id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08280v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08280v1 | Optimizing Odia Braille Literacy: The Influence of Speed on Error Reduction and Enhanced Comprehension | 2023-10-12T12:36:46 | 2023-10-12T12:36:46 | Monnie Parida, Manjira Sinha, Anupam Basu, Pabitra Mitra | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study aims to conduct an extensive detailed analysis of the Odia Braille
reading comprehension among students with visual disability. Specifically, the
study explores their reading speed and hand or finger movements. The study also
aims to investigate any comprehension difficulties and reading errors they may
encounter. Six students from the 9th and 10th grades, aged between 14 and 16,
participated in the study. We observed participants hand movements to
understand how reading errors were connected to hand movement and identify the
students reading difficulties. We also evaluated the participants Odia Braille
reading skills, including their reading speed (in words per minute), errors,
and comprehension. The average speed of Odia Braille reader is 17.64wpm.
According to the study, there was a noticeable correlation between reading
speed and reading errors. As reading speed decreased, the number of reading
errors tended to increase. Moreover, the study established a link between
reduced Braille reading errors and improved reading comprehension. In contrast,
the study found that better comprehension was associated with increased reading
speed. The researchers concluded with some interesting findings about preferred
Braille reading patterns. These findings have important theoretical,
developmental, and methodological implications for instruction. | [
-0.0013621827,
-0.0627823099,
-0.0280843414,
0.0252229031,
-0.0288483463,
0.043769788,
0.0568936281,
-0.0129260402,
0.029712528,
0.0353806466,
0.0185567997,
-0.0621609837,
0.0705495179,
-0.0027339035,
-0.0514029078,
-0.043418102,
-0.0211788081,
-0.0165924374,
-0.0019655833,
0.0074632755,
0.0227472633,
-0.0044504381,
-0.0745060742,
-0.0026472877,
0.0516181402,
-0.0429904647,
0.0314575136,
-0.0171919391,
-0.0056425007,
-0.0315967612,
-0.0048812898,
0.0171142798,
-0.0284562856,
0.007467404,
0.0000021594,
-0.0227321051,
0.0286335908,
-0.0173904076,
0.0305653792,
0.0531616546,
0.016042538,
-0.0577943325,
-0.0006000999,
0.0299262088,
0.0238723215,
-0.037033271,
0.0505360216,
0.0346155837,
-0.0874134377,
0.0042774682,
0.0086826524,
0.017814517,
0.0307416208,
0.0110693853,
0.0596664622,
0.0199433155,
-0.0225986391,
0.0071568573,
0.0372633487,
0.0175792389,
-0.0661972314,
0.0708886236,
-0.0121981166,
-0.0200112257,
0.0111788474,
0.0114639467,
0.1152344719,
-0.0314288959,
0.0022728292,
0.0265847538,
0.0875366852,
-0.0140210064,
-0.0198097844,
0.0154744536,
-0.029814247,
0.0402133241,
-0.061935585,
0.039312195,
-0.036059536,
-0.0130351763,
-0.0311915074,
-0.0323311836,
-0.0075674481,
0.0082864547,
0.0638946667,
-0.0132935299,
-0.0028740917,
-0.0336311497,
-0.0533274896,
-0.0180266351,
0.0717412233,
0.0274436455,
-0.0254246388,
0.0354438052,
0.0249738526,
0.0299970172,
-0.0157353636,
-0.0448655412,
0.0311418641,
-0.0113301976,
0.0744725168,
0.071980767,
-0.0272764359,
-0.0098325172,
-0.0079425341,
0.0435754955,
-0.008750489,
0.0557432659,
-0.0115969591,
0.0595653579,
0.036253497,
-0.0402929708,
0.0146773318,
-0.0281741302,
-0.0265733171,
-0.0173434019,
-0.0424796604,
-0.0155872935,
0.0631757751,
-0.0173874386,
-0.0443793982,
0.0163311046,
0.0155300545,
-0.0281513408,
0.0027625631,
0.0343771763,
-0.0502291769,
0.0452452153,
-0.0874234885,
0.0282651968,
0.024274366,
-0.0086676087,
-0.0121858744,
-0.0286955405,
-0.0155269057,
0.0082066227,
-0.0225329492,
-0.0228994992,
-0.0127644399,
0.0170222037,
0.0088684158,
0.0012016455,
-0.0549331941,
0.0015155772,
-0.0137786716,
0.0596516989,
0.0432332344,
-0.0201019086,
-0.0229718089,
0.0174116734,
0.0364303142,
0.0131694069,
-0.0186980404,
0.0341477804,
0.079761073,
0.0448157042,
0.0128090698,
0.0302489083,
0.0125887366,
-0.0267999973,
-0.018024236,
-0.0405608639,
-0.0334598497,
0.0148659833,
-0.0187144913,
-0.0041591851,
0.0337150134,
-0.0412715152,
0.0014539033,
0.0021885931,
0.0292920414,
0.0123218885,
-0.0119264694,
0.0188538507,
0.0402141586,
0.0532119609,
0.0576829351,
0.0016179461,
-0.0471200868,
0.0032917121,
0.0602229498,
-0.0088079767,
0.0424418189,
-0.0055905902,
0.0273874924,
-0.010242532,
-0.0303641111,
0.0157668944,
0.0148123307,
-0.013224192,
-0.0175605267,
0.0712552518,
0.000797689,
-0.041127339,
0.0204942264,
0.0073928731,
-0.0068242303,
-0.0615285002,
0.0215773135,
-0.0106214313,
0.0027806156,
0.0230719801,
0.0080360714,
0.0194365438,
0.0154381795,
0.0312421583,
0.0295722615,
0.0768548772,
-0.0171230827,
0.0257105362,
-0.0679737255,
0.0151209524,
0.0002494624,
-0.016236078,
0.0298807528,
0.0699498877,
-0.0082757063,
0.0208648425,
-0.0447270013,
0.0952114835,
0.0101408856,
0.0065861582,
-0.0414439626,
0.0240561441,
-0.0425974913,
-0.0158338249,
0.0044628582,
-0.0258042291,
0.0114762085,
-0.0231838059,
-0.0127799911,
-0.026335245,
-0.040880844,
0.0306441411,
0.0419141054,
0.0384321213,
-0.0027583193,
0.0257983953,
0.0240263995,
-0.0567308515,
0.0391666964,
-0.010061847,
0.0740205422,
-0.0099964589,
0.0248999316,
-0.0171130579,
-0.0034298953,
0.0201772638,
0.032838963,
-0.0412893705,
-0.0384983383,
-0.030632792,
0.0032937801,
-0.0126583241,
-0.011144693,
-0.0124034137,
-0.0055224616,
0.0015413209,
-0.0106960693,
-0.0128207114,
0.0372225679,
-0.0240542702,
0.0434822105,
-0.0159280077,
0.0197518636,
-0.0306869466,
-0.0080383578,
-0.0702398196,
-0.026739331,
0.0253524929,
-0.0296489503,
0.0012295777,
-0.0091132913,
-0.0027784761,
-0.0083467998,
-0.0001296447,
0.0431332774,
0.0069553726,
-0.0334074758,
-0.0328946263,
0.0006168511,
-0.0028884101,
-0.0285718758,
0.0109523935,
-0.0262767505,
-0.0076546608,
0.0821660459,
-0.012226372,
-0.0336779393,
-0.0306679346,
0.0376879573,
-0.0067917784,
-0.0021668789,
-0.0236795731,
0.041928295,
0.0256228,
0.0362047888,
-0.0171350744,
0.0077227722,
0.0222382285,
0.03190865,
-0.0273930598,
0.0024483269,
-0.0020442337,
0.0260314401,
0.0937652141,
-0.0152946655,
-0.0697015673,
-0.0111585101,
-0.013702374,
0.0204612855,
-0.0013510482,
-0.0334095396,
-0.0088774329,
-0.0369204432,
-0.0159993693,
-0.0630623922,
-0.0254142433,
-0.0070192735,
0.0290075839,
-0.0238306001,
-0.0140978675,
-0.0033708191,
-0.0199673492,
-0.0089467522,
-0.0395950563,
0.0488990396,
0.0005213442,
0.0428611189,
-0.0309786368,
0.0022226477,
-0.0967196673,
-0.0462887362,
-0.0362349339,
0.0354221612,
0.0438526273,
0.0273231752,
0.0355969258,
-0.0553209335,
0.0112528745,
-0.0027106074,
0.0055065462,
-0.0127354497,
0.0498091429,
0.0521705821,
-0.0941887498,
0.0379665606,
-0.0438888147,
-0.045741614,
-0.0240515657,
0.0455475301,
0.048111815,
-0.0114322826,
0.0156819485,
0.0091348961,
-0.0130079016,
0.001175959,
-0.0609769784,
-0.0010359507,
-0.0479681455,
0.014714431,
0.0292797592,
-0.0105990255,
-0.0129621709,
0.0221562944,
-0.0067928545,
0.0317336023,
0.026179418,
-0.0128074102,
-0.0514865965,
0.0413221866,
-0.0014614634,
0.0150434822,
0.0001072271,
0.0230095796,
-0.0245946348,
-0.0144120501,
-0.0413373522,
-0.0512005128,
-0.0904208869,
-0.0138552887,
-0.0546909608,
0.0325361565,
-0.0226147473,
0.0619094446,
0.0439834632,
0.0049442723,
-0.006896208,
-0.0268700626,
-0.0576107688,
0.0229359847,
0.0314349197,
-0.0506086275,
0.0314632766,
-0.0268925652,
0.0635768846,
0.0514321625,
0.0520960838,
0.0037019376,
0.0157123506,
0.0217243358,
0.0008789278,
0.0178316627,
-0.0153438365,
0.0548615456,
0.0029369199,
-0.0322798677,
-0.0358680859,
-0.0034574152,
0.0277958121,
-0.0177015793,
-0.0362401381,
-0.0267832484,
-0.0330497921,
0.0378553607,
0.019507369,
-0.0370101631,
-0.0356836319,
0.0317357443,
0.0151808299,
-0.0319461115,
0.0616039634,
-0.0608115532,
0.0071436074,
-0.0208046939,
-0.0342637785,
-0.0119310189,
-0.0366548635,
-0.0496541671,
-0.0282008536,
-0.0159023907,
-0.0014883979,
-0.023054257,
-0.0158097651,
-0.06729763,
-0.0218210202,
0.0027602969,
0.0246382896,
-0.0679204464,
-0.0398932174,
-0.0626740381,
0.002895165,
0.0549993329,
0.0694081932,
0.0687309876,
0.0369815193,
0.0227951109,
-0.0132375797,
-0.009598786,
0.0402158089,
-0.0078470595,
-0.0667749122,
-0.0181866437,
-0.0537185743,
-0.0568331704,
-0.0013390215,
-0.0535442494,
-0.0065059559,
-0.0245130919,
0.0513724796,
0.0177753698,
0.0168476459,
-0.0684802458,
0.0116875796,
-0.0927291662,
0.0119783739,
-0.0533571281,
0.0183373578,
0.0292241033,
-0.0765508711,
-0.0539358668,
0.0400989056,
-0.0329107381,
0.0747621357,
0.0171832368,
-0.0204146039,
-0.0302226543,
-0.0545665957,
0.0219163969,
-0.0234179031,
0.017769441,
0.009290915,
0.020074483,
-0.0391525254,
-0.0787884742,
-0.035243459,
-0.0371153168,
0.0124273598,
0.0127329184,
-0.0120867612,
0.0291518737,
-0.0160699561,
-0.037965484,
-0.0701830611,
-0.0277866069,
-0.073120676,
-0.0113398759,
0.1329678893,
-0.0156295244,
0.0715407282,
-0.0062469635,
0.0210042838,
0.0180241093,
0.0104592377,
-0.0521786958,
0.0619677193,
0.0643256456,
0.024399424,
0.0226788092,
0.0174973831,
0.0505918339,
-0.0281891264,
0.0663051531,
-0.0057603647,
-0.0261864606,
0.0135962497,
-0.0702856258,
0.0113878613,
0.0106785791,
-0.0282397307,
0.0437218212,
-0.0341817141,
-0.0035538503,
-0.0164727494,
0.0188307334,
0.0439679772,
-0.0160349589,
0.046822764,
-0.0561395846,
0.0140580554,
-0.0231809225,
-0.0543260649,
0.02143915,
-0.007565516,
-0.0323887467,
-0.0006185245,
0.0530574173,
0.0319349766,
0.0127495071,
0.0201476514,
-0.0182393156,
0.0183912925,
0.0318474285,
-0.0082017621,
0.0062811547,
0.0105648991,
-0.062139824,
-0.0122142471,
0.006400398,
0.0143084452,
-0.0251232665,
-0.0111878617,
-0.0500856303,
-0.0378631204,
0.0305411704,
-5.784824432e-33,
0.0188815538,
-0.0910222605,
0.0726071596,
-0.0211676583,
-0.0030743997,
0.0301083103,
-0.0089608356,
0.0573522113,
-0.0147009362,
0.003748998,
0.0333958901,
-0.0016293314,
-0.0039919619,
0.0285985153,
0.0085654482,
0.0354793333,
-0.0303978119,
0.0494639091,
-0.0470237024,
-0.047252778,
0.0389030203,
-0.0236433204,
0.0508263484,
-0.0061023468,
0.0713003203,
-0.0283021033,
-0.0145485699,
-0.081390284,
0.0100973705,
-0.0214093737,
-0.0449593551,
-0.0075196954,
0.0189989675,
0.074888438,
0.0297941584,
0.081002444,
-0.0192445815,
-0.0046733748,
0.0289618261,
0.0855939835,
-0.0266020689,
0.0044594011,
0.0219769049,
0.0322577693,
-0.0157162249,
-0.0402428843,
0.0262877271,
-0.0197936445,
0.0081888288,
0.0280634556,
-0.0614096113,
0.0085500879,
-0.0301625393,
-0.0128746303,
0.0368467979,
0.034207698,
0.0102916472,
-0.0663638487,
-0.0656915829,
0.0239491705,
0.0376795568,
0.0220444184,
-0.0093227243,
-0.0141552938,
0.0021394729,
-0.0071643069,
0.0184805915,
-0.093345657,
0.0072366646,
-0.020163618,
0.0967860669,
-0.0824779719,
0.016896056,
0.0167674534,
0.0593079291,
-0.0406003073,
-0.0275376402,
0.0414207131,
0.0325735249,
0.0451962389,
-0.0013610038,
-0.0340427756,
-0.0783980042,
0.0168576017,
-0.0046543363,
0.0498700775,
-0.0017594517,
-0.0015352719,
0.0268378593,
-0.0578405149,
0.0055402755,
-0.0257530082,
0.0007955274,
0.0229749233,
-0.0370840654,
-0.0085010305,
-0.0448340848,
0.0498845316,
0.0065740803,
-0.0222254321,
-0.0306322481,
-0.0012268224,
-0.013806751,
0.036073707,
-0.0011642376,
0.0168340299,
-0.0473249592,
-0.0448542722,
-0.032071691,
0.0185272954,
0.0149235092,
-0.0209437869,
0.043566186,
0.0150125036,
-0.0062429742,
-0.0297987554,
-0.0201250874,
0.0078556761,
0.0076372456,
-0.0393546037,
-0.0309345666,
-0.0408161096,
-0.0179341603,
-0.0096463785,
-0.0499267541,
-0.0157295745,
0.0242639109,
0.0217105057,
-0.0259747449,
-0.0055070124,
0.0399335213,
0.0221067723,
2.805e-7,
0.0355287492,
0.0719208643,
0.029241452,
0.0492367521,
-0.0141010284,
-0.0179109294,
-0.0075269449,
0.0043306495,
0.0112470249,
0.0707504302,
0.0389246307,
0.0140561489,
-0.0044733863,
-0.017233381,
0.0169918276,
-0.0458338261,
0.0257347338,
0.0589629263,
0.0010426757,
0.0048931586,
-0.0382144712,
-0.0491010807,
-0.0529943258,
-0.0241704155,
0.005850147,
-0.0212293454,
0.0155422818,
0.0030838754,
0.0766491666,
-0.0202117711,
0.0073611434,
-0.0008891386,
0.0037972508,
-0.0216033161,
0.0046390095,
-0.0415589958,
-0.0011118843,
-0.0194239933,
-0.0446796305,
0.0677687004,
0.040533565,
0.0569408648,
-0.0328483619,
-0.0455956459,
0.0257111285,
0.0507816486,
-0.0000596736,
0.0959810093,
0.0215348117,
0.0341150537,
0.0078871818,
0.0079079941,
-0.0146630919,
0.0056752418,
0.0060567386,
-0.0673421323,
0.00227687,
-0.0059043388,
0.0351838991,
-0.0204980001,
0.0283445884,
-0.0056029921,
-0.0656716153,
0.0018070431,
-0.0383526161,
-0.0629883856,
0.0331106037,
1.612795813e-34,
0.0064163492,
-0.0588479228,
0.0231699571,
-0.0260387324,
-0.048561845,
-0.0349442624,
0.0280659609,
0.0105821826,
0.0439282656,
-0.0031993866,
0.0102897827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08279v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08279v3 | Enhancing Text-based Knowledge Graph Completion with Zero-Shot Large Language Models: A Focus on Semantic Enhancement | 2023-10-12T12:31:23 | 2024-06-27T04:55:28 | Rui Yang, Jiahao Zhu, Jianping Man, Li Fang, Yi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The design and development of text-based knowledge graph completion (KGC)
methods leveraging textual entity descriptions are at the forefront of
research. These methods involve advanced optimization techniques such as soft
prompts and contrastive learning to enhance KGC models. The effectiveness of
text-based methods largely hinges on the quality and richness of the training
data. Large language models (LLMs) can utilize straightforward prompts to alter
text data, thereby enabling data augmentation for KGC. Nevertheless, LLMs
typically demand substantial computational resources. To address these issues,
we introduce a framework termed constrained prompts for KGC (CP-KGC). This
CP-KGC framework designs prompts that adapt to different datasets to enhance
semantic richness. Additionally, CP-KGC employs a context constraint strategy
to effectively identify polysemous entities within KGC datasets. Through
extensive experimentation, we have verified the effectiveness of this
framework. Even after quantization, the LLM (Qwen-7B-Chat-int4) still enhances
the performance of text-based KGC methods \footnote{Code and datasets are
available at
\href{https://github.com/sjlmg/CP-KGC}{https://github.com/sjlmg/CP-KGC}}. This
study extends the performance limits of existing models and promotes further
integration of KGC with LLMs. | [
0.051448442,
0.0275643487,
0.0006272386,
0.0611886308,
-0.0074680522,
-0.0036488078,
-0.0176007897,
0.0007570801,
0.0628435537,
-0.0526369959,
0.0208370015,
0.0072856452,
0.004585485,
-0.0035107031,
0.0300331041,
-0.0361960493,
0.0365614258,
0.0032720552,
-0.0210814252,
-0.0306923073,
-0.016274387,
0.0293245353,
0.0095996298,
-0.0231539868,
0.0164857358,
0.0068190414,
0.0065482971,
0.0079512037,
0.0086273514,
-0.0208701249,
-0.0223585684,
0.054155875,
-0.0014887332,
0.0031138288,
0.0000024093,
-0.0616011955,
-0.0232131332,
0.000334496,
-0.0468391962,
-0.0027396367,
0.0230695773,
-0.0476316623,
0.0411275066,
-0.0345656425,
-0.001111991,
-0.0230242424,
0.0392862856,
0.040689826,
0.009754234,
0.0630814433,
-0.0155877611,
-0.0165698491,
0.0170862135,
-0.0287525617,
0.0183376949,
-0.0328945518,
0.0561235808,
0.0016322249,
0.0207756981,
0.0455658287,
-0.0339571945,
0.0315513015,
-0.0049245562,
0.0149171893,
0.0640582964,
0.0492507294,
-0.042422384,
0.0038199276,
0.0473225936,
0.1095906422,
0.0382029936,
0.0090740528,
0.0212035086,
-0.012937421,
-0.0091101462,
0.0202750228,
-0.0197151564,
-0.0241800677,
-0.0213338174,
0.0057460447,
-0.0321221948,
-0.0220446009,
0.0582344048,
0.0171934832,
-0.0282312781,
0.037722148,
0.0196206011,
-0.0255028903,
0.0001612677,
0.006886716,
-0.0610121824,
-0.0598058738,
-0.0110404165,
0.0276437178,
-0.0491070487,
0.0318066999,
-0.0210857634,
-0.0105592385,
0.0169984456,
0.0043782825,
-0.0327509418,
0.0280045439,
-0.0072419858,
0.0679731891,
-0.0503885224,
0.0185040068,
0.0144603951,
-0.0348432921,
-0.0557432696,
-0.0349694081,
-0.0532447807,
0.0027758747,
-0.0425223522,
0.0291617513,
-0.0298119467,
-0.0143930027,
-0.0385009982,
0.0415618196,
-0.001870518,
0.0622622222,
0.0184607841,
-0.0005991809,
-0.0203248579,
-0.0050559533,
-0.0448668785,
0.0120922495,
-0.0364739746,
0.0113154668,
-0.0285664946,
0.002561783,
-0.0039473842,
-0.0072038197,
0.0406686403,
-0.0733757615,
0.0115703298,
0.0233157072,
0.0158219784,
-0.0667622983,
-0.0356422029,
-0.0447680876,
-0.0456788875,
-0.0404100865,
-0.0462687649,
-0.071682632,
0.0468120575,
0.0152895199,
0.0027834806,
-0.0354379304,
0.0306919646,
-0.0071625267,
-0.064298071,
0.0942118987,
-0.0891094133,
-0.0024375678,
-0.01583267,
0.0000256477,
-0.0277714953,
0.0585121214,
0.0016543383,
-0.0108263716,
0.0512363948,
0.0039811521,
-0.0394516923,
0.0107131405,
0.0443284139,
0.0156649966,
0.0242261849,
0.0245061312,
0.0117864674,
0.0381140932,
0.0171540584,
0.0265338738,
-0.0407677852,
0.0074143107,
0.0417939126,
0.0162195135,
0.0129757971,
0.0072225141,
0.0258841477,
0.0060821637,
-0.0191437323,
-0.002589979,
-0.0255647544,
-0.0028444855,
-0.0485715233,
0.0322628804,
0.0261597577,
0.0156654511,
-0.0331890285,
-0.0064525157,
0.0137653938,
-0.0210940037,
0.0440321714,
0.0407309234,
0.0818137005,
0.0132781295,
-0.0314028114,
0.026572587,
0.055395741,
-0.0284927431,
0.0203065109,
0.0158803985,
0.0253104717,
0.0913115516,
0.0558041409,
-0.0398258232,
-0.0259198286,
-0.0024710333,
0.0078399219,
0.0184834786,
0.0042619742,
-0.0335284472,
-0.001615734,
-0.052933149,
-0.0793440789,
-0.0135243293,
-0.0159252323,
-0.0003472448,
0.0500189587,
0.0345153958,
0.0403691456,
-0.0466862768,
0.0016437882,
0.0218352191,
-0.0431114919,
-0.0144271292,
0.0335006602,
0.0196074694,
-0.0024745048,
0.0454601906,
0.0214940254,
-0.017087454,
0.0131967096,
-0.0159854591,
-0.0141191501,
-0.0412790626,
0.0207846835,
-0.0775148273,
0.0373624712,
0.0058643436,
0.0070405784,
-0.0195144787,
-0.0422147028,
-0.0531020164,
-0.0171739813,
0.0155913401,
0.0411956385,
-0.0172795132,
0.016637912,
-0.0046578115,
-0.0059909411,
-0.0349602439,
0.0939255878,
0.0167830903,
0.047402259,
0.0477733798,
0.0060958797,
-0.0018645623,
-0.036439836,
-0.0714919716,
-0.0208215099,
0.0156182842,
0.0022009488,
0.0408182107,
-0.0291291252,
-0.0624703914,
0.0075284578,
-0.1325599551,
0.0306004174,
0.0256791059,
-0.0072575561,
-0.0273680333,
0.0401604399,
0.0071551413,
0.0032439937,
0.001504717,
-0.008224682,
-0.0400145575,
0.0327935666,
0.0208213087,
0.0187236145,
-0.0338197313,
-0.0102864429,
-0.0252106767,
-0.0155095467,
0.0512472652,
0.0081588998,
-0.0332058147,
-0.021482734,
0.08429683,
-0.0427201204,
0.0081004808,
-0.0188533831,
0.0315569751,
-0.0257795826,
0.0107797161,
0.0362955406,
0.0305447057,
-0.0354359671,
0.0015239528,
0.0195229072,
-0.0030072108,
-0.0371046402,
0.0188691597,
-0.0482456423,
-0.0072383122,
-0.0096313497,
-0.0132898232,
-0.0061510107,
0.0284400545,
-0.0027569109,
-0.0607966222,
-0.0785605758,
-0.0001754318,
0.0064932005,
0.0044631339,
-0.043551106,
0.0161581114,
0.0269041602,
0.0225359611,
-0.0398135297,
-0.0025054417,
0.0733552575,
-0.0192346815,
0.0159278158,
0.0119999284,
0.0229087733,
-0.0328283198,
0.0468925312,
0.0164396334,
0.0035250846,
0.0199311301,
0.0110164071,
-0.0394780934,
0.0016663348,
0.0240273792,
-0.0072401911,
0.033462856,
0.0092376526,
0.0344800614,
0.0142983776,
-0.0022304794,
-0.0127428975,
-0.0130190691,
-0.0264025461,
0.0394167379,
0.0314836875,
-0.0036120634,
0.0372609906,
0.0049497802,
0.0150413979,
0.0247957762,
0.0063811154,
-0.0228750817,
-0.0657378733,
0.0272099357,
0.0579680689,
-0.0414688811,
0.0222136006,
-0.0116418768,
0.0214691833,
0.028006928,
0.0007593757,
-0.0108869355,
0.0237217695,
-0.0041552004,
0.023417566,
-0.0608259216,
-0.0546747819,
0.0112212813,
0.0505556874,
-0.0117847221,
0.0175827313,
0.1164010689,
0.0138086649,
-0.0437371768,
0.0060894415,
0.0198474731,
0.0184278339,
0.0358154215,
0.0124604227,
-0.130107969,
-0.0354206562,
-0.0075055161,
0.0199508332,
0.0052032024,
-0.0751807913,
-0.0136877568,
-0.111988388,
-0.001934844,
0.0067313896,
-0.0319731571,
-0.0312706232,
-0.0607094318,
0.0348911621,
-0.0176394302,
-0.0176945925,
-0.0058757872,
0.0021966826,
0.0097256573,
-0.0134660602,
0.0106739039,
-0.0703724548,
0.0251843408,
-0.0539878346,
0.0618150942,
0.0118702976,
0.0345391221,
-0.0063657491,
0.0239222031,
-0.0312774219,
-0.0191096831,
-0.0273355823,
-0.0130786244,
0.0331948213,
-0.0284931436,
-0.0022052818,
-0.0135000357,
0.011237815,
-0.0223436877,
-0.0399754159,
0.0065863715,
0.0975171924,
0.0325633995,
-0.0159528926,
0.0025281752,
-0.0327762626,
0.0148223797,
0.0805521235,
0.0171436109,
-0.0120073548,
0.0222580954,
-0.0126362657,
-0.0021730659,
-0.0299019907,
0.0032611112,
0.0073493156,
-0.0521175154,
0.0059071686,
-0.0473884419,
-0.0489845797,
0.0741364062,
-0.0032816275,
0.0041165915,
0.0674108714,
-0.0156055596,
-0.0268468224,
-0.046415396,
0.0159150828,
-0.0584964342,
0.0301360786,
-0.0321049802,
-0.0095984014,
0.0162736233,
-0.0520152599,
-0.0135687329,
-0.005462118,
-0.0694344714,
-0.065233767,
-0.0629455224,
0.0220643338,
0.0021447814,
0.086886391,
-0.0394727811,
-0.0754129589,
0.0569674,
0.0712952912,
-0.0372943692,
0.0090983761,
-0.0076467749,
0.0154883862,
-0.0021829729,
0.0401216075,
-0.0730960071,
-0.0024535914,
0.0078120963,
0.0703565925,
-0.0457334369,
-0.0625575334,
0.0044352654,
0.0438284352,
0.0177738294,
-0.0144935772,
0.0125644188,
-0.0470106229,
0.0138326176,
-0.0365990624,
-0.0293453559,
-0.0326519683,
-0.0241996516,
0.0161620975,
-0.0076927841,
0.0176602118,
-0.0220449399,
-0.0104044992,
0.0460763983,
-0.0416716672,
-0.0311281607,
0.0053467699,
-0.0167394169,
0.0844547078,
-0.0168629885,
-0.0118372776,
0.0426472239,
-0.0109428875,
0.0128449518,
-0.0361256711,
0.0275799762,
0.0211195592,
-0.0180623885,
-0.0280123986,
-0.0144326799,
-0.0230766386,
0.0238660518,
-0.028910825,
0.0307359267,
0.0673628598,
-0.0108973254,
0.0350221954,
-0.0194189958,
-0.0413236469,
-0.0141982408,
0.0329445153,
0.0240285713,
-0.0449621417,
0.0334610008,
0.0407902263,
-0.0185996909,
0.0237559434,
0.0911789984,
0.0194341354,
0.0719306916,
-0.0111336764,
-0.0314129405,
-0.0209724363,
-0.0041141226,
0.0180003457,
0.0500429757,
-0.0293134172,
0.0269880984,
-0.0370396823,
-0.0797306374,
0.041718632,
-0.0539178774,
-0.0733605623,
0.0083315047,
0.0210040081,
0.0108072199,
0.0308978837,
-0.040701773,
-0.0548101626,
0.0023076539,
0.0088868663,
-0.0115236985,
0.0122385407,
-6.892534636e-33,
-0.0259514134,
-0.0323413163,
0.0243031941,
-0.0026408834,
-0.0079595987,
0.0121833989,
-0.0116956374,
-0.0292206351,
-0.0290551446,
0.0076196995,
-0.0084650945,
-0.0029839161,
-0.0023261511,
0.0299049616,
-0.0220343769,
0.00304866,
0.0286101494,
0.0330433995,
0.0181391034,
0.0267153289,
0.0264129881,
0.0194171295,
0.0502403118,
-0.0378752872,
0.0637265965,
-0.0154197617,
0.0215645917,
0.024499923,
0.0461153872,
0.0550362244,
-0.0329689458,
0.0645412207,
0.0231093001,
-0.018985156,
0.0006594674,
-0.0010712213,
-0.1142429411,
-0.0355513133,
0.0330143236,
0.0000408666,
-0.0351990312,
-0.0530866534,
0.0222899653,
-0.0208020899,
0.0598868243,
-0.0456020385,
0.0346833095,
-0.0264748204,
-0.0754624903,
-0.0497224666,
-0.0346865244,
0.0457721949,
0.0062631262,
0.0184003804,
0.037764702,
0.0100046964,
0.022970492,
0.0251290333,
-0.0745463222,
0.0105900196,
0.0291425809,
0.0235994011,
0.0166535433,
0.0356460959,
0.0328171328,
0.0094063012,
0.0070047076,
0.0097412029,
-0.0490616076,
0.0154628288,
0.0044080978,
0.0307914671,
-0.0140163656,
0.0809670389,
-0.0124067925,
-0.0280587152,
-0.0661916137,
-0.0028058533,
-0.0169086158,
-0.0063948538,
0.0062595243,
-0.0010723204,
-0.0434551165,
-0.0656387433,
-0.055123888,
-0.0245058071,
-0.0430970676,
-0.0307999887,
-0.0060731112,
0.0074824044,
-0.0320118889,
0.0125383213,
-0.0032093744,
-0.0729364306,
-0.0355926901,
0.0441029929,
0.0012160033,
0.0228800718,
0.0101406518,
0.0187206641,
-0.0676963329,
-0.036301408,
0.0507156886,
-0.0423342995,
0.0063330201,
0.0365989394,
0.0280511398,
0.0006156513,
-0.0166912433,
-0.007190749,
-0.0094339214,
-0.016854817,
-0.021016812,
-0.0187259503,
0.0350305401,
0.0368441977,
0.0233964399,
0.0494293235,
0.0964113921,
0.0121260276,
-0.000272215,
-0.0140942847,
0.0042630797,
-0.0094228294,
0.0184370335,
0.0092988173,
-0.0033093949,
-0.0010492491,
0.025325872,
-0.0276819188,
-0.0259930398,
-0.0079658544,
3.145e-7,
0.0276961941,
0.0249336455,
-0.0059033511,
0.0326815695,
-0.0024967361,
0.0197349414,
0.0278489944,
0.0234272573,
-0.0038156197,
-0.0245327652,
0.0579208434,
0.0079380823,
-0.0069197109,
0.0115169724,
-0.1132781729,
0.013009876,
-0.0222548619,
-0.010077686,
-0.065904893,
-0.0013087777,
0.0797049403,
0.0540050901,
0.0401985198,
0.0223465543,
-0.0069136675,
-0.0401720516,
0.0635044649,
-0.0261559468,
-0.0038507886,
0.0556897596,
0.0237041581,
0.0307121333,
-0.0129658971,
0.0630366802,
0.0054756254,
0.0479158051,
0.0191128254,
0.0580912679,
0.0030264643,
0.0154531458,
-0.0005581594,
-0.039213147,
0.0022359202,
-0.0403769612,
0.1347786635,
-0.0584446974,
-0.0010101493,
0.0179196391,
-0.0642705038,
-0.0344897062,
-0.0079933871,
-0.0068928762,
-0.0056752269,
-0.0030487729,
0.0132373096,
0.0294899475,
-0.0344445258,
-0.075602226,
0.0144118229,
0.0291172862,
-0.0180133712,
-0.0413403995,
0.0022181778,
-0.0315833502,
0.0136254365,
-0.0852851793,
0.0454865135,
3.235005912e-34,
0.0190169923,
0.0149786156,
-0.011853463,
-0.0008628911,
0.0282686781,
-0.0407672562,
-0.0544934943,
0.0036888679,
0.035503976,
-0.1115091518,
-0.0077896132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08256v1 | Impact of Co-occurrence on Factual Knowledge of Large Language Models | 2023-10-12T12:01:32 | 2023-10-12T12:01:32 | Cheongwoong Kang, Jaesik Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) often make factually incorrect responses despite
their success in various applications. In this paper, we hypothesize that
relying heavily on simple co-occurrence statistics of the pre-training corpora
is one of the main factors that cause factual errors. Our results reveal that
LLMs are vulnerable to the co-occurrence bias, defined as preferring frequently
co-occurred words over the correct answer. Consequently, LLMs struggle to
recall facts whose subject and object rarely co-occur in the pre-training
dataset although they are seen during finetuning. We show that co-occurrence
bias remains despite scaling up model sizes or finetuning. Therefore, we
suggest finetuning on a debiased dataset to mitigate the bias by filtering out
biased samples whose subject-object co-occurrence count is high. Although
debiased finetuning allows LLMs to memorize rare facts in the training set, it
is not effective in recalling rare facts unseen during finetuning. Further
research in mitigation will help build reliable language models by preventing
potential errors. The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/CheongWoong/impact_of_cooccurrence}. | [
0.0286025014,
0.0108340904,
-0.0106937848,
0.0419926532,
-0.0407954715,
0.019662628,
-0.0046546827,
-0.0291999821,
-0.0210327655,
-0.078408286,
-0.0136728166,
-0.0310055055,
0.0151428236,
0.0209951904,
0.0189355556,
-0.0099015404,
0.0750514045,
-0.0386093855,
0.0011706176,
-0.0599528961,
0.0027055775,
-0.0043400857,
-0.0112930881,
0.0034050862,
-0.0342068039,
-0.0345874988,
0.0195598919,
-0.0293949805,
-0.0095715933,
-0.0095388805,
0.020710256,
0.0526341461,
0.003314218,
0.0409564637,
0.0000020178,
-0.072893627,
0.009428042,
-0.0191732887,
-0.044179257,
0.0416222326,
0.0103015527,
0.0220451783,
0.0091340365,
0.0292180628,
-0.0231956337,
0.0015112115,
0.0366932191,
0.0578649007,
0.0219693054,
0.0427059233,
0.0110440804,
-0.0065833032,
0.0254554655,
-0.0127819227,
-0.0015811108,
-0.0168396235,
0.0329918489,
0.0286872033,
-0.0362709984,
-0.0041092844,
-0.0372903086,
0.0381024666,
0.0119580701,
0.0684322715,
-0.0032455223,
0.0688307434,
-0.0533437803,
-0.0405102037,
0.00997674,
0.0476300828,
-0.0211647041,
-0.0451858789,
0.0102969855,
-0.0187243931,
-0.0011776778,
0.0299707726,
-0.0403726213,
0.0164012015,
-0.0139897661,
0.0412656926,
0.0154382093,
-0.0417149812,
0.0323952846,
0.033386264,
-0.0196230076,
0.0319184363,
0.0169210192,
-0.0419879258,
0.0093709845,
0.0135109713,
0.0105881924,
-0.0650137737,
-0.0096533187,
0.0100357728,
-0.0248321891,
0.0345770381,
-0.0458914898,
0.0114832837,
0.0709710121,
-0.0770389214,
0.010118233,
-0.0058100577,
-0.0517714098,
0.0527628101,
-0.0297719333,
0.018904468,
0.0216760077,
0.0282569267,
-0.0286696963,
-0.0269726142,
-0.0242125597,
0.0019692015,
-0.0083653582,
0.0498364344,
0.0346446075,
0.0066194939,
-0.0516221151,
-0.017508762,
-0.0108877607,
0.0115450956,
-0.0220851414,
0.0082432711,
-0.0388833545,
-0.0219345074,
-0.0386013128,
0.0274048224,
-0.0391854681,
0.0418461114,
-0.0213665999,
-0.0758116618,
-0.0098388009,
-0.0068488894,
0.0157417264,
-0.0399070084,
0.0221007653,
-0.0178460218,
-0.0026994592,
-0.0617514402,
-0.0521564856,
-0.0290614869,
-0.0360695757,
-0.0795528144,
-0.0112528708,
-0.0957113728,
0.0148368953,
0.0252479631,
0.0092065968,
-0.0442673154,
0.0118627613,
0.0428606533,
-0.0817722157,
0.0565063581,
0.0133336196,
0.0202345215,
0.0142957559,
0.001862945,
0.0464295223,
0.0747481287,
0.0389637873,
0.017179314,
0.0497424379,
-0.0018846333,
0.0031962239,
0.0210081656,
0.0230506808,
-0.0158060789,
-0.0022634512,
0.0032146855,
0.0072695841,
0.0154610276,
0.0563949645,
0.0589092225,
-0.0079258066,
-0.0437991023,
0.0777981877,
0.025479326,
-0.0113941068,
0.0132552898,
0.0169065073,
-0.0068762018,
0.0185731351,
0.0543011166,
-0.0678284317,
0.0094088418,
-0.0457679369,
0.0258591417,
0.0313884839,
0.0639770776,
-0.0413592234,
-0.0143568153,
-0.0114830807,
-0.019233102,
-0.0056182975,
0.034133587,
0.0543066375,
-0.0084165409,
-0.0101763951,
0.0571419299,
0.0569254272,
-0.0202014111,
-0.0043651196,
-0.0371080339,
0.0323278904,
0.0124882516,
0.0201780349,
-0.026215231,
-0.0449641086,
-0.0000507228,
0.0128244366,
0.0048729889,
0.0926094055,
-0.0007921818,
0.0106546581,
-0.0391424559,
-0.0079041477,
0.0127823632,
0.0222672317,
0.0097837904,
0.0168323275,
0.0187818035,
0.0274509341,
-0.0147862192,
-0.0158500429,
0.0357650891,
-0.0346224494,
-0.0510505661,
-0.026859615,
-0.0052385181,
0.0211881716,
-0.0035276676,
-0.024550816,
0.0260700881,
0.0243210141,
0.010229487,
-0.0049541839,
-0.0361361802,
-0.0449503772,
-0.0284962095,
0.0616769642,
-0.016389152,
-0.0358590782,
0.0163102131,
-0.0244868752,
-0.0393043086,
-0.0001155045,
-0.0196852572,
0.0482238792,
-0.0596935116,
0.0279657114,
-0.0033155717,
0.0343548469,
-0.0267544352,
0.0738430247,
-0.0122721288,
0.0271082036,
-0.0157375447,
-0.018132668,
0.0313502364,
-0.060054455,
-0.0435104966,
0.0076560238,
-0.0043928204,
0.0377703682,
0.038091179,
-0.0319013074,
-0.0562843829,
-0.0147326821,
-0.0558419749,
0.0186547134,
-0.0089029279,
-0.0145813944,
-0.0124841565,
-0.0110748606,
-0.0258019045,
-0.0306080468,
-0.0247876551,
0.0185238328,
0.0134320101,
0.0655731633,
0.0017771472,
-0.0229153745,
0.0174454823,
-0.0391848423,
-0.0016088168,
-0.0313856862,
0.0259653218,
-0.0028260609,
-0.0110736964,
-0.0298759826,
0.0764719993,
-0.0480958074,
0.0239283461,
0.0099825663,
-0.0119379349,
-0.0071377857,
0.0311316065,
0.0461738631,
0.0803515017,
-0.0014862072,
0.0095801409,
0.0932289734,
-0.0376800671,
-0.0585174225,
-0.0057858899,
-0.034000732,
-0.0512876622,
-0.0011834922,
-0.0319030993,
-0.0247156657,
0.0558643639,
0.0300890338,
-0.0113954647,
-0.0154048707,
0.0075254454,
-0.0402021296,
-0.0236384645,
-0.0255709551,
0.00025206,
-0.0397559442,
0.0291778818,
-0.0097117657,
-0.0450324491,
0.0529085211,
-0.0177915636,
0.0315984376,
-0.0458635278,
0.0251862779,
0.0023233828,
0.0369691812,
0.0308150705,
0.0221388619,
0.0394468457,
0.0055459891,
-0.0773947313,
-0.0255518798,
0.0363340788,
-0.0575605482,
0.0531164482,
-0.0426134989,
0.0126252659,
-0.0060086185,
-0.0509497821,
-0.06804768,
-0.0766308159,
-0.0410499834,
0.0019382951,
-0.043769367,
0.0096000889,
-0.0435281768,
-0.0255273525,
0.0536002144,
0.0147157181,
-0.0054295026,
-0.0089556044,
-0.0116860298,
0.0294364057,
0.0837698802,
0.0134220598,
0.0434038714,
-0.0297037158,
-0.0169317219,
0.0434683934,
0.0323713459,
0.0193856843,
-0.0179236121,
-0.0254288856,
0.0181994233,
-0.0333440416,
-0.0229697134,
0.0456592701,
0.0305423066,
-0.0399874598,
-0.0181899257,
0.105350256,
0.0347614735,
-0.0116212368,
0.0084358184,
0.0068219374,
0.0361289904,
0.0313494466,
0.016922392,
-0.0558316894,
-0.0271575749,
0.0107943201,
-0.0261198264,
-0.0071053468,
-0.0302996635,
-0.0201290138,
-0.1444709897,
-0.0007384417,
0.0074832239,
0.0195666887,
-0.0609195791,
-0.0456851199,
0.0086636003,
-0.0143015236,
0.0223328788,
0.011030646,
-0.0413652398,
0.0211829189,
0.0351698138,
-0.0403417572,
-0.088879168,
0.0331472717,
-0.0488057286,
0.0708387792,
0.0412834883,
0.0391960777,
-0.0418319777,
-0.0064491555,
0.0204790458,
-0.0248608366,
-0.0059994571,
0.0075547113,
0.0618349873,
-0.0086909188,
-0.0108386716,
-0.0154205048,
0.0183554366,
-0.0029532393,
-0.0502482653,
0.0080189714,
0.0630652159,
-0.0164807085,
-0.0303418208,
0.0041524828,
0.0060861572,
-0.0069868821,
0.098876439,
0.0367308334,
-0.0084032472,
-0.0030811282,
-0.029379366,
-0.0006089431,
0.0359427966,
-0.0143895438,
0.0321068354,
-0.0103487857,
-0.0037062515,
-0.0693536848,
-0.0397114716,
0.038599439,
0.0057699429,
0.00696347,
0.0377250463,
0.0401538834,
-0.0017102353,
-0.0097301863,
0.0286791734,
-0.0686492771,
0.0281456057,
-0.0584484898,
0.0017254159,
0.0297739152,
-0.0224229172,
-0.0282537881,
-0.0044302167,
-0.0688645691,
-0.0544593967,
0.0440881811,
0.0369751491,
0.0268198941,
0.0435448177,
-0.0079975119,
-0.0718883276,
0.0390876681,
0.0410822593,
-0.0601170249,
0.0300048105,
0.0100794015,
-0.0317661054,
0.0036904858,
0.0320526697,
-0.0360058956,
0.0105477823,
0.0441105552,
0.0329519212,
-0.0317250118,
-0.0509581119,
0.0300030112,
0.0140503421,
0.0816538185,
-0.0194295533,
0.0461361222,
-0.0421007276,
0.0090181008,
0.0227084141,
-0.0093228631,
0.0103841657,
0.003322223,
0.0019336643,
-0.0065522259,
-0.0200083237,
-0.0230172686,
-0.017066747,
0.0384296849,
-0.0165599249,
-0.0074009751,
0.0045372071,
-0.0075034034,
0.0300564747,
-0.0038275311,
-0.039849557,
0.0289133023,
0.0054730834,
0.0418010764,
-0.0034325579,
0.0523707904,
0.0013882933,
0.0002284687,
-0.0394674987,
-0.0220716596,
-0.0560417697,
-0.0111608608,
-0.0122733498,
0.0208405238,
0.0645554736,
-0.0678740889,
0.0233675856,
-0.0481630601,
-0.0084889131,
-0.0487778746,
0.0089045363,
0.0041951616,
0.0131742135,
0.0302105192,
0.0128889717,
-0.0308341999,
0.0277420767,
0.1356765628,
-0.0010537514,
0.0478954166,
0.0159608442,
-0.0212531146,
-0.0128982496,
-0.0274636466,
0.0188795067,
0.0021339706,
-0.0468714423,
0.0305334907,
-0.0952149406,
-0.0948273689,
-0.0044568679,
0.0053637112,
0.0135713415,
-0.0371049419,
0.0440407395,
0.0609376654,
-0.0195426941,
0.0065638674,
-0.0484739318,
0.038926851,
0.0321903229,
0.0031558799,
-0.0181467738,
-6.780626104e-33,
-0.0354264639,
0.017664928,
0.0174230915,
0.0381910279,
0.0231978968,
0.0073558069,
-0.0020449387,
0.0153124658,
-0.0551696755,
0.0124071063,
-0.0182932541,
-0.0003541865,
0.0226819087,
0.0020786093,
0.0183235202,
-0.0174922626,
0.0533874668,
0.0035821579,
-0.0153775439,
0.0056397244,
0.0323748663,
0.0340563916,
0.0700833872,
-0.0852529332,
0.0052108513,
0.0141499694,
0.0313921124,
0.0133347819,
-0.0209191386,
0.0490434617,
-0.0359579287,
0.0738036707,
0.0285002664,
-0.037950024,
-0.0298738163,
0.017262049,
-0.0623329878,
-0.0600522645,
0.0474652722,
0.0014748996,
0.0475485139,
-0.0083586583,
0.0330315381,
-0.0137678646,
-0.0391750075,
-0.007258886,
0.0307563692,
-0.0220089424,
-0.0716465265,
-0.0009265039,
-0.0676283017,
0.03102866,
0.0320537798,
-0.0362786762,
-0.0092082601,
-0.0180764422,
0.0022126762,
0.0088076228,
-0.0534176528,
0.0147373416,
0.0291946176,
0.0346269719,
0.0369018055,
0.018163275,
-0.0006853256,
0.0942736343,
0.0224079639,
0.0095364638,
0.0078768283,
-0.0094592776,
0.0402257256,
0.0165330321,
0.0171224233,
0.0854376405,
0.0648500547,
-0.007396827,
-0.0660176873,
0.0133008836,
0.0056944378,
0.0473801382,
0.0557710566,
-0.0285897497,
-0.0439380854,
-0.055048123,
-0.0585529506,
0.0623394512,
-0.0406614766,
0.0063980687,
0.0282658488,
0.0011043746,
0.0101365494,
0.0218056496,
0.025813207,
-0.0249919835,
-0.0603608973,
0.0046094013,
0.0137988515,
-0.0245747045,
-0.0217799395,
0.0436088108,
-0.0781681687,
-0.0096088788,
-0.0365161896,
-0.0225149039,
0.0116282133,
0.0301625002,
0.069943808,
0.0132681057,
-0.0751337036,
-0.0024111858,
-0.025382936,
-0.0366825201,
0.0437572896,
-0.0160809439,
0.0386829302,
0.028591739,
0.0045244005,
0.0199680999,
0.0280234832,
-0.0207273532,
-0.0377453044,
-0.0493180901,
-0.0154021895,
0.0362383947,
-0.0098379515,
-0.0067421338,
-0.0490061902,
0.0100611467,
0.0503227748,
-0.024547888,
-0.0070885122,
0.002495623,
2.714e-7,
0.0245609712,
0.0485366136,
-0.0334369279,
-0.0034633428,
-0.0047679613,
0.0649648979,
-0.0344225839,
0.035065867,
0.0384244584,
-0.0203107558,
-0.0256014429,
0.0413131677,
0.0344916843,
0.0321680345,
-0.0608237609,
0.0099647427,
-0.0556250624,
0.000042603,
-0.0429753177,
-0.0001035136,
-0.0060623861,
0.0945048705,
0.0363790132,
-0.0132462429,
-0.0032292651,
-0.050716985,
0.0673569143,
-0.0328109749,
-0.0244078115,
0.0179705508,
0.0365825556,
0.027469147,
0.0234709438,
0.0523347333,
-0.02452874,
0.0182276666,
0.0222148541,
0.0199105237,
0.0008693816,
0.0178902466,
-0.0241916142,
-0.0353711806,
-0.0311259516,
-0.0707971379,
0.0849317387,
-0.0653564185,
-0.0346921757,
-0.063255921,
0.0201359987,
0.0130640706,
0.0332956798,
-0.0018128431,
-0.035820324,
-0.0060965419,
0.0135176927,
0.0102632567,
-0.0158075932,
-0.0500560626,
-0.027685985,
0.0440528728,
-0.0384773612,
-0.0807740465,
-0.0070165964,
-0.0266595706,
0.0256846491,
-0.0571107231,
0.0282069836,
2.595704126e-34,
0.0359195434,
-0.0039284406,
0.0060757492,
-0.0183532368,
0.0171797238,
-0.0140662165,
-0.0261090174,
0.0350363031,
0.0036247259,
-0.0535109974,
-0.0014955058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08240v1 | Who Said That? Benchmarking Social Media AI Detection | 2023-10-12T11:35:24 | 2023-10-12T11:35:24 | Wanyun Cui, Linqiu Zhang, Qianle Wang, Shuyang Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | AI-generated text has proliferated across various online platforms, offering
both transformative prospects and posing significant risks related to
misinformation and manipulation. Addressing these challenges, this paper
introduces SAID (Social media AI Detection), a novel benchmark developed to
assess AI-text detection models' capabilities in real social media platforms.
It incorporates real AI-generate text from popular social media platforms like
Zhihu and Quora. Unlike existing benchmarks, SAID deals with content that
reflects the sophisticated strategies employed by real AI users on the Internet
which may evade detection or gain visibility, providing a more realistic and
challenging evaluation landscape. A notable finding of our study, based on the
Zhihu dataset, reveals that annotators can distinguish between AI-generated and
human-generated texts with an average accuracy rate of 96.5%. This finding
necessitates a re-evaluation of human capability in recognizing AI-generated
text in today's widely AI-influenced environment. Furthermore, we present a new
user-oriented AI-text detection challenge focusing on the practicality and
effectiveness of identifying AI-generated text based on user information and
multiple responses. The experimental results demonstrate that conducting
detection tasks on actual social media platforms proves to be more challenging
compared to traditional simulated AI-text detection, resulting in a decreased
accuracy. On the other hand, user-oriented AI-generated text detection
significantly improve the accuracy of detection. | [
0.091790162,
0.0336372331,
-0.018290665,
0.0297177732,
-0.0265429467,
0.0027429776,
0.0221690629,
0.0172164161,
0.0419243202,
-0.0406301878,
-0.0076221917,
0.0000287862,
-0.0168584399,
0.0351650864,
0.0127786817,
0.0183043275,
0.0205326993,
0.0265218429,
0.0445979089,
0.0271179006,
0.0419771299,
0.0267831702,
-0.0152850961,
0.0345522948,
-0.0459214263,
-0.0344961062,
0.0313814804,
0.0062880446,
0.031334132,
-0.0420605354,
0.0135852005,
0.072408393,
-0.0268521104,
0.1316592991,
0.0000017825,
-0.0156127857,
-0.0056653721,
-0.0107302535,
-0.0578262769,
-0.0048298822,
0.0742504746,
0.0148070464,
-0.0352184065,
0.0297538266,
-0.0700129494,
0.0255847499,
0.0389399119,
0.0314547271,
0.0564895086,
0.0939408988,
-0.035340406,
0.0085526742,
0.0412048735,
0.013726905,
-0.0223748684,
-0.0477437899,
0.0272329152,
-0.0195770394,
0.0046157157,
-0.0068916744,
0.0278006475,
0.0384072512,
0.0236448441,
-0.033907339,
-0.0170172714,
-0.0098305857,
-0.0266760401,
-0.0246685371,
-0.0054441784,
0.0605038218,
0.0124203218,
-0.0195747279,
0.0273295715,
-0.0247747973,
0.0163748004,
0.0083097182,
0.0061190226,
0.0267106928,
-0.0482419133,
-0.0117872609,
-0.0130445557,
0.0337489061,
0.0233676396,
0.0503079817,
0.007914139,
0.0111155873,
-0.027136093,
-0.0362523906,
-0.0082343034,
-0.0114139402,
0.0214002002,
-0.040660616,
0.0375288576,
0.0336033069,
-0.0273843892,
-0.0018373419,
-0.0903668702,
-0.1006924435,
0.0261888131,
-0.0849648193,
0.0182134677,
-0.0024693396,
-0.0009774249,
0.0630131662,
-0.0134859374,
0.0714304969,
-0.0235802662,
0.0422388725,
0.017993018,
0.0119231418,
-0.0203907285,
-0.0082993945,
-0.0110568292,
-0.0029818974,
0.0194809493,
-0.0262660794,
-0.0469801687,
0.0144445924,
-0.0295965225,
0.0132898027,
-0.0530139208,
0.0049349503,
-0.0111810258,
0.0002921589,
0.0026678622,
-0.0315618813,
-0.0068216906,
0.0239494462,
0.0024184205,
-0.0808842704,
0.0022187205,
0.0680105537,
0.0391798653,
-0.0156314988,
-0.0003462553,
0.0347028933,
-0.0110070743,
-0.0347983129,
-0.0355639048,
-0.0517765991,
-0.0030361072,
-0.0254051089,
-0.0173731763,
-0.0459543914,
0.0223805346,
0.004988669,
-0.0279172417,
-0.0245047174,
-0.0041474449,
0.05632101,
-0.0055792616,
0.0301269796,
-0.0291971602,
0.0119528752,
0.0364530422,
0.0316966735,
-0.0132277291,
0.0416124053,
0.0142310392,
0.1054794639,
0.0528306514,
0.0113250399,
0.0614554286,
0.0569118485,
0.0346467718,
0.0063621853,
0.0300237164,
0.004271565,
-0.0641464069,
-0.0165092405,
0.0158916097,
0.058721412,
0.0035676088,
-0.0146186715,
0.0808630288,
0.0628148168,
-0.050118506,
0.0034112358,
0.0617075376,
0.0411695354,
0.0577892587,
-0.0077065951,
-0.0266076904,
0.0109529914,
-0.0694904998,
-0.066125527,
0.0082037272,
0.0049428069,
0.0068016001,
-0.0321476124,
-0.0084921923,
-0.0201181378,
0.0329591595,
-0.0303798113,
0.0165750273,
0.0201096721,
-0.0187524669,
-0.0490388647,
-0.0099273762,
-0.0256328769,
-0.0080794413,
-0.0624015182,
0.0306525957,
0.0438294671,
0.0290171411,
-0.0422211997,
0.062926501,
-0.0224315561,
0.023212688,
0.0829723477,
0.0432284363,
-0.016618073,
-0.058400739,
0.025742732,
-0.018046055,
-0.0126739675,
0.0006716639,
-0.0040191789,
0.0560826249,
0.0261421073,
0.0122011248,
0.0027792228,
-0.0622223392,
0.036355868,
-0.0198156405,
-0.0137798646,
-0.0254557971,
0.0302748289,
0.0250821114,
0.0352250896,
-0.0223580524,
0.0069913566,
0.0265211407,
-0.0190375596,
-0.0673267767,
-0.0244476013,
0.0022076706,
0.0266025588,
0.0161513276,
-0.0230779368,
-0.0349649563,
0.0614732057,
-0.0277866106,
0.0124348234,
0.0568007939,
-0.0689423978,
-0.0135756368,
-0.0451652929,
-0.0218003094,
-0.0229304023,
0.0469503701,
0.0024569395,
0.0863933265,
-0.0457865559,
-0.0321088098,
0.0161589049,
-0.0275209993,
0.0308280587,
0.0149704348,
0.010223656,
-0.0249399431,
-0.03704511,
0.0342767462,
0.036425326,
-0.0177757479,
-0.0408852436,
0.001888599,
-0.0765307844,
-0.0264490042,
-0.0315994322,
0.0020328134,
0.0347405933,
-0.0233670902,
0.0124829654,
0.0080027068,
-0.0197365824,
-0.0149695957,
0.011869018,
0.0325550325,
0.0359918959,
-0.0098966165,
0.0077931108,
-0.0599377789,
0.023661837,
-0.044056695,
0.0221883059,
0.0637611374,
-0.0760576352,
0.0094803739,
0.0050199595,
-0.0255791768,
-0.0046212357,
-0.0182036888,
-0.0502021015,
0.0332225859,
-0.0004812434,
0.0016663115,
0.0521338955,
0.0482595488,
0.052572526,
0.0016364497,
0.0740988627,
-0.020287307,
0.0028850886,
0.002246097,
0.013970417,
-0.0363134891,
-0.0512642004,
0.0415416881,
0.0282293092,
0.0268948171,
0.023041945,
-0.0260356776,
0.0512114391,
-0.0403465852,
-0.0638966784,
0.0031039624,
-0.0209589116,
-0.0167549606,
0.0306211971,
-0.0562004633,
-0.0439147986,
0.0527865142,
-0.0024982993,
0.0368169732,
0.0153919663,
-0.061136771,
-0.0182982255,
0.0173937157,
0.0311192572,
0.0352331921,
-0.0321608931,
0.0246309061,
-0.0041964031,
0.0056834188,
0.0308334846,
-0.0360545367,
-0.0330885202,
0.0320964344,
0.0352411829,
0.0096819494,
-0.0206456929,
-0.0550512746,
-0.0848043859,
-0.0468683988,
-0.0119437259,
0.0270252135,
-0.0703127384,
-0.0108963903,
-0.0266707372,
0.0352433473,
0.040705435,
-0.006599552,
-0.0173508469,
-0.0193606745,
0.0253492706,
0.0381824113,
-0.0206755083,
0.038274765,
-0.0289866496,
0.020097414,
0.0693913326,
0.0276997164,
-0.0110675348,
-0.0196312871,
-0.0540457778,
-0.0165217742,
0.009747019,
0.0172712747,
0.0138934562,
0.0296289492,
-0.0202929508,
0.033187788,
0.0774398595,
0.0171487257,
-0.0108847758,
0.0124051394,
-0.0225500055,
-0.0014090288,
0.0237857476,
-0.0072916988,
-0.0930938348,
-0.0176866446,
-0.0294308942,
0.0137187727,
-0.0429510213,
-0.0313551538,
-0.0215263795,
-0.0901143849,
0.0040552714,
-0.0243270472,
-0.0212806594,
0.0052537327,
-0.0310992002,
-0.0036291496,
-0.0107183913,
-0.0265116487,
-0.0393870622,
-0.0004021355,
0.0074461396,
-0.009988782,
-0.0642252415,
0.0100225741,
0.0114420801,
-0.0331566967,
0.0266805366,
0.0577933714,
0.0637650043,
-0.0205538217,
-0.0301621221,
0.0025961928,
0.0186746549,
0.0062486962,
0.0014384931,
0.1129546687,
-0.0225941334,
-0.0077323369,
-0.0260215383,
0.0257491339,
-0.0354130939,
-0.0069427998,
0.0006384961,
0.028083425,
0.0122537808,
-0.0371772349,
-0.0273672845,
0.00444292,
0.0516862124,
0.0568915494,
0.0403387137,
-0.0588993169,
-0.051567506,
-0.0189298745,
0.0052745133,
-0.0773240775,
-0.0535447262,
-0.0039163586,
0.0032910111,
-0.0494927242,
-0.0893075764,
-0.0318691507,
-0.0169333089,
-0.0189733095,
-0.019618988,
-0.003141989,
0.0243561342,
0.0038884119,
-0.03599656,
-0.0223874282,
-0.0348466039,
0.0646310151,
-0.0248846933,
-0.0277497526,
-0.0188421924,
-0.0408190526,
-0.0069651976,
0.0550746657,
-0.0783167779,
-0.0376846455,
0.0212442726,
0.0398542583,
0.0158318095,
-0.0064250403,
-0.0440274924,
-0.0542965755,
0.0787940174,
0.0338819921,
-0.0368317068,
0.005363116,
0.0331731327,
0.0241093002,
-0.007178809,
0.0218655281,
-0.0208930559,
0.0081857638,
0.0180379041,
-0.0400906987,
-0.0648364648,
0.0065931957,
0.0098568136,
0.0314382352,
-0.007772631,
0.0013572682,
-0.0145165911,
-0.0074025202,
-0.062573351,
0.002435274,
-0.0361017436,
-0.0153577263,
-0.0047942968,
0.0227744076,
-0.006987574,
-0.0038711671,
0.0359628014,
-0.0133125158,
0.0125550339,
-0.0427409038,
-0.0191669539,
0.0141373454,
0.0738782734,
-0.0064250068,
0.0061043384,
0.0093850819,
0.0547603182,
-0.0020110572,
0.0432501771,
0.0080839423,
0.0116082318,
-0.0131597538,
-0.0347760841,
0.0259161592,
0.0219502691,
-0.0500975288,
-0.0442539044,
-0.0139843337,
0.0221297387,
0.0363077782,
0.0153345261,
0.0449875593,
-0.0005918686,
-0.0015515117,
-0.0005983554,
-0.0126033286,
-0.0068232645,
-0.0353656337,
-0.0467470437,
0.0018595713,
-0.0317249037,
0.0351074226,
0.0705101416,
0.0041146958,
0.0368541554,
0.0046666781,
-0.0381233804,
-0.0468399338,
-0.0126012759,
-0.0153811174,
0.0397297852,
0.0041355807,
0.0136408973,
-0.0323901027,
-0.0557178818,
0.0290629789,
-0.0242077708,
0.0008052448,
0.0112692621,
-0.0335344896,
0.0636633858,
-0.0096589513,
0.0050079366,
-0.0694477856,
-0.007100563,
-0.0208579358,
-0.0326463655,
-0.0057588145,
-5.915370427e-33,
0.0142554827,
-0.0932266712,
-0.0082398709,
0.0104818353,
0.0244395733,
0.0403109342,
-0.018213721,
-0.002608734,
-0.0278151613,
0.02212766,
-0.0064186598,
0.0455424301,
-0.0086306781,
-0.0078348387,
-0.0418883897,
-0.0230403021,
0.0365408435,
-0.0250000823,
-0.0505512841,
0.0345625579,
0.0509100333,
-0.0287077706,
-0.0060753254,
-0.1080496311,
0.0158183388,
-0.0195986535,
-0.0378045328,
-0.0011320882,
-0.0216354057,
0.0602161102,
-0.0202237479,
0.0439508855,
0.0520665087,
0.0195646863,
0.0000425552,
0.0371215008,
-0.0123405401,
0.0006059339,
-0.028913524,
0.0133053958,
-0.0579108484,
-0.0323278569,
0.0267036408,
-0.0392206311,
-0.0143373748,
0.0438546911,
0.0594245195,
0.0011687735,
0.0553749651,
-0.0120447371,
-0.0773380399,
0.0174181126,
-0.0013866038,
-0.0002466082,
-0.0028977448,
0.0531277433,
0.0411495529,
0.0256575253,
-0.0978601873,
0.012732204,
-0.0346122049,
-0.0371529795,
0.0439778529,
-0.0099923657,
-0.0389391258,
0.0672469288,
0.0565897971,
0.0428415723,
-0.0373993739,
-0.0084784701,
-0.0307374913,
0.0300039444,
0.061209619,
0.0870977119,
-0.0038147324,
-0.0624330901,
-0.0408254676,
0.0299832784,
0.0416979752,
-0.0100957928,
0.038046699,
-0.0154353026,
-0.0750611871,
0.0235535856,
-0.0020618173,
-0.0519623198,
-0.0601879507,
0.0064373096,
-0.0103846639,
0.0287740938,
-0.0615685098,
0.0056031314,
0.0066283871,
-0.0748593807,
0.0235148147,
0.0370460153,
-0.0355097242,
0.0259675682,
0.0305874385,
0.041778896,
-0.0323078968,
-0.0033223196,
0.0513484068,
0.0018877218,
0.0419272929,
-0.0175198857,
0.077699855,
0.0279666428,
-0.0332069173,
-0.0062720426,
-0.0112178782,
0.0414082855,
-0.0118028717,
-0.0090783304,
0.0144709432,
-0.0094580306,
-0.0380544998,
-0.0102776336,
0.0436057746,
0.0391927585,
-0.013192486,
-0.0108361663,
-0.0324260183,
-0.0405710526,
-0.0251581483,
-0.0228953473,
-0.0255569629,
0.0114497039,
0.0041880459,
-0.0796452463,
0.0176705047,
-0.0390405059,
2.545e-7,
0.005568556,
0.0387476794,
0.0139898341,
-0.0059293224,
0.0339448936,
0.0530349575,
0.0603307486,
0.0317624062,
-0.0489250533,
-0.0176652726,
-0.0134843644,
0.0503452048,
0.057153441,
0.0063409857,
-0.0105577791,
0.0098555759,
-0.0726283565,
0.0212898664,
-0.0714025795,
0.0045128791,
0.0273231156,
0.0378761552,
0.0479543321,
-0.036992792,
-0.0174808446,
-0.0916907042,
0.0193056874,
0.042550981,
0.0144364694,
0.0331980623,
0.0453279354,
0.0345655791,
0.024800811,
0.0076953783,
-0.0205103103,
0.0086867725,
0.0275313966,
0.0250401758,
0.0157745369,
0.001388924,
-0.000983874,
-0.0359452553,
0.021722205,
-0.0231326148,
0.0537974611,
-0.0132861044,
-0.0502144061,
-0.052744884,
-0.0196776949,
-0.0378093906,
0.0344090015,
-0.016006913,
-0.0027362902,
0.0163117889,
-0.0044422378,
0.0050328989,
-0.0158271212,
-0.0388637856,
0.0048698499,
-0.047794614,
-0.0353203826,
0.0022615448,
-0.0699906051,
0.0116498312,
0.0453949347,
-0.0193925798,
0.0597750247,
1.723080831e-34,
0.0116162095,
-0.0090366313,
-0.009349566,
-0.0259698648,
0.0464368984,
0.0461052246,
-0.0231792796,
-0.0241517853,
0.027231466,
-0.0277739335,
0.0254037734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08232v1 | Language Models are Universal Embedders | 2023-10-12T11:25:46 | 2023-10-12T11:25:46 | Xin Zhang, Zehan Li, Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Pengjun Xie, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the large language model (LLM) revolution, embedding is a key component of
various systems. For example, it is used to retrieve knowledge or memories for
LLMs, to build content moderation filters, etc. As such cases span from English
to other natural or programming languages, from retrieval to classification and
beyond, it is desirable to build a unified embedding model rather than
dedicated ones for each scenario. In this work, we make an initial step towards
this goal, demonstrating that multiple languages (both natural and programming)
pre-trained transformer decoders can embed universally when finetuned on
limited English data. We provide a comprehensive practice with thorough
evaluations. On English MTEB, our models achieve competitive performance on
different embedding tasks by minimal training data. On other benchmarks, such
as multilingual classification and code search, our models (without any
supervision) perform comparably to, or even surpass heavily supervised
baselines and/or APIs. These results provide evidence of a promising path
towards building powerful unified embedders that can be applied across tasks
and languages. | [
-0.0077868695,
0.0757376254,
0.0101673575,
0.0575303361,
0.0196051728,
0.0325169601,
-0.0050378954,
-0.0069623832,
-0.0148112448,
-0.044870384,
-0.0446290374,
0.0131721441,
-0.0296838693,
0.0331844017,
0.0312969349,
-0.0125993714,
0.0027474691,
0.0063236752,
-0.0313024931,
0.0035006548,
-0.0026270805,
0.0237387214,
0.0410366505,
0.0644059554,
-0.0030785236,
0.0120219579,
-0.0020945449,
-0.0084354673,
0.0068137753,
0.0048712958,
0.0148093039,
0.0152205406,
0.0607114248,
0.0625754818,
0.0000018152,
0.0022254772,
-0.0368588343,
-0.0135509279,
-0.0216819253,
-0.0048960429,
0.0353642963,
-0.0736229047,
0.0007585377,
0.0264756624,
-0.0300181713,
-0.0885993838,
0.077437304,
0.0143023077,
0.0734838098,
0.0773822963,
-0.0098461667,
-0.0451256558,
0.0337369032,
-0.0341897756,
-0.0215654075,
-0.025026001,
-0.0032975187,
0.0019884375,
-0.0250821281,
0.0257798024,
-0.0490897447,
0.0425663628,
0.0421330258,
0.0209565349,
-0.0165313594,
0.0164292455,
-0.0401532315,
-0.0218659975,
-0.0183031037,
0.0758499503,
-0.043097686,
-0.045635961,
-0.0208450295,
0.0173086785,
-0.0176766943,
-0.0216314904,
-0.0226043817,
0.0459717512,
0.0154888416,
0.0493187197,
0.0218345374,
0.0148545559,
0.0473329872,
-0.0066257194,
-0.0645383745,
0.0315965302,
0.0459302627,
-0.010472429,
-0.0239125639,
0.0135541521,
0.0160408393,
-0.0084975455,
0.0294444226,
0.0143574262,
0.0018413707,
-0.0011285987,
-0.0234758127,
-0.0571638979,
-0.0133065656,
-0.0161872953,
0.0280440878,
0.0706863254,
-0.0150108756,
0.0560470335,
-0.0534836315,
0.0356021523,
-0.0451666005,
0.040040832,
-0.0433244966,
-0.0430641361,
-0.0449696928,
-0.0067940224,
-0.037885949,
0.0102684684,
-0.0215554461,
-0.0186977442,
0.0175341144,
0.0460958481,
0.0161909331,
0.0278459843,
0.0187954716,
-0.0036468883,
-0.0437135324,
-0.018646447,
0.0702112764,
0.0485971086,
-0.0087559884,
-0.0336296782,
-0.013784688,
-0.0506412089,
-0.0211215932,
0.0199869536,
0.0107745072,
-0.0305656604,
0.0006971557,
0.0365815945,
-0.0094487844,
-0.0501872972,
-0.0146412905,
0.0338153802,
0.00636697,
-0.0132210497,
-0.0063816551,
-0.0632207543,
0.03606328,
0.0138810119,
0.0487734117,
-0.0662550852,
-0.0045415657,
-0.0148182316,
0.0084562711,
0.0803390667,
0.0017448972,
-0.0205969941,
0.031992808,
0.027519431,
0.0305184014,
0.0603723302,
-0.0099717909,
0.0222043246,
0.0373528898,
-0.0315269716,
0.018605601,
0.0716402233,
-0.0002396186,
0.0020761848,
0.0047646253,
0.0013104212,
0.0206083972,
0.0016035765,
0.0460011736,
0.0273621883,
-0.0370392241,
-0.0177667812,
0.019226376,
0.0083207879,
0.030521147,
0.0543636009,
0.0656783804,
0.004133842,
-0.021284828,
-0.0189528391,
-0.0253335238,
0.0057108989,
-0.0110213626,
-0.0130494433,
0.0227890182,
0.0387302898,
-0.0419384092,
-0.0142615931,
0.016443029,
-0.0571890473,
0.005128942,
-0.0109829679,
0.0782502592,
0.0322341695,
-0.0443493091,
0.0763293728,
0.0148366494,
-0.0531722978,
0.0352762341,
-0.029526202,
0.0089808814,
0.0297120102,
0.0561109036,
-0.0273201894,
-0.0016383302,
-0.0194374155,
0.0228128824,
0.0115382234,
0.0475499816,
-0.030390773,
0.0497898795,
-0.0700056329,
-0.0311873853,
-0.007470679,
0.0375008844,
0.0409363844,
0.0300349183,
0.0251179915,
0.0318900943,
-0.0464031622,
0.0012609693,
0.024930818,
-0.0296887532,
-0.0206946563,
-0.0147072561,
0.0191787016,
0.0040737791,
-0.0069271824,
-0.0355843492,
-0.0104916869,
0.0404611453,
-0.0633351058,
-0.0312878639,
0.0011443897,
-0.0430747122,
-0.0572558977,
0.0386257172,
-0.063436307,
0.0045814477,
0.0747306794,
-0.0464975983,
-0.0210659653,
0.0147581669,
-0.0136977853,
0.0633003637,
-0.0202542655,
0.0077650598,
-0.0343585536,
-0.0174574554,
-0.0328172371,
0.0252118129,
-0.0061459923,
0.0203130171,
0.0035413883,
-0.0220718216,
0.0225348398,
0.0073505417,
-0.0730828643,
0.0495919026,
-0.0131405322,
0.0449796095,
0.0403339379,
0.0006287249,
-0.003424237,
-0.0279998127,
-0.1031434461,
-0.009171756,
-0.0444081686,
0.0159654208,
0.0220595095,
0.0334594175,
0.0049111722,
-0.0313730501,
-0.0260588136,
-0.0265772771,
-0.0109055461,
0.0218318142,
0.005244819,
-0.0200237073,
-0.0057346886,
-0.0221331473,
-0.0316204093,
-0.002527823,
0.0798290372,
-0.0379958786,
-0.0174487233,
-0.0437014736,
0.0277496073,
0.0219120421,
0.0183679666,
-0.0166956522,
-0.0580076128,
-0.0090191131,
-0.0304099806,
0.0421690121,
0.0661911517,
-0.0205604266,
0.0413926356,
0.0302983448,
0.0045422539,
-0.0652274117,
-0.0068741064,
-0.0063937646,
-0.0700575784,
-0.0616473258,
-0.0122366464,
0.0156538505,
0.092217885,
-0.0132214008,
-0.0026368257,
-0.0694865286,
-0.0057689818,
-0.0155805778,
0.0086818766,
0.0032418009,
0.0080527607,
-0.0049896087,
0.0305178128,
-0.0179766715,
-0.0723665878,
0.0826579034,
-0.0361053236,
-0.0360881351,
-0.0316540264,
-0.0123148412,
-0.0546744838,
0.0482448265,
-0.0062772455,
0.0565126315,
-0.0062962295,
-0.0559664927,
-0.0512488,
0.0389712378,
0.012107213,
-0.0309426188,
0.0503071174,
0.0091517353,
-0.0202208366,
-0.0188163277,
-0.0421050191,
-0.0338172913,
-0.0250494611,
-0.0377628431,
0.0022758231,
0.0286289211,
-0.0223159604,
-0.0358988941,
-0.0117050279,
0.0054577254,
0.0363336913,
0.0274794493,
-0.0194320492,
-0.0155795813,
0.0114066191,
0.0260689724,
-0.01006456,
-0.0079195835,
-0.0042042467,
0.0211824812,
0.0323666707,
0.006692884,
0.0073684757,
-0.0578726754,
0.015339205,
0.0543204322,
-0.0201560408,
-0.004875137,
0.006441074,
0.0291204173,
-0.0351245925,
-0.0186035391,
0.1221701354,
0.04519381,
-0.0717374533,
-0.0247381758,
-0.0051621362,
0.0118707521,
0.0380452983,
-0.0040094098,
-0.0924654976,
-0.0502912253,
-0.0050736601,
-0.0025542809,
0.054326877,
0.0112346457,
0.005002846,
-0.1072220132,
-0.0072994111,
0.0375721492,
-0.0038733508,
-0.0739006922,
-0.0405989476,
-0.0457385741,
-0.0404966325,
-0.0023436532,
-0.0114247631,
0.0040583331,
0.0082554212,
0.0042480826,
-0.0020662975,
-0.0669381618,
0.0103249839,
-0.0635092631,
0.0316473469,
0.0688986108,
0.0157192778,
-0.0113599515,
-0.0152615495,
-0.0044192853,
-0.0209484287,
-0.048221238,
0.0058715404,
0.0389542878,
-0.0321319774,
-0.0390363075,
0.0287749507,
0.0120853633,
-0.0746967569,
0.0207100511,
-0.0076005436,
0.1003341451,
0.0024211584,
-0.0125920242,
-0.0027760102,
-0.0462367125,
-0.0090657119,
0.078560397,
0.0230914913,
-0.0329826698,
-0.0113730915,
-0.0669654235,
0.0377214849,
-0.004790782,
-0.0544905812,
0.0217247289,
0.0216270443,
-0.0278535075,
-0.0654586777,
-0.0244750474,
0.0351457819,
0.0248077456,
0.0166909937,
-0.0301280301,
0.0227972139,
-0.0415422097,
-0.0746629313,
0.0327328108,
-0.0453290492,
0.0075357538,
-0.0560417436,
0.0081855357,
0.0344776474,
-0.0011432267,
-0.0040590805,
-0.0104684662,
-0.0656290576,
-0.0438640192,
-0.0162314903,
0.0440688804,
0.0118275601,
0.0302823074,
-0.0372790881,
-0.0435786657,
0.0310915653,
0.0060905986,
-0.0373059921,
-0.0248848535,
0.0798992813,
-0.0281583872,
-0.0101382937,
0.0519453436,
-0.0491730422,
-0.0120929731,
-0.0003662155,
0.0080876993,
-0.0035316607,
-0.0247319397,
0.0377567038,
-0.0240790863,
0.0293571185,
-0.0165500194,
0.0306264199,
-0.0242688283,
-0.0153509472,
-0.0092129353,
-0.0247502904,
-0.0367150418,
0.0146073774,
0.0877494365,
-0.0037932028,
0.0023163664,
0.0410143398,
0.0239402708,
0.0493985079,
-0.0205869842,
0.0471966416,
0.0162582044,
0.006405463,
0.0526488647,
0.0257095601,
-0.0314387158,
0.0020823132,
-0.0103154825,
0.0097213332,
-0.0488118492,
0.0382585935,
0.0015172274,
-0.0112528382,
-0.0152052091,
0.0321676992,
-0.045509465,
-0.038700331,
0.0041937614,
-0.0191884711,
0.0880735219,
-0.024303155,
0.046875827,
0.0050599622,
-0.0130270785,
-0.0291323215,
0.0235178731,
-0.0014439435,
-0.023461571,
0.0442785397,
0.004775946,
-0.0357363448,
0.0072383475,
0.0721106455,
-0.0057240268,
0.0315403901,
0.0196478721,
0.0003156236,
-0.0296170283,
-0.0000950737,
0.0325216353,
0.004018419,
-0.0458934791,
0.0070307069,
-0.0061277603,
-0.0540895909,
0.0012561487,
-0.0064624259,
-0.0306998175,
0.011339372,
0.0047904556,
0.0700814128,
-0.0044052275,
0.0015059214,
-0.0294272974,
0.0245440099,
0.017334016,
-0.0328256115,
-0.0314983688,
-5.624336025e-33,
0.0093464144,
0.031500455,
-0.0178762376,
-0.0254979469,
0.0081260912,
0.0132480888,
-0.0401197113,
-0.0088603226,
-0.0424438082,
-0.0009283343,
-0.0069646896,
0.0429183282,
-0.0009901427,
0.0434376113,
0.0002897585,
-0.0261681397,
0.0661033988,
0.0143119842,
-0.0293323267,
0.0248927847,
0.0018416046,
0.0396678224,
0.0614836812,
-0.0044481703,
-0.0121778445,
0.0071698087,
-0.003526527,
0.0243258756,
0.0343077183,
0.0792135522,
-0.0322529599,
0.0342379808,
0.0080755772,
-0.0481564812,
-0.0397122279,
0.0009197881,
-0.1066787615,
0.015492945,
-0.0229947902,
0.0481277257,
0.0028171216,
-0.0321353152,
0.0318283327,
-0.0471375473,
0.0315388739,
-0.0169737507,
0.0220780279,
-0.0159524195,
-0.0040816818,
-0.0443749391,
-0.0348364748,
0.025718214,
-0.0278400965,
-0.0242339838,
0.0661451966,
0.0188316703,
0.0380002409,
0.0529700927,
-0.0788306743,
0.0126447016,
-0.0453354381,
0.0382575952,
0.0795394927,
-0.0145805785,
-0.0076027988,
0.0348774344,
-0.0168214124,
-0.0296366569,
-0.0128965881,
0.0036730024,
0.0393423252,
0.031031087,
0.0360953659,
0.0432048477,
0.0330295675,
-0.0285491161,
-0.0326870568,
0.0254436135,
-0.0231925901,
0.031303402,
0.0130998055,
0.0509359427,
-0.0353116207,
-0.0172495227,
-0.0429903828,
-0.0215058848,
-0.028836308,
-0.0289542302,
0.0258606207,
0.0155788744,
-0.0069141672,
-0.0296035707,
0.0598926321,
-0.0850815102,
0.0109038921,
0.0586794354,
-0.0048951474,
0.0107158609,
-0.0193589572,
0.0812921897,
-0.0190743785,
-0.0159133356,
0.0245533362,
-0.0268691983,
0.0079665883,
-0.0069933324,
0.0433017872,
0.0332836546,
-0.0800979733,
-0.0136432787,
-0.0465078354,
-0.0400437526,
0.0034868061,
0.059900254,
0.0308906566,
0.0136031816,
-0.0190230832,
0.0224542283,
0.0263436642,
0.0207747798,
-0.0398657732,
-0.0026140201,
0.0178649705,
0.0196085181,
-0.0001182345,
-0.0197162889,
-0.0683788657,
0.0476660803,
0.0454240181,
-0.0568812639,
-0.0125825321,
-0.0090149892,
2.342e-7,
0.0594646968,
0.0196800381,
0.0316737667,
-0.0010123244,
0.004403152,
0.0453905463,
-0.0247354079,
0.0422108211,
-0.0095247785,
0.002856245,
-0.0213133618,
0.017954357,
0.0489720702,
0.0175274778,
-0.0835638866,
0.0036340184,
-0.0316119567,
0.0095811971,
-0.0400187895,
-0.0226385035,
0.0565335155,
0.1552967876,
0.0066826628,
0.017328443,
-0.0015672104,
-0.0447382703,
0.0722757205,
-0.0354365967,
-0.0033665781,
0.0316017605,
-0.0199281536,
0.0504771844,
-0.0073443791,
-0.0499465913,
-0.0211971011,
0.0317806005,
0.048016604,
0.057607159,
0.0358715914,
-0.0044367439,
-0.0102088451,
-0.0349496566,
-0.0403277129,
-0.0371469185,
0.0632030442,
-0.0683383271,
-0.019980127,
-0.0114100091,
-0.0322973207,
0.017753901,
0.0288364049,
-0.0374580361,
-0.0257890746,
0.0377140045,
0.0421842523,
-0.0026955646,
0.0071942271,
-0.0970742553,
-0.0310191363,
0.0224802457,
-0.0339867026,
-0.0215620901,
-0.0178472083,
-0.0214117635,
0.0421039425,
-0.0342937261,
0.0482000187,
2.375991145e-34,
0.0234464686,
-0.0033036487,
0.0217010379,
0.0180099066,
0.0469374135,
-0.0494733043,
-0.0036634577,
-0.0212616343,
-0.0028127981,
-0.0554150529,
-0.0031812009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08225v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08225v1 | Fast Word Error Rate Estimation Using Self-Supervised Representations For Speech And Text | 2023-10-12T11:17:40 | 2023-10-12T11:17:40 | Chanho Park, Chengsong Lu, Mingjie Chen, Thomas Hain | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | The quality of automatic speech recognition (ASR) is typically measured by
word error rate (WER). WER estimation is a task aiming to predict the WER of an
ASR system, given a speech utterance and a transcription. This task has gained
increasing attention while advanced ASR systems are trained on large amounts of
data. In this case, WER estimation becomes necessary in many scenarios, for
example, selecting training data with unknown transcription quality or
estimating the testing performance of an ASR system without ground truth
transcriptions. Facing large amounts of data, the computation efficiency of a
WER estimator becomes essential in practical applications. However, previous
works usually did not consider it as a priority. In this paper, a Fast WER
estimator (Fe-WER) using self-supervised learning representation (SSLR) is
introduced. The estimator is built upon SSLR aggregated by average pooling. The
results show that Fe-WER outperformed the e-WER3 baseline relatively by 19.69%
and 7.16% on Ted-Lium3 in both evaluation metrics of root mean square error and
Pearson correlation coefficient, respectively. Moreover, the estimation
weighted by duration was 10.43% when the target was 10.88%. Lastly, the
inference speed was about 4x in terms of a real-time factor. | [
-0.0263381731,
0.0378583409,
0.0428230576,
0.0162188411,
0.0026692145,
-0.0118735228,
0.0602544919,
-0.0274645928,
0.0145203006,
-0.0304033961,
-0.0630961284,
-0.0263206251,
0.0625004098,
-0.0114194974,
0.0049171168,
0.0380285382,
0.0206467882,
-0.039284613,
0.0230923891,
-0.0246742293,
0.0283410475,
0.0151839238,
-0.0350603871,
0.0410713814,
-0.0176840145,
0.026156012,
0.0060972008,
0.0098918872,
-0.0305568483,
-0.0342638344,
-0.005658899,
0.0364920348,
0.0543074422,
0.0368804857,
0.0000024278,
-0.0282135233,
-0.0568375029,
0.0231285207,
-0.0626153722,
0.015862003,
0.0072885221,
0.0183307119,
-0.0516848266,
0.0585121326,
0.025430372,
-0.0110340863,
0.0251263753,
0.0404050127,
-0.0094072307,
0.0432360247,
0.002844915,
0.0022999202,
-0.0271623023,
-0.0346277282,
-0.047333464,
-0.058962509,
-0.0284598824,
0.0125405444,
-0.0587173402,
-0.046460405,
-0.044986587,
0.0337447673,
0.0017069431,
-0.0168389827,
0.0077274265,
0.0069482313,
-0.0576450117,
0.0159929432,
-0.0326736532,
0.0219007842,
-0.0047588502,
-0.0364014022,
0.0096244365,
-0.0088953748,
-0.0227547772,
-0.0025417523,
0.0342016965,
0.0049492856,
-0.0137875751,
0.0239684489,
-0.0371369049,
0.0553938188,
0.0000322531,
-0.0046550962,
-0.0312018823,
0.0104491645,
-0.0076140692,
-0.0337334983,
0.0306808949,
-0.021932561,
0.0313582458,
0.0224461779,
0.0469791889,
-0.0259506386,
-0.0160640534,
-0.0214711409,
-0.058466956,
-0.0694712624,
0.0086710444,
-0.0627423972,
0.0111849634,
0.0160156619,
-0.0123513723,
0.0112210652,
-0.0143969338,
0.0796191618,
0.0516233444,
0.0014060911,
-0.0252511241,
0.0207736194,
-0.0218990259,
0.0543446951,
-0.0481820442,
0.0554413125,
-0.0145106204,
-0.0292516164,
-0.0895707458,
-0.0006600859,
0.007188343,
0.0054187165,
0.049510058,
-0.0269400086,
-0.0410798453,
0.0090310704,
-0.0163837858,
0.0139173204,
0.0479031317,
0.0144138746,
-0.0274836645,
-0.0727165192,
-0.0128026791,
0.0018170015,
0.0603246577,
-0.0127275474,
0.0317115933,
0.0623142496,
0.0029069043,
-0.0767093375,
-0.0160714127,
0.012345993,
-0.0393629409,
-0.0344565995,
-0.0558635108,
-0.0865049064,
0.0290885326,
-0.0016345091,
0.0222910419,
-0.0234850384,
0.0006962557,
-0.0181509163,
0.0756902322,
0.0473932251,
-0.0420891382,
0.0099163316,
0.0505681969,
-0.0135627231,
0.0174520873,
0.070273526,
0.0443231054,
0.0274939314,
0.0178149957,
-0.0281712115,
-0.001654312,
0.0263862014,
0.0034173839,
-0.0246148929,
0.0179936029,
-0.034580268,
-0.0223666485,
-0.0136168553,
0.0652105436,
0.0422446579,
0.0013882259,
-0.0238773972,
0.0445005447,
0.0761030316,
0.0457495004,
0.0114547275,
0.002333317,
0.0458302088,
0.0193163361,
-0.0122153293,
0.0122448877,
0.0235518515,
-0.0205659494,
0.0135662695,
0.1102173477,
0.0591106117,
-0.034688212,
-0.0542346686,
-0.0208725818,
-0.0263968427,
-0.0371925049,
0.0395061709,
0.069277592,
-0.0362624303,
-0.0380444564,
0.057838358,
0.0214836784,
-0.0452838615,
0.0030149012,
-0.0464207642,
0.0341211967,
0.0230239797,
0.0406743325,
-0.0187893417,
0.0200576261,
-0.0284743253,
-0.0395992287,
0.0206124615,
0.0108709428,
0.0373060703,
0.0480705351,
-0.0426813848,
-0.0303377062,
0.0423267372,
-0.0272854455,
0.0117607219,
-0.0229380187,
0.0343846418,
0.0453209355,
-0.0497696288,
-0.0687583685,
0.0088620335,
0.0320905037,
-0.0516506694,
0.0340431668,
0.0269949026,
0.0942552015,
0.0108413892,
-0.027467927,
-0.0032857696,
0.0205044392,
0.0015162478,
-0.0464559533,
0.0302263368,
-0.0862913504,
-0.0672518462,
0.0474867672,
-0.0536514372,
-0.0003325704,
0.0370360166,
0.0155184334,
-0.0846199542,
0.0250639655,
-0.062180236,
0.0059668785,
-0.075898245,
0.0667002201,
0.0279446207,
0.0134000499,
0.0214610416,
-0.003906609,
-0.0055092336,
-0.0095115053,
-0.0199711807,
-0.0000898397,
0.011488853,
-0.046014905,
-0.0353929736,
-0.030108707,
-0.0413870774,
0.039701242,
0.0441162102,
-0.010279051,
-0.0171750672,
-0.0086958203,
-0.0803013444,
-0.0110261319,
-0.0488869995,
0.029917784,
-0.0200701561,
0.0188971944,
0.0063131535,
-0.0395778418,
-0.0240613334,
-0.0265691616,
-0.0234160516,
-0.0276881494,
-0.0605095439,
-0.0072220392,
-0.0119608575,
-0.0361547694,
0.0193198733,
-0.0075745229,
-0.0177419707,
0.0124313915,
-0.0672675967,
-0.0551772602,
0.0198426079,
0.0166491047,
0.0401757173,
0.0269126724,
-0.0351527818,
0.0128861908,
-0.0103486655,
0.0193328429,
-0.0174469631,
0.0105705578,
0.0099276938,
0.0480239391,
0.004984342,
-0.0508247502,
0.0048467806,
0.002238086,
0.0074284035,
0.0291448273,
0.0201361608,
-0.0207761861,
0.0218116455,
0.051250264,
0.0202393699,
-0.0184482019,
-0.0423490033,
-0.0098012574,
-0.0394287705,
-0.0356639214,
-0.0334296823,
0.0333505906,
-0.0262496676,
0.0009224172,
-0.0566911474,
0.0292937569,
-0.0945153907,
-0.0254492443,
-0.0420059338,
-0.0712092072,
-0.0243671015,
-0.031073451,
-0.0157525353,
0.0040601981,
-0.0395120345,
-0.0602469929,
0.0305300951,
0.0274773668,
0.0263319407,
-0.0664399713,
0.0299457498,
-0.040039327,
0.0358637497,
0.0062838094,
-0.0212922674,
-0.0242289454,
-0.0412278809,
-0.020636538,
0.0141026108,
-0.0225255769,
-0.0095848646,
0.0033928473,
0.0338582322,
0.0138292946,
0.0801444575,
0.0000163966,
-0.0291519053,
-0.0359527469,
0.0278243646,
0.0143877091,
0.0295835044,
-0.0138556305,
-0.0090250084,
0.0821937621,
0.010082257,
0.0639308617,
0.0432380699,
-0.0591217503,
-0.0081454124,
0.0011191822,
-0.0068614027,
0.0572174639,
0.0312647857,
0.0374924354,
-0.0304532181,
-0.0100380052,
0.1319411099,
0.0085509317,
-0.0317821652,
-0.0447139218,
-0.0116479844,
-0.0385565348,
0.0170052908,
-0.0114979558,
0.0083721839,
-0.0186021365,
0.0237236563,
0.0576299764,
0.0010174351,
0.0092127249,
0.0058421968,
-0.088756904,
0.033162158,
0.0263685342,
-0.0225455333,
-0.0471132398,
-0.0716164857,
-0.0319395959,
-0.0474274904,
0.0507517196,
0.0115895886,
0.0047934833,
-0.0220832862,
0.0504237451,
-0.0904710814,
-0.0409578457,
0.0075114216,
-0.0264214966,
0.0476773381,
0.0550867766,
0.0080393916,
-0.0302847847,
-0.0438210294,
0.0126417996,
-0.0140099386,
-0.0169695336,
-0.0140633751,
0.0550958887,
-0.0003531436,
-0.0290584639,
0.0039695897,
0.032940641,
0.0065277871,
0.0452427417,
-0.0012959335,
0.0195086487,
-0.0373476259,
0.0193249304,
0.019895738,
-0.0052025495,
-0.012354278,
0.0419575348,
0.0288735777,
-0.007086324,
0.0255715698,
0.0490126424,
0.044837404,
-0.0066733668,
-0.0369111449,
0.0289787743,
0.0108618643,
-0.0469907746,
-0.0277053174,
-0.03073599,
0.031884212,
0.0402446762,
-0.0188328698,
0.0358405523,
0.0050151059,
0.0184669867,
-0.0365259014,
-0.0248213559,
-0.0277460944,
0.0030041279,
-0.0647976622,
-0.0145830503,
0.0267629549,
-0.0033227282,
-0.0098982397,
0.0193734728,
-0.0177068617,
-0.0300034843,
0.0199948102,
0.022224525,
0.004866845,
-0.0006055906,
-0.0463888645,
-0.0213878378,
0.0917631388,
0.0409167968,
-0.0520288236,
0.0174824726,
0.0011824304,
0.0008594763,
-0.0214895513,
0.0069051771,
-0.0453306995,
0.0461093076,
-0.048923973,
-0.0022838896,
-0.0105472524,
-0.0706910044,
0.0432284772,
0.052240856,
0.0754521638,
-0.0141554717,
0.038530305,
-0.0202741809,
0.0387090109,
0.0060694246,
0.0401472673,
-0.0214218199,
0.0361339077,
-0.0132992696,
-0.0267935544,
-0.0101611074,
0.0346571207,
-0.0246681012,
-0.0636541471,
-0.0090403073,
0.0375014842,
0.0115760174,
0.0043912092,
-0.0283079762,
0.0200612508,
-0.0013568894,
-0.0019291019,
0.0759665295,
0.0041285497,
0.0215672776,
0.0167233422,
-0.0318541229,
0.0238363165,
0.0515988991,
0.0254114941,
-0.0360621214,
-0.0157250743,
-0.0542616621,
0.0366112851,
0.0277048741,
-0.0284375418,
0.0414148159,
-0.000518019,
0.0516417474,
-0.0863891914,
0.0419391617,
-0.0176968109,
0.0268357713,
0.0139751183,
0.0056890356,
-0.0228181388,
0.0304289218,
0.0453548133,
0.020548515,
-0.0015243122,
0.0106560476,
-0.0166866723,
-0.0416565314,
-0.006954663,
-0.0350471959,
-0.0048855375,
-0.0400112867,
-0.0119288862,
-0.0013471972,
-0.0728477314,
0.0537761748,
0.0094139976,
0.0442220233,
0.0072123646,
-0.0128042689,
0.0206461456,
-0.0541976467,
0.0412371904,
-0.0009757361,
-0.0272376593,
-0.0089288624,
0.0150080733,
0.0225051139,
-6.964798151e-33,
-0.0332958363,
-0.04806678,
-0.0126082012,
-0.0456016846,
0.0034406306,
0.0571991839,
0.0071290499,
0.0335737094,
0.0469581969,
-0.012116868,
-0.0142654553,
0.0034763422,
0.0460509323,
-0.0143356882,
-0.0230263192,
0.0401889309,
0.0893250704,
-0.0159049816,
-0.0198562481,
-0.0460208468,
0.0493987612,
0.0497549661,
0.046062313,
-0.0733553171,
-0.0602228753,
0.0588107556,
-0.0297000911,
-0.058565259,
0.0386476703,
0.0240014941,
0.0272853952,
0.0520488769,
-0.0179434232,
0.0017135295,
-0.0451340936,
-0.0054540117,
-0.0798149481,
-0.0170016922,
-0.0431914777,
0.0563584119,
0.0044457992,
0.0267745592,
0.0469862968,
0.0110052899,
-0.0698107779,
-0.0084917145,
0.0341849513,
0.0035030178,
-0.043944627,
-0.066060707,
0.0169743001,
0.0569309033,
-0.0165238269,
-0.0136243077,
0.1136543602,
-0.0194224063,
-0.0127780726,
-0.0420149639,
-0.0823202282,
-0.0153218061,
-0.0153722344,
0.0660888627,
-0.0010733281,
-0.026973458,
-0.0247486997,
0.0516674966,
0.0355885252,
-0.0358526818,
0.0266212523,
-0.0632884055,
0.0591979325,
-0.0023730118,
0.0166877098,
0.0085600549,
0.0531917699,
-0.0168305598,
-0.0670227781,
0.0504739732,
0.010189916,
0.0480447337,
0.0233722143,
0.0337286182,
-0.0819970816,
0.0078326529,
-0.033784233,
0.0030031186,
-0.052456066,
-0.015768636,
0.0476910658,
0.031276416,
-0.0155779477,
-0.0048585911,
0.0199976638,
-0.0195528548,
0.0285655446,
-0.0048123999,
0.009680138,
-0.0103763361,
-0.0118389735,
0.0182179715,
-0.0176587291,
-0.0046269754,
0.0249119774,
0.0713285878,
0.024363257,
-0.0396087281,
0.0054112123,
0.0706001967,
-0.0704870671,
-0.0017912232,
-0.0194511544,
-0.0148759605,
-0.0104501564,
-0.0447663106,
0.0437980592,
-0.0312426835,
-0.0179818347,
0.0072449441,
-0.0364038236,
-0.0053644334,
0.0098058684,
0.0167911649,
0.0136936028,
0.0346025154,
-0.0214933734,
-0.0094110165,
0.0015071218,
-0.0150755132,
0.044209905,
0.0004871294,
-0.0050971825,
-0.0123124765,
3.155e-7,
-0.0342031457,
0.0312812403,
0.0421218202,
-0.0345855094,
-0.0295094457,
0.0034102052,
-0.0126643078,
0.0076767593,
-0.0065848934,
0.0086211711,
0.0391925126,
0.0082571814,
0.0652870089,
0.0319112241,
-0.0676839277,
-0.0082514398,
-0.0848869383,
0.0664017051,
0.0247381125,
-0.0014013916,
0.0235398244,
0.070238173,
-0.0090330401,
-0.0498623662,
0.0015533394,
-0.0057115238,
0.0354092233,
0.0059739514,
0.0049356618,
-0.0188619029,
0.0293629598,
0.0459490083,
-0.0225714277,
0.006531463,
-0.0411895066,
0.0597863495,
0.0156278946,
0.0106510771,
-0.0192583632,
-0.0347164832,
0.0484950952,
0.0641280934,
0.0040752855,
0.0469730608,
0.0354075357,
0.0150247123,
-0.0158112291,
-0.0345653817,
-0.0066383607,
0.0415306948,
0.0177438352,
0.012840339,
-0.000198106,
0.0132352822,
-0.0028442547,
-0.0305860564,
-0.0120072616,
-0.0640740767,
0.0084638633,
-0.0047099986,
-0.0131763425,
-0.0220345315,
-0.0390529782,
0.0148985218,
0.0373404101,
-0.0226467587,
0.0345367752,
2.491621677e-34,
0.0291020423,
-0.0174218267,
0.0151179582,
0.0233433452,
0.0173067767,
-0.0245648269,
0.0166804865,
-0.0081375595,
-0.0185650196,
-0.0618531257,
-0.0293656532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10679v1 | Large language models can replicate cross-cultural differences in personality | 2023-10-12T11:17:23 | 2023-10-12T11:17:23 | Paweł Niszczota, Mateusz Janczak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, I.2.7; K.4.2; J.4 | We use a large-scale experiment (N=8000) to determine whether GPT-4 can
replicate cross-cultural differences in the Big Five, measured using the
Ten-Item Personality Inventory. We used the US and South Korea as the cultural
pair, given that prior research suggests substantial personality differences
between people from these two countries. We manipulated the target of the
simulation (US vs. Korean), the language of the inventory (English vs. Korean),
and the language model (GPT-4 vs. GPT-3.5). Our results show that GPT-4
replicated the cross-cultural differences for each factor. However, mean
ratings had an upward bias and exhibited lower variation than in the human
samples, as well as lower structural validity. Overall, we provide preliminary
evidence that LLMs can aid cross-cultural psychological research. | [
0.0142551847,
0.0567011461,
-0.0499633737,
0.0007896794,
-0.0259594116,
0.0289953351,
0.0513230972,
0.0177154168,
0.0425477102,
0.0203361697,
-0.0612277724,
-0.0385405086,
-0.0136311585,
-0.0074469964,
0.0367832817,
-0.0500769503,
0.0290579405,
-0.0000123116,
0.0429288745,
-0.0306653325,
-0.0337166116,
0.0134264668,
0.0499749072,
0.0119478349,
0.028558366,
-0.0019601968,
0.0335250981,
-0.0183975883,
0.0348117016,
-0.0582031719,
-0.0173161048,
0.0342800431,
0.0180716962,
0.0078010694,
0.0000020573,
-0.0395925604,
0.0121288067,
-0.0037102662,
0.0354160368,
0.0428896546,
0.065274328,
0.0088819778,
-0.0075919502,
0.0060544186,
-0.0322738998,
-0.0478487127,
-0.0094579635,
0.0315420404,
-0.0113070635,
0.0128594358,
0.008803037,
-0.0080630025,
-0.0372247025,
-0.0252247844,
0.0208552349,
-0.0016974425,
0.0322241411,
0.021872811,
-0.0104646469,
-0.0022944985,
-0.0366707444,
-0.0391753949,
0.002902953,
0.0359917656,
-0.0631989911,
-0.0027056567,
-0.0281486753,
0.0103307497,
0.0450761802,
0.0292657614,
0.0510660261,
-0.010862153,
-0.009909139,
-0.0169928595,
0.0337355398,
0.0152003337,
0.0022484672,
0.0453330241,
0.0006780541,
-0.0208123028,
0.067270048,
-0.0270958915,
0.0049253223,
-0.0249064956,
0.021989733,
0.0810339451,
0.0179670881,
-0.0439226925,
-0.0176971219,
-0.010378005,
-0.0097148782,
-0.0497806966,
-0.0014533146,
-0.0208405461,
0.0176128112,
0.0051830611,
0.0240861215,
0.0547344685,
0.0286635365,
-0.0291234646,
-0.0083943019,
0.0748373196,
-0.0351052731,
-0.0390648507,
0.040308442,
0.089217566,
-0.0117572211,
0.0287443865,
-0.0469999276,
-0.0036460671,
-0.0533940569,
0.0258443728,
0.0827137008,
-0.0269360207,
0.019547848,
0.0327917002,
-0.1511666179,
-0.0024517037,
-0.0107654072,
0.0069132433,
-0.0071395822,
-0.0872056186,
0.0022482893,
0.031496305,
-0.0444446169,
0.0463407971,
-0.0491788872,
-0.0102784289,
-0.0282836724,
-0.0410090685,
0.0533796325,
-0.0118394159,
-0.0306218043,
-0.024896428,
0.0342912972,
-0.0021715758,
0.0245011654,
0.0127732586,
-0.0253035259,
0.0302150771,
-0.0234719496,
-0.0604200587,
0.0453651771,
-0.0494940691,
0.0057080775,
0.0268677752,
0.0009399921,
-0.0365456641,
0.013369808,
0.0172246005,
-0.0318063945,
0.0163571034,
0.0453489572,
0.0415253341,
0.0174853541,
0.0183179788,
0.0083350064,
0.007127854,
-0.0131758712,
-0.0170744453,
0.0434873998,
-0.0585377179,
-0.0019686061,
0.0399463885,
-0.0373990797,
0.0601086058,
-0.0115207927,
-0.0130194956,
0.0379499309,
-0.0222552046,
0.0308499187,
0.0072391368,
-0.0175580159,
0.0518388301,
0.0466725789,
0.0879952386,
0.0050691171,
0.0723037496,
0.0007986639,
0.0297372304,
-0.0031436346,
0.0165678188,
-0.0554240979,
-0.0026604838,
-0.0335233063,
0.0246301871,
-0.0142839607,
0.0452179722,
-0.0352198519,
0.0126524288,
-0.022685593,
-0.0150656225,
0.0523766316,
0.0355292596,
-0.0140220365,
-0.0493358895,
0.0432767831,
-0.0010358263,
0.0449712388,
-0.0226277076,
-0.0410233028,
-0.0313717313,
0.0039991247,
0.0547137558,
-0.0482275896,
0.0247431006,
0.0308118425,
-0.0118355704,
0.0070512188,
0.0223020278,
0.0353389643,
0.0271188635,
-0.0310281087,
-0.0133400289,
0.0023646522,
0.0066068224,
-0.0090456959,
0.0265868027,
0.0183011033,
0.0659316555,
-0.0092264125,
0.012318668,
0.0097325202,
-0.0274924394,
-0.0883670077,
-0.0134325149,
-0.0042296695,
-0.0259283707,
0.0670383796,
-0.0010513006,
-0.0136762504,
-0.0180341285,
-0.0351571031,
0.0006641729,
-0.0108908592,
0.0481350906,
-0.0199129619,
0.0192006305,
-0.0082649542,
-0.0132666687,
0.0091687636,
0.0070174914,
0.0281584077,
0.0305470414,
0.0253637582,
0.0393072665,
0.0448217578,
0.0018952446,
-0.0000964688,
-0.0565201044,
0.0588593408,
0.0089672711,
0.0194403324,
-0.0335376859,
0.0342913568,
-0.0055244975,
0.0095448615,
0.0067984299,
-0.0313568078,
-0.0256387573,
0.0323561132,
0.0393599309,
-0.0002629914,
0.0005066416,
0.0356638767,
-0.0521461666,
-0.0500169508,
-0.0623559654,
0.0249411222,
0.0288873203,
0.0133122997,
0.0234065317,
-0.0156243835,
-0.0613979436,
0.0196322016,
-0.0654190853,
-0.0068869735,
0.0996950045,
0.076761812,
0.0005469238,
-0.0312866718,
-0.0146290008,
-0.0059457202,
-0.0295978356,
-0.0298203807,
-0.0225203652,
-0.0252182465,
0.023333868,
-0.021819124,
0.0189264007,
-0.0785425231,
-0.0352545418,
-0.0302649494,
-0.0811152086,
0.0135543523,
0.0408808701,
0.0744904652,
0.0253588948,
-0.0137380119,
0.0061804275,
0.0610979088,
-0.0164664201,
0.0009584263,
-0.0442491882,
0.0195755474,
-0.0290136579,
-0.0299796127,
-0.14628613,
-0.0671602786,
0.0185127873,
0.0147676365,
0.0247117952,
0.0035426186,
0.019224586,
-0.0359149501,
-0.0382287316,
0.0462226383,
0.0132476594,
-0.0200176705,
0.0606235377,
-0.0034043719,
-0.0191902313,
0.0181067176,
0.0230587684,
0.0067187259,
-0.0165655203,
-0.0025848285,
-0.0229220539,
0.0240080543,
0.0039566942,
-0.0369970985,
0.0166584458,
0.0137880044,
-0.0071738129,
-0.050860092,
0.0120615605,
-0.0466588028,
0.0235281456,
-0.0118416697,
-0.0787552893,
-0.0337965377,
-0.0135830604,
-0.0148713551,
0.0112439133,
-0.0142662451,
0.0206679497,
0.0035321815,
0.0109511157,
0.0063120485,
-0.0290314313,
0.0840406492,
-0.0338266343,
-0.0371628813,
0.0316183791,
0.0244413745,
-0.0389271043,
0.0268955864,
-0.0157591067,
0.0282325465,
-0.0989771336,
0.0157806966,
-0.044980377,
-0.0308070369,
-0.0043148762,
0.0331244059,
0.0520363934,
0.0116290487,
0.0513219014,
-0.0362413153,
0.0162554421,
0.0453048609,
0.0014085877,
0.0440200344,
0.0927089676,
-0.0143633764,
-0.0123993065,
-0.0127178272,
-0.0303320326,
0.0012157349,
0.0492892675,
0.0427476428,
-0.0297873057,
0.0389857441,
-0.0035617899,
-0.0057937033,
-0.0460585169,
-0.0131698158,
-0.0139029184,
-0.0813460648,
0.0247648824,
0.0207129382,
-0.0442295671,
-0.0152445994,
0.0006518623,
0.0055733146,
0.0037144551,
0.040854089,
-0.0269597229,
0.0181648321,
-0.0054088659,
-0.056641262,
-0.0537474565,
-0.0225488674,
0.0692201182,
-0.0345005766,
0.0094559565,
-0.0355769992,
0.051867079,
-0.0067889355,
-0.08002951,
-0.0378521606,
0.0021919527,
-0.0179029088,
0.0144761968,
-0.0002118275,
0.0268664286,
0.004596612,
-0.0833261013,
-0.0245925877,
-0.0040341667,
0.029556673,
-0.0025554732,
0.0276032351,
0.03384085,
-0.0595518388,
0.0414595306,
0.0047698063,
-0.0063536852,
0.027124824,
-0.0269497186,
-0.0756045878,
0.0297528114,
-0.0301307701,
-0.022466749,
0.0365946926,
-0.1091835797,
0.0170200747,
-0.0352959707,
0.011986034,
-0.0155594051,
-0.0764134526,
-0.0182307642,
-0.0227746107,
0.0274282545,
-0.028624272,
-0.0158158988,
-0.009876702,
0.0128887109,
-0.0028856625,
-0.0244610999,
0.0011596724,
0.0138239618,
-0.0158379283,
0.0362352952,
-0.0405865125,
0.0155265117,
-0.0191430543,
-0.0358928554,
0.0084685227,
0.0458320193,
-0.0107215112,
0.0071169436,
0.0037126618,
0.0543921068,
0.0281539764,
-0.0327353403,
-0.0453767702,
0.007373054,
0.0494203977,
-0.0423415005,
0.0833183229,
0.0241797473,
0.0064446186,
-0.0073299087,
0.0417997316,
0.0599445179,
-0.0126564912,
-0.0254117791,
-0.0729370862,
0.0203505587,
0.0705443844,
-0.0182828624,
-0.0330054723,
0.0117093381,
-0.0113307126,
-0.0447238423,
-0.0770248547,
0.0072717615,
0.0251731779,
-0.0830932111,
0.0328294933,
-0.0046792957,
-0.0010870559,
0.0016168249,
-0.0126085076,
0.0014352867,
-0.0672437325,
0.0665243939,
-0.0122628873,
0.0588801764,
-0.025241524,
0.0328238308,
-0.0051256618,
-0.0023481704,
-0.0075199483,
0.0511290878,
-0.0236167442,
0.1039148197,
-0.0389574617,
-0.0346605442,
0.0289085414,
0.004099342,
-0.0389776789,
-0.0407478884,
0.0325659998,
0.0000721418,
0.0113530979,
-0.016544966,
0.0363244489,
-0.0358527526,
-0.0012322647,
-0.0569554716,
0.0087306006,
-0.0196612738,
-0.0260029268,
0.0189592447,
-0.0122448727,
-0.0225973409,
-0.0039271275,
-0.0080610076,
0.0404680446,
-0.0383216515,
0.002669513,
-0.056848336,
-0.030138107,
0.0135847069,
0.0362627357,
0.0050351419,
-0.0493013635,
-0.0268181823,
-0.0769763663,
-0.0717111006,
-0.0176321175,
0.0071097976,
-0.0031258266,
-0.0031359666,
-0.0372089036,
0.0340154655,
-0.0496977717,
-0.0377778038,
-0.033357136,
0.0105041936,
-0.0120882075,
-0.0268699843,
0.0405006893,
-6.161222866e-33,
-0.0179596227,
0.003684883,
0.0326921754,
0.0225582197,
-0.0240186788,
-0.0553023592,
-0.0149861537,
0.0397424102,
-0.0296407156,
-0.0084314719,
-0.0476412922,
-0.0081359893,
0.0147567606,
-0.0340215228,
0.0432734638,
0.0197564047,
0.0030668112,
-0.0074318224,
0.01313587,
-0.0171274263,
-0.0016698772,
-0.0035614732,
0.1123519167,
-0.0301422123,
0.0198758878,
-0.024156943,
0.0256032087,
-0.0487628877,
0.0227838214,
0.0281568374,
-0.0276797172,
0.0361848548,
0.0474770069,
-0.0382776,
-0.007004933,
-0.0290758945,
-0.0109560052,
-0.0165900178,
0.0173389912,
-0.0037371507,
0.0446397737,
-0.055847045,
-0.0142251858,
-0.0120737385,
-0.0771294534,
-0.001887158,
0.0149718188,
-0.0486435704,
0.0360237472,
0.0439549498,
-0.021831885,
0.0072215679,
0.02060798,
0.073957555,
-0.0122658461,
0.0379825421,
-0.0603948236,
0.0447159223,
-0.0307557099,
0.0336888917,
0.0013574035,
0.0025932775,
0.0067762993,
-0.0078165783,
0.0339954682,
0.017971769,
0.079467006,
0.056994956,
0.0063668378,
-0.0648267716,
0.0402992778,
0.0038411871,
0.009969187,
0.1105628163,
0.0154360207,
-0.0825061053,
-0.0265394468,
-0.0284300931,
0.0801226646,
-0.0548834205,
0.0319770053,
0.0432278886,
0.0126911914,
-0.0331050716,
0.0021917014,
0.0000320517,
-0.0069184066,
-0.0579309464,
0.0302033853,
-0.0209348723,
0.0463642217,
-0.0202401131,
0.0872795433,
-0.0067149205,
-0.0222393703,
-0.0171842575,
-0.032662224,
0.0008929134,
0.0010428807,
-0.032807868,
-0.0472984128,
-0.0091994097,
-0.0510365255,
0.040152166,
0.0304156803,
0.0220497232,
-0.0150948092,
-0.0122378711,
-0.0590146966,
0.0130824894,
-0.0046745231,
-0.0245860834,
0.0390328914,
-0.0349405892,
0.0159323476,
-0.0096924789,
0.0346295722,
-0.0273755584,
0.0523717776,
-0.0218347739,
-0.0782405362,
-0.0053311163,
-0.0063184598,
0.0318152495,
0.0087026302,
0.0125004482,
-0.0302280374,
0.0641967803,
0.0475364663,
-0.0224238392,
-0.0022146881,
-0.0259707905,
2.806e-7,
-0.0564930625,
0.0710754693,
-0.0367670022,
0.0471033491,
0.0504780449,
0.0166135449,
-0.0536017828,
-0.0132755404,
0.0931413993,
-0.0147416238,
0.0018694127,
0.0036061429,
0.0438861251,
0.0462209061,
-0.0369881168,
0.0499070622,
0.0000535936,
0.0003110323,
-0.0227536689,
0.023810206,
-0.0096934438,
0.0228398982,
0.0104456889,
-0.0007532884,
-0.0495977104,
0.0130686658,
0.0278884191,
-0.0571857914,
-0.0524391904,
0.0012581281,
-0.0390268229,
-0.0232271459,
0.0098311957,
0.0664518103,
0.0026513841,
0.0006831042,
0.0235300772,
0.0507171266,
0.0096987495,
0.0362578817,
-0.0006118036,
0.0078878039,
-0.0166876819,
-0.0643433034,
0.0170763545,
0.0108096572,
-0.0258519221,
0.0016246089,
-0.0076428638,
-0.0151089309,
0.0668359026,
-0.0055924179,
0.0040132073,
0.0410772301,
0.0450997651,
0.0225568265,
0.0311129279,
0.0472472757,
0.0182342865,
0.0073250774,
-0.0304210316,
-0.0613688119,
-0.0330119058,
0.0198872201,
-0.0128589189,
0.0107134879,
-0.0072048493,
2.664840413e-34,
0.0138869081,
0.024189353,
0.0252973009,
-0.0572744757,
0.0506206267,
0.0180992614,
0.0010898074,
0.0105196657,
0.0065677636,
-0.0169044062,
-0.0127388481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08221v1 | SimCKP: Simple Contrastive Learning of Keyphrase Representations | 2023-10-12T11:11:54 | 2023-10-12T11:11:54 | Minseok Choi, Chaeheon Gwak, Seho Kim, Si Hyeong Kim, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Keyphrase generation (KG) aims to generate a set of summarizing words or
phrases given a source document, while keyphrase extraction (KE) aims to
identify them from the text. Because the search space is much smaller in KE, it
is often combined with KG to predict keyphrases that may or may not exist in
the corresponding document. However, current unified approaches adopt sequence
labeling and maximization-based generation that primarily operate at a token
level, falling short in observing and scoring keyphrases as a whole. In this
work, we propose SimCKP, a simple contrastive learning framework that consists
of two stages: 1) An extractor-generator that extracts keyphrases by learning
context-aware phrase-level representations in a contrastive manner while also
generating keyphrases that do not appear in the document; 2) A reranker that
adapts scores for each generated phrase by likewise aligning their
representations with the corresponding document. Experimental results on
multiple benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed
approach, which outperforms the state-of-the-art models by a significant
margin. | [
0.0737355649,
0.0082665132,
0.0196841247,
-0.012327414,
-0.0530995466,
0.0082944073,
-0.0295245051,
-0.0078456793,
0.0372608043,
-0.0519823059,
0.0135644237,
0.0120565454,
-0.0252746996,
0.0467282347,
0.017575385,
-0.0775341243,
0.0221614335,
0.0010246409,
0.0220616441,
-0.0123133957,
0.015075204,
0.0218120497,
0.0076667992,
0.0368882753,
0.0457343087,
-0.0151805449,
-0.0150384139,
-0.0472082831,
0.0588076562,
-0.0218810067,
0.0609293282,
0.0145955412,
0.0175877735,
0.0216671154,
0.0000018033,
-0.0473743603,
-0.0377758257,
-0.0212046262,
0.0449076965,
0.0305669643,
0.1089323312,
-0.0219625402,
0.0184004512,
0.0403866321,
-0.0407987945,
0.0142419795,
0.0207347125,
0.055613827,
0.0524049439,
0.0499346144,
-0.0227600951,
-0.090474695,
0.0078296093,
-0.0385095477,
-0.0138330776,
-0.0427562743,
-0.0003841365,
-0.0425247103,
-0.0451048538,
0.0192554127,
0.0202139243,
0.0273284372,
0.0061754878,
0.0166571736,
0.1024496108,
0.0497937724,
-0.0659554824,
-0.0001389223,
-0.0379767083,
0.0701851249,
-0.0350351185,
0.0158876181,
0.0611722283,
-0.0432414263,
0.011020815,
0.012636642,
-0.0465044715,
0.0071302145,
-0.0167994779,
0.0138787879,
0.0491317883,
0.0323216356,
-0.0184680969,
0.0190135017,
-0.0448517874,
-0.0421348624,
0.0361033864,
-0.0112397559,
-0.0322010852,
-0.0075958376,
-0.0768020824,
-0.0539707802,
0.0096422359,
0.0114804544,
-0.0085222526,
0.0159965139,
-0.0214728918,
-0.0303977616,
0.0863188952,
-0.0787751898,
-0.0105761131,
-0.0222963039,
0.012670191,
0.0504489094,
-0.0291862674,
0.0446745493,
0.0233179666,
0.0050387196,
-0.040501982,
0.0001176606,
-0.0258974005,
0.0028742822,
0.0188074838,
0.0552766547,
-0.0004528216,
-0.03145786,
-0.0492357351,
0.0078007467,
0.0163923558,
0.0152330175,
-0.000095996,
0.0625503361,
-0.0310352631,
0.0124510042,
0.0071245255,
-0.0041475459,
-0.0176509116,
0.0048405575,
0.0011748264,
-0.0042039617,
-0.0153616956,
-0.0012134372,
0.0417301729,
-0.0054382207,
0.0371738113,
0.0281811915,
-0.0176870767,
-0.050736919,
0.0035706633,
-0.032234747,
-0.0309728459,
-0.001332534,
0.0071859248,
-0.0733475611,
0.0183244441,
0.0171225499,
-0.0107775163,
-0.0111038582,
0.0250719171,
0.0391351581,
-0.0521615148,
0.0283169951,
0.0115990052,
-0.0372088403,
0.0015442085,
0.0061606499,
-0.0236354303,
0.0198934134,
0.0147923911,
0.0564180128,
0.0407695025,
-0.0029543298,
0.0101850629,
-0.0042496258,
0.0304061398,
-0.001639741,
0.0063989493,
0.0005286189,
-0.0040501864,
-0.0078670345,
-0.0039441683,
0.0215169676,
-0.0038910639,
0.0057328301,
0.0207317863,
0.088259995,
0.0143760182,
0.0267937072,
-0.0101412274,
0.0504013672,
-0.0189391132,
0.0367302336,
0.0220513046,
0.0113751357,
0.0166085064,
0.0503544994,
0.0863019899,
0.054077331,
-0.0006105704,
-0.0448797531,
-0.0217767358,
0.026584791,
-0.0272075944,
-0.0238424316,
0.0521354266,
0.0236909408,
-0.0650106817,
0.0456720777,
0.0086562783,
-0.0601129979,
-0.0237194765,
-0.0231940951,
-0.0051214164,
0.0584439933,
0.066254057,
-0.0248294938,
-0.0180978104,
0.0048454823,
-0.0104202917,
0.050027214,
0.0098411748,
-0.0122476984,
-0.0063342685,
-0.0523242317,
-0.0445708521,
-0.0540528558,
0.0191346426,
-0.0159612186,
0.0156949591,
-0.0082256291,
0.0371765681,
-0.0045448053,
-0.0179359503,
0.0127797574,
-0.0058210329,
-0.0390962549,
0.006725444,
-0.0339739434,
0.0163224973,
0.030189354,
-0.0050758501,
0.0264972188,
0.054604467,
-0.0513316579,
-0.0056466111,
0.0136527559,
-0.0246382449,
-0.0449158959,
0.0411491729,
-0.058495786,
0.0246241838,
0.024707891,
-0.0617558695,
-0.0271159727,
0.0572303608,
-0.0603806078,
0.0592636093,
-0.0287024193,
0.000376478,
0.0013607503,
0.0216285679,
-0.0327631161,
0.1246250719,
-0.0080101825,
0.0143636353,
-0.0294004604,
-0.0071629398,
-0.025078997,
0.0071147135,
-0.0004716489,
-0.0082117021,
0.0107780937,
-0.0058024498,
0.0339396261,
0.0019667554,
-0.0469507724,
-0.0142571162,
-0.0772714764,
0.0139897587,
0.0144745242,
0.0053012613,
0.0465246625,
0.009422252,
0.0096023697,
-0.0256469008,
-0.053787753,
-0.0522165149,
0.0105729606,
-0.0065045431,
0.025693465,
0.0169701166,
0.0164958779,
-0.0255542565,
0.0149407201,
-0.0080224136,
0.0540222526,
0.0120288869,
-0.012266227,
0.0379316881,
0.0860731974,
0.0065623815,
-0.051457148,
0.0049665566,
0.0032801866,
-0.0088733993,
-0.011663273,
0.0480723009,
-0.00575116,
0.0693410635,
0.0100576458,
-0.0066831675,
-0.0354434066,
-0.0515973233,
-0.0278580189,
-0.0305983182,
0.0015086931,
0.0584683307,
-0.0375132598,
0.0356466584,
0.0630460456,
0.0237473659,
0.012137929,
-0.0526412427,
0.0461624637,
0.0080384519,
0.0151317464,
-0.0543436073,
0.034122888,
-0.0083896117,
-0.0070689349,
-0.0396063104,
-0.0138565842,
0.0489656404,
0.0086634504,
0.0250489935,
-0.0722360089,
-0.0142424507,
-0.0537517183,
0.0314583778,
-0.038977813,
0.0005325657,
0.0137096802,
-0.0150454473,
0.007686459,
-0.0500551909,
0.0080167633,
-0.0769167766,
0.0491474122,
-0.0316377133,
-0.0256578866,
-0.0143171083,
-0.0094494093,
-0.0395551734,
-0.0350490026,
-0.017651571,
-0.0065631396,
0.0381530896,
-0.0151201179,
-0.0001676365,
0.0042451974,
0.0150243947,
0.0514462441,
-0.0194486044,
-0.0211332012,
0.0155663732,
0.06875588,
0.0761028454,
-0.0465271696,
0.0157822203,
-0.0165270399,
0.0454366617,
0.0621531978,
0.0797061175,
-0.0269308835,
0.0071430095,
-0.0001033452,
0.0096528335,
-0.0372845866,
0.0046098256,
-0.0280725695,
-0.0052391984,
-0.0212765783,
-0.0189301036,
0.0895499438,
0.0514696091,
-0.0627413616,
-0.0074752895,
-0.0027468309,
0.0001411237,
0.0012787116,
0.0003451111,
-0.0407027602,
-0.0216583442,
-0.0264660604,
0.0383866876,
-0.0199434273,
-0.028948646,
-0.026469864,
-0.0889208838,
0.0371171832,
0.0187223982,
-0.0350631215,
-0.0215454437,
-0.045470573,
-0.0217077751,
-0.0361484736,
-0.0478236899,
0.0101392446,
-0.0605661646,
0.0382594094,
-0.0028361019,
-0.0404549278,
-0.0231091455,
0.0266525075,
-0.0583688617,
-0.0234487616,
0.0591638424,
0.0314421095,
-0.0053882343,
-0.0247924328,
-0.0319960564,
-0.0452376381,
-0.0190278664,
-0.0048528626,
0.0071922508,
-0.0230724383,
0.0001096555,
-0.0376918055,
0.0316704027,
-0.017889671,
-0.0381499529,
0.0455857664,
0.0075396565,
0.0204071011,
0.0086326217,
-0.042919632,
0.0267911423,
-0.0297952928,
0.0710706487,
0.0347228013,
-0.0098127257,
-0.0245068464,
-0.0085335597,
0.0547963493,
-0.1021535173,
-0.0222442579,
-0.0522009358,
-0.0348017849,
0.0462745838,
-0.0720398873,
-0.0477146283,
0.0179586858,
-0.0336860009,
-0.0164223071,
0.0246648639,
-0.0679553151,
-0.0238189455,
-0.0887897611,
-0.0196330585,
0.0135522913,
-0.0308456235,
0.0060933209,
-0.0333250761,
0.0672634393,
-0.0412865356,
-0.0504628494,
0.0158016328,
-0.0160496943,
-0.0464689918,
0.0207922459,
0.0289266389,
0.0121305324,
0.0109199956,
0.0072471309,
0.0058053723,
0.0848746747,
0.0930858403,
-0.0229900535,
-0.0012009485,
0.0256220773,
0.0125398729,
0.0039794669,
0.0118272332,
-0.075402528,
0.0050749099,
-0.0115162442,
0.0555367172,
-0.0445528328,
-0.0167579148,
0.0004811237,
-0.0074545406,
0.0404669605,
-0.0493319295,
-0.0174137652,
-0.0315873586,
-0.017961638,
0.0300390664,
-0.0033618677,
-0.0312268753,
0.0566332005,
-0.006602027,
0.0044281892,
-0.0105609493,
0.0721484497,
-0.0533926785,
0.0230380055,
-0.0329532996,
-0.0010606082,
0.0257184543,
-0.0326820612,
-0.0495725684,
-0.005225379,
-0.0340642966,
-0.031064095,
-0.0199334417,
0.0206809696,
0.0132019361,
0.0044893334,
0.0001503593,
-0.0193758998,
-0.0305346213,
0.0715458542,
-0.1004601941,
0.0084698629,
-0.07665883,
-0.0302099269,
0.0685847923,
-0.0197201204,
0.0078587867,
-0.0024618779,
-0.020151617,
0.0058769132,
0.0484143347,
-0.0062399078,
-0.0180439577,
-0.0454855263,
0.0349913165,
-0.0077071087,
0.015620674,
0.077611275,
0.007756358,
0.0453534685,
-0.002218639,
-0.0285278969,
-0.0282667466,
0.0062292246,
0.028573161,
0.0429422818,
0.0199561864,
-0.0054746671,
-0.0482297689,
-0.0349338353,
0.0889926776,
0.005004148,
0.0331041329,
0.0062216818,
0.0288848002,
0.0462345742,
-0.012778216,
-0.0270615201,
-0.0893952325,
0.0439993925,
-0.0250276551,
-0.0202905014,
0.010898619,
-6.352672692e-33,
-0.0131625254,
-0.0298786853,
-0.0299964007,
0.0175620355,
0.0227512661,
0.0216425061,
-0.0276517123,
-0.0558930337,
0.0416270085,
-0.0108549697,
-0.0246433523,
0.0239179134,
0.013147423,
0.0202887803,
0.0409527607,
0.0084650824,
0.0281543974,
0.0307038967,
-0.0155673744,
0.0366882123,
0.0228708591,
0.0363482535,
0.0755732208,
-0.0323868357,
0.0189106241,
-0.0603659749,
-0.0059834085,
-0.0252091885,
0.0379382856,
0.0526030213,
-0.0191397276,
0.0315311514,
0.0215612426,
-0.0748995319,
-0.0137156164,
-0.0011301707,
-0.0376966335,
-0.0206376165,
0.0028173067,
-0.0599938221,
-0.0143579468,
-0.0665866733,
0.0331944302,
-0.0216601323,
-0.0073779919,
-0.014862786,
0.0659182146,
-0.0266350005,
-0.0290961172,
-0.050490573,
0.0083991643,
0.0258858316,
0.0032704053,
0.004300063,
-0.0110303937,
0.0315727182,
0.0120877009,
0.0520311482,
-0.0390442945,
0.0452861525,
0.0670124292,
0.0193337556,
0.0214436632,
0.0500805974,
0.0107245231,
0.0742963701,
0.0025600602,
-0.0671405196,
0.0308086723,
0.0196925327,
-0.0279268548,
0.0199484061,
0.0333062932,
0.0673373714,
0.0601939,
0.0231263805,
-0.0227332935,
0.0766919404,
0.0049227965,
-0.0048250104,
0.0239912756,
-0.0035617149,
-0.021973148,
0.0041532004,
-0.0068005933,
-0.0006486229,
-0.0434327684,
-0.0192680433,
0.008520321,
0.0419650227,
-0.0843964741,
0.0323827676,
-0.0060559171,
-0.0049579949,
0.0203629099,
0.0308118556,
0.0054992056,
-0.0103566721,
0.0208947565,
-0.0153483879,
-0.0583377406,
0.0074496754,
0.05559735,
0.0218819566,
0.0110293543,
-0.0263475329,
0.0055557764,
-0.0013182552,
-0.0385359786,
0.0179731082,
-0.0051166364,
0.0075032902,
-0.0438287482,
-0.0219878573,
0.0029911788,
0.0196561161,
-0.0248285923,
0.0323253386,
0.0202463176,
0.0196951944,
-0.0028705641,
-0.0062785656,
-0.0045731361,
0.0496228673,
0.0249060262,
0.0250511765,
-0.0041097244,
0.0334902629,
-0.0085873958,
-0.0110355662,
-0.049492266,
-0.0182598028,
2.553e-7,
0.0084508443,
0.0302855335,
0.0387084,
-0.008412037,
-0.0180847496,
0.0674388856,
0.0035291726,
0.0630424246,
-0.0093182316,
-0.015853513,
0.0329087004,
0.0406413563,
-0.0018628916,
0.0058774427,
-0.0992244333,
0.0231819823,
-0.11455708,
-0.0085833287,
-0.0174067747,
-0.0066803033,
0.0758877248,
0.0541198142,
0.0150261987,
-0.0305452086,
-0.0206447672,
-0.0186151061,
0.0475701466,
-0.0006593216,
-0.0362068601,
-0.0356862284,
-0.0151356868,
0.0329249986,
-0.0348374695,
0.0053609698,
-0.0090385228,
0.0237991475,
0.062874496,
0.0165749043,
0.0163558032,
-0.0574763939,
-0.00527036,
0.0003757335,
0.0147951189,
-0.0314545482,
0.0521297045,
-0.0588657223,
-0.0004801338,
-0.0733201727,
-0.0721051395,
0.0476383828,
-0.0051049865,
-0.0345408022,
-0.0593240149,
0.0243595913,
-0.0345704779,
0.0197019912,
-0.0288921092,
-0.0687937886,
-0.0027298459,
0.0166380368,
0.0092970058,
-0.0010350544,
-0.0448862314,
0.0460832752,
-0.023476867,
-0.0609454513,
0.0204092264,
2.186182787e-34,
0.0572661385,
-0.01612195,
-0.0555444807,
0.0260835402,
0.0025281759,
-0.032705646,
-0.0084584523,
-0.0053117974,
0.0312919058,
-0.0291213021,
0.0039698314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08187v1 | Visual Question Generation in Bengali | 2023-10-12T10:26:26 | 2023-10-12T10:26:26 | Mahmud Hasan, Labiba Islam, Jannatul Ferdous Ruma, Tasmiah Tahsin Mayeesha, Rashedur M. Rahman | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of Visual Question Generation (VQG) is to generate human-like
questions relevant to the given image. As VQG is an emerging research field,
existing works tend to focus only on resource-rich language such as English due
to the availability of datasets. In this paper, we propose the first Bengali
Visual Question Generation task and develop a novel transformer-based
encoder-decoder architecture that generates questions in Bengali when given an
image. We propose multiple variants of models - (i) image-only: baseline model
of generating questions from images without additional information, (ii)
image-category and image-answer-category: guided VQG where we condition the
model to generate questions based on the answer and the category of expected
question. These models are trained and evaluated on the translated VQAv2.0
dataset. Our quantitative and qualitative results establish the first state of
the art models for VQG task in Bengali and demonstrate that our models are
capable of generating grammatically correct and relevant questions. Our
quantitative results show that our image-cat model achieves a BLUE-1 score of
33.12 and BLEU-3 score of 7.56 which is the highest of the other two variants.
We also perform a human evaluation to assess the quality of the generation
tasks. Human evaluation suggests that image-cat model is capable of generating
goal-driven and attribute-specific questions and also stays relevant to the
corresponding image. | [
0.0552216172,
0.0187556092,
-0.0189728998,
0.0290094204,
-0.0274384432,
0.0135664837,
0.0005753709,
0.0003418653,
0.015568519,
0.0108106127,
0.0144957546,
-0.0624233596,
-0.0007259495,
0.0387667306,
0.0281471014,
-0.0860357061,
0.0035161371,
0.0009455311,
-0.0079165902,
-0.0068606185,
0.0182511676,
0.0007168309,
0.0079789283,
0.0133829024,
-0.0250082463,
0.0057287519,
-0.0476901196,
0.0421513729,
-0.020226093,
-0.0411695503,
0.0013092649,
0.0406019725,
0.0192847978,
-0.0325548872,
0.000001861,
-0.0160526168,
0.0024307196,
-0.0201195683,
0.0205047168,
-0.0679036602,
0.0148434704,
-0.0319895931,
0.0222159866,
0.0310500283,
-0.0516829938,
-0.0118215336,
0.0718783513,
0.0475904681,
0.0872815922,
0.0579910278,
-0.0293681901,
-0.0560768545,
0.016999336,
-0.0017389955,
0.075176537,
-0.0004396748,
-0.0335388742,
0.0410211571,
0.0331703834,
0.0082018171,
-0.0338902734,
0.0498957597,
0.0594386198,
-0.0218229406,
0.0167403445,
0.0311154127,
0.0152716041,
-0.0606800728,
-0.0108882161,
0.0775309131,
-0.037256375,
0.0162250232,
-0.002168044,
0.0164295472,
0.0345485732,
0.0051846122,
-0.05066403,
0.0677443519,
-0.02928086,
-0.0181006826,
0.0175234359,
0.009844129,
-0.0572860315,
-0.0142622357,
0.0201233309,
-0.0395583622,
0.011982928,
-0.0198084712,
-0.0660751089,
0.0257801339,
-0.0456993207,
-0.0672770143,
0.0070184227,
0.0474522077,
-0.0045669926,
0.0335498974,
-0.0417305231,
-0.0035215421,
-0.0177869648,
-0.0133254491,
0.0280683115,
0.0323002562,
-0.0409248695,
0.028092429,
-0.0173848588,
0.0718119293,
-0.0047884434,
0.0135068139,
-0.0695656389,
-0.0113272145,
0.0059360815,
-0.0520614311,
-0.0399698615,
0.0228561498,
-0.0727127567,
-0.023614943,
-0.0388652459,
0.0472302176,
0.0394525528,
-0.0069865501,
0.0530014411,
0.0328727104,
-0.0370450877,
-0.0117045185,
-0.038582854,
0.0141465561,
-0.0448120423,
-0.0145975044,
0.0375258811,
-0.060237918,
0.0080021741,
0.0375339054,
0.0265039597,
-0.0243468639,
-0.0293110013,
0.025779862,
-0.0556586832,
-0.0104532633,
-0.0248465538,
-0.0145684825,
-0.0086151557,
-0.0489908382,
0.0315672345,
-0.0233942531,
0.0315173529,
0.0054789921,
-0.0258624293,
-0.0055631683,
0.0078758029,
0.0407613404,
0.0156688169,
0.0717054531,
-0.0166457538,
-0.0025600239,
0.0657031462,
0.0220474508,
0.0492518246,
0.0328251347,
0.0093871551,
0.0452422686,
0.0224463064,
-0.0165740605,
0.0327796862,
0.004614579,
-0.0080662267,
-0.0421996787,
-0.0238474868,
0.025675172,
-0.0003114163,
0.0436131284,
-0.0050140279,
0.0742917135,
-0.0268580299,
0.0165363811,
0.0577501766,
0.0133264875,
0.0019207021,
0.0399028584,
0.0367277153,
0.0139938472,
0.0072831931,
0.053427007,
-0.0337136723,
0.094629094,
0.0033118643,
0.0009956721,
-0.007561787,
0.0065238657,
-0.0526055321,
-0.0459211394,
0.0302365031,
-0.000354937,
0.0100353295,
0.0078931907,
0.002089821,
0.0588259175,
-0.0530421436,
0.0189513359,
-0.0192544945,
-0.0764452815,
0.0190683994,
-0.0384904742,
0.0679289177,
0.0080688838,
0.0444695652,
0.0385637879,
-0.0032332151,
0.0151802534,
-0.0005997543,
0.0532265939,
0.0029841287,
-0.0215954352,
-0.0173064899,
-0.0596623458,
0.0157052744,
-0.0153575828,
-0.0186031125,
-0.0009846921,
-0.0078819562,
0.018531464,
0.0121124368,
-0.0105734561,
-0.0174158867,
0.0589942187,
0.031549193,
0.0000037344,
0.0073258332,
0.0242132023,
-0.0355388001,
-0.0227485001,
0.0013904156,
-0.011315465,
0.0131127276,
-0.0483429357,
0.0003123339,
0.0380720794,
-0.0587205477,
-0.1019376442,
-0.0198540725,
-0.0628871918,
0.0133593902,
0.0078931358,
-0.0042040804,
-0.0386885032,
0.0059845038,
-0.0459351875,
-0.0234792028,
-0.0601655394,
0.0171132535,
0.0169859324,
0.0048658121,
-0.0409379825,
0.0469724797,
0.002516788,
-0.02082555,
-0.0150258224,
0.0199134294,
0.0370189287,
-0.0366988666,
-0.0240226407,
0.0469006635,
-0.0100079114,
0.0126193548,
0.0264129154,
0.0733005032,
-0.0458908938,
-0.0103861038,
-0.0664356351,
-0.0067091393,
-0.0131544853,
-0.0196528509,
0.0284553468,
0.0320595056,
-0.0088999523,
-0.0459653772,
-0.1008754298,
0.0485382527,
0.0425575972,
-0.0203346107,
0.068414785,
0.0011474198,
0.0376746804,
0.0080856299,
-0.0068665934,
0.0428689606,
0.0658628419,
0.0409584865,
0.0301233735,
-0.0357310995,
0.0105917081,
-0.027607711,
-0.0161499474,
0.0062407814,
-0.0413245969,
0.0136364745,
-0.0232221521,
0.0289183371,
0.0724235401,
0.037463963,
-0.0001054232,
-0.0410582274,
0.0024679727,
-0.0027779269,
0.0057645878,
-0.0273162182,
-0.0327125005,
0.0240962971,
-0.0573130809,
-0.0037561606,
0.034136273,
0.0128950281,
0.0316150971,
-0.0590042025,
0.0362114683,
-0.002948371,
-0.0193953235,
-0.0940245986,
0.0324854739,
-0.0246237665,
0.0695658252,
-0.0434829667,
-0.054136347,
0.0224614367,
-0.0021598011,
-0.0298980363,
-0.0302997734,
0.0452113561,
-0.0115097687,
0.083824873,
0.0306173097,
0.0342197269,
0.0220109764,
-0.022217704,
-0.1039571911,
0.003822607,
0.0213704612,
-0.0255906004,
0.0029648519,
-0.0726975128,
-0.010037614,
-0.0305046011,
-0.0356309041,
-0.0791392922,
0.006685752,
0.0354995206,
-0.0312036518,
-0.020251492,
-0.0000947081,
0.0121897263,
0.0483594276,
0.0133133009,
-0.0133413225,
-0.060379684,
-0.0163983218,
0.0007373354,
0.125390783,
0.0925448388,
0.0388899259,
-0.0025970666,
-0.0196328126,
0.0366638824,
0.0469902381,
-0.0298676398,
0.0129927285,
-0.0004196868,
0.0543871485,
0.0030594096,
0.0407653935,
0.0195270814,
0.024458522,
0.0653392673,
-0.0116997585,
-0.0614745729,
0.0534065515,
0.0553393289,
0.0041709491,
-0.0381299034,
-0.0267763268,
0.0128385751,
0.0053743669,
0.0476117656,
-0.069870241,
-0.0155811254,
-0.0282638408,
-0.0274236221,
-0.0011357687,
0.009645205,
-0.0433811098,
-0.1052042842,
0.0395773649,
-0.0210133493,
-0.0164844077,
-0.0135123571,
0.0414366871,
-0.0438477658,
0.0325139165,
-0.0012397621,
0.0161490142,
0.0131430915,
0.0092151994,
0.0316158086,
0.014696911,
-0.0236194823,
-0.0339617655,
-0.0177186113,
-0.0153911132,
0.0428604856,
-0.0016853219,
0.010324588,
-0.0277995076,
-0.01876265,
-0.028373763,
0.0000694257,
0.0052651302,
0.0353770554,
-0.0124262488,
-0.041487094,
-0.0191728435,
0.0243355297,
0.0016538436,
0.0286149532,
0.0394084752,
0.0098443525,
-0.0088505847,
-0.0235996936,
-0.0126405936,
-0.0047075353,
0.0042739147,
0.037356928,
0.0571247377,
-0.0545113981,
-0.0329799205,
-0.0290761888,
-0.0218088478,
-0.1046045795,
-0.0389530808,
0.0351687893,
0.004412842,
-0.0296210293,
-0.1135837436,
-0.0251982659,
0.0334131494,
0.0349129029,
-0.0279135089,
-0.0419015475,
0.0199975893,
0.0114655057,
-0.0650812313,
-0.0065164897,
-0.0031362802,
0.0019271416,
-0.0412685238,
-0.0085241701,
-0.0000545831,
-0.0556423999,
-0.0201547034,
0.0029649136,
-0.0490572341,
-0.0087517146,
0.0003287399,
0.0736019909,
0.0073997015,
-0.0149047468,
0.0053643095,
-0.0276724491,
0.0109665897,
0.0212344509,
-0.0059080278,
-0.0276824534,
-0.0423790254,
-0.0104237404,
-0.0111129424,
0.0179134049,
-0.0006298621,
0.0248978138,
0.0016024801,
0.0222276952,
-0.0180079006,
-0.0173765924,
0.0422371551,
0.0127151497,
-0.0288182776,
-0.0416510291,
-0.0112067321,
-0.0174389426,
-0.0122373141,
0.002336221,
-0.0312713683,
-0.0513241179,
-0.0194768514,
0.0207131207,
0.0240960643,
0.034604717,
-0.0207774416,
-0.0415159427,
0.0196907595,
0.0137448022,
0.0076488652,
0.0002493073,
0.0419338532,
-0.0071637356,
0.0125145521,
0.0020498654,
-0.0314196423,
0.0115314629,
0.0628996044,
-0.0007623046,
0.1175656617,
-0.0010376141,
-0.0178387985,
0.0233083405,
0.0692297295,
0.0265909433,
-0.0048521515,
-0.0255749878,
0.0221069064,
0.0266163852,
0.0284839775,
-0.028577812,
0.0220624227,
0.0124405203,
0.0101629468,
0.0506685115,
0.0009971308,
-0.0392425768,
0.0877739042,
-0.0193486679,
-0.0009452681,
-0.0376488343,
0.0236259494,
-0.0154892243,
-0.0312805586,
-0.0025355006,
0.0246609729,
-0.069185555,
-0.0122203296,
0.0107185729,
-0.0339444205,
0.017063953,
0.0680564716,
-0.0208153538,
-0.0374120548,
-0.0104601746,
0.0131182354,
0.020192109,
0.0249799453,
0.0693406537,
0.0427779183,
0.0219692066,
0.008502733,
-0.0243054871,
0.0249646101,
-0.0943089128,
-0.0074560507,
-0.0157022644,
-5.867723967e-33,
-0.0451222993,
-0.031439241,
0.032990396,
-0.0603168905,
-0.0153067932,
-0.0120488247,
-0.0434120148,
0.0241251681,
-0.0077934642,
-0.0367582254,
-0.0035821847,
-0.035178069,
0.0038585358,
0.042664133,
0.0119619798,
-0.0214585029,
0.0083067939,
-0.0081883995,
-0.0167336389,
0.0209270269,
-8.615e-7,
0.0158953331,
0.0125062689,
0.0177319665,
-0.0245163012,
-0.0458752327,
-0.0400291532,
0.0142521868,
0.0306873824,
0.0386066586,
-0.0424919501,
0.0147246113,
0.0457492806,
-0.0115761235,
-0.005533406,
0.0538637191,
-0.0546848141,
0.0017710883,
0.0007699616,
0.0570034683,
-0.1139086634,
0.0008368602,
-0.0027777725,
-0.031838689,
0.0307902619,
0.0139196338,
0.0211107805,
0.0051460508,
0.0023852983,
0.0173720513,
-0.0226495992,
-0.015375834,
-0.020323528,
-0.0369079039,
-0.0292629153,
0.0940630138,
0.0135565121,
-0.0343952589,
-0.0137408832,
0.029750172,
0.015078987,
0.0120863263,
0.0530938841,
0.0511617847,
-0.0322804414,
-0.0131527456,
0.0317195766,
-0.051945705,
0.0027984709,
0.0468478426,
-0.0148039507,
0.0451568142,
0.0600232221,
0.0797334462,
0.0541063137,
-0.0241681766,
-0.0268388148,
0.0682344884,
-0.0234322883,
0.0363130607,
-0.0042382418,
-0.0421994776,
0.0085112117,
-0.0193546452,
0.0172625072,
0.0135764768,
-0.0401149988,
-0.0392749533,
0.0683402494,
0.0108158151,
-0.0173293669,
0.0045128646,
0.0679235905,
-0.0282242838,
0.0646930635,
-0.0313020721,
-0.0587672703,
0.0642536953,
0.0015734237,
0.0307496134,
-0.0343413502,
-0.0142092202,
0.0620149039,
0.0224737767,
-0.0337432846,
0.0561174601,
0.020141542,
-0.0199241545,
-0.0443187691,
0.0040109982,
-0.0356521271,
0.0571626984,
-0.026884865,
0.0532639399,
-0.0295971259,
0.0125965923,
-0.0770384669,
-0.0000163433,
-0.0331882834,
-0.0090103606,
-0.052639164,
-0.0049441103,
0.0123262331,
0.0424453393,
-0.0417861603,
0.0329037718,
-0.0568638444,
0.0057008108,
-0.0019952341,
-0.0510841124,
-0.014047496,
0.0329854228,
2.576e-7,
0.0116320448,
0.0165793188,
0.0284051243,
0.0224837735,
-0.0032428333,
0.0119228559,
0.0111067696,
-0.0022729298,
0.0247966889,
-0.0122314934,
0.0208777077,
0.0156522263,
0.0307015702,
-0.0183930676,
-0.0787886158,
0.0259691682,
-0.0193453729,
-0.0080231028,
-0.0340509079,
0.0312745161,
0.0978224203,
0.0402681455,
-0.0479922965,
-0.0192038808,
0.0146651305,
-0.0204454046,
0.0738246366,
0.0257358104,
-0.0271507241,
0.0072572762,
-0.0291891657,
0.0724247098,
-0.0260209441,
-0.0038379484,
-0.0010243925,
-0.0287850406,
0.0290237367,
-0.0079154233,
0.0019930608,
-0.0236226823,
0.0146645047,
0.0634446144,
0.0020594806,
-0.0775908157,
0.0742197707,
-0.0486490205,
-0.0246771257,
0.0216633584,
-0.0229490865,
0.0062368228,
0.0072937724,
-0.0415622182,
-0.0614375547,
-0.0131496973,
0.0763188675,
-0.0475542471,
0.0238801185,
-0.0319545157,
-0.0011757486,
-0.022156477,
-0.0158441514,
-0.0138258683,
-0.0592426434,
-0.0014078144,
-0.0158270039,
0.0041073179,
-0.0268992614,
1.722097158e-34,
0.0130770784,
0.0263086092,
0.0217967853,
-0.0088509005,
0.0166764017,
-0.0104790349,
-0.0085193245,
-0.0264282152,
0.0160164163,
-0.0737936944,
-0.0266047791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08185v1 | EIPE-text: Evaluation-Guided Iterative Plan Extraction for Long-Form Narrative Text Generation | 2023-10-12T10:21:37 | 2023-10-12T10:21:37 | Wang You, Wenshan Wu, Yaobo Liang, Shaoguang Mao, Chenfei Wu, Maosong Cao, Yuzhe Cai, Yiduo Guo, Yan Xia, Furu Wei, Nan Duan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Plan-and-Write is a common hierarchical approach in long-form narrative text
generation, which first creates a plan to guide the narrative writing.
