id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07093v1 | Argumentative Stance Prediction: An Exploratory Study on Multimodality and Few-Shot Learning | 2023-10-11T00:18:29 | 2023-10-11T00:18:29 | Arushi Sharma, Abhibha Gupta, Maneesh Bilalpur | cs.CL | cs.CL | To advance argumentative stance prediction as a multimodal problem, the First
Shared Task in Multimodal Argument Mining hosted stance prediction in crucial
social topics of gun control and abortion. Our exploratory study attempts to
evaluate the necessity of images for stance prediction in tweets and compare
out-of-the-box text-based large-language models (LLM) in few-shot settings
against fine-tuned unimodal and multimodal models. Our work suggests an
ensemble of fine-tuned text-based language models (0.817 F1-score) outperforms
both the multimodal (0.677 F1-score) and text-based few-shot prediction using a
recent state-of-the-art LLM (0.550 F1-score). In addition to the differences in
performance, our findings suggest that the multimodal models tend to perform
better when image content is summarized as natural language over their native
pixel structure and, using in-context examples improves few-shot performance of
LLMs. | [
0.0059736487,
0.0557951555,
0.0253862869,
0.0378266834,
-0.0329818279,
0.0257934779,
0.0516038612,
-0.0029530274,
-0.0189120732,
-0.0972667634,
-0.0001243725,
-0.062690191,
-0.0335750058,
-0.0258661658,
0.0182226673,
-0.0597306192,
0.0116186617,
0.0075682267,
0.0694325566,
-0.0057157888,
0.0533018969,
0.0364031494,
-0.0275604594,
0.0582875758,
-0.0159256179,
-0.0571332872,
-0.0071535693,
-0.0156496428,
0.0530764945,
-0.0372949578,
0.0153278438,
0.0529032983,
0.0426304266,
0.035634473,
0.0000018863,
-0.0232966002,
-0.0202284027,
-0.0221873075,
0.0282184072,
0.0035349138,
0.0474112444,
-0.0215316657,
0.0128683038,
0.0005499374,
-0.0372456051,
0.0077766352,
0.0468392223,
0.0560479052,
0.057628233,
0.0605870895,
-0.0194511022,
-0.0455392562,
0.0017997934,
-0.0128508704,
-0.0218977276,
-0.0097217085,
-0.0162641313,
0.0021792955,
-0.0412872545,
0.063167803,
-0.022646904,
-0.0011332746,
0.0071312021,
-0.0139950169,
-0.0505226664,
0.0244752839,
-0.0215113852,
-0.0416881293,
0.0041283472,
0.0582374521,
-0.0078379875,
-0.021496566,
0.0049510552,
-0.0406695455,
-0.0159383863,
0.0261641145,
-0.0780619904,
0.0514096282,
-0.0160448309,
0.0478691794,
-0.0130151445,
-0.0068599787,
0.0157174692,
0.0353471115,
0.0238546934,
-0.0094425734,
-0.0277553182,
0.001492392,
0.0259635877,
0.0334786698,
-0.0577357151,
-0.0498812348,
-0.0043840669,
0.0111808535,
-0.0007706587,
0.0250304844,
-0.0007437775,
-0.0070625381,
0.02800221,
-0.0675865561,
0.0421284772,
-0.0033648161,
-0.0123608345,
0.0817488059,
0.0062356326,
-0.0146009615,
-0.0131889721,
-0.0321726575,
0.0257868394,
0.0082350671,
-0.0667665526,
0.0006216507,
-0.0038442025,
0.0089302845,
-0.025484886,
-0.0480538793,
-0.0049383119,
-0.0167223085,
-0.0266483165,
-0.0074755182,
0.0034389773,
0.003624913,
0.0156045696,
-0.0244817082,
-0.0267389044,
0.076142326,
-0.0207169279,
0.0228901859,
0.0146366237,
-0.0045699379,
0.0108325165,
0.0265951976,
0.0187800564,
-0.003321968,
0.0007451464,
0.0272942223,
-0.0231755059,
-0.0038828102,
0.0059454809,
-0.0319261886,
-0.0515113138,
-0.0834042951,
0.0410623364,
-0.0803047791,
0.0342087373,
-0.0087082433,
0.0148206512,
-0.0526397191,
0.0042045633,
0.0443087108,
0.0188555606,
0.0783011913,
0.0439112447,
-0.0212271251,
0.0182203595,
0.0208494235,
0.0160401631,
0.1110326648,
-0.009557589,
0.0546935089,
0.0309119783,
-0.0036248367,
-0.025466742,
0.0209814422,
0.0012970517,
0.0037197899,
0.0249507483,
-0.0090777595,
-0.0563057028,
0.003031566,
-0.0022118683,
0.0427421406,
-0.0106119551,
-0.0430729352,
0.0829868093,
0.0496174544,
0.0032947492,
-0.0027487422,
0.0100075714,
0.0180053096,
0.0150551964,
-0.0302710049,
-0.0016082878,
0.0761754736,
-0.0089605348,
-0.0226427186,
0.0340625457,
0.0429940931,
-0.0252114031,
-0.028542636,
-0.0182742011,
-0.0093997736,
-0.0130022326,
-0.0161823202,
0.0281128976,
0.0004289663,
-0.0603696965,
0.0124634299,
0.0450504012,
-0.0328574069,
-0.0649013072,
-0.0013021522,
0.0357908383,
0.0130047388,
0.0004055064,
-0.0142412335,
-0.0307306182,
-0.0380200408,
0.0839335248,
0.0692711473,
0.0208480787,
-0.0116047757,
0.0014175762,
-0.0460181199,
-0.0445732549,
-0.0313178599,
0.0027231332,
0.0199135803,
-0.0088457912,
0.0214633178,
-0.0021545659,
0.0366659388,
0.0261572525,
0.0133886635,
0.0444678739,
0.0031058097,
0.0120193651,
0.0300039351,
0.0220131353,
0.046014104,
-0.0138065582,
-0.026213536,
0.008659604,
-0.0298515595,
-0.0384515934,
0.0040741968,
-0.0281127598,
-0.0627839044,
0.0384742394,
-0.0163847152,
-0.0065648919,
-0.0355277658,
-0.055104997,
0.0369211286,
0.0510770902,
-0.0079716435,
-0.0337551907,
-0.0436889157,
-0.0352883451,
-0.0074710133,
0.016644381,
-0.0286341794,
0.0441209711,
0.0032955525,
-0.0375343412,
-0.0066792872,
-0.0079929177,
0.0272485018,
-0.0140680065,
-0.0279772114,
0.0222107135,
0.0154790329,
0.0333934687,
0.0298404396,
-0.0306886453,
-0.0269204173,
-0.014053259,
-0.1186853349,
-0.0050717904,
-0.0112015996,
0.0056315577,
-0.0074809291,
-0.0420251377,
0.0246505085,
0.01162042,
-0.0020169963,
-0.0086258734,
-0.0088343052,
0.0319676511,
0.011602751,
-0.0163079388,
0.0502206348,
-0.0299148839,
-0.0054599326,
-0.019836003,
0.0606671236,
0.0040804544,
-0.0286231264,
0.0108187851,
0.0096056061,
-0.0409078263,
-0.0078078732,
-0.0189756677,
-0.0347629376,
0.0528529175,
-0.0174347572,
0.0317933001,
0.0555084869,
0.014287347,
0.0527199917,
-0.0036783009,
0.0105066337,
-0.0576738752,
-0.0048867343,
-0.0002055169,
0.0186512657,
0.0081471987,
0.0235687159,
-0.0000832961,
0.0995336175,
-0.0116331317,
0.0241517499,
-0.0611303039,
0.0776770264,
-0.0250322819,
-0.0146713546,
-0.0137176393,
0.0069363341,
0.0051929792,
-0.0032022363,
-0.0301130898,
-0.0201565158,
0.0592730083,
0.000639025,
0.0161644835,
-0.0056715198,
-0.0283357333,
-0.0125532718,
0.047833845,
0.0341200344,
0.0066868979,
0.0183805544,
0.0492534228,
-0.0091919191,
-0.0517342389,
0.0380733572,
-0.0216474682,
0.0283460487,
-0.0028487158,
0.0160559136,
0.0007121158,
-0.0593044311,
0.0283762366,
-0.0687798262,
-0.0761513859,
-0.0305082537,
-0.04850135,
-0.009466392,
0.0346605703,
0.0144336065,
0.0130349258,
-0.0352603868,
-0.000410514,
-0.0140990801,
0.0274028629,
0.0330110677,
0.0290250853,
-0.0278563537,
-0.0164985359,
-0.0434607491,
0.0569212362,
0.068579331,
-0.0171666984,
0.013810467,
-0.0739814639,
-0.0299021341,
-0.0159932803,
0.0237680152,
-0.0258749221,
-0.0211467464,
0.0864162073,
-0.0508260913,
0.0675627962,
0.0788786635,
0.0214469898,
-0.0222112369,
-0.032541085,
0.0397651419,
-0.0033128907,
0.0134639284,
-0.0318386853,
-0.0695244372,
-0.0578269213,
-0.0455577113,
-0.0113083562,
-0.0231752545,
-0.0254550837,
-0.0050075096,
-0.0997414365,
0.0239052512,
-0.013477793,
-0.0197847039,
0.0204433333,
-0.0518594347,
0.0115003306,
-0.0351526253,
-0.0180388335,
-0.0057154503,
0.00825362,
0.008738325,
0.0247404575,
-0.0559173115,
0.007905459,
0.0138553884,
-0.0518410988,
-0.0006241368,
0.0121235875,
0.0478857048,
-0.0142004769,
-0.0143042533,
0.029509075,
0.0244523045,
-0.0004338789,
-0.02374327,
0.0347875915,
-0.0274817906,
-0.0212600045,
-0.0266393162,
0.0379766002,
0.0172394048,
-0.0581882633,
-0.0260045733,
0.0569519252,
-0.0271661822,
-0.0266491491,
-0.0370690487,
0.0542328581,
0.016464293,
0.0208892394,
0.029655451,
-0.0621493533,
-0.0476264693,
-0.0359306596,
-0.0091211852,
-0.0941057727,
-0.0128722237,
-0.0301378667,
0.0008577828,
0.0427234434,
-0.0486651585,
-0.0210972577,
0.0085201543,
0.0495447405,
-0.0515236892,
0.0126995081,
0.0192542225,
0.036685586,
-0.026482122,
0.01899934,
0.0136036305,
0.0269223135,
0.0229487829,
0.0026975702,
0.0440359004,
0.0199235436,
-0.0266531464,
0.0098804729,
-0.0602890216,
-0.0469687022,
-0.0556867085,
0.0762961358,
0.0061048302,
0.0008414689,
0.0457018875,
-0.0578122884,
0.0380322821,
0.0854037255,
0.0466748402,
0.0005898627,
0.0257215481,
0.0328577086,
0.0018697599,
0.0175743159,
0.0128059965,
0.036258027,
0.025222905,
0.0042351326,
-0.0405031107,
0.0308989882,
-0.0223768316,
-0.0089236675,
0.0653642192,
-0.0049912757,
-0.0879842639,
-0.0080331387,
-0.018424347,
-0.0188727211,
-0.0227506962,
-0.0345348716,
0.0080199232,
-0.0011241182,
-0.0484782755,
-0.0339984186,
0.011015974,
0.0065132394,
0.0741161257,
-0.029127581,
0.0671309978,
0.0533963218,
-0.0066130641,
-0.0134387854,
0.0117844995,
-0.0133585306,
0.0057387049,
0.0142440526,
-0.0054090787,
-0.0087103657,
0.1008085236,
0.0057206722,
-0.0048922915,
0.0228260458,
0.016704401,
-0.00485721,
-0.0129569583,
-0.0466193296,
-0.0034600757,
0.0248073582,
-0.0317363925,
0.0220022313,
-0.0050918451,
-0.0339614637,
-0.023647882,
0.0348164998,
-0.0292307381,
-0.0270205494,
0.0694587603,
0.0227425527,
-0.0215033814,
0.0051355893,
0.0444866791,
-0.0333001465,
0.0212971717,
0.0606287718,
-0.0203479026,
-0.0306310095,
-0.0197940487,
-0.0031687205,
0.0161395129,
0.0242487174,
0.0110808704,
-0.0470380671,
-0.0208430011,
0.0087028649,
0.0026338063,
-0.0134348748,
0.039828822,
0.0074630133,
0.0495114885,
-0.0022762951,
0.0548327342,
-0.047214523,
0.002818448,
-0.0111488765,
-0.0115733184,
0.0003747718,
-6.185254379e-33,
-0.0069399672,
-0.0427800342,
0.0001176263,
-0.0076036318,
0.0301038083,
0.0022732196,
-0.0360991359,
0.0386194959,
-0.0096709728,
0.0669760108,
0.0267767292,
-0.0023447482,
-0.0011641727,
0.0287787542,
0.0003880544,
0.0190165006,
0.0020144405,
-0.0304191448,
-0.021716591,
0.012011678,
0.0391021147,
-0.0127062947,
0.0294165537,
-0.0502878651,
0.0016418905,
0.0255931094,
-0.0174698792,
-0.0239178073,
0.0336345136,
0.0886836573,
-0.020364821,
0.0312192813,
0.0492919236,
-0.0618043877,
-0.0097652497,
0.0715501383,
-0.0443374999,
-0.0194182172,
0.0056645861,
-0.0277077556,
-0.0246324744,
-0.0100109866,
0.0093078101,
0.0113209737,
-0.0405915901,
-0.0484560765,
0.0145208649,
-0.0012746034,
0.0129431412,
-0.0506706722,
-0.0486943498,
0.0301118661,
-0.0543652065,
-0.0311837513,
-0.0049844184,
0.0116014061,
0.030562222,
0.0877924934,
-0.0289744753,
0.010114708,
-0.0634095445,
-0.0071806731,
0.0284417588,
-0.0249438267,
0.0067783254,
0.0947510377,
-0.0004500138,
0.0150337173,
-0.0623878762,
0.0255514812,
0.0100623202,
0.0595599636,
0.064722456,
0.091777131,
0.0309080817,
-0.000701527,
-0.0847660005,
-0.0106890984,
0.0403439477,
0.0339517035,
0.0329647325,
0.0236239862,
0.0310078468,
-0.0111737689,
-0.0262101926,
-0.0733381212,
-0.0255075209,
-0.0288406685,
-0.025135465,
0.0189604573,
-0.000530204,
0.0539082848,
0.075184986,
-0.051002115,
-0.03012353,
0.0437589884,
-0.0336299539,
0.0493037552,
0.0112802926,
0.0236723013,
-0.0558322147,
0.0048475526,
0.0100584906,
0.0085714832,
0.0289228968,
-0.0193896908,
0.0667117536,
-0.0107455011,
-0.0779846758,
-0.024587173,
-0.0412280709,
0.0027696737,
-0.0335964113,
0.0663879141,
0.0185323264,
0.0171785578,
-0.0237572789,
0.0490120836,
-0.0105052227,
-0.0216333736,
0.0239197481,
-0.0527171679,
-0.039738778,
-0.0110580819,
-0.0239603538,
-0.0291694794,
0.0040303692,
-0.0230250135,
0.0095550176,
-0.0881897286,
-0.0017736001,
0.0361652002,
2.566e-7,
0.0466792695,
0.0768519118,
-0.0385959409,
-0.0517488383,
0.0488211922,
0.0522961318,
-0.0199890938,
0.0271894559,
0.0024226748,
-0.0559248403,
-0.0435361005,
0.052366104,
0.0433904342,
0.0418430306,
-0.0561829172,
-0.0008509839,
-0.0531038009,
-0.0124863693,
-0.0555563085,
0.0271646883,
-0.0008761549,
0.0945098549,
0.0066275825,
-0.0163842402,
0.0031726116,
-0.0004627345,
0.0858621672,
-0.0137189208,
-0.0368314385,
-0.0247457698,
0.0305893943,
-0.0651393607,
-0.0122231888,
-0.005616758,
-0.0164464228,
-0.0195000656,
0.016799463,
0.0679047853,
0.021133557,
-0.0247706659,
0.0025606747,
-0.0003909436,
-0.0186467599,
-0.0234851055,
0.0775304139,
-0.0785283223,
-0.0588867217,
-0.0796929598,
-0.0484839864,
-0.0144244684,
0.044700738,
0.0036026572,
-0.027919637,
0.0170855094,
0.0009728959,
-0.0111960936,
-0.0021043147,
-0.0878366753,
-0.029330356,
0.0371006094,
-0.0235197451,
-0.0276204664,
0.0228046812,
-0.0571313463,
0.0508229956,
-0.0562145449,
-0.017346587,
1.779617747e-34,
0.043257881,
-0.0329133049,
0.0203024335,
-0.0059261727,
0.0193426721,
0.0254149456,
-0.0212103743,
-0.0193686932,
0.0243505649,
-0.0511950701,
0.0139176808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07091v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07091v2 | Jaeger: A Concatenation-Based Multi-Transformer VQA Model | 2023-10-11T00:14:40 | 2023-10-19T04:03:08 | Jieting Long, Zewei Shi, Penghao Jiang, Yidong Gan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Document-based Visual Question Answering poses a challenging task between
linguistic sense disambiguation and fine-grained multimodal retrieval. Although
there has been encouraging progress in document-based question answering due to
the utilization of large language and open-world prior models\cite{1}, several
challenges persist, including prolonged response times, extended inference
durations, and imprecision in matching. In order to overcome these challenges,
we propose Jaegar, a concatenation-based multi-transformer VQA model. To derive
question features, we leverage the exceptional capabilities of RoBERTa
large\cite{2} and GPT2-xl\cite{3} as feature extractors. Subsequently, we
subject the outputs from both models to a concatenation process. This operation
allows the model to consider information from diverse sources concurrently,
strengthening its representational capability. By leveraging pre-trained models
for feature extraction, our approach has the potential to amplify the
performance of these models through concatenation. After concatenation, we
apply dimensionality reduction to the output features, reducing the model's
computational effectiveness and inference time. Empirical results demonstrate
that our proposed model achieves competitive performance on Task C of the
PDF-VQA Dataset. If the user adds any new data, they should make sure to style
it as per the instructions provided in previous sections. | [
0.0403661765,
0.0377373062,
0.0057998938,
0.0455217846,
0.0044921828,
0.0143013,
-0.0023848831,
-0.0140397027,
-0.0108709494,
-0.0627089068,
-0.0184445679,
0.0104443096,
-0.006233213,
0.0310209654,
0.0170864016,
-0.0720671862,
0.0471666418,
-0.0185747631,
-0.0233827103,
0.0022374452,
0.0293367747,
0.0282952487,
0.0096561546,
0.0623811036,
-0.0139701534,
-0.0298643727,
-0.0136722568,
0.0140373157,
0.0215020888,
0.0382023677,
-0.0093754521,
0.0271470603,
0.0449711122,
-0.0220306758,
0.000001913,
-0.0031218373,
-0.0259616524,
0.0142206829,
0.0226848312,
-0.0145582985,
0.0079574762,
-0.0533280894,
0.0433854423,
-0.0014362844,
-0.0471271314,
-0.0522750318,
0.0551357381,
0.0508189909,
0.0814062729,
0.0248591993,
-0.0236818232,
-0.0405287892,
0.040278282,
0.004950624,
0.0106585063,
-0.0757500902,
-0.0049253479,
0.0200266708,
0.0393030085,
-0.0028544276,
-0.0419260524,
0.0456101634,
0.0236778874,
0.0048314664,
-0.01005123,
0.0156090558,
-0.0088139763,
-0.0073961238,
-0.0187773742,
0.0913234055,
-0.004023273,
0.0083804233,
-0.0053793015,
0.0124863172,
0.0152211534,
0.0565567687,
-0.0535507947,
0.0102868965,
-0.0368751585,
-0.0358732045,
-0.0393879227,
0.0091972295,
-0.0129512167,
0.0063417647,
0.0045781885,
-0.0246632025,
0.014557139,
0.009397381,
-0.0191823915,
0.0325008444,
-0.0841215476,
-0.0275595654,
-0.0285154395,
0.0546214096,
0.026416352,
-0.0097082127,
-0.0364096873,
-0.0785771981,
0.0011561365,
-0.0292406771,
0.0021846597,
0.0146243852,
-0.0754838139,
0.0838580206,
-0.0324782357,
0.081140101,
-0.0462644398,
0.0022315425,
-0.0670983568,
-0.0592705794,
-0.0448951647,
-0.0298823714,
-0.0680625737,
0.031738922,
-0.0495915301,
-0.05966755,
-0.0066708298,
0.0251297615,
-0.0023450765,
-0.0294196643,
0.023643937,
0.0285515375,
-0.0229593087,
0.0067478544,
-0.0482874736,
0.0829234198,
-0.0250131097,
0.0147455651,
-0.0262509454,
-0.0286611803,
-0.0146139935,
0.0286057051,
0.0162572525,
-0.0680435598,
0.0087780897,
0.0657840148,
-0.053325247,
-0.0441291183,
-0.004152956,
-0.0337792188,
-0.0253982544,
-0.0325303674,
0.0419675261,
-0.0572816506,
0.054657612,
-0.00161258,
-0.0004117252,
-0.0263859332,
-0.0206435975,
0.0161321666,
-0.0252382495,
0.0888627842,
0.0062509254,
-0.0293485802,
0.0570697263,
0.0061270464,
0.0214151964,
0.0621641129,
0.0140548442,
0.0186525881,
0.0438989475,
-0.0079769185,
0.0228436347,
0.0377262868,
-0.0166277178,
-0.0192363989,
-0.0017030048,
0.0195860434,
0.0135958707,
0.0046311822,
0.0458544903,
0.0560544059,
-0.0607662871,
-0.0273572542,
0.0264506768,
0.0310799833,
0.0184597149,
0.0001001946,
0.0543499999,
0.0158387143,
0.0165134612,
0.0158393905,
-0.0071986066,
0.0727915689,
-0.0081148464,
0.0261464417,
0.0023460891,
0.059854418,
-0.0336358845,
-0.0327414572,
0.0117675466,
-0.0177070927,
0.0227649007,
0.0591951944,
0.0389152355,
0.0346212983,
-0.0564697348,
0.0260569137,
-0.0105138374,
-0.0257873237,
-0.0064069252,
-0.0382264294,
0.0467786938,
0.0494988039,
0.0257871989,
0.0098191397,
-0.0115986615,
0.0013573618,
0.0236775856,
-0.0037064687,
0.0142479921,
-0.0082961293,
0.0244741607,
-0.0612793192,
-0.0472506732,
-0.044148583,
-0.0320147052,
-0.0113640809,
0.0181530602,
-0.0037164218,
0.0228821021,
-0.0432079919,
0.0434151553,
0.0235874839,
0.0135264639,
-0.0243768264,
-0.0329340398,
0.025640741,
-0.0082423361,
-0.0068646264,
-0.00792972,
-0.003211604,
0.0222691484,
-0.0552438982,
-0.0006251416,
-0.0012847781,
-0.0012909985,
-0.046331685,
0.0134845916,
-0.0505646616,
0.0037481752,
0.0248601716,
-0.0606044866,
-0.0355681367,
-0.0237345118,
-0.0285225511,
-0.0144171147,
-0.0461806692,
-0.0094125466,
0.0579828955,
0.0226895846,
-0.0482082143,
0.0638229772,
-0.0171864759,
-0.0023387547,
-0.0155886542,
-0.0024189053,
0.0279865693,
-0.0263555273,
-0.0139693972,
0.0143622262,
0.0088966629,
0.0139136938,
0.0217109881,
-0.0055425749,
-0.0336257145,
-0.0374345072,
-0.086817123,
0.008721537,
-0.0065061003,
-0.0282090865,
0.0009062635,
0.029538529,
0.0141721088,
-0.0375729166,
-0.0342125557,
-0.0054728417,
0.0175365955,
0.0382696986,
0.0454563461,
0.0175754335,
0.0255066212,
-0.028173143,
-0.0421911962,
0.008728453,
0.0978943035,
0.005787224,
-0.0140380152,
-0.0090823676,
-0.047210522,
-0.0484302379,
0.038338352,
-0.0107862065,
-0.0154832583,
0.0013553251,
-0.0295970999,
0.0584277511,
0.0635262579,
0.0079315724,
0.0086084912,
0.0009601041,
-0.0118830772,
-0.0313553624,
0.0359047316,
-0.0204631407,
-0.0471896343,
0.0035657685,
-0.0116529735,
-0.0222135596,
0.018268479,
-0.0241408627,
-0.0056838612,
-0.0613862425,
0.043454688,
0.0393216982,
-0.0122883087,
-0.0498012155,
0.0119987,
0.0246440154,
0.0151796136,
-0.0506383888,
-0.0330340602,
0.0562853254,
-0.0203996617,
-0.0049927086,
-0.0141513776,
0.0182519704,
-0.0650930852,
0.0948113948,
0.0162159894,
0.0167648755,
-0.0062716873,
0.0048900037,
-0.0708364993,
0.0030772861,
0.024736112,
-0.0412595011,
0.0635494292,
-0.0369431935,
0.0368698426,
-0.026287511,
-0.0198101625,
-0.0146287829,
-0.0407894179,
-0.0403674096,
0.0093589826,
-0.025651738,
-0.0102421641,
-0.0131676178,
0.0407446697,
0.0387690328,
0.0215752907,
-0.0141881704,
-0.0026412043,
-0.0148958331,
0.0816496164,
0.1175991148,
0.0672485456,
-0.0143946055,
-0.0398512743,
0.007788511,
0.0653560758,
-0.003344985,
-0.0156096164,
-0.0209869314,
0.0119821094,
0.0193025097,
0.0046983096,
-0.0182266403,
-0.0016443942,
0.0428660475,
-0.0539062731,
0.0081814891,
0.0699240267,
0.0092182914,
-0.007094732,
-0.0290205702,
-0.0000602003,
0.0281243119,
0.0211346,
0.0465395227,
-0.1043621525,
-0.0572158508,
-0.0354459323,
-0.0026539653,
0.0375857912,
0.0221984405,
-0.0134403771,
-0.0758997425,
0.0552786589,
-0.0288330559,
-0.0090390854,
-0.0049005128,
0.0045525776,
-0.0077589033,
-0.0212742668,
-0.0053969235,
-0.0064901295,
-0.0204930417,
0.0154011166,
0.0041322024,
0.0524891354,
-0.0123823825,
0.0196099486,
-0.0250881203,
-0.0615452491,
0.0571157746,
0.0044620205,
-0.002264784,
-0.0724779293,
-0.015561033,
-0.0801040232,
0.001453369,
0.0192824937,
0.0668664277,
-0.0228065923,
-0.0309629515,
-0.0084572574,
0.0165644325,
0.0059293965,
-0.0251205768,
-0.0103299459,
0.0179188624,
-0.0000243031,
-0.0316478126,
-0.0353101902,
-0.0024564846,
-0.0448006652,
0.0455431156,
0.0160230715,
-0.0263341367,
-0.0605144463,
0.0067777317,
-0.0088050151,
-0.0204445068,
-0.0494413152,
-0.0132184606,
0.012983459,
-0.0064764083,
-0.0859812424,
-0.0149607817,
0.0439697988,
0.0441343188,
-0.0456648432,
-0.0022920333,
-0.0047082962,
0.0304816924,
-0.0667947009,
0.1043109372,
0.009503955,
0.0344572775,
-0.0469066463,
0.0180639047,
0.0302002728,
-0.0303016659,
-0.0457018577,
0.0212082025,
-0.0649472922,
0.0011797869,
-0.0240929443,
0.0832537934,
0.0126243178,
0.0072828848,
0.0001734528,
-0.0368826501,
-0.0013419547,
0.0135448398,
-0.0069220802,
0.0267406628,
-0.0093269777,
-0.0335981511,
-0.0247243922,
0.0069874069,
-0.0593228005,
0.0181246139,
-0.0300806779,
0.0126246596,
-0.0563279614,
-0.0307853185,
0.0262359455,
-0.0053237583,
0.0438364893,
0.0305254962,
0.0239517447,
-0.0130373752,
-0.0140573485,
0.0155355763,
-0.0212453958,
-0.0864850208,
0.0169737004,
0.0145197203,
0.0023951998,
0.0079953065,
0.0108170575,
0.0242106915,
0.0247139018,
-0.0467756726,
-0.0204462875,
0.0366036482,
-0.0143035166,
-0.0205597375,
-0.0007025201,
-0.0100991363,
-0.0275073461,
-0.0049359975,
0.0425906107,
-0.0201960634,
0.0574021861,
0.0262845978,
-0.0086043179,
-0.0170179904,
0.0275446046,
-0.0547959656,
-0.0626169071,
-0.0217646901,
0.0178196505,
0.0421181917,
0.0017517377,
0.0233781282,
0.036058601,
-0.0385508873,
-0.0142807579,
0.0015799672,
0.0153548168,
0.0034294701,
0.0828777403,
0.0341450237,
-0.0006832368,
-0.0231072847,
0.0826116726,
0.0118040387,
0.0242101438,
-0.0085972939,
0.004734423,
-0.0384778939,
-0.0487277247,
-0.0091744857,
0.0188041031,
0.0189525317,
0.0271270107,
-0.0128496243,
-0.0411151424,
0.0410141647,
-0.0081734871,
-0.0296819881,
0.0174203478,
0.065323256,
0.0410642251,
0.0344875082,
-0.0646700561,
-0.0449334383,
-0.0074091447,
-0.0134406462,
-0.0011825907,
0.0151308551,
-6.115135039e-33,
-0.0540759191,
-0.0275253523,
0.0446579158,
-0.0119048627,
-0.0315797962,
0.0139105488,
0.0040056696,
-0.0116706733,
-0.0527788252,
-0.0132193929,
0.0323766917,
0.0011801943,
0.0074263057,
0.0396326184,
-0.0157470144,
-0.010181698,
0.0412344709,
0.0046591763,
-0.0055704149,
0.0025959278,
0.0222372096,
0.0146784298,
0.0404537469,
-0.045847401,
-0.0242078342,
-0.011440305,
-0.0298643876,
-0.010602084,
0.0227802079,
0.1026784703,
-0.0196830351,
0.0055273189,
0.0118667204,
-0.0179447141,
-0.0069929063,
0.0265199896,
-0.1138817891,
-0.0053619752,
0.0435133092,
0.0191355869,
-0.0599892735,
-0.0341118015,
0.0432274118,
-0.0199587625,
0.0517946705,
-0.0498863831,
0.062246535,
-0.0089006806,
-0.0356101729,
-0.0510451309,
-0.0417428054,
0.0131860022,
-0.0170561988,
-0.0247074626,
-0.0041092178,
0.0789156929,
0.0098638451,
0.0395810045,
-0.0641017035,
-0.0122890659,
-0.0240157023,
0.0232982486,
0.0753009692,
0.0351906344,
0.0075958315,
0.0251734871,
0.0047096009,
-0.0399363153,
-0.0515105985,
-0.0200244542,
0.0047448771,
0.0586375557,
0.0559413657,
0.0566210411,
0.0266462229,
0.024096014,
-0.037376117,
0.032002721,
-0.0432242714,
0.0799249932,
-0.0157249607,
-0.0216599889,
0.0154941455,
0.0012801725,
-0.0354329795,
0.0445567369,
-0.04259298,
0.0035542711,
0.0360891372,
0.041084066,
-0.0003537213,
0.0521234199,
0.0615176596,
-0.0261201635,
0.030981848,
0.0536146685,
-0.0357575156,
0.072566621,
0.0137823457,
0.0319711864,
-0.0050516622,
0.0059986273,
0.0535522476,
-0.040192306,
-0.0121034449,
0.0529403985,
0.0298624374,
0.0014443978,
-0.0574472062,
-0.0124379005,
-0.0143618155,
0.0024867838,
-0.0542112775,
0.0051004323,
0.0096115908,
0.0349770151,
-0.0513876416,
0.0229012053,
-0.0171202086,
0.0135007519,
-0.0227305274,
-0.0473647192,
0.0279807057,
0.0278051216,
0.0032913976,
0.0169543158,
-0.0129095465,
-0.018099051,
-0.0062711872,
-0.0422378108,
-0.0143786138,
0.0616542958,
2.587e-7,
0.0788817108,
-0.0208282322,
0.0153963966,
0.003700447,
-0.0199153237,
0.0198998731,
0.0197757408,
0.0139316134,
0.0249139462,
-0.003945651,
-0.0213661436,
0.0647860393,
0.0284352321,
0.0018907248,
-0.0507343747,
0.0272441711,
-0.0268328153,
-0.0108416006,
-0.047664281,
-0.0113755446,
0.0804263651,
0.0820175186,
-0.0351088829,
-0.0062370463,
-0.0059722858,
-0.0596633926,
0.1095730662,
0.0092879944,
-0.0185797326,
-0.0099895727,
0.0500439666,
-0.0047929054,
-0.0019524518,
0.0106441686,
0.0019024534,
0.0099615287,
0.0705471709,
0.0582003519,
-0.0137821715,
-0.0553628951,
-0.0206290279,
0.0072134244,
-0.0017176757,
-0.0193181746,
0.1114575341,
-0.0452135019,
-0.014750924,
-0.028805146,
-0.0721402839,
0.0088617643,
0.0313452967,
0.0013557224,
-0.0287796669,
0.0338449515,
0.0591479167,
-0.0457375683,
-0.0100482339,
-0.0709091574,
0.0028939038,
0.0245423671,
-0.0372727364,
-0.0183133818,
-0.0358573087,
-0.0414042845,
0.0276694875,
0.0037224805,
-0.0512010753,
2.122839712e-34,
0.0357561372,
0.0028711038,
0.0272199064,
0.0328700878,
0.0292073563,
-0.0296868421,
-0.0293713957,
0.0000789992,
0.0131582106,
-0.0990140289,
-0.0018896902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07088v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07088v2 | Diversity of Thought Improves Reasoning Abilities of LLMs | 2023-10-11T00:01:41 | 2024-02-23T20:35:30 | Ranjita Naik, Varun Chandrasekaran, Mert Yuksekgonul, Hamid Palangi, Besmira Nushi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are documented to struggle in settings that
require complex reasoning. Nevertheless, instructing the model to break down
the problem into smaller reasoning steps, or ensembling various generations
through modifying decoding steps boosts performance. However, these methods
assume that the input prompt is fixed and expect the decoding strategies to
introduce the diversity needed for ensembling. In this work, we discuss how one
can create and leverage variations of the input prompt as a means of diversity
of thought. We propose a method that automatically improves prompt diversity by
soliciting feedback from the LLM to ideate approaches that are apt for the
problem. We then ensemble the diverse prompts in our method DIVSE (DIVerse
reasoning path Self-Ensemble) across multiple inference calls, or use diverse
approaches within a single inference call; we call the latter IDIV-SE (In-call
DIVerse reasoning path Self-Ensemble). Apart from our approaches outperforming
prior work, DIV-SE(in particular) advances state-of-the-art performance on the
challenging planning and graph coloring benchmarks. Our results improve the
Pareto frontier of the accuracy-cost trade-off. | [
0.0251732897,
0.0431027599,
-0.0009427641,
0.0410152189,
-0.0754402652,
-0.0050415969,
-0.0130819483,
-0.0192909259,
0.0038741585,
-0.028724473,
0.0028042181,
-0.0431362912,
0.0018305626,
0.0153487381,
-0.0080477912,
-0.0412938558,
0.0292180032,
-0.0922064707,
-0.0042491909,
-0.0456822626,
-0.0389422774,
0.0066261482,
-0.0231870804,
0.0490545072,
0.0113710957,
-0.0246642139,
-0.052347362,
0.0253020413,
0.0015001314,
-0.0224186108,
-0.0278739408,
0.0522975512,
0.0103332922,
0.0523999482,
0.0000022111,
-0.0613174215,
-0.0428947769,
-0.0245013051,
-0.0423513949,
-0.0217886399,
-0.0254829116,
0.0401955768,
0.009009812,
0.0307106879,
-0.0239565726,
0.037549343,
0.0397290289,
0.0188981537,
0.0659255087,
0.0575688705,
0.029973058,
-0.0109022465,
-0.0074259872,
0.0023252196,
0.0145499082,
-0.026969796,
0.0012421955,
0.0102470387,
0.056963712,
-0.0044038547,
-0.0359654427,
0.0258741248,
0.0480485298,
-0.0104415175,
-0.0179749746,
0.0229073558,
0.0236878265,
-0.0142068611,
-0.022562895,
0.0537380278,
-0.0270703919,
0.0088627888,
-0.0178830884,
-0.0160049833,
0.0019072145,
-0.0080783954,
-0.0373127311,
0.0516218431,
-0.0463190153,
0.029053783,
0.0010349748,
0.012447156,
0.0317749791,
0.0098598031,
-0.0560273714,
0.1338353008,
-0.0079882219,
-0.0150902653,
0.0154347252,
0.0175832119,
0.0078927726,
-0.0461414456,
-0.0051183691,
0.032993,
-0.0670278221,
0.0289126113,
-0.0029828441,
0.0072235521,
-0.0084494483,
0.0478665754,
0.083235614,
0.0593882576,
-0.0174653288,
0.0439630561,
0.012422909,
0.0054923953,
-0.0282628872,
0.0116374623,
-0.0603311323,
-0.0102525027,
-0.0528623275,
-0.0030578994,
-0.029045213,
0.0395457782,
-0.0374954455,
-0.0045601609,
-0.009679921,
0.0519213863,
-0.0075778486,
0.0169605892,
0.0489746258,
0.0010513187,
-0.0074165487,
-0.0647299662,
-0.0485282689,
0.023303315,
-0.0450085141,
-0.0051649925,
0.0384313464,
-0.0588486567,
-0.030292023,
0.0063285897,
-0.0218522251,
-0.0285171624,
-0.0026264486,
0.0539907292,
-0.0246977974,
-0.0062492662,
-0.0449181199,
-0.0501783006,
-0.017540317,
-0.0580246747,
0.0359530859,
-0.1035140678,
0.0194529146,
-0.0018665023,
-0.006828812,
-0.0435242131,
0.0057186629,
-0.0244363509,
-0.0118606789,
0.0731434003,
-0.0110288775,
0.0343090668,
0.0245459471,
0.0117094778,
-0.0434976965,
0.1190475002,
0.0260540787,
0.0170491915,
-0.002080455,
0.0281004459,
0.0199564323,
0.0522956215,
-0.0140422713,
-0.0089912098,
0.0122101167,
0.0077347062,
-0.0105172675,
0.0495035797,
0.0084730899,
0.0520356111,
-0.0265178662,
-0.0193501264,
0.0294479225,
0.0470783226,
0.0086149788,
-0.0288115647,
0.0509526879,
0.0071271663,
-0.0131765986,
0.0148256803,
-0.0380017683,
0.0505768172,
-0.0247276649,
0.0153668122,
0.0357352681,
0.0510351285,
-0.0096642654,
-0.0532426685,
-0.0362036414,
0.004839838,
0.0009149018,
0.0279640742,
0.0159978904,
-0.0122426972,
-0.0559201837,
0.0477653556,
0.0082060378,
-0.0274524,
-0.0440355875,
-0.0437038839,
0.0394427218,
0.0972880721,
0.0376583897,
-0.0074571958,
-0.0496501066,
-0.0000964768,
0.0148729226,
0.0314596631,
0.0295302477,
-0.0054571051,
0.0180875976,
-0.0755425245,
-0.0536751635,
-0.0138085186,
0.0011062667,
0.0676293448,
0.0409758538,
-0.0387243629,
-0.0238419138,
-0.0128889447,
0.011594845,
0.0107332142,
-0.0227668453,
-0.0046403012,
0.0051254858,
0.0075300904,
0.0287068021,
0.0184916444,
-0.0060988823,
0.0412141904,
-0.0033947241,
-0.0297534354,
-0.0368072949,
0.0015113404,
-0.0711682662,
-0.0654177368,
0.0316799879,
-0.0448903777,
-0.0278616678,
-0.0225084033,
-0.0390684828,
-0.0376307629,
0.0252592023,
-0.0473389439,
-0.0140159484,
-0.0115540568,
0.0242572483,
0.0163873937,
-0.0280745067,
-0.040592771,
0.0664793402,
-0.0523024388,
-0.0202351697,
0.0303459596,
0.027468197,
0.0171797834,
-0.072272256,
-0.0223873872,
0.0509588867,
0.0149192614,
0.0059738653,
-0.010535554,
0.0213480778,
-0.0569318533,
-0.0506695025,
-0.07705383,
-0.0107023101,
-0.0107094077,
-0.0006092236,
-0.0192306135,
0.0019266028,
-0.0067513678,
-0.0053489376,
-0.0223208573,
0.0078621991,
0.0140114967,
0.0338155665,
0.0097960737,
0.0013346683,
-0.0275336616,
0.0033254395,
-0.022868162,
-0.0124574136,
0.0314162113,
-0.0224215817,
-0.0390526317,
-0.054294847,
0.0048343278,
-0.0395639539,
0.0121404808,
-0.0134715103,
0.0020130656,
0.0483312532,
-0.0339961164,
0.0361110754,
0.0663458928,
-0.0071196784,
-0.0121811265,
0.0792368948,
-0.0434456952,
-0.0572439171,
0.043024648,
-0.0042379638,
0.0027107161,
-0.0196997616,
-0.0431443639,
-0.0036966964,
0.0615698658,
0.0002794412,
0.0039865053,
-0.081512548,
0.0133533143,
0.018145876,
-0.0509800576,
-0.0220837872,
-0.0235535856,
0.0118809072,
0.0647256672,
-0.0236955415,
-0.0433396548,
0.1002249867,
-0.0112639265,
0.0015792734,
-0.0212161466,
0.0129785948,
-0.0662415475,
0.0888429582,
-0.0341786705,
0.0020191623,
0.0227833632,
-0.001001337,
-0.0607288815,
-0.0058805724,
0.0222951528,
-0.0420812108,
0.0845998079,
-0.0899481401,
-0.0007569139,
-0.0008516728,
-0.0553819314,
-0.0590766259,
0.0164893735,
-0.0494304374,
0.0116272839,
0.022524884,
-0.0157115199,
-0.0284360703,
-0.0168430209,
0.0110789388,
0.0162762236,
-0.0211105049,
0.0092927292,
-0.0043447958,
-0.0021060375,
0.009423635,
0.0486776903,
0.0364005603,
-0.0411547385,
0.0711300001,
0.0367330723,
0.023758363,
-0.0226077214,
-0.0214125719,
0.0300082862,
0.0323600248,
0.0033823953,
-0.0189919174,
0.0290468931,
0.0817390829,
-0.046716366,
-0.0260228999,
0.102366358,
0.0358299986,
-0.0180385001,
-0.0008235879,
-0.0594591983,
0.0762417093,
0.0199417248,
0.0350063965,
-0.0518235043,
-0.0395438671,
0.0187047999,
0.0083029857,
-0.0172070451,
-0.0507460348,
-0.0275673997,
-0.1394210607,
0.0341065004,
0.0254368186,
0.0075286725,
0.013970905,
0.0082569709,
-0.0291104373,
0.0212907083,
0.0111411344,
0.0196431857,
0.0328972228,
0.0099294493,
0.0214141011,
-0.0353209637,
-0.0303492546,
0.003375463,
0.0025791563,
0.0406063348,
0.0526865758,
-0.0183759537,
0.0328325927,
-0.0495524183,
0.0362204649,
0.0200555231,
0.0305907596,
-0.0379391648,
0.0093867835,
0.0164944381,
0.0184482727,
0.0135847889,
0.0193552729,
-0.0292348228,
-0.0409375057,
0.0233798269,
0.0767324716,
-0.0586785711,
-0.0200118888,
-0.0126701789,
-0.0005512973,
0.0024186431,
0.0790980384,
0.0247011352,
-0.0100704562,
-0.0357872806,
-0.0947566107,
-0.0330895334,
-0.1090804562,
-0.004502343,
0.0299885403,
0.0195802338,
0.0087648761,
-0.0367085785,
-0.0081517287,
0.0535396114,
0.0434350483,
-0.0093421331,
0.001036221,
-0.025629811,
0.0121408086,
-0.0146738635,
0.0256847553,
-0.0252428167,
0.0188440476,
-0.033872433,
-0.029841952,
-0.0186360031,
-0.0255527254,
0.0090252021,
0.0201464277,
-0.0785199329,
-0.0783131197,
0.0030555362,
0.0437719375,
0.0291491114,
0.0595623478,
-0.0010084648,
-0.0516881235,
0.0527708568,
0.0390773304,
0.0573671088,
0.0124856932,
0.0192032252,
0.0549799614,
0.022080766,
0.0409284011,
-0.0439088829,
0.0061176363,
0.0388769582,
0.0728810802,
-0.0355546772,
-0.0187615603,
0.0309805423,
0.0197074823,
-0.0236229002,
-0.0310146511,
-0.0127026327,
-0.0070906891,
0.026921032,
-0.0023758307,
-0.0470918827,
-0.0511779822,
0.0215267539,
0.0193048473,
-0.0547760502,
0.041421771,
0.0188221894,
0.0186046865,
0.0220370274,
-0.0112738507,
0.0066492888,
0.0251846872,
-0.0017256095,
0.0361407623,
-0.0158681739,
-0.0131552201,
0.046074558,
-0.0253803972,
0.0212412216,
0.0426617637,
0.0689490139,
0.0261480622,
-0.014720236,
-0.0266768113,
0.0000765408,
-0.0806145594,
-0.1048343703,
0.0277790725,
0.0665597916,
0.0559141301,
0.042034369,
0.0059951851,
-0.0348966122,
0.0128148478,
0.0053180694,
0.0080976598,
0.042587705,
-0.0288817678,
0.0649674907,
0.0424887575,
0.0082222251,
-0.0582540333,
0.0365281925,
-0.0389475077,
0.0419413373,
-0.0066710571,
0.0193504412,
-0.0571423583,
-0.0567422658,
-0.0399001949,
0.0332326107,
-0.0078856964,
0.0207323432,
-0.05982925,
-0.0311691817,
0.0264474861,
0.0560489818,
0.0166053418,
0.0058757984,
0.0516285487,
0.0491832159,
-0.0003579152,
-0.0418662988,
0.0051154355,
-0.0042193565,
-0.0156952683,
-0.0272655282,
-0.0240467824,
-6.674853653e-33,
-0.02860884,
-0.0401673242,
0.0628991798,
-0.0633276924,
0.0008522194,
-0.0281619858,
-0.0332277082,
0.0266305096,
-0.0098860208,
-0.0043839035,
-0.0169932134,
-0.0037816006,
0.0101393871,
0.0332522281,
0.0216947459,
-0.0190516934,
0.0233030356,
0.0165506098,
-0.0560984388,
-0.030583838,
0.0198109895,
-0.0014895073,
0.0100116655,
0.007421419,
0.0013882185,
0.0159926508,
-0.0088396072,
0.0527976044,
-0.0346886925,
0.0548738167,
0.0060503492,
0.018126661,
0.0180817116,
-0.0304641891,
-0.0353372693,
0.0106106047,
-0.0060303728,
-0.0523038767,
0.0398420431,
0.000043213,
-0.0559624098,
-0.0518232547,
0.0097056739,
0.0146976896,
-0.0134031661,
-0.0369859971,
-0.0059097582,
-0.0212779157,
-0.0022399509,
0.0221549626,
-0.0074821915,
0.0319085196,
-0.0066694613,
-0.03871179,
0.0179077014,
0.0185447931,
0.0052582067,
0.0138854384,
-0.0071746754,
0.0317660458,
0.0230762735,
0.0131048495,
0.0860938504,
0.0355821177,
-0.0073141167,
0.0305932425,
0.0028432244,
0.0005276066,
-0.0917098224,
-0.0231921077,
-0.0211134013,
0.0644623712,
0.0320307799,
0.016919272,
-0.0091606807,
0.0444400348,
-0.0278964173,
0.0176898427,
0.0493895859,
0.00592762,
0.0395094976,
0.0302118827,
-0.0254479013,
-0.0267448202,
-0.0426557846,
-0.0187283885,
-0.0189047549,
-0.0092596291,
0.033383403,
-0.0110767828,
-0.0230969563,
-0.0182009153,
0.0455942452,
-0.0190991182,
-0.0221986044,
0.0223273672,
-0.0124670416,
0.0199739039,
-0.0022275369,
0.0540633723,
-0.0228456892,
-0.0078134658,
0.0398745164,
-0.0063220952,
-0.0023539031,
0.0186186992,
0.0005297697,
0.0171069726,
-0.0641954839,
-0.0180957653,
-0.0839366317,
0.0315939337,
-0.0069772741,
-0.0150903193,
0.0476254597,
-0.0010380256,
-0.0124466801,
0.0215353109,
0.0096427714,
-0.0306456983,
-0.016248513,
0.007949234,
-0.0315158479,
0.0130087277,
-0.0064561991,
0.0228170194,
0.0007313683,
-0.0398612954,
0.0069892784,
-0.0035573172,
-0.0146591794,
0.0538272597,
2.862e-7,
0.0218674876,
0.0269192737,
0.0203016382,
0.0332026407,
0.0120545207,
0.0237320364,
-0.0538105965,
-0.0294312891,
0.0017779805,
-0.0597548857,
-0.0008965739,
0.0832103118,
0.059653651,
0.0360915922,
-0.0811895505,
0.0102345683,
-0.0137771023,
0.0148609746,
-0.0570409931,
-0.0096233562,
0.0615967587,
0.0653511807,
0.0098334793,
-0.0075226668,
-0.004852829,
0.0023946404,
0.0368357114,
-0.0365222357,
0.0038040662,
0.0065190387,
0.0218661446,
-0.0465796553,
0.015620322,
0.0274525434,
0.0267971102,
0.0023437145,
-0.0304488409,
0.0449057221,
0.0016110765,
-0.0428433083,
-0.0130570289,
-0.0284636952,
-0.0050550732,
-0.0385819972,
0.067006208,
0.0071195923,
-0.0292464327,
-0.0432406478,
0.0369851105,
-0.0121732382,
0.0117267761,
-0.0150575256,
-0.0066632484,
0.0141979679,
0.012155531,
-0.0232876725,
0.022916859,
-0.0731179714,
-0.0268564671,
-0.0393030941,
-0.0478402749,
-0.0630933195,
-0.0441877209,
0.0429964662,
0.0195873715,
-0.0412254743,
-0.0285196714,
2.883425883e-34,
0.0383350402,
-0.0119576398,
0.0157419872,
0.0720553175,
0.0283562485,
-0.0226833802,
-0.0111597953,
0.0138161657,
0.0270018838,
-0.0687095746,
-0.0385974869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07081v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07081v2 | Crossing the Threshold: Idiomatic Machine Translation through Retrieval Augmentation and Loss Weighting | 2023-10-10T23:47:25 | 2023-10-20T19:24:14 | Emmy Liu, Aditi Chaudhary, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | Idioms are common in everyday language, but often pose a challenge to
translators because their meanings do not follow from the meanings of their
parts. Despite significant advances, machine translation systems still struggle
to translate idiomatic expressions. We provide a simple characterization of
idiomatic translation and related issues. This allows us to conduct a synthetic
experiment revealing a tipping point at which transformer-based machine
translation models correctly default to idiomatic translations. To expand
multilingual resources, we compile a dataset of ~4k natural sentences
containing idiomatic expressions in French, Finnish, and Japanese. To improve
translation of natural idioms, we introduce two straightforward yet effective
techniques: the strategic upweighting of training loss on potentially idiomatic
sentences, and using retrieval-augmented models. This not only improves the
accuracy of a strong pretrained MT model on idiomatic sentences by up to 13% in
absolute accuracy, but also holds potential benefits for non-idiomatic
sentences. | [
0.0469298325,
0.0631619245,
-0.0026925583,
0.0283344351,
-0.0171378274,
0.0027632297,
-0.0186474659,
0.0450292751,
0.0280735381,
-0.0164801907,
-0.0385200605,
-0.0152355777,
0.0025033506,
-0.0073074745,
0.0144192586,
-0.0454550907,
0.0205016658,
0.0297019202,
-0.0256751273,
-0.0021033923,
-0.0014914172,
0.0324163474,
0.016453024,
0.0323539414,
-0.033460889,
0.020490665,
0.0402841158,
0.0689807534,
0.0265369359,
-0.0231116377,
0.0431190319,
-0.0057915696,
0.0101141697,
0.0396110564,
0.000002269,
-0.0291950013,
-0.0268652067,
-0.0374851413,
0.0164831672,
0.0070891306,
0.048880145,
-0.0438416526,
-0.0191559419,
0.0034521397,
-0.040113125,
0.0296451412,
0.0559572168,
0.0467056781,
0.0140672969,
0.0739453733,
-0.0128178895,
-0.0520222485,
0.0011802678,
-0.0561926849,
0.0129440036,
-0.0775737688,
0.0010599334,
-0.023863757,
-0.1049296558,
0.0097909356,
-0.0302764364,
0.0583568886,
0.0257327985,
0.016259538,
0.006891429,
0.0285785645,
-0.0256469231,
-0.0016909802,
-0.0421070419,
0.0482518971,
-0.0072615002,
-0.0268092602,
-0.0375597961,
-0.0246728119,
0.0019556752,
-0.0548445471,
-0.0480690226,
-0.0093456609,
0.0100703845,
0.0191703495,
0.015478231,
0.0387681946,
0.00734432,
0.0306624509,
-0.0858151913,
-0.0165577438,
0.0205971934,
-0.0070951954,
0.017194489,
-0.0104992148,
-0.0432665534,
0.0274119433,
0.0286480896,
-0.0261217542,
0.0246751476,
0.0140720727,
0.0200671237,
-0.0380446948,
0.0143571636,
-0.0789654478,
0.0416487418,
0.0538604073,
-0.0034321335,
0.032102868,
-0.0103004891,
0.0355076902,
-0.0160650704,
0.0459595397,
-0.0706878752,
-0.0120175807,
-0.0562712513,
-0.0033805834,
-0.0567785501,
0.0139743583,
-0.0159267038,
0.0127982236,
-0.0318076611,
-0.0003690631,
-0.0092811473,
-0.0424968563,
0.0192452129,
0.0133127682,
-0.1095016003,
-0.0340623669,
-0.011113761,
0.0896921307,
0.0035487211,
0.0451425016,
-0.0121622421,
-0.0721939802,
-0.0201617014,
0.0106669525,
-0.0008022049,
-0.0674845725,
0.0386824086,
0.0604759157,
-0.0189582575,
-0.0891017243,
-0.0064660558,
0.007202453,
-0.0142390374,
-0.0226841141,
0.0144367078,
-0.0352825709,
0.0494286269,
-0.0144643085,
0.0439316481,
-0.0960640609,
0.0286773313,
0.0025942959,
-0.0375919901,
0.0450154245,
0.0335366726,
0.0036322239,
0.0097999573,
0.0006946205,
-0.0211606175,
0.0505627394,
0.0457508415,
0.0134869423,
0.0446143225,
-0.0065071648,
-0.0062725469,
0.0455407836,
0.0258856658,
0.0476370305,
-0.0426220559,
0.0113483267,
-0.0153488219,
0.0212347209,
0.0378688946,
0.0332723409,
-0.0094656469,
0.0577211045,
0.0662763789,
0.0127179651,
-0.016815111,
0.0180703569,
0.0074587064,
0.0455115587,
-0.031240508,
-0.0276656877,
-0.0057470156,
0.0066492041,
-0.032425303,
-0.0036097812,
0.0089917202,
0.0330056921,
-0.0119159883,
-0.0556833148,
0.0261289943,
-0.0233094282,
0.0572031066,
-0.0223840363,
0.0370049812,
0.0449039117,
-0.0389035195,
0.0906956941,
-0.0116869854,
-0.0699241683,
-0.0232966822,
-0.0272496603,
-0.0838444456,
0.0395841077,
0.0444176681,
0.005110865,
-0.0017042803,
-0.0064377743,
0.0543617718,
0.0132237868,
0.0247586425,
0.0353887491,
0.0447132029,
-0.0391340144,
-0.0104929125,
0.034221895,
0.0077402196,
0.0080395155,
0.0006245602,
0.0628716201,
0.0301721096,
-0.0331472643,
-0.0912283286,
0.0171417743,
-0.007428512,
-0.0583648086,
0.0517644472,
-0.003635936,
0.0166278947,
0.0008737172,
-0.0308164842,
0.0127477404,
0.0467365496,
-0.049713023,
-0.0389772616,
0.0704988614,
-0.0079702856,
-0.0345317833,
0.0212566331,
-0.0456395335,
-0.0376519598,
0.0000637443,
-0.0540623702,
-0.0132326074,
0.0050034048,
-0.0510678813,
0.021827938,
-0.0406328849,
0.0205881856,
-0.0146668069,
0.0319832861,
-0.0454201028,
0.0448597074,
-0.0136057818,
-0.0065030586,
-0.0503520593,
-0.0527783297,
0.0285908654,
-0.0172315631,
0.0071769222,
0.0117171835,
-0.0310558602,
0.0407430716,
0.0561545603,
0.0413992889,
-0.0233279392,
-0.0270936079,
-0.0853123739,
0.005651223,
0.00253461,
0.0244401656,
0.0067732623,
0.0688817054,
-0.0186119862,
-0.0229490176,
0.0252012946,
-0.0578084812,
0.0035245256,
0.0223333109,
0.0066893934,
-0.0023685195,
-0.0044232039,
-0.0057915179,
0.001382662,
-0.0068154284,
0.0179844555,
0.0188108813,
0.0016129639,
-0.0030444136,
0.022875566,
-0.0327529125,
-0.0355786197,
0.0055989763,
-0.0855919197,
-0.0103169493,
-0.0291928891,
0.0123370131,
0.0740500912,
0.0375011601,
0.0133105963,
0.0129392678,
-0.0206753816,
-0.0593789518,
-0.0025616426,
-0.0342668034,
-0.0802922323,
-0.0299199652,
-0.0574346371,
0.0265582819,
0.0338003077,
0.0197495185,
0.0111148665,
-0.0495615527,
0.0196725018,
0.003033011,
0.0059576849,
-0.0332602151,
0.0585192256,
-0.007615583,
0.036134921,
0.0029595667,
-0.0176887512,
0.063953273,
0.0079242075,
-0.0204800665,
-0.0727270842,
0.0074076238,
-0.010852132,
0.0621636063,
-0.0343002602,
0.0382606871,
0.0065194103,
-0.0102575272,
-0.0167823751,
0.0005563895,
0.0086085442,
-0.0532255433,
0.0153855933,
-0.0265461951,
-0.0082233278,
-0.0145332171,
-0.0301470701,
-0.0066026645,
-0.0341490023,
-0.00301366,
-0.0377714299,
0.0289955214,
0.0096932575,
-0.0187746715,
-0.0288815759,
0.0343435369,
0.0005386157,
0.0006265296,
-0.031563729,
-0.0056116632,
0.003384473,
-0.0035029505,
-0.0013158172,
-0.0285726488,
-0.0074136998,
0.0058219121,
0.0189948548,
0.0095816357,
-0.0302955173,
-0.0133161917,
-0.0219251942,
0.0451959074,
-0.0167517923,
-0.0076889298,
-0.0072837807,
0.0370105542,
-0.0286293998,
-0.0388247147,
0.0648495257,
0.0285929311,
-0.0245178845,
0.0145503953,
0.0034021772,
0.0394750163,
0.0210557692,
0.0243923236,
-0.0776925683,
-0.0466656722,
0.0094652409,
0.0097098025,
-0.0112722646,
0.0365558341,
-0.0133867841,
-0.0992811844,
0.0199703313,
0.0494780727,
-0.0351102725,
-0.0507190265,
-0.0011324203,
-0.0583613366,
-0.0468658991,
0.0045122127,
-0.003865727,
0.0059915823,
-0.0021584621,
-0.0140419155,
0.0086259777,
-0.0724696815,
-0.0085713249,
-0.0242342651,
-0.0219557267,
0.0423969664,
0.086437583,
-0.0293174163,
-0.0721816495,
0.0110922391,
-0.0254919827,
-0.0108579379,
-0.0065013086,
0.0104145315,
0.00948299,
-0.0103107644,
0.0320358016,
-0.003574633,
-0.0174614638,
0.0011574603,
0.0187358614,
0.0098386034,
-0.0316437967,
0.0354235806,
-0.0018504043,
-0.0397976115,
0.0237221047,
0.0539315976,
0.0084987609,
-0.0535570942,
0.0444451869,
-0.0179775655,
0.0273470599,
-0.0527481027,
-0.0338515081,
0.0002298713,
-0.0496722572,
0.0053642523,
-0.0913717225,
-0.0278262086,
-0.0243818648,
0.0431913324,
0.0040625692,
0.0006316963,
-0.0879663453,
0.0000067267,
-0.0635065809,
0.0666975155,
-0.0400403216,
0.0221944731,
-0.0503992476,
0.0040083611,
0.025975747,
-0.0309476797,
-0.0183469262,
0.0409746431,
0.0052590691,
-0.0719586164,
-0.0463947803,
0.0841851234,
0.0226619523,
0.0307510532,
-0.0131724896,
0.0133989295,
0.0220917836,
0.0583023839,
0.0066847294,
-0.0010498501,
0.0731375962,
-0.0196229238,
-0.0006211646,
0.040544156,
-0.0261369608,
0.0393162854,
-0.0241829902,
0.0878866389,
0.0024574716,
-0.0665719658,
0.0369246416,
0.0168057699,
0.0380868316,
-0.052639246,
-0.0619559586,
0.0132144671,
0.0485596135,
0.0162756406,
-0.0428150967,
-0.0159850474,
0.0093332604,
0.0678132772,
0.0096632158,
-0.0125356186,
0.0092913024,
-0.0278161112,
-0.0283128675,
0.0145837525,
-0.0420427956,
-0.0134297628,
-0.003198605,
0.0057180701,
0.0472305678,
-0.0095546292,
-0.0157955419,
0.0124227619,
0.0314751342,
-0.0024632276,
0.040106833,
0.0126750786,
-0.0085663497,
-0.0061164834,
0.034373153,
-0.0025979495,
-0.0182980374,
-0.0114734489,
-0.0217494797,
0.0548827425,
-0.0276889112,
0.0809361786,
-0.0178100821,
0.0063696592,
-0.0196725857,
0.0256304052,
0.0038550857,
-0.0687610283,
-0.0000759239,
-0.020926021,
-0.0112348534,
0.002871437,
0.0359709263,
-0.0613813512,
0.0216966737,
-0.0044868053,
-0.0117112994,
-0.0122946519,
0.0088298265,
0.0782889947,
0.0030209189,
0.0129056154,
-0.0103885988,
-0.0320209414,
-0.0436994955,
0.0418223143,
-0.003172762,
0.0110862469,
-0.0344477147,
0.0222073123,
0.0690127015,
0.0007419551,
0.0331535526,
-0.0578675717,
0.0125215882,
-0.0862333626,
-0.0026988448,
-0.0657806247,
-6.728512766e-33,
-0.0389330201,
-0.0027149282,
-0.0116559258,
0.0047766217,
-0.0145537201,
0.0095849819,
-0.0464264303,
-0.0083521949,
0.0027253982,
0.0163925048,
-0.0100201992,
0.0207486525,
0.0020641093,
0.0355712026,
0.0277050827,
0.0566810109,
0.0188691784,
0.0387629122,
-0.0424418747,
0.0073480532,
0.0649767295,
0.0298105069,
0.0928064957,
-0.0460915081,
0.0124846343,
-0.0010023343,
-0.0368136875,
0.0194902346,
0.0333734937,
0.0490224063,
0.016496446,
0.0674375221,
0.0056500756,
-0.0018146372,
0.0235095173,
-0.0263323188,
-0.0723173395,
0.0139951557,
-0.007845127,
0.0438002981,
0.0572285764,
-0.0539669767,
0.0754518732,
-0.0437019579,
-0.0239787977,
0.0312399976,
0.0201573577,
-0.0355625674,
-0.002202532,
-0.0241316725,
-0.0788505599,
-0.0080645503,
0.010407825,
-0.0472420417,
-0.0191510674,
0.0302572735,
0.0120324753,
-0.00002265,
-0.0678246021,
0.0270950831,
-0.0310757048,
0.0150270909,
0.0248495508,
-0.0287969355,
0.0013807931,
0.025258163,
-0.021633517,
-0.0427841805,
0.0482782833,
0.0071134972,
0.0617146082,
0.0192807652,
0.0586651638,
0.0371506028,
0.0482458957,
-0.0374237448,
-0.0211674813,
0.0562514178,
-0.0048214048,
0.0306883641,
0.0285362173,
0.0502699651,
-0.0496153757,
-0.0043492108,
-0.0132574691,
-0.0137681998,
-0.0048617804,
-0.0364237614,
0.0089545343,
0.0137432339,
-0.0346409157,
0.0314512029,
0.0693785176,
-0.0251747798,
-0.0456599668,
-0.0009770367,
-0.0355694517,
-0.0185632892,
-0.0175131019,
0.0287235901,
-0.018777404,
-0.039137423,
0.0130154798,
0.0254373401,
-0.0026941497,
-0.0067656818,
0.065979667,
0.0279179793,
-0.037836358,
0.0019046261,
-0.0275528505,
-0.034644179,
-0.041351106,
0.0089230333,
0.0191318076,
0.0486104339,
-0.0258883145,
-0.0093785217,
0.0521567315,
-0.0087748468,
-0.0671686083,
-0.0149426805,
-0.0029303529,
0.060639929,
-0.0449053347,
0.0221881643,
-0.01317761,
-0.0032060773,
0.0267714038,
-0.0388454758,
-0.0489629619,
-0.031503275,
3.08e-7,
0.0461054333,
0.0543236956,
0.0094740996,
-0.0172182955,
-0.0304475091,
0.0457357951,
-0.0234541465,
0.0352801792,
-0.0331876166,
0.0381565578,
0.0370332226,
0.0380322784,
0.0534073748,
0.0036318279,
-0.0647248551,
0.0088696266,
-0.0518441536,
0.0556310527,
-0.043401897,
-0.026909424,
0.0211612955,
0.1033050716,
-0.0092778318,
-0.0049601546,
0.0155668734,
-0.0717230365,
0.0955143645,
-0.0318173878,
0.0379012898,
-0.007198696,
0.065558508,
0.0610051192,
0.0044450243,
-0.0039191437,
-0.0190950725,
-0.0164657086,
0.0549533591,
0.0314068384,
-0.0388794839,
0.0088804243,
-0.0301603675,
-0.0161710121,
-0.0195996072,
-0.0251341946,
0.0265805051,
-0.0921741202,
-0.0223107263,
-0.0052765971,
-0.0349456668,
0.0475371853,
0.0571772866,
-0.0325128697,
-0.04323484,
0.016321918,
0.0477277972,
0.0269971974,
-0.0217256621,
-0.0548657775,
-0.0328923389,
-0.0078914547,
0.0280723814,
-0.0113558229,
-0.0230434258,
0.0272634104,
-0.0486595146,
-0.0339450799,
-0.008943947,
2.530660029e-34,
0.0410309806,
-0.0150284264,
0.0037039982,
0.0124632642,
0.0602641441,
-0.0142276175,
0.0329392441,
0.0282952525,
-0.0300269164,
-0.0160898473,
0.0190092903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07075v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07075v3 | Don't Fine-Tune, Decode: Syntax Error-Free Tool Use via Constrained Decoding | 2023-10-10T23:37:53 | 2024-06-04T15:50:22 | Kexun Zhang, Hongqiao Chen, Lei Li, William Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) excel at many tasks but often
fail to use external tools due to complicated and unfamiliar syntax
constraints. While extensive fine-tuning and prompting can mitigate the issue,
these approaches are expensive and hard to generalize. Furthermore, because
syntax constraints are only learned implicitly during fine-tuning, models still
make frequent syntax errors. Motivated by the fact that these constraints can
be better satisfied explicitly with constrained decoding, we propose TOOLDEC, a
decoding algorithm using finite state machines to force LLMs to follow tool
syntax. Our experiments show that TOOLDEC eliminates all syntax errors,
achieving significantly better performance on various base models and
benchmarks. More surprisingly, when applied to generalist out-of-the-box LLMs
such as Mistral-Instruct, TOOLDEC improves its accuracy in tool use from the
initial 0% to an impressive 52%, matching the performance of specialized
fine-tuned models such as ToolLLM. | [
-0.0142243709,
0.0720502362,
-0.0091115497,
0.0348002762,
0.0064097904,
0.0079060923,
-0.0574399754,
-0.0123833632,
-0.0002726409,
-0.0103655132,
-0.0313438512,
0.0193919521,
0.0048311208,
0.0079080556,
0.0281668007,
-0.0264001898,
0.0729169324,
-0.0498933271,
-0.0468180291,
0.0294585843,
-0.0133849466,
0.0135444244,
-0.0093300948,
0.0637921542,
0.0058867573,
-0.0283271205,
-0.0204097759,
0.0480237752,
-0.0065091928,
-0.0023256245,
0.0143220574,
0.0165646076,
0.0236080289,
0.0348329954,
0.0000021302,
-0.0450045206,
-0.0264319628,
-0.0051133796,
-0.0414218716,
0.0182575639,
-0.0030232759,
-0.0628691465,
-0.0326401815,
0.0482725427,
-0.0160043593,
-0.031513866,
0.0607723668,
-0.0299126171,
0.0740957707,
0.0951948836,
0.0040124431,
0.0140646575,
0.0160680935,
-0.0050338819,
-0.0420289226,
-0.0119979596,
0.0046085622,
0.0080809677,
0.0037948566,
-0.0126873348,
-0.0209816862,
0.0234884135,
0.0279324278,
0.000973804,
0.0012149879,
0.0166920591,
0.0233486574,
-0.0265602134,
-0.0313724354,
0.0349012874,
-0.0391811915,
-0.0214142241,
-0.0097263195,
-0.017388314,
-0.0285882819,
-0.0058774832,
-0.033666119,
0.0499003641,
-0.0328653529,
0.040747989,
0.0506222285,
-0.0336515792,
0.0324445553,
-0.0034436472,
0.0170399658,
0.0448460057,
0.0188015327,
-0.0163349081,
-0.0094796941,
0.0132724475,
-0.0008080144,
-0.0577162132,
0.0020083336,
0.0387591645,
-0.0639911443,
0.018950792,
-0.0785645843,
-0.0067450996,
0.0111970166,
-0.0311068632,
0.0468782671,
0.059778247,
-0.0066596176,
0.0408033282,
-0.0181228556,
0.0227467027,
-0.0006836792,
0.0127810519,
-0.0241124108,
0.0168189928,
-0.0474960431,
-0.0291301794,
-0.0277101342,
-0.0035549577,
-0.0388496816,
-0.0059879888,
0.0087526124,
0.0447635241,
0.0238179769,
0.0476892516,
0.0355145857,
-0.0468796715,
-0.0531605408,
-0.0211069919,
0.0193933155,
0.0133668873,
-0.0036275892,
0.006581306,
-0.0300479122,
-0.0545135997,
-0.0397459939,
0.0272315536,
-0.0316800661,
-0.0323978588,
-0.0154961692,
0.0853743926,
-0.0274909884,
0.0180527363,
-0.0185395628,
-0.0268295333,
0.0320460983,
-0.0068556061,
-0.0020972278,
-0.044428207,
0.0107827615,
0.0507716946,
0.0244670212,
-0.0722508132,
0.0065919608,
-0.009467449,
-0.0181499179,
0.018839905,
-0.0270130467,
-0.0115284398,
-0.0167210568,
0.000914957,
-0.0025843929,
0.0442185476,
0.0265444573,
0.0316528566,
-0.0397873074,
-0.0056414232,
0.0135700582,
0.0776333958,
-0.0291493814,
0.0103315264,
-0.0556852296,
-0.0193293337,
0.0335768759,
0.0060305442,
0.0709186271,
0.0637972131,
-0.0023062758,
0.0141276922,
0.0239834376,
-0.0216503385,
0.0114455475,
0.0514512509,
0.0485479124,
0.0340822004,
-0.0092280637,
-0.023482753,
-0.0681744143,
-0.0093774237,
-0.0355957597,
0.0251419898,
-0.0142546417,
0.0253751129,
0.0163249169,
-0.0360616855,
-0.0059808209,
-0.0040632295,
-0.0122571234,
0.0021369169,
0.0363647193,
0.0040917029,
-0.0654140189,
0.0604283325,
0.0014967649,
-0.0109162945,
-0.0264613982,
-0.0505071133,
0.0145154912,
0.0522174574,
0.0722638816,
-0.0060748043,
-0.0403835513,
-0.004111703,
-0.0010076623,
0.0122752292,
0.0303833708,
-0.0020253609,
0.0298788734,
-0.0378713682,
-0.0083816107,
-0.006269196,
0.0169786401,
0.0285818614,
0.0229886454,
-0.0340128988,
0.0007651493,
-0.0566814803,
-0.019585276,
0.0414514281,
0.0349623039,
-0.0640195236,
-0.0224272236,
-0.0054007308,
-0.0021026286,
-0.0298780296,
-0.0385623537,
0.0184527803,
0.0238627382,
-0.0254110135,
0.0122977421,
-0.0222796947,
-0.0563597307,
-0.0160866138,
0.024428308,
0.0155124683,
-0.0153071517,
0.0181685574,
-0.0374745987,
-0.0346225128,
0.0295761991,
-0.0286784545,
0.058861658,
0.0036205677,
0.022216104,
0.0159771238,
-0.0050504268,
-0.0612166263,
0.0399586856,
-0.0261105224,
-0.0237279963,
-0.0037216556,
0.0025986696,
-0.0325216241,
0.0120880436,
-0.0210423712,
0.0178333409,
0.0149107259,
0.048651848,
-0.0106717562,
0.0309359767,
0.0025728156,
-0.0378660969,
-0.0844093114,
0.0303521827,
-0.0245187897,
0.0178725328,
-0.0073617282,
0.0148099633,
-0.0097742863,
-0.0128558911,
0.017169917,
-0.0095375879,
-0.0311105512,
-0.004974266,
-0.0131649133,
0.0071802582,
-0.0689018518,
-0.0590162985,
-0.0316140503,
-0.0356601141,
0.0014101758,
-0.01661589,
-0.0227119196,
-0.0929398239,
0.1222616285,
0.0456979163,
0.0451851934,
0.0030064699,
-0.0325748995,
0.0145298522,
-0.0353940167,
0.0111768786,
0.0711926371,
-0.0721494257,
0.0145510053,
0.0754315108,
-0.0166465994,
-0.0753357038,
0.0119043672,
0.0343970209,
-0.0890304595,
-0.0479396842,
0.003820508,
0.0482872836,
0.0914549157,
0.0170448851,
0.0214083828,
-0.0239907075,
0.0243184343,
0.002160202,
-0.0244289972,
0.0140564991,
-0.0195813328,
-0.0057321712,
0.0140951602,
-0.0236169659,
-0.0591696091,
0.0610705577,
-0.0621590912,
-0.0145087531,
0.0204072595,
-0.0082607558,
-0.0213518515,
0.04227468,
0.0187426507,
-0.0084294071,
0.0143149886,
-0.045351468,
-0.0127129089,
0.0064758034,
0.0324812606,
-0.0015107082,
0.0184295755,
-0.0640600026,
0.0258018821,
-0.0287732128,
-0.0311597902,
-0.0232529771,
-0.0246004649,
-0.0385914184,
-0.0009125104,
0.0700349882,
-0.0269399136,
0.0151884919,
0.0036012807,
0.0097871944,
0.034266606,
0.0087900404,
-0.0283941925,
-0.0540732034,
-0.0152868051,
0.0008866196,
0.0102912821,
-0.005069436,
-0.0404202454,
0.0278559122,
0.0351135395,
0.0412677452,
0.0079141632,
-0.0733126923,
0.0149418712,
0.0683351085,
-0.0076520084,
-0.0372280553,
0.0506154895,
0.0862218291,
-0.0824851468,
-0.0179417245,
0.0864476264,
0.0332800448,
-0.0437341183,
0.0234363005,
-0.0175702106,
0.0537291802,
0.0346747711,
0.055377394,
-0.0805374533,
-0.049456086,
0.0513235107,
0.0426051356,
0.025168499,
-0.0067247339,
0.0052874419,
-0.0986991301,
0.0190211851,
0.0530294329,
0.0056967116,
-0.0101881931,
-0.0170791019,
-0.0151339192,
0.0021494241,
-0.0012981709,
0.0499369428,
-0.0106389793,
0.0000416762,
0.0448156595,
0.0021970284,
-0.0662817806,
0.0197677668,
-0.0154203866,
0.0635798052,
0.1068981513,
-0.0381188318,
0.0105534848,
-0.0003566697,
0.0900857374,
0.021040678,
0.0270673539,
-0.0429339781,
-0.0456304364,
-0.0002323367,
-0.0197901689,
0.0154401492,
0.0177641492,
-0.0363543406,
0.0030169687,
-0.0039476156,
0.0760614201,
-0.0283859186,
0.0294595435,
0.0025356659,
-0.0889900774,
-0.0026866647,
0.0206236765,
0.0365081057,
0.0098704742,
-0.0598114207,
-0.1016253233,
-0.0341158733,
-0.055461742,
0.0067826132,
0.0133136231,
-0.0011793374,
-0.0153433327,
-0.0389492102,
-0.0269905683,
0.0532355458,
-0.0030589532,
0.0226118732,
-0.0406107754,
0.0246985909,
-0.0025691586,
-0.0531385243,
0.016433144,
-0.047458902,
0.0313894711,
-0.0702964216,
-0.029787479,
0.0016623896,
0.0182217956,
-0.001431452,
0.0253048148,
-0.0569992997,
-0.0597411692,
0.0019417786,
0.0832930282,
0.0214500725,
0.0381241217,
-0.0472205728,
-0.0669737384,
-0.0580638051,
0.041997809,
-0.0233252011,
0.0200674403,
0.0406428166,
-0.0287297294,
0.0096586803,
0.0229634233,
-0.026367262,
-0.0216310825,
0.0227632709,
0.046763733,
-0.0377960019,
-0.0316316001,
0.0522629172,
0.0158426668,
0.0020679992,
0.0060734679,
0.0332604647,
0.0013704882,
0.0033789258,
-0.0048996476,
0.0059609218,
-0.0442261323,
0.0192709379,
0.014562076,
-0.0255269278,
0.034666039,
-0.0294288378,
0.0141310431,
0.0367620476,
-0.0265965648,
0.036643263,
-0.0071530389,
-0.0117086619,
0.0707951635,
0.027596619,
-0.034481585,
0.0584757403,
0.0136871124,
0.0516972579,
-0.0142054427,
0.0349474549,
0.0163632948,
0.0402983613,
-0.0504773296,
0.0022108653,
0.0215849262,
-0.1120122969,
-0.027281899,
-0.0263323337,
0.0847088471,
-0.005572442,
0.0597841479,
-0.0312180184,
0.0213217288,
-0.0330501348,
0.0345719345,
0.0010191657,
-0.0298813898,
0.0105330041,
0.0472574979,
-0.0170594342,
-0.0140944095,
0.064636685,
0.030320568,
0.0427643135,
-0.0024028656,
-0.0097078178,
-0.0539377965,
-0.0139630679,
0.0203073025,
-0.0278064962,
-0.0255767014,
-0.0020454759,
-0.0032107951,
-0.0601331182,
-0.0419339538,
0.0453417338,
0.0012950423,
-0.040849261,
0.0103724534,
0.0397485271,
-0.0053180088,
-0.0479319878,
-0.0354571603,
-0.0225720927,
0.0290203393,
-0.0384330153,
-0.0336649865,
-5.971271061e-33,
-0.042644579,
0.0283986516,
0.024630459,
-0.044791095,
0.0012726575,
-0.023142904,
-0.0725445002,
-0.0082728937,
0.033917062,
-0.0251911916,
-0.0127653535,
-0.0065582497,
0.0126263183,
0.0048549729,
0.053624779,
0.002312154,
0.0868034214,
0.0155370543,
-0.0512675866,
-0.013536999,
0.0027421047,
0.0226501357,
0.0473739915,
-0.0171830468,
-0.0166649036,
0.0148570128,
-0.0171920471,
0.0336854123,
0.0067991703,
0.0356405601,
-0.0089407871,
-0.0049504763,
-0.0165584497,
-0.0260057971,
-0.046158433,
-0.0181649644,
-0.0548297018,
-0.0122229699,
0.0280137938,
0.0253439322,
-0.0032229354,
-0.0540733449,
0.0346096568,
0.0194976088,
-0.024737075,
0.0089513604,
-0.0133982934,
-0.0177143738,
-0.0035410216,
-0.0211944152,
-0.0373233184,
0.0127286157,
-0.0084699076,
-0.0526298881,
0.0060702292,
-0.0099554434,
0.0058718026,
-0.009005364,
-0.0293974895,
-0.0017297863,
0.0486200526,
0.0843288153,
0.1036512479,
0.009546929,
-0.0149977189,
0.0130745713,
0.0246197619,
-0.0174160693,
-0.0025475658,
0.0512796044,
0.0349013805,
0.0294376537,
-0.0514510497,
-0.0257581733,
0.0062478702,
0.0118158571,
-0.016658688,
-0.0021739875,
0.006840717,
0.0966933966,
0.0125531964,
0.0752436221,
-0.0714628696,
-0.0369803421,
-0.0430568755,
0.0265016239,
-0.0178851224,
-0.004475045,
0.04504155,
0.007075584,
-0.019074427,
-0.0321658365,
0.038254559,
-0.0111293355,
0.0031393338,
0.0093852188,
-0.0126391351,
0.0448810607,
-0.0331307761,
0.0096604303,
-0.0146981347,
-0.041499339,
-0.0020133401,
-0.0668555573,
0.0670020208,
0.0095053976,
-0.0435981266,
0.0390420593,
-0.0604846776,
-0.01005405,
-0.0477758721,
0.0011896631,
-0.0211667009,
0.0412107445,
0.0537025183,
-0.0167182069,
-0.005869824,
0.023222534,
-0.0396202058,
-0.0383983515,
-0.0620620549,
0.0020111238,
-0.0024264071,
0.0095040686,
-0.0283487365,
-0.0159519129,
-0.0270407591,
-0.018829925,
0.0034386066,
-0.0473286882,
-0.0196339618,
0.0003466414,
2.823e-7,
0.0186857805,
0.0810908228,
0.0270050317,
0.0774050876,
0.0158065222,
0.0402880795,
-0.0298624653,
-0.0058353497,
-0.0025924696,
0.0045717158,
-0.0226877499,
0.054072164,
0.0421505533,
-0.0002962376,
-0.0533426218,
0.0370394699,
0.0154079562,
0.0488747545,
-0.06732779,
-0.0361378193,
0.0084713334,
0.0878900737,
-0.0058053914,
0.0021748601,
0.0113565177,
-0.0308824126,
-0.0075615859,
-0.0076864222,
-0.0249958709,
0.0136080412,
-0.0293526966,
0.0302539282,
-0.0223723575,
0.0126391165,
0.0188740324,
0.0010619696,
-0.029499596,
0.1017676294,
-0.0027927042,
0.0001642895,
0.0191374104,
-0.0031467304,
-0.0030713035,
-0.0179787595,
0.0180395897,
-0.0161025468,
0.0056589828,
-0.0086757941,
-0.0078624552,
0.0247110855,
-0.0592696629,
-0.0091674812,
0.009539119,
0.0148954056,
0.0221095402,
-0.0119698709,
-0.0247994121,
0.0051521696,
-0.0628032982,
0.0564206578,
-0.0435565747,
-0.0713475943,
-0.0301161278,
0.0500162654,
-0.0110863978,
-0.0109183155,
-0.0165614579,
3.001039833e-34,
0.0404037423,
-0.0079914881,
0.0645510852,
0.0835363865,
0.0533468276,
0.0115879448,
-0.0148708001,
0.0496796332,
0.0216805395,
-0.0785863027,
-0.0377376378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07064v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07064v2 | Large Language Models can Learn Rules | 2023-10-10T23:07:01 | 2024-04-24T19:01:59 | Zhaocheng Zhu, Yuan Xue, Xinyun Chen, Denny Zhou, Jian Tang, Dale Schuurmans, Hanjun Dai | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | When prompted with a few examples and intermediate steps, large language
models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance in various reasoning
tasks. However, prompting methods that rely on implicit knowledge in an LLM
often generate incorrect answers when the implicit knowledge is wrong or
inconsistent with the task. To tackle this problem, we present
Hypotheses-to-Theories (HtT), a framework that learns a rule library for
reasoning with LLMs. HtT contains two stages, an induction stage and a
deduction stage. In the induction stage, an LLM is first asked to generate and
verify rules over a set of training examples. Rules that appear and lead to
correct answers sufficiently often are collected to form a rule library. In the
deduction stage, the LLM is then prompted to employ the learned rule library to
perform reasoning to answer test questions. Experiments on relational
reasoning, numerical reasoning and concept learning problems show that HtT
improves existing prompting methods, with an absolute gain of 10-30% in
accuracy. The learned rules are also transferable to different models and to
different forms of the same problem. | [
0.0459111966,
0.0425242074,
-0.0085308542,
0.0334415399,
-0.0604437739,
0.0252695959,
0.0194547065,
0.0097652227,
0.0209066328,
-0.064601399,
0.0260994714,
-0.028884612,
-0.0314094126,
0.0194614064,
0.0192744881,
-0.0201221816,
0.0195259452,
-0.064397946,
0.0339203402,
-0.0004786226,
-0.0074957279,
0.0203875694,
-0.0111787422,
0.018842848,
-0.0287575256,
-0.0177149307,
-0.0200015809,
-0.0223090053,
-0.0228360891,
-0.0302932765,
-0.0145118833,
0.0496062934,
0.0343692116,
0.0457583703,
0.0000021631,
-0.0762404427,
-0.0110810278,
-0.0060855108,
-0.0446789116,
-0.0158540923,
0.0005483954,
-0.0024751658,
0.0189892165,
0.042968493,
-0.0512296222,
-0.0255471263,
0.0103274155,
0.0670127347,
0.0643026456,
0.0581856295,
0.0134320688,
-0.0353324823,
0.0096392287,
-0.0014613675,
0.0463109836,
-0.0240999386,
0.0578912832,
0.0512015782,
0.0294318851,
-0.0333844349,
0.0029118592,
0.0210877657,
0.0384004712,
-0.02745918,
-0.0187883973,
0.0415992774,
-0.0435107611,
0.0045055556,
-0.0028525996,
0.0737167746,
-0.0048820507,
-0.0349444374,
-0.0119377784,
0.0034153156,
-0.0114502115,
0.0581206568,
-0.020465713,
0.0548769459,
-0.0148353986,
-0.0243778452,
0.043870002,
-0.029576771,
0.0380568616,
0.0219258983,
-0.0510763973,
0.1041789725,
0.0006194668,
-0.0512935705,
0.0207389742,
0.0008048888,
-0.0068873763,
-0.0620306954,
-0.0156451594,
0.0706326663,
-0.0368793048,
0.0531728901,
0.0054109935,
0.0398864783,
0.0176609494,
-0.0489578061,
0.0196493939,
0.0376457609,
-0.0020274306,
0.0741294026,
-0.064190425,
-0.0011223273,
-0.0201756563,
0.0078137852,
-0.0638871938,
-0.0196581557,
-0.0578228422,
0.0106742242,
-0.0133475149,
0.0557389222,
0.0106692109,
-0.0165311266,
-0.0036205009,
0.047783602,
-0.0013574872,
0.0394697636,
-0.0159780681,
-0.0357266665,
0.0141594298,
-0.043428313,
-0.0692166686,
0.0061089518,
-0.0285996087,
0.0426425971,
0.0030187464,
-0.0379460491,
-0.00131243,
-0.0209108293,
-0.0010873162,
0.0110353846,
0.0323160887,
0.0525447913,
0.0108001549,
-0.0035113969,
-0.059128765,
-0.0366408862,
0.0196671374,
-0.0563561991,
-0.0223985128,
-0.0808884725,
0.0014344052,
0.0274049845,
-0.0092229908,
0.0034117429,
0.030850023,
0.0258991364,
-0.0221960656,
0.0960180312,
0.0061775371,
0.0150774065,
0.034344852,
0.0075745229,
-0.0684237853,
0.0484630875,
0.0004480721,
0.0127238818,
-0.0129333651,
0.0008963015,
0.0277155023,
0.0121983029,
0.0145639516,
-0.0114443004,
-0.0292034112,
0.0278048273,
0.0163098201,
0.0400371701,
-0.0386692621,
0.062473353,
-0.0292164031,
0.0276942458,
0.0258878842,
0.0505319089,
0.0307846908,
-0.0000437922,
0.0698629767,
-0.033042863,
0.0125256209,
-0.0173325967,
-0.0591230355,
0.008783401,
-0.0517324582,
-0.0017681556,
-0.0131646646,
-0.0017858186,
-0.025096532,
-0.0536446422,
-0.0298712123,
0.0163496006,
-0.0210176148,
0.0501858667,
0.069441177,
0.0078020133,
-0.0069270907,
0.0346043706,
0.0351074524,
-0.0099185742,
-0.0158979613,
-0.0720343292,
0.1100539193,
0.0814146623,
0.055630412,
-0.0343386456,
-0.0160042625,
-0.0364121348,
0.0453729667,
0.0181891508,
0.0437136218,
-0.0351768211,
-0.0217959546,
-0.0417933986,
-0.0118155675,
0.0180455856,
0.0033067761,
0.0170281958,
0.0266997851,
-0.0241186842,
0.0148634491,
-0.0079652006,
-0.0214090478,
0.0498341918,
-0.0170847364,
-0.0171595868,
0.0194433481,
0.0085110068,
0.0293429811,
-0.0055015148,
-0.0020072612,
0.0160072986,
0.0183362868,
-0.0334915109,
-0.0522860698,
-0.0185727682,
-0.0322753526,
-0.053063333,
0.0516953804,
-0.0013649625,
-0.014166438,
-0.0499950126,
-0.0367847905,
-0.0149241267,
-0.0079179844,
-0.0180375036,
0.0539216846,
-0.0441936851,
0.0089730704,
0.0252955537,
-0.0362156481,
-0.024032006,
0.0724123046,
0.0069049108,
-0.0051139537,
0.016223738,
-0.0070498898,
0.0098611787,
-0.0237396546,
0.0015786091,
0.0089890314,
-0.0069304225,
0.0078237318,
0.0172867794,
0.0254317243,
-0.0584810041,
-0.0181519855,
-0.0399180986,
0.0041186684,
0.0048778793,
-0.0061251265,
-0.0198381655,
-0.0146990623,
0.004624133,
-0.033558961,
-0.0471614115,
-0.0021991928,
-0.0002279781,
0.0144682471,
0.0466881916,
0.020257961,
-0.058849439,
-0.0104961535,
-0.0042891093,
-0.0431358255,
0.0540700592,
-0.0012077086,
0.0315366611,
-0.0572895892,
0.0244876705,
-0.0340378992,
0.0392607115,
0.0008107604,
0.0136987483,
0.0260007996,
-0.0550106838,
0.0156807024,
0.0907269642,
0.0076092281,
-0.0132134203,
0.084265314,
-0.0179917645,
-0.0717468709,
0.0161119439,
-0.0251606647,
-0.0105935792,
0.0011609551,
-0.0264612995,
-0.0173158552,
0.015110448,
-0.0235167313,
-0.0154403606,
-0.0619063079,
0.050301455,
-0.0060285665,
0.0023394914,
-0.0544214472,
-0.0248998795,
0.0216751751,
0.0535645448,
-0.0050771344,
-0.0434418619,
0.0944309086,
-0.0067238384,
0.0144453477,
-0.060352847,
0.0115444092,
-0.0503537804,
0.0607950352,
-0.0037800849,
0.0162173789,
0.0283166394,
-0.0021097867,
-0.032434091,
-0.0252907407,
0.0417811424,
-0.0425318852,
0.0628922656,
-0.0818491057,
0.028700335,
0.0191615969,
-0.0334614851,
-0.0919398442,
-0.0193451308,
-0.0400882326,
0.0006346067,
-0.0504467636,
0.0003043239,
-0.0094165737,
0.0064208903,
0.0161717143,
0.0163723696,
0.019760102,
-0.0372242928,
-0.001441872,
-0.0017994093,
0.0270372424,
0.0186097119,
0.011274552,
-0.0183292516,
0.068487443,
0.022598885,
0.0151756108,
-0.0009444873,
-0.0504151471,
0.0281620678,
-0.0003002785,
-0.0386237092,
0.0140349064,
0.0407705754,
-0.0126187252,
-0.0765000582,
0.0273716338,
0.1424659044,
0.0516727977,
-0.0071758665,
-0.0178158637,
-0.0453612059,
0.0008486588,
0.0258733146,
0.0586402006,
-0.1000073701,
-0.0287426356,
0.010614289,
-0.0122150388,
-0.004233445,
-0.0276953876,
-0.0041395645,
-0.1361678392,
0.0217803847,
0.0043152669,
-0.0068443269,
-0.0066183484,
-0.0352106579,
0.0045342534,
-0.013670614,
-0.0297777839,
0.0305527821,
-0.0126631279,
-0.0027966092,
0.0232034624,
0.0056685619,
-0.0314441323,
0.0522631593,
-0.0473251082,
0.0744810104,
0.0461586863,
0.0049508587,
0.0061845588,
-0.0434615538,
-0.0026863192,
0.0165361017,
-0.0011398525,
-0.0537366718,
0.011634456,
-0.0025373679,
0.0139552141,
-0.0137409503,
0.058768563,
-0.0297953561,
-0.0231096428,
0.050439246,
0.0902694985,
-0.0137973744,
-0.0535060465,
0.0018933123,
0.0193542819,
-0.0138857309,
0.0949732736,
0.0025050985,
0.0050260294,
-0.0036425914,
-0.040764641,
-0.0661827475,
0.0092132865,
-0.0113211107,
0.002194471,
0.0029409886,
0.0159085356,
-0.0551132411,
0.0089528048,
0.0598199032,
0.0447833426,
0.0343439206,
0.0089808423,
0.0043353313,
0.0274138451,
-0.0136260688,
0.0230571236,
-0.0367069468,
0.0164430123,
-0.0168255456,
0.0034698527,
0.0127154039,
-0.0314651765,
-0.0244343951,
-0.0056648883,
-0.0020166002,
-0.0630056038,
-0.0097755203,
0.0510758311,
0.0181169081,
0.0394546166,
-0.0190190636,
-0.01827332,
0.0362485945,
0.008238608,
-0.0448832102,
-0.0422355197,
0.0259532109,
-0.0119377021,
0.0137420911,
0.0395520553,
-0.043101348,
0.0363543071,
0.0118745053,
0.0495372638,
-0.0482860841,
-0.0220070723,
0.0678575858,
0.0410964601,
0.0067358268,
-0.0008029073,
-0.0442834646,
-0.0248035192,
0.0303425286,
-0.0138772661,
-0.046606373,
-0.0248352457,
0.0361682922,
0.0131490426,
-0.0058863079,
-0.0063301902,
-0.0693800077,
-0.0193054453,
0.0388422534,
0.0261526592,
0.003929242,
0.0496261977,
0.0455254726,
0.0531522632,
-0.0407004505,
-0.0039295889,
0.0198423695,
0.0156292897,
0.0406423658,
-0.0217446815,
0.0840892792,
0.0494218096,
-0.0015283579,
-0.0712473094,
-0.0166709367,
-0.0386799164,
-0.0700557679,
0.0119480873,
0.0542963073,
0.0348056853,
0.0098558692,
-0.0162708275,
-0.0753368214,
-0.0043304511,
0.0211137924,
0.017111253,
0.0158415642,
-0.0181092937,
0.0645708144,
0.0276234318,
-0.015044244,
-0.0045472388,
0.0246649515,
-0.0327059403,
0.0547994673,
0.0083944146,
-0.0153382532,
-0.0386036932,
0.0088981129,
0.01818881,
0.0049567386,
-0.0322013311,
0.044581864,
-0.0557958037,
-0.0603908412,
-0.0393189453,
0.031832993,
-0.0188485719,
0.0069874292,
0.0137444967,
0.0820832103,
0.0306214839,
-0.0607618578,
-0.0420960635,
0.0092615215,
-0.037723951,
-0.0301252324,
-0.0066165174,
-6.293419695e-33,
-0.0165919978,
-0.0155319059,
0.0615116842,
0.0096055856,
0.004704325,
-0.0129903322,
-0.0265821442,
-0.0094506443,
-0.020533964,
0.0202385299,
-0.0052840537,
-0.0032391178,
-0.0033695723,
-0.030602131,
0.0225229431,
-0.0158483479,
0.0196144283,
0.0126842037,
-0.0319903977,
0.0088938279,
0.0268076397,
0.0040754904,
0.0020274427,
-0.0280426666,
-0.0067043114,
0.0026905045,
-0.0019476353,
0.0718639642,
-0.0789876357,
0.031774573,
-0.0290344227,
-0.0036948516,
0.0078676548,
-0.0358072706,
0.019740127,
0.0276102927,
-0.0718515739,
-0.0287786871,
0.0469615422,
-0.0193798728,
-0.0105401548,
-0.0216919929,
0.0160256289,
-0.0002775326,
0.007534564,
0.0017130374,
0.0172248688,
-0.0348129347,
0.0006766967,
-0.0023234799,
-0.0583919249,
0.0297146551,
-0.0059737642,
-0.0537282489,
0.0063019828,
0.0233952757,
-0.0119405799,
-0.0386839733,
-0.0195116606,
0.0453732498,
0.0399766564,
0.0010140174,
0.0546997152,
0.010422593,
-0.0290285014,
0.035333585,
0.0024447639,
-0.0124044344,
-0.023010632,
-0.0063630431,
0.005766375,
0.0429326184,
0.0273539647,
-0.013143409,
0.0409236848,
0.0349935479,
-0.0801268443,
0.0096641863,
0.0537344143,
0.056240458,
0.0400924385,
-0.0118138725,
-0.06253203,
-0.0104487259,
-0.0691168532,
0.0435352214,
-0.0479423143,
-0.0491736531,
0.0351207219,
0.0040597133,
-0.0046783527,
-0.038556613,
0.0101251435,
-0.0513655022,
-0.0341087021,
0.0108857863,
-0.0075869542,
-0.0223850086,
-0.031967096,
0.0343112946,
-0.0716453344,
-0.0294525027,
0.0220349636,
-0.0219992846,
-0.0107801966,
0.0210937019,
0.0384013467,
0.0256566945,
-0.055559922,
-0.0252565686,
-0.0502098463,
-0.0176798701,
-0.0052964017,
-0.0010508905,
0.0049947347,
0.0617770627,
0.0090914341,
0.0067808717,
-0.0203267373,
-0.0450417362,
-0.0479363613,
0.0145190768,
0.0102572152,
-0.0047401898,
-0.0283445884,
0.0009511667,
-0.0350087546,
0.0053874282,
0.0234307013,
-0.0245747846,
-0.0122718774,
0.0363744572,
2.883e-7,
0.0197529197,
0.0639713407,
-0.0178423915,
0.0629374683,
-0.0249496438,
0.0313705467,
-0.0419134796,
-0.0277371388,
0.0468546376,
-0.005215406,
0.021796478,
0.0602724329,
0.0201731957,
0.0443287194,
-0.0776714012,
-0.0499894209,
-0.0097806398,
-0.0559419431,
-0.0625774488,
-0.0104393056,
0.0593826249,
0.0787005052,
0.0174000282,
-0.0244047437,
0.0171335749,
-0.0492611006,
0.0480039194,
-0.0143682398,
-0.0124163972,
0.0178954136,
0.0403018668,
-0.0124096218,
0.010584374,
0.0735994875,
0.0122072902,
0.0212823842,
-0.048931621,
0.0419816598,
-0.0031037689,
0.0195982642,
-0.037552733,
-0.015872756,
0.025162423,
-0.0482585654,
0.0729395151,
-0.0500911027,
-0.0211838391,
-0.0047502606,
0.0281113386,
-0.0532582067,
-0.0212834515,
-0.0152392425,
-0.005258752,
-0.0050841677,
0.0160642192,
-0.0255216155,
0.0035871665,
-0.0606630445,
-0.002744308,
0.0140411966,
-0.0091852127,
-0.0627579316,
-0.0124297338,
0.0093602873,
-0.0086359391,
-0.035100095,
0.0214780103,
2.810004093e-34,
0.0291479845,
-0.0133062834,
0.0030893176,
0.0669200271,
0.048554834,
0.0116343554,
-0.0142136598,
0.0081483303,
0.0538157523,
-0.1296720505,
-0.0001254758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07059v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07059v2 | DKEC: Domain Knowledge Enhanced Multi-Label Classification for Diagnosis Prediction | 2023-10-10T22:53:15 | 2024-06-19T20:58:52 | Xueren Ge, Satpathy Abhishek, Ronald Dean Williams, John A. Stankovic, Homa Alemzadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multi-label text classification (MLTC) tasks in the medical domain often face
the long-tail label distribution problem. Prior works have explored
hierarchical label structures to find relevant information for few-shot
classes, but mostly neglected to incorporate external knowledge from medical
guidelines. This paper presents DKEC, Domain Knowledge Enhanced Classification
for diagnosis prediction with two innovations: (1) automated construction of
heterogeneous knowledge graphs from external sources to capture semantic
relations among diverse medical entities, (2) incorporating the heterogeneous
knowledge graphs in few-shot classification using a label-wise attention
mechanism. We construct DKEC using three online medical knowledge sources and
evaluate it on a real-world Emergency Medical Services (EMS) dataset and a
public electronic health record (EHR) dataset. Results show that DKEC
outperforms the state-of-the-art label-wise attention networks and transformer
models of different sizes, particularly for the few-shot classes. More
importantly, it helps the smaller language models achieve comparable
performance to large language models. | [
0.021219464,
-0.0117420992,
-0.0012858711,
-0.0181445759,
0.0150831491,
0.0151330456,
0.0143268947,
0.0450418182,
0.0574060678,
-0.0458137691,
-0.0405492485,
-0.0257449653,
-0.0136985322,
0.0223889183,
0.014018625,
-0.0272429474,
0.0211969633,
0.0250207353,
0.0526017845,
0.0272915661,
-0.0003869374,
0.0176625494,
0.0068045789,
0.0438574255,
0.0120300157,
-0.0063914154,
0.0220302232,
0.0130479019,
0.0374818183,
-0.0671419203,
0.0273000412,
0.0169818942,
-0.0107829003,
-0.0328526534,
0.0000018883,
-0.0218753051,
-0.0288938433,
-0.00213428,
-0.0162761696,
-0.0446367152,
-0.0089947022,
-0.0602442473,
0.0493068583,
-0.0056109941,
0.0016683849,
-0.0628044009,
0.0150107658,
0.0793228522,
0.0376032591,
0.0655555204,
-0.0160310678,
-0.0267940052,
0.0362838134,
-0.0122816348,
0.0371840596,
-0.0793331936,
0.051206626,
-0.0144150285,
0.0424109474,
-0.0112296259,
-0.0076892781,
0.0443547443,
-0.0002029059,
0.026971221,
0.0556332543,
0.0651775822,
0.017345408,
-0.0161730908,
0.0118028764,
0.0847003683,
-0.0490200557,
-0.0225014202,
0.0117087457,
-0.0256127771,
0.0133090857,
0.0076750689,
-0.0022339949,
-0.0296352413,
-0.0553936027,
-0.015092779,
0.0100567043,
0.0217557084,
0.0296405945,
-0.0312437601,
0.018866932,
0.0197074655,
-0.0086560333,
-0.026084898,
0.0118797924,
-0.0128280222,
-0.0275082402,
-0.0367963649,
0.0349252932,
0.0429074876,
-0.0397953317,
0.0121149486,
-0.0314095132,
-0.0462481007,
0.0608316883,
-0.0497337505,
-0.0009047791,
-0.0124376649,
-0.0021263112,
0.0333044566,
-0.0124025503,
-0.0139161078,
-0.0326795802,
0.0411515124,
-0.0354912877,
-0.0129077286,
-0.0726820454,
-0.0020787695,
-0.0398622043,
0.0320108645,
0.0699390247,
0.010838002,
-0.0614565387,
-0.0158433057,
-0.0104020853,
-0.0131696984,
0.0433812514,
0.0296912976,
-0.0249518938,
0.002437321,
0.0004982839,
0.0485159606,
-0.0120529532,
0.0289454069,
-0.0211619381,
0.0235714167,
-0.0055978424,
0.0354020819,
0.0213187691,
-0.006348975,
0.0092058443,
0.0680347979,
0.0290452577,
-0.031761691,
-0.0249766037,
-0.0507241823,
-0.0705788508,
-0.0047073206,
0.0041338364,
-0.0262202546,
0.0183609333,
0.0243987236,
-0.0010757608,
-0.0381460302,
0.0174846444,
-0.0352587439,
-0.0748487711,
0.0398417003,
-0.0315874927,
-0.0030295942,
0.035039939,
0.0186031852,
-0.0038018599,
0.0133217387,
-0.0072278772,
-0.0467652716,
-0.0099320803,
-0.0031666404,
0.0326357223,
-0.000570073,
0.0572059378,
-0.0372981317,
0.0090529192,
0.0122305155,
0.0028927028,
0.0661817491,
-0.0111910412,
0.0024196543,
0.0282354392,
-0.0167568866,
0.0170886423,
-0.0136185987,
0.0412720926,
-0.024845995,
0.0320510454,
-0.0042700446,
-0.0686237216,
-0.033090245,
-0.0003114681,
0.0410643481,
0.0014020399,
0.0013155659,
0.0210335404,
0.0065454151,
-0.0375618078,
-0.0189995691,
-0.0377706178,
-0.0050420268,
-0.0615301728,
-0.019641323,
0.0626161247,
0.0001256148,
-0.0358183682,
0.1006146967,
0.0646409318,
0.0382489823,
-0.0168531276,
-0.035057202,
-0.0262063127,
0.0753563121,
0.0102502583,
-0.0509676971,
-0.0494086966,
-0.041846253,
0.0343579687,
-0.0288748201,
0.0074133375,
0.0046764817,
0.0151130976,
-0.0140878735,
0.0004907512,
0.0157764032,
0.023290541,
-0.0032221221,
-0.0269935634,
0.0397561863,
-0.0067054126,
-0.0596693791,
0.0099176941,
0.02500787,
-0.0104114925,
0.0048299115,
0.0159535613,
0.0214907452,
0.0293614548,
-0.0054490478,
-0.0029896917,
0.0070442823,
0.0161316991,
-0.0337902084,
-0.0740642548,
-0.0395558886,
-0.0239229985,
-0.0624936856,
0.0122124059,
-0.0172941908,
-0.0086991321,
-0.0465827845,
-0.0468766764,
-0.0231074728,
-0.0083654029,
-0.0321671106,
-0.0146907466,
0.0267031193,
-0.0203583967,
0.0476136543,
-0.0089817056,
-0.0305665117,
0.0452988073,
-0.0228553526,
0.0361825973,
-0.0296978261,
-0.0333494805,
0.0112357782,
0.020614583,
0.002893253,
-0.0262419432,
-0.0288095176,
0.009732144,
-0.0171608943,
-0.0058819046,
-0.0199093521,
-0.0054240264,
-0.0388865583,
0.0035737236,
0.0312269926,
-0.0148175163,
0.0099221375,
0.015491101,
0.0220020674,
-0.0254304204,
-0.0290289596,
0.0166242998,
0.0058548413,
0.0128649399,
0.0460273884,
0.0334989354,
0.0077067493,
0.0353968367,
-0.0152650075,
-0.0498289242,
0.0436590612,
0.0212417357,
-0.0480463319,
-0.0319374166,
-0.0154384952,
-0.0571137853,
-0.0108310916,
0.0141127557,
-0.022201838,
-0.0357528254,
-0.0137865087,
-0.0191439129,
0.0282779038,
-0.0068635228,
-0.0113257365,
0.0448338166,
0.0258665048,
-0.0225054063,
0.0332243964,
-0.0342480689,
-0.0125716217,
0.007105703,
-0.0006196109,
-0.0050571053,
0.1003486738,
0.0324156433,
-0.0173255298,
-0.0567337386,
-0.0232647695,
-0.0030874985,
0.0412218235,
-0.0687946603,
0.0252845548,
-0.0234058853,
-0.0330050364,
-0.0138322664,
-0.0099286772,
0.1026385874,
0.0297169555,
0.0287217107,
-0.0369455777,
-0.0287412237,
-0.0453595668,
0.0006351102,
-0.0004705679,
0.0435233749,
0.0703831464,
0.0048661483,
-0.0121944975,
0.0311154444,
0.0088660605,
-0.043371357,
0.0406366996,
0.0475199856,
0.0411171578,
0.0170728453,
-0.0336601473,
-0.0217860322,
-0.034218587,
-0.0212389603,
0.0003236298,
-0.0303161032,
0.0269573256,
-0.0616388433,
0.0407457091,
0.0192524754,
0.0607899167,
0.0258674528,
-0.0329598002,
0.0116173215,
0.0637116283,
0.0062633138,
-0.0369362198,
-0.0274106171,
-0.0278941318,
0.0084925583,
0.0426613763,
-0.0172005016,
0.0109842643,
0.0326643996,
-0.0225464012,
-0.0152789187,
-0.016258724,
-0.0202553775,
0.0212123301,
0.0030047353,
-0.0447758175,
0.0070573427,
0.0764621049,
0.016972458,
-0.0732442066,
0.0216127615,
-0.002470918,
-0.0149862254,
0.0107804853,
0.0179627147,
-0.059184894,
-0.0555689447,
-0.0225730184,
0.0153041072,
0.0118409507,
-0.045123335,
0.0256783906,
-0.0209980085,
0.0006970896,
-0.0134069175,
-0.0375455655,
-0.0238554329,
-0.0436656252,
-0.0017914405,
0.027781425,
-0.0413472615,
-0.0432399213,
0.0199423805,
-0.0172566939,
0.0018447774,
-0.0445976853,
-0.0753470957,
0.0694983155,
0.0040161829,
0.0496160947,
-0.0015056224,
0.0313696787,
-0.0398118049,
-0.0141735366,
0.0016904161,
0.0282723755,
0.0150215812,
-0.0027627223,
0.0818762928,
-0.0236025341,
-0.0015527421,
-0.0173157565,
-0.0077834767,
-0.0786485747,
-0.0336986966,
0.0074601094,
0.1192777678,
-0.0030044431,
-0.0782956854,
-0.0530728325,
-0.0114448955,
0.0430965535,
0.0396192186,
-0.021479398,
-0.0630602539,
0.0091973254,
0.018785784,
0.0167429037,
-0.00316532,
-0.0216862187,
0.0763565451,
-0.0460829996,
-0.0859256238,
-0.0227120146,
-0.0057196408,
0.0331424177,
-0.0501092002,
0.0007503561,
-0.0081271008,
0.014797478,
-0.0005900642,
-0.0574825108,
0.0352036953,
0.0117125586,
0.0182198323,
-0.0298641678,
0.0044437596,
0.0815817714,
-0.0052555045,
-0.0313588753,
0.0228141882,
-0.0230586175,
-0.0044324812,
-0.0150825884,
0.0292935409,
-0.0015626706,
-0.0031524647,
-0.0241041631,
-0.0205772426,
0.0427723527,
0.0554875396,
-0.0688666925,
-0.0239766501,
0.0017726474,
-0.0529126562,
-0.0004247086,
0.039863646,
-0.0405146293,
0.0622873753,
0.0180817172,
-0.0124411853,
-0.0202764217,
-0.0403027572,
-0.0131354509,
0.0053288466,
0.064475134,
-0.0335027426,
-0.0372875892,
-0.0216948781,
0.0430861712,
0.0440921821,
-0.0030060397,
-0.013281418,
-0.0113448594,
0.0440742783,
-0.0409075022,
-0.0076120389,
0.0076866322,
-0.0078058899,
-0.0439840965,
-0.0284579284,
0.0115115196,
0.0201952718,
0.0016340319,
0.0654753372,
-0.0162418801,
-0.0100590456,
0.0077029369,
0.0208851714,
0.008868604,
-0.0133391665,
0.0431094207,
0.0172789246,
0.0467039198,
0.0013770794,
-0.0099636661,
-0.0410240814,
0.0109497728,
-0.0231024437,
-0.0309231859,
0.0468225591,
0.0244707987,
0.0176890623,
0.0001523253,
0.0020567894,
-0.0253788736,
0.0480851158,
-0.0443331674,
-0.0169179719,
0.0448585562,
0.0016093514,
-0.0141848372,
0.0115570426,
0.0985140353,
0.0315350741,
0.0436480902,
0.0067977603,
-0.0440846197,
-0.0474030413,
0.0184166078,
-0.0159744024,
0.0409303345,
-0.0263711922,
0.0078972084,
-0.0733935758,
-0.0408901796,
0.0584541149,
-0.0764075294,
-0.0497367233,
0.0050682724,
0.0432608724,
0.0034324492,
0.0428040549,
-0.0249859467,
-0.0032801977,
0.0317321457,
-0.0425978266,
-0.0057002259,
0.0353484116,
-5.956565626e-33,
-0.0161617268,
-0.0566418879,
-0.0013011078,
-0.0573615767,
0.0322444476,
0.04562461,
-0.0332906879,
-0.0153360646,
-0.0158971194,
0.0359464809,
0.0099915052,
0.0310999807,
-0.0253336914,
0.027950583,
0.0415896364,
-0.0496450439,
0.0082112886,
0.0160668995,
-0.0206327606,
0.0685168058,
0.0222179294,
0.0604848973,
0.0711897463,
-0.0816282108,
-0.010706095,
-0.016887309,
0.0268464908,
-0.0008256429,
0.0061918176,
0.0797103569,
-0.0221005827,
0.068760626,
0.0700788572,
-0.0331860408,
0.0006823029,
0.0192740299,
-0.0545801371,
-0.0309385937,
-0.0332775302,
-0.0349903852,
0.0036419497,
-0.0400533304,
0.0401391238,
0.0184371248,
0.0689645186,
-0.0711905807,
0.0622175522,
-0.0085138837,
-0.0411280058,
-0.0721088946,
-0.0015704219,
0.0460130349,
-0.0159657244,
0.0038144509,
-0.0436678827,
0.0022808095,
-0.0032265063,
0.0649063811,
-0.0570784062,
-0.0158205125,
-0.0103336396,
0.0170513783,
-0.0003404152,
-0.0204446595,
-0.0504280962,
0.0577152595,
-0.0164788831,
0.0077919862,
-0.0565924942,
-0.0110952016,
-0.0585264973,
0.04355314,
0.023442544,
0.0288133919,
0.0142521085,
-0.0466531031,
-0.092290841,
0.0038236221,
-0.0742071941,
0.0303484816,
0.0436817296,
-0.0373854712,
-0.0293675773,
-0.0000794026,
0.0135078188,
0.0243932623,
-0.039500922,
0.0058347262,
0.0089984126,
0.0033713963,
0.0332998112,
0.0293019973,
0.004494783,
-0.033117488,
-0.0130212512,
0.0257025808,
0.0416068286,
0.0317653418,
-0.0169608984,
0.0241477415,
-0.0736051872,
0.0015143814,
0.0099999681,
-0.0007502023,
0.0244334843,
0.0242852103,
0.0743643567,
-0.0461659878,
-0.0441315025,
-0.0454274826,
0.0291971453,
-0.0413552783,
-0.0372080058,
0.0340492837,
0.0249036439,
0.0660415441,
-0.0040646978,
0.0796305016,
0.0375224464,
-0.0137483831,
0.0001822014,
-0.0115933847,
0.0094244797,
-0.0016999072,
-0.0426723883,
-0.0352458023,
-0.0271883048,
0.024810439,
0.040257331,
-0.0614033192,
-0.0110116368,
0.0031387846,
2.835e-7,
0.1248863935,
0.038287282,
-0.0410957076,
-0.0209949519,
0.0423446149,
0.0309673436,
0.0355378799,
0.047763072,
-0.0243063942,
-0.0340732448,
0.0329600163,
0.0033261578,
0.0081589809,
0.0462361984,
-0.0820602328,
-0.0350879021,
-0.0433980785,
-0.0005256426,
-0.0249281637,
-0.0244487803,
0.0815355554,
0.0811334476,
-0.0033237969,
-0.0164646599,
0.0111708082,
0.00270308,
0.042930562,
0.0072632502,
0.0307637639,
0.030813437,
0.0086264117,
0.0336158052,
-0.0221361592,
0.0825757161,
-0.0214442126,
-0.0016233082,
0.0029565126,
0.0852386206,
-0.0703046396,
0.0093137734,
-0.002046319,
-0.0028300919,
0.012177268,
-0.0272389427,
0.0700821057,
-0.1096569821,
-0.0233743191,
0.0289288126,
0.0026271401,
0.0105302511,
0.0338666774,
-0.0020794393,
-0.006918265,
0.0234750677,
-0.0049066301,
0.0005022898,
-0.0184802469,
-0.0940896794,
-0.0333914459,
0.0866331682,
-0.0014111355,
-0.0094025889,
0.0222929716,
-0.0486148894,
0.0716473088,
-0.0885657594,
0.0097043859,
2.261869011e-34,
0.0130839013,
-0.0011724303,
-0.0153260771,
-0.0067962292,
-0.0035915964,
-0.0654364005,
0.0077476911,
-0.0144274095,
0.0350967534,
-0.061504323,
0.0001656056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07023v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07023v2 | Automatic Macro Mining from Interaction Traces at Scale | 2023-10-10T21:23:47 | 2024-04-16T03:42:43 | Forrest Huang, Gang Li, Tao Li, Yang Li | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG | Macros are building block tasks of our everyday smartphone activity (e.g.,
"login", or "booking a flight"). Effectively extracting macros is important for
understanding mobile interaction and enabling task automation. These macros are
however difficult to extract at scale as they can be comprised of multiple
steps yet hidden within programmatic components of mobile apps. In this paper,
we introduce a novel approach based on Large Language Models (LLMs) to
automatically extract semantically meaningful macros from both random and
user-curated mobile interaction traces. The macros produced by our approach are
automatically tagged with natural language descriptions and are fully
executable. We conduct multiple studies to validate the quality of extracted
macros, including user evaluation, comparative analysis against human-curated
tasks, and automatic execution of these macros. These experiments and analyses
show the effectiveness of our approach and the usefulness of extracted macros
in various downstream applications. | [
0.0620068274,
-0.0007751664,
-0.0573818013,
0.0192789845,
-0.0090930779,
0.0045373691,
-0.0130153373,
0.0005705473,
0.0188229326,
-0.0478370078,
0.0079477243,
-0.025850486,
0.0336605981,
0.0236968677,
-0.0005090018,
-0.0256156772,
0.0075102365,
-0.0462581515,
-0.0705584437,
0.0871963426,
0.0047049797,
0.0048315707,
0.020916013,
0.0821294785,
-0.0076688165,
0.018768888,
-0.0074115787,
-0.0007936162,
0.0098940963,
-0.0205529612,
-0.0532986298,
0.0464187302,
0.0050842646,
-0.0095595252,
0.0000019506,
-0.0141210211,
0.0109850541,
-0.0069655376,
0.0157046691,
0.0370294824,
-0.0032609131,
0.0564462468,
-0.0376009606,
0.0346638709,
-0.0460463054,
0.0082149655,
0.0061299079,
-0.0101929829,
0.0308421049,
0.0146457097,
-0.0090514962,
0.0141640184,
-0.0121662105,
0.0163545161,
0.0433014594,
-0.0492150038,
0.0099452129,
-0.0075400402,
0.0150815351,
0.0238151643,
0.0681775436,
-0.0245981682,
0.0012591956,
-0.0288479943,
-0.0221343804,
0.0169590972,
-0.0067761107,
0.0016257459,
-0.0185755622,
0.0837750733,
-0.0579944253,
0.0137486551,
0.0693693236,
-0.006434863,
-0.0147432629,
0.0043625217,
-0.0409828201,
-0.0022464506,
-0.0202450734,
-0.0007866552,
-0.0252805986,
0.0161229186,
0.0400500447,
-0.00574246,
-0.0178259145,
-0.0225762967,
-0.0038031652,
-0.0112404907,
-0.0113237565,
-0.0212157927,
0.0081768027,
-0.0338296145,
0.049006775,
0.0147023685,
-0.0055228486,
0.0102226865,
-0.0069706049,
0.0202217847,
0.0162391905,
-0.0449194163,
0.0357643813,
0.0222531483,
-0.0047975816,
0.0444604792,
0.0057412693,
0.0292539354,
0.0081935311,
-0.0920610651,
-0.0137484455,
0.0250077974,
-0.0611209758,
0.0257857796,
0.007874581,
0.0289012808,
-0.0649574399,
-0.0128912376,
-0.0027637929,
0.0448502563,
-0.0031883472,
0.000635371,
-0.0384630077,
-0.0160464179,
0.020346541,
0.006806971,
0.0156197296,
-0.0708963796,
-0.0464118384,
0.0347629525,
-0.0099964309,
-0.0888909921,
-0.0017706048,
-0.024866933,
0.017506877,
-0.0044940952,
-0.0287479144,
0.0212004408,
0.0060529565,
-0.0269658212,
-0.064851217,
-0.0597615987,
0.0139826927,
-0.0043841191,
-0.0368751325,
-0.1019365937,
0.0257118326,
0.0034159906,
-0.0126220081,
0.0024179916,
0.0208273549,
0.0227988269,
-0.0285166726,
0.0445111357,
0.0119023817,
0.0337910354,
-0.0171129871,
0.0202392489,
0.0257891566,
0.0095107947,
0.0159718599,
0.0942527354,
0.0568785593,
-0.0285508521,
0.0518541001,
0.0761023983,
-0.0430766121,
-0.0233204421,
0.046076186,
-0.0012664197,
0.0209061187,
-0.0488377959,
0.0051813805,
0.0335026421,
-0.0072853509,
0.058375407,
0.0426150747,
0.1127218828,
-0.0322539061,
0.0144761791,
0.0489245653,
0.0136969239,
-0.0053742598,
-0.0209992509,
-0.0264337808,
-0.0531352796,
-0.0657058209,
-0.0443049446,
0.0268255398,
0.0270531271,
-0.006528025,
-0.0124080786,
0.0083993031,
-0.0350613222,
0.0258086827,
-0.0207200553,
0.029636981,
-0.0060246564,
0.0038980318,
0.0243504867,
0.0044761775,
-0.0402372442,
-0.0125620738,
-0.0592448786,
0.0091227749,
0.0759847686,
0.0371387154,
-0.0207419097,
0.0229704417,
0.0077251205,
0.0043392018,
-0.0298963822,
-0.0021425511,
-0.0290846545,
0.0354555771,
-0.0116297863,
-0.0256172009,
0.0135394214,
0.0359753594,
-0.0214031544,
0.0129065141,
-0.0024699175,
0.0415267386,
-0.0383350626,
-0.0485162102,
0.0232900586,
0.0510366149,
-0.0642772391,
0.0676591992,
0.039773345,
0.0010418922,
0.0480643064,
0.0039791707,
-0.002088937,
0.0382512435,
-0.0390017778,
0.0226034913,
0.01216699,
-0.0039103874,
0.02529254,
0.0152651733,
0.0250383392,
-0.0293674078,
-0.0320554897,
0.0013699403,
-0.0105930464,
-0.0101901898,
-0.0132836429,
0.0436148383,
0.0181570686,
0.0488729849,
0.0171426348,
-0.0176646244,
-0.0271097459,
0.0511906818,
-0.0016069027,
0.017142117,
0.0239747409,
0.0351563543,
0.0000670005,
0.0223293658,
0.0050159139,
-0.0022975381,
-0.0388910547,
0.0506956577,
0.050430052,
-0.0050134324,
-0.0059473142,
-0.0180497579,
-0.0790567249,
0.0407550037,
-0.0160752162,
0.0419499092,
0.0488513894,
0.0900598392,
-0.0002507067,
-0.0338154957,
0.0298848189,
-0.0316428803,
-0.0025780194,
0.0110490415,
0.0197040346,
0.0108618923,
-0.0268568452,
-0.0468068793,
0.0256580003,
-0.0178824905,
0.0351993442,
0.0058348565,
-0.0160587206,
-0.013000926,
-0.014190915,
0.0472913459,
-0.0070547136,
-0.0351417772,
-0.0629887134,
0.0081616789,
-0.0369912423,
0.0045412364,
0.0523800775,
-0.0182108171,
0.0459174588,
0.0218355078,
-0.028147785,
-0.0528309904,
-0.0332541354,
0.0058662412,
-0.0184495989,
-0.0252505727,
-0.0522358976,
0.0874200314,
0.0773879886,
0.0150716668,
0.0549166501,
0.0010121795,
-0.0296237059,
-0.0078641558,
0.0234939028,
-0.0092733447,
0.0297721997,
-0.0481652915,
0.0577971973,
-0.0209332071,
-0.0537019484,
0.0264319535,
-0.0120490389,
0.0215821601,
-0.0020254974,
-0.0590049438,
0.0122592757,
0.0941390693,
-0.0001818528,
0.0033233191,
0.0205989443,
-0.0577391535,
0.0464774109,
-0.0202573296,
0.0128358789,
-0.0409453511,
0.0418381542,
-0.0808165371,
-0.0054270276,
0.0294366609,
-0.0506960973,
-0.0109291859,
-0.040376734,
-0.0292355455,
-0.0229156185,
0.0259097889,
-0.0331721418,
-0.0071042515,
0.0284995753,
0.019991409,
0.0437070578,
0.0145685803,
-0.0270446204,
0.003915743,
0.0219237562,
0.011351658,
-0.0541934371,
-0.0847923309,
0.0312853605,
0.0144415321,
0.042721279,
0.0066243745,
0.0085373223,
-0.0325023569,
-0.020671064,
0.003421484,
-0.0208230112,
-0.0048488844,
0.1115377545,
0.0385947824,
-0.0551326089,
0.007957085,
0.0884198844,
0.0697648749,
-0.02934587,
0.0230042208,
0.0176003929,
-0.0319612809,
-0.0030549602,
-0.0007424212,
-0.070940122,
-0.07361494,
-0.0002513701,
0.0162791405,
0.0087662088,
-0.0171572808,
0.0240084268,
-0.0829089731,
-0.0302558765,
0.0188996084,
-0.0331925675,
-0.0298304223,
-0.0964977592,
0.0441671722,
-0.0214634649,
-0.0491697975,
-0.0194241144,
-0.0294868425,
0.0000581669,
-0.0166866984,
-0.0959398374,
-0.0859178603,
0.0534380861,
-0.0640141666,
0.0017661329,
0.108885929,
0.0206078291,
0.0090206526,
0.0167270638,
0.0316804312,
-0.0129939299,
0.0193859935,
-0.0162071977,
0.0247504283,
0.032014899,
0.0265709199,
-0.0237425175,
0.0746831372,
-0.0796195269,
-0.0348743498,
0.0568573214,
0.0753731951,
-0.0090385703,
-0.0035846895,
-0.0077773803,
-0.0512885079,
0.0741369352,
0.0408102497,
0.0196681563,
-0.0585769489,
-0.0178258233,
-0.0366814472,
-0.0128637739,
-0.0165363383,
-0.0462796278,
-0.0299920104,
0.0105046695,
-0.0375245772,
-0.0540183,
-0.0130487252,
0.047617048,
0.032587532,
0.0184802357,
0.0151796555,
0.0552610569,
0.0300992373,
-0.0235899612,
0.0435417444,
0.0137734776,
0.0593495853,
-0.0125706783,
0.0100018103,
0.0344040319,
0.0099853305,
-0.0000502854,
0.0062124864,
-0.0558968075,
-0.0615449585,
-0.0362794772,
0.0550563,
0.0102064954,
0.0172534641,
-0.0375398844,
-0.0109466985,
-0.0156550407,
0.057643652,
-0.0648777559,
-0.0454391725,
0.0075793378,
-0.0228021741,
-0.0191219933,
0.0022477866,
-0.0502754636,
-0.0099947611,
-0.031063186,
0.0227938071,
-0.116815649,
-0.0625447854,
0.0295444652,
-0.0215938184,
0.068065688,
0.0204295665,
-0.0068307067,
-0.0057384609,
-0.0130280964,
0.0353045464,
-0.0203734357,
-0.0294756684,
0.0283931065,
-0.0283132736,
-0.0069442391,
0.0181140658,
-0.0088676605,
-0.0486294255,
0.0017842653,
-0.0099693369,
0.0191245545,
-0.0078918384,
0.0547205023,
0.032059215,
-0.0055596512,
-0.0235585514,
0.0083919885,
0.0148187764,
0.0512293838,
-0.0396363065,
-0.0001588975,
-0.031810496,
0.0016877609,
0.0286570396,
0.0596925244,
-0.0139043601,
0.0133618368,
0.0251414664,
-0.0249735303,
0.0517436527,
-0.0348344035,
0.0283651892,
-0.0365930498,
-0.0067114509,
-0.0327035263,
0.0304666441,
-0.0404502861,
0.0101366602,
-0.0222413689,
0.007979854,
-0.0358957052,
-0.0198267214,
0.0667363778,
-0.0743730068,
0.0057947175,
0.0303663183,
-0.0770550072,
-0.0433670655,
-0.0083741788,
0.0110813752,
0.0759634078,
-0.0609292686,
-0.0246226676,
-0.0380806699,
-0.0185594931,
-0.0529569797,
0.0037358124,
-0.0026970841,
-0.0242306646,
0.0290920548,
0.0756541416,
0.0209230762,
0.0288285092,
-0.0562748164,
-0.0123692397,
-0.034617994,
0.0344300978,
-0.0724284127,
-5.253630657e-33,
-0.0077760345,
-0.0499085113,
-0.0179137718,
0.0320253,
-0.0134837301,
0.0048269015,
-0.0459273234,
0.0254263822,
0.0241437722,
-0.0325703062,
-0.0219757594,
-0.0202701688,
0.0064669354,
-0.021663351,
0.0219589751,
0.0778357312,
0.0670372993,
0.0219384264,
-0.0491266437,
0.0310393833,
0.0187758859,
-0.0128472066,
-0.022384977,
-0.0973611847,
0.0005495689,
-0.021279959,
0.0086687049,
-0.0084396061,
0.0587006211,
0.0514645018,
-0.0330918655,
-0.0124671357,
0.0231456682,
-0.0023619076,
-0.0057640313,
0.0429129973,
-0.0378036834,
-0.0251702536,
0.0430930629,
0.0291887708,
0.0117613813,
-0.0326363817,
0.011267283,
-0.0090427799,
-0.0251237173,
0.0679707006,
0.0378329568,
-0.0272573754,
-0.0420655683,
-0.0137335127,
-0.0304032639,
0.0241257213,
-0.008646003,
-0.0227228813,
-0.0162495319,
-0.0203977339,
-0.0196298566,
-0.0141623858,
-0.0302398968,
0.0119402111,
-0.0058231256,
0.0085413111,
0.030669665,
0.0360444412,
0.0587613471,
0.0323193073,
-0.0272064563,
0.0309305638,
-0.0411468968,
-0.0041082627,
-0.0273315758,
0.0812218115,
-0.0367258936,
0.0002636079,
0.0638177991,
-0.0330732018,
-0.0325633436,
0.0373592973,
0.0609597899,
0.0306258164,
0.0162848644,
0.0011717163,
-0.0293207727,
0.0123142693,
-0.0027121415,
0.0370299146,
0.0036818194,
-0.0465202369,
0.0098303733,
0.0278705154,
-0.0240269098,
-0.0223243535,
0.0048127179,
0.0128948484,
-0.0227263961,
-0.0358157195,
-0.0129625509,
-0.0056626452,
-0.0174942929,
-0.0328358337,
-0.0193959028,
-0.0228637103,
-0.0511289723,
-0.0183435902,
0.0737417713,
0.032816235,
-0.0229556914,
0.0109001789,
-0.0422620848,
-0.0122245802,
-0.0217914358,
-0.0054054023,
-0.0514620878,
0.0221298169,
0.0528843887,
-0.0065729367,
-0.0261542574,
0.0643778443,
-0.0183310565,
-0.0137055442,
-0.0124243163,
-0.0324650966,
0.0374712758,
-0.0179177672,
-0.0325722769,
-0.0460098237,
-0.0979900584,
0.0488418266,
0.0788684562,
0.0174297299,
-0.021997815,
0.0002723644,
2.589e-7,
-0.0311317276,
0.0079596667,
-0.0312825665,
0.0500752814,
-0.0019769054,
0.0739051849,
-0.0013660013,
0.0053315624,
-0.0166604221,
0.0160840806,
-0.0151944458,
-0.0246180091,
0.029465545,
0.0384006649,
-0.0297719911,
0.0126933577,
0.0049939519,
-0.0083578499,
-0.0624168664,
0.0202347431,
-0.0053948718,
0.0569984578,
0.0187420435,
0.0194005407,
0.0129549755,
-0.0546744466,
0.0046155327,
-0.0403271094,
0.0023518489,
0.0376506411,
0.0046257856,
0.0541555919,
-0.0357345864,
-0.0113124838,
-0.029810831,
0.0110095544,
-0.0097123813,
0.0511507057,
-0.0184792317,
0.0467899814,
-0.0031441918,
-0.0985912308,
0.0106894039,
-0.0172757376,
0.0597486123,
-0.0269976519,
-0.020826092,
-0.0258697066,
0.0429852977,
-0.0123032006,
-0.0455520265,
0.0174724925,
-0.0061424044,
0.0108888149,
-0.0000588338,
0.0146739539,
-0.0214662869,
-0.0587710217,
0.0064735748,
0.0204564221,
0.0038313589,
-0.0544462539,
-0.0467603616,
0.0318923071,
-0.0376945809,
0.0021895864,
0.0360381417,
2.392056158e-34,
-0.0064086481,
0.0117801558,
0.0373889618,
0.0196651295,
0.0383376889,
0.0237839576,
-0.0164550189,
0.0309003945,
0.064426586,
-0.0588740222,
0.0082659088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10677v1 | LLMs as Potential Brainstorming Partners for Math and Science Problems | 2023-10-10T21:16:35 | 2023-10-10T21:16:35 | Sophia Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the recent rise of widely successful deep learning models, there is
emerging interest among professionals in various math and science communities
to see and evaluate the state-of-the-art models' abilities to collaborate on
finding or solving problems that often require creativity and thus
brainstorming. While a significant chasm still exists between current
human-machine intellectual collaborations and the resolution of complex math
and science problems, such as the six unsolved Millennium Prize Problems, our
initial investigation into this matter reveals a promising step towards
bridging the divide. This is due to the recent advancements in Large Language
Models (LLMs). More specifically, we conduct comprehensive case studies to
explore both the capabilities and limitations of the current state-of-the-art
LLM, notably GPT-4, in collective brainstorming with humans. | [
0.0313880816,
0.0921275169,
-0.0199785586,
0.0512485728,
-0.0613466725,
0.0058999648,
0.014872605,
-0.0136286411,
-0.0282392371,
-0.0097689852,
-0.0152697796,
-0.0508912019,
-0.0197137762,
0.0379781127,
0.0212445986,
-0.031974528,
0.0041917255,
-0.0633854717,
-0.00199737,
-0.0378025211,
-0.0371627957,
0.0131616304,
-0.0279158428,
0.049775742,
-0.0078079468,
-0.0173120312,
-0.0116450088,
-0.0204726774,
-0.0098990984,
-0.0010906106,
-0.0282340795,
0.0757702738,
0.0318690836,
0.0975483954,
0.0000019067,
-0.0457835384,
0.0053563537,
-0.0026298335,
-0.0148102306,
-0.0137395291,
0.0046073692,
0.0073676379,
-0.025517337,
-0.0029637651,
-0.0602038279,
0.0416039117,
0.0361795872,
0.0143954307,
0.0388426036,
0.010020162,
0.0026879483,
-0.0311340429,
0.0688619539,
-0.0303736143,
0.0450309813,
-0.0499932691,
0.0059220879,
-0.0128414994,
0.0307262242,
-0.0187175125,
-0.0215835869,
0.055674877,
0.0672570691,
-0.0256075319,
-0.0058863955,
0.0375604145,
-0.0424285904,
-0.0292678103,
-0.0042491183,
0.0697933286,
-0.0157867316,
-0.001190514,
0.0077375113,
-0.0032838662,
0.0026823066,
0.0319051594,
-0.0480562299,
0.0362695195,
0.014768648,
0.0061716074,
-0.0039617405,
-0.0159187727,
0.0244156886,
0.0481299423,
0.0010898587,
0.0884185657,
0.0308899544,
-0.0016079746,
-0.0088979993,
0.0214397088,
-0.0527091473,
-0.0578980595,
0.0356563367,
0.0163256135,
0.0000466174,
-0.0013878853,
-0.0300676357,
-0.0339570828,
-0.0079408204,
-0.0096341241,
0.0538436621,
0.0335645452,
0.0503054596,
0.0641463026,
0.0129869664,
0.0145367356,
-0.062198855,
0.0191954207,
-0.0196363851,
0.0019051707,
-0.0689449906,
-0.0269122012,
-0.0349633507,
0.0406154282,
-0.0086648399,
-0.0276872832,
-0.0148665113,
0.0507739633,
-0.004111656,
-0.0214608815,
-0.0033649513,
0.04247481,
-0.0144378375,
-0.0578248315,
-0.043537382,
0.0162024572,
-0.0113548469,
0.0084102284,
0.0279272143,
-0.0261442456,
0.0031241698,
0.024334399,
-0.0527406,
-0.0620657429,
0.0219260026,
0.07396245,
0.0150916725,
0.0121841608,
0.0139083052,
-0.0378288217,
0.0173160154,
-0.079496257,
0.0308550633,
-0.0684499592,
0.0314031281,
0.0089520402,
-0.017667776,
-0.0599595495,
0.0214208104,
-0.0078199962,
0.0008666042,
0.077597037,
-0.0127348322,
0.0228752401,
0.0684293061,
0.0234906301,
-0.0026748052,
0.0490458198,
0.0713987499,
0.021638047,
0.0119503587,
-0.0064488845,
0.0430477709,
0.0415243767,
0.0063120318,
-0.0042760959,
-0.0132647026,
-0.0177104827,
-0.0088417958,
0.0795598403,
-0.0174629893,
0.0802627131,
-0.0180372521,
-0.0046418277,
0.0695952401,
0.106663391,
0.0091949636,
0.0848331228,
0.01817316,
-0.0296538156,
0.005601129,
-0.0232728608,
-0.0227038264,
0.06199608,
-0.0267759245,
-0.001872511,
0.0430006422,
0.03301128,
-0.0310264323,
-0.0197601039,
0.0151182748,
0.0290880203,
0.0012420333,
0.0126387803,
0.0372905582,
-0.0379435308,
-0.0236484408,
0.0299155619,
-0.0330653116,
-0.0351483412,
0.0238432232,
-0.0553606041,
0.0375482142,
0.0393195339,
0.0604496337,
-0.0030689058,
-0.0324728489,
-0.0252067614,
0.0105277896,
0.0472542942,
0.0430232845,
0.0077468622,
-0.0360831581,
-0.0179652609,
-0.0089772493,
-0.0360371321,
-0.0182744563,
-0.0103215938,
0.0134587623,
0.0115560219,
0.0076153469,
0.0082595358,
-0.0123260245,
0.011924048,
-0.0744485036,
0.0232627764,
0.0019694665,
-0.0167057738,
0.016930582,
0.0275824051,
-0.0213562232,
0.0397234038,
0.0342925042,
-0.0520270988,
-0.0583763234,
0.0091279475,
-0.0275911614,
-0.0100038191,
0.0380079746,
-0.065730989,
-0.0059296321,
0.0168461893,
-0.00711822,
-0.0210896451,
0.0766072497,
-0.0577306002,
-0.0069512096,
-0.0432025641,
0.0009850954,
-0.0192927737,
0.0267300382,
-0.0247701239,
0.0395349339,
-0.0167764444,
-0.0071701962,
0.0055079395,
-0.0095047336,
0.0158422161,
-0.0610223562,
-0.0244327076,
0.0368440896,
0.0367329866,
0.0067824158,
0.0027473797,
0.0100308312,
-0.0430540368,
-0.0449637249,
-0.0637342706,
-0.0076060314,
-0.0127298888,
0.0184946768,
-0.0098340809,
-0.0022377921,
-0.0030684168,
0.0087686051,
-0.0343290456,
-0.0037299469,
0.0271751489,
0.0020336467,
0.0438186415,
-0.000289461,
-0.0121847577,
-0.0190204475,
-0.0329350792,
-0.0246029273,
0.0286641121,
0.0536815375,
-0.0273296423,
-0.0382456593,
0.0330912098,
-0.0649826229,
0.0212945957,
0.0080122491,
-0.0020310851,
0.0410778448,
-0.0304301921,
0.046522744,
0.0505674928,
0.0119151399,
0.0383818708,
0.0117613887,
-0.0236093905,
-0.0214360356,
0.026450552,
-0.0358936042,
0.0094664861,
-0.0084865149,
0.0231774077,
0.00092477,
0.0564038903,
-0.0256163646,
-0.0180988703,
-0.037715409,
0.0836402252,
0.016526537,
-0.0324854665,
-0.0393830612,
-0.0003882893,
-0.010566677,
0.063733533,
-0.0104244463,
-0.0440821759,
0.0882825851,
0.0068703787,
-0.0152299264,
-0.0471277535,
-0.0245839134,
-0.0464034937,
0.059216857,
-0.0317722261,
-0.0043808706,
-0.0278960764,
0.0096882405,
-0.0451456718,
0.0230715331,
-0.0139261354,
-0.0183507521,
0.0130425869,
-0.0526311584,
0.0101285046,
-0.0162648689,
-0.0472396836,
-0.0224919599,
0.0112838401,
-0.0287515987,
0.0477466136,
0.0474112704,
-0.0289932135,
-0.0423899442,
0.016019145,
0.0525735244,
0.0270480085,
0.0049244314,
0.001670305,
-0.0128070954,
0.0100999512,
0.0588283427,
0.0327069461,
0.013548553,
-0.0465731584,
-0.0011348334,
0.0398897715,
0.0248266496,
0.0206180923,
-0.0066440944,
0.0396106876,
0.0319517069,
0.0178861506,
-0.0316216163,
-0.0059101167,
0.047111582,
-0.0422669128,
-0.0098324306,
0.0803376958,
0.025586443,
-0.0709049255,
0.0025047497,
-0.0400591381,
-0.019745525,
0.0127300406,
0.0089020832,
-0.0620872863,
-0.0132112298,
0.0205908455,
-0.0267270319,
0.0037716758,
-0.0599498302,
-0.0275111664,
-0.0969492495,
0.0515259728,
0.0093197273,
-0.0281128492,
0.01129374,
-0.0185103845,
-0.027124444,
0.0039071059,
-0.0003535679,
-0.0042894739,
0.0275179725,
0.0227504969,
0.0087285833,
-0.0025204408,
-0.0359074883,
0.0130341677,
-0.0409048833,
0.0176862087,
0.0916164741,
0.030724328,
-0.009534833,
-0.0771492794,
-0.0156186018,
0.0455075577,
0.0133434329,
0.0107331472,
-0.0090267966,
0.0071760337,
-0.0112269046,
-0.0045048334,
0.0696615726,
-0.0941731483,
-0.009019753,
0.0196765345,
0.1218427196,
-0.0352490507,
-0.0015477719,
-0.0312136412,
0.0117160259,
-0.0200018901,
0.0703976303,
0.0216809791,
-0.0526221059,
-0.059271697,
-0.0441782922,
0.010706747,
-0.0740530416,
-0.0468298793,
-0.0570719615,
0.0589324497,
0.0343445465,
-0.0389585868,
-0.0081449645,
0.0612833872,
0.0347382613,
0.0216311887,
-0.0108461976,
-0.0245551039,
0.0051538385,
-0.0311630145,
0.037740849,
-0.0189294554,
0.0487498082,
-0.084428221,
-0.0162130576,
-0.0007007246,
-0.03579152,
-0.0238389,
0.0593342148,
-0.1125406325,
-0.0886086226,
-0.0178800058,
0.0100889541,
0.0331523232,
-0.0173966158,
0.0033159319,
-0.0789524242,
0.0504889973,
0.0479463674,
-0.0317812972,
0.0181714483,
-0.001410393,
0.0326578058,
-0.0048032063,
0.0182061847,
0.0096020643,
0.0038197229,
0.0453266464,
0.050518427,
-0.0191872306,
-0.0343162678,
-0.0051800827,
0.0090748174,
0.0103507377,
-0.0182523578,
-0.021316018,
-0.0218528919,
-0.0077572055,
0.011069973,
-0.0139137935,
-0.0840471759,
-0.0098161539,
0.0225827955,
-0.0077038966,
0.0405744836,
0.0195010826,
0.0086271763,
0.042515263,
-0.0165413246,
0.0239991788,
0.0035336057,
0.0245701335,
0.0418091454,
0.0144229922,
0.0212312192,
0.028293496,
-0.0475915186,
0.033221148,
0.0052572349,
0.0552772544,
0.0147282844,
0.0159499981,
0.0068626753,
0.0392213166,
-0.0887380764,
-0.1311624795,
-0.0219419003,
0.0479290783,
0.0462408774,
0.0703002363,
-0.023969708,
-0.0504982211,
-0.0212472621,
-0.0155904097,
0.0188020151,
-0.0138503723,
-0.0101071969,
0.0197331533,
0.0289219059,
-0.0096814139,
-0.0215919763,
0.0726869255,
-0.0149971014,
0.010747469,
0.0158273354,
0.0127236675,
-0.0018962681,
-0.0270208418,
0.0035813393,
0.010875958,
0.006119689,
0.0367061757,
-0.0486548394,
-0.0500487834,
0.0266108643,
0.00088889,
-0.0056096003,
-0.0100780623,
0.0470458195,
0.0616298392,
-0.0408381149,
-0.0007905739,
-0.0020808016,
0.0172714125,
-0.044747293,
-0.0456701964,
-0.0482522435,
-5.828927144e-33,
0.0104754483,
-0.0487137996,
0.0395427272,
0.0215389188,
-0.0401819423,
-0.0323408507,
-0.0649769455,
0.0483242832,
-0.0033207957,
0.0068922755,
-0.0154313073,
0.0010025876,
-0.008121402,
0.0148542849,
0.0138819683,
-0.0200807154,
0.032541424,
-0.0399365053,
-0.0122072399,
0.0304901749,
-0.0056724506,
0.0246595293,
0.0430882014,
-0.0381722599,
-0.0069139623,
0.0007229409,
0.0169672351,
0.0337110311,
-0.0203029979,
0.0400791205,
-0.0541599169,
0.0206569433,
0.0116608655,
-0.0590064265,
-0.0292394049,
-0.0206678566,
-0.0041239643,
-0.0132654961,
0.006210654,
-0.0305973236,
-0.0368885249,
-0.0334578231,
0.0387847126,
-0.0032986656,
-0.0397319607,
-0.0124603109,
0.0210721418,
-0.0223061685,
-0.0203354061,
-0.0041007493,
-0.0379784927,
-0.0018908397,
-0.0182077885,
-0.011855498,
0.0655312166,
-0.047780063,
-0.0170944072,
0.0281165112,
-0.0292082131,
0.0597758628,
0.0264666378,
0.0212278254,
0.0829773694,
-0.0348426588,
0.0316836722,
0.0519086383,
0.052356191,
0.0012801813,
-0.0498037152,
-0.0087000849,
0.0174693447,
0.0764557496,
0.0776209161,
0.0564854071,
0.0076905582,
0.0360136107,
-0.0051334817,
-0.012107091,
-0.0062945094,
-0.0164910629,
0.036127571,
0.0345576406,
-0.0152653046,
-0.0254907645,
-0.0174478535,
-0.036708191,
-0.0428256392,
-0.0207868703,
0.0001876677,
-0.0227377526,
-0.0094247013,
0.0284347236,
0.0452500321,
-0.0522499979,
0.0249712653,
0.0230740607,
0.0021271845,
0.0359826684,
0.0219239369,
0.0061888555,
-0.0750946924,
-0.0208857283,
-0.0109834829,
0.0704044476,
0.017773306,
0.0091855377,
-0.0319106914,
0.0219420176,
0.0064942893,
-0.01073917,
-0.0556514636,
0.0199268796,
0.0472927056,
0.0132882064,
-0.0086742574,
-0.0080202706,
-0.0124836601,
-0.0071190796,
-0.0025154089,
-0.0162625853,
-0.0067808283,
0.0170408357,
-0.0357185267,
0.0100446017,
-0.0266669337,
-0.0340201482,
-0.0238558147,
-0.0367897376,
0.0877287015,
-0.0407426208,
-0.0350253843,
-0.0003730219,
2.628e-7,
0.0112006273,
0.0263594184,
0.0323138833,
-0.0307737198,
0.0357717648,
0.0185710918,
-0.0283587687,
0.0015951919,
0.0078306971,
0.0164767206,
0.0086816521,
0.0590932705,
0.0595090315,
0.0198809616,
-0.0796474889,
0.012027584,
-0.080211252,
0.0146577833,
-0.0670531169,
-0.0083307652,
0.0109028229,
0.0557788424,
0.058646597,
-0.0421454161,
0.0016590629,
-0.0447443575,
0.0606901459,
-0.0575547814,
0.0125711635,
0.0373964347,
-0.0037654149,
0.0042285169,
-0.0136382785,
0.0110940225,
0.0006332596,
-0.0144729428,
0.0302968193,
0.0110640777,
0.0215807781,
-0.0234860927,
-0.0251412448,
-0.008851652,
0.0101012206,
-0.0574848577,
0.0410786569,
-0.0726728439,
-0.0571848527,
0.0063793818,
0.0386627913,
-0.0411197171,
0.0393438861,
-0.0394794792,
0.0442994274,
-0.0336060636,
0.004645769,
0.0125475144,
0.003631837,
-0.0458698831,
0.0012870369,
-0.0331882164,
-0.1017173007,
-0.0545701794,
-0.0587859787,
-0.0248130262,
0.0105128586,
-0.0344457664,
0.013967541,
2.347845861e-34,
0.0331500024,
0.0105215581,
0.0037778784,
0.0489470996,
0.0338298604,
0.0049030902,
-0.0094661433,
-0.0154973874,
-0.0052425619,
-0.0689350143,
-0.0545776561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07018v1 | NEWTON: Are Large Language Models Capable of Physical Reasoning? | 2023-10-10T21:08:51 | 2023-10-10T21:08:51 | Yi Ru Wang, Jiafei Duan, Dieter Fox, Siddhartha Srinivasa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO | Large Language Models (LLMs), through their contextualized representations,
have been empirically proven to encapsulate syntactic, semantic, word sense,
and common-sense knowledge. However, there has been limited exploration of
their physical reasoning abilities, specifically concerning the crucial
attributes for comprehending everyday objects. To address this gap, we
introduce NEWTON, a repository and benchmark for evaluating the physics
reasoning skills of LLMs. Further, to enable domain-specific adaptation of this
benchmark, we present a pipeline to enable researchers to generate a variant of
this benchmark that has been customized to the objects and attributes relevant
for their application. The NEWTON repository comprises a collection of 2800
object-attribute pairs, providing the foundation for generating infinite-scale
assessment templates. The NEWTON benchmark consists of 160K QA questions,
curated using the NEWTON repository to investigate the physical reasoning
capabilities of several mainstream language models across foundational,
explicit, and implicit reasoning tasks. Through extensive empirical analysis,
our results highlight the capabilities of LLMs for physical reasoning. We find
that LLMs like GPT-4 demonstrate strong reasoning capabilities in
scenario-based tasks but exhibit less consistency in object-attribute reasoning
compared to humans (50% vs. 84%). Furthermore, the NEWTON platform demonstrates
its potential for evaluating and enhancing language models, paving the way for
their integration into physically grounded settings, such as robotic
manipulation. Project site: https://newtonreasoning.github.io | [
0.0036018849,
0.0417354926,
-0.0094911186,
0.0720458701,
-0.0206758957,
0.0233744681,
0.0224349499,
0.0012967386,
-0.0190501884,
-0.026492035,
-0.0125366133,
-0.003999114,
-0.012544563,
-0.0012882595,
0.0202411395,
-0.0405711047,
0.0385701321,
-0.0447209328,
-0.0281467773,
-0.0106741227,
-0.0380798057,
-0.0123977121,
-0.0529729575,
0.0149158379,
0.0029322552,
-0.0302507617,
-0.0016583141,
-0.0318562314,
0.0372649617,
-0.0213238876,
-0.0358304866,
0.0569243096,
0.0505953096,
0.0587747134,
0.0000020052,
-0.0429020748,
0.0401131511,
0.0241741352,
-0.0407602899,
0.0031590958,
0.0036909457,
-0.0420618467,
0.0020654537,
-0.0034378832,
-0.0209505428,
-0.0141909895,
0.0332913212,
-0.012447007,
0.0196214151,
0.0350218862,
0.0065848916,
-0.0196916331,
0.0289512035,
0.0080238143,
0.0501973368,
-0.0358271003,
-0.0090573607,
0.0665078163,
0.0603588633,
0.0487506315,
-0.0439653695,
0.0294568669,
0.0884013623,
-0.0108851688,
-0.023778284,
0.0615699217,
-0.0399446264,
0.0208382308,
0.0140613643,
0.0543502718,
0.0376151055,
-0.024796661,
-0.0104881646,
0.0018063938,
-0.0205098391,
0.004381719,
-0.0661195219,
0.0264815781,
0.0117192445,
-0.0126050264,
-0.0586423613,
-0.0242509563,
0.0353951752,
0.0196768809,
-0.0245681573,
0.123877883,
0.0171973556,
0.0257810261,
0.014933479,
-0.0030287569,
-0.0058476417,
-0.0550858304,
-0.0131818252,
0.0339648388,
-0.0146400072,
0.0028475106,
-0.0055281254,
0.0202125851,
0.0041503012,
-0.0286928192,
0.0282985121,
0.0454076007,
0.0137976296,
0.0612461083,
-0.0315339044,
0.089638181,
-0.0312687047,
0.0488816239,
-0.0386364497,
0.0120090535,
-0.0887598097,
-0.0254438389,
0.0326208547,
0.0100457305,
-0.0275684185,
-0.0432712995,
-0.0047529433,
-0.002546024,
-0.0193012673,
-0.0157354623,
-0.0429262631,
0.027144257,
0.0083599826,
-0.0364811011,
-0.0456174649,
0.0193646252,
-0.0434020273,
0.060486611,
0.0145000378,
-0.0447000526,
-0.0238552801,
-0.0164554771,
-0.0157155991,
-0.0384413637,
0.0043190885,
0.050874155,
0.0095484508,
0.0057001449,
0.0187188666,
-0.0429873057,
-0.0012407547,
-0.0808915496,
0.0195346847,
-0.0648322925,
0.0157717392,
0.0258297846,
-0.0067548268,
-0.0465755314,
0.0146114128,
0.0142845558,
0.0010695052,
0.0893583596,
0.0302981902,
0.0072996742,
0.0086536361,
0.0256754085,
-0.0200986043,
0.0454121381,
0.0204066131,
0.0047464487,
-0.0134299248,
0.0027895519,
-0.0438851416,
0.0216352101,
-0.0162943881,
-0.0200909115,
-0.0727369562,
0.0281932335,
-0.0163876917,
0.0615808256,
-0.0022064596,
-0.0001269736,
-0.0039628483,
-0.0159820393,
0.036838837,
0.0476694666,
-0.0484478883,
0.028486317,
0.0314244702,
-0.0347978249,
0.0208453797,
-0.0364569724,
-0.0692948848,
0.0554537587,
-0.0249211118,
-0.0182572939,
-0.0148258898,
0.0032446305,
-0.0214421526,
-0.0159505494,
-0.0343048163,
0.0235217959,
0.0300072264,
0.0272525605,
0.059687458,
-0.011016177,
0.0079658581,
0.0362631977,
-0.0058302078,
-0.0398398079,
-0.0140377814,
-0.0103279799,
0.0160510931,
0.0287141986,
0.0229522418,
-0.0314792693,
-0.0747017264,
0.0201422404,
0.0547544062,
0.0379307196,
0.0409362651,
0.0192459207,
-0.0067270342,
-0.0087260343,
-0.0216778237,
-0.0371232741,
0.0057627656,
0.0286411922,
-0.0058075697,
0.0042820307,
0.0110863829,
-0.026025651,
0.0151718315,
0.0472110175,
-0.0287034418,
-0.0072918171,
-0.0272516534,
-0.0217119139,
0.0324134529,
-0.0096602365,
0.0021481721,
0.0066046584,
0.037017867,
-0.0279972292,
0.0024563128,
0.0325228907,
-0.0248698592,
-0.0138370758,
0.0518795364,
-0.0160745103,
-0.0406020954,
0.0514512472,
-0.0192106739,
-0.023202559,
0.0365734212,
0.0126829706,
0.0390099324,
-0.0092961565,
-0.0155167626,
-0.0199722964,
0.0044185231,
0.0083454968,
0.0617333464,
-0.0016583883,
0.0331775732,
0.0149433343,
0.0609245822,
0.0245223995,
-0.0430528857,
-0.0086236838,
0.024392901,
-0.0162081067,
0.0007638925,
-0.006369039,
-0.0089196889,
-0.0532133766,
-0.0018187306,
-0.0513720177,
-0.0114124259,
0.011013614,
-0.0090793865,
0.0204345826,
-0.035555061,
-0.0067615639,
0.0167161841,
0.0334901027,
0.0324012786,
-0.0390475616,
0.0105647705,
0.0138395559,
-0.0142292231,
-0.0207734983,
-0.0035403273,
-0.004375021,
-0.0848656297,
0.0401036628,
0.0519358777,
0.0778650269,
-0.0159040373,
0.0381295048,
-0.0557519197,
-0.000643826,
-0.0049055512,
-0.0260970574,
0.0687916949,
-0.0461295918,
0.0227880646,
0.1016982347,
-0.0447017439,
0.0309715234,
0.0760307238,
-0.055871997,
-0.0283517428,
0.0052954624,
-0.0083232652,
0.0015444864,
-0.026362516,
0.0011489984,
-0.0144327655,
0.0387194231,
-0.0026320985,
-0.0182314552,
-0.0513440333,
0.0262711681,
-0.0538716018,
-0.0219363309,
-0.0393940844,
0.0382704064,
-0.0232304148,
0.0464317873,
-0.0236175731,
0.0023369144,
0.0621383935,
-0.0297169276,
0.0162845738,
-0.0128215086,
0.0295065977,
-0.0080951294,
0.1319321692,
0.0091989022,
-0.0121276947,
-0.0113668703,
0.0134628937,
-0.0219203513,
0.0143074458,
0.010089187,
0.0098020872,
-0.0051132045,
-0.090460591,
0.019464964,
0.0019544302,
-0.0366808698,
0.0040837247,
-0.0029854891,
-0.0447342806,
0.0491070822,
-0.075849995,
-0.0742782429,
-0.0271482989,
0.0039138822,
0.03494706,
0.0328882299,
-0.0294100437,
-0.0175214838,
-0.0439679027,
0.0025680326,
0.0292092096,
0.0463232547,
0.0077944761,
-0.0298399553,
0.0290216021,
0.0429309942,
0.0449133515,
-0.0021679283,
-0.0765582398,
0.0345980078,
0.0051297927,
0.0315672606,
0.020997785,
0.0311922096,
0.0653932914,
-0.0709741563,
-0.0484455638,
0.1020361036,
0.0291393604,
0.0084631974,
0.0200410634,
-0.0243838951,
0.0129616102,
0.0326819271,
-0.0083918786,
-0.0528088138,
-0.0547350086,
0.0137743922,
-0.0324004479,
0.0323561132,
-0.0560174584,
0.0024580897,
-0.0977560878,
0.0233894363,
-0.0198395289,
-0.0536326393,
-0.070301421,
-0.0034956734,
-0.0041457629,
-0.0108551811,
-0.0046575973,
0.0217856579,
0.0230499413,
0.010607779,
0.0034944995,
0.0069156135,
-0.0555266701,
0.0913043544,
-0.0396043509,
0.0055995984,
0.0474545173,
0.0374125801,
-0.0363313742,
-0.0477761738,
0.0220533777,
0.000726576,
0.0084383357,
-0.0147139672,
-0.0243603084,
0.0224167816,
-0.0091600344,
-0.0155976657,
0.0560478158,
-0.0542609207,
-0.0865950882,
-0.0009667381,
0.1196897775,
-0.0160809699,
-0.0186379347,
-0.0364623331,
-0.0283104219,
-0.0442132317,
0.0797426179,
0.0127380462,
-0.0066591376,
-0.0451722629,
-0.033762902,
-0.0468570963,
0.0296737775,
-0.0457206666,
-0.0067499164,
0.0650889575,
-0.0054140869,
-0.026901383,
0.0118384175,
0.0340908431,
0.02562722,
-0.0122169182,
-0.0376771353,
-0.0051610218,
0.0048683509,
-0.039614927,
0.057072226,
-0.0014230859,
0.026445426,
-0.0120270019,
0.0272201989,
0.040437609,
-0.0247475095,
-0.0483699478,
0.0255110357,
-0.0325014256,
-0.0594465025,
-0.0000591638,
0.0371123999,
0.0305626523,
-0.0058598411,
-0.0233955644,
-0.0344436765,
-0.0172214806,
0.0114504294,
-0.0671506226,
0.0484821796,
-0.0089025106,
-0.0198155977,
0.0173698068,
0.0079499641,
-0.0090645384,
0.0232014414,
-0.0116026718,
0.0135195488,
-0.0098933866,
-0.024212772,
0.0078119594,
0.0020808408,
0.0445362516,
0.0410875082,
-0.0245395545,
-0.0291404743,
0.014246908,
-0.0296126138,
0.0156773515,
-0.0473146103,
0.0119644627,
0.0360779613,
-0.0259342156,
-0.0083887884,
-0.0027089023,
0.0148426937,
0.0538545214,
-0.0001891624,
0.0163661931,
0.0019509301,
0.0448983163,
0.0207788292,
-0.0034008308,
0.0071649039,
-0.034743581,
-0.0767083839,
0.0630525053,
-0.0227833521,
0.0402589217,
0.047903046,
0.0016396794,
-0.0440800264,
-0.0089112464,
-0.1061590537,
-0.0756479427,
0.0186400842,
0.011348567,
0.0123932846,
-0.0173157845,
0.0056692655,
-0.0867624655,
-0.0170345325,
0.0024160102,
0.026725566,
0.0397607498,
-0.0098926863,
0.0875990167,
0.0578427613,
0.0216639247,
-0.0296107512,
0.0321389809,
-0.0289353523,
0.057859946,
0.0154868932,
-0.0127374623,
-0.0296892039,
-0.0254862551,
-0.0104039693,
-0.0005735495,
0.0010592451,
0.0106601669,
-0.0533361994,
-0.0703022182,
-0.0053054704,
0.0626659021,
-0.0209065136,
-0.0096196206,
0.0162155908,
0.0550488792,
-0.0165064856,
-0.0547786802,
0.0409665219,
0.0069856346,
-0.0443836041,
0.005874922,
-0.0323470756,
-5.64318875e-33,
-0.0191782992,
-0.0042390455,
0.0319686085,
-0.0175468121,
-0.0123386001,
0.0013752005,
-0.0628581122,
-0.0112225441,
-0.0397062637,
0.0398241729,
0.0110959699,
0.0143578975,
-0.0172315221,
-0.005111461,
0.0297793821,
-0.0156825595,
-0.0108085806,
0.0111412928,
-0.025754787,
0.0112654725,
0.0414839797,
-0.0039789611,
0.0361208431,
-0.0124227982,
0.0139675345,
0.0018359781,
-0.0009193002,
0.0247692727,
-0.0665243119,
0.0408223011,
-0.043544203,
-0.0083320457,
0.0184793845,
-0.0394659862,
0.0010085221,
0.0049378611,
-0.0607098043,
-0.0563874841,
-0.007408415,
0.0131478915,
-0.0381805748,
-0.0161100496,
0.0438847542,
0.0180257782,
-0.0349152535,
-0.0546421409,
0.0323034748,
-0.0405024253,
0.0217955709,
0.0346677825,
-0.0252843257,
0.0075073061,
-0.0205761641,
-0.0188329443,
0.0287320428,
0.0072849276,
-0.0184752233,
0.029572105,
-0.0290673394,
-0.014635697,
-0.0302585419,
0.0185091738,
0.0616108514,
-0.0215323139,
0.0499466993,
0.086983256,
0.0248787347,
-0.0437348634,
-0.0521810278,
0.0106896702,
0.0381358787,
0.0962793082,
0.0480449907,
0.0738324448,
0.0489796661,
0.0311278868,
-0.0949089676,
-0.0038607398,
-0.0023922119,
0.1008459404,
0.0305158868,
0.0011649899,
-0.0046379426,
0.0083461925,
-0.0514367633,
0.0235909987,
-0.0321799032,
-0.0237075109,
0.0457996987,
-0.0477410294,
-0.0012702515,
-0.0096382145,
0.036117889,
-0.0523997545,
-0.0144749004,
0.0421659797,
-0.0060493983,
0.0355354995,
0.0125117311,
0.0369684286,
-0.0477731712,
-0.0179255903,
-0.0043477961,
-0.0074374601,
0.0351034515,
-0.0100155035,
-0.0031449359,
0.0433806479,
-0.0093051028,
-0.0273504611,
-0.0591261908,
-0.0426046476,
0.0212957244,
0.0249074716,
0.0441769809,
0.0594055466,
-0.0079480661,
0.0408785492,
-0.0310499072,
-0.0220453329,
-0.0213027857,
0.0290315058,
-0.0272405203,
0.0047164359,
-0.0268687271,
-0.0510113202,
-0.0373677239,
-0.0343648046,
0.0372620076,
-0.053956382,
-0.0174958836,
0.0534987524,
2.66e-7,
0.0419433713,
0.0458266959,
0.0028398158,
-0.0145030813,
0.0185192265,
0.0226240158,
-0.0488245413,
0.0097361291,
0.0185790304,
-0.0357519947,
-0.0299923141,
0.0614865683,
0.0506516583,
0.0297491867,
-0.0764297619,
0.0492511317,
-0.0069381581,
-0.0387185626,
-0.0470963567,
0.004947722,
0.0355649106,
0.0406022072,
0.0375980139,
0.0112413242,
0.0189487636,
-0.0230419133,
0.0438576937,
-0.0617367104,
0.0495100282,
-0.0039666407,
-0.0248854328,
-0.0195048284,
0.0018554676,
0.0377697274,
0.0029375714,
-0.0133581357,
-0.0143376105,
0.0645136908,
-0.0082545625,
-0.0083772084,
-0.0250731539,
-0.0418944657,
-0.0001954065,
-0.0669830441,
0.0893878341,
-0.0539749824,
-0.0340870023,
-0.0077356966,
0.0067962357,
-0.0248455424,
0.0028061485,
0.0316252634,
0.0341764279,
-0.023443548,
-0.0058242795,
-0.0239729919,
-0.0254466031,
-0.0706167743,
-0.0340086818,
0.0310741644,
-0.0762413144,
-0.0120531553,
-0.0455348194,
-0.0446913019,
0.0290113911,
-0.0562550463,
-0.0358229093,
2.312432487e-34,
-0.0115245562,
0.0229208395,
0.0112533495,
0.0077030906,
0.0291632153,
-0.0001115052,
0.0297294036,
0.0240802281,
0.0278261825,
-0.0702316016,
-0.0092305876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07008v1 | Answer Candidate Type Selection: Text-to-Text Language Model for Closed Book Question Answering Meets Knowledge Graphs | 2023-10-10T20:49:43 | 2023-10-10T20:49:43 | Mikhail Salnikov, Maria Lysyuk, Pavel Braslavski, Anton Razzhigaev, Valentin Malykh, Alexander Panchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Pre-trained Text-to-Text Language Models (LMs), such as T5 or BART yield
promising results in the Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) task.
However, the capacity of the models is limited and the quality decreases for
questions with less popular entities. In this paper, we present a novel
approach which works on top of the pre-trained Text-to-Text QA system to
address this issue. Our simple yet effective method performs filtering and
re-ranking of generated candidates based on their types derived from Wikidata
"instance_of" property. | [
0.0660032928,
0.0000987375,
0.0167624466,
0.0440302566,
-0.0060182111,
0.0025127209,
-0.0171340201,
0.0153459553,
0.0902823061,
-0.1023870409,
-0.0039748731,
-0.006334235,
-0.0227009766,
0.0359276533,
0.0305093657,
-0.0260212086,
0.0518203117,
-0.0194750316,
-0.0072341566,
-0.0250276644,
-0.005164911,
0.0748298094,
0.0024740822,
-0.0034621803,
0.0442488901,
-0.0424085036,
0.0189764071,
-0.0048400578,
-0.0063459319,
0.0029802585,
0.0379987769,
0.0372750461,
0.020994829,
-0.0108443713,
0.000001843,
-0.0493476093,
-0.0149014965,
0.0005539699,
-0.0431237854,
0.0274916496,
-0.0299299657,
0.0531478599,
0.0579944924,
0.0189620666,
-0.0449646413,
0.0012585936,
0.0047321953,
0.013837616,
0.061717011,
0.0498311296,
0.0204698071,
-0.0039086784,
0.027607562,
0.0091005042,
0.0335052833,
-0.0484311432,
0.0397670344,
-0.018354319,
0.0603088439,
0.0471121557,
0.0075104781,
-0.0006355515,
-0.0168996155,
-0.0106528988,
0.0500376523,
0.0141585348,
-0.0198500156,
0.0681980401,
0.0157891344,
0.1124891937,
0.0167966317,
-0.0410908498,
0.0284035522,
0.0016849807,
-0.0019084102,
0.0435973518,
-0.0103822658,
-0.0349779315,
-0.0321549214,
-0.0279308092,
-0.0031412914,
0.0273630992,
0.0108830938,
0.0056600897,
-0.0086995875,
0.0765792057,
0.0258059334,
-0.0134708909,
0.0047519468,
0.0028911091,
-0.0197941791,
-0.0836361572,
0.0250865575,
0.0549511947,
-0.0153041882,
-0.005849978,
-0.0316488594,
0.0031681848,
0.0112003218,
-0.0623458102,
-0.035494145,
-0.0082886331,
0.0445781872,
0.0305415466,
0.0020113599,
0.0113340793,
-0.0009227919,
0.0169237126,
-0.073134549,
-0.0122711081,
-0.0411745161,
-0.0250038598,
-0.0555220135,
0.0528109111,
0.0112676946,
-0.0247465596,
-0.0110590579,
0.0042618243,
0.0195381269,
-0.0196356662,
0.037900351,
0.0544322729,
-0.0173975024,
-0.015327584,
-0.0779007599,
0.0575986877,
-0.0255188774,
0.0234878808,
-0.0500537083,
0.0337720662,
0.025700558,
-0.0207252987,
0.0421828888,
-0.057377506,
0.016960701,
0.0600161999,
0.0147875939,
0.0023433026,
-0.0472001284,
-0.0138158156,
0.0109075699,
-0.0122641362,
-0.0058495882,
-0.0524618663,
0.02993205,
0.0232290551,
-0.0209085904,
-0.0266895816,
0.0185742024,
0.0322681144,
-0.0601962246,
0.0538457483,
-0.0533997901,
-0.0005495095,
0.0568114333,
-0.0160554629,
-0.0142848343,
0.0120196585,
0.0237616301,
-0.0009961314,
0.0674636811,
0.0005713454,
0.019215377,
0.0277274884,
0.0231979955,
0.0318390317,
0.040021766,
0.0774342865,
-0.0359673053,
0.0203037094,
0.0178862605,
0.0395291895,
-0.004917914,
-0.0428504124,
0.0396069251,
0.0461222827,
0.0370111465,
0.022804793,
0.0182214975,
0.0295521114,
0.0482182465,
0.0258249063,
0.0019501193,
0.0249845553,
-0.0659257993,
0.0070855655,
0.0117033385,
0.0281793252,
-0.0517088622,
-0.0077738278,
-0.0050864555,
0.0192079898,
0.0095956689,
0.0269187614,
0.0047177542,
0.0298697632,
-0.0477036349,
0.0670255572,
0.0050898055,
0.0075369021,
0.0311027858,
-0.037632823,
0.0463568084,
0.0390211418,
0.0318401903,
-0.0513229892,
-0.0496419109,
-0.0105056474,
-0.0496100225,
0.0016330247,
0.026921114,
-0.063608028,
-0.0391176082,
-0.0475338027,
-0.0112203658,
-0.0206533372,
-0.0196661036,
0.0006582321,
0.0062426007,
0.0622178167,
0.0195326712,
-0.1260650903,
-0.034088999,
0.0122534223,
0.0355531313,
-0.040103849,
0.0096981796,
0.0020552927,
-0.0260380004,
0.0197111573,
0.0130077945,
0.0116270036,
0.0040117702,
-0.0092844339,
-0.0290583447,
-0.032018058,
-0.0153194498,
-0.045646932,
0.0405667797,
-0.0059629194,
-0.0156760644,
0.0238707773,
-0.0416782349,
-0.0466991626,
-0.0054238574,
0.0111638065,
0.0198362488,
-0.0152559681,
-0.0308156107,
0.0291454941,
-0.0341708064,
-0.0544848777,
0.0992788374,
0.0287814699,
0.0049029402,
0.0238477122,
-0.0364541449,
0.0176090747,
-0.0336125009,
0.0128018567,
0.0116022369,
0.0277647693,
0.034514226,
0.0167209506,
0.0058393269,
-0.0582153425,
0.0060081645,
-0.0738483816,
0.0142360283,
-0.0143746901,
0.0466825627,
0.0116211232,
0.0265750047,
0.0239890683,
-0.0058958814,
-0.0657557845,
0.0134201432,
-0.0047046728,
0.0077140909,
0.0235893019,
0.0249361042,
0.0685511455,
-0.0582052432,
-0.0448544845,
-0.0077257846,
0.0776167437,
0.0157839954,
0.0232363418,
-0.0123366285,
0.0765132084,
-0.0665588826,
0.0092520565,
0.017691914,
-0.004234592,
-0.0250817966,
-0.0113922106,
0.0059057348,
0.0369856209,
0.0118100606,
-0.0380911008,
0.0021797041,
0.0142923091,
-0.049811177,
0.0143300463,
-0.0037372948,
0.0264855325,
0.0014085777,
-0.0027053808,
0.0171178263,
0.0085855033,
-0.0032597308,
-0.0496257879,
-0.0359164253,
0.0216551684,
-0.0119019337,
0.0377875492,
-0.0820383951,
-0.0204535089,
0.0358743407,
-0.009765109,
-0.0155963376,
0.0204235148,
0.0652748644,
0.0031935133,
0.0272483975,
-0.0561693236,
-0.0217233729,
-0.0792609528,
0.0390070006,
0.0128654316,
0.0003196851,
-0.0326057076,
-0.0235009901,
-0.057997264,
0.0001679461,
-0.0024392516,
-0.0331026465,
0.0198076125,
0.0191210322,
0.0433592945,
0.0039519412,
-0.00244142,
-0.0189598706,
-0.0050411369,
-0.041889295,
0.0085571669,
0.0019335347,
0.011411475,
0.0382002257,
0.0385324992,
0.0126284566,
0.0153064197,
-0.017675139,
0.0045525995,
-0.0227718726,
0.1061390862,
0.0712423772,
0.010742195,
-0.0034126346,
0.0064142309,
0.0075808424,
0.0131995631,
0.0146626877,
-0.0198375694,
-0.0031848252,
-0.026537437,
0.01288631,
-0.0927820057,
-0.0520576127,
-0.0170743298,
0.0222155247,
-0.0450988896,
0.0029459428,
0.0814505368,
0.0382470042,
-0.0186054371,
-0.0034442388,
0.0039248471,
0.0134038907,
0.001035966,
0.0590955503,
-0.075747937,
-0.0152136972,
-0.0429129526,
0.0346868746,
0.0150885945,
-0.0237109568,
0.0093738902,
-0.107905075,
-0.0099245086,
-0.0076089548,
-0.0275698956,
-0.0074414313,
-0.0222571697,
0.0189266354,
-0.020389853,
-0.0248596389,
-0.0070605176,
-0.0270251203,
0.0535002314,
0.0133259464,
0.0161563214,
0.0110804355,
0.0585541613,
-0.0251882561,
-0.0046290113,
0.0232653413,
0.0469751358,
-0.0163670443,
-0.001349202,
-0.0255275182,
-0.0400122851,
-0.029470522,
0.0158902928,
0.0496262945,
-0.0246978495,
0.0110287052,
-0.024733657,
0.0458616391,
-0.0227408819,
0.0182805303,
0.0159375444,
0.0910372287,
0.0117646344,
-0.0318686292,
-0.0194173101,
-0.0389581993,
0.0187498573,
0.0695611164,
0.0000861,
-0.024410231,
-0.0410782211,
-0.0356920734,
0.0064391014,
-0.0292075798,
-0.0767263249,
0.0158112813,
-0.0231527556,
0.0663301945,
-0.1051008925,
-0.0339561701,
0.0335482694,
0.0115937376,
-0.0100854328,
0.0456201471,
0.0375175364,
0.0124612469,
-0.0174344592,
0.0294019859,
-0.0224891249,
0.0230034869,
-0.0529531427,
-0.0262948666,
0.0392933041,
-0.0457458906,
-0.0312129203,
-0.0144954771,
-0.0292887595,
-0.0416288897,
-0.0365882032,
0.0513958,
0.0162167046,
0.000374599,
-0.0355795883,
-0.0253942925,
0.0764645338,
0.0239713099,
-0.0583846159,
0.001414757,
-0.0020197146,
0.022325838,
-0.0441234522,
0.0431746542,
-0.0930565223,
-0.0093708783,
-0.0220039934,
0.0447631255,
-0.0252857991,
-0.0930152088,
0.0176107958,
0.0364452265,
-0.0713638365,
0.0469533429,
0.0039371867,
-0.052891776,
0.0280817505,
-0.0034065715,
-0.0296647511,
-0.0260047875,
0.0132865291,
-0.0081821894,
-0.0294053722,
-0.0229761712,
-0.030608274,
0.0056751948,
0.0783780739,
-0.0259183887,
-0.02932062,
0.069160752,
0.0125336833,
0.0282410029,
-0.0247188732,
-0.0238139033,
0.0066067595,
0.0083183246,
0.0576789826,
-0.0201994628,
-0.0074475422,
0.0187141802,
-0.0406661965,
-0.052100867,
-0.0046951049,
-0.0808993429,
-0.0611480698,
-0.0413607582,
0.0576457046,
0.0187529065,
-0.0124513619,
0.0473386943,
0.0241725519,
-0.0442331769,
-0.0243729874,
-0.0143472468,
0.0319235176,
0.0330993645,
0.0333894379,
0.024766596,
-0.0086281849,
0.0767352879,
0.0605839007,
0.001315388,
0.0522501096,
0.0216573663,
-0.0443887115,
-0.0103698066,
-0.0084918663,
-0.020577807,
0.0413179994,
0.0126221636,
0.0150819793,
-0.0636889189,
-0.0513232574,
0.0457312204,
-0.0116829621,
-0.0238285623,
-0.0113840243,
0.0427533798,
0.0222203247,
0.0468454026,
-0.0122488383,
-0.0534903482,
0.0322022028,
-0.048759006,
-0.0319745876,
-0.0180899706,
-6.165033672e-33,
-0.0321153142,
-0.0482734889,
0.0076684845,
-0.0357373804,
-0.0027402216,
0.0116107389,
0.0244819187,
-0.0511105657,
-0.0487204045,
-0.0186907127,
-0.0270538833,
-0.0014775133,
-0.0197841581,
0.0299732424,
-0.0410084613,
-0.0101986602,
-0.0014748159,
-0.0149168288,
-0.0042066439,
0.0361535698,
0.0308783744,
0.0215605162,
0.0436814614,
-0.0331009626,
-0.0133505259,
-0.0605773702,
0.024497766,
-0.0042064069,
-0.0110612605,
0.0570865683,
-0.0345100276,
0.0401148163,
0.0290351156,
-0.0138299763,
0.0346131511,
-0.0000131528,
-0.0725853145,
-0.0499150977,
-0.0093814516,
-0.0273295492,
-0.0492502674,
-0.0450082794,
-0.003595443,
0.0055184988,
0.0771181509,
-0.0269402154,
0.0594825447,
0.0143456412,
-0.017740719,
-0.0040812707,
-0.0177025963,
0.0101187788,
-0.0139517589,
0.0000144719,
-0.0698717684,
0.0580623262,
-0.0181765743,
0.0054305061,
-0.0756019279,
-0.0067986981,
0.0360250324,
0.0101134228,
-0.0034944669,
-0.0277332682,
-0.0213389788,
0.0169563796,
-0.026198294,
-0.0223017149,
-0.0057434682,
-0.0005650918,
-0.0383110195,
0.0352778621,
0.0246498231,
0.0480854847,
0.0123693058,
0.0167857893,
-0.0828900635,
0.0452507548,
-0.0125223566,
-0.0056227157,
-0.045453012,
-0.0250106715,
-0.0167647433,
-0.0253151525,
-0.0674388856,
0.0012225751,
-0.044936873,
-0.0473765619,
0.0349679515,
-0.0277845562,
-0.0394372977,
-0.0131078307,
0.0259142164,
-0.0392330885,
-0.0158946067,
0.0515742563,
-0.0315839052,
0.0342178643,
0.0042100493,
0.0636023656,
-0.0735998973,
0.0267909709,
0.0319253281,
-0.0262339618,
-0.0079183877,
0.0276739337,
-0.0372865647,
0.0077149658,
-0.0180823058,
0.0190387219,
0.0008210641,
-0.0271620657,
-0.0313437879,
0.0188775677,
-0.0027403762,
0.0503216572,
0.0205007307,
0.0475563928,
0.0116805062,
0.0033884938,
-0.0197257418,
-0.0505988672,
0.0349026062,
0.0298571605,
-0.0239022691,
0.0266949534,
-0.0099215191,
0.0465341099,
-0.0315445252,
-0.0323759466,
-0.0030154164,
0.0003279196,
2.653e-7,
0.0556314625,
0.0109914057,
-0.0119430628,
0.062563993,
0.022144286,
0.0241171289,
0.0711348355,
0.071097672,
0.0386787802,
-0.0119507341,
0.0198822748,
0.021976158,
-0.0222186893,
0.0535304882,
-0.0539531,
-0.0228847545,
-0.0552878194,
-0.0134338131,
-0.0533183329,
-0.0683108568,
0.0509252548,
0.0661565661,
0.0287003927,
0.0003453947,
-0.0461739637,
-0.0673645362,
0.061743062,
0.024587512,
-0.0194214787,
0.0517480336,
0.0398395918,
0.0066189873,
-0.012752532,
0.0198523588,
-0.0175261516,
0.0168507937,
0.0765278935,
0.0124197463,
-0.0248589925,
-0.0438456871,
-0.02845327,
-0.0356538296,
0.0291407555,
-0.0272489171,
0.1083111614,
-0.0034149699,
0.0073248623,
0.0314683244,
-0.0439121425,
-0.0447144918,
0.0036886504,
-0.0239170771,
-0.0075622192,
0.0174554978,
-0.0010625041,
-0.0077817729,
-0.008254542,
-0.0486091115,
0.0092335884,
0.0062208707,
0.0122321285,
-0.0329957008,
0.0056940923,
-0.0257295463,
0.007553265,
-0.0492439307,
0.0435317047,
2.172044712e-34,
-0.0005159771,
-0.0035571035,
-0.0053430521,
0.0171900354,
0.0184812266,
-0.0143110994,
0.0054395339,
-0.0268833339,
0.040687453,
-0.0979380906,
-0.0059635141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06987v1 | Catastrophic Jailbreak of Open-source LLMs via Exploiting Generation | 2023-10-10T20:15:54 | 2023-10-10T20:15:54 | Yangsibo Huang, Samyak Gupta, Mengzhou Xia, Kai Li, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | The rapid progress in open-source large language models (LLMs) is
significantly advancing AI development. Extensive efforts have been made before
model release to align their behavior with human values, with the primary goal
of ensuring their helpfulness and harmlessness. However, even carefully aligned
models can be manipulated maliciously, leading to unintended behaviors, known
as "jailbreaks". These jailbreaks are typically triggered by specific text
inputs, often referred to as adversarial prompts. In this work, we propose the
generation exploitation attack, an extremely simple approach that disrupts
model alignment by only manipulating variations of decoding methods. By
exploiting different generation strategies, including varying decoding
hyper-parameters and sampling methods, we increase the misalignment rate from
0% to more than 95% across 11 language models including LLaMA2, Vicuna, Falcon,
and MPT families, outperforming state-of-the-art attacks with $30\times$ lower
computational cost. Finally, we propose an effective alignment method that
explores diverse generation strategies, which can reasonably reduce the
misalignment rate under our attack. Altogether, our study underscores a major
failure in current safety evaluation and alignment procedures for open-source
LLMs, strongly advocating for more comprehensive red teaming and better
alignment before releasing such models. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Princeton-SysML/Jailbreak_LLM. | [
-0.006613994,
0.0894856155,
-0.0171372425,
0.0643951148,
-0.0261993594,
-0.0103840623,
-0.0100395475,
-0.0268393327,
0.0109790526,
-0.0142626669,
-0.0168940034,
-0.0189476442,
0.0320551395,
0.0162189119,
0.0393958353,
0.0251307096,
0.0646354705,
-0.038844455,
-0.0367328711,
-0.0022283704,
-0.0121139055,
0.0118073532,
0.0103299618,
0.031832099,
0.030778842,
-0.0442941263,
-0.0482680723,
0.025179537,
0.035549853,
-0.0230284352,
-0.008993418,
0.0211191848,
-0.0262086708,
0.0877238736,
0.0000021401,
-0.031486474,
-0.038674403,
0.0323304906,
-0.0261647291,
0.0503320731,
0.0142255062,
-0.0571518056,
-0.0566779859,
0.0272690114,
-0.0301949196,
0.0216818396,
0.0441177823,
0.0142324567,
0.0614551008,
0.0884738043,
0.014039739,
-0.0033415861,
0.0733067617,
-0.0169343539,
-0.0083989846,
-0.0619900487,
0.0068606404,
-0.0311988536,
-0.0272245053,
0.0066945888,
0.0021367539,
0.0123977764,
0.012227078,
0.0061190971,
-0.0529818162,
0.0200278591,
-0.0302047096,
-0.0461065136,
-0.0222962815,
0.062934041,
-0.0501866601,
-0.0231259409,
0.0063292491,
-0.003573738,
0.011414133,
-0.0178076662,
0.0066472967,
0.0555932112,
0.0026723123,
0.0397275127,
0.0572961792,
-0.043156147,
0.0577145703,
-0.0254047513,
-0.005824463,
0.0652695447,
0.0328486189,
-0.0391549356,
-0.0129931858,
-0.0250700023,
-0.0117819356,
-0.0597314164,
-0.0426125973,
-0.0004186752,
0.002084685,
0.0348960236,
-0.1030588821,
-0.0430159904,
0.0329839364,
-0.0535595641,
0.030107351,
0.0465405993,
0.0046467548,
0.0029518064,
-0.0111378254,
0.0344919786,
-0.0569356941,
0.0559490919,
-0.0168589912,
0.0312283896,
0.0422132872,
-0.0061054933,
0.0207965281,
-0.0037441992,
-0.0239855554,
0.0163211878,
-0.0185586065,
0.0453311652,
0.0019882408,
0.0638483241,
-0.0285103116,
-0.0007306952,
-0.0158128887,
0.0016441438,
0.0316114239,
-0.012985778,
0.0083501199,
-0.0290498734,
0.0013150624,
-0.097738117,
-0.0360396132,
0.0225070976,
-0.079195112,
-0.0361008346,
-0.0201757103,
0.1055613533,
0.0086413519,
-0.0054068943,
-0.06360282,
-0.0470327884,
-0.028326733,
-0.0434004478,
0.0095542464,
-0.064475365,
-0.0041589369,
-0.0045929938,
-0.0289395861,
-0.0816478208,
0.031153027,
0.0068624201,
-0.0518000573,
0.0579992905,
-0.0332053006,
-0.0037373626,
0.0055042007,
0.0113365911,
0.019278625,
0.0854415596,
0.0384914018,
0.0466045104,
0.0399542935,
-0.0087344581,
0.0277183894,
0.0752298087,
0.0124801975,
0.0354522094,
-0.0226974785,
-0.0081389975,
0.0418032594,
0.0339739285,
0.0195523407,
0.0470634587,
0.011291285,
-0.042824436,
0.064089492,
0.0314413048,
-0.0366946794,
0.0506862067,
-0.0119070271,
-0.0188919306,
0.0016006993,
0.0074441801,
-0.0779757276,
0.0013091507,
-0.0925948173,
0.0039584003,
-0.0013061051,
0.0699450374,
-0.0054293089,
-0.0225123838,
-0.0202713553,
-0.035653878,
-0.0227576829,
-0.0139458366,
0.0170577262,
-0.0033935201,
-0.0359033681,
0.0577562153,
0.0152466735,
-0.0693833902,
-0.0384540893,
-0.0547788888,
0.0202511661,
0.0350540318,
0.0605658367,
-0.0252637248,
-0.0372469984,
0.0074199443,
-0.0442421995,
0.0236088168,
0.0231452044,
0.0263207257,
0.014399197,
-0.0377714969,
-0.0119456183,
-0.0183550026,
0.0109078772,
0.0265530329,
0.0052402848,
0.0014769633,
-0.0145583283,
-0.0269792676,
-0.0401773974,
0.0425235555,
-0.023695901,
-0.0382320434,
-0.0157539714,
0.0257825926,
0.0211480893,
0.0129238386,
-0.0354000591,
0.0275012515,
0.0626511574,
-0.0124237863,
0.018656075,
0.0106124869,
-0.0281566698,
-0.0189233664,
0.060046576,
-0.0175618269,
-0.0240183268,
0.0699649155,
-0.0538171977,
-0.0152838659,
0.0437518246,
-0.0135967648,
0.0234964546,
0.0099493396,
0.0482267067,
-0.0091675567,
0.0332193896,
-0.0394314602,
0.0352745913,
-0.0436594896,
-0.0082479352,
-0.0021875524,
0.0120542385,
0.025105197,
-0.0324939899,
-0.0572845675,
0.0313602723,
-0.0132452678,
0.0224555973,
-0.012135434,
0.0202337783,
-0.0034127906,
-0.0540081635,
-0.0295858458,
0.0113660693,
-0.0194192082,
0.0486922711,
0.0344734751,
-0.0072041047,
-0.034639243,
0.0090440456,
-0.0220348667,
-0.0093128486,
-0.0068980884,
-0.0186157022,
0.0322990082,
-0.0271824114,
-0.0636221096,
-0.0369866006,
-0.0042396146,
-0.0181955621,
0.0433856398,
-0.0113308663,
-0.00342641,
-0.0694818199,
0.0354447179,
-0.0040745572,
0.0466488414,
-0.0108050909,
-0.0545797423,
0.0265662391,
0.0044869366,
-0.0108986627,
0.0956168845,
-0.0120278466,
0.0541092642,
0.0702290237,
0.0501750521,
-0.0399813503,
-0.0115949577,
0.0430185981,
-0.060246665,
-0.0461555235,
-0.0403632708,
0.0157051552,
0.0689842626,
0.007868574,
-0.0062541235,
-0.0432752557,
0.0116469702,
0.0282413568,
-0.0312520601,
0.0362561792,
-0.0126876486,
-0.0498433672,
0.014092722,
-0.0261145923,
-0.0904975832,
0.0383532755,
-0.0809385329,
0.0114801927,
-0.0166230518,
-0.0248037726,
-0.0177318398,
0.0323659293,
-0.0100056641,
0.0360542908,
0.0367183015,
-0.0163215622,
-0.0505639352,
0.017609261,
0.0115372557,
-0.036214307,
0.0584293529,
-0.039985396,
-0.0046331012,
-0.040958792,
-0.0375926606,
-0.0502913259,
-0.0377946831,
-0.0065840683,
-0.0193261988,
0.0198843181,
-0.0391581096,
-0.0215786919,
-0.0531717874,
0.0296346731,
-0.0160146523,
-0.0147862984,
0.0195144154,
-0.040827103,
0.0154907573,
0.0465570986,
-0.0240314994,
0.0190966092,
-0.031488806,
0.0262545459,
0.0739715174,
0.0426275879,
0.0386069901,
-0.0413301438,
-0.0147853214,
0.0564701557,
0.003986239,
-0.0073720645,
0.028469963,
0.0486773998,
-0.0145492703,
0.0142478151,
0.0582615435,
0.0208748449,
-0.0175624657,
0.0376835987,
-0.0148531515,
0.069546409,
0.02545828,
0.027646929,
-0.0792208016,
-0.0165576972,
0.0310137961,
0.0741303414,
-0.003904925,
-0.0138466787,
-0.012822629,
-0.1430042982,
0.0021065965,
0.0430305935,
-0.0288610272,
-0.0292719118,
0.0026685763,
-0.0252822116,
-0.0060359626,
0.0621305481,
0.0275316946,
0.020168148,
-0.0020783979,
0.011005979,
-0.0051895115,
-0.0289731491,
-0.0162555389,
-0.0272513181,
0.095783323,
0.0914133862,
0.0015884736,
-0.0184490588,
-0.0168423466,
0.0344697647,
0.0203868076,
-0.0060195411,
0.018594915,
0.0060538119,
0.0108008608,
-0.0254155323,
0.0236486327,
0.0309991743,
-0.0380067006,
-0.0115148285,
0.0157037228,
0.0437389389,
-0.0051609268,
-0.0059651989,
-0.016021857,
-0.0342210382,
0.0112691093,
0.0563176312,
0.0155747794,
-0.0180246551,
-0.0443392806,
-0.0704444423,
-0.0006463234,
-0.0455168188,
-0.0337043554,
0.0462432802,
0.0167996269,
-0.0374149308,
-0.0491601974,
-0.0172173996,
-0.0245320685,
0.0245770197,
0.0328686163,
-0.0245170854,
-0.0114111342,
-0.0148477862,
-0.0348758511,
-0.0036394084,
-0.0112643829,
0.0439555608,
-0.0619753599,
0.0176786166,
-0.0039415173,
-0.0181814414,
0.0029445973,
0.0261435136,
-0.0636763424,
-0.1176846921,
0.0163770393,
0.074482657,
0.0223428588,
0.0220297929,
-0.0215154793,
-0.0455461144,
0.0371822603,
0.0589501262,
-0.0046378048,
0.0509909205,
0.0502269007,
-0.0191345289,
0.0073083676,
0.0304766539,
-0.0306768622,
-0.035109736,
0.065114826,
0.0103075067,
-0.0398169495,
-0.019240601,
0.0173338763,
0.0579579584,
0.0164823122,
-0.0498753116,
0.0217067674,
0.0099051697,
0.0353504233,
-0.0144180972,
-0.0100758504,
-0.0153894182,
0.007545853,
0.0211019646,
-0.0336761698,
0.0464980491,
0.0074713416,
0.0023434025,
0.0255622398,
-0.0097569963,
0.0327316001,
-0.000694057,
0.0683673397,
0.0636689365,
0.0239926986,
-0.0155591881,
0.0648695081,
-0.0272320341,
0.0397339426,
0.002777101,
0.0362596363,
-0.0051589226,
0.0147232329,
-0.0081291143,
0.0609546714,
-0.0452339537,
-0.0604759939,
-0.0150248213,
0.0475073494,
0.0515212044,
0.0326709561,
0.0502930507,
-0.0060388376,
0.0112628425,
-0.033168897,
0.0106211687,
-0.019209357,
-0.0424817987,
0.0153051298,
-0.004192268,
-0.0238239635,
-0.0042230128,
0.0712480322,
0.0063534896,
0.0646230355,
-0.0072951727,
0.0131579898,
-0.0194241032,
-0.0309069715,
0.043529395,
-0.0387912691,
-0.0519975983,
-0.0608330406,
-0.0499687307,
-0.0742356852,
0.0043258891,
0.0409371182,
0.0174296666,
0.003542268,
-0.0126893893,
0.0419300795,
-0.0215705894,
0.0308914799,
-0.0416299999,
-0.010032393,
-0.018690899,
-0.0575022399,
0.0084507931,
-6.284164882e-33,
-0.0021793661,
0.0029232327,
-0.0300565455,
-0.0279974826,
-0.0149473259,
-0.0158371851,
-0.0321760885,
0.0179867893,
-0.025448693,
-0.0446293093,
-0.0152336275,
-0.0111870272,
0.0006997461,
0.0022607723,
-0.0078845639,
-0.0289193988,
-0.0039393161,
-0.0063174241,
-0.0408879519,
-0.0036476348,
0.0446556918,
0.0085786134,
0.0452328287,
-0.0548215397,
0.0259254947,
-0.0277022626,
-0.0434540547,
0.0213705711,
-0.0588277318,
0.0504890643,
0.0161251295,
0.0196918957,
-0.0126126455,
0.0014417781,
0.0037688694,
0.0328468569,
0.0080300905,
0.0018061113,
0.0157295968,
0.0181914065,
-0.0174267702,
-0.0845081061,
0.0486722179,
0.0098576816,
-0.0389562137,
0.0074147149,
-0.0008572344,
-0.0171172787,
-0.0203774348,
0.0037211217,
-0.0358305797,
0.011006658,
-0.0407180339,
-0.007159133,
-0.0002661616,
-0.0263687391,
0.0275416765,
0.0100198928,
-0.0283098314,
0.0158228334,
0.0398484506,
0.0162851419,
0.1152066812,
0.0035863807,
0.0023773438,
0.0649293661,
0.0202213265,
-0.0309549216,
-0.0283698943,
0.0003380576,
0.0044091674,
0.0406359062,
0.0218879618,
0.0704203174,
0.0272647478,
-0.0289111026,
-0.0616756491,
0.0302203838,
0.0143154832,
0.0068985824,
0.0000858965,
0.012722007,
-0.0654883832,
0.0095300488,
-0.0183176119,
-0.0591559857,
-0.0252553318,
-0.0309607275,
0.0247835312,
-0.0118227657,
-0.0310785547,
-0.0492545553,
0.0082065053,
-0.0531129204,
0.0158728585,
0.0174262077,
-0.0256265234,
-0.0007732876,
-0.0278506987,
0.0304889642,
-0.0063374653,
-0.0254301373,
-0.0077382713,
-0.0508454703,
0.0535816103,
0.028165061,
0.0172271859,
0.0321188644,
-0.0552398972,
0.0207338929,
-0.0313868634,
0.0237067845,
0.0316118337,
0.0139542511,
0.0476409532,
-0.0462127365,
0.0034671023,
0.0015183707,
0.0319147371,
0.0437692031,
-0.0595913678,
0.01559301,
-0.020421708,
0.0149215572,
-0.011074896,
0.0108190347,
0.0027329328,
0.0374598913,
0.0522268973,
-0.0681942999,
-0.0215206873,
-0.0071336604,
2.897e-7,
0.0226846617,
0.0269150138,
0.0612476915,
0.010569118,
0.0092652868,
0.073167257,
-0.0435349196,
0.0785581023,
-0.0294224732,
-0.0198764093,
-0.0310558733,
-0.0053552007,
0.0706454217,
0.0367885605,
-0.0414606035,
0.0531193912,
-0.0573928617,
0.0275199544,
-0.0676039904,
-0.0094778659,
0.0268031005,
0.0984581038,
-0.0154500436,
-0.0269215759,
0.0010256694,
-0.037781015,
0.0036539198,
-0.0103708059,
-0.0163214281,
0.0157792084,
-0.0007855634,
0.0044601369,
-0.026846962,
-0.0165231749,
-0.0130972257,
-0.0140990997,
-0.0271747094,
0.0557013154,
-0.003225669,
-0.0428271741,
-0.012477302,
-0.0373011902,
-0.0238393787,
-0.0267282203,
0.0554369129,
0.0347732678,
-0.0263400562,
-0.0377755053,
0.0028372237,
-0.0093557294,
0.0132176178,
-0.0319567546,
0.0362535305,
0.0173362531,
0.0054226248,
-0.0067010056,
-0.0010990411,
-0.0447507016,
-0.0420047864,
-0.0282595791,
-0.0199622288,
-0.0595000014,
-0.014846771,
0.0354781076,
0.0331259556,
-0.0248259269,
0.0017296515,
2.946163073e-34,
-0.0217492711,
-0.0519125201,
0.0288117807,
0.0337168761,
0.0143856648,
-0.0151742995,
0.0175048169,
0.0249537043,
-0.0058256467,
-0.0381640159,
-0.0310376212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06983v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06983v1 | Violation of Expectation via Metacognitive Prompting Reduces Theory of Mind Prediction Error in Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T20:05:13 | 2023-10-10T20:05:13 | Courtland Leer, Vincent Trost, Vineeth Voruganti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent research shows that Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit a compelling
level of proficiency in Theory of Mind (ToM) tasks. This ability to impute
unobservable mental states to others is vital to human social cognition and may
prove equally important in principal-agent relations between individual humans
and Artificial Intelligences (AIs). In this paper, we explore how a mechanism
studied in developmental psychology known as Violation of Expectation (VoE) can
be implemented to reduce errors in LLM prediction about users by leveraging
emergent ToM affordances. And we introduce a \textit{metacognitive prompting}
framework to apply VoE in the context of an AI tutor. By storing and retrieving
facts derived in cases where LLM expectation about the user was violated, we
find that LLMs are able to learn about users in ways that echo theories of
human learning. Finally, we discuss latent hazards and augmentative
opportunities associated with modeling user psychology and propose ways to
mitigate risk along with possible directions for future inquiry. | [
0.0587852038,
0.0339134559,
-0.0667511374,
0.0578587689,
-0.016857041,
0.0078024142,
0.0132987732,
-0.0402780212,
0.0440653078,
0.0004069493,
-0.0248190667,
-0.0206204411,
0.0005735872,
0.0175344348,
0.0397820175,
-0.0521646142,
0.0165149309,
-0.0258286539,
0.0042226282,
-0.0175650027,
-0.0205740966,
0.0083733313,
-0.008857484,
0.0374862887,
-0.0036472159,
-0.0143325673,
-0.0371110104,
-0.0277591329,
0.0160358809,
-0.038247671,
-0.0057640839,
0.0212261584,
-0.0094544543,
0.0231258217,
0.0000020935,
-0.0722238719,
-0.0017711256,
-0.027139917,
-0.0161191784,
-0.0528644174,
0.0122302817,
0.0320016742,
0.022733314,
-0.0245396402,
-0.0747293159,
0.0159397572,
0.0177670494,
0.0425775237,
0.0028441281,
0.0278252121,
-0.0047530131,
0.0351070054,
0.0113477251,
0.0160477627,
0.085532926,
-0.0723180622,
0.0113764871,
-0.0432678238,
-0.0140613532,
-0.0339855365,
-0.0374083295,
-0.0014716521,
0.0074233385,
-0.0077191582,
0.0236984212,
0.0065799509,
0.0409701951,
-0.0449148975,
-0.0426243506,
0.052919507,
0.1000375897,
-0.0088542216,
-0.0019311135,
0.0178530756,
0.0642363578,
0.0962628648,
-0.009102664,
0.0187389068,
-0.0095026577,
-0.0024155464,
0.012913893,
0.014874748,
0.0029924228,
0.038796097,
0.0205085091,
0.0704418421,
-0.0225820057,
-0.0350403897,
-0.0015506862,
0.0142483441,
-0.0220917407,
-0.0443358459,
-0.0392041393,
0.0152029656,
-0.0230468959,
0.0117366239,
-0.0523628592,
-0.0261786114,
-0.0202568248,
0.0350041352,
0.0978412181,
0.0509161539,
-0.0097491601,
0.0323304646,
0.0161197074,
0.0411639288,
-0.0220004432,
0.0013114396,
-0.0228941198,
0.0314388648,
-0.0487158038,
-0.0126501508,
-0.0158074144,
0.056723278,
0.0348202549,
0.0086778803,
0.020121403,
0.0085989637,
-0.0570337959,
0.0224036407,
-0.0440855883,
-0.0011868353,
-0.0191378333,
-0.0060154656,
-0.0650348291,
-0.0024341652,
-0.037742354,
0.0154872146,
0.0179244168,
-0.0573521703,
-0.0387911722,
-0.0268032793,
0.0135346027,
0.0134439813,
-0.016760394,
0.0407709926,
0.0109095275,
-0.0542099513,
-0.0053448365,
-0.0410340801,
0.0122244237,
-0.0354137868,
0.0266368892,
-0.0237886384,
0.0052712942,
-0.0016879543,
-0.0030849017,
-0.0357258245,
0.0160754435,
-0.0074612889,
-0.0409626365,
0.0660625622,
-0.0022753468,
0.0016951197,
-0.0126148239,
0.0251591839,
-0.0391151942,
0.0287877023,
0.009493758,
-0.0125262886,
0.005799436,
0.0310736243,
0.0520105921,
0.0050775316,
0.037867412,
-0.0191268492,
0.02808607,
-0.030630013,
0.0301493108,
0.0090128426,
0.025296649,
0.0098256571,
-0.0177934151,
0.0198502671,
0.0589306206,
0.0743724331,
-0.094249852,
0.0197389908,
0.0453504957,
0.0066970722,
0.0019952341,
0.0620804913,
-0.0857943818,
0.0309930556,
-0.0523674339,
-0.0458167903,
0.0037515343,
0.0123569639,
-0.0373733677,
-0.0108862463,
0.0199920479,
0.0038773022,
0.0181210954,
0.0069574374,
0.003935467,
0.0127541469,
0.0128845898,
-0.0063869166,
0.0291354358,
-0.0565768592,
0.0097404988,
-0.0911425054,
-0.0025519615,
0.0528051592,
0.0237540342,
-0.0515543632,
-0.0174792688,
0.0102044633,
-0.0048220973,
0.0527753867,
0.0603615418,
-0.0069056042,
-0.0265813507,
0.0174487773,
0.0023523653,
-0.0059792348,
0.0218043979,
0.0154632041,
-0.0180845466,
-0.0086489925,
-0.0142590962,
-0.0387723893,
-0.0072613838,
0.0235685129,
-0.0357076339,
-0.0477712937,
-0.087327905,
0.0451533981,
0.0208758619,
-0.0005274512,
0.0282233339,
-0.007489996,
0.0282160901,
0.0164646022,
-0.0235036593,
0.0422681272,
-0.0593568571,
-0.0247432441,
0.0239711516,
-0.0332584716,
-0.0482627712,
0.0310242381,
-0.0017768493,
-0.0411469005,
0.0631582737,
-0.0255508833,
0.0755966455,
-0.0051388131,
0.0265133735,
-0.0342151113,
-0.0108404821,
0.0318964422,
0.0410292596,
-0.0505198501,
-0.0089825941,
0.0145719619,
-0.0526911095,
-0.0187228378,
-0.0092366505,
-0.030584354,
-0.0321407057,
0.0111529753,
0.0016345044,
-0.0109646283,
-0.0215043668,
-0.0663151219,
-0.0137007022,
-0.0757943839,
-0.0520678423,
0.0155733312,
0.0034260158,
-0.009034628,
-0.0115448991,
-0.0156944133,
0.0010455204,
-0.022805782,
0.0353622176,
0.0105473557,
0.0099522276,
0.0305892862,
0.0124230841,
-0.0228549484,
-0.0108382069,
0.0316970311,
-0.0536853336,
0.0390800014,
0.0009897834,
0.0058321119,
-0.0146189509,
0.0148910731,
-0.0394597091,
0.0603271909,
-0.0387135409,
-0.0247977506,
0.0152557604,
0.0118319681,
0.0287099611,
0.086961925,
-0.0076662414,
0.0544546433,
0.061494939,
0.0045640841,
-0.0511666723,
0.0256721117,
0.039879445,
-0.0382291675,
-0.0245618653,
-0.0498123094,
-0.0205245148,
0.0539601482,
0.0309207123,
-0.0122700427,
-0.0804821625,
0.0881524757,
-0.0102787055,
-0.0707658678,
0.0448544659,
-0.0318497308,
-0.0068581724,
0.0524402112,
0.0017737062,
-0.0411863811,
0.1203149632,
0.0066151889,
-0.0090471217,
0.0223052111,
0.0367040262,
0.0116725778,
0.0434964001,
0.0188701041,
0.0328823775,
0.0353412628,
0.0067901141,
-0.0973877907,
-0.0149739226,
0.0087904641,
-0.0279683191,
-0.0049131298,
-0.0580236502,
-0.02803877,
0.0217319019,
-0.0213594753,
-0.0543320365,
0.0041082422,
-0.042421408,
-0.0274004042,
-0.0385794081,
-0.0081825443,
-0.0195420217,
-0.083046481,
0.0331361592,
-0.0318413042,
-0.0110327052,
-0.0383172072,
-0.0162832942,
-0.0321416296,
0.0312558897,
-0.0009246633,
0.0262216181,
-0.0310948994,
0.0724536926,
0.0454302356,
0.0410233587,
0.0306501035,
0.0194552746,
0.0005968454,
0.0272463672,
0.033008527,
-0.0218840744,
0.0498441048,
0.0651643351,
-0.0134083126,
-0.0080922572,
0.0935167298,
0.0317372382,
-0.0290165264,
0.0055583748,
-0.0553417429,
0.0119388187,
0.0184992962,
0.0116455965,
-0.0639468357,
-0.0003534813,
-0.0035905985,
0.0248817615,
-0.0638376698,
-0.0837195441,
-0.0073315795,
-0.0793814361,
0.0085152788,
-0.0069505433,
0.0112755839,
0.0025799219,
-0.010329579,
0.0316289812,
0.0285064038,
-0.0060041049,
0.0100892382,
-0.001143866,
0.0438358672,
-0.0053249868,
0.018273836,
-0.0394263752,
0.0308072437,
-0.0250597503,
0.0865295827,
0.0227887332,
0.0365388729,
-0.0018502047,
-0.0476249605,
-0.019735055,
0.0394582078,
0.0271355174,
-0.0107432604,
0.037098363,
-0.0340038314,
0.0173622314,
-0.0214862376,
0.0600953922,
-0.0000953015,
-0.0188848656,
0.018497942,
0.1207531095,
-0.029890744,
-0.0138266785,
0.0187292304,
0.0121414941,
0.0087255351,
0.0634047836,
0.0240581576,
-0.0726993755,
0.0335481055,
-0.0161504801,
-0.0094047906,
0.0663768277,
-0.0391590334,
0.0336672254,
0.044272244,
-0.03513515,
-0.0519574471,
-0.053734567,
0.0179491695,
0.0019553043,
0.0404412597,
-0.0213516075,
0.0146114836,
0.0193732008,
-0.0087967785,
0.0094362702,
-0.0494713746,
-0.0301560685,
-0.0221218355,
-0.0101567479,
0.01044551,
-0.0924411863,
0.0275023244,
-0.023957042,
0.0115269125,
-0.0576340668,
0.0046469634,
0.0768432617,
0.0304985177,
0.0472435169,
0.0182251427,
-0.0340815187,
0.0476056002,
0.0025379614,
-0.0070971693,
0.0445310324,
0.0402957648,
0.048095841,
0.0074815927,
0.0692175329,
-0.0191137828,
-0.015720237,
0.0224748608,
-0.0178157501,
0.0040759081,
-0.0091563845,
0.0443842225,
0.0221675988,
0.06702362,
-0.0126827946,
0.0343843251,
-0.0202012006,
-0.0176420361,
-0.0013919844,
-0.0355929621,
-0.0270908698,
-0.0265384428,
0.0342160948,
0.0592243932,
0.0101442961,
-0.0717505068,
-0.0217519607,
0.0033394205,
0.0053415298,
0.0311134588,
0.010872798,
0.0465804897,
0.0192948394,
0.0267564021,
0.0060938611,
-0.004581973,
-0.0044243443,
0.0236290414,
0.0164784882,
0.1224492863,
0.0421736948,
-0.0223345309,
-0.018769512,
0.0232240651,
-0.0609926432,
-0.061971467,
0.0297544282,
0.017273495,
-0.0207050443,
-0.0059179645,
-0.0236659069,
-0.0582107715,
0.0416183583,
0.0310108941,
0.0143529857,
0.015026846,
-0.0622249842,
0.0096634934,
-0.0141894724,
0.002411559,
0.0198601745,
0.0395434462,
-0.0740247071,
0.0581446066,
-0.0258312039,
0.0018872183,
-0.0341097042,
0.0208079945,
0.0274228714,
0.0274778996,
-0.0185474958,
0.027787203,
-0.096445106,
-0.03157207,
0.0039903596,
0.0271995161,
-0.0049082534,
-0.0559474267,
0.027010683,
0.0500864238,
-0.0155457053,
-0.04759546,
-0.0069996254,
-0.0036992826,
-0.0213144012,
-0.0000111997,
-0.0275553316,
-6.179806697e-33,
-0.0368764773,
-0.0430639572,
-0.0028762494,
0.0717041641,
-0.0046842173,
-0.0267818645,
-0.0410847068,
0.0267768223,
-0.0155148208,
0.0014461227,
-0.0333497487,
0.0091437614,
-0.0089212535,
-0.0073974421,
0.0319868401,
-0.0007218362,
0.0243871305,
-0.0276625399,
-0.0353375599,
-0.0014435062,
0.0074400399,
-0.0153918155,
0.0200419854,
-0.0509122722,
0.0579118021,
-0.0076180277,
0.0032770832,
0.0237919018,
-0.0340075456,
-0.0140929306,
-0.0216398221,
0.0458468534,
0.0210040919,
-0.0024782224,
-0.0053679897,
0.022883134,
0.0014791066,
-0.0753668696,
0.0340195559,
-0.0263817236,
-0.0200845879,
-0.0365619436,
-0.0359642655,
-0.0243622307,
-0.0521455444,
0.0327156149,
0.0405827463,
0.0108098434,
0.0572794378,
0.0507811531,
-0.0505898073,
-0.0601833761,
-0.0113257188,
-0.0327776857,
0.0343713798,
0.010821675,
-0.0000513705,
-0.069794789,
-0.0276481733,
0.0505337901,
0.0133471573,
-0.0284216553,
0.0526607744,
-0.0021504604,
0.0091670984,
0.0625682622,
0.0739044547,
0.0414206758,
-0.020599531,
-0.0280848313,
0.0290950779,
0.0118583916,
0.014070753,
0.0233296603,
-0.024235921,
-0.0223741345,
0.008732046,
0.0268303212,
0.0261836257,
0.0215191338,
0.0194483642,
-0.017492421,
-0.0446787514,
-0.0179092884,
-0.0538046174,
-0.0624281131,
-0.0186189655,
-0.0021227251,
-0.0004059839,
-0.0130982921,
-0.0268653333,
-0.062099468,
-0.0016204093,
-0.050640773,
-0.0056102262,
-0.025356641,
0.006325501,
0.0210210662,
-0.023076389,
0.0104251625,
-0.028533943,
-0.050564263,
-0.0104978569,
-0.0148623278,
0.042922359,
0.0342483222,
0.0174996462,
0.0208683908,
-0.0327581577,
-0.0121230558,
-0.0457732826,
0.0288611259,
0.0371082388,
-0.0739784017,
0.0329307131,
-0.0035999396,
-0.0308477096,
-0.0367018655,
0.0276858639,
-0.0077970191,
-0.0946135819,
0.0476644784,
-0.0537971966,
-0.0292923711,
-0.0613488033,
-0.0080783218,
-0.0411687046,
0.0149108134,
0.0360834412,
-0.0415271632,
-0.0062693767,
-0.0068279319,
3.014e-7,
-0.04595479,
0.0594304204,
-0.0259084832,
-0.0337335169,
0.0254369453,
0.0728860572,
-0.0347284935,
0.0441913418,
0.0277605895,
-0.0440755896,
0.0023653086,
0.0253528506,
0.0388231426,
0.0254511926,
-0.0571256503,
0.0091413576,
0.0449849367,
-0.0333286561,
-0.0055383476,
0.0282651763,
0.0347838104,
0.0029672249,
0.0504290685,
0.0036899436,
-0.0032091865,
0.0083323643,
0.0171182044,
-0.0278436728,
0.0376787558,
-0.0227533802,
0.0130688809,
0.011800589,
0.0248329975,
0.0798094645,
0.0191786028,
0.0447115935,
-0.0508974083,
-0.0057211895,
-0.0150801949,
0.013424322,
-0.0137164928,
0.0146882739,
-0.0239198711,
-0.0263861381,
0.0191154238,
-0.0590228178,
-0.0362093523,
0.0418822765,
0.0117740501,
-0.0047238604,
-0.0318757854,
0.0171401072,
-0.0216879863,
0.0146998847,
-0.0072803944,
-0.0081456164,
0.033478193,
-0.0414430313,
0.0051382217,
-0.0092031723,
0.0030370448,
-0.0986627415,
0.0043937424,
0.0130343856,
0.0013936831,
-0.0903241932,
0.0166590959,
2.402285714e-34,
-0.0296938289,
-0.003625246,
0.0576756783,
-0.0342814326,
0.0529604889,
-0.0248395167,
-0.0168265067,
0.0301103629,
0.0755609125,
-0.0727555454,
-0.0276710596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06977v1 | Why bother with geometry? On the relevance of linear decompositions of Transformer embeddings | 2023-10-10T19:56:10 | 2023-10-10T19:56:10 | Timothee Mickus, Raúl Vázquez | cs.CL | cs.CL | A recent body of work has demonstrated that Transformer embeddings can be
linearly decomposed into well-defined sums of factors, that can in turn be
related to specific network inputs or components. There is however still a
dearth of work studying whether these mathematical reformulations are
empirically meaningful. In the present work, we study representations from
machine-translation decoders using two of such embedding decomposition methods.
