987,
-0.0182304177,
-0.0370824002,
-0.031022273,
0.0714139193,
0.0082037998,
-0.020510111,
0.0941953287,
0.0320175029,
0.0221220311,
-0.0257005226,
0.0327955559,
-0.0222449228,
0.0103597874,
0.0181239899,
-0.0267355219,
0.0113325482,
0.0027869381,
0.0491599217,
-0.0394020788,
0.0416801758,
0.0161818657,
-0.0048793219,
-0.0071916957,
0.0375838354,
0.0294384249,
0.0025447293,
0.0541526638,
-0.1366621405,
0.006685961,
0.0044587837,
-0.0290422514,
-0.0351189934,
-0.0120084146,
0.0201323777,
0.0137696434,
-0.0010498717,
-0.0103979614,
0.0420671366,
0.0074534956,
-0.051822532,
0.0059734182,
0.0583562218,
0.0109037152,
-0.0674490556,
-0.0468837395,
-0.0003359386,
0.0440528356,
-0.014897598,
-0.0399169773,
2.421003854e-34,
0.0155394329,
0.0289444365,
0.0273323003,
-0.0037812949,
-0.0175608713,
0.0051672678,
0.0334349312,
-0.0265746936,
0.0688397065,
-0.0274442881,
0.0146974437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08559v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08559v4 | Phenomenal Yet Puzzling: Testing Inductive Reasoning Capabilities of Language Models with Hypothesis Refinement | 2023-10-12T17:51:10 | 2024-05-22T14:35:15 | Linlu Qiu, Liwei Jiang, Ximing Lu, Melanie Sclar, Valentina Pyatkin, Chandra Bhagavatula, Bailin Wang, Yoon Kim, Yejin Choi, Nouha Dziri, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The ability to derive underlying principles from a handful of observations
and then generalize to novel situations -- known as inductive reasoning -- is
central to human intelligence. Prior work suggests that language models (LMs)
often fall short on inductive reasoning, despite achieving impressive success
on research benchmarks. In this work, we conduct a systematic study of the
inductive reasoning capabilities of LMs through iterative hypothesis
refinement, a technique that more closely mirrors the human inductive process
than standard input-output prompting. Iterative hypothesis refinement employs a
three-step process: proposing, selecting, and refining hypotheses in the form
of textual rules. By examining the intermediate rules, we observe that LMs are
phenomenal hypothesis proposers (i.e., generating candidate rules), and when
coupled with a (task-specific) symbolic interpreter that is able to
systematically filter the proposed set of rules, this hybrid approach achieves
strong results across inductive reasoning benchmarks that require inducing
causal relations, language-like instructions, and symbolic concepts. However,
they also behave as puzzling inductive reasoners, showing notable performance
gaps between rule induction (i.e., identifying plausible rules) and rule
application (i.e., applying proposed rules to instances), suggesting that LMs
are proposing hypotheses without being able to actually apply the rules.
Through empirical and human analyses, we further reveal several discrepancies
between the inductive reasoning processes of LMs and humans, shedding light on
both the potentials and limitations of using LMs in inductive reasoning tasks. | [
0.064462088,
-0.0075022709,
-0.0364900418,
0.0102581782,
-0.0667914599,
0.0406809151,
-0.0142345028,
0.0056699244,
0.0041697687,
-0.0273463074,
0.0602201559,
-0.0119243329,
0.0285479631,
-0.0220380817,
0.036444366,
-0.0296865311,
0.010842842,
-0.0366943367,
0.0814993382,
-0.0120847486,
-0.0144745633,
0.0387338661,
-0.0267469697,
0.0282157604,
-0.0167347398,
-0.0182231404,
-0.0024484242,
-0.0170559846,
-0.0360688791,
-0.0550493151,
-0.0263537373,
0.0507228114,
0.0238493066,
0.0249368586,
0.0000022848,
-0.0770160034,
0.0330983251,
-0.0343916491,
-0.0361010768,
-0.0063200342,
0.0373842157,
-0.0166903287,
-0.0020292168,
0.0270178523,
-0.0346252583,
-0.0250830818,
0.0294635203,
0.0433269292,
0.0242592841,
0.0625715107,
-0.0095790625,
-0.0447561033,
0.007565375,
0.0184837021,
0.0429189615,
0.0175227057,
0.028092891,
0.0199363604,
-0.0076818713,
-0.026195826,
-0.0004382753,
0.0058623995,
0.0612386651,
0.0062528681,
-0.0138662411,
0.0225428566,
-0.0521371588,
-0.0566575788,
0.0132714687,
0.0369453877,
0.0181682967,
-0.0630930141,
-0.0523655079,
0.020946905,
0.02438467,
0.0654826984,
-0.0433542505,
0.078060776,
-0.0584771149,
0.0068890564,
0.0681580529,
-0.0180881489,
0.0375672244,
0.0225454364,
-0.0346194766,
0.1315325201,
-0.015276717,
-0.0498661771,
0.0101594431,
0.0007666475,
-0.0175611265,
-0.0267591756,
-0.0203552302,
0.0274160188,
-0.0170896072,
0.0232444573,
0.0405544974,
0.0180944204,
0.0387803912,
-0.0291201416,
0.0271464977,
0.051120121,
0.0209471788,
0.056594342,
-0.038725473,
0.0161518734,
-0.0135988314,
0.0436951555,
-0.0334206261,
0.0234545469,
-0.0721396282,
-0.0427286215,
0.0063892985,
0.0054253596,
0.039324604,
0.0033776835,
0.0221190713,
0.0343394093,
-0.0169193856,
0.0075961952,
-0.069728218,
-0.0381076671,
0.0107505722,
-0.0318782888,
-0.0575226024,
-0.0168067235,
-0.0465251729,
0.0607413277,
0.0037340322,
-0.0424595661,
-0.0258133933,
-0.0153330592,
-0.0243796874,
0.0156565513,
0.0070163445,
0.0410452783,
0.0071502416,
-0.017376801,
-0.0500568748,
-0.0529186316,
0.0526715443,
-0.0404190756,
0.0215162318,
-0.0631294549,
0.0039374074,
0.048048459,
-0.0207464136,
-0.0400083736,
0.0048050918,
0.0325338468,
-0.0317863636,
0.0598893911,
-0.0300969686,
0.0467776731,
0.0366829298,
0.0044202339,
-0.0367087051,
0.0643968359,
0.0339856595,
0.0174232163,
-0.0177422427,
0.0136908572,
0.0503729284,
-0.0066657355,
-0.0067731515,
-0.0010091714,
-0.0275308304,
-0.0081318347,
-0.0239883084,
0.0363181308,
-0.0165219307,
0.0279153548,
-0.0156851038,
0.01908198,
0.0558367781,
0.0743071511,
0.0068228068,
0.0171588045,
0.0675252527,
-0.0165408161,
0.025550779,
-0.016877763,
-0.0533564053,
0.0067197769,
-0.0282203555,
0.0009799188,
-0.0415243767,
0.0083117886,
-0.0072694863,
-0.0616479069,
-0.0393301323,
0.0405474976,
0.0410593599,
0.0119014047,
0.0715852752,
0.0481808409,
-0.0250472967,
0.0254801363,
0.0403167978,
-0.0354565755,
-0.0266903993,
-0.0420439057,
0.0651149675,
0.0969046503,
0.0560913049,
-0.0146849267,
0.0126149189,
-0.0098395981,
0.0678171292,
0.0430660211,
0.0419123396,
-0.0037148355,
-0.0352296419,
-0.0174732152,
-0.0063324533,
-0.0151861226,
0.0113640223,
0.0159506388,
-0.0116874548,
-0.051093895,
-0.0137518644,
-0.0132432124,
-0.0158024337,
0.0669316947,
-0.0113924118,
0.0195641629,
-0.0435275622,
0.0113161281,
-0.0187454335,
-0.0125595899,
0.0206637923,
0.0301234517,
0.0185199529,
-0.0399170406,
-0.0363928378,
0.0388453342,
-0.0052467966,
-0.0175147094,
0.0304234363,
-0.0635936484,
-0.0124867558,
-0.0120117394,
0.0023270659,
0.0098125786,
0.0393032469,
-0.0603709258,
0.0310756918,
-0.0173450653,
0.026762886,
-0.0368185379,
-0.0247620307,
-0.0306078978,
0.070227012,
-0.0026046503,
-0.0088998498,
0.016703885,
-0.005437992,
-0.0135303,
-0.0229966566,
0.0165129993,
-0.00847321,
-0.0138804717,
-0.0280251876,
0.020784812,
-0.011070176,
-0.0399330631,
-0.0137075242,
-0.0459842421,
-0.0228973795,
-0.0112679489,
-0.0092885392,
-0.0034473732,
-0.034467712,
0.0015684298,
0.0052525843,
0.0219802763,
-0.0248622317,
-0.0151635231,
0.0603415631,
0.036892917,
-0.0344350152,
-0.0510140136,
0.0144040128,
-0.0043484047,
-0.071376875,
0.0671176016,
0.057442192,
0.0257232003,
-0.0673303977,
0.0073252986,
-0.0216238573,
-0.033427123,
-0.0323535874,
-0.0050522867,
0.0585331321,
-0.0166830719,
0.0017997456,
0.0627578273,
0.0092193363,
0.0347639732,
0.0400749743,
-0.0025617483,
-0.036090631,
-0.0065840804,
-0.0273876749,
0.0426214226,
-0.0128317308,
-0.0416838676,
-0.0376147218,
0.0456996448,
0.0170116238,
0.0165270958,
-0.0619853772,
0.0819237977,
0.0055795931,
-0.0115752174,
-0.056492433,
-0.0494313389,
0.0020856455,
0.0662577599,
-0.0401944704,
-0.0711864904,
0.0835709497,
0.0101620285,
-0.0098652411,
-0.0428970866,
0.0002553009,
-0.0369564034,
0.0575980544,
0.0056832195,
-0.0132844094,
0.0105430912,
0.0032792361,
-0.028376257,
0.0217293501,
0.0263046846,
-0.0121820103,
0.0430352688,
-0.052132111,
-0.0191654861,
0.0324029587,
-0.0059539224,
-0.0502192192,
-0.0286336243,
-0.0264908932,
-0.0064497627,
-0.0031672013,
0.0337383822,
-0.0112035032,
0.0121888295,
0.0258239917,
0.0010194947,
0.0361096635,
-0.0550797209,
-0.0048054694,
-0.0911002383,
-0.0071516307,
-0.0156476907,
0.0383560658,
-0.0022184092,
0.0564835072,
0.028258089,
0.0099579487,
0.0098831486,
-0.046270337,
0.0769789591,
-0.0178809315,
-0.0143751744,
-0.0111780325,
0.0386576094,
0.0090567609,
-0.069599472,
0.0243834313,
0.1202221885,
0.0470561646,
-0.0000325961,
0.0308801252,
-0.0397037677,
0.0241754428,
0.0423797555,
0.0085059153,
-0.0970512405,
-0.0075020096,
0.0336951353,
-0.0220886599,
-0.0181013122,
-0.0398100242,
-0.0226984322,
-0.0647153258,
0.0283011571,
0.0153547861,
-0.0232044272,
0.0124921734,
-0.0755576491,
-0.0256673656,
-0.013457872,
-0.0445480496,
0.0524880253,
-0.0127459094,
0.020709537,
0.0098678349,
-0.0289478619,
-0.0232256595,
0.0280567296,
-0.0013729448,
0.0088482089,
0.0261865743,
-0.0042204899,
0.0010629205,
-0.0479038954,
-0.0019025316,
0.0221908893,
0.0293404981,
-0.0342542827,
0.0132241827,
0.038774319,
0.0347535089,
-0.0320612453,
0.0207391642,
-0.0708280876,
-0.0643842369,
0.0355959348,
0.1005558148,
-0.032446865,
-0.0330089405,
0.0059734317,
0.0266775265,
-0.0371062756,
0.0897042602,
0.026386166,
-0.005719,
-0.0097966157,
-0.0402448103,
-0.015395496,
0.001143474,
-0.046061635,
0.0071526421,
0.0449741222,
-0.02002717,
-0.0611938015,
-0.03536525,
0.0331480876,
0.0054973457,
0.0255026966,
0.0170662403,
0.017141277,
-0.0162828714,
-0.0481509604,
0.0569882207,
-0.0058033331,
0.0021669667,
-0.0050729671,
-0.0135853784,
-0.062702857,
-0.0733315274,
-0.0121644288,
0.0098675368,
-0.000407098,
-0.0679257959,
0.0198939182,
0.011163895,
0.0250854716,
0.0204107855,
-0.0068016914,
-0.0344771072,
0.0025032754,
-0.002511011,
-0.0034796174,
-0.0016631624,
0.026704412,
-0.0096767824,
0.0302562453,
0.0312571935,
-0.0055460213,
0.0540158711,
0.0152231595,
0.0258844681,
-0.0268192366,
-0.0076472717,
0.0711986572,
0.0325005986,
0.0434069484,
-0.0190481897,
-0.0366339907,
-0.0193110611,
-0.0044654207,
-0.0110943979,
-0.0406530648,
-0.0255290922,
0.0236755125,
0.0009264417,
0.0093849199,
-0.0222799461,
-0.0551578067,
-0.040750131,
0.0322871245,
-0.0051882272,
0.0081055099,
-0.0020208457,
0.053522829,
0.0095204748,
-0.0025787849,
0.0009182453,
0.0163256899,
-0.0610373914,
0.0361330323,
0.002129901,
0.0797824487,
0.0313045792,
0.0022735936,
-0.0812012702,
-0.0347542316,
-0.0617788993,
-0.0600385927,
0.0313696787,
0.0101561667,
0.0079187704,
0.002554788,
0.0072267223,
-0.053471487,
0.0243936684,
0.0218639039,
0.0183158871,
0.0040534157,
-0.0402718857,
0.033707127,
0.043399509,
-0.037045639,
-0.0078982795,
0.0374015644,
-0.0407876037,
0.0588108413,
-0.0105932159,
-0.0266286023,
-0.0250951722,
-0.0350510068,
-0.014663673,
0.0169856045,
-0.0072984737,
0.0224068072,
-0.0786589533,
-0.0251135044,
-0.0225991812,
0.0152406897,
0.0303408559,
-0.005274286,
-0.0076924297,
0.0869181156,
-0.0304670762,
-0.0674018189,
-0.0146093573,
-0.01264033,
-0.0426778868,
0.0040674242,
-0.0550917089,
-6.385800327e-33,
-0.0035243058,
-0.0072121131,
0.0500265099,
0.0311245415,
0.0177561883,
-0.03348675,
-0.0464853346,
0.0260926411,
-0.0009237913,
0.0591005832,
-0.0032149595,
0.0065585538,
-0.0021368389,
-0.0292615294,
0.024296619,
-0.0067708511,
-0.0018634133,
0.0205797367,
-0.0615491048,
-0.0285085719,
0.0215056427,
0.0028888439,
0.0090061687,
-0.0699091777,
0.0195089001,
-0.0068153376,
0.0092003746,
0.0463977121,
-0.0763511956,
0.0205367934,
0.0040646996,
0.0082471306,
0.049699828,
-0.0659137145,
0.0042366325,
0.0388402268,
-0.0222936179,
-0.022114614,
0.0608802661,
-0.0103951721,
-0.0060967295,
-0.0560563058,
0.0534234233,
-0.0111405188,
-0.0235224441,
-0.0064344099,
0.0492013954,
-0.0307410453,
0.0215621777,
0.0241009723,
-0.0865787417,
0.0177947264,
-0.0396660306,
-0.0207046717,
-0.0065484173,
0.0165900271,
-0.0454012528,
-0.0442525446,
-0.047348544,
0.0625261366,
-0.0055429456,
-0.0189214442,
0.0564517789,
-0.0326888934,
-0.0094822776,
0.0456801094,
0.0085364599,
0.0551337749,
-0.0412711166,
0.0173178781,
0.0128378384,
0.0520687923,
0.05245924,
-0.0049901311,
0.0165281165,
0.0129396785,
-0.0511996895,
-0.0206978228,
0.0335423127,
0.0304765031,
0.0482961871,
0.0188992955,
-0.0777876228,
-0.023701271,
-0.0433221832,
0.0330257751,
-0.0335214958,
-0.0527787544,
0.024869198,
-0.0042424235,
-0.0154197766,
-0.0348425917,
-0.0099570733,
-0.0100100935,
0.0151017169,
0.0197755583,
-0.0541208312,
-0.0170067027,
-0.008665638,
-0.0019232269,
-0.0355345272,
-0.0147049837,
0.0321101211,
0.0277302563,
0.0428011864,
0.0133172711,
0.0313296057,
0.0049501229,
-0.0095313182,
-0.0469282232,
-0.0550475754,
-0.0503650643,
0.028090965,
-0.046755787,
0.0244745314,
0.0575821176,
-0.0081620812,
-0.0222827531,
0.0336708277,
-0.0235267486,
-0.0529297143,
0.0308964886,
-0.0354410373,
0.002157555,
-0.0257277042,
-0.0290849525,
-0.0344279781,
-0.0080692703,
0.0312040951,
-0.0718557984,
-0.024056511,
0.0390527211,
2.958e-7,
0.0103280582,
0.118093729,
-0.016586205,
0.0258978736,
0.0225513577,
0.0159728136,
-0.0211177673,
-0.0611447878,
0.0610834286,
-0.0060619526,
0.0079812538,
0.0593023822,
0.0298940334,
0.0250979196,
-0.0557723418,
-0.0485802665,
-0.044439923,
0.0171869248,
-0.025611639,
0.0152608119,
0.0462019481,
0.0380217321,
0.0496152937,
-0.0119163962,
-0.0105903177,
-0.0619803444,
0.0464256257,
-0.0379206613,
0.0098606525,
0.0125533622,
0.0306601971,
0.0034967908,
0.028889738,
0.0654729828,
0.0171476994,
-0.0020765285,
-0.032845024,
0.0088641774,
-0.0232126489,
0.0351228826,
-0.015314674,
-0.0222802497,
-0.0041627795,
-0.0737592578,
0.0605609454,
-0.0620154962,
-0.0327418745,
0.0215903167,
0.0142985294,
-0.0306960475,
-0.0002559783,
0.0258486569,
0.016162701,
0.0119907204,
0.0164044183,
-0.0129669765,
-0.0070202737,
-0.0489128083,
-0.0427730381,
0.0203570053,
-0.0364363566,
-0.0393704996,
-0.0349758156,
0.0144166546,
0.0325978063,
-0.0404452756,
0.0133297658,
2.706396664e-34,
-0.0146735562,
-0.0093690325,
0.0324208736,
0.0360269919,
0.0555936471,
0.0085490122,
0.0050978973,
0.0504561178,
0.0422591418,
-0.0838908926,
0.0148368776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08540v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08540v5 | Do pretrained Transformers Learn In-Context by Gradient Descent? | 2023-10-12T17:32:09 | 2024-06-03T04:18:11 | Lingfeng Shen, Aayush Mishra, Daniel Khashabi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The emergence of In-Context Learning (ICL) in LLMs remains a remarkable
phenomenon that is partially understood. To explain ICL, recent studies have
created theoretical connections to Gradient Descent (GD). We ask, do such
connections hold up in actual pre-trained language models? We highlight the
limiting assumptions in prior works that make their setup considerably
different from the practical setup in which language models are trained. For
example, their experimental verification uses \emph{ICL objective} (training
models explicitly for ICL), which differs from the emergent ICL in the wild.
Furthermore, the theoretical hand-constructed weights used in these studies
have properties that don't match those of real LLMs. We also look for evidence
in real models. We observe that ICL and GD have different sensitivity to the
order in which they observe demonstrations. Finally, we probe and compare the
ICL vs. GD hypothesis in a natural setting. We conduct comprehensive empirical
analyses on language models pre-trained on natural data (LLaMa-7B). Our
comparisons of three performance metrics highlight the inconsistent behavior of
ICL and GD as a function of various factors such as datasets, models, and the
number of demonstrations. We observe that ICL and GD modify the output
distribution of language models differently. These results indicate that
\emph{the equivalence between ICL and GD remains an open hypothesis} and calls
for further studies. | [
-0.0075146817,
0.0526954271,
-0.001092758,
0.0600853302,
0.0119854324,
0.0106645618,
0.0145503283,
0.0159662832,
-0.0501258597,
-0.0466048308,
-0.1042555794,
-0.0190060791,
0.0172573458,
-0.057854034,
0.0562123507,
-0.0464117751,
0.0085679861,
-0.0237491932,
-0.0736595541,
-0.0150507595,
-0.0246509556,
-0.0460674763,
-0.016558392,
0.0415988602,
-0.0204434954,
0.0119661083,
0.0035975426,
-0.0130265206,
-0.0002342388,
-0.0210876558,
0.0153710824,
0.0196210146,
0.0379884318,
0.035637971,
0.0000021074,
-0.0622998141,
0.0181898568,
-0.0040890793,
-0.0346043259,
-0.0053199222,
0.0134090297,
-0.0051968927,
-0.0232054982,
0.0159728639,
-0.0675194561,
-0.0396584421,
0.0171374623,
0.0480642654,
0.0539491065,
0.0945071727,
-0.0028423304,
-0.0545892827,
0.0033832632,
-0.0315115675,
0.0144914687,
-0.0197489969,
0.0124594923,
-0.0286069661,
-0.0280194338,
-0.0221729632,
-0.0336512923,
0.0198792182,
0.0372697115,
0.0368847139,
-0.0517561436,
0.0719164759,
-0.003560069,
-0.0180610605,
-0.0164504144,
0.0479343124,
-0.0356299765,
-0.032912448,
-0.0163018778,
-0.0041022981,
-0.0066893934,
-0.0360074788,
-0.03862416,
0.0561149567,
0.031951312,
0.0514775962,
0.0100480607,
0.009636865,
0.0432380103,
-0.0248238202,
-0.029213246,
0.080976516,
-0.008340314,
-0.0397454984,
0.0107402029,
0.0127882306,
0.0022470227,
-0.058527071,
-0.0169262048,
0.0550412163,
-0.0068119825,
0.0366099589,
-0.0215293765,
-0.0234832652,
0.0033228928,
-0.0311096814,
0.0712443814,
0.0258205906,
-0.0365554504,
0.0078159738,
-0.0321812108,
0.0697513595,
-0.0441588275,
0.06509047,
-0.0309249647,
0.0321120545,
-0.027281085,
0.002873502,
-0.0276321433,
0.0196392965,
-0.0005436277,
0.0193386599,
-0.0466515124,
0.0543423183,
0.005160518,
-0.011052412,
0.0213254169,
-0.0263859238,
-0.0524131358,
0.0147342086,
-0.0281098355,
-0.0181039907,
0.0016747828,
0.0616691075,
-0.0066244849,
-0.0540881902,
-0.028090626,
0.0192224681,
0.0059270673,
0.0042469557,
0.0207678452,
0.0845156088,
-0.0215917621,
-0.0605988093,
-0.0373571217,
0.0141543699,
0.0110245319,
-0.0615126528,
0.0225832239,
-0.0680449158,
0.0191076845,
0.0327733047,
0.021357175,
-0.0535310581,
-0.0091850581,
0.0047470122,
0.0173914917,
0.0698218346,
-0.0154994726,
0.0170171801,
-0.0052642031,
0.0012264976,
-0.0301395692,
0.0453305393,
0.0027213066,
-0.0122076189,
-0.0050252308,
0.00667828,
0.0298168194,
0.0559992492,
0.0512678437,
0.0069151781,
-0.0065501514,
-0.0145502826,
-0.0204725079,
0.0293306932,
0.0353962667,
0.0367841721,
-0.0418269895,
0.0218088664,
0.0638771877,
0.0897682011,
0.0392307714,
0.0034395251,
0.0327875204,
-0.0368967094,
0.0417344868,
0.027949281,
-0.088286072,
-0.0331109464,
-0.0180215836,
-0.0013992252,
-0.019918941,
0.0011924923,
-0.0372173302,
-0.0442307927,
-0.0194677748,
-0.0367679037,
-0.0223123692,
-0.0211650934,
0.0494765453,
0.0605511069,
-0.0439733006,
0.054575365,
0.0284107141,
-0.04317059,
-0.0034334338,
-0.0842954144,
0.005941336,
-0.0362946503,
0.005314583,
-0.0247631874,
-0.0185722522,
0.0019671419,
0.0314288624,
0.0333083905,
-0.0064074122,
-0.0202842318,
-0.0032740855,
-0.0080139218,
-0.0110975606,
-0.0172929317,
0.0247458424,
0.0009217501,
0.0085399523,
0.002968241,
-0.0092038177,
-0.0413231775,
-0.012362957,
0.0731461942,
-0.0374822468,
-0.0247135926,
-0.0127288578,
0.0026411901,
0.0419416167,
-0.0174724963,
-0.0194780752,
-0.000152997,
0.0528966114,
-0.0188387483,
0.0035953471,
0.0303577278,
-0.0572722927,
-0.0631861687,
0.0398390777,
-0.0308225472,
-0.0013843522,
0.0382596739,
-0.0215673707,
-0.0326864645,
-0.0175809991,
-0.0162783451,
0.0993125439,
-0.0312946029,
0.0255647302,
-0.0163051896,
0.0106235621,
-0.0457232855,
0.059836559,
-0.0045955558,
-0.0050449036,
0.032322295,
0.0339718089,
0.0002069778,
-0.0011382469,
-0.0218793452,
0.0103598339,
-0.0252114478,
0.0339365751,
-0.0256859101,
0.0395317338,
-0.0226250682,
-0.0149947871,
-0.0752940625,
0.0050189323,
-0.0504873171,
0.0343629979,
0.0331346542,
-0.0393560231,
-0.0250209197,
-0.0126016922,
-0.0104263704,
-0.0037513759,
0.02034338,
0.0133995125,
0.0584956557,
0.0292156413,
-0.0058572269,
-0.0195549671,
-0.0139436312,
-0.0039190296,
0.0636302084,
-0.0164535549,
0.0261272509,
-0.0632473156,
0.0494785495,
0.0082073715,
0.0424222015,
-0.0351886898,
-0.0372620076,
0.0368123241,
-0.0018242312,
0.0413345546,
0.0547541082,
-0.0032989269,
0.0871209055,
0.0417831466,
0.0309947059,
-0.0509147309,
-0.0044306922,
-0.0412867106,
-0.0438204147,
-0.1014010981,
0.0122693982,
0.0228923149,
0.09367273,
-0.0158185344,
-0.0141476607,
-0.0215185471,
0.0211183857,
-0.0128835486,
-0.0241360981,
-0.00337951,
-0.0131111909,
-0.0563694648,
0.0581352785,
0.0213842262,
-0.0497955307,
0.0200481508,
-0.0313344523,
-0.0192670692,
-0.0188676845,
-0.0300196428,
-0.0362040363,
0.023898825,
0.0134145943,
0.004557108,
-0.001496892,
-0.0216306429,
-0.0755546242,
0.0217140783,
0.0277896188,
-0.0198467765,
0.0733778998,
-0.0167090353,
0.0066529852,
-0.0399857424,
-0.0348184742,
-0.082284905,
-0.0216074511,
-0.0060416595,
-0.0070163687,
-0.0002157277,
-0.0231428128,
-0.0098058032,
-0.0026507562,
0.0191036966,
0.0465200208,
0.0150003089,
-0.0275575612,
-0.0246177372,
0.0257761013,
-0.02751684,
0.0205952749,
0.0509231985,
-0.0514663272,
-0.0050292304,
0.0291422717,
0.0650317594,
-0.0184636526,
-0.0522323027,
0.0153060118,
0.0331385173,
-0.0391409434,
-0.0082751503,
0.0412614383,
0.0326024741,
-0.0306862723,
-0.0225054994,
0.0913385302,
0.0083576413,
-0.0809975937,
0.0135419285,
0.0251175966,
-0.0172230322,
0.0438631736,
0.0249544475,
-0.0572274961,
-0.0137430178,
0.0089401696,
0.0119364019,
0.0090017179,
0.0006125348,
-0.0121643888,
-0.1145341322,
0.0060962606,
-0.0188630912,
-0.0670630261,
-0.0088078752,
-0.0360722989,
0.001652405,
-0.0035122619,
0.0548104644,
0.0321365632,
-0.0444842838,
-0.0038667538,
0.0556841753,
-0.0010788867,
-0.0848941728,
0.0022226546,
-0.0295953583,
0.0219305269,
0.0628660843,
0.0146156102,
-0.0226034075,
-0.04867661,
0.0869852379,
-0.0256959572,
-0.000454491,
-0.0051379022,
0.0249939431,
-0.005875411,
-0.0294133332,
0.0045507443,
0.0341430232,
-0.038062416,
-0.0146199884,
-0.0246299561,
0.0506876446,
-0.0053804354,
-0.0479309149,
0.0005990771,
-0.034798786,
0.0062616947,
0.0355620906,
0.0251787677,
-0.0531805344,
-0.0228202809,
-0.0156549048,
0.0145208733,
0.0322326124,
-0.0916748345,
0.0387253836,
0.0138411978,
-0.0134263486,
-0.0536559336,
-0.0269014481,
-0.0295455586,
0.0718556717,
0.0146219619,
-0.0398274027,
-0.0149072418,
-0.004241195,
-0.0220117737,
0.0502698459,
-0.0049236268,
-0.000340608,
-0.084203288,
-0.0013068113,
0.0864818022,
-0.0399069227,
-0.0352087058,
-0.0225275215,
-0.0935505703,
-0.0601903573,
0.0260608047,
0.0627126694,
0.020666277,
0.0547765754,
0.0215823799,
-0.0382442884,
0.0891520754,
0.053068094,
0.0281191822,
0.0494259372,
0.0654493496,
-0.0312009268,
-0.0037484914,
0.0171754193,
-0.0441016592,
0.0308011156,
0.0379180796,
0.0058791093,
-0.0329309143,
0.0028160461,
0.0440022387,
-0.0123176128,
0.0812369958,
-0.0354825668,
-0.0305903908,
-0.0180010069,
0.0468645915,
0.0216684751,
-0.0063529513,
-0.039017126,
-0.041442845,
0.0026398618,
0.0504775345,
0.0041895211,
0.030397797,
0.0110967876,
0.0528040342,
-0.0134620732,
0.0289970953,
0.0279464275,
0.0026610498,
0.03451306,
0.0507017411,
0.016181292,
0.0208343137,
0.0042858967,
0.0325683206,
0.012658814,
0.01747513,
0.0322985649,
0.0028054642,
-0.0197279174,
0.0178694297,
-0.0864827931,
0.0017766557,
-0.0342881605,
0.0164785851,
0.067562297,
-0.0182574578,
0.0242050774,
-0.0379917249,
0.0109384805,
0.0080473321,
0.0085807526,
-0.038852822,
-0.0009751861,
0.0554522909,
-0.0070014321,
0.0097098481,
0.0223109107,
0.0755073577,
0.0017470376,
0.0466158763,
-0.001387196,
0.0458107814,
-0.0172908884,
-0.0376633815,
0.042297639,
-0.0187768657,
0.0056298287,
-0.0376765542,
-0.0198489111,
-0.0693572089,
0.0227845479,
0.0005609338,
-0.0127054024,
-0.0381498337,
0.0532352142,
0.0535133183,
0.0021903424,
-0.0009646275,
0.0081973542,
-0.0305139013,
0.0220325254,
-0.0133602675,
-0.0116684018,
-6.339085447e-33,
-0.0218310691,
-0.0292345192,
0.0286870394,
0.0363621153,
-0.0160033796,
0.0001338158,
-0.036017485,
0.0059493817,
-0.0256318972,
0.002702364,
-0.0466891378,
0.0119208246,
0.0153501816,
0.0185335781,
-0.0282947626,
-0.026187459,
0.020824248,
-0.0336328447,
-0.0090746712,
0.0009931973,
-0.0221547559,
0.0208722576,
0.0789369717,
-0.0553537048,
0.0063229785,
-0.0367399901,
-0.025119476,
0.0378132388,
-0.0414579101,
0.0532172807,
-0.0463203378,
0.041465424,
0.0166024715,
-0.0482706279,
-0.0353110693,
-0.016156191,
-0.042497091,
-0.0216143411,
-0.0250528362,
0.0530425943,
-0.0572568178,
0.006668028,
0.0752704442,
-0.0073868893,
-0.0713575408,
0.0142468289,
0.0309106912,
0.0137691768,
-0.0221828613,
-0.0525203012,
-0.0377995931,
-0.0031380462,
0.0253095124,
-0.0293550808,
0.0358333886,
0.009420082,
-0.0055118348,
0.0151654202,
-0.0614989921,
0.0126997279,
0.0194687843,
0.0171540659,
0.0657878295,
0.0341127664,
0.0032955282,
0.0369943529,
0.0470776185,
0.0099246502,
0.0030433885,
-0.0662968606,
0.0696815699,
0.0186001454,
-0.0075233248,
0.0277272277,
0.0317441188,
0.003174949,
-0.069738701,
0.0010272451,
-0.0141075691,
0.0055315853,
0.0139458291,
0.0140742743,
0.0000302589,
-0.0188164506,
-0.0462195501,
-0.0090127578,
0.0039977636,
-0.0140281413,
0.0176536292,
0.0261025261,
0.006589755,
-0.0180428922,
0.0175980106,
-0.0531178787,
-0.0452069901,
0.0125705227,
-0.0189266354,
0.0413151011,
0.0013843379,
0.0086386567,
-0.0405589342,
-0.0280386582,
-0.0367643647,
0.0223104879,
0.0341046415,
0.0032229098,
0.03632107,
0.0506746732,
-0.0531626157,
-0.0033538141,
-0.0238208342,
0.0104737831,
0.0314438716,
0.0277713574,
0.0570007786,
-0.0131086316,
-0.0206186343,
0.0409651622,
0.0271092262,
-0.0368194617,
-0.0381348617,
0.0320779346,
-0.0189291313,
0.0356913358,
-0.0364329405,
-0.0285402741,
-0.0234585628,
0.0741420314,
0.0341551118,
-0.0653606281,
-0.0162448306,
-0.0006496271,
2.783e-7,
0.0466055498,
0.0173599403,
0.0242266841,
0.0343539678,
0.0378306061,
0.0112181799,
-0.0666799024,
0.0168685056,
-0.0033326193,
-0.009851791,
0.0141075319,
0.026022613,
0.026605377,
0.0204320867,
-0.0578896552,
-0.0326822549,
-0.0643144622,
0.0252913646,
-0.0183685701,
-0.0107903136,
-0.0089481389,
0.0941838473,
-0.0087559577,
-0.0211463813,
-0.0219224989,
-0.0021791458,
0.0897662789,
-0.0314826965,
0.0473950692,
0.032599397,
-0.021232035,
0.0198264904,
0.0052352767,
-0.0024201274,
0.0012481073,
0.0296454839,
-0.0058517503,
0.032696519,
0.0093333405,
-0.0351554044,
0.009491072,
0.0262064897,
0.0119816829,
-0.0250265487,
0.0519928448,
-0.094957523,
0.0079886476,
-0.029442979,
0.0123763001,
-0.0335188024,
0.0160705838,
-0.0089721251,
0.0272024833,
0.0262191743,
-0.0005386766,
0.0033239163,
-0.0418920405,
-0.1003286242,
-0.0556907132,
0.0391482078,
-0.0378928892,
-0.0492811836,
-0.0205443352,
0.022805199,
0.0418345779,
-0.0268986262,
-0.0139666274,
2.483544286e-34,
-0.0015756546,
-0.0065450422,
0.0367899612,
0.0582327358,
-0.0320212208,
-0.0141240172,
0.0199941713,
0.003907558,
0.0396224484,
-0.0488610417,
0.0080112759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08535v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08535v3 | Formally Specifying the High-Level Behavior of LLM-Based Agents | 2023-10-12T17:24:15 | 2024-01-24T06:07:20 | Maxwell Crouse, Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Ramon Astudillo, Kinjal Basu, Soham Dan, Sadhana Kumaravel, Achille Fokoue, Pavan Kapanipathi, Salim Roukos, Luis Lastras | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Autonomous, goal-driven agents powered by LLMs have recently emerged as
promising tools for solving challenging problems without the need for
task-specific finetuned models that can be expensive to procure. Currently, the
design and implementation of such agents is ad hoc, as the wide variety of
tasks that LLM-based agents may be applied to naturally means there can be no
one-size-fits-all approach to agent design. In this work we aim to alleviate
the difficulty of designing and implementing new agents by proposing a
minimalistic generation framework that simplifies the process of building
agents. The framework we introduce allows the user to define desired agent
behaviors in a high-level, declarative specification that is then used to
construct a decoding monitor which guarantees the LLM will produce an output
exhibiting the desired behavior. Our declarative approach, in which the
behavior is described without concern for how it should be implemented or
enforced, enables rapid design, implementation, and experimentation with
different LLM-based agents. We demonstrate how the proposed framework can be
used to implement recent LLM-based agents (e.g., ReACT), and show how the
flexibility of our approach can be leveraged to define a new agent with more
complex behavior, the Plan-Act-Summarize-Solve (PASS) agent. Lastly, we
demonstrate that our method outperforms other agents on multiple popular
reasoning-centric question-answering benchmarks. | [
0.0068875966,
0.0151562598,
-0.0138774011,
0.0169944055,
-0.0290542375,
-0.0191383287,
-0.0219576154,
0.006081278,
0.0333127677,
-0.0168728568,
0.0418572351,
0.0478102975,
-0.0474774241,
0.0586296432,
0.0133616654,
-0.0336500593,
0.0493482687,
-0.0112961289,
0.0225121379,
-0.0259036757,
-0.0081624733,
-0.0172881503,
-0.0066922111,
0.0288997274,
0.0068389289,
-0.0370091423,
-0.0592802539,
-0.0214495063,
0.0044177659,
-0.0136379497,
-0.0296743158,
0.0056980364,
0.0125740673,
-0.0029522402,
0.0000021053,
-0.0606301017,
-0.0030006375,
-0.0026471023,
-0.0472920425,
-0.061014615,
-0.0410390794,
0.0079416586,
0.0008809317,
0.0258868709,
-0.0540515371,
0.0062506283,
0.0290234145,
0.0016123924,
0.0865116492,
0.0794943348,
0.0214983076,
-0.0106276069,
0.0441406071,
0.0258911252,
0.0570345782,
-0.0472604409,
-0.0094977086,
-0.0008913889,
0.0476738214,
-0.0241241176,
-0.0129398601,
0.0066698617,
0.0351157598,
0.0104461303,
-0.0094525209,
0.0182589237,
0.0135458689,
-0.0446768701,
-0.039874699,
0.0499105453,
0.0344050154,
0.0040209359,
0.0196959712,
0.0011400171,
0.0135987615,
0.0117711704,
-0.0371766947,
0.0482104644,
-0.0277046431,
0.0181505047,
0.0296022557,
-0.0048288237,
0.0131803732,
0.0037095395,
-0.0469117127,
0.0865598917,
-0.0111269411,
-0.0051179244,
-0.0300150663,
0.0066615432,
0.0338375941,
-0.0716160312,
0.0021875279,
0.0889302641,
-0.0461781174,
0.0312028322,
-0.0133096064,
0.0002720715,
0.0331519134,
-0.0142535586,
0.0243303552,
0.0628131405,
0.0303779878,
0.0351504534,
-0.0084214257,
0.0460243933,
-0.0171824396,
0.0373016596,
-0.0322638713,
-0.0109765539,
-0.0224791858,
-0.017247133,
-0.0101526659,
0.0849589482,
-0.0020081636,
0.0148612009,
-0.0131593402,
0.091287598,
-0.0084641669,
0.0284661595,
-0.0271578897,
0.0043678279,
-0.0023567874,
0.0035616644,
-0.0638894066,
-0.0004978816,
-0.0818386748,
-0.0172839612,
0.0275893249,
-0.0370641984,
-0.0088808089,
0.0066362261,
0.0067732232,
0.0317685194,
-0.0014022345,
0.0978388861,
-0.0165157337,
-0.0042434456,
-0.0324080512,
-0.0710036755,
0.0410761833,
-0.0426310673,
0.0158499219,
-0.0799252093,
0.0371675268,
0.0037668392,
-0.0319278613,
-0.0626137927,
0.0143770203,
0.0282479338,
0.0163742155,
0.0474246852,
-0.0252786819,
-0.0020734933,
-0.0102766687,
0.0143099735,
-0.0354532935,
0.0613778457,
0.0562001467,
0.0358578973,
0.0400401987,
0.0244297255,
0.0456025861,
0.044774428,
-0.0143101318,
-0.0099181533,
0.0428489596,
0.000434218,
-0.0568620674,
0.0486377962,
-0.0250751507,
0.0118742203,
-0.0288963486,
-0.0041792928,
0.0308083855,
0.0685606897,
-0.0100160008,
0.0174357947,
0.0193341784,
0.0175731201,
0.004030332,
0.0052684098,
-0.0341326222,
0.0650703162,
-0.056762848,
0.0274365395,
-0.0369215533,
0.0250172112,
-0.0218684953,
-0.0851617754,
0.0007444419,
0.0006982811,
0.0269212145,
0.0108369431,
0.0085065095,
0.0215349346,
-0.0435022861,
0.0280309338,
-0.0256462153,
-0.065313831,
-0.0053740614,
-0.0973079577,
0.0732669458,
0.062305443,
0.0725869238,
-0.0287856944,
-0.0524994172,
0.0304466132,
0.0299239345,
0.0625901595,
0.01365849,
-0.0184060019,
-0.0293063931,
-0.0277460329,
-0.0537680127,
-0.0191690754,
-0.0086273151,
-0.0038122383,
0.0096783722,
-0.0277735554,
-0.0422254838,
-0.0170904491,
0.0422809869,
0.0373231657,
-0.0034204593,
-0.0441182107,
-0.0045683179,
0.0209085792,
0.007116213,
0.0237225275,
0.0376063883,
0.0219429322,
0.0679468438,
-0.0048156451,
-0.0303922649,
-0.0004688812,
0.0027045365,
-0.0320072398,
0.0445872247,
-0.0333286375,
-0.0332995504,
0.0641991869,
-0.0464860089,
-0.0202540234,
0.0167097244,
-0.046046257,
0.0161433555,
-0.0234332271,
-0.0107102059,
0.0134959985,
-0.03051522,
-0.0135074295,
0.0533433743,
-0.0139287626,
-0.0446271412,
0.0079302182,
0.0317875966,
-0.0009856997,
-0.0212527551,
0.003855495,
0.0260361806,
0.0170018077,
0.0310136545,
0.0425362363,
0.039558664,
-0.0388074368,
-0.035396874,
-0.0129401777,
0.0094033936,
-0.0056453305,
0.0123351775,
-0.0049895551,
0.0257518273,
0.0225696173,
-0.0013573017,
-0.0593871288,
0.0572499074,
0.0354916863,
-0.0096674552,
0.0503907241,
0.0081290649,
-0.0914138108,
-0.014833211,
0.0079125222,
-0.0162361134,
-0.0163493976,
-0.0122260284,
-0.016568793,
-0.0593497306,
0.0192188192,
-0.0251528602,
0.027199395,
-0.0116495583,
-0.0132649979,
0.0695035756,
-0.0477449819,
-0.0273423381,
0.0539759658,
0.0034624974,
0.0322606564,
0.050551638,
-0.0086691193,
-0.0938846469,
0.040861696,
-0.0338164829,
-0.0231062155,
-0.0358228832,
-0.0255475622,
0.0182349049,
0.0592540354,
-0.0254717804,
0.0224960726,
-0.0559865683,
0.0399816222,
0.0499074832,
-0.0459478088,
-0.0036840981,
0.003168406,
-0.0442544706,
0.0447532199,
-0.0049990714,
-0.0352350697,
0.0900578648,
0.0007179405,
-0.0007297848,
-0.0062382971,
-0.0141812041,
-0.053383369,
0.0841191784,
-0.0138085531,
-0.0089295125,
-0.0040099006,
-0.0013545653,
-0.0276652034,
-0.0161583573,
0.0056317844,
-0.0369395874,
0.0642443225,
-0.0519132987,
-0.0111190043,
-0.0089584263,
-0.0404354222,
-0.0533154048,
0.0022229636,
-0.0215712003,
0.00631095,
-0.032812126,
-0.0043910756,
-0.0342690833,
-0.0306290183,
0.022259118,
-0.0348561443,
-0.0109128524,
-0.0302322637,
-0.0601035021,
-0.0190838985,
0.03642435,
0.0681420863,
0.0037710513,
-0.0098793497,
0.0433914065,
0.092237249,
0.0321128406,
-0.0353641659,
-0.0073952237,
-0.0046166945,
0.0542688631,
-0.0232705791,
0.0239478927,
0.0399525985,
0.0294854101,
-0.0587259121,
-0.0035096779,
0.08780846,
0.032238055,
-0.0123862401,
0.0168633945,
-0.0499453172,
0.0295650139,
0.0326152556,
0.0593237951,
-0.0787820145,
-0.0355362371,
-0.0001511428,
0.0680792704,
-0.0228874963,
-0.0276862904,
-0.0261122193,
-0.0679010376,
0.0260538384,
-0.0087367361,
0.0140317967,
0.0010261581,
-0.0318386778,
-0.0005668205,
0.024488857,
-0.0127165327,
0.0354366489,
0.0178103521,
-0.0191019196,
-0.0053018196,
-0.0329198688,
0.0399341621,
-0.0128308525,
-0.0288911294,
0.0369590968,
0.0756614432,
0.0154407844,
0.0008105029,
-0.0263662413,
-0.0067607346,
0.0152635304,
0.0182557087,
-0.0282988194,
-0.0255037248,
-0.0087666297,
0.0102943722,
-0.0241598468,
0.0302287098,
-0.055704087,
-0.030600924,
0.0284364577,
0.0954545066,
-0.0351822041,
-0.0144673372,
-0.0492597818,
-0.0052942801,
-0.0078776823,
0.0578735583,
0.001847269,
0.006259915,
-0.0712095723,
-0.0533178151,
-0.0344454013,
-0.085132502,
-0.0227158628,
-0.0067369943,
0.0012113241,
0.0224874299,
-0.060175769,
-0.0664608106,
0.0614329576,
-0.0112685142,
-0.0155048668,
-0.0123642571,
0.0119348448,
0.0132019483,
-0.0349875651,
-0.0268739443,
-0.0309633464,
-0.002986528,
-0.0038357673,
-0.026248198,
0.0284343287,
-0.0496129841,
0.0181652829,
0.0160553232,
-0.0098104868,
-0.0338429995,
-0.0110054985,
0.0729748979,
0.0216411166,
0.0125368992,
-0.0060242801,
-0.029486645,
0.0471884049,
0.0300510172,
-0.0205599442,
0.0321066678,
0.020984266,
0.0200329721,
-0.0041787536,
0.027150197,
-0.0809133053,
-0.0034282948,
-0.0339840129,
0.06533245,
-0.0649586394,
-0.0365321524,
0.0369081423,
0.0351771414,
-0.0696536973,
-0.0099140648,
0.0133775705,
0.0215261634,
0.0151564926,
-0.0151420683,
-0.0026379325,
-0.0346127152,
0.008148958,
-0.0448644012,
-0.0387133583,
0.0481113419,
0.026936993,
-0.0217551198,
0.0211496092,
-0.0109662488,
0.0458806381,
-0.0206910446,
-0.010493421,
0.007247048,
-0.0044201068,
-0.030579133,
0.0186654124,
-0.0058064531,
0.0354120992,
0.0062307972,
0.0368685722,
0.0231934749,
0.0101962173,
-0.0475579165,
0.0227585603,
-0.0679605752,
-0.0937772915,
0.0457233563,
0.0385114811,
0.033201132,
0.0822896436,
0.0185858533,
-0.0538838655,
0.0031068665,
0.0253749285,
-0.004409946,
0.0149075203,
-0.0344202407,
0.0085862223,
0.0471877158,
0.0268152095,
-0.0848599523,
0.038650807,
-0.0373770408,
0.0610121451,
-0.0566515215,
0.0104561169,
-0.0578358807,
-0.0612102151,
-0.0147783421,
0.0199834909,
0.0120077757,
-0.0472348742,
-0.0692641661,
-0.0267383978,
0.0084449919,
0.0495750532,
0.001832573,
-0.0345718898,
0.0468058102,
0.012229912,
0.0326727778,
-0.0664965883,
-0.019140346,
0.0096498653,
-0.0611675568,
-0.0157532822,
0.0227051284,
-5.467442059e-33,
-0.0390878767,
-0.0233957469,
0.0938795507,
0.0396635681,
0.0028416661,
-0.029990498,
-0.0691893324,
-0.0004896785,
-0.0024119816,
-0.0156797692,
-0.0293074455,
-0.0142375436,
0.0076307119,
-0.0210522227,
0.0036063103,
-0.0295516383,
0.0182920974,
-0.0215012282,
-0.0461990163,
-0.0168927237,
0.0229133852,
-0.0224960614,
0.0089485506,
-0.0215915032,
-0.0064689862,
-0.0089818602,
-0.0343198068,
0.0486681685,
-0.0467077978,
0.057102941,
0.0121388528,
0.038432613,
0.005839074,
0.0003526094,
-0.0238502081,
0.0419209041,
-0.0605349243,
-0.0609930158,
0.0144429924,
-0.0014075908,
-0.082387127,
-0.0498905331,
0.0228491966,
0.0131282471,
-0.0278070997,
-0.0003249307,
0.0176443271,
-0.0154392086,
0.0189846251,
-0.0350801982,
-0.0446177758,
0.0061435518,
0.0072347405,
-0.0187549293,
0.0076903524,
0.0130615588,
0.0240544658,
-0.0252721999,
-0.0039969562,
0.0377185829,
0.0247076191,
-0.019826198,
0.0702587888,
0.0253005959,
0.0073746047,
0.0612709187,
0.043893449,
0.0199171323,
-0.0365798734,
0.0340051316,
-0.0153522212,
0.0433696471,
0.0253664311,
0.0648648217,
-0.0125500234,
0.0195263568,
-0.0359863453,
0.0668771043,
0.0527623743,
0.0466955118,
0.0195991267,
0.0132698342,
-0.0419883169,
0.0004077132,
-0.0306597389,
0.0629518628,
-0.0088426499,
-0.0541961752,
0.0184807982,
0.0296778325,
-0.0312524922,
-0.0432477556,
0.010936073,
-0.0359453298,
0.0210450608,
0.0132644614,
-0.0059469999,
0.0248469803,
-0.0151553182,
-0.0152419992,
0.0204799399,
-0.0130727086,
-0.0177565273,
-0.0492169745,
0.0334016755,
0.0271365903,
-0.0511683524,
0.0389081575,
-0.0192063954,
0.0053292047,
-0.0598100089,
0.0148564167,
0.0336818695,
-0.045451425,
0.007926059,
-0.0080161206,
0.0004290337,
0.0041017528,
-0.0276471525,
-0.0355311334,
-0.0368469767,
0.0323757194,
0.0327337645,
0.0252753217,
-0.0310904793,
-0.0158287976,
-0.0529336073,
0.0550599322,
0.018062463,
-0.0548733249,
-0.0003693078,
0.0248179995,
2.731e-7,
-0.0007477345,
0.0099008344,
0.0285724513,
0.0858409032,
0.0139792915,
0.0410549119,
0.0086428374,
-0.001043901,
-0.0215162598,
-0.0611477122,
-0.0087354202,
0.0624140538,
-0.0018373755,
0.0353128798,
-0.0959082395,
0.0078961691,
0.0387583934,
0.000876365,
-0.028272545,
0.0092192022,
0.0734103397,
0.0076637575,
0.013341099,
-0.0152910426,
0.0027261195,
-0.0221634079,
0.0161641836,
-0.019737415,
-0.0015340107,
0.0408085622,
-0.0506306216,
-0.0246019568,
0.0123515837,
-0.0005786921,
0.0212378278,
0.0022775454,
-0.0363625363,
0.0877619684,
0.0145766297,
-0.0727608874,
-0.0087554697,
-0.0396244377,
0.0284833331,
0.0141393794,
0.0457011238,
-0.001460055,
-0.0125910975,
0.0085583171,
-0.0053745569,
-0.0295563657,
-0.0772127435,