Following this approach, several studies rely on simply prompting large
language models for planning, which often yields suboptimal results. In this
paper, we propose a new framework called Evaluation-guided Iterative Plan
Extraction for long-form narrative text generation (EIPE-text), which extracts
plans from the corpus of narratives and utilizes the extracted plans to
construct a better planner. EIPE-text has three stages: plan extraction,
learning, and inference. In the plan extraction stage, it iteratively extracts
and improves plans from the narrative corpus and constructs a plan corpus. We
propose a question answer (QA) based evaluation mechanism to automatically
evaluate the plans and generate detailed plan refinement instructions to guide
the iterative improvement. In the learning stage, we build a better planner by
fine-tuning with the plan corpus or in-context learning with examples in the
plan corpus. Finally, we leverage a hierarchical approach to generate long-form
narratives. We evaluate the effectiveness of EIPE-text in the domains of novels
and storytelling. Both GPT-4-based evaluations and human evaluations
demonstrate that our method can generate more coherent and relevant long-form
narratives. Our code will be released in the future. | [
0.0341119654,
0.0319772474,
-0.0160860792,
0.0152240479,
-0.0550997704,
-0.0140447142,
-0.0053800028,
-0.0088143442,
-0.0004611466,
-0.0166836791,
0.0355855934,
-0.026617812,
0.0236967783,
0.0857271031,
-0.0071298038,
-0.0723934248,
-0.0210480951,
-0.0321986452,
0.0313633904,
0.0266708676,
0.0138972392,
0.0428583808,
-0.0135442344,
0.0296082105,
0.0060006101,
-0.0202360693,
-0.052273158,
0.0012785111,
0.0317693613,
-0.0652372018,
0.0032506164,
-0.0063639907,
0.0131503073,
-0.0209993236,
0.0000018267,
-0.0570848919,
-0.043149475,
-0.0188931376,
0.0287990142,
-0.0277337003,
0.0041745603,
-0.0103669567,
0.0188956317,
-0.0070868591,
-0.0111773815,
0.0211943854,
0.0006245672,
0.0608756393,
0.0479732379,
0.0826359913,
-0.0162625983,
-0.0621670224,
-0.0148153398,
0.0086282166,
-0.0124648707,
-0.0041132956,
-0.0291225873,
-0.0135992402,
0.0607441068,
-0.0048460355,
0.0190138258,
-0.0214145519,
0.0325171091,
-0.0111995311,
-0.0120467981,
0.0542871431,
0.0058049457,
-0.0017679787,
-0.0222211555,
0.0597680137,
0.029054055,
-0.0084749404,
0.023838412,
-0.0329749286,
0.0001802061,
-0.0139598465,
-0.044754602,
0.0447698981,
-0.0326191634,
0.0217084102,
0.0290350504,
0.0086232815,
-0.0007172601,
-0.0342752859,
0.0244800299,
0.0380044319,
0.0268578213,
-0.0155208912,
-0.0191206019,
0.0091544073,
0.0131544843,
-0.1048956662,
0.0462612435,
0.0645426884,
-0.0081792353,
0.0150358891,
-0.0563900061,
0.0218449086,
-0.0260181576,
0.0004113677,
0.0633832589,
0.0334454887,
0.0176655706,
-0.0054142834,
0.0165205169,
0.0485948659,
0.0283571817,
-0.0428911932,
-0.0611518584,
0.0778359175,
-0.0568712279,
0.0100037595,
-0.0683350042,
0.0279972181,
-0.0626627877,
-0.0429080687,
-0.0093939248,
0.0106390174,
0.0453057103,
0.0019412907,
0.003502341,
0.0201771744,
-0.0258105136,
-0.0102928821,
-0.0449979939,
0.0104328208,
-0.0760508627,
-0.0191153623,
0.0342611037,
0.0437279902,
-0.0367474407,
0.0070911646,
0.052642256,
0.0022377688,
-0.0017634322,
0.0458305329,
-0.0390639156,
0.0025435749,
-0.0476607606,
-0.0848877281,
-0.0219749287,
-0.0582206249,
-0.0147155821,
-0.0472935587,
0.0337440521,
-0.0074975332,
0.0022937839,
-0.001021795,
0.0065102559,
0.0070593203,
-0.0101206172,
-0.0148087423,
-0.0131658986,
0.0161909461,
0.0257737618,
0.0134562096,
0.0093306731,
0.0260532014,
0.1016125306,
0.0732098967,
0.0207662117,
0.0410246663,
0.0413552783,
0.0220375787,
-0.0207648724,
-0.0112306364,
0.0189666376,
0.016949717,
-0.0021509766,
0.0766619667,
-0.0018718991,
0.0463883653,
-0.0243324563,
0.0412072167,
0.0604267865,
0.0366609469,
0.0378127806,
0.0116479341,
0.0964723676,
0.0004935875,
0.0040249331,
0.0506538115,
0.0016186042,
0.0123504484,
0.0130676813,
0.0168057475,
-0.011943914,
-0.0106311915,
-0.0005065967,
-0.0292096473,
-0.0066900607,
0.0201977082,
-0.007616038,
-0.0370607376,
-0.0151717784,
0.0314154774,
-0.0959854126,
-0.0201248638,
-0.0200006682,
-0.0805075765,
0.0592995398,
0.0063112313,
0.083166413,
0.104205206,
0.0497119501,
-0.0141426614,
-0.0310256984,
-0.0102830725,
-0.0043935543,
0.0098636849,
-0.0044667111,
-0.0586270913,
0.0361238308,
-0.0327053405,
0.0056156996,
-0.0467652828,
-0.0067434679,
0.0002965418,
-0.00698133,
-0.012786841,
0.001224976,
-0.0288193431,
-0.0356167592,
0.0503830984,
-0.0540014356,
-0.0261152852,
-0.0013901878,
-0.0007796401,
-0.0045741056,
-0.0099534104,
-0.0241222642,
0.0051309606,
0.0192121398,
-0.0328000896,
-0.0172826033,
0.0221699458,
-0.0513978936,
-0.0578019693,
0.0044231443,
-0.0441685505,
0.0139403455,
-0.0440292433,
0.0163079742,
-0.0693442598,
-0.0024213544,
-0.0382164307,
0.0166426245,
-0.0153813316,
0.0199054554,
0.0343538336,
-0.043475084,
-0.0440784693,
0.0636050254,
0.0295229424,
-0.0292012673,
0.0085026585,
-0.0043875417,
-0.0079032844,
-0.0218704082,
0.0319766812,
0.0435861349,
0.0481536426,
-0.0275957268,
0.0486438014,
0.0217857566,
-0.0520441569,
-0.0637045503,
-0.0977651253,
0.0358115472,
-0.0217217878,
0.0254473872,
0.0402938314,
0.0035209481,
-0.0426409394,
0.0109316176,
-0.0574740283,
-0.0047795661,
0.0023138279,
-0.0347610489,
0.0243032072,
0.037333034,
0.0088280225,
-0.0297628921,
0.0143753393,
-0.0166878682,
0.020792041,
0.0834868103,
-0.0058650929,
-0.0643887147,
0.0412174128,
0.0027602974,
-0.0228620786,
-0.0030275886,
-0.0032462673,
0.0194591004,
0.0014421641,
0.070437789,
0.0289426018,
-0.003829384,
0.0187788997,
0.0537039302,
-0.059891142,
-0.0036107635,
0.0227349959,
-0.0307240449,
0.0135928886,
-0.0328118056,
-0.0393458866,
0.035496477,
0.0542088933,
0.0390896834,
0.0188081786,
-0.065846093,
0.011610236,
0.0142786084,
-0.0188259166,
0.0352054946,
-0.0344161987,
-0.017746387,
0.0639083982,
0.0084111644,
-0.0205155574,
0.0739302859,
-0.0363474786,
-0.0023435445,
-0.0141100883,
0.0208596662,
-0.051260978,
0.0806575939,
0.0184653699,
0.0418925285,
0.0211755279,
-0.0029956098,
-0.0501476079,
0.0016094341,
-0.0002293782,
-0.0045437426,
0.0363012478,
-0.0815563798,
-0.0251909476,
0.0033056438,
-0.0254630689,
-0.0360601023,
-0.037621282,
-0.0053336457,
0.0117323082,
0.0113261333,
-0.048789572,
0.0066889981,
0.0054465258,
0.0006011328,
0.0577828474,
-0.0154562453,
-0.0362732187,
-0.0197329894,
0.0412238315,
0.0684306026,
0.0087219412,
-0.0117092719,
-0.0498248227,
0.0481638573,
0.021966286,
-0.0186029449,
0.0370025672,
0.0047977511,
0.0428180583,
0.026333889,
-0.0458750874,
-0.017682476,
0.0387299508,
0.0582070909,
-0.0592981316,
-0.0421518721,
0.0994708091,
0.024125021,
-0.0016404854,
0.0128557114,
0.0031882529,
0.0670420825,
0.0049070432,
0.0189067833,
-0.0438884571,
-0.0027266948,
0.0182153247,
0.0311976746,
-0.0157467406,
-0.0627868474,
-0.0345652178,
-0.0780826658,
0.0546144173,
0.0039216951,
-0.023686653,
0.0344003364,
-0.0007559065,
-0.0233072564,
0.0226954594,
-0.0173627529,
0.0191285647,
-0.0336037725,
0.0386463962,
-0.0327287428,
-0.048499763,
0.0052498071,
0.0000725848,
-0.0135769751,
0.0083365534,
0.0665411428,
0.0538819581,
0.001951499,
0.0421949066,
-0.0345988572,
-0.0221345797,
0.0041672294,
-0.0122983735,
0.0201113708,
-0.0174731351,
0.0157795027,
-0.0181045514,
0.0779931322,
-0.0221235715,
-0.0681882501,
0.0748459995,
0.0498165227,
-0.0154435616,
-0.0430665053,
-0.0179696959,
0.0248849504,
0.0127739096,
0.0536293909,
0.0265874639,
-0.0373503566,
-0.0465206429,
-0.0183348041,
0.0128146121,
-0.1136427671,
0.0050342684,
-0.0012125737,
-0.0347093754,
0.0559820645,
-0.0893525109,
-0.0703040883,
0.0534316115,
0.071762234,
0.0553069636,
-0.0204385202,
0.0077978717,
-0.0126375202,
-0.0361684859,
-0.0143695716,
0.0020945815,
-0.0071093785,
-0.0077988412,
-0.0190479755,
-0.0183238927,
-0.0523043126,
0.012835606,
0.0446853004,
-0.0623045154,
-0.0377259217,
-0.0132067613,
0.0100423219,
0.0127699031,
0.0279802699,
0.0300274193,
-0.0421661213,
0.0433048606,
-0.0017909199,
-0.0194737576,
0.0546569563,
-0.0317354128,
0.0700320229,
0.0004986961,
0.0143306572,
-0.0084904693,
-0.0059555843,
-0.0167367589,
0.082505621,
-0.0111958226,
0.0001228245,
0.034392409,
0.0353480764,
-0.0249957256,
-0.0779560208,
-0.0314254612,
-0.076851815,
-0.0222772826,
-0.0664333925,
-0.0303046051,
-0.0592719279,
0.0590209477,
0.0198316835,
0.0005475195,
-0.0108908881,
-0.0077040307,
-0.0447737575,
-0.0214328393,
-0.0414136201,
-0.0200199354,
0.0364241675,
-0.0219603088,
0.0286142565,
-0.0097570103,
-0.0133777466,
-0.0147343231,
-0.0579178669,
0.0615365244,
0.0014186128,
0.0301816259,
0.0194961391,
-0.0110283764,
0.0092770141,
0.0114055732,
-0.0327002704,
-0.0166964289,
0.0045866645,
0.0065964311,
0.0159661472,
-0.0073666694,
0.0600859113,
-0.0304332394,
0.0318810679,
0.0044483487,
0.0184043832,
0.0186111424,
-0.0163278412,
-0.0272001587,
0.0206093155,
-0.0299066268,
-0.0067001018,
0.0452417359,
0.0081929369,
0.0425756387,
0.0016935052,
-0.0081537757,
-0.0439843386,
-0.0628705919,
-0.0105010262,
0.0450859629,
0.0211416297,
-0.0435353816,
-0.0578497015,
0.0006680405,
0.0189685635,
0.0235891622,
0.0082407286,
-0.0204644371,
0.0222342331,
0.0249103922,
-0.0268860739,
-0.0201675016,
-0.0650904924,
0.002967509,
-0.019294301,
-0.0274759792,
-0.0137856808,
-5.427361376e-33,
-0.0475455411,
-0.0403595939,
0.0403597988,
-0.015087503,
-0.0699054971,
0.000332467,
-0.0545020737,
-0.0103980899,
0.0701740906,
0.039613001,
0.0029614605,
-0.0306997951,
0.0043079783,
0.0007609968,
0.0026946482,
-0.001454846,
0.0421225466,
0.0145814158,
-0.0872419104,
0.0179094933,
0.0509051867,
0.0281549357,
0.0238063056,
-0.0080633629,
-0.0034842661,
-0.0478541628,
-0.0326541811,
0.0138359144,
0.0344179682,
0.0322142802,
-0.0154199013,
0.0002741145,
0.026363004,
0.008464749,
-0.0238176361,
0.0403852016,
-0.0313422531,
-0.0186099987,
0.0313236266,
-0.0280432999,
-0.053092774,
-0.0546526574,
0.0149505362,
-0.011305457,
-0.0074604,
-0.032438755,
0.0365575701,
-0.0091335913,
0.0162286293,
0.0034084907,
-0.097958602,
-0.0098647699,
-0.0219895691,
-0.0319118127,
0.0110674324,
0.0636410266,
0.0242437813,
-0.0234865751,
0.016097784,
0.012742375,
-0.0124850236,
0.0309704151,
-0.0068626045,
0.0268940721,
-0.0305535886,
0.075729996,
0.0096373186,
0.0042890748,
-0.0610558055,
0.04692249,
-0.0213752333,
0.0341074616,
0.0049547777,
0.0387713313,
-0.0054007163,
0.0300532877,
-0.0584585853,
0.0617930964,
-0.034933053,
0.0132297548,
0.0306336749,
-0.0181278642,
-0.0049428237,
-0.0204259157,
-0.0486909673,
-0.0231143795,
0.0160529092,
-0.0088714333,
0.0308552887,
0.0203998536,
0.0154649578,
0.0355090052,
0.0140846213,
0.0010593508,
0.0321596302,
0.0185925681,
-0.1034975797,
0.0432197675,
0.0012730205,
0.0439366363,
-0.0281460006,
-0.0104952622,
0.0409694389,
0.0254132207,
0.0507299677,
-0.0076130088,
-0.0145418337,
0.0628141537,
-0.0386392139,
0.0093897767,
-0.0618408322,
0.01335447,
-0.0267164353,
-0.0244984999,
0.0093478542,
-0.0182488803,
-0.0140214302,
0.0058130599,
0.0165450536,
-0.0412784815,
-0.0336660221,
-0.0402488187,
0.0295072012,
0.0090552839,
-0.018102536,
0.034201473,
0.0411490723,
-0.000016849,
0.014005553,
-0.0395522714,
0.0072636842,
0.0362049527,
2.512e-7,
-0.0066782217,
0.0099354032,
0.0433943756,
0.0200421046,
-0.013658708,
0.0247760843,
-0.0006198383,
0.0221458189,
-0.013241455,
-0.0256439745,
0.0565852411,
0.0080791507,
0.0300419144,
0.0396106206,
-0.0730212927,
0.0239992905,
-0.0494954139,
-0.0401506163,
-0.095185563,
-0.0494190007,
0.1270815283,
-0.0196834523,
0.0324079357,
-0.0032265149,
0.0152867613,
-0.0236585718,
0.0660477877,
-0.0050591128,
-0.0329916924,
0.0569444932,
-0.0137134269,
-0.0127842771,
-0.0289182607,
-0.0240203701,
-0.0023276631,
0.0226325504,
0.0197740179,
0.0767743289,
-0.0049288152,
-0.0046491399,
0.0200282279,
-0.0305129718,
-0.0078153145,
-0.0478863679,
0.0349546745,
0.000226269,
-0.0203993395,
-0.0081935534,
0.0046965093,
-0.0075959177,
-0.0213209335,
-0.0041083833,
0.0115108918,
0.0566093065,
0.0136949848,
0.0216012709,
0.006121798,
-0.0525654219,
-0.0098790843,
0.0464210324,
-0.0351204462,
0.0020051273,
-0.0288192518,
0.0116142333,
-0.0441071801,
-0.0883719027,
-0.0003226557,
2.374957307e-34,
-0.0075245011,
-0.0121536748,
-0.0174704567,
0.0211093295,
0.0562349446,
0.0214716122,
0.0380800553,
-0.0009054697,
0.0128168305,
-0.0621426776,
-0.0489364937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08172v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08172v2 | Exploring the Cognitive Knowledge Structure of Large Language Models: An Educational Diagnostic Assessment Approach | 2023-10-12T09:55:45 | 2023-10-18T11:37:43 | Zheyuan Zhang, Jifan Yu, Juanzi Li, Lei Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have not only exhibited exceptional performance
across various tasks, but also demonstrated sparks of intelligence. Recent
studies have focused on assessing their capabilities on human exams and
revealed their impressive competence in different domains. However, cognitive
research on the overall knowledge structure of LLMs is still lacking. In this
paper, based on educational diagnostic assessment method, we conduct an
evaluation using MoocRadar, a meticulously annotated human test dataset based
on Bloom Taxonomy. We aim to reveal the knowledge structures of LLMs and gain
insights of their cognitive capabilities. This research emphasizes the
significance of investigating LLMs' knowledge and understanding the disparate
cognitive patterns of LLMs. By shedding light on models' knowledge, researchers
can advance development and utilization of LLMs in a more informed and
effective manner. | [
0.0367630571,
-0.0113018304,
-0.0608911365,
0.0526729487,
-0.0100297416,
0.0228582341,
0.0232456848,
0.0133261634,
0.0477048606,
-0.0704845637,
-0.0126890037,
-0.02033264,
0.003177142,
0.0459646732,
0.0398584232,
-0.034511026,
0.0602536015,
-0.0491780378,
0.0032954838,
-0.0057221968,
-0.0181570556,
0.0101120239,
-0.0114799207,
0.0336985663,
0.0230025947,
-0.0363983251,
0.001566731,
-0.0455447361,
0.0017651409,
-0.0228289273,
-0.0272264741,
0.0442027524,
-0.0048141615,
0.044551637,
0.0000020243,
-0.0793438405,
0.0340556204,
0.0008341727,
-0.015706405,
0.0303876717,
0.0235810298,
0.0563831106,
-0.0277830623,
0.0258347709,
-0.02232497,
-0.0026976406,
0.0252433661,
0.0227807127,
0.0404291674,
0.0388786346,
0.0169306621,
-0.0298026353,
0.0684164912,
0.0116434069,
0.0125120953,
-0.0060762311,
0.022273466,
0.0550758429,
0.0332248397,
-0.0069433064,
-0.0217628479,
0.0115051828,
0.0133144241,
-0.0195137262,
-0.0426443256,
0.0280011538,
-0.0035411923,
-0.0215707794,
0.0320578776,
0.0222813934,
0.0030246684,
0.0091356486,
-0.0177404135,
0.0126689598,
0.0093154553,
0.0382534415,
-0.0569958687,
0.0417661481,
0.0164844245,
-0.017496299,
0.0268311724,
-0.015593648,
0.0283042602,
-0.006506321,
-0.0394753404,
0.058953464,
-0.0017487307,
-0.022896966,
0.0010467365,
-0.0207185671,
-0.0302247871,
-0.0657558739,
-0.0248541702,
0.0289077088,
-0.0199459381,
0.040228352,
0.0041956538,
-0.0383070596,
0.0483062826,
-0.0601625033,
0.0350997932,
0.0283134989,
0.0194040835,
0.0299398415,
-0.0464651063,
0.0842515528,
0.0178588927,
0.0164170545,
-0.0140956854,
-0.0033939355,
-0.0876555219,
-0.0420829281,
-0.0124346279,
0.0526197143,
0.0283754524,
-0.0130757829,
-0.0589050688,
0.0202946812,
-0.0284456927,
-0.0041121519,
-0.0286174789,
-0.0220048781,
0.0180101041,
0.0121905301,
-0.0833442956,
-0.0119776996,
-0.0150021827,
0.0070683802,
-0.005817215,
-0.0356563851,
0.0217958093,
0.0174283609,
-0.0177801698,
-0.0177762806,
-0.0051302272,
0.030184092,
0.0029433661,
-0.0204555895,
-0.0338961557,
-0.0307321884,
0.0230361819,
-0.0606071353,
0.0223634448,
-0.0706468225,
-0.0172656756,
0.0543226972,
0.0137924841,
-0.0171656143,
0.0110172322,
0.0216426738,
0.0051087835,
0.0154244173,
-0.0059229597,
-0.0124708842,
0.0150699904,
0.0055207033,
0.025300771,
0.0824217126,
0.0224058013,
-0.0290645864,
0.0069638891,
-0.0226740707,
0.006824695,
0.0392226093,
-0.0181460436,
-0.0253533497,
-0.0164134894,
0.0205550119,
0.0076498995,
0.0434269458,
0.0151825435,
0.0437637642,
-0.0003332562,
0.028824877,
0.0238064285,
0.0504053161,
0.0080626551,
0.0524126925,
0.0478704721,
-0.0088312877,
0.0616371259,
0.0025528385,
-0.0153832883,
-0.0075163925,
-0.0427078828,
0.02033283,
-0.0078642592,
0.0355685651,
0.0129874339,
-0.0578271523,
-0.0529917926,
0.0105765741,
0.0043667802,
0.0156515893,
0.0632688329,
-0.0169035643,
0.0019700497,
0.0464696474,
-0.005561389,
-0.0459610075,
0.0033030296,
-0.0847090632,
-0.0038145925,
0.0408192091,
0.0359403715,
-0.0429906659,
-0.0481893234,
0.0163049717,
0.0027746873,
0.0562650412,
0.0444840491,
-0.0289140791,
-0.04027877,
-0.0081175044,
0.0000658126,
-0.0117550595,
0.0049628606,
-0.0253943931,
-0.0191124342,
0.0001285259,
-0.0080861626,
-0.0628225952,
-0.0759430453,
0.0278104264,
-0.0679661408,
-0.0035760666,
-0.0655189976,
-0.0114536379,
0.040768072,
0.0227852743,
-0.009742084,
0.0232136138,
0.0393687673,
-0.0335646421,
0.0039666598,
0.0112674432,
-0.0156463999,
0.0427663028,
0.0536742397,
-0.0270941202,
-0.0230954513,
0.0275894273,
0.0068308185,
-0.0439677723,
0.0363245383,
-0.0608373433,
0.076392591,
-0.0147950323,
0.0467978828,
-0.0775632933,
-0.0034813778,
0.0127015077,
0.0827892646,
-0.0038705147,
0.0551833622,
-0.0038575891,
-0.0091090547,
0.0231447518,
-0.0276561193,
-0.0417615622,
0.0068275686,
0.0013130541,
0.0272133593,
0.0094197448,
-0.020014761,
-0.0536421984,
-0.0073277866,
-0.1080474257,
-0.0090439664,
0.0050865198,
0.0281591658,
0.0257671066,
-0.0597378947,
-0.0167083275,
0.0184415765,
-0.0242904518,
0.001263058,
0.0075659058,
0.0136045814,
0.0071343072,
-0.0156271011,
-0.0335624665,
-0.0025234059,
-0.0175289921,
-0.0629466474,
0.0415043794,
0.0388219431,
0.0213824026,
-0.026194362,
0.0488924012,
-0.0476671457,
0.0058976077,
-0.0107943052,
-0.0224340893,
0.0432282314,
-0.0024405646,
0.0388323404,
0.0545562506,
0.0163073745,
0.0460753515,
0.0574579313,
-0.028856203,
-0.0314325243,
-0.0004663314,
0.0152864913,
0.0030877667,
-0.0816699117,
-0.0548773631,
-0.0236538015,
0.06465289,
-0.0031138957,
-0.0104509993,
-0.0053775087,
0.020012768,
-0.0603416748,
-0.0228691939,
-0.055697687,
0.0002587534,
-0.0071472893,
0.0534735285,
0.0047430582,
-0.0088241743,
0.0650325045,
-0.0299052745,
0.0138400095,
-0.0564508662,
0.0267134774,
-0.0302039143,
0.0708739385,
-0.0044209831,
0.012297322,
-0.0035189413,
-0.032911174,
-0.0687073618,
0.017788142,
-0.0077030808,
-0.0601438992,
0.0312867872,
-0.0454657376,
-0.0013780765,
0.0126280217,
0.001283096,
-0.0427761413,
0.0504472144,
-0.0287817288,
0.0580365807,
0.0296155624,
-0.0395933054,
-0.0708358735,
-0.0022763582,
0.0339323245,
-0.004953275,
0.0062308521,
-0.0149507057,
0.0030880689,
-0.0122246956,
0.0354433805,
0.0373294316,
0.0598647594,
-0.0506298468,
0.0291916151,
0.0354257412,
0.0001310369,
-0.0145562058,
-0.0096990922,
0.0005918889,
0.0293105021,
-0.0471548513,
-0.0081806807,
0.0304175243,
0.0170343425,
-0.0781019181,
-0.0228982326,
0.1144220084,
0.0515842363,
-0.005684427,
0.009655226,
-0.0456139334,
0.0012874671,
0.0799144432,
0.0321890153,
-0.0605179779,
-0.0073336526,
-0.0093358429,
-0.0154468389,
-0.0473831855,
-0.0544157401,
0.0000011442,
-0.1288359314,
0.0072585242,
-0.0138820047,
-0.0518443398,
-0.0329034626,
-0.0385479853,
0.0066813971,
0.0311893318,
0.0335836373,
-0.0019715112,
-0.0321410038,
-0.0108940192,
0.0132931499,
-0.0169973187,
-0.0610261522,
0.0838326663,
-0.0243031215,
0.0623607226,
0.0319003984,
0.0286115147,
-0.0498083271,
0.0048889983,
0.0285466164,
-0.0110455723,
0.0131445816,
0.0207159072,
0.0199201312,
-0.0056260466,
0.0070388224,
-0.0334637798,
-0.0117584355,
-0.0157967377,
-0.0112569313,
0.0180089809,
0.1162981614,
-0.0038495157,
-0.0413097069,
-0.037421193,
-0.0051878416,
-0.030468829,
0.0644042119,
0.0413342118,
-0.041542016,
-0.0046178866,
-0.037711326,
-0.0198171735,
0.0015958213,
-0.0839266926,
0.0688169673,
0.028056385,
0.0193144754,
-0.0379252769,
-0.0436787494,
0.0546609536,
-0.002569827,
0.0266700163,
0.0178271271,
0.0199984964,
-0.0129151447,
-0.0491169244,
0.0526977181,
0.0141200982,
0.0066999001,
-0.0998743773,
-0.0267401021,
-0.0046474547,
-0.0069962,
-0.0379494466,
0.0445472151,
-0.0419336967,
-0.0434442498,
0.0101105087,
0.0188143775,
0.027506806,
-0.0449236929,
0.0036358463,
-0.0911491588,
0.0425875112,
0.006511989,
-0.0319784358,
0.0221183579,
-0.0111295367,
-0.0480012111,
0.0130159492,
0.0200446974,
-0.0284135845,
0.028287489,
0.0040507992,
0.023532182,
-0.0163175408,
0.013300606,
0.0158905871,
0.0357893668,
0.0201762114,
-0.0136090973,
-0.016923381,
-0.0526627824,
-0.0003577546,
-0.0490669757,
-0.0301748589,
-0.0133241676,
-0.0053600292,
0.0111872945,
-0.0008337063,
0.0167552233,
-0.0101385508,
-0.0198296402,
0.000238682,
0.0093763415,
0.0397434756,
0.0037303341,
-0.0072830413,
0.0275864955,
-0.003238467,
0.0010166153,
-0.0490005016,
-0.0269272104,
0.0540366694,
0.0092270197,
0.0906044394,
-0.012039829,
-0.0136587368,
0.0158889443,
0.0094500715,
-0.0248261746,
-0.0497345626,
0.0008855932,
0.0467498153,
0.0200214181,
0.0049375016,
0.0276674218,
-0.0444931537,
0.0220184121,
-0.0284628794,
-0.012398229,
-0.0214406382,
-0.0214676633,
0.0489122495,
0.0512284338,
0.0042421832,
0.0092512714,
0.0450990908,
0.0029840646,
0.0200857595,
-0.0232582651,
-0.0042961673,
-0.0297128651,
-0.0309516117,
0.0164466053,
0.0258024894,
-0.0338449478,
0.0185116529,
-0.1073120087,
-0.0947781652,
0.0227659047,
0.0370865799,
0.0053848894,
-0.0218900368,
0.0099528376,
0.0754316151,
-0.0090689175,
-0.027405059,
-0.0370451249,
0.0077898088,
-0.0516982786,
-0.018464569,
-0.0079397354,
-6.069326391e-33,
-0.0465458445,
-0.0580471531,
0.0399151742,
-0.0408234596,
0.0354242176,
0.000174765,
-0.0409573838,
0.0554999933,
-0.0479682833,
0.0071429578,
-0.0105718644,
0.0213080756,
0.0005744077,
-0.0025300267,
0.0400022604,
0.0452181287,
0.0057131601,
-0.0056425561,
-0.021169411,
0.0261782296,
0.0727195516,
-0.0223622341,
0.056729231,
-0.0487052649,
0.0515261032,
-0.0277726762,
0.021911256,
0.0053498494,
-0.0497954376,
0.0863175765,
-0.0376624689,
0.0528746359,
0.0424516387,
-0.0116582094,
-0.0129248612,
-0.0066904714,
-0.0364398248,
-0.0326498002,
0.0571215078,
0.0090664849,
0.003702984,
-0.0367810391,
0.0424808115,
-0.0091296611,
-0.0150206564,
-0.0266085397,
0.0678858161,
-0.0130437696,
0.0148718432,
0.0211712997,
-0.0877294838,
0.0187697355,
-0.0423190966,
0.0319631845,
0.0082384152,
0.0145350257,
-0.018446885,
-0.0102976961,
-0.0559604801,
0.0210492201,
0.0205543973,
0.0570479259,
0.0898621529,
0.0244072042,
0.008172838,
0.0803297311,
0.0192315988,
0.0253437944,
0.0228045173,
0.02739284,
0.075154461,
0.0407469347,
0.0458018407,
0.0303451028,
0.0159940831,
0.0021966796,
-0.0426406935,
-0.0210057292,
0.0304827951,
0.0437133014,
0.0195818357,
-0.0477743782,
-0.0356298834,
-0.0173622929,
-0.0331439376,
0.0073011774,
-0.0242920071,
-0.0175575465,
0.0324675553,
-0.0534302481,
-0.0019430517,
-0.0195155386,
0.0379287861,
-0.0402845815,
-0.0185234435,
-0.0310400501,
0.0009198844,
0.080227688,
-0.0022356804,
0.0589255132,
-0.0457407795,
-0.0638814941,
0.0017099762,
-0.022731863,
0.0488723777,
0.0110347345,
0.0130435489,
0.0133139985,
-0.034758132,
-0.0106451325,
-0.0484163165,
-0.0089219874,
0.0061497437,
-0.0031494203,
0.0175102912,
0.013275153,
0.0017206245,
-0.027485298,
0.0282934755,
-0.0260952134,
-0.029467674,
0.0143657317,
-0.0193248652,
-0.0123050427,
-0.0375308022,
-0.036713168,
-0.0647995621,
0.0395389609,
0.0482348837,
-0.0455382802,
0.0016301026,
0.0208200067,
2.738e-7,
0.0830925256,
0.081788078,
-0.0362036787,
0.0370033607,
0.0188605953,
0.0095543824,
-0.029395774,
-0.0149883032,
0.0512752645,
0.0040269364,
-0.0299824849,
0.0172326975,
0.0158301555,
0.0365645364,
-0.090817742,
-0.0249339584,
-0.0255509987,
-0.0177651811,
-0.0614563897,
0.0303609427,
0.037017446,
0.0584050864,
0.0041386262,
-0.0101115294,
-0.0450353101,
-0.0829138383,
0.0167113878,
-0.0061259409,
0.015770046,
0.0250522532,
0.0226827059,
0.0385686234,
0.0201493967,
0.0803696588,
0.0043020626,
0.0226886552,
-0.019114621,
0.0343004391,
-0.0200219993,
0.0368715078,
0.0168857072,
-0.0287537072,
-0.0059286742,
-0.0757731795,
0.0655800402,
-0.0341511965,
-0.0391500071,
-0.006001899,
-0.004741183,
-0.0162826087,
-0.0073437691,
-0.0253548827,
0.0034552799,
0.0379298925,
-0.0011165669,
-0.0526466854,
0.0185027663,
-0.0068057589,
-0.0116221569,
0.0156946201,
-0.0642468557,
-0.088972196,
-0.0296853501,
-0.0260488633,
0.0137807317,
-0.0460673496,
0.0125507973,
2.455967924e-34,
0.0226736348,
0.0146876983,
0.0229106247,
0.0150018148,
0.045499403,
-0.0151860714,
-0.004691218,
0.0326033011,
-0.0120133283,
-0.0623155087,
-0.0214227997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08170v1 | Simplicity Level Estimate (SLE): A Learned Reference-Less Metric for Sentence Simplification | 2023-10-12T09:49:10 | 2023-10-12T09:49:10 | Liam Cripwell, Joël Legrand, Claire Gardent | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic evaluation for sentence simplification remains a challenging
problem. Most popular evaluation metrics require multiple high-quality
references -- something not readily available for simplification -- which makes
it difficult to test performance on unseen domains. Furthermore, most existing
metrics conflate simplicity with correlated attributes such as fluency or
meaning preservation. We propose a new learned evaluation metric (SLE) which
focuses on simplicity, outperforming almost all existing metrics in terms of
correlation with human judgements. | [
-0.0168856271,
0.0086556831,
-0.0051287436,
0.006250795,
-0.0517157502,
-0.0049282229,
-0.0015901268,
0.0140012158,
-0.031970188,
-0.0175386593,
-0.0244646575,
0.0343176574,
0.0715087801,
-0.0559452176,
0.0242761094,
-0.0756863579,
0.0356869549,
0.0223307982,
0.0395349115,
0.0198602453,
0.032547012,
-0.0336123928,
-0.0057406239,
0.074263297,
0.0104440497,
-0.0220176131,
0.0399505198,
0.0337459743,
0.0298770145,
0.0336941816,
0.0177921224,
0.0446058065,
-0.0363890454,
-0.0387563258,
0.000001727,
-0.0278081484,
-0.0368711688,
-0.013207051,
0.0167389549,
0.0767615512,
0.0865501016,
-0.0249509644,
-0.0094166594,
0.0258856043,
-0.0197313242,
0.0013055598,
0.0307577178,
0.0319601074,
0.0665580556,
0.038545575,
-0.0253285952,
-0.0244834349,
-0.0556412265,
-0.0239331331,
-0.0226485878,
-0.055523131,
0.0049851802,
-0.0059597278,
-0.0575980507,
-0.0428388305,
-0.0165751595,
0.0358054712,
0.0080200909,
-0.0215711724,
0.0036473803,
0.0029163004,
-0.0549697019,
0.0200533103,
0.0308401342,
0.0435203314,
-0.0395082086,
-0.0278948769,
-0.0117204897,
-0.0027363077,
0.0415101871,
-0.0009970218,
-0.0401246287,
-0.0509819165,
0.038926769,
0.0212676395,
-0.0206576549,
0.0120958611,
0.0069878586,
-0.0040386445,
0.0497578643,
0.0149262967,
0.031642165,
-0.0279252436,
-0.0151730422,
0.0028795747,
0.0177927129,
-0.0312546119,
0.0130873183,
0.0160691738,
0.0036084065,
-0.0077476394,
-0.0542215779,
-0.0809456632,
-0.0136112534,
-0.0001418313,
0.0338180661,
0.0070458106,
0.0114061264,
0.0348713584,
-0.0717698336,
0.0775282383,
0.0264447853,
-0.0181148425,
-0.0250264294,
0.0118503626,
0.0243894104,
0.0482897274,
-0.0607637018,
0.0337061398,
-0.0122004654,
-0.0384614579,
-0.0804231763,
-0.0290860869,
-0.0207810868,
-0.030793421,
-0.0176287349,
-0.0140941087,
-0.0096570663,
-0.0273594242,
-0.0073993006,
0.0918021947,
-0.0386555381,
0.046017576,
0.0006909153,
-0.0283041075,
-0.0301095154,
0.018436268,
0.0749234781,
0.0216667634,
-0.023969559,
-0.0081945835,
-0.0325625576,
-0.0199492499,
-0.05026602,
-0.0131930439,
0.0248304978,
-0.0374981649,
-0.0213817954,
-0.0621437542,
0.0031720009,
-0.0035233733,
0.0206445847,
-0.0605585352,
-0.0135075981,
0.0058154683,
-0.0176417064,
0.0298526771,
-0.0299182311,
0.0035522564,
-0.0388544686,
0.0142607726,
0.0096358741,
0.0471828803,
0.0241530798,
0.0308693517,
0.0693109185,
0.0027664802,
0.0440200195,
0.0080477316,
0.0139417751,
-0.0054956893,
0.0335948244,
-0.0507686064,
-0.0989679843,
0.0259439256,
0.0335182697,
0.0578420274,
-0.0350116305,
0.0219066422,
0.0738180131,
0.0018932879,
0.0382123217,
0.0077621038,
0.0673662946,
0.0462080501,
0.0439049937,
0.0622520782,
-0.0102577629,
0.0297398549,
-0.0157436226,
0.0418532491,
0.0781615376,
-0.0137682538,
-0.0138489837,
-0.0499169752,
0.0289032161,
-0.0424427539,
-0.0055392142,
-0.0269920789,
-0.012166705,
0.0376760066,
-0.0519228913,
0.0670613796,
0.0013351497,
-0.0447399281,
0.0047751139,
0.0009716614,
-0.0018799922,
0.0231549405,
-0.0087129055,
0.0018579464,
-0.0238554589,
-0.0086816102,
0.0303936824,
0.0094099194,
0.0333514996,
-0.0161745157,
0.0631745979,
-0.0597791076,
0.0121039134,
0.0161434691,
0.0499890707,
-0.0597400665,
0.0394635685,
-0.0474187508,
0.0459017642,
-0.0943029374,
-0.006723084,
0.0187592302,
0.0481331013,
-0.0009470093,
0.0192174986,
0.0391594768,
0.0134762051,
0.0135923354,
0.0054453383,
0.0237172246,
-0.0029825538,
-0.0293840766,
0.00153546,
0.0203293934,
-0.0066039921,
-0.0660161003,
0.0102862613,
-0.0949786752,
-0.025197085,
0.064358443,
-0.0481584594,
-0.0413253419,
-0.0022197478,
-0.060775876,
0.0154611534,
-0.0405904986,
0.0513874032,
-0.006094981,
0.0354168378,
-0.0054257303,
0.0458816513,
0.0266008005,
0.0437708572,
0.0460764021,
-0.039441213,
0.0391048789,
-0.0083647398,
0.0074085551,
-0.1267606318,
-0.0438166037,
-0.0014414468,
0.0462292954,
0.0353817046,
-0.0434056297,
-0.0140345152,
-0.0337537378,
-0.0084012067,
-0.0142401196,
0.0205123965,
0.0548618473,
0.0471474715,
0.0142672993,
-0.0038374523,
-0.009644852,
0.0245096162,
-0.0253962781,
0.0193816051,
0.0748263001,
-0.0046316814,
-0.0410425402,
-0.0531096719,
0.0111542335,
0.0122146206,
0.041222129,
0.0060693887,
0.0183093399,
-0.0023609588,
0.0323260985,
-0.0204868428,
-0.0269917604,
0.046306733,
-0.0763705522,
-0.0307025649,
0.012171193,
0.058366783,
0.0814723596,
0.0045084637,
-0.0085168956,
0.0181551054,
0.0122030973,
-0.0164387077,
-0.0074311076,
-0.0281547159,
0.0216160845,
-0.004919529,
-0.0405808315,
0.0376364365,
0.0267242473,
-0.0032993059,
0.0226623602,
-0.0519666895,
0.0243896488,
0.0031566245,
-0.0044376692,
-0.0262526888,
0.0090152342,
-0.0281222183,
0.0090776198,
-0.0194588955,
-0.0191101823,
0.0537398644,
-0.0185123179,
-0.0107005909,
-0.0230580308,
0.012239839,
-0.0239316002,
-0.0136908246,
-0.0249211341,
0.0288589615,
0.0159360878,
-0.014639806,
-0.0474198833,
0.0084542111,
0.0372002125,
-0.0001293319,
0.0497846417,
-0.0538356155,
-0.0016093469,
-0.0185709689,
-0.0721218362,
-0.0022875746,
-0.0460446812,
-0.0125333192,
0.0123704029,
0.0355722606,
-0.0198313799,
-0.0357612073,
-0.0348625891,
0.0468116291,
0.0292359162,
-0.0143888192,
0.0007893572,
0.0015112964,
0.0631504208,
0.054991845,
0.0033204898,
0.0369984359,
-0.0165477842,
0.0257365331,
0.0136753805,
-0.0114660067,
0.0057108924,
0.0014835609,
-0.0181034971,
-0.0052233534,
-0.0197044536,
0.0018051143,
0.0423024632,
0.044931598,
-0.0416256338,
-0.0062253727,
0.1090624928,
-0.0128785986,
0.0085231476,
0.0059414268,
0.0012442905,
0.0475440957,
-0.0150557673,
-0.0176824927,
-0.0466112345,
-0.0456355549,
0.0156818312,
0.0138025815,
0.0209603943,
-0.0265565477,
-0.0081877001,
-0.0344586708,
0.0236717667,
0.008606378,
-0.0617182516,
-0.0445900485,
-0.0272287093,
0.0640233532,
-0.0096774735,
-0.0082991589,
0.026822051,
-0.0429214761,
0.0157694984,
-0.0508266538,
-0.0863191113,
-0.0573913828,
-0.0398435071,
-0.044715371,
0.0495381467,
-0.0039441912,
0.0347294509,
0.0199911352,
-0.0140966885,
0.0382783227,
-0.0272840001,
-0.0328332111,
-0.0035868566,
0.0210593138,
0.0363892429,
0.0006990747,
-0.016983727,
0.031974107,
-0.0044103474,
0.0238891505,
-0.001768453,
0.0078096851,
0.0422740839,
-0.034702085,
0.0307840351,
0.0183684547,
-0.0209538341,
0.0728289634,
0.0886747763,
0.0186535083,
-0.0423420221,
-0.0055580926,
-0.0138726784,
-0.0698893517,
-0.0425562561,
0.0002206998,
-0.0097679598,
-0.0457859375,
-0.087906301,
-0.0459641144,
0.0132845119,
-0.0033010922,
-0.0189431533,
0.0151768243,
0.001815391,
0.0203235373,
-0.0009701089,
-0.0231888462,
-0.0185726844,
0.0349153019,
-0.0235563088,
0.0362137705,
-0.0155973397,
0.0331885628,
-0.0181356985,
0.0387180299,
-0.0426507182,
-0.0289401971,
0.0080900788,
0.04449654,
0.016453281,
0.0002221489,
-0.0107523156,
-0.0457492732,
-0.0044136955,
0.0045932243,
-0.0379904732,
0.0814246386,
0.0657620281,
-0.0202465914,
0.0150679238,
0.0852223709,
-0.0528652109,
0.0180593152,
-0.0119404495,
0.0693952069,
0.0025943839,
-0.0344815291,
0.0089925667,
0.0449385494,
0.0203022994,
-0.0200357474,
0.0081626438,
0.025081154,
-0.0031910627,
-0.0434406027,
-0.0167653169,
-0.0319958106,
0.009747915,
0.0011417627,
0.0681863055,
-0.0444022305,
0.0174964666,
-0.0000301949,
-0.0059572738,
0.0107828705,
-0.0243971162,
-0.0028777621,
-0.0153260035,
-0.0123112863,
-0.0184452739,
-0.0396403819,
-0.0253434833,
-0.0336756557,
-0.0165572036,
-0.0149707273,
-0.0435822904,
0.0075120227,
0.0278854799,
-0.0459110923,
0.0284882318,
-0.0195685159,
0.0305858031,
-0.0171814915,
0.02238103,
0.0599636994,
0.0160888992,
0.1276349276,
-0.0171022713,
-0.020734122,
-0.0263315979,
0.04416411,
-0.0063164053,
-0.0249124374,
-0.0044796742,
0.0100533282,
0.0168145578,
0.0496049821,
0.075220786,
-0.0575426929,
0.016466517,
-0.0294051822,
0.0057351277,
-0.0447518155,
-0.0252768248,
-0.0641672239,
0.0530868955,
0.0143327657,
-0.0229824465,
-0.0708734766,
-0.0543798245,
0.0146793956,
0.0201176945,
0.0209249686,
-0.0178595185,
0.0217022151,
0.0260393955,
-0.0190623049,
-0.049998574,
-0.0177693199,
-0.040959917,
0.0133400559,
-0.0296349563,
-0.0450699814,
-6.300213318e-33,
-0.0058087241,
0.008476913,
-0.036101345,
-0.035515137,
-0.03130126,
0.0496926755,
-0.094969444,
0.0040118317,
-0.0240891818,
0.0607862175,
0.0019964718,
0.0060517266,
0.0157345906,
-0.0032707129,
-0.0287886001,
0.0405525528,
0.0679517612,
0.017714154,
-0.0451077633,
-0.0103184478,
-0.0404931195,
0.0082823494,
0.0245089475,
-0.1006616205,
-0.0402220637,
0.0289341025,
-0.078491874,
0.011015553,
0.068777889,
0.0306297131,
0.0342446119,
0.0525198169,
0.0146535682,
-0.0352148414,
-0.026327448,
-0.0122857997,
-0.0884610265,
-0.0366951078,
0.066751942,
-0.0269457381,
-0.05056284,
-0.0457759425,
0.0416987166,
-0.0143437879,
-0.004889234,
-0.0247103311,
0.0294228848,
-0.0480758287,
0.0038255702,
-0.0618603751,
-0.0420423485,
0.0188619494,
-0.0253350139,
-0.0300814454,
-0.0011529571,
0.0126580866,
-0.048316516,
-0.0208529942,
0.0009059448,
0.0326123126,
0.0296830684,
0.0812526345,
0.0063298596,
-0.0527046733,
-0.0178598985,
0.020199202,
0.0164138973,
0.0034715831,
0.0085902894,
-0.0374403857,
0.0328067988,
0.032218419,
0.0729951784,
0.0414244607,
-0.0143176634,
0.0468193293,
-0.0528350659,
0.0405869521,
0.0210509636,
0.0485384539,
-0.0264763124,
0.0092462702,
-0.0151016535,
-0.0097736623,
-0.021739265,
0.0284758862,
-0.021003319,
-0.0203585085,
0.0063517992,
0.0213985741,
-0.0225978848,
-0.0264334362,
0.0243885089,
-0.0200055353,
0.00368155,
0.041272182,
0.0029434329,
0.0369616337,
0.009173817,
-0.0475339331,
-0.0076373359,
0.0347085372,
0.0301345102,
0.0524486639,
0.0116866957,
-0.019885648,
0.0589981042,
0.0189935081,
-0.0566587187,
0.0121232932,
0.0006373814,
-0.0354774296,
-0.0128665809,
-0.0636294112,
0.0039523793,
0.0182772484,
-0.008964357,
0.0043843458,
0.0182557944,
-0.014243695,
0.0117730983,
0.0247355551,
0.0438669473,
0.0261244327,
-0.0308692195,
0.002575089,
-0.0166643076,
0.0023104348,
0.0143221235,
-0.0258261003,
-0.0377920903,
-0.0117922286,
2.446e-7,
0.0562153831,
0.0277459733,
0.0185058676,
0.0040709595,
-0.0060896762,
0.0165894739,
0.031554278,
-0.0113792755,
-0.0255999137,
0.0422798917,
0.0677145869,
-0.0232762992,
0.0398436636,
-0.0435744524,
-0.1200421527,
0.0053270184,
-0.04020923,
-0.0603389964,
0.0205227174,
-0.0308227688,
0.0221334063,
0.0426015332,
-0.001184994,
0.0150462873,
-0.0073611285,
-0.0326404981,
0.0148712471,
-0.0388236456,
0.0196484737,
0.0249188766,
0.0542534404,
-0.0026842447,
0.0105349449,
-0.0230001416,
-0.0275424253,
0.0030271017,
0.0440425575,
0.0892717913,
-0.0031003486,
0.0311525185,
-0.0020186757,
-0.0562436394,
0.0037896845,
-0.0154880499,
0.0504386313,
-0.0587855764,
0.0223553795,
0.0049183425,
-0.0424003154,
0.0173211768,
0.0051305583,
0.0237001237,
-0.1063957512,
0.0213064793,
0.0359337516,
0.0007720272,
-0.0383075885,
-0.0621523708,
-0.0596313775,
0.0172072295,
0.0227833949,
-0.0137581425,
0.0056663402,
0.0090665696,
0.020677764,
-0.0573697016,
0.0212345459,
2.16508978e-34,
0.0558044724,
-0.0358286873,
0.0455487482,
0.0308565721,
0.0243898053,
-0.0348607786,
-0.0281967279,
-0.0252564289,
0.003670502,
-0.067899555,
-0.0035340574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08167v1 | Multiclass Classification of Policy Documents with Large Language Models | 2023-10-12T09:41:22 | 2023-10-12T09:41:22 | Erkan Gunes, Christoffer Koch Florczak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Classifying policy documents into policy issue topics has been a long-time
effort in political science and communication disciplines. Efforts to automate
text classification processes for social science research purposes have so far
achieved remarkable results, but there is still a large room for progress. In
this work, we test the prediction performance of an alternative strategy, which
requires human involvement much less than full manual coding. We use the GPT
3.5 and GPT 4 models of the OpenAI, which are pre-trained instruction-tuned
Large Language Models (LLM), to classify congressional bills and congressional
hearings into Comparative Agendas Project's 21 major policy issue topics. We
propose three use-case scenarios and estimate overall accuracies ranging from
%58-83 depending on scenario and GPT model employed. The three scenarios aims
at minimal, moderate, and major human interference, respectively. Overall, our
results point towards the insufficiency of complete reliance on GPT with
minimal human intervention, an increasing accuracy along with the human effort
exerted, and a surprisingly high accuracy achieved in the most humanly
demanding use-case. However, the superior use-case achieved the %83 accuracy on
the %65 of the data in which the two models agreed, suggesting that a similar
approach to ours can be relatively easily implemented and allow for mostly
automated coding of a majority of a given dataset. This could free up resources
allowing manual human coding of the remaining %35 of the data to achieve an
overall higher level of accuracy while reducing costs significantly. | [
0.0046453741,
0.0931055248,
0.0051976652,
0.0078997891,
-0.0250190143,
0.0459581055,
0.0301039107,
0.0396094136,
0.0226061102,
-0.1151918247,
0.0354177058,
-0.0194586199,
-0.0139135439,
0.0381280333,
-0.0188955199,
-0.0785030872,
0.0394026116,
0.0007246139,
0.0591621175,
0.0042430409,
-0.0206531119,
0.0101666991,
0.0111372173,
0.0799530894,
0.0086052613,
-0.0028485532,
-0.045210436,
-0.0569343753,
0.0203246158,
-0.0080633694,
0.0562037863,
0.0755050704,
0.0317687355,
0.0404235087,
0.0000019425,
-0.0292151552,
-0.0106241005,
0.0014617601,
0.0247744974,
0.018496858,
0.0636596382,
-0.0194692351,
-0.0165015869,
0.0323441029,
-0.0150955683,
0.0075220186,
0.0381290056,
0.0147655532,
0.0475367419,
0.0484682173,
-0.0082722725,
-0.0414549336,
0.0273615681,
-0.0258012898,
0.0163008515,
-0.0501144566,
0.0486551337,
-0.0156802535,
-0.0471789874,
0.0100288587,
0.0081780618,
0.0116733592,
0.0015180042,
0.011181308,
-0.0234589595,
0.0487389714,
-0.0151410913,
-0.0014224749,
0.0037502628,
0.0190574285,
-0.005552839,
-0.0335820951,
0.038697578,
-0.0280906074,
-0.0109642996,
0.0209303368,
-0.0258457027,
0.0322812311,
-0.0089704422,
0.0385378189,
0.0530957133,
0.0052809273,
0.0128866229,
0.0553805679,
-0.0323187932,
0.0379235148,
-0.0333917327,
-0.0366974138,
0.0378457978,
0.0148741044,
0.017912332,
-0.0543021448,
0.0106405374,
0.00205877,
-0.0026682508,
0.0272642262,
-0.0103932107,
-0.0126678357,
0.0279023517,
-0.0830320269,
0.0206794534,
0.0191910602,
0.0002252873,
0.0634136647,
0.0268102605,
0.0211542472,
-0.0080371173,
0.0196626484,
0.0198798012,
0.0162120722,
-0.0638736188,
-0.0012072622,
-0.0417112559,
0.0512620807,
-0.024759233,
-0.0041129971,
-0.0422548279,
-0.0063026859,
-0.027374262,
0.0074909255,
0.0073322626,
-0.0109281596,
-0.0321254544,
-0.0379178338,
-0.059754055,
0.0397542045,
0.0002468477,
0.0317222737,
-0.0341071151,
0.0463465601,
0.0451715216,
0.0426290669,
-0.0109383268,
0.0220191237,
0.0041048806,
0.0127275428,
-0.032103043,
-0.0364555679,
-0.0348002166,
0.000830991,
-0.0248883553,
-0.0264913552,
0.0125742033,
-0.0465645045,
0.0002419553,
-0.0407295674,
0.0037337984,
-0.0195125192,
-0.0121591203,
-0.0137078371,
-0.018979067,
0.0720405132,
0.0071570505,
0.0034924415,
0.0759177804,
0.0175929256,
0.0200051349,
0.0595808513,
0.0300295576,
0.030854363,
0.0347752795,
-0.0289993864,
0.038378913,
0.0351021029,
-0.0274472721,
0.04122518,
-0.0024302101,
0.0265526734,
-0.0022410473,
-0.0103755509,
0.0186111238,
0.0126866167,
0.012287817,
-0.0023881572,
0.0460772477,
0.0751167014,
-0.0230471045,
0.0245747659,
-0.0098276036,
0.0447486378,
0.0175174065,
-0.0108826766,
0.0340549871,
0.0039020036,
-0.0213911906,
-0.0202131867,
0.0465631336,
-0.0167311728,
-0.0281718597,
-0.0495555364,
-0.0118931644,
-0.0392388925,
0.0140987495,
-0.0071659102,
0.0644450411,
-0.0318272002,
-0.0469163582,
0.0101997983,
0.0280079339,
-0.0218900796,
-0.0108795669,
-0.0856536254,
0.0404467955,
0.0146783665,
0.0085026519,
-0.0498206802,
-0.0100640235,
-0.0349187069,
0.0426929407,
0.0387724154,
0.097394444,
-0.0394861326,
-0.0588481836,
-0.0450562015,
-0.0149549488,
0.0144546963,
0.0329644866,
0.0737954304,
0.0257845726,
-0.0008588542,
0.0128197502,
0.0247065481,
-0.0237312336,
0.0517455973,
0.0013872074,
-0.0340054482,
0.0117378132,
0.0222731791,
0.0823782161,
-0.0052665644,
-0.0136409365,
-0.0301711205,
0.0134905213,
-0.0233069416,
-0.015598393,
-0.0788042843,
0.0031869481,
0.0554055944,
0.0002977794,
0.0281405151,
-0.0227179099,
0.0363481902,
-0.0467581265,
-0.0102781951,
0.0097521143,
0.0080707846,
0.0122575378,
-0.0630849972,
-0.0001846338,
-0.0204710569,
-0.0395959653,
-0.0638526827,
0.0603444502,
0.0222061165,
0.0127534233,
-0.0071370155,
-0.0475849472,
0.0542533137,
-0.0323895738,
-0.0107337236,
0.0676132962,
0.0033379765,
0.0330503546,
0.0244433749,
0.0034636599,
-0.0024962546,
-0.0793150812,
-0.0679389387,
0.0068021212,
-0.0245151538,
0.0338047408,
-0.0024197884,
-0.0619600825,
-0.0096419686,
0.0285106208,
-0.0233280025,
-0.0183288287,
-0.0504120439,
-0.003869541,
0.0306840818,
-0.0038685796,
-0.01210168,
-0.0173101518,
0.0144332303,
-0.0418932289,
0.0104636913,
0.0425532348,
-0.0323398151,
-0.032102868,
0.0492115654,
-0.0144735426,
-0.005857544,
-0.0114267841,
-0.0388412401,
0.0163191166,
-0.0082513625,
0.0075683128,
0.0200842526,
0.033742018,
0.0772540867,
0.0701786429,
0.03361452,
-0.0475400612,
0.0075946106,
-0.0340956822,
0.0040015168,
-0.0311798751,
0.0226424802,
0.0499972329,
0.0571555421,
0.0063321004,
0.0001418576,
-0.0731158033,
0.0176699851,
-0.0238071103,
0.0441725254,
-0.0366644189,
-0.0246696956,
-0.0275002569,
0.003913701,
0.017292574,
-0.0357517079,
0.0217388514,
0.016625369,
0.0322991498,
-0.0788994655,
-0.0259051081,
-0.0390575677,
0.0763275325,
0.0074490979,
0.0110147707,
-0.041594211,
-0.0154395401,
-0.0101998709,
-0.0142312758,
0.0110891555,
-0.035088554,
0.0475402102,
-0.0583071373,
0.0270489119,
-0.0512019619,
-0.0587546304,
-0.0181022249,
-0.0673784763,
-0.0034888671,
0.0165514182,
0.0108245797,
-0.0371546447,
-0.0044929753,
0.0540368669,
-0.0144970333,
0.0687917769,
0.0146065317,
-0.0089459084,
0.010061549,
0.0031320637,
-0.0091128554,
-0.0190742332,
-0.0698828921,
0.0236567128,
0.0127911922,
-0.0133529902,
0.0506224036,
0.0472161733,
-0.0454037599,
-0.0391539782,
0.0244867392,
-0.073265247,
-0.0126596084,
0.0336407833,
-0.0050543393,
-0.0607806891,
0.0271291304,
0.0792649612,
0.0520303212,
-0.0890476778,
-0.0241538808,
0.0234201588,
-0.0080295429,
0.0190447085,
0.0037397163,
-0.0819262266,
0.0209306329,
0.0306205768,
0.0100315008,
-0.0431646444,
-0.0254383031,
0.0040483885,
-0.0836525634,
0.0452279933,
0.0157276709,
-0.0405067466,
-0.0194821972,
-0.0597502887,
0.0085233189,
-0.0143601149,
-0.040906392,
-0.0243728906,
0.02286922,
-0.001593909,
0.0196650624,
-0.0746188909,
-0.0631267726,
0.0366274789,
0.0293568857,
0.0399915166,
0.0476303212,
0.086744003,
-0.0231820289,
-0.0148089118,
0.0942194983,
-0.0381227545,
-0.0357193984,
0.0236887932,
0.0319257081,
-0.0123407086,
0.0194512624,
0.0165552441,
0.032497935,
0.0042309132,
-0.0142697282,
0.0028526036,
0.0592954941,
-0.0710367635,
-0.0575386584,
0.024077408,
-0.0296677873,
0.0074185994,
0.0576858856,
0.0074874689,
-0.0253442414,
-0.0195012987,
-0.0401453227,
0.016510956,
-0.0164897572,
-0.005277148,
-0.0044693067,
-0.0461636782,
-0.0231371596,
-0.0050020618,
-0.0214231648,
0.0289699621,
0.0114606321,
0.0007613124,
0.0046307882,
0.0528469048,
0.0334949084,
0.0176224504,
0.0045095277,
-0.0207241978,
-0.0153755778,
-0.0460144132,
-0.1081808433,
0.0075915586,
0.0545856059,
-0.0461209901,
-0.025004169,
-0.0087591615,
-0.0473964103,
0.0042766123,
-0.0272213947,
0.0289006159,
-0.0361020565,
0.0020789893,
-0.0312844776,
0.0383950397,
0.0667762384,
-0.0106530339,
-0.0398419313,
0.039077282,
0.0407903939,
-0.0240652468,
0.0005288934,
-0.0089581693,
0.0163708311,
-0.0157917775,
-0.0519145355,
-0.0710507706,
-0.0201485809,
-0.0008492455,
0.0309208017,
0.0632972345,
-0.0218414348,
-0.0690439343,
-0.0646948144,
-0.0068935053,
0.0076804436,
-0.0185264237,
0.0001047303,
-0.0219593849,
0.0304286387,
-0.0189402904,
-0.0496253893,
0.0616871566,
0.0161299128,
0.0073884386,
-0.0114547908,
0.0349488556,
-0.0125763873,
0.0761339739,
0.0210297704,
-0.0104102399,
-0.0573045686,
0.0146763651,
0.0250446573,
0.0132225733,
0.0000853683,
0.0606856346,
-0.0033509824,
0.0252936799,
0.0195469689,
-0.0158771593,
-0.0372994281,
-0.0229192469,
-0.040446341,
0.0618798397,
0.0096868891,
0.0087269899,
-0.0214675292,
-0.0528864115,
-0.0445979051,
-0.0057472512,
0.0275530778,
-0.0114332363,
-0.0232200902,
0.0357182026,
-0.0052899807,
-0.0526049435,
-0.0083885463,
0.0458427779,
0.0209918078,
0.0188513603,
0.0376957096,
-0.0291098878,
-0.0269966107,
-0.0443203896,
0.0250167344,
0.0078524472,
-0.0175076891,
-0.0265227295,
-0.0378650278,
-0.0023089533,
-0.0082802931,
-0.0256292764,
0.0102850161,
-0.0072522801,
-0.0038535546,
0.0476223528,
-0.0370160304,
0.0276936051,
-0.0492753461,
-0.0399206802,
-0.0491547175,
-0.0002619972,
-0.0190314092,
-5.749208423e-33,
-0.0241181515,
-0.0520537868,
0.0130484914,
0.0067425924,
0.030838212,
-0.0039243614,
-0.009833619,
0.005282213,
0.0227938406,
-0.0156176239,
0.0212391205,
0.0086165583,
0.0159931388,
0.0056661456,
0.021608863,
-0.003048609,
0.0155442962,
-0.0271969046,
-0.0200920552,
0.0300843976,
0.0076569747,
-0.0334882215,
0.0056211068,
-0.0716960505,
0.0466979258,
0.0450442582,
-0.0081965812,
-0.0502121411,
-0.0125503242,
0.0456255227,
-0.0305625852,
0.0347787999,
0.0581194647,
-0.0198576488,
0.021739088,
0.0789317042,
-0.0142616639,
-0.034465,
-0.0551828258,
-0.0398700014,
0.0448375344,
-0.0529287122,
0.0215302054,
0.0490882285,
-0.0753979832,
-0.0153008318,
0.051455304,
-0.021354381,
0.0144887753,
-0.0351260863,
-0.0521401912,
0.0416319445,
0.0053558834,
0.0208050758,
0.0096936785,
0.0171987433,
0.0051834253,
0.0553373136,
-0.0481438302,
0.007718456,
0.0042095818,
0.0039204326,
-0.0035993385,
-0.0384381972,
-0.0049668988,
0.0373376496,
0.0084467772,
0.0340983532,
-0.0444100946,
-0.0261991508,
0.0376294665,
-0.0057068504,
0.0454509184,
0.0332181267,
0.0718754306,
-0.0595070757,
-0.0663950369,
0.0523563698,
0.0364545099,
-0.0180790685,
0.0341290385,
-0.0070667835,
-0.024850525,
-0.0283597466,
-0.0373509116,
-0.0499254577,
-0.0016786201,
-0.0023631509,
0.0214145668,
0.0151278563,
0.0276544821,
0.0437009484,
0.0120191602,
-0.031401556,
-0.0002554375,
0.0065648118,
-0.0449076928,
0.0311729889,
-0.0062332829,
0.0200347118,
-0.0834789127,
-0.0704679042,
-0.0005426112,
0.0090928795,
0.0449027829,
-0.0075106276,
0.0221203621,
0.0008746746,
-0.088208288,
-0.0049589695,
-0.0004178478,
-0.0199743658,
0.0514799207,
0.0757701695,
0.0191707686,
-0.0116800191,
0.0679621249,
0.035682641,
0.0062568723,
0.0000609219,
-0.0040504839,
-0.025399683,
-0.0485611521,
-0.0037769228,
-0.0240359157,
0.0029365509,
-0.0099327564,
0.0097133424,
0.0399007984,
-0.0070361295,
-0.0167969819,
-0.0096938778,
2.53e-7,
0.0443777964,
0.0736487061,
-0.0451385193,
-0.0278689973,
-0.0065852893,
0.0341569409,
-0.0271649323,
0.0384792425,
-0.0424119756,
-0.0063127531,
0.0415069796,
-0.0257338732,
0.0471907593,
0.0359030515,
-0.1016333327,
-0.0264898501,
-0.0495651737,
0.0379484966,
-0.1060570851,
0.0447218567,
0.0249759108,
0.0492237061,
0.0490469113,
0.0094131837,
-0.0137277842,
-0.0107045965,
0.0514390692,
-0.0446784683,
-0.0327797905,
0.0223237723,
0.0296805277,
0.017692497,
-0.0319444053,
0.0548634566,
-0.0176629964,
-0.0113642132,
-0.0151358005,
0.0999116153,
-0.0136262458,
0.0075362884,
-0.011118561,
-0.0159146003,
-0.0131835956,
-0.0175192375,
0.057794597,
-0.0574040189,
-0.033854045,
-0.0104342708,
0.0153349973,
-0.0189819094,
0.041882921,
0.0029781116,
0.0306279138,
-0.0002136565,
-0.0130010676,
-0.0398533195,
0.0219636634,
-0.0684996173,
0.0280880425,
0.0206525587,
-0.0458774231,
-0.0436493494,
0.0070292465,
0.019085994,
0.0842037871,
-0.0722163171,
0.0409905538,
2.443816021e-34,
0.0130594885,
-0.0057251812,
-0.0195766781,
-0.0210535452,
0.0562245212,
0.0266219024,
0.0053095636,
0.0106654931,
-0.0044270954,
-0.0789377019,
0.0208060071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08166v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08166v3 | Ziya-Visual: Bilingual Large Vision-Language Model via Multi-Task Instruction Tuning | 2023-10-12T09:39:17 | 2023-10-31T17:51:51 | Junyu Lu, Dixiang Zhang, Xiaojun Wu, Xinyu Gao, Ruyi Gan, Jiaxing Zhang, Yan Song, Pingjian Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements enlarge the capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
in zero-shot image-to-text generation and understanding by integrating
multi-modal inputs. However, such success is typically limited to English
scenarios due to the lack of large-scale and high-quality non-English
multi-modal resources, making it extremely difficult to establish competitive
counterparts in other languages. In this paper, we introduce the Ziya-Visual
series, a set of bilingual large-scale vision-language models (LVLMs) designed
to incorporate visual semantics into LLM for multi-modal dialogue. Composed of
Ziya-Visual-Base and Ziya-Visual-Chat, our models adopt the Querying
Transformer from BLIP-2, further exploring the assistance of optimization
schemes such as instruction tuning, multi-stage training and low-rank
adaptation module for visual-language alignment. In addition, we stimulate the
understanding ability of GPT-4 in multi-modal scenarios, translating our
gathered English image-text datasets into Chinese and generating
instruction-response through the in-context learning method. The experiment
results demonstrate that compared to the existing LVLMs, Ziya-Visual achieves
competitive performance across a wide range of English-only tasks including
zero-shot image-text retrieval, image captioning, and visual question
answering. The evaluation leaderboard accessed by GPT-4 also indicates that our
models possess satisfactory image-text understanding and generation
capabilities in Chinese multi-modal scenario dialogues. Code, demo and models
are available at
~\url{https://huggingface.co/IDEA-CCNL/Ziya-BLIP2-14B-Visual-v1}. | [
0.0173166171,
0.0209499896,
0.008394354,
0.0838894099,
-0.0128818275,
0.0142736556,
0.0211114231,
-0.0149401659,
0.0116759911,
-0.055038847,
-0.0712328106,
-0.0553083606,
-0.0061925757,
0.0278731324,
0.0343595967,
-0.0579351485,
0.0212687906,
-0.0371168517,
-0.0131527232,
-0.0019197594,
0.0328448005,
0.0035062167,
-0.0049866051,
0.0269137286,
0.0033440373,
-0.0395888798,
-0.0188337173,
0.0343480669,
0.029704703,
-0.0212391336,
-0.0203354172,
0.0283354875,
0.056220822,
0.0286722202,
0.0000017682,
-0.0122430967,
0.0088728312,
-0.0043954621,
0.0272136908,
-0.0260431096,
0.0371294357,
-0.0526007228,
-0.0074863359,
0.0008382596,
-0.04055411,
-0.020721959,
0.0783911198,
0.0504462272,
0.088174805,
0.0690526739,
-0.0246363617,
-0.0387755111,
0.0068906569,
-0.0169414207,
0.0377167724,
-0.0478951186,
-0.0048791943,
0.0214932952,
0.0176584702,
0.0160325635,
-0.0417606086,
0.0541402698,
0.0286237635,
-0.049908638,
-0.0352371298,
0.0338196009,
-0.0278417803,
-0.0463937931,
-0.0268780012,
0.1112946495,
-0.0095274206,
0.0162240285,
-0.0255490467,
0.0255701076,
-0.0014662127,
-0.0386395156,
-0.0801370963,
0.0772631913,
0.0097732963,
0.0068427045,
-0.034211643,
0.0010632473,
-0.0143661853,
0.0083306003,
0.0002041594,
-0.0154805006,
0.0172755625,
0.0033009381,
-0.0352917388,
-0.000354018,
-0.0271344129,
-0.0516749062,
-0.0232556649,
0.0591789819,
-0.0407184102,
0.0235555414,
-0.0462397896,
-0.0128889307,
-0.0144269252,
-0.0526295453,
0.0325374193,
0.0505270772,
-0.0525662638,
0.0779534057,
-0.0111931218,
0.0866990015,
-0.0118538523,
0.0361131653,
-0.0673507974,
-0.0374132134,
-0.022872569,
-0.0010283919,
-0.0519362502,
0.0095063848,
-0.0797064677,
-0.0465691052,
-0.0210535079,
0.0443091765,
0.0021944349,
0.0078860652,
0.0078000054,
0.0114167435,
-0.0566055588,
-0.0110647874,
-0.0236593317,
0.0752699748,
0.017106127,
-0.0012661722,
-0.0248814598,
-0.0481582955,
-0.0160848424,
0.0654809549,
0.0054905904,
-0.0431777276,
-0.0194322467,
0.0738814846,
-0.0768875703,
-0.0209260006,
-0.0039480641,
0.0031618259,
-0.0224162992,
-0.0637137145,
0.014140646,
-0.0358398557,
0.0334596373,
-0.0080741663,
-0.0083387867,
0.0151652005,
0.0118085453,
0.0246735066,
-0.0050022593,
0.0783315003,
0.0326003395,
0.0017747504,
0.012163992,
0.0294008758,
0.0310286786,
0.1087737605,
0.0229237974,
0.0205128882,
0.0368409604,
0.0029152152,
-0.0049180104,
0.0318814069,
-0.0074911914,
0.0134015689,
-0.033902429,
0.0375543162,
0.0229499526,
0.0278716497,
0.0261070263,
0.0425526388,
-0.049918063,
-0.0079154903,
0.0714805871,
0.0084664337,
0.0139905671,
0.0021509139,
0.0513208099,
0.0200653337,
0.0039137835,
-0.0063101132,
-0.0483406372,
0.0852209851,
-0.0039780079,
0.0187241882,
0.0057404367,
0.0325725563,
-0.0621407703,
-0.0337531529,
0.0024391206,
-0.0036956498,
0.0093822842,
0.0214101933,
0.0315035805,
0.0137963854,
-0.0605612621,
0.0240048263,
-0.0036459214,
-0.0326848887,
0.0105147883,
-0.0332301781,
0.0101131396,
0.0568237416,
0.0111998748,
0.0035762989,
-0.0343548991,
0.0020925088,
0.0354309715,
0.0686542466,
-0.0122605907,
-0.0096560922,
0.0276239701,
-0.0816424489,
-0.0149365356,
-0.0280695781,
-0.0221215989,
0.0138428984,
-0.0213088877,
0.0023980318,
0.0259881634,
0.0087339915,
-0.0029622712,
0.0185956974,
0.0134136342,
-0.0064453026,
-0.017196361,
0.0188403185,
-0.0058516269,
-0.007647377,
-0.0168870874,
-0.0176183395,
0.0248757042,
-0.030871693,
0.0178267192,
0.0417458005,
-0.0439979322,
-0.0832443163,
0.035478659,
-0.0428968892,
0.0058903242,
-0.0166244879,
-0.0600610785,
-0.0530635454,
0.0149067594,
-0.0285298582,
-0.025142476,
-0.0702630728,
0.0155318687,
0.0181071106,
0.028754808,
-0.0408975929,
0.0410433561,
0.0170991812,
-0.0229153745,
0.0562727004,
0.0391286276,
0.0050991839,
-0.0558709539,
-0.0339870043,
0.0443384424,
0.0069569843,
0.0313972719,
-0.0006415558,
0.0468718521,
-0.0470200107,
-0.020638058,
-0.1301974952,
0.0117533421,
-0.0168385487,
-0.0212710723,
0.0198249836,
-0.0019235131,
0.0102131898,
-0.0369395725,
-0.0598812774,
0.0394102782,
0.0479081795,
0.0004978543,
0.0436629541,
0.0206464231,
0.0076818522,
-0.015859222,
0.0147386976,
0.0302361548,
0.0450434051,
0.0157696512,
-0.0011141512,
-0.0400443152,
0.0270127952,
-0.0360411964,
0.0219376162,
-0.0202608146,
-0.0513459593,
-0.0076160142,
0.0012579407,
0.0648081973,
0.0698036477,
0.0124487234,
0.0039275461,
-0.00190484,
-0.0339170955,
-0.0213818178,
0.0327972285,
0.0067415205,
-0.0746055841,
-0.0150516191,
-0.0112599349,
-0.0330186784,
0.0328836441,
-0.0191878621,
0.0108419489,
-0.0778134763,
0.0030276938,
0.0194515791,
-0.0286849588,
-0.0476174392,
0.0420065559,
-0.0055063446,
0.0126861455,
-0.0518587008,
-0.0381888077,
0.0491078757,
-0.0362778902,
-0.0546331853,
-0.0287684426,
0.0031466801,
-0.0383277014,
0.0515865944,
0.013488533,
0.0314785205,
-0.0118825519,
-0.0020774805,
-0.0742521286,
-0.0104689477,
0.0046962691,
-0.0153463501,
0.0540986471,
-0.061575342,
0.0201998018,
-0.0683446378,
-0.0335463248,
-0.023166975,
-0.0193919875,
-0.0091413306,
0.0027742763,
-0.0355026349,
-0.0022423293,
-0.0249179807,
0.0361819603,
0.0462304801,
0.0116448887,
-0.0292491037,
0.0139798298,
-0.0265584607,
0.0357690752,
0.0608130805,
0.0589453429,
-0.0353565551,
-0.0553377755,
0.0346666276,
0.0473489203,
0.0273782108,
-0.0132438056,
-0.0096856244,
0.0115659675,
0.0279847886,
0.0494212843,
-0.0154662281,
0.0018490474,
0.0561648197,
-0.0485733934,
-0.0111975754,
0.0584129691,
-0.0010421156,
-0.0320665427,
-0.0332657024,
-0.0159841441,
0.0276689101,
0.022359442,
0.0341156647,
-0.1190443113,
-0.0325609967,
-0.0360548012,
-0.0285177454,
0.0150712226,
0.0209997129,
-0.0474019386,
-0.1035389006,
0.0549771227,
0.0091776177,
-0.0183109455,
-0.016554581,
0.0346576832,
-0.0073360899,
-0.0092711374,
0.0073925029,
0.0019479735,
-0.0010225958,
-0.0088489335,
-0.0122819645,
0.0697084963,
-0.0422778502,
0.0138015933,
-0.0179322176,
-0.0037101305,
0.0246674865,
0.036644347,
-0.0006339062,
-0.0434041321,
-0.0064291069,
-0.0146082556,
-0.0155938482,
0.0099333636,
0.0351243243,
-0.0105585512,
-0.0364564955,
0.009511197,
0.020509772,
0.0105166379,
-0.0119282817,
-0.0083435206,
0.0231222678,
-0.0084584914,
0.0122312689,
-0.0034410271,
0.0282705836,
0.0028795211,
0.0526901297,
0.0103581175,
-0.0372642949,
-0.0363829993,
-0.0060588256,
-0.0299195983,
-0.0826169029,
-0.0261533689,
0.0062734536,
-0.0179201085,
0.0204179995,
-0.0659705773,
-0.013100964,
0.0233934894,
0.0726727247,
-0.0230800249,
-0.009216208,
-0.023990592,
0.0219274815,
-0.0280686077,
0.0466196574,
-0.0226016995,
0.0291868448,
-0.0567510501,
0.0076290555,
0.0306468457,
-0.0597614497,
0.0050880271,
0.0191553831,
-0.0874036252,
-0.0524598919,
-0.0598840266,
0.0681755021,
0.0115452539,
0.035879191,
0.0168711226,
-0.0442974605,
0.0180404466,
0.0179629829,
0.0297802798,
0.0119341724,
0.0105365692,
0.0249612071,
-0.0118544046,
0.0536923222,
-0.0178841874,
0.0062679481,
0.0063705654,
0.0381076485,
-0.0092002032,
-0.0226333179,
0.0044221496,
0.0149926804,
-0.0073354584,
-0.0011986393,
0.0045961542,
-0.0259412639,
0.0253447946,
-0.028478533,
-0.0346970148,
-0.0773221925,
-0.0007698886,
0.0145731438,
-0.023963511,
0.0236520004,
0.0264362544,
0.0012427022,
0.0060961754,
-0.0256270114,
-0.0027460344,
0.011680658,
-0.0158529654,
0.0158661883,
0.0257085841,
-0.0091553079,
0.0079059051,
0.0077351625,
0.0503114015,
-0.0090904785,
0.096727185,
0.0161241759,
-0.0374838747,
-0.0069299061,
0.0501410924,
-0.0055822162,
-0.0434941128,
-0.0093090143,
0.038496539,
0.0810243413,
0.0321143232,
0.0472304337,
0.0063141021,
-0.0194583461,
-0.0140781403,
0.0570198633,
0.0088770855,
-0.0548610166,
0.0699187219,
0.0044929069,
-0.0095994035,
-0.006881556,
0.0685958564,
0.010281438,
-0.0013375967,
-0.0035636825,
0.033437565,
-0.042881757,
-0.0274661463,
0.033671692,
-0.0134248864,
-0.0015088652,
0.0280678049,
-0.0133881522,
-0.0399577171,
-0.014408106,
-0.0001050788,
-0.0414829925,
0.0024319731,
0.0467124395,
0.0630684122,
0.0322426856,
-0.011522783,
-0.0280577987,
-0.0072612572,
0.005862535,
0.0008819743,
0.0054749432,
-5.726660972e-33,
-0.0615699925,
-0.0199143589,
0.0585767627,
-0.0266780499,
-0.0398993678,
-0.0014950045,
-0.0285902657,
-0.0066182953,
-0.0423938334,
-0.0098590143,
0.0311914086,
-0.0106479181,
0.0161429476,
0.0550520979,
-0.0335783958,
-0.0068764151,
0.013511437,
0.0041976352,
-0.0101490458,
0.0250095855,
0.0413219482,
0.0001035344,
0.0375400558,
-0.0407358631,
-0.0200750623,
-0.0044247191,
-0.0224851724,
0.0403723568,
0.0198876895,
0.0749844313,
-0.0059476127,
0.0445532985,
0.0171092041,
-0.0187186152,
-0.0264599379,
0.0367855392,
-0.0413851999,
0.009574715,
0.0496270247,
0.0407599062,
-0.0730192065,
-0.0105835805,
0.0103438273,
-0.0435652584,
0.0198740475,
-0.0339503586,
0.0228152871,
-0.024415439,
-0.0034701915,
0.032198634,
-0.0674685687,
-0.0023136009,
-0.0052575981,
-0.0471157916,
0.0214182325,
0.0829905495,
0.0138028804,
0.0309023857,
-0.0508790351,
0.0216912907,
-0.0164541136,
0.0128558474,
0.0893165991,
0.0671859905,
0.0143728526,
0.0201787204,
0.0290043037,
-0.025856344,
-0.0200861897,
-0.0209568143,
0.005467521,
0.0574288107,
0.0312481131,
0.0882636011,
-0.0323288478,
0.028444726,
-0.0705283582,
0.0078337109,
-0.0182579812,
0.0469075404,
0.0052109426,
0.0107921874,
0.0139437085,
-0.0085578635,
-0.0351052992,
0.00175642,
-0.0458096787,
-0.0152587211,
0.0312962979,
0.039075207,
-0.0069454084,
0.0104686115,
0.1014019325,
-0.0364493206,
0.0092535187,
0.0231208038,
-0.0393170752,
0.036806833,
-0.005430867,
0.0459506996,
-0.0465283059,
-0.033869911,
0.053871341,
0.0028229323,
-0.0208815951,
0.0332571939,
0.0353189185,
0.0170483571,
-0.0216815956,
0.0080629326,
-0.0459957458,
0.0028644372,
-0.0276219323,
0.0649401397,
-0.0086268783,
-0.0032046568,
-0.0628932789,
0.0567803308,
-0.0090944078,
-0.0289302636,
-0.01662663,
-0.0604110211,
0.0118847908,
0.0120770428,
-0.0253009237,
0.0706656426,
-0.0275289323,
-0.0303260405,
0.0076855202,
-0.0544075221,
-0.0222308841,
0.0589612462,
2.489e-7,
0.0176546667,
0.005838675,
-0.0028727788,
0.0178065654,
0.0079534985,
0.0509445369,
-0.0412636213,
0.0340045094,
0.0250519384,
0.000446424,
-0.0065903259,
0.0442594476,
0.0490658097,
-0.0202101637,
-0.0335431732,
0.0145289367,
-0.0355411656,
-0.0243128091,
-0.0475543588,
0.0116680302,
0.0645191967,
0.0928344056,
-0.0567403287,
0.0063960324,
0.0259550456,
-0.056188345,
0.1057232171,
0.0050105499,
-0.0414599106,
0.0155080436,
-0.0279018562,
0.0171423871,
-0.0321990289,
0.0111316405,
0.0117459828,
0.0201638639,
0.027822597,
0.0666154027,
-0.0097708162,
-0.0402714163,
0.0068774456,
0.0178027842,
-0.0211138539,
-0.0695560575,
0.0784590766,
-0.0620451234,
-0.0303293932,
0.0213431027,
-0.0130837997,
0.0003029898,
0.017071465,
-0.034433037,
-0.0594609454,
0.0201150216,
0.0614201538,
-0.0318849981,
-0.0161496196,
-0.048982203,
-0.0159091707,
-0.0307781436,
-0.0479242206,
-0.0279418137,
-0.0561218001,
-0.0243577044,
0.0120241586,
-0.0043760026,
-0.0359804146,
1.907210426e-34,
0.0257384591,
-0.0376071744,
0.0042193444,
0.0078834277,
0.0215237048,
-0.0027688986,
-0.0390546285,
-0.0111172581,
0.0161000304,
-0.0852115303,
-0.0315992422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08152v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08152v2 | Context Compression for Auto-regressive Transformers with Sentinel Tokens | 2023-10-12T09:18:19 | 2023-10-15T09:15:02 | Siyu Ren, Qi Jia, Kenny Q. Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The quadratic complexity of the attention module makes it gradually become
the bulk of compute in Transformer-based LLMs during generation. Moreover, the
excessive key-value cache that arises when dealing with long inputs also brings
severe issues on memory footprint and inference latency. In this work, we
propose a plug-and-play approach that is able to incrementally compress the
intermediate activation of a specified span of tokens into compact ones,
thereby reducing both memory and computational cost when processing subsequent
context. Experiments on both in-domain language modeling and zero-shot
open-ended document generation demonstrate the advantage of our approach over
sparse attention baselines in terms of fluency, n-gram matching, and semantic
similarity. At last, we comprehensively profile the benefit of context
compression on improving the system throughout. Code is available at
https://github.com/DRSY/KV_Compression. | [
-0.0028044623,
0.0338371731,
0.0123859504,
0.029440565,
-0.0465187021,
-0.0112910923,
0.0079147713,
0.0034107023,
-0.0489105508,
-0.0522566065,
-0.0194630567,
-0.020952832,
-0.0098656509,
0.0329228044,
0.0296880323,
0.0175534654,
0.0502106138,
0.001878527,
-0.0422616526,
0.0022701619,
-0.0174359679,
0.0049518966,
0.0095807305,
0.0552690066,
-0.0254982207,
-0.0173783544,
-0.0263314471,
0.028306447,
0.0018689709,
-0.0197259467,
-0.0083960397,
0.0463970155,
0.0120927328,
0.0155686578,
0.0000018696,
-0.0320917852,
-0.0170367509,
-0.0013133464,
-0.021221783,
-0.0159251578,
0.060699448,
-0.0057805409,
-0.0191479754,
0.0100793662,
-0.0075955866,
-0.0239569079,
0.0493807457,
0.029817408,
0.0464795046,
0.0675688908,
-0.0163599644,
0.0036666547,
0.0366740599,
-0.014209277,
0.0419441275,
-0.037887875,
-0.0072142608,
-0.0716069415,
-0.0038160861,
-0.0011937936,
-0.0145086506,
0.0320061445,
0.0354690664,
-0.0025028468,
0.034949664,
0.0364561342,
-0.045004867,
0.0026882067,
-0.014453263,
0.0416295603,
-0.0289959945,
-0.0620018728,
0.0160442833,
0.0023563812,
-0.023772262,
-0.0467422865,
-0.0526839606,
0.0515899174,
0.0101663666,
0.0348044448,
0.0216605496,
-0.0028391662,
0.0102704195,
-0.0060985801,
-0.0333230868,
0.037246082,
0.039809227,
-0.014333575,
-0.0389024615,
0.0044425665,
-0.0028274013,
-0.0686639249,
-0.0095938798,
0.0675890893,
-0.0182745624,
-0.0028642907,
-0.0915332437,
-0.0598257706,
0.021975236,
0.012901891,
0.0095078722,
0.0695680752,
-0.0299297776,
0.009501962,
-0.0560292117,
0.0693080351,
-0.0108028091,
0.0240595117,
-0.0262665823,
-0.030239949,
0.0081482241,
-0.0092492569,
-0.0588278472,
0.0441826768,
-0.0306359362,
-0.0144156413,
-0.0476834513,
0.0462569781,
0.0217734315,
-0.0080562858,
-0.0091324756,
0.0167638324,
-0.072119236,
0.0069424859,
0.0218153689,
0.0233413149,
-0.008587895,
-0.0177601129,
0.0244013965,
-0.0699549541,
-0.0460622609,
0.0521265306,
0.0158282015,
-0.0089459615,
-0.0170369036,
0.0781483129,
-0.0138348453,
-0.0501255579,
-0.0460676774,
-0.0302326288,
0.0121237719,
-0.0521086752,
0.0069081732,
-0.0780370831,
0.014944762,
0.0301251076,
-0.0314553678,
-0.0260115098,
0.0002378705,
0.0513643585,
0.0065362528,
0.0235887468,
0.0207602121,
-0.0103145456,
-0.0075039105,
-0.0058093201,
0.0177050848,
0.0593544394,
0.0219689198,
0.0342507102,
-0.0049804077,
0.0190839283,
-0.0132845808,
0.0264886636,
0.0555615947,
-0.0081236763,
-0.0202512629,
-0.0156855136,
-0.024219038,
0.0205371175,
0.0759721026,
0.0559600331,
-0.0377966724,
-0.0103811435,
0.0329008065,
0.0793303922,
0.0316649042,
0.0518052988,
0.0584233291,
0.0000549401,
-0.0327436253,
0.0139940344,
-0.0426601097,
0.07103993,
-0.007434113,
0.0280622039,
0.0245499462,
0.0432609543,
-0.0361242965,
-0.0020198019,
-0.0123625221,
-0.0255232509,
-0.0172991939,
-0.0271111671,
0.0207186919,
0.0307655949,
-0.0624404922,
0.1203192249,
-0.0021332509,
-0.0825534835,
-0.0016614823,
-0.0436346494,
0.0010955383,
0.0125112813,
0.0687797591,
0.02327553,
-0.0230162926,
-0.0017998007,
-0.0012292238,
0.0532089025,
-0.0047118063,
0.028212592,
-0.0123497462,
-0.0566863827,
-0.0242101569,
-0.0345679186,
-0.0059476518,
-0.0145032117,
0.0220763311,
0.0200998019,
0.0462810546,
-0.0101094106,
0.0203337036,
0.0372276083,
-0.0466462746,
-0.0416211449,
0.0193610117,
0.011295625,
0.0265008919,
-0.0208833907,
0.0173344295,
0.0315215997,
0.0489542447,
-0.0467628725,
0.0080027599,
0.0280255806,
-0.0736543834,
-0.0316162594,
0.0233410578,
-0.0382805131,
0.0098157832,
0.0310505535,
-0.0307283159,
-0.0483904779,
0.0120925475,
-0.0607775562,
0.0605041347,
-0.0505499877,
0.028135987,
0.027604511,
0.042765934,
-0.0271116905,
0.0479098596,
-0.0149697931,
0.0008367175,
0.0425343141,
0.0382121094,
0.0091054905,
0.0014802803,
-0.004978708,
-0.0500375181,
-0.0234043524,
-0.0090853879,
0.0061110901,
0.0019251283,
-0.0090430155,
-0.03617993,
-0.0681752414,
0.0157911666,
-0.0297852699,
0.016508732,
0.0285280552,
0.0544413105,
0.0227749068,
0.0115152858,
-0.043796014,
0.0375255421,
0.0376707911,
0.0109248199,
0.0267966148,
-0.030211689,
-0.0056684301,
-0.0210694727,
-0.0132726785,
0.007636827,
0.065758206,
-0.007382188,
-0.0083396249,
-0.0403021798,
0.0477872454,
-0.0139861079,
0.0120497784,
-0.0119004669,
-0.0326471105,
-0.0017147332,
-0.016053712,
0.0662293807,
0.0366188996,
0.0291264337,
0.0277168229,
0.036296349,
-0.0054525058,
-0.0535274744,
0.013856126,
-0.0267027467,
-0.0131184263,
-0.0153454384,
-0.011041387,
0.0354265422,
0.0812465847,
0.000577553,
-0.0084972577,
-0.0218449067,
-0.0296247657,
0.0168109592,
-0.0244469382,
0.0079521928,
-0.0130120208,
-0.037544135,
0.0220282432,
-0.0111838365,
-0.046523381,
0.0675611645,
-0.0516269468,
-0.0098195979,
-0.0272245426,
0.0104020517,
-0.0562251695,
0.0219833106,
0.0000456877,
0.0175016541,
-0.0292907674,
-0.0081814993,
-0.038697008,
0.0397760347,
-0.0091800671,
-0.0224238783,
0.0861955658,
0.0140880411,
0.0243678577,
-0.0451928824,
-0.0323262103,
-0.0697760582,
-0.0127768787,
0.0027079375,
0.0268749502,
0.0456264056,
-0.0131718237,
-0.0697613358,
0.0403428562,
0.0023258859,
0.0557644963,
-0.0147327883,
-0.0191082507,
-0.0245803669,
0.0376426689,
0.0470631756,
0.0079656756,
0.0482490696,
-0.014907415,
-0.0134690274,
0.0727596954,
0.0381729938,
0.033818379,
-0.0276763942,
0.007333166,
0.0351709276,
-0.0141059654,
0.0035833833,
0.0277730282,
0.0425405428,
-0.0506324731,
-0.0487685688,
0.0940594897,
0.0145998104,
-0.0811225176,
0.0019732297,
-0.0307153556,
0.044368539,
0.0194750838,
0.0241583716,
-0.082849063,
-0.032408163,
0.0213695895,
0.0347903818,
-0.0012112951,
-0.0097716944,
-0.0313059837,
-0.0782353431,
0.0401979126,
0.0094112549,
-0.0463073067,
-0.0199787356,
-0.0175420567,
0.0015031075,
0.0244333595,
0.0144658023,
0.0290189348,
-0.0205003526,
-0.0123345153,
-0.0148249678,
0.0147990305,
-0.0367090106,
-0.0143812289,
-0.0083362609,
0.0341686867,
0.0352275409,
-0.0010165032,
0.0463415459,
-0.0524723604,
0.028250698,
-0.0102637531,
0.0103155216,
-0.0291960612,
-0.0014762048,
-0.023850454,
0.001043413,
-0.023697719,
0.0286443587,
-0.0328019075,
-0.014997785,
-0.0507985651,
0.0550430715,
-0.0181008279,
-0.0005128924,
-0.0423238873,
0.0003424804,
0.0042726854,
0.0873709098,
0.0594007894,
-0.0028295279,
-0.0541583337,
-0.0153515358,
-0.0028736347,
-0.0652033687,
-0.032789547,
-0.0054082056,
0.0124747101,
-0.0638621673,
-0.0459837578,
-0.0026483666,
0.0012199591,
0.028301958,
-0.0414473675,
-0.0255024936,
-0.0126325246,
-0.0319021568,
-0.0958321467,
0.0063628983,
-0.0274157058,
-0.0094322525,
-0.0771851763,
0.0219550207,
0.0336223766,
-0.032019712,
-0.0118866302,
0.0318889432,
-0.1477312893,
-0.0563523509,
0.0106161395,
0.0321179368,
0.0129440138,
0.045413658,
0.0079648905,
-0.0392575115,
0.0747648701,
0.0774590597,
-0.0552169159,
0.0437092967,
-0.0015324244,
0.0052825804,
0.0137210377,
0.0409183986,
-0.0627799258,
0.0242792573,
0.0208764765,
0.0478342995,
0.0299086999,
-0.0358316936,
0.0250741895,
-0.0039935051,
0.0316380002,
-0.0209742449,
0.0466449708,
0.0231348034,
0.0272595659,
-0.0150285587,
0.019196406,
-0.044239074,
0.0129179768,
-0.0356201567,
-0.0318476148,
0.013266583,
0.0452777222,
0.0022289471,
0.0466364101,
0.0064975694,
0.0100261597,
-0.0442831479,
-0.0021760946,
0.0246494673,
-0.0122230221,
-0.0408420563,
-0.0505869947,
-0.0002580851,
0.0152299274,
-0.0383774452,
0.0210526567,
0.0220103394,
0.0502521507,
-0.0186839495,
0.0204086062,
-0.0534900986,
-0.0023577737,
-0.0299879033,
0.0034431836,
0.0440716334,
-0.0008354289,
0.0400760137,
-0.0416786075,
0.000118488,
-0.0093198484,
0.032687977,
-0.0039432151,
-0.0106474981,
0.0375018716,
0.0122622,
0.0107636331,
-0.0103218183,
0.0820570216,
-0.0010367151,
0.0280679539,
-0.0127725508,
0.0203265008,
-0.0372259989,
-0.0220882557,
-0.0218445938,
0.0133519769,
0.0166171119,
-0.0171118621,
-0.0265116449,
-0.0553647913,
0.0523910969,
-0.0147596681,
-0.0260131266,
-0.0280836988,
0.0487614311,
0.0421562456,
0.0191814527,
-0.0300056711,
0.0076192403,
0.0275195725,
-0.0148295788,
-0.0410604067,
-0.0160791017,
-6.341335784e-33,
-0.043634899,
-0.058666449,
0.044556465,
0.0034836668,
-0.0371418521,
0.0098100035,
-0.0626915544,
-0.0434706993,
0.0196442921,
-0.0109651778,
-0.0234072022,
0.0041067284,
0.0089978268,
0.0457732789,
-0.0310314689,
0.0098987697,
0.06700629,
-0.010511429,
-0.0340938531,
0.058884833,
0.04301228,
0.0237728041,
0.0298189018,
-0.0173467807,
-0.0451593511,
-0.0218695682,
0.0352942087,
-0.0202536713,
0.0166336894,
0.0558640361,
-0.0239406712,
0.0309670083,
0.0166839454,
-0.0278386977,
-0.0382427946,
0.0299001727,
-0.0745533183,
-0.0205796212,
-0.0008429558,
-0.0180615261,
-0.029346494,
-0.0517957434,
0.0631371588,
-0.0025256677,
-0.0156260133,
-0.0359092988,
0.0083146822,
0.0060311006,
-0.0670908168,
-0.0927373096,
-0.0676341206,
0.013604708,
0.0077670091,
-0.0005223749,
0.0181850456,
0.0633969977,
-0.0135081196,
0.0573319495,
-0.0465440042,
0.0181422401,
-0.0377431065,
0.0834364966,
0.0811991766,
0.0113131246,
0.019580733,
0.027183475,
-0.0013540082,
-0.02405045,
-0.0610497035,
0.0066162208,
0.044588089,
0.0292061344,
0.0247295741,
0.0362394601,
0.0509388894,
-0.0135288015,
-0.0622784607,
0.0220883843,
-0.0064846855,
0.0777262971,
0.0357265361,
0.0031531714,
0.0014415585,
0.0007669268,
-0.0131682428,
0.0124700842,
-0.0364286415,
-0.0245221108,
0.0253182389,
0.0438678525,
-0.0256125499,
-0.0392905287,
0.0563969873,
-0.0211370029,
0.0122100161,
0.0323400907,
0.0019938045,
0.0095439916,
-0.009115017,
0.0077367998,
-0.0256834365,
-0.0147039359,
0.0248855669,
0.013715527,
0.0105151627,
0.0121641969,
0.0185498018,
0.0537750311,
-0.0655153096,
-0.0072118109,
-0.0456477255,
0.0360348187,
0.0032483826,
-0.0041715978,
0.0325818285,
-0.0227833372,
0.0100420797,
0.0557641089,
-0.0383790694,
-0.0183895938,
0.0058967336,
-0.0087965773,
0.0309396535,
0.0539268367,
-0.0502839088,
0.017028762,
-0.0706789345,
0.0568407327,
0.0374317691,
-0.0527705215,
-0.0231071189,
0.0405662209,
2.638e-7,
0.0074396678,
0.0320205539,
0.0412115082,
0.0227515381,
0.0271117948,
-0.009695353,
0.0392176583,
0.0370239988,
-0.0050323182,
0.0163528435,
-0.0004483609,
0.0135982651,
0.0595298037,
0.0251005944,
-0.0984258056,
0.0435755402,
-0.0942104086,
0.0044719046,
-0.037050005,
-0.0094629833,
0.051121518,
0.0604562275,
-0.0441938713,
-0.0144057898,
0.0435454398,
0.0077798739,
0.0596371293,
0.0132165067,
0.021308424,
0.0088850539,
0.0536377281,
-0.0103901634,
-0.0112184584,
-0.0263654012,
-0.0215133354,
0.0142322332,
-0.0379483625,
0.0500442572,
0.0102446293,
-0.1040292457,
0.0328355059,
-0.0429625101,
-0.0091430675,
-0.0467377603,
0.0486316569,
-0.0544310398,
0.0070919399,
-0.068655178,
-0.0174893867,
0.0082578138,
-0.0345860645,
-0.0095664673,
-0.0139755039,
0.0181949511,
0.0324215591,
-0.0171448682,
-0.0228812769,
-0.0883728638,
-0.0264769532,
-0.0276221894,
-0.0516877063,
-0.0076256115,
-0.0761173368,
-0.0115272496,
0.0524629578,
-0.0149536999,
-0.0291624628,
2.815125299e-34,
0.0390740111,
-0.0335443728,
0.0101257786,
0.0372866802,
-0.0116968071,
-0.016884733,
0.0154627273,
0.0428277813,
0.0022388413,
-0.0806403831,
-0.040238414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08132v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08132v1 | On the Relevance of Phoneme Duration Variability of Synthesized Training Data for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-10-12T08:45:21 | 2023-10-12T08:45:21 | Nick Rossenbach, Benedikt Hilmes, Ralf Schlüter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Synthetic data generated by text-to-speech (TTS) systems can be used to
improve automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems in low-resource or domain
mismatch tasks. It has been shown that TTS-generated outputs still do not have
the same qualities as real data. In this work we focus on the temporal
structure of synthetic data and its relation to ASR training. By using a novel
oracle setup we show how much the degradation of synthetic data quality is
influenced by duration modeling in non-autoregressive (NAR) TTS. To get
reference phoneme durations we use two common alignment methods, a hidden
Markov Gaussian-mixture model (HMM-GMM) aligner and a neural connectionist
temporal classification (CTC) aligner. Using a simple algorithm based on random
walks we shift phoneme duration distributions of the TTS system closer to real
durations, resulting in an improvement of an ASR system using synthetic data in
a semi-supervised setting. | [
-0.0065312786,
0.0579846576,
0.0147815244,
-0.0013025694,
-0.015098976,
-0.0069288616,
0.0550621338,
-0.0056185597,
-0.0153443404,
0.0275245197,
-0.0089205438,
-0.0633684024,
0.0941670015,
0.0188493356,
0.0136920586,
-0.0336137936,
0.0251772739,
-0.0332397781,
-0.0117345201,
0.0022755708,
0.0076657352,
-0.024847988,
-0.0416195244,
0.0327826925,
-0.0214714482,
-0.0116802081,
-0.0090349186,
-0.0321419016,
0.0218121782,
-0.0276469905,
-0.0658406764,
0.0085907336,
-0.0015534592,
0.028816184,
0.0000016124,
-0.0420777351,
0.0014232614,
0.0258092191,
-0.0742838755,
-0.0100646932,
0.0138550261,
0.0385444127,
-0.0188830663,
0.0586068965,
-0.0113567607,
-0.0057239798,
0.0626288578,
0.0048480825,
-0.0102447206,
0.0809535608,
-0.0068324464,
-0.0066445973,
0.0229801182,
-0.0220539495,
-0.0063833445,
0.0189923011,
-0.0059240893,
0.010893601,
0.0139603401,
-0.0643911809,
-0.0152442157,
0.027266575,
0.0031300958,
0.0206106845,
0.0524925701,
0.0222670007,
-0.03379241,
0.0050280001,
0.0204759333,
0.0417492688,
-0.0145790046,
-0.0291982889,
0.0347211026,
0.0053261952,
-0.0043917033,
-0.0161913186,
0.0357326679,
-0.0099233603,
-0.0117439879,
0.0256557912,
0.0122649446,
0.0469201356,
0.0198247228,
-0.0534122735,
-0.0276871584,
0.0018031566,
0.0056533115,
-0.0594485551,
-0.0379824787,
-0.0217605531,
0.0773108304,
-0.0108444113,
0.0255017541,
0.0060617621,
-0.0237785876,
0.0098978877,
-0.0387993418,
-0.0387470908,
-0.027586516,
-0.0522211455,
-0.0110323485,
0.0625929981,
-0.0366148017,
-0.0450734384,
-0.0259915218,
0.0581512079,
-0.0020893735,
-0.0095342631,
-0.0376672372,
0.012883544,
-0.0470442884,
0.0204663072,
-0.0000992139,
0.0003906844,
-0.0195770282,
0.0077998699,
-0.0444246791,
0.0250973031,
-0.0036648444,
-0.0019600014,
0.0216300841,
0.0066061565,
-0.0791275203,
0.0013575217,
-0.0687714964,
-0.0087744351,
0.02230311,
0.0278035477,
-0.0198896062,
-0.0573372655,
-0.0163135827,
0.0030650992,
0.0293785501,
0.0011416064,
0.000420823,
0.0879418179,
-0.0254931785,
-0.0007678036,
-0.0886101872,
0.029067805,
-0.0134943333,
-0.0453299619,
-0.0351517461,
-0.0566133447,
0.0541650839,
-0.0013556568,
-0.0226248596,
-0.0037325411,
-0.017689392,
-0.03550791,
0.0167324655,
0.0688290969,
-0.0000166543,
0.0323454514,
0.0524838604,
-0.0634386763,
0.046309799,
0.0343402289,
0.0745165795,
-0.0750089884,
-0.0067336406,
-0.0445982255,
0.001837751,
0.0351944007,
-0.01765435,
-0.0469129533,
-0.0177563932,
0.0150399031,
0.0280262511,
0.0594942234,
0.0622632205,
0.0336859412,
0.0133118136,
-0.0274993088,
0.0498733595,
0.0239913762,
0.0689506829,
0.0409839526,
0.067215167,
-0.0254294164,
0.0105127692,
0.02631527,
0.0120649328,
-0.0173860639,
-0.0267148595,
0.0632850602,
0.0390480347,
0.0713868216,
-0.0306408312,
-0.0214166064,
-0.013090319,
-0.0309581589,
-0.0215869118,
-0.0133701554,
0.0404247269,
-0.0186665244,
-0.0423281454,
0.012047275,
-0.0111630196,
-0.0137525471,
0.0312223732,
0.0229650605,
-0.0137638692,
0.0746320039,
0.0020262585,
-0.0172394495,
-0.0231720079,
-0.0503859632,
-0.0745079368,
0.0442447327,
-0.0138379056,
0.0119258594,
0.0332018547,
-0.0664372221,
-0.010289019,
0.0558917783,
-0.0386124738,
0.0307340752,
-0.0175889544,
0.0524404757,
0.0320256129,
-0.031622719,
-0.0311245956,
0.0141952494,
-0.0750147402,
-0.0389286727,
-0.002489005,
0.0171626136,
0.0692999363,
0.0295975003,
-0.0349953398,
-0.0061716447,
0.0079518594,
-0.0182524994,
0.0266320687,
0.0466560796,
-0.0804151297,
-0.0306878909,
0.056216158,
0.0023413356,
0.0022070543,
0.0101242475,
0.0136198346,
-0.1017656922,
0.0314706005,
-0.0329947099,
0.0326480418,
-0.0045432956,
0.0763101727,
0.0555666089,
0.0354000404,
0.025804881,
-0.0038618725,
-0.0039887363,
0.0207801517,
0.034290012,
0.0328515992,
0.0176038984,
-0.0818310082,
0.0388594307,
0.0189684518,
-0.0337581374,
0.0089591164,
-0.0037397966,
-0.0428954288,
-0.0315621085,
0.0041363789,
-0.0560283288,
0.0017966154,
0.0164897665,
0.0612860136,
-0.0156602263,
0.0164771266,
-0.0046948926,
-0.0117691932,
-0.0778440088,
-0.0415964387,
0.0132057397,
-0.0554164872,
-0.0122085931,
0.0083549852,
-0.048119802,
-0.041451741,
0.0165427625,
-0.0181723181,
0.0362054706,
-0.0187325291,
-0.0458230041,
-0.0596066639,
0.0065812743,
0.0058910795,
0.0583411455,
0.0042722654,
-0.0205464344,
-0.0157381445,
0.0370656326,
0.115042381,
0.0051140613,
0.0489784665,
-0.0208886471,
0.0026670338,
0.0009835664,
-0.0283716507,
0.018793622,
-0.0211681239,
0.0417458415,
-0.0188935623,
-0.0240762793,
-0.0342623331,
0.0432312489,
0.0093005989,
0.030478891,
-0.0746656954,
-0.0394779518,
0.0056246435,
-0.0104621397,
0.0336773545,
0.0039329515,
-0.069181256,
-0.0138350371,
-0.0308584087,
-0.0386531241,
0.0291335694,
-0.0719503462,
-0.0228803419,
-0.048646573,
-0.0845971033,
-0.0000351842,
-0.0148956664,
-0.0004121399,
-0.0159294195,
0.0011926518,
-0.0249151867,
-0.0361619107,
0.0081757735,
0.0154573889,
-0.0613519102,
0.0165699385,
0.0064817346,
0.0328242108,
0.0021391083,
0.0055825585,
-0.0468363911,
-0.0082725137,
0.0047054118,
-0.0255793948,
0.0151500115,
-0.0179518927,
0.0012563264,
0.037961673,
-0.0221058037,
0.074678041,
0.0082511194,
0.0004795461,
0.0008949959,
0.0497384332,
0.0018442288,
0.0230704397,
-0.0198719557,
-0.0069234255,
0.0243518036,
-0.0611355677,
0.0491647422,
-0.0034118842,
-0.086341992,
-0.0626166463,
-0.0278933384,
0.0018045318,
0.0103806015,
0.0395709164,
-0.0192596205,
-0.0089759436,
0.0056692944,
0.0635706633,
0.0008453898,
0.0073354314,
-0.0071199127,
0.0136229619,
0.00312316,
-0.0005029188,
-0.0175493844,
-0.0036692186,
0.0262505002,
0.0255644917,
0.0428090468,
-0.0275410488,
0.0278640203,
-0.0155097032,
-0.1070780009,
-0.0167881362,
0.0174585562,
-0.0972606018,
-0.035610836,
-0.0373872705,
-0.0329221971,
-0.0292050429,
0.0433109514,
0.023838222,
-0.0398962647,
-0.0046562562,
0.0625563785,
-0.1094352007,
-0.0854358524,
-0.0401754789,
-0.0136298388,
0.1448099464,
0.0473117158,
0.0118966186,
0.0122362971,
-0.0570345521,
0.0246377755,
0.0196544919,
0.0232397243,
0.0054380768,
0.0474719107,
0.0197939165,
-0.0165897291,
0.0215988122,
0.0269423034,
0.0129000712,
0.0142790014,
-0.0250636041,
0.0758797675,
-0.0287269764,
0.0121319545,
0.0123804593,
0.0087900646,
0.0210811049,
0.0481818877,
-0.0333006307,
-0.0254998617,
-0.0128644118,
0.0313469209,
0.0361886062,
-0.0383255817,
0.0021452708,
0.0393533222,
-0.0513395369,
-0.0746541992,
-0.0212385952,
-0.0420060419,
-0.0304766223,
0.067534551,
0.0130558638,
0.0370949656,
-0.0127646839,
0.0315294452,
-0.0366271436,
0.0354177393,
-0.0213083196,
0.035220094,
-0.0702481791,
-0.0137433941,
-0.0323999822,
-0.0445903987,
-0.0133242384,
-0.0092512276,
-0.063732937,
-0.0698787645,
0.0145726092,
-0.0324311815,
0.0201721601,
0.0838233307,
0.0056545953,
0.0067397659,
0.0690643415,
0.0308336653,
-0.0486112423,
0.0004160573,
0.0387718379,
-0.0040526432,
-0.0004055976,
-0.0361470245,
-0.0439328477,
0.0066639595,
-0.021174863,
-0.0030491699,
-0.0129803699,
0.003033546,
-0.0019151353,
0.0199476685,
0.0531071201,
0.0098974099,
0.0275656153,
-0.0380379371,
0.0201855693,
0.0001744951,
0.0691536292,
0.0094094463,
-0.0131470412,
0.0274292231,
0.0756679475,
0.0134595474,
0.0026854496,
-0.0556957461,
-0.0310224015,
0.0479945876,
0.0165221598,
0.0353064053,
0.0305446908,
0.0080756173,
0.0023380525,
-0.0070572658,
0.0281891227,
0.0119981952,
0.0038899151,
0.0159939211,
0.0001215114,
0.0154393008,
0.0732448772,
0.004279275,
-0.0259486027,
-0.0271760691,
0.0126256607,
-0.0397813879,
-0.0058466014,
0.042486798,
-0.0341993049,
0.0105699813,
-0.0034994374,
0.0589447841,
-0.0173045415,
-0.0077854744,
-0.0041662059,
0.0532938316,
-0.0079013407,
-0.0104387449,
-0.0495345443,
0.0182434097,
0.0764010772,
0.0217821281,
0.0410592519,
-0.0524027385,
0.0139047047,
-0.0323969759,
-0.0199317392,
-0.0598629341,
-0.0105016986,
-0.0314123258,
-0.0669256225,
-0.0259530284,
-0.0689953268,
0.0542760007,
0.0130416937,
0.0292089786,
-0.0146015417,
0.0254391804,
-0.0074542775,
-0.0246871617,
0.0592220798,
0.026097523,
-0.0259687062,
0.047876291,
-0.026616659,
-0.031611532,
-5.87515603e-33,
-0.0080547817,
-0.0086237639,
0.0229079798,
0.0009365181,
-0.0439919084,
0.0232355502,
-0.0096270815,
0.0172283407,
0.0314341746,
-0.0340016373,
-0.0277635697,
0.0009688472,
0.030797461,
0.0049007791,
0.0077662598,
0.0210291464,
0.0741900355,
-0.0079524638,
-0.0054823505,
-0.0526631363,
0.0659855902,
0.0403036252,
0.016061822,
-0.0512075946,
-0.0233558919,
0.0059847552,
0.0247059464,
-0.0384618528,
0.0497246571,
0.037489444,
0.0002087198,
0.0474167839,
0.0088199899,
-0.0376990139,
-0.006425757,
0.0124888644,
-0.0819456577,
-0.0109650474,
0.0322680101,
0.033647988,
0.002077753,
-0.0320292115,
0.0241557527,
-0.0040587955,
-0.0615851954,
-0.0091436589,
0.0421411954,
-0.0705461204,
-0.0213349517,
-0.0790476128,
-0.0221018102,
0.0316565186,
-0.0126213999,
0.0050294278,
0.0618950464,
0.0216598175,
-0.0173370726,
-0.0255622193,
-0.0600861348,
0.0183531977,
0.0242724773,
0.0418144204,
0.0347661152,
0.0798772052,
0.043207746,
0.0083847409,
0.0454327799,
-0.0259207822,
0.016003523,
-0.0123897512,
0.0216646083,
-0.0272777267,
0.0189478938,
0.0031124908,
0.0846224874,
-0.0569890551,
-0.019023655,
0.0349900909,
-0.0002383438,
-0.0342348218,
-0.0033641362,
0.0240418948,
-0.0397874825,
0.0205226112,
-0.0217097551,
-0.0103386063,
-0.0069061215,
-0.0081719384,
0.0501727574,
0.0235096868,
0.0510513932,
0.0075421901,
0.0553647541,
0.0057321433,
0.0267753489,
-0.0110669583,
-0.0117891263,
-0.0268800724,
0.011109747,
-0.0043918546,
-0.0518327542,
-0.0608327202,
0.0583468266,
0.0536697358,
0.0249265786,
-0.0378903635,
-0.0100162681,
0.0229372624,
-0.0648954064,
0.0231847074,
0.0092161521,
0.039169766,
-0.0042773071,
-0.0365091451,
0.0761899352,
-0.0578777045,
0.0019178697,
0.0586909577,
-0.0349637046,
0.0123910028,
0.02356047,
0.0464988984,
0.0034676995,
0.025889907,
-0.0047103334,
0.0230195336,
0.0109026162,
0.0151609182,
0.018588569,
-0.0126599744,
0.0075056138,
0.021712143,
2.606e-7,
-0.0432787612,
-0.0030703065,
0.0709182769,
0.0034246978,
0.0235557165,
-0.0212370269,
0.0083753271,
-0.0069806781,
-0.026959328,
0.023510579,
0.02051856,
-0.0409030244,
0.0617322959,
0.0140188225,
-0.0392628796,
-0.0546102263,
-0.0640094578,
0.0434448458,
-0.0473849997,
0.0263000336,
-0.005076935,
0.0631584823,
-0.0141187869,
-0.0229680333,
0.0144066093,
-0.0317210555,
0.0058092978,
-0.0057943808,
0.0023819401,
-0.0174805969,
0.0423325598,
-0.0334984772,
-0.0293530542,
0.0320972316,
-0.0366059095,
0.0344174132,
-0.0079093119,
-0.0110201333,
-0.0227172859,
-0.0250659585,
0.0106820166,
0.0136799579,
-0.0507203937,
0.0386735536,
0.0267757233,
-0.0051069381,
0.0054628416,
-0.0222794376,
-0.0587614365,
0.0387807637,
0.0047267238,
0.0289413538,
0.0261390321,
0.002189053,
0.0036579687,
0.0030091042,
0.0075184773,
-0.0088675022,
0.0046477104,
0.0474783853,
-0.0386782549,
-0.0144839734,
-0.0161065366,
0.0013355323,
0.077230297,
-0.0092207072,
-0.0049216538,
1.949647839e-34,
0.0148280449,
-0.0361875594,
0.041019205,
-0.0238454621,
-0.0197654404,
-0.0760994777,
0.041808892,
0.011486928,
-0.0073891259,
-0.0321180411,
-0.0413870327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08130v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08130v4 | Fine-grained Conversational Decoding via Isotropic and Proximal Search | 2023-10-12T08:38:12 | 2023-11-15T03:59:42 | Yuxuan Yao, Han Wu, Qiling Xu, Linqi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | General-purpose text decoding approaches are usually adopted for dialogue
response generation. Although the quality of the generated responses can be
improved with dialogue-specific encoding methods, conversational decoding
methods are still under-explored. Inspired by \citet{wu2023learning} that a
good dialogue feature space should follow the rules of locality and isotropy,
we present a fine-grained conversational decoding method, termed
\textit{isotropic and proximal search (IPS)}. Our method is designed to
generate the semantic-concentrated response, while still maintaining
informativeness and discrimination against the context. Experiments show that
our approach outperforms existing decoding strategies in the dialogue field
across both automatic and human evaluation metrics. More in-depth analyses
further confirm the effectiveness of our approach. | [
0.0533942804,
0.0695857033,
-0.0000353409,
0.0330124833,
-0.0169073045,
-0.0203804262,
-0.0234541241,
0.0313098989,
-0.0335171819,
-0.0167938583,
-0.0260288082,
-0.0236262716,
0.0225893334,
0.0288847331,
0.0224233437,
-0.0632179379,
-0.0006799352,
0.0108698504,
0.0368544199,
0.0000403428,
-0.0174602047,
0.0020204275,
-0.0462858528,
0.0682507306,
-0.0085251369,
0.0089126993,
-0.0194426496,
0.0416781977,
0.0128086973,
-0.0191154741,
0.0257786959,
0.0127567118,
0.006716012,
0.0161579102,
0.0000017686,
0.0064279987,
0.0000686608,
-0.017251553,
0.0089009544,
-0.0098403599,
0.0031649382,
-0.0178595353,
0.0191310719,
0.0154531831,
-0.0657538697,
-0.0306289699,
0.0649710745,
0.0750204772,
0.0310424734,
0.0731829554,
-0.0162098054,
-0.0472937971,
0.0002794168,
-0.0102020297,
0.0144304885,
-0.0282366239,
-0.0402914248,
0.0109791625,
-0.0017411704,
0.034750741,
-0.0139481584,
0.0376388244,
-0.0087741027,
-0.0268849414,
0.0182197411,
0.045945581,
-0.0444970354,
-0.0118966969,
-0.025134217,
0.0823482573,
0.0533361509,
-0.0024551149,
-0.0137008047,
-0.0169014428,
-0.0152058583,
-0.0584167764,
-0.0357917361,
0.017304806,
-0.0049658646,
0.0099948216,
-0.0214065276,
0.0823227912,
-0.0241226591,
0.0096725263,
-0.0346303768,
0.0150683997,
0.0084170811,
-0.0398478061,
-0.0257163849,
0.012209936,
0.0019704013,
-0.0181138385,
0.031249648,
0.029618904,
-0.0374696106,
-0.0104130059,
-0.0081792958,
0.0276471823,
-0.0011228125,
0.0121776266,
0.0192253776,
0.0354780741,
-0.0119950585,
-0.0086207278,
0.0210177321,
0.0454957262,
-0.0250449311,
-0.0129322903,
-0.0536157377,
-0.012254592,
-0.0327664725,
-0.012507828,
-0.0343808904,
0.030631287,
-0.0890482068,
-0.0527076721,
-0.0014564077,
0.0288112666,
0.0183778051,
-0.0107256575,
0.0042763953,
0.040634457,
-0.0142609626,
0.0144088492,
0.0058754226,
0.0536599047,
-0.0401708409,
-0.0000306997,
0.0137741407,
-0.0534145869,
-0.0388598591,
0.0692784041,
0.0318245441,
-0.0041127661,
-0.0175722111,
0.0636915192,
-0.0494322069,
-0.038300626,
0.0177839361,
-0.0080635333,
-0.0730561092,
-0.0372248925,
-0.0036284369,
-0.0002018082,
0.0166066699,
0.009197291,
-0.0221289247,
-0.0327669457,
0.012706032,
-0.0152086578,
-0.017848989,
0.0195669942,
0.0105780354,
0.0096956193,
0.0447165444,
-0.0065062307,
0.0326517001,
0.0493195541,
0.0184714496,
0.039942205,
0.0330386572,
0.0000381534,
0.0074084876,
0.001987699,
0.0345625542,
-0.0028380074,
-0.0129307127,
0.031812802,
-0.0461184569,
0.0142541863,
0.0371319465,
0.0509755649,
-0.0723627433,
0.0006237132,
0.0676151961,
0.0676648095,
-0.0071010566,
0.0268698186,
0.0156684276,
0.0773449391,
-0.0454161316,
0.0262424946,
-0.0097728753,
0.0137984455,
-0.0116678383,
0.0045555173,
0.0778341219,
-0.0169881191,
-0.0378545523,
-0.0430138446,
0.035307195,
0.0017155894,
-0.0021914169,
0.0036642479,
0.0314668603,
0.0462654009,
-0.0728795081,
0.0444018729,
-0.0082827536,
-0.0619449615,
-0.028585311,
-0.0213039555,
0.0187641457,
0.0576672815,
0.0599485897,
0.0060508032,
-0.0143701714,
0.0291509368,
-0.014432855,
0.0775849819,
0.0407111123,
-0.0105619142,
0.0543604307,
-0.0752893239,
-0.0116889719,
0.0092842951,
-0.0060929828,
0.0176035278,
-0.0012202852,
0.0035098155,
0.0322178975,
0.0011029957,
0.0338653177,
0.0238245595,
-0.0013189262,
-0.0262413956,
0.0384255499,
0.0219994672,
0.0142953787,
0.0294714961,
-0.0291579142,
0.0088964095,
0.0150062693,
-0.0395607613,
-0.0005933722,
0.0034418472,
-0.0346352793,
-0.0857633203,
-0.0332879797,
-0.0528126918,
-0.0027071715,
-0.0059048436,
0.0062897336,
-0.0420950949,
0.0285733119,
-0.0513160005,
0.0351177119,
-0.0467208847,
-0.0240330696,
0.0346438177,
0.0350474417,
-0.0689962581,
0.0245771315,
0.0115091233,
-0.0041699554,
0.0412276946,
0.0232391376,
0.0371753983,
-0.0690000355,
0.0233117249,
0.0350178555,
-0.0569488145,
0.0093159098,
0.0157611463,
0.0615560338,
-0.0032462673,
-0.0689014271,
-0.0680363774,
-0.0043570432,
-0.0102918167,
-0.0034133729,
0.0191073474,
0.0214540213,
-0.0097386027,
-0.0248945951,
-0.0511977151,
0.0148018738,
0.0469516441,
-0.0247468222,
0.0430508852,
0.0261319131,
-0.0016469595,
-0.0290043242,
0.0186563637,
0.0497330837,
0.0330012962,
-0.0411281697,
0.0242245942,
-0.0458312742,
0.0355911441,
-0.006827354,
0.0096887713,
0.0046286648,
-0.0822526142,
0.0343138501,
0.008998204,
-0.0073135579,
0.0524275824,
0.0259627774,
0.0459070355,
-0.0200988073,
-0.0305992309,
-0.0625929385,
0.0233001392,
-0.0289019551,
0.0024090123,
-0.0290673543,
-0.0632455498,
0.0336106271,
0.0342532285,
0.070039928,
0.0693463683,
-0.0885615796,
-0.0014609693,
0.0524732769,
-0.0879040137,
0.0017938487,
-0.0055930619,
-0.0182736162,
0.0344323441,
-0.0092144785,
-0.0238920227,
0.0534482673,
-0.047230836,
-0.0370778255,
-0.03969381,
-0.0151948705,
-0.0030955034,
0.035483472,
-0.0346964188,
0.0218310915,
-0.0258940272,
-0.0682408214,
-0.0135338521,
-0.0138010746,
0.0053449413,
-0.0350257307,
0.0287441127,
-0.0045913481,
-0.0047218916,
0.0010211671,
-0.0470350422,
-0.0410256833,
-0.0857992768,
0.0169771146,
-0.0221010167,
0.0049380823,
-0.0588175096,
-0.0031333885,
0.0454110205,
0.0036873873,
0.0182029828,
-0.0564077012,
-0.0020771087,
-0.0301799253,
0.0591204204,
0.0434266254,
0.0498771295,
-0.0148545327,
-0.0139358593,
0.0493541583,
0.0508048907,
0.012820323,
-0.0031327014,
-0.007114321,
-0.0105545307,
0.046681419,
0.0362471491,
-0.0061966493,
0.0054630325,
0.0818111002,
-0.0022997453,
-0.04889597,
0.1018305495,
0.0161546692,
-0.0445880108,
-0.0109221367,
-0.0172457527,
0.0931051373,
-0.0005015042,
0.0175767634,
-0.0151504138,
-0.0432229228,
-0.0243624225,
0.049026534,
-0.0255947672,
0.0097633265,
-0.0061050113,
-0.0827621371,
0.0387547165,
0.0395972207,
-0.0366475657,
-0.075242497,
0.0219172891,
-0.0178304315,
0.0094311573,
0.015625177,
-0.0086897649,
0.0071599628,
0.0042803576,
0.0048210477,
-0.0352131948,
-0.0349415913,
-0.0356733426,
-0.006914875,
0.0186296627,
0.0944725946,
0.0369909331,
0.0196463484,
0.0257795751,
0.0014674132,
-0.06205073,
0.0152548533,
-0.0216966365,
0.0687301606,
-0.0060055288,
-0.0210087802,
-0.0229684114,
0.0122112148,
-0.0367489085,
-0.0105031012,
0.0159124322,
-0.0129457004,
-0.0756327957,
0.0196817871,
0.002330024,
0.0603454933,
0.0938921943,
0.0775077119,
0.0470838584,
-0.0320601128,
-0.0374579355,
-0.0117271189,
0.0381673276,
-0.0573670752,
-0.0244487096,
0.0247111376,
0.0705278963,
-0.0099658482,
-0.0929982439,
-0.0750864521,
0.0119170295,
0.0455570631,
-0.0477048755,
-0.0329749882,
-0.0115154162,
0.0057791471,
-0.0461852662,
-0.0099765584,
-0.0026650701,
-0.0159108043,
0.0059509431,
-0.0016460969,
0.0233387612,
-0.0532518625,
-0.0048655518,
0.0407738574,
-0.0328302309,
-0.0499714725,
-0.0261546727,
0.0228798334,
0.0192367136,
0.0603846461,
-0.0241846554,
-0.0263146944,
0.044464767,
0.004821395,
-0.0071441936,
0.0088065835,
0.0282734819,
-0.00915136,
-0.0047611245,
0.0390830003,
-0.0057200966,
0.0181044582,
-0.0141801974,
0.0610415414,
-0.0087905694,
-0.1035149768,
0.0192585774,
-0.0195503496,
0.0193579569,
-0.0026831871,
-0.015434443,
0.0157322083,
0.0267508309,
-0.0065481085,
0.027921997,
-0.050931558,
-0.0294894502,
0.0292241406,
-0.024955349,
-0.0036453851,
0.0034062334,
-0.0248058364,
0.0807028711,
-0.0318003334,
0.0075829709,
-0.0042725219,
0.0038116456,
0.0007963704,
0.0151380328,
-0.0484070182,
0.04527013,
-0.0107006291,
0.0432454832,
-0.0039848271,
0.0852572694,
0.0239185877,
-0.0550673306,
-0.0104229664,
0.0288025364,
-0.0796522126,
0.0099113295,
-0.0307237748,
-0.0051963679,
0.0169624966,
-0.0055569392,
0.0513992496,
-0.0257063918,
0.0339726172,
0.0061805104,
0.0515740141,
-0.0212305468,
-0.0181575939,
0.012754635,
0.0117684221,
-0.0320854597,
-0.0048421305,
0.0638101697,
-0.0170581657,
-0.0132806636,
-0.0096124345,
0.0307329725,
-0.0718070418,
-0.0324808732,
0.0126907732,
0.0453703217,
0.0075062369,
0.0292508136,
-0.0274221562,
-0.0133608049,
-0.0557216331,
-0.0113973953,
-0.0342457704,
-0.0306950267,
0.0393628031,
0.0516360626,
-0.0181595795,
0.000428625,
-0.0162140019,
0.0172256082,
-0.0172683652,
-0.0044175354,
-0.0801509842,
-6.231463796e-33,
-0.0371699668,
-0.0397507548,
-0.019514082,
-0.0006948928,
-0.0614298806,
-0.0271763336,
-0.0533878356,
-0.0042139594,
-0.0237238016,
0.0148819741,
-0.0272009205,
0.0237986296,
0.0156230275,
0.048769515,
-0.0411886796,
-0.0081557715,
0.0489441231,
0.0043775393,
-0.0255134422,
0.055306416,
0.0122742392,
0.0322075263,
0.0079640439,
-0.1103542149,
-0.0336810611,
-0.0287025403,
-0.0318957046,
0.0470125638,
0.0529774241,
0.0460889824,
-0.0395176448,
0.0252625216,
0.0120483078,
0.0071064103,
-0.0126553914,
0.027612593,
-0.04948695,
0.0102753602,
0.006683642,
0.015934553,
-0.0195406973,
-0.032489948,
0.0124866851,
-0.0150772613,
0.0072836047,
0.0086541511,
-0.0057227002,
-0.0374565944,
-0.0268077478,
0.0069001038,
-0.0633346513,
0.0289076194,
-0.0319954753,
-0.0461413004,
0.0100580025,
0.0600269474,
0.0144075481,
-0.0146646276,
0.0151144844,
0.059091188,
-0.0074183014,
0.0303741265,
0.0118282977,
0.0257473737,
-0.0132945096,
0.0653512701,
0.0463166609,
0.022136936,
-0.0060785664,
-0.1159881875,
-0.0112199346,
0.0321099609,
-0.0273473784,
0.0620599613,
-0.0226455908,
-0.0110159926,
-0.0124445977,
0.0047612428,
-0.0067281257,
-0.0210725218,
0.0463307239,
0.0179605521,
-0.0501113236,
-0.0093633449,
-0.0104903253,
-0.0325164348,
-0.0101084104,
-0.0376275666,
0.0292220041,
0.0261207502,
0.0052811666,
-0.0225405078,
0.0433150716,
-0.0409087427,
0.065902546,
0.0506671183,
-0.0345406607,
0.0160709471,
-0.01713912,
-0.0114993369,
-0.0084372666,
-0.0430857576,
0.0410491787,
0.0113054039,
-0.0084913187,
0.03308402,
-0.0342369564,
-0.0094681848,
-0.0462991744,
-0.0118021565,
-0.0011718521,
0.0202408917,
-0.0789122283,
0.015465484,
0.0064847823,
-0.007101363,
-0.0201973841,
0.0727370754,
-0.038764134,
0.0220989753,
-0.0161271375,
-0.0521372817,
0.0438868366,
0.0316969566,
-0.0251086596,
0.0442845151,
-0.0059332633,
-0.0128240641,
0.0169048924,
-0.0309223682,
-0.0049905153,
0.001896388,
2.558e-7,
-0.0032234068,
0.0662304312,
0.0346302092,
0.0187495425,
0.0192170758,
0.0511070862,
0.0236863513,
0.0130446954,
0.022694299,
-0.0446105562,
0.0479037538,
0.0025379576,
0.0913777947,
-0.0060376218,
-0.0967935994,
0.0064425436,
-0.0393940471,
-0.0582276359,
-0.0136228967,
0.0040209703,
0.109961614,
0.059310779,
-0.0454812273,
0.0076298853,
0.0124228038,
-0.0179281589,
0.0397984311,
-0.0288698729,
-0.0112876361,
0.0250524972,
-0.0159579031,
-0.0518705919,
0.0038202764,
0.0138972513,
-0.0079806047,
0.0214136336,
0.0074552703,
0.0621790402,
0.0096328268,
-0.1228231415,
-0.0164379142,
0.0434176847,
0.0064548915,
-0.0327119753,
0.0231608283,
-0.0590168238,
-0.0292737521,
-0.0039251382,
-0.0081210444,
-0.0040720589,
-0.0175296385,
-0.0433714017,
-0.0057183863,
0.0452704541,
0.0120201828,
0.0118822241,
0.0081517212,
-0.0724984705,
-0.0222181622,
0.0195331629,
-0.0631315708,
-0.0437004268,
-0.02029269,
-0.0106729316,
0.0501023047,
-0.0180439781,
-0.0154228359,
2.347802928e-34,
0.0228396785,
-0.0157643054,
0.0106799165,
0.0535106398,
0.0181412697,
0.0042621531,
0.0152805112,
0.010574447,
0.0484420359,
-0.0591443889,
-0.0109048197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08123v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08123v1 | Who Wrote it and Why? Prompting Large-Language Models for Authorship Verification | 2023-10-12T08:24:15 | 2023-10-12T08:24:15 | Chia-Yu Hung, Zhiqiang Hu, Yujia Hu, Roy Ka-Wei Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Authorship verification (AV) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing (NLP) and computational linguistics, with applications in forensic
analysis, plagiarism detection, and identification of deceptive content.