Our results indicate that, while decomposition-derived indicators effectively
correlate with model performance, variation across different runs suggests a
more nuanced take on this question. The high variability of our measurements
indicate that geometry reflects model-specific characteristics more than it
does sentence-specific computations, and that similar training conditions do
not guarantee similar vector spaces. | [
-0.0373924561,
0.049667418,
-0.0099205384,
0.0696272776,
-0.0019624776,
0.0441553667,
0.025924664,
-0.020631548,
-0.0650813878,
-0.0232520103,
-0.0250187926,
0.0001623439,
0.0487613045,
-0.0021330682,
0.0350083187,
-0.0490972772,
-0.0162229426,
0.0132192858,
-0.0516647622,
0.0039373925,
-0.0182099659,
-0.0017371729,
0.0100547895,
0.078056328,
0.0257824231,
0.0011372801,
-0.005245069,
-0.01608756,
0.0217093229,
0.0263272077,
-0.0408356898,
0.0097316941,
0.0415297225,
0.0700873509,
0.0000016718,
0.0308309384,
-0.0142477304,
-0.0031253102,
-0.017717788,
0.0300522503,
0.0175400991,
-0.1006933898,
-0.0435258597,
-0.0090310937,
-0.0182554591,
-0.0655465871,
0.0507830866,
0.0390700437,
0.0150916167,
0.0705042705,
-0.0239135977,
-0.0572209321,
0.0082705235,
-0.0234857015,
-0.0261430722,
0.0016776132,
-0.029038107,
-0.0359183401,
-0.0762859434,
0.0179555658,
-0.0689208433,
0.054426413,
0.0602097698,
0.0416241027,
0.0008225284,
0.0364458263,
-0.0304039121,
0.014874313,
0.0009760368,
0.0290039536,
-0.0229583904,
-0.0051920903,
-0.0447138846,
0.0154788271,
-0.0002330658,
-0.0143448338,
-0.0399436057,
0.0105805919,
0.0282588433,
0.0342026837,
-0.0259608254,
0.0388274714,
0.0382875986,
-0.0485918373,
-0.0665835664,
-0.0146904225,
0.0359013379,
-0.0498713702,
-0.0397436284,
0.0480074957,
-0.0028960991,
0.0309309438,
0.0049514771,
-0.013548349,
0.0497579239,
-0.0080656633,
0.0098719709,
-0.0470961295,
-0.0249216706,
-0.0236309841,
0.0670691431,
0.0670053065,
0.0069472217,
-0.0120607475,
-0.0357374586,
0.1103091389,
-0.0641988069,
0.0583587661,
-0.0722055286,
0.0191224143,
-0.0123118134,
-0.038259156,
-0.0348364972,
-0.0033110364,
-0.0136928624,
-0.0173656996,
-0.0423749797,
0.0482477508,
0.0107779372,
-0.0034530642,
0.0157591105,
0.0046281102,
-0.0333141051,
0.0218836032,
0.033037398,
0.0766787603,
0.0000965009,
-0.0077705015,
-0.0108801657,
-0.0298767872,
-0.034671329,
0.0090824049,
-0.0012207859,
-0.0136806155,
-0.0178911239,
0.045805864,
-0.0122752339,
-0.0689884946,
0.0221575182,
0.0016929242,
-0.0479980782,
-0.0337630883,
0.0406216942,
-0.0364523903,
0.0487618148,
0.0173602104,
0.0106521314,
-0.0095028868,
-0.0384407714,
-0.0032565349,
0.0326494873,
0.0566364527,
0.0712471083,
-0.0207464341,
0.0084013306,
0.0047748601,
0.0081671588,
0.0623132624,
0.0269587114,
0.0606790036,
0.0124141481,
-0.0402456969,
-0.0024310029,
0.0450826362,
0.0128406845,
0.008936571,
-0.0358027369,
-0.050612174,
0.0049991221,
0.0253489465,
0.0404745303,
0.0283402,
-0.0587918609,
-0.0090321107,
0.0561714545,
0.0778746679,
0.0577328466,
0.0513865128,
0.064457126,
-0.0063124117,
0.0002980712,
0.059330076,
-0.0291181598,
-0.0019501029,
0.0228856578,
0.0094950348,
-0.0132496273,
0.054004997,
-0.0409500338,
-0.0380985141,
0.0099020069,
-0.0330246501,
0.0350407548,
-0.0502980016,
0.0575060397,
0.017480744,
-0.0429974236,
0.0648822486,
-0.0233581718,
-0.0678654909,
-0.0064889067,
0.0036015906,
-0.0416955166,
-0.0136650251,
0.0228324085,
0.0559839159,
0.0270032268,
-0.0033698734,
-0.0114534516,
0.0041524144,
0.0302225035,
-0.0070659234,
0.0275727287,
-0.0385193489,
-0.0363975875,
0.019228017,
0.056792818,
0.0145377927,
-0.0224062614,
-0.0385053083,
0.030197395,
-0.0507024005,
-0.0015077651,
0.0334054418,
0.0098633561,
-0.032383848,
0.0032548408,
0.0577353723,
0.0115136476,
0.0273467973,
0.0067116013,
0.0162869189,
0.0355184339,
-0.0648627505,
-0.01249367,
0.0560433865,
-0.0506701656,
-0.0568179712,
0.0051410752,
-0.0642782822,
0.0201569926,
0.0556715578,
-0.0094230641,
-0.0168636404,
0.0225302409,
-0.0631143004,
0.0374342464,
-0.0320269391,
0.0127304401,
-0.0366199203,
0.0204134192,
-0.0247284826,
0.023266403,
-0.0283811614,
0.0417703576,
0.0088068014,
-0.0471517295,
0.0313687623,
-0.0164823346,
-0.0362541452,
0.0260643661,
-0.0032427334,
0.041446548,
0.0027788898,
-0.025583243,
0.0399515033,
-0.0631271675,
-0.0477134846,
-0.0390356705,
-0.0401201323,
0.0434970371,
0.0327003822,
0.0191275217,
0.0261331946,
0.0137232104,
0.0054652644,
-0.0313933827,
-0.0076513155,
0.0081169363,
0.0221461002,
-0.0180115476,
-0.0378441811,
0.0174181499,
-0.0340901949,
-0.0179027598,
0.1028463468,
-0.0333634093,
0.0080399485,
-0.0651742369,
0.0130778672,
0.0295012202,
-0.0140483659,
-0.0304518212,
-0.0900777578,
0.0356369726,
0.0098982323,
0.0459735878,
0.0666602924,
-0.005134142,
0.0634597465,
0.0406293087,
0.0404130854,
-0.021501366,
-0.0246843118,
-0.0559206046,
-0.0106706461,
-0.082508266,
-0.0379422791,
0.0284796041,
0.08365421,
0.0112390602,
0.0099481968,
-0.0777909905,
-0.0158057883,
-0.0266696513,
-0.0001624014,
-0.015007331,
-0.0000352123,
-0.0114945928,
0.0317196585,
-0.012674557,
-0.067614466,
0.0552571379,
-0.0435717776,
-0.0287552327,
-0.0382843651,
-0.0223241076,
-0.0479412116,
0.035470251,
0.0080852211,
0.033151567,
-0.0261050686,
-0.0324910171,
-0.0322542414,
0.0232741665,
-0.0065983315,
-0.0181726925,
0.0506112352,
0.0261967443,
-0.0566055663,
-0.0250595119,
-0.0240809601,
-0.005851578,
-0.0040041641,
-0.0013964697,
0.0023238773,
0.0309729837,
-0.0296906494,
-0.0418029614,
0.0108481413,
0.0169404354,
0.0142082702,
-0.0052706362,
-0.0073355292,
-0.0218113475,
0.0327551477,
-0.0066618924,
0.0242587049,
0.0284623522,
-0.0305968653,
0.0205271859,
0.0171493813,
-0.0085959043,
0.0329109579,
-0.0664211586,
0.0251969174,
0.019141864,
0.0233216975,
-0.0098275645,
0.0095568933,
0.021705607,
-0.0232093111,
-0.0399627201,
0.0910233185,
0.0203736555,
-0.0541259646,
0.0123417201,
0.0156708285,
0.0313921534,
0.0229670051,
-0.0066639306,
-0.0532787479,
0.0095327999,
-0.0148213934,
0.0177972019,
0.0584106818,
0.0313844569,
0.0115185492,
-0.061744418,
0.0334851258,
0.0455269292,
-0.0344239622,
-0.0914357305,
-0.0332383104,
-0.0567553639,
-0.0301659685,
0.0390901826,
-0.0379156694,
-0.0177873336,
-0.0163230505,
0.0328278057,
-0.0041272654,
-0.0611197315,
-0.0361288451,
-0.0604032241,
-0.0266970452,
0.0202032924,
0.0277354922,
-0.0032152038,
-0.0861662477,
-0.0404997244,
-0.0141021088,
0.0044887848,
0.0367375128,
0.0234848913,
-0.0004414073,
-0.0293770488,
-0.0086935274,
-0.0074040964,
-0.0615583099,
0.0046794484,
-0.0713374838,
0.0800581127,
-0.0324605964,
-0.0143240737,
0.0014370254,
-0.0231936332,
-0.0321916044,
0.0596426427,
0.0653457791,
-0.0164439809,
-0.0223365389,
-0.0217885412,
0.0564900413,
0.0003013401,
-0.0708071142,
0.0291329063,
0.0349358246,
-0.0568343066,
-0.0543743297,
-0.025125308,
0.0101103727,
0.0484595001,
-0.0113350097,
-0.0296752714,
0.0006440364,
-0.0331218615,
-0.0371199325,
0.0329845548,
0.0024935754,
0.0155969607,
-0.0070472956,
0.0533199124,
0.0082338043,
-0.0092916684,
-0.0192381181,
-0.0274153762,
-0.0950595215,
-0.0408270359,
0.0154704992,
0.0058396356,
0.0176067259,
0.0182006191,
-0.0109469192,
-0.0115171662,
0.0338986591,
-0.0048014671,
-0.022217026,
0.0434435345,
0.0669978634,
-0.0277652312,
-0.0182622466,
0.0279817302,
-0.0004068891,
0.0035897014,
-0.0175935086,
0.0121713588,
-0.0080675343,
-0.0439568758,
0.0237138662,
-0.0229009259,
0.0514991283,
-0.0123476908,
0.0093961069,
0.0023125394,
0.0133125763,
-0.0140973786,
0.0156752113,
-0.0340924822,
-0.0598900877,
0.0691037923,
0.0207213536,
-0.0132156769,
0.0322386324,
0.0010846908,
0.0440912358,
-0.0152420914,
0.025434861,
-0.0000531129,
-0.0119771687,
0.0083534755,
0.0572897568,
-0.0025032798,
-0.0068811174,
-0.0185353272,
-0.0156919789,
-0.0179586392,
0.0018639894,
-0.0125447502,
0.0445142053,
-0.0709057227,
0.0493956134,
-0.0658868551,
-0.012908089,
0.0073995655,
-0.05313503,
0.0426496752,
-0.0251834895,
0.0515105985,
-0.0079217367,
-0.0222559627,
-0.004582251,
0.017065905,
-0.0198072605,
0.0067046527,
0.0639549717,
-0.0081842821,
-0.0127827451,
-0.0304071233,
0.0334654674,
-0.0342247784,
0.0203396175,
-0.0155152511,
-0.0090024741,
-0.0310015064,
-0.0244625136,
0.0027861265,
0.005759011,
-0.0508037433,
-0.0492478758,
-0.0573645681,
-0.0603661314,
0.0095860194,
-0.0073090326,
0.0081754308,
-0.0053294273,
-0.0011382343,
0.0622721203,
-0.0398763418,
0.0048366236,
0.0168162491,
-0.0200635716,
-0.0038850163,
-0.0274543352,
-0.029137535,
-5.324188604e-33,
0.0082003847,
0.0202598106,
0.0004920571,
-0.0298737604,
-0.0184937827,
0.0381344967,
-0.002095768,
0.0167080145,
-0.0202045124,
0.0134498756,
0.0020405173,
0.0183435455,
0.0106984368,
0.0322307236,
-0.0194912516,
-0.0055323527,
0.0624490939,
-0.0050750338,
-0.0382417962,
-0.01877122,
0.0241428949,
0.0073219105,
0.0619658753,
-0.0441240817,
0.0062891738,
-0.0134946639,
0.010124146,
0.0079519069,
0.0393034145,
0.0749543682,
-0.0469931848,
0.0425386466,
0.0360663794,
-0.0458696224,
-0.0332587808,
0.0227258373,
-0.0566154085,
0.0172664933,
-0.0112865483,
0.0518673137,
-0.0336038694,
-0.0570241958,
0.041407086,
-0.0297840908,
-0.0414185971,
-0.049990207,
0.0009053469,
0.008301435,
-0.0380137451,
0.0100760031,
-0.037500225,
-0.0157895591,
-0.019510366,
-0.007662728,
0.0751053467,
0.0186668839,
-0.0084483018,
0.0386194214,
-0.0674179867,
0.010306336,
-0.0205934159,
0.042477455,
0.052001711,
-0.0129185254,
-0.0021623769,
0.0340663008,
0.0608947389,
-0.0345535167,
-0.031808529,
-0.0307498518,
0.0669687912,
0.0019479807,
0.0567046106,
0.0057308697,
0.0517196916,
-0.0059117563,
-0.0220694076,
0.0190636422,
-0.0476943254,
0.0310171582,
0.0328717083,
0.0194715466,
-0.0268998891,
-0.0117472718,
-0.0103536127,
-0.0581681468,
-0.004328989,
-0.0218192227,
0.0155157344,
0.0247584265,
-0.023691237,
-0.0165443011,
0.0438865088,
-0.062080279,
0.035485357,
0.0525867008,
-0.0136459377,
0.0562653951,
0.0070094978,
0.0163388234,
-0.0027962287,
0.0065262867,
0.0267421175,
0.0203394722,
0.0184235238,
-0.0281975474,
0.0554547757,
0.048914507,
-0.0382877216,
-0.0141295902,
-0.0310669802,
-0.0585549287,
-0.021343641,
0.0767979026,
0.044321727,
0.020671729,
-0.0270313472,
-0.0013515875,
-0.0217250846,
0.035599947,
-0.0141494274,
0.0450120047,
0.0344484337,
0.0524243824,
-0.0116887074,
-0.0081519149,
-0.028578978,
0.0708115473,
0.1072073579,
-0.0596835427,
-0.0460600369,
0.0006802253,
2.383e-7,
0.0779199004,
0.0257301349,
0.0593634024,
0.004425765,
0.025361402,
0.0252649151,
-0.0307388976,
0.0417107642,
-0.0034530151,
0.0269282591,
0.0196539108,
0.0235974938,
0.0358869657,
0.0059176553,
-0.0588182099,
0.006405306,
-0.0504809022,
0.0216731112,
-0.0325123444,
0.0085400781,
0.0499061979,
0.0924926028,
-0.0267904308,
0.0009456002,
-0.0026480239,
0.01652316,
0.0439350307,
-0.0417023785,
0.0224411767,
-0.0209542606,
0.008854216,
0.0131659051,
0.005485706,
-0.0277966335,
0.0020696677,
0.0338229463,
0.0379700996,
0.039249856,
0.0139257647,
-0.0138684763,
-0.0082179829,
-0.0383739136,
-0.0289427824,
-0.0202258099,
0.0129086636,
-0.0754940212,
-0.0314682387,
-0.0201196466,
-0.0285392068,
0.0376748256,
0.0491240695,
-0.0105477124,
0.0075863511,
0.021855399,
0.042167481,
-0.015105417,
0.0321034454,
-0.0507039502,
-0.0179444086,
0.0010419703,
-0.0418971777,
-0.0333582535,
-0.0525685251,
-0.0079103569,
0.1043629795,
-0.0246243011,
-0.0213231035,
2.345274697e-34,
-0.0073431488,
0.0232655685,
0.049641557,
0.0436405949,
0.0068965917,
-0.0566341095,
0.0382791348,
-0.0307309907,
-0.0011041234,
-0.0731077418,
0.0004217697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06960v1 | Jaynes Machine: The universal microstructure of deep neural networks | 2023-10-10T19:22:01 | 2023-10-10T19:22:01 | Venkat Venkatasubramanian, N. Sanjeevrajan, Manasi Khandekar | cond-mat.stat-mech | cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.CL | We present a novel theory of the microstructure of deep neural networks.
Using a theoretical framework called statistical teleodynamics, which is a
conceptual synthesis of statistical thermodynamics and potential game theory,
we predict that all highly connected layers of deep neural networks have a
universal microstructure of connection strengths that is distributed
lognormally ($LN({\mu}, {\sigma})$). Furthermore, under ideal conditions, the
theory predicts that ${\mu}$ and ${\sigma}$ are the same for all layers in all
networks. This is shown to be the result of an arbitrage equilibrium where all
connections compete and contribute the same effective utility towards the
minimization of the overall loss function. These surprising predictions are
shown to be supported by empirical data from six large-scale deep neural
networks in real life. We also discuss how these results can be exploited to
reduce the amount of data, time, and computational resources needed to train
large deep neural networks. | [
-0.0280683301,
0.0161219556,
-0.0445670374,
0.0432291739,
-0.0260618888,
-0.0087330975,
0.0232332963,
-0.0160978194,
-0.0272337236,
0.0376526266,
-0.0503991432,
-0.0084287645,
-0.0030268154,
0.0134071065,
0.040450044,
-0.0331635289,
0.000876298,
0.0309386235,
-0.0131847942,
-0.0678571314,
-0.0123785883,
-0.0656525791,
-0.0300186612,
-0.0152671868,
0.0108277658,
0.0061578625,
0.0241165459,
0.004368857,
0.0529599898,
-0.0175345056,
-0.0239914712,
-0.0394507349,
-0.0303874332,
0.0373670273,
0.000001827,
-0.0250659455,
0.0269718263,
0.0238202382,
-0.0125820711,
-0.0127949435,
-0.0217015855,
-0.0103077814,
-0.0415453911,
-0.018322587,
0.0119366525,
-0.0316952094,
0.0900395736,
0.0303280186,
-0.0136409951,
0.0447384417,
-0.0172491577,
-0.0122691477,
0.0644457266,
-0.0401526019,
-0.0305681974,
-0.0321758129,
-0.0146553144,
0.0158858877,
-0.0160663836,
-0.0358487107,
-0.0028327187,
0.037740048,
0.043771036,
0.0316647217,
0.0033484052,
0.0571375974,
0.0097130341,
0.0186394248,
0.029293621,
0.0541009493,
-0.0110716904,
0.0310763288,
0.0102849528,
-0.0171399377,
0.0077500744,
0.0154988263,
-0.0258872882,
0.0145348497,
0.0443961173,
0.0109973606,
-0.0383221656,
0.0663858876,
0.0848943368,
0.0467946082,
-0.0063646534,
0.005028083,
0.0062990007,
0.0085023539,
-0.0158716943,
0.0146569014,
-0.025672907,
-0.0240708068,
-0.0057777567,
-0.0001411469,
0.0200757999,
-0.037032932,
-0.0507293008,
-0.0140779195,
-0.0325332731,
-0.0462704711,
-0.0049327598,
-0.0277729966,
0.0671362355,
0.0650734529,
-0.0039980905,
-0.0211948026,
-0.0333667062,
-0.0409686454,
-0.0242618434,
-0.0044244179,
-0.0116856899,
-0.0163482502,
0.0247823354,
0.0601679496,
0.0297394041,
-0.0237602368,
-0.039523866,
0.0555625223,
-0.06750305,
-0.0164066516,
-0.05704863,
0.0319773816,
0.0339950621,
-0.0152775254,
-0.0111409659,
-0.0153771024,
-0.0003133093,
0.0519971624,
0.0129475668,
-0.0044948338,
0.0037327094,
-0.012118117,
0.0127149774,
0.0054401113,
0.0152589781,
0.0816917345,
-0.0193725415,
0.0206221752,
-0.0070891315,
-0.0005951847,
-0.0054521151,
-0.0100969952,
0.0229559578,
-0.0018590067,
0.0033945506,
-0.0150422808,
0.0182541031,
-0.0142337922,
-0.0411267243,
-0.0658200681,
-0.0467368588,
0.0533715114,
0.0364975035,
-0.031491328,
0.0512722395,
-0.0163853131,
0.0302989129,
0.0490229279,
0.0651066601,
0.0477143526,
0.043083664,
-0.0109843249,
-0.0005019779,
0.0476529822,
0.0165002178,
0.0053921053,
-0.0217343494,
-0.0336749293,
-0.0337894931,
0.0491773784,
0.0108324857,
0.0263839625,
-0.0542414859,
-0.0721985996,
0.0438072905,
0.0563544333,
0.0410757512,
0.0800479874,
-0.023674015,
-0.0285552982,
0.0267547332,
0.0217996426,
-0.0314331576,
0.0523388833,
-0.0360089354,
-0.0437373631,
0.0407755747,
-0.031292811,
-0.06695766,
-0.0367425308,
0.0209482647,
-0.0079362718,
-0.0481566526,
0.0049537574,
0.0268280581,
-0.0705086812,
0.0132531645,
0.0035085685,
-0.0217587426,
0.0310006086,
0.0035036004,
-0.0357746817,
-0.0350425504,
0.0088691432,
-0.007723718,
0.0185940433,
-0.0378992893,
0.0366937853,
-0.0441173576,
-0.0179434605,
0.015596306,
0.0096628126,
0.0252101254,
-0.0323552564,
0.0133842807,
-0.0291129667,
-0.0122025479,
0.0184771027,
-0.0642317608,
0.014872265,
0.0035381333,
0.0182798542,
-0.0045374697,
-0.0236238688,
-0.0371740721,
-0.0254256446,
0.0506354906,
0.0359513871,
0.0688649565,
-0.0224793833,
-0.0403256714,
-0.002913154,
0.0000524746,
-0.0676509067,
-0.0137263425,
0.0111384168,
-0.0140263978,
0.0511585884,
-0.0313168578,
-0.0517916493,
0.043963775,
0.0136585878,
0.0165085569,
-0.0520930998,
0.0531441756,
0.0117784161,
0.0414750651,
-0.0078326855,
-0.0457291231,
0.0111117586,
0.0368233919,
0.0084539391,
-0.0530772507,
-0.0110909417,
-0.0395656563,
-0.0042684237,
0.0002616807,
0.0258839671,
-0.0613653585,
-0.0018590377,
-0.0381330848,
-0.0126936194,
-0.0062516499,
0.0091774268,
-0.0401944518,
0.0955948383,
-0.0265761595,
-0.0214352589,
-0.0254841018,
-0.0099328747,
0.0315459855,
-0.0225385856,
-0.003855787,
-0.0057485909,
0.0426498987,
0.0113793463,
0.0636205152,
0.0254561976,
-0.0176558495,
0.0350786038,
-0.031137228,
0.0289748292,
-0.0208521336,
-0.0778498501,
0.0056054457,
0.0648656711,
0.0427207537,
0.0567970872,
-0.0080458904,
0.0310962256,
0.0179395191,
0.0268694274,
-0.0288555678,
-0.0528465994,
-0.0250397213,
-0.0283544008,
0.0020066209,
0.0844202936,
0.0016328749,
-0.0107230656,
0.0155721121,
0.008325452,
0.0203012861,
0.0220049899,
0.0058698328,
0.0106736599,
-0.0697562322,
-0.0249407925,
-0.0023814577,
0.0278149098,
-0.0134240547,
0.0016875246,
-0.0047016214,
0.0167102907,
0.0040771496,
-0.0524307378,
-0.0123347593,
0.0245033316,
-0.0034923526,
-0.0011279895,
-0.0007984662,
-0.0265881326,
0.0583439916,
-0.0125715034,
0.0412926897,
0.0046594851,
-0.0407633074,
0.0055197072,
0.0771308392,
0.0475811511,
0.0169348065,
-0.0318319984,
-0.0108759282,
-0.0654040053,
-0.0440188311,
0.0061546764,
0.0384273939,
0.0095184213,
-0.0058322977,
0.0170275755,
-0.0465849824,
-0.0499144308,
0.0185529795,
0.003684171,
-0.0481742322,
0.0347017199,
0.0411912613,
-0.0394681133,
-0.0134516908,
-0.0373860821,
0.0316026509,
0.0130199436,
0.0188028924,
-0.0314028002,
0.0000919823,
0.0775892213,
0.0415246412,
0.0139958868,
0.0074312575,
0.0038003684,
0.0360583924,
-0.0341821164,
-0.0318390504,
0.0585670248,
-0.0876027271,
-0.0199410692,
0.0003500501,
0.0118483491,
-0.0239833947,
-0.0146149443,
0.0115627684,
-0.0137087172,
0.0324347205,
0.0252442062,
-0.0680561289,
-0.0393458754,
-0.0156139405,
0.0496831052,
-0.0021598425,
-0.0242084097,
0.0076070419,
-0.0336090513,
-0.0361895226,
0.0151220141,
0.0018956923,
-0.0047614835,
-0.0246317405,
0.0014449008,
-0.037330348,
-0.032786686,
-0.0233319402,
-0.0277446304,
-0.0159242805,
0.0084841745,
-0.0555909574,
-0.0918242186,
0.0303564388,
-0.0136631504,
0.0161242671,
-0.0114189908,
0.0072471565,
-0.0125548113,
0.0232352261,
0.0169065446,
-0.0791568458,
0.0391905047,
0.0422486626,
0.0015620034,
-0.1056382433,
-0.0183513314,
0.00481294,
0.0219047312,
0.0068296432,
0.0272872243,
0.0356350951,
0.0263201147,
-0.0365558304,
-0.0337272994,
-0.00355616,
0.0344683304,
0.043687176,
0.0335232057,
-0.0258656722,
-0.0048541445,
-0.0256417952,
-0.0172443036,
-0.0343455561,
-0.0071167857,
0.0452720933,
-0.0342356488,
-0.0187628064,
-0.0866684169,
-0.0310402066,
0.0140019935,
-0.0344258063,
0.0027214568,
-0.0155569306,
0.0355486833,
-0.0317522399,
-0.0016649769,
0.0348403044,
-0.0648234263,
0.0575681627,
0.0112143373,
-0.0674282536,
0.0435371958,
0.062198855,
-0.0254272837,
-0.0364012495,
0.0231036581,
-0.0147306388,
-0.027329972,
0.0318697542,
0.0554510914,
-0.0790256485,
-0.0083928257,
-0.0341812111,
-0.0152598834,
-0.0366915911,
-0.0394257717,
0.0486451797,
0.0072146845,
0.0202616267,
0.0110496487,
-0.0707361847,
0.0709865689,
0.0782650933,
-0.0545207597,
0.0254273526,
0.0815540627,
-0.0046989429,
-0.0137473857,
0.0533476733,
-0.0165988524,
0.0361768715,
0.0140889427,
-0.0127792228,
-0.0239191446,
0.0297367256,
-0.0465259291,
-0.0086256433,
0.0441120267,
0.0097184181,
0.0045380294,
0.0219437331,
0.0144414324,
0.0644659996,
0.028489301,
-0.0369913131,
-0.0122078853,
0.0312744193,
0.020504389,
0.000354297,
-0.0202114265,
0.1101636291,
-0.004448419,
0.0067649684,
0.0149714453,
0.0428029895,
0.0153773976,
0.0368057564,
0.0254238043,
0.002622392,
0.0646034777,
-0.0152387619,
0.0165592171,
-0.0108170286,
-0.0203076713,
0.0111856703,
-0.0054177893,
-0.0540531687,
0.007400739,
-0.0777751207,
-0.0992450416,
0.0237783175,
0.01485008,
0.0357960127,
0.0287053362,
-0.0300333705,
-0.0624778159,
0.012294095,
0.0056397924,
-0.0240353644,
-0.0344341472,
0.0349634588,
-0.0024821968,
0.0424911454,
-0.0187711399,
0.0410505794,
0.0212636609,
0.0212999303,
0.0246571563,
-0.0131446645,
0.0384689905,
0.0344451629,
-0.0084482832,
0.0372231863,
0.0459607765,
-0.0031796936,
-0.0263475087,
0.0044454667,
-0.0096769435,
-0.0316596851,
0.0187070686,
0.0564668626,
-0.0195027143,
0.0158319343,
0.0546067804,
-0.0240581371,
-0.0108419042,
0.0418237299,
0.0290227588,
-0.0153460903,
-0.0455845147,
0.0092281429,
-6.090004806e-33,
0.0719672441,
0.0236565229,
-0.0051849652,
0.0326058678,
0.0358850546,
0.0331309959,
0.0108192824,
-0.0196695849,
-0.0744677931,
-0.0026819687,
-0.0422459394,
0.0282635316,
0.0212984309,
0.0347910002,
0.0503993891,
-0.0373829119,
0.0333450176,
-0.003106548,
0.0769143775,
0.0478103422,
-0.027122736,
-0.0137986848,
0.0278808866,
0.0470195077,
0.0000274643,
-0.0173199736,
-0.0164284874,
0.0322744288,
0.0254600514,
0.0254199095,
-0.0747197345,
0.0214990061,
-0.0283457022,
-0.034453515,
0.04457381,
-0.0185106304,
-0.0353966579,
0.0076086028,
-0.0372801051,
-0.0240851715,
-0.0567398593,
-0.0244735572,
0.0679907799,
-0.0106407339,
-0.020767346,
-0.0518884771,
0.0188101158,
0.0241246298,
-0.0219748411,
-0.0528563634,
0.018950792,
0.010719345,
-0.042470023,
0.0132504441,
0.0278162528,
-0.0706324056,
0.0015970252,
-0.0230289791,
-0.0736468136,
0.0334516317,
0.0280850083,
0.0253848322,
0.0030017903,
0.0563314483,
0.0580133386,
0.0612072721,
0.0853267983,
0.0005374332,
-0.0386652388,
0.0138371037,
-0.0054960242,
0.0400511287,
0.0303206835,
-0.0021720771,
0.05651832,
-0.0442467257,
-0.1024587601,
-0.0204172749,
0.0647187755,
-0.0029992426,
-0.0249852259,
-0.009973905,
-0.025371911,
-0.0267928354,
-0.0231112987,
-0.0842729136,
-0.0048664976,
0.0154067092,
-0.0269422382,
0.0118607637,
0.0429767221,
-0.0026334175,
0.0195106622,
-0.0599324629,
0.0398510285,
0.0169670992,
0.082614094,
0.0224798713,
-0.002461999,
-0.0215003453,
-0.0138623361,
-0.0372383371,
-0.1098763272,
0.032208439,
0.0009955778,
0.0475430936,
0.0072802217,
0.0245173369,
0.0452128388,
-0.022705676,
-0.0006157226,
-0.0429471917,
0.0370130241,
-0.0595295727,
0.0282677207,
-0.017865926,
0.0080840643,
0.0311677884,
-0.0330873281,
0.0694351345,
0.0112758148,
0.0557619408,
-0.0294775944,
0.0103495894,
-0.0078474386,
0.0069031757,
-0.0540112182,
0.0324550383,
0.0238383785,
-0.0870398656,
-0.0033060538,
-0.0368148759,
2.604e-7,
-0.0273890179,
-0.0037751344,
-0.0330067538,
-0.0302589517,
0.0267992802,
0.0489704758,
0.0015079038,
-0.0023743066,
-0.0091557251,
0.0044235284,
0.0572515912,
0.0171864145,
0.0077169626,
0.036003001,
-0.0494074561,
-0.0211236943,
-0.0203408543,
0.0267038234,
0.0148265343,
-0.0427611731,
-0.0458078273,
0.0372726843,
0.0349648967,
-0.0112109818,
0.0389594808,
-0.0638950318,
-0.0306943841,
-0.0379122347,
0.0873636901,
0.0098754307,
0.0187377185,
-0.0253854301,
-0.0286467038,
-0.0099236583,
0.0103285015,
0.0202259738,
-0.0171718523,
-0.0091284579,
0.0156897418,
-0.0224760789,
-0.0340724103,
-0.0144187622,
-0.0158159453,
-0.0066474471,
0.0664329678,
-0.0797218457,
-0.0770554468,
-0.0334828608,
0.0200411472,
0.0014303925,
0.0464688726,
0.0038522917,
0.0034691689,
-0.0081341285,
-0.0377963111,
-0.0438509248,
0.0332401171,
-0.0513941385,
0.0353187956,
0.0803882778,
-0.0130227869,
-0.034463767,
-0.0456644222,
-0.0205813702,
0.1094359681,
0.0430556387,
0.0047885119,
1.847282944e-34,
0.0337757878,
-0.0370953754,
0.0325778797,
-0.0368438587,
-0.0040579177,
0.0140577657,
-0.0508136787,
-0.0162104815,
0.0532826446,
-0.0534429699,
-0.0566211268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10675v1 | Creation Of A ChatBot Based On Natural Language Proccesing For Whatsapp | 2023-10-10T18:54:15 | 2023-10-10T18:54:15 | Valderrama Jonatan, Aguilar-Alonso Igor | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the era of digital transformation, customer service is of paramount
importance to the success of organizations, and to meet the growing demand for
immediate responses and personalized assistance 24 hours a day, chatbots have
become a promising tool to solve these problems. Currently, there are many
companies that need to provide these solutions to their customers, which
motivates us to study this problem and offer a suitable solution. The objective
of this study is to develop a chatbot based on natural language processing to
improve customer satisfaction and improve the quality of service provided by
the company through WhatsApp. The solution focuses on creating a chatbot that
efficiently and effectively handles user queries. A literature review related
to existing chatbots has been conducted, analyzing methodological approaches,
artificial intelligence techniques and quality attributes used in the
implementation of chatbots. The results found highlight that chatbots based on
natural language processing enable fast and accurate responses, which improves
the efficiency of customer service, as chatbots contribute to customer
satisfaction by providing accurate answers and quick solutions to their queries
at any time. Some authors point out that artificial intelligence techniques,
such as machine learning, improve the learning and adaptability of chatbots as
user interactions occur, so a good choice of appropriate natural language
understanding technologies is essential for optimal chatbot performance. The
results of this study will provide a solid foundation for the design and
development of effective chatbots for customer service, ensuring a satisfactory
user experience and thus meeting the needs of the organization. | [
0.1425849795,
-0.0201366395,
-0.0253118128,
0.0026032329,
-0.0458700359,
-0.0220912024,
-0.011522579,
0.0094014835,
0.0945482403,
-0.0829105228,
-0.0071313214,
0.001120907,
-0.0116079934,
0.0501915626,
-0.0261307545,
-0.0528385416,
0.006476359,
0.0128666312,
0.0065011587,
0.0333959348,
0.0189288929,
0.0243399125,
-0.0263259001,
0.0558990128,
-0.0390039235,
-0.0283440202,
-0.0099244798,
-0.012495202,
-0.0121818986,
-0.0017714978,
0.0436400771,
0.0197570156,
-0.0413192734,
0.002857445,
0.0000020147,
-0.0692367107,
-0.0238812342,
0.027393464,
-0.0573358163,
-0.0693576187,
0.072982654,
0.0224963855,
-0.029204553,
0.0850581899,
-0.0424554832,
0.0854636431,
0.0210826173,
0.0622920394,
0.0737245455,
0.055841431,
-0.0295432787,
-0.0416163206,
-0.0256863981,
0.0623200014,
0.0194456968,
-0.0682071894,
-0.0111767659,
0.0007626968,
0.0838139057,
-0.0140201421,
0.0186767615,
-0.0018381127,
0.029739039,
-0.0101268394,
-0.0028895598,
0.004352584,
-0.0318606719,
-0.042284485,
-0.0459185801,
0.035039559,
-0.0075561972,
0.0139060197,
-0.014633744,
0.0120413108,
0.0354156569,
-0.0410847105,
-0.004251922,
-0.0204251055,
-0.03603331,
-0.0259844586,
-0.0314402618,
0.0326427817,
-0.0428635255,
-0.0095300917,
-0.0019827362,
0.0210525524,
-0.0139000677,
-0.0302412603,
0.0063874945,
-0.0291714035,
0.0302339736,
-0.0279247761,
0.0379659757,
0.0647106022,
-0.0435644276,
0.024721995,
-0.0010700895,
-0.0267584771,
0.0195269082,
-0.0807927474,
-0.0617230721,
0.0374808721,
-0.0144667597,
0.0371056646,
0.0072427485,
0.0699422657,
0.0488579497,
-0.0120216748,
-0.0445325412,
-0.0380687565,
-0.0629556626,
-0.0226755962,
-0.032198403,
0.0740452707,
-0.0160945766,
-0.0158468466,
-0.0565706454,
0.0473415032,
0.0629489124,
-0.0231432375,
0.018209001,
0.0449796729,
-0.0213755015,
0.0024802259,
-0.0551388599,
-0.002587612,
-0.0605011173,
-0.0125682736,
-0.0247466359,
-0.0736707374,
0.0710494295,
0.0079634199,
0.0190388113,
-0.0032620195,
0.0103770168,
0.0778088123,
-0.0122291092,
-0.0730782524,
-0.0502660088,
-0.0020336276,
-0.0068791364,
-0.0521034226,
-0.0246974621,
-0.0195712801,
0.0209152233,
0.0299614333,
-0.0438725092,
0.054685425,
0.0136058265,
0.0428855643,
-0.0432173721,
0.0411242209,
-0.0612508729,
0.0078046951,
0.0290541835,
-0.0082212351,
0.010710327,
0.0364663377,
0.0089618256,
0.0268931258,
0.0290509369,
-0.0070639946,
0.0165943913,
0.0007708627,
-0.0602607131,
-0.0952681527,
0.0154301859,
0.0181380026,
-0.0448688902,
-0.0034159133,
-0.028245857,
0.0444080383,
-0.0038075906,
0.0241895672,
0.0168407504,
0.0610883422,
-0.0226311609,
0.0453637205,
0.0058254162,
0.082563974,
0.0353960358,
-0.0077185635,
-0.0171273816,
0.0352706201,
-0.0407230742,
-0.0282317214,
-0.0111493384,
0.0126673011,
-0.0109657515,
-0.0633785427,
-0.003172308,
-0.0518784858,
0.0527957864,
0.0074084355,
0.0244474616,
0.0046625999,
-0.0401753746,
-0.015713729,
-0.0079185143,
0.0005306445,
-0.0832266733,
-0.0200908259,
0.0058133421,
0.1041511521,
0.0514732413,
-0.0088989986,
-0.0433724895,
0.0008458572,
-0.0661864802,
0.0388963819,
0.0245048814,
0.0210094862,
-0.031007681,
-0.0088220267,
-0.009808477,
0.009275822,
-0.0163674541,
-0.0188504029,
0.009937753,
0.0332381576,
-0.0088505894,
0.0447470546,
-0.0176116675,
0.0126105305,
0.044526834,
0.0038308837,
-0.0230551194,
0.019048145,
0.0223697461,
0.0577363633,
0.0155996382,
-0.0043129856,
-0.0002140599,
0.0041416693,
-0.0402481966,
0.041192282,
0.0050418959,
-0.0133645944,
0.0336212255,
-0.0014936625,
-0.0257432871,
0.0462138429,
-0.0221105199,
-0.0262623858,
-0.0173814967,
-0.076692991,
0.0599225648,
-0.0165025238,
0.0199592579,
-0.0345172547,
0.0279388856,
-0.0112907542,
0.0418738499,
0.0231459513,
-0.00597416,
-0.0365481414,
0.0306577589,
0.0191440824,
-0.003072337,
-0.005456252,
0.0071278117,
-0.0213081911,
0.0400265865,
0.0614465699,
0.0393018089,
-0.0404883251,
0.0200193096,
-0.0830092877,
0.0016957083,
0.0092976531,
-0.038812045,
0.007580664,
0.0472921319,
-0.0033200199,
-0.0651652291,
-0.0177427158,
0.0188103318,
0.0143180545,
-0.005409624,
0.0570357181,
-0.0215582121,
-0.0675243065,
-0.0477976315,
0.0320037715,
0.0066297501,
-0.0174728762,
0.0876752511,
-0.0493022315,
-0.0372800007,
-0.0030382175,
-0.0502726138,
0.0033234656,
0.0129255448,
-0.0684456378,
0.0328278616,
0.0065327371,
0.0134908445,
0.0230031423,
0.0349372141,
0.0270213448,
-0.0452351607,
0.0545789152,
-0.0298488177,
0.0141375251,
-0.0081140073,
-0.0375615954,
0.0036499652,
-0.0287683215,
0.0426391698,
0.0181714147,
-0.0025191358,
0.0242975336,
-0.0512582846,
0.0180043355,
-0.0149515774,
-0.03845888,
-0.03084521,
0.0275269579,
-0.0411602333,
0.0258370396,
0.0269233119,
-0.0313345715,
0.0482583679,
0.0347352736,
-0.0028406149,
-0.1055308878,
-0.0573359206,
-0.0201721899,
0.0548343994,
-0.029822778,
0.047420796,
0.0075097503,
-0.0661860332,
-0.0166858956,
-0.0125882206,
0.0030509005,
-0.0442285053,
-0.0748705864,
0.0148256449,
0.021383103,
0.026079677,
-0.0134760989,
-0.0698010921,
-0.0408908874,
-0.0519307256,
0.0107375002,
0.0703753456,
-0.0200094189,
-0.0523290858,
0.0183646306,
-0.0188658163,
0.0214064158,
0.0038794044,
-0.0114486916,
-0.0070334547,
-0.0490098223,
0.0358699709,
0.0284061003,
0.0109250369,
0.0658697635,
0.0505249016,
0.0187343583,
0.0359790586,
-0.0141658857,
-0.0296667106,
-0.0255933404,
-0.0150145637,
-0.050023783,
-0.0101547316,
0.019103419,
-0.0097131375,
-0.0249063317,
0.0354468338,
0.0893547758,
0.0527343787,
-0.0061559463,
0.0113381837,
-0.0364947431,
-0.0732798725,
0.0105130933,
0.078334406,
-0.0408931784,
-0.0379842035,
-0.0133956168,
0.0111490395,
-0.000801562,
-0.0253689736,
-0.013024725,
-0.0775465518,
0.0062449314,
-0.0146941021,
-0.0360789895,
-0.0536154434,
-0.0072227228,
-0.025349468,
0.0072972504,
0.0482412539,
-0.0035916541,
-0.0096561518,
-0.0297784638,
-0.0001339629,
-0.0620694496,
-0.0149485972,
0.0519064628,
-0.0439110249,
0.0217384994,
0.0758859217,
0.0516324602,
0.0201251321,
0.03340156,
0.0102050425,
0.088757284,
0.0300391633,
0.0006060487,
0.0522765778,
-0.0032707762,
0.0056512048,
-0.0669648275,
-0.0223217048,
-0.0115894517,
0.0234187264,
-0.0094659245,
0.0062262518,
-0.0222827457,
0.0202024058,
-0.032964021,
0.0267246999,
-0.0019407305,
0.028572714,
-0.021830311,
-0.0585197769,
-0.0526111126,
-0.0049952324,
-0.014364305,
0.0487437621,
-0.0268776454,
0.0379081294,
-0.0577858835,
-0.0283491686,
-0.081566669,
-0.0418305509,
0.0201580953,
0.0186695214,
0.011569106,
0.0293618627,
0.0333175063,
0.0275394637,
0.0315664187,
-0.0437421873,
0.0044262134,
0.012454059,
-0.0496100597,
0.0244145934,
0.0403175019,
-0.0221569855,
0.0067386352,
-0.0390949771,
0.0199436732,
0.0004439716,
-0.0239149164,
0.0136180865,
0.0118473331,
0.006978896,
-0.0506498478,
-0.05923656,
-0.0477221273,
0.0377523713,
-0.0513484925,
-0.0382623523,
-0.0129989618,
0.0738458633,
-0.0083716353,
0.0104928026,
-0.0559760854,
-0.0076923841,
-0.0647925064,
0.0075757043,
-0.0087585328,
-0.0321847536,
0.0640116557,
0.0729934275,
-0.0260916427,
0.0066605476,
-0.0215384923,
0.0207622852,
0.0192156751,
-0.0262166485,
-0.0204849467,
-0.028374251,
0.0072658858,
-0.0427724905,
0.0192652848,
0.0335594565,
-0.0435653143,
-0.0824652612,
0.0077878875,
0.038572941,
0.0221493952,
0.0014015812,
0.0117327096,
-0.0254234094,
-0.0061408416,
0.0076592104,
0.0260950588,
0.0382279009,
0.0299881902,
-0.0024579137,
0.0502866916,
-0.0287939515,
-0.0245250892,
-0.0384959579,
0.0304519348,
-0.0196488947,
-0.1005636156,
0.0012499065,
0.0567759313,
0.0272197351,
-0.0115233166,
-0.0142721655,
-0.0417828411,
0.0364334323,
-0.0123807341,
0.0260037892,
-0.0050396747,
0.0120323747,
-0.0138495769,
-0.016640516,
-0.0357425176,
-0.0155759864,
0.0172675401,
-0.014724087,
-0.0347769186,
-0.0364149474,
-0.0503638834,
-0.0610895678,
0.007923794,
0.0307423323,
0.0240014941,
-0.0010389659,
0.0220054612,
-0.0324731693,
-0.0319567174,
-0.0274505671,
-0.0049009947,
-0.0060529951,
-0.0234493669,
0.0667242706,
0.0430074856,
0.0011654727,
-0.0357702449,
-0.0547814295,
-0.0050809593,
-0.0255137607,
0.0176729895,
-0.0070097861,
-5.63271032e-33,
-0.0166563429,
-0.0326800346,
0.0337558985,
0.0231613573,
0.0136026079,
-0.0297241714,
0.0101601947,
-0.0086548049,
0.0118592987,
-0.0155291958,
-0.0492175445,
0.0317251645,
0.0166758895,
-0.0290817171,
0.0036331832,
-0.025335798,
0.0390863232,
-0.0290542953,
0.0057621552,
-0.0085259611,
0.0196456574,
0.0575048104,
0.0246621314,
-0.0791024342,
0.0309383068,
-0.0069760946,
-0.0049472549,
0.0209365413,
0.0627542809,
0.0184961986,
0.0042016674,
0.0162826907,
0.0366719477,
-0.0178113803,
0.0134277642,
0.0268607214,
-0.033872366,
-0.0375732593,
0.0199590009,
0.077692464,
-0.0309195239,
0.019067293,
0.035089612,
-0.0546840131,
-0.0112000844,
0.066796124,
0.0583001301,
-0.0145815592,
0.0032743409,
0.0471425429,
-0.0717874691,
-0.0086100716,
-0.0318032056,
-0.0322239511,
-0.01429448,
0.0902639776,
-0.032965105,
-0.0221411549,
-0.0306052752,
-0.0015093747,
-0.0296938643,
-0.0568112433,
0.0178790316,
0.0110692605,
0.0087000774,
0.0171394516,
0.0538371131,
-0.0164032038,
0.0103041027,
-0.0022089449,
0.009631224,
0.0578687266,
0.0300120078,
0.0015951676,
0.0082999002,
-0.0323681906,
-0.0175186843,
0.0312741511,
0.0785752833,
0.0319693238,
0.0069307783,
-0.0009029313,
-0.0722305849,
0.0077719074,
0.0398084335,
0.0483632274,
-0.013347297,
-0.0429026484,
0.0053885668,
0.0055594067,
-0.0413794182,
-0.0631170347,
0.0088680191,
-0.0449698195,
0.0226056203,
-0.009231722,
0.010398143,
-0.0030695382,
0.004214881,
0.0100841755,
-0.0234846342,
0.0084481295,
-0.0082241613,
-0.0308167767,
0.0307099484,
0.0005592249,
-0.0173379015,
0.0002284766,
-0.0147996768,
-0.0070103803,
0.0108968196,
0.0303002447,
-0.0218554083,
-0.02692491,
0.0035184713,
0.0247803591,
-0.0383429527,
0.0632162541,
0.0012695192,
0.0387390889,
-0.0364209302,
0.0054739304,
0.0185090601,
-0.0224496741,
-0.0403960906,
-0.0104523087,
-0.0302989092,
0.0223720595,
-0.0117958374,
-0.0210730899,
-0.018382661,
-0.0014852117,
2.637e-7,
0.0063960869,
0.0324377641,
-0.0393069535,
0.0165292881,
-0.0037234828,
0.0593291111,
0.0444010943,
-0.0042119217,
0.0051848842,
0.0187821127,
0.0122069111,
-0.0023417517,
0.0115062604,
0.0165797528,
-0.0950875282,
-0.0266726632,
-0.0215073768,
-0.0408103876,
-0.0485128351,
0.0574333072,
0.0738017783,
0.0610028692,
0.0037189971,
-0.0316287279,
-0.0313069373,
-0.0095003946,
-0.009387386,
-0.0077154711,
0.0031311812,
0.0181570146,
0.0522987582,
0.0495938882,
0.0373120941,
0.019079322,
0.0163939018,
0.0349153243,
0.031949345,
0.0013422474,
-0.0007233354,
0.0054112198,
0.0667098761,
0.0084129004,
-0.0058784033,
-0.0215694234,
0.053605441,
-0.0413649231,
-0.0397430211,
-0.0273998324,
0.0313468762,
0.0066498239,
0.0035274583,
-0.0176018346,
-0.0462063923,
0.012706494,
0.0026119649,
-0.0231360793,
0.0072181313,
-0.0212721787,
0.0419021323,
0.0209949985,
-0.003908657,
-0.0114905424,
-0.0302909426,
-0.0018655792,
0.0572095402,
0.0196651723,
0.037757922,
1.637247473e-34,
0.0020944774,
-0.0084763523,
0.0185855236,
0.0849084556,
0.0509060025,
0.0362246707,
0.0378218479,
0.0182390492,
0.0298753344,
-0.0021067802,
0.0109932888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06940v1 | Document-Level Supervision for Multi-Aspect Sentiment Analysis Without Fine-grained Labels | 2023-10-10T18:53:21 | 2023-10-10T18:53:21 | Kasturi Bhattacharjee, Rashmi Gangadharaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) is a widely studied topic, most often
trained through supervision from human annotations of opinionated texts. These
fine-grained annotations include identifying aspects towards which a user
expresses their sentiment, and their associated polarities (aspect-based
sentiments). Such fine-grained annotations can be expensive and often
infeasible to obtain in real-world settings. There is, however, an abundance of
scenarios where user-generated text contains an overall sentiment, such as a
rating of 1-5 in user reviews or user-generated feedback, which may be
leveraged for this task. In this paper, we propose a VAE-based topic modeling
approach that performs ABSA using document-level supervision and without
requiring fine-grained labels for either aspects or sentiments. Our approach
allows for the detection of multiple aspects in a document, thereby allowing
for the possibility of reasoning about how sentiment expressed through multiple
aspects comes together to form an observable overall document-level sentiment.
We demonstrate results on two benchmark datasets from two different domains,
significantly outperforming a state-of-the-art baseline. | [
0.0257645231,
0.0420282111,
0.0039029375,
0.0378695279,
-0.0131800091,
0.0166779365,
-0.0040852451,
-0.0273604635,
-0.0556066372,
-0.0536836721,
-0.02894664,
-0.0157860201,
-0.0529710613,
0.027774917,
-0.0305921901,
-0.0182273723,
0.0357824489,
0.0259193443,
0.0618282147,
-0.0104248514,
0.0482872725,
0.0293199234,
-0.0084626535,
0.0166629311,
-0.0505374596,
-0.0045056669,
-0.0024799157,
-0.0197579321,
0.0149866892,
0.0062321294,
0.0279453266,
0.0381903388,
0.0237107854,
-0.0487733707,
0.0000018523,
0.0265489295,
-0.0454634465,
-0.0225414634,
0.0675173998,
-0.0029051544,
0.0990226865,
-0.0539106615,
0.0237352028,
0.002781658,
-0.0315924212,
-0.0136877857,
0.0311611202,
0.0849604681,
0.0841337666,
0.0371236168,
-0.0382242501,
-0.0045902058,
-0.0085227322,
-0.023994023,
0.0032616821,
-0.0404929072,
-0.0060282331,
-0.0026058492,
-0.0246289987,
0.0642431602,
-0.0035775623,
-0.010864161,
0.0070264679,
-0.0135028064,
-0.0041161696,
-0.0169105716,
0.0352345593,
0.0009110697,
-0.0071097771,
0.0566370264,
0.0392418467,
-0.0118112909,
0.0281685833,
-0.0230795369,
-0.0293320697,
0.0008920378,
0.0073741865,
0.0061567551,
0.0181529503,
0.0448604673,
0.0522011481,
0.0301236957,
0.0031352525,
0.0193629246,
0.0264737923,
0.0378985256,
-0.0154990964,
-0.0365084708,
0.0039173141,
0.0708873868,
-0.0049021943,
0.0198185705,
0.0157290678,
-0.0193401501,
0.0108880699,
0.0216742009,
-0.0116211539,
-0.0298594292,
0.0171821304,
-0.0385196246,
-0.0097600389,
-0.0031993506,
-0.0524271652,
0.0605199747,
0.0389891788,
-0.0487303995,
0.0037506439,
-0.0275350753,
-0.0125123542,
-0.0043682577,
-0.0376959592,
0.0364972018,
0.0205292609,
0.0207174104,
-0.0135351289,
0.0067420024,
-0.0368359499,
-0.0327147506,
-0.0465124883,
0.0064517655,
0.0258620698,
-0.0094980551,
0.0006736187,
-0.011195329,
0.0103535783,
0.0649154931,
-0.0722849667,
0.0630541593,
-0.0479299761,
0.0518366471,
0.019872278,
0.0370469987,
0.0073640696,
0.006165883,
0.0008825011,
0.0025952228,
0.0414855406,
-0.0210105684,
-0.0495668538,
-0.0384225696,
-0.0175320581,
-0.0458193459,
0.0096565438,
-0.0638961196,
0.0433425829,
-0.0054951143,
-0.0079888534,
0.0285578631,
0.020833753,
0.0176385734,
-0.0216599964,
0.0665280595,
-0.0222290624,
-0.0228503738,
-0.003342136,
0.03877379,
0.0535517186,
0.0441592894,
-0.0395751484,
0.0394064821,
0.0291478895,
0.02026226,
0.010502357,
-0.0110311564,
0.0115614738,
0.0074779745,
0.0231451467,
-0.0361972712,
-0.0475252531,
-0.0447202586,
0.0014188219,
0.055440966,
-0.0014883658,
-0.0508562326,
0.0197772086,
0.0136884153,
-0.0623580925,
0.0388694108,
-0.0100439498,
0.025884835,
0.0029883084,
-0.0211373158,
-0.0035524822,
0.0375992209,
-0.0009059569,
-0.020782005,
0.0190091599,
-0.0126107223,
-0.0373087786,
-0.0661196336,
-0.0236169286,
-0.0463054925,
-0.0112767145,
-0.0466188826,
0.0900260583,
0.0068512745,
-0.0138986949,
-0.0504262485,
0.0780691504,
-0.0558798611,
0.0046403697,
-0.0062360023,
0.0629913583,
0.054537788,
0.0022670073,
-0.0431686863,
-0.006923134,
-0.0534881093,
0.0035483502,
0.0240703281,
0.0369355679,
-0.0085139228,
-0.0054640304,
-0.0255262293,
0.0108893272,
-0.0144865494,
0.0394765735,
0.0088541405,
-0.0356420651,
-0.0044839829,
-0.0134203983,
-0.0263101663,
0.0234014727,
0.019765351,
0.0163961072,
0.0084535806,
0.0334282257,
0.0135578169,
0.041773133,
0.0568435378,
-0.0021103011,
-0.0131536694,
0.0419252664,
-0.0378873162,
-0.0739531592,
-0.0147697488,
-0.005981165,
-0.017903585,
0.0082424851,
-0.035221938,
-0.0170452613,
-0.0084936135,
-0.0175913014,
-0.0194221139,
-0.0002412614,
-0.0071636257,
-0.0329389721,
-0.0227596369,
-0.0299101602,
-0.0010034899,
-0.025321871,
0.003663884,
0.0512253344,
-0.0364833884,
0.0075675119,
-0.0143106664,
-0.045325987,
0.0246646833,
0.042761825,
-0.0546205007,
-0.042355381,
0.0456321053,
0.0206187535,
0.0588452294,
-0.0002182498,
0.0033677584,
-0.033984229,
-0.109797731,
-0.0126889711,
-0.0039275102,
0.0435260423,
0.0394133925,
-0.0093432814,
0.0248513184,
0.0181894526,
-0.0440828428,
-0.0158319846,
-0.0386158414,
0.0261031967,
0.0354714394,
0.0036328039,
0.0651922971,
-0.0638072714,
-0.0155153237,
-0.0475142412,
0.0042800903,
0.0244012587,
-0.0241048746,
-0.0171596874,
0.0251174048,
-0.0203300994,
0.0100111235,
-0.0201073196,
-0.0089377174,
-0.0021592574,
-0.0435386635,
0.0360680148,
0.0116353491,
-0.0073050912,
0.0624599755,
0.0503985956,
0.0016982539,
-0.0290116873,
0.0169305597,
-0.0687135085,
0.045277968,
0.0071049314,
-0.0001556389,
0.001984041,
0.0577988625,
0.0060749496,
0.0022389684,
-0.0555616692,
0.016930351,
-0.0470463783,
0.0143027809,
0.0064920848,
0.0061681899,
0.0291581824,
0.0027530647,
0.0039091459,
0.009705063,
0.0749314204,
0.0247462317,
-0.0062622763,
-0.0615258217,
0.0069339918,
-0.0389130041,
0.0457243323,
-0.0431683511,
0.0015701553,
0.0056572589,
0.0382834151,
0.009979534,
-0.0172415376,
-0.0093691396,
0.0050836983,
0.0280619171,
-0.0209516734,
0.0136659956,
0.0185471699,
-0.0435132533,
0.0287577696,
-0.0444127508,
-0.0191111602,
0.0161591507,
0.0093588382,
-0.0306598265,
0.005786526,
-0.0375805646,
-0.0058925468,
-0.0161532685,
-0.0263170656,
-0.0247442983,
0.0170778632,
0.0298913866,
0.0500415936,
-0.0881792381,
-0.0038292094,
-0.0417163447,
-0.0182217378,
0.0527658537,
-0.0274109282,
0.0043834993,
-0.0226492379,
-0.0185854193,
0.0154886385,
0.0005452521,
-0.0177894253,
-0.0511403494,
0.056085743,
-0.0636088103,
0.0019931449,
0.0964614451,
0.0384658501,
-0.0670992807,
-0.0182924028,
-0.0061455835,
0.0034321111,
0.0169638619,
0.0019253714,
-0.0691979825,
-0.039931871,
-0.056677971,
0.0335793234,
0.0045562261,
0.0020603933,
0.0073619336,
-0.0603192002,
0.0101936227,
-0.0179598145,
-0.0118104322,
-0.0237514433,
-0.0589920655,
0.0219899472,
-0.0416800231,
-0.018687591,
-0.0456919074,
0.0337692127,
0.0016865372,
-0.0089002345,
-0.0145879593,
-0.0147044407,
0.0321004614,
-0.0240943562,
0.0251957104,
0.0213089995,
0.0448832065,
0.0017043868,
-0.033464808,
0.0128451353,
-0.0480438061,
-0.0017262723,
-0.0182000175,
0.0740874037,
-0.0574670695,
-0.0324109532,
-0.006065967,
0.0478367396,
-0.0795455351,
0.0107965441,
-0.0108281318,
0.0524569675,
-0.0077286544,
-0.0178917143,
-0.0280880369,
0.0156802554,
0.0461035892,
0.0536370687,
-0.0123105692,
-0.0915771648,
-0.0194849372,
-0.0007175389,
0.0200354494,
-0.0028638251,
-0.0376093499,
-0.0906759351,
-0.0063542896,
-0.0545517541,
-0.0708150938,
-0.044904612,
0.0132214176,
0.01268005,
-0.0257262178,
-0.0234477408,
0.045180887,
-0.0204772707,
-0.0170557629,
0.026133921,
0.0105010998,
0.0134507362,
0.0090207476,
-0.0576047078,
0.0809278488,
-0.0019285667,
-0.0104590189,
-0.014865648,
-0.04231821,
-0.0222553462,
-0.0106462957,
0.035827525,
0.0054389606,
0.0020957622,
-0.0263798833,
-0.0146379722,
-0.0111568486,
0.0708745942,
-0.0633353889,
0.002053279,
0.0483938493,
0.0487298667,
0.0222327933,
0.0257446878,
-0.0192537084,
0.06547077,
0.0017748406,
-0.0237547699,
-0.0664574876,
-0.0258142091,
0.0012152978,
-0.0397007018,
0.0699019954,
0.03795949,
0.0028921599,
-0.038645789,
-0.0329544544,
-0.019333981,
-0.0543652028,
-0.0265366007,
0.0137235317,
-0.0172920544,
0.0054046898,
-0.0756510943,
0.0466137901,
0.0075368434,
0.0608464032,
-0.0127141019,
0.0249001458,
0.0197025388,
0.0350736193,
-0.0493012965,
0.0078598596,
0.0050736698,
-0.0090515995,
-0.0115302866,
-0.0046589733,
-0.0163451992,
0.0662911162,
0.0014370566,
0.0089576747,
-0.0002699593,
0.0046435231,
-0.0281343795,
0.0126914615,
-0.0168674309,
0.0067395358,
-0.02619268,
-0.0124481032,
0.0702283978,
-0.0440903008,
-0.0149930511,
-0.0091984998,
0.0381306708,
-0.0169528946,
0.011928807,
0.0234857257,
0.0196724758,
-0.0090080295,
0.0112729166,
0.0521170795,
-0.0723703057,
0.0295959804,
0.0033690834,
-0.0167981423,
-0.0281921774,
0.0177390687,
0.0330380574,
0.024265727,
-0.0059786537,
0.0497070067,
-0.0586961769,
0.0063980445,
0.0108486339,
-0.0205783732,
0.0137457,
0.0173837468,
0.0217337664,
0.0428991243,
-0.008576476,
0.0488819741,
-0.081948407,
-0.0150125204,
-0.0086381482,
-0.0205451939,
-0.0281517189,
-6.351754337e-33,
-0.0382161215,
-0.0152154854,
-0.0490087271,
0.0549249277,
0.0141283823,
0.0122805368,
-0.0123750139,
0.0563320182,
0.01763184,
0.0632461756,
0.0372446552,
0.0473117009,
-0.0293526426,
0.015097688,
0.039446,
-0.0081192665,
0.0559471846,
-0.0399891958,
0.0062339841,
0.0613846444,
0.0581920743,
-0.0246103927,
0.0392709263,
-0.1501117796,
0.0575818866,
0.0010449798,
-0.0641752779,
0.0137051689,
0.0093264645,
0.0530386306,
-0.0181359649,
0.0369182378,
0.0506248772,
-0.012446668,
0.0102153756,
0.0383377224,
-0.0310960785,
-0.0216322858,
-0.0266990177,
-0.0185299832,
-0.0357739851,
-0.0211463124,
0.0185491573,
0.0080264919,
0.0174589846,
-0.0037753221,
0.0533254854,
-0.001612551,
0.0311135054,
-0.1298359632,
-0.0451315604,
0.0372645743,
-0.0096269986,
-0.0270991959,
0.0189241059,
0.0161192678,
0.0241681989,
0.0526501238,
-0.0172919407,
0.0288405865,
-0.044694934,
0.0038242098,
-0.0333257653,
-0.0808200985,
-0.0243772473,
0.0898258314,
-0.0075682704,
0.0365127921,
-0.0239929017,
0.0087610474,
0.0155708008,
0.0466731749,
0.0297455117,
0.0160633102,
0.0126853678,
-0.0012502798,
-0.0264362916,
0.0341393165,
0.0275142007,
-0.006690695,
0.0457364656,
0.0055389581,
-0.0408331193,
-0.0185970813,
0.0134660266,
-0.0715479478,
-0.0457078516,
0.0088142343,
-0.0191575978,
0.0067628701,
-0.0372664854,
0.0091661615,
-0.0245505925,
-0.0452499576,
0.0097287307,
0.0458459482,
-0.0590944439,
0.0428383164,
0.0049555018,
-0.0168528818,
-0.0815808177,
-0.0182888471,
-0.0174214598,
-0.0072893207,
-0.0051839096,
-0.0138853667,
0.0906289071,
0.0159547217,
-0.0961901098,
-0.0217758231,
-0.0011570703,
0.0083029186,
-0.0269775204,
0.0436187759,
0.0004377226,
-0.003226741,
0.0063522058,
0.1296247244,
0.0169820748,
0.0720114857,
-0.0052310452,
-0.0415089317,
0.0077270824,
0.0130483853,
-0.0188965742,
-0.0526087321,
0.0308448728,
-0.0308396611,
0.0013087064,
-0.0340825915,
0.0048148488,
0.002967542,
2.552e-7,
0.0574869961,
0.0710907876,
-0.0027602641,
-0.0266210623,
0.0292914584,
0.0855646729,
-0.009274045,
-0.0014255103,
-0.0211592782,
-0.0211738236,
0.0357460938,
0.0210209601,
0.0201254096,
0.0228322614,
-0.0585585795,
0.0537780263,
0.001434556,
-0.0205068942,
-0.0200785138,
-0.0065883864,
0.0763242692,
0.0502142906,
0.059310697,
-0.0011305723,
-0.0167113747,
0.042954497,
0.0887767524,
-0.0094364937,
-0.0452782102,
0.029005833,
-0.0041085989,
0.0043428992,
-0.0049430788,
-0.0517310612,
-0.0053979382,
0.01683731,
0.0142694851,
0.0969839096,
0.0271484014,
-0.0320603922,
0.0358295217,
0.0221266467,
0.0098131988,
0.0537330024,
0.0308725964,
-0.0454248674,
-0.0286945459,
-0.118891567,
-0.0172473267,
0.0449658968,
0.0136238849,
-0.0007281475,
-0.0382189453,
0.0359429158,
-0.0288744438,
-0.0390146188,
-0.0388003215,
-0.0623809136,
-0.0043088496,
0.0392735191,
-0.0078541962,
-0.0207866952,
0.0262077227,
0.0657255426,
-0.0065360954,
-0.0483765379,
0.004244315,
2.217826773e-34,
0.0554598793,
-0.0601210482,
-0.0285227764,
0.020248523,
0.0063161482,
0.0079972986,
-0.0680099949,
-0.0217215046,
0.0278070662,
0.0012391213,
0.0168835763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06927v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06927v2 | Sparse Fine-tuning for Inference Acceleration of Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T18:28:38 | 2023-10-13T13:47:44 | Eldar Kurtic, Denis Kuznedelev, Elias Frantar, Michael Goin, Dan Alistarh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We consider the problem of accurate sparse fine-tuning of large language
models (LLMs), that is, fine-tuning pretrained LLMs on specialized tasks, while
inducing sparsity in their weights. On the accuracy side, we observe that
standard loss-based fine-tuning may fail to recover accuracy, especially at
high sparsities. To address this, we perform a detailed study of
distillation-type losses, determining an L2-based distillation approach we term
SquareHead which enables accurate recovery even at higher sparsities, across
all model types. On the practical efficiency side, we show that sparse LLMs can
be executed with speedups by taking advantage of sparsity, for both CPU and GPU
runtimes. While the standard approach is to leverage sparsity for computational
reduction, we observe that in the case of memory-bound LLMs sparsity can also
be leveraged for reducing memory bandwidth. We exhibit end-to-end results
showing speedups due to sparsity, while recovering accuracy, on T5 (language
translation), Whisper (speech translation), and open GPT-type (MPT for text
generation). For MPT text generation, we show for the first time that sparse
fine-tuning can reach 75% sparsity without accuracy drops, provide notable
end-to-end speedups for both CPU and GPU inference, and highlight that sparsity
is also compatible with quantization approaches. Models and software for
reproducing our results are provided in Section 6. | [
0.0030132658,
0.0849401727,
0.0103595937,
0.0485303663,
-0.0077570332,
0.0031775574,
0.0074075074,
0.0210893415,
-0.0550152436,
-0.0337175988,
-0.0272100717,
-0.0423024297,
0.0263541825,
-0.007825817,
0.0551564321,
-0.0270009395,
0.0252641663,
-0.0428133495,
-0.0172656476,
-0.0291407295,
0.0236322004,
0.0339146554,
0.0009782278,
0.0135915549,
0.0206028894,
0.0137025816,
-0.0068474612,
0.0519878641,
0.008007966,
0.0099168085,
0.0012803769,
0.0744596198,
0.0424396768,
0.0494527295,
0.0000022431,
0.0008193172,
0.0097544743,
0.0024261158,
-0.0173429605,
0.0409464724,
0.0237700306,
-0.008566319,
0.0010028554,
-0.0080422275,
-0.0042493236,
-0.0125122517,
0.0961353853,
-0.0127233034,
0.0455024801,
0.0593754984,
-0.0058279424,
-0.0107588163,
-0.0066737556,
-0.054620564,
0.0071538868,
-0.0442887545,
-0.0066678845,
-0.0310284272,
-0.0477553383,
-0.0025680903,
-0.00440019,
0.0201085713,
0.0006805624,
0.0201649796,
-0.0402102545,
0.0252332501,
-0.0539193451,
-0.0398584008,
0.0071261688,
0.0244601183,
-0.0608170591,
-0.0285719037,
0.0021560576,
0.0071908799,
-0.0470527858,
-0.0598042235,
-0.0346803963,
0.02486738,
0.0102469521,
0.0112714842,
0.027489474,
-0.0371951498,
0.0468631089,
0.0394087173,
-0.0297418982,
-0.001709481,
0.0519532561,
-0.0002232778,
-0.045009695,
0.0226729717,
-0.0860531554,
-0.0380329341,
-0.0088350037,
0.0074906587,
-0.0374458395,
0.0019967358,
-0.0955786109,
-0.0278562363,
0.0045070173,
0.0326037407,
0.0910252929,
0.0647709221,
0.0127619142,
-0.0003253544,
-0.0174045023,
0.0153358812,
-0.0210395679,
0.0141997151,
-0.0382535607,
0.0290435441,
0.015002423,
0.0215017591,
-0.0424885564,
0.0404579677,
-0.0586074516,
0.0120153306,
-0.0377430245,
-0.0099953236,
-0.0369466096,
-0.0149453394,
-0.0049077994,
0.0168193672,
-0.0851204544,
-0.016014969,
0.019195253,
0.0442438424,
-0.0251063257,
0.0402793661,
0.0244385842,
-0.0777542293,
-0.0411522575,
0.0256031845,
0.0142163932,
-0.0465605818,
0.0285829622,
0.0301404148,
-0.0132886162,
-0.0472504236,
-0.0303953253,
-0.0221153032,
0.0032472559,
-0.1014920399,
-0.0268651992,
-0.0922828615,
0.0228856355,
0.0122959306,
0.0110732736,
-0.054994233,
0.0190849546,
0.0100391442,
-0.0298439246,
0.0391374081,
-0.0289916247,
-0.0097357305,
0.0088532232,
0.0192725677,
0.0351023972,
0.0866650194,
0.0323790722,
0.0692346171,
-0.0303744134,
0.0070932265,
-0.0486240014,
0.0244457442,
0.0685207397,
0.0665096119,
-0.0299981181,
-0.0220663585,
-0.0189069603,
0.0343253836,
0.0807014406,
0.0898251683,
-0.0627179444,
-0.0067470749,
0.0728732049,
0.0577617437,
0.0284175575,
0.0346732326,
0.0456635058,
-0.0206426885,
-0.0150772976,
0.0409240238,
-0.0293918476,
0.0174734406,
-0.0139150061,
0.0172209777,
0.0870784,
0.0645202547,
-0.040515922,
-0.0216852333,
0.0111049498,
0.0098915072,
-0.0085012289,
0.0323294736,
0.0312242452,
0.0250366386,
-0.0389615595,
0.0818014517,
0.0535758622,
-0.0549157821,
-0.0033365046,
-0.0740593001,
0.0018643063,
0.0249403678,
0.0328768566,
0.0115139484,
-0.0093276398,
-0.0029666016,
0.0019651004,
0.0241015553,
0.0197908469,
0.0268351063,
0.0409586914,
-0.0497453548,
0.0081910267,
-0.0150396004,
0.0219623577,
0.0364141837,
0.0265164468,
0.0378276296,
0.0350851864,
-0.0159766022,
-0.0343822502,
0.0192190949,
-0.0086416267,
-0.0426879935,
0.0238726214,
0.0028995275,
0.0202496294,
-0.0175326429,
-0.0224125367,
0.0050700763,
0.0275528114,
-0.0533415675,
0.0404019691,
-0.0501747616,
-0.0362300947,
-0.0235520583,
0.0241746213,
-0.000027674,
0.0276355688,
0.0284034591,
-0.0464073606,
-0.0516155325,
0.0373230875,
-0.0179175157,
-0.0044448087,
-0.0659388527,
0.0056338115,
0.0142994439,
0.030741211,
-0.0399748795,
0.0268026907,
-0.0216236226,
0.031470377,
0.0360469297,
0.0209104475,
-0.0041416134,
-0.0452157408,
-0.0482199304,
-0.0016622285,
0.0103247212,
0.0468063578,
0.0321829803,
0.0153662255,
0.0112886643,
-0.0116262417,
-0.0828511566,
0.048396714,
-0.0450856984,
0.0244300961,
0.038627442,
0.0576885864,
0.0164919272,
0.0013093512,
-0.0205694884,
0.0096245101,
0.023112854,
0.0245983209,
-0.0107785417,
0.0146313179,
-0.0070778471,
-0.0230450686,
-0.024711838,
0.0521092154,
0.0089449976,
-0.0273436159,
0.0037663388,
-0.0402271487,
0.0702940226,
-0.0299051441,
0.03362545,
-0.0073251408,
-0.0483531021,
0.0067711193,
-0.0196996983,
0.033228375,
0.0431430377,
0.0000033632,
0.0348553695,
0.0291249324,
0.0230644476,
-0.0194316991,
0.0163383558,
-0.0231424589,
-0.0632351339,
-0.0237715188,
-0.0152024115,
-0.0199517757,
0.0826506764,
-0.0004861946,
-0.0255418364,
-0.0422184803,
0.002206238,
0.0174425859,
-0.0315396227,
-0.0096588368,
0.0355060063,
0.0076185279,
0.0361707471,
-0.0335416049,
-0.0791350454,
0.0336219743,
-0.0585446693,
0.0108765913,
0.0083539849,
-0.0226533096,
-0.0198806506,
0.0250217915,
0.0175194107,
0.034199927,
-0.0481964499,
0.003177366,
-0.0607848056,
0.0134930639,
0.0189791564,
-0.022167528,
0.0494424663,
-0.0422366038,
0.0156636294,
-0.0577797517,
-0.0373738259,
0.0073789996,
-0.0057443203,
0.0006560725,
0.0297809634,
0.0606674254,
-0.0294268038,
-0.0025176208,
0.015728021,
-0.0211313795,
0.0586618148,
-0.0272517689,
-0.010441754,
-0.0271838196,
0.014076869,
0.0589145198,
0.0276112743,
-0.0047830506,
-0.048220586,
-0.0436529256,
0.0265523884,
0.0099612139,
0.0111207785,
-0.0568167567,
0.0140783461,
0.0382936187,
0.0184733346,
-0.0063761827,
0.0326565653,
0.0840912014,
-0.0666666552,
-0.024592001,
0.0800440013,
-0.0158821288,
-0.0253512301,
0.0173187107,
0.0493814796,
0.0902348608,
0.0192436855,
0.012840963,
-0.1003761441,
-0.03461878,
0.0019238506,
0.0343370549,
0.0026470805,
0.0026859404,
-0.0031184822,
-0.0501093417,
0.0192114692,
0.0478183255,
-0.0165996347,
-0.0504082814,
-0.0080638342,
-0.0101282839,
-0.0116672171,
0.0184335876,
0.001251027,
-0.0019454868,
0.0057063503,
0.029157972,
0.0388560407,
-0.0603679828,
0.0058894954,
-0.0037503426,
0.0151202474,
0.0344846286,
0.0187077653,
0.0093334569,
-0.0205925126,
0.0017658367,
-0.0037588505,
-0.0032555729,
-0.0259763841,
0.0151701588,
0.0175028779,
-0.0147360452,
0.0136328917,
0.0171574038,
0.0052872994,
0.0041204439,
-0.012731934,
0.0454040989,
-0.0266833641,
-0.0147629455,
0.033913482,
-0.0246400386,
0.0033850931,
0.0332345366,
0.0275573079,
-0.0056202319,
-0.0605292805,
-0.0260190275,
-0.0132268071,
-0.052183751,
-0.0115593551,
-0.0223244652,
-0.0065097813,
-0.0480353832,
-0.0185164344,
0.0194793213,
0.0115796216,
0.0517468303,
-0.0338222347,
0.0203955825,
-0.0010083441,
-0.0119072581,
-0.0660913661,
0.0174307674,
-0.0470876619,
0.022054268,
-0.0504124351,
-0.0500602014,
-0.0085420879,
-0.0319047645,
0.0143915862,
0.0205959827,
-0.1755247712,
-0.0832410902,
-0.0252813883,
0.0354108177,
0.0158113316,
0.0656683072,
0.0061572692,
-0.0656870306,
0.0496493541,
0.0733935386,
-0.0414515361,
0.0674600005,
0.017804129,
-0.0374729745,
-0.0167788137,
0.059093114,
0.0014516338,
0.0126868542,
0.0145118609,
0.0509285666,
0.006118896,
-0.0650569722,
-0.0040247883,
0.013153512,
0.0220553186,
-0.0372902043,
0.0114190876,
-0.0229843911,
0.0171645787,
0.038195204,
0.0045785983,
-0.0485081002,
-0.0633778274,
0.0292554926,
-0.006758716,
-0.0235149302,
-0.0199329965,
0.0436912812,
0.0198595207,
-0.0497300848,
0.0046772426,
-0.028587753,
0.0052414755,
0.063895382,
0.0108250016,
-0.0229111295,
0.0164531544,
-0.0183348954,
0.0435998663,
-0.0400280096,
0.0241587944,
0.0159610063,
0.0283255577,
-0.0438099802,
0.0249946248,
-0.0246454421,
-0.0759902596,
-0.0526847988,
0.0110083027,
0.0711035803,
0.0040428415,
0.052707307,
-0.0220592152,
-0.0272914246,
-0.0356118754,
0.0327311866,
-0.0165014602,
0.0002109301,
0.0202166736,
0.0249804966,
0.0044972734,
0.0186603274,
0.0663708299,
0.0298529267,
0.0369250402,
0.0195494834,
-0.0037027539,
-0.006119323,
-0.068862088,
-0.0288401917,
0.0333155319,
0.0129843252,
-0.0000048186,
0.0053662057,
-0.0651571527,
-0.0164101142,
-0.0117573813,
0.0126790283,
-0.0380719677,
0.02660539,
0.0461166538,
-0.0262261592,
-0.0012790759,
-0.0289812032,
0.0048558661,
0.0167740472,
-0.0009366628,
-0.0129837329,
-7.161033709e-33,
-0.0429336876,
-0.0072999508,
0.041066058,
0.0055481684,
-0.0447017327,
-0.0074755554,
-0.0349540859,
-0.0103606768,
-0.0132265398,
0.0313503928,
0.0108877942,
-0.0028909361,
0.0071628909,
0.0358153507,
-0.040918462,
0.0217080507,
0.0863624662,
0.0099621089,
-0.0159646682,
0.0539286397,
0.0130302971,
0.0139642954,
0.0476048738,
0.0074775293,
-0.0520979129,
-0.0324598663,
-0.0066395747,
-0.0118029043,
-0.0109558813,
-0.0001349514,
-0.0165896751,
0.0422774181,
-0.003421098,
-0.0007826055,
-0.0356148221,
-0.03594888,
-0.0701061338,
-0.0126026329,
0.0308684185,
-0.0119839013,
-0.0040765554,
-0.043307621,
0.0154809263,
0.0210801736,
-0.0149077801,
-0.0411577076,
-0.0449106507,
-0.0036216355,
-0.0596480444,
-0.0420328006,
-0.0720388293,
0.0194083769,
0.0050586388,
-0.0305510275,
0.0489355251,
-0.0480921492,
-0.0405133888,
-0.0134899179,
-0.0294364337,
-0.0210725144,
0.0183751155,
0.1193449497,
0.0585151836,
0.039741043,
-0.015715953,
0.0188424308,
-0.0043426575,
0.0294489861,
0.0024948684,
0.0564360432,
0.0739089102,
0.0366316549,
0.004705078,
0.0101799732,
0.0823839977,
-0.0170161519,
-0.0608827993,
-0.0172880907,
-0.0422182307,
0.0454716831,
0.0549340621,
0.0348226689,
0.0247945078,
-0.043591693,
-0.0467224717,
-0.0013940189,
-0.0475311577,
0.0054193824,
0.0049877088,
0.0495156758,
-0.0221967977,
-0.0137769878,
0.0422001742,
-0.0183269419,
0.0177818723,
-0.0137334652,
-0.0331268497,
-0.0129880346,
-0.0194281805,
0.0348971337,
-0.0190635938,
-0.0753035918,
0.0214724708,
0.014361836,
0.0048587071,
-0.0054197772,
0.0307552367,
0.0411704183,
-0.0501601361,
-0.0112480894,
-0.0676806122,
0.0278942063,
0.0137456814,
0.0616381094,
0.0298393834,
-0.0102989897,
-0.002522106,
0.0499243513,
-0.0241419468,
-0.0109300688,
-0.0336689241,
-0.0102159819,
0.0184320379,
0.0323378593,
-0.0556717962,
0.0351296589,
-0.0454730541,
-0.005093765,
0.0215332881,
-0.0555317141,
-0.0593494065,
-0.0037959157,
2.958e-7,
0.0008877274,
0.0007157031,
0.0027230452,
0.0218179096,
-0.0056901695,
-0.0043844627,
0.0206232462,
0.005662722,
0.0001869825,
-0.021860607,
0.029114943,
0.0518861786,
0.0548964515,
0.011418418,
-0.0472754911,
0.0423672162,
-0.0387308672,
0.0309703257,
-0.051104039,
-0.0490875319,
-0.0050304323,
0.0751585215,
-0.0243794601,
-0.0244766362,
0.0750013292,
0.0098386323,
0.0445055738,
0.016650768,
0.0030587011,
0.010006859,
0.0295262448,
0.0242923163,
-0.008777177,
-0.0162723307,
-0.0268936884,
-0.0083714975,
-0.0249534287,
0.0762658119,
-0.0382558443,
-0.0027133129,
0.0159715731,
-0.0126111731,
-0.0095433863,
-0.0258489102,
0.0272691138,
-0.0129807005,
-0.0091415243,
-0.0705798045,
0.0158002563,
-0.0036613448,
0.0166033898,
-0.0452317037,
0.0169678815,
0.0286400318,
0.0230169836,
-0.0046379496,
-0.0325787365,
-0.0599462613,
-0.0062635611,
0.0229588505,
-0.0478111543,
-0.0719390735,
-0.0811403021,
-0.0107187238,
0.0133123146,
-0.0295801759,
-0.0022318221,
3.012761027e-34,
0.0340112858,
-0.0186332501,
0.0101527143,
0.0286478326,
0.0443961881,
-0.0229810644,
-0.0175194945,
0.0265018437,
-0.0085314028,
-0.068936564,
-0.0560715236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06918v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06918v2 | Improving Contrastive Learning of Sentence Embeddings with Focal-InfoNCE | 2023-10-10T18:15:24 | 2023-10-20T19:39:40 | Pengyue Hou, Xingyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The recent success of SimCSE has greatly advanced state-of-the-art sentence
representations. However, the original formulation of SimCSE does not fully
exploit the potential of hard negative samples in contrastive learning. This
study introduces an unsupervised contrastive learning framework that combines
SimCSE with hard negative mining, aiming to enhance the quality of sentence
embeddings. The proposed focal-InfoNCE function introduces self-paced
modulation terms in the contrastive objective, downweighting the loss
associated with easy negatives and encouraging the model focusing on hard
negatives. Experimentation on various STS benchmarks shows that our method
improves sentence embeddings in terms of Spearman's correlation and
representation alignment and uniformity. | [
0.0055011637,
0.0093716392,
-0.0096833231,
0.0293156877,
-0.0520215891,
-0.0038905861,
-0.0187735502,
-0.0505350865,
-0.0527486354,
-0.0353273936,
-0.0409097262,
-0.0301165376,
-0.0089891953,
-0.0126382681,
0.0323434658,
-0.0408735946,
0.0407053456,
0.0426165611,
0.0112580098,
0.0082559679,
0.0465491153,
0.0069635157,
-0.0405043289,
-0.0008951106,
-0.0170161407,
-0.0365840197,
0.0067024073,
0.0204438921,
0.047872752,
-0.0636386797,
0.0297113657,
0.0381720699,
0.0248304997,
0.0042504491,
0.0000017156,
-0.0142490827,
0.0146424258,
-0.0179590173,
-0.0140409507,
0.0414505117,
0.0909554213,
-0.0612732321,
0.0067315362,
0.0103368172,
-0.0142722558,
0.0126342997,
0.026044149,
0.0779830292,
0.0513915569,
0.0770341903,
-0.0138972709,
-0.0342528075,
0.0106446045,
-0.0419358686,
-0.0209531039,
0.0170043278,
0.007189576,
-0.0367637947,
-0.0214673784,
0.0531464182,
-0.0062615988,
0.0371250361,
0.0375020653,
0.0362657756,
0.0167333689,
0.034744706,
-0.0352800451,
0.0565450825,
-0.0290171392,
0.0573295057,
0.01842428,
-0.0062634684,
-0.0357284844,
-0.0204581972,
-0.0184537806,
-0.0187234245,
-0.0514280647,
0.0009077489,
0.0480435342,
0.0428878628,
0.0504324399,
0.0417002663,
0.005123761,
-0.0030780451,
0.0149070034,
-0.0260441303,
0.0266280025,
-0.0727512911,
0.0233126674,
0.0089058448,
-0.053391207,
0.0511337444,
0.0152568305,
-0.019880306,
0.0142466668,
-0.0111270463,
-0.0126829185,
-0.0442444347,
0.0278525595,
-0.0647636279,
-0.0013446506,
0.0286572687,
-0.0168670341,
0.0354650021,
-0.038160909,
-0.0000577651,
-0.0033128057,
0.0310096368,
-0.0281893015,
-0.0222718436,
-0.0410108715,
-0.0227656942,
-0.0155145535,
0.0520073771,
-0.0130467173,
-0.0392402373,
-0.018108841,
-0.0001727058,
-0.0414517,
-0.0034486246,
-0.0014649566,
0.0229887161,
-0.0385753214,
-0.0018438617,
-0.0098690577,
0.0477984212,
-0.0413101949,
-0.0009190345,
-0.0202085823,
0.008803051,
-0.0406111889,
0.0274634827,
0.0209100377,
-0.0121409614,
-0.0047620386,
0.0176550653,
-0.0146456948,
-0.0401040539,
-0.0287923049,
-0.0058370433,
-0.0303205792,
-0.0544826202,
-0.0073193447,
-0.0430527441,
-0.011841692,
-0.005706138,
-0.021979006,
-0.0238580126,
0.0090786684,
0.0126910219,
0.0082826549,
0.0512096956,
0.0319317468,
-0.0503033139,
-0.0650072023,
0.0043197391,
0.0448982455,
0.0762702748,
-0.0019897374,
-0.0014021837,
0.0199182201,
0.0337398387,
0.0079993382,
-0.0125634279,
0.0143932076,
0.0046564196,
-0.0403196774,
0.0055280668,
-0.0112354308,
0.0278136358,
0.0343654044,
0.0369588658,
-0.030395491,
-0.0400472507,
0.0450427234,
0.010934432,
0.005003944,
0.0201138332,
0.0368680954,
0.0555324107,
-0.038428165,
0.0068477066,
-0.018981982,
0.0476572886,
0.0002514367,
0.0346724689,
0.0096215056,
-0.011521982,
-0.041645553,
-0.0002881764,
-0.0095969168,
-0.0421440639,
0.0018706532,
-0.0329758897,
0.0501539372,
-0.0078706658,
-0.068424426,
0.0347100534,
0.0345377177,
-0.0440008007,
-0.0587933175,
0.0415941663,
0.0010018062,
0.0510682128,
0.0186568908,
-0.0335154012,
-0.0539979711,
-0.0271277614,
-0.0026523632,
0.0851108208,
0.0216859654,
-0.0067324117,
0.0182444975,
-0.0677674711,
-0.0191908982,
-0.0103873294,
0.0164929908,
-0.0118930377,
-0.0224523526,
0.0263488628,
0.0493458137,
-0.0113822576,
-0.0015966092,
0.0234982949,
0.0135213258,
-0.0317777917,
0.0071634199,
0.0183373932,
0.0105704674,
0.0245360639,
-0.0167045016,
0.0168920681,
0.0550812781,
-0.0639049709,
-0.0263336021,
0.0139323156,
-0.1044118479,
-0.1005662531,
0.0229806695,
-0.0997591466,
0.0000100729,
0.1033663079,
-0.0357731283,
-0.0150158647,
0.0448358543,
-0.0388756096,
-0.0020331217,
-0.0385339297,
0.0007666787,
0.0435334109,
0.0585599542,
-0.0217612293,
0.0488212034,
-0.0400502048,
0.0065934095,
0.0170487259,
-0.0101880766,
0.0106579335,
-0.0447633602,
-0.0129995402,
-0.0444112904,
0.0184324086,
0.0077558435,
0.0099068861,
-0.0261510406,
-0.0270642862,
0.0054868911,
-0.0858603492,
0.040609546,
-0.0182977952,
0.0075572082,
0.0656513423,
-0.0115695093,
0.0089601288,
0.0181037672,
-0.0271302164,
0.0131485183,
-0.0357624032,
0.0217848197,
0.042283643,
-0.0013435924,
-0.0156794637,
-0.0242556073,
0.0007339348,
-0.0402550437,
0.0493571237,
-0.0732990354,
0.0149756623,
-0.0203027874,
0.0312041454,
0.0103832223,
-0.0126393503,
0.0002063052,
-0.0560665987,
0.0032746901,
-0.0129715102,
0.0373607092,
0.0246102996,
0.0349136367,
-0.0015926537,
0.0215476211,
0.0053680097,
0.0032163986,
0.0044746497,
-0.0320343263,
0.0763440803,
-0.0042051249,
-0.0172906797,
-0.0250867493,
0.0953375325,
0.0067877374,
0.0087443804,
-0.0466690734,
-0.0208051056,
0.0037245336,
0.0117156468,
0.0107785752,
0.0427480489,
-0.0177565292,
-0.053765934,
-0.0471592285,
-0.0003531157,
0.0619690008,
-0.0193223264,
-0.038275484,
-0.063562721,
-0.0361537524,
-0.0148021569,
0.004283512,
-0.0197074581,
0.0052986792,
0.028281264,
0.0268357601,
-0.0381571092,
-0.063320674,
0.0249581262,
0.0174181685,
0.0038156137,
0.0163012464,
-0.0207347497,
-0.0105254808,
-0.0251075476,
-0.0211452562,
-0.1226914674,
-0.0086803362,
0.0435776301,
0.038342528,
0.0312208831,
-0.0214845873,
-0.0170739144,
-0.002504586,
0.0110323932,
-0.0307588484,
-0.0099957148,
-0.0304111913,
0.040655978,
0.0711423829,
0.0005407858,
0.0134918094,
-0.0168320034,
0.0244653523,
0.0333233252,
0.0064322273,
0.0024561312,
-0.0246509127,
-0.0257848836,
0.0161778666,
-0.0112746712,
0.0159043819,
0.0171935689,
0.0394598618,
-0.0127347112,
-0.0407056548,
0.1228551045,
0.0242234133,
-0.0229273122,
0.0264270697,
0.0049786884,
0.0358129777,
0.0360632502,
-0.0476698279,
-0.03169946,
-0.0405343249,
-0.0306243487,
0.012544049,
0.0066434848,
0.0106978687,
-0.0128879724,
-0.0852771774,
-0.0030778211,
0.0297368262,
-0.0123613039,
-0.0160497129,
-0.0070014317,
-0.0321140885,
-0.033080142,
0.0131113427,
-0.0052427691,
-0.0061797053,
0.0038479152,
0.0265099909,
-0.0263436846,
-0.0422047488,
-0.0317549966,
-0.0557306744,
0.0393143855,
0.0100157214,
0.0282911099,
-0.0194465835,
-0.0517037362,
0.0357870385,
-0.0718987659,
-0.0184442308,
-0.0158935394,
0.0701830089,
-0.0381062999,
-0.0018691282,
-0.0389226861,
0.0240143202,
-0.0681788549,
-0.0336152278,
-0.0090905763,
0.073367849,
-0.0042137834,
0.0414853245,
-0.0337103046,
0.0393974409,
0.0168292057,
0.0870227516,
0.0077455649,
-0.0359525047,
0.0057772635,
0.0127487378,
0.0350675061,
-0.0326945372,
-0.0436376482,
-0.009197806,
0.0488011949,
0.0367988497,
-0.0597013123,
-0.0803499967,
-0.0059280414,
0.0669250861,
-0.0272429064,
0.0326827802,
-0.0619754232,
-0.0255800541,
-0.0496554002,
0.0078064441,
-0.0257725827,
0.0094854804,
-0.0176417716,
-0.010180518,
0.0252329875,
-0.0034246105,
-0.0217308681,
-0.0315493532,
-0.0722169876,
-0.0505259372,
-0.0268581882,
0.0305205509,
0.001063062,
0.0291243698,
-0.0076374505,
0.0301915724,
0.095741801,
0.0607283115,
-0.027255293,
-0.0012967468,
0.0876358151,
-0.0409866683,
0.0243961811,
0.0394384488,
-0.0063252063,
-0.0048001171,
0.0379062705,
0.0567811951,
-0.0015134155,
0.02903945,
0.0338548757,
-0.0256325696,
0.1116661951,
0.0033801114,
-0.0273285266,
-0.0067367819,
0.0026560605,
-0.0552374162,
-0.0033066676,
-0.0270121265,
0.013913813,
0.0190372448,
0.0244849939,
-0.0362791196,
0.0211456865,
-0.0265279096,
-0.0078549013,
-0.0103156529,
-0.0005346205,
0.0185277145,
-0.0197543073,
-0.0327678919,
0.0278463345,
-0.0370902307,
-0.0216525681,
-0.0284944363,
-0.0012613065,
-0.0159940086,
0.0218193028,
0.0059561487,
0.0034207369,
-0.0268376265,
0.0433785021,
-0.0581240058,
0.0728733838,
-0.0244055893,
-0.025764361,
0.0611026362,
-0.0358195864,
0.0418912694,
-0.0075685191,
-0.0032995138,
-0.0119990353,
0.0355927832,
-0.0462500975,
0.0115926666,
0.0211249515,
0.0186096504,
-0.0249324515,
-0.0007020988,
0.0714375377,
-0.0445146263,
0.0250811633,
0.0069946535,
-0.0204068888,
-0.042983789,
0.0048374748,
0.0224122442,
0.0616978034,
0.0101934681,
0.0244819578,
-0.0375193991,
-0.0445356816,
0.0382314362,
0.0118798371,
-0.0167152788,
-0.0164613277,
0.0574592575,
0.0110589443,
-0.0249260459,
-0.0283106174,
-0.0033502502,
0.0138754416,
0.0224545728,
-0.0338237919,
-0.0453986041,
-6.470537307e-33,
-0.0169016607,
0.0480285063,
-0.0306279697,
-0.0205503386,
-0.0282146763,
0.0255588479,
-0.0234867223,
0.0040227491,
0.0274758954,
0.0591901504,
0.0315546542,
0.0199052095,
-0.0044576628,
0.0491766147,
-0.0204722416,
-0.0112843076,
0.0634173378,
0.0176986568,
-0.0197629221,
-0.013432404,
0.0471211299,
0.0526974909,
0.0885056928,
-0.076438196,
-0.0280318242,
-0.0086810514,
0.0242070034,
0.0206500776,
0.0542274341,
0.0485779829,
-0.0139625287,
0.0752026215,
0.0175176933,
-0.0643775016,
-0.0172124263,
-0.0281509832,
-0.0526561625,
-0.0479092002,
0.0155312466,
-0.0093736546,
-0.0264192913,
-0.0567187443,
0.032504864,
-0.0148460539,
0.0043713152,
0.0143180769,
0.0132153733,
-0.010931395,
0.0044479794,
0.0106521966,
-0.0905266404,
-0.0030377209,
-0.0013908972,
-0.0169344172,
0.0157506354,
0.0117509766,
0.01758199,
0.0046698782,
-0.0096484916,
-0.0138367843,
-0.0171843991,
0.0461015292,
0.0081524896,
0.010695342,
-0.0115887653,
0.0662646443,
0.017097326,
-0.0109138843,
0.0533343777,
-0.0107647516,
0.0195932575,
0.0062074997,
0.0766015947,
0.0917194486,
0.031037163,
0.0285348762,
-0.0790804327,
0.0280200448,
0.0084777111,
0.0111730741,
0.0490037948,
0.0288820602,
-0.0431706719,
-0.0228547975,
0.0333465785,
-0.0273346491,
0.0043617394,
-0.0226475764,
0.0310310107,
0.0099992035,
-0.0249390397,
0.069419533,
0.0156634599,
-0.0358232148,
0.0034924746,
0.050836388,
-0.0263095517,
-0.0060664951,
0.025357103,
-0.0239082463,
-0.1051927879,
0.0059272982,
0.0210989509,
0.0347360745,
0.0026149568,
-0.0173579529,
0.0859673396,
0.0071524936,
-0.0770308822,
-0.021907663,
-0.0096754655,
-0.03222261,
-0.0225007553,
-0.0325968526,
0.0212166011,
0.0221377071,
-0.0399509482,
0.0609746799,
0.0269599799,
-0.0439840592,
-0.016819153,
-0.0051953169,
0.0181220472,
0.0394163132,
0.0060452316,
0.0116613638,
-0.0183285922,
-0.0065666651,
0.0399402678,
-0.09305536,
-0.0239941459,
-0.0178112853,
2.407e-7,
-0.00260717,
0.0072632027,
0.0146629736,
0.0131058805,
0.0367344357,
0.0648238286,
-0.0223262757,
0.0351694785,
-0.035579361,
0.0261320993,
0.061970327,
0.0419096164,
0.0177186299,
0.0165570788,
-0.0736139417,
0.0381146707,
-0.0513928384,
-0.0336324349,
-0.0145248407,
0.0252951104,
0.087491475,
0.1107073948,
0.0304084942,
0.0201919582,
0.0153986877,
-0.0292996988,
0.0557894669,
-0.0276784189,
-0.0079410421,
-0.0548507757,
-0.0306761954,
0.0017591986,
-0.0265544951,
0.0144529566,
0.0129143922,
0.0368026607,
0.0029544909,
-0.0120037533,
0.0005424573,
-0.0574737117,
0.0029214334,
0.0027660958,
-0.0024184051,
0.0184542798,
0.0802173615,
-0.0875091031,
-0.0315682627,
-0.0417473055,
-0.0628205538,
0.0182271115,
0.0165017862,
0.0193725973,
-0.0522046685,
-0.0281475149,
0.0150532816,
0.011787829,
-0.0413872302,
-0.0638822392,
-0.0018016124,
0.0638588369,
-0.004533594,
-0.0165660214,
-0.0174622294,
0.0379797742,
0.0410925448,
-0.0430721454,
0.0152114658,
2.174779114e-34,
0.0490157306,
0.0145389084,
0.0064134421,
0.0105615482,
-0.0032579319,
-0.0297022182,
-0.044455491,
-0.0647426248,
0.0598350912,
-0.0437928289,
0.000833408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06913v1 | A Comparative Study of Transformer-based Neural Text Representation Techniques on Bug Triaging | 2023-10-10T18:09:32 | 2023-10-10T18:09:32 | Atish Kumar Dipongkor, Kevin Moran | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.IR | Often, the first step in managing bug reports is related to triaging a bug to
the appropriate developer who is best suited to understand, localize, and fix
the target bug. Additionally, assigning a given bug to a particular part of a
software project can help to expedite the fixing process. However, despite the
importance of these activities, they are quite challenging, where days can be
spent on the manual triaging process. Past studies have attempted to leverage
the limited textual data of bug reports to train text classification models
that automate this process -- to varying degrees of success. However, the
textual representations and machine learning models used in prior work are
limited by their expressiveness, often failing to capture nuanced textual
patterns that might otherwise aid in the triaging process. Recently, large,
transformer-based, pre-trained neural text representation techniques such as
BERT have achieved greater performance in several natural language processing
tasks. However, the potential for using these techniques to improve upon prior
approaches for automated bug triaging is not well studied or understood.
Therefore, in this paper we offer one of the first investigations that
fine-tunes transformer-based language models for the task of bug triaging on
four open source datasets, spanning a collective 53 years of development
history with over 400 developers and over 150 software project components. Our
study includes both a quantitative and qualitative analysis of effectiveness.
Our findings illustrate that DeBERTa is the most effective technique across the
triaging tasks of developer and component assignment, and the measured
performance delta is statistically significant compared to other techniques.
However, through our qualitative analysis, we also observe that each technique
possesses unique abilities best suited to certain types of bug reports. | [
0.0773721188,
0.0319337249,
-0.035834875,
0.0067311609,
-0.0164133012,
0.0017166251,
-0.0161986426,
0.0003627002,
0.0025745521,
-0.1070066988,
0.0216288175,
0.01379536,
0.0028963597,
0.0114812329,
0.0022002358,
-0.0356907323,
0.0270063467,
-0.012314749,
0.0000983733,
0.0456090346,
-0.0110279815,
0.028855959,
-0.0087978067,
0.086744003,
-0.0062446278,
-0.023385046,
0.0143486038,
-0.0047163507,
0.0163320992,
0.0049689556,
0.0274550635,
0.0048886766,
-0.0024290986,
0.0308146644,
0.0000021162,
-0.0179072879,
-0.0085255969,
0.011916901,
0.0444881208,
0.0272105914,
-0.0223594476,
-0.0631837845,
-0.0294956304,
0.0331006609,
-0.0054097716,
0.0030864214,
0.0490228049,
0.0196719971,
0.0556316264,
0.0317471474,
-0.0014436134,
0.0128451958,
0.0104586473,
0.0104062157,
0.0490240827,
-0.0221994538,
-0.0328757092,
0.0214675143,
-0.0003657927,
0.0310379565,
0.0308096465,
0.0257863421,
0.0203673635,
0.0008389596,
0.0184183363,
0.0361611992,
-0.0314122811,
-0.0172830485,
-0.0054380824,
0.0316932946,
-0.0687157139,
-0.0145861749,
-0.0079772146,
-0.0237898584,
-0.015747793,
0.0149623025,
0.032423649,
0.0071142823,
-0.0127663482,
-0.0185649861,
0.0288408622,
-0.0238253679,
-0.0086220047,
-0.040351171,
-0.0490975641,
0.0180197805,
-0.0244077463,
0.0144087914,
-0.0330590494,
-0.0282430071,
0.0061223111,
-0.0310784616,
0.0304322429,
0.0495223701,
0.0207451526,
0.0181469619,
-0.041248057,
-0.0587693602,
0.0563698374,
-0.0429816879,
-0.0347238742,
0.0319547355,
-0.087477237,
-0.0118892044,
-0.0402898453,
0.0590099171,
0.0186469909,
0.0523808226,
0.017279679,
0.0069174259,
-0.0694842041,
-0.0198404249,
-0.0470247753,
0.0260907169,
0.0222075637,
0.032578852,
0.0271987841,
0.0398397744,
0.0350446813,
0.0232472941,
0.0465455092,
0.0104819834,
-0.0667747557,
0.0176666509,
0.0004552357,
0.019072311,
-0.0229668655,
-0.0053586112,
-0.0275366995,
-0.0047869524,
-0.0059249895,
-0.0089004543,
-0.0376164429,
-0.0397326536,
-0.0066197133,
0.0266639832,
0.0192388166,
0.0031871393,
-0.039064195,
-0.009757543,
-0.0173352156,
0.0373418219,
-0.0556118451,
-0.0529230684,
-0.0359994359,
0.0312945843,
0.0142973848,
-0.0425793342,
-0.0103891604,
0.0010999374,
-0.0182654765,
0.0606518798,
-0.0752907023,
0.0163376313,
0.058760535,
0.0343037359,
0.0393686593,
0.0185654797,
0.0621151775,
0.0503426418,
0.0269382615,
-0.0067053349,
0.0516666435,
0.003707072,
-0.0466221087,
-0.0040280363,
0.0425017513,
-0.0016676638,
0.0053326371,
-0.011146931,
0.0239623729,
0.0311714616,
0.0055910796,
-0.0280763041,
0.017661944,
0.0338416621,
0.024897296,
0.0384111181,
0.0251150373,
0.0363443717,
-0.0292775314,
-0.0474576429,
-0.0042106849,
0.0635749027,
0.0071632778,
-0.0278497525,
-0.0151144927,
0.0257799178,
-0.0220928229,
-0.0541938581,
-0.0212282576,
-0.0259552952,
-0.0104306908,
-0.0156913605,
0.0553147867,
0.0145277437,
-0.0506446138,
0.0877366662,
0.0169409979,
-0.0235936567,
-0.0443958379,
-0.0364430584,
0.0104224198,
0.0528536998,
0.0355760455,
-0.0884560719,
-0.1162075549,
-0.0034115589,
-0.0312635079,
-0.0338737257,
0.0538049191,
-0.0107803782,
-0.0125541436,
-0.0389168598,
-0.0155061996,
-0.0482421853,
-0.0044966144,
0.0540182143,
-0.0197363794,
0.0057248343,
0.0034867011,
-0.0347812772,
-0.0513454489,
0.0437307991,
0.0055819922,
-0.0128226224,
0.0323118046,
-0.0084202765,
-0.0151103223,
-0.0193147063,
-0.0377554223,
0.0008863733,
0.0526718013,
-0.0260735452,
-0.0466392264,
0.0116472393,
0.0147966566,
-0.0327890888,
0.0194821879,
-0.0201860853,
-0.0083714398,
0.0505927019,
-0.0639457405,
0.0329711027,
0.0302835014,
-0.0386196375,
-0.0530577153,
0.0091916611,
0.0297657866,
-0.0439899899,
-0.0245809965,
-0.0548432507,
0.0348198228,
0.0333394073,
0.0043052421,
-0.0757031292,
0.0378150158,
0.0475087017,
-0.0059805787,
-0.065655835,
0.0342722535,
-0.0303071234,
0.0267339442,
0.0067480896,
0.0173096508,
0.040877685,
-0.066840522,
-0.0815088823,
-0.0309718326,
-0.006881217,
0.0169519875,
0.0064344993,
0.0047468762,
0.0306548402,
-0.0150040155,
-0.0192154497,
-0.0581520386,
-0.007659222,
-0.0198029727,
0.0628669932,
-0.0023713172,
-0.0066061718,
-0.0510336161,
-0.0151941814,
-0.0617072061,
0.0219996981,
0.0323984958,
-0.0710356534,
-0.1194334924,
0.0262779761,
-0.0267524496,
0.0294451769,
-0.0121941175,
-0.0513696633,
0.0055468073,
0.0128903417,
0.0347339697,
0.0148149142,
0.0204619709,
0.0402022786,
0.0294325221,
0.0452114418,
-0.0452002361,
0.0043201977,
0.0184410289,
-0.0189680178,
-0.0014632493,
-0.0678759441,
0.0747290999,
0.0554102249,
-0.0080818273,
-0.038482029,
-0.0507385023,
-0.00871222,
-0.0161097664,
0.0375513472,
0.0530194305,
-0.0495951027,
0.0341650173,
0.0062403628,
-0.0311178267,
-0.0530741289,
0.0835747123,
-0.0170193445,
0.002173634,
-0.1084989831,
0.0039192177,
-0.068076618,
0.079819575,
-0.0359675437,
0.0275813136,
0.0335421115,
-0.0370334312,
-0.0061001284,
0.009862287,
-0.0157902408,
0.0075228619,
0.0539260656,
-0.0439809822,
0.0313755497,
0.014096031,
-0.0074421554,
0.001140867,
-0.0360083245,
-0.0286579002,
0.0071012015,
0.0335421935,
-0.0009044345,
-0.0681796595,
0.0553957485,
0.0216325,
0.0600795373,
0.0713610277,
-0.0605071895,
-0.0058083241,
-0.0746460035,
-0.0404704846,
-0.003110297,
0.0145090083,
0.0249896571,
-0.0335259289,
0.0301185921,
0.0855869874,
0.0374261066,
-0.058261849,
-0.0362587385,
0.0005394254,
-0.0599176846,
-0.0427226126,
0.0160996635,
0.0151220448,
-0.0339802355,
-0.0128303235,
0.0669448748,
0.0760923624,
-0.0403479263,
0.0300856084,
0.0335163102,
-0.0089570004,
0.0547661148,
0.0373039581,
-0.0807176232,
-0.0313341692,
-0.0134245371,
0.004827552,
0.0183587801,
-0.0001270921,
0.0222212803,
-0.0570459142,
0.0096462844,
-0.0275976397,
0.0476454385,
-0.0292955656,
-0.022716172,
-0.0060491706,
-0.0103980144,
-0.0321988501,
-0.0172357708,
0.0046568005,
0.0093795992,
0.0143770827,
-0.0728763342,
-0.0087941345,
0.0288913492,
-0.0342667475,
-0.0071021342,
0.094633624,
0.0281746294,
0.022851726,
0.0086983284,
0.0300889201,
-0.0012384686,
0.0448885672,
0.0060720756,
0.0728155747,
0.0105421478,
-0.006492191,
0.0577097535,
-0.0514615849,
-0.0634092093,
-0.0139129423,
0.0075975833,
0.0309051145,
-0.0273756403,
0.0168192871,
-0.0202192273,
0.0030059877,
0.0185526516,
0.0046186354,
0.0435293913,
-0.0367951095,
-0.0186391622,
-0.0262886807,
0.0337377824,
-0.0225102399,
-0.0308541674,
0.0126256961,
-0.0215380434,
-0.0435004868,
-0.0964704901,
-0.0237294491,
-0.000373354,
0.0450514294,
0.0384721532,
-0.0691046938,
0.0441588834,
-0.019680718,
-0.0192993414,
0.04630097,
0.0538720228,
0.0295365732,
-0.0241950452,
-0.005718736,
0.0033229014,
0.0161819141,
-0.0333414674,
-0.0038709026,
-0.0501871519,
-0.0266423058,
-0.0203656927,
0.0525235832,
0.0104983468,
-0.0347072966,
-0.0536508709,
-0.1304587722,
-0.0221183673,
0.0578468665,
-0.0177454613,
0.0025105053,
-0.0011585711,
0.0002129105,
-0.0347838514,
-0.0118383234,
-0.0474785902,
0.0044547841,
-0.0197088625,
0.0014814514,
-0.0217935927,
-0.0057742866,
0.010342286,
-0.0243280753,
0.0409293771,
0.0685434937,
0.0271568652,
-0.0260943957,
-0.0017156345,
0.0125426101,
0.0024850848,
-0.0397851877,
0.0524962284,
0.0011860713,
-0.0488960221,
-0.0094453748,
0.0456967726,
-0.0550370291,
0.0332173854,
-0.0247463994,
0.0508458652,
0.0229386259,
0.0277095959,
0.0010795958,
0.0186083317,
-0.0038928464,
-0.0264644213,
0.0031891584,
0.0267195441,
-0.0201461855,
0.0153654972,
0.0140108457,
0.0414234139,
0.0038462498,
0.0200632717,
-0.052163031,
-0.0730963275,
0.0038519078,
-0.0352985747,
0.0087519847,
0.0580877997,
0.0221142489,
0.0097123468,
-0.0047431118,
0.0046745283,
0.0290003158,
-0.0004079954,
0.0162227582,
-0.0011443512,
0.0112647712,
-0.0048792888,
-0.0563385487,
0.0603136308,
-0.0312363245,
0.006208417,
-0.0248707589,
-0.0341973342,
-0.017085107,
0.0114745013,
0.0173591152,
-0.0462170765,
-0.0227172356,
-0.0441377051,
-0.0421182103,
-0.0175076909,
0.0631294101,
-0.0014927055,
0.0370789021,
-0.0173412021,
-0.0290982779,
0.0929019824,
0.0247458965,
-0.0213974416,
-0.0060896389,
-0.0449785329,
-0.03327398,
-0.023773564,
-0.0525515787,
-5.42382828e-33,
-0.0290866587,
-0.0370948911,
-0.0249752607,
-0.0213038437,
0.0232918691,
-0.0032278711,
-0.0329659581,
-0.0006220172,
0.0031879549,
-0.0107877934,
0.0060228673,
0.0264766626,
-0.0077906931,
-0.035587918,
0.0449597538,
0.0237154216,
0.0493656434,
0.0489906408,
-0.0383950844,
0.0415598638,
0.0049217651,
0.0252782479,
0.031405963,
-0.0738644302,
0.03100341,
0.0373256765,
0.0264643859,
0.0134489192,
0.0478623584,
0.0732770041,
0.0224882737,
0.0043148967,
0.0142536703,
-0.0224360377,
-0.0076703262,
-0.0369913056,
-0.0349612944,
-0.0195217133,
-0.0343356729,
-0.0037823941,
0.0618722104,
-0.0121274367,
0.0571691319,
0.0016921586,
0.0175153427,
-0.0066620377,
0.0703986511,
0.0176657643,
0.0003634629,
-0.0688194707,
-0.07231877,
0.0260554627,
-0.0351085775,
-0.0100113498,
-0.0111927157,
0.0657035708,
0.0246648807,
0.0383186713,
-0.0354935117,
-0.0634780824,
0.0031682311,
-0.0073712016,
0.0203712415,
-0.0081627229,
-0.0434184186,
0.0167694204,
0.0165896118,
0.0646456257,
-0.0337397307,
-0.0221305303,
0.045533929,
0.0223027747,
0.0653400049,
0.0014805864,
0.0275913589,
-0.0087005049,
-0.0376824774,
0.0595959052,
-0.0180034395,
0.0225177016,
0.024570195,
0.0415476598,
-0.057292074,
-0.0116547802,
-0.0295991115,
-0.0040928903,
-0.0253415927,
-0.0082972171,
0.0136434268,
0.0094959857,
-0.017639054,
0.0682600215,
0.0152240032,
-0.0357433707,
0.0227034781,
-0.0024312295,
-0.0407974906,
0.0449850485,
-0.0310956351,
0.0269575063,
-0.0110612372,
-0.0099252136,
0.0239789598,
0.0685826614,
0.0837560967,
-0.0153095862,
0.0433858782,
0.015832074,
-0.0645243004,
0.0477062538,
-0.0244377684,
0.0025532611,
-0.0296903141,
0.0763743818,
-0.0230463669,
-0.0094560925,
0.0052606328,
-0.008705426,
0.0077844616,
-0.0174817126,
-0.0364441276,
0.0598919839,
-0.0291617587,
0.005480818,
-0.0226432197,
-0.0320753977,
-0.0083903484,
0.0416255929,
0.0291751549,
-0.0440084264,
-0.0512133911,
0.0083156135,
2.688e-7,
0.0341644697,
0.0642342865,
0.0253426787,
-0.0292629134,
0.0144340042,
0.0403329171,
0.0064527905,
0.0277436674,
0.0458303951,
0.0319714807,
-0.014502544,
0.0023063249,
0.0199567992,
0.040072199,
-0.0246769283,
-0.0324879959,
-0.0237887651,
0.0233519971,
-0.0749356151,
0.0304170065,
0.0253223386,
0.0283924583,
0.0165536031,
0.0023617037,
-0.0073522045,
-0.0192684755,
0.0009497395,
-0.0059764464,
0.0285126269,
0.0865151063,
0.0436548628,
0.0487609729,
-0.0314156748,
-0.0174858458,
-0.0098371329,
-0.034822084,
-0.0135682318,
0.0020290203,
-0.0443150103,
-0.0142949838,
0.0166420918,
0.0011880283,
0.0001120077,
-0.043987155,
0.0035100842,
-0.0797616467,
-0.0181121435,
0.0479506552,
0.0371687487,
-0.0090746405,
-0.0092790248,
-0.0034989701,
0.0267904866,
0.0198188629,
-0.0031426449,
-0.0227376577,
-0.0009599226,
-0.1012536734,
-0.0277973451,
0.0434358753,
-0.0317430571,
-0.0100819087,
-0.0201428682,
-0.0118055297,
0.0554564446,
-0.0015858443,
0.0726782829,
2.561476118e-34,
0.0289418213,
-0.0175180975,
-0.0480450802,
-0.0242180377,
0.0413964204,
0.0043965066,
0.0418862775,
-0.0119404178,
-0.0119542656,
-0.0102354176,
-0.0300477538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06839v1 | LongLLMLingua: Accelerating and Enhancing LLMs in Long Context Scenarios via Prompt Compression | 2023-10-10T17:59:58 | 2023-10-10T17:59:58 | Huiqiang Jiang, Qianhui Wu, Xufang Luo, Dongsheng Li, Chin-Yew Lin, Yuqing Yang, Lili Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In long context scenarios, large language models (LLMs) face three main
challenges: higher computational/financial cost, longer latency, and inferior
performance. Some studies reveal that the performance of LLMs depends on both
the density and the position of the key information (question relevant) in the
input prompt. Inspired by these findings, we propose LongLLMLingua for prompt
compression towards improving LLMs' perception of the key information to
simultaneously address the three challenges. We conduct evaluation on a wide
range of long context scenarios including single-/multi-document QA, few-shot
learning, summarization, synthetic tasks, and code completion. The experimental
results show that LongLLMLingua compressed prompt can derive higher performance
with much less cost. The latency of the end-to-end system is also reduced. For
example, on NaturalQuestions benchmark, LongLLMLingua gains a performance boost
of up to 17.1% over the original prompt with ~4x fewer tokens as input to
GPT-3.5-Turbo. It can derive cost savings of \$28.5 and \$27.4 per 1,000
samples from the LongBench and ZeroScrolls benchmark, respectively.
Additionally, when compressing prompts of ~10k tokens at a compression rate of
2x-10x, LongLLMLingua can speed up the end-to-end latency by 1.4x-3.8x. Our
code is available at https://aka.ms/LLMLingua. | [
0.0141188586,
0.0074393386,
-0.0007157066,
0.0233186744,
-0.0258334372,
0.0015894084,
-0.0035033324,
0.0137479082,
-0.0234630723,
-0.0188541524,
0.0113975592,
-0.0319668055,
0.0006719533,
0.0269770809,
0.0302625988,
-0.0414546542,
0.0391163379,
-0.0412251465,
-0.0029702128,
-0.0081591699,
0.0038146125,
-0.0076216785,
0.0037895818,
0.0509439334,
0.0127287488,
-0.0493664555,
-0.0425435677,
0.0137309711,
-0.0165962018,
-0.0338024534,
-0.0255411472,
0.0601511262,
0.0192121826,
0.014890301,
0.0000023517,
-0.068630524,
-0.0229331646,
-0.0099275876,
-0.0939062312,
0.0380346142,
0.0246995259,
0.0152067142,
0.0019900857,
0.0402892642,
-0.0244375523,
-0.0014096075,
0.0255929548,
-0.0102443313,
0.0544659048,
0.0384418704,
-0.0011370626,
0.0038111841,
0.0219022762,
-0.0439002812,
0.03991054,
-0.0670889914,
-0.012921148,
-0.0407416523,
0.0401950069,
0.0234445482,
-0.0226501524,
0.0347427875,
0.0553420074,
-0.0133871417,
-0.0055891112,
0.0444948673,
-0.0251907185,
0.0008647874,
-0.0190907922,
0.0825999603,
-0.0110795908,
0.0081562279,
-0.0137431677,
-0.0100945188,
0.0274240728,
-0.066467315,
-0.0779200271,
0.0152077144,
-0.0192789529,
-0.0230823606,
-0.0267273821,
-0.0148441773,
-0.0006896079,
-0.0079146978,
-0.0374116227,
0.0261813644,
0.0176710188,
-0.02372339,
-0.034156166,
-0.0182312913,
-0.0110888937,
-0.0717477351,
-0.0056310864,
0.0617779307,
-0.05645914,
0.0101581924,
-0.0457901061,
-0.021836644,
0.0436939299,
0.0152082574,
0.008335541,
0.0552569963,
-0.0325964354,
0.0584635027,
-0.0477010719,
0.0768559128,
0.0098498445,
-0.013821004,
-0.0578450374,
-0.0062492657,
-0.0097796097,
-0.0026623413,
-0.044577837,
0.0550494082,
-0.0638340414,
-0.0179724451,
-0.019236343,
0.053159371,
0.037016008,
0.0352667309,
0.0150369667,
-0.0139227919,
-0.0218969118,
-0.0015142503,
-0.0084667141,
0.0302891843,
-0.0569736511,
-0.0155255711,
0.0271919314,
-0.0665029287,
-0.0272909012,
0.0106384857,
0.0175765119,
-0.0064407806,
0.0125699276,
0.0369747914,
-0.0013282009,
-0.0394116715,
-0.0269008093,
-0.0232840106,
-0.0076398137,
-0.0194345862,
-0.0340856537,
-0.0797722861,
0.0225042515,
0.01347961,
-0.0055350009,
0.0098170079,
-0.0175954178,
0.0374265574,
-0.0042948341,
0.0579606667,
-0.0034447443,
0.0183923114,
0.0411816202,
0.0167091936,
0.0006471471,
0.0590271205,
0.0130365528,
0.0423823744,
0.0456925109,
-0.0204560217,
0.0064251232,
0.0463599451,
0.0330394357,
0.0244037658,
-0.0029598677,
0.0304586794,
0.0370224081,
0.0244166441,
0.04829555,
0.0589650385,
-0.0171583816,
-0.0115344999,
0.0323307551,
0.0810175464,
0.016579397,
-0.0293695126,
0.0345703512,
0.0411537364,
-0.0121313594,
0.0005923137,
-0.0496342368,
0.0483417697,
-0.0373881459,
0.0449004993,
0.0731424242,
0.0197673813,
-0.0410021544,
-0.0282546468,
-0.0166145377,
-0.0145457489,
-0.0351267904,
0.0383070745,
-0.0018376821,
-0.0042778379,
-0.0588889234,
0.0599454194,
0.006780446,
-0.0606244504,
-0.0236427765,
-0.0593666472,
0.0461704358,
0.0548217185,
0.0435783938,
-0.022931641,
-0.039066352,
-0.0325016193,
0.0157159697,
0.0270695649,
0.0322113633,
-0.0154833151,
0.0077757505,
-0.048145581,
-0.0281024743,
-0.0043440266,
-0.0150546869,
0.0210356433,
0.020563608,
0.0208355244,
0.0158400126,
-0.0110195801,
0.0175161138,
0.0255437884,
-0.0390089899,
-0.0542671084,
0.006001872,
0.0124176564,
0.0185040087,
0.0051868302,
0.0079750074,
0.0077657285,
0.0340200886,
-0.0527036041,
0.0011989122,
-0.0301361345,
-0.084547393,
-0.0633879006,
0.0365226865,
0.0042782268,
0.0019160233,
0.0290858243,
-0.0430323966,
-0.055872526,
-0.0377998985,
-0.0304297302,
0.0101083005,
-0.0283526517,
0.0083530666,
0.006543614,
0.0169852506,
-0.0561821721,
0.0366525427,
-0.0171830934,
0.0267395526,
0.0513127744,
0.0457942262,
0.0109370621,
-0.0470072068,
-0.0100593269,
0.0226988699,
-0.0137089966,
-0.018797772,
0.0134290941,
0.0247431938,
-0.0335154831,
-0.0170690324,
-0.1119576469,
0.0162036624,
-0.026681982,
0.0186504684,
0.0178397428,
0.0388175696,
-0.0356701277,
-0.0185844656,
-0.0605595671,
-0.0043394011,
0.0091774417,
0.0263022389,
0.0217362866,
0.019184066,
0.0011520094,
-0.0405249372,
-0.0213275254,
0.0038142225,
0.0397648476,
-0.0353064761,
-0.0378237925,
-0.0327290632,
0.0446470752,
-0.0004959422,
-0.0026790164,
-0.0181175284,
-0.0168966018,
-0.0011198698,
-0.0435982123,
0.0802356824,
0.0604470521,
0.0186661817,
-0.0201360658,
0.0319096074,
0.0118979085,
-0.0614757054,
0.0391572788,
0.0055560735,
-0.0435161553,
-0.0030326487,
-0.0223625712,
0.0248824526,
0.0547555424,
-0.0101692323,
-0.0087519456,
-0.0343005396,
0.0064486596,
0.0084759388,
-0.0079436582,
-0.0573624112,
-0.0093709733,
-0.0295896754,
0.0592489392,
-0.0195900537,
-0.0436610319,
0.0756140798,
-0.0642062947,
-0.0173351038,
-0.0057200734,
-0.0023585095,
-0.0534124784,
0.0681497231,
-0.0048889215,
0.0005355628,
-0.008769352,
-0.0440124199,
-0.0454105847,
0.0099213384,
-0.0180998258,
-0.0405276865,
0.0322465785,
-0.0158422813,
0.0062578241,
-0.0464141071,
-0.0423636101,
-0.0205995776,
-0.0253935046,
-0.0108444327,
0.0056682713,
0.0131617943,
0.011900886,
0.016532978,
0.0218800101,
0.0183073785,
0.0852386057,
-0.0276274718,
-0.0039288756,
-0.0259901695,
0.0408398397,
0.0458737612,
0.0186861139,
0.0406509489,
-0.0217725504,
0.0734203681,
0.0477567464,
0.0917955041,
0.0215991866,
0.0207966268,
-0.008927335,
0.0382006317,
-0.0266246479,
-0.0325615369,
0.0602375828,
0.0598071329,
-0.0648865402,
-0.0089420071,
0.1280978322,
0.0366998427,
-0.071642451,
-0.0141939335,
-0.037916895,
0.0504952334,
0.0379672796,
0.0379084647,
-0.0965816751,
-0.0474785082,
0.036262542,
0.0259547494,
-0.0051550199,
-0.0384179316,
-0.0207289923,
-0.1323749721,
0.025973523,
-0.024471188,
-0.0386030748,
0.0097552817,
-0.0461824462,
-0.0075350329,
0.0387069769,
0.0442003086,
0.0454174578,
-0.0055580884,
-0.0092427656,
-0.0039603361,
-0.0304613188,
0.0094632609,
0.0399237312,
-0.0049846638,
0.0258375686,
0.0588464625,
-0.0024931699,
0.0063085547,
-0.0156560801,
0.0567552187,
0.0002133631,
0.0032012414,
-0.0094829993,
0.0199514981,
-0.0125786066,
0.0075858887,
0.0088138906,
0.0436443388,
-0.0163977314,
0.0016967463,
0.0412954092,
0.0578586943,
0.0038825565,
0.0109167416,
-0.0439710617,
-0.0176201034,
-0.0278238337,
0.0816767216,
0.0622669607,
-0.0400170535,
-0.0265816841,
-0.0318759382,
-0.0207069088,
-0.0233804919,
0.0037774188,
-0.00445071,
0.0127293896,
0.0088721616,
-0.0451323725,
-0.038854938,
0.0490912646,
0.0410569087,
-0.0233413726,
0.022133369,
-0.0400527269,
0.0284598488,
-0.0593226999,
0.0084280353,
-0.0471053161,
0.0131978262,
-0.0863356218,
0.0578441918,
0.0293796398,
-0.011454979,
-0.0161860269,
0.018267924,
-0.0988818407,
-0.0481451005,
-0.0440119952,
0.0314626619,
0.0243213736,
0.0511172302,
-0.0083594657,
-0.0470535569,
0.0440476537,
0.0452863574,
-0.0446304679,
0.0472918861,
-0.0075686914,
0.0246470291,
-0.0006717255,
0.0329824165,
-0.0750382319,
-0.0005055498,
-0.0269344803,
0.0360938236,
-0.0013757178,
-0.0617923886,
0.0132916132,
0.0619455501,
0.0128184296,
0.0022862465,
-0.0235611163,
0.0066759055,
0.0536760688,
-0.0120720789,
-0.0043651704,
-0.0297540203,
0.0190172698,
-0.0104507804,
-0.0419251248,
0.0431884155,
0.0046257493,
-0.0066047763,
0.0239422396,
-0.0318541303,
0.0081711179,
-0.0174513366,
-0.0112263057,
0.0519209765,
-0.0150600243,
-0.0350227281,
-0.0272833742,
0.0115802651,
0.0220703688,
-0.0263936743,
0.0621611997,
0.0155933984,
0.0162433591,
0.0129573829,
0.0381354503,
-0.0707397014,
-0.0581452064,
-0.0133556174,
0.0465136394,
0.0224072635,
0.0178933237,
-0.0055538351,
0.0097188791,
0.0070100776,
-0.039423354,
0.0091449264,
0.0198314916,
-0.0329685621,
0.0517123826,
0.0525419377,
0.0057365019,
0.0107329441,
0.0855975896,
-0.028374413,
0.022607537,
0.0094759194,
0.0239050966,
-0.0493923388,
-0.0112081012,
-0.0027970455,
0.0552887432,
0.0021556669,
0.0002571815,
-0.0421923883,
-0.0397570319,
0.0182004888,
0.0053922213,
-0.0199763216,
-0.0273182727,
0.0541694835,
0.0632805377,
0.0097153923,
-0.019990785,
-0.0116158053,
0.0194684453,
-0.0176548548,
-0.0281066187,
0.0317469463,
-6.614143778e-33,
-0.0390487611,
-0.0276073888,
0.0450430848,
-0.00591231,
-0.0241646562,
0.0132264821,
-0.0355764404,
-0.0140714459,
-0.0117262844,
-0.0440898314,
-0.0610954203,
0.0235665403,
0.009839939,
0.0278770104,
-0.0205259472,
-0.0058859517,
0.0435588844,
-0.0036544201,
-0.0242689885,
0.0476571843,
-0.0000566547,
0.027900612,
-0.0062616705,
0.0129313394,
-0.0011217088,
-0.0124700051,
0.0306339469,
0.0140485093,
0.0268135164,
0.0500558615,
-0.033231847,
0.0275395382,
0.0129260868,
-0.0861087143,
-0.0260423999,
0.0562900826,
-0.0618145466,
-0.0308992732,
0.0121297203,
-0.028269764,
-0.0174403731,
-0.0726347268,
0.034971673,
-0.0060133706,
0.0055755568,
-0.016172668,
0.0106595466,
-0.0279889051,
-0.0531827658,
-0.0527700707,
-0.0295352601,
0.0108600808,
-0.008924867,
-0.0178478062,
0.019213777,
0.0573400147,
-0.0032875184,
0.0684818178,
-0.0176074188,
0.0022552677,
-0.0027457743,
0.0662391484,
0.0682882369,
0.014047795,
0.0126057761,
0.0269133262,
0.0234713331,
-0.0125123272,
-0.0207184833,
0.0054948744,
0.0292273555,
-0.0025427376,
0.042702917,
0.0483649783,
0.0563093051,
-0.008821168,
-0.0495468304,
0.032283619,
0.0311301704,
0.0179818347,
0.0234907027,
-0.0045434176,
-0.0163858514,
-0.0183298606,
-0.0644039065,
0.0282590799,
-0.0359975919,
-0.0088100145,
0.0541920215,
0.0104808956,
-0.0076633869,
-0.0658302754,
0.0628840998,
-0.0173095725,
0.0152369225,
0.0134568699,
-0.0163422115,
0.038240511,
0.0025440033,
0.0391827263,
-0.0345722958,
0.0215411242,
0.0148014473,
-0.0142599726,
0.0113488007,
0.0115278717,
0.0096436124,
0.0086942092,
-0.0754960775,
-0.0002997929,
-0.0132353539,
0.0158585552,
-0.0005364427,
-0.0159050766,
0.0471280925,
-0.0128536131,
0.0105815167,
0.0581084453,
-0.021602435,
-0.0269604158,
-0.0151950102,
-0.0493688844,
-0.0067956042,
0.0212053303,
-0.0395316035,
-0.0145557979,
-0.0408658944,
0.0530741513,
0.0413475707,
-0.0474871211,
-0.0208436679,
0.023885062,
2.949e-7,
0.0004250058,
0.0354179963,
0.0411367789,
0.0231769104,
0.0134813888,
0.0097255334,
0.0051289992,
0.0202040486,
0.0160188507,
-0.0279405247,
-0.002795299,
0.0161948558,
0.0345667563,
0.0173437726,
-0.1578108519,
-0.0007018425,
-0.0589751638,
0.0098392982,
-0.0629235879,
0.0069637019,
0.0639994815,
0.1194949448,
-0.0279647764,
-0.0158382617,
0.0251361206,
-0.0275656823,
0.0108147729,
-0.0321918763,
-0.0037063137,
0.0134174302,
0.024291452,
0.0050341012,
-0.001700966,
-0.0102822958,
0.0183689855,
-0.0036643534,
0.0019136423,
0.0763755441,
0.0268312041,
-0.0514101647,
0.0223201606,
-0.0211281162,
-0.0058037969,
-0.0539104082,
0.0930479616,
-0.0205903202,
0.0089623211,
-0.0363286547,
-0.0124921761,
-0.0436268561,
-0.0013914353,
-0.0014893555,
0.0226801876,
0.0179469492,
-0.0113043534,
-0.0354681835,
0.0075623132,
-0.0938833728,
-0.0353726223,
-0.0020215085,
-0.0198769961,
-0.0585769601,
-0.0698081851,
-0.0147924861,
0.0194416903,
-0.0814021006,
-0.0130323116,
3.201422819e-34,
0.0408465117,
-0.0254816022,
0.026174739,
0.035891857,
-0.0106676426,
-0.0231437311,
-0.0083619496,
0.0100904573,
0.0340420678,
-0.1088843793,
-0.0422836393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06837v1 | Generating and Evaluating Tests for K-12 Students with Language Model Simulations: A Case Study on Sentence Reading Efficiency | 2023-10-10T17:59:51 | 2023-10-10T17:59:51 | Eric Zelikman, Wanjing Anya Ma, Jasmine E. Tran, Diyi Yang, Jason D. Yeatman, Nick Haber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Developing an educational test can be expensive and time-consuming, as each
item must be written by experts and then evaluated by collecting hundreds of
student responses. Moreover, many tests require multiple distinct sets of
questions administered throughout the school year to closely monitor students'
progress, known as parallel tests. In this study, we focus on tests of silent
sentence reading efficiency, used to assess students' reading ability over
time. To generate high-quality parallel tests, we propose to fine-tune large
language models (LLMs) to simulate how previous students would have responded
to unseen items. With these simulated responses, we can estimate each item's
difficulty and ambiguity. We first use GPT-4 to generate new test items
following a list of expert-developed rules and then apply a fine-tuned LLM to
filter the items based on criteria from psychological measurements. We also
propose an optimal-transport-inspired technique for generating parallel tests
and show the generated tests closely correspond to the original test's
difficulty and reliability based on crowdworker responses. Our evaluation of a
generated test with 234 students from grades 2 to 8 produces test scores highly
correlated (r=0.93) to those of a standard test form written by human experts
and evaluated across thousands of K-12 students. | [
0.0329764001,
0.0384683348,
-0.0629141256,
0.0332128219,
-0.0749530196,
0.0037097693,
0.0486900322,
0.0335453264,
0.0087266201,
-0.0407007821,
0.0466159359,
-0.0335383043,
-0.0087992083,
-0.0177512094,
0.0192835163,
-0.038530875,
0.0059741787,
-0.0292410702,
0.0211544689,
-0.0094273919,
-0.0102006868,
-0.009802578,
-0.0265467409,
0.0214694813,
0.029496327,
0.0004834411,
-0.0106958644,
-0.0235470105,
0.0259221494,
-0.0520936549,
0.0317631327,
0.0736308992,
-0.0270461179,
0.0257943533,
0.0000021353,
-0.0242291056,
-0.0121200019,
-0.011844527,
0.0081612607,
0.0422814749,
0.0682504252,
0.0533322841,
-0.002000981,
0.0351107903,
-0.0372238606,
-0.017221475,
0.0290843695,
-0.0322996005,
0.0521309562,
0.0419718847,
0.0018363982,
0.0352512002,
0.0165923983,
0.0011084637,
0.0486114621,
-0.0432554595,
0.0332589895,
0.0195530057,
0.0425708406,
0.0246347375,
-0.0414263867,
0.0216042139,
-0.0012860402,
0.0270784423,
-0.0020568669,
0.0108630937,
-0.0092638237,
0.0296658371,
-0.0131692011,
0.0495282598,
-0.0051598153,
-0.031801194,
0.0063513601,
-0.026460534,
-0.0108839693,
0.0831889212,
-0.0331699625,
-0.0099413628,
0.0055337246,
-0.0138364499,
0.0100211278,
-0.0118373567,
-0.0067396695,
-0.0043443651,
0.0197087117,
0.0462659337,
0.0218383484,
-0.061153125,
-0.0311822277,
0.0604106709,
-0.0260500349,
-0.0440159924,
0.0499005578,
-0.0047508525,
-0.0188790448,
0.0039540958,
-0.0136591289,
-0.0958443657,
0.0380148105,
-0.0116351722,
0.0540621988,
0.0343591198,
0.0300015248,
0.0384567156,
-0.0247626603,
0.0719416291,
0.0234562922,
0.0171329603,
-0.0438361131,
0.0353776813,
-0.0526030064,
0.0029590242,
-0.0225364994,
0.0050290888,
-0.0294900294,
-0.0036320954,
-0.0624254644,
-0.0041922783,
-0.0244562961,
-0.0219008792,
-0.0002419216,
-0.0171940792,
-0.0141032403,
0.0078329509,
-0.0338430665,
0.0181144327,
-0.0479153432,
0.0140674002,
-0.0024103082,
0.0130575821,
0.0085886335,
-0.0083384691,
0.0229549091,
-0.013502866,
-0.0089125438,
0.0361305512,
-0.0053126854,
-0.0026800775,
-0.0137441866,
-0.0408883356,
0.0103897564,
-0.0112242298,
-0.0172235165,
-0.0740076974,
0.0022291967,
0.0189104117,
0.0140880579,
-0.016563857,
-0.0169771127,
0.0226848647,
-0.0133720366,
0.0366857052,
0.051073879,
0.0210264754,
0.031603802,
0.0035242271,
0.0240394957,
0.0379142575,
0.0456695966,
-0.0133074718,
0.0155351656,
-0.0569728538,
0.0359041952,
0.0458055958,
0.0018774788,
0.0435152799,
-0.0043830122,
-0.0245823879,
0.0017446813,
0.0229038056,
-0.0329580382,
0.0593254119,
-0.0040083444,
0.0279994961,
0.0683013722,
0.0628895611,
0.0111001031,
-0.0076508368,
0.0199487619,
0.056894742,
0.003269406,
0.0293147955,
-0.0155915823,
-0.0043524066,
-0.0363599323,
0.0113618644,
0.0063185445,
0.012129683,
0.0212732367,
-0.0246748757,
-0.0092307692,
0.0161862429,
0.0441742465,
0.0211932976,
0.0710752979,
-0.0637401342,
-0.0655176193,
0.0154029699,
0.0156486817,
-0.0425854959,
0.0095823016,
-0.0362426527,
0.0453749858,
0.0524511039,
0.0512802154,
-0.0055326559,
-0.004801963,
0.0062949611,
-0.0071318098,
0.0349032171,
0.0280330591,
0.0018210978,
-0.0191932339,
-0.0463999137,
-0.0249498449,
0.078057386,
0.0286707208,
-0.0170101076,
0.0266222619,
0.0111242486,
0.0364236534,
-0.0603695251,
-0.0505290069,
0.0460468829,
-0.0559976809,
-0.0443062969,
-0.0245793834,
-0.0011931882,
0.0394000188,
0.0015226149,
0.0182295442,
-0.0083677191,
0.0161695499,
-0.0046511414,
0.0106576094,
-0.0264586452,
-0.0110944575,
0.0017085668,
0.0201325789,
-0.0462638736,
0.003617232,
0.0918867514,
-0.0087047312,
-0.0338796638,
0.0055950778,
-0.0291086491,
0.0055451095,
-0.0217261687,
0.0265188795,
-0.0398701057,
-0.0461136252,
-0.046940919,
0.0401639752,
0.0267587099,
0.0738194436,
-0.0264787022,
0.0170157775,
0.0091445297,
-0.0283302162,
-0.040002171,
-0.0149873551,
0.0041604294,
0.0460246541,
0.0241503324,
0.0048895343,
-0.0625249892,
-0.0370677412,
-0.089761205,
0.0196191631,
0.0191370714,
0.0172165502,
-0.0010023979,
-0.0532196388,
-0.0204326417,
0.0320128985,
-0.0277841706,
0.0301315971,
0.0313965268,
0.0119349435,
0.0127246836,
-0.0275432467,
-0.0357093513,
-0.0392991379,
-0.0371790975,
-0.0623147003,
0.0124993445,
0.0664699227,
0.0377578028,
-0.0527460612,
0.034530092,
-0.0034684481,
-0.0136060584,
0.0386842601,
-0.0479730591,
0.0295242853,
-0.0088593177,
0.0642044619,
0.0613795556,
-0.005712857,
-0.0115768751,
0.0132407183,
-0.0593573414,
-0.0542179942,
0.0151308365,
-0.0080194054,
0.0162100922,
-0.0209593438,
-0.0920034647,
-0.0100633828,
0.0617734827,
0.0355696455,
-0.0468427651,
-0.0595611595,
0.0586890057,
-0.0815878361,
0.0020518373,
-0.0770035088,
-0.0176322721,
-0.0321820453,
0.0417359881,
-0.0131442724,
-0.0218922757,
0.0673408434,
-0.017814083,
0.0223797783,
-0.0902888551,
0.0233706869,
0.0015846428,
0.028633574,
0.0278853066,
-0.0155007392,
-0.0387766063,
0.0273425225,
-0.0292028319,
0.0287366845,
0.0478610098,
-0.0494166575,
0.0101248575,
-0.0542868488,
-0.0293761455,
0.0039481255,
-0.0191732515,
-0.0166358873,
-0.0415064804,
-0.0038138207,
-0.0384365357,
0.035965018,
-0.0233380236,
-0.039512448,
0.0053953882,
0.0114578903,
0.0414888822,
-0.0398086123,
-0.0129616661,
-0.0223451089,
0.0512506068,
0.028886592,
-0.0281962305,
-0.0095546702,
-0.0857133493,
-0.0073414771,
0.0480251946,
0.0381791741,
0.0298005603,
0.018607825,
0.0188574512,
0.0234883502,
-0.0187437143,
0.0188940782,
0.0403219163,
0.0433333442,
-0.0706462637,
0.0238642879,
0.0910774693,
0.0425825678,
-0.0169290565,
-0.0137318214,
0.0084557189,
-0.0063724257,
-0.0105460668,
0.0395572186,
-0.0471805111,
-0.0004330811,
0.0112463403,
0.059162382,
-0.0436438657,
-0.0362541489,
0.0162287802,
-0.1168246195,
0.044017408,
0.0211437102,
-0.0292072184,
0.0462468714,
-0.0343690068,
-0.00045219,
-0.0012138846,
0.0107748229,
0.0081162155,
0.0309275631,
0.0263040047,
0.0082126707,
-0.0084886448,
-0.034360189,
0.055538401,
-0.0082649142,
0.0694436207,
0.0090793204,
0.012940214,
-0.0663055703,
-0.0798115805,
0.0192558542,
-0.0228180792,
-0.045298513,
0.009831409,
0.0143786352,
0.0418929048,
-0.0029615182,
-0.0610243641,
0.0122164506,
-0.0455610566,
0.0093017705,
0.0534753501,
0.0647688359,
0.0624707751,
-0.0587765127,
-0.0157057904,
0.0022619516,
0.0190872587,
0.0780002847,
0.0160716493,
-0.0830515549,
0.0005525649,
-0.0521450415,
-0.0044750767,
-0.0715979785,
-0.0616122223,
-0.0005720793,
-0.0184618644,
0.0107539017,
-0.0594564043,
-0.0338451751,
0.0782148764,
0.0199928246,
0.0268275626,
0.0177982002,
0.0569386706,
-0.0418593995,
-0.0304249432,
0.0434379429,
-0.0060951337,
0.0077519547,
-0.0754916519,
-0.0263184216,
0.0025631292,
-0.0018909469,
-0.0510223284,
0.0694300458,
-0.1263745576,
-0.0654499456,
0.0488600582,
0.020330321,
0.0278755035,
-0.0364058279,
0.0059680436,
-0.0179602765,
-0.0094128996,
-0.0265422929,
-0.0401770994,
0.0345733762,
-0.0409994945,
-0.0371158347,
-0.0006302205,
-0.025672812,
0.01265876,
0.0325223766,
0.029819848,
0.0384577177,
-0.035013333,
-0.0570315309,
0.0071832752,
0.0623754412,
0.0546282344,
0.0014750364,
-0.0368969962,
-0.0472316593,
-0.0071473573,
-0.0369839072,
-0.0061938018,
-0.0178624578,
-0.0514664315,
0.0199996177,
-0.0042506126,
-0.0193285756,
-0.0411456898,
-0.0152338566,
0.0280431639,
-0.0457834415,
0.0524506047,
-0.0304204114,
0.0410378724,
0.0388436653,
-0.0067291125,
-0.0073300498,
-0.0156263653,
-0.0226080026,
0.0891902,
0.0306169335,
0.0451432578,
-0.0042562787,
-0.006734571,
0.0032391499,
0.0011846693,
-0.0170214456,
-0.0055613252,
-0.0381089449,
0.0346680917,
-0.0438551418,
0.0067732758,
0.030261904,
-0.0502999648,
-0.0009840694,
-0.0366794057,
-0.0185993295,
0.0231460631,
0.0343886353,
0.0122551201,
0.0251228716,
0.0208987556,
0.0070149233,
0.0484733582,
0.0296066217,
-0.0323306732,
0.0005664101,
-0.0221257769,
-0.0528508388,
0.039978791,
-0.0035003168,
0.0596609637,
-0.0086539825,
0.019650314,
-0.0647350922,
-0.041155152,
0.0245062113,
0.0589867271,
0.0411537625,
-0.022993179,
-0.005715616,
0.0448867716,
-0.0582592264,
-0.0008558109,
-0.0342410691,
0.0245284326,
-0.0372495987,
-0.0504556,
-0.0041385051,
-6.765940507e-33,
-0.0317610092,
-0.072817795,
0.0215723123,
-0.0120054549,
0.0109811649,
0.0074593551,
-0.0379244015,
0.0396510474,
0.037771754,
-0.0059056547,
0.0054796115,
-0.0041103875,
0.0133885369,
0.0230697449,
0.023613425,
0.031177083,
0.0268491376,
-0.0099472459,
-0.0335719585,
-0.0223409068,
-0.0051766159,
-0.0165266804,
0.0367096215,
-0.0237746928,
0.0549570136,
-0.0479495749,
-0.0085307676,
-0.0096552595,
-0.0280493554,
0.0302499812,
-0.0220357329,
0.0627056807,
0.0274340454,
-0.0286746379,
0.018336108,
0.0100815939,
-0.0366509706,
-0.0202533752,
0.0149750644,
-0.0182002801,
-0.0552913845,
-0.0144512663,
0.0430496559,
0.0126506388,
-0.0295789354,
-0.0033122753,
0.0526582114,
-0.039654918,
-0.0083050439,
0.0488254502,
-0.0385204293,
0.0147529077,
-0.0319254473,
0.0053726765,
0.0042874929,
0.0260560773,
-0.0142922625,
0.0141543625,
-0.0563402586,
0.0449486449,
0.0589152277,
0.0314226262,
0.0158500541,
-0.0132161006,
0.0095752729,
0.0626970828,
0.031409286,
-0.0034611472,
-0.0020977652,
-0.0330836363,
0.080612354,
-0.0259783249,
0.0945625901,
0.0799022615,
0.0395482257,
-0.0389901362,
-0.0571628809,
0.0475729629,
0.0173757561,
-0.0372861587,
0.0435048491,
-0.0116584403,
-0.1081896201,
-0.0418515019,
-0.0291896667,
-0.009506871,
-0.0438579097,
-0.0218131691,
0.0593474023,
-0.0363039784,
-0.0474202372,
-0.0228870343,
0.0317694396,
-0.0109956469,
-0.0068241255,
-0.0305738691,
-0.0296505708,
0.0575124137,
-0.0320799053,
0.0196482819,
-0.0115428325,
0.0057783844,
-0.029515082,
0.0140474644,
0.0155256772,
0.0131625086,
-0.0365204625,
-0.0253300667,
-0.0651890114,
0.0285360534,
-0.0242063161,
0.0093651889,
0.0157516915,
-0.0072019268,
0.0139680021,
0.024150975,
0.023092635,
0.0154394154,
0.033925619,
-0.0693195984,
-0.0319109857,
0.0142643517,
-0.0106621329,
-0.0282957572,
0.0084826108,
-0.0274755303,
-0.0119446442,
0.0163056906,
0.0262819454,
-0.0244846493,
0.0002519025,
0.008483218,
2.787e-7,
0.0187720414,
0.0904049948,
-0.0205684211,
0.020328939,
-0.0011581747,
0.0204219017,
-0.033106219,
-0.0197980143,
0.095173873,
0.0383964926,
0.0127832992,
0.0281660035,
0.0507201925,
0.0469960086,
-0.0814844519,
-0.0007529036,
-0.0059524239,
0.0303502399,
-0.050157655,
0.0240196101,
0.0782615021,
0.0002527616,
0.0249317531,
-0.0064217113,
-0.0321465805,
-0.050026767,
0.0110939723,
-0.041150596,
-0.037876036,
0.0176799055,
-0.0015115364,
-0.0170269217,
0.0281009581,
0.0814201385,
-0.021533696,
-0.0151287429,
0.009599301,
0.0441430025,
0.0186803471,
0.0148395943,
0.0126402751,
-0.0167940371,
0.007975704,
-0.0708675459,
0.0317559838,
-0.0013209068,
0.0084959194,
0.05336871,
-0.0276528746,
-0.0565703474,
0.0059150415,
-0.0227612276,
-0.0208351184,
-0.0049979449,
0.0061532576,
0.0027256042,
0.0223824959,
0.0102432379,
-0.0149039775,
-0.0311889425,
-0.0398727134,
-0.0816088617,
-0.0411515683,
-0.0058175209,
-0.0080940556,
-0.042045489,
0.0265233405,
2.457760782e-34,
0.0392533466,
0.0308277588,
0.0385686271,
-0.0395445898,
0.0313216522,
0.0039606034,
-0.011342058,
0.0123133585,
0.0189140346,
-0.0794752836,
-0.0263546389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06830v1 | Lemur: Harmonizing Natural Language and Code for Language Agents | 2023-10-10T17:57:45 | 2023-10-10T17:57:45 | Yiheng Xu, Hongjin Su, Chen Xing, Boyu Mi, Qian Liu, Weijia Shi, Binyuan Hui, Fan Zhou, Yitao Liu, Tianbao Xie, Zhoujun Cheng, Siheng Zhao, Lingpeng Kong, Bailin Wang, Caiming Xiong, Tao Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Lemur and Lemur-Chat, openly accessible language models
optimized for both natural language and coding capabilities to serve as the
backbone of versatile language agents. The evolution from language chat models
to functional language agents demands that models not only master human
interaction, reasoning, and planning but also ensure grounding in the relevant
environments. This calls for a harmonious blend of language and coding
capabilities in the models. Lemur and Lemur-Chat are proposed to address this
necessity, demonstrating balanced proficiencies in both domains, unlike
existing open-source models that tend to specialize in either. Through
meticulous pre-training using a code-intensive corpus and instruction
fine-tuning on text and code data, our models achieve state-of-the-art averaged
performance across diverse text and coding benchmarks among open-source models.