-0.0276182033,
-0.0008317764,
-0.0005513933,
-0.0292789601,
-0.0164766312,
0.0062041529,
-0.0260905623,
-0.001193351,
-0.0309873447,
-0.0424035154,
-0.0636003688,
-0.0304466281,
0.0438392423,
-0.0095552746,
-0.0510372594,
-0.0337932296,
2.603603815e-34,
-0.0164950192,
-0.0029072261,
0.0114666875,
0.074560158,
0.0305488911,
0.0193225555,
-0.0144233899,
0.0301218107,
0.0757272616,
-0.0453251898,
-0.0466964617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08523v1 | LLM-augmented Preference Learning from Natural Language | 2023-10-12T17:17:27 | 2023-10-12T17:17:27 | Inwon Kang, Sikai Ruan, Tyler Ho, Jui-Chien Lin, Farhad Mohsin, Oshani Seneviratne, Lirong Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Finding preferences expressed in natural language is an important but
challenging task. State-of-the-art(SotA) methods leverage transformer-based
models such as BERT, RoBERTa, etc. and graph neural architectures such as graph
attention networks. Since Large Language Models (LLMs) are equipped to deal
with larger context lengths and have much larger model sizes than the
transformer-based model, we investigate their ability to classify comparative
text directly. This work aims to serve as a first step towards using LLMs for
the CPC task. We design and conduct a set of experiments that format the
classification task into an input prompt for the LLM and a methodology to get a
fixed-format response that can be automatically evaluated. Comparing
performances with existing methods, we see that pre-trained LLMs are able to
outperform the previous SotA models with no fine-tuning involved. Our results
show that the LLMs can consistently outperform the SotA when the target text is
large -- i.e. composed of multiple sentences --, and are still comparable to
the SotA performance in shorter text. We also find that few-shot learning
yields better performance than zero-shot learning. | [
0.0184537917,
0.0489158258,
0.0211808309,
0.0183410849,
-0.037842162,
-0.0001756092,
-0.0050775823,
-0.0108592054,
0.0339718163,
-0.0573712066,
-0.0545699038,
-0.0092350161,
-0.0115429694,
0.0100660194,
0.0060567432,
-0.0388782956,
0.0203666482,
0.0288674794,
0.0300550889,
0.0073845964,
0.0127983475,
0.0219510831,
0.0288610011,
0.0068368842,
0.0378616303,
-0.0151307108,
0.0002312846,
0.0007412007,
0.0137494914,
-0.0667895079,
0.0312900096,
0.0357161686,
0.031692151,
-0.0021679311,
0.0000021754,
-0.0621441528,
-0.0326758362,
-0.0076100235,
-0.0285876244,
-0.0008588982,
0.0584236607,
0.0611538179,
0.0461491309,
0.008196081,
-0.0306587331,
0.0011710082,
0.0460800156,
0.059320733,
0.0127264354,
0.0728562623,
-0.0044130725,
-0.026150845,
-0.0255687144,
-0.0562650226,
0.013341466,
-0.0180799272,
0.0169760585,
-0.063233465,
0.0363899358,
0.0312276315,
-0.0121949678,
-0.0088115456,
0.0106193582,
0.0007444044,
0.0513005815,
0.0488483831,
-0.0200438388,
0.0087589268,
-0.0212963037,
0.1094009653,
-0.0214426592,
-0.0330649503,
-0.0001416652,
-0.0293589421,
0.0009919973,
-0.0314267986,
-0.0282517597,
-0.0205019005,
-0.0073299082,
0.0359019227,
-0.0463931151,
0.0178882647,
0.014517623,
0.0077257748,
-0.0479668416,
0.0713406503,
-0.0199453477,
-0.0396113396,
0.0660411939,
0.0004466147,
-0.0231767967,
-0.0566888414,
0.044552356,
0.0179827232,
-0.0297672525,
-0.0128047774,
-0.0211455747,
0.0283761751,
0.0089936061,
-0.0484721325,
0.0827975273,
0.013305963,
-0.0290622748,
0.0550667383,
-0.0079708854,
0.079392761,
-0.0266985931,
0.0569506288,
-0.066772759,
0.050710395,
-0.0268022921,
0.0086540813,
-0.0259689204,
0.05996022,
-0.0060268505,
-0.0108922636,
-0.0624104924,
0.01787767,
-0.0014948712,
0.0439811088,
0.0424742289,
0.0787577182,
-0.0089708548,
-0.0032303252,
-0.0579301566,
0.0643200427,
-0.0009104998,
0.0186731704,
0.0094439061,
0.0234979577,
0.011931289,
0.0359552912,
0.0256511681,
-0.0416232161,
0.0323399939,
0.0668019578,
0.0115403263,
-0.0586753488,
0.0047337976,
0.0328849442,
-0.0566776842,
-0.0497357994,
0.0126279434,
-0.0681698471,
0.0306647327,
0.007797976,
-0.0247864015,
-0.0253036544,
0.0285351723,
0.0229054466,
-0.0373407118,
0.0807607397,
0.0565376468,
-0.0332766399,
-0.000058457,
-0.0273054186,
-0.0184909012,
0.0097589325,
0.0260124933,
0.0764277726,
0.0417080745,
-0.0083455443,
0.000455602,
0.0108796768,
-0.0088405376,
-0.0253348649,
-0.0351042524,
0.0493614823,
-0.0268814377,
0.0412276722,
0.0313529,
0.0503715165,
-0.0049333321,
-0.0432080217,
0.0965049043,
0.0310629196,
0.0458993949,
-0.02485561,
0.0139606968,
0.0784537047,
-0.0346214585,
0.0060952944,
-0.0511532687,
0.0332808681,
-0.0114340456,
0.0047581317,
0.0169743486,
-0.013447036,
-0.0237952322,
-0.0479264259,
0.0173278973,
-0.0423157848,
0.0359720849,
0.042038165,
0.0399116576,
0.0021866562,
-0.0714264512,
-0.0091038486,
0.0326980166,
-0.027949525,
-0.015031049,
-0.0348712206,
0.0385455079,
0.1078009829,
0.0267528705,
-0.0570684597,
-0.0237619542,
-0.030014962,
-0.0267117079,
0.003038676,
0.0450900421,
-0.0050301198,
-0.0093125217,
-0.0409318469,
-0.0084596546,
-0.0403759778,
-0.0143403802,
0.045838993,
0.0075689084,
-0.0055753975,
0.002249897,
-0.0141807552,
-0.0158009604,
0.0003073121,
0.0546283051,
-0.0545063838,
0.059955474,
0.0235635266,
0.0220157746,
0.0019209258,
0.0302861873,
0.0297615342,
0.0281170141,
-0.0211258326,
-0.0409171693,
-0.0067352559,
-0.0450344644,
-0.0495371819,
0.0222871192,
-0.0238783676,
-0.0274781939,
0.042039223,
-0.0472521819,
-0.0022721675,
-0.0314529426,
-0.0434956886,
0.0715303272,
-0.0002387363,
0.0267706346,
0.0141948508,
-0.019594077,
-0.0683717877,
0.0728611872,
-0.0051215906,
0.0121063069,
0.0079136193,
-0.0009762375,
-0.0167449638,
-0.0554374643,
-0.0183157083,
0.0088725276,
0.0137337521,
0.0076620895,
0.024511952,
0.0144576542,
-0.0256670825,
-0.015060951,
-0.0639810041,
0.0018654383,
0.0100811236,
0.0223184563,
-0.0135125779,
-0.0106601296,
0.0094903745,
-0.0058440473,
-0.0513618067,
0.0084688142,
-0.0267217699,
0.0162684973,
0.0386414081,
-0.0122452676,
0.0092514604,
-0.0674636811,
-0.0097887656,
-0.0111275865,
0.050348334,
-0.008939472,
0.0051126522,
-0.0311994571,
0.0384318717,
-0.0017955963,
0.0019649155,
-0.0085421884,
-0.031393785,
0.0061865887,
-0.0381013602,
0.0165737141,
0.1106954738,
0.0441012979,
-0.0026909329,
0.0694409609,
0.0168444943,
-0.0783551186,
0.0007012227,
-0.0620657019,
-0.0025140655,
-0.0190017261,
0.0076989629,
0.0294831339,
0.0672330409,
-0.0204017665,
0.0131274173,
-0.0484253876,
-0.0048580812,
0.0182373729,
0.0194078051,
-0.0271874685,
0.0051443814,
-0.0214397572,
0.0014147646,
-0.0138617968,
-0.0151076969,
0.0868994221,
-0.0079057859,
-0.0092252633,
-0.0448801145,
-0.0185295008,
-0.0721877664,
0.0193178281,
0.0572024137,
0.0126711717,
-0.018090494,
-0.0117660984,
-0.0552647859,
-0.0298320893,
0.0190482959,
-0.0232466292,
0.0611889064,
-0.002589297,
-0.0054449243,
-0.0126680294,
-0.0629842132,
-0.0494480915,
-0.061161302,
-0.0336107574,
-0.0041321637,
0.0214770287,
-0.0192268435,
-0.0196319446,
-0.0228411984,
0.012468338,
0.0300738681,
0.0021700524,
-0.0000134523,
-0.0028321045,
0.0503653698,
0.0407280847,
0.0312551372,
-0.0030930804,
0.0070272638,
-0.0146251936,
0.0526905209,
0.0234032627,
-0.0017654533,
-0.0449828133,
-0.0065613734,
0.0156710166,
-0.0585600697,
0.0029717272,
0.0002250401,
0.0103250146,
-0.0452896729,
0.0172351208,
0.1123213843,
0.0311296545,
-0.0813633725,
-0.0086949021,
0.0122715309,
0.0115665467,
0.0363612399,
0.0399133228,
-0.0588381104,
-0.0254604239,
-0.0245840177,
0.0377206579,
-0.0037095204,
-0.0047258241,
-0.0283067282,
-0.1293714643,
-0.0249956287,
-0.0167756714,
0.0023807569,
-0.0092645045,
-0.055567205,
0.0057602278,
-0.0103570865,
-0.0185228009,
-0.0194124077,
-0.0183198117,
-0.0292793512,
-0.0110317189,
-0.0275728814,
-0.0202875584,
0.0585418232,
-0.009859005,
-0.0247687176,
0.0518115461,
0.0206647217,
-0.0083901705,
-0.0288264174,
0.0396428555,
0.0105937766,
-0.0162609573,
0.0009214263,
0.022062188,
-0.0321980864,
0.0159428921,
-0.0225111432,
0.0229653567,
0.0101532089,
-0.0191707034,
-0.019675836,
0.0432417952,
-0.000040544,
-0.0456428938,
0.0142317908,
0.0245660879,
0.0059702317,
0.0555730574,
0.0281513054,
-0.0796430111,
-0.0385990739,
-0.053785868,
-0.0189063344,
-0.0635268688,
-0.0323221348,
0.0075714351,
0.0002464842,
-0.0027618154,
-0.0676135197,
-0.0081940386,
0.0172466394,
-0.0134295914,
-0.0027990949,
-0.0686122999,
0.0334495008,
-0.014352208,
-0.0610641278,
0.0392755233,
-0.0155433882,
0.0190853998,
-0.0874587297,
-0.0151616,
0.0593449697,
-0.0388571881,
-0.0267112218,
-0.0390496664,
-0.0599810965,
-0.0571784526,
-0.0261020567,
0.0789374039,
0.0098857665,
0.0483209826,
-0.0210455954,
-0.0274987575,
0.03899277,
0.0927440971,
-0.0196441952,
-0.02147137,
0.0507607684,
0.0441327654,
-0.0176441576,
0.0141547807,
-0.044143308,
0.0147174746,
0.0116071813,
0.0044216039,
-0.0334914215,
-0.0425293744,
0.0481503867,
-0.0072469972,
0.032093212,
0.0070810439,
0.0142818224,
-0.0305237956,
0.0445833243,
0.0180793069,
-0.0293052327,
-0.0172113515,
-0.0744219199,
0.0021865908,
-0.024608789,
-0.0319674797,
-0.0286304113,
-0.0333668478,
0.0154073332,
-0.0481190942,
0.0356482863,
0.0332631916,
-0.0127585866,
0.0388567708,
0.0112432679,
-0.0396911502,
0.0122145973,
0.0220777858,
0.0589828864,
-0.0031017736,
0.0467448421,
0.01873089,
-0.0249141417,
-0.0337110125,
0.0476100743,
-0.0300143864,
-0.0066185147,
-0.0262773428,
-0.0204118025,
0.0116579132,
-0.0547688343,
0.0059018806,
-0.0003638681,
-0.0266151447,
-0.0417123735,
0.0262573957,
-0.0515036508,
-0.039056167,
0.0303218849,
0.0208448824,
0.0006730363,
0.0306851566,
0.0685244873,
-0.0019942396,
-0.0056538177,
0.0287225936,
-0.030248167,
-0.0663834289,
-0.0261929967,
-0.0168613549,
0.0354762189,
-0.005713528,
-0.0095142946,
-0.0357921384,
-0.0455649532,
0.0474427678,
-0.0222974606,
0.007781371,
-0.013618594,
0.0475176051,
0.0057059317,
0.00414888,
0.0096785314,
-0.0201494843,
0.0526620336,
0.0032235933,
-0.019143682,
-0.0358617865,
-6.113548489e-33,
-0.0019365518,
-0.0683422089,
-0.0003634454,
0.0213307198,
-0.028685499,
-0.0181805026,
-0.0102357166,
-0.0115995547,
0.0080562532,
-0.0043898583,
-0.0161579363,
-0.0198654048,
0.0006946687,
0.0267591197,
0.0016297998,
-0.0631338432,
0.0314005427,
0.023829503,
-0.0383316129,
0.0123477289,
0.0346114747,
0.0374896191,
0.0561842732,
-0.0412610546,
-0.0116317738,
0.0199808814,
0.0207785908,
-0.0014788504,
0.012321352,
0.1023271084,
-0.001693945,
0.0437455028,
0.019367855,
-0.0008243786,
0.0305163618,
0.0849723592,
-0.0571117215,
-0.0168964248,
-0.0130152218,
0.0082989139,
0.0018519922,
-0.0353843383,
0.0220140256,
0.0044616144,
0.0285637006,
-0.0113274017,
0.0427994877,
-0.0176940039,
-0.0313823186,
-0.0012654902,
-0.0211168937,
0.0058487901,
-0.0056391824,
-0.0202265456,
-0.0099437367,
0.0806388557,
-0.0185794719,
0.1061450243,
-0.0541763864,
0.0351461098,
-0.0292057935,
0.0280039757,
0.0168705937,
0.0026838912,
-0.0066446797,
0.045088008,
-0.009388255,
-0.0301360171,
-0.0216127522,
-0.01422658,
-0.0071145445,
0.0546388365,
0.0281049851,
0.022398565,
0.0133524239,
-0.0029824721,
-0.0402803309,
0.0223610252,
0.0252089463,
0.0015752732,
0.0423856191,
0.0166236944,
-0.0091354456,
-0.0339696519,
-0.0053579574,
-0.0297238994,
-0.0714834109,
-0.0105709247,
0.0203261767,
0.0122391609,
-0.0306457207,
0.0136052417,
0.0193672609,
-0.0380723067,
-0.0438705869,
0.0155466367,
-0.0238992553,
0.0357557461,
0.0194140077,
0.0069928225,
-0.0858699828,
0.0126962662,
0.0032920353,
-0.011745885,
-0.0108349891,
0.0164747015,
0.0539907701,
0.0095133185,
-0.0639912039,
-0.0033325145,
-0.0222023726,
-0.0304894242,
-0.0362386368,
0.0333760493,
0.0374730341,
0.0463548303,
-0.0255441889,
0.0859698355,
-0.0145655395,
0.0107952151,
-0.0445311666,
-0.0210066773,
0.0155221522,
0.0504684709,
-0.0008393551,
0.0100160986,
-0.0026269276,
0.0755228847,
-0.0036507475,
-0.0399348848,
-0.0139430799,
-0.0061183507,
2.832e-7,
0.0335977785,
0.0573188886,
0.0097982045,
-0.0010962313,
-0.0050968998,
0.0323648341,
0.0229477808,
0.0337548181,
0.0127257127,
0.0099150063,
0.039082516,
0.0185416713,
0.0251182653,
-0.0142113902,
-0.1028626487,
-0.0058337674,
-0.0495493524,
-0.0154450806,
-0.0275812671,
-0.0404790342,
0.0587377772,
0.0865272507,
0.0489071347,
0.0072958157,
0.0031187627,
0.0112733487,
0.0667963028,
-0.0617100708,
-0.0038207353,
-0.0107014431,
-0.0122230528,
-0.0128175057,
-0.0604198053,
-0.0047391052,
-0.0183740575,
0.0168581754,
0.0042439187,
0.0660148561,
0.0165512841,
-0.1009443775,
-0.0011959907,
0.0167651642,
-0.0065421993,
-0.0464234129,
0.0833010077,
-0.1028280258,
-0.0127483234,
-0.0324176885,
-0.0377470106,
-0.0224291347,
0.0279747024,
-0.0321233012,
-0.0032829093,
-0.0119392863,
0.003899412,
-0.0305259731,
-0.0109846415,
-0.0903872699,
0.0012349922,
0.0310534276,
-0.0313456394,
-0.0188033581,
-0.0506720319,
0.0367661491,
0.0100017264,
-0.0196201485,
0.0019212645,
2.407776329e-34,
0.0370344408,
0.0051623783,
-0.0089169601,
-0.0305473879,
0.001516606,
0.0261076391,
0.0126844449,
-0.0046696682,
0.0661283955,
-0.0964662656,
-0.0010376727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08511v1 | HoneyBee: Progressive Instruction Finetuning of Large Language Models for Materials Science | 2023-10-12T17:06:19 | 2023-10-12T17:06:19 | Yu Song, Santiago Miret, Huan Zhang, Bang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI | We propose an instruction-based process for trustworthy data curation in
materials science (MatSci-Instruct), which we then apply to finetune a
LLaMa-based language model targeted for materials science (HoneyBee).
MatSci-Instruct helps alleviate the scarcity of relevant, high-quality
materials science textual data available in the open literature, and HoneyBee
is the first billion-parameter language model specialized to materials science.
In MatSci-Instruct we improve the trustworthiness of generated data by
prompting multiple commercially available large language models for generation
with an Instructor module (e.g. Chat-GPT) and verification from an independent
Verifier module (e.g. Claude). Using MatSci-Instruct, we construct a dataset of
multiple tasks and measure the quality of our dataset along multiple
dimensions, including accuracy against known facts, relevance to materials
science, as well as completeness and reasonableness of the data. Moreover, we
iteratively generate more targeted instructions and instruction-data in a
finetuning-evaluation-feedback loop leading to progressively better performance
for our finetuned HoneyBee models. Our evaluation on the MatSci-NLP benchmark
shows HoneyBee's outperformance of existing language models on materials
science tasks and iterative improvement in successive stages of
instruction-data refinement. We study the quality of HoneyBee's language
modeling through automatic evaluation and analyze case studies to further
understand the model's capabilities and limitations. Our code and relevant
datasets are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/BangLab-UdeM-Mila/NLP4MatSci-HoneyBee}. | [
0.0178297237,
0.0905604661,
-0.0122086946,
0.0300585032,
-0.0252690297,
-0.0170549955,
0.0238455068,
-0.0022008426,
0.0220662151,
0.0025435598,
-0.0404382758,
0.0175642949,
-0.0064749224,
0.0187840275,
0.0159495082,
-0.0212327354,
0.0431032963,
-0.0596951395,
0.0274426248,
-0.0247201882,
0.0199854467,
-0.0201146305,
-0.0139082111,
0.007237358,
0.0310860239,
-0.0297650583,
-0.0124248415,
-0.0328416564,
0.0277020056,
-0.0415980257,
0.038127169,
0.0792138502,
-0.0006327119,
0.0225709863,
0.0000023954,
-0.0547152907,
0.0127597935,
0.0474456884,
-0.007555624,
0.0430384055,
0.0492429137,
-0.064613916,
-0.0362370647,
0.0056631924,
-0.005889121,
0.0254194997,
0.0565704629,
-0.0061464952,
0.0593966432,
-0.0155764483,
0.0109758843,
-0.0007917325,
0.0517731272,
-0.0057025421,
0.0460904054,
-0.0044649807,
0.0207954831,
0.0595211238,
0.0794466436,
0.0553093515,
0.0058654677,
0.0425844528,
0.0241618939,
-0.0263957009,
0.0299276244,
0.0204645414,
-0.0603858009,
-0.0183832571,
-0.0154666062,
0.0832831338,
0.0292814653,
-0.0544696264,
-0.0382731408,
-0.0224102736,
-0.0448407754,
0.0225769989,
-0.0655985177,
0.0406012125,
0.0074710348,
0.0005654406,
0.0285224095,
-0.0107058501,
0.0162978191,
0.0434827395,
0.0113843689,
0.0677716136,
-0.0008129803,
-0.0238455366,
-0.0128655024,
0.0118621662,
0.0079608429,
-0.0253952425,
0.0072510187,
0.0384526961,
0.012794177,
0.0047780983,
-0.0149021093,
-0.0095277,
0.0742178634,
-0.0305910036,
0.0490827374,
0.0548392944,
-0.0096321516,
0.0409354456,
-0.0100416103,
0.0226975456,
0.0340200104,
0.0103633683,
-0.0335165039,
-0.0083073452,
-0.026450824,
-0.0239755381,
-0.033476416,
0.0018913493,
-0.0130769061,
-0.0082823578,
-0.0117427818,
-0.0016383599,
-0.023701515,
0.0358182117,
0.0086365286,
-0.037189018,
-0.0533109531,
-0.0034052068,
-0.0260108691,
-0.0071991957,
-0.0151665173,
0.0240424294,
0.0093677584,
-0.0834030211,
-0.0369446687,
-0.0111362441,
-0.0350636616,
0.0025347644,
0.0124409553,
0.0995012522,
-0.0140236877,
-0.0157916527,
-0.0121772438,
-0.0305543747,
0.008146123,
-0.0600267053,
0.0048978687,
-0.0659362897,
0.059777189,
0.0309588183,
0.0092922738,
-0.0557294786,
0.0140674617,
-0.0156739429,
-0.0020916229,
0.0749780387,
-0.0421283506,
-0.0523754805,
0.0187419094,
0.0260664914,
0.0304485317,
0.0497545041,
0.0384417772,
0.0268554501,
-0.0048795515,
-0.010766332,
0.00011859,
0.0136699639,
0.0215365142,
0.0178980492,
-0.014160648,
-0.0008619403,
0.013959677,
0.0469277985,
-0.0061975042,
0.0344638862,
-0.0188434068,
0.0213624295,
0.0470960401,
0.0294530969,
-0.003630965,
0.0178581625,
-0.0026695933,
0.0426058061,
0.0740988404,
-0.0369686596,
-0.0213073604,
0.0591283701,
-0.0066847941,
-0.0229434147,
0.0391160436,
0.0296357721,
0.0079694837,
-0.0680991113,
-0.041586142,
-0.0119870985,
0.0167259816,
-0.0225334615,
0.0447218604,
-0.0053438963,
-0.028914215,
0.0373196676,
0.0529255867,
-0.0835809857,
-0.0308554731,
-0.001986624,
0.0581862144,
0.0827655345,
0.041129306,
-0.0500795282,
-0.0733163208,
0.0167154316,
0.0210090633,
0.0342923142,
0.0286331102,
-0.0181013513,
0.0163447279,
-0.0524768308,
-0.0354336351,
-0.0220566336,
0.0104523432,
-0.0161095001,
0.0043450231,
-0.0305686221,
-0.0109206364,
-0.0133920964,
-0.0776533112,
0.0439170115,
-0.0511289015,
-0.014210213,
-0.0237971656,
-0.0304760914,
0.0374571942,
0.0076386905,
0.0311996378,
0.0099768545,
0.0717555657,
-0.0135202054,
0.0143911531,
-0.0434805416,
-0.0072929328,
-0.0192125533,
0.0542726219,
-0.0562561825,
0.0269077513,
-0.0065070447,
-0.0411783271,
-0.0166455433,
0.0227062572,
-0.0027993156,
-0.0060934131,
-0.0027038348,
-0.0004649709,
-0.0348542035,
0.0393711813,
-0.0397641025,
0.0068032038,
-0.0026893336,
0.0368095785,
0.0067230323,
0.0223082155,
0.0361026824,
-0.0281745493,
-0.0122916866,
0.0307583567,
0.0161370877,
0.0425887071,
0.0230617803,
0.0276250001,
-0.0423565172,
-0.046033565,
-0.0130106546,
-0.0054857056,
0.0095204618,
0.0151294023,
0.0370606594,
-0.0511302762,
-0.0125078857,
0.009262641,
0.0307497624,
0.0029398305,
-0.0126225986,
-0.0289608352,
0.0421830155,
-0.014251831,
-0.028592037,
-0.0418636762,
-0.0308678634,
-0.0232553259,
0.0351971723,
0.0246670488,
0.0223384574,
-0.0686378777,
0.0095315734,
0.0018838563,
0.0102613429,
-0.0167885944,
-0.067230165,
0.0318078883,
-0.0070148488,
0.0366829745,
0.0200620629,
-0.0251163691,
0.0483358204,
0.0698054209,
-0.0230948441,
-0.0385798849,
-0.0168148242,
0.0068035764,
-0.0055710534,
0.0355274789,
-0.0134260012,
0.0096486937,
0.0481579937,
-0.0401756838,
-0.0038119862,
-0.0199787077,
0.0570369028,
-0.0094975205,
-0.0133453021,
0.0492794216,
0.0021407828,
0.0236351658,
0.0122997286,
0.0111090345,
-0.0450429954,
0.0752748847,
-0.0705960393,
-0.0009945381,
-0.0617011189,
-0.0308874026,
-0.0126172248,
0.0200381018,
0.0053226505,
0.0181244016,
0.045810964,
0.0252174586,
-0.0274386518,
0.0129034501,
0.0220001098,
-0.025238961,
-0.0231487006,
-0.0670795068,
0.0264301468,
-0.0147621734,
-0.0222352315,
-0.0331491828,
0.0375415981,
-0.020006584,
0.0457117893,
0.0176056586,
-0.0470823422,
-0.0250011329,
0.0161744338,
0.0778325051,
0.0019254645,
-0.024837872,
-0.0067191492,
-0.047265958,
-0.005938428,
0.0061925505,
-0.013713141,
0.0343597792,
-0.0294785909,
0.0104463603,
0.0595329776,
0.0182965621,
0.0136940489,
-0.0672141835,
-0.0011436295,
0.0678784549,
-0.0044346093,
0.0177418273,
0.0037864051,
0.0424394235,
-0.0744541809,
-0.0138170011,
0.0527107492,
0.0178414695,
-0.0426057018,
0.0175910406,
0.0175246317,
0.0343355127,
0.0083683096,
0.0322145596,
-0.0878077149,
-0.0101040155,
0.003273258,
0.0290971119,
0.0029538465,
-0.0166727044,
-0.0240926482,
-0.0929200277,
0.0730812475,
0.0133668818,
-0.0557709187,
-0.0472800061,
-0.0767112896,
-0.0181587022,
-0.0023350965,
0.0115470598,
0.0533587821,
-0.0288388059,
0.0066218292,
0.0328144729,
-0.0137112197,
-0.1052926555,
0.0398934595,
-0.0063264556,
0.0528410487,
0.0133429728,
0.0010240391,
-0.0359953754,
-0.0259968564,
0.0460760035,
-0.0229861792,
-0.0334185138,
-0.0365845002,
0.0067310329,
0.0300629158,
-0.0209404714,
-0.0015078459,
0.0537409335,
-0.0360157602,
-0.0335399099,
-0.011706776,
0.1156665236,
-0.0289743841,
0.0289030448,
-0.0364050604,
-0.0218317062,
0.0214876868,
0.0467774309,
-0.010410808,
-0.0153116165,
-0.0616310425,
-0.0632694885,
-0.0235594548,
-0.0295804851,
-0.021692019,
0.0210025404,
-0.0280875303,
0.0025187479,
-0.0249818582,
-0.01310213,
0.051488556,
0.0152222905,
0.017618563,
-0.0091985716,
0.0337363854,
-0.0168730356,
-0.0507625751,
0.0254669543,
-0.0399979576,
0.0415172204,
-0.0588953495,
-0.043915879,
0.0370198637,
-0.0303383972,
-0.0222901832,
0.0544607453,
-0.0425671935,
-0.0694314018,
0.0010815448,
0.0681529194,
0.0290491544,
0.0050226292,
-0.0192443766,
-0.0926898271,
0.041887898,
0.0380715914,
-0.0668051839,
-0.0043183668,
0.0056730807,
-0.0044648778,
-0.0018528189,
-0.0177634228,
-0.0020163087,
0.0330218822,
-0.0198247172,
0.0159073342,
0.004078398,
-0.0698747411,
0.034875948,
0.0436989628,
0.0053477813,
-0.0013407596,
0.0077421311,
-0.026382003,
0.0035639761,
0.0122706844,
-0.0066567576,
-0.0373804681,
0.0419494621,
0.0249784477,
-0.0623088628,
0.0196636599,
-0.018244138,
-0.0027435289,
0.0561970845,
-0.0198260508,
0.0803505182,
-0.0305824596,
0.0214516129,
0.0826380476,
-0.0117721111,
-0.0242553577,
-0.0291583426,
-0.0567237251,
0.0524093062,
-0.0332844518,
0.0244691223,
0.034058854,
0.0417254604,
-0.0339911766,
0.0496242866,
-0.0396360196,
-0.0749427602,
-0.0678904429,
0.0184399597,
0.0126878917,
0.0515736192,
0.0493176803,
-0.0616462268,
-0.017650282,
-0.0302691348,
0.0631080717,
-0.0080851782,
-0.0305187143,
0.0522473902,
0.0282988884,
0.0130506018,
-0.0320047587,
0.0686262622,
0.0341060534,
0.0047014663,
-0.0258348864,
-0.0003847697,
-0.0430066735,
-0.027641153,
-0.048206985,
0.0017623227,
-0.0278972015,
-0.0374604277,
-0.0210202914,
-0.0395950004,
-0.0178255346,
0.0681444556,
-0.0200030822,
-0.0486435853,
0.032648243,
0.081963703,
-0.0149613768,
-0.0147208693,
-0.0058780997,
-0.0010264048,
0.017134333,
-0.0279369708,
0.0072004618,
-6.507070937e-33,
-0.0180344004,
0.0010499777,
0.030523546,
0.0539117157,
-0.0047141393,
-0.044164639,
-0.0570624694,
-0.0380658098,
0.0001316445,
0.027963005,
-0.0056216796,
-0.0099904453,
0.0171471778,
-0.0169998314,
0.0546527877,
0.0215773806,
0.0385651886,
0.0324784443,
-0.0433629826,
0.0331698507,
0.0167581253,
0.0206746664,
0.0851685628,
-0.0630465075,
0.0273346845,
-0.0012847419,
-0.0021734159,
-0.0446207188,
-0.0540340953,
0.0559799895,
-0.0399684832,
0.0380456373,
-0.0175529141,
-0.0336705446,
-0.0283043701,
-0.0155121591,
-0.0798214301,
-0.0381352529,
-0.0144704841,
0.0016166519,
-0.0297557674,
-0.0342484713,
0.0190230869,
-0.0035553959,
-0.0749253705,
0.0012504151,
0.0169213302,
-0.0484230034,
-0.0271613169,
0.014040282,
-0.0894952938,
0.0150885861,
-0.0106923431,
-0.0023342341,
0.0190167818,
0.0147195673,
-0.0074350247,
0.0347731225,
-0.0432459004,
0.0504330099,
0.0659472346,
0.0489600152,
0.0764579028,
-0.0165937636,
-0.0022444201,
0.015413424,
0.0225811135,
0.0215775445,
0.0381418802,
0.0100689568,
0.012954968,
0.053260155,
0.0579801798,
0.0260804575,
0.0325806737,
-0.014805642,
-0.0987377912,
0.0038443918,
0.0205675866,
0.0487852916,
0.0160067044,
0.0310618635,
0.0092890533,
-0.0439376757,
-0.0538835078,
0.0358467773,
0.0142335696,
-0.0121439537,
-0.0224356167,
-0.0023827201,
-0.069208093,
-0.0030605234,
0.0103089698,
-0.0413180776,
-0.0505754463,
0.0487814434,
-0.0440707095,
0.0248143617,
0.008099149,
0.0162097868,
-0.0984819382,
-0.0421371385,
-0.038471438,
-0.0128882332,
0.0555542409,
0.0102857137,
0.0031194084,
0.0498859212,
-0.0436858311,
0.0235727169,
-0.0724016353,
-0.0177146029,
0.0370998941,
-0.0007555913,
0.0076161469,
0.0009801957,
0.0039254795,
0.0431483015,
-0.0019579867,
-0.0105907237,
-0.0050174827,
0.0441086516,
-0.0181723591,
-0.0001223844,
-0.0228981767,
-0.0278027803,
-0.0762018412,
0.015032039,
0.0397749655,
-0.0526186861,
0.003861499,
0.0285538901,
3.066e-7,
0.0312224142,
0.0813217014,
0.0294653121,
0.0282701012,
-0.024240287,
0.0043088757,
-0.0535366684,
-0.0083711306,
-0.0120006222,
-0.0047328104,
-0.0230640043,
0.009735859,
0.0490667634,
0.0513107255,
-0.0520936362,
-0.0274663754,
-0.0281401556,
-0.035366144,
-0.0719544366,
-0.01766943,
0.018558545,
0.0524037965,
-0.0013969152,
-0.0322519429,
-0.0045210118,
-0.0409329869,
0.0529308468,
-0.0155052962,
0.0131211272,
0.0778827146,
0.0216725394,
-0.0139862997,
-0.0229051691,
0.0257079434,
-0.0188632905,
-0.0373286866,
-0.0234830976,
0.0523770601,
0.0150795728,
0.0381018855,
0.0377338789,
-0.0550203845,
0.0025970961,
-0.0317541175,
0.0255668722,
-0.0107381986,
-0.0032519314,
-0.005525528,
-0.0007342259,
-0.0142153287,
0.0177974608,
-0.0392172411,
0.0092395376,
-0.0002230392,
-0.0179693326,
0.0190447737,
-0.0223642513,
-0.0274309311,
-0.0301170517,
-0.0058944169,
-0.0367109366,
-0.0682142526,
-0.0267735105,
-0.0385564193,
0.0062822658,
-0.0424476527,
0.0063493587,
3.033778728e-34,
0.0464598797,
-0.0383669734,
0.045668669,
0.0241112132,
0.0166049097,
-0.0046361568,
0.0208449028,
0.0418099239,
-0.0095442329,
-0.0677388534,
-0.0085174562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08496v1 | The Uncertainty-based Retrieval Framework for Ancient Chinese CWS and POS | 2023-10-12T16:55:44 | 2023-10-12T16:55:44 | Pengyu Wang, Zhichen Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic analysis for modern Chinese has greatly improved the accuracy of
text mining in related fields, but the study of ancient Chinese is still
relatively rare. Ancient text division and lexical annotation are important
parts of classical literature comprehension, and previous studies have tried to
construct auxiliary dictionary and other fused knowledge to improve the
performance. In this paper, we propose a framework for ancient Chinese Word
Segmentation and Part-of-Speech Tagging that makes a twofold effort: on the one
hand, we try to capture the wordhood semantics; on the other hand, we
re-predict the uncertain samples of baseline model by introducing external
knowledge. The performance of our architecture outperforms pre-trained BERT
with CRF and existing tools such as Jiayan. | [
0.0398948304,
0.0562778674,
0.0038145264,
0.0273389257,
-0.027543366,
-0.0027684991,
-0.0270111393,
0.0520639233,
-0.0140344752,
-0.0740004703,
-0.0072894837,
-0.073675327,
0.0049979184,
-0.034872096,
-0.0192144141,
-0.0578741878,
0.0586569682,
0.0177709348,
0.0198334772,
0.0270487405,
-0.0080000935,
-0.0543341115,
0.0089728022,
-0.0148790032,
-0.0078313155,
-0.0079573561,
-0.0225006789,
0.0144199589,
0.0127769513,
-0.0257649198,
0.0019033579,
0.0131619228,
-0.0229462814,
0.0282518789,
0.0000015599,
-0.0498266257,
-0.0920674726,
-0.0031296238,
0.0060249763,
0.0227332674,
0.0254509374,
0.0684785694,
-0.0423585288,
-0.0248239432,
-0.0139103448,
0.0041561266,
0.0187653452,
0.0920250043,
0.017125668,
0.0880889744,
-0.0060388902,
-0.0147660933,
0.0244169161,
0.0087763174,
-0.0019529627,
-0.0552956834,
0.0153574124,
-0.0063110497,
0.0094843172,
-0.008279006,
-0.0146454666,
0.0157482196,
-0.0457704701,
0.0350313783,
-0.027991442,
-0.0081848288,
-0.0653451607,
-0.0024896034,
-0.0185957383,
-0.0068103126,
0.0290762577,
0.0054140543,
0.0031631475,
0.0313041545,
-0.0147096347,
0.0225772504,
-0.023456268,
0.0179345943,
-0.0509703271,
0.0238639098,
0.0421240777,
-0.0208320003,
0.0101550752,
0.0237686187,
-0.0725750625,
0.0816869736,
0.0438025407,
-0.0619725622,
-0.0153275942,
-0.0020684337,
-0.0422421768,
0.0130873201,
0.0226328634,
0.0305144172,
0.0007405935,
0.0510624349,
0.0169453658,
-0.0074940305,
-0.0325425044,
-0.0569435544,
-0.0458009951,
0.0213671625,
-0.0124278627,
0.0293222796,
0.0008133418,
-0.0072210357,
0.0437384956,
-0.0117090587,
-0.0418554097,
-0.008909855,
-0.0398920402,
-0.0212197024,
-0.0756276697,
0.0457753129,
-0.0235881712,
-0.0234469473,
-0.0394467786,
-0.0145994416,
0.011561634,
-0.0164196938,
-0.008008372,
-0.011909659,
-0.0138716195,
-0.0028342959,
-0.0510471351,
-0.0025950992,
-0.0221333541,
-0.0119206551,
-0.011698015,
-0.0305050537,
0.0044904333,
-0.002782983,
0.0080981571,
-0.0312373899,
0.0087909019,
0.0188790895,
-0.0228403248,
-0.0621949211,
-0.0521926768,
-0.0004157099,
-0.0666993633,
0.0001585073,
0.0251861513,
-0.0313844383,
-0.0218920764,
-0.0071292985,
0.0388571918,
-0.0091280425,
0.0223110486,
0.0112568187,
-0.0316454694,
0.0543605685,
-0.0316012129,
-0.0027309977,
-0.0090827942,
0.0182507411,
0.0317369215,
0.0269796457,
0.0811589286,
-0.010546458,
0.1084373221,
0.0528617129,
-0.0308264326,
0.0075385584,
-0.0423753671,
-0.0475995652,
-0.0789440349,
-0.0423817784,
0.0220293608,
-0.0279724207,
-0.0601530746,
0.062088117,
-0.0109383781,
0.0157272872,
0.0023449671,
0.0276030973,
-0.0016362577,
0.0264909733,
-0.0179833379,
-0.0235744491,
0.0472063161,
0.0593212321,
0.0036261585,
-0.0392183922,
-0.0245170761,
0.0403841697,
-0.0095781339,
0.0024559656,
0.0035670104,
-0.0538781248,
-0.0616581999,
-0.0072990153,
0.0277726203,
-0.025082618,
0.0982491001,
0.0018012426,
-0.0432353057,
0.0050063576,
0.037628293,
-0.0672607943,
0.024578305,
-0.0492372029,
0.0285947043,
0.0666540787,
0.0804852694,
-0.0999678522,
0.0366002582,
0.0575670376,
-0.0608674474,
0.0374087878,
0.0195561554,
-0.0236239489,
-0.0309958197,
-0.0555827133,
0.0003071699,
0.0227105245,
0.02494587,
-0.0222729892,
0.0230173841,
0.0290717129,
0.0122548854,
-0.046838928,
-0.018104529,
0.0586010218,
-0.0240472816,
-0.0101445671,
-0.0494437814,
0.0097102802,
-0.0088305911,
0.0425680541,
-0.0539146177,
0.0456489846,
0.0318740681,
-0.0275094174,
-0.0219808929,
0.0142894667,
0.0029659804,
-0.0425739326,
0.0756675005,
0.0084882947,
-0.0081119239,
-0.0235837717,
-0.0012631429,
-0.0567971244,
0.0166237522,
0.0194759574,
0.074430488,
-0.0640541241,
0.0670700446,
0.0158938561,
-0.0112466151,
-0.0572656281,
0.0907060429,
0.0108864289,
0.0610815659,
-0.0083760275,
-0.0381211154,
0.0240409281,
-0.0046444908,
-0.0862500444,
-0.0245172959,
-0.0008608005,
0.0055871643,
0.0366869308,
-0.0163730383,
-0.0151525466,
-0.0482327119,
-0.0664176792,
0.0414026529,
-0.0538068973,
0.0224607401,
-0.0218570363,
0.0149208242,
-0.019179482,
0.0111240707,
0.0085987523,
0.0317476243,
-0.0326150358,
-0.0115644392,
0.0310837124,
-0.0181077532,
0.0123939626,
-0.0318207331,
0.0015006372,
0.0048572128,
0.0192036796,
0.014086321,
-0.0580565259,
-0.0283213668,
-0.0054922998,
-0.0146347908,
0.0452647246,
-0.0204226319,
-0.0106963571,
-0.0132770333,
-0.05125314,
0.0158561487,
0.0050840261,
0.021926498,
0.0210945532,
0.00693047,
-0.0583435148,
0.041248396,
0.0182814766,
-0.0053531369,
-0.0242787227,
-0.0104995333,
-0.0073123788,
-0.0082096606,
0.0528744496,
-0.0014298387,
-0.0206909925,
-0.008429477,
-0.0709903762,
-0.0372969285,
0.0193278976,
0.0058359732,
0.0216476955,
-0.0581323877,
0.0169777051,
-0.0211772937,
0.0031934956,
0.0355359949,
-0.0197695848,
0.0182701275,
-0.0566797741,
0.0048358669,
-0.0335684307,
0.0281468183,
0.020295931,
-0.0035861162,
0.0227469634,
-0.0175082628,
-0.0621050522,
0.0260391105,
0.0355883092,
-0.0543187484,
0.0039129974,
-0.0048475727,
0.0019534174,
-0.004848938,
0.0427808054,
-0.0219408087,
0.0111682722,
-0.024656022,
0.0437958539,
0.0596183687,
-0.0050551081,
0.0354867056,
0.0605090521,
-0.0334230512,
0.0493172109,
-0.0059150355,
0.0148451077,
-0.0108871786,
0.0702703744,
-0.0005171211,
0.0154608535,
0.0095801661,
-0.0254529137,
0.0330215953,
0.0200394765,
0.0700982437,
-0.0302870944,
0.0159377884,
-0.011713108,
0.0322992355,
-0.0668697134,
-0.0388349406,
0.0035719143,
0.0018960607,
-0.0429358296,
-0.0198999047,
0.1098597795,
0.0741606057,
-0.0005782777,
-0.0248264242,
-0.0333469845,
-0.0452115312,
0.0162587315,
-0.0339983031,
-0.0438858718,
-0.0218542442,
0.0201730505,
0.0275661051,
0.035199102,
-0.0165903587,
0.0421036854,
-0.1037162244,
0.0395053215,
-0.0260609742,
-0.0053636055,
0.0060343109,
-0.0414174385,
0.009656501,
0.0128872888,
-0.0301209465,
0.0313585959,
-0.0151133528,
0.023040466,
0.0118843149,
-0.0331254601,
-0.0092364382,
-0.0293568373,
-0.0538156591,
0.0103401281,
0.0591575429,
0.0705062076,
-0.0382587016,
0.0093728201,
0.0070532113,
-0.0582441501,
-0.0074978992,
0.0122076562,
0.0581519939,
-0.0013697002,
0.0123152593,
0.0202891957,
-0.0219520777,
0.0138232829,
-0.0408456549,
0.0325717553,
0.0192922931,
-0.0000592784,
0.0283708461,
0.0118193217,
-0.0044921162,
0.0049089831,
0.0879779086,
-0.0288025606,
-0.0100009087,
-0.0107977949,
0.0223546773,
0.0324481688,
-0.0130098807,
0.0130029982,
0.0407506078,
-0.0757682547,
-0.0193127077,
-0.1240231469,
-0.042236384,
-0.0131833134,
0.0382364914,
0.0156989098,
0.0233335476,
0.0247686971,
0.0427951254,
-0.0825721398,
-0.0070790257,
0.0055395546,
-0.0067757037,
-0.0586267561,
0.0010552387,
0.0247702189,
-0.0225206669,
0.0113706114,
0.0565146059,
0.0013384717,
-0.0379213691,
0.0334134996,
-0.0074306312,
0.0129493913,
0.0065397439,
-0.0259712413,
0.0167028569,
0.0238709003,
0.0043052384,
-0.0180906635,
-0.0102865733,
0.0318097621,
0.025191851,
-0.0494041517,
0.0063870223,
-0.041921068,
-0.0288781412,
-0.0093440358,
0.0474837795,
-0.0235021487,
-0.0128473016,
0.0292324424,
0.0548894443,
0.0610946901,
-0.0551805124,
0.0132766291,
-0.0473188348,
0.0239610132,
-0.0479248539,
-0.0333672054,
-0.0204333868,
0.0176814087,
0.0287161563,
-0.0390201285,
-0.0395493247,
0.0636359975,
0.0259878468,
0.0229139477,
-0.0122175999,
-0.0090183532,
0.0334302336,
0.0222993381,
-0.0354184136,
0.0087805195,
0.0453259125,
-0.0035103164,
-0.0020838366,
0.0415174551,
0.0020619428,
0.0592180565,
0.0244022086,
-0.0238469224,
-0.0242500529,
-0.0159961674,
-0.0709324032,
-0.0425593331,
0.0001979757,
0.0528310463,
0.0206522215,
-0.033839535,
0.0466062874,
-0.0533636659,
-0.0385899357,
-0.0193743519,
0.0249512419,
0.0752211884,
0.0151947616,
-0.0277445316,
0.005303809,
-0.0215840824,
-0.0047206506,
0.039293848,
-0.0395653993,
0.0445889421,
0.0134328166,
-0.0795730129,
-0.026069887,
-0.004714021,
0.0302638803,
0.0223703235,
-0.0348378308,
0.0301892031,
-0.0743881017,
-0.0330960266,
0.0373163484,
0.0318693668,
0.0074417153,
0.0022714003,
-0.0005979798,
0.0641144887,
-0.0064625693,
0.0402832814,
-0.0621157996,
0.0018020341,
0.0116484091,
0.0031484594,
-0.0019871269,
-5.110693116e-33,
-0.0419200771,
0.0056666075,
-0.0031409373,
-0.0427600667,
-0.0031476007,
-0.0085180886,
-0.018035803,
0.0169335064,
-0.0013548636,
0.0116778072,
-0.0346423909,
0.0050226282,
0.0382446982,
0.0240481291,
-0.0322711654,
0.012323481,
0.0254065227,
-0.0069407993,
0.002288972,
-0.0500809215,
0.1235901266,
0.0531477928,
0.0789457336,
0.0088644102,
0.0472983457,
0.0044144103,
0.0142999655,
0.0494927242,
0.0552531518,
0.0237872098,
-0.0188158881,
-0.0170972254,
0.025280498,
0.0327365436,
0.0134511935,
-0.0222677551,
-0.1277561635,
-0.0284978598,
0.0059881206,
0.0543244854,
0.0250464063,
0.0664779693,
-0.0354643799,
-0.0010202543,
0.0544219054,
0.0312409382,
0.0510585606,
-0.0550911799,
-0.0173950363,
-0.0403419286,
-0.0448665731,
0.0739175826,
0.015456154,
-0.018157633,
0.0368068665,
-0.0217256434,
-0.0005072089,
-0.0103666857,
-0.0262005329,
-0.0329532772,
0.0245831348,
0.0441048667,
-0.0554146543,
0.0514168702,
-0.0327401273,
0.0370993502,
-0.0005527897,
-0.0541140214,
0.0022296174,
0.0090754172,
0.0406450704,
0.0157370344,
-0.0041965544,
0.0281444844,
0.0403733589,
-0.0093337242,
-0.0451689884,
0.0184659883,
0.054862082,
0.0146218855,
0.0258979276,
0.0119499126,
-0.0641686246,
-0.0034551497,
0.0071858158,
-0.0643133968,
-0.0154345073,
0.0268516541,
-0.0135699445,
0.0303641204,
-0.0562841333,
-0.0103134224,
0.0066254521,
-0.0370985121,
-0.0010879772,
0.0133668985,
-0.0283312071,
0.0170392487,
-0.0477275439,
0.001196609,
0.0006500886,
-0.0487096198,
0.0001257601,
-0.017070774,
-0.0634144917,
-0.0115233576,
0.0076350947,
0.0140455337,
-0.0370003432,
0.0242023692,
0.0101674488,
-0.0217831377,
0.0101505881,
0.0157968756,
0.0247817207,
0.0240225587,
0.0221424997,
0.0239369087,
0.062450774,
0.037896961,
-0.0104453517,
0.0024894429,
-0.0056149894,
-0.0287530422,
0.018235866,
0.0193742849,
0.0305242687,
0.0221336298,
0.0055834949,
-0.0429483876,
0.014532459,
0.0174733978,
2.449e-7,
0.0579638295,
-0.0280353744,
0.0582926646,
0.0376634859,
-0.0285203978,
-0.0087306947,
-0.0323696397,
0.0037239043,
-0.0224669613,
-0.0264736097,
0.0403663367,
-0.0012020874,
0.0414245762,
0.0254958495,
-0.0406907797,
-0.023062693,
0.0169767998,
-0.0425104238,
-0.0050204634,
0.0257571265,
0.0288334284,
0.0690724626,
-0.0015166918,
-0.0039931838,
-0.0397471003,
-0.0443360917,
0.0290830731,
-0.0017144433,
-0.0358942784,
0.0757454708,
0.0755617172,
-0.001109377,
-0.0143929729,
0.005741674,
-0.0244170614,
0.0715327859,
0.0614101999,
0.0242087152,
0.0103378724,
0.025437586,
0.016080603,
-0.0277697407,
0.0068200608,
0.0027065212,
0.0399359465,
0.0327012166,
0.0196174551,
0.006929555,
-0.0280703492,
0.0165758282,
-0.0115377111,
-0.0151868872,
-0.0207074173,
0.0416328833,
-0.0033408147,
0.0444643013,
-0.0042880592,
-0.0970094427,
-0.0062937685,
0.0066052405,
-0.0340287015,
-0.0602294467,
0.0513720624,
-0.0520008877,
-0.0185308773,
-0.095783174,
-0.0157345813,
2.125806917e-34,
0.0498121604,
-0.009980211,
-0.0862205178,
0.0508800559,
0.0359391086,
-0.0340564959,
0.0229573958,
-0.0022438404,
-0.0211875122,
-0.0362148024,
-0.012932146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08491v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08491v2 | Prometheus: Inducing Fine-grained Evaluation Capability in Language Models | 2023-10-12T16:50:08 | 2024-03-09T10:44:58 | Seungone Kim, Jamin Shin, Yejin Cho, Joel Jang, Shayne Longpre, Hwaran Lee, Sangdoo Yun, Seongjin Shin, Sungdong Kim, James Thorne, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, using a powerful proprietary Large Language Model (LLM) (e.g.,
GPT-4) as an evaluator for long-form responses has become the de facto
standard. However, for practitioners with large-scale evaluation tasks and
custom criteria in consideration (e.g., child-readability), using proprietary
LLMs as an evaluator is unreliable due to the closed-source nature,
uncontrolled versioning, and prohibitive costs. In this work, we propose
Prometheus, a fully open-source LLM that is on par with GPT-4's evaluation
capabilities when the appropriate reference materials (reference answer, score
rubric) are accompanied. We first construct the Feedback Collection, a new
dataset that consists of 1K fine-grained score rubrics, 20K instructions, and
100K responses and language feedback generated by GPT-4. Using the Feedback
Collection, we train Prometheus, a 13B evaluator LLM that can assess any given
long-form text based on customized score rubric provided by the user.