Existing AV techniques, including traditional stylometric and deep learning
approaches, face limitations in terms of data requirements and lack of
explainability. To address these limitations, this paper proposes PromptAV, a
novel technique that leverages Large-Language Models (LLMs) for AV by providing
step-by-step stylometric explanation prompts. PromptAV outperforms
state-of-the-art baselines, operates effectively with limited training data,
and enhances interpretability through intuitive explanations, showcasing its
potential as an effective and interpretable solution for the AV task. | [
0.0496859886,
0.0736857653,
0.0004344851,
0.0555805936,
-0.0907570645,
0.0210444629,
0.0955088064,
0.0021471076,
-0.0154750636,
-0.0094801467,
0.0163384266,
-0.0514603034,
0.0246107876,
0.0242948309,
0.0375565104,
0.0233307779,
-0.015815841,
-0.0034329882,
0.0629807934,
0.0140756425,
0.018180063,
0.0391721427,
0.0200554896,
0.0435622744,
-0.015727384,
-0.0579991341,
0.0108945174,
0.0346799605,
0.0028232418,
0.0203224923,
-0.0157497581,
0.081176497,
0.0176014621,
0.0968263373,
0.0000017385,
-0.0642129406,
-0.0214771926,
0.0170192998,
-0.0672332421,
0.0192096159,
0.0455182046,
0.0255714618,
-0.0243565813,
-0.0025526388,
0.0067569073,
0.0017306737,
0.0166819207,
0.0655301288,
0.0450891666,
0.0883644447,
-0.006043728,
-0.0400985442,
0.0203787144,
0.0008619386,
0.0015625498,
0.0257735886,
0.0336833708,
-0.0552893057,
0.0076592821,
0.04569038,
0.0096379109,
0.0285946541,
0.0252194759,
-0.0707247555,
-0.0091807218,
0.0033500448,
0.0099604782,
0.0194350705,
0.0366164558,
-0.0046123415,
-0.0159429926,
-0.0414187163,
-0.0039531393,
0.0053372458,
0.006647185,
0.0260008164,
-0.0225217268,
0.0459824577,
-0.0328392945,
-0.0241234545,
0.010627388,
-0.0035998018,
0.0280154739,
0.0468228795,
0.0136123989,
0.0249602776,
0.0048849811,
-0.0187074188,
-0.0205009598,
-0.0208478756,
0.0069884839,
-0.0569239445,
0.046397917,
0.0300901886,
0.011438177,
-0.0331748948,
-0.0073050824,
-0.0665725321,
0.0227174982,
-0.0001254978,
0.0589174442,
-0.0375288129,
-0.0396093689,
0.0375833735,
-0.0355567262,
0.0645524114,
-0.0266457461,
0.0031438675,
-0.007301826,
-0.02237463,
-0.0281294789,
-0.0486392826,
-0.0236405637,
-0.0067641381,
0.0005418356,
0.0071246964,
-0.0326434262,
0.0145466281,
0.0166304018,
-0.0008885746,
-0.0272397678,
0.0084717274,
-0.0252357572,
-0.0105035175,
-0.0015524761,
0.019993851,
-0.019506529,
0.0103609608,
0.0071037184,
-0.0064740889,
-0.005419502,
0.0457995906,
0.0443594418,
-0.0299646948,
0.0439433418,
-0.0025305662,
0.0265289191,
-0.0189358555,
-0.0192834362,
-0.0371988043,
-0.0401865765,
-0.0429410525,
-0.0489702709,
-0.0500256233,
-0.0066541559,
-0.0164707955,
-0.0297230594,
-0.053318873,
-0.0335758477,
0.0311618559,
-0.0458529443,
0.0572945476,
0.0023904445,
-0.00356551,
0.0316740274,
-0.0181845762,
-0.0067973756,
-0.0546039268,
0.0378962681,
0.058716841,
0.0491757616,
-0.0291088354,
0.0374568813,
0.0079429494,
0.0058891098,
-0.0148481848,
0.0146745145,
-0.0280963276,
-0.0109881591,
0.0317079835,
0.0140346251,
0.0217584483,
0.0039979573,
-0.0197615828,
0.0849734098,
0.064578332,
-0.0005564661,
0.0390069745,
0.0742644444,
0.0424239039,
-0.0025111167,
-0.0135962293,
-0.0513347574,
0.0196152087,
-0.0386567824,
-0.0085703079,
-0.0334964357,
0.0235999096,
0.0021759295,
-0.0216649082,
-0.0037015213,
0.0042634537,
-0.011923017,
0.0283689816,
0.032054197,
0.0002354495,
-0.0268389564,
-0.0432989225,
0.002227864,
-0.064593859,
-0.0006577992,
-0.0326560624,
0.0702965185,
0.0670788214,
0.0420889407,
-0.0130812349,
0.0299598016,
-0.0710126683,
0.0380590186,
0.0402118638,
-0.0253691487,
-0.0017427142,
0.0040248493,
-0.0301491488,
-0.0227708258,
-0.0286694765,
-0.0046844906,
0.0395452864,
0.0231148042,
-0.0060680793,
0.0330698974,
-0.0239840243,
-0.0458686873,
0.0361495502,
-0.0257410966,
-0.0604698323,
0.0262607634,
0.0387949981,
0.0063969321,
0.0414086245,
-0.0146189379,
0.0072554145,
0.0110658342,
-0.0578401312,
-0.0347112417,
-0.0437757969,
0.0178608876,
-0.0133603355,
0.0156415217,
-0.0008852657,
0.0065845195,
0.0203714035,
-0.0308312662,
-0.0205812436,
-0.0125547461,
-0.0090575535,
-0.0339496881,
-0.0754192397,
-0.0033631085,
-0.0235015824,
0.0452770293,
-0.0327165574,
0.0540328771,
0.0421965271,
0.0219267923,
0.0163119007,
-0.0030273886,
0.0343559124,
-0.0227724686,
-0.0117592495,
-0.0079666069,
-0.0317650586,
0.0066908849,
0.0396986492,
0.0257196352,
-0.0044344203,
-0.0503269956,
-0.0802145526,
0.0105856676,
-0.0319399014,
0.0209564716,
-0.0121539813,
-0.016275011,
-0.0095201014,
0.0085002407,
-0.0284604356,
-0.0660641119,
-0.0132671092,
0.0212341808,
0.0550163575,
-0.0120083038,
-0.0549172424,
-0.0170744676,
-0.0138295433,
-0.0177569874,
0.0617863387,
0.0339676589,
-0.0043817307,
-0.0351365358,
0.0032087958,
-0.0008946966,
-0.027188899,
-0.0038225804,
0.0071076853,
0.0049226354,
-0.0382123813,
0.0275155678,
0.0676555187,
0.0152920112,
0.044023592,
-0.025478214,
0.0097702853,
-0.0248530693,
-0.0179773234,
-0.0279899314,
0.019751383,
-0.0024346411,
-0.0388768651,
0.0313920639,
0.0106736952,
-0.0131732086,
-0.03600334,
-0.0219254252,
0.0175948255,
0.0202394817,
0.0089902263,
0.0088142222,
-0.0599556379,
0.0005698545,
-0.0101197455,
-0.0333567783,
-0.0569902956,
0.0719405785,
-0.0761601254,
-0.0001125901,
0.0005581439,
-0.033456333,
-0.0361423045,
0.0847729072,
0.0026916121,
0.0221484508,
0.0220634323,
-0.0430787019,
0.0010704026,
0.0008953612,
0.0499807745,
0.0191797148,
-0.0112978434,
-0.0369551703,
0.0180889629,
0.0189819951,
0.0058368384,
-0.0175448079,
-0.1233893782,
-0.0341133215,
-0.005462578,
-0.0149585046,
-0.0488817394,
-0.0063107829,
-0.0441879109,
0.0537984595,
0.0301000439,
-0.0405469052,
0.0051978002,
-0.030964341,
0.0218451787,
-0.0011054877,
-0.0232069194,
0.0103603974,
-0.0383899584,
-0.0026037055,
-0.0061204839,
-0.0196387861,
0.0185934249,
-0.0267152507,
-0.0065683313,
-0.0234294906,
-0.0458104424,
-0.0401445143,
0.0111960014,
0.044353649,
-0.0896264091,
0.0222493391,
0.1433719844,
-0.0036187565,
-0.0240518004,
-0.0279196668,
-0.0224297084,
0.0122134946,
0.0051498329,
0.0274095684,
-0.068593584,
-0.0293297116,
0.001367242,
0.0108975293,
-0.034222059,
-0.0198049489,
-0.0280202311,
-0.0731906742,
0.065937236,
-0.0237405077,
-0.0518754981,
-0.002971078,
-0.0619655401,
-0.0565090366,
0.0333585031,
-0.0093620718,
-0.0055822795,
0.0059103207,
0.0083328681,
-0.001949991,
-0.0281916633,
0.0055905553,
0.0217540991,
-0.0520527102,
0.003885824,
0.0555963479,
0.0800798312,
-0.0273957569,
-0.0291435998,
-0.0148595069,
-0.0034637048,
-0.0000817481,
-0.0148610817,
0.0777025893,
-0.0110985544,
-0.0017756056,
-0.0451372787,
0.095045954,
-0.0444958955,
-0.0143755497,
-0.000843196,
0.0589232743,
-0.0089878906,
-0.0153460847,
0.0131304068,
-0.0239144154,
0.0336512253,
0.0732861906,
0.0457810014,
-0.0441203825,
-0.0775648206,
-0.0128504485,
-0.0289448034,
-0.0084850108,
-0.0271351784,
-0.002925989,
-0.0022113582,
-0.0332120173,
-0.0335863344,
-0.0115024718,
0.0097402493,
0.0086120702,
0.0193499047,
0.0460788496,
-0.0359578691,
-0.0259116963,
-0.0709993914,
0.0613882616,
-0.0297869612,
0.08340092,
-0.0314436816,
0.0383596122,
-0.0152563322,
-0.0541224219,
0.0092497813,
0.0224501677,
-0.0534823276,
-0.0173032563,
-0.0021034819,
-0.0243680645,
0.0134924846,
0.0708830953,
-0.0254725702,
-0.1150512695,
0.0400206894,
0.0154927215,
0.0059792041,
0.0020558373,
0.023550136,
-0.0210964605,
-0.0255490597,
0.0273458716,
-0.0242169276,
0.0268345494,
0.0495820157,
-0.0558330901,
0.0117527731,
-0.0264852159,
0.0021880579,
0.0373966657,
0.0461769924,
-0.026150059,
-0.0091402903,
-0.031360399,
-0.0186611507,
-0.0198484212,
-0.0151251033,
-0.0085276561,
0.0099006305,
0.0205785576,
-0.017409591,
-0.0175021812,
0.0156080788,
0.0142312767,
0.054372713,
-0.0334140211,
0.0454676189,
-0.0109455753,
0.051227849,
-0.003893344,
0.0145311281,
-0.0059261504,
0.0279722214,
-0.0125202918,
0.073253341,
-0.0041486463,
0.0443576388,
0.0246640649,
0.0196654759,
-0.0113903955,
0.0233679451,
-0.0824677423,
-0.0287300684,
0.0139888497,
0.0049120658,
0.0220315866,
-0.0435250923,
0.0428785756,
0.0064001642,
0.0029839345,
-0.0281341709,
0.0698415488,
0.0131697217,
-0.0201892257,
-0.0331520215,
0.0041225934,
-0.0379160605,
0.0394020788,
0.0464104526,
0.0194797497,
0.0187571626,
0.0250042658,
-0.0401411578,
-0.0128766568,
-0.0205136873,
0.0319118015,
0.0284391548,
-0.0002963951,
-0.0229472015,
-0.0648595095,
-0.0184249915,
0.0575987361,
-0.0107866656,
0.0005281472,
0.0033617362,
-0.0081592603,
0.0733016208,
-0.0246710237,
-0.0253336411,
-0.0426225998,
0.0701105148,
0.0161356796,
-0.0391104743,
0.0156913456,
-5.291097336e-33,
0.0181503799,
-0.0629516691,
-0.0015858986,
0.0173398703,
-0.0015548957,
0.0367894545,
-0.0373445004,
-0.0437246673,
-0.016172342,
0.0482953452,
-0.0233714581,
0.0001147166,
0.0068256441,
0.0322493203,
-0.0073052994,
0.0114361495,
0.04562122,
0.0279905535,
-0.0080634803,
0.0417003408,
0.0535673425,
0.0236210153,
0.0372322947,
-0.0535426401,
0.0639728084,
-0.0376219861,
-0.055231452,
0.0182063486,
-0.0439269021,
0.0247688871,
-0.0108744428,
0.0251697078,
0.0146892779,
-0.046547167,
0.0006058773,
0.0667655692,
-0.0640653372,
-0.0076021869,
-0.0150445988,
0.0221313592,
-0.0012296983,
-0.0675846934,
0.0238252915,
-0.0227968246,
0.0329850577,
-0.0098165283,
0.072379306,
-0.0045330515,
-0.0159051195,
-0.0578181706,
-0.0487848558,
0.0180508178,
-0.0325010046,
-0.0231034327,
0.0350326709,
0.0213283766,
-0.005090565,
0.0071575902,
-0.0477792248,
-0.0180789381,
-0.0228596628,
0.0088054575,
-0.0048887739,
0.0270423777,
-0.0365057886,
0.0317717977,
0.0303339288,
0.0008922112,
-0.0340983644,
0.0419679508,
0.0348314121,
0.0457789376,
0.0858039781,
0.0889408812,
0.0082852133,
0.0072657475,
-0.0537332967,
0.0168241914,
0.0377325565,
-0.0208951458,
0.0337551832,
-0.0322845057,
-0.0650069043,
-0.0392258801,
-0.0354375914,
-0.0623163842,
-0.0329565555,
0.0013092982,
0.0224699862,
-0.0277224984,
-0.0413133912,
0.0169889145,
0.0333090276,
-0.062082395,
-0.0220166724,
0.0171556585,
-0.0279500745,
0.0498388782,
-0.0015376481,
0.0094574559,
-0.0013717028,
-0.0146707091,
-0.0021969934,
-0.0072734575,
0.0126976967,
-0.0052089179,
0.1195630953,
0.0201966707,
-0.0557355434,
-0.0059014694,
-0.0036646114,
0.0312369652,
0.008042424,
0.0544931516,
-0.0170188434,
0.0342581533,
0.0151859485,
0.045923084,
0.0201755464,
0.015822215,
-0.0127577549,
0.0032677692,
-0.0107915299,
-0.0255232789,
-0.0135659818,
-0.0203291159,
0.0258498155,
0.0072411895,
0.0162039474,
-0.0301982109,
0.0141709466,
-0.0212851707,
2.311e-7,
0.0388532057,
0.0152907073,
0.0484425351,
-0.0348610692,
0.0018899472,
0.0467238612,
0.0653030798,
0.0118539501,
-0.0122740259,
-0.0267131217,
0.0189402271,
0.0267820749,
0.0795331895,
-0.0070860274,
-0.0853519365,
0.0229159519,
-0.0373675078,
-0.0292757694,
-0.0943225995,
0.0312210526,
0.0649626702,
0.0520169251,
0.0554579087,
-0.0587053895,
0.001397009,
-0.0700115785,
0.0288736206,
-0.0001626768,
0.0044119982,
0.0322022885,
0.0559096858,
-0.060529843,
0.0251110345,
0.0223032683,
-0.0104568359,
0.0274852663,
-0.0330615528,
0.0639747679,
-0.019529447,
0.01656726,
-0.0211646669,
-0.043650493,
0.0065031531,
-0.0704980195,
0.0630495995,
0.0468102209,
-0.0047522774,
-0.0434175171,
-0.0184720382,
-0.0564492159,
0.0083417268,
-0.0105802631,
0.0247192793,
0.0224867128,
0.0099731246,
-0.0529580265,
-0.0092505282,
-0.0753008127,
-0.018337993,
-0.0070219454,
-0.0366415977,
0.0487256348,
-0.0226576738,
-0.0154015766,
0.086666815,
-0.0918243602,
0.0272600185,
2.406455505e-34,
0.0208767671,
0.0134476433,
0.0021510152,
0.0065220296,
0.0563422181,
0.0593517572,
-0.0060292617,
0.0297023188,
0.0065088896,
-0.0580020174,
-0.0132849757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08104v1 | Voice Conversion for Stuttered Speech, Instruments, Unseen Languages and Textually Described Voices | 2023-10-12T08:00:25 | 2023-10-12T08:00:25 | Matthew Baas, Herman Kamper | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Voice conversion aims to convert source speech into a target voice using
recordings of the target speaker as a reference. Newer models are producing
increasingly realistic output. But what happens when models are fed with
non-standard data, such as speech from a user with a speech impairment? We
investigate how a recent voice conversion model performs on non-standard
downstream voice conversion tasks. We use a simple but robust approach called
k-nearest neighbors voice conversion (kNN-VC). We look at four non-standard
applications: stuttered voice conversion, cross-lingual voice conversion,
musical instrument conversion, and text-to-voice conversion. The latter
involves converting to a target voice specified through a text description,
e.g. "a young man with a high-pitched voice". Compared to an established
baseline, we find that kNN-VC retains high performance in stuttered and
cross-lingual voice conversion. Results are more mixed for the musical
instrument and text-to-voice conversion tasks. E.g., kNN-VC works well on some
instruments like drums but not on others. Nevertheless, this shows that voice
conversion models - and kNN-VC in particular - are increasingly applicable in a
range of non-standard downstream tasks. But there are still limitations when
samples are very far from the training distribution. Code, samples, trained
models: https://rf5.github.io/sacair2023-knnvc-demo/. | [
-0.0117771253,
0.0528182127,
0.0080463449,
-0.0188060421,
0.0136129363,
-0.0513006821,
0.05157011,
0.017995717,
-0.0717054754,
0.0022590135,
-0.070807673,
-0.0052319989,
0.0510656051,
0.0169930328,
0.0298442151,
-0.0986729339,
0.0450235568,
-0.0838685855,
-0.0107762953,
0.0080190673,
-0.0164157357,
0.0230034348,
-0.0549611449,
0.0386944227,
-0.0039637289,
-0.0049096746,
0.0253209565,
0.0346883386,
-0.0268984474,
0.0114736902,
-0.0229875445,
-0.0223129597,
0.0016233481,
0.0181104895,
0.0000018467,
0.014886749,
0.014348045,
-0.0208100639,
-0.0208782367,
0.0147909168,
0.0650181919,
-0.0091443006,
-0.0202097464,
0.0256170481,
0.0030654175,
-0.0547706634,
0.0322811082,
0.0167172104,
0.0189113244,
0.0560837425,
0.0064418982,
-0.0336039513,
0.0342835188,
-0.0101663312,
-0.0066756988,
-0.0024670453,
-0.0099416608,
-0.0220207591,
-0.0260223802,
-0.0265871268,
0.0010376815,
0.088781178,
-0.0300672762,
-0.0181440432,
0.0130891521,
0.0104994876,
-0.0434748717,
-0.0354523137,
0.0198188238,
0.0064239842,
-0.0447478555,
0.0000350918,
0.0177389495,
0.0286728851,
-0.0076882923,
0.0176302884,
-0.0108008562,
-0.0058578197,
0.0189868417,
-0.0033930726,
-0.0664967522,
0.057919085,
0.0281099416,
-0.04398074,
-0.0202062447,
-0.0426857285,
0.0098349079,
-0.0458818562,
0.0245717019,
-0.0159405656,
-0.0320955142,
-0.0060225609,
0.0514111221,
-0.0296350587,
-0.0346047282,
-0.0203301255,
-0.0430302396,
-0.0111071728,
-0.015899498,
-0.0204796791,
0.0295065138,
0.0587623119,
-0.0414641649,
-0.0160705876,
-0.0408546962,
0.0133924419,
-0.0030118548,
0.0078188144,
-0.013241468,
0.0109908925,
-0.0475189202,
-0.0082428232,
-0.0514725335,
-0.0382292941,
-0.0184685104,
-0.0192036368,
-0.0168327987,
-0.0097420234,
-0.0329314619,
-0.0147161856,
-0.0020658737,
0.0313419402,
-0.0565138608,
-0.0161565654,
-0.0043382514,
0.0545131676,
0.0325377397,
0.0927728564,
0.0155112352,
-0.0163931362,
0.0223437846,
-0.0083978036,
0.0145617528,
-0.01360639,
0.0418847464,
0.0198511835,
0.0041893278,
0.0263234004,
-0.0088208085,
-0.0177992154,
-0.030064011,
-0.0121987108,
-0.0193932168,
-0.0776259452,
0.0194967873,
-0.0423175357,
0.0152082564,
-0.0299322512,
-0.0216710046,
0.0249220394,
-0.0220255386,
0.0609145872,
-0.0131065575,
0.0616317652,
0.0758858472,
-0.0025506197,
-0.0497860722,
0.013090943,
0.0487240627,
-0.0385370106,
0.0332971923,
-0.0742113665,
0.0005693017,
0.0844745636,
0.045890525,
0.002748366,
-0.0570846722,
-0.0103141963,
-0.0051231668,
0.0616961196,
0.081640847,
0.0369233973,
-0.0027176847,
-0.0070248959,
0.0528551675,
0.0281880908,
0.0688238889,
0.0057860552,
0.026748836,
0.0084818108,
-0.0050043645,
-0.0058763279,
-0.0381246991,
-0.0001468111,
-0.0121485032,
0.011133723,
0.0416310728,
0.0636099353,
-0.0504319258,
0.02396583,
0.0497896522,
-0.0324704833,
-0.0165355019,
-0.0185964108,
0.0295616146,
0.0466561355,
0.023500368,
0.0367517993,
-0.0334948748,
-0.0562712215,
0.045517303,
-0.0522848554,
-0.0362904705,
-0.000421255,
0.0088783503,
0.0038853593,
0.0294950679,
-0.0579772368,
-0.0403999574,
0.0397205129,
-0.0160306562,
-0.0225146282,
0.0342244841,
-0.0206111912,
-0.0067764963,
0.0485307835,
0.0064179045,
-0.0256817378,
-0.0562835,
0.0353262387,
0.0488595515,
-0.0581403561,
0.044641532,
-0.0011309396,
-0.0262160506,
0.0145175019,
0.0632993057,
0.0134635326,
0.0042820964,
0.0469244905,
0.0181190129,
0.0312365759,
-0.0116147781,
-0.0429354757,
0.0032157928,
0.0174875986,
-0.0197081417,
-0.0616845824,
0.0480638631,
0.0001283963,
0.0773351267,
0.0469471291,
0.028057307,
-0.1030598134,
0.0347373299,
0.0163181983,
-0.0028300383,
0.0062160841,
0.0192707982,
0.0113213034,
-0.0013573695,
0.0309855286,
-0.009000916,
0.0398927964,
0.0018413779,
0.0079382164,
-0.0065508084,
-0.0119123766,
-0.0697704032,
-0.0094128475,
0.0346045829,
-0.0415777788,
0.0123443399,
-0.0060693594,
-0.0404082537,
-0.0093769804,
-0.0233970359,
-0.065583095,
0.0450298153,
-0.0022355309,
0.0347323753,
-0.0055376911,
0.0350366123,
0.0179045871,
-0.0305721927,
-0.0561369471,
-0.0168886259,
0.0248696897,
0.0131334336,
-0.0607595854,
0.0115423882,
-0.0000650573,
-0.0134892287,
-0.0030035111,
0.0290058032,
-0.0181704219,
-0.0652268305,
-0.068104431,
-0.0446786657,
0.0571014844,
-0.0139945056,
0.0147531722,
0.0203390811,
0.0181082096,
-0.0176592618,
0.0123421382,
-0.0040757423,
-0.0336588733,
-0.0011179722,
-0.0729446709,
0.0293480419,
-0.0050878217,
-0.0888893306,
-0.0089078257,
0.0617224872,
0.0121902023,
-0.0593257286,
-0.0128794964,
0.016347507,
0.0066310163,
0.0612538643,
-0.0051749931,
-0.0414233096,
-0.0014983347,
-0.0130069302,
-0.0006460933,
-0.002484838,
0.0181765687,
-0.0079460172,
0.0049305353,
-0.0111878114,
0.0148232756,
0.0021318244,
-0.0474444665,
-0.0418413579,
0.015753353,
-0.0597705767,
0.0044086669,
-0.0187817384,
-0.0416267402,
-0.0006044311,
-0.0442030542,
0.0073724529,
-0.0225349497,
0.0139215244,
-0.0070631769,
-0.0442355424,
0.0110283047,
-0.0025201612,
0.0036609017,
-0.0441906378,
-0.0076121916,
0.005558379,
-0.019548323,
0.0329218432,
0.0221946053,
-0.0176794883,
-0.0039087553,
0.0069470899,
0.0467234254,
-0.0259046312,
0.0913951248,
-0.0220984817,
-0.0154797602,
-0.0193628781,
0.0752660409,
-0.0103097958,
0.0137936128,
-0.001722518,
-0.0117188906,
0.0526311919,
-0.0148471044,
0.0449053496,
0.0295395236,
-0.0183468089,
-0.0415272526,
0.0162175223,
0.0383153856,
-0.0643386468,
0.0420562327,
0.0296859387,
-0.0539061837,
0.0166118182,
0.0579356849,
-0.0014790737,
-0.0601191334,
-0.0056340965,
-0.0116146235,
0.0040792101,
-0.0207730792,
0.0050266939,
-0.0562723987,
-0.0095823463,
0.0373572819,
0.0908851326,
0.0150625901,
0.0008991864,
0.0008125184,
-0.0558980368,
0.0308201183,
0.0372528434,
-0.071274206,
-0.0532538109,
-0.0031616963,
0.0012508334,
0.0076619131,
0.0684428141,
0.0155907478,
-0.0223366972,
0.026918212,
0.040245641,
-0.0242549349,
-0.0681849271,
-0.0208295211,
-0.0346834436,
0.1461359113,
0.0642806813,
0.0135808298,
-0.0048048622,
-0.0099308509,
0.0139547279,
-0.0277262926,
0.0038290056,
-0.0044877776,
0.0330599658,
0.0634342507,
0.0126748076,
0.0592050739,
0.0338142999,
-0.0371563509,
0.0246625263,
0.0266121905,
0.0199731607,
-0.004200506,
-0.0347639769,
-0.0069861021,
-0.0053270683,
0.0431220606,
0.0686733872,
0.0036126291,
-0.0404292606,
0.0009187738,
0.0281620063,
0.0537190177,
-0.0197402444,
-0.0480081998,
0.0231065024,
-0.0030734364,
-0.0631254837,
-0.0291318074,
0.0166381616,
0.006630633,
0.0535167456,
0.0095163574,
0.0091428859,
-0.0063744136,
-0.0026259252,
-0.0159347672,
0.0051968805,
-0.0298912115,
0.0447860621,
-0.0344230682,
0.0064483616,
0.028738765,
-0.0304849744,
0.0137225511,
-0.0488031618,
-0.0208222587,
-0.0307488441,
0.0218649954,
-0.0221068468,
0.0167083871,
0.0462504514,
-0.0218754448,
-0.0406280197,
0.0154829416,
0.0285604987,
-0.086973004,
0.071556896,
0.0645920634,
-0.0002517664,
-0.009720251,
0.0329802483,
-0.0251814444,
0.0087598218,
-0.0385804847,
0.0128577081,
-0.0137848603,
-0.0435177945,
-0.0280548725,
0.0060223802,
0.0310502574,
-0.023088621,
0.0449836403,
-0.0180767253,
0.0039898246,
-0.0041811415,
0.0512594208,
-0.0616630428,
-0.0295679066,
0.0802095532,
0.0437986031,
0.0244219117,
-0.0139796054,
-0.015246043,
0.0361126028,
-0.0477042012,
0.0090635503,
0.054670468,
0.0249270573,
0.0108902333,
0.0141752902,
-0.0029034088,
0.0454457104,
0.0438617282,
0.0056126281,
-0.0396882631,
-0.0020552746,
-0.0082652131,
0.0073945224,
0.0168584231,
0.0066495454,
-0.0373557098,
-0.0447483659,
-0.0298542921,
-0.0256593116,
-0.0259186886,
0.0146809258,
0.083199136,
0.0245447289,
0.0304600783,
-0.0178458244,
0.0025965325,
-0.0076843612,
0.0158713162,
-0.0148453135,
-0.048905883,
-0.0055712485,
0.0079100123,
0.028425619,
-0.0352548324,
0.0253676679,
-0.0525913648,
-0.0068242555,
0.0244556107,
-0.0247545242,
-0.0066988491,
-0.0165689439,
-0.0320719443,
-0.0340763591,
0.0058790524,
-0.0215705652,
0.0165907517,
-0.0135528017,
-0.0237492025,
-0.0152616594,
-0.0024078048,
0.0001149362,
-0.0144974459,
0.037895456,
-0.0145783825,
-0.0298169479,
0.00500724,
-0.0256118234,
0.008059076,
-4.916348267e-33,
-0.0706664696,
0.0453309976,
0.0141539266,
-0.0214638039,
-0.0506285168,
-0.0328931436,
-0.0455232933,
0.0016323837,
0.0156917889,
0.0044498318,
-0.0290965009,
0.007684744,
0.0214312486,
0.0217782371,
0.0254670568,
-0.0018963809,
0.1115839556,
-0.0335449576,
-0.0077425372,
0.0408105664,
0.0690257996,
0.0268358402,
0.0031763189,
-0.1015048102,
-0.0078569977,
0.0073422091,
-0.0271341596,
-0.0152613912,
0.0150708277,
-0.0229998697,
-0.0070704091,
0.0449084193,
-0.018406326,
-0.0110949222,
-0.0341777094,
0.0075505814,
-0.097553134,
0.0128850052,
-0.0374701917,
0.0683203861,
0.0366737954,
-0.0156899001,
0.0415812992,
0.0222554374,
-0.0128373262,
-0.0115956385,
0.0042787553,
-0.0691304281,
-0.0345453583,
-0.0788625553,
-0.001509625,
0.0303746145,
-0.0187861957,
-0.0286585167,
0.0836956874,
0.1429501921,
-0.0568246134,
-0.0796636865,
-0.0372873433,
0.0148137314,
-0.0298430249,
0.0508378968,
0.0130478488,
0.0259466358,
-0.022161277,
-0.0178246405,
0.0602771938,
-0.0862623304,
0.0145016601,
0.0027867961,
0.0598612167,
0.0472552739,
0.0327674113,
0.0124667166,
0.0342781805,
-0.0690789744,
0.0080434587,
0.0307312217,
0.0171736293,
-0.0506362617,
0.0136124091,
0.0407523327,
-0.0184833705,
-0.0246794093,
-0.0419327021,
-0.0600452833,
0.0030349749,
-0.0257316735,
0.0340797193,
0.0050823032,
0.0217279792,
-0.0192452725,
0.0513245165,
-0.0176459868,
0.0112286741,
-0.0139715318,
-0.0405237339,
0.036819879,
-0.0372120701,
-0.0254531484,
-0.0122306421,
-0.0502001271,
0.0863489658,
0.0114623914,
0.0359531492,
-0.0131550832,
-0.0178945791,
0.0416623838,
-0.040078342,
0.0028034172,
0.0228444003,
0.0429896601,
0.0059101507,
0.0442810655,
0.0165599976,
-0.0196118653,
0.0234134179,
0.0029800741,
-0.0327477977,
-0.0281292703,
0.013057936,
0.0279273819,
0.0319661945,
0.0291106887,
-0.0495752729,
0.0238031801,
-0.0105877537,
-0.0206842721,
-0.0033737211,
-0.0169822164,
-0.0199186523,
0.014230838,
2.567e-7,
0.0330823027,
-0.0299021937,
0.0094074458,
-0.0596531779,
0.0009887066,
0.0308591481,
-0.0375388525,
0.0174125787,
0.0081289476,
0.0348157696,
0.0249349494,
-0.0380042642,
0.0981079713,
0.0580571815,
-0.0602750666,
-0.0200757664,
-0.0589356646,
0.0413393602,
-0.0099046221,
0.0275207534,
0.0257924162,
0.0225421395,
-0.0521165691,
-0.0952992439,
0.0421626158,
-0.042925518,
0.0467535369,
-0.0112691615,
0.013942562,
-0.0174634513,
0.0587865822,
-0.0428604633,
-0.0032273193,
0.022055503,
-0.0165035166,
0.0408392251,
0.0446428396,
0.0444647707,
0.01071853,
-0.0190580972,
-0.0219610259,
0.0338722728,
-0.0024136659,
0.0027497003,
0.0703493729,
-0.0098390849,
0.0244656447,
-0.0196473394,
-0.0672502741,
0.0257290397,
0.0042375121,
-0.0272982959,
0.0271408167,
-0.0282780621,
0.0323816985,
0.0528201684,
-0.0381940529,
-0.0092538353,
-0.0432011373,
0.0207656045,
-0.0756066591,
-0.0103801014,
-0.0376309492,
0.0640722886,
-0.0246762671,
-0.0165350158,
-0.0058725248,
2.100836387e-34,
-0.0008314205,
0.015788151,
0.0256866813,
-0.0396617986,
-0.0471597724,
-0.0435934775,
0.0551908091,
0.0357088745,
-0.0494181998,
-0.04264348,
-0.0399314612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08102v1 | QASiNa: Religious Domain Question Answering using Sirah Nabawiyah | 2023-10-12T07:52:19 | 2023-10-12T07:52:19 | Muhammad Razif Rizqullah, Ayu Purwarianti, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nowadays, Question Answering (QA) tasks receive significant research focus,
particularly with the development of Large Language Model (LLM) such as Chat
GPT [1]. LLM can be applied to various domains, but it contradicts the
principles of information transmission when applied to the Islamic domain. In
Islam we strictly regulates the sources of information and who can give
interpretations or tafseer for that sources [2]. The approach used by LLM to
generate answers based on its own interpretation is similar to the concept of
tafseer, LLM is neither an Islamic expert nor a human which is not permitted in
Islam. Indonesia is the country with the largest Islamic believer population in
the world [3]. With the high influence of LLM, we need to make evaluation of
LLM in religious domain. Currently, there is only few religious QA dataset
available and none of them using Sirah Nabawiyah especially in Indonesian
Language. In this paper, we propose the Question Answering Sirah Nabawiyah
(QASiNa) dataset, a novel dataset compiled from Sirah Nabawiyah literatures in
Indonesian language. We demonstrate our dataset by using mBERT [4], XLM-R [5],
and IndoBERT [6] which fine-tuned with Indonesian translation of SQuAD v2.0
[7]. XLM-R model returned the best performance on QASiNa with EM of 61.20,
F1-Score of 75.94, and Substring Match of 70.00. We compare XLM-R performance
with Chat GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 [1]. Both Chat GPT version returned lower EM and
F1-Score with higher Substring Match, the gap of EM and Substring Match get
wider in GPT-4. The experiment indicate that Chat GPT tends to give excessive
interpretations as evidenced by its higher Substring Match scores compared to
EM and F1-Score, even after providing instruction and context. This concludes
Chat GPT is unsuitable for question answering task in religious domain
especially for Islamic religion. | [
0.0874142796,
0.0258655623,
-0.0241730288,
0.0274118893,
-0.0529279746,
0.0215745494,
-0.0048965532,
0.0136066321,
-0.0226778071,
-0.0097402725,
-0.0577903204,
-0.0773945153,
0.0366992578,
-0.0339335725,
0.0104668755,
-0.0267855171,
0.0594421215,
-0.0335538425,
0.0277709775,
-0.0028749751,
0.0475161113,
0.048727151,
-0.0146590108,
0.008256373,
0.0113897705,
-0.0395236015,
-0.04119201,
-0.0353245139,
0.0245119873,
0.021917047,
0.002330096,
0.0425008349,
-0.0145715615,
0.0289510991,
0.0000021183,
-0.0552467518,
-0.0012169472,
-0.0218536314,
-0.019889174,
0.0330504179,
0.0303566214,
0.016398523,
0.0050460398,
0.0089841578,
-0.0457762554,
0.0103399418,
0.0296009909,
0.0802307576,
0.0794899762,
0.0541370735,
0.0272860248,
-0.0923619568,
0.0240425952,
0.0009489885,
0.0243502818,
-0.0271902513,
0.0153435813,
0.030009767,
0.0168157071,
0.0473564938,
-0.0453684479,
0.0224168338,
0.0442848764,
-0.0026609595,
-0.0591852702,
-0.0409119427,
-0.073491089,
-0.0199121349,
0.0296875108,
0.0344089195,
0.0144912899,
-0.022021072,
0.0277979504,
0.0392745025,
-0.0037783699,
0.0653603226,
-0.0238132961,
0.0069234776,
-0.0720404461,
-0.0144995991,
0.0377135314,
0.0382307544,
-0.019727543,
0.0209558979,
-0.0176586732,
0.0137590282,
0.0201760139,
-0.0330532044,
-0.0409323238,
-0.0456791818,
-0.066797033,
-0.0374570861,
0.002600505,
0.017643664,
0.0059578489,
0.0090717357,
-0.0388013721,
0.0098268669,
0.0288533736,
-0.0878387541,
0.0020511644,
0.074535042,
0.0495586842,
0.0135963066,
-0.0134892594,
0.0473004431,
0.0192221738,
-0.0045983223,
-0.0582935326,
-0.0317365453,
-0.0490336791,
-0.0181848314,
-0.0522873923,
0.0410436876,
-0.051994767,
0.0154447611,
-0.0783060938,
0.0132461814,
0.0358688086,
-0.0483634546,
0.0101380497,
0.0041480642,
-0.0349813215,
-0.0099040316,
-0.0279696845,
-0.0055860532,
-0.0557097606,
0.0008894789,
-0.0336262248,
-0.1069303751,
0.022878198,
0.0189225655,
-0.0227498244,
-0.0238532964,
0.0076382537,
0.0593677908,
-0.0071694152,
-0.0073255571,
-0.0301017817,
0.0049061696,
-0.0302556138,
-0.0616605617,
-0.0236783586,
-0.0601818375,
0.0685861558,
0.0349229574,
-0.0364378989,
0.021688506,
0.016760299,
0.0713066906,
0.0218710098,
0.0417265669,
0.0115185501,
0.0429344177,
0.0995690152,
0.0156247895,
0.0330319963,
0.0225988422,
0.0303841047,
0.016155323,
0.024811808,
-0.0159200002,
0.0089297099,
0.0007956213,
0.0417435095,
-0.0229644049,
0.0000292565,
0.0689174905,
-0.0193898156,
0.0174469445,
-0.0299012866,
0.0499342531,
-0.0102750314,
-0.0069550257,
-0.0101543749,
0.0593784973,
0.0311976392,
0.070836924,
0.0106070209,
0.0675390959,
0.0812802464,
0.0026804942,
-0.0020317365,
0.0390375815,
-0.0008773496,
0.0182723049,
0.0728057101,
0.0473807789,
-0.0303211864,
-0.0429059416,
0.0186406802,
0.0193082727,
-0.02870051,
0.0220035724,
0.0365049168,
-0.0021478352,
0.0054883775,
0.0268477984,
0.0549111255,
-0.0251730941,
-0.0086100893,
-0.0708129406,
0.0281617939,
-0.0032814497,
0.0260843877,
-0.0058690645,
-0.0105845891,
0.0068557314,
0.0312901065,
0.036938604,
0.0074869534,
0.002779234,
-0.0233687814,
-0.0349423103,
-0.0002871618,
0.0202391054,
-0.0168566667,
-0.0198546983,
0.037462838,
0.0462861247,
0.0499153323,
-0.0495298803,
0.0014145323,
0.0278033763,
0.0078066541,
-0.0175210554,
-0.0354007334,
-0.0099588037,
0.0517283492,
0.0193267632,
-0.005874366,
-0.0114047965,
0.0214485563,
-0.0223959889,
-0.0262512229,
-0.0007322932,
-0.0470029302,
-0.0289756991,
0.032501027,
-0.0627619103,
0.0120623298,
0.090310812,
-0.0260252412,
-0.0607824475,
0.0295910463,
-0.0507220589,
-0.0216046721,
-0.0285419095,
-0.0076856357,
-0.0083223078,
0.0010198947,
-0.0325824805,
0.0774757937,
-0.0054001743,
0.033128541,
-0.0094165383,
0.0007578442,
0.0617033467,
0.0035093946,
-0.0148576004,
-0.0040898337,
0.0091379993,
0.0378332697,
0.0357441567,
-0.0152563965,
-0.0122951856,
-0.0286218561,
-0.0702116117,
0.0143832704,
0.0184740797,
0.0556705184,
0.0111376587,
0.0170987323,
-0.023824241,
-0.0172111448,
-0.0492582805,
-0.0305195395,
0.0658495203,
-0.0023539225,
0.0355886668,
-0.0186822154,
0.0085124848,
-0.0402869955,
-0.0422047079,
0.0165330116,
0.0179522559,
0.0376705527,
-0.0480859503,
-0.005433863,
-0.0140153756,
-0.0591465756,
-0.032405436,
-0.0095310993,
-0.0601217151,
-0.0120733604,
0.0095380349,
-0.0493664965,
-0.0153376898,
0.0672369152,
-0.0598335601,
-0.0594771095,
0.0226667225,
-0.0492513031,
0.0003062145,
0.0072435634,
-0.0424251705,
-0.0061698812,
-0.0451422743,
-0.0029851457,
0.0180561189,
0.0373775624,
0.0081675667,
-0.0409778357,
0.0539293513,
-0.0275155939,
-0.0073231412,
-0.0106097935,
-0.0174329411,
-0.0131304925,
0.0679722056,
-0.009288705,
-0.046629671,
0.0046672379,
-0.0056278296,
0.0072793709,
-0.0637193918,
0.0232494548,
-0.0709369183,
-0.0127935093,
-0.0613052398,
0.0269210283,
-0.0218936391,
-0.0280965343,
-0.0237674359,
-0.0115857869,
-0.0190865584,
-0.0473151356,
0.0117480336,
0.0297519248,
0.0418900177,
-0.0561489798,
0.0167655218,
-0.0629070401,
-0.0158357676,
-0.0203624088,
-0.0143642314,
0.0242241416,
0.0575898364,
-0.006243296,
0.055579517,
0.0201284066,
-0.076134868,
-0.0390157625,
-0.0041716322,
-0.0097657032,
0.0053297575,
0.0329535343,
-0.0159100369,
0.0280583818,
0.0051348573,
0.0258391649,
0.0600737333,
-0.0324987918,
-0.0007593035,
-0.0019755282,
-0.0320876539,
0.0040989085,
-0.0160888769,
-0.0163207725,
-0.0374587998,
0.0167557485,
-0.0409277491,
0.0231345221,
0.0978142768,
0.0419765115,
0.0076752305,
-0.0093808072,
-0.047741022,
-0.01139207,
-0.0215105992,
0.0611450188,
-0.1306827813,
-0.0095712477,
-0.009787526,
0.0174362715,
-0.0075683035,
0.0023221187,
0.0173054431,
-0.0767539963,
-0.0216643177,
-0.0225378238,
-0.0567024201,
-0.0544372611,
-0.0071353973,
-0.0107635967,
0.013378459,
0.0140021313,
0.0308048856,
-0.0196127351,
0.065492712,
0.0349318534,
0.0170148872,
-0.0016788739,
0.0440534651,
-0.0174770039,
0.0216934513,
0.040183641,
0.0337433033,
-0.0444358811,
-0.0061533549,
-0.0167771559,
-0.0525014736,
-0.0253760722,
-0.0132487267,
0.003998952,
0.004579714,
-0.0326850899,
-0.0760730356,
-0.0147743691,
-0.0465712398,
0.0280998647,
0.0599718802,
0.030141497,
-0.0132798748,
0.0290899444,
0.003226795,
0.0534610823,
-0.0203465894,
0.0669135451,
-0.0083196815,
-0.0493827909,
-0.0020169979,
-0.0046198433,
-0.0436832607,
-0.0104792435,
-0.0789030641,
-0.029719511,
0.038725853,
0.0318543874,
-0.0892363936,
-0.0387730636,
-0.0192879811,
0.024919847,
0.0085352287,
0.0184463952,
-0.0101850145,
0.0509900413,
-0.0368997641,
-0.0306787398,
-0.0220928397,
0.0017008105,
-0.0425130688,
0.0427447967,
0.021424206,
-0.0461162068,
-0.0061804452,
0.004666666,
-0.0536482744,
-0.0184361506,
0.0165380985,
0.0363600962,
0.0219343379,
-0.0379790701,
-0.0166319106,
-0.0207854323,
-0.0084438054,
0.0094953608,
-0.0403799675,
0.0499045774,
0.0350118652,
0.0535157844,
-0.02523374,
0.0440531038,
0.0163550973,
0.0390184447,
0.0095723448,
-0.0201424472,
0.0094736582,
-0.0441548042,
0.028783638,
0.0014617385,
-0.0731361806,
0.0112065692,
-0.0208059028,
-0.0003006422,
0.0027099999,
-0.017015446,
-0.0076468522,
-0.0311781839,
0.0029310342,
0.0159590784,
0.0183813032,
0.0112695852,
-0.0500330292,
0.001945953,
-0.024693694,
-0.0375507846,
0.0379319489,
0.0252849218,
0.0387436524,
-0.0585027486,
0.0235201214,
-0.0132995173,
-0.0368334018,
-0.0026128751,
0.0410741232,
-0.0313402116,
0.0785861164,
-0.0207201187,
-0.0085517466,
0.0290958993,
0.0445566215,
-0.0252889376,
-0.0733105987,
0.0102130948,
0.057002157,
0.0138732232,
0.0270512085,
0.0005094553,
0.0494703129,
0.0099893976,
-0.01628411,
0.0228589624,
0.039425984,
0.0396835618,
0.0398829877,
0.0210286453,
-0.0327470265,
0.0191467404,
0.0595976152,
-0.0121461628,
0.0270742662,
0.0294522606,
-0.0260352045,
-0.0119357659,
-0.0075065643,
-0.0298439879,
0.0211046003,
-0.0207696352,
0.0285684764,
-0.0625933111,
-0.0285632145,
0.0206730161,
0.0134217078,
-0.0184748657,
-0.0209665895,
0.0536843687,
0.0681572333,
0.0391455367,
-0.0347551666,
-0.0747556239,
0.0453770645,
-0.0251238272,
-0.0212211981,
-0.0318193734,
-6.07002581e-33,
-0.0506656282,
0.0065771881,
0.0026560402,
-0.0045572924,
0.0157760344,
-0.0232096501,
0.0010835724,
-0.0100155612,
-0.0723822713,
-0.004724069,
-0.048179999,
0.0270462967,
0.0196549036,
0.0001890573,
0.0115567371,
-0.0601968877,
-0.0135220177,
-0.0185987968,
-0.0121813873,
0.0374806225,
0.0272357184,
0.0168730449,
0.0675197765,
-0.0493007414,
0.0056399954,
-0.0475443453,
-0.0109815141,
-0.0036120708,
-0.0116365999,
0.082918115,
-0.0344638303,
0.0575230643,
0.0339851305,
-0.0522201359,
-0.0025703793,
0.0406228974,
-0.058795955,
-0.0174733493,
0.0687101856,
0.0201807711,
-0.0446299165,
-0.0165921561,
-0.0046613715,
-0.0275649689,
-0.0171626005,
0.0419972576,
0.0126019614,
-0.0054358798,
-0.0076715304,
0.0098848399,
-0.0706720576,
0.03598487,
0.0110959802,
-0.0267040767,
-0.0085686166,
0.083308354,
-0.0258340258,
0.0025530695,
-0.0260869693,
-0.0263509341,
0.0314547159,
0.0346913636,
-0.006478976,
0.015238761,
-0.0193376858,
-0.0048608081,
0.0231635012,
-0.0277536623,
0.0506343953,
-0.007822182,
-0.041543331,
-0.0106464941,
0.0508090481,
0.0806484893,
0.0185968392,
0.0025089593,
-0.0782519951,
0.0091995215,
0.0066339318,
0.0174010843,
0.0186752845,
-0.0216716267,
-0.0769628808,
0.0036682351,
0.015536692,
0.0051501724,
-0.0243524332,
-0.0292202476,
0.0279134866,
-0.0043340987,
-0.0369653702,
-0.0047882302,
0.0205348693,
-0.0609819777,
0.0521265082,
0.0033662149,
-0.0144403856,
0.0018319822,
-0.0056803958,
0.0388980098,
-0.0534983352,
0.0269265287,
0.0205694325,
-0.0058104312,
-0.0124512464,
-0.024882311,
0.0060899691,
-0.0326368958,
-0.0671499744,
-0.0010287821,
-0.0169070531,
0.0400851034,
-0.0261407197,
0.0079491334,
0.0078304661,
0.0136565454,
-0.0024944341,
0.0232079942,
0.0139112258,
-0.0532268323,
-0.0271605048,
-0.0412868224,
-0.0041246722,
-0.0205797963,
-0.0187096968,
0.0551126823,
-0.0488051213,
0.0366406851,
-0.0601595156,
-0.0573005453,
-0.0011379973,
0.0315503664,
2.903e-7,
0.0728223696,
-0.0283927657,
0.0392804854,
0.0172667466,
-0.0222515352,
-0.0063142572,
0.051193051,
0.0119650653,
0.0254719891,
0.0362835452,
-0.0012721588,
0.0052783494,
0.0593111031,
-0.0048581152,
-0.0694528148,
-0.0343480445,
-0.0622292757,
-0.0045944289,
-0.0459348112,
0.0107000545,
0.0515997373,
0.1179728284,
-0.0248483773,
-0.0136526795,
-0.0558197275,
-0.0061726724,
0.042544622,
0.0234241448,
-0.0512264371,
0.0503035933,
0.0411012359,
-0.003676486,
0.0290660914,
0.0185574498,
0.0019166602,
0.0328700244,
0.0521069989,
0.0827306733,
0.0321087949,
0.0066323206,
-0.0084752599,
-0.0010479214,
0.0057574352,
-0.0743803009,
0.1154533029,
-0.0326723605,
-0.0359281376,
0.0218163077,
-0.0094882501,
0.0196211189,
-0.0000137673,
0.01713291,
-0.0324920267,
0.0062352968,
0.0406293087,
-0.0157117639,
-0.0104505168,
-0.0404209979,
0.026361471,
-0.0197817832,
-0.0238068271,
-0.0191079061,
-0.0138770333,
-0.0179287791,
0.0288095213,
0.0168405604,
-0.0062815882,
2.41011446e-34,
0.0348538123,
-0.0051938966,
0.0306825042,
-0.0036676084,
0.0409291945,
0.0209459234,
-0.0036646225,
0.0015089106,
0.0399635546,
-0.0473878682,
-0.0210446306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08101v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08101v2 | Promptor: A Conversational and Autonomous Prompt Generation Agent for Intelligent Text Entry Techniques | 2023-10-12T07:51:43 | 2023-10-15T06:59:36 | Junxiao Shen, John J. Dudley, Jingyao Zheng, Bill Byrne, Per Ola Kristensson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text entry is an essential task in our day-to-day digital interactions.
Numerous intelligent features have been developed to streamline this process,
making text entry more effective, efficient, and fluid. These improvements
include sentence prediction and user personalization. However, as deep
learning-based language models become the norm for these advanced features, the
necessity for data collection and model fine-tuning increases. These challenges
can be mitigated by harnessing the in-context learning capability of large
language models such as GPT-3.5. This unique feature allows the language model
to acquire new skills through prompts, eliminating the need for data collection
and fine-tuning. Consequently, large language models can learn various text
prediction techniques. We initially showed that, for a sentence prediction
task, merely prompting GPT-3.5 surpassed a GPT-2 backed system and is
comparable with a fine-tuned GPT-3.5 model, with the latter two methods
requiring costly data collection, fine-tuning and post-processing. However, the
task of prompting large language models to specialize in specific text
prediction tasks can be challenging, particularly for designers without
expertise in prompt engineering. To address this, we introduce Promptor, a
conversational prompt generation agent designed to engage proactively with
designers. Promptor can automatically generate complex prompts tailored to meet
specific needs, thus offering a solution to this challenge. We conducted a user
study involving 24 participants creating prompts for three intelligent text
entry tasks, half of the participants used Promptor while the other half
designed prompts themselves. The results show that Promptor-designed prompts
result in a 35% increase in similarity and 22% in coherence over those by
designers. | [
0.0554076396,
0.0270828102,
-0.0194161814,
0.0002783059,
-0.0340736061,
-0.007035831,
0.0696754009,
-0.013379842,
0.0370709449,
-0.0034895074,
-0.0264201518,
-0.0283918418,
-0.0005549219,
0.0760445073,
0.003039276,
-0.0493536405,
0.0035796678,
-0.0396480113,
0.0275789071,
0.0217117853,
0.04248612,
0.0139197474,
-0.0240938328,
0.0797794908,
-0.0341754779,
-0.0494411662,
-0.0458372012,
0.0141531778,
-0.0262431521,
-0.0395780616,
0.058055304,
0.086509712,
0.0125080161,
0.0530240349,
0.0000020182,
-0.0281267557,
0.0128517225,
-0.0408875681,
-0.0287195034,
-0.0312881283,
0.005209005,
0.0178353656,
-0.0359934904,
0.02551038,
-0.0315936133,
0.0179601256,
0.0534773842,
0.0642154366,
0.0531989634,
0.0350368731,
-0.0211840384,
0.0198290367,
0.0312510021,
-0.0240485687,
0.0349238627,
-0.0270585846,
-0.0372999236,
-0.0391404927,
0.0276012253,
0.0290848501,
0.014481266,
0.0536819175,
0.025473265,
-0.0348202959,
0.0268099755,
0.0544919819,
0.0294784363,
-0.0443175808,
-0.0440215729,
0.0843532383,
-0.0204489436,
0.007283492,
-0.0035248422,
-0.0320905,
0.0299156737,
-0.0018815906,
-0.0348795094,
-0.0091098165,
-0.0281323195,
-0.0173580088,
-0.0218710359,
0.0034760807,
-0.0099060368,
-0.0103542823,
0.0069465903,
0.0269285105,
0.020416731,
-0.0340666026,
-0.0102122836,
0.0113698766,
0.0089163706,
-0.0978794768,
0.0226415452,
0.0082076015,
-0.0836744905,
-0.0028067785,
-0.0394339301,
-0.0433519781,
0.0192524604,
0.007076127,
0.0310951136,
0.0410152562,
-0.0312862471,
0.0250485353,
-0.0082287965,
0.035748899,
-0.0053352243,
-0.0076223318,
-0.0143088214,
0.01377788,
-0.0281284861,
-0.0447251648,
-0.0449127033,
0.0077491296,
-0.0277111996,
-0.0474550463,
-0.0103451163,
0.0727444664,
0.0109787015,
0.0365511663,
0.0120563945,
0.039128758,
-0.0286378898,
-0.010999186,
-0.0450875908,
-0.0207618866,
-0.0410969779,
0.004792036,
0.0428970717,
-0.0592920594,
0.0104752975,
0.0111386804,
0.0346962772,
-0.0123680411,
-0.0169490464,
0.0310132373,
-0.0474703796,
-0.0058223465,
-0.012096487,
-0.0364636667,
-0.0141379042,
-0.0252041966,
-0.0289356299,
-0.0508569591,
-0.017583916,
0.0238969419,
-0.0274951272,
-0.0675364733,
0.0032489598,
0.0660670176,
0.0210949369,
0.0644699782,
-0.0319533311,
-0.0033118681,
0.0780636668,
-0.0103036817,
-0.0028327908,
0.0177660529,
0.0323616676,
0.1051013991,
0.0096331034,
-0.0103167072,
0.0493563563,
0.0541370809,
-0.0313802771,
-0.0283872727,
0.0126522789,
-0.026303824,
0.0191639382,
0.0360809378,
0.0080010388,
0.0497560501,
0.0067363125,
0.0573731735,
0.0998130813,
0.0633652583,
0.0170427058,
0.0410842001,
0.0557488538,
0.0273829196,
-0.0252402518,
-0.0116630914,
-0.075665988,
0.0372593775,
-0.0270263739,
0.0331913419,
0.0155554144,
0.0184595101,
-0.0170121919,
-0.0615870245,
0.0095785819,
-0.0031895349,
0.0068937396,
0.0280426685,
0.0101847751,
0.0098590292,
-0.0783204511,
-0.011342233,
-0.0182551332,
-0.0643864051,
-0.0344611406,
0.0008190794,
0.0503878072,
0.1334559768,
0.0039498322,
-0.0229715388,
-0.0218879208,
-0.0276554935,
0.0452158935,
0.0419016145,
0.0425492488,
-0.000259784,
-0.0128065385,
-0.0340174288,
-0.0276544392,
-0.0145576335,
-0.0150226271,
0.0271360073,
-0.0055363737,
0.0211086534,
0.0205493756,
0.0448270254,
-0.0333582945,
0.0399172865,
-0.0400722064,
-0.0536200479,
0.010801048,
0.0316004194,
-0.0327591784,
0.003361753,
0.0054353517,
0.0120953554,
0.0172063839,
-0.0377349183,
-0.0244386438,
0.0100903735,
-0.0672508702,
-0.0322517268,
0.0134460218,
0.0094458498,
-0.0215077195,
-0.0090205641,
-0.0230938643,
-0.0398481935,
-0.011497519,
-0.0293716937,
0.0235127155,
-0.0477638096,
-0.0140683865,
0.0082851034,
-0.0028327485,
-0.0213708617,
0.0455708876,
0.0249827113,
-0.0152655952,
0.0359339081,
0.0457100794,
0.0180672389,
-0.0491455086,
-0.0294275898,
-0.0046140091,
-0.0129740871,
0.0242677368,
0.0526191369,
0.0464466102,
-0.055665452,
-0.0235881843,
-0.0859983563,
0.0283958241,
-0.0255734287,
-0.0124631124,
0.0031109829,
0.0431964919,
-0.0259754825,
-0.0469380692,
-0.0703487396,
-0.0020836266,
-0.0036888251,
0.0155221289,
0.0594477504,
-0.0140434019,
0.0050741094,
-0.0350259058,
0.0072625806,
-0.0164058283,
0.0292739887,
0.0479254834,
-0.0434791856,
-0.0451604687,
0.0335375257,
0.0009169056,
0.0243140757,
0.0241891257,
-0.0259816926,
0.0364771262,
-0.0133931935,
0.0763799697,
0.0586296953,
0.0317706801,
0.0180201307,
-0.0020518901,
0.0015481593,
-0.0487683229,
0.0351991802,
-0.0104864752,
-0.0164648984,
0.0104321968,
-0.0146812825,
0.0445993021,
0.0655776188,
0.0075774118,
0.0430079922,
-0.0649901778,
0.0312847383,
0.0388854817,
-0.0170880388,
-0.0457057804,
0.0117841354,
-0.0337507948,
0.0650297999,
-0.0272995289,
-0.06118159,
0.0703150779,
-0.0335476659,
-0.0303820446,
0.0067649437,
-0.0264707506,
-0.0094456617,
0.0384921469,
-0.0034651794,
0.0135072609,
0.0382139683,
-0.0404847749,
-0.0311653838,
0.0377917252,
0.025047645,
-0.0108606471,
0.0156094721,
-0.0451852046,
-0.0016377581,
0.0143407229,
-0.0880727842,
-0.0636483878,
-0.0437035598,
-0.0572352856,
-0.0028329641,
0.0105046565,
-0.0272833072,
-0.0048907395,
0.002882319,
0.0030618864,
0.0782921687,
-0.0173594579,
-0.0279164296,
-0.0444334112,
0.0182171818,
0.0601547286,
0.0131244203,
-0.0507677309,
-0.0182414334,
0.0476818606,
0.0171859115,
0.002226657,
0.0025376284,
-0.0421855859,
0.0029463228,
0.0196792092,
-0.0281015597,
-0.0330656283,
0.0559299625,
0.0483364947,
-0.0463331901,
-0.0007330407,
0.1174609289,
0.0241731368,
-0.0586187355,
-0.0207130518,
0.0086428896,
0.0616837293,
0.0257146843,
0.0273196865,
-0.068987757,
-0.0600380749,
0.02875215,
0.0146120479,
-0.0055729304,
-0.0063256114,
-0.0152447736,
-0.0955436677,
0.0081946701,
-0.0407401472,
-0.0067874477,
0.0090361796,
0.0069406517,
-0.0083700912,
0.0285241865,
0.007169405,
0.0018747193,
-0.0110393399,
0.0000983802,
0.0127960229,
-0.0620660558,
-0.0222437046,
-0.0015912956,
-0.0262990687,
0.0358262993,
0.0952535495,
0.0165061988,
0.0061308951,
-0.0376656726,
0.0234543979,
0.0036877308,
0.0323566981,
-0.0046506375,
0.0330829658,
-0.0074692145,
0.0010513475,
-0.042816475,
0.0711532235,
-0.0567819178,
-0.0249263998,
0.0504167862,
0.0416384526,
-0.017527733,
0.0042079687,
-0.0190821178,
-0.0173958316,
0.0440044925,
0.0450146198,
0.0477489531,
-0.0886057764,
-0.0709257871,
-0.078571111,
0.0120929759,
-0.0492216349,
0.0009582067,
-0.0240852218,
0.0129604824,
-0.0206958093,
-0.0622048117,
-0.0387187228,
0.0441675447,
0.0078268712,
0.0279820133,
0.0067044948,
-0.0133761819,
0.0253273007,
-0.027765017,
0.0098581128,
0.01413495,
0.033658728,
-0.0677780658,
0.0189448129,
-0.0102494908,
-0.0627351701,
-0.0245562661,
0.0203445945,
-0.0592371747,
-0.0420910604,
-0.0270378105,
0.0453241654,
0.0132145518,
0.0311229136,
-0.0245130192,
-0.0770572275,
0.0272579305,
0.0410843827,
-0.0333734788,
-0.0456148945,
0.0159069896,
0.0191602446,
-0.0001483405,
0.0172632933,
-0.0385966934,
-0.0077477549,
0.0086560016,
-0.0084709004,
0.0012967208,
-0.0764911175,
0.0304862242,
0.0195984282,
0.0383085534,
-0.0195053425,
0.0074810903,
-0.0435112901,
0.0062105604,
0.0489957258,
-0.0332278088,
-0.0457625203,
0.0367310569,
-0.0250089988,
-0.0156355593,
0.01564968,
-0.0122541683,
-0.010011117,
0.0336033851,
-0.0558191128,
0.0192664694,
0.0027523516,
0.0656735599,
0.0244752169,
0.0038003831,
-0.0109521868,
0.0408042558,
0.0037129996,
0.0496533774,
-0.0176652148,
0.0712906122,
0.0222531743,
-0.0090153599,
0.0021734252,
0.0703187287,
-0.069773145,
-0.0548559837,
-0.0239291899,
0.037488617,
0.0209540334,
0.0145330308,
-0.0192863587,
-0.0325687639,
0.0134308031,
-0.018262567,
0.035359256,
0.0227190517,
-0.0361493118,
-0.0361534245,
0.0006573465,
-0.018171519,
-0.0527522229,
0.0593308359,
-0.0422926284,
0.0062974268,
0.0132091446,
-0.0214923415,
-0.0588697232,
0.0227471013,
0.031317126,
0.035403654,
-0.0119518461,
-0.0156034287,
-0.0159538183,
-0.0222423729,
0.0255152415,
-0.0015419193,
-0.0185861625,
-0.0120469667,
0.0531998053,
0.0706225708,
-0.0238410886,
-0.002823856,
-0.0202396847,
0.03370253,
-0.0370805748,
-0.0315856226,
-0.0706644729,
-5.418851164e-33,
-0.0044457261,
-0.0450981706,
0.0235583652,
0.025941465,
0.0034877143,
-0.0214583073,
-0.0434396677,
0.0040336009,
0.0140646379,
0.0058834273,
-0.0580820814,
-0.0133769168,
0.0047157472,
0.0365076289,
0.0369852893,
-0.0162564702,
0.0819937885,
0.0087737488,
-0.0277774483,
0.0518208109,
0.0094147511,
0.0481791832,
0.0079611186,
-0.0431162752,
0.0432061404,
-0.027586991,
-0.0093845753,
0.008095053,
0.0165234189,
0.0389300622,
-0.0316838957,
0.045929268,
0.0098436102,
-0.0441439375,
-0.0147582721,
0.0944679379,
-0.056620568,
-0.0539956167,
-0.023888791,
0.0021492462,
-0.0261798482,
-0.057994213,
0.0192185454,
-0.0450387038,
-0.0111602535,
0.0297408085,
0.0692483634,
0.0126150064,
-0.0069927648,
-0.0222514682,
-0.0626384169,
-0.0052748532,
-0.0269491412,
-0.0454805605,
0.0324164443,
0.0505694821,
0.0162493698,
-0.0171807781,
-0.0363721326,
0.0345735997,
0.0076659299,
0.0147868926,
0.0567307547,
0.031102635,
-0.0098001678,
0.0545730665,
0.0213433504,
0.0228601564,
-0.018456351,
0.0123825809,
0.0085730795,
0.0416592658,
0.0230973773,
0.0612357333,
0.0273637604,
-0.0175584182,
0.0120824529,
0.06499549,
0.0433857925,
-0.0129360724,
0.0224324018,
-0.0052631847,
-0.0127853341,
-0.0178919565,
-0.0364856683,
-0.0099251429,
-0.0302131511,
-0.0414802767,
0.0391981304,
-0.000887958,
0.0191619545,
-0.0112933181,
0.0108105196,
-0.003950187,
-0.0068086279,
-0.0134158768,
-0.0243992098,
0.0215395,
0.0000160079,
0.0261127166,
-0.0176429544,
-0.0050099487,
-0.0006382694,
0.0219806992,
0.0192119684,
0.0456891768,
0.0200692341,
0.0124566173,
-0.0664881766,
0.0024053724,
-0.0351468176,
0.0243112464,
-0.010598789,
0.0095948474,
0.0148465866,
-0.0101463692,
-0.0512495302,
0.0356631838,
-0.0128077641,
0.0022000819,
-0.0637926236,
-0.0405511335,
-0.0089467717,
-0.0017224152,
-0.0363081954,
-0.0295793377,
-0.0465336181,
0.0391428247,
0.0411214195,
-0.0273011643,
-0.0057531735,
0.008386191,
2.538e-7,
-0.0158777405,
0.0334286205,
0.0042195427,
0.0122497585,
0.0032594965,
0.0575353354,
0.0075115524,
0.034646906,
0.018001046,
-0.0079740891,
0.0063500507,
0.0051733321,
0.0208782423,
-0.0035256755,
-0.1228385046,
-0.024887111,
-0.0583941527,
0.0473136902,
-0.074542433,
0.0371388607,
0.0838964507,
0.0525876023,
-0.0112726744,
-0.0263261199,
0.045424778,
-0.0130470395,
0.0092250397,
-0.0280190036,
0.0360782854,
-0.0059494218,
0.053240303,
-0.0067785392,
-0.0163611397,
0.006560172,
-0.0003947209,
-0.0273054633,
0.0085061379,
0.0240138825,
-0.0008514243,
0.0068002068,
-0.0058172327,
0.0059024375,
-0.0014999845,
-0.0690575987,
0.0485399626,
-0.0131174326,
0.0155053893,
-0.0370719582,
0.0051178639,
-0.0602459759,
0.0136253284,
-0.0191153213,
-0.0004592004,
-0.0047420179,
0.0170241874,
-0.0099009722,
-0.0034722555,
-0.0565648228,
-0.01889522,
-0.0128113898,
-0.0260948129,
-0.0203398895,
-0.1247631758,
0.0161290094,
0.0061247665,
-0.0508614443,
0.0237528533,
2.029526353e-34,
0.005237841,
0.0167528894,
0.0370825827,
0.0462156273,
0.0258540045,
0.0190529041,
0.0524119176,
0.0348326974,
0.0606406517,
-0.0732531324,
-0.0312867537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08099v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08099v2 | ClimateNLP: Analyzing Public Sentiment Towards Climate Change Using Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-12T07:48:50 | 2023-10-19T16:07:41 | Ajay Krishnan, V. S. Anoop | cs.CL | cs.CL | Climate change's impact on human health poses unprecedented and diverse
challenges. Unless proactive measures based on solid evidence are implemented,
these threats will likely escalate and continue to endanger human well-being.
The escalating advancements in information and communication technologies have
facilitated the widespread availability and utilization of social media
platforms. Individuals utilize platforms such as Twitter and Facebook to
express their opinions, thoughts, and critiques on diverse subjects,
encompassing the pressing issue of climate change. The proliferation of climate
change-related content on social media necessitates comprehensive analysis to
glean meaningful insights. This paper employs natural language processing (NLP)
techniques to analyze climate change discourse and quantify the sentiment of
climate change-related tweets. We use ClimateBERT, a pretrained model
fine-tuned specifically for the climate change domain. The objective is to
discern the sentiment individuals express and uncover patterns in public
opinion concerning climate change. Analyzing tweet sentiments allows a deeper
comprehension of public perceptions, concerns, and emotions about this critical
global challenge. The findings from this experiment unearth valuable insights
into public sentiment and the entities associated with climate change
discourse. Policymakers, researchers, and organizations can leverage such
analyses to understand public perceptions, identify influential actors, and
devise informed strategies to address climate change challenges. | [
0.0460011363,
0.105820857,
0.0233670566,
0.0210539903,
-0.0267696586,
0.0173051544,
-0.010040639,
0.0277566127,
0.031319987,
-0.0903203189,
0.0417740121,
0.0222245753,
-0.0314178839,
0.0469563603,
0.0047006323,
-0.047629986,
0.0204918273,
0.0436034873,
0.054667592,
-0.0034060152,
0.0395401381,
0.0078439107,
-0.0027609938,
0.0290922094,
0.0047369092,
0.0072020558,
0.0364933684,
-0.0048073549,
0.0454558283,
-0.0490038916,
0.0391579904,
0.049348779,
0.0144927669,
0.0398504175,
0.0000017478,
-0.0267545655,
-0.0394697972,
-0.0220471472,
0.0444677286,
-0.0092360098,
0.1110432297,
-0.0396061577,
0.0004391611,
0.0237050653,
-0.0702163503,
0.0220013056,
0.0602930002,
0.0475100689,
0.0630334243,
0.052128654,
-0.0183769334,
-0.0295054559,
-0.0304140616,
0.0253052823,
-0.0480394214,
0.0435034782,
0.0518553182,
-0.0639236793,
-0.0380844399,
-0.0066196779,
0.0208133012,
0.034618102,
-0.0388795845,
0.0147217009,
0.0027181939,
0.009898521,
-0.0362300538,
-0.0266799182,
-0.0282929651,
0.0484608039,
0.0177554842,
-0.008431593,
0.0135044158,
-0.0282695275,
-0.0097731585,
0.0011958738,
-0.0304817185,
0.0079718726,
0.0046307445,
0.039603021,
-0.0041851131,
0.0364993922,
-0.0179626457,
0.0568622276,
-0.0091569452,
0.061322704,
-0.0431150906,
-0.0651371405,
0.0013345284,
0.037312001,
0.0182365011,
-0.0285376552,
0.0143846283,
-0.036915876,
0.0032968528,
0.0344860479,
0.0055420059,
-0.0281532519,
0.024390392,
-0.1032279953,
-0.0110311415,
-0.0154013559,
0.0160800293,
0.0314051844,
0.0743705705,
-0.0162033867,
0.0149272075,
-0.0028238951,
0.0289901532,
0.0060649449,
-0.0652947724,
-0.0167281833,
-0.0019598552,
-0.0006681228,
-0.0280845854,
0.0237468798,
-0.023880288,
-0.0520107187,
-0.025200747,
-0.0238042958,
-0.0159587525,
0.0347947255,
0.036199566,
0.0040545291,
-0.0220448151,
0.0820354521,
-0.033995647,
0.0231634006,
-0.0201233588,
-0.0061948751,
0.0203550067,
-0.0044694594,
0.0475428626,
0.0045358534,
-0.0083525712,
0.0489133932,
0.048007872,
-0.031913612,
-0.0044653597,
-0.0395753197,
-0.0051566623,
-0.0078802649,
-0.0174032021,
-0.0537870899,
-0.0068491786,
0.0008468858,
0.0000394976,
-0.0245480239,
0.0025678941,
0.0040619788,
-0.0454667471,
0.052594915,
-0.0563446768,
-0.0361438543,
0.0348774232,
0.0059251259,
0.0344344303,
0.0540094003,
0.0455843695,
0.0297855716,
0.0522495583,
-0.0187520981,
-0.0041447235,
0.0006116611,
-0.0000665393,
-0.0125988126,
-0.0094830692,
-0.0104102856,
-0.0809880719,
-0.0070865019,
-0.0306828469,
0.0269737523,
0.0117691979,
0.0009438974,
0.0353928171,
0.0716860816,
-0.0461483523,
0.0015198196,
-0.007560173,
0.0822463259,
-0.0185399801,
-0.0258571468,
-0.0075443229,
-0.0044861059,
-0.0452956185,
-0.0433022045,
0.0147975944,
0.0238918904,
0.0086339125,
-0.0412060246,
-0.032501597,
0.0161316916,
0.055927068,
-0.0543839708,
-0.0030723799,
-0.0296468474,
-0.056420777,
-0.0037744874,
0.0207726713,
-0.0678180531,
-0.0088505354,
0.0049171038,
-0.0209063906,
0.0572743677,
-0.0149112735,
0.0209747571,
-0.0120662944,
-0.0577892996,
0.0081382738,
0.0295565855,
0.0370646045,
0.0277592242,
-0.0440796167,
-0.0052248174,
-0.040788576,
0.015256173,
0.0099794976,
-0.0037964566,
0.0111425305,
0.0339607783,
-0.0165147185,
0.024843758,
0.0029820083,
0.0283141565,
0.015309982,
-0.0281443372,
-0.0428976156,
0.0083053354,
0.0463342555,
0.0503263846,
0.0017654317,
-0.0031075492,
0.041846022,
-0.0105809206,
-0.1006161273,
0.0595460497,
0.0134334201,
0.0456700772,
0.0239258315,
-0.0435638539,
-0.0419668667,
0.0329763852,
-0.0325082354,
0.005180432,
0.0684782267,
-0.0046106507,
0.0098525183,
-0.011520505,
-0.0521981567,
-0.0341570936,
0.0200648028,
-0.0214406047,
0.0578490868,
-0.0077023376,
-0.008535482,
-0.0373063087,
-0.0598256961,
0.0051196585,
0.0018623337,
-0.0068010767,
-0.0187262595,
-0.0174623542,
0.007452073,
0.046604868,
-0.0186604876,
-0.0594935976,
0.0151371593,
-0.0689488277,
0.0051526437,
-0.0135807116,
0.0275243726,
0.000154575,
0.0004553429,
-0.021468617,
0.0382399857,
0.0277442373,
-0.0243738145,
-0.0023655645,
0.0253315382,
0.0479299724,
-0.0248201936,
0.0294115562,
-0.0490870327,
0.0082233259,
-0.050500229,
0.0248160847,
0.0480465144,
-0.0779140145,
-0.0004059754,
0.021715641,
-0.0235904027,
0.0014911424,
0.0073550162,
-0.031675607,
0.005360302,
0.0027757643,
-0.0271812249,
-0.0014936012,
0.066533342,
0.0565754361,
-0.0216037687,
0.0246375035,
-0.0303986687,
0.0124410009,
-0.0315073021,
0.0115005989,
0.001302097,
0.0117663024,
0.0436471291,
0.0719530433,
-0.0178118851,
-0.0010994424,
0.0163163133,
0.073877126,
-0.056121394,
-0.0231625307,
-0.0146514587,
-0.019949045,
0.0001696186,
0.0279840082,
0.0004308323,
-0.0389766023,
0.0459201448,
0.0284937602,
0.0217841566,
-0.11761076,
-0.0416627079,
0.0031713811,
0.0373850241,
0.0142697021,
0.0137578538,
0.04915943,
0.0020151825,
0.0521091148,
-0.069678247,
-0.0310072359,
0.0059466525,
-0.0088822506,
-0.0271551087,
0.0215719379,
-0.0046149255,
-0.027807666,
0.0035130701,
-0.0581469685,
-0.0999433547,
0.0058237463,
0.0217900965,
-0.0666846782,
-0.0325027443,
-0.0009037091,
0.0119596859,
-0.0321983173,
0.0244568475,
-0.0355223939,
0.0166393686,
0.0033434827,
0.0076437411,
0.0394493937,
0.0266928282,
0.0300735701,
-0.0139087439,
0.0468303077,
0.0048267194,
0.0040704454,
-0.0519567169,
-0.0035328723,
-0.0078447834,
-0.0207990222,
0.0114551326,
-0.0330286361,
0.0606785566,
-0.0312392768,
0.0449243225,
0.0851696134,
0.0253867116,
0.0136077404,
0.0080809593,
0.0154217808,
0.001713363,
0.0087643545,
0.0073020626,
-0.0770318657,
-0.0267756768,
-0.0149264308,
-0.0249475595,
-0.0298652388,
-0.0399028137,
-0.0186939817,
-0.054061681,
0.0452040061,
-0.022085527,
0.0113798827,
0.0167014431,
-0.0865977407,
-0.007711574,
-0.0233245473,
-0.0192592666,
-0.0802334249,
-0.021094406,
0.0139993522,
0.0140189771,
-0.0759427696,
-0.0335741937,
0.0200681649,
-0.0082150372,
0.0109907836,
0.0594511814,
0.0788662508,
-0.0192466788,
-0.0095692566,
0.0322717875,
0.0020174005,
0.001632379,
-0.0347475335,
0.0126787247,
0.0009405172,
-0.0097607514,
-0.0378489755,
0.0141285369,
-0.052796714,
0.0008777817,
-0.0160552915,
0.0563691333,
-0.0101724146,
-0.0300986022,
-0.0268406682,
0.0663247406,
0.0380696431,
0.0349773727,
0.0037594484,
-0.0098381843,
-0.051089678,
-0.068886131,
0.0423695669,
-0.0564586967,
-0.056684535,
-0.0415866449,
-0.0138956588,
-0.0128636463,
-0.0241608582,
-0.0325553305,
0.0352345407,
-0.0185514651,
-0.0288205817,
-0.009163864,
0.1071613654,
0.0049778903,
-0.0607668981,
0.0572814047,
0.0021294644,
0.044293128,
-0.0002253408,
-0.082487464,
0.0352136418,
0.0807713494,
-0.0224110112,
0.0348719805,
-0.0296020471,
-0.0716405362,
0.0008572744,
-0.0129163815,
0.0207062792,
-0.0291135013,
0.0145578003,
-0.0344468392,
0.0261905324,
0.1031723395,
-0.0243261606,
-0.0159630273,
0.0326171257,
0.0656788945,
0.0230975188,
-0.00233156,
0.0434682369,
0.0143912258,
-0.0190361142,
0.0070243082,
-0.0618492849,
0.0092526125,
-0.0083758486,
-0.0108726267,
0.0643349066,
0.0196164772,
-0.0438770875,
-0.0444143787,
-0.0538734309,
0.0121206213,
-0.0083376765,
-0.0397260077,
-0.0098212603,
-0.0023718588,
0.0257679,
-0.0754185542,
0.0373685956,
-0.0691794455,
0.0089817019,
-0.049238313,
0.106454812,
0.030718632,
0.0358581394,
-0.0118458085,
-0.0202115718,
0.0220163893,
-0.0350500308,
-0.0047216932,
-0.0213447995,
0.0244414881,
-0.0302396063,
-0.0193090979,
0.0266317241,
-0.0252163224,
0.0245169979,
-0.032310158,
-0.035687875,
-0.016693458,
0.0439741947,
0.0029572658,
0.0087691629,
0.0336933918,
-0.0075639673,
-0.0105340295,
0.0099744657,
0.0259036738,
-0.0369431041,
-0.0173463412,
0.0406062901,
-0.0069517666,
-0.0779252127,
-0.006162975,
0.0056652422,
-0.0141547276,
0.038925726,
0.0543713383,
-0.0247162245,
-0.035903085,
-0.0279901922,
-0.0148266433,
-0.0076156505,
0.0238887556,
0.0483074002,
-0.0382692814,
-0.007109873,
0.0925701633,
-0.0377353393,
0.0142357964,
0.0078185489,
-0.0023778498,
0.032000564,
-0.0283106938,
-0.0044812267,
-0.0212410167,
-0.0085943602,
-0.029932024,
-0.0542776175,
-0.0070226691,
-6.160657527e-33,
0.0039303931,
-0.0618081912,
-0.0066828188,
0.0263777245,
-0.0063953237,
0.0188451037,
-0.0009263841,
0.0428250805,
-0.0056766481,
0.0396292433,
0.0001799109,
0.0065905186,
0.0298772641,
-0.0104639847,
0.0267386287,
0.0054839049,
0.0379447378,
-0.0290070958,
0.0027588475,
-0.0092052203,
0.0581544414,
0.0404987074,
0.0668343753,
-0.134338215,
0.0368332155,
0.0140435817,
-0.0317599699,
-0.0363739952,
0.0337002948,
0.0077720657,
-0.0344504081,
0.0674294755,
0.0402247943,
-0.0353490524,
-0.0189130828,
0.1058931574,
-0.037564531,
-0.0429992303,
-0.004395789,
-0.0250862017,
-0.0054392321,
0.0134296399,
0.0244964045,
0.0180996433,
-0.0382937081,
0.0531288125,
0.0402092747,
0.0095541822,
0.0346442759,
-0.0183868166,
-0.0597422644,
0.0450971574,
-0.0337681063,
0.0517313816,
-0.0193518959,
0.0194193423,
-0.0022783759,
0.0657199845,
-0.0834698603,
0.0153799914,
0.0204472989,
-0.0000051966,
-0.0052699558,
-0.045534946,
0.0013628533,
0.0925436914,
-0.0036657136,
0.0139328856,
-0.0476491563,
0.0002907164,
0.0068905354,
0.0014930774,
0.016678229,
0.079801105,
0.0541569553,
-0.0533879399,
-0.049682349,
0.0151497805,
0.050468307,
0.0194301419,
0.0184248686,
-0.0085244682,
0.0263484158,
-0.0135366116,
-0.017624747,
-0.0215056278,
-0.0193290021,
0.0109802401,
-0.0262225419,
0.0138081927,
-0.030346239,
0.0212335065,
0.0078831138,
-0.0422779955,
-0.0361335054,
0.0367757268,
0.0121403886,
0.0135539519,
0.0290060937,
0.0298081227,
-0.0613289848,
-0.0053419974,
-0.0414213166,
0.0367441252,
0.0267269779,
-0.0424716137,
0.0240110829,
0.0063715535,
-0.0389171727,
-0.0006535542,
0.0082314909,
0.0346266851,
-0.0174432304,
0.0026857017,
-0.0086443527,
0.026892582,
0.018152643,
0.018076038,
0.0170580428,
0.021038061,
0.0357406661,
0.0327801183,
-0.0499250926,
0.0086144386,
-0.0179800726,
-0.0278328247,
-0.02476383,
-0.0022193908,
-0.0293280743,
-0.0524126999,
0.0054620085,
-0.0375858694,
2.43e-7,
0.0702192336,
0.073915571,
-0.0169156957,
-0.040507067,
0.0173840821,
0.0424838103,
0.0295169037,
0.0347534008,
-0.0267416853,
-0.0133884558,
-0.0506591611,
-0.0124303773,
0.0062170252,
0.0116792424,
-0.0620483682,
-0.0318885036,
-0.0255045779,
0.0052290601,
-0.0603246726,
0.0214922596,
0.0406975001,
0.0666417629,
0.0267857797,
-0.001409064,
-0.0312644355,
0.0117280679,
0.0564963222,
-0.0709804296,
-0.0048907152,
-0.0105221989,
0.0052533452,
-0.0118508916,
0.0116837658,
-0.0085265609,
-0.0442377478,
-0.0094840787,
-0.0225192346,
0.0344164148,
0.0327240452,
-0.0524768792,
0.0324835889,
-0.0135063464,
-0.0070243087,
0.0081654433,
0.010336427,
-0.0765093118,
-0.0583740845,
-0.0624630824,
-0.0169199333,
-0.0033374419,
0.0295211617,
-0.0297863632,
-0.0347253941,
0.0057082307,
-0.0011447356,
-0.0214675404,
-0.0246793386,
-0.0532705113,
0.0224431716,
-0.0451255105,
-0.013706563,
0.016937932,
-0.0009057868,
-0.0012977559,
0.0507460497,
0.0292063039,
0.0350890011,
1.661931477e-34,
0.0381376818,
-0.0032162748,
-0.023259487,
-0.0286602527,
0.0531943329,
0.035304904,
-0.0165780373,
0.0283490457,
0.0048458977,
-0.0460355803,
0.0205468405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08085v1 | Low-Resource Clickbait Spoiling for Indonesian via Question Answering | 2023-10-12T07:17:17 | 2023-10-12T07:17:17 | Ni Putu Intan Maharani, Ayu Purwarianti, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clickbait spoiling aims to generate a short text to satisfy the curiosity
induced by a clickbait post. As it is a newly introduced task, the dataset is
only available in English so far. Our contributions include the construction of
manually labeled clickbait spoiling corpus in Indonesian and an evaluation on
using cross-lingual zero-shot question answering-based models to tackle
clikcbait spoiling for low-resource language like Indonesian. We utilize
selection of multilingual language models. The experimental results suggest
that XLM-RoBERTa (large) model outperforms other models for phrase and passage
spoilers, meanwhile, mDeBERTa (base) model outperforms other models for
multipart spoilers. | [
0.0686536431,
-0.0322404578,
-0.0265273638,
0.0422722548,
-0.0313227959,
0.0135825407,
-0.0101098856,
0.0503594279,
0.024610674,
0.0169183873,
-0.0259763207,
-0.0531542748,
0.0035421869,
-0.0042673005,
0.0234354958,
-0.0984631479,
0.0505121127,
-0.037652459,
0.0292005502,
-0.0069191311,
0.0258997642,
0.0240288936,
0.0662306398,
0.0119122118,
0.0219323393,
-0.02311478,
-0.0133443242,
-0.0088760285,
-0.006005283,
-0.013880156,
0.0501392223,
0.0561953895,
0.0105282469,
0.0289736632,
0.000001503,
-0.0259450246,
0.0088494625,
0.0132456459,
-0.0225517135,
0.0558727384,
0.0232569408,
-0.0293968376,
0.0140906563,
0.0025131069,
-0.0289206058,
0.0003989932,
0.0283424836,
0.0704159588,
0.0668337196,
0.0606279671,
0.0057395352,
-0.0057482272,
0.0188961141,
-0.0364300981,
0.1043624431,
-0.0293349437,
0.0274459254,
-0.0061025065,
0.0388868786,
0.0562764369,
-0.0284600705,
0.0456383117,
0.0068508293,
-0.0102559933,
-0.049738843,
-0.0066569373,
-0.0100636203,
-0.013213696,
0.0155101139,
0.039475441,
-0.0393725894,
-0.0522845685,
-0.0140180681,
0.021772638,
0.0255543273,
0.0241877846,
-0.088437371,
0.0308957044,
0.0263325889,
-0.004694541,
0.0425106622,
-0.0180730857,
-0.0058521484,
0.0394656546,
0.0645226911,
0.0029949062,
0.0176931508,
-0.0271365456,
-0.024461804,
-0.0131170461,
-0.0113422107,
-0.0733036846,
-0.0002200051,
0.0384703614,
0.0063200099,
0.0162108578,
-0.0568016917,
-0.0294116884,
0.04920315,
-0.0619556829,
-0.061241921,
0.0041257017,
-0.0147294709,
0.0529039539,
-0.0426341891,
0.0060150647,
-0.0216110479,
0.0041466085,
-0.0270621981,
-0.0211475976,
0.0394689962,
-0.0550624765,
-0.0569045097,
0.0477651469,
-0.0324455053,
-0.0058517759,
-0.0326441452,
0.0337314829,
0.0339502469,
-0.0106806392,
0.0146822399,
0.0303377174,
-0.0409924947,
0.0084430119,
-0.0127272783,
0.0118738692,
-0.0521361679,
0.0031882816,
0.0299721733,
-0.0653264448,
-0.0405781157,
0.0199624393,
-0.0082366085,
-0.0381807275,
0.0378362052,
-0.0042917542,
-0.0026967491,
-0.0267755389,
-0.0793669671,
-0.0448151119,
-0.0438837893,
-0.0590987504,
-0.0344318599,
-0.0626439676,
0.0378262773,
0.0119374152,
-0.018145835,
0.0041279416,
0.0063904957,
0.071729593,
-0.0338090882,
0.056501884,
-0.0050312225,
-0.0235265251,
0.0050576935,
0.0541339256,
0.0381897464,
0.0789735764,
-0.022889683,
0.0724902973,
0.0795069411,
-0.0010752516,
0.0013941613,
0.0297838692,
0.0265464596,
0.015449333,
0.0189777501,
0.0383198075,
-0.0003824441,
-0.0198357813,
0.0060229329,
0.0203067828,
0.0032427399,
0.0081907623,
0.0317230523,
0.0102087101,
-0.0512793846,
0.0310002603,
0.0574097782,
0.011879785,
-0.0088694077,
0.0479836948,
-0.0070128944,
0.0383347683,
-0.0283131432,
0.0216326285,
0.0437779427,
0.0175874662,
-0.0534641966,
-0.0292485766,
0.0319477767,
-0.0229566079,
-0.0239445344,
0.0070751016,
0.0497672893,
0.0454475954,
-0.0690433234,
0.0405026376,
0.0432317145,
0.0046863509,
0.0513849184,
-0.0343650579,
0.0382562913,
0.0121166054,
0.0407049656,
-0.0118982056,
-0.0209868308,
-0.0223294813,
0.0229428243,
0.0299695842,
-0.0216461886,
-0.0213000495,
-0.0200258549,
-0.00669161,
-0.0019210945,
-0.0373477861,
0.0358904041,
0.0329073593,
0.0114402603,
0.0269597471,
0.0402423777,
-0.0540441945,
0.0000185937,
0.0063764579,
-0.0066211773,
-0.0167309958,
0.0007552374,
0.0007578786,
0.0246570762,
0.0181112736,
0.0118389521,
-0.0145641407,
0.0427447408,
-0.0106334109,
-0.0049715219,
-0.0199135114,
0.0331358202,
-0.0821333602,
-0.0048668515,
-0.0692132413,
0.0040599857,
0.0601735972,
0.0072587905,
-0.0384291336,
0.0197929218,
-0.0121106515,
0.0289406236,
-0.0564828329,
0.0061808862,
-0.0286131036,
0.0187183935,
-0.0191545915,
0.039060045,
-0.0057989266,
0.0645064935,
0.042740915,
-0.0303309876,
0.0392226875,
-0.0334530696,
-0.0514284633,
0.0134674292,
-0.0213055369,
-0.0105469674,
-0.0005356082,
-0.010567816,
0.0003225806,
-0.0141093228,
-0.0691199005,
-0.0101653188,
-0.0169576574,
0.0268421993,
0.045141533,
0.0467975773,
-0.0294649508,
-0.0219232943,
-0.047027804,
-0.0470055304,
0.0454589762,
0.0267888047,
-0.0179883149,
0.0227790754,
0.0489568375,
-0.0142030837,
-0.0044634212,
0.0223062951,
0.0452684388,
0.0206984337,
-0.0618214495,
-0.0176235344,
0.0119077945,
-0.0008509471,
-0.0265916288,
-0.0274383221,
-0.0444366187,
-0.0353245884,
0.0071073202,
-0.0235586185,
0.0195245184,
0.0226977114,
-0.0225490835,
0.0210635327,
0.0091338027,
-0.040016558,
-0.0216943827,
-0.0363009013,
-0.0377375521,
-0.0107314782,
-0.0472426377,
0.0319668762,
0.0272149183,
0.0272730496,
0.0166450515,
-0.0230395738,
0.0310360212,
-0.0311573725,
-0.0046873083,
-0.0179228131,
-0.0283501428,
-0.0088759921,
0.0435287729,
-0.0084139947,
-0.0231377929,
0.0684547424,
-0.0197815038,
-0.0142324399,
-0.003856183,
0.0198213477,
-0.0591946878,
0.0054210494,
-0.0337872282,
0.0269067623,
0.028188521,
-0.0349668302,
-0.0272971764,
-0.003036997,
0.0230954774,
-0.0097395815,
-0.0000885439,
0.0318084322,
-0.0105102425,
-0.0123066539,
-0.0300218109,
-0.0464349873,
-0.1003094167,
-0.0219308566,
-0.0067351013,
0.0288295485,
0.0263048057,
-0.0016717415,
0.0501319915,
0.0214556661,
-0.0624004379,
-0.0534864552,
-0.0039781234,
0.027379781,
0.107365571,
0.0908432603,
-0.0436358415,
0.0040779663,
-0.0282649472,
0.0281368475,
0.0460718423,
-0.0065046633,
0.0116140926,
0.0651250109,
0.0073401816,
0.0482192263,
-0.0342000164,
-0.0467473269,
-0.0505371429,
-0.0015804964,
-0.0509494059,
-0.0116673848,
0.0712650269,
0.0371047035,
-0.0429836176,
-0.0182465892,
-0.0249725934,
0.0308630392,
-0.0155887827,
0.0499499217,
-0.0660240427,
-0.0174548663,
-0.0268281028,
0.0213418119,
-0.018548565,
-0.0173806064,
-0.0218348801,
-0.1375307292,
0.002017227,
0.0042948616,
-0.0740017444,
-0.0239803307,
-0.0632328987,
-0.015516269,
0.0049306233,
-0.0203294717,
0.0095344689,
-0.0040716124,
0.0193745662,
-0.0091252252,
0.0159961432,
-0.0389293544,
0.017777944,
-0.0177757144,
0.0088646961,
0.0336282179,
0.0079652658,
-0.0332641155,
0.0302581061,
0.0069568469,
-0.0990166441,
-0.0210761279,
-0.034263365,
0.0395465046,
-0.0183187053,
-0.0122544765,
-0.0490746684,
0.0445967019,
0.0344142765,
0.0163710136,
0.0235068016,
0.0689169914,
0.0270931851,
-0.046820648,
-0.0263022315,
0.0113915699,
0.0061553665,
0.0892251953,
0.0254580136,
-0.054859437,
-0.0146761006,
-0.0154623473,
-0.0345986411,
-0.0674945191,
-0.0124030504,
-0.0320564546,
-0.0416825488,
-0.0085935155,
-0.0604121052,
-0.0633544996,
0.0262275077,
0.0168685727,
-0.0045844563,
0.0274764337,
-0.0510936454,
0.0037825117,
-0.0329778977,
-0.031189166,
-0.028219264,
-0.0152231911,
-0.0382030718,
0.0117502715,
0.0373754017,
-0.0362907536,
-0.006374713,
-0.0421876125,
-0.0829618946,
-0.0322536975,
-0.024796728,
0.0582764633,
0.0246051587,
0.0332286395,
-0.0190884154,
-0.0590982474,
0.0381901972,
0.0515356809,
-0.0134015912,
0.0092676301,
-0.0096385581,
0.0152415764,
0.0149819804,
0.0373326838,
-0.0468117222,
0.0021372235,
0.036012996,
-0.0096029053,
-0.0617114902,
0.0068264566,
0.0242054891,
0.0336737856,
-0.0181003846,
-0.0459258892,
0.0049610767,
-0.0274797063,
-0.0094770547,
-0.0026016196,
-0.0257164631,
-0.0285628103,
0.0357389897,
0.0427081734,
-0.0289486833,
-0.0074386825,
0.0330965705,
-0.0571645685,
-0.0226177275,
-0.0538978055,
0.008140495,
0.0451871566,
-0.0028444787,
-0.0055215242,
0.0371182002,
-0.0028278488,
-0.0114282202,
0.0223874971,
0.0250481907,
-0.0037834418,
0.0485741757,
-0.0005698462,
-0.0422386192,
0.0458925366,
0.0435814112,
-0.0189249478,
0.0490110032,
-0.0345870405,
0.0403558686,
0.0328870267,
-0.0648822859,
0.0237180255,
-0.0046165437,
-0.0303200521,
-0.0089115286,
0.0058443425,
-0.0146645624,
-0.0328951515,
0.0545104444,
0.0212226436,
-0.019584408,
0.0446493961,
0.1018642932,
0.0046070246,
-0.0071297786,
0.0849146172,
-0.0300042294,
0.011264124,
0.0131430477,
0.0153280683,
0.0528961942,
-0.0066311252,
-0.0048805084,
-0.0576940849,
-0.0589106642,
-0.0195225328,
-0.0087497467,
0.00396048,
0.0287964363,
-0.0044557061,
0.0456586108,
0.0569126159,
0.025406858,
-0.0708153918,
0.027609434,
-0.0334919281,
-0.0301830899,
0.0029035076,
-5.480279192e-33,
-0.0162610561,
-0.0247059539,
-0.0428568348,
0.050376378,
-0.0226289704,
0.012118537,
-0.0168111958,
0.0228676125,
-0.036219269,
-0.0050253873,
-0.0231130738,
0.0197407007,
0.0071994066,
0.0231052898,
-0.0058155209,
-0.0369134881,
-0.0035480931,
0.0148293544,
-0.0355076492,
0.0378886499,
0.0243123937,
0.036944598,
0.0217205063,
0.0491214395,
0.0839082524,
-0.0774298236,
-0.0398946442,
0.0092125461,
0.0511632562,
0.0656283721,
-0.0043530804,
0.0638730377,
0.0442156158,
-0.0286717769,
-0.0143874818,
0.0529334955,
-0.0762212723,
-0.0369556062,
0.0776019469,
0.012647463,
0.0038395957,
-0.0183777511,
0.0328260809,
-0.0347542726,
0.0348390341,
0.0199121162,
0.041456487,
-0.0308252294,
-0.0137057435,
0.0041972501,
-0.011399542,
0.0173987485,
-0.0121454149,
-0.0392911993,
0.0332959592,
0.1102531776,
0.0079702986,
0.0440134741,
-0.0479754321,
0.0403090492,
0.0127410823,
0.0444269031,
0.0333024934,
0.0000035557,
0.0091584716,
0.0175327733,
0.0301978216,
0.0087618772,
-0.0151153477,
0.0439272188,
-0.0049744886,
0.0110176681,
0.0724653751,
0.0568939708,
0.0490116403,
-0.0385549366,
-0.0614816099,
0.0364319794,
-0.0014724522,
0.0217752047,
0.0089147938,
-0.049529057,
-0.029176807,
-0.0360064134,
-0.018034013,
-0.017402688,
-0.0450002663,
-0.0451419763,
0.0242425855,
-0.0021570129,
-0.0529442579,
-0.003835744,
0.0124240154,
-0.0668523088,
0.0375677347,
0.0093457708,
0.0036951825,
0.0278756674,
0.021628242,
0.0513835624,
-0.0019957747,
0.0577322468,
-0.0118848234,
-0.012304916,
-0.0289971884,
0.0032304712,
0.0376971364,
0.0013290317,
-0.063483946,
0.0112920096,
-0.0160416439,
0.0086402213,
-0.0163956359,
-0.0025280674,
0.0201157089,
0.0036604325,
-0.0150161618,
0.0003505816,
0.0523541793,
0.0334207416,
-0.0022014359,
-0.0034712416,
-0.0171104241,
0.0196859706,
-0.0217774529,
0.0191137977,
0.0076916507,
0.0427488387,
-0.0455558449,
-0.0733202994,
-0.0007661555,
0.0133963572,
2.215e-7,
0.0179604217,
0.0094679315,
0.0158608537,
0.0118759219,
0.0078616664,
0.0297345649,
0.0082536573,
0.0069636111,
0.0199489295,
0.0154045643,
0.0038693175,
-0.0264041703,
0.0262741707,
0.0079028765,
-0.1244463995,
0.0426750928,
-0.0558344498,
-0.0350092836,
-0.0314107388,
-0.0358137898,
-0.0039886879,
0.0455221497,
0.0083271395,
-0.0197784491,
-0.0190276131,
-0.0408952571,
0.059634693,
0.0144582745,
-0.0746494606,
0.0326769203,
0.065194726,
0.0466233343,
0.0194676593,
-0.0162526723,
-0.0210154373,
-0.0017673364,
0.0491938703,
0.0268630218,
0.0407351926,
-0.0355077423,
0.0126717128,
-0.0312068593,
-0.0314453803,
-0.1069286168,
0.1163085476,
-0.0016125155,
-0.0330793858,
-0.0127059044,
-0.0342956819,
-0.0186616033,
0.0253765583,
-0.0566458479,
-0.0388792418,
0.0063129901,
0.017243119,
-0.0069426154,
-0.005785217,
-0.0189988222,
-0.0158699807,
0.036387302,
-0.0453347601,
-0.0075282729,
-0.0275201425,
-0.0256787296,
-0.0036366666,
-0.0325702056,
0.0211131033,
1.752299097e-34,
0.0571634322,
-0.0309710596,
-0.0091048619,
-0.009368619,
-0.0467921719,
0.0127064586,
0.0514808595,
-0.0109271808,
0.0453101397,
-0.050197456,
-0.0169063471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08078v1 | To token or not to token: A Comparative Study of Text Representations for Cross-Lingual Transfer | 2023-10-12T06:59:10 | 2023-10-12T06:59:10 | Md Mushfiqur Rahman, Fardin Ahsan Sakib, Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Choosing an appropriate tokenization scheme is often a bottleneck in
low-resource cross-lingual transfer. To understand the downstream implications
of text representation choices, we perform a comparative analysis on language
models having diverse text representation modalities including 2
segmentation-based models (\texttt{BERT}, \texttt{mBERT}), 1 image-based model
(\texttt{PIXEL}), and 1 character-level model (\texttt{CANINE}). First, we
propose a scoring Language Quotient (LQ) metric capable of providing a weighted
representation of both zero-shot and few-shot evaluation combined. Utilizing
this metric, we perform experiments comprising 19 source languages and 133
target languages on three tasks (POS tagging, Dependency parsing, and NER). Our
analysis reveals that image-based models excel in cross-lingual transfer when
languages are closely related and share visually similar scripts. However, for
tasks biased toward word meaning (POS, NER), segmentation-based models prove to
be superior. Furthermore, in dependency parsing tasks where word relationships
play a crucial role, models with their character-level focus, outperform
others. Finally, we propose a recommendation scheme based on our findings to
guide model selection according to task and language requirements. | [
-0.0131415334,
0.0315882005,
-0.0080040302,
0.03920573,
-0.0643555745,
0.0133639472,
0.0290567186,
0.0297168326,
-0.0419240035,
-0.0361692607,
-0.0444428734,
-0.0262869913,
0.016764719,
0.0145430202,
0.041501224,
-0.100677371,
0.0347072333,
-0.0346608907,
0.0153581789,
0.0166907087,
0.0291553698,
-0.0029064433,
0.0089547904,
0.0387844294,
-0.0624134503,
-0.0034229639,
0.028956607,
0.0270615481,
0.0322130397,
-0.012412766,
-0.0484867655,
0.0236201715,
0.0110602407,
0.010054321,
0.0000016661,
-0.0436140262,
-0.0356091633,
0.0077315755,
0.0335370786,
-0.0069864984,
0.0862847269,
-0.0872881711,
-0.0215661731,
-0.0189348925,
0.0178332925,
-0.0172202196,
0.0873915255,
0.0627837554,
0.0149753625,
0.0774453804,
-0.0482763834,
-0.0314611979,
0.0210201871,
-0.0165068861,
0.0174831692,
-0.0452999249,
0.0095998459,
0.0371424779,
-0.0023200712,
-0.0123989768,
-0.0506486855,
0.0261301473,
-0.031264592,
-0.0167485196,
0.0199668221,
0.0424250886,
-0.0487223305,
0.0131061776,
-0.0016030929,
0.0553844273,
-0.061367318,
-0.0171598792,
-0.0172466878,
0.0140135437,
-0.0219000969,
-0.0152449161,
-0.0719352216,
0.0226512421,
0.0082215508,
0.0543311089,
0.0176391229,
0.0096908296,
0.0081120683,
-0.0083585745,
-0.0468820296,
0.0351455696,
0.0500274599,
-0.0194793027,
-0.0036612297,
0.0454364456,
-0.0303912871,
-0.0385976918,
0.0536415316,
-0.0177296288,
0.0391690582,
0.0151774473,
-0.0562306643,
-0.0369708017,
-0.0135327568,
-0.0008088647,
0.0127654271,
0.043546848,
-0.0632045567,
0.0569198057,
-0.0756295249,
0.0601804256,
0.009819679,
0.035781838,
-0.0386004224,
-0.0447933003,
-0.0857525319,
0.0116495686,
-0.059180934,
0.0409472287,
-0.0228993632,
-0.0248147715,
-0.0046549058,
0.0036034191,
-0.0007209291,
-0.0262702741,
0.0312466528,
-0.0295259561,
-0.025360357,
0.0111493533,
-0.0045611029,
0.075106144,
-0.0222301856,
-0.0002300612,
-0.0044180229,
-0.0381786115,
-0.0072581228,
0.0463741161,
0.0187961776,
-0.0664422214,
-0.0097951684,
0.0697740316,
-0.0535063483,
-0.0516104922,
-0.0065482962,
0.0387921371,
-0.040240705,
-0.0422621593,
-0.0135368984,
-0.0682032779,
0.0232100561,
0.0164319817,
0.0362827182,
-0.0015131945,
-0.0343166888,
0.0076529128,
-0.0318637416,
0.0782607645,
0.033096686,
0.0052733649,
0.0083809569,
-0.019222606,
-0.027406577,
0.0715209842,
0.0238030292,
0.0300890766,
0.0272455625,
-0.0094848163,
-0.0467907377,
0.0498039909,
-0.0274619348,
0.0133222016,
-0.0664339811,
-0.0234557763,
0.0313376412,
0.0026111559,
0.0744282231,
0.0813366622,
-0.0464204289,
0.0174715109,
0.0553629361,
0.0718650892,
0.0123016508,
-0.0048221177,
0.0533426665,
-0.0117337918,
-0.0141036967,
0.0099026738,
-0.019541258,
0.0152134728,
0.0310718156,
0.0133600803,
-0.0092274593,
0.0357237048,
-0.0390414298,
0.0332211889,
-0.012213246,
-0.021288082,
0.0135533698,
-0.0503428578,
0.071363762,
0.0076636951,
-0.0467632078,
0.0660274327,
0.002785953,
-0.055386506,
0.032519687,
-0.0296012256,
0.0106812594,
0.0769678727,
0.0372466668,
0.0038620073,
0.0018889693,
0.0195222218,
0.0223822594,
0.0359927528,
0.0201267079,
0.0010194222,
0.0435040221,
-0.0453564413,
0.0027293181,
-0.0052230344,
-0.0057091503,
0.0409488566,
-0.0423707217,
0.0583754033,
-0.0052245227,
-0.077853404,
-0.0019016812,
0.0542592034,
0.0102049578,
0.0106311217,
0.0050270371,
0.0096904188,
0.0008578186,
0.003428851,
-0.0369245224,
0.0035035161,
-0.021287581,
-0.04841334,
0.0307747014,
0.0108119175,
-0.0553183034,
-0.0506982021,
0.0116747143,
-0.0504960753,
0.0153176114,
0.0005109991,
-0.0355354436,
-0.025949616,
0.0056358306,
-0.0027546808,
0.0586442724,
-0.0429670177,
0.0141825648,
-0.0062718387,
0.016157927,
-0.0166720934,
0.0357025079,
0.0321206525,
-0.0068561328,
0.0124244066,
-0.0033981365,
0.0449999981,
-0.0424040481,
-0.0255028829,
0.032874722,
-0.0102829076,
-0.0246169027,
0.0125850178,
0.0151642878,
-0.0235615261,
-0.0297573786,
-0.1180406511,
-0.0232397281,
-0.017910419,
0.0285523217,
0.0146946153,
0.0024368421,
0.0112794023,
-0.010018331,
-0.0187674779,
-0.0105446251,
-0.0307283271,
0.037574064,
0.0394193046,
0.0101638753,
0.015729649,
-0.0312371887,
-0.0200180151,
0.0083811777,
0.0521884486,
-0.0360314846,
-0.0367336385,
-0.0504328236,
0.0178039148,
-0.0148466118,
0.0049569644,
0.0165057778,
-0.0257346556,
0.0245550722,
-0.014275684,
0.050205227,
0.0396412686,
0.0028133767,
-0.0175709128,
0.0171488393,
-0.0356712826,
-0.038261041,
-0.0236971825,
0.0338953584,
0.0270840041,
-0.0277470294,
-0.0579442568,
0.0049479534,
0.0510151908,
-0.0277833771,
0.0108789876,
-0.0894680843,
-0.036814101,
-0.0395893231,
-0.029608069,
-0.0203370582,
0.0062153866,
0.0051048701,
-0.0104762577,
-0.0430342332,
-0.025980724,
0.0540211499,
-0.0860652179,
-0.0309148617,
-0.0263691135,
0.0120768426,
-0.0451698266,
0.0383067541,
0.0250753928,
0.0116264755,
-0.0038398071,
-0.0518966243,
-0.0298308097,
0.0024922481,
0.0138969012,
0.0001994936,
0.0320756026,
-0.0319924466,
0.0299229063,
-0.0236898493,
-0.0132557545,
0.004438255,
0.0046230345,
-0.0180273689,
0.0469131283,
-0.0061788908,
0.0086530037,
-0.0131314397,
0.07348378,
0.0185382925,
0.0283296667,
-0.0123350937,
0.0045536491,
-0.0107241459,
0.0578145646,
0.023845112,
-0.0315599144,
-0.0399436355,
-0.025161339,
0.0339225717,
0.0010857164,
0.0454797298,
-0.011606738,
-0.0440186523,
0.0263353959,
0.019773636,
0.0102853561,
-0.0397287123,
-0.0285782479,
0.0822614804,
-0.0321420506,
-0.0172712877,
0.0833381116,
0.0048145177,
-0.0440615974,
-0.0243733563,
-0.0265873838,
0.0429283753,
0.0021922074,
0.0085353367,
-0.0635718927,
-0.0399338044,
0.0090882191,
-0.0017565674,
0.0340817496,
-0.020471083,
0.0032068114,
-0.1139479205,
0.0181858577,
0.0046208906,
-0.0445892178,
-0.0034435482,
-0.0344357975,
-0.0129524991,
-0.0354459323,
0.0227897111,
-0.0454836562,
-0.0175239127,
0.0075805895,
0.0392185785,
-0.0041963086,
-0.0109556746,
0.0090294024,
-0.0340748504,
0.0185576845,
0.0464487784,
0.0250488073,
-0.0305866878,
-0.0340479426,
0.0356142744,
-0.0274095759,
0.0057354118,
-0.0230669491,
0.0588495806,
-0.0221322533,
-0.0289999321,
0.0464297719,
-0.0385951251,
0.0303128678,
-0.0344528891,
-0.0381285399,
0.0497527234,
0.0283359475,
-0.0080530103,
0.0016358811,
-0.0211963225,
0.0032204164,
0.0715127289,
0.0235360842,
-0.039441999,
-0.0540421046,
0.0098998919,
0.023127947,
-0.0843433291,
0.0280297305,
0.00468115,
-0.0688583925,
-0.0651282221,
-0.0822916552,
-0.0169800315,
0.063117303,
0.0526197664,
0.0044761691,
0.0085572852,
-0.0353202783,
0.02031211,
0.0164722372,
0.0320383832,
-0.0149604017,
0.019584788,
-0.0774025172,
-0.0054860879,
0.0015604349,
-0.0164807104,
-0.0094030742,
-0.0448557511,
-0.0437181294,
-0.0197177641,
-0.003593212,
0.0676612929,
0.0117800888,
0.009294115,
-0.0231995974,
-0.0624442808,
0.0218622014,
0.0254651885,
-0.0059705558,
-0.0053256671,
0.0064529018,
0.0090212896,
-0.015993299,
0.0279177856,
-0.0347999148,
0.0319777913,
0.0022105884,
0.0479774177,
0.0048104543,
-0.0227583311,
-0.0158672314,
0.0122816833,
0.0366204046,
-0.0270525627,
0.000442885,
-0.016042579,
0.0089063281,
-0.0483804457,
0.0411293283,
-0.0534109063,
-0.0226335432,
0.0479479507,
0.0266952552,
0.0080158859,
0.0147197517,
-0.030109765,
0.0295917876,
-0.0270285252,
0.0199202746,
0.0192557294,
0.0518397875,
0.002264675,
0.038707003,
-0.0157738682,
-0.0674369186,
-0.0058443979,
0.0188353863,
-0.0732865855,
0.0219011158,
0.0137047274,
0.0098011103,
0.0249053724,
0.0540400222,
-0.0087681608,
0.0189908575,
-0.0071133119,
0.0084718941,
0.0352828726,
-0.0356860869,
0.0969183594,
0.0026422525,
0.0037462206,
-0.0335922018,
0.0161949974,
0.0126950555,
-0.0149331372,
0.0013306011,
0.0058179172,
0.0035609347,
-0.0094606103,
0.066368863,
0.0077335779,
-0.0016297249,
-0.0192226302,
-0.0227577426,
-0.0020468591,
0.0288137589,
0.0371483155,
-0.0311090518,
-0.0217835922,
-0.0223188121,
-0.0406002253,
-0.0558145605,
0.0231246762,
-0.0329524465,
-0.0109462971,
0.0194345061,
0.0257855505,
0.0435203947,
0.006477566,
0.0210789181,
-0.0132000409,
0.0053221495,
0.0242274329,
-0.0079481322,
-0.0002828469,
-5.595711268e-33,
-0.013729793,
0.0272390991,
-0.0069924793,
-0.0196681526,
-0.0307077877,
0.0156040983,
-0.0408992097,
-0.0175950006,
0.0040985472,
0.0117860194,
-0.0023938089,
-0.0424503945,
0.0372709408,
0.0415694453,
0.0054865768,
0.0072451546,
0.0553360842,
-0.0053904266,
-0.0327428766,
0.0025029117,
0.0508337244,
0.0448268391,
0.0721091256,
0.0003860234,
-0.0112401303,
0.0370506085,
0.014935201,
-0.0179154836,
0.0993057936,
0.0463259742,
0.000939704,
0.009855669,
0.0270037819,
-0.0178955887,
-0.0299834851,
0.0415560268,
-0.0812566876,
-0.0173512585,
0.0512784347,
0.0358609334,
-0.009132782,
-0.0176330768,
-0.0012115248,
-0.029729059,
0.0263183173,
-0.0063717626,
0.0402938351,
-0.0296061151,
-0.0211094748,
0.0164610129,
-0.0991102532,
0.0318969116,
-0.0106536411,
0.0025556372,
0.1031051576,
0.0711181909,
0.0086028455,
0.0335970335,
-0.0333143286,
0.0000449037,
-0.0448792949,
0.0495337658,
0.06664671,
0.0290176775,
-0.0254854262,
0.0485927202,
0.0378657058,
-0.0338461958,
0.0239759441,
-0.0015022469,
0.0457135737,
0.0432532802,
0.0398747809,
0.0004115526,
0.0079796501,
-0.0170494486,
-0.0539766215,
0.0202036109,
0.0140240854,
0.0327782631,
-0.0034832491,
0.0573271737,
-0.0010021586,
0.0141020929,
0.0066697719,
-0.0732467994,
-0.0299592372,
-0.0543053523,
0.039542038,
-0.0064985375,
-0.0165368132,
0.0189415179,
0.1133623645,
-0.0075038965,
-0.026333278,
-0.030853115,
-0.0255192649,
0.0616875589,
-0.0044206185,
0.017278105,
-0.0676655695,
-0.0794718862,
0.0611742176,
0.0342613161,
0.0393261649,
-0.0236789808,
0.0718232691,
-0.0107020549,
-0.0629458427,
0.0015598112,
-0.029271679,
-0.0093562938,
-0.0394987091,
0.0799823403,
0.0085808681,
0.0025797198,
-0.0186544508,
-0.0002895458,
0.00398735,
-0.0320864804,
0.0011823041,
-0.0062659462,
-0.0008173293,
0.0095899738,
-0.0446374305,
0.0098636914,
-0.0183116067,
0.0360571854,
0.0182169136,
-0.022603387,
-0.0414225124,
0.048878599,
2.446e-7,
0.0523443818,
0.0266287625,
0.0423571207,
-0.0473246537,
0.0180143472,
0.0236900989,
-0.0555600673,
0.0543858483,
0.0185666215,
-0.0099177612,
-0.0336021222,
-0.0021481481,
0.0549890511,
0.0354481973,
-0.0750026926,
0.0223483853,
-0.0180998929,
0.0174277816,
-0.0282214209,
0.0237079505,
0.0470283069,
0.0522687398,
-0.0326316282,
-0.0040392829,
0.0088719409,
-0.0608998425,
0.0692115352,
-0.036712911,
0.004453152,
-0.002514093,
-0.0026201154,
-0.0052554468,
-0.0277821589,
0.0358029865,
-0.0143455435,
-0.007753951,
0.0912781581,
0.0344411358,
-0.0451341644,
-0.0295517985,
-0.0362476557,
0.0117182117,
-0.0171672385,
-0.0870089605,
0.0832103044,
-0.0059990743,
0.0006408558,
-0.0118471105,
-0.026081752,
0.0353837907,
0.0142028015,
-0.0047618579,
-0.0705002919,
0.0519943647,
0.0736460462,
0.0124801714,
-0.0769770741,
-0.0399958268,
-0.0104434974,
0.0045712721,
-0.0071433489,
-0.0446100794,
-0.055239398,
0.0037100371,
0.0257888325,
-0.0369459242,
-0.006701272,
1.982821805e-34,
0.0077401074,
-0.0078285886,
0.0060043214,
0.0125440741,
0.0012834992,
-0.021120511,
-0.0500279516,
0.0161911603,
-0.0449956879,
-0.065218702,
-0.0068477937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08072v2 | Training Generative Question-Answering on Synthetic Data Obtained from an Instruct-tuned Model | 2023-10-12T06:46:07 | 2023-10-13T00:40:29 | Kosuke Takahashi, Takahiro Omi, Kosuke Arima, Tatsuya Ishigaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | This paper presents a simple and cost-effective method for synthesizing data
to train question-answering systems. For training, fine-tuning GPT models is a
common practice in resource-rich languages like English, however, it becomes
challenging for non-English languages due to the scarcity of sufficient
question-answer (QA) pairs. Existing approaches use question and answer
generators trained on human-authored QA pairs, which involves substantial human
expenses. In contrast, we use an instruct-tuned model to generate QA pairs in a
zero-shot or few-shot manner. We conduct experiments to compare various
strategies for obtaining QA pairs from the instruct-tuned model. The results
demonstrate that a model trained on our proposed synthetic data achieves
comparable performance to a model trained on manually curated datasets, without
incurring human costs. | [
0.050988894,
0.0616233684,
-0.0023186717,
0.0477839857,
0.0080391569,
0.0112934578,
-0.0188358482,
-0.0111794434,
-0.0207138825,
-0.0246834606,
-0.0167315286,
-0.009887266,
-0.0409499407,
0.0242761467,
0.0124784904,
-0.0354926921,
0.0573672503,
-0.0089854216,
-0.0377864391,
-0.0209999867,
0.0112007391,
0.0372736119,
-0.0110906987,
0.0107242223,
-0.0102730887,
-0.0419714414,
-0.016743144,
0.011318624,
0.0119622694,
0.0068183881,
0.0146669,
0.0726490468,
0.0059980503,
0.0073036323,
0.0000017769,
-0.0354129411,
0.0029903201,
-0.0109116677,
-0.0448446497,
-0.0055093253,
-0.0277816858,
0.0075629442,
0.0064773713,
0.0443702675,
-0.0771267116,
-0.029448159,
0.0374127738,
-0.0153471688,
0.0906197131,
0.0720556676,
-0.0006421685,
-0.0335195176,
0.0270644762,
-0.004620227,
0.0472961552,
-0.037571609,
-0.0101747084,
0.0228314735,
0.0133033749,
0.0208205227,
-0.00831977,
0.018354468,
0.0599205457,
-0.019056607,
0.0143328682,
0.0328402445,
-0.0412623845,
0.0200655535,
-0.0045673908,
0.1035464108,
0.009395997,
-0.0295681637,
-0.0145636676,
0.0022720953,
0.0231531635,
0.0032237174,
-0.0414166227,
-0.0044480478,
-0.0130089456,
0.009514343,
0.0114028351,
-0.0154105145,
-0.027582353,
-0.0111573162,
0.017392328,
0.0260547884,
0.0215144716,
-0.0326001719,
-0.0461165532,
0.0189335365,
-0.0371206068,
-0.0645584539,
-0.0255328342,
0.0520324707,
-0.0140374741,
0.0162299033,
-0.0535160154,
-0.0313732028,
0.0175759196,
-0.0046801609,
0.0194498617,
0.0178326797,
0.0370505862,
0.0568027645,
-0.0075231749,
0.0335007831,
-0.0052630506,
0.0036583038,
-0.075682655,
-0.042121727,
-0.0596769527,
-0.0384962261,
-0.0765984505,
0.0244264193,
-0.0695157945,
-0.0080592446,
-0.0158618595,
0.0210204404,
0.0418689139,
-0.0135977417,
0.0322681256,
0.0389354229,
-0.0397718213,
-0.0002633454,
-0.0389411747,
-0.0044629285,
-0.1046774611,
0.0005155902,
0.0072346916,
-0.0899961293,
-0.0254047625,
-0.0005445838,
0.0292328466,
-0.0189721696,
0.0015939719,
0.0412894078,
-0.0272358004,
-0.0052517047,
-0.014728507,
-0.0366410688,
0.0258939788,
-0.0493995808,
-0.027682377,
-0.0652479827,
0.0634654313,
0.0120588839,
-0.023528222,
-0.0148266107,
0.0008268394,
0.0498071201,
-0.0034441918,
0.0707090348,
-0.0450055227,
0.0302611683,
0.0209911224,
-0.009577251,
0.0317707174,
0.0691174045,
0.042078048,
-0.0286506806,
0.0272135735,
-0.0070768553,
0.0461124405,
0.0133450376,
0.0439085998,
0.0066948221,
0.0119120087,
0.0834676772,
0.012859581,
0.024045825,
0.0337482207,
0.0394813083,
-0.0414476693,
-0.0042348313,
0.035042312,
0.0288199205,
0.0279490426,
0.0586540103,
0.0626680255,
0.0161307808,
0.0220712461,
-0.0088533685,
-0.0058149719,
0.0624032989,
-0.024851108,
0.0112521229,
0.0130835557,
0.0086415783,
-0.0541082062,
-0.0373323373,
0.0157899987,
0.0149547691,
-0.0392194614,
0.0395856574,
0.0058457577,
0.0417230576,
-0.02664412,
0.0245454255,
0.0135640427,
-0.0434801579,
-0.0004967358,
-0.0230028573,
0.0631518811,
0.0638395324,
0.0404794142,
0.009310863,
-0.0354112014,
-0.0230172109,
-0.0058655087,
0.0514532328,
0.0422029123,
-0.0488111265,
0.013386311,
-0.0209570378,
0.0002076796,
-0.0283597186,
-0.0094333896,
0.0127739059,
0.0399055481,
0.0332085229,
0.0115835136,
-0.0600324273,
0.0129557131,
0.0214399379,
-0.0250074901,
-0.0524984822,
0.0115218889,
-0.0249799602,
-0.0007199618,
0.0215567611,
0.0043741041,
0.0152206877,
0.0240251049,
-0.0191306882,
-0.0214575045,
0.0017758481,
-0.0228955839,
-0.0688248202,
0.0091656288,
-0.0363355093,
-0.0194157641,
0.0170851406,
-0.0510558262,
-0.0513487533,
-0.0171816554,
-0.0550974049,
-0.000976811,
-0.0841439143,
-0.0526371673,
0.0379103608,
0.0110157039,
-0.0395295769,
0.0484643579,
0.016175041,
0.0214898176,
0.0024804566,
0.0102136033,
0.03091879,
-0.0624355748,
0.0345569737,
0.03832075,
0.0113996724,
0.0215581767,
0.0100032343,
0.0275932997,
-0.0603084192,
-0.0215612799,
-0.0695065558,
0.0376491435,
-0.0107165091,
0.0319318548,
0.0606059022,
0.0118901646,
-0.0281459019,
-0.0172381364,
-0.0903230757,
-0.009875604,
0.0397783183,
0.0157053825,
0.0641147643,
0.0039205286,
0.0218996815,
-0.0329042748,
0.0043843114,
-0.0031142321,
0.0131187867,
0.0293713361,
0.0552688427,
-0.0638870671,
-0.0162425265,
-0.0376654156,
0.0427693278,
0.0316005051,
-0.0698702261,
0.0149898827,
-0.0164989866,
0.0573007241,
0.0557925366,
0.0104922308,
-0.014486542,
-0.00246172,
0.0207687505,
-0.057670217,
0.0492603406,
-0.0164648816,
-0.036097385,
-0.0081040608,
-0.0320418254,
0.0004492483,
0.0388039052,
0.0099266758,
-0.0113851503,
-0.060922727,
0.088534832,
0.0169858262,
-0.0206765179,
-0.0372986868,
0.0478030629,
-0.0088228807,
0.0525604524,
-0.0181929134,
-0.0093449354,
0.0590652712,
-0.0025818904,
-0.0286916606,
-0.0610995144,
0.0093060182,
-0.0407810546,
0.0155705353,
-0.0130806528,
0.0163072664,
-0.0008234211,
0.0199278351,
-0.0544006601,
-0.0095185405,
0.0363132656,
-0.0310666468,
-0.0113713723,
-0.0181469731,
0.0289119482,
-0.0252856314,
-0.0504946224,
-0.0596737601,
-0.0445003174,
-0.0039299931,
-0.0054549701,
-0.0125956479,
-0.0177284572,
0.0399555378,
-0.0163983181,
-0.0017233875,
0.0327730514,
-0.0213355217,
-0.0257983916,
-0.0179496631,
0.0913514569,
0.0934839621,
0.018193882,
-0.0092122341,
-0.0110761551,
0.0475781672,
0.0430295281,
0.0195326898,
0.0368879735,
0.0093827415,
-0.007657263,
-0.0016376933,
-0.0191063527,
-0.0031659857,
0.0246793404,
0.052913405,
-0.0311892238,
-0.0493938588,
0.1035913751,
0.0464652516,
-0.007996995,
-0.0104379356,
-0.0045472165,
0.0281186253,
0.0269003138,
0.0702094659,
-0.1018775776,
-0.0221456103,
-0.0281889513,
0.0334322043,
-0.0083086668,
-0.0168666132,
-0.0092342859,
-0.1628935784,
0.0413643979,
-0.0432418324,
-0.0544388965,
-0.0248152334,
-0.019894762,
-0.0168324914,
-0.0062769759,
-0.0174186341,
0.0113352155,
-0.0134448083,
0.0513586663,
0.0042669056,
0.0228104498,
-0.0192799531,
0.0363244638,
-0.0098707816,
0.0299597476,
0.0745113194,
0.0295550451,
-0.0021994477,
-0.0345791243,
0.0013727325,
-0.0559885725,
-0.0096261604,
0.0124838455,
0.0467902198,
-0.0001597527,
-0.0226984508,
-0.0166936684,
0.0635524541,
-0.0452095494,
0.0263471995,
0.0311189275,
0.0566263758,
0.0108619323,
0.0016863915,
-0.0169301368,
0.0036406219,
0.0160731636,
0.0775625855,
0.051007852,
-0.0447084494,
-0.0440905988,
-0.0296064485,
-0.0024265249,
-0.1192264557,
-0.0453035161,
0.020967856,
0.0593753532,
0.0194192566,
-0.1070580184,
-0.0858338326,
0.046003405,
0.0324211493,
-0.0381079055,
0.0082080988,
-0.0438626483,
0.0096411686,
-0.0208450984,
0.0122658387,
-0.0495948195,
-0.0102993157,
-0.0543298498,
-0.0439610183,
0.0405793749,
-0.0416708477,
-0.0311634112,
0.0037988774,
-0.0638525188,
-0.0358510278,
-0.0272943769,
0.0783758536,
0.0211572722,
0.034467835,
-0.0261089578,
-0.0061777048,
0.0067786216,
0.0530463383,
-0.02175867,
-0.011161671,
0.0213999562,
0.0157794785,
-0.0088363113,
0.0352310091,
-0.0224378109,
0.0384705253,
0.01562184,
0.0418565571,
-0.0473732986,
-0.0235923957,
0.0706128925,
0.0133203575,
-0.0081302952,
0.0054618744,
0.0192781799,
-0.0251854341,
0.0135214766,
-0.0462559909,
-0.012078044,
-0.0585791171,
0.0100619942,
0.0120923733,
-0.0371806249,
-0.0088207228,
-0.0178150684,
-0.0418398865,
0.04222605,
-0.0474315025,
-0.0171059612,
0.0524046719,
-0.0069918884,
0.0032865305,
-0.022947697,
-0.0070469747,
0.0040154881,
0.009287728,
0.0580127127,
0.0098854862,
0.0566064343,
0.0232956056,
-0.0109270178,
0.0105290171,
0.0148289204,
-0.0524698757,
-0.0538293272,
-0.0430465527,
0.0360784195,
0.044610709,
0.0211461019,
0.0223269463,
0.0116902962,
-0.0273322184,
0.0143513717,
0.0127179725,
0.0166405551,
-0.0046086358,
0.0367142335,
0.0280969869,
-0.0126630906,
-0.0346256085,
0.0902058706,
0.016849475,
0.067600742,
-0.0150220152,
0.0205606911,
-0.0417654589,
0.0023282112,
-0.0393707976,
-0.036085099,
0.0209988449,
0.0473811477,
-0.0349835902,
-0.0586612634,
-0.0228302702,
0.0407836996,
-0.0029542397,
0.0059388313,
0.0520411097,
0.034858495,
-0.0102713751,
-0.0219911821,
-0.0448944084,
0.0366741158,
-0.0461069942,
-0.0269401483,
-0.0087178349,
-6.316816441e-33,
-0.0280396603,
-0.0105362348,
0.0270293467,
-0.0210857559,
-0.0028261787,
-0.029232733,
-0.0328329317,
-0.0200894736,
-0.0513235293,
0.0015747723,
-0.0386496522,
0.0081338855,
-0.0005994665,
0.032291092,
0.0087198121,
-0.0459753461,
0.0089962073,
-0.0220666435,
-0.0198918059,
0.0414348319,
0.0336983502,
0.0146003906,
0.0479554832,
0.0095402021,
-0.008023466,
-0.0647168383,
-0.007756412,
0.0512268394,
-0.0241455119,
0.0603350215,
-0.0258933455,
0.0383691117,
0.0277162362,
-0.0334378183,
0.0105145751,
0.0255493019,
-0.0847507119,
-0.0572600402,
0.009374585,
-0.0368665308,
-0.0567696504,
-0.033972837,
-0.001641036,
-0.0337331146,
0.0318449773,
-0.0191196986,
0.0331812873,
-0.0348775275,
0.013506433,
-0.0458193384,
-0.0477359928,
-0.0025047881,
-0.0031596022,
-0.0356219038,
-0.0403716862,
0.076844357,
0.0086197108,
-0.0041596503,
0.0068307244,
-0.00858761,
0.039034985,
0.035270825,
0.012416428,
0.0042373477,
0.0213187244,
-0.0038937072,
0.0182337388,
-0.0117698265,
-0.0168967023,
0.0297911465,
-0.0350667797,
-0.0096141947,
0.0634424314,
0.1075226739,
0.0509904176,
0.0166626144,
-0.0609144866,
0.0353037156,
-0.0113774119,
0.0066092485,
-0.0217271447,
-0.0217076074,
-0.0138099967,
-0.0023596112,
-0.0455072373,
-0.0247899331,
-0.0285428166,
-0.0320110507,
0.0497821756,
0.0113889771,
-0.035108421,
-0.0196820833,
0.0236266609,
-0.0247510113,
0.0258049779,
0.023125682,
-0.0247595627,
0.0222602244,
0.0024314343,
0.0343171135,
-0.0325115249,
0.0244508144,
0.0469922088,
0.0208238903,
-0.001945434,
0.0452585407,
0.0198610108,
-0.0048185033,
-0.054480426,
0.0152722569,
-0.0478771627,
0.0670901313,
-0.0580016226,
-0.0205934346,
-0.001892858,
0.0383558199,
-0.0188901816,
0.023054203,
-0.0014334095,
-0.005244249,
-0.0359907709,
-0.0172360018,
0.0062294067,
0.0231768675,
-0.0116485013,
0.035253752,
-0.0477482192,
0.0065761167,
0.0035617731,
-0.0514962561,
-0.0041750874,
0.0398534425,
2.373e-7,
0.0586531833,
-0.0094097368,
0.0477793291,
0.0524788313,
0.0209688712,
0.0052730967,
0.0169804301,
0.0198843237,
0.0378030539,
-0.0137408581,
0.0059773168,
0.0455574244,
0.0340375602,
0.0349847563,
-0.0998705924,
0.0199513007,
-0.0769659653,
-0.0193063896,
-0.0364789143,
-0.0282396246,
0.05074393,
0.0707346424,
-0.0043239216,
-0.0029581091,
-0.0058554965,
-0.0188475642,
0.0559839085,
0.018758228,
-0.014816789,
0.0354382321,
-0.0052307844,
0.0244998969,
0.0100185089,
-0.0016576283,
-0.0222871322,
0.0088632749,
0.0126556838,
0.0391174331,
-0.0075656264,
-0.0362527631,
-0.0065044458,
-0.0431515016,
0.0088804876,
-0.0542917885,
0.0927190259,
-0.0584816709,
0.0131120561,
0.0092423679,
-0.0559539869,
-0.0087624053,
0.0072153509,
-0.0588586964,
-0.0232929774,
0.0198233481,
0.0283418894,
-0.0139844855,
0.0392083526,
-0.0229448397,
-0.0134144612,
0.0237701237,
-0.0328144431,
-0.0258876793,
-0.0028292681,
-0.0125535782,
-0.0004552655,
-0.021306226,
-0.0008433991,
1.70581989e-34,
0.0269663073,
0.0072928965,
0.0416949242,
0.0171342455,
0.0208310317,
-0.0004414714,
0.0045796097,
-0.0308461655,
0.0495655425,
-0.0731890947,
-0.0297124721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08069v1 | Rethinking Negative Pairs in Code Search | 2023-10-12T06:32:42 | 2023-10-12T06:32:42 | Haochen Li, Xin Zhou, Luu Anh Tuan, Chunyan Miao | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recently, contrastive learning has become a key component in fine-tuning code
search models for software development efficiency and effectiveness. It pulls
together positive code snippets while pushing negative samples away given
search queries. Among contrastive learning, InfoNCE is the most widely used
loss function due to its better performance. However, the following problems in
negative samples of InfoNCE may deteriorate its representation learning: 1) The
existence of false negative samples in large code corpora due to duplications.
2). The failure to explicitly differentiate between the potential relevance of
negative samples. As an example, a bubble sorting algorithm example is less
``negative'' than a file saving function for the quick sorting algorithm query.
In this paper, we tackle the above problems by proposing a simple yet effective
Soft-InfoNCE loss that inserts weight terms into InfoNCE. In our proposed loss
function, we apply three methods to estimate the weights of negative pairs and
show that the vanilla InfoNCE loss is a special case of Soft-InfoNCE.
Theoretically, we analyze the effects of Soft-InfoNCE on controlling the
distribution of learnt code representations and on deducing a more precise
mutual information estimation. We furthermore discuss the superiority of
proposed loss functions with other design alternatives. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of Soft-InfoNCE and weights estimation methods
under state-of-the-art code search models on a large-scale public dataset
consisting of six programming languages. Source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Alex-HaochenLi/Soft-InfoNCE}. | [
-0.0106960544,
0.0401225165,
-0.0312385857,
0.0671839267,
-0.0195856467,
-0.0173629448,
-0.0522242151,
0.0247584153,
-0.0330314599,
-0.0088220816,
-0.0566570275,
-0.0143639259,
0.0142977908,
-0.0097747389,
0.0489758886,
-0.0107351216,
0.0344094783,
0.019970078,
-0.0212636758,
-0.0010831902,
0.0135550229,
-0.0089878766,
0.0088933352,
0.0389067531,
0.0586156659,
0.0006844123,
0.0080728345,
0.0585409403,
-0.0007877668,
-0.0671439767,
0.0166116934,
0.0228304248,
-0.0096271764,
0.0309979822,
0.0000022028,
-0.009770018,
-0.0185761023,
-0.011022957,
-0.0124203181,
0.0371629149,
0.0201342981,
-0.0157059059,
0.0206474029,
0.0030455482,
-0.0218789801,
-0.0061821165,
0.0704870597,
0.0147695988,
0.0539067276,
0.0213605072,
0.0256950632,
0.0151944561,
-0.0075924867,
-0.0091357948,
0.0804406628,
-0.032622233,
-0.004852626,
-0.0186439492,
0.0283678528,
0.0138623891,
0.0033817904,
0.0428878479,
-0.0057628104,
0.0524374768,
-0.0114624435,
0.0400826894,
-0.0642463937,
0.026454553,
0.0292561986,
0.047545366,
-0.0394934826,
-0.0392661914,
0.0042807823,
-0.0518634915,
-0.0326248407,
-0.0284236297,
-0.0027578999,
-0.0186080225,
-0.0026688946,
0.0017750021,
0.0273540523,
-0.002982649,
0.0154016381,
-0.0058591492,
-0.0185716059,
0.0261132196,
-0.0190647244,
-0.023459198,
0.0153539488,
-0.0380925052,
-0.054565262,
0.0203268472,
0.009523375,
0.0030931171,
0.0485586114,
-0.0174398255,
0.0001810368,
-0.0564672723,
0.0497525893,
-0.0603670999,
-0.0261213016,
0.0200492796,
-0.0173075385,
0.005675232,
-0.0375466906,
0.0407088548,
-0.0101110563,
-0.0024266427,
-0.0159408804,
0.0224523116,
-0.0293424614,
-0.0137549257,
-0.0279796943,
0.0855408683,
0.0226779412,
0.0270329472,
0.007525356,
0.0125434436,
-0.0439920165,
0.0032039711,
-0.0312183406,
-0.0157972947,
-0.0150919519,
0.03086094,
-0.0124947131,
-0.0132974843,
-0.0207997635,
-0.040346887,
-0.0492991917,
-0.0028211211,
-0.0089694979,
0.0093816891,
-0.0252730642,
-0.0137036284,
0.0078666192,
0.0329681672,
0.0287337471,
0.0055885282,
-0.0454154797,
-0.0231173318,
0.0410744175,
0.0474315323,
-0.0250173341,
-0.0733320937,
-0.0543087088,
0.0068512317,
-0.0053908969,
-0.0730922595,
-0.0216038842,
-0.0044706231,
-0.0035324306,
0.0699832514,
-0.0594048426,
0.0073193186,
0.0043717492,
0.0275063887,
-0.0115144253,
0.0558239147,
0.0026609427,
-0.032281246,
0.0249861348,
-0.031920135,
0.0419508442,
-0.0046143597,
0.0436648391,
0.0073145446,
0.006056854,
0.0240565687,
0.0055734133,
-0.0175351631,
0.0149532026,
0.022535922,
-0.0589733236,
-0.0370929055,
-0.0031559418,
0.0140004726,
0.0512461178,
0.0066949511,
0.0161845721,
0.0668860674,
-0.0493299551,
-0.0249883067,
-0.0323981941,
0.0431411378,
-0.0295093879,
0.0092596905,
0.0282941945,
-0.0386448428,
-0.0284840837,
-0.031339772,
0.0110825375,
-0.0040376913,
0.0196173247,
-0.0350612588,
0.0335145853,
-0.0094768414,
-0.0516213477,
0.0255530253,
0.0394826345,
-0.030825045,
-0.0450652801,
-0.0324655324,
0.0297633987,
0.0256491005,
0.0318509713,
-0.1037785634,
-0.028795613,
0.0326589048,
-0.0661820918,
-0.063934952,
0.0337849855,
0.0009638666,
0.0351259224,
-0.0797972307,
-0.0284476243,
0.0066982866,
-0.029774908,
0.0435900651,
-0.0281159282,
0.0022890491,
0.0481084697,
0.0137535157,
-0.0644526258,
0.0084770443,
0.0045667416,
-0.008163292,
0.035464514,
0.0129235974,
0.0114534032,
-0.0242311526,
-0.0196575262,
0.0173075125,
0.0589255057,
0.0028727173,
-0.0413145833,
-0.0637781397,
-0.0251741428,
-0.0557862483,
0.0001448761,
-0.0694952905,
0.0611308664,
0.0443776101,
-0.0115447342,
-0.0039592814,
0.0736320764,
-0.0295995418,
0.0408905484,
0.0502921604,
0.0189193953,
-0.0117326817,
-0.0137819964,
-0.0391351096,
0.04711245,
-0.0070175049,
0.0714347959,
-0.0131424712,
0.0540100299,
0.0240777601,
-0.0114752194,
-0.0422411412,
-0.0054837037,
-0.0463283435,
0.0298985336,
0.0172148775,
0.0189172868,
0.0006330278,
-0.0039862585,
-0.0545428433,
0.045643758,
0.0098691387,
0.0305732787,
0.016338734,
0.0093115494,
0.0355912894,
-0.0340743624,
-0.0061746836,
-0.0158867482,
-0.0819647759,
0.0261302292,
0.0189293921,
0.0410687514,
-0.0341343507,
-0.0208493229,
-0.0442213826,
-0.0499930643,
0.0370969325,
-0.0510088988,
-0.0411163867,
-0.0608977117,
0.1235552207,
-0.0240800343,
0.0149895325,
-0.0375941582,
-0.0424960628,
0.0122340117,
-0.044739686,
0.0048240563,
0.0350645371,
-0.0061517917,
-0.0416721143,
0.0085212635,
0.0215725265,
-0.077932924,
0.0101190004,
0.0161671154,
0.0212719962,
0.0318757519,
-0.0380708948,
0.0194318164,
0.0389349721,
-0.0168414097,
-0.0109130396,
-0.0291404314,
-0.0061121327,
0.0040018372,
0.0078168735,
0.0401766896,
-0.0160206854,
0.0292830784,
0.0089735296,
-0.0302261766,
-0.0713515356,
0.0194771774,
-0.0146188643,
-0.023383759,
-0.0378701538,
-0.0256497301,
-0.0250064898,
0.0330321454,
-0.0065443222,
0.0134329926,
0.0251541324,
-0.032781411,
-0.0566754453,
-0.0220126323,
0.0533098429,
-0.0362100191,
0.0619476065,
-0.0065674605,
-0.0021615645,
-0.0001256881,
-0.0451979712,
-0.0077535282,
-0.0430970974,
0.0337890573,
-0.0150815481,
0.0747810826,
0.0155451084,
0.0071263243,
0.0388308801,
0.0195699893,
0.0659029037,
0.0401913412,
-0.05004026,
-0.023350779,
-0.047441978,
-0.0379146188,
-0.0556199998,
0.0416145436,
-0.0162491053,
-0.0093752202,
-0.0131559549,
0.06108943,
0.025578836,
-0.0188625064,
-0.0359850712,
0.0445565991,
-0.0048017451,
-0.0846891776,
0.043572776,
0.0241064094,
-0.0284043197,
-0.0199812874,
0.0549402162,
0.0284302849,
-0.1004565209,
0.0105169155,
-0.0163307488,
0.0291710086,
0.0941265449,
-0.0009787314,
-0.0253143776,
-0.0318641625,
-0.0161820371,
0.059453845,
-0.0334850326,
-0.0212288406,
-0.0028434189,
-0.0924085155,
-0.0539385602,
0.0195214991,
-0.0207508691,
-0.0569265597,
-0.0106427874,
-0.0298039224,
-0.0408517271,
-0.0815493166,
0.0342958905,
0.0014582729,
0.023894025,
0.0096222674,
-0.0180665087,
0.0266094841,
-0.0045628366,
-0.0577809103,
0.0085579725,
0.0831779167,
0.0287577081,
-0.0167980883,
-0.0004278637,
0.0241107717,
-0.0832724571,
-0.002290834,
-0.0591750294,
0.0890053138,
0.0153681412,
-0.0078569427,
0.0339054354,
-0.0176436678,
-0.057224907,
0.0180644449,
0.0365592055,
0.0193341486,
-0.0254494287,
-0.0069026696,
-0.0121813891,
-0.0004761474,
0.0185031891,
0.0505816936,
0.0187640972,
0.0015166642,
0.0316511355,
-0.0311018415,
0.0518724769,
-0.0057152864,
-0.0150106959,
-0.052362863,
-0.0061942386,
0.01729686,
-0.0656168163,
0.0126119507,
0.0002490865,
0.0921702236,
0.0086268252,
0.0109412661,
-0.0286815315,
-0.0243732445,
-0.0472480282,
-0.0005999443,
0.0043701711,
0.0067233457,
-0.0402428694,
-0.0261841454,
0.0377875082,
-0.0168582033,
-0.038651865,
0.009879997,
-0.0633708313,
-0.0251609478,
-0.0680847093,
0.0701226816,
0.0136958519,
0.0312349796,
-0.0445088781,
-0.0559172221,
0.0050436584,
0.0725594684,
-0.0044518793,
-0.0045778826,
0.0509758666,
-0.0516068153,
0.0361972675,
-0.011852256,
-0.0568654612,
-0.0211500004,
0.0324115716,
-0.0200999212,
-0.0572365001,
0.0129434438,
0.0202895571,
0.011454232,
0.0557252169,
0.0437151529,
-0.0291389469,
-0.0005628118,
0.0286938995,
0.0366861857,
-0.0346677862,
-0.047806669,
0.0349938199,
0.0211025607,
0.0122932177,
0.0020774987,
0.02766487,
0.0480603948,
0.0172456782,
-0.013125265,
0.0317792818,
0.0486106873,
0.0851884633,
0.0324636884,
0.005806068,
-0.0076079508,
-0.0129582798,
0.0121050421,
0.050627593,
-0.0185432415,
0.0420222953,
0.0274895616,
0.0379124098,
0.0231461413,
0.0194612108,
-0.0517860316,
-0.0391738191,
-0.0243865419,
-0.0534468703,
0.0151078086,
0.0339405425,
0.0111916335,
0.0416463837,
0.0375036038,
-0.0396394804,
0.0298538581,
-0.0371916816,
-0.0024392752,
0.0053536398,
0.0391028039,
-0.0087172901,
-0.0474579073,
0.1077638194,
-0.0532799698,
0.0194937438,
-0.068938978,
-0.0177721828,
-0.0029495975,
0.0535337552,
0.0582529269,
0.0743653327,
-0.0043027713,
-0.0043523018,
-0.0309995115,
-0.0232003722,
0.0080994554,
0.010044612,
0.0335764326,
0.0162808709,
0.0561175309,
0.0721994862,
-0.0010566212,
-0.018148236,
0.0070741586,
-0.0302331578,
-0.036848329,
-0.0105249435,
-0.0533924028,
-5.998676609e-33,
-0.0317315385,
-0.0007527434,
-0.0336484984,
0.0140747018,
0.0018665472,
0.0240230877,
-0.006262437,
-0.0144385248,
-0.0156157417,
-0.0364733748,
0.0458214581,
0.0483635031,
-0.0206693206,
-0.0441738181,
0.0363219567,
-0.0043890821,
0.0208060592,
0.0539287403,
-0.0266182441,
0.0396283753,
-0.0030456248,
0.0459174104,
0.0517843142,
-0.0690687895,
-0.075186342,
-0.0035022818,
0.0612817332,
0.0047749258,
0.0346427597,
0.0446199887,
0.0235625636,
-0.0148896864,
-0.0105590103,
-0.0403184332,
-0.0411414504,
-0.0876122713,
-0.0004262457,
-0.0658599585,
0.0073010153,
-0.0067293164,
0.0348295644,
-0.0448315032,
0.0733615085,
0.0154221477,
0.0134807229,
0.0355147161,
0.0287441742,
0.0258431751,
-0.0181207173,
-0.0337194167,
-0.0231860615,
0.0431490205,
-0.0301480144,
-0.0125189219,
0.0038168258,
0.0290178992,
0.0122321835,
0.0489970036,
-0.0195793211,
-0.0049432577,
-0.0078374948,
0.0791740268,
0.0350293107,
0.0237639081,
0.0138021847,
0.0094763832,
0.0620936714,
0.0340353511,
0.0693926141,
-0.062552847,
0.0696041659,
0.0009572172,
0.0434211083,
0.0206345953,
0.0841184929,
0.0036741837,
-0.0110469097,
0.0227172039,
-0.0091934279,
0.0053347792,
0.0224294849,
0.0627452806,
-0.0813644677,
-0.0172259808,
-0.0111171091,
-0.0625237823,
-0.0288766865,
-0.0190611146,
0.0290793721,
-0.0027275214,
-0.0284267552,
0.0745142922,
0.0115444604,
-0.0315253288,
-0.0075765778,
0.0281496812,
-0.040949218,
0.0119188204,
-0.0120532485,
-0.0225804523,
-0.057387244,
-0.0420610011,
0.0110769393,
0.0125964964,
0.0694030821,
0.0053676269,
0.0433013588,
0.0111264819,
-0.0752859637,
-0.0597072877,
-0.0270767286,
-0.0446072482,
-0.0303492863,
-0.0360172354,
0.0072883572,
0.009764133,
0.0130763948,
0.0059050829,
0.0662670061,
-0.0407564379,
-0.0671848878,
-0.031490542,
-0.0194703713,
0.008439621,
-0.0106310518,
-0.040944919,
-0.0218717419,
0.0092779286,
0.0260839164,
-0.0423274823,
-0.0785213336,
0.0231103301,
2.92e-7,
-0.0104047004,
-0.0017123172,
-0.0302183013,
0.0341549441,
0.0055504865,
0.0637810528,
-0.0126358969,
-0.0228105467,
0.0064998879,
0.037333142,
0.0074985558,
0.005311701,
-0.012239974,
0.0201047398,
-0.0314984061,
0.0268796515,
0.0044872123,
-0.0268995054,
-0.0260962788,
-0.00777272,
0.028971212,
0.1008060947,
0.0247967243,
0.0289551858,
0.0206984133,
-0.0616396591,
0.0088964785,
-0.012089788,
0.0690061375,
0.0161075126,
-0.0280213226,
-0.0073047406,
-0.0328189209,
0.0132970493,
0.0006678366,
-0.0068577779,
0.0304861125,
-0.041107066,
-0.0022376329,
0.0026951812,
0.0475891419,
-0.025348058,
-0.0077165389,
-0.017299477,
0.0506536327,
-0.0042526256,
-0.0130466493,
0.0047136522,
-0.0459938645,
-0.0140709579,
-0.006063378,
0.0081725549,
-0.0043791342,
-0.0047443188,
-0.027747171,
-0.0080547715,
-0.0479154885,
-0.0315568373,
-0.0180136804,
0.0532581173,
0.0178735498,
-0.0439168513,
-0.0540839732,
0.0282518435,
0.0052549778,
-0.0078465939,
0.0573099889,
2.716105742e-34,
0.016295813,
-0.0389929228,
-0.0128777763,
0.0355153568,
0.0434155613,
-0.0024803185,
-0.0539695248,
0.0054176971,
0.01059506,
0.0418208018,
-0.0049658981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08041v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08041v3 | QLLM: Accurate and Efficient Low-Bitwidth Quantization for Large Language Models | 2023-10-12T05:25:49 | 2024-04-06T10:22:57 | Jing Liu, Ruihao Gong, Xiuying Wei, Zhiwei Dong, Jianfei Cai, Bohan Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in NLP, but their demands hinder their
widespread deployment. While Quantization-Aware Training (QAT) offers a
solution, its extensive training costs make Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) a
more practical approach for LLMs. In existing studies, activation outliers in
particular channels are identified as the bottleneck to PTQ accuracy. They
propose to transform the magnitudes from activations to weights, which however
offers limited alleviation or suffers from unstable gradients, resulting in a
severe performance drop at low-bitwidth. In this paper, we propose QLLM, an
accurate and efficient low-bitwidth PTQ method designed for LLMs. QLLM
introduces an adaptive channel reassembly technique that reallocates the
magnitude of outliers to other channels, thereby mitigating their impact on the
quantization range. This is achieved by channel disassembly and channel
assembly, which first breaks down the outlier channels into several
sub-channels to ensure a more balanced distribution of activation magnitudes.
Then similar channels are merged to maintain the original channel number for
efficiency. Additionally, an adaptive strategy is designed to autonomously
determine the optimal number of sub-channels for channel disassembly. To
further compensate for the performance loss caused by quantization, we propose
an efficient tuning method that only learns a small number of low-rank weights
while freezing the pre-trained quantized model. After training, these low-rank
parameters can be fused into the frozen weights without affecting inference.