Comprehensive experiments demonstrate Lemur's superiority over existing
open-source models and its proficiency across various agent tasks involving
human communication, tool usage, and interaction under fully- and partially-
observable environments. The harmonization between natural and programming
languages enables Lemur-Chat to significantly narrow the gap with proprietary
models on agent abilities, providing key insights into developing advanced
open-source agents adept at reasoning, planning, and operating seamlessly
across environments. https://github.com/OpenLemur/Lemur | [
0.0500495881,
0.0555306002,
-0.0281834099,
0.0373357609,
-0.0309605189,
0.0147077981,
-0.0389714986,
-0.0370068252,
0.0523391776,
-0.0239320621,
-0.0275647696,
0.0346511155,
-0.0315498747,
0.0916661769,
0.0159575734,
-0.0330525488,
0.0483157188,
-0.0368954875,
0.0101575712,
0.0183563512,
0.0146332532,
0.0196173582,
-0.0103910882,
0.0638720319,
0.0227890164,
-0.0082239173,
-0.0453528166,
-0.0121496767,
-0.0101925647,
0.0021747658,
0.0263240859,
0.0295984615,
0.0319512486,
0.0167217683,
0.0000021266,
-0.0479886569,
0.0277143065,
-0.0068363193,
-0.0235204156,
-0.0407830179,
0.0726615638,
-0.0179449264,
-0.0142311631,
0.0291574765,
-0.0866943523,
0.0027643896,
0.0688048899,
-0.0205301084,
0.0662594587,
0.0852613151,
0.0052097016,
0.0060384665,
-0.0026678036,
0.0177617464,
0.0118686371,
-0.0480892025,
-0.0216678753,
0.0121777253,
0.0644014627,
0.0212676432,
0.0007340336,
0.0224189758,
0.0481042415,
-0.022638116,
0.0057256636,
0.0371991545,
-0.0717694461,
-0.0536875203,
-0.0419153236,
0.0645808727,
0.0003404215,
-0.032810811,
0.025082862,
0.0085282903,
0.0319542512,
-0.0369551145,
-0.0148478933,
0.0354742073,
-0.000304486,
-0.0007418715,
0.0088414652,
-0.0275771562,
0.0019505873,
0.0256022494,
-0.0000934701,
0.0436750911,
-0.0213119388,
0.0127456235,
-0.0098955464,
-0.0266919173,
0.0018132926,
-0.0924738571,
0.0022711135,
0.0673470795,
-0.038278196,
0.0307031069,
-0.0578322969,
0.0223705657,
0.0269155446,
-0.0447727852,
-0.025545314,
0.0620069392,
-0.0237083659,
0.0428412259,
0.0023810165,
0.0510349795,
0.021255251,
0.0381529368,
0.0011689954,
-0.0142445462,
-0.0692666396,
-0.0146453846,
-0.0322836079,
0.0128408559,
-0.0474821106,
-0.0206682812,
0.0101970509,
0.0816629305,
0.0086173909,
0.0285005495,
-0.004721079,
0.0100635458,
-0.0509672314,
-0.0018940159,
-0.0493160821,
-0.0132838869,
-0.023907328,
-0.0103449915,
0.0244564489,
-0.1027395129,
-0.0017538718,
0.0113128517,
-0.0251207612,
-0.0153554203,
0.0001639697,
0.1045788303,
0.0000697623,
-0.0152187161,
-0.0073561319,
-0.0029934212,
0.0029278931,
-0.069547005,
-0.0099976202,
-0.0662354678,
0.0175345652,
0.0122327898,
-0.03457959,
-0.0769639611,
0.0104876952,
0.016257802,
-0.0027081741,
0.0803686157,
-0.0492625237,
-0.0075446689,
0.0148567241,
0.0123158228,
-0.0300755873,
0.0679228157,
0.0399550162,
0.0150865978,
0.0157862622,
0.0054587736,
0.0281596724,
0.0231240634,
-0.0409092046,
-0.0304375812,
0.0334565192,
0.0492978841,
0.0032924504,
0.0231017396,
0.0079474347,
0.0400057212,
-0.009203217,
-0.0248444211,
0.0496640578,
0.0583342537,
-0.0244486369,
0.0219833106,
0.060527239,
0.0670969561,
0.0039770706,
-0.0469674543,
-0.0647777542,
0.0635131449,
-0.009987127,
-0.0002513918,
-0.0442006513,
0.0256640818,
-0.0137545103,
-0.0725221783,
-0.0067426567,
-0.0347087979,
0.0641638935,
0.0067359745,
0.0204879194,
0.0093742255,
-0.0486473031,
0.0055622398,
0.0174100325,
-0.0668960437,
-0.0263980944,
-0.0660005286,
0.0091551226,
0.081298463,
0.0395068973,
-0.0286038332,
-0.0491391718,
-0.0064649186,
0.0066412105,
0.0536789298,
0.0455393903,
-0.0135836489,
0.0170140509,
-0.0319444649,
-0.0033472765,
-0.0429483727,
0.0025475398,
0.0270831492,
0.010057481,
0.0052132616,
-0.0126997018,
0.008032687,
-0.0245189909,
0.0361838192,
-0.0392282233,
0.0003349478,
-0.0434945077,
-0.0151413279,
0.0349317491,
-0.0092458902,
-0.0003710201,
0.0174688622,
0.0255571958,
0.0127822654,
-0.0309344195,
0.0413408354,
-0.0073546288,
-0.0324969143,
0.0514771938,
-0.0150803076,
-0.026019711,
0.0651328042,
-0.0216622148,
-0.0106183263,
0.0682172477,
-0.0266470201,
0.0433132835,
-0.0253201015,
0.0168791544,
-0.0009841198,
-0.0180172995,
0.0141209448,
0.0455705151,
0.0276540536,
-0.0278871004,
0.0007567645,
0.0470029861,
0.0008030735,
-0.0282630492,
-0.002265085,
0.0205838066,
-0.0064311116,
0.0297764726,
0.0181620792,
0.046228949,
-0.0362782218,
-0.0479002036,
-0.0936289728,
0.0093338843,
-0.0256614592,
-0.0128282569,
0.0194332693,
0.0005183035,
-0.0094733778,
-0.0098506017,
-0.0285925847,
0.0122477617,
0.0013917544,
0.015453265,
0.0399263352,
-0.0046326923,
-0.070918262,
-0.0625982434,
0.0163815729,
-0.0142422961,
-0.0112521062,
0.0252755601,
-0.0099730352,
-0.0343679078,
0.0431144424,
-0.051327914,
0.0411459617,
-0.0315919295,
-0.0600689165,
0.0288277492,
-0.0289192516,
-0.0066498681,
0.058790803,
-0.0003215487,
0.0257658139,
0.0397238918,
-0.0121938372,
-0.0551804751,
0.0475203358,
0.0013785089,
-0.043466866,
-0.0395527966,
-0.0003093007,
0.0185578391,
0.075520657,
-0.0086724283,
0.0102481563,
-0.0540125966,
0.0173593499,
0.0172002967,
-0.0475229509,
0.0223460868,
-0.0124221873,
-0.0121769924,
0.0387847647,
-0.0407112911,
-0.0560750142,
0.0936614871,
-0.0093702609,
-0.0487372465,
-0.0452514701,
-0.0363849103,
-0.0526669025,
0.0816732645,
-0.0032519877,
-0.0007098783,
0.0210536644,
-0.0208321121,
-0.0328988358,
-0.0119106742,
0.0178466607,
-0.0230533239,
0.0159522779,
-0.077793017,
0.020290114,
0.0148760052,
-0.0561214462,
-0.0317672901,
-0.0129634971,
-0.0459542386,
0.0184961297,
0.0186061859,
-0.0182513241,
-0.0325034745,
-0.0119048096,
0.0042251679,
0.0301637203,
0.0166201107,
-0.0253785346,
-0.0373084098,
-0.0677570254,
0.0116598541,
0.008370474,
-0.0151003171,
0.0012334734,
0.0177480206,
0.0284385514,
0.0099767335,
-0.0052549858,
-0.0409739055,
0.0250345599,
0.0140963588,
-0.0094850659,
-0.0308702867,
0.0419011638,
0.0604490452,
-0.0649486557,
-0.0214511491,
0.1146610752,
0.0145736299,
-0.0165068842,
0.0168704093,
-0.0563706346,
0.0429914035,
0.0496303141,
0.0476008095,
-0.0739362612,
-0.0603228249,
-0.0042824666,
0.0070944685,
0.0089589842,
-0.0416293181,
-0.0132530201,
-0.0919984877,
0.0264527984,
-0.0007337272,
-0.0335240252,
-0.0205430817,
-0.0367115475,
0.0002215837,
-0.0422099121,
-0.0197353531,
0.0154497372,
0.0078632198,
0.0008519763,
-0.0136936661,
-0.0326619446,
-0.0154816834,
0.0345848091,
-0.0432960354,
0.0610714145,
0.1037637144,
0.0301065054,
0.0122246305,
-0.0165454056,
0.0064658173,
0.0424477942,
0.018511286,
-0.0034375857,
0.029409131,
-0.0259925779,
-0.0142519316,
-0.0232848916,
0.04269756,
-0.0476025082,
-0.0135890413,
0.0091616185,
0.0431062207,
-0.0177531447,
-0.0025585631,
-0.0258235671,
0.012726957,
0.0468218215,
0.0523763709,
-0.0011195862,
-0.0138554526,
-0.0782912076,
-0.0609804504,
-0.0393497273,
-0.0135464706,
-0.0468575098,
0.0142894005,
0.0238687377,
-0.048330795,
-0.0597464964,
-0.068689853,
0.063022688,
-0.0005919483,
0.0216851309,
-0.0130478805,
0.0121620269,
0.0296267625,
-0.0142430514,
0.027282808,
-0.0317792334,
0.0207311045,
-0.0354867056,
-0.0334917232,
0.006830194,
-0.0475718491,
-0.0069966009,
0.0196581576,
-0.0489441045,
-0.0709340274,
0.0064826338,
0.0695051849,
0.0283139516,
0.022374792,
-0.0317513756,
-0.0301450789,
-0.0492354818,
0.022494169,
-0.0823875293,
0.0200245064,
0.0414494611,
0.0225476138,
0.0321052223,
0.0490697101,
-0.0665322095,
0.0156196868,
-0.038368687,
0.0355480313,
-0.0169054586,
-0.001811062,
0.0206473526,
-0.0086694518,
-0.01726171,
0.0264683031,
-0.0287459511,
-0.0146722766,
-0.0080905482,
-0.0087696174,
-0.0274624377,
-0.0750113204,
0.0139933703,
-0.0174944196,
0.0085945847,
0.068080537,
0.0080288453,
-0.0383826643,
0.0369749293,
0.0231710337,
0.0313250609,
0.0401017927,
0.0370213836,
0.0299732741,
0.0109469071,
-0.0366320424,
0.0351282619,
-0.0336066,
0.0392603837,
-0.0155420955,
0.0610227659,
-0.0093188854,
-0.0106608709,
0.0221392307,
0.014798875,
-0.073363699,
-0.0770428106,
0.0456549861,
0.0299009513,
0.0331757665,
0.0455976725,
0.0430916063,
-0.0620203242,
0.0327691212,
-0.0085441172,
0.0527132563,
0.0029357232,
-0.0740355924,
0.0240642987,
0.0277675092,
-0.021283377,
-0.0498360097,
0.0570789836,
0.0005727911,
0.0617245622,
-0.0199609697,
-0.0178750865,
-0.033760827,
-0.0191194415,
0.0401013345,
-0.0115535874,
0.0071674655,
0.0007051352,
-0.0408027321,
-0.0463813134,
-0.0128626619,
0.0410360061,
-0.0149934171,
-0.0343015827,
0.0599848218,
0.0607084371,
0.0029431495,
-0.0294460803,
-0.0419527031,
-0.0000164399,
-0.0037054375,
-0.0135409161,
-0.0339725912,
-5.637359033e-33,
-0.0329182856,
-0.0020085298,
0.0645081848,
0.0135982931,
0.0098520042,
-0.0318321548,
-0.0610756278,
-0.0016630137,
-0.0527120568,
-0.0229045115,
0.0031657778,
0.048122216,
0.0051629404,
-0.0133414408,
0.0199740045,
-0.0090549849,
0.0286871623,
0.0062574917,
-0.0273904037,
0.0026558032,
0.0081793005,
0.0054182829,
0.024983922,
-0.0571297333,
0.0359098651,
0.0013957134,
0.0115946885,
0.0268438272,
0.0075278357,
0.0407796428,
0.0008837223,
-0.0118463682,
-0.0011070571,
0.0064550638,
-0.0397062898,
-0.0008856258,
-0.0246664081,
-0.0187259261,
0.0262625199,
0.0110424319,
-0.0389155149,
-0.0273910519,
0.0392322168,
-0.0265979134,
-0.014598337,
0.0123815797,
0.0247253422,
-0.0047633462,
0.0229793377,
0.0591228567,
-0.0784645304,
0.029648155,
-0.0425074473,
-0.0427850634,
-0.0084485831,
0.0438911356,
-0.0113409022,
-0.0295673385,
-0.015008349,
0.0292393658,
-0.0054096454,
0.0083408514,
0.0761978701,
0.0016207397,
0.0277623944,
0.063477248,
0.0540686026,
0.016489692,
-0.0245057549,
0.0262667742,
0.0258398894,
0.0805241987,
0.0210172236,
0.0565150566,
-0.0135763977,
0.0083973119,
-0.0295392349,
0.0176887289,
0.0308974348,
0.0424183607,
-0.004865061,
0.0447347537,
-0.059085995,
-0.0114852395,
-0.0242955424,
0.0360419936,
-0.005887825,
-0.0562028475,
0.0421272255,
0.0045061666,
0.0050095143,
-0.0237475131,
0.0116185974,
-0.0280537754,
-0.0001140332,
0.0358701646,
-0.0379600264,
0.0276088417,
-0.0068780142,
0.0334258154,
-0.0509374216,
-0.0011027928,
0.021221349,
0.010626155,
0.0610353798,
0.03512308,
-0.0097578168,
0.0614994839,
-0.0219311677,
-0.0099755004,
-0.0616409741,
0.0211690236,
0.0041165408,
0.0007546555,
0.0166181233,
-0.0169503577,
-0.0157878548,
0.0471930578,
-0.0236920062,
-0.0490606539,
-0.0624824353,
-0.010822325,
0.0031982274,
-0.0111221327,
-0.0515716299,
-0.0260887519,
-0.077286832,
0.0411285087,
0.007139517,
-0.0435840078,
-0.0039290264,
0.0155198351,
2.831e-7,
0.0065480703,
0.0053794519,
0.0192424208,
0.0406359956,
-0.0058286767,
0.0377860554,
-0.0308207795,
0.0534318276,
-0.0083990255,
-0.0190123133,
-0.0298625287,
0.0683991984,
0.031920217,
0.0277583655,
-0.0935501307,
-0.0200699233,
0.0006090043,
-0.0143085308,
-0.0620783083,
-0.0201710835,
0.0495497547,
0.0638092309,
0.0281545203,
0.0103556551,
-0.0086357938,
-0.069338955,
0.0194488037,
-0.0273677688,
0.0091121243,
0.0171016101,
-0.0417249165,
0.0368198939,
-0.0160746593,
-0.0092638182,
0.0143101616,
0.0023947237,
-0.0218224395,
0.090167135,
-0.0240717996,
-0.02057801,
0.0246739686,
-0.0143686747,
-0.0312766954,
-0.0266384538,
0.0610932596,
-0.0391262472,
-0.0331567749,
-0.0097069647,
-0.0006663005,
0.004509843,
-0.0498417281,
-0.0195577461,
-0.0398146138,
-0.0049054679,
-0.0062121507,
-0.04311404,
-0.0033840095,
-0.0590735301,
-0.0171774626,
-0.0370722339,
-0.0280511715,
-0.0540440753,
-0.0491233356,
0.0313745178,
0.0207668785,
-0.0279330332,
0.0213061608,
2.666023713e-34,
0.0113274716,
0.010679448,
0.0053040031,
0.056728743,
0.0756517947,
0.0177227408,
0.0211115684,
0.0231843814,
0.0531271026,
-0.0344161876,
-0.0393258631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06827v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06827v3 | Teaching Language Models to Hallucinate Less with Synthetic Tasks | 2023-10-10T17:57:00 | 2023-11-07T05:11:46 | Erik Jones, Hamid Palangi, Clarisse Simões, Varun Chandrasekaran, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Arindam Mitra, Ahmed Awadallah, Ece Kamar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate on abstractive
summarization tasks such as document-based question-answering, meeting
summarization, and clinical report generation, even though all necessary
information is included in context. However, optimizing LLMs to hallucinate
less on these tasks is challenging, as hallucination is hard to efficiently
evaluate at each optimization step. In this work, we show that reducing
hallucination on a synthetic task can also reduce hallucination on real-world
downstream tasks. Our method, SynTra, first designs a synthetic task where
hallucinations are easy to elicit and measure. It next optimizes the LLM's
system message via prefix-tuning on the synthetic task, and finally transfers
the system message to realistic, hard-to-optimize tasks. Across three realistic
abstractive summarization tasks, SynTra reduces hallucination for two
13B-parameter LLMs using only a synthetic retrieval task for supervision. We
also find that optimizing the system message rather than the model weights can
be critical; fine-tuning the entire model on the synthetic task can
counterintuitively increase hallucination. Overall, SynTra demonstrates that
the extra flexibility of working with synthetic data can help mitigate
undesired behaviors in practice. | [
0.0241505075,
0.0378108136,
0.0056059966,
0.008398273,
-0.0127450349,
0.0091242949,
-0.0414725281,
0.0098255388,
-0.0132725947,
-0.0220309738,
-0.0176485162,
-0.0561590232,
-0.0046775918,
0.0028277149,
0.031526234,
-0.0630637631,
0.0528345779,
-0.049359031,
-0.0286136549,
-0.0059965714,
-0.0072163199,
0.0082723117,
0.0192412697,
0.0328478515,
0.0067299926,
-0.0138507774,
-0.0016404557,
0.0087190792,
0.002829452,
0.0250526629,
0.0105304141,
0.0701595023,
0.0226022247,
0.0274044387,
0.0000018996,
-0.0435907654,
0.0089439452,
-0.0228283964,
-0.0312631503,
0.0127723673,
0.0641156882,
-0.0187640581,
0.0152314352,
0.0303567369,
-0.028902445,
0.0023605484,
0.0309397802,
0.0723815635,
0.0589455105,
0.0771283209,
0.0061913948,
0.00072867,
0.0224531218,
-0.0120972004,
0.0454803817,
0.0156547297,
0.0111245578,
0.032440085,
0.0039068111,
-0.0278900284,
0.0006901049,
0.0462415069,
0.0214113817,
0.0197193809,
0.0322462916,
0.0378527828,
-0.0972782299,
-0.0169035979,
0.0215734318,
0.048860997,
-0.0527538694,
-0.0626228079,
0.0277304873,
0.0201211665,
0.0345031954,
-0.0242490824,
-0.0648533329,
0.0229290575,
-0.0242350791,
0.0136225307,
0.026121024,
-0.0110879708,
0.0359865576,
0.0154648004,
-0.0289081819,
0.0163769778,
0.006498836,
-0.0330242366,
0.0141642271,
0.012001114,
-0.0410265662,
-0.0353392214,
0.0197041854,
0.0250796285,
-0.0754133835,
-0.0064716935,
-0.0417781137,
-0.0528317392,
0.0190874673,
-0.0631522611,
0.0263465196,
0.0288233384,
-0.0023583216,
0.039651826,
-0.0334735587,
0.0226685908,
0.0108137317,
0.0882951394,
-0.0541435108,
0.0162473321,
-0.0314335003,
-0.0203790832,
-0.072900787,
0.0265285689,
-0.0376682281,
-0.0115238354,
-0.0150655424,
0.0152065242,
-0.0164601933,
-0.0205153078,
0.0033634086,
0.038851276,
-0.0296606962,
-0.0130421733,
-0.0048855906,
-0.001389589,
-0.0396526866,
-0.018519504,
0.0356863923,
-0.030037025,
-0.0432889201,
0.0048302379,
-0.0012904217,
0.0120544927,
0.0131878871,
0.0347356312,
-0.0358457454,
-0.0049966434,
-0.0265962537,
-0.0369584039,
0.0037324857,
-0.0618493408,
0.0158115085,
-0.0513006076,
0.0179031678,
0.0007498904,
-0.0205067787,
-0.0151494462,
0.0077671972,
0.0021688263,
-0.0336314179,
0.064006716,
0.0077090906,
0.0143898679,
0.0250046328,
0.0208183751,
-0.0180908535,
0.0826042593,
0.0211375132,
0.0513109379,
0.0034182181,
0.0056652059,
0.0502865128,
0.0141050061,
0.0343211666,
-0.0003920198,
-0.0108179562,
-0.007649695,
0.0023042473,
0.0219879784,
0.0543475486,
0.089253135,
-0.040046405,
0.0135482904,
0.0574903004,
0.0250416566,
0.0221316088,
0.0003678965,
0.0431737751,
0.0011723909,
-0.0057034674,
0.0608159006,
-0.0837298483,
0.0510199815,
-0.0410937965,
0.0518285111,
0.0690387338,
0.0015681983,
-0.0448514633,
-0.0645873994,
0.0008634822,
0.0124977911,
0.0073497645,
0.0306649394,
0.005720065,
0.0413572155,
-0.0764418766,
0.0760320425,
0.0253455993,
-0.0550781861,
0.0237116367,
-0.0532294884,
0.0000813161,
0.1043256447,
0.062733762,
-0.0392176323,
0.0080319913,
-0.0145188002,
0.0321515426,
0.0559691601,
0.0478083901,
-0.0147318067,
0.0127726505,
-0.0458918847,
0.0095830066,
-0.0007696305,
0.0483671986,
-0.0264256988,
0.0100817904,
-0.0311844274,
0.027883742,
-0.031562686,
-0.0767744333,
0.0420668609,
-0.041066438,
-0.0598244816,
-0.0393115766,
-0.0290612392,
-0.0005246833,
-0.0142811621,
-0.0000139663,
0.049512364,
0.0138540082,
-0.0584119447,
-0.0348195396,
-0.0173722934,
-0.0664541945,
-0.0346912779,
0.0254592653,
-0.0233458485,
0.0149803888,
0.0450268164,
-0.0187275782,
-0.0460991189,
0.0213553645,
-0.0745727196,
0.0453810208,
-0.0478974134,
0.0330881104,
0.0027667992,
0.0206986833,
-0.0267700013,
0.0695271268,
-0.0238705017,
0.006500666,
0.0382144116,
-0.0092536826,
-0.0486332811,
-0.0095133511,
0.0007144152,
0.0016289271,
0.0179648511,
0.0369981825,
0.0249411687,
-0.0235714372,
-0.0536826476,
-0.0385938585,
-0.0835782737,
-0.0005602396,
-0.049269788,
-0.002804772,
0.0571301915,
0.0091348523,
-0.0019224922,
0.0183137115,
-0.045284871,
-0.0191510972,
0.0139625678,
0.0337962769,
-0.005181646,
0.010132038,
-0.0055512902,
-0.0501899794,
-0.0111880256,
-0.0121032149,
0.0400704592,
-0.0340963118,
-0.0241017211,
-0.0681558624,
0.0748399571,
-0.0150169572,
0.0143983513,
-0.0009508565,
0.0021036861,
-0.0043864078,
-0.0249185599,
0.1009533256,
0.0897514224,
0.0229170248,
0.0169821903,
0.0775650665,
-0.0042829937,
-0.0377815068,
-0.0005033411,
-0.0194767322,
0.00147315,
0.0025562576,
-0.0483937673,
0.0063186572,
0.0567674376,
0.0069324421,
0.0056054532,
-0.0683734789,
0.0242480393,
-0.0288374573,
-0.0509700179,
-0.0248905644,
-0.0081610391,
-0.0312991925,
0.0418539084,
-0.0555468649,
-0.0341227055,
0.0855292082,
0.001484037,
-0.0059579369,
-0.0459225364,
0.0034797795,
-0.0206600782,
0.0057806405,
0.0025891808,
0.0212995466,
-0.0217409916,
-0.0112218028,
-0.0672808513,
-0.0054446426,
0.0060561355,
-0.0634862706,
0.0496863164,
-0.025605185,
-0.0002094965,
-0.0051566022,
-0.0263611563,
-0.0471130908,
-0.0118673537,
0.0043593552,
0.0293176603,
0.0014628065,
0.0249843821,
-0.04685333,
0.0054560881,
0.0245116614,
0.0750394911,
-0.035405606,
-0.0281059369,
-0.0068431143,
-0.0052096122,
0.0827256963,
-0.0107486499,
0.0454926379,
-0.0777231604,
0.0383031368,
0.0491200611,
0.0721943006,
0.0109619098,
-0.0067639337,
-0.0194557328,
0.0118424213,
-0.0403697267,
0.0071963985,
0.0105422754,
0.0227364302,
-0.0552117974,
-0.0326988287,
0.1034990326,
0.0274315756,
-0.0596328415,
0.0245128684,
-0.0482396707,
0.0874464735,
0.0179190356,
0.0388908051,
-0.0553056635,
-0.0132826343,
0.009632892,
0.0104480488,
-0.0134743955,
-0.0109221572,
0.0051446739,
-0.0882281512,
0.0103313318,
0.0377799347,
-0.0441029109,
-0.0239552762,
-0.0095276702,
-0.0099291466,
0.001450429,
0.0448842049,
0.0238858219,
-0.0122807724,
-0.0222916678,
0.0222453084,
-0.0233049467,
-0.0179638024,
0.0056258379,
-0.0199595951,
0.0249234196,
0.0536062084,
0.0056748614,
0.0165813062,
-0.0351550877,
0.0608012266,
0.0036642323,
-0.0049415561,
0.0090128658,
0.0832386985,
0.0127577698,
0.0133677237,
-0.0046806117,
0.040782962,
-0.026152676,
-0.0137297027,
-0.0387065597,
0.0517957248,
-0.0147956768,
-0.0417479649,
-0.0258069243,
0.0393649526,
0.0072613889,
0.0890429989,
0.0377010889,
-0.0216195248,
-0.0517347753,
-0.0195519049,
0.0119104451,
-0.058354333,
-0.0517318211,
0.0153016197,
0.0302940737,
-0.0161492247,
-0.0897208825,
-0.0566357784,
0.0465967581,
0.0148840789,
-0.0181999356,
0.0176657215,
-0.0458191298,
-0.0090942206,
-0.052317623,
0.0438499786,
-0.0596969947,
-0.0061634635,
-0.0191934779,
-0.0274633467,
0.0281005297,
-0.0141038503,
0.0045043104,
0.0369196422,
-0.0797043741,
-0.0749518201,
-0.0007977101,
0.0397871211,
0.0288660452,
0.0658965334,
-0.000202716,
-0.0398750566,
0.0509948879,
0.0156687573,
-0.0010923259,
0.0211992487,
0.0204746462,
-0.0103420867,
0.0082397088,
0.0390136726,
-0.0368574858,
0.0001444198,
0.0150549179,
0.0427973159,
0.0021866753,
0.0192630291,
0.0484686047,
0.0189330876,
-0.0059582437,
-0.0095270593,
0.0033017779,
-0.0296933949,
-0.0047003278,
-0.0188483354,
-0.0200200286,
-0.0396468826,
0.0128686782,
0.0064212703,
-0.0009456706,
0.022861775,
0.0268321075,
-0.0162823107,
-0.0093043316,
-0.0200217888,
-0.0626498535,
-0.0452031307,
-0.0176948607,
0.0289104134,
-0.0080125723,
-0.0566928647,
-0.0014627167,
-0.0061148233,
0.0521885082,
0.0014313884,
0.0251022931,
0.0178080499,
0.0087510729,
-0.045631934,
0.0375788137,
-0.0843004808,
-0.054682944,
-0.0517360158,
0.0288471952,
0.0393503606,
-0.0268641803,
0.0663845167,
-0.0268990286,
0.0071219536,
-0.0213338826,
-0.0074812653,
0.027889004,
-0.0260819383,
-0.0298967399,
0.0416693166,
0.0038410376,
-0.0240777172,
0.0924301893,
-0.0101511562,
0.0435599536,
-0.0210905056,
-0.0016478988,
-0.0423909761,
-0.0637114197,
-0.0241992474,
-0.012601289,
-0.0221323241,
-0.0216485783,
-0.0522904098,
-0.0494191423,
-0.0062853685,
0.0124840103,
-0.0222738329,
-0.0355508141,
0.0585440397,
0.0443786718,
-0.0415513963,
-0.0351720639,
-0.0271015298,
-0.021572765,
0.0485392325,
0.0103502944,
-0.0252528526,
-6.31739978e-33,
-0.0176999327,
0.012140465,
0.0338556804,
-0.0093606543,
-0.0323322043,
-0.0193702523,
-0.0551518537,
0.0180517733,
0.00413932,
-0.0009750478,
-0.0276514795,
0.0345317312,
0.015373935,
0.0227047373,
-0.0000983745,
-0.0210851114,
0.056043569,
-0.0135798203,
-0.0615619272,
0.0542598888,
0.0267856847,
0.0211100262,
0.038335219,
-0.0118786935,
0.008366229,
-0.0143826129,
-0.0047894609,
0.0240486842,
-0.00020649,
0.0251734126,
-0.0339578092,
0.0315268077,
0.0299835391,
-0.0489699692,
-0.0625871718,
0.0246645715,
-0.0427066423,
-0.0086476328,
0.0318092443,
-0.0089743705,
-0.0654490292,
-0.0552247316,
0.0543726608,
-0.0116305817,
0.0059376759,
-0.0307126436,
0.019121591,
-0.0592198931,
-0.0486310273,
-0.023249004,
-0.0780164599,
-0.0123092793,
0.012190599,
-0.0286106095,
0.0146216005,
0.0618384033,
-0.0232206602,
-0.0134750009,
-0.0143862022,
0.0318023264,
0.0076843263,
0.0452764146,
0.0497153178,
0.0403040424,
-0.0113659753,
0.0571634248,
0.0443509892,
0.0176311731,
-0.0198270027,
-0.0181305576,
0.0438326336,
0.0371464603,
0.0490680896,
0.003931833,
0.0620314553,
0.01963415,
-0.0148234172,
0.0193289723,
-0.0439492166,
0.0135047091,
0.0618816912,
0.0096632261,
-0.0287924334,
-0.0503443666,
-0.0332930833,
0.061145287,
-0.0388361178,
-0.0145248109,
0.0167690925,
0.0358545482,
-0.0354076363,
-0.028884409,
0.0252182987,
-0.0310072824,
0.0572525002,
0.0104491021,
-0.0093803667,
0.0059823105,
-0.0019520719,
-0.0161850024,
-0.0274169799,
-0.0028680258,
0.0364874676,
0.0151572237,
0.0012588134,
0.0312374067,
0.0398921296,
-0.0099177994,
-0.0474943593,
0.0101984944,
-0.0380752198,
0.0386716723,
-0.0001118377,
-0.0048724357,
0.0382723622,
0.003102524,
-0.0085410634,
-0.0025368815,
-0.0028011324,
-0.0074291956,
-0.0231699236,
0.0462668464,
-0.0045888885,
0.0397395156,
-0.0152266202,
0.0018150579,
-0.0548020266,
0.0026281415,
0.0563815199,
-0.0615087785,
-0.028181145,
-0.0099948049,
2.607e-7,
0.0147878267,
0.0370935537,
0.0129594086,
0.0290513579,
-0.0097988592,
0.0040047471,
0.0169579536,
0.0129562207,
0.0358731076,
-0.0638081431,
0.0132074943,
0.0596640408,
0.0748723447,
0.0160875767,
-0.1068428978,
-0.039886523,
-0.0666503385,
0.0065493737,
-0.0373899341,
-0.056451451,
0.0201161802,
0.0749155432,
-0.0186745767,
-0.0137637956,
0.0124915289,
-0.0524885505,
0.073884733,
-0.0165013373,
-0.028493898,
0.0506450906,
0.0277523659,
0.0196539145,
0.0086727981,
0.0237698872,
-0.0024910327,
-0.0348319374,
0.0188374426,
0.0360890888,
-0.0064498424,
-0.0554986633,
-0.0078583406,
-0.0099912258,
0.0116653126,
-0.010833635,
0.0498566255,
-0.0544404387,
0.0074925874,
0.0014807631,
-0.006434354,
0.0080608372,
0.0294659641,
-0.0021205463,
-0.0324155428,
0.0275982264,
0.0010378106,
0.0294018704,
-0.0032556993,
-0.0687756538,
-0.0330466479,
0.0339298435,
-0.0192818865,
-0.0484549925,
-0.0127549898,
0.0031306464,
-0.0147622805,
-0.0846906751,
0.0001099867,
2.876447993e-34,
0.078495048,
0.0031279915,
0.0468215086,
0.0321028084,
0.0173240919,
-0.0309812855,
0.0324279033,
0.0072043389,
0.025623221,
-0.0643007979,
-0.0222231559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06825v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06825v1 | Mistral 7B | 2023-10-10T17:54:58 | 2023-10-10T17:54:58 | Albert Q. Jiang, Alexandre Sablayrolles, Arthur Mensch, Chris Bamford, Devendra Singh Chaplot, Diego de las Casas, Florian Bressand, Gianna Lengyel, Guillaume Lample, Lucile Saulnier, Lélio Renard Lavaud, Marie-Anne Lachaux, Pierre Stock, Teven Le Scao, Thibaut Lavril, Thomas Wang, Timothée Lacroix, William El Sayed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce Mistral 7B v0.1, a 7-billion-parameter language model engineered
for superior performance and efficiency. Mistral 7B outperforms Llama 2 13B
across all evaluated benchmarks, and Llama 1 34B in reasoning, mathematics, and
code generation. Our model leverages grouped-query attention (GQA) for faster
inference, coupled with sliding window attention (SWA) to effectively handle
sequences of arbitrary length with a reduced inference cost. We also provide a
model fine-tuned to follow instructions, Mistral 7B -- Instruct, that surpasses
the Llama 2 13B -- Chat model both on human and automated benchmarks. Our
models are released under the Apache 2.0 license. | [
0.0038464004,
0.0936967507,
0.003318205,
0.0343309641,
-0.0221665297,
0.0032895918,
-0.0123450058,
-0.0405135378,
0.042632658,
-0.0397542976,
-0.013964518,
-0.0171686169,
-0.0217823703,
0.0475945584,
0.0540711023,
-0.0526266135,
0.057237193,
-0.0831695721,
0.0181135889,
0.0030947069,
-0.0263015479,
-0.0252519194,
-0.0000127257,
0.0125302915,
0.0331534632,
-0.0585120767,
-0.030484274,
-0.0021924716,
-0.0125323506,
-0.0203311071,
-0.0261677131,
0.035994336,
0.0178426243,
0.0109034684,
0.0000022501,
-0.0314707905,
0.0274662413,
-0.000375841,
-0.0256012492,
0.0725828558,
0.0002599355,
0.0044089062,
0.0096310033,
0.0300676506,
-0.013827228,
0.0229978729,
0.0466011465,
-0.0176045559,
0.0800627843,
0.0637144595,
0.0126262717,
-0.0230108686,
0.0230394974,
-0.0428458042,
0.0373843201,
-0.0709482804,
0.0013211273,
-0.0086191893,
0.0597032681,
0.0009539034,
-0.0023742516,
0.0376408584,
0.0520365164,
-0.0161991846,
-0.0243744459,
0.0163293667,
-0.0246257149,
-0.0296780523,
-0.0174111445,
0.0664767027,
-0.0505114868,
-0.0399617851,
0.0071471659,
0.010272583,
-0.0034300454,
-0.0597131588,
-0.0698712319,
0.0191699788,
-0.0081125442,
-0.0197362751,
0.0487513319,
0.0119550936,
0.0139256632,
-0.0233503785,
-0.0325484462,
0.0331186578,
0.0015047991,
0.0034785729,
-0.0471086502,
-0.0454426333,
-0.0369771421,
-0.0837042704,
0.0078355391,
0.0786666945,
-0.0179712493,
0.0072488277,
-0.0571758188,
-0.0104021607,
0.0469924212,
-0.0570935383,
0.0392547995,
0.0828831643,
0.0009651301,
0.0610753149,
-0.024913894,
0.0528105535,
-0.0439172722,
-0.0029672533,
-0.0221115947,
0.0169329345,
0.0072498391,
0.0190831143,
-0.0369431525,
0.0259768255,
-0.0553244576,
-0.0315416828,
0.0046200985,
0.0482350364,
0.0367099345,
0.018395029,
0.0474201292,
-0.0026168064,
0.0027284208,
-0.0006349506,
0.0008223149,
-0.0281606559,
-0.0330382101,
-0.008398707,
0.0140791414,
-0.0965705663,
-0.0572779179,
0.030621402,
-0.0191472583,
-0.0258610435,
-0.0149796866,
0.119518429,
-0.021917779,
-0.011985464,
-0.0354978666,
-0.0369249433,
0.0283200759,
-0.0704056174,
0.0031557111,
-0.0505508818,
0.0427587777,
0.0210001189,
-0.0421969518,
0.0000688823,
0.0167206228,
0.056240432,
0.0073193694,
0.0340635665,
0.0112148337,
-0.0170305092,
-0.0149798309,
-0.0007349266,
-0.0368212014,
0.0682351217,
0.0252699591,
0.0464889817,
-0.0197834969,
0.0086782007,
0.0247276053,
0.0130420923,
0.0309638176,
-0.0267840698,
0.0061455718,
0.0462964475,
-0.0168212932,
0.0204230677,
0.06185304,
0.0770841613,
-0.0181662012,
-0.0456924103,
0.0269777775,
0.0264163073,
0.0033284931,
0.0415752158,
0.0551814698,
0.0167711228,
0.0087602604,
-0.0187888984,
-0.0881681964,
0.09629298,
0.0071841977,
0.0393574089,
0.0458144359,
0.0193911362,
-0.021030141,
-0.0599541403,
-0.0154827079,
0.0223973244,
-0.0071623134,
0.0270605348,
-0.0050264369,
-0.0176431555,
-0.0787094831,
0.0618094429,
0.0087919477,
-0.0440795086,
-0.0542192534,
-0.037302874,
0.0556056276,
0.0620583631,
0.0312004946,
-0.0170402154,
-0.043281652,
-0.0039608274,
0.024136113,
-0.0033276111,
0.0242767539,
0.0325667225,
0.000785879,
-0.0456057265,
0.020529557,
-0.0498183966,
0.011197363,
0.0239248257,
0.0299883485,
0.0016133887,
0.0012012897,
-0.0158761591,
-0.0087227393,
0.0237224344,
0.0091921901,
-0.0436978899,
-0.0572389998,
-0.0088479873,
0.0390323475,
-0.0325545706,
0.005483197,
0.0491753593,
0.0406896658,
-0.0415643603,
0.0184521861,
-0.0064052693,
-0.0770429373,
-0.0823431313,
0.022086395,
0.0023464302,
-0.0068479474,
0.0178255457,
-0.0294838566,
-0.0170221515,
0.0719537362,
-0.0503647961,
0.0478831641,
-0.0160636753,
-0.0027185362,
0.0227730796,
0.0142660942,
-0.0002572346,
0.0661056787,
-0.0461539552,
-0.0054599619,
0.020513026,
0.006303227,
-0.0019474707,
-0.0387052745,
0.0187194496,
-0.000409577,
-0.0158075336,
0.0187609568,
-0.0407964624,
0.0112887407,
-0.0015425594,
-0.0480186939,
-0.0588789061,
0.016527256,
-0.0391934849,
0.0490044802,
-0.0082399677,
0.0108165555,
0.0053132721,
-0.0085809166,
-0.0136308316,
-0.0214650538,
-0.0151792532,
0.0150685171,
0.0098631782,
-0.014895292,
-0.0573771074,
-0.0666047409,
-0.0147666419,
-0.0322777741,
0.040073324,
-0.0115553401,
-0.0468516722,
-0.0285459831,
0.0010692935,
-0.0319126844,
0.0373117477,
-0.0394796021,
-0.0304728504,
0.005013267,
-0.0278410893,
0.0457501113,
0.0980576351,
-0.0244601015,
0.0010530812,
0.0388914458,
-0.0209999848,
-0.037503738,
0.0523235016,
0.0206222534,
-0.0422601998,
0.0336111858,
-0.0086028464,
0.000798437,
0.1120900363,
-0.0161520112,
-0.0130395629,
-0.048072502,
0.0214095023,
0.0441184044,
-0.0055307467,
0.0133302072,
-0.0228446741,
-0.0121216048,
0.0379205383,
-0.0563449636,
-0.0525908023,
0.0769228265,
-0.032846868,
-0.0094176903,
-0.0240215529,
0.0255299304,
-0.0450621322,
0.0275115445,
0.0023992283,
0.0054409765,
-0.0042913756,
-0.0218896158,
-0.005674351,
0.0110489242,
-0.0191264451,
-0.0319851451,
0.054574322,
-0.0521141663,
0.0224545188,
-0.0231393334,
-0.0343702137,
-0.0346447006,
0.0091430983,
-0.0389704332,
0.0269417074,
0.031792216,
-0.0014507544,
-0.0485049225,
0.0229798779,
0.030231379,
0.0626756176,
-0.0192658845,
0.0101822698,
-0.0271490682,
-0.0246726274,
0.0048337532,
-0.0066727134,
0.0231262483,
-0.0281036589,
0.0233274624,
0.0516154394,
0.0573963039,
0.0278436933,
-0.0131113734,
-0.0007864833,
0.0144037269,
-0.0073009976,
-0.0059524253,
0.0534972399,
0.0669808835,
-0.0798939541,
0.0007920937,
0.088599138,
0.0146126803,
0.0001092781,
0.0179406609,
-0.0683356151,
0.0428894162,
0.0220754705,
0.0442630686,
-0.0841191709,
-0.059747912,
0.0148159154,
0.008578633,
0.0246183872,
-0.0285092406,
-0.0230604988,
-0.0435689054,
0.0281124469,
-0.0001661328,
0.0051119658,
-0.0113407709,
-0.0398475714,
-0.0141252242,
-0.0004578454,
-0.0157546047,
0.0527174249,
-0.0011630198,
-0.0044360422,
0.0041231024,
0.0121913739,
0.0018252461,
0.0598669201,
-0.0115823057,
0.0013557561,
0.0336178727,
-0.0026147428,
0.0514458008,
-0.0894096047,
0.0195966996,
-0.004798559,
0.0222908054,
-0.0118585536,
0.0072254324,
-0.0133453254,
-0.0263291672,
0.0001951396,
0.0276980568,
-0.0655464232,
0.014551471,
0.0095437961,
0.0694428906,
0.0172161944,
-0.0191289093,
-0.0425506644,
0.0110022128,
-0.0208821762,
0.0601958781,
0.0449678861,
-0.000031393,
-0.0623071156,
-0.0432853289,
-0.0359033272,
-0.0220833682,
-0.031277366,
-0.0270867702,
0.0325221121,
-0.0547626391,
-0.028576795,
-0.0347956792,
0.0207714159,
0.0412332192,
-0.0135487914,
-0.0390057564,
0.0524415523,
-0.0217556879,
-0.0362457968,
0.0219979286,
-0.0119877318,
0.0100305444,
-0.0831336826,
0.0133040138,
0.0069043911,
0.0053457152,
-0.0170091931,
0.0771693513,
-0.1226090118,
-0.0551016368,
-0.0301621519,
0.0766020641,
0.0191841461,
0.0074728881,
-0.0239536185,
-0.0300438702,
-0.0525288135,
-0.0079581225,
-0.0167496577,
0.0440590903,
0.0174389165,
0.0013208535,
0.032790482,
0.0375636593,
-0.0137266153,
-0.0051376252,
-0.0038951344,
0.0297613125,
-0.0408953764,
0.0002641377,
0.0147507833,
-0.0024873021,
-0.0240884591,
0.0307208207,
0.0241032373,
0.0134060066,
0.0533748344,
-0.0087515591,
0.0114169829,
-0.0558694936,
0.0244764145,
-0.00492222,
-0.0248791408,
0.0052338797,
-0.0202421043,
-0.0072960262,
-0.0004116094,
-0.0077195256,
0.0552603193,
-0.0052316654,
0.0180577915,
0.0365984328,
-0.0280377045,
-0.0358104408,
0.0025457861,
-0.0370782763,
0.0489991643,
-0.040057227,
0.0323309265,
0.0029363649,
0.0163388606,
-0.0055697332,
0.0047956384,
-0.0242250208,
-0.1140191481,
0.0106605263,
0.0585786849,
0.0388717912,
0.0410762578,
0.0347265005,
0.0106176632,
0.0053845313,
-0.01840307,
0.041685909,
-0.0095793894,
-0.0281254295,
0.0094212983,
0.0535181165,
0.002626458,
-0.0222921111,
0.0594807528,
-0.0012247574,
0.0159172658,
0.0236960407,
-0.0007671558,
-0.0472783074,
-0.0263647959,
0.0198137742,
0.042950999,
0.0194959119,
0.0023486814,
-0.0250315033,
-0.0488908179,
0.0135739837,
0.0332878157,
-0.0190519225,
-0.0267490167,
0.0350165963,
0.0744827092,
-0.0041514486,
-0.0806324109,
-0.00698554,
0.0107799675,
0.0056363712,
-0.0534206033,
-0.0298745725,
-6.787255893e-33,
-0.0295499787,
0.0249434896,
0.0467155613,
-0.014652825,
-0.0121168876,
-0.0388907678,
-0.073983036,
-0.0106754927,
-0.0447120108,
-0.012086927,
0.0040957914,
0.0326020494,
0.0051983888,
-0.0023843648,
0.0265953001,
-0.0093285749,
0.0182870831,
0.0205655452,
-0.0200268608,
0.026011683,
-0.0034640366,
0.0063851038,
0.0258004162,
-0.0211052615,
-0.0291313957,
0.009680884,
0.0214370526,
0.0034308899,
-0.0326029882,
0.0322885774,
-0.0334677957,
0.0125763081,
-0.0047589499,
-0.0202050675,
-0.0304960813,
-0.0112314075,
-0.0509149022,
-0.0341346972,
0.044097092,
-0.0045086904,
-0.040809609,
-0.0702468157,
0.0434443504,
0.0075667431,
0.0098207276,
-0.0331644788,
-0.0038304124,
-0.0001345522,
-0.040598847,
-0.0042282972,
-0.050356172,
0.0231324658,
-0.0045462949,
-0.0428058021,
-0.0079931058,
0.037405476,
-0.0227387473,
0.0417381935,
-0.0512815751,
-0.0223357622,
0.0488112196,
0.0581401736,
0.0617661178,
-0.0263708178,
0.023473423,
0.0057099708,
0.0540901348,
-0.0075980294,
-0.0416930728,
0.0520765707,
0.0112464558,
0.0358344465,
0.0212641601,
-0.0265183803,
0.0284584314,
0.023402255,
-0.0649940372,
-0.0396809056,
0.0129445828,
0.0669736415,
0.0292871669,
0.0314039364,
-0.0505103953,
-0.0186706763,
-0.0120842913,
0.0032838054,
-0.0532343909,
-0.0182857718,
0.0312063564,
0.0119376536,
0.0035918287,
-0.0135309147,
0.035745278,
-0.0040924675,
0.0156703275,
0.020333115,
0.0106365811,
0.0159495659,
-0.0048660291,
0.0510437973,
-0.0606861413,
0.0145541588,
0.0219377838,
0.0130508738,
0.031447947,
0.0081285443,
-0.0029952298,
0.0269012917,
-0.0461692661,
-0.0249886587,
-0.0648205355,
0.0192718171,
0.0007725717,
0.0188888069,
0.0561850406,
0.0037493268,
0.0199972019,
0.058623068,
-0.040671207,
-0.0467437617,
-0.0070561999,
0.018615922,
-0.0042156875,
0.057378538,
-0.0411908925,
-0.01343993,
-0.0734931827,
0.0188475158,
-0.0253003724,
-0.0632127598,
-0.011305294,
0.0730933174,
2.977e-7,
0.0016502051,
0.0452209003,
0.0154251028,
0.0639119893,
-0.000570594,
0.0089154756,
0.0113944244,
0.0284351762,
0.0296935346,
-0.0360683836,
-0.0140142255,
0.0606947318,
-0.0247933287,
0.0051696217,
-0.0807105526,
-0.0136364931,
-0.0684870631,
-0.0116291083,
-0.0400082096,
-0.0765761659,
0.055909317,
0.1099876389,
-0.0152626708,
0.0294734389,
0.0318624265,
-0.0104915528,
0.0291181672,
0.0373091847,
-0.0437820591,
0.0126083838,
0.018837709,
-0.0054961871,
-0.0388352014,
-0.0086718928,
0.0162036978,
0.0126425475,
-0.0184869245,
0.081402123,
0.004051182,
-0.0259498954,
0.0176782012,
-0.0472816862,
-0.0184068307,
-0.0575531572,
0.0680231825,
-0.019603543,
-0.0069862111,
0.0281445216,
-0.0111531578,
0.0245955922,
-0.0114429947,
0.0214985795,
0.0202653371,
0.0062678582,
0.0041066934,
-0.05167941,
0.019633377,
-0.0568324141,
-0.0380616449,
-0.0004943185,
-0.0452496521,
-0.024806397,
-0.0843138099,
-0.0017593849,
0.0301815458,
-0.0219543707,
-0.0197896641,
2.891826306e-34,
0.0477557443,
-0.0322511047,
0.0208612606,
0.0327299275,
0.0471659154,
-0.0050180955,
-0.0201877356,
0.0124094235,
0.036744412,
-0.055007983,
-0.0394036472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06816v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06816v1 | Text Embeddings Reveal (Almost) As Much As Text | 2023-10-10T17:39:03 | 2023-10-10T17:39:03 | John X. Morris, Volodymyr Kuleshov, Vitaly Shmatikov, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | How much private information do text embeddings reveal about the original
text? We investigate the problem of embedding \textit{inversion},
reconstructing the full text represented in dense text embeddings. We frame the
problem as controlled generation: generating text that, when reembedded, is
close to a fixed point in latent space. We find that although a na\"ive model
conditioned on the embedding performs poorly, a multi-step method that
iteratively corrects and re-embeds text is able to recover $92\%$ of
$32\text{-token}$ text inputs exactly. We train our model to decode text
embeddings from two state-of-the-art embedding models, and also show that our
model can recover important personal information (full names) from a dataset of
clinical notes. Our code is available on Github:
\href{https://github.com/jxmorris12/vec2text}{github.com/jxmorris12/vec2text}. | [
0.0207789131,
0.0884447545,
-0.0097006792,
0.0621978752,
-0.0385088548,
0.0005360747,
-0.0134496419,
0.0507214554,
-0.0070173368,
0.0382644869,
0.0064734225,
-0.0231911391,
0.0095860139,
0.0428086519,
0.0640463158,
0.0009472152,
0.0127070434,
0.0168471374,
0.0068835169,
-0.0212472081,
-0.0075613162,
-0.0273712389,
0.0290432088,
0.0314239673,
0.0111789545,
-0.000575003,
0.0032994237,
0.0087370891,
0.0417090505,
-0.030688284,
-0.0188612491,
0.0342501029,
0.0508565791,
0.0486204997,
0.0000019587,
0.0290497094,
-0.0329992734,
0.0247728266,
-0.0470953509,
0.0138737569,
0.0470920503,
-0.0767863169,
0.0225565117,
-0.0065621035,
-0.021556979,
-0.0439494811,
0.0254260227,
0.0565908365,
0.0569524653,
0.0663556308,
-0.0046348898,
-0.0015722198,
0.0254853982,
-0.0465381294,
0.0153435823,
-0.0371369086,
0.0178374145,
-0.0420161597,
-0.0229655039,
0.0775409937,
-0.0146178687,
0.0400647111,
0.0074967351,
0.0201430358,
0.0270223655,
0.0647791848,
0.0077953176,
-0.0025534809,
-0.0045087514,
0.0323453546,
-0.0038809502,
-0.0109263817,
0.0194169618,
0.0196351018,
0.0073798508,
-0.0163320191,
-0.0044739102,
0.006398919,
0.0083275652,
-0.0017315256,
0.011685878,
0.0246105231,
0.026007466,
-0.0204337742,
0.028821798,
-0.0388023183,
0.0007262385,
-0.0244487561,
-0.045667138,
-0.0266590547,
-0.0018151987,
-0.0332616977,
0.0672085583,
0.00502259,
0.0372499079,
0.0155035341,
-0.0565199703,
-0.0765042678,
0.0107337534,
0.0019464492,
0.0318639651,
-0.0013292141,
0.0028489036,
0.0224976856,
-0.0296315383,
0.059130583,
-0.0399770215,
0.0351381041,
-0.0039194487,
0.0219348446,
0.0152949253,
-0.0348518007,
-0.0151429577,
0.0412016809,
-0.0628953651,
-0.0136445612,
-0.0002940873,
0.0115010198,
0.0166158602,
0.05742025,
-0.0458726585,
0.0464823097,
-0.050101053,
-0.0131893726,
0.0579224266,
-0.0539067313,
-0.0000614508,
-0.0175449736,
0.0176013298,
0.0098482771,
-0.0293375961,
-0.0194600243,
0.03698745,
0.017217448,
-0.0143517293,
0.0558404103,
-0.0182200242,
-0.0275860373,
0.0348831117,
-0.0643207505,
-0.0320556648,
-0.0040594107,
0.0193882752,
-0.0354695097,
0.03876606,
-0.0020371594,
-0.0123606762,
-0.0816288516,
0.0103266314,
0.0266309138,
-0.0737641007,
0.1037325114,
0.0141848549,
-0.0388403274,
0.0259980187,
0.0676479116,
0.0137678124,
-0.0064667808,
0.0193367843,
0.0524058603,
0.0343130976,
-0.0170215331,
0.0140819056,
-0.0024576604,
0.074270241,
0.0004013289,
-0.0157122891,
0.0195157249,
-0.0066846022,
0.0294383373,
-0.0206344705,
0.0716767386,
-0.0341837965,
-0.0650842711,
0.0476494618,
0.1035934091,
-0.0227305982,
0.0273446757,
-0.0242217295,
0.0187737346,
-0.0279977936,
0.00747015,
-0.0334560908,
0.0181800462,
-0.042404864,
-0.0221401323,
0.0162523221,
-0.0306207016,
0.0086505068,
0.0106856348,
0.0288704336,
-0.0584004633,
0.0128518892,
-0.0588282198,
-0.0040368759,
0.0208292566,
-0.0432323813,
0.0023379829,
0.0145819886,
-0.055830013,
-0.0072838236,
-0.0153911244,
0.0201486759,
0.0574195385,
0.0648817196,
-0.0294973794,
0.0142569076,
-0.0350833088,
-0.0128701627,
0.0120355543,
-0.0229159519,
0.015139576,
0.0403333195,
-0.0339062512,
-0.0316480733,
0.0034542035,
0.0279972348,
0.0172931179,
0.0029502406,
0.0099596661,
0.0184504408,
-0.0240276214,
0.0124030346,
0.0294075813,
-0.0925843716,
-0.0311503839,
0.0201443955,
0.021346949,
0.0239572562,
0.0376480483,
-0.0171734467,
0.0606865995,
0.0621575601,
-0.0421274118,
-0.0431143641,
-0.0230125561,
-0.023852678,
-0.0514147729,
-0.0269698054,
-0.0729123503,
0.03388777,
0.0453992523,
-0.0211262628,
-0.0135337627,
0.0016147211,
-0.0398985296,
0.0520267189,
-0.0100910692,
-0.0255181529,
0.0106683448,
0.0033196951,
-0.014083161,
0.0226273295,
-0.0758151934,
0.034208715,
-0.0325624421,
-0.0301447399,
-0.0186514128,
-0.0181374233,
-0.0363679789,
-0.0606487505,
-0.001672616,
0.0118142674,
-0.0032305557,
0.0027281984,
0.0184465833,
-0.0539618656,
-0.0548254326,
0.0083866622,
-0.0128260665,
0.0128380321,
0.0180454962,
-0.0051653017,
0.0277786199,
-0.0218344871,
-0.0389465764,
-0.013006445,
-0.0320340879,
0.027425332,
0.0402716435,
0.0170588829,
0.0101560252,
-0.0149805052,
-0.0044745845,
-0.0112331789,
0.0493657179,
-0.054164242,
-0.0168339796,
-0.0380664915,
0.045173578,
0.0144983651,
0.0113460105,
-0.0343018584,
-0.0427991487,
0.0025531393,
0.0124482531,
0.0248246845,
0.0559759699,
0.0052073137,
0.059956383,
-0.0338332281,
0.032871224,
-0.0210885033,
-0.0146294963,
-0.0389914215,
0.0143714892,
-0.0368432216,
-0.0472844839,
0.0053228359,
0.0327568315,
0.0403942242,
-0.0102739707,
-0.0505492426,
0.0143362498,
-0.003015891,
-0.0307235122,
-0.0013247877,
-0.0310164224,
-0.0111416588,
0.0216450468,
-0.0248388071,
-0.0384366438,
0.0584034547,
-0.0079006804,
0.0046217414,
0.0343970992,
-0.0078501087,
0.0046716752,
0.0605957396,
0.0227827616,
0.0419894569,
0.049028635,
-0.0567875169,
-0.0233041644,
0.0450880378,
0.004923617,
-0.0572499149,
-0.0004510425,
0.0446888916,
-0.0365730636,
0.0030017272,
-0.0817883387,
-0.022251863,
-0.1166539043,
0.0150316814,
-0.0098065846,
0.0197926573,
-0.0603822172,
-0.051994957,
-0.0292975865,
0.0186971892,
0.0046569495,
-0.0053316685,
0.0077326647,
-0.0467077382,
0.0284615718,
0.0003763277,
-0.04499368,
-0.0089566698,
-0.0342988372,
-0.0082875555,
0.0998596996,
0.0212702751,
0.0601255521,
0.0243139807,
-0.0212422889,
-0.0156032816,
0.0231280979,
-0.0509931147,
-0.0064177969,
0.0312685743,
-0.0196330026,
-0.027331423,
0.0830477104,
0.0064498973,
-0.0538075678,
0.0096734837,
0.022852879,
0.0018482098,
-0.0102125779,
-0.024834346,
-0.0884006843,
0.0049606259,
0.0173147023,
0.0340129547,
-0.0000861534,
-0.05948551,
-0.0056645009,
-0.0831900761,
-0.0021603587,
0.0111654066,
0.0103196427,
-0.0534000099,
-0.0333303995,
-0.0227700789,
0.0248992629,
0.0024448829,
0.0109874737,
0.0050310758,
-0.0132930772,
-0.0061889822,
-0.0026855909,
-0.0226409156,
-0.0207737666,
-0.0235307384,
0.0444024317,
0.0424055308,
0.0493602119,
0.0092711383,
-0.043451976,
-0.041218169,
0.019320311,
-0.0122500556,
0.021151334,
0.1332351267,
-0.0263466369,
-0.000914408,
-0.0361146405,
0.0789294988,
-0.0088676792,
-0.0104971034,
-0.0239451695,
0.0115957027,
0.0057264981,
-0.0023356527,
-0.0105180573,
0.0089905458,
0.0257237572,
0.0595568195,
0.0134953214,
-0.018078981,
-0.0108241839,
-0.0210146774,
0.119145371,
-0.0054153223,
-0.0131552098,
-0.0003193128,
0.0226606783,
-0.0056090816,
-0.0546508171,
0.0191550888,
-0.0084933769,
0.0454685017,
-0.0000346023,
-0.00038505,
-0.0180470198,
-0.0460224524,
-0.0739228576,
-0.021197699,
-0.0390904397,
-0.0054071103,
-0.0174312647,
0.0101538468,
0.0093161641,
-0.0039282031,
-0.0405900702,
-0.0194212459,
-0.0585473813,
-0.0455758683,
0.0046327887,
0.0247101262,
0.0106304763,
0.0707897171,
-0.0108480137,
-0.058067333,
0.109772779,
0.0342781469,
-0.072726123,
-0.0042807092,
0.0253114402,
-0.0040351362,
0.0075193793,
0.0508360565,
0.0003363923,
-0.0335387923,
0.0620972589,
-0.0384352766,
-0.004926695,
-0.0082873087,
-0.0314258486,
-0.0097907092,
0.0438353568,
-0.0011332985,
0.0262935832,
-0.0208224021,
0.0198647492,
-0.0580935739,
0.0113844275,
-0.034433648,
-0.0275410153,
0.0728931427,
-0.0226443559,
0.0005894044,
-0.0054695192,
0.0198714118,
0.0603352115,
-0.0628948286,
-0.0041319956,
0.0432747491,
0.0409218371,
0.0457945727,
0.0111689251,
-0.0280981045,
0.0417163782,
-0.0088493926,
0.0305236839,
-0.0491018817,
-0.0140453158,
-0.0030254778,
-0.0050339843,
-0.0278352816,
0.0547647625,
-0.0724525824,
-0.0107072862,
-0.0296914261,
0.0361639634,
-0.0271053091,
0.0097058918,
0.016599115,
-0.0286291577,
0.0125433234,
-0.0080281878,
0.0242079254,
-0.0571131632,
-0.0185695719,
0.0032277144,
-0.0105355689,
-0.0132102231,
0.0269324332,
0.1026465148,
0.0505638868,
0.0268545523,
-0.0143112531,
-0.0425776727,
-0.050545577,
0.0326827504,
0.0599451773,
0.0434149168,
-0.0208718218,
0.0189407002,
-0.038277626,
-0.0506566502,
0.032424029,
0.0022551292,
-0.0202830974,
0.029762622,
-0.0218079276,
0.0164725017,
0.0095208408,
-0.0488983802,
-0.0422311462,
0.056382183,
0.0237792283,
-0.0785610452,
0.0083071813,
-6.060283534e-33,
0.0187436659,
-0.0251795389,
-0.0402786285,
0.024212189,
0.005179707,
0.046882458,
-0.023806449,
0.007948135,
0.0304971412,
0.0152692702,
-0.0611636862,
0.006479478,
-0.0014994283,
0.0439505465,
-0.0133258626,
-0.0024908334,
0.0282267611,
-0.024752371,
-0.0227194522,
0.0407691635,
0.051740054,
0.0835331455,
0.049859874,
-0.075094752,
0.0190160889,
-0.0208105966,
0.0032081716,
0.0140926018,
0.0111686997,
0.0345407613,
-0.038211327,
-0.0554115959,
0.0240470394,
0.0107568186,
-0.0109731788,
0.0475317016,
-0.101435706,
-0.003137666,
-0.0312502608,
-0.0112685421,
-0.0396667905,
-0.0455454923,
0.046625156,
-0.0575458929,
0.0044745938,
-0.0251167864,
-0.0158397164,
0.0088460362,
-0.0191405397,
-0.0081833713,
-0.0136959078,
0.0136835678,
-0.0279401895,
-0.0049670045,
0.0598382913,
-0.0142065762,
0.0323809311,
-0.0189334396,
-0.0646010265,
-0.0252403449,
-0.0294777639,
0.0006013063,
-0.0268353019,
-0.0185023136,
0.005224532,
0.0572277084,
0.0642812252,
0.0123787047,
-0.0359719433,
-0.015119072,
-0.0253212377,
0.036577113,
0.027906755,
0.0490083583,
0.0173333678,
-0.0744484141,
-0.0585344471,
0.0067805639,
-0.0818167999,
-0.0159654673,
0.0751261637,
0.0500560179,
-0.0780223459,
0.0020404621,
-0.041299969,
-0.0337208211,
-0.0056532756,
-0.0185824744,
-0.0069443565,
0.0392377228,
-0.0775027126,
-0.0174105968,
0.0039238296,
-0.0605468936,
-0.0204761215,
0.0057903538,
0.032026425,
0.007257286,
-0.0350444876,
0.0334097855,
-0.0388588645,
-0.0017215527,
0.0321364179,
-0.0149315111,
0.0195812769,
-0.0004368087,
0.0766384378,
-0.0059269494,
-0.0796892568,
-0.0415049531,
-0.0245289952,
0.0153560014,
0.0358640328,
0.012045756,
0.0621867739,
-0.0222163741,
0.0115842866,
-0.0133238928,
0.0264058318,
0.0659537017,
-0.029596623,
-0.0113674318,
0.0190488286,
-0.0146908043,
-0.0052088387,
-0.0291428342,
-0.0004713218,
0.0422475263,
0.0799032971,
-0.0014079305,
0.0269624479,
0.0073990519,
2.649e-7,
0.0411796793,
0.0174723398,
0.062714614,
-0.0429635085,
0.0502815098,
0.0386849642,
-0.0040759919,
0.0497868843,
-0.0057196207,
-0.0086214934,
0.0028435749,
-0.016856147,
0.0637048036,
0.0190647934,
-0.0717727095,
-0.0001728866,
-0.0497283526,
-0.0294740666,
-0.0005920219,
-0.0280124638,
0.0341905132,
0.0834878385,
0.0315329172,
-0.0017229596,
-0.0143203558,
-0.0389497913,
0.0516150631,
-0.0331167839,
-0.0161257405,
-0.0152264358,
0.0045882752,
0.0597751178,
0.0186615754,
-0.0549194068,
-0.0422877185,
0.0049608089,
0.0036475097,
0.0763963833,
-0.0120981578,
-0.0077827941,
-0.0117668789,
-0.0246830136,
-0.0217931084,
-0.0249267127,
0.0341159925,
-0.018544089,
-0.0388334431,
-0.0300542153,
-0.0187777244,
-0.0165742375,
0.0499815568,
0.001656452,
-0.0297431722,
0.0427718945,
0.0073553082,
0.0457102098,
0.0204904433,
-0.0706241354,
-0.003917329,
-0.0270690173,
-0.0598198846,
0.0156762954,
-0.0021679555,
0.0172179732,
0.0214840602,
-0.0530770198,
0.0115269097,
2.635218644e-34,
-0.0198631678,
-0.0139073851,
-0.0087081781,
0.0320165753,
0.0271779597,
-0.0171876345,
0.0561550595,
0.0144866277,
0.0119886464,
-0.0449308902,
-0.032698404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06803v1 | Advancing Transformer's Capabilities in Commonsense Reasoning | 2023-10-10T17:21:03 | 2023-10-10T17:21:03 | Yu Zhou, Yunqiu Han, Hanyu Zhou, Yulun Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in general purpose pre-trained language models have shown
great potential in commonsense reasoning. However, current works still perform
poorly on standard commonsense reasoning benchmarks including the Com2Sense
Dataset. We argue that this is due to a disconnect with current cutting-edge
machine learning methods. In this work, we aim to bridge the gap by introducing
current ML-based methods to improve general purpose pre-trained language models
in the task of commonsense reasoning. Specifically, we experiment with and
systematically evaluate methods including knowledge transfer, model ensemble,
and introducing an additional pairwise contrastive objective. Our best model
outperforms the strongest previous works by ~15\% absolute gains in Pairwise
Accuracy and ~8.7\% absolute gains in Standard Accuracy. | [
0.0258054193,
0.1040991619,
0.0052636834,
0.0442489125,
-0.0215696115,
0.0068962565,
0.0187790766,
-0.0061098216,
0.0257228855,
-0.0486891046,
-0.0081723994,
0.0275889784,
-0.0015182638,
0.0066817217,
0.0005335258,
-0.0265498757,
0.0305843093,
-0.0185129344,
-0.0550604425,
-0.0050374065,
-0.0207277816,
0.0284134503,
-0.0095249983,
0.0148543958,
0.0040294658,
-0.0133309094,
0.0309028663,
-0.0173096042,
0.0368392877,
0.0091536995,
0.0039222627,
0.0577732287,
0.022526253,
0.0191659722,
0.0000020418,
-0.047839161,
-0.0099568181,
-0.0092321634,
0.0009303585,
-0.0207476914,
0.0015992745,
-0.0170497354,
0.0138379252,
0.0026265711,
-0.0740233883,
0.0242864825,
0.0358138867,
0.0453767963,
0.064515613,
0.0510312989,
-0.0237399023,
-0.0674559474,
0.0151149901,
-0.0115831019,
0.0064926627,
-0.0543337874,
0.0293175951,
0.0260426104,
-0.033238586,
-0.0197448581,
-0.0335500352,
0.0569991842,
0.0365008712,
0.0053740069,
-0.0216555223,
0.0386832654,
-0.0679727048,
0.0125760892,
-0.0197741203,
0.1059103534,
-0.0029944601,
-0.0376730114,
-0.0411374122,
0.0121871149,
-0.0031530387,
0.0237801466,
-0.002839989,
-0.0022789708,
0.0226946622,
0.0338289849,
0.0385949276,
0.0159439892,
0.0109977089,
0.0411254466,
-0.0699597374,
0.0500951856,
0.0084644211,
0.0070780874,
0.03518245,
0.040198043,
-0.0530404747,
-0.0065296902,
0.022196712,
0.037302915,
-0.0130891921,
0.0242839828,
-0.0143751297,
-0.0363289677,
-0.0190889761,
-0.0219287183,
0.0303160027,
0.0217303894,
-0.0012565089,
0.0859358832,
-0.0445604213,
0.0188315697,
-0.0015317855,
0.0517260358,
-0.0299457759,
-0.052944757,
-0.0375417322,
0.0147775272,
-0.0382035933,
0.0347458571,
-0.0303267557,
-0.0116154216,
-0.0131348232,
-0.0173227284,
0.012242387,
-0.0140882991,
0.0479680113,
0.019680012,
-0.0353022441,
-0.0457968153,
-0.0193781573,
0.0525160432,
-0.0333120376,
0.0699646845,
0.0209066793,
-0.0498732179,
-0.0318396501,
-0.0048363823,
0.0356716104,
-0.0511603877,
0.0358060412,
0.0081476113,
-0.0505734645,
-0.0256666709,
-0.023466263,
0.0272819158,
-0.0165276919,
-0.0354276821,
-0.0330446213,
-0.0747855827,
0.0500966571,
0.0243847817,
-0.0007638234,
-0.0309133623,
-0.0078512169,
0.0070284344,
-0.0403860621,
0.1102692261,
-0.0067040832,
-0.0037123484,
-0.0200538021,
0.0160320699,
-0.0036487486,
0.0289375093,
-0.0018225048,
-0.0068618134,
0.031489484,
-0.0293976348,
-0.0021156059,
-0.0018381248,
0.0373574868,
-0.0098657049,
0.0122491876,
0.0178403463,
-0.0187818669,
0.0127836335,
0.0257904362,
0.0421745591,
-0.0072443001,
-0.019146366,
0.0705213696,
0.0427697413,
0.0175649971,
0.0422239751,
0.0191832483,
0.005080217,
-0.0195111651,
-0.0263102558,
-0.0454361066,
0.016278388,
-0.0687291473,
-0.0294995178,
-0.0128559358,
0.048365999,
-0.0232269876,
-0.0208330043,
0.0211933516,
-0.0290145893,
0.0210454799,
-0.005132609,
0.0443333499,
0.042998191,
-0.0417422876,
0.1029184759,
0.0504088067,
-0.0726260468,
-0.0100744702,
-0.0291154254,
0.0055892561,
-0.0016493935,
0.0303613357,
-0.0070025478,
-0.0355249196,
-0.0010513481,
0.001318066,
0.0319287665,
0.0344121791,
0.0086120013,
0.0506587289,
-0.0489978418,
-0.0052792057,
0.0014779498,
-0.0069196406,
-0.0005942481,
0.0196671523,
0.0250563584,
0.0101360539,
-0.0347377248,
0.0231746137,
0.0163707063,
-0.0410199612,
-0.0258830823,
-0.0063195042,
-0.0032558439,
0.0203788038,
-0.0326379016,
0.0132382717,
-0.0039887824,
0.0236549564,
-0.0252537671,
-0.0277438946,
0.0476164632,
-0.0671689734,
-0.1274579167,
0.0343086906,
-0.0492982641,
-0.0442218706,
0.0734559968,
-0.052972205,
-0.0065097767,
-0.0187092889,
0.0161563978,
0.0527048372,
-0.0345295779,
-0.0153578669,
0.0131911719,
0.0174228791,
0.0045135571,
0.0903801695,
-0.0424861796,
-0.0012771689,
-0.0372991897,
-0.0107265506,
-0.0005472074,
0.0040521794,
-0.0094878133,
-0.0160773117,
-0.014749039,
0.0174439754,
-0.0120885838,
0.0216880906,
-0.0415306352,
-0.0123794088,
-0.0866748467,
-0.0278155766,
-0.0021268197,
-0.0186285507,
0.0146737611,
-0.0117175179,
0.0144536924,
0.0018589352,
-0.0387256593,
-0.0118785035,
-0.0076947799,
-0.0081271622,
0.0324458033,
-0.0124371918,
0.0280125253,
-0.0139897,
-0.010677699,
-0.0144924754,
0.0587542094,
-0.0006370276,
0.0531085804,
0.0003469638,
0.0443399176,
-0.0227515921,
0.0243802089,
-0.0031209497,
-0.040042039,
0.0033675532,
-0.0247368831,
0.008872902,
0.0631667748,
0.0191887673,
0.0005980413,
0.0247926712,
-0.0310786571,
-0.03448309,
0.01821661,
-0.033010263,
0.0013391528,
-0.0364211462,
0.0089216018,
-0.0137550803,
0.0657139868,
-0.0157167744,
-0.015992593,
-0.0559641011,
0.0104907425,
0.018865196,
-0.0085381214,
-0.0360869803,
0.0333670266,
0.0097474512,
0.0325240865,
-0.0311003793,
-0.0014490749,
0.0631636307,
-0.0315058455,
0.0011763141,
-0.0610807501,
0.0124641452,
-0.0240091886,
0.0715376958,
-0.0159690436,
0.005785624,
-0.0307796132,
0.0115061579,
-0.04727979,
-0.0225667637,
0.0187868942,
-0.0408248641,
0.0539585799,
-0.027487753,
0.0307013243,
0.0008810502,
-0.0711791366,
-0.0328666233,
-0.0653120354,
-0.0169606842,
0.00680727,
0.0092208469,
-0.0096958298,
-0.0541446842,
-0.00655072,
-0.022556385,
0.0338672549,
0.0320758782,
-0.0239259917,
-0.0028656416,
0.036848262,
0.0254608877,
0.0543636046,
0.0428922921,
0.0179958288,
0.0163777135,
0.0741073787,
0.0290087517,
-0.0244001504,
-0.032739982,
0.037211068,
0.0290188603,
-0.0072864303,
0.0083685936,
0.0018651581,
0.0785497576,
-0.0289818216,
-0.0309850555,
0.0974617749,
0.0287308823,
-0.0146662425,
0.0024366418,
0.0091079054,
-0.0136908684,
-0.0064691403,
0.0225084517,
-0.0553849526,
-0.077617459,
0.0035770724,
-0.0106293447,
0.0354112051,
-0.0693301857,
0.0153118735,
-0.116673328,
0.0136149861,
-0.0007721449,
-0.0603963397,
-0.0656302869,
-0.0274053533,
0.010236864,
-0.0405210368,
-0.0005920177,
-0.0066139419,
0.0065004169,
0.0093746604,
0.0000671546,
0.0055312463,
-0.0615551248,
0.0596057735,
-0.0547373481,
0.0335781053,
0.0477047302,
0.0618490651,
0.0023067908,
-0.084533684,
-0.0086845811,
-0.0676348284,
-0.0096580992,
-0.0211149938,
0.0293328371,
-0.0315519795,
-0.0220827367,
0.0061447262,
0.0584800281,
-0.0776609629,
-0.0475286096,
-0.0005939532,
0.0592959188,
0.0075863134,
-0.0333178379,
0.0059160371,
0.0233253967,
0.011644545,
0.1013437659,
0.0104919421,
0.0111569688,
-0.009880526,
-0.0306065995,
-0.0234820489,
-0.0333965644,
-0.0387940481,
-0.0062523326,
0.0454639569,
0.0159541368,
-0.0762609169,
-0.0318133421,
0.0384733528,
0.0393065214,
-0.0312261451,
-0.0069936011,
-0.0208551791,
0.0089420024,
-0.0416246653,
0.060954012,
-0.0358587727,
-0.0032552518,
-0.0307129379,
0.0049094935,
0.0312688239,
-0.0115810903,
-0.0592049137,
0.0053271176,
-0.0511002913,
-0.033547271,
-0.0120905386,
0.0823254138,
0.0133533217,
0.0383564346,
-0.0456077307,
-0.0049373354,
0.0397947729,
0.0753688365,
-0.0453257225,
-0.0109995231,
0.067092739,
-0.0278730802,
0.01759018,
0.0611376278,
0.0089215944,
0.0268011745,
0.040106602,
0.0557681061,
-0.0652665868,
-0.0293939095,
0.0110092023,
-0.0121231135,
0.068958275,
0.0185892191,
0.0325478166,
-0.0118516199,
0.0284512844,
-0.009765882,
-0.0305074938,
-0.050897494,
0.0178138819,
0.0511053316,
0.0068606054,
-0.0304234512,
0.0419636779,
-0.0105560906,
0.0119051384,
-0.0195241403,
0.0179468039,
0.0603789389,
0.0267256703,
0.0241251085,
-0.0260759071,
-0.0214193445,
-0.028335277,
0.0059771533,
0.0457020216,
-0.0051145568,
0.0657108426,
0.0493833758,
-0.0061836266,
-0.0148282917,
0.0056291874,
-0.0561095849,
-0.0157410856,
-0.0141581213,
0.0236010011,
0.0279782135,
-0.0394939892,
0.0244368594,
-0.0078057651,
-0.0139122242,
0.0029897434,
0.0625866801,
0.014034803,
0.0079196813,
0.0355690457,
-0.0100921094,
0.0159338769,
0.0024131928,
0.0504762642,
-0.1077942476,
0.0418796055,
0.0248528924,
-0.0154485898,
-0.037419375,
-0.034230262,
0.0061428053,
0.0018354089,
0.0110995974,
0.0453158282,
-0.0480555631,
-0.0657404736,
0.0008797451,
-0.0181980897,
0.0145847183,
0.0243376922,
0.0126310587,
0.0831025839,
0.0183843337,
-0.0289041642,
-0.0265609119,
0.007609705,
-0.0590276495,
0.0150664616,
-0.0286416989,
-6.737343668e-33,
-0.0254550409,
-0.0098814834,
0.0079273777,
-0.0335444137,
0.022675056,
-0.0041856943,
-0.049550835,
-0.0287695024,
-0.0537207909,
0.0210167263,
-0.0165220536,
0.0379002467,
-0.0045902361,
0.0467218384,
-0.0273839459,
-0.0040405593,
0.0042837863,
0.0525728129,
-0.0318696685,
-0.0195950773,
0.0393182747,
0.0285548456,
0.0532806925,
-0.0267195702,
-0.0287361629,
0.0208503529,
-0.0001511789,
0.0260392521,
-0.0445089936,
0.0373850353,
-0.0009924046,
0.0186493378,
0.0200274922,
-0.0382346027,
0.0101135941,
0.0345794782,
-0.1025781855,
-0.0500782728,
0.0150031643,
-0.0175994262,
-0.042665273,
0.0021103446,
0.0237021931,
0.0089780223,
0.0314503573,
-0.0417391546,
0.028269317,
-0.035798084,
0.0097832,
-0.0387872234,
-0.0314770341,
0.0161574557,
-0.0144885592,
-0.0266392604,
-0.0188435409,
0.0213417709,
0.0009698133,
0.0260401927,
-0.07502193,
0.0167190228,
0.0353317447,
0.0054396638,
0.0547073744,
-0.0155246891,
-0.0097682476,
0.0355513282,
-0.0542996787,
-0.0497472659,
-0.0614770018,
0.0290182512,
0.0293596927,
0.0833506584,
0.079658784,
0.0468326733,
0.0397383235,
-0.0003849912,
-0.0465140529,
0.0381833985,
-0.026132388,
0.0486058407,
0.0066483887,
0.0049115783,
-0.0143928723,
-0.0069974973,
-0.0454537384,
-0.0273637287,
-0.0120419972,
-0.0117036942,
-0.0045758914,
-0.0204120446,
-0.079692021,
0.0309248343,
0.0415821709,
-0.0422282964,
-0.0285323858,
0.0214586295,
-0.0249821953,
-0.0376767144,
-0.0125344899,
0.0343560576,
-0.0684311986,
-0.0090851421,
0.047950007,
0.0040217843,
0.0030004235,
0.0286434609,
0.054140836,
0.0180996526,
-0.0439662896,
-0.0269906651,
-0.0347460061,
-0.0021667241,
-0.0171394795,
0.0218663253,
0.0265096389,
0.0367519259,
-0.0112914573,
0.0329311378,
-0.0056370371,
0.00350705,
-0.0220251828,
0.0289809722,
0.0136919934,
0.0150955468,
-0.0162510052,
-0.0036124918,
-0.0556109697,
-0.0380502865,
0.0307669081,
-0.0411704741,
-0.0151188495,
0.0297310892,
2.618e-7,
0.0731385276,
0.014986475,
-0.0063548582,
-0.0150175383,
-0.0180237796,
0.0573356003,
-0.0058159111,
0.0184486602,
0.0125403013,
-0.0092253312,
0.0177735277,
0.0918011591,
0.0323783681,
0.0235675052,
-0.0286523346,
-0.0201270171,
-0.0651410148,
-0.0135370875,
-0.0208871812,
-0.0202680994,
0.0669102073,
0.0931185186,
0.0519069098,
-0.0450875461,
0.0185386464,
-0.044060301,
0.0535341464,
-0.0580297969,
0.0207294449,
-0.0032066419,
0.0160968211,
0.0086516049,
-0.0070229159,
0.0713752285,
-0.012962928,
0.0168017577,
0.0079989545,
0.0527005456,
-0.0093407407,
-0.034075968,
-0.0301941466,
-0.0241178256,
0.0127386739,
-0.0619952306,
0.1094015539,
-0.1068509743,
-0.0167751368,
-0.0163274799,
-0.0506788231,
0.0283604395,
0.0099488841,
0.0095478613,
-0.0146414563,
0.0027488985,
0.0264103562,
-0.0056144055,
-0.0244013015,
-0.1018228084,
-0.0167161226,
0.0210604295,
0.0042719203,
-0.0342723913,
-0.0070810812,
-0.0640218183,
0.0376545899,
-0.0582382791,
0.0083982628,
2.277716833e-34,
-0.0125189619,
0.0103642931,
0.0081643146,
-0.0072655976,
0.0439078398,
-0.0165952761,
-0.0044137295,
-0.0141380271,
0.0046091718,
-0.0738778412,
0.0162518974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06786v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06786v1 | OpenWebMath: An Open Dataset of High-Quality Mathematical Web Text | 2023-10-10T16:57:28 | 2023-10-10T16:57:28 | Keiran Paster, Marco Dos Santos, Zhangir Azerbayev, Jimmy Ba | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | There is growing evidence that pretraining on high quality, carefully
thought-out tokens such as code or mathematics plays an important role in
improving the reasoning abilities of large language models. For example,
Minerva, a PaLM model finetuned on billions of tokens of mathematical documents
from arXiv and the web, reported dramatically improved performance on problems
that require quantitative reasoning. However, because all known open source web
datasets employ preprocessing that does not faithfully preserve mathematical
notation, the benefits of large scale training on quantitive web documents are
unavailable to the research community. We introduce OpenWebMath, an open
dataset inspired by these works containing 14.7B tokens of mathematical
webpages from Common Crawl. We describe in detail our method for extracting
text and LaTeX content and removing boilerplate from HTML documents, as well as
our methods for quality filtering and deduplication. Additionally, we run
small-scale experiments by training 1.4B parameter language models on
OpenWebMath, showing that models trained on 14.7B tokens of our dataset surpass
the performance of models trained on over 20x the amount of general language
data. We hope that our dataset, openly released on the Hugging Face Hub, will
help spur advances in the reasoning abilities of large language models. | [
-0.0097371126,
0.1052530557,
-0.0016516141,
0.0499457456,
-0.009126178,
0.0431299731,
0.0076427967,
0.0156572629,
-0.023458628,
-0.0319868103,
-0.0349664353,
0.0040708231,
-0.0071750763,
0.0466101095,
0.0268690642,
-0.0301807895,
0.010565199,
-0.0265101809,
0.0122567825,
-0.0193564482,
-0.0059796404,
-0.010862832,
0.0021785898,
0.0051414124,
-0.0188153945,
-0.0566227958,
0.0189888049,
-0.0177782215,
0.0164290648,
-0.00655173,
-0.0100321164,
0.0458782539,
0.0133644203,
0.0440271236,
0.0000020884,
-0.0297984537,
-0.0093613379,
0.0131082572,
-0.0336368084,
0.0268340223,
0.0131649598,
-0.0291200839,
-0.0029991665,
0.0155158564,
-0.0679186732,
-0.0064627086,
0.0169281568,
0.0238178428,
0.0571378097,
0.058495272,
0.0002726654,
-0.0162478872,
0.0350881293,
-0.0019653819,
0.0277785938,
-0.0127210841,
0.0209516287,
0.0008838514,
0.0223170631,
0.0286141243,
-0.0225056857,
0.0362235643,
0.0508373119,
-0.0227187704,
0.0185046494,
0.0300727673,
-0.0769998059,
-0.0016666516,
0.0182301402,
0.0908699408,
-0.0212194156,
-0.0403517857,
0.0409028232,
-0.0064331344,
-0.0350512639,
0.0482244119,
-0.0722518638,
0.029930843,
0.0098857563,
-0.0031007773,
-0.0116119012,
-0.0279346853,
0.0411594361,
0.0301692151,
-0.0385836661,
0.0632378012,
0.014122908,
-0.0362225696,
0.0040890113,
0.0011495763,
-0.0420315377,
-0.0429686941,
0.0418439023,
0.0124782398,
0.0658679008,
0.0111079179,
-0.0636922345,
-0.0541036092,
0.0157302395,
-0.0298858583,
0.0159574728,
0.0413158499,
-0.0125444504,
0.0450207368,
-0.0236634705,
0.0194947589,
-0.0223205034,
0.0253209118,
0.0058463654,
0.0322404876,
-0.0287659839,
-0.0086779101,
-0.0049465876,
0.0428994,
0.0228824783,
-0.0004278584,
-0.0131067783,
0.0224942975,
-0.0239507072,
0.0171465464,
0.0124132307,
-0.0110075306,
-0.0037937986,
-0.0240639336,
-0.0007874602,
-0.0127450032,
-0.0267503466,
0.0332508758,
-0.0042928681,
-0.0761915445,
-0.0285522584,
0.014735586,
0.0395293608,
-0.0362648927,
0.0219272319,
0.059225142,
0.054390952,
-0.0117719872,
0.0188324805,
-0.0276628751,
-0.0009654373,
-0.0126327947,
0.0016791619,
-0.0904896781,
0.0397612713,
0.0169999991,
-0.008119016,
-0.033984527,
-0.0090720281,
0.0389750414,
-0.0057820375,
0.0537238233,
-0.0495253988,
-0.019323606,
0.0128109027,
-0.0205616057,
-0.0337308086,
0.0117001515,
0.0221809037,
-0.0049275979,
0.0455737486,
-0.017664291,
0.0135126021,
0.0297425073,
0.0322245061,
0.0028055757,
0.0438654833,
0.0361827761,
0.0359845497,
0.0426214188,
0.0267868731,
0.040040426,
-0.0882257745,
-0.0363178626,
0.0359904654,
0.0637893453,
-0.0060833357,
0.0246026721,
0.0216884222,
0.0042830179,
0.0512051359,
-0.0190115795,
-0.078861393,
-0.0012441889,
-0.0286938921,
0.0094426153,
-0.0028661836,
-0.0078770649,
-0.0119141778,
-0.0611877255,
-0.0006316068,
-0.0152423596,
-0.0073335734,
-0.0059421589,
0.0899022147,
0.015584047,
0.0134958103,
0.0225508045,
0.0184110459,
-0.046110291,
0.0090408409,
-0.0286933314,
0.0308922678,
0.0099139055,
0.0507234409,
-0.0464789271,
-0.0016817519,
-0.0226144809,
0.0345298052,
0.0144036654,
0.0346509032,
-0.0178765487,
-0.0119005321,
-0.058568839,
-0.0193397105,
-0.0373879448,
-0.004913175,
-0.0181608014,
0.0181972403,
0.0195304491,
0.0307331532,
-0.0081428383,
-0.0312404353,
0.0356382839,
-0.0334853269,
-0.0577520616,
-0.012551154,
-0.0216466282,
0.0265002791,
-0.0340193547,
-0.008099026,
0.0443231314,
0.0188228227,
-0.031200042,
-0.0146655971,
-0.0360797495,
-0.0157814957,
-0.0176697522,
0.0898066759,
-0.080348365,
-0.0184748396,
0.0286824461,
-0.0352849849,
-0.0096887443,
0.0611395128,
-0.0231013447,
0.0348102972,
-0.0315437131,
0.0070952591,
-0.0041160188,
-0.0019343097,
0.0031490831,
0.0490809456,
0.0201100241,
0.0154925231,
0.0009075308,
-0.028767921,
0.0068854294,
-0.0367258042,
0.0034275739,
-0.0261495747,
-0.0272609033,
0.0494935997,
0.0129475463,
0.0175403561,
-0.0411789864,
-0.0150965229,
-0.0516614839,
0.0019065277,
-0.0041319691,
0.04181014,
0.0031147834,
-0.0374346562,
0.0058732592,
-0.0166023299,
-0.0114008216,
-0.0330545008,
-0.0181136169,
-0.0096684806,
0.0373636819,
0.0018956641,
-0.0031130495,
-0.0471957289,
-0.0581866875,
-0.0426420271,
0.0426023379,
0.0260713045,
0.050563544,
0.0136220194,
0.0374234058,
-0.0503879227,
-0.0131474752,
-0.0157358721,
0.0087391082,
0.0238084011,
-0.0403199606,
-0.0025796788,
0.0933666751,
-0.0228918679,
0.0304499585,
0.0092034684,
0.0002634816,
-0.0614895262,
-0.0127637563,
-0.0387419611,
0.0297535937,
-0.0260415953,
-0.0040134969,
0.0042265635,
0.0509298556,
-0.0254916139,
-0.0273160189,
-0.0313124917,
0.0483092293,
-0.009130504,
0.0014121423,
-0.0449853651,
0.0298677012,
-0.0093434202,
0.0354220793,
-0.0097691249,
-0.0496118963,
0.0348684117,
-0.0008608872,
0.0131095704,
-0.0437725931,
0.034809161,
-0.0412657782,
0.0132231573,
0.0044640885,
-0.0195867512,
-0.0069473879,
0.0065109399,
-0.0297822803,
0.0228541791,
0.0554347895,
-0.0268656909,
0.0079355454,
-0.0307665672,
0.0237499364,
-0.0174771007,
-0.0622699,
-0.0169353709,
-0.0129004009,
-0.0349903926,
-0.0027006853,
-0.0244616065,
-0.0320178233,
-0.0272500459,
-0.046874959,
0.0387244485,
0.0481214598,
-0.0502351783,
-0.0241906643,
-0.0177686643,
-0.0010240559,
0.0422066376,
-0.0147595201,
0.0687618852,
-0.0805785656,
-0.0308639295,
0.0663794726,
0.0235392712,
0.0075610932,
-0.0165178739,
0.0149858259,
0.0085379332,
-0.0387481898,
-0.0451195277,
0.0125153642,
-0.035399735,
-0.0602719486,
0.011806624,
0.090952605,
0.0358406901,
-0.0012998935,
-0.0123445448,
-0.0471053869,
0.0009356674,
0.0150740733,
-0.0124741951,
-0.0642594248,
-0.0227705501,
0.0327321514,
0.0237841159,
0.0429775529,
-0.0337605737,
0.0385019854,
-0.0958697274,
0.0242512226,
0.0191483535,
0.0112009803,
0.0046925363,
-0.0647988766,
0.0073380526,
-0.0244355593,
-0.0337616429,
0.0251873396,
-0.0305353366,
0.0402674824,
0.0130728222,
0.0057153557,
-0.0497634411,
0.0053751059,
-0.023662826,
-0.0544195026,
-0.0227334015,
0.0665274858,
-0.0220887084,
-0.0898106918,
0.030021539,
0.0076195756,
-0.0484285951,
-0.0149140498,
0.0401057117,
-0.0084486278,
-0.003841124,
-0.0200382601,
0.0967526585,
-0.0921396539,
-0.0120401932,
0.0251846649,
0.1097743884,
-0.0132188927,
-0.0141134001,
-0.0336669125,
-0.0494006202,
-0.0806957707,
0.0513555519,
0.0385183804,
-0.0175798349,
-0.0575754307,
-0.0426659845,
-0.0315877423,
0.0027493048,
-0.0159088355,
-0.0214367509,
0.0231033415,
-0.0489454754,
-0.0667264685,
-0.0192243792,
0.0297187343,
0.0339242145,
0.0065229735,
-0.0519266799,
0.0385445096,
-0.012498159,
-0.0540804602,
0.057712853,
-0.0687983483,
0.0272541326,
-0.0585206337,
0.0332802907,
0.0016083533,
-0.0290256888,
-0.0536708273,
0.0031980702,
-0.071211651,
-0.0440304689,
-0.0187855028,
0.0330296978,
0.0239397194,
0.0307441372,
-0.0325249769,
-0.0370661989,
0.0134219229,
0.0238331128,
-0.0752016753,
0.0067527425,
0.0651161522,
-0.0407387279,
0.0259689707,
0.0203603394,
-0.0233988222,
-0.0007397507,
0.0115093933,
-0.0046679685,
-0.0431853235,
0.0060149739,
-0.000015788,
0.0624488033,
0.0296373107,
0.0378639549,
0.0003818519,
-0.0141001847,
0.0160175357,
-0.012308998,
-0.0052985842,
-0.0312552303,
0.0257418174,
0.0253923014,
0.0252601244,
-0.0280545633,
0.0162000228,
0.0258154701,
0.0446893908,
0.0100023923,
0.0530430004,
0.0134728886,
0.0671051517,
0.0391901843,
-0.0348544866,
-0.0018904246,
-0.0168958809,
-0.0321088322,
0.039981965,
-0.0166795906,
-0.0145224668,
0.0412126221,
0.0165739749,
0.0147263752,
0.0089638261,
-0.0901097357,
-0.0908741206,
-0.0091013014,
-0.0181950089,
0.0138675403,
0.0185869075,
0.0325835459,
-0.0315204412,
-0.0437494256,
-0.0272994079,
0.048727829,
0.04098038,
0.0003232145,
0.0443083979,
0.0338067748,
-0.0410953946,
-0.0368296765,
0.0601452626,
-0.0249882787,
0.011764871,
0.0253751669,
0.0182008259,
-0.0353706516,
0.0010669855,
0.0026545469,
0.028696321,
0.015467993,
-0.0280959718,
-0.0341532975,
-0.0874908864,
0.0201535113,
0.032123059,
-0.0303554554,
0.0097516049,
0.0690096244,
0.0553715974,
-0.0227075983,
0.0130586261,
-0.0052385507,
0.0399169847,
-0.0036498145,
-0.0416179821,
-0.0239222087,
-5.649111405e-33,
0.0260704048,
0.0084225582,
-0.001441119,
0.0509647168,
0.0093294671,
0.016478911,
-0.0266735479,
-0.0203604437,
-0.0111544719,
0.0250791032,
-0.0101057682,
0.0565413386,
0.0065209093,
0.0015044602,
0.0214373507,
-0.0082811927,
0.0368856043,
-0.0279440098,
-0.0195613448,
0.0199143812,
0.0192472581,
0.0261962526,
0.0782687441,
-0.060867589,
-0.0028273363,
-0.000739134,
-0.0049116542,
-0.0082930597,
-0.0108659854,
0.0797214657,
-0.0415996052,
0.0245325752,
-0.0042745634,
-0.0015656949,
-0.0239235889,
-0.0009650394,
-0.062192183,
-0.0450120308,
-0.0207613744,
0.011492434,
-0.0161181595,
-0.0518860817,
0.0521369167,
0.0034236026,
-0.0280865151,
-0.0474391952,
0.0662873387,
-0.0426404774,
-0.051064752,
-0.053664811,
-0.0218290798,
0.0548239052,
-0.0290913433,
0.0211960394,
0.0374581851,
0.0189813897,
-0.0264715627,
0.0548613183,
-0.0104417438,
0.0222258437,
0.0047703087,
0.017887421,
0.0288126171,
-0.0538759716,
0.0601547435,
0.0483573712,
0.0151049299,
-0.0479247384,
0.0191991348,
-0.0015088526,
0.0937697813,
0.0613666028,
0.0643844381,
0.0352856666,
0.0660494789,
0.0134936366,
-0.0417359024,
0.0060797408,
-0.0227669943,
0.037868984,
-0.0129088201,
0.0103043932,
-0.0313539319,
-0.0073049166,
-0.0405900739,
0.0042576441,
-0.0417880416,
-0.004581742,
-0.001294969,
-0.0108957887,
-0.0380130373,
0.0042757355,
0.0035445581,
-0.0669176653,
-0.054208044,
0.0341555141,
-0.0220465548,
0.0311044473,
0.0204356685,
-0.0100226384,
-0.073228091,
-0.0233680531,
-0.0113526359,
0.0058213444,
0.0495463945,
0.0057982313,
0.0459484532,
0.0240279604,
-0.0524306409,
-0.0217233207,
-0.0369219147,
-0.0256525464,
0.0543141775,
0.0758472085,
0.0459921323,
0.0327622928,
0.0198994447,
0.0125762345,
-0.0022536814,
0.0228971783,
-0.0516567677,
0.0363156535,
-0.0011112486,
0.0326905102,
-0.0172885861,
-0.0589752644,
-0.0428013392,
0.0219435412,
0.0540715531,
-0.1237434074,
-0.006700038,
0.0439055599,
2.743e-7,
0.0438033305,
0.0520459041,
0.0306213219,
-0.0046688989,
0.029587714,
0.0339268483,
-0.016244689,
0.0020048306,
0.0106655639,
-0.0048989803,
0.004882317,
0.0277555343,
0.0580713041,
0.0322284997,
-0.0807048082,
0.0326284617,
-0.0758778453,
-0.0283278953,
-0.0429736637,
-0.01051227,
0.0226129666,
0.1172141507,
0.0415387154,
0.0028609547,
0.0449769124,
-0.0345035791,
0.0687570125,
-0.0116781807,
0.0297922213,
0.01817034,
-0.0164082069,
0.0118375812,
0.0064992183,
-0.0195406992,
-0.0302138384,
0.021761477,
0.0252197571,
0.0578521416,
0.0152906738,
0.0601033047,
0.0049482174,
-0.0751543716,
0.0113805728,
-0.0638388246,
0.0870468318,
-0.0034251036,
-0.0368344262,
-0.0266624689,
-0.0563161485,
-0.0515680127,
0.0362362675,
-0.0176950116,
0.0203108583,
0.019958796,
0.0169229377,
-0.0269401371,
0.0146342861,
-0.0648228303,
-0.0250212606,
-0.0135610206,
-0.0393279195,
-0.0476348028,
-0.04729506,
0.0051869601,
0.0574778356,
-0.0128144147,
0.001017548,
2.94569586e-34,
0.0758450851,
-0.0370802209,
0.0298429262,
0.0208842065,
0.0227717496,
-0.0105762482,
-0.0082654711,
0.0038074504,
0.016446365,
-0.0747686923,
-0.0077197095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06773v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06773v1 | Uni3D: Exploring Unified 3D Representation at Scale | 2023-10-10T16:49:21 | 2023-10-10T16:49:21 | Junsheng Zhou, Jinsheng Wang, Baorui Ma, Yu-Shen Liu, Tiejun Huang, Xinlong Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Scaling up representations for images or text has been extensively
investigated in the past few years and has led to revolutions in learning
vision and language. However, scalable representation for 3D objects and scenes
is relatively unexplored. In this work, we present Uni3D, a 3D foundation model
to explore the unified 3D representation at scale. Uni3D uses a 2D initialized
ViT end-to-end pretrained to align the 3D point cloud features with the
image-text aligned features. Via the simple architecture and pretext task,
Uni3D can leverage abundant 2D pretrained models as initialization and
image-text aligned models as the target, unlocking the great potential of 2D
models and scaling-up strategies to the 3D world. We efficiently scale up Uni3D
to one billion parameters, and set new records on a broad range of 3D tasks,
such as zero-shot classification, few-shot classification, open-world
understanding and part segmentation. We show that the strong Uni3D
representation also enables applications such as 3D painting and retrieval in
the wild. We believe that Uni3D provides a new direction for exploring both
scaling up and efficiency of the representation in 3D domain. | [
-0.0337049924,
0.0404498093,
0.0478788204,
0.0519858561,
0.0104335304,
0.0411863178,
0.032654278,
-0.0324742272,
-0.0339380391,
-0.0406130552,
-0.0257818606,
-0.0347380489,
-0.0074981642,
0.060589131,
0.0076393834,
-0.0479631312,
-0.0006970541,
-0.0126134865,
-0.0308236927,
-0.0296465233,
0.0176124554,
0.0300650802,
-0.0068876576,
0.012065771,
-0.0133460285,
-0.0136644626,
-0.0433542915,
0.0516274236,
0.0005683101,
-0.0747848079,
0.0286466684,
0.0147221861,
0.0753635392,
-0.0104957027,
0.000002079,
-0.0292165969,
-0.0425331742,
-0.0162111409,
-0.0045152511,
0.053698089,
0.0002189301,
-0.0194882005,
-0.0118822837,
-0.0245577376,
-0.0315275155,
0.0095257144,
0.0809560046,
0.0797422677,
0.0279360563,
0.0408103876,
-0.0254499707,
-0.0458634086,
0.0305462107,
-0.0225521363,
0.0248022489,
-0.0162088722,
0.0074215513,
0.0100664496,
-0.0159084518,
0.0515523925,
0.0046414053,
0.0083075482,
0.0244343951,
0.0442480743,
0.0451647714,
0.0397931002,
-0.0332936533,
-0.0261666756,
-0.0077064564,
0.0796224996,
-0.0514740348,
-0.0094788419,
-0.0019662182,
-0.0275296234,
-0.0071547539,
-0.0239442084,
-0.0239841547,
0.0082602631,
-0.0016934711,
-0.0176842287,
-0.0519367196,
0.0334384553,
0.0157737583,
-0.015318268,
-0.0338843316,
-0.0454791002,
0.0303999577,
0.032517612,
-0.0405250117,
-0.006157096,
-0.0423709638,
-0.0361059532,
-0.0111084264,
-0.0013358642,
0.0165138096,
-0.0323010571,
-0.0360539816,
0.0069522196,
-0.0159011036,
-0.0245987978,
0.08058092,
0.0161929801,
-0.0418158695,
0.0821354687,
-0.0291795097,
0.0133701963,
-0.0607785992,
0.0634797215,
-0.0267743152,
-0.0060550258,
-0.0087300641,
-0.0315777138,
-0.0693706349,
0.0115982872,
-0.01865617,
-0.0313272625,
0.0127167227,
-0.0080739157,
0.0116689978,
-0.0364352539,
0.0228688065,
0.0474610813,
-0.0066775628,
-0.0329127461,
0.0300132334,
0.0640619323,
-0.0196629725,
0.0351920091,
-0.0632780865,
-0.0271758828,
-0.0284526683,
0.0212700646,
0.0451596752,
-0.0106185582,
0.0367080495,
0.0360897742,
-0.0485251471,
-0.0992169827,
0.029467795,
-0.0263858568,
-0.0205901377,
-0.0121936109,
0.0586445481,
-0.036775209,
-0.0005264741,
-0.0112359738,
-0.0070456574,
-0.0238321591,
-0.0127992909,
-0.0280520674,
-0.0034918126,
0.0573390909,
-0.0289520547,
-0.0282064471,
0.0199248735,
0.0033618694,
0.0378780253,
-0.0147932507,
0.0217002016,
0.0660344735,
-0.0342378318,
0.0286784805,
0.0146969901,
0.0536371507,
0.0344084837,
0.0228037443,
-0.034930151,
-0.0034921924,
0.0276331156,
0.0634703934,
0.0114937993,
-0.0292977616,
-0.0424894951,
-0.0441466048,
0.0461743623,
0.0152154882,
-0.040998973,
0.0038932324,
0.0394415334,
0.0230169911,
0.0017559894,
-0.067947939,
-0.0265142191,
0.0456649475,
0.0044100229,
-0.025545869,
-0.0226408076,
0.0588888377,
-0.0555440187,
-0.0282408781,
0.0016084237,
-0.0110045439,
0.0057169255,
-0.0121524828,
0.0479056649,
0.0204526354,
-0.0256138016,
0.0815420076,
0.0022299592,
-0.0319372229,
-0.0356097519,
0.0071708746,
0.0282297563,
0.0190617647,
-0.011288764,
-0.0138232848,
-0.0126611786,
0.0030216696,
0.0548119135,
0.0243911333,
0.0081536788,
0.0064163399,
0.0588665754,
-0.0351040363,
-0.073708415,
-0.0149703426,
0.0068351962,
0.0365257226,
0.0302684773,
-0.0241637379,
0.018728422,
-0.093660742,
0.0452270545,
0.0124677103,
-0.0156342518,
-0.0328856148,
-0.0148816872,
0.0294272285,
-0.008148293,
0.0028064104,
-0.0025619536,
-0.0420423374,
0.0142882662,
-0.0312743336,
0.0077523221,
-0.0035873116,
-0.064285405,
-0.0174634717,
-0.0133377239,
0.0345832743,
-0.010539067,
0.0410758816,
-0.0196895432,
-0.0060482388,
0.0016643873,
0.0271157529,
-0.0167365838,
0.0180885475,
-0.0122672329,
0.0315505415,
0.0510643795,
-0.0602523834,
0.0287036486,
-0.0520968474,
-0.0286413524,
-0.0191226695,
-0.0181046445,
0.0367813781,
0.029471321,
-0.0215308331,
-0.0061463863,
-0.0089621674,
0.0239712913,
0.0298104491,
0.0182304271,
0.0039469199,
0.0365481712,
-0.0479954146,
-0.0001469978,
-0.0054898523,
0.0137744974,
0.0050738202,
0.022673253,
0.0049665808,
-0.0456440449,
-0.0154390344,
0.0262037534,
-0.0152585749,
-0.016795978,
0.0259768479,
-0.0075064832,
-0.0055421554,
-0.0129431169,
0.007652136,
-0.0048341886,
0.0614892393,
0.0449572057,
-0.0612260289,
0.0148492064,
0.007412693,
-0.0397422686,
0.0359693356,
-0.0023559837,
0.0107506244,
0.0521577299,
-0.0753477663,
-0.0007899731,
0.0790827125,
-0.0251590479,
-0.0203396603,
-0.0277518556,
0.0346406996,
-0.0783700794,
-0.0072470196,
-0.0143785374,
-0.0111970268,
-0.0188797321,
0.0202399604,
0.0120973708,
0.0502147153,
-0.0097895926,
0.0135246534,
-0.0406406261,
0.0372434184,
0.032753855,
-0.0025088794,
-0.0493915342,
-0.0012998215,
0.0042476249,
-0.0005167588,
-0.0399325714,
-0.0294698235,
-0.0399379469,
-0.0544145033,
0.0205426011,
-0.0002299047,
0.031514585,
-0.0254785959,
0.0662562251,
0.0315392502,
0.0197673924,
-0.0202618539,
-0.0199410357,
-0.0207014401,
0.0327236839,
0.0167372059,
0.0272698421,
-0.0173824281,
-0.038789358,
0.0589512587,
-0.0205105208,
-0.0672946051,
0.0302613657,
-0.037225455,
-0.0443641022,
0.0128855417,
-0.0893698633,
-0.0379858501,
-0.0179467965,
-0.0168948155,
0.0046786936,
0.0748007298,
-0.0257782899,
-0.0189827587,
-0.0136892851,
0.0289282352,
-0.0239290316,
0.038015388,
-0.0371542275,
-0.0166974515,
-0.0238756258,
0.0706196427,
-0.0380012803,
0.0269652382,
-0.0936290026,
0.0418614261,
0.0223788209,
0.0373623855,
-0.0188514162,
-0.0033425661,
0.0523271337,
-0.022237042,
-0.0135438088,
0.0018759025,
0.0295528043,
-0.0136375846,
-0.044668097,
0.0316975079,
0.0188130196,
0.0007326766,
-0.0497334152,
-0.0960502848,
-0.0749126822,
-0.0422462448,
-0.0327221565,
0.0985244885,
-0.0108332606,
0.0071857562,
-0.0560835339,
0.019020468,
0.0360136591,
-0.0207855813,
-0.0322989263,
0.023253249,
0.0227587745,
-0.033376094,
-0.0434236377,
-0.0291500222,
-0.0061840294,
0.0137435673,
0.0143983858,
0.0670724809,
-0.0239817519,
0.0232906565,
-0.0385709368,
-0.0262385663,
0.0208535362,
-0.0106882527,
-0.0209760759,
-0.0335821509,
0.0469477028,
0.0622593425,
0.0120937321,
0.0039157495,
0.0451964848,
-0.0144556733,
-0.0147420308,
0.0166736022,
0.0052291113,
-0.0023566675,
-0.0268934127,
-0.0475526862,
0.0370229967,
-0.0121587059,
0.05402942,
-0.0399521887,
-0.0312632024,
-0.0161581729,
0.0381009988,
-0.0133782709,
-0.0091264751,
-0.0414850563,
0.0244097896,
-0.0041452423,
0.0128663816,
-0.0319445394,
-0.0089912703,
0.0103417421,
-0.0078263413,
-0.0464814119,
-0.0001863415,
0.0372163877,
0.0037366429,
-0.0217620265,
-0.063000448,
-0.0432611182,
0.0069693075,
-0.1118122786,
0.0458782203,
-0.0397520028,
0.0355299637,
-0.0285427067,
0.0232779644,
0.0444418229,
-0.0726483017,
-0.0214344729,
-0.0517827012,
-0.0807361156,
-0.0000903814,
0.0008129631,
0.0704380572,
-0.0002152488,
0.0539071038,
0.0209929757,
-0.0543548502,
0.0694399029,
0.0279909354,
-0.0060412902,
0.0499195345,
0.018569354,
0.0165145881,
-0.0309834592,
-0.0091620572,
-0.0193840675,
0.0782938674,
-0.0136845708,
-0.0442954116,
-0.0220930502,
-0.0673685446,
-0.0188853219,
-0.0274681468,
0.0856441185,
0.0234356318,
0.0363458358,
-0.0582529753,
0.0121600814,
0.0122539364,
0.017717218,
-0.064404048,
0.0222824831,
0.0217165779,
0.0085404506,
-0.0134973526,
0.0366613939,
0.0454386063,
0.0541494004,
-0.0419059098,
-0.0346606933,
0.0001025102,
-0.0117376531,
0.0075268145,
0.0192079302,
0.0074082925,
0.0960276276,
-0.0524500199,
0.0334657989,
-0.0267308969,
0.0266940258,
0.0204137191,
0.0253618155,
-0.0433634669,
0.0912062898,
-0.032536298,
-0.0906569734,
-0.0668375269,
0.0345017016,
0.0077568609,
0.0193471834,
0.0374797881,
0.0078113894,
-0.017681852,
0.0001264721,
0.0355685428,
0.0182698704,
-0.0483051278,
0.0504308119,
0.0184131116,
-0.0071049081,
-0.0349744298,
0.0007579378,
0.0163837764,
0.0010548282,
0.0039833235,
0.013191347,
-0.0105097005,
-0.0017901746,
0.0329493172,
0.008160417,
0.0213155262,
0.0602280647,
0.0158892591,
0.0241357461,
-0.0300110467,
0.0436888598,
-0.0428943485,
0.0325217471,
0.0434363633,
0.0429965891,
-0.0157842506,
-0.0294881053,
0.0154372714,
-0.0151240081,
-0.0237614773,
0.0015162657,
0.0372408368,
-5.954025456e-33,
-0.0085487124,
0.0011942891,
0.0222792998,
-0.028929431,
-0.0037633225,
0.0095391562,
-0.0068762633,
0.0208841395,
-0.0342964381,
-0.0030649477,
0.0194233656,
-0.0024184859,
0.0032705606,
0.0209988113,
-0.0043644165,
-0.0120020835,
0.063011989,
-0.0216676909,
-0.0141046336,
0.0353501923,
0.016378928,
0.0238917135,
0.1103717461,
-0.0496347696,
-0.0403732322,
-0.0294446591,
-0.0340675414,
0.0063225385,
0.0219031069,
0.0162990242,
-0.0191101786,
-0.0612128749,
0.0142859044,
-0.0495630912,
-0.0021886486,
-0.0022977793,
-0.0922743976,
0.0009346074,
-0.059334524,
0.0262058731,
-0.0588084683,
0.0364596024,
0.0029029297,
-0.0082454812,
0.0189753361,
-0.0583398491,
0.0384991542,
0.0051595215,
-0.0148120625,
-0.0529582053,
-0.026598487,
0.0428500324,
-0.0168897826,
-0.0354720987,
0.0298802871,
-0.0033117437,
0.0537844039,
0.0070392718,
-0.0501459241,
-0.0189651418,
-0.0341060683,
0.0026444539,
0.0000501456,
0.0410587005,
-0.0234978031,
0.0860887021,
0.0588539466,
-0.0375405699,
-0.032130383,
0.022063937,
0.0320387781,
0.0319726281,
0.0122925825,
0.0789253861,
0.0485674031,
0.0393998921,
-0.0395234488,
0.0315105654,
-0.0906898826,
0.0017033622,
-0.0152912699,
-0.0014399447,
-0.0334031582,
-0.007857685,
0.0045332508,
-0.0283603482,
-0.0287268963,
0.011675287,
0.0659831911,
0.0170902312,
-0.019928867,
0.0221409742,
0.0644011199,
0.0023903775,
-0.0051594898,
0.0708154812,
-0.0313739143,
0.0480792038,
-0.0099100051,
-0.0169730242,
-0.0531691015,
-0.0180392303,
0.0045824531,
-0.0006417744,
0.0291583706,
0.0205720142,
0.028337568,
0.0350749157,
-0.0053672995,
-0.0167160202,
-0.0259088501,
-0.0195628554,
0.0091733458,
0.1025081053,
0.0469429977,
0.0313303135,
0.0021706575,
0.0499588139,
-0.0211032126,
-0.0014545524,
-0.0428900793,
-0.0250523016,
-0.0044269119,
0.0341072716,
-0.0098226704,
0.0251786262,
-0.054944139,
-0.0185366422,
0.0533870049,
-0.0906216502,
-0.0158345625,
0.0437063761,
2.699e-7,
0.0377017334,
0.0218594633,
0.0259944759,
-0.0383732431,
-0.0511767156,
0.0723469853,
0.0261934213,
0.0840365812,
-0.0454401895,
-0.0204204135,
0.0458577015,
0.0652931929,
-0.0176503919,
-0.0137612252,
-0.1051613465,
0.0622716583,
-0.0505424887,
0.0341833644,
-0.0644002855,
0.0177327655,
0.056652423,
0.0726649091,
-0.0424988717,
-0.0058933129,
0.0191300139,
0.0016549814,
0.064188011,
-0.0113997683,
0.0328727886,
0.0077804234,
0.0211669412,
0.0212057512,
-0.031810008,
-0.0077307541,
0.0131324418,
0.0323095992,
0.0475910492,
0.029063005,
-0.0379110388,
0.0026147226,
0.0007439169,
-0.0159165226,
-0.0137045737,
-0.0249248575,
0.0480001569,
-0.0358204879,
0.0181187671,
-0.0311491247,
-0.0093663875,
-0.0082769301,
0.0488920994,
0.0127734961,
0.024269212,
0.0256362408,
0.0098959617,
-0.0439269021,
0.0045373589,
-0.0865325183,
-0.0469494276,
-0.0089371065,
-0.010012514,
0.0190342795,
-0.0322058015,
-0.0543729849,
0.0187601801,
0.0157234706,
-0.0443454832,
1.754732394e-34,
-0.0156592708,
0.0022073758,
0.0142862936,
-0.0224490147,
-0.0106329359,
-0.010777886,
0.0278315209,
-0.0156719591,
-0.024904741,
-0.0395907648,
-0.0018043922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06770v2 | SWE-bench: Can Language Models Resolve Real-World GitHub Issues? | 2023-10-10T16:47:29 | 2024-04-05T18:16:29 | Carlos E. Jimenez, John Yang, Alexander Wettig, Shunyu Yao, Kexin Pei, Ofir Press, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Language models have outpaced our ability to evaluate them effectively, but
for their future development it is essential to study the frontier of their
capabilities. We find real-world software engineering to be a rich,
sustainable, and challenging testbed for evaluating the next generation of
language models. To this end, we introduce SWE-bench, an evaluation framework
consisting of $2,294$ software engineering problems drawn from real GitHub
issues and corresponding pull requests across $12$ popular Python repositories.
Given a codebase along with a description of an issue to be resolved, a
language model is tasked with editing the codebase to address the issue.
Resolving issues in SWE-bench frequently requires understanding and
coordinating changes across multiple functions, classes, and even files
simultaneously, calling for models to interact with execution environments,
process extremely long contexts and perform complex reasoning that goes far
beyond traditional code generation tasks. Our evaluations show that both
state-of-the-art proprietary models and our fine-tuned model SWE-Llama can
resolve only the simplest issues. The best-performing model, Claude 2, is able
to solve a mere $1.96$% of the issues. Advances on SWE-bench represent steps
towards LMs that are more practical, intelligent, and autonomous. | [
0.0590843111,
0.0641647205,
-0.0316319317,
0.0023435145,
-0.0277549867,
0.0077628298,
-0.0285909567,
0.0085676648,
-0.0053208144,
-0.0496643372,
0.0091854101,
0.0139511134,
-0.0061281594,
0.0661007017,
0.0088096373,
-0.0307156872,
0.0215669442,
-0.0548875295,
0.0427688733,
0.0305428486,
-0.0197617952,
0.0204445682,
-0.0085224053,
0.0482613966,
0.014738949,
-0.0227609463,
-0.0002185429,
0.0288203154,
-0.0166472699,
0.0255913101,
0.027834652,
0.0168528017,
-0.0044233617,
0.0350388177,
0.0000021716,
-0.0452167802,
0.0127771702,
0.0111179352,
0.0029543913,
0.0160598252,
0.0027304252,
-0.0230841897,
-0.022621369,
0.0254907236,
-0.0236061886,
0.0422997922,
0.0260377564,
-0.0304014441,
0.08259397,
0.0448611788,
0.0190249067,
0.031950362,
-0.0371325612,
-0.0032746266,
0.0622133575,
-0.0165419579,
-0.0141131794,
0.0615813658,
0.0493716858,
-0.0046196594,
0.0346400887,
0.042990353,
0.0238748621,
-0.0155949285,
0.0120473327,
0.0208709054,
-0.0400926173,
-0.0190233383,
0.0005362645,
0.022576632,
-0.0664081872,
-0.0515908934,
-0.0071239341,
-0.0246864706,
-0.041128017,
-0.0064125764,
-0.0414173976,
0.0207506996,
0.0357887857,
-0.0159173347,
-0.0043562022,
-0.0379863121,
0.0256510936,
-0.0045511001,
-0.016910864,
0.101160787,
0.0064417291,
0.0310286526,
-0.0061392323,
-0.0057888529,
0.0102185681,
-0.0664179847,
0.0134450793,
0.0753670037,
-0.0344830118,
0.0063230637,
-0.0099453237,
-0.0144802118,
0.0664763749,
-0.0500063412,
-0.0312759615,
0.0508114994,
-0.0441296697,
0.0376815982,
0.0054369005,
0.0709425732,
-0.0278400891,
-0.0046467045,
0.0016868,
0.0033474693,
-0.0486683622,
0.0091406275,
-0.022980297,
-0.0002680961,
-0.0136848548,
0.0331534669,
0.016602423,
0.0443569198,
0.0141171217,
0.0843084604,
-0.0107090753,
-0.0213628355,
-0.0608217828,
-0.0371100493,
0.0046147322,
0.0087324763,
-0.0277862512,
-0.0093182577,
-0.0108271344,
-0.0136016021,
-0.010694433,
-0.0207246095,
-0.0394039564,
-0.0364589617,
0.0224551782,
0.0779840276,
0.0292374305,
0.0585544594,
-0.0289579481,
-0.0491642877,
0.0121422606,
-0.0289810952,
-0.0629338324,
-0.1052772105,
-0.0475944765,
0.0375287719,
0.0064036394,
-0.0894708186,
-0.0288113113,
-0.0383424014,
-0.0005478637,
0.0069639306,
-0.0419593193,
0.03777951,
0.0712004006,
0.0504449643,
-0.0413059108,
0.0348315015,
0.0124178743,
0.0112602869,
0.0395703167,
-0.0330126733,
0.0640878975,
0.03356288,
-0.034034159,
0.0062711965,
0.031140374,
0.021031877,
0.0057603167,
-0.0167045314,
0.0001453795,
0.0450252332,
0.0171677675,
-0.0343536995,
0.0150963571,
0.0424942337,
-0.0082012992,
-0.0185067933,
0.0246183332,
0.0267192293,
0.0192345642,
-0.0126223266,
-0.0285666976,
0.0568232387,
-0.0036314472,
0.0065528257,
-0.0382768735,
0.0331073292,
0.002368123,
-0.0576837584,
-0.034763772,
-0.0101138782,
-0.0691125616,
0.0050282301,
0.033147458,
-0.0065682344,
-0.0065235859,
0.0563077293,
0.0340677798,
-0.0028430128,
-0.0144393099,
-0.0305784307,
0.0181899853,
0.0706201345,
0.0920574367,
-0.0707686916,
-0.0808258504,
-0.0260268468,
-0.0016766612,
-0.0145147629,
0.0420046598,
-0.0279709827,
-0.0032388677,
-0.020108493,
-0.0282773953,
-0.0782465264,
0.0073650982,
0.0002443034,
0.0252841152,
-0.0318385586,
0.014207094,
-0.0367614664,
-0.055732917,
0.0366173945,
-0.0169996042,
0.0276586767,
0.003408703,
-0.0241328664,
0.0014567523,
-0.0175932348,
-0.0318519361,
-0.0001062548,
0.0385507047,
-0.0293488409,
-0.0406114943,
-0.0108908508,
0.0186203495,
0.0245673303,
0.0577931516,
-0.0111360392,
-0.0343101956,
0.0256330986,
-0.0647316128,
-0.0062010181,
0.0484197289,
-0.0076238676,
-0.0104926275,
0.0394326672,
0.0429575741,
-0.04408684,
-0.0289264116,
-0.0050046537,
0.0259576607,
0.0252292324,
0.0150552355,
-0.00952446,
0.0645452514,
0.0459907912,
-0.0027473678,
-0.0758736208,
0.0133346645,
-0.0226434376,
0.0213351641,
0.0060182302,
0.0335574634,
-0.0277814437,
-0.053519439,
-0.0132380361,
0.0031194494,
-0.0138718113,
0.0100130122,
0.0306042749,
0.0234657656,
0.0075287037,
-0.019857049,
0.0120189851,
-0.0129154567,
-0.0031597412,
0.0048233615,
0.0443858393,
0.0116785234,
-0.031448368,
-0.0662729517,
0.0000495841,
-0.0372017138,
0.0391226746,
-0.0074669723,
-0.0263684504,
-0.0782993436,
0.0255438853,
-0.034211386,
0.0411616042,
-0.0063353488,
-0.0253560878,
0.0151065886,
-0.027924357,
0.0852311701,
-0.0024641238,
-0.024682099,
-0.023980381,
0.078842774,
-0.0057989303,
-0.0594015308,
-0.0076112612,
0.0531268269,
-0.0433978625,
-0.0027214056,
-0.0215217955,
0.0141208749,
0.0658776835,
-0.0311677754,
-0.0115827769,
-0.0376020223,
0.0247655287,
-0.0252363924,
0.029337015,
0.0317735299,
-0.046463605,
0.0225902628,
0.0683248341,
-0.042326171,
-0.0809471309,
0.0598028414,
-0.0423981771,
-0.0128387222,
-0.0279949028,
-0.0342164524,
-0.0760420561,
0.0828091651,
-0.0021895624,
-0.0038549292,
-0.0300396737,
-0.0114304433,
-0.0068984572,
0.0243267808,
-0.0190187786,
0.0013747764,
0.0460770093,
-0.0746425092,
0.0166379046,
-0.0019416839,
0.0026370259,
-0.0108788693,
0.0017281019,
-0.0857087299,
-0.0036398869,
-0.0144700492,
0.0074422355,
0.0142553141,
0.023554692,
0.0114605306,
0.0567511022,
0.0652801394,
-0.0290643387,
-0.0133429272,
-0.0497568287,
-0.007453111,
-0.017123457,
-0.0298753716,
0.0204647165,
0.0043083052,
0.0210996661,
0.1048864052,
-0.0001205443,
-0.0629627928,
-0.0024302236,
0.0129028065,
-0.0582301617,
-0.0506305732,
0.0296359323,
-0.0134374732,
-0.0652237609,
-0.0166428704,
0.0828056484,
0.0639892295,
-0.0283691455,
0.0152252968,
-0.0502311029,
0.0197653696,
0.0660529882,
0.0611119345,
-0.0986407623,
-0.029870728,
-0.0015145752,
-0.0063600498,
0.0052326042,
0.0060485285,
-0.0189355034,
-0.0589153431,
0.0268295407,
-0.0019547909,
0.003365509,
-0.0085142972,
-0.0241704639,
0.0130114071,
-0.0088478262,
-0.0521304086,
0.0426333621,
0.0169335492,
0.0233144127,
-0.0185604654,
-0.0259588026,
-0.0013949519,
0.0755850375,
-0.0148324938,
-0.0079137217,
0.0739827603,
0.0090094926,
0.0250251461,
-0.0014782238,
0.066400215,
-0.015493596,
0.0043609864,
-0.0389907435,
0.0396508835,
0.0218668152,
-0.0387290418,
0.0775792152,
0.0058638337,
-0.072757028,
-0.0297317002,
0.0150984917,
0.0740529224,
-0.0414557159,
-0.0080127427,
0.0000296339,
-0.0132965473,
-0.0207941178,
0.0358392783,
0.0589299165,
-0.0057121366,
-0.0374324247,
-0.0467323959,
-0.0251236372,
-0.0253030062,
-0.0356205478,
-0.0319342315,
0.0403577834,
-0.0028985501,
-0.0648364127,
-0.0034778945,
0.0286210217,
0.0208883919,
0.055922959,
-0.0186160114,
0.0169875342,
-0.0079326471,
-0.0263560284,
0.0058721369,
-0.0008969101,
0.024600802,
-0.0438639037,
-0.021255523,
0.0266444106,
0.0005918441,
-0.0268227644,
-0.0081964936,
-0.0560036339,
-0.0538743176,
-0.0022081304,
0.062378332,
0.0306596477,
-0.0124409134,
-0.0594037026,
-0.0825840086,
-0.0497080199,
0.0131352637,
-0.0458535179,
0.0041499613,
0.0072106491,
0.0025936081,
0.0084886635,
-0.0012898287,
-0.0735279098,
0.0106887696,
-0.0094328541,
-0.0014865261,
-0.0229447298,
-0.0207882598,
0.0149003882,
0.021707084,
-0.0061102114,
0.0750682801,
-0.0274641607,
-0.0223654099,
0.0276496336,
0.0292756595,
-0.0338854901,
-0.0389010906,
0.0228268523,
-0.0269110985,
-0.0577816777,
0.0435822792,
0.0425147153,
-0.0596748516,
0.0455546379,
0.0021397106,
0.0346691944,
0.0188767686,
0.0593820624,
0.0431218073,
-0.0175738391,
-0.0119440649,
-0.0003708848,
-0.0082239257,
0.0404866971,
-0.0086583765,
0.0204501878,
-0.0121866921,
0.0238762852,
0.0096525485,
0.006488061,
-0.0709810704,
-0.0786381438,
0.0183821078,
0.0089906389,
0.0124844154,
0.0384358391,
0.052796334,
-0.0107678687,
-0.0196107868,
-0.0276023317,
0.0394833833,
0.0141497012,
-0.0216520838,
-0.0067928759,
0.0174105726,
-0.007603155,
-0.0078713633,
0.0673277229,
-0.0399532914,
0.0369119793,
0.0095454231,
-0.020584492,
-0.01578613,
-0.0073024645,
-0.0079372618,
-0.0507828891,
-0.0183705278,
-0.0575053282,
-0.0578452833,
-0.037196964,
0.0161837023,
0.0547958687,
0.0089764073,
0.0050778836,
0.0124004157,
0.0891862586,
0.0200512502,
0.0205780063,
0.0082163,
-0.0076465299,
0.0012119985,
-0.0101860659,
-0.0437023863,
-5.437366302e-33,
-0.0176775735,
-0.0208211243,
0.0330898315,
0.0250791255,
0.0305229407,
0.0167232156,
-0.0892959908,
0.0096653821,
-0.020108765,
-0.029808335,
-0.004184132,
0.0306525808,
-0.0103959367,
-0.0803074688,
0.086255841,
0.0508396812,
0.0468623824,
0.0571250394,
-0.0649726391,
0.0498064309,
-0.0154168913,
0.0350568853,
0.0042151911,
-0.0284772366,
-0.0168311708,
0.0181471743,
0.0217617713,
0.0252504535,
0.0049923756,
0.0484965369,
-0.0098230038,
-0.0010779606,
0.0100973863,
-0.0187521055,
-0.0279259924,
-0.0762494281,
0.0054128543,
-0.0182694327,
-0.0247448124,
-0.0123234699,
0.0217548609,
-0.0170196556,
0.0763534904,
0.0247220453,
0.0079656355,
0.0096032778,
0.0225763246,
-0.0175221711,
0.0346436948,
0.0320230424,
-0.0625332817,
0.0480055213,
-0.0483928956,
-0.0045834184,
-0.0125429314,
0.0012201845,
0.0301361866,
0.0842841789,
0.022792194,
-0.0085078757,
0.0185019951,
0.0361862071,
0.0841207057,
-0.075835444,
-0.0396533906,
0.0123465881,
-0.0427152775,
0.0213485621,
0.0005611256,
0.0222184043,
0.0180583708,
0.0698322058,
0.0517640449,
0.0139161721,
-0.0095462268,
0.0061500352,
-0.0191252399,
0.0602367558,
0.0022239489,
0.0642785057,
-0.0304263402,
0.0524796583,
-0.0079223597,
0.0103279082,
-0.0464909635,
-0.0038469259,
-0.0318075679,
-0.0225602686,
-0.0007852553,
-0.0296245273,
-0.0270269979,
0.0285306107,
0.0001627735,
-0.0291205179,
0.0041006552,
0.0114724375,
-0.0761449412,
0.0419039242,
-0.0102460738,
0.0293466225,
-0.0017639177,
0.003144555,
0.0012127224,
0.0348598473,
0.0749000534,
-0.0173373427,
0.0057197614,
0.0227904171,
-0.0624131076,
0.0229160637,
-0.0717564523,
-0.0111554395,
-0.0271620397,
0.0457962789,
-0.0340076275,
-0.0207206067,
0.012299858,
0.0371428281,
-0.0278664753,
-0.0422251336,
-0.0640258864,
0.0702699125,
-0.0024454582,
-0.0003530915,
-0.044782456,
-0.0325446352,
-0.024238253,
0.0641990229,
0.0315749794,
0.0101224501,
-0.0392476246,
0.0217945445,
2.759e-7,
0.0467352532,
0.0363554545,
0.016836537,
0.0251250491,
0.0149760889,
0.0485006459,
-0.0667580366,
-0.0206705332,
0.0331835933,
-0.0092981439,
-0.0313384272,
0.0002976518,
0.0309920087,
0.0500381105,
-0.005530199,
-0.0062489216,
-0.0119035076,
-0.0065335697,
-0.0718994439,
-0.01264311,
-0.003949617,
0.0205627363,
0.0500054099,
-0.0152493892,
0.0032426054,
-0.0512612499,
-0.0180716868,
0.0092264609,
0.0460169241,
0.0981950462,
-0.0547578074,
0.0288634002,
-0.0099334372,
-0.0347068012,
-0.0271347817,
-0.0404673405,
-0.0254378561,
0.0456545614,
0.013706129,
0.0030875946,
-0.004780856,
0.0126858056,
-0.0070905918,
-0.0635213256,
0.0194245987,
-0.0286614317,
-0.0266625024,
-0.0242002867,
0.0147619871,
0.0046661342,
-0.0131459022,
-0.0040120208,
0.0057515642,
0.0032102251,
-0.0268451255,
-0.0019470546,
-0.0511001907,
-0.0584707446,
-0.0398711972,
-0.016462693,
-0.0239161067,
-0.0100298123,
-0.0422539562,
0.0209262669,
-0.0053230631,
-0.0240592863,
0.0368618779,
2.458307662e-34,
0.0206993893,
-0.04409457,
-0.0014504752,
0.0215596277,
0.0394334942,
0.0051746615,
-0.0416996218,
-0.0183573011,
-0.0213069171,
0.0166769903,
-0.0244716275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06764v1 | OmniLingo: Listening- and speaking-based language learning | 2023-10-10T16:40:00 | 2023-10-10T16:40:00 | Francis M. Tyers, Nicholas Howell | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this demo paper we present OmniLingo, an architecture for distributing
data for listening- and speaking-based language learning applications and a
demonstration client built using the architecture. The architecture is based on
the Interplanetary Filesystem (IPFS) and puts at the forefront user sovereignty
over data. | [
0.0556193516,
0.0362690128,
-0.0200681686,
0.0437412187,
-0.0255970582,
-0.0172425006,
0.0527255237,
0.0006842055,
0.0309270825,
0.0264781695,
-0.0491286702,
-0.0387272052,
0.0079405122,
0.0263519306,
0.0008968331,
-0.0920028538,
0.072620973,
-0.0378771387,
-0.0064277304,
-0.0418623239,
0.017285822,
0.0085514309,
-0.0337571502,
-0.0063745943,
0.0346218385,
-0.0240613706,
-0.038232293,
0.0125004742,
-0.0426572151,
-0.0266906638,
-0.0368746445,
0.0320206024,
0.0243706312,
0.0748892203,
0.0000017,
-0.0163185094,
-0.0340851285,
0.0063546901,
-0.0414797477,
0.0264163408,
0.0481359996,
0.0769882649,
-0.0505770594,
-0.0100390203,
-0.0289062057,
-0.0341874994,
0.0693067238,
-0.0078871921,
0.0410928242,
0.0003291715,
0.0034826742,
-0.0177698359,
-0.0336143039,
0.0321054682,
-0.0074504279,
0.0297568813,
-0.0196864866,
0.0482030362,
0.0549775623,
0.0207230356,
-0.0291149747,
0.0110657336,
0.04005941,
-0.0129913185,
-0.0084823146,
0.0166585762,
-0.0443547666,
-0.0461872742,
-0.0547219962,
0.0161113348,
0.0521318242,
-0.0339650624,
0.000950245,
0.0705766454,
-0.0150391031,
-0.036055997,
-0.0356932618,
0.0286949147,
0.0248374902,
0.0032032328,
-0.0096847024,
-0.0466178209,
-0.0315885618,
0.022283949,
0.0293225273,
0.0586608574,
0.0137452083,
-0.0282620657,
-0.0069456487,
-0.0042027505,
0.0345076732,
-0.017083779,
0.0471143946,
0.0208944958,
0.0175949093,
0.0068313116,
-0.0459451042,
0.0258371942,
0.0083213262,
-0.0500389561,
-0.0019275014,
-0.0045281854,
-0.0037817494,
0.0239044297,
0.0446663909,
-0.0054033855,
0.0271024369,
-0.0157951899,
0.0454710983,
0.004328961,
-0.0401117764,
-0.015144513,
-0.0458488688,
0.0800553858,
-0.0502544865,
-0.0160706788,
-0.0122605404,
0.0342054702,
0.02193035,
0.0062073795,
-0.0361254886,
-0.0188924409,
0.0154827172,
-0.0121465484,
-0.0055869431,
0.0165027268,
-0.0018066206,
0.0017655914,
0.0217539072,
-0.1064595506,
0.0596278384,
-0.0069046607,
-0.0211909134,
0.0430087224,
0.0277354233,
0.0886490569,
0.0107198628,
-0.0264228359,
-0.0006631055,
-0.0492386259,
0.0648113415,
-0.0576270297,
-0.0364120789,
-0.0749512389,
-0.0101349438,
0.0069431462,
0.0084380452,
0.0011502679,
-0.0155238025,
-0.0000589481,
0.0140824588,
0.0500165746,
-0.0160491504,
-0.0147602558,
0.0351883657,
0.0514153726,
0.0257056076,
-0.0094371084,
0.0332968645,
-0.0733985677,
0.0258748885,
-0.019389974,
-0.0171946883,
0.0223001987,
-0.0119338697,
0.0141701903,
0.037992999,
0.0198591892,
0.0228089429,
-0.0098413369,
-0.0671767667,
0.0413530506,
0.0070415218,
0.047136534,
0.0453444012,
0.0656168908,
0.0046678162,
0.0020270064,
-0.0401437953,
0.0525020175,
0.0127434526,
-0.0579995923,
-0.0041118744,
0.0670662075,
0.0418035202,
-0.033370208,
-0.0178920589,
0.025175957,
0.0101798959,
0.0079553854,
-0.0092617273,
-0.0184248369,
-0.0431066304,
0.032470461,
-0.0121045886,
0.0102832168,
0.0382936783,
0.0549077503,
0.0356183313,
-0.079390049,
0.0237190314,
0.0067265132,
0.0406468883,
0.0433350429,
-0.0079687824,
-0.0067006852,
0.0110184485,
0.0067288475,
0.0057572369,
0.0380232185,
0.0651188865,
-0.0276066195,
-0.0003061273,
-0.0280057751,
0.0129557205,
0.0696467757,
-0.0022909071,
0.0566725694,
-0.0519763567,
0.0686817542,
-0.0162479188,
-0.0107952682,
0.0074124713,
-0.0193699449,
0.0149721019,
-0.0102471635,
-0.0305867735,
0.0302704815,
0.0087657385,
0.0389598534,
-0.0150805311,
-0.0224592704,
0.0505050309,
0.0452358574,
0.0554114915,
0.0224456452,
0.0273863785,
0.0586199351,
0.0332934447,
-0.0681864992,
0.0432296693,
-0.000447346,
0.0266595352,
-0.0240299758,
0.0434237272,
-0.0234307032,
0.0264420025,
0.0074853171,
0.0283935647,
-0.0257174782,
-0.0106600765,
0.0108917691,
-0.0435114913,
0.0271228217,
0.0110979406,
0.0028505987,
0.0266038794,
0.080934532,
-0.049917642,
-0.0290849507,
0.0691267848,
-0.0263912082,
0.0157615654,
-0.0103322128,
0.0117862215,
-0.0483177342,
0.0106932279,
-0.1118223518,
0.0037735789,
0.0007019147,
0.0274143051,
0.0274232589,
0.0405810326,
-0.0119647821,
-0.0580939911,
-0.0326073319,
0.0103502972,
0.0303836428,
-0.0079848217,
-0.009833877,
-0.04165617,
-0.0492759869,
-0.0122489333,
-0.0365010425,
0.0273897238,
-0.0013764248,
0.020297695,
-0.0229066331,
-0.0600326583,
-0.0641942024,
-0.0739795938,
-0.0067358827,
0.0107466904,
0.0069752419,
0.0407826826,
-0.0446781367,
0.0085419631,
0.0642855093,
-0.0216809772,
-0.0106646055,
0.0514511019,
-0.0140707484,
-0.0283622351,
-0.0250507314,
0.0078125056,
0.0003396567,
-0.0139999734,
0.0232949853,
-0.0075406665,
0.0128724137,
-0.0244942307,
-0.0027731075,
-0.0142196091,
0.0145740323,
-0.0631737858,
-0.0080918046,
-0.0271722358,
-0.0081659229,
-0.0465139411,
-0.0255915951,
0.0188437402,
-0.0445894934,
0.0684007853,
-0.022672737,
-0.0343810581,
-0.036622256,
-0.0591123924,
-0.0146452561,
0.0612387843,
-0.0528545938,
0.0318081342,
-0.026693223,
-0.0590259023,
0.0189042538,
0.0175897181,
0.0163473431,
-0.0542463101,
-0.0639910772,
-0.0727244616,
-0.0485153981,
0.008596045,
0.001821398,
0.0023556452,
0.069905147,
-0.0344992466,
-0.0271152351,
-0.061599832,
-0.0114159249,
-0.0247165095,
-0.0157157145,
0.0656172782,
0.002186117,
0.0172252301,
0.0254565887,
0.0004486819,
-0.0601924434,
-0.0238918457,
0.0321764089,
-0.043837443,
-0.0219061449,
-0.0111276861,
0.0041666031,
0.0363570265,
-0.0373432934,
0.0927745849,
0.0299629401,
0.0745089501,
0.014943081,
-0.0456748642,
0.0278439894,
0.0590180494,
-0.0210053343,
-0.0313167013,
0.053598702,
0.0115263816,
-0.0609687008,
-0.0094609344,
-0.0342433751,
0.0012421261,
0.0184861794,
0.0286299232,
-0.0977386534,
0.0173315331,
-0.0141211739,
0.0351080038,
0.0014321505,
0.0221368615,
-0.0326148607,
-0.0083280588,
0.0269162375,
0.0499472283,
-0.0541367531,
-0.0335041136,
-0.0488031395,
-0.0481150821,
0.0291433781,
-0.0097042769,
-0.0086282706,
0.0051013492,
0.0160089917,
0.0320087336,
0.0068256999,
0.011191166,
0.0272122677,
-0.0551808961,
0.0693739653,
0.038679529,
0.028064562,
0.016510101,
-0.0641953647,
-0.0378780663,
0.0441767871,
-0.0316764973,
-0.0290131066,
-0.0260795038,
0.0419996008,
-0.0122732511,
-0.0381804407,
0.0518680848,
-0.0032638656,
0.0221548434,
0.0015932146,
0.0403242782,
-0.0510129966,
0.0299463309,
0.0217863936,
-0.0105036311,
0.0589107201,
0.0422539189,
-0.0302715134,
-0.0304357093,
-0.0223105494,
-0.031458158,
-0.008699324,
-0.0043595457,
-0.0277863052,
0.0214986596,
-0.0021234681,
-0.051744666,
-0.0132507337,
-0.0121762054,
0.0045453296,
0.0337313078,
0.0496114157,
0.0084191049,
0.0336176567,
0.0215079989,
-0.0474319942,
-0.0374917276,
-0.0517306067,
0.0435587503,
-0.0982293561,
-0.0319905393,
-0.0092833247,
-0.0287718344,
-0.0054965988,
0.0149067938,
-0.0053369086,
-0.061031118,
0.060589239,
0.0239525177,
0.0361586064,
0.003102906,
0.0378822349,
-0.0357425325,
0.0188783724,
-0.0027210552,
-0.0425352901,
0.0626710281,
-0.0043912651,
-0.0503907576,
0.0252755694,
-0.0140812322,
-0.0405350439,
0.0010303296,
0.0028046248,
-0.0452650264,
0.0302128252,
-0.0429879799,
-0.0021019075,
0.063431561,
-0.0175698977,
-0.0353149995,
-0.0320837758,
-0.0121125728,
0.0545795634,
0.009358936,
0.0212156679,
-0.0243765824,
0.0121641317,
0.0199310761,
0.035246022,
0.0442003123,
0.0129064107,
0.0518541485,
-0.0427683033,
0.0342089385,
0.0842171684,
0.039092809,
-0.0144997267,
0.0422367416,
0.0248960555,
-0.017984096,
0.005564644,
-0.0073253349,
0.0354778804,
-0.0084043872,
0.0548891872,
0.0109742777,
-0.0191991292,
0.011713489,
0.0097440332,
-0.012343551,
-0.0376123674,
0.0518571995,
0.0251781121,
0.0047454732,
0.0464240126,
-0.0161297545,
-0.0983370841,
0.0458001941,
-0.0063420767,
0.0200838745,
-0.0361523144,
-0.0447414443,
0.0015228622,
-0.0058005494,
0.0122934896,
0.0408542044,
-0.0019495577,
-0.0334944315,
0.0017439963,
-0.045826681,
0.0476782359,
-0.0670125037,
0.0256392695,
-0.0327557959,
0.051768858,
-0.0492772646,
0.0146253062,
0.0046952916,
-0.029672008,
-0.0717916712,
0.034006685,
-0.0089226384,
-0.0638584122,
0.0617245361,
0.0017092768,
0.0205833316,
-0.0111963945,
-0.0119159613,
0.0152505841,
-0.0382287502,
-0.0149707086,
0.0084027424,
-5.310260098e-33,
-0.0074307132,
-0.0037967956,
0.0152088245,
0.1118225381,
-0.0262145121,
-0.0243327245,
-0.0469794609,
0.0235721339,
-0.0291872621,
-0.0182165597,
0.0338219851,
0.0004954259,
0.0186251942,
0.0219280496,
0.0034945435,
0.0308658779,
0.0168004148,
0.0353761613,
-0.0061427047,
0.0051539633,
0.0690877736,
0.0379658118,
0.0464632958,
-0.0671626925,
0.0384547003,
-0.0287750363,
0.0195908677,
-0.0040016822,
-0.0396304466,
0.0061284206,
0.0088683357,
0.0012506401,
-0.0492918007,
-0.0027725413,
-0.0018828781,
0.0360155776,
-0.0461223386,
0.0041414672,
0.0207191035,
0.0679904222,
0.0018695275,
-0.0003560862,
-0.0270397291,
-0.0245619565,
-0.0167779308,
0.0327447802,
-0.0141026163,
0.0469037779,
-0.0434637405,
0.0714263096,
-0.0481739007,
-0.0125967348,
-0.004531689,
0.0270461831,
0.0664523393,
-0.0438739769,
-0.0619441904,
-0.0597962961,
-0.0161463786,
0.0853860378,
-0.0187429413,
-0.0026947993,
0.0280254483,
-0.0062209172,
0.0084792627,
0.0420965962,
0.0501828678,
-0.0507886596,
0.0367640927,
0.0145040769,
0.0061205677,
0.0150367329,
0.0171529818,
-0.0299931131,
-0.0384605676,
-0.0255584735,
0.009111545,
-0.0543972775,
0.0651876777,
-0.1081179827,
-0.0339860246,
0.0195146855,
-0.0484305844,
0.0072776983,
-0.0242311433,
-0.0074037402,
0.0014296371,
-0.0352650285,
0.0093319099,
-0.0069069653,
0.0035872478,
-0.0283664856,
0.0059576882,
-0.0377829969,
-0.0069677667,
-0.0166196506,
0.0350022353,
-0.005014136,
-0.0090480829,
0.0070238751,
-0.0459207334,
-0.0034025025,
-0.0246009324,
-0.0131536163,
-0.0015463601,
0.020064868,
-0.0182560384,
0.036636807,
-0.0543909483,
0.0350543186,
-0.0067235641,
0.0183547586,
0.0261038784,
-0.0045889844,
0.0197925065,
-0.0076116007,
0.0009456293,
0.0273605138,
-0.0129060857,
-0.0334445052,
-0.0140506197,
-0.0491550118,
-0.0580379069,
-0.0207949951,
-0.0337414369,
-0.0079592662,
-0.0779078379,
0.0375832617,
0.0197518375,
-0.0461725257,
0.0189507194,
0.035959661,
2.594e-7,
-0.0377783068,
0.0400159433,
0.0396626964,
-0.0419552475,
0.0163175836,
-0.0113217654,
-0.0021508771,
0.0588319972,
0.0197301805,
0.0656425655,
-0.0551666915,
-0.0232490115,
0.0484169461,
0.0167451799,
-0.1173991337,
0.0116448486,
-0.0380949043,
-0.0400086716,
-0.0306587871,
0.0143005121,
0.0297373384,
0.0491230674,
0.0062009427,
-0.0245709363,
0.0274413954,
-0.0115793506,
0.0050843703,
0.0199802816,
0.0503951684,
-0.0415815599,
-0.0045569479,
0.0180083215,
-0.0029743884,
0.0330732279,
-0.0626954064,
-0.0232951362,
-0.0571260266,
0.0234149341,
-0.0001199458,
0.008813329,
0.0186764691,
-0.0119741755,
-0.0663675815,
0.0003462169,
0.0164994914,
0.0204076339,
-0.0286580287,
0.088680312,
0.0214265604,
-0.057376232,
-0.0310023334,
-0.033528842,
0.0203342866,
-0.0063560586,
-0.0324676111,
-0.0494073518,
0.0158165675,
0.0045254044,
-0.0028938456,
0.0107035022,
0.0074146455,
-0.0343699716,
-0.0546679124,
-0.0468196943,
-0.0148249362,
0.0272134729,
0.0041944208,
1.394362904e-34,
-0.0497813486,
-0.0163521357,
0.0086401962,
0.0047803824,
-0.0389361829,
0.0110940328,
0.106738776,
0.0509953499,
0.028009532,
-0.0018783002,
-0.0135069666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06762v1 | TRACE: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Continual Learning in Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T16:38:49 | 2023-10-10T16:38:49 | Xiao Wang, Yuansen Zhang, Tianze Chen, Songyang Gao, Senjie Jin, Xianjun Yang, Zhiheng Xi, Rui Zheng, Yicheng Zou, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligned large language models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional capabilities in
task-solving, following instructions, and ensuring safety. However, the
continual learning aspect of these aligned LLMs has been largely overlooked.
Existing continual learning benchmarks lack sufficient challenge for leading
aligned LLMs, owing to both their simplicity and the models' potential exposure
during instruction tuning. In this paper, we introduce TRACE, a novel benchmark
designed to evaluate continual learning in LLMs. TRACE consists of 8 distinct
datasets spanning challenging tasks including domain-specific tasks,
multilingual capabilities, code generation, and mathematical reasoning. All
datasets are standardized into a unified format, allowing for effortless
automatic evaluation of LLMs. Our experiments show that after training on
TRACE, aligned LLMs exhibit significant declines in both general ability and
instruction-following capabilities. For example, the accuracy of llama2-chat
13B on gsm8k dataset declined precipitously from 28.8\% to 2\% after training
on our datasets. This highlights the challenge of finding a suitable tradeoff
between achieving performance on specific tasks while preserving the original
prowess of LLMs. Empirical findings suggest that tasks inherently equipped with
reasoning paths contribute significantly to preserving certain capabilities of
LLMs against potential declines. Motivated by this, we introduce the
Reasoning-augmented Continual Learning (RCL) approach. RCL integrates
task-specific cues with meta-rationales, effectively reducing catastrophic
forgetting in LLMs while expediting convergence on novel tasks. | [
-0.0133285793,
0.0473074056,
-0.0152042452,
0.0288000833,
-0.0125807989,
0.0426728651,
-0.0251332968,
-0.0579680167,
-0.0111707067,
-0.0005798442,
-0.0346331298,
-0.0301711038,
-0.0164870489,
0.010400705,
0.0277619138,
-0.0039400021,
0.0729206353,
-0.0754712895,
-0.0263914149,
-0.0091367038,
-0.0017339597,
-0.0163422972,
-0.0459175818,
0.0369718932,
-0.0018140344,
-0.0595131405,
-0.0140532115,
-0.0309730247,
0.0007640325,
-0.0453064889,
0.0141180065,
0.0156085426,
0.0358746685,
0.0110132312,
0.0000022984,
-0.0629853532,
-0.0009429658,
-0.0238954835,
-0.0594587401,
-0.0046027945,
-0.0026230686,
0.0285994578,
-0.0484677367,
0.0451865196,
-0.0482525118,
0.0035724207,
0.0513690673,
-0.0252737757,
0.0781409293,
0.0505684838,
0.0143515337,
-0.0144416541,
0.0671700314,
-0.0215150211,
0.0325284973,
-0.0398489125,
0.010385843,
0.0265304111,
-0.0244844407,
-0.0094235614,
0.0153844329,
0.0291239657,
0.0627687201,
-0.0065258872,
-0.0137550496,
0.0420287922,
0.0110296998,
-0.0216615833,
0.0005163025,
0.0269458648,
-0.017450504,
-0.0280271061,
-0.0003296087,
0.0232480895,
-0.0180900991,
-0.0633090138,
-0.0614776276,
0.0550525784,
0.0008822289,
0.006386138,
0.0383078344,
-0.044220455,
0.0351415537,
0.0194766652,
-0.0527355298,
0.0637681037,
0.0049487427,
-0.0258784629,
-0.0136058787,
-0.0126558626,
-0.0412000641,
-0.0255522709,
-0.0001598892,
0.0633603707,
-0.0397649072,
0.044910077,
-0.0356815904,
-0.0003006795,
0.0134051852,
-0.0527910553,
0.0566275865,
0.0624524727,
-0.0033565937,
0.0405198149,
-0.0639471635,
0.0720441565,
0.0130137512,
0.03228838,
-0.0115866959,
0.0331988148,
-0.0777804255,
-0.0155834109,
-0.0106477095,
0.061530862,
0.0109514417,
0.0084583247,
-0.0333503485,
0.0733897313,
-0.0058102324,
0.0400067084,
-0.0065873419,
-0.0073430985,
-0.0295118429,
-0.0019719824,
-0.0234766714,
0.0139966365,
-0.021415621,
0.0109805632,
0.0303205326,
-0.0358806998,
-0.0145932166,
0.0179553013,
-0.0585218817,
-0.0286737606,
0.0319509916,
0.0933401063,
-0.0354759954,
-0.0259005781,
-0.0639847741,
-0.0042445972,
0.0202251375,
-0.0852878913,
0.0239791349,
-0.0521005802,
0.0186078977,
0.0090444367,
-0.0182339903,
-0.0535268672,
0.0150816804,
0.0006188615,
0.0062711486,
0.0569417067,
0.034017317,
0.007351201,
0.0117537901,
0.0226607881,
-0.016801849,
0.0693713278,
0.0277858544,
-0.0311212912,
0.0007523417,
0.0007484977,
-0.0226404555,
0.0335527547,
0.028590491,
0.007109649,
-0.0312365778,
0.021426389,
0.0321801454,
0.0234277267,
0.0246211458,
0.0234338138,
-0.0154683637,
0.0227692891,
0.0512426943,
0.0262309965,
0.0098928334,
0.043438334,
0.0496210381,
-0.0289139003,
0.0340813324,
-0.0037813012,
-0.089088507,
0.0421863385,
-0.0147353029,
0.0293882061,
-0.00533864,
0.0231316723,
-0.0228490178,
-0.0657036602,
0.0073268586,
0.0113606229,
-0.0084338756,
0.0259156972,
0.0394711755,
-0.0167567413,
-0.0564891919,
0.0624704659,
0.0049537113,
-0.0310477316,
-0.0234335326,
-0.0702589899,
0.0257265214,
0.0548826344,
0.0352819264,
-0.0276928376,
-0.1060937047,
-0.0018757631,
0.0116918767,
-0.002199074,
-0.0060623763,
-0.0045914012,
0.0418577343,
-0.0447294004,
0.0021529915,
-0.0153205087,
0.0173941869,
0.0056271474,
0.039110098,
0.0160992928,
0.0080308486,
-0.0373261236,
-0.0387551337,
0.0463490933,
-0.0739498138,
-0.0174289774,
-0.0186833981,
-0.003166347,
-0.0102916528,
-0.0115571935,
-0.0241814274,
0.0257864241,
0.047144454,
-0.0269956253,
0.0244834162,
0.0299086571,
-0.0842684135,
-0.0206861366,
0.0652040765,
0.0241603311,
-0.0301541649,
0.0097607076,
-0.0206711031,
-0.0283780824,
0.0132382549,
-0.0169218406,
0.0357027277,
-0.0191486385,
0.0553550944,
-0.0241195168,
-0.0068973606,
-0.010601609,
0.0678992718,
-0.0199776199,
-0.0059809093,
0.0238363482,
0.0326269008,
-0.0142125888,
-0.0487034991,
0.0093915667,
0.0081916247,
-0.0150177572,
0.0254806299,
-0.0287772901,
0.0151564116,
-0.0499471091,
-0.0116250357,
-0.0731417909,
0.0473696999,
-0.0170672387,
0.0342908129,
0.0320206098,
-0.0231955573,
-0.0071617095,
0.0001273925,
-0.0060218037,
-0.0200845432,
-0.0094791688,
0.0178737938,
0.0157532673,
-0.0102461809,
-0.0406774692,
-0.0489184409,
-0.0060108607,
-0.0286027044,
0.0183475148,
-0.0361146666,
0.0205038451,
-0.0575636625,
0.0541855879,
-0.0324723236,
0.0220932122,
-0.0226423759,
-0.0423947126,
0.0254909527,
-0.0086103976,
0.0416326709,
0.101118952,
0.0032440485,
0.0129562588,
0.0655347109,
-0.003029868,
-0.043543227,
0.0196696781,
-0.005770029,
-0.0354089402,
-0.0137672974,
-0.0008957,
-0.0070312787,
0.0816448703,
-0.0399383679,
0.0074863038,
-0.0249760486,
0.0069915443,
-0.0321305953,
0.0007525705,
-0.0461858958,
0.0036174669,
-0.0295251012,
0.0198779944,
-0.0423462652,
-0.078515321,
0.0713909715,
0.0079813926,
-0.0018138598,
-0.0493945256,
-0.0052825636,
-0.0226963256,
0.065489158,
-0.0365211479,
0.0003421878,
0.0200849902,
-0.0217211805,
-0.0563890822,
-0.01267232,
0.046654094,
-0.0228630658,
0.0789810419,
-0.0619475357,
0.0064427732,
0.0100179082,
-0.0539710559,
-0.0742861852,
0.0160014015,
0.0036800688,
0.0194974691,
0.0094768303,
-0.015326838,
-0.0292837042,
-0.0218759608,
0.0485423245,
0.0241150409,
-0.0118396282,
-0.0214218348,
-0.0071385265,
-0.01653165,
0.0134550128,
-0.0108274082,
0.0326210111,
-0.059293244,
0.0589304045,
0.0276454277,
0.0497097299,
-0.0089880051,
-0.0325206816,
0.0299208928,
0.0028095744,
0.0059982655,
-0.0080560325,
0.0410782136,
0.0488973185,
-0.0729838461,
-0.0353334285,
0.1060789675,
0.0368123204,
-0.0261971354,
0.0111348182,
-0.0372098535,
0.0547536314,
0.0430750623,
0.0461284816,
-0.0513478518,
-0.0190712586,
0.0339552611,
0.0337263457,
0.005630454,
-0.0275372211,
-0.0048128143,
-0.0960925072,
-0.0106032528,
0.0338831991,
-0.0301997568,
0.0194776189,
-0.0371793956,
-0.031272646,
-0.0054715937,
0.0197025891,
0.033165317,
-0.0209694561,
-0.012333476,
0.0390873253,
-0.0291720983,
-0.0442600511,
0.0604339801,
-0.0194848124,
0.058750052,
0.0659485087,
0.0033888957,
0.0317470059,
-0.0471709669,
0.0863679945,
0.0188409276,
0.0183077138,
0.0024220762,
0.0146736382,
0.018353302,
-0.0123676201,
-0.0083419289,
0.0336127058,
-0.0202187505,
-0.0193271711,
0.036902681,
0.0904109478,
-0.0107085602,
0.0164521597,
0.0050792065,
-0.0416673534,
-0.0405140743,
0.0437657088,
0.0138176382,
-0.0356709473,
-0.0526931658,
-0.0398865156,
-0.0209153369,
-0.0608424395,
-0.0147768334,
0.0264424849,
-0.0244415421,
-0.0268424731,
-0.0443429276,
-0.018069705,
0.0009592359,
0.0548839308,
0.0185703672,
-0.0017305656,
0.0011129049,
0.0048531317,
-0.0676794201,
0.0169528015,
-0.0194567293,
0.0312356576,
-0.0934855193,
0.0229697861,
0.023205841,
-0.0105621479,
-0.0122568486,
-0.0034731026,
-0.1036336422,
-0.074271664,
-0.009204587,
0.06826175,
0.023865696,
0.0689431503,
-0.0098809684,
-0.0453031249,
-0.0103076426,
-0.0119548542,
-0.0363228023,
0.0207875092,
0.0517219864,
-0.0130776847,
0.0308561455,
0.0194966253,
-0.0307121575,
0.0063699791,
0.0138497707,
0.0400112122,
0.0084691178,
0.0550601184,
0.0326221213,
-0.0166107304,
0.0055482751,
-0.002052502,
-0.0225285478,
-0.0243195482,
0.0307745282,
0.0142055824,
-0.0077671763,
-0.0192001369,
0.0179818776,
0.0278760828,
0.0064232433,
0.0265795495,
-0.0176328532,
0.0371013209,
0.0374903865,
0.002039073,
0.0397724658,
-0.025682753,
0.0188745018,
0.0468208492,
0.007794545,
-0.0396940336,
0.021005068,
-0.0140027031,
0.0512658283,
-0.0213920902,
0.0618917607,
0.0146152796,
0.018137997,
-0.0160826109,
0.0173820481,
-0.043176502,
-0.1029399633,
0.0016756442,
0.0167360269,
0.0991442427,
0.0272661746,
0.0374724567,
-0.0340079069,
0.0245073214,
-0.032567665,
0.0086334702,
-0.0133359414,
-0.0351424478,
0.0144807398,
0.0389323384,
0.0176494662,
-0.005388103,
0.0704459995,
-0.0237085875,
0.0543528572,
-0.0161549039,
0.0146355042,
-0.0294448733,
-0.0078003984,
-0.0073195668,
-0.0037312431,
-0.0147737926,
-0.0118151596,
-0.0207814798,
-0.0980623886,
-0.0004457121,
0.0328399017,
0.0068416866,
-0.0242654011,
0.0084784199,
0.0593518168,
-0.0203414187,
-0.0117502427,
-0.0074496297,
0.0081402929,
0.0188667737,
-0.0065094782,
-0.0290184319,
-6.728526725e-33,
-0.0064668576,
0.0108801592,
0.0636064783,
-0.0322252549,
-0.050109949,
-0.0090334956,
-0.0712850839,
0.028912032,
-0.0391361713,
-0.0153014921,
-0.0026049369,
0.0294646751,
0.000283015,
0.0065133055,
0.0408340469,
-0.0176599622,
0.0071058483,
0.0115444139,
-0.0386296324,
0.030038489,
0.0288244225,
0.0272354297,
0.0211279672,
-0.0299294684,
-0.0026384813,
0.0158445705,
-0.0025762247,
0.0543676876,
-0.0243172087,
0.0862930641,
-0.003068578,
-0.0066256369,
0.0143191284,
-0.0489777848,
-0.0385265239,
-0.0454644933,
-0.0664849654,
-0.0198643859,
0.0275594573,
0.0029772958,
-0.0235972255,
-0.0535087697,
0.0229105782,
0.0097342227,
-0.0387364179,
-0.0255854782,
-0.0006470468,
-0.0346775576,
-0.0428466834,
0.0206370465,
-0.0538087785,
0.0093212724,
-0.0331376977,
-0.0403331518,
0.004240701,
-0.0088723488,
-0.0220615733,
-0.0422336906,
-0.0488156825,
0.001291342,
-0.0194461886,
0.0512569733,
0.0827691928,
0.0297457669,
0.0331779681,
0.0455679856,
0.035288848,
0.0170674361,
-0.0023490384,
-0.0098567586,
0.0460730232,
0.0376477093,
0.0064479043,
-0.0369807072,
0.0253708679,
-0.0159147494,
-0.0741413236,
-0.0147681395,
0.0550955348,
0.064004764,
0.0418970175,
0.0170026943,
-0.0210790653,
-0.0296605453,
-0.0491430648,
0.0563837215,
-0.0445986055,
-0.0197795462,
0.0654976815,
0.0144544281,
-0.0169649906,
-0.0412119366,
0.0247127693,
-0.0172165167,
-0.007506405,
0.0466339923,
-0.045887053,
0.0404860415,
-0.009956385,
0.0440005586,
-0.0578109361,
-0.035878472,
-0.0133091621,
-0.0146853821,
0.0371498838,
0.0024038213,
0.0446466655,
0.037284486,
-0.03794761,
-0.0197988451,
-0.0800518394,
0.0109888697,
0.0449348874,
0.021898929,
0.034880586,
0.0199153163,
-0.0102181314,
0.0546122044,
-0.0068948199,
-0.0352041312,
-0.0596243814,
0.0353632383,
-0.0025896498,
0.053538572,
-0.0213022474,
-0.0184068456,
-0.0489686392,
0.0331585817,
-0.0055275355,
-0.095271036,
-0.026906468,
0.0087361354,
2.939e-7,
-0.0060796533,
0.0348865688,
0.0064772796,
0.0399666801,
0.0219924469,
0.0361885391,
-0.0611553937,
-0.0324465074,
0.02509165,
0.0308755506,
-0.021873273,
0.0560350716,
0.0432834402,
0.0154241687,
-0.0341576524,
0.0035011752,
-0.0244705696,
-0.0011503564,
-0.059930943,
0.0093487501,
0.0250504166,
0.0608972013,
0.0037333746,
-0.0080085453,
0.0304875318,
-0.0482542105,
0.0639601201,
0.0077780546,
0.0235464033,
-0.0125372251,
-0.0449839607,
0.0497989543,
-0.0293238331,
0.0010306496,
-0.0147526246,
-0.0113468627,
-0.0595481098,
0.0700769126,
0.0066177123,
-0.0129806083,
0.0202030092,
-0.0017717567,
-0.0068557616,
-0.0471290685,
0.0728971213,
-0.0537329428,
-0.0167631358,
-0.0023867474,
0.0223469045,
0.0076157791,
-0.0179882757,
-0.0006198914,
-0.0239059497,
-0.0062533519,
0.0017089505,
-0.0072014048,
-0.0134586254,
-0.071263507,
-0.0338375717,
0.0490690432,
-0.0300846212,
-0.0538183339,
-0.0755187646,
0.0242044181,
0.0290882997,
-0.0547952205,
0.0101472503,
2.991644143e-34,
0.0098482482,
-0.0392262898,
0.0346691385,
0.0641278997,
0.0323296003,
-0.0293239783,
0.0260263495,
0.0152358124,
0.0137637062,
-0.0443945006,
-0.0225076713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06714v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06714v2 | Exploring Memorization in Fine-tuned Language Models | 2023-10-10T15:41:26 | 2024-02-22T21:19:59 | Shenglai Zeng, Yaxin Li, Jie Ren, Yiding Liu, Han Xu, Pengfei He, Yue Xing, Shuaiqiang Wang, Jiliang Tang, Dawei Yin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown great capabilities in various tasks
but also exhibited memorization of training data, raising tremendous privacy
and copyright concerns. While prior works have studied memorization during
pre-training, the exploration of memorization during fine-tuning is rather
limited. Compared to pre-training, fine-tuning typically involves more
sensitive data and diverse objectives, thus may bring distinct privacy risks
and unique memorization behaviors. In this work, we conduct the first
comprehensive analysis to explore language models' (LMs) memorization during
fine-tuning across tasks. Our studies with open-sourced and our own fine-tuned
LMs across various tasks indicate that memorization presents a strong disparity
among different fine-tuning tasks. We provide an intuitive explanation of this
task disparity via sparse coding theory and unveil a strong correlation between
memorization and attention score distribution. | [
0.0304052476,
0.0763155594,
-0.0250611864,
0.0441046767,
-0.0279633626,
0.0170440748,
0.0322719701,
-0.0122321714,
-0.0234224685,
-0.0205937643,
-0.0615606233,
-0.0359022021,
0.0076341298,
-0.0011095394,
0.0330622755,
-0.0023290184,
0.0223699193,
-0.0554056764,
-0.0051214234,
-0.0264062732,
-0.0289259013,
-0.0000150262,
0.0190081336,
0.0104271565,
0.034584552,
-0.0291418675,
0.0084757842,
-0.0124368081,
-0.0018910925,
-0.0162898991,
0.0142020164,
0.0940442607,
0.026651619,
0.0482662246,
0.0000018804,
-0.0338477604,
-0.027639199,
0.0000921107,
-0.0468808003,
0.075800553,
0.015576194,
0.0058710384,
0.026260497,
-0.0075573996,
-0.0198852681,
-0.0116915591,
0.0791779384,
0.0134610441,
0.029633671,
0.0547874831,
0.0054776412,
-0.0036560646,
0.004326921,
-0.0411847793,
0.0099296365,
-0.0614310987,
0.016905196,
-0.0063704583,
-0.0463886783,
-0.0039937566,
-0.0315016508,
0.0360151082,
0.0150675783,
0.052442085,
0.0309301224,
0.0534405001,
-0.0304205418,
-0.0072550108,
-0.0060158209,
0.0473015085,
0.0031631035,
-0.031191662,
0.0066947341,
0.0207847394,
0.0233011413,
-0.0083291819,
-0.0482096523,
0.0524606183,
-0.0059857401,
0.0123059219,
0.0014366659,
-0.0314583816,
0.0405397266,
0.0108666373,
0.0037925863,
0.026921697,
0.0100810155,
-0.0138294138,
-0.0292838644,
-0.017916508,
0.0056240368,
-0.0737665221,
0.0290135164,
0.0093120467,
0.0345310532,
0.0165312979,
-0.0731809363,
-0.0355645157,
0.0384520479,
-0.0019415828,
0.0892284736,
0.0025669774,
0.0035813346,
0.0403709523,
-0.0384664685,
0.066196993,
-0.0063525527,
0.044215329,
-0.0075874524,
0.034603253,
-0.0479284935,
-0.0103807338,
-0.0080363518,
0.0497779846,
0.0138305826,
-0.0050351736,
-0.0127315717,
0.0356192216,
0.0132871205,
0.002771192,
-0.0229581222,
0.0106683113,
-0.0246266294,
0.0036772888,
-0.0008088783,
-0.0191297233,
-0.022477882,
0.0180739984,
0.035845235,
-0.0506161265,
-0.0384718701,
-0.0273619983,
-0.0089524779,
-0.0399835706,
0.0005136525,
0.0387998037,
-0.0017798654,
-0.0295888521,
-0.022504095,
-0.0344686583,
0.01302756,
-0.0715220571,
0.0181379654,
-0.0594419315,
-0.0056162858,
0.0269187316,
0.0143229747,
-0.0592687652,
-0.0143766226,
0.0149297537,
-0.0720062628,
0.0477886535,
0.0204219613,
0.0048154797,
-0.0163527261,
0.0171387084,
0.0291313753,
0.0481671318,
0.0085783517,
0.0207724236,
0.0319807902,
-0.0401897207,
0.0235300232,
0.0052220663,
0.0249609258,
0.0187249053,
-0.0215808731,
-0.0024136086,
0.0453041196,
-0.0280813109,
0.0379781723,
0.0528088249,
-0.0284991246,
-0.0443504304,
0.0813059881,
0.0902693495,
0.0228384957,
0.0242187027,
-0.0427441821,
-0.0101879174,
0.0257714521,
0.049395103,
-0.0860792622,
0.043302685,
-0.0269082617,
-0.0139256502,
0.0125857452,
0.0096074119,
-0.0373054557,
0.0064420518,
-0.0038938201,
-0.0191615373,
0.0104788924,
0.0164888985,
0.0258227792,
-0.0034637915,
-0.0136266034,
0.069286257,
0.0200633518,
-0.0395218953,
0.0083641922,
-0.0497397184,
0.0151161328,
0.0642488152,
0.0127934273,
-0.0098774247,
0.0056162584,
-0.0223376863,
0.0174502842,
-0.0207610689,
0.0462804213,
0.0189846531,
0.0482492298,
-0.0443665758,
-0.0237406772,
-0.0699061975,
0.030782789,
0.0344591774,
0.0012305924,
0.0013403675,
0.0276939329,
-0.025909787,
-0.0332854167,
0.027553523,
-0.021558715,
-0.0511315651,
-0.0010881552,
-0.0165815558,
0.0217452571,
0.0013997225,
-0.0191913173,
0.0283680595,
0.0275621116,
0.0156744644,
0.0495208763,
-0.0424146913,
-0.0366011895,
0.0341184624,
0.0094955647,
-0.0103157582,
0.0262056571,
0.0581133217,
-0.0022538796,
-0.0429830663,
0.017661415,
0.0038733697,
0.0753243268,
-0.0168334413,
0.0248422027,
-0.0430378169,
0.0311790202,
-0.0450810716,
0.0325438455,
-0.0308062527,
0.0146813067,
-0.0184507594,
-0.0131394295,
0.0073412736,
-0.0483859628,
-0.0266979653,
0.0150931934,
-0.0183688942,
0.0336280167,
0.0032174434,
-0.0303107407,
-0.0445747674,
-0.0135766286,
-0.0483431071,
0.0085535608,
-0.0306120496,
0.0215741266,
0.01718623,
-0.016405534,
-0.0185216758,
-0.0175268203,
-0.0455922708,
-0.0072064092,
-0.0433693603,
0.0532520749,
-0.0185657609,
-0.0081953816,
-0.0176039767,
-0.0317173861,
-0.0489983633,
0.0222195555,
0.0260428507,
-0.0194765776,
0.0168217681,
-0.0526856109,
0.0652726889,
-0.0113972174,
0.0187817439,
-0.0078545064,
-0.0393045023,
0.0282566287,
-0.0016383844,
0.0251245778,
0.112669535,
0.005535577,
0.0115630133,
0.0835391879,
-0.0019067382,
-0.0118425572,
-0.0193838663,
-0.0161809847,
-0.0868838206,
-0.051066231,
-0.0036777952,
0.0071719652,
0.0527861081,
0.0114673292,
-0.0200052671,
-0.0329915583,
-0.0010808669,
-0.0179953482,
-0.0382615924,
-0.0320656709,
0.0151610896,
-0.0339634605,
0.0613921024,
-0.0128413513,
-0.0889339224,
0.0629327968,
-0.0184368975,
0.0140309427,
0.0036029166,
-0.0092129838,
0.0016147732,
0.0621621497,
0.0154147455,
0.0362803191,
0.0326899141,
-0.050915651,
-0.0456763841,
-0.0216331352,
0.0346743949,
-0.0520960763,
0.0368228741,
-0.0012905248,
-0.0359056368,
-0.0126740877,
-0.0257942248,
-0.0306637846,
-0.0336577147,
-0.02641006,
0.022639107,
0.0118163042,
-0.0166289601,
-0.0311205015,
-0.0176897105,
0.0474539921,
0.0078615984,
-0.0078055114,
0.01014244,
-0.0010968582,
-0.007119535,
0.0433019176,
-0.0069261608,
0.0195222721,
-0.0448826477,
-0.0292302165,
0.0630942956,
0.0699930191,
0.0365070142,
0.0196257215,
0.012740585,
0.0402501523,
-0.0052477997,
-0.0050163469,
0.0498119034,
0.0593965277,
-0.0558588542,
0.0133172031,
0.0949191079,
0.0180616602,
-0.0793435872,
-0.0073800813,
0.0101844771,
0.030267816,
0.0401970856,
-0.0215001442,
-0.0624320172,
0.0020335109,
0.0214638822,
0.0560654625,
-0.0060595945,
-0.0342496447,
-0.0033873622,
-0.0737206936,
-0.0048795724,
0.0310390927,
-0.0401567966,
-0.0260966886,
-0.0532154925,
0.0061386731,
-0.0103732292,
0.0121985404,
0.0115523757,
-0.0131227309,
-0.013318643,
0.0274800677,
0.0204221588,
-0.0641083568,
0.0483874418,
-0.028834939,
0.0711380616,
0.0557280853,
-0.0097543867,
-0.0169301033,
-0.0515635014,
0.015203991,
-0.0052695298,
0.0187832322,
0.0073270262,
0.0447831862,
-0.0052908962,
-0.0168998577,
-0.0014122719,
0.0583738051,
-0.0247530099,
-0.02827009,
-0.005365801,
0.0542156771,
0.0009850352,
-0.0288184937,
0.0340036526,
-0.0520572774,
-0.0050236564,
0.0753141269,
0.049182687,
-0.0240831804,
-0.0014763993,
-0.0377061926,
0.0377289616,
-0.0389768779,
-0.0091955224,
0.041977413,
0.0036041951,
-0.0535088927,
-0.0368982367,
-0.0080319289,
0.0202328041,
0.0075802393,
0.0229875054,
0.0265053287,
0.0344231017,
-0.0480703712,
-0.0665566847,
0.0546754971,
-0.0687661394,
-0.0114161037,
-0.0764665231,
-0.0766702294,
0.0081877131,
0.0048741181,
-0.0048045847,
0.0061539742,
-0.110137932,
-0.0696889013,
0.0260996316,
0.0555875413,
0.0206708331,
0.0314421467,
0.0083007514,
-0.0689493641,
0.0298576728,
0.0198268332,
-0.0767013431,
0.0525253378,
0.0344294161,
-0.0651585385,
-0.0135663738,
0.0334742293,
-0.023735065,
-0.0218413193,
0.0883043036,
-0.0161487423,
0.0102855191,
-0.0251008086,
0.0170815904,
0.0132874092,
0.0445459597,
-0.0167657528,
0.0125893196,
-0.0229654182,
0.0163416844,
0.0237937327,
0.0031892494,
-0.0133303618,
-0.0582385771,
0.0537470281,
-0.0205479134,
0.0241314285,
-0.0143868998,
0.0101595018,
0.039973896,
-0.078519702,
0.0190972574,
0.0094326567,
-0.0042458833,
0.0594707914,
0.0263460539,
-0.0536770597,
0.0471536517,
-0.0414323956,
0.0374359675,
-0.0005569019,
0.0315726101,
-0.0173214972,
0.0200986508,
-0.0489647575,
0.0351643637,
-0.064503327,
-0.0782899261,
0.0126641849,
-0.0150528876,
0.0490732603,
-0.0545701757,
0.0112884752,
-0.0300147478,
0.0013422124,
-0.047431048,
-0.0068405545,
-0.0247725546,
-0.0066490038,
-0.0152467731,
0.0099281715,
-0.0096048089,
0.0429512598,
0.1092139557,
0.0176834706,
0.0487865694,
-0.0182279963,
-0.0047674039,
-0.0197132155,
-0.0140070217,
0.0062789144,
0.0413227938,
-0.0117944749,
-0.0056836512,
-0.0270004086,
-0.0923243687,
-0.0014259338,
-0.0425233841,
0.0169543736,
-0.0254087523,
0.0262196399,
0.050182797,
-0.0375649072,
0.0014935979,
-0.0526077561,
0.0024779092,
0.0194146056,
-0.011675993,
-0.0224838536,
-6.567420082e-33,
0.0001088554,
0.004661235,
-0.0105658695,
0.0251818169,
-0.0004864295,
0.0285773519,
-0.0365835689,
0.0152334459,
-0.032793019,
-0.0411378965,
-0.0410094485,
-0.0016232888,
0.0073019094,
0.036651291,
0.0041655586,
-0.0335142314,
0.0367924199,
-0.0221180376,
-0.0316586755,
0.0423939675,
0.0524152666,
0.0264554489,
0.0689837784,
-0.0549129993,
0.0274728034,
0.0113397595,
-0.0041884026,
-0.0225201417,
-0.0464403853,
0.0719075501,
-0.0384723805,
0.0161702428,
0.0177102797,
-0.037415795,
-0.0452378318,
-0.004456426,
-0.053212516,
-0.0057118582,
0.0265848693,
-0.0219139177,
0.0314005204,
-0.0726654157,
0.0662697405,
-0.0261948816,
-0.0048292833,
-0.0386111103,
0.0028655562,
-0.0228111725,
-0.0710386783,
-0.0164888781,
-0.0177683849,
-0.017621005,
-0.0286611002,
-0.0314436927,
0.0570596792,
-0.0323278867,
-0.015202878,
0.0004843319,
-0.0457560942,
0.0375366248,
0.0501137115,
0.0425151624,
0.0724301487,
0.050110314,
0.0534906834,
0.0631736442,
0.0221213344,
0.0475671068,
0.0020615153,
0.0011133909,
0.0474219471,
0.0337562896,
0.0078586657,
-0.0215664655,
0.0292048361,
-0.0379261449,
-0.0247329995,
-0.0405701809,
-0.0534953102,
0.0395046063,
0.0868795216,
0.0247367863,
-0.0060607856,
-0.0282156244,
-0.0745344758,
0.0132236267,
-0.0536992215,
0.0215269066,
0.0202926081,
0.0099715237,
-0.042613849,
-0.0317377001,
0.0611410961,
-0.0410388038,
-0.0052464739,
0.0238144007,
0.0128723606,
0.0332258418,
-0.0119279753,
0.002718972,
-0.0865970403,
-0.0085822633,
0.0063890102,
-0.0230762716,
0.0236188062,
0.0265944898,
0.0356137082,
0.0147761609,
-0.0450894125,
-0.0055493936,
-0.0542566366,
0.0087803761,
0.0626314804,
0.0392699689,
0.0387107953,
-0.0032547903,
0.0004215254,
0.0428644158,
-0.0016698821,
-0.0281397924,
-0.0449886173,
0.0160816889,
-0.0147761488,
0.0192222372,
-0.0078448197,
-0.0194417611,
-0.0444725081,
0.0170110278,
0.0831060484,
0.017437337,
0.0021642891,
-0.0073190131,
2.574e-7,
-0.0057988339,
0.0137092136,
-0.0296784192,
-0.0210132916,
0.0098455539,
0.0365703553,
-0.0196675248,
0.0502308197,
0.0123051153,
-0.0407026038,
-0.0297664888,
0.0621291026,
0.0481161512,
0.0201798081,
-0.0514296107,
-0.0125182346,
-0.0312181283,
0.0344463363,
-0.0402657241,
-0.001851246,
-0.0103815645,
0.1048928574,
0.034915138,
-0.0069675175,
0.0254114978,
-0.0682519302,
0.0526397489,
-0.058278095,
0.0076104258,
-0.0018050341,
0.0055374573,
0.0786312744,
-0.0024255705,
0.0252139345,
-0.0051962156,
0.0017650076,
-0.0323871709,
0.0899940059,
0.0096010892,
-0.0228737593,
-0.0232724175,
-0.0297887847,
-0.0274939295,
-0.0483443178,
0.0585425794,
-0.033452522,
-0.0523429625,
-0.0139439534,
0.0501511134,
-0.0386937819,
0.026223043,
-0.0266112629,
0.0327371284,
0.0142662916,
-0.0258551482,
0.0090295849,
-0.0056392341,
-0.0774959847,
-0.0149736675,
0.0084253838,
-0.0361528434,
-0.0551442169,
-0.0374210365,
-0.0487114787,
0.009471735,
-0.0296555366,
0.0426718891,
2.179830755e-34,
0.0067238007,
-0.0322804973,
0.0174018722,
0.038544558,
0.0285068452,
-0.0312797986,
0.0199152865,
0.021137137,
0.0076465714,
-0.0910030231,
-0.0152787752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06707v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06707v3 | Quality-Aware Translation Models: Efficient Generation and Quality Estimation in a Single Model | 2023-10-10T15:33:51 | 2024-03-25T13:27:16 | Christian Tomani, David Vilar, Markus Freitag, Colin Cherry, Subhajit Naskar, Mara Finkelstein, Xavier Garcia, Daniel Cremers | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Maximum-a-posteriori (MAP) decoding is the most widely used decoding strategy
for neural machine translation (NMT) models. The underlying assumption is that
model probability correlates well with human judgment, with better translations
getting assigned a higher score by the model. However, research has shown that
this assumption does not always hold, and generation quality can be improved by
decoding to optimize a utility function backed by a metric or
quality-estimation signal, as is done by Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) or
Quality-Aware decoding. The main disadvantage of these approaches is that they
require an additional model to calculate the utility function during decoding,
significantly increasing the computational cost. In this paper, we propose to
make the NMT models themselves quality-aware by training them to estimate the
quality of their own output. Using this approach for MBR decoding we can
drastically reduce the size of the candidate list, resulting in a speed-up of
two-orders of magnitude. When applying our method to MAP decoding we obtain
quality gains similar or even superior to quality reranking approaches, but
with the efficiency of single pass decoding. | [
-0.0051359944,
0.0646130815,
0.0295954198,
0.0179310776,
0.0167726055,
0.0129518742,
-0.0189815462,
0.0004004493,
-0.0208606403,
0.0003208668,
-0.013687605,
-0.0225352626,
0.0242859796,
-0.0178047568,
0.0283338167,
-0.0177354943,
0.0155767724,
-0.0153293554,
-0.0118326154,
0.0077800713,
-0.0500875153,
0.0035524224,
0.0021731351,
0.0664957091,
-0.0036450378,
-0.0030350762,
0.0165552348,
0.039504163,
0.0549359843,
-0.0283884313,
-0.0138971163,
0.0422845483,
-0.01169213,
-0.0084492918,
0.0000021207,
0.0254359562,
-0.0425317883,
0.026444314,
0.0224832669,
-0.0047955099,
0.0256753229,
-0.0283434205,
-0.0576192848,
0.0444355048,
-0.0016005147,
-0.0082570929,
0.0633631423,
-0.0116672674,
0.0634503588,
0.0812457651,
-0.003886706,
-0.028077323,
0.0191902425,
-0.0547237694,
-0.0198438875,
-0.0618116446,
-0.0250191148,
0.0362223797,
-0.0657988563,
0.0050022975,
-0.0201221798,
0.0424522609,
0.044779662,
0.0093071526,
0.0089120744,
-0.0009674354,
0.0579900481,
-0.023352813,
-0.0188818742,
0.0377410054,
-0.0789712816,
0.0008482267,
-0.0488972329,
-0.026646575,
0.004914674,
-0.0513397716,
0.007486579,
0.034230981,
-0.0023445978,
0.03918764,
0.0090492656,
0.0680595487,
0.0425329134,
-0.0001854876,
-0.041061528,
0.0062927534,
-0.008859464,
-0.016987795,
-0.0364580378,
0.0332050957,
-0.0150281005,
0.0255345963,
0.0352879874,
-0.0112036895,
0.0323643237,
0.0118600782,
-0.0205421131,
-0.0460527986,
-0.0288639888,
-0.0614956655,
0.0081042955,
0.0614470243,
0.0127086239,
0.0180280115,
-0.0004314982,
0.0416170172,
-0.0034957132,
0.0350923613,
-0.0609010682,
-0.0021255603,
0.0068555875,
0.0304111987,
-0.0051943371,
0.0042555691,
-0.0228221025,
-0.0090910476,
-0.0240802392,
-0.0242667831,
0.0054496829,
0.0054421742,
0.0580218025,
0.0058316165,
-0.0841901004,
-0.0328107662,
-0.0168310851,
0.0501761436,
0.0101293027,
-0.0261838622,
0.0258390848,
-0.0465126447,
-0.0172522813,
-0.0026941756,
-0.0152049763,
-0.0041805496,
-0.0068151127,
0.0779734477,
-0.0235021412,
-0.0265400894,
-0.025803905,
0.0152400676,
-0.0071269115,
-0.0119681833,
0.0094841644,
-0.0313353576,
0.0257698726,
-0.0219648946,
0.0178895649,
-0.0378943905,
0.0066952468,
-0.0160229448,
0.001293092,
0.043926768,
0.0028546811,
0.0008870871,
0.0364636034,
0.0115481773,
-0.0260448437,
0.0659090132,
0.0641278625,
0.0534165576,
-0.0182700828,
-0.0020700125,
-0.009129568,
0.0377525985,
-0.009318985,
0.0307707656,
-0.0083259065,
-0.0364980623,
-0.0137239695,
0.0209152009,
0.0591856502,
0.0460302383,
-0.0670935661,
0.0286821909,
0.0961410254,
-0.0284672584,
0.0565049648,
0.0376141109,
0.0343431607,
0.0222890973,
-0.0369713791,
0.0044665937,
-0.0176187661,
0.040044345,
0.060582675,
-0.0069052596,
0.0725235343,
0.0522581004,
0.0009706444,
-0.0750583261,
0.0031806258,
-0.0590827577,
0.0068148924,
-0.0171778332,
0.0342941284,
0.0249636732,
-0.0530453473,
0.0084226103,
-0.0135610821,
-0.0211250894,
0.0329657607,
-0.0386861153,
-0.0078972587,
0.0324480273,
0.0591130815,
0.0276897065,
-0.0099778119,
-0.0187756643,
-0.0791492388,
0.0349925309,
0.0362676159,
0.0209831093,
0.0569035262,
-0.0768804178,
-0.027357161,
0.0353262573,
0.0216842443,
0.0407272615,
-0.0349203683,
0.0080033913,
0.0372192636,
-0.0283414125,
-0.0610478632,
0.0244094767,
0.0455591977,
-0.0470611975,
0.0441336334,
0.0169736743,
0.0470418409,
0.0109306211,
-0.0164369736,
0.0327297524,
0.0026422963,
-0.0397973806,
-0.0093497513,
0.0030479587,
-0.0606754199,
-0.0496444963,
-0.0045286161,
-0.0340575427,
0.0157915819,
0.0483103767,
-0.034643136,
-0.026634315,
-0.0113791833,
-0.0599538125,
-0.0055281655,
-0.0361201093,
0.0300999638,
0.0346916951,
-0.0221366193,
-0.0325386375,
0.0318619907,
-0.0559331551,
-0.0177768674,
0.0138687668,
-0.0223920885,
-0.0040324996,
-0.0564066879,
-0.0147004053,
0.0553898737,
-0.0119639924,
0.0531657152,
0.0463639311,
0.0423960052,
-0.0008862392,
-0.0282714088,
-0.0027048013,
-0.0060158055,
-0.0158483628,
0.0183449946,
0.0167650506,
0.0170217473,
0.0290205274,
-0.0058332384,
-0.0334240049,
-0.0212889425,
-0.0206919145,
-0.0087641357,
0.0027127794,
0.0122104883,
0.0398725383,
-0.0133800199,
-0.0194785092,
0.0328033827,
0.0245703477,
-0.0216600485,
-0.000892608,
-0.108625032,
0.0389620438,
-0.018613942,
0.0040513785,
0.0092978841,
-0.0887236968,
0.0329762623,
-0.0121585159,
0.0277527552,
0.0689064711,
0.0079136109,
0.0019944096,
0.0252993256,
0.0349711925,
-0.069111295,
0.0234516654,
-0.0362256579,
-0.0139025524,
-0.019895386,
-0.0641450286,
0.0339309759,
0.0301969312,
0.0254709329,
0.0202417634,
-0.114631705,
0.0227640122,
0.0031184647,
-0.0444248542,
0.0122884735,
0.0234613884,
0.0240614265,
0.0159943607,
-0.0109422905,
-0.0485176891,
0.0403769687,
-0.041985061,
0.0118966885,
-0.0593148805,
0.0133104194,
-0.0076682898,
-0.0095113618,
-0.0190204792,
0.0407287069,
-0.0423415266,
-0.0399095379,
-0.0225573871,
-0.0004106914,
0.0349249244,
-0.0396086723,
-0.0178424865,
-0.0560318306,
-0.0294877086,
-0.0327495337,
-0.0108829336,
0.0062144627,
0.0530770123,
0.0066998745,
-0.0290590413,
0.0217332821,
-0.0015415775,
0.0275756884,
0.0392533019,
-0.0116502568,
0.0548942238,
-0.0165253654,
0.0096415114,
-0.0025140706,
0.0345533751,
-0.0028904486,
0.008049041,
0.0382229239,
-0.0459945165,
0.0191624425,
0.0306503493,
-0.0060124807,
0.0170311537,
-0.0503855497,
-0.0274189468,
0.047247719,
0.0547508001,
-0.0095788818,
0.0357009731,
0.0342389531,
-0.0645801499,
-0.0073278141,
0.0760435164,
0.0007058052,
-0.0579304844,
-0.0060943612,
-0.0022019078,
0.0263529141,
-0.0317781307,
-0.0077078352,
-0.0249243248,
-0.0362101384,
0.0002246268,
0.0578575768,
0.0088885026,
0.0052695656,
-0.0209604669,
-0.0889983475,
0.0375574045,
0.0698521063,
0.0055271615,
-0.0678095967,
0.014348275,
-0.0695756823,
-0.0768255219,
0.0188767985,
-0.002204024,
0.0672601834,
-0.0040982831,
0.0388018712,
0.0187242217,
-0.096455507,
-0.0622968003,
-0.0466803052,
0.049390886,
0.119957976,
0.0130554913,
0.0092684804,
-0.0403936468,
-0.0138038341,
-0.0314892679,
0.0157922395,
0.0072325054,
0.014206212,
-0.0367081203,
-0.0051850937,
0.0150444554,
-0.0234219935,
0.0188839734,
0.0224264897,
-0.0301910806,
0.0206643473,
-0.0281533077,
-0.0076167448,
-0.00511755,
-0.0383331403,
0.003129482,
0.0411502123,
0.0396970361,
-0.0431301743,
0.0057825083,
-0.0392514169,
0.0423819423,
-0.057945691,
0.003796618,
0.0158904213,
-0.0006841067,
-0.0842869505,
-0.1020402163,
-0.0475076884,
-0.0123960376,
0.0036293857,
-0.0325824656,
-0.0220030863,
0.039953135,
-0.0033111686,
0.0151831061,
0.0276728533,
-0.0136060044,
-0.0185353681,
-0.0693151876,
0.024252791,
0.0083144577,
-0.0328474008,
0.0023226617,
0.0167954285,
-0.067774035,
-0.0546887666,
-0.0362583958,
0.090093784,
0.0184263662,
0.0175463147,
-0.0510987379,
-0.0517421663,
-0.0082958639,
0.0034402946,
-0.0146279959,
-0.0073528248,
0.0621054247,
0.0036614551,
-0.0379580073,
0.0235731974,
-0.0260112286,
0.0269450583,
-0.0390298963,
0.050084129,
-0.0159402359,
-0.0140845235,
0.0288641714,
-0.0202489216,
0.0303852465,
-0.0544260144,
-0.026823476,
-0.0238921884,
0.0070219957,
-0.0203257818,
0.0020647387,
-0.0599831156,
0.0341490731,
0.056060914,
0.0033116392,
-0.0074620182,
-0.026697332,
0.0148833534,
-0.0307248775,
0.0204444323,
-0.0053382823,
-0.0285632797,
-0.0262323916,
0.0153060062,
0.0066663409,
-0.0324562341,
0.0043689217,
-0.0012532684,
-0.003745679,
-0.0267820414,
0.0194736235,
0.0054268963,
-0.0047646849,
0.0401270501,
0.0663609728,
-0.0140147256,
-0.0556374118,
-0.0716982782,
-0.0104356818,
0.0721815377,
0.0336703546,
0.1053803042,
0.0086255856,
0.0049539949,
-0.038230069,
0.0344306603,
0.0298754368,
-0.0046136728,
0.0036767351,
0.0060601458,
0.0111233965,
-0.0152490027,
0.0442972258,
-0.0301414691,
-0.0197866317,
-0.0648358166,
-0.0071692038,
-0.0371900089,
0.0004581812,
-0.0225580186,
-0.0204713326,
-0.0223423224,
-0.0107544055,
-0.0183332879,
-0.0393815674,
-0.0089968545,
0.0249561407,
0.0371825732,
-0.0388051271,
0.0179661103,
0.0403025225,
-0.0721452385,
0.0055345935,
-0.0388974324,
-0.0544947535,
-0.031978827,
-0.0153936241,
-0.0274928957,
-6.238198644e-33,
-0.021918688,
-0.0151529638,
-0.0042055291,
-0.0896947235,
-0.0026424804,
-0.0051320866,
-0.0160600077,
-0.0334237106,
-0.0028032137,
0.0098827472,
0.025821114,
0.0156645346,
0.0254668482,
0.0002804261,
-0.007640678,
0.007927984,
0.0737312585,
0.005577479,
-0.0578521639,
-0.0043274891,
-0.0037023344,
0.0040545859,
0.0537612624,
-0.0251427088,
-0.0066635888,
0.0194635615,
-0.0555606298,
0.0014802542,
0.0202856045,
0.0409932695,
0.0200812928,
0.0150321238,
0.0178470928,
-0.0614157058,
-0.0160920657,
-0.0479352921,
-0.0487703569,
0.0175254382,
-0.0287802927,
0.0181720778,
-0.0112786628,
-0.0591805913,
0.030496208,
0.0165909901,
-0.0489239022,
-0.0193791073,
-0.0181031507,
-0.0611114763,
-0.0482531376,
-0.0401828326,
0.0163601004,
0.0575362109,
0.0083105238,
-0.0350882113,
0.0371087156,
0.0448234938,
-0.0397638753,
0.0154989483,
-0.0644640177,
0.0244886782,
0.0386382341,
0.0573269986,
0.069188267,
-0.003818477,
-0.0314814821,
-0.010072344,
0.0213817246,
-0.0309935939,
0.0331838764,
0.0069378782,
0.0142347636,
0.0306630936,
0.0784821659,
0.0438453667,
0.0486815833,
-0.0163647961,
-0.0430839173,
0.0677720681,
-0.0370136797,
0.0237581711,
0.0118269641,
0.0385042056,
-0.0509095863,
-0.0124742379,
-0.0619559325,
-0.0929009542,
-0.0053981347,
-0.0176094826,
0.0233726818,
0.0393039957,
-0.0450791232,
-0.0263426304,
0.090975076,
-0.0052948184,
0.0788211599,
-0.0095098084,
-0.0354877152,
0.0266406983,
-0.0214903653,
0.0240029227,
-0.0153789138,
0.0195539575,
0.0336428136,
-0.00099198,
-0.01188224,
-0.0003186017,
0.0060377978,
0.0335362963,
-0.0139544988,
0.0136391837,
-0.031887535,
0.0150167588,
0.0085750911,
0.0523204505,
0.0253840648,
-0.0337860286,
-0.0174138155,
0.0696657225,
-0.0197626948,
0.0662371144,
-0.0198293589,
0.0223085992,
0.0388549194,
0.0231309105,
-0.0280982014,
0.0214264449,
-0.0178146604,
0.0158131439,
0.0763202086,
-0.0343428105,
-0.0660462976,
0.0493468568,
2.712e-7,
0.0338578448,
0.0373043381,
0.021083096,
0.012719552,
0.0069356309,
0.0765127763,
0.0048450958,
0.0246005896,
0.0078915004,
0.038966395,
0.0120221591,
0.0047883419,
0.090902321,
0.0366535373,
-0.0589054488,
-0.0132692782,
-0.0337359235,
0.0290741045,
-0.0047839419,
-0.02995703,
0.0321096294,
0.0704864264,
-0.0564942993,
0.0013012107,
0.0241052154,
0.0128034083,
0.0581596196,
-0.0232440047,
-0.0183120295,
-0.0106809894,
0.064769499,
0.0150297945,
-0.0291458797,
-0.0421939306,
-0.0322853439,
-0.0233424865,
0.0354061201,
0.0776910856,
-0.0044160113,
-0.0481004901,
0.0371764638,
0.0291214734,
0.0134542733,
-0.0097794188,
0.0273812413,
-0.0604372993,
-0.0252251122,
0.0137135768,
-0.0370037034,
0.027914267,
0.0232259687,
-0.0501265787,
-0.0418446213,
-0.0012333498,
0.0426951051,
0.0127640953,
0.0163379889,
-0.0209138636,
-0.025921043,
-0.0518300943,
0.0049555227,
-0.0590830632,
-0.0273130462,
-0.0143996375,
0.0408026353,
-0.0626403838,
-0.0136682177,
2.120022658e-34,
0.0576683544,
-0.0373974219,
0.0535896979,
0.0107230209,
0.050480824,
0.0042583332,
-0.0216872636,
-0.0021068249,
-0.0039617531,
-0.0289808195,
-0.0528714471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06702v1 | Temporally Aligning Long Audio Interviews with Questions: A Case Study in Multimodal Data Integration | 2023-10-10T15:25:33 | 2023-10-10T15:25:33 | Piyush Singh Pasi, Karthikeya Battepati, Preethi Jyothi, Ganesh Ramakrishnan, Tanmay Mahapatra, Manoj Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | The problem of audio-to-text alignment has seen significant amount of
research using complete supervision during training. However, this is typically
not in the context of long audio recordings wherein the text being queried does
not appear verbatim within the audio file. This work is a collaboration with a
non-governmental organization called CARE India that collects long audio health
surveys from young mothers residing in rural parts of Bihar, India. Given a
question drawn from a questionnaire that is used to guide these surveys, we aim
to locate where the question is asked within a long audio recording. This is of
great value to African and Asian organizations that would otherwise have to
painstakingly go through long and noisy audio recordings to locate questions
(and answers) of interest. Our proposed framework, INDENT, uses a
cross-attention-based model and prior information on the temporal ordering of
sentences to learn speech embeddings that capture the semantics of the
underlying spoken text. These learnt embeddings are used to retrieve the
corresponding audio segment based on text queries at inference time. We
empirically demonstrate the significant effectiveness (improvement in R-avg of
about 3%) of our model over those obtained using text-based heuristics. We also
show how noisy ASR, generated using state-of-the-art ASR models for Indian
languages, yields better results when used in place of speech. INDENT, trained
only on Hindi data is able to cater to all languages supported by the
(semantically) shared text space. We illustrate this empirically on 11 Indic
languages. | [
0.017099943,
0.0632738471,
-0.0079099471,
0.0251185019,
-0.0223364234,
-0.0100440299,
0.0138474293,
-0.0440963842,
0.0021285836,
0.0011043164,
-0.0129663497,
-0.0521693006,
0.0344722159,
-0.0102720866,
0.0249940418,
-0.0482368805,
0.0446533412,
-0.002234044,
0.0038451131,
0.0288298596,
0.0255452637,
0.0194980055,
-0.0481827967,
0.0213453565,
-0.0344383419,
-0.0222694948,
-0.0499688461,
0.0134700565,
0.0442828201,
-0.0168705024,
-0.0301854834,
0.0043659098,
0.0353712738,
0.0296336859,
0.0000015998,
-0.0094639696,
-0.0340700783,
0.0044531384,
-0.0339413695,
-0.0338514335,
-0.0071345735,
-0.0015076189,
-0.0034339922,
0.0467935689,
-0.004649289,
0.0061024241,
0.0637285411,
0.0182952378,
0.0533952974,
0.0727011189,
-0.0151208611,
-0.0003964916,
0.0055424422,
-0.024529865,
0.0251998901,
-0.0146763194,
-0.0329170227,
-0.0179235954,
0.0386207737,
0.007627198,
-0.0142508829,
0.0731315762,
0.0161125083,
-0.0047100945,
0.0224715676,
0.0035498736,
-0.0666340292,
-0.0407165587,
0.0060863481,
0.087043412,
0.0162160732,
0.0120118801,
-0.0011335461,
0.0392609052,
-0.0070424895,
-0.0088504376,
-0.0461582057,
0.0279314239,
-0.0146927051,
-0.014263913,
-0.0183883477,
0.0422182269,
-0.0066507128,
-0.0581727177,
0.0322067142,
0.0133675849,
0.0017478989,
-0.0385179035,
-0.0034859963,
-0.0359762199,
-0.0031552925,
-0.0146249468,
0.0296376459,
-0.0023105945,
-0.0215640254,
0.0179673266,
-0.0326177031,
-0.0267422143,
0.0152290557,
-0.0216417797,
-0.0080123991,
0.020929046,
-0.0678246096,
0.0615936145,
0.0447092876,
0.0407803543,
-0.0450618714,
-0.0132129388,
-0.0453648008,
0.00527883,
0.008015452,
-0.0260839257,
-0.0034462139,
-0.0078298897,
-0.0391740575,
-0.0311899446,
-0.039758414,
0.0275580753,
0.0059829052,
0.0170957148,
-0.0000315752,
-0.0045048068,
-0.0225318894,
-0.0081478292,
0.0351028033,
0.031309586,
-0.0051795756,
0.0452207029,
-0.0082203113,
-0.0278366189,
-0.0144348787,
0.0319319628,
0.0198020153,
-0.0022884556,
-0.0302634537,
0.0424047671,
-0.0214726124,
-0.0077121658,
-0.0276054684,
-0.0151823219,
-0.0450093262,
-0.0510789603,
-0.0052702627,
-0.0169149768,
0.0895540267,
-0.0056277374,
-0.0491107889,
-0.0072703515,
0.0059908107,
0.0303467773,
-0.0090175141,
0.0959338024,
0.0674548373,
0.051371716,
0.0519804396,
0.021660395,
0.0595242418,
0.031238921,
0.0553539544,
-0.0307844412,
0.030112071,
-0.0355503969,
-0.0184047054,
0.0704068989,
-0.0035970102,
-0.029309608,
-0.0164691545,
0.0516412631,
0.017938735,
0.074171178,
-0.0024017005,
0.0389225893,
0.029783586,
-0.0276517924,
0.0532787368,
0.0710899383,
-0.0051259547,
-0.0450867675,
0.0207289141,
0.0198257621,
-0.0280976389,
0.04207737,
-0.0150316367,
0.0257341303,
0.0340042338,
0.0225657467,
0.0841953158,
0.0174446832,
-0.0161584374,
0.0072095222,
-0.0180303678,
-0.0221220367,
-0.0127183637,
0.0617621094,
-0.0124239633,
-0.0178501587,
-0.0524529703,
0.0227700472,
-0.0022657742,
-0.0443678349,
-0.0182025116,
0.006138321,
0.0232472457,
0.0059229117,
-0.0012827882,
-0.0674848333,
-0.0276086759,
-0.0529796332,
0.0419630669,
0.0340755023,
0.0267759692,
-0.0070677339,
0.017328022,
-0.0429002866,
0.0065415497,
0.0296141449,
-0.0319233388,
0.0182183739,
-0.0110330731,
0.0455186181,
0.0169396661,
-0.0213474352,
0.0422452614,
0.0126705598,
-0.0120179821,
-0.0216811858,
-0.0283273272,
0.0487951227,
0.0713154748,
0.0499359556,
-0.0253319871,
0.0096411817,
0.0486916006,
-0.0325884596,
0.0572877079,
0.0541434735,
-0.0581482723,
-0.0594212525,
0.0093674809,
-0.0639720187,
-0.0086817648,
0.0376923159,
-0.0095072482,
-0.0584541559,
0.0122181782,
-0.0203711428,
0.0225804374,
-0.0155733544,
0.0313039608,
0.0607401468,
0.0132771637,
-0.0386588685,
-0.0030352708,
0.0157828182,
-0.0042633894,
0.0052271192,
-0.009332017,
0.0497679785,
-0.0824398026,
0.0144289117,
0.0266600791,
-0.0078903167,
0.0039397385,
0.00701587,
-0.0594071113,
-0.0571598858,
-0.0168544967,
-0.1172895133,
0.0382138006,
-0.0137030492,
-0.0064933519,
-0.0264291391,
0.052840326,
0.0088510821,
-0.0428043567,
-0.0610394254,
-0.0581577234,
0.0624849647,
0.0187166315,
-0.0219989419,
0.0052159205,
0.0033306128,
-0.027953079,
0.0023633314,
-0.0300244112,
0.030502921,
-0.0104816798,
-0.0373901986,
-0.024343688,
-0.0385584794,
-0.0227415822,
-0.0169742927,
-0.0236199312,
-0.0313693956,
-0.0285247862,
0.0148530751,
0.019901799,
0.0938639492,
0.002498168,
-0.0171429701,
-0.0204692781,
0.0016506338,
-0.0233267732,
0.0414131135,
0.0287331641,
0.0448592417,
-0.0039366423,
0.0029143025,
-0.0044893711,
0.0313363411,
0.0613352768,
0.0406468809,
0.0001425495,
-0.0352792963,
-0.0031902185,
0.011885562,
-0.0337880589,
-0.0152988741,
-0.0546110347,
0.0477776155,
-0.0448071621,
-0.0200191196,
0.0478963852,
-0.0369764045,
-0.0551204123,
-0.0518105812,
-0.0568038449,
-0.0361014493,
0.0498029329,
-0.0281412657,
0.0264912993,
0.0271059405,
-0.0437299237,
-0.0795406103,
0.0206476953,
0.0128241321,
-0.0574829504,
0.0029818285,
0.0086919591,
0.0023041575,
-0.0240246691,
-0.0511963964,
-0.0496129431,
-0.0894745439,
0.0083430419,
-0.0247916095,
-0.0166192092,
0.0113621037,
-0.0428104699,
0.0584224612,
0.0433843881,
0.0102295913,
-0.0090696113,
0.0444905572,
-0.0050663515,
0.092213355,
0.0579758883,
0.0294213388,
-0.0468844585,
-0.006021922,
0.032066118,
-0.014571202,
0.0625758171,
-0.0015156299,
-0.0118222693,
-0.0250933636,
-0.0031938453,
0.0016241723,
-0.0175558589,
0.0025073099,
0.0487738736,
-0.0339853801,
0.0176228136,
0.0778876841,
0.0286402181,
0.0078864414,
-0.0230410714,
0.0016252438,
-0.0194184259,
0.0104270633,
0.0453133024,
-0.0747091472,
-0.0222521555,
0.0430880301,
0.0065664742,
0.0375533924,
0.0306590218,
-0.019877892,
-0.0863335133,
0.0290697236,
-0.001468776,
-0.0390161835,
-0.036712423,
-0.0165378638,
-0.0199471638,
0.0130102569,
0.0410541035,
0.0107878558,
-0.0255503077,
-0.0143499495,
0.0208585951,
-0.0508222729,
-0.0193561129,
0.0011742379,
-0.0214849971,
0.061318092,
0.0787414014,
0.0189898815,
0.0017370949,
-0.0466054752,
0.0095347874,
0.0114954161,
-0.0233997423,
0.0530435443,
0.0534590967,
-0.0212566387,
-0.0159165896,
0.0292136315,
0.0579266883,
0.0266345348,
0.0258908961,
0.0248422027,
0.0835200623,
-0.00508735,
0.0292466599,
-0.0240250342,
0.0588798262,
0.0424349532,
0.052570343,
0.0196079109,
-0.0197752323,
0.0050031608,
0.0032970884,
0.0400545485,
-0.0417870134,
-0.0301862583,
0.0459206998,
-0.0115673514,
-0.0006605567,
-0.0058952738,
-0.0671932399,
0.0256812908,
0.0414985977,
0.0431044959,
-0.0010507436,
0.0196690727,
0.0143526448,
-0.0687345043,
0.0497273691,
-0.0040485556,
0.0429307371,
-0.0535314865,
-0.0018118725,
0.0378994271,
-0.0297368355,
-0.0071875285,
0.0145482998,
-0.0679962263,
-0.0491648875,
0.0036845529,
-0.0131267309,
0.013428566,
0.0763350204,
-0.0111375479,
0.0127631454,
0.0384390131,
-0.0240317769,
-0.0661588311,
-0.0228225291,
0.0022750567,
0.02038165,
-0.0207365323,
0.0167241208,
-0.0546242483,
0.0102366544,
-0.0266654007,
0.0064442814,
-0.0531673916,
-0.0499199033,
0.0017303447,
-0.010240159,
0.0634227246,
-0.0196221415,
-0.0178300012,
-0.0546985902,
0.0336397588,
0.0145776859,
-0.0055708401,
-0.0474166796,
-0.0208263304,
0.0183130614,
0.0062546739,
0.0000731438,
0.0107699884,
-0.0375633612,
-0.0069300006,
-0.0568186082,
0.0640117228,
0.0177159663,
-0.0087805605,
0.0030863741,
0.0100117456,
0.0088671651,
0.0585025176,
0.0182307139,
0.0609204061,
0.0180701371,
0.0667342767,
-0.0079181911,
0.0115339998,
0.0257207621,
0.025938103,
-0.02337013,
0.0262405016,
-0.0012546835,
-0.0045914515,
0.0228025541,
-0.0588497445,
-0.0051642735,
0.0664751604,
-0.0003455015,
-0.0166365411,
0.0466309972,
-0.0405236185,
-0.0289044026,
0.0523145907,
0.0020513921,
-0.027314188,
0.0566472895,
0.0425502881,
-0.0137073612,
-0.0275884233,
0.0096151093,
-0.0302824657,
-0.0671955049,
-0.0254890583,
0.0265588462,
0.0123483334,
-0.0237306636,
-0.0049582119,
-0.0177809652,
-0.0701663569,
0.0099266823,
-0.0291011482,
-0.0220436137,
-0.00028351,
0.0051114969,
0.013117129,
0.0257656276,
-0.0100520318,
0.0068297479,
-0.0164777841,
-0.0597517118,
-0.0518666729,
0.0184445959,
-5.480611637e-33,
-0.0255959406,
0.0032710435,
-0.0127801085,
-0.03215928,
-0.0659138635,
0.0336729735,
-0.0167596936,
-0.012372626,
-0.0163893811,
-0.0120657636,
-0.0298773404,
-0.0059691644,
0.0274448749,
0.028501628,
0.0191588029,
-0.0071299784,
0.0367996991,
-0.0113615114,
-0.0153535046,
-0.0067282189,
0.019513499,
0.0385107622,
0.0123220803,
-0.0497646108,
-0.013782368,
-0.0254631564,
0.0249726493,
0.0245863907,
0.0131329084,
0.0836200938,
0.0002614575,
-0.020255683,
-0.0156301502,
-0.0466391146,
0.0196307953,
0.1094125435,
-0.1143443584,
0.0308432207,
0.0076962244,
0.0833676606,
-0.0238894131,
-0.0276416,
0.0226447415,
-0.0453484505,
0.0435368232,
-0.0239788145,
0.0243146345,
-0.0068220268,
-0.0251467265,
-0.0160577707,
-0.0324664339,
0.002937475,
-0.0636547431,
-0.046628654,
0.0373992249,
0.0711843744,
0.0415192656,
-0.0139823901,
-0.0576507896,
-0.0027817891,
-0.0168218631,
0.042861823,
0.0472871885,
0.0284268949,
-0.0540708192,
0.0103299348,
0.0305080302,
-0.097656481,
0.006024431,
-0.0151015911,
-0.0118129626,
-0.0022169112,
-0.0180662926,
0.0105936881,
0.0050884248,
-0.0020613889,
-0.0424048565,
-0.0023001318,
-0.0023955849,
0.0108797168,
0.0056410972,
0.0141127398,
-0.0479786582,
0.0041307835,
-0.0171966888,
0.0107218307,
-0.0282184519,
-0.0189202055,
0.0761112198,
-0.0076372828,
0.0295462552,
0.0274387766,
0.0873306543,
-0.011980542,
0.0513621867,
-0.0153645603,
-0.0115615642,
0.0084501067,
-0.0141398869,
0.0619547851,
-0.0540091433,
0.0519263446,
0.0384512879,
0.0275956262,
0.0267285891,
-0.0166399237,
0.0217967648,
0.0053262897,
-0.0812017173,
-0.0083596213,
0.0193870384,
0.0279000401,
-0.0507075489,
0.031703122,
0.0504302606,
0.0079694716,
-0.0133531736,
0.0389510989,
-0.0061652442,
0.0237788111,
-0.0334336795,
-0.0505443215,
0.0004116697,
-0.0150853274,
-0.037746042,
0.0343089923,
0.0020365729,
0.0203710198,
-0.0124583952,
-0.0212226082,
0.0041791438,
0.0392182283,
2.428e-7,
-0.0274985284,
-0.0079798158,
0.0322846062,
-0.0014613374,
0.0014547117,
-0.0101742446,
-0.0294191483,
0.0061279843,
-0.007963419,
0.011612922,
0.0358516499,
-0.0281673986,
0.1183421388,
0.0245674662,
-0.1312827468,
-0.0362335071,
-0.0694982558,
0.0033399339,
-0.0647320747,
-0.0059381509,
0.0067914524,
0.1304525584,
-0.0107615124,
0.0051857382,
-0.0427983738,
-0.0250751134,
0.0182451103,
0.0143828755,
-0.0429101959,
-0.0356750675,
-0.0035843146,
-0.0141883381,
-0.0576097779,
-0.0044889301,
-0.0280131269,
0.0166938826,
0.0304108281,
0.0418920293,
-0.0087051168,
-0.0906667039,
-0.0539458655,
0.0675847456,
-0.0285721458,
-0.0217216853,
0.0637303293,
-0.0188714266,
-0.0550144278,
-0.0249830931,
-0.0614989474,
-0.0113813225,
0.0118168062,
0.0212123152,
0.0061485833,
-0.0132821845,
0.0357857905,
-0.0647022501,
-0.0080789458,
-0.0333606601,
-0.0259892344,
0.03367275,
-0.0445538647,
-0.0097303651,
0.0153454244,
-0.034005776,
0.0065883156,
-0.0437837541,
-0.0078566028,
2.028511801e-34,
0.0467471257,
-0.0081680138,
0.016534688,
0.0057647028,
0.0417121984,
-0.0451001227,
0.0182493478,
-0.0119757103,
0.039377261,
-0.0703781396,
-0.023733234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06694v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06694v2 | Sheared LLaMA: Accelerating Language Model Pre-training via Structured Pruning | 2023-10-10T15:13:30 | 2024-04-11T01:18:06 | Mengzhou Xia, Tianyu Gao, Zhiyuan Zeng, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The popularity of LLaMA (Touvron et al., 2023a;b) and other recently emerged
moderate-sized large language models (LLMs) highlights the potential of
building smaller yet powerful LLMs. Regardless, the cost of training such
models from scratch on trillions of tokens remains high. In this work, we study
structured pruning as an effective means to develop smaller LLMs from
pre-trained, larger models. Our approach employs two key techniques: (1)
targeted structured pruning, which prunes a larger model to a specified target
shape by removing layers, heads, and intermediate and hidden dimensions in an
end-to-end manner, and (2) dynamic batch loading, which dynamically updates the
composition of sampled data in each training batch based on varying losses
across different domains. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach by
presenting the Sheared-LLaMA series, pruning the LLaMA2-7B model down to 1.3B
and 2.7B parameters. Sheared-LLaMA models outperform state-of-the-art
open-source models of equivalent sizes, such as Pythia, INCITE, OpenLLaMA and
the concurrent TinyLlama models, on a wide range of downstream and instruction
tuning evaluations, while requiring only 3% of compute compared to training
such models from scratch. This work provides compelling evidence that
leveraging existing LLMs with structured pruning is a far more cost-effective
approach for building competitive small-scale LLMs | [
0.0095938519,
0.0760559067,
-0.0093803685,
0.0419390798,
0.0012393423,
0.0010009602,
0.0201946832,
0.0246537104,
-0.033708062,
-0.0151395379,
-0.0765728578,
-0.0593410581,
-0.0062957359,
0.014081913,
0.0122592608,
-0.0290774275,
0.0298226327,
-0.0456563458,
-0.0171061158,
-0.0206794553,
0.0071978765,
0.0102873528,
0.027671244,
0.01804935,
0.0335473455,
-0.0255561229,
-0.0150947329,
0.0153916916,
-0.0252531413,
-0.0152327577,
0.02153893,
0.0379417054,
0.014138734,
0.0487693883,
0.0000023584,
-0.0210162997,
0.0103712864,
-0.0081129447,
-0.0283847023,
0.1096883491,
0.0447704047,
0.013253144,
-0.0349226892,
0.017279068,
0.0062106601,
-0.0396578051,
0.0391696021,
-0.0009102838,
0.0634452775,
0.0737325251,
0.0078757973,
-0.0359737426,
0.0111412294,
-0.0518984161,
-0.0476782098,
-0.022853639,
0.0261926446,
-0.0428100601,
-0.0354394391,
-0.0123129943,
-0.0116393659,
0.018044211,
0.0190791152,
0.0159566607,
-0.033208631,
0.0341764838,
-0.0170787573,
-0.0299552232,
0.0088977804,
0.0651412681,
-0.0527140424,
-0.0198288281,
0.0174578186,
-0.0395605788,
-0.0386304334,
-0.0509919226,
-0.0370538495,
0.025279263,
0.0339528471,
0.0282363929,
-0.0120417569,
-0.0215369295,
0.0546954386,
0.0081819221,
-0.025771914,
0.039062202,
0.0362832062,
0.0084053269,
-0.0269678887,
-0.0279001109,
0.0043503535,
-0.0600874461,
0.0082843928,
0.0142249903,
-0.0016667783,
0.0158943813,
-0.042594526,
-0.0204011872,
0.0093952166,
-0.0498881787,
0.0824119151,
0.0397179462,
-0.0064866836,
0.0384567231,
-0.0221265759,
0.0167548973,
-0.0133597767,
0.0186872911,
-0.0490416512,
0.0203586891,
0.0349519551,
0.0083870301,
-0.028145723,
0.0273630265,
-0.051326286,
-0.0158752762,
-0.0302712414,
-0.0031363838,
0.0090118274,
-0.0343169011,
0.0382610261,
-0.0086231194,
-0.0038105925,
-0.0169530939,
0.0107622584,
0.0238795709,
-0.0202661622,
0.0287443027,
-0.0112906471,
-0.064664118,
-0.023920197,
0.023162609,
-0.0122150937,
-0.0127145592,
0.0506773368,
0.050812006,
0.0019136465,
-0.0565133952,
-0.0605975576,
0.0026776535,
0.0089995898,
-0.0705061629,
0.0184204206,
-0.0588828065,
0.0234439317,
-0.0468714274,
0.0162021648,
-0.0432667322,
0.007838238,
0.0177971683,
-0.0375684015,
0.0263302736,
-0.0066921576,
0.0141394455,
0.0036864248,
0.0032404303,
0.053442467,
0.0903312713,
0.0392811187,
0.0470105708,
0.0293094851,
-0.0204169173,
-0.0481872261,
0.0622416623,
0.0552503206,
0.0318787731,
-0.0613023788,
-0.012073325,
0.0095524658,
0.0188610014,
0.0717791393,
0.0689992011,
-0.0382887796,
-0.0286192093,
0.0568466298,
0.0516119637,
0.0086199045,
0.0445966646,
0.0390342176,
-0.0061307102,
0.0291978903,
-0.0287758652,
-0.0272777993,
0.0061401259,
0.0003767115,
0.0034938147,
0.0433461368,
0.0641321614,
-0.0511690006,
-0.0235100407,
-0.0197274163,
-0.0162395742,
-0.0298228823,
0.0250072926,
0.0260689314,
0.0047856155,
-0.0531136952,
0.0903419331,
0.065072827,
-0.0612749942,
-0.0221309699,
-0.0839512199,
0.0068665012,
0.0315113217,
0.0210506823,
-0.0118249105,
-0.0379623324,
0.040529605,
0.025250202,
0.0272538979,
0.0273224954,
-0.0053609768,
0.0287918746,
-0.0702139437,
0.0067808814,
-0.0043238713,
0.0243097134,
0.0232237838,
0.0482788533,
-0.0011794027,
0.0181542989,
-0.0170937274,
-0.0147094745,
0.0380957611,
-0.0456777364,
-0.0231582895,
0.0313398838,
-0.0070152595,
0.0331568159,
-0.0196539722,
-0.0219041463,
-0.0008839633,
0.0538526028,
-0.034526702,
0.0210354794,
-0.0390250199,
-0.0460425876,
-0.0174567588,
0.0482790507,
0.0620030873,
0.046091795,
0.0340111218,
-0.0596694425,
-0.0304088276,
0.0366060734,
-0.0279053599,
0.0481364578,
-0.0419182368,
0.0420308672,
-0.0268038474,
0.0608955845,
-0.0117420908,
0.0154996635,
-0.0262987763,
0.0061117662,
0.0050731031,
-0.0269709174,
0.0007373017,
-0.0284477938,
-0.0347323902,
0.0037170043,
-0.0144979237,
0.0272802617,
-0.0411755554,
0.0153769748,
-0.0116042681,
-0.0188965723,
-0.0497342832,
0.0339043401,
-0.0348945335,
0.0408725031,
0.0247030482,
0.0384861939,
-0.0154658156,
0.0037334962,
0.027517125,
0.0046213204,
-0.0151585462,
0.0330743715,
-0.0050652656,
-0.0151588023,
-0.0676859617,
-0.051193133,
-0.0582435541,
0.0220396053,
0.0566089638,
-0.0405563861,
-0.0134259192,
-0.026741337,
0.0182736758,
0.0013679588,
0.0431771614,
-0.0050295629,
-0.0655793473,
-0.023127947,
-0.0155591872,
0.0176359285,
0.0634493455,
-0.0100844502,
0.0282740165,
0.049108997,
-0.007221797,
-0.031490542,
0.0187280681,
-0.0080778049,
-0.0203122851,
-0.0308028013,
-0.0227730181,
-0.0059883711,
0.0978538916,
-0.0279753115,
-0.0070039365,
-0.0376637578,
-0.0164514966,
-0.0023977128,
-0.0148111302,
-0.0125626959,
-0.0104223443,
-0.0322473645,
0.0194080733,
-0.0086244419,
-0.055353187,
0.0127967102,
-0.0703189895,
0.0010367901,
-0.0064433715,
-0.0181081761,
-0.0563802049,
0.0465192646,
0.0272394065,
0.0264350642,
-0.0132486569,
-0.0063174712,
-0.0390990824,
0.0229393952,
-0.0235164631,
-0.0119330045,
0.0151749188,
-0.0398001038,
0.0193508118,
-0.0187039841,
-0.04068527,
-0.0114563946,
-0.0147900572,
-0.0312171634,
0.0171117596,
0.0568089932,
-0.030259436,
-0.0311777182,
0.0246823654,
-0.0032790247,
0.051208809,
0.0119404262,
0.0389830582,
-0.009235071,
0.0121044265,
0.0340546444,
0.0047968356,
0.0314007364,
-0.0377767608,
0.0257732291,
0.0345900096,
0.0760639012,
-0.0110245757,
-0.0473294333,
0.0017703302,
0.0568380691,
-0.0153700029,
-0.0264172982,
0.0213398468,
0.0579037182,
-0.0639603212,
-0.0180179738,
0.0845714957,
0.0149117922,
-0.0521601737,
0.0199250802,
0.0306593683,
0.0510712191,
0.0186110977,
0.036089357,
-0.0521573722,
-0.0349499322,
0.0198809169,
0.006580615,
0.0136592081,
0.0027703568,
-0.0235982928,
-0.1303100735,
0.0183832701,
-0.0006182563,
-0.0269485023,
0.0436480008,
-0.0486179329,
-0.0112822168,
-0.003814396,
0.0148217818,
0.034789525,
-0.0276942439,
-0.0186534803,
0.0159400888,
-0.0233385302,
-0.0355154313,
0.0514692105,
-0.0100004738,
0.0420808308,
0.0291919485,
0.005914988,
0.0224144347,
-0.0532863438,
0.1031198725,
-0.028564129,
-0.0103251776,
-0.0221360959,
0.0310323611,
0.0245115422,
-0.0213301349,
0.0263435468,
0.0097956583,
-0.0193007346,
-0.0059061558,
-0.0232783835,
0.0547616221,
0.0268405508,
-0.0122562377,
-0.009511427,
-0.0202581864,
-0.0410027392,
0.0546078049,
0.041763436,
-0.0348205157,
-0.0299288779,
-0.0021851582,
-0.0270280875,
-0.0342421979,
-0.0290737916,
0.0092179086,
-0.0145445345,
-0.0411741249,
-0.0278495438,
0.0281214043,
0.0054093115,
0.033844661,
-0.0022466474,
-0.0210813321,
0.0138222454,
0.0205223113,
-0.0551557653,
0.031139005,
-0.0483300872,
0.0152693568,
-0.1040879264,
0.0109495781,
0.0335987173,
0.0058487831,
-0.0348199084,
0.0113314809,
-0.1378452331,
-0.0724156201,
-0.0129063744,
0.0478077419,
0.0177753828,
0.024379693,
0.0129563203,
-0.0673762634,
0.0540541485,
0.0244555771,
-0.0415776223,
0.0534505509,
0.0294539239,
-0.058520887,
-0.0097707957,
0.0631753132,
-0.0256301593,
0.0349070877,
0.0385041498,
0.0246785264,
0.0208814181,
-0.0037671546,
-0.0248925649,
0.0261274688,
0.0306829996,
0.0003672231,
-0.0211151056,
-0.0287658013,
0.0648921505,
0.0081417849,
0.0023912902,
-0.0355686285,
0.0071655647,
0.0135540366,
-0.0044108513,
-0.0221286733,
0.0102551021,
0.0293322485,
0.0246136133,
-0.0124799693,
0.0278318953,
-0.002948808,
0.0091276262,
0.0588383526,
-0.0191002134,
-0.0067695184,
0.0177565254,
-0.0011182454,
0.0227091908,
-0.0500033051,
-0.0276067294,
-0.0094610928,
0.03358775,
-0.0891690105,
0.0363926254,
-0.0108838091,
-0.0706421882,
-0.0612266622,
0.0361837782,
0.0459589027,
-0.0023656029,
0.0329837911,
0.0201956481,
-0.0164043233,
-0.0253219865,
-0.003922346,
-0.0118817799,
-0.0397924632,
0.0337220952,
0.0055478523,
-0.0202627461,
-0.0229273885,
0.0797050297,
0.0318642929,
0.0677691475,
0.0086206375,
0.0279412083,
-0.0198359806,
-0.0505579673,
-0.017499892,
0.0400211662,
-0.0357905664,
-0.0267135426,
-0.0274314396,
-0.061464034,
-0.0239687636,
-0.0013091784,
-0.0051064356,
-0.0095746517,
0.0335425846,
0.0425538532,
0.0229935832,
0.0101262275,
-0.0079192286,
-0.0313410796,
0.0039346437,
-0.0367689319,
0.0503238887,
-7.252684799e-33,
0.0013973359,
0.0434776507,
0.0409931503,
-0.0036979672,
-0.0286116116,
0.0264035277,
-0.0371481366,
-0.0273460448,
-0.0258771386,
-0.0145045687,
-0.0437343456,
0.0102849398,
0.0158648863,
0.0296267439,
-0.016609801,
0.0330197439,
0.0639500841,
-0.0310032647,
-0.0230574105,
0.0471874177,
0.0093998928,
0.0289641935,
0.043138478,
0.0102332542,
-0.0677386522,
0.0102257254,
-0.0260207485,
0.0056834598,
-0.026175946,
0.0322895087,
-0.0466792136,
0.0119185671,
0.0008750007,
-0.0260278713,
-0.0125286262,
-0.0128079494,
-0.0694721863,
-0.008549449,
0.0415351093,
0.0256505273,
-0.016102884,
-0.0361981019,
0.0347938724,
0.0340617448,
-0.0181869864,
-0.0078475168,
-0.0072503123,
-0.0103321858,
-0.0328606889,
-0.0237234458,
-0.0338438675,
0.0345478728,
0.0124995578,
-0.0230930373,
0.0282094441,
-0.0395042636,
-0.0138410572,
0.027382765,
-0.049029991,
0.0085706478,
0.0346479937,
0.0881577656,
0.0691837668,
0.0484441482,
0.0173255578,
0.0470039546,
0.0378791019,
0.0025877287,
-0.0012403145,
0.0255299881,
0.0699960291,
0.0412326977,
0.0087634893,
-0.0186800305,
0.0455150604,
-0.0425123647,
-0.1006023586,
-0.0281661358,
0.0202401187,
0.0311807711,
0.0258877408,
0.037028566,
0.0114534348,
-0.0292995032,
-0.0449999012,
-0.0278265662,
-0.0415153317,
0.0069201547,
0.0246823058,
0.0405676253,
-0.0451798327,
-0.0243103039,
0.0155911483,
-0.0359071717,
-0.0268904157,
0.0156064015,
-0.0144013194,
0.0180671327,
0.0052249064,
0.0287170522,
-0.0658629313,
-0.0504583567,
-0.0135604404,
-0.0402664393,
0.0214422774,
-0.0085878586,
0.0230240077,
0.0366947278,
-0.0739262402,
-0.0112177748,
-0.0539427325,
0.023353586,
0.0378532745,
0.0804138631,
0.0406405702,
0.0109531013,
0.0036531552,
0.0465165377,
0.0126145044,
-0.0160494465,
-0.0275579542,
0.0041892636,
0.0219331514,
0.0425943434,
-0.0426849611,
0.0078815669,
-0.046038311,
0.0160650648,
0.0477248877,
-0.0812737942,
-0.0462868288,
0.025287902,
2.919e-7,
0.0157555826,
0.0313348398,
-0.0035249034,
0.0236226507,
0.0120969284,
0.0224502105,
-0.0202764198,
-0.0108951433,
-0.0098035876,
0.0138889523,
-0.0085249972,
0.0215959214,
0.0516638421,
0.0059688678,
-0.0731032938,
0.0363296308,
-0.0683090314,
0.0199956074,
-0.0429352745,
-0.0605746433,
-0.0537164696,
0.1366041154,
0.0278987344,
-0.0637814105,
-0.0081260856,
-0.0261918008,
0.0325051732,
-0.0073471307,
0.0123466561,
0.0410283878,
-0.0179363675,
0.0163387544,
-0.0347482525,
-0.0322566815,
-0.0171482768,
0.0268757641,
-0.0340088271,
0.0822992399,
0.009643903,
0.0059147533,
0.0505673476,
0.0046042954,
-0.0258515459,
-0.0298253801,
0.0630670488,
-0.005034897,
-0.010778375,
-0.0589967445,
0.0148288487,
-0.0203260463,
-0.0049249488,
-0.0334107168,
0.0129513228,
0.052855894,
0.0066966377,
-0.0468985662,
-0.0235314444,
-0.0834837407,
-0.039771691,
-0.0309886113,
-0.0616869703,
-0.0362264328,
-0.0711641088,
0.0205875281,
0.0321448967,
-0.0406059027,
0.0183048528,
3.134504589e-34,
0.0486032479,
-0.0375451371,
-0.015280853,
0.0581836887,
0.0194482096,
-0.021747563,
0.027230205,
0.016404178,
-0.0364596322,
-0.0953788161,
-0.0264827088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06692v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06692v3 | Generalizable Chain-of-Thought Prompting in Mixed-task Scenarios with Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T15:10:03 | 2024-02-20T15:27:20 | Anni Zou, Zhuosheng Zhang, Hai Zhao, Xiangru Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have unveiled remarkable reasoning capabilities
by exploiting chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting, which generates intermediate
reasoning chains to serve as the rationale for deriving the answer. However,
current CoT methods either simply employ general prompts such as Let's think
step by step, or heavily rely on pre-defined task-specific demonstrations to
attain preferable performances, thereby engendering an inescapable gap between
performance and generalization. To bridge this gap, we propose GeM-CoT, a
Generalizable CoT prompting mechanism in Mixed-task scenarios where the type of
input questions is unknown. GeM-CoT first categorizes the question type and
subsequently samples or constructs demonstrations from the corresponding data
pool in an automatic pattern. With this technical design, GeM-CoT
simultaneously enjoys superior generalization capabilities and remarkable
performances on 10 public reasoning tasks and 23 BBH tasks. | [
0.0144565208,
0.0317718536,
-0.004766488,
0.0353061035,
-0.06175768,
0.0273740273,
0.0431039222,
-0.0018755128,
0.0248154346,
-0.028679084,
-0.0097456509,
-0.0451286212,
-0.0347308777,
0.0123310722,
0.0358946808,
-0.0554605089,
0.0324938446,
-0.0804998726,
0.0162551831,
-0.0226990599,
-0.0147777451,
-0.0022526991,
-0.0290082525,
0.033395566,
0.0063416124,
-0.0493318327,
-0.0613974594,
-0.0050004744,
0.0189671665,
-0.0324337482,
-0.0204112008,
0.0707890391,
0.0333985649,
0.0314755924,
0.0000021092,
-0.0655947104,
0.0002471471,
-0.0009552447,
-0.0542399473,
-0.0473750085,
-0.0245154295,
0.075979352,
0.0215579458,
0.0300022811,
-0.0383045264,
-0.0072229933,
0.0129094487,
0.0413817167,
0.0512602888,
0.0537883602,
0.0240066629,
-0.0109841367,
-0.0222417042,
-0.0077941935,
0.0447873287,
-0.0348132737,
0.0099114552,
0.0027059952,
0.0726043358,
0.0201064125,
-0.0059376964,
0.0082854144,
0.060245648,
-0.0029128406,
-0.0317951478,
0.0265910737,
-0.0500910245,
-0.0004880595,
-0.016643839,
0.0852079988,
0.004736729,
-0.0107246935,
-0.0008827773,
0.011777577,
0.033147797,
0.0108182216,
-0.0558197238,
0.0435997359,
-0.0234715603,
-0.0112373699,
0.0201867539,
0.0274634343,
0.0042796382,
0.0057118004,
-0.0350170955,
0.0823252127,
-0.0047495868,
-0.0369973704,
0.0324241295,
0.0287396125,
-0.005295279,
-0.0842294618,
-0.0074399109,
0.0535599403,
-0.0760432258,
-0.0039092042,
-0.0036766103,
-0.031567201,
-0.0050172061,
0.0361255519,
0.0430435017,
0.0423767976,
-0.0332487151,
0.0666848496,
-0.0328632705,
0.0425085463,
-0.0322339758,
0.0286460761,
-0.0399600789,
-0.0094188647,
-0.0469730869,
0.0018053465,
-0.0367366225,
0.0642185211,
-0.029961355,
-0.0087066768,
0.0000898301,
0.0367230773,
-0.0235490873,
0.0276868735,
0.0341210403,
0.0240048897,
-0.0153736649,
-0.0433601812,
-0.0395459421,
0.0134371631,
-0.0686474666,
0.0213350467,
0.0670792311,
-0.0226976369,
-0.0234290846,
-0.0019099198,
0.0247521773,
-0.0261946097,
0.0257918518,
0.0556024648,
-0.0309809987,
-0.0042598266,
-0.0472725816,
-0.0296679828,
0.0117094349,
-0.0706585571,
0.0106279338,
-0.0680445954,
0.0258734021,
0.0094918665,
-0.0187210012,
0.0230660774,
0.010473527,
0.03728351,
-0.0082854852,
0.0629438236,
0.0215814207,
-0.0068312665,
0.0090422546,
0.0255721286,
-0.068103835,
0.0834674835,
0.0170421675,
0.0226115193,
0.0157140624,
0.0189762339,
0.0142660625,
0.0219432339,
0.0149779851,
0.00170766,
0.0167023651,
0.0401975997,
-0.0118221575,
0.0444570184,
-0.0049425503,
0.0442325734,
-0.0057654493,
0.02140598,
0.0286442135,
0.0749306157,
0.0016602828,
0.0026038287,
0.0645416453,
0.0041863364,
0.026071256,
0.0271619111,
-0.0541852079,
0.0414986834,
-0.0614464618,
-0.0013931997,
0.0270685684,
0.0399014205,
-0.038955044,
-0.0321746171,
0.0188896544,
0.0297536906,
0.0217483044,
0.057101436,
0.0382167958,
0.0178578962,
-0.0176419374,
0.0319855437,
0.0096548991,
-0.019977821,
-0.0116153769,
-0.0717258677,
0.0662563369,
0.0190293137,
0.042366229,
-0.0516483784,
-0.0394083932,
-0.0255917106,
0.050457295,
0.0245064795,
0.0162872449,
-0.030397132,
-0.0239887312,
-0.0401549302,
-0.029829558,
-0.0134605914,
-0.0062422184,
-0.002753716,
0.015963316,
0.0042043473,
-0.0114473756,
-0.0512257405,
0.0258384533,
0.0013232244,
0.0015578639,
-0.0135953603,
0.0178851262,
0.029643828,
-0.0092061115,
0.0241277833,
0.0171445869,
0.0149395457,
0.012487812,
-0.0385664701,
-0.0273521971,
-0.0055473996,
-0.0464064255,
-0.0589506887,
0.0245858077,
-0.0267207157,
-0.0536604151,
0.0070539969,
-0.0434563868,
-0.0438048244,
0.0099058142,
0.0106828678,
0.0215971954,
-0.0263480693,
-0.0024047696,
0.0115578594,
-0.0431952812,
-0.0428207219,
0.0887290239,
0.003906298,
0.0145264529,
0.0424980596,
-0.0126550077,
-0.0082598925,
-0.0536722168,
-0.0129057486,
0.0194787681,
-0.0089539029,
-0.0122562749,
0.0028398184,
0.0450722426,
-0.0802686214,
-0.0115033211,
-0.084567301,
0.0179808252,
-0.0326748826,
0.0189582519,
-0.0083764093,
0.0126886237,
-0.0037270719,
-0.024903411,
-0.0831316039,
0.002916967,
-0.0006012638,
0.0158882122,
0.0219236463,
0.0109914476,
0.0153120467,
0.0210481528,
-0.0034511774,
-0.0278489199,
0.0556747317,
-0.0118484776,
0.0389302783,
-0.0487617031,
0.0321805589,
-0.0327218175,
0.0216112863,
0.0022746082,
0.0340555757,
0.0509127676,
-0.0311507601,
0.0578533188,
0.0693360344,
-0.0068214792,
-0.039056588,
0.040145319,
-0.0050944332,
-0.0691491589,
0.0515806451,
0.0097900331,
-0.0074891266,
-0.0017179467,
0.0000966531,
-0.0216828249,
0.0512435995,
-0.0128183914,
-0.0253126826,
-0.0661619976,
0.027149206,
-0.0061041885,
-0.0144119998,
-0.0755680576,
-0.0144311748,
-0.0052670385,
0.036259193,
-0.0068068313,
-0.0069761919,
0.1004418507,
-0.0042078779,
-0.0105444416,
-0.0576255582,
0.0063993684,
-0.0249022972,
0.0894501954,
-0.0429467112,
-0.0035393643,
0.0153551651,
-0.0222108867,
-0.0734917149,
0.0232076421,
-0.0088685136,
-0.0403030142,
0.0714921206,
-0.0702674836,
-0.0214564335,
-0.0037699204,
-0.0646233931,
-0.0618550815,
-0.0067608911,
-0.0445691012,
-0.0091130938,
-0.0198801514,
-0.0120863123,
0.0268380921,
-0.0248088315,
0.0491122045,
0.0260910038,
-0.0130334217,
-0.0102993716,
-0.0371363834,
0.0455684662,
0.0546413474,
0.0320400819,
0.0090252236,
-0.0097382003,
0.036614459,
0.0548250712,
0.0693990961,
-0.0116267996,
-0.0152811799,
0.0192059427,
0.0143868271,
-0.0083210329,
-0.0090524238,
0.0325936899,
0.0523328818,
-0.0587428957,
-0.0157466587,
0.1004889682,
0.0276951324,
-0.0685105249,
-0.0099751931,
-0.0534246713,
0.0539570078,
0.0239659995,
0.0527773015,
-0.1077792495,
-0.0364817455,
0.0364457332,
-0.019280171,
-0.0170964208,
-0.0606406964,
0.0056589427,
-0.1344216466,
0.0253078546,
-0.0266056042,
-0.0172284618,
0.0321877897,
-0.0135844024,
0.0292490181,
0.0390091389,
-0.022206163,
0.0145343179,
0.0225665979,
0.0026568247,
0.0312817506,
-0.0043593585,
-0.0299540721,
0.059611816,
-0.0271797162,
0.0204190966,
0.0183685385,
-0.0083380835,
0.0114260204,
-0.0584392063,
0.0366329923,
0.0085368184,
-0.0073757027,
-0.0201716963,
-0.0080833267,
0.0097122649,
-0.0098095229,
-0.0382483192,
0.073602356,
-0.0046674837,
-0.0224934462,
0.0433476046,
0.1340655237,
-0.0306334496,
-0.0254589897,
-0.0157754347,
-0.0240408536,
0.0247492306,
0.0662988126,
0.0156365149,
-0.0597194768,
-0.0070051965,
-0.0403471887,
-0.0548181273,
-0.0387110524,
-0.0408668742,
0.0104499236,
0.0460120663,
0.0342522152,
-0.0366157815,
-0.0246526953,
0.0666890293,
0.0806041881,
0.000201725,
-0.005716017,
0.0135160619,
0.0217812266,
-0.0236191936,
0.0435602739,
-0.0352616273,
0.0208418425,
-0.0536312498,
0.0037914172,
-0.0129100382,
-0.048666399,
-0.03165837,
0.022862304,
-0.0799495131,
-0.0443762094,
-0.0288720541,
0.03635481,
0.0290920027,
0.0247785877,
-0.0146549987,
-0.0268576909,
0.041370485,
-0.0058556236,
-0.0132975644,
-0.0093886452,
0.016085187,
0.0115473168,
-0.00400365,
0.0467501134,
-0.060537491,
-0.009976605,
0.0070670149,
0.0615167171,
-0.0126467431,
-0.0163337737,
0.0356496908,
0.0169356875,
0.0269999821,
0.0073881657,
0.000150718,
-0.0424554721,
0.0449153855,
-0.0123754069,
-0.0528390706,
-0.0371764041,
0.0268165581,
0.0013138244,
-0.0424498729,
0.021253733,
-0.049993895,
0.0014286977,
0.0261293352,
-0.0165067911,
-0.0187666249,
0.0435831361,
0.0367571823,
0.0523053259,
-0.02118266,
-0.0142857507,
-0.0208859164,
0.0144391265,
0.0546890274,
-0.0003550751,
0.1142764986,
0.0505324043,
-0.0295658652,
-0.0344253257,
0.0196837671,
-0.0708575025,
-0.0848830566,
0.0180026162,
0.0383956768,
0.0164332669,
0.0300445966,
-0.0363084339,
-0.0152190803,
-0.0279941652,
0.0293870308,
0.0293682907,
0.0286420304,
-0.0480580516,
0.0285433941,
0.0287789162,
0.0151377572,
0.0072730659,
0.0416140668,
-0.0416904837,
0.0121029979,
0.0138107287,
0.0164117962,
-0.0372907892,
-0.0300679598,
-0.0073516369,
0.0144150034,
0.0003873737,
0.0212505292,
-0.0803733692,
-0.0662568435,
-0.0191363972,
0.0148592032,
-0.0102791619,
-0.0044592377,
0.05303948,
0.0698610693,
0.0038705263,
-0.0458965115,
-0.0070542623,
0.0131263807,
0.0077836667,
-0.0431900434,
-0.0260379501,
-6.40121767e-33,
0.0018213313,
-0.0195519328,
0.0542213358,
-0.0377577171,
0.005827785,
0.0003407668,
-0.0229709391,
0.0136461388,
-0.0153009985,
0.0183348432,
-0.0463407487,
-0.0092615662,
0.009974164,
0.0205646232,
0.0276063792,
-0.0307758339,
0.0059070061,
-0.0127170328,
-0.0317503959,
0.0294010043,
0.0207552835,
-0.0027930702,
0.0125168404,
-0.0338601433,
0.0514724217,
-0.0083718421,
-0.0096840076,
0.0394571908,
-0.0592684634,
0.0190394484,
-0.0264136121,
0.0203733612,
0.0173180215,
-0.035649199,
0.0072220187,
0.0596404001,
-0.0554443598,
-0.0444795452,
0.0223705918,
-0.0315707661,
-0.1044013724,
-0.0147572709,
-0.0384254754,
0.0161255524,
0.0070275869,
-0.015763374,
-0.002219199,
0.0011353486,
0.0194354262,
0.0046444843,
-0.0033184933,
-0.0138797518,
-0.005727957,
-0.038215898,
-0.0114166401,
0.0874260888,
-0.0198462959,
-0.0037079786,
-0.025060961,
0.0306082089,
0.0155733339,
-0.0194244329,
0.0646604151,
0.0100130308,
-0.0185326356,
0.028990699,
-0.0114811147,
-0.0079891793,
-0.0478789061,
0.0027345642,
-0.0307859927,
0.0523192994,
0.0376170091,
0.0159030128,
0.0252834782,
0.0797290206,
-0.0609032698,
0.0186968055,
0.0571691357,
0.0126236044,
0.0152464537,
-0.0177134462,
-0.0438220836,
-0.0097852712,
-0.0403753109,
0.0320882276,
-0.0531099476,
-0.0243825763,
0.0468133949,
-0.0007278566,
-0.0221742,
-0.0130374683,
0.0292751621,
-0.0225213338,
-0.0195528381,
0.0183307026,
0.0073972619,
0.0222454593,
0.0045453729,
0.0320731029,
-0.0207297895,
-0.0064919614,
0.0204579961,
0.0030451755,
0.0134585043,
0.0201896206,
0.0298470557,
0.0154984547,
-0.0565404221,
-0.002885032,
-0.0684065893,
0.0302888807,
-0.0002349587,
-0.0003071338,
0.0183938034,
0.0131570576,
-0.0092978952,
0.0498443879,
-0.0088003352,
-0.0426233858,
-0.0334719755,
0.0303538553,
-0.0111035351,
0.0014229658,
-0.0004919303,
0.00304167,
-0.0172377285,
0.0059502786,
0.0124444114,
-0.0438815169,
-0.0049158349,
0.0347494632,
2.787e-7,
0.0008198991,
0.0014850374,
-0.0108564338,
0.0401368216,
-0.0138615025,
0.0253038146,
-0.005682969,
0.0190190077,
0.0407403968,
-0.0517409816,
-0.0032944644,
0.0496300273,
0.026968712,
0.0469757766,
-0.1085412949,
-0.0551935956,
-0.0190719292,
-0.0153228156,
-0.0593493879,
-0.0182660744,
0.0623178855,
0.0617745891,
0.0053331824,
-0.0094445571,
0.0218718126,
-0.032563746,
0.0281246323,
0.0022339283,
0.0010311219,
-0.0107586905,
0.0138853909,
-0.0019097101,
0.0172563214,
0.0403924137,
0.0188460425,
-0.0071304054,
0.0007360226,
0.0205064584,
0.030382432,
-0.0343624726,
-0.0504399464,
-0.0400164127,
0.0229783803,
-0.0460976772,
0.0904092416,
-0.0322565809,
-0.0054248329,
0.0163296517,
0.0345796645,
-0.0535613485,
-0.0169077888,
-0.0112169143,
0.0016440356,
-0.0070991716,
0.0083899079,
-0.0106532555,
0.030047996,
-0.0700202212,
-0.0292065497,
0.0134139154,
-0.0442554131,
-0.0359653085,
-0.0373851024,
0.0121063348,
0.0092788069,
-0.0825672746,
-0.013995328,
2.750452447e-34,
0.0174693409,
0.0037906379,
0.0421765819,
0.0326138847,
0.0316448398,
-0.0116873644,
-0.0416867919,
-0.0187253691,
0.0466136076,
-0.0931027904,
-0.0426118709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06684v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06684v1 | Learning Multiplex Embeddings on Text-rich Networks with One Text Encoder | 2023-10-10T14:59:22 | 2023-10-10T14:59:22 | Bowen Jin, Wentao Zhang, Yu Zhang, Yu Meng, Han Zhao, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In real-world scenarios, texts in a network are often linked by multiple
semantic relations (e.g., papers in an academic network are referenced by other
publications, written by the same author, or published in the same venue),
where text documents and their relations form a multiplex text-rich network.
Mainstream text representation learning methods use pretrained language models
(PLMs) to generate one embedding for each text unit, expecting that all types
of relations between texts can be captured by these single-view embeddings.