Experimental results show that Prometheus scores a Pearson correlation of 0.897
with human evaluators when evaluating with 45 customized score rubrics, which
is on par with GPT-4 (0.882), and greatly outperforms ChatGPT (0.392).
Furthermore, measuring correlation with GPT-4 with 1222 customized score
rubrics across four benchmarks (MT Bench, Vicuna Bench, Feedback Bench, Flask
Eval) shows similar trends, bolstering Prometheus's capability as an evaluator
LLM. Lastly, Prometheus achieves the highest accuracy on two human preference
benchmarks (HHH Alignment & MT Bench Human Judgment) compared to open-sourced
reward models explicitly trained on human preference datasets, highlighting its
potential as an universal reward model. We open-source our code, dataset, and
model at https://kaistai.github.io/prometheus/. | [
0.0471498519,
0.0238687117,
-0.0078654997,
0.0165206827,
-0.0450532809,
0.002931702,
-0.016310472,
-0.0044016289,
0.0032977622,
-0.05021514,
-0.0695909262,
-0.029416848,
-0.0080728149,
0.0288233142,
0.0185265429,
-0.0409833752,
0.0298078638,
-0.0138633093,
0.0337236561,
0.007930425,
0.0383633785,
0.0182976387,
0.0023253579,
0.0370227657,
0.0472612157,
-0.0580269061,
0.007596713,
0.0038110379,
0.0159747433,
-0.0308722612,
0.0304349661,
0.0787014291,
-0.0240855925,
0.0554529056,
0.0000021383,
-0.0331520624,
-0.01424558,
0.0108547471,
0.0043085907,
0.0706949532,
0.0812735409,
0.0435454287,
-0.0178130623,
0.0106790448,
-0.0435033329,
-0.0241643507,
0.0366997384,
0.0167992804,
0.0921040103,
0.0659636185,
0.0010630887,
-0.0031849712,
0.0261071771,
-0.0120750442,
0.0134555418,
-0.0355232097,
-0.0255150944,
0.016041711,
0.0242119133,
0.0277006198,
-0.0034539993,
0.0052837622,
0.0270310063,
-0.0288346931,
0.0359149128,
0.005469955,
-0.061339464,
-0.000333069,
-0.0139085893,
0.1046921983,
0.0175416786,
-0.0334840082,
-0.0259790402,
-0.0014144181,
-0.0027485779,
-0.0192627273,
-0.0414764844,
-0.011948227,
-0.0019603758,
0.0115585718,
-0.0139830112,
-0.0023740621,
0.0178929362,
0.0073443241,
0.0055503002,
0.0661258399,
0.0389333256,
-0.0567856729,
0.0282854736,
0.0011876068,
0.0050245193,
-0.0328369848,
0.0341995358,
0.0060207252,
-0.0444436893,
-0.0067059239,
-0.0389954895,
-0.0206794441,
0.053828951,
-0.018327767,
0.0446908027,
0.0240489021,
-0.0139649212,
0.028335942,
-0.0319180749,
0.1004004329,
0.0106155388,
0.0456031598,
-0.0657695308,
0.010533602,
-0.0427298397,
-0.0003248219,
0.0225850269,
0.0086086281,
-0.0228726901,
-0.0074421009,
-0.0951181203,
0.0023499096,
-0.0165835135,
0.0055900686,
0.0299831945,
0.0037465391,
-0.0084357904,
0.005374067,
-0.0400273912,
0.0551188402,
-0.0212311186,
-0.006319582,
0.0141319707,
-0.0139262872,
0.0239588618,
0.0333101191,
-0.0057079913,
-0.0296009462,
-0.0022104681,
0.0441210084,
-0.0108905574,
-0.0047858283,
0.0228239559,
0.0092295995,
-0.0303481687,
-0.0738470852,
-0.0184847862,
-0.0629986599,
-0.0040010116,
0.019020522,
-0.0069529042,
-0.0242524389,
-0.0008135766,
0.0449136086,
0.0055856351,
0.0382520445,
0.0187355373,
0.0102374041,
-0.0130787129,
0.0093183396,
0.0125113931,
0.0354515202,
0.0302575473,
0.0293292627,
0.0265067648,
-0.0394732654,
0.0079404321,
0.0436170883,
-0.0181498993,
-0.0140144788,
0.0171933174,
0.0212537441,
0.0032048232,
0.0311408117,
0.0073357713,
0.0579080768,
0.0060589318,
-0.0003556562,
0.088650912,
0.0391051508,
0.0438668132,
-0.0051111621,
0.0298504774,
0.0401689559,
0.0147807207,
0.0198000763,
-0.0416246168,
0.0160120241,
-0.027237542,
0.0255866237,
0.0510167927,
0.0140497684,
-0.0000677865,
-0.0754960328,
-0.0060863663,
0.0071448358,
-0.0003160089,
0.0077538267,
0.0464746431,
-0.0137418313,
-0.0670519099,
0.0179180671,
0.0199519396,
-0.0878136307,
0.023281863,
-0.0371264182,
0.0500591658,
0.1060521752,
0.0656159967,
-0.019198101,
-0.0197189413,
0.0138408523,
-0.0383478701,
0.0492147543,
0.0628291592,
-0.0121232402,
-0.0301042907,
-0.0814460143,
-0.0210738666,
0.0157077257,
-0.0026520169,
0.0189457648,
0.0312962346,
0.0010993615,
0.0292509012,
-0.0522095934,
-0.0895610526,
0.0286002178,
0.0205107555,
-0.0533172078,
-0.0177318193,
-0.0098562837,
0.0420338586,
0.0199046023,
0.0047583892,
0.031534303,
0.0165315606,
-0.0020565949,
0.0140120955,
-0.0404908508,
-0.0376349241,
-0.0051316009,
0.0387412831,
-0.038087558,
-0.0289502237,
0.0629054159,
-0.0274646543,
-0.0516061448,
-0.0051303902,
-0.0237623844,
0.0148620103,
-0.0450580828,
0.014521895,
-0.0179342981,
-0.0274920072,
-0.0757547319,
0.0237632375,
0.0268678032,
0.0268659666,
-0.0236987341,
0.0023620743,
-0.0026658541,
-0.0260236748,
-0.0637407824,
-0.0100755431,
-0.0095520299,
0.0446425155,
0.011836485,
0.0595259778,
-0.0665720701,
-0.043700628,
-0.1071542948,
0.0247882232,
-0.0135524273,
0.0352659896,
0.0238268077,
-0.0161314774,
0.0011689026,
0.027216468,
-0.057889536,
-0.0190965254,
0.0045523201,
0.0120844413,
0.0170956887,
-0.0016666637,
0.0117267258,
-0.0667215809,
-0.0326699317,
-0.021638656,
0.0087340353,
0.039303869,
0.0646730736,
-0.0398357287,
0.0330443308,
-0.0250702016,
-0.0115286503,
0.0286740325,
-0.0458497368,
0.0138152745,
-0.0108913351,
0.0478819944,
0.0567035601,
-0.0039068353,
-0.015566512,
0.0304954331,
-0.0023202319,
-0.0699375272,
-0.00144485,
-0.0128107965,
-0.0437027328,
-0.0193288997,
-0.0366336815,
0.0010273234,
0.0431628563,
0.0134837264,
-0.0080985455,
-0.0745779723,
0.0154998181,
-0.0387516096,
-0.0179253146,
-0.0227207877,
-0.0056454376,
-0.0262827128,
0.0246450957,
-0.0261882693,
-0.0605961867,
0.0941030681,
-0.0648665354,
-0.0204128046,
-0.0653680861,
0.0066946847,
-0.0430267565,
0.0414806902,
-0.0038180335,
-0.0032022158,
-0.0106885051,
-0.0108376304,
-0.0530424006,
-0.0029368778,
0.0050376076,
-0.068184644,
0.0689250007,
-0.0599418581,
-0.006783884,
-0.0068328795,
-0.026742965,
-0.019786818,
-0.0068097059,
0.0014731099,
-0.012275069,
-0.0005378517,
-0.0023197916,
-0.018803861,
0.0040179798,
0.0221078135,
0.0562291294,
-0.0592010915,
0.0109865135,
-0.0049628131,
0.0156532917,
0.0595476702,
-0.0169306956,
0.010320086,
-0.0373176932,
-0.0048603173,
0.0613210872,
0.0332505479,
-0.0066627297,
-0.0106218113,
-0.0161580574,
0.0225833356,
-0.0415412597,
-0.006036079,
0.0130614256,
0.0363239758,
-0.090825282,
0.0012035558,
0.1248747557,
0.0182225574,
-0.0613352656,
-0.0246627219,
-0.0417756625,
0.0466502383,
0.0162316263,
0.0362852141,
-0.0374456123,
-0.0305056851,
-0.0049309358,
0.0559391342,
-0.0097950697,
0.0098664174,
0.0152101824,
-0.1200722679,
0.0351668298,
0.0179043282,
-0.0262848809,
-0.0117194848,
0.0000561741,
-0.0008384414,
-0.0263786558,
0.0439218953,
0.035619285,
-0.0079920851,
0.0260760076,
0.0020632113,
-0.0397759527,
-0.0278194323,
0.0603115521,
-0.0191742461,
0.0287872609,
0.0875800475,
0.0362739153,
-0.0179106947,
-0.0596349202,
0.0340167247,
-0.0372986682,
-0.0208375063,
-0.0098762522,
0.0467934571,
-0.0030816731,
-0.0007796799,
-0.0548663139,
0.0181122087,
-0.0358890295,
0.029538922,
0.0351238027,
0.0692333579,
0.0119289057,
0.0022351821,
-0.0089986445,
0.0072052311,
0.0008898088,
0.067859523,
0.0298599135,
-0.0790802613,
-0.0643857569,
-0.0237845574,
-0.0062877196,
-0.0609684475,
-0.0525535047,
0.0201754011,
-0.0004764414,
-0.0104119247,
-0.0923953801,
-0.0634393767,
0.0202248599,
0.0052852854,
0.0177252814,
0.0155489659,
-0.0121392459,
-0.0100965565,
-0.0370933153,
0.0634101853,
-0.0161213614,
0.016827181,
-0.0876544937,
-0.0028714619,
0.0169937033,
-0.0104556167,
-0.021225689,
0.0480739065,
-0.0297467522,
-0.047610864,
-0.0246538538,
0.060653273,
0.0266683921,
0.0069200136,
-0.0234073699,
-0.0354791358,
0.0236953497,
-0.024612762,
-0.057480175,
-0.0038925414,
0.0141468048,
-0.0287739486,
-0.0173336454,
0.0160942171,
-0.0210552774,
-0.0011598076,
0.0327765718,
0.0475715101,
0.0277014934,
-0.0527932122,
0.0203532148,
0.0381080732,
0.0338212214,
0.0023334094,
0.0093180882,
-0.0273924116,
0.0343005881,
-0.0294549651,
-0.0111567471,
-0.03514174,
-0.0235705841,
0.0372172408,
-0.0295730047,
-0.0195343029,
0.0012131655,
-0.0445989147,
0.0483598709,
-0.0627420768,
0.0406724028,
0.0107246349,
0.0219873954,
0.0316074938,
-0.0186854135,
-0.0460056812,
-0.019173434,
-0.0112832021,
0.0630146414,
0.0037148516,
0.0720622838,
-0.0058381911,
-0.014662846,
0.0431650281,
0.0558343641,
-0.0328006223,
-0.0038614497,
-0.0239205509,
-0.0206087232,
0.0107181994,
0.0184387919,
0.0680616274,
0.001388914,
0.0009898243,
-0.0541129895,
0.0380703248,
-0.007278,
-0.0097637884,
0.0016758906,
0.0206317827,
-0.0055215084,
-0.0097363209,
0.074105233,
0.0016372942,
-0.0010078133,
-0.0146679673,
-0.0126439398,
-0.0536220111,
-0.0446978882,
-0.0108403759,
0.0170127433,
-0.042236805,
-0.0165323466,
-0.063806057,
-0.0588403903,
0.0118470052,
0.0521784164,
-0.0099500418,
-0.0327755697,
0.024386771,
0.0661162883,
-0.0594943687,
-0.0441663302,
-0.0534655675,
-0.0026634098,
-0.0254941266,
-0.0261542015,
-0.032102108,
-6.468134156e-33,
-0.0160820503,
-0.0152520267,
0.010037818,
0.0050881333,
-0.0398112983,
0.0094552357,
-0.0297599752,
0.0022612428,
0.0114409626,
0.002370724,
-0.0121268053,
-0.0184175037,
0.0152595872,
0.0290455986,
0.0341812782,
-0.0075952765,
0.0369902514,
0.0073415604,
-0.0336082727,
0.0474169254,
-0.0082235839,
-0.0009533773,
0.0497795083,
-0.0476295315,
0.0648610443,
-0.0015958323,
-0.0190346725,
-0.0125571247,
-0.0487112366,
0.0947392732,
-0.0001383374,
0.0474278927,
0.0264585204,
-0.0278002806,
-0.0044718683,
0.0379348956,
-0.041998554,
-0.0012689531,
0.0439983122,
-0.0116485152,
-0.0325919278,
-0.0260381214,
0.0559331886,
-0.0289114676,
-0.0231009685,
-0.0210945513,
0.0437416323,
-0.0311179832,
-0.0067222673,
-0.0003045252,
-0.0587448217,
0.0264755227,
-0.0129283285,
-0.0070118578,
-0.0117921885,
0.0765175745,
-0.023339076,
0.0404708348,
-0.0521949381,
0.0128197325,
0.0121842679,
0.0419890657,
0.0730186701,
0.0125343157,
-0.0141408034,
0.0374417938,
0.0031201029,
-0.0077189235,
0.0103112906,
-0.038628608,
0.0371592641,
0.0254686158,
0.0677173212,
0.0422011837,
-0.0195638295,
0.0159851164,
-0.0403265953,
0.0684204474,
-0.0034045759,
0.0307299364,
0.0484627411,
0.0086381966,
-0.0592089295,
-0.0039406023,
-0.0410770103,
-0.0009463888,
-0.0676949769,
-0.0407948419,
0.0530372299,
-0.0183761418,
-0.0136261471,
-0.0154912854,
0.0187650733,
-0.0096399589,
0.0062936917,
-0.0094212927,
-0.0204257444,
0.0480749272,
-0.029529931,
0.0278100651,
-0.0441528596,
0.0214218572,
-0.0005617083,
0.0099701164,
0.0186447706,
-0.0034836833,
0.0191047247,
-0.0123142106,
-0.0726339146,
0.0028153043,
-0.0272420868,
0.0148136001,
-0.0190557688,
0.022683423,
0.0195091758,
0.0066410033,
-0.0095907217,
0.062228892,
-0.0082309982,
0.0252151843,
-0.0605615079,
-0.0549134351,
0.0199913904,
-0.0029307986,
-0.0481233001,
0.0016708816,
0.0048093903,
0.0043045776,
-0.0122477477,
-0.0041063,
0.0118688587,
0.0293254163,
2.734e-7,
0.0424800478,
0.0781195164,
-0.0115270801,
-0.0165166426,
0.0082322694,
0.0354187936,
-0.0108744046,
0.0194740221,
0.0497105867,
-0.0169084053,
0.0183439031,
-0.0053946348,
0.0773371756,
0.013227365,
-0.0979040861,
0.0089134984,
-0.0434585139,
0.0078687705,
-0.0423965007,
0.0126674837,
0.089295499,
0.0835162997,
0.006713863,
-0.0078309691,
0.0098636216,
-0.0123739326,
0.0447988287,
-0.0361349881,
-0.0275147464,
0.0513791218,
0.0381637849,
-0.0015565698,
0.0005194622,
0.039386265,
-0.0060738376,
-0.0114033455,
0.0223335531,
0.1016196162,
-0.0065291338,
-0.032330364,
0.0037113896,
-0.0081029972,
0.0032953878,
-0.0952824503,
0.0605865754,
-0.0090802005,
-0.0225224514,
-0.006208844,
-0.0323155411,
-0.0287262853,
-0.002526595,
-0.0161619056,
-0.0143035641,
0.0339424722,
0.0084181977,
-0.0429301634,
-0.0153449262,
-0.0505149998,
-0.0451593511,
0.0228500329,
-0.0202205852,
-0.0592520013,
-0.0549379848,
0.0001492676,
-0.006438823,
-0.076913625,
0.0239975732,
2.648043012e-34,
0.0400390066,
-0.0182582699,
0.0504047573,
-0.01808572,
0.0355932526,
0.0370905288,
0.005694062,
0.0094722258,
0.0242217984,
-0.0829759315,
-0.0107740723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08487v1 | GraphextQA: A Benchmark for Evaluating Graph-Enhanced Large Language Models | 2023-10-12T16:46:58 | 2023-10-12T16:46:58 | Yuanchun Shen, Ruotong Liao, Zhen Han, Yunpu Ma, Volker Tresp | cs.CL | cs.CL | While multi-modal models have successfully integrated information from image,
video, and audio modalities, integrating graph modality into large language
models (LLMs) remains unexplored. This discrepancy largely stems from the
inherent divergence between structured graph data and unstructured text data.
Incorporating graph knowledge provides a reliable source of information,
enabling potential solutions to address issues in text generation, e.g.,
hallucination, and lack of domain knowledge. To evaluate the integration of
graph knowledge into language models, a dedicated dataset is needed. However,
there is currently no benchmark dataset specifically designed for multimodal
graph-language models. To address this gap, we propose GraphextQA, a question
answering dataset with paired subgraphs, retrieved from Wikidata, to facilitate
the evaluation and future development of graph-language models. Additionally,
we introduce a baseline model called CrossGNN, which conditions answer
generation on the paired graphs by cross-attending question-aware graph
features at decoding. The proposed dataset is designed to evaluate
graph-language models' ability to understand graphs and make use of it for
answer generation. We perform experiments with language-only models and the
proposed graph-language model to validate the usefulness of the paired graphs
and to demonstrate the difficulty of the task. | [
0.0213890355,
0.049817916,
-0.0046507856,
0.0439229086,
-0.040066272,
0.00580977,
0.0007720537,
0.0008658332,
0.0605308563,
-0.057614062,
-0.0149233909,
-0.0510152541,
0.0099032978,
0.0588715076,
0.0512408055,
-0.0162819996,
0.0139588015,
-0.0299111139,
-0.0173052736,
-0.0135542825,
0.0060985284,
0.0412995964,
0.0039677438,
0.0302953105,
-0.0210635867,
-0.0260219742,
-0.0160718616,
0.0436657891,
-0.0307040978,
-0.0214476138,
-0.0116035994,
0.0422633626,
0.0573145114,
0.0231263172,
0.0000016831,
-0.0076534003,
0.0243769493,
-0.0070139766,
0.0128446035,
-0.0118309176,
0.0313802846,
-0.034029115,
0.0440711677,
0.0060188249,
-0.0483168326,
-0.0428277887,
0.0507548526,
0.004766217,
0.0763509274,
0.0554563366,
-0.0215334948,
-0.0182081014,
0.0284272656,
-0.0048611043,
0.0265872516,
-0.0161270835,
0.0112886401,
0.0554377139,
0.0570244007,
-0.0383559391,
-0.0695919991,
0.0423595905,
0.0218168143,
-0.0182732046,
0.0127754007,
0.0249384232,
-0.0000879011,
-0.0117358183,
-0.0061008143,
0.1348318756,
0.0373377576,
-0.0226541702,
0.0038202726,
-0.0031087983,
0.0024340835,
0.0558561049,
-0.0624535307,
0.0099561615,
-0.0112180915,
-0.0049698185,
-0.0151813542,
-0.0434359722,
0.0441398807,
-0.0003036127,
0.0130238319,
0.0853889808,
0.0300728325,
0.0152281458,
-0.0126675665,
0.0228158012,
-0.040602088,
-0.0589352101,
-0.0199129395,
0.053599339,
-0.0248151384,
0.022280803,
-0.0672068372,
-0.0159621891,
-0.0082387812,
0.0268665329,
0.0242650807,
0.0090398081,
-0.003929805,
0.0337621346,
0.0087315841,
0.0268001091,
-0.0343122818,
0.0534085222,
-0.0707650483,
-0.0180419572,
-0.0340677835,
-0.0162198376,
-0.041480422,
0.0288662929,
-0.0175699033,
-0.0716030449,
-0.00770916,
0.0435408168,
0.015371196,
-0.0220963564,
0.036010325,
0.0404207222,
-0.0190728791,
-0.0175732747,
0.0153681897,
0.0552607477,
-0.0099879503,
0.0298159905,
0.0215212535,
-0.0281666201,
0.0094397962,
0.0143937292,
0.0614380576,
-0.0340496823,
0.0050043738,
0.0825730711,
0.0180581529,
-0.0158376005,
0.0190260615,
-0.0628262907,
-0.0340540856,
-0.0552728176,
0.0288609434,
-0.0922743753,
0.0539215431,
0.0471057743,
-0.0107837915,
-0.0311535057,
0.019516075,
-0.0007363747,
-0.0520023778,
0.0445512682,
-0.0394667573,
0.0489393324,
0.0275082681,
-0.0042601549,
0.0087114843,
0.0593729354,
0.0476314798,
0.0029424904,
0.0500051118,
-0.0118878279,
-0.0263834968,
0.0391849391,
0.0393130705,
0.0139881717,
0.0039303163,
0.006761794,
-0.0276031103,
0.0209283177,
0.0004934096,
0.051478792,
-0.0319954716,
-0.0353175737,
0.0675352141,
0.0281772073,
-0.0000503216,
-0.0294682402,
0.0280143283,
0.0209279917,
0.0012310997,
0.0401461758,
-0.027175501,
0.0487846136,
0.0096819997,
0.0510739908,
0.0366888642,
-0.0053051501,
-0.0369283818,
0.0135457655,
0.0080024898,
-0.0160716046,
0.0602694005,
0.0273697171,
0.0319159329,
0.0460309237,
-0.0602676012,
0.0555436537,
0.0212118663,
-0.0472687222,
0.0399696492,
-0.0153052052,
0.013711405,
0.0516135991,
0.0500423387,
0.016295338,
-0.043546252,
0.0113919424,
0.0363189578,
0.0292906612,
0.0146821234,
-0.035392493,
0.0086382646,
-0.0433325544,
-0.0189580768,
-0.0450615734,
-0.0166468024,
0.0072801933,
-0.0019630624,
0.0070303082,
0.002219259,
-0.1076164171,
-0.0193687845,
0.0016057092,
0.0035962365,
0.0142574375,
-0.0301443022,
-0.0062149381,
-0.023233816,
0.0275741201,
-0.0114231026,
0.0392457433,
0.014067878,
-0.0265833605,
0.0024353031,
0.0271948054,
-0.054044269,
-0.0684443489,
0.0480607264,
-0.05077485,
-0.0149980187,
0.0149450619,
-0.0282907411,
-0.0615429319,
0.0489202552,
-0.0870049521,
0.0290510021,
-0.0295509622,
-0.0159481633,
0.022904871,
0.0124624325,
0.0044610486,
0.0489342175,
0.0013700939,
0.0179679152,
0.0314171799,
0.029845478,
-0.0006169471,
-0.0486820526,
-0.011859199,
0.0431497507,
-0.0013684232,
0.0188558195,
0.0207723454,
-0.0058516203,
-0.0765219554,
0.0190738216,
-0.112365298,
-0.0074977088,
-0.024556756,
0.0118401833,
0.0281378813,
0.0261729732,
0.0072518722,
-0.0251249671,
-0.079260774,
0.0587313473,
0.060161747,
0.0373396687,
0.0179888811,
-0.0057999091,
0.0151828891,
-0.0193018839,
-0.0466700085,
-0.0035918308,
0.0772295967,
0.0251221731,
-0.0034188204,
-0.0158181749,
0.0498412661,
-0.0525982566,
0.0024575244,
0.0142402379,
-0.0090272631,
0.0210251696,
-0.0191080123,
0.0594965518,
0.0338392518,
-0.0186870378,
-0.0111723393,
0.0318994485,
-0.0495036319,
-0.0226116348,
-0.0202211514,
-0.0322191343,
-0.0142514361,
-0.0333713703,
-0.0449076518,
-0.0359606855,
0.0266506504,
0.0289879851,
-0.0028018407,
-0.0598709099,
0.0016309205,
-0.0145253446,
-0.0299830064,
-0.0490404591,
-0.0136021441,
-0.002365412,
0.0161856543,
-0.0507047325,
-0.0291646589,
0.0832606032,
-0.0279333163,
-0.0092685251,
0.0435967855,
0.01546429,
-0.0464240052,
0.0716606155,
0.0575795807,
0.0318260267,
-0.0242881328,
-0.0199537817,
-0.0589523092,
-0.0001793534,
0.0176119097,
-0.0488205925,
0.0165754464,
-0.0084607564,
0.0213780683,
-0.0047413409,
-0.0042403964,
-0.0121048596,
-0.0099182744,
-0.0229422003,
-0.0028042535,
-0.0076304995,
-0.0194571074,
0.0240244754,
0.0239127036,
0.0115868002,
-0.0144093921,
-0.0404482186,
0.0168184284,
-0.0286522992,
0.1114113405,
0.1045223624,
0.0162774734,
-0.0154085467,
-0.0687009916,
0.0010002007,
0.0511453301,
0.0397548266,
0.0020409098,
-0.0068273488,
0.024064377,
0.0083899787,
0.0265019555,
-0.0226425063,
0.007133876,
0.0782420114,
-0.0265775379,
-0.0072865859,
0.0723631606,
0.0144902226,
-0.0355447121,
-0.0015587573,
0.0062984303,
0.0379747823,
0.0066259247,
-0.0013578082,
-0.0996562019,
-0.0310402308,
-0.0294111669,
0.012400873,
0.0228128713,
-0.0410084389,
-0.0184104033,
-0.1129904613,
0.0216432158,
0.0288682058,
-0.007235534,
-0.037479911,
-0.0039938292,
-0.0187871829,
0.0242349599,
-0.0028769209,
-0.0193838757,
-0.0164588615,
-0.003155034,
0.0219452605,
0.0048608389,
-0.02464181,
0.0192680266,
-0.0215022676,
0.0121612484,
-0.0115333721,
0.0428869426,
0.0156759322,
-0.0236426033,
0.0204378143,
-0.0078501385,
-0.0138683356,
0.0105078081,
0.039915856,
-0.0183204804,
-0.0141252195,
-0.0388753451,
0.028575711,
-0.0440506972,
-0.0256725922,
-0.0273546632,
0.0786749274,
0.0023768437,
-0.0256818552,
-0.0206543878,
0.0109613035,
0.002526517,
0.0378008373,
0.0565429963,
-0.0137423351,
-0.0425339751,
-0.021509001,
0.0334695242,
-0.0743013918,
-0.0415129513,
0.0230248235,
0.019626746,
0.0488512702,
-0.0802978277,
-0.040089231,
0.0315774642,
0.0044159964,
-0.0144592663,
0.0300868638,
0.0135598583,
-0.0219736584,
-0.0835845619,
0.0297219995,
-0.0414787829,
0.0410389453,
-0.0300142094,
-0.0177116375,
0.0064947205,
-0.0417325869,
0.0077851689,
0.0354243927,
-0.0942332298,
-0.0901128501,
-0.0406197496,
0.0133726867,
0.0157524254,
0.0320032351,
-0.0087498929,
-0.0345803462,
0.0254395884,
-0.0006077594,
-0.007648827,
0.0004889733,
-0.0157966688,
-0.0378118455,
-0.0178659465,
0.0317261554,
-0.063974984,
-0.0194417424,
-0.001658282,
0.053871274,
-0.0028153744,
-0.0688220412,
0.0111774001,
0.0453697182,
-0.0389457755,
-0.0030854794,
0.003702577,
-0.0442425162,
-0.0285158008,
-0.0371371321,
-0.0069970177,
-0.0475795642,
-0.0125929434,
0.033950448,
-0.0239166562,
0.0039927168,
-0.0241956003,
-0.0028432976,
0.0326397568,
-0.0374239162,
0.0061934395,
0.0179254171,
-0.0344800726,
0.0400392301,
-0.0161645096,
-0.0142706614,
0.0004964207,
-0.0158127062,
0.0325947292,
0.0088504441,
0.0569941886,
-0.0003675242,
-0.0586722419,
-0.0077560605,
0.0301714763,
-0.0533286929,
-0.0268669147,
-0.0187832955,
0.0215298086,
0.0491871089,
0.0108959209,
0.0730180442,
-0.0042902753,
-0.0144479536,
-0.0359335318,
0.0687478557,
0.0240015145,
-0.046097476,
0.0750115067,
0.0302446429,
-0.0049712872,
0.0305277407,
0.0837781131,
0.0706946701,
0.0172967687,
0.0171387456,
-0.0094081396,
-0.0081238709,
-0.033371374,
-0.0143739888,
0.0256598368,
-0.0149238473,
0.016699601,
-0.0416660532,
-0.107661441,
-0.0068921479,
0.0115275942,
-0.0138247199,
0.0050751041,
0.0109541425,
0.0192257054,
0.0356548466,
-0.015094989,
-0.0603970587,
0.064039588,
-0.0433309115,
0.0037022373,
0.0054886001,
-5.82382109e-33,
-0.0310555138,
-0.0863993689,
0.0220007785,
0.0054860241,
-0.0493211709,
0.0194149949,
-0.0610126369,
0.0018416889,
-0.013286558,
-0.0041227969,
0.0182259567,
0.0149609121,
-0.0105336104,
0.0392205901,
-0.0410987437,
-0.0209318902,
0.0139792589,
-0.0041464809,
-0.018249929,
0.0570610389,
0.0389121808,
0.0144248819,
0.0351709351,
-0.036013145,
0.0072178524,
-0.0609487891,
0.0153489187,
-0.0083130393,
0.0146194696,
0.0576270893,
-0.024988424,
0.0529795103,
0.0277678482,
0.017770879,
-0.0311112404,
0.0323949531,
-0.0560461879,
0.0004375384,
0.0260212272,
0.0175157413,
-0.0681533888,
-0.028845327,
0.019552689,
-0.0085709235,
0.0267565809,
-0.0541513525,
0.0347142667,
0.0029138851,
-0.0260857288,
0.0229314473,
-0.0418795943,
0.0184476022,
-0.003451641,
-0.0311169084,
-0.0041484232,
0.0612525269,
0.0224981494,
-0.0163613148,
-0.0474122614,
0.0564907305,
-0.0267089307,
-0.0011199421,
0.06897147,
0.0233946759,
0.0178337656,
0.0467593856,
0.0117188133,
-0.0209533013,
-0.0005131016,
0.0110868821,
0.003964371,
0.0792152956,
0.0016387412,
0.06269712,
-0.0378675722,
0.0004058278,
-0.0579961725,
0.0065201111,
-0.0392046571,
0.0139500732,
0.0190945584,
-0.0071050772,
0.0167257972,
-0.033435002,
-0.0306597613,
-0.0011892916,
-0.033959657,
-0.032817509,
0.0258842502,
-0.020689439,
-0.0340560451,
0.0013220917,
0.0527151972,
-0.0628371909,
-0.0047413791,
0.0856453851,
-0.0361657701,
0.0638488606,
-0.0187146589,
0.0513140596,
-0.0254160259,
-0.0040320228,
0.0549027473,
-0.0224317405,
-0.00017249,
0.032829497,
-0.0004892167,
0.0337019302,
-0.0158435926,
-0.0060297921,
-0.0587974489,
-0.0194707811,
-0.0487071685,
-0.0190180093,
0.0704278573,
0.0318133831,
-0.0512200966,
0.0244599767,
0.0063734273,
0.0383343399,
-0.024854945,
-0.0312453043,
0.0021485125,
0.0438891277,
-0.0362519585,
0.0062085073,
-0.0442894027,
-0.0080131097,
0.005455832,
-0.0232462697,
-0.0228541289,
0.0161715485,
2.433e-7,
0.0532578044,
0.0108359614,
0.0336262919,
0.0494331755,
0.0324497968,
0.0184151419,
-0.0201144982,
0.0384322703,
0.0373617336,
-0.0563173592,
0.014142721,
0.0449011214,
0.0271429941,
0.0200220421,
-0.0324351564,
0.0467238575,
-0.0545251481,
-0.002949927,
-0.0373196453,
0.0005925883,
0.0365414321,
0.0435473733,
-0.0273843817,
-0.0247166548,
-0.0138384327,
-0.0658453107,
0.0969038084,
-0.0133394497,
-0.0608437918,
-0.0065029082,
-0.0113907177,
0.0045993743,
0.0078108478,
0.0244511925,
-0.0057097073,
-0.0120447483,
0.0598970838,
0.0137579795,
0.0028947825,
-0.0487685837,
-0.0273538101,
-0.016978547,
0.0013103153,
-0.0400800295,
0.0809089467,
-0.0319365487,
-0.050698556,
-0.032628987,
-0.0329112895,
-0.0168690085,
0.0006884001,
-0.0326916724,
-0.0228004884,
0.0258177724,
0.0298886541,
-0.0265211742,
0.0017401166,
-0.0029318337,
-0.0250851177,
0.0118705984,
-0.0249622799,
-0.0557462871,
-0.0318393335,
-0.0121703679,
-0.0029610614,
-0.044666972,
-0.0052582314,
1.967638183e-34,
0.0123894932,
-0.0015318549,
0.0183954593,
-0.0190637968,
0.0168875437,
-0.0513571985,
-0.0255033523,
-0.0066912663,
0.0089808851,
-0.1210776418,
-0.0160352811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08483v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08483v2 | Understanding the Humans Behind Online Misinformation: An Observational Study Through the Lens of the COVID-19 Pandemic | 2023-10-12T16:42:53 | 2024-01-18T11:43:52 | Mohit Chandra, Anush Mattapalli, Munmun De Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | The proliferation of online misinformation has emerged as one of the biggest
threats to society. Considerable efforts have focused on building
misinformation detection models, still the perils of misinformation remain
abound. Mitigating online misinformation and its ramifications requires a
holistic approach that encompasses not only an understanding of its intricate
landscape in relation to the complex issue and topic-rich information ecosystem
online, but also the psychological drivers of individuals behind it. Adopting a
time series analytic technique and robust causal inference-based design, we
conduct a large-scale observational study analyzing over 32 million COVID-19
tweets and 16 million historical timeline tweets. We focus on understanding the
behavior and psychology of users disseminating misinformation during COVID-19
and its relationship with the historical inclinations towards sharing
misinformation on Non-COVID domains before the pandemic. Our analysis
underscores the intricacies inherent to cross-domain misinformation, and
highlights that users' historical inclination toward sharing misinformation is
positively associated with their present behavior pertaining to misinformation
sharing on emergent topics and beyond. This work may serve as a valuable
foundation for designing user-centric inoculation strategies and
ecologically-grounded agile interventions for effectively tackling online
misinformation. | [
0.0291315801,
0.0087684337,
-0.0421447195,
-0.0577091128,
-0.0316669494,
-0.0244507734,
-0.0101563726,
-0.0078825681,
0.0406829417,
0.0032043215,
0.0283117425,
0.0038137615,
-0.001720147,
0.0365290418,
0.0287350435,
-0.0568533018,
0.0141745033,
0.0391257517,
0.0467848964,
-0.0029040368,
0.0273057725,
-0.0211115237,
-0.0155678373,
0.0177801102,
0.010814474,
-0.0390806049,
0.0226401482,
0.0219181478,
0.0583380349,
-0.1044085398,
0.0483591296,
0.0096707158,
0.0678366274,
0.0197444651,
0.0000020718,
-0.0099452026,
-0.0196043625,
-0.0286165718,
-0.0233656373,
0.0052704816,
0.0340427831,
-0.0238044057,
0.0408462472,
0.0293754786,
-0.0307396129,
0.0242075566,
0.0270428471,
0.0300060716,
0.0558193512,
0.0577171892,
-0.0270919539,
-0.0098449169,
0.0127380313,
0.0052764574,
0.0086346576,
-0.0070719863,
0.0417229868,
-0.0365411788,
-0.0136507079,
0.01307989,
0.0447976924,
0.0175683014,
-0.0192951541,
0.0011259313,
0.0145293344,
0.019772185,
0.0404114313,
-0.0449996702,
-0.0163070634,
0.0165684242,
0.0771926716,
-0.0136048598,
0.0582715943,
0.004454772,
0.0146907903,
0.0761426538,
-0.0451844707,
-0.0087314993,
-0.024421446,
0.0115984809,
0.0164395552,
0.0249235723,
0.0541039929,
0.0482958034,
0.0358546339,
0.0737135261,
-0.0174062811,
-0.031512659,
-0.0207300391,
-0.0122577008,
0.0534124561,
-0.0513456054,
-0.0089640534,
0.0014682458,
-0.0132692307,
-0.0024446202,
0.0264304951,
-0.0408693328,
0.0272820778,
-0.0856119469,
-0.0433113538,
0.0039266287,
0.052693665,
0.017705312,
0.072330609,
-0.0462882556,
-0.057452105,
-0.0085562412,
0.0632721707,
0.0158460364,
-0.0304913837,
0.0490942597,
0.0203820858,
-0.0462349504,
0.0568866879,
0.0337005295,
-0.0221252814,
-0.0309043676,
-0.0370045118,
-0.0421164259,
-0.0712874979,
-0.0070826565,
-0.0134580862,
0.0068584019,
-0.0025347993,
0.043241486,
-0.0636220425,
0.0191657841,
0.004063969,
-0.0100181978,
-0.0072539491,
0.0009307228,
0.0325646177,
-0.0185342524,
-0.0146980174,
-0.0126804346,
0.0336000919,
0.0139412843,
-0.0449869707,
-0.0434210673,
0.0108430367,
-0.0146826524,
0.0107673369,
-0.0335099697,
-0.0261247661,
0.0342991576,
-0.0023920694,
0.0106559927,
-0.0178198628,
0.0057301191,
-0.0978969932,
0.0099719577,
-0.0452109165,
0.0063772989,
0.0532965139,
0.0478207059,
0.0114463279,
0.0398490652,
-0.0007385989,
0.0686727837,
0.0143136932,
0.0120213879,
0.0046658297,
0.0063649323,
0.0551754683,
0.0225885101,
0.0318633467,
-0.0310254656,
-0.0304426514,
-0.0303527471,
-0.0293182489,
0.0064865076,
-0.0086932899,
0.0394294485,
0.0629894882,
-0.0223553218,
-0.0387681425,
-0.0384898856,
0.0136431865,
0.0149881942,
-0.0280622151,
-0.0378948897,
0.0132116815,
0.0082124472,
-0.0132124042,
-0.0196510088,
0.0168858189,
0.0556470342,
-0.0472530276,
0.0121563543,
-0.0251683537,
-0.0018359908,
0.0363338776,
-0.0245404225,
-0.0179344453,
-0.0402482301,
-0.0110038146,
0.0109734638,
0.0597558282,
0.0210203566,
0.0193138607,
-0.0186841507,
-0.0008082613,
0.0668166354,
0.0118963839,
0.0290643051,
-0.0322561152,
-0.0463940352,
0.0732098743,
0.0099913971,
0.0467901193,
-0.0069824522,
-0.0638115704,
0.010274196,
-0.0014189779,
-0.0000737957,
0.0349408165,
0.0109474258,
0.0354896337,
0.0378046036,
-0.0441827774,
0.0105486643,
0.0069142659,
0.0025863948,
-0.0220687557,
0.0216709785,
-0.0641440377,
0.0332391672,
0.0858667269,
0.0121908402,
0.025148483,
-0.0035629275,
0.0466631502,
-0.002152951,
-0.0355177559,
0.0108000562,
-0.0037341693,
0.0733560324,
-0.006122923,
-0.0481100865,
-0.028153697,
-0.0141219227,
-0.0110584013,
0.0347827971,
0.0767084733,
0.0044897688,
0.0206625443,
0.0132983439,
-0.0777857155,
-0.0195812806,
0.020396173,
0.0386650376,
0.0292933155,
-0.0455104746,
-0.0367378779,
-0.0138269197,
-0.062123213,
-0.0114068426,
0.0147519661,
0.0449330881,
-0.0866376534,
-0.0138573246,
-0.032386627,
0.0348585993,
-0.0520850457,
-0.0350090712,
0.0294089578,
-0.0514800884,
-0.044785127,
-0.0183056351,
-0.0030825399,
0.0602433272,
0.0111015337,
-0.0237942804,
0.0142731396,
0.022260705,
0.0256311744,
-0.0122718718,
0.07741227,
0.0202231351,
-0.006550428,
-0.0062878849,
-0.0342296138,
0.0398634858,
-0.0525376387,
-0.0201248862,
0.0765993148,
-0.0994366407,
0.0091796881,
-0.0566341691,
-0.0563706085,
-0.0240150504,
-0.0377057567,
-0.0101752924,
-0.0001797222,
0.0184144769,
0.0378333256,
-0.0197959319,
0.0446067974,
0.0965113863,
0.0045385575,
0.0343704969,
-0.0092407204,
0.0048825126,
-0.072630547,
-0.0048525794,
-0.0225894824,
-0.0624645762,
0.0110090496,
0.0651863962,
0.0241011363,
0.0458332337,
-0.013542207,
0.0310488846,
-0.0493598394,
-0.0256998856,
-0.0314309932,
-0.0410921574,
-0.0123632867,
0.0411979519,
-0.0219536386,
-0.0329506025,
0.025635561,
0.0318907909,
0.0883604363,
0.0056716856,
-0.014225916,
0.0118004009,
-0.0488624796,
-0.0058448329,
0.0075774281,
0.0814849585,
0.0145479385,
0.0112043843,
-0.0687695518,
0.0580050685,
-0.0058376482,
-0.046847932,
-0.0006016797,
0.0171058346,
0.0415594988,
-0.0107214693,
-0.0205426645,
-0.1003393605,
-0.0457974002,
-0.0378498025,
0.0143595468,
-0.0221267566,
-0.059639886,
-0.0226913802,
0.0453224517,
-0.0336206146,
0.0275887661,
-0.0179613121,
0.0683572516,
-0.0251121987,
0.0072799395,
-0.0353264697,
0.0373648331,
-0.060664814,
-0.0142649943,
0.0131964115,
0.0389877371,
-0.0157685205,
0.0093903113,
-0.0217130091,
-0.0202377476,
0.0072350609,
0.0082949661,
0.0507874675,
0.0622887537,
0.0062741484,
0.0133624403,
0.0536441654,
0.0241683405,
0.0073623797,
-0.0051180022,
-0.0083054537,
0.0141257653,
0.003910712,
-0.009587843,
-0.0233220942,
0.0052565066,
-0.0059665078,
-0.0090541821,
-0.0622600876,
-0.0321598388,
-0.0215619449,
-0.0053986651,
0.022473624,
0.0024675753,
0.068156369,
-0.0034055721,
-0.0692334771,
0.0080758324,
0.0009712217,
-0.0280328784,
-0.0224046148,
0.0309922099,
-0.0018684624,
-0.0025862858,
-0.0576126687,
-0.0255859178,
0.0110020628,
0.0008006487,
0.0309714917,
0.0021864024,
0.0572939627,
-0.0294403378,
-0.0549190678,
0.0022911439,
0.015106515,
-0.0244062599,
-0.0349981561,
0.0882863626,
-0.0239151455,
0.047184363,
-0.0473938733,
0.0473277271,
-0.0416573584,
-0.0309791993,
0.000098257,
0.0847287253,
0.0310750473,
-0.0525841303,
-0.0291065481,
0.0162775554,
0.0664323717,
0.0139942802,
0.0013423716,
0.0086911861,
0.0183351003,
0.000136106,
0.0266837291,
0.0039892793,
-0.0221920852,
-0.0328403935,
0.0118924808,
-0.0555668436,
-0.0243480038,
-0.0141197573,
-0.040945515,
-0.0443486534,
-0.0095949396,
-0.0494079776,
0.0504433624,
-0.0285243429,
-0.0107344016,
-0.0179767963,
-0.0012867572,
0.0437120348,
-0.0187793821,
-0.0346422642,
-0.0309157409,
0.0336425863,
0.0056536822,
0.0556637011,
-0.0523606651,
-0.0394434519,
0.0622418001,
-0.0218083281,
0.0252957344,
0.0269104093,
0.0043645534,
0.0439006463,
0.079091534,
0.0230608489,
-0.0349676535,
-0.0335325822,
0.0246210545,
0.0259331763,
0.0090700695,
-0.0017176819,
0.0265016966,
-0.00164329,
0.029570099,
-0.050781846,
-0.0667875707,
0.0300593916,
0.0102990279,
-0.0381208248,
0.0603205822,
-0.0245556552,
-0.0381977819,
-0.0157131162,
-0.0588779934,
0.0186811145,
-0.0214707218,
0.0760475174,
-0.0350291207,
0.0026677521,
-0.042222634,
-0.0245215278,
0.0538612679,
-0.0331760496,
-0.0362240709,
-0.059506502,
0.0051867492,
-0.0070086708,
0.0505050719,
0.007957967,
-0.0129630454,
0.0400217026,
0.013619056,
-0.0088964235,
0.0149333859,
0.0059663756,
0.0079309549,
-0.0416431017,
-0.0109860078,
0.0408609509,
-0.0370459296,
-0.0491283573,