Extensive experiments on LLaMA-1 and LLaMA-2 show that QLLM can obtain accurate
quantized models efficiently. For example, QLLM quantizes the 4-bit LLaMA-2-70B
within 10 hours on a single A100-80G GPU, outperforming the previous
state-of-the-art method by 7.89% on the average accuracy across five zero-shot
tasks. | [
-0.0258659273,
0.0644674897,
0.0230225716,
0.0469927713,
0.0130842421,
0.0098608136,
0.0043944707,
-0.0009062833,
-0.0533835553,
-0.0339273252,
-0.0339634903,
-0.018311223,
-0.0245843399,
0.0052065873,
0.0166424047,
0.0009624158,
0.0422632843,
-0.0392096117,
0.005098233,
-0.0100944014,
0.0022082655,
0.0167283099,
-0.0001414484,
0.0132335294,
0.0216255747,
-0.0164149031,
-0.0100015728,
0.0189923588,
-0.0016243078,
-0.0169639084,
-0.003741164,
0.0569988415,
0.0197699368,
0.0200337246,
0.0000021947,
-0.0261479281,
-0.0282595865,
-0.0237898082,
-0.0498668104,
0.0760581866,
0.003404266,
-0.0211017411,
-0.046292711,
0.029916741,
-0.0061425106,
-0.0235107411,
0.0510876514,
0.0202475768,
0.0635976046,
0.071547024,
-0.0059322952,
-0.020628551,
0.033175692,
-0.0311891157,
-0.0238614026,
-0.0456598364,
0.0156052914,
0.0256641414,
-0.0282474067,
-0.0138572305,
-0.0242693685,
0.0287955888,
0.027363373,
0.0168322157,
-0.0050209882,
0.0185321029,
-0.042506177,
-0.0145769231,
-0.0143693769,
0.0666087568,
-0.114209637,
-0.0434310772,
0.0175250154,
-0.0051998245,
-0.0369211547,
-0.0917855203,
-0.0421709493,
0.0219486672,
0.0411898643,
0.0650618076,
-0.0119348867,
-0.0248442255,
0.0624182634,
0.0294278059,
-0.0541717261,
0.0350280218,
0.0167036615,
-0.0097699035,
-0.0125476029,
-0.01189801,
-0.0916479453,
-0.0229212139,
-0.0301043727,
0.0013398257,
-0.0064964672,
-0.0027118244,
-0.0402605273,
-0.0212800093,
-0.0193606671,
-0.0296085812,
0.0094459141,
0.062704742,
-0.0023405422,
0.0286351442,
-0.010363875,
0.0412459075,
0.007431949,
0.0575520657,
-0.0713233352,
0.02240666,
-0.0086839693,
0.0036629392,
-0.049808301,
0.0414118543,
-0.0274398662,
-0.0299457312,
-0.0455925874,
0.0019202053,
-0.0156905781,
-0.0384585783,
0.0122912237,
0.0109174466,
-0.0300792865,
-0.0243146271,
0.0421697423,
0.030340679,
-0.0137292761,
0.0095760953,
-0.0098333787,
-0.0595239289,
-0.0134438332,
0.0278900526,
0.0014694915,
-0.0238779858,
0.0266859327,
0.0077383537,
-0.0153940637,
-0.0557198748,
-0.0253889281,
0.0156597588,
-0.0019201604,
-0.0563278943,
-0.0276479218,
-0.0686862543,
0.0026942494,
-0.0246322695,
0.0159335602,
-0.0499196127,
0.0190980248,
-0.0039924281,
-0.010823369,
0.0598882809,
-0.0296971686,
0.0130118886,
0.0185443796,
0.0052301828,
0.048018951,
0.1080819145,
0.0310768038,
0.0283522159,
0.0113479374,
-0.0047020968,
-0.0058414126,
0.041027993,
0.0369661637,
-0.0145783545,
-0.0558423325,
-0.0438745692,
-0.0182549786,
0.0442117229,
0.1139168292,
0.0789126307,
-0.0645000488,
-0.0195796546,
0.0365069956,
0.0305011347,
0.0360710584,
0.005690481,
-0.0262183286,
0.0050232792,
0.0027516093,
-0.0059540733,
-0.065414384,
0.0164668541,
0.0356477201,
-0.0038029095,
0.0505715609,
0.0711201355,
-0.0482200906,
-0.0511918552,
-0.0359143242,
-0.0139350276,
0.014601008,
0.0043940037,
0.0292220525,
0.0127382046,
-0.0036442664,
0.0906045437,
0.0388643779,
-0.0384479389,
0.0089968611,
-0.0722453371,
-0.0252062548,
0.0638259947,
0.0226364415,
0.0069918288,
0.0023851353,
0.0165974833,
0.0062267673,
0.014669721,
-0.0272975545,
0.0038094039,
0.0336142667,
-0.0749920011,
-0.0270272736,
-0.0025598817,
0.0234703664,
-0.0022915029,
0.0142501723,
-0.0041611488,
-0.0158422776,
-0.0477446951,
0.0098150959,
0.0344413109,
-0.0049441135,
-0.0772856772,
0.0325986594,
-0.013899968,
0.0166762546,
0.0141312368,
-0.0165693909,
0.0047326302,
0.039150238,
-0.0626717433,
0.0070126192,
-0.0174626727,
-0.0015870547,
-0.0525153577,
0.0436177365,
0.0137030249,
0.0388304144,
0.040329095,
-0.0531708859,
-0.0456967987,
0.0314588621,
-0.0057191444,
0.0495317467,
-0.0579883344,
0.0225267299,
0.0015690667,
0.026141068,
-0.0250616074,
0.023074694,
-0.0334698595,
-0.0012799853,
0.0168936159,
0.0081598135,
-0.0205160193,
-0.0337253064,
-0.0394463018,
0.0264472328,
0.0044121323,
0.060745839,
-0.0151896523,
-0.0095643783,
-0.0056815059,
-0.0107713761,
-0.0591170266,
0.0262578223,
-0.0585029535,
0.0338996872,
0.0393696241,
0.0314830393,
0.0046903011,
-0.0200428758,
-0.004779031,
-0.0383631997,
0.0090898676,
0.009473471,
-0.0004551366,
-0.0054992791,
-0.0095167551,
-0.0314194523,
-0.0396008156,
0.0289470498,
0.0439746194,
-0.0684781224,
-0.035143543,
-0.0591417775,
0.0009092484,
-0.0191731825,
0.0437874906,
-0.0017231917,
-0.067249842,
-0.0190409385,
-0.0021607908,
0.0079436181,
0.057985682,
-0.0011448615,
0.0229608566,
0.0965441093,
0.0122430231,
-0.0231315661,
0.0186012182,
-0.015215694,
-0.0492384322,
-0.0159699097,
0.003736939,
0.0020938863,
0.0606530495,
-0.0232368428,
0.0035230396,
-0.0243316777,
0.024602348,
-0.0241562873,
-0.0125176692,
-0.036161501,
0.0004445258,
-0.02220002,
0.0563410074,
-0.0086274315,
-0.0396428183,
0.0192851536,
-0.0188589208,
0.0091647599,
-0.0284879841,
-0.0193292908,
-0.0004577355,
0.0352217779,
0.0166827887,
0.0373764969,
-0.020381704,
-0.0334261172,
-0.0496609621,
-0.0317910761,
-0.0178208388,
-0.031229306,
0.0279276967,
-0.03310645,
0.0477991812,
-0.0168427918,
-0.0464798473,
-0.0069129416,
0.0043481179,
-0.0020036222,
0.016020488,
0.0090431767,
-0.019125605,
0.0269051325,
0.0570482388,
-0.0082416488,
0.0306870993,
-0.0030460015,
0.0197617188,
-0.0196695197,
0.0490768179,
0.0423914716,
0.0136259897,
0.0277095065,
-0.0034720944,
-0.00664313,
0.033132337,
0.029289661,
0.0564721264,
-0.0225686282,
-0.0034425489,
0.025207717,
-0.0096407989,
-0.0134455813,
-0.0025808916,
0.0747474208,
-0.0362931862,
-0.0149713857,
0.0895193145,
0.0243396703,
-0.0546108074,
0.0197796524,
0.0476928316,
0.0469149128,
0.0012441007,
0.0068847295,
-0.1108603626,
-0.0246231817,
0.0173071008,
0.024289282,
0.0240344182,
0.0269827377,
-0.0225339197,
-0.0880144909,
0.0047860546,
0.0299220849,
0.0225100238,
-0.0264045577,
-0.0341784172,
-0.0278321356,
-0.0566707216,
0.1010789648,
0.0516365059,
-0.0160365105,
0.0008525536,
0.0290027335,
-0.0332606658,
-0.0636117682,
0.0182907451,
-0.0179536771,
0.06965518,
0.0611440241,
0.0095248837,
-0.0020567195,
-0.0033289343,
0.0322909839,
-0.0636606365,
-0.0171331968,
0.0065042586,
0.0029922044,
0.0069204601,
-0.0033865005,
0.011365369,
0.0146396421,
-0.013497103,
-0.0177805778,
-0.0491837561,
0.0140168685,
-0.0182599686,
-0.0116179762,
0.0078828409,
-0.0295142271,
-0.0524155013,
0.0533707999,
0.0127344225,
-0.006323419,
-0.0769960657,
0.0009972571,
0.0028296348,
-0.0316337496,
-0.0281251259,
0.0186063088,
-0.0176913347,
-0.081798695,
-0.0581689663,
0.0045734881,
0.0064787669,
0.0326691382,
-0.0431253053,
0.0247988384,
-0.0042648981,
0.0194172189,
-0.0579164177,
0.0106617985,
-0.0052886838,
0.0027438523,
-0.0215917956,
0.0130523276,
0.0128515372,
-0.0138589209,
-0.0076009072,
-0.0295015369,
-0.1221030578,
-0.0737991631,
0.0110585205,
0.0119291153,
0.0193433668,
0.0629257485,
-0.0065185181,
-0.06869708,
0.0289884601,
0.0572934076,
-0.00909313,
0.0649518371,
0.0182055496,
0.0063366033,
-0.0103981532,
0.0511559136,
-0.0273672193,
0.0580572858,
-0.016487699,
0.0516026579,
-0.0723971054,
-0.014631249,
-0.0151788723,
-0.0195600055,
0.0627142265,
0.0005451645,
-0.0169117879,
-0.0177246258,
0.0249734931,
0.0092702815,
0.0218090937,
-0.0337886401,
0.022567708,
0.0376392826,
0.022481855,
-0.0225689709,
-0.0181811135,
0.0380955562,
-0.0249551982,
0.0325893052,
0.0133584458,
-0.0391508453,
-0.0065484475,
0.0296771824,
-0.0004077466,
-0.0201753881,
0.0402458347,
0.0008062501,
0.01584539,
-0.0491119102,
-0.013876141,
0.0039043934,
0.0070266761,
-0.0538170524,
0.0530939624,
-0.0299549215,
-0.0355981551,
-0.0489834808,
0.0180977061,
0.0744623169,
0.049476102,
0.0735479519,
0.0286056995,
-0.0220954083,
-0.0028100626,
0.0249852389,
0.0157723259,
0.0287343115,
0.0493410565,
0.0241585858,
-0.0279881526,
-0.0311406404,
0.034196794,
0.0307865515,
0.0313932151,
-0.0004784217,
0.0199794117,
0.0062076631,
-0.0053086653,
-0.0752943978,
0.0269158613,
-0.0269040484,
-0.0010303059,
0.0070335595,
-0.0391228199,
-0.001006263,
0.0205410067,
-0.0071626306,
-0.0404926091,
0.0273811426,
0.0508144461,
0.0090885041,
-0.0314334221,
-0.0248208493,
-0.0807987303,
0.0020014893,
-0.0215489995,
0.0219492018,
-7.131431822e-33,
0.0076194964,
0.0043818993,
0.0152247762,
-0.0278082825,
-0.0308841802,
0.0155084897,
0.0007083418,
-0.0119316159,
-0.0364328027,
-0.0299134161,
-0.0058910726,
0.024358293,
0.0201734677,
0.0149548966,
-0.0301950481,
0.0186267681,
0.1038618907,
-0.0144705158,
-0.0048354953,
0.0250810012,
-0.0043199947,
0.0244781096,
0.0504599512,
0.0413121544,
-0.0452836007,
-0.0138590429,
-0.0267323311,
0.0214404613,
0.0346627347,
0.0242857151,
-0.0409997515,
0.0270335637,
0.0187756084,
0.00912889,
-0.0134338019,
-0.0276206266,
-0.0719666854,
-0.0007582206,
0.0123147806,
0.0241280794,
0.0099115148,
-0.0206237398,
0.0685549974,
0.0086022774,
-0.0483810902,
-0.016061822,
-0.0124615217,
-0.0035964753,
-0.0274742413,
-0.0437872596,
-0.0137030277,
0.0451202318,
0.0303620957,
-0.0072252615,
0.0637765676,
-0.0422387011,
-0.0368304066,
-0.0160791054,
-0.0920916349,
-0.0276923683,
0.0313086361,
0.0881837457,
0.0436630584,
0.0493987203,
0.0175044816,
0.0455659404,
0.0436289944,
-0.0207956657,
0.004748994,
0.049504023,
0.067488946,
0.0477488004,
0.0351405405,
0.0201383531,
0.1235934868,
-0.0079804529,
-0.0745627955,
-0.0124793183,
0.0353284441,
0.0220892951,
0.0337165408,
0.0796644688,
-0.0124122798,
-0.0386077017,
-0.0348524414,
-0.004981006,
-0.044488892,
-0.0542785265,
0.0187364165,
0.0489181057,
-0.0247749705,
-0.0035803914,
0.0139749777,
-0.0248281043,
-0.0186070669,
0.0041165217,
-0.0109533574,
0.0237475149,
-0.0140824979,
0.0237421617,
-0.0527807884,
-0.0310348794,
0.0000371754,
-0.0034538864,
-0.0000835127,
-0.015797995,
0.0184088591,
0.0400930643,
-0.0729188845,
-0.0161582474,
-0.0186433494,
0.0165771637,
0.0030259243,
0.0692844018,
0.0242566448,
0.0137166008,
0.0010665396,
0.0359764919,
-0.008817534,
0.0270376299,
-0.0223220978,
-0.0015998837,
0.0210774485,
0.0331155695,
-0.0444509499,
0.009556816,
-0.023779707,
0.0404360816,
0.0322755463,
-0.081465736,
-0.0437284261,
0.0224752016,
2.974e-7,
0.0544186458,
0.0265195202,
0.0077509657,
-0.009915594,
-0.0061219097,
-0.0232940037,
-0.018616382,
-0.0004447776,
-0.0056391726,
-0.0345732272,
-0.0127006583,
0.0432786867,
0.0220504086,
0.0235326122,
-0.0804710016,
0.0437228121,
-0.0446045138,
0.0067970706,
-0.0473564006,
-0.0520438589,
0.0257320516,
0.1255731434,
-0.0191736612,
-0.0173333716,
0.0364151001,
-0.0040374687,
0.0333663523,
0.0052547622,
-0.0006522393,
0.0284315683,
0.049749013,
0.0171407871,
0.0014908097,
-0.0472766347,
0.00429034,
-0.0027808419,
-0.0505810231,
0.0915537924,
-0.0326386504,
-0.0576625578,
0.0075202612,
0.0283635277,
-0.0097411685,
-0.0202760957,
0.0715056732,
-0.0554161817,
-0.0289955027,
-0.1054929718,
-0.0106890639,
-0.0068492251,
0.0230403338,
-0.0114810662,
0.0070708296,
0.0458750315,
0.0224737842,
-0.0147816017,
-0.0271113403,
-0.1020061523,
-0.039018333,
0.030967677,
-0.0175749268,
-0.053596884,
-0.0418606102,
-0.0116040846,
0.0117839342,
-0.0441531241,
0.0153967487,
2.777156832e-34,
0.0403114334,
-0.0195428766,
0.026499832,
0.038439434,
-0.0132083381,
-0.0184705183,
0.0086306157,
0.0235507935,
-0.0285672043,
-0.06334389,
-0.0003897473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08027v1 | Exploring Large Language Models for Multi-Modal Out-of-Distribution Detection | 2023-10-12T04:14:28 | 2023-10-12T04:14:28 | Yi Dai, Hao Lang, Kaisheng Zeng, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is essential for reliable and trustworthy
machine learning. Recent multi-modal OOD detection leverages textual
information from in-distribution (ID) class names for visual OOD detection, yet
it currently neglects the rich contextual information of ID classes. Large
language models (LLMs) encode a wealth of world knowledge and can be prompted
to generate descriptive features for each class. Indiscriminately using such
knowledge causes catastrophic damage to OOD detection due to LLMs'
hallucinations, as is observed by our analysis. In this paper, we propose to
apply world knowledge to enhance OOD detection performance through selective
generation from LLMs. Specifically, we introduce a consistency-based
uncertainty calibration method to estimate the confidence score of each
generation. We further extract visual objects from each image to fully
capitalize on the aforementioned world knowledge. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our method consistently outperforms the state-of-the-art. | [
0.0092101917,
0.0793373063,
0.0390755832,
0.0885720924,
-0.004236578,
0.0208689868,
-0.0250961725,
0.0551798902,
-0.0151437493,
-0.0626156479,
0.0193988364,
-0.0596941039,
0.0119842347,
0.0172067303,
0.0208839644,
-0.0305920094,
0.0001072147,
-0.0766992122,
-0.0243966226,
0.0016615161,
-0.004339024,
-0.0083727511,
0.0189621989,
0.0256808288,
-0.0491399504,
-0.031830214,
-0.0063716411,
0.0390284732,
0.0284808893,
-0.0114887441,
-0.0200363304,
0.0356168449,
0.0345855616,
0.0174490158,
0.0000021138,
-0.0341223739,
-0.0127820829,
0.0060317791,
0.0284660142,
-0.0053319926,
0.0324667506,
-0.0158500765,
-0.0061092037,
0.0005798544,
0.0027988607,
0.0438300222,
0.081617482,
0.0425533503,
0.012226508,
0.0693004131,
-0.0234625917,
0.0356618427,
0.0167534649,
0.0061265342,
0.0217340961,
-0.0380436555,
0.0295763016,
0.0010607213,
-0.0487782583,
-0.0010152154,
-0.0286411922,
0.005991193,
-0.0025139826,
0.0060081114,
-0.0543541834,
0.0204795208,
-0.0176832061,
0.0006741419,
-0.0126501722,
0.0560473278,
-0.069222793,
-0.0073048649,
-0.0082123885,
-0.0233187042,
0.0074923071,
0.0374467783,
0.0011878813,
0.0776428655,
-0.0302975606,
0.0426540524,
-0.0323820487,
0.0298246108,
0.0178257432,
0.004298606,
-0.0402033143,
0.0156238731,
0.0128867291,
0.0093893493,
-0.0275953114,
0.0140734008,
-0.0809124336,
-0.0406552218,
-0.0221409686,
0.0102208564,
0.0018335031,
-0.0130107645,
-0.0783913806,
-0.0002897221,
0.0087567,
-0.0513644777,
0.0497014672,
-0.0132907331,
-0.0779311135,
0.0375839993,
0.0056870561,
0.0481531881,
-0.02442961,
0.0265619289,
-0.0402088165,
-0.0123461131,
-0.0187302642,
0.0210803691,
0.006125554,
-0.0023841916,
-0.0400505587,
-0.0391082801,
-0.0082080932,
0.0216609091,
-0.0329972506,
0.0252055787,
-0.0496456474,
0.0290983245,
-0.0154895885,
-0.0216303114,
0.0097214505,
0.0049351426,
0.0528154187,
-0.0196735766,
-0.0320321769,
-0.0750113726,
-0.0159231313,
0.0742436573,
-0.0213266369,
0.0243328009,
-0.0094286585,
0.0730782673,
-0.003458078,
-0.0497446805,
-0.0307695549,
-0.0502692461,
-0.0677555799,
-0.0334143676,
0.0053376528,
-0.0822919458,
-0.0629147068,
-0.0012135763,
0.0316510834,
-0.039877262,
0.054709509,
0.0062745847,
-0.0407121554,
0.0283817574,
-0.0478638336,
0.0172130186,
-0.01426211,
0.0036850753,
0.0309914891,
0.0971763283,
0.0165940654,
0.025487043,
0.0448215082,
0.0335771441,
0.0978089273,
0.0560383871,
-0.0245735552,
0.0444312878,
-0.0564423054,
-0.0262091961,
0.0077988156,
-0.0309182927,
0.047688961,
0.0232165158,
-0.005492474,
-0.0292490982,
0.0657532588,
-0.0197781101,
-0.0258680154,
-0.0493649058,
0.015963139,
0.0207273625,
-0.0545055009,
0.0214724187,
-0.0454885177,
0.0056663523,
-0.0354141928,
-0.0091047948,
-0.0209137294,
0.0354587659,
-0.0191126391,
-0.0121690538,
-0.0244394895,
-0.0286330041,
-0.0309902765,
0.032993909,
0.0686535314,
0.0064854268,
-0.0165259633,
0.0481684133,
0.0316996388,
-0.0025873042,
-0.0115216412,
-0.0500934646,
0.0164875537,
0.0278986376,
0.0400990583,
-0.0215853006,
0.0232438203,
-0.0138063533,
0.0173245519,
0.0138727855,
-0.0521168448,
0.0188646857,
0.0485233702,
-0.0352847017,
-0.0481225103,
-0.0033300603,
0.0295603797,
0.0001959301,
-0.003055295,
0.0033891094,
0.0257679299,
-0.0762705058,
-0.0153029403,
0.0376259759,
0.05623772,
-0.0142871058,
-0.0065682963,
0.0149237169,
0.0109565239,
-0.0163110606,
-0.0308797117,
-0.0025942142,
0.0279970188,
-0.0309177153,
0.0005467546,
-0.0123474831,
-0.0277282782,
-0.0213815067,
0.0394682996,
-0.0259376578,
-0.0166441891,
-0.0166723989,
-0.0402449667,
0.004428328,
-0.0095580341,
-0.043639347,
-0.0017814556,
-0.0568255708,
0.0160773769,
0.0005056302,
0.0416443497,
-0.0148784472,
0.0894861892,
-0.0470282137,
-0.0164305661,
0.0467762016,
0.0245135985,
0.0352669097,
-0.0171067286,
-0.0011470587,
0.0160166174,
-0.038318757,
0.0247064922,
0.0005371357,
0.0296121668,
-0.0045657344,
-0.0330655575,
-0.0607929267,
-0.0340500586,
-0.0385816768,
-0.0359049141,
0.0208684914,
-0.0148902442,
-0.0101430658,
-0.032974273,
-0.006129411,
0.0203807224,
0.0140411695,
-0.0021288402,
0.0053933668,
-0.0238300506,
-0.0364205129,
0.0385980159,
0.0165847037,
0.0255563781,
0.0896011591,
-0.0104562854,
-0.0422975086,
-0.1032326072,
0.0349658839,
-0.0318058282,
0.0570108853,
-0.0218863208,
-0.0022994569,
-0.022332564,
-0.0046600546,
0.0239427779,
0.0479696989,
0.0280935597,
-0.0072108689,
0.0779170617,
-0.0393197052,
0.0070700557,
-0.030640617,
0.0028756403,
-0.0460402295,
0.0070792842,
-0.0263084974,
0.0206882991,
0.0117539512,
0.0124377934,
0.0008382726,
-0.0064351242,
-0.0144552086,
-0.0134126274,
-0.0400808901,
-0.0461252332,
-0.0252487492,
-0.0142814033,
0.0530446172,
-0.0123078665,
-0.0491187274,
0.0383101217,
-0.0465360507,
0.0149400886,
0.0236853454,
-0.0007468816,
0.0011212067,
0.0292200074,
0.0156609491,
0.0465476401,
0.0264062528,
-0.0272859111,
-0.0412391201,
-0.039984744,
0.0093542524,
-0.01540937,
0.0508645289,
-0.0604976676,
0.0025054982,
0.0047657518,
-0.0328232385,
-0.0581876449,
-0.0833371282,
0.0053899698,
-0.0158431046,
-0.0612335391,
-0.0420603827,
-0.0287585035,
0.0450588688,
-0.0166046489,
0.0258898865,
-0.0178254284,
-0.0082502756,
-0.0136303753,
0.0746043101,
0.067437999,
-0.0223163944,
-0.0028352439,
-0.0542194545,
-0.0312307328,
0.0751422048,
0.0124359028,
0.0347789004,
-0.0220135469,
0.0147719812,
0.0440033749,
0.0682971254,
-0.0152977407,
0.0661915466,
0.0524391867,
-0.0231507681,
-0.0336549245,
0.0741010904,
0.0106706442,
-0.053265471,
-0.0031138193,
-0.01056193,
0.0266665537,
0.0259582829,
-0.0188088212,
-0.0843924657,
-0.0460028723,
0.0089804651,
-0.0015223915,
-0.02370397,
-0.0131854583,
0.0172272585,
-0.0939713717,
0.0635104626,
0.0200452395,
-0.0388665423,
-0.0642221645,
0.024056172,
0.0121128876,
-0.0005731803,
0.0000750023,
0.0049015982,
0.0034599893,
-0.0210210234,
0.0131959757,
0.0158614274,
-0.0621463917,
0.0121525303,
-0.0562328175,
0.0104742078,
0.0575458296,
-0.0020522128,
-0.0105650853,
-0.061006248,
-0.0000239194,
-0.0515537523,
0.0036918528,
0.0261872504,
0.0554903448,
-0.0214631483,
-0.0161188748,
-0.0023329838,
0.0308181457,
-0.0237654448,
-0.0337377302,
-0.0254138485,
0.0225038007,
-0.0198624693,
-0.0365815312,
-0.0344897099,
0.0019805785,
0.0536360815,
0.042593576,
-0.014391792,
-0.0284426101,
-0.0087687792,
-0.0234407242,
0.0024141043,
0.0501828641,
0.0523854494,
0.0496910028,
0.0161632579,
-0.0876078755,
-0.0625737235,
0.030320935,
-0.0209281631,
0.0307390783,
0.0056347772,
-0.0051115882,
-0.0093499962,
0.005510231,
-0.0600376725,
0.0247505046,
-0.0421552323,
0.0124990474,
-0.0067341328,
0.0669089258,
0.0279834345,
-0.0171918217,
-0.0293666292,
0.0962495804,
-0.0715749487,
-0.0410546586,
-0.0039459709,
0.0353152156,
0.0166773405,
0.034465082,
-0.0234409347,
-0.0188163836,
0.053848777,
0.0596235767,
0.0410541594,
0.01772663,
0.014515629,
-0.0313121118,
0.0096981674,
0.0277654845,
-0.0259595718,
0.0088968175,
0.0468311906,
-0.0530660264,
-0.0528503917,
-0.0348039009,
0.033795476,
-0.022623593,
0.0392363593,
-0.0436532125,
-0.0143370032,
-0.0121498611,
-0.0033042198,
-0.0065715387,
-0.0430819057,
-0.0429785736,
0.0674360543,
0.0390342437,
-0.0256711021,
0.027226286,
0.0374851599,
-0.0049253791,
0.0150588704,
-0.0013540729,
-0.0498685762,
0.0559958704,
-0.0195671115,
0.025841441,
-0.0071587213,
0.0129117779,
0.0150783258,
0.0063484358,
0.0153564373,
0.0066238348,
0.0999738351,
0.023689257,
-0.0365231037,
-0.0196692068,
-0.0047547687,
0.0075212363,
0.0086536519,
-0.0786773264,
0.0685086548,
0.0506435633,
-0.0153783131,
0.0254056491,
-0.0327932909,
0.0050043566,
-0.0394217335,
0.0577996336,
0.0028135588,
-0.0419200994,
0.0122129442,
0.0150396125,
-0.0439567678,
0.0160222705,
0.0739728138,
0.0290405769,
0.004772373,
-0.0080928039,
-0.0419375561,
-0.0417929403,
0.0284207352,
0.0639256909,
0.0334767327,
-0.0178553984,
0.0450466014,
-0.0318627395,
-0.0566673093,
0.0043300819,
0.0009317184,
0.0233963095,
0.0468287654,
0.0107711274,
0.0838730931,
-0.0082949717,
-0.0230290312,
-0.0316109806,
-0.0517871007,
-0.0012743953,
-0.0028447926,
-0.0100441156,
-6.269388918e-33,
-0.016426038,
-0.0780086964,
-0.0298719648,
-0.0361176804,
0.0233614221,
0.0137171736,
0.0027289803,
0.0201086458,
0.010813891,
0.0213033464,
0.0157244969,
0.011038512,
0.0191380717,
0.0467083715,
-0.0121235317,
-0.0173197053,
0.0190484338,
0.0198522005,
-0.0338685028,
-0.009473959,
0.0654932335,
0.0118406219,
0.0600502491,
-0.0975691229,
0.0042087683,
-0.0091948081,
-0.0754798353,
0.0058092475,
0.0331036225,
0.034323141,
-0.0283435695,
0.0390192904,
0.0262738187,
0.0310196467,
-0.0119237639,
0.002159518,
-0.0033660436,
0.0128434598,
-0.0252635814,
0.0171846524,
-0.0041884934,
0.0041390695,
0.0364470147,
-0.0181800332,
-0.0077929702,
-0.0210961569,
0.0558465496,
-0.052251026,
-0.0090066167,
0.0102015762,
-0.0576927364,
0.0214788802,
0.0038753992,
-0.0551878996,
0.0113989972,
0.0031508373,
0.0256171413,
-0.0137741081,
-0.005446224,
0.009335178,
0.000147495,
0.0188658144,
0.0612017624,
0.0467458107,
-0.0156738255,
0.077904664,
-0.027904531,
-0.0319263563,
-0.0248383544,
-0.0454907753,
0.0245786645,
0.0876714736,
0.0126464535,
0.0822140276,
0.0356427431,
0.0128629226,
-0.0712763146,
0.0185967125,
-0.0719789863,
-0.0008572922,
0.0430804119,
-0.0180596001,
-0.052874174,
-0.0211595055,
-0.0164789706,
-0.0386795066,
-0.0268340372,
0.0162536912,
0.036247436,
0.037555974,
-0.0362428799,
0.0102424147,
0.0457730256,
-0.0462935679,
-0.0149526829,
0.0078058429,
-0.0328135453,
0.0231340919,
-0.0121088149,
-0.0008943679,
0.0195937492,
-0.0350583456,
0.0565743372,
-0.0250282008,
-0.0227711964,
0.0094317729,
0.055233825,
0.0324783139,
-0.0701378509,
0.0042172978,
-0.0407427587,
0.0206513815,
0.0074956939,
0.0744305402,
0.0380314291,
-0.0360779949,
-0.0296690036,
0.0166542605,
-0.0001487259,
0.0110012898,
0.0033411763,
-0.0102360249,
-0.0230028257,
0.0194340292,
-0.0386789925,
0.007536998,
-0.0127630616,
-0.0722575337,
0.049805481,
-0.0244308785,
-0.0075108018,
0.0005559833,
2.827e-7,
0.0112464726,
0.0266115703,
-0.0072652386,
0.002029828,
0.0079596769,
0.0629817694,
-0.0160344429,
0.0208443198,
-0.0013046396,
-0.0953535512,
0.0017177502,
0.0043367627,
0.0435684323,
0.0162649993,
-0.0566282906,
0.0272785276,
0.0140038934,
-0.013097696,
-0.0401321836,
-0.0171193704,
0.021828657,
0.101806283,
0.0184365846,
-0.0609267578,
0.0689644068,
-0.10034924,
0.0685116053,
-0.0050555361,
-0.0060496824,
-0.00888885,
0.0259219073,
0.0315233208,
0.0500741862,
0.0602623969,
0.0047417125,
-0.023563711,
0.0280268602,
0.0476662517,
-0.0030978394,
-0.0084741144,
-0.0460720472,
0.0388180241,
0.0035403203,
-0.0569799878,
0.0507678986,
0.0098748654,
-0.0191485398,
-0.0653311238,
-0.0076605468,
-0.0501014665,
0.0327190235,
-0.0234865602,
0.0074216607,
0.024447931,
0.040616028,
0.0247304551,
-0.0268396921,
-0.0367529429,
-0.0298628081,
-0.0060637831,
-0.0344877616,
-0.031364087,
0.0224201027,
-0.0146533381,
0.0495412499,
-0.0625822991,
-0.0162193552,
2.808539546e-34,
0.0115578724,
0.0030747487,
-0.0230529662,
0.0035159057,
0.0253659505,
0.0223897193,
-0.013701723,
-0.0053842645,
-0.0448603928,
-0.005924629,
0.0145749245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.08017v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.08017v1 | Harnessing Large Language Models' Empathetic Response Generation Capabilities for Online Mental Health Counselling Support | 2023-10-12T03:33:06 | 2023-10-12T03:33:06 | Siyuan Brandon Loh, Aravind Sesagiri Raamkumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2 | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
various information-seeking and reasoning tasks. These computational systems
drive state-of-the-art dialogue systems, such as ChatGPT and Bard. They also
carry substantial promise in meeting the growing demands of mental health care,
albeit relatively unexplored. As such, this study sought to examine LLMs'
capability to generate empathetic responses in conversations that emulate those
in a mental health counselling setting. We selected five LLMs: version 3.5 and
version 4 of the Generative Pre-training (GPT), Vicuna FastChat-T5, Pathways
Language Model (PaLM) version 2, and Falcon-7B-Instruct. Based on a simple
instructional prompt, these models responded to utterances derived from the
EmpatheticDialogues (ED) dataset. Using three empathy-related metrics, we
compared their responses to those from traditional response generation dialogue
systems, which were fine-tuned on the ED dataset, along with human-generated
responses. Notably, we discovered that responses from the LLMs were remarkably
more empathetic in most scenarios. We position our findings in light of
catapulting advancements in creating empathetic conversational systems. | [
0.0743093863,
0.0198438037,
-0.040807914,
0.0142645231,
-0.0156029733,
0.0402011462,
0.0386654437,
-0.0073772599,
0.0544402786,
-0.0146630546,
-0.0216517411,
-0.0334744602,
-0.0316533409,
0.0172643699,
0.0090382081,
-0.0883859396,
0.0118314056,
0.0201547388,
0.0603233501,
-0.0127990674,
0.0027452449,
0.0475821905,
-0.0462911911,
0.0726639554,
-0.0125687504,
-0.0301084612,
-0.0110078519,
0.0403714888,
0.0099454205,
-0.0577430129,
0.0432391539,
0.0363209769,
-0.0191528946,
0.0187576488,
0.0000021563,
-0.0269799624,
0.0166901629,
-0.0125179449,
-0.0214494523,
-0.0139498776,
0.0604625903,
-0.0426393636,
-0.0146285435,
0.0490554087,
-0.0273405518,
-0.0567709208,
0.0430571809,
0.0286393408,
0.0693385676,
0.0545347929,
-0.0312657468,
-0.0061727422,
0.0144422418,
-0.0191132948,
-0.0504187532,
-0.0033220819,
-0.004897377,
0.0198662113,
0.0319770016,
-0.0299971905,
-0.0076639978,
0.0363008082,
-0.0155557944,
-0.011305728,
-0.0002760402,
0.0227398127,
-0.0074364841,
-0.0453089587,
-0.008656634,
0.1074436381,
0.037419185,
0.0522192791,
0.0076226187,
-0.0159902424,
0.0038521085,
-0.0148242069,
-0.041313976,
0.0272312369,
-0.0111296875,
-0.00348522,
-0.0038502649,
-0.0039194212,
-0.0100770574,
0.0056447745,
0.0307505112,
0.0114220642,
0.0106782224,
-0.0064587104,
-0.0099865217,
-0.0039062346,
-0.0372610204,
-0.0579746924,
0.0071158148,
0.0613493994,
-0.0691563562,
0.022608282,
-0.0291648842,
0.0113530774,
0.0349460393,
-0.0228543263,
0.0405421928,
0.0713360012,
-0.0151790315,
-0.0255977865,
0.0400845557,
0.0145211909,
0.0188087691,
0.0241658203,
-0.0309128966,
0.0224172957,
-0.0452242717,
-0.0165484659,
-0.0425142236,
0.0023137364,
-0.0460767634,
-0.0172460079,
-0.0699423179,
0.0331737213,
0.0062958584,
-0.0231078435,
0.0012998214,
-0.0184457563,
-0.0267970599,
-0.0005269468,
-0.0366829596,
0.0298788734,
-0.0482629836,
0.0068841665,
0.0141708953,
-0.099661462,
0.0210236236,
0.0147192795,
-0.017738644,
-0.0336226895,
0.0142122759,
0.0560770184,
-0.0008867752,
-0.0248708297,
-0.0293289423,
-0.0110853361,
-0.0421188734,
-0.0617302842,
0.0058282698,
-0.0144281192,
0.0321524888,
0.0208549779,
0.0040716119,
0.0051900391,
0.0401360951,
0.0045102756,
-0.0736247599,
0.0494635291,
-0.0174813569,
0.0446683057,
0.047769092,
0.0125556625,
-0.0030069535,
0.0391739421,
-0.0031606171,
-0.0078082765,
0.0266268998,
-0.0284110401,
0.0072507239,
0.0184625164,
-0.0227695089,
-0.0346619748,
-0.0056062355,
-0.0052672052,
-0.0427309908,
0.0555345416,
0.0252278205,
0.0505591445,
-0.0503912121,
-0.0184399448,
0.0628250465,
0.0925270617,
0.0187088698,
0.0748071447,
0.0341666341,
0.0267772581,
-0.0021096296,
-0.0201633368,
-0.056717094,
0.0230066869,
0.0014425924,
-0.0103820087,
0.0152188437,
0.0136027467,
-0.0377534181,
-0.0487628803,
-0.0212910101,
-0.0180045236,
-0.01245894,
0.0063011399,
-0.0172817763,
-0.0155898258,
-0.0280532967,
0.0200961735,
0.0369784422,
-0.060951855,
-0.0591103025,
-0.0570958294,
0.0014543494,
0.1220428571,
0.0491143838,
-0.0153704714,
-0.062877655,
-0.0075133322,
-0.0253192149,
0.0580707788,
0.0391190685,
-0.0013630234,
0.0377486758,
-0.0461883806,
0.0236272532,
0.014311512,
-0.0096414331,
0.0157702584,
-0.0163125638,
0.0210361816,
-0.020804612,
0.0242768675,
-0.0148555953,
0.034500435,
-0.0412746556,
-0.0160243399,
0.0192887262,
-0.0070248665,
0.0394267403,
0.0118260551,
-0.0144600207,
0.0123415468,
0.0024151693,
-0.0105592897,
-0.0327542648,
0.0469008647,
-0.0640463755,
-0.0690869242,
0.0407617725,
-0.0040881317,
0.0143124126,
-0.0002157304,
-0.0076425369,
-0.0174243804,
0.0465585738,
-0.0456109717,
0.0265204087,
-0.0519169606,
0.0299550034,
0.0032643331,
0.0194891654,
-0.0235737693,
0.0147980489,
-0.005533597,
0.0170919467,
0.0199242886,
0.0045320131,
-0.0255717728,
-0.0410272926,
-0.0052273055,
0.0336836018,
-0.0150851337,
-0.0105177099,
-0.0326253772,
0.0293151494,
-0.0506019853,
-0.0483255163,
-0.1659703851,
0.0081977649,
-0.0053170426,
-0.0140257543,
0.0258992054,
-0.0070831175,
-0.0434485413,
-0.0091893207,
-0.0574331209,
0.0421013609,
0.0636905208,
0.0128579121,
0.0105295917,
0.0052988417,
-0.0087184897,
-0.0621683709,
-0.0105362507,
-0.0220192298,
0.0201310571,
-0.0219481923,
0.0177894942,
-0.0313578621,
-0.0013123822,
-0.0590920486,
0.0060546077,
-0.0137526589,
-0.0883364528,
0.0111113274,
-0.0036774618,
0.040090315,
0.0157117452,
0.0352702178,
0.0522327721,
-0.01462333,
-0.0103399558,
-0.0621459261,
0.0462339595,
-0.025815608,
-0.0279708337,
-0.0530043617,
-0.0610282905,
-0.0166729055,
0.0554411113,
0.0256749615,
0.0263554137,
-0.0585206039,
-0.0100929197,
0.0333091542,
-0.0273941066,
-0.0065170685,
-0.0047502988,
-0.003145488,
-0.0152381333,
0.0059862714,
-0.0418904983,
0.0624365918,
0.0013236002,
-0.0441331901,
-0.0547126085,
-0.0263072401,
-0.0147304423,
0.0334707648,
-0.0201311689,
0.0368305556,
0.0236088242,
-0.0245207995,
0.0081246616,
-0.0197629277,
0.0020509476,
-0.0464883111,
0.0111030797,
-0.0346395299,
-0.021130573,
0.0203581378,
-0.0132965613,
-0.0503437705,
-0.0348663703,
-0.0187067408,
-0.0189944357,
0.0304252189,
0.0110721653,
-0.0083235018,
-0.0120056858,
0.0292096939,
0.0415617153,
-0.0207824167,
-0.035658028,
-0.0103017958,
0.0131482817,
0.0259123147,
-0.0070960922,
0.0467178486,
-0.0303139109,
0.1029918715,
0.0452875532,
0.010336047,
0.008887805,
0.0343334414,
0.0068358495,
0.0039910134,
0.0227685831,
-0.0002512057,
0.0172291584,
0.0580682084,
-0.0042159716,
-0.0375071205,
0.1370262355,
0.0220631398,
-0.0426039174,
0.0235281456,
-0.0518220402,
0.0126772393,
0.0019349636,
-0.0024692409,
-0.0461376943,
-0.0233412273,
-0.0218201987,
0.0586959422,
-0.0459055305,
-0.0239658598,
0.0129911192,
-0.0794618279,
0.0512564406,
0.0048017995,
0.0158473756,
0.0056280121,
0.011612081,
0.0006672576,
0.0383227989,
0.0258915219,
-0.0156914908,
0.0087834755,
-0.0087398272,
0.0158300921,
-0.0336129107,
-0.0089183925,
0.029845275,
-0.0125595117,
0.098515071,
0.0239934735,
0.0730475485,
0.0105143888,
-0.0022920144,
-0.0009388555,
0.0448706299,
0.0127008045,
0.0074652312,
0.0579834729,
0.0184203517,
0.0153971091,
-0.0341306925,
0.0567328259,
-0.0390404835,
-0.0011761014,
0.0150729567,
0.0490199402,
-0.0330885984,
-0.0018751717,
-0.0260152239,
0.0583841875,
0.052827727,
0.0585470013,
0.0372390263,
-0.0584763959,
-0.0326491445,
0.0103803063,
0.043095924,
0.0052711861,
-0.0258251019,
0.0167260338,
0.0058373739,
-0.0078259017,
-0.0698689818,
-0.085223265,
0.0035571561,
-0.0082658902,
-0.0306823775,
-0.0525153652,
0.0200800672,
0.0318922438,
-0.0184973627,
0.0342257656,
0.0013990088,
0.0341826081,
-0.0477809235,
-0.0000455944,
0.0210260656,
-0.0295906086,
-0.0004260707,
0.0374434367,
-0.0121966768,
-0.0488258265,
0.0060784719,
0.0553733669,
0.0157108437,
-0.0086239139,
0.016752135,
-0.0322967544,
-0.0109223574,
0.0419314727,
-0.0479702055,
-0.0037649921,
0.0236557312,
0.0723573938,
-0.0059773838,
0.0362481475,
0.01211177,
0.079177022,
0.0316488594,
0.0574635565,
0.0350039229,
-0.0699281245,
-0.0074789003,
0.0432934873,
0.0089579513,
-0.002322813,
-0.0417276286,
0.0051191701,
-0.0146739194,
-0.0472365245,
0.015639225,
-0.0410750732,
-0.0224672556,
0.0092319036,
0.0007552955,
-0.0152328527,
-0.0936735272,
-0.0623198189,
0.0022214891,
-0.0452116914,
-0.0038608094,
-0.0294507965,
-0.0070574945,
0.0090556238,
0.002595115,
-0.0207803715,
0.0377138406,
-0.0134361302,
0.0215788744,
-0.0243184641,
0.1290100515,
-0.0123334173,
-0.0210099146,
0.0277369842,
0.0291577391,
-0.0279801693,
-0.0952902436,
-0.0314845257,
0.0295909997,
0.0620615706,
0.0423463322,
0.0436918847,
-0.0348001048,
0.021970015,
-0.0222909041,
0.0295885783,
0.0024398102,
-0.0358748622,
0.012102617,
0.0025836299,
-0.0263584517,
-0.0186496414,
0.036480993,
-0.0463198125,
0.0454031155,
0.0109587694,
-0.0165492333,
-0.0348333046,
-0.032594353,
0.022164803,
0.0039238278,
-0.0199849773,
0.0236435737,
-0.0630465448,
-0.0472767279,
0.0079607349,
-0.0167807508,
-0.0223075468,
-0.0639260933,
0.017988706,
0.0332165584,
-0.0016527472,
-0.0126390373,
-0.0415293686,
0.0700134486,
-0.0597524047,
-0.0088970698,
-0.032059323,
-6.03762037e-33,
-0.0042591887,
0.0011461566,
-0.0029398643,
-0.0069438876,
-0.0443690456,
-0.0164614376,
-0.0430033207,
0.0340481177,
-0.006659186,
0.0349534787,
-0.0059072021,
0.0577216484,
0.000574715,
0.0383796617,
-0.0080129206,
-0.0108631477,
0.0244428813,
-0.0158132948,
-0.0176636167,
0.064764224,
-0.0035314776,
0.0539003387,
0.0205638297,
-0.080194667,
0.0162117481,
-0.0220289081,
0.0137498695,
0.0228315555,
0.0296247285,
0.0393322222,
-0.0517773777,
0.0649564266,
0.0262233876,
-0.0055543506,
0.0079070413,
0.0150194801,
-0.0268964563,
0.0013887115,
0.0169846509,
-0.0267346613,
-0.063310422,
-0.0381825306,
0.014267114,
-0.0070425798,
-0.0219537336,
-0.0342304222,
-0.0012375036,
-0.0279726759,
0.0184893012,
-0.0256608315,
-0.0445314832,
-0.0112380516,
-0.0402333736,
-0.0388870016,
-0.0373808369,
0.0717670992,
-0.0398283154,
0.0129608382,
-0.0072196075,
0.0149981063,
0.0066345027,
-0.0245141871,
0.0097501818,
-0.0337991901,
-0.0127090532,
0.0649291947,
0.0145672159,
0.0081776967,
-0.024832841,
0.0035491693,
-0.0094611086,
0.0412642583,
0.0379729867,
0.0538620129,
-0.0347516164,
-0.0365052074,
-0.0273395553,
0.0122766197,
0.0459823757,
-0.0039836233,
0.0529432595,
0.0008576083,
-0.0383278392,
-0.0083201975,
-0.0463096797,
-0.0393897742,
-0.017026674,
-0.0424293913,
0.0379666463,
-0.0109347412,
-0.0008687861,
-0.0573057607,
0.0056388774,
-0.0270582475,
0.0182279684,
0.025720777,
-0.0114634922,
0.0339628235,
-0.0138527555,
0.0273025446,
-0.0242110714,
-0.0148372138,
0.0173371546,
0.0000226353,
0.0380369462,
-0.0013951223,
-0.0057885335,
-0.02102747,
-0.0381688401,
0.005969414,
-0.0187744386,
0.0806219876,
-0.018476814,
0.0193127692,
-0.0406509899,
0.0038976234,
-0.0195675027,
0.0200525504,
0.006454973,
0.0043002618,
-0.0723688081,
-0.0529446118,
0.0164042488,
0.0247152857,
-0.0443942621,
-0.0036070633,
-0.0228617042,
-0.0047943094,
0.0473372638,
-0.0305696987,
-0.0265178289,
-0.0065297936,
2.811e-7,
0.004264174,
0.0613798946,
0.0170141365,
-0.0078953207,
0.0411258787,
0.0440640301,
0.0217050947,
0.0575127825,
0.0643610805,
-0.0133004328,
0.008108411,
0.0356855392,
0.0759271309,
0.0478917994,
-0.024007095,
-0.016829066,
-0.0651727989,
-0.0348113552,
-0.0492241606,
0.0220983233,
0.0961036161,
0.0512680262,
-0.0065862373,
-0.0330131724,
0.0191939566,
0.023882227,
0.0266880058,
-0.0759370252,
-0.0159839001,
0.0462767519,
0.0125502264,
-0.0087266816,
0.0412644632,
-0.0020545137,
0.0168587826,
0.0069344323,
-0.0152532272,
0.0982935205,
-0.0190049205,
-0.0380147919,
0.0363251083,
0.0309095494,
0.0159772504,
-0.067477569,
0.0247165021,
-0.0908279493,
-0.0342604443,
-0.011294798,
-0.0114128208,
-0.0511401072,
0.0150705297,
-0.0543631762,
-0.0387768,
0.0693872571,
0.0346308611,
-0.012715932,
0.0291037876,
-0.0523181073,
0.0040450101,
0.0313458927,
-0.0717658177,
-0.0532128289,
-0.0199851263,
0.0077213966,
0.0045103515,
-0.0389832705,
0.028303951,
2.259817176e-34,
0.0145313703,
0.037902195,
0.0318108089,
0.0382382348,
0.0508363172,
0.0188295189,
0.023788251,
0.0237519257,
0.0105327638,
-0.096784018,
-0.0150828809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07968v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07968v4 | Think, Act, and Ask: Open-World Interactive Personalized Robot Navigation | 2023-10-12T01:17:56 | 2024-05-29T21:06:18 | Yinpei Dai, Run Peng, Sikai Li, Joyce Chai | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.HC | Zero-Shot Object Navigation (ZSON) enables agents to navigate towards
open-vocabulary objects in unknown environments. The existing works of ZSON
mainly focus on following individual instructions to find generic object
classes, neglecting the utilization of natural language interaction and the
complexities of identifying user-specific objects. To address these
limitations, we introduce Zero-shot Interactive Personalized Object Navigation
(ZIPON), where robots need to navigate to personalized goal objects while
engaging in conversations with users. To solve ZIPON, we propose a new
framework termed Open-woRld Interactive persOnalized Navigation (ORION), which
uses Large Language Models (LLMs) to make sequential decisions to manipulate
different modules for perception, navigation and communication. Experimental
results show that the performance of interactive agents that can leverage user
feedback exhibits significant improvement. However, obtaining a good balance
between task completion and the efficiency of navigation and interaction
remains challenging for all methods. We further provide more findings on the
impact of diverse user feedback forms on the agents' performance. Code is
available at https://github.com/sled-group/navchat. | [
0.0541717559,
0.014482866,
0.0133893024,
0.0116675692,
-0.0238319039,
-0.0137464106,
-0.0069268625,
-0.025977198,
0.0208726786,
-0.0583647527,
-0.044341214,
0.0061075105,
-0.0292304773,
0.0339422747,
-0.0208463948,
-0.0674326196,
0.0440033153,
-0.0665761009,
-0.0033275743,
0.0262391418,
-0.0329959691,
-0.0192013215,
-0.0429953113,
0.0899236873,
0.0407172255,
-0.009828506,
-0.0652828366,
0.0057251817,
0.0061111357,
-0.0503721796,
-0.007898313,
0.0486375429,
0.0565480068,
0.0219727643,
0.0000021175,
-0.0372589901,
0.0317009538,
-0.0317768194,
-0.0348646715,
-0.0319286399,
0.0595627353,
0.0471002832,
0.0086163534,
0.0167222526,
-0.0107750576,
-0.0371450856,
0.0378316455,
0.0474223197,
0.0538249835,
0.03457563,
0.0107158506,
-0.002909509,
-0.0177272763,
0.0175767206,
0.0445047095,
-0.051569052,
0.0023401936,
0.0049120323,
0.0357162952,
0.0382019766,
-0.0060024271,
-0.0007237948,
0.0235118326,
-0.017715767,
0.0336736888,
0.0654772222,
-0.0000243517,
-0.058701545,
-0.0196135007,
0.0917192921,
0.0028026535,
0.0167643633,
-0.0211146679,
0.0004706314,
-0.0032272832,
-0.0209100284,
-0.0471858345,
0.0189103335,
-0.0149987955,
-0.0184732899,
-0.0540512167,
-0.0007340452,
0.0003832096,
0.0216444004,
-0.026402371,
0.0750113428,
0.0136379292,
0.012549825,
0.0085959099,
-0.0188161209,
-0.0175760556,
-0.0825633556,
0.0205506813,
0.0635009632,
-0.0649860427,
0.0285004154,
-0.0379554331,
0.0257112123,
-0.0144028328,
-0.0532660708,
0.0435075425,
0.0372338966,
-0.0372661389,
0.0360261388,
0.0178834517,
0.036446631,
-0.0181962401,
-0.0000613357,
-0.0339800939,
-0.0127679268,
-0.0463550389,
0.0401975997,
-0.0290610436,
0.0460810624,
-0.0444149189,
-0.0576695502,
0.0199962743,
0.089944154,
0.0115829026,
0.0315012634,
-0.0486345589,
0.0288078543,
-0.0339207016,
0.0086149154,
-0.0629699603,
0.0036683856,
-0.0495179668,
-0.0130801704,
0.0018338652,
0.0010776008,
0.0272404011,
0.03481327,
0.0122819226,
-0.0092806676,
-0.0288519505,
0.0998278931,
-0.0021684482,
-0.0656500235,
-0.020883685,
-0.0191527214,
0.0268969107,
-0.0468855649,
-0.0178772695,
-0.0477465726,
-0.0001452995,
0.0157620702,
-0.0232969522,
-0.0160939172,
0.02353568,
0.0441301614,
-0.0104121836,
0.0688326508,
0.0163437407,
0.0018007932,
0.0236411598,
-0.0000621729,
0.0284180269,
0.0261992868,
0.0288081747,
0.0792878121,
0.0049869847,
0.0328588039,
0.0303066224,
0.021463532,
-0.0814569294,
-0.008647264,
0.0076299622,
0.0118400287,
-0.0024229826,
0.0621556751,
-0.0113856914,
0.0466469377,
-0.0440091603,
0.005124779,
0.0439377651,
0.0312661976,
-0.0183840841,
-0.0252550077,
0.0515064672,
0.0315200798,
0.0016152774,
-0.049941238,
-0.0254317727,
0.0417030714,
-0.0499112308,
-0.0393418111,
-0.000430719,
-0.0069444715,
-0.0200123433,
-0.0586857013,
0.0068454421,
-0.0071285358,
0.0510968566,
0.0065351757,
0.0732550845,
-0.0275891498,
-0.0480863452,
-0.0221659932,
0.01507138,
-0.0333326384,
-0.0308767837,
-0.0297376756,
0.0647006705,
0.0790484548,
0.0475502834,
0.0064097033,
-0.0528989658,
-0.0056371787,
-0.0175531823,
0.060664136,
0.0111419428,
-0.0220127832,
-0.0018656731,
0.0011887437,
-0.0490715504,
0.0332783237,
-0.0315113366,
0.033285711,
0.0137333078,
0.0182383098,
0.0009461029,
-0.0092803482,
-0.0016630407,
0.0472487919,
0.0215950161,
0.0035370565,
0.007119264,
0.0042007407,
0.0084118899,
0.0319564342,
0.0200859718,
-0.0254830364,
0.0374637097,
-0.0000301815,
-0.0281839762,
0.0072517334,
-0.0080322037,
-0.0134284906,
0.0132296635,
-0.0034898103,
0.0083152829,
0.0376415364,
0.0112481331,
-0.0251230653,
-0.0007703857,
-0.0214115269,
0.0179043282,
0.0124921435,
0.0218768064,
0.0121744517,
-0.0140614007,
-0.0457973965,
0.0297315717,
0.0047039557,
-0.0115888696,
0.0201347433,
0.0268130545,
0.0161877498,
-0.0590042248,
-0.0244859718,
0.0328746364,
0.0294269137,
-0.0107696159,
0.0694942549,
0.0158208404,
-0.0355772711,
-0.0200121514,
-0.0905970186,
-0.0106857,
-0.0152997728,
-0.0294768959,
-0.0149142323,
-0.0061589335,
0.0064567486,
-0.0188941527,
0.016936088,
0.0397525616,
-0.0070233145,
0.0018056193,
0.0322178006,
0.0322801247,
-0.0563912839,
-0.0607798994,
0.0126599064,
-0.0110462066,
0.0035012332,
0.031503763,
-0.0078961356,
-0.0622667745,
0.0090071112,
-0.0705756769,
0.0558234081,
-0.0167447012,
-0.0467665195,
0.055914592,
-0.0472257398,
0.0088539133,
0.0890616998,
-0.0043505761,
0.0460453853,
0.0704123452,
-0.0334399007,
-0.0662300065,
0.0170203503,
-0.0244905595,
-0.0301864315,
-0.0637530833,
0.0123959621,
0.0476694182,
0.0332257226,
-0.0333207697,
0.0112977382,
-0.0391069874,
-0.015239927,
-0.020570321,
-0.0264583696,
-0.0107457545,
0.0398461856,
-0.0237180963,
0.0503128283,
-0.001405539,
-0.0165334791,
0.0372534655,
-0.0150713287,
-0.0197828859,
-0.0032733935,
-0.0110649075,
-0.0246171262,
0.0799561068,
0.030230375,
0.0341051035,
0.0248910468,
-0.0155040529,
0.0134427072,
-0.0018743477,
-0.0272194222,
-0.0111662447,
0.0092495726,
-0.0646619722,
0.0210185591,
0.0153937759,
-0.0401054285,
-0.0458958782,
-0.0274121296,
-0.0078558614,
0.0042409333,
-0.0224364866,
-0.0652391464,
-0.0504838228,
0.0046427883,
0.0300256945,
0.0465102904,
0.0072613545,
-0.0256610364,
-0.0378993936,
-0.0491841361,
0.0496429056,
0.0421546921,
-0.0110921795,
-0.0164746866,
0.0207665171,
0.0336480401,
0.0259237364,
-0.0211336724,
-0.0527952723,
-0.0055801994,
0.0393312126,
-0.0079590855,
0.0074744029,
0.0456176735,
0.0438249782,
-0.0449312888,
-0.0171710718,
0.123536177,
0.0491211377,
-0.0369868502,
-0.0013699855,
-0.0374253988,
0.0122009665,
0.0481279865,
0.0406751521,
-0.0423513539,
-0.0463296361,
0.0166017413,
-0.0006725634,
-0.0044624414,
-0.0359926187,
-0.0043175993,
-0.1173013002,
0.021089809,
-0.0018299398,
-0.0519012511,
-0.0101353386,
0.0012887244,
0.0257047154,
-0.0164423939,
-0.0157916397,
0.0366221368,
0.0129168639,
-0.0229505822,
-0.0204337724,
0.0087110521,
-0.0103745889,
0.0188037418,
-0.0342984311,
0.0484999381,
0.0520528369,
0.0222133026,
0.0179789606,
-0.0167648736,
0.0030095452,
0.0422275886,
0.0177149083,
-0.0388858803,
0.0134860873,
-0.0438629799,
-0.0155466795,
-0.0271824803,
0.0225459021,
-0.0279960092,
-0.0321745127,
-0.0211853441,
0.0297829676,
-0.0417620763,
0.018121399,
-0.056859646,
-0.0059756245,
0.0185959097,
0.0583744422,
-0.0383285061,
-0.052392371,
-0.0619288161,
-0.0448915623,
-0.0838088095,
0.0180330109,
-0.0475542806,
0.0189012736,
-0.0273926891,
-0.0718043968,
-0.0690406784,
-0.0625591725,
0.0632444993,
0.0343864821,
0.0082776397,
-0.0187498182,
-0.0086187497,
0.022519609,
0.0168804415,
0.0279427301,
-0.0535345301,
0.015599641,
-0.0696952417,
-0.0131839076,
0.0354473889,
-0.0495031588,
-0.0133803338,
0.0126413498,
-0.0399354696,
-0.0615919493,
-0.0049902298,
0.0283384323,
0.0149459234,
0.0061804983,
-0.021879714,
-0.0600214526,
0.0007592569,
-0.0006067216,
-0.0071150381,
0.0086891437,
0.0015430435,
0.0841267407,
0.0146981534,
0.0248200707,
-0.0415942855,
-0.0077474103,
-0.0424934439,
0.0231060497,
-0.0363569558,
-0.0732868463,
0.0221610591,
0.0024633445,
0.0471462309,
0.0315456912,
0.0150219658,
0.0042666998,
0.0074089277,
-0.025489537,
-0.0154333934,
-0.0661851615,
-0.0018987824,
-0.0034358858,
0.0004625294,
0.051148098,
0.0359192006,
-0.033834435,
0.0293503702,
-0.0037782281,
-0.0100298896,
0.0235023182,
0.0042994451,
0.0211859215,
0.0218208209,
-0.0266543236,
0.0014615632,
-0.0150160417,
0.0411032848,
0.0175906513,
0.0913359076,
0.0126156677,
-0.0226030052,
-0.0513442717,
0.0341436826,
-0.0504777655,
-0.0568584874,
0.0257134922,
0.0804599151,
0.0286473054,
0.0399894565,
0.0196649041,
-0.0824471265,
0.0277165994,
-0.0204722956,
-0.0026785915,
0.014107205,
-0.0478654392,
0.0476145595,
0.0260522626,
-0.000792039,
-0.0031294075,
0.0431879424,
0.0156007521,
0.0290670525,
-0.0165748578,
-0.0134465517,
-0.0498594753,
0.0201743823,
0.0494672842,
0.0378591791,
-0.0098908236,
0.0109942509,
-0.0160710253,
-0.0028384391,
-0.0285680927,
0.04077572,
-0.0308461767,
-0.0282986704,
0.0677541122,
0.0178359523,
-0.0183154475,
-0.0685847625,
-0.040405456,
-0.0432458594,
-0.0314274915,
-0.0067635532,
-0.030198805,
-5.931659472e-33,
-0.0640159398,
-0.0559726097,
0.0516039506,
0.022424601,
-0.0287474748,
-0.0711017177,
-0.0429539904,
0.0510633886,
-0.0137996273,
-0.0181658398,
0.0093998648,
-0.01494567,
0.0018368701,
0.039230112,
0.0091242027,
-0.0161244813,
0.0587006621,
0.0186312627,
-0.0295308735,
0.000335679,
0.0329312533,
0.000677463,
-0.0117466673,
-0.059083201,
0.0463096462,
-0.0256027877,
-0.0050769607,
0.0396236107,
0.0176364593,
0.0400081538,
-0.0207018573,
0.0232325289,
-0.0099995658,
-0.0022515107,
-0.0192909408,
0.0271983333,
-0.0310154203,
-0.0341999382,
-0.0042815446,
0.0530704409,
-0.051976651,
-0.0368254744,
0.0448598266,
-0.0104809562,
-0.017511934,
0.0437394343,
0.0206136256,
-0.0069396729,
-0.023358196,
0.0773613676,
-0.067122601,
0.0061162617,
0.0018761846,
-0.0697007626,
0.0146347173,
0.0356399268,
-0.0202165507,
0.0356144831,
0.0071339584,
0.0127686216,
0.0137476567,
0.0044717737,
0.0444505028,
0.0443261079,
0.0344089717,
0.0425423272,
0.056448672,
-0.017724108,
-0.0172375608,
0.0044440222,
0.0085357362,
0.061879389,
0.0105658108,
0.0565460436,
-0.0118355257,
0.0568301529,
-0.0130514046,
0.0186598245,
-0.0292685814,
0.0606355667,
0.016823804,
0.0372472703,
-0.0354825333,
0.0238997508,
-0.0464571118,
-0.0133115137,
-0.0167152379,
-0.0443708114,
0.0308535546,
0.0298209377,
-0.0230629314,
-0.0824754462,
0.0615759231,
0.0155171975,
-0.0110145565,
-0.0182057098,
-0.0346111245,
0.0591384545,
-0.0214842204,
-0.0048587634,
-0.045604948,
-0.032236401,
0.0315162353,
-0.0662154406,
-0.0171085503,
0.0400237814,
-0.0734626949,
0.0465999432,
-0.0195148978,
-0.0233319718,
-0.03162219,
-0.0315644443,
0.0026197394,
0.0344530046,
0.0606776774,
-0.0109288618,
-0.049296461,
0.1109442115,
-0.0348040126,
-0.0304198079,
-0.0124527067,
-0.0503043644,
0.0118049523,
-0.0353294984,
-0.046027787,
0.0069567356,
-0.0308473166,
0.0358850248,
0.0091049867,
-0.0379767343,
0.0065454138,
0.0241329428,
2.829e-7,
-0.0278099626,
0.0352785438,
-0.0227807686,
0.0661206841,
-0.0049257628,
0.0704314634,
0.0003557459,
0.0446053296,
-0.0240168925,
-0.0103957914,
-0.0087733921,
0.0537083596,
-0.0053294385,
-0.0192272961,
-0.080471836,
-0.0020564061,
0.0440751053,
-0.0252165012,
-0.0760486498,
0.0010330392,
0.0683158115,
0.0742779523,
0.0129449237,
0.0228657629,
0.0411415547,
-0.0344150029,
0.0411187261,
-0.0383108146,
-0.0344703756,
-0.0285616331,
0.0216771513,
0.0499675721,
-0.0122831892,
-0.0011419039,
0.0406815298,
-0.001930816,
0.0017338651,
0.071674414,
-0.0219467934,
-0.0575116575,
0.0062213973,
0.019826645,
-0.0069397171,
-0.0098364893,
0.0595850237,
-0.0438935086,
-0.005493782,
0.0193976462,
0.0496111549,
-0.0027158046,
-0.0023938532,
-0.0378491506,
-0.0098002246,
-0.0356491022,
-0.0017421638,
0.0059270593,
-0.0246623401,
-0.0423029326,
0.0127159199,
-0.0258474071,
-0.0519861989,
-0.0322392099,
-0.0335348621,
-0.0168049838,
-0.0170099195,
-0.0033936133,
-0.0238393731,
1.927639003e-34,
0.0013207578,
0.0341146067,
-0.0079454156,
0.0324834622,
0.0346787795,
0.0375472382,
-0.0355945677,
0.0066623581,
0.054112874,
-0.0658131763,
-0.0350384638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07962v1 | Clustering of Spell Variations for Proper Nouns Transliterated from the other languages | 2023-10-12T00:57:32 | 2023-10-12T00:57:32 | Prathamesh Pawar | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the prominent problems with processing and operating on text data is
the non uniformity of it. Due to the change in the dialects and languages, the
caliber of translation is low. This creates a unique problem while using NLP in
text data; which is the spell variation arising from the inconsistent
translations and transliterations. This problem can also be further aggravated
by the human error arising from the various ways to write a Proper Noun from an
Indian language into its English equivalent. Translating proper nouns
originating from Indian languages can be complicated as some proper nouns are
also used as common nouns which might be taken literally. Applications of NLP
that require addresses, names and other proper nouns face this problem
frequently. We propose a method to cluster these spell variations for proper
nouns using ML techniques and mathematical similarity equations. We aimed to
use Affinity Propagation to determine relative similarity between the tokens.
The results are augmented by filtering the token-variation pair by a similarity
threshold. We were able to reduce the spell variations by a considerable
amount. This application can significantly reduce the amount of human
annotation efforts needed for data cleansing and formatting. | [
0.0407283753,
-0.0226804521,
-0.036837209,
0.0537378266,
-0.0422425754,
0.0039529759,
-0.0100523904,
0.0206575636,
0.0039332109,
-0.003204504,
0.0156843849,
-0.0273765549,
0.0746953636,
-0.0716763511,
0.023462439,
-0.059493117,
0.0548808835,
-0.0111650508,
-0.0429442115,
-0.0069937641,
0.0528635196,
0.0260599684,
-0.0173943434,
0.0444842391,
-0.0263995007,
0.0370117612,
0.0184021462,
-0.0290408358,
0.036265932,
0.0344114527,
-0.0345091224,
0.0231156517,
-0.0367294513,
0.0622265525,
0.0000016062,
-0.0488518104,
-0.0782682896,
-0.0337427817,
0.0151668629,
-0.0438409112,
0.0821897462,
0.0153561365,
-0.0247746874,
0.0150724221,
0.0360300727,
-0.0000091015,
0.1061624289,
-0.0156366415,
0.0310880467,
0.0314502902,
-0.0025749486,
-0.0713910237,
0.0020060386,
0.056739118,
0.017582668,
-0.0253286492,
0.0136273382,
-0.0335060842,
0.0036722985,
-0.0189078022,
-0.0094114663,
0.0043802466,
-0.1064834818,
0.0024222946,
0.0238916744,
0.0121315457,
-0.0249168314,
-0.0254056863,
0.0542829596,
0.0365706719,
-0.0282682497,
-0.0587400384,
0.0240597799,
0.0367899835,
-0.0125993555,
0.0442781784,
0.0134809678,
-0.040943034,
-0.0259084105,
0.0096482392,
0.0638905168,
0.0184667781,
0.0060338019,
0.0140438993,
-0.0332914703,
0.0713244528,
0.0381224193,
-0.0493364111,
-0.0337066539,
0.0063197357,
0.031983085,
0.0085688625,
0.0502318963,
0.0133591583,
-0.021627441,
0.0403095223,
-0.0083887912,
-0.1095017418,
0.0205233432,
-0.0536840223,
-0.0211117528,
0.0110793114,
0.0294265542,
-0.0019290122,
-0.0301497616,
0.0290194564,
0.0280129518,
-0.0155402757,
-0.0405161306,
-0.0445583165,
-0.080355227,
-0.0091307238,
-0.0601885766,
0.0176743139,
-0.0413412862,
0.0464327075,
-0.0680308715,
0.0067670504,
-0.0117238751,
-0.0024375624,
-0.012163939,
-0.0295912828,
0.0315753222,
-0.0089977328,
-0.0302634034,
-0.0117081935,
-0.074015297,
-0.0087367836,
-0.0506104268,
-0.0266216155,
0.043696247,
0.0013011727,
0.0391185284,
-0.0128889242,
-0.0207278766,
0.0144009395,
0.0013699685,
-0.0065518208,
-0.0421727821,
0.0039841188,
-0.0200682357,
-0.0133445449,
-0.0612531975,
-0.0795069858,
0.0300961155,
-0.0041387905,
0.0032540034,
-0.0600975379,
-0.0066615092,
0.0168925747,
-0.0614509806,
0.1029325873,
-0.0470218919,
0.0327952169,
0.0781477243,
-0.0220054258,
0.0384742245,
-0.0221501011,
0.0120088467,
-0.0239172261,
0.0740023032,
-0.0351643935,
0.0555577353,
0.0302183293,
-0.0183256399,
-0.0276208576,
-0.0145547474,
-0.0306595787,
-0.0013188595,
0.0381789207,
-0.0154128019,
0.0631216988,
-0.011511012,
0.0199101456,
-0.0111544402,
0.0871163756,
-0.0067351311,
0.0194396172,
-0.0089833317,
0.026140796,
-0.0136672882,
-0.0099850688,
0.0086500952,
-0.0356254689,
-0.015113323,
0.0106585007,
0.0116957035,
0.0192255396,
0.0038947472,
-0.0078229588,
-0.0281008761,
0.0032401779,
0.0231219046,
-0.0518837906,
0.0097846128,
-0.0030603423,
-0.0345548093,
0.0363796763,
0.0317837857,
-0.0420083553,
0.0426945016,
-0.0290903766,
-0.0046619442,
0.0853249282,
0.0402953476,
-0.0169113241,
-0.012152873,
0.0214505829,
-0.0619394816,
-0.0250959229,
-0.0482035689,
-0.0335348062,
0.0009177647,
-0.0538058132,
0.0407744087,
0.108840473,
-0.0059004202,
-0.0018075001,
-0.0062365704,
0.0278563984,
0.0262486208,
-0.0674798638,
-0.0389826559,
0.0493750907,
-0.0047035166,
0.0274859089,
0.0152021591,
0.0384715535,
0.0078826929,
0.0246986728,
0.0123126814,
-0.0048089996,
0.013795034,
-0.0083044516,
0.0455757305,
0.0331657082,
0.0314409286,
0.0184083041,
0.0125545319,
-0.0658612624,
-0.0013606251,
-0.0136284959,
-0.0088317199,
-0.0351813324,
0.0009401805,
-0.0069050407,
0.0626116917,
-0.0228624381,
0.0822948962,
-0.0177559666,
-0.0047184294,
-0.0601236299,
0.0439238697,
0.0158290509,
0.0209628195,
-0.0119935051,
0.014214701,
0.0027951815,
-0.0169122536,
-0.0188417099,
-0.0222458914,
0.0133449743,
0.0206327587,
0.0161092505,
-0.0173632838,
-0.0146733392,
-0.0483294763,
-0.0480085276,
-0.031387046,
0.0060991026,
0.0194455404,
0.0283770412,
0.0657582283,
-0.0168318991,
0.008520727,
0.0159361437,
0.0162504669,
0.0270285029,
-0.0002234776,
0.071152702,
-0.0113630323,
-0.0195974056,
-0.0415233858,
0.0100910589,
0.0138759352,
0.0141343214,
0.0115433931,
-0.0853917301,
-0.0538760684,
0.0424461849,
-0.0603122748,
0.001205429,
0.0362058766,
-0.0523077622,
-0.0232275203,
-0.0282105524,
0.0268096812,
-0.0064648744,
0.0126355113,
-0.0218531191,
0.0011239187,
-0.0418661907,
-0.0264810175,
-0.0449046455,
-0.009137704,
0.0531056114,
-0.016096605,
-0.019650599,
0.0511729158,
-0.0197507348,
-0.0358234569,
-0.0317888334,
-0.0043947217,
-0.0308472738,
-0.0454506613,
0.0078022494,
-0.0379117727,
0.0116608348,
-0.0286363102,
0.0567361452,
-0.0037234046,
-0.0190229472,
0.0348572917,
-0.0468757749,
0.0343422927,
-0.065592967,
-0.0131610082,
-0.0138257518,
0.0004769969,
-0.0329361148,
0.0392762013,
-0.0503700301,
-0.0764356554,
0.0132582188,
0.0142905517,
0.0049131466,
0.0049970788,
0.0531505197,
-0.0342659913,
0.0073489007,
0.0291899294,
0.0323514715,
-0.0201122258,
0.0247185268,
-0.0086143501,
-0.0540761352,
0.0565063544,
-0.0153664015,
0.0202017389,
0.0778910294,
-0.0232982077,
0.0025418703,
0.020278303,
0.0016888443,
0.0001229087,
-0.0043978053,
-0.0263433959,
-0.0146516403,
-0.0076405508,
0.031580966,
-0.0111604659,
-0.0098519819,
0.0021867908,
-0.061513193,
0.0391366296,
-0.0065793875,
0.0260207355,
-0.0783660337,
-0.0148050934,
0.0070503135,
-0.0091930144,
0.00898208,
-0.0374234505,
0.1124926135,
0.0539808087,
-0.0247067809,
0.0004769822,
-0.0215728246,
-0.0125435861,
-0.0112990225,
0.012445759,
-0.0144523494,
0.0218145605,
0.0409206152,
0.0015651332,
-0.0071195923,
-0.0460547023,
0.03866072,
-0.1144693494,
-0.0319950543,
-0.0059160367,
-0.0764746442,
-0.061803598,
-0.0203362722,
-0.0119081568,
-0.0294264015,
0.0013523054,
0.0197134707,
-0.0055134357,
-0.0124048945,
0.0408264324,
-0.0375086218,
-0.0500161722,
-0.0259979684,
-0.0950281993,
0.0145294294,
0.022954369,
0.0616038218,
-0.0484912321,
-0.0400903635,
-0.0224209409,
-0.0232050065,
-0.0312785022,
-0.0301170796,
0.0084748492,
0.0268988591,
-0.000826332,
-0.0444735661,
-0.0156029109,
0.0038272971,
-0.0073066419,
0.0447195806,
0.0175392274,
0.0208933689,
0.0321496911,
0.0419036373,
-0.000999789,
0.0045535685,
0.0264774393,
-0.0065768347,
0.0204498321,
-0.0133043155,
-0.0052501303,
0.0180567,
0.0049303565,
-0.0268074572,
-0.0047354274,
-0.0618108511,
-0.0454287454,
-0.0938998461,
-0.0367359817,
0.0524424724,
0.0701201633,
0.0433636196,
0.0358549841,
0.0320488401,
0.0219958257,
0.0133005874,
-0.0413632989,
-0.0314998589,
0.0212673675,
-0.061711248,
0.0137864482,
0.0267210659,
0.0217933897,
-0.0095899766,
-0.0200370681,
-0.012666679,
-0.0364416875,
0.0539827012,
0.006092397,
0.0223175157,
0.0361873582,
-0.0601565801,
-0.0437462591,
0.0026065689,
-0.0071888547,
0.0041756914,
-0.032449957,
-0.0010282819,
-0.0195075944,
0.0030522968,
-0.0034932988,
0.0143012218,
0.0122924214,
-0.0274551325,
-0.0073180022,
-0.0445269607,
-0.0176141635,
0.0365317427,
0.040040005,
0.029980436,
-0.0625931621,
-0.025481984,
-0.0454085618,
-0.0273022372,
0.003372865,
0.003339791,
0.062449377,
-0.0159315187,
0.0216937885,
0.0140925758,
-0.019643683,
-0.0444135629,
-0.030377306,
0.0032305864,
0.0220693033,
0.0123064136,
0.0133075956,
0.0908920616,
0.0220435914,
0.0219191071,
0.018187087,
-0.0110005252,
0.004304823,
0.0388909541,
-0.0498823039,
-0.0519129783,
-0.0002898347,
0.0379577279,
-0.0099967131,
0.0689421296,
0.0366724655,
0.041515056,
-0.0093617495,
0.0327999294,
0.0322776251,
-0.0273152906,
0.029838223,
-0.0156371444,
-0.0108879423,
0.0008101085,
0.016927639,
-0.0009151225,
0.0189501196,
-0.0388281308,
-0.0136210676,
-0.0034127554,
-0.0079443008,
0.0167876668,
-0.0711087212,
0.0022966019,
0.0167456977,
-0.0707097799,
0.0027283556,
0.0371454097,
-0.0546996146,
-0.0017538968,
-0.0137993218,
-0.0339134857,
-0.0618305244,
-0.0504323207,
0.0303529091,
-0.0083129089,
0.0220092386,
0.0292224791,
0.0430102646,
0.0279807169,
0.0465464517,
0.0779644847,
-0.0264977887,
-0.0369174555,
0.0207280722,
-0.0542492978,
0.0019186115,
-5.480335028e-33,
-0.0149989231,
-0.0171052795,
-0.0151469754,
-0.0585765056,
-0.013655982,
-0.0231271368,
0.0160529166,
0.0251192693,
-0.0216162819,
-0.0027088223,
-0.0077706086,
-0.0186512955,
0.0387237333,
-0.0309791267,
0.0274955127,
-0.006801255,
-0.0012296793,
0.064384453,
0.0249800775,
-0.0140766995,
0.0799710602,
0.0207936019,
0.0756352022,
-0.0122999651,
0.0305258017,
-0.0325968787,
-0.0170766693,
0.0503301173,
0.0674205497,
0.0402316377,
-0.0190083608,
0.0253062919,
0.0139835523,
0.0080743833,
-0.0059646899,
-0.0061288178,
-0.0942849889,
-0.0478090234,
0.0241275616,
0.0214047153,
0.0542944968,
-0.0437092856,
0.0536340922,
-0.0172731262,
-0.0504337326,
0.0900305286,
0.0439710133,
-0.0081327986,
-0.0181955546,
0.0371788666,
-0.0741821826,
0.0163589306,
0.0111691626,
0.0499241501,
0.0554478541,
-0.0124181043,
-0.0110496115,
-0.0047747907,
-0.0836615488,
0.0319435969,
0.0328389183,
0.045252569,
0.030868087,
0.0123011535,
-0.0400499217,
0.0020135213,
0.021609528,
-0.0343078487,
-0.0043488466,
0.0575192869,
0.0430202633,
0.006216832,
0.0176759362,
0.0431485996,
0.0149500249,
-0.0829688311,
0.0164204612,
0.0474164039,
-0.0105116637,
0.0199910793,
0.011829841,
-0.0044281879,
-0.0599744618,
-0.0454756953,
0.0294250436,
0.0007212631,
-0.0066097835,
0.0005905452,
0.0173324961,
-0.0372066945,
-0.0472170673,
0.0470487401,
0.0027944257,
0.0130823907,
-0.0370420478,
-0.0369121917,
-0.0021275943,
0.021408774,
-0.0283117369,
0.0221735388,
0.0110493498,
-0.0937098339,
-0.0064881933,
0.0132464124,
0.0114821084,
0.0072132931,
-0.0107791163,
-0.0450548641,
-0.0645524338,
0.0109003596,
0.0074739372,
0.0326047912,
-0.0202940647,
0.0014351485,
-0.0135163683,
-0.0084264018,
0.0099954996,
-0.0056917309,
0.0949483588,
-0.000753161,
0.0254435204,
-0.0123875169,
0.0169183612,
-0.024945654,
-0.0225274246,
0.0400127508,
-0.0432596803,
-0.0368572138,
0.0361804552,
-0.0372879021,
-0.0049327267,
-0.0143100666,
2.523e-7,
0.0423527434,
0.0837479979,
0.0503786467,
-0.0303138178,
-0.0403300598,
-0.020192489,
0.0015992103,
0.0028998419,
-0.0154145742,
0.0387066193,
0.0423998535,
-0.0255591627,
0.0020430952,
0.047267396,
-0.0970695689,
0.0122520924,
-0.0308077447,
-0.0139056891,
-0.0498186313,
0.0268685296,
-0.0178304557,
0.0657916218,
0.0345800631,
-0.0095222713,
-0.0222910531,
-0.0024556278,
-0.0320959613,
-0.011601151,
0.0027466763,
0.0304612145,
0.0548414998,
-0.022206869,
0.0314723551,
0.0176629182,
0.0023408029,
0.004735121,
0.0611301251,
-0.0158234909,
-0.0515537858,
0.0846484154,
0.0213109199,
-0.0692613572,
0.0252963677,
-0.0380094238,
0.0457556844,
0.0709396675,
0.0277929921,
0.0271111317,
-0.0034471815,
0.0512806922,
0.0042841486,
-0.000483969,
-0.0429641716,
0.0346458741,
0.0458169617,
-0.0025807179,
-0.0174629334,
-0.0305418521,
0.025478268,
-0.0032879091,
0.0205458719,
-0.0265423823,
0.0512409732,
-0.0211741626,
0.0167454481,
-0.0025397162,
0.0043371902,
2.034890465e-34,
-0.0188084841,
0.0453861207,
-0.0261070505,
0.0204136651,
0.0266231131,
0.0106135774,
-0.0240761563,
0.0432381444,
-0.0313501656,
-0.0098332902,
-0.0073172287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07957v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07957v2 | A New Approach Towards Autoformalization | 2023-10-12T00:50:24 | 2023-10-19T18:08:20 | Nilay Patel, Rahul Saha, Jeffrey Flanigan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Verifying mathematical proofs is difficult, but can be automated with the
assistance of a computer. Autoformalization is the task of automatically
translating natural language mathematics into a formal language that can be
verified by a program. This is a challenging task, and especially for
higher-level mathematics found in research papers. Research paper mathematics
requires large amounts of background and context. In this paper, we propose an
avenue towards tackling autoformalization for research-level mathematics, by
breaking the task into easier and more approachable subtasks: unlinked
formalization (formalization with unlinked definitions and theorems), entity
linking (linking to the proper theorems and definitions), and finally adjusting
types so it passes the type checker. In addition, we present arXiv2Formal, a
benchmark dataset for unlinked formalization consisting of 50 theorems
formalized for the Lean theorem prover sampled from papers on arXiv.org. We
welcome any contributions from the community to future versions of this
dataset. | [
-0.0714374557,
0.0866835713,
-0.0021291489,
0.0207888298,
0.0078574969,
0.0015897468,
0.019674195,
-0.0289213583,
-0.0223664101,
-0.0552092418,
0.0096399914,
0.0624076091,
0.0007626163,
0.0398347192,
0.0476005264,
-0.0681905746,
0.0291831195,
-0.0105430484,
0.0119517567,
0.0001429701,
-0.0049390234,
0.0058123702,
-0.0130545702,
-0.0013855747,
0.0054935389,
-0.0614705682,
0.0134409061,
-0.03466608,
0.0286558215,
-0.0289420225,
-0.0439191088,
0.0776761398,
-0.0264122989,
0.0621649511,
0.0000019324,
-0.0741770789,
-0.0447351001,
0.0661821812,
-0.0233154967,
0.0482086688,
-0.0468177833,
-0.0297364611,
-0.0088165523,
-0.0217277054,
-0.0377581306,
-0.0169291236,
0.0187171977,
0.0084520644,
0.0566876382,
0.0222815219,
-0.0102062551,
-0.0695593357,
0.0909757465,
0.0209606774,
0.0473814793,
-0.0420863591,
-0.0003256953,
0.0017542531,
0.0066561946,
0.0286832191,
0.0401364379,
0.0392237939,
0.0234395042,
-0.0382315814,
0.0279316474,
-0.0152688883,
-0.091936186,
0.0150847547,
0.0229896829,
0.057021305,
0.0323473141,
-0.0498888753,
0.0291468315,
0.0245704222,
-0.0316800736,
0.0487434939,
-0.0352814831,
0.0174096022,
-0.0017159827,
-0.0319070481,
0.0019687468,
-0.0169422086,
0.0610079616,
-0.000402056,
-0.0245397184,
0.0651748553,
0.0224395879,
-0.0416849293,
-0.0212977864,
-0.0315369926,
-0.0532058254,
-0.0869335681,
0.0453734435,
0.0212866906,
0.0545546561,
-0.0251921322,
-0.0261562727,
-0.0518723354,
0.0111977356,
-0.0163270831,
-0.0383535959,
0.0162025392,
0.014475883,
-0.0063072634,
-0.0413185433,
-0.0078203194,
-0.031809099,
0.0048881108,
0.0358471125,
0.031629134,
-0.007694263,
-0.0021962465,
-0.0572641008,
0.0160474181,
0.0365914665,
0.0307818484,
-0.0452228859,
0.0185652468,
-0.0553485826,
0.0787634626,
-0.0424545854,
-0.0738299116,
-0.0383707061,
-0.020305166,
0.0004016283,
-0.0120321875,
-0.0315421708,
-0.0258639418,
-0.0164141674,
-0.0312670469,
0.0126422821,
0.0169608518,
0.0041963407,
-0.0159476195,
-0.0188599955,
0.027965229,
0.0567611754,
0.0152531257,
-0.0086912895,
-0.0455274843,
0.0567214489,
-0.0026189392,
-0.0376299731,
-0.1034995243,
0.0267695859,
0.0160288233,
-0.0019414051,
-0.0471575186,
-0.039903976,
0.0080819447,
0.024648292,
0.0883403718,
-0.0662135631,
-0.021228943,
0.0172308907,
-0.0219484959,
-0.0138836913,
-0.0533143654,
0.051022768,
-0.0314635225,
0.0499374047,
-0.0088667227,
0.0390786305,
0.0190301482,
0.0490129367,
-0.0247476418,
0.0095962789,
0.0431828126,
0.0109217567,
0.0615585968,
-0.0218731184,
0.0697733611,
-0.0258791167,
0.0200590901,
-0.0240077451,
0.0397075564,
0.0446429662,
0.0038666804,
0.0233108904,
0.0090969875,
0.0795128569,
-0.0131673766,
-0.0668995082,
0.0169950649,
-0.0137245804,
0.0372618958,
0.0260073636,
0.0102549866,
-0.000020136,
-0.0495075881,
-0.027767539,
0.0023539825,
-0.0528414585,
-0.0482077114,
0.0494436584,
0.0280720089,
0.0412431061,
0.0579029471,
-0.0297346655,
-0.0218359511,
-0.0153838145,
-0.0146682607,
0.0500088148,
-0.0571481846,
0.0457250476,
-0.0927666724,
0.0170786139,
-0.0586670935,
0.0193935968,
0.0618255176,
0.0195750371,
-0.0472454801,
-0.0569349639,
-0.014763196,
0.0123893386,
0.0112096751,
0.0225752536,
-0.0268909354,
0.0243705101,
0.0262243487,
0.0211482178,
-0.0520820916,
-0.0309224688,
0.0258168485,
-0.007935633,
-0.0526630469,
-0.0001202559,
0.014030912,
-0.0031318043,
0.018574046,
-0.0263285693,
0.045125939,
-0.0017685865,
-0.0026619565,
0.0230567567,
0.0033161789,
0.063992694,
0.0076660253,
0.0224379171,
-0.0937390029,
-0.0276988987,
-0.0021507253,
-0.0423837863,
-0.0085976673,
0.02256402,
0.0074629611,
0.0121385548,
0.0038790323,
0.0017600607,
0.0147231575,
-0.0026440723,
0.0298037603,
0.007495211,
0.0370701961,
-0.0033293336,
0.0220568571,
-0.0452665314,
0.0099727474,
0.000137083,
-0.0270165019,
0.0007009626,
0.0030676108,
0.0304815024,
0.0124444785,
-0.0014128315,
0.0114586521,
0.0183210876,
0.0446271747,
0.0119138435,
0.0035179767,
0.0545803905,
0.0135008292,
-0.0032546781,
0.0049955864,
0.0018023712,
0.020393841,
-0.054963477,
-0.0208629724,
-0.0379264392,
0.0709300041,
-0.0031366686,
-0.0137413349,
-0.0426346585,
-0.02066545,
-0.0721663609,
0.011816618,
0.0244467948,
0.0079614557,
-0.035189122,
0.0187299661,
-0.0082542254,
-0.0205786582,
-0.0147973057,
0.0418047085,
0.0103553338,
0.0090645654,
0.011534038,
0.0744640604,
0.0080858245,
0.0016818348,
0.0246484801,
0.0273624491,
-0.032770209,
-0.0100182621,
0.0061565959,
0.0243846588,
0.0268002637,
-0.0225168467,
0.0593040958,
0.0136907902,
-0.0444324575,
-0.0076640216,
-0.0116142342,
0.0186355785,
-0.0102589838,
0.0404339507,
0.0125218472,
0.0112506663,
-0.0101498943,
0.0317243449,
0.0449002832,
-0.0474952683,
0.034325216,
-0.0432351604,
0.0012497796,
-0.0499873832,
0.0125844274,
-0.0788350105,
0.0073398561,
0.0026393915,
-0.0204300825,
0.0357892327,
0.0006269362,
-0.0072003286,
-0.0097209699,
0.0537359007,
0.0196658969,
0.0213767122,
-0.0148409596,
0.0467273332,
-0.0155018084,
0.0015367147,
-0.0128615778,
0.0383024365,
-0.0204011556,
0.0277310107,
-0.0125728166,
-0.0475199595,
-0.0242778584,
0.0326964259,
0.056412138,
0.0156980045,
0.0055589876,
-0.0360501558,
-0.0201923214,
0.0027651493,
0.0066670845,
-0.0328261703,
0.0409640446,
-0.0111768628,
-0.0067392774,
0.032311298,
0.024959404,
0.0319937579,
-0.0051510353,
-0.0460487418,
-0.0350640453,
-0.0979614705,
-0.029562166,
-0.0026442625,
-0.0434185825,
-0.0342774577,
0.0237734616,
0.0760373548,
0.0138157848,
-0.0253676716,
0.0002099957,
-0.0509507433,
0.0108102867,
-0.0125021283,
0.0258845761,
-0.1300686449,
0.0234682709,
-0.0048365993,
0.0103031658,
0.0297992695,
-0.0132627068,
0.0291109588,
-0.0560662448,
0.0379425883,
0.0389073156,
-0.0456165113,
-0.0131528853,
-0.0467328168,
0.0121136941,
-0.0146668516,
-0.0323819183,
0.0159761943,
-0.0115861511,
0.0199567489,
0.0050467965,
-0.0713084415,
-0.0419409797,
-0.0280677639,
-0.0690006688,
-0.0021453931,
-0.0052146004,
0.0665561929,
-0.0389411785,
-0.0603094101,
0.0021670344,
0.0507835597,
-0.069957532,
-0.0037394529,
0.0005297431,
-0.0449181795,
0.0297549758,
0.001658447,
0.0506986938,
-0.0321056359,
-0.0485248454,
0.0413392708,
0.0854750648,
0.014957984,
-0.020798713,
-0.0448963158,
-0.0307482183,
-0.02336834,
0.0405803286,
-0.0081004938,
0.0378264338,
-0.0185836907,
-0.0429133512,
0.0078283846,
-0.0295226499,
-0.0432242602,
-0.037994124,
-0.0433171652,
-0.01387103,
-0.05296994,
-0.0029317415,
0.0160304997,
0.0593908578,
0.0146150608,
-0.0379381776,
0.0332892016,
-0.0014906657,
-0.0664640665,
0.0521514788,
-0.0295921713,
0.0325150043,
-0.0211279672,
-0.0125995092,
-0.0167123023,
0.0465461537,
-0.0328759663,
0.0514244698,
-0.0065592295,
-0.0204157997,
-0.0265728105,
0.0155898333,
0.0276946351,
0.0422560833,
-0.0153608685,
-0.0095306169,
0.0146253025,
0.0501815379,
-0.020776771,
-0.0106489575,
0.0372603759,
-0.0092735859,
-0.0169852469,
0.012622959,
-0.0193518084,
-0.037978325,
-0.0533562899,
0.0261430591,
-0.0197626166,
-0.0404837094,
-0.0016891524,
0.0826722085,
-0.0192185268,
-0.0050973203,
0.0131981699,
0.0273377486,
0.0052725924,
-0.0013355544,
-0.0107611865,
-0.0271655358,
0.062878646,
-0.0253997501,
0.0090864366,
0.0014750558,
0.0641000867,
0.0084127448,
-0.0059401426,
0.032601513,
0.0389073789,
-0.0078275427,
0.0721441656,
0.0617627725,
-0.0395550616,
0.0106796585,
-0.036991328,
-0.0218160134,
0.0699294731,
-0.0365639217,
-0.0428149104,
0.0584765673,
0.0182859879,
-0.0369376019,
0.0050565223,
-0.0288979579,
-0.0626190007,
-0.0194596052,
0.0177213065,
0.0006851096,
0.0575830564,
0.0388382114,
-0.040779233,
-0.0304896515,
0.0109375734,
0.0622664988,
0.0271230005,
0.016906675,
0.0088519668,
0.0247451775,
-0.0007331787,
-0.0226698797,
0.0277169105,
-0.0186127461,
0.0105649838,
-0.0080228932,
-0.0049593835,
-0.0389006734,
0.0163081177,
-0.0337391123,
0.0188483763,
-0.0234834813,
-0.0584691577,
-0.061008431,
-0.0741743371,
0.0629168227,
0.0355390161,
-0.0226427112,
0.0302981772,
0.0070944042,
0.0558654144,
0.0288614873,
-0.0429032519,
0.0169037897,
0.0476554967,
-0.0330643207,
-0.0720079765,
-0.0189099126,
-5.029990653e-33,
-0.0155093074,
-0.0113655869,
-0.0163937192,
0.0060670404,
0.0115209846,
-0.0005218004,
-0.0391639732,
-0.0460205674,
0.0299174134,
0.0514903106,
-0.0231323708,
0.038993746,
0.0037775894,
-0.0313014612,
-0.0016040568,
0.0257116649,
0.0442773551,
-0.0222894065,
-0.0511263385,
-0.0012186148,
-0.0020838031,
-0.0252205227,
0.094212614,
-0.0476806499,
0.0871608332,
0.0003496142,
-0.0074077672,
0.0193038825,
0.0049171667,
0.0718904361,
-0.0074907267,
-0.009793424,
-0.0295703299,
-0.0033498032,
-0.0181331802,
0.0184836481,
-0.0894630924,
-0.0206483621,
0.0054737064,
0.0152178528,
-0.0366580151,
-0.0207085498,
0.0529326536,
-0.0095212888,
-0.0385670066,
-0.0147590628,
0.0597015657,
0.0203361008,
-0.0107113123,
-0.0495779887,
-0.0490612425,
0.0671360567,
-0.0286833886,
0.0238338113,
0.0146691184,
-0.0072697084,
-0.008360751,
-0.0256240815,
-0.0367246717,
-0.0027160926,
-0.0222260058,
0.0060565998,
0.0166877732,
-0.0622826628,
0.0308037922,
0.0069588418,
0.0253653228,
-0.003371953,
-0.013516455,
0.044109907,
0.035514757,
0.0485418141,
0.027401153,
0.0481278412,
0.060323596,
0.0399906784,
-0.0277746469,
0.0671805143,
-0.0216138419,
0.0423788019,
-0.0365495868,
-0.005643805,
-0.0374319255,
-0.0012115053,
-0.0211996026,
-0.0263016187,
0.0013880818,
-0.0112959836,
-0.0386710875,
-0.034855511,
-0.0542807505,
0.0300330501,
0.0067688134,
-0.032385096,
-0.0710217431,
0.0085238181,
0.0317240395,
0.0332266316,
0.0021853617,
0.0029087167,
-0.0114765437,
-0.0013198757,
-0.0309089683,
0.0444694608,
0.0561761372,
0.0193637554,
0.0194718949,
0.0259498078,
-0.0181393754,
-0.0036245317,
0.0125823794,
-0.059453968,
0.0110314284,
0.0257139653,
0.0255292952,
0.0510089397,
0.0516011305,
0.0203200411,
-0.0093275271,
-0.0059753275,
-0.0275609512,
0.1246406212,
0.0188132748,
0.055512581,
0.0069671101,
-0.0385512561,
-0.0328639857,
-0.0010251331,
0.0729405805,
-0.0518108569,
0.0144947879,
-0.0284297504,
2.691e-7,
0.0356692895,
0.0252051186,
0.048004929,
0.025688054,
-0.0185242072,
0.0079992516,
0.0158296805,
-0.0008769732,
-0.0083197802,
0.0031168167,
0.0026546016,
0.0160296746,
-0.0083982367,
0.034572985,
-0.0839368999,
-0.0599929914,
-0.0496878363,
-0.0023923398,
-0.0394854806,
-0.020006476,
0.0177497491,
-0.0088634565,
0.0273578372,
0.0323591046,
-0.0266780406,
-0.0529434159,
0.0072580082,
0.0446813256,
0.0325263403,
0.0809769183,
0.0206619836,
-0.0381608605,
0.0153932516,
-0.0196650065,
-0.0151666012,
0.0184027143,
0.0179342441,
0.0503054038,
0.0258773379,
0.0903611928,
-0.0527400821,
-0.1049011573,
0.0288020279,
-0.0142786121,
0.0163194537,
-0.0332625248,
-0.0316773579,
-0.0072558867,
-0.0761135593,
-0.0462480746,
0.0212739892,
0.0054319063,
-0.0022076727,
0.0175684299,
0.0028371643,
0.0087530687,
-0.0023399554,
-0.0749503672,
-0.0358524993,
0.0409866385,
-0.0174496099,
-0.0268722549,
-0.0013613258,
-0.0053314301,
0.025934916,
-0.019013213,
-0.0042178114,
2.775007651e-34,
0.0514338426,
-0.0053396602,
0.0170356464,
0.0468687974,
0.0516239479,
-0.0227819625,
-0.0049086125,
-0.0035839155,
0.0288530681,
-0.0400940366,
-0.0026328336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07931v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07931v1 | D2 Pruning: Message Passing for Balancing Diversity and Difficulty in Data Pruning | 2023-10-11T23:01:29 | 2023-10-11T23:01:29 | Adyasha Maharana, Prateek Yadav, Mohit Bansal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Analytical theories suggest that higher-quality data can lead to lower test
errors in models trained on a fixed data budget. Moreover, a model can be
trained on a lower compute budget without compromising performance if a dataset
can be stripped of its redundancies. Coreset selection (or data pruning) seeks
to select a subset of the training data so as to maximize the performance of
models trained on this subset, also referred to as coreset. There are two
dominant approaches: (1) geometry-based data selection for maximizing data
diversity in the coreset, and (2) functions that assign difficulty scores to
samples based on training dynamics. Optimizing for data diversity leads to a
coreset that is biased towards easier samples, whereas, selection by difficulty
ranking omits easy samples that are necessary for the training of deep learning
models. This demonstrates that data diversity and importance scores are two
complementary factors that need to be jointly considered during coreset
selection. We represent a dataset as an undirected graph and propose a novel
pruning algorithm, D2 Pruning, that uses forward and reverse message passing
over this dataset graph for coreset selection. D2 Pruning updates the
difficulty scores of each example by incorporating the difficulty of its
neighboring examples in the dataset graph. Then, these updated difficulty
scores direct a graph-based sampling method to select a coreset that
encapsulates both diverse and difficult regions of the dataset space. We
evaluate supervised and self-supervised versions of our method on various
vision and language datasets. Results show that D2 Pruning improves coreset
selection over previous state-of-the-art methods for up to 70% pruning rates.
Additionally, we find that using D2 Pruning for filtering large multimodal
datasets leads to increased diversity in the dataset and improved
generalization of pretrained models. | [
-0.0206136294,
0.0309733655,
-0.0143388798,
0.0063098497,
-0.049831178,
0.0289463382,
0.0078374511,
0.0319170207,
0.0294051673,
-0.0009928084,
0.0023695,
-0.009807704,
0.0044520218,
-0.0090301819,
-0.0162746813,
-0.0668524578,
0.019398842,
-0.0039534131,
0.0198772904,
-0.0334749408,
-0.0070858649,
0.0287828688,
0.0184565783,
0.0271971077,
-0.0343976244,
-0.0265523661,
-0.0010878019,
0.0636660978,
-0.0065454491,
-0.0175499059,
0.0276897084,
0.0607356429,
0.0107302442,
-0.0174227525,
0.0000023429,
-0.0176485088,
-0.0338587612,
-0.0167499762,
-0.047599256,
0.0216175951,
0.0231366009,
0.0117606204,
0.0103843696,
-0.0273087379,
-0.0030608312,
-0.0292845666,
0.041909717,
0.0300322492,
0.0655380711,
0.0428994633,
-0.0114545859,
-0.0017204678,
-0.0044198255,
-0.0537441559,
-0.0486430675,
-0.0117626106,
0.0445026085,
-0.0126221953,
-0.01143857,
-0.0076550813,
-0.0239592232,
0.0041767671,
0.0381766297,
0.0530545264,
0.0183080696,
0.0020510764,
-0.04268324,
-0.0132211233,
0.0285431854,
0.0895680934,
-0.092708759,
-0.008647019,
0.009112441,
-0.0500931852,
-0.0009145961,
-0.0035203996,
-0.0346196704,
-0.0239624251,
0.0069555542,
0.0373724811,
-0.0602053441,
-0.0093489671,
0.0400804356,
-0.0162961762,
-0.0105010774,
-0.0173139367,
-0.0065431567,
0.0030907972,
0.0367767066,
0.0046676593,
-0.0481402799,
-0.0278046746,
-0.0144121731,
-0.0261754636,
-0.0215094741,
-0.0302898344,
-0.041714672,
-0.0025584346,
-0.0041235336,
0.0105876848,
0.0380809419,
-0.026580492,
-0.0329589881,
0.0419495031,
-0.0010639677,
-0.0095930379,
0.0334696025,
0.0586249828,
-0.0472780056,
0.0041496279,
-0.0224055387,
0.0566528253,
-0.0459294431,
0.0579477213,
0.024195997,
0.0138931656,
-0.0672706813,
-0.0249379594,
-0.0616365224,
-0.0376315191,
0.0299724378,
0.0193025041,
-0.0465006493,
0.0027556552,
0.0166410934,
0.0262386035,
-0.0189587679,
0.0117235156,
0.0002051109,
-0.0715586543,
-0.0237022191,
-0.003723416,
0.0306814723,
-0.0317446329,
0.0447248854,
0.0295163784,
-0.0193261448,
-0.0609541088,
-0.0296301395,
-0.0042835562,
-0.0083378917,
-0.0211402103,
0.027413277,
-0.0839520767,
0.049561318,
-0.0350314938,
0.007493828,
-0.0846519992,
-0.0048930445,
0.0271793641,
-0.0415678546,
0.0325025395,
0.019965725,
0.0237985533,
0.0504120216,
-0.0082585877,
-0.0072281924,
0.0917187184,
0.0221755914,
0.0362179428,
0.0251276959,
0.0050957282,
-0.0132671306,
0.0064290701,
0.0526784845,
0.030405743,
-0.0445136912,
-0.0077437786,
-0.0539133511,
-0.0029922905,
0.0165767465,
0.0276666675,
-0.0529903956,
-0.0633997768,
0.0082332017,
0.0083742412,
0.046318002,
0.0038532747,
-0.0040683444,
0.0100677619,
-0.0040941034,
0.0178771,
-0.0423635989,
0.0222149901,
0.0444416516,
-0.0290755052,
0.0115258126,
0.0389576666,
-0.0491028875,
-0.0459225737,
-0.0083528254,
-0.0321873464,
0.0546091348,
0.056863863,
0.0724253953,
-0.0104168821,
-0.0210583434,
0.059429504,
0.0403989665,
0.0000622366,
-0.0566925928,
-0.0414707959,
-0.0285398625,
0.0025249189,
-0.0015296688,
-0.0479137227,
-0.0132593056,
0.0247022137,
0.0914101899,
-0.0805936679,
0.0559681281,
0.0051072971,
0.0607438162,
-0.0641554669,
-0.0647042468,
0.0051339231,
0.0045020729,
0.0442847982,
0.0259004161,
0.0017694662,
0.004117331,
-0.0253496133,
-0.036662031,
0.0315698385,
0.013418125,
0.0015396873,
0.0393294655,
0.0182302296,
0.0241403058,
-0.0124211833,
-0.000845857,
-0.0393132493,
0.0473130122,
-0.0283112805,
0.0153341033,
-0.0564287007,
-0.0456365496,
-0.0253254175,
0.0192630645,
-0.0760818124,
-0.025569642,
0.0880394876,
-0.0814771205,
-0.040203914,
0.021900462,
-0.0542841665,
-0.0569458976,
-0.0056912033,
-0.0287583917,
-0.0039735767,
0.0522365421,
-0.006706276,
0.054173708,
-0.0367012769,
0.0046902774,
-0.0072760354,
-0.036787264,
0.0133247636,
-0.07549458,
-0.0311911348,
0.0033988177,
-0.042640157,
0.0004370462,
0.0406607203,
0.0261308029,
-0.0091678444,
0.0276991203,
-0.0580697022,
0.0038451767,
-0.0404678173,
-0.0217132103,
-0.0113452319,
0.008397161,
-0.0090857446,
-0.0472969525,
-0.0008686354,
0.0121889915,
-0.0039193276,
0.0281818323,
0.0042367177,
-0.0063455463,
-0.0087253908,
0.0205105152,
-0.0845289379,
0.0284658745,
0.0635397881,
-0.0144224083,
-0.0246955976,
-0.0009531259,
0.0305392593,
-0.0189184248,
0.0155663462,
-0.0101477113,
-0.0139359739,
-0.0083063226,
-0.0222025346,
-0.0178283937,
0.0941756368,
-0.0288214386,
0.0385229252,
0.0514712445,
0.015941374,
-0.0044120918,
0.0295171589,
-0.0377430394,
0.0582701229,
-0.0066159256,
-0.0661514625,
-0.065544039,
0.0025005492,
0.0002789798,
-0.010226192,
-0.0356948338,
0.028676847,
0.0226023663,
-0.0136736436,
-0.013052837,
0.0166686699,
0.0134694185,
0.0098746438,
-0.0560904592,
-0.0354871899,
0.0460793637,
0.0196303111,
-0.0052211056,
-0.0208285917,
-0.03696879,
-0.0073878719,
0.0357188396,
0.0248666126,
0.0063969772,
0.0068441252,
0.016625233,
-0.0700229704,
-0.0317050442,
0.0448662899,
-0.0262372456,
0.0417692587,
-0.0533077307,
0.008466132,
-0.0189384408,
-0.0408389121,
-0.0203156248,
0.0511808582,
0.0111052096,
0.0255975407,
0.013429557,
0.0036678505,
-0.0159492828,
-0.012505671,
-0.0288009979,
0.0742173344,
-0.0050788126,
0.0243648775,
0.0109607261,
-0.0032128745,
0.0215055235,
0.0359684378,
0.0139060998,
-0.0383407399,
0.0319062769,
0.0275801327,
0.0595403351,
-0.000126188,
-0.0432857275,
0.0085674915,
-0.0011105323,
-0.0035140549,
-0.0384246968,
-0.0079860194,
0.0463733524,
-0.057546135,
0.0004366912,
0.0359800421,
-0.0151863731,
-0.0504109338,
0.0070824628,
0.0388496704,
0.0131026311,
0.0179093741,
0.0145732779,
-0.0107001513,
-0.0235541165,
0.0176845808,
0.0132659255,
0.0260860939,
-0.034194313,
0.014047442,
-0.0672470704,
0.088568598,
0.0139026083,
-0.0394445062,
-0.0257035997,
-0.0447810628,
0.0091559086,
-0.0573322624,
-0.0069528152,
-0.0716787279,
0.0162144359,
-0.0285644308,
0.0404491164,
-0.0310754105,
-0.0673775747,
0.0272955932,
-0.0106103681,
-0.0095366547,
-0.0070798881,
0.0222966094,
0.0071011833,
-0.0066310037,
0.0555812456,
-0.0045112665,
-0.0194849297,
-0.0350116752,
0.0649874732,
0.0356172659,
-0.0029828891,
0.0378282368,
0.0217833333,
0.0115127694,
0.0051091881,
-0.0070705907,
0.0828081816,
-0.0190609731,
0.0060357666,
-0.0204741564,
-0.0554851852,
0.0339325853,
0.0260478724,
0.0314831175,
-0.012705381,
-0.0413859189,
-0.0099419979,
0.0151615608,
-0.0765883252,
-0.0035285815,
0.0546930321,
-0.0186077282,
-0.0422623158,
-0.0376201831,
0.005017336,
0.0261645988,
0.0368244015,
-0.058002457,
-0.029593043,
-0.0026631227,
0.0480199307,
-0.0669718534,
0.0149649028,
-0.0136775738,
0.0144503983,
-0.0126431081,
-0.0109323235,
-0.0294661913,
-0.0128209442,
-0.0473363847,
0.0037156008,
-0.1015186608,
-0.0253276248,
-0.0107422937,
0.0279669408,
0.0150194308,
0.0904083699,
0.0039259088,
-0.0586148575,
0.0638122335,
0.0553102791,
0.0003228316,
0.0110303527,
0.0762371048,
-0.0825901255,
-0.0255179722,
0.0644052476,
-0.0469511263,
0.0640562996,
0.0430551618,
-0.023241004,
-0.0241550896,
-0.000371674,
-0.0254334342,
0.0551571026,
0.0527374111,
0.0277689509,
-0.0269848108,
-0.0456647836,
0.0298601668,
0.042334985,
0.0094685815,
-0.0508204214,
0.038187746,
0.0045443713,
0.01904523,
0.0057836492,
0.0208850075,
0.0526402257,
-0.0166116133,
-0.0605092496,
0.0514683835,
0.0001146134,
0.028667232,
0.0322612412,
0.0186543148,
-0.0115015367,
0.0239566639,
0.0118936514,
0.0056808149,
-0.0112396264,
-0.0224263165,
0.0226083584,
0.0304102693,
-0.0535837151,
0.0000065453,
-0.0566163063,
-0.0768493637,
-0.0458353087,
0.0154575733,
0.0427359119,
-0.0221273266,
0.0353201069,
-0.0263491068,
-0.0096824551,
-0.0545521528,
-0.0042416626,
0.0207727514,
-0.0035657701,
0.0237277206,
0.0197474323,
0.0295098126,
0.0229325593,
0.0740531012,
0.0082598934,
0.0185158495,
0.0043077101,
-0.0261379741,
-0.0696913749,
-0.0350962467,
0.0139787737,
0.0350966044,
0.0085333074,
0.0049409578,
0.0116310399,
-0.0588866435,
0.0456109866,
-0.022407975,
0.0240419023,
0.0199140981,
0.0716382191,
0.0541760065,
-0.0230163764,
-0.0010014992,
-0.0082501071,
-0.0225283466,
-0.0249501299,
-0.0315386318,
0.0147995204,
-6.563952373e-33,
0.0393290967,
0.038164258,
-0.0156164402,
-0.0400266126,
-0.0146718966,
0.0222557038,
-0.0025991416,
-0.0386542454,
-0.0360068753,
0.0390076712,
-0.0222115051,
0.0247541126,
0.0127551453,
0.0346437544,
-0.0289882496,
-0.0176997986,
0.0853238553,
-0.0394983962,
-0.025396077,
0.0661546811,
0.0036303543,
0.040540155,
0.0371576063,
-0.0436151214,
-0.066397205,
0.028602669,
-0.007541433,
0.0017364849,
-0.0016109095,
0.0402453281,
0.013133741,
0.0612574145,
0.0123601872,
-0.0712682903,
-0.0153666111,
-0.0272076149,
-0.0654190481,
-0.066052556,
-0.0510766022,
0.027299894,
-0.0131577849,
0.0009216683,
0.0689899251,
0.0337046236,
0.0269305687,
-0.0645802394,
0.0459899306,
-0.0317230783,
-0.0404074751,
0.0034468658,
0.055961147,
0.0467858016,
-0.0101322895,
-0.0398640409,
0.0193259697,
0.0257525668,
-0.0299790818,
0.0217373595,
-0.0356584303,
0.0096800271,
0.0101775993,
0.0051856209,
0.0056573618,
0.0161553398,
-0.01215568,
0.0579976216,
0.0349515304,
-0.0057119499,
0.0459996983,
-0.0052334326,
0.0477361083,
0.0881881937,
0.020755874,
0.041951783,
0.0233743358,
-0.0447888412,
-0.1360259503,
-0.0167583488,
-0.0014160289,
0.0047732065,
-0.0022385421,
0.0272118393,
-0.0277745016,
-0.0480974019,
0.0271527823,
-0.022877939,
-0.0016500093,
-0.0088300556,
-0.0035015577,
0.0342443548,
-0.0902910978,
0.0496790409,
0.0132282069,
-0.0440512225,
-0.0220832843,
0.0389698595,
-0.022123687,
0.0358645357,
0.0405354388,
-0.0071576079,
-0.0378290787,
-0.0312604718,
0.0253983159,
-0.0325446986,
0.0348030701,
-0.0367580839,
0.0523965806,
0.0378232449,
-0.0205091201,
-0.0153878685,
-0.0086642718,
0.0410264134,
0.0058140112,
0.0859133229,
0.0194685645,
0.0261991285,
0.0201101881,
0.0544411093,
0.0277017746,
-0.0212313253,
-0.0475872494,
0.0028704645,
0.0041625318,
0.0434000082,
-0.0079477057,
-0.0137217008,
-0.0424535759,
-0.0345456861,
0.0510144085,
-0.0597014539,
-0.0451346561,
0.0213589743,
2.95e-7,
0.0184090901,
0.0241352282,
-0.0060185012,
-0.0050366609,
0.0052532949,
0.0219607521,
-0.0171951372,
0.0186948907,
-0.0329323523,
-0.005047637,
0.0615798645,
0.0545622483,
0.0303908363,
0.0378671251,
-0.074940823,
0.0539045781,
-0.0376681611,
0.0044191433,
-0.0153806927,
-0.0086016161,
0.0000790521,
0.0884754285,
0.038274724,
-0.0393345281,
-0.001853915,
0.0104567213,
0.0014294633,
-0.0417966433,
0.0429617763,
-0.0178809669,
0.031448029,
0.0060784193,
-0.0297603738,
0.0686465651,
-0.0104367444,
-0.0156067386,
0.028106045,
0.0528346859,
-0.0120903235,
-0.0005420146,
0.0165532511,
0.0588648319,
-0.0016389408,
-0.0199425444,
0.0811787248,
-0.0518575795,
-0.0062950589,
-0.0498978607,
0.0053542377,
-0.0051849727,
0.0461968295,
0.0032178743,
-0.0112324329,
0.0389269516,
0.0141168926,
-0.0307490826,
0.0116032166,
-0.0735462606,
0.0476835817,
0.0179203916,
-0.050958354,
-0.0380412899,
-0.0585892424,
0.006892174,
0.0516697504,
-0.0123540452,
-0.030373821,
2.798108182e-34,
0.0547489114,
0.0028596336,
-0.0062792366,
-0.0454937927,
-0.020102201,
-0.039048966,
-0.0154182501,
0.0194703266,
-0.0249173511,
-0.0071142004,
-0.0448682047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07929v1 | Crosslingual Structural Priming and the Pre-Training Dynamics of Bilingual Language Models | 2023-10-11T22:57:03 | 2023-10-11T22:57:03 | Catherine Arnett, Tyler A. Chang, James A. Michaelov, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do multilingual language models share abstract grammatical representations
across languages, and if so, when do these develop? Following Sinclair et al.
(2022), we use structural priming to test for abstract grammatical
representations with causal effects on model outputs. We extend the approach to
a Dutch-English bilingual setting, and we evaluate a Dutch-English language
model during pre-training. We find that crosslingual structural priming effects
emerge early after exposure to the second language, with less than 1M tokens of
data in that language. We discuss implications for data contamination,
low-resource transfer, and how abstract grammatical representations emerge in
multilingual models. | [
-0.0145631209,
0.0480310917,
-0.0475833677,
0.0392169654,
-0.0467832983,
0.0230030082,
-0.0053876024,
-0.0335665122,
-0.03423509,
-0.0378529243,
-0.0391467437,
-0.0677847415,
0.0074343169,
-0.0189315267,
0.0513811707,
-0.0326199718,
0.0884072781,
-0.0269572623,
-0.0372196361,
-0.0409383178,
0.0046935482,
-0.0059301131,
0.0321663246,
0.0096994611,
-0.0217720345,
-0.0163240004,
-0.0185978543,
-0.0401130691,
-0.0057787569,
-0.0215542838,
0.0046003293,
0.0532476045,
0.0050293417,
-0.0060875886,
0.0000019162,
-0.0377468169,
0.0146481534,
-0.0119011281,
0.0043356023,
0.0373809189,
0.0217088349,
-0.0544026978,
-0.0040790387,
-0.0327339619,
-0.0339084864,
-0.0311145019,
0.0182676613,
0.0196875464,
0.0026109521,
0.0067395112,
-0.0059740292,
-0.0099091409,
0.0223207269,
-0.0212878678,
-0.0032923378,
0.0081011318,
0.027068587,
0.0019294879,
-0.0462424494,
0.0018623911,
-0.0589227714,
0.0455363728,
0.0359962434,
0.0447541066,
-0.0280236155,
0.0258197896,
-0.0329352431,
-0.0255370792,
0.0167648774,
0.0186859053,
-0.0049562571,
-0.0576835796,
-0.0017489579,
0.0111715915,
0.0110361772,
0.0031851223,
-0.0114012193,
0.0167383794,
0.0313193537,
0.0425825864,
0.1018420979,
-0.0511524491,
0.0257175509,
-0.004886054,
-0.0227089096,
0.0626751855,
0.0125351064,
-0.0566815361,
0.0226172283,
0.0578529239,
0.0533999242,
-0.0907742009,
-0.0538648888,
-0.0384383872,
0.0089038983,
0.0230827741,
-0.0333711542,
-0.0288888626,
-0.0103015751,
-0.0351113044,
0.0196454618,
0.0152875232,
-0.0732381195,
0.0080989106,
-0.0204658285,
0.0400824994,
-0.0211791079,
0.0428311564,
-0.0497012548,
-0.0135427592,
-0.01034451,
-0.0226727501,
-0.0169804003,
0.0194082484,
0.0079124896,
0.0207559187,
-0.0321032405,
0.0041916422,
0.0002915222,
-0.0336484276,
-0.0385243446,
-0.0323561728,
-0.0582751445,
0.0234204493,
-0.0323459469,
0.0226148218,
-0.0353785008,
0.0345314406,
-0.031363748,
-0.078097336,
-0.0087363673,
-0.0000828983,
-0.0266613588,
-0.0279153958,
0.0073246793,
0.0406890325,
-0.0293492433,
-0.0188507438,
-0.0097109871,
-0.0266281515,
0.0082860021,
-0.0644453093,
0.0633667856,
-0.0456492081,
0.0291493107,
0.0396214947,
0.020809412,
-0.0128873046,
-0.0050955429,
-0.0191981811,
-0.0226889569,
0.0227562115,
0.0435314514,
0.0333024077,
-0.0462923646,
-0.0205700416,
0.0411433764,
0.072802946,
-0.0305452608,
-0.0568588302,
0.0180510674,
-0.0551973023,
-0.0382834114,
0.0577589832,
0.0491341837,
0.0058503579,
-0.011004312,
0.015898006,
0.0523804463,
-0.0217507146,
0.0503790453,
-0.0013701324,
-0.0289631728,
0.0211633481,
0.020699406,
0.0346075483,
-0.0513031781,
0.0281890649,
0.0609494187,
-0.0263803303,
0.0053401552,
0.0521386787,
-0.0439893939,
0.0067832447,
-0.0037678094,
-0.0089537445,
-0.0277730525,
0.043661233,
-0.0275096744,
0.0083159255,
0.0318238847,
-0.0091279866,
0.0148096019,
-0.0075041135,
0.0221184753,
0.0498509258,
0.0002338998,
0.0929912329,
0.0499037355,
-0.0211724397,
0.0218271594,
0.0346405022,
-0.0268350579,
-0.0065548816,
-0.0362713896,
0.0341350064,
0.0186983813,
-0.0214017536,
0.0317493193,
0.0102610625,
0.1005270928,
0.0059189652,
0.0296202209,
-0.0128669245,
0.0181408171,
-0.0405289941,
0.0056735245,
0.0442507789,
-0.0270130187,
0.0216974858,
-0.0114459889,
-0.0474310331,
-0.0330392309,
0.0280736815,
-0.0723766387,
-0.0140431086,
-0.0294420011,
0.0180607289,
0.0200520847,
-0.0007599763,
-0.0175223891,
0.0206249598,
0.012973764,
-0.0191274583,
0.0529880077,
0.0681687593,
-0.0733725652,
-0.0321248621,
0.0061254539,
-0.0265746377,
-0.0115715386,
-0.0108742723,
0.0012265275,
-0.0323423557,
0.0623169169,
-0.0090150731,
0.0536542237,
-0.0085297991,
0.0232852809,
-0.0249141101,
0.0251191072,
-0.0046028486,
0.0496716686,
-0.0045974823,
0.0246584974,
-0.0171366781,
-0.0164338965,
0.0240265001,
-0.0217756517,
-0.0276852436,
0.0113123991,
-0.0321667045,
-0.0059833466,
0.0160834268,
-0.0098684505,
-0.0212175734,
0.0186416805,
-0.0535571389,
-0.0349298529,
-0.0060970518,
0.0242923535,
0.0236211736,
-0.0130689135,
-0.0142009174,
0.0105952881,
-0.0417918824,
-0.0122588305,
0.0432337075,
0.0500386022,
-0.0124356458,
-0.0139416009,
0.0115678078,
-0.0180915408,
-0.0152672417,
-0.0034526165,
0.0319922827,
-0.0351733677,
-0.0438697971,
-0.029529592,
0.0295581557,
-0.0199427251,
0.0065607014,
-0.0019934836,
-0.0412563756,
0.0088095739,
0.0380840451,
0.0621425919,
0.0388384052,
-0.0429110155,
-0.0005376808,
0.050903514,
-0.0219642073,
-0.046938289,
-0.0239921715,
-0.0218716096,
-0.0216538962,
-0.0598400533,
-0.0566280894,
0.0042929696,
0.1151878461,
0.012402758,
-0.0212509669,
-0.042415563,
-0.0030866461,
-0.0823346078,
-0.0346013419,
-0.0170908626,
-0.0091019804,
-0.032144133,
0.053234268,
-0.0414456129,
-0.0449315235,
0.0381394103,
0.0167488679,
-0.0099690249,
-0.0455299616,
0.0087787956,
0.0132822851,
0.013694834,
0.0186707415,
0.0090577248,
0.0282852724,
0.0070440145,
-0.0570477806,
0.0020328041,
0.0439776704,
0.0168906767,
0.026415525,
-0.0276623741,
-0.0088149868,
0.0197974369,
-0.0704402179,
-0.024577776,
-0.0471557193,
-0.0071595949,
0.0149028115,
0.0157060605,
0.0321602784,
0.0025667762,
-0.0321686491,
0.0466618873,
0.0028794301,
-0.0117659103,
0.0123212775,
-0.0220187828,
-0.0068077929,
0.0019791573,
-0.0369451866,
0.0359139591,
-0.0832924619,
-0.0046251775,
-0.0249837451,
0.005548792,
0.0255539641,
0.0078507205,
0.0255904272,
0.0387794003,
0.0326112062,
-0.0828749016,
-0.00340312,
0.0627939478,
-0.0153606441,
-0.0433552861,
0.020257799,
0.0105175655,
-0.0016113053,
0.0459401011,
-0.0253501181,
0.0298585612,
0.0473195538,
0.0100635067,
-0.0764931887,
0.0393231921,
0.0392127223,
-0.0479660146,
-0.0245896,
-0.0233687405,
-0.0034074602,
-0.1294331849,
-0.0086068222,
0.0213882513,
-0.084382385,
0.0208812356,
-0.0008086078,
0.0028270727,
0.0080292532,
0.0351478495,
-0.020451637,
-0.0279566236,
0.0204612594,
0.030984126,
0.0276292767,
-0.0899524316,
-0.0015832712,
-0.0192522295,
0.0223301779,
0.010013287,
0.0082765967,
-0.0376313627,
-0.0553686917,
0.0914373398,
-0.0269011352,
0.0083787534,
0.0230585821,
0.0059057819,
0.0364013426,
-0.0145752141,
-0.0253404416,
0.0203244258,
0.0099043017,
-0.0364465974,
-0.0307471082,
0.0639031678,
0.0052411905,
-0.0284151044,
0.023808524,
-0.0163615905,
-0.0072064591,
0.0423619151,
0.0555859134,
-0.0235460605,
0.0032891459,
-0.0317517444,
0.0161449742,
-0.0201569553,
-0.0279810168,
0.0371770412,
-0.0457205363,
0.0383936577,
-0.0336457267,
-0.0711312816,
-0.0097533967,
-0.0279827397,
0.0328388624,
-0.0001548059,
-0.0312629156,
-0.0842306316,
-0.0083437031,
0.0760695711,
-0.0207171272,
0.0201872587,
-0.0520432889,
-0.0249741673,
-0.0020176452,
-0.0427995697,
-0.0273164231,
-0.0648873746,
-0.0259954743,
-0.0640149191,
0.0596407987,
0.0471682623,
0.0134663815,
0.0314030461,
0.0245779268,
-0.0302271899,
0.0320181437,
-0.0133465249,
-0.0289190449,
0.0381658971,
0.0280041862,
-0.0214232989,
0.0244256705,
0.0472759753,
-0.0129301036,
0.0205134321,
0.0612355657,
-0.0173180047,
-0.00140321,
0.0400031097,
0.037881162,
0.0434533171,
0.0512795262,
-0.0229321364,
0.0170232095,
-0.0562032945,
-0.0122441379,
-0.0304920729,
-0.0109824575,
0.0017987838,
-0.0161350816,
0.0582213923,
0.0496269464,
0.0139612425,
0.0451020338,
0.0307283886,
0.0231214259,
0.0013723151,
0.0043656249,
0.0351588242,
0.0239569154,
0.0475697219,
0.0577818826,
0.0352445692,
0.0522212125,
-0.01963141,
0.0484212115,
-0.0374732949,
0.0123649444,
0.030836666,
0.0212343503,
-0.0113546103,
-0.0247996375,
-0.0065070116,
-0.0263704918,
0.0341734067,
-0.0198493302,
0.036140047,
-0.094016619,
0.0805030465,
-0.0360227078,
0.0037688939,
-0.0121469507,
0.0043218574,
0.012202247,
-0.0455035083,
0.0478962362,
-0.0274803713,
-0.0372187793,
-0.0159283336,
0.062979579,
-0.0122356052,
0.0373365246,
-0.021283241,
0.0187978633,
-0.0114642447,
0.0398718305,
0.0370628759,
-0.0128804827,
-0.0231729858,
0.0312762298,
-0.0551007912,
-0.0821593776,
-0.076807119,
-0.0022079446,
-0.0129268682,
-0.0222141892,
0.0087890141,
0.0818596631,
-0.0086528836,
-0.001421491,
-0.0337347388,
0.0032588751,
0.0306473039,
-0.0034170086,
-0.0009438553,
-6.214923856e-33,
-0.004853501,
0.0295307282,
-0.0226900112,
-0.0348968804,
0.0010817378,
0.0194951762,
-0.0240097716,
0.0387232862,
-0.0268133655,
0.0308117531,
-0.0127670281,
-0.0128295217,
0.0239640754,
-0.0230184365,
0.0360240862,
0.004105302,
0.014737702,
-0.0128148366,
-0.0244052578,
-0.0239810366,
0.011707359,
0.0066736918,
0.1067055389,
-0.0302655715,
0.0538080521,
-0.0106159747,
0.0235234983,
-0.0232048966,
-0.0476109348,
0.0284560323,
-0.0209751111,
0.0317588337,
0.0312539451,
-0.0081137903,
-0.0275291428,
0.0380602032,
-0.0597762577,
-0.0691012144,
0.1003978625,
0.0285503007,
-0.0507872663,
-0.0402080901,
0.0127399452,
-0.0397495143,
-0.0372479483,
0.0149318147,
-0.000893665,
-0.0010556668,
0.0067663831,
0.0107768942,
-0.0689927861,
-0.0197362136,
0.0133498898,
0.0262677185,
0.0512515269,
0.0677397996,
-0.0110224718,
-0.0619586259,
-0.0460414141,
0.0179610364,
-0.0146737583,
0.0325174928,
0.061000444,
0.0114873815,
0.0349958055,
0.0463603623,
0.0681148991,
0.0648324043,
0.060605891,
0.0314752907,
0.0702907667,
-0.016903419,
-0.0014622459,
0.0353456698,
0.0152426092,
-0.0263163801,
-0.0460050665,
-0.0333092809,
0.0131778121,
0.0065259738,
-0.0063718827,
-0.0088373953,
0.0389777981,
-0.0589139946,
-0.0663858056,
-0.0574407652,
0.0118916472,
-0.0235838909,
0.0266559962,
-0.0089659225,
0.0055845091,
0.0008595525,
0.0616766997,
-0.0304923244,
-0.0869079679,
-0.0050408673,
-0.0026799852,
0.004892787,
0.0072197528,
0.0510397889,
-0.0986183584,
-0.0326658301,
-0.0420213379,
0.0031854911,
0.0308244433,
0.055493094,
0.0476953313,
-0.0068514845,
-0.0224242099,
-0.0068630138,
-0.0400837772,
0.0095891906,
0.0379783586,
0.026108548,
0.0861167163,
0.0472876579,
0.001977483,
0.0011121191,
0.0727240816,
-0.0090083517,
-0.037864022,
0.0149795087,
-0.0250861868,
0.0747268647,
0.0015404201,
0.0123335021,
-0.0738969594,
0.0490960032,
0.0978396609,
-0.0393839143,
-0.030072052,
0.0037792607,
2.635e-7,
0.0394888781,
0.0230860375,
-0.0121267289,
0.0242590196,
-0.0010603793,
0.0085173957,
-0.0441757552,
0.0209867768,
0.0291779023,
-0.017963402,
-0.0567594841,
-0.0009849885,
0.0423527174,
0.0371952876,
-0.0553182252,
-0.0110571962,
-0.0303563215,
0.0148727,
-0.0371661521,
0.0253820606,
-0.0311641339,
0.0662179738,
-0.0160537139,
0.0104282191,
-0.0339022279,
-0.0009935487,
0.0597122535,
-0.031503763,
-0.0299520567,
0.0214511957,
-0.0236573983,
0.0017184278,
0.0143324062,
0.0573545508,
-0.0081829997,
0.0300670303,
0.005286281,
-0.0321622193,
0.0173578057,
0.0220226124,
0.0270404536,
-0.0291016996,
-0.0648337007,
-0.0841478854,
0.0548608489,
-0.0655814782,
-0.0277418848,
0.007693084,
-0.0336940549,
0.0353412516,
0.0528406799,
0.0059470991,
-0.0365386866,
0.0332368761,
0.0416941717,
0.0297124237,
-0.0149830114,
0.0057898299,
-0.0406126827,
0.0446274653,
0.004495231,
-0.0345063619,
0.0014146696,
-0.0013516811,
-0.0045364941,
-0.0408724211,
0.0058855359,
2.167736479e-34,
0.0111288149,
-0.0130408406,
0.062810801,
-0.0316266492,
0.0326489061,
-0.0663369745,
0.0249758512,
0.0326236673,
-0.0226261579,
-0.0290246755,
0.0065837745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07923v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07923v5 | The Expressive Power of Transformers with Chain of Thought | 2023-10-11T22:35:18 | 2024-04-11T18:03:53 | William Merrill, Ashish Sabharwal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.LO | Recent theoretical work has identified surprisingly simple reasoning
problems, such as checking if two nodes in a graph are connected or simulating
finite-state machines, that are provably unsolvable by standard transformers
that answer immediately after reading their input. However, in practice,
transformers' reasoning can be improved by allowing them to use a "chain of
thought" or "scratchpad", i.e., generate and condition on a sequence of
intermediate tokens before answering. Motivated by this, we ask: Does such
intermediate generation fundamentally extend the computational power of a
decoder-only transformer? We show that the answer is yes, but the amount of
increase depends crucially on the amount of intermediate generation. For
instance, we find that transformer decoders with a logarithmic number of
decoding steps (w.r.t. the input length) push the limits of standard
transformers only slightly, while a linear number of decoding steps, assuming
projected pre-norm (a slight generalization of standard pre-norm), adds a clear
new ability (under standard complexity conjectures): recognizing all regular
languages. Our results also imply that linear steps keep transformer decoders
within context-sensitive languages, and polynomial steps with generalized
pre-norm make them recognize exactly the class of polynomial-time solvable
problems -- the first exact characterization of a type of transformers in terms
of standard complexity classes. Together, this provides a nuanced framework for
understanding how the length of a transformer's chain of thought or scratchpad
impacts its reasoning power. | [
0.002821703,
0.0643055439,
0.0080798566,
0.0047598714,
-0.0340584666,
-0.0046421089,
-0.0401124917,
-0.0036896158,
-0.0343174003,
-0.0077947294,
0.0226865187,
0.0006664162,
0.0100755431,
0.0175306275,
0.013887763,
-0.0673218071,
0.0166294854,
-0.0290869456,
-0.0178392287,
-0.0238115173,
-0.0549570695,
-0.0289392564,
-0.0406775288,
0.0151757728,
-0.0137807187,
-0.0127674621,
-0.0385625921,
-0.063210696,
0.0018195999,
0.000350768,
-0.0589699261,
0.0111513296,
-0.0314718634,
0.0279446468,
0.0000019954,
-0.0271128826,
-0.0230763275,
0.0191903766,
-0.0641638115,
-0.031938199,
-0.0642472133,
-0.03891721,
0.0069614127,
0.0435452349,
-0.0430777743,
-0.0674140304,
0.07573843,
0.0483288728,
0.0226720478,
0.0448523797,
-0.0126276836,
-0.0406025834,
0.0519211628,
0.0204786975,
0.0352620371,
-0.0457264446,
-0.0177099071,
-0.0530458391,
0.0259726085,
-0.0326761566,
-0.0464550443,
-0.0135071669,
0.0475371741,
-0.0016964906,
-0.0407161005,
0.0242373329,
0.0263899323,
-0.0138935586,
-0.0303322114,
0.0129595427,
-0.0213629361,
-0.0177246518,
-0.030723203,
0.0187650025,
-0.0115782917,
0.0142192282,
0.0147924898,
0.0275926199,
-0.0449745394,
0.0192020871,
0.0092280246,
0.0246329401,
0.0318387002,
-0.072748147,
-0.0781944618,
0.1123618484,
0.0059431694,
-0.0173434727,
-0.0215569511,
0.0323893987,
0.0396510623,
-0.0466098152,
-0.0017956868,
0.0553218126,
-0.0110716196,
-0.0012578927,
-0.0009116869,
0.0305681638,
-0.0384570211,
0.0519227087,
0.009884892,
0.0402541794,
0.0386706516,
0.0184043981,
0.0024134223,
0.0688526183,
-0.0703466237,
0.0431957059,
-0.0215349197,
0.0004423157,
-0.0063291071,
-0.0106517738,
-0.0657345057,
0.0380571857,
0.0141990455,
0.0148333274,
-0.0009208205,
0.0385505743,
0.0063567637,
0.011649901,
-0.0758802295,
-0.0260718372,
-0.0088892998,
-0.0087143518,
-0.0143694608,
0.0565905012,
-0.0145895062,
0.0019133119,
-0.0079739345,
-0.0624629855,
-0.0344378911,
-0.0253705308,
0.0314657576,
0.0029786176,
0.0033803289,
0.0801673904,
-0.034017887,
-0.0459149852,
0.0323441662,
-0.0253336038,
0.03943865,
-0.0285733268,
0.0585577004,
-0.0333607905,
0.0206012633,
0.062573567,
0.0248098206,
-0.0326653495,
-0.0190035868,
-0.0206022933,
0.0274300184,
0.0652297139,
0.0080244625,
0.0088257482,
-0.0361723378,
0.0060101789,
-0.0263175238,
-0.0045390157,
0.0120325498,
-0.0063334554,
0.016435774,
0.006711151,
0.0787861347,
0.0352194011,
-0.0196782108,
-0.0265597552,
0.0691610053,
-0.0335557796,
-0.0108329654,
-0.0203551166,
-0.0621217936,
0.0954298005,
-0.0161292069,
0.0092001501,
-0.0321573317,
0.0453384109,
0.0468742736,
0.0661873743,
0.0614729375,
0.032220535,
0.0283816494,
0.0890766829,
-0.0162111558,
0.0036596677,
-0.0118280891,
0.0009321553,
-0.0356230624,
-0.0104455585,
-0.0035199863,
-0.0609639026,
-0.0116007803,
0.0159416255,
0.0146392742,
-0.0424970277,
0.0476853698,
0.025251152,
-0.0591249056,
0.0411663838,
-0.0282839015,
-0.0384145603,
-0.0115360748,
-0.0448138379,
0.0146147842,
-0.0281774532,
0.0300986748,
-0.0419503599,
0.0372306183,
0.0167239979,
-0.0267568044,
0.0155992005,
0.0537925586,
0.0012905993,
0.0268133339,
0.0164723005,
-0.0008791552,
0.0135206524,
0.0274291746,
-0.026040148,
-0.0056658876,
-0.0257782042,
-0.0158461872,
-0.0036941105,
0.0431296825,
-0.0066016535,
0.0243528243,
-0.0303919986,
0.0014611259,
0.0559701808,
0.0351170786,
0.0066087465,
-0.0210325941,
0.0505165085,
0.0176928993,
-0.0185802523,
-0.0321263783,
0.0101017887,
-0.0411595404,
-0.0039364304,
-0.0209014658,
-0.0898836628,
-0.0249561481,
0.0567152537,
-0.0117919706,
-0.0252272356,
0.0427253097,
-0.0633233339,
0.0552394427,
0.0450142212,
0.0380950272,
-0.0293806866,
-0.0006850979,
-0.0043178354,
0.0399107672,
0.0007868138,
0.0272405203,
-0.0002548108,
-0.0247023404,
0.0175698046,
0.0399541818,
-0.0663776323,
0.0333860479,
-0.0364852659,
0.0072366255,
0.0462280549,
-0.0175601505,
0.0012357656,
-0.0452019013,
-0.0251486078,
-0.0144986436,
-0.0140874414,
0.0348090529,
-0.0154915359,
0.0319350734,
0.0333232358,
0.0029478432,
-0.0306814462,
0.0139346775,
0.0380458497,
0.0065240781,
0.0307216048,
0.0337221362,
-0.0712651834,
0.0247083921,
-0.0183179528,
-0.0276676845,
0.0618033819,
0.0032112317,
-0.0480445288,
-0.0235074442,
0.0123157911,
0.0037465827,
0.0207146853,
-0.0511431769,
0.0039399425,
0.0567247421,
-0.0131739583,
0.0217064135,
0.017679859,
0.0094332946,
0.0471250042,
-0.0169150457,
-0.0000492992,
0.0221441649,
0.0231004413,
-0.0304134246,
-0.0579642206,
-0.0450028889,
-0.0162871778,
0.0417767279,
0.1180342436,
-0.0319675617,
-0.0205135737,
-0.0552367717,
-0.01876745,
0.0060921097,
0.0354085974,
0.0363307931,
-0.0484843291,
-0.0148102185,
0.0689803958,
0.0029701849,
-0.0285959635,
0.0514634438,
-0.0291746017,
-0.0019625477,
-0.0071722404,
-0.0094844364,
-0.0627954081,
0.0895744339,
0.0356131867,
-0.0087282127,
-0.0171229206,
-0.0288722608,
-0.014353645,
0.0012257971,
0.022880625,
-0.0238480158,
0.0307447799,
-0.0108770048,
0.0114948405,
-0.0495728962,
-0.0731751844,
-0.0597928688,
0.049611222,
-0.0271577537,
-0.0234442726,
0.0641784668,
-0.0404918194,
-0.0545114838,
0.0105545362,
-0.0036113539,
0.048593197,
0.0346206725,
-0.0240335409,
-0.0032555338,
0.0108079407,
-0.0552697591,
0.0519765131,
0.0423258021,
-0.0195469055,
0.0384388603,
0.0685868859,
0.0293114185,
-0.0098125311,
-0.0102715064,
0.0400888287,
0.0533061773,
-0.0124447746,
-0.0241316669,
0.0337060317,
0.015192274,
-0.0245503094,
-0.0674433783,
0.0271329042,
0.0126436381,
-0.0298898406,
0.0313459262,
-0.0124595203,
-0.0107434671,
0.0157491155,
0.0395255536,
-0.1093944237,
-0.0034966113,
0.0153439771,
-0.0131509192,
-0.0673085749,
-0.0422122963,
-0.0352290459,
-0.0625875145,
-0.0307319965,
0.0008588378,
-0.0152981244,
-0.048337087,
0.0060583884,
0.0058633932,
0.0475668199,
-0.0509520844,
0.0022518982,
-0.0147456564,
0.0001705503,
0.0354024917,
0.0091736903,
-0.0044664545,
-0.0215611141,
0.0404330119,
-0.0199481305,
-0.0012974206,
-0.0002776616,
-0.0138923246,
-0.0630213767,
0.0308432262,
0.0184531193,
-0.0178883132,
0.0214814395,
-0.0369924121,
0.0334197134,
-0.0261955857,
-0.0112835318,
0.0004782674,
-0.0051257219,
-0.0070796744,
0.0173864216,
0.0787502304,
-0.0115980729,
-0.0716676414,
0.0173861776,
-0.0322480984,
-0.0194747429,
0.004375698,
0.0093596736,
0.0087777218,
-0.0398354568,
-0.0653199404,
0.0148911141,
-0.0178305265,
-0.0946137235,
0.0121069029,
0.066478774,
-0.0446557254,
-0.0141144553,
0.0324641988,
0.0382573754,
0.035337612,
-0.0040291538,
-0.0413574502,
0.0643704012,
0.0007780719,
-0.057443846,
-0.028064454,
-0.0256942771,
0.0148076685,
-0.059757188,
0.0309258774,
0.009443244,
-0.0098875649,
-0.0394911021,
-0.0109498287,
-0.0560244024,
-0.0170938931,
0.0487282239,
-0.0004736637,
0.0351039693,
-0.0333715305,
0.0297631677,
0.0091291014,
0.0076652472,
0.0457375981,
-0.0480806418,
0.0115749035,
0.0722155422,
-0.0420003608,
0.0171604231,
0.0218119677,
-0.0046053538,
0.0067193168,
0.0016054738,
0.0266896896,
0.0122285737,
-0.0230828561,
0.0624727383,
0.030581817,
0.0188442562,
0.0592939295,
0.0485739596,
0.022945296,
0.0206414964,
0.0271787345,
-0.0184148606,
-0.0868545324,
-0.0173686296,
-0.0303309336,
0.0297045279,
0.016579112,
-0.0199839361,
0.0195912924,
0.0473986007,
0.0453452058,
0.0191267133,
-0.0052735512,
-0.0066212756,
0.0453115515,
-0.0005049633,
-0.0066516851,
0.0164985098,
0.0313325413,
0.0297725108,
0.0297509171,
0.0342477746,
0.0515543371,
0.0263382252,
-0.0685218871,
-0.0086500812,
-0.0837458298,
-0.0592266582,
0.0573422015,
-0.0126337595,
-0.0092506111,
0.0364032574,
-0.0331852734,
-0.0325424299,
0.0121163372,
0.0243702251,
0.0099662645,
-0.0171156973,
-0.0630961061,
0.0418339297,
0.0427809395,
0.0514458008,
0.006047565,
0.0417563133,
-0.0344075635,
0.0165541638,
-0.0150385424,
0.012540495,
-0.0557231829,
-0.0576217845,
-0.071355857,
0.0109981755,
0.04484782,
0.0220543724,
-0.0889396742,
-0.0731609538,
0.0080225877,
-0.0220424347,
0.0587390363,
-0.035223376,
0.0294270627,
0.0393108018,
0.0454031639,
-0.0164689254,
-0.0045269611,
0.010452644,
0.0446647704,
0.0210923925,
0.0000608982,
-5.772393212e-33,
-0.010750507,
-0.0680578202,
0.0195775889,
0.0249569546,
-0.0085133454,
0.0135468561,
-0.0680677891,
0.0181119964,
-0.0096540572,
0.0170118194,
-0.0339128114,
0.0001539603,
0.001538077,
0.0591473691,
-0.0545042679,
-0.0369455442,
0.0441747047,
0.0126283104,
-0.0589601547,
0.0008055922,
0.018365724,
-0.0687220171,
0.0108258538,
0.0109868264,
0.0218792818,
-0.0398537181,
0.0008359671,
0.0212146677,
-0.0451791883,
0.0355593935,
0.0066556456,
0.0169615671,
0.0181275774,
-0.0607797317,
-0.0102012809,
0.0430728011,
-0.0684052035,
-0.014439363,
0.0184022319,
0.0170375519,
-0.0513071269,
-0.0244120974,
0.0115766497,
-0.0113378512,
-0.0182787254,
-0.0184703879,
-0.0215457994,
0.0148452809,
0.0164853279,
-0.0314549059,
0.0038488694,
0.0060438216,
-0.0507039055,
-0.0134639563,
-0.0045308471,
0.0457853451,
-0.0062641413,
-0.0180506427,
-0.0219306871,
0.0392784029,
0.0308036711,
-0.0299449749,
0.0198735856,
-0.0272836592,
-0.0307693556,
-0.0080407783,
0.0564449951,
-0.014564584,
-0.0299266241,
0.0141453156,
-0.0382136628,
0.0326876454,
0.0337561928,
-0.0155703099,
0.0573277175,
0.0226808079,
-0.0221282169,
-0.0167646781,
-0.0145395622,
0.0612083115,
0.0288198162,
-0.049901545,
-0.0319578834,
-0.0714686885,
-0.0517140143,
0.0275834315,
-0.013815199,
0.0330680646,
-0.0162245072,
0.0189682487,
-0.022762727,
-0.0158611853,
0.0530166291,
-0.0428469777,
0.0152682047,
0.0527936295,
0.0088779377,
0.0335479043,
-0.0198028814,
0.0098655866,
0.0447706804,
-0.0096416716,
-0.0031520333,
-0.0213588644,
0.0166884754,
-0.0100676771,
-0.0149133001,
0.0477978215,
-0.0552003197,
-0.0146088433,
-0.0601909347,
0.0350270569,
-0.0042550219,
0.0459626466,
0.0551501699,
0.0226661265,
-0.0182403009,
0.0114020687,
-0.0492236987,
-0.0032299417,
-0.0160366129,
0.1189537793,
-0.0153678954,
0.0378776267,
-0.024452785,
-0.0688232929,
-0.0496319756,
0.0618041083,
0.0520435423,
-0.073668845,
-0.024026759,
-0.007006696,
2.903e-7,
0.0112675158,
-0.0316394456,
0.0959686488,
0.0212925598,
0.0522757843,
0.021613501,
0.0286061671,
0.0175451133,
-0.0157372728,
0.0153424479,
-0.0071589979,
0.0222371928,
-0.014122379,
0.0203265287,
-0.041679021,
-0.0316728838,
-0.0159096215,
-0.0000075279,
0.0238046721,
0.0228839815,
0.0651466176,
0.030434221,
-0.0104594072,
-0.0037977709,
-0.0020728132,
-0.0219134837,
0.0065620537,
0.0084103318,
0.0603547394,
0.0065012253,
-0.0145960087,
-0.0057518035,
0.029601628,
0.0091187647,
0.0068214852,
0.0336137824,
-0.0209840816,
0.0237881783,
0.0831799954,
-0.004845723,
-0.0087150605,
-0.0333949104,
-0.0240939558,
0.0345744416,
0.0384383909,
-0.0726549402,
-0.0595394485,
0.0468468517,
-0.0016832027,
-0.0277006999,
-0.0337962471,
0.0442119204,
-0.0094372947,
0.0084206751,
0.0002036325,
-0.0042969664,
0.0382822119,
-0.044545237,
-0.00006423,
-0.0488417745,
-0.038915433,
-0.0296034869,
-0.0073675844,
-0.0041517513,
0.0342880599,
0.0064363335,
-0.0118164793,
3.017117473e-34,
0.0184287317,
-0.0320421942,
0.0378804356,
0.0082711652,
0.0464927778,
-0.0535663739,
0.0132542523,
0.005464361,
0.0810221508,
-0.0891477242,
-0.0249246489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07911v1 | Pit One Against Many: Leveraging Attention-head Embeddings for Parameter-efficient Multi-head Attention | 2023-10-11T21:38:40 | 2023-10-11T21:38:40 | Huiyin Xue, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scaling pre-trained language models has resulted in large performance gains
in various natural language processing tasks but comes with a large cost in
memory requirements. Inspired by the position embeddings in transformers, we
aim to simplify and reduce the memory footprint of the multi-head attention
(MHA) mechanism. We propose an alternative module that uses only a single
shared projection matrix and multiple head embeddings (MHE), i.e. one per head.