However, this presumption does not hold particularly in multiplex text-rich
networks. Along another line of work, multiplex graph neural networks (GNNs)
directly initialize node attributes as a feature vector for node representation
learning, but they cannot fully capture the semantics of the nodes' associated
texts. To bridge these gaps, we propose METERN, a new framework for learning
Multiplex Embeddings on TExt-Rich Networks. In contrast to existing methods,
METERN uses one text encoder to model the shared knowledge across relations and
leverages a small number of parameters per relation to derive relation-specific
representations. This allows the encoder to effectively capture the multiplex
structures in the network while also preserving parameter efficiency. We
conduct experiments on nine downstream tasks in five networks from both
academic and e-commerce domains, where METERN outperforms baselines
significantly and consistently. The code is available at
https://github.com/PeterGriffinJin/METERN-submit. | [
0.0007267518,
0.05176799,
0.0298941657,
0.0429547988,
0.0093486588,
-0.0126781007,
0.0166106801,
0.0125455819,
0.0206916742,
-0.0565600023,
-0.0284620542,
0.0402029268,
-0.0264064725,
0.0275004003,
0.0394774452,
0.0021810683,
0.016134331,
0.0369470567,
0.0319475308,
-0.0275057834,
0.0455942489,
0.0557900444,
0.0416284539,
0.0037057789,
-0.0043971245,
-0.0400259048,
0.0352141038,
-0.007724735,
0.0170474816,
-0.0247102547,
-0.01001056,
0.028344946,
0.0528134517,
-0.0010856908,
0.0000017622,
-0.0041655544,
-0.0016979681,
-0.0000860345,
0.0056872829,
0.0087149488,
0.0335455984,
-0.0207600314,
0.0814321488,
-0.0044253208,
-0.0364270285,
-0.0312148444,
0.0081012277,
0.0594393499,
0.0063840849,
0.0523366965,
-0.0383704305,
-0.0213448741,
0.0190225039,
-0.0304217096,
0.0009808985,
-0.0261393972,
0.0109286513,
-0.0003685942,
-0.0139249843,
0.0678368881,
-0.0190751441,
0.0225494877,
0.0271060653,
-0.009373364,
0.0328472108,
0.0613744482,
0.0750294328,
0.0460186079,
0.0242665038,
0.1299364716,
-0.0276129879,
0.0089228442,
-0.0021626425,
-0.0323604345,
0.0010318231,
0.014945088,
-0.0355395302,
-0.0230588,
-0.0010655556,
0.0102087054,
-0.053389363,
0.0259812754,
0.0813141465,
0.0104319239,
-0.0078068622,
0.0269957576,
0.0020339908,
-0.0096915839,
0.0190339759,
0.0064467648,
-0.0000193629,
0.0175588168,
0.0119013991,
0.0201091412,
-0.0091994628,
0.0213743057,
-0.0079250298,
-0.021878371,
0.0229060464,
-0.0585496053,
-0.0049040602,
0.0037518302,
0.0026591413,
0.0507990867,
-0.0703501925,
0.0007912371,
-0.0414777137,
0.0231726542,
-0.0408180952,
0.0046749152,
-0.0394778736,
-0.017216159,
-0.0070901485,
0.0533254892,
0.0126753822,
-0.0708877146,
-0.0006080052,
0.0133698806,
-0.0256109964,
0.0140794972,
-0.0168876667,
0.0641057864,
0.0087616909,
-0.0095374826,
0.0374602973,
0.0573708676,
-0.0444355607,
0.0312312711,
-0.0159433987,
0.0489284471,
-0.0022266337,
0.0047275294,
0.0398628712,
-0.040155191,
-0.0162010472,
0.0485540964,
0.0193283912,
-0.0305601899,
-0.0086288005,
-0.0523173586,
0.011812916,
-0.0396279171,
0.0487902164,
-0.0524221696,
0.0690779015,
0.0071596256,
-0.0037245245,
-0.0573461317,
0.0215086844,
-0.0142366486,
-0.0798631907,
0.0328959264,
-0.0047327606,
-0.0263372827,
0.0106824953,
0.0270520337,
0.0207653083,
0.050435029,
0.023979865,
0.0081724208,
0.0394387431,
-0.0028774894,
-0.0343254842,
-0.0008505562,
0.0537415482,
-0.0342672765,
0.0200541671,
-0.0121968566,
0.0004403575,
0.0454644226,
0.0458925441,
0.0201793481,
-0.0637629852,
-0.0292550772,
0.0167887919,
0.0196045954,
0.0041901511,
0.0116587542,
0.051735539,
0.0029445889,
-0.0103340596,
-0.0208166707,
-0.0092858709,
0.0367829278,
0.0250227321,
-0.003981045,
0.0266586319,
0.0180950295,
-0.0470429882,
0.030337574,
0.0512920022,
-0.0238772184,
0.027516596,
-0.0069016838,
0.07063476,
0.0173715316,
-0.0317412913,
0.0302533135,
0.0391049162,
-0.0077200518,
0.0225169901,
0.0330826417,
-0.0127517879,
0.0309920069,
0.0613861531,
-0.0296861324,
-0.0043993318,
-0.0468744785,
0.0059230179,
-0.0142197357,
0.0354855768,
-0.036793299,
0.0089600235,
-0.0579018705,
-0.059881635,
-0.0278154295,
0.0082506649,
0.0298718829,
-0.0095990384,
0.009675175,
0.0389957093,
-0.0023897942,
0.0085579706,
0.0120997,
-0.033565402,
0.0190597083,
0.0167381279,
0.0069786534,
-0.0091212997,
0.0572100617,
-0.0090395389,
0.0080894176,
0.0252495613,
-0.0349325985,
-0.019000344,
-0.0042748451,
-0.078830719,
-0.0353672467,
0.052828677,
-0.0571485832,
0.003073009,
0.0231698137,
-0.0397574939,
-0.0441687219,
0.0645303279,
-0.0258301627,
0.0282475315,
-0.0080174496,
-0.0677817613,
-0.0171260964,
0.0220682696,
0.032400243,
0.0346502401,
-0.0278742686,
0.0497422256,
-0.0070182849,
-0.0310369972,
0.0280180704,
0.0002381227,
-0.0355159044,
-0.0319364518,
0.0105376597,
0.0196497682,
0.0296072848,
-0.0141296424,
-0.0213578865,
-0.0011399831,
-0.0427224338,
0.0033711877,
0.0091667799,
-0.0160472933,
0.0115286708,
-0.004343709,
0.0550446026,
-0.0238308031,
-0.0743316114,
0.0265038442,
-0.0248087253,
0.0155524816,
0.0423169658,
-0.0165914856,
0.0034511962,
-0.0272400361,
-0.0490173846,
-0.0324130878,
0.115420714,
0.0037954457,
-0.0374305733,
-0.0037272351,
0.0067453235,
-0.0402536653,
-0.0297858883,
-0.0528704114,
0.0434587039,
-0.0104959058,
-0.0134087484,
0.014476289,
0.032109648,
-0.0246333983,
0.0535239838,
0.0276774578,
0.0204734243,
-0.0810479298,
-0.0203835219,
-0.0588477589,
0.0741577893,
-0.052597113,
0.0088551585,
-0.0339919142,
0.0146648986,
0.0051649204,
-0.0441355631,
-0.0157137457,
-0.014055022,
0.0027996199,
-0.0129397102,
-0.0497345775,
-0.0198448375,
0.0404132977,
-0.0407490097,
-0.0242536198,
0.0066900519,
0.0472965129,
-0.01141968,
0.0027509858,
0.0164360348,
-0.0120369634,
-0.0444117896,
0.0300108381,
0.0343089662,
0.0565467887,
-0.0107835643,
-0.0255202577,
-0.0180087574,
0.0215342157,
0.0186171271,
-0.018907316,
0.0071827839,
0.0431236289,
-0.0066243731,
-0.0388064496,
-0.0253011938,
0.0165968165,
-0.020793166,
-0.0042213802,
0.0531479158,
0.0119002815,
-0.0031476831,
-0.0387398861,
-0.0401975475,
0.0071754646,
0.0236474685,
-0.0225599147,
-0.01777713,
-0.0311174002,
0.0713966936,
0.0443298295,
-0.0297663305,
0.0060890317,
-0.0164018348,
-0.0122027863,
0.0707389489,
-0.0389228687,
-0.0130354613,
-0.0525718518,
0.0050656646,
-0.0231494848,
-0.0145034492,
0.0206621867,
-0.0331012942,
0.0125343418,
-0.026636282,
-0.0071329493,
0.0609620437,
0.0351423733,
-0.0812377855,
-0.0166854151,
-0.0001047083,
0.0166249443,
0.034317337,
0.0176205263,
-0.1083369702,
0.0006178033,
-0.017794814,
-0.0004405635,
0.060178563,
-0.0339371972,
-0.0142069859,
-0.0455996431,
-0.0310892537,
0.0089636967,
-0.0154208606,
-0.020842813,
-0.0698819309,
-0.0252116639,
0.0022506262,
0.0028624532,
-0.0073841191,
0.0105013354,
-0.0241123661,
-0.0012762523,
-0.0124024022,
-0.0384947993,
0.0149296112,
-0.0411937349,
0.0411287323,
-0.0167967714,
0.032073658,
-0.0234860759,
-0.0086597502,
0.0019958226,
0.0111294547,
-0.0376711078,
-0.0049046222,
0.0731828213,
-0.0208013132,
0.0157499611,
-0.0308108851,
0.035754595,
-0.0713278875,
-0.0165997781,
-0.0315204635,
0.0863022655,
0.0183348376,
-0.0506123155,
-0.0391364545,
-0.0269741137,
-0.0151580032,
0.0131271156,
0.0306158885,
-0.0309546348,
-0.0480506085,
-0.0469425172,
0.0311785322,
-0.0246226415,
-0.0252763499,
-0.0110062566,
-0.0207018852,
0.0334333219,
-0.0356895365,
-0.0523815714,
0.0239814892,
0.0102320034,
0.0005968696,
-0.0202059746,
0.0286792405,
-0.0584624149,
-0.0319746695,
-0.0160199981,
-0.0221158396,
0.0251073372,
0.0391824469,
0.0486978255,
0.0626205727,
-0.0306088701,
-0.0413383693,
-0.0361071154,
-0.048519861,
-0.0600538254,
-0.0731600896,
0.0135274027,
0.0024911719,
0.0442905128,
-0.0352683291,
-0.0299774446,
0.0520774238,
0.0247719567,
-0.0483711883,
0.0019467503,
0.0447081178,
-0.0280530248,
-0.0121911196,
0.0288512148,
-0.0607894436,
0.0396697186,
0.0028041226,
0.0341890268,
-0.0300227031,
-0.0564602017,
-0.0090145888,
0.0053776661,
0.0132262306,
0.0441038124,
0.0708647892,
-0.0949275568,
-0.0111162523,
-0.0092551792,
-0.0049535753,
-0.0385958962,
0.0264095161,
0.0393531062,
-0.0161399078,
-0.017830288,
-0.0245319884,
0.0778404772,
0.0465872437,
0.002873275,
-0.0261980314,
0.0218887236,
-0.0237830076,
-0.0031568187,
0.0249214265,
-0.0377813987,
0.0187342539,
-0.0246796645,
-0.0195161738,
-0.0516571291,
0.0137127899,
0.0377232023,
-0.0079082511,
-0.0534593016,
-0.001393145,
-0.0569455028,
0.0101577658,
-0.0307876915,
-0.0206201952,
0.0770819187,
0.0233704578,
0.05494681,
-0.0155517124,
-0.0036336833,
-0.0127236107,
0.0480479822,
-0.0301068854,
-0.0382170379,
0.0440074503,
0.0129046831,
-0.0129854325,
-0.0034893444,
0.0935688764,
0.0193659402,
0.0303583834,
-0.0068349834,
-0.0404200517,
-0.0412120186,
-0.0192880668,
0.0133518567,
0.060542386,
-0.0188042484,
-0.0100108003,
0.0055700797,
-0.0432755128,
0.0265020784,
-0.0168592427,
-0.0343544856,
0.0347029045,
-0.0040289797,
0.014717822,
0.0232533235,
0.0107450821,
-0.021400582,
0.0114879962,
-0.0032164266,
-0.0478500575,
0.0160498917,
-6.033076349e-33,
0.0139246695,
-0.0318092518,
-0.0177822951,
0.0073461803,
-0.0457895324,
0.0230634008,
-0.0396404937,
-0.0167935751,
-0.0528255366,
0.0430054329,
-0.0011886794,
0.0000190228,
-0.0321188942,
0.0224182159,
0.0107374433,
-0.0044376096,
0.0208736248,
-0.0149982367,
0.0472635478,
0.0590031259,
0.0516176037,
0.0193248093,
0.050228592,
-0.1044459566,
0.017182555,
-0.0407574512,
0.001583791,
0.0136775756,
0.0218937304,
0.0413121507,
-0.0503866859,
0.0445618667,
0.0399814434,
-0.0237755068,
-0.0262604058,
0.0357629061,
-0.1309412122,
-0.0468256176,
-0.043229185,
-0.0107725216,
-0.0379653275,
-0.0318541899,
0.0520279035,
0.0192413088,
0.0887063965,
-0.0535690486,
0.0722532794,
0.0205788109,
-0.057777103,
-0.045360554,
-0.0214777645,
0.0165350102,
-0.0051122592,
0.0418767072,
0.017724406,
0.0117373243,
0.04367036,
0.0463563651,
-0.0624682233,
-0.0081802113,
-0.0712844655,
-0.0101286927,
-0.012222874,
-0.0338357501,
-0.0138121434,
0.0659764633,
-0.0029287534,
-0.0205454491,
-0.0036626903,
0.0226055309,
0.0150825223,
0.0430192761,
0.029296184,
0.0650078282,
-0.0002844917,
-0.0447726026,
-0.0940193459,
-0.0189708658,
0.0121392393,
-0.0087606469,
0.0393327475,
0.0190890692,
0.0187653322,
-0.0386964343,
-0.0353581794,
-0.0178361852,
-0.0408859551,
-0.0395262651,
-0.0094015365,
0.0252172295,
0.0061657103,
0.0646310896,
0.0338786989,
-0.0848427862,
-0.0856399536,
0.0896428823,
0.0042294837,
0.0343766883,
0.0196704604,
0.0095283529,
-0.0666334853,
-0.0279235393,
0.0190142691,
-0.0492876135,
0.0016595133,
0.0057364735,
0.1030470654,
-0.0051810276,
-0.0452557616,
-0.0065866304,
-0.0257822461,
-0.0691564828,
-0.0039806026,
0.024290856,
0.0154793076,
0.0323932171,
-0.0202093199,
0.0415668897,
0.0659264028,
0.0089233676,
-0.0112841753,
0.0179482382,
0.0376207083,
0.0375828408,
-0.0080220895,
-0.0348659828,
-0.0366023518,
0.0107010324,
0.0600751601,
-0.0475217514,
-0.0023300841,
0.0093742562,
2.537e-7,
0.0676146597,
0.0138024809,
0.0236969441,
-0.0068065049,
0.0296536591,
0.0328634232,
-0.0038324005,
0.0930869579,
-0.0277366545,
0.007668741,
0.0247673206,
0.0180510134,
-0.0134848412,
0.0364631675,
-0.0555231795,
-0.0013197911,
-0.0929837748,
-0.0467066839,
-0.0307317749,
-0.0372385494,
0.0307910573,
0.0518025793,
0.0381167158,
0.0145484451,
0.0053616161,
-0.0656050295,
0.0881394446,
-0.0082955724,
0.0341761187,
0.0256664623,
0.0124756237,
0.0184797887,
-0.0492647886,
-0.0303033609,
-0.0098958472,
0.0524507314,
0.0344985165,
0.0612480454,
0.0006864063,
-0.018760711,
0.0399659947,
-0.0273014661,
0.0163243916,
-0.0140105113,
0.0294423997,
-0.0590855628,
-0.0193622876,
-0.0174185392,
-0.0309079364,
-0.0072299372,
0.0410895906,
0.0220403019,
0.0441494584,
0.0131576732,
-0.0013257476,
-0.0107992589,
0.0041535506,
-0.11183431,
0.0026213229,
0.0198772289,
-0.032738328,
-0.0151949478,
0.0049219113,
-0.0145235946,
0.0744368061,
-0.0341880508,
0.0338152274,
1.922428372e-34,
0.0131232804,
-0.0252501536,
-0.0093884943,
0.0566205084,
-0.0085937474,
-0.0456485264,
-0.0206219107,
-0.0238942932,
0.0249518678,
-0.0774405599,
-0.0053350134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06675v2 | SEER : A Knapsack approach to Exemplar Selection for In-Context HybridQA | 2023-10-10T14:50:20 | 2023-10-20T08:02:25 | Jonathan Tonglet, Manon Reusens, Philipp Borchert, Bart Baesens | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering over hybrid contexts is a complex task, which requires the
combination of information extracted from unstructured texts and structured
tables in various ways. Recently, In-Context Learning demonstrated significant
performance advances for reasoning tasks. In this paradigm, a large language
model performs predictions based on a small set of supporting exemplars. The
performance of In-Context Learning depends heavily on the selection procedure
of the supporting exemplars, particularly in the case of HybridQA, where
considering the diversity of reasoning chains and the large size of the hybrid
contexts becomes crucial. In this work, we present Selection of ExEmplars for
hybrid Reasoning (SEER), a novel method for selecting a set of exemplars that
is both representative and diverse. The key novelty of SEER is that it
formulates exemplar selection as a Knapsack Integer Linear Program. The
Knapsack framework provides the flexibility to incorporate diversity
constraints that prioritize exemplars with desirable attributes, and capacity
constraints that ensure that the prompt size respects the provided capacity
budgets. The effectiveness of SEER is demonstrated on FinQA and TAT-QA, two
real-world benchmarks for HybridQA, where it outperforms previous exemplar
selection methods. | [
0.0098523349,
0.0229652803,
-0.0022348906,
0.0141904168,
-0.0264377724,
0.0353830159,
0.0064000017,
0.01120672,
0.0005459348,
-0.0424783081,
-0.0104393335,
-0.0145443426,
-0.0510066748,
0.0348791443,
0.0226098523,
0.0036371564,
0.0387430824,
-0.0132360142,
-0.0028937934,
-0.018924186,
0.0021668694,
0.0223497264,
-0.0218396503,
0.0142762363,
0.0104934378,
-0.0200431868,
-0.0073482888,
-0.0132844131,
0.0177538693,
0.0239718836,
0.0289399419,
0.0387001298,
0.0389058962,
-0.036745619,
0.0000020089,
-0.0383483842,
-0.0741811097,
-0.0215903129,
-0.0686445087,
-0.0127851274,
-0.0122296494,
0.0032120361,
0.0453641675,
0.0143430466,
-0.0319103785,
0.000110064,
0.0200486481,
0.0518796146,
0.0421589501,
0.0416299775,
0.0099725854,
-0.0057550948,
-0.0235288311,
0.0202563014,
0.021287946,
-0.0400697514,
0.0095378375,
0.0034129573,
0.0542227253,
-0.0105566997,
0.0045131426,
0.0205052029,
0.0530469455,
0.024080554,
0.0101947878,
0.0350935757,
-0.0590203479,
0.0664813668,
0.0131179737,
0.0970071107,
0.0050735734,
-0.0486121178,
0.0160273183,
-0.0306703616,
0.0045046117,
-0.0155579783,
-0.0371816643,
0.0158418305,
-0.0533870421,
-0.0056361272,
0.0274016913,
0.0320184343,
0.0081181424,
0.0176733248,
-0.0686756,
0.0747208074,
-0.0041078292,
-0.0358290114,
0.0201311279,
0.0032268632,
-0.0474991016,
-0.0090265563,
-0.0071288259,
0.0547704995,
-0.0744439587,
0.0227421615,
0.0317978859,
-0.0346262231,
0.0046153567,
-0.0309512857,
-0.0015520782,
0.0632491484,
0.0136522427,
0.0728602782,
-0.0158323962,
0.0215972047,
-0.0299985316,
-0.0092788246,
-0.0317987911,
-0.0502789915,
-0.0682224408,
-0.0088946065,
-0.0527166091,
0.0397908427,
-0.0583273396,
-0.0343624167,
-0.0052303253,
0.0305623114,
-0.0059659574,
-0.0095495442,
0.0175678357,
0.0323710553,
-0.0097848335,
0.013496791,
-0.0242256019,
-0.0094807511,
-0.0733320192,
0.0169564988,
-0.0068060225,
-0.0344811007,
-0.0406282581,
-0.0008753898,
0.0112699987,
-0.0744208321,
0.001734385,
0.0735760406,
-0.0418420956,
-0.0314972512,
-0.017328741,
-0.0320876166,
-0.0091199949,
-0.048433058,
-0.0262830351,
-0.0613143332,
0.0606021695,
0.0146000506,
0.005732941,
-0.0034037596,
0.0005454383,
0.0278100353,
0.023158079,
0.0376991667,
0.0370796174,
-0.0238258839,
0.0054681753,
0.006272384,
-0.0496720746,
0.119952336,
0.0025129644,
-0.0325741656,
0.010747971,
0.0250168648,
-0.0122027816,
0.0280578826,
0.0390895568,
0.0175767951,
0.0067689717,
0.068388097,
0.0465979986,
0.0257800929,
-0.0330127887,
0.0050193518,
-0.0424853861,
-0.0053070034,
-0.0073646847,
0.0009955176,
0.0318151563,
0.0230687242,
-0.0133264717,
-0.0124184666,
0.0296207536,
-0.0287725851,
0.0011167222,
0.0501408726,
-0.0368630067,
0.002454733,
0.0315683112,
0.0308262985,
-0.0422105975,
-0.0244871136,
-0.0133443484,
0.0287692249,
0.0020227262,
0.0404078923,
0.0366748832,
0.0015389941,
-0.0535892174,
0.0376106948,
0.0137075307,
-0.0013363723,
-0.0163576473,
0.0027712537,
0.0412951782,
0.036527399,
0.0276878588,
-0.0852795169,
0.0018527197,
-0.0396561921,
-0.0074161417,
-0.033024922,
-0.0077238097,
-0.0524039939,
0.0193092674,
-0.0287914723,
-0.0459270105,
-0.0155288503,
0.000204951,
-0.0317525603,
0.0475132391,
0.0361021385,
-0.025304608,
-0.0830167159,
0.0485734344,
0.0216368511,
-0.0117188813,
-0.0316045545,
0.0144882919,
-0.0001959346,
0.0205774903,
0.0123645999,
0.0316734947,
0.0088019054,
0.004843493,
-0.0588246249,
-0.0402406491,
-0.0045016254,
-0.04526015,
-0.0501256101,
0.020700017,
-0.0139731569,
-0.0147283226,
-0.0268632639,
-0.0510708094,
-0.0577555597,
-0.0022097724,
-0.025832193,
0.0145524712,
-0.0414252467,
-0.045524314,
0.0237435549,
-0.0055607152,
-0.0298334341,
0.1189586222,
-0.0036673632,
0.0064580934,
0.0160159171,
-0.0764399096,
0.0055660405,
-0.0531547032,
0.0317735337,
-0.0130576361,
0.0160841253,
0.0087421481,
-0.0037045176,
-0.0013330241,
-0.0673588887,
0.0040476522,
-0.1019150168,
0.039358981,
-0.0560994856,
0.0201053973,
0.0205215439,
0.0203091055,
0.0064346227,
0.0139827747,
-0.0441756397,
-0.0108736008,
0.0010418547,
0.0170599781,
0.023397943,
0.0433160998,
0.0222673789,
0.0037484181,
-0.0161937922,
-0.0119710527,
0.07478223,
-0.0073160143,
-0.0210853163,
0.008445845,
-0.0365770459,
-0.012823048,
-0.0052760341,
-0.0093411589,
0.0502016097,
-0.0356509797,
0.0069063562,
-0.0203066207,
0.0126059772,
-0.0313655809,
-0.000373072,
0.0013058886,
0.020000428,
-0.0606106371,
0.0452812128,
-0.0075152311,
0.0500557236,
0.0106111914,
-0.0002072706,
0.0380560756,
0.0138726719,
-0.0128242401,
-0.009494842,
-0.0638663843,
0.0522571243,
-0.0053945011,
-0.0011766719,
-0.0942213535,
0.0235402863,
0.0244534537,
0.0615273044,
-0.0036709879,
0.0167969316,
0.0584951937,
0.0376306027,
0.0093041481,
-0.0711961314,
0.0070995209,
-0.0827872828,
0.0268506352,
-0.0294523146,
0.011011227,
-0.031994503,
0.0102071278,
-0.0350440033,
-0.0205461979,
0.0067384299,
-0.0077046654,
0.0910752043,
-0.0318417959,
0.039257098,
0.017328456,
-0.0467417911,
-0.0199821945,
-0.0101111419,
-0.0269041657,
0.0433139279,
-0.0150787635,
0.0094053689,
0.0023458935,
-0.0174899008,
0.0113376798,
0.037558239,
-0.0113968505,
-0.0055145854,
-0.0103715593,
0.029418638,
0.0541906096,
0.0271283127,
0.0152041288,
-0.0247522257,
0.0361392945,
0.033852201,
0.0307136588,
-0.0363206677,
0.0269548744,
0.0277258381,
0.0135750854,
-0.0258336589,
-0.0250517521,
0.0248472299,
0.0223657079,
-0.0451174714,
-0.0372906812,
0.0790849328,
0.0404920876,
-0.0215528179,
-0.000051992,
-0.0445144102,
0.035387069,
0.0253570508,
0.0535740554,
-0.1276690662,
-0.0465404987,
-0.0156360436,
0.0071023745,
0.0029439689,
-0.0620406233,
0.0163404457,
-0.1011565775,
0.0279265605,
-0.0135636628,
-0.1299042851,
-0.0195609909,
-0.0145579772,
0.0128615387,
-0.0399214663,
0.010711222,
0.0220635217,
-0.0185080636,
0.0189990848,
0.0212419555,
0.0118348356,
-0.0244426541,
0.0412465669,
-0.0115516856,
-0.0122897848,
0.0123089645,
0.010984947,
-0.0087637044,
-0.0294845682,
0.0489009432,
-0.0728200525,
-0.0046026707,
-0.0235352106,
-0.006026098,
0.0037867608,
-0.0066728396,
0.021610653,
0.0529898629,
-0.0550473593,
-0.0264439955,
0.0492216088,
0.1212868318,
-0.020701969,
-0.0082696965,
0.0175678916,
-0.0473634042,
0.0162250809,
0.0839385167,
0.0241557118,
-0.0136510171,
-0.0544930436,
-0.0124548515,
-0.0613739826,
-0.0441535115,
0.0302116796,
0.0421834104,
0.0388673283,
0.0475408807,
-0.0532426871,
-0.0059255473,
0.0700481161,
0.0763099492,
-0.0265466962,
0.0532675274,
-0.0352514982,
0.0129539846,
-0.0335736871,
0.0040771738,
-0.0458453707,
0.01362703,
0.028993424,
-0.0053612073,
-0.0183304641,
-0.0519004315,
-0.0385472551,
-0.0021770722,
-0.0298581719,
-0.0240960885,
-0.020202551,
0.014481172,
0.019293705,
0.0450959355,
-0.0037657607,
-0.0371282697,
0.0500372536,
-0.0039585629,
-0.0191860087,
-0.0010150491,
0.0217717644,
-0.0193693396,
-0.0071349288,
0.0380087122,
-0.0681355819,
-0.0209097862,
0.0083277477,
0.0724083632,
-0.0181660075,
0.0104748663,
0.0359282233,
-0.0428030156,
-0.0647150874,
0.0405600183,
-0.0479955561,
-0.0324940793,
0.0447319187,
0.0062625054,
-0.0346621685,
-0.0181944333,
0.0298231151,
-0.0075610681,
-0.039147716,
0.0044458038,
-0.0154714994,
0.0040729097,
0.0665630326,
-0.0063211778,
0.0116002429,
0.0795684159,
-0.0192293432,
0.0089377975,
-0.042046614,
-0.012231173,
-0.0212613214,
0.0203525051,
0.0673204958,
-0.0071011689,
0.0473610274,
0.0534670092,
0.006564423,
-0.058099784,
-0.0139910541,
-0.0580894016,
-0.0498062037,
-0.0089813592,
-0.0137125757,
-0.0080651138,
-0.0169248544,
0.0005244243,
-0.0019048472,
-0.042991057,
0.0051237801,
0.0075458395,
0.0349574275,
-0.009431826,
0.0474735796,
0.0449942797,
-0.0039847777,
0.0067239846,
0.0586052053,
-0.014675539,
0.0441338457,
0.0127260666,
0.0198711604,
-0.0469717197,
-0.0227683373,
-0.0195615701,
0.0484554656,
0.0124897407,
0.006333591,
-0.0418669581,
-0.0372330956,
0.0470136926,
0.0030456099,
-0.0526822954,
-0.0060418476,
0.0603430681,
0.0342375003,
0.0561210439,
-0.0273589678,
-0.0085000331,
-0.0062271822,
0.0070359372,
-0.0104884971,
-0.0036933657,
-6.224205119e-33,
0.0066343541,
0.0020254359,
0.0249551013,
-0.0726001337,
0.032947015,
0.008260712,
-0.0432075821,
-0.0351775736,
-0.0046113906,
-0.0218582526,
-0.0240181126,
0.0134457257,
0.0011426692,
0.0288640354,
-0.0030427007,
-0.0531924181,
-0.0224194992,
0.0068518245,
-0.0358347781,
0.022576509,
0.0308973286,
-0.0033814863,
0.0296934955,
-0.0195055343,
0.0186517611,
-0.0007193661,
0.0110086016,
0.0219038874,
-0.0193714686,
0.0665524453,
-0.0214315597,
0.0195910018,
0.0313363783,
-0.0707487762,
0.0094042178,
0.0167350285,
-0.1070321873,
-0.0462560765,
0.0349717662,
-0.0152435526,
-0.0431278571,
-0.031937927,
-0.011271283,
0.0000797312,
0.0315965675,
-0.0291054118,
0.018279884,
-0.0332214981,
-0.0093765203,
-0.064915061,
-0.0196712464,
0.0213579293,
-0.0480775312,
0.0624372698,
-0.0193135124,
0.0822333023,
-0.0168499388,
0.0101176128,
-0.0227510724,
-0.0298529044,
0.0089696143,
-0.019328868,
0.0414463431,
-0.0159079153,
0.0246580038,
0.0236883834,
-0.0291900076,
-0.0200261232,
-0.0486949459,
-0.0299978592,
-0.0324725136,
0.0145561565,
0.0601408407,
0.0474083647,
0.0470012277,
0.0405169837,
-0.1105018333,
0.0051864381,
0.0507173762,
-0.0007269345,
0.0337811857,
0.0002468188,
-0.0457865074,
-0.0500592254,
-0.052627787,
0.0308638867,
-0.0421330743,
-0.0153403925,
0.0469726063,
0.0014978566,
-0.0194984619,
0.0105836717,
0.0267201029,
-0.0317209288,
-0.0206341427,
0.0538777672,
0.0006336813,
-0.0140883066,
0.0422662906,
0.0548593737,
-0.0364586934,
-0.017152641,
0.0273851696,
-0.0221596528,
0.0337069035,
0.0014971078,
0.0269047767,
-0.0106943697,
-0.0478399545,
-0.0045546982,
-0.0470946059,
0.0644001737,
0.000822817,
0.0373949483,
0.0245160274,
0.0466747098,
0.0047027692,
0.0446095616,
0.014423036,
-0.0289700683,
-0.0055097998,
-0.0029384098,
-0.024753876,
-0.0141076986,
0.0175549779,
0.0157654267,
-0.0014689242,
0.0109895188,
-0.0260796137,
-0.0396187045,
0.005543387,
0.0619339496,
2.61e-7,
0.0701995119,
0.0118949255,
0.0050896988,
-0.0025728554,
0.006181553,
0.007490905,
0.0102618244,
0.0120698856,
-0.0290702153,
-0.0588942878,
0.0262843445,
0.0475094579,
0.0352897532,
0.0363190435,
-0.0517997332,
-0.0029318144,
-0.0411804728,
-0.0181301478,
-0.0479353331,
-0.0148239378,
0.0654677302,
0.0970860571,
-0.0227866936,
-0.0149332359,
-0.0106787803,
-0.0335175544,
0.0484760441,
-0.023440117,
0.0342681855,
-0.0099426992,
0.0018664509,
-0.0201423876,
0.0269657318,
0.0641395599,
0.0116022732,
0.0452169031,
0.0112869171,
0.0517144203,
0.0117003741,
-0.0506490991,
0.0034417436,
-0.0420733355,
0.036859408,
-0.061544694,
0.144765079,
-0.0358973891,
0.0013337363,
0.0261129625,
-0.0121654812,
-0.0308277719,
0.039808169,
0.0277564917,
0.0131071499,
0.0398081355,
0.0149304215,
0.0008268571,
0.0237514917,
-0.082433179,
0.0051869261,
0.0145392213,
-0.0290192142,
0.0099177957,
-0.0057734638,
0.034860421,
0.0126211904,
-0.0468126684,
0.0125843044,
2.538337706e-34,
0.0288331043,
0.0128030619,
0.0305415094,
0.0753464922,
0.0166152101,
-0.0370903984,
-0.0132500483,
-0.0112389205,
0.044041615,
-0.077194646,
0.0007119527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06671v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06671v2 | Making Large Language Models Perform Better in Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-10-10T14:47:09 | 2024-04-14T05:30:19 | Yichi Zhang, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Yajing Xu, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language model (LLM) based knowledge graph completion (KGC) aims to
predict the missing triples in the KGs with LLMs. However, research about
LLM-based KGC fails to sufficiently harness LLMs' inference proficiencies,
overlooking critical structural information integral to KGs. In this paper, we
explore methods to incorporate structural information into the LLMs, with the
overarching goal of facilitating structure-aware reasoning. We first discuss on
the existing LLM paradigms like in-context learning and instruction tuning,
proposing basic structural information injection approaches. Then we propose a
Knowledge Prefix Adapter (KoPA) to fulfill this stated goal. The KoPA uses a
structural pre-training phase to comprehend the intricate entities and
relations within KGs, representing them as structural embeddings. Then KoPA
communicates such cross-modal structural information understanding to the LLMs
through a knowledge prefix adapter which projects the structural embeddings
into the textual space and obtains virtual knowledge tokens positioned as a
prefix of the input prompt. We conduct comprehensive experiments and provide
incisive analysis concerning how the introduction of cross-modal structural
information would be better for LLM's factual knowledge reasoning ability. Our
code and data are available at https://github.com/zjukg/KoPA . | [
0.0447664484,
-0.0000786464,
-0.0235272236,
0.0656401515,
0.0060145706,
-0.00451307,
-0.047633227,
-0.0006204513,
0.0744359642,
-0.0437518433,
0.0005212361,
0.0131543009,
-0.010607441,
0.0334069133,
0.0323410407,
-0.0307901017,
0.0517174676,
-0.0311634373,
-0.0134879528,
-0.0176310167,
-0.0326022804,
0.0250382144,
-0.0026031376,
-0.0084910924,
-0.0211283844,
-0.0098141683,
-0.0134192631,
-0.0070313006,
-0.0256752688,
-0.0383645222,
-0.0228556916,
0.0012284811,
0.0305342283,
-0.015818445,
0.0000022052,
-0.0338414125,
0.0068435208,
-0.0143091492,
-0.0626625419,
-0.0110517498,
-0.0116284564,
-0.0094562545,
0.0329541489,
-0.0092304833,
-0.039574869,
-0.0112585602,
0.0323413759,
0.0596516728,
0.0156107759,
0.0485509448,
-0.0064014434,
-0.0061243474,
0.0381150767,
-0.0131408889,
0.0406874195,
-0.0113364458,
0.0323872566,
0.0538771898,
0.0293627735,
0.0695149899,
-0.0336036198,
0.040409375,
0.0234643985,
0.0058925138,
0.055443339,
0.0414123125,
0.0202835668,
0.0016812049,
0.0114848427,
0.0907328501,
0.0377245173,
0.0013632072,
-0.0137065677,
0.0102155972,
0.0111754583,
0.0281059425,
-0.0427732095,
-0.0110225799,
-0.021749435,
-0.0062195272,
0.0073097697,
-0.0408063605,
0.0543868057,
-0.0002697533,
-0.0424281172,
0.0893369466,
0.0165908374,
-0.0309299249,
0.0141530419,
0.0077545443,
-0.0113341985,
-0.0584422089,
-0.0057537532,
0.0514430515,
-0.0308151171,
0.0524551943,
-0.0304278564,
-0.0079108011,
-0.001304575,
-0.03073439,
-0.0054283193,
0.0430505201,
-0.0057579679,
0.0762188658,
-0.0855802074,
0.0260932408,
-0.0176252089,
0.029500315,
-0.0688926578,
-0.0247703958,
-0.0542731099,
-0.02047587,
-0.0138423219,
0.046655912,
-0.0434041731,
-0.0379450433,
-0.0089018503,
0.0650658011,
-0.0087640136,
0.0407665409,
0.0169427879,
-0.0049979561,
0.0044414396,
-0.0247861817,
-0.0594988205,
0.0424814932,
-0.0439701416,
0.0220968369,
-0.0401304923,
0.0034531548,
-0.0056730378,
0.0006905408,
-0.0036905135,
-0.0240017679,
0.0254376605,
0.048437506,
-0.0078673707,
-0.0231785607,
-0.0525628217,
-0.0607563183,
-0.002634912,
-0.0517532192,
0.0373684429,
-0.0659913421,
0.0396960266,
0.0358657166,
-0.0137381116,
-0.010430553,
0.0394954272,
-0.0025280158,
-0.0567030609,
0.0745851919,
-0.0263713133,
0.0097237928,
-0.0122948447,
0.0196174569,
-0.0271036122,
0.0539001524,
0.0073704175,
0.0070543825,
0.0193093531,
-0.0048692892,
-0.0591317341,
0.0164407752,
0.0441683643,
0.0096768979,
-0.0077161337,
0.0112420954,
0.0241486337,
0.0284789149,
0.012384533,
0.00814573,
-0.0261833724,
0.0175460726,
0.0553128421,
0.0169913229,
0.0258617532,
0.0054428279,
0.046463456,
-0.0159650948,
-0.008186629,
0.0152845383,
-0.0578248091,
0.0250677485,
-0.0844914615,
0.034488976,
0.0029748124,
0.0285880249,
-0.0037680564,
-0.0374977775,
0.0079389773,
-0.0064314879,
0.0228522457,
0.0524760745,
0.0828094855,
0.0231802389,
-0.0259303059,
0.036366459,
0.050472334,
-0.0080185803,
0.0272118058,
0.0016878282,
0.0363240167,
0.0472454168,
0.0286929253,
-0.0220266003,
-0.0524637587,
0.0350360684,
0.0110906009,
-0.0157394316,
0.0059153265,
-0.0335628092,
-0.025252929,
-0.0450499691,
-0.0487117507,
-0.0140308309,
-0.0198558904,
0.0117786853,
0.0392190814,
-0.0029159319,
0.0191059131,
-0.0962768346,
0.0435342044,
0.0254764352,
-0.0398549922,
-0.0045230682,
-0.0233301781,
0.0291900374,
0.0147976782,
0.0121392095,
0.0365563594,
0.0066293483,
0.0453516953,
-0.0278967731,
-0.0328868963,
-0.0099750059,
-0.0448098816,
-0.0549244843,
0.0404984877,
-0.0097271856,
-0.0256382842,
-0.044874955,
-0.0206712559,
-0.0450564697,
0.0170721225,
0.0011731852,
0.0954620317,
-0.0047512362,
0.0007179088,
0.0225561541,
-0.0316399001,
-0.0004887446,
0.1019024551,
0.0082540661,
0.0222778041,
0.0382435694,
0.0093949568,
-0.0144178877,
0.0316829197,
-0.0216134079,
0.0001680672,
0.0154614672,
-0.027716944,
0.0016419629,
-0.0357671753,
-0.0693491846,
-0.0035053908,
-0.1248833537,
0.0087729171,
0.0269419737,
0.0022689796,
-0.0067306645,
0.0289208889,
0.0150854047,
-0.0238063559,
-0.0057807933,
0.0264966898,
-0.0193124078,
0.023126265,
0.0017125839,
0.0180885233,
-0.0187783092,
0.0131511521,
-0.0047514774,
-0.0439218953,
0.0588763133,
0.0057748468,
-0.0244477484,
-0.0348118357,
0.0402510762,
-0.0302796457,
0.0148015888,
-0.0488252267,
0.0087300362,
0.0003329606,
-0.0129408361,
0.072109282,
0.0586826913,
-0.0340082049,
0.01224449,
0.0572455451,
-0.0228554718,
-0.0541208982,
0.0149224615,
-0.0215707049,
-0.0061212201,
-0.0667600334,
0.0088189337,
-0.0186177492,
0.0308821462,
-0.0104261283,
-0.0171565041,
-0.0621706769,
-0.0191167295,
-0.0093024103,
-0.0264543202,
-0.0293076914,
-0.0257098116,
0.0177233443,
0.007800445,
-0.0133311888,
0.0089296615,
0.0953988507,
-0.0313247889,
-0.0047714971,
0.0033314822,
0.0060434612,
-0.0266856737,
0.0795570835,
0.0089280605,
0.0136426864,
0.0193718057,
-0.0231585447,
-0.0501044802,
0.011975104,
0.027228443,
-0.014671606,
0.0380061343,
-0.0163219403,
-0.0050648362,
0.0224396475,
-0.0043207272,
-0.0266827326,
-0.0014252316,
-0.0532736667,
0.0058911894,
0.0078466851,
-0.0247599389,
-0.0008157474,
-0.0113559561,
0.030166531,
-0.023952622,
0.0020493576,
-0.012514445,
-0.0416951552,
0.0154239284,
0.0264649186,
-0.0033970005,
0.0310012884,
-0.0336756893,
0.0035455669,
0.0564843901,
0.0292656589,
-0.0347185805,
-0.0026036776,
0.0164962672,
0.0217539966,
-0.0283173062,
-0.0427086987,
0.0132016866,
0.0211974196,
-0.0613406114,
0.023040561,
0.1049819514,
0.0045716697,
-0.0130466968,
0.008710701,
-0.0030247793,
0.0238015801,
0.0536700003,
0.0233600549,
-0.1058325768,
-0.015620999,
0.0159616712,
-0.0183965564,
0.0242416523,
-0.0534512475,
-0.0008612844,
-0.1262884438,
-0.0055445656,
0.0049905195,
0.0110074421,
-0.067420207,
-0.0324921496,
0.0093141906,
0.037360467,
-0.0307081249,
-0.0006938554,
-0.0238542724,
-0.0076547498,
-0.0080730226,
0.0125774555,
-0.0279020146,
0.0265588854,
-0.0281662997,
0.0540795475,
-0.0248212442,
0.0138784731,
0.0018822553,
-0.0368667692,
0.0004529195,
0.0223376248,
-0.0039331326,
-0.0106168995,
0.0021760121,
-0.019270191,
0.000654349,
-0.0367738642,
0.0289660841,
-0.0361006297,
-0.0232531093,
0.0033498392,
0.124549076,
0.0059853136,
-0.0006372147,
-0.0029597892,
-0.0043868832,
-0.0169129968,
0.0669184402,
0.0132886469,
0.0012882323,
0.0125868507,
-0.0141275786,
0.0061680968,
0.0385606848,
-0.0017637182,
0.0451003686,
-0.0355254784,
0.0550451875,
-0.0388871357,
-0.0217532553,
0.091091305,
0.0313356966,
0.0236924384,
0.0425973423,
0.023572186,
-0.0323736444,
-0.0382012017,
0.0292506218,
-0.0578961261,
0.0223623738,
-0.0063924706,
0.0162415225,
0.00408865,
-0.0504472926,
-0.0115602715,
-0.0327765346,
-0.0276489202,
-0.0501824506,
-0.046303995,
0.0255053863,
0.0093943346,
0.0988370478,
-0.0277588777,
-0.0288148019,
0.0530401729,
0.0100057265,
-0.0442327932,
0.0061716312,
0.0274937749,
-0.0251544714,
0.0217991248,
0.0377761014,
-0.0811618194,
-0.046388302,
0.0056443969,
0.0565540493,
-0.0263538174,
-0.0050579435,
0.0309801716,
0.0330797173,
0.0096097654,
0.0085843038,
0.0395089127,
-0.0466416292,
0.0324412063,
-0.0344824381,
-0.0393545926,
-0.0226093195,
-0.007412476,
0.0266960748,
-0.0000069685,
0.0258459412,
-0.0472356677,
0.0367875174,
0.0623357482,
-0.0002414588,
0.002106901,
0.0401163213,
-0.0153807634,
0.0802565962,
-0.004421528,
-0.0102943713,
0.0354126617,
0.0160648134,
0.0213090219,
-0.0670854673,
0.0486082062,
0.0313588269,
-0.0383713767,
-0.0615323558,
-0.0270904806,
-0.0381073691,
-0.0339703076,
-0.0099171503,
0.0475135297,
0.0441506729,
-0.0206802338,
-0.0007215993,
-0.056734968,
-0.0208831429,
0.0237112697,
0.0124345496,
-0.0165867712,
-0.0442255288,
0.048480887,
0.0421406589,
-0.0065119155,
0.0163019057,
0.0668368638,
0.0106415525,
0.0669671074,
0.0129276169,
-0.02914639,
-0.0194862951,
-0.0227061585,
0.0425345637,
0.0500827655,
-0.0485832654,
0.0319823474,
-0.0515545979,
-0.1051116809,
0.0139043182,
-0.0084646326,
-0.0625147447,
-0.0019386696,
0.0078332033,
0.0658148304,
0.0481832214,
-0.0491392687,
-0.0264778826,
0.0170784257,
-0.0068999329,
-0.0055435468,
0.0169000607,
-6.439407278e-33,
-0.0581152365,
-0.0502034016,
0.0301923119,
0.0106716789,
-0.0329842828,
0.0091687934,
-0.0281213671,
-0.0021501756,
-0.0292372406,
0.0241641961,
-0.0091247447,
-0.001098172,
-0.0123095894,
0.0175024718,
0.0067485832,
0.0075486829,
0.0196169019,
0.0472392179,
0.0176542532,
0.00521171,
0.0273964927,
0.0259630941,
0.0539329611,
-0.060467016,
0.0313997231,
0.0000514855,
0.0449562594,
0.0279126372,
-0.0087617794,
0.0644816831,
-0.0083904509,
0.0523458868,
0.0214468706,
-0.0142182605,
0.0013310388,
0.0242543072,
-0.1157222837,
-0.0474549718,
0.0687705278,
0.0132659962,
-0.0344900005,
-0.0132074151,
0.0296997204,
-0.0247407109,
0.0606482215,
-0.0458971225,
0.0336972252,
-0.0301495474,
-0.0579689778,
-0.0455511957,
-0.0753862336,
0.0023079843,
0.0051333271,
0.0043952735,
0.0183448102,
-0.0007467015,
0.0404211469,
-0.0275354031,
-0.0423329435,
0.02126237,
-0.0172045194,
0.011037929,
0.0371884219,
0.048388157,
0.0138438651,
0.0230030194,
-0.0246359408,
-0.0083266478,
-0.0412043817,
0.0068563712,
0.0088358596,
0.0536821596,
-0.0087574441,
0.0353572182,
-0.0311657637,
-0.0291894209,
-0.0696409792,
-0.0297505632,
0.0184522476,
0.0533435754,
-0.0037668669,
0.0119162481,
-0.0262379441,
-0.0321993046,
-0.0850367472,
-0.0046254219,
-0.0336686485,
-0.0455962345,
0.0092317853,
-0.0021215316,
-0.034197621,
-0.0041062175,
0.0003929294,
-0.0577062741,
-0.0141485566,
0.0365224592,
0.0216253344,
0.0190795735,
-0.0206559021,
0.055551853,
-0.0444853939,
-0.0406719372,
0.03107398,
-0.0799628869,
0.0008783166,
0.0212357286,
0.0238559078,
0.0144879175,
-0.0283009578,
-0.0291098077,
-0.0472678952,
-0.0573006868,
0.0065785083,
-0.0018136406,
0.0908595249,
0.0598064736,
-0.0161809288,
0.0196163319,
0.0279302187,
0.0379622579,
-0.0270606726,
-0.0160279758,
0.0026046117,
-0.0065491977,
-0.00709794,
-0.0116045168,
-0.0609878227,
-0.0378194302,
0.0297676548,
-0.053365577,
-0.0159019325,
0.0250074882,
3e-7,
0.0220216848,
0.0502425805,
-0.0117516732,
0.0294634197,
-0.0281725023,
0.0344133787,
0.0030037174,
0.0001289285,
0.0310378578,
-0.069396019,
0.0158937387,
0.01874833,
-0.0151065914,
0.028994035,
-0.104661867,
0.0029781666,
-0.0107661216,
-0.0322127789,
-0.0506009683,
0.0193796866,
0.0500375479,
0.055901885,
0.046310734,
0.0088866306,
-0.0112953978,
-0.0629552826,
0.059367083,
-0.0078343572,
-0.032051608,
0.0052151564,
0.0180916153,
0.0298210829,
-0.0095512867,
0.077567406,
0.0002062113,
0.0353591032,
0.0022525573,
0.0166632012,
0.0223185755,
0.010938962,
-0.0272289701,
-0.0325548314,
-0.007307848,
-0.0488333888,
0.0937346444,
-0.0618000776,
-0.0170055702,
0.000971577,
-0.0566436984,
-0.0394807383,
-0.0403019786,
0.0164926294,
0.0015802564,
-0.004507808,
0.0200999621,
-0.0017747671,
-0.0071942392,
-0.072843641,
0.0080697127,
0.0357821025,
-0.0396540165,
-0.0484783165,
-0.0206816569,
-0.0395014733,
0.0496646315,
-0.0421554558,
0.0030402299,
3.116876077e-34,
-0.0009792738,
-0.0040081386,
0.0236519333,
0.0152667603,
0.061246857,
-0.0272659119,
-0.0212773811,
0.0126364632,
0.0278812759,
-0.1398809254,
-0.0170288347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06666v1 | Unlock the Potential of Counterfactually-Augmented Data in Out-Of-Distribution Generalization | 2023-10-10T14:41:38 | 2023-10-10T14:41:38 | Caoyun Fan, Wenqing Chen, Jidong Tian, Yitian Li, Hao He, Yaohui Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Counterfactually-Augmented Data (CAD) -- minimal editing of sentences to flip
the corresponding labels -- has the potential to improve the
Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) generalization capability of language models, as CAD
induces language models to exploit domain-independent causal features and
exclude spurious correlations. However, the empirical results of CAD's OOD
generalization are not as efficient as anticipated. In this study, we attribute
the inefficiency to the myopia phenomenon caused by CAD: language models only
focus on causal features that are edited in the augmentation operation and
exclude other non-edited causal features. Therefore, the potential of CAD is
not fully exploited. To address this issue, we analyze the myopia phenomenon in
feature space from the perspective of Fisher's Linear Discriminant, then we
introduce two additional constraints based on CAD's structural properties
(dataset-level and sentence-level) to help language models extract more
complete causal features in CAD, thereby mitigating the myopia phenomenon and
improving OOD generalization capability. We evaluate our method on two tasks:
Sentiment Analysis and Natural Language Inference, and the experimental results
demonstrate that our method could unlock the potential of CAD and improve the
OOD generalization performance of language models by 1.0% to 5.9%. | [
0.0506747887,
0.079007633,
-0.0068117138,
0.0471882001,
-0.0331053026,
0.0477044545,
-0.0146227125,
-0.0092477733,
0.0018685822,
-0.0767962039,
-0.0076279007,
-0.0039025452,
0.0023015768,
0.018992696,
0.0216607619,
-0.0051711272,
0.0274538659,
0.035685569,
0.0304864403,
-0.0394969583,
-0.0039288686,
-0.0080371657,
0.0130076129,
-0.0281810313,
0.0076641301,
0.0087637631,
0.0250432454,
0.0286857076,
0.0155362831,
0.0366509669,
-0.005190833,
0.0334138796,
0.0056680501,
0.0055993241,
0.0000020604,
-0.0603810735,
-0.0268025976,
0.0166664962,
0.0060392357,
-0.0008126361,
0.0241431035,
-0.0551108122,
-0.0066982321,
-0.0143326195,
-0.0154635087,
-0.0138500659,
0.0677011535,
0.0635824949,
0.0073095178,
0.1141557097,
-0.0221660268,
-0.0322301723,
0.0055523585,
-0.0218816195,
0.0100591974,
0.0062942277,
0.0371650234,
0.0014702512,
-0.0521115847,
-0.0049437592,
-0.0391835161,
0.0299923718,
0.0142126186,
0.0423524342,
0.0585090518,
-0.0067596533,
-0.0239614937,
-0.0004554912,
0.0240151398,
0.049463097,
0.0137416208,
-0.0424281321,
-0.0203418452,
-0.0385735445,
0.0265189745,
0.0469909161,
-0.0162944812,
-0.0212640669,
0.0041316403,
0.032918103,
0.0154359974,
-0.0167022366,
0.051960092,
0.0249268971,
-0.0358021036,
0.0950708687,
0.0086284326,
-0.0375373811,
-0.0249554552,
0.0324973166,
-0.0487924516,
0.0008649938,
-0.0281046201,
-0.0191726033,
0.0175946075,
0.0113304975,
-0.0188994315,
-0.0560514256,
0.0068688821,
-0.0913574621,
0.004420111,
0.0073267184,
-0.0479717813,
0.0373643152,
-0.0088990573,
0.0540425442,
-0.0158105511,
0.0360086896,
-0.0552731454,
-0.0125715509,
-0.0173356608,
-0.0071355635,
0.0156211806,
0.0392400473,
-0.0386796147,
0.0319165662,
-0.0336777493,
0.0089020832,
-0.0205383189,
-0.0363855213,
0.003438758,
0.0205656979,
-0.0154875936,
-0.0101852445,
0.0051864702,
0.0375798382,
-0.0156305414,
0.0597171262,
-0.0493995287,
-0.0454105102,
-0.0133984191,
0.025436461,
0.0229027718,
-0.0382046737,
0.0043836981,
0.081111379,
0.003166476,
-0.0328366272,
-0.0165629219,
-0.008437057,
-0.0475192219,
-0.0700533167,
0.0057011275,
-0.0580306239,
-0.0157421734,
0.0419745445,
-0.0193311796,
-0.0411999077,
0.0062728962,
-0.0151372869,
-0.0799147487,
0.0434350744,
-0.0195158329,
-0.0138341915,
0.027328318,
-0.0296079908,
0.0246580821,
0.0882402584,
0.0130576435,
-0.038939435,
0.0389035493,
0.0077258791,
0.0120189879,
0.0503300354,
0.0155200223,
0.021617379,
-0.0698322132,
0.0095333969,
0.0154243577,
-0.0320923179,
0.0410203412,
-0.0240070038,
-0.0145810358,
-0.0187461432,
0.0345061198,
-0.0577446036,
-0.015887795,
-0.0012384364,
-0.0133497566,
-0.0147952428,
-0.0145556284,
0.0488581248,
-0.0454369597,
0.0019055709,
-0.0463722795,
0.0109185949,
-0.0134671098,
-0.0198239423,
-0.0270758905,
-0.0435030088,
-0.0227567535,
-0.0171709117,
0.0664313063,
0.0214846339,
0.0794045925,
0.0329183154,
0.0328280181,
-0.0220469944,
0.0437463373,
-0.0599836484,
0.0070129745,
-0.0070579248,
-0.0426474102,
0.0481498837,
0.0363574103,
-0.0505508818,
-0.0311409738,
0.0029766394,
-0.0089070937,
0.0209890064,
0.0357130244,
0.0004481537,
0.0199789722,
-0.0169301778,
-0.0259899087,
-0.0202089157,
0.0618390702,
0.0069469512,
0.0064394111,
-0.0086847879,
0.0281533282,
-0.0566156916,
-0.0320982486,
0.0237490237,
-0.0054974966,
-0.0201136153,
0.0499031655,
0.0217830129,
0.0109408684,
0.0151360026,
-0.0151057681,
-0.0069306735,
0.003841853,
-0.0422163121,
-0.0410854332,
0.0400887765,
-0.0107048843,
-0.0674170032,
0.008428772,
-0.0195132382,
-0.037949454,
0.0531162806,
-0.055825714,
-0.0167696979,
0.0715948939,
-0.034764789,
0.07003171,
-0.0405240133,
0.0194126889,
-0.024940433,
-0.0044867122,
-0.0229863934,
0.0827349201,
-0.0232114159,
0.0143872527,
-0.0644694641,
-0.0221341383,
0.0440264605,
-0.0366736613,
-0.0112986285,
-0.0145969139,
0.0008935796,
-0.0133173121,
0.0362071358,
-0.0334469043,
-0.0238839313,
0.0127079394,
-0.0827461183,
-0.0241004676,
-0.0423227996,
0.0014393704,
0.0448487066,
0.0189103689,
-0.0003802907,
-0.0269255172,
-0.0122441314,
-0.0278350115,
-0.0156603828,
0.0376354605,
0.0346187986,
-0.0117617026,
-0.001957108,
-0.0245261304,
-0.0010481004,
-0.0463120192,
0.0441536829,
-0.0087310132,
-0.0665649474,
-0.0302759614,
0.0218145195,
-0.0439356565,
0.0198752321,
-0.0299152676,
-0.0063649253,
-0.0546892285,
0.0125668887,
0.0304337833,
0.0446438752,
-0.0101390015,
-0.0395501368,
0.0534155592,
0.0121526401,
-0.0091682747,
-0.0096589839,
-0.0281370599,
0.0139906593,
0.0052917521,
-0.0497722998,
-0.0174660087,
0.0505132303,
0.0228342041,
-0.0540701896,
-0.0553624853,
-0.0265961234,
-0.0135422535,
-0.0270024277,
-0.0426030383,
-0.0418903939,
-0.0064949817,
0.0345070474,
-0.0281544738,
-0.053088937,
0.0768246502,
-0.0025986875,
0.0059800665,
-0.0729759708,
-0.0037958825,
-0.0396755151,
0.0576556511,
0.0234650485,
0.0216990486,
0.029705951,
-0.0077142227,
-0.0333824456,
-0.037825916,
0.0460529402,
-0.0036505808,
0.0488559119,
-0.0441928171,
0.0287578143,
0.0170600507,
-0.0378497243,
-0.0234268047,
-0.1226182058,
-0.0058217645,
-0.0043659131,
-0.0137367481,
-0.0185268503,
-0.0385113098,
-0.0151564637,
-0.0041422928,
0.053858567,
-0.0302978959,
0.0177609716,
0.0103897089,
-0.0002855334,
0.0522225834,
-0.0135415317,
-0.0126417605,
-0.0054101869,
-0.0390156955,
-0.0123158246,
-0.008022218,
-0.0544758327,
0.0222414434,
-0.0071802451,
-0.0146573251,
0.0044031278,
-0.0371812545,
-0.0146575961,
0.0406315066,
-0.0095657362,
-0.0093935765,
0.0722538456,
0.0447639748,
-0.033616554,
-0.0009904202,
-0.0039960057,
0.0070795752,
0.055569645,
-0.0312420428,
-0.0623378567,
-0.0282941051,
-0.0051420447,
0.0024519062,
-0.0357729532,
-0.0182371475,
-0.0162886027,
-0.0998546481,
0.0133948382,
-0.0018451905,
-0.0484394655,
-0.0585347228,
-0.0397514775,
0.0125613334,
-0.0398321003,
-0.0200608149,
-0.0076661739,
0.0127127208,
0.0110021159,
-0.0167542975,
-0.010111168,
-0.0455005951,
-0.012701516,
0.0056720413,
0.002173655,
0.0658300668,
0.0248320829,
-0.0152300177,
-0.0003870194,
0.0351677984,
-0.0032649518,
0.0192104392,
-0.0102239745,
0.0669377819,
0.009694824,
-0.0060135135,
-0.0061571323,
0.0344502665,
0.0019598587,
-0.0174845438,
-0.0289301351,
0.0459902659,
-0.0055872048,
0.011951413,
-0.0039158906,
0.0030051833,
-0.0003732401,
0.0746389329,
0.0068727373,
-0.0383818448,
0.018093504,
-0.0258171614,
-0.0296262577,
0.022115333,
0.0271748025,
-0.0319475867,
0.0186914094,
-0.0693162903,
-0.0826486722,
-0.0568954013,
-0.0319020748,
-0.0130484151,
0.0031470452,
0.0410905927,
-0.0385142788,
-0.0381388851,
-0.0522374883,
0.0288367663,
-0.012749115,
0.0038370138,
0.0487711541,
-0.0211240929,
0.0149857569,
-0.0500523485,
-0.0371426269,
0.0222515389,
-0.0633275658,
-0.101220116,
0.0266616289,
-0.0031535826,
0.0220342688,
0.0840553343,
-0.0061126589,
-0.0408934653,
0.0097287921,
0.0944625512,
-0.0146905491,
0.0524682291,
0.0387462229,
-0.02020978,
0.0332925208,
0.0415650085,
-0.0386073813,
0.0070649451,
0.0647714958,
-0.0062393807,
-0.0149419857,
-0.016718911,
0.0192959607,
-0.001938454,
0.0930652544,
-0.0272804704,
-0.03671984,
-0.0383477062,
0.0431640707,
-0.0544018261,
-0.0437053777,
-0.011001193,
0.0057483627,
0.0255186763,
0.0267115012,
-0.0342826284,
0.0615921952,
-0.0531713627,
0.0336686,
-0.0137621332,
0.0380275436,
0.027861068,
0.0041890759,
0.0041966825,
0.0135308867,
-0.0031451837,
0.017733654,
0.0360335447,
0.0133601492,
-0.0081416843,
0.0166676082,
0.0193113759,
0.0148758162,
-0.0523232371,
-0.0266251713,
-0.0836341158,
0.0592768639,
-0.0099664237,
0.0214790031,
0.0235616509,
-0.0787810907,
0.0464963615,
-0.0141381081,
-0.0250033792,
-0.0066374042,
0.020114867,
0.0117975613,
-0.007001543,
0.0168511104,
0.00540982,
-0.040563006,
0.0355774425,
0.0656203479,
0.0326652192,
0.0510063134,
-0.0502561107,
0.0108939754,
-0.0204401817,
-0.0209749844,
0.0414467305,
0.0224844143,
-0.0253280029,
0.0212453734,
-0.0815908387,
-0.0735858232,
0.0149530601,
-0.0413339958,
0.0194767453,
0.000973427,
0.0210524574,
0.0512530953,
-0.0159540828,
-0.0048443144,
-0.0370587297,
0.0228526704,
0.0197414421,
-0.0061708447,
-0.0275665876,
-6.510636358e-33,
-0.0098317424,
-0.0145311952,
-0.0251667872,
-0.007812799,
0.0450246893,
-0.0073374906,
-0.0038706041,
0.0249647386,
-0.0254695415,
0.0290080905,
0.0111921402,
0.0434431136,
0.0209313594,
0.0230438355,
-0.0112387454,
0.0044200765,
0.0428767204,
0.0286580138,
-0.0163753256,
-0.0217074919,
0.0235140231,
0.0325524621,
0.1019133851,
-0.0992139578,
0.0732420161,
-0.0371638089,
-0.0050107851,
0.0174601413,
-0.0069910805,
0.0145231467,
0.0192779638,
0.0793188363,
0.0373350866,
-0.0189357959,
0.0027066749,
-0.0138587989,
-0.0356862359,
-0.0101544801,
0.0575209707,
0.0235991403,
0.0143646877,
-0.0070939525,
0.0383407362,
-0.0139371501,
-0.0327621512,
0.0121366261,
0.0587414242,
-0.0461315103,
0.0189866405,
0.0245693251,
-0.1032664254,
0.0391388908,
-0.0009783892,
0.0075274603,
0.0146030197,
0.0453014895,
0.0260520056,
0.0222395342,
-0.0285790097,
0.0349011198,
0.021934377,
0.004112327,
0.018727947,
0.0254785679,
0.0086690737,
0.042473577,
-0.0004758084,
0.0369121172,
-0.0260079671,
-0.013164348,
0.0265368652,
-0.0167530105,
0.0321447514,
0.115107052,
0.0738444328,
-0.0160897784,
-0.0917619169,
-0.0046359203,
-0.0348421969,
-0.05123486,
0.0072042802,
0.0169501789,
-0.054015927,
-0.0327386893,
-0.0285947863,
-0.0150226131,
-0.0345878825,
0.0079835262,
-0.0023881926,
0.0235768873,
-0.0197290555,
-0.0031968448,
-0.0038089871,
-0.0357535593,
-0.0124910632,
0.0519325621,
-0.0409747288,
0.010167609,
0.0114525612,
-0.0053662481,
-0.0462028533,
0.0033755212,
0.01232161,
0.0554605722,
0.0054595303,
-0.0087233298,
0.1312953532,
0.0077846223,
-0.0708231479,
-0.0029947876,
-0.0137340641,
-0.0095769363,
-0.0221752748,
0.043849729,
0.0337404385,
0.0297827367,
-0.0202097557,
0.0584277064,
0.0678319633,
0.0388075449,
-0.0228421278,
0.0266774427,
-0.0101210168,
-0.0027374413,
0.0006738223,
-0.0150410403,
0.0577709973,
0.0004078501,
0.0174407978,
-0.044688765,
-0.0120027727,
-0.0065502045,
2.783e-7,
0.0813121423,
0.0406664833,
0.0102605727,
-0.0158274956,
0.0355587713,
0.0585738234,
-0.0281007551,
-0.0049787047,
0.0305851344,
-0.0069686696,
0.0410926715,
0.0167483073,
-0.0025004758,
-0.0001863166,
-0.070114173,
0.075401336,
-0.0225953534,
-0.0184395071,
-0.001867061,
-0.005612311,
0.0333881266,
0.0980121046,
0.0407156125,
-0.0120679447,
-0.0151380673,
-0.020868836,
0.060884241,
-0.0337213613,
-0.0053505516,
-0.0216652174,
-0.0384136438,
0.0282076877,
0.0167283434,
0.0679607242,
-0.0355470702,
0.0429125726,
0.0008686765,
0.0277588032,
-0.0388983712,
-0.0364903286,
-0.0256358311,
0.0168283731,
-0.0119845076,
-0.0458554998,
0.0909852535,
-0.0154579207,
-0.045210693,
-0.0366530269,
-0.0405177176,
0.0725536272,
0.0387806147,
0.0007325753,
-0.006081555,
0.0047686249,
0.0266895052,
0.0007345044,
-0.0206168778,
-0.0495552793,
-0.0684848577,
0.0268144365,
-0.0296643395,
-0.0489001982,
-0.0083528012,
0.0493863747,
0.0401017293,
-0.0433569923,
0.0320898034,
2.564913521e-34,
0.0412413254,
0.0413333774,
-0.0136472108,
-0.0440617092,
0.0077574672,
-0.0211180095,
-0.0461371504,
0.0136154881,
0.0165491309,
-0.0453999452,
0.0239508841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06645v1 | Self-Supervised Representation Learning for Online Handwriting Text Classification | 2023-10-10T14:07:49 | 2023-10-10T14:07:49 | Pouya Mehralian, Bagher BabaAli, Ashena Gorgan Mohammadi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Self-supervised learning offers an efficient way of extracting rich
representations from various types of unlabeled data while avoiding the cost of
annotating large-scale datasets. This is achievable by designing a pretext task
to form pseudo labels with respect to the modality and domain of the data.
Given the evolving applications of online handwritten texts, in this study, we
propose the novel Part of Stroke Masking (POSM) as a pretext task for
pretraining models to extract informative representations from the online
handwriting of individuals in English and Chinese languages, along with two
suggested pipelines for fine-tuning the pretrained models. To evaluate the
quality of the extracted representations, we use both intrinsic and extrinsic
evaluation methods. The pretrained models are fine-tuned to achieve
state-of-the-art results in tasks such as writer identification, gender
classification, and handedness classification, also highlighting the
superiority of utilizing the pretrained models over the models trained from
scratch. | [
-0.0252388977,
0.0322171859,
0.0037893867,
0.0458505228,
-0.0245070998,
0.049701374,
0.0858325511,
0.03565358,
0.0330465361,
-0.0185886882,
-0.0649585277,
-0.0497662388,
-0.0009401403,
0.0263313819,
-0.0092522223,
-0.0393552333,
-0.0113599319,
-0.0328591093,
-0.020934118,
-0.0069389557,
0.0214838348,
-0.0086795138,
-0.0183344297,
0.0033597534,
-0.0307613574,
-0.0234054085,
0.0110103404,
-0.0116597507,
0.0050968444,
0.0137767904,
0.0158716161,
0.0526806973,
0.0327225775,
0.0423233509,
0.0000021563,
-0.0499050766,
-0.0278419573,
0.0064490312,
-0.0023354387,
0.0043388656,
0.0823840871,
0.0190707371,
-0.0380539037,
-0.018454859,
-0.0167689715,
-0.0084857615,
0.0461794697,
0.0944512412,
0.0382725857,
0.0261174999,
-0.0175016988,
0.012338331,
-0.0264989603,
-0.0358685665,
-0.0082071535,
0.0110797221,
0.0143407388,
-0.0313251168,
-0.056706544,
-0.0146898506,
-0.0110706184,
0.0109750088,
0.0133611746,
-0.0457998775,
0.0224137865,
0.0386670083,
0.0168775581,
0.0479953736,
0.0319442637,
0.0523434654,
-0.0149329612,
-0.0212221276,
0.0220250897,
-0.043653816,
-0.0105838338,
0.0313486643,
0.0008022334,
0.0310512595,
-0.0123447012,
-0.0084726568,
-0.0251987185,
0.0472459942,
0.0291000567,
0.0192537028,
0.0007050626,
0.0160745922,
-0.0310568921,
0.0021199977,
-0.0224633403,
-0.0123331118,
0.0120060751,
-0.0432466678,
0.0630846694,
0.013182126,
0.0683854744,
-0.0603967793,
-0.0520669669,
-0.0642114729,
-0.0260737464,
-0.0328281112,
0.0983484611,
0.0083858334,
-0.0196468942,
0.0116773592,
-0.0136681562,
-0.0038986031,
-0.0457808189,
0.046827998,
-0.0314820558,
0.0445380658,
-0.0378871039,
-0.011196807,
-0.0493650772,
0.0328121632,
0.0309842862,
0.0083298925,
-0.0036652267,
-0.0247124266,
-0.0294601321,
-0.0573822819,
0.0222925544,
-0.001408992,
-0.039661821,
-0.0249272697,
-0.0138099119,
-0.0089623854,
-0.0267623644,
0.0405720733,
-0.0259695295,
0.0264801998,
0.0031661852,
0.0215282124,
0.0576002635,
-0.0288350321,
0.0438652262,
0.0453257151,
-0.0170023013,
-0.0220072176,
-0.0000427998,
0.0117959622,
0.0074861706,
-0.0460088588,
0.0037527727,
-0.0459473692,
-0.0077080838,
-0.0373667777,
0.0015206774,
-0.0280824024,
-0.0368747637,
-0.0244523305,
0.0793330371,
0.0486708693,
-0.0050670272,
-0.0113237919,
0.0905021131,
0.005781461,
-0.0244202651,
-0.0126860989,
0.0169980433,
0.0572525337,
0.0127507886,
-0.0441798419,
0.0394397825,
0.0227808803,
0.0044534309,
-0.0263798367,
0.0014785714,
-0.0137768872,
0.0196606591,
0.0226612296,
0.0612947531,
-0.0268951785,
-0.04795973,
-0.0291348714,
0.0491586737,
0.0464573279,
0.0755693242,
0.0672949329,
0.027932616,
-0.001739729,
0.0356390998,
0.0074483063,
-0.0111324443,
0.0063683796,
0.0273513757,
-0.0211433563,
-0.0300861262,
0.0055437977,
-0.0145032248,
-0.058683034,
0.0259873476,
-0.0321184061,
-0.0052075838,
0.0179181043,
0.0597886033,
0.0013933494,
0.0014795725,
-0.0571383238,
-0.0210373197,
-0.0259323232,
0.011193864,
-0.0438290536,
-0.0047391555,
0.0457456149,
0.0019670567,
-0.0644273162,
0.0199808348,
-0.0127551807,
0.0139627624,
-0.0145409554,
-0.0182745438,
-0.0008500514,
0.0753909126,
-0.0400450863,
-0.0437049381,
0.0064085964,
-0.0216132533,
0.0213074293,
-0.0389937647,
0.0051114932,
0.0175278299,
-0.0506593361,
-0.0254522841,
0.0620229617,
-0.0262869857,
-0.080472596,
0.0536703132,
0.0497511625,
0.0115333097,
0.0229019504,
-0.0575905144,
-0.0115811648,
0.0081271604,
-0.0583456531,
-0.0380083807,
-0.0493959188,
-0.0434017517,
-0.002240405,
0.0088658687,
-0.0332646593,
-0.0192886218,
0.0267466344,
-0.0193082765,
-0.0417559817,
-0.0166089572,
0.0472877063,
-0.0332811177,
-0.0716718063,
-0.0185839646,
-0.0055482481,
-0.0028771996,
0.0026144742,
0.0233212672,
0.0462538861,
-0.0091239298,
-0.0093072457,
-0.0227645319,
0.0017197649,
-0.0301703978,
-0.0155942021,
-0.048388727,
-0.0130901644,
0.0253109392,
-0.0029244483,
0.0336102247,
-0.0037986019,
0.0146193365,
-0.0405956134,
0.0185528789,
-0.0091511318,
0.0198174492,
0.0353601463,
-0.0021669455,
0.0030878568,
-0.056027256,
-0.022429239,
-0.073602654,
-0.0343001075,
-0.0243260916,
0.0499361977,
-0.038022738,
0.0356106535,
0.0248135533,
-0.0292110536,
0.0033831235,
-0.0117105898,
0.0298317913,
-0.0366126187,
-0.0314874016,
0.0276935287,
0.0112570254,
0.0178140532,
-0.0088241203,
-0.0215788428,
-0.0137249818,
-0.0092048189,
-0.0537107885,
0.0861547142,
-0.0170574896,
-0.023904087,
0.0626663342,
0.0148980618,
0.0270170085,
-0.0049140588,
-0.0088570332,
0.0817148164,
0.0242333598,
0.0078058932,
-0.0048260675,
0.0267685894,
0.0273674671,
0.007104509,
-0.0134856468,
-0.068612054,
-0.0235726833,
-0.0082978727,
-0.067764625,
-0.0218514781,
-0.0075816642,
-0.0174887553,
-0.0494186841,
-0.0585864522,
0.029458994,
-0.0429164656,
-0.0100408942,
0.0299991351,
-0.0277133249,
-0.009061588,
0.0398883,
0.0307762194,
0.026661329,
0.0291749425,
-0.0366772376,
-0.0381294973,
0.0434457846,
0.0616599731,
-0.0236437898,
-0.0744544938,
0.0269599091,
0.0218246859,
-0.0145246433,
-0.0387834571,
0.009688044,
-0.0667771623,
0.0143557964,
-0.0211715214,
-0.0344863087,
0.0060370667,
0.0709384009,
0.0143924486,
0.0004039246,
0.1212461218,
-0.0098676505,
-0.015087897,
-0.0067568687,
0.053611882,
-0.021032447,
0.0003316355,
-0.0385787673,
-0.0123081217,
0.0371820964,
0.0289195515,
-0.0069324253,
-0.0093021067,
-0.0046681869,
0.027054349,
-0.021655608,
-0.0186419189,
-0.0314519554,
0.0284467079,
0.0566404015,
-0.0513809994,
-0.0104557285,
0.0791725665,
-0.0029037569,
0.0014173286,
-0.038439393,
0.0547619276,
-0.0284044202,
-0.0104816165,
-0.0001620458,
-0.0613598973,
0.001779417,
0.0178948734,
0.0303602535,
-0.0222865734,
-0.0231184307,
0.0108364811,
-0.0602420606,
0.0443945564,
0.0244726501,
-0.0275833216,
0.0391484834,
-0.0621896312,
0.008870272,
-0.0233020559,
-0.0642332509,
-0.0382502489,
-0.016841324,
-0.0320353284,
0.0112586198,
-0.0278536752,
-0.0189354215,
0.0138556194,
-0.015190498,
-0.0241512507,
0.0119630415,
0.0285322238,
-0.0092770439,
0.0014295254,
0.0068596108,
-0.0182262566,
0.0115937963,
-0.0086088181,
0.1087223515,
0.0164212752,
0.0083273891,
-0.0703472346,
0.0694116279,
-0.0054853917,
-0.0009087737,
0.0122717302,
0.0046622455,
-0.0274317805,
0.0278011225,
0.0246043671,
-0.0524830446,
0.0107837515,
0.00621458,
0.0207219608,
-0.0411814339,
-0.064252004,
-0.0117050651,
0.0433870777,
-0.0184726901,
-0.0590785593,
0.0449207872,
-0.0016013193,
-0.0735643283,
-0.0160062332,
-0.0176708158,
0.0031025845,
0.031065274,
-0.0078021344,
0.0012534816,
0.0551290885,
-0.0244671088,
-0.0502051786,
0.0394693762,
-0.0337930843,
0.0437488183,
-0.0467767678,
-0.004116796,
-0.0171006471,
-0.0593546778,
0.001182941,
-0.0053164633,
-0.0957988352,
-0.0369036645,
0.0473035499,
0.0499495119,
0.0057905409,
0.0067354678,
-0.0313614048,
-0.0798007026,
0.0686319023,
0.0520761609,
-0.0075316615,
-0.0284995716,
0.0415598676,
-0.0371984728,
-0.0410619006,
0.0142161744,
0.0369125456,
0.0738253221,
0.0318990611,
-0.0834017098,
-0.027191516,
0.0075525572,
-0.0217624176,
0.0111846551,
0.0744045302,
-0.0235409085,
0.0201020688,
-0.0719009861,
-0.0044389358,
-0.0276032649,
-0.0164628271,
-0.0173591916,
-0.0170772187,
0.0387785137,
0.0105365152,
-0.0033192222,
0.0181142427,
0.0233667884,
0.0201866608,
-0.0425273553,
0.0153285805,
-0.0167328604,
0.0862682387,
-0.0409591757,
0.034264151,
0.0267737489,
0.0498791002,
0.0052921744,
0.0057303621,
0.0021259889,
0.0207605772,
-0.0039031049,
0.0634185225,
-0.0242030527,
0.0503875241,
-0.0768800154,
-0.0020947573,
-0.0916114897,
0.012611703,
0.0213998836,
-0.0328763127,
0.0108784465,
-0.0151635064,
-0.0121103544,
-0.0388019085,
0.049953036,
0.0191606451,
-0.0076498734,
-0.0117307464,
-0.0093714437,
-0.0096049942,
-0.0260037016,
0.035503719,
0.0068233605,
-0.0022668864,
0.0579087213,
-0.0238948278,
-0.0567580499,
-0.013746459,
0.0206197519,
0.0154592041,
-0.0232539289,
-0.0095760161,
0.0127236675,
-0.020381311,
0.0555032045,
-0.0183446035,
-0.0223051086,
0.0237614997,
0.0063878442,
-0.0070691425,
-0.0327050053,
-0.0166773368,
-0.0205608271,
0.0297686663,
0.0465719514,
0.0319301635,
-0.003872789,
-6.010175883e-33,
-0.0012639707,
-0.0265754312,
-0.0124844238,
-0.015886439,
-0.0282841939,
0.0115031675,
0.0113746207,
0.0415615216,
0.0261826999,
0.013873985,
-0.0368834399,
-0.0068492014,
0.0307135917,
0.0394478999,
-0.0320393853,
0.0216884017,
0.0825290903,
-0.0437655598,
-0.0172026996,
0.0257445648,
0.0263287891,
0.0428476706,
0.0728218332,
-0.0636014566,
0.0098593403,
-0.0745650679,
-0.0652267933,
-0.0312609076,
0.0114084445,
0.0145874619,
-0.0404284969,
0.0170819908,
0.0218237676,
0.0002754486,
-0.0158472117,
0.0337284617,
-0.1124630794,
-0.0618179739,
-0.0980022252,
0.0367837921,
-0.0129040489,
-0.0140855061,
0.0083768079,
-0.0007568283,
-0.005850404,
-0.0279984418,
0.0578442886,
-0.0086991778,
0.0162302423,
-0.0265327822,
0.0060161017,
0.0368640646,
-0.0185067318,
-0.0403354131,
0.0852729604,
0.0042461986,
-0.0068971096,
-0.0248029772,
-0.1377449185,
0.0015818545,
0.0011949308,
0.003722372,
0.013406896,
0.0416694023,
0.0303488635,
0.0054652607,
0.0238161404,
0.0253823604,
-0.0223224312,
0.0187642351,
0.049930729,
0.0034229115,
0.0082236324,
0.0947879925,
0.0915511474,
-0.0158710405,
-0.0366351344,
0.0595021583,
-0.0097379507,
-0.0443830863,
-0.0154181672,
0.0254525319,
-0.0166482348,
0.0052893581,
-0.0245588142,
-0.0811450854,
0.0121795172,
0.0126669006,
0.0050148796,
0.007267327,
0.005731862,
-0.0003215908,
0.0162819829,
-0.0318931639,
-0.0505220108,
-0.0530812591,
-0.0076004756,
0.0619495623,
0.0180406142,
-0.0331076942,
-0.0228966754,
-0.036000751,
0.0227230284,
0.0389860235,
0.0380104743,
-0.023747785,
0.0614121668,
0.0239744484,
-0.0582055338,
0.0024312311,
-0.0099116582,
-0.0044149067,
0.0720948651,
0.0780406818,
0.0258137099,
-0.0034217874,
0.0097425543,
0.0913299024,
0.0124874795,
0.0052285474,
-0.0036538593,
0.009161829,
0.0121268351,
0.0162265655,
0.0228573922,
0.01577208,
-0.0002191612,
0.002104664,
0.0732642412,
-0.0505662113,
-0.0266085677,
-0.020685738,
2.476e-7,
0.058527261,
-0.0242353175,
0.0538535751,
0.0170233957,
0.0003965915,
0.0622152388,
-0.0102466932,
0.0158436298,
0.0035686996,
0.012929366,
0.0681388527,
0.0318897329,
0.0512614027,
0.0082367696,
-0.0088137845,
0.0445039272,
-0.0246080216,
0.0305281244,
-0.0182594061,
0.048120074,
0.0187639184,
0.0391183048,
0.0142758405,
-0.0333732404,
0.0219306368,
-0.0312828384,
0.069993481,
-0.0224581081,
0.0629737303,
0.0038499075,
-0.0174933411,
0.002151299,
-0.0386351123,
0.0014745384,
-0.0161847528,
0.005242826,
0.0254301336,
0.0311484262,
-0.0350814015,
0.0490867384,
0.0113409702,
0.0532478653,
0.0173978265,
-0.0288817324,
0.08710666,
-0.0204849057,
-0.0305397678,
-0.0595348552,
0.0117971888,
-0.0186374541,
0.0799140632,
-0.0151324393,
0.0061052311,
0.045949854,
0.0433232896,
-0.0001230828,
-0.0118754935,
-0.0579851568,
-0.0654046908,
-0.0105998814,
-0.0107563436,
0.0308138747,
-0.050639417,
-0.010807965,
0.0337305032,
-0.0683454052,
0.0228051618,
1.861577139e-34,
-0.0410837382,
-0.0040217675,
0.0010731323,
-0.0188525673,
-0.0136021394,
0.000280884,
0.0368643254,
-0.0449954607,
0.000188589,
-0.0285950638,
-0.0018341334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06627v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06627v4 | What If the TV Was Off? Examining Counterfactual Reasoning Abilities of Multi-modal Language Models | 2023-10-10T13:45:59 | 2024-04-15T18:03:26 | Letian Zhang, Xiaotong Zhai, Zhongkai Zhao, Yongshuo Zong, Xin Wen, Bingchen Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Counterfactual reasoning, a fundamental aspect of human cognition, involves
contemplating alternatives to established facts or past events, significantly
enhancing our abilities in planning and decision-making. In light of the
advancements in current multi-modal large language models, we explore their
effectiveness in counterfactual reasoning. To facilitate this investigation, we
introduce a novel dataset, C-VQA, specifically designed to test the
counterfactual reasoning capabilities of modern multi-modal large language
models. This dataset is constructed by infusing original questions with
counterfactual presuppositions, spanning various types such as numerical and
boolean queries. It encompasses a mix of real and synthetic data, representing
a wide range of difficulty levels. Our thorough evaluations of contemporary
vision-language models using this dataset have revealed substantial performance
drops, with some models showing up to a 40% decrease, highlighting a
significant gap between current models and human-like vision reasoning
capabilities. We hope our dataset will serve as a vital benchmark for
evaluating the counterfactual reasoning capabilities of models. Code and
dataset are publicly available at https://bzhao.me/C-VQA/. | [
0.0439917929,
0.0792500302,
-0.0195859335,
0.0225274619,
-0.0807823241,
0.0383796021,
0.0150808822,
0.0282820389,
0.0172793344,
-0.0640503317,
0.0099886525,
-0.03395091,
-0.0360743701,
0.0556856245,
0.0287468415,
-0.0034674285,
0.0557494052,
-0.0551076904,
0.0212376695,
-0.0302421581,
-0.0263606664,
-0.0168836992,
-0.0181042831,
0.002006022,
-0.0032196469,
-0.0236025434,
-0.0044433367,
0.0188392568,
0.0071361661,
-0.0305455346,
-0.0278007705,
0.0467909761,
0.0365681797,
0.0246991925,
0.0000021149,
-0.0480487458,
0.0057766787,
-0.0233538859,
-0.042763561,
0.0094275651,
0.0009009367,
0.0085080024,
0.0114350561,
0.0220775884,
-0.0469248518,
0.0134983324,
0.0471784398,
0.0514464565,
0.0247002188,
0.0761261955,
-0.0042188452,
-0.0245979894,
-0.0088516138,
-0.0172752421,
0.0151795186,
-0.0285935234,
0.0169409849,
0.0442151465,
-0.0189651903,
0.005360845,
-0.0047589522,
0.0298563521,
0.0438287184,
0.0170095898,
-0.091086857,
0.0384383611,
-0.0198010635,
-0.0293554571,
-0.0027635137,
0.0492004827,
0.0332801454,
-0.0407598913,
-0.0071520708,
-0.019977482,
0.0172395613,
0.0430558473,
-0.0368531942,
0.0274126213,
-0.0187326688,
-0.0004604861,
-0.0107224947,
0.0141565297,
0.0276628677,
0.0070041087,
-0.0143937217,
0.0700012147,
0.0104929106,
-0.0048543457,
-0.0013481751,
-0.0054383003,
-0.0480478406,
-0.0410842374,
-0.0068566147,
-0.0112371938,
-0.0306316912,
-0.0018298989,
-0.0078342864,
0.0066514299,
0.0288352724,
-0.0620934181,
0.0325752981,
0.0442684479,
-0.0211651642,
0.0726888552,
-0.033572726,
0.0302801058,
-0.0546748191,
0.0373792872,
-0.0203361306,
-0.0164243244,
-0.0087542469,
-0.021152284,
-0.0009459613,
-0.0043069459,
-0.0687064454,
-0.0016775306,
0.00324759,
-0.0145216929,
-0.0344597027,
0.0170263443,
-0.0051007126,
0.0207206272,
-0.0167352855,
-0.0625788271,
-0.0537383705,
0.0195695814,
-0.0427096486,
0.0446587205,
-0.003731013,
-0.0696311966,
-0.0038022951,
-0.0142135471,
-0.016076263,
-0.0359238684,
0.0242866352,
0.0843615383,
-0.0152508933,
0.0185257681,
-0.0179721881,
-0.0288766921,
-0.0001710403,
-0.0673471242,
0.0550897531,
-0.0706182867,
0.0001400429,
0.0131102093,
-0.0073545463,
-0.0077551082,
-0.000593111,
0.0230450127,
0.006207596,
0.0807672292,
0.0333052166,
-0.0006044431,
0.0032395765,
0.0021743609,
0.0093813241,
0.0941570848,
0.0101216696,
-0.0025841736,
0.0350602046,
0.0177809633,
-0.0054976679,
0.0097547416,
0.0266070478,
0.0015683642,
-0.0920766816,
0.0378276333,
0.003472022,
0.0209883787,
-0.0172048155,
0.0240200926,
-0.022080997,
-0.0857610404,
0.0517030209,
-0.0228550136,
-0.0117135914,
-0.0129316337,
0.0166382622,
-0.01550462,
-0.0216916371,
0.0155753354,
-0.0512299724,
0.0769486651,
-0.06714461,
0.0088721123,
-0.0298297871,
0.0238569453,
-0.0154110622,
-0.0394429043,
-0.0206708238,
0.0177568607,
0.0181704927,
0.0415076278,
0.045496013,
-0.0101066241,
-0.0482610576,
-0.0397023149,
0.025912039,
-0.0349500254,
-0.0284753852,
-0.045084063,
0.0141858971,
0.0096752672,
0.0346270502,
-0.046025347,
-0.0326350071,
0.0191624798,
0.0131542897,
0.0213494077,
0.0745519549,
0.0099695176,
-0.0021869882,
-0.045508083,
0.0024606746,
-0.0243126508,
0.0317288078,
0.0147870881,
-0.0153855812,
-0.0013178078,
-0.024437312,
0.0038143408,
0.0555295981,
0.0249197781,
-0.0257531982,
0.0108301239,
-0.0366469957,
-0.0018566236,
-0.0062198369,
-0.0246747695,
-0.0053826654,
0.0273801237,
0.0540624075,
-0.0158355013,
-0.0091424463,
0.0206950735,
-0.0457198396,
-0.064878583,
0.0294328108,
-0.0745989978,
-0.0340295285,
0.072466433,
-0.0300559513,
-0.0225238577,
0.0270261019,
-0.0089078443,
0.0651794076,
-0.0360482596,
0.003786305,
-0.0065442617,
-0.0004520906,
-0.0142782554,
0.0707705393,
-0.0376872085,
0.016759092,
0.001883131,
-0.0159155149,
0.0319763422,
-0.0306494609,
0.0019620166,
0.0309711806,
0.0075588827,
-0.027386019,
-0.0003117366,
-0.0197210182,
-0.0588881038,
0.008042153,
-0.0925326794,
-0.0177329779,
-0.0188676622,
-0.0262565222,
0.0057866666,
-0.0349831879,
-0.0053662295,
-0.0328897387,
-0.0018107826,
0.0258983299,
-0.006242652,
0.0437474586,
0.0107786153,
-0.0154919056,
0.0156531744,
-0.0107024321,
-0.0418667048,
-0.0454498902,
0.0608516596,
0.0104933912,
0.0194447301,
0.0184324589,
0.0041994448,
-0.0497359894,
0.0430744253,
-0.0381043181,
-0.0159984976,
0.0120564513,
-0.0282749645,
0.0381825455,
0.0621626303,
0.0028153192,
-0.0157897398,
0.0698878095,
-0.0289290771,
-0.0391329005,
0.0241409224,
-0.0034786938,
-0.026272526,
-0.0401808731,
-0.0500537381,
-0.0888159499,
0.0276910029,
0.0012376448,
0.0018149927,
-0.0659037828,
0.0481213666,
0.001723111,
-0.056161955,
-0.040484108,
0.000093443,
-0.0132699357,
0.0913309678,
-0.0164928157,
-0.0090878829,
0.085921295,
0.0212011263,
0.0053136637,
-0.0085592894,
0.0478039794,
-0.0002719546,
0.0961136743,
0.0223208126,
0.0080414684,
0.0195386037,
0.0098370109,
-0.065733932,
-0.0184719749,
0.0390591547,
-0.0283158645,
0.0300763249,
-0.079530105,
0.0007761634,
-0.0127424514,
-0.0404562093,
-0.029121872,
-0.0624385253,
-0.0413255468,
-0.0066257543,
-0.0384575203,
-0.0048177117,
-0.0568781719,
0.0192083567,
-0.0034065663,
0.0299121011,
0.0176644959,
-0.0061509074,
-0.0050419583,
0.0042281109,
0.051513344,
0.0666080117,
0.0554145835,
-0.0201950669,
0.0082614999,
0.0516313314,
0.0459603705,
-0.0178421624,
-0.0017575838,
0.0455683246,
0.0052057425,
0.0429138951,
-0.0121767046,
0.0270682368,
0.0280973744,
-0.0439928286,
0.0023281353,
0.0702814907,
0.0466083027,
-0.0106958775,
0.0078970334,
-0.0365685746,
0.0257220063,
0.0537436903,
-0.0169384237,
-0.076978609,
-0.0521902815,
0.0242617466,
-0.0263934322,
-0.0406357534,
-0.0598492324,
-0.007373197,
-0.1197781563,
0.0437699705,
-0.0190128926,
0.0225961972,
-0.0285520814,
-0.0339477919,
-0.0136410492,
-0.0327400453,
-0.0476233065,
0.0124003133,
0.0092537776,
-0.0100618647,
-0.0212358441,
0.016173536,
-0.0267978925,
0.0640112162,
0.0063564084,
0.032744281,
0.0355867185,
0.0234240796,
-0.0148312496,
-0.0358300097,
0.0312362574,
-0.0175970066,
-0.0127436025,
-0.0088913385,
0.0226198155,
0.0017250211,
-0.0042874184,
-0.0323624387,
0.0229640715,
-0.013566833,
-0.0579290725,
0.0008164117,
0.0699282363,
-0.0215122346,
-0.0221836604,
-0.037764702,
0.0220397953,
-0.0315293968,
0.0834396333,
0.002310826,
-0.0286313295,
-0.0249517485,
-0.0235618409,
-0.0296538994,
-0.0178047866,
-0.0305731874,
-0.0075019943,
0.0864246711,
-0.0027577933,
-0.0489465222,
-0.0226579662,
0.0057783667,
0.0407223813,
-0.0254359823,
-0.0236472394,
0.0244046971,
0.0135686863,
-0.0559962615,
0.0230405424,
-0.0186906792,
0.0309203751,
-0.0087444494,
0.0233105477,
0.0296962745,
-0.0394065157,
-0.0504663959,
0.0092372168,
-0.0893170163,
-0.0510350093,
0.0190135147,
0.0277220644,
0.0332644433,
0.0135471374,
-0.0062234579,
-0.0235747471,
-0.0152113121,
0.0262527131,
-0.0186935868,
0.0399038643,
0.0493434481,
0.0022650997,
0.0165658277,
0.0642659515,
0.0056340108,
-0.0139323082,
0.0256026499,
0.0394065678,
-0.0358959287,
0.0234535486,
0.0371903889,
-0.0046525477,
0.0623146407,
0.0179185234,
-0.0181352161,
-0.0264847167,
0.0377121828,
-0.0500700995,
-0.0321056545,
-0.0099081583,
0.0120648844,
0.0152134337,
-0.0051167584,
-0.0136015546,
-0.0008668787,
-0.0208892524,
0.0017388184,
-0.0171885714,
0.0312619843,
0.0863928124,
0.0154363271,
0.0236791689,
-0.0242858008,
-0.0079973191,
0.0283772461,
-0.0103293443,
0.0558746234,
-0.0089133997,
0.0724338144,
0.0422796197,
-0.0398335643,
-0.037917275,
-0.021181114,
-0.0894380063,
-0.0433438495,
0.0232526287,
0.0449208729,
0.0327272601,
-0.026000848,
0.0056043686,
-0.0414218046,
-0.0073131463,
-0.0054466757,
0.0181304459,
0.032769911,
-0.0328310654,
0.0705766603,
0.0382117294,
-0.0175476559,
0.0275720488,
0.0618943162,
-0.003732977,
0.054550916,
-0.0041126707,
0.0060364651,
-0.0161396433,
-0.0608922206,
0.0257026162,
0.0499792024,
0.0006294993,
0.038199842,
-0.1035105735,
-0.0667934641,
-0.0140649909,
0.0351786613,
0.0134310052,
0.0042425729,
0.0077812215,
0.0686247051,
0.016026983,
-0.0427771062,
-0.0161070544,
0.0316214599,
-0.0053683347,
0.0237191245,
-0.0553026199,
-6.725407992e-33,
-0.0125328004,
-0.0145772183,
0.0331455581,
-0.0805912241,
0.0310489479,
-0.0143289994,
-0.0160507336,
0.0202235654,
-0.0651851445,
0.0135426605,
-0.0006788457,
0.0372186154,
0.019858731,
0.0226352736,
-0.002048379,
-0.0261221118,
0.0101672662,
0.0050848541,
-0.0296755303,
-0.0227596927,
0.0236885082,
-0.029043192,
0.0326960273,
-0.063307181,
-0.0000724116,
0.0021197118,
-0.0152174635,
0.0343003124,
-0.1012892798,
0.0544217303,
-0.013780986,
0.0055153826,
0.0276739374,
0.0060234419,
0.0020047259,
-0.0086659547,
-0.0010629595,
-0.0139931375,
0.0508597381,
0.0050491551,
-0.0197501816,
0.0063269464,
-0.0137021523,
0.0114804683,
-0.0339043066,
-0.0048727691,
0.0124892956,
-0.0427582078,
0.0230366513,
0.0470571034,
-0.0426281206,
0.0214073248,
-0.0307369623,
-0.0139509914,
-0.0179022178,
0.0826261342,
0.0116221616,
0.0151569359,
-0.0590245686,
0.061234206,
0.0129448771,
-0.0320918523,
0.0786041021,
0.0127180526,
0.028692212,
0.0543447435,
0.0464269035,
0.0027346443,
-0.031560611,
-0.0167978071,
0.0155812856,
0.0627849102,
0.0518788695,
0.1149082333,
0.0520479493,
-0.0188837778,
-0.0731050149,
-0.0264782161,
-0.0426739417,
0.0415860862,
0.0733647868,
0.0203045234,
-0.0104037877,
-0.0012545582,
-0.0733972937,
-0.0121689839,
-0.0537188463,
0.0352802873,
0.0285751894,
0.0073824376,
-0.016479414,
0.0265402067,
0.0521273725,
-0.0360005237,
0.0032197183,
0.0339541174,
-0.0108993519,
0.012949748,
0.0083017182,
0.0757675022,
-0.0524245203,
0.0182085652,
0.0481201932,
-0.0134365745,
0.0037338759,
-0.0137274349,
0.0127401315,
0.0146922683,
-0.053176064,
-0.0194399022,
-0.0392138734,
-0.0133602424,
0.0056671081,
-0.0242096689,
0.0621936284,
0.0161608215,
-0.0210960936,
0.001838806,
0.0039664335,
-0.0266965125,
-0.0496818274,
-0.0245292969,
-0.015529722,
0.0239315741,
0.0048071952,
-0.0124164158,
-0.0562497675,
-0.0338089354,
0.0211540721,
-0.0204893537,
-0.0182369482,
0.0485600904,
2.707e-7,
0.0319337808,
0.0480776243,
-0.0000979253,
0.0184358247,
0.0198893733,
0.0759180561,
-0.0487505458,
-0.0073150638,
0.0495186001,
-0.0263783447,
-0.0004148927,
0.0438705124,
0.017456606,
0.0170265865,
0.0152416108,
0.0242163539,
-0.0482032336,
-0.0520769171,
-0.0420270152,
0.0031473073,
0.077988252,
0.0970842093,
0.0090918886,
0.0014031125,
0.0294553488,
-0.0104056159,
0.0538654253,
-0.0519813523,
-0.0142402798,
-0.0423676781,
-0.0205283053,
0.0080118561,
-0.0059880493,
0.0565751493,
0.0058019101,
-0.0230116397,
-0.019652253,
0.0445744544,
-0.0068732607,
-0.0616253018,
-0.0380220227,
-0.0011084122,
-0.0183999073,
-0.063360095,
0.1040843129,
-0.0164365806,
-0.0310235377,
0.0203215536,
-0.0221718382,
0.0202867445,
0.0237382371,
-0.0075064944,
-0.0395162329,
-0.0154289678,
0.0185283627,
0.0040404834,
-0.0065576625,
-0.061743889,
-0.0286200177,
0.0263445918,
-0.037565738,
-0.0443032235,
-0.0430022441,
-0.0079041207,
0.048256509,
-0.0499478914,
-0.015510126,
2.581809874e-34,
0.06272199,
0.0304542091,
-0.0041466537,
-0.0233735386,
0.0467103943,
-0.0191862099,
-0.0074912128,
0.0077227643,
0.0196488779,
-0.0773335844,
-0.0213348102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06626v1 | Topic-DPR: Topic-based Prompts for Dense Passage Retrieval | 2023-10-10T13:45:24 | 2023-10-10T13:45:24 | Qingfa Xiao, Shuangyin Li, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt-based learning's efficacy across numerous natural language processing
tasks has led to its integration into dense passage retrieval. Prior research
has mainly focused on enhancing the semantic understanding of pre-trained
language models by optimizing a single vector as a continuous prompt. This
approach, however, leads to a semantic space collapse; identical semantic
information seeps into all representations, causing their distributions to
converge in a restricted region. This hinders differentiation between relevant
and irrelevant passages during dense retrieval. To tackle this issue, we
present Topic-DPR, a dense passage retrieval model that uses topic-based
prompts. Unlike the single prompt method, multiple topic-based prompts are
established over a probabilistic simplex and optimized simultaneously through
contrastive learning. This encourages representations to align with their topic
distributions, improving space uniformity. Furthermore, we introduce a novel
positive and negative sampling strategy, leveraging semi-structured data to
boost dense retrieval efficiency. Experimental results from two datasets affirm
that our method surpasses previous state-of-the-art retrieval techniques. | [
0.0196998622,
-0.010204046,
-0.0156912152,
0.003252655,
-0.0417981632,
-0.0105234785,
0.0484599881,
-0.0074095535,
0.0030791124,
-0.0307818372,
-0.0115613192,
-0.0667137876,
-0.0024102852,
0.0676524937,
-0.001668699,
-0.0807855129,
0.0368708223,
-0.0363567807,
0.0647481009,
0.0191775896,
0.019501403,
-0.0119456844,
-0.0026546244,
0.0005734708,
0.021114137,
-0.0045527346,
-0.0214817449,
0.0063831341,
0.0262649078,
-0.0737841949,
0.0498515852,
0.049968116,
0.0378968231,
-0.0322248563,
0.000001832,
-0.0417122431,
-0.0513148159,
-0.0156839807,
-0.024094969,
-0.0344027802,
0.0608029664,
0.0084218811,
0.0602599047,
-0.0151467109,
0.0086903693,
-0.034718316,
0.0035013743,
0.0824664831,
0.0352907553,
0.0537699498,
-0.0137681002,
0.0021643739,
-0.0169370528,
-0.0012948533,
0.0108306864,
-0.028074529,
0.0164546445,
-0.0313874409,
0.0304131471,
0.0891779289,
-0.0086988658,
0.0264101755,
-0.0052378569,
0.0186092574,
0.0354603007,
0.0320615433,
0.0192373842,
0.0160440467,
-0.0362107828,
0.071584031,
0.0162019376,
-0.014545734,
-0.0024989145,
-0.043214906,
-0.0219435487,
0.0111249387,
-0.0589517877,
0.0337774679,
-0.0297613349,
0.0180073343,
-0.0002486953,
0.0483938046,
0.0030217941,
-0.0174337048,
-0.0082504628,
-0.0000527758,
0.0273921229,
-0.0463858806,
0.0226911642,
0.0091097932,
-0.0327752456,
-0.0018367915,
0.0559059791,
0.0055540339,
-0.0258956086,
0.0120172938,
0.0036132582,
-0.048374027,
0.016762482,
0.0158334915,
0.0119795166,
0.0243683718,
-0.0522404946,
0.0459049791,
0.0132589554,
0.0282920189,
0.0109239435,
0.0028444799,
-0.0578552298,
0.0183935817,
0.0021948447,
0.0063170092,
-0.0722623244,
0.0446783453,
-0.036362078,
-0.0206859875,
0.0155541915,
0.0121118203,
0.0231068637,
-0.0095791453,
-0.0258548744,
0.0231267102,
-0.0414013006,
-0.0119936783,
-0.0216788501,
0.0502167381,
-0.0455062911,
-0.0066204458,
-0.001446536,
0.0195482224,
-0.0220879596,
-0.006434557,
0.0277574956,
-0.0282064043,
-0.0283814017,
-0.0044617155,
-0.0396829844,
-0.0957248509,
-0.0492094904,
-0.0158175491,
-0.0222533848,
-0.014035698,
-0.0386687927,
-0.0387242734,
0.0349830985,
-0.0007723493,
0.0041275518,
-0.0240983758,
0.0138778752,
0.047140263,
-0.0295381658,
0.0562818423,
-0.0074725803,
-0.017453745,
0.0283509083,
0.046725031,
0.0170510281,
0.0364083797,
-0.0160589106,
0.0284755398,
0.0661941171,
0.0476833507,
-0.0016049807,
-0.0064094313,
0.0044103824,
-0.0001219277,
-0.0156311225,
0.0134564303,
0.0305369031,
0.005586748,
0.0011638277,
0.0351291671,
-0.0514439754,
-0.0326029509,
0.0427985676,
0.0648388267,
0.0003724711,
-0.0487830676,
0.0414164886,
0.0483171679,
-0.0166679733,
0.0276230518,
-0.0181891974,
-0.0146242576,
-0.0362912454,
0.0151714981,
0.0663531348,
-0.0024240515,
-0.0192032699,
0.0018058447,
0.0019401175,
-0.0006572535,
-0.0246165991,
0.0139701497,
0.0654507428,
0.007876737,
-0.0660827607,
0.0230284799,
0.0432026312,
-0.0513425767,
0.0087297708,
0.0148165505,
0.0678165704,
0.0728683174,
0.0733980536,
-0.0729363859,
-0.0116423648,
-0.006429228,
0.0430220701,
0.0176492743,
0.0294636115,
-0.0281199329,
0.0178064685,
-0.0429332405,
-0.0386753045,
0.0177499522,
-0.0018664133,
0.0197341871,
0.0044848192,
0.0072128526,
0.0078113484,
-0.0496005639,
0.0016215261,
0.040091496,
-0.0174935013,
-0.0182683375,
-0.004642433,
0.0030001628,
-0.0063616773,
0.0390754789,
-0.0060700728,
-0.0116413971,
0.0454934463,
-0.0397608131,
-0.0006834764,
-0.0296200477,
-0.1055078357,
-0.0324337482,
-0.0115728229,
0.0112176063,
0.016167812,
0.0042413161,
0.011132231,
-0.031742394,
-0.0439831689,
-0.0039615366,
-0.0068465704,
-0.0146597195,
0.0149325589,
0.0229514875,
-0.0120276976,
-0.1042792201,
0.0733574703,
0.0198200438,
0.0766025335,
0.0622213893,
0.046087984,
0.0345951617,
-0.0553321689,
-0.0329975486,
0.0105555588,
-0.0006145939,
-0.0181982834,
0.0770274475,
-0.0236704834,
-0.0385981537,
0.0009387354,
-0.0644404218,
0.0274733622,
-0.0208436735,
-0.0121151898,
0.0223104637,
0.0071475748,
-0.0400407016,
-0.0313605629,
-0.0130239483,
-0.0474762805,
0.008288838,
0.0232516434,
0.0276855342,
0.0327154323,
0.0164038576,
-0.0550476164,
-0.0172998514,
0.0020172365,
0.0448758639,
-0.0025881398,
-0.0136881694,
-0.0598750114,
0.04996261,
0.036388468,
0.0146005061,
-0.0201859903,
0.0233709123,
0.0128328623,
-0.0681852698,
0.0681790784,
0.0247166511,
0.0232078265,
-0.0004699132,
0.0396476276,
-0.0591154173,
-0.0869866237,
0.0297851954,
-0.0430875644,
0.0130869169,
0.0128095057,
-0.0123731429,
0.029067615,
0.0402249917,
0.0315387584,
0.0066382266,
-0.0247999299,
-0.0163829513,
-0.0188015439,
0.0047385148,
-0.0527967215,
-0.006146173,
-0.0331140831,
0.0575808473,
-0.0262341704,
-0.0324080363,
0.0676489472,
-0.0388892256,
-0.0259296726,
-0.0820147619,
0.0084143877,
-0.0289889891,
0.0928422511,
-0.0071063624,
0.0043354323,
0.0316646472,
-0.0539435297,
-0.0410924517,
-0.0047535752,
0.018040292,
-0.0221008398,
0.0351869091,
-0.0220892783,
0.0219772924,
-0.0192308761,
-0.0208056737,
-0.0721568316,
-0.0933696702,
0.0061501358,
-0.0132904947,
-0.0254264306,
0.0025380731,
-0.0105752284,
0.017590018,
0.0082699908,
0.0443277806,
-0.0287574828,
-0.0161128398,
-0.0272349175,
0.0675821081,
0.0348270014,
0.0056963055,
-0.0147800185,
-0.0211632419,
0.0343074203,
0.0256704763,
-0.0048958967,
-0.0227196459,
0.0265481174,
0.0107933525,
0.0663134158,
-0.0674788207,
0.0070574437,
0.0225689821,
0.071515426,
-0.0548334308,
-0.0470750257,
0.1071503833,
0.0515185967,
-0.0626069978,
-0.0510327853,
-0.018990688,
0.0175484996,
-0.0060258056,
0.010657073,
-0.0540578067,
-0.0239390302,
0.0108828722,
0.0619242676,
0.0310195889,
-0.0284964293,
-0.0135359531,
-0.0716477707,
0.0158731304,
0.0003395115,
-0.0139792152,
-0.0345673412,
-0.0572495647,
0.0209508818,
0.0081787072,
-0.0008643911,
0.0360784382,
-0.025382556,
0.0184228588,
-0.0173188616,
0.0399457328,
0.0208573341,
0.0081080068,
-0.0372900739,
0.0222652722,
0.0186507907,
-0.0039292728,
0.0094053298,
-0.0001320303,
-0.0064980472,
-0.090248391,
-0.0174063239,
-0.00594872,
0.0514253713,
-0.0031642793,
0.007848192,
-0.0430778414,
0.013250391,
0.0032490524,
-0.0695021003,
-0.0063872831,
0.0143675646,
-0.0106365969,
-0.0043786881,
-0.0501950011,
0.0447171517,
0.0302219465,
0.083879523,
-0.0152050434,
-0.0014329068,
-0.0177496895,
0.0004145241,
0.0469841175,
-0.0107358964,
-0.0232894402,
-0.0068358383,
-0.0103641357,
0.0276119746,
-0.059603747,
-0.0419235118,
0.001949364,
0.0243963599,
0.0048069046,
0.0263618976,
-0.0320498869,
0.002701076,
-0.0290761143,
0.0615183897,
-0.0527310744,
0.0016924897,
-0.0650497973,
-0.0344434492,
0.0313169882,
-0.0587898567,
-0.0204842985,
-0.0023897241,
-0.0440253317,
-0.0369635262,
0.0172138941,
-0.0092858328,
0.0044159032,
0.0277182758,
-0.0179141313,
-0.0134275658,
0.0958751589,
0.030021837,
-0.077252537,
0.007671067,
-0.0092577878,
0.0254114103,
-0.0383958332,
0.0070435354,
-0.0535907149,
0.0304277278,
0.0083893621,
0.0456372052,
-0.0120333908,
-0.1222632676,
0.0144877573,
0.0012983885,
0.1010625884,
0.0364442356,
0.0106520038,
-0.0907845721,
-0.0155169526,
0.0138304578,
-0.0250884313,
-0.015140756,
0.0549471527,
0.0074147005,
-0.0470931791,
-0.0353281647,
0.0370674543,
-0.0103849657,
0.0678260848,
-0.0394104719,
-0.0244810227,
0.0409218743,
-0.0289285351,
-0.006692911,
0.0165516473,
-0.0134231355,
0.0195340328,
-0.0417000912,
0.0596527942,
-0.0013689293,
0.0876157954,
0.0132376039,
-0.0256162938,
-0.0265602469,
0.0150046451,
-0.0915684029,
-0.0175550207,
0.0020757932,
0.0136096617,
0.0259763226,
-0.0214912351,
0.0072284103,
-0.0045712995,
0.0057900455,
-0.0299293716,
-0.0223635454,
0.0493841693,
0.014444896,
0.0366341583,
0.0386336446,
0.0066308454,
0.0492193773,
0.0565666892,
-0.0346568376,
0.0263376776,
0.0129442066,
-0.0274092574,
-0.0316961519,
-0.0036386044,
0.0300206877,
0.0851873979,
-0.0062299529,
-0.0067053861,
-0.0241365042,
0.0030978562,
0.0660880506,
-0.0013365488,
-0.0236168467,
0.0033961039,
0.046957165,
0.0533724241,
-0.0196766984,
-0.0148656266,
-0.032404162,
0.0297432635,
0.0228831638,
-0.0158848576,
-0.0400720276,
-6.168053223e-33,
-0.033184316,
-0.0010858742,
-0.0059048529,
-0.0171713475,
-0.0284802765,
0.0096313236,
-0.0149616217,
-0.0003207924,
0.0225941148,
0.0072108191,
-0.0187884402,
-0.0053000115,
0.0185176693,
0.0193498451,
-0.0358972438,
-0.0267315004,
0.0648763403,
0.0070431777,
-0.0320913531,
0.0388760827,
0.0528955348,
0.0520798713,
-0.0185274146,
-0.0504067913,
0.0559996255,
-0.0536048561,
0.0192596726,
0.0215938985,
0.0767940432,
0.0194264669,
-0.0345698483,
0.0374438427,
0.01930416,
-0.0400157981,
-0.0299084689,
0.0576003045,
-0.090660803,
-0.0605987646,
-0.0073018619,
-0.0221803766,
-0.0248060971,
-0.0255213473,
-0.001676286,
-0.0350774638,
0.0567890294,
0.0081211664,
0.0462047867,
0.0065893065,
-0.0174034014,
-0.0357474163,
-0.0266586356,
0.0319788717,
-0.0161962789,
-0.0148326745,
0.0112575563,
0.0384595655,
0.0593613945,
0.0273123775,
-0.017985031,
0.0153977657,
-0.0007584018,
0.0351702385,
-0.0495399535,
0.0190395098,
-0.0491924211,
0.0640595332,
0.0140186902,
-0.025487233,
0.0071394173,
-0.0037631292,
0.005292675,
-0.0501209348,
-0.0094606094,
0.0501733907,
-0.0005426533,
0.0145889353,
-0.037445873,
0.0619426332,
0.0324415341,
-0.011972595,
0.0442222729,
0.0152199753,
-0.0349643528,
-0.0322265066,
-0.0433052219,
-0.034598127,
-0.0157684032,
-0.0134173026,
0.0349725224,
0.0307420287,
-0.0161137935,
0.0022780546,
0.0663040802,
0.0104767783,
0.0016737777,
0.017619146,
-0.0050393273,
0.003153597,
0.0008575409,
0.0154061941,
-0.032717146,
-0.0159296636,
0.0386446901,
-0.0384134054,
-0.0482892655,
0.0128780734,
0.0078538628,
0.0043671224,
-0.0837309435,
0.018492721,
0.026024092,
-0.0117340451,
-0.0155888833,
0.0518042743,
0.0186306331,
0.0161473006,
0.0024479115,
0.1020915061,
0.0390927717,
-0.0041969414,
-0.05007907,
-0.0214121584,
-0.0219037123,
0.0032900327,
-0.0093654813,
0.0280497484,
-0.0091610244,
0.0431516692,
0.0108270729,
-0.0358087793,
0.0287394766,
0.032533288,
2.442e-7,
0.0208831001,
-0.0060474146,
0.0306184404,
0.0017195272,
-0.0274923705,
0.0259208735,
0.0029163796,
0.0183599424,
0.0326734148,
-0.0266206786,
0.0107915485,
0.0386134833,
-0.0233589001,
0.0125252428,
-0.1280676723,
-0.0100795366,
-0.0016706975,
-0.0318463333,
-0.062144734,
-0.0260098837,
0.1109918579,
0.0604742505,
0.0063035209,
0.0069718151,
-0.0039074486,
-0.0461227931,
0.0337123908,
-0.0152224302,
-0.0134780472,
0.0242183041,
0.0522211827,
0.0165665634,
-0.0174861569,
-0.014400186,
0.0261046905,
0.0432055704,
0.0299744792,
0.0575676411,
0.0422270596,
-0.0573092774,
-0.0014685798,
-0.0002300277,
-0.0000764026,
-0.0041108006,
0.0639479384,
-0.028507242,
0.0193788521,
-0.0070013762,
-0.0302300714,
-0.0269261077,
0.0098221125,
0.0184977781,
-0.0498640873,
0.0453830399,
-0.0038906173,
0.0196184609,
-0.0058653634,
-0.1158195361,
-0.0216770638,
-0.0006762142,
-0.0229508393,
-0.0178927723,
-0.0109170061,
-0.0032383329,
-0.0172142386,
-0.0943559334,
0.0280979071,
2.203271306e-34,
0.0246281493,
-0.0149289416,
-0.0335222632,
-0.0178923011,
0.0091606285,
-0.0220929943,
0.0135889463,
-0.0107668536,
0.0008238509,
-0.0875087604,
-0.026467409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06590v1 | No Pitch Left Behind: Addressing Gender Unbalance in Automatic Speech Recognition through Pitch Manipulation | 2023-10-10T12:55:22 | 2023-10-10T12:55:22 | Dennis Fucci, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri, Mauro Cettolo, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems are known to be sensitive to the
sociolinguistic variability of speech data, in which gender plays a crucial
role. This can result in disparities in recognition accuracy between male and
female speakers, primarily due to the under-representation of the latter group
in the training data. While in the context of hybrid ASR models several
solutions have been proposed, the gender bias issue has not been explicitly
addressed in end-to-end neural architectures. To fill this gap, we propose a
data augmentation technique that manipulates the fundamental frequency (f0) and
formants. This technique reduces the data unbalance among genders by simulating
voices of the under-represented female speakers and increases the variability
within each gender group. Experiments on spontaneous English speech show that
our technique yields a relative WER improvement up to 9.87% for utterances by
female speakers, with larger gains for the least-represented f0 ranges. | [
-0.0076134545,
0.0882339925,
-0.0212963596,
-0.0027417797,
0.0223342665,
-0.0024307247,
0.0338893011,
-0.0477505848,
-0.0348085277,
0.0204691868,
-0.058680594,
-0.0813366696,
0.0555889755,
0.0643870756,
0.0479991436,
-0.0407497622,
-0.0079504503,
-0.0313024782,
0.0303177498,
-0.0571687631,
0.002622792,
-0.0026368643,
-0.0375228152,
0.0200560335,
0.0044328729,
0.0048764669,
-0.0199589655,
0.031260062,
0.0213572681,
0.0351357684,
0.0283159316,
0.0318789892,
0.0228411034,
0.0063958056,
0.0000018881,
-0.0431685895,
0.0107410019,
0.0354832634,
-0.0798591301,
0.0107414182,
0.0326409712,
0.0333713852,
-0.064040333,
0.031992171,
-0.023171721,
-0.0210182127,
0.0371260718,
0.0281381831,
0.0176581349,
0.030431319,
-0.0051435721,
0.0089612585,
-0.0063755475,
-0.0291485842,
-0.0076014092,
0.0387837775,
-0.0051037264,
-0.0400381237,
-0.0374718904,
-0.0255878288,
-0.030008411,
0.0319646485,
0.0132271526,
0.0199505109,
0.0562104322,
0.0306006353,
-0.0743532479,
-0.0539880581,
-0.0087253731,
0.032439813,
0.0131977666,
0.0106581394,
-0.0037631055,
0.0056787981,
-0.0028630756,
-0.0414291024,
-0.0221489947,
0.0065252823,
0.0385012142,
-0.0065289261,
-0.0238789003,
-0.0362734944,
0.0523546413,
-0.0098666921,
0.0088709006,
0.0296798069,
-0.0183551498,
-0.0472096354,
0.044044517,
-0.0269038957,
-0.0070860554,
-0.0054320088,
0.0579825304,
0.0003152395,
0.0168146715,
-0.0249425173,
-0.0464585163,
-0.0590609536,
0.0104076201,
-0.0731568933,
-0.0007323007,
0.0639242306,
-0.009813372,
-0.0571327098,
-0.0069575151,
0.0349485204,
0.0000546186,
-0.0165188704,
-0.0134888925,
-0.0255455058,
0.0265966244,
-0.0249975082,
0.0004377948,
0.0021552371,
-0.029408874,
0.0044777808,
-0.0538110659,
0.0087771462,
-0.0805166885,
-0.0237534139,
0.01049951,
0.0328146778,
-0.0497705713,
0.0121492567,
0.0382295549,
0.0440704748,
-0.0168567449,
0.0485729761,
0.0070373295,
-0.1288496554,
-0.0080223633,
0.0025574053,
0.0419397503,
0.0129498616,
0.0311953761,
-0.0033212826,
0.0147997318,
0.009554931,
-0.0216884539,
0.0140677495,
-0.00886764,
-0.0444400869,
0.0147716422,
-0.056547191,
0.0174853392,
0.0221383758,
-0.0175855476,
-0.0149092348,
-0.0013860319,
-0.0160234403,
0.0229759607,
0.029170651,
0.0214426704,
-0.0038621207,
0.0778950229,
-0.0188038573,
-0.0336637944,
0.0614091866,
0.0661028475,
-0.0296833869,
-0.0138270333,
-0.0166066457,
-0.0130912084,
0.0567449369,
0.0413629897,
0.0376244187,
-0.0196775664,
-0.0449018516,
-0.0309781078,
0.041723635,
0.1160876676,
-0.0610587895,
0.0271568801,
-0.0508490503,
0.0501933694,
0.0698775649,
0.0710560009,
0.0400881357,
-0.0001332712,
-0.0201210845,
0.0098319044,
-0.0078185108,
-0.0542093702,
0.013620113,
-0.0022407323,
0.0003527411,
0.0027813578,
0.0710040927,
-0.032986287,
-0.0347903483,
0.0020541844,
-0.0087652747,
-0.0077885049,
0.0364628993,
-0.0009608374,
0.0221391153,
0.0565432161,
0.0392961986,
0.0282715242,
-0.0596481785,
0.0399037525,
-0.0228413269,
-0.0688552484,
0.0087043913,
-0.0400204808,
-0.0524445921,
-0.0040597599,
-0.0373024419,
-0.0559953414,
0.0381561182,
0.024115406,
0.044634603,
0.0728644356,
-0.0473618098,
0.0039925333,
0.0591357686,
0.0061705536,
0.0653856173,
0.0056045265,
0.0258850232,
0.0122300368,
-0.0165359005,
-0.0234709177,
-0.0304791667,
-0.018836543,
-0.0268819742,
0.0322057493,
0.0102128331,
0.0398978479,
0.0380606577,
-0.0308535881,
-0.0122771934,
0.0153137762,
-0.0026093947,
-0.0261900872,
0.0023543085,
-0.0361016393,
0.0129925478,
0.0293713026,
-0.0507622361,
-0.0090140868,
0.0406003483,
0.0231787395,
-0.0746847317,
0.1078012511,
-0.0289972797,
-0.0000886172,
-0.0417845696,
0.0321373641,
0.0289021451,
0.0368126668,
0.0354082435,
-0.0348833613,
0.0202409476,
-0.0611642972,
0.0020981515,
-0.0165542215,
-0.0441066287,
-0.1192770302,
0.0064189304,
0.0293517392,
0.0069310446,
0.0262451917,
-0.0045716856,
-0.0731130391,
-0.0305768028,
-0.0111637376,
-0.0570705011,
-0.0130493008,
0.0069149719,
0.0073423604,
-0.0161249693,
0.0436261706,
-0.0138293058,
-0.0442085862,
-0.0392177925,
-0.0421065874,
-0.0134374108,
0.008620657,
-0.0265681949,
-0.0000581312,
0.0160640217,
0.0109345634,
-0.0197683163,
-0.0152211562,
0.002572441,
-0.0022248835,
-0.013733645,
-0.0131061338,
-0.0335118622,
0.0392329171,
0.0321414135,
-0.0060055447,
-0.0094283624,
-0.0458579585,
0.0185398124,
0.0366852656,
0.0873662978,
0.0093390383,
-0.039268747,
0.0412995294,
0.0221880209,
-0.0172781758,
0.0053879335,
0.0367776342,
0.0649461821,
0.0196088124,
-0.0242977701,
-0.0311669596,
-0.0232758876,
0.0322579108,
0.0039622909,
-0.0191643182,
0.0251388811,
-0.0259120092,
-0.0426106229,
-0.0135116754,
-0.0406696238,
-0.0303245541,
0.0070084706,
-0.0444477983,
-0.0300384127,
-0.0099201472,
-0.0420145728,
-0.0460438058,
-0.0038518854,
-0.031694185,
-0.0496438406,
-0.0390192159,
-0.0157779027,
0.0001232816,
0.0035204876,
-0.0190000832,
-0.0223344322,
-0.0085104583,
0.0029158939,
-0.0687001348,
0.0524826609,
-0.0044659865,
-0.0074013351,
-0.0214328729,
-0.0249254145,
-0.0218611136,
0.0190507453,
-0.0060613025,
0.0369583145,
-0.0217356402,
-0.0134122763,
0.0132294558,
0.0023732076,
0.0272115637,
0.0756308436,
-0.0374505036,
0.01925149,
-0.0197747014,
-0.0201805029,
-0.0022819818,
0.0773070753,
-0.0238739345,
-0.0117049506,
-0.0044716615,
-0.0418870673,
0.0421637371,
0.0176283494,
-0.0233774185,
0.0378885902,
0.0287507381,
0.0069167735,
0.0055610696,
-0.0276331548,
-0.0000569749,
-0.0611244105,
0.0566815995,
0.0634196252,
0.00324772,
-0.047062479,
-0.0044300039,
-0.0245412253,
0.0344099328,
0.0180096254,
0.0027493879,
-0.0111097852,
0.0308790635,
0.065947853,
0.0256636236,
-0.0137128318,
0.0130177438,
-0.0406013504,
-0.0992658064,
0.0425408706,
0.044490613,
-0.0249903779,
-0.0474239811,
-0.0318906717,
0.003714185,
-0.0319838263,
0.0642924607,
0.0152493902,
-0.029810885,
-0.017251743,
0.048563581,
-0.0665617362,
-0.0384699777,
-0.0112083005,
-0.0607348047,
0.0718628392,
0.040598236,
0.008464952,
-0.0410110541,
-0.0363184102,
0.000600707,
0.0367288664,
0.0226884894,
-0.0251174662,
0.0391020179,
0.0286590382,
-0.0205154251,
0.0006145195,
0.070137009,
0.0000743053,
0.0027234771,
-0.0091996882,
0.012917662,
0.0121296598,
0.0418868251,
-0.0088876886,
0.0033289685,
-0.0225438867,
0.0335203297,
0.0228392743,
-0.0214087255,
0.0163601357,
-0.0133978073,
0.0568985641,
0.0008901433,
-0.0295581296,
0.0196097866,
0.0670383424,
-0.0839936361,
0.0283626635,
-0.0089037837,
-0.0234525967,
0.023701923,
0.0090840021,
-0.0387072749,
0.0337266997,
0.0057853083,
-0.0306192711,
0.0225848705,
-0.0213916562,
0.0306916684,
-0.0140586747,
-0.0603879765,
-0.0282227769,
-0.087715894,
-0.012190463,
-0.0230609197,
-0.0068595172,
-0.0428788178,
0.0803955495,
-0.0045026233,
0.0218480844,
0.0954267383,
-0.0447734147,
-0.0584687516,
0.0408333391,
0.0152341062,
-0.0273949821,
0.0638404116,
0.0936326906,
-0.0288841985,
-0.0002040344,
0.0121923331,
-0.0490139127,
0.0359241255,
-0.0053292578,
-0.0151243731,
0.0143771553,
-0.0242369305,
-0.014740576,
0.039578598,
0.0020952492,
-0.0166514553,
0.0340111516,
-0.0353786759,
0.0461849347,
-0.0014401942,
0.0553743951,
-0.002947256,
-0.0257980786,
0.0377869308,
0.0492544249,
0.0166467652,
0.0017845003,
-0.0276079718,
-0.0399722867,
0.0134367589,
0.0508633219,
-0.0142245777,
0.0312782191,
-0.0211219881,
0.0431992933,
0.0087696183,
0.0287710577,
0.0088258442,
0.0173908919,
0.0307626538,
-0.019305367,
-0.0091697965,
-0.0166862812,
-0.047698684,
0.0253290813,
-0.0668521374,
-0.0217595641,
-0.0183724742,
-0.0081347935,
-0.0010722586,
-0.003919492,
0.038715262,
0.0046839598,
0.0087971063,
0.0145967901,
-0.043127723,
-0.0291838441,
0.0490585528,
0.0142665729,
0.0143629173,
0.0230677519,
0.0204922538,
0.0066035846,
0.0308426991,
0.0393029079,
-0.0521647632,
0.0069198809,
0.0046215858,
-0.0262711849,
-0.0184292737,
-0.0367188342,
-0.0429996178,
-0.0213193335,
-0.0348786749,
-0.0541397855,
0.0275878143,
-0.0056503122,
0.0294314735,
-0.0286657792,
-0.0022686881,
-0.0183931645,
-0.0542965755,
-0.0357200541,
0.0255336463,
-0.0632835552,
0.023914542,
-0.0132798832,
0.0136455698,
-6.309712782e-33,
-0.0302474704,
0.0282449741,
0.0006310163,
0.0169437062,
-0.0537439808,
0.0347262397,
-0.0080962228,
0.0240099151,
-0.0002972608,
-0.0112965545,
-0.0311565697,
0.0195995905,
0.038420815,
0.0206097811,
-0.0121356286,
0.0161952972,
0.1047742814,
0.0260975845,
0.0222884845,
-0.0597852394,
0.0042043347,
0.0412109829,
0.0336293578,
-0.0490367264,
-0.0113548888,
0.02221944,
-0.0122402394,
-0.0086103668,
-0.0095177786,
0.0124847181,
0.0144081386,
0.0861073434,
-0.0033021483,
-0.0457414053,
0.02634985,
0.045667924,
-0.1003353745,
-0.0170775503,
-0.0482180119,
0.0575572662,
0.0514897369,
-0.0151195601,
0.0566137992,
0.0318794698,
-0.0485796034,
-0.0377909765,
0.0247907974,
-0.028479198,
0.0557549223,
-0.0326027945,
0.0026895762,
0.0265154224,
0.0018613962,
-0.0048267571,
0.0425121449,
0.0340141952,
-0.0531158745,
-0.026493961,
-0.0760891065,
0.0188064091,
0.0424384885,
0.0039406936,
0.0072486191,
0.0750783607,
0.0237175655,
0.0021508958,
0.0973690003,
-0.0205152873,
0.0058070933,
-0.0765364543,
0.0416498296,
-0.0504557453,
0.0177760292,
0.0045524645,
0.1080359668,
0.00482562,
-0.0064729648,
-0.0352029502,
0.0312305465,
0.005412465,
0.0002822602,
0.0121471602,
-0.0675745904,
-0.0100657549,
-0.0547018796,
-0.073028475,
-0.050900016,
-0.0339285135,
0.0111390371,
-0.0119900443,
0.00356093,
0.01318393,
-0.0346736647,
-0.0536644235,
0.0221021175,
-0.0348420627,
0.0278908741,
-0.0298664868,
0.0395413563,
-0.0171624981,
-0.0150972763,
0.0184824783,
0.0606082305,
0.0757877827,
-0.0060545169,
-0.0171063505,
0.0027598722,
0.0633690283,
-0.0419153012,
-0.0164106898,
-0.0089919893,
0.0230334476,
0.0456120074,
0.043284487,
0.0248846747,
0.0329103917,
0.0035461828,
0.0167179815,
0.0121996701,
0.0365271643,
-0.038590543,
0.02105687,
-0.0112141604,
0.0525815077,
-0.0165385753,
0.0000714801,
0.0413943976,
-0.0242046379,
0.0264301095,
-0.0684962943,
-0.0012839155,
-0.0229393709,
2.798e-7,
-0.0532149598,
-0.0031216443,
0.0664293319,
-0.0301032476,
0.0169444289,
0.0206025895,
-0.0314218104,
0.0144819161,
0.0517045595,
0.0184846744,
-0.0067948462,
0.0457161777,
0.0016384422,
0.0224544201,
-0.0556432158,
-0.0111506255,
-0.0580901504,
0.0163053796,
0.0358804613,
0.0084260385,
-0.0565671921,
0.0639049485,
0.0179007947,
-0.0788768381,
0.0207594354,
0.0127813658,
-0.0155022014,
0.0097106555,
0.0114545878,
-0.0325004272,
-0.0521566868,
0.0056323004,
0.0022047779,
0.0411838479,
-0.0215614457,
0.0619414896,
-0.0072145164,
-0.0043660174,
-0.0453642495,
-0.0222490113,
-0.0141095733,
0.0679292306,
-0.0279151425,
0.0182042494,
0.0560712218,
0.0068154363,
-0.0657657981,
-0.0488957278,
-0.0539224558,
0.037543539,
0.0335765369,
-0.0307942443,
-0.0000291014,
0.0051534181,
-0.0053057354,
-0.0095704449,
-0.0000435624,
-0.0263898782,
-0.0129886912,
0.0214086827,
-0.0527578406,
-0.034865696,
-0.0392073132,
0.0153351277,
0.0255998001,
0.0259568337,
-0.0026280442,
1.858365422e-34,
0.0239603929,
0.0161211677,
0.0174065698,
-0.0164179187,
-0.0474886745,
-0.0110069867,
0.0655697733,
0.0151877441,
0.0416407287,
0.0013954042,
-0.0532921813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06588v2 | FTFT: Efficient and Robust Fine-Tuning by Transferring Training Dynamics | 2023-10-10T12:53:48 | 2024-03-29T23:53:28 | Yupei Du, Albert Gatt, Dong Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the massive success of fine-tuning Pre-trained Language Models
(PLMs), they remain susceptible to out-of-distribution input. Dataset
cartography is a simple yet effective dual-model approach that improves the
robustness of fine-tuned PLMs. It involves fine-tuning a model on the original
training set (i.e. reference model), selecting a subset of important training
instances based on the training dynamics, and fine-tuning again only on these
selected examples (i.e. main model). However, this approach requires
fine-tuning the same model twice, which is computationally expensive for large
PLMs. In this paper, we show that (1) training dynamics are highly transferable
across model sizes and pre-training methods, and that (2) fine-tuning main
models using these selected training instances achieves higher training
efficiency than empirical risk minimization (ERM). Building on these
observations, we propose a novel fine-tuning approach: Fine-Tuning by
transFerring Training dynamics (FTFT). Compared with dataset cartography, FTFT
uses more efficient reference models and aggressive early stopping. FTFT
achieves robustness improvements over ERM while lowering the training cost by
up to $\sim 50\%$. | [
0.0086745471,
0.038688641,
-0.0117025403,
0.0397441238,
0.0206254721,
0.0511147305,
-0.0228571985,
-0.0110207107,
-0.0295190234,
-0.0346716233,
-0.0756694525,
-0.0081137558,
-0.0161454286,
0.0019141447,
0.0596075654,
-0.0363620557,
0.0408671834,
-0.054332491,
0.0009040424,
-0.0069259782,
0.0131710013,
0.0133964745,
0.0169549007,
0.0192105211,
0.0444056392,
0.0328817368,
0.0017116755,
0.0445482358,
0.0455498658,
-0.0166440662,
0.0270808544,
0.0432061367,
0.0327621289,
0.0072868112,
0.0000020416,
-0.0271786992,
-0.0258942544,
0.0134264324,
-0.0017892753,
0.0206580292,
0.0279104225,
0.0044359853,
0.0042139916,
0.0189025104,
-0.0059333383,
-0.0342882127,
0.0589836091,
0.0070348592,
0.0631120801,
0.0917713419,
-0.0099479845,
-0.024962863,
0.0100476015,
-0.0637593716,
-0.0457664952,
-0.0422125868,
0.0580280051,
-0.0049106041,
-0.0575404242,
-0.0188531652,
-0.0302651841,
0.0133512355,
-0.0368275754,
0.0391093455,
-0.0413782708,
0.0183198769,
-0.0581215397,
0.0001922837,
-0.0016041565,
0.0982148722,
-0.0481405519,
-0.0141067728,
0.035969004,
-0.0276476983,
-0.0327297039,
0.0061978945,
-0.0200259294,
-0.0103142401,
0.0377278253,
0.0520091951,
0.0040977453,
-0.0039455388,
0.036495503,
0.0188338663,
-0.0632152408,
0.0003745128,
0.0207718965,
0.0085684396,
0.0115674064,
-0.0077594845,
-0.0321515985,
-0.0063194125,
-0.0191253107,
0.0015271392,
-0.0002063999,
0.0132889599,
-0.0830003619,
-0.0229063276,
0.004384425,
-0.0108114667,
0.0773449689,
0.0315859318,
-0.0361349806,
0.045474194,
-0.0262504593,
0.0039916108,
0.0104782814,
0.0839169919,
-0.0258639492,
0.012904536,
-0.0269414056,
0.0190475136,
-0.0615850501,
0.0083592134,
0.0230745301,
-0.0100101801,
-0.0360936709,
0.0041316408,
0.0091240974,
-0.0228514094,
0.0044626668,
-0.0398023613,
-0.0464635603,
-0.007788918,
0.022891283,
0.0270645041,
-0.0225627013,
0.0428480729,
-0.0165907424,
-0.0569689199,
-0.0237458609,
0.0233563837,
0.0161058232,
-0.0147365453,
0.0285235979,
0.0491983742,
0.0023398208,
-0.044475954,
-0.0612691268,
0.0095964661,
-0.0080995848,
-0.0712681264,
-0.0184913017,
-0.0492835268,
0.0150610395,
-0.0028922057,
0.0235531777,
-0.0438158624,
0.0059119258,
-0.00925407,
-0.0792234093,
0.069408603,
-0.0300036222,
0.0375217907,
0.0054018893,
-0.0284994822,
0.0126046268,
0.090206556,
0.0484367386,
-0.0110444454,
0.0404353514,
-0.0199538115,
-0.0042226193,
0.0831627846,
0.0308991168,
0.0514520109,
-0.0405920148,
0.0032914474,
0.0302086659,
-0.0126594352,
0.0221509282,
0.0224345699,
-0.0526658818,
0.022467332,
0.0742857605,
0.0187258441,
0.0217296984,
0.0119111948,
0.013191916,
-0.0074489154,
-0.004643213,
-0.013287643,
-0.0533937514,
-0.0244836528,
-0.0308511797,
0.002668879,
0.0264192894,
0.0238419138,
-0.0519354753,
0.0030851064,
0.0112092942,
-0.0028421341,
0.0180128235,
0.0065911086,
0.0614557452,
0.0245371386,
-0.034993019,
0.0857765526,
0.0517915599,
-0.0268605892,
-0.0136785712,
-0.0603413954,
-0.011290729,
0.0252527576,
0.01493413,
-0.0238531902,
-0.0252117831,
-0.0084377714,
0.0805168822,
-0.015250694,
0.0360657498,
0.0157454833,
0.0321606956,
-0.0675695091,
-0.0266259424,
0.024791576,
0.0134621654,
0.0146579742,
0.0182856563,
0.0195646398,
0.0149035482,
-0.0560715124,
-0.058510974,
0.0460977592,
-0.0103622572,
-0.0058683921,
-0.0035940709,
0.0092003355,
0.0219292827,
-0.039375212,
-0.0420382582,
0.0064770547,
0.023725139,
0.0074407649,
0.0496664047,
-0.0218762737,
-0.030124845,
-0.0136498371,
0.0288839117,
-0.0004378106,
0.016135186,
0.0299260896,
-0.0694916844,
-0.0305644274,
-0.0363634117,
0.0015958685,
0.0233033579,
-0.046304211,
0.0360484384,
-0.0341404192,
0.0432083569,
-0.0359243974,
0.0256979093,
-0.0065934719,
-0.0152940983,
0.0055464655,
0.0186855271,
0.0174676906,
-0.0237616431,
-0.0426075906,
0.0127860261,
-0.0257362612,
0.027068574,
-0.0113267349,
0.0258824714,
-0.0218350403,
-0.0354730599,
-0.0533211753,
0.0036096249,
-0.0543002561,
0.0262694322,
0.0229925364,
-0.0104981065,
-0.0406421348,
-0.0200730953,
0.000804297,
0.0303695574,
-0.012621671,
0.0173906311,
0.0126703409,
0.0140387928,
-0.0120580429,
-0.0278695151,
-0.0105971741,
0.0306412075,
0.0498994887,
-0.0569181964,
-0.0073038521,
-0.0700458214,
0.0499623232,
-0.0032854727,
0.0341263264,
-0.0282382518,
-0.0544531085,
-0.0413814597,
-0.0252637323,
-0.0053254738,
0.0365649685,
-0.0018602156,
-0.0082736639,
0.0403389037,
-0.0173487682,
-0.0267743655,
0.0029554842,
-0.0209138207,
-0.0628508106,
-0.0527024306,
0.0070592733,
-0.0269365385,
0.034580186,
0.0052476325,
-0.0097401002,
-0.0451920405,
-0.0158457905,
0.0018840536,
-0.0050900495,
-0.0073247976,
0.0032498208,
-0.0288568158,
0.0186258741,
-0.0256538801,
-0.0643118024,
0.0520721227,
-0.0547991917,
0.0050653899,
-0.0125590209,
-0.0307754297,
-0.0276114698,
0.0248565525,
0.0004741114,
0.0042799879,
0.0209868215,
-0.0140402801,
-0.064347975,
-0.0359016396,
0.0348901376,
-0.0192260314,
0.0329933092,
-0.0324585177,
0.0324845836,
-0.0222259536,
-0.0367007591,
-0.0062127318,
-0.0703760087,
-0.0140267918,
0.0063287225,
0.0131418006,
-0.016372133,
-0.0039478089,
0.0571440645,
-0.0189949144,
0.0702554137,
-0.0333086587,
0.0057853856,
-0.0123983016,
0.0094180191,
0.0588623695,
0.0087101366,
-0.0006446562,
-0.0534268096,
-0.0254848842,
-0.0047846604,
0.0173896328,
0.0050166943,
-0.0415072292,
0.0229342598,
0.0242091119,
0.0022719298,
-0.0162767842,
0.0339123793,
0.0495541394,
-0.0491276681,
-0.0444035009,
0.0908290148,
-0.0172013585,
-0.0275078658,
-0.0031635463,
0.0424029715,
0.0593865924,
0.0207744278,
0.027652476,
-0.026264241,
-0.0384157859,
0.0177331213,
0.051666759,
0.0247104056,
-0.0150119122,
0.0056764232,
-0.0989068151,
0.0216315538,
0.0389679559,
-0.0536999404,
-0.0199100692,
0.0012955548,
0.0230747871,
-0.0204224586,
-0.0093741631,
0.0054732226,
-0.0222997982,
-0.0135860499,
0.0463204533,
-0.0287985317,
-0.0676398799,
0.0073463097,
-0.053149499,
0.0196287893,
0.0724419728,
0.007602843,
-0.0060069771,
0.0166644454,
0.041751992,
-0.003617001,
0.0099048773,
0.0025183349,
0.0421545655,
-0.0196711849,
-0.0309478156,
0.0597588122,
0.0560914092,
-0.0017056993,
0.0051421062,
0.0074354578,
0.0235080644,
-0.0186118837,
-0.0002521051,
0.0149243306,
-0.001501831,
0.0302891545,
0.0335367359,
0.0361827686,
-0.0272038989,
-0.0037261012,
-0.0102402568,
-0.0016404986,
-0.0237891097,
-0.0191987194,
0.0039993138,
-0.0169636048,
-0.0166591313,
-0.0497683771,
-0.0062041054,
0.0049142241,
0.0648667812,
0.0047190539,
0.0203398187,
0.0009440869,
0.0271533467,
-0.0290258322,
0.0210484695,
-0.0681251064,
0.0078473883,
-0.0351516642,
-0.0156424176,
0.062223684,
-0.0085701942,
-0.0296660941,
0.0208033528,
-0.1061726734,
-0.084036544,
-0.0077449419,
0.0759473741,
0.0176939536,
0.0400022119,
-0.0163103789,
-0.0852563456,
0.0807776973,
0.0232751258,
-0.0238546059,
0.0231256429,
0.0496217757,
-0.0646627024,
-0.024358483,
0.0300621446,
-0.0523527116,
0.0088299206,
0.0527051836,
0.0238412414,
-0.029242659,
-0.0447657555,
-0.0375406519,
0.0054673892,
0.1068057492,
-0.0278326198,
-0.0120442249,
-0.035736084,
0.0460674316,
0.0225887075,
-0.0101326797,
-0.039969787,
-0.004164061,
0.0302131288,
-0.0171132479,
-0.0421618931,
-0.008173232,
0.0226705521,
0.0241498351,
-0.0371564068,
0.0398206934,
0.0153699564,
0.0185274761,
0.0464024246,
0.0123562627,
0.0000858109,
0.0392198972,
0.0343210027,
-0.0006950681,
-0.0458510108,
0.0303325765,
0.0266635939,
0.0411338992,
-0.0285679381,
0.0058291126,
-0.0243290588,
-0.0708458945,
-0.0691680983,
0.0183428992,
0.0498009697,
-0.0161715616,
0.0529005788,
0.0057957168,
-0.0227485839,
-0.0413190164,
0.0246211514,
-0.0088408962,
0.0017967694,
0.0303324871,
0.0036225445,
-0.0301182289,
0.032124918,
0.0832335055,
0.0252717547,
0.0720838606,
-0.0006935195,
-0.005276558,
-0.029166054,
-0.0123753529,
0.0251034442,
-0.005701845,
-0.0038678814,
-0.0012400006,
-0.0081202174,
-0.0743896365,
-0.0128266998,
-0.0292107072,
-0.0020084262,
-0.0004882343,
0.0446137041,
0.0537624136,
-0.0162676591,
0.0447915532,
-0.0288109668,
-0.0408098027,
0.0344745256,
-0.0017654087,
-0.0076601473,
-6.751420947e-33,
-0.0232795663,
0.0286714677,
0.0009742936,
-0.0285477918,
-0.0163021833,
-0.0195497181,
-0.0161840562,
0.0059894579,
-0.0254554879,
-0.0090506496,
-0.0190566648,
0.0005599814,
0.0268318653,
0.0353351533,
-0.0454748012,
-0.0070821652,
0.0373371355,
-0.022594396,
-0.0329427384,
0.0199278649,
0.0114847906,
0.0651562884,
0.0579925962,
-0.0492274351,
-0.0325780176,
0.00665962,
-0.0534408614,
0.0026346769,
0.0068353764,
0.0403243341,
0.0108675314,
0.0355113298,
-0.0043345853,
-0.0313219838,
-0.0535851121,
-0.0182758942,
-0.0819840133,
-0.0229641385,
0.0253149197,
-0.0027012809,
0.0304834135,
-0.0055852667,
0.06666217,
-0.0161937289,
0.0083525386,
-0.0068749199,
0.0179907605,
-0.0577840433,
-0.043909166,
-0.0412687734,
-0.0289461073,
0.0479871519,
0.0000708844,
-0.0257045254,
0.0408406481,
-0.0195900202,
-0.0190967377,
0.0278322771,
-0.0243958123,
0.0133051295,
0.0665822178,
0.0357216746,
0.0304038506,
0.0469728373,
0.000958891,
0.0271158237,
-0.012962549,
-0.0025982826,
0.0414159745,
-0.0190717392,
0.0778264329,
0.0764420107,
0.0028683355,
0.0446939282,
-0.0128725814,
-0.0331567228,
-0.1036345735,
0.0174001344,
-0.0342000611,
0.0048213066,
0.0449796095,
0.0368779674,
-0.0159886274,
-0.0488627851,
-0.0819911137,
-0.0302134268,
-0.0148178171,
-0.0043335864,
0.0377639569,
0.0361846574,
-0.0403599851,
0.0047732159,
0.0554002821,
-0.0402298085,
-0.0268949177,
0.0180040486,
-0.0459847227,
-0.0101768291,
-0.0199819189,
0.0159055665,
-0.0447777808,
-0.090468213,
0.0177170727,
-0.0136037171,
0.0236572959,
-0.0315258466,
0.0693572462,
0.0505084246,
-0.0667851418,
0.0013926697,
0.002075834,
0.0159882642,
0.0102941701,
0.0706724897,
0.0321842469,
-0.0143154999,
0.0165225826,
0.0556193739,
0.0024609806,
-0.0264015123,
-0.0013483074,
-0.0093537653,
0.018901201,
0.0553926267,
-0.0309907421,
0.0290707983,
-0.0207061376,
-0.0023457506,
0.0728653595,
-0.0370986052,
-0.0232644491,
0.034122657,
2.692e-7,
0.0637175366,
0.0369030572,
0.0052781045,
-0.0098099075,
0.002449906,
0.036973536,
-0.0533131361,
0.0282621793,
-0.0006741459,
0.0111732557,
0.0537410639,
0.0440709256,
0.0801477656,
-0.0086225383,
-0.0706429929,
-0.0151750837,
-0.0685584024,
0.0614018738,
-0.0454175286,
-0.0488770455,
0.0030131824,
0.1073818207,
0.0167784877,
-0.0073836786,
-0.0013183255,
-0.0459957868,
0.0557074994,
-0.0626129881,
0.0260348171,
0.0382052734,
-0.0328295231,
0.0769099742,
-0.030586075,
0.0084603792,
-0.0258298237,
0.0389614068,
0.010924465,
0.0826632231,
-0.0060868617,
0.0021723011,
0.0270449724,
0.0278187357,
-0.010724023,
-0.0477642938,
0.078504324,
-0.1096529588,
-0.0148655381,
-0.0289231073,
-0.0059685139,
-0.0385241471,
0.0149507523,
-0.0437022895,
-0.0043432494,
0.046978265,
0.0395096242,
0.003680604,
-0.0344985537,
-0.1011516377,
0.0009221514,
0.0100953076,
-0.041266799,
-0.0495484099,
-0.0352395624,
-0.0222224649,
0.0179466289,
-0.0441287905,
0.0331253968,
2.818967237e-34,
0.0456900224,
-0.0501618311,
0.0110404054,
-0.0209297668,
0.0359198004,
0.003800879,
0.0293044951,
0.024797665,
-0.0149894021,
-0.087542139,
-0.0217335913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06555v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06555v2 | It's About Time: Temporal References in Emergent Communication | 2023-10-10T12:10:40 | 2024-05-03T09:44:44 | Olaf Lipinski, Adam J. Sobey, Federico Cerutti, Timothy J. Norman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.MA | Emergent communication studies the development of language between autonomous
agents, aiming to improve understanding of natural language evolution and
increase communication efficiency. While temporal aspects of language have been
considered in computational linguistics, there has been no research on temporal
references in emergent communication. This paper addresses this gap, by
exploring how agents communicate about temporal relationships. We analyse three
potential influences for the emergence of temporal references: environmental,
external, and architectural changes. Our experiments demonstrate that altering
the loss function is insufficient for temporal references to emerge; rather,
architectural changes are necessary. However, a minimal change in agent
architecture, using a different batching method, allows the emergence of
temporal references. This modified design is compared with the standard
architecture in a temporal referential games environment, which emphasises
temporal relationships. The analysis indicates that over 95\% of the agents
with the modified batching method develop temporal references, without changes
to their loss function. We consider temporal referencing necessary for future
improvements to the agents' communication efficiency, yielding a closer to
optimal coding as compared to purely compositional languages. Our readily
transferable architectural insights provide the basis for their incorporation
into other emergent communication settings. | [
0.0565714315,
0.0438242145,
-0.0693929344,
-0.0025764261,
-0.0329728276,
-0.0327152424,
0.0023707147,
0.0196572971,
-0.0263000019,
-0.0096496101,
-0.0010055418,
-0.0398440845,
0.0550917424,
0.0503334887,
0.0100622419,
-0.0261881594,
0.0467681661,
-0.016437931,
0.0068617295,
0.0062837088,
-0.0304706562,
-0.0411854535,
-0.0016994906,
0.0375101566,
-0.0006099796,
-0.0085172262,
-0.0724474043,
-0.0458073132,
0.0019529375,
-0.0432082787,
-0.0391643941,
-0.0147776399,
0.0207259115,
0.0058970181,
0.0000018715,
-0.0331121385,
0.0428538807,
-0.0309610516,
-0.035541445,
0.0088734543,
0.0232498012,
0.0248407274,
-0.0061837975,
-0.033988189,
-0.0648142993,
-0.0617349148,
0.0710505769,
-0.0262507815,
0.0287418943,
0.0546329878,
0.0082226377,
-0.0120591177,
0.0341305435,
-0.0061740871,
0.0021168445,
-0.0404188856,
-0.0003504052,
-0.0192765966,
0.0679034218,
-0.0173917729,
-0.0387278982,
0.0233902708,
0.0310376789,
-0.0031769832,
0.0588113219,
0.0784132406,
0.0309862047,
-0.0315171368,
-0.0274808425,
0.0392056853,
0.0382222719,
-0.024816025,
0.0050358148,
0.0245347768,
0.0157817621,
-0.0598326512,
0.0138186347,
0.0144857857,
-0.0026327071,
0.0150630036,
0.0289429761,
0.0155049209,
0.0186540335,
0.0025035222,
0.0473232642,
0.077148512,
-0.0123884808,
-0.0177423954,
-0.0412188582,
-0.0208791159,
0.0728471801,
-0.0982886404,
-0.0163309965,
0.0437741205,
-0.0192374066,
0.0235511959,
-0.0334691256,
0.0491296276,
-0.0256265458,
-0.0607665703,
0.009669573,
0.0041918289,
0.0246543717,
0.0231226962,
-0.0085575618,
0.0618573055,
-0.0118605141,
-0.0330041014,
-0.0255299453,
0.0223645549,
-0.0632109046,
-0.016656097,
-0.033266712,
0.0527532957,
0.0107552316,
-0.0114873657,
-0.0196056738,
0.0638384521,
-0.0103051662,
-0.0256678741,
-0.0516932942,
-0.0177942254,
-0.0444259681,
0.0240011085,
-0.0585208796,
-0.0249211658,
-0.043551594,
0.0082374783,
-0.0042129098,
-0.0543752611,
-0.0198495705,
-0.0112496624,
0.0112709887,
0.0004353331,
-0.0524831191,
0.0754843578,
-0.0269619524,
-0.024175657,
-0.0268818028,
-0.0083812987,
-0.0257874206,
-0.0276995096,
0.01469051,
-0.01734812,
0.0256243851,
-0.0240841638,
-0.0315392911,
-0.0108623747,
-0.0115276519,
-0.0472282581,
-0.0270795897,
0.0704246685,
-0.0230170973,
0.0381936729,
0.0088112755,
0.0041493946,
0.052365426,
0.0418267138,
0.0681770518,
-0.041293513,
-0.0087197116,
0.004954421,
-0.0331729241,
-0.0002950737,
0.0286461432,
-0.0255818088,
0.0213495791,
-0.0207083449,
-0.0043165484,
0.0725083128,
-0.0029991127,
0.0423563197,
-0.032570146,
-0.0268691275,
0.0613920689,
0.0168052167,
0.0184593573,
0.0220196899,
0.0649110228,
0.0206492189,
-0.0227039214,
0.0073197605,
-0.0017231617,
0.0508438312,
0.0210611392,
-0.0117974365,
-0.000668718,
0.0141722681,
-0.04122857,
-0.0301627535,
0.0192955732,
0.0046296534,
0.0184212327,
-0.0421159752,
0.0085561462,
0.0494610071,
-0.0137530584,
0.0192290042,
0.0114662535,
0.0013324823,
0.0176615529,
-0.0550679564,
0.0497128181,
0.0403038934,
0.0125448341,
0.0118577471,
-0.0369715765,
0.0277295504,
0.0128963292,
0.0546190292,
0.043340113,
-0.0446785241,
0.041637402,
-0.0032571461,
-0.0126931928,
0.0005233751,
-0.0334153771,
0.0213004202,
-0.0244149324,
0.0415944606,
-0.0414563119,
0.0174865425,
0.0246222932,
0.0246973485,
-0.0088717304,
-0.0215427913,
-0.015135088,
0.0085535627,
0.0469382145,
-0.0093785189,
-0.0236515123,
0.0271015409,
0.0143918665,
0.010339288,
-0.0145081915,
0.1128058285,
-0.0589128286,
-0.0232006181,
0.0205051247,
-0.0071970546,
0.0261528175,
-0.0416657068,
0.0249959026,
-0.0182680786,
0.1124462411,
-0.0619435608,
0.1021178961,
0.0128262006,
0.0307196788,
-0.0309445858,
0.0082592964,
-0.0007354775,
0.0444488674,
0.0074757966,
-0.0489159711,
-0.014699664,
0.0254729819,
-0.0045507038,
-0.0380736776,
0.0272771753,
0.0347499736,
-0.0115811303,
-0.0089547094,
0.0416458026,
-0.0154149281,
-0.0514297746,
-0.0487831086,
-0.0360426567,
-0.0298356675,
0.027365217,
0.0162698422,
-0.0142468186,
-0.0199513603,
0.0148164695,
0.0019839723,
-0.022889901,
0.0589483418,
-0.0165303014,
0.0414766558,
0.0515445061,
0.0601969697,
-0.0568344034,
-0.0265728515,
-0.0058269845,
-0.0219969675,
0.0369360298,
0.0220905561,
-0.0501793995,
-0.0804755166,
-0.0119456528,
-0.0301345494,
-0.0177158825,
-0.025405677,
-0.0217388738,
0.0336300023,
0.0097006345,
0.0576387234,
0.0451480411,
0.0067845793,
0.0838243812,
0.0756732896,
-0.0757866874,
-0.0320929252,
0.0288657956,
-0.025523955,
-0.0090917097,
-0.0827248842,
-0.0307500921,
0.0103950649,
0.0853909478,
-0.0143929301,
-0.0111177294,
-0.0548266806,
0.0533452444,
-0.001099484,
-0.0703895241,
0.0034507809,
-0.05809021,
-0.0179330967,
0.00555566,
-0.0485249534,
-0.0106701618,
0.0685042515,
0.0260761622,
-0.0056489129,
0.0105769522,
0.0009112143,
-0.0103120776,
0.0858278126,
0.0219326969,
-0.0220197961,
0.0908764228,
-0.0208308939,
-0.0705543235,
0.0037596377,
0.0677129626,
0.038077455,
-0.0144085661,
-0.0803398937,
0.0092368042,
0.0022798385,
-0.0545124374,
0.0000454647,
0.0001493198,
0.0142744733,
0.0143445628,
-0.0235727616,
0.0153390681,
-0.0628278553,
0.0111171873,
-0.0035576264,
-0.0263523757,
0.015207353,
-0.0421605967,
-0.0232486352,
0.0054873554,
0.0245274715,
0.0449135117,
0.0194677915,
-0.0083051901,
0.032997936,
0.0197033491,
0.0593549795,
-0.0030337763,
-0.0335341878,
0.0132696424,
0.0164167732,
-0.0092533194,
-0.0526183359,
0.0402773321,
0.0293721929,
-0.0554556809,
-0.0353178456,
0.0256555583,
0.0152074462,
0.0102605559,
0.0256339759,
-0.0158865545,
0.0168330669,
-0.0026921856,
0.0204437617,
-0.0756975561,
0.0173620768,
-0.0019733142,
-0.0396518148,
-0.057194069,
-0.0366571136,
-0.0262563508,
-0.0815343484,
-0.0184536409,
0.0127975624,
-0.0570747778,
0.0224674828,
-0.0053105298,
-0.02689212,
0.0194087904,
-0.0220683981,
0.0279599633,
0.0241715498,
0.0131437471,
0.0141165527,
-0.0226677619,
0.0058403658,
-0.0253685545,
-0.0352238417,
0.1426421404,
0.0352187864,
0.0743619204,
0.0033549671,
-0.042294465,
0.0107947262,
-0.0091382042,
0.0035594332,
-0.0167102031,
0.0267130062,
0.0255140252,
-0.0030274354,
0.0153593561,
-0.0427688174,
0.0214915723,
0.0054445714,
-0.0026997637,
0.0816322342,
-0.0200013667,
-0.0698569119,
-0.0104694925,
0.0242064912,
0.0414442755,
0.012567848,
0.0083898222,
-0.0458623208,
-0.0582260154,
-0.0050121979,
-0.0070435801,
-0.0512427166,
-0.0565186217,
-0.031295564,
-0.0128771681,
-0.0525158942,
-0.117284663,
-0.0509148762,
-0.0577980988,
0.0057865959,
0.0256228074,
-0.0144481994,
0.0117396573,
0.0060830871,
-0.0240608584,
-0.0414453521,
0.0017578695,
-0.02763387,
-0.0296821073,
-0.043185506,
0.0243094638,
-0.041531384,
0.0094171623,
0.0428933538,
-0.0400785133,
-0.0547165386,
0.025186358,
0.0252135377,
0.0145394355,
0.0305083487,
0.0180280749,
-0.0593266301,
0.0541950502,
0.0066041173,
0.0492653698,
0.0449830107,
0.018415343,
-0.0067975568,
0.0167855322,
0.036655318,
-0.0332599543,
-0.0005828725,
0.0008502065,
0.0323958881,
-0.0186067168,
0.0359876752,
0.008943161,
-0.0443641767,
-0.0016738976,
0.0108305803,
-0.0129275499,
0.006524391,
0.0070063462,
-0.0066706208,
0.0132211773,
-0.0357477926,
-0.016095629,
-0.0171334371,
0.063318111,
0.0326339118,
0.0060002068,
0.0259882715,
0.0134162698,
0.0682688355,
0.0147996154,
0.0482011922,
0.0603640303,
-0.0056292848,
0.0580155775,
0.0186104532,
0.0614071563,
-0.0168960914,
0.0360645801,
-0.0079609929,
-0.0141638229,
0.0283074658,
-0.0334107392,
0.0284501687,
0.0148616321,
-0.0572154932,
0.0080375616,
0.062888436,
-0.0316496007,
0.0501401313,
0.0215991251,
0.0380814411,
-0.0528093129,
0.0113673145,
-0.0158996694,
0.0031798491,
0.0044502406,
-0.0897524208,
0.0058570621,
0.0184169896,
-0.0206708275,
0.0197063703,
0.0507764593,
0.025554724,
0.0570765771,
-0.027394373,
0.0115143834,
0.0020427054,
-0.0036256982,
-0.0681815073,
0.0037137161,
-0.0082989465,
0.0334640145,
-0.0438629426,
-0.0051010801,
0.0399997272,
0.0309149772,
0.0342209637,
-0.0277339667,
0.0446576513,
0.0258879736,
0.0259662159,
-0.070625037,
-0.029039273,
0.0004973744,
-0.0002680698,
0.0045873942,
-0.0285982341,
-6.131892813e-33,
-0.0387682617,
-0.0322609469,
0.0664344355,
0.017211223,
-0.0434799902,
0.0159197859,
-0.0697821826,
0.008778465,
-0.0382250249,
0.0014042527,
-0.0048004398,
0.0272134226,
0.0156019693,
-0.0240457784,
0.0261657517,
-0.025493063,
0.0208735429,
-0.0368838049,
0.0146808634,
0.0262778718,
0.0259761196,
-0.0102515751,
0.0431753695,
-0.0343718678,
0.0052179191,
0.0738926083,
0.010615143,
0.0287526827,
0.0159441624,
0.0215203352,
-0.0050002849,
0.0193314534,
0.0106193563,
-0.014736806,
-0.0205516759,
-0.0100178085,
-0.0656036139,
-0.0534235947,
0.0138350157,
-0.0034402532,
-0.0443173051,
-0.0685145184,
-0.0010739811,
0.01724126,
-0.0423549414,
-0.0217213444,
0.0214181691,
-0.0215230938,
-0.0355461016,
-0.0221451893,
-0.0576689281,
0.0154123809,
-0.022043135,
0.0054673492,
0.035794396,
-0.003550079,
0.0044520916,
-0.0701641217,
-0.0508268587,
0.0879616812,
-0.0054821097,
0.0198466517,
0.0061354893,
0.0355822518,
0.0593817011,
0.0191532485,
0.0872045979,
0.0682364479,
-0.0125845009,
-0.005016455,
0.0303365886,
-0.0011686923,
0.0098888176,
-0.0044002878,
-0.0162153468,
-0.0236571934,
-0.0139642209,
-0.0267392378,
0.0749496147,
0.011240744,
-0.0087675182,
0.0242748428,
-0.0235578939,
-0.0141563891,
0.0034011097,
-0.0070974263,
-0.0025248742,
-0.0226461627,
-0.0074320519,
0.0151016396,
0.0613883585,
0.0025703015,
0.0282323435,
-0.0311368145,
-0.0242874883,
-0.0410358794,
-0.0065565752,
0.0362029523,
0.0171353277,
-0.00754906,
-0.0630551204,
-0.0186137948,
-0.0010565694,
0.0275487993,
0.0407959707,
0.0198249761,
-0.0189967453,
0.0499616675,
-0.0329505764,
-0.0173627529,
-0.0046803132,
-0.0108656287,
0.0293950085,
-0.0910772458,
0.0071011656,
-0.0013759462,
-0.0102841239,
0.0059276908,
0.0418342315,
0.0172110647,
-0.0392169505,
0.0701977909,
-0.0332221463,
0.0324932113,
-0.0303319935,
-0.0020919968,
-0.0835715905,
0.1089175865,
0.0100031402,
-0.0565038882,
-0.0379143693,
-0.0139335971,
2.872e-7,
-0.0326201767,
0.0294186082,
0.03258086,
0.0294180848,
0.0499687791,
-0.0044437405,
-0.021470163,
0.0189469047,
-0.0290481448,
0.0175414961,
0.0292042084,
0.0089114122,
0.0119338287,
0.0191933718,
-0.0554088727,
-0.0129609164,
-0.0871943906,
-0.0033567315,
-0.0244194791,
-0.0108834263,
0.0062845438,
0.0281513389,
0.0453339778,
0.0166634694,
-0.0227503758,
-0.0340597518,
0.0313262492,
-0.0113380561,
0.03623835,
0.056471847,
-0.0354090258,
-0.033312697,
-0.0502554029,
-0.0227404702,
0.0018550286,
0.0066484222,
-0.0601872616,
-0.0239169672,
-0.0105866855,
-0.0485918149,
0.024872005,
0.0127122467,
-0.0313707553,
0.0200517271,
0.03998987,
-0.0647526979,
-0.0591901429,
0.0352760069,
0.0190397315,
0.0102506848,
-0.0506964773,
0.0104079535,
-0.0363828428,
-0.0090234727,
-0.0104569038,
0.0196153,
0.010310173,
-0.0781836584,
0.0065844157,
0.0301374868,
0.0008862705,
-0.0623481199,
-0.0465489253,
-0.0006676331,
0.0421888828,
-0.0027870529,
-0.0007129824,
2.029921016e-34,
-0.0142601468,
-0.0217542406,
0.021371875,
0.0062578246,
0.0197800938,
-0.0141716804,
0.0201031137,
-0.0009407458,
0.0954866856,
-0.0200975891,
-0.0338087082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06552v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06552v3 | Automated clinical coding using off-the-shelf large language models | 2023-10-10T11:56:48 | 2023-11-13T12:38:00 | Joseph S. Boyle, Antanas Kascenas, Pat Lok, Maria Liakata, Alison Q. O'Neil | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.8 | The task of assigning diagnostic ICD codes to patient hospital admissions is
typically performed by expert human coders. Efforts towards automated ICD
coding are dominated by supervised deep learning models. However, difficulties
in learning to predict the large number of rare codes remain a barrier to
adoption in clinical practice. In this work, we leverage off-the-shelf
pre-trained generative large language models (LLMs) to develop a practical
solution that is suitable for zero-shot and few-shot code assignment, with no
need for further task-specific training. Unsupervised pre-training alone does
not guarantee precise knowledge of the ICD ontology and specialist clinical
coding task, therefore we frame the task as information extraction, providing a
description of each coded concept and asking the model to retrieve related
mentions. For efficiency, rather than iterating over all codes, we leverage the
hierarchical nature of the ICD ontology to sparsely search for relevant codes. | [
0.0112552531,
0.0765467659,
0.029977927,
0.0032314656,
-0.0193925202,
0.0469417311,
0.0168587882,
0.041399736,
-0.0076046917,
-0.0189151168,
0.0064906166,
-0.0634180456,
-0.0153435757,
0.0668207482,
-0.0213327594,
-0.0100836754,
-0.0038280063,
-0.0017674845,
0.0198885985,
-0.0148990648,
-0.0587779991,
0.0178675465,
-0.0054514511,
0.0421833582,
-0.0183823258,
-0.0109094419,
0.0097623263,
-0.0207616892,
0.026335014,
-0.0732208416,
-0.0114378948,
0.0553417876,
0.0092061339,
-0.0091888886,
0.0000017774,
-0.0522917993,
-0.0256993938,
0.0175916478,
-0.0604793392,
-0.0489272438,
0.0175097696,
-0.0625358075,
0.0137875723,
-0.0131532531,
-0.029976286,
-0.0944649801,
0.0698136613,
0.071089901,
0.0159036722,
0.0635311753,
-0.0104817338,
-0.0234115589,
0.0484126285,
-0.0264510158,
0.0532602519,
-0.085240379,
0.0811858699,
0.0416700058,
0.0225078948,
0.0145601183,
-0.0079641128,
0.0423373058,
0.0140761007,
0.0069459402,
0.022272896,
0.0690765306,
-0.0213378109,
0.0136092957,
-0.0030353889,
0.0673725754,
-0.0247539077,
-0.0119841052,
0.009398262,
-0.0100061195,
-0.0423293412,
-0.0539229773,
-0.0274467841,
0.0165395122,
0.0013027687,
0.0110974284,
0.0171082728,
0.0218661223,
0.0364814252,
-0.0176264923,
-0.0348359421,
0.0043331203,
0.0096286014,
-0.0052015153,
0.0150346877,
-0.0010599792,
-0.0261499397,
-0.0496667735,
-0.0169846881,
0.038709525,
-0.0219359342,
0.0089963954,
-0.0381569266,
0.0040953583,
0.0303534027,
-0.0432148911,
0.0054857228,
0.0071529322,
-0.0161247533,
0.0477073155,
-0.0135480594,
-0.012373738,
-0.0244580451,
0.0108979149,
-0.0532738008,
-0.0203939807,
-0.0691498742,
0.0113884956,
-0.0323445313,
0.0358473361,
0.0314857177,
-0.0067886794,
-0.0655144528,
-0.0088895513,
0.0069130831,
0.0020164298,
0.024842117,
0.0532394424,
-0.0344645493,
0.0005160426,
0.0049520941,
-0.0175153706,
0.0217697881,
-0.0057814713,
-0.0172171891,
-0.0434178784,
0.0232262537,
0.0373944528,
0.0331821144,
0.0061705587,
0.014351177,
0.039305035,
0.0074836039,
-0.0213729795,
-0.0253238622,
-0.0228610486,
-0.0292059295,
-0.0028686505,
0.027196547,
-0.0515396371,
0.0142430756,
0.0053783804,
0.0215625502,
-0.0847753808,
0.0151969083,
-0.0329748243,
-0.0587179288,
0.07311216,
-0.0683356375,
-0.0051424601,
0.0023719266,
0.0225279648,
0.0417518355,
0.0303670876,
0.0254834853,
-0.0249577761,
-0.0032658693,
-0.046002239,
0.0367388204,
0.0223465264,
-0.0053892815,
-0.0290632378,
-0.0063520782,
0.0249887146,
0.0103151454,
0.0689000785,
0.0264464151,
0.0245197508,
0.0091106286,
-0.0193005856,
0.0025792727,
0.0659548864,
0.0302796047,
0.0220829956,
0.0474772118,
-0.0148570044,
-0.041747909,
-0.0727357268,
0.0023577134,
0.0192479882,
0.0611061156,
0.0139888572,
0.0153876869,
-0.0433709174,
-0.0354791693,
-0.0381817333,
-0.017832635,
-0.0103307478,
-0.0512540266,
0.0036094121,
0.0687624514,
-0.0076839789,
-0.0158561151,
0.0474700257,
0.0404908955,
-0.011266131,
0.0006380038,
-0.0742111281,
-0.0169326663,
0.061762128,
0.0497499332,
-0.0286377855,
-0.0349166133,
-0.0182522722,
0.0142915118,
0.0181113183,
-0.0068244734,
-0.014318957,
0.019906193,
-0.0498815663,
-0.0128476573,
0.0575748086,
0.0147061059,
0.0045160865,
-0.0034974422,
-0.0147579946,
-0.0141052222,
-0.0095725982,
-0.0416943654,
0.0258543994,
-0.0475475937,
-0.0515618511,
0.0356667116,
0.0001106806,
0.0391625501,
0.0073719961,
-0.028759554,
0.0120005645,
0.0203714184,
-0.0427954309,
-0.0471918099,
-0.0639016032,
-0.042079825,
-0.0137074962,
0.0096438713,
-0.0269446727,
-0.0033126464,
-0.017978292,
-0.0441100188,
-0.020912705,
-0.0403936282,
-0.0112837516,
0.0529749729,
-0.006083454,
0.0118905846,
0.0534402579,
-0.0241193697,
-0.0249363873,
0.0352072939,
-0.0228828881,
0.0141133033,
-0.0129003283,
-0.0025539764,
0.0218622349,
-0.0107211852,
-0.0035634006,
0.0267362539,
-0.0423442461,
0.0343485475,
-0.0227225665,
0.0361994579,
0.0126060285,
0.011548209,
-0.1241269037,
-0.010437604,
0.0157946292,
-0.0248218868,
0.0226602219,
0.0320722573,
0.0035674179,
-0.012894759,
-0.0558635332,
0.0015215254,
0.0075000864,
-0.0127932858,
0.0214207377,
0.0346865728,
-0.0139231747,
-0.0065267608,
0.0048074578,
-0.0344566964,
0.0400087535,
0.0087217269,
-0.0038521087,
-0.0184222907,
0.0499778949,
-0.027248973,
0.0176925454,
-0.0060365847,
-0.0280538835,
0.0145307165,
-0.0366664119,
-0.0103622833,
0.0239208192,
-0.0109013803,
0.016355738,
0.029352013,
-0.0007939975,
-0.009403592,
0.0049783075,
-0.0498940311,
-0.0609576404,
-0.0054771714,
-0.0372657552,
0.0021167002,
0.1034906656,
0.0299534034,
-0.0111903809,
-0.0455552824,
-0.0249379128,
-0.0187499281,
0.0101530226,
-0.0625334531,
0.0347416922,
-0.0167144947,
0.077982001,
0.0191818327,
-0.0398496464,
0.0620921925,
-0.0153565649,
0.0247216746,
-0.0256934073,
-0.0305224564,
-0.0485734791,
0.044971548,
-0.0285814628,
0.0383374915,
0.0407821015,
-0.0437416434,
0.0229296051,
0.0309663564,
-0.0431223847,
-0.0496429317,
0.0639288127,
-0.0059355004,
0.0459195487,
0.0010620591,
-0.0544775166,
-0.0475933179,
0.0174975768,
0.0030348825,
0.0291953851,
0.0397346243,
-0.0053548282,
-0.0337937772,
0.0470264293,
-0.0348251015,
0.0661837459,
0.02965861,
-0.0113787428,
-0.0098432964,
0.0185970366,
0.0281652901,
-0.0162011851,
-0.0164839979,
0.0199563745,
-0.0137556344,
0.0378788598,
0.0039471267,
0.0527612865,
-0.0353060588,
0.0439723805,
0.0180370864,
-0.0308271199,
0.0267592147,
0.0440651216,
-0.0041145026,
-0.0280824788,
-0.0131250164,
0.1221715435,
0.0205235388,
-0.0958056524,
0.0131420037,
-0.0084135346,
-0.0500145555,
-0.0153159536,
0.0006712399,
-0.0635357574,
-0.0176061746,
-0.0037885231,
0.0014308001,
-0.0127236703,
-0.0545698069,
0.0326447152,
-0.0448795147,
0.0496834964,
0.0084968358,
-0.0213143453,
-0.0664544553,
-0.037299946,
-0.0041850284,
-0.0180107765,
-0.0420585833,
-0.0092629036,
-0.01004712,
-0.0290976241,
-0.0020788666,
-0.0619520731,
-0.073201485,
0.0625057518,
-0.0292731784,
0.070088394,
0.0941512957,
0.0220990591,
-0.0227649789,
0.0205157436,
0.0012614109,
0.0088748205,
-0.0220599752,
-0.0180157889,
0.0660315529,
-0.0178973172,
-0.0234849621,
-0.0231304262,
0.0461679697,
-0.0808821544,
-0.0126319602,
-0.0163849872,
0.0628256053,
-0.0296346843,
-0.0464604311,
-0.0189961568,
0.0014618045,
0.0285018831,
0.0621613674,
-0.0112113114,
-0.029420102,
0.013046721,
-0.0138035417,
0.0528390072,
0.0042254175,
-0.0349712744,
0.0341017731,
-0.0531055778,
-0.0852783173,
-0.0498846769,
-0.0140640307,
0.0708793402,
-0.0003831713,
0.0119223399,
-0.0012088959,
0.0229937788,
-0.0180423427,
-0.0576484688,
0.0279304571,
-0.0367299616,
-0.0238374453,
-0.0849974975,
-0.0308538228,
0.076788038,
0.025760198,
-0.0416969843,
0.0164220333,
-0.004457863,
0.0036870567,
-0.012375949,
0.0339570232,
0.0171240605,
0.0109985108,
-0.0123957284,
-0.0242722072,
0.0140431887,
0.0295947827,
-0.0055574975,
-0.0287336912,
-0.022857476,
-0.0154504748,
-0.005637798,
0.0312425699,
-0.0409579054,
0.0804116502,
0.0246442314,
0.0180697776,
-0.0378836803,
-0.037223801,
0.0315919966,
-0.0060017277,
0.0437467471,
-0.0211272258,
-0.0442694537,
-0.0243224893,
0.0226827804,
0.013432011,
0.0025403237,
-0.0265781842,
-0.0031168996,
0.061907012,
0.0129143707,
-0.014992184,
0.011005776,
-0.014806536,
-0.0313523524,
-0.0079429587,
0.0224838164,
-0.0129250297,
0.0300157424,
0.0775309354,
-0.0224610493,
-0.0379228257,
0.0393947996,
-0.0011546741,
0.0172282998,
-0.0214826856,
0.0452225767,
0.0070755682,
0.0619774051,
-0.0046130223,
0.0025027185,
0.0071362499,
-0.0509712845,
-0.0405545793,
0.0026341511,
0.078908287,
0.0125109814,
-0.0170362405,
-0.03841497,
0.0364086293,
-0.0449688882,
0.0407274254,
-0.0329587385,
0.00468595,
0.0239887871,
0.0090841912,
-0.0197469126,
-0.0254381858,
0.1027667895,
0.0531096198,
0.058557678,
-0.0027167406,
-0.0297630653,
-0.0458669066,
-0.0049403245,
0.053351298,
0.0074069728,
-0.0423495546,
0.0193316508,
-0.0129748592,
-0.0639012605,
0.0406031497,
-0.0130190821,
-0.0469376184,
0.0137991104,
0.0692485571,
0.0369354151,
-0.0117797144,
-0.0271989722,
-0.0234857649,
0.0183239263,
0.0090396991,
-0.0383253172,
-0.0250174999,
-5.93630745e-33,
0.0029889171,
-0.0134913502,
0.0382862836,
0.0009215774,
0.0227673762,
0.0211206451,
-0.024737766,
-0.0130182579,
0.0224922374,
0.0263401438,
-0.0020994202,
-0.0215422288,
0.0082649104,
0.051763095,
0.0279400311,
-0.0253600925,
0.0275348909,
0.0113528287,
0.0070927353,
0.0442090854,
0.0020664525,
0.0379652157,
0.0252658091,
-0.0565689243,
-0.0005538377,
0.0042020776,
0.0532861166,
0.0199894104,
0.0534120277,
0.0365932956,
-0.0550912246,
0.0147514688,
0.0458605029,
-0.006628464,
0.0144981192,
0.0231899247,
-0.081716314,
-0.0225232355,
-0.0030510968,
-0.036032401,
-0.0002001827,
-0.0758484825,
0.029917961,
0.0078391256,
-0.0289666858,
-0.0181777943,
0.0205860585,
-0.0141001781,
-0.014514043,
-0.079880856,
-0.044654578,
0.048520755,
-0.0025460338,
-0.0031911212,
-0.0078962436,
-0.0599822551,
-0.0257718265,
0.0366069041,
-0.0281768311,
0.007715242,
-0.006355634,
0.0492432378,
0.022126995,
-0.0209451988,
-0.0085983137,
0.0650026649,
0.0013460716,
-0.0201064385,
-0.0326164775,
0.0165486336,
-0.0273705143,
0.0427141897,
0.0105623016,
0.0240834355,
0.0474533401,
-0.027179759,
-0.078093484,
0.0328472592,
-0.0845982581,
0.0377382748,
0.0372410975,
0.0099141682,
-0.0514452308,
-0.0058573275,
-0.0146157881,
0.0320149213,
-0.0152073381,
-0.0539958216,
0.0565000549,
-0.0165948346,
-0.0052940678,
0.045905605,
0.0472439416,
-0.039322,
-0.0139394756,
-0.0292462204,
0.080570437,
0.0499960668,
-0.0465792902,
0.0309997872,
-0.056808304,
-0.0233748984,
0.045571778,
-0.064606607,
0.0247650705,
0.024060091,
0.0217607059,
-0.0106889689,
-0.0515829064,
-0.0305715241,
0.0277562086,
-0.0346847102,
-0.0034030913,
0.0535222851,
0.0308083128,
0.0286331158,
0.020689344,
0.0280303601,
-0.006355294,
-0.0244650394,
-0.0177545864,
-0.0368194841,
0.0144980773,
-0.0201802272,
-0.0327927731,
-0.0122022554,
-0.0808869228,
-0.0032306442,
0.0478452072,
-0.0289365891,
-0.0089015346,
0.0206228159,
2.667e-7,
0.0933462828,
0.0369488001,
0.015554185,
-0.0008879116,
0.0105767557,
0.0091871079,
0.0210989788,
0.0148378052,
-0.0148336599,
-0.0146581568,
0.033205457,
0.0099411504,
0.0189500526,
0.0222843271,
-0.089329958,
-0.0276466962,
-0.0085660508,
-0.0075285258,
-0.023959307,
-0.022704931,
0.0553118363,
0.1212362573,
-0.0191051289,
-0.0091562876,
0.0319674872,
-0.0378811881,
0.0329591334,
-0.0415149257,
0.006407415,
0.0615035295,
-0.0391908027,
0.0498026311,
0.0004877742,
0.06294512,
0.0114541221,
-0.0187618528,
0.0039775497,
0.0929496661,
-0.0659156218,
0.0301097091,
0.0012184266,
-0.0092403963,
0.0313681252,
-0.0192376971,
0.067842491,
-0.0913862959,
-0.0205096342,
-0.0243471842,
-0.0092973821,
-0.0104665523,
0.005487741,
-0.0165614188,
-0.0066538681,
0.0445486084,
0.0382831879,
-0.0018621306,
-0.0439520143,
-0.0730483755,
0.0278086532,
0.0490465797,
-0.0313493013,
-0.0303966682,
0.0335326828,
-0.0198567864,
0.0351671875,
-0.0524316691,
0.0230235942,
2.374504328e-34,
0.028672507,
0.0241759736,
-0.0365126133,
0.0472066551,
0.0302257426,
-0.0272085741,
-0.0084288372,
0.0197986085,
-0.0111250067,
-0.0753038153,
0.0071292329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06547v1 | Rationale-Enhanced Language Models are Better Continual Relation Learners | 2023-10-10T11:50:27 | 2023-10-10T11:50:27 | Weimin Xiong, Yifan Song, Peiyi Wang, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Continual relation extraction (CRE) aims to solve the problem of catastrophic
forgetting when learning a sequence of newly emerging relations. Recent CRE
studies have found that catastrophic forgetting arises from the model's lack of
robustness against future analogous relations. To address the issue, we
introduce rationale, i.e., the explanations of relation classification results
generated by large language models (LLM), into CRE task. Specifically, we
design the multi-task rationale tuning strategy to help the model learn current
relations robustly. We also conduct contrastive rationale replay to further
distinguish analogous relations. Experimental results on two standard
benchmarks demonstrate that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art CRE
models. | [
0.037479192,
0.0838284642,
0.0062490716,
0.0724072009,
-0.0004616443,
0.0352709815,
-0.0107678063,
-0.0233476758,
-0.0254675336,
-0.0443200506,
-0.006409511,
-0.0621529929,
-0.0144387223,
0.0005230382,
-0.0139108561,
-0.0711506903,
0.0466656089,
-0.0319723785,
0.0456856973,
0.0066156606,
-0.0292346627,
0.0141775459,
0.0072920909,
0.0119607672,
0.0028511961,
-0.0488853976,
-0.0028002858,
-0.0326623842,
0.0141738085,
-0.0537619367,
0.0023163036,
0.0468801856,
0.0408657566,
-0.0169802736,
0.0000020144,
-0.0775325224,
-0.0357143357,
-0.026810104,
-0.0764627308,
-0.0205481332,
0.000778985,
0.0211489405,
0.0106992684,
-0.0004529999,
-0.0463974252,
-0.0225290973,
0.0317588858,
0.0603077672,
0.0266024247,
0.0455937982,
-0.0063207676,
-0.0406799838,
0.0514576696,
-0.0378424414,
-0.0058556427,
-0.024895696,
0.0160238426,
0.0347348005,
-0.0229826868,
0.0134035395,
-0.0217202809,
0.0155867534,
0.0444751419,
-0.0180835444,
0.0277668666,
0.0627587363,
0.0359099321,
-0.0213669799,
-0.0101296091,
0.0638493225,
-0.0232370663,
-0.0346500315,
0.0114462562,
0.0280792248,
-0.0254659597,
0.0044304598,
-0.0436633192,
0.0260695536,
-0.016155079,
0.044502873,
0.0702162758,
0.0001794552,
0.0267656669,
0.0326112807,
-0.0511550158,
0.0227457713,
0.0062828264,
-0.013114051,
0.0158075355,
-0.0001830069,
-0.0457603559,
-0.0293525383,
-0.0123669785,
0.0596890412,
-0.0310513079,
0.0440937169,
-0.0303824823,
0.0159491058,
-0.0089091808,
-0.0472908393,
-0.0214524791,
0.0331604667,
0.0078726867,
0.0850320533,
-0.0441382043,
0.0496296957,
0.018826222,
-0.0142445248,
-0.0189307481,
-0.0029066466,
-0.0599614717,
-0.0118075069,
-0.0121946353,
0.0684751421,
-0.0305357762,
-0.0027016576,
-0.0194735061,
0.0362033769,
-0.0242254343,
0.0244854596,
0.0210727882,
0.0205967817,
-0.0454645976,
-0.0355208069,
-0.0136093227,
0.007533391,
-0.0272026882,
-0.0043617478,
0.0038282215,
-0.0166799575,
-0.0318729654,
-0.0047074179,
0.0154714538,
-0.0366228335,
-0.0163120702,
0.076028049,
-0.02264525,
-0.0504985042,
-0.018723309,
-0.0120481513,
0.0069765858,
-0.0719676539,
-0.0160223842,
-0.0152210733,
0.0168700181,
0.0189081915,
-0.000028934,
-0.0690317601,
0.039759282,
-0.0214564987,
-0.0602073744,
0.0937690958,
0.0090465872,
0.0058921291,
-0.0282896999,
0.0355728269,
0.0068492237,
0.0581806339,
0.0120720863,
-0.0403498262,
0.0399884693,
0.0073208157,
-0.0131652253,
-0.0153285144,
-0.0018261451,
-0.0028205747,
-0.0597452596,
0.0135493279,
0.0320619158,
0.0213164352,
0.0487195738,
0.0445837304,
-0.0141498651,
-0.0200422946,
0.0239471961,
0.0148967337,
0.0244752355,
0.0592779778,
0.0320110992,
-0.013005103,
0.0053646094,
0.0520130657,
-0.0875169113,
0.0301278755,
-0.0089978958,
0.0335919224,
-0.0248944797,
0.0152974548,
-0.0020719636,
-0.0207668096,
0.000582885,
-0.0203808155,
-0.0247499347,
0.015225294,
0.0740443766,
0.0213785917,
-0.0663592741,
0.0537790656,
0.0470645279,
-0.0450482592,
0.0057997517,
-0.0406417847,
0.0584190823,
0.0770871118,
0.0259166136,
-0.0294418093,
-0.0634995252,
-0.015589715,
0.0081864716,
-0.0004619136,
0.0189027935,
-0.0412697941,
0.0615330115,
-0.0448965169,
-0.0584936924,
0.0008099746,
0.0287146792,
0.0051685493,
0.0553145558,
0.0183844268,
0.0160638336,
-0.0285671502,
-0.0363691486,
0.0304585081,
-0.0444650538,
-0.0589041002,
0.0143300556,
-0.0037792274,
-0.0059043397,
0.0243659224,
-0.0153166438,
-0.0029491899,
0.0568292178,
-0.063093923,
0.0147185782,
0.0677452758,
-0.0896678194,
-0.0404833257,
0.0436245911,
0.0402463973,
-0.0365836397,
-0.0259173177,
-0.017084714,
-0.0218236707,
0.0116947796,
0.0368817002,
0.0705392659,
0.0076309289,
0.0450570732,
-0.0018524058,
-0.0008054911,
-0.0145597421,
0.0952213109,
-0.0027282599,
-0.0126159964,
0.0370722711,
-0.004396677,
-0.0417602807,
-0.0537707359,
0.0161087532,
0.0298421215,
0.0120007293,
-0.030028617,
-0.0021466801,
-0.0135550993,
-0.0389156416,
-0.0128355324,
-0.0168459266,
0.0042903433,
-0.0059610899,
0.0173321292,
0.0108277928,
-0.0051113111,
0.0015974442,
-0.0177686755,
0.0121855503,
0.0079472782,
-0.0381463841,
0.008374962,
0.0269597378,
-0.0102125434,
-0.0081097232,
-0.0603597201,
-0.0039271931,
-0.0110499812,
0.079105489,
-0.0014219519,
0.0328099877,
-0.0352234356,
0.0426166691,
0.0012809886,
0.0162641574,
-0.0292850565,
0.0031425499,
-0.008874312,
-0.0155666061,
0.0302220397,
0.0641074255,
0.0338172652,
0.0737163872,
0.0645490512,
-0.0097184023,
-0.044757586,
0.0287113003,
-0.0419998951,
0.01014583,
-0.0012156033,
0.0077358722,
-0.0268170703,
0.0680919141,
-0.0304111689,
0.0201964192,
-0.0049892813,
0.0570602007,
-0.0041728192,
0.0178473704,
-0.0487481579,
-0.0269440431,
-0.0206965841,
-0.002367842,
-0.0413010456,
-0.0197877847,
0.0703641847,
0.0187618565,
-0.0018765299,
-0.0369310603,
-0.0175740998,
-0.0139205446,
0.0953523144,
-0.0319685712,
0.0001142908,
0.0432229154,
-0.0218087658,
-0.0596971661,
-0.0846602619,
0.0360181965,
-0.0039702235,
0.0862545744,
-0.074100554,
-0.0076595568,
-0.0066371611,
-0.0286315996,
-0.0996459797,
-0.0320303738,
-0.0329172239,
0.0060574138,
-0.0438661054,
-0.0079551674,
-0.0012098599,
0.0228123628,
0.0273653399,
0.0143260267,
-0.0041657668,
-0.0188458916,
0.0117108515,
0.0694077089,
0.0880472884,
0.0294075515,
0.0226349328,
-0.0052112951,
0.0859190151,
0.035819497,
0.0296329148,
-0.0482887626,
-0.0172169562,
0.0138733843,
-0.0076440526,
-0.043125689,
-0.0021485074,
0.0009975664,
0.0091530262,
-0.0875644982,
-0.0232715756,
0.1259839833,
0.0231206194,
-0.0269362517,
0.0076744226,
0.0143087599,
0.0325416401,
0.0473685116,
-0.0053554308,
-0.0305567533,
-0.0178002045,
0.0106990365,
0.0139090931,
0.0251089372,
-0.0268043913,
-0.0289786495,
-0.0962194651,
-0.001465051,
0.0058650267,
-0.0300300065,
0.0036415667,
-0.0480534583,
-0.0249090381,
-0.0232548695,
0.0156498812,
0.02456332,
-0.0346628129,
0.0173938815,
0.0101595689,
-0.0013152116,
-0.0383562259,
0.0138083622,
-0.0155488504,
0.0539952554,
0.0184758361,
0.048337359,
0.0132198958,
-0.0272362344,
0.0578627698,
-0.0405964293,
0.0086396858,
-0.0373054706,
0.0530417748,
0.0115212081,
-0.0096175829,
-0.022168003,
0.0160297677,
-0.0411587022,
-0.0355369672,
0.0257166643,
0.053251259,
0.0058169221,
-0.0150243472,
0.0111215357,
-0.0360091962,
0.0048459861,
0.0803316236,
0.0192123149,
-0.018369332,
-0.0559149049,
-0.0276722703,
0.0124143139,
-0.0825572833,
0.0084584076,
-0.0635025203,
-0.0303231832,
0.0151459267,
-0.0387088619,
-0.0227643494,
-0.0206946284,
0.0146667976,
0.0148591688,
0.0206475854,
0.0076274476,
0.012502457,
-0.0661324188,
0.0055882679,
0.0017227745,
-0.0141021628,
-0.009656027,
0.0240858234,
0.0264320169,
-0.0480739325,
0.0041208086,
-0.0572982207,
-0.0390749499,
-0.0444432274,
-0.0172774121,
0.0279619936,
0.0244197175,
0.1104528457,
-0.0033417759,
0.0055076759,
-0.0215434916,
0.0243357774,
-0.0323661231,
-0.0098526953,
0.0591511019,
0.0000335548,
0.014045259,
0.0592480563,
-0.034119986,
-0.0128209218,
0.0235972647,
0.0536830314,
-0.0157547053,
-0.0136627601,
0.0283512175,
-0.0432758704,
0.0299363658,
0.0016442041,
-0.0129128704,
-0.0603829697,
0.0219974723,
-0.029611215,
-0.0059569725,
-0.0272764619,
0.0612137467,
0.0053042378,
0.0219304934,
-0.0161272287,
-0.0522659458,
-0.00029433,
0.0426625721,
0.0087013133,
0.0070641697,
-0.0032641583,
-0.0175207965,
0.0311614145,
-0.0025131262,
-0.0364493132,
0.0208597276,
-0.0001065545,
0.0273325257,
-0.0170015749,
0.0477020591,
-0.0031846806,
-0.0361208953,
-0.0235146675,
-0.0092592547,
-0.0641924962,
-0.0380150899,
-0.005560454,
-0.0062681208,
0.0793469399,
-0.0263944678,
0.07646171,
-0.025639765,
0.0055029546,
-0.0128943631,
0.0515935272,
0.0171136931,
-0.0178661663,
0.0021559834,
0.0252424646,
-0.0167489424,
0.0431290045,
0.0922234431,
-0.027690351,
0.035134811,
0.0383768789,
-0.008799105,
-0.0205397811,
-0.0326554812,
-0.0467181578,
0.0142269498,
-0.030947106,
0.0284072403,
-0.0352228694,
-0.078047879,
0.014839326,
-0.0256736279,
-0.0070206583,
-0.0358412527,
0.0017846482,
0.0173599534,
-0.0112818582,
-0.0234640781,
-0.0290857852,
0.0473295264,
-0.015446675,
-0.0028834138,
-0.0451534167,
-6.651329807e-33,
-0.0168114714,
-0.0469368473,
0.0064024874,
-0.0230211988,
-0.0474299751,
0.0287875924,
-0.0891269669,
0.0010277621,
-0.0174406897,
0.015771905,
0.0022390573,
0.0222005919,
0.000368652,
0.0033918102,
0.0229731444,
-0.0352651998,
0.063098982,
0.0371965766,
0.0074853478,
0.0235661175,
0.0554898046,
0.0431461558,
0.0451053828,
-0.0832849815,
0.0041101761,
0.0347666554,
0.0310668722,
0.0537972935,
0.0035921454,
0.0883610025,
-0.0236829873,
0.0211265069,
0.0234781522,
-0.0348485038,
-0.0059801592,
-0.0195196159,
-0.1540810913,
-0.0307459775,
-0.0038989398,
-0.0345490128,
-0.0057897093,
-0.038887836,
0.0269694403,
0.0015267697,
0.0141082527,
-0.0560303107,
0.0278158393,
-0.0442681983,
-0.0683497265,
-0.008114079,
-0.0707510263,
0.0173875187,
0.0021310193,
-0.006268457,
0.0070306202,
-0.005907956,
0.0153369652,
-0.0135513181,
-0.0594580248,
-0.0446361192,
0.0023749324,
0.0098503344,
0.0410651192,
0.0339448154,
-0.0031472135,
0.0675135925,
-0.0345395133,
-0.0178836882,
-0.0114150848,
0.010889641,
0.0031632639,
0.0352053829,
0.0187843833,
0.0074909576,
0.0417185612,
-0.0053721131,
-0.069677189,
-0.0130652953,
0.0158794764,
0.0701595023,
0.0276388992,
0.011291733,
-0.0088344011,
-0.0404302366,
-0.0180020519,
0.0195207298,
-0.0353384614,
-0.0268247705,
0.0232724324,
0.0109865079,
-0.0307653435,
-0.0210433789,
-0.012750674,
-0.04640802,
-0.0241496824,
0.0651929229,
-0.0278028697,
-0.0269959625,
0.0107059199,
0.0009860236,
-0.0270596463,
-0.0114738643,
-0.014584763,
0.0079001551,
-0.0109462393,
0.0233461633,
0.0465801395,
0.0055090338,
-0.052596271,
-0.0154337212,
-0.045719292,
-0.0027011645,
0.0029349376,
0.0606937036,
0.0300700609,
0.0355411507,
-0.0069761551,
0.0569536164,
0.0440585464,
-0.0031943708,
-0.0421599708,
0.0533013754,
0.0201112833,
0.0360064246,
0.0080788815,
-0.0256096199,
-0.0010735058,
0.0201403871,
0.021858681,
-0.0603237934,
-0.0141291674,
-0.005680833,
2.533e-7,
-0.0071526789,
0.0284168068,
0.0300056767,
-0.0250854082,
0.0289370455,
0.0360301398,
0.0045509227,
-0.008986936,
0.0113546308,
0.0358363353,
-0.0172658712,
0.0323458202,
0.030798886,
0.0155809401,
-0.0448089875,
-0.0170691963,
-0.0611308329,
-0.0430547521,
-0.0513844639,
-0.0008007896,
0.0794363394,
0.0639661849,
0.0443596952,
0.0076160775,
-0.0119206188,
-0.0449553095,
0.0472415648,
-0.0320981592,
0.028539706,
0.0015980923,
-0.0030825958,
0.0248662774,
-0.0095350845,
0.0005513478,
-0.0316511355,
0.0323720984,
-0.0510083027,
0.0525603071,
-0.0109166894,
-0.0417090133,
-0.0062641953,
0.0052821948,
0.019968871,
-0.0614561625,
0.0754759833,
-0.0766735822,
0.0001401698,
0.0097516906,
-0.0049455473,
0.0108856605,
-0.0387685075,
0.0227062777,
-0.0086426614,
0.0165817142,
-0.0039194226,
0.0034449934,
-0.0071627926,
-0.0994421914,
-0.0126539674,
0.042868726,
-0.0038729855,
-0.0211410876,
-0.0009306623,
-0.019018067,
0.0348274335,
-0.0337214246,
0.0196104459,
2.261168306e-34,
0.017807629,
0.0190900229,
0.0003693902,
0.0786443129,
0.038983155,
-0.0142682986,
-0.0262365229,
-0.0053576361,
0.0609097071,
-0.0521666668,
-0.0119378967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06546v1 | AutoCycle-VC: Towards Bottleneck-Independent Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Voice Conversion | 2023-10-10T11:50:16 | 2023-10-10T11:50:16 | Haeyun Choi, Jio Gim, Yuho Lee, Youngin Kim, Young-Joo Suh | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper proposes a simple and robust zero-shot voice conversion system
with a cycle structure and mel-spectrogram pre-processing. Previous works
suffer from information loss and poor synthesis quality due to their reliance
on a carefully designed bottleneck structure. Moreover, models relying solely
on self-reconstruction loss struggled with reproducing different speakers'
voices. To address these issues, we suggested a cycle-consistency loss that
considers conversion back and forth between target and source speakers.
Additionally, stacked random-shuffled mel-spectrograms and a label smoothing
method are utilized during speaker encoder training to extract a
time-independent global speaker representation from speech, which is the key to
a zero-shot conversion. Our model outperforms existing state-of-the-art results
in both subjective and objective evaluations. Furthermore, it facilitates
cross-lingual voice conversions and enhances the quality of synthesized speech. | [
-0.0555190593,
0.0240016803,
0.0254426692,
0.0010360621,
0.0188893881,
-0.0481801108,
0.0673158243,
-0.0059660519,
-0.0873260573,
-0.0060424297,
-0.0872979686,
-0.0114031853,
0.0110421646,
0.0153520312,
0.0133715179,
-0.0712362081,
0.0188576132,
-0.0312180705,
-0.0133908717,
-0.0249230601,
-0.0011784133,
0.0040525016,
-0.0640899688,
-0.0197739191,
-0.0371729769,
-0.0206649601,
0.0120781297,
0.0313968286,
0.027544992,
-0.019263804,
-0.0466169566,
-0.0011119461,
0.0255455021,
0.0598942079,
0.000001727,
-0.0179972406,
0.0003108398,
-0.0099336114,
-0.0738233402,
0.0032590767,
0.0461476445,
0.0257081594,
-0.045847889,
0.0128406957,
-0.0003639002,
-0.0280974749,
0.0415688083,
-0.0395740382,
0.0323878936,
0.0415928066,
-0.0090445327,
-0.0237950906,
-0.0518490635,
-0.0076800138,
-0.0032125409,
0.0184985921,
-0.032667473,
-0.0146754151,
-0.0229981616,
-0.0231695417,
-0.0373126082,
0.0723516122,
-0.0239242762,
-0.0118715353,
0.0567191094,
-0.0177385248,
-0.0182452686,
-0.0435982719,
0.0141003402,
0.0604801886,
-0.0148570519,
0.0107974792,
0.007236585,
0.0354796872,
-0.0221758652,
-0.0440382138,
-0.0102980332,
0.0098654237,
0.0381154604,
-0.0095541691,
-0.0642461404,
0.0752385706,
0.0069544045,
-0.0678908601,
-0.0307505429,
-0.0041092271,
0.0161376465,
-0.0092594847,
0.0198508017,
0.0001574989,
0.0457522757,
0.0041078669,
0.021908205,
0.0208655,
0.025146082,
-0.0119070504,
-0.0322557203,
-0.0039304285,
-0.0425388925,
-0.0017892285,
0.0155498087,
0.0480450615,
-0.0164195001,
-0.0131103238,
0.004805319,
0.0065893084,
0.0088574989,
-0.0011039939,
-0.0380551927,
-0.0503238738,
-0.027295839,
0.0143769216,
-0.0528682396,
0.0066114524,
0.0080696261,
0.0095678065,
-0.0808423087,
-0.0191521589,
-0.0423322693,
0.0237592086,
0.005905787,
0.0045742216,
-0.0690340698,
-0.0292493161,
0.0212573968,
0.0983093306,
0.0339247771,
0.0161528457,
-0.0156111754,
-0.0594651476,
-0.0046552452,
0.007297107,
0.0050187521,
0.0293222107,
0.0031097427,
0.0688938722,
0.0023346827,
0.030038001,
-0.0095572099,
-0.029367676,
-0.0280776434,
-0.0416603014,
0.0082042841,
-0.0630867407,
0.0267581642,
0.0020379692,
0.0010928898,
0.0205438957,
-0.0246245898,
-0.0111358138,
0.0124066612,
0.0281082708,
-0.008210808,
0.03154926,
0.0688367039,
-0.0151041392,
0.0041625006,
0.0197569933,
0.0579671077,
-0.0416412316,
0.0039427057,
-0.0553018861,
0.0177750755,
0.0945503116,
0.0504330173,
0.0481696278,
-0.04414149,
-0.0372899547,
0.0020201367,
0.0409911089,
0.0765183866,
0.0009624797,
-0.0288578365,
-0.0057594259,
0.029308401,
-0.0045471657,
0.0670702457,
-0.0068381005,
0.0678409934,
0.0130343875,
-0.0100255739,
-0.0176877491,
0.0119143464,
0.0249408856,
-0.0106360614,
0.010556954,
0.0321888179,
0.0255719684,
-0.0601110049,
0.0238134619,
0.0339984484,
-0.0142162014,
-0.0166982636,
-0.0244115274,
0.0425965674,
0.04707966,
0.0068120416,
0.0666410476,
-0.0232833941,
-0.0770047829,
0.0428574272,
0.0115993414,
-0.0367190503,
0.0047902372,
-0.003922204,
0.0166884828,
0.0448860787,
-0.0606034473,
-0.0425261892,
0.0453319401,
-0.0096559217,
-0.0274433959,
0.0590740815,
-0.0335042626,
-0.0101527115,
0.0484742559,
-0.0309170689,
0.0177593306,
-0.0655830503,
0.0383455046,
0.0283173434,
-0.0230988171,
0.0724936128,
-0.0504379943,
-0.0295919031,
-0.0080680847,
0.0546343103,
0.0100715104,
0.0242924541,
0.037774846,
-0.0202195719,
0.0251550339,
0.0071646618,
-0.0576602481,
0.0317684785,
0.0347043723,
-0.065628916,
-0.0442699343,
0.0554127917,
-0.0236566048,
0.0440585278,
0.0092994962,
0.0132662673,
-0.1057065576,
0.0737937987,
0.0375465415,
0.0027702795,
-0.0047263219,
0.0323572531,
0.0405002013,
0.0190501511,
0.0310704932,
-0.0416896492,
0.0384173729,
-0.012552103,
0.0448070467,
0.0258089751,
0.0301486086,
-0.0719988719,
0.0200403072,
0.0677353889,
0.0100593558,
0.0065034064,
-0.0159694944,
-0.0600299537,
-0.0147688603,
0.0172322504,
-0.0701141208,
0.0255923606,
0.015270723,
0.0143204574,
-0.0103345597,
0.0291559007,
0.0029201291,
-0.0422382578,
-0.0312908702,
0.0153552173,
0.0013767692,
-0.0147983227,
-0.0159796234,
-0.0010942778,
-0.0078135682,
0.0106222378,
-0.0129850525,
0.037647061,
-0.0013185299,
-0.0900331065,
-0.0207407903,
-0.0137954392,
-0.0044715526,
0.0017012529,
0.0192647632,
0.0068455418,
-0.0129056033,
-0.0098895514,
0.0423502736,
0.0185140315,
-0.0014994096,
0.0089559602,
-0.0827312917,
0.0269728005,
-0.0485177524,
-0.053883601,
-0.0168050472,
0.0610621497,
0.0098577123,
-0.0026508989,
0.0069220453,
-0.007424789,
0.0097160758,
0.0321429521,
0.0311221648,
-0.0298387092,
-0.0362421162,
-0.0083406661,
-0.0306519978,
0.0084469607,
0.0080392091,
-0.0049059452,
-0.0198474489,
-0.014585048,
-0.003123533,
-0.0478839502,
-0.0586869083,
-0.0515282713,
-0.0083759706,
-0.0512860268,
-0.0060279383,
-0.0471625961,
-0.0166213568,
0.0253640134,
0.0018417346,
0.0239970181,
-0.0283757504,
0.0044341502,
0.0229249112,
-0.0558947958,
-0.0031951724,
0.0077671702,
-0.0116145005,
-0.0655046105,
0.0258960091,
-0.0009717413,
0.0177389439,
-0.0074294666,
0.0351665802,
-0.0132873878,
-0.0178998094,
0.0093425224,
0.0495454334,
0.0364559963,
0.0348549187,
0.0026764683,
0.013711039,
-0.004740905,
0.0654073134,
-0.0051831813,
-0.0092748599,
-0.0322037525,
-0.0248351432,
0.0431803949,
-0.0115903132,
0.0398943238,
0.0622918978,
-0.0210658107,
-0.0161133055,
0.0296504721,
0.0390397497,
-0.0534562208,
0.0145245846,
0.0509781912,
-0.0143686039,
0.0520374067,
0.0462157167,
-0.0276775453,
-0.08731924,
-0.0186196025,
-0.0192553848,
0.0213090256,
-0.0173335206,
-0.0076697702,
-0.0761175454,
-0.0190825239,
0.0276752803,
0.0212722942,
0.0164561551,
0.0377444737,
-0.0363989063,
-0.0670646653,
0.0140072098,
0.07410869,
-0.033484254,
-0.019821655,
-0.0004209755,
-0.0417764895,
-0.0291933659,
0.0464459136,
-0.0082139345,
-0.0213359687,
-0.0114819622,
0.0436837934,
-0.0311504826,
-0.0099928947,
-0.0268184766,
-0.0313294865,
0.1069032624,
0.0420534387,
0.0345247462,
0.0144845098,
-0.0054748422,
-0.0216871053,
-0.0286683999,
-0.0065988679,
-0.0062066242,
0.0324101262,
0.0147201391,
0.0159184225,
0.0511126556,
0.003775286,
-0.0111653274,
0.0194504447,
0.0054975217,
0.0294597093,
0.0177434906,
-0.0019305573,
-0.0191027187,
0.0348529629,
0.0202388857,
0.0654654801,
0.0061681885,
-0.0308308415,
-0.0107587362,
-0.0086088227,
0.0515612289,
-0.0813198611,
-0.0627577528,
0.0382440314,
-0.0153991152,
-0.0615256466,
0.0111542447,
-0.0091026714,
-0.0046681226,
0.0542052723,
-0.0170203671,
-0.026561765,
-0.0141761275,
0.008471814,
-0.0222480781,
-0.0657309666,
-0.0697640777,
0.0381741412,
-0.0425259247,
0.0098117758,
0.0209233612,
0.0046925666,
0.0425743572,
0.0047273571,
-0.0420060679,
-0.0336917378,
0.0058282311,
-0.0216623452,
0.0089459186,
0.092075415,
0.0206503216,
-0.0205496848,
0.0871317908,
-0.0159954522,
0.0000944231,
0.04567682,
0.0856349096,
0.0307115112,
-0.0250609014,
0.0245101247,
-0.0232324749,
0.0357397497,
-0.0163256936,
0.0102679003,
-0.0239659902,
-0.0635746121,
-0.001430748,
0.003985859,
-0.0203812029,
-0.0204364099,
0.0681533739,
0.0238455776,
0.0060053407,
-0.0511827171,
0.0349632986,
-0.0447347909,
-0.0398838408,
0.0514699779,
-0.0185545422,
0.0248691663,
0.0257361047,
-0.0446163379,
-0.0165751539,
0.0190606415,
0.0026692734,
-0.0030887912,
0.00714166,
-0.0125997663,
0.000005814,
0.0073710321,
0.012720108,
0.0514937155,
-0.0098335566,
-0.048302345,
0.0096906871,
-0.0105769131,
0.0271393303,
-0.0057156892,
0.0149159301,
-0.0103899939,
0.0097294152,
-0.0133141112,
-0.044636596,
0.0322497375,
0.002828921,
0.0986835212,
0.0040748459,
0.0217154585,
-0.0271582529,
0.0224464443,
-0.0498754829,
0.0404074937,
-0.0053035771,
-0.0469678231,
0.0105672674,
0.0206691846,
0.0530139171,
0.032946948,
0.0044486187,
-0.0327324905,
0.0473648869,
-0.0052738856,
0.0044667367,
-0.042381905,
-0.0332344621,
0.0002304532,
-0.0582592227,
-0.0239557307,
-0.0347887315,
0.0247359686,
-0.0411492847,
0.0301924013,
-0.0332500376,
0.0075862566,
-0.0337016135,
-0.0270170439,
0.0209125038,
-0.005704612,
0.0028630847,
0.0586662032,
-0.023309214,
0.009874491,
-5.09051649e-33,
-0.0576535575,
0.0608698949,
0.0397636257,
-0.0261494387,
-0.0552862734,
-0.0211114809,
-0.0374628976,
0.024915535,
-0.025020577,
-0.0086904941,
-0.0207542498,
0.0005909223,
0.0186332352,
0.0221793447,
0.018442424,
0.0546703003,
0.1187981889,
-0.0574940816,
-0.0165685639,
0.0711835101,
0.0467456765,
0.0386692546,
0.0261506084,
-0.0603411049,
-0.0733964294,
0.0033392117,
-0.0040226728,
-0.0045027831,
0.038469445,
-0.0319965035,
0.0118179247,
0.0714555755,
-0.0229727142,
-0.0432064496,
-0.0172020737,
-0.0211425051,
-0.0559546016,
-0.0108091822,
-0.0530313626,
0.0223832075,
-0.0073693967,
-0.0353893451,
-0.0112488614,
0.0163435545,
-0.0386582538,
-0.0554131605,
-0.0009522566,
-0.0294541977,
-0.0513052791,
-0.0525908731,
-0.0128018539,
0.0399204791,
-0.0019802474,
-0.0309919324,
0.0984220356,
0.1157905683,
-0.0422541648,
-0.0220536869,
-0.0806553066,
0.0622430332,
-0.0407307334,
0.0492314287,
0.0469775908,
0.0404974446,
0.0079966187,
-0.0038673617,
0.053304676,
-0.0544284135,
0.0173057485,
0.0325138234,
0.0564749092,
0.0353788212,
0.0205272734,
0.0387501679,
0.0770081282,
-0.0357154384,
0.0143300705,
0.017585583,
-0.0115676224,
-0.0167602394,
-0.0204362981,
0.0556759164,
0.0415922068,
-0.0138143236,
-0.0390727483,
-0.0821675658,
-0.0028412649,
-0.0415067263,
0.0013319821,
-0.0094876522,
0.0151868463,
-0.0140584754,
0.0945764855,
-0.006144281,
-0.0080074957,
0.0115773557,
-0.0351589099,
0.0251553562,
0.0020630071,
-0.0125793722,
-0.0323836952,
-0.0347697362,
0.07032267,
0.0407946296,
0.0086960541,
-0.0035474759,
-0.009079013,
0.0427414253,
-0.0051589827,
-0.0431541763,
0.0145400809,
0.0148286661,
0.0270703603,
0.0114338947,
-0.0042361734,
0.009207828,
0.0148863588,
0.0164566133,
-0.0309796669,
0.0010880261,
0.0403342023,
0.0086248135,
0.0512185059,
0.0256727431,
-0.0499978215,
0.0560923368,
-0.0213396102,
-0.018726401,
0.073136434,
-0.0313271321,
-0.0322329588,
-0.0284355041,
2.51e-7,
-0.013970443,
-0.0285314173,
0.0259102471,
-0.0674393103,
0.0391695201,
0.0510782413,
-0.0234704651,
0.0153909978,
-0.0040900414,
-0.0061601154,
-0.0034355831,
0.0009259653,
0.0781849772,
0.0409262814,
-0.0247097854,
-0.0358520262,
-0.002689793,
0.0190671943,
-0.001788801,
0.0373066142,
0.0033204453,
0.0304979645,
-0.0449094214,
-0.0598573275,
0.0475894772,
0.0375512652,
0.0531279184,
0.0112155685,
-0.0149542205,
-0.0079430966,
0.0236262586,
-0.0211757366,
-0.0130038923,
-0.0050930046,
-0.0388910547,
0.0096711777,
0.012531382,
0.0107903099,
-0.0166432653,
-0.0767580941,
-0.0031790945,
0.0494474955,
-0.0419082083,
0.0651374906,
0.0120846322,
0.0123323146,
0.0010544263,
-0.0451772325,
-0.086087577,
0.0896090865,
0.0071905744,
-0.009688531,
-0.0259434804,
-0.0009913316,
0.0452032275,
0.0377021022,
-0.0239387974,
0.0047145328,
-0.0197770204,
-0.0220920257,
-0.0539053977,
-0.0096549746,
-0.0168601982,
-0.0061580031,
-0.007737889,
0.024652347,
-0.0127292927,
1.702963921e-34,
-0.0193805117,
-0.0112499045,
0.0336606987,
-0.0410340764,
-0.0467621535,
-0.0419986434,
-0.0028950218,
0.0232961774,
-0.0307120439,
-0.021604944,
-0.0607613102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06540v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06540v1 | A Novel Contrastive Learning Method for Clickbait Detection on RoCliCo: A Romanian Clickbait Corpus of News Articles | 2023-10-10T11:38:16 | 2023-10-10T11:38:16 | Daria-Mihaela Broscoteanu, Radu Tudor Ionescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | To increase revenue, news websites often resort to using deceptive news
titles, luring users into clicking on the title and reading the full news.
Clickbait detection is the task that aims to automatically detect this form of
false advertisement and avoid wasting the precious time of online users.
Despite the importance of the task, to the best of our knowledge, there is no
publicly available clickbait corpus for the Romanian language. To this end, we
introduce a novel Romanian Clickbait Corpus (RoCliCo) comprising 8,313 news
samples which are manually annotated with clickbait and non-clickbait labels.