-0.0337280929,
0.0010493648,
-0.0139444964,
-0.0011234647,
0.0258184727,
0.040622022,
-0.0001446629,
-0.0256149247,
-0.0085041998,
0.0328922123,
-0.0279435758,
0.0063044485,
-0.0156175783,
-0.0190977808,
-0.0599480942,
0.031589929,
0.0331705362,
-0.0108469212,
0.0625406206,
0.0101818899,
-0.065359287,
0.0019032736,
-0.0000262749,
-0.0339006744,
0.0380876958,
-0.0099631893,
0.0387625992,
-0.0875992104,
-0.0257580485,
0.0563996211,
-0.0396512523,
-0.0094939191,
0.0138575882,
-0.0139247533,
0.0419316404,
0.0108902566,
0.0212491322,
-0.0126316445,
0.0460118726,
-0.0129029471,
-0.0508862026,
-0.0462186709,
-7.015839585e-33,
0.0335476995,
-0.0417268127,
-0.0262638442,
-0.0338109992,
-0.0108859278,
0.0274760444,
-0.0313585885,
-0.0078953542,
-0.0192030594,
0.007762027,
0.0116158416,
0.0269689597,
0.0042356835,
-0.0274668057,
0.0189113561,
-0.0164871346,
0.0334562212,
-0.0089186337,
-0.0112545546,
0.0145052774,
0.0407741107,
0.02039681,
-0.02494484,
-0.0723405108,
0.038782157,
-0.0307666976,
0.013236233,
0.0116445124,
0.0290729906,
-0.0149232652,
-0.0027610397,
0.0049269223,
0.0465221256,
-0.014471855,
0.0126264608,
0.0619217865,
-0.036948435,
-0.0596421249,
0.0361285172,
-0.0682146549,
-0.0080425162,
-0.02156014,
0.008889324,
0.0176339,
-0.0360713825,
0.0156497192,
0.0110880313,
0.0526966192,
0.0685071349,
0.0170583278,
-0.031889081,
0.0009629435,
-0.029608991,
0.0126716308,
-0.0667443871,
0.081016995,
0.021457525,
0.0585993156,
-0.1107135862,
0.0541263185,
-0.0235795584,
-0.0299793351,
0.0253304075,
-0.0114191882,
0.0105266254,
0.0314298533,
-0.0270020999,
0.0459114537,
-0.0659386963,
0.0111781294,
-0.0319168866,
-0.0132118305,
0.0009190243,
0.0612226799,
0.0238529202,
-0.082000114,
-0.0838870034,
0.0264057275,
0.0166898035,
0.0330873318,
-0.0004671324,
0.0115258629,
-0.0252981819,
-0.0076115313,
0.0108775618,
-0.0445134602,
-0.0179666616,
-0.0030689801,
-0.0202945005,
0.0375134908,
-0.001293964,
0.0082999077,
0.0046577202,
0.0271855611,
-0.0338955224,
-0.0283632819,
0.0374147259,
-0.0158362836,
0.0412604958,
0.030417392,
-0.0629911497,
0.024905283,
-0.0327691659,
0.0517292768,
0.0311513525,
-0.0258987751,
0.0309064966,
0.0025439328,
-0.0150652155,
-0.0165491402,
-0.0188311227,
0.0374572203,
-0.0343131796,
-0.0472329594,
0.045719225,
0.0576645248,
-0.0056243278,
-0.0316593088,
0.0569768362,
0.0415851176,
0.0152775059,
-0.0429615453,
-0.0816058293,
0.0083327303,
0.0023008429,
0.0057413899,
-0.0265893154,
0.0312108584,
-0.0187047776,
-0.087209411,
-0.001298406,
-0.0696690083,
2.919e-7,
0.0409664661,
0.0724738464,
-0.0081451321,
0.0163983312,
0.0584942624,
0.033466965,
-0.0015747304,
-0.0045125517,
-0.026235614,
-0.0900231376,
-0.0015564744,
0.0234818589,
-0.0191870965,
0.0348763689,
0.0171309114,
-0.0202231742,
-0.0352460146,
0.0228730664,
-0.0328487046,
-0.0039808936,
0.0067265565,
-0.0332082286,
0.0443904772,
0.0050128172,
-0.0384185575,
0.040983323,
0.0483671688,
-0.0236931723,
-0.0274213068,
0.0048432164,
-0.0131241595,
0.0102906749,
-0.0009058391,
0.0182570089,
-0.0125818169,
-0.0579160452,
-0.0780158713,
-0.0357657075,
0.0180702899,
0.0178639758,
-0.016431259,
-0.0361644886,
0.0128610553,
-0.0429362357,
0.0251343735,
-0.0762342289,
-0.078309916,
0.0209577065,
-0.0419769697,
0.0562856123,
0.019904118,
0.0163105149,
-0.0502158441,
0.003933263,
-0.0270065777,
0.0495295078,
0.0017590657,
-0.0395379663,
0.0158008747,
-0.0148712769,
-0.0580542274,
-0.0586003438,
-0.023049619,
-0.0114452792,
0.0123538151,
0.0154063608,
0.0795190707,
2.223211318e-34,
0.0291298274,
0.0071531213,
-0.0281554237,
-0.0537217595,
0.0238683093,
0.0081865834,
-0.0221859403,
-0.0188641474,
0.0565060824,
0.0027858892,
0.0144218868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08475v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08475v5 | Can We Edit Multimodal Large Language Models? | 2023-10-12T16:32:44 | 2024-04-18T15:46:22 | Siyuan Cheng, Bozhong Tian, Qingbin Liu, Xi Chen, Yongheng Wang, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | In this paper, we focus on editing Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs).
Compared to editing single-modal LLMs, multimodal model editing is more
challenging, which demands a higher level of scrutiny and careful consideration
in the editing process. To facilitate research in this area, we construct a new
benchmark, dubbed MMEdit, for editing multimodal LLMs and establishing a suite
of innovative metrics for evaluation. We conduct comprehensive experiments
involving various model editing baselines and analyze the impact of editing
different components for multimodal LLMs. Empirically, we notice that previous
baselines can implement editing multimodal LLMs to some extent, but the effect
is still barely satisfactory, indicating the potential difficulty of this task.
We hope that our work can provide the NLP community with insights. Code and
dataset are available in https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyEdit. | [
0.022167664,
0.0732339248,
-0.0324151143,
0.0453860313,
-0.0562744997,
-0.0006735834,
0.021695815,
-0.0094019026,
-0.032997217,
-0.0789843947,
-0.0810154155,
-0.0390994325,
0.0076904907,
0.0070883674,
0.0303541385,
-0.0837997124,
0.0470347703,
-0.0351863392,
-0.047851149,
0.0120880874,
0.0119116111,
-0.0151856961,
-0.0275025498,
0.0478659533,
0.0080905417,
-0.0253297314,
-0.0284242816,
0.0311827827,
-0.0165762175,
-0.007312506,
-0.0126850661,
0.075836435,
0.0125702489,
0.0126063507,
0.0000020152,
-0.0518434942,
-0.0252127051,
-0.00377468,
0.0288645923,
0.0316713117,
0.0652500466,
-0.0140856272,
-0.0160153322,
-0.0265816599,
-0.00696183,
-0.0005657373,
0.0591380857,
0.0339565128,
0.0741591901,
0.0506623052,
-0.0017172856,
-0.0132691879,
0.0063487203,
0.0032959911,
-0.0005147501,
-0.0226062704,
0.0076537454,
0.0336761475,
-0.002066246,
-0.0101372786,
-0.0431440435,
0.063804388,
0.0097901188,
-0.0446972251,
0.0097630853,
-0.0268422347,
0.0033960568,
-0.0260865502,
-0.0137987677,
0.0638808459,
0.02169572,
0.0105256848,
-0.0201270301,
-0.0178534612,
0.0198207293,
0.0414763652,
-0.0619093031,
0.0236434657,
0.0253968369,
-0.0131087201,
-0.0344737507,
-0.0882599354,
0.0310387034,
0.0137438541,
0.0203655958,
0.0502788983,
0.0536704138,
-0.0083119273,
-0.0334609859,
-0.0128184864,
-0.0133151095,
-0.0737883598,
-0.026921995,
0.0179772414,
-0.0206573792,
0.0011438356,
-0.0549632534,
-0.0268984605,
-0.0005308114,
-0.0245477166,
0.1030797884,
0.0224530678,
-0.0183158424,
0.0440943688,
0.0120343883,
-0.0026235264,
-0.0102637168,
0.0036199379,
-0.0234816987,
0.0234869532,
-0.0357557535,
0.0045845583,
-0.0428759754,
-0.0115675228,
-0.0469283946,
-0.0049314019,
-0.0429114364,
0.0356088541,
-0.0127768312,
-0.0044844374,
-0.0177666787,
-0.0220963508,
-0.0152704176,
-0.0177986603,
-0.0091615161,
0.0342561714,
0.0067611067,
0.0047106002,
0.0057727094,
-0.0486239307,
0.0369670913,
0.0226603448,
-0.0029948025,
-0.0439933054,
-0.0136155877,
0.0973163396,
-0.0031355466,
-0.0201311801,
-0.0269164145,
-0.0398094319,
-0.0203011222,
-0.0400057733,
0.0020161127,
-0.0650789961,
0.014280282,
-0.0051684505,
0.0019465656,
-0.0481032357,
-0.0258263759,
-0.0304610915,
-0.0066526416,
0.087899588,
-0.0177638065,
0.0314190276,
0.0382800326,
0.0174777415,
-0.0218800083,
0.0879398882,
0.0562586859,
-0.0104502393,
0.0969018489,
-0.0306034628,
0.0255553182,
0.0879614949,
-0.0392602831,
0.0313985646,
-0.0382750668,
-0.0180097856,
0.002807199,
0.0363202915,
0.0122741796,
0.0227224808,
-0.034252245,
0.0053180945,
0.128447786,
0.0061069778,
0.0606012419,
-0.0004052037,
0.0176126584,
-0.0352470614,
0.0306710918,
0.0135453865,
-0.0285520703,
0.0518185049,
-0.0306297243,
0.0225825906,
0.0238257889,
0.0278360844,
-0.0045498856,
-0.0246270597,
-0.0253998023,
0.0255294126,
0.0137456721,
-0.0313411653,
0.026364252,
0.0119210305,
-0.0073339762,
0.0540937111,
0.0246402286,
-0.0581925549,
0.002818353,
-0.0544530079,
-0.0081636645,
0.0337828249,
0.0738566667,
-0.0328330323,
-0.0544916317,
-0.0300362222,
0.0172904413,
0.0406183973,
0.0665226057,
-0.0248309337,
0.0057193944,
-0.0294195097,
-0.0283090714,
-0.0482732058,
0.0346846282,
-0.0208134651,
0.0188468583,
-0.0222469606,
-0.0133267194,
-0.0336913615,
0.0165324658,
0.0090228654,
-0.0270036478,
0.0129317092,
-0.0228242185,
-0.0026670615,
0.0208197869,
-0.0181479231,
-0.0308764875,
-0.0057323668,
-0.013155045,
-0.0021541959,
-0.0066649518,
0.0398884341,
0.0036814986,
0.0010499058,
0.0584712848,
-0.0305179469,
-0.0258278511,
0.0314575993,
-0.0147651089,
-0.0012990618,
-0.0045278068,
-0.0384397805,
0.026040826,
-0.0406945832,
0.0366864279,
-0.0132828709,
-0.0092294617,
-0.0437786318,
0.0053266324,
-0.0222003851,
-0.0067236871,
0.0332931764,
-0.0091016591,
-0.017601788,
-0.0344986729,
-0.0316297822,
0.0410734899,
0.0181396753,
0.0064705168,
0.0035756233,
-0.0048767943,
-0.0536375456,
-0.0530086346,
-0.1014862806,
-0.0122133531,
-0.0148840835,
0.0018630389,
0.0519043095,
0.0379519537,
-0.0258270986,
0.02092731,
0.0026832183,
0.0282731168,
0.0026482427,
0.0575735196,
0.0482267775,
0.0070301956,
-0.021331897,
-0.0606617332,
-0.0040147463,
0.0143072354,
0.0635918602,
-0.0107512819,
-0.033019878,
-0.0491406433,
0.0015720538,
-0.0356717333,
-0.0044450792,
0.0165282097,
-0.0279070977,
0.0070707202,
-0.011581515,
0.0922081992,
0.0325066745,
-0.0012990868,
0.035345573,
0.0597584993,
-0.0657197088,
-0.0086456025,
0.004654034,
0.0296809375,
-0.0261134077,
-0.032276094,
-0.0428953394,
0.0063019716,
0.0696467087,
-0.0031466456,
-0.0232876483,
-0.0170744192,
0.0502395034,
-0.0193885099,
-0.049602434,
-0.0310634542,
0.0210925061,
-0.0239345599,
0.0467399843,
-0.0257977527,
-0.0724276528,
0.0135983899,
-0.0396395624,
0.0159059428,
0.0215915125,
-0.0162867662,
-0.0401515886,
0.0806258321,
0.002844977,
0.0215617679,
-0.034318205,
-0.0005669751,
-0.0694195405,
-0.0115608973,
0.0470019653,
-0.0121482378,
0.08557605,
-0.0979084596,
0.0003692461,
-0.0367133431,
-0.0153080467,
0.0090840142,
-0.0230420511,
-0.0299306214,
-0.0067418166,
0.0034480852,
-0.0152778355,
-0.0245083664,
0.0055542365,
0.0475731194,
0.0299143512,
-0.0040269508,
-0.0145437382,
-0.0197105724,
0.0237268154,
0.046720989,
0.0573890656,
-0.0099440571,
-0.0619145632,
0.0121799465,
0.0535400547,
0.0149578657,
-0.004159221,
-0.0525461808,
0.0080900146,
0.0224384516,
-0.0391921066,
-0.014469903,
0.0083193025,
0.0944029465,
-0.0533118397,
0.0340183266,
0.0886187777,
0.0062259892,
-0.0475385077,
0.0109682782,
-0.0270207729,
0.0351223387,
0.0287301634,
0.012471674,
-0.0795812383,
-0.0447468981,
0.0477129556,
-0.0066545359,
0.0044021718,
-0.0301390551,
-0.0113565214,
-0.0732766241,
0.0507306494,
-0.0075354753,
-0.020125486,
-0.0184202455,
-0.0114641432,
0.0149231683,
-0.0041009556,
0.0336439796,
0.0355841108,
-0.0333003178,
0.0088430345,
-0.0404848643,
-0.0140461121,
-0.0344028808,
-0.0135303438,
-0.0431751758,
0.0542751886,
0.0206764434,
0.0073435903,
-0.0007424004,
-0.0231367294,
0.0862510279,
0.0552057624,
0.0066731176,
-0.0253753364,
0.020389339,
0.0006962049,
-0.0070677935,
-0.0085151168,
0.0184305403,
0.0424341112,
-0.042534288,
0.0106781162,
0.0543922298,
-0.0128493495,
0.0184860602,
-0.0285641942,
-0.0132390438,
-0.0290133338,
0.0493790731,
0.0608883314,
-0.0699990839,
0.0061424039,
-0.0584622249,
-0.0353435539,
-0.0137336496,
-0.0487015136,
-0.0221437626,
-0.0486226268,
0.045426771,
-0.0547533222,
-0.0394058265,
0.0215494111,
0.0292161498,
0.0433158092,
0.008466457,
-0.034785375,
-0.0045978022,
-0.0236478988,
0.0261369273,
-0.0413939208,
0.0326172709,
-0.0556329936,
-0.0098728649,
0.0377210155,
-0.0282160211,
0.0103865732,
-0.0021823959,
-0.0698030815,
-0.0671523511,
-0.026094744,
0.0408272594,
0.0223483853,
0.0199202336,
0.0325493626,
-0.1138082892,
-0.0366010629,
0.0057220734,
0.0028880662,
0.0588797182,
0.0209665131,
0.0303959418,
-0.008827677,
0.0360177122,
-0.034411706,
-0.034322802,
0.0470311195,
0.0707949474,
0.0136448666,
-0.0552804694,
0.0001961819,
0.0354877338,
0.0153243961,
-0.0029253252,
-0.0093290014,
-0.0527559333,
0.005434148,
-0.0421101376,
-0.0279713664,
-0.0525582843,
0.0338168219,
0.0030090287,
0.0070486418,
-0.0177744068,
0.0430542231,
-0.0097258193,
0.0396062955,
-0.032993935,
0.0568939298,
0.0188183635,
-0.0504775681,
0.0129339779,
0.0209428649,
-0.0055988128,
0.0291188415,
-0.02284953,
0.0032829582,
-0.0004231772,
0.0800006017,
0.0036697739,
-0.0191592351,
-0.0426350385,
0.0579299554,
-0.0287981015,
-0.0192615949,
-0.0120854396,
0.0480134115,
0.071713835,
0.0165021028,
0.0640820116,
-0.0177725088,
-0.0461019762,
-0.0323613957,
0.0684822947,
0.0293056406,
-0.0105869193,
0.0227653794,
0.0094100442,
-0.0175681431,
0.0072505916,
0.0517119691,
-0.0248184875,
0.0790308267,
-0.010004269,
0.0089351879,
-0.0405183248,
-0.0178198759,
0.0462589674,
0.0005935361,
-0.0256338511,
-0.0206626356,
-0.0501457267,
-0.0561189204,
-0.0050234878,
0.0362581797,
-0.0141753992,
0.0079784663,
0.0062586293,
0.0632428676,
0.0067195538,
-0.0059551913,
-0.0411821641,
-0.0026431365,
0.0189787187,
0.0144405365,
0.0162002072,
-5.765013679e-33,
-0.0106227985,
-0.0201770831,
0.0330428518,
-0.0238863174,
-0.0392948054,
-0.0178902578,
-0.0189903732,
0.0619848184,
0.0319102295,
-0.0091052698,
-0.0091769453,
-0.0248426367,
-0.0048138318,
0.0020671058,
0.0105217705,
0.01765134,
0.0411370657,
0.0169096906,
-0.0408512093,
-0.0379612967,
-0.0249161664,
0.01716475,
0.058253672,
-0.0273615513,
0.0358890705,
0.0338965505,
-0.0265816506,
0.0171175133,
-0.0294664968,
0.072724089,
-0.0197887477,
-0.0030910228,
0.0300540421,
-0.0278761387,
-0.0380526967,
-0.0084665921,
-0.0094415592,
0.0136568379,
0.0253491923,
0.0512475632,
-0.0494711883,
-0.0475786664,
0.0553672761,
0.0003930928,
-0.0505338944,
-0.0326673575,
0.0252441894,
-0.0552245378,
0.001455468,
0.0199326724,
-0.0493584462,
0.0391794778,
-0.0015630241,
-0.0094372267,
0.0173389558,
0.0122236703,
0.0249560811,
0.0016404712,
-0.0358402096,
0.0321792923,
0.0212158952,
0.0378129818,
0.0805793181,
0.0011013543,
0.0225866046,
0.0538823269,
0.0421931818,
0.0076352926,
-0.0124859605,
0.0237610284,
0.0245448239,
0.0418648049,
0.0226647276,
0.0965963751,
-0.015566187,
0.0368850455,
-0.021458054,
0.0183150358,
-0.0381066911,
0.0303509589,
0.0080750957,
0.0668672547,
0.0385358445,
0.0284825116,
-0.0762399882,
0.0001471388,
-0.0472938642,
-0.0276852995,
0.0357793234,
-0.0101955039,
-0.0175335947,
-0.0261030253,
0.0541366264,
-0.0243249014,
-0.0496062636,
-0.0192013793,
-0.0302082151,
0.0838091671,
-0.0007926081,
-0.0193084069,
0.0160574596,
0.0078882333,
0.0129152304,
-0.004058308,
0.0307803098,
-0.0042360318,
0.0080153001,
0.0434243977,
-0.0733692646,
0.0160752777,
-0.0096561452,
-0.0101336688,
0.0007541615,
0.0242850222,
0.0224223901,
-0.0410829857,
-0.0446150042,
0.0275697857,
0.0464241207,
-0.0019812863,
-0.0447711609,
-0.0115238456,
-0.0162246302,
0.0084731514,
-0.0007602603,
0.0206398759,
-0.0402697325,
-0.016038958,
0.0400485843,
-0.0367588922,
-0.0240491498,
-0.0017361505,
2.551e-7,
0.0447039679,
0.0580509305,
-0.0050461246,
0.0111304969,
0.0417669676,
0.0465870462,
-0.0596423,
-0.0026919758,
0.0058517922,
-0.0356001295,
-0.0363031514,
0.006710398,
0.0559375174,
0.0201473292,
-0.0321705975,
0.00017945,
-0.0107118599,
0.043088071,
-0.0333680548,
-0.0012422429,
0.0241874214,
0.0395597927,
0.004031606,
-0.0157701261,
-0.0098148044,
-0.0406421497,
0.0688868687,
-0.0695211366,
-0.0527465083,
0.0328805372,
0.0556038991,
-0.0009108033,
0.0123977521,
-0.0303936172,
-0.0123259267,
-0.0450066738,
0.0253231972,
0.0741949826,
-0.0005588197,
0.0061927103,
0.0228399541,
-0.0044505824,
-0.0374821611,
-0.0309870206,
0.0645782128,
0.0015157316,
-0.0219850428,
-0.0527072325,
-0.0149417426,
-0.011175449,
0.0360854343,
-0.0585925803,
-0.0209978763,
0.0273805447,
0.0262069143,
0.0106155211,
-0.0596504584,
-0.0270659272,
-0.0436585248,
-0.0227593929,
-0.0287824739,
-0.0690620765,
-0.0378135256,
-0.0298543815,
0.031516552,
-0.0924694985,
-0.0396930538,
2.058950676e-34,
0.039596349,
-0.0057158661,
0.046154052,
0.0176428072,
0.0494197868,
-0.0181459095,
-0.0162102208,
-0.0102736587,
-0.012952215,
-0.0925035328,
-0.0255001672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08461v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08461v2 | DistillSpec: Improving Speculative Decoding via Knowledge Distillation | 2023-10-12T16:21:04 | 2024-03-31T03:06:51 | Yongchao Zhou, Kaifeng Lyu, Ankit Singh Rawat, Aditya Krishna Menon, Afshin Rostamizadeh, Sanjiv Kumar, Jean-François Kagy, Rishabh Agarwal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Speculative decoding (SD) accelerates large language model inference by
employing a faster draft model for generating multiple tokens, which are then
verified in parallel by the larger target model, resulting in the text
generated according to the target model distribution. However, identifying a
compact draft model that is well-aligned with the target model is challenging.
To tackle this issue, we propose DistillSpec that uses knowledge distillation
to better align the draft model with the target model, before applying SD.
DistillSpec makes two key design choices, which we demonstrate via systematic
study to be crucial to improving the draft and target alignment: utilizing
on-policy data generation from the draft model, and tailoring the divergence
function to the task and decoding strategy. Notably, DistillSpec yields
impressive 10 - 45% speedups over standard SD on a range of standard
benchmarks, using both greedy and non-greedy sampling. Furthermore, we combine
DistillSpec with lossy SD to achieve fine-grained control over the latency vs.
task performance trade-off. Finally, in practical scenarios with models of
varying sizes, first using distillation to boost the performance of the target
model and then applying DistillSpec to train a well-aligned draft model can
reduce decoding latency by 6-10x with minimal performance drop, compared to
standard decoding without distillation. | [
0.0212382227,
0.1160941571,
0.0192640424,
0.0038977019,
-0.0173697658,
0.0241241809,
-0.013729197,
0.0049883937,
-0.0758180246,
0.0155451121,
0.0229464695,
-0.0666609555,
0.0095217414,
0.0437419601,
0.0084321508,
0.003659551,
0.0191942267,
-0.0490586497,
0.0379777066,
-0.0130742593,
-0.0091191782,
0.0448312648,
0.0050351457,
0.0433937013,
0.0056994068,
-0.0111622373,
-0.0344236866,
0.0379510075,
-0.0151709123,
-0.0337566584,
0.0239301063,
0.0649802238,
0.0180594865,
0.0204052553,
0.0000020653,
-0.0108180698,
-0.0184315946,
0.0139993774,
-0.0481931195,
0.0200114045,
0.0458506793,
-0.0498071015,
-0.0017461268,
0.0053072595,
-0.0088365581,
-0.0318909176,
0.0520701259,
0.0226716585,
0.0046800319,
0.0706540495,
-0.000962486,
-0.039721515,
0.0176361669,
-0.0119771929,
-0.0307062995,
-0.0298266169,
0.0110674202,
-0.0219101552,
-0.0623724498,
-0.0135923289,
0.0056088082,
0.0294221621,
0.0254763197,
0.0154979406,
-0.0234870818,
0.0340927094,
-0.0110046631,
-0.0488402583,
0.0003427078,
0.0493245609,
-0.0141333565,
-0.0709512755,
0.0026479871,
-0.0002029871,
-0.024891533,
-0.0157950092,
-0.0153878769,
0.0022451617,
-0.0318323895,
0.0260718148,
0.0728128999,
0.0182911176,
0.0481818877,
0.0031633195,
-0.0464563295,
0.0474376641,
0.0170464236,
-0.0181651134,
-0.0158878062,
0.0098992204,
-0.0162773896,
-0.0514016114,
0.0136584137,
-0.0205209665,
-0.0413530581,
-0.0177698862,
-0.0519499779,
-0.0740766153,
-0.0141943377,
0.0118687022,
0.0407446511,
0.0753147081,
0.0052000885,
-0.0067562661,
-0.0115520423,
0.0158959702,
-0.0245522764,
0.0252821818,
-0.0503587499,
-0.007860777,
-0.0203288794,
-0.0010908938,
-0.0573720597,
0.0284555852,
-0.0473814718,
-0.027110368,
-0.0062818886,
0.0017234505,
-0.0082300967,
-0.0080739427,
0.068852216,
-0.0046981657,
-0.054660771,
-0.0035716097,
0.0296662804,
0.0402824804,
-0.021867834,
0.001706497,
0.0180472489,
-0.0411853716,
-0.044519648,
-0.00053145,
-0.0038840612,
-0.0237633958,
-0.0191990193,
0.0519386344,
-0.0329155847,
-0.0144051323,
-0.0100028245,
-0.0388314724,
0.0020867162,
-0.0801107958,
-0.0061806398,
-0.0681876689,
0.0423793904,
-0.000593218,
-0.0014929359,
-0.0559944883,
-0.0183500685,
-0.0229317304,
0.0023072723,
0.06719964,
-0.0215804018,
0.0090851719,
-0.0006791797,
0.0057571377,
-0.0240869708,
0.1274562329,
-0.0108289486,
0.0379528962,
0.009791716,
0.0225914288,
-0.0342534557,
0.0513315611,
0.0673236102,
0.0161769353,
0.0020844426,
-0.0113772685,
-0.0064411233,
-0.0077887163,
0.0778244212,
0.0212025028,
-0.0824633166,
0.0130602466,
0.0645989403,
0.029383406,
0.0366239995,
-0.0146515733,
0.0353739709,
0.046903234,
-0.0084563261,
0.0140923196,
-0.0335077606,
-0.0030487443,
0.0081083206,
0.0289201681,
0.032694824,
0.0619954914,
-0.0265616868,
-0.004479215,
0.0057610665,
-0.0126290824,
-0.0002969146,
0.022783678,
0.0605740473,
0.0293460861,
-0.0526315905,
0.0894610882,
0.0353003666,
-0.0304153301,
-0.0188804939,
-0.0306028184,
0.0347449668,
0.0618380941,
0.0467646793,
0.021866411,
-0.0209091399,
0.0090493299,
-0.0308503285,
0.0299653914,
0.0221666731,
-0.0368765481,
0.0602061562,
-0.040454749,
-0.0355251059,
0.024776265,
0.0382878669,
0.0178116206,
0.0620765761,
-0.011538839,
0.0155529333,
-0.0619291589,
-0.0021493281,
0.0303064138,
-0.0074090185,
-0.0167342983,
0.0172560867,
0.0168002918,
0.0590443872,
0.0145295635,
-0.0196602978,
0.0114587257,
0.0206292197,
-0.0397188589,
0.0123262228,
0.007328955,
-0.0569506325,
-0.0692978203,
0.0153381256,
-0.0107402466,
0.0043139621,
0.0460894518,
-0.033102043,
-0.0476562493,
0.0058752666,
-0.0002408032,
0.0466099679,
-0.0560154691,
0.0288974848,
0.007330318,
0.0105331307,
0.0096949255,
0.0278167855,
-0.0470699258,
-0.0252298415,
0.001861663,
-0.007388175,
-0.0210464988,
-0.0049246652,
-0.0165896434,
0.0159617979,
-0.0408056974,
0.0016859927,
0.0156086367,
0.0206647813,
0.0248916876,
-0.0084075034,
-0.057690274,
0.0046065282,
-0.0549802296,
0.0236947164,
0.0328898616,
0.0170558915,
-0.0048773307,
0.0047838027,
-0.004561434,
-0.0279033221,
-0.0171192121,
0.0148497513,
-0.0350960717,
0.0140904952,
-0.0221962966,
-0.000790284,
-0.0162641127,
0.0340621062,
0.046964094,
-0.0450780466,
-0.0088529298,
-0.0724614263,
0.0078031989,
0.0186179709,
-0.0020078132,
-0.0028588362,
-0.022209594,
0.015700087,
-0.0220148154,
0.0240927208,
-0.0164837819,
-0.0227787513,
0.0165232252,
-0.0012051306,
0.0122536235,
-0.0683564842,
-0.0029375702,
-0.0242941082,
0.0193327442,
-0.0617578737,
-0.0517574549,
-0.0045183464,
0.0888652131,
-0.001146441,
-0.0038854375,
-0.0798584819,
-0.00981104,
0.0027147061,
-0.0548956469,
-0.03183759,
-0.0112117585,
0.0013387919,
0.0294632874,
-0.0436444916,
-0.0550017729,
0.0745024607,
-0.0565012917,
0.0011580591,
-0.0339643098,
0.0049588042,
0.0002511799,
0.0522701852,
-0.0078048636,
0.0122709395,
0.0101421904,
-0.0246311016,
-0.0229646191,
0.0133983567,
0.0231687073,
-0.0108271372,
0.0522890612,
-0.0469059125,
0.0381432399,
-0.0111001479,
-0.0446379818,
-0.0281686205,
-0.0548623055,
-0.0147973197,
0.0183077604,
0.0689598471,
-0.0497999825,
-0.0027682474,
0.0176799167,
-0.0631873533,
0.0652196109,
-0.0053927931,
0.0101226326,
-0.0178619996,
0.0163185243,
0.0598722249,
-0.0241058711,
0.0245192535,
-0.0432124287,
0.0358553976,
0.0585039183,
0.0484200977,
0.0079631563,
-0.0515257865,
-0.0008943938,
0.0460296199,
0.0035479518,
0.0084300051,
0.0419426486,
0.0627784431,
-0.048682157,
-0.0277468748,
0.0984841138,
-0.0001164296,
-0.044605229,
0.0006460469,
0.0365611352,
0.1064437106,
-0.0123204263,
-0.0059809736,
-0.084923923,
-0.0383443795,
0.0515019856,
0.0405184254,
-0.008255627,
-0.0129102329,
-0.0263175312,
-0.0785773247,
0.0377976932,
0.0135647869,
-0.0392711349,
-0.0049519385,
-0.0384117067,
-0.0546614043,
0.0015560981,
0.0229779258,
0.0375676192,
0.0391856954,
0.0147609385,
0.020581102,
0.0000605105,
-0.0645858422,
0.0067863283,
-0.0207549445,
0.0628094822,
0.0541186333,
-0.0075298226,
0.0401485935,
-0.00021724,
0.0030566319,
-0.022402633,
-0.0357363969,
-0.0080664866,
0.0399833359,
-0.0186643247,
0.0176120289,
0.0056585255,
0.037891794,
-0.0533383191,
-0.017092457,
-0.0281231422,
0.0132857123,
-0.0039148135,
-0.0268528294,
-0.0093103526,
-0.0154381646,
0.0439929292,
0.0635922998,
0.0347411856,
-0.0081039518,
-0.0500104018,
-0.0153004145,
-0.0195931606,
-0.1085278839,
0.0279052667,
0.0086910678,
0.0312870443,
-0.038297575,
-0.045246169,
0.0069926372,
0.0125859389,
0.0574308299,
-0.0182595942,
0.0377629437,
0.0114386212,
-0.0273224786,
-0.0874521434,
0.0182528049,
-0.0136837875,
0.0104169045,
-0.0240354091,
-0.0309074428,
-0.0109175332,
-0.0161598101,
-0.0293574072,
0.0383163765,
-0.1547074169,
-0.0758292899,
0.0095407637,
0.0291439816,
0.0236974489,
0.0588086657,
-0.0390845686,
-0.0365774333,
0.0780398846,
0.0213189479,
-0.0750603154,
0.0009740165,
0.0203193016,
-0.0484941751,
0.0055523678,
0.0443088561,
-0.0173768159,
0.0132640954,
0.0135256452,
0.0451722331,
0.0055304244,
-0.0084712263,
0.0295258518,
0.0192819424,
0.028241178,
-0.052807074,
-0.0190081764,
-0.0127134612,
0.0296170209,
0.0068287184,
0.0006328969,
-0.0312497858,
0.0109900432,
0.0311375987,
-0.0498019829,
0.005518306,
0.0460479073,
0.0399321914,
0.0472853668,
-0.0027818296,
-0.0375807285,
-0.0227248091,
0.0284082592,
0.0739841461,
-0.035786584,
-0.0033176928,
0.0303101856,
-0.0201262459,
0.01488904,
-0.0389527977,
0.0002266625,
0.0382185988,
0.0390527509,
-0.0138955321,
0.013795279,
-0.0596387088,
-0.0441821031,
-0.0528771728,
0.0033102455,
0.0455458611,
-0.0010813816,
0.0628604889,
-0.0154806934,
-0.0007014316,
-0.0146936579,
0.0164278764,
-0.0219708979,
-0.014636795,
0.0432916768,
0.0066122352,
-0.0277914722,
-0.0052092331,
0.0863948688,
0.0378931053,
0.0522295237,
-0.0024561686,
0.0094002038,
-0.028006034,
-0.0688296631,
-0.0191997886,
0.0577924326,
-0.041490946,
-0.001288068,
-0.0289983861,
-0.0560410097,
-0.0015965617,
-0.0000786502,
-0.0095949667,
0.0094915284,
0.032555487,
0.0459641069,
-0.0313875042,
-0.0545546152,
-0.0284991637,
-0.0316626467,
0.0204250757,
-0.0224867687,
-0.0100422259,
-6.632800343e-33,
0.0085048284,
0.0059239655,
0.0200158358,
-0.0652663633,
-0.0421605855,
-0.0081598498,
-0.0309244245,
-0.0427352265,
0.0027069286,
0.0292997323,
-0.0283538494,
0.0378638096,
0.0389745273,
0.0594495609,
-0.0183682088,
0.0066893459,
0.0954142362,
-0.025325954,
-0.0306056868,
0.0159036312,
0.0402888618,
0.0392598882,
0.0106786033,
0.0004703297,
0.0038072402,
-0.0378453322,
-0.0179262366,
-0.0140754757,
0.0082083633,
0.0334676094,
-0.0188692249,
0.01326901,
0.0133667924,
-0.0262264609,
-0.0565804951,
0.0047292481,
-0.1070586964,
0.0100846877,
0.0343670174,
0.0156319495,
-0.0065207682,
-0.0222595539,
-0.0217036568,
0.0205603596,
0.0049396404,
-0.0197075158,
-0.0316060819,
0.0000553775,
-0.0306734275,
-0.0514989123,
-0.0318527743,
0.0225616414,
0.0017907186,
-0.0000204564,
0.0675019175,
0.0007948098,
-0.0032438496,
0.0013766092,
-0.0773810297,
0.014299904,
-0.0303165969,
0.0581208542,
0.0698316097,
0.0257486813,
-0.0162994731,
0.0331678092,
0.0142844813,
-0.0185558032,
-0.0457856879,
-0.0183149446,
0.039205499,
0.0420125052,
-0.029851187,
0.0319675915,
0.0965391919,
-0.0446423143,
-0.0369524918,
0.0183889288,
-0.0025356277,
0.0108387629,
0.0576936826,
0.0164167434,
-0.0211221464,
-0.0368390009,
-0.0744786263,
-0.0199720189,
-0.0258349311,
-0.0043529668,
0.041757565,
0.0419806391,
-0.0275936071,
-0.0241771378,
0.0641835481,
-0.0592707545,
0.0377740785,
0.0462018996,
-0.0107058724,
0.0108677587,
-0.0199824441,
0.0252332296,
-0.0350986756,
-0.0318142995,
0.0558369793,
0.0076901126,
-0.0119367717,
0.0066917911,
0.0156594105,
-0.0023682024,
-0.050479237,
0.0029333392,
-0.0491324179,
0.0456718393,
0.0026420264,
0.0477187037,
0.0696825981,
0.0143910311,
-0.001274205,
-0.0081829289,
0.0026482334,
0.0236699414,
-0.012556388,
0.0409986973,
0.0106550651,
0.0550293662,
0.0028832166,
0.0178504568,
-0.0498409346,
-0.029110454,
0.0197651926,
-0.033784233,
-0.0214731619,
0.0719525814,
2.63e-7,
0.0214870237,
0.0067922594,
0.0567416437,
0.0095488569,
0.0050869868,
0.0045608254,
0.0050654332,
0.0018549495,
-0.0118287988,
-0.039739497,
0.0074492209,
0.0467499346,
0.0759887025,
0.0426049344,
-0.0971183702,
-0.0000664566,
-0.0255263448,
0.0118874125,
-0.032087706,
-0.0483876728,
0.0045948653,
0.0848136246,
-0.0106445514,
-0.0358720273,
0.0496222712,
0.0166113935,
0.0148079097,
0.0172405839,
-0.0050440468,
0.0402773954,
-0.004170381,
-0.0301006772,
0.0108740414,
0.0338492692,
-0.0203291476,
-0.0058542443,
-0.041758243,
0.0507284254,
0.0077855946,
-0.0282499958,
-0.0280171949,
-0.0176321361,
-0.0082233315,
-0.0476347096,
0.0480238236,
-0.0272518974,
0.0030217736,
-0.0384502597,
-0.0243613943,
-0.0052006869,
-0.0252569541,
-0.0092960186,
0.0228106435,
0.0724886358,
0.0342307538,
-0.0026335574,
-0.008074549,
-0.0733934119,
-0.0224668216,
-0.0200551804,
-0.0544808693,
-0.0454167165,
-0.0316877775,
-0.0058289496,
0.0551213548,
-0.0814101323,
0.0164100938,
2.874057744e-34,
0.0508085415,
0.0135582658,
-0.0069140466,
0.0514260344,
0.0047234087,
-0.0376141779,
0.0066660773,
0.0360999294,
-0.0088359406,
-0.0568831563,
-0.0156070618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08433v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08433v1 | A Confederacy of Models: a Comprehensive Evaluation of LLMs on Creative Writing | 2023-10-12T15:56:24 | 2023-10-12T15:56:24 | Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Paul Williams | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, 68T50, 00A64, I.2.7; J.5 | We evaluate a range of recent LLMs on English creative writing, a challenging
and complex task that requires imagination, coherence, and style. We use a
difficult, open-ended scenario chosen to avoid training data reuse: an epic
narration of a single combat between Ignatius J. Reilly, the protagonist of the
Pulitzer Prize-winning novel A Confederacy of Dunces (1980), and a pterodactyl,
a prehistoric flying reptile. We ask several LLMs and humans to write such a
story and conduct a human evalution involving various criteria such as fluency,
coherence, originality, humor, and style. Our results show that some
state-of-the-art commercial LLMs match or slightly outperform our writers in
most dimensions; whereas open-source LLMs lag behind. Humans retain an edge in
creativity, while humor shows a binary divide between LLMs that can handle it
comparably to humans and those that fail at it. We discuss the implications and
limitations of our study and suggest directions for future research. | [
0.0502045415,
0.0197922848,
-0.0186281595,
-0.0067729731,
-0.0447983071,
0.0111177834,
0.0113370446,
0.0191297289,
-0.0213474967,
-0.0571086481,
-0.0344064943,
-0.0089287609,
0.0252134986,
0.0082947742,
0.0147447046,
0.0038093987,
-0.0146851297,
-0.0116725005,
0.0456570424,
0.0005396968,
-0.0566211902,
0.026632471,
-0.0175925922,
0.036235176,
0.0376856998,
-0.0388936549,
-0.0026799082,
0.0585855655,
0.0195605159,
-0.0366284363,
0.0095558772,
0.0375750065,
0.0179081131,
0.0002445735,
0.0000019621,
-0.0569534227,
0.0240714885,
-0.0394679122,
0.0443224087,
0.0190811735,
0.048382666,
0.0626537725,
-0.034078788,
-0.0155633586,
0.0032481868,
0.0824925005,
0.0289660133,
0.0562766604,
0.030213641,
0.0828832015,
0.0253935345,
-0.0502322316,
0.0484834872,
-0.0017079746,
0.0150223812,
0.0618001074,
-0.0146286283,
0.0259905159,
0.0373260826,
-0.0566736609,
-0.028430637,
-0.0087773763,
0.0082409019,
0.006326125,
-0.0049829166,
0.048250284,
0.0149934422,
0.0259646829,
-0.0127604296,
-0.0079044253,
0.0274470393,
0.0095742,
-0.0144858258,
0.0223156512,
0.0118610784,
0.0115419896,
-0.0277607497,
0.0398707427,
-0.0124156708,
0.0030535508,
0.019338008,
-0.0161341466,
-0.0205727182,
0.0277769212,
0.0786791891,
-0.0158529561,
0.0174664296,
0.0028938132,
-0.0264569893,
0.0174148269,
-0.0077836928,
-0.0643455014,
0.0155401453,
0.0352391191,
-0.006778521,
-0.0182837248,
-0.029792184,
0.0029846509,
0.0052105035,
-0.0696172714,
0.0949938297,
0.0160623454,
0.0109567558,
0.0218446739,
-0.0066613769,
0.0453105979,
0.0044564083,
0.0612468645,
-0.0263303556,
0.0706187859,
-0.0540612787,
-0.0035406835,
-0.0129692592,
0.0051552751,
0.0004465177,
-0.0307558589,
-0.0573200956,
-0.0352840051,
0.0251212958,
-0.0070314677,
-0.0189535003,
0.0504529104,
-0.0123230806,
0.0128661096,
-0.0313473046,
-0.0203527082,
0.0164842885,
0.0178324766,
0.0021303541,
-0.0015586539,
0.0032803325,
0.0245463345,
-0.0036574972,
-0.0461676866,
0.0363849364,
0.0558264405,
-0.0121015012,
-0.0421856977,
-0.0652622879,
0.0047609257,
0.0019330315,
-0.0374225043,
0.0087456228,
-0.0567770191,
0.005056039,
-0.0166589431,
0.0340760313,
-0.0561694838,
-0.0246743429,
0.0021301145,
0.0051932968,
-0.0242087375,
-0.01539033,
0.0298604071,
0.0249998048,
0.0116235614,
-0.0323156975,
0.0001308633,
0.1054662541,
0.0563541725,
0.0057818769,
0.015833864,
0.0349915251,
-0.0144650256,
-0.070811443,
0.002744769,
-0.0422653779,
-0.0106195873,
-0.0154738594,
0.0882263109,
0.0411275774,
0.0519003384,
-0.0208503958,
0.0468222164,
0.1123007387,
0.0541166253,
0.0515559167,
0.0285434518,
0.0779361576,
-0.0009930218,
0.0460190549,
0.0383061916,
0.0028146026,
0.0179155245,
-0.0096905576,
0.0214145873,
-0.0105855577,
0.049510546,
-0.0062756096,
-0.0287477169,
-0.0349117853,
0.0135746095,
-0.0136430655,
-0.0246076696,
-0.0403993204,
0.0043061734,
-0.0362840705,
-0.0226551369,
-0.004074519,
-0.07055071,
0.0003331657,
0.0107408967,
0.0773695409,
0.1245488524,
0.0538977608,
0.0158667099,
0.0216504112,
-0.0501828939,
0.0199766085,
0.0354569405,
-0.0073621576,
0.0135823535,
0.0271287672,
-0.0141918976,
0.0266073309,
-0.0825596899,
0.0271624345,
-0.0280008782,
-0.050266955,
0.0433163717,
-0.0216811541,
0.022631865,
-0.0537562072,
0.0692414418,
-0.0839510784,
-0.0382507108,
-0.0238804836,
-0.0245911255,
0.0141714979,
0.0084342984,
-0.0768614411,
0.0129971365,
0.0038663398,
-0.0234986208,
-0.0399410687,
0.0629427955,
-0.0243495069,
-0.0222230684,
0.005172424,
-0.103789188,
-0.0039524334,
-0.0017949115,
0.0332015418,
0.0090952124,