We empirically demonstrate that our MHE attention is substantially more memory
efficient compared to alternative attention mechanisms while achieving high
predictive performance retention ratio to vanilla MHA on several downstream
tasks. MHE attention only requires a negligible fraction of additional
parameters ($3nd$, where $n$ is the number of attention heads and $d$ the size
of the head embeddings) compared to a single-head attention, while MHA requires
$(3n^2-3n)d^2-3nd$ additional parameters. | [
0.0084391003,
0.0232350826,
0.0021356435,
0.0113471337,
0.0120988181,
0.0150150154,
0.0168289375,
-0.0408262722,
0.0148297744,
-0.0308057293,
-0.0568838902,
-0.0456523895,
0.0071814028,
-0.0176902935,
0.0219857451,
-0.0529361665,
0.0569923408,
0.0043481411,
-0.0326132067,
0.0160339121,
0.0245419387,
-0.0230325088,
0.0199707095,
0.0361834094,
-0.0236159489,
-0.021065563,
-0.0321382061,
-0.0378176346,
0.0326373018,
-0.0132038677,
0.0143925566,
0.0673866421,
0.0372727402,
0.0231739245,
0.000002214,
0.0057358015,
0.0177131724,
0.0026199326,
-0.0111859087,
0.0643506944,
-0.0118641527,
0.005001178,
0.0151626989,
0.0093814051,
0.001246949,
-0.0531425066,
0.0615579374,
0.0514262915,
0.0615286343,
0.0561074764,
-0.0072496254,
-0.0405745395,
0.0217684768,
-0.0610513315,
0.0233269185,
-0.0250051823,
0.0044895164,
-0.0463965535,
-0.0625155792,
0.0236443523,
-0.0280203465,
0.045407854,
0.0251605399,
0.0224044099,
0.018281728,
0.0525991693,
-0.0365017019,
0.0077642789,
-0.0355368927,
0.0773220882,
-0.0580891706,
-0.011058975,
-0.0240066089,
-0.0249583758,
-0.0035549402,
-0.0377791561,
-0.0486993641,
0.0261034481,
0.0403271653,
0.0106982859,
-0.0044072913,
0.0468003377,
0.0320074894,
-0.0354387499,
-0.0281293876,
0.0086259274,
0.0182661414,
-0.0102088423,
0.0022254412,
0.0266838055,
-0.0232987795,
0.0101190256,
0.0037953344,
0.0217018668,
0.0127019472,
0.0132340156,
-0.0321184099,
-0.0524400659,
0.017825488,
-0.0816611052,
0.0909728855,
0.0572876632,
-0.0342991352,
0.0617532432,
-0.0455334112,
0.0358051062,
-0.0590969734,
0.0351767503,
-0.0221327934,
0.0086482288,
0.0103431791,
0.0098137837,
-0.0527895056,
0.0125501584,
-0.0040351036,
-0.0441909023,
-0.0008259877,
0.0185435507,
0.005465474,
-0.0156130819,
0.0364586972,
0.0352597646,
-0.0296212025,
-0.0073667141,
0.0328441858,
0.0828606561,
-0.0322444066,
-0.0239119474,
-0.0143305706,
-0.0424610823,
-0.0734296665,
0.049959328,
0.008097196,
-0.0398898795,
-0.0024143674,
0.060191758,
-0.0075895577,
-0.0765145868,
-0.0011997321,
0.0260934848,
0.0066873687,
-0.0622115545,
0.0355338976,
-0.0112884333,
0.0597962365,
-0.0219939258,
-0.0134443054,
-0.0075408951,
0.013148698,
0.0475024246,
-0.0445922576,
0.0441222303,
0.0608104914,
-0.0179997776,
-0.0047112629,
0.0275288876,
-0.0102011347,
0.0587263927,
0.0114448303,
0.0321656875,
0.0123759909,
-0.0392642505,
-0.0412933528,
0.0110352216,
0.0251204651,
-0.023616543,
0.0241612233,
0.0117783984,
0.0396535248,
0.0104318941,
0.0430719778,
0.0175247584,
-0.0279910527,
-0.0050563971,
0.051518824,
0.0441206023,
0.0185587555,
0.0294070877,
0.044059027,
-0.0164341275,
-0.0047614444,
-0.0093094893,
-0.0818732455,
0.074776724,
0.0063800914,
-0.0238236208,
0.0151276775,
0.0228058938,
-0.0426406078,
-0.0194809325,
0.0251327511,
-0.0078029674,
-0.0263815243,
0.001625305,
0.0279013477,
-0.0335871093,
-0.0686845407,
0.0713732988,
0.0150620108,
-0.0582266711,
0.0020542608,
-0.0061850138,
-0.0230395868,
0.0223805606,
-0.0031928669,
-0.0556103624,
-0.0357082859,
-0.0067070494,
0.0315062702,
0.0114524756,
0.0516741872,
0.0371540748,
0.0332571603,
-0.0474321358,
0.0140399467,
-0.0243738424,
0.0195658486,
0.0203109533,
0.0406183749,
0.0195634402,
0.0323178284,
0.0352266468,
0.0440066569,
0.0336086787,
-0.0144115165,
-0.0152197005,
-0.0270132888,
0.0023157217,
0.0202707071,
-0.0164362323,
-0.0043314993,
0.0253989585,
0.0647450089,
-0.0399965234,
0.0332915485,
0.0035777811,
-0.0753204226,
-0.0142098116,
0.0297125354,
-0.0040849214,
0.0000884452,
0.0564528853,
-0.0235981811,
-0.0255473144,
0.0142878769,
-0.0397043116,
0.0769772381,
-0.0363769382,
0.00598145,
-0.0089634201,
0.0679291338,
-0.0284291897,
0.0378686897,
-0.0404436998,
0.008680989,
0.0118689928,
-0.0516623519,
0.0129544809,
-0.0013598994,
-0.0465453714,
0.0093932711,
0.0095317559,
0.0332609415,
-0.0156166926,
-0.0338034406,
-0.0330288708,
-0.0105836736,
-0.0592745431,
0.0260633584,
-0.0553420149,
0.0103003783,
0.0232033916,
-0.0054687988,
0.0218830146,
-0.0313100629,
-0.0181366913,
-0.0128628565,
-0.0215169583,
0.0337888524,
-0.004593343,
-0.0240814146,
0.0131977843,
-0.028560685,
-0.0425929688,
0.0102252634,
0.06354592,
-0.0303604472,
-0.0122310771,
-0.0496911034,
0.0086903237,
-0.0180672109,
0.0220733136,
-0.0053999256,
-0.0318381526,
-0.0162730962,
-0.0343705267,
0.078479819,
0.0907571092,
-0.0079843607,
0.0259204749,
0.0784696788,
-0.020715002,
-0.0206217598,
0.0316559449,
-0.0359911583,
0.0192567911,
-0.0081049874,
0.0167237576,
-0.0096389502,
0.0425384045,
-0.0034819813,
0.0013020859,
-0.0582872592,
-0.0109036854,
0.0270700082,
-0.0102108158,
-0.0128426645,
-0.0050484985,
-0.0396858416,
0.0057033217,
-0.0104313716,
-0.0337207615,
0.0371938273,
-0.0354282185,
-0.0319667757,
-0.0063578845,
0.0140679199,
-0.0267032944,
0.0419345312,
0.0362346843,
0.0171213672,
-0.0406627208,
-0.0306545515,
-0.0390110165,
0.0390523896,
0.0220308881,
-0.0162260793,
0.0383862406,
0.0196480695,
-0.0151142096,
-0.0439154394,
-0.0182150546,
-0.041357372,
-0.02531063,
-0.0242898408,
0.0180532131,
0.0170541015,
-0.0138605693,
-0.085675329,
0.0111688506,
0.043433398,
0.0673969164,
0.0113263903,
0.0255515184,
-0.0042406339,
0.0302502848,
-0.0048960238,
0.0632870048,
0.0284966975,
-0.0144336671,
0.0144389514,
0.0787549764,
0.0201372579,
-0.0200310536,
-0.04667072,
-0.011519962,
0.033128906,
-0.0422739983,
-0.0351729728,
0.0069184522,
0.0171975121,
-0.0706837028,
-0.0046617882,
0.0851466134,
0.0225727744,
-0.0566908307,
-0.0115339505,
0.0112043554,
0.0514444634,
0.0287096556,
0.0228725933,
-0.0180811137,
-0.0325989723,
0.005679396,
-0.0073299706,
0.0615023598,
-0.0380604193,
-0.0269864891,
-0.0802304745,
0.0254352,
0.0094670141,
-0.0237650014,
-0.0323112682,
-0.0360059515,
-0.0083546722,
0.0073969234,
-0.0135460347,
0.0174419135,
0.0023934206,
-0.0242171083,
0.0065765968,
-0.019062493,
-0.0131251523,
0.0430044085,
-0.0181456804,
0.0076940674,
0.0427742898,
-0.0142222112,
0.0177075975,
-0.0679854304,
-0.0135367177,
-0.0469265543,
-0.0102848494,
0.0119587425,
0.0568803139,
-0.0528203659,
-0.0190687384,
-0.0394341163,
-0.0069992361,
-0.0406707525,
-0.017890336,
-0.0365197957,
0.1149199754,
-0.0015609183,
-0.0162017234,
-0.0207580868,
0.0130621251,
-0.0376031213,
0.0560509115,
0.0554679036,
-0.042340178,
-0.0281689242,
0.0028491654,
0.0174849443,
-0.0050221765,
-0.0410604216,
0.0237801503,
0.0260651987,
-0.0390664563,
-0.0282876156,
-0.0281325541,
0.0415720418,
0.0147654079,
-0.0149163771,
-0.0312132016,
0.0246728733,
0.0126060164,
-0.0492822751,
0.026921045,
-0.0180073604,
-0.012540549,
-0.0566434525,
0.0241623782,
0.04532855,
0.0326472819,
-0.0158569906,
0.020673167,
-0.0972225964,
-0.0441011973,
0.0058236928,
0.0709345639,
0.003930673,
0.011213121,
0.0027905055,
-0.0337415673,
-0.0047901282,
-0.0060238168,
-0.0129569275,
0.0514461473,
0.0555693023,
-0.0313972831,
-0.002459649,
0.0396710038,
0.0030694413,
0.024180064,
0.0074230819,
0.0242689569,
0.0166844837,
-0.0396297127,
-0.0126145268,
-0.0112585118,
0.0919822231,
0.0136698699,
0.0678253397,
-0.0097446525,
0.0235339869,
-0.0207885243,
-0.0030835508,
-0.0313530602,
-0.0083532501,
0.0168197677,
-0.0250105653,
-0.0253916886,
0.0575996377,
0.0387157872,
-0.0224621799,
-0.0200427175,
0.0250526797,
-0.0274803154,
-0.062651284,
-0.0067034643,
0.0500866286,
-0.0400168635,
-0.0212581772,
-0.0091771744,
0.023233369,
-0.0304159801,
0.0355402976,
0.0125818038,
-0.0045593078,
-0.0504409187,
0.0214902516,
-0.0654821843,
-0.0431734845,
-0.0013528151,
-0.0052937474,
0.0345749483,
-0.0438504629,
0.0267391596,
0.014486202,
-0.0213650726,
-0.0072744405,
0.0250892211,
-0.0060972739,
-0.0255774334,
0.0203119144,
0.0073893052,
-0.0124974437,
-0.0021932316,
0.0637551546,
-0.0053960341,
0.0042031389,
0.0125651443,
-0.0177237596,
-0.0435350612,
-0.0667052269,
-0.0066375635,
0.0312401429,
-0.0018721014,
0.0114163421,
-0.0532937013,
-0.0565440468,
-0.0100422679,
-0.0425865985,
-0.0304485727,
-0.00673969,
0.0186819565,
0.0022676352,
-0.0026806693,
-0.0257154591,
0.0056331703,
0.0222577099,
0.004021782,
-0.0199078321,
0.0119774872,
-6.257190225e-33,
-0.0104852496,
0.0158172827,
-0.0062179822,
-0.0449192636,
-0.0449790098,
0.0174734164,
-0.0169374198,
0.0173395723,
-0.0414793305,
-0.0232442264,
-0.016041629,
0.0120520759,
0.0041846759,
0.0184798315,
0.0092477538,
-0.0006588023,
0.042783007,
-0.026298089,
-0.0191307142,
0.033951845,
0.0219917875,
0.0452127904,
0.086579226,
0.0339146741,
-0.0355375409,
-0.0031303328,
-0.0113099841,
-0.0035525777,
-0.0106591526,
0.0165455807,
-0.0577275418,
0.0308109112,
0.0288219582,
-0.0565334633,
-0.039664302,
0.0453676991,
-0.1075338721,
-0.0408840813,
-0.009876499,
0.0012109638,
-0.0327274278,
0.0095208986,
0.0247583073,
0.0059922147,
0.0584088005,
-0.0538530424,
0.0091123302,
0.0192712005,
-0.0702625662,
0.0430076085,
-0.0376683325,
0.0037760683,
-0.0065467912,
0.0007646253,
0.0297026653,
0.0324227065,
0.0247828774,
0.0641767681,
-0.109430626,
-0.0112658171,
-0.0100272428,
0.0369930454,
0.0277518071,
0.0055613308,
0.0095662056,
0.0672057793,
0.0054574148,
-0.0217011031,
-0.0563854054,
-0.0220642202,
0.0312718116,
0.009893544,
0.0352983549,
-0.0252540205,
0.0525821559,
-0.0167326685,
-0.0889163688,
-0.0225232057,
0.0032313995,
0.0697451606,
0.0451022275,
0.0058237906,
-0.0279425513,
-0.0240201522,
-0.0173861589,
0.0179420952,
-0.0277922358,
-0.0375617668,
0.0444857366,
0.0373563804,
-0.0296018869,
0.0378138125,
0.0609806813,
-0.0248367842,
0.0451126434,
0.044231791,
-0.0192852952,
0.0345956497,
0.0008586446,
0.031893611,
-0.0467205346,
0.0272894055,
-0.0031385946,
-0.0273184255,
-0.0086500235,
-0.0226799138,
0.0592128336,
0.0364741161,
-0.0898054838,
-0.016426893,
-0.0384663604,
-0.002324872,
0.0158083402,
0.0686331615,
0.0252131056,
0.009342514,
-0.0062769372,
0.0568171106,
0.012881632,
-0.0086155729,
-0.0282096136,
0.0032389923,
0.030542111,
0.0281727333,
-0.0044029225,
0.0048493673,
-0.0728059337,
0.0370499939,
0.0522619486,
-0.0867701545,
-0.0115829837,
0.0044599418,
2.826e-7,
0.0574881062,
0.0280627124,
-0.0018764697,
-0.0164949782,
0.0248359907,
0.017010266,
0.021731019,
0.0558220595,
-0.0403119996,
0.0004737916,
0.0012749459,
0.0471106656,
0.0014702315,
-0.0094297687,
-0.0656232312,
-0.0639491752,
-0.0782845318,
0.011547327,
-0.0303088911,
-0.0556165799,
-0.0064002778,
0.1356444508,
0.0025445784,
0.0265817381,
0.0053736833,
0.0139883198,
0.0840538442,
-0.025160443,
0.0085197054,
-0.0036808741,
0.0203172378,
0.0498333536,
-0.0574357137,
-0.0246994533,
-0.0173236392,
0.0203427915,
0.0193751566,
0.095626995,
-0.0033220558,
-0.0423324555,
0.0229730476,
0.011932306,
-0.0274813771,
-0.0231533907,
0.060717959,
-0.090105243,
-0.033812847,
-0.0227867905,
-0.0265738573,
0.0113338791,
0.0447814986,
0.0174403843,
0.009872118,
0.0161656123,
-0.0142509453,
-0.0366767608,
-0.0033671835,
-0.1343473792,
-0.0307311825,
0.0055942605,
-0.0455416292,
-0.0205589309,
-0.0617535226,
-0.0989940986,
0.0694638118,
-0.0430767313,
-0.0193598457,
2.440885091e-34,
0.0407119952,
-0.0286417399,
0.0455822684,
0.0291673597,
0.0011404566,
-0.0428063907,
0.028024124,
-0.0270220824,
0.029554477,
-0.0801492929,
-0.0405524001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07889v2 | LangNav: Language as a Perceptual Representation for Navigation | 2023-10-11T20:52:30 | 2024-03-30T22:00:22 | Bowen Pan, Rameswar Panda, SouYoung Jin, Rogerio Feris, Aude Oliva, Phillip Isola, Yoon Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | We explore the use of language as a perceptual representation for
vision-and-language navigation (VLN), with a focus on low-data settings. Our
approach uses off-the-shelf vision systems for image captioning and object
detection to convert an agent's egocentric panoramic view at each time step
into natural language descriptions. We then finetune a pretrained language
model to select an action, based on the current view and the trajectory
history, that would best fulfill the navigation instructions. In contrast to
the standard setup which adapts a pretrained language model to work directly
with continuous visual features from pretrained vision models, our approach
instead uses (discrete) language as the perceptual representation. We explore
several use cases of our language-based navigation (LangNav) approach on the
R2R VLN benchmark: generating synthetic trajectories from a prompted language
model (GPT-4) with which to finetune a smaller language model; domain transfer
where we transfer a policy learned on one simulated environment (ALFRED) to
another (more realistic) environment (R2R); and combining both vision- and
language-based representations for VLN. Our approach is found to improve upon
baselines that rely on visual features in settings where only a few expert
trajectories (10-100) are available, demonstrating the potential of language as
a perceptual representation for navigation. | [
0.0548601002,
0.029641483,
0.0090314597,
0.0500029512,
-0.0320173576,
0.0138337109,
-0.002688373,
-0.0275622215,
0.0153133292,
-0.0978000686,
-0.0111643551,
-0.0178193599,
0.0077459817,
0.0626214147,
0.0273049008,
-0.08002951,
0.026146289,
-0.0835385695,
0.0117565775,
0.0197796505,
0.0107551264,
0.0095254462,
-0.0133014228,
0.0446465127,
-0.0121122031,
0.0305709392,
-0.0268618669,
0.0135413185,
0.0417949706,
-0.0374478586,
-0.0302443001,
0.0215671118,
0.1032130867,
-0.0115700616,
0.0000017898,
-0.0099723367,
0.0512796901,
-0.0249324981,
0.0068248953,
-0.0678783208,
0.0566684119,
-0.0237791557,
-0.0068179467,
-0.0127219399,
-0.045726154,
-0.0391516052,
0.0393176004,
0.0349213108,
0.0598230995,
0.0666918084,
-0.0230718404,
-0.0450820252,
-0.0440725684,
0.0064856131,
0.000527236,
-0.0291462336,
-0.0038468051,
0.0285323672,
-0.0250918493,
0.0383287817,
-0.0590610057,
0.0041343337,
0.0048721801,
-0.0128532099,
-0.001367215,
0.0755661279,
-0.0205122512,
-0.0251464378,
-0.0514234118,
0.111151278,
-0.0226471703,
-0.0225505941,
-0.009881557,
0.0155591536,
-0.0288302526,
-0.0456557833,
0.003385795,
0.0133315362,
0.0100437766,
0.0375689007,
-0.0055911057,
0.0065765036,
0.0008703041,
-0.0040037096,
-0.0342965871,
-0.0053410647,
0.0133483065,
0.0441287011,
0.0260906778,
0.0131246913,
-0.0021725839,
-0.0796685517,
-0.0007457423,
0.0320013724,
-0.0063090883,
0.0271045119,
-0.0610212311,
0.0652938858,
-0.0483420566,
-0.0478816666,
0.0517649986,
0.0336099379,
-0.0290332083,
0.0618348531,
-0.0231865551,
0.0688432679,
0.0070770346,
0.0440593883,
-0.038511131,
-0.0025032358,
-0.0372629873,
0.0294217207,
-0.060124483,
0.0068233404,
-0.0430537537,
-0.0522007011,
0.0056485315,
0.0227637328,
-0.0062400312,
0.0094842194,
-0.0323438458,
0.0328836888,
-0.0275676455,
-0.009345728,
-0.0350578465,
0.0129370829,
-0.014798061,
0.0125020659,
-0.0130894184,
-0.0332210474,
0.0256906692,
0.0398161188,
0.0054212371,
-0.0038525902,
-0.0061581731,
0.1108321771,
-0.025469292,
-0.0440017059,
-0.0227793511,
0.009842624,
0.0006945998,
-0.0645710155,
0.008601319,
-0.0857146606,
0.0362484753,
-0.0074332738,
-0.0068225469,
-0.0643553287,
0.0135351075,
0.0039327866,
-0.0347219631,
0.0805115327,
-0.0028195733,
-0.0073694098,
-0.0007549518,
-0.0058519654,
0.0503597297,
0.0780070797,
0.0610752106,
0.0269651394,
0.0004562626,
0.0279976483,
0.0267351139,
0.0255882721,
-0.0275842343,
0.0434206687,
-0.0523732007,
0.0133595085,
-0.0114327827,
0.0193749834,
0.0555634946,
0.0493168235,
-0.04473361,
-0.0007737103,
0.0451014154,
0.0738918409,
-0.0162679683,
-0.0069304937,
0.0823582113,
-0.0130491378,
0.0008775633,
-0.0208182037,
-0.0673983619,
0.0492449962,
0.0076624509,
-0.0252565499,
-0.0338773243,
0.0267908722,
-0.046682369,
-0.0373535231,
0.0269499961,
-0.0006996429,
0.0231164191,
0.0048631495,
0.0277404096,
-0.0105174333,
-0.0329214931,
0.0049618976,
0.0090722507,
-0.0303225089,
0.0114088077,
-0.0212786011,
-0.0201941878,
0.0903415903,
0.0064262487,
0.0393797942,
-0.0295508187,
-0.0100005353,
0.046934247,
0.0402280167,
0.0541101806,
-0.0033502853,
0.0457890593,
-0.0390866324,
-0.0700268671,
0.0190471541,
-0.0114860227,
0.0509026088,
-0.0170502532,
0.0271005649,
0.0349666737,
-0.0021927734,
-0.0493064635,
0.0436109863,
0.027597649,
-0.0244431384,
-0.0037897869,
0.0142288189,
-0.0197413862,
0.0077518639,
-0.0144114969,
-0.0091207242,
0.0085996995,
-0.0037531774,
0.0350048803,
0.0544432551,
-0.0340526551,
-0.0525383912,
0.02109446,
-0.0748479962,
-0.0188461393,
0.0197469536,
-0.0427673869,
-0.0447854549,
-0.0158516634,
-0.0498987287,
-0.0203664098,
-0.0029701886,
-0.0183024257,
0.0500943437,
0.0045327242,
-0.0170534961,
0.038217023,
0.0137153193,
-0.0044213585,
0.0190809499,
0.0045152432,
0.0172602348,
-0.0374580845,
0.0006624011,
-0.0016806634,
0.033799801,
0.0059411274,
0.0550895259,
0.0412908979,
-0.0368806124,
0.0166549515,
-0.0712020546,
-0.0424808785,
-0.0393173844,
-0.0238472875,
0.0197200924,
-0.0316963643,
0.0122399665,
-0.0340125822,
-0.0263945088,
0.0442958251,
0.0159530509,
-0.0004905114,
0.0188718643,
0.0016797492,
-0.0420585871,
-0.0593463145,
0.0120625375,
-0.0032047534,
0.0042844778,
0.039454069,
-0.0218981709,
-0.0829563886,
0.0045789196,
-0.0267924964,
0.0703746229,
-0.0371950306,
-0.0415072553,
0.0220337119,
-0.0466889776,
-0.0102684563,
0.0367427506,
-0.0249560382,
0.0185999684,
0.0569442287,
-0.0477961227,
-0.0505015515,
0.0059289793,
-0.0175201911,
-0.0208318308,
-0.0922478288,
-0.0113044549,
0.0007006543,
0.0085467743,
-0.0238189138,
0.0178043675,
-0.0760658458,
-0.002275116,
-0.02362925,
-0.0419696793,
-0.0181666072,
0.0642601177,
-0.0207029115,
0.0506349206,
-0.019054452,
-0.0433151051,
0.0386728011,
-0.0183963384,
-0.0258717295,
-0.0153957149,
0.0035070188,
-0.0008119709,
0.0702031627,
0.0677649528,
0.0441541672,
-0.0377401039,
-0.0117972558,
-0.0240376201,
-0.0390600152,
-0.0023196815,
0.0128724249,
0.0647098497,
-0.1099612862,
0.0337002762,
0.0013482638,
-0.0024371021,
-0.0214741565,
-0.0167572387,
-0.0561698079,
0.0052975267,
-0.0405707434,
-0.0159834381,
-0.026626531,
0.0444641039,
0.0129085779,
0.0670046583,
0.0292378217,
-0.027926404,
-0.0243780203,
-0.0175476391,
0.085495688,
0.0247482192,
-0.03961071,
-0.0125856176,
0.0393668599,
0.0390795544,
0.0144363167,
-0.0089591965,
-0.0614588223,
0.0511114709,
0.0343317501,
0.0155492509,
-0.0009786447,
0.0739330724,
0.055110164,
-0.0391894728,
-0.0615630522,
0.0906641185,
0.0097546829,
-0.0358184278,
-0.0068484601,
0.0380128585,
0.0149083072,
0.0464200005,
0.0445988812,
-0.0264992788,
-0.0449232049,
-0.011646877,
-0.027310418,
0.028950762,
-0.0043844259,
-0.0392824449,
-0.0679124296,
0.0335590355,
0.0360840634,
-0.0651380271,
-0.023733763,
0.0037671179,
0.0036331872,
-0.01231529,
-0.0339761376,
-0.0252007935,
-0.0041083023,
-0.0255792402,
-0.0204313155,
-0.0042151664,
-0.0161188357,
0.0052779624,
-0.0170878749,
0.0306663159,
0.0509025231,
0.024889309,
-0.0123118628,
-0.0250477921,
0.014199947,
0.0173724499,
0.0308557879,
-0.0192263573,
0.0346475169,
-0.0223396607,
-0.0247814655,
0.0408921316,
0.0256017987,
-0.0374913551,
-0.0359943956,
-0.0014517212,
0.0095268544,
-0.0488224253,
-0.0057549914,
-0.0198826715,
0.0088533582,
0.0324889347,
0.037890017,
-0.0023240454,
-0.0074951942,
-0.0634590536,
-0.0445053205,
-0.0321399458,
-0.0371396765,
-0.0834543109,
-0.0017952354,
-0.002737053,
-0.0479663275,
-0.0616686456,
-0.0652331859,
0.0582545213,
0.0880521163,
0.0291255489,
-0.039485395,
0.0215228852,
0.0177207775,
-0.0087561728,
0.0180173703,
-0.0698952824,
0.0305979196,
-0.0444209911,
-0.0081623532,
0.031117592,
-0.0017977514,
-0.0069177682,
0.0304856002,
-0.0357371159,
-0.075620234,
-0.0066541247,
0.0691149756,
0.0176731907,
0.0522328839,
-0.0051860083,
-0.0215727035,
0.0490958504,
-0.0026727682,
0.0321588181,
0.0116019072,
0.005045813,
-0.0051036468,
-0.0155254714,
0.034196347,
-0.0360232741,
0.0129660647,
0.0023553523,
0.0267553125,
-0.0380254649,
-0.0272896346,
0.0260115825,
-0.0408020318,
0.0685708895,
-0.0109180603,
0.0349985994,
-0.0038703396,
-0.015673548,
-0.0413338132,
-0.0062204544,
-0.0741989836,
-0.0005124694,
0.0161841996,
0.038603846,
0.0375726558,
-0.0034537127,
-0.0230731331,
-0.0152669474,
0.0080525586,
-0.0263587516,
0.0333777405,
0.0134343039,
0.0073639792,
0.0177120697,
-0.0070435656,
0.0107158972,
-0.0059898677,
0.0373432897,
-0.0054189605,
0.0355699174,
0.0544635467,
-0.0233802702,
-0.045105774,
0.0193003397,
-0.0520931557,
-0.0575831532,
-0.0107733663,
0.059495762,
0.0771103278,
-0.0218066387,
0.0387568884,
-0.0650133044,
0.0175488424,
-0.006372741,
0.0104621388,
0.0226802845,
-0.0493632965,
0.0823212862,
0.0082505187,
0.003654608,
-0.0150039671,
0.0650463179,
0.0257189181,
0.0392972454,
0.0129021928,
-0.0094758701,
-0.0410047732,
-0.0104948413,
-0.0141573623,
0.0028357974,
-0.0043607303,
0.0399129577,
-0.0179013256,
-0.0495844819,
-0.0339842662,
0.0078211837,
-0.018865047,
-0.0156226903,
0.0737295896,
0.0234204605,
0.0014598621,
-0.0154658305,
-0.0282810684,
-0.0342267714,
-0.0094453255,
-0.0094877128,
-0.048517745,
-5.356754205e-33,
-0.0387189165,
-0.0417429097,
0.0682494715,
0.0059928657,
-0.0166629478,
-0.0269061811,
-0.0437660404,
0.0048275897,
-0.0176625215,
0.0419408157,
0.0338408723,
0.0102502732,
0.0224116594,
0.0383921713,
-0.0036696163,
-0.0000271812,
0.0391763709,
-0.0077083623,
-0.0393543094,
0.0006984408,
0.0313306823,
-0.0213219915,
0.0444619916,
-0.0716561452,
-0.0122918142,
0.0014622175,
-0.0118550668,
0.0428985432,
0.0388018973,
0.0366843268,
-0.0156938806,
0.0145242335,
-0.0001575961,
-0.0208579861,
-0.0411129259,
0.0101448121,
-0.0150522972,
-0.0707924291,
0.0153879235,
0.0569285788,
-0.051929988,
-0.0136303576,
0.0130730532,
-0.0307979994,
-0.0174849126,
0.020269027,
0.045876544,
-0.0141567402,
-0.0210673958,
0.047364179,
-0.0708118752,
0.0046410831,
-0.0024826436,
-0.0389910862,
0.0546169281,
0.0409850776,
-0.0080708312,
-0.0285911895,
-0.0130587751,
0.0306468979,
-0.0067621302,
0.0119684748,
0.0699187368,
0.0598436259,
0.0196342841,
0.0589257702,
0.0442863256,
-0.0113474233,
-0.0246423148,
0.0165138487,
0.0286740977,
0.0413291231,
0.0040156939,
0.0478334762,
-0.0217532776,
0.0182271544,
-0.0318150967,
0.0049750288,
-0.0577873699,
0.0640350953,
-0.0206528958,
0.0058905003,
-0.0475857221,
-0.0117786583,
-0.0501299314,
-0.019486608,
0.0026655446,
-0.0343204476,
0.0397969559,
0.0189652294,
0.0032476732,
-0.0061810352,
0.0639038607,
-0.0327147655,
-0.0442786962,
0.0136372764,
-0.0241440684,
0.0160592217,
0.0145769184,
0.0389528461,
-0.0372814313,
-0.0500674322,
0.0320866518,
-0.0000367822,
0.0157906022,
-0.001041751,
0.0001190288,
0.0572085381,
-0.0396527387,
-0.0129065895,
-0.0511392914,
-0.0370752364,
0.0189599041,
0.0162818208,
0.0431863815,
-0.0027485404,
-0.0534953848,
0.0360568352,
-0.0182381328,
-0.07753364,
0.0214924924,
0.0038823111,
-0.001521034,
0.0483402312,
-0.0389586389,
0.0104786763,
-0.0419234484,
0.0197873432,
0.0238703676,
-0.0324649364,
-0.0007689873,
0.0587052442,
2.462e-7,
-0.0114107672,
0.0272991005,
0.0110935718,
-0.010443938,
0.0035532718,
0.052801773,
-0.0340255275,
0.0419510864,
-0.0232530478,
-0.0102578485,
0.0208073761,
0.0579989478,
0.0038857316,
-0.0042814603,
-0.0188653301,
0.0513859317,
0.0446151979,
-0.0177499186,
-0.0573233888,
-0.0093476949,
0.0837695077,
0.0763329789,
-0.013604518,
0.002287159,
0.0247920211,
-0.0652363747,
0.0724173039,
-0.0524960682,
0.0063071419,
-0.0233657267,
0.0146740275,
0.0786553621,
-0.0597621128,
-0.0007118917,
-0.0131874206,
-0.0119650895,
0.0018767847,
0.0615171753,
-0.0489148945,
-0.0245921947,
-0.0221335888,
0.0095784245,
-0.0033799056,
-0.0272866841,
0.0569865853,
-0.076801464,
0.0124451034,
-0.0131402817,
-0.0028072088,
0.0015540698,
-0.0032814716,
-0.0115794856,
-0.058094997,
-0.0169018097,
0.0384200849,
0.0020022632,
-0.0183237307,
-0.0721860901,
0.0204760861,
0.0075195357,
-0.009143699,
0.0096371286,
-0.0415013246,
0.0376025662,
0.0397359654,
0.0038114951,
-0.0208237544,
1.536389369e-34,
0.0123234792,
-0.0120616499,
-0.004160428,
-0.0289511923,
0.0030385172,
0.0084109148,
0.0046481178,
0.0153204044,
0.0227523074,
-0.0429720171,
-0.0390920117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07875v1 | TabLib: A Dataset of 627M Tables with Context | 2023-10-11T20:34:42 | 2023-10-11T20:34:42 | Gus Eggert, Kevin Huo, Mike Biven, Justin Waugh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG | It is well-established that large, diverse datasets play a pivotal role in
the performance of modern AI systems for text and image modalities. However,
there are no datasets for tabular data of comparable size and diversity to
those available for text and images. Thus we present "TabLib'', a compilation
of 627 million tables totaling 69 TiB, along with 867B tokens of context.
TabLib was extracted from numerous file formats, including CSV, HTML, SQLite,
PDF, Excel, and others, sourced from GitHub and Common Crawl. The size and
diversity of TabLib offer considerable promise in the table modality,
reminiscent of the original promise of foundational datasets for text and
images, such as The Pile and LAION. | [
0.002766242,
0.0902666897,
-0.0100420592,
0.0197158214,
-0.0198187325,
0.0431038328,
0.0185212214,
0.0442926437,
-0.0173213743,
0.0037333663,
-0.0609734915,
0.0057510077,
-0.0123228449,
0.0629118234,
0.0038929142,
-0.0047028386,
-0.0040096454,
0.0001252927,
-0.0470358804,
0.0401969701,
-0.0204953104,
-0.0193150602,
-0.0187363345,
0.0193467494,
-0.0470533855,
0.0109381387,
-0.0553900898,
0.0173314251,
-0.0313367061,
-0.0061230185,
-0.0298556946,
0.053326007,
0.0538544506,
0.037985716,
0.0000018967,
0.0485092476,
-0.02070795,
-0.03174657,
0.0202195309,
-0.0052738241,
0.0697492287,
-0.0478510149,
-0.0273288321,
-0.0392875634,
-0.0331896059,
-0.0018712051,
0.0511486977,
0.0289859213,
0.0492183715,
0.0448481105,
-0.0117141576,
-0.0170095544,
0.0092899594,
-0.0091199623,
0.0907910988,
-0.0441761948,
0.0142385801,
-0.0043408866,
0.0174465571,
-0.0317655616,
-0.0050750524,
0.0603304729,
0.0611906834,
-0.0431968234,
-0.0039203432,
0.0584909059,
-0.0415804163,
0.006982374,
-0.0112610152,
0.0863751918,
0.0054294732,
-0.0240470208,
0.0112399934,
0.007480693,
0.012874024,
-0.0307682995,
-0.0596734956,
0.0278262049,
-0.0109923398,
-0.0171660595,
-0.0269667804,
-0.0085386634,
0.0004653831,
-0.0141006224,
-0.0315076746,
0.0055437684,
-0.0196716841,
-0.0344470106,
-0.0127329044,
-0.012551954,
0.0278076623,
-0.0497640967,
0.005589515,
0.0252742916,
-0.0295455605,
0.0023650858,
-0.0189972464,
-0.0597768724,
-0.0052910731,
-0.0044884006,
0.0594334975,
0.0197999999,
-0.0361869149,
0.0496156067,
-0.0144822132,
0.0143181626,
-0.0314945988,
0.0302365907,
-0.0040376899,
-0.0307138879,
-0.0312500373,
0.0243877452,
-0.0335924998,
-0.0007515224,
-0.0765247792,
-0.0313397534,
0.0097571509,
0.0397609323,
-0.0206291508,
0.069909066,
0.0057474403,
0.0458249599,
-0.0314837992,
-0.0034593577,
-0.0176688191,
-0.0389776193,
-0.0340856463,
0.0063834428,
0.0050689164,
-0.0569924638,
0.0039567701,
0.0000314322,
0.0570579357,
-0.0284448359,
0.0572057813,
0.0642330721,
-0.0347234979,
-0.025935201,
-0.0244231746,
-0.0068785176,
-0.0124858562,
-0.0456474572,
0.0075180004,
-0.045943033,
0.0550189912,
-0.0181553103,
-0.0040147561,
-0.0652672425,
-0.0025665415,
0.0406244397,
-0.0097575905,
0.1000017673,
-0.0005359825,
-0.0014741598,
0.0056121862,
-0.0158666763,
-0.0617506914,
0.0418523885,
0.0313235223,
0.0806581974,
-0.0090259202,
-0.0053560552,
-0.0003273882,
0.0262533948,
0.0204138029,
0.0005480854,
-0.0237442013,
0.0379911773,
-0.007995246,
0.0335714221,
-0.0166220181,
-0.0087246504,
-0.025448285,
-0.0100041442,
0.0483811758,
0.0452883057,
0.0160008222,
0.0901656002,
0.0216331985,
-0.0242560878,
0.0379610434,
-0.0076473122,
-0.0267866533,
0.0582382232,
0.0394818261,
-0.0126063628,
0.0290790629,
0.0086089643,
-0.020348046,
-0.062310189,
0.0362755284,
0.0040320121,
0.030115597,
-0.0215809699,
0.0543393791,
0.0085019274,
-0.057408534,
-0.0883738399,
-0.0073104003,
-0.0653709397,
-0.0511129573,
-0.0053594825,
0.0211053547,
0.0654418468,
0.0309889261,
-0.0938596502,
-0.0211824998,
0.0087459441,
0.0173314493,
0.0352923013,
0.0020262655,
-0.0476538651,
0.0273881927,
-0.0324414559,
-0.0348495394,
0.0146483276,
-0.0024544885,
0.0221620835,
0.0258099325,
0.0154676661,
0.0126736658,
-0.0202019308,
-0.0015811104,
0.0309916176,
0.0323716141,
-0.0016867471,
0.0053558871,
0.0123758959,
0.030442996,
0.0257292092,
-0.0237360112,
-0.0016879193,
0.0727751181,
-0.0125913657,
0.0204578005,
-0.0068797967,
-0.0095725916,
0.034687724,
0.020442633,
-0.0144527974,
-0.0463796705,
-0.0017402646,
-0.0251974724,
-0.0438237339,
0.01244043,
-0.0019129333,
-0.0211903062,
-0.0065198587,
-0.0027231136,
0.0032530208,
0.0211274065,
0.0260250196,
0.0718671903,
-0.0097860992,
0.0006663879,
0.0315250866,
-0.0494831279,
0.0233903509,
-0.0261621401,
0.0304948427,
-0.0172378868,
-0.0118132094,
0.0352819972,
0.0301944707,
0.0394890942,
-0.0532902926,
-0.0068625938,
-0.1244444549,
0.0350410007,
-0.0311983395,
-0.0001210203,
0.0243874993,
0.0046557686,
-0.0073773805,
-0.0462725125,
-0.0384360142,
0.0228237603,
-0.0230006147,
-0.0205092672,
0.0557421371,
0.0317489877,
-0.0068233409,
-0.034934368,
-0.0383897275,
-0.0304531213,
-0.0000443356,
0.0075565134,
-0.0482272394,
0.0325379707,
-0.0278383419,
0.0166520085,
0.0457081385,
0.0057150456,
-0.00754346,
0.0094240876,
-0.0428254157,
0.0167783182,
0.0882142484,
-0.0260112789,
0.0624030791,
-0.0054799952,
-0.0100112194,
-0.0187764447,
0.033480715,
0.0197787415,
0.0382288657,
-0.0018793442,
-0.0495250337,
0.0419134796,
0.0272658467,
-0.0362626202,
0.0405343287,
-0.0411924273,
0.0186596289,
0.0364390202,
-0.0306768548,
-0.0523311757,
0.0703944415,
0.0097775497,
0.0080904169,
-0.0312921628,
-0.0060717063,
-0.0077524092,
-0.0221970063,
0.0033329348,
0.012356922,
-0.0225060098,
-0.0473851599,
0.103099674,
0.0379232764,
0.0109317899,
-0.0080631152,
-0.0176783912,
-0.0503112413,
0.0270581339,
-0.0005258454,
0.0052537904,
0.0948351771,
-0.0585332252,
0.0180246588,
-0.0071804509,
-0.067869395,
-0.0120551642,
-0.0428681634,
-0.004830644,
-0.0030110583,
0.0213747583,
-0.0465614609,
-0.0905470774,
-0.0564554371,
0.0321846902,
0.0868411511,
0.0081362436,
-0.0396690816,
-0.042115733,
0.0639227256,
0.0107898097,
-0.0020631645,
-0.0455317087,
-0.0104697244,
-0.0210736841,
0.0547550768,
-0.0041045919,
-0.0047691967,
-0.0386276133,
0.040852271,
-0.0001830642,
-0.0090069901,
-0.0044516991,
0.0367867127,
-0.0357778221,
-0.04660476,
-0.0197454374,
0.0535673983,
0.0294709988,
-0.0259690043,
-0.0455023386,
0.0122078145,
0.0164703578,
0.0111301756,
0.0150933191,
-0.1009873226,
-0.0365560912,
-0.0030290254,
-0.0298634768,
0.0181240384,
-0.0419406407,
-0.0177149866,
-0.0429735631,
0.0633361638,
-0.0135724414,
-0.0727846324,
-0.0848203674,
-0.0028625531,
-0.0084670642,
-0.0484543703,
-0.000731485,
0.0456871875,
-0.0297233518,
0.0039218673,
0.0141959805,
0.0339192636,
-0.003035679,
-0.0190085154,
-0.053469304,
0.0343563966,
0.034979213,
0.0760528371,
-0.0220908392,
-0.0174098425,
0.0121290553,
0.0393915698,
-0.0118810032,
-0.0145892492,
0.0806223676,
-0.0038009093,
-0.0061870548,
0.0083115594,
0.0106938109,
-0.0521612652,
-0.0044948608,
0.0238996875,
0.033605665,
-0.0376846083,
0.0150563726,
-0.0106887734,
-0.0389044881,
0.0028869971,
0.0437344536,
0.0340276323,
-0.0061613149,
-0.0584995188,
-0.0294957291,
-0.0424541123,
-0.0527861603,
0.0246530622,
0.0366977267,
-0.0264439005,
-0.0426354557,
-0.0665820912,
-0.0055916579,
0.0356639661,
0.0602261908,
-0.0039637336,
0.0175153073,
-0.0434855632,
-0.0079328185,
-0.066656746,
-0.0056602969,
-0.0518041626,
-0.0143231247,
-0.0256415959,
-0.05870343,
0.0004936483,
-0.056659963,
-0.0108424323,
0.0426982827,
-0.0593209453,
0.0283119325,
0.0096016796,
0.0213153064,
0.0274927039,
0.0162137393,
0.0204123259,
-0.0151445232,
0.0164009929,
0.0274154693,
-0.0541589372,
-0.0383686088,
0.0066998317,
-0.0533655919,
0.0070783002,
0.0331061147,
-0.0294243023,
-0.0040186807,
-0.0152132679,
-0.0142809888,
0.022026971,
0.0387796648,
0.0114160087,
-0.0100012133,
-0.006271543,
0.0252697542,
-0.078031823,
-0.0339794122,
0.0172954481,
-0.0446057357,
-0.0343638845,
-0.0105916811,
-0.0045311828,
0.0211252533,
0.0158687197,
-0.0268367995,
0.0273086596,
0.0327858403,
0.0256564934,
-0.0588256456,
0.0028318248,
0.0603023618,
0.0066679595,
0.0266027171,
-0.0264931694,
-0.0014741751,
-0.0072427071,
-0.004561448,
0.055720862,
-0.0133508639,
-0.00492776,
0.0253247283,
-0.0750158057,
-0.0448431186,
0.0867716074,
-0.0774574205,
-0.0268764198,
-0.0045466195,
0.0280265063,
0.0374498405,
0.0182607565,
-0.0033359122,
-0.0369393788,
-0.0166237149,
0.0259132087,
0.0189236123,
0.0802671015,
-0.0034830195,
0.0076850061,
0.0042310506,
-0.0024287247,
-0.008449153,
0.0707434341,
0.0266343784,
0.0143064689,
0.0372481644,
-0.0235297643,
-0.0538263209,
0.0160981584,
0.0087473495,
0.0076961373,
-0.0104171848,
-0.0202885401,
-0.0012158108,
-0.0213322863,
0.0519554019,
0.061950203,
-0.0219808761,
0.0257166885,
0.0216503181,
0.04052829,
0.0605738312,
0.0178723764,
-0.0261086896,
0.0301972423,
-0.040328227,
-0.0625282899,
-0.0019264986,
-5.949789269e-33,
-0.024183929,
-0.0172722172,
0.037583746,
-0.0435535498,
-0.0104358438,
0.0044110068,
-0.0338585488,
-0.0287557188,
0.0087643173,
0.0002037125,
-0.0534778908,
0.0435589142,
0.03011957,
-0.0074526388,
0.0301048364,
-0.0703887343,
0.0182103999,
-0.0067719426,
-0.017297348,
0.0338690802,
-0.002167807,
0.03057345,
0.0049569192,
-0.0541960038,
0.0093760639,
0.0302421115,
-0.0101554962,
-0.0199336633,
0.0139292246,
0.0201506782,
-0.0447618701,
0.0146281142,
0.0169518478,
-0.0300612673,
-0.0215687454,
0.0249244571,
-0.1414498687,
-0.0205644574,
-0.0418402888,
0.0462432317,
-0.0270971153,
-0.0293477084,
0.0049134013,
-0.0366922505,
0.0123553155,
-0.0044482774,
0.0409823991,
-0.0450376049,
-0.0025534732,
0.0058105467,
-0.0062871552,
0.0095068915,
-0.0283109769,
-0.0002562046,
0.0965198055,
0.0110167982,
0.0499523133,
0.0118149277,
-0.0450407229,
0.0080100885,
-0.0299909059,
0.0074418383,
0.0669262335,
-0.014081385,
0.0474709794,
0.0342868268,
0.0603506602,
0.0014098263,
-0.0424936749,
-0.0154690873,
-0.048356276,
0.0943506807,
0.0228334721,
0.0055121859,
0.0367391445,
0.0052457652,
-0.0406746045,
0.0745066032,
0.0125322845,
-0.0076583368,
-0.0165781155,
0.0014643216,
-0.0202546325,
0.0253675375,
0.0161685012,
-0.029292535,
-0.0224261731,
0.0029810602,
0.0059134667,
0.0053335517,
0.0286250822,
0.0124549856,
0.0128225731,
-0.0214795098,
0.0165621806,
0.0374190696,
-0.0129414648,
0.0396529138,
0.0195283704,
-0.0265960898,
0.0187181849,
-0.0352608822,
0.049603004,
0.0102015985,
0.0558501706,
0.0228473172,
0.0727569833,
0.0441977307,
-0.0479577556,
-0.0152729517,
-0.0377006494,
0.0177342426,
0.0388368778,
0.008568801,
0.0013929867,
0.0167720411,
-0.0068232766,
0.0284878388,
0.0231985264,
0.0297549237,
0.0010198449,
-0.0055213557,
-0.0159891639,
-0.0426435284,
0.0134025086,
-0.0146847805,
-0.0767141059,
-0.0052985437,
0.0315894298,
-0.0376959443,
-0.0015164558,
0.0055810963,
2.342e-7,
0.0430855118,
0.0114860982,
0.0846756548,
0.0147738773,
0.0287366919,
0.0208874904,
-0.041851595,
0.0021605098,
-0.0747988075,
-0.0119176665,
0.07696677,
-0.0118686743,
0.0542374589,
0.0359390751,
-0.0270392932,
-0.0354870148,
-0.0509489812,
-0.0293310452,
-0.0683560446,
0.0070973421,
0.015678769,
0.1034061015,
-0.053563375,
-0.0324496441,
0.0355670713,
-0.0321970023,
0.0229109172,
-0.0840205401,
0.0839480385,
-0.0086868592,
0.0230044648,
-0.0027518224,
-0.037868049,
0.0200765394,
-0.0359466597,
0.0136863943,
0.0141211348,
0.0346627682,
-0.0099274125,
0.0280934554,
0.015587315,
-0.0552949496,
0.0316932313,
-0.0571062937,
0.0940679684,
-0.0015159523,
0.0058224429,
0.0610605329,
-0.0056045856,
0.0431366488,
0.0058863224,
0.0078132171,
0.0008798012,
0.0167810861,
0.0288030487,
-0.0208581164,
0.0031649114,
-0.0753368363,
-0.0253590755,
0.0073897657,
-0.0175088532,
0.0213960446,
-0.0467155054,
-0.0315721184,
0.0001616333,
-0.0674760491,
-0.0294928141,
2.1005944e-34,
0.0286297128,
0.0005315853,
0.0322135873,
0.0268044341,
0.0531212315,
-0.0301834699,
-0.0033006531,
-0.0017267744,
-0.0143409679,
-0.0642688721,
-0.0157536361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07856v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07856v1 | Assessing Evaluation Metrics for Neural Test Oracle Generation | 2023-10-11T19:58:07 | 2023-10-11T19:58:07 | Jiho Shin, Hadi Hemmati, Moshi Wei, Song Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | In this work, we revisit existing oracle generation studies plus ChatGPT to
empirically investigate the current standing of their performance in both
NLG-based and test adequacy metrics. Specifically, we train and run four
state-of-the-art test oracle generation models on five NLG-based and two test
adequacy metrics for our analysis. We apply two different correlation analyses
between these two different sets of metrics. Surprisingly, we found no
significant correlation between the NLG-based metrics and test adequacy
metrics. For instance, oracles generated from ChatGPT on the project
activemq-artemis had the highest performance on all the NLG-based metrics among
the studied NOGs, however, it had the most number of projects with a decrease
in test adequacy metrics compared to all the studied NOGs. We further conduct a
qualitative analysis to explore the reasons behind our observations, we found
that oracles with high NLG-based metrics but low test adequacy metrics tend to
have complex or multiple chained method invocations within the oracle's
parameters, making it hard for the model to generate completely, affecting the
test adequacy metrics. On the other hand, oracles with low NLG-based metrics
but high test adequacy metrics tend to have to call different assertion types
or a different method that functions similarly to the ones in the ground truth.
Overall, this work complements prior studies on test oracle generation with an
extensive performance evaluation with both NLG and test adequacy metrics and
provides guidelines for better assessment of deep learning applications in
software test generation in the future. | [
-0.0193423312,
0.0418375172,
-0.0115940245,
-0.0066218288,
-0.0298391469,
-0.031098891,
-0.0070861466,
0.0213640463,
0.0708885118,
-0.0130630182,
0.0262868851,
0.0145458262,
-0.0141788907,
0.032768283,
0.0339693427,
0.0075177816,
0.0462702438,
-0.0051699453,
-0.0359152034,
0.0285968073,
-0.045517534,
-0.0126801813,
-0.0188488662,
0.0415691696,
-0.0239003263,
-0.0382911339,
-0.0054336842,
0.0400873795,
0.0029361276,
-0.0293956976,
-0.013948841,
-0.0171028879,
-0.0605410039,
0.0289003998,
0.0000021979,
-0.0371574908,
0.0288278051,
0.0551111959,
-0.0016231866,
0.069136709,
-0.045521412,
0.0449072085,
-0.0045948513,
0.0417612121,
-0.0034734909,
-0.0041773249,
0.0029502879,
0.0037594005,
0.062235035,
0.0794516504,
0.0176270567,
0.0489506647,
0.0441452116,
-0.0027885274,
0.0340222903,
-0.0594512001,
-0.0373908989,
0.0383798853,
0.0217072889,
-0.0116835646,
0.0488136336,
-0.0050086193,
0.0718991384,
0.0059328084,
-0.055999063,
0.0271330606,
-0.0472793244,
0.0258561708,
0.0172604676,
-0.0023474987,
-0.040968895,
-0.0352607705,
-0.0143738538,
0.0025765756,
0.0004231519,
-0.0301202182,
0.0396194123,
0.008562441,
-0.0001398438,
-0.0348053835,
0.0226887334,
-0.0013413795,
0.0146198906,
-0.0491705537,
-0.0420310907,
0.0436747558,
0.0016084537,
-0.0073037711,
0.0164144691,
-0.0088109253,
-0.0054969583,
-0.0140447253,
-0.0277013183,
0.0124661354,
-0.0734998509,
-0.018161308,
-0.018619949,
-0.0311370194,
0.048319988,
-0.0335182436,
0.0167901553,
0.0230102912,
-0.0460724868,
-0.01722854,
-0.0878688544,
0.1082819328,
0.0296963193,
0.0515685491,
-0.0123689733,
0.019005077,
-0.0233171601,
0.0095230639,
-0.0041667349,
0.0419734381,
0.0085287839,
-0.0101804342,
-0.0389174335,
0.028554026,
-0.0232171305,
0.0579874292,
-0.0424297266,
0.0113640493,
-0.0173569079,
0.0220257547,
-0.0125791728,
-0.0538019203,
-0.0319558568,
-0.0457535274,
0.0089650601,
-0.0847314224,
0.0260225534,
0.0086800829,
-0.0654658303,
-0.0001431544,
0.0256075207,
0.1126299649,
0.0105445152,
-0.008648172,
-0.0558155067,
-0.047532361,
0.0120788841,
-0.0461244881,
0.0125539321,
-0.033559233,
-0.0170188025,
-0.0200067554,
-0.0296499543,
-0.0034483885,
-0.0141788619,
0.0127356276,
0.0280284099,
0.0017516535,
0.0485882834,
-0.0114481226,
0.0184626523,
0.0479435958,
0.015282236,
0.0779766589,
0.042844709,
0.0092059001,
0.0235061329,
-0.0121412557,
-0.0060491683,
0.0101642488,
-0.005817649,
-0.0036684803,
-0.0120465262,
0.0203520395,
-0.006815712,
0.015396907,
-0.0300643761,
0.064400427,
-0.0130657172,
-0.036854513,
-0.0145811867,
0.0086545488,
0.0345755965,
-0.003714384,
0.0837481692,
-0.0079570636,
0.0233784765,
0.0186143778,
-0.0431747511,
0.040105056,
-0.0655612424,
0.0463742018,
-0.0085193012,
0.0501523092,
-0.0252828766,
-0.0744008049,
0.0032309906,
0.0057766917,
-0.0389897935,
0.0124774771,
0.0278712753,
0.0235389061,
-0.0717571527,
0.027258113,
0.0025967141,
-0.0608122833,
-0.0104413796,
-0.0774147883,
0.0255121216,
-0.0468268655,
0.0504947715,
-0.0567464903,
-0.0436050557,
0.0230028201,
-0.0628314614,
-0.0069415676,
0.0388003141,
0.0076215644,
-0.0391587242,
-0.0213819332,
-0.0154021,
-0.0386817977,
0.042874787,
0.0233700052,
0.0115028173,
-0.0065409564,
0.0344603583,
-0.0544583686,
-0.1031101048,
0.0389311016,
-0.0245705731,
-0.0304664522,
0.0512309819,
0.0047103907,
0.0331896432,
0.0171721298,
-0.0338240564,
0.0207578894,
0.0470698401,
0.0352701694,
-0.0003342364,
-0.0216524173,
-0.0417761579,
-0.0215691216,
-0.0382115841,
-0.0618853867,
0.0187729765,
0.0123070972,
-0.0447088219,
-0.0192723572,
-0.0011059758,
-0.001222337,
-0.0070080059,
0.0129934931,
-0.0036354298,
-0.0237274375,
-0.0182690471,
-0.0303873513,
0.0256310757,
0.0312618315,
0.0135971494,
0.0069500837,
0.0700098127,
0.0423279032,
0.0226019584,
-0.0452913977,
0.0000815299,
-0.0546476208,
0.0037482064,
0.0043141539,
0.0737535879,
-0.047565382,
-0.0333751813,
-0.0535553172,
0.0598603785,
-0.0319230668,
0.0465924926,
0.0135566415,
-0.0091706663,
0.0214873552,
0.010311679,
-0.0612677,
-0.0095781721,
0.0110654067,
-0.0004740466,
0.000801284,
-0.0267495774,
-0.0129852993,
-0.0167311579,
0.0081941988,
-0.0624778457,
0.0925975814,
-0.0222325418,
0.0259954389,
-0.0465981215,
0.0509545133,
-0.0094500985,
0.0027861085,
-0.028271582,
-0.0301278364,
0.0459396206,
0.0132606663,
-0.0190565884,
0.0365626141,
0.0218355488,
0.0074144052,
-0.020858448,
0.03737377,
-0.0467032827,
0.0125854919,
0.0499963425,
-0.0389755331,
0.0325660147,
-0.0292036794,
0.0416438207,
0.0068909605,
-0.023510674,
-0.0165254176,
-0.0519070178,
-0.0127686793,
-0.0177876372,
0.0291692074,
0.0031166577,
-0.0233868398,
-0.0087423045,
-0.0111241294,
-0.0018480077,
-0.0661563203,
0.0286918879,
-0.0376072414,
0.0081352293,
-0.0962454453,
0.0075453059,
-0.0519982018,
0.0768179595,
0.0051821559,
0.0266035274,
0.0203463808,
-0.0227042623,
-0.0392530002,
-0.0072405036,
-0.0465784781,
-0.0504073985,
0.0494183004,
-0.0209201239,
-0.0076033557,
0.0116207544,
-0.0072878939,
-0.0591843799,
0.0699134693,
0.0208687391,
0.0547407083,
-0.0037410331,
0.009924612,
0.0135481842,
0.024917338,
-0.0464125983,
0.0167752635,
0.0272658952,
-0.0347958356,
-0.0179645233,
-0.0516110919,
0.0134609202,
-0.0058362251,
0.0246386528,
0.0193981864,
0.0099310847,
-0.0053784698,
0.0240910575,
0.0446536168,
-0.0806648508,
-0.0172644593,
-0.0657282695,
-0.0364832804,
0.0187736414,
0.0621463507,
-0.0006728826,
-0.0562361367,
-0.0142279807,
0.0252740793,
0.0342907757,
0.0211920645,
0.0226872582,
0.0347548686,
0.0569416136,
0.0495267957,
0.0692821667,
-0.1197004467,
-0.0070376238,
0.00921873,
0.0237275455,
-0.0066428464,
-0.0027640539,
-0.0171736199,
-0.1254461855,
0.0167330094,
0.0028846757,
-0.0486281291,
0.005445262,
-0.0074586626,
-0.0170417372,
-0.0392045267,
0.0544247851,
0.0711357966,
0.0402986147,
-0.002997875,
0.0268660448,
-0.0497193001,
-0.0249882061,
0.0558170266,
-0.0592118911,
0.005657827,
0.0592451505,
0.0088043511,
-0.0018693956,
-0.0276976116,
0.0159969926,
-0.0355159938,
0.0671311021,
0.0085614063,
0.0468562581,
0.0491960607,
-0.0234935619,
0.0224489998,
0.0135072004,
-0.0476862676,
0.0680173486,
0.053125035,
0.0220871363,
-0.0059255036,
-0.0288645532,
-0.0375188477,
-0.0014602731,
-0.0125402883,
0.0344710238,
0.0395961106,
-0.0115669807,
-0.0400249101,
-0.0385766253,
-0.0138806337,
-0.0805298612,
-0.041979868,
0.0131753022,
-0.0475973375,
0.0274122208,
-0.049400948,
-0.0368358195,
0.0167401377,
0.0685435385,
0.0230614468,
-0.0953488946,
-0.0154117327,
-0.023134632,
0.0024773232,
0.0432618074,
0.0410920382,
0.0197975598,
-0.0226027053,
0.0172571894,
0.0367954671,
0.0122941667,
-0.0195165351,
0.027670851,
-0.029461002,
-0.0348390117,
-0.0108510973,
0.061805319,
0.0136587564,
-0.039689023,
-0.0670482889,
0.0063857171,
0.0032352712,
0.0414941423,
-0.0352000743,
0.0059902859,
0.0503800474,
-0.0696009621,
-0.0309987701,
-0.0194363594,
-0.062630035,
0.008528674,
-0.0090875747,
0.010662022,
0.057721477,
-0.0141715948,
0.0297437981,
0.0241022706,
0.0540132858,
0.0338585339,
-0.0641318336,
0.0170763284,
0.0189280659,
-0.0129044624,
0.0025746308,
-0.039491266,
0.0835868567,
-0.0130988657,
0.0288525485,
-0.0066820364,
-0.0294588227,
0.0102913147,
0.0524485856,
0.0357739218,
-0.0117406454,
0.0169665553,
0.0247358382,
0.0045484961,
-0.0304479413,
-0.025816204,
-0.0192255992,
-0.0109987678,
0.0429749005,
-0.0202069841,
0.0504224673,
0.0307730399,
0.0775865912,
-0.0106880106,
-0.0170567222,
-0.0231978279,
-0.0479560085,
-0.0248380266,
0.0300783589,
0.0145636732,
0.0362407304,
0.0017193491,
-0.0469423756,
0.0559443757,
-0.0131174093,
-0.0150849773,
-0.0213467814,
-0.0050362912,
-0.0115859108,
0.0247016307,
0.0137714036,
-0.0211924426,
0.0732810721,
-0.0242789574,
0.02833483,
-0.047040727,
0.0253512599,
-0.0366419815,
-0.0071480479,
0.0077891485,
0.0029512355,
-0.0239799041,
-0.0713580698,
-0.0209652223,
-0.0729164779,
0.0020715834,
0.0514024645,
0.056974262,
0.0150481649,
0.0135504585,
0.0820981711,
0.0058392785,
0.0093906103,
0.0063995356,
-0.068177402,
-0.0461392105,
-0.0233245715,
-0.0129476767,
-5.535818362e-33,
-0.0198170505,
-0.0159849413,
0.0437574089,
-0.0457196385,
0.015172651,
0.0244755559,
-0.0235778075,
0.0300024301,
-0.0172750466,
-0.0087409709,
-0.0115103265,
0.0106215291,
0.01612827,
0.000105118,
0.0206464678,
-0.0117712133,
0.0311556943,
-0.0225434974,
-0.0263443757,
0.0536217615,
-0.0046398304,
-0.0111622736,
-0.0125759309,
-0.0297945142,
-0.0050290134,
0.0107716778,
0.0156868752,
-0.0472546667,
-0.0646443591,
0.0504556261,
0.0167534444,
0.0131040793,
-0.016539596,
-0.0085988594,
0.0256906208,
-0.0522994623,
-0.0244682133,
-0.0451727882,
-0.0151842637,
-0.0247892607,
-0.0876443088,
-0.0073575801,
0.0456577092,
0.000768089,
-0.0171029121,
0.0079797814,
-0.0010335718,
0.0145772966,
-0.0054608588,
-0.0847053379,
-0.026390899,
0.0270419624,
-0.0552913398,
-0.0075055207,
-0.0663961172,
0.0645794198,
-0.024833193,
-0.031580288,
-0.0108817881,
-0.0257324819,
0.0209946856,
0.0062557403,
0.0465578772,
0.0101110796,
-0.0081837885,
0.0484439209,
0.0279081054,
0.0282413848,
0.0206318926,
0.0334679745,
0.0728614405,
0.0501558818,
0.0865004882,
0.0079796389,
0.0569412075,
-0.0107048424,
-0.0527322106,
0.0473617204,
0.0501602516,
-0.0181211289,
0.0535364226,
-0.011859946,
-0.0945675746,
0.0049795834,
-0.037794549,
-0.0198747069,
-0.0312686227,
-0.0528368242,
0.0722034052,
0.0144491298,
-0.0183178373,
0.036946252,
0.0365040861,
-0.0240772702,
0.0276756976,
0.0338093005,
-0.0493545495,
-0.026586147,
-0.0459556505,
-0.0007032637,
0.0124969343,
-0.0453904271,
0.011152341,
0.0078370655,
0.0606961735,
-0.007700704,
0.0367687978,
-0.0160694029,
-0.0418843739,
0.0166684352,
-0.0282569788,
0.0245777834,
0.0121637899,
-0.0138342623,
-0.0073916558,
-0.0014419042,
0.0068660071,
0.0331533253,
-0.0202804655,
-0.0307221245,
-0.0541365184,
0.0749413967,
0.0006188612,
0.0267301966,
-0.0041337865,
-0.0117305713,
-0.0028737402,
0.0219033007,
-0.0166910384,
-0.0511923954,
-0.044170253,
0.0821614265,
2.87e-7,
-0.0110982126,
0.0299329404,
-0.00916008,
0.0396405756,
-0.0032048083,
0.0115091251,
0.0107703721,
-0.0199467074,
0.0454639792,
-0.0099193593,
-0.0395815782,
-0.0364552811,
0.0130228149,
0.0291547719,
-0.0396400131,
0.0233295374,
-0.0360314734,
-0.0282555036,
-0.0559130535,
0.0126853036,
0.0345540456,
0.021769885,
-0.0241203364,
-0.0073608118,
0.0338430256,
-0.068486616,
-0.023066543,
0.0196861941,
-0.0016943018,
0.0770133585,
0.0579721257,
0.0162361059,
0.0267985761,
0.0458197147,
-0.0033908037,
-0.0130132362,
0.01593679,
0.0167463291,
0.0627893433,
-0.0329001509,
0.0377160423,
-0.0170952678,
0.0336723588,
-0.0403996743,
0.0540584736,
0.0178561155,
0.0061336062,
-0.0330068432,
-0.006102961,
-0.0460890047,
0.0183022935,
-0.0102231363,
0.0130676813,
0.0000967662,
-0.0009685077,
0.0010006276,
-0.0326298364,
-0.0249314588,
-0.0169391818,
0.0733621716,
-0.018662475,
-0.0098453388,
-0.0027750724,
0.023632599,
-0.0257858559,
-0.0129833622,
0.0111568253,
2.914149219e-34,
-0.0091861598,
-0.0395157263,
0.0430084765,
-0.0128686447,
0.0531612709,
-0.0056631202,
0.0018157776,
0.0002032166,
-0.0401392207,
-0.0007375157,
-0.0306468718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07849v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07849v2 | Synthetic Data Generation with Large Language Models for Text Classification: Potential and Limitations | 2023-10-11T19:51:13 | 2023-10-13T01:31:59 | Zhuoyan Li, Hangxiao Zhu, Zhuoran Lu, Ming Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The collection and curation of high-quality training data is crucial for
developing text classification models with superior performance, but it is
often associated with significant costs and time investment. Researchers have
recently explored using large language models (LLMs) to generate synthetic
datasets as an alternative approach. However, the effectiveness of the
LLM-generated synthetic data in supporting model training is inconsistent
across different classification tasks. To better understand factors that
moderate the effectiveness of the LLM-generated synthetic data, in this study,
we look into how the performance of models trained on these synthetic data may
vary with the subjectivity of classification. Our results indicate that
subjectivity, at both the task level and instance level, is negatively
associated with the performance of the model trained on synthetic data. We
conclude by discussing the implications of our work on the potential and
limitations of leveraging LLM for synthetic data generation. | [
0.0379900523,
0.066575706,
-0.0144211072,
0.0344742015,
-0.018128952,
0.0143369474,
0.0527198873,
-0.0090667894,
0.0219883695,
-0.0814333484,
-0.0408503339,
-0.0466973335,
-0.0335144512,
0.027425712,
0.0040804348,
0.0077138259,
0.0175663587,
0.0095801698,
-0.0193162784,
-0.0162840486,
-0.0296879448,
0.0256337002,
0.0491561443,
0.0003249468,
-0.0102150729,
0.0054296497,
0.0286623221,
-0.0002408963,
-0.019864209,
-0.0092679886,
0.0323179923,
0.0614449307,
-0.0049548638,
0.0569842458,
0.0000017367,
-0.0404090621,
0.0183036476,
-0.0015688407,
-0.0363907404,
0.025615057,
0.0856662989,
-0.0072825681,
0.006543647,
0.0374578163,
-0.0406160541,
-0.0267096162,
-0.0082086213,
0.0497275293,
0.0118603362,
0.1084099934,
-0.0174454451,
-0.0068083066,
0.0131160021,
-0.0112206284,
-0.0064436216,
0.0046652774,
0.0336788706,
0.0066776318,
-0.0350311585,
0.0576299466,
0.015080628,
-0.0144254016,
0.0270082559,
-0.0124430228,
0.0354814306,
0.0534950979,
-0.0596951246,
-0.0007779014,
0.0355860814,
0.030633295,
-0.0258069001,
-0.0553268082,
-0.0117089543,
0.0035398381,
0.0209648497,
0.0276387613,
0.002949886,
0.0329257958,
-0.037908189,
0.0603398867,
0.0439272486,
0.0188304037,
0.0235945024,
0.0076028514,
0.0073250569,
0.0013003942,
-0.0017794546,
-0.0367549099,
0.014925844,
0.0489976704,
-0.0190608762,
-0.0198456123,
0.0011718033,
-0.0246456023,
0.0144730285,
0.0074596223,
-0.0769037083,
-0.029971594,
0.0249351636,
-0.1452249289,
0.0353546441,
-0.000763696,
0.015836319,
0.0173470657,
-0.0376978032,
-0.0228017196,
0.0114472033,
0.0228557382,
-0.0436438955,
-0.0062115276,
-0.0412587225,
0.0066643055,
-0.0038142819,
0.028321445,
-0.0486351736,
0.0076939431,
-0.0558792278,
0.0231624823,
-0.0032353434,
-0.0116501283,
0.0157032236,
0.0148493461,
-0.02368683,
0.0134862652,
-0.04516159,
-0.050840497,
0.0030694101,
0.0448830239,
-0.0626457781,
-0.0348763578,
0.0305842236,
0.0305477101,
-0.0044698082,
-0.0322121568,
0.0361021534,
0.0365658477,
-0.0076134424,
-0.0438363329,
-0.0628719106,
0.0018866395,
-0.0048455852,
-0.0607637763,
0.0156830642,
-0.0499594063,
0.0222105701,
0.0273319799,
-0.0133198444,
-0.0389843658,
0.0171664748,
0.0035357978,
-0.0207512733,
0.0602198616,
-0.0392940827,
0.0193679389,
0.0247433539,
-0.0150723634,
0.0218605641,
0.070117712,
0.0103480769,
0.0224721972,
0.0526974723,
-0.0281190425,
0.022794148,
0.0192574356,
0.0194470733,
0.0249361899,
-0.0295967199,
0.0113082761,
0.015216968,
-0.0008070652,
0.0439519994,
0.0155697567,
-0.0085055009,
-0.0390978754,
0.0660605431,
0.0197556317,
0.0147426957,
0.05709574,
0.0414083488,
0.0063122213,
0.0060547618,
-0.0045936103,
-0.0130924908,
-0.020539565,
-0.0335370749,
-0.0146333771,
-0.0118572237,
0.0041891509,
-0.0351028256,
-0.0720438883,
-0.030705981,
-0.0096849687,
-0.0052375034,
0.0086911609,
0.0462042503,
-0.0038189713,
-0.0092329364,
0.0327974074,
0.0383166671,
-0.0544446036,
-0.0000623982,
-0.0446237959,
0.0356337205,
0.0607600771,
0.0196596999,
-0.0265016388,
-0.0224033073,
-0.0110240141,
0.0015610224,
0.0517701879,
0.0750138387,
-0.0254112054,
-0.0111127337,
-0.0158599038,
0.0044525424,
-0.0288036037,
0.0192773715,
0.0049510216,
0.0335637853,
0.0035662148,
0.0203272309,
-0.0333172157,
-0.0891818106,
0.0555189699,
-0.0630940571,
-0.0490769967,
0.0481833443,
-0.0153743289,
0.0466188192,
-0.0096401041,
-0.0453973934,
-0.0123307072,
0.0325557552,
-0.0279586092,
-0.0439681336,
-0.0131636094,
0.0079441536,
-0.0446302816,
0.0050395033,
-0.0040314822,
0.0007432545,
0.020315662,
-0.0322852395,
-0.0005403779,
-0.0141837634,
-0.0029330649,
0.0098171839,
-0.0478609875,
0.0267698597,
-0.0261850171,
0.0458077416,
-0.0395914055,
0.052678287,
-0.0019506484,
0.0432875939,
-0.0256911851,
-0.017117301,
0.028321078,
-0.0024132617,
0.0073644235,
0.0111978315,
0.0088235773,
0.025423361,
0.015695693,
-0.0046520634,
-0.0127403326,
-0.0461597927,
-0.1173924655,
0.008742814,
-0.0250943881,
-0.0021880183,
0.0037741533,
-0.0548461191,
-0.0296154283,
0.0172089692,
-0.0516332276,
-0.0558208227,
0.0008187898,
0.0224226788,
0.0060684774,
-0.0258761346,
0.0119814426,
-0.0360383317,
-0.0042505809,
0.0012566599,
0.0875419155,
0.0021695374,
0.0034129,
-0.0694505274,
0.0663158372,
-0.0100527527,
0.0191776138,
-0.0027239707,
-0.0357090123,
-0.0207365714,
0.0062342142,
0.032665696,
0.0305440202,
0.0198839642,
0.0311159734,
0.0558548123,
0.0301675666,
-0.0355267264,
0.0032407891,
-0.0327906534,
0.0238032453,
-0.0505766608,
-0.0846445933,
0.0318606868,
0.0559738316,
-0.0099077933,
-0.030986324,
-0.0482504405,
0.061796736,
-0.0013555664,
-0.0164629146,
-0.0250795707,
0.0035373035,
-0.0031254215,
0.0411228985,
-0.0272452626,
-0.0586904325,
0.029515367,
-0.0235202517,
0.0252992343,
-0.0454713292,
-0.0212844927,
-0.0466197841,
0.037319161,
0.0088440673,
-0.00668649,
-0.0039341315,
0.0435439982,
-0.0042944653,
0.0199915413,
0.0205301754,
-0.0303544104,
0.0195203498,
-0.0269510876,
0.018757252,
-0.0202622637,
-0.0344382077,
-0.0532852784,
-0.0640883744,
0.0180367138,
-0.0042894757,
0.0201971848,
0.0105804093,
0.0046879072,
0.0116174193,
-0.0355945379,
0.0408100486,
-0.0172164161,
-0.0297655948,
0.0262149535,
0.0254970156,
0.0118979001,
-0.0380216166,
-0.0091501102,
-0.0075949025,
0.0315116271,
0.0258726049,
0.012641157,
0.0485920273,
-0.0181045458,
-0.0200438071,
0.042055361,
-0.0132134883,
-0.0341535248,
-0.0254781283,
0.0150748817,
-0.0439729951,
-0.0394945554,
0.1147804335,
0.033947546,
-0.0369720422,
-0.0056753438,
-0.0016161662,
0.0048968238,
0.0435096473,
0.0284253638,
-0.0087273382,
0.0076106237,
-0.0103276903,
0.0155534167,
-0.0334530286,
-0.0209328532,
-0.0037943765,
-0.1456127912,
0.0516936146,
-0.0090989936,
-0.0652967915,
-0.0219888482,
-0.0702706352,
-0.0155506982,
-0.0058228304,
-0.0098276967,
-0.0164817963,
-0.0158455484,
-0.0016601763,
0.0487208851,
-0.0360260196,
-0.0611516424,
0.0028322949,
-0.007602992,
0.0477240533,
0.0234280918,
0.048661571,
-0.0018047164,
-0.0083788075,
0.0400230959,
0.0075307284,
-0.0189200155,
-0.0127581395,
0.0954962671,
-0.0012434948,
-0.0073105604,
0.0098494096,
0.0337684043,
-0.0235061515,
0.0015345874,
-0.0122720003,
0.058824528,
-0.0087823514,
-0.0372175574,
-0.0347355418,
-0.0137595059,
0.0041345325,
0.0712919757,
0.0140903518,
-0.0838792026,
-0.0078891367,
-0.0096983686,
-0.0220652223,
-0.0509803966,
-0.0513358079,
0.0486585386,
-0.0346585885,
-0.0367563106,
-0.0465090051,
-0.0663592443,
0.0192992277,
0.0207569823,
0.0008389906,
0.0030118416,
-0.0097997552,
-0.0252552982,
-0.0566521958,
0.070613414,
-0.0312716216,
0.0202219151,
-0.0282889809,
-0.0387019664,
0.0503201336,
-0.0420004725,
-0.0007528765,
-0.0225139372,
-0.0308526512,
-0.0458464958,
0.0027127583,
0.0353832245,
0.0147419656,
0.0365217552,
0.0398195088,
-0.0487746857,
0.0308229178,
0.0683967695,
-0.0426785909,
-0.0084824702,
0.0510396622,
0.0080540488,
-0.0134207765,
0.0195212327,
-0.0134085938,
0.0375278667,
0.0704123303,
-0.0235354919,
-0.0119862314,
-0.0317877978,
0.0069819032,
0.016106274,
0.0728915334,
-0.0171916336,
-0.017739689,
-0.0464806668,
0.0079460843,
-0.0209073685,
-0.0285653938,
-0.0249012019,
-0.0234198924,
0.0282123592,
0.0163081996,
-0.0568537116,
0.0347323306,
-0.0474743135,
0.0563766435,
-0.0318859518,
-0.02088774,
-0.0131658008,
0.0215647686,
0.0474735461,
0.0267835706,
-0.0523676313,
-0.0005824577,
0.0216894131,
0.0132433632,
-0.0056544691,
0.0361862332,
-0.0052245376,
0.0467416272,
-0.034938626,
-0.005642422,
-0.0468046255,
0.0052517424,
-0.0516645871,
0.0627277717,
0.0393932611,
-0.0558793172,
0.0105777327,
-0.0491204746,
-0.0275803227,
-0.0273008272,
0.0268483143,
0.0271959044,
-0.0233013351,
0.015022994,
-0.0124050453,
-0.0588119924,
-0.004348441,
0.1055092663,
0.0398365483,
0.0431573205,
-0.0001836378,
-0.0363053605,
-0.0467246212,
-0.0167224221,
0.0560374223,
-0.0226471964,
0.0036394775,
0.0088029895,
-0.0744219944,
-0.06572254,
0.0404193401,
-0.0236310791,
0.0198431276,
-0.0244888552,
0.007473493,
0.0786397606,
-0.012481533,
0.0374735668,
-0.0493001714,
0.0061825812,
-0.0049627163,
-0.002445071,
-0.0316925012,
-5.801555023e-33,
0.0240831729,
-0.0214175675,
0.0019267478,
0.0295641832,
-0.009747535,
0.0048984527,
0.0116163958,
0.0094918748,
0.0359879509,
0.0047112303,
-0.0302643962,
0.0045348806,
0.0076763574,
0.0444792956,
0.0024758868,
-0.0016898799,
0.0802217871,
-0.0203217696,
-0.0246860515,
0.0130906031,
0.0502896011,
0.0065935953,
0.0419926494,
-0.091871202,
0.0249880962,
-0.000366085,
0.0430574752,
0.0101165948,
0.0049386532,
0.0354760364,
-0.0379784591,
0.1098282561,
0.0467667915,
-0.0406048931,
0.0327286832,
0.0046225684,
0.0060788514,
-0.0262992568,
-0.0002545675,
0.0078449138,
0.0192757845,
-0.0468249507,
0.0162305646,
0.0356889591,
-0.0303192269,
0.0059867934,
0.0431189351,
-0.0533124767,
-0.0412403792,
-0.0942154601,
-0.0749155879,
0.0358527116,
0.0399882719,
-0.0119125172,
0.0174866077,
0.0189915914,
0.0121978559,
0.0197869297,
-0.0216679163,
0.0025010442,
0.0052501108,
0.0161074791,
-0.0027895027,
0.0309932958,
0.0160744414,
0.0657526255,
0.040036194,
0.0821810514,
-0.0307112075,
0.0225437824,
0.0268472265,
0.0145619344,
0.0640602112,
0.1063941866,
0.0545055605,
-0.0394257121,
-0.0594897009,
0.0303470027,
0.0197604951,
-0.0705340877,
0.0485962518,
-0.0171569567,
-0.0212860759,
-0.0486243442,
-0.0589253567,
-0.0171617232,
-0.0168038793,
0.0142891714,
0.0001432166,
0.0273930822,
-0.0304129291,
-0.0345429629,
0.01958685,
-0.0442908853,
-0.0284113325,
0.0141599979,
-0.0254600644,
0.0144734643,
0.0071108346,
-0.0396416187,
-0.0309661292,
-0.0440438427,
0.0025738305,
0.0044267247,
0.0220802017,
-0.0088931667,
0.068473883,
-0.0045852619,
-0.0613766126,
0.0248271301,
-0.0286398791,
0.0475593992,
0.0355425365,
0.0644672289,
0.0023952571,
0.0097185811,
0.0061893873,
0.0339614376,
0.0350998715,
0.0382849798,
-0.0282831509,
-0.007299663,
0.0005384459,
0.0247194953,
0.007647763,
0.0015543784,
-0.0449397117,
0.0018110314,
0.0070875725,
-0.0871590376,
-0.0045332373,
-0.0130507071,
2.345e-7,
0.0322215855,
0.0400176309,
-0.0238909982,
0.0069360179,
0.0247430857,
0.0472021848,
-0.0056738923,
0.0126296449,
0.0110554686,
-0.0073174969,
-0.0079073608,
0.0162556954,
0.0714302137,
0.0634955093,
-0.082788825,
-0.0326554067,
-0.0480034426,
0.0267902315,
-0.0500141755,
-0.0047200047,
0.0417365134,
0.0965526477,
0.0173147302,
-0.0356375612,
0.0112435622,
-0.0291789584,
0.0843237936,
-0.0626948178,
-0.0254901387,
0.061623618,
0.0386623368,
0.0061191451,
-0.0027966439,
0.0216910504,
-0.0383913107,
0.011421727,
-0.0225892439,
0.0525885336,
0.0213693511,
0.0035707224,
0.0220979154,
-0.0354164317,
-0.0099823866,
-0.0416261181,
0.0629912391,
-0.0760089159,
-0.0177481249,
-0.0386788212,
0.0153235123,
0.0040195379,
0.0534242801,
-0.0603196174,
0.0017364541,
0.034594994,
0.0108613474,
-0.0311341602,
-0.0214744974,
-0.0699752569,
-0.0348211899,
-0.0045837457,
-0.0559058487,
-0.0303225946,
0.0082991188,
0.0335066542,
0.0612884015,
-0.0288426373,
0.0622108728,
2.228171812e-34,
0.0434981324,
0.0385601036,
-0.0027381512,
-0.0194036663,
0.0067628282,
-0.0214802623,
0.0085245837,
0.0030021472,
-0.0033542719,
-0.0438790433,
0.0151657099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07848v1 | Framework for Question-Answering in Sanskrit through Automated Construction of Knowledge Graphs | 2023-10-11T19:50:59 | 2023-10-11T19:50:59 | Hrishikesh Terdalkar, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sanskrit (sa\d{m}sk\d{r}ta) enjoys one of the largest and most varied
literature in the whole world. Extracting the knowledge from it, however, is a
challenging task due to multiple reasons including complexity of the language
and paucity of standard natural language processing tools. In this paper, we
target the problem of building knowledge graphs for particular types of
relationships from sa\d{m}sk\d{r}ta texts. We build a natural language
question-answering system in sa\d{m}sk\d{r}ta that uses the knowledge graph to
answer factoid questions. We design a framework for the overall system and
implement two separate instances of the system on human relationships from
mah\=abh\=arata and r\=am\=aya\d{n}a, and one instance on synonymous
relationships from bh\=avaprak\=a\'sa nigha\d{n}\d{t}u, a technical text from
\=ayurveda. We show that about 50% of the factoid questions can be answered
correctly by the system. More importantly, we analyse the shortcomings of the
system in detail for each step, and discuss the possible ways forward. | [
0.0922430679,
-0.0430852808,
-0.0270261411,
0.0910988674,
-0.0286167338,
-0.0229320023,
-0.0551596284,
0.0315816551,
0.051888153,
-0.0336799994,
0.0355295464,
0.005638211,
-0.0039832513,
0.0002512214,
0.0109987287,
-0.0570676923,
0.014138205,
-0.0212153513,
0.0328760557,
-0.0080400677,
0.0449707396,
0.0526203923,
-0.0269066151,
-0.0210361183,
-0.0413949192,
-0.0159233045,
0.0170925427,
-0.0256391652,
0.0230068825,
-0.01719868,
-0.0272217151,
0.0194930267,
-0.020634735,
-0.0407522842,
0.0000016584,
-0.0873284414,
-0.0130505692,
-0.0054440983,
-0.0290246401,
-0.0402263328,
-0.0078437589,
0.0159862358,
0.069364205,
0.0101806317,
-0.0684657171,
0.0277004298,
0.019710293,
-0.0134385936,
0.0501302183,
0.0667777658,
-0.0078277485,
-0.0616119467,
0.0157561041,
0.031491138,
-0.0063587702,
-0.0067666522,
0.0166964773,
0.0664588884,
0.0454609022,
-0.0178409778,
-0.0454118624,
0.0272151772,
-0.0157554001,
-0.0069323601,
0.0516145974,
-0.015062145,
-0.0176592898,
0.0255036987,
0.0302282441,
0.0380946584,
0.0420625322,
-0.013405079,
0.0124974241,
0.0390383527,
-0.0345238969,
0.0119173666,
-0.0070452238,
0.008900255,
-0.0818860009,
-0.0013859173,
0.0510678999,
-0.0161561761,
-0.0283181574,
0.0043404978,
0.0436096862,
0.0063056257,
0.0012532838,
-0.0139557896,
-0.006675736,
-0.0298029408,
-0.0337612629,
-0.0493025482,
0.0279487073,
0.0919688493,
-0.0162872132,
0.054910779,
-0.0061179786,
-0.0571360961,
0.0228126012,
-0.0407052599,
-0.0621724986,
0.0149120754,
0.0332688279,
0.0128870662,
0.0071816635,
0.0233667716,
0.0277288016,
-0.0006725488,
-0.0548351854,
-0.0246259533,
-0.0053474526,
-0.0518434457,
-0.072928071,
0.0526621528,
-0.0125471624,
0.0271223485,
-0.0196624119,
0.0044041667,
0.0217767134,
-0.0151591199,
0.0185222197,
0.0111743314,
-0.0226142406,
-0.011752001,
-0.0331888795,
0.0231959,
-0.0560912825,
-0.0176654141,
-0.0393719226,
0.00332111,
0.0315104127,
-0.0035295621,
0.0353468917,
-0.0150628248,
-0.0050104884,
0.0369333141,
0.0077653811,
-0.0257896371,
-0.0456480607,
-0.0033602505,
0.0065885792,
-0.0444157273,
-0.0435756817,
-0.0704980716,
0.042831406,
0.0731663331,
-0.0307044834,
-0.0316488296,
0.0638032928,
0.0182030741,
-0.0523346625,
0.0591456182,
-0.018343566,
0.0114537468,
0.0338285379,
0.0133337975,
0.0259810239,
-0.0255750604,
0.0375452787,
-0.0129351178,
0.0940581933,
0.0036744161,
0.0092729125,
0.0005759139,
0.0239854436,
-0.0202952493,
0.0414053053,
0.071691893,
-0.0148666641,
0.019506216,
-0.0444720536,
0.0789908245,
0.0306649581,
-0.0193765983,
-0.0227423869,
0.0720399767,
-0.0313696973,
0.0802467093,
0.0180603471,
-0.0057856184,
0.0663941577,
0.0276655927,
-0.0112360194,
0.0089774588,
-0.006228799,
0.0120337885,
-0.0173414797,
-0.0162579473,
0.0088940393,
-0.0357097276,
-0.0367335677,
-0.0042478801,
-0.0171397645,
-0.0136943236,
0.0562795326,
0.0000986601,
-0.0088243317,
-0.0032660451,
0.0426739641,
-0.040373031,
0.0520707518,
0.0047025769,
0.0491212718,
0.0503837839,
0.0348737463,
-0.0281475987,
-0.0055411826,
0.0525038317,
0.0094022257,
0.0489102527,
0.0165543761,
-0.0455565304,
-0.0457934737,
-0.0117529705,
0.033467643,
0.0148350932,
-0.0414705686,
0.0125301601,
0.0064206626,
0.0332913361,
-0.0090628443,
-0.0262642447,
0.0074129086,
0.0245381091,
0.0012034278,
0.0011333294,
-0.0205494873,
0.0112445513,
0.0096483929,
0.0309708528,
0.00216862,
0.0378996059,
0.0386719182,
-0.0298275165,
-0.0381736234,
-0.0039044116,
0.0258075204,
-0.0477487817,
0.014262693,
-0.0520747304,
0.0008718948,
0.0012408873,
0.0000276304,
-0.053818617,
0.0126974089,
-0.0587068312,
0.042725917,
-0.0045902138,
0.0064017083,
0.0529561937,
-0.035692744,
-0.0439147465,
0.0542458631,
0.0402609631,
0.0330424942,
-0.0220258422,
-0.0422506295,
0.0511910804,
-0.034947034,
-0.0102322567,
0.0053770598,
0.0080633229,
-0.0069214813,
0.0233077183,
-0.0041037365,
-0.0433025174,
-0.0024590432,
-0.0752705857,
0.0182740446,
0.000708725,
0.0590812638,
-0.0034491939,
0.0256304815,
-0.0086976867,
-0.0285264049,
-0.0399362147,
0.0342427567,
0.0656698123,
-0.0265493803,
0.0417169556,
0.0246182587,
0.0153929098,
-0.0436851643,
-0.0105036842,
-0.0337972157,
0.0356416218,
0.0323315002,
-0.0346166454,
-0.0087881498,
0.0163351316,
-0.0681007802,
0.0248871334,
-0.0181060657,
-0.0119769471,
-0.0220809318,
0.0037022096,
0.0131314481,
-0.0134353917,
0.0084665911,
-0.0116312318,
-0.0201122295,
-0.0145297265,
0.0066407332,
0.0150419055,
0.0082386257,
0.0252552424,
0.0120419431,
-0.0090198433,
-0.0091003152,
-0.0261445343,
0.0358812995,
-0.024416713,
0.0012471797,
0.0163939428,
-0.0268351734,
0.0701217279,
-0.0026229667,
0.0021165349,
-0.0070456471,
0.0430563614,
0.0082806423,
-0.0108887404,
0.0698803812,
0.0106218792,
-0.000476171,
-0.0910457,
0.0021585242,
-0.0335252769,
0.0657302886,
0.0157535281,
0.0309642628,
-0.0115808966,
-0.0098947361,
-0.0590469316,
-0.0198948868,
0.0204901788,
-0.0347416475,
0.0238846466,
-0.0571343303,
0.0476709604,
-0.0405714028,
-0.0101303784,
-0.0378580168,
0.014909572,
-0.0170866866,
-0.0182173476,
0.056752257,
0.0024919787,
0.0823000148,
0.0303378608,
-0.0360557064,
-0.0568622015,
-0.0271538906,
-0.0044833752,
-0.0044441866,
0.0791841447,
0.0719147027,
0.0029716839,
0.0166822728,
0.0837898031,
0.0256315302,
0.0289296843,
0.0321852118,
-0.0158986598,
-0.0025033799,
-0.0265992191,
-0.0011068262,
-0.0591984056,
0.0188038144,
0.0018487129,
-0.0293608829,
-0.0527382903,
0.0166300908,
0.0721999779,
0.0534124747,
0.0308457967,
-0.0065332893,
-0.0616182052,
-0.0477140769,
0.0065432745,
0.0678519681,
-0.13563627,
0.0009947392,
-0.0369378179,
-0.0058504087,
0.0103890179,
-0.0268449262,
-0.0099672424,
-0.0873310342,
-0.0349847004,
-0.0292875953,
-0.0067876852,
-0.0298786461,
0.0056191767,
-0.034032654,
0.0138776042,
-0.0609982014,
0.0375347883,
-0.0516618676,
0.0293297023,
0.0044757864,
0.0036254968,
0.0507694632,
0.0227509383,
-0.0235201679,
-0.0217180774,
0.0142903915,
0.0548424013,
-0.0138897402,
0.0133678932,
-0.0260700341,
-0.0312585086,
-0.0157708582,
-0.0249451548,
0.0371131524,
-0.0105721429,
0.000402282,
-0.0619544275,
0.0111333849,
-0.0297284406,
0.0011612262,
0.0742675215,
0.0747385174,
0.002574261,
-0.0431279689,
-0.0236333534,
0.0017825562,
-0.0129886894,
0.0438761935,
-0.0281502381,
0.0303565748,
-0.0403121002,
-0.0100598298,
0.0413182601,
-0.0111831482,
-0.056456361,
-0.0054666507,
-0.032885287,
0.0193367675,
-0.0664844513,
-0.0486083105,
0.0271043684,
0.0103128832,
0.0390993021,
0.0481347516,
0.0486089215,
0.053642489,
-0.0591248088,
-0.045440942,
-0.0102979634,
0.0097697107,
-0.0037556861,
0.0032982698,
0.0401023217,
0.0062237834,
-0.0058193388,
-0.0295982491,
0.0125082275,
-0.0260684229,
-0.0329707675,
0.0419320725,
0.0145064341,
0.0161070358,
-0.0367418528,
-0.0221956335,
0.0098619293,
0.0145415897,
-0.0578136183,
0.0085116457,
-0.0045102411,
0.0228971113,
-0.0262887087,
0.0316070393,
-0.0445832945,
-0.0410681553,
-0.0392148122,
0.0236900039,
-0.0238879789,
-0.0205799136,
0.0352430567,
0.0527904257,
-0.0319965631,
-0.0297506787,
0.0404977575,
-0.0055377791,
0.0022064506,
-0.0381130017,
-0.037825942,
-0.0208662301,
0.0093190419,
-0.0207096525,
0.0177560486,
-0.0253650732,
-0.0475091562,
0.0027668593,
0.0244424269,
0.0537213124,
0.0273193866,
0.0482293256,
0.0334974118,
-0.0049442993,
-0.0266375858,
0.0033272102,
-0.0286798701,
0.0027206889,
0.0295557696,
-0.0131918136,
0.0474382602,
0.0052234326,
-0.0515893288,
0.0376103148,
-0.0100389021,
0.0236762464,
-0.0264475942,
-0.0015276406,
0.0267385673,
0.0253567155,
0.0144098066,
0.0130130779,
-0.044523038,
0.0089304354,
0.0241892729,
0.0100410245,
0.0166417826,
0.0121532669,
0.079022333,
0.0260837097,
0.0206334312,
0.0099706147,
0.0489210635,
-0.0541641973,
0.0144472849,
0.0741844475,
-0.0758396462,
-0.023089353,
-0.0563837029,
-0.0560823269,
-0.013459377,
0.0311872754,
0.0309441853,
-0.0888471156,
-0.0503965691,
-0.0331555903,
-0.003612675,
0.0189518407,
-0.0280652046,
0.039626848,
0.0201063529,
0.0903558284,
-0.0716945305,
-0.0417541228,
0.0800998509,
-0.1270175725,
-0.0137858195,
0.0018546265,
-5.18204048e-33,
-0.0697711185,
-0.0453008749,
0.0253906399,
0.0401103646,
0.0037380345,
-0.0083836885,
-0.0452945568,
-0.0004713161,
-0.0472276956,
0.0291859563,
-0.0359066986,
0.0174533837,
-0.0079782922,
-0.0065974803,
-0.0181954876,
-0.0337495394,
-0.0538658686,
-0.0118752066,
0.0123871919,
0.0151130501,
0.0683637708,
-0.0072472584,
0.0482688211,
-0.0272461437,
0.0457409471,
-0.0525828563,
0.0067159557,
0.0751357302,
-0.0298306085,
0.0241121724,
-0.0377268456,
0.0508284681,
0.0225826669,
0.0136798797,
0.0337970443,
0.0388603397,
-0.110898234,
-0.07350941,
0.0557144955,
0.0303256232,
-0.0375962295,
-0.0066804378,
-0.0059482474,
-0.0092174774,
0.04370391,
0.041277051,
0.0638594776,
-0.007906178,
0.0102516077,
-0.0674579144,
-0.0338776819,
0.0159695912,
-0.0355751105,
-0.0229770504,
-0.0489739291,
-0.0260931347,
0.0029359062,
-0.0361796953,
-0.0185567606,
-0.0383976549,
0.0047839275,
0.0138488458,
-0.0164230112,
-0.009421329,
-0.0297537241,
-0.0320333801,
-0.0311244279,
-0.0644678846,
0.0096656652,
0.0196988713,
-0.0531309433,
0.054710947,
0.0280478429,
0.0269486122,
0.0103512341,
-0.0116621405,
-0.0633083284,
0.0120250322,
0.0100788809,
0.0776261762,
-0.0416986719,
-0.0329885371,
-0.0404013507,
-0.0411669351,
0.0210341569,
-0.0188330784,
-0.0213985667,
-0.0518507883,
0.0056806188,
-0.0484619848,
-0.0118233133,
0.0102308122,
-0.0036564388,
-0.0656402111,
0.0182247199,
0.0616894327,
-0.0027990669,
0.0063577266,
-0.003471781,
0.0331137441,
-0.0183687899,
0.0200460497,
-0.0111855734,
-0.0168424714,
-0.0123221288,
0.0045068129,
-0.0118101183,
-0.0221920442,
-0.0307325758,
0.0033653066,
-0.00552384,
0.0285022799,
-0.0461838767,
-0.0166541245,
-0.0176200867,
0.0616493821,
0.0207555499,
0.0347367898,
0.0415460654,
0.041275844,
-0.062272042,
0.0230224635,
0.012771803,
-0.0265944581,
-0.0093898978,
0.0272616521,
-0.0226230603,
0.039007891,
-0.0103530455,
-0.0289020184,
0.018235378,
0.0213111285,
2.469e-7,
0.0513460971,
0.0055607678,
0.0599196143,
0.0177293085,
-0.011338274,
0.0003520081,
0.0138665056,
-0.0034067435,
0.0021434666,
0.0039729159,
-0.0002012981,
0.0240669027,
-0.0169749931,
0.0733330399,
-0.0831236318,
0.0208593402,
-0.0384406447,
-0.0948690623,
-0.0542098098,
-0.0047963872,
0.0224928893,
0.0013654114,
0.0445592888,
-0.0036252481,
-0.0850053206,
-0.0291175302,
0.0255633909,
0.0367355123,
0.0167245399,
0.0633989349,
0.0297358707,
-0.0549788997,
0.0057014287,
0.02858904,
0.0060516745,
0.0380791835,
0.0029559094,
0.0176354051,
-0.0148580344,
0.0187326856,
0.0098637296,
-0.0311798546,
0.0413520746,
-0.0280305482,
0.0615411997,
-0.005773122,
0.0023702292,
0.0437444039,
0.0115573462,
-0.0156425983,
-0.0382018723,
0.006498388,
-0.0152899753,
0.0101286853,
0.019755777,
-0.058870852,
0.0070162001,
-0.0259752683,
-0.0026715419,
0.0735902712,
0.0160225909,
-0.0532096028,
0.0282896217,
0.015214256,
0.0078961793,
-0.0419140942,
0.0004658717,
1.75248162e-34,
0.0283289608,
0.0051935576,
0.010726301,
-0.0013835016,
0.0349694788,
-0.027910307,
-0.036333587,
0.0297641754,
0.0609077699,
-0.0764101148,
-0.0170820486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07830v1 | Does Synthetic Data Make Large Language Models More Efficient? | 2023-10-11T19:16:09 | 2023-10-11T19:16:09 | Sia Gholami, Marwan Omar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Natural Language Processing (NLP) has undergone transformative changes with
the advent of deep learning methodologies. One challenge persistently
confronting researchers is the scarcity of high-quality, annotated datasets
that drive these models. This paper explores the nuances of synthetic data
generation in NLP, with a focal point on template-based question generation. By
assessing its advantages, including data augmentation potential and the
introduction of structured variety, we juxtapose these benefits against
inherent limitations, such as the risk of overfitting and the constraints posed
by pre-defined templates. Drawing from empirical evaluations, we demonstrate
the impact of template-based synthetic data on the performance of modern
transformer models. We conclude by emphasizing the delicate balance required
between synthetic and real-world data, and the future trajectories of
integrating synthetic data in model training pipelines. The findings aim to
guide NLP practitioners in harnessing synthetic data's potential, ensuring
optimal model performance in diverse applications. | [
0.0646610335,
0.0629738644,
-0.0072068442,
0.0268810242,
-0.0122466665,
0.0145144332,
0.0283381063,
-0.0116743986,
-0.0099939341,
-0.0661742836,
0.0194615237,
-0.0445541404,
-0.0283676609,
0.0592098422,
0.0294166654,
-0.0473746471,
0.0208095107,
-0.0126084937,
-0.0210895836,
0.0156151755,
-0.0352098793,
0.006803954,
0.0241652466,
0.0375549234,
-0.0412103832,
-0.0031137739,
-0.020809589,
0.0163735729,
-0.0262951348,
0.002954894,
0.0304789655,
0.0729628429,
0.0289640389,
0.0376688726,
0.0000018126,
-0.0232411753,
-0.0202230681,
0.0197830386,
-0.067491442,
-0.0319474749,
0.0280667692,
-0.0267706849,
0.0162788369,
0.038369175,
-0.0548981316,
-0.0628852397,
0.0362338424,
0.0636554807,
0.0354745276,
0.1076837629,
-0.0232554059,
-0.0512783378,
0.0568222292,
-0.0163317975,
0.0084778806,
0.0254144073,
-0.0051319133,
-0.0104082478,
-0.0014454783,
0.0282338671,
0.0077860476,
0.0311378874,
0.0497243591,
0.0117349345,
0.0290364753,
0.0368023552,
-0.0662914664,
-0.0357067697,
-0.0255195834,
0.0745016932,
-0.0292156879,
-0.0391949564,
0.0006125362,
-0.0166810211,
0.0155500779,
0.0110267587,
-0.021948697,
0.0251073632,
-0.0039316532,
0.009524364,
0.0327558145,
-0.0102930153,
0.0198203269,
-0.0156011153,
-0.0372754186,
0.0222765356,
0.0193243306,
-0.0312286802,
-0.0100040184,
0.009449482,
-0.0318485349,
-0.0678287894,
-0.0104337577,
0.0089699524,
-0.0300073419,
0.0071391892,
-0.0615017153,
-0.0545914806,
0.0020429248,
-0.0409086533,
0.0449921377,
0.0343762301,
-0.002370077,
0.0217154361,
-0.0109276297,
0.0239862204,
-0.0452093706,
0.0228577722,
-0.0570705533,
-0.0087508634,
-0.0375637934,
-0.0228242129,
-0.0524772778,
0.0307197981,
-0.0615097098,
-0.0134975724,
0.0132913534,
0.0327214636,
0.013081992,
0.002219303,
0.0356712155,
0.0550938025,
-0.0570531301,
0.0132003929,
-0.0466345027,
0.0069081006,
-0.0404706113,
0.0178920496,
0.0286104716,
-0.0981826782,
0.0196158253,
0.0129446723,
0.0267879907,
-0.0396809392,
0.0196260531,
0.04431054,
-0.0242238417,
-0.0232011322,
-0.0284139253,
-0.0216650162,
-0.0020890776,
-0.0446683206,
0.038520325,
-0.0876070186,
0.0627321973,
0.0223758202,
-0.0101397857,
-0.0129099824,
0.0099988487,
0.0235051941,
-0.0257737916,
0.0613123327,
-0.0100946585,
0.025255844,
-0.0070854845,
-0.0351620167,
0.0355646685,
0.075391762,
0.0287026688,
0.0040152613,
0.043826025,
-0.0258817207,
0.0273520332,
0.0291320235,
0.004476347,
-0.0213852525,
-0.0264130458,
0.0271769296,
-0.0061319438,
0.0326409079,
0.0029948573,
0.068919979,
-0.0180935264,
-0.02353766,
0.0583631732,
0.0082779434,
0.0225541145,
0.0574105978,
0.0883145779,
0.008283399,
0.0099560171,
0.013028942,
-0.0331936963,
0.004558451,
0.0037259418,
0.0025417861,
-0.0202549286,
0.0178991817,
-0.033890795,
-0.0524208471,
-0.0317510739,
0.0282111764,
-0.0339922868,
0.0206303913,
0.0047474545,
0.0556005612,
-0.0466620214,
0.086824201,
-0.0060535092,
-0.0374906026,
-0.0310567468,
-0.0079479516,
-0.0001598963,
0.0407516845,
0.0373504683,
0.0014035919,
-0.0412609316,
-0.0455168076,
-0.0381566249,
0.0644001365,
0.0890933871,
-0.0207452308,
0.0121948021,
-0.0297984686,
0.0057398393,
-0.0366479829,
0.0190242659,
0.0006078501,
0.0373151191,
-0.0304110534,
0.0062124771,
-0.0585606284,
-0.0562295131,
0.0504009537,
-0.0393172354,
-0.0521871038,
0.0389580131,
-0.003673861,
0.0038526205,
0.011824308,
-0.0065425998,
0.0071103638,
0.0332394317,
-0.0384171791,
-0.0369846933,
0.0143930819,
-0.0512813292,
-0.0469646193,
0.0049199057,
-0.0622041784,
-0.0344251245,
0.0461584143,
-0.0465028919,
-0.0246371608,
-0.0408578254,
-0.0350248329,
0.0285018366,
-0.0390600413,
0.0081724031,
0.0151959825,
0.0533297546,
-0.0330318399,
0.0646146238,
-0.0003081632,
0.0247094836,
0.0089667961,
-0.0039851228,
0.0128922425,
-0.0319122747,
-0.0098211719,
0.0268931929,
-0.0349116772,
0.002984996,
0.0015258732,
0.0230641607,
-0.0598932058,
-0.0173307154,
-0.0816358253,
0.0042739622,
-0.0368176661,
-0.0093418816,
0.0336113535,
0.0265551805,
-0.0154961953,
0.0212061629,
-0.0621603243,
-0.042866379,
0.0197861847,
0.023565935,
0.0401265882,
0.0136254691,
0.0126708401,
-0.0107265459,
-0.0154735306,
-0.0212164409,
0.0842652172,
-0.0112171452,
0.0077028191,
-0.0348010957,
0.007195856,
0.0112399356,
0.0498777032,
0.0013560574,
0.0031157003,
0.0055937101,
-0.0185448732,
0.0829855502,
0.0196183175,
0.0172342397,
0.0165422875,
0.0229418129,
0.0288461503,
-0.056993261,
0.0320427231,
-0.0508599877,
0.004940148,
-0.0376422964,
-0.0374014825,
0.0228258912,
0.0549474284,
-0.0110807363,
-0.0248231497,
-0.0423261598,
0.0340943523,
0.0083668819,
-0.0332433954,
-0.0184485335,
0.0213815346,
-0.0070462008,
0.0593852922,
-0.0155564286,
-0.0104904035,
0.0467974693,
0.0035215635,
-0.0133347427,
-0.0493167751,
0.0018142425,
-0.0359036997,
0.0283101331,
0.0209474824,
-0.0153178759,
0.0101526808,
0.000450509,
-0.0551885664,
0.0226780456,
0.0019746993,
-0.0238572415,
0.0461238176,
-0.0193492025,
0.0073085078,
-0.006115444,
-0.0250684172,
-0.0862347111,
-0.0544753969,
0.0093180789,
0.0098768631,
0.0440560728,
0.0047169123,
-0.0059736944,
-0.0138829239,
-0.02517239,
0.0833749697,
-0.0162391625,
-0.0221377574,
-0.0266255997,
0.0968149379,
0.037845403,
0.0174342021,
0.0449190587,
0.0035299058,
0.0408864133,
0.0305120777,
0.0173201486,
0.0373327062,
-0.0492478609,
0.0237047691,
0.0354849994,
-0.0205467883,
-0.0155804576,
0.0241703838,
0.0220438354,
-0.0689615086,
-0.0539674796,
0.0905271769,
0.049012199,
-0.0028611233,
0.0064370502,
-0.0023090441,
0.056321647,
0.0522964075,
0.0656168312,
-0.0828632116,
-0.0041235709,
0.0054296623,
-0.0057526552,
-0.0398980528,
-0.0276952293,
-0.015743101,
-0.1324207932,
0.0420578048,
-0.0590407513,
-0.0285182651,
-0.0046251318,
-0.0356617346,
-0.0224792715,
0.0075677652,
0.0283977017,
-0.0210489668,
-0.0109350802,
-0.0089618284,
0.0382217057,
-0.0211911015,
-0.0813611373,
-0.0117529295,
-0.0289836936,
0.0321669541,
0.0203346275,
0.036601644,
-0.0104524028,
-0.0316214487,
0.0296795797,
0.0236102827,
0.0016163592,
-0.0026555723,
0.0758023784,
0.0049620043,
-0.0328345336,
0.0116312439,
0.038610246,
-0.0432942286,
0.0105488691,
-0.0368603654,
0.0711553022,
-0.0050125984,
-0.0290397666,
-0.026057452,
-0.0318282992,
0.0133791305,
0.0757059976,
0.0294826347,
-0.0279186498,
-0.0203005597,
-0.0341671892,
-0.0012182004,
-0.0742283165,
-0.0439164452,
0.0367137082,
0.0335618816,
-0.0334929749,
-0.0874104872,
-0.0545217991,
0.04972573,
0.0286294185,
0.0074279485,
-0.0471654348,
-0.017842548,
-0.0008129039,
-0.0581624508,
0.0629410446,
-0.0363912731,
-0.0107263131,
-0.0335306972,
-0.0277477,
0.0221422631,
-0.0316270366,
-0.027180776,
0.0238429662,
-0.0988074169,
-0.0456093438,
0.0354112163,
0.040063832,
0.0174200442,
0.0553239398,
-0.0000820125,
-0.0191952474,
0.0241648909,
0.0737313405,
-0.0357306004,
-0.039385397,
0.0452787913,
-0.0227732304,
-0.000475803,
0.0197236687,
-0.0145787103,
0.0023829846,
0.0285770297,
0.0344072692,
0.0015161112,
-0.0123751229,
0.0654163808,
0.0174180791,
0.0290888064,
0.0038576822,
-0.00392794,
-0.0221872367,
0.01790905,
-0.0342414975,
-0.035355147,
-0.0540077835,
0.0023872186,
0.0092851212,
0.0508616082,
-0.0201815329,
0.037193615,
-0.0259079915,
0.0585495606,
-0.0305220075,
-0.036647737,
0.0146684945,
-0.0045664883,
0.0219898783,
0.0036227144,
-0.0273176059,
0.0334585495,
0.0181171745,
0.0539463349,
-0.0053689233,
0.027054552,
0.0180291664,
0.0144685395,
-0.0272726752,
-0.0122377854,
-0.0760004446,
-0.0600859299,
-0.051072944,
0.0263373852,
0.0007318985,
-0.0602709241,
-0.0071700998,
-0.0365674943,
-0.0253565051,
0.0094060451,
0.0119630527,
0.0181349684,
-0.0203990061,
0.0237356499,
0.0143742952,
-0.0272422675,
-0.0203805007,
0.0662705749,
0.0194920655,
0.0586828329,
-0.0054879733,
0.0088432981,
-0.065623723,
-0.0086735059,
0.0120802149,
-0.0130389808,
0.007742004,
0.0008522962,
-0.0725338981,
-0.0629272163,
0.0113324579,
0.0023798062,
0.0080450261,
0.0063006529,
0.0279197823,
0.0571925081,
-0.0097056543,
0.007334583,
-0.0256614573,
0.017171897,
0.0280857868,
-0.0055245971,
-0.0199953355,
-6.43038095e-33,
0.0089804679,
-0.0171403587,
0.0204569269,
-0.0459281206,
-0.038839817,
0.0009666088,
-0.01334316,
0.0107570449,
-0.0221572407,
0.0010040188,
-0.0634099841,
0.0213894732,
0.0214525517,
0.0396482944,
-0.0082430746,
-0.0458307452,
0.0555163175,
-0.0244900361,
-0.0266753938,
0.0019830307,
0.0335806534,
0.0183477756,
0.052541513,
-0.014012509,
0.0034944047,
0.0044362349,
0.0180935506,
0.0360910222,
-0.0230282452,
0.0331383795,
-0.0289994739,
0.048322726,
0.0406053923,
-0.0782214254,
0.002307154,
0.0117441453,
-0.0711028799,
-0.0221244022,
0.0181428306,
0.0253030472,
-0.042871438,
-0.0458016768,
0.0462807566,
-0.0014308153,
0.0388645157,
-0.0151384687,
0.0340587087,
-0.040164452,
0.0044062594,
-0.0807722434,
-0.0564046316,
-0.0069243945,
0.0063663842,
-0.0059124269,
-0.0163441151,
0.0937879235,
0.0049881614,
0.024454372,
-0.0221633315,
0.018365413,
0.0345027596,
0.0344847739,
0.0338167064,
0.0080151791,
-0.0042740763,
0.0225769803,
0.0098431632,
0.0150223952,
-0.0297052637,
-0.0028101653,
0.0265598204,
0.0489209034,
0.0572721101,
0.081485711,
0.0684613287,
0.0137486095,
-0.0313537642,
0.0351883955,
-0.0160997398,
-0.0152098313,
0.0067286608,
-0.0266684256,
-0.0125687784,
-0.0228742156,
-0.0632613823,
-0.0079274355,
-0.0254851095,
0.0201088879,
0.0287264809,
0.0364302993,
-0.0497091934,
0.0265692472,
0.0446586795,
-0.0519701689,
0.0127275223,
0.0128240092,
-0.0209390596,
0.0296389535,
0.0019637684,
0.0062354067,
-0.0215589833,
-0.0349405371,
0.033639662,
0.0200803336,
0.0099478262,
0.0097394455,
0.0333858058,
0.0080847004,
-0.0639152601,
-0.0010796328,
-0.0339013413,
0.054199405,
-0.0311611593,
0.0223235935,
0.0294951461,
0.0365433656,
-0.0299860537,
0.0409772061,
0.0071841562,
0.0042465664,
-0.0464941636,
0.0458631068,
0.0052749682,
0.0506500863,
-0.0125801582,
0.0026702222,
-0.0538077801,
-0.0040243035,
0.0477888696,
-0.0685152113,
-0.023316104,
0.0170423705,
2.482e-7,
0.0322715417,
0.0427863672,
0.0431906469,
0.004433692,
-0.0041016876,
0.0178646147,
0.0295026936,
0.0111908522,
0.0188494027,
-0.0368949622,
0.0140477121,
0.0154385148,
0.0387991481,
0.0294265002,
-0.0910114348,
-0.0157080609,
-0.0592213385,
0.0043079122,
-0.0530809425,
-0.0186745785,
0.0368846841,
0.1207469553,
-0.004251977,
-0.0309524778,
0.008198576,
0.0440326855,
0.0441030301,
-0.0306098294,
-0.0079834191,
0.0417368226,
0.0400305204,
0.0388880186,
0.0065931375,
0.0298392829,
-0.0224024169,
0.0229480844,
0.0150839193,
0.0393073447,
0.0442877151,
-0.0240829904,
-0.0107901338,
-0.038076587,
-0.0212662276,
-0.080034785,
0.0634614453,
-0.1082737222,
-0.010604972,
-0.0145067284,
-0.0354951359,
0.0307372492,
-0.0107097337,
-0.0457645245,
-0.010246844,
0.0249560196,
0.0263213851,
0.0011465432,
0.0075502233,
-0.0450651385,
-0.0229951087,
-0.0030106136,
-0.0387588739,
-0.0251363963,
-0.0199878644,
-0.0251174159,
0.0331486464,
-0.0285061486,
-0.0042112716,
2.568912727e-34,
0.0281906966,
0.068699345,
0.0201647561,
-0.0025013175,
0.0010772822,
-0.0342311785,
0.0253258869,
-0.0194236562,
0.0058682309,
-0.091911532,
-0.0272861086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07826v1 | Antarlekhaka: A Comprehensive Tool for Multi-task Natural Language Annotation | 2023-10-11T19:09:07 | 2023-10-11T19:09:07 | Hrishikesh Terdalkar, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the primary obstacles in the advancement of Natural Language
Processing (NLP) technologies for low-resource languages is the lack of
annotated datasets for training and testing machine learning models. In this
paper, we present Antarlekhaka, a tool for manual annotation of a comprehensive
set of tasks relevant to NLP. The tool is Unicode-compatible,
language-agnostic, Web-deployable and supports distributed annotation by
multiple simultaneous annotators. The system sports user-friendly interfaces
for 8 categories of annotation tasks. These, in turn, enable the annotation of
a considerably larger set of NLP tasks. The task categories include two
linguistic tasks not handled by any other tool, namely, sentence boundary
detection and deciding canonical word order, which are important tasks for text
that is in the form of poetry. We propose the idea of sequential annotation
based on small text units, where an annotator performs several tasks related to
a single text unit before proceeding to the next unit. The research
applications of the proposed mode of multi-task annotation are also discussed.
Antarlekhaka outperforms other annotation tools in objective evaluation. It has
been also used for two real-life annotation tasks on two different languages,
namely, Sanskrit and Bengali. The tool is available at
https://github.com/Antarlekhaka/code. | [
0.0613131411,
-0.0214593057,
-0.0132755246,
0.0264773462,
-0.0380183011,
0.0352501087,
0.0296461247,
-0.037380714,
0.0276863594,
-0.0824075267,
0.0099557294,
-0.0069997427,
0.0141883101,
-0.0431288332,
0.0292738993,
-0.0702555701,
0.0140836248,
-0.015908543,
0.0487145036,
0.0508271977,
0.0491717644,
0.0277307015,
-0.0236773025,
0.0559666976,
-0.0370133482,
-0.0321985073,
-0.0064154239,
-0.009259562,
0.0055295913,
-0.0613507926,
-0.0093899416,
0.0625810623,
-0.025087839,
0.0315028764,
0.0000019851,
-0.069928959,
-0.0286915265,
0.0155819943,
0.0083047953,
-0.0251702145,
0.0529856123,
-0.0050768033,
-0.0221574008,
0.0121494224,
-0.0164043028,
0.0173741132,
0.0929731578,
0.0344748273,
0.0818964466,
0.0814562812,
-0.0061805756,
-0.0213935841,
-0.0016153281,
0.0108458968,
-0.0571652949,
0.0026068042,
-0.0065153488,
0.0206679422,
0.0101790084,
0.0050064391,
-0.0007499604,
0.0296274945,
-0.0174328834,
-0.0321917832,
0.0074470248,
-0.0151456986,
-0.0567117073,
-0.0276831929,
-0.0004181509,
0.0117487321,
-0.0048684091,
-0.020389989,
0.0106879091,
0.0008678671,
-0.0199490096,
-0.0236085262,
-0.0502714403,
0.0434679911,
-0.0192140117,
0.0355508737,
0.0524052419,
0.0139610181,
-0.0076318984,
-0.0009582306,
0.0389402062,
0.0504357591,
-0.0059799375,
-0.0193011276,
0.0002641357,
0.032549981,
-0.0340367071,
-0.0479269661,
0.0370960422,
0.0056364867,
-0.0142672239,
0.0188320521,
-0.0391202681,
-0.1228068247,
0.0308367405,
-0.028474953,
0.0603265874,
0.0137462346,
-0.0233173333,
0.0340138637,
0.0076507418,
0.0033007881,
0.0351005271,
-0.0179965198,
-0.0093668047,
-0.0017790645,
-0.0135670332,
-0.0197754521,
-0.0385717079,
0.0140588563,
-0.0228721183,
-0.0108441161,
-0.0391007811,
0.0148392664,
-0.0178273674,
-0.0014046716,
0.0473449044,
-0.0462967828,
-0.0158478059,
0.0260198954,
0.0302970801,
0.0058621764,
-0.0261931829,
0.016201755,
-0.0173571091,
-0.0528150424,
0.0197730754,
0.0267669465,
0.0408968776,
-0.0292239357,
-0.0063542612,
0.0262988359,
0.0225666035,
-0.0482910201,
-0.0338509604,
-0.0030574638,
0.0030695528,
-0.046958331,
-0.0426580235,
-0.0756250918,
-0.0004135774,
0.0155288065,
-0.0035024367,
0.0052803983,
0.0469413884,
0.0301843639,
0.0041920296,
0.0802908465,
-0.0502031967,
-0.0172619354,
-0.0126526738,
-0.0117641147,
0.0265358854,
0.0654411614,
0.0466810688,
0.0034611456,
0.0670243725,
0.0108853495,
-0.0125519056,
0.0293393526,
-0.0533167608,
-0.0479465239,
0.031619899,
-0.0218489822,
-0.0278017428,
0.0323690958,
-0.0186490435,
0.0363898575,
-0.0080408622,
0.0414147228,
0.0169389974,
0.0554614887,
0.0027995468,
0.0251943264,
0.0393294841,
0.0440305136,
0.0347110964,
0.0209883302,
-0.0228377953,
0.0324227326,
0.0331792869,
0.0042529339,
0.0090254089,
-0.0011113916,
0.0357488953,
-0.0463006906,
-0.0707267448,
-0.0509878397,
0.0099396911,
-0.0294898655,
0.0553430021,
0.0242683943,
-0.0299065057,
-0.0028094505,
0.0353291817,
-0.0703563243,
-0.0059512299,
0.0060664574,
-0.0000136884,
0.0670631081,
0.0243704915,
-0.0665840432,
0.0056982706,
-0.0084688216,
0.0296764784,
0.0446181521,
-0.003010557,
-0.0304965284,
-0.0364009291,
-0.0306118876,
0.0164815281,
-0.0010736849,
0.0076362486,
-0.0029419335,
-0.005925111,
0.0039206753,
-0.0060191303,
0.024383679,
-0.072019659,
0.053293135,
0.0347678699,
-0.0062061637,
-0.0112332171,
0.002026832,
0.0187872928,
0.0441632047,
-0.0261322707,
0.0236971565,
0.033280421,
-0.0206356142,
0.0068097967,
0.0478509553,
0.049711708,
-0.0391754173,
0.0361478999,
-0.0588226616,
-0.0264296029,
0.0415015742,
0.0021953888,
-0.0578558259,
-0.004500899,
-0.0156187257,
0.0121730613,
-0.0290750228,
0.020475477,
-0.0004029255,
-0.0052257618,
-0.0390767604,
0.0211338811,
0.0448323265,
0.0101811476,
-0.0271260422,
-0.034422949,
0.0391808189,
-0.0001715429,
-0.0645664185,
0.0081888856,
0.0296939295,
0.0124874767,
0.0089162821,
-0.0020852366,
-0.0200956855,
-0.0102845896,
-0.1440734565,
0.0180328526,
-0.0367868878,
0.0268939864,
0.0047744554,
0.0027695007,
-0.0015745742,
-0.0458254926,
0.0026570219,
0.0145917041,
0.0014151909,
0.024744181,
0.0351898745,
-0.0081467275,
0.0130483462,
-0.0379273742,
-0.0039689336,
-0.0228283107,
0.0084704747,
0.0679130778,
-0.0968306586,
-0.0372809395,
0.0043760682,
0.0162622239,
0.0037548337,
0.0340180658,
-0.0182333011,
-0.0020384379,
0.0000990065,
-0.0076198084,
0.0374973267,
-0.0271097422,
0.0170165226,
0.0634093434,
0.0014760101,
0.0266587846,
-0.0052173054,
0.0324203148,
0.0431701206,
0.0075397277,
-0.0051765381,
-0.0095698508,
0.0390707292,
-0.0106330141,
-0.0209714845,
0.005706233,
-0.0070249443,
-0.0739218146,
0.0303875338,
-0.0202664938,
0.0008408572,
-0.0654010773,
0.0369361453,
-0.0010687583,
-0.0276842061,
0.0564130396,
-0.0283696577,
-0.0405025221,
-0.0981959552,
-0.0079498021,
-0.048201371,
0.0929226652,
-0.0169801414,
0.0009995989,
-0.0349121802,
-0.041421555,
0.000110921,
0.0737982541,
0.0363260023,
-0.014466106,
0.0117250169,
-0.0521136783,
0.01979159,
-0.0563782863,
0.0000127161,
0.0040476583,
-0.0273897462,
-0.0503080897,
0.0083813118,
0.0333150923,
0.0049835783,
0.0257606413,
0.018381495,
-0.0269826632,
0.0427158661,
-0.0274973754,
0.024439007,
-0.0129684266,
0.0261195041,
0.035045173,
0.0142368702,
-0.0294324942,
0.0363841504,
0.0170403086,
0.0007352515,
-0.0248491857,
-0.0353129618,
-0.0012145524,
-0.0156681668,
0.0279487967,
-0.0708148256,
-0.031344451,
-0.0202308465,
0.0260758772,
-0.0698536783,
0.007518067,
0.0977055207,
0.0536272898,
-0.0167561732,
-0.0083262939,
-0.0312994421,
-0.0123288045,
0.0410019606,
0.0100227855,
-0.0965612158,
-0.0261296518,
0.0068073217,
0.012013793,
0.0037079167,
-0.0165423509,
-0.0103835212,
-0.0870640576,
0.0057193958,
-0.0179936569,
-0.0364509486,
0.0452246666,
-0.0077990242,
-0.0012610122,
-0.0393054523,
-0.0247248318,
-0.0182729922,
-0.0213885289,
0.0207154509,
0.034959618,
-0.0423609465,
-0.0189450048,
-0.0354432575,
-0.064064458,
0.0472177602,
0.0339442976,
0.0433514602,
-0.0104405703,
0.0338898525,
0.0320855603,
0.0116092861,
-0.0085461745,
0.0002258422,
0.0424062163,
0.0065805982,
-0.0265350323,
-0.0072690048,
-0.0206118803,
-0.0013182019,
-0.0137142334,
0.0453153551,
0.0575350896,
0.0060958369,
0.0508447737,
0.0011621431,
-0.0104363421,
0.0242925845,
0.0348712616,
0.0092610074,
-0.0414052382,
-0.0716063157,
-0.0324197076,
-0.0204961002,
-0.0753850713,
-0.0525169559,
0.0155727491,
-0.0640012026,
-0.0580959879,
-0.0871706977,
-0.0836545452,
0.0577679835,
0.021108821,
0.060741026,
0.0740165785,
0.0142803313,
0.0063490919,
-0.0515949801,
-0.026958365,
0.0118701058,
0.012850198,
-0.0144897271,
-0.0391041003,
0.0286904946,
-0.0221326668,
0.0177195612,
0.0360320807,
-0.0587546267,
-0.0461000912,
0.0209999997,
0.0176805537,
0.0137073034,
0.0036582176,
-0.0489731543,
-0.0677303299,
-0.055006288,
0.0059289616,
-0.002797117,
-0.0008169365,
0.0252429154,
0.0218742695,
-0.0136801125,
0.0316026509,
-0.0122064352,
0.0030365475,
-0.0494545996,
0.0092813373,
-0.0064873258,
-0.0217309389,
0.0330050737,
0.0267939698,
0.0412685052,
-0.060185831,
-0.0171899479,
-0.0489695668,
-0.0159762446,
-0.0375471599,
-0.0429767892,
-0.0435640067,
0.0385898612,
0.018626295,
0.0091274679,
-0.0190400966,
0.0138619803,
0.0072114612,
-0.0261560008,
-0.0270169303,
0.0664387718,
0.0447963402,
0.0081896428,
-0.0516619608,
0.0185521599,
-0.0139571382,
-0.0055504953,
0.0017849959,
0.0131959971,
0.0077420212,
-0.005317803,
-0.0050871605,
-0.0412212275,
0.0257447772,
0.0357899442,
0.0010623382,
0.0700387582,
-0.0073062787,
0.0365988314,
0.0980305001,
-0.0331060365,
0.1167969406,
-0.0334110186,
-0.0144516211,
0.0064820442,
0.0567392372,
0.0031937861,
-0.0316310301,
-0.051089406,
-0.0064439727,
-0.0151419034,
-0.010822597,
0.0554282367,
-0.0166273024,
-0.0047987779,
0.0326192267,
-0.0456258915,
-0.0445787571,
-0.0220059901,
-0.0441004336,
0.0193556212,
0.0187251512,
0.0005489328,
-0.0426704325,
-0.0213907361,
-0.0083660427,
-0.0084775276,
-0.0134227099,
-0.0202485081,
0.0208876655,
0.0253995731,
0.020386599,
0.0120268175,
-0.0848361552,
-0.0095880283,
-0.0278224349,
-0.0017504983,
-0.0040607569,
-5.654785737e-33,
-0.0486768112,
-0.0318834893,
-0.0145792589,
0.0374606103,
0.0082020247,
0.0107827494,
-0.0215366241,
0.0164671186,
0.0336411595,
0.0003009941,
0.0016723672,
0.0031674355,
0.0253630821,
-0.0292189289,
0.0529995076,
0.0010427131,
0.0419520885,
0.0100308107,
-0.0183648132,
-0.0231011827,
0.0838355646,
0.0105016157,
0.0708357394,
-0.0967545882,
0.0724317655,
-0.0313609652,
-0.0232276414,
-0.0034897143,
-0.0110391714,
0.0409645773,
-0.0022219061,
0.0322378688,
0.0184991919,
-0.0239177886,
-0.0254008602,
0.0153615484,
-0.0750132278,
-0.0260678176,
0.0271855481,
0.0674834475,
-0.0365235768,
-0.0247630179,
-0.0009099549,
-0.0383573137,
0.0121614113,
0.0572005957,
0.0411529578,
-0.017887067,
0.0013403362,
-0.0364301465,
-0.0901658684,
0.044013992,
-0.0328371115,
-0.006168704,
0.0619090982,
0.0402492397,
0.0261530224,
-0.0460578017,
-0.0666354597,
0.0201023668,
-0.0345970206,
0.0451072492,
0.0149997575,
-0.0133122699,
-0.0573672503,
0.0379663706,
-0.0095526716,
-0.037680544,
0.0405042097,
0.0629330724,
-0.015324235,
0.0243497342,
0.0506319478,
0.0243260544,
0.0356892198,
-0.0108724367,
-0.013099242,
0.0159365758,
0.0469500422,
-0.0105169462,
0.0065646297,
0.0058688442,
-0.0442910865,
-0.0271506589,
0.0065490697,
-0.0410575457,
-0.0020504198,
-0.0204847325,
0.0319769755,
0.0010292836,
-0.0458467267,
0.0934730321,
-0.0002721092,
-0.0160335358,
0.004419459,
0.0000586271,
-0.0113604041,
0.0727798492,
-0.0207083579,
0.003226077,
-0.0101551153,
0.004342007,
-0.0008841231,
0.0105772428,
0.0447962955,
-0.019725306,
0.096567288,
0.0113427173,
-0.0477124751,
-0.0055937348,
-0.0030452739,
0.0459197424,
-0.0131545374,
0.0259184483,
0.0284398682,
-0.0240318961,
-0.0044583534,
0.0300271418,
0.0918653831,
0.0020259924,
-0.0448581129,
0.0096358694,
-0.0290236399,
-0.0537903234,
-0.0079201879,
0.0377738066,
0.000826555,
0.0265054628,
-0.02048954,
-0.0386492759,
0.0112477941,
0.0252592172,
2.734e-7,
0.0559261292,
0.057481084,
0.0335468426,
-0.0452068001,
0.0122430688,
-0.0247882288,
-0.0434009954,
0.0106216464,
-0.0213272516,
0.0175455511,
0.0092689246,
-0.0204940792,
0.0469037853,
0.0452821404,
-0.1461642087,
-0.0392963737,
-0.0327747762,
-0.0024491949,
-0.0780974776,
0.0306400098,
0.0441457331,
0.0636733174,
0.0282958299,
0.0150666041,
-0.0394857787,
-0.0353797488,
0.0325679109,
0.0175845176,
0.0213493928,
0.0036368435,
0.0144610936,
0.0096826414,
-0.0106919575,
0.0076436759,
-0.0186773166,
0.0333754309,
0.062904343,
0.0490738787,
-0.0047823088,
0.0274694264,
0.0445158258,
0.0136754904,
0.0201929677,
-0.0067641521,
0.0594922565,
0.0469453558,
-0.0396655016,
-0.0371777117,
0.0421622694,
0.0059224851,
0.0133749526,
0.0003591078,
-0.0116521521,
-0.0139642078,
0.0102249756,
-0.0721402541,
-0.0331261829,
-0.0323435776,
-0.0603938214,
0.0112729846,
0.0089554517,
-0.0186477713,
-0.0079308655,
-0.0097727757,
-0.0015734889,
-0.1085538492,
-0.0074684951,
2.531860548e-34,
0.0397616588,
-0.0236338209,
0.0268221404,
0.0507761464,
0.0226604901,
0.0167416036,
-0.0157088526,
0.0321319774,
-0.0011940189,
-0.0308395233,
-0.0264613833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07821v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07821v1 | Non-autoregressive Text Editing with Copy-aware Latent Alignments | 2023-10-11T19:02:57 | 2023-10-11T19:02:57 | Yu Zhang, Yue Zhang, Leyang Cui, Guohong Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has witnessed a paradigm shift from Seq2Seq to Seq2Edit in the
field of text editing, with the aim of addressing the slow autoregressive
inference problem posed by the former. Despite promising results, Seq2Edit
approaches still face several challenges such as inflexibility in generation
and difficulty in generalizing to other languages. In this work, we propose a
novel non-autoregressive text editing method to circumvent the above issues, by
modeling the edit process with latent CTC alignments. We make a crucial
extension to CTC by introducing the copy operation into the edit space, thus
enabling more efficient management of textual overlap in editing. We conduct
extensive experiments on GEC and sentence fusion tasks, showing that our
proposed method significantly outperforms existing Seq2Edit models and achieves
similar or even better results than Seq2Seq with over $4\times$ speedup.
Moreover, it demonstrates good generalizability on German and Russian. In-depth
analyses reveal the strengths of our method in terms of the robustness under
various scenarios and generating fluent and flexible outputs. | [
0.0493091531,
0.0640940219,
-0.0051813638,
0.0006303694,
-0.0473570973,
0.0082568498,
-0.016059814,
-0.0225549266,
-0.0250280034,
-0.045061402,
-0.0067901351,
-0.0307762269,
0.0290110651,
0.0336347036,
0.0270026233,
-0.0367359258,
0.0535683148,
-0.0064538326,
-0.0254413988,
0.02419178,
0.0319052599,
-0.0086386343,
0.0026979875,
0.0332107395,
-0.011652722,
-0.0395295843,
-0.0323913358,
0.0262070429,
0.0379677974,
0.0471109636,
0.021245759,
0.0791966245,
-0.012156806,
0.0831084624,
0.0000019467,
-0.0181250218,
-0.0504659377,
-0.0203630589,
0.0336428098,
0.0326370932,
0.0449850522,
-0.0243740268,
-0.069735378,
0.0090582892,
-0.0369730741,
0.0296884626,
0.0753693357,
0.0445882119,
0.0732694268,
0.085303165,
-0.0353932977,
-0.0049605244,
-0.0087749921,
-0.0452700667,
0.0105067324,
-0.0099189803,
0.0291880146,
-0.0249307845,
-0.0133610312,
-0.0015110106,
-0.0001946835,
0.0546909384,
0.006999807,
-0.0948515236,
0.0144614996,
0.0238628089,
-0.0378227755,
-0.0066462713,
-0.0131913079,
0.0167217273,
-0.0069775968,
-0.0396637358,
0.0020423669,
-0.0096563203,
0.0121610956,
0.005363876,
-0.0460672416,
0.0023095629,
-0.0163590498,
-0.0029618442,
0.0146334022,
-0.0557777062,
-0.0020018877,
-0.0135178519,
0.0087900292,
0.0218922775,
0.0523383245,
-0.0234738868,
-0.0364234634,
0.0209409297,
-0.0167921074,
-0.0785687715,
0.0127512533,
0.0165035482,
-0.0516157635,
-0.0424942374,
-0.086361289,
-0.0661870316,
-0.0309966616,
-0.0146181406,
0.0100385211,
0.0401533209,
0.0410009474,
0.0398855768,
-0.0413812399,
0.0516148731,
-0.0375002399,
-0.0072477972,
-0.0166837573,
-0.0069927219,
-0.0495701246,
-0.0175680481,
-0.0649341121,
-0.002138189,
-0.0307986122,
-0.0168687552,
-0.0604670234,
0.0541957952,
0.0077081989,
0.0105452472,
0.0091117043,
0.0088768713,
-0.0431713872,
-0.009401612,
0.025910534,
-0.0103478646,
0.014589197,
0.0113863247,
0.0021576246,
0.0039946898,
-0.0230372567,
0.032033585,
0.0167307127,
-0.0615778752,
-0.0441196822,
0.0239731874,
-0.0613716617,
-0.007181068,
-0.0011546004,
-0.0244894531,
-0.0334933996,
-0.0298201703,
-0.0494190156,
-0.0603580736,
0.0273157023,
0.0005478196,
-0.0160000585,
-0.0592193194,
0.0002104202,
-0.0021061893,
-0.0459596068,
0.0522576682,
-0.0317455381,
0.0192992222,
0.0391011387,
-0.0229542423,
0.0004848491,
0.0212986097,
0.0393543243,
0.0068774503,
0.0411874764,
0.0531444512,
0.0180347264,
0.0565087274,
-0.0235344414,
0.0112942765,
-0.0020659261,
-0.0327784158,
0.0285844672,
0.0193560496,
0.0353115648,
0.0440876298,
-0.0156439021,
0.0228162427,
0.0910990089,
-0.0012707266,
0.0343470052,
0.0211760402,
0.0382418707,
-0.0238052662,
-0.0049836589,
0.0448130332,
-0.0376081057,
0.0526024774,
-0.0029005196,
0.0274760853,
0.0618711449,
-0.0071687442,
0.0071124597,
-0.0015097309,
0.0179717094,
0.0015623969,
0.0071030492,
-0.0925819948,
0.0119103137,
0.0095100524,
-0.0557271354,
-0.0012955382,
-0.0297173262,
-0.0719304159,
0.0028905128,
-0.0014169234,
-0.0382728986,
0.0378118828,
0.078955628,
-0.0053606974,
-0.054375466,
-0.0110868756,
0.0005330611,
0.0477224626,
0.0506028868,
-0.0194052551,
-0.0063086813,
-0.0381103754,
-0.0434273444,
-0.0492782444,
-0.0048161685,
-0.013590646,
0.0354343057,
0.0125488769,
0.0301636178,
0.0197266806,
-0.0140831843,
0.0135191856,
-0.0292088278,
-0.0015845268,
-0.0020446579,
0.0295426641,
-0.0253564771,
-0.009860564,
-0.0350636654,
0.055856064,
-0.0173665769,
-0.0337315835,
-0.0558301769,
0.0670317784,
-0.0012756665,
-0.0561104827,
0.037893448,
-0.0239827186,
-0.048442103,
-0.0057855286,
-0.0189776048,
-0.0614591166,
-0.0257465858,
-0.0331896804,
0.0283637308,
-0.0552935973,
0.0662074685,
0.0200465508,
-0.0428689346,
-0.00427804,
0.0418061577,
0.0051269303,
-0.0179832857,
0.0693299547,
0.0159043223,
0.01939689,
-0.0297634508,
-0.0317145027,
-0.0129515305,
0.0442130789,
-0.0400954261,
0.0291933846,
0.0091274045,
0.000754586,
-0.0603550449,
-0.0539247356,
0.017467238,
-0.0593892075,
0.0301616248,
0.0528924242,
0.0456184298,
-0.0088916486,
-0.0132193705,
-0.0349736176,
-0.0045102476,
0.0103628393,
0.0508180186,
0.0604379252,
0.0145687694,
-0.0040264404,
-0.0485748686,
0.0097213276,
-0.0315096676,
0.0016655048,
0.0226411093,
-0.0570084564,
-0.0330774002,
0.0237116423,
-0.0142609896,
0.0357345976,
0.0237085205,
-0.0307145957,
-0.0205596071,
-0.0031928485,
0.1066711992,
0.0419564694,
0.0284288246,
-0.031759344,
0.0101551758,
-0.0181958079,
0.0300925486,
0.0081586642,
-0.0096825715,
-0.0116113024,
0.0133085297,
-0.0196425505,
0.0191107951,
0.1024399027,
0.0062298803,
-0.0055251927,
-0.0850693733,
0.0032119588,
-0.0125761181,
-0.0128483959,
-0.0274292007,
-0.0193926971,
-0.0407751277,
0.012414448,
-0.0761024728,
-0.02854787,
0.0720557347,
-0.0025889105,
-0.0077628451,
-0.0081167547,
-0.0043248748,
-0.0305907838,
0.0261424836,
0.0059491959,
0.0307359826,
-0.0438264087,
-0.0255563669,
-0.1051180437,
0.0284559801,
0.0685635731,
0.019294858,
0.0334364623,
-0.0398326479,
0.0340255573,
-0.0312359445,
-0.0433986671,
-0.008692136,
-0.0411390439,
0.0253688712,
0.0391477533,
0.0584242791,
-0.0375808701,
-0.0429234058,
0.0311971772,
-0.0031833914,
0.0994249955,
-0.0519755855,
-0.019006528,
-0.0204232335,
0.0653053373,
0.0813164636,
-0.0197875649,
-0.0384197421,
-0.0478920415,
0.0326445773,
0.0738205537,
0.02753352,
0.0040683337,
0.0228108503,
-0.0250435397,
-0.0063491948,
-0.067716293,
-0.0185816307,
-0.0290998183,
0.0336600244,
-0.0078495238,
-0.0256288964,
0.1116620302,
0.0237516686,
-0.0263002459,
-0.0229805112,
-0.0256727096,
0.0269005857,
0.0236015636,
0.033009734,
-0.0825773105,
-0.0055609164,
0.0144918682,
0.0049248058,
0.0067582517,
-0.0385289453,
0.0002130646,
-0.0685185865,
0.0258219671,
0.0204663649,
-0.0241393708,
-0.0210461896,
0.0160335824,
0.0287410058,
-0.0058008041,
-0.0466486439,
0.0422713794,
-0.0306087993,
0.0113959992,
-0.0105683478,
-0.0041861795,
0.0045417915,
-0.0412944891,
-0.0410987213,
-0.0029153579,
0.045484744,
0.0440757759,
0.0366188958,
-0.0218218341,
0.0736850277,
-0.006058841,
-0.009635061,
-0.0041540675,
0.0142250657,
-0.0328152142,
0.0060344371,
0.0006085823,
0.0377975293,
0.0479245,
-0.045037847,
0.0231649652,
0.0454480089,
-0.0361441188,
0.0079028774,
-0.0005653754,
-0.0174629204,
0.0376776382,
0.0509216599,
0.0356842317,
-0.04628364,
-0.0405386947,
-0.0389783271,
-0.0226109698,
-0.0473394096,
-0.0233434811,
-0.0212461539,
0.0060091293,
-0.0192529596,
-0.0869170651,
-0.0449277684,
0.0357828513,
0.0234228875,
0.0280326642,
0.0533116832,
-0.0454968065,
-0.0638870001,
-0.0430182703,
-0.0507817306,
-0.000173925,
0.0262015481,
-0.0596918911,
0.0098670013,
-0.008688774,
-0.0047813146,
-0.0138806868,
-0.0316301323,
-0.0737814158,
-0.0979972631,
-0.0092575634,
0.0115118399,
0.0113603063,
0.0424543992,
-0.0226678904,
-0.0386208333,
0.0237511769,
-0.0013501637,
0.0084538637,
0.0330404304,
-0.0063890591,
0.0125623867,
-0.0146099702,
0.0514592752,
-0.0310301799,
-0.0512960479,
0.0016149773,
0.0683774576,
-0.006419945,
-0.0762342885,
0.008438128,
-0.0210775193,
0.0433648266,
-0.0103627546,
0.0557614677,
-0.0682273805,
0.0369836949,
-0.0385620706,
-0.0007106267,
-0.0265679136,
0.0242271703,
-0.0091409627,
0.012708392,
-0.0179065503,
0.0685988739,
-0.0466149449,
0.0110500446,
-0.0652853772,
-0.0170209445,
-0.0073503768,
0.0253760032,
0.0499722026,
-0.0018476172,
0.0008618795,
0.0305958055,
0.0112630064,
0.0066538379,
-0.0306940209,
0.0468431227,
0.0558369793,
0.0102356113,
0.0058216462,
0.0488782264,
-0.0842213631,
0.038306661,
-0.0228993949,
0.0072853002,
0.0814155117,
-0.0164945852,
0.1195454076,
-0.0635387152,
-0.0308466833,
-0.0180191342,
0.0443224683,
0.0423850156,
-0.0050179893,
-0.0242351051,
-0.0117131537,
0.0139438398,
0.0386946835,
0.0483544618,
-0.0233497862,
0.0374112129,
-0.0078190388,
-0.0372968093,
-0.0203396995,
-0.0175226573,
0.0276279692,
-0.0449102335,
-0.0381186344,
-0.0224852953,
-0.0161868911,
-0.0283341072,
0.041841846,
0.0453309976,
-0.04978339,
0.0258144848,
0.002690597,
0.0438680798,
-0.0219922587,
-0.0153729096,
-0.0430553444,
0.0124598434,
0.0299000125,
-0.0361974835,
-0.0207380131,
-5.688368141e-33,
-0.0048153815,
-0.0215382781,
0.0083134081,
0.0236071795,
-0.0226107016,
-0.0070273802,
-0.0595345534,
0.0067151035,
0.0571712963,
0.0030897374,
-0.0333135203,
0.0452773347,
0.004372519,
-0.0249643791,
0.0225727651,
0.0715944618,
0.0934662893,
0.0029923646,
-0.0269973893,
-0.0014397394,
0.0275500976,
0.0311074816,
0.0483787991,
-0.0356858969,
0.0579123758,
-0.0122495247,
0.0019078873,
0.0073619843,
0.0219481234,
0.0393403098,
0.0210976042,
-0.019315837,
0.0082585402,
-0.0263677444,
-0.0291117895,
0.0052506924,
-0.0504362397,
-0.024722388,
-0.0039933361,
0.0038019302,
-0.0322139263,
-0.0570077039,
0.0062011485,
-0.0196882188,
-0.0046453476,
-0.0002355281,
0.0266584642,
0.0078755897,
0.0294987373,
-0.0442429893,
-0.0649656281,
0.0300701149,
0.0022103239,
0.004190465,
0.0014646936,
0.0197073948,
0.0523761213,
-0.0352395065,
-0.0762072429,
0.0256888904,
-0.0004861823,
0.0746354908,
0.0417393781,
-0.007223356,
0.0020192773,
0.0274378583,
-0.0231568757,
0.0025923047,
-0.0188328791,
0.0054989215,
-0.024023477,
-0.0009400748,
0.0163877215,
0.0533000156,
0.0013596528,
-0.0079051554,
-0.0248115696,
0.077720575,
-0.0175437741,
0.0491004139,
-0.01588431,
0.0397414714,
0.0221382808,
-0.0074444665,
-0.0172115434,
0.0159179606,
-0.0252045635,
-0.0048944172,
0.0431047939,
0.0244428013,
-0.0071707587,
0.0053711035,
0.020771578,
0.0255954489,
-0.0094165131,
0.0052479929,
-0.0534975603,
0.0223924797,
-0.0396158174,
0.0241532046,
0.0029970293,
-0.0037362943,
0.0434157513,
0.0261821467,
0.0200466625,
0.0042886063,
0.0232165065,
0.028954139,
-0.0838863179,
0.0028811644,
0.0003485934,
0.0242506638,
-0.0180377085,
-0.0239221379,
0.0164218992,
-0.0406270102,
0.0179497059,
0.0019388226,
0.0234461557,
0.0050795567,
-0.0362651572,
0.0035839705,
0.0419609509,
0.0296772514,
0.0028261982,
0.0413041264,
-0.0063623842,
0.0408228748,
0.0078391051,
-0.0343443714,
-0.0053230529,
0.0126623958,
2.5e-7,
0.049202852,
0.0153631596,
0.0497078076,
-0.0191198662,
0.0076308097,
0.0087823132,
-0.0460251831,
0.0330825523,
-0.0037796865,
0.0513044223,
0.030135626,
0.0236151572,
0.0439381152,
0.0014266085,
-0.0660539493,
0.0188022126,
-0.07814271,
0.0281947497,
-0.0750993937,
-0.0043408168,
0.0553795844,
0.0405671,
-0.0154618928,
0.0173088294,
-0.0156231057,
-0.0368395075,
0.0823513716,
0.0331305675,
-0.0189362336,
0.0196337029,
0.0462314002,
-0.0239046738,
-0.0053993752,
-0.0117764091,
-0.0368718617,
0.0008515608,
0.0353881232,
0.0624880344,
-0.0360030085,
0.0128040705,
0.009165504,
-0.01595488,
-0.0301183034,
-0.0053192046,
0.0688729584,
-0.0427940302,
0.0133183338,
-0.0200047996,
-0.028829189,
0.0446846373,
0.0362220816,
0.0050186152,
-0.0330165327,
0.0148078427,
0.0302085355,
0.062428724,
-0.0316465311,
-0.0558596179,
-0.0325188227,
-0.0175057855,
-0.0055471938,
-0.034077324,
-0.0421245135,
0.0231355149,
0.009499656,
-0.0195541456,
-0.0188764594,
2.416878374e-34,
0.0122270733,
0.0099145425,
0.0347567499,
0.0147735262,
0.0170583893,
-0.0343890116,
0.0312816687,
0.0189212468,
-0.0056828777,
-0.0772927552,
-0.0760760754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07819v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07819v2 | Faithfulness Measurable Masked Language Models | 2023-10-11T19:00:40 | 2024-05-09T18:55:43 | Andreas Madsen, Siva Reddy, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | A common approach to explaining NLP models is to use importance measures that
express which tokens are important for a prediction. Unfortunately, such
explanations are often wrong despite being persuasive. Therefore, it is
essential to measure their faithfulness. One such metric is if tokens are truly
important, then masking them should result in worse model performance. However,
token masking introduces out-of-distribution issues, and existing solutions
that address this are computationally expensive and employ proxy models.