Furthermore, we conduct experiments with four machine learning methods, ranging
from handcrafted models to recurrent and transformer-based neural networks, to
establish a line-up of competitive baselines. We also carry out experiments
with a weighted voting ensemble. Among the considered baselines, we propose a
novel BERT-based contrastive learning model that learns to encode news titles
and contents into a deep metric space such that titles and contents of
non-clickbait news have high cosine similarity, while titles and contents of
clickbait news have low cosine similarity. Our data set and code to reproduce
the baselines are publicly available for download at
https://github.com/dariabroscoteanu/RoCliCo. | [
0.0594132617,
0.0371184088,
-0.0225514602,
0.0551890619,
-0.0516983755,
0.0375365131,
-0.01443158,
0.0286600031,
0.0062048892,
-0.0021746014,
-0.032436762,
-0.0456757732,
-0.0029194243,
0.048119463,
0.0064474954,
-0.0608146973,
0.0279530175,
0.0160639863,
0.0131203299,
-0.0062924246,
0.0289656669,
0.0051376093,
0.0244582482,
0.0109568955,
0.0150942793,
-0.0224784166,
0.024431685,
0.0223677885,
0.0464239977,
-0.0274101552,
0.0817663297,
0.0375771672,
0.0080558416,
0.0769337937,
0.0000016015,
-0.0344495438,
0.0027833099,
-0.0099273929,
0.0128373336,
0.0094706239,
0.050755389,
-0.0393633172,
-0.0147940479,
0.0169440527,
-0.0183889028,
0.0012740369,
0.0482858084,
0.0775573477,
0.050779108,
0.0786727369,
-0.0216613021,
-0.0223955121,
-0.0104096262,
-0.0415614061,
0.0002095301,
0.0066588963,
0.0350150131,
-0.0378999002,
-0.0175349936,
0.0389520191,
-0.0114146331,
0.0271074567,
0.0021446468,
-0.0093622766,
-0.0500903577,
0.0364406481,
-0.027514454,
-0.0218324047,
0.0107668908,
0.0301495381,
-0.089031443,
-0.0454864167,
0.0107834991,
0.0210897997,
-0.0007291641,
0.0065946286,
-0.0599263683,
0.034806598,
0.0095136929,
0.0359004326,
0.0153726665,
0.0049537108,
0.0056820321,
0.0342741236,
0.0281555932,
-0.0390745848,
0.0169688128,
-0.0459562466,
0.0477559939,
0.0029108305,
0.0465130657,
-0.0502301976,
0.0473183878,
0.0052429228,
-0.0088987872,
-0.014994422,
-0.0401915424,
-0.0701968372,
0.0280295704,
-0.095151484,
-0.0442614444,
0.0060579963,
-0.0335258283,
0.0424177535,
-0.0362516157,
0.010701919,
-0.0088694496,
0.0386685096,
-0.0244702529,
0.0243113767,
0.0073407274,
-0.0129770245,
-0.0272276942,
0.0399327576,
-0.0162177142,
-0.013820976,
-0.0554357357,
0.0245458838,
0.008044024,
0.0347785503,
-0.0177251268,
0.043802768,
-0.0348649248,
0.0046433653,
0.0064355964,
0.0235147942,
-0.0030394269,
0.0037503748,
-0.0125387087,
-0.0338896811,
-0.0357453562,
0.0199223515,
-0.0056186914,
-0.0359827988,
0.0544391461,
-0.0017619712,
-0.0042143222,
-0.0488663651,
-0.0521616563,
0.0087896306,
-0.0406418592,
-0.0209330972,
-0.0236454383,
-0.0778842419,
0.0110349311,
-0.0167144332,
-0.0008186228,
-0.0132683292,
-0.010307082,
0.0616907179,
-0.044852037,
0.0489802957,
0.0265683141,
-0.032765951,
0.0111426562,
0.0332145952,
0.0081148949,
0.0624257959,
-0.0116291847,
0.1575179249,
0.0441721566,
0.0206526462,
0.0154773705,
0.0360938571,
0.022961732,
0.0065966463,
0.009401002,
0.0103133842,
-0.0178010631,
0.0208184365,
0.0295895506,
0.0376715176,
-0.0090423254,
-0.05077805,
0.0929354876,
0.0055623022,
-0.015642887,
0.0471546948,
0.0539369546,
0.0036163423,
-0.0180123057,
0.0207896829,
-0.0390176065,
0.0020349915,
-0.0088810697,
0.008678332,
0.0022332286,
0.0545707829,
-0.0166350026,
-0.0050047431,
0.0240342543,
-0.0218779724,
-0.0091243032,
-0.0352869369,
0.0622092262,
0.03637366,
-0.0799792483,
0.0112486593,
0.0258220136,
0.009100738,
0.0225344673,
-0.0244471971,
0.0403944179,
0.0064374893,
0.0400224887,
0.0026976799,
-0.0121471761,
-0.0349140428,
-0.0147074228,
0.0438259803,
0.0100703025,
-0.0225047991,
-0.0520926788,
-0.0104693398,
-0.0365220271,
-0.0417089462,
-0.0023442991,
0.0546773002,
-0.0235308297,
0.0488291159,
0.0346262977,
-0.0075022671,
-0.0292928331,
0.0108959097,
0.0296455938,
-0.0177450869,
0.0012230686,
0.0266097803,
0.0400873758,
0.0089047281,
-0.0097331898,
-0.0094551388,
0.0406402498,
-0.0130963316,
-0.0221992098,
-0.0050929836,
0.0410841517,
-0.0684837699,
0.0152203077,
-0.1279030591,
-0.0099184606,
0.1119572967,
-0.0187120214,
-0.0032050202,
0.0451959446,
-0.048702687,
0.0247920416,
-0.0388218947,
-0.016440874,
-0.0282348245,
0.0298681147,
0.0231481213,
0.077322498,
-0.0141606126,
0.0382408835,
0.0326785445,
-0.0237311684,
-0.0085484348,
-0.0337628648,
-0.034772452,
-0.0158732012,
-0.0214561336,
-0.0162631553,
0.0194795653,
0.0042958548,
-0.0063708359,
-0.0080923587,
-0.0755703896,
-0.000278995,
-0.0181388669,
0.0161177367,
0.0455314331,
-0.0002810209,
-0.0097277369,
-0.0054755509,
-0.0829346851,
-0.0879050195,
-0.0227097422,
0.0212841127,
0.0048540179,
-0.0055044689,
0.0057416139,
0.0089020617,
0.0149062146,
-0.011740922,
0.0594628416,
0.0381169654,
-0.0056101214,
-0.0187259614,
0.0032234713,
0.0062583187,
-0.0070890491,
-0.0281471107,
-0.026875386,
-0.0388652459,
0.0355412252,
0.0011171405,
0.0365743898,
0.0634850264,
0.0336754061,
0.0156374983,
0.0344888866,
-0.0443336181,
-0.030696556,
-0.0605929345,
0.0314642154,
-0.0382242948,
-0.063972041,
0.0537558533,
0.0205859877,
0.0167729277,
0.0380143896,
0.0065143844,
0.0276981276,
0.0084030414,
0.0268336423,
-0.0174512621,
-0.0145783285,
-0.0014571864,
0.0161865726,
-0.0143445032,
-0.0106852464,
0.0703175515,
-0.0196395405,
0.006229355,
-0.0173839163,
-0.0114677809,
-0.0174523443,
-0.0156992227,
-0.0187871475,
0.0397849903,
-0.0002374203,
-0.0563957989,
-0.0080075972,
0.0123796007,
0.0476705022,
-0.0232648849,
0.0125776147,
0.024837425,
-0.0002568008,
-0.0023801976,
-0.0658900216,
-0.0705855265,
-0.0713682026,
0.0124142952,
-0.020295212,
0.0319251865,
-0.0094010737,
-0.0663007796,
0.0146988546,
0.0012769242,
0.0279811732,
-0.0349332578,
-0.0063387551,
0.0223501697,
0.1126526073,
0.041593615,
-0.0456454828,
0.0164139476,
-0.0008906559,
-0.0395745449,
0.0356765762,
-0.0039535728,
0.0197597705,
-0.0333055444,
-0.0089076292,
0.0336213261,
-0.0546374097,
0.0105876494,
-0.0588976406,
-0.0778819621,
-0.0201907959,
-0.0205637217,
0.0717810094,
0.0094892727,
-0.0449094214,
-0.020542521,
0.0142833497,
-0.0074179424,
-0.0005794224,
0.0072301831,
-0.0553526692,
0.002671374,
-0.0095564127,
0.0151246358,
-0.0237108357,
-0.009423052,
-0.0108917588,
-0.0966935158,
0.0130861308,
-0.000431858,
-0.0377175435,
-0.0540747419,
-0.0697672889,
-0.0070075789,
-0.0375514962,
-0.0103133023,
0.0037225124,
-0.0131190531,
-0.005213568,
0.001503156,
-0.0016392653,
-0.0684170574,
-0.0095435111,
-0.0110777402,
0.0145863444,
0.0346638337,
0.0594605505,
-0.0572216138,
-0.0176326986,
-0.0122483196,
-0.0488076881,
-0.0523168221,
-0.0420738682,
0.0761353299,
-0.0462077819,
-0.0051601147,
-0.0069142994,
0.041085422,
0.03084342,
0.0151627893,
-0.0074378559,
0.0303213112,
0.0336136036,
-0.0724877417,
-0.0433327891,
-0.0125990454,
0.0264934599,
0.0754769519,
0.0376359113,
-0.0260286964,
-0.0047239568,
-0.0083323438,
-0.0295725893,
-0.0602021217,
-0.007495909,
-0.0131053645,
-0.03105193,
-0.0545587875,
-0.0705598146,
-0.0303078853,
-0.0160182063,
-0.0041525662,
0.0215405207,
-0.0416946337,
-0.0106981639,
-0.0101012615,
-0.0816603526,
-0.0033013483,
-0.0044727833,
0.0089808917,
-0.0302079655,
0.0204325095,
0.0589755997,
-0.0570412278,
-0.0591876544,
-0.0080582481,
-0.0745154619,
-0.0214205347,
-0.0299408492,
0.0400393121,
0.011304264,
0.051873263,
-0.0216486417,
-0.0262876321,
0.0861502364,
0.0666288361,
0.0094441092,
-0.0357543267,
0.0305628255,
0.0063814865,
0.0283522829,
0.0117557086,
-0.033193294,
0.0425474383,
0.0277284645,
-0.0361060314,
-0.0358393379,
0.0425151587,
0.0172392465,
0.0109109944,
0.0597661585,
-0.0377730951,
0.022452347,
-0.0524043925,
-0.0004461232,
0.0167467762,
-0.0033649213,
-0.0213013515,
0.0309936032,
0.0536831915,
0.0276504811,
-0.0291836169,
0.0275243185,
-0.0391116962,
-0.0401455648,
-0.0655889809,
-0.0144813284,
0.0112873064,
0.0544161536,
0.0223567355,
0.0058718086,
-0.0219553784,
0.023640871,
0.0337324962,
0.0422293283,
-0.0154403942,
-0.000233106,
0.0644542575,
-0.0229978338,
0.046619378,
0.0432566442,
-0.0132422065,
0.0506892502,
-0.0870474204,
-0.0006037048,
0.0339619257,
-0.0482369773,
0.0036562551,
-0.0251500607,
-0.0063521937,
0.02474894,
-0.0056072394,
-0.0276432671,
-0.0486130603,
-0.0096487347,
0.0007422141,
0.0044886414,
0.0142211821,
0.0684277043,
-0.0419368036,
0.0136997318,
0.0502195694,
-0.0729189664,
-0.0230665244,
0.0157055445,
0.059729524,
0.0141633796,
-0.010619577,
-0.0437670648,
-0.0312022325,
-0.0457822308,
0.0476055332,
0.0140702082,
0.0255875736,
0.0592412129,
0.0243465248,
0.0659182072,
0.0217778739,
0.0410123132,
-0.0185574349,
0.0142707517,
-0.0210758895,
-0.0481111631,
-0.0292114429,
-5.586091684e-33,
0.0290972646,
-0.0413233228,
-0.0497785807,
0.0210779682,
-0.012322058,
0.0091648139,
-0.0307910573,
-0.0417325832,
-0.0072511304,
0.0192756802,
0.0235281233,
0.0250353068,
0.0025009138,
0.0436440259,
-0.0330943502,
-0.0372814015,
0.0398140252,
0.0167045519,
-0.0245439224,
0.0421854071,
0.0141152432,
0.0353745632,
0.0476435795,
-0.0375602841,
0.0261900704,
-0.026267413,
-0.0649173632,
0.0288786422,
0.0421392731,
0.0514694937,
-0.0035519982,
0.0359471887,
0.0439794809,
-0.0205832273,
0.0294489656,
0.0586170666,
-0.0429831967,
-0.0393744484,
0.0405155607,
0.0224640593,
0.0030033516,
0.0060743913,
0.0711148009,
-0.0131054018,
0.0028701599,
0.0019013125,
0.0613756143,
-0.048829753,
0.0123845069,
-0.0235024523,
-0.0197772048,
0.0027746642,
-0.0307933353,
-0.0057329908,
0.0144330291,
0.0854681507,
0.0334595516,
0.0694229379,
-0.0760405734,
0.0362575874,
-0.0058525647,
0.0144234104,
0.046209991,
-0.0145863183,
-0.0036250262,
0.0600818396,
0.0098311994,
-0.0142582422,
-0.0147502543,
0.0389197096,
0.0318267904,
0.0139066223,
0.0697795972,
0.0681888387,
0.0449876599,
-0.0276529919,
-0.0711769462,
0.0496738777,
0.0426967926,
-0.0216809418,
0.0133895669,
-0.0261261649,
-0.0455351286,
0.0197580382,
0.0065187803,
-0.0542434081,
-0.0395184904,
-0.0374650992,
0.0163816735,
-0.0026419051,
-0.0371922702,
0.0483204387,
-0.0214523897,
-0.0527612753,
-0.0029226304,
0.0110003753,
-0.0054731541,
-0.0148438411,
0.0054329247,
0.0123004531,
-0.0026804155,
-0.010386005,
0.0000639673,
0.0080339629,
0.0015090543,
-0.0273993537,
0.0712778345,
0.0194755029,
-0.0544369072,
0.0192079209,
-0.0104422234,
-0.0057041412,
-0.0058884639,
0.0136463046,
0.0129674841,
-0.0198318437,
-0.0208270438,
-0.0172553305,
0.0306788664,
0.0221878327,
-0.0221138932,
-0.0211153682,
-0.0049713859,
0.0431474,
-0.0080038775,
-0.0377494171,
-0.0042769494,
0.0226213522,
0.0147613669,
-0.0917269066,
-0.0092812525,
-0.0185593888,
2.469e-7,
-0.0110462755,
0.0386240557,
-0.0030312983,
0.0168518666,
0.0023393722,
0.0401079953,
0.0015368938,
0.0631559044,
0.0177325681,
-0.0088438857,
0.0009975927,
-0.0317658223,
0.0018058321,
-0.0044635446,
-0.1114850566,
0.0303486735,
-0.1017503366,
-0.0524848774,
-0.0292479042,
-0.0078773852,
0.0200997293,
0.0655793846,
0.0610699318,
-0.0510451868,
0.0271118097,
-0.0273658298,
0.0324207768,
0.0115790414,
-0.0240107067,
0.0102487933,
0.0353222936,
0.0144146066,
-0.0067200637,
-0.0135016451,
-0.0171982553,
0.023598833,
0.0359547697,
0.0223232172,
0.035032142,
-0.0003579546,
-0.0002598754,
-0.0465206057,
0.0051163011,
-0.0917770937,
0.0518537387,
-0.0419549495,
-0.0049065049,
-0.0540688224,
-0.0588942543,
-0.029104799,
0.0585737303,
-0.0547527783,
-0.0103617646,
-0.001016301,
0.0036492231,
0.0184648205,
0.0056782216,
-0.055293031,
0.0432007164,
0.0235645846,
-0.0412946269,
0.0027735033,
-0.0121700671,
-0.0153026162,
0.0316523015,
-0.0394792594,
0.0346699581,
1.891156434e-34,
0.0505241305,
-0.0375651345,
-0.0272423979,
-0.0223554671,
-0.0392553546,
0.0193322413,
0.0148712983,
-0.0166792776,
0.0098212082,
-0.0107060838,
-0.0058402386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06536v1 | EmoTwiCS: A Corpus for Modelling Emotion Trajectories in Dutch Customer Service Dialogues on Twitter | 2023-10-10T11:31:11 | 2023-10-10T11:31:11 | Sofie Labat, Thomas Demeester, Véronique Hoste | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the rise of user-generated content, social media is increasingly
adopted as a channel to deliver customer service. Given the public character of
these online platforms, the automatic detection of emotions forms an important
application in monitoring customer satisfaction and preventing negative
word-of-mouth. This paper introduces EmoTwiCS, a corpus of 9,489 Dutch customer
service dialogues on Twitter that are annotated for emotion trajectories. In
our business-oriented corpus, we view emotions as dynamic attributes of the
customer that can change at each utterance of the conversation. The term
`emotion trajectory' refers therefore not only to the fine-grained emotions
experienced by customers (annotated with 28 labels and
valence-arousal-dominance scores), but also to the event happening prior to the
conversation and the responses made by the human operator (both annotated with
8 categories). Inter-annotator agreement (IAA) scores on the resulting dataset
are substantial and comparable with related research, underscoring its high
quality. Given the interplay between the different layers of annotated
information, we perform several in-depth analyses to investigate (i) static
emotions in isolated tweets, (ii) dynamic emotions and their shifts in
trajectory, and (iii) the role of causes and response strategies in emotion
trajectories. We conclude by listing the advantages and limitations of our
dataset, after which we give some suggestions on the different types of
predictive modelling tasks and open research questions to which EmoTwiCS can be
applied. The dataset is available upon request and will be made publicly
available upon acceptance of the paper. | [
0.0667054355,
0.0193728227,
-0.0275094397,
0.001835661,
-0.0362771675,
0.037968412,
-0.035811916,
-0.0266015753,
0.034185987,
-0.0569889434,
0.004685211,
-0.0217180941,
-0.0386978798,
0.0291226562,
-0.0229450297,
-0.0436772853,
0.0087717893,
0.070921123,
0.0653308108,
0.0069127171,
0.0637759492,
0.0433180183,
-0.0093741277,
0.0190526675,
-0.0503832512,
-0.0040773284,
-0.0217875708,
0.0138286212,
0.0561940931,
-0.0340614393,
0.0832983404,
0.0555214286,
0.0100030126,
0.0171384998,
0.0000020908,
-0.0234276243,
-0.0174004212,
-0.0219984595,
-0.0135909878,
-0.0199022405,
0.0695694014,
0.0011449619,
-0.0016259595,
0.0154993739,
-0.0307200085,
0.0252048355,
0.0408921503,
0.0499361716,
0.1107233167,
0.077211827,
-0.0453909561,
-0.0300088208,
-0.0638091713,
0.0194181055,
-0.0107915951,
-0.0157352332,
0.0089021595,
-0.0239131842,
-0.0238459799,
-0.0458712131,
0.0124112116,
0.0053126346,
-0.0340523757,
0.0100478157,
0.0173827689,
-0.0078088297,
-0.0387073457,
-0.0553415082,
-0.0082090739,
0.0443444625,
0.0220204331,
0.0033726508,
0.0106997313,
-0.0009433723,
0.0183912367,
-0.0175379626,
-0.0269511156,
-0.0322649442,
-0.0092617003,
0.0029173314,
-0.0345807187,
0.0403932482,
-0.0302019808,
0.0302792024,
0.016829839,
0.0361538231,
-0.0313708931,
-0.0439459756,
0.0284274984,
0.0344338566,
-0.0106372936,
-0.0202027988,
-0.004030305,
-0.0121652465,
0.0034573285,
0.0140849836,
0.0011261908,
-0.005501573,
-0.0032549612,
-0.1052943915,
-0.0364023484,
0.018637279,
-0.0142814275,
-0.0012775417,
0.0412076414,
0.0018458305,
-0.0013106285,
-0.021927299,
-0.0170247518,
0.0114720883,
-0.057142444,
0.0375350043,
-0.0022800174,
0.0251361504,
-0.0124479728,
-0.0240083467,
-0.0862434059,
0.0111753335,
-0.017715238,
-0.0026791783,
-0.0115994802,
0.0216196682,
-0.0000528005,
0.0099654533,
-0.0212823339,
0.019880807,
-0.048379343,
0.017519109,
-0.0324904136,
-0.0243179966,
0.0454755239,
0.018347647,
0.0341771021,
-0.0065825549,
-0.0124081112,
0.0205739196,
0.0089369398,
-0.0332875662,
-0.0634161681,
-0.0416396558,
-0.01336296,
-0.0518202521,
-0.0086837253,
-0.0193582773,
0.0550149865,
0.0393394157,
-0.0152241485,
0.0444068313,
0.0245282724,
0.0172305051,
-0.0354694165,
0.0298775733,
-0.0560489669,
0.0083224596,
-0.0043562348,
-0.0044246851,
0.044458352,
0.0341880992,
0.0321815684,
0.0638115928,
0.0575349554,
0.0001805508,
0.0424526744,
0.0160422511,
-0.0133368075,
-0.0461433157,
0.0064450833,
-0.0118097952,
-0.044069618,
0.0001929671,
0.013794506,
0.0228395853,
-0.0095435465,
-0.0107865287,
0.0232844204,
0.0365683287,
-0.0497643612,
0.022102626,
-0.0137916068,
0.0210406967,
0.0244860277,
-0.017082978,
0.0190391131,
0.0175371654,
-0.0151330819,
-0.0179474913,
0.0139591731,
-0.0131818261,
-0.0193350315,
-0.0449300259,
-0.0124671217,
-0.0227156952,
0.0054522422,
-0.0243918262,
-0.0019524398,
-0.0499798581,
-0.0340301804,
0.0191341247,
0.0223798472,
-0.0779376253,
-0.0462274328,
-0.0048025358,
0.0165069923,
0.0934931636,
0.0108229658,
0.0045061852,
-0.0181850176,
-0.0452890098,
-0.0290932991,
0.0367989801,
0.0060812035,
-0.013480965,
-0.0238887761,
-0.0476128682,
0.0171539038,
-0.0057425317,
-0.0101328772,
0.0112065179,
-0.0449618548,
0.0137514174,
-0.0346338414,
0.0246677939,
0.0011813632,
-0.0298806392,
0.0009649795,
0.0001405047,
-0.0089353258,
0.0172416717,
0.0466250814,
0.0671412423,
-0.0004910672,
-0.0353855379,
0.016474681,
0.0085325595,
-0.0385279208,
0.0802263618,
0.0364389531,
0.0093555395,
0.0297706164,
-0.0176545829,
-0.037015222,
0.0241809376,
-0.042467609,
-0.0249871146,
0.0631393865,
-0.0204489995,
0.0358154699,
-0.0225100927,
-0.0096702892,
-0.03277703,
0.0388334915,
0.0019947945,
0.0272745285,
0.0045948797,
-0.008778506,
-0.0421135798,
-0.0646634325,
-0.0000031108,
0.0263678953,
-0.0374529324,
-0.0047878535,
0.0341119021,
0.0286253691,
0.0224106461,
-0.0515830889,
-0.0626669973,
-0.0130068874,
-0.107919246,
0.0061160158,
-0.0062518287,
-0.0058853594,
-0.0085460236,
0.0121038025,
-0.0273451526,
0.0122197876,
-0.0277136061,
0.0307808928,
0.032910306,
0.0014502372,
0.0276779775,
0.0066533051,
0.0107601918,
-0.0672170669,
0.0279511381,
-0.0423445813,
-0.0039055073,
0.0399765186,
-0.0625212565,
0.0008107133,
-0.0000869418,
-0.0626587942,
0.0298865326,
-0.0072649382,
-0.0761890262,
-0.0203935783,
0.0005423649,
-0.0150033906,
-0.004396969,
0.0530185774,
0.0682342127,
-0.0587900579,
-0.0408909433,
-0.0466952585,
0.0461380593,
-0.0507369824,
-0.0222269949,
-0.0292396229,
-0.0381517448,
0.0079153236,
0.0750182196,
0.0075294217,
0.0135594467,
-0.0485945195,
-0.0368863195,
-0.0130144255,
0.00030086,
-0.0070944065,
-0.0109277545,
-0.0149608487,
0.0424146205,
0.0372982547,
-0.047850877,
0.0287240669,
0.0471037515,
0.0017506008,
-0.0591879189,
-0.018543439,
-0.0380826183,
0.0335161164,
-0.0379469842,
-0.0070576356,
0.0288908277,
-0.005713501,
0.0490344428,
-0.0480191074,
-0.0247446969,
-0.0531292111,
0.0028801654,
-0.0008344578,
0.0062446762,
0.0412101522,
-0.0383509547,
-0.0042005568,
-0.067333743,
-0.075126715,
-0.0248618089,
0.0435777828,
-0.0304435585,
-0.0269588195,
-0.0118200444,
-0.012496856,
-0.0705631673,
-0.0033302866,
-0.0331556834,
0.0158301946,
0.0224204026,
0.0572846644,
0.021477256,
0.018669147,
-0.0017566578,
-0.0078865374,
0.0336547866,
-0.0031087263,
-0.0080544846,
-0.0116129769,
-0.0064832014,
-0.0144785773,
-0.0008424398,
0.0017937945,
-0.0633117408,
0.0233037937,
0.0059527378,
0.0317099616,
0.1166495606,
0.0317503139,
-0.0090876101,
0.0074385791,
0.0216591116,
0.013898124,
0.0192020908,
0.0339853317,
-0.0733706057,
0.0055257785,
-0.0360985138,
0.0441233143,
-0.0129240574,
-0.040972434,
-0.0188097358,
-0.108446151,
0.0553183369,
0.0020780477,
0.049696669,
-0.0010465471,
0.0139541933,
0.0169552993,
-0.0206265021,
-0.0043744636,
-0.073754333,
0.0292964838,
0.0119095622,
0.0499786697,
-0.0483713746,
-0.031382177,
0.0332165733,
0.0025332591,
0.0263199098,
-0.0017022243,
0.0855182409,
-0.0108227273,
-0.0229367167,
0.0202620365,
0.0110957231,
-0.000249645,
0.0011395229,
0.0726455599,
-0.0229321644,
-0.0207571499,
-0.0508552119,
0.0248309188,
-0.060837701,
0.025507642,
-0.0163547583,
0.0277641378,
-0.0391045623,
-0.0240202677,
-0.0241918825,
0.033812236,
0.0294360872,
0.0505504161,
-0.0096038394,
-0.0659452006,
-0.0075638648,
-0.0248572007,
0.027685564,
0.0109375827,
-0.0454264246,
-0.0043616877,
0.0070671416,
-0.0398216583,
-0.0557137467,
-0.0738917738,
-0.0146913137,
0.009658007,
-0.0255735405,
-0.0456170477,
0.0362518057,
-0.0142986961,
-0.0236301478,
0.0265601799,
0.0306018945,
0.0327782519,
-0.003726749,
-0.0055656526,
0.0552117079,
0.0182412267,
-0.0070029576,
-0.0359255262,
-0.0418182798,
-0.063080959,
0.0417416133,
0.0130059551,
0.0199389327,
0.0183515958,
0.020039646,
-0.0622355156,
-0.0258389432,
0.0679991096,
-0.0216854867,
-0.0081216851,
0.0268603899,
0.1152381673,
-0.0307658017,
0.0163421761,
-0.0106603485,
0.046857141,
-0.0282065775,
-0.026519753,
-0.0231807716,
-0.0158172343,
-0.0002887803,
0.0079998104,
0.0482500196,
0.0178612396,
-0.0469090901,
-0.0321663916,
-0.0309367329,
-0.0042923233,
-0.0208844598,
-0.0368464328,
-0.0374377519,
-0.0236982442,
0.001194665,
-0.0800176114,
-0.0584861524,
-0.031329453,
-0.0184826758,
-0.0361937471,
0.0393533297,
0.0369607508,
0.0005952353,
-0.0256980155,
-0.0015605274,
0.0072813905,
-0.0007222767,
0.0260966159,
0.0125988089,
0.001073632,
0.0383191332,
0.0064501972,
0.0009056785,
0.0268320162,
0.0248509459,
-0.0087760845,
0.0121367974,
-0.0148256049,
0.0151211135,
-0.0066672438,
-0.0748573169,
0.070549801,
-0.0317759849,
0.033936251,
-0.0081671728,
0.0147379274,
-0.034137249,
-0.0273392238,
0.0216143876,
0.0035618364,
-0.0517786741,
0.0150687657,
0.0428761132,
-0.0905235708,
0.0514484644,
-0.0131775001,
-0.0407124534,
-0.0614971258,
0.0337684453,
0.0463982522,
-0.0234779902,
0.0357437469,
0.0510983765,
-0.075748533,
-0.0401830934,
0.0617508814,
-0.0611127988,
0.0040663439,
-0.0238101855,
0.0378636196,
0.0571338236,
0.0020993007,
0.0428757779,
-0.0419630446,
-0.0011311295,
-0.0738203451,
-0.0242506638,
-0.041930411,
-6.571234561e-33,
0.0313600264,
-0.0079600178,
-0.0535443351,
0.0466417819,
-0.0345047712,
0.0083571021,
0.0278667174,
0.0202176012,
0.0299201999,
0.0447339602,
-0.0250223242,
0.0456944779,
0.0129511226,
0.0054988447,
0.0376587473,
-0.0414528027,
0.0198966302,
-0.0258965325,
-0.0038491841,
0.0555110238,
0.0563320182,
0.0157348514,
0.0504607894,
-0.1479543,
0.0487793796,
-0.0020230606,
-0.0244221278,
-0.0022411938,
0.0904637724,
0.0340864435,
0.0034156374,
0.0790027678,
0.0338183977,
0.0217343476,
0.0366285183,
0.0588843562,
0.0108880438,
-0.0076932986,
-0.0053469772,
0.0324805751,
-0.0269577838,
0.0002584897,
-0.0052096029,
0.0158364028,
-0.0486501977,
0.0307089444,
0.0301514491,
-0.007625585,
0.0596484281,
-0.0628644973,
-0.0246189442,
0.0270181894,
-0.0633815303,
-0.0429227278,
0.0283158533,
0.0789078847,
0.0123649193,
0.0061858529,
-0.0437238701,
0.0246663131,
-0.0387131199,
-0.0439169109,
-0.004000653,
-0.0640328825,
-0.0193119291,
0.0642198846,
0.0066291075,
0.0479685739,
0.0302763637,
0.0630367249,
-0.0263003949,
0.0605022311,
0.0024515982,
0.0095636742,
-0.0309831463,
-0.0400363877,
-0.0017904027,
0.0502951071,
0.0788887441,
0.0203608386,
0.024327876,
0.0038511881,
-0.0152127938,
-0.0083315326,
0.0437776744,
-0.0241658129,
-0.0051096235,
0.0058046822,
-0.0147264162,
-0.0165968388,
0.0158456769,
-0.0081766611,
0.0182320569,
-0.0140002407,
-0.0411362424,
0.0203038938,
-0.0325873271,
0.0721015483,
0.0159700718,
0.008220572,
-0.0177810881,
-0.0032260232,
-0.0283552576,
0.0423228107,
0.0470693298,
-0.0153253954,
-0.0061893435,
0.0353081264,
-0.0402548946,
-0.015734667,
0.0090322038,
0.0366899483,
-0.0667686835,
-0.0325708687,
0.0036084747,
0.0340217836,
-0.0046880385,
0.0341834128,
0.0147187123,
0.07466764,
0.0106975054,
-0.0206559077,
-0.0067488803,
0.0052128499,
-0.0226542614,
-0.0169919841,
0.0406826921,
-0.0269888025,
-0.0117443092,
-0.0194290634,
0.0052249064,
-0.0124029657,
2.861e-7,
-0.0036260867,
0.0901672021,
0.0071008787,
-0.0143850762,
0.0474109389,
0.0523171723,
0.02995307,
0.0023583905,
0.0430428423,
-0.0604583733,
0.0389648788,
-0.0598831624,
0.0380773246,
0.0167461168,
-0.0817651302,
-0.0315909758,
-0.036772456,
-0.0071629239,
-0.0462782681,
0.0425528549,
0.0857492685,
0.0766345486,
0.0401378162,
0.0038784018,
-0.0112503534,
0.0452904403,
0.0234425664,
-0.0352246165,
-0.0237182956,
0.0289322697,
0.0195671432,
-0.009193304,
-0.0126595432,
-0.0013311723,
-0.0231667943,
0.0221837666,
0.0229331255,
0.0104816128,
0.0408107787,
-0.034614969,
0.0427363589,
0.0172798168,
0.0088432329,
-0.0124399886,
0.0145245986,
-0.0855800807,
-0.0621164478,
-0.0544246659,
0.0006737378,
-0.0083349915,
0.0494729988,
-0.0024969715,
-0.0778588429,
0.040864449,
0.001972365,
-0.0075063892,
-0.0162599497,
-0.0873876289,
0.0371515453,
0.0323714241,
-0.0421083607,
-0.003690934,
0.0107811494,
0.035824541,
0.0290860422,
0.0093036378,
0.030825479,
1.61993212e-34,
0.0446664318,
-0.0116951549,
-0.0061823828,
0.0489097461,
0.0330362096,
0.0260331687,
-0.0044438699,
0.0025317047,
0.0383100994,
-0.0310904197,
0.0324175432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06517v1 | Toward Semantic Publishing in Non-Invasive Brain Stimulation: A Comprehensive Analysis of rTMS Studies | 2023-10-10T11:00:23 | 2023-10-10T11:00:23 | Swathi Anil, Jennifer D'Souza | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | Noninvasive brain stimulation (NIBS) encompasses transcranial stimulation
techniques that can influence brain excitability. These techniques have the
potential to treat conditions like depression, anxiety, and chronic pain, and
to provide insights into brain function. However, a lack of standardized
reporting practices limits its reproducibility and full clinical potential.
This paper aims to foster interinterdisciplinarity toward adopting Computer
Science Semantic reporting methods for the standardized documentation of
Neuroscience NIBS studies making them explicitly Findable, Accessible,
Interoperable, and Reusable (FAIR).
In a large-scale systematic review of 600 repetitive transcranial magnetic
stimulation (rTMS), a subarea of NIBS, dosages, we describe key properties that
allow for structured descriptions and comparisons of the studies. This paper
showcases the semantic publishing of NIBS in the ecosphere of
knowledge-graph-based next-generation scholarly digital libraries.
Specifically, the FAIR Semantic Web resource(s)-based publishing paradigm is
implemented for the 600 reviewed rTMS studies in the Open Research Knowledge
Graph. | [
0.0517110564,
0.0368584581,
0.0004961194,
-0.0170811433,
0.0073456243,
0.0140968636,
0.0552548394,
0.0697385222,
-0.0038200943,
-0.0213251431,
-0.0176139697,
0.0384052619,
0.0241633859,
0.0416519381,
0.0160015952,
0.0011901545,
0.0223206803,
0.0806929171,
0.0131847458,
-0.0139709776,
0.0048865038,
0.0122027444,
-0.0252440199,
0.0092351101,
-0.0008888656,
-0.0244231652,
0.0244709551,
0.0027431366,
-0.0063157398,
-0.0720231757,
-0.034748368,
0.0763537735,
0.0169672742,
0.0405838378,
0.0000021865,
-0.0316712521,
-0.0155202476,
0.0801651999,
0.0300040357,
-0.0038411336,
0.0561876148,
-0.0227481313,
0.0457465574,
-0.0003906537,
0.00080903,
-0.0381181054,
0.0734315515,
0.008290221,
-0.0207332373,
-0.0134639479,
-0.0053783222,
0.0194581859,
0.024659289,
0.0001820457,
0.0627492219,
0.0673750043,
0.0182060041,
0.0195825677,
0.0336946771,
0.0032707613,
-0.0079998719,
0.0435259379,
-0.0372904316,
-0.0008332424,
0.0338533111,
0.0350919515,
-0.0101599079,
-0.0280298386,
0.0145585062,
-0.0006718496,
0.1250061095,
0.002749803,
0.0624988899,
0.0284287483,
-0.0561557263,
0.0371318124,
-0.0820548758,
0.0172966775,
-0.0023160141,
-0.0267541967,
-0.0481764525,
-0.0277974624,
0.0325018801,
0.0070466716,
0.0152324047,
0.037188489,
-0.0189534631,
0.0239658337,
0.0137468753,
-0.0183188245,
0.0581296086,
-0.0533223748,
-0.0082400944,
-0.0005749353,
-0.0147900153,
-0.0071918466,
0.0154642295,
-0.0375124328,
0.0667228252,
0.0134286061,
0.0000327262,
0.0092996005,
0.0335847139,
0.012175981,
0.0581340827,
-0.0025697916,
-0.061712455,
0.0716511756,
0.042110987,
0.0201476291,
-0.0882681012,
-0.004424748,
0.0220119022,
0.0168919675,
-0.0106587643,
-0.0267951153,
-0.038429074,
0.0258263592,
-0.023439873,
0.0057367613,
-0.0042095315,
0.0273083523,
-0.045888979,
0.0102565149,
-0.0198357347,
0.0091895396,
0.0422138013,
0.0037519422,
0.0116696227,
0.0301286895,
-0.0007612136,
-0.0143003967,
0.0257175192,
0.0203950685,
0.0078122835,
0.0644589216,
0.0556790009,
0.0116431145,
0.0118123544,
-0.0570249148,
0.0179666821,
0.0066585997,
0.0363326482,
-0.0624600016,
0.0357264988,
0.0382083207,
0.0016117905,
-0.0540506504,
-0.01275656,
0.0060696593,
-0.0537492,
0.0321354344,
-0.1256407648,
-0.020789966,
0.0362685807,
0.0264155883,
0.0087103676,
0.0062160185,
0.0194941387,
-0.0054122824,
0.0461060144,
0.0491257533,
-0.0398317315,
-0.0683809072,
0.0309585407,
-0.0260952562,
-0.0086784624,
0.0210836977,
0.0061371736,
0.072036773,
-0.071066536,
0.0621180758,
-0.0525558405,
0.0353114158,
0.0248172283,
0.043761652,
0.0033826916,
0.0308274049,
-0.0185122937,
-0.0406397842,
-0.0114094233,
-0.0591104254,
-0.0351258069,
0.0672457218,
0.0086023705,
-0.0021031683,
0.0206848867,
-0.0200688839,
-0.0006921482,
-0.022445403,
-0.0276752133,
-0.0381796658,
-0.0129659595,
0.0152574116,
0.0167683531,
-0.0237877108,
0.0296221264,
0.0326138325,
0.0291906111,
0.022487618,
0.0272621401,
0.0060385,
-0.0114031695,
0.0410363749,
0.0461380407,
-0.0277028922,
-0.0105805472,
-0.0456453152,
0.0249612946,
0.0993282869,
-0.0449846089,
0.0035774186,
-0.022365693,
0.0034432833,
-0.0366125703,
-0.0337055139,
-0.0146733848,
-0.0044531333,
-0.0309441369,
0.0520078503,
-0.0490310453,
-0.0860035941,
-0.0216435976,
0.0226697698,
-0.0105066579,
0.0353712887,
-0.0262926053,
-0.0498376414,
0.011195383,
0.0317056626,
-0.0002375115,
0.0171696525,
0.0098629929,
-0.0360024609,
-0.0634992421,
-0.0539736785,
0.0444494151,
0.0794245973,
0.0034490055,
-0.0445282869,
0.0396929644,
0.0051790117,
-0.039641045,
-0.0062218113,
-0.0031284876,
0.0075873947,
0.0657846779,
0.0038614324,
-0.0339284725,
-0.0270438753,
-0.0238051582,
-0.0108233383,
-0.0164892618,
-0.0001883895,
-0.0077076545,
0.0336988792,
-0.1362929791,
0.0431630798,
0.0180797596,
-0.0470609367,
0.0566445589,
-0.0385967456,
0.0163720232,
-0.0156503022,
-0.0425247326,
-0.0122493636,
0.0481986776,
-0.0151157444,
0.0078213708,
0.0398628525,
0.027956238,
0.0046943934,
0.001658246,
0.0104227485,
0.0157004222,
0.0140399095,
-0.0049161157,
0.0228144415,
0.0284606833,
0.0396853574,
0.0632922351,
0.0375896767,
-0.0207909029,
-0.0366271213,
-0.025403874,
0.0412514731,
0.0086269509,
-0.0041589751,
-0.0169590488,
0.0164705664,
-0.0700864345,
0.0071511269,
0.0184649359,
0.0363198668,
0.0200576801,
0.038865421,
-0.0521476902,
0.0200095661,
-0.0128947021,
-0.0039622704,
0.0640084818,
0.0020423429,
-0.0255569853,
-0.0409545004,
-0.0186698623,
-0.008976615,
0.0106714545,
-0.0011809114,
0.0408341698,
-0.004966564,
0.0320358016,
0.0082594054,
0.0072991159,
-0.0150648188,
-0.0335769951,
0.025303958,
-0.0413306579,
-0.0255383272,
0.005403921,
0.0598960407,
-0.0061868727,
-0.0242843702,
0.0579072312,
-0.0078555709,
0.0408018753,
-0.0521372482,
0.013683253,
-0.0281110499,
0.0202266648,
-0.0277959276,
0.0157109518,
0.0320072137,
-0.0033907471,
-0.0073121558,
-0.026337957,
0.0417000391,
0.0247586872,
-0.0377736688,
0.0263968855,
-0.0049092923,
-0.0038726905,
0.009839288,
-0.0065891352,
0.0139089022,
0.0160496309,
0.0052005439,
0.0592465624,
0.0018929573,
-0.000411122,
-0.0055574775,
0.0744540095,
0.0247982461,
-0.01336399,
-0.0375265107,
-0.0161110349,
-0.0325772576,
-0.0257322155,
-0.0419272855,
-0.0035828289,
0.0401455536,
-0.0882427469,
0.0643636137,
-0.0454890132,
-0.0022885271,
-0.0300384946,
-0.0278014913,
-0.0153108845,
-0.0849446207,
-0.0173346754,
0.000517918,
-0.0575297773,
-0.0064313542,
0.023335252,
0.0634706765,
0.0386462733,
-0.0608556569,
-0.0390388928,
-0.0248644035,
-0.0348610468,
-0.0147589808,
-0.0036424564,
-0.0634268671,
0.0526429452,
-0.0508228056,
0.0536189042,
-0.0070445142,
0.0089653851,
0.0070346962,
0.0648753494,
0.0006059702,
-0.0698692799,
-0.0812044367,
0.008635574,
-0.0487296581,
0.0220345613,
0.0121333329,
-0.0276938677,
0.0069066938,
-0.0287674684,
-0.0043972195,
0.0133606158,
-0.0178982094,
-0.048197262,
-0.0043496131,
-0.0484221391,
0.0560727827,
0.0081269117,
0.0333668329,
-0.0237738956,
-0.0109193362,
-0.0476194955,
0.0354022048,
-0.0500209704,
-0.0373126641,
0.037421193,
0.0018455804,
0.0458496809,
-0.067484051,
0.0220474526,
-0.0124027412,
0.0082094409,
-0.0468768403,
0.051535327,
-0.0394590124,
0.0254882891,
-0.0351936258,
0.00807619,
0.0178563725,
0.0144382585,
0.0056817015,
0.0286700372,
0.0341502205,
0.0162903573,
0.0339259543,
0.0451999865,
0.0045273118,
0.0186808389,
-0.0858026445,
-0.0529286899,
-0.0557194985,
-0.0113564907,
-0.0172761399,
-0.0155892158,
0.0200434737,
0.036781434,
0.1228150278,
-0.0482984148,
-0.061296355,
0.0063780663,
0.0134812808,
-0.0232358128,
0.0243567508,
-0.0120910611,
0.0066732201,
0.0198796112,
-0.0303128697,
-0.0148596587,
0.0703633651,
0.0037411728,
-0.0081022792,
-0.0077322251,
0.0182597246,
-0.0253061745,
-0.014820151,
-0.0325845107,
0.0423719026,
0.0638819933,
-0.0297542792,
-0.0134938248,
-0.0176378768,
0.0302615389,
-0.0157679133,
-0.03684384,
-0.0478130616,
0.0117109967,
-0.0193784144,
-0.0075626513,
0.0197254475,
0.0347136557,
0.0252460074,
0.0304322261,
0.0292027015,
-0.0453703329,
0.0579898767,
-0.0082082571,
-0.0175029039,
-0.0349198803,
0.0352856852,
-0.006627549,
-0.0213789977,
-0.0185598396,
0.001915445,
0.0073118131,
0.0640348494,
-0.0305491276,
-0.0098225232,
-0.0356576256,
0.0486765616,
-0.0524640083,
-0.0024188096,
-0.0134501765,
0.0041875672,
-0.0423991457,
-0.01353662,
-0.0522814058,
0.0020591971,
-0.0511716418,
0.0082796253,
0.0497847572,
-0.0101195965,
-0.012650921,
0.0359362327,
-0.0367862023,
-0.043761082,
0.0369355753,
-0.0077075921,
0.0098786084,
0.101131618,
0.0477778129,
-0.0304561444,
-0.0170799885,
-0.0010004635,
0.0051253359,
-0.0151247932,
0.0372842737,
0.0096619278,
0.0083214929,
0.0091796247,
-0.0546605289,
0.0477695204,
-0.0246171448,
-0.0272584967,
-0.0125084724,
-0.0802492574,
0.0138264569,
-0.0220461935,
0.0357387401,
0.0301097166,
-0.0263776127,
-0.068627879,
-0.0264962912,
-0.0242953897,
0.0461848155,
0.0257782005,
-0.0394306295,
-0.0412951671,
0.0240711197,
0.0027495027,
0.0424512997,
-0.0510107577,
0.0153157199,
-0.0115288487,
-0.038394548,
-0.0981383994,
-0.0169798825,
-6.070240338e-33,
0.0359589607,
-0.0182671547,
0.0038332813,
0.0141971968,
-0.035760764,
0.0243705176,
-0.0422172286,
0.0130494274,
0.0367904343,
0.0295529366,
-0.036757946,
0.004039526,
-0.0047173374,
0.0416054279,
0.0390215442,
0.0088280579,
-0.0177910142,
-0.0111003285,
0.002647836,
0.0252491124,
0.0238392614,
-0.0287750345,
0.0426367298,
-0.091139771,
0.036142379,
-0.0142502459,
0.0039424812,
-0.0072942278,
0.0135326125,
0.0514698699,
-0.0172474254,
0.056496378,
0.0320634171,
-0.0176407844,
0.0139299082,
-0.0482179001,
-0.0665474907,
-0.0013772293,
0.0089639314,
-0.0893030539,
-0.05757723,
0.0360480547,
0.0549615175,
-0.0244929213,
0.0259824414,
0.0187101886,
0.0423064567,
-0.0087637138,
-0.0277724005,
-0.0755549967,
0.0080907773,
-0.000199591,
0.0037682222,
0.0506949425,
-0.0155798187,
-0.0535993576,
-0.021250993,
0.0305531453,
-0.0716430694,
0.0115353791,
-0.0212700181,
0.0236391462,
0.0110976538,
-0.0568895303,
0.0224787332,
-0.0015433215,
-0.0450069346,
0.0314346962,
0.0283989795,
0.0436816029,
0.0007972002,
0.0406798422,
0.0293096416,
0.0628406703,
-0.0224184133,
-0.0076746191,
-0.0546306521,
0.0006788874,
-0.0520319194,
0.0383930318,
0.0235940833,
-0.0132928584,
-0.0112770572,
-0.0390165821,
0.021211436,
0.0040846472,
-0.0377361365,
-0.03163369,
0.0110942805,
-0.0400408059,
-0.0107874917,
0.0161537807,
0.0084511796,
-0.0073103174,
0.0216273628,
-0.0077881846,
0.053329818,
0.0309260134,
0.0118493335,
-0.048009064,
-0.0305771809,
0.003655877,
0.0149820065,
-0.0023390891,
0.0351157673,
-0.0228041839,
-0.0067295167,
-0.0084134527,
-0.0117968144,
0.0356503949,
0.0119857378,
-0.0234756581,
-0.017369533,
-0.054055687,
-0.0341918543,
-0.0048421933,
0.0443114303,
0.0021794077,
0.0315290466,
0.0255756676,
-0.0290524177,
-0.03570522,
-0.0221777782,
0.0367406718,
0.0431702994,
0.0343930013,
-0.0129765943,
0.027604904,
0.0243514478,
-0.0124372337,
-0.0127609288,
-0.036630325,
3.051e-7,
0.0529633425,
0.0338901468,
-0.0161005184,
0.058884237,
0.060930308,
-0.0377264321,
0.039690502,
0.0194041133,
-0.0053450018,
-0.0506400652,
0.0085331183,
0.0159067735,
-0.0111584393,
0.0209032614,
-0.0194914714,
-0.1147129536,
-0.0134288371,
-0.0652519688,
-0.013568664,
-0.0599320009,
0.0227070563,
-0.1275933087,
0.0214896165,
-0.0038578073,
-0.0245605931,
0.0105765248,
0.0177118927,
-0.0115915993,
0.0586292893,
0.0270282235,
0.0297389925,
-0.0009233836,
0.0262964945,
0.0083187092,
-0.0009304597,
-0.0801718011,
-0.0474613868,
-0.0073657767,
-0.0483283326,
-0.004651668,
0.0382866189,
-0.0504025556,
0.0034244317,
-0.0364961512,
0.0080687022,
-0.0513311625,
-0.033297386,
0.0643514395,
-0.0167911649,
-0.0370428376,
0.089665249,
-0.0421522595,
-0.024713492,
-0.0175582636,
-0.0310372934,
0.0287144724,
0.0003165195,
0.015045966,
0.0677240416,
0.0268480685,
-0.0044601876,
-0.0494265296,
0.0151369125,
-0.0586417131,
-0.0047942526,
-0.0515969992,
0.005221766,
2.654200123e-34,
0.0084736692,
-0.0064999335,
-0.0032119998,
-0.0494250357,
-0.0009780813,
0.0318535641,
-0.0172597487,
-0.0507923253,
-0.0147580653,
-0.0474952757,
-0.0077864313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06505v1 | Evaluation of ChatGPT Feedback on ELL Writers' Coherence and Cohesion | 2023-10-10T10:25:56 | 2023-10-10T10:25:56 | Su-Youn Yoon, Eva Miszoglad, Lisa R. Pierce | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Since its launch in November 2022, ChatGPT has had a transformative effect on
education where students are using it to help with homework assignments and
teachers are actively employing it in their teaching practices. This includes
using ChatGPT as a tool for writing teachers to grade and generate feedback on
students' essays. In this study, we evaluated the quality of the feedback
generated by ChatGPT regarding the coherence and cohesion of the essays written
by English Language Learners (ELLs) students. We selected 50 argumentative
essays and generated feedback on coherence and cohesion using the ELLIPSE
rubric. During the feedback evaluation, we used a two-step approach: first,
each sentence in the feedback was classified into subtypes based on its
function (e.g., positive reinforcement, problem statement). Next, we evaluated
its accuracy and usability according to these types. Both the analysis of
feedback types and the evaluation of accuracy and usability revealed that most
feedback sentences were highly abstract and generic, failing to provide
concrete suggestions for improvement. The accuracy in detecting major problems,
such as repetitive ideas and the inaccurate use of cohesive devices, depended
on superficial linguistic features and was often incorrect. In conclusion,
ChatGPT, without specific training for the feedback generation task, does not
offer effective feedback on ELL students' coherence and cohesion. | [
0.0219777245,
-0.0508877672,
0.0017297636,
-0.0275972765,
-0.055674661,
-0.0172026306,
0.0038133003,
-0.0472365618,
0.0354962684,
-0.0605272688,
0.0197027642,
-0.0048595448,
0.0149497092,
-0.0091882972,
0.0048478092,
-0.0517238937,
0.0042305575,
0.0231953431,
0.0311137717,
0.0221207086,
0.0306430999,
0.0137126772,
-0.0319436342,
0.0337126814,
-0.0165372901,
-0.0621420927,
-0.048143398,
0.0124267349,
0.0135106938,
-0.0090774959,
0.0483615249,
0.0766834244,
-0.0536562055,
0.0028873365,
0.0000023332,
-0.0573561862,
-0.0028111213,
-0.0342776254,
0.0138864825,
0.0472452417,
0.0499145016,
0.0658263788,
-0.0239637084,
0.0070959223,
-0.0087531805,
0.0654431805,
0.0420797803,
0.0679573044,
0.0662079453,
0.0406179726,
0.0063372422,
-0.0235218722,
0.0574822612,
0.053713087,
0.0292459168,
0.0436476208,
-0.0397459008,
0.0373370312,
0.0385290682,
0.0092501957,
-0.0251849927,
0.0192925297,
0.0166659001,
-0.0769245774,
-0.0078491727,
0.0046075336,
-0.0653277785,
-0.0236146376,
0.0319458991,
-0.0035378712,
0.0485130735,
-0.025196908,
-0.0207586922,
-0.0094170086,
0.0326955691,
-0.0024030474,
-0.0466103815,
0.0142512191,
-0.0372824147,
0.0250612367,
0.0565853752,
-0.0362435542,
-0.0463979207,
0.0084732864,
0.0533068702,
-0.0273024719,
-0.010756406,
-0.05437335,
-0.0254736226,
0.0330687314,
-0.0042646029,
-0.0413329937,
0.0010289764,
0.0529575348,
-0.0341358483,
-0.0198010243,
-0.0223685913,
-0.0351184979,
0.0197273791,
-0.0556526594,
0.0271302313,
0.024849508,
-0.006005988,
-0.0201903414,
0.0299198683,
0.0572918802,
0.0671617389,
0.0486896038,
-0.0241601672,
0.0271820165,
-0.0809738114,
-0.0293702912,
-0.0289151724,
0.0826856792,
0.0552722029,
-0.0173998047,
-0.0507687628,
-0.0301965158,
-0.0333292484,
0.0237099156,
-0.0290907566,
-0.004822968,
0.0074029802,
0.0204382651,
0.0083770277,
0.0385949165,
-0.0065526227,
-0.0314798914,
0.0077453009,
-0.0182770658,
0.0268485844,
0.0281645264,
-0.0211772863,
-0.0139846103,
-0.0268000942,
-0.0589053817,
-0.0336307809,
-0.0089194225,
-0.0216268394,
-0.0407639444,
-0.0106431162,
-0.050175935,
-0.0377560295,
-0.0682451129,
-0.0339632146,
-0.0118933087,
0.0011147182,
-0.0036881478,
-0.0077768369,
0.0168360379,
0.0346334875,
-0.0230724979,
-0.0302487686,
-0.00697518,
0.0320446342,
0.0033805033,
0.0208007824,
-0.0191378221,
0.0361721106,
0.0084590912,
0.0251829047,
-0.017348513,
0.0601753779,
-0.0349891447,
-0.0448051915,
-0.0332889259,
0.0710953772,
-0.0255604032,
-0.0394074917,
0.0323836729,
-0.0667067021,
0.0477851219,
0.0027939258,
0.09740863,
0.0541678444,
0.0307838321,
0.0516127534,
0.0270878915,
-0.0565934442,
0.0276805274,
0.0556461364,
0.0638694391,
-0.0013540399,
-0.0167040993,
0.0099779107,
0.0369663574,
0.0267491825,
-0.0013143527,
-0.003038195,
-0.0909248963,
-0.0584042743,
0.0419851504,
-0.0105326688,
0.0033287976,
-0.0057201111,
-0.0142792091,
-0.0244630687,
0.0029043162,
0.0211266056,
-0.0900755376,
0.0214495938,
-0.0061162477,
0.0811537132,
0.084153235,
0.0211771186,
-0.0032206089,
-0.0535736345,
-0.0342487432,
0.0644202605,
0.0472913943,
0.0260827132,
-0.0074514281,
-0.0362107605,
-0.0218340736,
-0.004485948,
-0.0377898403,
0.0029511987,
-0.0262831412,
-0.0401887409,
0.0318184569,
0.0075904462,
0.036918927,
-0.0807893053,
0.0425977148,
0.0329230987,
0.0133428676,
-0.0024879351,
-0.0044290246,
-0.005396998,
0.0647647753,
-0.0419014692,
0.0173198413,
-0.0114074964,
0.011289469,
-0.0226254743,
0.0101193525,
-0.0530400425,
-0.0136055071,
0.0353040807,
-0.0802409276,
-0.006743608,
-0.0098479809,
0.0050151641,
-0.0266923849,
0.0349853337,
-0.0050802263,
0.0242623743,
0.0001495081,
0.0432156809,
-0.0457743555,
-0.0598312244,
-0.0343031846,
-0.0442045145,
0.0569667555,
0.0265240464,
-0.0716898218,
0.0408602022,
0.0228866376,
-0.0106187016,
-0.0275381375,
0.0421285592,
0.0214892216,
0.0250551626,
0.0329963788,
0.049117513,
-0.070738554,
-0.0698668137,
-0.0793832615,
-0.0108528147,
-0.0131246634,
0.0293451417,
0.0253635291,
-0.0617801175,
-0.0001338544,
0.0210518539,
-0.0160028152,
-0.0477579385,
0.0124550844,
-0.042616386,
0.041827213,
-0.045848377,
0.0122720208,
-0.0287163127,
-0.0159066636,
-0.0271452591,
-0.010076113,
0.0766826645,
-0.028465163,
-0.0371736996,
0.0354406834,
0.0176380742,
-0.069309555,
0.0442768559,
-0.0731900334,
0.0637148768,
0.0361497663,
0.0845045373,
0.0389915407,
0.04582588,
0.0182848219,
0.0281436127,
-0.0523817837,
0.0038226277,
-0.0130771529,
-0.0011011967,
0.0041810675,
0.000769772,
-0.0266247094,
0.0065918891,
0.0154470401,
0.0166463759,
-0.0252163317,
-0.0427168049,
0.0134644518,
-0.056887053,
0.0559871532,
-0.0281122904,
-0.0557217374,
-0.0047258274,
-0.0312789008,
-0.0195890926,
-0.0052989786,
0.0378566571,
-0.0097252149,
-0.0118060512,
-0.0675689206,
0.0165902153,
-0.0225285627,
0.0203526709,
-0.0352381654,
0.0080121858,
0.0134870522,
-0.0103572905,
0.000706924,
-0.0366873145,
0.0727940649,
0.0006677457,
0.0339318216,
-0.0303015001,
-0.0278597903,
0.0000865329,
-0.0009934625,
-0.0238895975,
0.0136722811,
0.0106249377,
0.0186912324,
0.0104458313,
-0.0006455455,
-0.0029359304,
0.006449393,
0.0337663479,
-0.0230442937,
-0.0615305714,
-0.020701563,
0.0321755037,
-0.0268078875,
0.0085066929,
-0.0030541359,
0.0061758761,
-0.0296419002,
0.0639123991,
0.0655690059,
-0.0245973282,
0.0005999002,
-0.0078841699,
-0.0190402847,
-0.0110615501,
-0.0482238829,
-0.0370248035,
-0.0296497252,
0.065092355,
-0.0676584244,
-0.0129816653,
0.0926187858,
0.0062158373,
0.015219395,
-0.0235779826,
-0.0476058163,
0.0003526385,
-0.0111591313,
0.0300918352,
-0.0267102532,
0.0066410685,
-0.0087906076,
0.0007687049,
-0.0129954629,
0.0005019995,
0.0109515199,
-0.0432487838,
0.0336417221,
0.0098759755,
0.0247219075,
-0.0145886382,
0.0068234424,
-0.0437891297,
0.0248383079,
-0.0039243014,
0.0094596939,
-0.002981669,
0.0283467341,
0.0661843866,
-0.0767205879,
0.0133097451,
-0.0541489683,
-0.0195687767,
0.0197569318,
-0.0020401441,
0.0304847434,
-0.0259735137,
-0.0436981618,
0.0553967506,
0.0215727706,
-0.0314974114,
0.0038806186,
0.0085415309,
-0.021572493,
0.0289253574,
-0.0578048714,
0.0305367019,
0.0101312222,
-0.0556437597,
0.0691919401,
0.0422995389,
-0.0219978523,
-0.0299970787,
-0.0137397666,
0.0370544195,
-0.0133410143,
0.0432582833,
0.0319749936,
-0.0203378238,
-0.0319610015,
-0.0297660176,
-0.0031723131,
-0.0315223932,
-0.006098378,
0.0200613625,
-0.0258356277,
0.0814664289,
-0.0220233016,
-0.1045665592,
0.0300396476,
0.0205047838,
0.018080283,
0.0428362824,
-0.0141730607,
-0.0002345984,
0.0132369185,
-0.0140856402,
0.0709375739,
-0.0089711966,
-0.055600509,
-0.0006115228,
-0.0734479502,
-0.008633065,
-0.0112306885,
-0.0220845193,
-0.0181283392,
-0.0387074351,
0.0522656925,
0.0169962738,
0.0031101319,
-0.0297039002,
0.0276536196,
-0.0183976665,
-0.0156463329,
-0.0287119485,
0.010255808,
0.0160056017,
-0.004596706,
0.0201723203,
0.0266163219,
-0.0016161707,
0.0414642617,
-0.0025716557,
0.0205512606,
0.0166480765,
0.0381982028,
-0.0207622331,
0.0117714368,
0.0608286299,
0.0368625447,
-0.017988611,
-0.0158050545,
-0.0614492781,
-0.0025256635,
-0.0251829177,
-0.0509939417,
-0.0059345737,
0.0156566817,
-0.0431072935,
-0.0456096604,
0.0032611846,
0.0370833986,
-0.0890766159,
0.0496217534,
-0.0238290932,
0.0670790896,
-0.0398471542,
-0.0036987567,
-0.0032101234,
0.0089591332,
-0.033080183,
0.0066016568,
-0.0032688773,
0.0321143083,
0.0054660379,
0.0516909733,
0.0167633146,
-0.0021254586,
0.0630882829,
0.0207715668,
-0.006547288,
0.020870002,
-0.010632853,
0.0264643878,
-0.0027141932,
0.0060462495,
0.0752586871,
-0.0256714988,
0.0114753153,
-0.0338381194,
0.0779178739,
0.0050003217,
-0.0175522678,
0.0000200007,
-0.0005208171,
-0.013483,
-0.0698115081,
-0.0049802079,
-0.1020127162,
-0.0558822118,
0.0159986094,
0.0002673052,
-0.0225849953,
0.0117512839,
0.0329920873,
0.0028971341,
0.0327541195,
-0.0037041968,
-0.0281399805,
0.0233708601,
-0.0073884898,
0.0221916623,
0.0289573278,
-0.007173148,
0.0102696605,
0.047442086,
-0.0090918569,
-0.0001813324,
-0.0408677384,
-0.0021719646,
-0.020413043,
0.0146824326,
0.0113115842,
-6.018464587e-33,
-0.0003952949,
-0.0375907756,
0.0148867108,
0.1025241688,
-0.0385256074,
-0.0068449425,
-0.0322186947,
0.0653194487,
0.028950328,
0.0663851127,
-0.000803293,
0.0187531281,
-0.0096912524,
0.0468308702,
0.0468722284,
0.0114564169,
0.0326572992,
0.0724624842,
-0.0141969742,
-0.0172995552,
-0.0162245426,
-0.0189492796,
0.0999754071,
-0.0246619731,
0.0767495781,
-0.0575348251,
-0.0163145047,
-0.0346694253,
-0.0295162816,
0.0389478654,
0.0274512079,
0.0542857051,
0.0178156812,
-0.026483899,
0.0064136432,
0.0105209174,
0.0044098296,
-0.0885851085,
0.0188595373,
-0.0066971988,
-0.0484411679,
-0.049152758,
0.0103422841,
-0.0026096292,
-0.0231741779,
-0.0341433138,
0.0372243598,
0.0391275026,
0.0060027675,
0.0139121283,
-0.0808061138,
0.0330673046,
-0.0301950462,
-0.0325180478,
-0.0231612734,
0.0435674861,
-0.0137899341,
-0.0586218722,
-0.0451008379,
0.0302720107,
0.0276130121,
0.0475878753,
0.0091768168,
-0.032229837,
-0.0465339758,
0.0670001805,
-0.0322098136,
0.0238287933,
-0.048255641,
0.0541375428,
0.0142934136,
-0.0366177484,
0.0764880031,
0.0322769955,
0.0201982781,
-0.0153014278,
-0.009954283,
0.0068632648,
0.0219677109,
0.0484477207,
0.0217698105,
-0.0335855894,
-0.0358664356,
-0.048311606,
-0.0373734906,
-0.0130048851,
0.0093729915,
-0.0604012795,
0.0112052364,
-0.0531278141,
0.0020832524,
-0.030699091,
-0.0438925251,
0.0351652652,
-0.0261074528,
-0.0425324552,
-0.0471314453,
0.0295895841,
-0.0293492582,
-0.0091769444,
-0.0177561361,
0.0138059929,
-0.0234071072,
0.0606467836,
0.0177092198,
0.0110595822,
0.0415451452,
-0.014314157,
-0.0277480148,
-0.0236280132,
-0.0011123541,
0.0387213789,
-0.0030050497,
-0.0390594266,
-0.0032518338,
0.0356845334,
-0.012464215,
0.0740432218,
0.0034399524,
-0.0113377264,
-0.0221106634,
-0.0316512622,
0.0192959532,
-0.0369507,
0.0170321707,
0.0178103913,
-0.0200854298,
0.0154992929,
0.0138062406,
-0.0198921934,
0.0014686628,
-0.0274905656,
2.946e-7,
0.0237906892,
0.0400854424,
0.0150886215,
-0.0340622924,
-0.0279567689,
0.0179000925,
-0.020458553,
-0.0122201871,
0.0261506923,
0.0259999447,
-0.0220475961,
0.0062749968,
0.0443179272,
0.0546417087,
-0.049993068,
-0.0345383137,
-0.0523462035,
-0.0370899253,
-0.0304253642,
0.0633249134,
0.1250362396,
-0.0335352086,
0.0185003746,
-0.0194123127,
-0.024818873,
0.0179749057,
-0.0050643655,
-0.0113077806,
-0.0414180793,
0.0400920101,
0.0489811115,
-0.0609217063,
0.0581525937,
0.0274275746,
0.007270413,
-0.0690817833,
0.009114434,
0.0255424753,
0.0118021965,
0.0199287329,
0.0239806324,
0.0250111353,
0.0018670217,
-0.059334565,
0.0492460802,
-0.0373644009,
-0.0223646294,
0.003166141,
0.0175129529,
-0.0385475866,
0.0334833153,
-0.0058062398,
-0.0178985689,
0.0053369091,
0.0066383104,
-0.0331402607,
0.0294104256,
-0.0004050553,
-0.0482025668,
0.0309397224,
0.0262447521,
0.0098358653,
-0.0165270139,
-0.0057409396,
-0.0037445382,
-0.0589846261,
-0.0112107405,
2.422720719e-34,
0.0217115507,
-0.0312967524,
0.0638318732,
0.0019430084,
-0.0008916117,
0.0338182263,
0.0463454053,
0.0117037762,
-0.0006699959,
0.0300871246,
-0.0157608073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06504v1 | Revisit Input Perturbation Problems for LLMs: A Unified Robustness Evaluation Framework for Noisy Slot Filling Task | 2023-10-10T10:22:05 | 2023-10-10T10:22:05 | Guanting Dong, Jinxu Zhao, Tingfeng Hui, Daichi Guo, Wenlong Wan, Boqi Feng, Yueyan Qiu, Zhuoma Gongque, Keqing He, Zechen Wang, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | With the increasing capabilities of large language models (LLMs), these
high-performance models have achieved state-of-the-art results on a wide range
of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, the models' performance on
commonly-used benchmark datasets often fails to accurately reflect their
reliability and robustness when applied to real-world noisy data. To address
these challenges, we propose a unified robustness evaluation framework based on
the slot-filling task to systematically evaluate the dialogue understanding
capability of LLMs in diverse input perturbation scenarios. Specifically, we
construct a input perturbation evaluation dataset, Noise-LLM, which contains
five types of single perturbation and four types of mixed perturbation data.
Furthermore, we utilize a multi-level data augmentation method (character,
word, and sentence levels) to construct a candidate data pool, and carefully
design two ways of automatic task demonstration construction strategies
(instance-level and entity-level) with various prompt templates. Our aim is to
assess how well various robustness methods of LLMs perform in real-world noisy
scenarios. The experiments have demonstrated that the current open-source LLMs
generally achieve limited perturbation robustness performance. Based on these
experimental observations, we make some forward-looking suggestions to fuel the
research in this direction. | [
0.0544507988,
0.0670243204,
-0.0115023674,
0.0453845188,
-0.0220193956,
-0.0021299839,
-0.0058241375,
0.0013403387,
0.0215291064,
-0.0431241803,
-0.0404443704,
-0.0583856776,
0.0099922772,
0.0200937204,
0.0405465066,
-0.0408993959,
0.0717313737,
-0.0647737384,
-0.0252814963,
0.0203796271,
0.0000343312,
-0.03999855,
-0.033776883,
0.0485324748,
-0.0107027972,
-0.0119978776,
-0.0186547097,
0.037637677,
0.0000058104,
-0.0224374402,
-0.0063619651,
0.0844387487,
0.0179909989,
0.0427758843,
0.000001964,
-0.0408701599,
0.0255088229,
-0.0043425974,
-0.0973629132,
0.0160843208,
0.0166896824,
0.0038006911,
-0.0131108668,
-0.0116151087,
-0.0097814212,
-0.0270482879,
0.0402277932,
0.0447237566,
0.073639594,
0.0795604587,
0.0190568883,
0.0148723321,
0.0313255489,
-0.0234987251,
0.0148752956,
-0.0605809651,
0.0454818904,
-0.0068877037,
0.0367970392,
0.030617604,
-0.0149729205,
0.0166004375,
0.0155973276,
-0.0414535478,
0.0069869692,
0.0119292755,
-0.0451586135,
-0.0045142951,
-0.050209105,
0.1006943285,
0.0096785771,
0.0188719369,
-0.0432792604,
-0.0199644342,
0.0142781055,
0.0040819878,
-0.033878468,
-0.0272820443,
0.0251328852,
0.005427557,
0.0120188072,
-0.0026701691,
0.0277815834,
0.0133656645,
-0.0161735825,
0.0654057935,
0.000190246,
-0.0703382269,
0.0028595566,
-0.0248217359,
-0.0238988064,
-0.0558383912,
0.0005957612,
0.0263280533,
-0.084511973,
0.0429331213,
-0.0543547384,
-0.0454736948,
0.0253381785,
-0.05043035,
0.042303063,
0.0507888198,
-0.0396269225,
0.0585623495,
0.0207176059,
0.0580580421,
-0.023394566,
0.0169079006,
-0.0135883018,
0.0224301293,
-0.0305308476,
-0.0219760388,
-0.0196958892,
0.0290750023,
-0.043674428,
-0.0205510184,
-0.0201518759,
0.0382951386,
-0.0057833726,
0.021559421,
0.0169181749,
-0.0030678203,
-0.0263117515,
-0.0173055474,
-0.0352836587,
0.0162865557,
-0.0119439652,
0.0095791733,
0.0180729013,
-0.0661887452,
-0.0414943881,
0.0181838311,
-0.0099944035,
-0.0538300872,
-0.0188790672,
0.1003106385,
0.0225606747,
-0.0371922478,
-0.040291138,
0.0048384364,
-0.0244806651,
-0.0710902587,
-0.0549935922,
-0.0332776941,
0.0398008376,
-0.0030345598,
0.0060105012,
-0.0628942326,
0.0398994423,
0.0168222617,
-0.0322940946,
0.1081272662,
-0.0142592508,
0.009851262,
0.0155055616,
0.0072117178,
-0.0267809946,
0.0766480044,
0.0453641564,
-0.0304608401,
0.0387620628,
-0.0087771378,
0.0068726223,
0.0499708727,
-0.0136310495,
-0.0085387593,
-0.0083775986,
0.0216610357,
0.0128378635,
0.0291327201,
0.0018842155,
0.0663679838,
-0.048075553,
-0.0118057812,
0.0624665655,
0.0338890292,
-0.0051602167,
-0.0148689048,
0.0068732738,
0.0255620088,
0.0228073355,
0.02127482,
-0.0744466633,
-0.0154833263,
-0.0194222741,
-0.0034047135,
0.0314661115,
-0.0203788392,
-0.0114292149,
-0.0429974832,
-0.0248126779,
-0.0044579096,
0.0173422098,
-0.0134056238,
0.040437188,
-0.0075225676,
-0.0479320921,
0.058510378,
0.0276054889,
-0.0320706032,
-0.0012198096,
-0.0171435736,
-0.0312738307,
0.0722267479,
0.055998791,
-0.0633365363,
-0.0561474822,
-0.0498020276,
0.0157668814,
0.0588300154,
0.0467850305,
0.008895305,
0.0390931554,
-0.0412750505,
-0.0124519942,
0.0090860212,
0.0137725705,
0.0385831967,
0.031270586,
-0.0411120169,
0.0085692899,
-0.013544485,
-0.0162998866,
0.0401476286,
-0.0309784766,
-0.0446466394,
0.0219346434,
-0.0091262199,
0.0400650948,
0.0230681133,
-0.0232154932,
-0.0091869496,
0.019683376,
-0.0202273838,
0.0295703076,
0.0320152119,
-0.074260138,
-0.0426869728,
0.0481037572,
0.0343783163,
-0.0559462681,
0.0199729167,
-0.0284162685,
-0.0400208607,
-0.0068181376,
-0.0349097475,
-0.0158985872,
-0.0594754778,
0.0368266106,
0.0134600718,
0.0226491503,
-0.0332559012,
0.0543587841,
-0.0060538175,
0.0303274412,
0.0518955179,
0.0434368923,
0.0200830605,
-0.0740652829,
-0.055340305,
-0.0186885167,
-0.026409369,
-0.0077726487,
-0.0092486804,
-0.0174182914,
-0.0398479849,
-0.0262400806,
-0.0639502555,
-0.010193957,
-0.0241320077,
0.0159223489,
0.0037845739,
0.0118028335,
-0.0155650917,
-0.0175455604,
-0.0052896757,
-0.0371800959,
0.0165847279,
0.0028339305,
0.0363905467,
0.0291550215,
-0.0051851938,
-0.0409770012,
0.0181089919,
-0.0146318385,
0.0331901051,
-0.0290818997,
-0.0623883903,
-0.0529180989,
0.0235447492,
0.0247082412,
0.0451117158,
-0.0214451272,
-0.0195814762,
0.0185702536,
0.0257853977,
0.0569541566,
0.0498327613,
0.003521844,
0.0220414046,
0.0117789228,
-0.0240140911,
-0.0465568639,
0.0521694422,
0.0020545011,
0.009365621,
-0.0573906749,
0.0100632636,
-0.0049294801,
0.0607492551,
-0.0067748148,
0.0162976198,
-0.0337517932,
0.0090574734,
-0.0213247798,
-0.0598968007,
-0.0328115672,
-0.0334067233,
-0.0766094625,
0.0268520601,
-0.0503006093,
-0.0201997347,
0.0904712975,
-0.0495781973,
-0.0192890223,
-0.0070776637,
0.0104130218,
-0.0331329182,
0.0308492053,
0.0000219158,
-0.0182563327,
0.0124878269,
-0.0618852042,
-0.0262120869,
-0.0164897982,
0.0024056179,
-0.035152588,
0.0434033908,
-0.0519093536,
-0.0010536263,
-0.0040659388,
-0.0511338115,
-0.0768497065,
-0.0418511182,
-0.0051810401,
0.0076507055,
0.0129443677,
-0.0204955265,
-0.0158595219,
0.028826531,
0.0056883451,
0.0325727314,
-0.0145071875,
0.0204452202,
-0.0358276851,
0.0472173393,
0.0230801497,
0.0709113777,
-0.0039799879,
-0.0162504204,
0.0584109835,
0.0289707705,
-0.0117676025,
-0.015980795,
-0.0055970093,
0.032901708,
0.0128643634,
-0.0296042804,
0.000598393,
0.0182050224,
0.0768042654,
-0.0779458731,
-0.0068104779,
0.0965156481,
0.0404784381,
-0.007451673,
0.0028101774,
-0.007286611,
0.0157959573,
0.0356489122,
0.0272355042,
-0.0842354,
-0.0259344671,
0.0292493049,
0.0219271854,
-0.0081676533,
-0.041560933,
-0.0111609073,
-0.127455458,
0.0367679484,
-0.0050297575,
-0.0326061994,
-0.0220369343,
-0.0251597334,
0.0567694902,
0.0035121068,
0.0712436438,
0.0213976149,
0.0215961263,
-0.0284674987,
0.0390425399,
-0.0130923456,
-0.0791798756,
-0.0255411509,
-0.0244695004,
0.1079913378,
0.0316215418,
-0.0156564228,
-0.009624131,
0.0197326913,
0.0478450432,
0.0130531481,
0.006369377,
0.0058295457,
0.0370698981,
0.006711775,
-0.0226268824,
0.0097328182,
0.0139377601,
-0.0092483293,
-0.0343121924,
-0.006895985,
0.0498788431,
-0.0233813804,
0.0570647568,
-0.0110278074,
-0.0056939689,
0.0489821136,
0.083841823,
0.051716838,
-0.0339395776,
-0.0146172121,
-0.0294059236,
-0.0126593206,
-0.0615049973,
0.0005935289,
0.0130764237,
0.0239358433,
-0.0040122727,
-0.0283386689,
-0.0437112637,
0.0209151823,
0.0064941873,
0.0234427284,
0.0316576324,
0.0040783212,
-0.0058914251,
0.0200315677,
0.0192425754,
-0.0338012092,
0.0400240943,
-0.0599028952,
-0.0138636716,
0.0156583115,
-0.009670794,
-0.0106866695,
0.0258756224,
-0.0984596908,
-0.0824026614,
0.0137517108,
0.0288293101,
0.0227494668,
0.0589784347,
-0.0256911367,
-0.0523907021,
0.0031764288,
0.0201383494,
-0.0484428331,
0.0046503744,
0.0323288478,
0.0158654824,
-0.0088246027,
0.036588233,
-0.0191247743,
-0.0126645062,
0.0133453896,
0.06008856,
-0.0335826837,
-0.0701224878,
0.024167005,
0.0162498727,
0.0226688795,
0.0124685615,
-0.0121144643,
-0.0246633515,
0.056844037,
-0.0340740979,
-0.0255953986,
-0.0348401703,
-0.0036537626,
0.0168033987,
-0.0372614264,
0.0077754073,
-0.0486683585,
-0.0387906358,
0.0957270712,
-0.0257289633,
0.0161696523,
0.0111979768,
-0.0491656512,
0.0171992537,
0.018124707,
-0.0141974138,
0.0402640998,
0.0026275609,
0.0283216666,
0.002402754,
0.0589251444,
-0.0049513495,
-0.037501011,
0.0144927204,
0.0201303586,
-0.0614074022,
-0.0112800281,
-0.0124332663,
0.0554614551,
0.0093924431,
0.0034329959,
0.0123035479,
-0.0246742722,
0.0053164,
-0.0233165305,
0.0051480075,
0.0181571413,
0.0139613273,
0.0488931723,
0.0505356565,
-0.0018853026,
0.0361169465,
0.0832130387,
0.0142536042,
0.0308686867,
0.0020175104,
0.0364109054,
-0.0579405278,
-0.014870286,
0.0069076,
0.0655764341,
-0.0485085808,
0.0365566239,
-0.0469768085,
-0.0613741502,
-0.0100441603,
0.0110838814,
-0.0013660011,
-0.0076230695,
-0.0020431732,
0.0153492065,
-0.0095823519,
0.014733742,
-0.0180627983,
-0.0194611624,
0.0265160128,
-0.0119262617,
-0.0400340669,
-6.048593977e-33,
-0.046144899,
-0.0071615516,
-0.0140450792,
-0.0161356926,
-0.0218343399,
-0.0091669606,
-0.0204814523,
0.0303473864,
-0.0047301413,
-0.0133386878,
-0.0306134596,
-0.0038946697,
0.0234146323,
0.0141983246,
-0.0232726093,
-0.0396470316,
0.0406428538,
-0.0087970207,
-0.02161007,
-0.0206789635,
-0.0172969196,
0.0310190879,
0.0405252241,
-0.0705660209,
0.0722521171,
0.0092200125,
-0.0155239049,
0.032341212,
-0.0016206618,
0.059742827,
-0.0145447291,
0.0633553267,
0.0051835091,
-0.0635307357,
-0.0190536547,
0.030528672,
-0.0839588344,
-0.0336727835,
0.0505368412,
0.0379371978,
-0.0042714444,
-0.0220381338,
0.0193865765,
-0.0192160588,
0.0123069203,
0.0122393835,
-0.0105529279,
-0.0342347696,
-0.0158163067,
0.0125392191,
-0.0210499335,
0.0538067669,
-0.0333088301,
-0.0380698554,
0.0136838667,
0.0476255827,
-0.0070709493,
-0.0155214379,
-0.0540340357,
0.0034835925,
0.0539858341,
0.0277921613,
0.0210941732,
0.0236597527,
-0.0042163404,
0.0540409125,
0.0046045179,
0.0273636729,
0.0078091538,
-0.0354962312,
-0.0099646552,
0.0178557411,
0.0165577177,
0.0489519797,
0.0348722488,
0.0216801073,
-0.0256933011,
0.0056341253,
0.0281998646,
0.0451057591,
0.0375191197,
0.0162344705,
-0.0674674585,
-0.0269855279,
-0.0434701815,
-0.0062042167,
-0.0451259613,
-0.0422122926,
0.0470069684,
0.002725618,
-0.0211437717,
-0.0020784482,
0.0384243317,
-0.0476310439,
-0.0143064409,
0.0144016864,
0.0281669982,
-0.0005774096,
0.0079571251,
0.0170037523,
-0.0301848557,
-0.0401929542,
0.0479098186,
0.0177175496,
0.0218822602,
-0.0185805857,
0.0088735381,
0.0212818123,
-0.0553611666,
0.0037827482,
-0.0200998355,
0.0359696187,
-0.0075324248,
0.062557593,
0.0497955419,
-0.0158752799,
-0.0214142036,
0.050093133,
0.0207034033,
-0.010861977,
-0.0314108506,
0.0021330155,
-0.0004244608,
0.0284972154,
-0.014340492,
-0.0048788213,
0.0091651799,
-0.0110934088,
0.0120288329,
-0.0265350547,
0.0292719807,
0.0139155518,
2.76e-7,
0.0355549492,
0.0660578012,
0.0384912677,
0.0175644346,
0.0169109628,
0.0085844761,
-0.0563852601,
-0.0013243535,
0.0223001447,
-0.0424795933,
0.0035360996,
0.0147379488,
0.0551899746,
0.013331037,
-0.1025489196,
-0.0525648147,
-0.0534619875,
0.0133284358,
-0.0515611656,
0.0087470682,
0.0904315859,
0.1010938063,
-0.0189534631,
0.0051707355,
-0.0213017259,
-0.063061513,
0.0267835725,
-0.0529996231,
-0.0230657421,
0.0205680449,
0.0530132465,
0.0239192471,
0.0158686507,
0.0518830828,
-0.0111403149,
0.0311384052,
-0.0051340838,
0.0611929074,
0.0045467964,
-0.0509264879,
-0.0156300627,
-0.0083772102,
0.0062250001,
-0.0586415716,
0.0568875782,
-0.0540970415,
-0.0211242232,
-0.0303700007,
-0.0208937358,
-0.0352370888,
0.029651409,
-0.0218261555,
-0.017610481,
-0.0137240235,
0.0386882573,
0.0028021345,
-0.0287334695,
-0.0645122603,
-0.0664500222,
-0.037068367,
-0.0502257459,
-0.0428529382,
-0.0307415612,
-0.0587802902,
0.0022947306,
-0.0534133762,
-0.0061111329,
2.565001453e-34,
0.0530892834,
-0.006532589,
0.0324863084,
0.071579963,
0.0317070074,
-0.0049314825,
0.0160190314,
0.0042310366,
0.0028322174,
-0.0886942074,
-0.0172700807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06502v1 | The Limits of ChatGPT in Extracting Aspect-Category-Opinion-Sentiment Quadruples: A Comparative Analysis | 2023-10-10T10:19:58 | 2023-10-10T10:19:58 | Xiancai Xu, Jia-Dong Zhang, Rongchang Xiao, Lei Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, ChatGPT has attracted great attention from both industry and
academia due to its surprising abilities in natural language understanding and
generation. We are particularly curious about whether it can achieve promising
performance on one of the most complex tasks in aspect-based sentiment
analysis, i.e., extracting aspect-category-opinion-sentiment quadruples from
texts. To this end, in this paper we develop a specialized prompt template that
enables ChatGPT to effectively tackle this complex quadruple extraction task.
Further, we propose a selection method on few-shot examples to fully exploit
the in-context learning ability of ChatGPT and uplift its effectiveness on this
complex task. Finally, we provide a comparative evaluation on ChatGPT against
existing state-of-the-art quadruple extraction models based on four public
datasets and highlight some important findings regarding the capability
boundaries of ChatGPT in the quadruple extraction. | [
0.0352697223,
0.0596467443,
0.0068010269,
0.0401208512,
-0.0607590601,
0.0305651017,
0.018364327,
0.0146251628,
-0.0100285616,
-0.0501509719,
-0.040620558,
-0.0195856653,
-0.048038058,
0.0128536616,
-0.0253692847,
-0.0185018089,
0.0619712248,
0.0263220407,
0.0598908328,
0.0153108826,
0.0308058951,
0.0557083003,
-0.0255920216,
-0.0047979369,
-0.049935516,
-0.0259262845,
0.013050464,
-0.0065797772,
0.0128256725,
-0.0364410467,
0.0443986356,
0.0213712137,
-0.0058503626,
0.0008859477,
0.0000018954,
-0.0178291984,
-0.0532493331,
-0.0180195123,
0.0284039024,
-0.0005680689,
0.0883345455,
-0.0129478481,
0.0104649514,
-0.0117356004,
-0.0608841367,
-0.021835696,
-0.021602124,
0.0796754658,
0.0450825579,
0.0706390887,
-0.0347423479,
-0.0297788419,
-0.0328396223,
-0.0132916439,
-0.037485674,
-0.0454152972,
-0.0006019567,
-0.0044392534,
0.0005320064,
0.0753366202,
0.0264116526,
-0.0095423609,
-0.0040674563,
0.0339726098,
-0.0438628085,
0.0270154849,
-0.0332098715,
0.0194483362,
-0.0199044701,
0.0336290114,
0.0238670018,
0.0273620225,
0.0173337311,
-0.0100681689,
0.0153421992,
-0.0090892054,
-0.005727076,
-0.0168111306,
-0.0336578675,
0.0170397721,
0.0481617302,
0.0154563366,
-0.0350431465,
0.003187848,
-0.0209905785,
0.0377914384,
-0.0113501744,
-0.0372626372,
0.049851127,
0.0606970303,
-0.0084264772,
0.0060868259,
-0.0064855632,
-0.0177081246,
0.0008715042,
0.0228024423,
-0.0007278418,
0.0582571402,
0.01294991,
-0.0181591026,
-0.005778328,
0.0019218363,
-0.0402526744,
0.0458693393,
0.0105519835,
-0.017221272,
0.0178384837,
0.0187223293,
-0.0041823247,
0.0350013003,
-0.0943551213,
0.0112194438,
-0.0407968834,
0.0517145805,
-0.024250593,
0.0073634759,
-0.0443232358,
-0.0015133865,
0.0217948463,
-0.0087577729,
0.0466552526,
-0.0341440514,
0.0127111925,
0.0250637177,
0.0172053799,
0.0522727594,
-0.0464791358,
0.0231193472,
-0.0143002141,
-0.0384611674,
-0.0082995659,
0.0048586186,
0.0155820185,
-0.0432555713,
0.0128274094,
0.0298263337,
0.0025381781,
-0.0756023005,
0.0136670489,
-0.028292058,
-0.0438123681,
-0.0448255017,
-0.0320824645,
-0.0410818458,
0.0662639961,
-0.0271514338,
-0.0189952571,
0.0252316967,
0.0105320448,
0.0113529777,
-0.0284493472,
0.0187563635,
-0.040749386,
-0.0296829846,
-0.0425787307,
0.0052557755,
0.0085605839,
0.0361609161,
-0.0226000194,
0.0397656225,
0.0607593395,
0.0177683253,
0.026136769,
0.0196241215,
-0.0070452602,
0.0009158124,
0.0552927814,
-0.0219482463,
-0.0490208119,
-0.049649898,
0.0054945624,
0.0467209816,
-0.0157034658,
-0.0306117963,
0.0222104397,
-0.0145208146,
0.021351682,
0.0697889552,
0.0272505637,
0.0249665622,
-0.0131666008,
0.0301952772,
-0.0137709696,
0.00920201,
-0.0265831687,
0.0030972559,
0.0043440876,
0.0247871689,
-0.0094533712,
-0.0566416122,
0.0050651687,
0.0094373636,
0.0056200973,
-0.0126024373,
0.055036705,
-0.0123039614,
-0.0499739759,
-0.0241157133,
0.0837279037,
-0.0378795266,
-0.0330810919,
-0.0366893709,
0.0372471847,
0.0310827028,
0.0374184772,
-0.0250790082,
-0.0254727881,
-0.0069629024,
-0.0279740803,
0.0079155592,
0.0627794042,
-0.0175625458,
0.0008215861,
-0.0316151418,
0.018273389,
0.0015741682,
0.0154150585,
-0.0079661673,
0.0032263449,
0.0482710786,
-0.0268628001,
0.0217577722,
0.0379344709,
-0.0055891965,
0.0090994202,
-0.0394395366,
0.0175570436,
-0.0051766699,
0.0111017795,
0.0551198833,
-0.0200880468,
-0.0219545066,
0.0260898303,
-0.0357127413,
-0.0459381193,
0.0315496214,
-0.059644118,
-0.0816651806,
-0.0144491773,
0.0172594488,
-0.0118665071,
-0.0159671195,
-0.0410005674,
0.007752093,
-0.0232282896,
0.0108820572,
0.0204977114,
-0.0296680462,
-0.0262273941,
0.0481094643,
0.0328861512,
-0.0292692687,
0.0679517761,
0.0058685862,
-0.0270081107,
-0.0283749718,
-0.0461594984,
0.0035051233,
0.0205972269,
-0.0164027177,
0.0155296279,
0.0018690057,
0.0129376361,
0.0225450229,
0.0602744371,
-0.0308093596,
-0.0652691498,
-0.0935397148,
0.0184586756,
-0.0054015773,
0.0644182563,
0.0168808829,
-0.0057230117,
-0.0198895428,
0.0363365263,
-0.0510326736,
0.002031879,
-0.0322415866,
0.0159614868,
0.035402894,
0.0316758044,
0.0173599403,
-0.0247061197,
0.0087626996,
-0.0437253751,
0.0024741832,
-0.0033598444,
-0.0582405403,
-0.0094855046,
0.0482488535,
-0.0121815531,
-0.0168414377,
-0.0060490821,
-0.0142584415,
-0.0079138,
-0.0598242842,
-0.0193501972,
0.0094532231,
0.0118574398,
0.0731912926,
-0.0296752229,
-0.0270259082,
-0.0192807838,
0.0420227908,
-0.0925345495,
-0.0202701241,
0.0178930983,
0.00860913,
0.0389504433,
0.0469858348,
0.0251309332,
-0.0025061062,
-0.0460054316,
0.0208130088,
-0.0037258328,
0.030072052,
-0.0024458217,
0.0573131591,
0.0123213716,
0.0302107986,
0.0200035423,
0.0255888831,
0.0521010198,
0.0346280672,
-0.0082228547,
-0.0828483924,
0.0021919778,
-0.0509914123,
0.0782511011,
-0.0479633473,
0.0025215964,
0.0326119959,
-0.0017416984,
0.0051216758,
-0.0446179919,
0.0045048222,
0.0007500797,
0.0217698272,
-0.0063134553,
0.0121962382,
0.0035565814,
-0.0520475656,
0.0309433509,
-0.0536040515,
-0.0240353979,
0.0033614479,
-0.0291054845,
0.0099868784,
0.0262287892,
-0.0325087644,
-0.0200277288,
-0.0128637254,
-0.0280605964,
-0.0286309998,
0.0112678409,
0.0855728686,
0.0457261987,
-0.0259060096,
0.009347178,
-0.0124740778,
0.010909481,
0.0961637273,
-0.0181286335,
0.0482710525,
0.0260704234,
-0.0020340974,
0.0306412913,
-0.0042357603,
-0.0038703077,
-0.0436895974,
0.0854539052,
-0.0498147272,
-0.0300211459,
0.1087143347,
0.0420294814,
-0.0595786087,
0.0220673699,
0.0246722866,
-0.0131342886,
-0.006592805,
0.0169024393,
-0.0859301835,
-0.0453864746,
-0.0448991507,
0.014490244,
-0.0180016328,
-0.0184311103,
-0.0206668582,
-0.0833790228,
0.0374544747,
-0.0200923476,
-0.0280372687,
-0.0340086482,
-0.0072606918,
0.0237720571,
-0.0440750942,
-0.0109542664,
-0.0070941574,
0.0050166626,
0.0119002443,
-0.0029554234,
-0.0127190789,
-0.0088245235,
0.0943495259,
0.0264060553,
-0.0160475578,
0.0053219921,
0.0352615379,
0.0050510974,
-0.0112202028,
0.0282905251,
-0.0891335681,
0.00596917,
-0.030170802,
0.03451401,
-0.0377798788,
-0.0306197442,
-0.0162948407,
0.0135605596,
-0.0447877571,
0.0119755846,
0.0253920965,
0.0241838619,
0.010955045,
-0.0334300585,
-0.0076317503,
0.0482566506,
0.0134571372,
0.0672545508,
-0.015699923,
-0.0679009855,
-0.0022729654,
0.0028029655,
-0.025956206,
-0.063447848,
-0.0707042962,
-0.010059881,
0.0002355672,
-0.0198720433,
-0.0699274689,
-0.0543805771,
0.0017380262,
0.0539932512,
-0.0500176437,
-0.0189569071,
0.0212623719,
0.0382953025,
-0.0044106054,
-0.0206681341,
-0.0128884763,
-0.0263405163,
-0.0078530228,
-0.0123219937,
0.0884232521,
-0.0159251206,
-0.0276530795,
-0.0074501401,
-0.0563202202,
-0.0279069208,
-0.006686307,
0.0242618378,
0.007819565,
0.0276263971,
-0.0177450143,
0.0466776378,
-0.0011100508,
0.0940520912,
-0.0320167653,
0.0012756228,
0.0345623642,
0.076105386,
0.0101353563,
0.0359576792,
-0.0012630066,
0.0582799502,
0.0054279147,
0.0012472629,
-0.0713990629,
-0.0212989356,
0.0390536673,
0.007064234,
0.0458753295,
0.0281771794,
0.0148304822,
-0.0210465714,
-0.021391971,
-0.0212795176,
-0.0143354926,
-0.0528599136,
-0.0000808388,
-0.0326455757,
-0.0442384705,
-0.0739279911,
-0.0082176235,
-0.0046921945,
0.0513534397,
-0.0404942334,
0.0135300448,
-0.0005406445,
0.0059878821,
-0.0267432667,
-0.031179063,
-0.0251405071,
-0.0159357507,
-0.0113505805,
0.0059047546,
-0.0412728414,
0.0953480005,
0.0188030563,
-0.0055984189,
0.0093287956,
0.0455270521,
-0.0271248482,
0.0386063419,
-0.020733133,
0.0116157774,
0.0100515569,
-0.0312338304,
0.0499254838,
-0.0389505476,
-0.0269724242,
0.0017465022,
0.0394791998,
0.0090330336,
0.0157423168,
0.0273199212,
0.0150220254,
-0.0285169315,
-0.0333504938,
0.0468822829,
-0.121280998,
0.0257961117,
0.1009840146,
-0.0105483001,
-0.0548462607,
-0.0169475786,
0.014335609,
-0.0032952875,
0.0514624231,
0.0401265919,
-0.0853951946,
-0.0047360542,
-0.0013443335,
-0.0313843116,
0.0096588014,
0.0059425062,
0.0170663055,
0.0696360469,
0.0114274397,
0.0315342657,
-0.0732094571,
-0.0336186439,
-0.0128220776,
-0.0248018373,
0.0211843736,
-6.39610427e-33,
-0.0314353667,
0.0184826758,
-0.0172493197,
0.026990667,
-0.0232671443,
-0.003097855,
-0.0122794127,
0.0230003539,
-0.0017407578,
0.0314735323,
-0.0013828811,
-0.0275933277,
-0.0059896987,
0.0282760262,
0.0094271684,
0.0011327482,
-0.0016361679,
-0.0062862299,
-0.0002145075,
0.0522107221,
0.0659121796,
0.0345853642,
0.0894471407,
-0.0928551182,
0.0096597299,
-0.0002999234,
-0.048434522,
-0.0171276778,
0.011912114,
0.0485218726,
-0.0100525394,
0.0273921732,
0.0427874178,
-0.0502173863,
0.0250952244,
-0.0085350471,
-0.0372214951,
-0.0556855649,
-0.0128304334,
-0.0298956744,
-0.017073201,
-0.0363986492,
-0.0257779602,
-0.022976825,
0.0072337105,
-0.0380921848,
-0.0067818863,
-0.0230983254,
-0.0058376635,
-0.0842227116,
-0.0480450839,
0.0374331139,
-0.0054393802,
-0.023113437,
0.0095254034,
0.0425471477,
0.0218092669,
0.0278510973,
0.0051082945,
0.0101681286,
-0.0317075551,
0.0154463202,
-0.0425359942,
-0.0808009878,
-0.0014817619,
0.0710104704,
-0.0099411206,
0.008093698,
-0.0130925952,
0.0372556746,
-0.0040809833,
0.0410057046,
-0.0165153984,
0.0794778466,
0.0468398109,
-0.014984265,
-0.0400135703,
0.0063330466,
0.0849590302,
-0.0513650514,
0.0446329266,
-0.0213430114,
-0.0674397573,
0.0095794071,
0.0632757992,
-0.0225384459,
-0.0247228649,
-0.0399256274,
0.0324742422,
0.0150257954,
-0.0327231437,
0.0095318155,
0.0002779822,
-0.0161540247,
-0.0075859264,
0.0277187824,
-0.0800215602,
0.0209680311,
-0.0285015758,
-0.0052187969,
-0.0127262902,
-0.0351891555,
-0.012970346,
0.0522615463,
0.0182824656,
0.0096599143,
0.0768713951,
-0.0046281996,
-0.0963736027,
-0.02500128,
-0.021609392,
0.0666213408,
-0.0274222493,
0.0424089245,
0.0139523298,
-0.0011546329,
-0.0217261761,
0.0892057791,
0.0234672688,
0.0189483743,
-0.0040723807,
0.0340376534,
0.0032885815,
0.0043743174,
0.0176901873,
-0.0223831851,
0.0186959207,
-0.0459104963,
-0.0418782271,
-0.0268181339,
-0.0192863736,
0.0059719635,
2.663e-7,
0.0270664245,
0.0566782877,
-0.0194935352,
0.0105578098,
0.0300217737,
0.0529741645,
0.0123310443,
0.0335733816,
-0.0146525046,
0.0042824596,
0.0366708376,
0.0343600474,
0.0099939685,
0.0245898496,
-0.0663598999,
0.0377911888,
-0.0071367966,
-0.0304244608,
-0.0398479626,
0.0077341716,
0.1402543485,
0.0769893005,
0.0168268271,
-0.0100250002,
-0.0187696554,
0.0314639173,
0.0204523169,
-0.0066278344,
-0.0561409816,
0.036897786,
-0.0379150547,
0.0048229094,
-0.0229339581,
-0.016530253,
0.00772028,
0.0019505876,
0.0018790168,
0.0872498006,
0.0441711582,
-0.0633237585,
0.0632055327,
0.0320752338,
0.0210669264,
-0.0035606893,
0.0746450126,
-0.0529163182,
-0.0316596255,
-0.0966601744,
-0.027026752,
0.0216544624,
0.0068343524,
0.0019599916,
-0.0347515643,
0.0690209046,
-0.0181177873,
-0.0217706077,
-0.0403872766,
-0.0708456933,
0.028175585,
0.0281300191,
-0.0004294471,
-0.0314404443,
0.0331802964,
0.0250382274,
-0.0095407208,
-0.0724122748,
0.0096943611,
2.188649029e-34,
0.0357314236,
-0.0146954181,
0.0155542148,
0.0276768487,
0.0084952693,
0.0062311213,
-0.0064904992,
-0.0249753352,
0.0143231358,
0.0053845495,
0.0119550461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06498v2 | A New Benchmark and Reverse Validation Method for Passage-level Hallucination Detection | 2023-10-10T10:14:59 | 2023-10-24T01:37:10 | Shiping Yang, Renliang Sun, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown their ability to collaborate
effectively with humans in real-world scenarios. However, LLMs are apt to
generate hallucinations, i.e., makeup incorrect text and unverified
information, which can cause significant damage when deployed for
mission-critical tasks. In this paper, we propose a self-check approach based
on reverse validation to detect factual errors automatically in a zero-resource
fashion. To facilitate future studies and assess different methods, we
construct a hallucination detection benchmark named PHD, which is generated by
ChatGPT and annotated by human annotators. Contrasting previous studies of
zero-resource hallucination detection, our method and benchmark concentrate on
passage-level detection instead of sentence-level. We empirically evaluate our
method and existing zero-resource detection methods on two datasets. The
experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method considerably
outperforms the baselines while costing fewer tokens and less time.
Furthermore, we manually analyze some hallucination cases that LLM failed to
capture, revealing the shared limitation of zero-resource methods. | [
0.0251350943,
0.021739997,
0.0079336734,
0.0364439413,
-0.0461882725,
0.0231150594,
-0.0207838751,
0.0039259237,
0.0161016956,
-0.0464005433,
0.0204195939,
-0.0647467822,
0.0079218,
-0.0216143895,
0.0292638801,
-0.0090299696,
0.0614967942,
-0.0557961836,
0.0269148406,
0.0019716108,
0.004806953,
0.0001561971,
-0.0242156405,
0.0352273546,
-0.0370989442,
-0.0414279439,
-0.0089828661,
0.0150537146,
0.0089605972,
-0.0268186927,
0.0067492244,
0.0736495629,
-0.0261372365,
0.0993372947,
0.0000020574,
-0.0304061975,
-0.017825054,
0.005692706,
-0.0429688953,
0.036087323,
0.0575517826,
0.0185293406,
-0.0516648553,
0.0254364703,
-0.011213107,
0.0070194537,
0.0464337766,
0.0902980492,
0.0775666088,
0.0841401443,
-0.0116205858,
0.0244779177,
0.0210496057,
0.0322478339,
0.0270975158,
-0.0178269427,
0.0385515876,
0.0424001068,
-0.0166526958,
-0.0288168918,
0.0124472259,
0.0355600864,
-0.0021735125,
-0.0146997133,
-0.0360641778,
0.0241779555,
-0.1197734028,
-0.0199546516,
-0.0074472325,
0.0448065549,
-0.0475007929,
-0.0577112958,
0.0148212826,
-0.0001379983,
-0.0036908821,
-0.023527205,
0.0096115349,
0.0198181029,
-0.0388921425,
0.0137120383,
0.0083961319,
0.0114344331,
0.0392616801,
-0.0042516757,
-0.0252616629,
0.0776960105,
0.0061791684,
-0.0517955981,
-0.0032215181,
0.010092807,
-0.0086178649,
-0.0582252294,
0.001013349,
-0.0081881015,
-0.0559515134,
-0.0137071004,
-0.0685838833,
-0.0145922061,
0.0518218912,
-0.0948348641,
-0.0050279172,
-0.0041445661,
-0.066680178,
0.0597947091,
-0.0285037179,
0.056600675,
0.0048439824,
0.0364114344,
0.0107645309,
-0.0038572727,
-0.0159393214,
-0.007003508,
-0.053827662,
0.0035103527,
0.0023929442,
-0.032643985,
-0.0158313494,
-0.007767803,
-0.0236557182,
0.04455553,
-0.0347081572,
-0.0080912653,
-0.0141640976,
-0.0224355366,
0.0216371082,
0.0062828478,
0.0151746618,
-0.0318755507,
0.0019002397,
-0.1085410714,
-0.008382936,
0.0440851189,
-0.0253967065,
0.0187725574,
-0.0120747406,
0.0325656459,
0.0214038901,
-0.0055627795,
-0.0497158207,
-0.0436373092,
-0.0221994147,
-0.0661702678,
-0.0161576588,
-0.0660204366,
-0.0224694721,
-0.001969134,
0.0025756219,
0.003931148,
0.0330603458,
0.0180089381,
-0.0139388386,
0.0834960043,
-0.0435459055,
0.0016954388,
0.019073071,
0.025441397,
0.002276897,
0.1006156653,
0.0304655358,
0.0234556552,
0.0578853451,
0.0062938831,
0.0691775754,
0.0434492901,
-0.0370168127,
0.0267381147,
-0.0187783893,
-0.0306199212,
0.020238122,
0.0206548534,
0.0048204549,
0.0725313649,
-0.0106292143,
-0.0310474839,
0.0458356403,
0.0380756855,
-0.0111769876,
-0.0044259331,
0.0141566712,
0.0537524372,
0.0062227012,
0.0293562207,
-0.0480022132,
-0.0093027381,
-0.0387367904,
-0.0219544321,
0.0743536577,
-0.0095078927,
-0.0177118462,
-0.0286772773,
-0.0492815971,
-0.0092555424,
-0.0035381452,
-0.0328423418,
0.0238413122,
-0.0026129864,
-0.0714722276,
0.0612177253,
0.0326081775,
-0.0481464863,
-0.0206429623,
-0.0364197493,
-0.0135591412,
0.0896577165,
0.0780746117,
-0.0375745334,
0.013551794,
-0.0485187247,
0.0663794056,
0.0605427027,
0.0553710014,
0.0108741261,
0.0042850082,
-0.0611383952,
0.0030771899,
0.0378930755,
0.0473806523,
0.0013623737,
0.0155033097,
0.0156533029,
0.0073256199,
-0.0540202036,
-0.0759770945,
0.0398911573,
-0.0025935255,
0.0031746316,
-0.02608357,
-0.0132636363,
0.0073489035,
0.0208098125,
-0.039795015,
0.0102075748,
-0.0061408258,
-0.0260108486,
-0.0430517681,
0.0181852393,
-0.0412385836,
0.0072990209,
0.0439140536,
-0.0137129063,
-0.0331482626,
0.0415311418,
-0.0040628342,
-0.0388678648,
-0.0024770256,
-0.0818555728,
0.0356344059,
-0.0417621769,
0.0548508354,
-0.0117615601,
0.0502643697,
0.0054302374,
0.0460761301,
-0.0234032981,
0.0275314935,
-0.0083957966,
0.0103008654,
0.0234143883,
-0.0158188753,
-0.0639806017,
0.0178338252,
-0.0075576915,
0.0329219289,
-0.0023647319,
-0.0432315245,
-0.0407091081,
0.0079215029,
-0.0946846083,
-0.0177395679,
-0.0434103459,
0.0109222597,
0.0188253392,
-0.0229584444,
-0.0287196953,
-0.0160492081,
0.0154062761,
-0.0004380933,
0.0229868907,
0.0136436885,
0.0187969413,
-0.0211477224,
-0.0217396915,
-0.0243053697,
0.031343773,
-0.030839812,
0.0379147716,
0.0127228182,
-0.0656089783,
-0.0850624442,
0.0424551293,
0.0018521171,
0.0496692732,
-0.0029401369,
-0.0606958196,
0.0317328498,
-0.0091462284,
0.0364404656,
0.0331808962,
0.0326433368,
0.0057642846,
0.0537405834,
-0.0175510161,
-0.0093915444,
-0.0116784144,
0.0229877122,
0.0120869549,
-0.010934432,
-0.0328707881,
0.0105445664,
0.0459964126,
0.0051381839,
0.0176149271,
-0.0609004572,
-0.0211702567,
-0.0624640435,
-0.0294523016,
0.0234474801,
-0.0213711224,
-0.0418239981,
0.0378022715,
-0.0178701058,
-0.0359559208,
0.0630995035,
-0.0635759085,
-0.0171782337,
-0.0183220915,
0.0074936533,
0.0085484106,
0.0260081198,
-0.0048025418,
0.0110304747,
0.0176422372,
-0.0284586046,
0.0086235646,
-0.0108515732,
-0.0122579159,
-0.0368672386,
0.0003479896,
-0.0450233966,
0.0103743458,
0.0074651125,
-0.0026638345,
-0.055702351,
-0.0503884964,
-0.0330936015,
-0.0240961257,
-0.0360022187,
-0.0355816782,
-0.0379002504,
0.0270267241,
-0.0040462692,
0.0565151274,
-0.0078810472,
-0.010899106,
0.0003234803,
0.010140975,
0.0389267318,
-0.0153527157,
0.0494807102,
-0.0357922725,
0.0346182883,
0.0865922496,
0.0418810323,
0.0559504852,
-0.0133837275,
-0.0478661247,
0.0115113696,
-0.0202448443,
-0.0231059287,
0.0099635981,
0.0544830821,
-0.0583321415,
-0.0160207245,
0.1085079238,
0.0276549198,
-0.062439207,
-0.0039223768,
-0.0553505383,
0.0289579965,
0.0139266197,
-0.0253315158,
-0.0891153812,
-0.0187606812,
0.0100433324,
0.0174853429,
-0.0323492549,
-0.0289023481,
-0.0110373925,
-0.0868744031,
0.0496140011,
0.021484714,
-0.0515661128,
-0.0103195924,
-0.0311318524,
0.0171539653,
0.0074152313,
0.022357231,
-0.0008985712,
0.0230629388,
-0.0425883606,
0.0251348149,
-0.0955023319,
-0.0371676236,
0.0353666544,
-0.049641408,
0.0918835327,
0.0641099438,
0.0173078645,
-0.0041511273,
-0.0542753525,
0.0474369451,
-0.0114208814,
-0.0189658515,
0.0307158064,
0.0655351356,
0.0103123672,
-0.0071819192,
0.0054443921,
-0.010988812,
-0.0388003327,
-0.0023093941,
-0.0049576689,
0.0760965422,
-0.0320095047,
-0.0290086456,
-0.002665112,
0.0432592258,
0.0466307923,
0.0846411288,
0.0110763405,
-0.0195786487,
-0.1013834849,
-0.01129747,
0.0542073362,
-0.0529671051,
-0.0451752916,
0.0371186733,
0.0484474339,
-0.0614684932,
-0.0566227473,
-0.0407307334,
-0.0002265708,
0.0298017561,
-0.0184529964,
0.0442025214,
-0.01987583,
0.0120036555,
-0.0261269044,
-0.0099612586,
-0.0658671036,
0.0280121546,
-0.0590141416,
0.0215946175,
-0.0184728783,
0.0201324131,
0.0103431763,
0.035802085,
-0.1006869525,
-0.0709860772,
0.06053124,
0.0027901896,
0.0249626264,
0.0309112761,
-0.0579386652,
-0.0403157137,
0.053282924,
0.0501157157,
-0.0412621088,
0.0211599395,
0.0229895003,
-0.0141344694,
-0.0006941716,
0.0190866049,
-0.0036700626,
-0.0183853023,
-0.0327554233,
0.0128613729,
-0.0190755688,
-0.015235885,
0.0090155592,
0.0145634105,
0.0017722119,
-0.0168806799,
0.0034244601,
0.0040801479,
-0.0026758574,
-0.0208593141,
-0.0162966587,
-0.0013432541,
0.0330523849,
0.0143266898,
-0.0443763174,
0.0194835141,
-0.0063482965,
-0.0592294708,
-0.006928646,
-0.0057470109,
-0.0233902168,
0.0240691155,
0.0270578545,
0.0569047183,
-0.0316969901,
-0.0126254847,
-0.0131375464,
0.0021677101,
0.0376448371,
0.0078186058,
0.0535023063,
0.0102024088,
-0.0273788087,
0.0019299038,
0.0308816452,
-0.0371328853,
-0.0481008627,
-0.0271537248,
0.0561901145,
0.0577732883,
0.0134262787,
0.0729182661,
-0.0430588126,
0.0170667171,
-0.0286852848,
-0.0000939131,
0.026810484,
-0.0262158513,
-0.0315130726,
0.0374065973,
-0.0337333195,
0.0448124669,
0.0746867955,
0.0033697768,
0.0455932878,
-0.000999868,
-0.0380406715,
-0.0348917134,
-0.0366355218,
-0.0621121936,
-0.0035166736,
-0.0419725552,
-0.0014867996,
-0.0645397082,
-0.0570363849,
0.0074762916,
0.0358125083,
0.037079718,
0.0068619391,
-0.0164205302,
0.0705075189,
-0.0254157111,
0.0017533484,
-0.0423036106,
-0.0222014096,
0.0445603728,
0.0022961118,
-0.0049517918,
-6.18068244e-33,
0.0025647569,
-0.0648681149,
0.0029059066,
-0.0222306568,
-0.0151424073,
0.0072682677,
-0.0303846337,
0.0250721872,
0.0416485444,
0.0291226991,
0.012882554,
0.0430794805,
0.0331782214,
-0.0083078006,
-0.002054703,
-0.0064438786,
0.0639363155,
0.0152601684,
-0.0444735624,
0.0304393973,
0.0426788777,
-0.004891823,
0.0221739709,
-0.0806857124,
0.0427760892,
-0.0507287346,
-0.0328695029,
0.0184028968,
0.0110502131,
0.0408863351,
-0.0310713015,
0.0320122726,
0.0100482246,
-0.0217064116,
-0.0137752378,
0.0061956812,
-0.0189594161,
-0.0012057311,
-0.0147587843,
0.0470921509,
-0.0068310574,
-0.0035368714,
0.0161013324,
-0.0211851504,
0.0194476638,
0.0194145981,
0.0213424843,
-0.0187469851,
-0.0094238874,
0.0374395065,
-0.0700618103,
0.0386312939,
-0.0068434286,
-0.0238294881,
0.025605252,
0.0398198031,
-0.0040398845,
-0.0494103841,
-0.0817866251,
0.0212504175,
-0.001329212,
0.0012583585,
0.0331547521,
-0.01486672,
-0.0292487722,
0.0813339055,
0.0364139713,
0.026376497,
-0.023668889,
-0.0277831536,
0.0158290006,
0.0034594899,
0.0454802252,
0.017974399,
0.0331858806,
-0.0128562814,
-0.0222216565,
0.0041975058,
-0.0289225206,
0.0268466268,
0.065925613,
-0.0043728724,
-0.0798490718,
-0.0310034901,
0.0224369727,
-0.0030150528,
-0.0173805356,
-0.021103289,
0.0368821137,
0.012031124,
-0.0343294516,
-0.0071254163,
0.0367246345,
-0.0368806273,
0.0278044567,
0.0161801688,
-0.02080868,
0.0086426931,
-0.0112143522,
0.0231057014,
0.0028680819,
0.0139203537,
0.0385865942,
0.0089688469,
0.0393178463,
-0.0058249482,
0.0272439141,
0.0192720518,
-0.0727140829,
0.0113063175,
-0.016497083,
0.0378732719,
-0.0025677471,
0.0009960133,
0.0442118533,
-0.0353720747,
-0.0183381047,
0.0092053106,
0.0147854136,
0.0087736929,
-0.0081213452,
0.0364200696,
-0.0398609713,
-0.0063451091,
-0.0365428068,
0.0062448238,
-0.0359479934,
0.0129854903,
0.0154073685,
-0.0510596931,
0.0032986824,
0.0012733629,
2.714e-7,
-0.0081380568,
0.0482872054,
0.0585160218,
-0.020145189,
0.0125772832,
0.0293073878,
-0.0069324132,
-0.0036738366,
-0.0057658772,
-0.0103399334,
-0.0081223147,
0.0158536956,
0.0798323825,
0.0659519657,
-0.1004436389,
-0.0364722796,
-0.042446848,
-0.0090541914,
-0.0633852333,
-0.0311502572,
0.0605577081,
0.038643606,
0.0275612958,
-0.0233577527,
0.0052674594,
-0.0573584326,
0.0287885796,
0.0065185432,
-0.0050777285,
0.0348102599,
0.0685222372,
0.0343421176,
0.0061260988,
0.047591377,
-0.0030729754,
-0.0442687757,
0.0163543578,
0.0266524889,
0.0020226331,
-0.0183536727,
-0.0157404859,
-0.0183303896,
-0.0086857295,
-0.0494048931,
0.0544519909,
0.0137765473,
-0.0181157272,
-0.032719072,
-0.0074676736,
-0.0229214579,
0.0488393754,
0.0196508132,
-0.0383257046,
0.024962673,
0.0103495177,
0.0254000966,
-0.0170932673,
-0.0565968044,
-0.0068004047,
-0.0011564884,
-0.0346674472,
-0.0200175252,
0.0005146721,
0.0141266324,
-0.004038651,
-0.0671693087,
0.0271301251,
2.503927634e-34,
0.0465428382,
0.0018822422,
0.0207351819,
0.0108816428,
0.0404504202,
0.021297643,
0.0487103425,
0.0000384936,
-0.0296343882,
-0.0203612726,
-0.000676343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06488v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06488v2 | SpikeCLIP: A Contrastive Language-Image Pretrained Spiking Neural Network | 2023-10-10T09:57:17 | 2023-10-12T03:23:40 | Tianlong Li, Wenhao Liu, Changze Lv, Jianhan Xu, Cenyuan Zhang, Muling Wu, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Spiking neural networks (SNNs) have demonstrated the capability to achieve
comparable performance to deep neural networks (DNNs) in both visual and
linguistic domains while offering the advantages of improved energy efficiency
and adherence to biological plausibility. However, the extension of such
single-modality SNNs into the realm of multimodal scenarios remains an
unexplored territory. Drawing inspiration from the concept of contrastive
language-image pre-training (CLIP), we introduce a novel framework, named
SpikeCLIP, to address the gap between two modalities within the context of
spike-based computing through a two-step recipe involving ``Alignment
Pre-training + Dual-Loss Fine-tuning". Extensive experiments demonstrate that
SNNs achieve comparable results to their DNN counterparts while significantly
reducing energy consumption across a variety of datasets commonly used for
multimodal model evaluation. Furthermore, SpikeCLIP maintains robust
performance in image classification tasks that involve class labels not
predefined within specific categories. | [
-0.0161207728,
0.0526108518,
-0.0059290486,
0.0648474693,
-0.0078935642,
0.0066782399,
0.0206832476,
-0.0368778184,
-0.0295648482,
-0.0277589038,
-0.0801242441,
-0.0093612233,
-0.0001138354,
0.0633977726,
0.0359556451,
-0.0554471947,
0.0793116689,
0.0198517218,
-0.0087376311,
-0.0244617108,
0.0555131994,
-0.0209417008,
-0.0445995368,
0.0232550651,
-0.0284313504,
-0.010382521,
-0.0357274674,
0.0243047792,
0.0356311277,
-0.0338057205,
0.0376675539,
0.0436456501,
-0.0019237003,
0.0488607623,
0.000001982,
-0.0101717431,
0.0518710874,
0.0254099388,
-0.0069126734,
0.0088702356,
0.0122293625,
-0.0020338306,
-0.0050293072,
-0.0198723003,
-0.0330375805,
-0.0295679811,
0.1370071918,
0.0194610711,
0.0531049222,
0.0262305774,
-0.0310550053,
-0.0548789389,
0.0382273942,
-0.0037811305,
0.0176488757,
0.0293950681,
-0.0191672724,
-0.0377440453,
-0.0070313402,
-0.0028241423,
-0.0476127155,
0.0493732169,
0.0283651967,
0.0068760416,
0.0105186682,
0.0477498807,
-0.0756379813,
-0.0184975807,
-0.048747085,
0.0740192905,
-0.0541496351,
-0.007203809,
-0.0234266911,
-0.0202358905,
-0.0328771882,
-0.0413341895,
0.0151096284,
-0.0321004838,
0.0295276418,
0.0463685021,
-0.0064473129,
-0.0121069206,
0.0588041358,
0.0140699875,
0.0177410729,
0.031060541,
0.0157646034,
0.03268582,
0.0294070765,
0.0154603012,
-0.0007999608,
-0.0139925843,
-0.0007074687,
0.0351382308,
-0.0286169518,
-0.0281959269,
-0.0646763816,
-0.0522570945,
0.0097053126,
-0.0573378615,
0.0455496199,
0.0575781688,
-0.0423770957,
0.0419818647,
-0.0107297329,
-0.0302096903,
-0.0327004306,
0.0418002345,
-0.0165903233,
0.0032966882,
-0.0140265441,
0.0032329489,
-0.0279425848,
-0.0028264914,
-0.0535668246,
-0.0459804386,
-0.0681085587,
0.0109866178,
-0.026273625,
-0.0309662186,
-0.0449032336,
0.0399085768,
-0.0134150404,
-0.003754579,
-0.0114201671,
0.0205113981,
0.0269865487,
0.0248117372,
0.002138074,
-0.0639125258,
-0.0083979415,
0.0386885852,
-0.0069547999,
-0.0270818416,
0.0462762713,
0.09175767,
-0.0489070527,
-0.0367561914,
-0.0617007837,
0.0405580327,
-0.0299412943,
-0.0074948245,
0.0404458269,
-0.0813218877,
0.0753283426,
0.0183476303,
-0.0143776713,
-0.0106230341,
0.0060142674,
-0.0069459933,
0.0081819808,
0.1209090054,
-0.0320622325,
-0.0304301903,
0.0216572378,
-0.0119285146,
-0.0393281505,
0.0625169575,
0.0645292699,
-0.0074801273,
0.0035262739,
-0.0150521966,
-0.0096100727,
0.0404188484,
0.0359346494,
-0.0160786733,
-0.062642321,
-0.0525725782,
0.0193899497,
-0.0231510233,
0.0747660771,
0.0574683994,
-0.0380640179,
-0.0398601666,
0.0450019017,
0.0330901332,
-0.0156396106,
0.0282580238,
0.0440020002,
-0.0304037612,
0.00450968,
-0.0137964049,
-0.057849858,
0.0541024581,
-0.0272797327,
-0.0311139263,
-0.0075932089,
0.0312282834,
-0.0496583581,
-0.023602346,
0.0232151672,
-0.0233207326,
0.0336276554,
0.0361457877,
0.0453966595,
-0.0308869109,
-0.0281490628,
0.0367032774,
0.0126906857,
0.0137172285,
-0.0220295005,
-0.0410857424,
-0.0743537098,
0.0375550985,
0.0050357003,
-0.0156175448,
-0.0053351116,
0.0229832642,
-0.0193265565,
0.0452736951,
0.0130699109,
0.0117343813,
0.0949657187,
-0.0524525493,
-0.0337510444,
-0.0507171378,
0.0084473072,
0.0058985865,
0.0187265463,
-0.000279,
-0.0027038585,
0.0438680127,
-0.0281407312,
0.0206348132,
0.0065774298,
-0.0215001721,
0.0177479051,
0.0006773214,
0.0395187587,
-0.0534625649,
-0.0193937812,
-0.0096866563,
-0.0172882136,
-0.0351779684,
0.0615844913,
0.0078281937,
-0.0285699572,
-0.0216594581,
0.0492259562,
-0.0324418023,
0.0021512304,
0.020501826,
-0.0255045891,
-0.0199273191,
-0.0011204765,
-0.0135244057,
0.0587715134,
-0.0309078395,
0.0152806016,
0.0018272368,
0.0121164201,
0.0102769211,
0.0104682175,
0.0181252602,
-0.0014275031,
-0.0059088063,
0.0234170556,
0.0251213126,
-0.0252153948,
-0.0763055161,
-0.0218867343,
-0.0275988542,
0.0053085648,
-0.0124918194,
0.0017223044,
-0.0625592247,
0.0266921464,
-0.0805670545,
-0.0112018203,
0.0016515858,
0.0031399769,
-0.0040151547,
-0.0033234542,
0.0134169431,
-0.0203744788,
-0.0330730081,
0.0418949984,
-0.0241180621,
0.0407499112,
0.0305759497,
0.0179664399,
0.011972527,
-0.0409139395,
-0.0126384422,
0.0058969394,
0.0552231595,
-0.0284437928,
-0.0569176748,
0.0016042549,
0.0673236251,
-0.0153272413,
0.0314518921,
-0.0027644921,
-0.0603235401,
0.0295837969,
0.0046397876,
0.0818015561,
0.052144438,
0.0041002836,
-0.0082400991,
0.0217148457,
-0.0310893916,
-0.0133010782,
0.0191907845,
-0.0145501085,
0.0264108907,
-0.0003614519,
0.0214070939,
-0.0558104813,
0.0528593026,
-0.0078944452,
0.0188088976,
-0.0225289539,
-0.0168510303,
0.004524067,
-0.0255852081,
-0.0553627089,
0.0225455612,
-0.0159070548,
0.0214542076,
-0.0305798836,
-0.0613392144,
0.0391272083,
-0.0010040076,
-0.0059432909,
0.0179007035,
-0.0186444912,
0.019932894,
0.0268888082,
0.0237930231,
0.0631256178,
-0.0653725564,
0.0153239556,
-0.0528088063,
-0.0449558944,
0.0141681284,
-0.0043044868,
0.0534022152,
-0.0058170748,
-0.0026788008,
-0.0581781678,
-0.0591127053,
-0.0373116173,
-0.0023413084,
-0.0219541583,
0.0014119539,
0.028370982,
-0.0076961052,
-0.0115509937,
0.0145682134,
0.0084233889,
0.0366026424,
-0.0118871853,
-0.0262084045,
-0.0152458539,
0.0529325344,
-0.0050940732,
-0.0274116304,
-0.0055545145,
-0.0173833035,
-0.0278966054,
0.060163755,
0.0169779044,
-0.0027944895,
-0.124709025,
0.0278792735,
0.0292411614,
0.0525999442,
-0.0296991542,
-0.0066687004,
0.0536959469,
-0.0369694456,
-0.0030972445,
0.0258242898,
-0.0008880984,
-0.073755309,
-0.0179198589,
0.0287911799,
0.0331712775,
0.0143182501,
0.0063594435,
-0.02316387,
-0.0529239252,
-0.0381154455,
0.0037289567,
0.0153147401,
0.0274485406,
-0.0464337394,
-0.0170660857,
0.027287757,
0.0157354493,
-0.0286622476,
0.0052441428,
-0.0045705223,
0.0011704342,
0.0038002634,
-0.0076515209,
0.0049402677,
0.027982071,
-0.02026866,
0.0204812493,
0.0489010327,
-0.0711638629,
0.0015978452,
-0.0306289699,
0.0072405236,
0.0596621074,
-0.0140077565,
-0.0335450023,
-0.061026752,
0.044456657,
-0.0078420304,
0.0042034709,
-0.0054814033,
0.0173802041,
0.012008057,
-0.041644413,
-0.0148412073,
0.0170949548,
0.0229813661,
-0.0599349067,
-0.0592693612,
0.0316918418,
-0.0343110897,
0.040365614,
-0.0653657615,
0.020325521,
0.0041036466,
0.0196394678,
0.0283193141,
-0.0658419505,
-0.0224393178,
-0.0098227197,
-0.0006837198,
-0.0776220635,
-0.0122777382,
-0.0167111307,
0.0142257959,
-0.0436747074,
0.0089075007,
-0.0195341315,
-0.0118334964,
0.0484398454,
-0.0097208135,
-0.0404282585,
-0.0250878073,
0.0132433493,
-0.0590734147,
0.0574493147,
0.0143090282,
0.0038921449,
-0.091725193,
-0.0378722996,
0.0552701354,
-0.01301465,
0.0065346472,
0.0318572968,
-0.0810882822,
-0.0544228777,
0.0185716227,
0.0555865988,
0.0091900695,
0.0258306656,
0.0236061458,
-0.0031167516,
0.0573115498,
0.1364868134,
0.0350301042,
0.0228609517,
0.0321841091,
-0.0118804732,
-0.0222622771,
-0.010543636,
-0.030174138,
0.0512028262,
0.0125477603,
0.0069211698,
-0.0148174278,
-0.041871801,
-0.0092712501,
-0.0417159796,
0.0944246724,
-0.0271021891,
0.0364329889,
-0.0135788135,
-0.0216590017,
0.0555001795,
0.0211919844,
-0.0437209159,
-0.0373549722,
-0.0057173418,
-0.0120494943,
-0.0163858049,
-0.0061553032,
0.0409309678,
-0.0377523378,
0.0038615125,
-0.001075666,
0.0473504029,
-0.0055936719,
-0.0235033836,
0.0402604491,
-0.0188612156,
0.0511309654,
-0.0232554711,
0.0015953495,
-0.0327221081,
0.0519502014,
0.0656759292,
0.01000934,
-0.0926191583,
0.0645099729,
0.0040906938,
0.0049324124,
-0.0158368722,
-0.0315260924,
0.0380108915,
-0.0033138227,
-0.0196004398,
-0.0213051252,
-0.0413721688,
-0.0149632888,
0.0656740591,
0.0037416329,
-0.0081436997,
0.0378704369,
0.0285320822,
0.0200712793,
0.0048808795,
0.0335398056,
-0.0514532961,
0.0095682377,
0.0359180458,
-0.0169723276,
0.0103923334,
-0.0348019004,
-0.0171041656,
0.0277560428,
-0.0083610406,
-0.0233972259,
-0.0156026455,
-0.0638705343,
0.0018893084,
0.0270851441,
0.0107442401,
0.0340919234,
0.078144975,
0.0648069829,
0.0165798385,
-0.0280014277,
0.0108543895,
-0.0191776734,
0.0568926334,
0.0051227207,
0.0135967657,
-5.881983448e-33,
0.0009704136,
-0.0203372817,
0.0400799513,
0.0257518683,
0.0139863938,
0.04351414,
-0.0206145477,
0.0186934583,
-0.0241642781,
0.0149598662,
-0.0042386767,
0.012622376,
0.008099908,
0.0217746366,
0.0221812464,
-0.008661828,
0.0121604046,
-0.0084689958,
0.0110905189,
-0.0043685851,
0.0344924927,
0.01256104,
0.0635405704,
-0.0509469584,
-0.0111074774,
0.0585274249,
-0.015883375,
-0.024852464,
-0.0053476393,
0.041992072,
-0.0717535093,
0.0516107753,
-0.010660924,
0.0290679969,
0.0014484365,
-0.0003559846,
-0.0772936046,
-0.0169521961,
-0.0073857675,
0.0156791862,
-0.0942203104,
-0.0083737932,
0.0589927621,
-0.0225709397,
-0.0123262135,
-0.0038939374,
0.0128999073,
-0.0288429614,
0.0295665674,
-0.0303754471,
-0.0137927048,
0.0028453665,
0.0275942571,
-0.0363846906,
0.0332611427,
0.0128647573,
0.0088907406,
0.0540250652,
-0.1148387194,
0.0237539932,
0.0330856144,
0.0075298147,
0.0458951555,
0.0797845423,
0.0215007067,
0.0669238418,
0.0357674919,
-0.0588093661,
0.0317027234,
0.028677538,
0.0738096237,
0.0294579417,
0.0228455067,
0.0583260395,
0.093009375,
-0.0331267565,
-0.0599561967,
0.0013323268,
0.0140006077,
-0.013170667,
0.0210404359,
0.020110812,
-0.0124117387,
-0.0461964682,
-0.0162804816,
-0.0187510047,
-0.0463064127,
-0.0422982909,
0.0050271731,
0.0047645825,
-0.0086680735,
0.0323642269,
0.0891327411,
0.0006547057,
0.0106846057,
0.0110190418,
0.0068596127,
0.0319663063,
0.0261387993,
-0.0174964033,
-0.043012958,
-0.025185613,
0.003806293,
-0.0070676375,
0.0239178538,
0.0123978797,
-0.0039222273,
0.0686092675,
-0.0203935336,
0.0060828379,
-0.0224237125,
-0.0246567875,
0.0463447906,
0.0250543673,
0.0279718712,
-0.0002981875,
-0.0246126261,
0.0637871847,
-0.0121454066,
-0.0058785281,
-0.0160014778,
-0.0200211834,
-0.0306509398,
0.054828044,
0.0035787667,
0.0001866334,
-0.0515408665,
0.0075692763,
-0.0245420709,
-0.0915096924,
-0.0186309554,
0.0456129164,
2.869e-7,
0.044703763,
-0.0061274599,
-0.034212593,
0.000668937,
0.040874429,
0.0443144254,
0.0053727529,
0.015467844,
-0.030685572,
-0.0374391861,
-0.0090471618,
0.0564187095,
0.002428113,
0.0387852862,
0.0017946418,
-0.0408381335,
-0.029343795,
0.0347373597,
0.0129475407,
-0.0140596032,
0.0163525119,
0.0560501106,
0.0206575692,
-0.0433679633,
0.0474720411,
-0.001015714,
0.0680615753,
-0.007308777,
0.0069727125,
-0.0118497703,
-0.0411538705,
0.026333468,
-0.0140320966,
0.0293905437,
-0.0026689908,
-0.0223026294,
-0.0021438999,
-0.0020385813,
-0.0559414327,
-0.0341030397,
-0.0039196629,
0.0263965558,
-0.0397273824,
-0.0429620482,
0.0691778138,
-0.0726696029,
-0.0415965244,
-0.0290327147,
-0.0316540636,
-0.0132617364,
0.054112453,
-0.0412305221,
-0.0370740667,
-0.0258331373,
-0.0224053487,
-0.0222210716,
-0.085772939,
-0.077033177,
0.0080705406,
0.0262937192,
-0.0032059161,
-0.0050044013,
-0.0778682083,
-0.0303191468,
0.0557654314,
-0.029005006,
-0.0292051043,
1.986783818e-34,
-0.0076580546,
-0.0366723053,
0.0097452318,
0.0141305542,
-0.0236561373,
0.0059507871,
0.0042531863,
-0.0320019424,
-0.0052025085,
-0.0049136705,
-0.0266224686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06474v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06474v3 | Multilingual Jailbreak Challenges in Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T09:44:06 | 2024-03-04T04:03:54 | Yue Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Sinno Jialin Pan, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable capabilities across a
wide range of tasks, they pose potential safety concerns, such as the
``jailbreak'' problem, wherein malicious instructions can manipulate LLMs to
exhibit undesirable behavior. Although several preventive measures have been
developed to mitigate the potential risks associated with LLMs, they have
primarily focused on English. In this study, we reveal the presence of
multilingual jailbreak challenges within LLMs and consider two potential risky
scenarios: unintentional and intentional. The unintentional scenario involves
users querying LLMs using non-English prompts and inadvertently bypassing the
safety mechanisms, while the intentional scenario concerns malicious users
combining malicious instructions with multilingual prompts to deliberately
attack LLMs. The experimental results reveal that in the unintentional
scenario, the rate of unsafe content increases as the availability of languages
decreases. Specifically, low-resource languages exhibit about three times the
likelihood of encountering harmful content compared to high-resource languages,
with both ChatGPT and GPT-4. In the intentional scenario, multilingual prompts
can exacerbate the negative impact of malicious instructions, with
astonishingly high rates of unsafe output: 80.92\% for ChatGPT and 40.71\% for
GPT-4. To handle such a challenge in the multilingual context, we propose a
novel \textsc{Self-Defense} framework that automatically generates multilingual
training data for safety fine-tuning. Experimental results show that ChatGPT
fine-tuned with such data can achieve a substantial reduction in unsafe content
generation. Data is available at
\url{https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/multilingual-safety-for-LLMs}. | [
0.0531687066,
0.0480876863,
-0.0262667574,
0.0442728326,
-0.0301982258,
0.0151822641,
0.0146441571,
0.0054904288,
0.0734428391,
-0.0287021156,
-0.0407229811,
-0.0496724583,
-0.0241396874,
0.0023568615,
0.0513252579,
0.0015598534,
0.058707986,
-0.0551297702,
-0.0224300306,
-0.0136942882,
0.0336646698,
0.0171024278,
0.0376324989,
0.0418478101,
-0.0086640706,
-0.0180471968,
-0.0042862846,
0.0244393516,
0.0126883453,
-0.0615067631,
0.0367277004,
0.0348986611,
-0.0116188386,
0.063930057,
0.0000021796,
-0.0408025347,
-0.0394797511,
0.0169561319,
-0.0224277116,
0.0116435811,
0.020730596,
-0.0570550747,
-0.0504454337,
0.0316041037,
-0.0343834423,
0.0114371032,
0.0370600969,
0.0326856859,
0.0772278309,
0.0757644922,
-0.0012164934,
-0.0063853315,
0.0333706066,
0.0032572888,
0.0084456746,
-0.0457162112,
0.0216752235,
-0.0102679888,
0.0109285256,
0.0323597826,
0.0121188471,
0.00196635,
0.0162059423,
-0.0295032263,
-0.0937754363,
-0.0082554128,
-0.0281762052,
-0.0368919708,
-0.0116449436,
0.0376838781,
-0.0491136238,
-0.0140924649,
0.0115736267,
0.0071192244,
0.0155450162,
-0.005187823,
-0.0141514568,
0.0663680956,
-0.0192388687,
-0.010860675,
0.0400060415,
-0.0126411989,
0.056744542,
0.020993622,
0.0179224201,
0.0546940155,
0.0133866919,
-0.0350485928,
0.0145307845,
-0.0221411288,
-0.0139751751,
-0.0578802302,
0.0133086666,
-0.0026584512,
-0.0282203928,
0.0362440236,
-0.0601968542,
-0.0510223657,
0.0628633797,
-0.0974260941,
-0.0327171609,
0.0341644622,
-0.0120834662,
0.0181400385,
-0.0081880381,
0.0060796151,
-0.016861381,
0.041948352,
0.0107609704,
0.0087900339,
-0.0022913443,
-0.0138838235,
-0.0340410285,
0.039290946,
-0.0021886081,
0.0374332294,
-0.0303664245,
0.0501939543,
-0.0205385182,
0.0256063528,
-0.0114342915,
-0.0253759809,
-0.0143766236,
0.0115889329,
0.0351893529,
-0.0141460253,
-0.0320963077,
-0.0258842073,
-0.001206175,
-0.0884813368,
0.0020140097,
0.0102504436,
-0.0722121522,
-0.0381045006,
-0.0028762596,
0.1300130934,
0.0183105431,
0.0035720798,
-0.0667617097,
-0.085931018,
-0.0395964347,
-0.0270542465,
-0.009187921,
-0.0870213285,
-0.01291354,
-0.0017347231,
0.0058986614,
-0.0592423379,
0.0228524655,
0.0177611466,
-0.0535252132,
0.041003745,
-0.0228099506,
-0.0172474012,
0.0055709393,
0.0477280505,
0.0059355306,
0.1010121033,
-0.0035252378,
0.0439723954,
0.0712802559,
-0.0238890182,
0.0153341843,
0.0681345314,
-0.0157828908,
0.0583579689,
0.0042733802,
-0.011102045,
0.0652472973,
-0.0285059512,
-0.0054503023,
0.05313785,
-0.0058747227,
-0.0191022996,
0.0518938713,
0.0211227126,
-0.0459027253,
0.0431470014,
0.0276364889,
-0.00762256,
-0.0163094513,
0.0247665886,
-0.0622033067,
-0.0107767498,
-0.0654163659,
-0.0313060507,
-0.0031245258,
0.0588004701,
-0.0129250297,
0.0087417802,
-0.0036459458,
-0.0135325482,
0.0170615371,
-0.0071166307,
0.0074326349,
0.0164273772,
0.0017890006,
0.0434794053,
0.0444622599,
-0.0367745273,
-0.0081879394,
-0.059421245,
-0.0287297796,
0.0881883428,
0.0584182031,
0.000576367,
-0.0434039123,
-0.0229969993,
0.0065048984,
0.0248724557,
0.0175141543,
0.0094268396,
0.0136709828,
-0.0220390633,
-0.0209704097,
0.0078194514,
0.0120116193,
0.0119316112,
0.023010252,
0.0216585528,
0.0085861171,
0.0064140307,
-0.0674917027,
0.0139543517,
-0.0305391122,
-0.0194668658,
-0.0014761386,
0.0187681746,
0.0119781187,
0.011059585,
-0.0164975934,
-0.005282193,
0.0334172919,
0.0078780474,
0.0206987057,
0.0195387434,
-0.0389182344,
-0.0150102619,
0.0455336235,
-0.0114885028,
-0.009471803,
0.0253237002,
-0.0206945725,
-0.0206250176,
0.0321841128,
-0.0518715233,
0.0171418842,
-0.0216275938,
0.0264546834,
-0.0082993926,
0.0038999242,
-0.0232738443,
0.0167150889,
-0.004430776,
0.0094516501,
-0.0030124236,
0.008529162,
0.0297763776,
0.005764592,
-0.0761888176,
0.0180391781,
-0.0408257395,
0.0412247032,
0.0487320758,
0.0614609346,
-0.0145987002,
-0.0151767554,
-0.070707038,
-0.0006443448,
-0.0339951813,
0.0263474695,
0.0589682721,
0.0351039469,
-0.036356438,
-0.0156858955,
-0.0308613516,
-0.0120560052,
0.0202003233,
0.0616002642,
-0.0024787223,
-0.0169150084,
-0.0168068632,
-0.0024325082,
0.0023245576,
-0.0141894631,
0.0183078256,
-0.0109702786,
-0.0332245715,
-0.0252302215,
0.0356302075,
-0.012730469,
0.0140445614,
-0.0111179771,
-0.0746271908,
0.0174566619,
-0.0194661524,
0.0232804306,
0.0322696604,
0.0011251253,
0.0252609085,
0.0785767287,
-0.0065396787,
-0.0518530756,
-0.0042621372,
0.0175982509,
-0.0576550253,
-0.0259952731,
-0.0622612536,
0.0247864053,
0.0533596724,
0.0176847875,
-0.0069410661,
-0.042809125,
0.0021168264,
-0.0468160436,
-0.0302363541,
-0.0203836095,
-0.0239746515,
-0.0367038362,
0.0207959786,
-0.0020725755,
-0.0555515662,
0.0851971954,
-0.0199579448,
0.0195863098,
-0.055351004,
-0.0258541349,
0.0039757024,
0.0500967801,
-0.0179117974,
0.0501007959,
0.0332018211,
-0.0457214825,
-0.0366208479,
0.0028002607,
0.0466710627,
-0.0063643805,
0.0201787148,
-0.0351968259,
-0.0011094848,
-0.0184036884,
-0.0667777956,
-0.0352576338,
-0.0727613717,
0.0081550162,
-0.0223005209,
0.0580466129,
-0.0224507973,
0.0175914466,
-0.0090744365,
0.055510547,
0.0009712623,
-0.0360943228,
-0.0076568471,
-0.018112503,
0.0143964011,
0.0329377726,
-0.0685229376,
0.0038335724,
-0.0261792354,
0.0429680943,
0.0931028202,
0.0378121398,
-0.0271837823,
0.0269427765,
0.0185617842,
0.039896138,
-0.0046618227,
-0.0499236062,
0.0369080454,
0.0584290996,
-0.0535222217,
-0.0376633145,
0.0653175414,
0.0336037055,
-0.0272721685,
-0.0048188786,
-0.0390648805,
0.043599844,
0.0141928233,
0.0417072028,
-0.0717013255,
-0.0120684337,
0.0179333705,
0.0475318618,
-0.0237887464,
-0.0256864633,
-0.0116137145,
-0.1040716246,
0.0102767209,
0.0245596115,
-0.0460224673,
0.002607753,
-0.0450275913,
-0.0420948081,
0.0164051745,
0.0264444873,
-0.0196429696,
-0.0086695394,
-0.0219546612,
0.0285443459,
-0.0559445135,
-0.0203794669,
0.0202449076,
-0.0444500893,
0.050378684,
0.0828247368,
-0.0116129722,
-0.0438759215,
0.0155640496,
0.0510641001,
0.000699576,
-0.0112715187,
-0.0097697489,
0.0113037908,
0.0096734874,
-0.0146999108,
0.0026007541,
0.0032019489,
0.0021621252,
-0.0299127903,
0.0418840013,
0.0775259957,
-0.0183493365,
-0.0027708029,
-0.0176532641,
0.0013367935,
0.0264589675,
0.046744559,
0.0140503682,
-0.0522811972,
-0.0243943799,
-0.0898330137,
-0.0132537056,
-0.0476345159,
-0.0104657141,
0.026944669,
-0.0164856296,
-0.0527057238,
-0.0437625647,
-0.0303742774,
-0.010242179,
0.0212738197,
0.0623121001,
-0.0081463689,
-0.0221388023,
0.002454319,
0.0127130859,
-0.0285126958,
-0.0377754718,
0.0342847705,
-0.070743598,
0.0306976307,
0.0019002764,
-0.015418509,
0.0142541956,
0.0212626308,
-0.0460655317,
-0.1046169549,
0.005697425,
0.0862235203,
0.0178324971,
0.0056497725,
-0.0431462526,
-0.0644637644,
0.0345977433,
0.0676413253,
-0.0753956139,
-0.0233829878,
0.0642272383,
-0.0125848884,
0.0154439099,
0.024034638,
-0.0447359607,
-0.0274482816,
0.0359687097,
0.0166144054,
-0.0470242873,
-0.012858836,
0.0162109416,
0.0669497252,
-0.0036374878,
-0.0356638655,
-0.0017359217,
0.0057289423,
0.0022671453,
-0.0166656356,
-0.0437768623,
0.0148791643,
0.0354790948,
0.0172545034,
-0.0362985469,
0.0333458446,
0.0253752787,
-0.0075449431,
-0.0049271719,
-0.0083099008,
0.0251060612,
0.0274769254,
0.0447453633,
0.0686061084,
0.0298772566,
-0.0164359156,
0.0417656302,
0.0163731109,
0.018455131,
-0.0338951312,
0.0435481407,
-0.0157254077,
-0.0292913169,
0.0218963157,
0.0529315323,
-0.0525529273,
-0.0458445214,
-0.0081179319,
0.045190271,
0.0307601076,
0.0052226535,
0.0540089495,
-0.0273058414,
0.0055769943,
-0.040856,
-0.0218824781,
0.008993567,
-0.0717990026,
0.0155676156,
-0.0089393137,
-0.0270697288,
-0.0084664775,
0.1028230786,
-0.0029972242,
0.0509602576,
0.0454255752,
-0.0401368476,
-0.0315512456,
0.0086349025,
0.0484566092,
0.0201626699,
-0.0704141334,
-0.033416409,
-0.0543082282,
-0.0864405409,
-0.0443870239,
0.0077217817,
0.0355190039,
0.0182789527,
-0.0113415197,
0.0628886074,
0.019999247,
0.0261898767,
-0.0635883436,
0.0183966998,
0.0181888603,
-0.0367408469,
0.0113055035,
-5.978533044e-33,
0.0178145785,
-0.0392929949,
-0.012593979,
-0.0096961921,
0.0345158912,
-0.0218949467,
-0.0318964906,
0.0148338145,
-0.0109205022,
-0.0134355603,
-0.0211530458,
-0.0153619042,
0.0040896339,
0.0100159422,
0.0041787359,
-0.0167732686,
0.0125240199,
0.0100932019,
-0.0153172817,
0.0467602685,
0.0717985034,
0.0159608535,
0.0402038582,
-0.0538050495,
0.0461485125,
-0.0211826004,
-0.0267398097,
0.0213099625,
-0.0233176518,
0.0643071011,
0.0066218167,
0.0416644029,
0.0216723774,
-0.0429636985,
-0.0203697644,
0.0313011706,
-0.008154911,
-0.0275561232,
0.0151644573,
0.0081497198,
0.0081105484,
-0.0664439052,
0.041579593,
-0.0190637708,
-0.0135173528,
0.0232014731,
-0.0026649842,
0.0026894703,
-0.0059490693,
-0.0257622618,
-0.0446478613,
0.0026581236,
-0.0040661138,
-0.0057526506,
0.0037161454,
0.0217304155,
0.0095803868,
-0.0315371267,
-0.0250823274,
0.0433584787,
0.0228516497,
0.016277479,
0.0576057099,
-0.0251744334,
-0.015607262,
0.0461291596,
-0.02328947,
0.0108644487,
0.0221443418,
-0.0126012536,
0.0044565466,
0.0212160815,
0.0339665078,
0.0790108889,
0.0278590582,
-0.04858239,
-0.0914897993,
0.0404319651,
0.0310193393,
0.0386824533,
0.0172469057,
-0.0112982802,
-0.044185508,
-0.0283708721,
0.0018449929,
0.0000608504,
-0.0256237574,
-0.0620908923,
0.028668467,
-0.0240231026,
-0.0102455309,
-0.0348245874,
0.0142900357,
-0.0481953211,
-0.0286956336,
0.0329555422,
-0.0103980908,
-0.0289809983,
0.0041927355,
0.0681663901,
-0.0034341591,
-0.015041573,
-0.0180149358,
-0.068768613,
0.0182932727,
0.0166121125,
0.0607131161,
0.0444921553,
-0.0690574721,
0.004715784,
-0.0270011164,
0.0625756532,
0.0180842038,
0.0221069399,
0.0181105994,
-0.0224281289,
0.0146375746,
0.0078446865,
0.0898211673,
-0.0222361218,
-0.0489804335,
-0.0040930822,
-0.0203297436,
0.0238013919,
-0.0066982582,
0.0159153808,
-0.0247553978,
0.0260807965,
0.0347044729,
-0.0671284869,
-0.0088230222,
-0.0078301886,
2.936e-7,
-0.001734842,
0.0169130005,
0.0030589532,
-0.0004946288,
0.0159930531,
0.0578899495,
-0.0263675004,
0.0657129437,
-0.0264665708,
-0.0137259876,
-0.0300089289,
-0.0163715724,
0.0492222384,
0.0913773999,
-0.0793390051,
0.0251163039,
-0.0696813911,
0.0158955585,
-0.0749263018,
-0.0065563843,
0.0398635641,
0.0838344544,
-0.00914877,
-0.0315936916,
-0.0229077283,
-0.0563347861,
0.0050601913,
-0.0090818768,
-0.0239354242,
-0.0098358095,
0.029621169,
0.0494359322,
0.0244749337,
0.0233984534,
-0.0387186818,
-0.0335051678,
-0.0392273292,
0.0311527699,
0.0186967794,
0.0054171463,
0.0081162313,
-0.0667187348,
0.0008238556,
-0.074040927,
0.0620666258,
0.0163000952,
-0.0039596558,
-0.0010748325,
0.0270186644,
-0.0472918563,
0.0162218176,
-0.0709762275,
-0.0465586074,
0.0153044574,
0.0237674247,
0.0189549066,
0.0094151376,
-0.032999251,
-0.0075443704,
-0.0014064375,
0.0116487732,
-0.0499870628,
-0.0176299121,
0.0380144604,
-0.0068095969,
-0.0451002046,
0.0376420803,
3.003909462e-34,
0.0024279461,
-0.0404074192,
0.0317416824,
-0.0178249851,
0.0344216339,
0.0198367611,
0.0039526066,
0.027291704,
-0.0065194382,
-0.0010688045,
-0.0400221534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06458v1 | Cultural Compass: Predicting Transfer Learning Success in Offensive Language Detection with Cultural Features | 2023-10-10T09:29:38 | 2023-10-10T09:29:38 | Li Zhou, Antonia Karamolegkou, Wenyu Chen, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing ubiquity of language technology necessitates a shift towards
considering cultural diversity in the machine learning realm, particularly for
subjective tasks that rely heavily on cultural nuances, such as Offensive
Language Detection (OLD). Current understanding underscores that these tasks
are substantially influenced by cultural values, however, a notable gap exists
in determining if cultural features can accurately predict the success of
cross-cultural transfer learning for such subjective tasks. Addressing this,
our study delves into the intersection of cultural features and transfer
learning effectiveness. The findings reveal that cultural value surveys indeed
possess a predictive power for cross-cultural transfer learning success in OLD
tasks and that it can be further improved using offensive word distance. Based
on these results, we advocate for the integration of cultural information into
datasets. Additionally, we recommend leveraging data sources rich in cultural
information, such as surveys, to enhance cultural adaptability. Our research
signifies a step forward in the quest for more inclusive, culturally sensitive
language technologies. | [
0.0329520889,
0.0771996006,
-0.0476292819,
-0.0003728964,
-0.0207772311,
0.0470307618,
0.070014134,
-0.0094660502,
0.0048864912,
-0.028315641,
-0.0280494671,
-0.0131445369,
-0.0039446829,
0.0081621148,
-0.0214399565,
-0.0286347941,
0.0307149906,
0.0526233315,
0.0280152075,
-0.0170248002,
0.0074229417,
0.0338270366,
0.0218948815,
0.0414026193,
-0.0493971333,
0.0055941609,
0.0463304333,
-0.0130395824,
0.0476050377,
-0.0005959035,
0.0525025465,
0.0208667405,
-0.010786958,
0.0203043297,
0.0000018126,
-0.0664902627,
-0.0243380461,
-0.0226006713,
0.0240857452,
-0.0339800119,
0.1276971698,
0.0031104677,
-0.0477215834,
0.0311356932,
-0.0270982906,
0.0139819877,
0.0791919455,
0.0274512284,
0.0163077787,
0.0512446165,
-0.0097142998,
0.0146502787,
-0.0615643933,
0.0151794776,
-0.0096174451,
0.0018182157,
0.0329728089,
0.0093885111,
-0.0701166615,
-0.0187769439,
-0.0435558073,
-0.0080745481,
-0.0085235611,
0.0111768413,
-0.0212792661,
-0.0345344096,
-0.061094936,
-0.0107862884,
0.0183870662,
0.038823504,
-0.0127743129,
0.0109556345,
-0.0191755798,
0.0032993304,
-0.0033143538,
-0.0088151852,
-0.0196819399,
-0.0199409854,
-0.0085888496,
0.019212639,
-0.0184894949,
0.0044149687,
0.0015988997,
0.0575655103,
0.0337642543,
0.025043169,
-0.0185969714,
-0.011379878,
0.0335918479,
0.0020823507,
0.0342629552,
0.0138631919,
0.0590094104,
-0.0135077666,
-0.0029943651,
0.0003613055,
-0.0294199064,
-0.0258581284,
0.0182987768,
-0.0432468802,
0.0213090945,
0.0536558814,
-0.0954872295,
0.0077398713,
-0.0065868124,
0.0617308244,
0.0202902425,
0.0158224963,
-0.0336251408,
-0.0378855057,
-0.0472772941,
0.0267298445,
0.0657175332,
-0.0263413824,
0.025473224,
0.0473075099,
-0.0567468479,
-0.0280201379,
-0.0552467071,
-0.0271136351,
-0.0494790003,
-0.0234678704,
-0.0271700993,
0.0224810056,
-0.0167250969,
0.0512992702,
-0.0395748354,
0.0114851575,
-0.0461538881,
-0.050900232,
0.0263087731,
0.0042055952,
-0.0214389544,
-0.0484879129,
0.0451018699,
0.0084936656,
-0.0082441419,
0.0025218742,
-0.0458221845,
0.0511261001,
-0.0152731063,
-0.0378608778,
0.0606935844,
-0.0659322366,
0.0205650963,
-0.0204088558,
-0.0047817128,
-0.0685578063,
-0.01015059,
0.0370205417,
-0.0654667318,
0.0358243808,
0.0209069606,
0.0029065565,
0.0453214496,
0.0085010072,
-0.0353334546,
0.0509203263,
0.0006647916,
0.0267346781,
0.0856379494,
-0.0369733311,
-0.0450784303,
0.019442264,
-0.0032755211,
0.0237709619,
-0.0824734196,
-0.0141316475,
-0.0109707406,
-0.0590726845,
0.0619253218,
0.0270370822,
0.0164698604,
-0.0277531948,
0.0239110012,
0.0714884102,
-0.025520267,
0.027466882,
0.0176780038,
0.0125464648,
-0.0429760627,
-0.0140493987,
-0.0611755252,
-0.0178308897,
-0.003779412,
-0.0653783977,
-0.0161335226,
0.1111668423,
-0.0237422921,
-0.0397609174,
-0.0116890874,
-0.0248607006,
0.0818028003,
-0.003135877,
0.0302762184,
0.0172128212,
0.0350911133,
-0.0467908941,
0.0654767826,
-0.0568655767,
-0.0033657646,
-0.0447063781,
0.0467810743,
0.0722441524,
-0.0189690068,
-0.0135810915,
0.0235456731,
-0.0464514121,
0.0438198671,
0.0113163423,
0.0518249571,
0.0018356354,
0.0173697937,
-0.034910135,
-0.0450720266,
0.0496880896,
-0.0094828922,
0.0310829058,
0.0512264296,
0.0666858703,
0.0085195508,
0.003468659,
-0.0412335545,
0.0252718572,
0.0012063049,
-0.0121834725,
0.0414866023,
0.0079268962,
0.0277456902,
0.0102551021,
-0.0075952848,
-0.0618529059,
-0.0402908325,
-0.0095454156,
-0.0104171243,
0.0149046807,
-0.0209661163,
0.0040782206,
0.0180097111,
-0.0363721251,
0.0041997484,
0.0463829674,
-0.0182575602,
0.0244553573,
0.047718253,
0.0213590674,
-0.0497037396,
-0.0277474355,
-0.0249849707,
-0.0501132384,
0.0737088174,
-0.0159859136,
0.0263817925,
-0.0044468306,
-0.0227744691,
-0.0291161351,
-0.0607508011,
0.0335583799,
0.0242506079,
-0.0530279279,
0.0362671055,
-0.0396071821,
0.0019105375,
0.0238799471,
0.0483269468,
-0.0408983007,
0.0352024324,
-0.0680153742,
-0.0104235904,
-0.0096429698,
-0.0257088374,
-0.0343951024,
-0.0161723178,
-0.0245450493,
-0.0092775906,
-0.0544742644,
-0.0141374134,
0.0319757536,
0.0496824086,
0.0103422152,
-0.0773636997,
-0.0127022332,
-0.0109519456,
-0.0461618043,
0.0077761882,
0.0177833121,
-0.0169076808,
-0.0345006548,
0.0121427514,
-0.0565825328,
-0.0458788425,
-0.0084795039,
-0.0083287647,
-0.0447637737,
-0.0042157634,
0.046369642,
0.0124077909,
0.0905627683,
0.0462733842,
0.0350623243,
0.0570004657,
-0.02927153,
-0.0221343692,
0.0038682478,
-0.0083572129,
0.0195160061,
0.0153410286,
-0.0755977482,
-0.0136800846,
0.0139609566,
0.0053458703,
-0.0155848125,
-0.0365909711,
0.023391543,
-0.047233168,
-0.0557265617,
-0.028685011,
-0.0257095303,
-0.0174089987,
0.0181753207,
-0.0084633278,
-0.0551213473,
0.0466994755,
0.0240534209,
0.0322609358,
-0.037021827,
-0.0224401671,
-0.0200248007,
0.0379036702,
-0.0252224766,
0.0346751362,
-0.0161283035,
-0.0106142284,
0.0138202626,
-0.0151215801,
0.0242739283,
-0.0552549884,
-0.0121467989,
-0.0231649354,
-0.0418076403,
-0.0049335412,
-0.0113025345,
-0.0418434255,
0.0136591159,
0.0106978975,
0.0054214015,
0.0017571307,
0.008973537,
0.0005770252,
-0.0060451962,
0.0430434309,
-0.0317036957,
0.0151075451,
0.0113320276,
0.0516744629,
-0.0562829003,
0.0315505117,
0.0466537438,
0.019629553,
0.0177051183,
-0.0274863932,
0.0315289423,
0.0417169929,
-0.0278477352,
0.0253908411,
0.050112348,
0.0417182408,
0.0253203847,
-0.0097207874,
-0.017846968,
0.0534777232,
0.0086076763,
0.0013353014,
0.0434623472,
0.0114956833,
-0.0082569607,
-0.0002987314,
-0.0314217322,
0.0034704485,
0.0064816508,
0.0218437742,
-0.0717423111,
-0.0054687709,
-0.0006815385,
0.0280030742,
-0.0802198723,
-0.0419043675,
-0.0211429466,
-0.0836956203,
0.0111874007,
-0.003114989,
-0.0644196644,
-0.0490246937,
-0.0051786755,
0.0385772362,
-0.024524169,
0.0434406921,
-0.0633625239,
0.0141795063,
-0.0336232185,
0.0256004818,
-0.0341317505,
-0.0299891103,
0.0497955903,
-0.018052835,
0.0304635707,
0.0591014512,
0.0672733113,
-0.0108963866,
-0.0377523415,
0.0096465601,
-0.017784005,
-0.0173936412,
-0.034323521,
0.0442150161,
0.0092209363,
-0.0213576872,
0.0234365873,
0.0145574342,
-0.0087684942,
-0.0180407111,
0.0413749777,
0.0371941216,
0.0386912338,
-0.0183206815,
-0.0488629527,
0.0092884041,
0.0118663311,
0.0746787116,
-0.0019031732,
-0.0749157444,
0.0119996406,
-0.0220308676,
-0.0412135646,
0.0274078101,
-0.0611966588,
0.0209892709,
-0.0686263442,
-0.0509596132,
-0.0563901737,
-0.0227157306,
0.0195909422,
0.017882159,
0.0227450579,
-0.0437973961,
-0.0364047587,
0.0089933062,
-0.0334268436,
0.0023660385,
-0.0100338375,
0.0509169847,
0.0011141563,
0.0083712302,
-0.0352181643,
-0.0188683644,
-0.0230662115,
-0.0200528484,
-0.0099885268,
-0.0219267514,
0.0887839347,
0.0699477568,
0.0027881279,
-0.0020382579,
-0.0040231878,
-0.0228098538,
0.0269627906,
0.0513021201,
-0.0037059204,
-0.0235906076,
0.0687133968,
0.0087564383,
-0.0094248997,
0.0183765069,
-0.0071649584,
0.0566263758,
0.0595468134,
-0.0418982767,
-0.0089561949,
-0.0181045365,
-0.0136092911,
0.0006581427,
0.0148114786,
-0.0111298505,
-0.0656343028,
-0.0278610736,
-0.0226349216,
0.0130067198,
-0.0193177722,
-0.0339609794,
-0.039134454,
0.0199829824,
0.0059301928,
-0.0259713251,
-0.0037031777,
-0.0094563859,
0.005490954,
-0.0620588921,
0.0480596051,
0.0184854213,
0.0822218135,
-0.0242056791,
0.0422603264,
-0.0443711504,
0.0154688237,
0.0452257991,
0.0117105925,
-0.0123852938,
0.0758639649,
0.0116706667,
0.0164881255,
0.0431554429,
0.0025213766,
0.0242620353,
0.0097322604,
-0.0061403993,
-0.0167398062,
-0.0177567601,
-0.073447682,
0.0578463636,
0.0139582045,
-0.0202847067,
-0.035721872,
0.0028387799,
0.0040898668,
-0.0492766052,
0.028649874,
0.0007542014,
-0.0201071501,
-0.0011536244,
0.0283088759,
-0.0790197551,
0.0029762266,
-0.0115233734,
-0.07261917,
-0.0032681322,
0.0012847652,
0.0698506385,
-0.0099597499,
0.0090797823,
0.0330048688,
-0.0432915054,
-0.0398397334,
-0.0130717941,
-0.0699453279,
0.0407945067,
-0.0116196768,
0.0214091465,
0.0968442187,
-0.0416715443,
-0.0112707615,
-0.0165485516,
-0.0334983841,
-0.0140340244,
-0.013377279,
-0.0099303909,
-5.439293011e-33,
-0.0226946156,
-0.0145958131,
-0.0041495827,
0.0233458579,
-0.0058301417,
-0.0466976613,
0.0248630121,
0.0072060484,
-0.0480189361,
0.0150888646,
0.0008652079,
-0.0008761442,
0.0099251745,
0.0105203902,
0.0232295021,
-0.0202253722,
0.0150255235,
0.0236200318,
-0.0435479432,
0.0027560894,
0.0575425141,
0.008662641,
0.0763319731,
-0.0976626426,
0.0285716262,
0.0642566681,
0.0110571738,
0.0067989258,
0.0501112528,
0.0461356789,
-0.0223617163,
0.0827378333,
0.0297498889,
-0.0343228914,
0.0110349618,
0.0192920547,
-0.0741677284,
-0.0262377746,
0.0005176357,
0.0163346361,
0.0852188021,
-0.0368607119,
0.0051156357,
-0.0149892978,
-0.0265668165,
-0.0231087338,
0.0526402071,
-0.0694426671,
0.0171801727,
-0.0366519317,
-0.0745429844,
0.0357912555,
-0.0250401516,
0.0269509722,
-0.0105588539,
0.0806072801,
-0.0079653542,
-0.0022653884,
-0.0377203934,
0.0137238717,
-0.0114018358,
-0.0166708641,
0.0426169038,
-0.0025217778,
0.0004737252,
0.0539020225,
0.0492351949,
0.016233515,
0.031397637,
-0.0048548486,
0.0617465451,
0.0101093389,
0.0037174062,
0.0774027556,
0.0161785297,
-0.0806330889,
-0.0241359472,
-0.0012903775,
0.0482707769,
0.0060284589,
0.0014036951,
-0.0087955566,
-0.0464758389,
-0.0418955982,
0.0171631239,
-0.0200847741,
0.0132364733,
-0.0517309383,
0.0434776247,
-0.0132466555,
-0.0334738828,
-0.0220776666,
0.0361734182,
-0.0022190656,
0.0008564823,
0.0063523753,
-0.0375561975,
-0.0371069387,
0.0373258144,
-0.0008951553,
-0.0824513361,
-0.0089197224,
-0.0117136277,
-0.0458499342,
0.0277807061,
-0.0050073876,
0.0849117413,
0.0541311242,
-0.0880406573,
0.0132844141,
-0.0029467274,
0.0421954654,
0.0050350497,
0.0373610221,
0.0036568709,
0.0313406065,
-0.0050597643,
-0.0220714509,
0.0538385771,
-0.0234474409,
-0.0331308581,
-0.0599320307,
-0.0308041647,
0.0023826899,
-0.0387161076,
-0.0196875967,
0.0001502966,
0.0065967408,
-0.0095469262,
-0.0407592021,
-0.0181853902,
-0.0283781923,
2.393e-7,
0.0083540576,
0.0204948243,
-0.0172490627,
0.0056885993,
-0.0112004979,
0.0193617884,
0.0048461207,
0.0347534753,
0.0647334382,
0.0475614145,
-0.0009433376,
0.035892386,
0.0517998263,
0.0859144703,
-0.0193429384,
-0.0348920152,
-0.0154650388,
0.0147034647,
-0.0417463556,
0.0154878711,
0.0088063329,
0.0459755026,
0.0486119092,
-0.0549949966,
-0.0310446545,
-0.0142411431,
-0.0000185628,
-0.0853497908,
0.0215503834,
-0.0548919626,
0.0482487082,
-0.0254436377,
0.0103345159,
0.0389408283,
-0.0012047681,
0.0113393078,
0.0579828098,
0.0452320874,
0.0393905044,
-0.0029248919,
0.001863189,
0.0312211961,
-0.0010739594,
-0.0480860174,
0.0548327006,
0.0157279763,
-0.0173829403,
-0.0427436568,
-0.0074709905,
-0.0210853312,
0.0724837855,
-0.0085301055,
-0.0021504667,
-0.0085433768,
0.065911375,
0.0248701964,
-0.0215287004,
-0.0181213748,
0.0150434161,
0.0089097703,
0.0018335206,
-0.0497728288,
0.0206470378,
-0.001992729,
-0.0402333438,
0.0448653735,
0.0604114123,
1.706266096e-34,
0.0040894141,
-0.0178433619,
0.0117366854,
-0.0497266613,
0.0348688327,
0.0191174485,
0.0460257828,
-0.0009420635,
0.018791005,
0.0146979019,
0.0115658455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06452v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06452v3 | Understanding the Effects of RLHF on LLM Generalisation and Diversity | 2023-10-10T09:25:44 | 2024-02-19T14:39:07 | Robert Kirk, Ishita Mediratta, Christoforos Nalmpantis, Jelena Luketina, Eric Hambro, Edward Grefenstette, Roberta Raileanu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) fine-tuned with reinforcement learning from
human feedback (RLHF) have been used in some of the most widely deployed AI
models to date, such as OpenAI's ChatGPT or Anthropic's Claude. While there has
been significant work developing these methods, our understanding of the
benefits and downsides of each stage in RLHF is still limited. To fill this
gap, we present an extensive analysis of how each stage of the process (i.e.
supervised fine-tuning (SFT), reward modelling, and RLHF) affects two key
properties: out-of-distribution (OOD) generalisation and output diversity. OOD
generalisation is crucial given the wide range of real-world scenarios in which
these models are being used, while output diversity refers to the model's
ability to generate varied outputs and is important for a variety of use cases.
We perform our analysis across two base models on both summarisation and
instruction following tasks, the latter being highly relevant for current LLM
use cases. We find that RLHF generalises better than SFT to new inputs,
particularly as the distribution shift between train and test becomes larger.
However, RLHF significantly reduces output diversity compared to SFT across a
variety of measures, implying a tradeoff in current LLM fine-tuning methods
between generalisation and diversity. Our results provide guidance on which
fine-tuning method should be used depending on the application, and show that
more research is needed to improve the tradeoff between generalisation and
diversity. | [
0.0508523956,
0.0082956646,
-0.0086741727,
-0.001673745,
-0.0325635895,
0.0129339425,
-0.0665865019,
0.0013737925,
-0.0459010266,
-0.0443514884,
-0.0646500289,
-0.0326626226,
0.0122104296,
0.0072411196,
0.0137833385,
-0.0768074766,
0.0383090526,
-0.076714009,
-0.0268423371,
-0.0171439443,
-0.0226625875,
-0.010088684,
0.0120368004,
0.0757877529,
0.0249424223,
0.0168538224,
-0.0113776736,
0.0123553732,
0.0413497686,
0.0127407471,
-0.0093452232,
0.0391839668,
0.0430807844,
0.0190954003,
0.0000019791,
-0.0571379997,
0.0231403802,
0.0088352496,
-0.0021953073,
0.0036778462,
0.0174032059,
0.0120558711,
-0.0062512956,
0.0222671852,
0.0138367424,
0.0031248098,
0.042908892,
0.0405314863,
0.030066181,
0.111145325,
0.0252106041,
-0.0241138823,
0.0364055447,
-0.0394165367,
0.0228730235,
-0.0072591105,
0.0109219505,
0.0018631589,
0.0465673879,
-0.0153249074,
-0.0460008159,
0.0041117985,
0.0453244261,
0.0143195884,
-0.0046412749,
0.0473073944,
-0.0263946243,
-0.013442494,
-0.0301978365,
0.0526559018,
-0.07631661,
0.0080244895,
-0.0026238204,
-0.0162213352,
0.0370297655,
0.0025222201,
-0.045404233,
0.0824370906,
0.0098271482,
0.0350171588,
0.0036556309,
-0.0144490963,
0.028759677,
0.0188912619,
-0.0378090702,
0.0357214473,
-0.0090769902,
-0.0454742126,
0.0101599516,
0.0126241492,
-0.0396586992,
-0.0487567261,
-0.033183638,
0.0603177883,
-0.0440309197,
-0.0008246326,
-0.044151634,
-0.0058105034,
0.0158673525,
-0.004558662,
0.0593567044,
0.0432874225,
-0.0400635675,
0.0105056819,
0.0047987262,
0.0492476262,
0.0006474216,
0.0629331991,
-0.0486036874,
0.0125930049,
-0.0567449629,
0.0008127858,
0.0011499625,
0.0593580082,
-0.0191771872,
-0.0190316178,
-0.0453855507,
0.0384793431,
-0.0300973449,
-0.003915769,
0.0324769206,
-0.0039590285,
-0.0695077404,
0.0273216534,
-0.0236824527,
0.0147530278,
-0.0469931662,
0.0081381537,
0.0474269539,
-0.0389256552,
-0.0117474999,
0.0061994982,
-0.0190432444,
-0.00004347,
0.0092434483,
0.0784787908,
-0.0228971802,
-0.0372810401,
-0.0229140017,
-0.0001643308,
-0.022451641,
-0.0826328322,
0.0118742958,
-0.0692392811,
-0.0163025614,
-0.0189702343,
-0.0045310687,
-0.0021845542,
-0.0129532898,
-0.0140513685,
-0.0425949916,
-0.0040844376,
0.0195961427,
0.0399380773,
0.042599652,
-0.0139610702,
-0.014148484,
0.0894149318,
0.0578877702,
0.0190338455,
-0.0062625245,
0.0144816656,
0.0310703143,
0.050066404,
-0.0136741754,
0.0278176069,
-0.0037524612,
-0.0153691145,
-0.0112853469,
0.0325000025,
0.0527932867,
0.054405313,
-0.0490149371,
0.0405383185,
0.048803173,
0.0512556806,
0.0404841974,
-0.0255381204,
0.048024375,
-0.0034391226,
0.004920451,
0.0620220937,
-0.0582969487,
0.0282143708,
-0.0090477876,
0.0515119024,
0.0361462608,
0.0333668068,
-0.0435858034,
-0.0470960103,
-0.0047663124,
-0.0176603924,
0.0235234257,
0.0185426846,
0.0767591745,
0.0013243662,
-0.0232461095,
0.0024458105,
0.0607628524,
-0.0281204004,
0.0207948014,
-0.0967234448,
0.048651658,
0.0487424731,
0.0364464186,
-0.0492895879,
-0.0042834966,
-0.0097243208,
-0.0203470495,
0.0526783839,
0.0489548407,
0.001478073,
-0.0051841033,
-0.0546601899,
-0.0387935974,
-0.0162098464,
0.0111602293,
0.0428043343,
0.0194846615,
-0.0164393317,
-0.0116452025,
-0.0159811676,
-0.0744527206,
0.0339446589,
0.0033506823,
-0.0010311438,
0.0089630643,
0.0064147701,
0.0125993481,
0.005158009,
-0.037739411,
0.0262546409,
0.0055832155,
-0.0087967794,
-0.0068642045,
-0.0249864291,
-0.0532880202,
-0.006682409,
0.0022747284,
-0.0261618868,
0.0039126622,
0.0392313525,
-0.0412564389,
-0.031625405,
0.0292234179,
-0.0155978072,
0.0049848924,
-0.0201516207,
0.0227982886,
-0.0228638332,
-0.0124379499,
-0.0591243804,
0.0441626869,
-0.0202222858,
-0.0249135587,
-0.0092896093,
0.0236497354,
-0.0168814827,
-0.0668282136,
-0.0378271677,
0.0363553055,
-0.0043887496,
0.0462319478,
0.0361132286,
0.0524179041,
-0.0370186418,
-0.0484718047,
-0.0615710244,
-0.00045922,
-0.0483779795,
0.0019857227,
0.0127294408,
0.0014719733,
-0.013186316,
-0.0023279721,
-0.0194452833,
-0.0310500488,
0.0425153859,
0.0235342663,
0.0157809332,
0.0306330416,
-0.0230995622,
-0.0340441987,
-0.0327677354,
0.0340872146,
0.0277566388,
-0.0288234521,
0.0423117355,
-0.0739089325,
0.0345406607,
-0.0200284384,
0.0240018945,
-0.0135028111,
-0.0179229993,
0.0355917253,
-0.0110021764,
0.0407935791,
0.0782516375,
0.0139903482,
0.0305237528,
0.0486507528,
0.0234451815,
-0.0509404317,
0.026385501,
-0.034511663,
-0.0710576773,
-0.0225379281,
-0.0027031691,
0.0086465999,
0.0479995459,
0.005403101,
0.0053196326,
-0.0880989507,
-0.0228472296,
-0.0140456464,
-0.0647251159,
-0.0384871736,
-0.0212943871,
-0.0557949059,
0.0196440835,
-0.0305418894,
-0.0552595071,
0.0546590127,
0.0106183793,
0.0411239713,
-0.0636373907,
-0.029388193,
-0.061681211,
0.0241524205,
-0.0079829609,
0.0097422181,
-0.0057921833,
-0.0180889852,
-0.0796396881,
-0.0390376002,
-0.0091729918,
-0.0090865269,
0.1112314388,
-0.0322139598,
-0.025722459,
-0.0108116055,
-0.0381205454,
-0.030692365,
-0.0236291755,
0.0087287761,
0.0264518466,
0.0166965947,
-0.0114981355,
-0.015059107,
0.0076688314,
0.0409514569,
0.0363513157,
-0.0507605448,
-0.0075751655,
-0.0093899155,
0.0086405603,
0.0663687512,
0.0266280342,
0.0156775191,
-0.0633486658,
-0.0031930609,
-0.0041527161,
0.0428066589,
-0.0109105175,
0.0043424177,
0.0220860541,
0.0049475837,
-0.0381135419,
-0.0215564165,
0.0775298402,
0.0585048236,
-0.0430897065,
-0.0359523743,
0.0798852742,
0.000209737,
-0.0560972355,
0.0296753366,
-0.0167857856,
0.0692706481,
0.0143040614,
0.0366538428,
-0.0502520204,
-0.0043927766,
0.0054484089,
0.0324994475,
-0.0126822647,
0.0094949193,
0.0242621936,
-0.1408831477,
0.030791888,
0.0181155391,
-0.1166743711,
-0.0405337401,
0.0155578544,
0.0111711938,
0.0189532246,
0.0365090221,
0.020721456,
-0.0185008384,
-0.0087494291,
0.0624301136,
-0.0070459414,
-0.0588561967,
0.00846864,
-0.0563820042,
0.0354413837,
0.1130470037,
-0.0186819341,
-0.0155863436,
-0.0021948025,
0.0439562052,
0.0106453979,
0.0534893721,
0.0088691218,
0.0252661221,
-0.003956378,
0.0002948068,
-0.0092907753,
0.0341418944,
0.0114165545,
0.0054105069,
0.0039521498,
0.0513651073,
-0.0182570778,
-0.0322914571,
-0.0265282262,
-0.0079418253,
0.0127963694,
0.0644506663,
0.0354197212,
-0.0568624064,
-0.0398793593,
-0.0232452471,
-0.0370294899,
-0.0498051383,
-0.0088056028,
0.0333117023,
-0.0215802453,
-0.0443594642,
-0.0472513251,
-0.0533556379,
0.0010643534,
-0.0000010408,
0.0098493109,
-0.0127251996,
-0.0059038606,
0.0387052782,
0.0328741781,
0.0348679088,
-0.0320827998,
0.0082979407,
-0.0709994584,
-0.0345931165,
0.0001048971,
-0.0697569102,
-0.0018054548,
-0.023649808,
-0.0796355456,
-0.0665216297,
0.0018620578,
0.0723044276,
0.0279918164,
0.0670067146,
0.0308631193,
-0.0637716278,
0.0517383888,
0.0288593397,
-0.0048302002,
0.0704003721,
0.016757261,
0.0194692537,
-0.0082263406,
0.0355964229,
-0.0832747892,
0.0142519828,
0.0490504354,
0.0469233133,
0.0181530155,
-0.029659275,
-0.0172021054,
-0.0091867046,
0.0177167691,
-0.016743971,
-0.0269484427,
-0.0327317417,
-0.0081761144,
0.0143570043,
-0.0100001013,
-0.031346757,
-0.0104646329,
0.0209638439,
0.0202113818,
0.0076050046,
0.0078699971,
0.0262522008,
0.0574782379,
-0.0391929932,
-0.0154419811,
-0.002371076,
0.0117846783,
0.0063557699,
0.0552686043,
-0.0363103338,
0.0240798015,
-0.0316243619,
0.0222376622,
0.0414245389,
0.0805125609,
0.0299328193,
0.008503194,
-0.0095508667,
0.0242249928,
-0.0962891579,
-0.0547177494,
-0.0180841554,
0.0650683865,
0.0428500883,
0.0235096309,
0.0296280086,
-0.0139157865,
-0.0038358166,
-0.0320564434,
0.003083278,
-0.0211428627,
0.0167806707,
0.0133340126,
0.0233945232,
-0.0000573967,
-0.0381406806,
0.0750014856,
-0.0104964282,
0.0385849811,
-0.0223510265,
0.0372028016,
-0.0234164596,
-0.0154721541,
0.022634346,
0.0184746422,
-0.0118494164,
-0.0068684239,
-0.0553068519,
-0.037296012,
-0.0160034262,
0.0342210494,
0.0371769704,
-0.0284781065,
0.0576540604,
0.0310698468,
-0.0288750529,
-0.0049285013,
-0.0351302512,
-0.0507984571,
-0.0046557495,
0.0027561735,
-0.0152009744,
-6.238003218e-33,
-0.0394581594,
0.0147975292,
0.0172430743,
-0.0102845263,
-0.0308232084,
-0.0104975635,
-0.0166863836,
0.0121561456,
-0.0265196171,
-0.0205427688,
-0.0173612759,
-0.0113198655,
0.0115262698,
0.026706269,
0.0366952978,
-0.0237244982,
0.0406321809,
-0.0106791081,
-0.0629563481,
0.0124550052,
0.0194578189,
0.0063582705,
0.0502659529,
-0.0017685571,
0.0093111154,
-0.0080281803,
-0.0256216321,
0.0214642249,
-0.0464496091,
0.0662276521,
0.0023205348,
0.053357143,
0.0242529474,
-0.0545880832,
-0.041738186,
0.0150020448,
-0.035370335,
-0.0490417331,
0.0292231124,
-0.0256543402,
-0.0492399633,
-0.0294944905,
0.0624856129,
0.0138317719,
-0.0518372841,
-0.0180743895,
0.0153105455,
-0.0249821767,
-0.0419288352,
-0.0139065934,
-0.05452393,
0.0071463399,
0.0150887081,
-0.0461150818,
-0.0296429787,
0.0089436537,
-0.0383493453,
0.0008554062,
-0.0132682938,
0.032599166,
0.086214669,
0.0011697413,
0.0671720952,
0.0630951524,
0.0130595211,
0.0220257882,
0.0060194335,
0.0243011154,
-0.0178480614,
-0.0597933494,
0.0430842564,
0.033244364,
-0.0040290151,
0.0218082797,
0.0234230775,
0.0217107274,
-0.0417225435,
0.0184229817,
-0.0014343451,
0.0368857868,
0.0502643958,
0.0378937684,
-0.0665408894,
-0.0321683437,
-0.038583193,
0.0294685028,
-0.0142112495,
-0.0440411158,
0.04604844,
0.0355301015,
-0.0020870951,
-0.037550129,
0.0353331566,
-0.0215876587,
0.0387356989,
0.0085460218,
-0.0543278344,
0.0284114573,
-0.0145699922,
-0.0339142196,
-0.0668739676,
-0.0426391475,
0.0283102598,
-0.0150082447,
-0.0264935121,
0.0229240861,
0.036708381,
0.038338773,
-0.0241175424,
0.0119886138,
-0.0054617333,
0.0417021997,
0.0310826395,
0.0452929661,
0.0173319485,
-0.013667047,
-0.0053002848,
0.0744440034,
-0.0040681688,
-0.042451039,
-0.0277893543,
0.0117958533,
0.001964821,
0.0041065342,
-0.0348982103,
0.0347811691,
-0.0195571389,
-0.0029058047,
0.0264486615,
-0.0268717948,
-0.0330714881,
0.0157040656,
2.681e-7,
0.0209832862,
0.0024740763,
0.0325528309,
0.0361943319,
0.0018052988,
0.031356819,
-0.0230394602,
0.0143529298,
0.0362725407,
0.0241671428,
0.020210702,
0.065629296,
0.024781486,
-0.0236126017,
-0.0385028161,
0.0022793913,
-0.0929117054,
0.0237091556,
-0.0383432731,
-0.0191488713,
-0.0158493668,
0.0871972889,
0.0188982096,
-0.016548574,
-0.0048472295,
0.009643889,
0.0502022319,
-0.0461780615,
-0.0265389178,
0.0216299854,
0.0048135701,
0.0316775292,
0.0010805012,
0.0044860421,
0.0295123532,
0.0224025678,
0.0065675955,
0.0391463153,
-0.0209117997,
-0.0306834839,
0.0137159787,
0.0169597548,
0.0179061312,
-0.0673620626,
0.0348672941,
-0.0673201457,
-0.0157755502,
-0.0487914495,
0.0416204818,
-0.0372741297,
0.0022275464,
-0.0623321421,
0.0083184121,
0.0110466592,
-0.0038710942,
0.0186539032,
0.0012439878,
-0.0782376602,
-0.0177584793,
0.0395214185,
-0.0436005779,
-0.071629256,
-0.0473551229,
0.0315368026,
-0.0058000996,
-0.0590873025,
-0.0215958003,
2.507591641e-34,
0.0466703065,
-0.0065359976,
0.0054950323,
-0.0042128027,
0.0203150585,
0.0101496195,
-0.0405782089,
0.0140669001,
0.0342786051,
-0.0574226603,
-0.0473714918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06450v2 | Constructive Large Language Models Alignment with Diverse Feedback | 2023-10-10T09:20:14 | 2023-10-11T07:04:04 | Tianshu Yu, Ting-En Lin, Yuchuan Wu, Min Yang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent research on large language models (LLMs), there has been a growing
emphasis on aligning these models with human values to reduce the impact of
harmful content. However, current alignment methods often rely solely on
singular forms of human feedback, such as preferences, annotated labels, or
natural language critiques, overlooking the potential advantages of combining
these feedback types. This limitation leads to suboptimal performance, even
when ample training data is available. In this paper, we introduce Constructive
and Diverse Feedback (CDF) as a novel method to enhance LLM alignment, inspired
by constructivist learning theory. Our approach involves collecting three
distinct types of feedback tailored to problems of varying difficulty levels
within the training dataset. Specifically, we exploit critique feedback for
easy problems, refinement feedback for medium problems, and preference feedback
for hard problems. By training our model with this diversified feedback, we
achieve enhanced alignment performance while using less training data. To
assess the effectiveness of CDF, we evaluate it against previous methods in
three downstream tasks: question answering, dialog generation, and text
summarization. Experimental results demonstrate that CDF achieves superior
performance even with a smaller training dataset. | [
0.0489789732,
0.0659585819,
0.0075883977,
0.0100329788,
-0.0371973217,
0.0115995472,
-0.0393002853,
-0.0524370931,
-0.0200723633,
-0.032715302,
-0.0290343426,
-0.0587960556,
-0.0179396253,
-0.0024263661,
0.0216041226,
-0.0448257178,
0.0457166098,
-0.0113224713,
0.012324647,
-0.0202849675,
0.0422509611,
0.0089928862,
0.0045738975,
0.0380970016,
-0.0008513781,
-0.0213130265,
-0.0187135153,
0.0135272173,
0.0311769396,
0.0020833143,
0.0411486998,
0.0648597553,
0.0193270128,
0.0528952256,
0.0000017372,
-0.0589755289,
-0.0069278874,
-0.0153031209,
-0.0177875236,
0.0038198971,
0.0480515175,
-0.0001162802,
0.0097996909,
0.0222717691,
-0.0213767085,
-0.0173981842,
0.0498137027,
0.0626388714,
0.0806980953,
0.0645748228,
0.0153015247,
-0.0166580789,
-0.0000084818,
-0.0081520351,
-0.0085993158,
-0.011912073,
0.0194079746,
0.0478560366,
-0.003642923,
0.0275655072,
0.0057395324,
0.0205021631,
-0.004194844,
-0.0167389698,
0.0491601862,
0.0065206736,
-0.0165463518,
-0.0430203266,
0.0024098579,
0.088565819,
0.0186281726,
-0.0279629845,
-0.0248258859,
-0.0139548434,
0.0310725607,
-0.0186828803,
-0.0452607311,
0.0189895965,
-0.0172765423,
0.0080870576,
0.0058915825,
-0.0295159183,
0.0093975877,
0.0365070254,
0.0307020079,
0.0176385045,
0.0262844097,
-0.048008237,
-0.017906215,
0.0176950637,
-0.0288025606,
-0.0426720157,
-0.0170648266,
0.0154932598,
-0.0740958229,
0.0242651291,
-0.0737012774,
0.0076514645,
0.0189820789,
-0.0418076515,
0.0367951393,
0.0282158516,
0.0130082676,
0.0594815239,
0.008001118,
0.0327131152,
-0.0368575267,
0.0216173958,
-0.0646998435,
-0.0077451067,
-0.029155748,
-0.0268582348,
-0.0101139769,
0.0309200902,
0.001818303,
-0.016926121,
-0.0498462468,
0.0538845286,
-0.0297792479,
0.0424155667,
-0.000657924,
0.0266949795,
-0.0285702739,
-0.0040162369,
-0.0561032072,
0.0587214828,
-0.0371932946,
0.0164642651,
0.0255398154,
-0.0151453568,
-0.0095366333,
0.0322585814,
-0.0112882843,
-0.0317943208,
-0.0142046185,
0.0114807403,
-0.0332818404,
0.0133601967,
-0.0205504615,
-0.0077366694,
-0.0290191472,
-0.0402904898,
-0.0272821356,
-0.081251286,
0.0194063131,
-0.0143479081,
-0.0347543471,
-0.0479846373,
0.0042604795,
0.0120683238,
-0.0163986869,
0.0616998747,
-0.0200950429,
0.0168146361,
0.0590910651,
-0.0056748171,
-0.0085351793,
0.050633058,
0.0019897402,
0.0016764085,
0.012099755,
-0.0090542156,
-0.0071293581,
0.0272901505,
0.0068043089,
0.0224681944,
-0.0217058603,
0.0322153978,
0.001300986,
0.0535170026,
0.0168214291,
0.0712795407,
-0.0230960585,
0.0223700572,
0.0874262154,
0.0044503263,
0.0182890762,
0.0163492411,
0.0008045557,
0.0420751162,
-0.0021369734,
0.0176233873,
-0.053352654,
0.0265023001,
-0.0481538959,
0.0482330099,
0.0410201885,
0.0391449258,
-0.0184858032,
-0.0601498112,
-0.0238205455,
0.0054933848,
0.0209253188,
0.0118400594,
0.0181386825,
0.0154755441,
-0.0347695798,
0.008812231,
0.0361650884,
-0.0301344302,
0.0140181566,
-0.018538516,
0.0799956918,
0.0481620394,
0.036151085,
-0.0335626863,
-0.0780634284,
-0.0248486996,
0.0135485604,
0.0489295311,
0.0816727728,
-0.0320335999,
-0.0543979779,
-0.0570508465,
-0.0398057476,
-0.006352304,
0.0070897457,
-0.0035760482,
0.0368197449,
-0.0491196141,
0.0099694617,
0.0135845542,
-0.0939208716,
0.0340584256,
0.0386540741,
-0.0176915899,
-0.0254101548,
0.0259313621,
0.0428368971,
0.0226682313,
-0.0037881248,
0.0170756467,
0.0057320669,
-0.0204424988,
-0.0530930832,
0.0175819378,
-0.0696612298,
-0.0306682587,
0.0601959378,
-0.0301620476,
-0.030687267,
0.0163182449,
-0.0384896547,
-0.0400414541,
0.0091387806,
-0.052318193,
-0.0321996212,
-0.0247132871,
0.0424358509,
-0.011187396,
-0.0372737125,
-0.0862435251,
0.0761971399,
0.032010477,
0.0046162456,
0.0202562846,
0.0083465856,
-0.0032953327,
-0.0074215299,
-0.0453638285,
0.0064079263,
0.0042366353,
0.0337325521,
0.068171747,
0.0065801591,
-0.0646588951,
-0.0461573526,
-0.0909971967,
0.0195479039,
-0.0110576246,
0.0152121251,
0.0411710143,
0.0032296311,
0.0098075559,
0.0104658613,
-0.0889190659,
-0.0393879041,
0.0283652749,
0.0094328076,
0.0564513169,
-0.0024183276,
-0.014108343,
-0.0530634075,
0.0119077992,
-0.0223586019,
0.0000581083,
0.0020474193,
0.0136023369,
-0.0494884439,
0.0132851927,
-0.0374172665,
0.0096338494,
0.0065959683,
-0.0274290722,
0.0061540771,
0.0351122543,
0.0549448133,
0.074777782,
0.0476455465,
0.0149276527,
0.0297487285,
0.0392479151,
-0.066355966,
0.0085872933,
-0.0322420746,
-0.0481162295,
-0.0314149596,
-0.0368953571,
-0.0053559369,
0.071033068,
0.0096173678,
0.0060186996,
-0.0800671428,
0.0607875697,
-0.0289306603,
-0.0062712338,
-0.0257819742,
-0.0480212644,
-0.0234218631,
0.0012156529,
-0.0531805605,
-0.0340817943,
0.1139762998,
-0.0176821612,
0.0143351192,
-0.0466105975,
-0.004695538,
-0.0435072258,
0.0054249782,
-0.0008583409,
0.0444341712,
0.0155364117,
-0.0061591752,
-0.0863832235,
-0.0048224605,
0.0773542225,
-0.0465575121,
0.0828110054,
-0.0485524349,
-0.0070360512,
-0.0206651539,
-0.0683575198,
-0.0755086839,
-0.0443650335,
0.0016394551,
0.0152309192,
0.0400493965,
0.0069525279,
-0.0270595271,
0.0002265703,
0.0276694782,
0.0013574357,
-0.0335295126,
-0.0005490062,
-0.0210772958,
0.0217516776,
0.0956351683,
0.0399534889,
0.0143937133,
-0.0327889696,
0.0210902486,
0.038518928,
0.0087498324,
-0.0024293526,
-0.0172303412,
-0.0089270445,
0.0271452237,
-0.03269694,
0.0134356078,
-0.001991932,
0.0875248909,
-0.0171530358,
-0.0093201827,
0.1115366146,
0.0248401575,
-0.0387606435,
-0.0126801543,
-0.031451948,
0.0508900583,
0.0368334688,
0.0220387597,
-0.0457747802,
-0.0224631205,
-0.0121576199,
0.0311582964,
-0.0213251431,
-0.0079705156,
0.0142792612,
-0.1461044848,
-0.0076879463,
0.0423901416,
-0.0352310352,
-0.0104839122,
0.0090546347,
0.0017658425,
-0.0149905756,
0.020688761,
0.0220567845,
0.0102805234,
-0.0103719411,
0.0578696169,
-0.0057440982,
-0.0286624059,
-0.0267549399,
-0.0498548336,
0.0732027888,
0.034158729,
0.0060102032,
-0.0002139748,
0.011428209,
0.0475824885,
0.0088735847,
-0.0143728191,
0.0195889287,
0.0140199373,
-0.0155277774,
-0.0018259011,
-0.0372325517,
0.0685656518,
-0.0014693137,
-0.0033057707,
0.0223285109,
0.0611099303,
0.0134731494,
0.029419221,
-0.0315962955,
0.0103802113,
-0.0111387186,
0.0717716664,
0.0214991402,
-0.0584197789,
0.0005279488,
-0.0251136236,
-0.0322359465,
-0.019884076,
-0.0234792531,
0.0304570533,
-0.0030723496,
0.0246102195,
-0.0739622936,
-0.0349386185,
0.0105398661,
0.0224079788,
0.0303643588,
-0.0149710588,
0.0039497884,
-0.0195653997,
-0.0130432257,
0.0550813489,
-0.0274430793,
-0.0001002763,
-0.0463237613,
-0.0119174747,
-0.0005513648,
-0.0572259501,
-0.010893493,
-0.0048333523,
-0.089572221,
-0.0946688652,
-0.0398292802,
0.0502668992,
0.018886758,
0.0740078464,
-0.0131365918,
-0.064921774,
-0.0033219904,
0.006600468,
0.0036391483,
-0.0018417366,
-0.0046786298,
0.0192667004,
-0.0069700796,
0.0222313851,
-0.0413151681,
-0.0199964829,
0.0198816005,
0.0451348051,
-0.0219734758,
-0.0354907401,
0.0595102459,
0.0308880825,
-0.0072369361,
-0.0188252944,
-0.025617132,
-0.0393983647,
0.0052328999,
-0.0057110218,
-0.0837112218,
-0.0121834492,
0.0016400696,
0.029823605,
-0.0162729789,
0.008007938,
0.0043609296,
-0.0091037443,
0.0971386805,
-0.0593397617,
-0.0051501505,
0.0192962866,
-0.0204903223,
0.0183059257,
0.0023108935,
-0.065008752,
0.0144699747,
0.0032414859,
0.042898193,
-0.0009379713,
0.0797850266,
0.0353767127,
0.0102634318,
0.0114666075,
0.0074995472,
-0.0365879275,
-0.0392406806,
-0.041671209,
0.0121775884,
0.0283160508,
-0.0134910438,
0.0493167527,
-0.0201412868,
-0.0205123015,
-0.0185711253,
0.0370212048,
-0.0145839509,
-0.0365971848,
0.0576928854,
0.0453450121,
-0.0085373567,
-0.0148964534,
0.05200864,
-0.0034781266,
0.0169742573,
-0.0367859639,
0.0039058458,
-0.0526226982,
-0.0366333053,
0.0417763852,
0.0210530218,
-0.0394011587,
-0.0013504052,
-0.0364319645,
-0.0299329739,
0.0090340609,
0.0167967062,
-0.0157050136,
-0.0217321422,
0.0427244939,
0.0514169671,
-0.0433410406,
-0.0418790169,
-0.0277217869,
-0.0006716165,
0.0080081122,
0.0126602948,
-0.0259667616,
-5.980460488e-33,
-0.0300926846,
-0.0180065315,
0.0182525627,
-0.0340726227,
-0.0700316131,
-0.0215088706,
-0.0020846881,
0.0451395139,
-0.0160422642,
0.0033535911,
0.0021850099,
-0.0097260233,
-0.0102831833,
0.0395966507,
0.0156622082,
-0.0232263058,
0.042370934,
0.0121280942,
-0.0590560846,
0.0097589083,
0.0103602381,
-0.0069852532,
0.0334699564,
-0.0362392999,
0.0519546345,
-0.0141724795,
-0.0220253877,
0.0401790366,
-0.0064933486,
0.0871219411,
0.0013901992,
0.042991437,
0.0225578211,
-0.0243864562,
0.0007174661,
0.0260762945,
-0.0304377638,
0.0146444207,
0.0726894736,
0.0186098404,
-0.0182036199,
-0.0481543094,
0.0369106121,
-0.0129762022,
-0.0126440879,
-0.0000431761,
0.035923142,
-0.0466476642,
-0.0395499729,
-0.0102842757,
-0.0891169757,
0.0195469391,
-0.0331469141,
-0.026374653,
-0.0412265919,
0.0574551895,
-0.0006833512,
0.0194045249,
-0.0416074507,
0.0229689237,
0.0022642119,
0.0326742828,
0.07970386,
0.0574715137,
0.0010232353,
0.0528400764,
-0.0153011885,
-0.0007734845,
-0.0359647609,
-0.0351403803,
-0.0114768501,
0.0060328622,
0.0386370011,
0.0900084004,
-0.0144272381,
0.0233754907,
-0.0419862345,
0.0066156154,
-0.0178050343,
0.0410573483,
0.055421479,
0.0138288671,
-0.0473841317,
-0.0091986367,
-0.0782562569,
0.0072678523,
-0.0348329134,
-0.0009097315,
0.0114416014,
0.0225009043,
-0.0526317358,
-0.0456015393,
0.0104591884,
-0.0361698605,
-0.0080922423,
0.0216306187,
-0.0283323899,
0.0179122332,
-0.0280189849,
0.0235327687,
-0.0520820022,
-0.0164310187,
0.0008698756,
0.003643655,
-0.0020662094,
0.0359321497,
0.0458352715,
-0.0122982739,
-0.0489388295,
0.0291835926,
-0.03476483,
0.0088067064,
-0.0387613624,
0.0177117381,
0.0587809607,
0.0123692611,
-0.0171411298,
0.0588250719,
0.0259248018,
0.0062815067,
-0.0412325934,
-0.0327292494,
0.0033836516,
0.0058540059,
-0.0225827787,
0.0154175702,
0.0084632002,
-0.0024034136,
0.0083950832,
-0.0466972068,
-0.0060605998,
0.0124017056,
2.457e-7,
0.0086444058,
0.0474139974,
0.0375889093,
0.001580548,
-0.0094951726,
0.0584383756,
0.0027587875,
0.0169298165,
0.0218722392,
-0.0048913234,
0.0326369181,
0.0207342356,
0.0734933838,
0.0071415766,
-0.0720638782,
-0.0293724518,
-0.0792981982,
0.0060822438,
-0.0459197313,
-0.0011199135,
0.0699446276,
0.1090511903,
-0.0074009746,
0.0074516805,
0.008867071,
-0.0258661825,
0.0801616758,
-0.0286499113,
-0.0575300902,
0.049166441,
0.0337132998,
-0.0193524361,
0.0038120749,
-0.0019466158,
0.0183717441,
0.0190042555,
0.0189635009,
0.065721944,
0.0071583153,
-0.0163723007,
-0.0404106975,
0.0070652114,
0.0143462522,
-0.0575686544,
0.0362991802,
-0.0750962943,
-0.0281486958,
-0.0339584723,
-0.0147399744,
-0.0187578108,
0.0418691076,
-0.030847393,
-0.0004950322,
0.0045895381,
0.0275723934,
0.0150291463,
-0.0109072868,
-0.0555760376,
-0.0283953454,
0.0040440895,
-0.0319897048,
-0.0563903935,
-0.0055710515,
0.0254678633,
0.0096072126,
-0.0350284539,
0.0288932361,
2.264908306e-34,
0.0453283899,
-0.0310001299,
0.0474504568,
0.0177168474,
0.0284219738,
0.0129434988,
-0.0049388008,
-0.0014011011,
0.0278072506,
-0.0819168836,
-0.0081276651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06436v1 | MemSum-DQA: Adapting An Efficient Long Document Extractive Summarizer for Document Question Answering | 2023-10-10T09:06:08 | 2023-10-10T09:06:08 | Nianlong Gu, Yingqiang Gao, Richard H. R. Hahnloser | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce MemSum-DQA, an efficient system for document question answering
(DQA) that leverages MemSum, a long document extractive summarizer. By
prefixing each text block in the parsed document with the provided question and
question type, MemSum-DQA selectively extracts text blocks as answers from
documents. On full-document answering tasks, this approach yields a 9%
improvement in exact match accuracy over prior state-of-the-art baselines.