0.0225495547,
-0.0555164777,
0.0134132141,
-0.0267471503,
0.0209744703,
-0.0265967865,
-0.0242809709,
-0.0116783883,
0.0419280231,
-0.0106578125,
0.0330282152,
-0.023939969,
-0.0289468952,
-0.0158281084,
-0.0071760449,
-0.0196287371,
0.0156318154,
0.0407750569,
0.0308571048,
-0.0381066278,
0.0018417146,
-0.0485191792,
-0.088631399,
-0.0467159301,
0.0326905735,
0.0197694506,
0.0034858554,
0.0205710568,
-0.0578247011,
-0.0558327846,
0.0497117713,
-0.0351872519,
-0.0664027184,
0.0030298643,
-0.0133446604,
0.0298225209,
-0.016083844,
-0.0250399485,
-0.0154667562,
0.0107515417,
0.0083134202,
0.0482489616,
0.0389423557,
0.0241282191,
-0.0140839349,
0.0634313896,
-0.0419547446,
-0.0652704313,
-0.0206874926,
-0.0495678261,
0.0321259685,
0.0101540759,
0.0258731544,
0.0339190587,
0.0387652777,
-0.0084678596,
0.0842911229,
-0.0297060534,
0.0100677116,
-0.0169546325,
0.0258557145,
0.0309545845,
-0.0233160034,
-0.0680411905,
-0.0005972157,
0.02874339,
0.0141380671,
0.0107604843,
0.0015915682,
0.0586535409,
0.0117106885,
-0.0368744209,
-0.0081818169,
-0.0423188321,
-0.0114383455,
0.05492156,
-0.0351830497,
-0.0303850863,
0.0595303699,
-0.0223447084,
-0.0205661301,
0.001512945,
0.0185471568,
-0.062229123,
0.0589703992,
-0.0188569743,
0.0292044096,
0.0137647493,
0.0144970408,
-0.058969114,
0.0006844149,
0.0571972504,
-0.0370602161,
0.045132149,
0.0035393243,
-0.0352017395,
-0.0262266751,
-0.0026490071,
-0.0267894343,
-0.0014464771,
-0.0331627354,
0.0064857528,
0.0287643373,
-0.0143173737,
-0.0231203362,
-0.053195782,
0.0379449651,
-0.0274811089,
-0.0056859022,
-0.016063692,
0.0112856263,
0.0118853953,
0.0147367334,
0.0163276419,
-0.0103994142,
-0.0565513074,
0.0083198575,
0.0067729927,
-0.0600845292,
0.0258261226,
-0.0229500607,
0.0428240336,
0.0160103645,
-0.0104434304,
-0.0212869532,
0.0114291972,
0.0644736141,
-0.0371249691,
0.0028893414,
0.0866909772,
0.0082474053,
0.0347221829,
0.0065869247,
-0.0102139991,
-0.0137710357,
0.0099754697,
0.023060821,
-0.0112696011,
0.0109501379,
-0.0029009376,
0.0254949275,
0.0058399742,
-0.0300303735,
-0.0198498778,
-0.0470792316,
0.0483338349,
0.0292111803,
0.0240220074,
0.0296661016,
-0.0018785177,
-0.0421195813,
0.0154775148,
-0.0399344265,
0.0307729896,
-0.002262383,
0.019768009,
-0.025737524,
0.0150043378,
-0.0196529832,
-0.0262646116,
-0.0471715257,
0.0225471389,
0.0293053351,
0.0563995428,
-0.014518911,
-0.0708313361,
-0.0515837446,
-0.0043765162,
0.0299416762,
0.0085283061,
0.0241712965,
-0.018260736,
0.0408174992,
-0.0680970103,
0.0159965605,
0.0133291315,
-0.0340376049,
-0.0009138231,
0.0220354665,
-0.0247601457,
-0.0324799679,
-0.0346900262,
0.0294665266,
-0.0128878932,
0.06220356,
0.0538440011,
-0.045794826,
-0.043787457,
-0.0449676886,
-0.0231954344,
-0.0907588378,
-0.0440251119,
-0.0059899138,
-0.002677741,
0.0289490391,
-0.0917953253,
-0.0121840611,
-0.002205984,
0.0493740365,
0.0354661867,
0.034858115,
-0.1111098081,
-0.0288084131,
-0.0199625157,
0.0042449678,
0.0291664246,
0.0102346642,
-0.0358111076,
0.0146320043,
-0.0309043657,
-0.0776091889,
0.0112063652,
0.0123758754,
-0.0692168102,
-0.0563947074,
0.0281052385,
0.0148265967,
0.018280929,
-0.0433087833,
0.03682914,
-0.0619395524,
0.0440562479,
0.0471519418,
0.0276936423,
0.0948178321,
-0.027219357,
0.042125769,
0.0205409396,
-0.0053306995,
-0.0052140113,
0.0221217982,
0.0493795201,
0.0305348784,
0.0408458039,
-0.0287405681,
-0.0060873791,
0.0162856206,
-0.0181453563,
-0.0771328583,
-0.0233768485,
-0.0389995351,
-0.0220712777,
-0.0091927452,
-0.0260455087,
-0.0341086052,
-0.0194815248,
-0.0014293836,
-0.0289659053,
-0.0206092279,
0.0019562868,
-0.026094256,
0.0573257059,
-0.0743384138,
0.0499713942,
0.0417203233,
-0.0179766901,
-0.0088040642,
0.0116415275,
-0.0266724117,
0.0338974707,
-0.0779010653,
0.0508226529,
0.0434041359,
0.0228800364,
-0.0000401486,
0.0075871181,
0.0048193154,
0.0298982877,
-0.0582258813,
-0.0274725333,
0.0165713727,
0.0014942772,
0.0646071434,
-0.0171653759,
0.0515426956,
0.0059350166,
0.0328143612,
-0.0092396764,
0.0341992639,
-0.0194445215,
-0.0048297029,
-0.0423026383,
0.0194387902,
0.0067283534,
-0.0343207233,
0.0501633435,
-0.0622240491,
0.0118019171,
0.0106341057,
-0.0309839156,
0.000153074,
-0.0279315561,
0.0024413343,
0.0125943637,
0.0576750115,
-0.0209179856,
-0.0662148148,
-0.0075431359,
0.0529916473,
0.0175939202,
0.0439114682,
-0.0460890494,
-0.0067723356,
0.0251921099,
-0.0051347492,
0.0103956619,
-0.0351886041,
-0.0175358579,
-0.0187057666,
0.0057976949,
-0.0221503936,
-5.44113119e-33,
-0.0258493368,
-0.0221791789,
0.0195853747,
-0.0040011639,
-0.0469847433,
-0.0285743587,
-0.0476545915,
0.0402617417,
0.0232424214,
0.0239743851,
-0.0220831875,
-0.0216602497,
-0.0199958943,
-0.0354088284,
0.0242713261,
0.0028656304,
0.0260033533,
-0.009256904,
-0.0475860871,
-0.055540435,
0.0131290611,
0.0127502177,
0.0095324218,
-0.0321751907,
0.0141432229,
-0.05965738,
-0.0290883463,
-0.0653086528,
-0.0082789138,
0.0411018133,
0.012095945,
0.0173216686,
0.0427086093,
0.0217379816,
-0.0014318501,
-0.0473237522,
0.0262753051,
-0.0169535093,
0.0129609276,
-0.0568787307,
0.0168231186,
-0.0686309338,
0.05451487,
0.0179787073,
-0.0359593332,
-0.0246028099,
0.0254350603,
-0.0151078776,
0.0047975867,
-0.0503505319,
-0.0631688386,
-0.0035749753,
-0.0044619413,
-0.0453272052,
-0.0101020299,
-0.0076519446,
0.01225805,
-0.0039148745,
-0.0271867048,
0.0429617837,
-0.0630450845,
0.02107317,
0.0041235243,
-0.0230415333,
-0.0186033938,
0.0950942412,
0.0209081005,
0.0802823678,
-0.0574311316,
0.0256554075,
-0.0278933793,
0.0694793612,
0.0447592475,
0.0687496215,
0.0049953773,
-0.0208274312,
0.020206742,
0.0420956761,
-0.0167588629,
-0.0463096946,
0.0240241848,
0.0248165894,
-0.0250569899,
-0.0517343543,
0.0077548167,
-0.0032482969,
0.0202449262,
-0.0273610801,
0.002870929,
-0.0138256093,
0.0053369021,
-0.0407198519,
-0.0069262343,
0.0063658571,
0.0195151232,
-0.0311823525,
-0.0712960064,
0.0945050567,
-0.0004115574,
-0.0239661261,
-0.0240268279,
-0.0031590743,
0.0281678345,
0.0654779822,
0.0537438244,
0.0087257894,
0.0343628339,
0.0138837136,
-0.0313283205,
0.0020571956,
-0.0180845428,
0.0267211571,
0.0287434701,
-0.0203792974,
-0.0095703648,
-0.0263349377,
0.0120356474,
-0.0448255725,
-0.0040390296,
-0.055587694,
-0.0099955108,
-0.0191928707,
-0.0213521812,
0.0001876056,
-0.0164693389,
0.029714074,
0.0138289277,
-0.020759318,
0.038931407,
-0.0299151093,
-0.0209058747,
-0.0172429178,
2.845e-7,
0.0236649532,
0.0030759752,
0.023648629,
0.0284318347,
0.0297559481,
0.0288791768,
-0.049137909,
0.0200327951,
0.0076892655,
0.0011089636,
0.0127236517,
0.0329744145,
0.0373139679,
0.0362887196,
-0.082283251,
-0.0076255254,
-0.0868385583,
0.043125052,
-0.0542247109,
-0.0344702862,
0.0745444968,
-0.087671794,
0.027167758,
-0.0575773679,
-0.0068614474,
-0.0332165435,
0.0160841867,
-0.0504767336,
0.0044238833,
-0.0053036446,
0.0459621809,
-0.0279338621,
-0.012885781,
0.0091367224,
-0.0138356118,
-0.0180959888,
0.0139211714,
0.0451577604,
0.0072433325,
0.0302149951,
0.0530407242,
0.0123710353,
-0.0291313305,
-0.0390103757,
0.0460679159,
0.0917059779,
-0.0252496824,
-0.0260296483,
0.0030766169,
-0.0079393955,
0.0203775279,
-0.0085111326,
0.0304483082,
0.0022758199,
0.0160831716,
0.01391875,
0.0222987197,
0.0045860889,
-0.0400190167,
0.0131864054,
-0.0495059118,
-0.0246170703,
-0.0395771824,
0.0211805962,
-0.0042205891,
-0.1137265638,
-0.0317574516,
2.36202618e-34,
0.0430826694,
-0.0405201837,
0.0161373243,
0.0346521772,
0.0272649601,
0.0388851874,
0.064016059,
-0.0506973751,
0.0018990573,
0.0063935788,
-0.0132281752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08395v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08395v3 | Prompting Large Language Models with Chain-of-Thought for Few-Shot Knowledge Base Question Generation | 2023-10-12T15:08:14 | 2023-10-23T07:34:28 | Yuanyuan Liang, Jianing Wang, Hanlun Zhu, Lei Wang, Weining Qian, Yunshi Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The task of Question Generation over Knowledge Bases (KBQG) aims to convert a
logical form into a natural language question. For the sake of expensive cost
of large-scale question annotation, the methods of KBQG under low-resource
scenarios urgently need to be developed. However, current methods heavily rely
on annotated data for fine-tuning, which is not well-suited for few-shot
question generation. The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has shown
their impressive generalization ability in few-shot tasks. Inspired by
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting, which is an in-context learning strategy for
reasoning, we formulate KBQG task as a reasoning problem, where the generation
of a complete question is splitted into a series of sub-question generation.
Our proposed prompting method KQG-CoT first retrieves supportive logical forms
from the unlabeled data pool taking account of the characteristics of the
logical form. Then, we write a prompt to explicit the reasoning chain of
generating complicated questions based on the selected demonstrations. To
further ensure prompt quality, we extend KQG-CoT into KQG-CoT+ via sorting the
logical forms by their complexity. We conduct extensive experiments over three
public KBQG datasets. The results demonstrate that our prompting method
consistently outperforms other prompting baselines on the evaluated datasets.
Remarkably, our KQG-CoT+ method could surpass existing few-shot SoTA results of
the PathQuestions dataset by 18.25, 10.72, and 10.18 absolute points on BLEU-4,
METEOR, and ROUGE-L, respectively. | [
0.0344909802,
0.013699878,
0.0034183392,
0.0310641956,
-0.0560334995,
0.0355158448,
0.0406779125,
-0.0166561045,
0.0245910976,
-0.0412164368,
0.0211642589,
-0.0368164293,
-0.0331746116,
0.0208830908,
0.0424131304,
-0.0303296801,
0.016318135,
-0.0303370748,
0.006547051,
-0.0079364758,
-0.0065609291,
0.0031885258,
-0.0277566761,
0.0276804268,
-0.0023621782,
-0.0302848946,
-0.0586999804,
0.0112384278,
0.0055878661,
-0.0503438376,
-0.0062885,
0.0591603406,
0.0256645698,
0.0156683233,
0.0000020452,
-0.0737780631,
-0.0151706785,
0.0163926538,
-0.0506561995,
-0.0491540134,
-0.0188481659,
0.0144518726,
0.0318134949,
0.0400677398,
-0.0440235808,
-0.0008138279,
-0.0002081717,
0.0289959684,
0.0717035234,
0.05366024,
0.006557045,
-0.031890709,
0.0110401353,
-0.0151907625,
0.0655693114,
-0.0227449015,
-0.0051025059,
0.0197813492,
0.0413900986,
0.0206249151,
0.0039934306,
0.0181215871,
0.0387728512,
-0.0158770736,
0.0077735288,
0.0362780504,
-0.0499264076,
-0.0292128026,
-0.0096675307,
0.1189934164,
0.0203979053,
-0.0048184255,
0.0229048077,
0.000059544,
0.0377236269,
0.0009542552,
-0.0314648934,
0.0494023375,
-0.0124630993,
-0.0450255312,
0.0220109038,
0.0210947897,
-0.001666,
-0.0143746659,
-0.0144864051,
0.0443532057,
0.0178255457,
-0.06113258,
0.0060764975,
-0.0162717886,
-0.0353024453,
-0.0952222645,
-0.029047979,
0.0427091457,
-0.0475072451,
0.0195577331,
-0.0408146195,
0.003849952,
0.0113975722,
0.0283862781,
0.0313955955,
0.0448219962,
-0.0091737984,
0.0396941565,
-0.0247405209,
0.0650419444,
0.0144001478,
-0.0054475213,
-0.0454348959,
0.0204063635,
-0.0595479682,
0.001612164,
-0.055319082,
0.0546455272,
-0.0448761061,
-0.0122875161,
-0.0177270994,
0.043087177,
0.020307431,
0.0489819832,
0.025055239,
-0.0006627359,
-0.0028262555,
-0.0181445051,
-0.0280120559,
0.0198215861,
-0.0717146024,
-0.0021929906,
0.0821889639,
-0.0228026286,
-0.0088665234,
0.0196570251,
0.0364844911,
-0.0045549558,
-0.0023329458,
0.0044830418,
-0.0080987038,
-0.0183590706,
-0.0303561855,
-0.0653062984,
0.000676079,
-0.0520831011,
-0.0095452946,
-0.0609009527,
0.038676165,
0.0093708895,
-0.0440437123,
0.019556703,
0.0176574588,
0.0440231375,
0.0055162539,
0.0430525616,
-0.0239174999,
0.004735657,
0.0292945392,
0.0094543295,
-0.0582789928,
0.0543667413,
0.0256646648,
0.014216911,
0.0144332619,
0.0089446651,
-0.0100871148,
0.0007216455,
0.0363697112,
0.0076089511,
0.0053516529,
0.0328385755,
-0.0279199891,
0.0680423081,
-0.0174252596,
0.0466571152,
-0.0415747315,
0.0383707955,
0.010434649,
0.0307755675,
-0.0019699237,
-0.0044479235,
0.084370926,
0.0380224138,
-0.0129432846,
0.0160121322,
-0.046266783,
0.0324798226,
-0.0454269908,
0.0118330326,
0.0250986833,
0.0141074937,
-0.0310490169,
-0.0176611822,
0.0234891437,
0.0276579112,
-0.0191593412,
0.023153685,
0.0077190646,
0.0387821421,
-0.0387154408,
0.0403126404,
-0.0023583951,
-0.0509035848,
-0.0073644859,
-0.0337959863,
0.0766993016,
0.0105861854,
0.0312597118,
-0.0109814592,
-0.0727571845,
-0.0202083495,
0.0359010845,
0.0337996744,
0.0100916792,
-0.0332774147,
-0.0231866147,
-0.0540804565,
-0.0096056275,
-0.0258543063,
0.018149836,
-0.0109739741,
-0.019466592,
-0.007811896,
0.0395851098,
-0.0443819016,
0.0129197575,
0.0233355835,
-0.0400687307,
-0.013094184,
0.0169037338,
0.021308355,
-0.0079720067,
0.0125993136,
0.0054715229,
0.034182597,
0.009389801,
-0.0538505763,
-0.0240846612,
0.0200418271,
-0.0236940384,
-0.1348348558,
0.0175785273,
-0.0002029111,
0.0014101273,
-0.0377190113,
-0.055090379,
-0.0556479245,
-0.0050084936,
0.0017251048,
-0.007904279,
-0.0396202803,
-0.0100595169,
0.0377065986,
-0.0395473726,
-0.0452905148,
0.0888299048,
-0.0047184397,
0.011676251,
0.0346985236,
0.0333639123,
0.0192348529,
-0.0484851785,
0.0053084344,
-0.0140067264,
-0.0362990201,
-0.0075134221,
0.014380658,
0.0608951747,
-0.0819691122,
-0.0198501721,
-0.070445627,
0.0527369045,
-0.0280358195,
0.0212742947,
0.0246228408,
0.0139304549,
-0.0095050447,
-0.0094795516,
-0.0974964499,
0.0268083643,
0.0248284545,
0.005206964,
0.0473477133,
0.0239803325,
0.0026025677,
0.0189938601,
0.0095076803,
-0.0162985623,
0.0403342545,
0.0098716663,
0.0442522317,
-0.0488216057,
0.0259573851,
-0.0426778756,
-0.0141295092,
0.0182281211,
0.0044622989,
0.0367702581,
-0.0310816597,
0.0453943908,
0.0552709252,
-0.0026421319,
-0.0172776412,
0.0245467685,
0.0105761588,
-0.0366129279,
0.0422901139,
-0.001067319,
0.0041135922,
0.0241446141,
-0.0237950291,
0.0115715023,
0.0369056202,
0.001173486,
-0.0186034292,
-0.0701282769,
0.0619550981,
-0.0007031834,
0.0087894555,
-0.07325726,
0.0228333008,
0.0086514065,
0.0615071803,
-0.0150911016,
0.0142087815,
0.0557515658,
-0.0100214081,
-0.0068449271,
-0.0400113165,
0.0302791279,
-0.0124282362,
0.0731575415,
0.0097912299,
0.0137796085,
0.0325830802,
0.0009791795,
-0.0910762399,
0.0254457276,
0.0085770451,
-0.0246256329,
-0.0037098168,
-0.0449950285,
0.002352675,
-0.0107985511,
-0.0554171205,
-0.0574692786,
-0.0208380166,
-0.0114274165,
-0.0070659877,
-0.0233473647,
0.0124365725,
0.0442481227,
0.0129159288,
0.0171296075,
0.0505434908,
-0.0228062868,
-0.0121112512,
-0.0422974192,
0.0913570225,
0.0667143986,
0.0122389961,
0.0377217829,
-0.0047709118,
0.0813504681,
0.0341144651,
0.0231071301,
0.0315361992,
0.0132915424,
0.0122959092,
-0.0151560381,
-0.0094524734,
-0.0264454465,
0.044676505,
0.0587241128,
-0.0632503331,
-0.0543656908,
0.1120617315,
0.0500454642,
-0.0100539103,
-0.016227141,
-0.022797009,
0.0535453707,
0.0227555409,
0.0446863323,
-0.0979969576,
-0.0454844683,
0.0080677001,
0.0141149228,
-0.0334817693,
-0.0756323114,
0.0002166431,
-0.1506881118,
0.0414361507,
-0.020673072,
-0.0300531723,
0.0173492078,
0.0014026311,
-0.0188512132,
0.0248470772,
-0.0280099809,
0.0458051972,
0.0106408736,
0.0337468423,
0.0229038652,
-0.0200050231,
-0.0589316785,
0.0205536392,
-0.0448428504,
0.0328498222,
0.0419075787,
0.0106562991,
0.0278440583,
-0.01958449,
-0.0154198976,
-0.0063852062,
-0.0077483905,
-0.0018003744,
0.0032313135,
0.0101099256,
-0.0231795795,
-0.0299620591,
0.0797070041,
-0.0310248714,
0.0062446231,
0.0651659742,
0.0680324063,
-0.0345366746,
-0.0183676556,
0.0021313992,
0.0159900207,
0.0091240834,
0.0786304325,
0.0456502214,
-0.0402553007,
-0.0064986618,
-0.022636706,
-0.0100725219,
-0.0807144046,
0.0130445845,
0.0431655645,
0.0284001995,
0.0276142191,
-0.1158599928,
-0.0372088104,
0.047858648,
0.0665537044,
-0.005131409,
-0.0189431887,
0.0181677658,
0.0066326507,
-0.0157110486,
0.0168216228,
-0.0217021909,
-0.0375396647,
-0.0495701879,
0.0037101475,
0.0243981984,
-0.0373708382,
-0.037399929,
0.0088522667,
-0.0920270309,
-0.0466968976,
-0.0311102029,
0.054811839,
0.0149945933,
0.0185758248,
-0.0113202753,
-0.020297559,
0.0383391343,
0.0174980164,
-0.0059250928,
-0.0265452936,
-0.0332817212,
0.0087879067,
-0.0163271315,
0.0388107561,
-0.0528409928,
0.0071568438,
-0.0207303707,
0.0779728815,
-0.0298591629,
-0.0029613457,
0.0457621627,
0.0444896407,
-0.0011967528,
-0.0350132659,
-0.0149409855,
-0.0295129474,
0.0196952429,
-0.0385753848,
-0.045397684,
-0.0763490722,
0.0134537667,
0.000752696,
-0.0272396971,
0.030403249,
-0.0466377512,
-0.0266732499,
0.0537152365,
-0.0034244484,
-0.0340179652,
0.0291916057,
0.0254585426,
0.0632191375,
-0.0448868796,
-0.0209100395,
-0.0054188343,
0.0004197741,
0.0355889499,
-0.0203987304,
0.1050051749,
0.0409094617,
0.0007617319,
0.0060884622,
0.0288129952,
-0.0260559134,
-0.0589287877,
0.0098279277,
0.0335979909,
0.0306029096,
0.0437658653,
-0.0333955921,
-0.0196580831,
-0.0155138858,
0.0101071224,
0.0619078241,
0.0166945402,
-0.0616340376,
0.0577529781,
0.0312135685,
-0.0155022973,
-0.0149037512,
0.0503143631,
-0.0011610162,
0.0187771432,
0.024262879,
0.0387056656,
-0.0551652685,
-0.012499433,
-0.0164372474,
0.0112454994,
-0.0058735916,
0.0437502787,
-0.0615469925,
-0.0544068255,
-0.0033369111,
-0.0039383611,
-0.0125746867,
0.0011287651,
0.047932405,
0.0421113297,
-0.0165400505,
-0.0155129116,
-0.0278532878,
0.0075905682,
-0.0688935146,
-0.0683229119,
0.0000172945,
-6.284095821e-33,
-0.0167594831,
-0.028488297,
0.0597072542,
-0.0585005842,
-0.0174860414,
-0.0163235776,
-0.0427011214,
0.0148024876,
-0.0031836489,
0.0063911481,
-0.0179294292,
-0.02413892,
-0.0181059483,
0.0549431853,
0.0069228997,
-0.0360255614,
0.0150306234,
-0.0209782608,
-0.0253681652,
0.0515350513,
0.0255636834,
0.0289321467,
-0.028874442,
0.0370841026,
0.0043036472,
-0.0404892117,
-0.0119698038,
0.0529810973,
-0.0307684392,
0.0257131029,
-0.0199190434,
-0.0085830577,
0.0320318453,
-0.0197994672,
0.0161728635,
0.0277090613,
-0.0214100108,
-0.0288939439,
-0.0098791923,
-0.0374009199,
-0.0785057098,
-0.0263596606,
-0.0044842865,
-0.0290265605,
0.0396727547,
-0.0125144944,
-0.0111453375,
-0.0100500444,
-0.0222372115,
-0.0387933031,
-0.0267601889,
-0.0019046901,
-0.0118615404,
-0.0694665834,
-0.0414174236,
0.0988309532,
-0.0121557629,
0.0068594362,
-0.0101700546,
0.0014644805,
0.0108446172,
0.0073538721,
0.0310776178,
0.0231965389,
-0.0053953547,
0.0190048572,
-0.0010544925,
-0.0122491177,
-0.0242185742,
0.0512422472,
-0.0193108413,
0.0562198684,
0.0362653956,
0.0636591241,
0.0414122269,
0.0335164778,
-0.0856829509,
0.0226309672,
0.0131470785,
-0.0026804521,
0.0025741803,
-0.0604070239,
-0.0040485607,
-0.0131151741,
-0.0585062653,
0.0042264867,
-0.0375700854,
-0.0133632347,
0.0600866601,
-0.0060918308,
-0.0214839317,
-0.0450019315,
0.037857011,
-0.0083400048,
0.01829914,
0.011072726,
-0.0308595262,
0.0284374431,
-0.0154910469,
0.0544500835,
-0.0509018488,
-0.0086787846,
0.0189893041,
0.0037484781,
0.0066557317,
0.054829862,
0.044864364,
-0.0111412369,
-0.0378947183,
-0.0051388484,
-0.0501255281,
0.0541103594,
-0.0285213906,
0.0163092092,
0.0082314797,
0.0336846411,
-0.0101186177,
0.0412122682,
0.0046277493,
-0.0310820211,
-0.0074064727,
0.002830433,
-0.0039178347,
0.0158264879,
-0.0301515423,
0.0075954539,
-0.0196111556,
0.0059176092,
0.0054596076,
-0.0422339588,
-0.003786375,
0.0180691183,
2.806e-7,
-0.0069277422,
0.0359246209,
0.0015061377,
0.0479879342,
0.0126521774,
0.0266382676,
0.0047672237,
0.0073455479,
0.0316860192,
-0.0560624562,
0.0154099884,
0.0027153371,
0.0216914881,
0.012330764,
-0.1224923432,
-0.0164627396,
-0.0423180237,
-0.0283081215,
-0.0594585091,
-0.0061522052,
0.1005778313,
0.0608569458,
-0.0183853153,
-0.0049756947,
0.0344192833,
-0.0277445372,
0.0435173772,
0.0319932401,
-0.0251232143,
0.017036682,
0.0182527844,
0.0106200799,
-0.0023147666,
0.0473338217,
0.0027573844,
-0.0049026674,
-0.0260276496,
0.0304189008,
0.0431399271,
0.0005362153,
0.003495076,
-0.0061083422,
0.0177761912,
-0.0492901579,
0.0798358396,
-0.0796821192,
-0.0100164795,
0.0122858975,
-0.0143640907,
-0.0413644239,
-0.0230569802,
-0.0309201553,
-0.0023670655,
-0.0068680733,
0.0266783126,
-0.006255094,
0.0421622582,
-0.0293222405,
-0.0030732171,
0.0225159414,
-0.0077471966,
-0.0350940675,
-0.0488959663,
-0.0095618414,
-0.0190589763,
-0.0562073514,
-0.0138811627,
2.618812233e-34,
0.0185444243,
-0.0127886999,
0.0313144177,
0.0101995142,
0.0233144946,
-0.0160637312,
-0.0403600819,
-0.0228325892,
0.0350463092,
-0.0917807445,
-0.0029133367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08394v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08394v2 | Towards Better Evaluation of Instruction-Following: A Case-Study in Summarization | 2023-10-12T15:07:11 | 2023-10-20T10:42:59 | Ondrej Skopek, Rahul Aralikatte, Sian Gooding, Victor Carbune | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite recent advances, evaluating how well large language models (LLMs)
follow user instructions remains an open problem. While evaluation methods of
language models have seen a rise in prompt-based approaches, limited work on
the correctness of these methods has been conducted. In this work, we perform a
meta-evaluation of a variety of metrics to quantify how accurately they measure
the instruction-following abilities of LLMs. Our investigation is performed on
grounded query-based summarization by collecting a new short-form, real-world
dataset riSum, containing 300 document-instruction pairs with 3 answers each.
All 900 answers are rated by 3 human annotators. Using riSum, we analyze the
agreement between evaluation methods and human judgment. Finally, we propose
new LLM-based reference-free evaluation methods that improve upon established
baselines and perform on par with costly reference-based metrics that require
high-quality summaries. | [
0.0427856483,
-0.002617531,
0.0021146862,
0.000530791,
-0.0174427927,
0.0238580424,
-0.001083388,
-0.0314510241,
-0.0114318915,
-0.0619231053,
-0.0342019461,
0.0029592512,
0.0258963276,
-0.0349037424,
0.0127906706,
-0.0675306916,
0.0290811528,
-0.0307182148,
-0.0354505815,
0.0148945358,
0.0157046262,
0.0092443898,
0.0025126638,
0.0619136021,
0.0564457774,
-0.0131173059,
-0.0026721479,
0.0030338892,
0.0109429685,
-0.0143400803,
0.001457274,
0.0376933813,
0.0107323686,
0.0265583489,
0.0000020511,
-0.0504504144,
-0.0023159913,
0.0109023126,
-0.0191498101,
0.0495958515,
0.0517892092,
0.0278589334,
0.0140268086,
0.0241062008,
-0.0159648303,
0.0120374002,
0.0073581743,
0.0146055641,
0.118211776,
0.0299508795,
0.0204014163,
-0.0136233093,
0.0198056996,
0.0044141635,
0.0263296831,
-0.0178990718,
-0.0229593888,
0.0483881049,
0.0409484692,
0.0294164605,
0.0085004615,
0.0403931886,
0.0161045101,
-0.0395332389,
0.0040703928,
0.0173841212,
-0.0532527901,
0.0121589759,
0.0141123254,
0.0841759816,
0.0327214375,
0.0219366923,
-0.0179044474,
0.001746843,
0.0135500412,
0.0378410332,
-0.0762495324,
0.0287846867,
0.0031995357,
-0.0095931301,
-0.0108923316,
0.0109947091,
-0.0077897739,
-0.007829709,
0.0042768242,
0.0677464008,
0.0029428767,
-0.0275963545,
0.0265140776,
0.0145081077,
-0.0402346998,
-0.0571259223,
0.0047291918,
0.0449095704,
-0.013433937,
-0.0012968123,
-0.0338893943,
-0.0083786873,
0.0617204681,
-0.0518288277,
0.0718229413,
0.0123402486,
0.0167309046,
0.059448909,
-0.0165852811,
0.0614981912,
0.0506958552,
0.0343249552,
-0.0630253106,
0.0507415868,
-0.0761728883,
-0.0025595441,
-0.0123469019,
0.0481118187,
-0.027287364,
-0.0142767737,
-0.0363167077,
0.020559445,
0.0097030345,
0.0196854845,
0.0117399562,
-0.0245588608,
0.0031074928,
0.0204301942,
-0.0326132998,
0.0140557513,
-0.0484063253,
0.0006559617,
0.0033720522,
-0.0390858464,
0.0211268663,
0.011853029,
-0.0200414751,
0.0026536204,
0.003889265,
0.0331818983,
-0.0089124227,
-0.0334661156,
-0.0152950976,
-0.041307386,
0.0197447184,
-0.0320658833,
-0.0170692634,
-0.0849662796,
0.0037456795,
0.0345559977,
-0.0032937098,
0.0084528858,
0.0134587046,
0.0509082824,
-0.0215562508,
0.0131274927,
-0.0043220962,
0.0337858684,
0.0335289761,
0.0094913272,
0.0125624649,
0.0485593714,
0.0582378581,
0.0336849429,
0.0485506319,
-0.0083322609,
0.0121290367,
0.015071949,
-0.0045705605,
0.021522902,
0.0173257049,
0.0257080216,
-0.0270436313,
-0.013938413,
-0.0085628461,
0.0676231086,
-0.0190098658,
0.0256774463,
0.0397352874,
0.0858957171,
-0.0036033175,
-0.0516827479,
0.0513787121,
0.0315762237,
0.0333868116,
0.0517983213,
-0.0256587006,
0.0207378138,
-0.0393795483,
0.0568898991,
0.0504381023,
0.0091888718,
-0.0156033719,
-0.0828934088,
-0.0150971999,
0.0110273594,
-0.0113550723,
-0.0020705487,
0.0159469433,
-0.0084538953,
-0.041287668,
0.0134378038,
0.0114590237,
-0.0662999302,
0.0274324752,
-0.0486721769,
0.0158529039,
0.0723543167,
0.0456935428,
-0.0275600925,
-0.0355811641,
-0.0171986297,
0.0629504621,
0.0176929459,
0.0183069613,
-0.0366443209,
-0.0130174765,
-0.049884405,
-0.0285210665,
-0.0154272299,
-0.0025404431,
-0.0103390254,
-0.0142367017,
-0.0285115354,
0.030691389,
-0.0687925443,
-0.1112170145,
0.0438658744,
-0.0285940655,
-0.0406286605,
-0.055301901,
-0.0014056256,
-0.0078934273,
0.0351290666,
-0.0064318087,
0.0325387307,
0.0176433884,
-0.0066139707,
0.0196709651,
-0.0149173299,
-0.0322787724,
-0.0106782978,
0.0324269719,
-0.0756459758,
-0.0048940326,
-0.0036065229,
-0.0328728706,
-0.0474575199,
-0.020477131,
-0.0618913211,
0.0084998012,
-0.0246324781,
0.0168082081,
-0.0024587477,
-0.0552394316,
-0.0631950125,
0.0230973903,
-0.0221242569,
0.044577904,
0.0707926154,
-0.0414144993,
0.0171805304,
-0.0055911825,
-0.0332150273,
-0.0024518962,
0.0120683797,
0.0280947573,
0.0464021452,
0.0557738021,
-0.0426678583,
-0.0339549184,
-0.0911279842,
-0.0064607449,
-0.0208201241,
0.0345172286,
0.0519631132,
0.0050675571,
-0.0033170437,
-0.0099303294,
-0.0518032722,
-0.0590520464,
0.0194149818,
0.026937332,
0.0395750031,
0.0272487178,
0.0187650099,
-0.0809699669,
-0.0447212905,
-0.0109548969,
0.0361763351,
0.0519457869,
0.0307067819,
-0.0434496626,
0.0207899809,
-0.0017982466,
-0.0413892902,
0.0233547799,
-0.0129046617,
0.0193334073,
0.0058676791,
0.0259429254,
0.0557275116,
0.0270767137,
0.0019245025,
0.0669011399,
-0.0048070489,
-0.071499005,
-0.023925405,
-0.0164830051,
-0.0422054231,
0.0057874904,
-0.0702849105,
0.0276819896,
0.0380385332,
0.0114379302,
-0.0037603562,
-0.0566704571,
-0.0014981411,
-0.070295468,
-0.0242471863,
-0.0826905817,
-0.0166411996,
-0.0023794421,
0.0327481516,
-0.0192245152,
-0.035602849,
0.0824353248,
-0.0499963313,
0.0148474658,
-0.0538890734,
0.0092842262,
-0.047074955,
0.0102138789,
0.0023018471,
0.0135960644,
-0.0332658589,
-0.0272523351,
-0.0456894226,
-0.0091790352,
0.051874049,
-0.0413006619,
0.0686305687,
-0.0679140314,
-0.0082929693,
-0.0129178483,
0.0304740034,
-0.0161873512,
-0.0399131589,
-0.0146234278,
0.0073646363,
0.0310493764,
0.0106606791,
-0.0163979772,
0.0351748541,
0.0588798933,
0.0430045463,
-0.0351996943,
-0.0320682079,
-0.0121138347,
0.0008763653,
0.0647789314,
-0.0059513841,
0.0247830078,
-0.0674603358,
0.0502298288,
0.0377810635,
0.0534367822,
-0.0103222057,
0.0179517623,
-0.0135640632,
0.028721299,
-0.0671489909,
-0.0046774969,
0.0274420343,
0.057127282,
-0.0495941639,
-0.0187709052,
0.129183352,
0.0479602218,
-0.0445654429,
-0.0143632703,
-0.0190565549,
0.0312401894,
0.0132653294,
0.017919099,
-0.0415981561,
-0.0240322519,
0.0071327756,
0.09144146,
0.0245110318,
-0.0101757096,
0.014401529,
-0.1110890582,
0.0074521708,
-0.0026745647,
-0.0497365594,
-0.0386949554,
-0.0470276214,
0.0163933579,
0.0124458428,
0.0106655648,
0.0475744903,
-0.0559612364,
0.0281290971,
0.0405771621,
-0.0627081618,
-0.0112624159,
0.0244317595,
-0.0289614536,
0.0231459253,
0.0823582411,
-0.0004537914,
0.0090102376,
-0.0227126144,
0.0425800346,
-0.0452661403,
-0.0043234588,
0.0027222377,
0.0706505403,
-0.0292253867,
0.0343509801,
-0.0234041102,
0.0272371806,
-0.0279530771,
0.0224751048,
0.0415018052,
0.0348263755,
0.0088940496,
0.0282695573,
-0.0435993075,
0.0347219221,
-0.0280226525,
0.0756068379,
0.0658097267,
-0.0340938903,
-0.0221976899,
-0.0473390631,
-0.0078305611,
-0.0498934016,
-0.0332663655,
0.0050531314,
-0.067175597,
0.0118494118,
-0.0820140392,
-0.0737521052,
0.0539131798,
-0.0041709705,
0.0218377467,
-0.0091816038,
0.0206386223,
0.0042117555,
-0.0049140779,
-0.0017094415,
-0.0091018453,
0.0294755045,
-0.1058477014,
-0.013168917,
0.0283170417,
0.0049091815,
-0.0137773287,
0.0039780843,
-0.040665891,
-0.0251941103,
-0.0075454437,
0.0538805053,
0.0229822993,
-0.0015461551,
-0.0059612915,
-0.0179652721,
0.0101436116,
0.0152199548,
-0.0091295317,
0.0116581488,
0.024210263,
0.0160387214,
-0.0180283226,
0.0022067176,
-0.0651973709,
0.0182301104,
-0.0222459733,
0.0474694408,
-0.0324501768,
-0.0601602085,
0.0211224426,
0.0593955629,
-0.0080772769,
-0.0135235377,
0.0152624073,
-0.0158330407,
0.0106879035,
-0.0233823881,
-0.0264316201,
-0.0434509926,
0.0261927005,
-0.0063697603,
-0.0201714598,
0.0078236535,
0.0309995394,
-0.0306066759,
0.0361701325,
-0.0450702049,
0.03422153,
-0.0031536822,
0.0181581341,
-0.0398230962,
-0.008615003,
-0.0510695241,
-0.0588331632,
0.0031674679,
0.0408742987,
0.0134460041,
0.0580244884,
0.0176810548,
0.0043080817,
0.0445905365,
0.0745880231,
-0.077117227,
0.000324032,
-0.0388265923,
0.0193958357,
0.0049175983,
-0.0111205941,
0.0688134581,
0.0147093469,
0.0000813261,
-0.0330246277,
0.0467434749,
0.0378230289,
-0.0014499661,
-0.0266060438,
0.0453073531,
0.0089617101,
-0.008419455,
0.0855412409,
-0.0045847963,
-0.0107181454,
-0.0112476321,
-0.0346693397,
-0.0409186259,
-0.0180216804,
-0.0313620009,
0.0237151254,
-0.0173347294,
-0.0292934831,
-0.0922639444,
-0.038225159,
-0.0225869734,
0.0552716516,
0.0230558831,
-0.010755281,
0.0370461568,
0.038756337,
0.0121061904,
-0.0123603763,
-0.0703636929,
0.0004441242,
-0.0428104363,
0.0174395796,
-0.0236140192,
-5.975055785e-33,
-0.0855950788,
-0.0177676566,
-0.015359764,
0.0109544275,
-0.0171448942,
0.0101203518,
-0.0361486152,
-0.0054496229,
-0.0022835189,
-0.002673286,
-0.0062092771,
-0.0063671567,
0.0049003698,
0.0115302578,
0.0273056999,
-0.0151484087,
0.0313073285,
-0.0052030273,
-0.0641573071,
0.0501209497,
0.0319781229,
-0.0294213109,
0.0302042961,
-0.0344320759,
0.0592502952,
-0.0245798696,
-0.0080792084,
-0.0131665431,
0.0037724327,
0.0642387271,
0.0033738278,
0.0255661458,
0.0209530592,
-0.0351820141,
-0.044096332,
0.0124175688,
-0.0610529371,
-0.0364361182,
0.045858752,
-0.0253921598,
-0.0515520051,
-0.0174972285,
0.0247814134,
-0.013695755,
-0.0197307132,
-0.0172078721,
0.0684855059,
-0.0350302048,
-0.0183872338,
-0.0173863582,
-0.0456706733,
0.0220731106,
-0.0317637175,
-0.0339203924,
0.0044662063,
0.0789255649,
-0.0009958864,
0.0028786066,
-0.0251737535,
0.0496105477,
0.0566461384,
0.0449817367,
0.0726836249,
0.0141781,
0.0049294443,
0.0403309576,
-0.0205452908,
0.0067957174,
-0.0030522426,
0.0131838815,
0.0264309663,
0.0082953796,
0.0326322801,
-0.0030960813,
0.0121386079,
0.0493790992,
-0.0132848052,
0.0883108675,
-0.0047410615,
0.0443853363,
0.0273006875,
-0.0403601043,
-0.072627686,
-0.0330223292,
-0.0590144582,
0.0139937699,
-0.0197040197,
-0.0257319547,
0.0249034688,
-0.0174873546,
-0.0599992163,
-0.0391488113,
0.0246070307,
-0.0119353021,
-0.0174438804,
-0.0010902962,
-0.0184079297,
0.0430846103,
-0.0023609642,
0.0008499847,
-0.0508242734,
0.0264530983,
0.0105699934,
0.0067346371,
0.0243204869,
0.0059161843,
0.0286463462,
-0.0077358815,
-0.0510937274,
-0.0025901669,
-0.0111321658,
-0.0080897659,
-0.0296170805,
-0.0324060991,
0.0060689799,
-0.0005787949,
-0.0160154849,
0.0795496777,
-0.033883106,
-0.0238301512,
-0.028930055,
-0.0454422273,
0.0117555009,
0.0111984713,
-0.0335513018,
0.0260106847,
-0.0156996939,
0.0294629894,
0.027933808,
-0.0250456277,
-0.0056512612,
-0.0042451858,
2.639e-7,
0.0684958696,
0.052624926,
0.0431511961,
0.0255655181,
-0.0485792644,
0.0115362583,
-0.0233578384,
-0.0140388142,
0.0694680959,
-0.0004946598,
0.0304068867,
0.0185878538,
0.0394964628,
0.0276760086,
-0.0672218874,
-0.0328796878,
-0.066909261,
-0.0088955164,
-0.0324541032,
-0.0215777103,
0.060665682,
0.0151359029,
-0.0286231302,
0.0175718516,
-0.0442008153,
-0.0112472586,
0.0104618929,
-0.0351350829,
-0.0189215411,
0.0294676051,
0.0684477761,
-0.0003485452,
0.0151561163,
0.007253143,
-0.0132627664,
-0.021598788,
0.0649955273,
0.063163504,
0.016316954,
-0.0062733935,
-0.0058676396,
-0.0443549901,
0.0454475395,
-0.0146606462,
0.0459141992,
-0.0198416915,
0.0126411058,
-0.0212785564,
-0.0578779876,
-0.0200222135,
0.0087546548,
0.0001072287,
-0.0309850238,
0.0418464169,
-0.0117570404,
-0.018051913,
0.0113777136,
-0.0335918814,
-0.025580883,
0.0270351153,
0.01915792,
-0.0898622423,
-0.0229213666,
0.0039118412,
-0.0531104133,
-0.0636325553,
-0.0260337926,
2.61420783e-34,
0.052513402,
-0.0173170827,
0.0351670273,
-0.0078754593,
0.0229853988,
-0.0019550554,
-0.0126830498,
-0.001902011,
0.0310595185,
-0.0972467214,
-0.0164461806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08383v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08383v3 | Reconstructing Materials Tetrahedron: Challenges in Materials Information Extraction | 2023-10-12T14:57:24 | 2024-04-26T19:12:13 | Kausik Hira, Mohd Zaki, Dhruvil Sheth, Mausam, N M Anoop Krishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci | The discovery of new materials has a documented history of propelling human
progress for centuries and more. The behaviour of a material is a function of
its composition, structure, and properties, which further depend on its
processing and testing conditions. Recent developments in deep learning and
natural language processing have enabled information extraction at scale from
published literature such as peer-reviewed publications, books, and patents.