Furthermore, other metrics are very limited in scope. This work proposes an
inherently faithfulness measurable model that addresses these challenges. This
is achieved using a novel fine-tuning method that incorporates masking, such
that masking tokens become in-distribution by design. This differs from
existing approaches, which are completely model-agnostic but are inapplicable
in practice. We demonstrate the generality of our approach by applying it to 16
different datasets and validate it using statistical in-distribution tests. The
faithfulness is then measured with 9 different importance measures. Because
masking is in-distribution, importance measures that themselves use masking
become consistently more faithful. Additionally, because the model makes
faithfulness cheap to measure, we can optimize explanations towards maximal
faithfulness; thus, our model becomes indirectly inherently explainable. | [
0.0204622857,
0.0794268623,
-0.038054727,
0.0314202867,
-0.0397299677,
0.0223186761,
-0.0063984077,
0.0059774653,
-0.0191681702,
-0.0658013448,
0.0180455595,
-0.0199880134,
0.0165841319,
0.0720691457,
0.0024862159,
-0.0713820979,
0.0382830799,
-0.0098694786,
-0.0096479431,
0.011771298,
0.0129187172,
-0.0058577275,
0.0262991097,
0.0752601251,
0.017312998,
0.0156136705,
0.0387111604,
-0.0174385794,
-0.0011622785,
-0.0003792334,
0.0268358309,
0.0540674403,
-0.0193264522,
0.010532042,
0.0000022422,
-0.052271273,
-0.0294527337,
0.0078613264,
-0.0375866368,
0.009010043,
0.0083885714,
-0.0332962945,
0.0041853855,
-0.0011749305,
-0.011406919,
0.0586478747,
0.0768226236,
0.0495632067,
0.0271929633,
0.0419802926,
-0.0026563578,
0.006744314,
0.0095638605,
-0.0158085003,
-0.0068705678,
-0.022870345,
0.0155345304,
0.0063789673,
-0.0584790744,
0.0152693698,
-0.0068642674,
0.0191881824,
0.0090128398,
0.0049634157,
0.0323906317,
-0.0028487123,
-0.0118830027,
-0.0138440887,
0.0304542463,
0.0277802162,
-0.0258692987,
-0.0853888392,
0.0369737446,
-0.0448918007,
-0.013396794,
0.0563687347,
-0.0665326118,
-0.0019083662,
0.0442020185,
0.0215062536,
0.0247875433,
0.0231234748,
0.0572116859,
0.0330572985,
-0.0172125716,
0.0781483576,
0.0118463738,
-0.000338554,
-0.0660113618,
-0.0200096332,
-0.0787937343,
-0.0792246535,
-0.0154816229,
-0.0145938331,
-0.0064374139,
0.0237147622,
-0.025355218,
-0.0311150178,
0.0155462567,
-0.0533666164,
0.0106994882,
0.018142337,
-0.0185277853,
0.0358949676,
-0.0421101861,
0.0762353837,
0.0118543245,
0.0259829387,
-0.0200094357,
-0.0156242,
-0.0494533032,
-0.0102432612,
0.014531225,
0.0294300653,
-0.0059070704,
-0.0314875245,
-0.0175003875,
-0.0158251449,
-0.0725664943,
0.0013424449,
0.0028174818,
0.0092995409,
-0.0177698787,
-0.0120359026,
-0.0167110655,
-0.0259665456,
-0.0212691743,
0.013678479,
-0.0037668236,
-0.049576249,
-0.0014312878,
0.0105984816,
-0.0106881298,
-0.0009447352,
-0.0058548939,
0.0745731369,
0.0566527806,
-0.0204318427,
-0.0061375955,
-0.0244818702,
-0.02327873,
-0.043285612,
-0.0322992206,
-0.0579051785,
-0.0296839327,
0.0311774053,
0.0331436098,
-0.0679253265,
-0.0043099653,
-0.0006138066,
-0.025082957,
0.0760315359,
0.0325547606,
0.0109902769,
-0.0359240733,
-0.0003893692,
-0.0376221202,
0.0401212387,
0.0249196235,
-0.0031032041,
0.0747452751,
-0.0323776118,
0.0050405632,
0.0018305731,
0.0273689888,
0.0178722013,
0.0015263229,
-0.00964393,
-0.0131531376,
-0.053419359,
0.024188403,
0.0203214604,
-0.0107314633,
-0.0141321588,
0.0639729574,
0.014540961,
-0.0019593944,
-0.0041562836,
0.022059001,
0.0230427068,
-0.0344015583,
0.0395396166,
-0.0705673546,
0.0167527385,
-0.0308549721,
-0.007806066,
0.0277832728,
0.001400526,
-0.0036445498,
-0.0680385605,
-0.0387869813,
0.0084425136,
0.019963257,
0.028799016,
0.0479340032,
0.0021222557,
-0.0144041022,
0.0623614229,
0.0296014864,
-0.0252483208,
0.003338652,
-0.0692576468,
0.0422121696,
0.0281313639,
0.024354117,
-0.0201032739,
0.0310033672,
0.0168754514,
0.0134421075,
0.007659317,
0.0018982887,
0.0005505822,
0.022780437,
-0.0101328949,
-0.0202053562,
-0.0239058975,
0.0790459961,
0.0212216675,
0.0211002808,
-0.0308917593,
0.0194319729,
-0.0631063879,
-0.0370798782,
0.0442631356,
-0.0185518805,
-0.0314023346,
-0.0088229226,
-0.012954724,
0.0558716431,
0.0010816217,
-0.0041239038,
0.0331565365,
0.0024461891,
-0.0208462644,
-0.0155452313,
0.0082224319,
-0.0270819478,
0.0266550612,
0.0203894172,
-0.0555417426,
0.0113807796,
0.073598139,
-0.0334337875,
-0.0490721874,
0.028756706,
-0.0402616262,
0.0794646814,
-0.029454764,
0.0356045961,
-0.035510201,
0.0186065435,
-0.0363290831,
0.05489197,
-0.0045963069,
0.070127137,
0.0182503648,
-0.0013307597,
0.0441884212,
-0.0188394953,
0.0024934332,
0.002260522,
-0.0135988183,
-0.0015765255,
0.0644814968,
-0.0312708765,
-0.0165569037,
-0.0245041046,
-0.0437860563,
-0.0242175963,
-0.0276117343,
0.0047605028,
0.0423343629,
0.0108419517,
0.0044618738,
0.000252059,
-0.0176767241,
-0.0529120639,
0.01871912,
0.0072953985,
0.0092906486,
-0.019933302,
-0.0291241426,
-0.041365955,
-0.0111287795,
-0.0056145894,
0.0693624541,
-0.0167159364,
-0.0339135788,
-0.0555022135,
0.0050944882,
-0.0224966258,
0.0086216284,
-0.0145406481,
-0.0214604493,
-0.0190731324,
0.044050552,
-0.0045285425,
0.0409790464,
0.004616579,
0.0007132081,
0.0293880273,
0.0322449468,
-0.0692156702,
-0.0541862659,
-0.0479566567,
0.0176579654,
0.0274447799,
-0.0791516006,
0.0279128402,
0.0586783998,
0.0247520898,
-0.0396112725,
-0.0864610747,
0.040019583,
-0.0432324409,
-0.0158253014,
-0.0189202037,
-0.0264201742,
-0.0039808089,
0.0589450747,
-0.0277867764,
-0.0862678662,
0.0452047363,
-0.0664626658,
0.0320895463,
-0.0023258415,
-0.0292142518,
-0.0363363475,
0.0388514213,
0.0076232469,
0.0104873031,
0.054964412,
-0.0015327752,
0.003793007,
-0.028068509,
0.0538663454,
-0.0216034595,
0.0346455984,
-0.0505525619,
0.0227065403,
0.0540724881,
-0.0100217983,
-0.0268955994,
-0.0541781373,
-0.0191406328,
0.0370581709,
0.0228200089,
-0.0213882513,
-0.0209161453,
0.0412743576,
0.0229708515,
0.02759872,
-0.0213613808,
0.0029299296,
-0.0193893947,
-0.0035837903,
0.0568794049,
0.0058832727,
0.0783735961,
-0.0318868645,
-0.0111897215,
0.0171245635,
0.0539200641,
0.0580885895,
-0.0210911501,
0.0032581668,
0.0067805494,
-0.0310191847,
-0.0141722159,
0.0175258424,
0.050563246,
-0.0472520068,
-0.0181107558,
0.1136470363,
0.0220029168,
0.0121773258,
0.0467589274,
-0.019920731,
0.0545313582,
0.0251776259,
-0.0099747917,
-0.031389486,
-0.0234159324,
0.0470539927,
0.0490110405,
-0.0428749546,
-0.0165739637,
-0.0053331726,
-0.0816391334,
0.0299477931,
0.0032544576,
-0.0009731204,
-0.0435363725,
-0.1040515155,
0.0267604478,
-0.0410512462,
0.0229265522,
-0.0218894314,
0.0302561596,
0.0075892634,
0.0214421246,
-0.0579170957,
-0.0595723167,
0.0302644782,
-0.0321002044,
0.0310386457,
0.0642464608,
0.0128183039,
0.005073281,
-0.0513818413,
0.0442356095,
-0.0365878455,
-0.0153186759,
-0.0221872386,
0.0520984717,
0.0057308767,
-0.0194150601,
-0.0288131051,
0.0393988676,
-0.0060352478,
-0.030487394,
-0.0405031592,
0.0217242166,
-0.0047751362,
-0.0346105844,
-0.0076823016,
-0.0226706918,
-0.0084804045,
0.1217624992,
0.0441429764,
0.0005426272,
-0.0157074742,
-0.0572452284,
0.0158280525,
-0.0148931611,
-0.0483392663,
0.004332317,
-0.0053365333,
-0.0200286396,
-0.0640274435,
0.0034135554,
-0.0125181861,
0.0281842034,
0.024673691,
0.0235105157,
0.0038129711,
-0.0525882244,
-0.0163838472,
0.0509717837,
-0.054243315,
0.0220321435,
-0.0450231433,
-0.0415785909,
0.0142814545,
-0.0229700767,
-0.0326064192,
-0.004705911,
-0.0408239625,
-0.0520825237,
0.0053425897,
0.0241659191,
0.0333579406,
0.0554616004,
-0.0129392585,
-0.0780548751,
0.0373283513,
-0.0179287661,
-0.0285990406,
0.017933121,
0.0435779393,
-0.0433687717,
0.0069850874,
0.0432068184,
-0.0511534624,
0.0131770708,
0.0449698381,
0.0443981178,
-0.0042479844,
0.002983697,
0.0379036628,
0.0170840248,
0.0538027957,
-0.005690001,
-0.0221969243,
-0.0374222137,
-0.0203661565,
0.002671187,
-0.0354773887,
-0.0330910385,
0.0315025076,
0.0164385922,
0.0241261534,
-0.047969304,
-0.0080547361,
-0.0487945527,
0.0035459106,
-0.0517568588,
0.0125210145,
-0.0115262037,
0.0048846616,
-0.0318644643,
-0.0108028986,
-0.0066871583,
0.0066702743,
-0.0271035023,
0.0391983092,
-0.011119986,
0.0072974609,
0.0208608955,
-0.0000500151,
-0.0145590622,
0.0163013265,
-0.0718209371,
-0.0158848036,
-0.0295447223,
-0.0194373261,
0.0262812506,
-0.0593437478,
0.0702581257,
-0.0095949126,
-0.0133669721,
-0.014850066,
0.0537639856,
0.0702335313,
-0.0008863464,
-0.013021661,
0.0246445239,
-0.0346224271,
0.0312737599,
0.054468561,
0.0272786617,
0.013226198,
-0.019757688,
-0.021503035,
-0.0104992213,
-0.000393096,
0.0173175409,
0.0825223252,
-0.0122069716,
0.0044979942,
-0.0675656199,
-0.065298669,
-0.0011202872,
0.0043552248,
0.0018836079,
-0.0206167866,
-0.0055273315,
0.0643783882,
-0.0092478236,
-0.0145057542,
-0.0709520876,
-0.0244559012,
0.0273751933,
0.0371875577,
0.0054185055,
-7.179121628e-33,
-0.010530889,
-0.051861234,
-0.0650640354,
0.0012165741,
0.0323157459,
0.0321373753,
-0.0454462692,
-0.0104015898,
-0.0252959728,
0.0114032142,
0.0192968082,
0.014563011,
0.0183868613,
-0.003441117,
-0.0033377274,
-0.0063689132,
0.0355501287,
0.0554220863,
-0.0573429391,
-0.0045332471,
0.046616476,
-0.0140112098,
0.0409948118,
-0.0872935429,
0.0869583115,
0.0116856275,
-0.0106767211,
0.0049609579,
-0.0154156666,
0.0676112771,
-0.0115338573,
0.0491228811,
0.0326881334,
-0.0651118904,
-0.0218995009,
-0.0035678709,
-0.0647750944,
-0.0210763309,
0.0703407004,
-0.0076957191,
0.0023518871,
-0.0210984107,
0.0692792907,
-0.0094149467,
-0.0399155766,
-0.0024622709,
0.0516432188,
-0.0348763987,
-0.0073188492,
0.0103813689,
-0.0609040782,
0.0534497127,
-0.0132379374,
-0.0219408385,
0.0253845137,
0.0334961973,
-0.0056228442,
0.0566859879,
-0.0362568349,
0.0113443807,
0.0065049552,
0.056308534,
0.0782336518,
0.0194619056,
0.020648459,
0.0993961394,
0.0200855359,
0.0035116081,
0.0117000611,
-0.0113298129,
0.0564235263,
0.0230741035,
0.0980048552,
0.0341912545,
0.0578895435,
0.0077179824,
-0.0574187525,
0.0350129232,
-0.0339833461,
-0.0143795172,
0.0585882403,
0.0251370985,
-0.0611955188,
-0.0310563967,
-0.0684527159,
-0.0390411504,
-0.0413079374,
-0.0036736266,
0.0380924493,
-0.0094183031,
-0.0772414505,
0.0154902171,
0.0198672786,
-0.0593646429,
-0.0211974923,
0.0042125364,
-0.001533039,
-0.0005253546,
0.0075012855,
0.0124261053,
-0.0325879641,
-0.0316942707,
0.0077423141,
0.0229383968,
0.0520244725,
-0.024289418,
0.0426827185,
-0.0062485882,
-0.0642804801,
-0.0086144209,
-0.0381803475,
-0.0137852244,
-0.0283274762,
-0.0119120618,
0.0333979987,
0.0353687927,
-0.020217618,
0.0393554494,
0.01091226,
-0.0165879633,
-0.0141317835,
0.051198367,
-0.036072474,
0.0367475748,
-0.0364387184,
-0.0348587185,
-0.0311895255,
0.0108138602,
0.0443658642,
-0.012870607,
-0.0434827954,
-0.010187936,
2.847e-7,
0.0364930555,
0.0453739725,
-0.0035026988,
0.0061592772,
0.0155425444,
0.0528732948,
0.010684222,
-0.01341403,
0.0035648076,
-0.0531456247,
-0.0359139033,
-0.0002093349,
0.0550097525,
-0.0227387268,
-0.027640691,
-0.0002782734,
-0.0602066033,
-0.0223171189,
-0.0300808419,
0.0247829352,
0.0206215885,
0.1028722376,
0.0376764722,
0.0385073908,
-0.0133829163,
-0.0279123932,
0.0232841317,
-0.0595796332,
0.0056066238,
0.0332018286,
0.0150409192,
0.0135124559,
0.0188145768,
0.0065660677,
-0.0336858816,
0.0238681082,
0.0383823924,
0.0497382209,
-0.0091520064,
-0.0145725617,
-0.0582459122,
-0.0147232581,
0.0128608039,
-0.1057380214,
0.0876438916,
-0.0194476638,
-0.0356592163,
-0.0622849502,
-0.0523071177,
-0.0056224694,
0.0170076285,
0.0191667639,
-0.0463342629,
0.0335638039,
0.0173940361,
0.0118091162,
-0.031099081,
-0.0557540096,
-0.0704667345,
-0.0289597623,
-0.0234980509,
-0.0408075154,
-0.0183775742,
-0.016338896,
0.0341135152,
-0.0634241775,
-0.0029275252,
3.055747156e-34,
0.041862499,
0.0139074372,
0.0104909064,
0.0117603363,
0.0653520823,
0.0064267744,
0.0258789062,
0.0161585454,
0.0301034823,
-0.0607972331,
-0.0043949583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07818v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07818v3 | On the Relationship between Sentence Analogy Identification and Sentence Structure Encoding in Large Language Models | 2023-10-11T18:59:48 | 2024-02-06T02:24:53 | Thilini Wijesiriwardene, Ruwan Wickramarachchi, Aishwarya Naresh Reganti, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Amit Sheth, Amitava Das | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to encode syntactic and semantic
structures of language is well examined in NLP. Additionally, analogy
identification, in the form of word analogies are extensively studied in the
last decade of language modeling literature. In this work we specifically look
at how LLMs' abilities to capture sentence analogies (sentences that convey
analogous meaning to each other) vary with LLMs' abilities to encode syntactic
and semantic structures of sentences. Through our analysis, we find that LLMs'
ability to identify sentence analogies is positively correlated with their
ability to encode syntactic and semantic structures of sentences. Specifically,
we find that the LLMs which capture syntactic structures better, also have
higher abilities in identifying sentence analogies. | [
0.0382126905,
0.0454621464,
-0.0297559481,
0.0658096597,
-0.0423387513,
0.0516135655,
0.0006064894,
-0.0056572692,
-0.0158522837,
-0.0771661624,
-0.0551823564,
-0.0099162711,
-0.0263546165,
-0.0521565974,
0.0315937884,
-0.0490162782,
0.0097073326,
-0.0132262772,
0.0026124022,
0.0153605994,
0.0221089441,
0.0314482823,
0.0325770862,
0.0267735329,
0.0404502787,
-0.0136461668,
0.046921134,
-0.0143485935,
0.0223659277,
-0.0388563238,
-0.0049169254,
-0.0064556473,
0.0151314493,
-0.0042186738,
0.0000015146,
-0.0584334135,
0.0174285248,
-0.0331900902,
-0.0099850958,
0.0620369725,
0.0786217153,
-0.0278428793,
0.0236672983,
0.0107933879,
0.0154260257,
-0.0145566622,
0.0322637931,
0.0534032956,
0.0138793075,
0.0319314636,
-0.0207669754,
-0.0767795444,
0.007142059,
0.011381628,
-0.0164723471,
-0.01384601,
0.0401763022,
0.0635581911,
0.004107778,
0.0123746675,
0.0100377575,
0.0114223249,
0.0039227246,
0.0306135658,
0.0062027201,
0.0452691466,
0.0206913762,
0.0392130874,
0.0040935916,
0.016527243,
-0.0243473556,
-0.0763610825,
0.0067595523,
0.0085949153,
-0.0078681707,
0.0306483824,
-0.0809018016,
0.0451796241,
0.0098886089,
0.0946037695,
0.1023728251,
0.0302400868,
0.0158045646,
0.015689142,
-0.0273661613,
0.0432998799,
0.0286238045,
-0.0315177813,
-0.0070843194,
0.001404667,
-0.022649521,
-0.0420392938,
0.0079206126,
0.0096491575,
-0.0037768281,
0.0061453525,
-0.0493738353,
-0.0315874144,
0.0109909186,
-0.1084529087,
0.1018996611,
0.0266939718,
0.0140440743,
0.0528805405,
-0.0960231572,
0.0606644414,
-0.0412850454,
0.0566732511,
-0.0827225447,
-0.0196298938,
-0.0722085387,
-0.0168217644,
-0.0292391703,
0.0535927974,
0.0051850216,
-0.0513153076,
-0.0122064324,
0.0227129683,
0.0006517873,
-0.0322276875,
-0.0256492011,
0.0044348254,
0.014518383,
-0.0073164981,
-0.0434629209,
-0.0128285419,
-0.0413228646,
0.047743056,
-0.0322576463,
-0.0251908265,
-0.0003780769,
0.034859892,
0.0328314304,
-0.0607936308,
0.0059974738,
0.0475280769,
-0.006793336,
0.0027759469,
-0.0297999457,
-0.0065994156,
0.0234958865,
-0.022415068,
0.0181082971,
-0.0329329669,
0.0251846854,
0.0191875752,
0.0098923473,
-0.0254940093,
0.0138589367,
0.0239994079,
-0.0604414418,
0.0410141163,
0.0565629415,
0.0275912434,
-0.0421529822,
-0.0437479503,
0.02684802,
0.0040115048,
-0.004100854,
-0.0212645102,
0.0137953693,
-0.0101052253,
-0.0243873559,
0.0194344092,
-0.0259846617,
0.015757259,
-0.0793199912,
0.008484168,
0.0347380713,
0.0385445096,
0.0622059256,
0.0562205203,
-0.0124581335,
-0.0228067394,
0.049671635,
0.0402955785,
0.0344337858,
0.0320769474,
0.0378382616,
-0.0177511368,
0.0127183208,
0.024312431,
-0.0420500152,
0.0079433909,
-0.00162414,
0.0197567325,
-0.0094649605,
0.0290206745,
-0.0409459285,
0.0276006367,
-0.0591518059,
-0.0010579311,
-0.0306615438,
-0.0308541451,
-0.0069991159,
0.0061086793,
-0.0026458066,
0.0563596487,
0.023991039,
-0.0057169963,
-0.0154073816,
-0.0233706646,
-0.0085601537,
0.0323811136,
0.0033532269,
0.0155959474,
0.0010374526,
0.0040418468,
-0.0188225564,
0.0360589288,
0.051227469,
0.000789354,
-0.0218826309,
-0.0356767848,
0.0151284831,
-0.0432203077,
0.0393728688,
-0.0022801813,
-0.0094624367,
-0.0124167884,
0.0094091101,
-0.0464138351,
-0.0135396728,
0.0488276072,
-0.0464247018,
-0.0421187915,
-0.0095675085,
-0.003655792,
0.0347686708,
0.0020317675,
-0.0059362724,
0.0482199937,
-0.014557763,
-0.0913000554,
-0.0195742603,
0.0459494181,
-0.0634694323,
-0.0490860604,
0.0195426121,
-0.0053608245,
0.0084078023,
0.0507521518,
-0.0097782109,
-0.0170712247,
0.003219513,
-0.0238068048,
0.1178694814,
-0.0064009074,
0.038758412,
-0.0209556781,
0.0225960873,
-0.0143751819,
0.0753232837,
-0.0010083037,
0.0350986235,
0.0131517416,
0.0143504348,
0.0148772905,
0.0116453236,
-0.0032813433,
-0.0393557847,
0.0008487274,
-0.0220825393,
0.0017931405,
-0.0316828713,
-0.0271071475,
-0.0199565031,
-0.0508411974,
0.0338429436,
0.0262164567,
0.032550741,
0.0711872727,
0.0035729953,
-0.0125150634,
0.0060936431,
-0.0174613781,
0.0074843932,
0.000942333,
0.03184155,
0.0324437097,
-0.0372235999,
-0.0487173386,
-0.0438240357,
-0.0122281117,
-0.0407832153,
0.0960943922,
-0.0040440839,
-0.005808135,
-0.0556020513,
0.0514871553,
-0.0159896165,
-0.0222207308,
0.017189512,
-0.0618385971,
-0.0331163406,
0.0049912189,
0.0390747301,
0.0604003109,
0.0026023502,
0.0175027102,
0.0770430937,
0.0356575362,
-0.0369900428,
-0.0468471572,
-0.0196704175,
0.0043873871,
-0.0403942131,
-0.0384783559,
0.0189518593,
0.0861627385,
0.0300635658,
0.0010117346,
0.0082924133,
0.0306128506,
0.0009480615,
0.0148024978,
-0.0135629727,
-0.030333491,
-0.0313695855,
-0.0002356527,
-0.0128885889,
0.0023720125,
0.0335522629,
-0.0115576545,
0.010414836,
-0.0257657878,
-0.0362018459,
-0.05077691,
0.0694988519,
0.0056735803,
0.023702804,
0.005926874,
-0.0146192508,
-0.0179377459,
-0.0202704109,
0.0075145224,
0.007462224,
0.0241838135,
0.0017571485,
0.0102513907,
-0.0042432798,
-0.0267883427,
-0.0404423214,
-0.0183071308,
-0.0738214403,
0.0218892172,
0.0003801881,
0.0358987115,
-0.0483367741,
0.0243368447,
-0.001432642,
-0.0131912343,
-0.0113460394,
-0.0002967806,
-0.041030772,
0.0850607231,
0.0613172799,
-0.0093249818,
0.0092812581,
-0.0236260295,
0.0579234809,
0.0053062593,
0.0220456272,
0.0562609881,
-0.0392442942,
-0.0113042099,
0.0146221118,
-0.0540135354,
-0.0201987177,
0.0033194206,
0.0106871678,
-0.0261296052,
-0.0062205163,
0.0960222334,
0.0346994698,
-0.0294392221,
0.0296325944,
-0.0203594882,
0.0274850018,
0.0320900716,
0.0126318801,
-0.0431687906,
-0.0397585295,
0.0293410476,
-0.0749956816,
-0.008827107,
-0.016799923,
0.0123556415,
-0.1026822105,
-0.0043054884,
0.0205173008,
-0.0563480519,
-0.0451223813,
0.0023674604,
0.0292644314,
0.0124169504,
-0.0085285436,
0.0130804162,
-0.0429281667,
-0.004612878,
0.0189938322,
0.0073852376,
-0.0258116573,
0.0069291652,
-0.0377643928,
0.0720046833,
0.0347683579,
0.0144024342,
-0.001777445,
0.0031750859,
0.0445956066,
-0.0319740772,
-0.0071814088,
0.0075952797,
0.0039658318,
0.0153868115,
0.0119855031,
-0.0350912996,
0.028540764,
-0.0347112902,
-0.0180699881,
0.0044360585,
0.0790327042,
-0.005529712,
-0.055309359,
-0.022626264,
0.007162075,
-0.0576539114,
0.08900024,
0.07212843,
-0.0150197716,
-0.0296968613,
0.0026767408,
-0.0202501994,
-0.0408458449,
-0.016906729,
0.0153270364,
-0.011694341,
0.039974831,
-0.0574612804,
-0.0160683282,
-0.0216793362,
-0.0302860271,
0.0190795027,
0.0155547466,
0.0136049818,
-0.0558196791,
-0.0097433897,
-0.0226723999,
-0.0666773021,
0.0183584634,
0.0117548956,
-0.0096483007,
0.0715773851,
-0.0136805521,
-0.0322802663,
-0.0509107411,
-0.0834473148,
-0.0136629185,
-0.0226800442,
0.0223607384,
0.0124441423,
0.007622343,
0.0307385772,
-0.0192372333,
0.0034381109,
0.0125813372,
-0.0280911531,
0.0362801366,
-0.0191213619,
0.0187720861,
0.0242811143,
0.0388201326,
-0.0241271704,
0.0323371589,
0.0580691881,
0.0637137219,
0.0297353938,
-0.0467946343,
0.0489887074,
0.0183300432,
-0.014383263,
0.0560504086,
-0.0194939412,
-0.0209032744,
-0.0062290286,
-0.018573869,
-0.0154499765,
-0.0211464502,
0.0020837795,
0.0352028087,
0.0558940694,
-0.026120875,
-0.0562339611,
0.0037754143,
0.0733733997,
0.0026394534,
0.0056594969,
-0.0134030124,
-0.0019496693,
-0.0104257213,
0.0053998893,
-0.0489023328,
0.0130617274,
-0.0051979017,
0.0224313196,
-0.0347405225,
0.0270244908,
0.0126133766,
-0.0126345512,
-0.0614351407,
0.015050387,
-0.0620230399,
-0.0245573297,
-0.0002770188,
0.0140649257,
0.0514578521,
-0.0581191741,
0.0458268896,
-0.0521463715,
0.0006038878,
-0.0073336884,
0.0185478367,
-0.0075114192,
-0.0152963866,
0.0480349474,
0.0012678271,
-0.0085355062,
-0.0227494109,
0.0523715131,
-0.0208947528,
0.0565555729,
0.0119404625,
-0.0504289344,
-0.0024989629,
-0.0281281658,
0.0061816559,
0.0135803688,
-0.0083855251,
0.0060496838,
-0.0190312602,
-0.0461654253,
-0.0029844826,
-0.0153281502,
0.0110775353,
-0.0387949459,
0.0074683758,
0.0174459107,
-0.0040133223,
-0.029890053,
-0.0279112067,
0.0113685932,
-0.0530001074,
-0.0203383267,
-0.0627556592,
-5.549681114e-33,
-0.0209671389,
0.0059289085,
-0.006973831,
-0.0235881768,
-0.0324317291,
-0.0233545993,
-0.0454534665,
-0.0318228453,
-0.0141105866,
0.0142512452,
-0.0001222072,
-0.0315011516,
-0.0001340863,
0.0161968824,
0.0339290984,
-0.027578868,
0.0348977745,
-0.0105940411,
0.0132468827,
0.0041417954,
0.013785813,
0.002270597,
0.0179407056,
-0.0323600881,
-0.0186740924,
-0.0171361063,
0.044653438,
0.0031147748,
0.024595581,
0.0939278677,
-0.0455729514,
0.0319240056,
0.0586047843,
-0.0033581404,
-0.0119455224,
0.0294243786,
-0.02074866,
-0.0263834745,
0.0683405772,
-0.0412857831,
0.0244317558,
-0.0661791861,
0.0356410109,
-0.0151479971,
-0.0238966849,
-0.0261853412,
0.0582220256,
-0.0495357551,
0.0074043516,
-0.0033710608,
-0.0902180895,
-0.0192129128,
0.0070011099,
-0.0005455387,
0.0029983267,
0.0389952287,
-0.0237887967,
0.0741104037,
0.0137776397,
0.0064156838,
-0.0018850233,
0.0303965732,
-0.0020290948,
0.0353554599,
0.0288642012,
0.0750895068,
-0.0010260127,
-0.0516741388,
-0.0254603978,
0.0140215028,
0.0100751063,
0.0195744019,
0.0230619274,
0.0338747017,
0.0410063826,
0.0061287922,
-0.035867516,
-0.0267711133,
0.0348190628,
0.0225729216,
0.0866520107,
0.0339659005,
0.0135438219,
-0.0028948323,
-0.0498822518,
-0.0125948889,
-0.0404436216,
-0.0232684258,
0.0570275486,
-0.0307588782,
0.0080381846,
-0.0022434941,
0.0451147519,
-0.0593655333,
-0.0283882897,
0.0030631984,
-0.0140870269,
0.0334512517,
-0.0342806093,
0.004437475,
-0.0585753433,
-0.0678771511,
-0.0313591287,
-0.035037972,
0.0255547334,
0.017313676,
0.0348960273,
-0.026884269,
-0.0566221401,
0.0060745315,
-0.0497535579,
-0.068307586,
-0.0340517014,
-0.0495894216,
0.0042832876,
0.0266449433,
0.0211640522,
0.0471336357,
0.0500252172,
-0.0410264879,
-0.0277269352,
-0.0246132668,
-0.0268054642,
0.0471798331,
-0.028277237,
0.0122675411,
-0.0604283698,
0.0137960864,
-0.0077844458,
-0.0433549173,
-0.0066705886,
0.0043355795,
2.218e-7,
0.0333820209,
0.036511451,
0.0112515874,
-0.0032930498,
0.0207604915,
0.0319614075,
0.0053376248,
0.0374140255,
0.030913664,
0.0287510622,
0.0065925312,
0.0186968911,
0.0460283272,
-0.0214814972,
-0.0870082453,
0.0633886009,
-0.1232290044,
-0.0243140608,
-0.0446423516,
-0.0071481462,
0.0649734214,
0.0765206292,
0.0295438543,
-0.0071549378,
-0.0089920331,
-0.0729642808,
0.0564463772,
-0.0811373964,
0.0041264524,
0.0232361108,
-0.0285624787,
-0.0095079634,
0.0091475695,
0.0211806558,
0.0422308259,
0.0471250266,
0.0103057632,
0.0445517674,
0.0265887193,
0.0149990674,
-0.0138667896,
-0.0252563637,
-0.0024162307,
-0.1095430329,
0.0613455288,
-0.0813858882,
-0.0246313009,
-0.0564741679,
-0.0002358836,
0.0075477227,
-0.0127880704,
0.0116650918,
-0.043947231,
0.0130089084,
0.0438534059,
-0.0026506977,
-0.0298313666,
-0.0689897984,
-0.0172921959,
0.0400972851,
-0.0418295376,
-0.0121440012,
-0.0273746159,
0.0140659977,
0.0591230951,
-0.0589011535,
-0.0170882419,
1.919221821e-34,
0.0157128274,
0.0101593863,
0.037509609,
0.0531312637,
0.0530186705,
0.0037442315,
-0.0005871081,
0.0504577979,
0.0179926809,
-0.117981717,
0.015851073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07815v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07815v3 | Language Models As Semantic Indexers | 2023-10-11T18:56:15 | 2024-06-12T20:36:22 | Bowen Jin, Hansi Zeng, Guoyin Wang, Xiusi Chen, Tianxin Wei, Ruirui Li, Zhengyang Wang, Zheng Li, Yang Li, Hanqing Lu, Suhang Wang, Jiawei Han, Xianfeng Tang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Semantic identifier (ID) is an important concept in information retrieval
that aims to preserve the semantics of objects such as documents and items
inside their IDs. Previous studies typically adopt a two-stage pipeline to
learn semantic IDs by first procuring embeddings using off-the-shelf text
encoders and then deriving IDs based on the embeddings. However, each step
introduces potential information loss, and there is usually an inherent
mismatch between the distribution of embeddings within the latent space
produced by text encoders and the anticipated distribution required for
semantic indexing. It is non-trivial to design a method that can learn the
document's semantic representations and its hierarchical structure
simultaneously, given that semantic IDs are discrete and sequentially
structured, and the semantic supervision is deficient. In this paper, we
introduce LMIndexer, a self-supervised framework to learn semantic IDs with a
generative language model. We tackle the challenge of sequential discrete ID by
introducing a semantic indexer capable of generating neural sequential discrete
representations with progressive training and contrastive learning. In response
to the semantic supervision deficiency, we propose to train the model with a
self-supervised document reconstruction objective. We show the high quality of
the learned IDs and demonstrate their effectiveness on three tasks including
recommendation, product search, and document retrieval on five datasets from
various domains. Code is available at
https://github.com/PeterGriffinJin/LMIndexer. | [
0.031239586,
0.0795580968,
0.005434609,
0.0357183591,
-0.0136328619,
0.0042453939,
0.0163978115,
0.0067867148,
0.0180838089,
-0.0670218542,
-0.0179176014,
-0.0245837495,
-0.0409541652,
0.0146562681,
0.0232025702,
-0.0213399101,
0.0435179733,
-0.0038299258,
0.0138671407,
0.0099306721,
-0.0116873644,
0.0189060234,
0.0309102759,
0.006286771,
-0.0199881978,
-0.0273385793,
0.0028989031,
0.0003724291,
-0.0153802875,
-0.0344502553,
0.0353367925,
0.0304371528,
0.0787051097,
0.0101142889,
0.0000019471,
-0.0044454262,
-0.0281682108,
-0.0129683632,
-0.0045785904,
-0.0161456298,
0.0679069832,
-0.0518590808,
0.0016676041,
-0.0122338086,
-0.0101437783,
-0.0678303912,
0.0189651661,
0.0693605319,
0.0315819159,
0.0596598275,
-0.0230489541,
-0.0559837893,
0.077677086,
-0.0450749733,
0.0292326156,
-0.0114512844,
0.0158395432,
-0.0064388239,
-0.0242991578,
0.0752962232,
-0.0184208434,
0.0442277007,
0.0208862163,
-0.0279107317,
0.054360576,
0.0375005193,
0.0423666239,
0.0044958834,
-0.0202938169,
0.0514427237,
-0.0458114259,
-0.0248458367,
-0.0042423997,
0.0071848333,
-0.0105383964,
-0.0368185714,
-0.0550937019,
0.032913506,
-0.0014642901,
0.0157379247,
0.0559638552,
0.0442205742,
0.0307324715,
-0.0029145041,
-0.0010226846,
0.0287500061,
0.0316512287,
-0.0265469812,
-0.0166154262,
-0.0278277751,
-0.0279833004,
0.001006657,
0.0232631247,
0.0233839154,
0.009267047,
0.0088272458,
-0.0168741997,
-0.0479609594,
0.0023035645,
-0.0451250449,
0.0053455951,
0.0364909917,
-0.0056333994,
0.0738496706,
-0.0566353984,
0.0702783391,
0.0130474586,
0.0366217829,
-0.0690621808,
-0.0213372502,
-0.0214851368,
-0.0298820566,
-0.0451649018,
0.0577258244,
-0.0122515857,
-0.040557567,
0.0270321462,
0.0586493164,
0.0172228571,
0.0071357968,
-0.013081233,
0.0108205536,
-0.0523012057,
-0.0136950873,
-0.0284415297,
0.0137014342,
-0.0043923743,
-0.0008978218,
0.0055866982,
-0.0070763007,
-0.0123904832,
0.0284041408,
0.0287885405,
-0.0286089256,
-0.0117638726,
0.0410509668,
-0.0194591172,
-0.0486562252,
-0.0647015795,
-0.0073576653,
0.0354710929,
-0.0176163483,
0.0019152981,
-0.0580067001,
0.0225701761,
0.0062074247,
-0.0254267696,
-0.0919460729,
0.0164380707,
0.027409032,
-0.0060319286,
0.0708719715,
-0.0185817592,
-0.0279020704,
0.0311453659,
0.0183761157,
0.0434625447,
0.0307145026,
0.012559589,
0.0398743078,
0.0437286794,
-0.0109205861,
-0.0131639428,
0.0096082957,
0.0096937837,
-0.0085122231,
-0.0589710474,
0.0020445553,
0.0216185339,
0.0321668498,
0.0581433848,
0.0616551042,
-0.0559284948,
-0.0299972333,
0.0396632887,
0.0636047646,
0.001788196,
0.0267084576,
0.04440872,
0.006361851,
-0.0412493274,
-0.008422141,
0.00600369,
0.0299982857,
0.0113496725,
-0.0144119319,
0.0190621633,
-0.015747074,
-0.050526496,
-0.033160042,
0.0184405614,
-0.0194131192,
0.019563457,
-0.0242658369,
0.0467168204,
0.0084209777,
-0.0255403798,
0.0189981163,
0.0197891686,
-0.027674146,
0.0217653755,
-0.0066041406,
0.0522253774,
0.0854585767,
0.0626950562,
-0.0281999856,
0.0135504445,
-0.0352765135,
0.0067384471,
-0.0020634499,
0.0394615121,
-0.0573779717,
0.0163668673,
-0.0419668704,
-0.0520047285,
-0.0348912291,
0.0052121286,
0.0233421065,
-0.0141329998,
-0.0051371767,
0.0432434566,
-0.0413471833,
0.0019765056,
0.0434389524,
-0.0642462969,
-0.0785632953,
0.0314653553,
-0.0090364683,
-0.0094698993,
-0.0103906579,
0.0085618198,
-0.0029955895,
0.0606248528,
-0.0422536358,
-0.0262804069,
-0.0404306874,
-0.0217145737,
-0.0461781435,
0.0350044854,
-0.0092271026,
0.0106282048,
0.034962222,
-0.046939671,
-0.0442235805,
0.0215868987,
-0.0205831639,
0.0285294019,
-0.0656684116,
-0.0162437912,
-0.0041072522,
-0.0080283117,
-0.0453886874,
0.0754269138,
-0.0239527859,
0.0389068872,
-0.0189688485,
0.0157774724,
0.0018523539,
-0.051208932,
-0.0031403122,
0.015415729,
0.01295669,
0.0402530506,
0.0435397588,
-0.001645138,
-0.0136192217,
-0.0051200013,
-0.0908465013,
0.0183922406,
-0.0343690664,
-0.0120313819,
0.0099878525,
0.0186965596,
0.0243174583,
-0.0423349738,
-0.0540703684,
-0.0315448754,
-0.0018963417,
0.0213685222,
0.0313889757,
0.005206591,
0.0004427736,
-0.0409067571,
-0.0410781987,
-0.0061227614,
0.0444836207,
-0.0240526386,
-0.0152087146,
-0.0450071059,
-0.0046680076,
-0.0052666874,
0.004177988,
-0.0416667946,
0.0164232757,
-0.0139493914,
-0.0519365147,
0.030308675,
0.0455243476,
0.0333586708,
0.0639073923,
0.0247369483,
0.0068796519,
-0.0816487446,
0.0050227256,
-0.0530122891,
0.043176692,
0.0009501339,
-0.005841698,
0.0162441991,
0.0684213787,
-0.0015896212,
0.0116756242,
-0.0145032257,
-0.0024148012,
0.0051229415,
0.0046565775,
-0.0578678325,
-0.0124439904,
0.0327595845,
0.0138045596,
-0.0194098037,
-0.0274241827,
0.0321577974,
-0.0181449428,
0.0029341523,
-0.0379342511,
-0.0279877838,
-0.0570643842,
0.0460217036,
0.0131736891,
0.0330068357,
-0.0000878374,
-0.0205111429,
-0.0296472479,
0.0475454368,
-0.0028623622,
-0.0256710798,
-0.0023503886,
-0.0125153568,
0.0305728503,
-0.0004089164,
-0.0549436323,
-0.0503431372,
-0.0908993185,
0.0222329702,
0.0249860659,
0.0167441647,
0.026093781,
-0.0455655679,
0.0320631638,
0.0179717652,
0.075857684,
-0.0173249394,
-0.0206927098,
-0.0217095967,
0.0429041982,
0.0505054779,
-0.0413012728,
-0.0015565584,
-0.0059246751,
0.01599597,
0.0366184972,
0.0099873375,
-0.0072333161,
-0.0410631038,
0.0203871094,
0.0273005459,
-0.0444901027,
-0.0116197756,
-0.0158337206,
-0.0410349555,
-0.0180618968,
-0.0408311859,
0.1154608727,
0.0332861207,
-0.0908534452,
-0.0142158251,
-0.0206933878,
0.0003691183,
0.0270963144,
0.0100121526,
-0.0356450677,
-0.019887384,
-0.0004853608,
0.0141949346,
0.0347354449,
0.0174716283,
0.0091881258,
-0.0740312487,
0.0312805921,
0.0211476479,
-0.0073003392,
-0.0455033816,
-0.04536644,
-0.0128674023,
0.0037736979,
0.0181044303,
0.0413703471,
-0.0211761724,
0.0092353607,
-0.0009924393,
0.0250631925,
-0.0479714721,
-0.0199146923,
-0.0156703889,
0.0066893157,
0.0756112039,
0.0119446553,
0.0213260427,
-0.0262759626,
0.0448574275,
-0.0380532295,
-0.0456939228,
-0.0141175939,
0.0739135668,
-0.0556028746,
0.0422434323,
0.0024056614,
0.0249524061,
-0.0512502082,
0.0072323685,
-0.0367471427,
0.021713635,
-0.0294215102,
-0.0088068843,
-0.0351619683,
-0.0572094172,
-0.0039424738,
0.0602197796,
0.0031130402,
-0.0149137797,
-0.0195033364,
-0.0624338128,
0.0689470544,
0.0045051272,
-0.0069831139,
-0.0114002163,
0.01521926,
0.0083076125,
-0.0838190541,
-0.0664743111,
-0.0100043612,
0.0027380923,
-0.0065021566,
-0.0021067685,
-0.0339647159,
-0.0807112977,
-0.0626941025,
0.010727752,
-0.0231076069,
-0.0057047131,
-0.0562758185,
0.0082711698,
0.0772452056,
-0.0348338373,
-0.0248793941,
-0.0285664015,
-0.023653863,
-0.0113940351,
-0.0455668308,
0.0458409078,
0.0056559001,
0.0650414228,
-0.0469079129,
-0.0606402867,
0.0570881516,
0.0199617334,
-0.0538939796,
-0.0398524441,
-0.014050778,
0.0072753672,
-0.0047638952,
0.0357693098,
-0.0750289857,
0.0390028469,
-0.0098126428,
0.0559275076,
-0.0133317607,
-0.0440305583,
0.0454726182,
-0.0377810746,
0.0626709461,
0.0034284766,
0.0626991019,
-0.0534364544,
0.0294602104,
-0.033320725,
-0.0434844941,
-0.0309746396,
0.0166643485,
0.0597766116,
0.0252293069,
-0.0292641539,
0.022274429,
0.0094924588,
0.0556507111,
-0.021972198,
-0.0161165483,
0.0038270988,
0.0149192428,
-0.0209887829,
0.0376828983,
-0.035231825,
0.0131990146,
-0.0245169196,
0.0491498634,
-0.0479041114,
0.0204761345,
0.0349501148,
0.0008548654,
-0.0650741607,
0.0192859881,
-0.0396781042,
-0.0077846344,
-0.0547252484,
-0.0160909314,
0.0556866527,
-0.016779555,
-0.0149913868,
-0.0150864776,
-0.0170593057,
-0.0386771597,
0.000964664,
0.0156299584,
-0.0501069762,
0.011231821,
0.046042569,
-0.0096692368,
0.0093928361,
0.0910146013,
0.0325224921,
0.009345118,
-0.0182059836,
-0.0100139892,
-0.0363215394,
0.0299099684,
0.0318809785,
0.0574849285,
-0.0231621135,
0.0058714752,
0.0030445508,
-0.0301573817,
0.048016157,
-0.004078798,
-0.0063528679,
-0.0109080607,
0.0556198396,
0.0602311902,
-0.010980756,
-0.0063488628,
-0.0676914379,
0.0157939531,
-0.0372955352,
-0.061578434,
-0.0756518319,
-5.94943662e-33,
-0.0265810918,
-0.0067116385,
0.0091210706,
0.0124806575,
-0.000655499,
-0.0173183773,
-0.0620521307,
-0.0334635638,
0.0333192647,
0.0205769055,
-0.0074862791,
-0.0012266499,
-0.007401464,
0.0425842255,
0.0201194081,
-0.0032066996,
0.0575476177,
-0.0017653069,
-0.0108505664,
0.0301653817,
0.0417476147,
0.057043869,
0.0230903551,
-0.0620973893,
-0.0171587486,
-0.0110260881,
0.0378331244,
0.0138550522,
0.0587980896,
0.0732654482,
-0.0231164563,
0.0440053158,
0.0223527495,
-0.0257506389,
0.0059789638,
0.0405549146,
-0.1259687394,
-0.0198371094,
-0.0578881092,
0.0079761446,
-0.0196998511,
-0.0729396343,
0.0198160447,
-0.0572429523,
0.0100934422,
0.0235562064,
0.0475666821,
0.0014615982,
-0.0667957217,
-0.0527660623,
-0.055346597,
0.0237895958,
0.0115359686,
0.0149308452,
0.0512864701,
-0.0010567273,
0.0234514493,
0.0501601957,
-0.0608212203,
-0.0127917267,
-0.0740083978,
0.0540829524,
0.0015331053,
0.0051505635,
-0.0057399413,
0.0496589765,
0.0162549689,
-0.0295262896,
0.0077531813,
0.0495395921,
0.0328329876,
0.0073347259,
0.030816678,
0.0066917823,
0.0437129214,
-0.0151249152,
-0.0426291227,
0.0653120056,
0.0134547343,
0.0347764008,
0.0227801912,
0.0796735361,
-0.0344562642,
-0.022816848,
-0.0395632982,
-0.0528426729,
-0.0317675583,
-0.0288246572,
0.0330247842,
0.0323185585,
-0.0040031592,
-0.0404561646,
0.0643440783,
-0.0342425667,
-0.042259004,
0.0376207232,
-0.0185046606,
0.037254788,
0.0084761539,
0.0371900462,
-0.0571712069,
-0.0277994666,
0.0478427447,
-0.0266328063,
-0.0293999761,
0.0141382515,
0.0406757332,
0.0190942939,
-0.0322485343,
-0.0060117217,
-0.0010526843,
-0.0420174338,
-0.0102535095,
0.0177791249,
-0.0000864596,
0.0284516308,
-0.0023476521,
0.043179296,
0.0407111719,
0.0106017487,
-0.0257194266,
-0.0413915589,
-0.0191965699,
-0.0020090484,
-0.007220984,
0.0011918889,
-0.0436663739,
0.044383686,
0.0265735649,
-0.057317771,
0.0316954851,
0.0502845235,
2.601e-7,
0.01767046,
0.0270593576,
0.0336308219,
-0.0087694302,
0.0308057498,
0.025271276,
0.0163184982,
0.0435070433,
0.0211099405,
-0.0007582334,
0.0174026266,
0.0039366195,
0.0205880292,
-0.0136962719,
-0.0765018538,
0.0467962883,
-0.0241258517,
0.0124384155,
-0.0356057398,
-0.0162316728,
0.0300933793,
0.1185319722,
0.0105596511,
0.0042491276,
-0.0071800728,
-0.0588120855,
0.0988375321,
0.0018722112,
0.0143896407,
0.0134581542,
0.0405816212,
0.0417231657,
-0.0065100049,
-0.0187865645,
-0.0103871711,
0.0611071102,
0.0337707661,
0.0636623576,
-0.0232239682,
-0.028552549,
0.0040829973,
-0.025053516,
0.0103094317,
-0.012250605,
0.0836299658,
-0.0492224209,
0.0144893518,
0.0252483506,
-0.0606629513,
0.0264803823,
0.0035004127,
-0.0070309872,
-0.0652876422,
0.0178140718,
0.0370360836,
0.0035386628,
-0.0024221325,
-0.0836435854,
0.025589278,
-0.0034048927,
-0.042841021,
0.0185982455,
-0.0266134199,
0.0543142781,
0.0098435767,
-0.0284350179,
0.0119208517,
2.44601617e-34,
0.0272898711,
-0.0019428325,
-0.0453116335,
0.0316554569,
0.0307852868,
-0.014876442,
-0.0315682516,
0.0461592078,
0.0176273081,
-0.080740571,
-0.0201624446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07803v1 | A general mechanism of humor: reformulating the semantic overlap | 2023-10-11T18:36:13 | 2023-10-11T18:36:13 | Javier Martínez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.m; J.5 | This article proposes a cognitive mechanism of humour of general
applicability, not restricted to verbal communication. It is indebted to
Raskin's concept of script overlap, and conforms to the incongruity-resolution
theoretical framework, but it is built on the notion of constraint, an abstract
correspondence between sets of data. Under this view, script overlap is an
outcome of a more abstractly described phenomenon, constraint overlap. The
important concept of the overlooked argument is introduced to characterise the
two overlapping constraints -- overt and covert. Their inputs and outputs are
not directly encoded in utterances, but implicated by them, and their overlap
results in another overlap at the level of the communicated utterances, that
the incongruity reveals. Our hypothesis assumes as a given that the evocation
of such constraints is a cognitive effect of the inferential process by which a
hearer interprets utterances. We base this assumption on Hofstadter's theory of
analogy-making as the essence of human thought. By substituting "stimuli" of
any kind for "utterances" in this model, we obtain a mechanism as easily
applicable to non-verbal communication -- slapstick, cartoons -- and we propose
it describes the necessary and sufficient conditions for a communicative act in
any modality to carry humour. | [
0.0531380251,
0.0159457922,
-0.0488065556,
0.0026209035,
-0.0138164684,
0.0287007205,
-0.0220289677,
0.0616139248,
0.0464465469,
-0.0447355919,
-0.0188090913,
0.0252532158,
0.0360805467,
-0.0318459645,
0.0487881824,
-0.0674947202,
-0.0338819325,
0.0112107564,
-0.0059587476,
-0.0292570945,
0.0006138509,
0.0150203211,
-0.0220680367,
0.0057239057,
0.0395371392,
0.026775483,
0.0034685337,
0.0367869884,
0.0249815453,
0.0295847934,
-0.0228271242,
-0.0157470256,
0.0041145068,
-0.0119477976,
0.0000017617,
-0.0594237819,
0.0619026013,
-0.0246644877,
0.0062659383,
0.038834475,
0.0390356965,
0.0004113143,
-0.017192021,
-0.0334869958,
0.0037881276,
0.0378994867,
0.0536448732,
0.0168527048,
-0.0030205538,
0.011775339,
0.002040619,
0.0143831139,
-0.0024975766,
-0.0122816041,
0.0472995974,
-0.038173046,
0.0434662737,
0.0437270515,
0.0333834887,
-0.0515036993,
-0.0700168759,
-0.0163807031,
-0.0119591244,
0.0346873552,
-0.0725222751,
0.0130989058,
-0.0150580034,
0.0063835685,
-0.0064041144,
0.0137637202,
0.0361576937,
-0.0078059682,
0.0116034243,
0.0264840573,
0.0093749911,
0.0361166298,
-0.0351857841,
0.0209102798,
0.0028557519,
-0.0039049613,
0.0165246129,
0.0459281504,
-0.0303068757,
0.0442880057,
0.0596189015,
0.0087271193,
0.0039278446,
0.0069377902,
-0.048860956,
-0.0432689413,
-0.0397524089,
-0.0427792743,
0.0335146673,
0.0421765447,
0.0324455611,
0.004466916,
-0.0087348148,
-0.0193732101,
0.0332937054,
-0.0851715505,
0.015328479,
0.0468734615,
-0.0351314135,
0.0687916577,
0.0201269742,
0.0407956727,
-0.0737124458,
0.0056963377,
-0.0301686674,
0.0417946503,
-0.010022725,
-0.0084364209,
-0.0287005622,
0.031495586,
0.0074061686,
-0.0122832349,
-0.0129792988,
0.0143121686,
-0.0319588557,
-0.0298124813,
-0.0565469265,
0.0112656243,
-0.0436342061,
-0.0345025547,
-0.0214406792,
0.0423771031,
-0.0451228097,
0.0310152788,
-0.0799868032,
-0.0305676199,
-0.0007809798,
0.0366514251,
0.0100100823,
-0.0170584749,
-0.0085535934,
0.1027724072,
0.0166056138,
-0.0080327168,
0.0087296637,
-0.0061253682,
-0.037715748,
-0.0039678877,
0.0076363944,
-0.0106893312,
-0.0049162186,
0.0047524003,
-0.0126527725,
0.0020971855,
0.0026458714,
0.000794186,
-0.0368225873,
0.0368144698,
0.0145421308,
0.0269667227,
0.0328218006,
0.0404944457,
-0.0416999757,
-0.0072736372,
-0.0144126387,
-0.0486098938,
-0.0100912116,
-0.0074128783,
-0.0194766894,
-0.0024815346,
-0.0019318128,
-0.0235072915,
-0.0198881906,
-0.0067099389,
0.0022233962,
0.0152480835,
0.0533097275,
0.0021157912,
-0.0500449613,
-0.0284758396,
-0.0069399518,
0.0165420435,
0.0161809586,
0.0447611287,
0.0052471319,
0.0170366298,
-0.0007481591,
0.1080345437,
0.029998729,
-0.0188635457,
-0.0241776109,
-0.0053195343,
-0.0108949272,
0.0342512988,
-0.0173687302,
0.0153771164,
-0.0125466119,
-0.0017205265,
0.0318140462,
-0.0400645025,
0.0142391277,
0.0547720827,
-0.009650453,
-0.0053610513,
0.0202137418,
-0.0140698822,
-0.0004357084,
0.0078176558,
-0.0389792249,
0.0391903631,
0.0217513461,
0.0072619547,
0.0474551953,
-0.0067126704,
-0.00049048,
0.0303382594,
-0.035051845,
0.0009838335,
0.000958771,
-0.0016379321,
0.0581468754,
-0.053581547,
0.0121363737,
0.0311845783,
-0.0644197315,
0.0320272185,
-0.029073773,
0.0500570536,
0.0892203897,
-0.013458197,
-0.0615082979,
-0.0284254998,
-0.0852388069,
0.0068111382,
0.0348221622,
-0.0181941334,
-0.0373247601,
-0.0032831912,
-0.0163338427,
-0.0245346166,
0.0024832401,
0.0834186748,
-0.0465269387,
0.0048229969,
-0.0070814369,
-0.1474082917,
0.0019765496,
-0.0142555321,
0.0439532474,
-0.0116181169,
0.0783425868,
-0.0694771186,
0.0464414321,
-0.0590359494,
-0.0047753803,
-0.0354893543,
-0.0051363963,
0.0138346488,
0.0396162271,
0.011801051,
0.0156203341,
0.025131762,
0.0043913089,
0.0397329517,
0.0276015103,
-0.0039710938,
0.0341049433,
-0.0266292561,
0.0062934337,
-0.0205531251,
-0.039411854,
-0.0408116169,
-0.0332602337,
-0.0736594275,
-0.0350944437,
0.0400115885,
-0.0254679639,
0.036815986,
0.008344396,
-0.011094098,
-0.0172984172,
0.0637054443,
-0.0023795702,
-0.0180643164,
0.0130383857,
-0.0011609008,
0.025067769,
-0.0457888879,
0.0166203268,
-0.0009477365,
-0.031193316,
0.0132465214,
0.0078298086,
0.0046967608,
-0.028203804,
0.0072494508,
-0.0630021989,
-0.0051824711,
-0.0270512439,
-0.0279142912,
0.0205598976,
0.0477306247,
-0.0130838295,
0.0352211371,
0.0413809121,
0.020197887,
0.0331221223,
-0.0393879488,
0.0054425313,
-0.02249166,
-0.0080425274,
0.0688251257,
-0.0012170227,
-0.0280365124,
-0.0632255524,
0.0419578627,
0.04034172,
0.0358134881,
-0.0488324389,
0.0705733746,
-0.0099064168,
-0.0079881726,
-0.0037635469,
-0.1281679422,
-0.0596747026,
0.0167772844,
-0.0090806037,
-0.0100989034,
0.0493856445,
-0.0117894271,
-0.0412893891,
0.0171823334,
0.0221994128,
-0.0117983101,
0.0980541855,
-0.0204326455,
0.0495320447,
0.0388757959,
-0.0420800559,
-0.0695026964,
-0.0263670105,
0.0372962728,
-0.0233534537,
0.0485095978,
0.033652354,
-0.0164700616,
-0.0097293146,
-0.0193762686,
-0.0326729789,
-0.0154340565,
-0.0346839018,
-0.0053060493,
-0.037024796,
0.0041354797,
0.0020250133,
-0.003010703,
-0.0105164889,
-0.0346259065,
0.0320704579,
-0.0033496653,
-0.0149226319,
-0.0276101585,
-0.0120645808,
0.014344722,
-0.0324832276,
0.0610726811,
-0.052069582,
-0.0108637372,
-0.0986660272,
0.036258202,
0.0161946937,
0.0386460163,
0.0123601304,
-0.0064106928,
-0.012838549,
-0.0233541429,
0.033159107,
0.0010518709,
-0.0065139309,
0.0058119358,
-0.0212926343,
0.0500159264,
0.0435485616,
-0.0378186554,
-0.0521879867,
0.0299417246,
0.0096956296,
-0.0364655256,
0.026703734,
0.0057272622,
-0.0641741604,
-0.0291337408,
0.0017392338,
-0.0252883993,
-0.0869122073,
0.0118400268,
0.0490997024,
-0.0293161739,
-0.0086524598,
0.0589098558,
0.0125042377,
0.0781675577,
-0.0225947201,
0.011261845,
-0.0166429169,
0.001054647,
0.0126860281,
0.0564945042,
-0.0076524718,
-0.0347457789,
0.0263801236,
0.0696106926,
-0.0398087576,
0.0450182743,
0.0062339418,
-0.0740210414,
-0.0056835669,
-0.0791000724,
0.0167099275,
-0.0042596743,
0.0136526376,
0.0124349566,
0.0221896973,
-0.0769345239,
-0.0100286156,
0.045173835,
-0.0327181108,
-0.0294055175,
0.0396114327,
-0.0323248394,
-0.0556170307,
-0.0296090469,
0.039621003,
-0.0274086203,
0.0413815528,
0.0520795323,
-0.0044357525,
0.0472458042,
-0.0165199153,
0.0088863662,
-0.0058153416,
-0.023597816,
0.0063726883,
0.0436566956,
-0.049762316,
-0.0517281517,
0.0162374321,
-0.0758645907,
0.0378717445,
0.0225986224,
-0.0077217924,
-0.0993570015,
-0.0099824425,
0.0145534668,
-0.0441565514,
0.0269384962,
-0.0396180712,
0.0344839245,
0.0186759699,
-0.0236239545,
-0.0989456251,
-0.0525716655,
-0.0019777829,
-0.0124043794,
-0.071110718,
0.045629818,
-0.0052332403,
0.0381219871,
-0.004983745,
0.0190710891,
-0.0226874389,
0.0031378248,
0.0548246168,
0.0056456155,
0.0830280632,
-0.0048878528,
0.0057144989,
0.0109583344,
0.0373526849,
-0.005319518,
0.0180380084,
0.0198039506,
0.0016727111,
-0.0518470779,
-0.0483377799,
0.0168425199,
-0.0134353433,
-0.0238919687,
-0.0042157634,
-0.0519762412,
0.0165071748,
-0.0221244935,
0.0328509323,
0.0167311449,
-0.001745904,
-0.0395860635,
0.0125972852,
0.0280083939,
0.0016088879,
-0.0460867137,
-0.0422856808,
0.0386126898,
0.0607105866,
-0.0138303516,
0.0687537491,
0.0125143602,
-0.0198962651,
0.0505458713,
-0.0138123706,
0.0417063273,
-0.0182239339,
0.0172830969,
0.006266118,
0.0184494015,
0.0609421842,
-0.0100675253,
-0.0172499437,
-0.0141287697,
-0.0015965906,
-0.0092464164,
0.0432345383,
-0.0149650499,
0.0277606882,
-0.0565063916,
0.0313283317,
-0.0199268498,
0.035972029,
0.039580632,
0.0114995996,
-0.0157982484,
-0.069446519,
0.0468762815,
0.0294116642,
0.0181422979,
-0.0110699804,
0.0016987474,
-0.1185888499,
0.030809395,
0.0043560499,
0.0012508773,
-0.0040712268,
-0.0695935339,
0.039112594,
0.0324436612,
0.0086124763,
0.0257562716,
-0.0286970008,
-0.0271308199,
-0.0004773478,
-0.0315442309,
0.0445046201,
-0.0345017835,
0.0329612084,
0.0183395818,
0.0273163971,
0.0024680006,
0.0222542286,
0.0802832618,
-0.044898361,
0.0323902108,
-0.0054721395,
-6.111604882e-33,
-0.0282112584,
-0.0245614536,
-0.0381434672,
0.0516000763,
-0.0432424285,
0.0169136319,
-0.0529333539,
0.0239177756,
-0.0171039402,
0.0135454694,
0.0245754402,
-0.0045822714,
-0.0023069861,
-0.0441814139,
0.0102128042,
-0.0422213748,
0.0208652373,
0.0412113629,
-0.0353536569,
-0.0322418399,
0.0465416685,
-0.014419144,
0.0386579521,
-0.0701242015,
0.0019031833,
-0.0233090501,
-0.0341524743,
-0.0462966636,
0.0703404993,
0.0307604205,
0.0129741626,
0.0571639426,
0.0311021395,
0.0505158789,
0.0097939586,
0.0786247924,
0.0178826377,
-0.0688842237,
0.087419048,
-0.0059017916,
-0.0085089998,
-0.0150868725,
0.0395314805,
-0.0285650305,
-0.0676106289,
-0.0179514531,
0.0354240201,
-0.0169463195,
0.031808462,
0.022511024,
-0.0866669863,
-0.0276057553,
0.0031779476,
-0.0282364022,
0.0182982907,
0.0483719558,
0.0226834491,
-0.0182052944,
-0.031464655,
0.0544499829,
-0.0991551951,
0.0002328327,
-0.034478683,
-0.0314124413,
0.0281548817,
0.0584043115,
-0.0216644704,
0.0271080676,
-0.0000436127,
-0.0241666492,
-0.002074976,
0.0240062084,
0.0092766993,
0.0390768722,
0.0667418838,
-0.0430083349,
0.0302297566,
-0.0280573424,
0.0354118086,
0.0082183378,
0.0260963477,
0.0297671221,
-0.0456754975,
-0.0013424237,
0.0181019288,
0.0185377933,
0.0085981088,
-0.0620858967,
-0.0222103186,
0.0126498332,
0.0204574745,
0.0386322923,
0.0294258259,
-0.0407607816,
-0.0116576785,
-0.0540701561,
0.0173425861,
0.0336787887,
0.0129676498,
-0.0242888518,
-0.0003271771,
-0.0297440793,
0.0019754265,
0.0552877299,
0.0514313206,
0.0170776974,
0.0293444134,
-0.0209639296,
-0.0002451844,
-0.0025916183,
0.0075196587,
-0.0242047142,
-0.0065904702,
-0.0821540803,
0.0215378702,
0.0696151406,
-0.0130620291,
-0.0718197227,
0.0332765095,
-0.0169801898,
-0.0369759798,
0.0171711594,
-0.0568577386,
0.0326998606,
-0.0921698213,
-0.0239911843,
-0.0083787162,
-0.0618425533,
0.0214834753,
-0.0300116949,
-0.0237663258,
-0.0432786904,
2.859e-7,
0.0074514383,
0.0164925177,
0.0455318764,
0.0268355366,
0.0645614564,
0.0044988343,
-0.0129223177,
0.0308780465,
0.0363292806,
-0.0096801203,
0.0137998136,
-0.0328452922,
-0.0159394145,
0.0041743061,
-0.044375591,
0.0213590674,
-0.0624172091,
0.0066475947,
0.0014141125,
0.0299128238,
0.0276670959,
-0.0394380242,
0.0113421101,
-0.0209462047,
-0.0031613531,
-0.0539236069,
0.0029827743,
-0.0173758287,
0.0778878257,
-0.0170004312,
-0.0425531045,
0.016345948,
0.0003339126,
0.0671656951,
0.0422170274,
-0.0280679669,
0.0383416712,
-0.0087257223,
-0.0202903356,
0.0401063003,
-0.01321238,
-0.0276772436,
-0.0412767641,
-0.0595309101,
0.0135751078,
-0.0049324934,
-0.0324348211,
0.0076832818,
-0.0147757744,
-0.0218954235,
0.0522640012,
0.0433207229,
-0.0150060868,
0.0000236519,
0.0307199452,
0.0221367087,
-0.0035919668,
-0.017455088,
-0.021517653,
0.0358143076,
-0.042212788,
-0.0121509489,
0.0077188099,
-0.0288931783,
0.0201556794,
-0.1084089577,
-0.0140063707,
1.990429916e-34,
0.0082277851,
0.0039158482,
0.0591597781,
-0.0433081463,
-0.0206485875,
0.0139725143,
0.0082374495,
0.0313417725,
0.0799367875,
0.02643588,
-0.0336125195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07795v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07795v1 | Ontology Enrichment for Effective Fine-grained Entity Typing | 2023-10-11T18:30:37 | 2023-10-11T18:30:37 | Siru Ouyang, Jiaxin Huang, Pranav Pillai, Yunyi Zhang, Yu Zhang, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-grained entity typing (FET) is the task of identifying specific entity
types at a fine-grained level for entity mentions based on their contextual
information. Conventional methods for FET require extensive human annotation,
which is time-consuming and costly. Recent studies have been developing weakly
supervised or zero-shot approaches. We study the setting of zero-shot FET where
only an ontology is provided. However, most existing ontology structures lack
rich supporting information and even contain ambiguous relations, making them
ineffective in guiding FET. Recently developed language models, though
promising in various few-shot and zero-shot NLP tasks, may face challenges in
zero-shot FET due to their lack of interaction with task-specific ontology. In
this study, we propose OnEFET, where we (1) enrich each node in the ontology
structure with two types of extra information: instance information for
training sample augmentation and topic information to relate types to contexts,
and (2) develop a coarse-to-fine typing algorithm that exploits the enriched
information by training an entailment model with contrasting topics and
instance-based augmented training samples. Our experiments show that OnEFET
achieves high-quality fine-grained entity typing without human annotation,
outperforming existing zero-shot methods by a large margin and rivaling
supervised methods. | [
0.0334855765,
0.0189110711,
0.0136471475,
0.0547243692,
0.0274701416,
0.0370221958,
-0.0238638986,
0.0105196498,
-0.0030413638,
-0.1071306318,
-0.0144544085,
0.0340240933,
-0.0201411899,
-0.0103736613,
0.0603482723,
-0.02247102,
0.0406795442,
0.0161662269,
-0.0164293554,
0.011425945,
0.0213168878,
0.0197568368,
0.0057068146,
0.0298371576,
0.0041215504,
0.0181255881,
0.0013649225,
0.0046230969,
0.0288848262,
-0.0296319649,
0.0307398681,
0.0770935491,
0.0175255332,
0.0442484133,
0.0000018632,
-0.0409550369,
0.0054549859,
0.0318292901,
-0.0267890245,
-0.0034112367,
-0.0165886525,
-0.0327129588,
0.018570479,
-0.0112655191,
0.0068019046,
-0.0678830296,
0.0366239175,
0.0890897959,
0.0183090996,
0.0529849939,
-0.0128466468,
-0.0113558127,
0.0337420106,
-0.0221304949,
0.0251652263,
-0.0218582638,
0.0235287789,
-0.0449905694,
0.0130570782,
0.0917429402,
0.0299261529,
0.0138325319,
-0.0314229876,
0.0301697776,
0.0458587036,
0.0126298377,
-0.0623950176,
0.0190382376,
0.0317258313,
0.0687309131,
0.0326918177,
-0.0152546875,
0.014963707,
-0.0025082908,
-0.0132837677,
-0.0178858861,
0.0136512509,
-0.0259051081,
-0.0474582873,
0.0002029688,
0.0176931303,
-0.0021950221,
0.0238574632,
0.0325700603,
0.0147979632,
0.01344964,
0.0026061474,
-0.0370120034,
-0.0111828381,
0.0346982852,
-0.0215983633,
-0.0680219084,
-0.0072175823,
0.0198121145,
-0.0225631092,
0.0013096762,
-0.0224187896,
-0.0186173022,
0.0300482679,
-0.021215057,
-0.0099473586,
0.0328862704,
-0.0298028775,
0.0511080027,
-0.0232602078,
-0.0352181122,
-0.0047315359,
-0.0206119958,
0.010847304,
-0.0221781582,
-0.0579213314,
0.0203328412,
-0.0634412169,
0.0727881566,
0.0001410388,
0.0004220312,
-0.0371710323,
-0.0110124098,
-0.0143115986,
0.0438348278,
-0.0187169816,
-0.0071117431,
-0.012641537,
-0.0038643167,
-0.0197718386,
0.0102608707,
-0.062537916,
0.0204873215,
-0.014439025,
-0.0210629925,
0.0071458593,
-0.0259869229,
0.0171706043,
-0.0478947647,
0.0420086719,
0.0549363717,
0.0491505265,
-0.0740689635,
-0.0904952884,
-0.0153312124,
-0.0162674636,
-0.0415648594,
-0.0198599529,
-0.0588745363,
0.0082223788,
0.0110908682,
-0.0052782265,
-0.0146807693,
0.0280695334,
-0.001590705,
-0.0751623735,
0.1252835244,
-0.0787196159,
-0.0250164513,
0.0144808488,
-0.0025015813,
-0.0064910278,
0.0687393248,
0.0294410251,
-0.0124796582,
0.0350656398,
-0.008688814,
-0.0169171225,
0.0344768241,
-0.0099722054,
0.0176663548,
0.0183481835,
0.0230756178,
-0.0549972579,
0.0416712351,
0.0296384227,
0.0286258738,
-0.0229263976,
-0.010192208,
0.0480372421,
0.0162634291,
0.0168248918,
0.0098363301,
0.0680421069,
0.0190616995,
0.0145398052,
0.0144472271,
-0.0709063411,
0.0236022212,
-0.0502743348,
0.0157420803,
0.0569767207,
0.0212256592,
-0.0450902209,
-0.0021510278,
-0.0254926737,
-0.0112102944,
-0.0051785614,
0.0095760711,
0.0446304977,
0.0385918543,
-0.021672599,
0.0402957089,
0.0683293492,
0.0054003242,
-0.0122315828,
-0.0056728981,
0.0255960785,
0.0623852797,
0.0400752947,
-0.0433315895,
-0.0558364913,
-0.0603088513,
-0.0084772734,
0.0697908178,
0.0377657637,
-0.0255869012,
0.0158905536,
-0.0134934057,
0.0010233418,
-0.0101920599,
0.045621004,
0.0034501618,
0.0425019898,
0.0155211939,
0.0263429023,
-0.0722362399,
0.0145098576,
0.021460792,
-0.0047631231,
-0.0482678115,
0.0078305919,
0.0314952694,
-0.0286851469,
0.0432552248,
0.0099775521,
-0.0050791209,
-0.0130098453,
-0.0244515985,
-0.0098114945,
-0.0470454767,
0.0432681628,
-0.0181093607,
-0.0005761718,
0.0088093467,
-0.0398279876,
-0.0285673719,
-0.0151020205,
-0.0382604823,
-0.0368567705,
0.0313223265,
0.0369769856,
-0.0390304103,
-0.0204687864,
0.0160485879,
0.0000361914,
-0.0325703397,
0.085888356,
0.0318217278,
0.0423031375,
-0.0169453379,
-0.0337171294,
0.0145852156,
-0.0338446833,
-0.062018916,
-0.0158694033,
0.0067758011,
0.0019651717,
0.0191188175,
-0.0099794008,
-0.0612308905,
0.0001973016,
-0.0961116478,
0.0231093634,
0.0121231731,
0.0384347513,
-0.0263176262,
0.0373517908,
0.0067533688,
0.0007144252,
-0.0069096903,
-0.0178405568,
-0.054600887,
0.0283894967,
0.0540705808,
0.0003318997,
0.0084951036,
-0.0431778394,
0.0081261452,
-0.0510434583,
0.0224514231,
-0.0025873936,
-0.0314509831,
-0.0486052185,
0.0351759493,
-0.0439620204,
0.0132505381,
0.0269570965,
-0.0045130048,
0.005489225,
0.0366158597,
0.0036681327,
0.0365779027,
-0.0101057477,
0.021361459,
-0.0142190689,
0.0327986814,
-0.0408197716,
0.0273645595,
0.010969799,
0.018252166,
-0.0040869871,
0.0062301238,
0.0059005204,
0.0850687549,
-0.0664116144,
-0.0265364815,
-0.0853639245,
0.0367275923,
0.0078346394,
0.0341191404,
0.0081223864,
0.0344770253,
0.0158378668,
-0.0076533156,
-0.017742373,
0.0442482941,
0.0774424225,
-0.038300205,
0.0037924363,
0.0359823778,
-0.002665268,
-0.0541240871,
0.0438220575,
-0.0071455766,
-0.0066448986,
0.0628820062,
-0.0242102873,
-0.0313707739,
0.0151993325,
0.0352862403,
-0.0098449197,
0.0698379353,
0.0288351513,
0.0235222168,
-0.0124468086,
-0.0559829324,
-0.0218786448,
-0.0408463366,
-0.0545358658,
0.0604933128,
-0.006266336,
-0.0201808643,
0.0084949108,
0.0091740768,
-0.0016859216,
0.0217773337,
-0.0018871693,
-0.0393157378,
-0.0511823259,
0.0441743433,
0.0497132912,
0.000586205,
0.0192753449,
0.0146180792,
0.0066766404,
-0.0043698433,
0.0110429954,
-0.0077402159,
-0.0171283297,
-0.0175322741,
0.0237751864,
-0.088013716,
-0.0783047676,
0.0004667491,
0.0623755865,
-0.0391146392,
0.0123648532,
0.0983456522,
0.0173402652,
-0.0144665958,
0.0250034127,
0.0385326631,
0.0147301564,
0.0312041473,
0.0337569565,
-0.0983054563,
-0.0785218254,
0.0016924494,
-0.005397521,
-0.0033254817,
-0.0741836205,
0.0226345398,
-0.0929761752,
-0.0042399848,
-0.0201380551,
-0.0532938428,
0.0044846893,
-0.0288825855,
0.0520376042,
-0.0542981811,
-0.002747844,
-0.0542091168,
-0.0224316362,
0.0229614023,
0.0192852914,
0.0266541932,
-0.0575878806,
0.0600070767,
-0.0681703389,
0.0766741186,
-0.0032142014,
0.0362657979,
-0.0256544575,
0.0417386591,
-0.0335792042,
-0.0359450318,
-0.0095290402,
0.0060165846,
0.0819781348,
-0.07068111,
-0.0157289933,
-0.0122421905,
-0.003079467,
-0.0146455159,
-0.0113300839,
-0.0041976306,
0.0248894636,
0.0132851228,
0.0111964894,
-0.007551312,
-0.0473429449,
0.0156152183,
0.0820301846,
0.0114435097,
-0.0457680114,
0.0049364362,
-0.0437561497,
-0.0171005521,
-0.03497326,
0.0141101228,
-0.015025977,
-0.0411240906,
-0.0029506998,
-0.0506533161,
-0.0928832814,
0.0568814576,
-0.0251303203,
-0.006845268,
0.0399550609,
0.0140372114,
-0.0074072471,
-0.0588485673,
0.0453869514,
-0.0379689001,
0.0289902929,
0.003942389,
-0.0364685655,
0.0436353981,
-0.0161873493,
-0.017362684,
0.0116842389,
-0.0767376944,
-0.0497934148,
-0.024077151,
0.0030909742,
0.0109257586,
0.0491527691,
-0.0194041133,
-0.0462140106,
0.0249757674,
0.0655910149,
-0.0622253641,
-0.016823167,
0.0421912037,
0.0295147896,
0.0034302976,
0.0599376597,
-0.0662242472,
-0.0025940179,
0.021538673,
0.0559760444,
-0.0590834394,
-0.0509755872,
0.0213793069,
-0.0165463444,
0.0403276868,
-0.0175998826,
-0.0062402296,
-0.0301117953,
0.0045042741,
0.0158277564,
-0.0306381155,
-0.0264094118,
-0.0461386256,
-0.0222839825,
-0.0005081697,
-0.008876916,
0.0315824747,
-0.0188559573,
0.0957449898,
-0.0506554134,
0.0109993657,
-0.008172486,
-0.0197305214,
0.0049217525,
-0.0318399481,
-0.0203790925,
0.0542875491,
0.0078359758,
0.032517381,
-0.0673484728,
0.0192619301,
0.0307719409,
0.0207398254,
-0.0234192777,
0.003899982,
-0.0008828418,
0.0371038169,
-0.0295558926,
0.0627126172,
0.046679195,
-0.0487635285,
0.0424223319,
-0.0228321701,
-0.0260849502,
0.0044704317,
0.0530859604,
-0.0309900828,
0.0005894976,
0.0104297418,
0.054722026,
-0.0449837521,
-0.0017789173,
0.0703998655,
0.015139807,
0.0666863695,
0.0150754368,
0.0042116218,
-0.0385406204,
0.0024076509,
0.0571257584,
0.032326594,
-0.0066415793,
0.0233245995,
-0.0777107552,
-0.076184459,
0.0055487244,
-0.0459174626,
-0.0633094832,
0.0016680151,
0.0206491128,
0.0072892397,
0.0350599773,
-0.0236366224,
-0.0510878973,
-0.0501402617,
0.0173346307,
-0.013402503,
-0.0276805852,
-6.516850315e-33,
-0.0516768508,
-0.0254198574,
0.0095393956,
0.0014987023,
0.0149656571,
0.0083161257,
0.0103607457,
-0.0123554124,
-0.0543492176,
0.0187657494,
-0.0236948524,
0.0023564687,
-0.0047032661,
0.0081555089,
0.0171641577,
-0.0143558402,
0.036029242,
0.041052036,
-0.0056615346,
-0.0060038329,
0.0104151294,
0.0043658549,
0.0676045939,
-0.0290658642,
0.0542626306,
-0.0241999421,
-0.0176103506,
0.0219039172,
0.017460417,
0.0896605328,
-0.0071076201,
0.0421296209,
0.0297541209,
-0.0265205689,
0.0340214223,
-0.0164449681,
-0.1242416501,
-0.0266117565,
-0.0086361542,
-0.0191513803,
-0.0065178811,
-0.029329937,
0.0305591933,
-0.0202223193,
0.020447474,
-0.0205733124,
0.0442515127,
-0.0203350056,
-0.0017851993,
-0.0424816348,
-0.0631336197,
0.0448330604,
0.0135309184,
-0.0138204684,
0.0263973325,
-0.0267881267,
0.0101384446,
-0.0206679478,
-0.0376686603,
-0.0024953939,
0.0088254334,
0.0005602294,
-0.0254791062,
-0.017413998,
-0.0138675533,
0.0262420587,
-0.0071444656,
0.0370641351,
-0.0248760562,
-0.0017509974,
0.0180583391,
0.0151809128,
-0.0121280737,
0.0626614243,
0.0719515756,
0.0124571463,
-0.0204988644,
0.0109849349,
0.0038379245,
0.0190417394,
-0.0257505737,
-0.0264441445,
-0.0513917767,
-0.0345091894,
-0.0440044925,
0.010373312,
-0.058316879,
-0.0259358678,
0.0047210013,
0.0004909855,
-0.0243378188,
0.0444265604,
-0.0134649677,
-0.0461438186,
-0.0279144812,
-0.004722652,
-0.0016607408,
0.0065428633,
0.010504555,
-0.0079056649,
-0.0618966743,
-0.0602987893,
0.0373285376,
-0.0279350113,
0.0230515804,
0.038246166,
0.1015495136,
-0.0098325675,
-0.0550510734,
-0.0023812549,
-0.0093659526,
-0.0103199976,
-0.0720892325,
-0.0124534816,
0.0367077999,
0.0164964218,
0.008859748,
0.0306791402,
0.078317292,
-0.0075132963,
-0.0137170404,
0.0245747045,
0.0007781759,
0.0324146152,
0.0083070584,
0.0076467562,
-0.0000762211,
-0.0269870255,
0.0098210843,
-0.0264689941,
-0.0155665139,
-0.0160474889,
2.62e-7,
0.0203775223,
0.0754290447,
-0.0166432094,
0.0299695972,
-0.0083749294,
0.0727878958,
0.059179198,
0.0538926125,
-0.018204879,
-0.0195889585,
0.0001805017,
-0.0024289787,
0.0241996869,
0.0192849487,
-0.0961536616,
-0.0115350764,
0.0040407302,
0.0322932526,
-0.047579404,
0.0031475385,
0.0381745175,
0.0682630315,
0.0523011237,
0.0078533515,
-0.0286874343,
-0.0374678597,
0.065725632,
0.0111015365,
-0.0099957539,
0.0293535069,
-0.0192683879,
0.069303304,
-0.0059178206,
0.0364179015,
-0.0168591142,
0.0078083584,
0.0315387771,
0.034442015,
-0.0438347422,
0.022049496,
-0.0174217802,
-0.0573683679,
0.0033947958,
-0.017572403,
0.0645910874,
-0.0563466512,
-0.025787184,
-0.0138135795,
-0.0236820076,
0.0079003423,
-0.0292669982,
-0.017206274,
-0.0176059585,
0.0039215339,
0.0275756381,
-0.0017804053,
-0.0331762172,
-0.0646860078,
0.0019285398,
0.0600604713,
0.0208060034,
-0.0229230244,
-0.0159232095,
-0.0530357249,
0.0261907,
-0.0967395231,
-0.0097695207,
2.542589689e-34,
-0.005865816,
0.0201723073,
0.0056683971,
0.0226216502,
0.0314321816,
0.0061124647,
-0.0419788696,
-0.0016653299,
0.0299338233,
-0.0225867555,
0.0071977894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07793v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07793v5 | GenTKG: Generative Forecasting on Temporal Knowledge Graph with Large Language Models | 2023-10-11T18:27:12 | 2024-04-16T18:35:30 | Ruotong Liao, Xu Jia, Yangzhe Li, Yunpu Ma, Volker Tresp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs) have ignited interest
in the temporal knowledge graph (tKG) domain, where conventional
embedding-based and rule-based methods dominate. The question remains open of
whether pre-trained LLMs can understand structured temporal relational data and
replace them as the foundation model for temporal relational forecasting.
Therefore, we bring temporal knowledge forecasting into the generative setting.
However, challenges occur in the huge chasms between complex temporal graph
data structure and sequential natural expressions LLMs can handle, and between
the enormous data sizes of tKGs and heavy computation costs of finetuning LLMs.
To address these challenges, we propose a novel retrieval-augmented generation
framework named GenTKG combining a temporal logical rule-based retrieval
strategy and few-shot parameter-efficient instruction tuning to solve the above
challenges, respectively. Extensive experiments have shown that GenTKG
outperforms conventional methods of temporal relational forecasting with low
computation resources using extremely limited training data as few as 16
samples. GenTKG also highlights remarkable cross-domain generalizability with
outperforming performance on unseen datasets without re-training, and in-domain
generalizability regardless of time split in the same dataset. Our work reveals
the huge potential of LLMs in the tKG domain and opens a new frontier for
generative forecasting on tKGs. Code and data are released here:
https://github.com/mayhugotong/GenTKG. | [
0.0543480292,
0.0725924075,
-0.0038776651,
-0.0020429629,
-0.0063458569,
-0.0025160024,
0.0013519062,
0.0091025447,
0.053075742,
-0.0308201276,
0.0191699043,
-0.0429522358,
-0.03828118,
0.0384653248,
-0.0208754558,
-0.0382997543,
0.0403225906,
-0.0047908174,
0.0152858635,
-0.0087106293,
-0.0137738483,
0.0203462243,
0.0087119015,
0.0481632464,
-0.0205299556,
-0.0200461559,
-0.0240322351,
-0.0179651249,
0.0097102085,
-0.0356271975,
0.0239073448,
0.0091959108,
0.0438657403,
0.0451377816,
0.0000020725,
-0.0013424123,
-0.0231398009,
-0.0140158487,
-0.0015066543,
-0.0041976674,
0.0318749584,
-0.0325427763,
0.0239139833,
-0.00053024,
-0.0969015285,
-0.0436936542,
0.0132185994,
0.0195828304,
0.0287252627,
0.1035496816,
-0.0023743822,
-0.0234852321,
0.0295437295,
-0.04987555,
0.0295263417,
-0.0599596985,
0.0070358855,
-0.0132370079,
0.0042119711,
-0.0052831941,
-0.0012772777,
0.0310686678,
-0.0045787883,
-0.0027218116,
0.0415273607,
0.0630476549,
0.0091433935,
0.0187730435,
-0.0202470999,
0.0561445653,
0.024609752,
-0.0270034429,
0.0245749783,
0.0309241079,
-0.0406151228,
0.0155700315,
-0.0257804599,
-0.0044213515,
0.0035235896,
0.0361931995,
0.0132317599,
-0.0249120537,
0.0319638103,
0.013490458,
-0.0225150976,
0.094585374,
0.0190799646,
-0.003300078,
-0.0551909283,
-0.0233812053,
-0.0003352919,
-0.0294511169,
-0.0269935597,
0.0400021598,
-0.0282599572,
0.0028346754,
-0.0162851065,
-0.0036090037,
-0.0307500064,
-0.0199537948,
0.0148614775,
0.0643892139,
0.0444967486,
0.0277145803,
-0.0197234713,
0.0305601917,
0.0102138016,
-0.0275565404,
-0.0559552684,
0.0062548327,
-0.0849305466,
-0.0038391801,
-0.0552737936,
-0.000154403,
-0.0206374638,
-0.0117718773,
-0.0581517965,
0.0103740431,
0.0027513586,
0.0018912794,
0.0343734436,
0.0333355553,
-0.0601547062,
-0.0237843748,
-0.0386263616,
0.0126994159,
-0.0056308857,
-0.0154439695,
-0.0135258595,
-0.0292597003,
-0.0192340948,
-0.0093888016,
0.0148378322,
-0.0087872231,
-0.0130237341,
0.063619867,
0.0025862523,
0.0031854936,
-0.0510622896,
-0.0635994449,
-0.0159340277,
-0.0588136055,
0.0597564057,
-0.0192416087,
0.0312108975,
0.0051010852,
-0.0078209648,
-0.0209248923,
0.0214402955,
0.0137676867,
-0.0383394919,
0.0104364194,
0.024094278,
0.0197047275,
-0.0377601497,
-0.0114121689,
0.0344390087,
0.0518395752,
0.0350131579,
0.004445781,
0.0236177575,
0.0223268252,
-0.0681256354,
-0.0004695842,
0.044192344,
-0.0125429453,
-0.0492448546,
0.0130468374,
-0.0089925984,
0.009078077,
0.0280003306,
-0.0013883385,
-0.0209690798,
-0.0075999354,
0.0037842866,
-0.0119716851,
0.0218781028,
0.0312138274,
0.0986600593,
-0.0204069335,
-0.0047549279,
-0.0310757142,
0.0008676242,
0.02418462,
-0.0311905779,
0.0263066143,
-0.01871478,
0.0384139605,
-0.0279386193,
-0.0166099686,
0.008248915,
0.009514627,
0.0099622561,
-0.0269313641,
0.0613801144,
-0.0018210668,
-0.0634018481,
0.0732901469,
0.0333260298,
-0.0477595665,
-0.0061081992,
0.0129301157,
0.0337043889,
0.1008788049,
0.0529990047,
-0.0044222255,
-0.0461831279,
0.0386889502,
0.0035632208,
-0.0048847659,
0.0312197227,
-0.0024449646,
-0.0241975933,
-0.0599610582,
-0.0466280654,
0.0090538608,
-0.002647423,
0.0197670814,
0.0415817648,
0.0467597656,
0.0656656921,
-0.0495137386,
0.004987882,
-0.0205485988,
-0.0323855914,
-0.0260209832,
0.009086811,
-0.0038390316,
0.0285154823,
0.0214634817,
-0.0180947091,
0.0488442667,
0.0597999729,
-0.0459278524,
-0.0188789405,
0.0330321752,
-0.0595528707,
-0.0777682364,
0.0335434787,
0.0057433187,
0.0255617499,
-0.0298301093,
-0.055944588,
-0.0400702618,
0.1071324944,
0.0009223075,
0.105817087,
-0.054660365,
-0.0219905116,
0.046902094,
-0.016936928,
-0.023242427,
0.060492482,
-0.0108842645,
0.0004257088,
0.0141389659,
0.0019161301,
-0.0175436232,
-0.0117712161,
0.0099950982,
0.0073370687,
0.0121230492,
-0.0075269216,
0.0125237871,
0.0079121627,
-0.0654212013,
-0.028772613,
-0.0900039524,
0.0093114572,
0.0073622549,
0.0157867651,
-0.0227101408,
-0.0164846834,
0.0148011846,
-0.0013663614,
-0.014195363,
0.045357015,
0.0089038797,
-0.0105472105,
-0.0185596887,
0.0311637577,
-0.0205757376,
0.0061455211,
-0.0220323261,
-0.0354732275,
0.0560393445,
-0.004368762,
-0.0034816456,
0.0074857417,
0.0322360285,
-0.0643071234,
0.0126070119,
-0.0422074199,
0.014882681,
-0.020139277,
-0.0728146508,
0.0752469748,
-0.0060603172,
-0.0132616367,
-0.0142591409,
0.0110858036,
-0.0855034962,
-0.0482179523,
0.0432500765,
-0.0388921238,
-0.002617039,
-0.0234635249,
0.0163608845,
-0.0259105917,
0.0425486751,
0.0018758094,
-0.0271730479,
-0.0967018455,
0.0208522081,
-0.0428674109,
-0.0074673835,
-0.0148239816,
0.0369566679,
0.0191423167,
-0.0107769063,
-0.0322429091,
-0.0516013615,
0.0402567722,
0.006423763,
-0.0129781133,
0.028456293,
-0.0163739379,
-0.0671114549,
0.0696643591,
0.0038622299,
0.0141803687,
-0.0015057342,
0.0073250872,
-0.0338647179,
0.0256162733,
0.0162959993,
-0.034735132,
-0.0023669838,
0.0103450194,
0.0337604396,
0.0186510943,
-0.0022903865,
-0.0321933478,
-0.0372556821,
-0.0159168746,
-0.0072565642,
0.0176002476,
-0.0108179012,
-0.0351346433,
0.0091468776,
-0.0406936333,
-0.0081825424,
0.0030421659,
-0.0184188616,
0.0224160552,
0.0500418469,
0.0537409633,
-0.0353119485,
-0.0400934964,
-0.0044432613,
-0.003423648,
0.0144441398,
0.0634261966,
-0.0466439016,
-0.0256746504,
-0.0000634279,
0.013884712,
0.0014290987,
-0.0209669862,
0.0276451185,
-0.0102970973,
-0.0680398494,
-0.0128811402,
0.1044626385,
0.0259936694,
-0.0110339746,
0.0008737479,
0.005285548,
0.0296797194,
0.0183656961,
0.0381661057,
-0.1005200446,
-0.0068737343,
-0.0004538709,
0.0040529049,
0.0120655531,
-0.065144144,
-0.0323667042,
-0.122742556,
0.0253202785,
0.040455509,
0.0346700139,
-0.0155450394,
-0.0325394161,
-0.0221771672,
-0.0038142491,
-0.0426735356,
0.0401777327,
-0.0267807115,
0.0445331298,
0.0307617355,
-0.0452677235,
-0.0425855741,
0.0402205512,
0.0143287657,
0.0524367131,
0.0257815029,
0.0360887423,
0.0248897057,
-0.0389983989,
-0.0241691824,
0.0404718928,
0.0241232887,
-0.0348329544,
0.0357413143,
-0.0141721098,
-0.0033277404,
-0.0048870966,
0.0099212518,
-0.0161772966,
-0.0212923177,
0.0025657052,
0.0937676057,
-0.0218039509,
-0.0285955966,
-0.0173862278,
-0.0027878631,
0.0079588993,
0.0610669591,
-0.0023838247,
0.0152964229,
-0.045977056,
0.0048971679,
0.0150012663,
-0.0866514966,
-0.0217734054,
0.006264254,
-0.0163804442,
0.0075442037,
-0.0583326183,
-0.0383397527,
0.0007328067,
0.0237084851,
0.0017347493,
0.0004960431,
0.0074790278,
0.0023549821,
-0.0813376158,
-0.0019913481,
-0.036280755,
0.0042058551,
-0.0330150127,
-0.0027560261,
0.0077632037,
-0.0077141388,
-0.0282427799,
0.0159401856,
-0.0749450177,
-0.0696502775,
-0.0188634377,
0.0206294302,
0.0055705477,
0.0608240552,
0.0324846655,
0.0401731133,
0.1048125103,
0.067718178,
-0.0215943493,
0.0061507113,
0.0407587662,
-0.0129058389,
0.0179588925,
0.0599292032,
-0.043823529,
0.0217461549,
-0.0202358887,
0.0742590427,
0.0078436397,
-0.0198027659,
-0.0116431229,
-0.0071365549,
0.0358397961,
0.0094488552,
-0.0044842516,
-0.0389999934,
-0.0039831582,
-0.0390308797,
0.0063995267,
-0.0683731064,
0.0060484312,
0.0219773073,
-0.02867979,
-0.0164943058,
0.0103097931,
0.0375243202,
0.0269051623,
-0.0182439033,
-0.0095619271,
-0.0107890125,
-0.0103610484,
0.0629163235,
-0.0036735341,
0.001579383,
0.0148413163,
-0.0118609993,
-0.0066653769,
-0.0284956638,
0.0060852948,
0.00677989,
0.0420269705,
-0.0554223917,
-0.0500091612,
-0.0554398112,
-0.0175207518,
-0.0110548725,
-0.0050416277,
0.0684500635,
-0.0318333767,
0.0578556359,
-0.0311824642,
0.0077760681,
0.00096479,
0.0380118936,
0.0006555149,
-0.0463022105,
0.0208130963,
-0.0187017228,
-0.0464111865,
0.0018178541,
0.1106411889,
0.0268888231,
0.0873515829,
0.0158221703,
-0.0558330826,
-0.0234809555,
-0.0343630947,
0.0028334109,
-0.015474108,
-0.005451967,
0.0181949344,
-0.0564210266,
-0.0591626205,
0.0335029252,
-0.0126275821,
-0.0524703488,
-0.0080698822,
0.0123531325,
0.0344424918,
0.0100569855,
-0.0188201871,
-0.0439936407,
0.0205772482,
-0.0284070279,
-0.0497122854,
-0.0361339673,
-6.469567524e-33,
-0.0233461242,
0.0039822818,
0.0603271276,
-0.0296955407,
-0.054069154,
0.0402267575,
-0.0466355793,
-0.0394179672,
0.0307682175,
0.0200050473,
-0.0275950618,
0.0129747521,
0.0040185209,
0.0105543025,
0.0539967604,
0.0145031605,
0.0421923399,
-0.0136710126,
0.0285015311,
0.0548799038,
0.0783790499,
0.0565544367,
0.0568903871,
-0.0006208523,
-0.0065878578,
0.0008634572,
0.0228840262,
0.0253411867,
0.0514814146,
0.0381763726,
-0.0019181609,
0.0274714213,
0.015808396,
-0.0299972799,
-0.0290172696,
-0.0021769749,
-0.0664107352,
-0.0651153922,
-0.0050680568,
-0.031381052,
-0.035069,
-0.0256241299,
-0.0331861153,
-0.0133852428,
0.0093338173,
-0.027378954,
0.0145834656,
-0.0113261947,
-0.0348681882,
-0.1195253953,
-0.0100466972,
0.0381307229,
-0.0007579479,
0.0020400246,
0.0277639013,
0.0377278328,
0.0506209582,
-0.008661747,
-0.0561239868,
0.0450438112,
-0.023194138,
0.0363579132,
0.0251117125,
0.0032027226,
0.0344760828,
0.0361841843,
-0.0101741618,
0.0009885383,
-0.0397271328,
0.0468860976,
0.0091385525,
0.056834802,
-0.0536941662,
-0.0113753434,
0.0346902274,
-0.0425375365,
-0.0625294,
0.0308259092,
0.0465245768,
0.062312644,
0.0285236053,
0.0071688178,
-0.0283210222,
-0.0047692931,
-0.0037160167,
0.0131774386,
-0.0073791621,
-0.0267304871,
0.0289090257,
0.0563546047,
0.0252770856,
-0.0142125087,
0.0500101335,
-0.0484910719,
-0.0077068759,
0.0720264465,
-0.0307997018,
-0.0602879561,
-0.0027112805,
0.0447183624,
-0.0718328729,
-0.0565312244,
0.0466685705,
-0.0290236976,
-0.0273241717,
-0.022244988,
0.000507832,
0.0458475947,
-0.0417419523,
-0.0252438616,
-0.0342654139,
0.0246954616,
0.0112202568,
-0.0259487126,
0.0572510585,
0.0287188068,
-0.0019898294,
0.0181561671,
0.0539944693,
0.0439463109,
0.0188031271,
0.0385058485,
0.0579975247,
-0.0031031161,
-0.0008909582,
0.0046056542,
-0.0400342084,
-0.0172476023,
0.0307278968,
-0.0229336619,
-0.0302962121,
0.0294997245,
2.796e-7,
0.0153132053,
0.024533093,
0.0121570118,
0.0733171776,
0.0234780237,
-0.0029731009,
0.0003979763,
0.0231573693,
-0.0103624631,
0.0312182475,
0.0723118261,
0.0245841816,
0.0326688178,
0.0266379323,
-0.0757790953,
-0.0000583312,
-0.0776991993,
-0.0361822881,
-0.0406177379,
-0.0552270524,
0.0278246086,
0.0834302977,
0.040806897,
-0.0033706822,
0.0337865464,
-0.0807292014,
0.0861680359,
0.0143737365,
-0.0267675202,
0.0103533668,
0.0555310287,
0.0116624655,
-0.019551836,
-0.0066968827,
-0.0288620479,
0.0280482098,
-0.0399244241,
0.0422178917,
0.0110321613,
-0.0032190739,
0.039166376,
-0.0270781368,
-0.0258678664,
-0.0032814208,
0.070826076,
-0.080600284,
-0.0040416252,
0.001257877,
-0.0337789468,
0.0332995243,
-0.0234519616,
0.0244222879,
-0.0060945218,
0.0212904084,
0.0215345342,
-0.0150904562,
0.0067326524,
-0.0614375696,
-0.0333355665,
0.0295892116,
-0.0352977961,
-0.0289565157,
-0.0191844068,
0.0032755863,
-0.0070481217,
-0.0390975587,
0.0267259385,
2.776730485e-34,
0.0621070489,
0.0159999952,
-0.0334395021,
-0.0144895352,
0.0439588539,
-0.036582429,
-0.0215916485,
0.0104003577,
0.0179836098,
-0.095124051,
-0.0412440225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07715v1 | To Build Our Future, We Must Know Our Past: Contextualizing Paradigm Shifts in Natural Language Processing | 2023-10-11T17:59:36 | 2023-10-11T17:59:36 | Sireesh Gururaja, Amanda Bertsch, Clara Na, David Gray Widder, Emma Strubell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | NLP is in a period of disruptive change that is impacting our methodologies,
funding sources, and public perception. In this work, we seek to understand how
to shape our future by better understanding our past. We study factors that
shape NLP as a field, including culture, incentives, and infrastructure by
conducting long-form interviews with 26 NLP researchers of varying seniority,
research area, institution, and social identity. Our interviewees identify
cyclical patterns in the field, as well as new shifts without historical
parallel, including changes in benchmark culture and software infrastructure.
We complement this discussion with quantitative analysis of citation,
authorship, and language use in the ACL Anthology over time. We conclude by
discussing shared visions, concerns, and hopes for the future of NLP. We hope
that this study of our field's past and present can prompt informed discussion
of our community's implicit norms and more deliberate action to consciously
shape the future. | [
0.0801961422,
0.1079681963,
-0.0188841913,
-0.0270476844,
-0.0567310117,
-0.013917869,
-0.0020542843,
0.0094074653,
-0.0094001042,
-0.0859758481,
0.0391101204,
0.0517399237,
0.0308684558,
0.0313392915,
0.0058459681,
-0.038307488,
0.0065348884,
0.0453250632,
0.0229192562,
0.0063453056,
0.0364271924,
0.0505187735,
-0.002820587,
0.0754135773,
-0.004496885,
-0.033464849,
0.0371805839,
-0.0452795774,
-0.0082914578,
-0.0307082999,
0.0070527014,
0.0477634259,
-0.0047126492,
0.0425696298,
0.0000019922,
-0.0638067648,
-0.0181634147,
0.0116601177,
0.0037868884,
0.0024482196,
0.0404885672,
-0.0075384504,
-0.0417345837,
-0.0068697771,
-0.0569332615,
-0.0061348327,
0.064241074,
0.023935318,
0.0203134213,
0.0242060758,
-0.0018698623,
-0.0547727309,
0.0195922349,
0.0259224325,
-0.054963015,
0.001935599,
0.022393059,
-0.0361636281,
0.0168015081,
0.0030894096,
-0.0057850727,
0.0333413593,
-0.0180466305,
-0.046960339,
0.050063476,
0.040447332,
-0.0422816314,
-0.0195034016,
0.007113643,
0.0077166241,
0.0655986071,
-0.02742978,
0.030006513,
0.0029827922,
-0.0282147527,
0.0120730605,
-0.0309566967,
0.0648156255,
0.0026521068,
-0.0169638023,
0.0027783634,
0.0130502172,
-0.0046197711,
0.0656163618,
0.02997634,
0.0551640205,
-0.0252413955,
-0.0343863741,
0.0374614038,
0.0258035045,
0.0348528065,
-0.0267480817,
0.0451293588,
0.0065857642,
-0.0014772997,
0.0134365084,
0.029691942,
-0.0176378824,
0.0444623157,
-0.0081923259,
-0.0125367614,
-0.0218917541,
-0.0163052231,
0.0207544398,
0.0073173088,
0.0124400398,
0.0119551308,
-0.0330597386,
0.0003630923,
0.0292214397,
-0.0796768442,
-0.0101234084,
-0.0168517288,
-0.0059510991,
-0.0221675392,
-0.0033722215,
-0.001622883,
0.002517197,
-0.0171277262,
0.0132106831,
-0.0320470631,
0.0533854999,
-0.0201165825,
0.0584571287,
-0.0096091228,
0.0221335627,
-0.029812796,
0.0157920159,
-0.0058311434,
-0.0219625216,
0.0345652252,
-0.0019729841,
0.0069152126,
-0.0447685234,
0.0252396706,
0.0383367985,
0.0133489342,
0.0152499126,
-0.0421755016,
-0.0493358783,
-0.0097384322,
-0.0248554274,
0.0222859662,
-0.0306366254,
-0.014481009,
0.0415788665,
0.0054496466,
-0.0605567917,
-0.0070706285,
0.0245509837,
-0.0347849205,
0.0474408343,
-0.0115202842,
-0.0136055965,
0.0307795517,
0.0091605801,
0.0245472435,
0.01860038,
0.0100430595,
-0.0013566002,
0.0657805577,
-0.0158068053,
0.0051397914,
0.0021315806,
-0.020212749,
-0.0102923308,
0.0217075087,
0.0041564321,
-0.0183026325,
0.021872228,
0.006720331,
0.061362341,
0.000511164,
-0.0275438987,
0.0280650649,
0.1023291871,
-0.0104957363,
0.0276900139,
0.0138496943,
-0.0099555803,
0.0134860463,
-0.0623186044,
0.0204151478,
-0.0224171057,
0.0131598953,
-0.0187396631,
-0.0206086244,
0.0365052745,
0.0064413613,
-0.0379774831,
-0.0327216201,
0.0476522818,
0.0250857975,
-0.0058285873,
-0.0138248689,
0.0126097221,
0.0000576894,
0.0000989532,
0.0018233095,
-0.0270401053,
-0.0037071144,
-0.0133522544,
-0.0103181126,
0.0099944267,
0.0472047925,
0.0139826154,
0.0703713596,
-0.0527614355,
-0.005288553,
0.0504270047,
-0.0201004557,
0.0084631825,
-0.0070043611,
0.0260311384,
0.0049932911,
0.0125645138,
-0.0001675263,
-0.0241547506,
0.0288493894,
0.0405980162,
-0.0217808727,
0.005427957,
-0.0700191781,
0.0404584482,
-0.0262048542,
-0.0467772968,
-0.0237231404,
-0.0051230192,
0.0147129996,
0.0678215027,
-0.0182216391,
0.0258954745,
0.0303614233,
-0.0039706654,
-0.0044725048,
0.0546442717,
0.0107815182,
0.0427631103,
0.0167294163,
-0.0821323916,
-0.0139989369,
-0.0192910116,
-0.0091165556,
0.0093431426,
0.0751811489,
-0.0218603015,
0.0477530584,
-0.0003873975,
-0.0124488445,
-0.0104164863,
0.001451792,
-0.0832968429,
0.0310701262,
0.0058366354,
0.0111497026,
0.0161032341,
-0.0406369008,
0.024218129,
0.0130998669,
-0.0388788283,
0.0598203354,
0.0034187948,
0.0085811885,
0.0825618133,
0.017321365,
-0.0634264424,
0.0076986058,
-0.0106591182,
-0.0258212928,
-0.0004750166,
-0.0097525092,
-0.0026407698,
-0.0289951917,
0.0083553893,
0.0116380705,
0.0097570606,
-0.043283198,
-0.0174752176,
0.0098482585,
0.0719451308,
0.03681162,
0.02542652,
-0.0458713211,
-0.0162665527,
-0.020328477,
0.058360111,
0.070069395,
-0.0555059277,
-0.0503826886,
0.0063225818,
-0.0179106407,
-0.0010090636,
-0.0168915428,
0.0244587269,
0.0247793663,
0.0346006453,
-0.0026111705,
0.0490281433,
-0.0120804068,
0.0750656053,
0.0066813501,
-0.0031529272,
-0.0299142376,
-0.0104302596,
-0.002182015,
-0.0059688622,
0.0136259822,
-0.0301753208,
0.0613099709,
0.0226475317,
-0.0090659354,
-0.0101442598,
0.0165123735,
0.0121796289,
-0.0643843263,
-0.017628707,
-0.028859701,
-0.0446775295,
-0.0357473083,
0.0262598358,
-0.0090018492,
-0.0028449721,
0.0265750233,
0.0081771193,
-0.0019679831,
-0.1047634631,
-0.0593919866,
-0.0217556916,
0.1132897437,
-0.0074867108,
0.0276711453,
0.0988387614,
-0.0588693395,
-0.0390284508,
-0.0192159601,
0.0196967181,
-0.0250495598,
0.0197660923,
-0.0334983021,
0.0269929413,
-0.0257955175,
-0.0203405637,
-0.0254352838,
-0.0236975718,
-0.0393271521,
0.036863137,
0.0773426294,
-0.0352407135,
-0.0623516254,
-0.0267275777,
0.0607152916,
0.0162414089,
0.0313067324,
-0.0455577746,
-0.0032597878,
0.0184799284,
0.0299986452,
-0.0009925648,
0.0434633754,
0.0507973917,
-0.0661851093,
0.0433447361,
0.0695261955,
0.0224383175,
-0.0166737102,
-0.0078482525,
0.0390076637,
-0.0772448033,
-0.016239766,
0.0121415388,
0.0227895789,
-0.0491465591,
0.0143236993,
0.0629822463,
0.0302111693,
-0.0623282939,
0.0118443351,
0.0045452532,
-0.031390816,
0.0204137247,
0.0399731398,
-0.103947565,
0.0127303647,
-0.0218367167,
-0.0153936902,
-0.0714926496,
-0.0633833483,
-0.0223950911,
-0.1042058915,
0.0172718484,
-0.0479295403,
-0.0215138532,
0.026678877,
-0.0691759363,
-0.0337287784,
-0.0237453636,
0.0466857888,
-0.0218457878,
-0.045021221,
0.0143923843,
0.0572090931,
-0.0605724044,
-0.0137854815,
0.0479253531,
-0.0420322642,
0.0621956624,
0.0309158321,
0.0890220478,
-0.0369147137,
-0.0330706835,
-0.0166837815,
-0.0264896378,
0.0216859244,
-0.0294092018,
0.0285006203,
-0.0177242085,
0.0120818261,
-0.0100366753,
-0.0089930678,
-0.047098875,
-0.0017994614,
-0.0086094765,
0.0548204705,
-0.0058938791,
-0.0097478051,
-0.0400609337,
0.0244124569,
-0.0111509347,
0.0373684689,
-0.018098779,
-0.0116868531,
-0.0269651525,
-0.0397141613,
0.051171653,
-0.0231610741,
-0.0703972802,
-0.0312061254,
-0.0499711744,
0.0051943283,
-0.0530553721,
-0.0533875972,
0.0309374295,
0.008644687,
0.0385180712,
0.0006007852,
0.0084367469,
-0.0199956261,
-0.0854108334,
0.0192239899,
0.0124295326,
0.0385920145,
0.0142489225,
-0.0561884567,
0.0106630027,
0.0561481006,
-0.0195142962,
0.0314482525,
-0.0002366666,
-0.0214745142,
0.0416596048,
-0.0076586232,
0.0265422855,
-0.0215763561,
0.0206212364,
-0.0470826551,
-0.012857045,
0.0706071332,
-0.0048802635,
-0.0095944824,
-0.0027467655,
0.0086424695,
-0.0027880601,
-0.0143145891,
-0.0092692943,
-0.0236689206,
-0.004357201,
0.0041569732,
-0.0401939787,
-0.0224337745,
0.0322801806,
0.0023194361,
0.0107542556,
-0.0638814867,
0.0063839369,
-0.0057395352,
-0.0811302513,
0.0147432992,
-0.0247787591,
-0.0157419145,
-0.0198924039,
-0.0025006486,
0.0125099597,
-0.0249889884,
0.0775432661,
-0.030607773,
0.0780125111,
-0.0536643863,
0.0721551701,
0.0530302264,
0.0337968729,
-0.0109245479,
0.0019767587,
-0.0032394808,
0.0081681944,
0.0090708602,
0.0714960247,
0.0260804985,
0.0258200187,
0.0108262794,
-0.015591858,
0.0108192982,
0.0047910563,
-0.0958473682,
-0.0368783511,
0.0191732626,
-0.0098013664,
0.021699965,
-0.0309525169,
0.0625241324,
0.0000629315,
0.0217969529,
0.0200456735,
0.0252294783,
0.0147371618,
-0.0202278048,
-0.0077999933,
0.0073571713,
-0.0535531007,
0.0003083003,
0.0545627512,
-0.0083938278,
0.0288589075,
0.0107673453,
-0.0108780172,
0.0218617246,
-0.0381295532,
0.023015162,
0.0047806483,
0.0126863942,
0.0042640129,
-0.0717321485,
-0.0198166259,
-0.0042908625,
-0.0410247967,
0.0417202413,
-0.0289972629,
0.0084968517,
0.0354100727,
0.0478624627,
-0.0451960377,
-0.0508463793,
0.037186116,
-0.0348567329,
-0.0428024307,
-0.0173738338,
-6.519827989e-33,
0.0129121738,
-0.0462002382,
-0.0016300065,
-0.0204611532,
-0.0486135073,
0.0270567946,
-0.0154928621,
0.0270817727,
-0.0513794161,
-0.0051278691,
-0.0712604895,
-0.0093984501,
0.0088668959,
-0.0055898242,
0.0788415894,
0.0061561256,
0.0193365887,
-0.0068161651,
0.0081353728,
-0.0219166465,
0.01594867,
0.0001455512,
0.0833480135,
-0.1074735522,
0.0862991139,
0.0457718447,
-0.0328890495,
-0.0013798131,
0.0649222657,
-0.0002475605,
-0.0118604386,
0.0331650078,
0.006015873,
-0.1069435105,
-0.0141575439,
-0.013215661,
-0.0569723323,
-0.0005228518,
0.0538843609,
0.0231125075,
0.0037927474,
-0.0032336153,
0.0441864282,
-0.0207314305,
-0.056658987,
0.0090064993,
0.0788569376,
-0.0094705634,
-0.0031351468,
-0.0446369462,
-0.0490985624,
0.0212628134,
-0.0386112407,
0.0742212608,
0.016267553,
0.0060499702,
-0.0104218302,
-0.0070297811,
-0.0962358117,
0.0010068875,
-0.0186129771,
0.0237140544,
0.0272267144,
-0.0102518797,
0.000239978,
0.0558532961,
0.0134985643,
0.0316005237,
0.0142362602,
-0.0108669642,
0.0264534764,
0.053231582,
-0.0300181229,
0.0710946172,
0.0323173776,
-0.0398373045,
0.0186615717,
0.0177195612,
0.0851852447,
0.0134618171,
-0.0157653596,
0.0074656908,
-0.0428497829,
-0.049223531,
-0.0087032709,
-0.0173459351,
0.0065891566,
-0.0281453114,
-0.0134026604,
-0.0168207884,
-0.0062091765,
0.061152637,
-0.003028241,
-0.059113726,
-0.0807502195,
-0.0024901968,
-0.0152484588,
0.029510824,
0.0144533375,
-0.0016095099,
-0.1192837805,
0.016094435,
-0.0337759741,
0.0573978834,
0.0368371569,
-0.0091808001,
0.0262271296,
0.030652456,
-0.0354382619,
-0.0307999942,
-0.0117352353,
0.022902878,
0.0053984066,
-0.0062838672,
-0.0146935303,
0.0296292715,
0.0115064904,
-0.0113973105,
0.0559010468,
0.0273099281,
0.0240931418,
0.003088031,
0.0100333048,
-0.0211893283,
-0.054846935,
-0.0552223809,
-0.0251569208,
0.0471190177,
0.0630451813,
-0.029788848,
-0.0211374816,
-0.0858217403,
2.799e-7,
0.0649135932,
0.0588355809,
0.019044539,
0.005852791,
0.0111768106,
0.0007124938,
0.0375400037,
0.0282104705,
-0.0184130836,
0.019412322,
-0.0270201173,
-0.0163826477,
-0.023689229,
0.0286041107,
-0.101707913,
-0.0613531023,
-0.0807081759,
-0.0128320511,
-0.0730592757,
0.0192651022,
0.0297921933,
0.0287890062,
0.0144477673,
-0.0091556842,
-0.059986677,
-0.0417435057,
-0.0081963269,
-0.0267412905,
0.0373752452,
0.0076461062,
0.0120595256,
-0.0013674884,
0.038585335,
-0.0145683363,
-0.0245516077,
-0.0197126567,
0.0188189577,
0.0204356313,
-0.0240162835,
-0.0247082636,
0.0247347727,
-0.0043602539,
0.0084768161,
-0.04888862,
0.0356560946,
0.0220917203,
-0.0457071289,
-0.0657496527,
-0.0392623618,
-0.0265614837,
0.0157994442,
0.0053744758,
-0.0331713855,
0.0376056023,
-0.0113684833,
-0.0095901806,
-0.0383814871,
-0.0773130581,
-0.014028158,
0.0120919514,
0.0336823799,
-0.0130630564,
0.0129481088,
-0.01546703,
0.0082854293,
-0.0280739665,
0.0271417387,
2.460063098e-34,
0.0135201151,
0.0102574416,
0.0021084056,
0.0478778221,
0.0329893082,
0.0313780159,
0.0042403531,
0.0060295709,
0.0018828367,
0.0391405448,
-0.0189071987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07713v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07713v3 | InstructRetro: Instruction Tuning post Retrieval-Augmented Pretraining | 2023-10-11T17:59:05 | 2024-05-29T04:15:39 | Boxin Wang, Wei Ping, Lawrence McAfee, Peng Xu, Bo Li, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Pretraining auto-regressive large language models~(LLMs) with retrieval
demonstrates better perplexity and factual accuracy by leveraging external
databases. However, the size of existing pretrained retrieval-augmented LLM is
still limited (e.g., Retro has 7.5B parameters), which limits the effectiveness
of instruction tuning and zero-shot generalization. In this work, we introduce
Retro 48B, the largest LLM pretrained with retrieval. Specifically, we continue
to pretrain a 43B GPT model on additional 100 billion tokens using the Retro
augmentation method by retrieving from 1.2 trillion tokens. Notably, the
obtained foundation model, Retro 48B, largely outperforms the counterpart GPT
43B trained on 1.2T tokens in terms of perplexity with only 2.58% additional
GPU hours, demonstrating the significant scaling potential of the method. After
instruction tuning on Retro, InstructRetro demonstrates significant improvement
over the instruction tuned GPT on a wide range of zero-shot tasks.
Specifically, the average improvement of InstructRetro is 7% over its GPT
counterpart across 8 short-form QA and reading comprehension tasks, 10% over
GPT across 4 challenging long-form QA tasks, and 16% over GPT across 3
summarization tasks. Surprisingly, we find that one can ablate the encoder from
InstructRetro architecture and directly use its decoder backbone, while
achieving comparable results. Our results highlight the promising direction to
obtain a better GPT decoder through continued pretraining with retrieval before
instruction tuning. Our code and checkpoints are publicly available at:
https://huggingface.co/nvidia/retro-48b-instruct-4k. | [
0.0167653058,
0.0751096755,
0.006300983,
0.0368672647,
0.0010945383,
0.0282820519,
-0.0377269909,
-0.0037431465,
-0.0393751487,
-0.0231870059,
-0.0416703112,
-0.0221419949,
-0.00874478,
0.0351932347,
-0.0003472705,
-0.0043482943,
0.0613177791,
-0.006557819,
-0.0055878353,
-0.0020067499,
0.0096469317,
0.024885213,
0.0019312949,
0.0272817798,
0.0188878234,
-0.0252036564,
-0.0197048765,
0.0219267439,
0.0054356786,
-0.0337277018,
-0.0051172962,
0.0438194349,
0.0590197481,
0.0478501581,
0.0000022279,
-0.0062562609,
-0.037531849,
-0.0191952195,
-0.0448394231,
0.0419637337,
0.0132939657,
-0.0138433957,
0.0018192265,
0.004102713,
-0.0245882645,
-0.0652626082,
0.0308891237,
0.0331215449,
0.07340464,
0.0864987895,
0.0042758402,
-0.0335258767,
0.0657595396,
-0.0372451134,
0.0228005983,
-0.0605477095,
-0.0109612783,
-0.011162228,
-0.0422093682,
0.0521696098,
-0.0286165401,
0.034229286,
0.0648476928,
0.0310242325,
0.0183873139,
0.0309614707,
-0.0164754447,
-0.0123701459,
-0.031743139,
0.0660515353,
0.0046338877,
-0.0245792698,
-0.0398971513,
0.0281849746,
-0.0155981444,
-0.0537174121,
-0.0319041274,
0.0119274361,
-0.001058107,
0.0234410055,
0.014280552,
-0.0183553845,
0.0446574092,
0.0040059825,
-0.0466614738,
0.0268818047,
0.0333737843,
-0.0222228076,
-0.0213719569,
0.0209671799,
-0.0512403175,
-0.0131969266,
0.00831223,
0.0126431286,
-0.0451793,
0.003794871,
-0.0472016819,
-0.0366682447,
-0.0092888055,
0.0493548699,
0.0314006209,
0.0766978711,
-0.0430675112,
0.0487541929,
-0.0250610821,
0.0727703944,
-0.0346405283,
0.0268408153,
-0.0590275079,
-0.0001145267,
-0.0490545705,
-0.0197809208,
-0.0658797622,
0.0386033803,
-0.0693420097,
-0.0274423975,
-0.020616632,
0.0128305852,
0.0193795413,
-0.0391157828,
-0.0089143338,
0.0054228725,
-0.0502774231,
-0.0150313247,
0.0103755817,
0.0455263592,
-0.0406961814,
-0.0135796685,
0.0304663014,
-0.0879996046,
-0.0400348827,
0.0059495755,
0.0126461536,
-0.0586692914,
0.0319653004,
-0.0081648408,
-0.0590557791,
-0.0552126244,
-0.0328215957,
-0.0073129488,
0.0306421034,
-0.0833854377,
-0.0035201777,
-0.0395435877,
0.0406064503,
0.0087870574,
0.0008155041,
-0.0068871272,
-0.0127288168,
0.0230574757,
0.0056556277,
0.0588398986,
-0.0064375415,
-0.0147737907,
0.0260628033,
0.0074511999,
0.0185994003,
0.0475174524,
0.0142860748,
0.0310360864,
0.0075457254,
0.0067681116,
-0.0086358385,
0.016466355,
0.0593594499,
0.0418373123,
-0.0111087551,
0.0409690477,
0.0071720947,
0.0224398896,
0.0592907667,
0.041091755,
-0.0816143155,
0.0020641326,
0.0352019295,
0.0208265875,
-0.010744839,
0.0446535908,
0.028753249,
0.0234103389,
0.0089522665,
-0.0165998973,
-0.0471820198,
0.0172716174,
-0.0323438123,
0.0141016748,
0.064736478,
0.0176592749,
-0.0442483649,
-0.0367932878,
0.0317802615,
0.0043376256,
-0.0026099463,
0.0194352083,
0.0584529303,
0.0081742378,
-0.0925021544,
0.0263451915,
-0.0041211313,
-0.0565214194,
-0.0117304716,
-0.075074017,
0.0276110675,
0.0504824445,
0.0716681257,
-0.0155191021,
-0.0375656337,
0.0221118405,
0.0076322658,
0.0348666012,
0.0146503076,
0.0161810964,
0.0351661406,
-0.0855305716,
0.0045548487,
-0.0378891863,
0.0157929733,
0.0453372188,
0.0481787361,
0.0230006557,
0.0215068441,
-0.0288376417,
0.0323018022,
0.033380527,
-0.0192473438,
-0.0642647371,
0.0004032353,
0.0048566912,
0.0204166621,
0.0126494234,
-0.014746068,
0.0174599383,
0.0397254527,
-0.0433966294,
0.0058787935,
-0.0181115996,
-0.0889500231,
-0.0535320826,
0.0219104085,
0.0075176726,
-0.0067634257,
0.0485094897,
-0.0391142666,
-0.0431739502,
0.05520951,
-0.035517551,
0.0841223523,
-0.0769938082,
0.0098289559,
0.0071205916,
0.0072586001,
-0.0173205044,
0.0347315185,
-0.0113576055,
-0.0057471995,
0.017114114,
-0.0051694503,
0.0308713894,
-0.0441906191,
-0.0120022623,
-0.0156464223,
0.0002842714,
0.019054411,
0.0077255485,
0.010949688,
-0.0110163055,
-0.0059782038,
-0.1069166362,
0.0286176708,
-0.0492685102,
-0.002732564,
0.0171105023,
0.0316752009,
-0.0066190562,
-0.0244665239,
0.017089555,
-0.015887944,
0.0011557942,
0.0306005366,
0.0151478499,
0.0134702921,
-0.0060780169,
-0.02707313,
-0.0447092764,
0.0145186605,
0.0354874022,
-0.0184022058,
0.0023787948,
-0.0275131147,
-0.0066413833,
0.0126472088,
0.0253920313,
-0.0188027341,
-0.053989809,
0.0320417956,
-0.0288241617,
0.0501271859,
0.0841008052,
-0.0164130982,
0.0329248942,
-0.0011244273,
-0.0045834277,
-0.0526872724,
0.0443255976,
-0.012823103,
-0.0703122765,
-0.0097207967,
0.0144891245,
0.0020942462,
0.0590008274,
-0.0130672324,
-0.0070496318,
-0.0750905573,
-0.0267275944,
-0.0050204732,
-0.0298821442,
-0.0605683625,
-0.0070541417,
0.0072737755,
0.0157217029,
-0.0597228147,
-0.049595248,
0.0630400181,
-0.0376243591,
-0.0189601276,
-0.040657565,
0.0155480336,
-0.0503409207,
0.0754174218,
0.0171319768,
0.0084052235,
-0.0358987451,
-0.0405858792,
-0.0072198976,
0.0067782057,
-0.0261962954,
-0.0289809555,
0.0459517501,
-0.0103183407,
0.0273207873,
-0.0058365888,
-0.0589711517,
-0.0128294034,
-0.0198521689,
-0.0031886329,
-0.0072793723,
0.0243994575,
-0.0115159359,
-0.0562236868,
-0.0119254813,
0.0418327712,
0.0893903449,
-0.0383794717,
0.0039320141,
-0.0359132513,
-0.0023693668,
0.0333093442,
-0.0136993006,
-0.0075804377,
-0.0470262468,
0.000184479,
0.0468175374,
0.0475112386,
-0.0488297306,
-0.0364486016,
0.0305130482,
0.0184778217,
-0.0061005508,
-0.0000936941,
0.0083801346,
0.0650411323,
-0.0737950131,
-0.0442071036,
0.1014206707,
0.0189557299,
-0.0648440942,
-0.0350025706,
0.0151358508,
0.02750233,
0.0186551791,
0.0325716101,
-0.101880841,
-0.0548018254,
0.0085474206,
0.0259874649,
0.0260850694,
0.0155105246,
-0.0106124263,
-0.1112987697,
0.0224671289,
0.0188993141,
-0.0342713147,
-0.056654796,
-0.0365810767,
-0.0461215861,
-0.0187706444,
0.0402252078,
0.0507661216,
0.0007559694,
0.029925419,
-0.007606999,
0.0203014687,
0.0130995046,
0.0233511068,
-0.0122665241,
-0.011962723,
0.083075434,
0.0047658589,
0.028466545,
-0.0279362891,
0.0305187404,
-0.0110424748,
0.0005974724,
-0.006552672,
0.0596801303,
-0.0388518274,
0.0037508528,
-0.0194064565,
0.024548227,
-0.0476827472,
-0.0112634841,
0.0027906517,
0.0543116033,
-0.0065848217,
0.019641662,
-0.0222541708,
-0.0563838221,
-0.0197158121,
0.0580849312,
0.0174746178,
-0.0139370495,
-0.0477483496,
-0.0214824881,
0.0240640417,
-0.0995614827,
0.0162347388,
-0.0043299436,
0.0214128066,
-0.0263401121,
-0.0272823852,
-0.0300168265,
0.0074388073,
0.0375468209,
-0.0272346381,
-0.0173561499,
-0.0155239953,
0.0030042161,
-0.0767717436,
0.0661442503,
-0.0446794182,
-0.0134351347,
-0.1096925065,
-0.0170108322,
-0.0026625716,
-0.0203684792,
-0.0238006059,
0.0345328227,
-0.0533235148,
-0.0360561945,
-0.0039561824,
0.031650953,
0.0203865003,
0.0675590411,
-0.0118446602,
-0.0117727481,
0.0426527262,
0.0270511918,
-0.052105248,
0.0194153339,
-0.0039585172,
-0.0229371302,
-0.0136198997,
0.0314347893,
-0.0168027859,
0.0177783184,
0.002822422,
0.0281489696,
0.0272320565,
0.0194225851,
0.0370545238,
0.0396806709,
0.0629391,
0.0034599828,
0.0279449746,
-0.0174403079,
0.0181654263,
-0.0053850953,
0.0254585873,
-0.0422122031,
-0.0055919769,
0.0563347153,
-0.0437204093,
-0.0088966973,
-0.0024748517,
0.019656349,
0.0628863126,
-0.0486115217,
-0.0059652925,
-0.0427153632,
0.0175377727,
0.0310470331,
-0.0264579449,
-0.0300410911,
0.0031515071,
-0.0078596687,
0.0413772725,
-0.0440125614,
0.0335884057,
0.0193397589,
0.0074166404,
-0.0318780094,
0.0522057638,
-0.0569501258,
-0.024613278,
-0.0391481183,
0.007935835,
0.0495808721,
-0.0005055044,
0.0437466912,
0.0172557067,
-0.0047711534,
-0.0261233859,
-0.0047881347,
0.0050315266,
-0.0231890921,
-0.000357558,
0.0260077659,
0.0011562008,
-0.0025230029,
0.0594425909,
0.0121605098,
0.055855453,
0.0213981606,
0.0156751014,
-0.0246954691,
-0.0106416689,
-0.0038388935,
0.0159197971,
-0.0226152129,
0.0190720689,
0.0170992166,
-0.044860024,
-0.006583184,
-0.0001909646,
-0.0318703167,
-0.0008704644,
0.01684702,
0.0490825921,
-0.0341394171,
-0.0867987797,
-0.0148521457,
0.0449441597,
-0.0150022171,
-0.0182225164,
0.002017417,
-7.152149175e-33,
-0.0183499791,
0.0443063341,
0.0523990877,
-0.0745397657,
-0.024017496,
0.0130586661,
-0.0391966365,
-0.0268021673,
-0.0182580668,
-0.0061473772,
-0.0241354778,
0.0270223096,
0.0166553203,
0.0675917193,
-0.0061852988,
0.0116252452,
0.0675040036,
0.0019064279,
-0.0145051228,
0.0536257178,
0.0040665665,
0.0434476994,
0.0548365749,
-0.010627999,
-0.0288222991,
-0.0181350932,
0.0146593116,
0.0326467305,
0.0007765609,
0.0474519096,
-0.0130875874,
0.0237881858,
0.0068083447,
-0.0477584824,
-0.0143875806,
-0.0003381489,
-0.090566434,
-0.016063571,
0.0173224173,
0.0156017188,
-0.0225532502,
-0.0535191,
0.0078795012,
0.0020553132,
-0.011286431,
-0.040333584,
-0.0193468556,
0.0096502658,
-0.0094105126,
0.0055102156,
-0.0482371338,
0.013731706,
0.0107274093,
-0.0191838536,
0.0170296673,
0.0161191523,
-0.0086355945,
0.0358653404,
-0.0674665794,
0.0071958005,
0.0001171347,
0.0510067195,
0.030869171,
0.037708886,
0.0288880523,
0.0234278738,
0.0221876949,
-0.0074746991,
-0.0400674194,
0.0175272115,
0.0238968115,
0.0237412397,
-0.0181012526,
0.0074758069,
0.0942883417,
-0.0139381979,
-0.0644831583,
-0.0043590115,
0.0112814661,
0.0630847663,
0.0408976674,
0.0355040096,
-0.0257572699,
0.0027650606,
-0.0263354015,
0.0012840198,
-0.0407461599,
-0.0250165109,
0.0563510396,
0.0522375666,
-0.0040639876,
-0.0166429393,
0.0514634214,
-0.0348682627,
0.0303055737,
0.0271220617,
-0.0187119041,
0.0077631446,
-0.0134435948,
0.0726609454,
-0.0440927632,
-0.0339236334,
0.043041978,
-0.0132887578,
-0.0058244178,
-0.0080015734,
0.0240903758,
0.0185449924,
-0.0592054203,
-0.0113863312,
-0.0351739936,
0.0191232711,
-0.0110612735,
0.0305404179,
0.0165758338,
0.0566389412,
0.0014483939,
0.044074513,
-0.0232672505,
0.0201917347,
-0.0472794808,
-0.0580371097,
0.0378443524,
0.0194119029,
-0.0072617396,
0.0014619186,
-0.0434148833,
-0.0148650249,
-0.0176387243,
-0.0831625536,
-0.0266812071,
0.0518095642,
2.91e-7,
0.0117103308,
0.0590977147,
0.0668935925,
-0.0002919103,
-0.0095560653,
0.0128716826,
-0.0083548212,
0.0103818346,
0.0381739028,
-0.0210176185,
0.0216888785,
0.0676636025,
0.041190993,
0.0010222564,
-0.0841942951,
0.0105885742,
-0.0442134961,
0.0111040222,
-0.0600777082,
-0.005047143,
0.0139527638,
0.1191204786,
-0.0099367192,
-0.000383171,
0.056171,
-0.0189949255,
0.0535633527,
0.0118167214,
-0.0321154892,
0.0161020681,
-0.011787435,
0.0618830584,
-0.0084999567,
-0.0096773757,
-0.0064096232,
0.025237171,
0.0029181903,
0.0656142384,
-0.0402792841,
-0.0619318411,
0.0127245653,
0.0084742373,
-0.0193517189,
-0.0227623079,
0.0653840154,
-0.0174737871,
0.0040284735,
-0.009632363,
-0.0764997527,
0.0037377574,
0.0127597786,
-0.0099901734,
-0.0010707001,
0.0432831235,
0.0485416092,
-0.007537303,
-0.003241644,
-0.0855612755,
-0.0121076657,
0.0190673992,
-0.0528218076,
-0.0208149552,
-0.0804716349,
0.0169272237,
0.0327675827,
-0.0520211942,
0.0111975484,
2.833143194e-34,
0.0636910498,
-0.02613285,
0.0496515743,
0.0150448224,
0.0501390472,
-0.0242364574,
-0.0407635756,
0.0049916436,
-0.0111176837,
-0.0901769027,
-0.0192053262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07712v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07712v2 | Found in the Middle: Permutation Self-Consistency Improves Listwise Ranking in Large Language Models | 2023-10-11T17:59:02 | 2024-04-22T17:53:48 | Raphael Tang, Xinyu Zhang, Xueguang Ma, Jimmy Lin, Ferhan Ture | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) exhibit positional bias in how they use context,
which especially complicates listwise ranking. To address this, we propose
permutation self-consistency, a form of self-consistency over ranking list
outputs of black-box LLMs. Our key idea is to marginalize out different list
orders in the prompt to produce an order-independent ranking with less
positional bias. First, given some input prompt, we repeatedly shuffle the list
in the prompt and pass it through the LLM while holding the instructions the
same. Next, we aggregate the resulting sample of rankings by computing the
central ranking closest in distance to all of them, marginalizing out prompt
order biases in the process. Theoretically, we prove the robustness of our
method, showing convergence to the true ranking in the presence of random
perturbations. Empirically, on five list-ranking datasets in sorting and
passage reranking, our approach improves scores from conventional inference by
up to 7-18% for GPT-3.5 and 8-16% for LLaMA v2 (70B), surpassing the previous
state of the art in passage reranking. Our code is at
https://github.com/castorini/perm-sc. | [
0.0145849492,
0.0447800346,
-0.0076975487,
0.0577311181,
-0.0097454721,
0.0080624763,
0.001533332,
-0.0293857437,
0.0526707955,
-0.0535442382,
-0.0448010415,
-0.0225456655,
0.0310574882,
-0.0178665649,
0.0384342484,
-0.0307646338,
0.0159166753,
-0.0612140968,
-0.0021824734,
-0.0354084969,
-0.0098461816,
-0.0227495003,
0.0041774381,
0.0015083539,
0.1044714153,
-0.0061666546,
0.0087115988,
0.0006568488,
0.0447134115,
-0.0435399674,
-0.0351997316,
0.0665933788,
-0.0144379223,
0.0485225432,
0.0000018927,
-0.0447931848,
-0.0381190628,
-0.0198592581,
-0.0064577176,
0.0519977547,
0.0075881635,
0.0166599713,
-0.0311779045,
0.0170115661,
-0.019839501,
0.0212668572,
0.0148333246,
-0.0184633508,
0.0523337163,
0.0312268324,
0.0172649678,
-0.0172551908,
-0.0051897545,
-0.076423116,
0.0012561196,
-0.0442509316,
0.0118623758,
-0.0372466445,
-0.0126380585,
0.0726739466,
-0.0317924209,
0.0253563374,
-0.0018402936,
-0.0181271881,
-0.0090933312,
0.040094763,
-0.0378569849,
0.0256252531,
-0.006908176,
0.0923358202,
-0.0052464041,
-0.0248540137,
0.0142675824,
-0.0005549981,
0.0295776539,
0.0037054482,
-0.066712603,
0.0410391316,
0.0151234753,
0.0115237348,
0.047364831,
0.0264456701,
0.0383321531,
0.0094818044,
-0.0525552742,
0.1151837856,
0.0508572012,
-0.0461736135,
-0.0308994483,
-0.00041542,
-0.0236564688,
-0.033689674,
-0.0289314594,
-0.0184024498,
-0.0433945283,
0.0145729613,
0.0056874794,
0.0264977533,
0.0005629464,
-0.029355783,
0.0222261995,
0.0203349181,
-0.0114750406,
0.0222406983,
-0.0013220414,
0.0776263177,
0.0093092453,
0.0555794723,
-0.0442277044,
0.0468289591,
0.0353159532,
-0.0205206089,
0.0331831127,
0.005408288,
-0.0169180315,
0.010001149,
-0.0858776942,
0.005141492,
-0.0021177868,
-0.0006075895,
0.0168359578,
-0.0239830799,
-0.0263420269,
0.0069957129,
-0.0018617536,
0.0106215887,
0.0225581191,
-0.0016878623,
-0.0084186634,
0.0065045091,
-0.0096498914,
-0.0267494638,
-0.032137312,
-0.0345625691,
-0.0102696642,
0.0504916385,
0.0033868782,
-0.0120950583,
0.0191994607,
0.0194793809,
-0.0317599699,
-0.0389108211,
-0.0291801542,
-0.0718139336,
0.0339693241,
0.0300128758,
0.0308036376,
0.0001902289,
0.0067522526,
0.0060822861,
-0.0343832672,
0.0478033237,
0.0423773713,
0.0112654585,
-0.0112794926,
0.0195562281,
0.0204278734,
0.0162588544,
0.0205293428,
0.0159809049,
0.0551668182,
-0.0190353971,
-0.0294879973,
0.0655274242,
-0.0018755008,
0.0001665884,
-0.0261619259,
-0.0137044871,
0.0129200462,
0.0162516069,
0.0168979466,
0.042722892,
-0.0308878627,
-0.0148899239,
0.0589473732,
0.0411793776,
0.0304341801,
-0.0279150512,
-0.0092643639,
-0.0219102465,
0.0027476454,
0.0751366988,
-0.058645159,
0.012751827,
-0.0018298446,
0.017226452,
0.0815708414,
0.0343026556,
-0.0011434588,
-0.0270717144,
0.007742295,
0.0138384653,
-0.026883522,
0.0064724204,
0.0439646803,
-0.012619623,
-0.0169906151,
0.0452985652,
0.0258169491,
-0.075846374,
-0.0177969597,
-0.0334564894,
-0.0104302708,
0.106473431,
0.0575693101,
-0.0365552194,
-0.0051339967,
0.0254084654,
0.01082817,
0.0215315912,
-0.0035691252,
-0.0187137909,
0.0249631535,
-0.0154769141,
-0.0099450601,
0.0366303176,
0.002553148,
0.0619326532,
-0.0099985776,
-0.0125741139,
0.0183465574,
-0.0344417505,
-0.0311870202,
0.0181633234,
-0.0304394793,
-0.0211158264,
0.02074017,
-0.0249348842,
0.0274592135,
0.004223871,
-0.0137164872,
0.0157976225,
0.0375117995,
-0.0402616039,
0.0331083424,
-0.0092348261,
-0.0521618165,
-0.0378062241,
0.0603614897,
0.0230671074,
-0.0026997186,
0.0763613731,
-0.0618904941,
-0.0306043401,
0.0189901218,
0.0211770665,
0.0142285544,
-0.013930521,
0.0473901927,
0.0253588334,
0.0106685515,
-0.0637423694,
0.0708898827,
-0.0105373366,
0.0795941278,
0.052372165,
0.0368794352,
-0.0136822769,
-0.0380256884,
-0.0475416109,
0.0525977835,
0.0109749455,
-0.0171643402,
0.0179126374,
0.010406062,
-0.0062113102,
-0.0397896245,
-0.1012495384,
-0.0133177005,
-0.020854041,
0.0015354509,
0.0165174268,
0.0190419387,
0.0034518004,
-0.0193745401,
0.0014083912,
-0.0459267981,
0.0351172462,
0.0263894573,
0.0266990252,
-0.0100007607,
-0.0306933019,
-0.0608686991,
-0.0584515929,
-0.0097514447,
0.0524379872,
-0.0248095449,
0.0220699515,
-0.0657810867,
0.0338570699,
-0.0576437563,
0.01511331,
-0.0463203117,
-0.0073848017,
0.0009606626,
-0.0166565888,
0.0418105423,
0.0630705655,
0.0279281922,
-0.0132523691,
0.0917142555,
-0.0250295959,
-0.0567099303,
-0.0319322683,
0.0195912272,
-0.0064872499,
-0.0152372252,
-0.0284547731,
-0.0416673832,
0.0397665389,
-0.0029538844,
-0.0318987332,
0.0028209852,
0.0068170945,
-0.0383902006,
0.0048358119,
-0.0566316172,
-0.0127314022,
-0.0447171181,
0.0502902195,
-0.0077533824,
-0.0589874014,
0.0341272205,
-0.0595501177,
0.0137357935,
-0.0474107675,
-0.0038975039,
-0.0593070313,
0.0655549169,
0.0294475742,
0.0132832453,
-0.0693613142,
-0.0174284186,
-0.070782125,
0.0080112601,
0.040354684,
-0.049416665,
0.0477143005,
-0.033029899,
0.0390494429,
-0.0232617557,
-0.0626904368,
-0.033600416,
-0.0592045337,
0.0048569599,
-0.0245074909,
0.030082684,
-0.0277199671,
0.0296210852,
0.0277647246,
0.0361771323,
0.0666180402,
-0.030241752,
0.0068368823,
-0.0121344244,
0.0495107025,
0.0388207473,
-0.0349381231,
0.0328567475,
-0.0132986233,
0.038597066,
0.0413250327,
0.0702132583,
0.0044865133,
0.0185951982,
-0.0062383725,
0.0537641421,
-0.0401004702,
-0.0366239585,
0.021411879,
-0.0057106204,
0.0006446163,
-0.0111865532,
0.1318681985,
0.0459930822,
-0.0579714738,
0.0167078059,
-0.0038808302,
0.048514992,
0.0094319871,
0.0539725944,
-0.0644697249,
0.0231163185,
0.0168782845,
0.0420513488,
0.0083061289,
-0.0201041512,
0.0019565655,
-0.1203489602,
0.0366357304,
0.0161643904,
-0.0288475771,
-0.0027538009,
-0.0291012209,
-0.0091266334,
-0.012030784,
0.0241231415,
0.0752762705,
-0.0295527019,
0.0113468198,
0.0028778571,
-0.0185617991,
-0.0170888398,
0.0086247856,
-0.0409268253,
0.0405811742,
0.0549717508,
0.0304183178,
-0.0448941849,
-0.0320677049,
0.0529086553,
-0.0267063193,
-0.054604914,
-0.0012610039,
-0.0070603397,
-0.0043167528,
-0.0055226302,
-0.0201770533,
-0.0040137735,
0.0022702657,
-0.007045594,
-0.0201393664,
0.0139295273,
-0.0017670986,
-0.0092376284,
0.0028320127,
-0.0001101095,
-0.0412843414,
0.0483394936,
-0.016907271,
-0.0102114808,
0.0032242227,
-0.0895843655,
0.036165636,
0.0254103504,
-0.0604549646,
-0.0001993425,
0.0084401993,
-0.0220674239,
-0.0610108413,
-0.0003666448,
-0.0184604935,
0.050044056,
0.0059845061,
0.0594332553,
-0.0449405573,
-0.0231986884,
-0.0203459151,
-0.0216278173,
-0.0171010774,
0.0138024194,
-0.0419251285,
0.0066754925,
0.0683359206,
0.0058653052,
-0.0319759659,
0.0081933849,
-0.0403344072,
-0.0714166611,
0.0133563001,
0.0587392114,
0.0240512621,
0.0138608543,
0.0171292033,
-0.0350902416,
0.0487997569,
0.0366687179,
0.0021398386,
0.0491933785,
-0.0054747178,
-0.0013209376,
-0.0027912692,
0.0216449909,
-0.0638271421,
0.0127446176,
-0.0077723777,
0.0535124242,
-0.0168305766,
-0.033240445,
0.0029451847,
0.031947054,
0.0383441932,
-0.0240860377,
0.0018088099,
-0.0579058155,
0.040773958,
-0.0548841693,
-0.037542481,
-0.0116452351,
0.041709695,
0.0476023294,
0.0081772646,
-0.0040536509,
-0.0204124078,
-0.0001071044,
0.022034578,
-0.0570125245,
-0.0167788994,
-0.0184976645,
-0.0402680635,
0.0140058659,
-0.0072045201,
-0.0129669774,
0.0198132973,
0.034846317,
0.0719731525,
-0.0156317987,
-0.0102232471,
0.0173235107,
-0.0264571421,
-0.0332880467,
0.0955637842,
-0.1104566753,
-0.0117914267,
-0.0338049084,
0.0203462187,
0.0521355644,
0.0099278977,
0.0934512764,
0.0176951904,
0.0076312446,
-0.0180201642,
-0.0388100073,
0.0339398682,
0.0068221563,
-0.0190289617,
0.049558118,
0.0163927767,
0.0595923364,
0.0939930305,
0.0476141237,
-0.0304648224,
0.0315681696,
-0.024730172,
-0.0165847894,
-0.0349352211,
-0.0430195555,
0.0469128601,
-0.0165668037,
-0.0342195518,
-0.0449593551,
-0.0604140237,
0.0150803123,
0.0334406197,
0.0159497783,
-0.0426110029,
-0.0281536113,
0.0935342908,
-0.01724305,
0.0325423963,
-0.0356266499,
-0.0439845696,
0.0156287719,
-0.0702911764,
-0.0188922919,
-6.318606866e-33,
-0.0735191405,
-0.0428317748,
-0.02524901,
-0.0159571376,
-0.0069817989,
-0.0134037361,
0.0040182788,
0.0356375054,
0.0232485328,
-0.0218766127,
-0.0411114506,
0.0108478796,
0.0150043126,
-0.0158197284,
0.0250344742,
-0.0085829124,
0.0028868944,
0.0022648468,
-0.0456947498,
-0.0041881958,
0.0071900752,
0.0237390399,
0.0247854684,
-0.0338084176,
0.0417967252,
-0.0304214209,
-0.0009249389,
-0.0127451466,
-0.0323480032,
0.0374357514,
0.0113625145,
0.0058652754,
0.0272301529,
-0.0649909601,
0.0051610675,
-0.0019499138,
-0.0177585445,
-0.0372699127,
0.0273364168,
-0.0381254889,
-0.0035860362,
0.0109691462,
0.0336459763,
0.0057520489,
-0.0378005505,
-0.0094856583,
0.0180590376,
-0.0024601442,
-0.0395975821,
0.0112101268,
0.013411371,
0.0222729575,
-0.0145441694,
0.0056922296,
0.0054499325,
0.0216150861,
0.0049429312,
0.0354761407,
-0.0349308439,
0.0517469421,
0.010786524,
0.0883515626,
0.0557348058,
0.0209175684,
-0.0261178371,
0.0538309515,
0.0358396731,
-0.0021522224,
0.0307829641,
-0.0530683734,
-0.0164917316,
-0.0089493059,
0.0212580767,
0.0089063188,
-0.0029528239,
0.0269362256,
-0.0722482577,
0.0355640277,
0.0233676676,
-0.0248696618,
0.0358667001,
0.0121105649,
-0.0464497581,
-0.0729136392,
-0.0219041035,
-0.0580080003,
-0.0215556528,
-0.0125697069,
0.0324050561,
0.0034463538,
-0.0593629107,
-0.0244762879,
0.0279136226,
-0.0361527912,
-0.1014598832,
0.020518288,
-0.0224285908,
0.029289674,
-0.0102655794,
0.063380152,
-0.0283460245,
0.0135835679,
-0.009842243,
-0.0141392294,
-0.0185728911,
-0.0017062718,
0.0088723628,
0.0030264589,
-0.0629844144,
0.0057529891,
0.0012325027,
-0.0135345655,
-0.0351269469,
0.0233497415,
-0.0002938345,
-0.0353374593,
0.0186235439,
0.0606451444,
0.0513434112,
-0.0053039771,
-0.0280585568,
0.0309364907,
-0.0079419864,
-0.0165252071,
-0.0203240998,
0.0240954459,
0.0001178672,
0.0650956109,
0.0201020427,
-0.0268548559,
-0.0326455049,
-0.0169019159,
2.668e-7,
0.0481187068,
0.032964237,
-0.0075546042,
0.0396704264,
0.0323883258,
0.0075510102,
-0.0264900513,
0.0589373223,
0.0443046875,
0.0018402636,
0.0132003352,
0.0154064605,
0.0022208223,
0.0152993882,
-0.0768263415,
-0.0263404921,
-0.086144045,
-0.0152725214,
-0.0322855227,
-0.0560918711,
0.0170718953,
0.1003342792,
-0.0134524619,
0.00970631,
-0.032564342,
-0.0401690565,
0.0249644499,
-0.0312486906,
-0.0197127834,
0.0039875233,
0.0537726693,
-0.0139191849,
-0.0257531386,
-0.0096419342,
-0.0005009919,
0.0182791781,
0.0528085083,
0.037856251,
-0.0141004724,
-0.0451269485,
0.023884818,
0.00859561,
0.0272731353,
-0.0695091113,
0.0598969273,
-0.0088237366,
0.0003548793,
-0.0167656355,
-0.0470244102,
-0.021766061,
0.0164558291,
0.0004786073,
-0.0275751557,
0.0418466032,
0.0142708113,
-0.0130503047,
-0.0042213304,
-0.0548140481,
-0.0686523616,
-0.0359629095,
-0.031335067,
-0.0798452646,
0.0079522887,
-0.0224089157,
-0.0159545913,
-0.0402826667,
0.0039443616,
2.84704043e-34,
0.0631477907,
0.0101352455,
0.020450145,
0.0133407805,
0.0388216749,
-0.0260872282,
0.020931771,
0.0095753791,
0.0019541611,
-0.1013511643,
-0.027534971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07710v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07710v2 | A Resilient and Accessible Distribution-Preserving Watermark for Large Language Models | 2023-10-11T17:57:35 | 2024-06-25T07:08:17 | Yihan Wu, Zhengmian Hu, Junfeng Guo, Hongyang Zhang, Heng Huang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Watermarking techniques offer a promising way to identify machine-generated
content via embedding covert information into the contents generated from
language models. A challenge in the domain lies in preserving the distribution
of original generated content after watermarking. Our research extends and
improves upon existing watermarking framework, placing emphasis on the
importance of a \textbf{Di}stribution-\textbf{P}reserving (DiP) watermark.