Notably, MemSum-DQA excels in addressing questions related to
child-relationship understanding, underscoring the potential of extractive
summarization techniques for DQA tasks. | [
0.0158695243,
0.0203493424,
-0.0029152145,
0.0376342796,
-0.0093378136,
0.035927996,
-0.0073553859,
-0.0216671508,
-0.0018184987,
-0.0274203252,
0.0231619608,
-0.0340244807,
-0.025064623,
0.0056733917,
-0.032521084,
-0.0763327703,
0.0587457605,
-0.0189971756,
-0.031643223,
-0.0005040753,
0.0310687125,
0.0128912004,
0.0230262913,
-0.0138633233,
-0.0063456278,
-0.0594408363,
-0.0191039946,
-0.0196630955,
0.0160825551,
-0.0287255608,
0.0230150595,
-0.0147246616,
0.027537467,
0.0093952576,
0.0000016888,
-0.0657346547,
-0.069726415,
0.0273128487,
-0.0155982478,
-0.0275116507,
-0.0172474068,
-0.038177859,
0.0553506501,
0.0312000513,
-0.0271351449,
0.0033930575,
-0.006926944,
0.0190465208,
0.0365264043,
0.0600601994,
0.0070945472,
-0.0173404589,
0.0376691446,
0.0119488733,
0.0387105905,
-0.0737370253,
-0.0091802226,
0.0222099964,
0.0656085685,
-0.0234812442,
0.0249443967,
0.0352394022,
0.0239086654,
-0.0363331959,
0.0183538496,
-0.0006455667,
-0.0027088989,
0.0383505933,
0.0277283639,
0.0720176697,
0.0646267161,
0.0008365883,
0.0541651696,
0.0214147642,
0.0109493416,
0.026929453,
-0.0808807462,
0.0415370092,
-0.0493876263,
-0.0215140898,
0.0193106998,
-0.0022045386,
-0.0348418318,
0.0039978116,
-0.0273804422,
0.0645168126,
-0.0041580461,
-0.0553214289,
0.0044915765,
0.0157139245,
-0.0175377969,
-0.0595156737,
0.0290917903,
0.0803801417,
-0.0065058889,
-0.0081698811,
-0.0583980232,
-0.0831031725,
0.0184537917,
-0.0456584916,
-0.0418074094,
-0.0182762314,
0.0320829228,
0.0800308958,
-0.0213345718,
0.0294108335,
0.0174238458,
-0.0117156459,
-0.1011450365,
-0.0403967425,
-0.0404786989,
-0.0172781236,
-0.0615456104,
0.0754169375,
-0.0259203203,
-0.0355229415,
0.0111334454,
0.0375881419,
0.0338387117,
0.002865701,
-0.0012318031,
0.0626982972,
0.0060606268,
-0.0112361452,
-0.0275143385,
0.0153408386,
-0.072325699,
0.0016008097,
0.0057221232,
0.0317440778,
-0.0153849637,
0.0061195851,
0.0774659291,
-0.0098554436,
0.0311879739,
0.0345161073,
-0.0294433124,
-0.0254224539,
0.0011266411,
-0.0262654703,
0.0134665696,
-0.0407400019,
0.0176447202,
-0.0381225087,
0.0302659087,
0.0396075547,
-0.0272145253,
0.0351862274,
0.0220419336,
0.0180336982,
-0.0412428901,
0.0301979389,
0.0046128314,
0.0042358967,
0.0401628651,
0.0202482212,
-0.005973204,
0.037446484,
0.0250151418,
0.0120848538,
0.0808186382,
0.002552079,
-0.0131308017,
0.0051697968,
0.0137419114,
-0.0068777055,
0.0502951629,
0.0857971162,
-0.0160843246,
-0.01451921,
0.025984792,
0.0304674711,
0.0175156854,
0.0075237839,
0.0070654838,
0.0619259253,
-0.049944073,
0.0258940663,
-0.0329895727,
0.0301903337,
0.0443591326,
0.019277785,
-0.0185671803,
0.0325284041,
-0.0188026149,
0.028300764,
0.031942144,
0.0084217051,
-0.0200906899,
-0.0246880632,
-0.0187079087,
0.0217092708,
0.0010684525,
0.0301611014,
0.0085403938,
0.0024998905,
0.0043255896,
0.0487324148,
-0.0277375281,
-0.0590184815,
0.0123530133,
-0.0156519692,
0.0795277655,
0.0283527188,
0.0320457108,
-0.0810213685,
-0.0450732894,
0.0000047084,
0.0153023619,
0.001423002,
-0.0119306408,
-0.0193552449,
0.0125864251,
-0.0058379318,
-0.0081132436,
-0.0139551694,
-0.0045018592,
-0.0089634713,
0.0206694826,
-0.007152467,
0.0395781882,
-0.0339257792,
-0.0038142598,
0.0410364121,
-0.0395090431,
-0.0490565002,
0.0190296061,
0.0071663503,
0.0004644522,
0.0130480742,
0.0169499163,
0.0320315212,
0.0364927538,
-0.0317003503,
-0.008867221,
-0.0067774723,
-0.0353868678,
-0.0219643414,
0.0221093874,
-0.0323867574,
-0.0250131544,
0.0383960269,
-0.0182181951,
-0.0491055623,
0.0150448354,
-0.0639638379,
0.0013146512,
-0.0298943054,
-0.0090248631,
0.0257076416,
-0.0259955972,
-0.0306747872,
0.0480304174,
0.0056837918,
0.0037093356,
0.0077230274,
-0.0552118011,
0.0101410141,
-0.0036545603,
-0.0011144056,
-0.0453494154,
-0.0044076829,
0.0115441447,
0.0265634991,
-0.0022479077,
-0.0529767573,
-0.0210708138,
-0.0707511976,
0.0493539795,
-0.0134980092,
0.0651252866,
0.060957253,
0.0308103655,
-0.0194430128,
-0.0146881668,
-0.0872144327,
0.0048531182,
0.0451338775,
0.0043268898,
0.050836321,
0.0176958833,
0.0409372151,
-0.0613531694,
-0.0079458989,
-0.0248493068,
0.0309253577,
-0.0141561525,
0.015303391,
0.0001110731,
-0.0094497493,
-0.0150032509,
0.0286097955,
-0.004363595,
0.0083289659,
-0.0013267965,
-0.0385117047,
0.0036308537,
0.0550020635,
0.0273910388,
-0.0123580126,
0.001740956,
-0.0104429396,
-0.0296555944,
0.0146688437,
-0.0100561148,
0.0377814732,
0.0511135794,
-0.0149102034,
0.0330317505,
0.0347020403,
-0.0160875227,
-0.0474273786,
0.0283942875,
0.0439028814,
0.0402296111,
0.0274499413,
-0.0547072776,
-0.0392802507,
0.0009834417,
0.0243869666,
-0.0237405486,
-0.0075382646,
0.0346547216,
-0.0251473226,
-0.0278040003,
-0.067423895,
-0.003766451,
-0.0698167533,
0.0845839828,
-0.007678506,
0.0009075007,
-0.0117933089,
-0.0273184478,
-0.017972203,
-0.0253510848,
0.0212593488,
-0.0547464937,
0.040668752,
-0.0289648473,
0.0350009277,
-0.046323806,
-0.021505082,
-0.049701266,
-0.0073182592,
0.0061818645,
0.029905051,
-0.0004651624,
0.0065473849,
-0.0386594944,
0.0142828487,
0.0531559438,
0.0312703773,
-0.061728403,
-0.021169126,
-0.021708874,
0.120727092,
0.0918283239,
0.0347129293,
0.0594800897,
-0.0305586606,
0.0270036943,
0.0665614977,
0.0212704726,
0.0105473371,
0.035654027,
-0.0275021121,
-0.0080807749,
-0.0398909226,
0.0158762187,
-0.0306484252,
0.0288879536,
-0.102169238,
-0.0359784625,
0.085961476,
0.0583581291,
-0.0074295681,
-0.0439606719,
-0.0671896264,
0.0022228421,
0.0105675478,
0.0590116158,
-0.0844113976,
-0.0247677118,
-0.0007651855,
0.0478394404,
0.0233995095,
-0.0267354324,
0.0038295898,
-0.058090847,
0.0075413231,
-0.0302631203,
-0.0568944179,
-0.0187055133,
-0.0177340116,
-0.0072688614,
0.0529283732,
0.0200931765,
0.0401723944,
-0.0512898043,
-0.0007536477,
0.0061931694,
-0.0342600718,
0.051906772,
0.027187435,
-0.0141873313,
-0.0496925414,
0.0545274019,
0.0122752041,
-0.0026839769,
-0.0207984298,
0.0163890589,
-0.0768824518,
-0.0616368242,
0.0104981717,
0.0015097827,
-0.0098710386,
0.0161908641,
-0.0376663357,
0.0492492206,
-0.005590382,
0.0311718248,
0.0561431348,
0.0359901339,
-0.0189849157,
-0.0289755128,
-0.0389183126,
0.0247872435,
-0.0270987619,
0.0687649474,
0.0234877411,
0.0131520191,
-0.0813117474,
-0.0039953529,
-0.0250453576,
-0.0692264736,
0.0326861702,
-0.0186280385,
-0.0292791892,
0.0743696615,
-0.0976259112,
-0.0259809978,
0.0590111502,
-0.005980086,
-0.0285508689,
-0.0293982308,
0.0177810173,
0.0222528223,
-0.0493574552,
0.0188560002,
-0.0163299013,
0.0060860901,
-0.0253526531,
0.007781364,
0.022190582,
-0.0085563501,
-0.0322229229,
0.0144555075,
-0.0550540723,
-0.0167391375,
-0.0263531674,
-0.0041524488,
0.0144372238,
0.0445901826,
-0.0007218892,
0.0119835734,
0.0213143472,
0.0332988352,
-0.0396604612,
-0.0176275745,
-0.0009393205,
0.0073364223,
-0.0308778901,
0.0246349312,
-0.061680194,
0.007477425,
-0.0400948711,
0.0244762879,
-0.0446516201,
-0.0342014208,
-0.0015367173,
0.0409783013,
-0.0218728408,
0.0421313718,
0.0347311869,
-0.0203051232,
0.0339728817,
-0.0265044179,
-0.0193523597,
-0.0271426905,
0.0191423204,
-0.0200549085,
-0.0228528008,
-0.0000651425,
0.0435475148,
0.0023811157,
0.0421044081,
-0.0272438992,
0.0185298845,
0.0078426637,
0.0045746015,
-0.0339120291,
-0.0418692753,
-0.0051800776,
-0.0253644492,
0.0022584633,
0.0865664631,
-0.0308476333,
0.0266874656,
0.0043314057,
-0.01301168,
-0.0353752151,
0.0188241191,
-0.0835400671,
-0.0332590863,
-0.0311654229,
-0.0022221555,
0.0138345566,
-0.0494173467,
-0.0020929694,
0.0182169564,
-0.0164649021,
0.0099680601,
-0.0237378702,
0.0217312183,
0.0265671499,
0.0289747287,
0.0299892407,
-0.0051628537,
0.0115640154,
0.0356457904,
-0.015247561,
0.0261966996,
0.0095145442,
-0.0326698832,
-0.0159928724,
-0.0117001599,
0.0117105404,
0.061251197,
-0.0188975222,
-0.0226185042,
-0.0204848796,
0.0057420717,
0.031333331,
0.0135505293,
-0.0121862581,
-0.0192298628,
0.0373468548,
0.0396733955,
0.0478236489,
-0.0727195218,
-0.0253607575,
0.0613613017,
-0.0753030702,
-0.0159804188,
0.0158170909,
-6.043095235e-33,
-0.0353315882,
-0.0127412621,
-0.0025179577,
0.0101681212,
-0.0321433544,
0.0261811465,
-0.034016341,
-0.0074152951,
-0.0053899186,
-0.0175337978,
-0.0387944281,
-0.0133608468,
0.0058589759,
0.0310650337,
-0.0028681613,
-0.0088361371,
-0.0154947555,
-0.0285952315,
-0.006214411,
0.0195046123,
0.0514645912,
0.0159994215,
0.0032567957,
-0.0180975813,
-0.0054867705,
-0.0425392054,
0.004043181,
0.0377403274,
0.0271714292,
0.0332438461,
-0.0307776891,
-0.0432140343,
0.0480870493,
0.0051109693,
-0.0061809919,
0.083717227,
-0.1524719,
-0.0066431854,
0.0215850584,
-0.0551844835,
-0.0809013546,
-0.0318796784,
0.0359154157,
0.0144158881,
0.0721202567,
-0.0489025041,
0.0345313288,
-0.0307149813,
0.0031100605,
-0.0551506616,
-0.0398867354,
0.0101964185,
-0.0180467349,
0.0169271659,
0.0048088343,
0.0359962583,
-0.0005297327,
0.0358488746,
-0.0294624567,
-0.029749766,
0.0228289068,
0.057668563,
-0.0052648499,
0.0080887647,
-0.0076464745,
0.0301109962,
-0.0005104769,
-0.0207236912,
-0.0214254949,
0.0276216585,
0.0025794434,
0.0154446447,
0.0485870913,
0.0243946295,
0.0571434051,
0.0659157783,
-0.0736761242,
0.0859154016,
0.0070279976,
0.0276985355,
-0.0205147918,
-0.0204526708,
-0.014448951,
0.0051265419,
-0.0205145534,
0.053877078,
-0.0297945645,
0.0062524453,
0.0109940981,
0.0017416051,
-0.0399352759,
-0.0276434757,
0.0341984555,
-0.0245344136,
0.0289009977,
-0.0099386666,
0.015695205,
-0.0000291877,
-0.0010244126,
0.027189685,
-0.0185439084,
0.0046350462,
0.0282083228,
-0.0393293723,
-0.0135255223,
0.0262070838,
0.0325503051,
-0.0660504475,
-0.0676707402,
0.004054748,
-0.006928877,
0.0545841344,
-0.0551569462,
0.0040920773,
-0.0108712045,
0.0277384948,
0.0276909731,
0.0471408851,
-0.016691817,
0.0327432938,
-0.0701655746,
-0.0403173305,
-0.0216566157,
0.0167695992,
0.0027081531,
0.0287431069,
-0.0407333188,
0.0416847765,
0.0055781724,
-0.0530508831,
0.0168075319,
0.0157252997,
2.355e-7,
0.062942937,
0.0404667594,
0.0753729567,
0.0459489934,
0.0280707609,
-0.0010983257,
0.0168711971,
0.0224227477,
0.0467081293,
-0.009764092,
0.0131808007,
0.0141310431,
0.0455583818,
0.0631884709,
-0.0957888812,
-0.0110819098,
-0.0759575069,
-0.0664089769,
-0.0504696779,
-0.0269064456,
0.0404510871,
0.0306812674,
-0.0216693096,
-0.0156597365,
-0.043080885,
-0.0437841453,
0.0252338983,
0.030602036,
0.0071371216,
0.0220706854,
0.0278521758,
-0.0440660529,
0.0073458846,
-0.0162421502,
0.0080239931,
0.0698334724,
0.0213930849,
0.0473655127,
0.0083821369,
-0.0166276172,
-0.0187822804,
-0.0340275839,
0.0443028025,
-0.0457504876,
0.1169157252,
-0.021689279,
0.0272006169,
-0.0596430972,
-0.0652117431,
-0.0194027498,
-0.0385567844,
0.0214608498,
0.0060911765,
0.0691435635,
-0.0011044104,
-0.0393765755,
0.0344737135,
-0.0724674016,
-0.0121184327,
0.0501390845,
-0.012068822,
-0.0174167547,
-0.0271399971,
0.0060897577,
0.0052264598,
-0.0462967455,
0.0125750601,
1.857339734e-34,
0.0350043885,
0.0002332918,
-0.0239248555,
-0.008829399,
0.038021639,
-0.02870165,
0.0152166532,
-0.0039938674,
0.025075173,
-0.112095952,
0.0165861957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06434v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06434v2 | Whispering LLaMA: A Cross-Modal Generative Error Correction Framework for Speech Recognition | 2023-10-10T09:04:33 | 2023-10-16T21:32:56 | Srijith Radhakrishnan, Chao-Han Huck Yang, Sumeer Ahmad Khan, Rohit Kumar, Narsis A. Kiani, David Gomez-Cabrero, Jesper N. Tegner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce a new cross-modal fusion technique designed for generative error
correction in automatic speech recognition (ASR). Our methodology leverages
both acoustic information and external linguistic representations to generate
accurate speech transcription contexts. This marks a step towards a fresh
paradigm in generative error correction within the realm of n-best hypotheses.
Unlike the existing ranking-based rescoring methods, our approach adeptly uses
distinct initialization techniques and parameter-efficient algorithms to boost
ASR performance derived from pre-trained speech and text models. Through
evaluation across diverse ASR datasets, we evaluate the stability and
reproducibility of our fusion technique, demonstrating its improved word error
rate relative (WERR) performance in comparison to n-best hypotheses by
relatively 37.66%. To encourage future research, we have made our code and
pre-trained models open source at
https://github.com/Srijith-rkr/Whispering-LLaMA. | [
-0.0313249901,
0.0812030882,
0.0274579879,
0.0004118952,
0.011160925,
-0.0074262721,
-0.0162919704,
-0.0151552083,
-0.0064677508,
-0.0492006168,
-0.0696528703,
-0.0185455773,
0.0809510201,
-0.0205507297,
0.0527496524,
-0.0053051226,
0.0132424766,
-0.066268228,
-0.004004728,
-0.0303757302,
-0.001352553,
0.0059584333,
-0.0506100319,
0.0484797955,
-0.0212545749,
0.0321681537,
0.0163179915,
0.0295987986,
0.0299086533,
-0.0213892274,
-0.003852081,
0.0029494201,
0.0092113782,
0.0546561666,
0.0000021634,
-0.0205343328,
-0.0165312588,
0.0162723884,
0.0036203938,
-0.0012559448,
0.0195489954,
0.0100019444,
-0.0586562976,
0.0930544883,
0.0100850863,
-0.0362013355,
0.0471869297,
0.0378941819,
0.0035480058,
0.0494719185,
-0.0089540295,
-0.0341046676,
0.0375654139,
-0.0258053411,
0.0031768798,
-0.0048244419,
-0.0050296765,
0.0021848145,
-0.0241504218,
-0.0175536983,
-0.0263891071,
0.0231312457,
-0.0121495435,
-0.0290102791,
-0.0104427477,
0.0407554135,
0.0257284846,
-0.0029405202,
-0.0502325594,
0.0526987948,
0.0276835207,
-0.0298154484,
0.0055458564,
0.0015624119,
-0.0182007141,
-0.0202235822,
0.0014830451,
0.0234581716,
-0.0046216054,
0.004929781,
0.0281112306,
0.0119586932,
0.0254168883,
-0.0311579499,
-0.0085861338,
-0.0196950249,
0.0326739289,
-0.0342829116,
-0.0267921314,
-0.0096543906,
0.0274489056,
-0.0411684364,
0.02075563,
-0.0068349936,
-0.0203832015,
-0.0203121826,
-0.0516261756,
-0.032257095,
0.0190361757,
0.0076785465,
0.0219933502,
0.0570770241,
-0.061870683,
-0.0012652104,
-0.0222992878,
0.0534532145,
0.0028795691,
0.0342780128,
-0.0207870975,
-0.0062625967,
-0.0113512231,
0.028689716,
0.0143372957,
-0.0229518022,
-0.0410482921,
-0.0096979924,
-0.1034569219,
0.0010100242,
0.0151053853,
0.0123354839,
0.0349066928,
-0.0120619591,
-0.0593972243,
-0.0296948887,
0.0027331191,
-0.0066950275,
0.0394658968,
0.0950899646,
0.0151634514,
-0.073996,
-0.0100518307,
0.0071773464,
0.0363347232,
0.0248590373,
0.0128694689,
0.068684876,
-0.0281732231,
-0.0292806849,
-0.0079964884,
-0.0056220554,
-0.0300722364,
-0.0392005816,
-0.0260142144,
-0.0591465011,
0.0357198194,
-0.0105656022,
0.0215526018,
-0.0365263484,
0.0166300368,
-0.0314051248,
0.0182957184,
0.0890021324,
-0.0237598363,
0.0087748356,
0.0410335995,
-0.0101580909,
0.0265897606,
0.027899269,
0.0505103767,
-0.0578020327,
-0.0160247982,
-0.0048205634,
0.011568361,
0.0275010839,
-0.0026392036,
-0.0116964784,
-0.0185909905,
-0.0372198634,
0.0187228322,
0.0068400721,
0.058279369,
0.0624216497,
-0.0377455577,
0.0178032499,
0.0306756869,
0.0224764757,
0.0499587059,
0.0179134086,
0.0146773094,
-0.0315459967,
-0.0086577758,
-0.0207465403,
-0.0175930411,
-0.0005831362,
-0.0254053604,
0.0120091764,
0.1227231175,
0.0587000027,
-0.0084089031,
-0.041135639,
0.0003074411,
-0.047369726,
-0.0252632219,
0.029707415,
0.0356318019,
-0.0107234325,
-0.0664649978,
0.0064493036,
0.0024553426,
-0.097196728,
-0.0028519938,
-0.0396859683,
0.0172369853,
0.0601319931,
0.0329863243,
-0.0161898881,
-0.0197198149,
-0.01380427,
-0.0797715858,
0.0142986989,
-0.0148667684,
0.0167812575,
0.0557553843,
-0.0817151293,
-0.0249458682,
0.0471750945,
-0.0049599549,
0.049082607,
-0.0346931256,
0.0211743768,
0.0315851755,
-0.0279498026,
0.0269996393,
0.0107366499,
-0.0220030118,
-0.028389059,
0.0257196929,
-0.0110318754,
0.0616673827,
0.0131538184,
-0.0575402528,
0.0240118075,
0.0321256965,
-0.0303905699,
-0.0176857952,
0.0353720225,
-0.0614537373,
-0.0547228456,
0.0619211681,
-0.0455367863,
0.0271246918,
0.0037149461,
-0.0056281965,
-0.0882397667,
0.010860729,
-0.0401688255,
0.0554901771,
-0.0900565088,
0.035139855,
0.0531841666,
0.016345555,
0.025764985,
0.0081651937,
-0.0235376656,
0.0038353282,
0.0173435844,
0.0087908022,
-0.0223691985,
-0.0695588291,
0.0181267243,
0.0121499803,
-0.0130355144,
0.0491438434,
-0.0123869451,
0.0202934388,
-0.014110784,
-0.0432458557,
-0.1213123724,
-0.0037117666,
-0.0192094482,
0.0168823227,
0.0010057777,
0.027924113,
-0.0293952785,
-0.0341216959,
-0.0115393791,
-0.0175323598,
0.0278441012,
-0.0122194914,
-0.0271376781,
-0.0187257379,
-0.0333653204,
-0.029046135,
0.0291784797,
-0.0000843607,
-0.0031544091,
-0.0223813653,
-0.0004161694,
-0.0856836215,
0.0482157283,
-0.0184899196,
0.0377379805,
0.0042841346,
-0.0469285287,
-0.0128743099,
0.009373554,
0.0743726566,
-0.0055243154,
-0.0090016173,
-0.0268822219,
0.0222006366,
-0.0489790179,
-0.0596482866,
-0.0040819058,
0.0365142636,
-0.0063028601,
0.0149044376,
0.0017548066,
-0.0613807626,
0.0527309701,
0.035451673,
0.0285083,
-0.0184619408,
-0.0203011613,
0.0088779014,
-0.0433104336,
-0.001731971,
-0.0238279961,
-0.0143735707,
0.0427836366,
-0.015768772,
-0.0204894356,
0.028733436,
-0.0988248438,
-0.0080023063,
-0.0195199121,
-0.0289130434,
-0.0205849577,
-0.0580997504,
-0.0385341495,
-0.0037580717,
-0.0001455669,
-0.0513213873,
-0.0104443878,
-0.0178762767,
0.0323200859,
-0.0760422051,
0.0394358858,
-0.024402637,
0.0259308815,
-0.0320611969,
-0.0293267276,
-0.0150867738,
-0.0436892621,
0.004514555,
-0.0008261962,
-0.0050873701,
-0.027664572,
-0.0078315632,
-0.0056020007,
0.0269548986,
0.0522635318,
0.0066310097,
-0.0108504724,
-0.0209806655,
0.0703913867,
-0.0375777297,
0.043855764,
0.0108110495,
0.0015198181,
0.022694122,
0.0120306443,
0.0862480849,
0.0402227566,
-0.0271726213,
-0.0093579646,
0.0585479774,
0.0320595503,
-0.0100390166,
0.0381905213,
0.0704945996,
-0.0225133393,
0.0074681146,
0.0853235349,
-0.0164594892,
-0.0248619672,
-0.0493898988,
-0.0066322088,
-0.0047244485,
0.0086681535,
0.0140122315,
-0.0430421643,
-0.0186405629,
0.0733472332,
0.0645586625,
-0.0089419996,
0.0192711707,
0.0059074638,
-0.1204818934,
0.0729011595,
0.0413251407,
-0.0096969903,
-0.0254992172,
-0.0492156968,
0.0069483249,
-0.0064341421,
0.0265709776,
0.0184148811,
-0.0100958748,
-0.0430198461,
0.0578806289,
0.0018041197,
-0.094053261,
-0.0198941249,
-0.0158799998,
0.0653088689,
0.0581047796,
0.0323560424,
-0.0023139666,
-0.0924705118,
0.0126807364,
-0.0134076551,
-0.0116825392,
-0.0021747435,
-0.0158936754,
0.0106843468,
-0.0075440169,
0.0294100959,
0.048349034,
0.0006401773,
-0.0081545673,
-0.0091586607,
0.0287744552,
-0.0187377278,
0.069841817,
0.0212580375,
0.0251822807,
0.0215694178,
0.0111337053,
0.0140861711,
0.0034198256,
0.000098579,
-0.0212579872,
0.0666566193,
0.0003728655,
0.0068621719,
0.0219334438,
0.0068865423,
-0.0652573779,
-0.0201752055,
-0.0310929753,
-0.0120887589,
0.0310809631,
0.0348327197,
-0.0244199038,
-0.0572617166,
0.0117586982,
-0.0245455746,
-0.0283241402,
-0.0126020564,
0.0324513055,
-0.0586434491,
0.044129014,
0.0552664921,
-0.0340903476,
-0.0188394282,
0.0059271483,
-0.0171932112,
-0.0695651546,
0.010805795,
0.0262043606,
0.0055025602,
0.0345366895,
-0.0031739746,
-0.0303065889,
0.0725797415,
0.0845432207,
-0.037760064,
0.0430337302,
0.0371629298,
-0.0023752609,
-0.0044123805,
-0.0017694926,
-0.0738567486,
0.0168127865,
-0.0302785784,
0.0103269182,
-0.0205458775,
-0.0559247024,
0.019072488,
0.012745644,
0.0627705157,
-0.0454100072,
0.0274776779,
-0.0660313591,
0.0342649184,
-0.0317300819,
0.0404521413,
-0.0134804603,
0.0179410055,
0.0320237428,
-0.0063491724,
0.0003187671,
0.0538328141,
-0.0340910628,
-0.0110288188,
-0.0296510216,
0.0593635589,
0.0490703322,
0.0500164181,
-0.0404884107,
-0.0125998063,
-0.0183925256,
0.0208929833,
0.0530358851,
0.0185095891,
-0.0318859443,
0.0161866974,
-0.0354570299,
-0.004746364,
-0.0193392541,
0.0271955635,
-0.0390503183,
-0.0252902042,
-0.027367942,
0.0473154709,
0.085865587,
0.0406297147,
0.0726765096,
0.0176739097,
0.0343495458,
-0.0338218734,
0.0417078845,
-0.0202576611,
0.0151918018,
0.0145119876,
-0.0094617074,
0.0017665885,
0.0156087177,
0.0555696152,
-0.0248737894,
0.0232675597,
-0.0430374518,
0.0145150078,
-0.0463821851,
-0.0373521186,
0.0166035555,
-0.0220190082,
-0.0247322675,
-0.0442234538,
0.0080249896,
-0.0631325245,
0.0586629771,
0.0526313782,
0.0192936324,
-0.0051954659,
-0.0148707312,
0.0057044034,
-0.0284543391,
0.0526695848,
-0.0180138238,
-0.0632573068,
0.0055575846,
-0.0068675815,
0.034962289,
-6.546735789e-33,
-0.0544527657,
0.0043740557,
-0.0034091193,
-0.0439244546,
-0.0397106595,
0.0206961799,
-0.0020779828,
0.004753035,
0.0639124289,
-0.0292101819,
-0.0389738418,
0.0189513564,
0.0381475277,
-0.0185442958,
0.0073907031,
0.038165383,
0.0909002945,
0.0038752947,
-0.0041923178,
-0.0173557717,
0.0575079769,
0.0545435399,
0.0161451567,
-0.0920583233,
0.0006898945,
0.0414467305,
-0.0639448985,
-0.0233613066,
0.0090416418,
0.0496087857,
-0.0029862621,
0.0153416814,
-0.0379001796,
-0.0041098292,
-0.0162862036,
0.0200094786,
-0.0823498741,
-0.0096149221,
-0.0196542814,
0.0144170979,
-0.012839105,
-0.0329503939,
0.0513085015,
0.0150063736,
-0.0682892948,
-0.0237803422,
-0.0028054805,
-0.0366410129,
-0.0176032837,
-0.0520095155,
0.0010309131,
0.0225804709,
-0.0292778518,
-0.0415617637,
0.0418404453,
0.0196579434,
0.0214740634,
-0.0176315717,
-0.0709268451,
0.0522148758,
-0.0051541519,
0.0195762571,
0.0469004326,
0.035065569,
-0.0297779571,
0.0365673192,
0.0250391401,
-0.0781806782,
0.0066626747,
-0.073764123,
0.0020972155,
0.012819224,
-0.0293291025,
0.096498698,
0.020853499,
-0.0494352989,
-0.0631595999,
0.0627133995,
-0.0020295826,
0.011324184,
0.0133360643,
0.0458560139,
-0.0247931033,
0.0073831384,
-0.0628768504,
-0.0373531729,
-0.0270403102,
0.017021127,
0.0297688339,
0.0447976775,
-0.0241176132,
-0.0421825461,
0.0302072614,
-0.0177679565,
0.0242876429,
0.0025272975,
-0.0051836777,
-0.0055277376,
-0.0238158684,
-0.0079901749,
-0.0145401843,
-0.029477803,
0.0540702231,
0.03761971,
0.0245177709,
-0.0653205886,
-0.0171976592,
0.0577117912,
-0.0892003402,
0.0235600807,
0.001179648,
0.0400554761,
0.0006104246,
-0.0166529063,
0.0448173247,
-0.0107477978,
0.0091005983,
0.0094819758,
0.0029571273,
0.0742490739,
0.0009085003,
-0.0191528667,
0.0060143746,
0.0400122181,
-0.0194207579,
0.0243424308,
0.0207969602,
-0.0518051423,
0.0142539013,
0.0091960616,
-0.0260497853,
0.0147942835,
2.948e-7,
-0.0428953432,
0.0153328031,
0.0413298421,
-0.0279339328,
0.0139491512,
0.0285172444,
-0.01229461,
0.0171060469,
0.0099981287,
0.0246603172,
0.0301454514,
-0.0209777877,
0.0684672445,
0.0454277471,
-0.0490669757,
-0.0245505497,
-0.0367956124,
0.0361691117,
0.0285315756,
-0.0246359296,
0.0369948633,
0.0603717193,
-0.0498276763,
-0.0237264689,
-0.015645951,
-0.0043669767,
0.0724832416,
-0.0077149859,
-0.0395269431,
-0.0205365457,
0.0235008802,
0.034008339,
0.0017477461,
-0.0257693958,
-0.0209493265,
0.0282189623,
0.0199805349,
0.0130095733,
-0.000710345,
-0.0766003206,
0.006364563,
0.0903369188,
-0.0134323314,
0.0064187972,
0.0031108116,
0.010612932,
0.0077121947,
-0.0398995541,
-0.0601153113,
0.0159041677,
0.0524949655,
-0.033327885,
0.0044482797,
0.0096582919,
0.0064721415,
0.0197612848,
-0.0421916209,
-0.0410131924,
0.0054524723,
0.0110302661,
-0.0425416678,
-0.0160806831,
0.0196847506,
0.0185691603,
0.0407479182,
-0.0391424559,
-0.0064569856,
2.298369258e-34,
0.0286110006,
-0.0334202722,
0.0341546386,
-0.0017661599,
0.0119374692,
-0.021462135,
0.0014772189,
-0.0026756325,
-0.0051496979,
-0.0440000892,
-0.0392096862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06433v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06433v1 | Retromorphic Testing: A New Approach to the Test Oracle Problem | 2023-10-10T09:03:01 | 2023-10-10T09:03:01 | Boxi Yu, Qiuyang Mang, Qingshuo Guo, Pinjia He | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, D.3.0; I.2.7; I.4.0 | A test oracle serves as a criterion or mechanism to assess the correspondence
between software output and the anticipated behavior for a given input set. In
automated testing, black-box techniques, known for their non-intrusive nature
in test oracle construction, are widely used, including notable methodologies
like differential testing and metamorphic testing. Inspired by the mathematical
concept of inverse function, we present Retromorphic Testing, a novel black-box
testing methodology. It leverages an auxiliary program in conjunction with the
program under test, which establishes a dual-program structure consisting of a
forward program and a backward program. The input data is first processed by
the forward program and then its program output is reversed to its original
input format using the backward program. In particular, the auxiliary program
can operate as either the forward or backward program, leading to different
testing modes. The process concludes by examining the relationship between the
initial input and the transformed output within the input domain. For example,
to test the implementation of the sine function $\sin(x)$, we can employ its
inverse function, $\arcsin(x)$, and validate the equation $x =
\sin(\arcsin(x)+2k\pi), \forall k \in \mathbb{Z}$. In addition to the
high-level concept of Retromorphic Testing, this paper presents its three
testing modes with illustrative use cases across diverse programs, including
algorithms, traditional software, and AI applications. | [
-0.0574473776,
0.0410051011,
-0.0663517416,
0.0154789248,
-0.0584416911,
-0.0576051027,
-0.0369357094,
0.0600329414,
0.0406786911,
0.016087357,
0.0318702608,
0.0378150232,
0.0144858314,
0.0226194728,
0.0151549047,
0.0139825493,
0.0455096588,
-0.0341358855,
-0.0829143822,
0.0227877721,
-0.0779816061,
-0.0523619987,
0.0195788965,
-0.0299975108,
0.0070499978,
-0.0169546157,
-0.0223121215,
0.0099163391,
0.0200211126,
-0.0098714251,
-0.0209701285,
-0.0248694643,
-0.0234660618,
0.0340827256,
0.0000022503,
-0.0010933267,
-0.0080614751,
0.0377685055,
-0.0203092899,
0.0155906575,
-0.0356103741,
0.0370535851,
-0.0113811847,
-0.0029342729,
-0.0119720129,
0.0196123943,
-0.0093636755,
-0.0299324133,
0.0857283399,
0.04655274,
0.0095398687,
0.01910487,
0.0578255542,
0.0328791775,
0.02206886,
0.0198603012,
-0.0055738832,
0.0035671371,
0.0785548687,
0.0083655249,
0.0202610679,
-0.0002252978,
0.0721393675,
0.017588539,
-0.0385912508,
0.000385426,
0.0628243461,
0.0341219455,
-0.0323585346,
-0.013365183,
0.0039862785,
-0.0949743465,
-0.006973865,
0.014304705,
-0.0152181834,
0.0183328427,
0.0595291816,
-0.0388937183,
-0.0177901872,
-0.0375441611,
-0.0009447928,
0.022871621,
0.0266034752,
-0.0503978655,
-0.0135180093,
0.0473166257,
0.0109510561,
-0.083484523,
-0.0088695632,
0.0129351094,
0.0370210856,
-0.0079476312,
0.027933199,
-0.0057547367,
-0.0194032416,
-0.0211543329,
-0.0136776874,
-0.0477587953,
0.0181123093,
0.0090637524,
0.0333642513,
0.0110660009,
-0.0255519208,
-0.0180520415,
-0.0479337573,
0.0711824223,
-0.0377424508,
0.0102155078,
-0.016192928,
0.0601836033,
0.017244827,
0.0084664412,
-0.0319502801,
0.0243214983,
0.0416392684,
0.0411987454,
0.0207482204,
-0.0066380268,
-0.0809260607,
0.0649944693,
-0.0527979322,
-0.0016022807,
0.0464148857,
0.0116574056,
0.0225308165,
-0.0703014731,
-0.0200316012,
-0.0315489843,
-0.0263907257,
0.0190214049,
0.0130537171,
0.0262015089,
-0.0727428347,
-0.0155778313,
0.0070640733,
0.0912088677,
-0.0083829956,
0.0745209605,
-0.0407121703,
-0.0240537021,
0.06148348,
-0.0372366048,
0.0863575786,
-0.0203232821,
-0.0085394811,
-0.0179860555,
-0.0103585497,
0.0248664934,
-0.0023356585,
-0.0019042873,
0.0585635602,
0.0704329386,
0.0552142523,
0.0306151602,
0.0362708978,
0.0444714017,
0.0095633175,
0.0232269391,
-0.0108898999,
-0.0491097607,
-0.0023121703,
-0.0541422628,
0.0331916846,
-0.0004029182,
0.0628019199,
0.0294188373,
-0.0700891018,
0.0277423859,
-0.0263137631,
0.0043967329,
-0.0990125015,
0.0440845266,
0.0094027873,
-0.0218985807,
-0.0327346735,
-0.0310353003,
-0.0256915949,
0.0286979992,
0.0433721356,
-0.0352756642,
-0.0095784413,
0.0453992896,
-0.0324231051,
0.0410760008,
-0.0603938475,
-0.0069991392,
-0.0398017615,
-0.0400261246,
0.0166929141,
-0.0448632464,
0.0058073238,
0.0218468048,
-0.0201824382,
-0.0267299637,
0.0306999516,
0.0406675525,
-0.0249003023,
0.0008557664,
-0.0262487978,
-0.0340018868,
-0.0659588501,
-0.1017929986,
0.0351247303,
-0.019503396,
0.0287353862,
-0.0823941901,
0.0448672622,
0.0315535292,
-0.0498160459,
-0.0021432242,
0.0020912192,
0.0010892976,
-0.0385258682,
0.0096075656,
-0.0177006014,
0.0758659467,
0.0288366694,
0.0532634817,
0.0174239911,
-0.0270663127,
0.0381014273,
-0.0123954471,
-0.0225965884,
-0.0127693843,
-0.0468692519,
-0.0734777451,
0.0373614989,
0.0458870195,
-0.0072624017,
0.0189886428,
-0.0096063977,
0.0014877978,
0.0597487465,
0.007252234,
-0.0391922258,
-0.0160769746,
-0.0383238345,
0.0332023911,
-0.0177153721,
-0.1096264794,
-0.0296718609,
0.0533026271,
-0.0158434398,
-0.0343520045,
0.0737039596,
-0.0151456613,
0.0187462065,
0.039344769,
0.0097147748,
-0.0329540186,
-0.0291199721,
-0.0064258282,
-0.0000806725,
0.034110941,
0.0229669381,
0.0295327809,
-0.0130040841,
0.0123706581,
0.03532096,
-0.0760811865,
-0.0211022999,
-0.0477074943,
0.0496987216,
-0.0315036811,
0.0469688438,
0.0016347372,
0.025327161,
0.0062095672,
0.0073263417,
-0.0295977406,
0.0517493226,
-0.0051842094,
-0.0290031657,
0.0524478741,
-0.0267780777,
-0.0179795735,
0.0236350764,
-0.022017872,
-0.0216915552,
0.0216552485,
-0.0024832753,
0.0065886746,
-0.0235084128,
-0.0172502585,
-0.0567289181,
0.0678571686,
-0.0286797024,
0.082379736,
-0.0341978446,
0.0320942365,
0.0791910589,
0.0085460525,
-0.0144290077,
-0.0175310913,
0.0247099921,
0.0011299896,
-0.0627291277,
0.0594005324,
0.0015008983,
-0.016419448,
-0.0682737529,
0.0496374182,
-0.0191587303,
-0.0096665062,
0.0646527261,
-0.0079267276,
0.0666331723,
-0.055938188,
-0.0045898068,
-0.0002168278,
-0.019475745,
0.0142564382,
-0.0285779294,
-0.0038418365,
0.0017781566,
0.045187518,
-0.0078399088,
-0.0327300169,
-0.0266717356,
-0.0486216024,
-0.0290338863,
-0.0164011568,
0.0261934884,
-0.0124448575,
0.0442082956,
0.0032036763,
0.003963267,
0.0167110991,
0.0142593672,
-0.0054786783,
-0.0249220952,
0.0461851172,
0.0242132712,
0.017505737,
0.0053305188,
-0.0159491729,
-0.0459280722,
0.0530067012,
-0.0070176739,
-0.0053642276,
0.0325125605,
-0.0433644541,
-0.044396475,
0.008862731,
0.0881497115,
0.0186479241,
-0.0623599552,
0.0116595086,
0.0308617931,
0.0310818814,
-0.0409189723,
0.0118197557,
0.0344782732,
-0.027132364,
-0.0206538253,
-0.0812277049,
-0.0597333945,
-0.045237083,
-0.0105832368,
0.0037351202,
0.0029398608,
-0.0485545173,
0.0477551222,
-0.0060157338,
-0.083438769,
-0.0244722646,
-0.0342745446,
-0.0310953707,
0.0089309951,
-0.0204241909,
-0.04087184,
-0.0075504538,
-0.0418435261,
-0.0524400622,
0.012742565,
-0.0188471749,
0.0197568499,
0.0008334692,
-0.0310001522,
0.0198441893,
0.0560536645,
-0.0739591271,
0.0215676297,
-0.0159556773,
0.0263447519,
-0.0511307344,
0.0166719388,
0.0192309991,
-0.1032726914,
-0.015215857,
0.0040917136,
-0.0213213358,
-0.0469696708,
-0.0007794453,
0.0023081547,
-0.0264534969,
0.0097913751,
0.0549120121,
0.0083598839,
-0.0240710359,
-0.0171631854,
-0.0233976953,
0.0524820201,
0.0429345109,
0.0192220882,
-0.0587249845,
0.0310312137,
0.030491285,
-0.0228961501,
0.0091213267,
0.0134231169,
-0.0434244536,
0.0324137993,
-0.0081430683,
0.0191790257,
0.054837957,
-0.0025128375,
0.0635724515,
-0.0266428124,
-0.0431426503,
0.0362558477,
0.0456241965,
0.0788936764,
-0.023931656,
-0.0053619612,
-0.0019668976,
-0.0184158124,
0.0792791322,
0.0057215728,
-0.0160499886,
-0.0113402279,
-0.0494404882,
-0.0577747859,
0.0204743035,
-0.062959373,
-0.0471819118,
-0.0231154896,
-0.0122870924,
0.0011154591,
-0.0127469543,
0.0268521514,
-0.0535627753,
0.0407456011,
0.0306169223,
-0.115335539,
-0.0141396187,
-0.0366968326,
-0.0530695431,
-0.0254812166,
0.0182511974,
0.060055282,
-0.0189857353,
-0.013673747,
-0.0013323985,
-0.0394549109,
-0.0324619487,
0.0078180721,
-0.0563902371,
-0.0093315281,
0.0327317975,
0.0673872009,
0.0162140504,
-0.0204065181,
-0.0553732589,
0.0584551021,
0.0411474705,
0.0012048668,
-0.0265000705,
0.0060785427,
0.0296952091,
-0.0645987988,
-0.0129438573,
-0.0072134114,
-0.0189087801,
0.0112370905,
0.0021201549,
-0.0464481264,
0.0210639592,
0.0056688092,
-0.0098910788,
0.0782749653,
0.0390816368,
0.0498815812,
-0.0663590357,
0.0391658731,
0.0488331355,
-0.0109246466,
-0.022696292,
0.0146383131,
0.0500642359,
-0.0205548853,
0.0038488272,
0.0042807795,
-0.0643811896,
0.0088082487,
-0.0127134398,
-0.0161855593,
0.0606205724,
0.0495248549,
0.0855810419,
0.0008754593,
0.0053418539,
0.0191983692,
0.008336707,
0.0342206582,
0.0697361156,
-0.0221175328,
0.018425107,
0.0048084836,
0.0578990094,
-0.0435039662,
-0.0118155638,
-0.0238830987,
0.0017718896,
0.0126129538,
0.0108119445,
-0.0098713664,
0.0290712602,
-0.0242945626,
-0.0136684421,
0.0272326078,
-0.0078391889,
-0.0382931456,
-0.0211780742,
0.0189322997,
-0.0269338805,
0.0159910191,
0.0478522368,
-0.0183052756,
-0.0000140279,
-0.0248498153,
0.0187584385,
-0.0404303335,
0.0768695325,
-0.0422226042,
0.0042251605,
0.0087515917,
-0.042258773,
0.0220365655,
-0.0572586022,
-0.0236879829,
-0.0454344042,
-0.0197286382,
0.0605078824,
0.035375841,
0.0041108909,
0.0251133516,
0.0347327888,
0.0403711163,
0.0335647985,
0.0053288047,
-0.0043938225,
-0.018762337,
-0.0092154862,
-0.0587549545,
-6.080572933e-33,
-0.0333522558,
-0.0272874981,
0.0185239166,
-0.0295797046,
0.0220072512,
-0.0103311939,
-0.0370319709,
-0.0131796822,
0.010097879,
-0.0301904846,
0.0045276824,
0.0172028355,
0.0243858155,
-0.0153780682,
0.0048296792,
-0.0035422803,
0.0387733579,
-0.0314287059,
-0.0544044748,
-0.0266875736,
0.008726065,
-0.0392123722,
0.0155815706,
-0.0343398638,
-0.0071105105,
0.0187832378,
-0.0320969857,
-0.0035687985,
-0.1078457013,
0.0445029587,
0.0324095972,
0.0066889166,
-0.0157349166,
-0.0214655362,
0.0138080874,
0.0120983012,
-0.0158129111,
-0.050789576,
0.0012423106,
0.0218397435,
0.00614422,
-0.0108787166,
0.0523376428,
-0.0043686312,
-0.0074911523,
0.0111663211,
-0.0253910366,
0.0187902264,
0.0579367056,
0.012120882,
-0.0478332639,
0.0328580663,
-0.0219707191,
-0.0192216691,
0.0047155838,
0.0677250326,
-0.0530331619,
-0.076516673,
0.0217084996,
0.0380689502,
0.0471383147,
-0.0347464643,
0.0003239866,
-0.0004142975,
0.0042259614,
-0.0363546237,
0.0334670171,
0.0221817382,
0.04891764,
-0.0186624452,
0.01746016,
0.0231186673,
0.0432653315,
0.0361739509,
0.0836014375,
-0.0633230582,
0.037562944,
0.0417183936,
-0.019654626,
-0.0541556701,
-0.0115143983,
-0.0211568158,
-0.0869509429,
-0.0079069175,
0.0047839535,
-0.0195622146,
-0.0253593698,
-0.0231318343,
0.0012589151,
0.025361469,
-0.0207785089,
0.0231781974,
-0.0035144365,
-0.0702401996,
0.0679898188,
-0.0001182076,
-0.0356165841,
-0.0191435665,
0.0007051294,
0.023935318,
0.0235339683,
-0.0591288581,
0.0419304222,
0.0269148983,
0.0768067688,
0.0043892823,
0.0040713642,
0.0059488239,
-0.0441322252,
0.0153834382,
0.0180914756,
-0.0169685483,
0.0094411541,
-0.0155890314,
0.0124567226,
0.0455452166,
0.0301404539,
0.0202332139,
0.0050422703,
-0.0749898553,
-0.0632303506,
0.0344333164,
0.0126907108,
0.0278317034,
0.0041726199,
-0.001552958,
0.013103513,
-0.0168214757,
-0.0309451353,
-0.0458639786,
-0.0070548085,
0.0385268331,
3.13e-7,
-0.0044388627,
0.0031779248,
0.0337918922,
0.0384013467,
0.0077418508,
0.013896537,
-0.0131448777,
0.0186562184,
-0.0375065058,
-0.0048063197,
0.0166330524,
-0.0284806062,
0.0377780721,
0.0218198113,
0.0376536697,
-0.0192347951,
-0.0334130935,
0.0012768554,
-0.0105318427,
0.0173317995,
0.0601464584,
-0.0273031518,
-0.0322163068,
0.009892758,
0.0165584255,
-0.0278620422,
-0.006583239,
0.0291776434,
0.009297221,
-0.0022803273,
-0.0954652727,
0.0039975876,
0.0267214905,
0.0410044864,
-0.0534043908,
0.0069619617,
0.0021817454,
0.0489990078,
0.0149356835,
-0.0279512573,
-0.0158911049,
-0.0144718029,
0.0203137752,
0.0184260327,
0.0231451318,
0.0483928807,
0.0223960131,
-0.0427708291,
-0.0487188585,
-0.0240882207,
-0.0065536094,
-0.0232863035,
0.016906729,
0.0105234478,
-0.0104346806,
0.0556981899,
0.0114757465,
0.013553421,
-0.0253935922,
0.0823945627,
-0.0241546277,
0.0073809624,
-0.0171952769,
-0.0140376659,
0.013445342,
-0.0210351497,
0.0194600075,
3.20928233e-34,
0.008407142,
-0.0091927657,
-0.0023374667,
-0.0244328696,
0.0183675345,
0.0017898649,
-0.0107245985,
0.0062147831,
0.0256786831,
0.0772407949,
0.0043761926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06422v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06422v2 | Large Language Models for Propaganda Detection | 2023-10-10T08:46:10 | 2023-11-27T10:18:36 | Kilian Sprenkamp, Daniel Gordon Jones, Liudmila Zavolokina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The prevalence of propaganda in our digital society poses a challenge to
societal harmony and the dissemination of truth. Detecting propaganda through
NLP in text is challenging due to subtle manipulation techniques and contextual
dependencies. To address this issue, we investigate the effectiveness of modern
Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3 and GPT-4 for propaganda detection.
We conduct experiments using the SemEval-2020 task 11 dataset, which features
news articles labeled with 14 propaganda techniques as a multi-label
classification problem. Five variations of GPT-3 and GPT-4 are employed,
incorporating various prompt engineering and fine-tuning strategies across the
different models. We evaluate the models' performance by assessing metrics such
as $F1$ score, $Precision$, and $Recall$, comparing the results with the
current state-of-the-art approach using RoBERTa. Our findings demonstrate that
GPT-4 achieves comparable results to the current state-of-the-art. Further,
this study analyzes the potential and challenges of LLMs in complex tasks like
propaganda detection. | [
0.0720874444,
0.0357975028,
-0.0083126156,
0.0139513975,
-0.0477078222,
0.0128053278,
0.0249926876,
0.0026568549,
0.0216736812,
-0.0634397566,
-0.020748321,
-0.0221065693,
0.0148427803,
-0.0245101471,
-0.0060415058,
-0.0405324437,
0.044427596,
0.0276155435,
0.0435691774,
-0.0274794027,
0.0224982742,
0.0455719195,
0.017924998,
0.0232663658,
-0.0518656075,
-0.0488730893,
0.0510868616,
0.0059489096,
0.0492400974,
-0.0182185955,
0.0258324016,
0.0528788529,
0.0428796858,
0.0728667676,
0.0000017565,
-0.0273090452,
-0.0168478172,
-0.0097390944,
-0.0002732871,
0.0476900153,
0.1053086072,
-0.0402759463,
-0.0150822913,
0.0360566825,
-0.0199221559,
0.0111603392,
0.0213433541,
0.0638624728,
0.0761406422,
0.0899359211,
-0.0122198183,
-0.0386340208,
0.0075610857,
-0.0096076261,
-0.0216025002,
-0.0276503004,
0.0649155527,
-0.0280123185,
-0.029842956,
0.0396304652,
0.0071888184,
0.0362566002,
0.0094694365,
0.0060018166,
-0.0650218576,
-0.0086662574,
0.0196246337,
-0.0300522707,
-0.0023730947,
0.0289635006,
-0.028996164,
-0.0354526602,
0.0079227993,
-0.0098845754,
0.0043302099,
-0.0057571186,
-0.0211012159,
0.0236060936,
-0.019471772,
0.0289282575,
0.0453187004,
-0.0343903191,
0.0434688218,
0.0436349027,
0.0258002039,
0.0198058933,
-0.0007751454,
-0.0383182317,
0.0503441691,
-0.028007362,
-0.0525858626,
-0.0186917409,
0.0154573517,
0.0054664384,
-0.0213849675,
0.0150584253,
-0.0464589484,
-0.0600477904,
0.0331949964,
-0.0821881741,
-0.0201782826,
0.0076730349,
0.0016411776,
0.0385539345,
-0.006406127,
0.0469897762,
-0.0229548886,
0.0276027098,
-0.0000865254,
0.0054172198,
-0.0339039341,
0.0032493891,
-0.0350951627,
0.0191885438,
0.0128186764,
-0.0078330496,
-0.0725624561,
-0.0124416659,
-0.0443359278,
0.025049597,
-0.0071823942,
0.0017058151,
0.0007489911,
-0.0054358663,
0.0002338797,
0.052257508,
-0.0158134643,
0.0161488634,
-0.0382898413,
-0.0292766932,
0.0033430757,
0.0504617877,
-0.0461729094,
-0.0397642665,
0.0303814113,
0.0031891617,
0.0227518845,
-0.0247512013,
-0.0227715746,
-0.0192774963,
-0.0549471825,
-0.0751694441,
-0.0081153894,
-0.0412368327,
-0.0223566033,
0.0039225775,
0.0217812601,
-0.0658447593,
-0.0066107991,
0.0502399951,
-0.0475243852,
0.0514994971,
0.0650262311,
0.0172691103,
0.0611633249,
0.0321804769,
0.0133094098,
0.0899344757,
-0.0081820246,
0.0936651826,
0.0503124483,
-0.0020130463,
0.027085647,
0.0424333587,
0.0349690467,
0.0352616087,
-0.0156479422,
0.0117876315,
0.0165658556,
0.0083738863,
-0.0146199698,
0.045015268,
0.0164312776,
-0.0475987233,
0.0860392228,
-0.0176331326,
-0.0135075301,
-0.0237432532,
0.048082225,
0.0226672199,
0.0052328231,
-0.0103769191,
-0.0387185067,
-0.023531042,
-0.0302942786,
-0.0455814116,
0.035428308,
0.0693021715,
-0.0311233439,
-0.0095975259,
-0.0242709164,
0.0028724873,
0.0131204762,
-0.0052163415,
0.0323108807,
-0.0136761693,
-0.0795659646,
0.0034610019,
0.0461591855,
0.0406264998,
0.0214956775,
-0.0690923035,
0.0376578309,
0.0300551392,
0.0464285873,
-0.0274772719,
0.0622927994,
-0.0574784875,
0.0505678356,
0.0390078463,
0.0628883839,
-0.0152186472,
-0.0503289849,
0.0099986801,
-0.0114346789,
-0.0575092062,
0.0280112028,
0.0451246649,
0.0499490425,
0.0235177688,
0.0088353548,
0.0227316711,
-0.0385638252,
0.0263907593,
0.0635844395,
-0.0341074765,
-0.0223840345,
0.0218641888,
0.0471534319,
0.0270486437,
-0.025137281,
-0.0343851745,
0.0435572788,
-0.0204065051,
-0.0396148786,
-0.0612007491,
-0.0194704868,
-0.0331349187,
0.0009381695,
-0.0076862508,
-0.0381970927,
0.0599559993,
-0.0231253877,
0.0221833792,
0.0365909152,
-0.0278854761,
0.0067612585,
-0.0381580889,
-0.0135827856,
-0.0383434668,
0.0307534542,
-0.0270107016,
0.0804245844,
0.0077945222,
0.0049056853,
0.0416842513,
-0.0194320343,
-0.0033716969,
0.0048261634,
-0.0157684963,
-0.0079487534,
0.0104855206,
0.0177446827,
0.0456787907,
-0.0055932417,
0.0025293964,
-0.0496601164,
-0.0710581914,
-0.001818348,
-0.0340275802,
-0.008683743,
0.0281538032,
-0.0165718738,
-0.0061691939,
0.04731315,
-0.0536366962,
-0.0093943495,
0.0046212664,
0.0476712547,
-0.0094330637,
-0.0089568067,
-0.0204075817,
0.0271918923,
0.042156484,
-0.0232369862,
0.0346913673,
0.0226068683,
-0.0327587128,
-0.0063858344,
-0.0061099776,
-0.0148142576,
-0.0119794859,
-0.0324357674,
-0.0169405956,
0.004657384,
0.0165130161,
0.0232634917,
0.042975653,
0.026299648,
0.0689960346,
0.0340049975,
0.02765131,
-0.0423717462,
-0.0278717913,
-0.0520929694,
-0.0152439848,
-0.0409395173,
-0.0427316688,
0.016047623,
0.059249483,
0.0408440046,
0.0084541719,
-0.0427269116,
0.0265274309,
-0.0334484875,
-0.0070229438,
-0.0019094994,
-0.0353216603,
-0.0090039624,
-0.0265796855,
-0.0365672633,
-0.0447936915,
0.0723058283,
-0.0111584235,
0.0424442925,
-0.0265801009,
-0.0408851765,
-0.0061707203,
0.0193463806,
0.0053962017,
0.0443584807,
0.0183409173,
-0.0210059937,
-0.0114946663,
-0.0228930153,
0.0276997723,
-0.0246626996,
-0.0071673598,
-0.0137969693,
0.0327358581,
0.0125212055,
-0.0295538213,
-0.0609131753,
-0.099339433,
-0.0098412596,
-0.0127097266,
0.0012894084,
0.00460468,
-0.0557863824,
0.0201609284,
0.0389063768,
-0.0084952032,
-0.0259131659,
0.0149974544,
0.0197518189,
0.0193544794,
0.0403803214,
-0.0605043769,
0.0230893772,
-0.0112632038,
0.0018051091,
0.0189208351,
-0.0066756355,
0.0483440906,
-0.0143208615,
-0.0223169308,
-0.0001179947,
-0.0197205786,
0.0003270918,
-0.006081244,
0.0151558146,
-0.0309990589,
0.0333820321,
0.1043086275,
0.0179956723,
-0.0538138635,
-0.0196223669,
0.0644616634,
-0.0125762923,
0.0185047798,
-0.0166455712,
-0.0750383288,
-0.0122740148,
0.0193802994,
0.0046626255,
-0.0694520846,
-0.0103842514,
-0.0129247895,
-0.0899029076,
0.0043139681,
-0.004616451,
-0.0280141421,
-0.02487587,
-0.1023702547,
-0.0141493212,
-0.0041535064,
0.0099355076,
-0.0216569081,
0.0114242174,
-0.013188431,
-0.0204480998,
-0.0166343153,
-0.0440393202,
0.0268581267,
0.0060589788,
0.0444570705,
0.0320568383,
0.0524867289,
-0.022004053,
0.0015019373,
0.0470538661,
-0.0169445481,
-0.0331252106,
-0.043576248,
0.0479907654,
-0.0411625691,
-0.0280157309,
-0.0054578008,
0.0359266251,
0.0003351478,
0.0223753955,
0.005911157,
0.0485743098,
0.0313907415,
-0.0616179034,
-0.0105054956,
0.0114212008,
0.0360261053,
0.0899717063,
0.0009508059,
-0.0471899919,
0.0022046671,
-0.0306090284,
-0.0000732079,
-0.0118944002,
-0.0537331663,
0.0132309338,
-0.0236150809,
-0.025410831,
-0.0228552353,
-0.0420603342,
0.0227849241,
-0.0031775127,
0.0321332999,
0.0050586797,
-0.0472837761,
0.032538306,
-0.0178965926,
0.0109401811,
-0.0304186214,
0.0622358881,
-0.0437598042,
0.0015314616,
-0.0025157388,
-0.0314876512,
-0.019949602,
0.0376449227,
-0.0772171319,
-0.0648938566,
0.0016456919,
0.0110724214,
0.019441193,
0.0359355733,
-0.0174094997,
-0.0096161002,
0.081652239,
0.0483269542,
-0.035470143,
0.0196525641,
0.0029438159,
0.0042574154,
0.0116961608,
0.0295873377,
-0.0162751134,
0.0334400237,
0.055349268,
-0.0330732018,
-0.0430888422,
0.0026536037,
0.0424866825,
0.0227329638,
0.039105285,
-0.0238606874,
-0.0371678285,
-0.0594532266,
-0.042627506,
-0.0241287705,
-0.0406437591,
0.0167745668,
0.0099797398,
0.0485958122,
-0.013308147,
-0.0135888234,
0.0166657884,
-0.0299448892,
0.0358997621,
-0.0137930652,
-0.020946946,
-0.0122579914,
0.0602852404,
0.0204031672,
-0.0057651498,
-0.0384291485,
0.0255660042,
0.022468809,
0.0092207165,
0.0054374062,
0.0248048827,
0.0105969943,
-0.0161923934,
0.0572917387,
-0.020658426,
-0.0008014204,
-0.0176449269,
-0.0472568721,
0.0256689638,
0.0454054959,
0.0124788908,
0.0463060476,
-0.0209282525,
-0.0342074968,
-0.024400901,
-0.0003190344,
0.0151072759,
-0.0252617169,
0.0240446124,
0.0155339753,
-0.0397047102,
0.0353955291,
0.0299315769,
0.0193254147,
0.0325697586,
0.0850726888,
-0.0798719153,
-0.0244074818,
-0.0294202901,
0.0286655892,
0.0170327313,
-0.014167144,
0.0073584937,
-0.0731507018,
-0.0411118604,
0.0008111388,
-0.0314803161,
-0.0057616141,
-0.0174190272,
-0.0096914712,
0.0776615292,
-0.0196412299,
0.0210466217,
-0.0590427183,
-0.0142368022,
-0.0240705609,
-0.0609272011,
0.0078021679,
-5.929824232e-33,
0.0119673014,
-0.0264873803,
-0.0230373126,
-0.0155144045,
-0.0103924116,
0.0243890136,
0.0237796195,
-0.0197992995,
-0.0370462909,
0.020150844,
0.0291221905,
0.010444792,
-0.012940485,
0.0066443798,
-0.07327573,
-0.0115304878,
0.0573748387,
-0.0141026014,
-0.0564430207,
0.0280032046,
0.045115117,
-0.0046725739,
0.0285806078,
-0.0506819524,
0.053981062,
0.0095111532,
-0.0564677417,
-0.0109552909,
-0.0078207841,
0.0474862158,
-0.0138275493,
0.0883877277,
0.0469151884,
-0.0462076887,
0.0344319493,
0.0843941122,
-0.0213451553,
0.0006481359,
0.0321381055,
-0.0054253004,
0.0153811956,
-0.0179920122,
0.0153287463,
-0.0085499007,
-0.0172911324,
0.0051214779,
0.0469315462,
-0.0207909159,
0.012627718,
-0.0087476335,
-0.0342137963,
-0.0068099429,
-0.0297089666,
-0.0107821431,
-0.034907829,
0.0485360324,
0.0408874899,
0.1185222417,
-0.0835796893,
0.0166904926,
-0.0248659328,
0.0096153067,
0.0121629508,
-0.0493374243,
0.0040731085,
0.0656828508,
-0.0009207162,
0.0336260051,
-0.0205184706,
0.0066977399,
-0.007512839,
-0.0053304103,
0.0536097623,
0.0651012808,
0.0256242137,
-0.0462709665,
-0.107753925,
-0.0018611866,
0.0734306946,
-0.0220170897,
0.0245224405,
-0.0407598577,
-0.0316838436,
-0.0067728409,
-0.0497726165,
-0.0338137895,
-0.0416133367,
-0.0307684653,
0.0204356611,
0.0425137095,
-0.0335610546,
0.0242305491,
0.0143068796,
-0.0231130607,
-0.0098906094,
0.0362290815,
-0.0285471529,
0.0036704175,
0.0018347327,
0.0534224473,
-0.0601035953,
-0.0089570917,
0.0224267952,
-0.0097517027,
0.0100456439,
-0.0322126485,
0.0413870774,
0.0237211902,
-0.0697716326,
0.0043985923,
-0.0155226765,
0.024892468,
-0.0306990035,
-0.001773615,
0.0162308309,
0.0134477466,
0.0066599976,
0.0081426334,
0.01465875,
-0.0180150773,
0.0424618945,
-0.0297190268,
-0.0105101513,
0.0183791388,
-0.0001678547,
-0.0266346168,
-0.0082635656,
0.0462676734,
0.023735432,
-0.098227039,
-0.0048349057,
-0.0331908055,
2.547e-7,
0.0012524853,
0.0532559231,
-0.0369942859,
0.0103122732,
0.029258877,
0.0359483436,
0.009868402,
0.0215418562,
-0.0228684079,
-0.0699870139,
-0.0206506345,
0.0305017736,
0.0138646653,
0.0138300601,
-0.0760983303,
0.0314100683,
-0.023286406,
0.0030108695,
-0.0923832357,
0.0153741539,
0.0323174484,
0.0956851318,
0.0575159974,
-0.0229725502,
-0.0253524091,
-0.0414047837,
0.0758532062,
-0.0020172973,
-0.0515013859,
0.0343774594,
0.0365431458,
-0.0139130075,
0.0044714548,
0.0038857025,
0.0054230061,
0.0036996815,
-0.0005143465,
0.0725087523,
0.0237230472,
-0.02479049,
-0.0255435519,
-0.01723231,
-0.0233481638,
-0.0749424547,
0.089035973,
-0.0475208461,
-0.0157785453,
-0.0238972623,
-0.0440284051,
-0.0437411591,
0.0499368832,
-0.0233676042,
-0.0269699115,
0.006223904,
-0.0162130855,
0.0188919343,
-0.0005057385,
-0.0556422137,
0.0478627868,
-0.0103298789,
-0.0616473109,
-0.0564417392,
-0.0133978138,
0.0065524038,
0.0260878466,
-0.0339496955,
0.0307913497,
2.226301582e-34,
0.0751559287,
-0.0663832203,
-0.0040610493,
-0.05488405,
0.033704035,
0.0263610799,
-0.0511142015,
-0.0203591548,
0.0073854825,
-0.0488605723,
-0.0009248347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06408v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06408v2 | Humans and language models diverge when predicting repeating text | 2023-10-10T08:24:28 | 2023-10-23T03:15:46 | Aditya R. Vaidya, Javier Turek, Alexander G. Huth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models that are trained on the next-word prediction task have been
shown to accurately model human behavior in word prediction and reading speed.
In contrast with these findings, we present a scenario in which the performance
of humans and LMs diverges. We collected a dataset of human next-word
predictions for five stimuli that are formed by repeating spans of text. Human
and GPT-2 LM predictions are strongly aligned in the first presentation of a
text span, but their performance quickly diverges when memory (or in-context
learning) begins to play a role. We traced the cause of this divergence to
specific attention heads in a middle layer. Adding a power-law recency bias to
these attention heads yielded a model that performs much more similarly to
humans. We hope that this scenario will spur future work in bringing LMs closer
to human behavior. | [
0.0407929569,
0.0068722023,
-0.0276273247,
0.0269563925,
-0.0236278027,
0.0115073808,
-0.0377324857,
0.004606884,
0.0115059949,
0.0152636608,
-0.0190321803,
-0.0998131707,
0.0373679437,
0.0142882662,
0.0449224822,
-0.0522420891,
0.0362990126,
-0.0608432591,
0.0207560696,
0.0016086882,
0.0294277295,
-0.0083031561,
-0.0136083979,
0.0089424755,
0.0166408271,
-0.0152771436,
-0.0125635145,
-0.0139316525,
0.0015756881,
-0.0425702743,
0.015515957,
0.0710445717,
-0.004058898,
0.05984338,
0.0000016109,
-0.0296343919,
0.0475944057,
-0.0270400979,
0.0063151806,
0.016070934,
0.0222560149,
-0.0002193977,
-0.0097133853,
0.0136347301,
-0.0514647625,
0.0086222989,
0.0161970071,
0.0500156805,
-0.0042927181,
0.0391427092,
-0.0111165214,
0.0031410789,
0.0482768677,
-0.0286179371,
0.0519531853,
-0.0392577238,
0.0067689014,
-0.0551865362,
-0.0115777776,
0.0020660597,
-0.0136942752,
0.0163162276,
-0.0144487582,
0.07096304,
0.0046765152,
0.0942871943,
0.0379106887,
-0.004478103,
-0.0531963371,
0.0418233164,
-0.0142574236,
-0.0515285954,
-0.0122601017,
-0.0098866513,
-0.022358058,
0.0045465813,
-0.0320392549,
0.0403723903,
-0.0172665715,
0.0319007561,
0.009985608,
-0.0158331413,
0.0271449946,
0.0021154049,
-0.0014646505,
0.0602593608,
0.0196101461,
-0.0660079345,
0.0184911601,
0.0317100063,
0.0141045749,
-0.0105646448,
-0.0051713665,
0.0245254673,
-0.0033908947,
0.0385464989,
-0.0296309348,
-0.0263266563,
0.0521718301,
-0.0733794793,
0.0854696929,
0.0415005982,
-0.0004336658,
-0.0044794916,
-0.0300648957,
0.0701900497,
-0.0318285115,
0.0024838038,
-0.0100819431,
0.0351604037,
-0.0103769777,
-0.0418289453,
0.0263691898,
-0.021664802,
-0.0074963863,
-0.0250447802,
-0.0471122637,
0.0315126143,
0.0158589724,
-0.0438582003,
-0.0287224855,
0.0088335983,
-0.0275950246,
-0.0266698208,
-0.0720346197,
0.0223884154,
-0.0096734185,
0.0242386758,
-0.0100714322,
-0.0545573458,
-0.0440211147,
0.0114166895,
-0.0478690788,
-0.0402043685,
-0.0406414084,
0.0559521802,
-0.0498989336,
-0.0410790034,
-0.0252432786,
-0.0137857962,
-0.0189038739,
-0.0516600199,
0.0428309813,
-0.0112315193,
0.0158138294,
0.0438685119,
-0.0428132378,
-0.0271496344,
0.0025216257,
0.0525344387,
-0.0518579111,
0.0434193648,
0.0487613119,
0.0319440961,
0.0337370783,
0.0137476651,
-0.0122380918,
0.0353022553,
0.0271932352,
0.0229421165,
-0.0138704889,
0.0196976177,
0.0070185498,
0.0495518818,
0.0063348552,
0.0008330491,
-0.0463836715,
-0.0329869501,
0.026984591,
0.0248041712,
0.0942146778,
0.0568102561,
-0.0081715398,
-0.0520528741,
0.081356898,
0.0733784065,
0.0111132627,
0.0200765841,
0.0041388492,
0.007851094,
-0.0021850567,
0.0572086498,
-0.0677704141,
0.0432254337,
-0.0309897661,
0.0417585298,
0.0274265576,
0.0197829157,
-0.0186913982,
0.0061506038,
-0.0196759421,
-0.0128169488,
0.0318501964,
-0.0312434733,
0.0156535804,
-0.0267886333,
-0.0930824056,
0.0341103785,
0.0198451672,
-0.0069673066,
-0.0048725,
-0.0070875343,
0.0211351551,
0.0642239675,
0.0079432335,
0.0164284967,
-0.0066736802,
0.0399268419,
0.0062225601,
0.0722707286,
0.0330492146,
0.0399517566,
0.0162349008,
-0.0227966756,
-0.0177216772,
0.0364690162,
-0.0146134328,
0.0059015937,
0.0244962499,
0.0224020984,
0.0220740065,
-0.0043710042,
-0.0188879482,
0.0740022287,
-0.0735690147,
-0.0289331544,
-0.0664013475,
-0.014736169,
0.0263548903,
-0.0480171815,
0.0136041725,
0.0366057083,
0.0271332562,
-0.0045083342,
0.0129286861,
0.0140239904,
-0.083136335,
0.0037751037,
0.0344696268,
-0.0300739091,
0.0140082585,
0.0412965938,
0.0194285195,
-0.0322954953,
-0.0031661808,
-0.038405709,
0.0599886663,
-0.0453330539,
0.0171580054,
0.0119630937,
0.0341560729,
-0.0360289961,
0.0450025983,
-0.0303841624,
0.0211771708,
0.0150336865,
-0.0085408613,
-0.0077152732,
-0.0251618903,
-0.0034707482,
0.0123944441,
0.0238971226,
-0.0221960954,
-0.0192492679,
-0.0305922441,
-0.0655516088,
-0.0335577391,
-0.0520386733,
-0.0288768988,
0.0184246209,
0.0044131344,
0.0094383834,
-0.0187903903,
-0.0321728028,
-0.0029052396,
-0.0319828615,
0.0050613205,
-0.0149659934,
0.0450416468,
0.0260589644,
-0.0209520217,
0.0106891943,
-0.0554587841,
-0.0075820801,
-0.0281038508,
0.0296876039,
-0.0113609936,
-0.0170032941,
-0.0737875253,
0.0445875004,
-0.0182151645,
0.0261616614,
-0.0263960753,
-0.0208566412,
0.0276516415,
-0.0003880174,
0.1217636019,
0.0721797273,
0.0662483349,
0.0041004037,
0.0474638045,
0.0179326944,
-0.0249853861,
-0.016696563,
-0.0454745442,
-0.0238134619,
-0.0068486691,
-0.0282076318,
0.000785211,
0.0869885162,
0.0397291966,
0.0217893198,
-0.0483888164,
-0.0271284208,
-0.002623172,
-0.0178276673,
0.0005003774,
-0.0101531548,
-0.0910964757,
0.0547118075,
-0.0255595632,
-0.0770673826,
0.0761548132,
-0.028393859,
-0.0000793977,
-0.0136461249,
0.0329273753,
-0.0007029759,
0.0371474065,
0.0250315405,
-0.0039085909,
-0.0246560369,
-0.0305742808,
-0.0785328746,
0.0126195671,
-0.0037460055,
-0.0218737386,
0.040910095,
-0.023645062,
-0.0191796776,
0.0057033664,
-0.0138306404,
-0.0642083064,
-0.0107547343,
-0.0359313264,
-0.0368404984,
-0.0088533675,
0.0318349302,
-0.0649898499,
0.0053721736,
0.0323210694,
0.0192240719,
-0.0459851772,
-0.0154400747,
0.0030108853,
0.0237979088,
0.0498404987,
0.0189410411,
0.0032510418,
-0.0726686418,
0.0003622301,
0.0548573211,
0.0238412544,
0.0341901407,
-0.0090501485,
0.0210618805,
0.0420047157,
-0.0383303724,
-0.0201573558,
0.0586205982,
0.0158476289,
-0.0452962592,
-0.0025510711,
0.1087937951,
0.0211239159,
-0.076996021,
0.0096910633,
-0.0326264873,
0.0737396851,
0.0107663954,
-0.0024525055,
-0.0149407284,
-0.0118215112,
-0.0009449506,
0.0125714252,
0.0017334252,
-0.0018531873,
-0.0126279304,
-0.0777773336,
-0.0175066385,
0.0383833088,
-0.0497187898,
-0.0116170049,
-0.0464010946,
-0.0036117758,
0.0190648362,
0.0272947475,
0.0531173535,
-0.0254855622,
0.0020066376,
0.0077953967,
-0.0392230041,
0.0025519391,
0.0106881615,
-0.0264362413,
0.0186632629,
0.0799184218,
-0.0019194154,
-0.0067817196,
-0.0579313636,
0.0320091136,
-0.0271719694,
0.0536899753,
0.0178639498,
0.036026042,
-0.007109941,
0.0379624851,
-0.0831850618,
0.021695476,
-0.0233066995,
-0.0293385983,
0.0028243179,
0.0828383639,
-0.0112157678,
-0.0516535416,
-0.0368961804,
0.0464148559,
-0.0243029259,
0.0880135074,
0.0159910005,
-0.0535172522,
-0.0516570956,
0.0136992652,
0.0461154319,
-0.0281185526,
-0.0382613093,
0.0277210884,
0.0290313959,
0.0167038236,
-0.0497777387,
-0.0644813478,
-0.0332440101,
-0.0087221544,
0.0193073135,
0.0699773654,
0.0110862702,
-0.0417189263,
-0.0274518188,
-0.0072903931,
0.0061518904,
-0.0022137335,
-0.0771230012,
-0.0027211804,
-0.020378856,
-0.0419883616,
0.0016150532,
0.0351365246,
-0.1089547426,
-0.0692387447,
0.0228571519,
0.0007734876,
0.0258962493,
0.0318589061,
0.0284229312,
-0.043449074,
0.0197742581,
-0.0062230718,
-0.0236330125,
0.0678321645,
-0.0212147813,
0.0148636065,
0.0124090975,
0.0179424062,
0.0085480725,
0.009944506,
0.0175540596,
0.0206151437,
0.015912829,
-0.0468105413,
-0.0090654427,
-0.0151410056,
0.0961029828,
-0.0217478573,
-0.0047181146,
-0.0366937369,
-0.0163899567,
0.021002708,
0.0362176187,
0.0220906418,
-0.0223266073,
0.0414052308,
0.0073743067,
-0.0457191616,
-0.0477177687,
-0.0305915438,
0.01052419,
-0.0561267138,
-0.0053626001,
-0.0358426273,
0.0150843561,
0.0269024149,
0.0274757165,
-0.0090704747,
0.0076847621,
-0.0650422275,
0.0376952402,
0.0323618427,
0.0645964965,
0.0293792505,
0.0126072895,
-0.0053532482,
-0.0183001142,
-0.0653486326,
-0.0374167524,
-0.0130953705,
-0.0352662876,
0.0000649181,
-0.0396726765,
0.0405977294,
-0.0390322991,
0.037570063,
-0.0211798381,
0.0039666621,
-0.0529274903,
0.0003615686,
0.0309333503,
0.0102836629,
-0.0148130851,
0.0067225629,
0.0913389474,
0.0434347093,
-0.0024081965,
0.0360683277,
-0.027446162,
-0.0148155186,
-0.0235352274,
0.0352499448,
0.0248218365,
-0.022240961,
-0.0215120595,
-0.0560068004,
-0.0273112077,
0.0607054271,
-0.0085767973,
0.0319371,
-0.0566433929,
0.0373233818,
0.0551167056,
-0.0457459316,
-0.0216768086,
-0.0243843682,
0.0027801071,
-0.0034489571,
-0.0270427521,
-0.0447065495,
-5.882624827e-33,
-0.0078547746,
-0.0222835559,
0.039127294,
0.0258157067,
-0.0568045601,
0.0049205492,
-0.0339240804,
0.0343934633,
-0.0160218999,
-0.0012618161,
-0.0215289108,
0.0198134501,
0.0192932859,
0.010746005,
0.0209903177,
-0.0053063966,
0.0011227267,
-0.0428603105,
-0.0155074345,
-0.000667978,
0.016185211,
0.0580237098,
0.0379021168,
-0.0240020063,
0.0295816008,
-0.0437046029,
0.0308506377,
-0.0099848732,
0.0168344565,
0.0388076715,
-0.0776407793,
0.0413749963,
0.0438663922,
-0.0334583335,
-0.0454846136,
0.0284188502,
-0.0134581905,
-0.0362991765,
0.0222432893,
-0.0068562487,
-0.0193522647,
0.0450629294,
0.0640067011,
-0.038861338,
-0.0437270813,
-0.0273634717,
0.0526320674,
-0.0149150686,
-0.0806526616,
0.0366812274,
-0.0599647723,
-0.0065800562,
0.0255899243,
0.0186199434,
0.0174171813,
0.0226844214,
-0.0157367084,
0.0548683517,
-0.0896098912,
0.0146763707,
-0.0117988018,
0.0385354869,
0.0313629061,
0.0471192636,
0.0093542682,
0.0688095614,
0.0694947243,
0.033452291,
-0.0502298474,
-0.0177512225,
0.0493212901,
-0.0005107235,
0.0091523258,
-0.0229629148,
0.0592836551,
-0.0367318802,
-0.0106189027,
0.0134361535,
0.0046403743,
0.043471273,
0.0786049515,
0.0118242865,
-0.0581361875,
-0.0280543696,
-0.0136166215,
0.0058111255,
-0.0199588519,
-0.0325790569,
0.0110765491,
-0.007965412,
0.0810660422,
-0.0263636019,
0.0434497669,
0.0057753357,
0.0158834606,
0.0115812467,
-0.0191775914,
-0.0129516358,
0.0019507236,
0.0243565422,
-0.0693375692,
0.0039806422,
-0.0013670059,
0.0439783596,
-0.0110124024,
0.016668506,
-0.0207473915,
-0.014016361,
-0.0656317025,
-0.0213920493,
-0.0584450923,
-0.027666131,
0.0471348651,
0.0041530766,
0.0556939207,
-0.0474498458,
-0.0099768722,
0.0083004702,
-0.0223288182,
-0.0474602617,
-0.029200634,
-0.0106202951,
-0.0087853782,
0.0083221458,
-0.0269417614,
0.0084529631,
-0.0343323909,
0.0276211761,
0.0365331024,
-0.065193288,
-0.0106336838,
0.0477048568,
2.459e-7,
0.0112542128,
0.0602910183,
0.0165239926,
0.0234645214,
0.0259121042,
0.0033625541,
-0.0091749514,
0.0328239165,
0.0036245845,
0.0052592126,
0.015450215,
0.0327288434,
0.044337403,
-0.0253089648,
-0.0659257323,
-0.0004915667,
-0.080925487,
0.0396989062,
-0.0177516975,
-0.028909713,
0.0076878923,
0.0251228288,
-0.0018052021,
-0.034433499,
0.0229746792,
-0.0230324585,
0.0679034293,
-0.0536764078,
0.0330756679,
-0.0309728291,
0.0220797788,
0.0215059444,
-0.0050640255,
0.018259868,
-0.0105637582,
-0.0077533354,
-0.0134405047,
0.0150083527,
-0.001399672,
-0.0519080237,
0.0289432295,
0.0119140847,
-0.0059783324,
-0.0568087772,
0.02643607,
0.0014672163,
-0.0292040817,
0.0275902841,
0.0003533924,
-0.0124449115,
0.0176445972,
0.0170775577,
-0.0108956546,
0.0015341007,
0.0084493319,
0.0088338349,
-0.0088935699,
-0.0827765539,
-0.0460040905,
0.0444116741,
-0.061600484,
-0.0170481075,
-0.0868138447,
-0.0004438096,
0.0619353615,
-0.0436565652,
-0.0192121025,
1.821249877e-34,
-0.0049396213,
-0.0479685478,
0.0303117521,
0.0434621572,
0.0169726238,
0.0037232961,
0.0381835289,
0.0432340093,
0.029442599,
-0.0704296082,
-0.0266159177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06404v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06404v3 | Hexa: Self-Improving for Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue System | 2023-10-10T08:15:24 | 2024-04-02T11:28:40 | Daejin Jo, Daniel Wontae Nam, Gunsoo Han, Kyoung-Woon On, Taehwan Kwon, Seungeun Rho, Sungwoong Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A common practice in knowledge-grounded dialogue generation is to explicitly
utilize intermediate steps (e.g., web-search, memory retrieval) with modular
approaches. However, data for such steps are often inaccessible compared to
those of dialogue responses as they are unobservable in an ordinary dialogue.
To fill in the absence of these data, we develop a self-improving method to
improve the generative performances of intermediate steps without the ground
truth data. In particular, we propose a novel bootstrapping scheme with a
guided prompt and a modified loss function to enhance the diversity of
appropriate self-generated responses. Through experiments on various benchmark
datasets, we empirically demonstrate that our method successfully leverages a
self-improving mechanism in generating intermediate and final responses and
improves the performances on the task of knowledge-grounded dialogue
generation. | [
0.0554561727,
0.0405756645,
0.0065706898,
-0.0108440667,
-0.000386133,
-0.0215751864,
-0.0145890284,
-0.0197425205,
0.0110399993,
-0.0336505733,
-0.0229008943,
-0.0129492935,
-0.0150828147,
0.0303058997,
0.0338821709,
-0.0462868437,
0.0274445359,
-0.0179062206,
-0.0179461967,
-0.0541271381,
-0.0065864036,
0.0023507166,
-0.0525927022,
0.0244723968,
-0.0375421718,
-0.0069878916,
-0.0483359955,
0.0096645467,
0.0121400552,
-0.028406335,
0.0264331102,
0.0592230074,
0.0183563065,
0.0221546926,
0.0000018078,
-0.0399798378,
0.0070652105,
-0.0505595729,
-0.062017519,
-0.0396850258,
-0.025332056,
0.0413067043,
-0.0109342774,
0.0401547961,
-0.0517892763,
-0.0103241317,
0.0221772268,
0.061144311,
0.1084649414,
0.0667567551,
-0.0018717762,
-0.0297564827,
-0.0024846154,
-0.0109716207,
0.0125580551,
0.0040135118,
-0.0301435068,
0.0447562113,
-0.0037688576,
0.0383738838,
-0.0043214075,
0.0089393426,
0.0341616087,
-0.061181277,
0.0227017477,
0.0410026051,
0.0011655082,
0.0148550794,
-0.01462611,
0.0900847614,
0.0673545226,
0.0047791656,
-0.0109546827,
-0.0019892466,
0.0403665528,
-0.0272412226,
-0.0346290655,
0.0201335307,
-0.0149590513,
0.0058429418,
-0.03186322,
0.0729336366,
-0.02779953,
0.0191849619,
-0.0115731955,
0.0667841211,
-0.0109226843,
-0.0337004811,
0.0042949226,
0.0142145418,
0.0150353471,
-0.0376267768,
-0.0022915059,
0.0346513093,
-0.0238088574,
0.0159362648,
-0.0297544859,
0.0555066392,
0.0222533122,
0.0156914704,
0.0315572508,
0.0223511979,
-0.0160271674,
0.0319181792,
-0.0067700366,
0.0272323154,
-0.0048660794,
-0.0320655182,
-0.0091327941,
0.0394533575,
-0.0413284488,
-0.01523518,
-0.0659495369,
0.0455846749,
-0.0850321278,
-0.0241042059,
-0.0404273197,
0.0502697788,
-0.005692428,
0.0040293466,
0.003392128,
0.0265738498,
-0.0480000637,
0.0181046668,
-0.0366419666,
0.0096922377,
-0.065507926,
-0.0063963449,
0.0672915876,
-0.0516660474,
-0.0263878163,
0.0253780168,
0.0096428627,
0.006950458,
-0.0160051975,
0.0283485297,
-0.0375825763,
-0.0125556476,
-0.0388665162,
-0.0523454137,
-0.0424965359,
-0.0756770149,
-0.0079762442,
-0.0403530598,
0.027793644,
-0.0312743187,
-0.038889572,
-0.0081935255,
0.0121660251,
0.0089926291,
0.0174087081,
0.0412128046,
-0.0309126582,
-0.0060873651,
0.0426056162,
-0.0036592239,
0.004458487,
0.056845814,
0.0052200397,
0.0240895338,
0.0265326537,
0.0094386302,
0.0185619183,
-0.0405822955,
0.0480002724,
-0.0049040802,
0.0289271399,
0.0244592987,
-0.0316332653,
0.0581785403,
0.0203425419,
0.0194690004,
-0.0588032864,
0.0227179546,
0.0455801785,
0.0304238591,
0.0054486799,
0.0224811826,
0.0318274908,
0.0255201757,
0.0077658235,
0.0384015851,
-0.0207687579,
0.0215392094,
-0.0105180424,
0.0194089543,
0.040457692,
-0.0042947591,
-0.0472267829,
-0.0554715507,
0.0360798985,
0.0287779551,
0.0077101849,
-0.008876279,
0.0175072383,
0.0564560592,
-0.0484574512,
0.0046659024,
-0.0003127191,
-0.0718468726,
-0.0092431912,
-0.0312306061,
0.0298584197,
0.0531580001,
0.0594457388,
-0.0014088888,
-0.0689853281,
-0.0336577445,
0.041649729,
0.0639526919,
-0.0212491304,
-0.0264348648,
0.0228240564,
-0.0578791313,
-0.0237650909,
-0.0387664177,
-0.0092312573,
0.0145197259,
0.0032866714,
-0.0001820655,
0.0304226,
-0.0286011174,
0.0643916354,
0.0038328364,
-0.0151697425,
0.0021200979,
0.0510590561,
0.0219404455,
0.0091221519,
0.0483956039,
-0.0023068974,
-0.0003620703,
0.0236289278,
-0.0124076596,
-0.0576145016,
0.0121218795,
-0.0965594649,
-0.0845750049,
0.0125432033,
-0.003374944,
0.0154624749,
-0.0122734234,
-0.0163102392,
-0.0751020759,
0.031671904,
-0.053409528,
0.009008117,
-0.0605203658,
0.0068342197,
0.0511485077,
0.0204159953,
-0.0380325429,
0.0559922308,
0.0001866098,
-0.0153936753,
0.0109955473,
0.064410314,
0.0230403356,
-0.0847120211,
0.0202947389,
0.0231338888,
-0.037829835,
0.01266002,
0.032993447,
0.019179903,
-0.0680644885,
-0.0139650069,
-0.0920402408,
-0.0006698227,
-0.0222409591,
-0.0114656957,
0.0225005746,
-0.0077633695,
-0.0156928021,
-0.0353335813,
-0.064494431,
0.0110089919,
0.0801950693,
-0.0008012917,
0.0535077304,
0.0273789018,
0.0228275247,
-0.0246495474,
0.0128153004,
0.0388455726,
0.0305377338,
-0.002233647,
0.0283668712,
-0.0592401288,
0.0083223907,
-0.0710290447,
0.0303278286,
-0.0014931656,
-0.0466268584,
0.0359594226,
0.0056957211,
0.0565118976,
0.0254432745,
0.0569436252,
0.0602975301,
-0.0117410971,
-0.0283677746,
-0.072986789,
0.0462254919,
-0.0394634865,
0.0311060976,
-0.002373772,
0.0200423356,
0.0072924914,
0.0159736536,
0.0469733663,
0.0321408808,
-0.0614835545,
0.0299739465,
0.0416206345,
-0.0477425307,
-0.0166208819,
0.021269409,
-0.023212513,
0.0427212492,
-0.0254460182,
-0.0191872511,
0.0766627565,
-0.0219453629,
-0.015793521,
-0.0335288718,
0.017965151,
0.0055496772,
0.0462174416,
-0.0534748882,
0.0119028203,
0.0046543279,
-0.0294476449,
-0.0232055187,
-0.0067422725,
0.0442689918,
-0.0380002744,
0.0411784537,
-0.0257805903,
0.009101375,
0.0150086004,
-0.0487253107,
-0.0845560953,
-0.0057848473,
0.0338449441,
-0.0227401312,
0.0044036689,
0.0117551656,
0.0192294884,
0.0111067919,
0.0062219365,
0.052172754,
-0.0227713082,
-0.0080400426,
-0.0214548521,
0.0456161909,
0.0309301633,
0.0258824117,
0.0318435505,
0.0051286481,
0.1090592295,
0.0342598595,
0.0638244972,
-0.0190948509,
0.0094551733,
-0.012282812,
0.006520093,
-0.0092505179,
0.0166727975,
-0.005218023,
0.0709014609,
-0.0142034767,
-0.0516968034,
0.097799167,
0.01461838,
0.0282619186,
-0.0029327639,
-0.015137325,
0.0366489738,
0.0106036514,
0.0188854896,
-0.0518587045,
-0.0106297899,
0.0047717984,
0.0688400865,
-0.0147340531,
-0.0454015657,
0.0041374532,
-0.1194893122,
0.0613064952,
-0.0006243958,
-0.0485555604,
-0.0435738005,
-0.0058605978,
-0.0085728774,
0.0276069958,
-0.0002850312,
0.0320682004,
0.0110231638,
0.0215932447,
0.0047784583,
0.0044451109,
-0.0535963438,
-0.0339353681,
-0.0117681576,
0.0713604018,
0.0444168448,
0.0378437415,
0.0713662133,
-0.0001584754,
0.0125855291,
-0.0376740582,
0.0158115476,
-0.0139781702,
0.0441438295,
0.0107699689,
-0.0148148583,
-0.0227386784,
0.0485082939,
-0.0268010776,
-0.0044524507,
0.0254166797,
-0.0022768108,
-0.074350372,
0.015313725,
-0.004148257,
0.069625631,
0.0322238281,
0.0549592674,
0.0399347693,
-0.024952732,
-0.0272993781,
-0.0085740723,
0.0387478918,
-0.0565566346,
0.0155452173,
0.0087908907,
0.0320667922,
0.0485975854,
-0.1112812608,
-0.0864743739,
0.00096473,
0.0904338807,
-0.0386427566,
-0.0243967324,
-0.0445807427,
0.0210463833,
-0.0152484039,
-0.0102820983,
-0.0189491343,
-0.0236608647,
-0.0682599097,
-0.0238453802,
0.0345379561,
-0.0498526506,
0.0143375956,
0.0040102927,
-0.0232943911,
-0.0608772524,
-0.0165760368,
0.0777278543,
0.0209303237,
0.0653011724,
0.007937423,
-0.0001992474,
0.0308840051,
0.0274015963,
-0.0266166795,
0.0021264732,
0.0303464457,
0.0450917147,
-0.0291534141,
0.0363853425,
-0.0144411651,
0.0393113419,
0.0030416041,
0.0825603753,
-0.0157756843,
-0.076628454,
0.0299792271,
-0.0180530082,
0.0353600644,
-0.0203794353,
0.0038773185,
-0.0212564711,
0.0324929282,
-0.0329808593,
-0.024078615,
-0.0602159165,
0.0377296805,
-0.0114022531,
-0.0205441713,
0.0274898987,
-0.0258467477,
-0.0635267794,
0.0916492641,
-0.033864893,
-0.0368113779,
-0.0134952301,
0.0096911285,
0.0004065672,
-0.0079618525,
-0.0172523633,
0.0292512756,
0.0306478702,
0.0088283429,
0.0101681482,
0.1007861942,
0.0208754875,
-0.025097657,
0.0214077793,
0.0466561653,
-0.0453296266,
0.0014643621,
-0.0561526641,
0.0245811343,
0.0045787278,
0.064905785,
0.0100130038,
-0.0032987995,
0.0050508422,
0.0093917791,
0.0464546829,
0.0027379959,
-0.0514466502,
0.0200177506,
0.0241465513,
-0.0136600258,
-0.0107307425,
0.0400192626,
-0.0286083221,
0.0241794437,
-0.0166105349,
0.0152826803,
-0.0721522272,
-0.0612068474,
-0.0565434992,
0.0103042126,
0.0235281624,
0.0301799811,
-0.0327931121,
-0.049718786,
-0.0425161682,
0.0323780924,
-0.0120626586,
0.0065327375,
0.068480894,
0.0405113213,
-0.0019030379,
0.0107049523,
-0.0311150923,
0.0288372412,
-0.0461942516,
-0.0123639489,
-0.0208462924,
-5.674724693e-33,
-0.0601928532,
-0.0410661735,
0.042029243,
0.0074016144,
-0.0358820222,
-0.041378133,
-0.0433413275,
0.0154010961,
0.0207802709,
0.0199698284,
-0.009264417,
-0.0134049952,
0.0048936144,
0.0611237809,
-0.0385026261,
0.014417083,
0.0652823523,
-0.0010484846,
-0.0458635949,
0.0543185286,
0.0298025534,
0.0360805877,
-0.0031022602,
-0.0630232766,
-0.0063846651,
-0.0194497537,
-0.0263249949,
0.0563253835,
0.01846941,
0.047499463,
-0.0181106981,
0.0365872644,
0.0084097637,
-0.0697086379,
-0.0091962563,
0.0149321118,
-0.0695508942,
-0.0374239534,
-0.0139635941,
-0.0170138869,
-0.0373577774,
-0.0049460083,
-0.025686942,
-0.0565639287,
0.0102879042,
0.0244383588,
-0.0190772656,
-0.0191782769,
-0.0168716721,
-0.0327800177,
-0.0425400808,
0.0128094982,
-0.0159994084,
-0.0743476599,
-0.0563486554,
0.0872007906,
0.0289126243,
-0.0731832832,
-0.0211004987,
0.0432590879,
-0.003252164,
-0.0113242399,
0.0470746607,
0.0303815454,
-0.0006381509,
0.0454119295,
0.0180030745,
0.0097941235,
-0.0402787142,
-0.0282301884,
-0.0236857384,
0.0008112342,
0.0199055858,
0.0595602058,
-0.0197237581,
-0.0030383763,
-0.0217650179,
0.0255378876,
0.0235430207,
0.0040051816,
-0.0251284856,
-0.0145182414,
-0.0178683996,
-0.0058536869,
-0.0402886607,
-0.0136681981,
-0.0011657036,
-0.0594108179,
0.04778824,
0.0441865399,
-0.0655478761,
-0.0300064906,
0.0212144703,
-0.0038518757,
-0.0044347914,
0.035681475,
-0.0420200191,
0.0017175266,
-0.0088688629,
-0.0185863655,
-0.0098944018,
-0.027262643,
0.0694909319,
0.0137958787,
-0.0115740895,
0.0235803798,
-0.0121767176,
0.007218577,
-0.0643772855,
0.0171106514,
-0.0267114583,
0.1004469618,
-0.0283055678,
-0.0227442849,
-0.0102841193,
-0.0207161438,
-0.0358743891,
0.0653089806,
0.0153690828,
0.0016530674,
-0.0289137922,
-0.0263791922,
0.0063909022,
0.0192261264,
-0.0242581461,
0.0164004937,
0.0055691903,
-0.0148425661,
-0.0170420781,
-0.0380650871,
0.0002742371,
0.0042215982,
2.509e-7,
-0.0501040593,
-0.0058316626,
0.0561081693,
-0.0187182985,
0.0169514883,
0.0294444412,
0.0018640126,
-0.006938966,
0.0033721512,
-0.0503823049,
-0.0013603619,
0.026478935,
0.038062077,
0.0045338739,
-0.0816273913,
-0.021126518,
-0.0474792123,
-0.0412454382,
-0.0196308605,
-0.0565685704,
0.0481692292,
0.0193328168,
-0.0132205021,
-0.0123903751,
-0.0013817395,
0.0110300705,
0.0498463959,
0.0211707335,
-0.0122111859,
0.0009861026,
0.0551644489,
-0.0083298841,
-0.0152509706,
0.0079511972,
0.0035632346,
0.0329687409,
-0.0181080699,
0.0152242286,
0.0211026259,
-0.0539239347,
0.0138026997,
0.0184632186,
0.0476066321,
-0.0182614215,
0.0210227966,
-0.0607558116,
0.0082171224,
-0.0019159546,
-0.0134057933,
-0.0401415676,
0.0176278818,
-0.052400656,
-0.0471833758,
0.007956801,
0.0273412913,
0.0198514611,
0.0496471003,
-0.0884940848,
0.0122454986,
-0.0031274713,
-0.055694323,
-0.0199725684,
-0.0294002481,
-0.0354282036,
0.001883838,
-0.009745623,
-0.0116413785,
1.914203699e-34,
0.0178975891,
-0.001212312,
0.0224006791,
0.0049018809,
0.0086104134,
0.0105917612,
0.0210466534,
-0.0021164231,
0.0478080027,
-0.0161443762,
-0.023961762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06391v1 | Improved prompting and process for writing user personas with LLMs, using qualitative interviews: Capturing behaviour and personality traits of users | 2023-10-10T07:54:24 | 2023-10-10T07:54:24 | Stefano De Paoli | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY | This draft paper presents a workflow for creating User Personas with Large
Language Models, using the results of a Thematic Analysis of qualitative
interviews. The proposed workflow uses improved prompting and a larger pool of
Themes, compared to previous work conducted by the author for the same task.
This is possible due to the capabilities of a recently released LLM which
allows the processing of 16 thousand tokens (GPT3.5-Turbo-16k) and also due to
the possibility to offer a refined prompting for the creation of Personas. The
paper offers details of performing Phase 2 and 3 of Thematic Analysis, and then
discusses the improved workflow for creating Personas. The paper also offers
some reflections on the relationship between the proposed process and existing
approaches to Personas such as the data-driven and qualitative Personas.
Moreover, the paper offers reflections on the capacity of LLMs to capture user
behaviours and personality traits, from the underlying dataset of qualitative
interviews used for the analysis. | [
0.0685993209,
0.0129508786,
-0.0515154377,
0.0235426072,
-0.0058783051,
-0.0030361575,
0.0009268997,
-0.0513505861,
0.0020427834,
0.0325686634,
0.0047449153,
0.0014768901,
-0.0201375373,
0.0422292426,
0.0140591804,
-0.0456363894,
0.0257803742,
-0.024537025,
-0.0200588275,
0.0277277362,
-0.0041549806,
0.0728329122,
0.0140497889,
0.0447762311,
-0.0018993495,
-0.0350190401,
-0.0046382933,
0.0138416719,
0.0461854003,
-0.022508936,
0.023525279,
0.007924635,
0.0220786873,
-0.006437846,
0.0000022626,
-0.0472578816,
0.018836759,
-0.0041673072,
-0.0257641971,
-0.0276951231,
0.0321131386,
0.1032042131,
-0.0234387275,
0.0211562607,
-0.0219617654,
0.0157739129,
0.0208561607,
0.0442067608,
0.0652343109,
0.0217636358,
-0.0318634771,
-0.0836532936,
-0.0353073813,
0.0250651632,
-0.0070064035,
0.0215234775,
-0.0319324508,
-0.0247210339,
0.0247838907,
-0.019962946,
0.041966226,
-0.0063185529,
-0.0170473177,
0.0033060897,
0.017449433,
0.0141773922,
0.0036534469,
-0.0598274693,
-0.0145053556,
0.0470826216,
0.0606615692,
0.0257521924,
-0.0069564115,
0.0120397359,
0.0350898392,
0.0175668411,
-0.0027862317,
0.0154212704,
-0.0438215919,
-0.0125784408,
-0.0360156,
0.029143041,
0.0029541117,
0.0067096907,
-0.0353979878,
0.0132568106,
0.0058308546,
-0.004600517,
-0.0002550616,
-0.0475531071,
0.0544709936,
-0.0230940077,
-0.0113195814,
0.0418974161,
-0.0035178273,
0.0206771791,
0.0050966837,
0.0526016057,
0.022966424,
-0.0411449447,
0.0205333363,
0.0350281559,
0.0043427367,
-0.0120227309,
0.023674313,
0.0341110453,
0.0228402261,
-0.0466261245,
0.0066160019,
0.0036418217,
-0.049175635,
-0.0135064349,
-0.0225144587,
0.0345199816,
0.0136319753,
0.0186289437,
-0.0373699889,
0.0754378587,
0.0238812324,
0.0457105488,
0.0030892678,
-0.0124416258,
-0.0203451701,
0.0229610447,
-0.054415673,
-0.0034453189,
-0.0663449466,
0.0100665083,
-0.0299681053,
-0.041359704,
0.0746765435,
0.0129186641,
0.0080371639,
-0.0202887822,
0.0266963355,
0.0399999507,
0.0176059436,
-0.0157581922,
-0.0648745969,
-0.0766040981,
0.0188989881,
-0.0388051011,
-0.0340390429,
-0.0654498562,
0.0047608349,
0.0329900347,
-0.0073944731,
-0.0468335859,
-0.0088622905,
0.0471290462,
0.0310496464,
0.0318025649,
-0.0473994501,
0.0375325121,
0.0304537155,
0.0233533289,
0.0424361452,
0.0061039999,
0.0022390489,
0.0463746898,
0.0009031481,
-0.0603667833,
0.0316771492,
0.0392923541,
-0.0670120642,
0.0086949393,
-0.0002397661,
0.0165585745,
-0.0065371916,
0.0022596435,
0.0349081159,
0.0228774566,
-0.0084147546,
0.0672928542,
0.0575492643,
0.0721776932,
0.0496884286,
0.0360341109,
0.0332084633,
0.0213984903,
0.0303762816,
-0.0336743034,
0.034113843,
0.0161733143,
0.0465063378,
-0.0113940202,
-0.0488944873,
0.0459382348,
-0.0337610506,
-0.0266938098,
0.0114620514,
-0.0146946386,
0.0068673207,
0.0404927135,
-0.0352661423,
0.0068217288,
-0.0048012533,
0.0247010291,
-0.0051983707,
-0.1039032266,
-0.0199191067,
-0.049692817,
0.0311649069,
0.1476365775,
0.0197283216,
0.0198880583,
-0.0163607672,
-0.0398714468,
-0.0353227518,
0.0507869907,
0.0183793865,
-0.0170610882,
-0.0476805195,
-0.0347529426,
0.0021683543,
-0.0357048139,
-0.0523991659,
0.0242387298,
-0.0213866867,
0.0155813694,
0.0094171371,
0.0415484086,
-0.0144054405,
-0.0100554796,
-0.0720302761,
-0.0435203277,
0.0079992395,
0.0221610069,
0.0033161668,
0.0690659434,
0.0250113495,
-0.0006518342,
0.0149198677,
-0.0119935526,
0.0389586128,
0.0644145384,
0.0346794538,
0.0668455213,
0.0313948952,
-0.0311730728,
-0.0051867031,
-0.0026218272,
0.0287722554,
-0.0081095612,
0.0106226541,
-0.0185715295,
0.0330621041,
-0.0136559298,
-0.012118523,
-0.015920369,
0.0216030795,
-0.0175027847,
0.0264251418,
-0.0157736242,
-0.0225098953,
0.0126542244,
0.0032525663,
0.0056693107,
-0.0550146066,
0.0129279112,
-0.0146353897,
0.0028567882,
0.0445220992,
0.0083171073,
-0.003606681,
-0.0551100634,
-0.0368384086,
-0.0930686146,
-0.0215290524,
0.0061143553,
0.0144800805,
0.035482157,
0.0143128578,
-0.0575650632,
-0.0140976384,
-0.0539088063,
-0.0504098348,
0.0086289076,
-0.0260676704,
0.0759893879,
0.0093891574,
-0.0045529148,
-0.0123695023,
0.0165283848,
-0.0191919859,
0.0009531075,
-0.0024770801,
-0.0219383892,
-0.0461342745,
-0.0052056066,
-0.0310345925,
-0.0740766749,
-0.0156180365,
-0.0232701954,
0.0508038253,
0.0164216571,
0.1050115228,
-0.0502763949,
0.0247385111,
0.0621017441,
-0.0125951106,
-0.0091766473,
0.0040017283,
0.003510678,
0.0192648266,
-0.005638591,
-0.0182456169,
-0.0964462012,
0.0773473307,
0.0002897674,
-0.0164108574,
0.0271887314,
-0.0390428007,
0.0810364783,
0.0203098115,
0.0100022936,
0.0396145992,
-0.0086424556,
-0.0323287547,
0.0634127781,
0.0476241149,
-0.009322701,
0.0064934539,
-0.0178942457,
0.0118968543,
-0.0167657118,
-0.0777632073,
-0.0188656617,
0.036676418,
-0.0532442555,
0.0304977056,
-0.0220772456,
-0.0284155868,
-0.0101981228,
-0.078231968,
-0.0303766262,
-0.0391883925,
0.035006389,
-0.0057147313,
-0.0323229879,
0.0040217019,
0.0191457514,
-0.0255816802,
-0.0339015834,
-0.0497746095,
-0.0433744863,
-0.0040449519,
-0.0037710879,
0.000254737,
-0.0138006909,
0.0116833374,
0.004738518,
-0.0020654653,
-0.0137802614,
0.001317606,
-0.0392683409,
0.019338008,
-0.0019640874,
-0.0048450427,
-0.0225302726,
0.0335250385,
-0.007477019,
-0.0374678522,
-0.0263947677,
-0.0038058346,
-0.0372760408,
0.0322502516,
-0.0303435344,
-0.0260435659,
0.0299820062,
0.0442118123,
-0.0097229723,
-0.0027917693,
0.082828261,
0.0070410892,
-0.0222412292,
0.0352245495,
-0.0034518682,
-0.021192139,
0.0328771695,
0.0812572166,
-0.0463778041,
0.0141323917,
-0.030723013,
0.0502345711,
-0.0386139713,
-0.0167821478,
-0.04600868,
-0.0167533178,
0.0520646572,
0.0157029312,
-0.0184746254,
0.0268575568,
-0.0124489963,
-0.0213373601,
0.0403247625,
0.0496385768,
0.0077244621,
-0.0275693182,
-0.0088344729,
0.0292227846,
-0.0829662383,
-0.0495180264,
0.0206146482,
-0.0157478545,
0.0135886399,
0.0324847698,
0.0626645088,
-0.0137695037,
-0.0762092471,
-0.0661845878,
0.0521477535,
0.0407662913,
0.0193360783,
0.0046049845,
-0.0268511716,
0.0131164687,
-0.0800364166,
0.0331093669,
-0.0319267884,
-0.0247238111,
0.0305340718,
0.0390609354,
-0.0634849966,
-0.0190785397,
-0.0401687101,
-0.0078226812,
0.0196173899,
0.0145197622,
0.0088152764,
-0.0858952329,
0.0050291833,
0.0043194043,
0.0126884654,
-0.0185717903,
-0.0697770864,
-0.0139181819,
0.0107003273,
0.0188719481,
-0.0011616054,
-0.0855050161,
0.0111639947,
0.049436003,
0.0188706499,
0.0140511096,
-0.0213719122,
0.0314220674,
-0.0260433499,
0.0242287572,
-0.0333090201,
0.0660407245,
-0.0755369365,
-0.011514008,
0.0375094749,
-0.0479066521,
0.0435309932,
-0.0334557816,
-0.0257183425,
-0.007405513,
0.0056284773,
0.0466033965,
0.0278252121,
-0.0215564556,
0.0467048474,
-0.0697298795,
0.0228843242,
-0.0024981934,
-0.0376522653,
0.006119932,
-0.0143475672,
0.0890194029,
-0.0328901298,
-0.0152059579,
-0.0112080239,
-0.0267752428,
-0.0228909273,
-0.0257967357,
-0.0573547818,
-0.0744547546,
0.011239443,
0.0423799008,
-0.0211771168,
-0.0468551144,
0.0044784714,
0.0043991907,
-0.0151519822,
-0.0105616283,
-0.0433770232,
0.0045078285,
-0.0222242568,
-0.012136667,
-0.0063115889,
0.0264900457,
-0.0628942698,
-0.0928552598,
0.0014763426,
-0.0353200547,
0.042800881,
0.0053205802,
0.0439319275,
0.0056671388,
-0.0128209703,
-0.0333858542,
0.0074234139,
0.0095363446,
0.0426509604,
0.0304216575,
0.0426085554,
-0.0344526879,
0.0340927988,
-0.0021033669,
0.0622746982,
0.0219472665,
-0.0628114194,
0.0438537002,
-0.0182401258,
-0.0188846979,
0.02387367,
-0.0007130826,
-0.0359146371,
0.0201575123,
-0.0216375384,
0.019576624,
-0.0009543292,
-0.0033197945,
-0.004375502,
-0.0036133472,
-0.044083301,
-0.0945017189,
0.0209510922,
-0.0310846288,
-0.0156023502,
-0.0389049836,
-0.03904346,
-0.0524795651,
-0.0220806859,
0.0403053313,
0.0103753032,
-0.0505161695,
-0.0637546778,
-0.0940446407,
-0.0470663719,
0.0168266501,
-0.0375487022,
-0.0285995249,
-0.0480721779,
0.0322022475,
0.0190652665,
0.0169848055,
-0.0248172227,
-0.0546425991,
-0.0077015567,
-0.0643793568,
0.0087205349,
0.0170507822,
-5.931222335e-33,
-0.0168380216,
-0.0526210703,
0.0634245425,
0.0239031948,
-0.0282942615,
-0.0544978566,
-0.0084219528,
0.0204670858,
0.0213334896,
-0.0256454498,
-0.0284190495,
-0.0514604338,
0.0099392598,
-0.0134564983,
0.0026868815,
0.0432293527,
0.0735237673,
0.0371802114,
-0.016148651,
0.046528317,
0.00994494,
0.0066148113,
0.0204488747,
-0.0593678802,
0.0253955014,
-0.0392394774,
-0.0170031413,
-0.0023289325,
0.0478302538,
0.0269344766,
0.0169923995,
0.0058114138,
0.0261447132,
0.0419799685,
-0.0069486978,
0.0501806512,
-0.0125353504,
-0.0197708476,
0.0398979113,
0.0643989518,
0.0103993379,
-0.0889979675,
0.0052316962,
-0.0310406312,
-0.027727427,
0.0337233357,
0.0517288446,
0.0131614869,
0.02147099,
-0.0095032863,
-0.0429625362,
-0.0087358812,
0.0016041124,
0.0275389943,
-0.0197678935,
0.0247734711,
-0.0467053205,
-0.0354441591,
-0.0834455267,
0.045553565,
-0.0244110525,
-0.0693804175,
0.0457435437,
0.0584759824,
-0.0232864562,
0.0138844736,
-0.0040406305,
0.0426475406,
-0.022117421,
0.0495596193,
0.011805498,
0.0579746254,
-0.0061926702,
0.0419278368,
-0.0606602058,
-0.0537645631,
0.0285131577,
0.0357003175,
0.0673630983,
-0.0243118536,
0.0506452397,
0.0016728793,
-0.0233592652,
-0.0420842133,
-0.0005011432,
0.0419607162,
-0.0019639477,
-0.0627352148,
-0.0073107337,
-0.0615587309,
-0.0443757661,
-0.02509767,
0.0030812519,
-0.0230082348,
-0.015639348,
-0.0338092484,
-0.0285408981,
-0.0035883014,
-0.0111968387,
-0.0003291974,
-0.0186530743,
-0.0037933819,
-0.0128321117,
-0.0014253533,
0.0584968328,
0.045313742,
-0.0252963547,
0.0172380432,
-0.0637461692,
-0.0099451263,
0.0145310601,
0.0507539921,
-0.0196221806,
0.0437527411,
-0.0027377482,
-0.00892678,
-0.0133250831,
0.0121631697,
0.0070345136,
-0.0167857688,
-0.0251791347,
-0.0007963679,
-0.0117407218,
0.007503123,
-0.0197121911,
-0.0099865003,
-0.0621351451,
0.0603215843,
0.1167610362,
-0.0123536186,
-0.0014195044,
-0.004623313,
3.057e-7,
-0.0425935909,
0.0329772085,
-0.031502746,
0.0111950347,
0.0171762742,
0.0291373413,
0.0299099889,
0.0221867301,
0.0081029795,
0.0211672224,
0.0348745845,
0.0112234401,
0.0118904877,
0.0542925484,
-0.0931374058,
0.0364862308,
0.0180157535,
0.030755505,
-0.0894954801,
0.0692335293,
0.0731668323,
-0.0107936524,
0.0048281029,
-0.0364024974,
-0.0042732181,
0.0203039125,
-0.0031529218,
-0.014812462,
-0.0085870903,
0.0284691416,
0.0151372617,
0.0036103094,
0.03650086,
0.0180642586,
-0.0005513489,
-0.0065017268,
-0.0042856722,
0.042484872,
-0.0141875064,
0.023144016,
0.0349190496,
-0.0147895431,
-0.0036184327,
-0.0289359987,
-0.0018785673,
0.0063104979,
-0.0527575649,
-0.0146543533,
-0.0189370234,
-0.039924562,
-0.0217743963,
-0.029655559,
-0.0173531473,
0.0540595502,
0.0138279982,
-0.036811918,
-0.0253781602,
-0.0208358765,
0.0627845377,
-0.0018980909,
-0.001806448,
-0.042328842,
-0.0234902445,
0.0265675429,
0.0434015952,
-0.0310704708,
0.0451080352,
2.189177772e-34,
-0.0653796718,
0.0625608787,
-0.0014970477,
0.0044190707,
0.0451884605,
0.0605459921,
0.0261331182,
0.0599829964,
0.0790876821,
-0.0218207967,
-0.0105115436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06390v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06390v1 | P5: Plug-and-Play Persona Prompting for Personalized Response Selection | 2023-10-10T07:53:36 | 2023-10-10T07:53:36 | Joosung Lee, Minsik Oh, Donghun Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The use of persona-grounded retrieval-based chatbots is crucial for
personalized conversations, but there are several challenges that need to be
addressed. 1) In general, collecting persona-grounded corpus is very expensive.
2) The chatbot system does not always respond in consideration of persona at
real applications. To address these challenges, we propose a plug-and-play
persona prompting method. Our system can function as a standard open-domain
chatbot if persona information is not available. We demonstrate that this
approach performs well in the zero-shot setting, which reduces the dependence
on persona-ground training data. This makes it easier to expand the system to
other languages without the need to build a persona-grounded corpus.
Additionally, our model can be fine-tuned for even better performance. In our
experiments, the zero-shot model improved the standard model by 7.71 and 1.04
points in the original persona and revised persona, respectively. The
fine-tuned model improved the previous state-of-the-art system by 1.95 and 3.39
points in the original persona and revised persona, respectively. To the best
of our knowledge, this is the first attempt to solve the problem of
personalized response selection using prompt sequences. Our code is available
on github~\footnote{https://github.com/rungjoo/plug-and-play-prompt-persona}. | [
0.0867136046,
0.0189418811,
-0.0255681705,
-0.0056618256,
-0.0257896893,
-0.0026267311,
0.0364746116,
-0.0025632291,
0.0564560704,
-0.0088382298,
-0.0220857952,
0.0116807241,
-0.0152811073,
0.0374987386,
-0.0045589427,
-0.0660171732,
0.0446491241,
-0.0035035796,
0.002453597,
0.0038521928,
0.0179025605,
0.0349287316,
-0.0278208032,
0.0790508166,
-0.0245085843,
-0.024355758,
-0.023895409,
-0.0001841565,
0.019223012,
-0.0081522083,
0.0391594991,
0.0492892303,
0.0170229096,
0.0023310883,
0.0000019829,
-0.0501813553,
-0.0218146797,
-0.0321385749,
-0.0410304666,
-0.0605609231,
0.0097651174,
0.0759561434,
-0.018101396,
0.0348974615,
-0.0617226586,
-0.022055367,
0.0354834758,
0.0472698361,
0.0671986118,
0.0641587377,
-0.0215271916,
-0.017291978,
-0.0116495145,
-0.0125905722,
0.0007447278,
-0.0123135448,
-0.0098151844,
-0.0576221049,
0.0558644049,
0.0435876325,
0.0060480605,
-0.0013464049,
-0.011477924,
-0.0270568728,
0.0385058224,
0.0300404113,
-0.0300947968,
-0.0489481501,
-0.0094544888,
0.1005844399,
0.058923766,
-0.0038402718,
0.0033864875,
0.0223344583,
0.0530583635,
-0.0206744429,
-0.0444774814,
-0.0307339225,
-0.0169934109,
-0.0217028726,
-0.0565002002,
0.0296894219,
-0.0484702773,
0.0073258509,
-0.0370126814,
0.0375122167,
0.0189189129,
-0.0213684812,
0.0086055519,
0.0074345679,
0.0150462007,
-0.0568880774,
0.0171629246,
0.0190444123,
-0.0566827506,
-0.000817506,
-0.0265481621,
0.013471581,
-0.0010286029,
0.0138286175,
-0.0124164904,
0.0578938909,
-0.0216085091,
0.0304905139,
0.0198418759,
0.0447026379,
0.0211703032,
-0.024243718,
0.0047457414,
-0.0227789711,
-0.0594651736,
0.0016184979,
-0.0520783141,
0.0564377308,
-0.0228196923,
0.0013476142,
-0.0320187099,
0.0451727435,
-0.0128768543,
-0.0103093581,
-0.0206211098,
0.0393215753,
-0.0522781685,
0.0403597914,
-0.0576317608,
0.0199448504,
-0.0835359916,
-0.0248025618,
0.0219779555,
-0.0844570994,
-0.0044069695,
0.0235444792,
0.021583382,
-0.0187328737,
-0.0135269146,
0.0139628788,
-0.011516205,
-0.0779431015,
0.0332470424,
-0.021338677,
-0.034589693,
-0.0708250776,
-0.0387649722,
-0.0368242264,
0.0246980339,
-0.0024633345,
-0.0273926444,
-0.0074033197,
0.0173086207,
0.0365640335,
0.0006854775,
0.0394217893,
0.0166739952,
-0.0139437355,
0.010999619,
0.0159650259,
-0.0316659063,
0.0289609265,
-0.0226092134,
0.0404069088,
0.0516341887,
0.0031146707,
0.0258542579,
0.0059335697,
-0.0101239765,
-0.0067762882,
0.0416276082,
0.0314799845,
0.005625858,
-0.0060968362,
0.028314285,
0.0092444587,
-0.049022045,
-0.0256169382,
0.0410427898,
0.0730732009,
-0.0404223464,
0.0250351727,
0.0454654694,
0.0549089313,
0.0225439295,
0.0120870527,
-0.0297862515,
0.0339003876,
-0.0268981215,
-0.0427728593,
0.0193348955,
0.0160025824,
-0.0484478697,
-0.0253657773,
0.0637594983,
-0.0193024315,
0.0313282982,
0.0109178266,
0.0160955824,
0.0104427105,
-0.0587366596,
0.0398735814,
0.0116088372,
-0.0686757565,
-0.0522017181,
-0.0194178913,
0.0307997297,
0.0589500666,
0.064772591,
-0.001718534,
-0.0028354879,
-0.0247592945,
-0.0213245228,
0.0309173651,
0.028861111,
-0.0188724305,
0.0053857598,
-0.0336024798,
-0.0315431915,
0.0108104367,
-0.0401640907,
0.0466055758,
0.0249978267,
0.0153998164,
0.0069821482,
0.0760734975,
0.0550884828,
-0.0052901204,
-0.0241676904,
-0.0000641833,
0.0171661507,
0.0177412946,
0.0340214148,
0.0395003669,
0.0304783955,
-0.0229114033,
0.0275635477,
-0.0022358047,
-0.0125797419,
0.0172893107,
-0.0238275379,
-0.0402420536,
0.0204460509,
-0.0102836424,
-0.0262193698,
0.0497209132,
0.0032240977,
-0.0364155322,
0.024583973,
-0.037847884,
0.0347536355,
-0.0463873409,
0.0073707863,
0.008785096,
0.0515332706,
-0.05024717,
0.0460754111,
0.0170378424,
-0.0103891371,
0.0393361412,
0.029794706,
-0.020051606,
-0.0927613899,
-0.0107422182,
0.0200441517,
-0.0007407487,
-0.0221274812,
0.0399084538,
-0.0132605834,
-0.057548862,
-0.0195426065,
-0.1259260774,
-0.0047963057,
-0.005049672,
-0.0244281329,
-0.0378120542,
0.0577828251,
-0.0244116951,
-0.0545053557,
-0.0652202368,
0.0284544565,
0.0223453902,
0.0108882245,
0.0564961843,
0.0005277247,
-0.0119175678,
-0.049587097,
0.0238937568,
0.014507818,
0.0272794366,
-0.0095188543,
-0.0176979676,
-0.0265962034,
0.0018359537,
-0.0644033253,
0.0515758097,
-0.0037034736,
-0.0458752103,
0.0521327481,
-0.0196325835,
0.0549538024,
0.0506344512,
0.0522088595,
0.034277238,
-0.0378047749,
0.0179877672,
-0.0928380266,
0.0399715751,
-0.0239632092,
-0.0062323259,
0.007277315,
-0.0079544783,
0.0316445753,
0.0192535743,
0.0089728646,
0.0072979927,
-0.0903901085,
0.0409713089,
0.0450315252,
-0.0173332319,
0.0167440288,
0.0363725722,
-0.0146126403,
0.0419163629,
0.0041991505,
-0.0294637624,
0.0908698514,
0.0075390502,
-0.0285532121,
-0.0254120361,
-0.0028459185,
-0.0242300443,
0.030334441,
-0.0406919345,
-0.0040652119,
0.016031947,
-0.044581607,
-0.0574638657,
-0.0287790857,
0.0079012699,
-0.0362271518,
0.0082303714,
-0.0025989793,
0.0113198617,
0.0189168435,
-0.0577397533,
-0.058451537,
-0.0491102077,
-0.0182765387,
-0.0408218466,
-0.0158018265,
-0.0046965862,
-0.040044412,
-0.007874052,
0.0097229248,
0.0264173802,
-0.0338950679,
-0.0005058076,
-0.0296681486,
-0.0210473239,
0.0204542167,
0.0331916213,
-0.0074830921,
-0.0005834464,
0.0590276942,
0.0405720174,
0.017935954,
-0.0151114771,
0.0069501242,
-0.0204248913,
0.0518987812,
-0.0297675356,
-0.0516727082,
0.0154682416,
0.0365672037,
-0.0023919402,
-0.0201837327,
0.1096239239,
0.0295281801,
-0.0589794777,
-0.010039445,
-0.0145981191,
0.0416423306,
0.0221511628,
0.0624119006,
-0.0257236566,
-0.0282417834,
-0.0055972445,
0.0627635047,
-0.0168605894,
-0.0488449857,
-0.0062940894,
-0.1202322319,
0.0314489454,
-0.0183414854,
-0.0263446197,
-0.0303787906,
-0.0491471663,
0.0252592098,
0.0007504903,
-0.0075379508,
0.0092619713,
0.0007465302,
0.0045842091,
-0.0126920706,
-0.008114757,
-0.0276145544,
0.0316876881,
-0.0122107742,
0.0451117605,
0.0830366164,
0.0703320727,
0.0520410389,
-0.0097648557,
-0.0506994016,
0.0486458726,
0.0124323294,
-0.0369460173,
0.0771425813,
-0.0014299317,
0.0016744721,
-0.0575267635,
0.0123868762,
0.0011720672,
0.0156141184,
0.021360917,
0.0162265636,
-0.0514810309,
0.0487035215,
-0.0189951137,
0.0434026085,
0.0318142846,
0.0461758673,
0.0065083611,
-0.0565838404,
-0.0409603864,
-0.0102041224,
0.0080574285,
-0.0195857622,
-0.0338083357,
-0.02630697,
-0.0219546407,
-0.0325189084,
-0.0971879587,
-0.0665792674,
0.027586963,
0.053871531,
-0.0103128189,
-0.0262445007,
-0.0237846654,
0.039545808,
0.011822409,
0.0168359447,
-0.0365622267,
-0.0020709038,
-0.0787571743,
-0.0238473341,
0.0410103276,
-0.0584874824,
0.0144152446,
-0.0270622373,
-0.0198344458,
-0.0354885906,
-0.0174937341,
0.0596785024,
0.0226182938,
0.0623621047,
-0.024980668,
-0.0620779581,
0.0051931036,
0.0080832671,
-0.039814014,
-0.0112794638,
0.0392323546,
0.0579304285,
-0.0454329699,
0.0328249373,
-0.0343069024,
0.0223710798,
-0.0052469182,
0.0132816778,
-0.0198442284,
-0.0925477818,
0.019508332,
0.0222046562,
0.047744371,
0.0218832269,
-0.0204982031,
0.0019805147,
0.0110222399,
-0.0298370719,
-0.0140849147,
-0.0283362679,
-0.0066369162,
-0.0272304211,
-0.021973636,
0.0318870768,
-0.0442660674,
-0.082250759,
0.0588197745,
-0.0228677373,
-0.0265180655,
0.0129870791,
0.0098188277,
0.0155639555,
-0.0040581445,
-0.0335121863,
0.018584393,
0.0274524502,
0.042619057,
-0.0097500496,
0.0692484006,
-0.0130645446,
-0.0171076059,
0.0117959687,
0.0297825895,
-0.0724224523,
-0.0044810665,
0.0273315124,
0.0549376532,
0.0094867172,
0.0190750677,
0.0239358265,
-0.0059317569,
0.0166445822,
-0.0311572719,
0.0328232013,
0.0047140974,
-0.024315035,
-0.0247448031,
0.0198880788,
-0.0297925919,
0.0184966139,
0.0423700474,
-0.0418767408,
-0.0087958146,
-0.0216434281,
-0.0078037349,
-0.0699253753,
-0.0154543724,
0.0212843772,
0.0269317962,
0.0045323409,
0.0094940867,
-0.0532441586,
-0.0185958352,
-0.0021221307,
-0.0206337404,
-0.0602774657,
-0.0046695871,
0.057083711,
0.0353956185,
-0.0103978841,
-0.0189718194,
-0.0765179247,
0.0312186815,
-0.0293876193,
-0.0344590805,
-0.0103694387,
-5.455023329e-33,
-0.0409015305,
-0.0098495176,
0.0115130786,
0.0072819474,
-0.0375185981,
-0.0281276945,
-0.0385697447,
0.011735999,
-0.0032471453,
-0.0239141397,
-0.0549377576,
-0.0197633207,
0.016314311,
0.0129396431,
-0.0187228303,
-0.00873187,
0.0590260141,
0.0079138521,
-0.0249782801,
0.0604983754,
0.071732454,
0.0451894999,
0.0011491446,
-0.0397245623,
0.0382515118,
-0.0299875382,
0.0180800334,
0.0160294976,
0.0398228057,
0.0717370883,
0.0116229886,
0.0308277123,
-0.0037690743,
-0.0023793573,
0.0099903047,
0.0529871471,
-0.081668295,
-0.0677495003,
-0.0097840205,
0.0276030004,
-0.0148499841,
-0.0494986363,
-0.0101094889,
-0.0558228642,
0.0084361602,
0.0436346941,
0.0442690477,
-0.0085874423,
-0.000135903,
0.0183317792,
-0.0287578087,
-0.0121677304,
-0.0190442577,
-0.0453419574,
-0.0142540317,
0.1114623845,
0.0096023893,
0.0181640815,
-0.0364348516,
0.0426688157,
-0.0510887913,
-0.0195068326,
0.0036833675,
0.0386570729,
0.0313332379,
0.0349157751,
0.0316997021,
0.0227816403,
-0.0154817495,
-0.0159973335,
0.0265932437,
0.0204273388,
0.0148485797,
0.0649746507,
-0.0214982647,
-0.0099026971,
-0.0368485786,
0.0518587008,
0.093212679,
0.0177434571,
0.0164563265,
0.0025232425,
-0.0788167864,
0.004141184,
0.0076866113,
0.0032626253,
-0.0136092994,
-0.0508612692,
0.0222378094,
0.0115016056,
-0.0713176951,
-0.0553239472,
0.0323172919,
-0.0364139453,
-0.0036706943,
0.0278892461,
-0.0396981053,
-0.0095145898,
0.012576079,
-0.0020399254,
-0.0189627521,
-0.0158546995,
0.0629111081,
-0.0507022142,
0.0024015827,
0.0274345241,
-0.0221134797,
0.0034399712,
-0.0585110262,
-0.034893278,
-0.0025501058,
0.0657746494,
-0.0337946117,
0.0505295843,
-0.0041306443,
0.0289231203,
-0.02788065,
0.0567468368,
0.0082346452,
-0.0031140775,
-0.0405599028,
-0.0274481829,
0.013868073,
-0.020357281,
-0.0391246527,
0.0028298746,
-0.0238293409,
0.0253934003,
0.0208044052,
-0.0265688766,
-0.0259060357,
-0.0019335346,
2.598e-7,
-0.0461313725,
0.0063090934,
0.0102467742,
0.0187214352,
0.0106176976,
0.0565588735,
0.0223985575,
0.0478183813,
0.0267378204,
-0.0103600146,
0.0124797486,
0.0403446034,
0.0595589802,
-0.0006407194,
-0.129549101,
-0.0202876944,
0.0094961543,
-0.0007084337,
-0.048712045,
-0.0113095893,
0.0812769458,
0.0521055087,
0.0449867621,
0.0088039283,
-0.0086275619,
0.0513114855,
0.0396914631,
0.0145361563,
-0.0206204653,
0.0046520559,
0.0368462019,
0.0068622706,
0.001899582,
0.0423635133,
0.0138051864,
0.0270625111,
0.0120208999,
0.0545296296,
0.0063045798,
-0.0524620079,
0.0285098311,
0.0209143236,
0.0122935753,
-0.0243041329,
0.0589616597,
-0.051846575,
-0.020290941,
-0.011224851,
-0.0325617641,
-0.0139519442,
0.0252068061,
-0.0224320982,
-0.0639612749,
0.0476429462,
0.0114014782,
-0.0182565413,
0.0073041879,
-0.0739173815,
0.0357518345,
-0.0332120396,
-0.0275007486,
-0.0583216995,
-0.016752556,
-0.009591613,
0.0100444509,
-0.0197008699,
0.0293717589,
2.037114261e-34,
-0.0188514125,
0.0300394595,
0.0071655144,
0.0291564818,
0.0181447398,
0.0006563264,
0.0100722704,
0.0077080894,
0.0759528726,
-0.0487210043,
-0.0230096299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06387v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06387v3 | Jailbreak and Guard Aligned Language Models with Only Few In-Context Demonstrations | 2023-10-10T07:50:29 | 2024-05-25T07:01:15 | Zeming Wei, Yifei Wang, Ang Li, Yichuan Mo, Yisen Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable success in various tasks,
yet their safety and the risk of generating harmful content remain pressing
concerns. In this paper, we delve into the potential of In-Context Learning
(ICL) to modulate the alignment of LLMs. Specifically, we propose the
In-Context Attack (ICA) which employs harmful demonstrations to subvert LLMs,
and the In-Context Defense (ICD) which bolsters model resilience through
examples that demonstrate refusal to produce harmful responses. We offer
theoretical insights to elucidate how a limited set of in-context
demonstrations can pivotally influence the safety alignment of LLMs. Through
extensive experiments, we demonstrate the efficacy of ICA and ICD in
respectively elevating and mitigating the success rates of jailbreaking
prompts. Our findings illuminate the profound influence of ICL on LLM behavior,
opening new avenues for improving the safety of LLMs. | [
0.0294035934,
0.0620036349,
-0.0262179244,
0.0232038405,
-0.0353510641,
0.0034172491,
0.0236243475,
0.0072728847,
0.0358306095,
-0.0178950001,
-0.027675055,
-0.0455490537,
-0.0009691884,
0.0008574743,
0.0329724662,
-0.0088597732,
0.057370685,
-0.0669019222,
-0.0081136478,
0.0074674012,
0.0331334174,
-0.023720026,
0.0086490717,
0.0281220637,
-0.0114629027,
-0.0156513155,
-0.027377909,
0.0124998568,
0.0132857524,
-0.0429194532,
0.0171175189,
0.0534366444,
0.0187813453,
0.0676366463,
0.0000020177,
-0.0459227934,
-0.0226681288,
0.0076941499,
-0.0305523314,
0.0281472579,
0.034827482,
-0.0605665967,
-0.0496956185,
0.019362459,
-0.0513979271,
0.0182194281,
0.03423113,
0.0419347771,
0.0506191105,
0.0625159591,
0.0113768633,
0.0175095703,
0.0524317212,
-0.014043754,
-0.0146465674,
-0.0590507984,
0.0246717837,
-0.0357095413,
0.0155822048,
0.0140554886,
0.0069548283,
0.0148987081,
0.0290511306,
-0.017072171,
-0.0613505505,
-0.0014969256,
-0.0338123851,
-0.0291591734,
-0.0210233536,
0.0355191492,
-0.0445696451,
-0.031226078,
0.0037939891,
-0.0080664409,
0.0406492613,
0.0230403133,
-0.0272048805,
0.027006859,
0.0120969927,
-0.0102856783,
0.0102196969,
-0.0019697242,
0.0696421638,
0.0102185803,
0.0289540198,
0.0409100279,
0.0008900692,
-0.0582708903,
0.0006519891,
-0.0170202889,
-0.0036752364,
-0.0569879152,
-0.0171513204,
0.0031447005,
-0.0273166467,
0.0418025255,
-0.0803555027,
-0.0290549956,
0.039306581,
-0.0510505512,
-0.0037335611,
0.0356699526,
0.0038886922,
0.0107961036,
-0.0058799698,
0.0210481398,
-0.0219830051,
0.0457508117,
-0.0039431844,
0.0595064089,
0.0021660612,
-0.040139582,
-0.0041294899,
0.0056037875,
-0.0199280027,
-0.0088727623,
0.0008413541,
0.0419510826,
-0.0384675413,
0.0338476077,
-0.0703248158,
0.002907902,
-0.0142848054,
-0.0014187745,
0.024504764,
-0.0278131273,
-0.0065517402,
0.0066819154,
0.0172691233,
-0.0596339144,
-0.0346429087,
-0.0061407597,
-0.0707929283,
-0.021998832,
-0.0151417293,
0.1015546918,
0.00711666,
-0.038583003,
-0.0528608747,
-0.0469962806,
-0.0391862728,
-0.0437527411,
-0.0026941677,
-0.080561772,
-0.0027027463,
0.0082408506,
-0.0202268045,
-0.0766328126,
0.023161741,
0.0145742837,
-0.0268945955,
0.063597165,
0.0307884067,
-0.0032953199,
-0.0039785788,
0.0560377873,
-0.0024878436,
0.0787711069,
0.0058428366,
0.0108539434,
0.0225661527,
-0.0177180991,
0.0466704108,
0.0598147027,
0.0213290434,
0.0555031374,
-0.0350811295,
-0.0191288888,
0.0639123842,
0.0116584981,
-0.0102813318,
0.0338413939,
-0.0006256445,
0.0042012087,
0.1039884388,
0.0614470243,
-0.0624708831,
-0.0005689624,
-0.0445660129,
-0.0410487801,
-0.0027001603,
0.0185753386,
-0.1035978496,
-0.0040568365,
-0.0737095177,
0.0064374814,
-0.0278760791,
0.02611316,
-0.007506961,
0.0139585538,
-0.0099879866,
-0.0040906565,
0.0275192801,
0.0319120921,
0.0051966282,
0.0258181803,
-0.0242412332,
0.028383201,
0.0352354236,
-0.0310896579,
-0.0224614982,
-0.074085176,
0.0245076474,
0.0515637286,
0.0494247898,
-0.0186605733,
0.0015826935,
-0.0381222181,
0.0341944396,
0.0429214574,
0.0001731609,
0.000840787,
-0.000382268,
0.0069355662,
-0.0180904437,
-0.0412184782,
0.0246855244,
-0.0093633868,
0.0270709153,
-0.0128957303,
-0.0151379341,
-0.0019955649,
-0.0385694131,
0.0318650492,
-0.0189342014,
-0.0378425978,
-0.0468932241,
0.0232199654,
0.0051338933,
-0.0018870207,
-0.0292438958,
0.002674859,
0.0613798983,
-0.0003434318,
0.0615118183,
-0.0023348026,
-0.0677207038,
-0.0126152392,
0.036980588,
-0.0034443436,
-0.0151063427,
0.0434451215,
0.0046818512,
-0.002983425,
0.0129264984,
-0.020122055,
0.0784524456,
0.0087582087,
0.0527942292,
-0.0249696691,
-0.0063046459,
-0.0443826579,
0.04520078,
-0.021593241,
-0.0039725835,
0.0281697717,
0.0130774044,
-0.001573964,
-0.0061157518,
-0.0539507307,
0.0040014139,
-0.0348135158,
0.0384378806,
0.014802794,
-0.0028766447,
-0.0171292759,
-0.0198771656,
-0.0365046002,
-0.0054138978,
-0.0316231698,
0.0114714969,
0.0374104865,
0.0125122732,
-0.0318780728,
-0.0179260354,
0.0019272789,
-0.0387538895,
0.0211079326,
0.0335087515,
-0.0103676459,
-0.0044068331,
-0.0516896136,
-0.0220398773,
0.0029713174,
-0.014086714,
0.0398170277,
-0.0344990157,
-0.006414338,
-0.0261210632,
0.0114828581,
0.0322468728,
0.0408601239,
-0.0265137888,
-0.0160780065,
0.0654361099,
0.036671482,
0.0220740102,
0.082062602,
0.0155011313,
0.0576474331,
0.0778152049,
0.0310701821,
-0.0606774986,
-0.0054107555,
0.0300454516,
-0.0462224856,
-0.0456622094,
-0.043339517,
-0.0049697338,
0.0556987152,
0.015165017,
0.020587353,
-0.0278253648,
0.0436155647,
-0.0181788765,
-0.0684998259,
-0.0272852983,
-0.0695975721,
-0.0789864734,
0.0042480966,
-0.0316827521,
-0.0871400014,
0.0668508559,
-0.0226449799,
0.0258671548,
0.0014050307,
-0.0192472748,
0.0208115801,
0.0568192378,
-0.0216363873,
0.0227979217,
0.0429923497,
-0.0359445922,
-0.0381472372,
-0.0164027344,
0.0071197222,
-0.0140739251,
0.0494308583,
-0.0572143644,
-0.0081737367,
-0.0082220752,
-0.0650286004,
-0.0670066774,
-0.073076196,
-0.0098891268,
-0.0144083761,
0.0146044502,
-0.0178378113,
0.0010397818,
-0.019024292,
0.0484650768,
-0.0012686233,
-0.0103517473,
0.0036162448,
-0.0348973237,
0.0062462185,
0.0582944416,
-0.0268365126,
0.0087216124,
-0.0441542231,
0.0403490178,
0.0812377408,
0.0532509126,
0.0094145145,
-0.0137044005,
0.0148305967,
0.036911916,
0.0144969523,
-0.0088731973,
0.0505281352,
0.0679903552,
-0.03505731,
-0.0331332125,
0.0565947816,
0.0256547034,
-0.0226623826,
0.046824865,
-0.0133069623,
0.0389573388,
0.0098159527,
0.0141707687,
-0.0439630337,
-0.0221268069,
0.026555296,
0.0491514429,
-0.0211370103,
0.0059715854,
-0.0090158461,
-0.1089669317,
-0.0001065101,
0.0302618835,
-0.0473537371,
-0.0109999245,
-0.0224816725,
-0.0081833182,
0.0247138049,
0.0605870001,
0.0103193382,
-0.0138214016,
-0.0289236922,
0.0225443095,
-0.001514248,
-0.0398447737,
0.0087885717,
-0.0418193899,
0.0644295961,
0.0756283253,
-0.0321352482,
-0.0383465029,
-0.0162547827,
0.0537394769,
-0.0047645345,
0.0204708744,
0.0244326014,
-0.0054146932,
0.0090631768,
0.0098871114,
-0.0166397486,
0.056249056,
0.0052478719,
-0.0684890524,
0.0338609628,
0.0730507895,
0.0057515865,
-0.0094137667,
-0.0340403132,
-0.0378299952,
0.041543033,
0.0415590629,
0.0223776717,
-0.0660299212,
-0.0198820923,
-0.0554139093,
-0.0363802202,
-0.0188298784,
-0.0228652954,
0.0024637892,
0.0361389145,
-0.0105335573,
-0.0246017613,
-0.0107624168,
-0.0210217163,
0.0435816534,
0.048981268,
-0.0133136129,
-0.0494006276,
0.0023154549,
0.0128865968,
0.0211998671,
-0.0037107551,
0.0576773658,
-0.0597544648,
0.0430024713,
-0.0409358367,
-0.037465442,
0.0085901599,
0.0122785764,
-0.0630439967,
-0.1057970822,
0.0358076878,
0.0629418418,
0.0290361606,
0.0398384109,
-0.0167380925,
-0.0560186133,
0.0655132756,
0.0726430193,
-0.0467044562,
0.0275884699,
0.0586345941,
-0.0411733314,
0.0098460931,
0.0237401836,
-0.0223367605,
-0.0462906621,
0.0683582798,
0.0256102495,
-0.0581800677,
-0.0002897501,
0.0454066247,
0.0096807312,
0.0104857292,
-0.0380345695,
0.0068402202,
0.008977063,
0.0169478282,
0.0041568209,
-0.0392157026,
0.0167038087,
-0.0087651415,
0.0353346244,
-0.019608127,
0.0339592695,
0.0010699584,
0.0054840096,
0.0105624627,
-0.0200252067,
0.0273496825,
0.0355178006,
0.0302534774,
0.0545765236,
0.0381533727,
-0.0183137693,
0.0667950809,
-0.0388703868,
0.0195030291,
0.0041641211,
0.0606063418,
0.0051045096,
-0.0136914924,
-0.0247429181,
0.0512229316,
-0.0686762631,
-0.0241375454,
-0.0137707042,
0.0393628851,
-0.0082214288,
-0.0233196374,
0.0193296503,
-0.031806618,
-0.0059968727,
-0.0281725302,
-0.0212710351,
-0.0087020891,
-0.0759384409,
0.0326500796,
0.0152271148,
0.0027102542,
0.0134478202,
0.0608117543,
-0.0051520392,
0.0600938424,
0.0159415938,
0.0098569319,
-0.0220887922,
-0.0141817778,
0.0879472792,
0.0316188298,
-0.0585923232,
-0.0197117906,
-0.0689547211,
-0.080655165,
-0.0392224826,
0.0253427774,
0.0119610708,
-0.033915218,
-0.0109285936,
0.037426509,
0.0008025274,
-0.0027491141,
-0.0217114463,
0.01338463,
0.0403605513,
-0.0306511112,
-0.0210712366,
-5.834378131e-33,
0.0144357393,
-0.0371375419,
-0.0316147134,
-0.0267984476,
0.0044365646,
-0.0189391803,
-0.0194148421,
0.0443406552,
-0.006996417,
-0.0271182451,
-0.0276226848,
-0.0048396755,
0.0019767659,
0.0015687236,
-0.0217937008,
-0.0344928354,
-0.0060848789,
-0.0063241627,
-0.047951825,
0.0205846317,
0.0282532666,
0.0159742162,
0.0095829079,
-0.0779293925,
0.0707081631,
-0.032822825,
-0.0370727666,
0.0025660123,
-0.0848694816,
0.0691363513,
-0.008448788,
0.0389219932,
-0.0018539845,
-0.0294829886,
0.0017778208,
0.0824839249,
0.0163840204,
0.0104205152,
0.0323386155,
0.0015321976,
-0.0212499537,
-0.0432514474,
0.0381218456,
-0.014181722,
-0.0439536944,
0.0080516506,
-0.0126698837,
-0.0147724627,
-0.0357597545,
0.010353893,
-0.0537201278,
-0.002882011,
-0.0140284821,
-0.0449643172,
-0.015902523,
0.0058754999,
-0.0033382848,
-0.027807638,
-0.0368710794,
0.0247004163,
0.0486131571,
-0.0020842252,
0.0798241869,
0.0241278801,
-0.0046587409,
0.0827552602,
-0.0418188684,
0.01044452,
0.0226243455,
-0.0412193462,
0.0221673213,
0.0355887003,
0.0572883673,
0.0694309846,
0.0419074707,
-0.0398663506,
-0.0435774922,
-0.0072886548,
0.0268776193,
0.0159131642,
0.0488688946,
0.0060760104,
-0.0564061105,
-0.0244515538,
-0.0240199268,
0.0044978429,
-0.0131866755,
-0.047186505,
0.0452787988,
0.0196017697,
-0.0262998305,
-0.0431758426,
0.0047307406,
-0.0454070568,
-0.0243434422,
0.0311470255,
0.0074053239,
-0.0009918065,
-0.006590283,
0.0151621141,
-0.046188958,
-0.0117727779,
-0.0188726075,
-0.0260525513,
0.0241654832,
0.0058045951,
0.0596690774,
0.0492426045,
-0.066980958,
0.0102071883,
-0.0269814804,
0.0549943969,
0.0425438471,
-0.0366358422,
0.0578451715,
-0.0212974325,
-0.0070855976,
-0.0037804199,
0.0368907079,
-0.0402799584,
-0.062167652,
0.0333697163,
-0.0590200201,
0.0051239827,
0.000889506,
-0.0056829611,
-0.0074798674,
0.0562539026,
0.0353949927,
-0.078276515,
-0.0019386022,
-0.0096547743,
2.722e-7,
-0.0146774612,
-0.007802363,
0.0141226985,
0.0029066689,
0.0262269769,
0.0631234348,
-0.044854369,
0.0894268826,
0.0117702652,
-0.0393155925,
-0.0262866411,
-0.0104959542,
0.0571075529,
0.0322241969,
-0.0419808626,
0.0337942429,
-0.0933020636,
0.0425517075,
-0.051349096,
0.0082023218,
0.008926874,
0.0814385489,
-0.0080801127,
-0.0178812388,
-0.0045348606,
-0.0563003272,
0.0320620835,
-0.0220882315,
0.0098303556,
-0.0293227229,
-0.0181118436,
0.0264174398,
0.0068094027,
0.0293677803,
-0.012497901,
0.0034233825,
-0.0486066043,
0.0363683999,
0.0059990999,
-0.0078340452,
-0.0224563275,
-0.0307894237,
-0.0160979051,
-0.0639044419,
0.0633881539,
-0.0173988622,
-0.0008622259,
-0.0264696199,
0.0350441672,
-0.0425969437,
-0.0106909722,
-0.017680198,
-0.0050744484,
-0.0111858891,
0.0104151843,
0.023959687,
0.0069284914,
-0.0462604016,
-0.0447045602,
0.0280951504,
-0.0013474348,
-0.0598821454,
-0.0277347565,
0.04904183,
-0.0054626139,
-0.0618758313,
0.0087863375,
2.559559741e-34,
-0.0165520776,
-0.0502614081,
0.0340801254,
0.0252297521,
0.0115627898,
0.0116477851,
0.0383279286,
0.0246085115,
0.0448254831,
-0.0324848518,
-0.0131100528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06374v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06374v2 | Rethinking Model Selection and Decoding for Keyphrase Generation with Pre-trained Sequence-to-Sequence Models | 2023-10-10T07:34:45 | 2023-10-22T08:37:43 | Di Wu, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Keyphrase Generation (KPG) is a longstanding task in NLP with widespread
applications. The advent of sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) pre-trained language
models (PLMs) has ushered in a transformative era for KPG, yielding promising
performance improvements. However, many design decisions remain unexplored and
are often made arbitrarily. This paper undertakes a systematic analysis of the
influence of model selection and decoding strategies on PLM-based KPG. We begin
by elucidating why seq2seq PLMs are apt for KPG, anchored by an
attention-driven hypothesis. We then establish that conventional wisdom for
selecting seq2seq PLMs lacks depth: (1) merely increasing model size or
performing task-specific adaptation is not parameter-efficient; (2) although
combining in-domain pre-training with task adaptation benefits KPG, it does
partially hinder generalization. Regarding decoding, we demonstrate that while
greedy search achieves strong F1 scores, it lags in recall compared with
sampling-based methods. Based on these insights, we propose DeSel, a
likelihood-based decode-select algorithm for seq2seq PLMs. DeSel improves
greedy search by an average of 4.7% semantic F1 across five datasets. Our
collective findings pave the way for deeper future investigations into
PLM-based KPG. | [
0.0690188929,
0.084723562,
0.0012772795,
-0.0050683925,
-0.0279079657,
-0.0245647002,
-0.0123493606,
0.0299794413,
-0.0104078501,
-0.0576678254,
-0.0304583739,
-0.0241595712,
-0.0420342721,
0.0521066748,
0.0211474914,
-0.0280613191,
0.0607730523,
-0.0226018578,
0.0061193057,
0.0059075663,
-0.0178091563,
0.0149899451,
0.0131717687,
0.053515926,
0.0340028517,
0.0256735627,
-0.0437125787,
0.002211692,
-0.0012669816,
-0.0404819362,
0.0117154885,
0.0729566738,
0.0130186733,
0.0079637775,
0.0000020506,
-0.0295983981,
-0.0229067933,
-0.0387835503,
-0.0223403405,
0.054049354,
0.0252720825,
-0.0173271839,
0.0408347212,
0.0274156556,
-0.0543402284,
-0.0414373353,
0.0535828583,
0.0306191742,
0.0360529348,
0.0597229004,
-0.0073666349,
-0.048401434,
0.0151196811,
-0.050707411,
0.0067113834,
-0.0868100002,
0.0042024339,
-0.0550903045,
-0.0097384546,
0.0272624791,
-0.0006733843,
0.0503735319,
-0.0028333263,
0.0263656974,
0.0945498869,
0.0171831977,
-0.0149713075,
-0.0500483029,
-0.044780612,
0.0776834413,
-0.0439756848,
-0.0217501707,
0.0221979041,
-0.0373684205,
-0.0131145706,
0.0067575877,
-0.0178747848,
0.0113162054,
0.0118443109,
0.008202577,
0.0129206292,
0.0065445844,
0.018217694,
0.0261022616,
-0.0607188232,
-0.0119259171,
0.0505481698,
-0.0211327821,
0.0062082149,
0.0139447236,
-0.079108879,
-0.0402120017,
0.0319244601,
-0.0009308173,
-0.0344194919,
0.0362846963,
-0.0763326138,
-0.0153734069,
0.0378778242,
-0.0508102067,
0.0674639642,
0.0296083298,
0.0287410077,
0.0121935466,
-0.0379685573,
0.0454468094,
0.0091826869,
0.0388831459,
-0.0459569544,
0.0131034823,
-0.0412739664,
-0.0153752696,
-0.0475513898,
0.0323704891,
0.0007971223,
-0.0553208292,
-0.0262732729,
0.023064075,
0.07525675,
-0.028329324,
0.0151780378,
0.0145057393,
-0.0378437713,
0.0112971924,
0.0007937255,
0.0026454043,
-0.0047371057,
0.0125235952,
0.0336360745,
-0.0279722679,
-0.0436432138,
-0.0055289133,
0.0256974474,
-0.0461172648,
0.0130135063,
0.0263187252,
-0.0091217421,
-0.0807560161,
-0.0237419829,
-0.0219947733,
-0.0327439606,
-0.0029815764,
0.0115505988,
-0.0495639555,
0.0429729074,
0.008472777,
-0.0251049828,
-0.0434640832,
0.0297152176,
0.0224530045,
-0.0599495173,
0.0463603251,
-0.0020091394,
0.0154700233,
-0.0231414102,
0.0028597729,
0.0155082699,
0.0462503619,
0.0150235416,
0.0433544181,
0.0503303073,
-0.0284809228,
-0.0000798796,
0.0318858922,
0.0269401949,
0.0068769716,
0.0281465575,
0.0042731636,
0.0045466651,
-0.0044113719,
0.0301493984,
0.0119241979,
-0.0274237711,
0.009024133,
0.0548730381,
0.08247298,
0.0332425497,
0.0356740281,
0.0264901817,
0.0511689596,
0.0035528201,
-0.0445725136,
0.0092157545,
0.0022550672,
-0.0118538924,
0.0336455368,
0.0759553015,
0.0383685976,
-0.0194732863,
-0.0491372868,
-0.0164713077,
0.0188367497,
-0.0131153576,
0.0131766181,
0.0514423698,
0.0317893177,
-0.0951987058,
0.0853420794,
-0.0054015638,
-0.0561163165,
-0.014962974,
-0.0276040696,
-0.0123198237,
0.0467861108,
0.0731786266,
0.0063062389,
-0.0414463989,
0.0148495818,
-0.0118510947,
0.04976473,
0.0151035041,
0.0202755909,
0.0188243762,
-0.0630301312,
-0.0530472659,
-0.0175926629,
0.0274201576,
-0.0156358723,
0.0361986309,
0.0206717104,
0.0448188148,
-0.0106232082,
-0.0253920406,
0.0266148727,
-0.0350697711,
-0.0455204584,
0.004708827,
-0.0277812313,
0.0157952886,
0.0118432883,
-0.0072374227,
0.0515283719,
0.0504108779,
-0.0195318907,
-0.001347521,
-0.0120183695,
-0.0562207326,
-0.0447258241,
0.007906775,
-0.0005140632,
0.0548832379,
0.034471672,
-0.0315117091,
-0.0318057239,
0.021290658,
-0.0335155651,
0.0717837289,
-0.046588704,
0.0262099914,
-0.0104970634,
0.0139161423,
-0.0472832881,
0.0480729491,
-0.0034284226,
-0.0164592676,
-0.0198830906,
-0.0083254725,
0.0056526372,
-0.0294001643,
-0.0009832557,
0.0335794017,
-0.0120536666,
0.0119289476,
0.0235680435,
0.0364119485,
-0.055661317,
0.0159180462,
-0.0663185641,
0.0167810842,
-0.0148254475,
0.0038647656,
0.0225189812,
0.0403604433,
-0.0139929596,
-0.018874703,
-0.0199623108,
-0.0304818731,
0.0101381997,
0.0113015138,
-0.0065326244,
0.0163845345,
0.0001997704,
-0.046934478,
-0.0030496041,
0.0162922479,
0.0682483688,
-0.0000573878,
-0.0377248712,
-0.0058894455,
0.0909530818,
-0.0033459971,
-0.0419492535,
0.0079628648,
-0.0386110432,
-0.0069751577,
-0.0294998512,
0.0234025177,
0.0040257238,
0.0356974564,
-0.0090417387,
0.0076882532,
-0.0151040107,
-0.0458778329,
-0.0172891952,
-0.0232408941,
-0.0566854142,
-0.0016439055,
-0.018642636,
0.0675483868,
0.0981388912,
-0.0206575766,
0.0204985365,
-0.0768880025,
0.0338190272,
0.0056728362,
-0.0252090208,
-0.0237174854,
0.0258429032,
-0.0111114243,
0.0505611859,
-0.0419831127,
-0.0231318437,
0.0290527064,
-0.0199844893,
0.0106055019,
-0.0770889446,
0.0380166285,
0.0043567047,
0.0549425706,
-0.0303081814,
0.0068315323,
0.0300903209,
-0.0303966478,
-0.022860026,
-0.0036569478,
-0.007341587,
-0.0557017401,
0.0615342818,
-0.0477445573,
0.0108012138,
-0.0013115632,
-0.0042869379,
-0.0535292141,
-0.0468816832,
-0.0332414582,
-0.0179261025,
0.02445307,
0.0076591084,
-0.0002322345,
0.022272829,
-0.0206325259,
0.0299922321,
-0.005754964,
0.0061543272,
-0.0016843028,
0.0340911299,
0.062322963,
-0.0122743053,
0.0139659178,
-0.0358934514,
0.0116611421,
0.0479832962,
0.0488235615,
-0.0091195069,
0.0197493657,
0.0004591104,
0.0404225141,
-0.0305195525,
-0.0271860342,
0.0006935538,
0.0486469232,
-0.0394242555,
-0.0286460258,
0.1108642966,
0.0253284108,
-0.0723095313,
0.0003381757,
0.0099709081,
0.0043621436,
-0.0038098781,
0.0162458606,
-0.0478468537,
-0.0477720201,
-0.0083598271,
0.0496232212,
-0.0017955779,
-0.0094205784,
-0.0080637103,
-0.095118776,
0.0253044292,
0.0174256898,
-0.0414946303,
-0.026727533,
-0.0535116531,
-0.0096824681,
-0.0203503426,
-0.0025129968,
0.0189494528,
-0.0338823646,
0.0487283804,
0.0067097135,
-0.0127252117,
-0.0736196712,
-0.0001235299,
-0.0485201403,
0.0028647326,
0.1036948636,
0.0131104114,
0.0139116729,
-0.0199613664,
-0.0041146236,
-0.0052502211,
-0.0112693375,
-0.0159340352,
-0.0044281217,
-0.0237707105,
-0.0143492082,
-0.007906287,
0.001576441,
-0.0605120584,
-0.0088042533,
0.022878265,
0.0180219989,
-0.0049559963,
-0.0057601742,
0.0079163359,
0.0187421106,
-0.0142217996,
0.0984021425,
0.044572942,
-0.0350202248,
-0.0514477268,
-0.0102903945,
0.0212116409,
-0.0968254954,
-0.0652436465,
-0.0019819702,
-0.0152759999,
0.0162789542,
-0.0522747561,
-0.0474398471,
0.0364272855,
0.0217520557,
-0.0214494001,
0.0297768898,
-0.0069729663,
-0.0093046017,
-0.0557196811,
0.0304729547,
-0.0249130018,
-0.0491797887,
-0.0609355681,
-0.0426413342,
0.0050514019,
-0.0420583338,
-0.0100465631,
0.0127316918,
-0.0744061247,
-0.0163082257,
0.0225597452,
0.0576784573,
0.0137230251,
-0.0013666804,
0.006202687,
-0.0108168731,
0.0709214434,
0.0274927057,
-0.0384938717,
0.0223851223,
0.0381649546,
-0.0207780227,
-0.0350748673,
0.0374197438,
-0.0358599909,
-0.0063635982,
0.0392815694,
0.1121052057,
0.0057500331,
-0.0764233246,
0.017116582,
0.0043848427,
0.0601552278,
-0.0365572236,
-0.0115298433,
-0.0119441841,
0.0137755051,
0.0246669892,
0.0234805755,
-0.0677078068,
0.0076136794,
0.0243020207,
0.0065955091,
-0.0092566181,
0.0074180504,
-0.0590301007,
0.0349888355,
-0.0400894843,
0.0047599017,
-0.0043159407,
0.0090269689,
0.0304163639,
-0.0244570058,
-0.0401328877,
-0.0068696318,
0.0030383957,
0.0209086537,
-0.029754607,
0.0256087482,
0.0035063513,
-0.0276069921,
-0.023102656,
0.0725665689,
-0.0681801662,
-0.055771023,
-0.042513106,
-0.0467373095,
0.093144469,
-0.0419935919,
0.0470876507,
-0.0085844779,
-0.0010745135,
-0.0221172441,
0.0582814775,
0.0126314806,
0.008334334,
-0.0224798433,
-0.0030826416,
-0.029763326,
-0.0208580438,
0.1063663214,
0.0365472585,
0.0398198292,
0.0210740082,
-0.032222636,
-0.0033828581,
-0.0284872614,
0.0350195915,
0.0164726544,
-0.0410791487,
-0.0180184916,
-0.036562115,
-0.0454106294,
0.0516869873,
-0.0481186919,
-0.0239587892,
0.0136035616,
0.0524345338,
0.0725387782,
-0.0133325262,
-0.0072470885,
-0.0553452559,
0.0195829999,
-0.0156205548,
-0.0251278505,
-0.0036374235,
-6.792447169e-33,
-0.0148762409,
0.0278266743,
-0.0014170407,
-0.0201015584,
-0.0291930716,
0.0023534494,
-0.0661737993,
-0.0042112786,
0.0034891048,
-0.023570016,
-0.0429421104,
0.0047943057,
0.0139764315,
0.0361837931,
0.0323286876,
-0.0401849523,
0.0468634106,
-0.0048577702,
-0.004321835,
0.0306905452,
-0.0123879928,
0.0686680824,
0.0808752701,
0.0199861974,
-0.014875331,
-0.0086356858,
0.0376866423,
-0.0499154963,
0.0218875296,
0.065691255,
-0.0034559371,
0.0326714963,
0.0038336504,
-0.0649746284,
-0.0482393056,
-0.0024348113,
-0.0517629422,
-0.0162073486,
0.0207671933,
-0.0148075856,
0.0053510317,
-0.0424066298,
0.0173515752,
-0.0208420698,
0.0018094426,
-0.0016919674,
0.0138327442,
-0.0218231138,
-0.0529526547,
-0.0463365614,
-0.008028171,
0.0109479735,
0.0238916539,
-0.0031428218,
0.0165850036,
0.0327095501,
-0.0363015272,
0.037287496,
-0.0154476222,
0.0192913506,
0.0553075336,
0.0413076691,
0.0398721881,
0.0784922168,
0.0363916755,
0.0387724377,
-0.0024484475,
-0.0285712704,
-0.0115110101,
0.062088374,
0.0407816581,
0.0330634639,
0.0135687776,
0.0198561344,
0.0685920715,
0.0076098656,
-0.0452671833,
0.003448749,
-0.0308506545,
0.0028634188,
0.0565436371,
0.0080735264,
-0.0050217472,
-0.0079835467,
-0.0626142919,
0.0232251044,
-0.0231567919,
-0.0465618856,
0.0622927435,
0.0455262437,
-0.0401579067,
0.0366476402,
0.0601807684,
-0.0059106709,
0.0174045209,
0.0061236238,
-0.0013545763,
-0.0089799603,
-0.0237928871,
0.0310599636,
-0.078268066,
-0.0016482217,
0.0516044088,
-0.0223939363,
-0.0047317203,
-0.0161021203,
-0.0510758497,
-0.0228541661,
-0.0219945423,
-0.0057706675,
-0.0465377755,
0.0060224053,
-0.0099778231,
0.0144823566,
0.0321177877,
0.0130462814,
-0.0089244731,
0.0387167037,
0.0032933615,
-0.0167099461,
-0.0246173386,
-0.0102397762,
0.0204730872,
0.0435740873,
0.0234020036,
0.0083680451,
-0.0574212298,
0.0122596789,
-0.0032839947,
-0.0448700041,
-0.0379910171,
0.0018964572,
2.788e-7,
0.0350278653,
0.0338162258,
0.0027029053,
0.010264759,
-0.0322822034,
0.0249526333,
0.013612859,
0.0420619808,
-0.0317573883,
0.0074376469,
0.0255173706,
0.0504423678,
0.0417728834,
-0.0187367853,
-0.0897757486,
-0.0253755134,
-0.053408239,
0.0553855561,
-0.0468976647,
-0.030637376,
0.0538270026,
0.0753645077,
-0.0041455207,
-0.0130600035,
0.0122945802,
-0.0275168177,
0.0602877662,
-0.0331656821,
-0.0253590718,
0.0492053814,
0.0066234237,
0.0234260689,
-0.0312484223,
0.0309937187,
-0.0398023911,
-0.0020586832,
0.0394993424,
0.0509825349,
0.0189225804,
-0.0973640159,
-0.0288477968,
0.0168030616,
0.032988742,
-0.0546416678,
0.0899846703,
-0.0480714552,
-0.0010520301,
0.0081592258,
-0.057389427,
0.0212105513,
-0.0185275245,
-0.0433539599,
-0.0073697492,
0.0083452119,
0.0191186573,
0.0319703333,
-0.0271448102,
-0.0722942725,
0.0114977751,
0.0002381342,
-0.0127292937,
0.000175638,
-0.1031718552,
-0.0095541365,
0.0198351946,
-0.027780775,
0.0108553516,
2.700133942e-34,
0.0176283289,
-0.0246472433,
0.0046551796,
0.0451619588,
-0.0023157278,
-0.0259027984,
0.017912358,
0.0231380276,
0.0067090653,
-0.0718252435,
-0.0078056799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06365v1 | Multi-Modal Knowledge Graph Transformer Framework for Multi-Modal Entity Alignment | 2023-10-10T07:06:06 | 2023-10-10T07:06:06 | Qian Li, Cheng Ji, Shu Guo, Zhaoji Liang, Lihong Wang, Jianxin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-Modal Entity Alignment (MMEA) is a critical task that aims to identify
equivalent entity pairs across multi-modal knowledge graphs (MMKGs). However,
this task faces challenges due to the presence of different types of
information, including neighboring entities, multi-modal attributes, and entity
types. Directly incorporating the above information (e.g., concatenation or
attention) can lead to an unaligned information space. To address these
challenges, we propose a novel MMEA transformer, called MoAlign, that
hierarchically introduces neighbor features, multi-modal attributes, and entity
types to enhance the alignment task. Taking advantage of the transformer's
ability to better integrate multiple information, we design a hierarchical
modifiable self-attention block in a transformer encoder to preserve the unique
semantics of different information. Furthermore, we design two entity-type
prefix injection methods to integrate entity-type information using type
prefixes, which help to restrict the global information of entities not present
in the MMKGs. Our extensive experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate that
our approach outperforms strong competitors and achieves excellent entity
alignment performance. | [
-0.0166987628,
0.0545654744,
0.01844915,
0.031565275,
-0.0053075501,
0.0076247449,
0.0052418294,
-0.0042856364,
-0.0115412725,
-0.02823494,
-0.0268160868,
0.0287283827,
-0.0054648123,
0.0026629702,
0.0412489139,
-0.0214849338,
0.0484566614,
0.0405175835,
-0.0400701538,
0.0114499759,
0.0147944465,
0.0120624369,
-0.009917831,
0.0115691684,
-0.0187065732,
-0.0148730697,
-0.0350000188,
0.0222988352,
0.0641585886,
-0.0139464587,
0.0004588831,
0.0389039777,
0.0073854579,
0.0237449259,
0.0000020923,
-0.0378592275,
-0.042439431,
0.0176152978,
-0.0315324739,
-0.0657056794,
-0.0177645981,
-0.0636351928,
0.0365436971,
-0.0055457656,
0.0119220875,
-0.0659483522,
0.0676390305,
0.0494778305,
0.0524967946,
0.0497563109,
-0.0322001241,
-0.0299276263,
0.0586272553,
-0.0118287038,
0.0047489516,
-0.0262364578,
0.0249315687,
0.0050363243,
-0.0419523381,
0.0230187736,
-0.0178713165,
0.046624504,
-0.0090997564,
-0.0073522967,
0.0373664908,
0.0015483382,
0.0360171162,
0.0211415384,
-0.0244414061,
0.0836516917,
-0.0112845488,
0.0060691116,
0.0188320503,
0.0020328253,
0.0217301827,
0.0287759658,
-0.006423444,
-0.0210649222,
-0.046919737,
-0.01164719,
-0.0323512182,
0.0286024157,
0.0115102893,
-0.0542004444,
-0.0276244339,
0.0124076465,
0.0398314185,
-0.0130970394,
-0.026925303,
-0.0015790496,
0.0299401022,
-0.0569231622,
0.0151048396,
0.0350838937,
-0.0156980045,
-0.0050588297,
-0.0727826208,
-0.0189300869,
-0.0163151585,
-0.0004049618,
-0.0185849909,
0.0508102365,
0.0059350487,
0.0525673889,
-0.0220615137,
0.0362593755,
-0.0404803976,
0.0353159979,
-0.023816457,
-0.0690831989,
-0.0590575449,
0.0203733649,
-0.0161799919,
0.0026876738,
0.0014727918,
-0.0138763497,
-0.0098525155,
0.0274951998,
-0.0303342771,
0.0374333113,
0.0051858746,
0.0011112235,
-0.0152986143,
-0.0350074768,
-0.0303500332,
0.0821266174,
-0.0323341712,
-0.0126713086,
0.0051180199,
0.0060435706,
-0.0077107199,
0.0267571509,
0.0350598954,
-0.0468618199,
-0.0114739239,
0.0675409436,
-0.0147777675,
-0.011030335,
-0.0334150791,
-0.0286949594,
0.0045342105,
-0.0244596153,
0.0157753509,
-0.0238976292,
0.0882004127,
0.0078453496,
-0.0176064372,
-0.0589777045,
-0.0093679391,
-0.0345663279,
-0.0309416931,
0.0713072866,
-0.0296776649,
0.0139147528,
0.0084961336,
-0.0212998707,
-0.0130205965,
0.0194199141,
0.024277227,
-0.0423650444,
0.0128105544,
-0.0178506747,
-0.023814708,
0.0326306522,
0.0396074615,
-0.0084417984,
0.0370126292,
0.0119879795,
-0.0105624944,
0.0489259884,
0.0589374639,
0.0138639398,
0.0009642863,
-0.0336905755,
0.0295223221,
-0.0349026546,
0.0462579206,
0.0329563692,
0.0168306381,
0.0169229861,
-0.0405823886,
-0.0016960963,
-0.046716094,
0.0516149402,
-0.0283402596,
0.0086053228,
0.041191563,
0.0993638039,
-0.0242501013,
0.0296295509,
0.0328403302,
0.0017208069,
0.0036854104,
0.0009598364,
0.0224916488,
-0.00049153,
-0.0369659662,
0.1109365374,
0.0143425195,
-0.031666182,
-0.0159156229,
0.0034283542,
-0.0416765884,
0.039884828,
0.0239801072,
-0.0059994548,
-0.0926338509,
-0.0256342012,
-0.0612850823,
0.0361932218,
-0.0004698816,
-0.004129447,
0.0058607487,
-0.0429365151,
-0.0651909113,
0.0251221284,
-0.0231903736,
0.023871094,
-0.0015170493,
0.0374374576,
0.0206120703,
-0.0662027523,
0.0850586072,
0.012649212,
0.0060617938,
0.0458870977,
-0.0289561152,
0.0455212928,
-0.0007041816,
0.0425096266,
0.0144664943,
-0.0122922929,
0.0259417016,
-0.0058575803,
-0.0037127445,
-0.00835869,
-0.0164556857,
-0.0493508689,
0.0516935587,
-0.0396825485,
-0.0459106676,
-0.0094943941,
-0.0197290927,
-0.0555712692,
-0.0375453308,
-0.0183374099,
0.0472959056,
0.0158250704,
0.0184086654,
-0.0072068647,
0.0047750934,
-0.0072342143,
0.073388271,
-0.0103737088,
-0.0059878193,
0.0150405709,
-0.0251293033,
0.0142822601,
-0.0031255938,
-0.0165701639,
-0.0135874143,
-0.0000577955,
0.0124563258,
0.0015776842,
-0.040498022,
-0.0601968504,
-0.0156524591,
-0.1108050495,
0.032241147,
0.0160182267,
0.0316226594,
0.0203888882,
0.050636977,
0.007499468,
0.0095325541,
-0.0546566807,
0.0035603363,
-0.0111587895,
-0.0122710876,
0.0352257788,
-0.02409067,
-0.0315076709,
0.0179856978,
-0.008771521,
-0.0498942956,
0.0483041592,
0.0129658235,
-0.0310621485,
-0.0433671437,
0.0034819865,
-0.0470565185,
-0.0017533387,
-0.0052445238,
0.0188986715,
-0.0226898342,
0.0528125837,
0.0488788188,
0.0331265107,
0.0047967518,
-0.0051203836,
-0.0094851237,
-0.0255746935,
-0.0580107644,
0.0208561216,
0.0166558232,
0.0348680355,
-0.0070663951,
0.0148743847,
-0.0130590471,
0.0323132165,
-0.0073224911,
-0.0023994644,
-0.0410415456,
-0.0037834432,
0.0760714039,
0.005591616,
0.0078569539,
0.0170335174,
0.0240926631,
-0.0258774254,
-0.0496749207,
0.0424068645,
0.0899956897,
-0.0462837443,
0.004601798,
0.035173174,
0.0278698262,
-0.0502576046,
0.025969157,
-0.0018234308,
0.0312480256,
0.0316298977,
-0.0425228253,
-0.041456569,
0.0503763258,
0.0331074521,
-0.0192069802,
0.0850190669,
0.0295980908,
0.0359919816,
-0.021002382,
-0.0266168416,
-0.0201333351,
0.0014213775,
0.021057725,
0.014227422,
0.0378898978,
-0.023816593,
-0.0719574839,
0.0225308836,
0.0145266885,
0.0020938052,
0.0086522447,
-0.0118465833,
-0.0348888636,
0.0736673027,
0.0306024998,
0.0671399683,
0.0165843684,
0.0219136477,
-0.0138404332,
0.0404425412,
0.0009301149,
-0.0402264521,
0.0033383856,
-0.0136299701,
0.0006180296,
-0.0476010665,
0.0160667524,
-0.0235518329,
0.059035968,
-0.0362577736,
0.0427837297,
0.0723187029,
0.0002122791,
-0.0346056409,
-0.0230355337,
0.031027317,
0.0305604395,
0.0253041405,
0.0107900947,
-0.1121383533,
-0.0640939176,
-0.0033911397,
0.0028904353,
0.0453633256,
-0.0757635236,
0.0236666333,
-0.0792588666,
-0.0200229567,
0.0015892964,
-0.0331946723,
-0.0777297541,
-0.0370691121,
0.0423345491,
-0.0215303954,
-0.0066811829,
-0.0017500687,
-0.0142112933,
-0.0377048813,
-0.0129385451,
0.0512345806,
-0.0546533056,
0.0091244867,
-0.0813132823,
0.0634415969,
-0.0154374791,
0.0124844778,
0.0162024796,
-0.0349809453,
-0.0554731824,
0.0064299833,
-0.0582064427,
0.0330860429,
0.0408339053,
-0.0874550119,
-0.001985356,
-0.0345195532,
0.0101638492,
-0.0349536911,
0.015884107,
-0.0154258553,
0.0859239176,
0.0302278977,
0.0201167092,
-0.0203048605,
-0.046986416,
0.0082718097,
0.0684343129,
-0.0141690942,
-0.0031767453,
0.0160819422,
-0.0196447354,
0.035662245,
0.0163271241,
0.0056814435,
0.0595494919,
-0.049389828,
-0.0308968127,
-0.0207747407,
-0.0436146893,
0.0164218675,
0.0097491918,
0.0142207164,
-0.0260987822,
0.0345321633,
-0.0253861677,
-0.0986451954,
0.016665088,
-0.0583172999,
-0.0016998403,
-0.0111846142,
0.0113432482,
0.0331943594,
0.0172487069,
-0.0199944079,
-0.0024354556,
-0.0931703076,
-0.0533003137,
-0.0554355718,
0.0002664818,
0.004479791,
0.0941105261,
-0.0074042198,
0.038947802,
0.016542742,
0.0198459886,
-0.0687581152,
-0.0138685871,
-0.0032821218,
-0.0317082256,
-0.0048811627,
0.0282054748,
-0.0676820576,
-0.0269747321,
-0.0228398181,
0.0262865871,
-0.0353743732,
-0.0791419297,
0.0130935935,
0.0169082563,
0.0043767798,
0.0133910002,
0.0142222075,
-0.0280544739,
0.0228170156,
-0.0020566208,
-0.0347751677,
-0.0273152515,
-0.0064577814,
-0.0090504084,
-0.0089880433,
0.040199209,
0.0518734083,
0.0313485079,
-0.0092984792,
-0.0259660576,
0.0132779963,
-0.0249045659,
0.0084875664,
0.0056896126,
-0.0330469906,
-0.0187317804,
0.032824669,
0.0508103445,
0.0294313934,
-0.0674735829,
0.0371712111,
0.0358090252,
0.0083426815,
-0.0481628552,
0.0364633165,
-0.0195690989,
0.0198101383,
-0.0484753437,
0.0036539566,
0.0473261327,
0.0243064407,
0.0651861429,
0.0329376832,
-0.006077277,
0.0118549885,
0.0373188928,
-0.0205540974,
-0.0065519735,
0.0426589362,
0.0046722763,
0.0066119642,
0.0033514586,
0.0604877174,
-0.0451062731,
0.0546631552,
-0.0452627577,
-0.0351702645,
-0.0451382995,
-0.0201677382,
0.0494458899,
-0.0127796074,
0.0070675742,
-0.0362954512,
-0.0385548286,
-0.0375618227,
0.0414783768,
-0.0130568668,
-0.0378719717,
0.0176273566,
0.025496304,
-0.0037258947,
0.0169255994,
-0.0699587688,
0.0118702939,
-0.0087249968,
-0.0150772873,
-0.0181438103,
0.0046953987,
-6.37347233e-33,
-0.0603278279,
-0.0241359826,
0.0164740495,
-0.0488946214,
-0.0510979705,
-0.0004254568,
-0.0225186963,
-0.0263743512,
-0.0358846635,
-0.0119199017,
0.0021159544,
0.0022804127,
0.0023815439,
0.0142410547,
0.0057239635,
-0.034873914,
0.0478244275,
0.0302001704,
-0.016001584,
0.0125239361,
0.0237201266,
0.0004917317,
0.0476045683,
-0.0738866329,
0.0247510429,
0.0125250472,
-0.003959849,
-0.0073378133,
0.0306696724,
0.0690849647,
0.002361879,
0.0006011175,
0.0149063924,
-0.0340655744,
-0.0029910963,
0.008715854,
-0.1132512465,
-0.0200487934,
-0.0359523818,
0.0237345491,
-0.0070241326,
-0.0410770029,
0.0731103569,
-0.0058499607,
0.0463748239,
-0.0760431662,
0.0462077968,
0.0000970736,
-0.006970251,
-0.0408318751,
-0.0205214508,
0.0256893728,
-0.0278553851,
0.006586405,
-0.0041520842,
-0.0030960222,
0.0685680434,
-0.0167124607,
-0.0977845043,
0.0096646864,
-0.0047853328,
-0.0088618305,
0.06472449,
0.0170087516,
-0.0007386729,
0.0385720655,
-0.0019135433,
-0.0434662253,
-0.0300097894,
0.0418549702,
-0.0071362741,
0.0386327989,
-0.002504043,
0.0718674511,
-0.004445666,
0.007699342,
-0.0362992622,
0.052353099,
-0.0459367856,
0.0103970701,
-0.0643430874,
0.030188797,
-0.0132591277,
-0.0128207905,
-0.0134838801,
-0.0180495325,
-0.027175488,
-0.0304486956,
0.017707089,
-0.0210216474,
-0.0289653074,
0.0660253614,
0.0499184504,
-0.0319726095,
-0.0227687843,
0.0420393683,
0.0168503989,
0.0519809313,
-0.0126727186,
0.0149236005,
-0.0065858192,
-0.044761423,
0.0662152544,
-0.041319672,
0.0163973123,
0.0465581827,
0.0298829339,
-0.002532139,
-0.0582116432,
-0.0047004009,
0.0035988991,
-0.0565922372,
-0.0630466565,
-0.0486922115,
0.0363662355,
0.0197476018,
0.0121060256,
0.0300922692,
0.0797627345,
0.0288010426,
-0.0369526632,
0.0092132203,
0.0386433043,
0.0485563427,
0.0128062647,
0.0306581631,
-0.0500346385,
-0.0826638043,
0.0038006676,
-0.0561359376,
-0.0047802725,
0.0182518978,
2.845e-7,
0.0339721702,
0.0103755789,
0.0659273192,
-0.0163332969,
0.0039065252,
0.0504253246,
0.0400971733,
0.0592571795,
-0.0168245863,
-0.0454400443,
0.0367183685,
-0.0079951044,
-0.0034239904,
0.0430698469,
-0.0344364569,
-0.0178562943,
-0.0046634409,
-0.0024071238,
-0.0524456203,
0.0430834927,
0.0909551382,
0.0759871826,
0.0105543192,
0.0308192279,
0.0046880799,
-0.0072600762,
0.0542959757,
0.0292006526,
0.0057439469,
0.0482811481,
-0.0033179878,
-0.0181089323,
-0.0080610747,
0.0610585436,
0.0010246122,
0.0405376628,
0.0357168093,
0.0512948148,
-0.0228603687,
-0.0148277031,
-0.0276719686,
-0.021853283,
-0.012816512,
-0.0335834548,
0.0607111417,
-0.0306464881,
-0.0070164162,
0.011136448,
-0.0541042127,
0.0456066355,
-0.0380231515,
0.0424108207,
-0.021009719,
0.0235677529,
0.0375900641,
0.0021667681,
-0.0327887498,
-0.0616026483,
0.005631573,
0.0132443188,
-0.0420396477,
-0.0026127896,
-0.000761171,
-0.0978838652,
0.0681368485,
-0.0500806645,
-0.0275612902,
2.871896625e-34,
-0.0432159603,
0.0038390695,
0.0034613428,
0.0069760494,
0.0561617091,
-0.0744826049,
-0.0503597185,
-0.0048812074,
-0.020935392,
-0.0543892346,
-0.0161047895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06362v1 | InfoCL: Alleviating Catastrophic Forgetting in Continual Text Classification from An Information Theoretic Perspective | 2023-10-10T07:00:13 | 2023-10-10T07:00:13 | Yifan Song, Peiyi Wang, Weimin Xiong, Dawei Zhu, Tianyu Liu, Zhifang Sui, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Continual learning (CL) aims to constantly learn new knowledge over time
while avoiding catastrophic forgetting on old tasks. We focus on continual text
classification under the class-incremental setting. Recent CL studies have
identified the severe performance decrease on analogous classes as a key factor
for catastrophic forgetting. In this paper, through an in-depth exploration of
the representation learning process in CL, we discover that the compression
effect of the information bottleneck leads to confusion on analogous classes.
To enable the model learn more sufficient representations, we propose a novel
replay-based continual text classification method, InfoCL. Our approach
utilizes fast-slow and current-past contrastive learning to perform mutual
information maximization and better recover the previously learned
representations. In addition, InfoCL incorporates an adversarial memory
augmentation strategy to alleviate the overfitting problem of replay.
Experimental results demonstrate that InfoCL effectively mitigates forgetting
and achieves state-of-the-art performance on three text classification tasks.
The code is publicly available at https://github.com/Yifan-Song793/InfoCL. | [
0.0150291137,
0.0515847839,
-0.0049031968,
0.0107274503,
-0.0093527138,
0.0239901505,
-0.0335952751,
-0.0001788661,
0.0185269434,
-0.0479976721,
-0.0149986558,
-0.0338343233,
0.0038084134,
-0.0132458862,
-0.007162875,
-0.0414682627,
0.0577340424,
0.0312760845,
-0.0163441803,
-0.0087896828,
0.0131381499,
-0.0461787209,
-0.0040271021,
-0.0405955724,
0.0097684776,
-0.0514492951,
-0.0123507893,
-0.0275898967,
0.0241982937,
-0.0603092797,
0.0411399156,
0.0199428052,
0.0407171659,
0.0222053006,
0.0000022104,
-0.0387449823,
-0.0218668021,
-0.01495858,
-0.0471879654,
-0.005263451,
0.045052737,
0.0074805561,
-0.0040404885,
0.0018977375,
-0.0348337181,
-0.0573925711,
0.0214215349,
0.0825586021,
0.0445710979,
0.0438464358,
0.0037925483,
-0.0259380732,
0.0744790807,
-0.0387932621,
0.0558311567,
-0.0168332551,
0.0223393887,
-0.0155531457,
-0.0388089009,
0.0280695055,
-0.0046217563,
0.0692200959,
0.0633016005,
0.0106090419,
0.0159312431,
0.0598638467,
0.0567127168,
0.0282978732,
-0.0252200253,
0.0117708463,
0.0002279829,
-0.0404743962,
-0.0352040455,
0.0102668516,
-0.0088454904,
-0.0676151961,
-0.0512566194,
-0.0099884123,
-0.0421385542,
0.0020309775,
0.0022757985,
0.0439901091,
0.0114720473,
0.0183641538,
-0.0185433477,
-0.077514559,
-0.0016160047,
-0.0243621282,
-0.0203917269,
-0.0344184488,
-0.028517697,
0.0175425615,
0.0097953919,
0.0250199959,
0.0045250715,
-0.0049690362,
-0.0252299905,
-0.0440513566,
0.056093771,
-0.0633700565,
0.0174283795,
0.0034812919,
0.0149986492,
0.0457202047,
-0.0193813909,
0.0419214442,
0.0167728253,
-0.0006391246,
-0.0197013635,
0.0398086235,
-0.0992658064,
-0.0343917869,
-0.0303073041,
0.0789094046,
0.0688361973,
0.0194711313,
-0.0207343753,
0.0439922288,
-0.0194399543,
0.0605074279,
-0.065263547,
0.0169778261,
-0.0527770296,
0.0099955387,
-0.0037863688,
0.0126521615,
-0.0055970363,
0.0002011055,
-0.0071828985,
-0.000547762,
-0.0306079593,
0.0195899773,
-0.0190011971,
-0.0206122529,
0.0287089739,
0.0468431599,
-0.0660279542,
-0.0579635687,
-0.061344251,
0.0034931975,
-0.0072176214,
-0.0627265871,
-0.0160576124,
-0.0142079415,
0.0018460402,
0.0012884844,
-0.0087954449,
-0.0514136329,
-0.0140935276,
0.0249055922,
-0.0117086116,
0.1137590036,
0.0273379069,
-0.0758023635,
0.0589321144,
0.0328581855,
0.0454549007,
0.0189210456,
-0.0288303941,
0.0047546765,
0.0115832398,
0.0242443196,
0.0232772361,
-0.0170745254,
0.0431982204,
0.0278309006,
-0.0611494668,
0.0152996052,
0.0558167212,
0.0321715027,
0.0140993828,
0.0306779444,
-0.0267178416,
-0.0144375525,
0.0470139123,
-0.0309762806,
0.0053035528,
0.0728635266,
-0.011491539,
0.0209786426,
0.0073230593,
0.0403892212,
-0.0427328236,
0.0492391847,
-0.0112853553,
0.0092365686,
-0.000639124,
-0.0179246664,
-0.0469645225,
-0.0538300239,
0.0331818983,
-0.0300534144,
0.0017469018,
-0.0193972904,
0.0584349371,
0.0222465117,
-0.0339488573,
0.0443628766,
0.016177427,
-0.0136363711,
-0.025424486,
-0.0353297032,
0.0239532907,
0.0647839159,
0.0477513671,
-0.0775162131,
-0.0229907427,
-0.0490257144,
0.0071851611,
-0.0304053016,
0.0350209661,
-0.0101354169,
0.0183994379,
-0.0559086576,
-0.0165090095,
0.0014547324,
0.0153334001,
0.0217795242,
-0.0026400902,
0.0408216715,
0.0143510355,
0.0135407746,
-0.0500185266,
0.0234771706,
-0.0207949914,
-0.0539091639,
0.0179799516,
-0.0064375782,
-0.0075677144,
-0.0078810062,
-0.0256598312,
-0.0005328491,
0.0582755432,
-0.0650136322,
-0.0295108277,
-0.0115257166,
-0.059321925,
-0.0623329394,
0.0445169769,
0.0193298161,
0.015260323,
0.0029722902,
-0.0409041047,
-0.0363116451,
-0.003981736,
-0.0024542918,
0.0442967266,
-0.040295925,
0.0167381484,
-0.0199265387,
0.0051358594,
-0.0358254462,
0.0593829937,
-0.0350075066,
0.0179283936,
0.0061112093,
0.0091030542,
0.0207405463,
-0.0551880188,
0.0111791538,
0.0225748997,
-0.0143252872,
0.0378682241,
0.0108486041,
0.0019686716,
-0.0090357764,
-0.033387851,
-0.0528203994,
0.0108887907,
-0.0094316993,
-0.0168677345,
-0.0153215006,
-0.0185825583,
0.013384752,
-0.0396936573,
-0.0319514722,
0.0017071858,
-0.0702804253,
0.0129202157,
0.0277985297,
-0.0041506784,
0.0104637211,
0.0018531538,
0.0001236741,
0.0339666568,
0.0481999591,
-0.0194576737,
-0.0233653579,
-0.0415253751,
0.0344246775,
0.0080762617,
0.0234638024,
-0.0357529111,
-0.0052115456,
-0.0281617716,
-0.0086526666,
0.016471127,
0.0676454678,
0.0608435795,
0.0412859283,
0.0140267015,
0.0316736884,
-0.0438602157,
0.0256281979,
-0.026008727,
-0.0110213151,
0.0078849187,
0.0059146709,
-0.0201165061,
0.0417878442,
-0.0143212769,
0.0175222866,
0.0188071486,
-0.0175436623,
-0.0273862071,
0.0177458674,
-0.0600417331,
0.0222816747,
-0.0109351287,
-0.0657782927,
-0.0046726367,
-0.0622126684,
0.0464563705,
0.0299684573,
0.0082633561,
-0.0468891785,
-0.0382067524,
0.0104159405,
0.0693633929,
-0.0007487471,
0.0214828756,
0.0582255758,
-0.0248478744,
-0.0444352552,
-0.0213237908,
0.0330553502,
-0.0196508728,
0.0239003971,
0.0423504002,
0.0137956981,
-0.0294819791,
-0.0557264164,
-0.0545172319,
-0.0640681982,
0.0326221399,
-0.0092620226,
-0.0183783285,
0.0126254391,
-0.0607358143,
-0.0076484289,
0.0570743866,
0.0340974182,
-0.0141378921,
-0.0386279002,
0.0027834726,
0.0575218946,
-0.0035746095,
0.0234019291,
0.0140174255,
-0.0203760546,
0.0457331352,
0.081963107,
0.0335582346,
0.0294427089,
-0.0141900387,
-0.0100176046,
-0.0043309703,
-0.0060559665,
-0.0099909557,
0.0008191958,
-0.0348450094,
-0.0572337881,
-0.039973896,
0.0550272539,
0.0183797069,
-0.1044258848,
-0.0202005394,
0.0289559886,
0.0341400094,
0.0139732044,
0.0034721019,
-0.0370230451,
-0.0314845182,
-0.0063416688,
0.0344202481,
0.0209612735,
0.0177153815,
-0.032674402,
-0.0061110863,
-0.0101520801,
0.038756676,
-0.0193641819,
-0.0209382046,
-0.0190337766,
-0.0720961168,
0.0084902169,
0.0133485282,
0.020844724,
-0.0118260467,
-0.0050914208,
0.0438744575,
-0.0342033282,
-0.0228548739,
0.0132241109,
-0.0054599103,
-0.0020014064,
0.0379999168,
0.0310701095,
0.0158521906,
-0.0488547869,
0.0625641942,
-0.0603028908,
-0.0183086209,
-0.0101167122,
0.0984322652,
-0.0093461657,
0.0070439992,
-0.0029300982,
0.0202604719,
-0.001624431,
-0.0358815081,
0.0252333842,
0.0057698805,
-0.0301238094,
0.0169902127,
-0.0001837393,
-0.0427276045,
-0.0015553891,
0.058503639,
-0.0007820664,
-0.0468748249,
-0.0308933854,
-0.0130128376,
0.043063987,
-0.0599069223,
0.0346731804,
0.0147309527,
-0.0246078894,
-0.0169904083,
-0.019525608,
-0.0421370566,
-0.0469791256,
0.0205792915,
-0.008902465,
0.0163192041,
-0.0613671839,
-0.0216934998,
-0.0958746821,
-0.0315145925,
-0.0062115486,
0.0197414625,
-0.0293357372,
-0.0048570568,
0.062994428,
-0.0337599628,
-0.0050001261,
0.0037512246,
-0.0909562558,
-0.0133565562,
0.0175721981,
0.0309270397,
0.0069098673,
0.0881157517,
-0.0080012809,
-0.0351802483,
0.0816049278,
0.0455531664,
-0.0121292146,
0.020056311,
0.0347073339,
0.0119514829,
0.017105937,
0.0270642098,
0.0017039373,
-0.0041708774,
0.0259955451,
-0.0050399485,
-0.002225741,
0.0546248928,
0.0153708393,
-0.0410735123,
0.0063749193,
0.0074303481,
-0.0258267242,
0.0007289061,
0.050129313,
0.0423445627,
-0.0126415174,
-0.0101386858,
0.0030701014,
0.0209004674,
0.005793523,
-0.0177104883,
0.0142944148,
0.0571852662,
0.0078617185,
-0.0074346107,
-0.0477835238,
-0.0025850332,
0.0317685753,
0.0267381445,
0.029562002,
-0.0542889051,
0.0131236585,
-0.0269730352,
0.0276280548,
-0.0303469598,
0.0351095386,
0.0312822573,
-0.0125930775,
-0.0739241615,
0.0338170566,
-0.051091861,
-0.0183953401,
-0.0380681604,
0.026176434,
0.0913528502,
0.0334051624,
-0.0151125574,
-0.0152585674,
0.0162707865,
-0.0335640348,
-0.0145865446,
0.0027128211,
-0.0349990539,
-0.0205740891,
0.0033254712,
-0.0182045326,
0.0414945893,
0.0673227683,
-0.0307488162,
0.0081623765,
0.0124752987,
-0.0187677816,
-0.0442131311,
0.0403660424,
0.0118465135,
0.0432055742,
0.0091421558,
-0.010748365,
-0.0099806124,
-0.0374519043,
0.0742250457,
-0.021392474,
0.0277658608,
0.0123275118,
0.0197895113,
0.0231617074,
0.0127717722,
-0.0051972996,
-0.0171431173,
0.0472619012,
0.0364136063,
0.0034416665,
-0.0080891009,
-6.48244286e-33,
-0.002495545,
0.016249815,
0.0205798075,
-0.020996809,
-0.0515426509,
0.0160146188,
-0.0364354849,
-0.0201573968,
0.0206425823,
0.0031484324,
0.0081127835,
0.0221186653,
-0.012038108,
0.0585401691,
0.0399551243,
-0.0478180237,
0.0531987064,
0.0262022577,
-0.0147544509,
0.063732937,
0.0827265605,
0.0566135906,
0.0240837354,
-0.0602727756,
0.0026578654,
0.0124273533,
0.0058304612,
0.0219389815,
0.0109546846,
0.0473662615,
-0.0512976944,
0.0439650677,
0.0384662338,
-0.0412918441,
-0.0300466679,
-0.0173989441,
-0.1274644583,
-0.0466630459,
-0.0590203851,
0.0316754952,
-0.0263538454,
-0.0234998837,
0.0150459958,
-0.0148384944,
0.0034760488,
-0.0307033844,
0.0185983572,
-0.0102010742,
-0.0707303211,
-0.0222063288,
-0.0346608683,
-0.0002821786,
0.0153168263,
-0.0065238224,
-0.0145549327,
-0.006215354,
0.006948017,
-0.015364537,
-0.135207504,
-0.0478388369,
0.0066998042,
0.0422300473,
-0.0151989488,
0.0257520899,
0.0272715967,
0.0511828922,
0.0188985001,
-0.015182226,
-0.0035305072,
-0.003926652,
0.0343051814,
-0.0426709503,
0.0299000125,
-0.0157526173,
0.0634837002,
-0.0629318282,
-0.0308897682,
0.0023923516,
0.0399511792,
0.0542679392,
0.0293940585,
0.0409271829,
-0.0296287369,
-0.0461611897,
-0.0176777095,
-0.0073009371,
-0.0351064354,
-0.0032446489,
0.0324025452,
0.0697101057,
0.0119641647,
-0.0300911795,
0.0035907186,
-0.0188729148,
-0.0607755035,
0.0246686377,
-0.0060432795,
0.0147926798,
0.0068489024,
0.0158326924,
-0.0338100083,
-0.0068292217,
-0.016321199,
-0.0047334018,
-0.0216670036,
0.0299465097,
0.0820541605,
0.0512090102,
-0.0513822809,
-0.0044725761,
-0.0005186452,
0.0000738341,
0.0415653698,
0.0081985593,
0.0066950587,
0.0465798303,
0.0045243343,
0.04167483,
0.0558447205,
-0.0142608499,
-0.0411236174,
0.010690188,
0.01470837,
0.0302015021,
-0.0160400309,
-0.0252198894,
-0.0362926461,
0.0023337437,
-0.0016998976,
-0.1297046244,
0.0379899517,
-0.0056277635,
2.875e-7,
-0.0256719496,
0.0062003448,
0.012390052,
-0.0758578703,
0.0522875004,
0.0452795811,
-0.0385110267,
0.0296211261,
-0.0301774535,
0.0785285011,
0.0105244201,
0.0184457414,
0.0281194616,
0.0091022057,
-0.047757484,
0.0269243475,
-0.0483717285,
0.0194707382,
-0.0444624349,
0.016657291,
0.0376384296,
0.1034682542,
0.0308818407,
-0.0009944476,
0.0572652109,
-0.0799074993,
0.0840633884,
0.0060332553,
0.053434182,
-0.0094533656,
0.0201255232,
0.0546820164,
-0.000516002,
-0.0118191447,
-0.0402727611,
-0.0360891521,
-0.030957561,
0.0105760936,
-0.0111450814,
-0.0549974926,
0.0167262964,
0.0171195175,
0.0024303321,
-0.0138641801,
0.0761586353,
-0.0932326987,
-0.0049941447,
0.0174221322,
-0.0084397094,
-0.0053109126,
0.0375961922,
0.0579462387,
-0.0417196974,
0.0132002914,
-0.023759244,
0.0614525378,
-0.021548178,
-0.1183488667,
0.0026396888,
0.0182074402,
-0.0447308905,
-0.0074689025,
-0.0460653305,
-0.0031683063,
0.0451324619,
-0.0665912926,
0.009100182,
2.541334987e-34,
0.0279088952,
-0.0313677751,
-0.0094635366,
0.0361138135,
-0.0172283016,
-0.0253719427,
0.039163433,
0.0084229652,
0.0426909439,
-0.0413713381,
-0.0022144138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06356v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06356v3 | A Semantic Invariant Robust Watermark for Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T06:49:43 | 2024-05-19T12:24:40 | Aiwei Liu, Leyi Pan, Xuming Hu, Shiao Meng, Lijie Wen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Watermark algorithms for large language models (LLMs) have achieved extremely
high accuracy in detecting text generated by LLMs. Such algorithms typically
involve adding extra watermark logits to the LLM's logits at each generation
step. However, prior algorithms face a trade-off between attack robustness and
security robustness. This is because the watermark logits for a token are
determined by a certain number of preceding tokens; a small number leads to low
security robustness, while a large number results in insufficient attack
robustness. In this work, we propose a semantic invariant watermarking method
for LLMs that provides both attack robustness and security robustness. The
watermark logits in our work are determined by the semantics of all preceding
tokens. Specifically, we utilize another embedding LLM to generate semantic
embeddings for all preceding tokens, and then these semantic embeddings are
transformed into the watermark logits through our trained watermark model.
Subsequent analyses and experiments demonstrated the attack robustness of our
method in semantically invariant settings: synonym substitution and text
paraphrasing settings. Finally, we also show that our watermark possesses
adequate security robustness. Our code and data are available at
\href{https://github.com/THU-BPM/Robust_Watermark}{https://github.com/THU-BPM/Robust\_Watermark}.