However, this information is spread in multiple formats, such as tables, text,
and images, and with little or no uniformity in reporting style giving rise to
several machine learning challenges. Here, we discuss, quantify, and document
these challenges in automated information extraction (IE) from materials
science literature towards the creation of a large materials science knowledge
base. Specifically, we focus on IE from text and tables and outline several
challenges with examples. We hope the present work inspires researchers to
address the challenges in a coherent fashion, providing a fillip to IE towards
developing a materials knowledge base. | [
0.0067729228,
0.0707019791,
-0.014579352,
0.0659995079,
-0.031702511,
-0.0016122622,
-0.0177837629,
0.0394769758,
-0.0259984862,
0.0094944313,
-0.0295078754,
0.0331996419,
-0.0043174932,
0.0491513424,
-0.0063977027,
-0.013699932,
0.0062816381,
-0.0073143304,
0.0535467118,
0.0194211937,
-0.0150378747,
-0.0063713216,
-0.029131595,
0.0006141223,
0.0040195016,
-0.002579445,
-0.0140940398,
-0.0422069132,
0.0337076597,
-0.0345853008,
0.0246309433,
0.0167502407,
0.0053857872,
-0.0096119605,
0.000002051,
-0.0215104651,
-0.0087929331,
0.0253609233,
0.0100643979,
0.0051125321,
0.0338245668,
-0.1144624576,
-0.0345260315,
-0.0461720936,
-0.0342465788,
-0.0136143006,
-0.0033639856,
0.0575353839,
-0.0153241679,
-0.0212052055,
-0.0199066792,
-0.0281282794,
0.0692490637,
-0.0095520075,
0.0759624839,
-0.0355708078,
0.0056228014,
0.0084030824,
0.0200169329,
0.0170284938,
0.03355119,
0.0847524926,
-0.0062483503,
-0.0187119525,
0.0567261539,
0.0297463108,
-0.0379024595,
0.0096447598,
-0.020049287,
0.1288335025,
0.034712635,
0.0091318376,
0.0090942951,
-0.0322274677,
-0.0583744012,
0.0130235339,
-0.0189928617,
0.0090258,
-0.0210118778,
-0.0138595458,
-0.0051539117,
0.000155242,
0.0224129986,
0.0200159736,
-0.0209271722,
0.0318680145,
-0.0321675315,
-0.0245305113,
0.0163889155,
0.0050167423,
0.0306712184,
0.011632354,
0.0139515353,
-0.0059541306,
0.0504433401,
0.0247747395,
0.0177215151,
-0.0317973867,
0.0400524549,
-0.0184064396,
0.0191339459,
0.0039221989,
-0.0369489901,
0.0589806139,
-0.0403105542,
-0.0117624328,
-0.00472809,
0.003883814,
-0.0350211449,
-0.0123854131,
-0.0237009041,
-0.0399065204,
-0.0149730025,
0.0020973331,
-0.013495964,
-0.0479013398,
0.0348559134,
-0.0172536615,
-0.0122707505,
0.0334616825,
-0.0061106104,
0.0291921161,
-0.0434590802,
-0.0495674908,
-0.0451844409,
0.0109949326,
0.0120300362,
0.0080488864,
-0.0070506851,
-0.036031872,
-0.0006191049,
-0.0054748044,
0.0498678721,
0.0152871469,
0.0037469631,
0.0712023452,
-0.0452049896,
-0.0423305072,
-0.0431341454,
-0.0466798469,
0.0100459615,
-0.0213830322,
0.0409577452,
-0.0107966447,
0.0913728774,
0.0088868551,
-0.0281561241,
-0.0772932172,
0.0029513792,
-0.0451370068,
-0.0416546091,
0.083301343,
-0.0389676318,
-0.0594326556,
0.0259052124,
0.0076540504,
0.0289677307,
-0.0253419504,
0.0378781855,
0.0683460087,
-0.0105182622,
0.0026198025,
-0.0115895346,
0.0147879729,
0.0234387312,
-0.0687091276,
-0.0128572481,
-0.0367671996,
-0.014330985,
0.0240161084,
0.0139184259,
0.0048876833,
-0.0070949583,
0.0270967819,
0.0340112709,
0.0335876681,
0.0069114785,
0.0743969977,
-0.0024228885,
0.0355228111,
0.0724816993,
-0.0323293656,
0.0215570573,
0.0284401998,
0.0194434617,
-0.0158889368,
0.0234643426,
0.011392938,
0.0157950986,
-0.0571334809,
-0.0049553369,
-0.0132335564,
0.0223069377,
-0.0419459976,
0.0718923435,
-0.000924072,
-0.0456016958,
0.0144500704,
0.0172629878,
-0.0126575436,
-0.0071780509,
0.0427282155,
0.0447207093,
0.0369765237,
0.0148200858,
-0.0878896192,
-0.0306503959,
0.0487222485,
-0.0020280257,
0.0188921113,
-0.0059085698,
-0.0474364869,
0.033162035,
-0.0215373673,
-0.0493284874,
-0.0199411139,
-0.0035003636,
-0.0046408577,
-0.0124671953,
-0.0336003825,
-0.0151713267,
-0.0278412495,
-0.0433056056,
0.0383213572,
-0.0228977669,
-0.0278460011,
0.0286804494,
0.0217439439,
0.0160159748,
0.0177887175,
0.0372651666,
-0.0104012592,
0.0973856077,
-0.0461729728,
-0.0212350599,
-0.021235371,
-0.0148304058,
-0.0011164346,
0.0140763279,
-0.0647112876,
0.0161327291,
-0.015980484,
-0.0378859229,
0.0007417543,
0.0360944234,
0.0331811123,
-0.0018126145,
0.0346987247,
-0.0288877785,
0.0295060296,
0.0485907011,
-0.0541751161,
0.0567256398,
0.0047586514,
-0.0051504341,
0.0031014816,
-0.0679078475,
-0.0141782816,
-0.012952636,
0.0329560488,
0.0137678506,
0.0068638436,
0.0074087786,
0.0319652744,
-0.0110949185,
-0.0206181388,
-0.0063377563,
0.0323401392,
0.0248219781,
0.0144930594,
0.0143854367,
0.0402196199,
-0.0237868931,
-0.0108331703,
-0.033533901,
0.0111512337,
-0.003735594,
-0.0687699616,
-0.087767899,
0.1082699373,
0.0426276624,
0.0017506736,
-0.0347241201,
-0.0442162678,
-0.0413083956,
0.0354921222,
0.0200815517,
-0.0189056005,
-0.0120617691,
0.0164865069,
0.0174863674,
0.045723889,
-0.0440547355,
-0.0109147485,
0.0086703533,
-0.0208549108,
-0.0064084758,
0.0523437001,
0.0149849309,
0.0778671205,
-0.0170062557,
-0.0086421631,
-0.0081238607,
-0.0092794793,
-0.0293082725,
0.1011204422,
0.0465367585,
-0.0396244824,
0.0691235214,
-0.0002102402,
-0.0015051496,
0.0524528921,
0.010359643,
0.0339523405,
0.039798256,
-0.0371994823,
0.0012588566,
0.0341869891,
0.0486896522,
0.0125564579,
0.0192648713,
0.0313658491,
0.04375083,
-0.0241850503,
0.0072213379,
-0.0625048205,
-0.0103566675,
-0.0142214615,
0.0309832282,
0.0103296014,
0.031737946,
0.0393721722,
-0.0052267108,
-0.007799143,
0.0073825256,
0.0284312572,
-0.0175196771,
-0.0284524765,
-0.0477351844,
0.0329737999,
0.0005848148,
-0.0649827644,
-0.014609471,
0.0052458071,
0.0284027811,
0.0317565575,
0.0286155492,
-0.0391171649,
-0.0384466611,
-0.0036628826,
0.0662560016,
0.0034926804,
0.0079132458,
-0.0103097279,
-0.0810333714,
0.111478366,
0.0331860222,
-0.0242219884,
0.0231425334,
0.0052627372,
-0.0239309371,
0.0792619884,
-0.0138123678,
0.0158320144,
-0.0858996361,
0.0077504162,
0.0038401827,
0.0101282233,
0.0087102894,
-0.0149855427,
-0.0446951836,
-0.0452833027,
0.0174805783,
-0.0065509882,
0.0205944292,
-0.0301304497,
0.0045859241,
0.0588811412,
-0.0249174833,
-0.0437904745,
-0.0284549445,
-0.09918385,
-0.0171131119,
-0.0278883353,
0.0150309466,
0.0116941044,
-0.0401953086,
-0.0103445444,
-0.0537534617,
0.0449220687,
-0.0443488993,
-0.070943594,
-0.091462791,
-0.0240023788,
-0.0062623108,
0.0020426207,
0.0029787684,
0.0434824862,
-0.0480230264,
-0.0329192691,
0.0351889767,
-0.0651333034,
-0.0775521174,
0.0090621505,
-0.0120756133,
-0.0249007791,
0.0047545978,
0.0628363043,
-0.0477241725,
-0.0036360391,
0.0203696098,
-0.0270909332,
0.0034708211,
-0.042564109,
0.0477034189,
0.0185349379,
-0.0093723042,
0.0121912044,
0.0603391044,
-0.0265507642,
-0.0360421054,
-0.001410282,
0.0639182404,
-0.0029415505,
0.0309579819,
-0.0329309255,
-0.0355862454,
0.0282259434,
0.0407427549,
-0.0387589708,
-0.0042976853,
-0.1076517031,
-0.0002130327,
0.0275518131,
-0.0616612285,
-0.00014283,
0.0211956333,
-0.030723244,
0.0275090858,
-0.0307829529,
-0.0046309731,
-0.0122560402,
0.002399991,
-0.0091857994,
-0.0345182158,
-0.0008731995,
0.0127939014,
-0.0724915788,
0.0231736172,
-0.0155649716,
-0.0146126598,
0.0077402722,
-0.0169266555,
0.018174924,
-0.0314787179,
-0.0289467685,
0.0363514051,
0.0145188021,
-0.0291110184,
0.0030159287,
-0.0126884989,
0.0162122864,
0.0384337269,
-0.0081122788,
-0.0354195908,
0.0726795942,
0.0136216469,
-0.063099362,
-0.0456083305,
-0.0166333392,
-0.037782114,
-0.0347156338,
-0.0255641975,
0.0064265472,
0.0220152587,
-0.0330320597,
-0.0058265007,
-0.0196228195,
-0.0471780188,
0.0155266551,
0.003479254,
0.0197118316,
0.0398299992,
0.0143354209,
-0.0377313048,
0.0010147769,
0.0522774905,
0.0060332376,
-0.0204552561,
0.0291602463,
0.0179669559,
-0.0543746278,
-0.036535576,
0.0222521871,
0.0615828261,
0.0663235113,
-0.0353001207,
0.0144239506,
0.0207017865,
0.031204544,
0.0439484641,
-0.0252077673,
-0.0018675566,
0.0180985853,
-0.0448000431,
0.0655114278,
-0.0376928896,
-0.0070386743,
0.0266743116,
0.011578463,
-0.0472492948,
0.0617671907,
-0.051682055,
-0.0470908731,
-0.0717833564,
-0.0342206024,
0.0121939695,
0.0311236549,
0.0316784754,
-0.0357104801,
-0.0261423625,
0.0119481599,
0.0439293198,
-0.0096991817,
0.0298962239,
0.0262114834,
0.0065460172,
0.0011937541,
-0.0104963696,
0.0559469834,
0.0526249595,
-0.017172819,
-0.0079858238,
-0.0254570544,
-0.0413772836,
0.0067267101,
-0.0183541849,
0.0108770598,
-0.0199494176,
-0.055461973,
-0.0153738037,
0.0235365033,
0.0394472368,
0.0673838779,
-0.0134077379,
-0.0129555753,
-0.0033277483,
0.1108403951,
0.0197157487,
-0.0500088222,
-0.0241042152,
0.0025346952,
-0.0152069815,
-0.0286813434,
0.0098421425,
-6.16350406e-33,
0.0153352395,
0.0262143426,
-0.0198804457,
0.0087099737,
-0.0017754291,
-0.0219798926,
-0.0557453893,
-0.0562776811,
0.0126002375,
0.0491741523,
-0.0137168011,
-0.0001957405,
0.0241758656,
-0.0150137069,
0.0496077389,
-0.0066823014,
0.0078255739,
0.0264455136,
-0.0252529699,
0.0156378727,
0.0245304741,
0.0469982214,
0.062640965,
-0.0607091449,
0.0232495461,
0.0259647332,
0.0433475487,
-0.0575355031,
0.0200467464,
0.0325029679,
-0.0825583339,
-0.0023800435,
0.0246040318,
-0.0450395085,
-0.019443633,
0.0026626284,
-0.1335648745,
0.0059350356,
-0.0377778895,
0.0056615849,
-0.048459474,
0.0211578608,
0.0204422772,
-0.0072653578,
-0.0258694775,
-0.0105424728,
0.0663381293,
-0.0327702425,
0.0144701069,
-0.0354339369,
-0.0857590288,
-0.002143997,
0.0047678091,
0.0412300639,
0.0608485341,
0.0166653339,
-0.0113392267,
0.0431241244,
-0.0789683089,
0.0173648428,
0.0037403891,
0.0388883799,
0.0303121954,
0.0063364124,
-0.0016882048,
0.0009351528,
0.0147506166,
0.0017852805,
0.0116261998,
-0.0075910236,
0.0076605771,
0.0967735499,
0.0418595336,
0.0146601303,
0.0473832265,
-0.0071862251,
-0.1173954681,
0.0053121345,
-0.0016630878,
0.0242502764,
-0.0091637122,
0.0118868388,
0.0272098817,
0.0096966652,
0.0111246072,
0.019006826,
0.0312165134,
0.0053430982,
-0.0324074365,
0.0202793572,
-0.0812417045,
0.0407718904,
-0.0098688435,
-0.0130662667,
-0.0261933636,
0.0570370965,
-0.0151579687,
0.0461942703,
-0.0130665721,
-0.0475916974,
-0.0988664404,
-0.0491812378,
-0.0712668821,
0.0128079951,
0.0485322252,
0.00545514,
0.0009696294,
0.0279304013,
0.0145507511,
0.0047516734,
-0.0354338214,
-0.0164853092,
0.0213924125,
0.012524602,
-0.0112388479,
0.0074502351,
0.006950513,
-0.013561653,
0.0185977966,
0.0437727422,
0.0253952518,
0.0200024806,
0.007325781,
-0.0128132449,
-0.0016933744,
-0.043015264,
-0.0606970005,
-0.0013868755,
0.039626848,
-0.0375452824,
0.0335583277,
0.0278675854,
2.73e-7,
0.0525960289,
0.0464073122,
0.0792020261,
0.0042005489,
-0.0068847248,
0.013369251,
-0.0004552664,
0.0036103618,
-0.0363895334,
-0.0281295478,
0.0605113134,
0.0172830354,
0.0428555571,
0.0236613173,
-0.0837201104,
-0.0563276783,
-0.0054195723,
-0.05572135,
-0.0717583895,
0.0043501169,
0.0034275008,
0.0260516144,
-0.0438065119,
-0.057770364,
-0.0110592674,
-0.0193823669,
0.0249682851,
-0.0188006572,
0.0487716347,
0.0657232478,
0.0628494695,
-0.0570840612,
-0.0583519638,
0.0547949187,
-0.0273013413,
0.0086678853,
-0.0014036658,
0.0092324121,
0.0229601096,
0.0365312546,
-0.0021609622,
-0.0422891676,
0.0594567508,
0.0058247223,
0.0494197048,
-0.0088691777,
-0.003378585,
0.0277410429,
0.0151694724,
0.0150159318,
-0.0209047124,
-0.0054311841,
0.0002448411,
-0.004663785,
-0.0135696223,
0.0234033633,
-0.0043565254,
-0.0766821876,
0.0385160856,
0.0501497425,
-0.0045042289,
0.0049309689,
0.0223405901,
-0.0312055126,
0.0211021863,
-0.0502678193,
0.0038452204,
2.369272919e-34,
0.0205149353,
0.0100879548,
-0.0016470219,
0.0346989408,
0.0158221945,
-0.0040936973,
-0.0008884417,
0.0026963647,
-0.0539024435,
-0.0633846968,
0.0122973481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08372v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08372v3 | Improving Factual Consistency for Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue Systems via Knowledge Enhancement and Alignment | 2023-10-12T14:44:05 | 2023-11-03T07:26:42 | Boyang Xue, Weichao Wang, Hongru Wang, Fei Mi, Rui Wang, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) based knowledge-grounded dialogue systems
are prone to generate responses that are factually inconsistent with the
provided knowledge source. In such inconsistent responses, the dialogue models
fail to accurately express the external knowledge they rely upon. Inspired by
previous work which identified that feed-forward networks (FFNs) within
Transformers are responsible for factual knowledge expressions, we investigate
two methods to efficiently improve the factual expression capability {of FFNs}
by knowledge enhancement and alignment respectively. We first propose
\textsc{K-Dial}, which {explicitly} introduces {extended FFNs in Transformers
to enhance factual knowledge expressions} given the specific patterns of
knowledge-grounded dialogue inputs. Additionally, we apply the reinforcement
learning for factual consistency (RLFC) method to implicitly adjust FFNs'
expressions in responses by aligning with gold knowledge for the factual
consistency preference. To comprehensively assess the factual consistency and
dialogue quality of responses, we employ extensive automatic measures and human
evaluations including sophisticated fine-grained NLI-based metrics.
Experimental results on WoW and CMU\_DoG datasets demonstrate that our methods
efficiently enhance the ability of the FFN module to convey factual knowledge,
validating the efficacy of improving factual consistency for knowledge-grounded
dialogue systems. | [
0.0654431656,
0.0308384094,
-0.0242919419,
0.0233831815,
-0.0307592247,
-0.0217245985,
-0.0036499812,
-0.0291895494,
-0.0324657001,
-0.0279163048,
-0.0484204777,
0.0152243217,
0.0216167867,
0.0410897993,
0.0109288646,
-0.0192832258,
0.0913012773,
0.0073589459,
0.0271585826,
-0.0122362757,
0.0189262256,
0.0248673465,
-0.0816562772,
0.0355827063,
-0.0841789618,
-0.0123615637,
-0.0262487307,
-0.0321087576,
0.020769624,
-0.0150869321,
0.0313843973,
0.0368811749,
-0.008544663,
0.0533820353,
0.0000020304,
-0.0421078987,
0.0472059548,
-0.0160213374,
-0.0834075063,
0.001740724,
-0.0264490657,
0.0284465533,
-0.0013921218,
0.0024245088,
-0.0426723324,
-0.0225098561,
0.0585089661,
0.1197429821,
0.0832444057,
0.0651920438,
0.0062533035,
-0.0160769392,
0.0301657785,
0.0028137008,
-0.0529542379,
-0.0234073941,
0.016019376,
0.07118956,
-0.0367421433,
0.0179515816,
0.0188114122,
0.0241657235,
0.0309379343,
-0.0396182537,
0.0209691692,
0.0293796603,
-0.0541082174,
-0.0092808567,
-0.0174096804,
0.0992418081,
0.0338830054,
-0.0189515427,
-0.0379665904,
-0.0303014759,
-0.0218809359,
0.0007738949,
-0.0139751388,
-0.0077336431,
0.0023431978,
-0.0105108041,
-0.0391589105,
0.0167053957,
0.0094360216,
0.0341548137,
0.0020769418,
0.0911376402,
-0.0097373892,
-0.0536212549,
-0.0055470746,
0.0043350537,
0.0294695087,
-0.0835710093,
0.0017540033,
0.0445886292,
-0.0383997187,
0.033695966,
-0.0403913893,
0.0299199931,
0.0381621234,
-0.0739019886,
-0.0039743776,
0.0366931893,
-0.0349550284,
0.0380151905,
-0.0141747352,
0.0839834213,
0.0075020576,
0.0128559312,
0.0035194659,
0.0143487966,
-0.0423941351,
-0.0323005095,
-0.0354301408,
0.0114222439,
-0.047073219,
-0.0235841535,
-0.0267493892,
0.0380341746,
-0.0219410472,
0.060638573,
0.0090385713,
0.0202852953,
-0.0292623248,
0.0155597059,
-0.0922805816,
0.0894786716,
-0.06674961,
0.0486795567,
0.0177884232,
-0.0474361554,
-0.0296095628,
0.0004536608,
0.0081947306,
-0.0046587223,
-0.0182593036,
0.0142744407,
-0.0072998772,
0.0088576311,
-0.0436931029,
-0.0218411032,
-0.0453643315,
-0.072781235,
-0.0462788269,
-0.0217523724,
0.0494565219,
-0.0194779765,
-0.0504649505,
-0.0128815472,
0.0245874766,
0.0070835822,
-0.0159650352,
0.0512769781,
-0.0157371536,
0.0077565736,
0.0431452058,
-0.0209089629,
-0.0408635437,
0.0290755462,
0.0315358713,
-0.0135076847,
0.0301973615,
-0.0149808088,
-0.014710878,
-0.0113971168,
0.0181922428,
-0.0090443799,
0.0376842208,
0.0157558415,
-0.0190763157,
0.0521839522,
0.0188675672,
0.0262901057,
-0.0320674032,
0.021917494,
0.1100729033,
0.0208544061,
0.0203237403,
0.0127750132,
0.0123281609,
0.0215261709,
0.0428781211,
0.0196813326,
-0.0310181696,
0.0204029977,
-0.0209986288,
0.0203567334,
0.0084471824,
0.059392143,
-0.0310908221,
-0.0686973929,
0.0045394693,
0.0087715322,
0.0430434495,
0.0044121412,
0.0340134166,
0.0334485434,
-0.0240229797,
0.0499811582,
0.0300869085,
-0.0440206379,
0.0016094592,
-0.0161517449,
0.0224441085,
0.0302833002,
0.0395400599,
-0.0206440184,
-0.0835849196,
-0.0153334737,
-0.0280307271,
0.0720269084,
0.0545869619,
-0.0085826088,
0.0005219735,
-0.0301861167,
-0.023465883,
0.0027855064,
0.0071075005,
0.0010936402,
0.017475998,
0.038019523,
0.0159789361,
0.0033232623,
0.001072053,
0.0311326887,
0.002718047,
0.008806265,
-0.0079977829,
0.0322049111,
0.0350348428,
0.0461157188,
-0.0157332849,
0.0120867239,
0.0250332914,
0.0487298332,
-0.0139872534,
0.020128293,
-0.0604525656,
-0.0575321093,
0.0489303879,
0.0351424292,
-0.0235754736,
-0.013265443,
-0.0411515646,
-0.0380129553,
0.0162229147,
-0.0436213352,
0.0392348953,
-0.0624214225,
0.0132025089,
0.027229704,
-0.0054637487,
-0.021369556,
0.034020327,
0.0169215892,
0.0016291795,
-0.0089219185,
-0.0054814559,
0.0291094333,
-0.0591517314,
0.0196813941,
0.011268232,
-0.0260787327,
0.0231556091,
0.0328311995,
-0.0162678156,
-0.050271295,
-0.0082600769,
-0.0732319355,
-0.0146682393,
-0.0138060991,
-0.0056413007,
0.0255173054,
-0.0105741145,
0.0097766239,
-0.0130320694,
-0.0536673516,
0.0055256211,
0.0540169217,
-0.0055622333,
0.066426456,
0.0373696722,
-0.0100727277,
-0.0228648186,
0.0285489876,
-0.0001591638,
0.0153309368,
0.0005282573,
0.0237696636,
-0.0544190891,
-0.0216708127,
-0.0989551246,
0.0237264708,
-0.0131956898,
-0.0520356596,
0.0308952127,
0.0622936226,
-0.0013130832,
0.0154586611,
0.0462333187,
0.0106427753,
-0.0052364329,
-0.0211323965,
-0.0713331252,
0.0504542962,
-0.0586798675,
-0.0064966455,
-0.0252613593,
0.0375894494,
0.0428681672,
0.0232712626,
0.0320033841,
0.0037476635,
-0.0509778075,
0.0282190852,
0.0201505367,
-0.0636019707,
-0.0035256119,
-0.0396422483,
-0.0290588047,
0.03516059,
-0.0333033577,
0.0002680693,
0.0909348801,
-0.0611961149,
-0.0015265023,
-0.0399002358,
-0.0149611142,
-0.0105795097,
-0.0086826244,
-0.027302986,
0.0121745737,
0.0229952335,
-0.0080088666,
-0.0450949632,
-0.0272333752,
0.0363906361,
-0.0520910062,
0.0818138123,
-0.0115479324,
0.0173469055,
0.0357999653,
-0.0464170687,
-0.0903014988,
-0.0221592281,
-0.0041560703,
-0.0006112754,
-0.0461500734,
-0.0208084174,
-0.034195412,
0.0213181153,
0.053370703,
0.0331820883,
-0.0180326384,
0.010100144,
-0.0248342697,
0.0039916649,
0.0464452244,
0.0437726937,
0.0578129143,
0.0327353403,
0.0382357948,
0.0284108445,
0.0011335129,
-0.0109582199,
-0.0065106722,
-0.0288449861,
-0.0150482673,
-0.023447277,
0.0212139264,
-0.0039682905,
0.0554011799,
-0.0279325806,
-0.0099071003,
0.1050475389,
0.0182646923,
0.0336356498,
-0.0009443142,
-0.0209923238,
-0.0060331929,
-0.0012128645,
0.0302338451,
-0.0652084574,
0.0063022589,
-0.0043454114,
0.0116838925,
0.0003365394,
-0.0198668204,
-0.0093625858,
-0.1223946884,
0.0012722046,
0.0020451513,
-0.0352866836,
-0.081122227,
0.0055631525,
0.0248961579,
0.0276221987,
0.0530571565,
0.0115919374,
0.0526295602,
-0.0174883269,
0.0070612719,
0.0040459144,
-0.0389507636,
0.0077474387,
-0.0324386619,
0.0841497928,
0.0606272705,
0.0329464264,
0.0057448614,
-0.0578145534,
-0.0206479859,
-0.001501304,
0.0025812828,
0.0133823361,
0.0079795811,
-0.0477574728,
-0.0107988128,
-0.008406505,
-0.0057987077,
0.0054478366,
-0.0341621749,
-0.0101134358,
0.0298209619,
-0.0452303104,
0.0196164344,
0.0144474395,
0.0436411574,
0.0459402762,
0.0820298195,
0.0303156134,
-0.0016824107,
0.0301873013,
-0.0173516273,
0.0058600204,
-0.002397178,
-0.0217938311,
0.0141778775,
-0.0056528379,
0.0201402735,
-0.0943408608,
-0.0484009236,
0.0013124539,
0.016017491,
-0.005854506,
-0.0558760017,
0.0611341298,
-0.0024261093,
0.0126090003,
0.0258324444,
-0.019783752,
0.0220362172,
-0.0532220714,
0.0000717919,
0.0227781236,
-0.0484455973,
-0.0186278466,
-0.0209607463,
-0.0058874791,
-0.0443497039,
-0.0111652333,
0.0651808456,
0.0144794127,
0.0384838171,
-0.0247250814,
0.0005648129,
0.00540506,
0.0187904369,
-0.0737118721,
0.0170456786,
0.0426676981,
0.0165665951,
-0.0190881267,
0.0211767349,
-0.0393322185,
0.0232674275,
-0.0183849186,
0.0626396313,
-0.0287836418,
-0.1096210182,
0.018144751,
0.0037201988,
0.0808381364,
0.0361774378,
-0.0037402324,
-0.0463386923,
0.0414069071,
-0.0261863228,
-0.0320630483,
-0.0294105392,
-0.0145085501,
-0.0301444158,
0.0337272733,
-0.0073477086,
-0.044306498,
-0.0239645708,
0.039810475,
0.0051761852,
-0.0538248867,
0.0280140601,
0.0074654422,
-0.0272612274,
0.0037980354,
-0.0496558398,
0.0232554972,
0.0121389935,
0.0297009256,
0.0009808058,
0.1020312831,
0.0440502428,
-0.0158866141,
-0.0048304354,
0.0177415907,
-0.0559016056,
-0.0049988935,
-0.0249329917,
-0.0011549529,
0.021340197,
0.0129840905,
0.0054296767,
-0.042305693,
-0.0045338282,
0.0016519169,
0.021650549,
0.0226146057,
-0.0170850176,
0.0344654024,
0.02550832,
-0.0317689851,
0.0014259658,
0.0249087736,
-0.028791083,
0.0470863096,
-0.0390393659,
0.0065829633,
-0.0242613405,
-0.0559063628,
-0.026113309,
0.0063949199,
-0.0244685132,
0.028370453,
-0.0652964935,
-0.0634189621,
0.0193368271,
0.035722591,
-0.0096178716,
-0.0178391933,
0.0583951436,
0.0409291424,
0.0069930539,
-0.010190038,
-0.0057400386,
0.007269938,
-0.0171816628,
0.0075279749,
-0.0498172008,
-6.417513695e-33,
-0.0442295671,
-0.0129028866,
0.0201319829,
-0.0009620799,
-0.0689540878,
0.0132824108,
-0.0299064368,
0.0114523116,
-0.046478875,
0.0325922444,
-0.0201018471,
0.0028022961,
-0.0014930143,
0.019193694,
-0.0427633114,
-0.0372397602,
0.0347074158,
0.0158043839,
-0.0316438936,
0.0017585917,
0.0175567735,
-0.0082394052,
0.0556205437,
-0.0811139867,
0.0280745141,
0.0198620521,
-0.0286782794,
0.05130836,
-0.028566597,
0.0628248453,
-0.0046516727,
0.0647068992,
0.0086175036,
-0.0642635152,
-0.0005468474,
0.0210843515,
-0.0725115538,
-0.049645789,
0.0637400299,
0.0273413993,
-0.0131960781,
0.0209529623,
0.020300461,
-0.0335456356,
-0.0031459965,
-0.0016696012,
-0.0006828558,
-0.0150474133,
0.0034120393,
0.0022345548,
-0.0459272787,
-0.0100148218,
-0.0107185664,
-0.0290430952,
-0.0466987602,
0.0346612185,
0.0127739422,
-0.0580038205,
-0.072699368,
0.0130950781,
0.0001891497,
-0.016617395,
0.0592604205,
0.048320327,
0.0016954681,
0.0553805903,
-0.0389526784,
0.0017560411,
-0.0971522406,
-0.0279759318,
-0.0021569117,
0.015659174,
0.0515892655,
0.0727247,
-0.0291302763,
-0.0315770358,
-0.0284900051,
-0.0089437859,
0.0051387637,
0.0611241236,
-0.0129592223,
-0.0057339901,
-0.0384917222,
-0.0046581328,
-0.0623852983,
0.0397133194,
-0.0214326531,
-0.0360869952,
0.0158702936,
0.0042193811,
-0.0217301045,
-0.0074133403,
-0.0099484501,
-0.0207646601,
0.0192862116,
0.0318464711,
-0.0051202397,
0.0071110581,
-0.0230520386,
-0.0176760554,
-0.069769837,
0.0204608627,
0.0306314956,
0.0127370292,
0.0123794293,
0.0222957861,
0.0347385071,
-0.0089723915,
-0.0224016644,
0.0146158114,
0.0027593053,
0.0464657024,
-0.0058509852,
0.0105004627,
0.0245475248,
0.0300137158,
-0.0458598025,
0.0469125435,
0.0012447903,
-0.0076608001,
-0.0344650187,
-0.030110158,
0.0218524355,
0.0385560133,
-0.0632151291,
0.0113998801,
-0.0399121046,
-0.0191554371,
-0.0162559766,
-0.0595582724,
-0.0077264044,
0.0243488513,
2.825e-7,
0.0076817046,
0.0127316881,
0.0654048175,
0.0361811109,
0.0058698561,
0.0518875271,
-0.0062102941,
-0.0021107583,
0.011737247,
-0.0640373379,
0.0354634598,
0.0191592202,
0.0406198539,
0.0055849198,
-0.0626508966,
-0.0570266061,
-0.1024861112,
-0.008384835,
-0.0308996029,
0.006344968,
0.0447497591,
0.0476184376,
0.0426789597,
0.0241153538,
-0.0199661609,
-0.0277349781,
0.0264453907,
0.0315862522,
0.013876304,
0.006608183,
0.0614853203,
-0.0300914478,
-0.0059045935,
0.047922764,
-0.0029948079,
0.0433058701,
-0.0198268723,
0.0511654131,
-0.0116885137,
-0.06500604,
-0.0590416119,
0.0109636905,
0.01503608,
-0.0575192757,
0.0474587865,
-0.0601070821,
-0.0010782912,
-0.0042725271,
-0.0243217517,
-0.017201934,
0.0199969523,
-0.0058169477,
-0.040311072,
0.026437154,
0.0404241122,
0.0414506607,
0.0137720052,
-0.0610196702,
-0.0076879174,
-0.0008341653,
-0.0436644107,
-0.0518077053,
-0.0071410122,
-0.0413909853,
0.0317410789,
-0.0202684645,
0.000554957,
2.217451625e-34,
0.0021802031,
-0.0009827105,
0.0430093408,
-0.0116948383,
0.051919993,
0.0243321173,
-0.005500433,
0.0027848578,
0.0508723482,
-0.0723497197,
0.0022136364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08367v1 | MCU: A Task-centric Framework for Open-ended Agent Evaluation in Minecraft | 2023-10-12T14:38:25 | 2023-10-12T14:38:25 | Haowei Lin, Zihao Wang, Jianzhu Ma, Yitao Liang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | To pursue the goal of creating an open-ended agent in Minecraft, an
open-ended game environment with unlimited possibilities, this paper introduces
a task-centric framework named MCU for Minecraft agent evaluation. The MCU
framework leverages the concept of atom tasks as fundamental building blocks,
enabling the generation of diverse or even arbitrary tasks. Within the MCU
framework, each task is measured with six distinct difficulty scores (time
consumption, operational effort, planning complexity, intricacy, creativity,
novelty). These scores offer a multi-dimensional assessment of a task from
different angles, and thus can reveal an agent's capability on specific facets.