Contrary to the current strategies, our proposed DiPmark simultaneously
preserves the original token distribution during watermarking
(distribution-preserving), is detectable without access to the language model
API and prompts (accessible), and is provably robust to moderate changes of
tokens (resilient). DiPmark operates by selecting a random set of tokens prior
to the generation of a word, then modifying the token distribution through a
distribution-preserving reweight function to enhance the probability of these
selected tokens during the sampling process. Extensive empirical evaluation on
various language models and tasks demonstrates our approach's
distribution-preserving property, accessibility, and resilience, making it a
effective solution for watermarking tasks that demand impeccable quality
preservation. | [
0.0239568837,
0.0882271007,
-0.0149459625,
0.0251926221,
-0.0376827233,
-0.0104199024,
0.0008029427,
0.0543810204,
-0.0246262457,
-0.0263585486,
-0.0109529914,
0.0200587362,
0.0067240847,
0.0457551293,
0.0561987124,
-0.0200083144,
0.0143321026,
-0.0094776731,
0.0088027455,
-0.0044257841,
0.0047478881,
-0.0052195014,
0.0565663688,
0.014251045,
-0.0446329974,
-0.0086185867,
0.0262585469,
0.0360119231,
-0.021363806,
-0.0069253156,
-0.0381753854,
0.0739471018,
0.0017845335,
0.0798883364,
0.0000020697,
-0.0211457293,
-0.0511728711,
0.0392684154,
-0.0470335931,
0.0236586668,
0.05239667,
0.0018305198,
-0.0575944036,
0.017949244,
-0.0090014627,
0.0548229069,
0.078574881,
0.0145285986,
0.0556178987,
0.021762168,
-0.0200686622,
0.0311634149,
0.0286222398,
-0.0071122069,
0.0189571641,
0.02154346,
0.0128699094,
0.0165974945,
-0.009714135,
0.0167519785,
-0.0097381379,
0.0651243627,
0.0104382867,
-0.0590556487,
-0.0312897563,
0.0088467654,
-0.0298948213,
-0.0103881275,
-0.0022424583,
0.0154985292,
-0.0570328459,
-0.0416856334,
0.0044222958,
-0.0149069754,
0.022286633,
0.0416265279,
-0.038803339,
0.0207893569,
0.0271466076,
0.0371643081,
0.0079694083,
-0.0035342011,
0.0449792631,
0.00635244,
0.0104888836,
0.0553178191,
0.0589989088,
0.0165577624,
-0.0756666735,
0.0071393456,
-0.0296965744,
-0.0748914406,
0.0693385825,
-0.0086703245,
0.0438414291,
0.0042084241,
-0.1119786277,
-0.0798462257,
0.0136982724,
-0.0074092327,
0.0657086745,
0.010667529,
-0.036883153,
0.0324958563,
-0.0610775985,
0.0596176982,
-0.0287056584,
0.0387492441,
0.012986023,
-0.0033267085,
0.02609271,
-0.0473299958,
-0.0244537257,
0.034126427,
-0.0345576182,
-0.0310371947,
-0.0095731774,
0.0730980113,
-0.0069632251,
0.0076371268,
-0.0091434056,
-0.0345399641,
-0.0224642623,
0.0016917775,
0.0505063534,
-0.0249055456,
0.009713619,
-0.0086189602,
-0.0007013459,
-0.0392128043,
-0.0183956176,
0.0333872102,
0.0074617206,
0.0071717538,
-0.0168084819,
0.0895888656,
0.0249005072,
-0.0245766472,
-0.0166231971,
-0.0462162867,
-0.0168246385,
0.0149300825,
-0.0023174996,
-0.0663780794,
-0.0106770005,
-0.0158236641,
0.0026385605,
-0.0896913186,
0.0177633483,
0.0289233774,
-0.0093505029,
0.0422029868,
-0.0157005731,
-0.0220640991,
0.0059327241,
-0.0062042898,
-0.0351000726,
0.0659992546,
0.0442280173,
0.0299965236,
0.0831323043,
0.0113197714,
0.0250722673,
0.054542724,
0.0220904443,
0.0478261188,
-0.0389913023,
-0.0565688051,
0.0584662668,
-0.0388449021,
0.0452221297,
0.0498512536,
-0.0026026685,
-0.0556202978,
0.0702562109,
0.065040715,
-0.0489194766,
-0.0266700611,
-0.0098674577,
-0.011070624,
-0.0196079612,
0.0125082089,
-0.0252488256,
-0.0140740983,
0.0008734798,
-0.0325567462,
0.0306298621,
-0.0179976225,
0.0061480035,
0.0187545419,
-0.0160028152,
-0.0327365771,
0.0250313953,
-0.0211791117,
0.0201575458,
0.055447761,
0.0065568597,
0.0534757413,
-0.0049654171,
-0.0114236111,
0.0513393842,
-0.0944294557,
0.0374082811,
0.0369271338,
0.092700772,
-0.0242957249,
0.0892509446,
0.0085686548,
-0.0019950522,
0.057532791,
-0.0354238674,
-0.0171279516,
0.0021163505,
0.0025399784,
-0.0287892763,
-0.0195407774,
0.0161332823,
0.03331827,
0.0269336328,
0.0478831008,
0.0287706591,
-0.0903160945,
0.0013622732,
0.0213753637,
0.0239287093,
-0.0225444399,
0.0116082579,
-0.0283738803,
0.0118227843,
0.0226853024,
-0.0252443366,
0.0448159426,
0.0124381036,
-0.0111674611,
-0.0097546857,
-0.0442618579,
0.0188103039,
0.0215309616,
0.027762888,
-0.0309522487,
0.0019380205,
0.0206119809,
0.0059873918,
-0.021512486,
0.0257837251,
-0.0399313457,
0.0614477322,
-0.0518656187,
0.0298272241,
-0.004040027,
0.0422918983,
-0.0277630333,
0.0132389972,
-0.0086535048,
-0.0048609516,
0.0101266317,
0.0393970422,
-0.0013424238,
-0.0098527288,
-0.0187289678,
0.0014119473,
-0.0364451148,
0.0125468429,
0.0150929419,
0.0025554048,
0.0161963236,
-0.029350847,
-0.011671192,
0.0062976009,
-0.0233126432,
0.0285613257,
0.0134952916,
0.0226837602,
-0.0023502072,
-0.0135495886,
-0.0346626267,
-0.0741065815,
0.0218565445,
0.0363575593,
0.0168362428,
-0.0345006175,
-0.0008080585,
0.0069543836,
-0.0166403428,
0.037208695,
0.0499682352,
-0.0021362395,
-0.0256420095,
-0.0627504736,
0.0081868554,
-0.0399900265,
-0.0089548975,
0.0085485298,
-0.0129971001,
-0.0035990279,
-0.0024892895,
0.0216447227,
0.0453788117,
0.0036260423,
-0.0014685359,
0.0219529662,
0.0174244493,
-0.0298890155,
-0.0441984236,
-0.0251281485,
-0.0054221353,
0.0308048278,
-0.026836317,
0.031647332,
0.0056779743,
0.0102606257,
-0.0023707631,
-0.0065439795,
0.0385301299,
-0.0244232677,
-0.0177682098,
-0.0087487921,
-0.0304696169,
-0.0422475263,
0.005234322,
-0.0296069942,
-0.0595312007,
0.0208938085,
-0.0525480807,
0.0208712574,
-0.0032451719,
-0.0055727512,
0.0220593512,
0.0243942887,
-0.0100399274,
0.0261406694,
0.0003778668,
-0.0377439186,
-0.0269773658,
0.0099426219,
0.0605955496,
-0.0632354245,
-0.0298877452,
-0.0387079082,
-0.0188788455,
-0.0037774774,
-0.0108828694,
-0.0399043672,
-0.0380489528,
0.0286966581,
0.0198977999,
0.0437643155,
-0.0360545963,
0.0116443234,
0.0368378982,
0.0404365994,
0.0407587886,
-0.0257181674,
0.0123683484,
-0.0255663805,
0.0682456642,
0.0097051691,
-0.0567000173,
0.0256141778,
-0.0153889097,
-0.0576606691,
0.0695522428,
0.0350312144,
0.0043509207,
0.059744902,
0.019723475,
0.0434126332,
0.0257699788,
-0.0139408614,
0.0090716314,
0.0357911102,
-0.025941899,
0.0011438209,
0.0604956783,
0.0366741419,
-0.0364549495,
0.0140890498,
-0.0076945466,
0.0357606746,
0.0020795101,
-0.0189661868,
-0.1091111824,
0.0005535606,
0.049064707,
0.0314610153,
-0.0331888236,
-0.0153638255,
-0.029720407,
-0.0796661824,
0.0294430275,
0.0186786316,
-0.0211804714,
-0.0267521068,
-0.0679461658,
0.0074685826,
0.0555548556,
-0.0047234176,
-0.0494532771,
0.0430956185,
-0.0073036049,
0.016619198,
0.0095312474,
-0.0576701276,
-0.0293854363,
-0.02568697,
0.0068218308,
0.0772551745,
0.0256019179,
-0.0082603479,
-0.0301735569,
0.0289186928,
-0.0251531899,
-0.0449614823,
-0.0139539437,
0.0326156318,
-0.0111134723,
-0.0371271409,
-0.016179651,
0.0139354961,
0.0192519054,
-0.0567657277,
-0.0354073644,
0.0441695303,
0.0110943355,
-0.0147757838,
-0.0115602678,
-0.0740159974,
0.0594024733,
0.0660834536,
0.0404636003,
-0.0516021661,
-0.002650277,
-0.0666081831,
0.0404487811,
-0.0189436916,
0.0120335901,
-0.0086541753,
-0.0241359659,
-0.0661413595,
-0.0882642195,
0.0381117351,
-0.0484207384,
0.0365002565,
0.0442277603,
0.0179131627,
-0.0013642217,
-0.0446017981,
-0.0617412664,
-0.0259826574,
-0.1069371775,
0.0308382567,
-0.0629137084,
-0.0168769062,
-0.0200637467,
-0.0313311592,
-0.0317217298,
0.038581498,
-0.0720716566,
-0.062679559,
0.0394133702,
0.0344403908,
0.0274466053,
-0.0152692897,
-0.0291889105,
-0.0376731269,
0.0841884986,
0.0286812708,
0.0021891876,
0.017139852,
0.0343919843,
-0.0534761436,
-0.0027599446,
0.025210334,
-0.0886185616,
0.0030467464,
0.0787538216,
-0.0043312111,
0.0039515444,
-0.0104535297,
-0.0006926969,
0.0373442508,
-0.0060567544,
-0.0309897847,
0.0172291677,
-0.005931179,
-0.0067144395,
-0.0358221941,
-0.0174132697,
-0.0331338942,
0.0239662025,
0.0124590266,
-0.0283020884,
0.0048790588,
-0.0031249058,
-0.0162289795,
0.0393046588,
-0.0046505514,
-0.0074554449,
-0.0196299478,
0.0263868626,
0.0368283652,
0.0134873698,
0.0199431051,
0.0418874137,
0.0058399141,
0.0276077148,
-0.0344066359,
0.0100654773,
0.026390519,
-0.0286083799,
-0.0228619557,
0.0598733537,
-0.0520446524,
-0.0008753149,
-0.0237201266,
0.0525258332,
0.0336454809,
0.0136117935,
0.002232875,
-0.0426395722,
-0.0142143453,
-0.0384854041,
0.0095297582,
0.0255890656,
-0.0458733961,
-0.0250969958,
-0.0169949848,
-0.0307030194,
0.0218777321,
0.0343307257,
0.0158498418,
0.0298767481,
-0.043453224,
-0.0366438851,
-0.0292778406,
0.0026571811,
0.0262486637,
0.0032642835,
-0.0348100327,
-0.013589602,
-0.0631589517,
-0.0863075703,
0.0063152425,
0.002427028,
0.0147382347,
0.0196954738,
-0.0384900197,
0.0451837778,
-0.0011108099,
0.0176226273,
-0.0449187458,
0.0331436209,
0.0285189599,
-0.0366869234,
0.0296284109,
-6.016851221e-33,
-0.001583019,
-0.0323409103,
-0.0687224939,
-0.0154395383,
0.0323572643,
0.0692210272,
-0.0437493362,
-0.0223520026,
0.0266903155,
-0.0101673529,
-0.022436399,
-0.0122834193,
0.0211548191,
-0.0039203372,
-0.040258497,
0.0102821467,
0.0406861007,
0.0206152927,
-0.0565304607,
0.0196096599,
0.0485983044,
-0.0306110382,
0.0192810893,
-0.0210692659,
0.0263901055,
-0.0333853364,
-0.0194773432,
-0.0247579291,
0.0140525596,
0.0650304258,
-0.0081427125,
0.0186720882,
-0.021738641,
-0.0104733193,
-0.0560767204,
0.041217085,
-0.025342444,
-0.028238479,
0.0066333106,
0.0221589319,
0.0036869871,
-0.0563198403,
0.0214349851,
-0.0225022677,
-0.0117375748,
0.0515833609,
-0.0100403894,
0.0011829776,
-0.025722146,
-0.0150796091,
-0.0117699811,
0.0146335969,
0.0074888361,
-0.0071469289,
0.0310001597,
-0.044362139,
0.0462224446,
0.006632077,
-0.0618080013,
0.0306271203,
-0.0184198767,
0.004717866,
0.0431269109,
0.0261886269,
0.0073692123,
0.0420451686,
-0.0213899612,
0.0057489383,
0.0455913618,
-0.0344146341,
0.0350716747,
-0.0293064602,
0.049288027,
0.044166822,
0.0584937446,
-0.0412757806,
-0.0026288091,
0.0384831429,
-0.0276456717,
-0.0407348573,
0.0532671809,
0.0280005075,
-0.013070805,
0.0033532204,
-0.0584401973,
-0.0790806562,
-0.007680499,
-0.0131565481,
0.0258793887,
0.0184397679,
-0.0659570098,
0.0037860919,
0.0403293781,
-0.0508647487,
-0.0777527094,
0.0187908225,
-0.0034354047,
0.0259344112,
-0.014765407,
0.0263665542,
0.0375644937,
0.0218006857,
0.0565699041,
-0.0375655554,
0.0004883182,
0.0086006196,
0.0336655192,
0.0283443294,
-0.0669037923,
0.0184946116,
-0.0126609681,
0.0144990012,
0.0315949842,
0.0117346914,
0.0329392254,
-0.0178985149,
0.0221338067,
-0.075774014,
0.0549949408,
-0.0090927631,
-0.0079379166,
0.0462803133,
-0.0329415277,
0.0167305879,
-0.03897091,
0.0125170927,
-0.0245009959,
0.0947241262,
0.0559108816,
-0.0456837043,
-0.0113012781,
-0.0309920684,
2.657e-7,
0.0617724545,
0.0143120578,
0.0480082072,
-0.0093222391,
0.0430338942,
0.0118557466,
0.0118692508,
0.0172127597,
-0.0135885412,
-0.0158461109,
-0.0476741754,
-0.0076506524,
0.0486564413,
0.0051064547,
-0.0915851593,
0.0434539244,
-0.0383194908,
0.0279038474,
-0.0370312035,
-0.0123331519,
0.0207409002,
0.0908302218,
0.0325470604,
-0.0364612862,
-0.0010885724,
-0.0562837012,
0.019350728,
-0.0053525455,
0.0220327023,
-0.0365285166,
-0.0105288615,
0.0201984197,
0.0411290042,
0.0082205059,
-0.0730709732,
-0.0202578902,
0.0318897665,
0.0466222949,
-0.0139095001,
0.0178667344,
-0.0449457355,
-0.0252738446,
0.0076540168,
-0.0573836379,
0.0491131432,
0.0706170648,
-0.0133295665,
-0.0922377035,
-0.0445687808,
-0.05311694,
0.0327196158,
-0.0323481783,
-0.0570692569,
0.0408551358,
0.0013801751,
0.0649109706,
-0.023156913,
-0.0494483337,
-0.0510103367,
-0.0822770894,
-0.0282729976,
-0.028460037,
-0.0562862232,
-0.0368756689,
0.0293145906,
-0.0575211383,
0.0424196646,
2.838752506e-34,
0.0128181111,
-0.0481802374,
-0.0103580235,
0.0432660133,
0.0272961576,
0.0110554714,
0.0299530644,
0.0259423237,
0.002017183,
-0.0186657347,
-0.0203174967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07707v1 | MatFormer: Nested Transformer for Elastic Inference | 2023-10-11T17:57:14 | 2023-10-11T17:57:14 | Devvrit, Sneha Kudugunta, Aditya Kusupati, Tim Dettmers, Kaifeng Chen, Inderjit Dhillon, Yulia Tsvetkov, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Sham Kakade, Ali Farhadi, Prateek Jain | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Transformer models are deployed in a wide range of settings, from
multi-accelerator clusters to standalone mobile phones. The diverse inference
constraints in these scenarios necessitate practitioners to train foundation
models such as PaLM 2, Llama, & ViTs as a series of models of varying sizes.
Due to significant training costs, only a select few model sizes are trained
and supported, limiting more fine-grained control over relevant tradeoffs,
including latency, cost, and accuracy. This work introduces MatFormer, a nested
Transformer architecture designed to offer elasticity in a variety of
deployment constraints. Each Feed Forward Network (FFN) block of a MatFormer
model is jointly optimized with a few nested smaller FFN blocks. This training
procedure allows for the Mix'n'Match of model granularities across layers --
i.e., a trained universal MatFormer model enables extraction of hundreds of
accurate smaller models, which were never explicitly optimized. We empirically
demonstrate MatFormer's effectiveness across different model classes (decoders
& encoders), modalities (language & vision), and scales (up to 2.6B
parameters). We find that a 2.6B decoder-only MatFormer language model (MatLM)
allows us to extract smaller models spanning from 1.5B to 2.6B, each exhibiting
comparable validation loss and one-shot downstream evaluations to their
independently trained counterparts. Furthermore, we observe that smaller
encoders extracted from a universal MatFormer-based ViT (MatViT) encoder
preserve the metric-space structure for adaptive large-scale retrieval.
Finally, we showcase that speculative decoding with the accurate and consistent
submodels extracted from MatFormer can further reduce inference latency. | [
0.0107960543,
0.062199384,
0.0028035527,
0.0371788591,
0.0289012603,
0.0118806167,
0.0444725454,
0.006225077,
-0.0487416051,
0.0004903831,
-0.0179231111,
-0.0262102857,
0.0109071834,
0.0223034304,
0.0073472857,
-0.0153663205,
0.0133362198,
0.001338965,
-0.0285186339,
-0.0163235534,
-0.0052619432,
0.017620312,
0.0363994986,
0.0650441125,
-0.0155366268,
0.0223183855,
-0.0346423723,
0.0568411835,
-0.0081882728,
0.0046735648,
0.0207244083,
0.0080746077,
0.0445884652,
0.0507497527,
0.0000021393,
0.0361999758,
-0.0063880612,
-0.0020320106,
-0.0370923504,
0.0416882485,
0.0407330282,
-0.0300718807,
-0.0335259959,
0.0170947686,
0.0197457168,
-0.0899571925,
0.0987835377,
-0.0124123991,
0.0204600524,
0.0415800437,
0.0042261528,
-0.0580945276,
0.0483354889,
-0.0296710394,
-0.0524522923,
-0.0179394446,
0.0020221649,
-0.0079273647,
-0.0229754616,
0.0072329934,
0.0040218094,
0.0482519045,
0.0689195544,
0.0467964411,
-0.0013180312,
0.0287617985,
-0.0366274118,
-0.0412785783,
-0.0044671306,
0.0136225568,
-0.0275640469,
-0.050519608,
-0.0254000518,
-0.0140523305,
-0.0426744297,
-0.0060856622,
-0.0187819302,
0.0288605448,
-0.0144708939,
0.0177652128,
-0.0240743514,
0.0163066573,
0.0516896769,
-0.0049281027,
-0.0600974485,
0.0044301017,
0.0283255894,
0.0005690088,
-0.031512253,
0.0015240806,
-0.01129256,
0.0006757832,
0.0409778468,
-0.0089418935,
0.0057121739,
-0.0117748445,
-0.0246606171,
-0.0868146792,
-0.0340366326,
-0.0394409299,
0.0548747294,
0.0501800738,
-0.0051670866,
0.0092488555,
-0.0494819544,
0.0255895872,
-0.0658292174,
-0.00062325,
-0.0646531731,
-0.0349725299,
-0.0092533743,
-0.0407114662,
-0.0368439853,
0.0019135835,
-0.0741673931,
-0.0209866744,
-0.0066562351,
-0.010023728,
0.0010017332,
-0.0371084064,
-0.001714576,
0.0404972099,
-0.059596166,
-0.0193617623,
0.0354212672,
0.071329698,
0.0091219526,
0.0202537701,
0.0354049392,
-0.1225639954,
-0.0088217314,
0.0172134805,
-0.0067406893,
-0.0092033837,
0.0392053612,
0.0608536936,
-0.02517852,
-0.0378149226,
-0.0189904775,
0.0093686152,
0.0127452556,
-0.0121209379,
0.0343490466,
-0.0553319901,
0.0470982268,
-0.009590718,
0.0280685909,
-0.0167039968,
0.0120666549,
0.0182745364,
-0.0164208133,
0.0399830937,
0.0182900783,
-0.0070836474,
0.0556967184,
-0.0059559215,
0.0147925466,
0.0750035346,
0.0338862985,
0.0530547202,
0.0243456792,
-0.009190225,
-0.0231181961,
0.0574321449,
0.0269738659,
0.0122930575,
-0.0372876152,
-0.0292627718,
-0.0153542571,
0.0119625544,
0.0282696113,
0.034214057,
-0.0458271354,
-0.0284130704,
0.0394747108,
0.0618587472,
0.0210582111,
0.0235473253,
0.0183014553,
-0.0098533137,
-0.0172323976,
-0.0408118851,
-0.0189393107,
0.0238369387,
0.0003510049,
-0.0296046678,
0.0315797403,
0.0692137182,
-0.0540475063,
-0.0064084241,
0.0001185557,
-0.0044696322,
-0.0025590672,
0.0112928869,
0.0563089065,
-0.0032014032,
-0.0200869236,
0.1227536276,
0.0197541825,
-0.0393803567,
-0.0272645745,
-0.0599029511,
0.0024373387,
-0.006189419,
0.0389134176,
0.0184059329,
-0.0046655554,
0.0522214398,
-0.0302451085,
0.0031056455,
0.004323639,
-0.0176787786,
0.0404246934,
-0.0674774125,
-0.0040001478,
0.0255608484,
0.0185006373,
0.0235617068,
0.0169132408,
-0.0043363129,
0.0244403668,
-0.0251263361,
-0.0206561256,
0.0187331084,
-0.0098647121,
-0.0069043525,
0.0565531254,
0.0069431183,
0.0217338372,
-0.0098240236,
-0.0146683296,
-0.0158726778,
0.0260441396,
-0.0430884995,
0.0193868466,
-0.0202536061,
-0.0636765361,
-0.0160521362,
0.0002916865,
-0.0180388633,
0.0469942279,
0.0502090193,
-0.0163304955,
-0.0399162732,
0.0273297671,
-0.0320545211,
0.0489651114,
-0.0390319638,
0.023870239,
-0.0238340441,
0.0090709198,
0.020132605,
0.0065195286,
-0.0250176974,
-0.0108073615,
-0.0064549581,
-0.0339557528,
0.0259843115,
-0.0161402915,
-0.0107988864,
0.0350454599,
-0.0174135976,
0.0167142879,
-0.0011832346,
-0.0200219136,
0.0209939536,
-0.0317066461,
-0.0671622902,
0.0056770765,
-0.0519415885,
0.0093802698,
0.031762328,
0.0565325618,
0.0257420279,
-0.0157366917,
0.009923487,
0.0222916789,
-0.0028117152,
0.0302796625,
-0.0520225056,
0.0145055223,
-0.0381538682,
-0.0118229901,
-0.0723480061,
0.0176810138,
0.0715023205,
-0.0204381999,
-0.0310414843,
-0.0498719215,
-0.0573549084,
0.0311201308,
0.0224370584,
-0.0348648243,
-0.0444686413,
0.02069363,
-0.0258631855,
-0.0134957228,
0.0892698616,
-0.0023124372,
0.0267155953,
0.0304052737,
0.0185913425,
-0.0620517768,
-0.0077036326,
-0.0256360788,
-0.0497684665,
-0.0397190787,
0.0014324072,
-0.0180166587,
0.0694571435,
-0.0199762862,
0.0229624137,
-0.07295423,
-0.051800143,
0.0240388773,
-0.0382225625,
-0.023277862,
-0.0149677796,
-0.0108595239,
0.0501784347,
-0.0276874397,
-0.0485849306,
0.0367990285,
-0.0348915346,
-0.0184807796,
0.0044457968,
-0.0160346571,
-0.01136648,
0.0339305252,
0.0243262537,
0.0292024612,
-0.011110615,
-0.0218447242,
-0.0314588137,
0.0316365473,
-0.0031224296,
-0.0289066173,
0.0443482324,
-0.0218923669,
-0.0122725945,
-0.0421782918,
-0.0682636648,
-0.0016131619,
0.0109902862,
-0.0266169347,
0.0254750568,
-0.0029887331,
-0.0125286747,
-0.0769376829,
0.0239316318,
-0.0009428441,
0.070135206,
-0.0104521746,
-0.0022482125,
-0.0315597989,
0.039090801,
-0.0181465894,
0.009966909,
0.0448195338,
-0.0519425571,
-0.0074930876,
0.058083836,
0.0116909398,
0.0158655141,
-0.0832353309,
0.0110204155,
0.0589031316,
0.0389153585,
-0.0174199548,
0.0341857448,
0.0765057951,
-0.0864986405,
-0.0120039927,
0.0476532131,
-0.0276387576,
-0.0649424791,
-0.0157507341,
0.0156998057,
0.0599809699,
0.0128228189,
0.0404846743,
-0.0466651246,
-0.034225896,
0.0275135934,
0.0340551101,
0.0241409782,
0.0353840105,
0.0143608106,
-0.0962703675,
0.0623039417,
0.0265139453,
0.0049629798,
-0.0600922555,
-0.0136815328,
-0.0420726128,
-0.0193793662,
0.0173618272,
0.0341787674,
-0.0054492126,
-0.0097508412,
0.0245694183,
-0.0026386185,
-0.0431015752,
0.0196822789,
-0.0221849661,
0.0004704588,
0.0221860297,
-0.0608531944,
-0.0053890864,
-0.0491412319,
0.0324077979,
-0.0216497947,
0.0188556425,
0.0131130759,
0.0136822667,
-0.0122195687,
-0.0034750171,
-0.0013518131,
0.0223764796,
-0.0104632722,
-0.0162623692,
-0.035518758,
0.0765207261,
-0.0028299266,
-0.0015261781,
-0.0195768904,
-0.0646262765,
-0.035494253,
0.0256712139,
0.0265726671,
-0.0077783084,
-0.0302679725,
-0.0201054644,
-0.0057351924,
-0.0030115501,
-0.0333220623,
0.0477720127,
0.0304052811,
-0.0909216329,
0.0055059358,
0.0229200702,
-0.0123880897,
0.0474998914,
-0.0096697584,
-0.0738666728,
0.0635065436,
0.0105176568,
-0.0665313378,
0.0319703259,
-0.0157263912,
0.0253593102,
-0.0471283533,
0.0416132174,
0.0353535786,
-0.0256974362,
-0.0163573716,
-0.0026368792,
-0.081861034,
-0.0419308729,
-0.01272137,
0.0198232029,
0.0225866009,
0.0628794581,
-0.0117510529,
-0.0515198298,
0.0406813771,
0.0258623287,
-0.0637891963,
0.0271459259,
0.0401998833,
-0.0927019119,
-0.0170089919,
0.0281999856,
-0.0468278006,
0.0398106873,
-0.0056892028,
0.0132663539,
-0.024672756,
-0.0512161441,
0.0216184352,
-0.0244687572,
0.0632529035,
-0.0067670117,
-0.0036481719,
-0.0154010579,
0.0428290665,
0.0392882228,
0.0274664182,
-0.0298335552,
-0.0096905353,
0.0141680362,
0.0214900691,
0.0235815439,
-0.0012906736,
0.0886004195,
0.019293027,
0.010143375,
0.0156990401,
0.0024336635,
0.0205432083,
0.0201613046,
-0.0021676566,
-0.0232949816,
-0.010648354,
-0.0094976854,
0.0486225076,
-0.0593195707,
0.034139201,
0.0177606307,
0.0123386988,
-0.0541008562,
0.0291970056,
-0.0324205644,
-0.0590777509,
-0.0650838241,
-0.0384109169,
0.0151930163,
-0.0069538248,
0.0228680465,
-0.0102277528,
-0.0209571533,
-0.038075719,
0.0108542852,
-0.0269043539,
-0.0149404583,
0.0732727274,
0.0184524488,
0.0064105582,
0.0111861704,
0.0103260139,
0.0152331339,
0.0358400568,
-0.0383649506,
0.0117185134,
-0.0067370683,
-0.0301028751,
0.0038996865,
0.0162152015,
-0.0212644804,
-0.009094811,
0.0085703656,
-0.0462584943,
-0.0083292508,
0.015408135,
0.00245491,
-0.0414259955,
0.0213728659,
0.0480767712,
0.0141874794,
-0.0143536199,
0.0115966955,
-0.0296361893,
-0.0101663526,
0.0085248286,
0.0000146811,
-7.032155447e-33,
0.0039273459,
0.0592436083,
0.010843114,
-0.0049233288,
-0.0222083293,
0.028526023,
-0.0178925265,
0.0017337714,
-0.0554050952,
-0.012780251,
-0.0232758932,
0.0134025319,
0.0165133849,
0.0461892784,
0.0158838481,
0.0206165202,
0.0538821518,
-0.0253516138,
-0.0009239092,
0.0224906523,
0.0312661901,
0.0270638,
0.0382774919,
-0.0469565019,
-0.0948450044,
0.0132150929,
0.0129942307,
-0.0014729213,
-0.0170176737,
0.0465811007,
-0.0324865654,
0.014541938,
-0.0004067135,
-0.0545961075,
-0.0143450927,
0.0012001254,
-0.0891244039,
0.0280432273,
-0.0313299596,
0.0560379885,
-0.0159803499,
-0.0198173057,
0.0412041545,
0.0328636467,
-0.0351684801,
-0.0413395986,
0.0086374246,
-0.0256841052,
-0.0342720672,
-0.0330338925,
0.0246546082,
0.0273464993,
0.023458926,
0.0095004654,
0.0468117259,
0.0285804924,
-0.0433580726,
0.0482068993,
-0.0603892393,
-0.0043217982,
-0.0100197122,
0.0433062501,
0.0465580784,
0.0533425473,
0.0117235901,
0.0599392727,
0.0289120153,
-0.0510840602,
-0.0581355058,
-0.0002945463,
0.020584831,
0.0698536932,
0.0381111652,
0.0329062007,
0.0703120157,
-0.0522577539,
-0.0512023754,
-0.0063960766,
0.0112498319,
0.0466553867,
0.0394448154,
0.0398586728,
-0.0028546413,
-0.0319859385,
-0.0261967015,
-0.0530844517,
-0.0293464698,
-0.0093007507,
0.0178312231,
0.0424804576,
-0.016279621,
0.00586341,
0.0618530735,
-0.0573079176,
0.0446751527,
0.0162258539,
-0.0053063785,
0.0484010838,
0.0054708323,
0.0406166837,
-0.0465859957,
-0.0296020545,
0.030458888,
0.0104075195,
0.0124890255,
-0.0008793332,
0.0069581647,
0.0484812409,
-0.0594711602,
-0.0178306364,
-0.0439835563,
-0.0157019794,
0.0125971539,
0.0289056823,
0.0600094907,
0.0230264161,
0.0075774286,
0.0326243713,
-0.0597190745,
0.026891768,
-0.0183504298,
-0.0239556469,
0.0479127243,
0.0349897891,
-0.0323224962,
0.0144414008,
-0.1011710986,
0.0006812254,
0.0345497243,
-0.0472450182,
-0.0259062089,
0.0950436071,
2.966e-7,
0.0044293972,
-0.0143367313,
0.0458899587,
-0.0515219904,
0.0380314216,
0.0460586734,
0.029106278,
0.0126466108,
0.0274334718,
-0.0475437865,
-0.0110341171,
0.0268064458,
0.080705747,
0.0082545578,
-0.0377901345,
0.021019293,
-0.1038772985,
0.0391987823,
-0.0094095496,
-0.0489605702,
0.0155078638,
0.1432724595,
-0.0148577169,
-0.0229666904,
0.0434740521,
0.014525759,
0.056417305,
0.0090485355,
0.0346867144,
-0.0188710615,
-0.0335194655,
0.0474586152,
-0.0273294263,
0.0005922292,
0.0152363693,
0.006680076,
-0.0184320826,
0.0642220899,
-0.0074443361,
-0.0098252101,
0.0330850445,
0.005198027,
-0.0579713881,
-0.045754455,
0.0615597442,
-0.0340785794,
-0.0222291648,
-0.048699148,
-0.0528629199,
0.0033221031,
-0.0390722975,
-0.009754288,
0.0245556105,
0.0160744935,
0.0074034454,
-0.0221770965,
-0.018952556,
-0.0866106451,
0.0169980619,
0.0125448331,
-0.0614751242,
-0.0200030711,
-0.0643395036,
0.0012929428,
0.062428195,
0.0107239587,
-0.0113256667,
2.859312407e-34,
0.005688027,
-0.0025175784,
0.0243840404,
0.0539899208,
-0.0133745745,
-0.0576211922,
0.0045981058,
0.0113792093,
-0.0258648507,
-0.0942750648,
-0.0350931734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07704v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07704v1 | Ferret: Refer and Ground Anything Anywhere at Any Granularity | 2023-10-11T17:55:15 | 2023-10-11T17:55:15 | Haoxuan You, Haotian Zhang, Zhe Gan, Xianzhi Du, Bowen Zhang, Zirui Wang, Liangliang Cao, Shih-Fu Chang, Yinfei Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce Ferret, a new Multimodal Large Language Model (MLLM) capable of
understanding spatial referring of any shape or granularity within an image and
accurately grounding open-vocabulary descriptions. To unify referring and
grounding in the LLM paradigm, Ferret employs a novel and powerful hybrid
region representation that integrates discrete coordinates and continuous
features jointly to represent a region in the image. To extract the continuous
features of versatile regions, we propose a spatial-aware visual sampler, adept
at handling varying sparsity across different shapes. Consequently, Ferret can
accept diverse region inputs, such as points, bounding boxes, and free-form
shapes. To bolster the desired capability of Ferret, we curate GRIT, a
comprehensive refer-and-ground instruction tuning dataset including 1.1M
samples that contain rich hierarchical spatial knowledge, with 95K hard
negative data to promote model robustness. The resulting model not only
achieves superior performance in classical referring and grounding tasks, but
also greatly outperforms existing MLLMs in region-based and
localization-demanded multimodal chatting. Our evaluations also reveal a
significantly improved capability of describing image details and a remarkable
alleviation in object hallucination. Code and data will be available at
https://github.com/apple/ml-ferret | [
0.0234912783,
0.0110001834,
0.0170456786,
0.0279403049,
-0.0215785913,
0.0090132905,
0.0043478985,
-0.0244284682,
-0.005879513,
-0.0758795738,
-0.0689288899,
-0.0096608633,
0.0169214904,
0.0421553515,
0.0446196832,
-0.089804776,
0.0145830046,
-0.0416376479,
-0.0645059347,
-0.0029819573,
0.0123648113,
0.0286437944,
-0.0287299082,
0.0455837213,
-0.0672057569,
0.0002283707,
-0.0316208601,
0.0070517659,
0.0015664247,
-0.0507066548,
-0.0228939708,
0.0318080001,
0.0378788486,
-0.0180177391,
0.0000022095,
0.0080159996,
0.0220175032,
-0.0117702531,
0.0621514916,
-0.0176469292,
0.0119099002,
-0.0596266501,
0.005087351,
-0.0243544132,
-0.0150699634,
-0.029798843,
0.0914942846,
0.0644625276,
0.0794306621,
0.0298789293,
-0.0241680928,
-0.0535727255,
0.0271673519,
-0.0041915006,
0.0598082468,
-0.0241562314,
-0.0017651216,
0.0311990809,
-0.0028244609,
0.0380319953,
-0.0583615415,
0.0200205315,
0.034989547,
-0.02720787,
0.0323249847,
0.0384103693,
-0.0333477668,
-0.025224274,
-0.0034135203,
0.0809351355,
-0.0284363572,
-0.0290190428,
-0.0012187706,
0.0302854646,
-0.0116262482,
0.0025258807,
-0.0525174066,
0.0344024599,
-0.0233172514,
0.0265184026,
-0.0892662629,
-0.0045100031,
0.0176097043,
-0.0078189438,
-0.0282504279,
0.0156135876,
0.0006011785,
-0.0055036391,
-0.0090598175,
0.001391818,
-0.0346793793,
-0.0635771975,
0.0254096258,
0.0253968891,
-0.0284147356,
-0.0206295513,
-0.0466672592,
0.0116400542,
0.0142106181,
-0.0184316821,
0.0063798325,
-0.0307293441,
-0.0858797282,
0.0709946454,
-0.0235116035,
0.0001576151,
-0.0294363312,
0.0387488976,
0.0019463513,
-0.0238963533,
-0.0340210795,
0.0159841422,
-0.0534390546,
0.0164490975,
-0.0552898012,
-0.0659519061,
0.0190449711,
0.0042500654,
-0.057078816,
-0.0054362607,
-0.0187847484,
0.046198424,
-0.0035196685,
-0.0044510309,
-0.0037098737,
0.0094760498,
-0.021148609,
0.0028960924,
-0.0197222885,
-0.0425699167,
-0.0218233448,
0.0449269004,
0.0270074867,
-0.0289497208,
-0.0391958058,
0.0802585334,
-0.0054252082,
-0.0313245282,
-0.0054173241,
-0.0229547154,
-0.0324711651,
-0.044075083,
0.0502012707,
-0.0483425781,
0.00198716,
-0.0159965605,
0.0165710002,
-0.0317740813,
0.0281949118,
0.0171484444,
-0.0236634035,
0.0833767802,
-0.0257918499,
0.0041005122,
0.0074571325,
0.0057684048,
0.0161980353,
0.0382422805,
0.0302413311,
0.0520795994,
-0.0073207542,
0.0168884937,
0.0162954107,
0.026650887,
0.016610356,
-0.0113931289,
-0.0520966984,
-0.0123236198,
0.0022775626,
0.0393683575,
0.0680186152,
0.0661230981,
-0.036198929,
-0.0402721353,
0.0882141069,
0.0525500812,
-0.0523248985,
0.0031165297,
0.0294925589,
0.0412850678,
-0.0118354065,
-0.0263347272,
-0.0914556831,
0.0801099092,
-0.0066787922,
-0.0081618894,
0.0406297483,
0.0300805662,
-0.02452402,
-0.0005088569,
-0.0259366874,
-0.0086535243,
0.0374857038,
0.0238956213,
0.0552496649,
0.0433330573,
-0.0206741188,
0.0799112841,
0.0152810449,
-0.0057684281,
-0.0372324437,
0.0007831652,
0.0356861018,
0.0177249983,
-0.0072625675,
0.0012953982,
0.0062229685,
-0.0399611592,
0.0992684811,
0.0587810054,
0.0121754119,
0.0154886786,
0.0354265347,
-0.0442169644,
-0.0394917019,
-0.0444161333,
0.0122690937,
-0.0042094449,
0.0395273976,
-0.0067965155,
0.0083357207,
-0.0259879138,
0.0273887143,
0.0368699208,
0.0713309944,
0.00495916,
-0.0578600168,
0.0067467224,
-0.0244715121,
-0.0182929467,
-0.0238126963,
0.0024477639,
0.023322098,
0.0011687513,
0.0431426689,
0.0166729167,
-0.0342734605,
-0.0153351547,
-0.0008012097,
-0.0243785493,
-0.026851112,
-0.0185303539,
-0.0195948239,
0.0137588503,
0.0370724387,
-0.0245229676,
0.0407539345,
-0.0115749538,
-0.0083692428,
0.0429898873,
0.018378403,
-0.0337286629,
0.0358698517,
-0.024891777,
-0.0125131831,
-0.0026883294,
0.0176128149,
-0.0140270265,
-0.0314470157,
-0.0229980983,
-0.0124045126,
0.00690341,
0.0095452117,
-0.0099456515,
0.0210669618,
-0.0493428372,
-0.0170687102,
-0.0577945039,
-0.0346350409,
-0.0158990938,
-0.0576673336,
-0.0062267357,
-0.0226791501,
0.0289385039,
-0.0603338741,
-0.0024869053,
0.026653789,
-0.0098850019,
0.0319255739,
-0.0040113493,
-0.0066712741,
0.0039209491,
-0.0247143749,
0.0358726718,
0.0287552923,
0.0378148891,
0.0021839296,
-0.0539537035,
-0.0254998617,
0.0308363438,
-0.0267650206,
0.0379218236,
-0.0170641877,
0.0075415159,
0.0249611903,
-0.0550138876,
0.0074434695,
0.0718974024,
-0.0147204418,
0.0289188176,
0.0227569863,
-0.0480256714,
-0.0333667509,
-0.018767247,
0.0079524945,
-0.0379575789,
-0.0157815944,
0.0046858615,
-0.0298420433,
0.041061461,
-0.0029178099,
0.0198858865,
-0.0212886706,
0.0115790907,
-0.0119147599,
-0.0630681366,
-0.074129276,
0.0369614772,
0.0071178866,
0.0332793482,
-0.0997988731,
-0.0900229439,
-0.0021595699,
-0.0259011202,
-0.0199003574,
0.0537466034,
-0.0030567644,
0.002135254,
0.0948026702,
0.0332429446,
0.0239100046,
-0.0028051324,
-0.0157572366,
-0.0073869131,
-0.0035829511,
-0.0388948768,
0.0183377359,
0.0355839096,
-0.0703103244,
0.0201556273,
0.0084425127,
-0.0170514286,
0.0096645346,
0.0078172209,
-0.000609838,
-0.0074606454,
-0.0465968512,
-0.0217382144,
-0.0122446446,
0.0574445575,
0.0312402882,
0.0147351036,
-0.0362800509,
-0.027594611,
-0.0125262467,
-0.0112176305,
0.0599832982,
0.0824183673,
-0.0348177627,
-0.0412208848,
-0.0605217963,
0.0733871982,
-0.0190237388,
0.0014503173,
-0.0508625247,
0.0505918935,
0.0035309182,
0.0490806811,
-0.0136333955,
0.0212506298,
0.0853488967,
-0.0472235493,
-0.057814274,
0.0547922179,
0.0203021709,
-0.0351130106,
-0.0238131844,
-0.0242056642,
0.0248968881,
0.0276962351,
0.0006160943,
-0.0652802214,
-0.0517221354,
-0.0048853979,
-0.05170127,
0.0740634203,
-0.0205643363,
0.0136780711,
-0.0788201541,
0.0575813875,
0.0068793371,
-0.0826184899,
-0.0915932953,
0.0429444499,
0.0122377556,
0.0079485085,
-0.0155064007,
-0.0184092447,
-0.0078310911,
-0.0072968667,
0.0242656674,
0.0461220779,
0.0005621439,
-0.0026470916,
-0.057652209,
0.0297578089,
0.0245492347,
0.020908121,
0.0510891452,
-0.0432232954,
0.0121259326,
0.060589768,
-0.0003821044,
-0.0259060264,
0.0532483086,
-0.0039138817,
-0.0192551184,
0.0218388531,
-0.0117166126,
-0.0047029522,
-0.0363416038,
-0.025666533,
0.0328878202,
-0.0457864702,
0.0189254936,
-0.041969344,
0.045080591,
0.0189931877,
0.0421720855,
0.0438693985,
0.007136466,
-0.030016033,
0.0018001123,
0.0000961672,
-0.0031462274,
-0.0263786875,
-0.0084800925,
-0.0002686648,
0.0037091943,
-0.0550959818,
-0.0080448957,
0.0698645934,
0.0282326825,
0.0038946767,
-0.0330283046,
-0.0144605162,
-0.0020932867,
-0.0461588912,
0.0905580074,
-0.0418042243,
0.0101932827,
-0.0310224053,
-0.0460970514,
0.0535824783,
-0.0182099137,
0.0078441231,
0.0714700446,
-0.066951938,
-0.0081198504,
-0.0131240087,
0.0799970999,
0.0162363146,
0.0467858724,
-0.0027386374,
-0.0484837368,
0.0329146907,
0.0061956742,
-0.0213541426,
0.0718985125,
-0.0023743198,
0.0163074918,
0.0064969081,
0.0220734719,
-0.0476702042,
0.0091300122,
0.0025558292,
-0.0046519507,
-0.0249814279,
-0.0469720736,
0.0048392112,
-0.0654377043,
0.0474541374,
0.0180087648,
0.0436210185,
-0.0317000858,
0.0034254184,
0.0191828199,
0.0060750511,
-0.0835901052,
0.0400982834,
0.0097142523,
0.0157748051,
0.0142403254,
-0.0249619391,
0.0209034402,
0.0577436201,
-0.0228887536,
-0.0269272979,
0.0031512163,
-0.0463433191,
0.0074889991,
0.0444417596,
0.002149618,
0.0051667788,
-0.0363271646,
0.0440230928,
0.0092377728,
0.0435490385,
0.0026491317,
-0.0599906854,
-0.0390918069,
0.0449448004,
-0.0008725064,
-0.0521436669,
-0.0315687209,
0.0604692772,
0.0537592731,
0.0057461583,
0.0419122465,
-0.005723753,
-0.0279891025,
-0.0002202435,
0.0652725175,
0.0373562798,
-0.0714828894,
0.0463631488,
0.0274998434,
-0.0132378498,
-0.0209280401,
0.02342855,
0.0105664292,
0.0329821371,
0.0052042878,
-0.00420568,
-0.0247311108,
-0.0117175663,
0.0167003758,
0.0475911126,
0.0298625529,
0.0434283577,
-0.0001457866,
-0.0639667362,
-0.0136200087,
0.0303882752,
-0.0356607586,
0.0167219136,
0.0735519975,
0.0330191925,
0.0108624529,
-0.0220488589,
-0.0295319837,
-0.0251187794,
0.0538032539,
-0.0128717655,
-0.0334966518,
-5.998204575e-33,
-0.057322111,
-0.0498002768,
0.0331945717,
-0.0133718811,
-0.0297231581,
-0.0018217009,
-0.0429615602,
0.0178618059,
-0.0061232387,
0.0327664912,
0.0218798742,
-0.0094459914,
0.0073196152,
0.0366948955,
0.0048774071,
-0.0090604154,
0.0233051758,
0.010679407,
0.0114456145,
0.0108759543,
0.038329944,
0.0245991722,
0.0824965388,
-0.0701929182,
-0.0370183773,
0.0464755893,
-0.035601154,
0.0281284545,
0.0057770209,
0.0413695015,
-0.0355721675,
0.0069343518,
-0.0123492861,
-0.0075086057,
-0.0294289812,
0.0143525265,
-0.0692591444,
0.0016518641,
0.0046841833,
0.0151542472,
-0.0380346775,
0.002362266,
0.0657782555,
-0.0331149995,
0.0284495074,
-0.0228104163,
0.041175019,
-0.0043051341,
-0.0487708636,
0.0225200858,
-0.0556372851,
0.0068197111,
-0.0008476618,
-0.065446876,
0.0290238336,
-0.0125907911,
0.0185410567,
-0.0031966905,
-0.0453251675,
0.0293502025,
-0.0139851077,
0.0437495485,
0.0453081839,
0.0309470706,
0.0290326905,
0.0849778727,
0.0592537783,
-0.0451124012,
-0.0234984756,
-0.0219183043,
0.0273470432,
0.0517708845,
-0.0154679976,
0.0322436616,
0.0112513583,
0.0433869623,
-0.0267495252,
-0.0013979196,
-0.0475829802,
0.0888085514,
-0.0093792509,
0.0108791422,
0.0333742835,
-0.0103959627,
0.0070548169,
0.01905437,
-0.034645997,
-0.0136118308,
0.0506652705,
0.0266735014,
0.0123712104,
0.0415417328,
0.0638872385,
0.0025330668,
-0.0286603011,
-0.0023729755,
-0.0058482527,
0.0656363741,
-0.0152168339,
-0.0254390519,
-0.0228050966,
-0.0389521271,
0.0379068106,
-0.0163815543,
0.0340498462,
0.0347371325,
0.0116591016,
0.0067905281,
-0.0464033633,
-0.0163821876,
-0.0569139458,
0.0167921018,
-0.0061422717,
0.0325831436,
0.0519547202,
-0.0174266417,
-0.0375129394,
0.045193661,
-0.0521884933,
0.0015237893,
-0.0235993359,
-0.0394144729,
-0.0377834849,
0.030322589,
-0.0250723641,
0.0002337678,
-0.057159178,
-0.0611604042,
0.0432374813,
-0.085567005,
-0.0194872338,
0.0149133531,
2.934e-7,
0.0077073774,
0.0409143753,
-0.0148646254,
0.0313236974,
-0.0006681884,
0.0097364616,
-0.002732411,
0.054072693,
-0.0132070342,
-0.0561116152,
-0.0322696976,
0.0778311491,
0.0214318391,
0.0075661582,
-0.0833639428,
0.0338711552,
-0.02104358,
-0.0048948303,
-0.0424768962,
-0.0311513692,
-0.0034592568,
0.0726991445,
-0.0128962519,
-0.0039586374,
0.0614680983,
-0.0422140434,
0.0575832166,
-0.0421218127,
0.0158695672,
-0.0163701158,
0.0439542532,
0.0154281547,
-0.0384416915,
0.0144591173,
0.0067812232,
-0.0428972691,
0.0523161329,
0.027318513,
-0.0371393636,
-0.0464904271,
-0.0095380237,
-0.0189283378,
-0.0124584828,
-0.0540737398,
0.0489497781,
-0.0732848793,
-0.0147995604,
-0.0124195078,
0.0170278493,
-0.0312365275,
0.0158932246,
-0.0339820907,
-0.0304523651,
-0.0089141401,
0.0247972924,
-0.0067794905,
-0.0147939892,
-0.0908839703,
-0.0349216834,
0.0034080949,
-0.0243875403,
-0.011149684,
-0.0344508365,
-0.045879595,
0.0015017802,
-0.010987455,
-0.0460751466,
2.37261642e-34,
0.0164362546,
0.0229555704,
0.0172295179,
0.0443996303,
0.0379651003,
0.0000984007,
0.0108692311,
0.0241954569,
-0.0481849276,
-0.0048059123,
-0.0123249181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07700v1 | Knowledge-enhanced Memory Model for Emotional Support Conversation | 2023-10-11T17:51:28 | 2023-10-11T17:51:28 | Mengzhao Jia, Qianglong Chen, Liqiang Jing, Dawei Fu, Renyu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The prevalence of mental disorders has become a significant issue, leading to
the increased focus on Emotional Support Conversation as an effective
supplement for mental health support. Existing methods have achieved compelling
results, however, they still face three challenges: 1) variability of emotions,
2) practicality of the response, and 3) intricate strategy modeling. To address
these challenges, we propose a novel knowledge-enhanced Memory mODEl for
emotional suppoRt coNversation (MODERN). Specifically, we first devise a
knowledge-enriched dialogue context encoding to perceive the dynamic emotion
change of different periods of the conversation for coherent user state
modeling and select context-related concepts from ConceptNet for practical
response generation. Thereafter, we implement a novel memory-enhanced strategy
modeling module to model the semantic patterns behind the strategy categories.
Extensive experiments on a widely used large-scale dataset verify the
superiority of our model over cutting-edge baselines. | [
0.0750080198,
0.0165887624,
-0.052154649,
0.0406512581,
-0.0213537551,
-0.0006114825,
0.0025500017,
-0.0147668989,
0.0099926535,
-0.0503368452,
-0.0172132775,
-0.0733071938,
-0.0189741738,
0.0684291944,
-0.0147460289,
-0.0905756354,
0.0198701806,
0.0566777177,
0.0632834956,
0.0330176838,
0.0241376795,
0.0194360279,
-0.0438616239,
0.0167357568,
-0.0355141014,
-0.0116687156,
-0.0217422582,
0.0264785718,
0.0484668575,
-0.0703203976,
0.0440484621,
0.0446416475,
-0.0021670915,
-0.0435450934,
0.0000019707,
-0.0194821823,
-0.0071995612,
-0.0461563841,
0.0004676279,
-0.0301039945,
0.0261779949,
-0.0091564097,
0.0101291686,
0.0050109061,
-0.0151449824,
0.0295329094,
0.0394214205,
0.0903651118,
0.0765120611,
0.054824546,
-0.0357124694,
0.0075693624,
0.0175080225,
-0.0262346938,
0.0187415592,
-0.0340622179,
0.0263657477,
-0.0060959095,
-0.0103037003,
-0.0112330765,
-0.0134660508,
0.0098215025,
-0.0378366746,
0.0201478638,
-0.0119477985,
0.0005930578,
0.010239372,
-0.0166329071,
-0.0095747337,
0.0818272755,
0.0302626546,
0.0562646016,
0.0395201519,
-0.0176924616,
-0.0090056974,
0.0265197214,
-0.0273546465,
-0.0186546519,
-0.0249781124,
0.0042247549,
0.0148778893,
0.0484832674,
-0.0159736238,
0.0173711479,
-0.0071318103,
0.0099735614,
-0.0486560948,
-0.0263073817,
0.0011027372,
-0.039434921,
-0.05849443,
-0.0478417724,
0.0040086228,
0.0102554038,
-0.0305151735,
0.0372087397,
-0.007396488,
-0.009051743,
0.0089818342,
-0.0393597335,
-0.0120616928,
0.0436548814,
-0.0437938049,
-0.0085459435,
0.0277287159,
0.0421246178,
0.0219913404,
-0.0420182496,
-0.0184989963,
0.0260016043,
-0.0691320449,
0.0015815666,
-0.04879684,
0.0183514338,
-0.0306283776,
-0.0550523959,
-0.0602587536,
0.04296951,
-0.0306952409,
0.0224095117,
-0.0226101242,
0.0124885775,
-0.0024891826,
0.03880677,
-0.0166598391,
0.0176881272,
-0.0385187045,
0.0078627905,
0.0593366846,
-0.0599407256,
0.0129985185,
-0.0031860205,
-0.0014909777,
-0.0179402288,
-0.0037560491,
0.0151610123,
-0.0077035539,
-0.0216440298,
-0.0389962196,
-0.0478538163,
-0.0533034019,
-0.0241457224,
0.019320935,
-0.0043248525,
0.0559884571,
-0.0043835035,
-0.0060093557,
-0.0329375453,
0.03592816,
-0.0082470467,
-0.0538196936,
0.0551368408,
-0.0216805693,
-0.0345229357,
0.0152630443,
0.0582135431,
0.0063162153,
0.0402964503,
0.0083485022,
0.0215864107,
0.0432618149,
-0.0095296726,
-0.0143447686,
-0.0255366322,
0.0202427115,
-0.0526891164,
-0.0179310422,
0.0160573833,
-0.0376734212,
0.0547380708,
0.0005579218,
-0.0174942072,
-0.0542091615,
-0.0156519003,
0.013347758,
0.0641619861,
0.0064082602,
0.0535459518,
-0.023563914,
0.0330097228,
-0.0111096436,
-0.0238805469,
-0.0101427911,
0.0335980207,
-0.0206740908,
-0.0122421198,
0.0144952424,
-0.0272135921,
-0.0544863641,
-0.0465242341,
-0.0168886036,
-0.0178190302,
-0.0211442728,
0.009193995,
-0.0246901345,
-0.0182951167,
-0.0278897602,
0.0544737726,
0.0152873695,
-0.0056005726,
-0.0485920161,
-0.0607151687,
0.0285993628,
0.0995462686,
0.0416929871,
-0.0647280887,
-0.0649349391,
-0.0070060026,
-0.0291485433,
0.0285375826,
0.0273336191,
-0.0007984196,
0.0180444736,
-0.0445833281,
0.00571843,
0.0045766742,
0.0134614762,
0.0179637093,
-0.0010375646,
0.0331581272,
-0.0017536405,
0.0405192152,
0.0768329427,
0.006331291,
0.0414542519,
-0.0096644303,
0.0049606501,
-0.0268770438,
0.0873101354,
0.03344265,
-0.001201916,
0.0130571313,
0.0173259862,
-0.0157673806,
-0.0409834348,
0.0133620128,
-0.083223477,
-0.0726470128,
-0.0024218175,
0.0545226298,
0.0262338538,
0.0013362975,
-0.0379672386,
-0.0566617176,
0.054427769,
-0.0119628459,
0.0640131235,
-0.0449393243,
-0.0078199962,
0.0203582514,
0.0242973659,
-0.0090297516,
0.0408611074,
-0.0364330485,
0.008774898,
-0.0258321334,
-0.0099504814,
-0.0306496732,
-0.0191857703,
-0.0124349175,
0.0284008272,
-0.0188770276,
-0.011861234,
-0.0134897884,
-0.003926408,
-0.0532297976,
-0.0187550206,
-0.1334139556,
0.0340011641,
-0.0100072296,
-0.0164493062,
0.0169674288,
0.0024107611,
-0.0194500517,
-0.0091508478,
-0.0536810644,
0.0734894127,
0.0258697364,
0.0139556201,
-0.0132823298,
0.0700904652,
-0.0116114533,
-0.0668811277,
0.0019076607,
0.0111081116,
0.0386136994,
-0.0332361162,
-0.0561614148,
-0.0063044578,
0.0414943695,
-0.0872564465,
0.0094945477,
-0.0602592342,
-0.0321516991,
-0.0084191933,
-0.0192333311,
0.0036670424,
0.0080762375,
0.0442663021,
0.079283759,
-0.030242227,
-0.0118505089,
-0.0413762964,
0.0315939859,
-0.0434866548,
0.0176410489,
-0.0440922827,
-0.0240058973,
0.0149451178,
0.0593478791,
0.0412007831,
0.0313051455,
-0.0347821452,
-0.0598514676,
0.0416978858,
0.0062283776,
-0.0436289683,
-0.0132221086,
-0.0069657266,
0.0009921112,
-0.0157894734,
-0.0145645002,
0.0372841358,
0.0266928151,
-0.0182138067,
-0.0418416373,
-0.0089051984,
-0.0091767767,
0.0644940361,
-0.009916869,
0.0382693261,
0.0252580084,
-0.0134960562,
0.0177237205,
-0.0889386162,
-0.0198491048,
-0.0538198128,
0.0029073064,
-0.0552444533,
0.0007198133,
0.047571104,
-0.0043472061,
-0.0759823322,
0.0066881366,
-0.0418808274,
-0.0088220127,
0.0080928896,
0.0010764265,
-0.0096489294,
-0.0135156941,
0.0359570757,
0.0482926592,
0.025059836,
-0.0350308716,
0.0237999149,
0.0720236078,
0.0554637536,
0.0024182901,
0.0154241035,
-0.0127433157,
0.0630799457,
0.0826759115,
0.003472866,
-0.0089539718,
0.0562459901,
0.0124822827,
-0.0131208226,
0.0166780837,
0.0007825748,
0.0321795791,
-0.0067786574,
-0.0216098521,
-0.035515219,
0.1106469333,
0.0576453395,
-0.0226100329,
0.010367346,
-0.0470520817,
0.0048996271,
0.0037023155,
-0.0031837588,
-0.0446012914,
-0.0230694357,
-0.0267492197,
0.014196069,
-0.0420964882,
-0.0345161781,
-0.0211988408,
-0.0244959015,
0.0073979101,
-0.0033058054,
-0.0277369842,
0.009682483,
0.0050590052,
0.0173054989,
0.0265843589,
-0.0078737708,
-0.0222561248,
0.0501547046,
-0.0204863977,
0.0097974725,
-0.049585592,
-0.0605904125,
0.0392718017,
0.0247364454,
0.1010076478,
0.0513305515,
0.0786104575,
0.0249713212,
-0.0156200323,
0.0246038679,
-0.0048540938,
0.0308407489,
-0.0339837335,
0.0751501024,
-0.0178754516,
0.0182587598,
-0.0068428931,
0.0443893336,
-0.062644735,
-0.0481282994,
0.0095786098,
0.0324778073,
-0.0684071407,
-0.0120256878,
-0.021342868,
0.0235267356,
0.0551392771,
0.0665098205,
0.0126962429,
-0.0449161679,
0.0232312772,
-0.0038817939,
0.040754199,
0.0005151583,
-0.0095318677,
-0.023163138,
0.0357389674,
0.0320298597,
-0.0741183385,
-0.0363610424,
0.0259433221,
-0.0179919414,
-0.0541310385,
-0.0408159569,
0.0083849961,
0.0014430335,
-0.0663910583,
0.0137664918,
0.0258174688,
-0.0029837501,
-0.0049100406,
-0.0348561481,
0.0194009617,
-0.0202820189,
-0.0105146635,
0.0158440508,
0.004454778,
0.0008523252,
0.0367262959,
0.0258207228,
0.0192612503,
0.0207651779,
0.062560901,
-0.0123583572,
0.0363108739,
0.0300617609,
-0.0165653098,
-0.0111186104,
0.0074188858,
0.0765114948,
-0.0171165075,
0.0368514173,
-0.0152749419,
0.064464137,
0.0186751578,
0.0342385657,
-0.0092925448,
-0.0262022056,
-0.0149246538,
-0.0363917351,
0.0210450497,
0.0111470586,
-0.0573318452,
-0.0074888403,
0.0008815445,
-0.0268902089,
0.0073096431,
-0.0438811034,
-0.0126118474,
-0.0245592911,
-0.0268620905,
-0.0321302824,
-0.0509621352,
-0.0466258861,
-0.0263648648,
0.0141978357,
-0.0306034703,
0.0360722207,
0.0003916954,
-0.0088109365,
0.0123595931,
-0.0202391166,
0.010846206,
-0.0001418659,
0.0267570075,
-0.0307760369,
0.1357456744,
0.011902716,
-0.0533386655,
0.0329440981,
0.0403501093,
-0.0545873232,
-0.0483683869,
-0.0171621703,
0.0024994814,
0.008315294,
0.0071134311,
0.0010664046,
-0.0572584271,
0.0314633809,
-0.0045765573,
0.023655653,
-0.0196973812,
-0.0380593576,
0.0307165869,
0.023573745,
-0.0121928323,
-0.0023440062,
0.0153141618,
-0.0480417088,
0.0351627916,
-0.0301952083,
-0.0334077962,
-0.0455737524,
0.0113110188,
0.0359577537,
0.0724191964,
-0.00857691,
0.0049806675,
-0.0745380372,
-0.0333620347,
0.0660918728,
-0.0389047489,
-0.0022529473,
-0.013955716,
0.0833974704,
0.0306935534,
0.0039203595,
0.0185987633,
-0.0216838326,
0.0355634168,
-0.086954549,
-0.014985878,
-0.0446794182,
-5.489023034e-33,
-0.0024708649,
-0.014949251,
-0.0055266661,
-0.0088463137,
-0.0302676633,
0.0348294526,
-0.0462923236,
0.0021192057,
0.016256867,
0.0227349196,
0.0360951573,
0.0609530285,
-0.0074099898,
0.0508926921,
-0.0325758047,
0.0035584199,
0.0338024609,
-0.0196002796,
0.0046381247,
0.0766557381,
0.039182853,
0.0595423467,
0.0172391422,
-0.1032888144,
0.0182020962,
0.0385535732,
0.0150012011,
0.0174666326,
0.0739125982,
0.0364814959,
-0.0337083004,
0.0614317358,
0.0357039496,
-0.0219484102,
0.0262510572,
0.0182051305,
-0.0219253674,
-0.0281748269,
-0.0152364951,
-0.0523742288,
-0.0501616597,
0.0104138264,
-0.0352203362,
0.011553715,
0.0375384949,
-0.016501341,
-0.0019967493,
-0.0164032839,
-0.0001034178,
-0.0458263829,
-0.0070828511,
0.0045490763,
-0.0234642569,
-0.0032128606,
-0.0393632539,
0.0282126088,
-0.0025094068,
0.0000704807,
-0.0189900137,
-0.009962311,
-0.0189274121,
0.0020241758,
0.0032900069,
0.002575832,
-0.0207434259,
0.1045876816,
-0.0045524174,
-0.0093228482,
-0.0142830666,
0.0128718158,
-0.0296190139,
0.0630261675,
0.0307060853,
0.0167056397,
-0.0009850658,
-0.020544406,
-0.037109226,
-0.0025525873,
0.0215260591,
0.0137212006,
0.0298580565,
0.0034310438,
-0.0476648025,
-0.0136696473,
-0.0257779434,
0.0165978111,
-0.0188024547,
-0.0371010527,
0.0379149541,
0.0209860951,
0.0000392389,
-0.0122834472,
-0.0012203791,
-0.0222425926,
0.014832749,
0.0284831636,
-0.0297856349,
0.03959262,
-0.0120609775,
0.0045895232,
-0.0141972862,
-0.0181231629,
0.0375937819,
-0.0220530126,
0.0150454435,
0.0160430297,
0.0216483921,
-0.0035478983,
-0.0331638567,
-0.0034515359,
-0.0147669334,
0.0590004474,
-0.0362116769,
0.0045275623,
-0.0655390993,
0.0530050136,
-0.0317699797,
0.0243128724,
0.0212074872,
-0.0151965171,
-0.0415855721,
-0.0462671518,
0.0006869259,
0.0353269204,
-0.0367442593,
-0.0174576752,
0.0000693161,
-0.0109346928,
0.0135960151,
-0.0079376893,
0.0095506059,
-0.0093932962,
2.689e-7,
-0.0023327929,
0.0450369827,
0.0020648143,
-0.0234243497,
0.062354669,
0.0274859052,
0.0357421674,
0.0701432079,
0.0421674326,
-0.0675807372,
0.0452523902,
0.0515552983,
0.0146041745,
0.0271756016,
-0.0196236596,
-0.07548666,
0.0058135618,
-0.0707921684,
-0.0382241905,
0.0197820552,
0.1261152327,
0.0711990073,
0.0355407186,
-0.0160587505,
0.0282718036,
0.0219268482,
0.0590536371,
-0.0688554272,
0.0197955891,
0.0328207016,
0.0088713607,
-0.0120489011,
0.0041245897,
-0.0014093446,
-0.0203162897,
0.0106116254,
-0.0360391401,
0.0601557903,
-0.0196594223,
-0.0869376659,
-0.0056206845,
0.050205972,
-0.0040539261,
-0.0277027972,
0.0224985518,
-0.0879695415,
-0.0069844285,
-0.0131070139,
-0.0106421439,
-0.0204795562,
-0.0126896184,
0.0107359448,
-0.0346821062,
0.0440284461,
-0.0071945284,
0.0212645493,
0.0311504956,
-0.1011511236,
-0.0083419587,
0.048891034,
-0.0723822564,
-0.0242596157,
-0.0226715431,
-0.0122924773,
-0.0255578011,
-0.0339690931,
0.0068488233,
2.166496241e-34,
0.0294992458,
0.0451668464,
-0.0049675223,
0.0401764959,
0.0067014745,
0.0233238712,
-0.042806074,
0.0167145524,
0.0149084367,
-0.0665846094,
-0.0068191439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07676v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07676v2 | Composite Backdoor Attacks Against Large Language Models | 2023-10-11T17:21:03 | 2024-03-30T16:09:34 | Hai Huang, Zhengyu Zhao, Michael Backes, Yun Shen, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior performance compared
to previous methods on various tasks, and often serve as the foundation models
for many researches and services. However, the untrustworthy third-party LLMs
may covertly introduce vulnerabilities for downstream tasks. In this paper, we
explore the vulnerability of LLMs through the lens of backdoor attacks.
Different from existing backdoor attacks against LLMs, ours scatters multiple
trigger keys in different prompt components. Such a Composite Backdoor Attack
(CBA) is shown to be stealthier than implanting the same multiple trigger keys
in only a single component. CBA ensures that the backdoor is activated only
when all trigger keys appear. Our experiments demonstrate that CBA is effective
in both natural language processing (NLP) and multimodal tasks. For instance,
with $3\%$ poisoning samples against the LLaMA-7B model on the Emotion dataset,
our attack achieves a $100\%$ Attack Success Rate (ASR) with a False Triggered
Rate (FTR) below $2.06\%$ and negligible model accuracy degradation. Our work
highlights the necessity of increased security research on the trustworthiness
of foundation LLMs. | [
0.0509572253,
0.074995704,
-0.010267349,
0.0701634437,
-0.0594100691,
-0.0179420765,
0.0534258224,
-0.0201075487,
0.0613376684,
-0.0493640006,
-0.0313068293,
-0.0164293926,
0.0373364128,
0.0512524061,
0.0651382953,
0.0335850008,
0.054924503,
-0.029415302,
-0.0224822089,
-0.017381059,
-0.032626126,
-0.0169370566,
0.0021591147,
0.0306522809,
-0.0006794265,
0.0003595484,
-0.0327650644,
-0.0084825037,
0.025971191,
-0.0116612706,
-0.0284324754,
0.031898085,
-0.0280832015,
0.0553935915,
0.0000022153,
-0.0442512408,
-0.0061415406,
0.0124958167,
-0.0195615571,
0.0484398678,
0.0033210805,
-0.0108690215,
-0.030874148,
0.0198299196,
-0.0141191389,
-0.0016215983,
-0.000500968,
0.0624682941,
0.0859295651,
0.06617973,
-0.0010474476,
-0.0066460902,
0.0807660371,
-0.0365516432,
-0.002821815,
-0.0285331011,
0.0279318485,
-0.0654098019,
-0.0283468347,
0.0092913462,
-0.0030576226,
0.000638788,
0.002893605,
-0.0162195116,
-0.0430107974,
0.0507636294,
0.0052016242,
-0.0334700271,
-0.0504182838,
0.0453418642,
-0.0494089425,
0.0403109491,
-0.0037051591,
-0.0062108715,
-0.0023919952,
0.0184602607,
0.0258056801,
0.031662073,
-0.0214536656,
-0.0252600983,
0.0199262537,
-0.0377286859,
0.0504764318,
0.0234681703,
0.0078180917,
0.0465691648,
0.0115608517,
-0.0102837468,
0.0195281878,
-0.0584963784,
0.0111153219,
-0.0587542467,
-0.010417657,
-0.0133968182,
0.0078153303,
0.0267813094,
-0.0674296096,
-0.022384325,
0.0382955894,
-0.038751971,
0.0109268678,
0.0496991463,
-0.0531913936,
0.0196279436,
-0.0060009342,
0.0588696934,
-0.0503856763,
0.0230909791,
0.0285328403,
0.0204167273,
-0.0080683697,
-0.0152586121,
0.0074292538,
0.0093148639,
-0.0363917202,
-0.0331519395,
-0.0631188974,
0.0173507165,
-0.0172414966,
0.0295718834,
0.0006537445,
-0.0113962637,
-0.0040360177,
0.028629601,
0.0332063995,
-0.0047364421,
0.0196375269,
-0.0177745335,
-0.0039711366,
-0.1001796946,
-0.0179215167,
-0.0152818915,
-0.0406042412,
-0.0201947391,
-0.0002881648,
0.0670794547,
0.0295539312,
-0.0283902511,
-0.064831242,
-0.0779152662,
-0.0319360085,
-0.0149273509,
-0.0058976873,
-0.0816749036,
-0.0061307685,
-0.0257951524,
0.0086991778,
-0.0266704597,
0.026622748,
0.0179364029,
-0.0343105346,
0.0926125795,
0.0006350992,
-0.0186327565,
0.0163236801,
0.0286551118,
-0.0250617303,
0.0554905683,
0.0034183576,
0.0645201057,
0.0661100671,
-0.0128511051,
0.0228494722,
0.0567932725,
0.0070148921,
0.0190247018,
-0.0092156855,
-0.0163237546,
0.0121083343,
-0.0062503396,
-0.0103345066,
0.0481845364,
-0.0287800133,
-0.0343021415,
0.0935955569,
0.0536988303,
-0.0436095409,
0.0199741516,
-0.0089607146,
-0.0155030964,
-0.0101644564,
-0.0052917292,
-0.099256061,
-0.0072942697,
-0.0759731233,
-0.0295337625,
0.0356829315,
0.0213689227,
-0.0021887657,
-0.0203091037,
0.0031370141,
-0.0433025658,
0.0005605455,
-0.003216041,
0.0214198194,
0.0129332049,
0.0027667754,
0.0186681785,
-0.0060080425,
-0.0474979617,
-0.0405403413,
-0.0696853474,
-0.0538607426,
0.0515417308,
0.0521129854,
0.0244092233,
0.0215550754,
-0.0331371278,
-0.0145330597,
0.0284133181,
0.0019396332,
0.029803928,
0.0044406583,
-0.0238401555,
0.0010110143,
-0.0149771925,
0.0303185359,
0.0289928745,
-0.0090792505,
0.0153666083,
-0.0125020128,
0.0395517126,
0.0437667407,
0.0211224332,
-0.0274002701,
-0.0559886582,
-0.0029592712,
0.0385670699,
0.038637951,
-0.0075170188,
-0.0180634148,
0.0236733928,
0.0267022904,
-0.0018867683,
-0.0103705721,
-0.0162653998,
0.0276033636,
-0.0014822282,
0.0397652797,
0.0308867544,
0.0063510481,
0.0850617737,
-0.0244380124,
-0.0225333311,
0.0355948061,
-0.0259460136,
0.0191463865,
-0.0020709806,
-0.0103009874,
-0.0026451293,
0.0362426937,
-0.0182584338,
0.0234530661,
-0.0443523005,
0.0024117408,
-0.0469472073,
0.006714948,
0.0232185386,
-0.0123749543,
-0.0562935472,
0.0261021219,
-0.0089652408,
0.0097017726,
-0.0290635061,
-0.0353103094,
-0.0328740589,
-0.0233009141,
-0.0498928428,
-0.0016588507,
-0.006551363,
0.0301628411,
0.0204176996,
-0.0044988738,
-0.0245026797,
-0.0146698346,
0.0087131616,
-0.0266516488,
-0.0023445459,
0.0539899245,
0.0003305379,
-0.0115146991,
-0.0398622788,
-0.008829142,
-0.0200494416,
-0.0300050154,
0.0813395157,
-0.0142251374,
-0.0178584307,
-0.0358162709,
0.0056894976,
-0.0023883088,
0.0254603885,
-0.0304919519,
-0.0692878738,
0.0157880709,
0.0202633701,
-0.0283760745,
0.0829802454,
0.0045154225,
0.0420269258,
0.0725933015,
-0.0024841791,
-0.0443343855,
-0.010891133,
0.0384812988,
-0.0283388421,
-0.0575320721,
0.0002548615,
-0.0111985449,
0.0608171932,
0.0546477176,
-0.0125683146,
-0.0082321912,
0.0133246761,
0.0229748022,
-0.0219597109,
-0.0314998999,
-0.0831926316,
-0.0501244329,
0.0261100121,
0.0064987801,
-0.0933329314,
0.0541988872,
-0.0656352416,
0.0190315079,
-0.0114074629,
-0.0172920823,
0.0072446573,
0.0646772385,
-0.0273957178,
0.0153020164,
0.028839279,
-0.0244547054,
-0.0141446637,
-0.0269952621,
0.0129084932,
-0.0455463454,
0.0430604033,
-0.0151283238,
-0.0057401555,
-0.015432775,
-0.0184608493,
-0.0536607429,
-0.075355038,
-0.0692322329,
-0.0224563889,
-0.0151335308,
-0.0306547005,
0.0107828099,
-0.0453873836,
0.0399917923,
-0.0134252962,
-0.0136066033,
-0.0165932868,
-0.0363182127,
0.0248161908,
0.0341047794,
-0.0607995167,
0.0328029245,
-0.0140776159,
0.0308215823,
0.0804648697,
0.0670778751,
0.0182490218,
-0.0473304763,
0.0015901944,
0.0112664718,
0.0031838771,
-0.0242386106,
0.0027344117,
-0.0182504188,
-0.0255935863,
0.0196000692,
0.0549236424,
0.0081793815,
-0.0715060309,
0.0168979391,
0.0227849837,
-0.0250611324,
0.0237564966,
-0.0055891844,
-0.0698423684,
-0.0331686363,
0.0370057337,
0.0222318843,
-0.02829629,
-0.0113022951,
-0.0121069206,
-0.1615630537,
-0.0009297449,
0.0061759306,
-0.0109471697,
-0.0124085946,
-0.0462593064,
0.000755397,
0.0170132127,
0.0226749349,
-0.0156449638,
0.0162918586,
-0.0344064422,
-0.0327334851,
0.0133414119,
-0.0384173915,
0.0328426175,
-0.015452723,
0.0590157062,
0.0409514681,
0.0060526663,
-0.0383599475,
-0.0161228199,
0.0583703779,
-0.001042643,
0.0098484783,
0.0193679444,
0.0466847047,
0.0007375674,
-0.021830786,
0.0157250613,
0.0472646803,
-0.0217701625,
0.0015852678,
0.0100004179,
0.035319943,
-0.0153030874,
-0.0107985428,
-0.0198782403,
-0.0133056119,
0.0366081335,
0.0373222344,
0.016600797,
-0.0593875423,
-0.0041761696,
-0.0444426946,
-0.0038088178,
0.0358465612,
-0.074709326,
0.0448876694,
0.0075685517,
-0.0484086052,
-0.036177814,
0.0033521713,
-0.0174232218,
0.0314572118,
0.0203595385,
0.0156834871,
-0.0056773177,
0.036366839,
-0.0071051558,
0.0277007259,
-0.016431639,
0.0688999593,
-0.0341342762,
0.0602218397,
0.0205363333,
-0.0178969912,
-0.0204225257,
0.0177649017,
-0.061776001,
-0.0730375946,
0.0163986497,
0.0275495406,
0.0251288172,
0.0151214851,
-0.0180302802,
-0.0626427829,
0.0774695277,
0.0178832114,
-0.0342109241,
0.029798178,
0.0635881349,
0.0022358464,
0.0051325243,
0.0280185733,
-0.0222614203,
-0.027734438,
0.0678960457,
0.0019745296,
0.0024409848,
-0.0110618826,
-0.0088456571,
0.063564755,
0.1021383405,
-0.0290665608,
0.0716948137,
0.001104782,
0.029323997,
-0.0105601968,
-0.0113033717,
-0.006325799,
0.0193848778,
-0.0025246362,
-0.024741523,
0.0107076354,
-0.0637745261,
0.0261342283,
0.006449901,
-0.0095535675,
0.035767246,
0.0325152203,
0.0404505171,
0.0627433136,
0.0128134526,
-0.0297082178,
0.05160781,
0.0278195348,
0.010167635,
-0.0058183507,
0.0083868373,
-0.0092977397,
-0.0398920849,
-0.0396564119,
0.0403124318,
-0.0725013092,
-0.0304266997,
0.0398311168,
0.0133907869,
0.0156916212,
0.0122415833,
-0.0034142341,
-0.0254200548,
0.0003046692,
-0.021648081,
-0.015687095,
0.0048839757,
-0.0286413878,
0.0297874417,
-0.0094865169,
-0.0154946046,
0.0369196497,
0.057202857,
-0.0261757169,
0.0813624337,
-0.0060545634,
-0.0187036507,
-0.016158266,
-0.0151248286,
0.0228234194,
0.0238302425,
-0.0383706279,
-0.0351631567,
-0.0542093366,
-0.0797713622,
0.0244631786,
-0.0031485911,
0.0059467503,
0.0122682471,
-0.0047125975,
0.0554049164,
0.0458633602,
0.0581513159,
-0.0689793304,
0.0317990929,
-0.0204115044,
-0.04769741,
0.0384457856,
-6.261158253e-33,
0.0481662713,
-0.0365056656,
-0.0403472222,
0.0283312723,
0.0155316414,
0.0424991697,
-0.0030306969,
0.0263568852,
-0.0155379698,
-0.0054281768,
-0.020608129,
-0.0006079897,
0.0173269678,
-0.003291897,
-0.0014471229,
0.0117767341,
-0.0064376732,
-0.0275327303,
-0.0112742912,
0.0101698516,
0.0792105198,
0.0076040737,
0.040230114,
-0.0489383563,
0.0424877144,
0.002101237,
-0.0461118408,
0.0122873541,
-0.0567023978,
0.0742583647,
-0.0028271973,
0.0494601466,
-0.0051702349,
-0.044678431,
0.0062904763,
0.0659321174,
0.0134656159,
-0.007099086,
-0.0310282726,
-0.005455981,
0.0247464254,
-0.0538363643,
0.0359409116,
-0.0281602144,
-0.0157034118,
-0.002376562,
-0.00808312,
-0.0410235152,
-0.0252398327,
-0.0440191738,
0.0042273537,
0.0058336882,
0.0042379024,
0.0122728134,
-0.0096577331,
0.0078326296,
0.0040250379,
0.0033033355,
-0.0486067869,
0.040459767,
0.0439584479,
0.0092932675,
0.0272078235,
-0.0021424831,
0.0165552087,
0.0739639848,
0.0335596092,
-0.0322510861,
-0.0222123992,
0.0285626706,
0.0143795693,
0.069395259,
0.0510787368,
0.0862929448,
0.0567199551,
-0.0508750938,
-0.0661337152,
0.0031899896,
0.0642876178,
0.0197190959,
0.0720555261,
-0.015012431,
-0.0631833598,
0.0169778317,
-0.0566863343,
-0.0185290296,
-0.0380216353,
-0.0302127134,
0.0123173464,
0.0208648536,
-0.0135020036,
-0.0133122141,
0.0155533375,
-0.0507794097,
-0.0228524078,
0.037365932,
0.0221377295,
0.0078454604,
-0.0086377328,
-0.0062958039,
0.0319803357,
0.0024874872,
-0.0421670675,
-0.0660690069,
0.0510712638,
0.0045017535,
-0.0060659703,
0.0202172957,
-0.1034809276,
-0.0143082878,
-0.03446161,
0.0151868211,
0.0450430885,
0.0319922492,
0.0433083028,
-0.0519594289,
-0.0123343682,
0.017084334,
0.0149989016,
0.0306556877,
-0.0359085575,
0.044201389,
-0.0374515429,
0.0311862044,
0.0041672294,
-0.0052969879,
-0.0170219317,
0.0062257471,
0.0443173461,
-0.0100559965,
0.0093195848,
-0.0217025355,
3.142e-7,
-0.0435927622,
0.0228929911,
-0.0100735687,
0.0199255478,
0.0285994038,
0.0840676948,
-0.0317516401,
0.0821109936,
-0.0155989481,
-0.0752266049,
-0.0605498143,
-0.0050132293,
0.0586061068,
0.0337159224,
-0.0405324847,
0.0145727303,
-0.0537351519,
0.0333348475,
-0.0482183769,
0.0136926249,
0.025529895,
0.1094035134,
0.0287625417,
-0.0364367664,
-0.0089486102,
-0.0363334902,
0.0110068265,
-0.0078988364,
-0.0324890018,
-0.0073687537,
0.0486732423,
0.0378808379,
-0.0018900698,
0.0439555235,
-0.0295915622,
0.0028012139,
-0.0775962994,
0.0277366303,
0.010709173,
-0.0548049845,
-0.0092585841,
-0.0399427377,
-0.0149633139,
-0.0189057402,
0.0582149066,
0.011847659,
-0.0192336086,
-0.0605137311,
-0.0045285095,
-0.0575774573,
0.0684808493,
-0.0596149154,
0.0207157899,
0.0187852271,
-0.0048897327,
-0.0192532931,
0.0148173366,
-0.0856785998,
-0.0383370034,
-0.0318561681,
-0.0271427035,
-0.0417344496,
0.0053155567,
0.0227453131,
-0.0023699054,
-0.015432111,
-0.0172210559,
2.881267749e-34,
-0.0063342601,
-0.0323859788,
0.0070963786,
0.0261886101,
0.0311383735,
0.0000305381,
-0.0142318206,
0.0085845487,
0.0096561909,
-0.0636479259,
-0.0300978068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07659v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07659v3 | Well Begun is Half Done: Generator-agnostic Knowledge Pre-Selection for Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue | 2023-10-11T17:00:29 | 2023-10-20T13:43:35 | Lang Qin, Yao Zhang, Hongru Liang, Jun Wang, Zhenglu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Accurate knowledge selection is critical in knowledge-grounded dialogue
systems. Towards a closer look at it, we offer a novel perspective to organize
existing literature, i.e., knowledge selection coupled with, after, and before
generation. We focus on the third under-explored category of study, which can
not only select knowledge accurately in advance, but has the advantage to
reduce the learning, adjustment, and interpretation burden of subsequent
response generation models, especially LLMs. We propose GATE, a
generator-agnostic knowledge selection method, to prepare knowledge for
subsequent response generation models by selecting context-related knowledge
among different knowledge structures and variable knowledge requirements.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of GATE, and indicate that
knowledge selection before generation is a lightweight yet effective way to
facilitate LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT) to generate more informative responses. | [
0.0623161532,
0.0132699246,
-0.024778964,
0.0383965969,
-0.0403877161,
-0.002692004,
0.0057912045,
-0.0015414864,
0.0322366618,
-0.0403321907,
-0.0057334313,
0.0139071653,
-0.0321563073,
0.0144018941,
0.021490043,
-0.0246949494,
0.0583477542,
-0.007767491,
-0.0078103808,
-0.0192821249,
-0.0107476143,
0.0177296512,
-0.0522144772,
0.0232769158,
-0.0215649363,
-0.0129859215,
-0.0341829583,
-0.0012139081,
0.0180016458,
-0.0457678512,
0.0238810796,
0.0437807813,
0.0091959415,
-0.0132875713,
0.0000019489,
-0.0416525453,
0.000391133,
-0.0366584398,
-0.0564665571,
-0.0318371356,
-0.0324380957,
0.0722832233,
0.0268943235,
0.008654424,
-0.0776382014,
-0.0183273889,
0.0349423215,
0.0595841967,
0.0420670249,
0.0298230369,
-0.0035765523,
-0.0145858033,
-0.027450474,
0.0056700925,
0.0431618467,
-0.0426675268,
0.0062535936,
0.03657059,
0.0196508225,
0.0314642489,
-0.0080004428,
0.0204850249,
0.0032343073,
-0.0487631895,
0.053481441,
0.0223720204,
-0.0161896385,
-0.0096721286,
-0.014125471,
0.1101291552,
0.0797502249,
0.0053272191,
0.0188327003,
-0.0105113368,
0.0177779458,
0.0238739643,
-0.045855429,
-0.038176544,
-0.0578260385,
-0.0102471178,
-0.0602988489,
-0.0058263345,
-0.0184925105,
0.0105551593,
-0.0096095735,
0.080801554,
-0.0199727602,
-0.0204057768,
0.0169602316,
0.0113640251,
0.0024025573,
-0.0663243085,
-0.0315386876,
0.0358179733,
-0.0505284183,
0.0279583,
0.0083705625,
0.0538662076,
0.0199784748,
-0.0004694285,
0.0023365454,
0.0492797382,
0.0147731509,
0.0244920868,
0.0089254314,
0.0496049486,
0.0109342365,
-0.006841721,
-0.020581102,
0.0219284147,
-0.0710555241,
-0.0350823775,
-0.0362386517,
0.0614238977,
-0.0725042894,
-0.0020547283,
-0.0157202687,
0.0509092771,
-0.0068528042,
-0.0034462658,
0.0113576846,
0.0291575938,
-0.0219221152,
0.0296654273,
-0.0673207492,
0.0310809966,
-0.0457542427,
0.0251067225,
0.0422000811,
-0.0760864541,
-0.0071551953,
0.0363790393,
0.0015287375,
-0.0011076876,
-0.0337758884,
0.0457593501,
-0.0387422331,
0.0146823525,
-0.0424193218,
-0.0482010804,
-0.0366847701,
-0.0643267483,
0.0281192642,
-0.0108978031,
0.0442976654,
0.0292037781,
-0.0420442931,
-0.0157246683,
0.0177127384,
0.0191431306,
-0.0215731356,
0.0406709462,
-0.006996457,
0.0065343692,
0.0145010101,
0.0483597666,
-0.0462713242,
0.0360028446,
-0.0022774006,
-0.0073446594,
0.0192835312,
-0.0122761689,
-0.0137855336,
-0.023744408,
0.014964547,
0.0034643081,
0.0478673093,
0.0335473269,
-0.0275083482,
0.0065424419,
0.0003627194,
0.0131358718,
-0.0576129667,
0.0265679285,
0.0546742342,
0.0385165438,
0.009048651,
0.0580844209,
0.0320142657,
0.0366636142,
0.0172221381,
0.0441354215,
0.0004174278,
0.0431941859,
-0.0364261232,
-0.0003665677,
0.0215630736,
0.0191925094,
-0.0451863818,
-0.0331561789,
0.0213681795,
0.0431891493,
0.0377054103,
0.0295508858,
-0.0085478546,
0.0266659055,
-0.0518773608,
0.0534317456,
0.0100606792,
-0.0647008941,
-0.0039190263,
-0.0616648756,
0.0480341204,
0.0454286747,
0.0668456256,
-0.0148844067,
-0.078077279,
0.0048972401,
-0.0047843191,
0.0471909568,
0.0369364619,
-0.0321837328,
0.0053887949,
-0.0440531559,
-0.0567330942,
0.0008477835,
-0.0161959026,
0.0160348341,
0.0082128886,
0.0136510739,
0.0101141175,
0.0010406639,
0.0544641726,
-0.0002911635,
0.0013804395,
-0.0114502786,
0.0125176068,
-0.0057515125,
0.0617654659,
0.0273929052,
0.030507477,
0.0036206623,
0.0410705023,
0.0055081006,
-0.0089677079,
0.0553749055,
-0.0843522325,
-0.0956203192,
-0.0060565397,
0.0119980713,
0.0114483107,
-0.049296543,
-0.0301576778,
-0.0446194336,
0.0357627869,
-0.0029061921,
0.0537247695,
-0.058918193,
-0.0242649466,
0.0302181859,
-0.0461359508,
-0.0392572545,
0.0679945871,
0.0142919105,
-0.0177552737,
0.0720975399,
-0.0181347039,
0.0292677321,
-0.0414195582,
0.0261587817,
0.0390319787,
-0.0148432041,
-0.0055775316,
0.0274813119,
0.0158806853,
-0.061518319,
-0.0108349351,
-0.0972376317,
-0.0108067021,
-0.000318436,
0.0152077442,
-0.0065663634,
-0.0046805209,
-0.0019327243,
-0.0004073611,
-0.0702857897,
0.061538469,
0.0529632047,
-0.0116321687,
0.0275440961,
0.034894146,
0.027572209,
0.0027630499,
0.0404670313,
0.0396764353,
0.0306499507,
0.0284486935,
0.0006978677,
-0.0432349034,
0.0442570485,
-0.0974461883,
0.0031590939,
-0.0231045503,
-0.029721912,
0.0406834595,
0.02002538,
0.0220721811,
-0.0028781635,
0.0319523551,
0.0364601351,
-0.0168118291,
-0.046775829,
-0.079174675,
0.0527115315,
-0.04295462,
-0.0191642009,
-0.0353324227,
0.006744863,
0.018358605,
0.0310823172,
0.0510845445,
0.0121689411,
-0.0692821294,
0.048379086,
0.0214269198,
-0.0137998527,
-0.0268547293,
-0.0131751057,
-0.0147720193,
0.0570523441,
-0.0196158048,
-0.0157828685,
0.065406017,
0.0063693416,
-0.0175729897,
-0.0486929752,
0.0526063479,
-0.0184174366,
0.0343235917,
-0.0642411783,
0.0179657266,
0.0178939309,
-0.0080895899,
-0.0537336804,
-0.0297578871,
0.0398482196,
-0.0250005219,
0.0347274989,
-0.0644595325,
0.0269841813,
0.0237936582,
-0.0356331542,
-0.0792723149,
0.0255258847,
0.0211493149,
-0.0113380337,
0.018166801,
0.0061503234,
0.0141252521,
0.0001576982,
0.0482025556,
0.0152263371,
-0.0033902032,
-0.0067492831,
-0.0233593863,
0.0474235341,
0.0226127096,
0.0223551895,
0.0260731373,
0.0137318494,
0.0565211102,
0.0721778646,
0.019392455,
-0.0366641209,
0.0345955268,
0.0030442269,
0.0342592634,
-0.0137581071,
-0.0173550639,
0.026198782,
0.0460954569,
-0.0012587954,
-0.0092110848,
0.0862353817,
0.0210068226,
-0.0047202534,
-0.001734667,
-0.0351678841,
0.0550786927,
-0.002891026,
0.0112803224,
-0.075339973,
-0.0012497958,
-0.0204406232,
0.0295059402,
-0.0152468933,
-0.0535567701,
-0.0258227717,
-0.0738301799,
0.0740871206,
-0.0062618372,
-0.040325772,
-0.0298525561,
0.0170479752,
0.0248860158,
0.0547000803,
-0.0095015876,
0.0390072428,
0.0063464083,
0.004222509,
0.0187851489,
-0.00950028,
-0.0304492135,
-0.0028590153,
0.0115007889,
0.0294928029,
0.0504341759,
0.0483156852,
0.0644931048,
-0.0336116776,
-0.0057789851,
-0.0221695155,
0.039990373,
-0.0594870262,
0.005237916,
0.0243994128,
0.0091745108,
-0.0333155245,
0.0225594193,
-0.0252853949,
-0.0324583054,
0.0270277299,
0.0465161577,
-0.0619623363,
-0.0142794484,
0.0134424753,
0.0585846938,
0.0537317768,
0.0857025236,
0.0364939682,
-0.0097470377,
-0.0212414619,
-0.0222064666,
0.0131929405,
-0.0508096553,
-0.0087369885,
0.000280071,
0.0094871195,
0.0589755848,
-0.0879949182,
-0.0406145565,
0.0268653277,
0.0183551274,
-0.0210726522,
0.0061631198,
0.00310073,
0.000342864,
0.0135091878,
-0.0214288514,
-0.0081250863,
-0.0322242603,
-0.021621868,
-0.0538316891,
0.0288596973,
-0.0688759536,
-0.0118751107,
0.0026379887,
-0.0118150469,
-0.055671595,
-0.034322951,
0.0777622014,
0.0317189656,
0.0303269662,
0.0388950035,
0.0102253109,
0.0437194258,
0.0130322538,
-0.0325409137,
0.0205952134,
0.0150675513,
0.0589412376,
-0.0338507816,
0.0444536842,
-0.0279525276,
0.0252744313,
0.0242997501,
0.0508324169,
-0.0318096466,
-0.1023852527,
0.0028668551,
-0.0071733654,
0.0016134194,
-0.0017768578,
-0.0187341142,
-0.0365796313,
0.0298681781,
-0.0080651082,
0.0014673651,
-0.0772469938,
-0.0074672555,
-0.0542898476,
-0.038695652,
0.0129238442,
-0.044587817,
-0.0510980524,
0.0714444667,
-0.0179173537,
-0.0114324056,
0.0067023691,
-0.0059193429,
0.0173904896,
-0.0097903945,
-0.0348800793,
0.0027689061,
0.0168533418,
0.0148378061,
-0.0006545,
0.1219958737,
0.019861348,
-0.0390010439,
0.019042125,
-0.0124283088,
-0.0432017334,
-0.0580869019,
-0.0155106122,
0.0265141279,
0.0233107898,
0.0568512008,
0.0270334557,
-0.0412982702,
0.0070457775,
-0.0077766948,
0.0490369983,
0.0304051656,
-0.0269973278,
0.0156600326,
0.0275791772,
-0.0245283246,
-0.0211470742,
0.0724911541,
-0.0147012733,
0.031023195,
-0.0249421317,
-0.0047814911,
-0.0699163899,
-0.0646223947,
0.0144931152,
0.0054149139,
0.0141191259,
0.0412590466,
-0.0863370821,
-0.0337966047,
0.0156135792,
0.002782135,
-0.0254574958,
-0.0241694637,
0.0776335448,
0.0485478304,
-0.0018991781,
-0.058643911,
-0.0260528773,
0.0197048858,
-0.0835414678,
0.0060904752,
-0.0405962095,
-5.943544822e-33,
-0.0531031825,
-0.0345076509,
0.0547626019,
0.0000492335,
-0.0326905884,
-0.0302695967,
-0.0448011234,
0.0011396506,
-0.0158042572,
-0.01429193,
-0.0082650073,
-0.0389956422,
-0.0083721103,
0.0375760198,
-0.0475379303,
-0.0422287844,
0.0391786471,
-0.0108479029,
-0.01584699,
0.0702210069,
0.0254423916,
0.0054616919,
0.0207754653,
-0.0658143312,
0.0286954213,
-0.009023835,
0.0043267356,
0.0202020202,
-0.0275708679,
0.0586410984,
-0.0207692292,
0.046228122,
0.0147553263,
-0.0443870276,
0.0006964275,
0.0040553035,
-0.0450966172,
-0.0579417422,
0.0649237409,
-0.0187263507,
-0.0375818014,
-0.0249419883,
-0.0179170743,
-0.0182797089,
-0.0000232294,
-0.012484082,
-0.0069550811,
-0.0115586454,
-0.0296677072,
-0.0507883914,
-0.0600891486,
-0.005749621,
-0.0110297445,
-0.0333368331,
-0.0475425534,
0.0779410526,
-0.003041052,
-0.0438116416,
-0.0225618351,
0.021591315,
0.0299392808,
-0.0320836566,
0.0528081879,
0.0390927009,
0.0329318829,
0.0510300845,
-0.0278019775,
0.0036264397,
-0.039519757,
-0.0365198106,
-0.0401310995,
0.0462327339,
-0.0037986268,
0.0536080152,
-0.0320317931,
-0.0187352113,
-0.0627855957,
0.0166494027,
0.0167481285,
0.033997599,
0.0185497161,
-0.0017916558,
-0.0167200919,
-0.0343194976,
-0.0447392017,
0.0015864148,
-0.0175498147,
-0.0515051149,
0.0462044887,
0.0117032742,
-0.0496053919,
-0.0237048864,
0.0467962548,
-0.0012080423,
0.0087642055,
0.0504482016,
-0.0372731909,
-0.0021107562,
-0.0158536974,
-0.0127847837,
-0.046136681,
-0.0078443047,
0.0363803767,
-0.0295808874,
-0.006808355,
0.0372031741,
-0.0277800895,
-0.0042044474,
-0.0123901227,
0.0098288096,
-0.0319566242,
0.0729814842,
-0.0080078058,
-0.0222184882,
-0.0125113092,
0.0253044311,
-0.0132704852,
0.0251416545,
0.0046793544,
-0.0387853123,
-0.0347359516,
-0.0213250332,
0.009335544,
0.0242954753,
-0.0335227214,
0.0106693497,
0.0154298199,
-0.0125726555,
-0.0042045573,
-0.0155057395,
-0.0167794917,
0.0181630068,
2.659e-7,
-0.0091491761,
-0.007237921,
0.0095779058,
0.0094076646,
0.0203625765,
0.0141990483,
0.0342081301,
0.0017431146,
0.0350317135,
-0.0411792435,
0.0300724264,
0.0374399833,
0.0531558841,
0.016659325,
-0.0912649482,
-0.0261055715,
-0.0200096946,
-0.0348640122,
-0.0105677173,
-0.0165460091,
0.0861505568,
-0.0224862117,
-0.0415360592,
0.0207054652,
-0.0217880849,
-0.0101243984,
0.0582771637,
-0.0241782591,
0.0185039584,
0.0238334574,
0.0779727474,
-0.0401509628,
0.0108383596,
0.0572938994,
-0.0024458019,
-0.0092394399,
-0.0206020512,
0.0438918769,
0.0182130467,
-0.0945645049,
-0.0118970461,
-0.0054479223,
0.0419673733,
-0.0403615758,
0.0451024659,
-0.0569792576,
0.0243033692,
0.0342678018,
-0.0224154666,
-0.0523913279,
-0.0356592722,
-0.0246850532,
-0.0146080563,
0.0166969299,
0.0118673472,
0.0071813175,
0.0181490593,
-0.0430521071,
0.0311361849,
-0.0022716923,
-0.0707407296,
-0.0944635123,
-0.0298781805,
-0.0361269303,
0.006014348,
-0.0297365002,
0.0038498857,
2.050341098e-34,
-0.0248015281,
-0.0030799916,
0.0215928126,
0.0386245996,
0.0368990675,
0.0078353602,
0.0114967758,
0.0146711906,
0.0480041616,
-0.0642464012,
-0.0253101718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07654v1 | Audio-Visual Neural Syntax Acquisition | 2023-10-11T16:54:57 | 2023-10-11T16:54:57 | Cheng-I Jeff Lai, Freda Shi, Puyuan Peng, Yoon Kim, Kevin Gimpel, Shiyu Chang, Yung-Sung Chuang, Saurabhchand Bhati, David Cox, David Harwath, Yang Zhang, Karen Livescu, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We study phrase structure induction from visually-grounded speech. The core
idea is to first segment the speech waveform into sequences of word segments,
and subsequently induce phrase structure using the inferred segment-level
continuous representations. We present the Audio-Visual Neural Syntax Learner
(AV-NSL) that learns phrase structure by listening to audio and looking at
images, without ever being exposed to text. By training on paired images and
spoken captions, AV-NSL exhibits the capability to infer meaningful phrase
structures that are comparable to those derived by naturally-supervised text
parsers, for both English and German. Our findings extend prior work in
unsupervised language acquisition from speech and grounded grammar induction,
and present one approach to bridge the gap between the two topics. | [
-0.0170353446,
0.0480617769,
-0.0105204787,
0.0279264506,
-0.0338415876,
0.0014838044,
-0.0092879822,
-0.02934549,
-0.022782525,
-0.0252944734,
-0.0407432914,
-0.0150446324,
0.0263328459,
0.0375518613,
0.0356429704,
-0.0598140433,
0.015853839,
-0.0395901166,
-0.0123653105,
0.0273540169,
0.0227651522,
-0.0280060787,
-0.040038351,
0.0068473392,
-0.0669679493,
-0.003149993,
-0.0214938559,
-0.0269592255,
-0.041520346,
-0.025701765,
-0.0185377914,
0.0068287654,
0.0567665212,
-0.0135317827,
0.000001325,
-0.0331370533,
-0.005003578,
-0.0140847741,
0.0083908858,
-0.0159603693,
-0.0152124278,
-0.0619868487,
-0.0175943524,
-0.011423734,
-0.0672312379,
-0.024317164,
0.0401442498,
0.0315263346,
0.0462768078,
0.0364243872,
-0.0393407159,
-0.0317605846,
0.0423297957,
-0.0175601933,
0.0029237762,
0.0470105447,
-0.0003618779,
0.0403082781,
-0.0395166948,
-0.0086293966,
-0.0517745651,
0.0175634511,
0.0261312034,
0.0089151682,
0.0555547811,
0.0839095935,
-0.066869311,
-0.0450468697,
-0.0164554827,
0.0817510113,
0.0139094759,
-0.0013445609,
-0.0004458653,
0.017246874,
0.0011331548,
-0.0277766678,
-0.0433948562,
0.0861360878,
0.0143087441,
0.0670629516,
-0.0267853308,
-0.0414641462,
-0.0264649801,
-0.0329869725,
0.0503854305,
0.0360732637,
-0.0093223108,
-0.0097665302,
0.0282280017,
0.0223239902,
-0.0461828746,
-0.0350853465,
-0.0050800983,
-0.028696632,
0.058536604,
0.0289572515,
-0.0171837453,
-0.0256411824,
-0.0454820283,
-0.0776289701,
0.0252246484,
0.002784712,
-0.0694791973,
0.0726016983,
-0.0483139567,
0.0084820744,
0.0136281392,
-0.015668571,
-0.0051172543,
0.0646291003,
-0.0403221287,
-0.002926403,
-0.035138052,
0.0153743643,
-0.0381718762,
-0.0302231852,
-0.0060519669,
-0.0252760276,
-0.0253136177,
0.0308886841,
-0.0193472952,
0.0053017298,
-0.051728081,
0.0281295702,
-0.0381143466,
-0.0302719641,
-0.0064732353,
0.0691072717,
-0.0303567797,
-0.0198323466,
-0.0392784402,
0.0525200777,
0.0365728587,
0.0040969187,
-0.0032662258,
-0.003794299,
-0.0660708472,
-0.0358219668,
-0.0347600579,
-0.0432219133,
-0.0417779125,
0.0007867949,
0.0514884852,
-0.0589477681,
-0.0087754475,
-0.0116707189,
-0.0302154049,
-0.0492060184,
0.014913206,
0.0196571965,
0.0076815132,
0.0700286329,
-0.0225297567,
-0.0230484363,
-0.0153908953,
-0.014705319,
0.0075877905,
0.0670011863,
0.04161641,
-0.0052607432,
-0.0026087675,
-0.0010328006,
0.0007267677,
0.0184679907,
-0.000043454,
0.0273295734,
-0.1090165228,
-0.0318563022,
0.0087393671,
-0.0065674321,
0.0528416485,
0.0444046743,
-0.0402370021,
0.0156869944,
0.0381318778,
0.0484433025,
-0.0371876098,
0.0296868682,
0.0497708544,
-0.0006388737,
0.0024744547,
0.0684477538,
-0.0455223992,
0.013601115,
0.0048611565,
0.0431621447,
-0.0383641906,
-0.0085586086,
-0.0093019689,
-0.0255156942,
-0.0149837872,
-0.0319149606,
0.0303970948,
-0.0289496705,
0.028939385,
0.0757606477,
-0.0344282053,
0.0430224761,
0.0421128161,
-0.0607364289,
-0.0180993676,
0.0232727043,
-0.0007917899,
0.004648855,
-0.019411413,
-0.0136204064,
-0.0116610806,
-0.0101258038,
0.047856085,
0.0418979637,
-0.0402910858,
0.0006497176,
0.0297679529,
-0.0358977057,
-0.0095395548,
0.0027648502,
0.0147782248,
-0.0069187908,
-0.0392254777,
-0.0128234085,
-0.0137717659,
-0.0523743592,
0.0031997378,
0.0429634042,
0.0280504785,
-0.018936865,
-0.0270580016,
0.0461288467,
0.0038770596,
-0.0109664118,
-0.0211588852,
-0.0010651349,
0.0105677294,
-0.0355993211,
0.030450277,
0.0416139029,
-0.0799841285,
-0.0309375171,
-0.0004127035,
-0.0601759404,
-0.0143443439,
-0.0392703377,
0.0127247944,
-0.0072981045,
0.0137842353,
-0.0044333106,
0.0639913529,
-0.0478084087,
-0.0045684036,
0.0218904857,
0.0289338268,
0.0192412976,
0.0519213714,
-0.0082020098,
-0.0334342979,
-0.0367685966,
-0.0272990149,
-0.0017305191,
-0.0341040641,
0.0197756644,
-0.014483491,
-0.0065182936,
-0.0172105785,
-0.018413417,
0.007849941,
-0.1040237546,
0.0042222631,
-0.0826859772,
-0.02030636,
-0.0058058687,
0.0135179702,
-0.0073340866,
-0.0233988799,
0.0139100738,
-0.0444623008,
-0.0227164775,
0.0225064158,
-0.0239364412,
-0.0031468465,
0.0382560343,
0.0014194719,
-0.05929121,
-0.0431136079,
0.0079216985,
-0.0263271425,
0.0324403718,
0.020167958,
-0.0221075453,
-0.0086093657,
0.030290816,
0.0236412659,
0.0536456704,
0.006252293,
-0.0626478195,
0.0157176889,
-0.0371464789,
0.0312236808,
0.1076387018,
-0.0149264084,
0.0037165168,
0.0221743118,
-0.0065344078,
-0.0098458249,
-0.0067939358,
0.010774985,
0.0190611221,
-0.0304148849,
0.0570276491,
-0.0359066129,
0.0668823719,
-0.0025987716,
0.0255869199,
-0.0500021577,
0.0373962149,
-0.0056405528,
-0.0148623399,
-0.013671116,
-0.0373331346,
-0.0298455097,
0.0568549298,
-0.0193040092,
-0.0612086132,
0.0319076553,
-0.0649887249,
-0.0695109963,
-0.0099303741,
-0.021928994,
0.0085438006,
0.0585282296,
0.0543325245,
-0.0083432896,
0.0652027875,
-0.032563787,
-0.059663672,
0.006897761,
0.0406196788,
0.0457983017,
0.0617944598,
-0.0362128206,
-0.0023564082,
0.0077816504,
-0.024366498,
-0.0731332451,
-0.0098195449,
-0.0492765903,
0.0026333882,
-0.0705222785,
0.0396909453,
0.0306227375,
0.0013235372,
0.0249122176,
0.022933796,
0.0210490432,
0.0150525458,
-0.0429099798,
0.0268379021,
0.0255877394,
0.0110666584,
-0.0649495721,
-0.0071707005,
0.0389702432,
0.0325818248,
0.0699266195,
0.0146418279,
-0.0608684495,
0.072504513,
-0.0094978921,
0.0304116216,
-0.0103182606,
0.0407906771,
0.0092922738,
-0.0193315595,
-0.0202885866,
0.080123961,
0.0430224314,
-0.0150661645,
0.0111072408,
0.0390894562,
0.0418690406,
0.0200185627,
0.008696774,
-0.0404085182,
-0.0140493363,
0.0183616634,
-0.0004717789,
0.0433414206,
-0.0009604162,
-0.007151912,
-0.0861922875,
0.0251332466,
0.0203689486,
0.0025396615,
0.0137778642,
-0.0136997523,
-0.0172805693,
0.0122953886,
-0.0178414006,
0.0079621784,
-0.023248516,
0.0188382715,
-0.0005902857,
-0.0167520475,
-0.006224249,
0.0041902461,
-0.0694243535,
0.0032369958,
0.0411909521,
-0.0093000112,
-0.0603764728,
-0.0542575307,
0.056050811,
0.0177121833,
0.0087015182,
0.0084288502,
0.0567128696,
-0.008263615,
-0.040026281,
0.0494858474,
0.0876923352,
-0.010482938,
-0.0300541408,
0.0109383818,
0.0490115881,
0.0150384698,
0.0236556269,
0.0504938401,
0.0417281687,
0.0008741292,
0.0111465706,
0.0377341956,
-0.0321376212,
0.0211879779,
-0.0280873626,
0.0639274046,
-0.0466820598,
-0.0240700468,
0.0283931922,
-0.0277765598,
0.0197820514,
-0.0812281668,
-0.014542792,
0.0366736501,
0.0572508648,
0.0352589041,
-0.0357543901,
0.1011439338,
-0.0010011866,
-0.0308740716,
0.0648988113,
0.032219138,
-0.0001022696,
-0.0627126843,
-0.0709518567,
0.0362719931,
-0.0294089187,
-0.0437241606,
-0.0297643784,
-0.0063003828,
-0.0579580963,
0.0315356366,
0.0462169796,
0.0065236827,
0.0842108727,
0.0054603172,
0.0211163443,
0.0005734265,
0.014021487,
-0.0292481445,
0.0612019002,
0.013668227,
-0.0468721464,
0.0038218175,
0.0046863896,
-0.009250138,
0.023592962,
-0.0226967018,
-0.0017332496,
-0.0036803086,
0.0325702354,
0.0264171623,
-0.0187509581,
0.1114953607,
0.0156493243,
0.0634089708,
-0.0383755341,
0.0152311483,
-0.0234736353,
0.0335441567,
-0.0647994056,
0.014683431,
-0.0114212232,
0.0747829676,
0.0104251187,
0.0022955071,
-0.027728539,
0.0598947592,
0.0165142957,
0.0061823186,
0.0406243242,
-0.0479245186,
-0.0069513954,
0.0052388655,
0.0346927941,
0.0190819353,
-0.0295677222,
0.0517465398,
-0.0093286838,
0.0423806868,
0.0099113137,
-0.0113615422,
-0.0234442987,
0.0094840797,
0.0012550496,
0.0542723313,
-0.0197629724,
0.0198805109,
0.062571682,
-0.0860992521,
-0.0041438546,
-0.0397510007,
0.017414717,
0.031789761,
0.0157249942,
-0.0578728504,
-0.0531824641,
0.0284121819,
0.0257611424,
-0.0288649444,
-0.0057321088,
0.0482752733,
0.0194585063,
0.016979361,
-0.011002752,
0.0594389774,
-0.0253516342,
-0.0154051865,
-0.009167619,
-0.0059903529,
-0.0111768236,
0.0697505847,
0.0105551928,
-0.057240162,
0.0056628813,
0.0129192164,
0.0070046261,
-0.0124348616,
0.0627805144,
0.0221668705,
-0.0001871768,
0.0022182486,
0.0239579864,
-0.027686473,
0.0323521346,
-0.0022278714,
0.0006879722,
-5.145902845e-33,
-0.0339722857,
-0.0231335368,
0.0182519592,
0.0576213226,
-0.0098762587,
0.0151018975,
-0.0114156632,
0.051196631,
0.0525673553,
0.0192752425,
0.0420659333,
-0.0062455591,
0.0038116514,
0.0568556897,
0.0298379213,
0.020490231,
0.0188590884,
-0.0543916225,
0.0154235298,
-0.0192636866,
0.0028879431,
0.0235213302,
0.0201199856,
-0.0262208059,
-0.0506123193,
0.0648598969,
-0.0050644218,
0.0141973151,
0.0462425202,
0.073693648,
0.0040086778,
-0.0211971719,
-0.0185273699,
0.031002121,
-0.018763274,
0.0302890409,
-0.08805722,
0.0058745285,
0.0213242006,
0.0610451624,
-0.0753493086,
0.0251330435,
0.044268541,
-0.0598682202,
0.0061553167,
0.000552243,
0.0474585555,
-0.010860648,
0.0085203862,
0.016308628,
-0.068059057,
-0.0229650605,
0.000263539,
-0.0141131785,
0.0710968748,
-0.0097360779,
0.030574441,
-0.0105350884,
-0.040890485,
0.0287319049,
-0.0326285027,
0.0470293015,
0.023517672,
0.0074608177,
0.0195219722,
0.0589043461,
0.0314995237,
-0.0589069575,
-0.0309909116,
0.0272878595,
0.0434322581,
0.0227595195,
-0.0162183791,
-0.0213457812,
-0.0258325078,
0.0065583419,
-0.0339004733,
-0.0347099528,
0.0019301905,
0.0375778712,
-0.0402639657,
0.0254026782,
-0.0017922204,
0.0001653946,
-0.010826584,
-0.0255083386,
-0.0276693199,
-0.022505939,
0.0251507182,
0.0224661008,
0.0231125318,
0.0017054958,
0.0452041104,
0.0028115693,
-0.0085793454,
-0.0379684903,
-0.0041781543,
0.0100755682,
0.0190449432,
0.0228860229,
-0.0396233425,
-0.0471254103,
0.0545609072,
0.0148746641,
0.0570116043,
0.0198422745,
0.055189319,
-0.0067190332,
-0.0400844961,
0.00066958,
0.0057228752,
-0.0147104086,
0.0338910744,
0.0285328943,
0.0349110849,
0.0462396927,
-0.0613832027,
0.0421270244,
-0.0031043333,
-0.0210263655,
-0.0598555207,
-0.0379820429,
-0.0782211199,
0.0684745908,
-0.044421941,
-0.0246697795,
0.0026174989,
-0.0391101129,
0.0467968732,
-0.0565613396,
-0.0249978006,
0.0164789129,
2.289e-7,
-0.0185647458,
0.0396109931,
0.0342923254,
0.0122806579,
0.0354998969,
0.052965261,
-0.0727731436,
-0.0080231335,
-0.0279295482,
-0.0648477599,
-0.0260202084,
-0.0095641427,
0.002422391,
-0.019077288,
-0.0637378097,
0.0408799648,
-0.0027074201,
0.0207930952,
-0.0296036173,
0.0026808616,
0.0400918536,
0.0828524828,
-0.0475405045,
0.0078003048,
0.0149642844,
-0.0696311295,
0.0572375134,
0.0228101909,
-0.0352045521,
-0.0732851401,
-0.0722252801,
0.001994075,
-0.0816373974,
0.0293451548,
-0.0299999584,
-0.0062126461,
0.0227321014,
0.020257378,
-0.0040153293,
0.0131405443,
-0.0150995506,
0.0687557757,
-0.0334470831,
-0.0024215735,
0.0481151007,
-0.079371646,
-0.0257858839,
0.010520977,
-0.0322252028,
0.0008280348,
-0.0270172246,
0.0209990535,
-0.033525303,
-0.0081286579,
0.0513417907,
-0.0105657894,
-0.0191376302,
-0.0132692801,
-0.0247172229,
0.0411890261,
-0.0029152161,
-0.0360997505,
-0.015355316,
-0.0029766595,
-0.0051463856,
0.032628011,
-0.0520132557,
1.507758735e-34,
0.0003781352,
-0.0168715492,
0.0638297573,
0.0254214685,
0.0084101968,
-0.0149476742,
-0.0205281302,
0.0177602079,
0.0032794802,
-0.0405741073,
-0.014755019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07652v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07652v2 | LLM4Vis: Explainable Visualization Recommendation using ChatGPT | 2023-10-11T16:51:46 | 2023-10-16T03:34:47 | Lei Wang, Songheng Zhang, Yun Wang, Ee-Peng Lim, Yong Wang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Data visualization is a powerful tool for exploring and communicating
insights in various domains. To automate visualization choice for datasets, a
task known as visualization recommendation has been proposed. Various
machine-learning-based approaches have been developed for this purpose, but
they often require a large corpus of dataset-visualization pairs for training
and lack natural explanations for their results. To address this research gap,
we propose LLM4Vis, a novel ChatGPT-based prompting approach to perform
visualization recommendation and return human-like explanations using very few
demonstration examples. Our approach involves feature description,
demonstration example selection, explanation generation, demonstration example
construction, and inference steps. To obtain demonstration examples with
high-quality explanations, we propose a new explanation generation
bootstrapping to iteratively refine generated explanations by considering the
previous generation and template-based hint. Evaluations on the VizML dataset
show that LLM4Vis outperforms or performs similarly to supervised learning
models like Random Forest, Decision Tree, and MLP in both few-shot and
zero-shot settings. The qualitative evaluation also shows the effectiveness of
explanations generated by LLM4Vis. We make our code publicly available at
\href{https://github.com/demoleiwang/LLM4Vis}{https://github.com/demoleiwang/LLM4Vis}. | [
-0.0194309801,
-0.0051206625,
0.0000489486,
0.0087166987,
-0.0110725909,
0.0240543559,
-0.0004472788,
0.0142809097,
0.0034710395,
0.0405883826,
0.0406885371,
0.0598147921,
0.0057843379,
0.041502092,
0.0183986947,
-0.0940971226,
0.0033827825,
-0.0093930503,
-0.0153066488,
0.0101092272,
0.0056932834,
0.0007732232,
-0.0226679035,
0.062862806,
0.0052268184,
-0.0369744599,
-0.056719929,
0.0169137027,
0.0220038034,
-0.0680109262,
-0.061370533,
-0.0139173511,
0.0400321707,
-0.0196494497,
0.0000026143,
-0.0272775311,
-0.0169914477,
0.0120809944,
-0.054867167,
-0.002093703,
-0.0214453023,
0.0067935139,
0.0569939055,
0.004683617,
-0.0184482764,
-0.0031143527,
0.0684909523,
0.0607800409,
0.0493187793,
0.0067626419,
-0.0037222742,
-0.0115078362,
-0.0369917713,
-0.0082909912,
0.0636012927,
0.0228841156,
-0.0311971288,
0.0135617172,
0.0104034077,
0.0380963273,
-0.0173262376,
-0.0076330798,
0.0191860367,
-0.024321219,
0.0739931911,
0.0523255654,
-0.0144570246,
-0.0238841362,
-0.0013685529,
0.0753657967,
0.0089465883,
-0.0113105932,
0.002999983,
-0.0135440053,
-0.0045881202,
0.0449411087,
-0.078843385,
-0.0472308211,
-0.0200838111,
0.0026989221,
-0.0217593983,
0.0255372431,
0.0265384521,
-0.0332442448,
0.0178777501,
-0.0010316564,
-0.0471395254,
0.0149614224,
-0.0153486636,
-0.0103003215,
-0.0122374604,
-0.052572947,
-0.0276310984,
0.0457625985,
-0.0627564788,
-0.013168335,
0.0451974235,
0.0125904093,
0.0072956001,
0.0117167654,
0.0521639325,
0.021268487,
-0.0690319911,
0.0391520709,
0.0056002564,
0.0233158153,
0.010453091,
0.0108547136,
-0.0011888009,
0.0058725905,
-0.0704334304,
0.002934973,
-0.0005782522,
-0.0023342073,
-0.0342872851,
0.0080064936,
-0.0266508125,
0.0424220785,
-0.0206550788,
0.0447986647,
0.0003609656,
0.0437097549,
0.0029447854,
0.0279493704,
-0.0908436701,
-0.0044394541,
-0.0750432909,
-0.0160917304,
0.002500443,
-0.0444063284,
-0.0177707989,
0.0360489264,
-0.0037886172,
0.0163295716,
-0.0111697866,
0.0855266377,
0.0105115669,
0.0127422819,
-0.0400752239,
-0.0470435619,
0.0209636185,
-0.0229138192,
0.0013870876,
-0.0325192474,
0.0005089371,
0.0149572976,
0.0141600454,
0.0205531716,
-0.0082508251,
0.0213493761,
-0.0132338898,
0.0858640373,
-0.0458057821,
-0.0013524237,
-0.007279919,
-0.0081480024,
-0.0727446675,
0.0259186216,
-0.0079330914,
0.0461457111,
0.0171032231,
-0.058749225,
0.061466001,
-0.0391249098,
0.0147256888,
0.0084298812,
-0.0152779575,
0.0244049784,
-0.0609686896,
0.0376139581,
0.0070843515,
-0.0366028175,
-0.0515459739,
0.0112186614,
0.0140425954,
0.0502124913,
0.0657677501,
-0.004036969,
0.0396644473,
0.028599875,
-0.0038687245,
-0.0157905482,
-0.011365273,
0.082515277,
-0.0191614684,
-0.0092370985,
-0.0147117684,
0.0013594213,
-0.0122463275,
-0.0702688172,
0.0014718827,
0.0134712169,
0.0010417163,
0.0027282874,
0.0398054346,
0.0216975082,
-0.0049139629,
-0.0130828694,
0.0406045616,
-0.018186722,
-0.0697059929,
-0.0332509279,
0.0718115121,
0.0850056484,
0.0574467033,
-0.0103785247,
0.0018438137,
-0.0219843723,
0.0414430611,
-0.0289416555,
0.0533830002,
-0.0070301131,
0.0163229872,
-0.0216476768,
-0.0717688203,
-0.0517868996,
-0.0004927485,
0.0241534114,
-0.0064069983,
-0.0154410722,
0.0005198483,
-0.0960217267,
-0.0362334102,
0.0163268503,
0.0245167017,
-0.0100449622,
0.0720300451,
0.0161846075,
0.0118038198,
0.038330175,
0.0432209298,
0.0052109584,
0.0274005812,
0.0176481958,
0.0340623036,
0.0459986925,
0.0079988362,
-0.076237753,
-0.0210055895,
-0.0622877851,
0.0011348422,
-0.0332125761,
-0.0538702346,
-0.0303842369,
-0.0136228958,
-0.0228220187,
0.0430903621,
-0.0151951825,
-0.0175450016,
-0.0141995503,
0.0043777796,
-0.0168932006,
0.0552246161,
0.0224210788,
0.0088307774,
0.0083777672,
0.011928007,
0.0285609402,
-0.0094365738,
0.0471298099,
0.0019473791,
-0.0101080798,
-0.0252865981,
-0.0153752742,
0.0050820606,
-0.0305827465,
0.0839160085,
-0.0547163077,
-0.0284405965,
0.0131836329,
-0.0097273821,
-0.0227777138,
-0.0041413731,
-0.0108697731,
-0.0573819242,
-0.0327402465,
0.0423520915,
-0.0362691693,
-0.0157405119,
0.0748263299,
-0.0150211249,
-0.0071614408,
0.0100213382,
0.0258256495,
-0.0026090764,
0.0712097287,
0.0556201823,
0.0184284598,
-0.0438365154,
-0.0195772294,
0.0031056255,
-0.0488871858,
-0.0274657179,
0.018123636,
0.042191837,
-0.0038348341,
-0.0070060301,
0.0033668284,
-0.0310300514,
0.0812992677,
0.0356291011,
0.0316962041,
-0.0674882606,
0.0044196271,
-0.038886901,
0.0431524888,
0.02835452,
-0.004155973,
0.0119414767,
-0.0166689232,
-0.0179858916,
0.017259011,
-0.0288680736,
0.0380389094,
0.0568016432,
0.0231129956,
-0.0528617054,
-0.0080849156,
0.0088573694,
0.0471060164,
-0.0032798874,
-0.0806849375,
0.0748195425,
-0.0289576836,
-0.0107912887,
-0.0057794941,
-0.0344889611,
-0.0380121917,
0.0707636774,
-0.0188308265,
-0.0072545912,
0.0124797812,
-0.0043420722,
0.0292184334,
-0.005642036,
0.0369976275,
-0.0167493168,
-0.0124519374,
-0.0447478369,
-0.0478708819,
0.0318272114,
0.0109735448,
-0.0434879102,
-0.0198105872,
-0.0219632853,
-0.0308747701,
0.0021337185,
-0.025507072,
-0.0194979906,
-0.0009789193,
0.0208608694,
-0.0109822266,
-0.0128691858,
-0.0357789434,
0.0060238792,
-0.0263504516,
-0.0204158053,
0.0443170108,
-0.0009053929,
-0.039642822,
0.0582495667,
0.0285225976,
0.0029020342,
-0.0033551422,
-0.0776143298,
0.0230277553,
-0.0500714518,
0.024269253,
0.0014785002,
-0.0019195531,
0.071838364,
-0.0178480763,
0.0358954482,
0.050493598,
0.0179817397,
-0.0608774051,
0.0426656157,
-0.0017617441,
0.0556651577,
0.0212842468,
0.0244994648,
-0.0922520831,
-0.0433310159,
-0.0059831711,
0.0643666163,
0.0266367644,
-0.0211009681,
-0.0183467567,
-0.0550925471,
0.0923646241,
-0.0146923447,
-0.0392206013,
-0.0167153087,
-0.0934732407,
-0.0036551848,
-0.0402279161,
-0.0192413758,
-0.016151879,
-0.0055584181,
0.0362038389,
0.0108200526,
-0.0278633703,
-0.0669838265,
0.0256900676,
-0.0104216216,
-0.0046166666,
0.0471540168,
0.0329038911,
0.0168217849,
-0.0277306642,
-0.0137610557,
0.056176208,
0.0516889505,
-0.0497606657,
0.1232030168,
0.0415362455,
-0.0206030346,
-0.0226183645,
0.0533696935,
0.0151576698,
-0.0287383776,
0.0295147747,
0.0577045195,
-0.0713839754,
0.0063058394,
-0.0351350084,
0.0025131917,
0.0168283116,
0.0511417091,
0.0681574121,
-0.0112431236,
-0.0066744047,
-0.0545372218,
0.017819643,
-0.014866434,
-0.0262443535,
-0.0060743177,
-0.0021281638,
-0.0362934656,
-0.0304450858,
-0.0042490484,
0.0562016368,
0.047007814,
-0.007409784,
-0.0110204238,
-0.0919734836,
0.0132507505,
-0.0315652378,
0.0636127219,
0.0446082428,
0.0183734894,
0.0102012763,
-0.0345492736,
0.0204674676,
-0.0602176189,
-0.005009362,
0.0094477823,
-0.0227821656,
-0.0088735549,
-0.0720212013,
0.0230053775,
0.0215418544,
0.0806371719,
-0.0060805599,
-0.0506165735,
0.0595779456,
0.0991312414,
-0.0097719776,
-0.0792729482,
-0.0044723023,
0.0184877682,
-0.0042699422,
-0.0157449767,
0.0018124478,
0.0080632316,
-0.0344527289,
-0.0277877711,
-0.0369675271,
0.0388135947,
0.0263463315,
0.0048112269,
0.0825111791,
-0.006881217,
-0.0331959501,
0.0030741394,
-0.0069950442,
0.0064473599,
-0.0032806366,
-0.035616532,
0.0424632877,
-0.0130156688,
-0.050013449,
0.0276118573,
-0.0475896373,
-0.0267330334,
-0.0340384543,
-0.0770511627,
0.0276253428,
-0.0104710171,
-0.0176363681,
0.0010274933,
0.0388680995,
0.0018610356,
-0.0146666467,
-0.0181985367,
0.0108513981,
0.0245780386,
0.051377669,
0.0235242173,
0.0321922414,
0.008015695,
0.0135423699,
-0.0518436395,
-0.05530129,
0.0099993944,
0.0636189282,
0.0009782087,
-0.0071514389,
0.0153135015,
-0.0191417616,
0.0109533574,
-0.0017842378,
0.0402526259,
-0.0224569887,
-0.0159426425,
0.0263050999,
0.0231428519,
-0.0380487218,
-0.0527982414,
0.0600005612,
-0.00757564,
-0.0089653572,
-0.0135657601,
-0.0200644098,
-0.0543005988,
0.0384252891,
0.0511995815,
0.0524332039,
0.0222001448,
-0.0036227405,
-0.0455618314,
-0.0465730578,
-0.0330180489,
-0.0382534675,
-0.0301296767,
0.0011696711,
0.039148137,
0.0643238053,
-0.005097012,
-0.0273040254,
-0.0126455221,
-0.0098279221,
-0.017953096,
-0.0216807798,
-0.0187727921,
-6.738320063e-33,
0.022064358,
-0.0715306997,
0.0290748216,
0.0230458658,
0.0252931751,
-0.0193257276,
-0.0478149094,
-0.0163380839,
-0.0096895536,
0.0545570031,
-0.0069755316,
-0.0298847966,
-0.0132454094,
0.0126010915,
0.0245450083,
-0.013162002,
0.0392109267,
0.0359595269,
-0.0279097576,
0.0514607467,
0.021935543,
0.0152996611,
0.0287266485,
-0.1102529913,
0.0204208605,
0.043512255,
-0.0279027671,
-0.004876154,
-0.0137855476,
0.0467956997,
-0.0190976094,
0.0249089692,
-0.0082299178,
-0.0333909132,
-0.0324659608,
-0.0151693271,
-0.0500422567,
-0.0657196566,
0.0094829677,
0.0058726198,
-0.0951431766,
-0.0185444839,
0.0280258078,
-0.0201744121,
0.0114520742,
-0.0314854793,
0.060389556,
-0.0096894903,
-0.0366142951,
0.0161750913,
0.02885448,
0.0435643457,
-0.0683185458,
-0.0552236587,
0.0333226845,
0.0639977157,
0.0113580115,
0.0442357957,
-0.0024042444,
0.0708117336,
0.0568091907,
-0.0493254401,
0.0488391407,
-0.0230296068,
0.0252260398,
0.0521687195,
0.0220553707,
-0.0329122022,
-0.0252283476,
0.0279727187,
-0.0409310423,
0.109946318,
0.0644973218,
0.0019128053,
0.0460006781,
-0.0053101745,
-0.0161791835,
0.0689941943,
-0.0172059946,
-0.0024551817,
-0.0033976855,
0.0142721701,
-0.0421251245,
-0.0345806479,
0.0184789486,
-0.0507181361,
-0.0249480251,
-0.0510408171,
0.0160979778,
-0.0089389933,
-0.0431937464,
0.0313401185,
-0.0253032111,
-0.0237113312,
-0.0064457762,
-0.0014878856,
-0.012118699,
-0.008076489,
0.0195705574,
-0.0802130476,
0.0086600399,
-0.0107116289,
0.018956067,
-0.00533712,
0.0363393016,
0.010933497,
0.0360848084,
0.0066160709,
-0.0134126246,
-0.0058548269,
-0.025590295,
-0.0317275226,
-0.0320058316,
-0.0693441033,
0.0246729739,
-0.0005195342,
-0.0613400079,
0.0441789217,
-0.0036283846,
0.0203247443,
-0.0165274628,
-0.0363815986,
-0.0746360719,
0.0145192556,
-0.0006039141,
-0.0410805307,
-0.0107201524,
-0.0677509233,
0.0595982894,
-0.0495720617,
-0.0278988834,
-0.002284477,
3.125e-7,
0.0106548639,
0.0556050725,
0.0118116476,
0.0013017878,
-0.0022680089,
0.0303898137,
0.0001190192,
-0.0143225072,
-0.0254638363,
-0.0242399629,
0.0406386629,
0.0063199555,
0.058682397,
0.0321701579,
-0.0542558804,
-0.0037504879,
-0.0429773293,
-0.0265522879,
-0.0632297844,
0.0077319262,
0.0815597847,
0.0288294107,
0.0241766237,
-0.0120545067,
0.0585139692,
-0.0104484856,
0.0203809179,
-0.0696772262,
0.0201694928,
-0.0302653201,
0.0209244955,
0.0179574043,
0.0224018544,
0.0088310242,
-0.0375366658,
-0.0341663919,
-0.0427532867,
-0.0046633007,
0.0086471327,
-0.0001828017,
0.0131883062,
0.006349104,
0.0414887704,
-0.0391576551,
0.0586058237,
-0.0584052876,
-0.044726871,
0.0055932212,
-0.0156381279,
-0.0138492873,
0.0398393497,
-0.0021510241,
-0.0047496837,
0.0191991087,
-0.0295689683,
-0.0263846237,
-0.0121231768,
-0.021984918,
-0.0386861376,
0.0014019316,
-0.0258368347,
0.0097197713,
-0.0127262985,
0.0079533178,
0.0133497324,
0.0179943778,
-0.0359550118,
2.870265168e-34,
0.0555799268,
0.015997339,
0.0035555353,
0.0301312674,
0.0321528614,
0.0032401714,
0.0483089797,
-0.0031391832,
0.063025482,
-0.0052282643,
-0.0215964746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07644v2 | Rethinking the BERT-like Pretraining for DNA Sequences | 2023-10-11T16:40:57 | 2023-10-12T03:32:32 | Chaoqi Liang, Weiqiang Bai, Lifeng Qiao, Yuchen Ren, Jianle Sun, Peng Ye, Hongliang Yan, Xinzhu Ma, Wangmeng Zuo, Wanli Ouyang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | With the success of large-scale pretraining in NLP, there is an increasing
trend of applying it to the domain of life sciences. In particular, pretraining
methods based on DNA sequences have garnered growing attention due to their
potential to capture generic information about genes. However, existing
pretraining methods for DNA sequences largely rely on direct adoptions of BERT
pretraining from NLP, lacking a comprehensive understanding and a specifically
tailored approach. To address this research gap, we first conducted a series of
exploratory experiments and gained several insightful observations: 1) In the
fine-tuning phase of downstream tasks, when using K-mer overlapping
tokenization instead of K-mer non-overlapping tokenization, both overlapping
and non-overlapping pretraining weights show consistent performance
improvement.2) During the pre-training process, using K-mer overlapping
tokenization quickly produces clear K-mer embeddings and reduces the loss to a
very low level, while using K-mer non-overlapping tokenization results in less
distinct embeddings and continuously decreases the loss. 3) Using overlapping
tokenization causes the self-attention in the intermediate layers of
pre-trained models to tend to overly focus on certain tokens, reflecting that
these layers are not adequately optimized. In summary, overlapping tokenization
can benefit the fine-tuning of downstream tasks but leads to inadequate
pretraining with fast convergence. To unleash the pretraining potential, we
introduce a novel approach called RandomMask, which gradually increases the
task difficulty of BERT-like pretraining by continuously expanding its mask
boundary, forcing the model to learn more knowledge. RandomMask is simple but
effective, achieving top-tier performance across 26 datasets of 28 datasets
spanning 7 downstream tasks. | [
0.0190946907,
0.0592703,
0.0019736777,
-0.0350156873,
0.0011132699,
0.0127402032,
0.0264832862,
0.0068883821,
-0.0178512521,
-0.0323630311,
-0.0222304035,
0.0037139372,
0.0042434782,
-0.0058785737,
0.0435673818,
-0.0155675095,
0.057098195,
0.0417328477,
0.0390453562,
-0.0130624892,
0.0188533813,
-0.0155437635,
0.0160055868,
0.0389040709,
-0.0276529025,
-0.0113150189,
-0.0086549232,
-0.0027281437,
0.0366214961,
-0.0367749594,
0.0363506265,
0.0696932226,
0.0094393939,
0.0379985645,
0.0000016365,
-0.0380207635,
-0.000872208,
0.0095517971,
-0.0208723135,
0.0459961481,
-0.0446653627,
0.0395645015,
0.0247187931,
-0.0032043711,
0.0013914015,
-0.015591776,
0.0740617514,
0.071406208,
0.0368477516,
0.0507345907,
0.00051694,
-0.0234972071,
0.0241268966,
-0.0166450553,
0.0209663548,
0.0117269959,
0.0500763692,
-0.0379470326,
-0.0110974088,
-0.0268225893,
0.0065136538,
0.0312122554,
-0.0011621444,
0.0401672684,
0.0191149712,
0.0630883053,
-0.0701206848,
-0.0426849052,
0.0104732793,
0.0554810129,
-0.066795297,
-0.0253697764,
-0.0028037964,
0.0088750087,
0.016843738,
-0.0219709072,
-0.0303661078,
0.0184630901,
-0.0036799158,
0.053190738,
-0.0371314436,
-0.0115180174,
0.0411143601,
0.0008247002,
-0.0460321568,
0.0346552171,
0.0288591236,
-0.0398967974,
-0.0264505688,
0.0265115593,
-0.0327069499,
-0.0438554324,
0.0657396838,
0.0046670013,
0.0158378072,
-0.0085447291,
-0.0433527716,
-0.0657463074,
0.0577400774,
-0.0299924351,
0.0711397305,
0.0125710983,
-0.0720146298,
-0.0018572268,
-0.0490963422,
0.0028176075,
-0.0187427159,
0.0564075783,
0.015345416,
-0.0032446347,
-0.0576566532,
-0.0175352879,
-0.0382661149,
0.0682601631,
-0.0197261069,
0.000969331,
-0.0416670404,
-0.0286073145,
-0.0012478918,
-0.0176281948,
-0.0231254902,
-0.0034838626,
-0.0373646319,
0.0678349063,
0.024547467,
0.0106253559,
-0.0322511531,
-0.0003752153,
0.0076139714,
-0.0275577735,
-0.0434037186,
-0.0065289531,
0.0337788723,
-0.0404005907,
0.0135030039,
0.0381979682,
0.0175251961,
-0.059403684,
0.00579393,
0.0010563779,
-0.0462432168,
-0.0063153435,
0.0020323216,
-0.0150123229,
0.0341520905,
0.0002214984,
-0.0186347477,
0.018748818,
0.0100315306,
-0.0202612355,
-0.037420772,
0.0941054523,
-0.0278652217,
-0.0571371056,
0.0074605709,
0.0185882039,
0.0262845363,
0.0402655676,
-0.0044027111,
0.008871451,
0.0209730547,
-0.0376500823,
-0.0118241357,
0.0135091133,
0.0541383512,
-0.068263866,
0.0097510936,
-0.0042108097,
0.0148866614,
0.0464769416,
0.0451726094,
-0.0036038118,
-0.036529772,
-0.0255950335,
0.021146819,
0.0624497272,
0.0287719183,
0.0501398854,
0.0359101817,
0.0213080589,
0.0087624574,
0.0219333377,
-0.0160393212,
-0.008483313,
-0.0183203053,
0.0373567864,
0.0199584905,
0.0300264694,
-0.0232995991,
-0.0123621561,
-0.0198291335,
0.0078519415,
-0.0194634479,
-0.0220445264,
0.0297374614,
0.0099198241,
-0.0301792286,
0.0876526386,
0.0426338725,
-0.059655875,
0.015583761,
-0.0418390259,
0.0126801636,
0.0449057706,
0.0249953549,
-0.0619725846,
-0.058557488,
0.0246145427,
-0.0217296369,
0.0026669633,
-0.002827313,
-0.0160574894,
0.038428288,
-0.0240339935,
-0.0461788028,
-0.0184787102,
0.0050361366,
0.0191165134,
0.0090089012,
-0.0108658811,
0.0192213822,
-0.0173595753,
0.0143734943,
0.0638007298,
-0.0109323878,
-0.0116396081,
-0.0214205608,
0.0119728167,
0.0407333635,
0.0388198644,
-0.049470339,
0.0397308618,
0.0532644838,
-0.0457863323,
-0.0219918527,
-0.0216549356,
-0.0170280207,
-0.0760723129,
0.0556720495,
-0.0340855345,
-0.0330302306,
0.0324068069,
-0.0399478301,
-0.0226058494,
0.0043687741,
-0.0450323448,
0.0899391174,
-0.0425694399,
0.002444841,
-0.0016496029,
0.0074329493,
-0.0316795632,
0.0295793209,
0.0090348702,
0.0239128061,
-0.0146365613,
-0.0117048407,
0.0254440866,
-0.0507217348,
0.0131713236,
-0.0312318187,
-0.0210797377,
-0.0252626594,
0.005639893,
-0.0116238892,
-0.0476889797,
0.0081615755,
-0.1169238463,
-0.0102542797,
0.0063637192,
0.0421243943,
-0.0338887274,
0.0053625423,
-0.0020597752,
-0.0184024833,
-0.0325145945,
-0.0587781966,
-0.0755054876,
0.0237804409,
0.0343361609,
0.0014646071,
-0.0005013716,
-0.0125250211,
-0.0308253597,
-0.0398899056,
0.0658989251,
-0.0143679501,
-0.042926129,
-0.0100573637,
-0.0620744787,
-0.0339234471,
0.0100196097,
0.0211439934,
-0.0519720614,
0.0114675993,
0.000033003,
0.0599556156,
-0.0044828933,
0.0036017543,
0.0078165485,
0.0264702942,
0.0002285999,
-0.0421463624,
0.0237676464,
-0.0170166492,
0.0303279441,
0.0164443664,
0.0311245397,
0.0280054882,
0.0853771865,
-0.0588289574,
-0.0416697972,
-0.0633028373,
-0.0090213716,
0.0215886626,
-0.0213582329,
-0.0090161311,
-0.0310429297,
-0.042951934,
0.014232384,
-0.0170733426,
-0.0199392773,
0.0626619533,
-0.0134147611,
-0.0075330865,
-0.0458059348,
0.0288528651,
-0.02085202,
0.0341996737,
0.0029170222,
0.0269012526,
0.0397092775,
-0.0422327518,
0.0095065786,
0.0273105111,
-0.0477006473,
-0.0406264625,
-0.0108593032,
0.0072416617,
0.0097985836,
-0.0056907469,
-0.0292142015,
-0.026149299,
-0.0174083654,
-0.007731169,
0.0225500092,
0.0703685433,
-0.0229985062,
-0.0296977535,
0.017501628,
0.0078477738,
0.0287914686,
-0.0050580068,
0.0221936163,
-0.0091805486,
0.0510100275,
0.0039585284,
-0.0286520422,
0.0505778715,
0.0086891521,
-0.0133742355,
0.0340148881,
0.0348197632,
-0.0002758186,
-0.0014909059,
0.0130775301,
0.0153070521,
-0.0698728412,
-0.009260945,
-0.0048971237,
0.0523856767,
-0.0353341475,
-0.0128264902,
0.0984598324,
0.0289273318,
0.0094136493,
0.021564506,
-0.0026017334,
-0.0028396947,
-0.0169492662,
0.0285302028,
-0.0905158147,
-0.0347249694,
-0.0096303532,
-0.0102997255,
0.0032235372,
-0.0429978296,
0.034226831,
-0.0685819238,
0.0013232479,
0.0234662369,
-0.0224993154,
-0.0220901035,
-0.0634356886,
-0.0441036038,
-0.0306237619,
0.0284581501,
-0.0073670531,
0.0028672908,
0.0208346471,
0.0417889431,
-0.006696994,
-0.069655776,
0.0320261493,
-0.0673794374,
-0.0028460915,
0.0843625218,
0.0204737037,
-0.0120255193,
-0.0298202634,
0.019626651,
-0.0064379857,
-0.0142078074,
0.0112681212,
0.0576925874,
-0.0000683007,
-0.0346388035,
-0.0334367678,
-0.0313878581,
0.0053744363,
-0.0386404432,
-0.016496608,
0.0783160776,
0.0158159174,
-0.0339525864,
-0.029799467,
0.008929898,
-0.0401103012,
0.0700468794,
0.0627643988,
-0.0118728159,
-0.0271901656,
-0.0013871267,
0.0671538562,
-0.0772128552,
0.0112318806,
0.0452812724,
-0.0643574744,
-0.0222508218,
-0.0775353611,
-0.0457654372,
0.0545894168,
0.0325302929,
0.0065885754,
0.0044406955,
0.0039817402,
-0.0252930187,
-0.0736253411,
0.0812474638,
0.0061496641,
-0.0195073653,
-0.0514806621,
-0.0646656081,
0.0267295949,
0.0070286929,
-0.0194800906,
0.036333587,
-0.0129051888,
-0.0779693872,
0.0084530832,
0.067452468,
0.0137671558,
0.023919126,
0.0196693577,
-0.0807214826,
0.0922406912,
0.0367785506,
-0.025031779,
-0.0357619748,
0.0402240679,
-0.0400543995,
-0.0153408935,
0.007508026,
-0.0348934568,
0.020835951,
0.0113118161,
0.0449073911,
0.0024928886,
0.019379653,
0.0292502083,
0.0378881544,
0.1026378796,
-0.006780772,
0.0149044432,
-0.0188537352,
0.029939333,
0.0022059914,
-0.0035485865,
-0.0071315425,
-0.0272908732,
0.0020200887,
-0.0038271379,
-0.0316790901,
0.0509429574,
-0.0191458445,
0.0086681293,
-0.0636355355,
0.0173495188,
-0.0141124856,
0.0041006631,
0.0261852629,
-0.0195641629,
-0.0184630901,
0.0111916242,
-0.0005415685,
-0.0177199189,
-0.0350228027,
-0.055244565,
0.0210329294,
0.0668166876,
-0.0298909359,
0.0349044874,
-0.0375438035,
0.0240913257,
-0.0266161691,
0.0207675528,
0.0471370369,
-0.0559425429,
0.0038488994,
0.0056423056,
-0.0424179062,
-0.0153775839,
0.0205496177,
-0.0362252407,
-0.0074127093,
0.0366492644,
0.0080612134,
-0.0581236221,
-0.0717097446,
0.0789305791,
0.0463176779,
0.0815653503,
-0.0097909244,
-0.0473243557,
-0.0282775089,
-0.0215336941,
0.077200979,
0.0184921771,
-0.0444962643,
-0.0240598656,
-0.0238752756,
-0.0442419872,
0.0340228043,
-0.0003385771,
-0.0131425895,
0.0430464745,
0.0268356167,
0.0000185852,
0.0179147366,
-0.0471465737,
0.0261318218,
0.0408484414,
0.0468784571,
-0.0470348336,
0.0407839492,
-5.998887831e-33,
-0.0059792581,
0.0032887829,
-0.0013587695,
-0.0208959263,
-0.019062385,
0.0214889403,
-0.0258377269,
-0.0209678821,
-0.0149056148,
0.0242871754,
-0.0062962691,
-0.0083272979,
0.0068043,
0.0040631406,
0.0215556212,
-0.0031844089,
0.0562136434,
0.0064737066,
0.0218172017,
0.0120760081,
-0.0033283471,
0.0827933252,
0.0588591024,
0.0017851633,
-0.0349772535,
0.0359521359,
0.042939838,
-0.0377706029,
-0.016386494,
0.0216222592,
-0.0349300019,
0.0147102932,
-0.0130265607,
-0.0215133429,
-0.0513456017,
0.0027968409,
-0.0983154103,
-0.0391798802,
-0.0274779908,
0.0188713092,
-0.0319255255,
-0.0307233986,
0.0553426556,
-0.017649537,
-0.0083339419,
0.0179752335,
0.0306753498,
0.001240124,
-0.0526738763,
-0.0644589961,
-0.0458043925,
0.0268327761,
0.0017685236,
-0.003817756,
0.0590048134,
-0.0391674154,
0.0316775106,
0.0318142511,
-0.0226351693,
0.0005323506,
0.0772780553,
0.0390516929,
0.0313929133,
0.0118000209,
0.0226730034,
0.0187967811,
0.0261003897,
-0.0324568823,
-0.0025470122,
0.0259662531,
0.0047695288,
0.0275092572,
0.034119498,
-0.029566085,
0.0567711592,
0.008732846,
-0.0911104977,
0.046273157,
-0.0228045285,
0.0099742496,
-0.0203917343,
0.0510618351,
0.0055635222,
0.008907347,
0.0048627201,
-0.0121161025,
-0.0183818787,
0.0000518721,
-0.0120512489,
-0.0073471279,
-0.021267321,
0.0861754864,
-0.0081586195,
0.0080952309,
-0.0372544751,
-0.015807163,
0.0449788533,
-0.0265239961,
-0.0236800332,
0.0212903246,
-0.053638,
-0.0456226766,
0.0562446117,
-0.0340264961,
0.0319573507,
-0.0219938122,
0.0878758281,
-0.0182174854,
-0.0412303358,
-0.01435077,
-0.0144605534,
0.0007018522,
0.0371735543,
0.0400256477,
0.0358833633,
0.0193857607,
0.0334720351,
0.0097892508,
0.0853832662,
-0.005513662,
0.0041347691,
0.0298625547,
0.0127433697,
0.0141037209,
-0.0009394889,
-0.0183794107,
-0.0252910499,
0.0442668162,
-0.0076561258,
-0.0710335076,
-0.0440129712,
0.0003584825,
2.496e-7,
0.0820157155,
0.0449935608,
0.0732656792,
-0.0407259427,
-0.0151136378,
0.019639818,
-0.0380793549,
0.0437994674,
-0.0760711581,
0.0149998628,
0.0051522721,
-0.0341954082,
0.0066319415,
0.0038516652,
-0.0493381172,
-0.036627017,
-0.0530300625,
0.0353456289,
-0.0622007586,
0.0193600506,
0.0161827169,
0.1126641631,
0.0043403595,
-0.0030078434,
0.045218762,
-0.0217387211,
0.0757625774,
-0.0137249874,
0.0180200264,
0.0307094622,
-0.0103814099,
0.0072097001,
0.0106817,
0.0351254903,
-0.053061679,
-0.0145429848,
0.0143977078,
0.0330737084,
-0.0322523303,
-0.0326563828,
0.0431317911,
0.0265272446,
0.007610478,
-0.0506152101,
0.0314427912,
-0.0694041699,
-0.038392771,
0.0003863734,
-0.023440849,
0.0249598417,
0.0023350166,
-0.0137859089,
0.0010827488,
0.0435196497,
0.0082217501,
0.0140573038,
-0.0306755342,
-0.1210914627,
-0.0247202441,
0.0179662015,
-0.0473628528,
0.0175158158,
-0.0692961365,
-0.0040045483,
0.0456646271,
-0.0639896989,
-0.0101443036,
2.403927962e-34,
-0.0091815656,
-0.0449923165,
0.0020923417,
0.0507912897,
0.035762161,
-0.0375042483,
0.023076877,
0.0257634111,
-0.0213625673,
-0.0429170504,
-0.0170573797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07641v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07641v2 | Evaluating Large Language Models at Evaluating Instruction Following | 2023-10-11T16:38:11 | 2024-04-16T04:50:08 | Zhiyuan Zeng, Jiatong Yu, Tianyu Gao, Yu Meng, Tanya Goyal, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As research in large language models (LLMs) continues to accelerate,
LLM-based evaluation has emerged as a scalable and cost-effective alternative
to human evaluations for comparing the ever increasing list of models. This
paper investigates the efficacy of these ``LLM evaluators'', particularly in
using them to assess instruction following, a metric that gauges how closely
generated text adheres to the given instruction. We introduce a challenging
meta-evaluation benchmark, LLMBar, designed to test the ability of an LLM
evaluator in discerning instruction-following outputs. The authors manually
curated 419 pairs of outputs, one adhering to instructions while the other
diverging, yet may possess deceptive qualities that mislead an LLM evaluator,
e.g., a more engaging tone. Contrary to existing meta-evaluation, we discover
that different evaluators (i.e., combinations of LLMs and prompts) exhibit
distinct performance on LLMBar and even the highest-scoring ones have
substantial room for improvement. We also present a novel suite of prompting
strategies that further close the gap between LLM and human evaluators. With
LLMBar, we hope to offer more insight into LLM evaluators and foster future
research in developing better instruction-following models. | [
0.0495047569,
0.0067005479,
-0.0237333197,
0.0257636122,
-0.0426696353,
0.0126856137,
0.0204261318,
-0.0036926938,
-0.0245114267,
-0.0435938612,
-0.0472908281,
-0.0272968411,
0.0067416285,
0.0015758622,
0.0196316075,
-0.0417616256,
0.0430906042,
-0.0462076142,
-0.0097413799,
0.0141542936,
0.0150661711,
0.0119771399,
-0.0041445354,
0.0596172959,
0.0578909591,
-0.0357888639,
-0.0180735141,
0.0154191256,
0.0134344688,
-0.0403490774,
0.0151692405,
0.051123824,
0.0057789069,
0.027123427,
0.0000022439,
-0.0505055413,
0.0178552214,
-0.0059570391,
-0.0344744474,
0.0715655088,
0.0543409362,
0.0383090936,
-0.0478803739,
0.0098627526,
-0.0005640935,
0.0263983402,
0.0325376168,
-0.0198965203,
0.0701509342,
0.0538315251,
0.0200659316,
0.0190821476,
0.0121218152,
-0.0017326776,
0.0134910243,
-0.0009496369,
-0.0062866118,
0.0153528312,
0.0501971133,
0.0479422361,
-0.013614554,
0.0231950935,
0.0215663575,
-0.0397167057,
0.0033075935,
0.0105203604,
-0.0188245811,
-0.0026482865,
-0.0391006581,
0.076832965,
0.0252044946,
0.0067556556,
-0.01454587,
-0.0174780171,
0.0075837113,
0.023268545,
-0.0464740098,
0.0408796519,
0.0087313214,
-0.0097252298,
-0.0048280889,
0.0154779255,
0.0034639796,
-0.0032816636,
0.0313312672,
0.0391042307,
0.0172730107,
-0.0579938889,
0.0031971885,
0.0161163565,
-0.0210663192,
-0.0786304995,
0.0101822624,
0.0379323736,
-0.0298053548,
0.0180776771,
-0.0371578448,
0.0007932668,
0.0392646343,
-0.032531295,
0.0980043113,
0.0476953164,
-0.0173945203,
0.0318760946,
0.0015201232,
0.1026909202,
-0.0043463632,
0.0240559913,
-0.0511827134,
0.0788520947,
-0.055223953,
-0.0133728068,
-0.004344895,
0.016724417,
-0.0072169947,
-0.0305426884,
-0.0637886003,
0.0201855451,
-0.0267765932,
0.0380722806,
0.0040272516,
-0.0282222349,
0.0026737808,
0.0111370841,
-0.006413003,
0.0213773828,
-0.0368789583,
0.0238147359,
0.0138403596,
-0.0361226909,
0.0214440655,
0.0325141251,
-0.0215314329,
-0.0048804102,
0.017162269,
0.043730583,
-0.0053320467,
-0.0091657508,
-0.0158442315,
-0.0326333344,
-0.0315130241,
-0.0477565601,
-0.0123288287,
-0.0708540231,
0.0004457603,
-0.0071295174,
0.0059868996,
0.0163885765,
0.0157232005,
0.0456836224,
0.0127159012,
-0.0001591555,
0.0310912207,
0.0521780513,
-0.0118638445,
0.0239578094,
-0.0043135658,
0.0267556943,
0.0456244722,
0.026881732,
0.0266291294,
-0.0371543765,
0.0055796318,
0.0493807718,
-0.000707712,
0.0183882043,
0.0096491491,
-0.0103777722,
0.0004156133,
0.029706277,
0.0078069596,
0.0790081397,
-0.0167304687,
0.0212593526,
0.0613419451,
0.0390263833,
-0.0104726516,
-0.0291034728,
0.0980457589,
0.0535430051,
0.0198079012,
0.0493669771,
-0.0403601751,
0.0090609584,
-0.0255315043,
0.0148024047,
0.0371494927,
0.0286486708,
-0.0114683555,
-0.0551630519,
-0.0055771992,
0.0199679844,
-0.0119865527,
0.0002061694,
0.0169418175,
-0.0033730727,
-0.0665520802,
-0.0159675572,
0.0289825723,
-0.0466049127,
0.0228068978,
-0.0661369786,
0.0339426324,
0.1225717813,
0.0598600022,
0.0179384332,
-0.0211917032,
-0.0151266772,
0.0486523956,
0.0470217206,
0.0186151415,
-0.0234388448,
0.0009029615,
-0.0457663834,
-0.0261783823,
-0.0283384975,
0.0047284602,
0.0161201358,
0.0014529093,
-0.0124118803,
0.0117112016,
-0.0139862429,
-0.0802344829,
0.0452500656,
-0.0426741801,
-0.064764984,
-0.0469197296,
0.0091199493,
0.013200121,
0.0324201658,
-0.0261605512,
0.0251461286,
0.0163739901,
0.0029846358,
0.033116173,
-0.0102143027,
-0.0710010603,
-0.0115161072,
0.0185583755,
-0.0377051793,
-0.0055401362,
0.0006124457,
-0.0091013964,
-0.0188248232,
-0.0040343967,
-0.0470263399,
0.0190971587,
0.0176759977,
0.0525431819,
-0.0281797498,
-0.0446662307,
-0.0440442041,
0.0014980087,
-0.0140535776,
0.039075017,
0.0640617386,
-0.0089954976,
0.0030857483,
-0.0248166751,
-0.0334913284,
0.0090225097,
-0.0252340212,
0.0218516029,
0.0201637764,
0.0353437252,
-0.0494812727,
-0.0721345097,
-0.0775773227,
0.0056089526,
-0.0093526868,
0.0279426053,
0.0437337048,
-0.0364509188,
-0.0115941158,
0.0366114751,
-0.032447163,
-0.0708451867,
0.0197361223,
0.0259206817,
-0.0033176509,
0.0019302386,
-0.0421789512,
-0.0486082919,
-0.0189527329,
-0.01967174,
0.0178976897,
0.0353406146,
0.0488687418,
-0.0681121275,
0.0366824158,
-0.0105254613,
-0.0397207588,
0.0102076903,
-0.0530057885,
0.0396323986,
0.0210756194,
0.0571383275,
0.0572261289,
0.017014239,
-0.0099836169,
0.0466740057,
-0.0391953848,
-0.0893246979,
-0.0226084851,
-0.0090519814,
-0.0415686928,
-0.0298710428,
-0.1035955846,
0.0094009405,
0.060076274,
0.0324725732,
0.0247938652,
-0.0662555099,
-0.0057986774,
-0.0624652579,
-0.044418402,
-0.0316477306,
-0.0639763847,
-0.0303990319,
0.0095792962,
-0.0248680171,
-0.0671147853,
0.0814723819,
-0.0520401821,
-0.0028038963,
-0.0252412912,
0.0093394341,
-0.0123655917,
0.0157614816,
-0.0231146682,
0.0225623101,
-0.0006470575,
-0.0114524737,
-0.0376446247,
0.0054545701,
0.0399762504,
-0.0391230546,
0.0357494205,
-0.0638327673,
-0.0289313328,
0.0361230262,
0.0133503051,
-0.0378578641,
-0.0381455794,
0.0162947215,
-0.017621899,
0.0368347429,
-0.0119669382,
-0.0246039871,
0.0024889044,
0.0459086187,
0.0031325652,
-0.0288923122,
-0.0065442091,
-0.032184016,
-0.017882267,
0.0396775492,
-0.0458545759,
0.0089015886,
-0.0718761086,
0.0573111027,
0.0348421596,
0.0181293115,
0.0076625436,
-0.015421276,
0.0073207929,
0.0461143479,
0.0020085981,
-0.0285103805,
0.0662468523,
0.0827727169,
-0.0631361306,
0.0011423357,
0.1156084314,
0.0273048598,
-0.0306224953,
-0.0023136139,
-0.0334463753,
0.0304925572,
-0.0107035227,
0.0153983142,
-0.0426824093,
-0.0133644585,
0.0105931545,
0.0548766516,
-0.0299075842,
0.003627853,
-0.0046942579,
-0.1118068248,
0.0413111486,
0.0193544179,
-0.0098197097,
-0.0161112808,
-0.0318504944,
-0.0054133907,
0.0221992042,
0.0329949558,
0.0241466202,
-0.0499844588,
0.0076704989,
0.0546651147,
-0.0249784235,
-0.0594064556,
0.0514285639,
-0.0324682929,
0.0816827863,
0.0823929384,
-0.006579062,
-0.0016521097,
-0.0499745272,
0.0293681473,
-0.0234421324,
-0.0025126191,
0.0141652096,
0.054652404,
-0.0201334059,
0.0179917645,
-0.0496564247,
0.0070916247,
-0.0117866872,
0.0057433872,
0.0374670178,
0.0610788837,
0.012567969,
0.000752078,
-0.0311073624,
0.0590791218,
-0.0005484582,
0.0929769427,
0.0502570644,
-0.0744968355,
0.0079792803,
-0.0284662172,
-0.0215420052,
-0.0404091887,
-0.0476491749,
0.015714474,
-0.0549273193,
0.0072764992,
-0.0677648559,
-0.0732652247,
0.0135804461,
0.0061250324,
0.0348350257,
-0.0047455602,
0.0048395679,
-0.0265274514,
-0.0030290103,
0.0129190302,
-0.020543782,
0.0493782796,
-0.1266357303,
-0.0152870975,
-0.0009334879,
-0.0186611079,
-0.0034158193,
0.0041948268,
-0.0605980828,
-0.0582091287,
0.0082374336,
0.059376955,
0.0198707934,
0.0004239932,
0.0274804812,
-0.011883758,
0.0005569233,
0.0017716415,
-0.0185186267,
0.0361543633,
0.0205015093,
-0.006596236,
-0.0045633116,
-0.0178316627,
-0.0168044809,
0.0453754663,
0.0293060765,
0.0397421382,
-0.0178983007,
-0.0494516045,
0.0416568927,
0.0495789051,
-0.0100641381,
-0.0372514166,
-0.0025012628,
-0.023778623,
0.0052837785,
-0.0239121411,
-0.0225921236,
-0.0427949019,
-0.0082456497,
0.0344559848,
-0.0175486766,
-0.0020077748,
0.0091437213,
-0.0512935743,
0.0251800194,
-0.0534341894,
0.0514497645,
-0.0344509669,
0.0477999486,
0.0084114345,
0.0090855649,
-0.0306942202,
0.0036538104,
-0.0154384198,
0.0527120754,
0.0271199085,
0.0883847699,
0.0032130599,
-0.0060305092,
0.0271934178,
0.0610407516,
-0.0311141107,
-0.0070113768,
-0.0294628274,
0.0064724605,
0.0143152671,
-0.0014929799,
0.0450254381,
-0.0006528259,
0.03031094,
-0.0394006073,
0.0291219745,
0.0008838846,
-0.0468054153,
0.0155464541,
0.0354672633,
0.0117020663,
-0.0249350108,
0.0372311845,
-0.0175377764,
0.0186991524,
-0.0013239306,
0.0027897726,
-0.0420084372,
-0.0321754143,
0.0247464012,
0.0078312419,
-0.00768669,
0.0005755268,
-0.0819589049,
-0.0348253474,
-0.0307444446,
0.0403987505,
0.0418342724,
-0.0477027558,
0.026026452,
0.0377812497,
-0.0299655218,
-0.0195264257,
-0.0511226915,
-0.020543959,
-0.0174984373,
0.0034251809,
-0.0408727489,
-6.30347605e-33,
-0.0483595729,
-0.0305869095,
0.0280157048,
-0.0102225412,
-0.0265340805,
0.0111548146,
-0.0437666066,
0.0107281134,
0.0104122078,
0.0040823612,
0.014676298,
-0.014523292,
0.0044908104,
-0.0110744759,
0.0326986797,
-0.0023924648,
0.0474777631,
-0.0063896477,
-0.0651466921,
0.033334177,
0.0043005613,
-0.0499020107,
0.0204087365,
-0.0330192447,
0.067880407,
-0.0360302851,
-0.0244286712,
-0.0300460178,
-0.0228675362,
0.0848452151,
-0.0013966154,
0.0298744068,
0.0129143596,
-0.0178069565,
-0.0299886353,
0.0324975587,
-0.0117919436,
-0.0354138128,
0.0572434403,
-0.0150110908,
-0.0335005634,
-0.0458640493,
0.0120588848,
-0.0193460342,
-0.0642941371,
0.0004283865,
0.0271078013,
-0.0138495276,
0.0039620316,
0.0210160036,
-0.0868021995,
0.0212971102,
-0.0334901735,
-0.064046964,
0.0123688318,
0.0913235471,
-0.0098730195,
-0.0009166098,
-0.022039948,
0.0679084435,
0.046411898,
0.0509174205,
0.0728654489,
0.0126503436,
-0.0107766567,
0.0512319952,
-0.0057647647,
0.0354901217,
0.0014839515,
0.0127163865,
0.0263208561,
0.0196900815,
0.0520257689,
0.0161524247,
0.0028247773,
0.0130459229,
-0.0068877316,
0.0349498466,
0.0220404901,
0.0032547279,
0.0384952612,
-0.020226514,
-0.0907474533,
-0.0299894046,
-0.0550551042,
0.0096324338,
-0.0190918464,
-0.0375188328,
0.0752037838,
-0.0044406299,
-0.0328505188,
-0.0426731221,
0.0375675932,
-0.014610419,
0.0034551704,
-0.0097652227,
-0.0464131907,
0.0500414781,
-0.0105041889,
0.0045520132,
-0.0886158571,
-0.0145375924,
0.0485899337,
-0.0095690032,
0.0370462947,
0.0239569098,
-0.0041266778,
-0.0022793207,
-0.062453486,
0.0099808918,
-0.0298384,
0.0152728679,
0.0063808253,
-0.0587196574,
0.0310696959,
0.005695432,
-0.0278290156,
0.0617691427,
0.0013094287,
-0.041010756,
-0.0269923843,
-0.0217894539,
-0.0178685114,
0.0254908893,
-0.0440967306,
0.0148798442,
-0.0432419218,
0.0011193625,
0.0083595058,
-0.0322442017,
-0.0145563213,
-0.017160913,
2.89e-7,
0.0010021434,
0.058213003,
0.0243632179,
0.0269520003,
-0.0121158045,
0.0106475987,
-0.0378392525,
-0.0200457163,
0.0648189113,
-0.0090260291,
0.0236706864,
0.0241425056,
0.0412697159,
-0.0082580429,
-0.0293347221,
0.0232573114,
-0.0688486248,
0.0084078303,
-0.0473132245,
0.0066899681,
0.0648665428,
0.019746175,
-0.0135985091,
0.0203010049,
-0.0033605422,
-0.0308455359,
0.0281436816,
-0.0380118676,
-0.0070538581,
0.038781397,
0.0077294628,
-0.0441026203,
-0.0059534255,
0.0193017628,
0.0028385366,
-0.0000086179,
-0.0022126539,
0.1064396948,
0.0085549522,
0.0338540189,
-0.0013141257,
-0.0166569501,
-0.011191749,
-0.0532232448,
0.0243924949,
-0.0171469804,
-0.0016935512,
-0.016577784,
-0.0571110733,
-0.0240145214,
0.0123538738,
-0.022633072,
-0.0003635527,
0.0229244735,
-0.0091362176,
-0.0185743477,
-0.0023914247,
-0.0025253345,
-0.0137358755,
0.0028138019,
-0.0113895452,
-0.0990365148,
-0.0588334389,
0.008522789,
-0.0304440167,
-0.08419846,
-0.0170886423,
2.738856379e-34,
0.0356348045,
-0.0420005992,
0.0663661137,
-0.0110805724,
0.0261524413,
0.0269498359,
-0.0416846573,
0.0241927039,
0.0406411588,
-0.0816091448,
-0.0169566795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07629v1 | The Past, Present and Better Future of Feedback Learning in Large Language Models for Subjective Human Preferences and Values | 2023-10-11T16:18:13 | 2023-10-11T16:18:13 | Hannah Rose Kirk, Andrew M. Bean, Bertie Vidgen, Paul Röttger, Scott A. Hale | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Human feedback is increasingly used to steer the behaviours of Large Language
Models (LLMs). However, it is unclear how to collect and incorporate feedback
in a way that is efficient, effective and unbiased, especially for highly
subjective human preferences and values. In this paper, we survey existing
approaches for learning from human feedback, drawing on 95 papers primarily
from the ACL and arXiv repositories.First, we summarise the past, pre-LLM
trends for integrating human feedback into language models. Second, we give an
overview of present techniques and practices, as well as the motivations for
using feedback; conceptual frameworks for defining values and preferences; and
how feedback is collected and from whom. Finally, we encourage a better future
of feedback learning in LLMs by raising five unresolved conceptual and
practical challenges. | [
0.0620790273,
0.0939901844,
-0.0209732912,
0.0289507862,
-0.0503705926,
-0.0067641633,
-0.0331456102,
-0.0194898807,
0.0254655369,
-0.0349595733,
-0.0430894233,
-0.0581676103,
0.0176978633,
-0.006007751,
0.0213101357,
-0.0529031269,
0.0228546504,
-0.0277829729,
0.0127488617,
-0.0260098558,
0.0201565251,
0.0021100114,
0.0142756719,
0.0282367691,
0.0118553275,
0.0216455683,
0.0004591082,
-0.0369639024,
-0.0048186523,
0.0208144505,
-0.0000823674,
0.0605001152,
-0.0054374365,
0.0279409848,
0.0000020253,
-0.041896861,
0.0077007348,
-0.0195829719,
0.0218690392,
0.0115973949,
0.0900537297,
0.041548796,
-0.0310462341,
0.0044960496,
-0.0164879672,
0.0073909867,
0.0361072235,
-0.0120794792,
0.0596279986,
0.0157827996,
0.0068334872,
0.0000945014,
-0.0396981277,
-0.0189673007,
0.0196124595,
0.0100561855,
0.0444798321,
-0.0173985008,
0.0327930525,
0.0205891039,
-0.0060729333,
-0.0001893848,
0.0151324235,
-0.0449368916,
0.0089194598,
0.0230851322,
-0.0133590288,
-0.0277625732,
0.0148623781,
0.0614485405,
0.0370046385,
-0.031433817,
-0.0428724997,
-0.0051424117,
0.0191087425,
-0.003923534,
-0.021311665,
0.0055227638,
-0.0103218928,
0.0224925131,
-0.0002463421,
0.0062014814,
0.0211985242,
0.0361229517,
-0.0226637665,
0.0638228431,
0.0102868332,
-0.0239311866,
0.027531296,
0.0293908101,
-0.0503501408,
-0.0349641405,
0.0311101116,
0.0045309137,
-0.0525145084,
-0.0056233238,
-0.0218944363,
0.0029138201,
0.0287148152,
-0.1019759551,
0.0606442355,
-0.0031854033,
-0.036032211,
0.0349344723,
0.0158326384,
0.0260004997,
-0.0122107323,
0.0201739743,
-0.0551489741,
0.0071347263,
-0.0117035592,
0.0159083344,
0.0112380125,
0.0386479571,
0.0340470113,
0.0282049328,
-0.0226136465,
0.0218778364,
-0.0372334197,
0.0465270802,
0.0051184124,
0.0201174188,
-0.0216012523,
-0.0140392212,
-0.0673296675,
0.0431288369,
-0.0375529677,
0.0008436051,
-0.0055188765,
0.0168249942,
0.0332601517,
-0.0019820109,
-0.0101213232,
-0.0189109184,
-0.0110714883,
0.0511693172,
0.0383577943,
0.012714901,
0.0046797921,
0.0085050743,
-0.0170433652,
-0.0611112602,
-0.036048878,
-0.0591253676,
-0.001791376,
0.000083083,
-0.0060276017,
-0.0400056727,
0.001614248,
0.0113060083,
-0.0362365134,
0.0626102388,
-0.0085297674,
-0.0033310815,
-0.0045686956,
-0.0251018163,
0.0190924481,
0.04839525,
0.0096091274,
0.0713259503,
0.0563269779,
-0.006731295,
0.0167145859,
0.0165528301,
0.0167701151,
0.0194293391,
-0.0502489321,
0.0120097362,
-0.015260702,
0.0575459078,
0.015265285,
0.0905595049,
-0.031098431,
-0.0388845503,
0.0865398273,
0.0342745483,
-0.0013718359,
0.0022446488,
0.016267078,
0.0419616215,
-0.0129630202,
0.0204586443,
-0.0196502693,
0.0155610517,
-0.0094230296,
0.0027615693,
0.0179257132,
-0.0186477005,
-0.0060912319,
-0.0900345221,
-0.0165483057,
-0.0152360238,
0.0309388861,
0.0398083776,
0.0537644811,
-0.0068320087,
-0.0012344025,
-0.0162369963,
0.0561113209,
-0.0536389761,
0.0453583896,
-0.0546716638,
0.0802279413,
0.0860858187,
0.0394062698,
-0.0033967923,
0.0153481485,
-0.0200324729,
-0.031212775,
0.0169224273,
0.0770435333,
-0.0588683076,
-0.0423899069,
-0.0260228775,
0.0071189916,
0.0447241142,
0.0015978204,
0.0314520188,
-0.0089412229,
-0.0471895896,
-0.0309240129,
-0.0045312042,
-0.0676563233,
-0.0040616812,
0.0243726708,
-0.0091376221,
0.0201595016,
0.0067922119,
0.0228688549,
0.0230484437,
0.0032871196,
0.0211996045,
0.0146072581,
0.0071468623,
-0.0328900255,
0.0167164821,
-0.0177373141,
-0.0157817435,
0.0438532233,
0.0275180209,
0.0066919886,
0.0383479521,
-0.0027636716,
0.0098186154,
0.012410474,
-0.0277871583,
0.0601918772,
-0.0299440157,
0.0276960768,
-0.0418548174,
-0.0427911207,
-0.0813117102,
0.0195312966,
-0.0141718956,
-0.0034221867,
-0.0201652832,
-0.0072544198,
0.0107686743,
-0.0192609392,
-0.0506755337,
0.0603082553,
0.0408227593,
0.049120076,
0.070588246,
0.0206040069,
-0.0387530476,
-0.0320848152,
-0.0849386528,
-0.0472755879,
-0.0153061282,
0.0024123765,
-0.0198795758,
-0.0069197314,
0.0117179975,
0.0011278539,
-0.0423226394,
-0.0427662916,
-0.018624641,
0.0340870507,
0.030984737,
0.0195837244,
0.0012165508,
-0.0586400889,
-0.0312187299,
-0.0090729408,
0.0148226516,
0.0062387316,
0.0151599105,
-0.0635237992,
-0.0144328382,
-0.0321100019,
0.021729717,
-0.0071640313,
-0.0268837847,
0.0182924736,
-0.0363965295,
0.0423839875,
0.0508163162,
0.0115548754,
0.0451497659,
0.0611290708,
0.0079137478,
-0.0823876411,
-0.0186240152,
-0.0760728121,
-0.0487070233,
-0.0217444636,
0.0289726518,
0.0199389663,
0.0595754646,
0.0129792877,
-0.0371266305,
-0.0853838846,
0.0341489352,
-0.0609212518,
-0.0163492411,
-0.0479259677,
-0.009285666,
-0.034866631,
0.0554068498,
0.0092579108,
-0.048315756,
0.1230239421,
0.0094362339,
0.0212600492,
-0.0652869567,
0.0163692739,
-0.0476084612,
0.0198573805,
-0.0163573455,
0.0074624401,
0.0091387695,
0.0087799747,
-0.0204195455,
-0.0253935345,
0.0381399728,
-0.0492943376,
0.0263822004,
-0.05018517,
0.006038317,
0.0187232029,
-0.0641454905,
-0.0146073438,
-0.0441126935,
-0.0308877751,
-0.0069150999,
0.0441161618,
-0.0187309124,
0.0393228829,
-0.0089770164,
0.017148409,
-0.0317556523,
-0.0212405883,
-0.0151956547,
0.0082390793,
-0.0026501711,
0.0749085769,
0.0046570105,
0.0261525624,
-0.0299130045,
-0.0538817532,
0.0575040281,
0.0711995289,
0.0097541772,
0.0157806817,
0.0034940222,
0.0730641037,
-0.024824718,
0.0061692959,
0.012064036,
0.0173597336,
-0.0395342484,
0.0090087205,
0.0918198898,
0.0338841565,
-0.1013653502,
0.0333099291,
-0.0449267514,
0.0341647342,
0.0144113731,
0.0391888134,
-0.0436180346,
-0.000760584,
-0.0128860828,
0.0325829722,
-0.0212199856,
-0.0187750012,
0.0129746618,
-0.1319128424,
0.0160093307,
0.0261467062,
-0.0051133372,
-0.017174717,
-0.0248594321,
0.0084858052,
-0.0452516079,
0.0003289312,
0.0124047203,
0.0175473616,
-0.0170604251,
0.0283327736,
-0.0053599444,
-0.0547247939,
0.0277295765,
-0.0430589803,
0.0593145937,
0.0776550025,
0.0399556272,
-0.001446974,
-0.0671803281,
0.0273163673,
0.0138491588,
-0.0372772925,
-0.0249322858,
0.0030162071,
-0.0293709654,
-0.0074119251,
-0.0381739102,
0.0256781597,
-0.0073478469,
-0.0023586508,
-0.0045436686,
0.0598662682,
-0.0023145247,
-0.0209479947,
-0.0165174939,
0.0110977991,
0.0208629295,
0.0430046916,
0.01498912,
-0.1178753525,
0.0116758589,
-0.0575047024,
-0.0363439694,
-0.0159797017,
-0.10654293,
-0.0256133899,
0.0369954854,
0.0091012046,
-0.076444529,
-0.0301743764,
0.0133826733,
0.0251341853,
0.021107167,
-0.0090833865,
0.020295145,
-0.0218903162,
0.0134069044,
0.0302455444,
-0.0123318825,
0.0206074025,
-0.056402538,
-0.0432262123,
0.0589951947,
-0.0312199332,
-0.0051543433,
-0.0157300327,
-0.0518365353,
-0.0803645402,
-0.00377309,
0.0760729089,
0.0207644701,
0.0577468723,
-0.0340186171,
-0.0841795728,
-0.0022928333,
0.0076224795,
-0.0074834814,
-0.0182398967,
0.0384843871,
0.061211925,
-0.014604276,
0.0412794352,
-0.0064799818,
-0.0129209058,
0.0009351638,
0.0135533111,
-0.006410731,
-0.0416653603,
0.0432842001,
0.0120013738,
0.0306393467,
-0.0333773531,
-0.0373174995,
-0.0395816453,
-0.006320911,
-0.0265900772,
-0.0654586926,
-0.0293227714,
-0.0188993104,
0.0131918183,
-0.0221328251,
-0.0391232036,
-0.0553205609,
-0.0278190356,
0.069368057,
-0.0173427742,
0.0034629744,
0.0125157591,
0.018557664,
0.0600708239,
0.0164423268,
-0.025770437,
0.0010529773,
0.0043398142,
0.0713683814,
0.0044668415,
0.0485454462,
0.0371466316,
-0.0452501103,
0.0205403753,
0.0236447845,
-0.0090936264,
-0.048554346,
-0.0472490042,
0.021266222,
0.0185259711,
0.0086746356,
0.0518404394,
-0.028424358,
-0.0172358416,
-0.0299534537,
0.0254847333,
-0.0173828937,
-0.0335965902,
0.0041039619,
0.0224345475,
-0.0331535079,
0.0110220406,
0.0506253578,
0.0071928706,
-0.0055195843,
-0.041985441,
0.0014777587,
-0.0435922928,
-0.0108582973,
-0.0072039491,
-0.0104853055,
-0.0400163643,
0.0179053433,
-0.0810162425,
-0.0395282023,
-0.0304873493,
0.050043419,
-0.0071210442,
-0.0291485824,
0.0265397951,
0.0640418679,
-0.0298982225,
0.0128519647,
-0.0776748061,
-0.0052223997,
-0.0357320867,
-0.0070662866,
-0.0200904571,
-6.344787329e-33,
-0.026671363,
-0.0181926508,
0.0059429789,
0.0219972264,
-0.0246467181,
-0.0643522367,
0.0027304741,
0.0540774353,
0.0081538185,
0.0044719307,
0.0036961264,
-0.0490831658,
0.0058423979,
-0.0047502713,
0.0567598604,
-0.0099480655,
0.0506322235,
0.0015072951,
-0.0329173952,
0.0221891161,
0.0165903326,
-0.0188265294,
0.0457073636,
-0.0762517676,
0.0618359707,
0.0292000696,
-0.0169074684,
0.0524602644,
-0.0337783992,
0.0651736036,
-0.010681171,
0.0754806921,
-0.0148911243,
-0.0108082294,
-0.0116186002,
-0.0153431464,
-0.0273185521,
-0.0160585642,
0.0044012419,
0.025135288,
-0.0214109328,
-0.0174792968,
0.0011865582,
-0.0049004126,
-0.0372084044,
0.0332031697,
0.0251252297,
-0.0078425808,
-0.037576057,
0.0286308601,
-0.0406519398,
0.0123601332,
0.0162466075,
0.0012258483,
0.0141851092,
0.0412770025,
-0.0224539135,
0.0168207753,
-0.0309349205,
0.0660392866,
0.028189702,
0.0320592374,
0.0435132869,
-0.0116615314,
0.0225224961,
0.0578991026,
0.0148443645,
0.0422082096,
0.0078550307,
-0.0133925611,
0.0521584377,
0.0067330324,
0.037149772,
0.0933663696,
-0.0256547797,
-0.0142756589,
0.0379468538,
0.0130779436,
0.0071099801,
0.0331108719,
0.0417595878,
0.0316122547,
-0.0693169534,
-0.0566197634,
-0.0400594398,
-0.051766701,
-0.0263172127,
-0.0281372294,
0.0055566696,
0.0055920626,
-0.0454605408,
0.007218841,
0.0119671365,
-0.0385261215,
-0.0839441642,
-0.0048062894,
-0.0410626233,
0.0405568928,
-0.0056938333,
0.002981707,
-0.0865460262,
0.0091757784,
-0.024956869,
-0.0132333133,
-0.0170179512,
0.0156191383,
-0.00090547,
0.0412178859,
-0.0280677825,
-0.0033927087,
-0.0206080209,
-0.0005423944,
0.0006873885,
0.0050786049,
0.0281023979,
0.0217185374,
-0.0140250074,
0.0777264982,
-0.0043650987,
0.0074083935,
-0.0260459837,
-0.0017317391,
-0.0022438208,
0.0112868259,
-0.0268556662,
-0.0230303463,
-0.0035090325,
0.0318071954,
0.0410188623,
-0.0016864673,
-0.0025308686,
-0.0274565089,
2.63e-7,
0.0101112723,
0.0732182413,
0.0069833053,
-0.016789034,
-0.0188958533,
0.0777814165,
-0.0064900699,
0.0025459058,
0.0470943451,
0.0162744951,
0.0049576508,
0.0138033153,
0.0586704575,
0.0367538258,
-0.0874191895,
-0.0126841441,
-0.0281627625,
-0.0000068744,
-0.0307362694,
-0.0367968604,
0.0372934565,
0.0740726441,
0.0589978769,
-0.0008252549,
0.0194852222,
0.0189353768,
0.0735557005,
-0.0778945461,
-0.0545470677,
0.0182079356,
0.0200829711,
-0.0320608392,
0.0049402104,
-0.0313982889,
0.0140159652,
-0.0226077996,
-0.0152341975,
0.0473926142,
0.0229709018,
-0.0686502382,
-0.0147318086,
0.0181138702,
0.0214483943,
-0.0609602705,
0.0361362584,
-0.0461555347,
-0.0426591635,
-0.052681651,
0.0616173446,
-0.0313728005,
0.0358656943,
-0.0496610627,
-0.0390260816,
0.0001179562,
0.0255718865,
0.0206770822,
-0.0235707331,
-0.0607961416,
-0.0207782295,
0.0042509371,
-0.0334343873,
-0.0503719375,
-0.0013132003,
0.0184440967,
-0.0285846218,
-0.0460272096,
0.0273068938,
2.248568476e-34,
0.0677993521,
0.0021634032,
0.0189883374,
0.0184199177,
0.03495121,
0.0368747786,
0.0262676124,
0.0207557641,
0.0746347606,
-0.0239162911,
-0.0250003431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07611v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07611v2 | Democratizing LLMs: An Exploration of Cost-Performance Trade-offs in Self-Refined Open-Source Models | 2023-10-11T15:56:00 | 2023-10-22T00:37:06 | Sumuk Shashidhar, Abhinav Chinta, Vaibhav Sahai, Zhenhailong Wang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PF, 68T50 (Primary), I.2.7; A.2; H.3.4; K.4.1; C.4 | The dominance of proprietary LLMs has led to restricted access and raised
information privacy concerns. High-performing open-source alternatives are
crucial for information-sensitive and high-volume applications but often lag
behind in performance. To address this gap, we propose (1) A untargeted variant
of iterative self-critique and self-refinement devoid of external influence.