Additionally, our algorithm could also be accessed through MarkLLM
\citep{pan2024markllm} \footnote{https://github.com/THU-BPM/MarkLLM}. | [
0.0436405167,
0.042008087,
0.0009845138,
0.0397786461,
-0.0432824567,
-0.0185385048,
0.0144040789,
0.0682578981,
0.0052218996,
-0.0602340028,
0.0088970466,
0.0222303309,
-0.0147816688,
0.0174011774,
0.056606818,
-0.0174008273,
0.04608934,
-0.0217610672,
-0.0177186038,
-0.0193271693,
-0.0048225694,
-0.0076382901,
0.0696910396,
0.0277712457,
-0.0308993813,
0.0017524123,
0.0108000161,
0.0208177343,
-0.0059292112,
-0.014733687,
-0.0459292121,
0.0385154821,
0.0095959296,
0.0940626636,
0.0000020399,
-0.0462502241,
-0.0474630669,
0.0429759473,
-0.0285785422,
0.066036731,
0.0542893484,
-0.0152987549,
-0.0303220451,
0.008381499,
-0.0084449807,
0.0369257331,
0.0333241932,
0.0580751561,
0.1003933251,
0.0532751046,
-0.015433006,
0.0051212138,
0.0332720727,
0.0008800616,
0.0125114638,
-0.0390751809,
0.0453779995,
0.0145186204,
-0.0254907049,
0.035385631,
0.0051824474,
0.0559783429,
-0.0203558076,
-0.0290583987,
-0.048645135,
-0.0107909814,
-0.0126184067,
0.0127184,
0.0149101336,
0.0112727098,
-0.0718889982,
-0.0188646503,
0.012353994,
-0.0061371354,
0.0268493649,
0.0439357571,
-0.0233806092,
0.0255638137,
0.0407855138,
0.0075318823,
0.0103992652,
-0.0155409276,
0.055020269,
0.0130280992,
-0.0049195173,
0.0450280234,
0.0563345924,
-0.0089698918,
-0.0634444878,
-0.0487661585,
-0.0419959538,
-0.0510837138,
0.044724077,
0.0007655451,
0.0486401021,
0.0126924999,
-0.1312715262,
-0.0631828383,
0.0180455521,
-0.032117825,
0.0313725099,
0.0201505143,
-0.0217190925,
0.0462616459,
-0.0761227384,
0.0869913846,
-0.0464201272,
0.0369454436,
0.0168892909,
-0.0404207259,
-0.0028962316,
-0.0343707427,
-0.0376472324,
0.0613995567,
-0.0226601288,
-0.0182863157,
-0.0434947722,
0.0662065148,
0.0016239334,
0.0477468409,
-0.0342382118,
-0.043172434,
0.022919504,
-0.0074684974,
0.0436520875,
-0.0593362637,
0.0321524963,
-0.0027100928,
-0.0226180349,
-0.023854034,
-0.0011749123,
0.0381840244,
0.0219244324,
0.0114195747,
-0.0164399929,
0.1249150038,
0.0381315015,
-0.045811329,
-0.0258539058,
-0.0610848367,
0.0096705062,
0.0381435193,
-0.007202927,
-0.0574530102,
-0.0251913592,
-0.0378410891,
0.008394056,
-0.0784316659,
0.0135176862,
0.0146378502,
-0.0367567129,
0.0481136404,
-0.0324696787,
-0.0361524858,
-0.0152882347,
0.0091226967,
-0.0370686576,
0.0412168391,
0.0339779072,
0.0532505214,
0.0868775696,
-0.0059256577,
-0.0057487069,
0.0464918241,
-0.0047232462,
0.0243683755,
-0.0182582159,
-0.0273785219,
0.0753471926,
-0.0312274024,
-0.0159588158,
0.0621848255,
-0.0085529843,
-0.0724587739,
0.0582031347,
0.0769916475,
-0.0452379063,
0.0067022536,
-0.0001988161,
0.0187012907,
-0.0022760078,
-0.0121347066,
-0.0224064961,
-0.0347274281,
-0.0311556384,
-0.0386521295,
0.0266574826,
-0.02103962,
0.0115014883,
0.0106750019,
-0.0479257889,
-0.0266909152,
-0.0163046159,
-0.029778704,
-0.0063005784,
0.0248178151,
-0.0384821445,
0.0539966635,
-0.016968064,
-0.0068127722,
0.0430437997,
-0.064809911,
0.0234291721,
0.0410278887,
0.0764263198,
-0.0044206386,
0.0724581331,
-0.0057220687,
-0.0061212252,
0.0431760028,
-0.0413241014,
0.0071775517,
0.0078362562,
-0.0233724546,
-0.0209787451,
-0.0405816734,
0.0166386515,
0.0102270739,
0.0338957682,
0.0340842791,
0.0520596579,
-0.0312369689,
-0.0001543624,
0.0276656449,
0.0291555449,
-0.0005611451,
0.0043730736,
-0.0419704467,
0.0364394151,
0.0198962446,
-0.0071874931,
0.0465858281,
0.0181323532,
-0.0153833833,
-0.0291238111,
-0.0188591201,
0.0186675806,
0.0141378623,
0.040650405,
-0.0397004932,
0.0030949772,
0.0358669087,
-0.030783888,
-0.0145711834,
0.0242756438,
-0.0587369353,
0.0495501496,
-0.0254278686,
0.0515473075,
-0.0124681545,
0.0471131131,
-0.0272470396,
0.0040101404,
-0.0122392215,
0.0106439944,
-0.0175961927,
0.0602838621,
0.01505097,
0.0029240979,
-0.0513122231,
-0.0150450692,
-0.0425611064,
-0.0029967166,
-0.0067360969,
-0.0112450002,
-0.0073729171,
-0.027092956,
-0.0395862833,
0.0075452426,
-0.0009492328,
0.0292957034,
0.0258829072,
0.0032642381,
0.0053958911,
-0.0114400461,
-0.009983073,
-0.0151447486,
0.0088902926,
0.0415340215,
0.0314520895,
-0.0252507366,
-0.037427377,
-0.0128013557,
-0.0152487159,
0.0044728685,
0.0748588815,
-0.0144038191,
-0.0520295389,
-0.0742898434,
0.0124697089,
-0.031538479,
0.0005905134,
-0.0028357666,
-0.0086248759,
-0.0149411429,
0.0054617655,
0.011358005,
0.031305816,
0.0372170545,
0.0043497519,
0.0427701734,
0.0165193491,
-0.0156171629,
-0.0582426712,
-0.0168693848,
-0.0096024191,
-0.0157742649,
-0.0182503015,
0.0533176847,
0.0034233755,
0.0099021392,
0.0010483642,
-0.0022281788,
0.034398593,
-0.0096930945,
0.0145984413,
-0.0192784388,
-0.0286717433,
-0.0256224759,
0.0001613737,
0.0044123703,
-0.0432325006,
0.0118834898,
-0.053995993,
0.0380764566,
-0.0054433886,
-0.0166832693,
0.0175089035,
0.0353287384,
-0.0207005683,
0.0361626074,
-0.0190435667,
-0.0266839527,
-0.0091248723,
-0.035235934,
0.0433479436,
-0.0442385636,
-0.0094189569,
-0.0196711775,
-0.0078007621,
-0.0028879268,
0.0055007595,
-0.0455802046,
-0.058973901,
-0.019515764,
0.0106400466,
0.0253258273,
-0.03442185,
-0.0262379162,
-0.0029198295,
0.0301691219,
0.0315391943,
-0.01496277,
0.0047835889,
-0.04233215,
0.0628209934,
0.0100288494,
-0.0659919083,
0.0101669496,
0.0063211578,
0.0068622432,
0.0904699862,
0.0167420637,
-0.0027937701,
0.0154347634,
-0.0049947407,
0.0271295533,
0.0005405074,
-0.0145231327,
0.0167511236,
-0.0045301779,
-0.0350477472,
0.0284067504,
0.0814570263,
0.0407200865,
0.0154308816,
0.0145396832,
-0.0084414454,
0.0011043031,
0.015939923,
-0.026513163,
-0.0752527043,
-0.0252414551,
0.0504066199,
0.007528381,
-0.01328931,
0.0004097441,
-0.0297344495,
-0.0459315963,
0.0148744117,
0.0279669873,
-0.0067727813,
-0.0077366591,
-0.0682807714,
-0.0142718293,
0.0573502034,
0.0007312956,
-0.0453261025,
0.0349443853,
-0.0336318649,
0.011287082,
-0.0117562274,
-0.0361641012,
0.0013596546,
-0.0432474203,
0.0074874628,
0.0448844135,
0.028077716,
-0.0137028908,
-0.0350372531,
0.0811755955,
-0.0055182017,
-0.0289082322,
0.0093299337,
0.026476793,
-0.0220177509,
-0.0257789884,
0.0052142157,
0.0097446134,
0.0333225355,
-0.0379726849,
0.0110994922,
0.0412303284,
0.008219827,
0.0157312285,
-0.0022269534,
-0.0263430923,
-0.0043805833,
0.0576294586,
0.0096603911,
-0.0170810428,
-0.0244375151,
-0.051852338,
0.0275157336,
-0.0048549529,
-0.0243443903,
0.0001935191,
-0.040822655,
-0.0335054845,
-0.0643577725,
0.0514044575,
-0.0542446673,
0.0258579534,
0.0400995053,
0.0484011583,
0.0104495436,
-0.0421971716,
-0.0356323496,
-0.0211311206,
-0.1213605553,
0.0392021649,
-0.0643426105,
0.045360595,
0.0412814021,
0.0013835141,
-0.0365570113,
0.0378288403,
-0.0773132592,
-0.0625576228,
0.0029126757,
0.0032788909,
0.0137965046,
-0.0145658348,
-0.0363881551,
-0.0629778355,
0.0659662262,
0.0223293658,
-0.0078243278,
0.01342203,
0.0587449558,
-0.0037222889,
0.0028487814,
0.0269109868,
-0.068598792,
-0.0191327091,
0.0510508604,
-0.0267348886,
-0.0120711355,
0.0126347961,
0.0042836401,
0.0704963878,
0.032262966,
-0.0075681857,
0.0232546404,
0.0272446964,
0.0196028724,
-0.0464361832,
-0.0370251983,
-0.0112869218,
0.0427562445,
0.0289989971,
-0.0204156283,
0.0152592724,
0.0053391028,
-0.0089712702,
0.0295462385,
0.0145581225,
-0.003568829,
-0.0543996617,
0.0259729177,
0.0214906484,
-0.0156581476,
-0.014601483,
0.0182906296,
-0.000286557,
0.0108392863,
-0.0198428594,
0.0012651543,
0.0116215935,
-0.0145111391,
-0.0463336594,
0.053590823,
-0.0681326538,
-0.0060900706,
-0.0249890797,
0.0566244014,
0.0463174172,
0.0169958267,
0.0100941872,
-0.0623216443,
-0.0147207398,
-0.030623693,
0.0146609163,
-0.0166209787,
-0.0641293451,
0.028745424,
-0.0102223149,
-0.0280876476,
0.0585034899,
0.0278669447,
0.032494314,
0.0402472652,
0.0112822205,
-0.0526263341,
-0.0279404726,
-0.0067426162,
0.0476219505,
0.0539255813,
-0.0515181832,
-0.020244455,
-0.0392147824,
-0.0624359287,
0.0138206035,
-0.0122977337,
0.0074124248,
0.0367840268,
-0.0545813739,
0.0414134078,
0.0166371185,
-0.002209424,
-0.0623719171,
0.0193567574,
0.0433239974,
-0.041762419,
0.0251721404,
-5.321887574e-33,
0.0034128518,
-0.0373109765,
-0.0634400845,
-0.0416886248,
0.0291443076,
0.0538058318,
-0.0105565125,
-0.0223252997,
0.0118588172,
-0.024789447,
-0.0023773387,
-0.0105066784,
0.0100539997,
0.010327179,
-0.075963147,
-0.004861773,
0.0320097394,
0.0284788664,
-0.0211454947,
-0.0102341631,
0.055481866,
-0.0340330712,
-0.0007447351,
-0.059140563,
0.0027212196,
-0.0211284664,
-0.0378382914,
-0.0288501494,
-0.0097092642,
0.044038102,
-0.0291209444,
0.0091680232,
-0.0258900356,
0.0250947755,
-0.0528068654,
0.0161612816,
-0.0167344511,
-0.017407028,
0.0155248595,
0.017393155,
0.0240198951,
-0.0777747333,
0.0175710153,
-0.0340824388,
-0.0150308944,
0.0239478797,
-0.0208367836,
0.0052767047,
-0.0466134809,
-0.0096832523,
-0.0141576929,
0.0253128763,
-0.0087155774,
0.035291709,
0.0438937619,
-0.0154246949,
0.0698953792,
0.035169173,
-0.0692971647,
0.0367648788,
-0.0408655666,
0.0150803691,
0.0421058759,
-0.0075369086,
0.0022900582,
0.0346367545,
-0.0241261721,
-0.0009742756,
0.0516278371,
-0.0078174388,
0.0029467833,
0.0030334238,
0.0886968374,
0.0454302952,
0.0475375354,
-0.0291495789,
-0.0144406604,
0.0235057846,
-0.0411582924,
-0.0136669613,
0.0757951662,
0.0287680011,
-0.0398879834,
0.0017961359,
-0.0584957078,
-0.037295036,
-0.0155083407,
-0.0124435816,
0.029310124,
-0.0004106417,
-0.0655038282,
0.0060633104,
0.0286070537,
-0.051050175,
-0.0499205031,
0.0155900363,
-0.0162100755,
0.0150236618,
-0.017005641,
0.0471187532,
0.0459104776,
-0.0262689777,
0.0454549901,
-0.0735226125,
0.0210707821,
-0.0208591986,
0.0218826924,
-0.0027347882,
-0.0874982029,
-0.0044920035,
-0.0042817062,
0.0056830989,
0.003121099,
-0.0444347933,
0.0300282631,
-0.0178557429,
0.0159224216,
-0.0391932093,
0.0328840278,
-0.0493833907,
0.0152296592,
0.0065185474,
-0.0490433052,
0.0314241946,
0.0021856087,
0.0261984617,
-0.0236094091,
0.0577578992,
0.051483158,
-0.0078275008,
-0.0084805638,
-0.0165211614,
2.733e-7,
0.007380099,
0.0230597984,
0.0405461825,
-0.0021811726,
0.0227965433,
0.0400757529,
0.0125185912,
0.0165234637,
-0.0406666473,
-0.008626353,
-0.0420736745,
-0.0211496148,
0.0345758758,
-0.0192848518,
-0.0625412539,
0.0317730494,
-0.057405185,
-0.0199955013,
-0.0527234115,
-0.0000766586,
0.0564841703,
0.1183395237,
0.040091902,
-0.0124800084,
-0.0298423264,
-0.0821118802,
0.0335714445,
-0.0235693883,
0.0011665707,
-0.0316022299,
0.0061799991,
0.0287168995,
0.0416317582,
0.0058086538,
-0.0385677107,
0.0059302845,
0.0405690037,
0.0657196641,
0.0235820413,
0.0480375662,
-0.0591153055,
-0.0392029993,
-0.0103065781,
-0.0569460653,
0.0524728186,
0.0698370785,
-0.0300526116,
-0.0828597024,
-0.0473430492,
-0.044267159,
0.0470792986,
-0.0284127947,
-0.0367146991,
0.0209152848,
0.0110259466,
0.0200057514,
-0.0151356272,
-0.0681085363,
-0.0272553861,
-0.0797120333,
-0.0287665743,
-0.005748454,
-0.0497397222,
0.0374176912,
0.076475136,
-0.0429369248,
0.02582925,
2.769308341e-34,
0.0062488173,
-0.0662859306,
-0.0014969555,
0.0488091111,
0.0616480038,
0.027286686,
0.0054384712,
0.0316538624,
0.0067293821,
-0.0357466489,
0.0058961478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06302v1 | Selective Demonstrations for Cross-domain Text-to-SQL | 2023-10-10T04:31:41 | 2023-10-10T04:31:41 | Shuaichen Chang, Eric Fosler-Lussier | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) with in-context learning have demonstrated
impressive generalization capabilities in the cross-domain text-to-SQL task,
without the use of in-domain annotations. However, incorporating in-domain
demonstration examples has been found to greatly enhance LLMs' performance. In
this paper, we delve into the key factors within in-domain examples that
contribute to the improvement and explore whether we can harness these benefits
without relying on in-domain annotations. Based on our findings, we propose a
demonstration selection framework ODIS which utilizes both out-of-domain
examples and synthetically generated in-domain examples to construct
demonstrations. By retrieving demonstrations from hybrid sources, ODIS
leverages the advantages of both, showcasing its effectiveness compared to
baseline methods that rely on a single data source. Furthermore, ODIS
outperforms state-of-the-art approaches on two cross-domain text-to-SQL
datasets, with improvements of 1.1 and 11.8 points in execution accuracy,
respectively. | [
-0.0191764459,
0.0670924708,
-0.0008273344,
0.041468773,
-0.012474834,
0.0020740642,
0.0307976734,
0.0274283998,
0.0334559232,
-0.0642709285,
-0.0253127962,
-0.0418989919,
-0.0357742272,
0.0055452874,
0.0665840432,
-0.0303746089,
-0.0051423195,
-0.0293824878,
-0.047345683,
0.0367573649,
-0.0217253491,
0.0175743531,
0.0044470839,
0.0055035069,
-0.0303891897,
-0.0123060849,
-0.0021360698,
0.014753595,
-0.0306093693,
-0.0344434232,
-0.0062391879,
0.0298149139,
0.0819177479,
-0.00679116,
0.0000020845,
-0.0385581404,
-0.0493322164,
0.0470926911,
-0.0435725376,
0.0395614617,
0.0642576292,
-0.0066380855,
0.0226679072,
0.0534904785,
-0.0650681928,
-0.020752538,
0.0133489901,
0.0318921097,
0.0305986013,
0.0909240171,
-0.0192101356,
-0.0054675895,
-0.0335127153,
-0.0505469665,
0.005023025,
-0.0211493913,
0.0262403693,
0.0277183186,
0.0516648404,
-0.0109219709,
-0.0172009338,
0.0088091753,
0.0095915701,
-0.0085245362,
-0.0600825623,
0.0009852812,
-0.0416455977,
0.0542742126,
0.0046456843,
0.034658514,
0.016154889,
-0.0359078571,
0.0146829952,
0.0033279653,
-0.0038115452,
0.0051021981,
-0.0274002589,
0.0069556474,
0.0328760445,
0.0374646485,
-0.0248167068,
0.0023025353,
0.0076451139,
0.0040916461,
-0.0493011139,
0.0243830197,
-0.0082902238,
-0.0239603352,
0.0318037197,
0.0126953702,
-0.0197230875,
-0.0368297137,
-0.0122663584,
0.0104519296,
-0.0570546985,
0.0248775966,
-0.0611950681,
-0.0288097337,
-0.0016794347,
-0.0312213674,
0.0870684683,
0.0269578733,
0.0161940213,
0.0662420839,
-0.0311852526,
0.035917066,
0.0247185435,
0.0371029563,
-0.0186925847,
-0.0064452472,
-0.0731201768,
0.03330753,
-0.0335760377,
0.0392741896,
-0.065309301,
-0.0324683152,
-0.0129037527,
0.011780045,
-0.0178728029,
0.0446201041,
0.0078024808,
-0.0193426218,
-0.0216259975,
-0.0205182452,
-0.019245293,
-0.0206689034,
0.0075133308,
0.0204945263,
-0.0084368074,
-0.0828108415,
-0.0237787291,
0.0290835872,
-0.0188313164,
-0.0303234402,
0.0086628888,
0.0749180317,
-0.0222715586,
-0.035664279,
-0.0671266392,
-0.0297086686,
0.0085331239,
-0.0208308082,
0.0022379283,
-0.053081505,
0.0412614718,
0.0109490762,
0.0041229334,
-0.0824443996,
0.0130520938,
0.0072289486,
0.0251952466,
0.0437102169,
0.0088628037,
0.0163336135,
0.0065304535,
-0.0257740803,
0.0035970993,
0.119642362,
0.0258900039,
0.0013468151,
0.0159333441,
0.0309350733,
-0.0129096527,
0.0588645302,
0.0463685468,
0.0475223996,
-0.0924475789,
0.0392711572,
0.045542445,
0.0440253206,
0.0102455821,
0.01813717,
-0.0198187958,
0.0330945738,
0.0466580391,
0.0100347931,
0.0260566939,
-0.0096198693,
0.0509495139,
0.0462505817,
0.0109394528,
-0.0263769068,
-0.0339754224,
-0.0207571872,
0.0303705037,
0.0287948996,
0.0404692627,
0.008676921,
-0.0281001311,
-0.025255762,
-0.0065508713,
-0.0196568277,
0.0129992897,
0.0419719815,
0.044263944,
0.053737361,
-0.059329018,
0.0195767507,
0.015112482,
0.0003083664,
0.0285670869,
-0.026931027,
-0.0344751775,
0.0455340408,
0.0202737991,
-0.0493491776,
0.0116696674,
-0.0242824499,
0.0668196976,
0.0473724194,
0.0570514537,
-0.046050068,
-0.0346309878,
-0.0198954958,
-0.0350156203,
-0.0239486285,
0.0276070591,
-0.0258865394,
0.0656845272,
0.0155228078,
0.0173958689,
-0.0813295841,
-0.0451926626,
0.0414924696,
-0.0718715191,
-0.0107762273,
0.0332926065,
-0.0191035997,
0.010448873,
0.021961065,
-0.0468643792,
0.0133023197,
0.0379254632,
-0.0021426214,
-0.0170098469,
-0.0359127037,
0.0390643068,
-0.0370520018,
0.0241142847,
-0.0330206528,
-0.0093748784,
-0.0172176119,
-0.0690819249,
-0.0058053453,
-0.0285050776,
-0.0069622812,
0.0540665314,
-0.0483084358,
0.0084582549,
0.005623484,
-0.0173480306,
-0.0355369411,
0.0323905572,
0.0073197684,
0.0116186114,
0.0220781919,
-0.0341543891,
-0.0032970782,
-0.0532363579,
0.0235352218,
-0.0188557953,
-0.000751286,
0.0394895971,
-0.055767078,
0.0176941678,
-0.0386065841,
-0.0010829096,
-0.0903318152,
0.0343130566,
-0.025782397,
0.0571719818,
-0.0035296348,
0.0152278924,
-0.0226057246,
-0.0101858322,
-0.0271845721,
-0.0538462959,
-0.0396875069,
0.0082103712,
0.0058891713,
0.0193680376,
0.0213470068,
0.02358138,
0.0053240662,
-0.0229551364,
0.0920709446,
-0.0643197522,
0.0095473314,
-0.0325715728,
0.0427766331,
0.0080314036,
0.0282083545,
0.0064821299,
0.0227295049,
-0.006708438,
-0.0007277007,
-0.0044093239,
0.0214558076,
0.0062109409,
-0.0147215668,
-0.0102930944,
0.0087537635,
-0.0756335407,
0.0007653433,
-0.0122971423,
0.0325383209,
-0.0359910466,
-0.0016924486,
0.0163637716,
-0.0079422295,
0.0095256492,
-0.0121251103,
-0.0114358673,
0.00379992,
-0.0197657347,
-0.0075337188,
-0.0519359931,
0.0234450921,
0.0020352078,
-0.0147232655,
0.0049292538,
-0.0049743983,
0.0715468302,
-0.0291006602,
0.0193621367,
-0.0452143289,
0.0114538074,
-0.0377449133,
0.0311426762,
-0.0268309619,
0.0051893652,
-0.0282187331,
-0.0364855751,
-0.0156055875,
-0.0117539829,
-0.0067735915,
-0.0522717573,
0.0905197486,
-0.0410124958,
0.0047977204,
-0.0067922701,
-0.0329815,
-0.0360200889,
-0.0068479511,
-0.0074068615,
0.0463973284,
0.0105797285,
0.0116074169,
-0.0119990613,
0.0020826738,
-0.0001869368,
0.0764691234,
-0.0186603945,
-0.010140609,
-0.0042423392,
-0.0396261476,
0.0094656581,
0.0314087942,
-0.0233473908,
-0.0552877784,
-0.0117728012,
0.0118661625,
0.0415543914,
-0.0469503291,
-0.0321840756,
-0.0109919095,
-0.0094001247,
-0.0266806632,
0.0201367829,
0.0436641984,
0.0016485158,
-0.0673114508,
-0.0224636253,
0.0807506144,
0.0228911713,
0.0095350286,
0.0009570608,
0.0491100326,
0.0099720703,
0.0388880335,
0.0638974309,
-0.1162735969,
-0.028175937,
-0.0008371925,
0.0270834994,
0.0536908321,
0.0012974507,
-0.0083898418,
-0.1764408648,
0.0726186335,
0.000361212,
-0.0504299551,
-0.0051488252,
-0.0321671553,
-0.0117826015,
-0.0138261626,
0.0209158789,
0.0259407796,
-0.0316692181,
-0.0135894762,
0.0312104858,
0.0208965894,
-0.1231411397,
-0.0240648221,
-0.0259171892,
0.0005564952,
0.0495726839,
0.0190882161,
0.0320115276,
-0.0124982484,
0.0254381802,
-0.0111031113,
0.0005343243,
-0.0289168973,
0.0830652118,
0.0122613059,
-0.0052128751,
0.0540173091,
0.0527491458,
-0.030558072,
0.0170703158,
0.0060526347,
0.0986972079,
-0.0214731786,
0.014000481,
-0.003801245,
-0.0518823825,
0.0568757541,
0.0427544825,
-0.0003921037,
-0.0501832627,
-0.0357865393,
-0.0072181486,
-0.0386919603,
-0.0342719853,
-0.0184466913,
0.0191067699,
-0.0360128731,
-0.0304350667,
-0.0319854841,
-0.0077990685,
0.0791871995,
0.0642912015,
0.0218409803,
0.0327675082,
-0.0225718077,
-0.0207111537,
-0.0379599966,
0.0174072068,
-0.0765306577,
0.0314972177,
-0.0267847981,
-0.000960243,
0.0166934971,
-0.074213706,
-0.0317501239,
-0.0088000661,
-0.0482344292,
-0.0431475751,
-0.0125320312,
-0.0004061105,
0.0109784408,
0.0457062982,
0.0019627798,
-0.0457972512,
0.0439012609,
0.0605389811,
-0.0202541873,
-0.0516769588,
0.011472119,
-0.01250323,
-0.0063143508,
0.0198763628,
-0.0376239382,
-0.004696948,
0.0048468611,
0.0088687371,
0.0237694178,
0.0138473185,
0.0300210603,
-0.005908526,
0.0329843462,
0.0246174466,
-0.0591135398,
-0.0175842047,
0.0559616871,
-0.0192917082,
-0.0523782298,
-0.0444256365,
0.0299009979,
0.0102213547,
0.0151921697,
0.0022995162,
0.0138229048,
0.0032361068,
0.0445189811,
-0.0371218473,
0.0190969035,
0.0456429422,
-0.0087202955,
0.0437769666,
-0.0194417983,
-0.0021427635,
0.0071874075,
0.0120264534,
0.0366005562,
-0.0222312678,
0.0377883092,
0.0351717845,
0.0439118668,
0.0049639288,
-0.0121807111,
-0.0000293139,
0.0111025609,
-0.0903729349,
0.0275488682,
0.0344626084,
-0.0221787002,
0.0550738089,
-0.0267819297,
-0.0086392947,
-0.0229548328,
0.0082515487,
0.0003213404,
-0.0149362786,
0.0103805577,
0.0051348736,
-0.0155864563,
0.0108451555,
0.0748402104,
0.0053274943,
0.0212112311,
-0.0022083085,
-0.014226472,
-0.0494918711,
-0.0546485856,
0.0839033648,
-0.0255956128,
-0.0197620802,
-0.0381910354,
-0.0290417019,
-0.0425925478,
0.0040395143,
-0.0086992327,
-0.0536639988,
-0.0128629385,
0.0471151136,
0.0613139607,
0.017576335,
0.0068627843,
-0.0396804698,
-0.0221848954,
0.03826873,
-0.0681039318,
-0.0445454344,
-5.947008122e-33,
-0.000255906,
-0.0217742734,
0.047849603,
-0.023811724,
-0.0164189916,
-0.0092234882,
-0.0083298385,
-0.0304370597,
0.0056418586,
0.0278644636,
-0.0350795947,
0.0151885003,
0.0340267159,
0.0456670672,
0.0161021166,
-0.0193841998,
0.0465895571,
-0.0406518914,
-0.0212800931,
0.0273409169,
0.0207944214,
0.0244172998,
0.0425247923,
-0.0783495679,
0.0322962105,
0.013165486,
-0.0369026549,
-0.0036084596,
0.0190441329,
0.0455153435,
-0.0062590796,
0.0149362655,
0.0022637502,
-0.0566576533,
-0.031157013,
-0.0235405527,
-0.0219193362,
0.0191648658,
-0.000915925,
0.0081966799,
0.0184254795,
-0.01007229,
0.0420881398,
-0.0384053662,
-0.0204650518,
-0.0105364425,
0.0041873627,
-0.0273406897,
0.0021148962,
-0.0601915903,
-0.0685961545,
0.0278946403,
0.0327140056,
-0.015088032,
0.0591532625,
0.0341157243,
-0.0049945288,
-0.0177292135,
-0.0336819366,
0.0438915938,
0.0219764188,
0.0347410142,
0.0652927309,
-0.0043647434,
0.0040849354,
0.0266187284,
-0.0417658389,
0.0117814355,
0.0496863052,
0.0026431989,
0.025682969,
0.0496031046,
0.0236733332,
0.0701105967,
0.0276344884,
-0.0144226644,
-0.0729316175,
0.0271889176,
-0.0325795412,
-0.0646228641,
0.0615488328,
-0.0052739792,
-0.0640691444,
-0.0196619909,
-0.0361467786,
0.0438503288,
-0.0271806624,
-0.0470028929,
0.0484579243,
0.0120295258,
-0.0274093729,
0.0112296501,
0.0310238004,
-0.0506974421,
-0.0838855878,
0.0220348053,
-0.0201257206,
-0.0304233283,
0.0012377854,
-0.0167644676,
-0.0407541618,
-0.0950458944,
0.0143115865,
0.0243242979,
0.0004243609,
0.0007569838,
0.0412829444,
0.0182083659,
-0.0877575129,
0.0378078632,
-0.0139510278,
0.0333491713,
0.0057759429,
0.0071432516,
0.0305427667,
-0.0057547526,
0.0115952864,
0.0464511849,
0.0032018346,
-0.0716374293,
-0.0003940463,
0.0140956063,
-0.0097081894,
0.0029060442,
0.0037294987,
0.0207197983,
0.0081616407,
-0.0204770006,
0.0239285622,
-0.0274165198,
-0.0182403885,
0.0341704078,
2.648e-7,
0.0584584847,
0.0487841852,
-0.0233306605,
0.0606000535,
0.0145306503,
0.0076089045,
-0.0406828262,
0.0351510346,
0.0327055082,
0.0075547132,
0.0107871415,
-0.0062652971,
0.0886914283,
0.0411009379,
-0.1174994484,
-0.0214344151,
0.016838992,
0.0017136735,
-0.0583319888,
-0.0309907869,
0.0250891987,
0.0841775909,
-0.0266626216,
0.0242276043,
0.0121847717,
-0.0559916012,
0.0382548273,
-0.0235143509,
-0.0260002278,
0.0474196784,
-0.0328130983,
0.0147103602,
-0.0109021105,
0.0473227352,
-0.0482586958,
0.0368240289,
0.0223256182,
0.073492825,
0.0342417546,
0.0142939119,
0.0074455407,
-0.053627748,
0.0131988162,
-0.0066817869,
0.0538874641,
-0.0852442756,
-0.0031088949,
0.0293867178,
0.0121043604,
-0.0380866341,
-0.0020921393,
-0.0058967145,
0.0432441831,
-0.0106794266,
0.0427245833,
0.0207265262,
-0.0109553253,
-0.0201094318,
-0.028246453,
0.0297657717,
-0.0543759763,
-0.0128133139,
0.0171582438,
0.0453523099,
-0.0532666519,
-0.0361952074,
0.0045971433,
2.96947207e-34,
0.0280582067,
0.0081582041,
0.0032263824,
0.0176978931,
0.0344593078,
-0.0121452631,
0.0152783683,
0.0007139319,
-0.005925952,
-0.0407539494,
0.0005113857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06272v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06272v2 | Let Models Speak Ciphers: Multiagent Debate through Embeddings | 2023-10-10T03:06:38 | 2024-02-26T17:36:48 | Chau Pham, Boyi Liu, Yingxiang Yang, Zhengyu Chen, Tianyi Liu, Jianbo Yuan, Bryan A. Plummer, Zhaoran Wang, Hongxia Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Discussion and debate among Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained
considerable attention due to their potential to enhance the reasoning ability
of LLMs. Although natural language is an obvious choice for communication due
to LLM's language understanding capability, the token sampling step needed when
generating natural language poses a potential risk of information loss, as it
uses only one token to represent the model's belief across the entire
vocabulary. In this paper, we introduce a communication regime named CIPHER
(Communicative Inter-Model Protocol Through Embedding Representation) to
address this issue. Specifically, we remove the token sampling step from LLMs
and let them communicate their beliefs across the vocabulary through the
expectation of the raw transformer output embeddings. Remarkably, by deviating
from natural language, CIPHER offers an advantage of encoding a broader
spectrum of information without any modification to the model weights,
outperforming the state-of-the-art LLM debate methods using natural language by
0.5-5.0% across five reasoning tasks and multiple open-source LLMs of varying
sizes. This showcases the superiority and robustness of embeddings as an
alternative "language" for communication among LLMs. We anticipate that CIPHER
will inspire further exploration for the design of interactions within LLM
agent systems, offering a new direction that could significantly influence
future developments in the field. | [
0.0296671689,
0.0624162778,
-0.0068928665,
0.070286639,
-0.0458845235,
-0.0148416106,
0.0272280481,
-0.0201792438,
0.0130606452,
-0.0520518646,
-0.0193883087,
-0.0079615135,
-0.0196947958,
0.0392471179,
0.0416525416,
-0.0188856963,
0.013475976,
-0.0266179387,
0.0324556865,
-0.0251213461,
-0.0000114342,
-0.0122766253,
0.0222728048,
0.0651921704,
0.0175291747,
-0.0069957189,
-0.0715012103,
-0.0409053378,
0.0190368462,
0.0004972555,
-0.0389659144,
0.0234331824,
0.05265522,
0.0770079792,
0.0000020784,
-0.0199448466,
0.0041046678,
0.0242507048,
-0.051284425,
-0.0228732433,
0.0541248396,
0.0143217063,
0.0053402265,
0.0001686431,
-0.063095212,
0.0031738197,
0.0649763048,
0.0744240806,
0.0637471899,
0.0633362085,
0.0080901477,
-0.0311889127,
0.0225779731,
-0.0058627622,
-0.0239772685,
-0.039019186,
0.0151079148,
-0.0085330065,
0.0162013434,
0.0329693928,
-0.0156449713,
0.0148487538,
0.0491971001,
-0.0356829539,
-0.0172788147,
0.0282937288,
-0.012017115,
-0.0421584919,
-0.0293251369,
0.0506416745,
0.0133486409,
0.0034630646,
-0.0173764601,
0.006150627,
0.0180083029,
0.0189369954,
-0.051420752,
0.055220414,
0.012607812,
0.023388166,
0.0160759352,
0.0151714012,
0.0408999287,
-0.0105647184,
-0.0831005499,
0.0832101703,
-0.004550111,
-0.0121628335,
-0.0241760202,
-0.030845359,
-0.0203576926,
-0.0860487297,
-0.0064978302,
0.031744618,
-0.041895248,
0.0055018482,
-0.0107178381,
0.0015377817,
-0.0062665967,
-0.0562536754,
0.0191852748,
0.0356052518,
0.0278299581,
0.039408613,
-0.0137550896,
0.0533784181,
-0.0293364972,
0.0602831431,
-0.0013995941,
-0.0311282426,
-0.0370378755,
-0.0582377501,
-0.0078346785,
0.0543798469,
-0.0498517975,
-0.0140466718,
0.0143795758,
0.0500103645,
-0.0534702092,
0.0464095622,
-0.0109466957,
0.017672766,
0.0006947413,
-0.0071044099,
-0.0469961539,
0.0284758564,
-0.0364430547,
0.0121223321,
0.0329457931,
-0.0528135858,
-0.0174476616,
-0.0045321085,
-0.0359708481,
-0.0053983573,
-0.0272155963,
0.1183530092,
0.0077128662,
-0.0064907339,
0.0267832037,
-0.0451596454,
0.0070376717,
-0.0800449178,
0.0221990645,
-0.0473926291,
0.0142616024,
-0.0031554769,
0.0032656873,
-0.0592418611,
-0.0017765943,
-0.0204132684,
-0.0395092778,
0.1168981418,
0.0111363772,
-0.0149923982,
-0.0023860948,
0.0268061012,
-0.0123797217,
0.07259202,
0.0550649874,
0.0255379584,
0.0364340581,
0.0228814613,
0.0068897731,
0.0125240125,
0.0164957009,
-0.0023381538,
0.002456656,
0.0054498394,
-0.0028953583,
0.0513829328,
-0.0169801302,
0.0564492345,
-0.0432571322,
-0.0768871084,
0.0610807315,
0.0762268975,
0.011727999,
0.0065744165,
0.0299837086,
0.0451676585,
-0.0132003361,
-0.0064611132,
-0.0517004915,
0.034204118,
-0.0230156481,
-0.0340578705,
0.0078809764,
0.0205627605,
-0.0303494688,
-0.0530282333,
0.0091859978,
-0.0154722342,
0.0609529167,
0.0045221555,
0.0256537516,
-0.0092557315,
-0.0194419567,
0.028188495,
0.0073086577,
-0.0340565294,
-0.0432119668,
-0.074806653,
0.0579511225,
0.026529111,
0.039260339,
0.0096690701,
-0.0346835963,
-0.0251739491,
-0.0068701976,
0.0689536035,
0.0213939827,
-0.0193350092,
-0.0052328762,
-0.0392291956,
-0.0485854894,
-0.0244667195,
-0.0008835426,
0.0300443433,
-0.0343800485,
-0.0162674766,
-0.005310196,
0.0008970398,
0.0262427405,
0.0150780603,
-0.0207370911,
0.0245135967,
-0.0303680543,
0.0126814647,
0.0787477568,
0.0201108027,
-0.0188853014,
0.0356577262,
0.0264406297,
-0.0073060193,
-0.0662687644,
0.022344945,
-0.0195403323,
-0.0106701404,
0.0290812701,
-0.0234482829,
0.0252196118,
-0.0081265671,
-0.0239417497,
-0.0063291742,
0.0416007377,
-0.0158378109,
0.0465147272,
-0.0238038991,
-0.0245063417,
0.000880629,
-0.0165837742,
-0.0409594215,
0.0161619075,
-0.0058836881,
-0.051467523,
0.0102914954,
0.0239698626,
0.0305671766,
-0.0241010655,
-0.0127386665,
0.0867817774,
0.0323005095,
-0.0025836008,
0.0472194068,
-0.0034283153,
0.0036814502,
-0.0477222614,
-0.0878846347,
-0.0135699948,
0.0005190046,
0.0064955885,
-0.0307229068,
-0.0201906972,
0.0274646524,
0.0278520361,
-0.0532465093,
-0.0064149019,
-0.0002738534,
0.0301641691,
0.0310836397,
0.0085128956,
-0.0454009138,
0.0078141736,
0.0086955596,
-0.0084101595,
0.0670148954,
0.0242942814,
0.0122237476,
-0.0621484965,
-0.0019807103,
-0.0681568235,
-0.0032023413,
-0.0311354417,
-0.0301390719,
0.0602135658,
0.009837117,
-0.0207479596,
0.0469316877,
0.0060252245,
0.0554572344,
0.039329011,
-0.0226526782,
-0.0839989558,
0.0206148066,
-0.0166002493,
0.0028819367,
-0.0645410642,
0.0016186585,
-0.0035646344,
0.0817027017,
-0.0115652531,
-0.0115152039,
-0.069648765,
0.0631843209,
0.0154200988,
-0.040671479,
-0.0195889436,
-0.0400224961,
0.0059035663,
0.0421376862,
-0.0090099005,
-0.0225908868,
0.1034318209,
-0.0226450041,
-0.0023258973,
-0.0347418971,
0.0015756628,
-0.0429594107,
0.0629814863,
-0.0374043696,
-0.0047316621,
0.0170941819,
-0.0050369906,
-0.0588993281,
-0.0500366613,
0.0348353796,
-0.0163715389,
0.0088976305,
-0.026978245,
-0.0108407931,
-0.0132524371,
-0.0411428511,
-0.0294606537,
-0.021851711,
-0.0807666406,
0.0260049477,
0.0122311432,
-0.0589970239,
-0.0355672613,
0.0214435719,
0.0273527075,
-0.0408580042,
0.0132042766,
-0.002359634,
-0.0470946319,
-0.0316823833,
-0.0032788708,
0.0423590057,
0.0242598616,
-0.0262329057,
0.0642686486,
0.0680541396,
-0.0259425566,
-0.0226271451,
-0.0463402867,
-0.0095856646,
0.0141128125,
0.0157267954,
-0.0033138464,
-0.0037054275,
0.0311367195,
-0.0361965112,
0.0142085822,
0.0984775051,
0.0212296899,
0.0068667019,
0.0104551101,
-0.0496052429,
0.0348361656,
0.0140164914,
0.0272285566,
-0.0806967169,
-0.0254721455,
0.0295153074,
-0.0207675919,
-0.0187392514,
-0.0426955931,
-0.0118691707,
-0.0668895394,
0.0451910533,
0.0206607562,
0.0119243599,
-0.01353392,
-0.0431088209,
-0.0366334803,
-0.0169424918,
0.0219201464,
-0.0258062482,
0.0538186431,
-0.011241246,
-0.0163232442,
-0.0123158172,
0.0050818911,
0.0050642723,
-0.0395389572,
0.0580052584,
0.0374686383,
0.0584211312,
-0.0031206009,
-0.0491123721,
0.0020226773,
0.0644020364,
-0.0091426708,
-0.0021177093,
0.0162574686,
-0.009357105,
-0.0119900415,
-0.026832886,
0.0108937016,
0.0088057416,
-0.0466430858,
0.0008333968,
0.0791111812,
-0.0497229435,
-0.0300076175,
-0.0145663014,
0.0144204674,
0.0229393039,
0.0727998614,
0.0307218544,
-0.0179336555,
-0.0496458225,
-0.0667550862,
-0.0317163877,
-0.0069241277,
-0.0516901314,
-0.0157356877,
0.0485091954,
0.0071311896,
-0.0376040973,
-0.0379733779,
0.0240819808,
0.0052061882,
-0.005247884,
-0.0085385796,
0.0628347248,
0.0034368397,
0.0084778238,
-0.0144550549,
-0.0575472005,
0.0155823538,
-0.0006901649,
0.0207591988,
0.0149429226,
-0.0158586968,
-0.024531642,
0.0206362288,
-0.0386528336,
-0.0774521232,
-0.017869968,
0.0549956821,
0.0297088809,
0.0132804122,
-0.0158836637,
-0.0347129181,
0.0930005684,
0.0020951605,
-0.0324238241,
0.0021594758,
0.0615629666,
0.0096005583,
0.019180702,
0.0579018928,
-0.025767358,
-0.0183017123,
0.0074082334,
0.0253638048,
-0.0272773523,
-0.0235006455,
0.0103201782,
-0.0002284646,
-0.0213974696,
0.0315693207,
-0.0108015658,
-0.0258500259,
0.0220917128,
-0.0754183978,
-0.0270183105,
-0.0704528615,
0.0111061586,
-0.0206043255,
-0.0203709472,
0.0429960154,
-0.0066774231,
0.0040820781,
0.0222643428,
0.0473493971,
0.0232612155,
-0.0030377728,
0.0204851627,
0.0175777394,
0.0134856552,
0.0044582309,
0.0007411062,
-0.023421891,
0.0365166105,
0.0006707805,
0.0492723733,
0.0472811572,
-0.0297726262,
-0.0466795191,
0.0333271362,
-0.0754243955,
-0.0849051178,
0.0592283681,
0.0369607955,
0.002614504,
0.0666093007,
-0.0056838929,
-0.062904723,
-0.005224362,
-0.0077885576,
0.0427322425,
0.0165501256,
-0.0462340452,
0.0625726283,
0.019688528,
-0.0449643023,
-0.0193305071,
0.0405247584,
0.0096884267,
0.0269642901,
-0.0323298834,
-0.0293002687,
-0.0645628944,
-0.0427056737,
0.0176080354,
0.008702145,
-0.0208589844,
0.0074465182,
-0.0734216943,
-0.0433509462,
0.0102011701,
0.0326309763,
-0.0219838023,
-0.0181177389,
0.0082537001,
0.0337082818,
0.0146424668,
-0.0069694445,
-0.0396465436,
0.0081781363,
-0.003674309,
-0.0276744496,
-0.0163069852,
-6.235697045e-33,
-0.0224215463,
-0.0425393358,
0.0454588979,
0.0034051645,
-0.0324445963,
-0.0271261744,
-0.034145128,
-0.001529052,
-0.0148092825,
0.064375706,
0.004100997,
0.0179956425,
0.0172775239,
-0.0044814483,
-0.0159415957,
-0.0426680334,
0.031367857,
-0.0051333751,
-0.0284673851,
0.0178818684,
0.0483598448,
-0.0226530544,
0.0321957693,
-0.0493762083,
0.0603909343,
0.0189644843,
-0.0155978231,
0.0385519825,
-0.0504831113,
0.0609515309,
-0.0367762111,
0.0169023424,
-0.0112257972,
-0.0522013977,
-0.0271356516,
0.0297342744,
0.0001641637,
-0.0302468594,
0.0333065428,
0.0016575942,
-0.0338986181,
-0.0614741929,
0.0166926477,
0.0001406462,
-0.0071864203,
0.0109076835,
-0.006878342,
-0.0225385167,
-0.005584565,
0.0329592451,
-0.0419003516,
0.0178651549,
-0.0268546678,
-0.0148056969,
0.0318151265,
-0.0213680752,
0.0237550363,
0.0124562113,
-0.0467260703,
0.0367344357,
0.0270126443,
-0.0368989334,
0.0437702797,
0.0071718763,
0.0087007247,
0.0782551393,
0.0081221489,
-0.0021722824,
-0.0609353855,
-0.0156777445,
0.0081334533,
0.0444702804,
0.0489647686,
0.064551264,
-0.0199172124,
0.0243423078,
-0.068216145,
0.0008545468,
0.0196118634,
0.0774995163,
0.0494702607,
0.0221599471,
-0.0448706597,
-0.0314920023,
-0.0536092333,
-0.0095549701,
-0.0258537196,
-0.0283789579,
0.0158342756,
0.0077388911,
-0.0075753122,
-0.0232879035,
0.0582049601,
-0.0888790414,
-0.0185631663,
0.0269574486,
0.036173813,
-0.0015135094,
-0.0025278598,
-0.0014716759,
-0.0192888323,
0.0009846896,
0.0043866416,
-0.0160626043,
0.0143370181,
0.0020814408,
0.0029099362,
0.0240224432,
-0.0199600831,
-0.007886976,
-0.0414176546,
-0.0345083401,
-0.0018762141,
0.0158283971,
0.0225705076,
0.0231600758,
-0.0206373986,
0.0006291026,
-0.0340165831,
-0.0188604407,
-0.018344773,
0.0397623219,
-0.0107382163,
0.0209564324,
-0.0114429286,
-0.013943648,
-0.0510388538,
0.0208007712,
0.0469634756,
-0.0207028911,
-0.0107823377,
-0.0159215778,
2.793e-7,
0.0147604169,
0.0208175592,
0.052162692,
0.0064994944,
0.0157742444,
0.0801196396,
-0.0137338117,
0.0345626548,
-0.0038966003,
-0.0464079641,
0.0014285117,
0.0633016229,
0.0534694307,
0.0346917287,
-0.0575318597,
0.0022196576,
-0.0280295908,
-0.0220884867,
-0.024813205,
-0.020339245,
0.0754567385,
0.0884783268,
0.0392128155,
0.0479364693,
-0.0157677606,
-0.0235534627,
0.0496321432,
-0.0482968912,
-0.0141382776,
0.0086119492,
0.0275612958,
-0.0145196822,
0.0286023319,
0.0021767975,
0.0400446877,
0.019854553,
-0.0251033958,
0.0484468155,
0.0110780308,
-0.0397807099,
-0.050315585,
-0.0547278188,
-0.006510471,
-0.0358504578,
0.03667669,
-0.1028876975,
-0.0885290578,
-0.022164885,
0.0080384584,
-0.0339180082,
0.0235026348,
-0.0073098466,
-0.020844046,
-0.000924929,
-0.0013343293,
-0.0017042649,
0.0606802255,
-0.0820819587,
0.0078388676,
-0.0396914408,
-0.0682860762,
-0.0454995558,
-0.0302104633,
-0.0169526953,
0.0719033554,
-0.0108341658,
0.0124548972,
2.634731916e-34,
0.0374906361,
0.0033388697,
0.0060184104,
0.0707079321,
0.0617551357,
0.0029715684,
0.0276150703,
0.002101009,
0.074325867,
-0.0792141259,
-0.0182097834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06271v1 | Towards Mitigating Hallucination in Large Language Models via Self-Reflection | 2023-10-10T03:05:44 | 2023-10-10T03:05:44 | Ziwei Ji, Tiezheng Yu, Yan Xu, Nayeon Lee, Etsuko Ishii, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promise for generative and
knowledge-intensive tasks including question-answering (QA) tasks. However, the
practical deployment still faces challenges, notably the issue of
"hallucination", where models generate plausible-sounding but unfaithful or
nonsensical information. This issue becomes particularly critical in the
medical domain due to the uncommon professional concepts and potential social
risks involved. This paper analyses the phenomenon of hallucination in medical
generative QA systems using widely adopted LLMs and datasets. Our investigation
centers on the identification and comprehension of common problematic answers,
with a specific emphasis on hallucination. To tackle this challenge, we present
an interactive self-reflection methodology that incorporates knowledge
acquisition and answer generation. Through this feedback process, our approach
steadily enhances the factuality, consistency, and entailment of the generated
answers. Consequently, we harness the interactivity and multitasking ability of
LLMs and produce progressively more precise and accurate answers. Experimental
results on both automatic and human evaluation demonstrate the superiority of
our approach in hallucination reduction compared to baselines. | [
0.0676196292,
0.0470776632,
-0.0107578794,
0.0013610331,
-0.0257925484,
0.0058025299,
-0.0086709792,
0.009467545,
0.0223643966,
-0.009351545,
0.0074462807,
-0.0356496796,
-0.0150624048,
-0.0252529774,
0.028447831,
-0.0274494197,
0.0321528204,
-0.0324615389,
-0.0094891312,
-0.0411396362,
-0.0015455621,
0.0179267675,
-0.025752712,
0.0348780118,
0.0078256465,
-0.0457664244,
0.0380890742,
-0.0212118234,
-0.0051774476,
-0.0167312715,
-0.0186950918,
0.0812797472,
-0.0343053527,
0.0319359303,
0.0000020425,
-0.0517616794,
-0.0014715609,
-0.0018664447,
-0.0413975157,
-0.020682022,
0.0333785824,
0.0188796818,
0.0087504098,
0.0314325616,
-0.051527258,
0.0092165684,
0.0134608932,
0.0368469022,
0.0805977061,
0.0054425169,
0.0017393199,
-0.0065726214,
-0.0049539059,
0.0173643939,
0.0641116872,
-0.0053072562,
0.0435540713,
0.0526396148,
0.0041619991,
-0.0409969948,
0.0001655706,
0.0549262911,
0.0091409227,
-0.0059246579,
0.0231715366,
0.0278030187,
-0.0286888778,
-0.0277948715,
0.016769575,
0.0748229474,
0.0198792089,
-0.0456598587,
0.0057628467,
0.0142687568,
0.0229864493,
0.0531436242,
-0.0530229323,
0.0161409248,
-0.0235469658,
-0.0235587116,
0.0045045456,
-0.0114958938,
0.0209208503,
0.0147346286,
-0.0100831231,
0.0268815625,
0.0267537143,
-0.0255090203,
-0.0018832331,
-0.0087390225,
-0.0053164386,
-0.0449625067,
0.0334465243,
0.0807895735,
-0.0530838035,
0.0078214761,
-0.0139391972,
-0.0228722673,
0.0925042629,
-0.0732545778,
0.0114538642,
-0.0051927855,
-0.0290716607,
0.045245558,
0.0019860649,
-0.0023279006,
-0.0371181965,
0.0437083915,
-0.0702490658,
-0.0004066045,
-0.0468424149,
-0.0423346609,
-0.0386499614,
0.0293231439,
0.0156010725,
0.0161042623,
-0.0260663703,
-0.0035381212,
-0.0356097668,
-0.0035816955,
-0.0152296051,
0.0623410083,
-0.0181033108,
-0.0241931174,
-0.0500879548,
0.0189826135,
-0.0254807323,
0.0120674698,
-0.006502613,
-0.0697476715,
-0.0046133231,
-0.0003518259,
0.0104650715,
0.0158019066,
0.0293778051,
0.0332770161,
0.0004182671,
0.0180192273,
0.0179562662,
-0.0747462735,
-0.0457606278,
-0.0503485017,
0.0043969103,
-0.0801634416,
0.0293828193,
0.0184726585,
-0.037419688,
-0.0436219983,
0.0371945985,
0.0529322885,
-0.0398461372,
0.0657301843,
-0.0444368944,
0.0478569083,
0.0802394077,
0.0496211797,
-0.0150198154,
0.0263489801,
0.0056197736,
-0.0166117474,
0.0092302319,
-0.039951738,
0.0872318447,
-0.0125210276,
0.0323346332,
-0.0249853674,
0.0005888172,
0.0449624769,
0.0047527994,
0.0551310703,
-0.018506268,
0.0742664039,
-0.0119218305,
-0.0065839025,
0.0361109823,
0.0578707308,
-0.0231797751,
0.0338334627,
-0.0000772666,
-0.0280066188,
0.0210513119,
0.0186525378,
-0.0067740544,
0.0319165364,
0.004782523,
-0.0128137199,
0.0067131878,
-0.0022667197,
-0.0174368136,
-0.040583048,
-0.0319238603,
0.0139447851,
-0.0057890648,
0.0495625846,
0.0133549646,
0.0327986591,
-0.0113626141,
0.0838630944,
0.0469512939,
-0.0551218614,
0.0200138632,
-0.0771450475,
0.0178611912,
0.1114165336,
0.0819306374,
-0.0257602111,
-0.0289800968,
-0.0336473137,
0.0402585827,
0.0286397971,
0.0270709172,
-0.0360022821,
-0.0206032004,
-0.018421676,
0.0093354238,
0.0319708735,
0.001994859,
-0.0365193561,
-0.0065531069,
0.0059878379,
-0.0155681241,
-0.0250198655,
-0.049748715,
0.0369818136,
-0.0482717454,
-0.0300962962,
-0.0066575352,
-0.0126610501,
0.0013307449,
0.0265650805,
-0.0079371529,
0.0668850243,
0.0190021694,
-0.0316019058,
-0.0535991415,
0.0081005413,
-0.0445188619,
-0.0103939567,
0.0333441272,
-0.0356364548,
-0.0243250951,
-0.0122843087,
0.0014301456,
-0.0320496038,
-0.0252593867,
-0.083971642,
0.0217009708,
-0.0380436182,
-0.0073197461,
0.0113982856,
0.0113606518,
-0.0525474437,
0.0488205813,
-0.0131813725,
0.0265632439,
0.0321071744,
-0.0240589343,
-0.0008505163,
-0.0363031887,
-0.0035786054,
-0.0110920435,
-0.007074099,
0.0265740436,
0.0044088764,
-0.0374722332,
-0.0523480773,
-0.0374235734,
-0.1010232568,
-0.0398110487,
-0.0130501287,
0.0099399518,
0.0338415653,
-0.0035594464,
-0.0018904834,
-0.0356739089,
-0.0443550795,
-0.0108245984,
0.0339980386,
0.0385691412,
0.0217286684,
0.0165112205,
0.0178797673,
-0.0224754084,
0.0119577302,
-0.0421218053,
0.0186078828,
0.0119098574,
0.0291872714,
-0.0606670007,
-0.006062706,
-0.0693268776,
-0.0099384179,
0.0235109702,
-0.0316859521,
0.0248661786,
0.0018397806,
0.0282031037,
0.0319341794,
0.0296347253,
0.0056231259,
0.0724529848,
-0.0051025241,
-0.0281395931,
-0.015469864,
-0.0264696311,
-0.0068140659,
0.0261374097,
-0.0592617802,
-0.0280221011,
0.0466993898,
0.0502916612,
-0.0032217165,
-0.050458245,
0.0452878363,
-0.0519982949,
-0.0440853909,
-0.0362501852,
-0.0178616848,
-0.0463947877,
0.0491841137,
0.0022921441,
-0.0141552547,
0.0877737105,
-0.0066920142,
0.0233484246,
-0.0514898859,
-0.0000288247,
-0.0229435805,
0.0280507617,
-0.0300138891,
0.033038374,
0.0071738954,
-0.0026032976,
-0.0291219931,
0.0110165402,
0.0088473689,
-0.079727985,
0.0250176601,
-0.0381308049,
0.0011324817,
0.0251022503,
-0.0243707392,
-0.0659587458,
-0.0590326414,
-0.0167332496,
-0.0411261544,
-0.0328529291,
0.0310098957,
0.0062630232,
-0.0047437521,
0.0164536331,
0.0150087262,
-0.0053464952,
-0.0268009901,
0.0093611116,
0.0173915364,
0.083798565,
0.0226013307,
0.0359640867,
-0.0022696527,
0.0482125431,
0.0834166035,
0.057005126,
0.0414310433,
0.0187818203,
-0.0428801402,
0.000883967,
-0.0279964451,
0.0212989412,
0.0130531862,
0.0257647038,
-0.0524007119,
-0.034584906,
0.0982928276,
0.0399085917,
-0.0447864532,
0.0203553401,
-0.0816324875,
0.0106969178,
0.0015384827,
0.0236790013,
-0.0661380365,
-0.0033028622,
-0.0276486836,
0.0291808899,
-0.0280454233,
-0.0285451114,
0.0197121315,
-0.0835292116,
0.0334986821,
0.0029703605,
-0.0170641113,
-0.010394928,
-0.0179873556,
-0.0044597895,
0.0254979469,
0.0065067057,
0.0158456359,
-0.013684242,
-0.0068396688,
0.0182800051,
-0.0712816194,
-0.0238221381,
0.0577850603,
0.0060545946,
0.051159516,
0.0717569441,
0.0325371213,
-0.0036637557,
-0.0570148192,
-0.00146312,
-0.0221936237,
0.0037075931,
0.0131991766,
0.0697180182,
0.0304295905,
0.0146156568,
-0.0406152047,
0.0475798324,
-0.0592681989,
-0.03347582,
0.0179424882,
0.099714376,
-0.0469099656,
-0.0285614338,
-0.0396816023,
0.0510472991,
0.0288585536,
0.0829976499,
0.027106626,
-0.0233225841,
-0.0215420686,
0.0169023871,
0.0543069281,
-0.0098612262,
-0.0589503683,
0.0623599961,
0.0562761091,
-0.0071914778,
-0.0703673363,
-0.0470871106,
0.0405163281,
0.0161477253,
0.0015073908,
0.0760463402,
-0.0263463072,
0.0089921663,
-0.0247472767,
0.0233755857,
-0.0254493803,
0.0025319962,
0.00839472,
-0.0304575805,
0.0309683587,
-0.0086980611,
-0.0065513216,
0.0027734779,
-0.0453676023,
-0.028135322,
0.0266662035,
0.0503998324,
0.0276285633,
0.0131545058,
-0.0263560675,
-0.0376731604,
0.0313870758,
0.0147886062,
-0.0382790305,
0.003273746,
-0.0121908979,
0.0149682108,
0.0017153913,
0.0334718227,
-0.0225633793,
-0.0008017392,
0.0019372964,
0.0195009802,
-0.0261946265,
-0.0397114046,
0.0379650705,
0.0107995113,
-0.0126333162,
-0.0217528362,
0.0248015244,
-0.0041547995,
0.0095384475,
-0.0389914177,
-0.0033999982,
0.0013483585,
0.0072812517,
0.0328991748,
-0.0519935153,
0.0124560557,
-0.0146940351,
-0.0773528665,
-0.004595059,
-0.0516702682,
0.0273048487,
0.0254797824,
-0.0134989545,
0.04041088,
-0.0227331817,
-0.010088617,
-0.0088916598,
0.0150522059,
0.0470639095,
0.0194711462,
0.0777089149,
-0.001504638,
-0.0212908201,
-0.0115748607,
0.03137381,
-0.0598606095,
-0.1112801507,
-0.0243252777,
0.0482144877,
0.0142356893,
0.0406983122,
0.0282237642,
-0.0016111145,
-0.0038349959,
0.006595402,
-0.0024320998,
0.0050957296,
-0.0068896404,
0.0502438806,
0.0226392988,
-0.0078889662,
-0.0209269058,
0.0854320154,
-0.0264034588,
0.0552513748,
0.0014983168,
-0.0397615619,
-0.0304461233,
-0.0594571382,
-0.0557937883,
-0.0243780483,
-0.0454105772,
0.0013106382,
-0.093920663,
-0.0557654053,
-0.0254835319,
0.0099664973,
-0.021927068,
-0.0266323313,
0.0511004217,
0.0789878815,
0.0135100456,
-0.0348344184,
-0.0363336243,
0.0911503211,
-0.0196052361,
-0.0010045466,
0.0291796476,
-6.473847793e-33,
0.0178695805,
-0.0649356321,
0.0415834188,
-0.0365434289,
-0.0087050023,
-0.0139264474,
-0.022442488,
0.0177913401,
-0.0032134966,
0.0284962784,
-0.0248392038,
0.0093596512,
0.0048491857,
0.0339226127,
0.0256744754,
-0.0411922075,
0.0275703762,
0.0019256835,
-0.0213817731,
0.0462105647,
-0.0042100311,
0.0278088916,
0.0061684297,
-0.049335435,
0.0295998231,
-0.0421955995,
0.0154526979,
0.0277778246,
-0.0256340466,
0.0527542271,
-0.0380500816,
0.052145157,
0.0360286348,
-0.04174776,
-0.0113187665,
0.0306529459,
-0.052033782,
-0.0218652524,
0.0110212406,
-0.0100846682,
-0.0755188316,
-0.0390398651,
0.0479484983,
-0.0167567227,
-0.0091544148,
0.0055954717,
0.0219826754,
-0.026683908,
-0.001835392,
0.025051875,
-0.0590259954,
-0.0036567112,
0.0193796288,
-0.0327147543,
-0.0290729329,
0.0380886942,
-0.0281267185,
-0.0259385202,
-0.0438069776,
0.0042202198,
0.0111213792,
-0.0029587308,
0.039240621,
-0.026867779,
-0.0047636498,
0.0355320983,
0.0489592478,
0.023115769,
-0.0472475961,
-0.0197285637,
-0.0605104826,
0.0249492489,
0.0797914118,
0.0343315303,
0.0301374979,
-0.0040318854,
-0.0577862747,
0.0080538774,
-0.0704685897,
0.0370600149,
0.0569648333,
-0.0378236435,
-0.0451328978,
-0.0130491853,
-0.0416304693,
0.0302954558,
-0.0254896954,
-0.0433884449,
0.0248495359,
-0.008559891,
-0.048650749,
-0.0098034777,
0.0037789727,
-0.0378898233,
0.0085036177,
-0.0139229773,
0.0037685728,
-0.0085942075,
-0.0053640702,
0.0053419662,
-0.0244604759,
0.0610627122,
0.0026116222,
0.0002576103,
0.0484220833,
0.0452388227,
-0.0026414082,
-0.0388047583,
-0.0478868186,
-0.0004762301,
-0.0299068782,
0.0133582624,
-0.0030681335,
-0.0151270404,
0.0445154719,
0.0308650807,
-0.013482633,
0.0060929866,
0.0169631653,
0.0197173916,
-0.0399546921,
-0.0001035809,
-0.0032320181,
-0.0144455982,
-0.0396678522,
0.00413075,
-0.0373971127,
0.0191182215,
0.0251408238,
-0.0584046803,
0.0019236171,
-0.0131423688,
2.791e-7,
0.0643033087,
0.0527064726,
0.00126554,
-0.0047639245,
0.046346046,
0.0143675553,
0.0313997455,
0.0028215139,
0.0338555984,
-0.0441498049,
-0.0003135431,
0.0326092206,
0.0444817059,
0.0642327219,
-0.0635310039,
-0.0403931886,
-0.0728994608,
0.0054462212,
-0.0308651421,
-0.0526361801,
0.05791023,
0.0409580171,
-0.0363726988,
-0.0487753525,
-0.022235062,
-0.0126153035,
0.0533550829,
0.0052470095,
-0.0023829541,
0.0494432226,
0.0492022522,
-0.0103291683,
0.034429457,
0.0590741113,
-0.0286382549,
-0.0618303977,
0.0195348747,
0.0285216793,
-0.0511480533,
-0.0423640348,
-0.0084999837,
-0.0165002458,
0.043192517,
-0.0762751251,
0.0779906809,
-0.0544413552,
-0.0288842823,
-0.0210848581,
-0.0012394374,
-0.0365792364,
0.072272405,
-0.0074910936,
-0.0328015573,
0.0231646225,
0.0157679748,
0.0393928401,
-0.0025345315,
-0.0356656238,
-0.0114222392,
0.006703848,
-0.0380661748,
-0.030552594,
0.0243467465,
-0.0340230726,
-0.0306469891,
-0.0975064784,
0.0175450835,
2.36902106e-34,
-0.0009813624,
0.0409477055,
0.0340324193,
0.0445285477,
0.0248270147,
0.009369297,
0.0405764133,
0.0266873576,
0.0274100434,
-0.0472336896,
-0.0248799957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06260v1 | An experiment on an automated literature survey of data-driven speech enhancement methods | 2023-10-10T02:07:24 | 2023-10-10T02:07:24 | Arthur dos Santos, Jayr Pereira, Rodrigo Nogueira, Bruno Masiero, Shiva Sander-Tavallaey, Elias Zea | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | The increasing number of scientific publications in acoustics, in general,
presents difficulties in conducting traditional literature surveys. This work
explores the use of a generative pre-trained transformer (GPT) model to
automate a literature survey of 116 articles on data-driven speech enhancement
methods. The main objective is to evaluate the capabilities and limitations of
the model in providing accurate responses to specific queries about the papers
selected from a reference human-based survey. While we see great potential to
automate literature surveys in acoustics, improvements are needed to address
technical questions more clearly and accurately. | [
0.0148362452,
0.0912281498,
-0.0047004945,
-0.058398433,
0.0024463015,
-0.0313439406,
0.0767557472,
-0.0144690843,
-0.0738241822,
-0.0224887189,
-0.0511313528,
-0.0059799394,
0.019562304,
-0.001374517,
0.0252636932,
-0.0530086756,
0.0015972563,
-0.051116433,
0.0179607384,
-0.0435521267,
-0.0397892818,
-0.0159059148,
-0.0445202813,
0.0312559344,
0.0240349155,
0.0166049823,
-0.0176705625,
-0.0044398517,
-0.0056191827,
-0.029489642,
0.0235559307,
0.0603911765,
0.0011784636,
0.0384120196,
0.0000019754,
-0.0428836271,
-0.0236528106,
0.062228106,
0.0022710275,
-0.0110386079,
0.0722579435,
0.0284051374,
-0.022747431,
0.0112246154,
-0.0069688219,
-0.0488695428,
0.0395987108,
0.0319951586,
0.0150873344,
0.0269946195,
-0.0147419386,
-0.0829789266,
0.0528042167,
-0.0063580591,
0.0337499231,
0.0149509292,
0.0439882316,
-0.0144759361,
0.0148624834,
0.0006680141,
0.0036808543,
0.0503102764,
-0.042057693,
-0.019107189,
0.0768682957,
0.0032323208,
-0.0523021817,
-0.0493978113,
-0.0004858018,
0.0449934453,
0.0180945769,
-0.0040922137,
0.0078135934,
-0.0247264076,
-0.0282770079,
0.0554966666,
-0.0265925061,
-0.0094023235,
0.0304587837,
-0.0563381352,
-0.0352020413,
0.0320839062,
-0.0036034249,
-0.0684107468,
-0.020739425,
0.0134933284,
0.0210600179,
-0.0457896776,
0.0390479751,
0.0047444957,
0.0396017469,
-0.0188115053,
0.0491180718,
0.0134155136,
-0.0375376754,
-0.0236362144,
0.0285541192,
-0.1114173755,
0.0015565609,
0.0477744304,
0.0132629545,
-0.023672672,
-0.0569217093,
-0.0235378537,
0.0145176668,
-0.016640462,
-0.0201974735,
-0.012926504,
-0.027125407,
0.017230995,
0.0192797948,
0.0028104165,
-0.0337780602,
0.0224523582,
-0.0240751673,
0.0194382034,
-0.0530231819,
-0.0301703773,
-0.008565357,
-0.0048275879,
0.031634111,
0.0204837117,
-0.0847412497,
-0.0098730046,
0.0168410987,
0.0417357013,
0.0239765309,
0.0735661685,
-0.0390071943,
-0.0248904768,
0.0254018176,
0.01180299,
0.0559505932,
-0.0039487896,
0.0402069911,
0.0259271339,
0.012221803,
-0.0423267744,
-0.0028648765,
0.0213997159,
-0.0063918475,
-0.0095900763,
0.0101410849,
-0.0665562525,
0.0391772501,
-0.009608292,
-0.0184139553,
0.0195794068,
-0.0285868272,
-0.0084730545,
0.0077345404,
0.0720749274,
-0.0494796634,
0.0178717598,
0.0683603212,
-0.0401341245,
0.0428861156,
0.0077354256,
0.029026797,
-0.0556210577,
0.0225702301,
-0.0519203246,
0.0406980589,
0.0196785331,
0.0142953852,
-0.0068362718,
0.0420411453,
-0.0043344274,
-0.0569780767,
0.0102619883,
0.0113745406,
0.0174130034,
0.0001368559,
0.0000251745,
0.0503623709,
0.0611231886,
0.0511043556,
0.0614677407,
0.0260386616,
0.0235770512,
0.021455681,
0.0103291729,
0.018840177,
-0.0168131515,
-0.0258940533,
0.0222035982,
0.0259653553,
0.0458435416,
-0.0153836338,
-0.0552979782,
0.0262436401,
-0.004626336,
0.0053236675,
0.0371076912,
0.0806448236,
0.0509219021,
-0.0269082915,
0.0075449003,
-0.00279394,
-0.0640878677,
0.016233163,
-0.0148711409,
0.0129864104,
-0.0225052331,
0.0482900366,
-0.0829970688,
-0.0160420798,
-0.0634529367,
-0.0499440357,
0.038194783,
-0.0269371402,
0.0123474551,
0.027118599,
-0.0223302245,
-0.0333480723,
0.0162055995,
-0.0059819072,
0.0135577759,
0.0018183584,
-0.0003236617,
0.009702215,
-0.0596699454,
0.0010395985,
0.0167717636,
-0.037180163,
-0.0310575198,
0.0428971946,
-0.0240577944,
0.0619541109,
0.0527333282,
-0.0450579599,
0.0034469687,
0.0195810515,
0.0012337245,
-0.0240828022,
0.0365615077,
0.0130312676,
0.0305235945,
0.0151546216,
-0.0689186603,
-0.001562785,
0.0244807098,
-0.0099193081,
-0.0532802269,
0.0282129645,
-0.0301069301,
0.0239220653,
-0.0281319059,
0.0148704685,
0.0135531174,
0.004569672,
0.0090374947,
-0.0167066548,
0.0505241081,
0.0025361858,
0.0297046639,
-0.0249858163,
0.0231076665,
-0.0332459249,
-0.0483990014,
0.0248280875,
-0.0294355843,
0.0001111723,
0.036155656,
-0.0110887829,
-0.0245223455,
-0.0079722935,
-0.0231445227,
-0.0043699257,
-0.0058855633,
-0.0116158584,
0.01793826,
0.0151461139,
0.0200518928,
0.0126596065,
-0.0187947135,
-0.0538525805,
-0.0036889226,
-0.0197292138,
0.0094199358,
-0.0155506069,
0.0107616354,
-0.053601522,
-0.0115649672,
-0.0039834674,
-0.0005751289,
0.0414334983,
0.0077980971,
-0.0308389906,
-0.0139554851,
-0.0020712123,
0.0583011024,
-0.0104440209,
-0.0137892198,
-0.0007022572,
0.0161447916,
0.081978552,
0.044193197,
0.0151795708,
-0.0324032679,
0.0444009751,
-0.0078110034,
-0.0248254109,
0.0067296866,
-0.0642192885,
0.0139697175,
-0.0012444775,
0.0028598984,
0.0411032028,
0.0004260789,
0.020880973,
-0.0344939008,
-0.0085890302,
-0.0055293394,
-0.0017690872,
-0.0460021123,
0.0165112447,
-0.0367511511,
-0.0259233955,
0.0199376121,
0.0462814383,
0.0169163439,
0.024739936,
-0.0563326329,
-0.0372890756,
-0.0788765624,
-0.0110955257,
0.0117379129,
-0.0394476727,
0.0381699055,
0.0113644246,
0.0476090498,
-0.0406896472,
-0.0554175228,
0.0103601869,
0.0351605676,
-0.0649734661,
-0.0270847455,
-0.0278737117,
0.0036359672,
0.0048317569,
0.0210736059,
-0.037110202,
-0.0172658563,
0.0137343965,
0.0129844956,
0.0825333595,
-0.0350682512,
-0.0296258088,
0.0398981199,
0.0558481067,
0.0752056092,
0.022700537,
-0.0218932014,
-0.0265550967,
0.0592792407,
0.0361891724,
0.0271365996,
0.0238191858,
0.0412263982,
-0.0258377735,
-0.0269657392,
-0.0052985623,
-0.0029198423,
-0.0698282197,
-0.008155847,
0.019946184,
-0.0526716672,
-0.0055818395,
-0.0040440415,
0.0101857185,
-0.0023584175,
0.0387700014,
0.0751898587,
0.0050767134,
-0.0444488861,
-0.0195827335,
-0.0174568705,
-0.0220531113,
-0.0133202784,
0.0053875381,
-0.0376273617,
0.0457137823,
0.0141495392,
0.0529545359,
-0.0282309391,
0.0219368264,
-0.0139409676,
-0.0954797566,
0.0628221333,
-0.0212656371,
0.0243363529,
0.0153280012,
-0.0447288565,
0.0354899466,
-0.0393803902,
0.0196556188,
0.0219357517,
-0.0076082782,
0.0022973765,
0.0303012412,
-0.0793859959,
-0.0680319443,
-0.0223566275,
-0.0009277308,
0.0532448813,
0.0771109462,
0.003252445,
-0.0427760109,
-0.0185507704,
-0.0376254953,
0.0099951457,
-0.0092258556,
0.0137991449,
0.0610506348,
0.0358889364,
0.0142165339,
0.0261439309,
0.0444048718,
-0.0037531944,
0.0054059546,
0.0173663124,
0.0331448875,
-0.0070516211,
0.0087097259,
-0.0240765065,
0.0659306943,
-0.0029582877,
0.0463059545,
-0.0100219091,
-0.0144664655,
0.0423532575,
0.0184073336,
0.0560710207,
0.0053633326,
-0.0392473303,
-0.0174567495,
-0.0225991178,
-0.0847616643,
-0.0547803268,
-0.0019689184,
0.0335000455,
0.0064947484,
0.023342343,
0.0078712022,
0.0684735551,
0.0279003661,
-0.0136060873,
-0.0126626575,
0.0155116469,
-0.0082220091,
-0.0156409051,
-0.0392939523,
0.0737397969,
-0.0276123658,
-0.0337563753,
0.004836306,
-0.0152657004,
-0.0415368043,
0.0451860018,
0.0346175656,
0.0201710928,
0.044972986,
-0.0278972276,
-0.0506103486,
0.0729579851,
0.0526772067,
-0.0578286424,
0.0149261765,
0.0747798011,
-0.032440614,
-0.0041145934,
-0.0130635705,
-0.0468906425,
0.0780990273,
-0.0362888314,
-0.0247872043,
-0.0259885788,
-0.0679108873,
0.0228745732,
0.0096667837,
0.0716709271,
-0.0089150462,
0.0462111086,
-0.0363027975,
0.0315617397,
-0.035669852,
0.0362725481,
-0.0504542813,
-0.00426888,
0.0025304351,
0.0076187504,
-0.0365611576,
0.0173421334,
-0.1075790301,
0.0132534709,
-0.0227223542,
0.0684987009,
0.0223098435,
-0.0008624715,
0.0090244999,
0.0013005184,
0.0096262721,
-0.0185576398,
0.0462866426,
0.031763684,
0.0316692367,
0.0193394162,
-0.0003559827,
-0.0174920224,
-0.0027907609,
0.0049751578,
-0.0866615772,
-0.0171111431,
-0.0463494547,
-0.0025431425,
-0.0360731632,
0.0005234497,
0.0355871208,
0.0027680136,
-0.000284486,
0.0067882081,
0.0159840919,
-0.0182482228,
0.0478859171,
0.0222429559,
-0.0162637234,
0.0051325546,
-0.011473571,
0.0532888919,
-0.0187835488,
-0.0094116759,
-0.000261727,
0.0061424342,
-0.022140041,
-0.0663310215,
-0.0441951789,
0.0136850402,
-0.0229365453,
-0.0083606904,
0.0079887966,
-0.0369089693,
-0.0085668778,
-0.0189391188,
0.0118799889,
-0.0758481696,
0.0198628511,
-0.0055968338,
-0.017749941,
-0.0192526318,
0.0156201115,
-0.0099898353,
-0.0251261778,
-0.0192145817,
0.0125738662,
-6.268836435e-33,
-0.0409123376,
-0.0083793793,
0.0104085738,
-0.0174853019,
-0.0216240082,
-0.0051339827,
-0.0260494314,
0.0045437748,
0.0052434979,
-0.000861324,
-0.0275094882,
0.0132316975,
0.0194164552,
0.0116373338,
0.0019537862,
0.0387539901,
0.0910783038,
-0.0388352461,
0.009074267,
0.0271798857,
-0.0314429291,
0.0182479117,
0.0233208984,
-0.0965008587,
-0.0012718472,
0.0063971402,
-0.0228087492,
-0.0612085164,
0.031852629,
-0.0159551445,
-0.0063706562,
0.0394411311,
-0.0577912703,
-0.0709969103,
0.0024771744,
0.0013770821,
-0.0707805008,
-0.0063185198,
-0.0042599905,
0.0371089578,
0.0270493869,
0.0280417316,
0.0624037459,
-0.0027235234,
-0.0261843558,
-0.0006779593,
0.067409575,
-0.0378953144,
0.0058765863,
-0.1095529273,
-0.0556302294,
-0.0137046082,
-0.0280759353,
0.0021234325,
0.0383136608,
0.0969808325,
-0.0350583829,
0.0261627864,
-0.0609052368,
0.0349406637,
0.1117901802,
0.0229750201,
0.0145058604,
-0.0352589488,
0.0322308391,
-0.0425819717,
0.0248963423,
-0.0363435782,
0.0354448706,
0.0025233284,
0.0017724488,
0.0307311807,
0.0393979438,
0.0596788898,
0.0549459606,
0.0044848281,
-0.0029086943,
0.0400824584,
-0.0095872255,
0.0042774854,
0.0203559864,
0.012502403,
0.0405975729,
-0.001086916,
-0.0364194177,
-0.0138984006,
0.0080038076,
-0.0343446285,
0.0065210355,
-0.0233219322,
-0.0190198161,
-0.0055070804,
0.0084376764,
-0.0405412689,
0.0075335451,
0.0049037766,
-0.0433710851,
0.0147642819,
-0.0121032521,
-0.027697036,
-0.0441794172,
0.0172067415,
0.1041155681,
0.0734838247,
0.0069001764,
-0.0325646214,
-0.0353486352,
0.0235979166,
-0.0612716116,
-0.0034923686,
0.023357667,
0.0295823384,
0.016413644,
0.0338547714,
-0.0115260324,
0.019353427,
-0.0005632793,
0.0178884771,
0.0015608186,
0.0266179834,
-0.0227403808,
0.0332280099,
0.009566078,
0.024416469,
-0.0390374772,
0.0067071328,
0.026030656,
-0.0466165543,
0.0725363865,
-0.0103554809,
-0.0247217417,
-0.0478653908,
2.855e-7,
0.0161341596,
0.0110363457,
0.0168409236,
-0.0158976,
0.0211950894,
-0.0042954641,
0.0349500924,
-0.0324204825,
0.0761197805,
0.0504838005,
0.0813450888,
-0.0510886312,
0.0234685186,
0.0474877618,
-0.0444262847,
-0.1039230675,
-0.0507377759,
-0.0063679069,
-0.0160909873,
0.0266011488,
0.0020678381,
0.0330916941,
-0.0410568826,
-0.0160057135,
-0.015757937,
0.0107481712,
0.0077742585,
-0.0334552489,
0.038852755,
0.0429457687,
0.0685137287,
0.0164705049,
0.0211892333,
0.0174147878,
-0.0634548962,
0.043188829,
0.0017005461,
-0.0193256214,
-0.0107529471,
-0.0498732962,
0.0377799049,
0.0651020929,
0.0105556501,
-0.0381460004,
0.0527994372,
-0.1100137308,
-0.0050758999,
-0.0449865758,
-0.1163619757,
-0.022872841,
0.0008433434,
-0.0389411785,
0.0173062682,
-0.0260870866,
0.006809256,
0.0419002399,
-0.0187424514,
0.0107477382,
0.0305905584,
0.0516477115,
-0.0509489365,
-0.0341577344,
0.0112020401,
-0.0744666606,
-0.0473716408,
-0.0136369104,
0.0250620842,
2.153593583e-34,
0.0720765442,
0.004649586,
0.0044143149,
-0.0079816803,
-0.0171622969,
-0.0080415513,
-0.0086783655,
0.0077738776,
0.010879539,
-0.0813905746,
-0.0532188341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06254v1 | Get the gist? Using large language models for few-shot decontextualization | 2023-10-10T02:00:00 | 2023-10-10T02:00:00 | Benjamin Kane, Lenhart Schubert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In many NLP applications that involve interpreting sentences within a rich
context -- for instance, information retrieval systems or dialogue systems --
it is desirable to be able to preserve the sentence in a form that can be
readily understood without context, for later reuse -- a process known as
``decontextualization''. While previous work demonstrated that generative
Seq2Seq models could effectively perform decontextualization after being
fine-tuned on a specific dataset, this approach requires expensive human
annotations and may not transfer to other domains. We propose a few-shot method
of decontextualization using a large language model, and present preliminary
results showing that this method achieves viable performance on multiple
domains using only a small set of examples. | [
-0.0071059274,
0.0862521455,
0.003841216,
0.0538694412,
-0.0248171613,
0.0396034606,
0.0231071655,
-0.0185034815,
-0.0309890714,
-0.0897606611,
-0.0288907215,
0.0172022954,
-0.0158463586,
-0.0075516012,
0.0022952971,
-0.0383483544,
0.0443706177,
0.0069099455,
-0.0144175654,
0.0156295411,
-0.016745314,
0.0298338421,
0.0042413813,
0.0185792875,
0.0308167953,
-0.048672948,
0.0018193703,
0.0322078466,
0.0493886173,
0.006242014,
0.0117439181,
0.0356345773,
0.0459418856,
0.0412961356,
0.0000016858,
-0.0363293774,
-0.0036925732,
0.0056449343,
-0.0406983085,
0.0294890776,
0.0076711485,
-0.0487392321,
-0.0163808409,
-0.009025624,
-0.0281933602,
-0.0745599866,
0.0496519171,
0.0176963881,
0.0520421714,
0.0682397112,
-0.0189846735,
-0.1140146405,
-0.0071095917,
-0.0155772269,
0.0107954992,
-0.0556425303,
0.044430878,
-0.0050961729,
-0.0246465784,
0.0393391922,
-0.0277776793,
0.0429932922,
0.0053720539,
-0.002932084,
-0.0207816549,
0.0227176975,
-0.0327759609,
0.0100859106,
-0.0057285954,
0.0644359365,
0.0037415386,
-0.01106044,
0.0177781992,
0.0162121411,
-0.0038426497,
-0.0132391229,
-0.046434775,
0.0171406455,
0.0040701367,
0.0290184375,
0.0078917714,
-0.0101400428,
0.0202831514,
0.0019760916,
-0.024168117,
-0.0013735308,
0.0445346273,
0.0072003566,
-0.0233104862,
0.0260410681,
-0.0376447178,
-0.0240273066,
0.0083858464,
-0.0048919232,
-0.0519812889,
0.0244144574,
-0.0407669507,
-0.0416194052,
-0.0242462978,
-0.0180725865,
-0.0067977281,
0.0245152768,
-0.0050956416,
0.0879486501,
-0.0339763016,
0.0223902036,
-0.0072484743,
-0.0397359282,
-0.0419256724,
-0.0259113684,
-0.0700878501,
-0.0203648135,
-0.0515177585,
0.0193779804,
-0.0702960342,
-0.0323864818,
-0.0145110693,
0.0127594853,
-0.0218650475,
-0.005808522,
-0.0143860551,
0.0093524503,
-0.0561133511,
-0.0164661407,
0.0311761741,
0.0554452501,
-0.0334473178,
0.0114801498,
0.0254070479,
-0.0263122246,
-0.009121133,
0.0027077987,
0.0245209169,
-0.0458389223,
-0.0681658015,
0.05412779,
-0.0061906409,
-0.0310304221,
-0.0561475009,
-0.01738552,
-0.0099918805,
-0.0416836664,
-0.034950614,
-0.0483926609,
0.0605728738,
-0.0049482686,
0.0026109975,
-0.0585687757,
0.0045667421,
0.0055720103,
-0.0329542495,
0.0897944123,
-0.0130423596,
-0.0130596301,
0.0421948843,
-0.0006256662,
0.0349894799,
0.1017452851,
-0.0100309309,
-0.0000524769,
0.0297437217,
0.0030907283,
0.0031808657,
0.0368126519,
-0.0256449264,
-0.0055652158,
-0.0468738005,
-0.0187145863,
0.0150137888,
0.0056509101,
0.0467712507,
0.0520709865,
-0.0748057961,
0.009070592,
0.0138731878,
0.0199926198,
0.0171789546,
0.0094659831,
0.087576516,
0.0207210258,
-0.0089006536,
0.0361424387,
-0.0392379947,
-0.0027799543,
0.0163265262,
-0.0070684757,
0.0199471992,
0.0311824176,
-0.0304122735,
-0.0129365856,
0.0156710185,
-0.0007855118,
0.0164614543,
-0.0094732651,
0.0547868349,
0.0540599413,
-0.020705197,
0.0184278693,
0.0355460569,
-0.0235772207,
0.0242112447,
-0.016733842,
-0.0087848995,
0.0697966442,
0.0430317372,
-0.0011748086,
-0.0130746504,
-0.0082692318,
0.021470394,
0.029637441,
0.0264796074,
-0.0459843948,
0.0413657613,
-0.0439273976,
-0.033915408,
-0.0256429613,
0.0721590817,
-0.0084047299,
0.0073014838,
-0.0306930672,
0.0367297865,
-0.0212130956,
0.0398718268,
0.0240459293,
-0.0665791035,
-0.0601905622,
0.0323042162,
0.0116918385,
-0.0005380179,
0.0459515266,
-0.0103450641,
-0.0093872529,
0.0000571314,
-0.0406337082,
-0.013592951,
0.0382452011,
-0.0271586496,
-0.1307364702,
-0.0136226881,
-0.0141060436,
-0.005794398,
0.000485087,
-0.0863881409,
-0.0298050158,
-0.001625139,
0.009873813,
0.0371402465,
-0.0518235825,
0.0149812652,
0.0421371385,
0.0101782205,
-0.048181016,
0.0736746192,
0.0375650674,
-0.0248134229,
0.0290562641,
0.0170026235,
0.0185820218,
-0.036128886,
-0.0066934582,
0.000437016,
-0.0174130928,
0.0046142652,
-0.0001226492,
-0.0241630562,
-0.0505319275,
0.0037959376,
-0.0944518223,
0.0306564271,
-0.028403217,
0.0190716125,
0.0415301248,
0.0358668603,
0.0135387741,
-0.0214319974,
-0.0123693524,
0.0093018785,
-0.0194897652,
0.0333260298,
0.0187754594,
0.0099594491,
-0.0046503916,
-0.0151563976,
-0.0046473932,
-0.0275865626,
0.0710618794,
-0.0454851575,
-0.0037940866,
-0.0481480323,
0.0730125904,
0.0088005634,
0.0312614478,
0.019998638,
-0.0230651814,
-0.0024382151,
-0.0042688558,
0.0479476526,
0.0820171684,
-0.021305155,
0.0176771767,
0.0002497573,
-0.0347037427,
-0.0275804028,
0.0204432663,
-0.018326357,
-0.0097223921,
-0.0062110792,
-0.0123938881,
-0.0000049522,
0.0660486445,
0.0160617717,
0.0225862674,
-0.0548130348,
0.033592172,
-0.0223575756,
-0.0269282423,
-0.0255133919,
0.0132703008,
0.0104841022,
0.0173808206,
-0.0289545059,
0.0324600004,
0.0552585348,
0.0219495464,
0.0062496806,
-0.0264569279,
0.0321070403,
-0.0297810342,
0.0372396223,
-0.0289945044,
0.0357582569,
0.0171863977,
-0.0315897688,
-0.0516102575,
-0.0214942172,
0.0070206872,
0.0013194153,
0.0195752624,
-0.0630263165,
0.0040521277,
-0.0297345743,
-0.0527287237,
-0.012137861,
-0.0314275064,
-0.0190822352,
0.0344123431,
-0.0067874794,
0.0105560394,
-0.0425374918,
0.0082266284,
-0.016953662,
0.0222059693,
-0.0206786431,
-0.0100284144,
-0.0320734046,
0.0958924592,
0.0661204085,
-0.0225667357,
-0.0402360335,
-0.0255074129,
0.0957475007,
0.0504350886,
-0.0055712969,
0.0408984981,
-0.0106304036,
-0.002628926,
-0.0024529435,
-0.0103249801,
-0.0532156751,
-0.0139130279,
0.0698524788,
-0.037952356,
-0.0332518741,
0.1102340221,
0.0068348222,
-0.0403606221,
-0.0184736364,
0.029763652,
-0.0238313247,
0.0087359287,
0.0047168215,
-0.1160289124,
-0.0672200173,
-0.0057872836,
-0.0235458463,
0.0490640365,
-0.0141929835,
-0.000937691,
-0.1159342676,
0.0522852726,
0.0348292775,
-0.0602019988,
-0.0154353296,
-0.0059945378,
0.0248226412,
-0.0324173383,
0.0052044848,
0.0035974744,
-0.0037818465,
0.0164795835,
-0.0021091257,
0.0300643388,
-0.0699910671,
-0.0180663206,
-0.0399226286,
0.0366646722,
0.0788819939,
0.0383491553,
0.0269028842,
0.0276174843,
0.0136169735,
-0.0788379833,
-0.0124898301,
0.0071820314,
0.0583070926,
-0.0308403205,
-0.0098449979,
0.0077794627,
0.0396533534,
-0.0120796012,
-0.0584541298,
-0.0021742748,
0.0179261509,
0.0074916761,
-0.0317891687,
-0.0363182724,
-0.0192530621,
-0.0233654324,
0.0950967297,
0.0354890078,
-0.0428574495,
-0.0463542119,
-0.0378428586,
0.0074573103,
-0.0612896085,
-0.0056883162,
0.0025202052,
0.0020435539,
-0.0223281961,
-0.0598656796,
-0.0449763797,
0.0462183245,
0.0219217706,
-0.0105842967,
0.0411269628,
-0.0373323485,
0.0094972495,
-0.0115487818,
-0.0250122342,
-0.035894949,
0.0027495795,
-0.0145312464,
0.0076097464,
0.0391209684,
-0.0047045182,
-0.0039968984,
-0.0258612055,
-0.0738911256,
-0.0375199579,
0.0034427955,
0.0093542058,
0.0134826871,
0.0297879279,
-0.0345589593,
-0.056151174,
0.0435307398,
0.0799478143,
-0.0129826562,
0.0100241508,
0.0062318244,
0.0516520105,
-0.0287009813,
0.0442039222,
-0.0281728171,
0.0281368606,
0.0090517588,
0.073415406,
-0.0296075977,
-0.0156552158,
0.0124255018,
-0.0454559289,
0.0600217469,
-0.0155166322,
0.0117742354,
-0.0087353289,
-0.0228208788,
-0.0513912775,
-0.0308053866,
-0.0400032252,
-0.0017337787,
0.0616565756,
0.0061317361,
-0.0107087828,
0.007713181,
0.0007833588,
0.0529430807,
-0.0769125521,
-0.0331136361,
0.0756210089,
0.0004817615,
0.002378728,
0.0003805545,
-0.0243328866,
0.0305424444,
0.0054458119,
0.0259196218,
-0.0595260225,
0.0685636774,
0.0131901568,
-0.0076805311,
-0.0034522563,
0.0153121036,
-0.044994399,
0.0258338768,
-0.0378017202,
0.0285333954,
0.0761238486,
-0.0029158797,
0.0547563955,
0.0501288921,
-0.0372523516,
-0.0164704863,
0.0595294833,
0.0329051055,
-0.004663642,
0.0130459815,
0.025682142,
-0.0306363888,
0.0019823923,
0.0711626485,
0.0200167987,
0.056714084,
0.0145420618,
0.0113045201,
-0.0246536788,
-0.0105254725,
0.0001526537,
0.0026638741,
-0.0096680755,
0.0031271246,
-0.0558185317,
-0.0687677339,
-0.0152961202,
-0.0045658168,
0.0094495639,
0.0269318074,
0.0095805759,
0.0427385308,
-0.0031848133,
-0.0691982657,
-0.04186517,
0.0218137018,
-0.0051510562,
-0.0418908633,
-0.0405685715,
-5.617274243e-33,
-0.0247552898,
0.0171943549,
0.0164510403,
-0.0342430063,
-0.0149904555,
-0.0082138376,
-0.041381903,
-0.0278581604,
-0.0125661772,
0.0225965865,
0.0050129248,
0.0150946602,
0.0127018867,
0.0412303023,
-0.0024693953,
0.0130624175,
0.092826426,
-0.0215929188,
-0.0106336195,
0.0207729787,
0.0285256486,
0.0458041765,
0.0295557491,
-0.0398304202,
-0.0034903891,
-0.0085199261,
-0.0290759299,
0.0361562669,
0.053590022,
0.0469808429,
-0.0273414925,
0.0053084614,
0.0218383931,
-0.0272535533,
-0.0154161919,
0.0201397575,
-0.1164177954,
0.0067035924,
0.0131800463,
0.009334052,
-0.0245349742,
-0.05864501,
0.0245288871,
-0.0300088096,
0.0119367503,
-0.0297646951,
0.0163075179,
-0.0330526568,
0.007734057,
-0.0554529279,
-0.0798129663,
0.0149810938,
-0.0152768316,
-0.0256596226,
0.0566306114,
0.0412120074,
-0.0094266422,
0.0029149209,
-0.0276940297,
-0.012097097,
-0.0162883569,
0.0384315327,
0.0458118133,
0.0436961502,
0.0148382476,
0.0428152904,
0.0400398336,
-0.0132924831,
-0.0022391102,
-0.012049648,
0.0102259601,
0.0431672707,
-0.0202362593,
0.0843333602,
0.0251646675,
0.0059622154,
-0.0688039511,
0.0371700227,
-0.0245335903,
0.0247588698,
0.0271178782,
0.046400357,
0.0066300347,
-0.0177563261,
-0.0400059074,
-0.041354917,
-0.009697332,
-0.028010875,
0.0461038761,
0.0039958255,
-0.0274961591,
-0.0177508257,
0.0700617582,
-0.0632433072,
0.0003738523,
0.0532181859,
-0.0134520838,
0.0227043536,
-0.002298452,
0.0012838001,
-0.015907025,
-0.0457040109,
0.0444110781,
0.0448738299,
0.0193629451,
-0.0118884128,
0.023501331,
-0.0213109739,
-0.0249438342,
0.007015775,
-0.0415684991,
-0.021796165,
-0.0378160737,
0.0432721749,
0.0130730849,
0.0399330854,
-0.0161815621,
0.024318831,
0.0362074412,
0.0058873543,
-0.0041643833,
0.000173964,
0.0108850235,
0.035909608,
-0.024087172,
0.002964186,
0.0219186023,
-0.0073070587,
0.0117774568,
-0.0353602767,
-0.0145695191,
0.0211178679,
2.336e-7,
0.0344659016,
0.0297771115,
0.0027490223,
-0.0318119489,
0.0491537414,
0.0346636884,
0.0013061359,
0.0183250271,
0.0063439971,
0.0132880332,
0.0047911331,
0.0411395282,
0.0524648875,
-0.0012809756,
-0.1181806773,
0.0365897156,
-0.0256486423,
-0.0138772288,
-0.0571703427,
-0.020036513,
0.0627825856,
0.0981748551,
-0.00171062,
0.0163268019,
0.00731555,
-0.032872811,
0.0680846572,
-0.0030310843,
-0.0360904783,
0.0330830999,
-0.0278370362,
0.0301598404,
0.00745482,
-0.0141811632,
-0.0128549347,
0.0059551164,
0.0193166286,
0.1016168222,
-0.0017005415,
-0.0204458907,
-0.0307924952,
-0.0070131044,
0.0246427096,
-0.0173902772,
0.0824010596,
-0.0682606548,
-0.020129066,
-0.0159847457,
-0.0812764317,
0.0208043437,
0.0023639675,
-0.0008038288,
-0.0434694365,
-0.0009060444,
0.0290188529,
0.0369674228,
-0.0707037896,
-0.0828007683,
-0.0319901295,
0.0210689344,
-0.037673261,
-0.0336518064,
0.0056168106,
-0.0033049101,
-0.0095062722,
-0.0317596681,
0.0205670688,
1.983609524e-34,
0.0319747627,
0.0151233934,
-0.0037298619,
0.0437563658,
0.0204301886,
-0.0207269546,
-0.0298700612,
0.0253322013,
0.008148009,
-0.0873067081,
0.0198474824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06245v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06245v1 | We are what we repeatedly do: Inducing and deploying habitual schemas in persona-based responses | 2023-10-10T01:44:47 | 2023-10-10T01:44:47 | Benjamin Kane, Lenhart Schubert | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Many practical applications of dialogue technology require the generation of
responses according to a particular developer-specified persona. While a
variety of personas can be elicited from recent large language models, the
opaqueness and unpredictability of these models make it desirable to be able to
specify personas in an explicit form. In previous work, personas have typically
been represented as sets of one-off pieces of self-knowledge that are retrieved
by the dialogue system for use in generation. However, in realistic human
conversations, personas are often revealed through story-like narratives that
involve rich habitual knowledge -- knowledge about kinds of events that an
agent often participates in (e.g., work activities, hobbies, sporting
activities, favorite entertainments, etc.), including typical goals,
sub-events, preconditions, and postconditions of those events. We capture such
habitual knowledge using an explicit schema representation, and propose an
approach to dialogue generation that retrieves relevant schemas to condition a
large language model to generate persona-based responses. Furthermore, we
demonstrate a method for bootstrapping the creation of such schemas by first
generating generic passages from a set of simple facts, and then inducing
schemas from the generated passages. | [
0.0505063236,
0.0496733412,
-0.0471143685,
0.0173282977,
-0.0099168783,
-0.0376029946,
-0.0010779226,
-0.0364518687,
0.034731809,
-0.0481208786,
0.0069677881,
-0.0314790681,
0.0028982791,
0.0789640322,
0.0170107093,
-0.0647564381,
0.0447118543,
-0.0265669227,
0.0149117224,
0.0151860677,
0.0174318049,
0.0283616241,
-0.0072759767,
0.0496481434,
-0.0413310155,
-0.0313976146,
-0.0182168726,
-0.0074564349,
0.0304705743,
-0.0145582855,
0.0161490086,
0.0108214235,
0.0463400856,
-0.0411137901,
0.0000020213,
-0.0595084019,
-0.0121361166,
-0.0511954315,
0.0179905128,
-0.0469870269,
-0.000420507,
0.0359200872,
0.0051743803,
0.0028979774,
-0.0824090689,
-0.0132378479,
0.0226489622,
0.0376422331,
0.0652477965,
0.0551739596,
-0.0308253411,
-0.0265863296,
-0.0168139413,
0.0075173886,
-0.0007139057,
-0.0283247791,
-0.0333741345,
-0.0037968166,
-0.0032056216,
-0.0105092786,
0.0286129322,
-0.0377830602,
-0.0057871477,
0.0065229288,
0.0350797437,
0.0413640253,
0.0219890736,
-0.0233761221,
-0.0172391944,
0.0700167939,
0.0732286423,
-0.0049705212,
0.0256533585,
0.0089284331,
0.0452404954,
0.0189145356,
-0.0075153075,
0.0383274443,
-0.0459581614,
-0.0143304002,
0.0150539838,
0.0421079844,
-0.0364337601,
-0.0343710594,
-0.0364484265,
0.0141948331,
0.0030024352,
0.0089448821,
-0.0319879577,
-0.0292031392,
0.0257404391,
-0.0917995423,
0.0019668236,
0.0466074906,
-0.0580649599,
0.025999302,
-0.0664742813,
0.0530963875,
0.0038095256,
0.0026494837,
0.0274910405,
0.0375188701,
0.0020491874,
-0.0132917389,
0.0098404726,
0.0241706874,
0.0065913089,
-0.0564970188,
-0.0013894262,
0.0191995781,
-0.0481387414,
-0.0229933988,
-0.0506244004,
0.043416921,
-0.0183928832,
-0.0240138955,
-0.0108983871,
0.0981056541,
0.0111958599,
0.0113112219,
-0.0429531895,
0.0298657678,
-0.0570198968,
0.0239035636,
-0.0528887659,
-0.0019631521,
-0.0634668171,
-0.0130768074,
0.032632757,
-0.0400448814,
0.014575325,
0.006759109,
0.0180373639,
-0.0014552616,
-0.0160759054,
0.0585863888,
-0.0100577539,
0.0021208178,
-0.0146126561,
-0.101623185,
-0.0123897167,
-0.0655390397,
-0.067021355,
-0.0390890762,
0.0246297903,
-0.0059280852,
-0.0098970458,
-0.0772989467,
0.0168858208,
0.0439515077,
0.0106520895,
0.049519904,
-0.0085130222,
0.0126736639,
0.0144111505,
0.0287626423,
-0.0209867004,
0.0234071203,
0.0468120351,
0.0485568382,
0.0128500527,
-0.0037110732,
0.0440992005,
-0.0003322356,
-0.0046506496,
-0.0376220606,
0.0307626501,
0.0270479675,
0.0412879102,
0.0091752559,
0.029405674,
0.0457040407,
-0.0308572222,
0.0120594073,
0.0796623603,
0.0371046923,
-0.025275873,
0.037261121,
0.05680044,
0.0014713261,
-0.0041970615,
0.045562692,
-0.005742644,
0.0258820988,
-0.0031721848,
-0.0104698297,
-0.0307852756,
0.0225303583,
-0.0241104774,
-0.0363740623,
0.0540001802,
0.0156414956,
0.0126304459,
-0.0012920605,
-0.0210756566,
0.0207105186,
-0.0357806049,
0.0385996178,
-0.0001403965,
-0.0761628747,
-0.0135555351,
-0.0108844973,
0.0358068086,
0.0952155292,
0.044698745,
-0.0158391781,
-0.0449515693,
0.0079864543,
-0.0010332302,
0.0418482944,
0.039117638,
-0.0544500835,
0.0257833749,
-0.0163052902,
0.0309383795,
-0.0236925948,
-0.0112238694,
0.0350613743,
0.0172877647,
0.0006028956,
0.0089568477,
0.01768714,
0.0141916284,
0.0098988842,
-0.0795182362,
-0.0146276653,
0.0271395519,
0.0256634895,
0.0080024432,
0.0356774069,
0.0095439404,
0.0015252067,
0.0300376732,
-0.0246196687,
-0.0001532553,
0.0897104219,
-0.0492427833,
-0.009549981,
0.007336006,
-0.0146077117,
0.0269306023,
-0.0241399538,
0.0335548781,
-0.0426842086,
0.0076513095,
-0.0398437046,
0.0565295108,
-0.029539993,
-0.0207138378,
0.0403795727,
0.0192613862,
-0.0318803862,
0.0460408702,
0.0348692797,
-0.056103956,
-0.0054656896,
-0.0014221162,
0.0036450364,
-0.0853652805,
0.0310535338,
0.0128445467,
0.0123165222,
0.0166009255,
0.0595046952,
-0.0247214176,
-0.0673782304,
-0.0416973904,
-0.1042135656,
-0.0015298986,
-0.0011521104,
-0.0108833658,
0.0098935217,
0.0243875645,
-0.0134994602,
-0.0299185254,
-0.0874718875,
0.0264195092,
0.0203800164,
-0.0070997658,
0.0611141808,
0.0273521822,
-0.0126566226,
-0.0330540724,
0.0451769345,
-0.0082856445,
0.0275585894,
-0.00007969,
0.0278325267,
-0.0483915396,
0.0222578011,
-0.0352843553,
0.0256563649,
-0.0085687386,
-0.0163793471,
0.0680250973,
-0.0072726985,
0.086344406,
0.0512608103,
0.0528225414,
0.0478026755,
-0.0066406117,
-0.0733666718,
-0.0445389673,
0.0192793272,
-0.025196353,
-0.0033144006,
-0.0404899381,
-0.0425030403,
0.0444343425,
0.0179035291,
0.0257229768,
-0.0002867443,
-0.0588133745,
0.0353827961,
0.0438421965,
-0.0287788156,
0.0523638055,
-0.0027601491,
-0.0213488117,
0.0464922674,
0.0006479774,
-0.0182135347,
0.0615410171,
-0.0268842019,
0.0073474864,
0.0017046437,
0.0078914389,
-0.0191834643,
0.0833255053,
-0.0172535982,
0.0375309698,
0.0454908125,
-0.0106345015,
-0.0275755227,
-0.0268472768,
0.0086285071,
-0.0180054009,
0.0291269682,
-0.0565412119,
-0.000719308,
0.035246443,
-0.0316689126,
-0.0846140981,
-0.0364439338,
-0.0092060212,
-0.0350134298,
0.0075921454,
-0.0301584583,
-0.011073688,
0.0100614764,
0.0056051905,
0.0292090625,
0.0030326075,
-0.0305223037,
-0.0257754251,
0.0129218968,
0.0502414964,
0.0370642059,
-0.0152042788,
-0.0211387761,
0.0577393621,
0.0331510566,
0.0043896548,
0.0143278027,
-0.0140062524,
-0.0183113758,
0.0069034011,
-0.021277342,
-0.0149621507,
0.0516729206,
0.0613322854,
-0.008749688,
-0.0446349196,
0.1105426103,
0.022510618,
-0.0037456707,
0.0230652094,
0.0170297734,
0.0570269302,
0.0293813404,
0.031663388,
-0.0749216005,
-0.0106304642,
-0.0066861073,
0.0275314935,
-0.0314182192,
-0.0610134788,
-0.0483798683,
-0.1009324938,
0.0350536741,
0.0200440753,
-0.0555101037,
0.0222718827,
-0.0073530315,
0.0108552519,
-0.0042960993,
-0.0212328285,
-0.002751979,
-0.0048845112,
0.017007472,
-0.0265794005,
-0.0489109717,
-0.0134724956,
0.0129605327,
-0.0280169938,
0.0789330006,
0.0192406606,
0.0511454791,
0.0553227365,
0.0118664401,
-0.0575588457,
0.0231056046,
0.0366744846,
0.0110453274,
0.0394320413,
-0.0297795944,
-0.0044365018,
-0.0104746949,
0.0626713485,
-0.0665897876,
-0.0258509424,
0.0390329659,
0.0246129148,
-0.0615958311,
0.0027183723,
-0.0078896526,
0.0264068823,
0.0571288727,
0.0484328791,
0.0184667464,
-0.0414307937,
-0.0234060232,
0.0053109135,
0.0166642237,
-0.0428284258,
-0.0246048234,
-0.0117583154,
0.0150889596,
-0.0106403474,
-0.0888165757,
-0.0867357999,
0.0041284361,
0.0784053355,
0.0184553284,
-0.0143984612,
0.0212376788,
0.0236161929,
-0.0461558886,
-0.0098464321,
-0.0467701294,
-0.006076898,
-0.0240325015,
-0.0498256348,
0.0351650007,
-0.0791735649,
0.0121023115,
0.0236909539,
-0.0407494903,
-0.0336326174,
-0.0283706877,
0.0407618657,
0.0246459432,
0.0681111217,
0.0213100333,
-0.0011646063,
0.0018858318,
0.0040260823,
-0.0586480796,
0.0060325675,
-0.0130435415,
0.0280987155,
-0.0164621361,
0.0204862151,
-0.001015989,
0.0411365069,
-0.045704022,
0.0269980431,
-0.0362604372,
-0.0761129633,
0.0510758013,
0.0024595517,
-0.0262035541,
-0.0183443874,
-0.0051559391,
-0.0187363885,
-0.0276061166,
-0.0465481244,
-0.0376750492,
-0.0442499816,
-0.0041143913,
-0.0123937419,
0.0022710245,
0.0312182568,
-0.0541053154,
-0.0661227331,
0.0844157189,
-0.0186299663,
-0.0568102747,
0.0368149057,
0.0050308718,
-0.0002428911,
-0.00884772,
-0.0195914898,
0.0090021444,
-0.0144787151,
0.0751691833,
-0.0054876804,
0.0686369538,
0.0169078186,
-0.0230341256,
-0.0037868675,
0.0287554152,
-0.0492318496,
-0.0172534846,
0.0094115781,
0.0124534313,
0.0232819505,
0.0025873319,
0.0431341007,
-0.0413353629,
0.0214222893,
0.0007360648,
0.0338363536,
0.0345898829,
-0.0289849602,
-0.0210615899,
0.0047355732,
-0.0419694558,
-0.0135182105,
0.0424187221,
-0.0331063643,
0.0242588446,
-0.0230833385,
-0.0285690073,
-0.0767734423,
-0.0264666956,
0.0024289254,
0.0355436839,
0.0152438879,
0.0081081577,
-0.0881429315,
-0.0128632309,
0.0122296624,
0.0042434265,
0.0050535514,
-0.0303394888,
0.0146552548,
0.0719574168,
0.0181008056,
-0.0095223989,
-0.0477722138,
0.0433362387,
-0.0568863042,
0.0025512977,
-0.0259093884,
-5.534832783e-33,
-0.0641749352,
-0.0585252531,
0.0423253588,
0.0218939874,
-0.0538697951,
-0.0136218658,
-0.0481171943,
-0.0088717975,
0.002353569,
-0.0254911762,
-0.0036474429,
-0.034544494,
0.0068275039,
0.001961113,
-0.0183945093,
0.0153108565,
0.0532441735,
0.0120744938,
-0.0582390241,
0.0596719459,
0.073238492,
0.0104219699,
0.0009792167,
-0.0746673793,
-0.002142346,
-0.0181763936,
-0.0310474224,
0.0211327672,
0.036996074,
0.0419735201,
-0.0326279588,
0.0174184013,
0.0114014372,
-0.0033912652,
-0.0077074957,
0.0583631098,
-0.0534236543,
-0.0293646641,
0.034130536,
0.0018346632,
-0.0106141027,
-0.040209543,
-0.0078050764,
-0.0446252301,
0.0003776652,
0.0098387273,
0.0349315032,
-0.016442094,
0.0157250222,
-0.001799654,
-0.0876907557,
-0.0129295858,
0.0095296847,
-0.0558129102,
-0.0360511243,
0.0440857261,
0.004479744,
-0.0381243341,
-0.0229608528,
0.051535517,
-0.0345570035,
-0.0053369938,
0.0016612259,
0.039294973,
0.0003945785,
0.0615779422,
0.0429561324,
0.0630779788,
-0.030778069,
0.0206277873,
-0.0008947561,
0.016430974,
-0.0428978652,
0.0557586513,
-0.0219846275,
-0.0126068015,
-0.0175873414,
0.0321369059,
0.0543026291,
-0.0323871262,
0.0436136052,
0.0043968796,
-0.0404945798,
-0.0174499825,
-0.0291640069,
0.0281016938,
0.0017431405,
-0.0283835251,
0.0241416488,
0.0030946753,
-0.0280559324,
-0.0047099493,
0.0261299051,
-0.0399200656,
0.0053631514,
0.0322827809,
-0.066136308,
-0.0023591481,
-0.0334609337,
0.0161524415,
-0.0072780065,
-0.0322744958,
0.0544335991,
0.0233875923,
0.036483109,
0.0671255961,
-0.0228383169,
0.0408439785,
-0.0314785279,
-0.0254065469,
-0.0334632955,
0.0535074063,
-0.0406475142,
0.007729175,
0.0075886105,
0.0118639106,
-0.0390970744,
0.0377106071,
-0.0160123445,
-0.0192752685,
-0.0557251461,
-0.00341112,
0.020074483,
0.0208088532,
-0.0144801885,
0.0174990147,
-0.024761945,
-0.0336063877,
0.0140532441,
-0.0013176163,
0.0000329032,
-0.0426029637,
2.695e-7,
-0.0750242993,
0.0050675767,
0.0138290264,
0.0460825972,
0.0389653742,
0.0521110147,
0.0414473638,
0.0642390251,
0.0054129413,
-0.0769938827,
0.0186063107,
0.0371941142,
0.0291711912,
0.0443662256,
-0.0723566636,
-0.002921113,
0.0178994965,
-0.0279154275,
-0.04082755,
0.0084373532,
0.1058780327,
0.0028903319,
0.0211405121,
-0.0097292969,
0.0322533175,
0.0213258658,
0.058324907,
-0.0152465263,
-0.0285890587,
0.0374220684,
-0.0046175248,
-0.0019689465,
-0.0259737391,
0.0245917309,
0.0014349931,
0.0128997648,
-0.0147709996,
0.0282340739,
-0.035721723,
-0.0295589771,
0.0044071251,
-0.008519683,
-0.0018856266,
-0.015325373,
0.0141669903,
-0.0294221267,
-0.0306436848,
-0.001036797,
-0.0195804313,
-0.0389016196,
-0.0463203005,
-0.0116231395,
-0.0315741114,
0.0163393505,
0.0017721739,
0.0238179844,
0.0264789667,
-0.0594038107,
-0.0157109182,
0.0338675119,
-0.064373523,
-0.0448214412,
-0.0123649426,
-0.0215842519,
-0.0173394848,
-0.0496208742,
0.0268436577,
2.392639313e-34,
-0.0143547216,
0.0692174211,
-0.0126373433,
0.0360262133,
0.0522306301,
-0.0051334044,
0.0442103818,
0.0168158542,
0.0829385221,
-0.0570215993,
-0.0363880396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06239v1 | Model Tuning or Prompt Tuning? A Study of Large Language Models for Clinical Concept and Relation Extraction | 2023-10-10T01:27:08 | 2023-10-10T01:27:08 | Cheng Peng, Xi Yang, Kaleb E Smith, Zehao Yu, Aokun Chen, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Objective To develop soft prompt-based learning algorithms for large language
models (LLMs), examine the shape of prompts, prompt-tuning using
frozen/unfrozen LLMs, transfer learning, and few-shot learning abilities.
Methods We developed a soft prompt-based LLM model and compared 4 training
strategies including (1) fine-tuning without prompts; (2) hard-prompt with
unfrozen LLMs; (3) soft-prompt with unfrozen LLMs; and (4) soft-prompt with
frozen LLMs. We evaluated 7 pretrained LLMs using the 4 training strategies for
clinical concept and relation extraction on two benchmark datasets. We
evaluated the transfer learning ability of the prompt-based learning algorithms
in a cross-institution setting. We also assessed the few-shot learning ability.
Results and Conclusion When LLMs are unfrozen, GatorTron-3.9B with soft
prompting achieves the best strict F1-scores of 0.9118 and 0.8604 for concept
extraction, outperforming the traditional fine-tuning and hard prompt-based
models by 0.6~3.1% and 1.2~2.9%, respectively; GatorTron-345M with soft
prompting achieves the best F1-scores of 0.8332 and 0.7488 for end-to-end
relation extraction, outperforming the other two models by 0.2~2% and
0.6~11.7%, respectively. When LLMs are frozen, small (i.e., 345 million
parameters) LLMs have a big gap to be competitive with unfrozen models; scaling
LLMs up to billions of parameters makes frozen LLMs competitive with unfrozen
LLMs. For cross-institute evaluation, soft prompting with a frozen
GatorTron-8.9B model achieved the best performance. This study demonstrates
that (1) machines can learn soft prompts better than humans, (2) frozen LLMs
have better few-shot learning ability and transfer learning ability to
facilitate muti-institution applications, and (3) frozen LLMs require large
models. | [
0.0688141584,
0.0209102444,
0.004660497,
0.0032411611,
-0.0389514379,
0.06023537,
0.0144417174,
0.0343823731,
-0.0179822482,
-0.0332278833,
-0.0454545394,
-0.058338441,
-0.0087402212,
0.0413187034,
-0.0184366722,
-0.0731474683,
0.054695826,
0.0077692713,
0.0362760685,
0.0106706358,
-0.0547305606,
0.0108993705,
-0.045514293,
0.0040568006,
0.0219212919,
0.0115915546,
0.0435459241,
-0.0399953909,
0.0079352129,
-0.0786882937,
-0.0268837344,
0.0510016084,
-0.0255264156,
0.0038726043,
0.0000021365,
-0.1045753509,
-0.0410108492,
0.0238656458,
-0.0708160028,
-0.0061563891,
0.042454388,
-0.0696755201,
0.0254144762,
0.0005976996,
-0.0296487119,
-0.0401916616,
0.02040096,
0.0306768324,
0.020372672,
0.0635693297,
-0.0176429395,
-0.0214473773,
0.01643393,
-0.0232358687,
-0.0201319605,
-0.0584632158,
0.0711584017,
-0.0035967242,
0.002597064,
-0.0080796042,
-0.010512419,
0.0355774574,
-0.0446028039,
0.0281585995,
0.0397925563,
0.0401389562,
-0.0431071967,
-0.0270855799,
-0.0112245204,
0.0724366084,
0.0053580571,
0.0271111149,
0.0277140196,
-0.01749596,
0.0044879387,
0.038196519,
-0.0289086998,
-0.0016256046,
-0.0227746889,
-0.0029868803,
-0.0090112016,
-0.0239517093,
0.0019360344,
0.0026296119,
-0.0422222055,
-0.0374617241,
0.0243940484,
-0.0286920108,
0.0734972879,
0.0120722353,
-0.0436269864,
-0.0105061894,
0.0176473409,
0.0364034548,
-0.037815392,
0.0299660433,
-0.0085964315,
-0.0107789896,
0.0759767964,
-0.0429512896,
0.0288072173,
-0.0009513329,
-0.0099930409,
0.0513471514,
-0.0511266626,
0.0063275513,
0.0117225451,
0.0358754173,
-0.0416253842,
0.0417589098,
-0.0547208451,
0.0263419151,
-0.0202893279,
0.0385507718,
0.0052534994,
-0.0136314519,
-0.0732857585,
-0.0067170919,
0.016298309,
0.0241156518,
-0.0004545649,
0.0060823876,
-0.011923234,
0.0144162839,
-0.0111616971,
0.0231195688,
0.0239177328,
0.0091198981,
-0.0304335859,
-0.0494251326,
0.0098468205,
-0.0384422615,
0.0447467938,
-0.0275712553,
0.0462151989,
0.0348016247,
0.0045124157,
-0.0484937653,
-0.0077828597,
-0.0194730889,
-0.0136987083,
-0.0271144565,
-0.0003262766,
-0.0310666841,
0.0439563952,
0.0289969891,
0.0139107257,
-0.0343037881,
0.022594152,
-0.0106946463,
-0.0723238066,
0.0494317599,
-0.0288927481,
-0.0006841525,
0.012203726,
0.0113654044,
-0.0249587204,
0.030669516,
-0.0005714981,
-0.0300122406,
0.0062609017,
-0.0366015807,
-0.0056564398,
0.0025865342,
0.0160077121,
-0.0512300916,
-0.0201388486,
0.0246338882,
0.0785142034,
0.0548161492,
-0.012567061,
0.0699648783,
-0.0014922394,
-0.008195091,
0.0105249109,
0.0430903323,
0.0476979949,
0.0120326262,
0.0366681144,
-0.0295211803,
0.0356407389,
-0.0265841801,
-0.0043510715,
-0.0363992192,
0.0034846435,
0.002574512,
-0.0512559041,
-0.0098252483,
-0.0145402029,
-0.00187756,
-0.0123287179,
-0.00418268,
-0.0635888875,
0.0144712999,
0.0663122535,
-0.0135611109,
-0.05061673,
0.0707567781,
0.0890996233,
0.0175048467,
-0.0272518545,
-0.0457281247,
-0.0017576555,
0.0282520931,
0.0318062343,
-0.0446971431,
-0.0532766543,
-0.0283850078,
0.0079982271,
-0.0189937763,
0.0399664529,
-0.0073809968,
0.0091466727,
-0.034084253,
-0.0044999029,
0.0458933078,
0.0310993157,
-0.0087755537,
-0.015332981,
0.062620081,
-0.0201831833,
0.0290760044,
-0.0162967406,
0.0706481487,
-0.056282755,
-0.0508713163,
-0.0064981962,
-0.0142405592,
0.0438086241,
-0.0074432893,
-0.0273130331,
-0.0036352368,
0.0147254495,
-0.0218763463,
0.0254046805,
-0.0536779948,
-0.0895008147,
-0.0404979177,
0.0080661112,
0.0630855113,
0.0083725881,
-0.0613351949,
-0.0272429716,
0.0209506713,
-0.0668440238,
0.0056539811,
0.0324456282,
-0.0063900384,
0.0600875728,
0.0055689332,
0.0249278564,
-0.0648343787,
0.0204654615,
0.0067976681,
0.0002478157,
0.0108933747,
-0.0337704234,
0.0055034906,
-0.0056173271,
-0.0188818909,
0.0399859995,
-0.0258983001,
-0.0200576987,
-0.0462175645,
0.0184248108,
-0.0276566595,
-0.0517110527,
-0.062985681,
-0.0029610626,
0.0310390256,
0.0002991031,
0.0245224405,
0.0216220859,
-0.0251389034,
-0.0144257778,
-0.0161331259,
0.0028724549,
0.013247232,
0.0140153393,
0.0187212229,
0.0705946535,
-0.0193437524,
-0.0256664809,
0.0055505997,
-0.0256161448,
0.0531568043,
0.0082615372,
-0.0502303988,
0.0222547948,
0.0626957491,
-0.0195906945,
-0.0287219957,
-0.0012671315,
-0.0085554114,
-0.0254813526,
-0.0205771476,
-0.0231310949,
0.0345581882,
0.0176533535,
0.018416835,
0.0243183244,
-0.011790297,
0.0014568802,
0.0079480968,
-0.0333167613,
-0.064917624,
-0.0017401794,
-0.0176627655,
0.0060736542,
0.068008922,
0.0280778687,
0.0171407573,
-0.0019101077,
-0.028510008,
-0.0188756604,
0.0383481495,
-0.0546261743,
0.0351260342,
-0.0480768755,
0.0381718352,
0.0081070848,
-0.001290264,
0.0740002692,
0.0070476481,
0.0455204248,
-0.0529352948,
-0.023366943,
-0.0371261351,
0.0128070358,
-0.0125378743,
0.0212367941,
0.0430882722,
-0.0127756242,
-0.0102088302,
-0.0164888036,
0.0215938538,
-0.0717432573,
0.0531544611,
0.0062619867,
0.0219894238,
-0.0269418955,
-0.0195089318,
-0.0537334122,
-0.0462393276,
-0.0092146909,
0.0188009981,
0.0125808595,
0.0416817218,
-0.0350398459,
0.0397667512,
-0.0217026398,
0.0619066097,
0.0110661564,
-0.0091247931,
0.0092527466,
0.0101853926,
0.0399161354,
0.0088654794,
-0.0325365514,
-0.0413885228,
0.0691394731,
0.0272597447,
-0.025606038,
0.0120964721,
0.0274300072,
0.0223500207,
0.010261598,
-0.0456657559,
-0.0056356369,
0.0363720916,
0.0275765527,
-0.0613803752,
-0.0158184152,
0.1180171594,
0.0121540884,
-0.0858858973,
0.0027017237,
0.0088408981,
-0.0183850303,
-0.0107604368,
0.0240668803,
-0.0450179093,
-0.0316953734,
-0.016164327,
0.0293628071,
-0.0281219743,
-0.0492883325,
0.0095889615,
-0.0617370829,
-0.0022842356,
-0.0043288791,
-0.0772640258,
-0.0108313616,
-0.0677361116,
0.0296449829,
-0.00540051,
-0.0114727821,
0.0052178488,
-0.0612733103,
-0.0297007039,
0.0093710646,
-0.053436622,
-0.0930880383,
0.0307686087,
-0.0257012546,
0.058817517,
0.0207927637,
0.0307686087,
-0.0463174805,
-0.0040846523,
0.0412268229,
-0.0211075135,
-0.0048845974,
-0.0203325357,
0.0794859082,
0.0085039092,
0.0028207449,
-0.0155324722,
-0.0071791834,
0.0010509486,
-0.0166592188,
0.0090479674,
0.0899828076,
-0.0164342355,
-0.0259337835,
-0.0078700939,
0.0164915174,
0.0160834957,
0.0410506502,
-0.0025434173,
-0.0149284657,
-0.0028057001,
0.0427049659,
0.0182824936,
0.0335186869,
0.0023670713,
0.0181045886,
-0.0899772123,
0.0046862252,
-0.0314721726,
0.0056373263,
0.0559221879,
0.0272448529,
0.0348408408,
0.0596223995,
0.0004821367,
0.034200158,
-0.0350267217,
0.0457766578,
0.0163710434,
-0.0187925361,
-0.0828203559,
-0.0598408058,
0.0428131893,
-0.0127282962,
-0.0310867559,
-0.0145564154,
0.0168571137,
0.0132385902,
0.0228785928,
0.0198775437,
0.0141585432,
0.0232017096,
0.0240644515,
0.0233685113,
0.0738906562,
0.0651456639,
-0.0460912697,
-0.0295940712,
-0.0144628314,
-0.0118597634,
-0.0357641019,
-0.0038567986,
-0.0194397941,
0.0250060558,
0.0492773466,
0.0195215307,
-0.0063358983,
-0.0536948517,
0.0109307673,
0.0712074935,
0.0595916398,
0.0047771651,
-0.0558960401,
-0.0480858013,
0.012591619,
0.003456655,
0.0448719971,
-0.0320356712,
-0.0137617523,
0.057033401,
0.0052885031,
-0.0132104838,
-0.0340347625,
-0.0256582499,
-0.0221888274,
-0.0200538151,
0.0309296641,
0.0173370633,
-0.0027737243,
0.0677184165,
-0.0178796258,
-0.0379446633,
0.0039763767,
0.0436279066,
0.0092945891,
-0.0234105587,
0.0971096158,
-0.0017807015,
0.0465872847,
-0.0084039886,
0.0374425203,
-0.0183328483,
-0.0064890133,
-0.0328605883,
0.0299603827,
0.0486532934,
-0.0247054286,
0.0023796067,
-0.0090903314,
0.0015332567,
-0.0284786597,
0.0351653658,
-0.0543390438,
0.0359833688,
0.0408291072,
0.0185789727,
-0.0001695493,
0.0107485522,
0.050624378,
-0.0289781019,
0.0604598299,
-0.0002225343,
-0.0305775404,
-0.0387286171,
0.0302074961,
0.0290048122,
-0.0269102938,
-0.0511220247,
0.0300635882,
-0.0664792061,
-0.0181622431,
0.0332417935,
-0.0610647686,
-0.047757443,
-0.010961053,
0.0671824664,
0.0400910005,
0.0192731339,
-0.0236765016,
-0.0454292893,
0.0299665648,
0.0091457032,
-0.0181849413,
0.0316014625,
-6.038453869e-33,
-0.0145003349,
0.0171240252,
0.0072524054,
0.0091897994,
-0.0506148711,
0.033894971,
-0.0108810952,
-0.0066272607,
-0.0189838689,
0.0296879299,
-0.0235847384,
-0.0482312255,
0.0113428477,
0.010784056,
-0.0039950092,
-0.0399048142,
0.0132933548,
0.0128425788,
-0.0040486041,
0.0194020569,
-0.0042908555,
0.0957837924,
0.0387397595,
-0.0706186071,
-0.0218955055,
0.0267646946,
0.0456688888,
-0.0035111874,
0.0133385425,
0.046217382,
-0.0426859967,
0.0095804995,
0.0296403784,
-0.0279429238,
0.0087934379,
-0.0090010557,
-0.0759592727,
-0.0191224441,
0.0046552131,
-0.0119142383,
0.0091913519,
-0.0241974127,
0.0385174491,
-0.0148159852,
-0.0143000325,
-0.0083493525,
0.0111172842,
-0.0537230484,
-0.0551840663,
-0.0266780145,
-0.0511942059,
0.0383574478,
0.0297167767,
-0.0028919263,
0.0049525397,
-0.0237402543,
-0.0417753272,
0.03826648,
0.023789471,
-0.044834327,
0.0442771465,
0.0372106954,
-0.0113019831,
0.0219591595,
-0.0174809657,
0.0609859489,
0.0130038662,
0.0049455105,
0.0035624974,
0.0064673899,
-0.0295318067,
0.0640705675,
0.0086274669,
0.0302742887,
0.0194408614,
-0.0509813875,
-0.0943614244,
0.0022583643,
-0.0097836917,
0.0343092531,
0.0317661576,
-0.0640104264,
-0.0304586682,
-0.0218397304,
-0.0362388752,
0.0097994572,
-0.0061029471,
-0.0230602156,
0.0265599638,
-0.0132508539,
0.003128873,
0.0114619303,
0.029493304,
-0.0083924588,
-0.010823668,
-0.0382223278,
0.0296455286,
0.014716004,
-0.0522538126,
-0.0179880876,
-0.0851663053,
-0.0774368048,
-0.0002889587,
-0.0336201638,
0.0602973513,
-0.0024220042,
0.0308813751,
-0.0236588195,
-0.0476491265,
-0.0164343063,
0.0055191866,
-0.0210848842,
0.0116871633,
0.026864402,
0.0196547527,
0.0181188397,
0.0124234874,
0.0597622581,
0.014402573,
-0.042511858,
-0.0224927813,
-0.0352018997,
0.0221152697,
0.0146099543,
-0.0366287678,
-0.0022748371,
-0.0272724219,
0.0547833145,
0.0205236059,
-0.0330773592,
-0.01116003,
-0.0071579674,
2.905e-7,
0.087223351,
0.0687089637,
-0.0492159128,
-0.0415157899,
0.0125192823,
0.0005884338,
-0.0087733399,
0.0016434261,
0.0274203699,
-0.0110635161,
0.0610440895,
0.0010555654,
0.0336371697,
0.0338294581,
-0.0762196854,
-0.0369576812,
-0.0928434432,
-0.0350941047,
-0.0536989644,
-0.016836239,
0.0691529363,
0.0624515489,
-0.0164775457,
-0.0392171368,
0.001403341,
-0.0331341662,
0.0278179087,
-0.0549914986,
-0.0013284512,
0.0644999593,
0.0150053203,
-0.0259139277,
0.0051450287,
0.0803848952,
-0.011398362,
0.0249785818,
-0.0003984485,
0.0895658582,
-0.0498777255,
0.0295073055,
0.0516940989,
0.0252827387,
0.036329858,
-0.0604688041,
0.0671142638,
-0.0565033704,
-0.0451190285,
-0.0223287325,
-0.0244314875,
-0.0466684811,
0.0682387799,
-0.0260266289,
0.0179645531,
0.0271470509,
0.0337070636,
0.0345375463,
-0.079975009,
-0.0533862002,
0.0156206507,
0.0668723732,
-0.0077725668,
-0.0522234514,
0.0627295598,
-0.0275589749,
0.0081308372,
-0.046184808,
0.0293669906,
2.783758197e-34,
0.0260010641,
-0.0175875816,
0.0292936563,
0.0432386957,
0.0032301792,
-0.0147564597,
-0.007164205,
0.047024291,
-0.0071787867,
-0.0638249367,
0.026452342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06238v1 | Tackling Data Bias in MUSIC-AVQA: Crafting a Balanced Dataset for Unbiased Question-Answering | 2023-10-10T01:22:41 | 2023-10-10T01:22:41 | Xiulong Liu, Zhikang Dong, Peng Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS | In recent years, there has been a growing emphasis on the intersection of
audio, vision, and text modalities, driving forward the advancements in
multimodal research. However, strong bias that exists in any modality can lead
to the model neglecting the others. Consequently, the model's ability to
effectively reason across these diverse modalities is compromised, impeding
further advancement. In this paper, we meticulously review each question type
from the original dataset, selecting those with pronounced answer biases. To
counter these biases, we gather complementary videos and questions, ensuring
that no answers have outstanding skewed distribution. In particular, for binary
questions, we strive to ensure that both answers are almost uniformly spread
within each question category. As a result, we construct a new dataset, named
MUSIC-AVQA v2.0, which is more challenging and we believe could better foster
the progress of AVQA task. Furthermore, we present a novel baseline model that
delves deeper into the audio-visual-text interrelation. On MUSIC-AVQA v2.0,
this model surpasses all the existing benchmarks, improving accuracy by 2% on
MUSIC-AVQA v2.0, setting a new state-of-the-art performance. | [
0.0113412747,
0.0482527986,
-0.0043481807,
0.0457515083,
0.0282771159,
-0.0098871421,
0.0228885375,
-0.0333904997,
-0.0460709482,
-0.0402178578,
-0.0516900308,
-0.005053048,
-0.0120395254,
0.0177530255,
0.0451437086,
-0.0496757776,
0.0228460263,
-0.0235942006,
0.0302205533,
-0.0114716273,
0.0325873755,
0.0105422512,
-0.0348759443,
0.0194699597,
-0.0490315147,
-0.018981969,
-0.0118686082,
0.0349192172,
0.013185218,
-0.0155223887,
-0.0195307881,
0.0424063541,
0.0299258754,
-0.0118363993,
0.0000016281,
-0.0074338242,
0.0402115472,
-0.0233877748,
0.0042236634,
-0.023757346,
-0.0354335271,
0.0284337662,
0.022850791,
0.0575363711,
-0.0246384405,
-0.0130344406,
0.0433369428,
-0.0159089547,
0.051492855,
0.0325754918,
-0.0130740497,
-0.0427562743,
0.0100572221,
-0.0019543632,
0.0520249829,
-0.0188190918,
0.0000477162,
0.0224595089,
0.0076792962,
0.0169775486,
-0.0746532455,
0.0462155528,
0.044149708,
0.0341695324,
0.0312541127,
0.0089237709,
-0.0700551793,
-0.0367500708,
0.0000223212,
0.1184512675,
0.0610704198,
-0.0029316279,
-0.0005377886,
0.0144014722,
0.03494424,
-0.0101615814,
-0.0725568682,
0.0424422026,
-0.0082970411,
-0.0100636994,
-0.0623740256,
0.0205110889,
0.0231456496,
0.0014108523,
0.0569230393,
-0.0056683635,
0.0147883296,
0.0045316191,
0.038789548,
0.0005532519,
-0.0325030722,
-0.0465964675,
-0.0046213996,
0.0381063372,
-0.0243850444,
-0.0192025062,
-0.0391465425,
-0.0030416688,
-0.0067421594,
-0.0141893988,
0.0235570874,
-0.0063365307,
-0.0792217106,
0.0930568948,
0.012919656,
0.0037478164,
-0.0225635488,
0.0051183873,
-0.0139303403,
-0.0371889062,
-0.0067036585,
-0.0237769987,
-0.0353786275,
-0.0055598281,
-0.0103398487,
-0.0384325571,
0.0199329853,
-0.0220135916,
-0.0539526753,
-0.0088999737,
-0.0058553736,
0.0534294806,
0.003962148,
0.0098319696,
-0.0085108532,
0.068165116,
-0.0692438781,
0.0889134556,
0.0052305982,
-0.0541871227,
-0.0104108201,
0.0128996326,
0.0276139081,
-0.0418138988,
0.0535588562,
0.0555576272,
-0.0046143355,
-0.0182768423,
0.038241569,
-0.0292759817,
-0.0229023602,
-0.0358006805,
0.0029157575,
-0.0605700947,
0.0640043989,
-0.0203088988,
-0.0219978988,
0.0174290072,
-0.0064241998,
0.0353429243,
-0.0047408217,
0.0805724561,
0.0467074439,
0.030002581,
0.0386467725,
0.0186537579,
-0.0008273037,
0.0687418208,
0.0320795961,
0.0024942961,
0.066626817,
0.0009543695,
0.0287645739,
0.035308674,
0.0175945051,
-0.0013555571,
-0.0163031351,
0.0312880948,
-0.0291672722,
0.0476585664,
0.0359567627,
0.0375429429,
-0.0203595031,
-0.0681479946,
0.0556392036,
-0.0081342701,
-0.0485554412,
-0.026829455,
-0.0223013107,
-0.015927216,
0.0320154317,
-0.0003532116,
-0.0162616652,
0.1133334115,
0.0181493871,
0.0203733519,
0.0689356327,
0.028882606,
-0.067042388,
-0.0084924027,
-0.0215623472,
0.014301802,
-0.0055581494,
0.0385265052,
-0.0120374719,
0.0253185425,
-0.0339448936,
0.0238964129,
-0.027372133,
-0.0193170421,
0.0185666252,
-0.0247871503,
0.0408547781,
-0.0346260667,
0.0374638848,
-0.0428723432,
-0.0082431128,
-0.0283680744,
0.0691897124,
0.0233713686,
0.0130430609,
-0.0364929363,
0.0416478403,
-0.0384728834,
-0.0495063961,
-0.0348734073,
-0.009328533,
-0.0017622366,
0.0013443015,
0.031194156,
-0.0136140455,
-0.0652700663,
0.0563548617,
-0.0081128618,
0.0302117337,
-0.0275724102,
0.0169187672,
0.0261644404,
0.0110233892,
0.0322599187,
-0.0279768165,
0.0192613769,
0.0094949976,
-0.0033585674,
0.0184696633,
-0.0070798839,
-0.0555928424,
-0.0133547392,
0.0348838903,
-0.1195607707,
-0.0003666983,
0.068902187,
-0.0353110135,
-0.0164580196,
0.0181605462,
-0.0148640675,
-0.0342589468,
-0.0244313702,
-0.0358411931,
0.0284708142,
0.0236729346,
0.0023457839,
0.0129393879,
0.0207567494,
-0.0111266207,
-0.0238322616,
-0.0221943781,
0.0462085307,
-0.0245582964,
-0.0046691382,
0.0357994437,
-0.0015009502,
0.0304628946,
0.0043560551,
-0.0437449999,
-0.0519129597,
-0.0019139395,
-0.099334307,
0.0099337511,
-0.0272693038,
-0.0330313258,
0.0243858416,
-0.0030321693,
-0.0055634533,
-0.0593973584,
-0.0665834174,
-0.0001340597,
0.0263100304,
0.0355031006,
-0.0229565296,
-0.0047059292,
0.0154595142,
-0.0090815416,
-0.0229976717,
-0.0096812956,
0.0352264196,
-0.0015131615,
0.0316654481,
0.0224184003,
-0.0597357415,
-0.0843588114,
0.0287630167,
-0.0048449161,
0.0018278108,
-0.0031659144,
-0.008530614,
0.013243271,
0.0416279621,
0.0043170373,
-0.0147115598,
0.0375851989,
0.0139988875,
-0.0152936503,
0.0262605175,
0.0176667552,
-0.0011891815,
-0.0041768779,
-0.0304417498,
-0.0226892736,
0.0001157641,
0.0315752923,
0.0121322442,
-0.0220327172,
0.0384607762,
0.014643413,
-0.0386572182,
-0.0772273466,
0.0028815381,
-0.0229627229,
0.0321272612,
-0.0292486735,
-0.0264995825,
0.0718109012,
-0.001474716,
-0.0027424176,
-0.0360211059,
0.0094887223,
-0.0343622863,
0.0633195415,
-0.0219505858,
0.0114792967,
-0.0099310158,
-0.006412738,
-0.0920404121,
-0.0378425159,
0.0376757421,
-0.0336313732,
0.0297204908,
-0.0218250118,
-0.0061777635,
-0.0323696472,
-0.0353016406,
-0.0119215641,
-0.0519645028,
-0.0313077457,
0.0042432155,
-0.0593150556,
0.0121100694,
-0.0214457922,
-0.0254617054,
0.0398374535,
-0.0145067377,
-0.0230046641,
0.0247981306,
0.0017410637,
0.0810167566,
0.0875553414,
0.0466298088,
-0.0135013741,
-0.0236866754,
0.0264269803,
0.0452671312,
0.043406114,
-0.0060470034,
-0.0111012263,
0.0108054178,
0.0226783566,
0.0426587425,
-0.0196825471,
0.0274430141,
0.0602828451,
0.0006856173,
0.0176523197,
0.0717753023,
0.0110570053,
-0.0235359836,
-0.0066410103,
0.0192834921,
0.0177390892,
0.039129287,
-0.0017713353,
-0.116400294,
-0.0606670082,
-0.0070863799,
0.0257181432,
0.049607154,
0.0204750281,
-0.0088347308,
-0.0756877959,
0.0422218889,
-0.0191140734,
-0.0448992588,
-0.043136742,
-0.017593069,
-0.0049411119,
-0.038766291,
0.0326595306,
-0.0159171298,
-0.0272925906,
0.0337996371,
0.0305075403,
0.0224566311,
-0.0194470268,
0.0368618518,
-0.0592355691,
0.0305357724,
0.04985952,
0.0367137305,
-0.0494101569,
-0.043082837,
-0.0032549163,
-0.0371876098,
-0.0162379052,
0.0338880569,
0.0643005297,
-0.0282585043,
-0.0226509813,
0.002473773,
0.0520749539,
0.0074435398,
-0.0254173577,
0.0307718012,
0.0616693161,
0.0061852885,
0.002571712,
-0.0671261549,
0.0146426437,
-0.0044588125,
0.0780955404,
0.034585923,
-0.0203899797,
-0.0019934275,
0.0186039805,
-0.0172172505,
-0.0400069728,
-0.0424939692,
0.0045013558,
0.0390327945,
0.0103478506,
-0.0415172875,
-0.0207091961,
0.0332611538,
0.0409458913,
-0.0388164446,
-0.0045130099,
-0.0516506508,
0.0286594555,
-0.0708760545,
0.0632884949,
0.0269327238,
0.0556749403,
-0.0298834592,
-0.0070214556,
-0.015166983,
-0.0680689365,
-0.0300067049,
0.0212519318,
-0.0666520223,
-0.020266274,
-0.0137827499,
0.0398617871,
0.0175928194,
0.0295404028,
0.0138970362,
-0.04900866,
0.0183247868,
0.0281376354,
0.0079758223,
0.02252011,
0.0099453041,
-0.0192325041,
-0.0053459802,
0.0111319227,
-0.0637014359,
-0.0026278915,
0.0021421211,
0.0373981632,
0.0173665956,
-0.0203864574,
0.0014459662,
-0.0291171838,
0.0390234925,
0.0056374501,
0.0181507505,
-0.0261805877,
0.0057787094,
0.0175830163,
0.0017377196,
-0.0355794951,
0.0151009429,
0.0227562822,
-0.0019576163,
-0.0487659238,
-0.001761766,
-0.0048246868,
-0.0176381916,
-0.0525436737,
0.0230654087,
0.0536998287,
-0.049015943,
-0.0335749649,
-0.0178175792,
0.0170986317,
0.0278599933,
0.024177989,
0.0430780686,
0.0412816443,
0.0491744354,
0.021124905,
-0.0326896384,
-0.0062733754,
0.0250659585,
-0.0623444803,
-0.0504068211,
-0.0062121688,
0.016299719,
0.0304685477,
-0.0209494568,
-0.0396752618,
0.0500609912,
-0.0251087975,
-0.001236186,
0.0115658036,
0.0067411405,
-0.0147646721,
0.0782705024,
0.0305609796,
0.0007644353,
0.0149887148,
0.0824974179,
-0.0117930397,
0.0228691678,
-0.0210565589,
0.0091247233,
0.0032063422,
-0.0049899393,
0.0062806928,
0.0124862604,
0.0051975078,
0.0310602821,
-0.0183211248,
-0.0719052032,
-0.0364934355,
-0.0025441903,
0.0051879808,
0.0035488545,
0.0332941264,
0.0476327948,
0.0297506023,
-0.0372637771,
0.0061507998,
-0.0110068033,
-0.0812440068,
-0.0146945091,
0.0265138522,
-5.331713237e-33,
-0.0070163039,
0.0120694367,
-0.015190349,
-0.0397166051,
-0.0171858631,
0.0226786844,
-0.0365323909,
0.0005265811,
-0.0479860231,
0.0099108601,
0.0374956951,
0.0349570736,
0.0042147981,
0.0267242808,
0.0149211744,
-0.0592514612,
0.0223007165,
-0.0303248707,
-0.0299701635,
0.0077948673,
0.0039890343,
0.0051080356,
0.0275604501,
-0.0545379929,
-0.0168416612,
0.0110822693,
-0.0098943766,
0.0076399827,
-0.0251096543,
0.1083313525,
-0.0069509521,
0.0383294635,
0.0045119431,
-0.0236880761,
-0.0039318483,
0.0360044912,
-0.074346222,
-0.0166595634,
0.0088141449,
0.0336206108,
-0.0602514893,
0.0110477582,
0.0221314281,
-0.0125544183,
-0.0244331211,
-0.0584879145,
0.0467379242,
-0.01946274,
0.014485714,
-0.0358351283,
0.0061025643,
-0.0160882976,
-0.0413614698,
-0.0477295294,
-0.0012708661,
0.0880595967,
0.0319116712,
0.0250168201,
-0.0296915751,
0.0222046375,
-0.0196674615,
-0.0000150437,
0.0820616037,
0.0179138016,
-0.0157550313,
0.05520292,
0.0494444408,
-0.0869013444,
-0.0586063527,
-0.0345059372,
-0.0298085827,
0.0436477922,
0.0411649942,
0.0613712184,
0.0425214805,
0.02249703,
-0.0309102107,
0.032566797,
-0.0287347771,
0.0398346186,
0.0028554329,
0.0061162449,
-0.0340605043,
-0.0030246454,
-0.0602232851,
-0.0231622495,
-0.0616925582,
-0.013734309,
0.0455094092,
-0.0036062764,
0.0187203102,
0.0396441557,
0.0491071194,
-0.0433802195,
-0.0002797803,
0.0493077785,
-0.0251292158,
0.0257452596,
0.0291111954,
0.0310763214,
-0.0280240215,
0.0767125487,
0.0986309946,
0.0073836823,
0.0153195309,
-0.0041510183,
-0.0158123616,
0.0433965102,
-0.0639004856,
-0.0174377877,
-0.0021680759,
-0.0087952586,
-0.0068251598,
0.0304761212,
0.0254619345,
0.0463785194,
-0.0434214696,
0.0167970695,
-0.0238786004,
0.0129081868,
-0.0317449868,
-0.0691270009,
-0.0443707258,
0.032769829,
-0.0106084058,
0.0143129081,
-0.0341660194,
-0.1003527567,
-0.0378664359,
-0.066139631,
-0.035505008,
0.0272617806,
2.365e-7,
0.0090263346,
-0.0240337607,
-0.015819842,
0.0016288607,
0.02532796,
0.0426525995,
-0.0320913009,
0.0276313256,
0.0114242909,
-0.0499507971,
-0.0080550313,
0.0547608025,
0.0492687151,
0.0386148095,
-0.0564873889,
0.0130785285,
-0.0739266798,
0.0266596992,
-0.071498625,
-0.0167530328,
0.0380906276,
0.1075165644,
0.0058309427,
-0.0246437974,
0.0268504657,
0.0062779989,
0.0262260325,
0.0152834179,
0.0059239217,
-0.0634632483,
0.0097407689,
-0.0193588696,
0.0146140577,
-0.0042500691,
-0.0338312201,
-0.0149277896,
0.0643124208,
0.0252479296,
-0.000747873,
-0.0870867819,
-0.0474366508,
0.0597600006,
0.0196649041,
-0.0277717505,
0.0952732116,
0.0285182018,
-0.0502513722,
-0.0448278598,
-0.0604598671,
0.0138170924,
0.0366893597,
0.0129712494,
-0.0234593395,
-0.0521265417,
0.0419633761,
-0.0143403104,
-0.0146372421,
-0.0877425596,
-0.0049530463,
0.0019856279,
-0.0309357345,
-0.0254015271,
0.010621028,
-0.0061569349,
-0.0025469668,
-0.0508638173,
-0.0442314856,
1.476780096e-34,
0.0292627085,
-0.0156840365,
0.0332500264,
-0.0228232257,
-0.0114507442,
-0.0229056217,
-0.0238733143,
-0.0559223071,
0.0232986696,
-0.0221791919,
-0.0186066888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06228v1 | Evolution of Natural Language Processing Technology: Not Just Language Processing Towards General Purpose AI | 2023-10-10T00:41:38 | 2023-10-10T00:41:38 | Masahiro Yamamoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Since the invention of computers, communication through natural language
(actual human language) has been a dream technology. However, natural language
is extremely difficult to mathematically formulate, making it difficult to
realize as an algorithm without considering programming. While there have been
numerous technological developments, one cannot say that any results allowing
free utilization have been achieved thus far. In the case of language learning
in humans, for instance when learning one's mother tongue or foreign language,
one must admit that this process is similar to the adage "practice makes
perfect" in principle, even though the learning method is significant up to a
point. Deep learning has played a central role in contemporary AI technology in
recent years. When applied to natural language processing (NLP), this produced
unprecedented results. Achievements exceeding the initial predictions have been
reported from the results of learning vast amounts of textual data using deep
learning. For instance, four arithmetic operations could be performed without
explicit learning, thereby enabling the explanation of complex images and the
generation of images from corresponding explanatory texts. It is an accurate
example of the learner embodying the concept of "practice makes perfect" by
using vast amounts of textual data. This report provides a technological
explanation of how cutting-edge NLP has made it possible to realize the
"practice makes perfect" principle. Additionally, examples of how this can be
applied to business are provided. We reported in June 2022 in Japanese on the
NLP movement from late 2021 to early 2022. We would like to summarize this as a
memorandum since this is just the initial movement leading to the current large
language models (LLMs). | [
0.0709727183,
0.0687498078,
-0.0359476693,
0.0406365916,
-0.0354430825,
0.0162955672,
0.0181531738,
0.0167193934,
-0.011082815,
-0.0417150259,
-0.0097330818,
-0.0336979814,
0.002403103,
0.065904133,
0.0215332173,
-0.0618305393,
0.0247948095,
-0.0192372501,
0.0151925106,
0.0068518319,
0.0032634162,
0.0238336883,
-0.0129373856,
0.0321696922,
-0.021237677,
-0.0197338313,
-0.0199072715,
-0.0749016702,
-0.0147918649,
0.0108570252,
0.0009510071,
-0.0014803506,
0.0538038202,
0.0635195524,
0.0000023474,
-0.0590982549,
-0.0104351565,
-0.008152714,
-0.0503895618,
0.0041536624,
0.0371565744,
-0.0055703432,
-0.018183222,
0.0083854133,
-0.0784839913,
0.0069480389,
0.0352292433,
0.0666723922,
0.0526523925,
0.075598076,
-0.0127624171,
-0.1077214777,
0.0641272143,
-0.0247372333,
-0.0197200738,
-0.0737324432,
0.0249480903,
-0.01853773,
-0.0227645487,
-0.0067817643,
-0.020970827,
0.0434802622,
0.0202572253,
-0.0119904829,
-0.0049419636,
0.0272923671,
0.0015645776,
-0.0094106849,
-0.0338538662,
0.0753024817,
-0.0246698633,
0.001201136,
0.0218606461,
-0.0192690976,
-0.010364715,
-0.0197470728,
-0.0466189682,
0.0436205044,
0.0230100397,
0.0339738578,
0.0185120348,
-0.0213788748,
0.0298148748,
0.0372251607,
-0.0241233986,
0.0602461509,
-0.0151496064,
-0.0486408398,
0.0163693652,
-0.0136713833,
0.0093008224,
-0.0431174897,
0.0109070819,
0.0528173372,
-0.0056205052,
0.036642354,
-0.0168107618,
-0.0470187441,
0.0037461121,
-0.0818820521,
0.016451152,
-0.0024693417,
-0.0049856668,
0.0337399244,
-0.0376606025,
0.050678581,
-0.0326608419,
-0.0297388621,
-0.0243004803,
-0.0047942083,
-0.0537623428,
-0.0418996103,
-0.0375392213,
0.0634670481,
-0.0556560978,
-0.0393807143,
-0.0433500223,
0.0300838947,
-0.0437150598,
0.0110030985,
-0.0189217497,
0.0335653871,
-0.0279023834,
-0.0173516665,
-0.0776790604,
0.0073971013,
1.56e-8,
0.0152862025,
-0.0168380328,
-0.0307914894,
0.0687119439,
0.0124161029,
0.0450423062,
0.015882181,
0.0375168622,
0.0900407061,
0.0124174124,
-0.0067652361,
-0.0838248134,
-0.0332059301,
-0.0098257083,
-0.0627452061,
0.0122555336,
-0.0593829155,
0.0238506272,
-0.0147439204,
-0.007161926,
-0.0466272198,
0.0153429573,
0.0168440267,
-0.0554918163,
0.0495000593,
-0.0280296728,
0.0263716504,
0.0390353277,
-0.0291401912,
0.0497774035,
0.0436119325,
0.0603564754,
0.0107715856,
0.055650562,
-0.0180838145,
0.0219731349,
0.041882284,
-0.0184680168,
-0.0444031209,
-0.0102711646,
-0.0206966866,
-0.0510135926,
0.0172768272,
-0.0095311692,
0.033868894,
-0.0108317239,
0.0270819589,
0.0665761828,
0.0588391535,
0.0270464178,
0.0832268596,
0.0474350862,
0.0077924081,
0.0082800183,
-0.0163290091,
-0.0122389467,
0.0045918198,
-0.027873585,
0.0119003672,
-0.0047571668,
-0.0178537406,
-0.0362681486,
-0.0642227754,
0.0052448576,
-0.0291446596,
0.0235739853,
0.0042212065,
0.0571895987,
-0.0159701221,
-0.040039286,
0.0371324159,
0.0222767126,
-0.0175262224,
-0.003566724,
-0.0539027788,
-0.006060347,
0.0770786479,
0.0225997716,
-0.0320880525,
0.0088634957,
-0.0260912254,
-0.0122299343,
0.0600226521,
0.0246511754,
0.0007607279,
-0.0204421114,
-0.0338035114,
0.013711147,
-0.0215503853,
-0.0125213703,
0.0165022109,
-0.0212730449,
0.0388201363,
0.004152128,
0.0291534085,
-0.0499474183,
0.0233010948,
-0.0310029592,
-0.0426987521,
-0.0033790178,
0.0377400629,
0.0279381815,
0.0636334643,
-0.0027756111,
0.0051736631,
0.028195532,
-0.0274161119,
-0.057417199,
0.0096378522,
-0.0405860841,
0.027323788,
0.0202341173,
-0.0584356748,
-0.0029974433,
0.0292579029,
-0.03896413,
-0.0289849844,
0.0192797258,
-0.033848878,
0.0373943038,
-0.0413421355,
0.0200579688,
-0.0403485075,
0.0224818327,
-0.0333777331,
0.0585178733,
0.0143149132,
0.0001577421,
-0.0173519515,
0.0015231702,
0.0152856344,
-0.0318659432,
-0.0423269384,
0.0376408212,
-0.0040173121,
0.0256037805,
0.0390031971,
0.0248833485,
-0.0181534924,
0.019914927,
-0.0719198436,
0.0037545995,
0.0036930107,
0.012186829,
-0.0109594064,
-0.0059823911,
-0.0002027394,
0.0047692657,
-0.0380791947,
0.0552150495,
0.0288064741,
0.0044135307,
0.0752595216,
0.0145842424,
-0.015930159,
-0.0460659228,
-0.0204684883,
-0.0191846322,
0.0261851382,
0.0530983098,
-0.0302459579,
-0.0695507377,
0.0491981097,
-0.0137967998,
0.0491026305,
0.0060772481,
-0.0406573266,
-0.0059000789,
-0.0342276022,
-0.0087174559,
0.0564690679,
0.0144133717,
0.0424311534,
0.022626115,
0.0112018231,
-0.0315555222,
0.0313916095,
-0.0307576694,
-0.0055152751,
-0.0583618581,
0.0072900509,
0.0130717177,
0.0418082178,
0.0058667311,
-0.0108076846,
-0.0138683496,
0.0322532579,
-0.0169781782,
-0.0299731791,
-0.0102565363,
-0.0216155779,
-0.0319596343,
0.0493403226,
-0.011219535,
-0.0412487835,
0.0399877802,
0.025425477,
-0.0021274928,
-0.0607281849,
-0.0452475622,
-0.043976523,
0.0872668847,
-0.0100938166,
0.039150551,
-0.0171978027,
-0.0526408628,
-0.0118985893,
-0.0001592837,
-0.015537492,
-0.0199017674,
0.061923638,
-0.0404497236,
0.0252541509,
-0.0002510292,
-0.0047324374,
-0.0627718791,
-0.0178328827,
-0.0349810086,
0.0152444514,
0.0557871163,
-0.0118637541,
-0.0319475494,
-0.0046927268,
0.0307756998,
0.0306036305,
0.0291987248,
-0.0054832599,
-0.0359178148,
0.0136808399,
0.0406100526,
-0.0209119916,
0.0209702794,
0.0277904533,
0.0201432724,
0.0421837009,
0.0316561796,
0.0251998156,
-0.0514022373,
0.0083125541,
0.0060757799,
-0.0627306774,
-0.0469070636,
0.0295387376,
-0.0055903764,
-0.0627180338,
0.0247655846,
0.1131778061,
0.0126272021,
-0.0143760582,
0.0190963261,
0.0268073417,
-0.062661089,
0.0222790893,
0.0246768296,
-0.0955385864,
-0.0077008684,
-0.0164453145,
-0.0314648934,
-0.0094864881,
-0.0532990545,
0.0128890947,
-0.1355060041,
0.0373396426,
-0.0319803134,
-0.0265398175,
-0.0445399731,
-0.0615494363,
-0.0300984699,
0.0054553547,
0.0436026081,
-0.0252610892,
-0.021865651,
-0.034448389,
0.0142288432,
-0.0754720569,
-0.0311097484,
0.027988771,
-0.0604874305,
0.007979312,
0.0789436698,
0.0905520469,
-0.0647595078,
-0.0156372506,
-0.0042749965,
0.0373190604,
0.0488480814,
0.0034749261,
0.05152601,
0.0161197614,
-0.0292699542,
-0.0176085327,
0.0161235146,
-0.0481291078,
0.0353982486,
0.0019223947,
0.0664615184,
0.0043434915,
-0.0189784635,
-0.0216735806,
-0.0209053922,
-0.0110138189,
0.04086674,
-0.0315751657,
-0.0756276622,
-0.0499753132,
-0.0177707206,
0.0073715253,
-0.0451743901,
-0.0450627692,
0.0023221953,
-0.0095623871,
-0.0174935926,
-0.0881754011,
-0.0485615395,
0.0353038125,
0.0160396472,
0.0423417762,
0.0080320407,
0.0417533442,
0.0092694312,
-0.0313782655,
-0.0206199698,
-0.0301872119,
0.0260612927,
-0.0369811282,
-0.0088711195,
0.0302409064,
-0.0097649703,
-0.0098679597,
-0.0001102514,
-0.057291124,
-0.065432407,
-0.0266439803,
0.0203655753,
0.0192214623,
0.0234919731,
0.0201771725,
-0.0605098195,
0.0336599648,
0.0529855229,
-0.0312844217,
-0.0083021866,
0.0315762348,
0.0034202659,
0.0128057497,
0.0250123069,
-0.0336661562,
-0.0037614834,
0.0099584889,
0.0083048465,
-0.0021098095,
-0.031631995,
0.0173620842,
0.033810921,
-0.000976561,
0.0083064148,
0.0008442528,
-0.0448226295,
-0.0078733787,
0.0137886405,
-0.013294911,
-0.0415818095,
-0.0159754157,
0.0253843348,
0.0124022337,
0.0148113081,
0.0358516276,
0.0066812462,
-0.013945872,
-0.0230536554,
0.0414638408,
0.0231356081,
0.0581655875,
0.0097242352,
0.0027838559,
-0.006758803,
0.0024385196,
-0.0081706289,
0.014362135,
0.0044847103,
0.0330048017,
-0.0142319314,
-0.0087722847,
-0.0516473837,
0.0028172305,
-0.0312947258,
-0.0962397456,
0.004565848,
0.0454449058,
0.0882363841,
-0.0342881009,
-0.0135260094,
-0.050277736,
0.0051592225,
0.0034116108,
0.0220685918,
-0.0241295509,
-0.0197788868,
-0.0327901877,
0.0173693616,
-0.0121767987,
0.0110933986,
0.0650007427,
0.0225036796,
0.0579568036,
-0.0038906375,
-0.0004936012,
-0.0258891992,
-0.0169430505,
0.0599763766,
0.0351754203,
-0.0102841929,
0.0056085321,
-0.0080694491,
-0.0673384517,
0.0148862787,
0.0014194058,
0.0289898738,
-0.0238983892,
0.0457829051,
0.0738237128,
0.0094172712,
0.013024928,
-0.0501117967,
0.0401201174,
-0.0028207735,
-0.0009322838,
-0.0347645134,
-6.498294402e-33,
0.0307960417,
-0.0226224288,
0.044669617,
0.0259290133,
-0.0127445059,
-0.0082416413,
-0.0010162387,
-0.0112475697,
-0.0388432629,
-0.0000147808,
-0.0391785949,
-0.0088405106,
0.012545743,
0.0290798023,
0.0311750397,
-0.005540133,
0.0353839546,
-0.0257734135,
0.0600776784,
0.0089523569,
0.0186024029,
0.0240140539,
0.0774543732,
-0.058541093,
0.032930281,
0.0137242163,
-0.0077762636,
0.0434690937,
0.0194155388,
0.046036683,
-0.0269671753,
0.0502015986,
0.0359165184,
-0.0805308819,
-0.0199251436,
0.0260074399,
-0.0523540601,
-0.016154604,
0.0060988902,
0.0196979754,
-0.0340920314,
-0.0154583538,
0.0781872123,
-0.0077904589,
0.0088949073,
0.0333062224,
0.0562232882,
-0.0323516764,
0.009786332,
-0.0172100347,
-0.0735163018,
-0.0023980506,
-0.041565042,
0.0243938193,
0.0362701975,
-0.0043700901,
-0.0242354404,
-0.0066193701,
-0.0932475999,
0.0502368025,
0.0265216157,
-0.0070082578,
0.0502667651,
-0.0046074637,
0.0146114277,
0.0353364088,
0.0587773658,
0.0078620212,
-0.0079672299,
-0.0049907104,
0.0435138792,
0.0975815058,
-0.0102156028,
0.0392680019,
0.0286016669,
-0.031342186,
-0.0690137297,
0.0086998735,
0.0133722378,
0.029004531,
0.0322887562,
0.0180877298,
-0.059027724,
-0.0271670185,
-0.0119536081,
0.0070474949,
-0.0222674683,
-0.0055209505,
0.0115945721,
0.0036278798,
-0.012001914,
0.0395860001,
0.0199942403,
-0.0998803899,
-0.0328378454,
0.0250324495,
0.003924429,
0.0390695594,
0.0007175086,
-0.0008532579,
-0.0682915077,
-0.0824908316,
-0.0805388093,
0.017002454,
0.0259130448,
0.0051422697,
0.0060619167,
0.0271798652,
-0.026525544,
-0.0048840982,
-0.0120726386,
-0.0205756743,
0.0525328517,
0.0270959083,
0.008736887,
-0.0029650391,
-0.0070913453,
0.0403428003,
0.0145557374,
-0.0047221128,
-0.0346872173,
-0.0222467873,
0.0078510847,
0.0046893796,
-0.0504910201,
-0.0269849859,
-0.0464520752,
0.015150032,
0.0583236702,
-0.0702268779,
-0.0273950808,
-0.0130323945,
3.029e-7,
0.0079250308,
0.0600925945,
0.0240422636,
0.0331738293,
0.0241224822,
0.0446790867,
0.0291860085,
0.002261119,
-0.0304407664,
0.0060729547,
0.0286046341,
0.0361950025,
-0.002184778,
-0.009973784,
-0.0868322477,
-0.0052565252,
-0.0240394622,
-0.0089078443,
-0.0836873353,
0.0164318085,
0.0288278628,
0.0822359174,
0.0406231321,
-0.048571635,
-0.0161035452,
-0.0389027521,
0.043836873,
-0.0009890485,
0.0288104825,
0.0402042456,
0.0270413309,
0.0549219698,
-0.0265189838,
0.0051101949,
-0.0112572126,
0.0473440662,
0.0241498519,
0.0639133155,
-0.0202505868,
0.0282788537,
0.0193535667,
-0.0359089263,
-0.0179806147,
-0.0312047619,
0.079053089,
-0.0578047335,
-0.0487911031,
-0.0481927581,
0.0058799135,
-0.0090713808,
-0.0307243038,
-0.0165093392,
0.0226013511,
0.0055749072,
0.0034340289,
-0.0456937812,
-0.0192259811,
-0.0534206256,
0.0283742398,
0.0269589592,
-0.0351502523,
-0.012019679,
-0.0253252015,
0.0010121942,
0.0663441643,
-0.0223869067,
0.0349664241,
2.474408032e-34,
-0.0002891183,
0.018465152,
0.0118072694,
0.0293701589,
0.034519624,
0.0183352772,
-0.0127505921,
0.0278828237,
-0.0048366543,
-0.0548410192,
-0.0514259413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06213v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06213v2 | GeoLLM: Extracting Geospatial Knowledge from Large Language Models | 2023-10-10T00:03:23 | 2024-02-24T16:11:57 | Rohin Manvi, Samar Khanna, Gengchen Mai, Marshall Burke, David Lobell, Stefano Ermon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The application of machine learning (ML) in a range of geospatial tasks is
increasingly common but often relies on globally available covariates such as
satellite imagery that can either be expensive or lack predictive power. Here
we explore the question of whether the vast amounts of knowledge found in
Internet language corpora, now compressed within large language models (LLMs),
can be leveraged for geospatial prediction tasks. We first demonstrate that
LLMs embed remarkable spatial information about locations, but naively querying
LLMs using geographic coordinates alone is ineffective in predicting key
indicators like population density. We then present GeoLLM, a novel method that
can effectively extract geospatial knowledge from LLMs with auxiliary map data
from OpenStreetMap. We demonstrate the utility of our approach across multiple
tasks of central interest to the international community, including the
measurement of population density and economic livelihoods. Across these tasks,
our method demonstrates a 70% improvement in performance (measured using
Pearson's $r^2$) relative to baselines that use nearest neighbors or use
information directly from the prompt, and performance equal to or exceeding
satellite-based benchmarks in the literature. With GeoLLM, we observe that
GPT-3.5 outperforms Llama 2 and RoBERTa by 19% and 51% respectively, suggesting
that the performance of our method scales well with the size of the model and
its pretraining dataset. Our experiments reveal that LLMs are remarkably
sample-efficient, rich in geospatial information, and robust across the globe.
Crucially, GeoLLM shows promise in mitigating the limitations of existing
geospatial covariates and complementing them well. Code is available on the
project website: https://rohinmanvi.github.io/GeoLLM | [
0.026579624,
0.0995584503,
-0.0190950464,
0.0009489798,
-0.0131061152,
0.0406257771,
0.0173937753,
-0.0137419282,
0.0321705043,
-0.0171466619,
0.0029545212,
-0.0108218854,
0.0418713801,
0.0045904969,
0.0450693294,
-0.0840755627,
0.002292562,
-0.0510142744,
-0.0028246818,
0.0014702164,
-0.0248459131,
0.0259681642,
0.0018791473,
0.0325185098,
-0.0088053988,
0.0304133426,
-0.010129082,
0.0007774621,
0.0010925607,
-0.0195171013,
0.021556437,
0.0047059101,
0.0153505942,
0.0001625257,
0.0000019702,
0.0123163965,
-0.0119561544,
0.017305851,
0.0338872224,
0.0210694484,
0.0223248973,
-0.049979154,
0.0101822913,
0.0200915746,
-0.0275997464,
-0.0317860618,
0.0478762574,
-0.0134391421,
0.0404280797,
0.0424260497,
-0.0076882369,
-0.0393864997,
0.0176213905,
0.0009186413,
-0.0046544783,
0.0290682167,
0.020805683,
-0.0065081134,
-0.015784204,
0.0612978525,
-0.0287255961,
0.0091070049,
-0.0100493077,
0.026290752,
-0.0359244011,
0.0571059138,
-0.0379452892,
0.0110127749,
0.0065823123,
0.0320806205,
-0.0205943454,
0.0068768249,
0.0522333868,
0.0328620896,
-0.0305649973,
0.0461436547,
-0.0582779497,
0.0115369335,
0.0066260691,
0.0638790727,
-0.0218756907,
-0.0019722451,
0.0350269526,
0.0396312885,
-0.0251512527,
0.1160333008,
-0.0003317253,
-0.0271057002,
-0.037914902,
0.0247606542,
-0.009258816,
-0.0163820721,
-0.010574651,
0.0270787571,
-0.0137495287,
0.0095766122,
0.0114807421,
0.0412677564,
0.0097693084,
-0.0499325618,
0.0257200189,
0.0107047567,
-0.02327336,
0.0614148565,
0.0118494285,
0.0245081149,
0.0202583037,
0.0379924923,
0.0076298788,
-0.0510763898,
-0.0297378357,
0.0080419006,
0.0077973525,
0.0066642156,
-0.0160480756,
0.0429046191,
-0.0292745661,
0.031193288,
-0.0014005584,
-0.0023783997,
-0.0489486642,
0.0208191052,
0.0121349432,
-0.0323165208,
-0.0296723787,
0.0196910277,
-0.000310592,
0.0140405139,
-0.0102579864,
-0.0171253867,
0.0291610453,
0.0238229819,
0.0376194902,
0.0074816556,
-0.0077051506,
0.0420684107,
0.0662978217,
0.0026448185,
-0.0586186163,
0.0128222546,
-0.0216334276,
-0.0298562665,
0.0169400163,
-0.0969249308,
-0.005034985,
0.0056737661,
-0.0298857223,
-0.0440993458,
-0.0133696683,
0.0243575703,
-0.0584978014,
0.0286420677,
-0.025019804,
0.0390783362,
0.0627781153,
-0.0270114616,
0.0280615482,
0.1053805873,
0.0124450075,
0.0620473847,
0.0672901571,
-0.0208647773,
0.0023759906,
0.0354821421,
0.0177107621,
0.0731368512,
-0.0346250646,
0.0049468148,
-0.0285073314,
-0.0266654696,
0.0367423892,
0.0189486556,
0.0100098345,
0.0158761088,
0.106294252,
0.0838518217,
-0.0247049928,
0.0047497954,
0.0350118242,
0.0795544684,
-0.051182732,
-0.0316985697,
-0.0559963025,
-0.0315816961,
-0.0433740057,
0.0190695077,
0.0306946225,
0.0529412515,
-0.023202138,
-0.0220571477,
-0.0173998252,
-0.0145749385,
0.0048423079,
0.0183986202,
0.0805606842,
-0.0558666438,
0.0199622288,
0.0627682135,
0.0558534376,
0.005368215,
0.0228865091,
0.0015245319,
0.0096431021,
-0.0218461771,
-0.0418053716,
-0.0006000778,
0.0200750344,
0.0055177761,
0.0329093374,
0.0183796939,
0.0068045836,
0.0181714166,
0.0099790385,
-0.0123294257,
-0.0419833511,
0.0415292047,
0.0249396022,
-0.0363735855,
0.0970485657,
0.0501392372,
0.0722647011,
-0.096504882,
0.0013434342,
0.0166475978,
-0.0046506412,
-0.0071309409,
-0.0178320818,
0.0280995704,
-0.008606704,
-0.014885691,
-0.0050239372,
-0.0106101204,
0.0194258709,
-0.0003047079,
-0.0219544712,
0.0057509942,
0.0112113114,
-0.0189200137,
0.0088044554,
-0.0078122201,
0.0168357231,
0.0370609872,
-0.0428111739,
-0.0068693683,
0.0279070456,
-0.030094292,
0.0829155967,
-0.0201280564,
0.0083149243,
-0.0010640009,
0.0343761668,
-0.0220466405,
0.026306048,
-0.0257669408,
0.0045106318,
-0.0041938559,
-0.0160206929,
0.0228972845,
0.0041557406,
-0.0030452327,
-0.0763226077,
-0.0127607062,
0.022928061,
-0.0074921376,
0.0119807888,
-0.032518886,
-0.0559287295,
-0.1113003567,
0.0130087137,
-0.0287234168,
0.0070584244,
0.0129218185,
-0.0340935141,
-0.0570914,
-0.0132726952,
-0.0090503255,
0.0024490061,
-0.002118503,
0.0192572884,
0.0115251113,
-0.0512838289,
0.0453527533,
0.0048653707,
-0.0127918785,
-0.0032702617,
0.0438117385,
-0.0189127438,
-0.0365808308,
-0.0004347495,
0.0207286291,
-0.0418795533,
0.0130289979,
-0.0151515715,
-0.0347718894,
-0.0223938785,
-0.0543609522,
-0.0070494954,
-0.0408754461,
0.0128206434,
-0.0210797936,
0.0282446165,
-0.049688492,
-0.0504946411,
0.003058075,
-0.0421772785,
-0.0304596256,
-0.0180233382,
-0.0501592495,
0.0054826261,
0.0338273942,
0.0003433142,
-0.0062853913,
0.0110137863,
-0.004334711,
-0.0575131662,
0.0227057487,
-0.0679198429,
0.0740469769,
0.0063138003,
0.0546291508,
-0.033406835,
-0.1142332479,
0.0027578864,
-0.0426796973,
0.0277532637,
0.0291204248,
-0.0279032104,
-0.0281760059,
0.0382096842,
0.0131170945,
-0.0046635438,
-0.0024152021,
-0.0004609122,
0.0007987362,
-0.0288043618,
-0.0382797495,
-0.0161934793,
-0.0090165017,
-0.0576353371,
0.0089893332,
0.0000234126,
-0.0400776528,
-0.0297276694,
-0.0425609201,
-0.0273980722,
-0.0098172436,
-0.0049930047,
-0.0632596314,
0.03308345,
0.0649283305,
0.0129463095,
0.013201125,
-0.0059605199,
-0.0150356032,
0.0038373442,
-0.0037078855,
0.0696468726,
0.0587551296,
-0.0134461895,
0.0111586228,
-0.0592588931,
-0.0020371284,
-0.034105178,
0.0283002891,
-0.0002248768,
0.027641166,
0.0217961352,
0.001556095,
-0.0250370596,
0.0306539312,
0.0436091572,
-0.0454230011,
-0.0037390287,
0.1216183007,
0.0251846816,
-0.01754722,
-0.0023752763,
-0.0194262471,
0.0337324739,
0.0419435725,
0.0390705317,
-0.0404985063,
0.0048590717,
-0.0062160026,
-0.0043792515,
0.0008815877,
-0.0346146934,
0.0010582079,
-0.1299909353,
0.0785957724,
-0.0095932912,
-0.0548598692,
-0.0435983166,
-0.0728203133,
-0.0292270966,
-0.0163365379,
-0.0549917072,
-0.0573650301,
-0.0218682941,
0.0340198949,
0.0307639278,
-0.1161806211,
-0.0235308763,
-0.0262619238,
-0.0879690945,
0.030593086,
0.0042516114,
0.0690396875,
-0.0347645096,
-0.0254243203,
-0.0242395308,
0.0369193964,
-0.001640534,
-0.0063735312,
0.0574876703,
0.0244302042,
-0.0382105,
-0.0025053141,
0.0141275376,
-0.0556503721,
-0.0099511594,
0.0505946986,
0.077268295,
-0.0098889219,
0.029346766,
-0.0113416277,
0.0326795951,
0.0307599194,
0.0004093858,
0.0017540697,
-0.0052785082,
-0.0202165544,
-0.0436014347,
-0.037754029,
-0.0063600093,
-0.0252997614,
0.0373617634,
-0.0126114897,
-0.0501632281,
-0.0307471976,
-0.0250477325,
0.0289271567,
0.023392966,
-0.0056737065,
0.0136589771,
0.0479520187,
-0.0265573785,
-0.064700909,
0.0526156984,
-0.0486743525,
-0.0005620869,
-0.0244703237,
-0.0196115151,
0.0188749954,
-0.006722609,
-0.007287187,
0.0064149438,
-0.1026599109,
-0.0395411663,
-0.0260438155,
0.0396795459,
0.0094349077,
-0.0056088571,
-0.0200625993,
-0.0118853543,
0.0847005546,
0.0329596326,
-0.0303539764,
0.0080302591,
-0.0023261337,
0.0241356902,
0.0272978544,
0.0071854549,
0.0030116118,
-0.0023673808,
0.0158204529,
-0.0458900146,
-0.0674102306,
0.0110081239,
-0.0263060741,
0.0129606873,
0.1537257135,
-0.0142460801,
-0.0111131473,
-0.026589198,
-0.0477162041,
0.0108328909,
0.0022667039,
-0.0197072774,
-0.0148090683,
0.0418637358,
0.0449369922,
-0.034726359,
0.0337122008,
0.0236491431,
-0.0481641591,
-0.0328436494,
-0.0313643031,
-0.0081787016,
0.012342127,
0.0050143888,
0.0419980064,
-0.0049649966,
-0.0239941496,
-0.0061328793,
0.0315126665,
-0.0083907302,
-0.0113983303,
-0.022128297,
0.0370536856,
0.0047337613,
0.0455581136,
-0.005757438,
-0.075608626,
-0.0191076193,
0.0448346883,
0.0620132051,
-0.036719881,
0.0008241425,
-0.0245758872,
-0.0131155318,
-0.0382951647,
0.0198440682,
-0.0054609347,
-0.0505060032,
0.0164738372,
-0.0256470516,
-0.064433977,
0.060951747,
0.0622198582,
0.0407121368,
0.0027661433,
0.0227057673,
-0.060133256,
-0.0027073144,
0.0208357479,
-0.0029001075,
0.0093949428,
-0.0277022887,
0.0111901741,
-0.0466977209,
-0.0826849863,
0.0072537069,
-0.0393365659,
-0.022073783,
0.0109542822,
0.0018669935,
0.0379125103,
-0.0471318662,
0.015608645,
-0.0995566398,
-0.0015181664,
-0.053575702,
-0.009008972,
0.0120771499,
-5.988876292e-33,
-0.0203504264,
-0.0788290352,
0.0572028719,
-0.0051195361,
-0.01941224,
0.0288232081,
-0.0132141337,
-0.0002445016,
-0.0268617682,
-0.0046191849,
-0.0133243175,
-0.0219453592,
0.0053387498,
0.0427762792,
0.0282675605,
0.0273361411,
-0.0277673602,
0.0126017584,
-0.0051865964,
0.0050733574,
0.0360153653,
-0.0034616624,
0.0597687997,
-0.0840786248,
-0.0203725733,
0.0162416529,
-0.0016023524,
0.0097448165,
0.0294125602,
0.0475669354,
-0.0213457178,
0.0705145895,
0.0312386472,
-0.0034103293,
-0.0438492261,
0.0209537093,
-0.0375153571,
-0.0299164895,
-0.0079354858,
0.002958246,
0.0057935854,
0.0000640509,
0.0271173418,
0.0204917323,
0.0277229846,
-0.0178450327,
0.0517384559,
-0.0092328563,
-0.062813431,
0.0154990256,
-0.0183976796,
0.0480238199,
-0.0078006377,
0.0087082256,
-0.016145952,
0.0503228903,
0.0144664664,
0.0446115173,
-0.0117634321,
0.0296116136,
0.0519879684,
0.048840493,
0.0141657041,
0.0361801796,
0.0222090073,
0.0795177445,
-0.0158333275,
-0.0545816943,
-0.0313813612,
-0.0356859341,
0.070447132,
0.0139592243,
0.0004190867,
0.0671169087,
0.0092041148,
-0.0354403518,
-0.0428955071,
0.0492626093,
-0.0132066831,
-0.0001311373,
-0.0056283576,
-0.0275941789,
-0.0099880435,
-0.0354026072,
-0.038604483,
-0.0688127428,
-0.0133594489,
-0.0151170734,
0.0243553612,
0.0081009194,
-0.0004312947,
0.051157888,
0.0208652336,
-0.0486634485,
-0.0304623004,
-0.0038372006,
-0.0153691769,
-0.0048328568,
-0.0052361409,
0.0291514322,
-0.0521662459,
-0.0486820079,
-0.0395768359,
0.0325692706,
-0.0111450795,
0.0300864335,
0.0072397585,
0.0460893326,
-0.0499920957,
0.0018029454,
-0.0333867557,
-0.0089203585,
-0.0220803395,
-0.0078530042,
0.011642525,
-0.0261090286,
0.0089144083,
0.0167362262,
0.0313491188,
0.0091595259,
0.0276680086,
-0.0224165078,
-0.0051411306,
-0.0081054056,
-0.0087831104,
-0.0258973204,
-0.0222633425,
-0.0136900488,
0.0081073791,
-0.0303215273,
-0.0065477029,
-0.0191247724,
2.696e-7,
0.0637149513,
0.0783966184,
-0.0063734655,
-0.0221981592,
-0.0069543105,
0.0144511182,
0.0063270833,
0.0130516784,
-0.0161672831,
0.0071326676,
0.0234031212,
0.033970423,
0.0741061419,
0.0398758426,
-0.1363036036,
0.0532970987,
-0.0559160411,
-0.0249681417,
-0.0759919509,
0.0052457582,
0.0153350579,
0.0917188451,
0.0453131273,
-0.0247134455,
0.0324545056,
-0.0247058626,
0.0494384915,
-0.0710376054,
-0.0319174305,
-0.0175065864,
0.0325149074,
0.0252285954,
0.0072905277,
-0.0240693111,
-0.034100119,
-0.0115414029,
0.0104487445,
0.0787188411,
0.0097498726,
0.0015000002,
-0.0013174508,
-0.0582646765,
-0.0143995276,
-0.1101194024,
0.0640650764,
-0.0201711748,
-0.0141856568,
-0.0218774751,
-0.0011373773,
0.0027143576,
0.0423186719,
-0.0169879198,
-0.014059687,
-0.0147041809,
0.0196922291,
-0.0225594305,
-0.0186254103,
-0.0433805063,
-0.0014926777,
0.0412082598,
-0.012339375,
-0.0402828194,
0.0044342647,
-0.0031899635,
0.0230128076,
0.0131053543,
0.0392570347,
2.258089521e-34,
-0.0065976791,
0.038857244,
-0.01106585,
-0.0276073515,
0.0261537489,
0.0246184636,
-0.0010117934,
0.0128778797,
-0.0276053082,
-0.0147816297,
0.0301867444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06204v1 | Estimating Numbers without Regression | 2023-10-09T23:07:05 | 2023-10-09T23:07:05 | Avijit Thawani, Jay Pujara, Ashwin Kalyan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite recent successes in language models, their ability to represent
numbers is insufficient. Humans conceptualize numbers based on their
magnitudes, effectively projecting them on a number line; whereas subword
tokenization fails to explicitly capture magnitude by splitting numbers into
arbitrary chunks. To alleviate this shortcoming, alternative approaches have
been proposed that modify numbers at various stages of the language modeling
pipeline. These methods change either the (1) notation in which numbers are
written (\eg scientific vs decimal), the (2) vocabulary used to represent
numbers or the entire (3) architecture of the underlying language model, to
directly regress to a desired number.
Previous work suggests that architectural change helps achieve
state-of-the-art on number estimation but we find an insightful ablation:
changing the model's vocabulary instead (\eg introduce a new token for numbers
in range 10-100) is a far better trade-off. In the context of masked number
prediction, a carefully designed tokenization scheme is both the simplest to
implement and sufficient, \ie with similar performance to the state-of-the-art
approach that requires making significant architectural changes. Finally, we
report similar trends on the downstream task of numerical fact estimation (for
Fermi Problems) and discuss reasons behind our findings. | [
-0.0138816275,
0.0873009712,
-0.031966161,
0.0428049713,
-0.0084325131,
-0.0264255386,
0.0309683718,
0.0298101176,
-0.0430454537,
0.0006089219,
0.0164651312,
-0.0624745637,
0.0113026649,
0.0701296255,
0.0451046526,
-0.0214194339,
0.0572691411,
-0.0635451749,
0.0585201941,
0.0084291361,
-0.051160451,
-0.0335218385,
0.0343009904,
0.0017851081,
-0.0374672376,
0.012966577,
0.034172006,
-0.0554428473,
-0.0173862297,
-0.0298343506,
-0.0475935489,
0.0250918623,
0.0438199341,
0.0910019428,
0.0000021693,
-0.0268450808,
-0.0030984592,
0.0235905666,
-0.0565932654,
0.0118813626,
0.0506188907,
-0.057596948,
-0.0140982885,
-0.0111483792,
-0.0184102245,
-0.0175518263,
0.0533771068,
0.0348897167,
0.0224831309,
0.0399710387,
0.0056328294,
-0.0419507883,
0.0410754271,
0.0076149837,
0.0026615532,
0.0126337465,
0.0176829267,
0.0134343943,
-0.0015777957,
0.0482527353,
-0.025292974,
0.0119896755,
0.0332016163,
0.0163095016,
0.008707718,
0.0229665656,
0.0008612456,
-0.0405607671,
-0.0005354411,
0.0299349632,
-0.0422134846,
-0.0273937024,
0.0065361545,
0.0091330474,
-0.0142389825,
-0.0423805863,
-0.0410391502,
-0.006182834,
0.0350377262,
-0.0047920751,
-0.0054847132,
0.00837122,
0.027975155,
-0.0305510294,
-0.0245477352,
0.0969697908,
0.0054434347,
0.0164106227,
-0.0367883332,
-0.0439521372,
-0.1272227466,
-0.0530047342,
0.011765454,
0.0011537091,
-0.0003964377,
0.0142997541,
-0.0491154678,
-0.0462258235,
-0.0203518029,
-0.05914272,
0.0223444235,
0.0631368309,
-0.0109236194,
0.0210208837,
-0.0079270685,
0.0632754341,
-0.0083600702,
-0.0293210316,
-0.0464387909,
0.0338217579,
0.0538007952,
-0.0325582288,
-0.0392689295,
0.0332024172,
-0.0389496572,
-0.0011512967,
-0.0504201688,
0.0230925102,
0.0081159202,
0.0376251936,
-0.0281752218,
-0.0388145447,
-0.0236809179,
-0.0372899696,
-0.0122072166,
-0.0084431972,
-0.0489067808,
0.0200565159,
-0.0176222082,
-0.0779260397,
-0.0105200568,
-0.0264245402,
-0.0196002144,
-0.0237300284,
0.0007366979,
0.0849297643,
0.0338221304,
0.0138371317,
0.0173338223,
-0.0474484377,
0.006089157,
-0.0070747132,
0.0158504248,
-0.0712211877,
-0.0237555224,
0.019595487,
-0.0003851675,
-0.0383952148,
0.0223779529,
-0.0014528494,
0.0272789057,
0.0677714944,
-0.0223763399,
-0.035685543,
0.0144484881,
-0.0108496463,
0.0170436781,
0.0486392863,
0.033218354,
0.0030086043,
0.0565164685,
-0.0470973887,
0.0102441693,
0.0147789419,
0.0265182834,
-0.0074929409,
-0.0507316478,
-0.0215542596,
0.0502820313,
0.0029196606,
0.0339054093,
0.055561807,
-0.0126092155,
-0.0515443459,
0.0614357591,
0.0436657593,
0.0099215955,
0.079552047,
-0.0082506463,
-0.0110799037,
0.0039406363,
0.0014171582,
-0.04479618,
0.0416114591,
-0.0076343324,
-0.0011256473,
0.0226569045,
0.0353474505,
-0.0224026442,
-0.064544566,
-0.0266292207,
-0.0017342062,
-0.0143581983,
-0.039093595,
0.0432606339,
-0.0240069367,
-0.0083958823,
0.0182663426,
0.0246795528,
-0.0101543609,
-0.0030549061,
-0.070144698,
0.0454137921,
0.0140286507,
0.0083355363,
-0.0505473614,
0.0560674705,
0.0067776092,
0.0162147824,
-0.000130202,
0.0372886695,
-0.0056093652,
0.0042633591,
-0.0479742289,
0.0361614004,
-0.025208883,
0.0329998359,
-0.0223493408,
-0.0284732468,
-0.0102071203,
0.0151403947,
-0.0502012596,
0.0064503481,
0.0222103037,
-0.0190558005,
-0.0730744749,
0.0011833605,
-0.0372476652,
-0.0146509064,
-0.0084946752,
0.0144530199,
0.0624681041,
0.0008743017,
-0.0122480821,
-0.0080856066,
-0.0282448065,
-0.0346412845,
0.0042451099,
0.0677998289,
-0.0123521173,
0.039886713,
0.0434652418,
-0.0020574511,
-0.0069890167,
0.0691320673,
-0.1023018062,
0.0445666946,
-0.0035839279,
0.0256261788,
0.0075849495,
0.0366593376,
-0.010053887,
0.0295335427,
-0.0131064756,
0.052155856,
-0.0048623304,
-0.0637696385,
0.0381235108,
-0.0204642415,
-0.0226266533,
-0.0190308541,
0.0191842392,
0.0186947845,
0.0254092105,
-0.0722928569,
-0.0057271286,
0.0189225208,
-0.0457833707,
-0.0461002514,
-0.0144882826,
0.0003606294,
0.0127609279,
-0.008442509,
0.0172462761,
-0.0379483476,
-0.0067149112,
-0.0081748767,
-0.0056401319,
0.0309749171,
0.0428805128,
0.0226641316,
-0.0527102649,
-0.0367933698,
-0.0679615065,
-0.0604871549,
0.0538274683,
0.0132494895,
-0.0085854763,
-0.0561450794,
0.0279333182,
-0.0523187853,
0.055737149,
-0.0409807079,
-0.0031073063,
0.0080608735,
-0.0265420415,
0.0555903912,
-0.0140087744,
-0.013035072,
0.0555272289,
0.0397097133,
-0.0161181428,
-0.015551772,
-0.032054875,
-0.0521372817,
-0.0079503795,
0.0229440834,
-0.0478188433,
-0.006646743,
0.0563328639,
-0.0074106464,
-0.0271558315,
-0.011158769,
0.0580743439,
-0.016273953,
-0.0430294313,
-0.0098579125,
0.0406601019,
0.0107327094,
0.0288220383,
-0.0151498178,
-0.0328774936,
0.0691414103,
0.0003602271,
-0.0135073299,
-0.0214578304,
-0.002374552,
-0.0075828158,
0.00833291,
0.0416745059,
-0.0103721758,
-0.0165852662,
0.0025107763,
-0.033355929,
0.0161897931,
0.0078006159,
-0.0401894823,
0.0498777926,
-0.0502386093,
-0.0054393378,
0.013932528,
-0.0467415936,
-0.0042520105,
-0.0529675633,
-0.0126408432,
0.0634134337,
0.0130198374,
-0.0231021903,
-0.0473932587,
0.019778274,
0.0879855156,
0.0491121486,
0.009535837,
-0.0123104714,
-0.0258711614,
-0.0026083908,
0.0394179672,
0.007483358,
0.0852650255,
-0.0573511384,
0.0330713987,
0.0114078652,
0.0469258353,
0.0365404077,
-0.028697636,
-0.0145346913,
0.0536109358,
-0.0220340341,
-0.0536865368,
0.0713179857,
0.0453387313,
-0.0365871824,
-0.0238577966,
0.1008467153,
0.0100787403,
0.0199426524,
0.0470413417,
-0.0370561779,
0.0038305488,
0.0247524716,
0.0063714534,
-0.0275961906,
0.0156287253,
0.0003159523,
-0.0058736918,
-0.0417244881,
-0.0353026018,
-0.0163393524,
-0.1049071252,
0.007768007,
0.0386153087,
-0.0224414784,
-0.0356588326,
-0.0728888288,
0.0137084359,
0.022399703,
0.0030791566,
0.0064016609,
-0.0079534538,
0.0094036954,
0.0206554793,
-0.0333071314,
-0.0207173862,
-0.0031361138,
0.0153764375,
0.0101113105,
0.0125665041,
0.0246838573,
-0.079553701,
-0.0180245973,
0.0359340832,
0.0281887334,
-0.0090064257,
0.0118947541,
0.0387369953,
0.0358560905,
-0.0278231055,
-0.0173861329,
0.0040793391,
-0.0107129198,
0.0040439754,
-0.0165170282,
0.0495831333,
-0.0227941852,
-0.0080847144,
0.0118809501,
-0.004843838,
-0.0067928797,
0.0323143005,
0.0294969268,
-0.0202043355,
0.0045710681,
-0.063052237,
0.0226516835,
0.035225451,
-0.0275488012,
-0.0631429777,
0.0143061699,
-0.063586235,
-0.049947165,
0.0323000923,
-0.0093449913,
0.0381255709,
0.0078264568,
-0.0340477042,
0.0466668867,
-0.0202954561,
-0.0267138854,
-0.0105378116,
-0.0394943878,
0.0548933521,
-0.0654412583,
0.0134034753,
0.0250962768,
-0.0391133502,
-0.0326248072,
0.0219442584,
-0.0687503442,
-0.0444497056,
0.063739337,
0.0508031212,
0.0342968106,
-0.0189112369,
0.0320740566,
-0.0703986958,
0.0382485352,
0.0527161025,
-0.0508922897,
0.0581677258,
0.001497823,
-0.0008997778,
0.0191399585,
0.0053706239,
0.0116499346,
0.0241488777,
0.0216234699,
0.016982913,
-0.0862699971,
-0.0095962109,
0.0298738591,
0.0583487414,
0.0516789369,
0.0247362219,
0.0043151765,
0.0024761814,
0.0166688114,
-0.0390124992,
-0.0013959535,
-0.0492871888,
-0.0053639812,
0.0237842984,
0.0702552497,
-0.0396569483,
-0.0110896705,
0.0349998586,
0.0273292456,
-0.0311115626,
0.0207001809,
0.0182670783,
0.0859457701,
0.0212417822,
-0.0338942856,
0.0086026909,
0.0233834274,
0.0036212278,
0.0718925595,
0.0080053331,
0.0055694431,
0.0112440567,
-0.0063846637,
-0.0580549613,
0.0351960585,
-0.0629594699,
-0.0692968965,
-0.0426299497,
0.0145914694,
-0.0280233566,
0.0337583199,
-0.0237881057,
-0.0578027256,
-0.0107964789,
-0.0399886705,
-0.0021624202,
0.0179552175,
-0.0063449955,
0.017662162,
0.0148088764,
-0.0281940587,
-0.0393741801,
0.0195345506,
0.0108718062,
0.0000714067,
-0.0011786922,
-0.0172396377,
0.008213033,
-0.0041991039,
-0.0164123736,
0.0237285718,
0.0003547783,
0.0209247656,
-0.06827306,
-0.0951078832,
0.0316501856,
0.0092371404,
-0.0007293942,
-0.037132252,
0.0527935401,
0.050894849,
-0.0248754993,
-0.0056634783,
-0.0184649657,
0.017233016,
-0.010071977,
-0.0012366659,
-0.047492981,
-5.977336611e-33,
-0.0360726789,
-0.0360766016,
-0.0075020152,
0.005707961,
0.0274063982,
0.0062419092,
-0.0231173728,
0.0360584185,
-0.0122046228,
-0.0056740087,
-0.0087116212,
0.0010485851,
0.0195599832,
-0.0287499446,
-0.0030537571,
-0.0125579499,
0.0660839006,
-0.0218838546,
-0.0304376353,
-0.0303501971,
0.0726213604,
0.0197158866,
0.0830788612,
-0.0399660133,
0.0128448196,
0.0306621566,
0.021260716,
0.015031551,
0.0213473216,
0.0216312837,
-0.0087708337,
0.070616588,
-0.0045782025,
-0.0717360303,
-0.0546348318,
0.0144165689,
0.0011437605,
-0.083509393,
0.0447119027,
0.0420123972,
0.0739324763,
-0.0164492279,
0.0152130323,
-0.0379820131,
-0.0625203103,
0.008582375,
0.0219993703,
-0.03419476,
-0.0156352371,
-0.0065500969,
-0.0182530843,
0.0039793737,
0.0485952944,
0.0380683765,
0.0565039888,
-0.0408871397,
-0.0188221782,
-0.0411380902,
-0.0492285825,
0.0439024493,
0.0332783014,
0.080688253,
0.0080414126,
0.0285377968,
-0.0003635745,
0.0255001821,
0.0900259018,
-0.0013923735,
-0.0510118604,
0.0312371925,
0.054849498,
0.0084428955,
0.0689434782,
0.025276104,
0.0911129788,
-0.0187565144,
-0.0573941469,
-0.0028493407,
0.0278396457,
-0.0146939801,
0.0266265273,
0.0105503798,
-0.0641384125,
-0.0163468551,
-0.0065027955,
0.0196808614,
-0.0398058519,
0.0033382198,
-0.0315387137,
-0.0348212793,
0.0143987685,
0.0275475234,
0.0169262234,
-0.0438616574,
-0.007544131,
-0.0234293509,
0.009174983,
0.0478053764,
-0.0050396565,
-0.0073676948,
-0.0649630651,
-0.0464759208,
-0.0153404055,
0.0110721439,
0.0246180855,
0.0147650028,
-0.0155075761,
0.046891585,
-0.0601693578,
-0.0189259965,
-0.0376010165,
-0.0629976615,
0.0512739345,
0.0171948727,
0.0081152236,
-0.0096988594,
0.0061319061,
-0.04314401,
-0.0021567191,
-0.0015830778,
-0.0163780637,
0.0911074728,
-0.0223485269,
0.0369928405,
-0.021196058,
-0.0758011639,
-0.0466804057,
0.0050163222,
0.0547405407,
-0.0399618633,
-0.0111845369,
0.0046573649,
2.947e-7,
-0.0141493576,
0.0265054666,
0.0028440107,
-0.0050171427,
0.0226928033,
0.0250134338,
0.019311389,
0.0292325504,
0.0209968705,
-0.0522732362,
-0.0007265681,
-0.0138788745,
-0.0307384729,
0.0642705113,
-0.0311908368,
-0.0238328613,
-0.0254805796,
0.0343190134,
-0.0393807441,
0.0056396658,
-0.0339484178,
0.1134022027,
0.0575042516,
0.0193344094,
0.0131608369,
-0.0361869372,
0.0403129682,
-0.0385577977,
-0.0054506366,
0.0340349078,
0.0215957835,
0.0317663662,
-0.0095208138,
0.0055138157,
-0.0041005947,
0.0475273542,
0.0522594601,
0.0490050875,
0.0232731719,
0.0287724305,
-0.0193333384,
-0.0059760441,
-0.0352162942,
-0.0131598683,
0.0264689457,
-0.0103911618,
-0.0601792932,
-0.0070701204,
-0.0079485215,
-0.018242944,
-0.0087265931,
-0.0208718814,
0.0023265237,
-0.0086003831,
0.0175392609,
0.0146397837,
0.0431224592,
-0.0224134214,
-0.0265283678,
-0.0094836662,
-0.0765154138,
-0.1101588085,
-0.049270153,
0.0074909809,
0.0103855794,
-0.0097189378,
0.0022633253,
3.075149701e-34,
0.04773698,
-0.0087653976,
0.0063660988,
0.0008160634,
-0.0024814149,
-0.0045996336,
-0.0064941607,
0.0342747159,
0.0623094924,
-0.0585689954,
-0.032366436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06202v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06202v3 | GPT-who: An Information Density-based Machine-Generated Text Detector | 2023-10-09T23:06:05 | 2024-04-03T18:59:10 | Saranya Venkatraman, Adaku Uchendu, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Uniform Information Density (UID) principle posits that humans prefer to
spread information evenly during language production. We examine if this UID
principle can help capture differences between Large Language Models
(LLMs)-generated and human-generated texts. We propose GPT-who, the first
psycholinguistically-inspired domain-agnostic statistical detector. This
detector employs UID-based features to model the unique statistical signature
of each LLM and human author for accurate detection. We evaluate our method
using 4 large-scale benchmark datasets and find that GPT-who outperforms
state-of-the-art detectors (both statistical- & non-statistical) such as GLTR,
GPTZero, DetectGPT, OpenAI detector, and ZeroGPT by over $20$% across domains.