The difficulty scores also serve as the feature of each task, which creates a
meaningful task space and unveils the relationship between tasks. For efficient
evaluation of Minecraft agents employing the MCU framework, we maintain a
unified benchmark, namely SkillForge, which comprises representative tasks with
diverse categories and difficulty distribution. We also provide convenient
filters for users to select tasks to assess specific capabilities of agents. We
show that MCU has the high expressivity to cover all tasks used in recent
literature on Minecraft agent, and underscores the need for advancements in
areas such as creativity, precise control, and out-of-distribution
generalization under the goal of open-ended Minecraft agent development. | [
-0.0078622913,
-0.0461712256,
-0.0170746204,
-0.0355872922,
-0.0269185845,
-0.0207951795,
0.0083907796,
-0.0216769874,
0.0194762461,
0.0250447467,
-0.0080160722,
0.0354178287,
-0.0821202993,
0.0465835258,
-0.0203556325,
-0.0255883634,
0.024424769,
-0.0397775508,
0.0162179191,
0.0156909507,
-0.0494016968,
-0.0427084826,
-0.0100890892,
0.0453855284,
0.0479762517,
-0.0367497168,
-0.0419829823,
-0.0052720574,
0.0725554302,
-0.0703130513,
-0.038317278,
-0.0208912473,
-0.0259838309,
-0.0083201341,
0.0000019861,
-0.0701828375,
-0.0223736074,
-0.0151223838,
0.002950965,
-0.0761940554,
0.0260657426,
0.0563336872,
-0.0535230972,
0.0298315752,
-0.0509531125,
0.020098798,
0.0864281654,
0.0322012492,
0.040356718,
0.0220960844,
0.0130451918,
0.0482400507,
-0.013744738,
0.013120031,
0.0217374247,
-0.0071559721,
-0.0343339853,
0.0064215981,
0.0612208247,
-0.02124306,
-0.0142708067,
-0.0379367024,
0.0428283997,
0.0206915326,
0.0255920179,
0.0286457203,
-0.0001465147,
-0.0165892765,
-0.0018015166,
0.0139133222,
-0.0269559193,
0.0334816538,
0.0300042816,
0.0130692162,
0.0013811375,
0.0102713294,
-0.0055072168,
0.0413262881,
-0.0432291813,
-0.0109929619,
-0.0223735217,
0.0403107405,
-0.0048091537,
-0.029193433,
0.0098677743,
0.0878501162,
0.0043975385,
-0.0185049884,
-0.0226474274,
-0.0346189253,
0.0133712701,
-0.0232618861,
-0.0233234335,
0.0262881145,
-0.0906604305,
-0.0270878039,
-0.0261388179,
0.0204845313,
-0.0166405663,
-0.0187963191,
0.0830214471,
0.027375361,
0.013897527,
0.0622845963,
0.026844345,
0.0388931073,
0.0181411374,
0.0303788427,
-0.0366068259,
0.0049344813,
-0.0952157751,
0.0248133168,
-0.0036411311,
0.0045001963,
0.000479742,
-0.0183089543,
0.0056525329,
0.0491268672,
-0.0727926046,
0.0078322003,
0.0126338014,
0.0220208112,
-0.0213659927,
0.0096822698,
-0.0432480909,
-0.0509587191,
-0.0930458605,
0.0020033524,
0.0305717401,
0.0128255663,
-0.0059269494,
0.0012358405,
-0.0130910706,
0.0098147048,
0.045362018,
0.0615606494,
0.0087535512,
-0.0119036008,
-0.0138878552,
-0.0291045308,
0.0472527184,
-0.0579683706,
0.0001345825,
-0.0459558666,
-0.0085100131,
-0.0412559733,
-0.0024477385,
0.0337766707,
0.0098029412,
-0.0378283672,
0.0130223818,
0.0358850881,
0.0286446754,
0.0231284816,
-0.0162933711,
0.0261752158,
-0.0210787803,
0.0064164866,
0.0220729634,
0.046681989,
-0.0040595592,
0.0257961452,
0.0483050719,
-0.0002108581,
-0.0682869926,
0.0016612646,
0.0516746715,
-0.0045416676,
-0.0193160772,
0.0822382644,
-0.0213134605,
-0.0047226259,
-0.0342509821,
0.0577570647,
0.0416552275,
0.0108498894,
0.0226898678,
0.0248076729,
0.0748585016,
0.0221193396,
-0.0061366367,
-0.0454972833,
0.0133725684,
0.0818914846,
0.0398816466,
-0.0297084693,
-0.0496233366,
0.0387154147,
-0.0009804582,
-0.0454167575,
0.0384696051,
-0.0053534484,
0.0751044303,
-0.0090511534,
0.0171060991,
0.0062877913,
-0.0460141711,
-0.0462800488,
-0.0408851914,
-0.0572403446,
-0.0176262241,
-0.0634194687,
0.0363931097,
0.08336588,
0.0426970907,
-0.0630273446,
-0.0528163612,
0.0168620758,
-0.0260834508,
0.0300606694,
-0.0069473283,
-0.0352746956,
0.0411803946,
0.0155276321,
-0.0370795839,
-0.0153566888,
0.0008597239,
0.0861091539,
-0.0113867,
-0.0291935578,
-0.0333358347,
-0.0310848076,
0.0038517769,
0.0043336069,
0.0258173458,
-0.0533751398,
0.0241421461,
0.0077946349,
0.0362063088,
0.0061974106,
-0.0027946304,
-0.0080402531,
0.0359111056,
-0.0013054663,
-0.0331539363,
0.0227507241,
0.0480679162,
0.0365051255,
0.0183733571,
-0.0577165,
0.0553924628,
0.0503467396,
0.0205449071,
-0.0405386984,
0.0408829898,
-0.0008490914,
0.024861116,
0.0192221832,
0.0199653674,
-0.0519281738,
-0.0052609183,
-0.0016348788,
0.0298678409,
0.011066895,
-0.0436350405,
0.0001031424,
-0.0116090085,
0.0319801532,
-0.0228643119,
0.0280024707,
0.0227633249,
0.0003482511,
0.0065906332,
0.0639580265,
0.0092540272,
-0.061626289,
-0.0412932187,
-0.067313686,
0.0230819322,
-0.0164709184,
0.0204796642,
0.0221240148,
-0.0008113144,
0.004762223,
-0.008584925,
0.014891359,
0.0223534349,
0.0092287427,
-0.0326440334,
0.0178460702,
0.0321269073,
-0.0268745944,
-0.0076686461,
0.0169364549,
-0.0301735103,
0.0064193322,
-0.0062362207,
0.0917910337,
-0.0089084553,
0.0437612049,
-0.052954074,
0.0083477162,
-0.0192523561,
-0.0640126467,
0.0732892752,
-0.015745623,
0.0298911501,
0.0691077858,
-0.0148083242,
0.0510473102,
0.1103446633,
-0.0589878857,
0.0057545924,
0.0368178114,
0.0253055245,
0.0032848839,
-0.0016278039,
-0.005042457,
0.0335018821,
0.0452158749,
-0.0301521011,
0.0008858001,
-0.0323114693,
0.065717198,
0.0226803292,
-0.0504833274,
0.0461534373,
0.0160862468,
-0.0228421651,
0.0131200245,
-0.0553383268,
-0.0013808112,
0.0620207749,
-0.0233116597,
0.0002924942,
-0.0025375434,
-0.0163437556,
-0.020661464,
0.0591662936,
-0.0177165084,
-0.0006793803,
0.0090220217,
0.0163924955,
-0.0219816249,
-0.0406800769,
0.0495015942,
-0.0349658541,
-0.0516728945,
-0.0444940217,
-0.0503223389,
0.0140000368,
-0.0168322455,
-0.0135153187,
0.0102534425,
0.0502058864,
0.0346915275,
0.0398748517,
-0.0292326026,
-0.0738555342,
-0.0297826752,
0.0441437662,
0.0068277763,
-0.0048698783,
-0.0154864872,
-0.0307697803,
-0.0300272703,
0.0538417399,
0.035448838,
0.0031004334,
0.0089775436,
0.0726994723,
0.0256528482,
0.0457904935,
-0.0595102608,
-0.0488862097,
0.0209135506,
-0.0174155366,
-0.019086929,
0.0217096265,
0.0499512553,
0.0691754818,
-0.0445374958,
-0.0298147406,
0.0397187136,
0.0243173745,
0.0510534756,
0.0089825029,
-0.039516177,
-0.0061800382,
0.033084739,
0.0716473758,
0.0411976725,
0.0030363128,
-0.0155686922,
0.0190025344,
-0.0724019483,
-0.0568471067,
0.0359382257,
-0.0554707572,
0.0329778343,
0.0014886098,
-0.0311723929,
0.0092263278,
-0.0149495201,
-0.0003987384,
0.0184873324,
-0.0654791296,
-0.020374693,
0.0337195508,
-0.0131380539,
-0.0046074926,
0.0000832329,
-0.0266772024,
0.0552952848,
-0.0601714961,
0.0796869174,
0.0790054575,
0.031628333,
-0.0055033923,
-0.0079752943,
-0.0569467656,
0.0657542571,
0.0173927974,
-0.0086045749,
0.0067484416,
0.0145159038,
-0.0062044812,
-0.0218486916,
-0.0246842671,
0.0025535808,
-0.0381845534,
0.0061066668,
0.0828579962,
-0.0276062265,
-0.0005732517,
-0.0388613194,
-0.024352761,
0.0814548433,
0.0177383851,
-0.039908614,
-0.0220657196,
-0.0656090528,
-0.0213444699,
-0.0178036746,
-0.0868646204,
0.0010189778,
-0.0390487984,
0.0156670939,
0.0099973753,
-0.0716371238,
-0.0587549917,
0.0168910157,
0.0422384143,
-0.0063928324,
-0.0388270803,
-0.0415281393,
0.048798915,
-0.0296221729,
-0.0309766978,
0.0238866266,
0.0144115724,
-0.0092863021,
-0.0410581157,
-0.0015903588,
-0.0748585761,
0.0293929391,
0.0508131683,
-0.0325840302,
-0.0041586701,
0.0324180312,
0.0447135977,
0.0206336938,
-0.0106582996,
-0.0053978111,
-0.0201082528,
0.0547565147,
-0.0089212405,
-0.0471355766,
-0.0032695909,
0.032247711,
0.0181321409,
0.0290165506,
-0.0089461813,
-0.0634527728,
0.0440692678,
0.0358005948,
0.0447852388,
-0.0056303698,
0.0050974004,
0.0065412777,
-0.0020547449,
0.0100072538,
-0.0171407647,
0.0045513012,
0.0072925505,
-0.0130802728,
-0.0116715729,
-0.0193886291,
-0.0278843157,
0.0103845494,
-0.0056392704,
-0.0036766659,
0.036809247,
0.0690605417,
0.0092692003,
-0.0357372835,
0.0086806985,
0.0574990436,
-0.0254366137,
-0.0115469843,
0.008712084,
0.0222138073,
0.0054705469,
0.0049389973,
-0.0110013103,
0.0506812632,
0.0321914628,
0.0284963734,
-0.006470894,
-0.02170421,
-0.0555545464,
0.0480655991,
-0.072464101,
-0.0148798181,
0.0548936911,
0.048471842,
0.0472238287,
0.0344691575,
0.0185835604,
-0.0398986749,
0.0447528027,
-0.0353346616,
-0.0434342176,
0.0048235143,
-0.027982587,
-0.0285504442,
0.0633688793,
0.0207812302,
-0.0293256175,
-0.0197737198,
-0.0349733904,
0.0482589565,
-0.0594467223,
-0.0230955705,
-0.0622056611,
0.000897517,
-0.0292552207,
0.0372089446,
-0.0236519575,
-0.0079557812,
-0.0608535744,
0.0208705086,
0.0223175287,
0.1349762529,
0.0199714899,
-0.0292588491,
0.002314317,
0.0411116779,
-0.0126008857,
-0.0399708375,
-0.0499501489,
-0.0729692206,
-0.0499639064,
0.0315068774,
-0.0027287242,
-5.305525059e-33,
-0.0277124029,
-0.0067494651,
0.0646558776,
-0.0250880569,
-0.0100665689,
-0.0650259927,
-0.0693183392,
0.007539155,
0.0020654085,
-0.0138106151,
-0.0208524782,
-0.0117697753,
0.0042358763,
-0.0344084837,
0.036748115,
-0.002034541,
0.0612464398,
0.0427900292,
-0.0564257428,
0.008704761,
0.0133619905,
-0.0114152879,
0.0054533137,
0.0040665255,
-0.0152772767,
0.0033418441,
-0.0198728498,
0.0071121696,
-0.002720176,
0.0241539981,
0.0172808785,
-0.0098325666,
0.0211332608,
-0.0339859352,
0.0096569145,
-0.0363940522,
-0.0462124012,
-0.0249335207,
-0.0490912199,
-0.0448745266,
-0.0411569551,
-0.0670322552,
-0.0088318856,
0.0294234585,
-0.0099912565,
-0.036235977,
0.043848183,
0.0094309039,
0.0357673578,
-0.0006869382,
-0.0639277548,
0.0102810664,
-0.0338694081,
-0.0594202243,
-0.0174318701,
-0.0032256951,
-0.0169870276,
-0.0437706932,
-0.0493227988,
0.0518296696,
-0.0485361926,
-0.0175477844,
0.0128729893,
0.0535982437,
0.0073795756,
0.0337119214,
0.0310390648,
0.0481863022,
-0.0200074427,
0.0398426577,
0.0021274537,
0.079858467,
0.0070928494,
0.0637125671,
0.0341989882,
-0.0063308701,
-0.0080223391,
0.0789434686,
0.0263809729,
0.0398881212,
-0.0007130931,
0.0259897728,
-0.0369757041,
0.0137504973,
0.0361022837,
-0.0357584395,
0.0158449095,
-0.0342905037,
0.0331187323,
-0.0081802038,
-0.0371175036,
-0.0437991731,
0.0297092758,
-0.0091176601,
0.0819977373,
-0.0296862591,
-0.0362141579,
0.0485430509,
-0.0399207398,
-0.0291547999,
0.0082206475,
-0.0527130105,
0.0395273753,
0.0017872758,
0.0488448068,
0.0132715385,
-0.0383666009,
0.0931787342,
-0.0140036307,
-0.0110017862,
-0.0408907607,
0.0067912699,
0.0063044885,
-0.0393740945,
-0.0014484978,
-0.0552149937,
0.0101034222,
-0.0372169539,
-0.0085687814,
-0.0605452955,
-0.0243692026,
0.0039524026,
-0.0245616864,
-0.0372751132,
-0.0016777905,
0.0081622293,
-0.068568401,
0.0256477017,
0.0073792739,
-0.001815134,
-0.0334661193,
-0.0023870824,
2.932e-7,
-0.0539397001,
0.0118034109,
-0.013561408,
-0.0122435866,
-0.0097772628,
0.0588957518,
-0.0624657832,
0.0130519187,
-0.031416554,
0.0020550895,
0.0554497875,
0.0204886366,
0.0130281905,
0.0239319596,
-0.0536450222,
0.0245275088,
0.0449316874,
0.022114953,
-0.0359765887,
0.013181394,
0.0470127575,
-0.0198279396,
0.0393100977,
0.0018820348,
0.0422804058,
-0.0576445609,
-0.0015081448,
-0.0115411645,
0.0511153303,
0.0127630755,
-0.0504726619,
0.011959401,
-0.0478587858,
-0.0191527475,
-0.0022137773,
0.0098435739,
-0.0099013895,
0.0419055447,
-0.0128855035,
-0.0106411679,
0.0025086843,
-0.0204781611,
0.0115469089,
0.00590614,
0.0181032177,
0.003989608,
-0.0362558812,
-0.0108758528,
-0.0027513145,
0.0263118353,
-0.0750080794,
-0.0160030853,
-0.0201608147,
-0.0500511453,
-0.0255858935,
-0.0155872786,
-0.0166668575,
-0.0267999899,
0.0079507604,
-0.0128179379,
-0.0546593294,
-0.0726953894,
-0.0340896584,
0.0044615772,
0.016590206,
-0.0308985934,
-0.0078150639,
2.215842208e-34,
-0.0466961004,
0.0351601467,
0.0028624274,
-0.0260637067,
0.0351696722,
0.0237036347,
-0.0179899428,
-0.0087180119,
0.0424620584,
-0.0039265887,
-0.0109697962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08365v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08365v2 | From Large Language Models to Knowledge Graphs for Biomarker Discovery in Cancer | 2023-10-12T14:36:13 | 2023-11-19T17:27:48 | Md. Rezaul Karim, Lina Molinas Comet, Md Shajalal, Oya Deniz Beyan, Dietrich Rebholz-Schuhmann, Stefan Decker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain experts often rely on most recent knowledge for apprehending and
disseminating specific biological processes that help them design strategies
for developing prevention and therapeutic decision-making in various disease
scenarios. A challenging scenarios for artificial intelligence (AI) is using
biomedical data (e.g., texts, imaging, omics, and clinical) to provide
diagnosis and treatment recommendations for cancerous conditions.~Data and
knowledge about biomedical entities like cancer, drugs, genes, proteins, and
their mechanism is spread across structured (knowledge bases (KBs)) and
unstructured (e.g., scientific articles) sources. A large-scale knowledge graph
(KG) can be constructed by integrating and extracting facts about semantically
interrelated entities and relations. Such a KG not only allows exploration and
question answering (QA) but also enables domain experts to deduce new
knowledge. However, exploring and querying large-scale KGs is tedious for
non-domain users due to their lack of understanding of the data assets and
semantic technologies. In this paper, we develop a domain KG to leverage
cancer-specific biomarker discovery and interactive QA. For this, we
constructed a domain ontology called OncoNet Ontology (ONO), which enables
semantic reasoning for validating gene-disease (different types of cancer)
relations. The KG is further enriched by harmonizing the ONO, metadata,
controlled vocabularies, and biomedical concepts from scientific articles by
employing BioBERT- and SciBERT-based information extractors. Further, since the
biomedical domain is evolving, where new findings often replace old ones,
without having access to up-to-date scientific findings, there is a high chance
an AI system exhibits concept drift while providing diagnosis and treatment.
Therefore, we fine-tune the KG using large language models (LLMs) based on more
recent articles and KBs. | [
0.0319481343,
0.0412104763,
-0.0133930165,
0.0064618625,
-0.0275746007,
-0.0047038756,
-0.0110943476,
0.0587309077,
0.0534817167,
-0.0081677176,
0.0228048004,
0.0299585909,
-0.0401008539,
0.0618851893,
-0.064701885,
0.0029971821,
-0.0024825733,
0.0062742336,
0.0488786995,
-0.0052814228,
-0.007633816,
0.0230875649,
-0.0004287545,
0.0144270239,
-0.0233446956,
-0.0178660285,
0.0469234958,
-0.0604257137,
-0.0060530058,
-0.0496339053,
-0.0164427664,
-0.0185016915,
-0.020247465,
0.0160872564,
0.0000018529,
-0.0854241848,
-0.0586014986,
0.0371379815,
-0.0223268867,
-0.0543622039,
0.0156791229,
-0.020969335,
0.0259771049,
-0.0043947524,
-0.0179497413,
-0.0063051721,
0.0188109707,
0.0454973131,
0.0168850049,
0.0550559461,
-0.0098178247,
-0.0296539124,
0.0810475424,
0.0133011555,
0.0399626233,
-0.0402604043,
0.0843308195,
0.03161861,
0.0594964921,
-0.0098163821,
0.0151142552,
0.0388729163,
-0.0343132429,
-0.0345298313,
0.0341665633,
0.0253675114,
0.0211412571,
-0.0099307084,
0.0109032532,
0.0540789403,
0.0324694216,
-0.0269262232,
0.0437785462,
0.0110627329,
0.0112697082,
0.0696854889,
-0.0223826468,
-0.0165594965,
-0.0294469018,
-0.0171100553,
0.0178006943,
-0.0260501076,
0.024183644,
0.0034284643,
-0.0114091132,
0.0881878287,
-0.0228743255,
-0.0154259233,
-0.0116487388,
-0.0031856871,
-0.009729377,
-0.0358713754,
0.0261464417,
0.0711425245,
-0.0466652811,
0.0205259174,
0.0275754239,
-0.0253044348,
0.0478458852,
-0.0552958995,
-0.036868684,
-0.0354213864,
-0.0252852682,
0.0607026666,
-0.0122214984,
-0.0306010991,
-0.0492997691,
0.0328261293,
-0.0206629653,
-0.03596735,
-0.0860687569,
-0.0200634077,
-0.0279476959,
0.0526936613,
0.0166574568,
0.0039757309,
-0.0458120145,
0.0109167611,
-0.0260034297,
0.0327982754,
0.0362773649,
0.0171428304,
0.025271982,
0.0186671671,
-0.0437275246,
0.0082006818,
-0.0096137803,
-0.0098519009,
-0.0208414085,
-0.0396341346,
0.0374429971,
0.0024549481,
0.0467445292,
-0.0218319055,
-0.0035277857,
0.0946716294,
0.0577045009,
-0.0071145729,
0.0103775943,
-0.0904660523,
-0.0348875076,
-0.0485585146,
0.0117340591,
-0.0538361184,
0.0157569479,
0.0379289091,
0.0048499843,
-0.0709262863,
-0.0053237518,
-0.0330458581,
-0.0498870984,
0.0206868649,
-0.0447051525,
-0.0226380955,
0.0338476747,
0.013785217,
-0.0214292221,
0.0124998754,
0.0128242243,
-0.0482962579,
0.0468612686,
0.0041751144,
-0.0612026304,
-0.0332894102,
0.051551789,
-0.0313516818,
0.0165604036,
0.0369179584,
-0.0190365035,
0.0648462847,
-0.056203112,
0.0175737441,
0.0101245856,
-0.0009674506,
0.0024687217,
0.0335620828,
0.049130708,
0.0209630653,
-0.000347637,
-0.0082882801,
-0.0115754372,
-0.0391784944,
0.0175121054,
0.0137850922,
-0.0283781998,
0.0214771442,
-0.0148270512,
-0.0001750069,
0.0232415833,
-0.042463433,
-0.0373601913,
0.0197581463,
-0.0234191138,
-0.0057547987,
0.0569529869,
-0.0307877306,
0.0230939426,
-0.0067565637,
0.0474957265,
0.0125532476,
0.0093928855,
-0.0329023898,
0.0264142938,
0.0588090494,
0.0476014167,
-0.0723361224,
-0.0340534113,
-0.0020632662,
-0.0246668961,
-0.0136788916,
-0.03051937,
-0.0454883203,
-0.0594648682,
0.027746655,
-0.0027069834,
0.0187246688,
0.0066990759,
-0.0339398012,
-0.0020714714,
0.0592235439,
-0.033323139,
-0.0573030524,
0.0177471396,
0.0173967294,
-0.0067202183,
-0.0111074895,
-0.0265510138,
-0.0032506546,
0.0418588668,
0.0275473986,
-0.0071954764,
0.042197682,
0.0372671485,
-0.0516142994,
-0.0849612057,
-0.0130970422,
0.0336650312,
-0.0009682496,
0.0319627598,
-0.019696001,
-0.0241346862,
-0.0460923128,
-0.0399940126,
-0.0137599008,
-0.0067549599,
0.0052270899,
0.0146865314,
0.0294246152,
-0.0223675705,
0.005210124,
-0.0151432306,
-0.0062117018,
0.0678640753,
-0.0055960589,
-0.0358645469,
-0.0086569767,
-0.0631880984,
0.0379783474,
-0.0078024869,
0.0013521709,
0.0050537735,
0.0281354506,
0.0081256423,
0.0363398157,
-0.034293022,
-0.0038500554,
0.0473066978,
-0.0532108992,
0.010743578,
0.0202313643,
0.0232707784,
0.0014203662,
0.0218509827,
0.0202552285,
-0.0194912925,
-0.0539476797,
0.0360110216,
0.0131006734,
0.0166927539,
0.0424702801,
0.0448183715,
-0.0265690498,
-0.0154674016,
-0.0176734291,
-0.0541720688,
0.0646329671,
0.0345189236,
-0.0116757052,
0.0134049784,
0.0275945384,
-0.0663179308,
0.0293612946,
0.0229437128,
0.0348372608,
-0.0063616023,
-0.0353373736,
-0.0607184209,
0.0651646927,
-0.0198850837,
0.0492457561,
0.035495948,
0.0061259437,
0.0020500892,
-0.0147667667,
-0.0539321564,
-0.0138682807,
-0.001828091,
0.0366532169,
0.0141100464,
0.016578462,
0.0074082827,
-0.0331728049,
-0.05462135,
0.0276597664,
-0.0321642421,
0.0127890855,
-0.0387166962,
0.0160722882,
0.0287372209,
0.0207622889,
0.0068842811,
0.0031970926,
0.1167909503,
0.0284356568,
0.0757043362,
-0.0399576202,
0.0056763655,
-0.0171717443,
0.0247896593,
0.002679107,
0.0440006442,
0.0352484807,
0.0397820771,
-0.0004975036,
-0.0394622572,
0.0340367258,
-0.0407469422,
0.0305460133,
-0.0536394492,
0.0714649856,
0.0526081249,
-0.0232507195,
-0.0136514436,
0.0685131922,
-0.0366865434,
0.0473159775,
0.0127014657,
-0.0306670722,
-0.0335788243,
-0.0098532867,
-0.010197809,
0.02683465,
0.030054342,
-0.0219575297,
-0.0095307259,
0.021304572,
0.0520469621,
-0.0271940026,
0.0078491718,
0.0219106507,
0.0575467274,
0.0481004268,
-0.0765070692,
-0.0403464064,
0.0101135587,
0.0151667232,
-0.0126900114,
-0.0622125082,
0.0202787519,
0.0034695701,
-0.0169891659,
-0.049678497,
-0.0172975753,
0.0744502842,
0.0401992947,
-0.0040597226,
0.0301173218,
0.0088259447,
-0.0648088306,
-0.0310528707,
0.0449035726,
-0.1053558961,
-0.014662575,
-0.0592624918,
-0.0267278105,
-0.0329670198,
-0.0654034391,
0.0144823054,
-0.0216381773,
0.0387236476,
-0.0160603803,
-0.0492555462,
0.0034466144,
-0.0570990928,
-0.0110890018,
-0.0352992639,
-0.0675448254,
-0.0312373601,
0.0339562409,
-0.0361190364,
-0.0072161085,
-0.0089926813,
-0.0884672403,
0.0191593152,
-0.0158366654,
0.0056760549,
0.0206010249,
0.0461145863,
-0.0091980603,
-0.0040982347,
-0.0303404592,
0.0343538709,
0.0168027058,
-0.0103260586,
0.0584579743,
0.0106668063,
0.0017995297,
-0.0911409706,
0.016891893,
-0.027364498,
-0.0110474406,
-0.0056434185,
0.103861548,
-0.0330642387,
-0.027324589,
-0.0404107459,
-0.0394422561,
-0.0000079383,
0.0399913229,
-0.053519167,
0.0093190782,
-0.0275034532,
0.0009133589,
0.0288908966,
0.0305280332,
-0.005756821,
0.0364657454,
-0.05144196,
0.0014460455,
-0.077030912,
0.0122001506,
0.0272800289,
-0.0398547351,
0.0218240209,
0.0350807682,
0.0404764004,
-0.023044629,
-0.0786203966,
0.0441746265,
0.0122641958,
0.0219351556,
-0.0163974203,
-0.0494663343,
0.0704785362,
-0.0139492564,
-0.0063889693,
0.0159798171,
0.0044118715,
-0.0320933126,
-0.0526505932,
-0.0172180478,
0.0217266008,
-0.0019593381,
-0.025745362,
-0.0469014868,
0.0781918094,
0.0220800973,
-0.0664756447,
-0.0423871465,
-0.0499955676,
-0.0376253948,
-0.0002852412,
0.0167900193,
-0.0502667353,
0.0056521003,
-0.0100689512,
0.0051030023,
-0.0359843671,
-0.016788274,
0.0605783984,
0.0495559536,
0.0103928298,
0.0369597338,
-0.0148887616,
-0.027136175,
0.0168760344,
-0.0200483184,
-0.0144315567,
0.0024205055,
-0.023826642,
-0.002781739,
0.0002234137,
-0.0066669327,
0.0374742337,
-0.0167696364,
-0.0436068512,
-0.0392758697,
0.0355732515,
0.024764752,
-0.0023827513,
0.0700227395,
-0.0254218951,
0.0152416183,
-0.0183396991,
-0.0295468662,
0.0047513549,
-0.0290375352,
0.021308545,
0.0384254418,
0.0088450918,
-0.0151722552,
0.0082075922,
-0.0468702912,
-0.0420858674,
0.0017799087,
0.0164354034,
0.0477687046,
0.0008452002,
0.0321797878,
-0.0513621382,
-0.0254217107,
-0.023981899,
0.0110850865,
-0.0073808832,
0.0188762117,
0.0360388607,
0.0275212191,
-0.0072063506,
-0.0448551513,
0.0473163389,
0.0400533117,
0.0477311984,
-0.029287383,
-0.0711808577,
-0.0354631692,
-0.0077132592,
0.037885461,
0.0212921631,
-0.0525911525,
0.02128613,
-0.0517965369,
-0.0338926055,
0.0538407043,
0.0229469575,
-0.0340404138,
0.0161070004,
0.0339298099,
-0.0025070223,
0.0439714417,
-0.0884461328,
-0.0460765585,
0.0298785251,
-0.0773646757,
-0.0477689281,
0.026612062,
-5.640207036e-33,
0.0296942573,
-0.0392924249,
0.029272031,
0.0401583426,
0.0061209546,
0.0219829958,
-0.0501790717,
-0.0363736525,
0.0145723382,
0.0778704435,
0.0174233858,
0.0059467661,
-0.0223317202,
-0.0169848185,
-0.0111117391,
-0.031018056,
0.0307545103,
0.0096721398,
0.0122693265,
0.0045000743,
0.0742692128,
0.0401700176,
-0.0091822529,
-0.075304389,
0.0009092317,
0.0398393832,
0.0298519544,
0.0248359367,
-0.0488871075,
0.068383269,
0.0026483058,
0.0732115954,
0.0223219004,
-0.010695803,
0.0363332629,
-0.028593285,
-0.0910779908,
-0.0269670002,
0.0012002949,
0.0179137513,
-0.0112907328,
-0.0204433333,
0.0351209603,
0.0011192606,
0.0217046663,
0.0003370563,
0.0496773273,
-0.0253179744,
-0.0436839946,
-0.0497872643,
-0.0216705147,
0.0241702311,
0.0002550843,
0.0177622791,
0.0057409308,
-0.0725644827,
-0.0138290022,
0.0098707406,
-0.0295556448,
0.0348265171,
0.0103216497,
0.012756424,
0.0160468053,
-0.0133945793,
0.0045959726,
0.0276541058,
-0.0321120061,
-0.0246389024,
0.0417624712,
0.0245938599,
-0.0413500257,
0.061630372,
-0.0270529948,
0.0197205208,
-0.0072079734,
0.0042474722,
-0.1228963137,
0.0231022779,
-0.0635211617,
0.0448138118,
0.006441039,
0.0041347016,
0.0030336443,
0.0020376444,
-0.0128652276,
0.0401826538,
-0.0313210413,
-0.0275620148,
-0.0064228177,
-0.0513728634,
-0.0102733187,
0.0418268219,
-0.0172269829,
-0.0603214428,
-0.0373973697,
0.0264473744,
0.05190631,
0.0069794701,
-0.0326588266,
0.0211691912,
-0.036395371,
-0.0291155148,
0.0167333391,
-0.062817663,
0.0237276629,
0.0246026013,
0.0403863378,
-0.0220839269,
-0.0061799684,
0.008500481,
-0.0046895654,
-0.0155771188,
-0.0111082811,
-0.0004036164,
0.0069700941,
0.0664387196,
0.0228313636,
0.0812287405,
0.0601230785,
0.0060538426,
-0.0054013622,
0.0139466962,
0.0248496048,
-0.0441583693,
-0.0563680343,
-0.0243639909,
-0.0213315114,
0.0170673858,
0.0019928399,
-0.0556265749,
-0.0081634494,
0.0222568754,
2.891e-7,
0.0884989873,
0.0318706073,
0.0093047135,
0.0223812703,
0.0520608164,
-0.0061612925,
0.0102850571,
-0.0055428264,
-0.0418142527,
-0.0312276911,
0.034612786,
0.0208774563,
-0.0230046492,
0.0255608223,
-0.0348133743,
-0.0226613544,
0.0136290221,
-0.0704116821,
-0.0448532328,
0.0355066247,
0.0835172608,
0.0048459596,
-0.0034382113,
-0.0055652861,
0.0378392301,
-0.0040271096,
0.0093141887,
0.0083317142,
0.0286140144,
0.0122804549,
-0.0081241447,
-0.0103130005,
0.0166602824,
0.103535451,
-0.009751847,
-0.0005936513,
-0.0223430973,
0.0331409872,
-0.0301738717,
0.0598103777,
0.0275714882,
-0.0230814461,
0.0479170159,
-0.0209830459,
0.057392139,
-0.0357948504,
-0.0773764104,
-0.0096139153,
0.0173746515,
-0.0318364948,
-0.0146256154,
-0.0236472059,
-0.0300614927,
0.018631354,
-0.000619524,
0.0432535112,
0.0092237713,
-0.0394142196,
0.0399367586,
0.0705835074,
-0.0067116814,
-0.0493807569,
0.0176738836,
-0.0101039913,
0.0445532054,
-0.0578087531,
0.0211343039,
2.214476614e-34,
0.027076466,
0.048013486,
-0.0275176559,
0.0007167138,
0.0390204675,
-0.0192640573,
-0.0150840515,
-0.0170870516,
-0.0055631176,
-0.0846219212,
0.0001071446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08320v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08320v3 | Defending Our Privacy With Backdoors | 2023-10-12T13:33:04 | 2024-02-07T14:13:05 | Dominik Hintersdorf, Lukas Struppek, Daniel Neider, Kristian Kersting | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | The proliferation of large AI models trained on uncurated, often sensitive
web-scraped data has raised significant privacy concerns. One of the concerns
is that adversaries can extract information about the training data using
privacy attacks. Unfortunately, the task of removing specific information from
the models without sacrificing performance is not straightforward and has
proven to be challenging. We propose a rather easy yet effective defense based
on backdoor attacks to remove private information such as names and faces of
individuals from vision-language models by fine-tuning them for only a few
minutes instead of re-training them from scratch. Specifically, through
strategic insertion of backdoors into text encoders, we align the embeddings of
sensitive phrases with those of neutral terms-"a person" instead of the
person's actual name. For image encoders, we map embeddings of individuals to
be removed from the model to a universal, anonymous embedding. Our empirical
results demonstrate the effectiveness of our backdoor-based defense on CLIP by
assessing its performance using a specialized privacy attack for zero-shot
classifiers. Our approach provides not only a new "dual-use" perspective on
backdoor attacks, but also presents a promising avenue to enhance the privacy
of individuals within models trained on uncurated web-scraped data. | [
0.0289054383,
0.1081903726,
-0.0202811621,
0.0587233603,
-0.0390356518,
0.0084603736,
0.0553826205,
0.0128818555,
0.0095859487,
-0.0223653838,
-0.0018888402,
-0.0090356655,
0.0130881919,
0.0418521799,
0.0386904106,
-0.0072072884,
0.0035533097,
0.0015011113,
-0.0018739357,
-0.0245306529,
-0.0145656047,
-0.0312580839,
0.0270222165,
0.0266449042,
-0.0010975722,
0.0062272865,
-0.0194475371,
-0.0123340767,
0.0543687083,
0.0109829959,
-0.0256135538,
0.0303062238,
0.0011440864,
0.0525103956,
0.0000018269,
-0.0202189293,
-0.0089281676,
0.0547230989,
-0.0393937565,
0.0014442023,
-0.0007966032,
-0.0401530601,
0.0009303103,
-0.002601509,
-0.037177261,
0.0331693776,
0.0345568284,
0.036429435,
0.0628593266,
0.06870424,
-0.0307640433,
-0.0271798708,
0.0257620011,
-0.0365748294,
0.0085184071,
-0.024301827,
0.008595028,
-0.0888397545,
-0.0798800513,
0.0087487381,
-0.0187630244,
0.0361971445,
0.0125371488,
0.0219202843,
0.0208731275,
0.0602334403,
-0.0391145907,
-0.04564289,
0.0124210222,
0.0635191575,
-0.0270546135,
0.0160120279,
0.00423173,
0.0126470802,
0.0396944769,
0.0091272667,
0.0175150689,
0.0462625921,
-0.0002063264,
0.0039487146,
-0.0545265228,
-0.0198299494,
0.0321536511,
0.0063591106,
0.0203898642,
-0.0124507062,
0.0148006901,
0.0136316307,
-0.0085929381,
-0.0386943929,
0.0116480505,
-0.0559695363,
0.0297263935,
0.0007913451,
0.0841712803,
-0.0050378409,
-0.0986396372,
-0.0192635804,
-0.0328918658,
-0.0381717421,
0.0229707584,
0.0130238915,
-0.0030473997,
0.0241341498,
-0.0149986343,
0.0650268346,
0.0106858509,
0.0553530008,
0.0206137095,
0.0117008341,
-0.0193148237,
-0.0211333577,
-0.007436364,
0.0463170856,
-0.0738237575,
-0.0280460212,
-0.023657281,
0.0109163374,
-0.0539186411,
0.031132482,
-0.017500909,
0.0348772481,
-0.033055041,
0.0187337995,
0.0033245664,
-0.0559126996,
0.0221934579,
-0.0282342248,
0.0105366977,
-0.0696991757,
-0.0225748178,
-0.0284474324,
0.0025085146,
0.0048254849,
-0.0067233541,
0.0852431431,
0.0160400141,
-0.0333362781,
-0.0035290385,
-0.0628438294,
0.0113437232,
-0.0140862865,
0.0169805028,
-0.0257298201,
-0.0004035369,
-0.0712892264,
0.0029669032,
-0.0869116634,
0.0094474042,
0.0208422411,
-0.0469728373,
0.1124218628,
0.0175514072,
-0.0315722935,
0.0082639353,
0.0272253342,
-0.0065482762,
0.0233926773,
0.0166730583,
0.0560117885,
0.0374214873,
-0.0090889875,
0.0506234206,
-0.0023408437,
0.0375833884,
0.0078136642,
-0.0548407435,
0.0174854677,
0.0061664251,
-0.0360872298,
-0.019212231,
0.0107803959,
-0.0255926903,
-0.0864312053,
0.0733997673,
0.0621816665,
-0.0325188749,
0.0219272356,
-0.0171634518,
0.0126353065,
-0.0204498563,
-0.0103318775,
-0.0614362173,
0.0084285028,
-0.0768954381,
-0.0615275837,
-0.0502128415,
0.0241737179,
-0.0379244238,
-0.0062570865,
0.0360738412,
-0.0579008684,
0.0305042602,
0.0245912094,
0.0178881753,
0.0468180962,
0.0085143959,
-0.0094893128,
-0.0192809105,
-0.0519029275,
-0.0073881042,
-0.0509781428,
-0.0468492098,
0.0507235117,
0.0438195579,
0.0358715281,
0.0198376812,
-0.0385092013,
-0.0411003157,
-0.0112014823,
-0.0111434171,
0.0061387289,
0.0739282072,
-0.0449319817,
-0.0583283156,
-0.0186138991,
0.0060203215,
0.0295781083,
0.0169983525,
-0.0135340411,
0.0497998893,
0.0064969398,
0.023286907,
0.01812144,
-0.0158051588,
-0.0659294501,
0.0309948642,
0.0437160768,
0.0236750841,
0.0176662598,
-0.0165389758,
0.0059898174,
0.0304900631,
0.0138649056,
-0.0036188399,
-0.0171771813,
0.0469972044,
-0.0004163925,
-0.0161385052,
-0.0669781268,
0.0234807413,
0.0832248181,
-0.0285242982,
-0.0039510946,
0.0094752871,
-0.0179229435,
0.0222159941,
-0.0082405861,
0.0023063857,
-0.0058360025,
0.0585696213,
-0.016496405,
0.0304173306,
-0.0294218566,
-0.0489619337,
-0.0404538065,
-0.0418924913,
0.0007571171,
-0.0399398655,
-0.0356132425,
-0.0017908777,
-0.0087716524,
0.0181423966,
-0.0094655138,
-0.0088075446,
-0.0176050998,
-0.0106884204,
-0.0217247475,
-0.0045200172,
-0.0049026986,
-0.0063815466,
-0.0265243836,
0.0019954073,
0.0017905835,
-0.0494101457,
-0.0186894573,
-0.0234390069,
-0.0636586845,
0.0417028256,
0.0040585096,
0.0325354375,
-0.0271514114,
0.0334882066,
-0.0278691687,
0.0175572466,
0.0707462057,
-0.0152845383,
-0.0155763933,
0.0045712595,
0.0168564543,
-0.0282552093,
0.060830541,
-0.0309337471,
-0.0255508125,
0.0003065855,
0.0418209955,
-0.046642933,
0.0675896853,
0.0134776095,
0.0646336451,
0.0255785398,
0.0417933762,
-0.0148141989,
-0.0224705189,
0.0119236987,
-0.0059231226,
-0.0392475016,
0.0019072118,
-0.0083549628,
-0.0198976416,
0.0153139252,
-0.0365626626,
-0.0529440641,
0.0832369477,
0.0105455378,
-0.0507487021,
-0.0440011285,
-0.0372124314,
0.0064066998,
0.0238463972,
-0.0167950504,
-0.0620493889,
0.0528679825,
-0.0165279973,
0.0402472951,
0.0698588341,
-0.0204274282,
0.0197117105,
0.0583277941,
0.0373816602,
0.0393410847,
0.0320081003,
-0.038382899,
-0.0308300573,
0.0143140545,
0.0207482595,
-0.0435737409,
-0.006657612,
0.016355969,
-0.0380288623,
-0.0012969924,
-0.0452309139,
-0.0587599091,
-0.1018880606,
-0.0012139156,
0.0029635809,
-0.0305337012,
-0.0409091562,
-0.0242324602,
-0.0204306301,
0.0095312493,
-0.0280963816,
-0.0110616721,
-0.0013475195,
-0.0362711921,
0.0137502002,
0.0094594462,
-0.0733531415,
-0.0164408777,
-0.0083860997,
0.0035338628,
0.0818262547,
0.0449082553,
0.0322048925,
-0.0004893038,
-0.0127171334,
-0.0073638144,
0.0209466796,
-0.0244454108,
-0.0001811646,
0.0027145727,
-0.0051298058,
-0.0000161103,
0.040306706,
0.0047192597,
-0.0593189225,
0.000326927,
0.0674786717,
-0.0175573267,
0.0091656363,
-0.022598356,
-0.0628153235,
-0.0095139239,
0.0373776853,
0.0292079728,
-0.0522467978,
-0.0238639135,
-0.015631929,
-0.1152334288,
-0.0130033819,
0.0098567009,
-0.0104593327,
-0.0396459661,
-0.0079200463,
0.0115341973,
-0.0033000051,
-0.0256188791,
-0.0368361957,
0.0076953359,
-0.0026228225,
-0.0074078725,
0.0318857692,
-0.0507722311,
-0.0188741032,
-0.0327540934,
0.0273729172,
0.0368493088,
0.0305669475,
-0.024408387,
-0.044341404,
-0.015192044,
0.0113989804,
0.0143564492,
0.0258455761,
0.1260844767,
-0.0448564589,
-0.0189690404,
0.0124708498,
0.0497379601,
0.0237545967,
0.0125983898,
0.0133197177,
-0.0057738665,
-0.0193253867,
-0.0096025821,
-0.0067907786,
-0.0458611958,
0.0102497805,
0.047300797,
-0.0011684215,
-0.0215231106,
0.0075369719,
-0.0486571267,
0.0345710255,
0.0105920555,
-0.025807742,
0.0331781544,
0.0195709541,
-0.0867665559,
-0.0123433201,
0.00122233,
-0.0010231322,
0.0417109057,
0.0379810743,
-0.0375633501,
0.0111161852,
0.0225201603,
-0.053071484,
0.0026924005,
-0.0523104481,
0.002836321,
0.0084940391,
0.0106393965,
0.0252651088,
-0.0003341906,
-0.0187988412,
0.0079602432,
-0.0574155152,
-0.0599966608,
0.0054340973,
0.0523648746,
0.0162503738,
0.0690784678,
-0.0257006232,
-0.0517114922,
0.1167185605,
0.0446874946,
0.0057546808,
-0.006631738,
0.0940450802,
-0.0530358516,
-0.0007479794,
0.033059001,
0.0091051552,
-0.0272417553,
0.0520770885,
-0.0603985451,
-0.0511587113,
-0.0124642057,
-0.0316790268,
0.0157298427,
0.0635488853,
-0.0041579362,
0.0457831882,
0.020156242,
0.038400732,
-0.0319403745,
0.0179640688,
-0.0113705462,
-0.0044613858,
0.0420595333,
0.0165808368,
0.0637367368,
0.0162967462,
0.0022874796,
0.0006187724,
-0.0614447966,
-0.0192102343,
0.0263989624,
0.0299561229,
0.0022153263,
0.0349547192,
-0.0056688385,
0.0559509881,
0.043510735,
0.0292866807,
-0.0257526021,
-0.000182329,
0.0131751187,
0.0286859367,
-0.025118988,
0.04121124,
-0.065049693,
-0.0213517081,
-0.0365604721,
0.0466475524,
-0.0368387476,
0.0314318836,
-0.0473855995,
-0.0103450408,
-0.0035182992,
0.0009053872,
-0.0106588788,
-0.0266947094,
-0.0579433292,
0.0136025511,
-0.0136740496,
-0.014953794,
0.0506565906,
0.0785171464,
0.0206941534,
0.0482584275,
-0.0364828631,
-0.0384327509,
-0.0484885573,
-0.0060269944,
0.0418151468,
0.0296579115,
0.0016197724,
0.0088120997,
-0.0162430815,
-0.0756373033,
-0.0274444409,
-0.0131401233,
0.0420608632,
0.0337293632,
0.0122107416,
0.0063777277,
0.011359673,
-0.0044804206,
-0.0751594454,
0.0057322308,
0.0029691632,
-0.0301880464,
0.0181907322,
-5.483363028e-33,
0.0269218106,
-0.0065992028,
-0.0152040953,
0.0420571789,
0.0127596455,
0.0498584993,
0.0281201378,
0.0016581398,
-0.0176838711,
-0.0127881486,
-0.0281107184,
0.0122740045,
-0.0121426648,
0.029529579,
-0.0356136188,
-0.0253664758,
0.029467646,
-0.010745367,
-0.0149844764,
0.0126460157,
0.0438455902,
0.0214926377,
0.0329137966,
-0.0515374057,
0.0291658361,
0.0228478462,
-0.0698920116,
0.0027204244,
-0.0145809762,
0.0614834242,
-0.0080658346,
-0.0169312656,
0.0057983389,
0.018468231,
0.0036191856,
0.0545002483,
-0.0364935026,
-0.0074334894,
-0.0746195912,
0.0104768472,
0.0111147659,
-0.0650591925,
0.0302866716,
-0.0521094166,
-0.0029324242,
-0.0192137286,
0.0071773026,
-0.0115168551,
-0.0074296528,
-0.0022366438,
0.0179567337,
-0.0032084377,
-0.0403568447,
-0.0185781512,
0.0767033026,
0.0269721188,
0.0248281453,
-0.0204419047,
-0.043772094,
0.0090682823,
0.0475493409,
-0.0482448079,
0.0385997221,
0.0020514147,
0.0406803526,
0.063739799,
0.0439025275,
-0.020911254,
-0.0206300896,
-0.0414826386,
0.0236812793,
0.050349649,
0.0240056198,
0.046600882,
0.0618266836,
-0.0593558438,
-0.0379210077,
0.0069790152,
-0.0521250777,
-0.0173637178,
0.0571345836,
0.0079007018,
-0.0675594583,
0.0210387371,
-0.0597898513,
-0.0675165728,
-0.0338869467,
-0.00032545,
0.0042321607,
0.0307998322,
-0.0728350058,
0.0299162883,
-0.0023043542,
-0.0810376555,
0.0123175485,
0.0301944129,
0.0182155855,
0.0176747739,
-0.0026705198,
-0.0111921551,
0.0230094809,
-0.0154369613,
0.0466475934,
-0.0169444419,
0.0525058955,
-0.012785865,
0.0845525935,
0.0176800098,
-0.0539223962,
-0.0480798073,
-0.0395405814,
0.0542557873,
0.054787863,
0.0522983074,
0.0303239301,
-0.0009318423,
-0.0189608056,
-0.0003629132,
0.0174973272,
0.056435518,
-0.0492961854,
0.0491516292,
-0.0030025935,
-0.0117290169,
0.0153095732,
-0.0276524071,
0.0278418921,
0.0260256957,
0.0974909812,
-0.0155466087,
-0.0035615487,
0.0008250627,
2.749e-7,
-0.048134353,
-0.0127305761,
0.0145816719,
-0.0284427181,
0.0108421827,
0.093822442,
0.0304595008,
0.0825197622,
-0.0195290446,
-0.0134065896,
-0.0058233021,
0.026894154,
0.0396942943,
-0.0160358232,
-0.0262976326,
-0.0128459446,
-0.0010735159,
-0.0071185934,
-0.0251279417,
-0.0071426099,
0.008503098,
0.091775313,
0.0645189658,
-0.0251313802,
0.0028981208,
-0.0362277925,
0.024077164,
-0.027146697,
-0.0194123425,
-0.0439537168,
-0.0078278519,
0.1084711924,
0.0008347108,
-0.0012390742,
-0.0546933003,
0.017236786,
-0.0294207316,
0.05155636,
-0.0289113615,
-0.0184802935,
-0.0336443968,
0.0073554497,
-0.0146219218,
0.0087018367,
0.0545449108,
-0.000114296,
-0.0655671209,
-0.0388151743,
-0.0172499437,
-0.0344639458,
0.0584597066,
-0.0284446869,
0.0068925852,
0.0104964916,
0.0274769962,
-0.0108300233,
0.0042209341,
-0.1010503247,
0.0093588848,
-0.0573693104,
-0.0114848418,
0.005945561,
0.0306040104,
0.0041188467,
0.0231197998,
0.0127423685,
0.0061847572,
2.089007745e-34,
-0.01664708,
0.0046355035,
-0.0080497684,
0.0141757689,
0.0286788531,
-0.0012018803,
0.0228763577,
-0.0339282006,
-0.0090589281,
-0.0381587148,