In addition to better performance, it is computationally inexpensive and
utilizes an interpretable representation of text articles. We find that GPT-who
can distinguish texts generated by very sophisticated LLMs, even when the
overlying text is indiscernible. UID-based measures for all datasets and code
are available at https://github.com/saranya-venkatraman/gpt-who. | [
0.035031274,
0.0494205914,
-0.0246271081,
0.0495750345,
-0.0513927862,
0.02435093,
0.0034397759,
0.0632936209,
0.0148415184,
-0.0376712158,
-0.0284988508,
-0.0413998105,
0.0083148843,
0.0285396595,
0.0288277622,
-0.0270834994,
0.0225829612,
-0.0138687426,
0.0351182297,
0.0213256814,
0.0334302709,
0.0212131031,
0.008065016,
0.0168273505,
0.006985995,
-0.031316068,
0.0092737125,
0.0192939378,
0.0398014709,
-0.0213738531,
-0.0143492781,
0.0752703696,
0.0117648719,
0.0760039762,
0.0000021319,
-0.0363838896,
-0.0052368827,
-0.0193221234,
0.0121737644,
0.007037756,
0.0733207166,
-0.039003469,
-0.039139282,
0.0203929823,
-0.0161437336,
0.0051294463,
0.0345264636,
0.0818783566,
-0.0212647393,
0.0946995392,
-0.0381298363,
0.0079099489,
0.0656504035,
0.0157304183,
0.0085930992,
-0.0120321689,
0.0200723279,
-0.0177797526,
-0.039158538,
0.0086183446,
0.0124301827,
0.0185648222,
0.0110293915,
0.0021692647,
-0.0329785198,
0.0262759626,
-0.0218657348,
0.0175916571,
-0.0292170364,
0.0467325635,
-0.0194053948,
-0.0531409644,
0.0402832441,
-0.0233601909,
-0.0015701526,
-0.0074477391,
0.0158560965,
0.033348076,
-0.0431795232,
0.0260792561,
0.0284463745,
0.0342900008,
0.0134632634,
0.0199866146,
-0.0019788817,
0.0426731482,
0.0201245584,
-0.033250533,
0.0131373033,
0.0201463941,
-0.032790672,
-0.0420707203,
0.0434547961,
-0.0059111528,
0.0059729004,
-0.0206452813,
-0.0779636875,
-0.0455034003,
0.0196861383,
-0.0313667282,
-0.0066108541,
-0.0004303649,
-0.0394294634,
0.0158706084,
-0.0118529135,
0.0813439265,
-0.0320437253,
0.0086886873,
0.0081457011,
0.0058240881,
-0.0218217243,
-0.0209777746,
0.0034579549,
0.011584172,
0.0096276347,
-0.0213076081,
-0.0404095687,
0.0369560197,
0.0231823232,
-0.0421663709,
-0.0111093698,
-0.0324405506,
-0.0227721557,
-0.0052413214,
0.0293460544,
-0.004956306,
-0.01371729,
0.0062541058,
-0.0270910207,
-0.0376673155,
-0.0082429983,
0.0994839221,
0.0228956304,
-0.0013745147,
0.0071134232,
0.0286868643,
-0.0121997502,
-0.0751146451,
-0.0436437428,
-0.0309752319,
-0.0230352934,
-0.0451614559,
-0.0261735171,
-0.0693823397,
-0.0127939982,
-0.0076889959,
-0.0123294098,
-0.0853251591,
-0.0206145905,
0.0368135013,
-0.0138747115,
0.0308563057,
-0.0412863828,
0.0207664166,
0.0279497094,
-0.0010990114,
0.0248508286,
0.0780325979,
0.0323745273,
0.0261751022,
0.0539679863,
0.0046936888,
0.041205924,
0.0589967407,
-0.0176287685,
0.0447987542,
0.0080407122,
-0.0605602786,
-0.040097367,
-0.0058772061,
0.0507324338,
0.0532357767,
-0.0107875848,
-0.0200499259,
0.078284964,
0.0831761062,
-0.0468625128,
0.0088368151,
0.0552315898,
0.0905617028,
-0.0058372896,
0.0548123978,
0.0101665836,
-0.0123406993,
-0.0644411594,
-0.0099822432,
0.0235663112,
0.0132375956,
0.0021521179,
-0.006262905,
-0.012447604,
-0.0167995971,
-0.0170086157,
-0.0277209114,
0.038155809,
-0.0069560464,
-0.024578996,
0.0025229915,
0.0068068933,
-0.0534186177,
-0.0025584234,
-0.0481690243,
0.0458229445,
0.0537733696,
0.0477018505,
-0.003214956,
0.0790840089,
-0.0178258382,
-0.0065179723,
0.087794967,
-0.0120045701,
0.0201527514,
0.0151614305,
-0.0357953459,
-0.0075003058,
0.0378172286,
0.0205033366,
0.0254381206,
0.046930097,
0.0533089004,
0.0251928642,
-0.0456810705,
-0.0194213521,
0.0438623913,
-0.027016703,
-0.0196298379,
0.0056509003,
-0.0145355109,
0.032270249,
0.0176683236,
-0.0421556644,
-0.0106900176,
-0.0107209813,
-0.0491719767,
-0.0200731717,
-0.0053423853,
0.0080301696,
0.0064300573,
-0.0061512012,
-0.0092475973,
-0.0169987101,
0.0193606317,
-0.0059614358,
-0.022757696,
-0.004711431,
-0.0353603363,
0.0145892976,
-0.0655164346,
0.0085609527,
-0.0168369487,
0.0531270057,
-0.032970652,
0.0713685751,
-0.0060114372,
-0.0075532529,
0.0218969602,
0.0004116144,
0.0541308597,
-0.0518092699,
0.0100224167,
-0.006530562,
-0.0227939952,
0.0218625776,
0.027866248,
0.0216902923,
0.0007483796,
-0.0414038077,
-0.1014596596,
0.0169951655,
-0.0356353968,
0.0112437801,
0.0580241084,
-0.0078885537,
-0.0419340879,
0.0181011707,
-0.0273757782,
-0.0232259706,
0.0280881245,
-0.0083956327,
0.0253652111,
-0.0450897552,
0.0129741738,
-0.0192156732,
0.0184817091,
-0.0388687104,
0.0117917247,
0.0370978974,
-0.0674193874,
-0.0856856704,
0.0570356511,
0.0023246878,
0.0017015282,
0.0125499265,
-0.039583493,
0.0003655359,
-0.0200894214,
0.0624100864,
0.0610652342,
0.0322892368,
0.0191587526,
0.0191192366,
0.0058045113,
-0.0298607666,
-0.0171021782,
0.007364064,
0.0264575779,
-0.0115472032,
-0.0622366667,
0.0833055303,
0.0579948686,
0.0525485277,
-0.0009354132,
-0.0267944131,
0.001729961,
-0.0330773853,
-0.0403793193,
0.0040643574,
-0.0257782806,
-0.0381153859,
0.0321728513,
-0.0139368847,
-0.0510118604,
0.051301185,
-0.0536157936,
0.0302828141,
-0.0618396215,
-0.0382732861,
-0.0370600224,
0.0162914824,
0.0226210728,
0.028967673,
0.0165764224,
-0.0378052481,
-0.0242407732,
0.0166792348,
0.0177951083,
-0.0038057507,
-0.0019286238,
-0.0450147614,
0.0006681384,
0.0016674356,
-0.0249526538,
-0.0247200392,
-0.0754901916,
-0.0224128235,
-0.0341526754,
0.0444978476,
-0.0833361372,
0.0105153127,
-0.008398856,
0.0312390681,
0.0401638038,
-0.0174330492,
-0.0149124833,
-0.0297788884,
0.0472094268,
0.0619348511,
-0.0393038802,
0.0322447121,
-0.037938524,
0.0032052461,
0.0594356842,
-0.0124376733,
0.0277942494,
-0.0006836854,
-0.0127908299,
0.0153241605,
0.0031805404,
-0.0330301113,
0.0322935842,
0.0615834817,
-0.021543052,
0.0190284438,
0.1352672577,
0.0142133851,
-0.0923247859,
-0.032233648,
-0.016767364,
0.0641980693,
-0.0149019966,
0.0076443739,
-0.0758868679,
-0.0488791801,
0.0080545954,
0.0022445377,
-0.0617941208,
-0.0113400193,
-0.0157830399,
-0.0402703993,
0.0340430364,
0.0037099328,
-0.0319271386,
-0.0066035073,
-0.0077472455,
-0.0077012042,
0.0165432487,
-0.0245065968,
-0.0229689479,
-0.0142940292,
0.0062495428,
-0.0125658689,
-0.0653232858,
-0.0592947192,
-0.0011135176,
-0.044798281,
0.0097648446,
0.0906770006,
0.0485940129,
-0.035280101,
-0.0408665799,
0.0005252409,
-0.0116917379,
-0.0267436467,
0.0017140238,
0.1118747517,
-0.0183846615,
0.003020843,
-0.0680942088,
0.0434099697,
-0.0350703783,
-0.0163030401,
0.0389501899,
0.0223772097,
-0.0197202414,
-0.0497944541,
-0.0065505109,
0.0052734055,
0.0087705571,
0.0987848863,
0.0194334835,
-0.067107074,
-0.0439133681,
-0.0100272512,
0.0585166626,
-0.0467770919,
-0.0681481734,
-0.014761324,
-0.0095751882,
-0.0753051788,
-0.0939232707,
-0.0330084525,
-0.0184237547,
-0.0049863821,
0.0392300002,
0.0325001255,
-0.0132324118,
-0.0201035812,
-0.0333606862,
-0.0398275927,
-0.0460303463,
0.0020006031,
-0.0993178487,
0.0208970048,
0.0209396929,
-0.0341414735,
0.0100441137,
0.0608607717,
-0.0567855947,
-0.0503006987,
-0.0156838875,
-0.0398192629,
0.0187372323,
0.0112546813,
-0.0293853413,
-0.0679211691,
0.0603276566,
0.0226573665,
-0.0191376898,
0.0415710211,
-0.0085099172,
-0.0367405415,
-0.0046293228,
0.0154371867,
-0.0087026609,
0.025821995,
0.009401137,
-0.0372032113,
-0.0438248254,
-0.0214215964,
0.0201719441,
0.0274294112,
0.0346839465,
-0.0194864664,
0.0310374796,
-0.0402715206,
-0.0363221504,
0.0020112244,
0.0187073648,
-0.0483155586,
0.005348437,
0.0415949076,
-0.0155976461,
-0.0388515703,
0.0422306135,
-0.0143966787,
0.006839165,
-0.0215096902,
-0.0060544573,
-0.0231072083,
0.0691647008,
0.0026180719,
-0.0066366298,
0.0094022518,
0.0250497721,
-0.0121431332,
0.0456711426,
0.0129982382,
0.078744404,
0.0086875698,
-0.0457587466,
0.0432717018,
0.0318025649,
-0.0576153547,
-0.0190338008,
-0.0174321141,
0.0279032346,
0.0462460369,
0.0228134356,
0.0744649619,
-0.0431206636,
0.0136189442,
-0.0326157585,
0.0390654951,
-0.014644932,
-0.0013282353,
-0.0250162687,
0.002506369,
-0.0537600927,
0.004477792,
0.1110557169,
0.0335532017,
-0.0076417858,
0.0061171446,
-0.0565233566,
-0.0225040559,
0.0037928238,
0.0146275964,
0.005138969,
-0.0015243611,
0.0407018922,
-0.0461834185,
-0.0372156985,
0.0117230676,
-0.0145632587,
0.0237019863,
-0.0193647724,
-0.0054532094,
0.0600018762,
-0.0522324555,
-0.0245179404,
-0.0454630367,
0.0014851915,
-0.0316513926,
-0.037457522,
-0.0253145117,
-6.454266261e-33,
-0.0144459298,
-0.0414653979,
-0.0289470535,
0.0262935814,
0.0175541826,
0.0182405617,
-0.0215405263,
0.0051907739,
0.0148546817,
0.038683556,
-0.0090592541,
0.0402763076,
0.0129196793,
0.0130789066,
-0.0168215577,
0.0066736066,
0.0324074887,
-0.0160697922,
-0.0309108961,
0.0300654341,
0.0507243574,
-0.0115786055,
0.0579597168,
-0.0937119275,
0.0091632893,
-0.0216807555,
-0.014949142,
-0.0176746603,
-0.0108655691,
0.0247715171,
-0.0323848836,
0.0417840444,
0.0294911955,
0.0247464441,
-0.0248495787,
0.0474266186,
-0.0396488793,
-0.0277912878,
-0.0016821882,
0.0155937737,
-0.0067680855,
-0.0625756606,
0.027565483,
-0.049671907,
-0.008506475,
0.0183302294,
0.0650918111,
-0.0091147255,
0.0203450099,
-0.0434131883,
-0.0612991191,
0.054516267,
-0.0016239701,
0.0376246534,
0.0350887738,
0.0306800101,
-0.0131978802,
0.0061510364,
-0.0745419562,
0.0144081116,
0.0064629614,
0.0268245693,
-0.0014095502,
0.0029460669,
-0.0170494057,
0.0641948208,
0.0302002542,
-0.0098700961,
0.0063028433,
-0.0333020091,
0.0187995005,
-0.0092658419,
0.0523449257,
0.0884635672,
0.0231214501,
-0.0287169293,
-0.0303282086,
0.0392248482,
0.0087542329,
-0.041651044,
0.0428357273,
-0.0087453788,
-0.0938613489,
-0.0282333326,
0.018136967,
-0.052485887,
-0.0281957295,
-0.0357217528,
0.0570219569,
-0.0093679707,
-0.0125376554,
-0.0288139898,
0.0358831771,
-0.0421001539,
-0.0007842055,
0.0185047612,
-0.0463516228,
0.04107669,
0.0211917441,
0.0039525582,
-0.0257905908,
-0.0151042407,
0.0159634873,
0.0360722281,
0.028922081,
-0.0040528025,
0.0397414602,
0.0314868577,
-0.0491466448,
0.0088197663,
0.0078157978,
0.0249674283,
0.0017895784,
0.0044825682,
-0.0111099835,
-0.0134430919,
-0.0063109924,
-0.0056465343,
0.0437443852,
-0.0211862996,
-0.0418357253,
-0.013316337,
-0.0509296544,
0.0360915326,
-0.0468343236,
-0.006406182,
-0.0110160718,
-0.011839292,
0.0515484177,
-0.0515549816,
0.0208330117,
-0.0110070184,
2.765e-7,
0.0187715217,
0.028248908,
0.0337981395,
-0.0190248191,
0.0060267826,
0.0449109487,
0.032121323,
0.0273232162,
0.0046349163,
-0.0191971138,
-0.0109574031,
0.0210208129,
0.0647279769,
-0.0058397949,
-0.1128938645,
0.0257713161,
-0.0262449495,
0.0183439814,
-0.0739151761,
0.0056376378,
0.0600045137,
0.0427482389,
0.0271127727,
-0.0217108987,
0.0288338847,
-0.0583975054,
0.0585379228,
-0.0304551627,
0.0285409447,
0.0378602445,
0.0563422143,
-0.005235963,
0.0130190151,
0.04081342,
-0.0283434037,
-0.0007629981,
0.0068742512,
0.0629202127,
0.0082537234,
0.016275296,
-0.0010734878,
-0.012492273,
-0.0061192978,
-0.0466394238,
0.0687345117,
0.0169422161,
-0.0453714579,
0.0053679855,
-0.0062689758,
-0.0781399831,
0.0095368279,
-0.0191697478,
-0.0178919509,
0.0213993397,
0.0081601404,
-0.0138713764,
-0.0186210405,
-0.0341908,
-0.0131480126,
-0.0177391563,
-0.0279841479,
0.0213933792,
-0.0646627098,
-0.0082978206,
0.0244471598,
-0.0705667809,
0.0443158261,
2.86512789e-34,
0.0202277415,
-0.0012550765,
0.0126502048,
0.008470091,
0.0484914817,
0.0345957279,
-0.005710932,
0.0193478782,
-0.0076294052,
-0.0420584269,
0.042428676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06201v1 | Compressing Context to Enhance Inference Efficiency of Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T23:03:24 | 2023-10-09T23:03:24 | Yucheng Li, Bo Dong, Chenghua Lin, Frank Guerin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) achieved remarkable performance across various
tasks. However, they face challenges in managing long documents and extended
conversations, due to significantly increased computational requirements, both
in memory and inference time, and potential context truncation when the input
exceeds the LLM's fixed context length. This paper proposes a method called
Selective Context that enhances the inference efficiency of LLMs by identifying
and pruning redundancy in the input context to make the input more compact. We
test our approach using common data sources requiring long context processing:
arXiv papers, news articles, and long conversations, on tasks of summarisation,
question answering, and response generation. Experimental results show that
Selective Context significantly reduces memory cost and decreases generation
latency while maintaining comparable performance compared to that achieved when
full context is used. Specifically, we achieve a 50\% reduction in context
cost, resulting in a 36\% reduction in inference memory usage and a 32\%
reduction in inference time, while observing only a minor drop of .023 in
BERTscore and .038 in faithfulness on four downstream applications, indicating
that our method strikes a good balance between efficiency and performance. | [
0.0300059263,
0.0671860129,
0.0088254986,
0.0533358119,
-0.0419689678,
-0.0053631337,
0.0116855465,
0.0042768219,
-0.0182767212,
-0.0450013317,
-0.0151967015,
-0.0335296914,
0.006612082,
-0.020695826,
-0.0033954899,
-0.0459515825,
0.0448033661,
-0.0486541055,
0.0062163062,
-0.023572607,
-0.004140215,
0.0023407126,
0.0373424999,
0.0217674822,
0.0239396635,
-0.0115986578,
-0.0198180396,
-0.0003443051,
-0.0074637327,
-0.0036763269,
0.0011735519,
0.0517898127,
0.0284837522,
0.0389964841,
0.0000019567,
-0.0561999902,
-0.020230636,
0.0032230695,
-0.0107105672,
0.0521473251,
0.0352112986,
-0.0300785303,
0.0077823941,
0.0313149802,
-0.0035147441,
0.0125464331,
0.0327239037,
0.0189900901,
0.0353457294,
0.0558617786,
-0.0123286443,
-0.0377533957,
0.0210513398,
-0.0267601367,
0.022558447,
-0.072180137,
0.0272634551,
0.0097644655,
0.024815375,
0.0268429164,
0.0049825972,
0.046718955,
0.0302380174,
-0.0007976393,
-0.0291256923,
0.0518691577,
-0.0559098199,
-0.0016871438,
0.0151856318,
0.0394497067,
0.016624311,
-0.0205825083,
0.0321624279,
0.0139767434,
-0.0181695353,
0.0113581354,
-0.06551902,
0.0394877344,
-0.0310848691,
0.0101959435,
0.0413292721,
-0.0003488655,
0.015455028,
0.04029328,
-0.0652484298,
0.0368722752,
0.0441935882,
-0.0182680432,
-0.0504701771,
-0.0032652318,
-0.0550312623,
-0.0674882904,
0.0062045194,
0.0425081253,
-0.0245250873,
0.0267662629,
-0.0918047503,
-0.0371402986,
0.0543006025,
-0.0583435856,
-0.0279966183,
0.0483173765,
0.0023055519,
0.0717011094,
-0.008826944,
0.0241510477,
-0.0429876745,
-0.0540555604,
-0.0458428487,
-0.0466826558,
-0.0040302319,
-0.0047087939,
-0.0449565314,
0.0395682752,
-0.0518649183,
-0.0597340167,
-0.0327479467,
0.0616927892,
0.0247194655,
-0.0119530717,
0.001320673,
-0.0064405901,
-0.0354040861,
0.0080899457,
0.0131879244,
0.0345556736,
-0.0440455861,
-0.0006690183,
-0.0065604053,
-0.0567438267,
-0.0128300823,
0.0212168489,
0.0155757228,
-0.0518315062,
-0.00464326,
0.0444854498,
0.0087760333,
-0.0347899161,
-0.017604718,
-0.0344909243,
-0.0150622725,
-0.0680121481,
-0.0105896723,
-0.0737276524,
0.0329979956,
0.0466381162,
-0.0260339249,
-0.0053998986,
-0.0099267922,
0.0350012854,
-0.0538182147,
0.042123802,
0.0071261441,
0.0094920481,
0.0429613255,
0.0085080862,
0.0248679221,
0.0839206725,
0.0146762067,
0.007351961,
0.0358990803,
0.00617105,
-0.032701809,
0.0352040902,
0.0454356931,
0.0159285367,
-0.0216461122,
0.026417993,
-0.010339682,
0.0044826707,
0.0384593904,
0.0756577849,
-0.0402977541,
-0.0080821617,
0.0365597643,
0.0539184362,
0.0195628684,
0.0073148841,
0.0193536133,
0.0162493438,
0.0091792187,
0.0298804343,
-0.0430702716,
0.0218313616,
-0.0336171091,
0.0439229384,
0.087782234,
0.0136752967,
-0.0355762281,
0.0058488054,
-0.0443452336,
-0.0004899896,
0.0002577016,
0.0139831528,
0.0465123169,
-0.0192177184,
-0.0298786964,
0.0779410377,
0.0287633352,
-0.0563376136,
-0.0288774576,
-0.0344675705,
0.0415062532,
0.0482881069,
0.0482268222,
-0.0351275019,
-0.0209290162,
0.0246066507,
0.0313130654,
0.0319817513,
0.0455293581,
-0.0043656221,
0.0073581371,
-0.0480026454,
-0.0081459042,
-0.0035300106,
0.0115901409,
-0.0009691147,
0.0734491125,
0.0063232104,
0.0396764316,
-0.0213529244,
0.0195546523,
0.0226329044,
-0.0610099249,
-0.0143377576,
-0.0123883635,
-0.0187632069,
0.0477524102,
-0.0022706208,
-0.0036550444,
0.0251240879,
0.0507557429,
-0.0317766219,
0.0011372134,
0.0084896414,
-0.0801453516,
-0.0409151018,
0.0296705123,
0.0035095329,
0.011521739,
-0.0103251813,
-0.017060481,
-0.040959809,
0.0138735892,
-0.0513160862,
0.0670231059,
-0.0365115739,
0.0125996601,
0.0029115763,
0.01631191,
-0.0220003463,
0.0749183074,
-0.018002836,
0.0241940562,
0.0791953355,
0.0301837754,
-0.0021268944,
-0.0438665152,
-0.029558843,
0.005298953,
0.0132084629,
-0.0096830036,
0.0402318873,
-0.0081965048,
-0.0066679618,
-0.0234106947,
-0.1228502989,
0.0261726808,
-0.0199475642,
0.0215856675,
0.0316365473,
0.0547807887,
0.0067841443,
0.0091002649,
-0.0200426169,
-0.0128077073,
0.0240832549,
0.044778686,
0.0171024036,
0.0085310666,
-0.0080036679,
-0.0436780341,
-0.0329899527,
-0.0110658957,
0.070218645,
-0.006920828,
-0.0446531959,
-0.0331124365,
0.0570748597,
-0.011248542,
0.0325896852,
-0.0244059209,
0.000570524,
-0.0126115028,
-0.047870528,
0.0682196841,
0.0448239148,
0.0245849602,
0.0235793777,
0.0244320184,
-0.0023895367,
-0.0449508056,
0.0063622436,
-0.0223845989,
-0.0090396609,
-0.0137378937,
-0.017865343,
-0.0026769836,
0.0610650964,
-0.0162458476,
0.0010895543,
-0.0233869758,
-0.0045825816,
0.0090720681,
0.0064958627,
-0.0128771886,
-0.0296885837,
0.0005669513,
0.0422303602,
-0.0084070973,
-0.0279256999,
0.0602481663,
-0.0545138083,
0.0182516631,
-0.0491130985,
-0.003652208,
-0.0531138517,
0.0649441779,
-0.0137927178,
0.022010535,
-0.0258564856,
-0.0003825267,
-0.0381952859,
0.0030854403,
-0.0035278383,
-0.0332966,
0.05731114,
-0.0609801039,
0.0584685914,
-0.0364063345,
-0.0330380276,
-0.0338091142,
-0.0192597285,
-0.0217885077,
0.0274982005,
0.0316509828,
-0.0237210952,
-0.022155432,
0.0494172461,
0.0159359518,
0.0747823492,
-0.0326682329,
0.0110032083,
-0.0107349837,
0.0719581023,
0.0530267023,
0.0139022684,
0.0281408224,
-0.0435525551,
0.0275835097,
0.0687858015,
0.0438212343,
0.0131742191,
-0.0125290751,
-0.0365971178,
0.0075598778,
-0.0245463662,
-0.0188958645,
0.0032656733,
0.0594047643,
-0.069679901,
-0.0293744225,
0.1206638068,
0.0305322763,
-0.0574236959,
-0.0241863001,
-0.0016534842,
0.0339692533,
0.0077365101,
0.0301199183,
-0.09733513,
-0.0375853255,
0.0176311843,
0.0024736288,
0.0124165881,
-0.0236725789,
-0.0093653072,
-0.1096595749,
0.0133174602,
-0.0080277491,
-0.048054412,
-0.0148978364,
-0.0564314723,
0.0091070794,
0.0230072886,
0.0175873488,
0.0350763574,
-0.0198821053,
-0.0114118112,
-0.0032637815,
-0.0022440185,
-0.054814402,
0.0052109887,
-0.0025944444,
0.0258205794,
0.0047225459,
0.0215534624,
0.0167950019,
0.0092463447,
0.0643812865,
-0.041341424,
-0.0182001274,
-0.039814312,
0.0406584367,
-0.0051599238,
0.0140181035,
-0.0117035098,
0.0311865192,
-0.0041475897,
-0.0232205186,
0.0062244921,
0.0527850427,
-0.0170834437,
-0.0113643538,
-0.0562078729,
-0.0006710893,
-0.0090061314,
0.1072218865,
0.0262775142,
-0.0186549854,
-0.0548807792,
0.0089653125,
-0.0302241407,
-0.0318723433,
0.0257514138,
-0.0194041878,
-0.0233368501,
-0.0281805135,
-0.0536238849,
-0.0091866888,
0.0297804829,
0.0042003007,
-0.0265306924,
0.0200662464,
0.007554465,
0.0023099862,
-0.0668374971,
0.0030796023,
-0.0167886447,
0.0037567697,
-0.0313954018,
0.0156388078,
0.0435746647,
-0.0000605901,
-0.0153945321,
0.0469485633,
-0.1083555222,
-0.0719191507,
-0.0207668915,
0.0018071744,
0.0276065916,
0.0645554736,
0.0006414014,
-0.0375709198,
0.0366781913,
0.0399933495,
-0.0262886249,
0.0457985997,
0.0035769478,
0.037894588,
0.0126689542,
0.0343688503,
-0.057896968,
0.0105536152,
-0.0313302837,
0.0429165736,
-0.0371464342,
-0.0545130707,
-0.0110294335,
0.0311828665,
-0.0250292942,
-0.0084406026,
0.0161536615,
0.0173328966,
0.0300171301,
-0.0449855588,
-0.0196779221,
-0.0341202244,
0.0211626738,
-0.0215799604,
-0.0093239238,
0.0072016991,
0.0272850581,
0.0134314056,
0.014703284,
-0.0343397595,
-0.0029245371,
-0.0025062887,
-0.0218605362,
0.0377768837,
-0.0185036454,
-0.0399170928,
-0.0299857389,
-0.0139751881,
0.0369007178,
-0.0693874881,
0.0289552771,
0.0280499309,
-0.014332748,
-0.0232320167,
0.0168579463,
-0.1184593067,
-0.0362746269,
-0.0084817307,
0.0552667826,
0.025876116,
-0.0173773766,
0.0647823364,
-0.0316203721,
-0.0202772301,
-0.0362125151,
0.0323780328,
0.0471574478,
-0.0062049939,
0.0230322685,
0.0370617583,
-0.0175961666,
0.0192019772,
0.0934493467,
0.0245273057,
0.0240631253,
-0.0058582611,
-0.0241392329,
-0.0291104428,
-0.033984866,
-0.0322894379,
0.0404763632,
-0.0215044692,
-0.0066867233,
-0.0460525751,
-0.0500292704,
0.0025105434,
-0.0030910166,
-0.0070997789,
-0.0343901217,
0.0281470269,
0.0698018596,
0.026649734,
-0.0186503027,
-0.0247996859,
0.0568740256,
-0.0335742235,
-0.0231227893,
-0.0214357078,
-6.366808012e-33,
-0.0244740564,
-0.016989883,
0.0158486273,
-0.0327691734,
-0.0258186925,
0.0389444306,
-0.0700760633,
-0.0349707864,
-0.0055501778,
-0.026364306,
-0.0308551081,
0.0273060258,
0.0027019819,
0.0337187797,
-0.0319777876,
0.0025011513,
0.0377349183,
0.0124100596,
-0.0045535797,
0.0496114232,
0.0412666835,
0.0142523358,
0.010673603,
-0.0421344377,
-0.0212686546,
-0.0176586267,
0.0320178047,
-0.0006005975,
0.0242251009,
0.0472977422,
-0.0469285138,
0.0105261123,
0.0191025417,
-0.0465257727,
-0.012978103,
0.0500459373,
-0.0820478126,
-0.0056891972,
0.0354482941,
-0.0361739658,
-0.0333122574,
-0.0351301171,
0.0398860462,
0.0123905037,
0.0176511128,
-0.0289663989,
0.0126603199,
-0.0213242508,
-0.062883772,
-0.0527702309,
-0.0573073812,
0.0337749533,
0.0117922863,
0.0003704992,
0.024070533,
0.0314743146,
-0.0049005025,
0.0780387074,
-0.007676431,
0.0041334694,
0.0058827372,
0.0548046902,
0.0488020964,
0.0053208414,
0.0297444724,
0.0372024626,
-0.0011313768,
-0.0086167781,
-0.0272258539,
-0.0278511234,
0.0202598535,
0.032389611,
0.0069014863,
0.0251972694,
0.0467229784,
0.0034437254,
-0.0844153687,
0.0146750994,
0.0330482386,
0.0304435324,
0.060897056,
0.0025824851,
-0.0043077264,
-0.0278030243,
-0.0203895643,
0.0196573008,
-0.0248619709,
0.0017602786,
0.0142572168,
0.0116318092,
-0.0368519649,
-0.0077629667,
0.0590735525,
-0.0567185059,
-0.0406727307,
0.0630253926,
-0.0142308082,
0.0014068885,
-0.0043423856,
0.0344596468,
-0.0258449968,
-0.0187032241,
0.0052872081,
0.0028955315,
-0.0134133603,
0.0150119942,
0.02524052,
-0.0084632002,
-0.0578178167,
-0.0131188864,
-0.0498069786,
0.0009895614,
-0.0500280112,
0.0332942456,
0.0242517348,
0.0307268985,
0.0334305316,
0.0610042028,
0.0274751019,
0.0204665642,
-0.0335309952,
-0.048256401,
0.0102544064,
0.0296680108,
-0.0272262692,
-0.0077973618,
-0.0332861096,
0.0477480032,
0.0264456104,
-0.064511165,
-0.0196311362,
0.0316063575,
2.668e-7,
0.048180446,
0.0395946093,
0.04229201,
0.0113262646,
0.032174319,
-0.0076197991,
0.020808924,
0.0202493723,
0.0040098135,
0.0176557414,
0.0041848659,
0.0279994421,
0.0332514904,
0.0337979123,
-0.1046773195,
-0.0217900872,
-0.1109086871,
-0.0335118137,
-0.0508838557,
0.0056828149,
0.0333742239,
0.1085238531,
-0.0283220857,
-0.0190931484,
0.0085416222,
-0.0312856287,
0.057959348,
-0.016982235,
-0.0212932955,
0.0255618468,
-0.0054801498,
0.0122732846,
0.0111367106,
-0.0157079715,
-0.0020443106,
0.0065159295,
-0.0258893948,
0.0843105242,
0.0159389302,
-0.0179784782,
0.0261010174,
-0.0626373067,
0.0056034154,
-0.0341730304,
0.0820423961,
-0.0443322994,
-0.0038210277,
-0.0560052618,
-0.0069007175,
-0.0230365787,
-0.0141691379,
0.0201141909,
-0.0209886823,
0.0287497137,
-0.0008726876,
-0.0262268726,
0.0046554115,
-0.1018613577,
-0.0434185416,
0.0066834306,
-0.0745818913,
-0.0612843558,
-0.0390709564,
-0.0321020298,
0.0356687419,
-0.0629043281,
0.0069774874,
2.951656672e-34,
0.0605955832,
-0.0042040586,
-0.0315417759,
0.0573218018,
0.0098868236,
-0.0260648672,
0.003284428,
0.0186747871,
0.0172734596,
-0.1049062535,
-0.0294946767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06200v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06200v2 | The Importance of Prompt Tuning for Automated Neuron Explanations | 2023-10-09T23:02:07 | 2023-10-11T05:00:10 | Justin Lee, Tuomas Oikarinen, Arjun Chatha, Keng-Chi Chang, Yilan Chen, Tsui-Wei Weng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances have greatly increased the capabilities of large language
models (LLMs), but our understanding of the models and their safety has not
progressed as fast. In this paper we aim to understand LLMs deeper by studying
their individual neurons. We build upon previous work showing large language
models such as GPT-4 can be useful in explaining what each neuron in a language
model does. Specifically, we analyze the effect of the prompt used to generate
explanations and show that reformatting the explanation prompt in a more
natural way can significantly improve neuron explanation quality and greatly
reduce computational cost. We demonstrate the effects of our new prompts in
three different ways, incorporating both automated and human evaluations. | [
0.0082560042,
0.0301512685,
-0.0158106051,
0.0363287367,
-0.0100152958,
0.0204073247,
0.0605838001,
-0.0422646143,
-0.0445208438,
0.0066005802,
0.0042296471,
-0.0375924408,
0.0231845677,
0.0346199945,
0.063933529,
-0.0370126292,
0.0563024506,
-0.0647682846,
0.0031358686,
-0.013336095,
-0.0085429456,
0.0347741619,
-0.0093413303,
0.0507237054,
0.0282466095,
-0.0294078737,
-0.0433193147,
-0.0085466113,
-0.0161261,
-0.0078834696,
-0.0242761727,
0.0358738787,
0.0333159789,
0.0652112067,
0.000002103,
-0.0070159696,
0.0351391435,
0.0055085742,
-0.0638614446,
0.0762436613,
0.0021127623,
-0.009957944,
0.0082946494,
0.0097872568,
0.0218267143,
-0.0159430057,
0.0913213044,
0.0144606149,
0.0581857413,
0.0627866983,
0.0260121897,
-0.0382893793,
0.0106181046,
-0.0307200365,
0.0495754704,
-0.0364217684,
0.0161740314,
-0.0306396987,
0.0154725378,
0.010150508,
-0.0144380173,
0.0243480243,
0.0561840124,
-0.0383468643,
0.0086716088,
0.0404320173,
0.0196742918,
-0.0589981712,
-0.033376541,
0.0298663806,
-0.019540811,
-0.0132331597,
-0.0162103958,
-0.0153196575,
-0.0098697115,
-0.0348032005,
-0.0694542974,
0.0165784061,
0.0024967659,
0.0212358721,
0.0090044858,
-0.0247915816,
0.0737912729,
0.0202984381,
-0.0132523058,
0.0607459806,
0.0148831233,
0.0166403148,
-0.044889722,
-0.0057024607,
-0.0213759821,
-0.0433777347,
0.0210701674,
0.0666705519,
-0.0283668283,
0.0118736429,
0.0114669548,
0.0152486861,
0.0149645023,
-0.0016349122,
0.0663247332,
0.0578368679,
-0.0145071298,
0.0150636882,
-0.0011008979,
0.0533669107,
-0.0187347773,
0.037609376,
-0.00879448,
0.0165994409,
-0.0455207638,
-0.0431614444,
-0.0051469761,
-0.0211312305,
-0.0361095741,
-0.0210160539,
0.0002009505,
0.0367890932,
0.0206291266,
-0.0248987842,
0.0095570264,
0.0076085222,
-0.035557501,
-0.0113915419,
-0.0538981929,
0.038209226,
-0.0672564283,
-0.0203031246,
0.0302257091,
-0.0558601655,
-0.0579389222,
0.0120891202,
-0.012915764,
-0.0311359987,
0.00304452,
0.058262188,
-0.0094628939,
-0.013574508,
-0.0291847941,
0.0008645855,
-0.0256653354,
-0.046445936,
-0.0162301715,
-0.0397774316,
0.0265155416,
-0.002383033,
-0.0467693657,
-0.0290296841,
0.0055984207,
0.0136146797,
-0.0540785044,
0.0584294945,
-0.0834359825,
0.0323379263,
0.0283591226,
0.0037901157,
-0.0151423179,
0.008179225,
0.0117851971,
0.0163728204,
0.0042486112,
-0.038869191,
0.0373983681,
0.008006515,
0.0182863623,
-0.0149648357,
-0.0319037177,
-0.0368461125,
-0.0110222716,
0.0617705397,
0.0559133776,
0.0545051843,
-0.0380709656,
0.0085240649,
0.0754164457,
0.0551725738,
-0.0152952895,
0.0163855311,
0.0548529886,
-0.0079600587,
0.0181331336,
0.0223153811,
-0.0837473199,
0.0538425371,
-0.0205128528,
0.0249768198,
0.0107886065,
0.0163435433,
-0.0380513854,
-0.0535246097,
-0.0108136721,
0.0206514858,
0.0209367722,
0.009960847,
0.0332589075,
-0.0094724949,
-0.0322008431,
0.0397785343,
0.0280789286,
-0.0200302526,
-0.0182727855,
-0.1075760946,
0.0693661422,
0.0872658715,
0.0258720499,
-0.0032874125,
-0.0211865548,
-0.0198497158,
-0.0132378871,
0.0804530457,
0.047924675,
0.019593196,
0.0272230078,
-0.0378141403,
-0.0061521172,
-0.05320004,
0.0256562196,
0.0209593698,
0.005654519,
-0.0583109818,
0.0212646555,
-0.0179082807,
-0.0686667114,
0.0404816717,
0.0001212166,
-0.0423568077,
0.0113926176,
-0.0081856027,
-0.0131168459,
0.0101432316,
0.0132406512,
0.0464073196,
0.0105570303,
-0.0090773487,
0.0361520424,
-0.0215061009,
-0.0694610104,
-0.0336462557,
0.0591053031,
0.0457802601,
-0.0160838421,
0.023490781,
-0.0355237909,
-0.0524707735,
0.0124537451,
-0.0514040962,
0.0338261724,
-0.0566888303,
-0.0122982068,
-0.0077458578,
0.0160831232,
-0.0278230123,
0.0545796044,
0.0257120952,
-0.0053674728,
0.0162228644,
0.0265095271,
-0.0006110208,
-0.0419719256,
-0.0242866538,
0.0073106065,
-0.0208060313,
0.0121142669,
-0.0074879425,
0.0110395532,
-0.0056386604,
0.0159416199,
-0.0399190709,
-0.0068085021,
-0.0111043379,
-0.0054049138,
0.0226950888,
-0.0157984961,
-0.000564029,
-0.0013597952,
-0.0305464305,
0.013331526,
0.0030505643,
0.0114118569,
0.0590793379,
0.0045726891,
-0.0780016854,
-0.0557125062,
-0.0382021479,
-0.0293505955,
0.0664413348,
0.0151722077,
-0.0214259494,
-0.0726592615,
0.0072174156,
-0.0170989912,
-0.0119800111,
-0.0092934929,
-0.0673967823,
0.0543426499,
-0.0076250355,
-0.0141774016,
0.0645873994,
0.0050956416,
0.0664168373,
0.0539800785,
0.0120391054,
-0.0208060127,
-0.000650105,
-0.0326526016,
-0.0223234184,
-0.0257397611,
-0.0303773992,
-0.0297455844,
0.10129904,
0.0157743711,
-0.0189247206,
-0.0504510365,
0.0183127429,
0.0136772795,
0.0030984962,
-0.0419072062,
-0.0433361307,
-0.0391941667,
0.0751016587,
-0.0238418728,
-0.0699021891,
0.0912004262,
-0.0512907729,
-0.0088814683,
-0.0112646995,
-0.0259286761,
-0.0015042257,
0.08758571,
0.0148081491,
0.030170029,
0.0342450477,
-0.0161552299,
-0.0191990826,
-0.025043577,
0.0034921989,
0.0063461862,
0.0232723355,
-0.0405489244,
-0.0318469368,
0.0259290319,
-0.0140681062,
0.0046829446,
-0.0089642471,
-0.0447083302,
0.0393266976,
0.0330683179,
-0.0418142974,
0.009976388,
0.0072749471,
0.0583732724,
0.04436424,
-0.0590261929,
0.0108775143,
-0.0363630988,
-0.0115772374,
0.0080472399,
0.0226343442,
0.0626399666,
-0.0640047491,
0.0298475288,
-0.0005254431,
0.0021869391,
0.0310660955,
-0.0573236682,
0.0150356274,
-0.0003858374,
-0.0174968541,
-0.0196181089,
0.0251374003,
0.0508901775,
-0.0770930424,
-0.000708131,
0.1290049404,
0.0260668267,
-0.0720218197,
0.021270074,
-0.0098013896,
0.0031020865,
0.0042849882,
0.0425720289,
-0.0491277613,
-0.0387744978,
0.0193658527,
0.0272968654,
0.0211283248,
0.0267246254,
-0.0184049923,
-0.071416609,
0.0315644443,
0.0243582297,
-0.0400040336,
-0.0333513096,
-0.028724391,
-0.037949495,
0.0135327885,
0.0452065282,
0.0632724836,
0.0221959557,
0.0194160473,
0.0041982578,
-0.0107457191,
-0.0383634456,
0.0399089605,
-0.0212555863,
0.084121421,
0.0873324499,
0.0145353721,
-0.0222312286,
-0.0533427671,
0.0421703942,
-0.0000615948,
0.0376901478,
-0.0012460835,
0.045352038,
0.0402039364,
-0.0389615223,
-0.045745004,
0.0282171015,
-0.0253326017,
-0.0263883211,
-0.0590539984,
0.0559921823,
-0.0296394639,
-0.0415489301,
0.0153762447,
0.0068830536,
-0.0004026624,
0.0810671449,
0.088625811,
-0.0358650908,
-0.0691486001,
-0.0465405956,
-0.0182398781,
-0.0442780554,
-0.0411349423,
0.0013910596,
0.0619437508,
-0.0400727391,
-0.0055640666,
-0.0180618688,
0.0314384736,
0.0031642984,
-0.0023335621,
-0.0219186991,
-0.028973043,
-0.0233586431,
-0.024756968,
0.0679867715,
0.0263926294,
0.0243280921,
-0.0754358321,
-0.024509849,
0.0230170283,
-0.0449456088,
-0.0106039606,
0.0400912911,
-0.0304519068,
-0.0640257671,
-0.0070713442,
0.0385503732,
0.0331470668,
0.0121132322,
-0.0133620165,
-0.0645059794,
0.0210472383,
0.0329523496,
-0.0292217601,
-0.0097203944,
0.0169233065,
0.0266564805,
0.0021506557,
0.029032249,
0.0025046575,
0.0017542472,
0.0128717413,
0.0339999497,
-0.0030248908,
-0.0183703545,
0.0325726122,
0.0286224205,
0.0646796674,
-0.0173953827,
-0.0051778844,
-0.0248003732,
-0.0064671673,
0.000586319,
-0.0065247491,
-0.0328908078,
0.0110175917,
0.0397497788,
-0.032048516,
0.0035924029,
-0.0464380905,
0.0159423333,
0.003874073,
-0.0143056549,
-0.0095237829,
-0.0110501433,
-0.0102746822,
-0.0037608978,
0.0023897137,
-0.0391729623,
0.0375740007,
-0.0404477417,
0.0256878268,
0.0033630312,
0.0404148661,
0.0000975387,
0.0150406072,
-0.0349531025,
0.0238429978,
-0.0689087287,
-0.0877192467,
0.008252006,
0.0075355717,
0.0086981431,
0.0192755405,
0.0562632047,
-0.0120209865,
-0.0221682712,
0.0000373457,
0.0434954055,
0.0266430937,
-0.0184050612,
0.051165387,
0.0335271768,
-0.0202185232,
-0.0771749243,
0.0663229972,
0.0299785621,
0.0271726996,
-0.001510567,
0.0014196753,
0.0133686392,
-0.0230466668,
-0.0112445494,
-0.0003137194,
-0.040822763,
-0.0221101828,
-0.0459683798,
-0.0705971122,
-0.0380281024,
0.031234853,
-0.0042566108,
-0.0255563688,
0.0231973808,
0.0485706627,
-0.0004988224,
-0.0342457183,
0.0045806142,
0.0170662086,
-0.0055721095,
-0.0001777126,
-0.0097078113,
-6.534805256e-33,
-0.0433836058,
-0.0393061675,
0.0256748199,
-0.0072803213,
-0.0003444972,
-0.016734587,
-0.0744538158,
0.0011196025,
-0.0121250702,
0.0354456902,
-0.0075057349,
0.0258054137,
0.0091012679,
0.0204981565,
0.0125849238,
-0.0180091653,
0.0268383399,
-0.0006144971,
-0.0191189852,
0.0350325033,
0.0303200111,
0.0289588626,
0.0566006787,
-0.0041258004,
0.0426298007,
0.036158815,
-0.0556607172,
0.0280506946,
-0.061360538,
0.0392758623,
-0.0501235425,
0.0297731534,
0.0030564377,
-0.0336106941,
-0.0202473607,
0.0237586964,
-0.022632964,
-0.0088921189,
0.0548970886,
-0.0221610237,
-0.0532264449,
-0.0627615973,
0.0376412421,
-0.0355702154,
-0.0015891371,
-0.0049423575,
-0.0060851094,
-0.0370562486,
-0.0291273464,
0.0240709148,
-0.0419518277,
0.0004837497,
-0.004389124,
-0.0449117571,
0.0111342352,
-0.0201234128,
-0.0362795964,
-0.0000741902,
-0.0316369943,
0.001047708,
0.0566792935,
0.0508199558,
0.0506117456,
0.0305685941,
0.0179701764,
0.0457449704,
0.0448657796,
-0.0273919366,
-0.0876334235,
0.0015545376,
0.0146915987,
0.0340009034,
0.091720745,
0.0043517249,
0.0357657596,
-0.0031795001,
-0.0425641574,
0.0076432507,
0.0081072245,
0.0428208672,
0.0402571969,
-0.002985972,
0.00150533,
-0.0502459109,
-0.0370435305,
-0.0593041554,
-0.0422089025,
-0.031464234,
0.0116241807,
-0.024437746,
-0.0549098067,
-0.0365624167,
-0.0050879009,
-0.0340240672,
0.0093997847,
0.040019799,
-0.0225892328,
0.0066189743,
0.0185330417,
-0.0065368619,
-0.0147160916,
-0.0112851001,
-0.0276989099,
0.0149568245,
0.0270200744,
0.0253489744,
0.0158102866,
0.0720686689,
-0.0172702614,
0.0142385056,
-0.0751488656,
-0.0112062823,
0.0046168175,
0.0208659489,
0.003419443,
-0.0077726333,
-0.0303257275,
0.0179648418,
-0.009438199,
-0.0054015722,
-0.0037172001,
0.0194602944,
-0.0176179763,
0.0474316068,
-0.0350946002,
-0.0035333489,
-0.0444170535,
0.0366477519,
0.0574156754,
-0.0479825698,
-0.0274441689,
0.015726598,
2.663e-7,
0.0526757427,
0.0436631851,
0.0329162478,
0.0536222421,
0.0434456728,
0.0318924636,
-0.000366511,
-0.0238191839,
-0.0142578576,
-0.0481800921,
0.0054943133,
0.0493242107,
0.0600067303,
0.0261221025,
-0.0230178498,
0.0085282093,
-0.0868441984,
0.0031001165,
-0.0702487305,
-0.0081757177,
0.0352378413,
0.0929026902,
0.0088825217,
-0.029981371,
0.040086899,
-0.0355644301,
0.0478170142,
-0.0243525878,
0.0306592677,
0.0161765069,
0.0225534793,
-0.0022511871,
0.0101483902,
-0.0121880639,
0.018775519,
-0.0100714331,
-0.0313887969,
0.0819193646,
-0.0253066849,
-0.0225334708,
-0.0090883765,
-0.0516755581,
0.0200753286,
-0.1000280008,
0.0485878922,
-0.0246612169,
-0.007382256,
-0.0095429514,
0.038240999,
-0.0558146574,
0.0305580739,
-0.0754295811,
-0.0060037547,
0.0128213847,
-0.030118797,
-0.0281780101,
0.0082782097,
-0.0733947381,
-0.0620136708,
-0.006945414,
-0.0308163967,
0.0030267155,
-0.0605984703,
-0.0141631793,
0.0347732343,
-0.0355302021,
-0.0109240003,
2.465212544e-34,
0.0317166597,
-0.0108334916,
0.0124027096,
0.0200949647,
0.0455637686,
0.0322964713,
0.0254912153,
-0.0164285004,
0.0243012551,
-0.0723347291,
-0.0486029685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06165v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06165v2 | CAW-coref: Conjunction-Aware Word-level Coreference Resolution | 2023-10-09T21:32:49 | 2023-10-19T17:31:14 | Karel D'Oosterlinck, Semere Kiros Bitew, Brandon Papineau, Christopher Potts, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | State-of-the-art coreference resolutions systems depend on multiple LLM calls
per document and are thus prohibitively expensive for many use cases (e.g.,
information extraction with large corpora). The leading word-level coreference
system (WL-coref) attains 96.6% of these SOTA systems' performance while being
much more efficient. In this work, we identify a routine yet important failure
case of WL-coref: dealing with conjoined mentions such as 'Tom and Mary'. We
offer a simple yet effective solution that improves the performance on the
OntoNotes test set by 0.9% F1, shrinking the gap between efficient word-level
coreference resolution and expensive SOTA approaches by 34.6%. Our
Conjunction-Aware Word-level coreference model (CAW-coref) and code is
available at https://github.com/KarelDO/wl-coref. | [
0.0350419059,
0.0038981377,
0.0266686715,
0.0456667803,
-0.0454074629,
0.0014211441,
-0.0280873813,
0.0158635713,
0.0512633026,
-0.0270973127,
-0.015002938,
0.0440482087,
-0.0021444757,
-0.0669053197,
-0.0195709541,
0.0213052314,
0.0867437646,
-0.032260783,
0.004716604,
-0.0303538274,
-0.0008384666,
0.0087709213,
-0.0233238991,
-0.0059427409,
-0.0392948389,
-0.0144045856,
0.0222769715,
0.0227814484,
0.021106299,
0.0119094132,
0.0119353756,
0.0160216,
-0.0589841902,
0.0557581894,
0.0000019549,
-0.0636221021,
-0.03625191,
0.0272905156,
0.0212670509,
0.0496628471,
0.0160303377,
0.0270577949,
-0.026720969,
0.0172516294,
0.0053962176,
0.0582341589,
-0.0100537781,
0.0349292643,
0.0240553152,
0.0193445794,
-0.0179142673,
-0.0228904299,
0.0348348506,
-0.020177817,
-0.0672358274,
-0.0835141465,
0.0221716147,
-0.0045763273,
0.0199079309,
-0.0273438599,
0.028630428,
0.0444473103,
-0.0512284636,
0.0171009991,
-0.0026522027,
0.0055069299,
-0.1035584733,
-0.0161289778,
0.0237512328,
0.0514445007,
0.0047986438,
0.0407003164,
0.0305890981,
0.0321959481,
-0.0372100361,
-0.0005304537,
-0.0143316248,
-0.0402215011,
-0.0754888877,
0.0151559189,
0.0162077229,
-0.0077677728,
-0.0063513517,
0.0339180864,
-0.026266953,
0.0979984105,
0.023181159,
0.0005636816,
0.0684323236,
0.0265524741,
-0.0442701615,
-0.0328538083,
0.0906130001,
0.003690022,
-0.0265547037,
0.0172685515,
-0.039897643,
0.0025393763,
0.0375141278,
-0.1060072631,
0.0170344561,
0.0083346497,
-0.054340627,
0.0452099666,
-0.0506682806,
0.030776348,
-0.0202398021,
-0.0083957631,
0.0059267017,
-0.0613251254,
-0.0053610764,
0.0456301533,
-0.0617584586,
0.0648162141,
-0.0966622606,
-0.04598023,
-0.039941553,
-0.0121494848,
0.0090582948,
0.0245477371,
0.0100899804,
-0.032631781,
0.0051172995,
0.0130087519,
-0.002405511,
0.0245093722,
-0.000445028,
-0.0185728483,
-0.0626047552,
-0.0219605472,
-0.0021152338,
-0.0063620699,
0.0554784872,
-0.0262939539,
0.0255692247,
0.0284210574,
0.0055549005,
-0.0470851958,
-0.017329257,
-0.0468375422,
-0.0402769521,
-0.0196669586,
-0.0523438416,
-0.067665711,
0.0239058379,
0.0038231716,
0.0188216288,
-0.0702183768,
0.0487856083,
0.0450435057,
-0.0752751902,
0.0690969229,
-0.0181392599,
0.0018887453,
0.0028139492,
-0.0038970602,
0.0548895486,
0.0538619459,
0.0365967192,
0.0218966734,
0.0598213784,
0.0351910703,
-0.0545595028,
0.0601075441,
0.0175104998,
0.0265260264,
0.0277642943,
-0.0066046938,
-0.0329130851,
0.0094362618,
0.0395900048,
0.0864416882,
0.0166468844,
-0.0062127104,
0.0180945527,
0.0488080084,
-0.0134374341,
-0.0083693946,
-0.004168503,
0.0003572331,
0.0093562631,
0.0056470479,
-0.0271659419,
-0.0063977409,
-0.0236452967,
0.0027074588,
0.0892190263,
0.016588781,
0.0038175238,
-0.0038706905,
-0.0373364687,
0.0178798791,
-0.0446160808,
-0.0284955148,
0.0270841923,
-0.0236603785,
-0.0494257249,
0.0463306233,
0.0364359543,
-0.074243851,
-0.0275776386,
-0.006422047,
-0.0337464064,
0.0291711856,
0.0797978714,
-0.0105438158,
-0.0622301027,
0.0491889752,
-0.0099682491,
0.0562535599,
0.0106654614,
-0.00605482,
0.0599406511,
-0.0238121711,
0.0182973742,
0.0568515435,
-0.0107114725,
0.0254657101,
0.0422347449,
0.0003140309,
0.0236855503,
-0.0269738249,
-0.0071574054,
-0.0123055512,
-0.0049552433,
0.0173207,
0.0158414561,
0.0125747696,
0.0308801737,
0.0363798961,
0.0004960447,
-0.0040903338,
0.0395600013,
-0.0116065256,
0.0149984164,
0.0268146005,
-0.0070735225,
-0.0348420516,
0.0465502143,
-0.0098359315,
0.0166868642,
-0.0386091545,
0.0122320205,
-0.0451554917,
-0.0460657477,
-0.0364988446,
0.0646604374,
-0.0082351705,
0.0501239039,
0.0328231081,
0.0044753975,
-0.0330693871,
0.0481175371,
-0.0098322984,
0.0077395192,
0.0376978032,
-0.0135313282,
0.031606365,
-0.0152918193,
-0.029231457,
-0.0195154194,
-0.0001749895,
0.0015955177,
0.0171775967,
0.0021215645,
-0.0430181809,
-0.0595095195,
-0.0929971635,
0.0405011363,
0.0146441367,
0.0462322757,
-0.0252231918,
0.0293723978,
-0.0182677712,
-0.0114307757,
0.0225812495,
0.0272896718,
0.019258244,
0.0080855126,
0.0131595545,
0.0218232423,
-0.0480212867,
-0.0540880561,
0.0138237691,
-0.0244642328,
-0.0164665394,
-0.009517883,
-0.0694437101,
-0.0321676694,
0.0407500863,
-0.0070671346,
0.0425206088,
0.0236912835,
0.0286702421,
-0.0226838533,
-0.0100043546,
0.0091967396,
0.025051577,
-0.0331724249,
0.0019810724,
-0.0107758818,
-0.0784603432,
-0.0656048283,
0.03474674,
0.040894866,
-0.0678422302,
-0.0186513234,
0.0003252659,
0.0255002901,
0.0418901667,
-0.0279997233,
0.0091926316,
-0.0106526576,
-0.0186722726,
-0.0133211156,
-0.0119866971,
0.0365664177,
-0.0187600106,
-0.0459923074,
0.0259882603,
-0.0350161679,
0.0094079487,
0.0015350193,
-0.0778994486,
-0.0101054944,
-0.0524439439,
0.0319905095,
-0.0553379767,
0.0673545748,
-0.0118027888,
-0.0051679648,
0.0638622418,
-0.0885404572,
0.0052176574,
0.0252842028,
0.0093434695,
-0.0370929316,
0.0675832406,
-0.040924944,
0.0473643318,
-0.0335722081,
-0.0033067069,
-0.0264882445,
0.0014221587,
-0.0608633496,
-0.0136425626,
-0.0091323303,
-0.0188513845,
0.0213756692,
0.0147809843,
-0.019703215,
0.0346073061,
0.0015573124,
-0.0012156169,
-0.0625755712,
0.0644917637,
0.0128097357,
-0.0051016142,
-0.0062000984,
0.0120020229,
-0.0206795763,
0.0494350456,
0.0336922221,
-0.0147665348,
0.0272914749,
-0.03632465,
0.0530278571,
-0.0764827356,
-0.0383116007,
-0.0198658388,
0.0637316182,
-0.0425561965,
-0.0360629261,
0.1236307174,
0.042562902,
-0.0506712645,
-0.0337125361,
0.0088005792,
-0.0160328578,
0.0136510599,
0.0028113087,
-0.0252428744,
-0.0344787389,
0.0319558308,
0.0169823226,
0.0392373353,
-0.0501639135,
-0.0026900591,
-0.1011759639,
0.0128303096,
-0.0104416488,
-0.0020056325,
-0.0140339378,
-0.0266367942,
0.0533906966,
-0.0209492818,
0.001952079,
0.0308071189,
-0.0365198776,
0.0200651288,
-0.0140162231,
0.0096833864,
0.0351540707,
0.0229297467,
-0.0744724423,
-0.0053764088,
0.0351985395,
0.0628218874,
0.0143653117,
0.004379286,
0.0289939474,
-0.0595124401,
0.0022790825,
-0.0631572828,
-0.0019317128,
-0.0165580697,
-0.0037943677,
-0.0026584191,
0.028075818,
-0.0158212036,
-0.0029149228,
0.0194074996,
-0.0061464896,
0.0234145708,
0.0585768111,
-0.01344389,
0.0393284895,
-0.0244529676,
0.0445469506,
0.0165364984,
0.00380435,
0.0043469318,
-0.0017678736,
0.0084457509,
-0.0422042832,
-0.0104968864,
-0.0215944853,
-0.064624086,
0.0029119351,
-0.0548270456,
-0.0412188619,
0.02087925,
0.0165735055,
0.0028500301,
0.0219200887,
0.0121651981,
0.0479325652,
-0.0420008563,
-0.0194643307,
-0.0600017123,
0.0177754667,
-0.0718029514,
0.0638328269,
0.0754434615,
0.0706749633,
-0.0178511143,
0.0642514974,
-0.0448395461,
-0.0331993699,
-0.0085576,
0.0064078206,
0.0178288799,
0.0329579972,
-0.0564536974,
-0.0058221291,
-0.055258546,
0.0571134128,
-0.0284461379,
0.0440631062,
0.03980124,
0.03801658,
-0.0052305395,
0.0577590987,
-0.0296525713,
0.0004908824,
-0.0432069153,
0.0676399767,
-0.0407813564,
-0.0966264382,
-0.0046393871,
0.0591612309,
0.0375735983,
-0.0205951873,
0.0423690267,
0.010375442,
0.0663566962,
-0.0191330127,
-0.0132391788,
-0.0020779937,
0.0259672869,
-0.0554763861,
-0.0168612227,
-0.0218224246,
-0.0084507847,
-0.0165677909,
0.0553065352,
-0.004208874,
0.0094951773,
0.0012135495,
-0.0241908412,
-0.0293508787,
-0.0367721319,
0.0024332092,
-0.0053500351,
0.0372971557,
0.0344627798,
-0.0425694734,
0.0018494157,
-0.026640363,
-0.0097183343,
-0.0204581283,
-0.0056846435,
-0.0258162692,
0.0334988572,
-0.0391873345,
0.0177048035,
0.0721360445,
-0.0035540969,
0.1315074265,
-0.0127750421,
-0.0190481637,
-0.011192997,
0.0070164171,
-0.0168313496,
0.0313006006,
-0.0219678804,
-0.0098983133,
0.0164397247,
0.0095972316,
0.0515042879,
-0.0131555395,
0.0055328952,
0.0391541198,
-0.0318260603,
-0.0422579274,
-0.0401269309,
-0.0254613291,
0.0223320648,
-0.0031846056,
0.0102056703,
-0.0592892319,
-0.0085319271,
0.101099208,
-0.0021291235,
0.0010984506,
-0.0061222711,
0.000884769,
0.0242924858,
0.0549750589,
-0.0037690878,
-0.0207804795,
0.0097543504,
0.0062977914,
-0.0696520656,
0.026080301,
-5.98887666e-33,
-0.0796746612,
0.0019360044,
-0.0130467955,
0.0282129273,
-0.0220295135,
0.030731177,
-0.0224579796,
0.0168856643,
0.0056127217,
-0.0160861369,
-0.0412220471,
-0.0021936065,
0.0331787206,
-0.0131539125,
-0.0138670355,
0.0200599637,
0.0160811283,
0.0459258854,
-0.0143331122,
-0.0096223494,
0.0558499135,
0.0216884166,
0.057006333,
-0.0852046758,
0.0128244776,
0.0162179731,
-0.0186776891,
0.0024801604,
0.0533386841,
0.0164225958,
-0.0157007687,
0.0205939468,
-0.0191746559,
0.0198752079,
0.000750707,
-0.0027443846,
-0.148300156,
-0.0295501221,
0.0514920987,
0.0052557308,
0.0385702811,
-0.0299649592,
0.0193065852,
0.0108263278,
-0.0025406005,
0.0047045983,
0.0104734832,
-0.0246242434,
-0.0419081971,
-0.0483521931,
-0.0531821288,
0.0473552309,
0.0303763989,
-0.0040124804,
0.0459457375,
-0.0224672277,
0.0056974455,
-0.0150059471,
-0.0214270446,
-0.010405302,
-0.0097930832,
0.0262466948,
-0.0008652175,
-0.0238515269,
-0.0165643003,
0.0153588438,
0.0031921258,
-0.0323566869,
0.0027129385,
-0.0040712259,
0.0097980164,
0.0585439391,
-0.0124472603,
0.0957336873,
0.0145914573,
0.0106900558,
-0.0318577662,
0.04157608,
0.0627352223,
0.016403066,
-0.016741043,
0.0041245543,
-0.0525014848,
-0.0142851043,
-0.0278681032,
-0.0220915955,
-0.0229641199,
-0.0233859774,
0.0008415232,
-0.0027985822,
-0.0277734157,
0.0618522726,
0.0068755005,
-0.02967689,
-0.0468789488,
0.0013100082,
0.0158988349,
0.0380132422,
-0.025816476,
0.031612765,
-0.0144739114,
-0.0287379082,
-0.0369144604,
0.0194623191,
0.0107319457,
-0.0144713195,
0.0110847987,
-0.034436889,
-0.0944319665,
-0.0136082042,
-0.023138918,
0.0129601257,
-0.0652535707,
-0.0279752668,
0.0203509293,
-0.0022723372,
0.0482297093,
0.023550583,
0.0445271917,
0.0113801658,
-0.0579541996,
-0.0374436527,
0.0444824733,
0.0370131321,
0.0248773675,
0.0212791916,
0.0254543852,
0.0066220313,
-0.0157998614,
-0.0239264593,
-0.0135585945,
0.0065734508,
2.627e-7,
0.0456946678,
0.0357531458,
0.0487277247,
0.0132221393,
-0.0073118214,
-0.0245066248,
0.0228641033,
0.0412389226,
-0.0109443096,
-0.0051347516,
-0.0007189999,
-0.0217233934,
0.0183285121,
0.0286710635,
-0.0805962831,
-0.0292112138,
-0.0271563586,
-0.0462758839,
-0.0520033576,
-0.0120173469,
-0.0216471367,
0.0333003327,
0.0253111925,
-0.0179083198,
-0.032448452,
-0.0281175319,
0.025797667,
-0.0168287344,
-0.021775471,
0.0118863257,
-0.0136866197,
0.0263388343,
0.0126780309,
0.0176869277,
0.0075727738,
0.0294113774,
0.0660195351,
0.0635640696,
-0.0081998333,
-0.0295485035,
0.0026062171,
-0.0594482608,
0.0128832515,
-0.0009295983,
0.0678398162,
0.0331979282,
0.0150135411,
-0.0510370806,
-0.0222130865,
0.026108535,
-0.0458000563,
0.018807115,
-0.0227361415,
0.0314867832,
0.0120508792,
-0.0066515524,
-0.0334780142,
-0.0566800311,
-0.0271588359,
0.0242314413,
0.0025149875,
-0.0560447499,
0.0099163894,
-0.060486149,
-0.0515147969,
-0.0471733585,
-0.0399433747,
2.426148708e-34,
0.0412222818,
-0.0022907767,
0.0084087625,
0.0430181436,
-0.0116162896,
-0.0068735527,
-0.0211099051,
0.0107627185,
-0.0041900822,
-0.0103367949,
0.004809557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06117v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06117v2 | Take a Step Back: Evoking Reasoning via Abstraction in Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T19:48:55 | 2024-03-12T04:38:27 | Huaixiu Steven Zheng, Swaroop Mishra, Xinyun Chen, Heng-Tze Cheng, Ed H. Chi, Quoc V Le, Denny Zhou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present Step-Back Prompting, a simple prompting technique that enables
LLMs to do abstractions to derive high-level concepts and first principles from
instances containing specific details. Using the concepts and principles to
guide reasoning, LLMs significantly improve their abilities in following a
correct reasoning path towards the solution. We conduct experiments of
Step-Back Prompting with PaLM-2L, GPT-4 and Llama2-70B models, and observe
substantial performance gains on various challenging reasoning-intensive tasks
including STEM, Knowledge QA, and Multi-Hop Reasoning. For instance, Step-Back
Prompting improves PaLM-2L performance on MMLU (Physics and Chemistry) by 7%
and 11% respectively, TimeQA by 27%, and MuSiQue by 7%. | [
-0.0131212091,
-0.0154904211,
-0.0211560596,
0.0488668941,
-0.036576204,
0.0165198147,
-0.0061562434,
0.0015997696,
-0.0042556589,
-0.0105966544,
-0.0170065686,
0.0200356282,
-0.0308728479,
0.0026290691,
0.0295476541,
-0.0435723811,
0.0450989604,
-0.0740669966,
0.0216040965,
-0.0248113442,
-0.0448343121,
-0.0140964929,
-0.0505310893,
0.0131091624,
0.0325111225,
-0.0526338629,
-0.0319182239,
-0.0163925793,
-0.0017361102,
-0.0412457138,
-0.036601305,
0.0256208442,
0.0239000805,
-0.0101164542,
0.0000023315,
-0.058713872,
0.0289168432,
-0.0249631349,
-0.0493693501,
-0.0002762845,
-0.0537552238,
0.0264168624,
-0.0082681868,
0.0120791597,
-0.034366332,
0.0295439269,
-0.0177461728,
0.0310606491,
0.0439716801,
0.013959635,
0.0163944494,
-0.0106614307,
0.0365348533,
0.0272122063,
0.0456366278,
-0.0042131464,
-0.0208694581,
0.0178360343,
0.0776128545,
0.0394361801,
-0.0072524757,
0.0475878529,
0.0632191747,
-0.013372777,
0.0171576217,
0.0553818643,
0.003060949,
0.0113533894,
0.0053937035,
0.0246861465,
0.0515085459,
-0.0137599148,
-0.0261505097,
-0.0054250746,
0.0151932547,
0.0259945709,
-0.0720028356,
0.0125391455,
-0.0131072653,
-0.0021516823,
0.0368456431,
-0.0344831236,
0.0519695692,
0.0085669858,
-0.0261050817,
0.0773429945,
0.0073915147,
-0.0388087966,
0.0364654809,
-0.0103195934,
0.0673389062,
-0.0299186632,
0.0019294284,
0.0880101174,
-0.0332644358,
0.0300176833,
0.0163703393,
0.0120205348,
-0.0103210397,
-0.0026514456,
0.0416443944,
0.0703979284,
0.0092878956,
0.0404061489,
-0.0605478287,
0.0094920788,
-0.0461781546,
0.0312292799,
-0.0095926709,
0.0021137246,
-0.0430757031,
-0.0328861885,
-0.0399172641,
0.0497652255,
-0.042811051,
-0.0067029279,
-0.0214191191,
0.0348947085,
-0.0053846054,
0.0077624824,
-0.0153952697,
-0.0025942614,
0.0208831076,
-0.0034170556,
-0.0475199148,
0.0275851302,
-0.036477033,
0.0261640865,
0.057303708,
-0.0766275153,
-0.0251721907,
-0.022450937,
-0.0477734096,
-0.0143750589,
0.0193918776,
0.1006359011,
-0.0239692945,
-0.0065582832,
-0.0375503749,
-0.0354958735,
0.0658589527,
-0.0575652868,
0.0357731543,
-0.0769533291,
0.018884575,
0.0102562476,
0.0042160228,
0.0195771065,
0.0130963838,
0.0149509665,
0.0234942716,
0.0553029217,
-0.0184988752,
0.0085521042,
0.0490908585,
0.0389702246,
-0.0932073593,
0.0442603268,
0.0450751223,
-0.0131548131,
-0.0133988047,
-0.0183514487,
0.0240843389,
0.0403479449,
0.0107044186,
-0.0026094501,
0.0108861858,
-0.0196512267,
-0.0436717384,
0.0542934537,
0.0134515576,
0.0114413779,
-0.0310873389,
0.0501467176,
0.0322838686,
0.0934390575,
0.0028275019,
0.0148695698,
0.0442759655,
-0.0627675578,
0.033436358,
-0.0039340421,
-0.0676752776,
0.0782506168,
-0.0262093227,
0.0213173814,
-0.0085856663,
0.0036854933,
-0.0341188088,
-0.0354559943,
-0.008104017,
0.0415497087,
-0.0363644697,
0.014649245,
0.0331656374,
0.0074160825,
-0.0115363346,
0.0516254678,
0.0026358438,
-0.0314081684,
-0.0152787091,
-0.0763332844,
0.0478243753,
0.0706506521,
0.0374300666,
-0.0011992182,
-0.0275435243,
0.0007373733,
0.022982154,
0.0363915749,
0.0178549979,
-0.0237368681,
-0.0251763221,
-0.0075047361,
-0.0038825101,
-0.0360285677,
-0.0152445845,
0.0042212,
0.0200498607,
0.0076964078,
-0.0177819114,
-0.0198435485,
0.0074994243,
0.0149990218,
-0.0696470067,
-0.0343492664,
-0.0430728644,
0.0202896483,
-0.0035593663,
0.016603373,
0.0271917097,
0.0112635791,
0.0386969037,
-0.0312586389,
-0.0155906435,
0.0081177251,
-0.070903793,
-0.0324252769,
0.0296771154,
-0.0101225507,
-0.041877836,
-0.0174488742,
-0.0034575341,
-0.0315501951,
0.0202549398,
0.0077660289,
0.0620893799,
-0.0128869973,
0.0209107939,
0.0136317452,
-0.0600241609,
0.0008282033,
0.0745228976,
-0.0081969351,
-0.0016913227,
0.0591641031,
0.0240416024,
-0.0072720791,
-0.0379717983,
0.0240967814,
0.0239015855,
0.0214456487,
0.0034278817,
-0.0485193171,
0.0179164559,
-0.0826862231,
0.0095940307,
-0.0451102033,
-0.0105757909,
-0.0123274177,
0.0290352907,
0.0179335754,
-0.0081182998,
-0.0072601917,
0.0016295661,
-0.0171595477,
-0.0207724776,
-0.0186515804,
0.0256902799,
-0.0038267134,
0.0047308789,
-0.0160623416,
-0.0089286296,
-0.0076370272,
-0.033696413,
0.0127975065,
-0.0096546328,
-0.000332604,
-0.0353417359,
0.0284325536,
-0.0162867419,
-0.0005153171,
-0.0205383357,
0.0301527437,
0.0759636611,
-0.038486179,
0.0189254675,
0.0662236139,
-0.0525720082,
0.0569398589,
0.0501249209,
-0.0072730044,
-0.0726183206,
0.0375383124,
0.0191283785,
0.0150908595,
-0.0212424751,
-0.0144191515,
-0.0047595366,
0.0778410211,
-0.0050583212,
0.0317733511,
-0.0157835986,
-0.0025651583,
0.0075393794,
-0.0234455857,
-0.0165535603,
-0.0151618551,
-0.0472612493,
0.0480997711,
-0.0113114929,
-0.0431490876,
0.0809571445,
-0.0032044565,
-0.0151781728,
-0.0245462693,
0.0182735398,
0.0010603897,
0.0667714328,
-0.0771226138,
-0.0176146887,
-0.0250972435,
-0.0145169459,
-0.0385675952,
0.0021193449,
0.0047408408,
-0.0215442535,
0.0796028152,
-0.0633513331,
-0.0055044149,
0.0027967039,
-0.030120831,
-0.0459485687,
0.0786472559,
-0.0454215258,
0.0346007682,
-0.0547084026,
-0.0317047685,
0.0060926541,
-0.0510226563,
0.0400578789,
-0.0000771383,
-0.022296818,
-0.0357676819,
-0.031136103,
-0.0070284326,
-0.0151928663,
0.0034729147,
0.0415797569,
-0.0836907402,
0.0785593688,
0.0545944832,
0.0539803095,
-0.0531999543,
-0.0261602383,
0.0074202535,
0.0437963828,
-0.0193318166,
-0.0329171456,
0.0172123928,
0.0627988204,
-0.0789268389,
-0.0241024401,
0.1116258502,
0.0192421172,
-0.0152129503,
0.0092357062,
-0.0879326239,
0.0408279747,
0.0408518724,
0.0238661543,
-0.0489022285,
-0.0233805403,
0.0354568027,
0.0070514353,
0.007381998,
-0.0143738789,
0.0033177913,
-0.101667434,
0.0467082672,
0.0079899719,
-0.0440301485,
0.0107434541,
-0.0063182604,
0.0141305653,
0.060620442,
0.008555931,
0.044315964,
-0.0060231993,
0.0103506558,
0.0379764736,
0.0194953624,
-0.0156916883,
0.0366387293,
0.0092694014,
0.0068080644,
-0.0061416519,
-0.0038303731,
-0.0131982556,
-0.0923506618,
0.0745063126,
-0.0164269749,
0.0441842787,
-0.0429374054,
-0.0229303278,
0.0029938014,
-0.0061520305,
-0.0167733375,
0.037496008,
-0.0082019176,
-0.0398803242,
0.0180969574,
0.134948194,
-0.0589706972,
-0.0077066435,
-0.0412128568,
-0.0180160515,
-0.0448142141,
0.0494486764,
0.0636378378,
-0.0158409588,
-0.0057023065,
-0.0395155475,
-0.0585359931,
0.006827632,
0.0077154124,
-0.0009701027,
-0.002888384,
0.0169254541,
-0.0093447641,
-0.0489612296,
0.061904557,
0.0602542236,
0.0062553552,
0.0383273847,
-0.0084856544,
-0.0117627699,
-0.0174535867,
0.0362315886,
-0.0241191182,
0.0362878889,
-0.0232753567,
-0.027772015,
-0.001800786,
-0.0260587614,
-0.0004539013,
-0.0081430739,
-0.0123842703,
-0.0559105054,
-0.0464279763,
0.0479083732,
0.0346746296,
0.0191019569,
0.0129128145,
-0.0337648503,
0.0172835458,
-0.0084152874,
-0.019432757,
0.0224224571,
0.0254376475,
0.0245021284,
0.0186460596,
0.0257122461,
-0.0231955331,
-0.0127323987,
0.0038483727,
0.042417068,
-0.0360756442,
-0.005152469,
0.0153047778,
0.0313239954,
0.0249549821,
-0.0015811746,
0.0190859437,
-0.0361750834,
0.0422272347,
-0.0261665471,
-0.0071266713,
-0.0226836372,
0.0015398905,
-0.0030496146,
0.001255439,
0.0117677432,
-0.0495796017,
0.0255952962,
0.0164307822,
-0.0078526353,
0.0528381951,
-0.0330618434,
0.0421580747,
0.0254042186,
0.0006482625,
-0.0118323229,
-0.0049349656,
-0.003548481,
0.0549338013,
0.00305719,
0.0901576206,
0.0425349139,
0.0192940142,
-0.0389037989,
-0.0008930426,
-0.0551626608,
-0.1435592026,
0.0517002679,
0.0426535904,
0.0159560647,
0.0179486424,
0.0051965783,
-0.0362122469,
0.0047458964,
0.0386692323,
0.0024130575,
0.0163289513,
-0.023810111,
0.0850418434,
0.0360158235,
0.0481028967,
-0.0342543237,
0.0016219434,
-0.0785333365,
0.0484844409,
-0.0121344104,
0.0216066651,
-0.0209514331,
-0.0270386338,
0.0135341855,
0.0087328544,
0.0111139966,
-0.0205772314,
-0.0825279132,
-0.0721518993,
0.0012467369,
0.0348697938,
-0.039234288,
-0.0487511382,
0.0628852844,
0.0514483936,
0.0188642256,
-0.0476427115,
0.0037563394,
-0.0067566182,
-0.0129585294,
-0.0181395039,
-0.0257692635,
-6.265043262e-33,
-0.0476054326,
-0.0237721466,
0.0740730688,
0.0421402156,
-0.0307054408,
-0.0343122222,
-0.0816837326,
0.0257929396,
-0.0267700218,
0.0157569498,
-0.0333332866,
0.0191238355,
0.0084527871,
-0.0314037949,
0.0486598052,
-0.0151471877,
0.0133509515,
0.004232761,
-0.0449346676,
0.0136815608,
0.0215902962,
0.0205485038,
0.0340949632,
-0.0468780436,
0.0271666311,
-0.0131475329,
0.0202844609,
-0.0024341301,
-0.1106661111,
0.0271968208,
-0.0195201617,
0.0161653329,
0.0117168091,
-0.0219935961,
-0.0194930937,
-0.0042565968,
-0.0570293218,
-0.0537883602,
0.0609991625,
-0.0048063835,
-0.0635627136,
-0.0482735448,
0.0234433524,
0.0421404392,
-0.0455112346,
-0.0190576576,
0.0220336858,
-0.0263325404,
-0.0201222207,
-0.0404325835,
-0.0498362258,
-0.0135198645,
-0.0017755232,
-0.0162561536,
0.005506773,
0.0021727325,
-0.0503419265,
-0.0092169112,
-0.005635194,
0.0085089505,
0.0457193181,
0.0043643704,
0.0793600231,
0.0202019606,
-0.0061033834,
0.0541206449,
0.0179867353,
-0.0336999148,
-0.0107470611,
0.0115708336,
0.0164689198,
0.0523545183,
0.014590269,
-0.0208181776,
0.0198349338,
0.0301259495,
-0.0350560248,
0.0046230275,
0.0178913847,
0.0659039244,
0.0050738952,
0.0019891874,
-0.0349607021,
-0.008407346,
-0.0428221412,
0.0431704558,
-0.0180750545,
-0.0444791093,
0.0261003319,
-0.0340988114,
0.01256923,
-0.0521433353,
-0.0110834315,
0.0040308693,
-0.0189462528,
-0.0176063832,
-0.0163191799,
0.0398244075,
-0.0150096472,
-0.0032060302,
-0.0677934065,
-0.0145306066,
-0.0195698589,
-0.0017077042,
0.042317342,
0.0350613147,
0.0109056085,
0.0125323264,
-0.0544588268,
-0.0112558845,
-0.0891172439,
-0.0162111968,
0.0398685485,
0.0129182301,
0.015692655,
-0.0031198522,
-0.0018018486,
0.0393222645,
-0.0483606197,
-0.047140874,
-0.030034272,
0.0486800224,
-0.0193507932,
0.0138866622,
-0.0235287547,
0.0010542874,
-0.0509459749,
0.0725573972,
0.0118088732,
-0.0778051242,
-0.0186762717,
0.0462543853,
3.051e-7,
0.0129697602,
-0.0004160538,
0.0111863613,
0.0341586657,
0.0162751023,
0.0155449677,
-0.0449300259,
-0.0371501334,
0.0414622352,
-0.036398638,
-0.0164175034,
0.063425988,
0.0169126298,
0.0138726421,
-0.1010537595,
0.0070840288,
-0.011479672,
-0.0048969975,
-0.0375854783,
-0.0067042476,
0.0608317181,
0.0008689071,
0.0397818387,
-0.0228142124,
0.0183365792,
0.0175964851,
0.0564982705,
-0.0246019587,
0.031156702,
-0.0158661027,
-0.0059919469,
0.0259831473,
-0.0027113236,
0.0177357886,
0.0049883584,
-0.0165502876,
-0.0564854443,
0.0313121527,
0.0006765607,
0.0008968663,
0.0014359206,
-0.03891287,
0.0112763215,
-0.0298967008,
0.0380901769,
-0.0031963871,
0.002319288,
0.0171825606,
-0.0004025887,
-0.0433318466,
-0.0164833795,
-0.0150715709,
0.0012507758,
-0.0284066685,
-0.0296313688,
-0.0261410885,
-0.0246428959,
-0.0549362674,
0.0007960479,
0.020848304,
-0.0116055747,
-0.0723560974,
-0.0268020667,
0.0003387231,
-0.005557463,
-0.0529301241,
-0.0480117686,
2.631793869e-34,
0.0023027454,
-0.003735766,
0.0542513803,
0.1100941449,
-0.0127932094,
0.0013678077,
0.0045447736,
0.0046874504,
0.0322685502,
-0.0380492285,
-0.0374143906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06111v1 | BYOC: Personalized Few-Shot Classification with Co-Authored Class Descriptions | 2023-10-09T19:37:38 | 2023-10-09T19:37:38 | Arth Bohra, Govert Verkes, Artem Harutyunyan, Pascal Weinberger, Giovanni Campagna | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text classification is a well-studied and versatile building block for many
NLP applications. Yet, existing approaches require either large annotated
corpora to train a model with or, when using large language models as a base,
require carefully crafting the prompt as well as using a long context that can
fit many examples. As a result, it is not possible for end-users to build
classifiers for themselves. To address this issue, we propose a novel approach
to few-shot text classification using an LLM. Rather than few-shot examples,
the LLM is prompted with descriptions of the salient features of each class.
These descriptions are coauthored by the user and the LLM interactively: while
the user annotates each few-shot example, the LLM asks relevant questions that
the user answers. Examples, questions, and answers are summarized to form the
classification prompt. Our experiments show that our approach yields high
accuracy classifiers, within 82% of the performance of models trained with
significantly larger datasets while using only 1% of their training sets.
Additionally, in a study with 30 participants, we show that end-users are able
to build classifiers to suit their specific needs. The personalized classifiers
show an average accuracy of 90%, which is 15% higher than the state-of-the-art
approach. | [
0.0381965041,
0.0067779617,
-0.0036716105,
0.021849826,
-0.0471145622,
0.0412139036,
0.0591209494,
-0.0012641586,
0.0321153998,
-0.1087888852,
-0.0221679322,
0.0039646775,
-0.0339586735,
-0.0102624949,
-0.0317638107,
-0.05019347,
0.0061077629,
-0.003981804,
0.0068139997,
0.0105754314,
0.0231685992,
0.0302572623,
-0.012062192,
0.0148674157,
0.0253456999,
-0.0286283512,
-0.0291754752,
-0.005709454,
-0.0172592886,
-0.0225893836,
0.0138544934,
0.0837358162,
0.0023756344,
0.0096960617,
0.0000018618,
-0.0515014604,
0.0033099162,
-0.0044242684,
-0.0451183692,
-0.0075195269,
0.0421815701,
0.0356819779,
0.0432787351,
-0.0139103131,
-0.0320479386,
-0.0082987994,
0.0243109744,
0.0418566763,
0.0491938926,
0.0482753441,
-0.0036799673,
-0.0329516679,
-0.0102775712,
0.0090444954,
0.0804490298,
-0.005480676,
-0.0090307947,
-0.0334914401,
0.0291821342,
0.0325549357,
0.0099173812,
0.0167898014,
0.0056637535,
0.0026050117,
0.0623449162,
0.0403481312,
-0.0330472998,
-0.0122604128,
-0.0095668193,
0.0734787658,
0.0345553383,
-0.0393221602,
-0.0030661665,
-0.0276672784,
0.018687116,
0.0145029081,
-0.0231309813,
-0.0172429513,
-0.0311873034,
-0.0081972703,
-0.013236681,
0.02891808,
0.0064970283,
0.0464576297,
0.0258383695,
-0.0217597373,
-0.0188945774,
-0.0191813353,
-0.0080865491,
0.0339474939,
0.0166517384,
-0.0695348084,
-0.012877956,
0.0457640626,
0.0094175041,
-0.0109194806,
-0.0498071425,
-0.0314854383,
0.043332912,
-0.0439088605,
0.0330226831,
-0.0032608034,
-0.0111124972,
0.0625291914,
-0.0277447365,
-0.0263574664,
0.0413706973,
0.0143347355,
-0.002490269,
0.0226444267,
-0.1062602997,
-0.0010833191,
-0.0316044092,
0.088283658,
0.0243039578,
0.0135428989,
-0.0503414944,
0.0532422066,
0.015569008,
0.0300002415,
-0.0063506491,
0.0380153544,
-0.0023517627,
0.0098367371,
-0.0299570449,
-0.0161297973,
-0.0555459037,
0.0136058191,
0.0030418772,
-0.022029154,
0.0181316584,
0.0282260794,
0.020832058,
-0.0081976643,
0.0208395831,
0.0184732191,
-0.0067046438,
-0.082235679,
-0.0220155735,
-0.0504165255,
-0.0218602046,
-0.0330150314,
-0.0509726331,
-0.0556224063,
0.0308974124,
0.029697638,
-0.0099615073,
-0.0096420338,
0.0026144728,
0.0399279632,
-0.0019382725,
0.0939726755,
-0.052551914,
-0.0288674254,
0.0709351748,
0.0279868934,
0.0038157378,
0.0520313829,
0.0042231977,
0.0388104953,
0.049573455,
-0.0078535937,
0.0543422289,
-0.0148312608,
-0.0310394615,
-0.0223992299,
0.0156469624,
0.0338741615,
-0.02934031,
0.0228559393,
-0.0272357203,
0.0083314162,
-0.0007392818,
0.0048232567,
0.0467042513,
0.0849659368,
0.04666996,
0.0099598123,
0.0192899499,
0.0379583165,
0.0116230296,
-0.0096338931,
-0.0089006806,
0.0493226387,
-0.0410869122,
-0.0268967953,
0.0056174733,
-0.0214395896,
-0.0358424187,
-0.0688296854,
-0.0377658941,
-0.0379709639,
0.0027499816,
0.0446716286,
0.0429770797,
0.0055163419,
0.0145931412,
0.024288293,
0.0182099584,
-0.0623133779,
0.0107548041,
-0.0409808047,
0.0531970561,
0.0783968717,
0.0148747545,
-0.031089047,
-0.0095426049,
-0.0385032333,
0.0322168544,
-0.0087070912,
0.0786718577,
-0.0161014628,
0.0069100359,
-0.0268418174,
-0.0282271169,
-0.0156286824,
0.0035613328,
0.0058179977,
-0.0004138256,
0.0100900959,
0.0252156071,
-0.0005875668,
-0.0128459912,
0.0501427501,
0.018083455,
-0.0766200051,
0.0727216005,
0.0373867191,
0.0080778487,
0.0373071656,
0.0311377402,
-0.0076090619,
0.0199050065,
-0.0176516622,
-0.0391904078,
-0.0157625154,
0.0120227057,
-0.0342888795,
-0.0057636886,
0.0379505865,
0.0083476761,
-0.0253751278,
-0.0293812677,
-0.0226404406,
-0.0236542448,
-0.0134362653,
0.0079173539,
-0.0828794762,
0.0058657844,
0.0034346567,
0.0062484914,
-0.0563531071,
0.0666726977,
0.0457120128,
0.0133095374,
-0.0090864878,
-0.0454707444,
0.0352346525,
-0.029624043,
-0.0281679127,
-0.0191261712,
0.0079915691,
0.0132530089,
0.0082602967,
0.0086305905,
-0.0267341193,
-0.004885633,
-0.0860859677,
0.0005959628,
-0.0178483874,
0.0287908539,
-0.0095122708,
-0.0162701793,
0.0019354376,
-0.0285888072,
-0.0560579561,
0.0078226784,
-0.0235532317,
0.0223754831,
0.0605639704,
0.014066725,
0.0259587746,
-0.0028161029,
0.00867966,
-0.0199884064,
0.041271802,
0.043745283,
-0.0199799817,
-0.05730436,
-0.0342510752,
0.0027274156,
-0.005322211,
0.0454700254,
0.0035095839,
-0.0117701087,
-0.0171720423,
-0.0526883341,
0.0568518005,
-0.003474579,
0.0548093766,
0.0500167273,
0.047947824,
-0.0472308993,
0.0094071496,
-0.0078764549,
0.019424906,
0.007615366,
-0.0184612907,
0.0306325182,
0.0454573967,
-0.0052676583,
0.0024253137,
-0.0619021133,
0.0290139485,
0.018698385,
0.0237690117,
-0.0472406149,
0.0144633511,
0.0048445314,
0.0147351697,
0.0153196342,
-0.0176952351,
0.0735562444,
-0.014291699,
0.0032054712,
-0.0134896412,
-0.0647831857,
-0.048034057,
0.0658386424,
-0.0041460386,
0.004735284,
0.0231140312,
0.0067822528,
-0.0110173961,
-0.020977132,
0.0343629569,
-0.0052032853,
0.0052947756,
-0.0098099802,
0.0086825639,
-0.0196923185,
-0.0681402758,
-0.015273477,
-0.1197355837,
-0.0535662062,
-0.0131531004,
-0.0430800952,
0.0221785363,
-0.0098019745,
0.0006240904,
0.0165325124,
0.0173833482,
-0.0222856924,
-0.0450245142,
0.0104500838,
0.041069515,
0.0306271203,
-0.022713054,
-0.0581236929,
-0.004951098,
0.044870507,
0.0573558472,
0.0068175313,
0.0385542214,
-0.0155378319,
-0.0261766966,
0.0305693652,
-0.0853123143,
-0.0439475216,
0.0083412519,
0.0454470478,
-0.0557012558,
0.0089082364,
0.104516536,
0.050701227,
-0.076162003,
-0.0121017266,
0.0134153469,
0.00383911,
0.040490035,
0.0432560369,
-0.0966294333,
-0.0671700016,
-0.0328534991,
0.0255225934,
-0.0246411338,
0.0053761117,
-0.0217129495,
-0.0798017532,
0.0059856167,
-0.0138322124,
-0.0240615848,
0.0418322571,
-0.0632891506,
-0.0067587364,
0.0000219756,
-0.0590167455,
-0.0348195508,
-0.0337946601,
0.0106071373,
0.0154042793,
-0.043073412,
-0.017477775,
0.0268160533,
-0.0002534227,
0.0098256273,
0.0451873392,
0.0141184414,
-0.0022557455,
-0.0291457195,
0.0116517106,
-0.0262633096,
0.042114377,
-0.017097421,
0.1055342779,
-0.0591050684,
0.0220456105,
-0.0060441699,
0.0266110692,
0.0048673041,
-0.0352608003,
0.048841428,
0.0618271865,
-0.0216819756,
0.0077792117,
-0.0378985554,
0.0012466031,
0.0040857783,
0.0638058633,
0.0202383287,
-0.0965762958,
-0.0133347828,
-0.0178333484,
-0.030957181,
-0.0538476631,
-0.0175711084,
0.0117976163,
-0.008387899,
-0.0289686546,
-0.0439834595,
-0.0372164473,
0.0501897782,
0.0196585655,
0.0113212476,
0.0256303567,
-0.0502859317,
0.0338332802,
-0.0321423486,
0.0051425314,
-0.0085122418,
0.0038161273,
-0.0473409258,
-0.0244074743,
0.0761762485,
-0.0613557138,
0.0094552906,
-0.0314845815,
-0.0866005048,
-0.032039728,
-0.0350548476,
0.0569868945,
0.0125689404,
0.0119276168,
-0.0055377288,
-0.1072916538,
0.0630259737,
0.0816760212,
-0.0266932547,
-0.0442955755,
0.0094202105,
0.0495323986,
-0.0285298508,
0.0158722922,
-0.0563342795,
0.0001872241,
0.0037645788,
-0.0547152869,
-0.0918232277,
-0.0226977691,
0.0082635339,
-0.0039714538,
0.0731172189,
-0.0306527577,
-0.0164082795,
0.0166393649,
0.0342463478,
-0.0041062864,
-0.0450491235,
-0.0040064971,
-0.0102711832,
-0.0028537684,
-0.0617075674,
-0.0202711355,
0.0164024346,
-0.0249263477,
0.0432318337,
-0.0682907924,
0.0121077951,
0.0299392324,
-0.0100992275,
-0.0235244296,
0.0224584732,
-0.0501538441,
0.0080556516,
0.0312112235,
0.0166104846,
-0.0114514548,
0.0745447576,
-0.0260328278,
0.0204507504,
-0.0098343333,
0.0400682911,
-0.0676462129,
0.0063975481,
0.0000739479,
0.0490802191,
0.0171210337,
-0.0087015554,
-0.0311107766,
-0.0249470174,
-0.0312035549,
-0.0228430554,
0.059274856,
-0.0141231762,
-0.0476929061,
0.0145836705,
0.0266644638,
-0.0424007364,
-0.0023320941,
0.0573549233,
-0.0087624453,
-0.0001192748,
0.0338336416,
-0.0270416103,
-0.0661475435,
0.022536654,
0.0263183862,
0.0454096422,
-0.0150801875,
0.0000621331,
-0.0633859187,
-0.0118865939,
0.0416931398,
-0.0419392139,
0.0072115208,
0.006105057,
0.027998399,
0.0526308268,
0.002456733,
-0.0280242506,
-0.060905803,
0.0170018505,
-0.0075537497,
0.0089427242,
-0.0102436291,
-5.770599481e-33,
-0.0141297504,
-0.0442960039,
-0.0071234223,
0.0458917245,
0.0653672069,
-0.0203122552,
0.0325971097,
0.0360298902,
0.0147810997,
-0.0126992818,
-0.0092627183,
-0.0290431362,
0.0045269653,
0.0332929455,
0.0437309481,
-0.022883594,
0.0419147573,
-0.0049281972,
-0.0140829217,
0.0280322712,
0.0258305818,
0.014516999,
0.0165780745,
-0.077008374,
0.0519239157,
-0.0090828817,
-0.0224466883,
-0.0149481427,
-0.0019069822,
0.0528578274,
-0.0063828346,
0.0488994718,
0.0386901163,
0.01730223,
0.0225040708,
0.0269992221,
-0.0583419465,
-0.0327302888,
-0.0335188508,
0.0137304822,
-0.0248378906,
-0.0471179485,
0.0331479758,
-0.0255058482,
-0.0015091886,
-0.0277431421,
0.0858429894,
-0.0055700387,
-0.0311137643,
-0.0654906034,
-0.0149757266,
0.0072744377,
-0.0035219386,
-0.0323022045,
0.0265760813,
0.0434660688,
-0.0101615107,
0.0142592471,
-0.0448305234,
0.0043091164,
-0.0019053865,
0.0032921846,
0.026648717,
0.0042447299,
-0.0267307814,
0.0583502501,
0.0401586443,
0.0144023616,
-0.0166241247,
-0.004969914,
-0.0056789047,
0.0066312524,
0.0417798944,
0.1059472114,
0.0731122494,
-0.0021882665,
-0.0055486872,
0.0555428527,
0.0438559763,
-0.0054010246,
0.0052672611,
0.0116411485,
-0.0484639443,
-0.008591041,
-0.0255092047,
-0.0325460806,
-0.0499125831,
-0.0333965681,
-0.0070098951,
0.0107539278,
-0.0210595988,
0.0135260513,
-0.0032074463,
-0.0043045636,
-0.0519626141,
-0.0386973582,
-0.0035539274,
0.0319920629,
0.0002979334,
-0.0392535552,
-0.0298418216,
-0.0101793874,
-0.0153815458,
-0.0116173234,
0.0416283719,
0.0103292391,
0.0991733074,
0.0119806007,
-0.079258576,
-0.0242767129,
0.0160130765,
-0.0020889428,
0.010746697,
0.0327860862,
0.0024637422,
0.0192279425,
-0.0293448288,
0.0811009407,
-0.000853032,
-0.0089913867,
-0.0238858853,
-0.0515859462,
-0.0047782282,
-0.0050625303,
-0.0020449611,
0.0015736644,
0.0120996516,
0.0116369408,
0.0303065982,
-0.0315866917,
0.0081132455,
-0.0080426196,
2.503e-7,
0.0250222925,
0.0475976095,
-0.0200520102,
-0.0216950569,
-0.0058213198,
0.0633132309,
0.017124448,
0.0371453762,
-0.0147906132,
0.0041571981,
0.0301210731,
0.0228638891,
0.0434577242,
0.0351256952,
-0.1052507907,
-0.0009839475,
-0.0280269254,
0.0495773144,
-0.0625350028,
-0.0052363593,
0.0869292542,
0.0430365913,
0.0653079227,
0.0025516192,
-0.0056218663,
-0.0557650253,
0.0627350807,
-0.0336808711,
-0.0006886841,
-0.0008451521,
0.0305932797,
0.0199920554,
-0.0240925383,
0.016817579,
-0.0530699305,
-0.0360063836,
-0.0041387547,
0.0661845356,
-0.0354132168,
-0.0582113042,
-0.000443959,
0.0040118466,
0.0190188475,
0.0041442779,
0.0931161419,
-0.0651768073,
-0.0220023822,
-0.0107453931,
0.0089757033,
-0.0274287183,
0.0489623956,
-0.0070229741,
-0.0059080645,
0.0241915844,
0.0021994503,
-0.026917547,
-0.0567661189,
-0.0874017477,
-0.0165348947,
0.0005329978,
-0.0182828587,
0.0227671154,
-0.0281669907,
0.0038753618,
0.0257024877,
-0.0659780204,
0.0103634922,
1.940845636e-34,
-0.0024077957,
0.0467118695,
0.0052383067,
0.0233562905,
0.0019095998,
0.0235894825,
-0.0023394024,
0.0009000582,
0.0651051104,
-0.0482880622,
0.0198295694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06103v1 | Leveraging Multilingual Self-Supervised Pretrained Models for Sequence-to-Sequence End-to-End Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-10-09T19:22:51 | 2023-10-09T19:22:51 | Pavel Denisov, Ngoc Thang Vu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | A number of methods have been proposed for End-to-End Spoken Language
Understanding (E2E-SLU) using pretrained models, however their evaluation often
lacks multilingual setup and tasks that require prediction of lexical fillers,
such as slot filling. In this work, we propose a unified method that integrates
multilingual pretrained speech and text models and performs E2E-SLU on six
datasets in four languages in a generative manner, including the prediction of
lexical fillers. We investigate how the proposed method can be improved by
pretraining on widely available speech recognition data using several training
objectives. Pretraining on 7000 hours of multilingual data allows us to
outperform the state-of-the-art ultimately on two SLU datasets and partly on
two more SLU datasets. Finally, we examine the cross-lingual capabilities of
the proposed model and improve on the best known result on the
PortMEDIA-Language dataset by almost half, achieving a Concept/Value Error Rate
of 23.65%. | [
-0.0127942376,
0.0525891781,
0.020032648,
0.0270891525,
0.0173095986,
0.0113921529,
0.0155185526,
-0.0400275104,
-0.0056163771,
-0.0155106345,
-0.0396908261,
-0.0429353081,
0.0265606474,
0.0215091947,
0.0120628932,
-0.0247401316,
0.0346929096,
-0.047640346,
-0.023931833,
0.0110829193,
0.0001101236,
0.0399262384,
-0.0439421572,
0.0097145364,
0.0067907651,
-0.025833277,
-0.0445110835,
-0.0079570841,
0.0002319995,
-0.0198705774,
-0.0206148345,
0.054981567,
0.0254629198,
0.0281225108,
0.0000021858,
-0.0538052656,
-0.02544198,
-0.0443211943,
-0.0865361318,
0.0237664077,
-0.0372700207,
-0.0076126656,
0.003361562,
0.0050654393,
-0.0131497886,
-0.0375040472,
0.0404988155,
0.0067436914,
0.04000571,
0.0473768562,
-0.000879964,
-0.0092871198,
-0.0007149542,
-0.0376081616,
0.0098509472,
-0.0462869927,
0.0208147373,
0.0124227684,
-0.0098769227,
-0.0372582376,
-0.0212926548,
0.067737624,
0.026524052,
-0.0028782184,
0.0127774421,
0.0099742198,
-0.0413641445,
-0.046626471,
-0.0430220775,
0.0852452815,
-0.0385207087,
-0.0410776436,
-0.0022989952,
-0.0148630189,
-0.0171297435,
-0.0235989168,
-0.0088042635,
0.0214897394,
0.0159310643,
-0.0110380873,
0.0345524475,
0.0334976353,
0.0477682203,
-0.0037496912,
-0.0490153581,
0.0642105266,
-0.0045006052,
-0.0244059153,
0.0060970457,
-0.0298093203,
0.0303945523,
-0.0533174798,
0.0200490467,
0.0303098951,
-0.026340533,
0.0394731425,
-0.032535363,
-0.0424824357,
-0.0095710615,
-0.0326668993,
0.0071291709,
0.0856040865,
-0.0781537294,
0.037915539,
-0.0085915243,
0.0388924927,
-0.006542176,
-0.0075245826,
-0.0585319065,
0.004491224,
-0.0246585589,
-0.0040828669,
-0.0398771614,
-0.0105941817,
-0.0553023629,
-0.0307120495,
-0.0200592466,
-0.0068238238,
0.0136106154,
0.0213561263,
0.0157899987,
-0.0271083396,
-0.0477859378,
-0.0093986774,
0.0067048157,
0.0661073253,
-0.0171917304,
-0.00513242,
-0.0350060463,
-0.0384065621,
-0.0320260711,
0.0235344302,
0.0170871913,
-0.0151459044,
0.0073713884,
0.0285383947,
-0.0039879666,
-0.0331700779,
-0.0347246937,
0.0103097288,
-0.0233948417,
-0.07895834,
-0.0279229786,
-0.0521176346,
0.0562991649,
-0.0029952496,
0.0106800748,
-0.0223899446,
0.0050794715,
-0.0399506651,
0.0186962541,
0.1100487709,
-0.04379756,
0.0283738282,
0.012478062,
0.0040464369,
0.0471066833,
0.0704991296,
-0.0069825635,
0.0127618834,
0.041965887,
-0.0318557173,
-0.0055687455,
0.069405891,
0.0285968035,
-0.0130311726,
0.008849781,
0.0186257754,
0.0468827076,
0.0165270679,
0.0594831035,
-0.0367817767,
-0.023000963,
-0.0094343452,
0.0114948647,
0.0250300243,
0.0474288985,
0.0041996278,
0.058500886,
0.0405503102,
0.008992455,
0.0092383213,
-0.0186531898,
-0.0035513353,
0.0139414156,
0.0275528915,
0.0372245312,
0.0217172671,
-0.0272460114,
-0.0451922901,
-0.0022108371,
-0.0314653516,
-0.0015560403,
0.0232558437,
0.0530079976,
0.0150091108,
-0.0521190464,
0.0718378201,
0.018265672,
-0.044321157,
0.049203001,
0.0115626166,
-0.0070111505,
0.0753991306,
-0.010083002,
-0.0223586932,
-0.0655782148,
-0.0283051357,
-0.0000413626,
0.0024978512,
0.0022281513,
0.0082104988,
0.0686953664,
-0.0813142061,
-0.031946633,
-0.0033425197,
-0.0233187973,
0.1002180427,
-0.0630481467,
0.0055426308,
0.0117616812,
-0.0573123023,
0.0054720184,
0.0115936631,
-0.0525597073,
-0.0204921253,
0.0063728299,
0.0282759499,
0.0492827222,
0.05265278,
-0.0045385323,
-0.0327408314,
0.0285717119,
-0.0054815919,
0.0014390451,
0.0347561873,
-0.092798464,
-0.0449689515,
0.0237989016,
-0.002887703,
-0.0506592803,
0.0094496729,
-0.0163237806,
-0.1026018783,
-0.0022615234,
0.0396917202,
0.0166935008,
-0.0704140738,
0.0336359441,
0.0310515556,
0.0404796712,
0.0260786023,
0.0121937329,
0.0059596081,
0.017685011,
0.0653932542,
-0.0019711803,
0.064771831,
-0.0597441681,
-0.0404625759,
0.0416373312,
-0.0406356119,
-0.0176393446,
0.0019107696,
0.0149572156,
-0.0456800498,
0.0316825919,
-0.1029340476,
0.0031580201,
-0.0286223982,
0.0395523682,
0.0345581397,
0.0338988155,
-0.0198569056,
-0.0570318252,
-0.0212939102,
-0.0692014247,
0.0291217808,
-0.0491119586,
0.0012820142,
0.0381003506,
0.0088032046,
-0.02968885,
0.0275543984,
-0.0053229691,
0.0106069706,
-0.0157883391,
-0.0404873081,
-0.0457789898,
-0.0082301954,
0.0029580367,
0.0373466462,
-0.0194182917,
-0.0516284294,
-0.0366558097,
0.0098702591,
0.0035310925,
0.028417049,
-0.0048653958,
-0.0248646773,
0.0393757038,
-0.060399387,
-0.0542229824,
0.0362931825,
-0.0040830248,
0.0307908207,
-0.0509712249,
0.037772987,
-0.0075883516,
0.0898948759,
-0.0013039212,
0.0179196168,
-0.044915162,
-0.0352799222,
-0.0064096102,
-0.0258144382,
-0.0305999611,
-0.0268356632,
-0.0179429464,
0.0606228858,
-0.0117063858,
-0.0143518476,
0.0474648215,
-0.1112898663,
-0.056483496,
-0.0596748106,
-0.0141559206,
-0.0226800721,
0.0316734761,
0.0016486875,
0.0090377266,
0.0150550753,
-0.0629029945,
-0.0161434356,
-0.0054324605,
0.0018354495,
-0.0011758897,
0.0053021172,
-0.024193529,
0.0089824153,
0.0078318538,
-0.0234993789,
-0.0505150892,
-0.0148172108,
-0.0369912945,
-0.0263557285,
-0.0058089909,
-0.0214838404,
-0.0209554583,
0.0231403578,
-0.016989382,
0.0492887236,
0.0087891072,
0.0314376764,
-0.0136712063,
0.0171029046,
-0.0034318573,
0.0293146428,
-0.0370242707,
0.0054577584,
0.0544745401,
-0.0166560654,
0.0136743831,
-0.0083289742,
-0.0210103989,
0.0280301329,
0.0579381064,
-0.0359667838,
-0.0247059502,
0.002306029,
0.0386821441,
-0.073696889,
0.0486313254,
0.1408850104,
-0.0091948211,
0.0038592487,
-0.0376563668,
-0.0035601358,
-0.0263492595,
0.0310968999,
0.0355233476,
-0.0824367553,
-0.0494959913,
0.0215016846,
0.0041490695,
0.0380330347,
0.004589125,
-0.0175184403,
-0.1196110919,
0.0404029414,
-0.0049326532,
-0.0966198668,
-0.0019582717,
-0.0208064467,
-0.0145779541,
-0.0244245026,
0.0132029383,
-0.0017136156,
-0.0019829771,
-0.0207333043,
0.0326084979,
-0.0580308549,
-0.0272340961,
0.0337533727,
0.0077722305,
0.0761292204,
0.0228382833,
0.0425533503,
-0.0004494874,
0.0086391848,
0.0190543234,
-0.0186524373,
-0.0190928485,
-0.0054273764,
0.0419749543,
-0.0124067366,
-0.0426599011,
0.0650651604,
0.0365972146,
-0.0234609582,
0.0220511425,
0.0071265469,
0.0355010629,
0.0110218627,
0.0288007353,
0.0331172533,
0.0370355286,
0.0494690873,
0.056680046,
0.0196570922,
-0.0094437506,
-0.0053629805,
-0.0080731167,
0.0384318493,
-0.0583575591,
-0.0047074435,
0.0433544666,
0.0022972799,
-0.0533226989,
-0.0053360108,
-0.0461909771,
0.0169034973,
0.0236612931,
0.0264949743,
0.0243953038,
0.0110782403,
-0.0042588362,
-0.0343698412,
0.0492173694,
0.0042621084,
0.0195836481,
-0.0578634143,
-0.0282067377,
-0.0088643879,
-0.0658482313,
-0.0203598272,
0.0217831638,
-0.0540602766,
-0.0291961227,
0.0043426747,
0.0507661924,
0.0157370809,
0.1127615571,
-0.0311128572,
0.0052636503,
0.037405055,
0.0080129132,
-0.0766486898,
-0.0491178595,
0.0755152628,
0.0101890452,
-0.0177149735,
0.0210206099,
-0.0291015003,
0.0204164479,
-0.0216751564,
0.0101907179,
-0.0117398249,
-0.0392493792,
0.0218521822,
0.0051946701,
0.0687663481,
-0.026014274,
0.0217489377,
-0.0582448319,
0.0466941446,
-0.006826885,
-0.0026869443,
-0.0298761036,
-0.000002764,
0.0426387116,
-0.0302718673,
0.0313998237,
-0.0242276695,
-0.0329457335,
-0.0308245439,
0.0085524702,
0.0357708372,
0.0462505743,
-0.0108981933,
0.0135050733,
0.0035310427,
0.0054534585,
0.0237026718,
0.0549330525,
0.0490909852,
-0.0085890573,
0.0456822515,
-0.0165609624,
0.0165238883,
0.0216961857,
0.0283032395,
-0.0195532497,
-0.043187771,
-0.0032140042,
0.0114719942,
0.0309495814,
-0.053386867,
0.0462205634,
0.0050087869,
0.022068711,
-0.0098054642,
0.0480194427,
-0.0293000899,
-0.0073419651,
0.0124509474,
-0.0198775306,
-0.0243802797,
0.0191156119,
0.0590091348,
0.0112742716,
0.0387352183,
0.0327446237,
0.0332775749,
-0.0504048765,
-0.0575195029,
-0.0006647372,
0.0209507477,
-0.074937582,
-0.0059951223,
-0.0120601421,
-0.0728093833,
-0.0021613815,
0.0146287326,
-0.0300327223,
0.029969275,
0.0137441009,
0.0498434529,
-0.0371845551,
0.0384438895,
-0.020235572,
-0.0286188349,
0.0042515039,
-0.0035134831,
0.0190602988,
-6.356062524e-33,
-0.0352232493,
-0.0034002583,
-0.0068858811,
-0.0021574479,
0.0070319129,
0.0133431768,
-0.0130921267,
-0.0100494772,
0.0247305743,
-0.0234697685,
0.0124920746,
-0.0035730244,
0.029727418,
0.0417111814,
0.0174762625,
-0.0009809626,
0.0721517652,
0.0232203621,
-0.0245569982,
0.0086547304,
0.0182115082,
0.0787087157,
0.0883559734,
0.003604759,
0.0341044776,
0.0006362679,
-0.0097031901,
0.0313688293,
0.0290762093,
0.0405810736,
-0.0017419382,
0.0317851193,
-0.0043853261,
-0.0569921657,
-0.0376617275,
0.0249948837,
-0.1258505285,
-0.0361551307,
0.0308508463,
0.056330096,
-0.0233610608,
0.0357250236,
-0.0082595246,
-0.0164131764,
0.0337309688,
0.0099418014,
0.0339485519,
0.0130455354,
0.0091653271,
-0.009050237,
-0.0278807357,
0.0241507813,
-0.081408985,
-0.0605006181,
0.0753013641,
0.0784046128,
0.0018440426,
-0.0320232734,
-0.0828442723,
0.0193365607,
-0.0286433585,
0.0059833732,
0.0797587261,
0.0115647148,
0.000836704,
0.0223513879,
0.034758877,
-0.035236761,
0.0245587304,
0.0240698755,
0.0017416239,
-0.0099323932,
-0.0385810062,
0.0156505909,
0.0530997515,
0.0130816502,
-0.0163806491,
0.0332350582,
-0.0217803847,
0.041407939,
-0.0234179311,
-0.0015358813,
-0.015565631,
-0.0034599295,
-0.0622934252,
-0.0360416584,
-0.0068413164,
-0.0386002809,
0.0419950224,
-0.0110290134,
-0.0230157748,
-0.004276555,
0.0659958571,
-0.026275171,
-0.0129482308,
0.0194913074,
-0.0146054951,
-0.0425728075,
-0.0092171263,
0.0913781375,
-0.0511189103,
-0.0297541935,
0.0005324899,
0.0385362096,
0.0136051122,
-0.0174637362,
-0.0017012237,
0.0218816753,
-0.041678302,
0.0277167745,
-0.0449397229,
0.0190387461,
-0.0452869274,
0.0434167609,
0.0633357391,
0.0059768907,
-0.0299987514,
0.069096081,
0.0091824736,
0.0079489266,
-0.0097318767,
-0.0632185489,
0.0210420862,
0.0353316031,
-0.0252851099,
-0.0225615837,
-0.02729485,
-0.0219028313,
0.0322367176,
-0.0237090122,
0.0301384106,
0.0328893177,
2.811e-7,
0.0378771424,
0.000132978,
0.0319628231,
0.0117587475,
-0.0018791223,
0.0159324892,
-0.0356549136,
-0.0243050624,
-0.0054212897,
-0.0026732336,
0.0263282806,
0.0147594595,
0.0418411568,
0.0087019019,
-0.109941721,
-0.0179466791,
-0.0404835008,
0.0076846792,
-0.0735532567,
0.0056755226,
0.0102983024,
0.0904422775,
-0.0208818726,
-0.0047629066,
0.0112692863,
-0.0298080966,
0.0070867487,
-0.0218694918,
-0.0101993969,
0.0256467648,
0.0099859582,
0.0487215668,
-0.0115719503,
0.040169064,
-0.0372306369,
0.0479402766,
0.0047206609,
0.0352831185,
0.0205843393,
-0.0250135642,
-0.0070056226,
0.024250064,
-0.0244855434,
-0.0546192713,
0.0563164204,
-0.0514247678,
-0.0112680662,
-0.0341650322,
-0.0366877429,
-0.0028907522,
0.0446457118,
0.0137572791,
0.0123323705,
0.0560957566,
0.0174464118,
-0.0510813519,
-0.04167917,
-0.058970809,
-0.0303774551,
-0.0039307787,
-0.012108624,
0.0417353734,
-0.0244560558,
-0.0765230134,
0.0393308997,
-0.0083270874,
-0.0068688807,
1.903620692e-34,
0.0335335508,
-0.0145299137,
0.0115459599,
0.0036118987,
0.0265460629,
-0.0462805666,
-0.0217062067,
0.0258262325,
0.0100787394,
-0.0165837295,
-0.0063106171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06061v1 | Auditing Gender Analyzers on Text Data | 2023-10-09T18:13:07 | 2023-10-09T18:13:07 | Siddharth D Jaiswal, Ankit Kumar Verma, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | AI models have become extremely popular and accessible to the general public.
However, they are continuously under the scanner due to their demonstrable
biases toward various sections of the society like people of color and
non-binary people. In this study, we audit three existing gender analyzers --
uClassify, Readable and HackerFactor, for biases against non-binary
individuals. These tools are designed to predict only the cisgender binary
labels, which leads to discrimination against non-binary members of the
society. We curate two datasets -- Reddit comments (660k) and, Tumblr posts
(2.05M) and our experimental evaluation shows that the tools are highly
inaccurate with the overall accuracy being ~50% on all platforms. Predictions
for non-binary comments on all platforms are mostly female, thus propagating
the societal bias that non-binary individuals are effeminate. To address this,
we fine-tune a BERT multi-label classifier on the two datasets in multiple
combinations, observe an overall performance of ~77% on the most realistically
deployable setting and a surprisingly higher performance of 90% for the
non-binary class. We also audit ChatGPT using zero-shot prompts on a small
dataset (due to high pricing) and observe an average accuracy of 58% for Reddit
and Tumblr combined (with overall better results for Reddit).
Thus, we show that existing systems, including highly advanced ones like
ChatGPT are biased, and need better audits and moderation and, that such
societal biases can be addressed and alleviated through simple off-the-shelf
models like BERT trained on more gender inclusive datasets. | [
0.0626004636,
0.0991663188,
-0.0179158114,
0.0078727966,
0.0057681818,
0.0234217998,
0.0786272585,
-0.0034792696,
0.0323525853,
-0.077343747,
-0.0033484439,
-0.0345356427,
0.0074571599,
0.0267998558,
0.0058955983,
-0.0026296426,
-0.0002306328,
0.0240237918,
0.0148986001,
-0.0099697597,
0.0312394314,
0.0312622041,
0.0031905582,
0.0740843341,
0.0025256434,
-0.0313372016,
0.032915011,
0.0127917491,
-0.0090019321,
0.0117578609,
0.0885143504,
0.0533665605,
-0.0409976617,
0.0694188476,
0.0000019496,
-0.0644315854,
-0.0012584295,
0.0445999727,
0.0024892008,
-0.0069105257,
0.0135376276,
0.0024042039,
-0.0227404144,
0.0455269553,
-0.0173042919,
0.0000229895,
0.03983628,
0.0299880616,
0.0630584881,
0.0408490449,
-0.0224168655,
0.004395721,
-0.0228872616,
0.0040209373,
0.0122916503,
-0.0082947696,
0.0351963378,
-0.0576121025,
-0.0144978222,
0.0090793381,
-0.007970186,
0.020517882,
0.0092138806,
-0.0277620498,
0.0208135284,
0.0345993526,
-0.0439585112,
-0.0725938976,
0.0047184112,
0.0519524738,
0.0142449327,
0.0064949114,
0.0428508967,
0.0225873236,
0.0111987414,
-0.0146714486,
-0.0274993274,
0.0343182571,
-0.0444326736,
-0.024951715,
-0.0548044369,
-0.0556021221,
0.0379153751,
0.0601095557,
0.0046727997,
0.0439524613,
-0.0078709861,
-0.0576267578,
0.0031145194,
0.0135668004,
0.0376477502,
-0.0531464517,
0.0468399674,
-0.013666926,
-0.0046927654,
-0.007582786,
-0.0238423776,
-0.024511721,
0.0270179883,
-0.0233437531,
0.019880861,
0.0276979059,
-0.0172731914,
0.0240419563,
-0.0252355523,
0.0342299864,
0.0275870264,
0.0406031199,
0.0166457966,
-0.0369446687,
-0.02180879,
-0.0051225978,
-0.0265644658,
-0.015854476,
0.0192171894,
0.0339584276,
-0.0260322969,
-0.0084933722,
-0.0638744161,
0.0137738911,
0.0151994396,
0.0103253564,
0.0028018644,
0.0333395712,
0.0093259001,
-0.023952201,
-0.0445993766,
0.0076246867,
-0.0267128032,
-0.0654571503,
0.0081954151,
0.007299535,
0.0083833411,
-0.0227885488,
0.0179182477,
0.0382678919,
0.02239893,
-0.0438728854,
-0.020142341,
-0.0176564772,
-0.0311125722,
-0.0372419842,
0.0171544664,
-0.0494625308,
0.000832458,
0.0402157418,
0.0053840699,
-0.0041279779,
-0.0037475307,
0.0212678313,
-0.027495414,
0.0553210415,
0.0380475037,
-0.0010258806,
0.0702489763,
0.0482604876,
-0.0334365815,
0.0849215612,
0.0316156857,
0.0303074159,
0.0524067432,
0.004734138,
0.0225778557,
0.03915805,
0.033561103,
0.0171097964,
-0.0059299883,
0.0124720894,
-0.0452510454,
-0.0081152963,
0.0322581679,
0.0263222288,
0.0312088206,
-0.0336435065,
0.0330418013,
0.0669664294,
0.0319630206,
0.0693768933,
0.0115218349,
-0.009664936,
0.0013928966,
-0.004057365,
-0.0678053275,
-0.0047721094,
-0.0342428461,
-0.0575001463,
0.0229707137,
0.0037899786,
-0.0299950317,
-0.0291639715,
-0.0122755086,
0.0014420429,
0.0264850538,
-0.0046889698,
0.0265596379,
-0.0031879253,
-0.0197859816,
0.0215295497,
0.0131539302,
-0.0567051545,
-0.0149154672,
-0.0935487002,
0.0308876317,
0.0562534146,
0.0001884309,
-0.055397775,
0.0195320696,
-0.0546019152,
-0.0048952759,
0.0133958748,
0.0375340283,
0.00648657,
0.000648572,
-0.0570677444,
-0.0366541967,
0.0274227504,
0.0291109551,
0.031312868,
0.0705467537,
0.0564315394,
0.0152227841,
-0.0000129604,
-0.0386866182,
0.0220664348,
0.0164321531,
-0.0140959658,
0.0245500095,
0.0227783117,
0.024774177,
0.0227227602,
-0.0416028723,
-0.0092991944,
-0.0299569461,
0.0108955456,
-0.0368936248,
-0.0243535936,
0.0190866422,
0.0224479251,
0.0252744108,
-0.0694021434,
-0.0947821662,
0.0732769668,
-0.0094124842,
0.0175009985,
0.0445506088,
-0.0458013453,
-0.0070526022,
-0.0134715717,
-0.0199133921,
-0.0239396486,
0.0127212238,
0.0004760996,
0.0082741585,
-0.0357441194,
-0.0080479793,
-0.0286210664,
-0.0424130671,
-0.0111871418,
-0.0412942097,
-0.0557380505,
-0.0100026652,
0.0033756448,
0.0371520035,
0.0335599184,
-0.0204692297,
-0.0303100478,
-0.0353669375,
-0.0994409174,
-0.0197962318,
-0.0161261149,
-0.0243566595,
-0.0208109673,
0.0067879753,
-0.0229799077,
-0.0101414574,
-0.0199146848,
-0.0331017897,
-0.0019914806,
0.0429613404,
0.0299723428,
-0.0249623619,
0.012432063,
-0.0309070162,
-0.0344631411,
-0.048110906,
0.0565208644,
0.0509809703,
-0.0243049171,
-0.0032753241,
-0.0220000632,
-0.0218009446,
-0.0062617213,
-0.0173101928,
-0.0379418656,
0.0450469591,
0.0125775943,
0.0161025785,
0.0687230006,
0.0587442368,
0.0427048989,
0.015674796,
0.0437354408,
-0.0297985487,
-0.0007001151,
0.0437183008,
0.0170892235,
0.0470274277,
-0.0712822378,
-0.0070636375,
0.0254392922,
-0.0101502305,
-0.0317373015,
-0.0545510575,
0.0476424359,
-0.0458205342,
-0.0572393127,
-0.0348160714,
-0.0251445565,
0.02468374,
0.0050453586,
-0.0388897508,
-0.035974957,
0.068858102,
0.0061815628,
-0.0095673036,
-0.0003994281,
-0.0313935168,
-0.0507265143,
0.0458526351,
-0.0206810832,
0.0217484627,
-0.0000342276,
-0.0128664132,
-0.0127212666,
-0.0453334041,
0.0326121673,
-0.0331544913,
0.0415208898,
0.00514512,
0.0264540128,
0.0172466747,
-0.0642577633,
-0.0440235287,
-0.0501095168,
-0.029097287,
-0.0243738256,
0.0040010614,
-0.0360739604,
-0.0381748676,
0.0210605897,
-0.0060088425,
0.0381621644,
-0.0069788559,
-0.0333527923,
0.0300610699,
-0.0070825587,
0.0050125341,
-0.030326331,
0.0104037775,
-0.0445308983,
-0.0255735852,
0.0611847155,
-0.0147261145,
0.0256217923,
-0.0127562983,
-0.0035932621,
0.0053520035,
-0.0306936502,
-0.0059780469,
-0.0431094244,
0.028623851,
-0.0435234122,
0.0199820083,
0.0878786817,
0.0196610168,
-0.0460032187,
0.0035268029,
0.0023052378,
-0.002946907,
0.0085946759,
-0.0116361128,
-0.1002482176,
-0.0142301433,
0.0213751197,
0.0453823209,
-0.0470354483,
-0.0666118339,
-0.0072693313,
-0.1060231552,
0.0094183385,
0.0044332752,
-0.0138175255,
-0.0442739837,
-0.0455284119,
0.0197099857,
-0.0483345054,
0.0035606991,
-0.0274831541,
0.0270255152,
0.0275622904,
0.0035163495,
-0.0777248591,
-0.0083252685,
0.0368816257,
-0.064943634,
0.0498155504,
0.0355966203,
0.0615020841,
-0.0283607338,
0.0129509633,
0.0636309683,
0.0182466824,
-0.0067031835,
-0.0127319936,
0.0499037132,
-0.0343064554,
-0.0211961847,
-0.053879384,
0.035357438,
0.0322366357,
0.0272095483,
0.0306682121,
0.0039577438,
0.0275160447,
-0.051880952,
-0.0815321505,
-0.0265344959,
0.0038039908,
0.0698082298,
0.0166987423,
-0.0553977415,
-0.0596921034,
-0.0778528899,
0.0072563179,
-0.004886223,
-0.0417109169,
-0.0059681037,
0.0199340358,
-0.0801344216,
-0.0194553602,
-0.0435243398,
-0.0075739762,
-0.0156327039,
-0.0148042571,
-0.1000308171,
-0.0002238806,
0.0314098746,
-0.066387549,
0.0307522304,
-0.0024569002,
0.0348906368,
-0.0014877556,
-0.035884738,
-0.0292128008,
-0.0127081396,
-0.0234447233,
0.0251036584,
-0.0210456066,
-0.0523203053,
0.0387407355,
0.0509728044,
0.0243237317,
0.0158350617,
-0.0281143878,
-0.0483787432,
0.0505048074,
0.0885199979,
-0.0257031489,
0.0077747251,
0.0555963628,
0.0099784657,
0.0049736155,
0.0369863436,
-0.0355228148,
0.020262247,
-0.0242592599,
-0.0158416368,
-0.0254610293,
-0.0121346768,
-0.0340899006,
0.0174290836,
0.0016756074,
-0.0065513346,
0.0062874546,
-0.0243302435,
-0.0172907449,
0.0180288833,
-0.0182736143,
-0.0083721615,
-0.0275948681,
0.0104528069,
-0.0047835652,
-0.049413465,
0.0137897264,
-0.0167424306,
0.0153592676,
-0.052259896,
0.0401423872,
0.0308343749,
0.0897194743,
0.007543596,
-0.0234621372,
-0.0029052335,
0.0132874185,
-0.0008945033,
0.0248058699,
0.034892913,
0.0085279774,
0.0037350652,
0.0210275706,
0.0043486832,
0.0027322439,
-0.0598625094,
-0.0111157857,
-0.0042965314,
0.0414649323,
-0.000091676,
0.0011022643,
0.0074113919,
0.0213153195,
-0.0301388297,
0.0114340503,
0.0107732676,
0.0180987101,
0.0183306187,
-0.0093766833,
0.0095931897,
0.0067229196,
-0.0174855515,
0.0339259729,
0.0317264348,
0.0551077239,
-0.0022486483,
-0.0577013455,
-0.0293517336,
-0.0061955722,
0.0154669136,
-0.0456769466,
0.0151278777,
-0.0066403658,
-0.0597141869,
-0.0521833338,
0.0089138402,
-0.0267919265,
0.0513752922,
0.0232579652,
-0.009289043,
0.0604815893,
0.0000644056,
-0.0299483258,
-0.0267468784,
0.0129644508,
-0.0131886154,
-0.0304846242,
-0.0015220095,
-5.948375369e-33,
0.0107983463,
-0.0621996559,
-0.0437031649,
-0.0182791501,
-0.0045377063,
0.0354263745,
-0.0167141911,
-0.0192452334,
0.0065105972,
0.0191055667,
-0.002382563,
0.0626639202,
0.0045330692,
-0.0048502469,
0.001882371,
-0.0391370952,
0.0607111417,
0.0085325632,
-0.0315189771,
-0.0023203464,
-0.0286389943,
0.0471257418,
-0.0109628355,
-0.0892982781,
0.0944073945,
-0.0039457441,
-0.0216870755,
-0.0049885032,
-0.0171678104,
0.04194621,
-0.000591924,
0.0719489306,
0.0164896268,
0.0042055682,
0.0397522226,
0.1033840925,
-0.0782237276,
-0.0173994061,
-0.0374585129,
0.0332873687,
0.033203315,
-0.0112122791,
0.0418697,
0.0183708984,
-0.0280070845,
-0.0392615609,
0.0607521683,
0.0171878804,
0.0861078352,
-0.0069706105,
0.001247231,
0.0194346849,
-0.0607985295,
-0.0129678166,
0.0126479911,
0.0586988889,
0.020428367,
-0.0096918941,
-0.0835476965,
0.0230381247,
0.0149086425,
-0.0580742471,
0.0201535411,
0.0047052293,
0.0144420788,
0.0318186209,
0.0769150481,
0.0431976169,
-0.0752876103,
-0.0819257274,
0.0242815558,
-0.0187470727,
0.038859345,
0.0348381698,
0.0361192599,
-0.0348155275,
-0.0730191767,
0.0069509507,
0.0446342379,
-0.0058222627,
0.0371823534,
-0.0235718265,
-0.0911887437,
-0.022787381,
-0.0076315193,
-0.0704557076,
-0.0272833332,
-0.0134783909,
-0.0036981876,
-0.0058904588,
-0.0673489571,
0.0088663474,
-0.033842355,
-0.0623638406,
-0.0528551526,
0.0101147909,
-0.0142268771,
-0.0302145611,
0.0292586032,
0.0009204167,
-0.0356987864,
0.0374949127,
0.0243766475,
0.0388794839,
0.0422912389,
0.0139119318,
0.0186291095,
0.031070644,
-0.0767128766,
-0.0348868631,
-0.0235027447,
0.0343140177,
-0.0187970717,
0.0508580618,
0.0161273107,
0.0346798748,
-0.0067777778,
0.0265597217,
0.0444964617,
0.0926779062,
-0.0490130149,
0.0228264574,
-0.0158419311,
0.0041453857,
-0.0010840244,
-0.0451945849,
-0.007032203,
0.0190628022,
0.0311372373,
-0.06214628,
0.0066761458,
-0.0699375868,
2.563e-7,
0.0074101146,
0.0370321609,
0.0244221017,
0.0055409428,
0.0272316709,
0.0477032028,
0.0237210952,
0.0612360798,
0.0477518924,
-0.0190977044,
-0.0365195982,
0.054057233,
0.0140379397,
0.0441128947,
-0.03273784,
-0.0405856594,
-0.0764843225,
0.019598309,
-0.0337531455,
0.0534655973,
-0.0084039867,
0.0608735755,
0.070335187,
-0.0225862972,
0.0012984424,
-0.0223492999,
0.0358526707,
0.0164069906,
0.0285566878,
-0.0078877984,
0.0265715327,
0.0169642661,
0.0279884841,
0.0222864468,
-0.002679518,
-0.0004189712,
0.0059951381,
0.0281685647,
-0.0153729664,
0.0282228906,
0.0060231257,
-0.000831552,
-0.0033390368,
-0.0540106222,
0.0772848949,
0.0236066356,
-0.0333689936,
-0.0731118917,
-0.0124803009,
-0.0342057161,
0.0948783308,
-0.0048177573,
-0.0311642252,
0.0178710259,
0.002348202,
-0.0254149865,
0.0133821256,
-0.0814175159,
-0.0218220465,
-0.0175769478,
-0.0222019684,
-0.0541761257,
-0.0081272218,
0.044706814,
0.0323731937,
-0.0446347184,
0.0537993386,
2.081204483e-34,
-0.000681961,
0.011794609,
-0.0121864444,
-0.0184345767,
0.0292178858,
0.0115933372,
0.029650379,
-0.0129506141,
0.0618839189,
0.0173428673,
-0.0035559004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.06046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.06046v1 | LLM for SoC Security: A Paradigm Shift | 2023-10-09T18:02:38 | 2023-10-09T18:02:38 | Dipayan Saha, Shams Tarek, Katayoon Yahyaei, Sujan Kumar Saha, Jingbo Zhou, Mark Tehranipoor, Farimah Farahmandi | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | As the ubiquity and complexity of system-on-chip (SoC) designs increase
across electronic devices, the task of incorporating security into an SoC
design flow poses significant challenges. Existing security solutions are
inadequate to provide effective verification of modern SoC designs due to their
limitations in scalability, comprehensiveness, and adaptability. On the other
hand, Large Language Models (LLMs) are celebrated for their remarkable success
in natural language understanding, advanced reasoning, and program synthesis
tasks. Recognizing an opportunity, our research delves into leveraging the
emergent capabilities of Generative Pre-trained Transformers (GPTs) to address
the existing gaps in SoC security, aiming for a more efficient, scalable, and
adaptable methodology. By integrating LLMs into the SoC security verification
paradigm, we open a new frontier of possibilities and challenges to ensure the
security of increasingly complex SoCs. This paper offers an in-depth analysis
of existing works, showcases practical case studies, demonstrates comprehensive
experiments, and provides useful promoting guidelines. We also present the
achievements, prospects, and challenges of employing LLM in different SoC
security verification tasks. | [
0.0281684604,
0.0629888922,
0.0138560524,
0.0363542363,
-0.0441019572,
-0.0358820148,
0.0458691828,
-0.0386540778,
0.0115822786,
-0.0369261056,
0.0031715801,
-0.0105390335,
-0.0121866278,
0.0129757971,
0.0412854329,
0.0426580645,
0.0698877871,
-0.0506892167,
-0.0248751361,
0.0247751363,
-0.0000719082,
-0.0177452862,
0.0175575167,
0.0485074036,
-0.0094255451,
-0.0059576104,
-0.0145473089,
0.0389353335,
0.0408484712,
-0.0136567904,
-0.0214797612,
0.0617812648,
0.0122094816,
0.0063885017,
0.0000022061,
-0.0404534973,
-0.0621033013,
0.0426742658,
-0.0295240488,
0.0288516153,
-0.0087609813,
-0.0109809684,
-0.0297575798,
0.0293993689,
-0.0290886685,
-0.0335324369,
0.0244302563,
0.0879284665,
0.0798494667,
0.0643226355,
0.0078575555,
-0.0334589779,
0.027274996,
-0.0211515948,
-0.0261766203,
-0.0369151086,
0.0149830412,
-0.0168439727,
0.0078644576,
0.014636389,
0.0076693785,
-0.0038137517,
0.040924672,
0.0046058991,
-0.0416270532,
0.0385170951,
-0.0314944088,
0.033897765,
-0.0268887784,
0.033374723,
-0.0536772497,
-0.0109812804,
-0.0035715695,
-0.0051082382,
-0.0344859362,
0.0074394955,
0.0232341234,
0.0172306783,
-0.0232577864,
-0.0026688124,
0.0035417269,
-0.0061460761,
0.0515497401,
-0.0579404607,
-0.0085549271,
0.0597118139,
0.0479456261,
-0.0149230389,
-0.0290578697,
-0.046118971,
0.0044325162,
-0.0716175437,
-0.0234772377,
0.0598080419,
-0.0081440667,
0.0239084847,
-0.0680332258,
0.0038320466,
0.0044262675,
-0.0172984209,
0.0017188932,
-0.0056798449,
0.0180761889,
-0.0113044167,
-0.0421306975,
0.0208748989,
-0.0537721924,
0.0336079597,
-0.0242684819,
0.0302872099,
-0.0345690362,
-0.045498509,
-0.0160173178,
0.064253442,
-0.0011969148,
-0.0145595586,
-0.0356049314,
0.0017326565,
-0.0159450043,
0.0580688752,
-0.0049120993,
-0.0202276036,
0.0031007607,
-0.0353504904,
0.0151012614,
-0.0464682281,
-0.0033989719,
-0.0097286804,
-0.0510865152,
-0.0767401308,
-0.0246832073,
-0.0049113338,
-0.0570724495,
0.0111158835,
-0.0219974201,
0.1055745259,
0.0368737914,
-0.0508830249,
-0.0711808279,
-0.0269701555,
-0.0352104791,
-0.0536742695,
0.0172842368,
-0.064803496,
-0.0265207533,
-0.0346218534,
0.0318755805,
-0.0099026589,
0.0261702035,
0.0134244878,
0.0168652311,
0.0728120729,
0.045631893,
-0.0263580903,
-0.0300943442,
0.041777011,
0.0869752541,
0.0130881239,
0.0465293303,
0.0114936251,
0.0197753813,
-0.0147455502,
0.0581319034,
0.0150285009,
-0.0057061268,
-0.0444747992,
0.0269197915,
0.0270847827,
0.0057854699,
-0.0819334462,
-0.0624460205,
0.069484435,
0.0166931134,
-0.0082726302,
0.0342753381,
0.0499839298,
-0.0145068234,
0.0475010462,
0.0426748395,
0.0098768454,
-0.0067201359,
-0.0389702283,
-0.0231573191,
0.0197391957,
-0.0581413209,
0.0002915925,
-0.0154542616,
0.042811349,
-0.0206664708,
-0.0115859751,
-0.0235935301,
-0.0557722636,
-0.0336092338,
0.0161464233,
0.0287984814,
0.0148377288,
-0.0083812634,
0.0428019091,
0.0292367525,
-0.0728177875,
-0.0458514914,
-0.1028054878,
0.0304292124,
0.0322935171,
0.0438194834,
-0.0353244245,
-0.004531648,
0.0042020925,
-0.0264599882,
0.0301994272,
-0.0148876142,
0.0301245563,
0.0058907773,
-0.0216484088,
0.0121342447,
-0.0285902172,
0.0294126701,
0.0238647591,
0.0128132803,
-0.0315362215,
0.0406080596,
-0.0110704564,
-0.0047957688,
0.0181257818,
0.0179558229,
-0.0155543536,
0.0480488241,
0.0309123266,
0.0098901698,
-0.0127805574,
-0.0571581349,
0.0543802343,
0.0239660684,
-0.0298190415,
0.0160449222,
-0.015401572,
-0.0266538579,
0.0094465427,
0.0099656349,
-0.0505716503,
0.0117624123,
0.016492445,
-0.0514822379,
-0.051619634,
0.0577595569,
-0.0640815645,
0.0066642012,
-0.0443106033,
0.0205799006,
-0.0000438215,
0.0215074997,
-0.0350644737,
0.039145533,
0.0169509109,
-0.0466881432,
-0.0043896618,
0.0131251467,
0.0370954275,
-0.0023002578,
-0.0358163714,
-0.0385947339,
-0.0167404059,
0.0007763171,
0.018019842,
-0.0048733992,
-0.0152916424,
-0.0143159693,
-0.0403292775,
0.0192588996,
-0.022672968,
0.0341281816,
0.0218208842,
-0.0040254956,
0.0033673968,
-0.0004350401,
0.0016324825,
-0.012871366,
0.0014994605,
-0.0563554727,
0.0012364774,
-0.0112419417,
-0.0531736128,
0.0181487966,
-0.0116516594,
-0.015452547,
0.0659238473,
-0.0179481078,
0.0511415638,
-0.0483587123,
0.0577067323,
-0.0115929935,
0.0107307825,
-0.0294322744,
-0.0331529863,
0.0439867489,
0.0118817203,
0.042602066,
0.0496507585,
0.0384734273,
0.0131629221,
0.0573672131,
-0.0600023381,
-0.0016797107,
0.0037038727,
0.0212737173,
-0.0488934442,
-0.0497147329,
0.0148405591,
0.0404090248,
0.0712303445,
0.0151894884,
-0.0216543023,
-0.041412916,
-0.0161019266,
0.0041977875,
-0.0048055495,
0.0351964422,
-0.0430179797,
-0.0179974064,
0.007406408,
-0.0257713906,
-0.0506349877,
0.0639458671,
-0.0693992004,
0.0231002085,
-0.0387692228,
-0.0126666389,
-0.0146934986,
0.0434421375,
-0.0038177774,
0.0098407809,
0.0337426886,
-0.0071640802,
-0.0335929915,
-0.0315709375,
0.0190149881,
-0.0396042876,
0.0416059196,
-0.0502864048,
0.0147568602,
-0.0346017703,
-0.0002393285,
-0.0578811243,
-0.0058618286,
-0.0113945203,
0.0019639977,
0.0130255204,
-0.0291178767,
0.0141462311,
0.0361080393,
0.0236179363,
-0.0158300195,
0.0349225551,
-0.0465005152,
-0.0154765807,
-0.018650433,
0.0265292339,
-0.0432000346,
0.0117516695,
-0.0228743777,
0.0145156505,
0.0420911498,
0.0541322418,
-0.0180564914,
-0.085031867,
-0.0170948301,
-0.0001024369,
-0.0289546717,
0.0352611095,
0.0578535832,
0.0486378744,
-0.0057785441,
-0.0323725231,
0.0706672668,
-0.0060177101,
0.0158982873,
0.027991619,
0.0646304488,
-0.0009373553,
0.0215905886,
0.0642761365,
-0.0914435834,
-0.0081129745,
0.0198295508,
0.0143170655,
-0.0229795221,
-0.0037477985,
-0.0709343329,
-0.1063064039,
0.0318233445,
0.0206715818,
-0.0405474529,
-0.0560397021,
-0.0291709714,
-0.0306737795,
0.0380024947,
0.0071068672,
-0.014559323,
-0.0072727343,
-0.0070206928,
-0.034377791,
-0.0818464309,
-0.0182826445,
0.032251589,
-0.020728875,
0.02498601,
0.0617675819,
-0.0438943021,
0.0117211686,
0.0019880848,
0.0506466962,
-0.0063029998,
0.0117567787,
0.0130172623,
-0.0115032261,
-0.0126709612,
-0.017278716,
0.0054947771,
0.0344333947,
-0.0170929488,
-0.0526789092,
0.0038226091,
0.0382559784,
-0.0101597216,
-0.0258937012,
-0.0034885861,
-0.0114023956,
0.0418002196,
-0.0009911445,
0.0101502193,
-0.0018249587,
-0.052170638,
-0.0228555333,
-0.0035180491,
-0.0467603952,
-0.0566364676,
0.0293869022,
0.023744924,
-0.0438252501,
0.0020638949,
0.0575342886,
-0.0509077571,
0.0139832348,
0.0515036061,
-0.0740220025,
0.0800299272,
0.0302009098,
-0.0646266937,
0.0106090363,
-0.0707568303,
0.0406009518,
-0.0415390134,
0.0067565641,
0.0103233913,
-0.009151469,
-0.0651365072,
0.0394398309,
-0.0816045552,
-0.0751523376,
-0.0136121651,
0.0914307982,
0.0150684984,
-0.043121703,
-0.0380345546,
-0.00515272,
0.0630759448,
0.0518176258,
-0.0236517843,
-0.0023893598,
0.0615334697,
-0.0451190807,
-0.0012708505,
-0.0164590739,
0.0092618503,
0.0615889505,
0.0843073651,
-0.0061205244,
0.0009586831,
-0.0329660065,
0.0281587821,
0.050198365,
0.0405289568,
0.0006460143,
0.0421219878,
-0.0064014592,
0.0553153194,
-0.0337838531,
-0.0075317421,
-0.0120159015,
-0.007611623,
0.0258269832,
-0.0405275337,
-0.0074736881,
-0.0089731952,
-0.0200280193,
0.0441030376,
0.0278540775,
0.0138539448,
0.0260271989,
0.0257982016,
0.0324174985,
-0.016892964,
-0.0128479488,
0.0397504494,
-0.0009542524,
0.0397864841,
0.0024686947,
0.0337219574,
0.0103302412,
0.0367060751,
-0.0500427522,
0.0397400819,
-0.0619733408,
-0.0701255649,
-0.0041388581,
0.041810479,
0.0026122401,
0.0457745306,
-0.0279620346,
-0.028552128,
0.0368704237,
-0.0613430217,
0.0577683859,
-0.0204830654,
-0.0485851802,
0.0221176799,
0.0018050337,
-0.002080891,
-0.009079312,
0.0554722622,
-0.0495346524,
0.0343098715,
-0.0217635036,
-0.0015998769,
-0.0829350352,
-0.0432987548,
-0.0153201548,
-0.0253044069,
-0.0294334423,
-0.0228316747,
-0.0712344423,
-0.0652467161,
-0.0120351939,
0.0159117635,
0.0430309363,
0.0478625782,
-0.0053964918,
0.0636950135,
0.0076596099,
-0.0247531179,
-0.0141623868,
-0.0168245342,
-0.0156828836,
0.0058356426,
0.0385230668,
-5.667461974e-33,
-0.0160344597,
-0.0086945593,
0.0188997388,
0.024479419,
0.013123923,
0.0128764221,
-0.0436882898,
0.0170728751,
-0.0071509364,
-0.0378665254,
0.0059152753,
-0.0002099377,
0.0221747495,
0.0510955639,
-0.0497686453,
-0.0163727663,
0.045867715,
0.0188073423,
-0.0297556389,
0.0774564818,
0.0286120679,
-0.0299656224,
0.0149631808,
-0.0715963542,
0.0151816541,
-0.054264985,
-0.0184301138,
-0.0206127241,
-0.0595562495,
0.0575898141,
-0.0033292202,
0.0154415052,
0.0140333539,
-0.0151770096,
-0.008826592,
0.0497706383,
-0.0208895914,
-0.0191933624,
-0.0183203574,
-0.0169991441,
0.0172786526,
-0.0751348808,
-0.0057870708,
-0.0065215803,
-0.0167481732,
-0.0037334838,
0.0126099391,
0.0065328926,
0.0218148977,
-0.0728245303,
-0.047561001,
0.0106481286,
-0.0296028741,
0.009525246,
-0.0154554797,
-0.034355592,
-0.022057917,
-0.0078851944,
0.0089394748,
0.0621335357,
0.0372142866,
0.0254177041,
0.086825639,
0.0114211058,
-0.0214810427,
0.023257982,
-0.0446650572,
0.0064951684,
-0.017152058,
-0.008267072,
0.023740381,
0.0632261634,
0.0115362955,
0.0857172385,
0.0315388218,
-0.0385838673,
-0.0718057752,
0.0194607899,
-0.0183923598,
0.0640920848,
0.0400991403,
-0.0046178889,
-0.0229296125,
0.0362749696,
-0.0005725864,
0.0563498773,
-0.0013097597,
-0.0092340577,
0.0046744319,
0.0399080776,
-0.0774790719,
0.0008590581,
0.0166710149,
-0.0514257774,
0.0162972324,
0.0018542908,
0.0446790196,
-0.0482839979,
-0.0351153985,
0.0194527619,
-0.0120942974,
-0.0561588779,
0.0414719917,
-0.0545775741,
0.0188834704,
-0.0232078154,
0.0102923727,
0.0524655581,
-0.0651292279,
0.0111788325,
-0.0210875012,
0.0409109071,
-0.0222339351,
0.0369590335,
-0.0051803049,
0.0103130704,
-0.0212332346,
0.0023287479,
-0.0292378385,
-0.0339350998,
-0.0283960626,
0.079227604,
0.0239507463,
0.0374105349,
0.0167370848,
0.036248941,
-0.0214323103,
0.0402165726,
0.0183048528,
-0.0314761326,
-0.0092634661,
0.0076421467,
3.142e-7,
-0.0051960112,
-0.01788266,
0.0527186505,
0.0213453714,
0.0026794195,
0.0318682492,
0.0071815774,
0.0426611528,
-0.0266334303,
-0.0343792476,
-0.0092719495,
0.0390159748,
0.0680442899,
0.006352711,
0.0083667543,
-0.0161471218,
-0.0056064939,
0.0010638359,
-0.0424442925,
0.0073040039,
0.0940169021,
0.0825765207,
-0.0249898601,
-0.0010763039,
0.0293405131,
-0.0639230236,
0.0346350707,
0.0021155961,
0.0026010075,
0.0285934228,
0.0001402143,
0.0364484042,
0.0028633135,
0.0816439837,
-0.0211240519,
0.0180323012,
-0.0836015046,
0.0537079237,
0.0211685691,
-0.0502453968,
-0.0540829971,
-0.0293959286,
-0.007484124,
-0.0409836285,
0.0581428036,
-0.0340353623,
-0.0117589626,
-0.0439711139,
-0.0005248906,
-0.0231438894,
0.0065540718,
-0.001295652,
0.0410451069,
0.0062675434,
0.0160736535,
-0.0115025099,
0.0351765789,
-0.0877423286,
-0.0234739967,
0.0019551113,
-0.0498014912,
-0.0259308759,
0.0349609926,
-0.0061852378,
0.0559978001,
-0.0019336641,
0.0134859914,
2.794015533e-34,
0.0079942141,
-0.0313421264,
-0.0073479344,
0.0427452549,
0.0312548652,
0.0194998793,
-0.0229575783,
0.0039891195,
-0.0092119342,
-0.0573791489,
-0.026869908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05919v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05919v1 | Few-Shot Spoken Language Understanding via Joint Speech-Text Models | 2023-10-09T17:59:21 | 2023-10-09T17:59:21 | Chung-Ming Chien, Mingjiamei Zhang, Ju-Chieh Chou, Karen Livescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Recent work on speech representation models jointly pre-trained with text has
demonstrated the potential of improving speech representations by encoding
speech and text in a shared space. In this paper, we leverage such shared
representations to address the persistent challenge of limited data
availability in spoken language understanding tasks. By employing a pre-trained
speech-text model, we find that models fine-tuned on text can be effectively
transferred to speech testing data. With as little as 1 hour of labeled speech
data, our proposed approach achieves comparable performance on spoken language
understanding tasks (specifically, sentiment analysis and named entity
recognition) when compared to previous methods using speech-only pre-trained
models fine-tuned on 10 times more data. Beyond the proof-of-concept study, we
also analyze the latent representations. We find that the bottom layers of
speech-text models are largely task-agnostic and align speech and text
representations into a shared space, while the top layers are more
task-specific. | [
-0.0038035193,
0.0646786541,
-0.0036705306,
0.0511700958,
-0.002997386,
0.0337406583,
0.0574391186,
-0.0177309047,
-0.0211704727,
-0.1062135845,
-0.0557042658,
-0.0397211537,
-0.0047212401,
0.0096773654,
0.0080956202,
-0.0484150499,
0.0474202484,
-0.027712699,
0.0229096226,
-0.0069069532,
0.0340225175,
0.024877511,
-0.0446740575,
0.0201191604,
0.0193134174,
-0.0126108304,
-0.0361017473,
-0.0052301213,
0.0052131782,
-0.0004768583,
-0.0017166702,
0.0379579104,
0.0631468743,
0.0290591046,
0.0000019008,
-0.0228668936,
-0.0145258503,
-0.0009260496,
-0.0532104187,
-0.0038459084,
0.0354008824,
-0.0179021135,
0.0110562826,
0.0032069334,
-0.0053733573,
-0.0508880317,
0.0219175722,
0.0554048568,
0.061278183,
0.0822167918,
-0.0127066467,
-0.0196147878,
-0.0014979657,
0.0032684165,
0.0368657224,
-0.0682051927,
-0.0113545479,
0.0000543022,
-0.0035522575,
0.0250962693,
-0.0093548466,
0.0394577347,
-0.0252056886,
0.0344428457,
0.0156802777,
0.0173758864,
-0.0493178703,
-0.0213675573,
-0.0024996183,
0.0931731611,
-0.0175269451,
-0.0171796624,
0.0109714223,
-0.0317817032,
-0.0470775701,
-0.0335965306,
-0.0130466549,
-0.00243864,
0.029055275,
0.0165793858,
-0.0009057605,
0.0259939451,
0.0285595097,
-0.0168104786,
-0.0214846116,
-0.0013382044,
-0.0302798096,
-0.0207828619,
-0.0142870247,
0.0087120943,
-0.0251178555,
-0.0246299021,
-0.0087092416,
0.0193753019,
-0.0198323131,
0.0207375977,
-0.0414669625,
-0.050286226,
-0.0172361806,
-0.0361136124,
0.0241914168,
0.0390349105,
-0.0535496771,
0.0792714432,
-0.0224233121,
0.0311612356,
0.019521717,
0.0011700315,
-0.0245562028,
-0.0238242242,
-0.0667235777,
-0.003534829,
-0.0409054309,
0.0654364228,
-0.0362616703,
-0.0313748866,
0.0153660094,
0.0088195987,
0.0105868038,
0.0020613202,
0.0072096777,
-0.0002603039,
-0.0137888724,
-0.0088788019,
0.0156915095,
0.0386761203,
-0.028319519,
0.0654685795,
-0.0205813646,
-0.0246456079,
-0.0382362902,
0.0141201811,
0.0456581153,
-0.0121948561,
-0.0063883276,
0.0444052368,
0.0230985228,
-0.0669451132,
-0.0377636626,
-0.0143580548,
-0.0098636867,
-0.061068736,
-0.0269395486,
-0.0126546863,
0.0645080507,
0.0054246299,
-0.0036507379,
0.0022595581,
0.0001444269,
-0.004564635,
-0.0400142707,
0.1211590916,
-0.0100299483,
0.0275562834,
0.0086518088,
0.0169166233,
0.0277413502,
0.0746080652,
0.0296222772,
-0.0191545002,
0.0142909084,
-0.0226325821,
-0.0345647447,
0.0161784943,
0.0370568037,
-0.0111322813,
-0.0118523743,
0.0288562607,
-0.0283794459,
0.0154811926,
0.0137059083,
0.0180735867,
-0.0369872637,
0.0037721242,
0.0319739506,
0.0658803284,
0.004458141,
-0.0009899223,
0.013507233,
0.0402815789,
-0.0157207828,
-0.0224348605,
-0.0274083037,
0.0179656073,
-0.026025109,
-0.0055418843,
0.0664772317,
0.001043389,
-0.0587780625,
-0.0033258342,
-0.0107519981,
-0.0333554968,
-0.0081375092,
0.0262201168,
0.0472385623,
-0.0029414361,
-0.060338553,
0.0529859066,
0.0361229479,
-0.0303660315,
0.0059983162,
-0.0220374409,
0.0322280489,
0.0776652917,
-0.0019783904,
-0.0380161405,
-0.0297773406,
-0.0437963158,
0.0204004347,
0.0193349011,
0.0344730169,
-0.0045105238,
0.0646571368,
-0.0423229858,
-0.0180257279,
-0.0219900794,
0.0317362696,
0.0278975908,
-0.0359183885,
0.019626705,
0.0165784936,
-0.0274827816,
0.0167988762,
-0.0008138242,
-0.0124452766,
-0.031452816,
-0.0017380288,
0.0253066346,
0.0422435552,
0.0494786315,
-0.0392218493,
-0.0160698276,
0.0234769769,
-0.012217802,
0.0022554288,
-0.0001696879,
-0.045258563,
-0.0923262164,
-0.0298356581,
0.0114562223,
-0.011089365,
0.0331069529,
-0.0479230769,
-0.062837936,
0.0176919997,
0.0047818683,
0.034032166,
-0.0288010743,
-0.0126749286,
0.0064344518,
0.0158183873,
-0.0184371285,
0.006907349,
0.0160091687,
0.0104882009,
0.0209622737,
-0.004129299,
0.0557759404,
-0.0255418997,
-0.0562496297,
-0.0094268695,
0.011217949,
0.0201671328,
-0.0077465638,
-0.0098991031,
-0.0213097092,
0.0118521908,
-0.0998901203,
0.0132230129,
-0.0249462742,
0.0168261509,
0.0341650285,
0.0121927336,
0.0167219453,
-0.0279917978,
-0.0364813656,
0.0018537133,
0.0091571137,
-0.01052396,
0.0015990317,
0.011019974,
0.0199525747,
-0.0508019812,
0.0327609442,
-0.0148946447,
0.0219155326,
-0.0007723204,
-0.0508813336,
-0.0280958749,
0.0481280982,
0.0077706939,
0.0245246515,
0.0041706292,
-0.0166135635,
-0.0179109089,
-0.0157902632,
0.0018232308,
0.0426959284,
-0.0129215186,
0.0359507687,
-0.0122827701,
-0.0220630858,
-0.0781319588,
0.0255363714,
-0.0025786397,
0.0278427042,
-0.0203403439,
0.0118833948,
-0.0349210761,
0.0868509114,
0.019515153,
0.0171007849,
-0.0685885251,
-0.0142384376,
-0.0280504338,
-0.0050439211,
-0.0245068893,
-0.0035155122,
-0.0084272595,
-0.0111435605,
-0.0181557331,
0.0246497802,
0.0727579445,
-0.0578524247,
-0.0134458151,
-0.0515107661,
-0.0377420932,
-0.0221279971,
0.0521904565,
-0.012991339,
0.0078009558,
0.008665042,
-0.0155432271,
-0.0547910668,
0.0174947549,
-0.0078994585,
-0.0365603007,
0.0149780391,
0.019516753,
0.0234386232,
-0.0147493733,
-0.0517676733,
-0.0312180817,
-0.0722943321,
-0.0737759992,
0.0076182103,
-0.0183802359,
0.0085388701,
-0.029514255,
0.0505990796,
0.005372684,
0.0325208195,
0.022465555,
0.0129456921,
-0.0340381525,
0.0328278653,
0.0331223793,
0.0075333612,
-0.0027925207,
0.0006159782,
0.0510319024,
0.0014056899,
0.0623881482,
0.0135457162,
-0.0247272421,
-0.0081743635,
0.0024308106,
0.0064788326,
-0.039737422,
-0.0071712271,
0.0570687652,
-0.0371168181,
-0.0011094809,
0.1539489031,
0.0120515646,
-0.0115558673,
-0.0210016817,
0.0250987429,
-0.0235450864,
0.0225563478,
0.0190263707,
-0.0674412549,
-0.077662006,
0.0057976502,
0.0179302413,
0.028594153,
-0.0185652412,
-0.0152070364,
-0.0826817527,
-0.012481303,
-0.0033310542,
-0.010323341,
-0.0183520764,
-0.0184595846,
0.0003692322,
-0.0268774219,
0.0253949668,
-0.0261116438,
0.0039417874,
0.0109842382,
0.0317533314,
-0.0262446459,
-0.0584236644,
0.0757222474,
-0.0004797345,
0.093521297,
0.0300026368,
0.027035173,
0.0118758464,
0.0029544251,
0.0123676639,
-0.0108047668,
0.0151222562,
-0.0024317112,
0.0663432702,
-0.0287141837,
-0.0224944763,
0.0285704657,
0.0038279241,
-0.0256690495,
-0.0216570068,
-0.0249985587,
0.0482112579,
-0.0261127409,
-0.0042484063,
-0.0037725451,
0.0397882536,
0.0154296113,
0.0959036276,
0.0404131748,
-0.0454499386,
-0.0102226892,
0.0239944253,
-0.0032203307,
-0.0499954782,
-0.0480554216,
0.0014241479,
0.0099694338,
0.0218538567,
-0.0401771329,
-0.0615439489,
0.0470149852,
0.0273155384,
-0.0198593512,
0.0117751127,
0.0204624571,
0.0017167325,
-0.0311786048,
0.0328370668,
-0.0119683985,
0.0204415359,
-0.0379345082,
-0.03754282,
0.0465693474,
-0.0330659263,
-0.0517587326,
-0.0226159431,
-0.0999235436,
-0.0450617298,
0.0119787585,
0.0250960384,
0.0190052669,
0.0403035469,
-0.0336001329,
-0.0725915283,
0.0599323511,
0.0424227044,
-0.1028318554,
0.0121734021,
0.0429881774,
0.0219896082,
-0.0216608066,
0.0418242998,
-0.0708171651,
0.0396714471,
-0.0130415075,
0.0085450625,
-0.042452842,
-0.0131849162,
-0.0089868801,
0.0003459593,
0.1190498397,
0.0394329801,
0.0060674828,
-0.0486465544,
0.0329372548,
0.0200188849,
0.0001723446,
-0.0577870272,
-0.0258319955,
-0.0025403097,
-0.0560179688,
-0.0475448556,
0.0236593988,
-0.0247297287,
0.0373968929,
-0.028077811,
0.0306547824,
0.0494094826,
0.0144820483,
0.0218186323,
0.0063282824,
-0.0140656196,
0.0428082459,
0.0182698965,
-0.0079016285,
-0.0111938054,
0.0538927205,
-0.0168003701,
0.0112385172,
0.007408116,
0.0032377129,
-0.0701067001,
-0.0574947484,
-0.0168954246,
0.0070064696,
-0.0088099791,
-0.0244433768,
0.0204002708,
0.0272360146,
0.0202918537,
-0.0190988202,
0.0447076149,
-0.0337490216,
-0.0131954681,
0.053821329,
0.0101210605,
-0.0115907546,
0.0092590274,
0.0769476295,
0.0256395265,
0.0506147332,
0.0018122601,
0.0487461351,
-0.0423813276,
-0.0250711031,
0.0445749909,
0.0353934653,
-0.0066058543,
0.0183459073,
-0.0321605243,
-0.0668664575,
0.0276648775,
-0.0420071036,
-0.0271530263,
0.00045447,
0.0125695104,
0.0047484529,
-0.012608232,
0.0546034724,
-0.0201049875,
-0.0129800783,
-0.0027428193,
-0.0094590597,
0.0389512219,
-6.971688752e-33,
-0.0474012196,
0.0225596111,
0.0088677034,
-0.0031058062,
0.0063646687,
0.0259063598,
-0.032529261,
0.014713834,
-0.026186116,
-0.0181944594,
0.001152596,
0.0433023088,
0.0082448851,
0.0404725596,
-0.0245224629,
-0.0359341204,
0.0700777546,
-0.0353263728,
0.020447012,
0.0217879359,
0.025163576,
0.0713848695,
0.0524201877,
-0.0690803826,
0.0128145982,
-0.0192473512,
0.0041855695,
-0.0070563974,
0.059183009,
0.0497004203,
-0.0126266517,
0.0257818773,
0.024667358,
-0.050150089,
-0.035432741,
0.0453508943,
-0.1103647649,
-0.0319815725,
0.0141784819,
0.0339325555,
-0.0144011285,
0.0363020897,
-0.0130546438,
-0.0114517855,
0.0615178421,
-0.00562716,
0.0235525332,
-0.0026286428,
0.0059168874,
-0.0322975628,
-0.0251907595,
0.0241770018,
-0.048349645,
-0.0184783284,
0.0801595822,
0.0647196546,
0.0268418156,
0.040902786,
-0.0884352028,
-0.0138994176,
-0.0151849706,
-0.019347487,
0.0274158251,
0.0040092133,
-0.0176772792,
0.0730852187,
0.0025908821,
-0.0403523445,
-0.0327844359,
0.0062611001,
0.0401244722,
0.0215415414,
-0.029306598,
0.0602609329,
0.0235739294,
-0.0267805923,
-0.0657752231,
-0.0058580986,
0.0160340667,
-0.0187878851,
0.0399567708,
0.0172049124,
-0.0512210093,
0.0005548633,
-0.0654407814,
-0.0309421346,
-0.0593855456,
0.0008454986,
0.0491481423,
0.0446823761,
-0.0118494704,
0.0044678655,
0.0686359778,
-0.0519204773,
-0.0186216868,
0.0216852706,
-0.0117278127,
-0.0145510603,
-0.0175319891,
0.0595624335,
-0.0841995329,
-0.038789928,
0.0487030298,
0.0306959711,
0.0261542425,
-0.0018549684,
0.0590248369,
0.018592108,
-0.0691655204,
-0.0205813628,
-0.0045005046,
0.0012548931,
-0.0398400463,
0.0139287766,
0.0323184915,
0.0387824774,
-0.0028905936,
0.0832273364,
0.0138681764,
-0.0227068439,
0.0136862556,
-0.0099479929,
-0.0050860103,
0.0110348314,
-0.0306428708,
-0.0339524411,
0.0231862906,
-0.0325461105,
0.0184266455,
-0.0492287502,
0.012630417,
0.0344185047,
2.643e-7,
0.027585784,
0.0267224219,
-0.014028661,
-0.0291773733,
0.0327676907,
0.056616623,
-0.008156688,
0.0313126333,
-0.0161239505,
-0.0310426131,
0.0208865628,
0.0328379013,
0.0207302887,
0.0094868885,
-0.0840792507,
-0.0044170697,
-0.0337347127,
0.0079209274,
-0.0328504369,
0.001891737,
0.0773840845,
0.1236267462,
0.0145622296,
0.0102006234,
-0.0083083101,
-0.0198092442,
0.062357299,
-0.0219418835,
0.0121360151,
0.000795455,
-0.0367725715,
0.0506432354,
-0.028325649,
0.0217259731,
-0.0156570561,
0.0376383141,
0.0143656954,
0.0635693669,
0.0055691926,
-0.08176478,
-0.0265939701,
-0.0069902437,
-0.0071472051,
0.0007968313,
0.0979046822,
-0.0990837216,
-0.0339705311,
-0.024596028,
-0.0357916206,
-0.001691267,
-0.0038813853,
0.0449201576,
0.013328515,
0.0157760531,
0.0017163465,
-0.0269263666,
-0.0174736306,
-0.1286154091,
0.0204506908,
0.0298480857,
-0.0434691533,
0.0152757475,
-0.0285158474,
-0.0520196371,
0.0630570203,
-0.0600608028,
0.0070117912,
2.090122858e-34,
0.0193160456,
-0.0177669581,
-0.0195138957,
-0.0039007517,
-0.0113785174,
-0.0260665864,
-0.0380080082,
-0.0298691113,
0.058782313,
-0.0678812042,
-0.0042209309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05915v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05915v1 | FireAct: Toward Language Agent Fine-tuning | 2023-10-09T17:58:38 | 2023-10-09T17:58:38 | Baian Chen, Chang Shu, Ehsan Shareghi, Nigel Collier, Karthik Narasimhan, Shunyu Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent efforts have augmented language models (LMs) with external tools or
environments, leading to the development of language agents that can reason and
act. However, most of these agents rely on few-shot prompting techniques with
off-the-shelf LMs. In this paper, we investigate and argue for the overlooked
direction of fine-tuning LMs to obtain language agents. Using a setup of
question answering (QA) with a Google search API, we explore a variety of base
LMs, prompting methods, fine-tuning data, and QA tasks, and find language
agents are consistently improved after fine-tuning their backbone LMs. For
example, fine-tuning Llama2-7B with 500 agent trajectories generated by GPT-4
leads to a 77% HotpotQA performance increase. Furthermore, we propose FireAct,
a novel approach to fine-tuning LMs with trajectories from multiple tasks and
prompting methods, and show having more diverse fine-tuning data can further
improve agents. Along with other findings regarding scaling effects,
robustness, generalization, efficiency and cost, our work establishes
comprehensive benefits of fine-tuning LMs for agents, and provides an initial
set of experimental designs, insights, as well as open questions toward
language agent fine-tuning. | [
0.0584605373,
0.0185867585,
-0.0304398909,
0.0473229885,
-0.0085941851,
0.0150440596,
-0.0061985939,
-0.0269841738,
0.0091130883,
-0.0398773439,
-0.0329798274,
-0.0011741179,
-0.0345594808,
0.02793427,
0.011394402,
-0.0353791863,
0.0514858812,
-0.0590710863,
0.0237589851,
-0.0162317399,
0.0030592496,
0.0155269708,
-0.026666481,
0.0534579046,
0.0342484005,
-0.0163404401,
-0.0296600331,
-0.0158237144,
0.0235770978,
0.0029905587,
0.0115580205,
0.0485913977,
0.0132790385,
0.0332612023,
0.0000019009,
-0.0529435799,
0.0124959182,
-0.0172567032,
-0.0365619473,
-0.0068623559,
0.0060019768,
0.0310555119,
0.008026924,
0.0449391566,
-0.0675202012,
-0.0060671838,
0.034692958,
-0.0090110293,
0.061413005,
0.0677214786,
0.0179081392,
-0.0042064632,
-0.0375533476,
-0.0144508369,
-0.0156092411,
-0.055448547,
-0.0030173527,
-0.038466569,
0.0338242874,
0.0333372168,
-0.0196584724,
0.030067822,
0.0288038738,
-0.0039134873,
-0.0265237484,
0.0303584877,
-0.0980343968,
-0.0161954276,
-0.011392137,
0.0806751847,
0.0254239347,
-0.0188883524,
-0.0048499038,
0.0111597907,
0.0169618744,
-0.0064628362,
-0.0467591621,
0.0193586424,
0.0193483979,
-0.0047302777,
0.0275588557,
-0.0351884253,
0.0185713433,
0.0266661271,
-0.0227735229,
0.0864522085,
-0.0054113721,
-0.0033266435,
-0.0203981251,
-0.0073536118,
-0.0028823472,
-0.0718586445,
-0.0164663959,
0.0714844465,
-0.0589261986,
0.0289963409,
-0.022208916,
0.0182078537,
0.0347204544,
0.0152418371,
0.0270382166,
0.055370409,
-0.016094394,
0.0461240597,
-0.0104003185,
0.040027611,
-0.002404016,
0.0499445125,
-0.0607915372,
-0.0457068309,
-0.040525049,
-0.0196637474,
-0.0417290516,
0.0083230752,
-0.021670701,
-0.0062568011,
-0.0222034734,
0.0569936559,
0.0186019018,
-0.0076517947,
-0.0377346538,
0.0115038408,
-0.0284318086,
0.0123926988,
-0.0543549024,
0.0212370325,
-0.0951139331,
0.0317057706,
0.0631807745,
-0.0742488131,
-0.0332602449,
0.0066349083,
0.0185671654,
-0.0117313871,
0.0153186554,
0.0664407685,
0.0085916081,
-0.0528174974,
-0.0142304804,
-0.0189561769,
0.0230740253,
-0.0852138251,
-0.0262690745,
-0.0802983865,
0.0344836861,
0.0038547951,
-0.0267756414,
0.0049737585,
0.003429543,
0.0161992423,
-0.0247020498,
0.0666600317,
-0.0287408326,
0.0324790105,
0.0027775725,
0.0089851469,
-0.0371415652,
0.0961691737,
0.0352970026,
0.0226560701,
0.0631460622,
-0.0056802151,
0.0246087778,
0.0351224281,
0.0044436543,
0.0376404449,
0.0274981447,
0.0329593793,
-0.0072030374,
0.0250377115,
-0.0016375002,
0.0241668243,
-0.0234028939,
0.0183518566,
0.0469355546,
0.0815103799,
0.0009433351,
-0.012276615,
0.0321049392,
-0.0145767238,
0.0161785856,
-0.0038915521,
-0.0653897151,
0.0569405295,
-0.0302213989,
0.0100272875,
0.02767854,
0.0590195097,
-0.0555824861,
-0.036582768,
-0.0031778975,
0.000114167,
0.0274015013,
0.0372545421,
0.0183864888,
-0.000400574,
-0.0213070437,
0.0069773369,
0.0295664631,
-0.0362987146,
-0.0199520085,
-0.0750100017,
0.0396646485,
0.0829564855,
0.0552338772,
-0.0008744915,
-0.0655885041,
0.0022831245,
0.0411557294,
0.0546690114,
0.037174575,
-0.0216530841,
0.0261422805,
-0.0416840315,
-0.0334637128,
-0.0195191372,
0.0074397884,
-0.0013134872,
0.0301091876,
0.0158196073,
-0.006280934,
-0.0388604514,
-0.0078015481,
0.0098646674,
-0.0249668732,
-0.024838144,
-0.0105863409,
0.0073860693,
0.0189725626,
0.0083099371,
0.0063633742,
-0.001231987,
0.034796387,
-0.0137613695,
-0.0107713537,
0.0319224298,
0.0079938406,
-0.0115887839,
0.0459058136,
0.0166908763,
0.0034882913,
0.0462432988,
-0.0493726805,
-0.0482826456,
0.0088369213,
-0.015022004,
0.0090701506,
-0.0119342748,
-0.0001579843,
-0.029338371,
0.026813224,
-0.0128213894,
0.0385442935,
0.019998135,
-0.0041000564,
0.0258158408,
0.055437617,
-0.0044408976,
-0.0415576138,
0.0012414793,
0.03442166,
0.0323322043,
0.027627755,
0.0148433149,
0.0237865243,
-0.0563936569,
-0.0090942597,
-0.0797602907,
0.0177820902,
-0.0334415585,
0.0172388665,
0.0351356566,
0.0299280174,
-0.0235164147,
-0.0051946589,
-0.0442503914,
0.0214102492,
0.0319937095,
0.0562577806,
0.0316660069,
0.0141387181,
-0.053505037,
-0.0626199171,
0.0023490654,
-0.0055961362,
-0.001535703,
-0.0078780707,
0.0257995222,
-0.0501675308,
-0.0070118336,
-0.0675892904,
0.0238482691,
-0.01778372,
-0.0746114478,
0.0241013933,
-0.0284559224,
-0.0127297835,
0.073722519,
0.0059925164,
-0.00268818,
0.0620054901,
-0.0188622773,
-0.0619619414,
0.0431598015,
-0.0205997806,
-0.0247769058,
-0.033513505,
-0.0122707356,
0.0017505237,
0.0371082649,
-0.0296651982,
-0.0010631046,
-0.0539695621,
0.0452547669,
0.0283445511,
-0.0224601608,
-0.0056018638,
0.0436182059,
-0.0302973595,
0.061775472,
-0.0093020089,
-0.0566121005,
0.0901350975,
-0.0137318987,
-0.0064795385,
-0.0651534051,
-0.0286139343,
-0.0405468009,
0.068999216,
-0.0265056174,
0.0110671585,
-0.020116128,
0.0038672523,
-0.0557636805,
-0.0354453437,
0.0045216414,
-0.0346821584,
0.0708171055,
-0.0384737849,
0.0095513985,
-0.0103524216,
-0.0530837402,
-0.0478849821,
-0.02424955,
-0.0500138551,
0.0233923048,
-0.0340555161,
-0.025260115,
-0.0130562615,
-0.014614108,
0.0327067152,
0.037003912,
-0.0366002917,
-0.0044847587,
-0.0381391831,
-0.007084881,
0.0863502994,
0.073682718,
0.016683083,
-0.0054464447,
0.070845522,
0.020325508,
0.0610512383,
-0.0323885381,
0.0047069401,
-0.0083631249,
0.0334414728,
-0.0149356592,
-0.0090844054,
0.0328896642,
0.0738641694,
-0.0614802986,
-0.0257377941,
0.1063088775,
0.0279127024,
-0.0101528307,
0.0085753398,
-0.0297356304,
0.0409709401,
0.0342464335,
0.060706418,
-0.0724561736,
-0.0684608147,
0.0011854589,
0.063360095,
-0.016604675,
-0.0194332916,
-0.0023675566,
-0.1164528504,
0.0429246388,
-0.014071865,
-0.0249018762,
-0.0134461029,
-0.0534183383,
0.0130803678,
0.0012648059,
0.0339501202,
0.0244154111,
0.0072539104,
-0.0103530707,
-0.001318636,
0.017152831,
-0.0514085665,
0.0273240935,
-0.0683570206,
0.0537433363,
0.0816104338,
0.0056988136,
-0.0064502298,
-0.0190609992,
-0.0013125534,
-0.0062890514,
0.0245214738,
-0.0131191844,
-0.0011214189,
0.0086038383,
-0.0236516874,
-0.002768737,
0.0334392115,
-0.0550133847,
0.0057011973,
0.016546702,
0.0907792374,
-0.0213743243,
-0.0000896658,
-0.0191122368,
-0.0015598746,
-0.0169932917,
0.0641951934,
0.0331202969,
-0.029382335,
-0.0568900071,
-0.0456620604,
-0.0644119307,
-0.0575899333,
-0.0131360218,
0.01407535,
0.0026770141,
0.018541364,
-0.0649968162,
-0.0824921876,
0.0636415258,
0.0287194476,
-0.0099082151,
0.068376869,
-0.0299393516,
0.0217640344,
0.0110070538,
0.0381493866,
-0.047110267,
0.0135787036,
-0.0396276638,
-0.0421169102,
0.0474702939,
-0.0231221188,
-0.0001677053,
0.0260292888,
-0.0733103082,
-0.0823541209,
-0.0059857303,
0.056605354,
0.0302548669,
0.0336028188,
-0.0444930457,
-0.0468300357,
-0.0055836206,
0.0470806211,
-0.0348723494,
0.0227770507,
-0.0026415505,
0.0073035737,
-0.0038271761,
0.0564325154,
-0.0973266512,
-0.0023617588,
-0.0249802861,
0.0653026998,
-0.0324999578,
-0.0439196527,
0.0198983047,
0.0244613178,
-0.0076036514,
0.0140631553,
-0.0193788949,
-0.0098219784,
0.0226116404,
-0.0039294017,
-0.0196012184,
-0.0190419406,
-0.0066096913,
-0.0114579415,
-0.0315466151,
0.0296926834,
0.0044557829,
-0.018244382,
0.0216593668,
-0.0363056995,
0.0214641746,
-0.0043827435,
0.0128805507,
0.0120235998,
0.0019530703,
-0.0177042838,
0.0229057148,
0.0036138266,
0.0477899648,
-0.0224876124,
0.0347140916,
0.0238645077,
-0.0133012813,
-0.0416659452,
0.0555553921,
-0.1010510474,
-0.0988012925,
0.0485065952,
0.0124147581,
0.0563195497,
0.0026476069,
0.0417475998,
-0.0083116842,
-0.0060690534,
-0.002335469,
-0.0080025755,
0.0333101489,
-0.0107637988,
0.0559053905,
0.0276706442,
-0.0143965576,
-0.0127017442,
0.0775300935,
-0.0358892083,
0.0764816478,
0.0023734507,
0.0136518646,
-0.0194613319,
-0.0188078396,
-0.0338634364,
0.0025578039,
-0.0141076967,
-0.0134366704,
-0.0318081677,
-0.0622332878,
-0.0265688915,
-0.0066038445,
-0.0160294846,
-0.0475918762,
0.0270381961,
0.0535844155,
0.0177120958,
-0.0319628231,
-0.0364182964,
-0.015872417,
-0.0493611433,
-0.0105799558,
0.0047158245,
-6.416001716e-33,
-0.0315907709,
-0.0124724461,
0.0396139435,
-0.0129898833,
-0.0058551296,
-0.0161464307,
-0.047619801,
-0.0103963818,
-0.0671318248,
-0.0221728384,
-0.0403267518,
0.0237280019,
0.0152910929,
-0.0065385322,
0.006680781,
-0.0468607731,
0.0215881336,
-0.0094482228,
-0.0467587896,
0.0081568453,
0.0511081778,
-0.0050744978,
0.0120342905,
-0.0012472671,
-0.0003373532,
-0.0276810788,
-0.028514659,
0.0651644915,
-0.0479666851,
0.0813379213,
0.0024726663,
0.0323703215,
0.0301509816,
-0.0087987138,
-0.0093017817,
0.0199408308,
-0.0668311715,
-0.0377576165,
0.0249293558,
-0.0067133983,
-0.0464629605,
-0.062984705,
0.0232117437,
0.000480169,
-0.0052268384,
0.0235817358,
0.0108640967,
-0.0269378293,
0.002869071,
0.0219685622,
-0.0461632535,
0.003795875,
-0.005958206,
-0.0405148901,
-0.0257553663,
0.0535411313,
-0.0038083824,
0.0294170957,
-0.0237890184,
0.0055020573,
0.0313838199,
0.0165417138,
0.0717440844,
0.0348872244,
0.0096111828,
0.0382781178,
0.0082129743,
0.0213055033,
-0.0182580445,
0.0035426544,
0.0299114659,
0.0268043336,
0.0424541682,
0.0461943485,
-0.0165604465,
-0.008051374,
-0.0544903018,
0.0390903056,
0.051303573,
0.0130051551,
0.0238701049,
0.0041051065,
-0.0290777367,
-0.0188807938,
-0.045821771,
0.0310608204,
-0.0435854234,
-0.0431427062,
0.0546233691,
0.0229046326,
-0.0099590523,
-0.0595992021,
0.0253571477,
-0.0295712389,
0.0278569218,
0.0305389557,
-0.0493198149,
0.0300833248,
0.0110197896,
0.0199779142,
-0.0423078053,
-0.0065536937,
0.0124411331,
-0.0043316386,
0.0029146667,
0.0411631018,
-0.0155482609,
0.0264274441,
-0.036354363,
0.010237202,
-0.0471151508,
0.0413601436,
-0.0103289327,
-0.0174078923,
0.0013005567,
-0.0002344881,
-0.0048498106,
0.0682502761,
0.0138715478,
-0.0089061307,
-0.0177321378,
-0.0103117367,
-0.0095387893,
0.0036091127,
-0.0298723523,
0.0054351734,
-0.0540147536,
0.0392337069,
-0.0194927361,
-0.0547853075,
-0.0153540308,
0.0273455605,
2.631e-7,
0.0209868383,
0.0367285274,
0.0046010613,
0.0509316623,
0.0082730986,
0.0492611006,
-0.0193575025,
0.0140313916,
0.0150748082,
0.0053842096,
-0.0253712609,
0.0441075265,
0.0243788213,
0.0450357273,
-0.0730905831,
0.0050868136,
-0.035305623,
0.0019056387,
-0.0685465187,
-0.0207032841,
0.0249550045,
0.097101815,
0.0235718712,
-0.009084072,
-0.017185159,
-0.0631927177,
0.0242967978,
-0.0131851817,
-0.0178193636,
0.03365767,
-0.0181059595,
0.0465938672,
0.0083206696,
-0.0003904649,
0.0092420569,
0.0395299755,
-0.0329303294,
0.0536881946,
-0.0066117132,
-0.052954074,
0.0058027175,
-0.0465530306,
0.0285520013,
-0.0621056259,
0.0890733674,
-0.0147216637,
-0.0307499133,
-0.0003243929,
0.0191993956,
-0.0164307803,
-0.0226863176,
-0.0448815562,
-0.0320752114,
0.021962285,
-0.015853446,
-0.0120157637,
-0.0076565379,
-0.08450865,
0.011638457,
-0.0018981661,
-0.0152169634,
-0.052958183,
-0.0504775904,
-0.0003258074,
0.0103834858,
-0.0525438525,
0.01605184,
2.311869765e-34,
0.0150344865,
0.002272188,
0.0205861591,
0.0663573891,
0.0339455456,
0.0131922774,
-0.0052607902,
-0.0094450992,
0.057754457,
-0.0864503831,
-0.0326579995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05914v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05914v2 | NEFTune: Noisy Embeddings Improve Instruction Finetuning | 2023-10-09T17:58:34 | 2023-10-10T17:31:00 | Neel Jain, Ping-yeh Chiang, Yuxin Wen, John Kirchenbauer, Hong-Min Chu, Gowthami Somepalli, Brian R. Bartoldson, Bhavya Kailkhura, Avi Schwarzschild, Aniruddha Saha, Micah Goldblum, Jonas Geiping, Tom Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We show that language model finetuning can be improved, sometimes
dramatically, with a simple augmentation. NEFTune adds noise to the embedding
vectors during training. Standard finetuning of LLaMA-2-7B using Alpaca
achieves 29.79% on AlpacaEval, which rises to 64.69% using noisy embeddings.
NEFTune also improves over strong baselines on modern instruction datasets.
Models trained with Evol-Instruct see a 10% improvement, with ShareGPT an 8%
improvement, and with OpenPlatypus an 8% improvement. Even powerful models
further refined with RLHF such as LLaMA-2-Chat benefit from additional training
with NEFTune. | [
0.0058753705,
0.0459441505,
-0.0141088441,
0.0443430692,
0.0268123522,
0.0250345208,
-0.027106436,
-0.0219828431,
-0.0536757335,
-0.0419066027,
-0.0541965701,
-0.0118106408,
0.0025442913,
-0.0279329251,
0.0792430118,
-0.0467564277,
0.0572830252,
-0.019516822,
-0.01309592,
-0.0076557957,
0.0317542814,
0.0182595961,
-0.0041446341,
0.0413859189,
0.0444829725,
-0.0149900476,
-0.0379935056,
-0.0032785996,
0.026523428,
-0.0248462614,
0.0088000977,
0.0530868694,
0.0257001538,
0.017760817,
0.0000019821,
-0.0289741289,
0.0121520096,
-0.0067832875,
-0.0275971293,
0.0687250346,
0.0542001128,
-0.0288500767,
-0.0386242382,
0.0139478212,
0.0096278731,
0.0163227189,
0.0680601671,
0.0524513684,
0.0670855641,
0.0464668646,
0.0085447142,
-0.0316274352,
0.0300773382,
-0.0398242474,
0.0188936815,
-0.0083166733,
-0.013389078,
-0.0222814642,
0.0231978223,
0.0460526049,
-0.0432243869,
0.0142819416,
0.0283427518,
-0.0077146669,
0.0106417118,
0.0465635657,
-0.0324073918,
-0.0245639775,
-0.0243421439,
0.0844617411,
-0.0462837368,
0.0089550065,
-0.0255837813,
0.0082462076,
0.005787415,
-0.0644326061,
-0.0454994366,
0.0216120258,
0.0335670933,
0.0406872407,
0.072700642,
-0.0607690178,
0.0411015898,
0.0025051201,
0.0239506029,
0.0158178695,
0.0383888781,
-0.0322906077,
-0.005123239,
0.0045766141,
-0.023538731,
-0.0194825083,
-0.0145055829,
0.02631866,
-0.0089669209,
0.0103550563,
-0.052730456,
-0.0097352732,
0.0385596901,
-0.0318318903,
0.0599121302,
0.0764594898,
-0.041714672,
0.0038337922,
-0.0332247131,
0.0152369542,
0.0133337872,
0.035782773,
-0.0241423063,
0.0564046837,
-0.0145135382,
0.0065765544,
-0.0617299899,
0.0415446013,
-0.0626436472,
0.0078475866,
-0.0451451354,
0.0173366647,
-0.0129044093,
-0.007702562,
-0.0119409813,
-0.0207109898,
-0.0680521801,
0.025258366,
0.0049791429,
0.0250587706,
-0.0658701509,
0.0160486549,
-0.0057750195,
-0.0682847202,
-0.0139307166,
-0.0019647575,
-0.0153696956,
-0.0290999319,
0.007521926,
0.0568414219,
-0.0191832948,
-0.0500491522,
-0.0446206219,
-0.0013661337,
0.0023571481,
-0.0691143051,
-0.0062967734,
-0.053685531,
0.0013650142,
-0.0273886286,
0.0250841305,
-0.0144064305,
0.0035282143,
-0.0037239795,
-0.0174162909,
0.0861820132,
-0.0302190073,
-0.0175928213,
-0.0013695224,
0.0092137912,
0.0366020389,
0.0630811527,
0.0227223914,
-0.0055687889,
0.0221353285,
-0.029318342,
-0.0461578518,
0.0237754341,
0.0271530785,
0.0061268527,
0.0058407718,
-0.0238292105,
-0.0115700187,
0.0199206304,
0.0660379305,
0.0502455421,
-0.0449631959,
-0.0392896719,
0.048915036,
0.0289166588,
0.0342036597,
0.0022579303,
0.0632743239,
0.0054780697,
0.0045109256,
0.0396874435,
-0.0690161884,
0.0305646099,
-0.0422591679,
0.0218387749,
0.0337169021,
0.0608347394,
-0.0518876165,
-0.0502400026,
0.0120552005,
-0.0190651938,
-0.0009058532,
-0.0274462663,
0.015835898,
-0.0027649547,
-0.0442743786,
0.004014608,
0.0797817856,
-0.0286138654,
0.0026470646,
-0.0399681218,
0.0398399867,
0.0525553897,
0.0126145622,
-0.0113934549,
-0.0761553496,
-0.0178695377,
-0.0185128469,
0.0339700729,
0.0574594662,
-0.0242654365,
0.0404712819,
-0.0785893723,
0.0018472377,
-0.0182639249,
0.0429592915,
0.0090284636,
-0.0143988812,
0.0144252768,
-0.0047187409,
-0.0024266716,
-0.0428033397,
0.048859857,
-0.0416041836,
-0.0414448678,
-0.0603111647,
0.0172112882,
0.0109786093,
0.0139111886,
-0.0134650255,
0.0005536284,
0.0322023109,
-0.0102840886,
0.0251342878,
-0.019703187,
-0.042985592,
-0.0642888471,
0.0645357892,
0.0055807843,
-0.0117170056,
0.0169639438,
-0.0432033651,
-0.0170721654,
0.0093177352,
-0.0259784386,
0.0379100926,
-0.0315752365,
0.0450371578,
-0.0081263455,
0.0236899741,
-0.0460301079,
-0.0145390881,
-0.0276499242,
0.0330642536,
0.0424649715,
-0.0013101746,
0.0106449025,
-0.0369122066,
-0.0541702844,
0.0274080168,
-0.01485522,
0.0337111242,
-0.0342516638,
0.0621396452,
-0.0387141965,
-0.0467076674,
-0.0520408489,
0.0237250365,
-0.0241175611,
0.0369884335,
0.0416129082,
-0.010593785,
-0.0025795046,
-0.0037627274,
-0.0083205281,
0.0051542339,
-0.0292220842,
0.0323656239,
0.0312799811,
0.0144990627,
-0.078875035,
-0.0513631813,
-0.0255099237,
0.0065018572,
-0.0060738744,
-0.0278320871,
-0.0187596343,
-0.080483295,
0.0418256633,
-0.0258836914,
0.0275575016,
-0.0163458157,
-0.1172252223,
0.0222546142,
0.0249082558,
0.0481988639,
0.0563310273,
-0.044644434,
0.0499191545,
0.0514346249,
0.0118026584,
-0.0351214819,
0.026941957,
-0.0251955558,
-0.0458096415,
-0.0673372224,
-0.0043587373,
-0.0528017282,
0.0951370597,
-0.0516821593,
-0.0158747267,
-0.0704096705,
-0.0132461181,
-0.0290657263,
-0.0177867021,
0.0123579437,
0.0205922704,
-0.0111664627,
0.0243263543,
-0.038517721,
-0.0731065273,
0.064544186,
-0.0386285335,
-0.0260633603,
-0.046458561,
-0.0257277284,
0.004423317,
-0.0004758916,
0.0150142899,
0.021544721,
0.0281358231,
-0.04166466,
-0.086324811,
-0.0206470098,
0.0109097026,
-0.0309385546,
0.040883787,
-0.0188504327,
-0.0289652757,
-0.0233876109,
-0.0266577154,
-0.006059763,
-0.0288797263,
-0.0129058203,
0.0054203901,
0.0170567092,
-0.0325490199,
0.0026587187,
-0.0174991116,
-0.0266451836,
0.014269013,
-0.0486545712,
0.0084542548,
-0.0273381006,
-0.0041519008,
0.0505662672,
0.013245929,
0.0250269864,
-0.0441065095,
0.0236109421,
0.0147120776,
-0.0166759398,
-0.0028538618,
-0.0211108904,
0.0364279002,
0.0448935442,
-0.0098733753,
-0.0449034534,
0.0209060907,
0.1131329909,
-0.039959196,
-0.0095123164,
0.0954273045,
0.0160051398,
-0.0004411329,
0.0390895829,
-0.0328857191,
0.0765170455,
0.0175890103,
0.0432010852,
-0.0655725971,
-0.0290128943,
0.0169837847,
0.0234274473,
0.0168465339,
0.0169661511,
0.0095322914,
-0.112763308,
0.0356268138,
0.0413637646,
-0.0520993099,
-0.0488663949,
-0.0306366179,
-0.011227563,
0.0017332343,
0.0544957034,
0.0044284207,
-0.0267781876,
0.0138767138,
0.0418786332,
0.0100731337,
-0.0498392656,
0.0155805042,
-0.022730466,
0.1214761809,
0.0316897593,
0.0115147317,
0.0085115721,
-0.0625795349,
0.0552596375,
-0.0065134042,
-0.0193334799,
-0.0162455998,
0.0695938766,
0.0068243323,
-0.0403057188,
0.0111386599,
0.0151848989,
0.0262965132,
0.0213177316,
-0.0478783697,
0.0724368766,
0.0064191907,
-0.0000095243,
0.0036820108,
0.0213087201,
-0.0112030171,
0.0315677188,
0.056420926,
-0.0300715268,
-0.0108080264,
-0.0452574939,
-0.0063490905,
-0.0253245197,
-0.0091911573,
0.0520331264,
-0.0272927489,
-0.0474445485,
-0.0595421791,
-0.0961738527,
0.0567842573,
0.0353864878,
0.0201658849,
0.0062022707,
0.0143084135,
-0.0137653667,
-0.0223913249,
0.0255260468,
-0.0233102143,
0.0342013501,
-0.0831219405,
-0.0323044583,
0.0210166834,
0.0175364353,
-0.0035840443,
-0.0103156026,
-0.0612366162,
-0.0885352641,
-0.0052587888,
0.0613380708,
0.0233156364,
0.0335512906,
-0.0130149247,
-0.0636578128,
0.0191327725,
0.0520488992,
-0.0362563431,
0.0179199632,
0.0884680152,
-0.0425460264,
0.0192772411,
0.0521647707,
-0.0045346185,
0.019273445,
0.0019699272,
0.0510593988,
-0.0064987489,
-0.0249565188,
0.0100634117,
0.0069907517,
0.0202279892,
-0.0235637557,
-0.023956513,
-0.0495712794,
0.0249076728,
-0.0092046047,
0.0287372023,
-0.038999375,
-0.014465685,
0.0492649078,
0.0128976703,
0.0082323048,
-0.0126736322,
0.0199373029,
0.0670704395,
-0.0146870073,
0.0343529917,
0.0007116565,
0.0138441576,
0.0107369851,
0.0587763079,
-0.0068528145,
0.0030799408,
-0.0170032401,
0.0416605696,
-0.0195673816,
0.0223564934,
0.0029204618,
0.019864656,
-0.0242706388,
0.0461122915,
-0.0036229745,
-0.002424872,
-0.0353129767,
0.0090916855,
0.0604290403,
-0.0053877882,
0.0768933296,
-0.0038061638,
-0.0090864981,
-0.0104824686,
0.0482935272,
-0.0479612686,
-0.0208528042,
0.0720111355,
0.0358828381,
-0.0181092545,
-0.0258796159,
0.0745375901,
-0.0067042005,
0.074210234,
0.0076819276,
0.0414712355,
-0.0278122909,
-0.003632305,
0.030452935,
0.0304560345,
-0.0234232415,
0.0239818934,
-0.0079645999,
-0.0882195532,
-0.0461689904,
0.0208652988,
-0.0300891064,
-0.0133841252,
0.015607439,
0.0142790135,
-0.0169526674,
-0.0037801878,
-0.0272735972,
-0.0374706872,
0.0392945074,
-0.023405239,
-0.0047233878,
-6.643373915e-33,
-0.0584491119,
0.0087308725,
0.010763404,
-0.0060871737,
-0.0483307466,
0.001777243,
-0.0206148252,
0.0142558282,
-0.0530745015,
0.0345700085,
-0.0064469543,
-0.0065176189,
0.0110810725,
0.0081068743,
0.018192105,
0.013147153,
0.0636183769,
0.0018800288,
0.0034226379,
0.0137799345,
-0.0236217938,
0.0259250365,
0.0741319954,
-0.0311699603,
-0.0056502474,
0.0050794319,
-0.0084296362,
0.0218448527,
-0.0123829609,
0.0427520983,
-0.0260618776,
0.0122186923,
-0.0014428971,
-0.03608476,
-0.0488736629,
-0.0381654128,
-0.0857268497,
-0.055625502,
0.0297532696,
0.0212336536,
-0.0413323492,
-0.0402564853,
0.0336037129,
-0.0065819174,
-0.0249421205,
-0.0085587567,
-0.0075836987,
-0.0307946429,
-0.0291649494,
0.0467349254,
-0.0936732441,
0.0201911647,
-0.0031585142,
-0.0473987311,
0.0304675717,
-0.0281909704,
0.013712625,
-0.0134129506,
-0.0316297933,
0.0123352474,
0.0511092916,
0.0750484765,
0.0580872558,
0.0014106113,
-0.0153762633,
0.018622566,
0.0190120861,
-0.0120640798,
0.0275926758,
0.0039217966,
0.0503789373,
0.0438274778,
0.0087186052,
0.0124301296,
0.0512499958,
-0.0197466109,
-0.0373334587,
0.0109032718,
0.0417917967,
0.0173511077,
-0.0018324099,
0.0259748399,
-0.0563803911,
-0.0319903158,
-0.0253988057,
-0.015225335,
-0.0052293572,
-0.0469890647,
0.0167650804,
0.0178667717,
-0.0051554646,
-0.0018043591,
0.008229821,
-0.033196073,
-0.0110088531,
-0.0052162716,
-0.0242666919,
0.0270286929,
-0.0091035161,
-0.0121778622,
-0.0423381366,
-0.0497485287,
0.0001871566,
-0.0242456533,
0.0215332396,
0.0024070675,
0.0850362256,
0.0152942697,
-0.0785784721,
0.0095613515,
-0.0442609042,
0.0103897946,
0.0420621932,
0.0444402434,
0.0293393973,
-0.0307298824,
-0.0128236935,
0.0649969056,
0.0192902274,
0.022140095,
-0.041620966,
0.0153484801,
-0.0038088611,
0.0201659966,
-0.0404418781,
0.0018836687,
-0.0363027938,
0.0629436299,
0.0128809605,
-0.0425428338,
-0.03191166,
-0.0168350805,
2.741e-7,
0.0031950036,
0.0465630181,
0.0259781275,
0.0039572096,
-0.0002508876,
0.0251490436,
-0.0352374092,
0.0039370027,
0.0033580158,
-0.0056928424,
0.0004503404,
0.0137086036,
0.043434374,
0.0291202497,
-0.0521577746,
-0.0126689859,
-0.0433845744,
0.0139274811,
-0.0359500684,
-0.0283357389,
0.0290517174,
0.1407510191,
0.0153858392,
-0.0055714049,
0.0175465103,
-0.0438059494,
0.0133593697,
-0.0126615036,
-0.0121603608,
0.0362422243,
-0.0051959413,
0.0405930243,
-0.0070219231,
-0.0370387286,
-0.0247928295,
0.0169778243,
-0.0302070081,
0.0717229992,
-0.0197916944,
0.0125660943,
0.0395497531,
-0.0040606325,
-0.0219989643,
-0.0407567248,
0.0300410725,
-0.0329583548,
-0.0353515856,
-0.0284493305,
-0.011439614,
0.014531373,
0.0207241308,
-0.041636128,
-0.0016813684,
0.0152935069,
0.0114768408,
-0.0256126281,
-0.0351693593,
-0.056200657,
-0.0032016078,
0.0527822338,
-0.0096722506,
-0.0662041828,
-0.0347371027,
-0.0236353911,
0.0192000661,
-0.0333293565,
0.005747539,
2.605790878e-34,
0.0282643866,
-0.0268434659,
0.0715349764,
0.052606836,
0.0198206212,
-0.0036553759,
0.0247096755,
0.0030517275,
0.0253189467,
-0.0448658541,
-0.013364831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05910v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05910v2 | SALMON: Self-Alignment with Instructable Reward Models | 2023-10-09T17:56:53 | 2024-04-09T23:21:45 | Zhiqing Sun, Yikang Shen, Hongxin Zhang, Qinhong Zhou, Zhenfang Chen, David Cox, Yiming Yang, Chuang Gan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) on response demonstrations combined with
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) constitutes a powerful
paradigm for aligning LLM-based AI agents. However, a significant limitation of
such an approach is its dependency on high-quality human annotations, making
its application to intricate tasks challenging due to difficulties in obtaining
consistent response demonstrations and in-distribution response preferences.
This paper presents a novel approach, namely SALMON, to align base language
models with minimal human supervision, using only a small set of human-defined
principles, yet achieving superior performance. Central to our approach is an
instructable reward model. Trained on synthetic preference data, this model can
generate reward scores based on arbitrary human-defined principles. By merely
adjusting these principles during the RL training phase, we gain full control
over the preferences with the instructable reward model, subsequently
influencing the behavior of the RL-trained policy models, and reducing the
reliance on the collection of online human preferences. Applying our method to
the LLaMA-2-70b base language model, we developed an AI assistant named
Dromedary-2. With only 6 exemplars for in-context learning and 31 human-defined
principles, Dromedary-2 significantly surpasses the performance of several
state-of-the-art AI systems, including LLaMA-2-Chat-70b, on various benchmark
datasets. We have open-sourced the code and model weights to encourage further
research into aligning LLM-based AI agents with enhanced supervision
efficiency, improved controllability, and scalable oversight. | [
0.035102129,
0.0468959287,
-0.0033797636,
0.0202345382,
-0.0178806968,
0.0118426988,
-0.0442716554,
-0.0290604383,
-0.0043393988,
-0.0020596068,
-0.0906070247,
0.0060552261,
-0.0117135979,
0.0206827149,
0.0094610006,
-0.0412483923,
0.0442751572,
-0.0304661114,
0.0293001011,
-0.0179410651,
0.0206533987,
-0.0135342758,
-0.0412977003,
0.0266618226,
0.0000198479,
0.0100341914,
-0.0263145305,
0.0002411782,
0.0153064178,
-0.0294325612,
0.0306044407,
0.0363528915,
0.0387597345,
0.0077493009,
0.0000020481,
-0.0585506186,
0.0268355031,
-0.021286089,
-0.0376763977,
0.001359379,
0.0300055146,
0.00546011,
-0.0242700204,
0.0221273452,
-0.0490380861,
0.0457609557,
0.0404148214,
0.0411150977,
0.0590966493,
0.0873299539,
0.025231367,
-0.0304496363,
0.0274232887,
-0.0257830322,
0.0033131498,
-0.0299751274,
0.0057596397,
-0.0076288143,
0.0456255563,
-0.0197685454,
-0.0240837298,
0.0018382907,
0.0144579532,
-0.0093163941,
-0.0211217664,
0.0095061846,
-0.029746972,
-0.0394390635,
-0.0330498628,
0.0789104328,
-0.0065432815,
-0.0261867326,
0.0070493873,
-0.0196064804,
0.0238706339,
-0.0166443028,
-0.0246274564,
0.0203015711,
0.0173671506,
0.0424058624,
0.0204078685,
-0.0327398181,
0.0205716919,
0.0286666527,
0.0106020765,
0.0816262811,
-0.0325751714,
-0.0323251784,
0.0033069346,
0.0050105508,
-0.0179727431,
-0.0341504738,
-0.0170383379,
0.0578830056,
-0.0811524913,
0.0219395328,
-0.0612456612,
0.0131999049,
0.0175140817,
-0.0132369036,
0.0569706038,
0.0697819665,
-0.0100343954,
0.0277737752,
-0.0080549121,
0.1138733104,
-0.0217323937,
0.0664751604,
-0.0248213224,
0.0145826908,
-0.0207803734,
0.0152043747,
-0.0022344419,
0.0354252569,
-0.0192385707,
-0.0066481493,
-0.0547947921,
0.040277034,
-0.0385335349,
0.0628432557,
0.0112349195,
0.0154502373,
-0.0701025128,
0.0041016722,
-0.0627255216,
0.0103981588,
-0.032602746,
0.0416606776,
0.0369540304,
-0.0366213508,
0.0011355164,
0.0213588309,
-0.0232600868,
0.0134989424,
0.0445868373,
0.0923798084,
-0.0111136176,
-0.0347187892,
0.0018138379,
0.0058510704,
0.0054966281,
-0.0603305921,
-0.0111414781,
-0.0539156459,
0.0504047722,
-0.0209189113,
-0.0422630943,
-0.0443537794,
0.007056505,
0.0064892299,
-0.0027341663,
0.0702473447,
0.009437927,
0.0255641602,
0.0118667465,
-0.024881091,
-0.0523273423,
0.0618731752,
0.0677785203,
0.0380633399,
0.0138281099,
0.0029418031,
0.0303483531,
0.0473359339,
0.0132210348,
0.010126723,
-0.0319810361,
0.0115805557,
-0.0121019939,
0.0694391504,
0.0743087903,
0.0222769231,
0.009296298,
0.0103909653,
0.0688461289,
0.0543032996,
-0.0169873163,
-0.0351421274,
0.0214203652,
0.0309306253,
0.0297439843,
-0.0134472325,
-0.0912019387,
0.0530827083,
0.0025890232,
0.0278007146,
-0.0027451478,
0.0083137136,
-0.0355720185,
-0.0514035858,
0.0215324592,
-0.0271518789,
0.0009229191,
0.0421901718,
0.0276377965,
-0.0161479805,
-0.0556596108,
-0.022058228,
0.0464347005,
-0.0277405772,
0.0159547459,
-0.0538804308,
0.0662425831,
0.0967634097,
0.0242149159,
-0.034422867,
-0.0329525135,
-0.0216292869,
-0.0007048046,
0.0766522363,
0.0130286086,
-0.0334992297,
-0.0204050764,
-0.030335065,
-0.0297498927,
-0.0274309386,
-0.0029100524,
0.011008516,
0.0315782428,
-0.0271190498,
-0.0429016724,
0.0047971378,
-0.0444812253,
0.0549070798,
-0.0158105157,
-0.0271496028,
-0.0301912855,
0.0003843837,
0.0519546047,
0.0052725016,
0.001585571,
-0.0075292387,
0.0524367094,
-0.0113359289,
0.0259486716,
-0.0161574539,
-0.027627442,
-0.012012437,
0.0424717776,
0.0124781616,
-0.017300291,
0.0538211241,
-0.0469630994,
-0.037555974,
-0.0227245986,
-0.0026392101,
0.0273326803,
-0.01394476,
0.0252754465,
0.0035296082,
-0.0355280749,
-0.0326080583,
0.0367355309,
-0.0202175174,
-0.0049585612,
-0.0006671286,
0.0139178419,
-0.0188891739,
-0.071676746,
-0.0183099359,
0.0078402134,
-0.0163569767,
0.0585087724,
0.0174919274,
0.0452016555,
-0.0356851593,
-0.0295155868,
-0.0364032164,
0.0191298611,
-0.0213800129,
0.0173769332,
0.0025060775,
-0.0080648204,
-0.0283088479,
-0.0304443426,
-0.0413900129,
-0.0131651554,
0.0007148908,
0.0031569027,
0.0506874658,
0.011917267,
-0.0407605991,
-0.0742722228,
0.020792149,
0.0105617791,
-0.0486521833,
-0.0215512682,
0.0302084032,
-0.0493129268,
0.0097828172,
-0.0269361902,
0.0612396188,
-0.0310400352,
-0.0799391046,
0.0506189167,
0.0154917045,
-0.0022412171,
0.1149915233,
0.0074218381,
0.0346428566,
0.0574745871,
0.0468881056,
-0.0949816406,
0.0252488498,
-0.0373475216,
-0.0537216589,
-0.032957159,
0.0403263792,
-0.0143144866,
0.0612888038,
-0.00572418,
0.0460534282,
-0.0678671226,
0.0182480067,
0.0223698299,
-0.027169846,
-0.0049630702,
0.0021950537,
-0.066140458,
0.0107538076,
-0.0489551499,
-0.0781188384,
0.0648138076,
-0.0014078647,
0.0035109476,
-0.0095626581,
-0.023974292,
-0.0192643125,
0.019967787,
-0.0029016214,
0.0199963376,
-0.0517285876,
-0.0175091326,
-0.0865590051,
-0.0168792885,
0.0132960491,
-0.0556938238,
0.0406036153,
-0.0349903628,
0.0165579505,
-0.0070659271,
-0.0623202585,
-0.0665859729,
-0.007501591,
-0.029276466,
0.0156132216,
-0.0200739708,
-0.0389124118,
-0.001131097,
-0.0328404754,
0.040018186,
0.0135883018,
-0.0050658332,
0.0166500285,
-0.0398676917,
-0.0430409871,
0.0552828498,
0.0583235249,
-0.0284190793,
-0.0185414646,
-0.0012292573,
-0.0072265919,
0.0392641872,
-0.0134993047,
-0.0161624849,
0.0235496257,
0.0331282876,
-0.0381345674,
0.0198958348,
0.0538761839,
0.0476638302,
-0.04133204,
-0.0127437301,
0.0901814327,
0.0201870501,
-0.0329795256,
0.020041883,
-0.0139067443,
0.0243678968,
0.034162052,
0.0366629623,
-0.0469324179,
-0.0286924709,
-0.0101400558,
0.0643581524,
0.0191141218,
0.004933265,
0.0058265156,
-0.1232111081,
0.011717651,
0.0085173417,
-0.0702697039,
-0.0228512567,
-0.0024714461,
0.0340286121,
-0.0326179042,
0.0173270851,
0.0410398245,
0.0141630564,
-0.0130418045,
0.0226374492,
0.0234238803,
-0.0535460263,
0.0173652004,
-0.0691596493,
0.0846632347,
0.0997804105,
0.0192025751,
-0.0079848003,
-0.0478894785,
0.0097205015,
0.0098220315,
0.0005617931,
0.0117403874,
-0.0144919008,
-0.0301913489,
-0.0155817941,
0.0065383511,
0.0768046305,
-0.0229195431,
-0.0044504595,
-0.021696629,
0.0502893813,
-0.0246005077,
0.0409617536,
-0.0071041756,
-0.0212954897,
0.0242901333,
0.0681929588,
-0.0028503675,
-0.0766748115,
-0.0241731312,
-0.010312669,
-0.0630237237,
-0.0254853461,
-0.0220713969,
0.0127077522,
-0.0231005736,
0.01365312,
-0.0804647952,
-0.0447360426,
0.0045440886,
0.0124357222,
0.0242788084,
-0.0217695627,
-0.0109625049,
-0.0103390515,
-0.025984006,
0.0349407122,
-0.031906683,
0.0173493605,
-0.0927123576,
-0.0249246154,
0.03128374,
-0.0513625629,
0.0068595675,
-0.0071581714,
-0.0252849422,
-0.0739163086,
0.0101900939,
0.0899012983,
0.0178926215,
0.0717493519,
-0.001943464,
-0.0245026574,
0.0490746461,
0.0634371042,
-0.0395949446,
0.0288254563,
0.0250527672,
0.0502359532,
-0.0105889738,
0.0433787815,
-0.0784318745,
0.0018246386,
0.0239054654,
0.0392959341,
-0.0126739535,
-0.0375578068,
0.0468182676,
-0.0161302481,
0.0231298488,
-0.0363105275,
-0.0181717351,
-0.0231158119,
-0.0017948443,
0.0038490528,
-0.0327298678,
-0.0293725505,
-0.0464389808,
0.0077479267,
-0.0075226701,
0.0184530839,
-0.0212701596,
-0.0016137587,
0.0162081569,
-0.0215058345,
0.0172885582,
-0.0021393949,
0.0241949428,
-0.0039708633,
0.0433396362,
-0.0054909028,
0.0298919789,
0.0060826777,
0.0448919497,
0.0251681954,
0.0721300021,
0.0352385677,
0.0172024257,
-0.0181322657,
0.0346549712,
-0.0004903556,
-0.0544870533,
-0.0369402096,
0.0166718997,
0.0531692579,
-0.0000063124,
0.0191370361,
-0.0346859843,
0.0038381435,
-0.0071610152,
0.0273932144,
-0.0450698361,
0.0050975867,
0.0594656095,
0.0361073725,
-0.0069821812,
-0.0014133513,
0.0500017218,
-0.0034782672,
0.0523016304,
-0.0303989667,
0.0623354055,
-0.0300061218,
-0.021648759,
0.0462947451,
0.0024863456,
-0.0215166062,
-0.0449589193,
-0.0355108231,
-0.04835115,
-0.0224093385,
0.062369816,
-0.0358284377,
-0.0295951981,
0.0469692312,
0.0054487321,
-0.0459498912,
-0.008820123,
-0.0338179916,
-0.0554099791,
-0.0024957038,
-0.0304827467,
-0.0192111339,
-6.315677681e-33,
-0.0431448892,
-0.0273707788,
0.0544853508,
0.0128272725,
-0.0312381461,
-0.0249340571,
-0.0043133963,
0.0086955912,
-0.0309021324,
-0.0076927184,
-0.0191476569,
0.0023637705,
-0.0001721434,
-0.0198801626,
0.0332222506,
-0.0308164563,
-0.0014323142,
-0.0476792268,
-0.0628855228,
-0.0119816931,
0.0313871019,
0.0061835288,
0.0440807641,
-0.07369297,
0.0432224907,
0.0021366603,
-0.042236127,
0.0305090975,
-0.0366284437,
0.0869201869,
0.0083876643,
0.0240943842,
0.0006609456,
-0.0012662505,
0.0019397505,
0.0274287276,
-0.0355774648,
-0.0404439047,
0.0085837338,
0.0088302316,
-0.0402645022,
-0.019995911,
0.0655483305,
-0.0277415346,
-0.059125986,
0.048413191,
0.0180472266,
-0.0213341173,
-0.0027095433,
0.0210061092,
-0.0603502467,
-0.0146042537,
0.0069244439,
-0.071016103,
-0.0021115174,
0.0028860467,
-0.0115268677,
0.0061586583,
-0.0434375443,
0.0272414014,
0.0132091288,
0.0024150251,
0.097498484,
0.0267783217,
0.0092434576,
0.045031853,
0.0003822329,
-0.0000533781,
0.0259653348,
-0.0281154588,
0.026248036,
0.0654303581,
0.0478207618,
0.036741253,
0.0047289203,
0.0106342444,
-0.0245261267,
0.0440472141,
0.0347734466,
0.040449895,
0.0044666217,
0.0518950261,
-0.0941299424,
-0.0059736352,
-0.0293785781,
-0.0019370739,
-0.019249931,
-0.0446260385,
0.0505689383,
0.0223405864,
-0.0167058632,
-0.0479890332,
0.0187690817,
-0.0266425554,
-0.0026955029,
-0.0004696472,
-0.0327475592,
0.0331565663,
0.0043348335,
-0.0332258604,
-0.0662677512,
-0.0490368716,
-0.0092614656,
-0.0373220406,
0.0126965418,
0.0452908687,
0.019002717,
0.0415707603,
-0.039058309,
0.0171129517,
-0.01769685,
0.0070153852,
0.0254361555,
-0.0437614284,
0.0509965532,
-0.0166760236,
-0.0146955457,
0.0686085597,
-0.0031812966,
-0.0646912679,
-0.0203855708,
-0.025097575,
-0.0194395036,
0.0037924098,
-0.0320222005,
0.0209260006,
-0.023030173,
0.0410500057,
-0.034542691,
-0.0313984901,
-0.0009721558,
0.01206725,
2.8e-7,
0.012481818,
0.0289141927,
0.0219779685,
0.0387993865,
-0.0019392372,
0.0492410026,
-0.0424305014,
0.0329336934,
-0.0182585996,
-0.0129973385,
0.036952354,
0.0451600812,
0.0364336222,
-0.0304272268,
-0.0703318343,
0.0019960131,
-0.047793299,
0.0187164601,
-0.0387342498,
-0.0084883776,
0.0110784937,
0.0791281313,
0.0264976174,
-0.0064891339,
-0.0120982388,
0.0122257695,
0.0388014689,
-0.0484952405,
-0.0133873001,
0.0162766576,
-0.0156623404,
0.0181192309,
-0.0353605822,
-0.0050968993,
-0.0033464998,
0.045799233,
-0.0170151964,
0.0797233209,
-0.0189338047,
-0.024816405,
-0.0035179672,
-0.0001326054,
0.0236692429,
-0.0290859044,
0.0304435529,
-0.0558670647,
-0.0144009767,
-0.0124143669,
0.0057321768,
-0.0251554009,
-0.0143878711,
-0.0299042575,
0.0162938926,
-0.0163436811,
0.0104393093,
-0.0005819178,
-0.0370468572,
-0.0419481881,
-0.0252940301,
0.0225254651,
-0.0257419478,
-0.0225054547,
-0.023060929,
0.0582162961,
-0.0253138486,
-0.0668545142,
-0.0005758659,
2.23538572e-34,
-0.0292386636,
-0.0410285294,
0.0326174907,
0.0391181223,
-0.0071338513,
0.0329878815,
-0.0081138359,
0.0278623328,
0.071150966,
-0.0240294822,
-0.0139084905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05884v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05884v2 | A Meta-Learning Perspective on Transformers for Causal Language Modeling | 2023-10-09T17:27:36 | 2024-03-25T17:58:36 | Xinbo Wu, Lav R. Varshney | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The Transformer architecture has become prominent in developing large causal
language models. However, mechanisms to explain its capabilities are not well
understood. Focused on the training process, here we establish a meta-learning
view of the Transformer architecture when trained for the causal language
modeling task, by explicating an inner optimization process within the
Transformer. Further, within the inner optimization, we discover and
theoretically analyze a special characteristic of the norms of learned token
representations within Transformer-based causal language models. Our analysis
is supported by experiments in various settings. | [
0.028976934,
0.0270622987,
-0.0451560393,
0.0122614307,
-0.0226486661,
0.016315842,
0.0137511278,
-0.0121616274,
-0.0784968957,
-0.0480733253,
-0.0173213799,
0.0183000304,
-0.0064559951,
0.0055272412,
0.0285645965,
-0.0390587449,
0.0684547797,
-0.0195320621,
0.0128762228,
-0.01102609,
-0.0262825359,
-0.0467794724,
-0.0011008763,
0.0746645331,
-0.0260284971,
0.0289570745,
0.0379955843,
-0.0199504048,
-0.0253825746,
-0.007392019,
-0.0171477627,
0.0295104347,
0.0106700407,
0.0672867745,
0.0000017183,
-0.0421084017,
-0.0108766146,
-0.0048142141,
0.0142462077,
-0.0593742356,
0.0204482712,
-0.0249792933,
-0.0105547318,
0.0168729387,
-0.0179830715,
-0.0736429617,
0.0818371251,
0.0721415728,
0.0176878721,
0.0895873755,
-0.0299521424,
-0.0883823857,
0.0281307008,
-0.0256229434,
-0.0016634698,
0.0111720329,
0.0370902158,
-0.0275998693,
-0.0359138772,
-0.0085707307,
-0.0576084256,
0.0011223507,
0.0177646987,
0.0099872975,
0.0183847919,
0.0170475524,
-0.0056064734,
-0.0166313276,
0.0066683022,
0.0195213687,
0.0063267662,
-0.038870059,
-0.00947922,
0.0276799053,
0.0290934872,
0.078013204,
-0.0298910271,
0.0208055321,
0.0129604125,
0.0115146497,
0.0044863294,
0.0147310961,
0.036165081,
-0.0261948444,
-0.0773603395,
0.0832189023,
0.0337204784,
-0.0352486558,
-0.0449917726,
-0.0083847875,
-0.0020394498,
-0.0147759737,
-0.0032954039,
0.0184157584,
-0.0307541639,
0.0326990746,
-0.0012518666,
-0.0301615279,
-0.005873742,
-0.0144291688,
0.0281361304,
0.0383713581,
0.0014566857,
0.0193599034,
-0.0549678914,
0.0604037382,
-0.0111875776,
0.079110384,
-0.0342713706,
0.0167454872,
-0.0605934374,
-0.0511537753,
-0.0603200421,
0.0379941352,
0.0051749307,
0.0029737242,
-0.0584635772,
0.0255353749,
0.0169211123,
-0.0127510754,
0.0273285229,
-0.0413268134,
-0.0319757499,
-0.0174257383,
-0.0216341168,
0.028638538,
-0.0334855467,
0.0535505675,
-0.0186222866,
-0.0112562822,
-0.012839241,
0.0037127845,
-0.0193180609,
-0.0523958094,
-0.0138613619,
0.1141933426,
0.0121830823,
-0.0595415495,
-0.0168896802,
0.0189909004,
-0.0217697918,
-0.0247622319,
0.0273993146,
-0.0460042991,
-0.0152523071,
0.0253285039,
0.0092508113,
-0.0101089487,
-0.0001399623,
-0.0276167002,
-0.0266618617,
0.0532402024,
0.0174998045,
0.000425082,
-0.0363143645,
-0.0329775661,
-0.014174412,
0.0560063235,
0.0489941947,
0.0133324359,
-0.0050381864,
-0.0178867653,
0.0130067179,
0.017598724,
0.0339457355,
-0.0194045715,
-0.0228565559,
-0.0464105159,
0.0551725812,
-0.0055586062,
-0.0121053346,
0.0435419083,
-0.0354356766,
0.009992471,
0.033732295,
0.0292196553,
0.0218880866,
0.0086834067,
0.0606740527,
-0.065137051,
-0.01460528,
0.0556143038,
-0.0654758066,
0.0116178133,
-0.0048268787,
-0.0146859949,
-0.0425021201,
0.0158875491,
-0.032909926,
-0.0403752699,
-0.0145546049,
-0.0150504075,
-0.0377399065,
-0.0583541989,
0.0868511647,
0.0487452634,
-0.0288400371,
0.0500178486,
0.0242114924,
-0.0370702855,
0.0273736417,
-0.0574215949,
-0.0088200709,
0.0246857088,
0.0479079783,
-0.0561609715,
0.002184544,
-0.0181393102,
-0.0011357323,
0.0371546373,
0.0003192443,
-0.0087740514,
-0.0082541453,
-0.0282806009,
0.0033450318,
0.0150060207,
0.0407982692,
0.0084631564,
-0.0380866416,
-0.0431015901,
-0.0021706065,
-0.0549873821,
-0.0152148195,
0.0653132573,
-0.0288019199,
-0.014359979,
-0.0123728411,
0.039054729,
0.017850725,
-0.0159673262,
-0.027828576,
0.0330951922,
0.0198947769,
-0.0634385422,
-0.0474709682,
0.0954585597,
-0.0528153516,
-0.0163920708,
0.0412848592,
-0.0844237879,
0.0156468004,
0.0333207697,
-0.0022005208,
-0.0712454468,
0.0621715002,
-0.0482789949,
0.0958058387,
-0.0148281371,
0.0379766896,
-0.0168562178,
0.0086991359,
-0.0507543422,
0.0523708761,
-0.0141800437,
0.023523448,
-0.0012466387,
-0.0579147898,
0.0373182669,
0.012538854,
-0.0160281565,
0.0057191127,
-0.0306878444,
-0.0025005601,
0.0497548282,
-0.044175934,
0.0122454828,
-0.0889802873,
-0.0294960886,
-0.0366251804,
-0.0259662159,
-0.0000687824,
0.0019026925,
0.0110076182,
0.0217286777,
0.0029205924,
-0.0037852773,
-0.0001058911,
-0.0167001169,
0.0172263123,
0.0310221277,
-0.0026794984,
-0.0319101438,
-0.0366045088,
-0.0363823175,
-0.0447234623,
0.0695659369,
0.0199393872,
0.0090319505,
-0.0265805312,
-0.0554382093,
0.0259799194,
0.0219127275,
-0.0393323675,
-0.0537246913,
0.012143435,
-0.0315537117,
0.0719040707,
0.0374831483,
0.0250339974,
0.0144523336,
0.0402083732,
0.0211778879,
-0.0348800756,
-0.0108860945,
-0.0589512922,
0.0000611007,
-0.0721433908,
-0.0262932219,
0.0010882133,
0.1012711897,
-0.0040224525,
-0.0292969923,
-0.0704284012,
0.0127935009,
-0.0110007944,
-0.0401710644,
0.0105092525,
-0.0078593269,
-0.0350945182,
0.0142172221,
-0.0407410897,
-0.0560107864,
0.0514921844,
-0.0061507914,
0.0056520049,
-0.0085490979,
0.0384471044,
-0.0553127043,
0.030360518,
0.0456495546,
0.0127803227,
0.0195452627,
-0.05650758,
-0.0606777817,
-0.0179969352,
0.0549681969,
0.0147237945,
0.0288002733,
-0.0081394315,
0.0392277688,
-0.0041806395,
-0.0437935926,
-0.0320091657,
-0.0296607353,
0.0008353177,
0.0190882348,
0.0265684202,
-0.008117809,
-0.0785249844,
0.0248079319,
-0.000615028,
0.0282927249,
-0.0133760711,
-0.008783591,
-0.036646992,
-0.0206958093,
0.0111841876,
-0.0326319449,
0.0344340466,
-0.0192057826,
0.0123467417,
-0.0084497202,
0.0240310673,
0.0068496247,
-0.0368880332,
0.0012221662,
0.0307165217,
-0.0326035284,
-0.0035636951,
-0.0155133326,
0.0199849512,
-0.0025736534,
0.0017293404,
0.101559706,
0.0397469848,
-0.0320862792,
0.0299792439,
-0.0118839638,
0.0026964194,
0.0594667569,
0.002627973,
-0.0472634733,
-0.0145508191,
0.0233373344,
-0.0231941156,
-0.0140991258,
-0.0290334113,
0.0218558684,
-0.0571518578,
-0.0022640161,
-0.0173841696,
-0.0246839095,
-0.009759672,
-0.0117952107,
-0.013644103,
-0.0517645516,
0.0177694056,
-0.0141406283,
-0.0405469984,
-0.0009299917,
0.0377026647,
0.0330618098,
-0.027505273,
-0.0503483601,
-0.0262998678,
0.0566894934,
0.0588258915,
0.001766089,
-0.0415446907,
-0.0321879573,
0.0580890626,
0.0506084487,
0.0211664326,
-0.0066906316,
0.0382063799,
-0.0008061136,
-0.0250552539,
0.003074527,
-0.000848168,
-0.0170290191,
-0.0405725017,
-0.003189293,
0.0787750855,
0.019860737,
-0.0195811689,
-0.0010925246,
-0.021814676,
-0.0170359127,
0.0524419993,
0.02097564,
-0.0205777921,
-0.0312463399,
-0.0112137245,
-0.0018802721,
-0.0099291774,
-0.0329375453,
-0.0055399849,
0.0451959148,
-0.0556999184,
-0.0559904203,
0.0077961218,
0.0226882976,
0.0509046726,
0.0313614868,
0.0010526149,
-0.0083534112,
-0.0176186487,
-0.0235877689,
0.0009499275,
-0.0393230394,
0.0252615139,
-0.0890727416,
0.0004333527,
0.0345398784,
-0.0366095118,
-0.0232440364,
-0.0495782942,
-0.035970401,
-0.0559683144,
0.0195743963,
0.0957424045,
0.0259609148,
0.0093339672,
-0.0076821065,
-0.0563409999,
0.0288355984,
0.0541142821,
-0.0364065766,
0.0004350975,
0.0908371285,
-0.0473875627,
0.0031727748,
0.0434657745,
-0.0205409378,
0.0441240706,
0.0350701511,
0.0265483968,
0.0028403215,
0.0701720864,
0.057602644,
-0.0121779926,
0.0713956803,
-0.0054861838,
0.0233211815,
-0.0328161791,
0.0245136805,
-0.0432033762,
-0.0013812784,
-0.0275019612,
0.0235658586,
0.0385998301,
0.0412702411,
-0.0033673141,
-0.0181309544,
-0.0465772562,
0.0124657666,
0.0212610867,
0.0678325742,
0.0042815553,
0.0377145372,
0.0143632982,
0.03318334,
0.0304998122,
0.0010611735,
0.0414950587,
0.0074618566,
-0.0079540089,
0.022404002,
0.0401814729,
0.0345367678,
-0.0771934018,
-0.0071682241,
-0.0970276967,
0.0045361761,
0.0279054269,
-0.0131993592,
0.0345546603,
-0.0022026957,
0.0170619357,
-0.0181373898,
-0.0058849109,
0.0021768936,
0.0253658816,
0.0229962766,
0.0211758297,
0.0175440442,
0.0055140858,
-0.013273336,
-0.0262413677,
0.0910932198,
-0.0380328298,
0.0491625331,
-0.0360212587,
0.0065896604,
-0.0370443538,
-0.0458210707,
-0.0040090247,
0.0060583749,
-0.0153863998,
0.0131354928,
-0.1074577123,
-0.0379215851,
0.0022530258,
0.0077544078,
0.0504638888,
-0.027605176,
0.0012918587,
0.0319143869,
0.002684118,
-0.0075881835,
-0.028244365,
-0.0108107366,
0.0277606752,
0.0089745885,
0.0039226292,
-5.804841264e-33,
-0.0459858812,
0.0010465173,
0.0318125449,
-0.0010709077,
0.0085534351,
-0.0143185407,
-0.0198444687,
0.0137097854,
-0.0225799587,
0.0168882739,
-0.0081220893,
-0.0025624963,
0.019618189,
0.0309773032,
0.0207192618,
-0.0092233475,
0.0457151644,
0.0037026238,
-0.0308909956,
-0.0184807684,
0.0425932258,
0.0257635061,
0.0306307245,
-0.011574938,
-0.0119467201,
0.0316414647,
-0.0104485685,
0.0475311838,
-0.0149811311,
0.068230696,
0.0012347302,
0.0158278532,
0.0330521874,
-0.0550557524,
-0.0203089919,
0.0049214652,
-0.0712810084,
-0.048852779,
0.0600928068,
0.0097605987,
-0.0191010386,
-0.0459677689,
0.0469139926,
-0.0217285436,
-0.0274967067,
-0.0041668145,
0.0341393799,
0.000281643,
-0.0416995957,
-0.003355843,
-0.1030130163,
0.0069532255,
-0.0135827912,
0.0271787308,
0.0232696198,
0.0232339241,
0.0057989266,
0.0208549276,
0.0303509887,
0.0474957749,
-0.0224586837,
0.0552648567,
-0.0098786484,
0.0807757527,
0.0047880909,
0.0504681468,
0.0569419898,
0.0334839188,
-0.0098030046,
-0.0056813895,
0.0505317785,
0.0230319742,
0.0378038026,
0.0480922535,
0.0154474359,
-0.0512745641,
-0.0251436699,
-0.0220467392,
0.0313652195,
0.0388719104,
0.0280589499,
-0.0150861433,
0.0024595119,
-0.0256394539,
-0.087131314,
-0.0537239797,
-0.0373895466,
0.0043231412,
-0.0058333036,
0.0365776904,
-0.0106431637,
-0.0405575335,
0.0326237567,
-0.0584855005,
0.0074468581,
0.031669952,
-0.0269845705,
0.0306605641,
-0.0107832346,
0.001908358,
-0.0656357408,
-0.0420335121,
0.0223311204,
0.0388794504,
0.0138829229,
0.0108955503,
0.091795519,
0.007207579,
-0.0565098152,
-0.0015469523,
-0.035180293,
-0.0316639543,
0.0182343684,
-0.0377419107,
0.0297772065,
0.0538830124,
-0.0172522422,
-0.0093552275,
0.0156501681,
-0.002499545,
-0.000491237,
0.0228569992,
0.0035539388,
0.0491762534,
-0.0335300714,
-0.0115291011,
-0.0535985939,
0.0495824777,
0.0628154352,
-0.079705134,
-0.0276690871,
-0.0161970183,
2.539e-7,
0.0666732267,
0.0566872098,
0.0500922017,
-0.0048071295,
0.0322853625,
0.0017301729,
-0.0005810828,
0.0254506804,
0.0354647785,
0.041001536,
0.0357362032,
-0.0017427424,
0.0059971143,
-0.0144740166,
-0.063057445,
0.0191131923,
-0.0551393293,
0.0072038849,
-0.003784965,
0.035775505,
0.035388343,
0.0957528055,
0.0151941692,
-0.0008430639,
-0.0391588882,
0.0007764735,
0.0728136003,
-0.047885906,
0.0392571278,
0.0130133312,
-0.0537235737,
-0.0147373118,
0.0053081946,
0.0226934794,
0.0018486936,
0.0413882397,
-0.0232648347,
0.0385016054,
-0.0186783187,
-0.0012055712,
0.0068831751,
-0.0153094335,
-0.013036428,
0.0122023467,
0.0394288599,
-0.0850829408,
-0.0410315171,
0.0090335282,
-0.0419104844,
0.0654497817,
-0.020718148,
-0.0101607637,
-0.0303758141,
0.0507115498,
0.011346139,
0.0368956216,
0.0259766988,
-0.0682219341,
-0.0244976114,
-0.0205365065,
-0.015145422,
-0.0581142753,
0.0023903924,
-0.0184799358,
0.0228412058,
-0.0314219818,
0.0010129657,
2.317664814e-34,
0.0440074615,
-0.0055753118,
0.0322752669,
-0.0218141992,
0.0044832393,
-0.0607276708,
-0.028595984,
0.0435176454,
0.0381917134,
-0.0900681764,
-0.0128563829
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.