-0.033635173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08309v1 | Not All Demonstration Examples are Equally Beneficial: Reweighting Demonstration Examples for In-Context Learning | 2023-10-12T13:15:11 | 2023-10-12T13:15:11 | Zhe Yang, Damai Dai, Peiyi Wang, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently gained the In-Context Learning
(ICL) ability with the models scaling up, allowing them to quickly adapt to
downstream tasks with only a few demonstration examples prepended in the input
sequence. Nonetheless, the current practice of ICL treats all demonstration
examples equally, which still warrants improvement, as the quality of examples
is usually uneven. In this paper, we investigate how to determine approximately
optimal weights for demonstration examples and how to apply them during ICL. To
assess the quality of weights in the absence of additional validation data, we
design a masked self-prediction (MSP) score that exhibits a strong correlation
with the final ICL performance. To expedite the weight-searching process, we
discretize the continuous weight space and adopt beam search. With
approximately optimal weights obtained, we further propose two strategies to
apply them to demonstrations at different model positions. Experimental results
on 8 text classification tasks show that our approach outperforms conventional
ICL by a large margin. Our code are publicly available at
https:github.com/Zhe-Young/WICL. | [
-0.0010435537,
0.021257855,
0.0055285525,
0.0316771865,
-0.0305432808,
0.0079525718,
0.0609384663,
0.0187757667,
0.0461003743,
-0.0246300641,
-0.0376316942,
-0.0380367339,
-0.0093859639,
0.0004249552,
0.0286028609,
-0.0373491533,
0.0086370474,
-0.0156395044,
-0.032567367,
-0.0057141772,
-0.0256900508,
-0.0194631647,
-0.006457286,
0.0208491348,
-0.0026247881,
-0.0336779952,
-0.0019008175,
0.0238435473,
-0.0003331358,
-0.0844717547,
0.0533429757,
0.04035924,
0.0457780249,
0.0266186371,
0.0000022084,
-0.0468982384,
0.0039288523,
0.0120927282,
-0.068169795,
0.0064711245,
0.067741923,
0.0024874236,
0.017708132,
0.0434736051,
-0.0531352013,
-0.0273823291,
0.0060008029,
0.0616167746,
0.0311145801,
0.0864029825,
0.0041785864,
-0.0165612511,
-0.0340152159,
-0.0436460562,
0.0214690026,
-0.0305853449,
0.0399784446,
-0.0193741079,
0.0089397822,
0.0011085356,
0.0001789909,
0.0428439677,
0.0411978811,
0.0118198944,
-0.0097798705,
0.0346739851,
-0.0452070385,
0.0108403265,
-0.0196900032,
0.036600925,
-0.0280287378,
-0.0647604689,
-0.0045703091,
-0.0460959226,
0.0199047644,
-0.014022598,
-0.0422701687,
-0.0101817334,
0.0307552014,
0.0077482439,
0.0243904646,
0.0599797182,
0.0454887114,
-0.0000156396,
-0.0175892171,
0.0463526137,
-0.0263906326,
-0.0587355718,
0.0117885275,
-0.017374225,
-0.0416800678,
-0.0317661241,
-0.0043441649,
0.031751655,
-0.0220791958,
0.0352392085,
-0.0420470834,
-0.0452495329,
-0.0005026468,
-0.0519306734,
0.0511173718,
0.0169794466,
0.0073897634,
0.0458233841,
-0.0454469956,
0.0422671624,
0.024121521,
0.0110008791,
-0.0591135323,
0.0202367697,
-0.0476263128,
0.0089340275,
-0.0711729005,
0.0310482215,
-0.0107228868,
-0.0276283044,
-0.0289901067,
0.0334799811,
-0.0348788612,
-0.0040115891,
0.0106425649,
-0.0242454745,
-0.0223857462,
0.0246665739,
0.0214685388,
-0.0101816608,
0.0137485377,
-0.0113716619,
-0.0153048653,
-0.0434074625,
-0.0362800211,
0.0301578641,
-0.0171919893,
-0.028659096,
0.0380398743,
0.0657797158,
0.0092142709,
-0.0893577263,
0.0143380063,
0.0045089899,
-0.0156323239,
-0.0334455408,
-0.0097961724,
-0.0627422184,
-0.0232399851,
0.007904591,
0.0193210877,
-0.0269355811,
0.0027798158,
0.034822315,
0.0149285495,
0.0584974065,
0.0268752202,
0.0111589395,
0.0425356217,
0.0112270648,
-0.0278453436,
0.06835448,
-0.0195397865,
0.0080817426,
0.0325808749,
0.009801914,
0.0366661698,
0.0395770855,
0.0741537586,
0.0358963311,
-0.0381393731,
0.0368073136,
0.0334725007,
0.0546027198,
0.0092910342,
-0.0252496582,
-0.0268283337,
0.0069642374,
0.051946979,
0.0473218225,
0.0398683995,
-0.0433794372,
0.0072715404,
0.0281755477,
0.0231493916,
0.0137916589,
-0.0315493755,
-0.0054939417,
-0.0511621051,
-0.0203315374,
0.0061010746,
-0.0070901662,
-0.0493113138,
-0.0282702856,
-0.0236365348,
-0.0101577528,
0.0328341164,
0.033736527,
0.0307802614,
0.0279133227,
-0.0594298616,
0.0198290572,
0.0347285792,
-0.0052983011,
-0.0122782318,
-0.0716887936,
0.0050622425,
-0.0010162339,
0.034771271,
-0.0511145629,
0.0027606087,
0.0058211805,
0.0567992516,
0.000602801,
0.0379904509,
-0.0236184672,
-0.0078427913,
-0.0155977085,
-0.0316252373,
-0.0099601494,
0.0085648056,
-0.011397481,
0.0270389169,
0.0050926828,
0.0036191922,
-0.0507952496,
-0.0550909638,
0.0682884678,
-0.028677972,
-0.0737666637,
0.0605989099,
-0.0038088611,
0.0481731221,
-0.0023023584,
-0.0015530762,
-0.0195572097,
0.0484863669,
-0.0060370141,
-0.0057388786,
-0.0193827208,
-0.0730381161,
-0.1106189042,
0.013673719,
-0.0171287134,
-0.0026192826,
0.0187023785,
-0.0403467268,
-0.0336552039,
-0.0163575821,
-0.009026452,
0.044386562,
-0.0409133025,
0.0139832851,
-0.0268183108,
0.0157177169,
-0.058048252,
0.0717117786,
0.0239590649,
0.0308681931,
-0.0278369766,
0.0114442213,
0.0141287055,
-0.0349040665,
-0.0364564583,
-0.0265837833,
-0.0250409208,
0.029991515,
0.0097136516,
0.0439027846,
-0.0181377996,
0.0129527589,
-0.118929781,
-0.0019418652,
-0.0539963432,
-0.0235778801,
0.0010771307,
-0.0022314407,
-0.0310761314,
-0.0418105461,
-0.0262823366,
-0.0658259839,
-0.0230951458,
-0.006328071,
0.0117597608,
0.0469517149,
0.0152002685,
0.0155413309,
-0.0149434963,
0.0037000771,
0.0900486335,
-0.0255290866,
0.0062076608,
-0.0567423366,
0.0506253429,
0.0476749614,
0.0181722436,
-0.0117927324,
0.0195036735,
-0.0074433046,
0.012296523,
0.008840085,
0.0561720617,
0.0177923962,
0.0510898158,
0.0383601002,
0.0655739531,
-0.0842821971,
0.0099881925,
-0.0280396361,
0.0316036567,
-0.0399121456,
0.0291819721,
0.0514138043,
0.0253241379,
0.0018921645,
-0.0087693287,
-0.0414453745,
0.0112485131,
-0.0154131837,
-0.0208133701,
-0.0529991835,
-0.0210859329,
-0.0178258121,
-0.0188681856,
0.0250184033,
-0.047094319,
0.0530607738,
-0.0330233686,
0.0045724376,
-0.0628206581,
-0.0511143804,
-0.0308149122,
0.0213125851,
-0.0018973327,
0.0047993721,
0.0018972678,
0.0000215162,
-0.0163141098,
0.0013875739,
0.0145199047,
-0.0205893572,
0.0068742428,
-0.0251906179,
0.0226501301,
0.0203134138,
-0.0531476587,
-0.0513311215,
-0.0696115717,
0.0162079446,
-0.0104345279,
-0.0418809503,
0.0267159548,
-0.0231535286,
0.0066117235,
0.0135366637,
0.0789135545,
-0.0078036883,
-0.0229711141,
0.0087552844,
0.0003821386,
-0.0015937445,
-0.0062674368,
0.0243011061,
-0.0584493913,
-0.0025627869,
-0.0006350304,
0.0991122276,
-0.0034570943,
-0.0483690985,
-0.0101306457,
0.0495807044,
-0.0586839952,
0.0026017532,
0.0557150468,
0.0260047056,
-0.0697565824,
0.0029202092,
0.103441149,
0.015163606,
-0.0764074475,
0.0100683952,
0.0014039767,
-0.0088481167,
0.0474017113,
0.0438172109,
-0.0472754091,
-0.0196341258,
0.008933411,
0.022021547,
-0.0053160968,
-0.0058695576,
-0.0004535187,
-0.1404748857,
0.0508218333,
0.0100239646,
-0.0224203654,
0.0044039912,
-0.0506364964,
-0.0047189943,
-0.0183449835,
0.0112151718,
-0.001686884,
-0.0347822085,
-0.0015416327,
0.0389949642,
-0.0285756681,
-0.1108889654,
0.0412316434,
-0.0157984458,
0.0309752002,
0.0139416652,
0.0076637152,
-0.0099237282,
-0.0484220721,
0.0488007665,
-0.0476794317,
0.0043352083,
-0.0382946059,
0.0476484038,
0.0007567335,
-0.0019376689,
0.0222577173,
0.0330597758,
-0.0162061919,
-0.0333584212,
0.0093517005,
0.0618644692,
-0.0113035943,
-0.0218040347,
-0.0088189393,
-0.0625910088,
0.0653083399,
0.0786296725,
0.0091049653,
-0.0619305484,
0.0100771738,
0.0123289451,
0.0138727333,
0.0248287842,
0.0025601194,
0.0299472231,
0.0044349013,
0.0491424203,
-0.0340368673,
0.0153430467,
0.0079919705,
0.1133746579,
-0.0095607331,
0.0230405293,
-0.0557251088,
-0.01442926,
-0.0469363444,
0.033525452,
-0.0318270586,
0.0213879049,
-0.0315750502,
0.0233569834,
0.0378444195,
-0.0391728058,
-0.04161378,
0.012765822,
-0.0340865366,
-0.0465565138,
0.0113644879,
0.0314768068,
0.0109319314,
0.0596960522,
-0.0031208454,
-0.0567071587,
0.1423036158,
0.0273661818,
-0.0098706214,
-0.0079841362,
0.0476767905,
-0.038428016,
-0.0234026257,
0.0184789337,
-0.0179750677,
0.0125910081,
0.0160298198,
0.0064880955,
-0.0267333817,
0.0028711378,
0.0170895346,
0.0072426517,
0.0538125411,
-0.0232208036,
-0.0461157747,
-0.0099809365,
0.0522440672,
0.0237551387,
-0.0346202925,
-0.0065580108,
0.0111821359,
0.0078175562,
0.0194881763,
-0.0173288025,
0.0546138771,
0.0023911532,
0.0249394383,
-0.0297099538,
0.0168169271,
-0.0024007994,
0.010401234,
0.0136059364,
0.0258171987,
0.0063184206,
-0.0229432173,
0.026187297,
0.0289096516,
-0.0043673865,
0.0349443555,
0.0487058535,
0.0416017026,
0.0078401826,
0.0208278652,
-0.0717062801,
0.0282311793,
-0.0812250674,
0.0038192431,
0.0362113528,
-0.0241602007,
0.0133595262,
-0.0249120519,
-0.0272829179,
-0.0302281845,
-0.0100022173,
-0.0468350016,
-0.038865082,
0.0114177298,
0.0265095625,
-0.0256417654,
0.0335537568,
0.061346069,
0.0006254731,
0.0294309687,
0.045380719,
0.011477273,
-0.0483555086,
0.0092353998,
0.0936372653,
0.0513997115,
-0.002844508,
-0.0087021329,
-0.0231777299,
-0.0472924523,
0.0370343514,
-0.0095334807,
-0.0185988452,
-0.0266428143,
0.0434936695,
0.0608626045,
0.0042864205,
0.0176674984,
-0.0139465751,
-0.0461616255,
0.0275924765,
-0.0293762609,
-0.0125896465,
-6.413375221e-33,
-0.0068036267,
-0.0353204086,
0.0180927832,
0.0383706205,
0.0242383126,
0.0044801566,
-0.0038583304,
-0.0211416706,
0.0153545681,
0.0057592401,
-0.0280770585,
-0.0055962494,
0.0134883225,
0.019936854,
-0.0045058411,
0.0208213516,
0.0361246653,
-0.0245604608,
-0.0458580777,
0.0119238934,
-0.0389746018,
0.0401439294,
0.0354993865,
-0.0894285291,
0.0109135509,
0.0026502837,
-0.0274072513,
-0.0037372934,
-0.0322582051,
0.0380064622,
-0.0244144853,
0.0522554219,
0.0124096619,
-0.0315824263,
-0.0259656552,
-0.0082740374,
-0.0470902547,
-0.0277582314,
-0.0331314951,
0.0221116729,
-0.0405478589,
0.0090023642,
0.0310689434,
-0.0137203578,
-0.0678544417,
0.0089999959,
0.0310206432,
-0.0048240069,
-0.0226708073,
-0.0392836593,
-0.0051741903,
0.0256256796,
0.0151768522,
-0.0211051479,
0.0392884314,
0.0075669969,
0.0123336436,
-0.0026630887,
-0.0943304747,
-0.00576135,
-0.0192145463,
0.0243898928,
0.0456574969,
0.005423347,
0.0264822356,
0.0527919084,
0.0159508754,
-0.0008723229,
0.0653097406,
-0.0721561834,
0.0824721307,
0.0077332351,
0.0388497151,
0.0391335152,
0.1012233719,
0.0001725786,
-0.0711039156,
0.0159558598,
-0.00058071,
-0.0196186919,
0.0500138104,
0.0281036068,
-0.0487337001,
-0.0248149037,
-0.0434783809,
-0.0334020294,
-0.0174096469,
-0.0335092023,
0.0281601232,
0.0679953918,
-0.0198598541,
0.0331395864,
0.0207482018,
-0.0592520237,
-0.0628479198,
0.0027178561,
-0.0132372873,
-0.0001914894,
0.0286008492,
0.0098482957,
-0.0349736325,
-0.0468905978,
0.0015966888,
0.0201351605,
0.0288050994,
-0.0248026121,
0.061152678,
0.0615591295,
-0.0844956189,
-0.0076406258,
-0.0076948651,
0.0251583662,
0.0093728658,
0.0359469205,
0.0345664732,
0.0139424019,
-0.0122859236,
0.0219239648,
0.0198136494,
-0.0624219216,
-0.0599758178,
0.0011378811,
-0.0367794856,
-0.0025288661,
-0.0053572827,
-0.0001429566,
0.0103159659,
0.0425743312,
0.0624253638,
-0.0325953104,
-0.0143706976,
0.0209101569,
2.854e-7,
0.0180990864,
0.0612345636,
-0.0196487885,
0.0146237407,
0.0080354614,
0.0416424014,
-0.0481955484,
0.0489361435,
-0.0112569584,
-0.0088052908,
0.0071454016,
0.0052878256,
0.0531827249,
0.0127221411,
-0.0917549059,
0.0002699473,
-0.0518617108,
0.0016799723,
-0.0326604173,
-0.0074403565,
-0.0053138593,
0.0924832374,
0.0306718908,
-0.0219601523,
-0.0017509762,
-0.0431285277,
0.0650147721,
-0.0159178153,
0.0066941208,
0.0139395641,
-0.0199622922,
0.0484110191,
-0.002232064,
0.0218328834,
-0.0231030621,
0.0470484272,
-0.0027936834,
0.0234395973,
0.0142508503,
-0.0194559153,
0.0066271573,
0.0438632593,
-0.0005934578,
-0.0240993612,
0.0433534607,
-0.0981975421,
-0.003187574,
-0.0322425105,
0.0092128189,
-0.0569277778,
0.042786289,
0.0139940092,
0.015473119,
0.0340216793,
0.0136086931,
-0.0083072605,
-0.0322097912,
-0.0974935442,
-0.0440659374,
0.0186413042,
-0.0465046763,
0.0142333936,
-0.0415159874,
0.0279910397,
0.0056438139,
-0.0743560269,
0.0305599086,
2.94178229e-34,
0.0300268196,
-0.0101849278,
-0.0248019919,
0.0157834813,
-0.01667176,
-0.012875556,
-0.0038733662,
0.0146069955,
0.0366305634,
-0.040938016,
0.007607731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08298v1 | MProto: Multi-Prototype Network with Denoised Optimal Transport for Distantly Supervised Named Entity Recognition | 2023-10-12T13:02:34 | 2023-10-12T13:02:34 | Shuhui Wu, Yongliang Shen, Zeqi Tan, Wenqi Ren, Jietian Guo, Shiliang Pu, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distantly supervised named entity recognition (DS-NER) aims to locate entity
mentions and classify their types with only knowledge bases or gazetteers and
unlabeled corpus. However, distant annotations are noisy and degrade the
performance of NER models. In this paper, we propose a noise-robust prototype
network named MProto for the DS-NER task. Different from previous
prototype-based NER methods, MProto represents each entity type with multiple
prototypes to characterize the intra-class variance among entity
representations. To optimize the classifier, each token should be assigned an
appropriate ground-truth prototype and we consider such token-prototype
assignment as an optimal transport (OT) problem. Furthermore, to mitigate the
noise from incomplete labeling, we propose a novel denoised optimal transport
(DOT) algorithm. Specifically, we utilize the assignment result between Other
class tokens and all prototypes to distinguish unlabeled entity tokens from
true negatives. Experiments on several DS-NER benchmarks demonstrate that our
MProto achieves state-of-the-art performance. The source code is now available
on Github. | [
0.0194501355,
0.0441916659,
0.0113122864,
0.0192008726,
0.011463264,
0.0281943716,
0.0329502709,
0.0079889409,
0.0022232863,
-0.0174322538,
0.0131478067,
-0.0038934702,
-0.0104874084,
0.0205113832,
0.0329625867,
-0.0004061456,
0.0239154026,
0.0101297339,
-0.0081604207,
0.0228529014,
-0.0061610956,
-0.0214435011,
-0.0421116315,
0.0296833329,
0.0017310408,
0.0081382738,
-0.0335849598,
0.0170978382,
0.0120446533,
-0.0799124017,
0.0373543799,
0.0483000837,
0.0036350396,
0.012779139,
0.0000022349,
-0.0279611833,
-0.0260754507,
0.0051212073,
0.0006279994,
-0.028531028,
0.0396999009,
0.0180413071,
0.0214718748,
0.0051511973,
0.0479235984,
-0.1115427166,
0.0841767415,
0.0839847103,
0.0155401062,
0.0563315153,
-0.015636066,
0.0022429186,
0.0467377268,
-0.0196216945,
0.0032428729,
-0.0119769294,
0.048725076,
-0.0504363105,
-0.0585587509,
-0.0091557661,
-0.0020576227,
0.0098813325,
-0.0372314528,
0.0303688832,
0.0751103014,
0.0385927819,
-0.0083859041,
-0.0099645592,
0.0049681356,
0.1133951545,
0.0106855463,
-0.0064164558,
0.0576729663,
0.0204381477,
-0.0205905605,
-0.0602501482,
0.0082019577,
-0.0409402587,
-0.016384976,
-0.0158906914,
-0.0167126711,
0.0418953635,
0.0245550852,
0.0036281457,
-0.0142700309,
-0.0212076623,
0.0073800506,
-0.0218265411,
0.0070815445,
0.0373185836,
0.0120113259,
-0.0379587375,
0.0869876221,
0.003513495,
0.0366000831,
0.0014925079,
0.004348306,
-0.0496436879,
-0.0088658025,
-0.0346768238,
-0.0445011146,
0.0113610579,
-0.0199905783,
0.0356662869,
-0.0745716542,
-0.0267475266,
-0.0238634665,
0.0079889344,
0.0287748128,
-0.0229939483,
-0.0609926656,
0.0162574723,
-0.0522018485,
0.1136828363,
-0.0143882409,
0.0020318648,
-0.0332274027,
0.0064515066,
-0.0282906126,
-0.0102023417,
-0.0168026388,
0.0066773565,
-0.0253666528,
0.0003614041,
-0.0165648665,
0.0275847968,
-0.0284269582,
0.0160500687,
-0.0341591574,
0.000872117,
-0.0015522445,
0.0008647545,
0.0342439264,
-0.0156039353,
0.0101809436,
0.1094625741,
0.0218627155,
-0.0653457269,
-0.0837522298,
0.0269325953,
0.0071796947,
-0.0415722542,
-0.0110895131,
-0.0331881046,
-0.0001507018,
0.0211407952,
0.0088530518,
-0.0729206577,
0.0042641717,
-0.0349807553,
-0.0309056509,
0.0473022498,
-0.0241013691,
-0.0393088572,
0.0234411303,
0.0184175484,
-0.0155405002,
0.0435353145,
0.0554085374,
0.0030277774,
0.0002816785,
-0.0069186571,
-0.0382736996,
0.0004456293,
0.0353691876,
-0.0052724504,
-0.0120467879,
-0.0081598507,
0.0026468334,
0.0309250746,
0.0434366167,
0.0341747291,
-0.0446170606,
-0.0189782158,
0.0183840673,
0.0186124649,
-0.0176129919,
0.0181701016,
0.0192228425,
-0.0036811971,
-0.0342437997,
-0.0475318693,
-0.0022323541,
0.0089925388,
-0.0178687666,
-0.0349880941,
0.0266527496,
0.063101992,
-0.0418149717,
0.002698594,
0.0358508788,
-0.02979034,
0.0063955467,
-0.0211479422,
0.0671594366,
-0.0221464112,
-0.0538367443,
0.0904491395,
0.0376701467,
0.0071929982,
-0.0108322762,
-0.0087411944,
0.0456790179,
0.0051322114,
0.0109800957,
-0.0181172583,
-0.0780804232,
-0.0445219688,
-0.0581763424,
0.0684024021,
0.0046480936,
-0.0058427532,
0.0519356839,
-0.029841084,
-0.0055866982,
0.036705181,
0.0331693925,
0.046803169,
-0.002469538,
0.0689045861,
0.0528378561,
-0.1163007692,
0.0010534739,
0.0313538685,
0.0228410847,
-0.0083767176,
0.0301200263,
0.0491757132,
0.0350408219,
0.0263294689,
0.0107968636,
-0.0352653936,
0.0176771171,
-0.0207856707,
0.0077360552,
-0.0315720662,
-0.0278152041,
-0.028700443,
0.0062363488,
-0.0372852124,
-0.0094899824,
0.01743971,
-0.0244713072,
-0.0454739109,
0.0218525343,
0.0214512814,
0.052813936,
-0.0223906599,
-0.008282464,
0.0151764601,
0.0237627998,
-0.0098442575,
0.0641058683,
0.0140622798,
0.0497359075,
0.0166621413,
-0.0007146235,
0.0190887358,
0.0042705489,
-0.0391949974,
-0.008765352,
-0.0088970521,
-0.0259117689,
0.0089535927,
-0.0284200665,
-0.0457045361,
-0.0351825431,
-0.0911658332,
-0.0039169635,
0.0104977172,
0.0199558195,
0.0009412715,
0.0331125259,
0.0174090937,
-0.0172297861,
-0.0160313901,
0.0330602862,
-0.0513838977,
-0.0034784335,
0.0414156616,
-0.0205042642,
-0.0497939698,
0.0186722986,
-0.008738053,
-0.0236562863,
0.0344102681,
-0.023532806,
-0.0811918303,
-0.0672796145,
0.0286609884,
-0.0619060546,
0.0197289623,
0.0384057425,
0.0196978189,
-0.0170007367,
0.0298507847,
0.0066381106,
0.0090955729,
-0.0040899613,
0.0010565141,
-0.0103122136,
0.0029061036,
-0.0466670692,
0.0146382479,
-0.0310978219,
0.078944169,
-0.0137142288,
0.0086518219,
-0.0145154847,
0.085819073,
-0.0334991105,
-0.0095299324,
-0.0395746194,
0.0020913992,
-0.0055146646,
-0.0019249204,
-0.004231181,
0.0389497094,
0.0036396708,
-0.0185017288,
-0.0255122893,
0.0329401009,
0.0763747543,
-0.0434834361,
-0.0110182269,
0.0118385283,
-0.0189295132,
-0.0366073847,
0.0019167829,
0.0231891833,
0.0267588291,
0.0309639182,
-0.0959822908,
-0.0051646628,
0.0108817462,
-0.0030320892,
0.0015931698,
0.0381480046,
0.0440013297,
0.0318395719,
-0.0271477774,
-0.0523827672,
-0.0231219381,
-0.018702602,
-0.0017098405,
0.0088443849,
-0.0145104779,
-0.006088526,
-0.0705336779,
0.0674946085,
-0.0218171868,
0.069742851,
0.0096221659,
-0.0098378211,
-0.0247181207,
0.0525959767,
-0.0065699187,
-0.0054906793,
0.0286833327,
0.0357500091,
-0.0098583624,
0.0321954973,
-0.0213604588,
-0.0275261197,
-0.0314442441,
0.0110061262,
-0.0048793741,
-0.0320511684,
-0.01621438,
-0.0019418257,
0.0475635566,
0.0138400896,
-0.046259407,
0.0777092576,
-0.0170510821,
-0.0471902639,
-0.0082405526,
0.0653394237,
0.0499471501,
0.0130562494,
0.0310285762,
-0.0275070872,
-0.0283310227,
0.020603193,
0.0164228752,
0.007942724,
-0.0918756723,
0.0037385914,
-0.0751280263,
-0.0155340768,
0.0079048406,
-0.0995332897,
-0.020680191,
-0.0875398219,
0.0183262005,
-0.0183389261,
-0.0100596715,
-0.0284608863,
0.0285670981,
-0.0226125997,
0.0458138883,
-0.009908434,
-0.015573374,
0.0135625806,
-0.0087215109,
0.0871947855,
-0.0163280219,
-0.0000539654,
-0.0216941107,
-0.0222944301,
-0.0123774642,
-0.0598555692,
-0.0563570671,
-0.010868432,
0.0643577203,
-0.052427642,
-0.0167037044,
-0.0203488581,
-0.0215026364,
-0.0635482222,
-0.0092374478,
0.0099324044,
0.0595390908,
0.0114835706,
-0.0188908577,
-0.0387375504,
-0.0394415855,
0.0315538943,
0.0505752973,
0.0039894306,
-0.0281702653,
-0.0119749401,
0.0127081955,
-0.0001633954,
-0.0084719891,
0.0673184469,
-0.0274202581,
-0.0349783115,
-0.0498192869,
-0.0497147553,
-0.0242839716,
0.0167193729,
0.0622906014,
0.0195278227,
0.0004200269,
0.0225382987,
0.0141643174,
-0.0397910997,
0.0279091652,
-0.0227335915,
-0.0341519378,
-0.0618606359,
0.0081298789,
0.0696778744,
0.0101026278,
-0.0505837239,
0.0032972295,
-0.0572861917,
-0.0437870398,
0.0109558189,
-0.0294051338,
0.0059424019,
0.0070192725,
-0.0242714882,
-0.0295956805,
0.0802268013,
0.0632025376,
-0.0582740605,
-0.0211638287,
0.0326406769,
-0.0004399311,
-0.0060617561,
0.007461803,
-0.0317460373,
0.0549894646,
0.0424801521,
0.0164019652,
-0.0357756577,
-0.0309387241,
-0.0351648517,
0.0008069724,
0.0889082029,
0.0258030929,
-0.0004260348,
-0.0635228232,
0.0202643014,
0.0627896339,
0.0337241851,
-0.0323602296,
0.0079077706,
0.0314461999,
0.009696438,
-0.023492666,
-0.0250221863,
0.0320790298,
0.0379218347,
0.0203354489,
-0.0227247961,
0.0157526657,
0.0052111698,
-0.0067228796,
-0.0033100904,
-0.0509532355,
0.031672623,
0.0496596284,
0.052902177,
-0.0754089132,
0.003365414,
0.0198603421,
0.0445211455,
-0.0106108813,
-0.0223110486,
-0.0270328373,
0.0519684143,
-0.0621821843,
0.0793991536,
0.0333721675,
0.0510109514,
0.0256649982,
-0.005427598,
0.0160198342,
-0.0052134893,
0.0031639871,
-0.0292908773,
0.012312307,
0.0375883393,
0.0194645301,
-0.0012663398,
0.0293035544,
0.0437608398,
0.0320997275,
0.0586405732,
0.0049893772,
0.0144966459,
-0.0605274402,
0.0283228606,
0.0381598808,
0.0336014964,
-0.0017818849,
0.0260962825,
-0.0028637135,
-0.0524633676,
0.0521197654,
-0.0812730715,
-0.0222735703,
0.0135986637,
0.0182947423,
-0.0060556489,
0.0139355585,
-0.0513832755,
-0.0102043096,
-0.02381441,
0.038654916,
-0.0175885987,
0.0116963601,
-7.164067219e-33,
-0.046065785,
-0.038431704,
-0.0043909894,
-0.0358912125,
-0.0052789585,
0.0363550298,
-0.0014256475,
0.0002813904,
-0.002272056,
-0.0136440974,
0.0011723447,
0.0100025591,
0.0131368181,
0.0033264623,
-0.0149527499,
-0.0453299358,
0.0659068748,
0.0222775638,
0.0207724143,
0.0292232186,
0.042425476,
0.0660418272,
0.0584005862,
-0.0939248577,
0.0161931552,
-0.0179734565,
-0.0250685979,
0.0058854492,
0.0737614781,
0.0444822758,
-0.0470886342,
0.0078088203,
-0.0082835518,
0.0041150679,
-0.0030912526,
-0.0233515743,
-0.1275465339,
-0.0278582722,
-0.0383855253,
0.0311832037,
0.0204843897,
-0.048780717,
0.0679402873,
0.0155978417,
0.0156532433,
0.0043060821,
0.0469737239,
0.0134351989,
-0.0201219413,
-0.0191756319,
-0.0266582146,
0.0454655103,
-0.0248936862,
0.0509962551,
0.053681083,
-0.0340201035,
0.0114878248,
-0.0385151803,
-0.1204375401,
0.0065104803,
-0.0359909758,
-0.0078832349,
-0.0126467878,
0.0277288314,
-0.0125452895,
0.0374566279,
0.0459397361,
-0.0056172358,
0.0085565522,
-0.0195229873,
0.034242671,
0.0021421374,
-0.0090421122,
0.0021210068,
0.0462594777,
-0.0462366119,
-0.0756862834,
-0.0006553676,
-0.0081859622,
0.00824966,
0.0211188793,
-0.0211908594,
-0.0573173836,
0.00142266,
-0.0151764704,
-0.0795174614,
-0.0441628173,
-0.0364331603,
0.0088238055,
0.0129981823,
-0.0515688471,
0.0075717033,
0.0215131659,
-0.0245193299,
-0.0601020306,
0.0180981606,
0.0355666839,
0.0359522216,
0.000714296,
-0.0272008032,
-0.0736813545,
-0.084256582,
0.0001296743,
0.0152416257,
0.0143742962,
-0.0132755321,
0.0376801267,
-0.0264136195,
-0.0690904781,
-0.0183341336,
0.0084875897,
-0.0039546569,
-0.028917022,
0.0035624488,
0.0034251362,
-0.0356209427,
-0.0102332048,
0.0327907689,
0.061541602,
0.0171902962,
0.0290156621,
0.0444754697,
0.0336098634,
0.0669084415,
-0.0367866643,
-0.0353425406,
0.0003520621,
0.0072359885,
0.0568294749,
-0.0566590652,
0.0066783181,
-0.0121098002,
3.128e-7,
-0.0278592296,
0.027186634,
0.0109012611,
-0.0550478585,
-0.0088392589,
0.0268459395,
0.0462801047,
0.0223464537,
-0.0143867517,
-0.0131006716,
0.0132884504,
0.0030482216,
-0.0162139591,
0.0179630797,
-0.1251247972,
-0.0321541205,
0.0069530201,
0.0208059605,
-0.0416900925,
0.0489186868,
0.0168067925,
0.0518879518,
0.031899903,
-0.0007165282,
-0.0183420144,
-0.0190538689,
0.0351450481,
0.0130797708,
0.0445239879,
0.0240923315,
0.0472279973,
0.0390530787,
-0.0119228251,
0.0284986738,
0.0225980002,
0.0189906769,
0.0358874425,
0.0650136247,
-0.0255432781,
-0.0116634984,
0.0046490091,
0.0059153596,
0.0224863011,
-0.0075457809,
0.0378891006,
-0.0362525135,
-0.0422557592,
0.0096623879,
-0.0253571402,
-0.0267906245,
0.0207816791,
0.0310124364,
-0.006801371,
-0.0137883788,
0.0065462887,
-0.0427606963,
-0.0338408202,
-0.0746526346,
0.0550331362,
0.0226953328,
0.0065734317,
-0.0276062507,
0.0026788185,
-0.0008881724,
0.0703064427,
-0.0514789745,
-0.0077245054,
2.90087302e-34,
0.0012088756,
-0.0020398251,
0.0029919129,
0.0051033194,
-0.0192760881,
-0.0524528809,
-0.0070512746,
-0.0137079274,
-0.0153894601,
-0.0623058453,
0.0166171174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08291v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08291v1 | Expanding the Vocabulary of BERT for Knowledge Base Construction | 2023-10-12T12:52:46 | 2023-10-12T12:52:46 | Dong Yang, Xu Wang, Remzi Celebi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T20 | Knowledge base construction entails acquiring structured information to
create a knowledge base of factual and relational data, facilitating question
answering, information retrieval, and semantic understanding. The challenge
called "Knowledge Base Construction from Pretrained Language Models" at
International Semantic Web Conference 2023 defines tasks focused on
constructing knowledge base using language model. Our focus was on Track 1 of
the challenge, where the parameters are constrained to a maximum of 1 billion,
and the inclusion of entity descriptions within the prompt is prohibited.
Although the masked language model offers sufficient flexibility to extend
its vocabulary, it is not inherently designed for multi-token prediction. To
address this, we present Vocabulary Expandable BERT for knowledge base
construction, which expand the language model's vocabulary while preserving
semantic embeddings for newly added words. We adopt task-specific
re-pre-training on masked language model to further enhance the language model.
Through experimentation, the results show the effectiveness of our
approaches. Our framework achieves F1 score of 0.323 on the hidden test set and
0.362 on the validation set, both data set is provided by the challenge.
Notably, our framework adopts a lightweight language model (BERT-base, 0.13
billion parameters) and surpasses the model using prompts directly on large
language model (Chatgpt-3, 175 billion parameters). Besides, Token-Recode
achieves comparable performances as Re-pretrain. This research advances
language understanding models by enabling the direct embedding of multi-token
entities, signifying a substantial step forward in link prediction task in
knowledge graph and metadata completion in data management. | [
0.0499737635,
0.0101844864,
-0.001955858,
0.0437354222,
0.0155172227,
-0.0041931528,
-0.0170490593,
0.0351124443,
0.0156350583,
-0.0542757921,
-0.0067776185,
-0.0044133896,
-0.0640918165,
0.0357051082,
0.0380492844,
-0.0422108397,
0.0455657765,
0.0184166562,
-0.0066520269,
-0.012727255,
0.0027413145,
0.0210902467,
0.0197401065,
0.0109996181,
-0.0517275892,
0.0127615975,
-0.022643622,
0.0108139757,
-0.0204779003,
-0.0495460555,
0.0176891722,
0.0544727445,
0.0567920506,
0.0281962119,
0.0000020656,
-0.0717945322,
-0.0226161573,
-0.0066831447,
-0.0594302304,
-0.0092941141,
-0.0210912619,
0.010411296,
0.0457538255,
0.0195391439,
-0.0282794684,
-0.0361456908,
0.0305240974,
0.0776594952,
0.0615242049,
0.0647729412,
-0.0049799704,
-0.0158089548,
0.0181294028,
-0.0186782461,
0.004996099,
-0.0196678266,
0.0312461574,
-0.0191397257,
-0.012250551,
0.0254617948,
0.0015088853,
-0.0027360015,
0.0066061923,
0.0239854045,
0.0525810495,
0.0415354297,
-0.039429985,
-0.0199516062,
0.0127334138,
0.0944458991,
-0.0173570253,
-0.0130487094,
-0.0094423564,
0.0288357474,
0.000501284,
0.0215710625,
-0.0076145451,
-0.0329285823,
0.0066941911,
-0.0044795,
-0.017966738,
-0.0142381787,
0.0536179729,
0.019762069,
-0.0485842004,
0.0582861416,
0.0341062248,
-0.0380622074,
-0.0162202343,
-0.01754242,
-0.0267611034,
-0.0714128315,
0.0013098479,
0.0303270686,
-0.0090775993,
0.0479305796,
-0.0397217982,
-0.0285535213,
0.0388113298,
-0.0355773605,
-0.029937651,
0.0252158754,
-0.028169319,
0.0695316643,
-0.0780129805,
0.0256660506,
-0.0062276232,
0.0116280764,
-0.0479967035,
-0.0490832739,
-0.0417648479,
-0.0066961837,
-0.0740381405,
0.069318369,
-0.0197694171,
-0.0195843149,
0.0040814155,
0.0295029171,
0.0074340086,
0.0355448164,
0.0189134236,
0.0027880629,
-0.0175880454,
-0.013818061,
-0.0399946347,
-0.0285802167,
-0.0621031299,
0.0026671335,
-0.0164067559,
-0.0437533967,
-0.0154653275,
-0.0211311933,
0.0067922673,
-0.047408279,
0.019533772,
0.0680576041,
0.0258756597,
-0.0427823588,
-0.0396567807,
-0.0220161378,
0.0140823182,
-0.018951213,
0.0217711888,
-0.0487012267,
0.0495753773,
-0.0148984492,
-0.0130650187,
-0.0159371365,
0.0337443724,
0.00748026,
-0.0228016023,
0.0996796936,
-0.0868935362,
-0.0260090269,
0.0203905664,
0.0205756966,
-0.0176053941,
0.0530672744,
0.0041810567,
0.019289447,
0.068355538,
0.0000968613,
-0.0320879109,
0.0239270907,
0.066046752,
0.0193016548,
0.0215682685,
0.0291638467,
0.0091858497,
0.027442053,
0.0059829061,
0.0445462503,
-0.0460289381,
-0.0065856432,
0.0103921453,
0.0347596072,
0.0011912719,
0.044246655,
0.0462644622,
0.0110515021,
0.0011333519,
-0.0281999912,
-0.0405735299,
-0.0110993031,
-0.0332703665,
0.020144539,
0.0040588281,
0.0066526416,
-0.0426193029,
-0.0011861301,
-0.0218646526,
-0.027361067,
0.0190837905,
-0.0097358497,
0.0518601499,
0.0053931158,
-0.0450009741,
0.1066964641,
0.0353291519,
-0.0452577993,
0.0360605083,
-0.0376983061,
0.0173729006,
0.0643487796,
0.0521110892,
-0.0732564926,
-0.0735602155,
-0.0112215206,
0.0197022595,
0.0319968201,
0.0276454166,
-0.0203447435,
-0.0026596503,
-0.0467609167,
-0.0389306769,
-0.0083764289,
0.0020532291,
0.0169341899,
0.0411050394,
0.0141992224,
0.0322929621,
-0.0902002603,
0.0381465033,
0.0448690578,
-0.019823337,
-0.005149079,
-0.0107979756,
0.0254434496,
0.0369738452,
0.03608777,
-0.0112944413,
0.0097810198,
0.0630298406,
-0.0396173224,
-0.0323385447,
-0.0147532616,
-0.0276045408,
-0.0565564223,
0.0572080612,
-0.0013234838,
0.0168767739,
0.0281182807,
-0.0314178802,
-0.0403730869,
-0.0112051191,
-0.0095748864,
0.1215716973,
-0.0586468503,
-0.0035628709,
0.0021514327,
0.0030334396,
-0.0240700431,
0.0774603188,
-0.0123677179,
0.0431098342,
-0.0024143693,
0.0012449195,
0.0511906072,
-0.0196924154,
-0.0590605848,
0.0037660038,
-0.0050390447,
-0.0034341055,
0.0378579199,
0.001024725,
-0.0724729821,
-0.0120003959,
-0.1302429438,
-0.0030806065,
-0.0063277055,
0.0194225553,
0.0054880823,
0.0267961286,
-0.0062127812,
-0.0111521725,
-0.0281324964,
-0.0367967896,
-0.0556262918,
0.0258719604,
0.0383233242,
0.011838546,
-0.038820982,
-0.0104341423,
-0.0166633353,
-0.0185147077,
0.0593850166,
-0.0142289279,
-0.0406414531,
-0.0050588436,
0.0045789387,
-0.0521820858,
0.032831151,
-0.0090710921,
-0.0120885903,
-0.0216545984,
-0.0301209874,
0.0574525893,
-0.0007948078,
0.0021593263,
0.0185250491,
0.0015764253,
0.0105570331,
-0.0585089996,
0.0212129876,
-0.0115595674,
0.0151399877,
-0.0017443355,
0.0022770998,
0.0089786602,
0.0334463418,
-0.0191331524,
-0.0331729576,
-0.0680656657,
-0.0259922873,
0.0018872041,
-0.0054862383,
-0.07172741,
-0.0041763354,
-0.0111549441,
0.0041067167,
-0.0313554741,
-0.0214517862,
0.0802511945,
-0.0406807922,
0.0203559529,
-0.021007482,
0.0227126367,
-0.0117625855,
0.0589347742,
0.0156021239,
0.0434291661,
0.0019609961,
-0.0316729583,
-0.0452599786,
0.0169143789,
-0.01520136,
-0.0404562466,
-0.020116305,
-0.0024368213,
0.0067109172,
0.0345272571,
-0.0005005532,
-0.0464446731,
-0.0325780138,
-0.0120863896,
0.0432635285,
0.0227719024,
-0.0084378216,
0.0053579109,
-0.0150633715,
0.0190634355,
0.0265773386,
0.0271654129,
0.0134632923,
-0.0205041133,
0.0354613513,
0.0525270738,
-0.0151455989,
0.0222732387,
-0.0168178584,
0.012033252,
0.0270451531,
0.0807272494,
-0.0368245654,
0.0041800225,
0.0112914629,
0.0173693225,
-0.0753864497,
-0.0439622067,
-0.002632176,
0.0162152853,
-0.0058338623,
0.0051626931,
0.1461328864,
0.0441412739,
0.0095828138,
0.0045090849,
-0.0093577933,
0.0197092276,
0.0329596773,
0.0187725369,
-0.0920835435,
-0.0169941001,
0.0090131992,
-0.0143232187,
0.0342622921,
-0.063524738,
0.0023567528,
-0.1087205261,
-0.0199554712,
-0.0357123874,
-0.0185839944,
-0.0217141099,
-0.069628261,
-0.009270194,
0.0151294135,
0.0000801971,
0.0078651728,
0.025197925,
0.0016165187,
0.0100601669,
-0.0091875102,
-0.0302905552,
0.06319049,
-0.075385198,
0.0444334224,
0.0290285815,
0.0411748923,
-0.0244560242,
-0.0232242551,
0.0144664617,
-0.0010105061,
-0.0238272063,
-0.0083287144,
0.0586507842,
-0.0363043509,
-0.0144690592,
0.0159120243,
0.0020744442,
-0.0420688428,
-0.016945228,
-0.0130732767,
0.0830884054,
0.0197405461,
0.0060140952,
0.0086860303,
-0.0355993211,
-0.0080180597,
0.0900538117,
0.0115082273,
-0.0308546517,
0.0243373234,
0.0075914832,
0.0188927464,
-0.0254533011,
0.0498872325,
0.0055111847,
-0.0602541044,
0.0158895049,
-0.0734987035,
-0.0458704904,
0.0717608184,
0.0367955565,
0.0072731422,
0.0092690242,
-0.0125800716,
-0.0019734518,
-0.0693235099,
0.0493977964,
-0.0075455545,
0.0179224405,
-0.0384775214,
-0.0379631035,
0.0126629081,
-0.0147538241,
-0.0365663692,
-0.0120755304,
-0.0262118522,
-0.0240156632,
-0.0028379108,
0.0454187281,
0.0124840951,
0.0488812439,
-0.0281504504,
-0.0078018401,
0.0650599673,
0.0051948009,
-0.0568080209,
-0.0214258879,
0.0329050198,
0.0108489785,
0.0230177604,
0.0427122042,
-0.0818195045,
-0.0208887178,
0.0090408977,
0.0445188209,
-0.0112152332,
-0.0281347968,
0.0252314582,
0.0649454966,
0.0510737486,
-0.0215876531,
0.0191319529,
-0.0561378486,
0.0221020691,
-0.0244957134,
-0.0378700681,
-0.026828805,
0.0159313269,
0.0026081884,
-0.0221594404,
-0.0066680373,
0.014498488,
-0.012061662,
0.0180448927,
-0.0095889913,
-0.0117483782,
-0.0097434353,
0.024339512,
0.0573438965,
-0.0087439278,
-0.0257685743,
-0.0340722278,
-0.0069547114,
-0.011292927,
-0.0565029979,
0.0192338508,
0.0151827894,
-0.0280131102,
-0.0368998609,
0.0279190522,
-0.0140290484,
-0.0229699463,
-0.056305632,
0.0359166935,
0.0373014919,
-0.0090074809,
-0.0088016437,
-0.0229580309,
-0.0309677869,
0.0005299062,
0.0074108737,
0.0031494491,
-0.0405937284,
0.0572375879,
0.0271184593,
-0.0354252085,
-0.0035643983,
0.0854447111,
0.0192747638,
0.0812929347,
0.0000725141,
0.0055713975,
-0.051445201,
0.021830136,
0.0569804981,
0.0690096617,
-0.0243658014,
0.0394390821,
-0.0290152188,
-0.0805743039,
0.0442849025,
-0.0134309009,
-0.0388001502,
0.0501445122,
0.0701026693,
0.0526250824,
-0.0027592969,
-0.0378818512,
-0.012262322,
0.0117089292,
0.0285480395,
-0.0284955427,
0.022987606,
-6.425493833e-33,
-0.0272578988,
0.0149396798,
0.0176981241,
-0.0264373776,
-0.0244743619,
0.0230683871,
-0.0286914371,
-0.0297121033,
-0.053332828,
0.024176579,
-0.0230157524,
0.0020717157,
0.0057480456,
0.0420713276,
-0.0411376171,
-0.02019112,
0.03507201,
0.0044146036,
0.0195693076,
0.0047493363,
0.038321536,
0.0686262697,
0.0652347654,
-0.0354701839,
0.0042649587,
-0.0211673342,
-0.016364852,
0.0488593727,
0.0415317118,
0.0553043522,
-0.0312488452,
0.0454743169,
0.0231027305,
-0.0394878983,
0.004305304,
-0.0066835405,
-0.1213359609,
-0.0576599091,
0.0162628256,
-0.0009416002,
-0.0350764766,
-0.0166917313,
0.0106098317,
-0.0307236295,
0.0516545698,
0.0291331615,
0.0376322009,
-0.017062936,
-0.0399397314,
-0.0372847803,
-0.0210036095,
0.0124907531,
0.0176169761,
-0.0103274602,
-0.011586939,
0.0102392305,
0.0285346061,
-0.0147263035,
-0.0678337961,
0.006088139,
0.016748514,
0.0037552267,
0.0250022039,
0.0113548897,
0.0269270092,
0.0697347745,
0.0023451212,
-0.0131478477,
-0.0236813873,
0.0270575378,
-0.0027398462,
0.0524092019,
0.0092710061,
0.0195612889,
-0.0130340997,
-0.0254928954,
-0.0568649732,
0.0137413004,
-0.0021922151,
0.0293605663,
-0.0102726407,
0.0037630196,
-0.0293121208,
-0.019966282,
-0.0616744719,
0.0205117222,
-0.0385794565,
-0.0286066122,
0.0257954635,
0.0174238756,
-0.0332228206,
-0.009270587,
-0.0065679546,
-0.0352911688,
0.0031102912,
0.0476436652,
0.0243388712,
-0.0420938395,
-0.0091160517,
0.041446209,
-0.0410416648,
-0.0364530273,
0.0413768589,
-0.0378042161,
-0.0278405957,
0.0058261855,
0.0367487185,
-0.0034578159,
-0.0603207313,
-0.0000663426,
-0.0452174433,
-0.0411654375,
0.0107551077,
-0.000850675,
0.0337837674,
0.0348391086,
-0.0040071169,
0.0095907673,
0.0794757083,
-0.0138092162,
-0.0208587758,
0.0157440249,
0.0245410763,
0.0250906069,
0.0008982364,
0.0011013112,
-0.0364695713,
0.006770202,
0.0404688008,
-0.0551315509,
-0.0071226875,
-0.0247347616,
2.843e-7,
0.0407882445,
0.0518958196,
0.0217094589,
-0.0033362638,
-0.0024319789,
0.0162399039,
0.0219201837,
0.0512432493,
-0.0266981442,
-0.0187785812,
0.0071098092,
0.0011125512,
-0.0225750841,
0.0284698308,
-0.1032935232,
-0.0181980971,
-0.0347227417,
-0.0348110124,
-0.0345760211,
0.0084086945,
0.0476250574,
0.110530667,
0.0347837321,
0.0079437569,
-0.0271746647,
-0.0490568765,
0.0442734472,
-0.0326628983,
-0.0111007988,
0.0275222789,
0.0314972885,
0.0713972896,
0.0079837684,
0.031006787,
-0.0544840395,
0.0330562852,
0.0271909982,
0.0386039354,
-0.0178605523,
0.0012074115,
0.0040131104,
-0.059404403,
-0.0131812664,
-0.0397612937,
0.0707973391,
-0.0067129424,
0.005363049,
0.0522369072,
-0.0612502061,
0.0125530027,
-0.0164020695,
-0.0421078652,
-0.0265302248,
0.0323235281,
0.0207554009,
0.0124932546,
0.0103150094,
-0.1086608618,
-0.0187922306,
0.0061127068,
-0.0624402948,
-0.0386687517,
-0.0096353702,
-0.0574519262,
0.0330459923,
-0.0808299482,
0.0315592326,
2.714564513e-34,
0.0017953415,
-0.0142828608,
0.0012199755,
0.0335287787,
0.0513070188,
-0.0564185642,
0.0022126276,
-0.0064169727,
0.0331318751,
-0.0596937798,
-0.013945464
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.