(2) A novel ranking metric - Performance, Refinement, and Inference Cost Score
(PeRFICS) - to find the optimal model for a given task considering refined
performance and cost. Our experiments show that SoTA open source models of
varying sizes from 7B - 65B, on average, improve 8.2% from their baseline
performance. Strikingly, even models with extremely small memory footprints,
such as Vicuna-7B, show a 11.74% improvement overall and up to a 25.39%
improvement in high-creativity, open ended tasks on the Vicuna benchmark.
Vicuna-13B takes it a step further and outperforms ChatGPT post-refinement.
This work has profound implications for resource-constrained and
information-sensitive environments seeking to leverage LLMs without incurring
prohibitive costs, compromising on performance and privacy. The domain-agnostic
self-refinement process coupled with our novel ranking metric facilitates
informed decision-making in model selection, thereby reducing costs and
democratizing access to high-performing language models, as evidenced by case
studies. | [
-0.0031700099,
0.0688417554,
-0.0118754758,
0.0489563644,
-0.0593554191,
-0.0289552473,
0.0062874309,
-0.0064418097,
0.0125458045,
-0.0361053273,
-0.0766806826,
0.0094618639,
-0.0272493716,
0.0071120132,
-0.0050057787,
-0.0026005488,
0.0436935946,
-0.054419592,
-0.0267893616,
-0.0174719971,
-0.0383667946,
-0.016060032,
0.0060493895,
0.0374192931,
0.0597894453,
-0.0274653118,
-0.0062904279,
0.0196873099,
-0.0238782801,
-0.0034885798,
-0.0038049649,
0.0624052137,
-0.0042956909,
0.0684542134,
0.0000023409,
-0.0584946312,
-0.0531657673,
0.0482877642,
-0.0372393467,
0.0710716248,
0.0603250824,
0.0439307727,
-0.0371453203,
0.0287921298,
-0.0248135887,
0.01249451,
0.0321245492,
-0.0462102368,
0.0670625567,
0.0542149059,
0.0232379213,
-0.0146740116,
-0.0118097737,
-0.0228270758,
-0.034946084,
-0.0315623656,
-0.0250090249,
-0.0159091614,
-0.0211063847,
-0.0024008856,
0.0028020756,
0.0402879976,
0.0308023039,
-0.0046474715,
0.0186101254,
0.0095559219,
-0.052775383,
-0.0104616601,
-0.0143467048,
0.0408359766,
0.0147697357,
-0.0264314786,
0.0202939175,
-0.0077637383,
0.0145852342,
-0.0023979924,
-0.0458610989,
0.0429993607,
0.001676935,
0.0118891969,
0.0169876795,
-0.0066130422,
0.0357199274,
0.0343840905,
-0.0046561426,
0.0756779611,
0.0124837728,
-0.010158563,
-0.0137039404,
-0.0257778428,
-0.0148198782,
-0.0373308174,
-0.0007956069,
-0.0056528035,
0.0206520744,
0.0040347921,
-0.0388023928,
-0.0164337922,
0.0125446664,
-0.0291921217,
0.0633056909,
0.0390492827,
0.0065646153,
0.0418552421,
-0.0243316777,
0.0240816474,
-0.0319948941,
0.0624751709,
-0.0221744403,
0.0191154219,
0.0134474821,
0.0111898556,
-0.0046569426,
0.0524372384,
-0.0617470816,
0.0263102222,
-0.0279058143,
0.057396248,
0.0254072119,
0.0125659173,
0.0379158594,
-0.0137929898,
0.0040935031,
-0.0173939764,
-0.0348193347,
-0.021168761,
0.0273328181,
-0.0215276256,
0.0092343716,
-0.0803248808,
-0.0222232062,
-0.0116182435,
-0.0534841828,
-0.0283436552,
0.01202456,
0.1056945473,
0.024081951,
-0.039184425,
-0.0522912592,
-0.0386431627,
0.0170704611,
-0.0683709234,
0.0100245262,
-0.0634231046,
-0.0249308348,
0.0160246566,
-0.0102211572,
-0.0628563985,
-0.0220672544,
-0.0128244217,
-0.0070520877,
0.0334502161,
-0.0494551994,
0.0170777459,
0.0120832948,
0.0469944887,
0.0037949323,
0.0722162351,
0.0236877408,
0.0189853981,
0.0603654906,
-0.0164313801,
0.0151518704,
0.0450080372,
-0.006189249,
0.0129303373,
-0.0206711311,
0.0297232382,
0.006565515,
0.0059492984,
0.027271308,
0.0312762409,
-0.0227828529,
-0.0184930116,
0.0932844579,
0.0471753441,
0.0508251525,
0.0111377677,
-0.0279774237,
0.0202914029,
0.0276723895,
-0.0159154553,
-0.0538556613,
0.0433158688,
-0.0151237464,
0.0157556497,
0.0331745446,
0.0296707209,
-0.0210425407,
-0.0669510812,
-0.0200821552,
-0.0225539207,
-0.0176344961,
0.0143324556,
0.0462764613,
-0.0149435392,
-0.02481688,
0.0899621025,
0.0259425417,
-0.0911987796,
-0.0563509688,
-0.0955697298,
0.0423053652,
0.0730087683,
0.0844585747,
-0.0587453656,
-0.0129238404,
-0.0063392506,
-0.0042359247,
0.0254616346,
0.0476767235,
0.0241465215,
0.0247740541,
-0.0360863134,
-0.0368290059,
-0.0364566371,
0.0234109536,
0.0401170738,
0.0322067328,
-0.0178654008,
0.0094755115,
-0.0471159928,
-0.0245641842,
0.0313611068,
-0.0091097485,
-0.0185639318,
0.0177329257,
-0.0111335609,
0.0351348333,
0.0285385661,
-0.0170966331,
0.0231839921,
0.0432515778,
-0.0024138999,
0.0002415096,
-0.022141451,
-0.011379295,
0.0081324391,
0.0209108815,
0.0310297981,
0.0196937826,
0.0243280642,
-0.0407975875,
-0.0308893174,
0.0595967881,
-0.0105798263,
0.0250351764,
-0.0353042334,
0.0354381166,
-0.0405275449,
-0.0117429197,
-0.0466732271,
0.0209498443,
-0.0203410499,
0.0053415797,
-0.0001449993,
-0.0054039392,
0.0384514518,
-0.0135759721,
-0.0419704057,
0.004040095,
-0.0104481364,
0.0398168601,
-0.0076776305,
0.0252513923,
-0.016444793,
-0.0340496413,
-0.0585277043,
0.0138083184,
-0.0302231926,
0.0412263237,
0.012592542,
0.0101035479,
-0.0202835705,
-0.0014162078,
0.0187920053,
-0.017476121,
-0.0048750336,
0.031456735,
0.0143547058,
-0.0129533159,
-0.0585631654,
-0.0371688865,
-0.0467050113,
0.0230604038,
0.0379150994,
-0.0509382114,
0.0053062262,
-0.0543640405,
0.0213765334,
-0.0430007502,
0.0314236693,
-0.0144955581,
-0.014380266,
0.0210087411,
-0.0054011871,
0.0114473403,
0.0503939316,
-0.0328128561,
-0.0250269026,
0.0791549608,
0.0030527411,
-0.0739355981,
0.0146983638,
0.0234942976,
-0.056175299,
0.0102899857,
0.0068438463,
0.0073585203,
0.0482462421,
-0.0264006592,
-0.0377138555,
-0.0199837703,
0.0283942576,
-0.0153125562,
-0.047449179,
0.002316098,
0.0081295539,
-0.0021113236,
0.0610958152,
0.008118947,
-0.092564404,
0.0477888137,
-0.0343099125,
0.0054867677,
-0.0118355947,
-0.0214509331,
-0.0756626725,
0.0596509464,
-0.021603642,
0.0051931846,
0.0290731173,
-0.0170923825,
-0.0339907147,
0.0138543453,
0.0773180723,
-0.0603411347,
0.083264932,
-0.0564443022,
0.0145022282,
-0.0211765748,
-0.0603771545,
-0.0022135843,
-0.0211000182,
-0.0012473684,
-0.0019139869,
0.007257822,
0.0072697271,
0.0041727554,
0.0251891706,
0.0199516509,
0.0576384068,
0.0019895579,
-0.008057504,
-0.0192194711,
-0.0108810933,
-0.0355117843,
0.0010538119,
0.0450314619,
-0.0027969531,
0.0150049366,
0.0717150643,
0.0625561029,
-0.0356600992,
-0.0151982708,
-0.0157414954,
0.0438419804,
-0.0469601229,
-0.0441183336,
0.0251884442,
0.036378894,
-0.0610187612,
0.0009627007,
0.1002663895,
0.0101013146,
-0.0311137792,
-0.0069462913,
-0.0506222248,
0.0644007921,
0.0451347381,
0.0235366225,
-0.0870705396,
-0.0078464942,
0.0335819907,
0.0680210069,
-0.0059203398,
-0.0361783318,
-0.0173785724,
-0.0946419463,
0.0677028149,
0.0072134961,
-0.0117139267,
0.0535683483,
-0.0611639768,
-0.0249874704,
-0.053482946,
-0.0007766667,
0.0408116058,
-0.0024205437,
0.0054550162,
-0.000154033,
-0.0421896391,
-0.0232531074,
0.0038256804,
-0.0204749946,
0.024126254,
0.0431330055,
-0.0077792425,
0.01008859,
-0.0403328612,
0.081742458,
0.0001672854,
0.0038571781,
-0.03668328,
0.0328585394,
0.0345982648,
-0.0162703227,
-0.007774347,
-0.0126629723,
-0.0252022073,
-0.0073972228,
-0.0229870118,
0.0461260155,
0.0006081673,
0.024669461,
-0.0098176366,
-0.0621646978,
-0.0449522287,
0.063799493,
-0.0000015247,
-0.014817494,
-0.0464426652,
-0.0287460238,
-0.0286838729,
-0.0021109909,
-0.0227867533,
-0.0071034911,
-0.0096128471,
-0.0446427613,
-0.0245168097,
0.0041235131,
-0.0446131863,
0.0304458831,
-0.0080571016,
0.0221941471,
0.0086467052,
-0.0097260131,
-0.0677080303,
0.0164650567,
-0.060210146,
0.0030044189,
-0.0657326132,
0.0085596433,
0.0184583738,
0.0157867987,
-0.011118927,
0.0292633474,
-0.0578334257,
-0.0823892057,
-0.0226963628,
0.0938332081,
0.0309709217,
0.0207577068,
-0.011302704,
-0.0597754717,
0.0297358651,
0.0350527391,
-0.0398030616,
0.0506753772,
0.0592960194,
-0.0171095133,
-0.0046241507,
0.0314858221,
-0.0255025178,
-0.0187083706,
0.0308869407,
0.0092907287,
0.027581241,
-0.0674370006,
0.009085007,
0.0537220314,
0.0326599143,
-0.0357115194,
0.0211304892,
-0.0239179507,
0.0414961949,
-0.0255087093,
-0.0116196685,
-0.0376047455,
0.0143510588,
0.0205659475,
-0.0270374231,
0.0075991093,
0.0451107882,
0.010927679,
0.0401452146,
-0.0622875467,
0.0295800809,
-0.0073325201,
-0.0088424915,
0.022745464,
-0.0120052211,
-0.0236256327,
0.0232640281,
-0.0016724432,
0.0393921509,
-0.0221850649,
0.048483558,
-0.0293440055,
0.0271226447,
0.0160774961,
0.074147433,
-0.0454315431,
-0.089771986,
-0.0222265515,
0.050120905,
0.048004441,
0.0741779655,
0.0721041411,
-0.0026197904,
-0.0068732761,
-0.0328766778,
0.0173098743,
0.0055693351,
-0.0041159536,
0.0023189487,
0.0159518272,
-0.0288995132,
0.0006910087,
0.0914832354,
0.0162184592,
0.0259408914,
-0.0192053858,
-0.0036114601,
-0.0374295786,
-0.0766821504,
-0.0297454558,
0.0132259019,
-0.0237673521,
-0.0618092604,
-0.0653012693,
-0.0540018082,
0.0093509285,
0.0424975231,
-0.0040813517,
-0.0286927111,
0.0371336639,
0.0836549103,
0.0075854766,
-0.0488746017,
-0.0386272222,
-0.0286118817,
-0.0372262411,
-0.024183793,
0.029215809,
-6.58080382e-33,
-0.0228833202,
0.0145030171,
0.0427778587,
0.012563373,
-0.0033474928,
0.003379612,
-0.0228517633,
0.0413638167,
-0.0159131102,
-0.045980759,
-0.0371044539,
0.0141821289,
0.0211588219,
-0.0108486582,
0.017809609,
-0.0018098726,
0.0174263548,
-0.0186702181,
-0.0519127585,
-0.0012256046,
-0.0152995866,
0.0194026139,
0.0496633053,
-0.0694614947,
-0.0004861348,
0.0258920826,
-0.0078014582,
-0.0030094313,
-0.0377402306,
0.0541472249,
0.004702183,
0.014023101,
0.00270789,
-0.0583755933,
-0.017245736,
-0.0551035032,
-0.0409640186,
0.0011352205,
0.0184620898,
-0.014965809,
-0.0048731305,
-0.0210112836,
0.0526215211,
0.0446083322,
-0.0734485164,
0.0020766563,
-0.0279305093,
-0.0282331407,
-0.0373421609,
0.0013203803,
0.0017299794,
0.0451041013,
-0.004443178,
0.003787925,
0.0459703691,
0.0048693414,
-0.0233092513,
-0.0160952453,
-0.0367630161,
0.018580839,
0.0130283199,
0.0449988507,
0.1318064332,
0.0146222934,
0.0095237633,
0.0172186121,
0.0327244028,
0.0200731792,
-0.0163607858,
-0.0270903055,
0.0194708351,
0.0679214075,
0.0425537638,
0.0283403918,
-0.0198698845,
0.0256090127,
-0.0748308823,
0.0136950174,
-0.0132675972,
0.0007313751,
0.0257587042,
0.0635230392,
-0.0448650233,
-0.0184785202,
-0.0435898155,
-0.0012915957,
-0.0297890995,
-0.0122073581,
0.0306632817,
0.0001449153,
-0.0317270756,
-0.0280114133,
0.022109881,
-0.0312041212,
-0.0274322182,
-0.0142013012,
-0.0172861777,
0.0268435013,
-0.0137185855,
0.0295774955,
-0.0651416332,
-0.0077197296,
-0.044597175,
0.013814589,
0.0196137801,
-0.0021402489,
-0.0092046866,
0.015992891,
-0.0753949285,
0.0173436608,
-0.0515516363,
0.0305092819,
0.0203395933,
0.0188569557,
0.0343970284,
-0.0469114743,
0.0141179422,
0.0613775179,
0.0144423516,
0.0159590393,
-0.0547167175,
0.0236810222,
0.0299649499,
-0.0075131929,
0.0281135365,
0.0079497946,
-0.0099184401,
0.0573540963,
0.0400979146,
-0.0249098837,
-0.0319629908,
0.0086564962,
3.071e-7,
0.0332019366,
0.0153834531,
-0.0049893549,
0.0220659059,
0.009588765,
0.0451145507,
0.0011138854,
0.0236059204,
-0.0232658759,
-0.0069414983,
-0.0104595376,
0.0291092396,
0.0548259653,
0.01783612,
-0.0486827791,
-0.0161602963,
-0.0544435531,
0.0246453471,
-0.0479228832,
-0.0560843796,
-0.0057022823,
0.0519005135,
0.0256844778,
-0.0143197151,
-0.0259217583,
-0.0490484238,
0.0569973327,
-0.0517284945,
-0.0273912307,
0.0471906848,
0.053868752,
0.0678170621,
-0.0219703913,
-0.039830111,
0.0006737701,
-0.0138838245,
-0.0132488078,
0.0789873227,
0.0242474452,
-0.0296658091,
0.0532345511,
-0.0549499691,
-0.0164711457,
-0.0310539585,
0.079579398,
0.0414255261,
-0.0327592082,
-0.0108352872,
0.0266885497,
-0.0441617183,
0.0357789621,
-0.0285110362,
0.0105077224,
0.0110846609,
-0.0000194261,
-0.0248545073,
-0.0255389884,
-0.0504126288,
-0.067083016,
-0.0356317796,
-0.0275323018,
-0.06495855,
-0.0512318499,
0.0434573144,
-0.0029972685,
-0.0351552777,
0.0252616499,
3.071743522e-34,
0.0325825363,
-0.0196514539,
0.0238810107,
0.0572050251,
0.016989816,
0.0156692192,
0.0149970045,
-0.020611342,
-0.0316695645,
-0.0501725525,
-0.0144475298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07609v1 | QACHECK: A Demonstration System for Question-Guided Multi-Hop Fact-Checking | 2023-10-11T15:51:53 | 2023-10-11T15:51:53 | Liangming Pan, Xinyuan Lu, Min-Yen Kan, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fact-checking real-world claims often requires complex, multi-step reasoning
due to the absence of direct evidence to support or refute them. However,
existing fact-checking systems often lack transparency in their
decision-making, making it challenging for users to comprehend their reasoning
process. To address this, we propose the Question-guided Multi-hop
Fact-Checking (QACHECK) system, which guides the model's reasoning process by
asking a series of questions critical for verifying a claim. QACHECK has five
key modules: a claim verifier, a question generator, a question-answering
module, a QA validator, and a reasoner. Users can input a claim into QACHECK,
which then predicts its veracity and provides a comprehensive report detailing
its reasoning process, guided by a sequence of (question, answer) pairs.
QACHECK also provides the source of evidence supporting each question,
fostering a transparent, explainable, and user-friendly fact-checking process.
A recorded video of QACHECK is at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ju8kxSldM64 | [
0.0286952648,
0.0275820196,
0.0186639447,
0.0230304375,
-0.0507739261,
0.0079207094,
0.0361077376,
-0.013401092,
0.0265970528,
-0.0349941701,
0.0466545895,
0.0102278246,
0.0241483171,
0.0315227769,
0.027182905,
-0.0240503196,
0.0452896841,
-0.0119474782,
0.0558391288,
0.0057083969,
0.0152248256,
0.0315923356,
-0.0587414242,
0.0374889672,
-0.0557486936,
-0.0479580685,
-0.0002217988,
-0.0002351326,
0.0260520633,
-0.0381204113,
-0.0144562516,
0.0310950298,
-0.0059505049,
0.0303215515,
0.0000022941,
-0.0416239016,
-0.0082869856,
0.0301699527,
-0.0910653546,
0.011665795,
-0.0272020474,
0.0681944564,
-0.0203191675,
0.0353906751,
-0.0064493371,
-0.011276653,
0.0397193432,
0.0639083833,
0.0914852396,
0.0474484451,
-0.0118700285,
-0.0294964742,
-0.0227052756,
0.0427927412,
-0.0125390561,
-0.0178836174,
0.022424249,
0.0339783989,
0.0031741813,
-0.0181059502,
0.0393211357,
0.0126509527,
0.018823998,
-0.0330814682,
-0.034731932,
0.0299120191,
-0.0070509431,
-0.0464929044,
0.0027572552,
0.0411347225,
0.0156028504,
-0.0391971059,
-0.0105834119,
0.0003251568,
0.0133655984,
0.0390757546,
-0.019918168,
0.0417628661,
-0.0428487472,
-0.0461159945,
0.000404257,
0.0027272999,
0.0139881354,
0.0133865559,
0.0148235792,
0.0533680096,
-0.0115033844,
-0.0141376415,
-0.0209294967,
0.0151133621,
0.0576907992,
-0.1050259843,
0.0053530638,
0.0278874729,
-0.031591244,
0.0000262523,
0.0198582765,
0.0333708487,
0.0473879576,
-0.0394388922,
-0.0033527559,
0.0275735185,
-0.0662211031,
0.0596996658,
-0.0221799649,
-0.0058100116,
-0.00558689,
-0.0377905108,
0.0325704738,
-0.0111226551,
-0.0151062775,
0.0069090398,
-0.0121259829,
0.0085618254,
-0.0421319157,
0.0336983763,
-0.0065255859,
-0.0270151738,
0.0007270324,
0.0491856858,
-0.0226913765,
0.0230419729,
0.0053187809,
-0.034004271,
-0.0615608618,
0.0356024355,
-0.0581559688,
0.0269832164,
0.0144407265,
-0.0353176743,
-0.0130565008,
0.0230906364,
0.0157092009,
0.0113456286,
0.0125223901,
-0.0017830827,
-0.0039548865,
0.0205767918,
-0.0268180333,
-0.0325925536,
0.0140276086,
-0.0545994975,
-0.0380669981,
-0.0563730337,
0.0137450052,
-0.0011282745,
0.0017844934,
0.0161657855,
-0.0079393443,
0.0444418378,
-0.0109646395,
0.0594622009,
-0.0367788002,
-0.0079542473,
0.0406732038,
0.0188202132,
0.0014338461,
0.0386155099,
0.0147500001,
0.0481021665,
0.0365845338,
0.040584635,
0.0382887125,
-0.0613742471,
0.0164666679,
-0.0132294688,
0.0491885617,
0.040377859,
-0.03007406,
-0.0034595835,
-0.060320992,
0.0294900108,
-0.0308742374,
-0.0017198083,
0.0438607074,
0.021202568,
-0.0029176108,
-0.0326775536,
0.0412457474,
-0.017043164,
0.0372289754,
-0.0283295345,
-0.0312629528,
0.0913710296,
-0.0355981551,
-0.0379182734,
-0.0270714723,
0.0824265629,
-0.0044463794,
-0.054083392,
-0.0378852896,
0.0068277116,
-0.002723658,
0.0297099315,
-0.0105893509,
0.0149296345,
-0.0323356502,
-0.0031371147,
0.0239636637,
-0.0346958339,
-0.0212527178,
-0.0616587996,
0.0677763149,
0.0307554025,
0.0370920524,
0.0068810554,
-0.0115598822,
-0.0278589539,
0.0397810526,
0.0023500999,
0.0560149774,
-0.0251711328,
0.0064248992,
-0.0100771263,
-0.0360734873,
-0.0486027636,
0.0248471238,
-0.0027488931,
0.0374721661,
0.0057399413,
-0.0214878097,
-0.0053413827,
0.0361066423,
0.0196107794,
0.0117109623,
0.0070421896,
-0.0102863638,
0.0088659972,
-0.0139391571,
0.0316383988,
0.0162431858,
0.0119584631,
0.0228356495,
0.0316782668,
-0.0343055204,
0.0254341923,
0.0476867072,
0.0065281009,
0.0151850302,
-0.03756148,
-0.0428342223,
0.0139652425,
-0.0098270448,
-0.0035124922,
-0.0318190157,
-0.0341962427,
-0.0279787742,
-0.0302366707,
-0.0191349518,
-0.0089379437,
-0.0178799592,
0.0054892688,
0.0577649623,
0.0313712135,
-0.0369074978,
-0.0352216624,
0.0097917458,
-0.0010849047,
-0.0031566585,
0.0186270494,
0.0250657015,
-0.000008431,
-0.0081234556,
-0.0076950686,
-0.0307499692,
-0.0451032147,
0.0573555268,
-0.0521596484,
0.0178262591,
-0.0267691519,
0.0128615638,
0.0077723972,
0.0047471863,
0.0012016112,
-0.0125894574,
-0.0147842849,
-0.0321492702,
0.0065916982,
0.0149004208,
0.0239758957,
0.0065870974,
0.0197263788,
-0.0150725404,
0.0198004823,
-0.0460503995,
0.0420969613,
0.0673965067,
0.0162968822,
-0.0460563526,
-0.0882562026,
-0.0882255509,
-0.0226489957,
0.0153053775,
0.0087669371,
0.0366834998,
0.0176102668,
0.0053668492,
0.0349190161,
0.0335556343,
0.0091754487,
0.031252645,
0.0020570285,
0.0072606262,
0.0219894126,
-0.0098190326,
0.0487337559,
0.0090106074,
-0.0338163599,
0.0018028058,
0.0209539905,
0.0234086644,
0.0195724834,
-0.0351771154,
0.0929825157,
-0.0414423533,
0.0269972738,
0.0055776089,
-0.0178013127,
0.0012889376,
0.0892826691,
-0.0111269476,
-0.0091396486,
0.0872018561,
-0.0110656293,
-0.0002357446,
-0.0354372934,
-0.0282040481,
-0.0069645592,
0.0348664448,
-0.0627108142,
0.0112717208,
0.0136885354,
0.0443673134,
0.0025952577,
-0.0625188947,
0.0534636788,
-0.0350370854,
-0.0165414177,
-0.0534516387,
-0.0097622871,
0.0242841858,
-0.0328870304,
-0.0289661791,
-0.0402182415,
-0.0561926179,
-0.0306552146,
-0.0539601706,
-0.0271450561,
-0.0514045358,
-0.0180548765,
0.1024148911,
0.0567973182,
0.0104362918,
-0.0133722797,
0.0223151706,
0.0074006538,
0.020995073,
0.0331458896,
0.0906086788,
0.0006854838,
0.0244550295,
0.0781055987,
-0.0199357271,
0.002694739,
0.0057178666,
-0.0402700901,
-0.0419246852,
-0.0039401753,
0.037910793,
-0.0174206737,
0.0453013927,
-0.0642008483,
0.005077255,
0.016032638,
0.0453707464,
0.0401685387,
0.0100712841,
-0.0117544401,
-0.0232093595,
0.0465778075,
0.0412929803,
-0.1199149415,
-0.0109053031,
-0.0182059035,
-0.0041782223,
-0.0273224358,
-0.0165227335,
-0.0362122804,
-0.0573004745,
0.0657321587,
-0.0344961323,
0.0353513397,
-0.0287169497,
-0.0871004686,
0.0138252806,
-0.0121682798,
-0.0367039777,
0.0460320413,
0.0368824564,
-0.0116220089,
-0.0033925038,
-0.013522285,
0.0068719885,
0.0699233487,
-0.0215231068,
0.0162875392,
0.0196774192,
0.0326738805,
0.0215043668,
-0.0535684116,
-0.0477950536,
-0.0326539539,
-0.029127866,
0.0028022616,
0.0378002413,
-0.0113369301,
0.0095656328,
-0.0773069561,
0.0099331485,
0.0461398996,
-0.038469404,
0.0129963337,
0.0826714858,
-0.0220115837,
-0.0363441631,
-0.0161830075,
0.0210054722,
0.0001491498,
0.0577585995,
0.0090923719,
0.005256597,
-0.0368910842,
-0.049181655,
-0.0505138598,
-0.0714805126,
-0.0627663732,
0.0425055623,
0.020508578,
-0.0202215314,
-0.090512827,
0.0057598338,
0.0105566327,
0.0409911908,
-0.0648407713,
-0.037893679,
0.0367728174,
0.0496336892,
-0.0200447179,
0.0095564406,
-0.0055110948,
0.0391769744,
0.0163528342,
0.0256348997,
0.0334017612,
-0.0209697708,
-0.0042191087,
0.0412905067,
-0.0186464973,
-0.0235760231,
-0.0157451537,
0.0194799565,
0.0175372604,
0.0179307181,
-0.0302379243,
0.0154154208,
0.0054994803,
0.0152617209,
-0.0535709448,
-0.0333385505,
0.0074302251,
-0.0292346161,
0.0089176549,
-0.0163874701,
-0.0156662054,
0.0261828732,
-0.0458383337,
0.0146442838,
-0.1013839021,
-0.0223316904,
0.0377666429,
0.0160766393,
0.0352317877,
0.0351919271,
-0.0128727797,
-0.0190778915,
0.02288297,
-0.0274776537,
-0.0267360136,
0.0241938587,
0.0546461791,
-0.0468626507,
-0.0457494706,
-0.0031117087,
-0.0224244352,
-0.056159094,
0.0106380889,
0.0056314548,
0.0099991513,
0.0123194754,
0.0180784091,
-0.0086113978,
-0.0243023578,
-0.0229059309,
-0.0226419698,
-0.0357315652,
0.0277082007,
0.0137106841,
0.019345073,
0.019448394,
-0.0395750478,
0.0152889919,
-0.0471895859,
-0.0775120631,
-0.049004063,
0.0058195493,
0.0028843987,
0.0051001972,
0.0360515304,
0.0065975292,
0.002454425,
-0.038569659,
0.0558516718,
-0.0131336367,
0.0104677733,
-0.0168788768,
0.0149312858,
0.0272396095,
-0.0371124968,
-0.0101210065,
-0.0136112925,
-0.0314994715,
0.0408938825,
-0.0128573179,
-0.0525833033,
-0.0399921648,
-0.0846004561,
-0.0571782961,
0.0308875758,
0.0116719101,
-0.0274858009,
-0.0951038077,
-0.0304880887,
-0.0238059163,
0.0422584452,
0.0240304191,
0.0150281545,
-0.0109785628,
0.0571072623,
0.0504985489,
-0.0723462701,
-0.0402643755,
0.0222959779,
-0.0375920124,
-0.0001726044,
0.044622466,
-7.059593689e-33,
-0.0006417222,
-0.0740930662,
0.0180508625,
-0.0390709303,
0.0327078067,
0.0166128539,
-0.0327756032,
-0.0178262405,
-0.0548259318,
0.0534175821,
0.0102586756,
0.0390868261,
0.0167512149,
-0.0436777882,
-0.0165682584,
0.0029732243,
0.04915189,
0.0251496155,
-0.0384124108,
0.029362632,
0.047862716,
-0.0261352435,
0.0193465054,
-0.0568139702,
0.0520361252,
-0.0170277879,
-0.0404385701,
0.0271504875,
-0.0718054101,
0.0377424285,
0.0046084779,
-0.0152242659,
0.0117429448,
-0.0402659401,
0.0216214824,
0.0091516813,
-0.0485861525,
0.0034056148,
0.0451076217,
-0.0574321859,
-0.0433637127,
0.0309527591,
0.0046878634,
0.0175849181,
0.0438591912,
-0.0160086025,
0.0270715915,
-0.0163545832,
0.0630524606,
-0.0168229528,
-0.0317958333,
0.0109793348,
-0.0214770921,
-0.0141298417,
-0.0626491904,
0.0958627909,
0.0180806164,
-0.0238595251,
-0.0984294862,
0.023657009,
-0.0348804556,
-0.0581335202,
0.0498221479,
-0.0462369882,
-0.0490432866,
0.0144093307,
-0.0199664682,
-0.0040269652,
-0.0516972169,
0.0521429703,
-0.040614251,
0.0543564744,
0.0860699117,
0.1044560894,
0.0125332605,
-0.0151758529,
-0.0770408511,
0.0255069118,
0.044512026,
0.0259764176,
0.0094839111,
-0.0214565285,
-0.0245896615,
0.018581653,
-0.0138265416,
0.0378572531,
-0.0350277871,
-0.0090302676,
-0.0126467887,
0.0312110465,
-0.0633554533,
0.045580782,
-0.0264771506,
0.0023496139,
0.0569471009,
0.0052104015,
-0.0159682985,
0.0012272085,
0.0119330101,
0.0098408395,
-0.0425835736,
0.0687563792,
0.0034009465,
0.0072067734,
0.0142184086,
0.0183245018,
0.0311742257,
-0.0129710874,
-0.0627825782,
0.0212755445,
-0.0043685879,
0.052431792,
-0.0065826233,
-0.044867292,
0.0028458736,
0.0446786024,
-0.0022194705,
0.0224397928,
-0.0129774995,
0.0235771462,
-0.0569933988,
-0.0035984865,
-0.0272649489,
0.035476651,
-0.0154357692,
-0.0073891422,
-0.0407155082,
0.0180259254,
0.0015631578,
-0.0805085376,
-0.0018010727,
0.04794503,
2.955e-7,
-0.0017616318,
0.0451933332,
0.0049974434,
0.008874719,
-0.0014118433,
0.0288456045,
0.0434878021,
0.0015738836,
-0.0109415101,
-0.0810362026,
-0.0478053801,
0.0481479801,
0.005013762,
0.0902123898,
-0.0385551602,
-0.0688328594,
-0.0225543492,
-0.0288133528,
-0.0814569443,
0.0043982849,
0.0482523181,
0.0025677611,
0.0436627306,
-0.0133713363,
0.0110666156,
0.0186341424,
0.0268500838,
0.0653272122,
-0.0476453826,
0.0006901079,
0.0557150878,
-0.0470770635,
0.0216538236,
0.0433576405,
-0.0203774497,
-0.0211677477,
-0.0457705483,
0.0538051203,
0.0139519358,
-0.0502962247,
-0.0500426181,
-0.0301408507,
0.0314807892,
-0.069700025,
0.0413689613,
0.0233743843,
-0.0014293331,
-0.0487237461,
0.0100423172,
0.0200229082,
0.0236644018,
0.0033190767,
-0.0082326848,
-0.0018486409,
-0.0356156565,
0.0181323458,
0.0274187624,
-0.0014601643,
-0.0122036403,
0.0221643001,
-0.0194196329,
-0.0507861786,
0.0327867009,
-0.0820758045,
0.0343339033,
-0.0493669957,
0.0121568348,
2.265970384e-34,
-0.0069374507,
0.0385240279,
0.012540373,
-0.0319621265,
0.0961080268,
0.0318898521,
-0.0013901538,
-0.0371560603,
0.0488122106,
0.0044037811,
-0.0201632679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07588v1 | Accurate Use of Label Dependency in Multi-Label Text Classification Through the Lens of Causality | 2023-10-11T15:28:44 | 2023-10-11T15:28:44 | Caoyun Fan, Wenqing Chen, Jidong Tian, Yitian Li, Hao He, Yaohui Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multi-Label Text Classification (MLTC) aims to assign the most relevant
labels to each given text. Existing methods demonstrate that label dependency
can help to improve the model's performance. However, the introduction of label
dependency may cause the model to suffer from unwanted prediction bias. In this
study, we attribute the bias to the model's misuse of label dependency, i.e.,
the model tends to utilize the correlation shortcut in label dependency rather
than fusing text information and label dependency for prediction. Motivated by
causal inference, we propose a CounterFactual Text Classifier (CFTC) to
eliminate the correlation bias, and make causality-based predictions.
Specifically, our CFTC first adopts the predict-then-modify backbone to extract
precise label information embedded in label dependency, then blocks the
correlation shortcut through the counterfactual de-bias technique with the help
of the human causal graph. Experimental results on three datasets demonstrate
that our CFTC significantly outperforms the baselines and effectively
eliminates the correlation bias in datasets. | [
0.0577803776,
0.0390767045,
-0.0126720052,
-0.00798574,
-0.0514979586,
0.0172254331,
0.0117626507,
0.0280870032,
0.0874096081,
-0.0668946579,
0.004867,
0.0577090085,
-0.0380029716,
-0.0163354967,
-0.0242843647,
-0.0224385895,
0.0276778787,
0.0285782646,
0.0680676475,
-0.0187170804,
-0.0170323029,
0.0101469159,
0.0106453709,
-0.0009565987,
-0.0732486099,
-0.0043467232,
0.0403714553,
0.0397288688,
0.0261867624,
-0.0102451481,
0.0519684516,
0.0376650989,
-0.0385733321,
-0.0118654631,
0.0000019366,
-0.038991496,
-0.0408648886,
-0.0044630459,
0.008111326,
-0.0340644382,
-0.0091492962,
-0.0213606339,
0.0402968451,
0.0037069037,
-0.0138584962,
0.0417436585,
0.0053011905,
0.0976091996,
0.0407097712,
0.0416935608,
-0.0434547439,
-0.0563047826,
0.012007392,
-0.0062285475,
0.0388576277,
-0.0528627597,
0.0437065214,
0.0258469544,
-0.029104989,
0.0143924113,
-0.0278040469,
0.0195141509,
0.0276841838,
0.0220508613,
0.0496593602,
0.0286975224,
0.0328517705,
-0.0407261997,
0.0213387497,
0.0461656228,
0.0124711199,
-0.0647943765,
0.0208587348,
-0.0287491232,
0.0372524559,
0.0597783774,
0.0071366536,
-0.0370722823,
-0.0392556787,
0.0023834163,
0.0225866009,
0.0438722856,
0.0253454261,
0.0243538767,
0.0020148563,
0.0742350891,
-0.0170886703,
-0.0260151122,
-0.0039671808,
0.0300306603,
0.0019158766,
0.0060337186,
0.0220424235,
-0.0191386081,
-0.0151130231,
0.0093699628,
-0.0222280007,
-0.0791378245,
0.0303315315,
-0.087471731,
-0.0553798079,
-0.0260541514,
-0.0225527808,
0.0310227424,
-0.0063366108,
0.0056311009,
-0.0097045777,
0.0352406166,
-0.0200706068,
0.0034137645,
-0.0495811328,
-0.0050828187,
-0.0227854103,
0.0469731279,
0.0362234674,
0.0262613371,
-0.030882651,
-0.0102375019,
-0.0198947303,
-0.0229015406,
0.0042570848,
0.0286740139,
-0.0203053579,
-0.0009779622,
0.031869296,
0.0176460724,
-0.032327503,
0.0512913428,
-0.0693071336,
-0.003410416,
0.0219977144,
0.0325564258,
-0.0079463171,
-0.0533265173,
0.0283728745,
0.0663526654,
0.009062889,
-0.051295802,
-0.0148995072,
-0.0578121766,
-0.0482849814,
-0.0291315913,
-0.0040059602,
-0.008525555,
-0.0241632052,
0.0462251864,
0.0284974407,
-0.0166588593,
-0.0066121882,
-0.0123405978,
-0.0771334171,
0.0547839813,
0.0425982624,
-0.0371343605,
0.082058318,
0.0137733249,
-0.0037398597,
0.0244128387,
0.0183754414,
0.0305470824,
0.0319524966,
0.0212306678,
0.0188951083,
-0.0108192656,
0.0419755355,
-0.0016405955,
-0.0402676351,
-0.0156186353,
0.0483331531,
-0.0346343182,
-0.0137116155,
-0.0204380136,
0.0065986984,
-0.0122453552,
0.0291391425,
-0.0738026649,
0.0186418146,
-0.0157366861,
-0.0071868827,
0.0162355509,
-0.0338796712,
0.0075595761,
-0.027324358,
0.0449845195,
-0.0504187942,
0.0033825627,
0.0184293073,
-0.0295299627,
-0.0151891746,
-0.0388339423,
-0.0010283821,
-0.0307073519,
-0.0018638663,
-0.0228689797,
0.0653685257,
0.0139013026,
-0.0285227224,
0.0117987348,
0.0421312414,
0.0036745749,
-0.008999113,
-0.0117611606,
-0.0305050816,
0.0213878192,
0.0137872668,
-0.0608072989,
0.0060950373,
-0.0074997842,
0.0081326794,
-0.0279381201,
0.0352151059,
0.0039520254,
-0.0232947171,
-0.0003069847,
-0.0284808222,
0.0171843972,
0.0247132033,
0.0412979648,
-0.0186347961,
0.0256888866,
0.0199123323,
0.009912842,
0.0019343103,
0.0398845822,
-0.0020580604,
0.0084021175,
0.0369700566,
0.0248422027,
0.0432195403,
0.008369335,
-0.0261963177,
-0.0271807257,
0.0282724183,
-0.0113101127,
-0.0484538972,
-0.017583156,
-0.0168452002,
-0.0508255064,
-0.0251192208,
-0.0036965185,
-0.0114150047,
0.0417020135,
-0.0349597,
-0.0438258685,
0.0437188372,
0.0129408427,
0.0138983428,
0.0098999292,
-0.0431441292,
0.0129383747,
0.0071417741,
-0.0242717508,
0.0490645953,
0.0194793455,
0.0356701203,
-0.0430419669,
-0.0110061709,
0.0413568281,
0.0343886875,
0.0162067469,
0.000514658,
-0.0210568588,
-0.0052104038,
0.0600152276,
-0.0065017184,
-0.0214555021,
-0.0268408749,
-0.0577070005,
-0.0409794897,
-0.0134537173,
-0.0271852762,
-0.0344049782,
-0.0209293347,
0.0214617755,
-0.0518280193,
-0.0026186355,
-0.024397511,
-0.0505091734,
0.0015551073,
0.0057405452,
-0.0077591054,
0.0172770843,
0.0153937023,
0.0033507277,
-0.0458176956,
0.0685075745,
0.0551544018,
-0.0879128426,
-0.0084332293,
-0.0220066607,
-0.0303642061,
-0.0377992094,
-0.0132776899,
-0.0038883227,
-0.0280347038,
0.0225555766,
-0.0269224513,
0.0314051509,
0.012247148,
-0.0108412402,
0.0160963945,
0.0197589882,
-0.0117108971,
0.0194687303,
-0.0325475894,
0.0637617335,
-0.0239002071,
-0.0580817349,
-0.035260547,
0.0624546446,
0.0296312273,
-0.0289511364,
-0.0716546923,
-0.0333741494,
0.0088208662,
-0.0111396378,
-0.0589900725,
-0.0226675998,
-0.0218776837,
-0.0026741361,
-0.0045704064,
-0.0737756565,
0.0669828355,
0.0375372507,
0.0107681006,
-0.0208734479,
-0.0001593528,
-0.0232089162,
0.073014617,
0.039435558,
0.0087649673,
0.0741417184,
0.0186321903,
-0.0134971701,
0.0078084026,
0.0578684583,
0.0135203907,
-0.0372595787,
-0.0266315043,
0.0503630154,
0.0049553975,
-0.0525130518,
-0.028855877,
-0.0585609414,
-0.0067036846,
-0.0116297323,
-0.0199438799,
0.0170954689,
-0.0547285229,
-0.0260398351,
0.0065735416,
0.0357778855,
-0.0317044035,
-0.0243633389,
0.0331256874,
0.0230827481,
0.0037272284,
-0.0698235109,
-0.0584118143,
-0.0290876459,
-0.0026179426,
-0.0018957088,
0.0048378566,
0.0120489215,
0.01944918,
0.00689924,
-0.0136087006,
0.0028152668,
-0.0427788682,
-0.0062938496,
-0.0025586719,
0.0049656052,
-0.0126689523,
0.0639846697,
0.046666164,
-0.0360225439,
-0.006865609,
0.0465340801,
0.0205462649,
0.0427330695,
-0.0179933775,
-0.021005949,
-0.0464396328,
0.000422144,
-0.0056823906,
-0.020495005,
-0.0075068544,
-0.0023864037,
-0.0086463522,
-0.0161640234,
-0.0041455398,
0.0033384925,
0.059335757,
-0.0696831197,
-0.0332835056,
-0.0438627861,
-0.0788588226,
-0.0453344993,
0.0508947186,
0.0081591606,
0.0068486794,
-0.0483839437,
-0.0130604496,
0.0125463931,
0.0402297415,
0.0151045071,
0.0193598401,
0.0564425923,
-0.0490346961,
0.0312729739,
0.0655471757,
-0.0093843183,
0.0090422463,
-0.0278060101,
0.0930500254,
-0.0275072176,
0.0152541744,
-0.0032915701,
0.0031099608,
-0.0194412991,
-0.049368754,
0.0024535141,
0.0485624485,
-0.0199898016,
-0.0169384256,
-0.0182949211,
-0.0112434365,
-0.0122935316,
0.0332819223,
-0.01943985,
-0.1081072912,
-0.0296013746,
-0.0250860006,
0.0058409926,
-0.0284194779,
-0.0206010658,
-0.0216419678,
-0.0202382319,
-0.057322327,
-0.0500164479,
-0.027373638,
-0.0354450531,
0.009742259,
-0.0393502265,
0.0253130309,
-0.0433345102,
-0.0186474435,
-0.0332974754,
0.0004903252,
0.0194759015,
0.0505235009,
-0.0298112407,
-0.0109073678,
0.0665869936,
-0.0336607024,
-0.0423126817,
0.032550808,
-0.0356361046,
-0.0453359298,
0.0108939875,
0.0271674264,
0.0112192705,
0.0505191199,
0.0044680987,
-0.0202032719,
0.0125341434,
0.1201672629,
-0.0637390018,
0.0016542313,
0.0443854071,
-0.0351170301,
-0.0152644757,
0.0069859554,
-0.0238230787,
0.0591133796,
0.0209331773,
-0.0037413789,
-0.026698038,
-0.0403498672,
-0.0006288136,
-0.0033020102,
0.1160905361,
-0.0459015854,
-0.0061402377,
-0.0305975229,
0.0034248983,
-0.0163199231,
-0.0293074958,
0.0186499059,
0.0227485299,
0.0160818193,
0.0010017374,
-0.0483735725,
0.0136347376,
-0.0185811538,
0.0194916949,
0.0220015123,
0.0078850798,
0.0013330891,
0.0796516016,
0.0262853988,
-0.0308510046,
0.0007230166,
-0.0236780047,
0.0865061507,
0.0097406413,
-0.0057392498,
0.0244251899,
0.0337102711,
0.0265509095,
-0.0343850255,
-0.0621217266,
-0.1105415672,
0.1050449684,
-0.0200840961,
-0.0252991989,
0.0205598399,
0.001753693,
0.042305097,
-0.0346880779,
-0.0143626537,
-0.0039501186,
0.0515100248,
0.0488954484,
-0.0153645035,
0.0059406189,
-0.0163580384,
-0.023660833,
0.0714548081,
0.0589808188,
0.0480413511,
0.0294020306,
-0.0303551722,
-0.0358957015,
-0.0337619781,
-0.0353540927,
0.0187944062,
0.0201760195,
-0.0012502397,
-0.0014219012,
-0.0725503638,
-0.0342510603,
0.0966258943,
-0.060215801,
0.0372389816,
0.0067301667,
0.0090175457,
0.0118985688,
0.0184310395,
-0.0479430147,
-0.0475044884,
-0.0064939382,
0.0116964933,
-0.0206318628,
-0.0114269983,
-6.080615178e-33,
0.0031183488,
-0.0674371347,
-0.0345578752,
0.006182842,
0.025194345,
0.0074273939,
0.0101935016,
-0.0223176759,
0.0062749381,
0.0258268844,
0.0148481857,
0.037938524,
0.0044327169,
0.0312605985,
0.0305286739,
0.0031428197,
0.0256243516,
-0.0010713803,
-0.0002575178,
0.0305495504,
0.0247187763,
0.0426524021,
0.0320112742,
-0.1503921002,
0.0796959326,
-0.0157715194,
-0.0192814544,
-0.0268052891,
-0.0298560038,
0.0094087347,
0.0114530791,
0.0532841794,
0.0609302223,
-0.019452706,
0.0463100784,
0.0133621674,
-0.0460260734,
-0.0512075648,
-0.0295063145,
-0.0010098917,
0.0073337317,
-0.0114472071,
-0.000817062,
0.018374851,
0.0110489903,
-0.0203108061,
0.094727613,
-0.0196057465,
-0.0230554044,
-0.031311769,
-0.0316399559,
0.0493060909,
-0.0104777059,
0.0216415823,
0.0014222376,
0.0827887356,
0.0120188734,
0.0595083684,
-0.0366837941,
0.0099582374,
-0.0354447961,
-0.0278209746,
-0.0331118107,
0.0441276133,
-0.0072252275,
0.0351653844,
0.011741153,
0.0437551364,
0.0067774509,
-0.0371030308,
0.0018486854,
-0.0027236682,
0.0371234864,
0.094905518,
0.0396564268,
-0.0493113808,
-0.1044155359,
0.0145659121,
0.0102843931,
-0.0397617966,
0.0090114512,
-0.0103722941,
-0.0336315669,
-0.0380363949,
-0.0448288955,
-0.0267575458,
-0.025456313,
0.0300510991,
-0.0049408041,
0.0206499882,
0.0015047517,
0.0319581516,
-0.0162920952,
-0.0373428538,
-0.0522592627,
0.0451301336,
-0.0484803319,
0.0445922986,
-0.0032156571,
-0.0055067847,
-0.0614424907,
-0.0168856066,
0.0273857396,
0.0226058513,
0.0489628427,
-0.0448278263,
0.1121813953,
-0.0264855511,
-0.0630585551,
-0.0299074799,
0.0260226838,
-0.0317839682,
0.0239060689,
-0.017730359,
0.0157378204,
0.0335769914,
0.0070943087,
0.0689107254,
0.0477691479,
0.0253410079,
0.0124338642,
-0.026562402,
-0.0244117193,
0.0091856215,
-0.022370372,
-0.030671427,
0.0265911687,
-0.0022306098,
-0.0002899424,
-0.0653030276,
-0.023140166,
-0.0144632412,
2.644e-7,
0.0549832992,
0.0563726686,
-0.0040366841,
-0.0380938165,
0.0317291245,
0.0760142058,
-0.0214014128,
0.0329199806,
-0.0046851602,
0.0212761313,
0.0589505099,
-0.0161328763,
0.0302465875,
0.0164354444,
-0.0551660806,
0.0005474651,
-0.0492720716,
-0.031280037,
-0.0230125785,
0.0180796143,
0.0745309591,
0.022083411,
0.0657477826,
-0.0218182821,
-0.023953842,
0.0342325941,
0.0606956966,
-0.0233244859,
0.037127763,
-0.0026536197,
-0.0230434127,
-0.0176258571,
-0.032260906,
0.0770125762,
-0.0514235608,
-0.0174022578,
-0.0092202099,
0.0230895393,
-0.0351813212,
-0.0170297399,
-0.0004495866,
0.0204466935,
0.0157422367,
0.0027017694,
0.0580561645,
-0.0138690853,
-0.0235420298,
0.0361458324,
-0.04728752,
0.030201558,
0.0500108749,
0.0280654151,
-0.0282676574,
0.0382410884,
-0.0014698482,
0.0332462937,
-0.0109897163,
-0.0733402818,
-0.0260678399,
0.0447211191,
-0.0232413318,
0.0154146431,
0.0040959939,
0.0388867967,
0.0640566871,
-0.0529944524,
0.0335249528,
2.033343266e-34,
0.0114143724,
-0.0232996903,
-0.0172036644,
-0.0718619153,
0.0059825559,
-0.0128633697,
-0.0527181439,
0.0358719639,
0.0305724386,
-0.036119692,
0.0257554017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07521v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07521v3 | Survey on Factuality in Large Language Models: Knowledge, Retrieval and Domain-Specificity | 2023-10-11T14:18:03 | 2023-12-16T12:47:19 | Cunxiang Wang, Xiaoze Liu, Yuanhao Yue, Xiangru Tang, Tianhang Zhang, Cheng Jiayang, Yunzhi Yao, Wenyang Gao, Xuming Hu, Zehan Qi, Yidong Wang, Linyi Yang, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie, Zheng Zhang, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This survey addresses the crucial issue of factuality in Large Language
Models (LLMs). As LLMs find applications across diverse domains, the
reliability and accuracy of their outputs become vital. We define the
Factuality Issue as the probability of LLMs to produce content inconsistent
with established facts. We first delve into the implications of these
inaccuracies, highlighting the potential consequences and challenges posed by
factual errors in LLM outputs. Subsequently, we analyze the mechanisms through
which LLMs store and process facts, seeking the primary causes of factual
errors. Our discussion then transitions to methodologies for evaluating LLM
factuality, emphasizing key metrics, benchmarks, and studies. We further
explore strategies for enhancing LLM factuality, including approaches tailored
for specific domains. We focus two primary LLM configurations standalone LLMs
and Retrieval-Augmented LLMs that utilizes external data, we detail their
unique challenges and potential enhancements. Our survey offers a structured
guide for researchers aiming to fortify the factual reliability of LLMs. | [
0.0578044206,
0.054434754,
-0.0284889881,
0.0677977577,
-0.0511893891,
-0.0288037229,
-0.0169857424,
-0.016685009,
-0.0082773231,
-0.0631316006,
0.0158902742,
-0.0605016686,
0.0259262919,
0.0109709101,
0.0121655539,
0.0217417795,
0.0535879955,
-0.0049181539,
-0.0104151824,
-0.0061297473,
-0.0000786572,
0.0356690288,
0.0160964895,
0.0389203094,
-0.0344021581,
-0.0015783773,
0.0291475952,
-0.0086649898,
-0.0228740238,
-0.0102237482,
-0.0161801223,
0.0081422478,
0.0077871,
0.0742029324,
0.0000021369,
-0.0764974058,
-0.0287220217,
0.0356192216,
-0.056979578,
0.0417849571,
0.0382130556,
0.0157948621,
-0.0157232657,
-0.0016152244,
-0.0277139619,
-0.029362319,
0.0342088081,
0.0205771104,
0.0287257563,
0.063503556,
0.0021046996,
-0.0251660869,
0.0293561369,
-0.006529572,
-0.0247114487,
0.0210681036,
0.0416279435,
0.0481286757,
-0.009411335,
0.036264535,
0.0020420875,
0.0532162189,
-0.0056469678,
-0.0165236443,
0.0046878564,
0.0196430478,
-0.0147689907,
-0.0197591875,
0.0469607152,
0.0020112945,
0.0900692865,
-0.0194099378,
0.0027986683,
0.0002825261,
-0.0143327815,
0.0548687428,
-0.0395008773,
0.0649156272,
-0.0192812774,
0.0241188556,
-0.0040649921,
-0.0108895442,
0.0535441451,
0.0217308346,
-0.0301992875,
0.0834559575,
0.0137546463,
-0.0546029992,
-0.0486113355,
-0.0072168559,
0.0001583754,
-0.0458809845,
-0.0088095944,
0.0109411404,
0.0072413241,
0.0486641936,
0.0131272208,
0.0157633629,
0.0595956668,
-0.0779443532,
0.0331743434,
-0.0081843911,
-0.0354677886,
0.0394359045,
0.0186691787,
0.0489852801,
-0.0071554696,
0.0010814556,
-0.0203795563,
-0.0056049605,
-0.0258709323,
-0.0111020785,
0.0223963242,
0.0306578502,
0.0020445511,
0.0250946041,
-0.0206473209,
-0.0000703513,
-0.0080057327,
0.0439155884,
-0.0175071787,
-0.0159926638,
-0.0380904414,
-0.0203936882,
-0.0814747289,
0.0256171916,
0.0043440103,
0.0387199335,
-0.0148978401,
-0.0817466825,
0.021349756,
0.0010172902,
-0.039009288,
-0.0190579835,
-0.0053007682,
0.0257379916,
0.0333735608,
-0.005498522,
-0.0481112413,
-0.0521120094,
-0.0417435728,
-0.0755482838,
-0.0384800024,
-0.0841099843,
0.0046735397,
0.0282839201,
-0.0086324131,
-0.0634242222,
0.0000175252,
0.0067179375,
-0.0276053566,
0.0410373248,
-0.0201988686,
0.0178260151,
0.0231420826,
0.0013375429,
0.028547246,
0.0546870381,
0.0397567712,
0.0076013249,
0.0812376961,
0.0345892683,
-0.0150485653,
0.0040288568,
0.0207251813,
0.0090802163,
-0.0186539814,
0.0349859744,
0.0145719396,
0.0197947938,
0.0204804633,
0.0583439171,
-0.0141337896,
-0.0196861327,
0.0877414495,
0.0339752547,
-0.0012294623,
0.007248132,
0.0457331426,
0.0146887861,
0.0462242886,
0.0131627833,
-0.0385095514,
-0.021167554,
-0.0129856439,
0.0293727573,
0.0293362997,
0.0628065169,
0.0088042682,
-0.0603191033,
-0.0392408408,
0.0075368979,
-0.0365842953,
0.0111338617,
0.0609625168,
-0.0204136427,
0.0180956852,
0.0842440948,
0.036534477,
-0.0509560183,
-0.0023309954,
-0.0322753564,
0.0281381309,
0.0283444226,
0.0584161654,
-0.035808336,
-0.0417868495,
0.024656672,
-0.0142096803,
0.0220672712,
0.0494809784,
-0.0047332891,
-0.0089084059,
-0.015998058,
0.0095365886,
-0.0196983255,
0.0327845216,
-0.0142475907,
0.0231508613,
0.0141362296,
0.0166921429,
-0.0689983591,
-0.0257828515,
0.0213097297,
-0.052756384,
0.0028533239,
-0.0321203806,
-0.0165469013,
0.0100171547,
0.0148885017,
-0.0367691852,
0.0159085467,
0.0078944666,
0.0137211978,
-0.0102513451,
-0.0140374759,
0.0190677941,
0.0279198028,
0.0694636032,
0.0179940052,
-0.0044187354,
0.0083242198,
0.0116555765,
-0.0052218414,
0.001891626,
-0.0402744114,
0.0387746878,
-0.0547804981,
0.0368105918,
-0.0147029376,
0.0122638699,
-0.0259402227,
0.0512629002,
-0.0061123311,
0.0157482345,
0.0004687023,
-0.0385944359,
0.034217339,
-0.0353441127,
-0.010616065,
0.0359931998,
0.0113939438,
0.0523909405,
0.0711652935,
-0.0482349768,
-0.0418360531,
-0.0014500396,
-0.0562730469,
0.0138442656,
-0.0066799256,
0.0078707235,
-0.0159374662,
-0.0056370059,
-0.0218525436,
0.0233521741,
0.012815387,
-0.0492081121,
0.0059776381,
0.0172082409,
0.0287791789,
0.0016405403,
-0.0030252868,
-0.02567604,
-0.0057590455,
-0.0092079276,
0.0492727011,
-0.0022373262,
-0.0027241409,
-0.0481082685,
0.05278432,
-0.1118812338,
0.0226605181,
-0.0079226336,
-0.0016543131,
0.0058092964,
-0.0090766326,
0.0308939945,
0.0084203165,
-0.0160094462,
0.0339136049,
0.0714400336,
-0.0420817882,
-0.0624659322,
-0.0236058794,
-0.0233409666,
-0.0508336313,
-0.0201817919,
-0.0351730436,
0.0097316904,
0.0155074112,
0.030477982,
-0.0235595498,
-0.0165145118,
0.0167451333,
-0.0791019425,
-0.0164154861,
-0.0276726801,
0.0027127638,
-0.0253664348,
0.0594616048,
0.0024070472,
-0.0556985252,
0.0542706177,
-0.0616896152,
0.0413696617,
-0.0250049606,
-0.0174608175,
-0.0100419382,
0.0422555804,
-0.0145506701,
0.0156663172,
0.0252089798,
-0.0006558844,
-0.0308565926,
-0.0075782319,
0.0634690896,
-0.0698043332,
0.0853484869,
-0.0555115081,
0.0400963053,
0.0317014717,
-0.0264305323,
-0.0406553298,
-0.0478114411,
-0.0086864345,
-0.0057709138,
-0.0103753693,
-0.0089949453,
-0.0554239675,
-0.0216599982,
0.0632007942,
-0.0017848815,
0.0068188142,
-0.0204449166,
-0.0067307069,
0.0012666819,
0.0258739349,
0.0153984884,
0.0505488738,
-0.0025781239,
0.0001075555,
0.0647883117,
-0.0083062956,
-0.0153782722,
0.0063658371,
-0.0550058782,
0.0306840762,
-0.0184052568,
-0.0294037759,
0.025190752,
0.0258171707,
-0.0663136095,
-0.0380767919,
0.1056732535,
0.042547714,
0.0077199116,
-0.0087173674,
-0.0154933529,
-0.0300656371,
0.0182251986,
0.0192470979,
-0.0618442185,
0.023277767,
0.0143634537,
0.0163079649,
-0.0348076858,
-0.0148663465,
-0.0271389354,
-0.1382817775,
0.0500380471,
0.0063315993,
0.0113811968,
-0.0577091761,
-0.0642933249,
0.0105916895,
-0.0076528266,
0.0309881568,
0.0312288199,
-0.0143539347,
-0.0094751436,
0.0135937547,
-0.0471331105,
-0.0756627247,
0.031165801,
-0.033813335,
0.0568520389,
0.0403032228,
0.0251666587,
-0.0276133996,
-0.0175061543,
-0.009342378,
0.0062028635,
-0.0266259126,
0.0014260038,
0.0030234638,
0.0016732981,
0.0098643443,
-0.0297110025,
-0.0381651744,
0.0280673094,
-0.0230817609,
-0.0184892081,
0.0848422348,
-0.0338168889,
-0.0036536651,
-0.0305145141,
-0.0013196896,
-0.0201331768,
0.0985697061,
0.0083085736,
0.0355440602,
0.0192742255,
-0.0443204455,
-0.0131336115,
0.0386598036,
-0.0660037026,
0.0360723659,
-0.0172350369,
-0.0165294521,
-0.0416297242,
-0.0367997661,
-0.0145390257,
0.015566905,
-0.0245593376,
-0.0017954358,
0.0516498983,
-0.0254780483,
-0.0424860194,
0.0150906108,
-0.0709320456,
0.0251673255,
-0.0153229833,
0.0284780972,
0.0424552225,
-0.0292397328,
-0.0039078919,
-0.0123557411,
-0.0530229323,
-0.0573440753,
0.0217794534,
0.0081882719,
0.0252865739,
0.0290275048,
-0.0188073926,
-0.0411950834,
0.0588860326,
0.0515066795,
-0.0630945042,
0.0214869529,
0.0037662035,
-0.0126163187,
-0.0021467572,
0.0446381941,
-0.0607988015,
-0.0011597737,
-0.0176368188,
0.0435270816,
-0.0135178333,
-0.0536286235,
0.0551565289,
0.0535895228,
0.0616778098,
0.0008067561,
-0.0302140117,
-0.0414040685,
-0.0078297425,
-0.0695788637,
-0.0481200032,
-0.0143917231,
0.0201035738,
0.0026324338,
0.0401338302,
-0.0241808239,
0.0154971853,
-0.0301087033,
0.0500111468,
-0.010623767,
-0.0191641171,
-0.0025077534,
0.0054211281,
0.0414428823,
0.0028905168,
-0.0209483635,
0.025657583,
-0.021002261,
0.0574829094,
-0.0085361227,
0.02841557,
0.0230500121,
-0.0046244548,
-0.0402407721,
-0.0261369999,
-0.0440566763,
-0.0125828022,
-0.0158284437,
0.0179655664,
0.0602769554,
-0.0066978103,
0.0605443195,
-0.0586826019,
-0.0198100638,
-0.029067615,
-0.0136224264,
0.0317424908,
-0.0269455872,
0.008283454,
0.0161288586,
-0.0528054126,
0.0503614694,
0.070891045,
0.003039917,
0.025467163,
-0.0210679825,
-0.0535598248,
-0.0015281772,
-0.0476495214,
-0.0163800269,
-0.0132810362,
-0.0352717377,
-0.024848016,
-0.1272474229,
-0.0913819894,
0.0199452639,
0.0141407205,
-0.0164448507,
-0.044315055,
-0.0160835851,
0.1001911461,
0.0405290201,
-0.0112009449,
-0.0685475096,
0.0156336613,
-0.037044514,
0.0272924919,
-0.0109126503,
-6.93455709e-33,
-0.020587232,
-0.0221903715,
0.0219193529,
-0.0357509144,
-0.0248008166,
0.0419824645,
-0.0095813842,
-0.0113500142,
-0.0421744697,
0.0306204241,
0.0080961408,
0.0370645113,
0.0136274742,
0.0010042565,
0.0100320764,
-0.0079954294,
0.0408405177,
0.0125782564,
-0.0337441564,
-0.0034417761,
0.0754410923,
-0.023932647,
0.0605333522,
-0.1007766128,
0.0833440423,
-0.003337075,
0.0087855253,
0.0411298499,
-0.025023425,
0.0583658442,
-0.0077978955,
0.0895173252,
0.0098210694,
-0.0687702894,
-0.0028909231,
-0.0711572319,
-0.0210667402,
-0.0124280993,
0.0523398481,
-0.0135351028,
0.0383665226,
-0.015928233,
0.0175306834,
0.0145645412,
-0.0440347232,
-0.0077200159,
0.0416015908,
-0.0268312674,
-0.0156575367,
-0.0074502886,
-0.0518944487,
0.0306317564,
0.0227482915,
0.030731352,
-0.0034968311,
-0.0347864144,
0.0196860414,
0.0171838086,
-0.0701755136,
0.0275184978,
-0.0032639641,
0.0300524291,
0.061340306,
-0.023304306,
0.0071340157,
0.0562829413,
-0.012001114,
0.0414071828,
-0.0560227782,
0.0016134633,
0.0315305553,
0.0340348259,
0.0019357005,
0.0982456207,
-0.0246664565,
-0.0114218649,
-0.0586873554,
0.0099872658,
0.0169965494,
0.0347664468,
0.0146718519,
-0.0102529833,
-0.0792399794,
-0.0320552215,
-0.0353375711,
0.0531945638,
-0.0232933816,
-0.0064127496,
0.0193103515,
-0.0136489486,
0.0008587959,
0.0179500766,
0.0047870418,
-0.048802875,
-0.0343518667,
0.0167882591,
-0.0299180336,
-0.0102280164,
-0.0029021199,
0.0528622977,
-0.0499412306,
0.0226601064,
-0.0180650763,
-0.0135337217,
-0.0274995733,
0.0297713242,
-0.0012195732,
0.0168888979,
-0.0312642232,
0.0087822722,
-0.0270214919,
-0.0269534457,
0.0059423363,
-0.060555812,
0.0305648539,
0.023481153,
-0.001770208,
0.0371690392,
0.0424575768,
0.0311806593,
-0.0143809719,
-0.0138627682,
0.0026746294,
-0.0128966505,
-0.0139244366,
0.0057921433,
-0.0525502674,
0.0155204879,
0.0379453264,
-0.0153578585,
-0.0099580856,
-0.0133873262,
2.944e-7,
0.04786174,
0.0585014001,
0.0037385253,
0.0410708115,
-0.0158855021,
0.0417092815,
-0.0334912054,
-0.0193050168,
0.0265366193,
-0.0517072305,
-0.01970491,
0.0345647335,
0.0412832312,
0.0638354197,
-0.0283535309,
-0.0002111859,
-0.0458017588,
-0.0258567911,
-0.057483729,
0.0038825856,
0.0125596887,
0.0725058615,
0.0390375704,
0.0058797002,
-0.0177962575,
-0.0636894628,
0.0417525358,
-0.0186258424,
-0.0675009638,
0.0376036242,
0.0704329386,
0.0188579354,
0.025218334,
-0.0322316773,
-0.0065853535,
0.0317631811,
-0.0060235546,
0.020552367,
0.0195474606,
0.0220155027,
-0.0511392131,
-0.0525084957,
-0.0130119845,
-0.0510766059,
0.0523150004,
-0.0083755944,
-0.0394390076,
-0.0529653169,
-0.0230625812,
0.0241244249,
0.00022113,
0.0073313704,
-0.040037971,
0.0125416555,
-0.0032947042,
0.0248370506,
-0.0118650515,
-0.0401250832,
-0.0262226947,
0.0317430198,
-0.0287493002,
-0.0998457074,
0.0280615129,
-0.0002150405,
0.0151367337,
-0.0591064356,
0.045694571,
2.985707667e-34,
0.0421015583,
0.0171742234,
0.002505318,
-0.027673861,
0.0593724623,
0.0013712061,
-0.0222006068,
0.0001032869,
-0.0091564106,
-0.0619988255,
-0.0019174226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07488v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07488v2 | KwaiYiiMath: Technical Report | 2023-10-11T13:35:05 | 2023-10-19T12:34:32 | Jiayi Fu, Lei Lin, Xiaoyang Gao, Pengli Liu, Zhengzong Chen, Zhirui Yang, Shengnan Zhang, Xue Zheng, Yan Li, Yuliang Liu, Xucheng Ye, Yiqiao Liao, Chao Liao, Bin Chen, Chengru Song, Junchen Wan, Zijia Lin, Fuzheng Zhang, Zhongyuan Wang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated
remarkable abilities in handling a variety of natural language processing (NLP)
downstream tasks, even on mathematical tasks requiring multi-step reasoning. In
this report, we introduce the KwaiYiiMath which enhances the mathematical
reasoning abilities of KwaiYiiBase1, by applying Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT)
and Reinforced Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), including on both English
and Chinese mathematical tasks. Meanwhile, we also constructed a small-scale
Chinese primary school mathematics test set (named KMath), consisting of 188
examples to evaluate the correctness of the problem-solving process generated
by the models. Empirical studies demonstrate that KwaiYiiMath can achieve
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance on GSM8k, CMath, and KMath compared with
the similar size models, respectively. | [
0.0360496603,
0.0548902117,
-0.008023412,
0.0402134471,
-0.0535418019,
0.0326840952,
0.0330313332,
-0.0041706041,
-0.0294444654,
-0.0549514964,
-0.0452610888,
-0.0560729578,
0.0145240519,
-0.0101427538,
0.0462582819,
-0.0287073273,
0.0427463837,
-0.0660180897,
0.0294518303,
-0.0141537786,
-0.0331425555,
-0.0125754271,
-0.0580656379,
0.0306332503,
-0.032064382,
-0.0552195236,
0.0294692442,
-0.0594414137,
-0.0066375285,
-0.0609624162,
0.0236959867,
0.0633129627,
0.0131760994,
0.02983303,
0.0000024247,
-0.0506233387,
0.0281179063,
-0.0127310725,
-0.0407917611,
0.0305404942,
0.0062846281,
-0.0254982691,
-0.0053156451,
0.006559582,
-0.0451462567,
0.036007259,
0.0072447574,
0.0984383449,
0.0747673437,
0.074153319,
0.0063204113,
-0.0816707015,
0.0489824861,
-0.0206972025,
0.017198842,
-0.0513199754,
0.033351846,
0.0352107212,
0.0169873685,
-0.0057945233,
-0.0308060795,
0.0396572575,
0.0453033522,
-0.0101694902,
-0.0248432998,
0.0239091832,
-0.0380528755,
-0.0046590362,
-0.0100048678,
0.0705649629,
-0.002630993,
-0.0282861087,
-0.027662158,
-0.0034889798,
-0.0374592021,
0.0275593176,
-0.0604245104,
0.0424742885,
-0.0027114959,
0.0163019821,
-0.0167449899,
-0.0306322537,
0.0237121042,
0.0474798866,
-0.0342804231,
0.091441296,
0.0074573439,
-0.0442420803,
0.0107789282,
0.0130865276,
-0.0994952917,
-0.0116938027,
0.0356109552,
0.0412786789,
-0.0110806599,
0.0076137013,
-0.0020708893,
-0.0507449284,
-0.0296673924,
-0.0634956136,
0.008738176,
0.0764908716,
0.0366704203,
0.0376800634,
-0.0430731103,
0.0611810572,
-0.024654502,
0.0455844104,
0.0030943304,
0.0443138853,
-0.0491247177,
-0.037532717,
-0.0045373994,
0.0314013436,
-0.0129075674,
-0.0288938303,
-0.0412490815,
0.0181216765,
-0.0240728613,
0.0057503148,
0.0195173435,
-0.005066772,
-0.0073665897,
-0.0309846997,
-0.050786525,
0.0363391191,
-0.0614125095,
0.0291525386,
-0.0091079306,
0.0006448687,
-0.0109434947,
0.0100740725,
0.0039659715,
-0.0309558604,
0.0273300037,
0.0246520303,
-0.010573714,
-0.0227434356,
-0.0467519946,
-0.0020227924,
0.0089295683,
-0.0726385191,
0.0154260788,
-0.0686464682,
0.0087855486,
0.0079092467,
0.0024448948,
-0.0165679157,
0.025957277,
0.024040712,
0.0089687435,
0.0743941218,
0.0257958341,
0.0142119033,
0.0077409171,
0.0008099587,
0.0006754749,
0.0780832693,
0.0458535329,
-0.0396642312,
0.0174144972,
-0.0284261294,
-0.0091969529,
0.0221333485,
0.0021292882,
-0.0320902802,
-0.0326181203,
-0.0121378824,
-0.0259185731,
0.0474308915,
-0.0099956337,
0.0051860558,
-0.0491820797,
0.0252918173,
0.0499416217,
0.0679658577,
-0.0001003956,
0.0291647967,
-0.005826341,
-0.0129019823,
0.0465953648,
-0.0070382501,
-0.091168955,
0.0382903069,
-0.0402501188,
0.0180747807,
-0.0140417907,
0.0086138006,
-0.0159929991,
-0.0536534972,
-0.0172817521,
-0.0099034607,
-0.0114453593,
0.0119906096,
0.0731530115,
0.0076226462,
0.0219615903,
0.0391205251,
0.0454353206,
0.0008370736,
-0.0016618386,
-0.0634201914,
0.0274212901,
0.0290295165,
0.0488641709,
-0.0361090824,
-0.0245500859,
-0.002414546,
-0.0229416862,
0.0540917814,
0.0083305277,
0.0082661891,
-0.0512017123,
-0.0576595925,
-0.0158596803,
-0.0228513274,
0.0203962512,
-0.0396967977,
0.0589410327,
0.010805618,
0.0221923143,
-0.024238959,
0.0219745785,
0.0245177411,
-0.0493858345,
-0.0449439175,
-0.0284800734,
0.0111925993,
-0.0184168983,
0.0036853922,
-0.0017986182,
0.0331823044,
0.007544802,
-0.0250553489,
-0.0163630452,
-0.0178975686,
-0.0619933978,
-0.0568614528,
0.0359279811,
0.022041956,
-0.0075157424,
0.0661567971,
-0.0249222126,
-0.0190367252,
0.042014543,
0.0071868333,
0.025160443,
-0.0309150629,
0.0460504703,
-0.0005692959,
0.0026567064,
-0.0156394374,
0.0827495083,
0.0262815543,
0.0158464089,
0.0134580797,
0.0146457925,
-0.0039259554,
0.0138112437,
-0.0341783129,
-0.0115037709,
-0.0145925255,
0.0378813371,
-0.0165610127,
0.0119887376,
-0.0333670452,
-0.0256663822,
-0.0134205399,
0.0200208593,
-0.0164250955,
0.038009759,
-0.0071877106,
-0.029110197,
-0.0067782612,
-0.0000406466,
0.0045961803,
0.0002485062,
-0.0028092079,
0.0112885619,
0.0150857205,
-0.0199605003,
0.0192907322,
-0.017637888,
-0.0313107297,
-0.0429254696,
0.0512384027,
0.0139260869,
0.0205986463,
-0.0404057801,
0.0145407142,
-0.0381422527,
0.0096338969,
-0.0016038521,
-0.014704274,
0.021364009,
-0.0132498555,
0.0504759215,
0.1015044823,
-0.0017928052,
0.0118449274,
0.0130445976,
0.0001653479,
-0.0483925119,
0.0236850064,
-0.0189836826,
-0.0236937627,
-0.0011901109,
0.0424501412,
-0.0400458723,
0.1023253947,
-0.0173301715,
-0.0185782146,
-0.0460582711,
0.0388506837,
-0.0225500483,
-0.0001187775,
-0.037642207,
-0.0017522803,
-0.0285841282,
0.0267355554,
-0.032439094,
-0.0070818397,
0.0543720983,
0.0199232791,
-0.0055093528,
-0.0783822313,
0.0275425259,
-0.0303853136,
0.0391965024,
-0.0073759384,
-0.0282405186,
-0.0088316957,
0.008410221,
-0.0365797505,
0.0062722825,
0.0093501359,
-0.0155175962,
0.0195289832,
-0.0280283727,
0.0054329261,
-0.0021853135,
-0.0272095446,
-0.0311180297,
0.0284130238,
-0.0387782939,
0.0488207936,
0.0101380749,
0.0059723835,
0.0097835613,
0.0252289344,
0.046208553,
0.0183370207,
-0.0441046208,
-0.0094039617,
-0.0288867634,
0.0077479016,
0.0359243415,
0.0443468504,
0.0346645676,
-0.0380355231,
0.0588137656,
0.0208614618,
0.0334942788,
0.0133413086,
-0.0013840043,
0.0334854797,
-0.0058271247,
-0.041231934,
-0.0241572112,
0.0109520685,
0.0279566851,
-0.1083334386,
-0.0086320769,
0.0955883339,
0.0542373769,
-0.0411664657,
0.0060091,
-0.0543199927,
0.0094833719,
0.0176320653,
-0.0069996556,
-0.0484588295,
-0.0307529494,
0.0195977986,
-0.0008700485,
0.0280147437,
-0.0264242236,
0.0284275413,
-0.1560794711,
0.0355744362,
0.0257698111,
-0.0161615573,
-0.0207637437,
-0.0456001088,
-0.0049207075,
0.0335667357,
0.0220893901,
0.0469344631,
-0.0027092763,
0.0232186764,
0.013094821,
-0.0187955797,
-0.0718625337,
0.0255169943,
-0.0526026562,
0.016181143,
0.0417894684,
0.0188792404,
-0.0143043483,
-0.0597571917,
0.028758958,
0.0139335515,
-0.0056207213,
-0.0074543459,
0.0133080175,
0.0254798327,
-0.03157942,
-0.0547643974,
0.0393204503,
-0.0508735366,
-0.0398973264,
0.0137347812,
0.0961656049,
-0.0167353861,
-0.0084381532,
0.0051377709,
0.0102411127,
-0.0690696836,
0.0436467417,
0.0377010219,
-0.0274692159,
-0.0682787001,
-0.0369015075,
-0.0276147574,
-0.063478604,
-0.0649941266,
0.03240823,
0.0436269976,
0.0163827855,
-0.0781111345,
-0.028412642,
0.0388043672,
0.0417805798,
0.0092794178,
-0.0167801566,
0.045455344,
-0.0158008151,
-0.0293664858,
0.0289374776,
-0.0096444944,
0.0457474738,
-0.0665051863,
0.0297133122,
0.0408047773,
-0.0209865887,
-0.0131141953,
0.0051143588,
-0.085659124,
-0.0654229149,
-0.0385303162,
0.0385801122,
0.0199957397,
0.0105784815,
-0.0149363065,
-0.0192258805,
0.0285619702,
-0.0011947841,
-0.0628902689,
0.0240340009,
0.020029027,
0.0181584805,
0.0074601527,
0.0217120461,
0.0083137024,
0.0109664816,
0.026601078,
0.0769629031,
0.0060601006,
0.0197359361,
0.0022850034,
0.0333912745,
0.0278512593,
0.0330413729,
0.0015559694,
-0.0178926494,
0.0374333002,
-0.0296140667,
-0.0013817156,
-0.0134996874,
0.0125608342,
0.0196796916,
0.0037649055,
-0.0157651398,
-0.0187142994,
0.0627029613,
0.0133034317,
0.0018637002,
0.0394734666,
-0.0125575727,
0.0263214763,
0.004737292,
-0.0066149528,
0.0010462395,
0.0119512789,
-0.0018715409,
0.0530159436,
-0.0162784904,
0.0835813805,
0.0119999731,
-0.0125862062,
-0.0265516452,
0.0007917201,
-0.0267639197,
-0.098325327,
-0.0141065642,
0.0005730051,
0.0445426553,
-0.0103539918,
-0.0147526953,
-0.0459928401,
-0.0262629408,
-0.0006841476,
0.0218260568,
-0.0027767171,
-0.008645949,
0.0117884548,
0.0275452789,
0.002889958,
-0.0474951193,
0.0512126498,
-0.0249152128,
0.0369117521,
0.0065510753,
0.0196930952,
-0.017357979,
-0.0537111945,
-0.0019541737,
-0.0008078817,
-0.0123776812,
0.0574797317,
-0.0411579683,
-0.0922177508,
0.0012053347,
-0.0212035552,
-0.0259549506,
-0.0048361006,
0.0021050845,
0.0430359207,
-0.0397124216,
-0.0394163728,
-0.0126407286,
0.0074429973,
-0.016247984,
0.0127749089,
-0.0086951265,
-7.056234714e-33,
-0.0180816185,
-0.0081296461,
0.0536233485,
0.0355152674,
-0.016781155,
-0.0315076932,
-0.0428786241,
0.0301162042,
-0.0280733798,
-0.0031035654,
-0.0047016279,
0.0054552299,
0.0043847621,
0.0183128268,
0.0070592128,
0.0232760198,
-0.0071404357,
-0.0170347411,
-0.0136584165,
-0.0222333837,
0.0118442057,
0.0155234681,
0.0874156654,
-0.0341882035,
0.0008579568,
0.0233440213,
-0.000972065,
0.0201017931,
-0.088894546,
0.0788689256,
-0.0253921766,
0.0372598656,
0.0386107042,
-0.0378613807,
-0.0088526802,
0.0068619214,
-0.0609480292,
-0.0279371385,
0.014240399,
0.0335346162,
-0.042708002,
-0.0113343475,
0.0680474415,
-0.0002759644,
-0.0097320918,
-0.0040975376,
0.0262675826,
-0.0589750335,
-0.0308651347,
0.0104333758,
-0.0624033771,
0.0353152901,
-0.0038659587,
-0.0140424259,
0.011567533,
0.0278772935,
-0.060367018,
-0.0096585006,
-0.055302348,
-0.0013378741,
0.0614662394,
0.0586156435,
0.0169867203,
0.0095370105,
0.0111245094,
0.0194221046,
0.0109369829,
-0.0337791927,
-0.0344176106,
-0.0505136065,
0.0801803395,
0.0489501692,
0.089868851,
0.024114076,
0.0146302311,
-0.026618937,
-0.0498775877,
-0.0171391889,
0.0078155668,
0.0698540956,
0.0295752678,
0.0052833846,
-0.0430633351,
-0.0168505497,
-0.0532569177,
0.0359098613,
-0.0741587803,
-0.0193202365,
0.0503289774,
-0.0100666704,
-0.036532972,
0.0323199295,
0.0054148519,
-0.0190533809,
-0.0049238857,
0.0306328852,
0.0189308897,
0.0342387334,
-0.021737596,
0.0175517965,
-0.0626220182,
-0.0396949798,
-0.0236511491,
-0.0052664895,
0.0258924346,
0.0141676133,
0.0217584185,
0.0174596533,
-0.063332513,
-0.0147835054,
-0.0313976482,
-0.020362772,
0.0923094153,
0.0482260846,
0.0223140959,
0.0147316204,
-0.0060751811,
0.0388668217,
-0.0119800977,
-0.0361770503,
-0.0382195599,
0.0172422156,
-0.0207987782,
0.0246655699,
-0.011829162,
0.0086742137,
-0.0352832079,
0.0054928763,
-0.0034796796,
-0.0600119159,
-0.0097868266,
-0.0011405153,
3.158e-7,
0.040496476,
0.0644445419,
-0.013110932,
0.01318336,
0.0135021461,
0.022443058,
-0.0568580292,
-0.0400074497,
0.0109534478,
-0.0134623041,
0.0229388792,
0.069272019,
0.0511744544,
0.0044921422,
-0.0559392311,
0.0576223582,
-0.0471298061,
0.0136141023,
-0.0573784783,
0.0055450639,
0.0316935033,
0.0879378468,
0.0057569845,
-0.0077937851,
-0.0107211042,
-0.0860791057,
0.0712696463,
0.0097982669,
0.0129885655,
0.0149843758,
-0.018389171,
-0.0026794928,
0.012809027,
0.030791102,
-0.0310557578,
0.0518255085,
0.0044849617,
0.0853571668,
-0.0048487671,
0.0263995733,
-0.022802962,
-0.0092595713,
0.0067578978,
-0.0667314306,
0.0651570335,
-0.0860447958,
-0.0434981659,
0.004695083,
0.004350503,
-0.0553329214,
0.0163205303,
-0.0210727546,
0.0300056525,
-0.0093823392,
0.0116475942,
0.0098594008,
-0.0044512502,
-0.0908026397,
-0.0384711176,
0.0282801986,
-0.0482132994,
-0.0239563659,
-0.0450797714,
-0.0223155655,
0.0353669822,
0.0037061193,
-0.001898649,
2.762456494e-34,
0.0493493751,
-0.0231580064,
0.0232257117,
0.0593358912,
0.0672436506,
0.0035311021,
-0.0387934186,
0.0097175604,
0.0245343354,
-0.075953193,
-0.0115936175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07487v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07487v2 | Cognate Transformer for Automated Phonological Reconstruction and Cognate Reflex Prediction | 2023-10-11T13:34:22 | 2023-10-18T06:48:37 | V. S. D. S. Mahesh Akavarapu, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Phonological reconstruction is one of the central problems in historical
linguistics where a proto-word of an ancestral language is determined from the
observed cognate words of daughter languages. Computational approaches to
historical linguistics attempt to automate the task by learning models on
available linguistic data. Several ideas and techniques drawn from
computational biology have been successfully applied in the area of
computational historical linguistics. Following these lines, we adapt MSA
Transformer, a protein language model, to the problem of automated phonological
reconstruction. MSA Transformer trains on multiple sequence alignments as input
and is, thus, apt for application on aligned cognate words. We, hence, name our
model as Cognate Transformer. We also apply the model on another associated
task, namely, cognate reflex prediction, where a reflex word in a daughter
language is predicted based on cognate words from other daughter languages. We
show that our model outperforms the existing models on both tasks, especially
when it is pre-trained on masked word prediction task. | [
0.0095470604,
0.0699025095,
-0.0247307941,
-0.0030519669,
-0.0793440938,
0.0019138636,
-0.0124724377,
0.0042903884,
-0.016636746,
-0.0290041547,
-0.0333991982,
-0.0429126769,
0.0600254498,
-0.0124511793,
0.0098592257,
0.0287762657,
0.045604527,
-0.0096638715,
-0.0054956018,
-0.0048165107,
-0.0286432374,
0.00150971,
0.0065006921,
0.0033345683,
-0.0193685424,
-0.0084641594,
0.0048565143,
-0.0046008234,
-0.0194706619,
0.0114447782,
-0.0078286193,
-0.0010529121,
0.0049590818,
0.073809579,
0.0000015655,
-0.0442048199,
-0.0101106744,
0.0078726579,
-0.033764448,
0.011827359,
-0.0221449304,
-0.0301063638,
-0.016989341,
0.0143889561,
-0.0106643755,
0.0170534421,
0.0925511345,
-0.0455341339,
-0.0046128798,
0.0680559799,
-0.0085131973,
-0.0967180133,
0.0389881358,
-0.0303536002,
0.0006744392,
0.0088148238,
0.0311109871,
0.0163905025,
-0.0173980724,
-0.0308764298,
-0.0396737494,
0.0502893701,
-0.0609550774,
0.0183003284,
-0.0453718267,
-0.0358802974,
0.0273044128,
-0.054592073,
-0.0112612126,
-0.0060365628,
-0.0284751598,
-0.063152276,
-0.012203428,
0.0243353453,
-0.017461367,
0.0313518532,
0.0186568666,
-0.0091305571,
-0.0282386877,
0.0581991635,
0.0892067105,
-0.057217706,
0.0292668492,
-0.0239732806,
-0.0147052659,
0.0661588237,
0.0605434328,
-0.0492188856,
-0.0243780687,
0.0073068463,
0.0392350964,
0.0239721779,
0.0255914591,
0.0301555432,
-0.0372779258,
0.015837362,
0.0032893496,
-0.0461586192,
0.011520694,
0.0049068471,
0.0193257183,
0.0259463117,
-0.0010405345,
0.0344807245,
-0.0713749602,
0.0178709328,
0.0044560349,
-0.0314242728,
-0.0198045708,
-0.0299329348,
-0.0433614664,
0.0113799684,
-0.0149640543,
-0.0074139563,
-0.0166348815,
0.0416710228,
-0.0254719853,
-0.0188974943,
0.0351557098,
-0.0270680804,
0.0255972091,
-0.0281835161,
-0.070760116,
0.0008750158,
-0.0051229182,
0.0284993276,
0.0444881916,
-0.0098074209,
-0.0730329528,
-0.0681164265,
-0.0184228495,
-0.0096401488,
0.018255325,
-0.0053602122,
0.0486862063,
0.0824110135,
-0.0226388779,
-0.0574146584,
-0.0008176431,
0.0012282953,
-0.0501439087,
-0.0087774964,
-0.0371550471,
-0.0422553755,
0.0350795276,
-0.0011845123,
-0.0115699656,
-0.0212657526,
0.004636711,
-0.0329938903,
-0.0880015045,
0.0412517563,
0.0158416834,
0.0299571324,
0.0031492088,
-0.0296535566,
-0.0006710311,
-0.0186310969,
0.0584478341,
-0.0455922522,
0.0247094743,
-0.0064167469,
-0.0194121916,
0.0467571616,
-0.0012205571,
-0.0376874916,
0.0031880254,
-0.0306758136,
0.0130756302,
0.036649663,
0.0446272641,
0.0325015225,
0.0291524436,
-0.0438525006,
0.0191289224,
0.0565375425,
0.0753853172,
0.0506224744,
0.0636908785,
-0.0064367824,
-0.0096935835,
0.0152354809,
0.0090751406,
-0.0429825857,
-0.0314829163,
0.0274175741,
-0.0357517153,
0.0515559278,
0.024096569,
0.0277639311,
-0.008547239,
-0.0241479278,
-0.0395397283,
0.0037042943,
0.0614569075,
0.0223101173,
-0.0831311122,
-0.01403563,
0.0498046204,
-0.0481007025,
0.030971352,
-0.0056569744,
0.0497892797,
0.0028881475,
0.0352447405,
-0.0657965615,
-0.0066670449,
0.0428969674,
-0.0683157668,
0.029081922,
0.0028469989,
-0.0159046445,
0.0181080755,
-0.0222951993,
0.0043426165,
0.042367328,
0.0253770594,
0.0769525766,
-0.0420606881,
0.0293035749,
0.0173125584,
0.0296378806,
0.0149878599,
0.0480655767,
-0.0905394182,
-0.0376273803,
-0.0176990461,
0.0238974132,
0.0537423901,
0.0383546874,
0.0098657319,
0.0645904616,
0.0455893911,
-0.0356805399,
0.0304518733,
0.0390340835,
-0.0208314359,
-0.0665668026,
0.0604531877,
-0.0298657659,
-0.0034011258,
-0.0239285603,
0.0237485655,
-0.0447983667,
0.0673684403,
-0.0599443316,
0.0875172839,
-0.0098323151,
0.0340550579,
-0.0254225582,
0.005824721,
-0.0403583571,
0.0514361523,
0.0584243052,
0.0444130711,
0.0330587067,
-0.0789594203,
0.0056293928,
-0.0215799287,
0.0110714938,
-0.0425833464,
-0.0242467001,
-0.043628633,
0.0328636654,
-0.0285770111,
0.0028484585,
-0.0396058448,
-0.0356528498,
0.0096649984,
-0.006733112,
0.0731774718,
0.0060519124,
0.0207105689,
-0.0068859267,
-0.0238910317,
-0.0365700498,
0.055858463,
-0.0000289071,
0.021685075,
0.0113627687,
-0.0396074429,
-0.0001241761,
-0.0696068928,
-0.0083504757,
-0.0383814834,
0.0763091743,
0.0388911664,
-0.0433293134,
-0.0429839604,
-0.0362066776,
-0.0505816229,
0.032103043,
-0.0012932748,
-0.0246148892,
0.0106862541,
-0.012565935,
0.0582604855,
-0.0158428457,
-0.0281934328,
-0.0441376753,
0.0321371481,
-0.0188962836,
-0.0013495993,
-0.0301125851,
-0.0730349943,
-0.0360179506,
-0.0141707892,
-0.0207448453,
-0.0274275728,
0.1032153368,
0.0225459207,
-0.0207847636,
-0.0434448607,
-0.0285092145,
0.0319882445,
0.0026072019,
0.0198140629,
-0.0383541733,
-0.0219631437,
0.0278011002,
-0.0345374756,
-0.0398574881,
0.0533594117,
-0.0412723832,
-0.0168385692,
-0.0148405591,
-0.0187979508,
-0.042399358,
0.0748849139,
0.0137455985,
0.0186916497,
0.0217565447,
-0.0279215928,
-0.0295835715,
0.0203448236,
0.0518004633,
-0.0634053722,
0.0012191701,
-0.0306403916,
-0.0115968483,
0.0130553469,
-0.0124173798,
-0.0152654294,
0.033392638,
-0.0474599563,
0.0140424874,
-0.0203612056,
-0.0223854054,
-0.02102031,
0.0060774484,
0.004975792,
0.0172029976,
0.0332008861,
-0.0015275702,
-0.0194347799,
0.0597764552,
0.0096789831,
0.0127134286,
-0.008081032,
0.0418421775,
0.0291594882,
-0.0016869281,
0.0332917869,
0.0320739448,
-0.011374562,
0.0058977953,
0.0465893298,
-0.0246174205,
-0.0017580674,
-0.0200051107,
-0.0282156002,
0.0117719788,
0.0083364593,
0.0664210692,
0.0374772809,
-0.0113126617,
0.0178168006,
-0.0418465771,
0.0166732166,
0.0119114239,
0.0126584731,
-0.0597684458,
-0.0221359786,
0.0223395694,
-0.0039560124,
0.0213797633,
-0.0464739613,
0.0137708075,
-0.1106681973,
0.0023529648,
0.0230132248,
0.0146248136,
-0.0491587669,
-0.0802582279,
0.0104387524,
-0.0482809134,
-0.045430351,
0.0716427714,
0.0052757799,
0.0093288207,
0.010724986,
0.0187411234,
-0.005937302,
0.0103390235,
-0.0658526048,
0.0258606225,
0.0438048616,
0.0605773628,
-0.0103234062,
-0.0187682342,
-0.0131459804,
-0.0525386184,
0.0104603544,
-0.0078447806,
0.0242755823,
0.049396906,
-0.010195015,
0.0034071854,
0.0324952863,
-0.0424631126,
-0.0365093425,
0.0077455314,
0.0715267882,
0.0216094535,
-0.0419553332,
0.0242464133,
0.0094536282,
-0.0090534147,
0.0561228506,
0.020179294,
-0.0098194778,
-0.0297010746,
0.0149954762,
0.0826553777,
0.01381303,
-0.0497952923,
-0.0051602898,
-0.0252135675,
-0.0656575337,
-0.1123367175,
0.014992387,
0.0114641273,
0.0409117714,
0.0759866834,
0.0037549662,
0.0368751138,
-0.0263973195,
-0.0601403899,
0.0220547281,
-0.0145191187,
0.0105251512,
-0.0743120611,
-0.0054489579,
0.0878495127,
-0.0438575745,
0.00004399,
0.02496792,
-0.0071931914,
-0.0979602933,
0.0088805901,
0.0392116271,
0.0278510284,
0.0216554701,
-0.016228348,
0.0294425841,
0.0605271123,
0.0034379549,
-0.0156001281,
0.0262343474,
0.0221442375,
-0.0368646048,
-0.0242496971,
0.0297088604,
-0.0324025415,
-0.0111425091,
-0.0057042353,
0.0527405962,
0.0099385669,
-0.0693371743,
0.0594629124,
-0.0217110887,
0.0989320353,
-0.072076425,
0.001916582,
-0.0132988719,
-0.0260971263,
-0.0007700032,
0.0272928812,
0.0019286367,
0.0022015427,
0.025337372,
0.0057398691,
0.0104933959,
-0.0631252378,
-0.0517638624,
0.012127215,
0.0124562243,
0.0284144692,
0.0338272639,
0.0178891979,
-0.016929457,
0.0116767781,
0.0297550876,
0.0541375317,
-0.0285679288,
0.0487890355,
-0.0353925079,
-0.0281493329,
-0.0247004684,
0.0403657183,
-0.0322520435,
-0.0210357327,
-0.0214993749,
0.0431724004,
0.0067266952,
-0.0137867564,
0.0885891691,
-0.0382879339,
0.0715616122,
0.0040842388,
-0.0022398699,
0.0041027493,
0.0515591465,
-0.0547385439,
0.0033089742,
0.01367993,
0.0004316853,
-0.0270442851,
0.0466159806,
0.0507888421,
-0.0291811358,
0.0874548852,
0.0002623317,
-0.0378036425,
0.0272079464,
-0.0446778014,
-0.0191729814,
-0.0701923147,
-0.0549998917,
-0.0450954996,
-0.0677413717,
-0.0496648923,
0.044829458,
0.0188281927,
0.0109672677,
0.0124180531,
-0.002316518,
0.0185567774,
0.0026823133,
0.0137144551,
-0.0572503023,
0.0744709373,
0.0136621315,
-0.0462284461,
-0.0023196605,
-5.305569875e-33,
-0.0044106366,
0.0107932063,
-0.0004396107,
0.0324242972,
0.0020191008,
0.0021181665,
-0.0347381569,
0.0336215384,
-0.042265702,
-0.0229571294,
0.0018781674,
-0.0456072204,
-0.0099528758,
-0.0291804969,
0.0153898019,
0.0247636195,
-0.007573022,
-0.0337150171,
0.0339833535,
-0.0593082495,
0.0162119735,
0.027899446,
0.0663392842,
-0.0377527773,
-0.0168327093,
0.0177385435,
-0.0060129757,
0.0148289539,
-0.0355574377,
-0.0006531816,
-0.0189055093,
0.0065390966,
-0.0031736954,
0.0136485407,
0.0226919912,
0.0323971957,
-0.0877449736,
-0.0098759476,
0.0333589055,
0.0032769085,
0.0066202926,
0.001536174,
0.0163994115,
0.0078660436,
-0.0267020706,
0.0182900615,
0.0203979649,
-0.0304690618,
-0.0285358559,
-0.0312516019,
-0.0828172639,
0.004259896,
-0.009878709,
-0.0230633654,
0.0787644237,
0.0658155158,
0.0353382342,
-0.0131622562,
0.0043810448,
0.0247497633,
0.0022535666,
0.0549340248,
0.0408894867,
0.0128686251,
-0.0352984779,
0.0254256297,
0.0522140786,
-0.0587114543,
0.0296470635,
0.0420079045,
0.0084525198,
-0.0036920463,
0.010371902,
0.0431478135,
0.0384372473,
-0.0284794234,
-0.0204645079,
0.0015108241,
0.0271360707,
-0.0014118975,
-0.0359404087,
0.0123460144,
0.0158699118,
0.030042287,
-0.0308964569,
-0.0489924178,
-0.0273682792,
-0.0176317748,
-0.0365853012,
-0.0190766994,
-0.019517662,
0.0507461093,
0.0127304681,
-0.0053672553,
-0.0104716709,
-0.0137375416,
0.0004531924,
0.0064706099,
-0.0505357794,
0.0547859222,
-0.0042650267,
-0.0542652234,
0.032345321,
0.0059841662,
0.0215315521,
-0.0120652495,
0.0008487319,
0.0430165641,
-0.0456769913,
0.0174178649,
-0.0343745984,
-0.0185100976,
0.0229764413,
-0.0108346567,
0.0215379894,
0.0338124558,
0.0170849655,
-0.0370175876,
0.0638822541,
-0.0034563947,
-0.0016512542,
0.0402926505,
0.005663218,
-0.001639694,
-0.0240141414,
-0.0084518045,
0.0195042081,
0.061664816,
0.0263001863,
-0.0022112841,
-0.0173346587,
0.0078014894,
2.574e-7,
0.0398523174,
0.0488950983,
0.0750029609,
-0.0157510154,
0.0190387238,
0.0078130933,
-0.0177989081,
0.01261607,
0.0244107097,
-0.0132593941,
0.0235067699,
-0.0564056374,
0.0405438356,
0.0289744716,
-0.0379395895,
-0.0086507425,
-0.0712389648,
-0.004221932,
-0.0288054124,
-0.0049998434,
-0.0191589519,
0.1162906587,
0.0117301214,
-0.0556362569,
-0.0386016518,
-0.0066042314,
0.0377197824,
-0.0275459215,
-0.0344567783,
0.0152954645,
-0.0143171875,
-0.0214568879,
0.0043838825,
-0.0191352759,
-0.0542240962,
0.0268284753,
0.0163081437,
0.0071400199,
-0.0106811067,
0.0223360602,
0.0662871152,
0.0201393403,
-0.0321034975,
0.0104568759,
0.0075266599,
0.005569201,
-0.0045548161,
-0.0368178003,
-0.0456243455,
0.081045419,
-0.0104441755,
-0.0399367437,
0.0284988377,
0.0427934863,
0.0274849646,
0.028208144,
-0.054795526,
-0.0016751465,
-0.0420959815,
-0.0033614517,
-0.0456124395,
0.0239935312,
0.0263440516,
0.0033385702,
-0.000924203,
-0.0527481399,
0.0071787885,
1.96906347e-34,
-0.0133874593,
-0.0402160697,
0.0174292102,
0.0234013777,
-0.0044730301,
-0.0493144393,
0.0089798514,
0.0773017704,
-0.0068854755,
-0.0066927653,
-0.0318752676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07423v1 | Adapting the adapters for code-switching in multilingual ASR | 2023-10-11T12:15:24 | 2023-10-11T12:15:24 | Atharva Kulkarni, Ajinkya Kulkarni, Miguel Couceiro, Hanan Aldarmaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, large pre-trained multilingual speech models have shown potential
in scaling Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) to many low-resource languages.
Some of these models employ language adapters in their formulation, which helps
to improve monolingual performance and avoids some of the drawbacks of
multi-lingual modeling on resource-rich languages. However, this formulation
restricts the usability of these models on code-switched speech, where two
languages are mixed together in the same utterance. In this work, we propose
ways to effectively fine-tune such models on code-switched speech, by
assimilating information from both language adapters at each language
adaptation point in the network. We also model code-switching as a sequence of
latent binary sequences that can be used to guide the flow of information from
each language adapter at the frame level. The proposed approaches are evaluated
on three code-switched datasets encompassing Arabic, Mandarin, and Hindi
languages paired with English, showing consistent improvements in
code-switching performance with at least 10\% absolute reduction in CER across
all test sets. | [
-0.02614755,
0.0731452703,
0.0022817124,
0.0359638445,
-0.0231627729,
0.0249541868,
0.0549943782,
-0.0187603869,
-0.0192408226,
-0.0129352277,
-0.0603442825,
-0.0280243512,
0.0211234149,
0.0447312146,
0.0387664139,
-0.0053334865,
0.0329989679,
-0.0797342435,
-0.0113022402,
-0.0066913017,
0.0051157358,
0.0158971511,
-0.0077644424,
0.0278647728,
0.0047216434,
0.0133805405,
-0.0038213409,
0.0341802612,
0.0212613121,
-0.0128774093,
-0.0096795671,
0.0308363233,
0.0160513967,
0.0291923229,
0.0000019757,
-0.0080988444,
-0.0225584842,
-0.0136439428,
-0.0611013249,
0.0261529908,
0.0281292573,
-0.0351226665,
-0.0052234349,
0.0390901454,
-0.0035636676,
-0.0446187481,
0.0872830749,
-0.0190801583,
0.0056646848,
0.0635341629,
-0.0198359471,
-0.0454382598,
-0.0021464908,
-0.024056226,
-0.0460648388,
-0.0433415659,
0.0043989541,
-0.0252053849,
-0.0079151001,
-0.0298088565,
-0.0739129037,
0.049520012,
0.0249980725,
0.0051393174,
-0.0380243473,
-0.0314117596,
-0.0276256576,
-0.0225554369,
-0.0238172803,
0.0375551097,
-0.0833037943,
-0.0521374866,
0.020543417,
-0.0452394187,
-0.0500834808,
-0.0495925434,
0.0172435567,
-0.0053214007,
-0.0074626026,
-0.0036921361,
0.0286758356,
0.0130038559,
0.047850538,
-0.0184994992,
-0.0938891694,
0.0025974512,
0.0110460175,
-0.0163070168,
0.0192800742,
-0.0291797277,
0.0542520992,
-0.0156296194,
0.0572242886,
-0.0014833293,
-0.009400161,
0.0088812513,
-0.0329628102,
-0.0330437385,
-0.0387769789,
-0.0232897587,
0.0502374619,
0.0752328858,
-0.0693935379,
0.0241302568,
-0.0251563676,
0.0472156443,
-0.0032414005,
0.0014891293,
-0.0089808954,
0.0049959351,
0.006723491,
0.019827595,
-0.0568705052,
-0.0232144911,
-0.0256735794,
-0.0276165567,
-0.0153705636,
0.0298878569,
0.0020373703,
-0.0165385641,
0.0284133218,
-0.0477266572,
-0.0060744239,
-0.0033972664,
0.0556248315,
0.0414668918,
0.0030793075,
0.0082076313,
-0.0030077633,
-0.0757037923,
-0.0062914719,
0.0342206322,
0.021572683,
-0.0050569233,
0.0142112868,
0.0597409457,
0.0012985814,
-0.0178179331,
-0.0551484264,
0.051218953,
-0.0243987013,
-0.0305752289,
0.0099910274,
-0.0359666534,
0.0464033596,
0.0315482281,
0.0332364738,
-0.0610914603,
-0.0235859472,
-0.0518292598,
0.011552928,
0.0836525187,
-0.0114124855,
0.0111957109,
0.0150596676,
-0.0195512157,
0.0384030007,
0.101661846,
0.0731062889,
-0.0465294681,
0.0425205491,
-0.0646014884,
-0.0194817912,
0.079401575,
-0.001352204,
-0.001102669,
0.0136969872,
-0.0266795158,
0.0674856156,
-0.0006277046,
0.0239844974,
0.0129282344,
-0.0349230021,
-0.0135652926,
-0.0093700821,
0.0033109097,
0.0506227314,
0.0330644883,
0.0573384911,
0.0046729781,
-0.0148772858,
0.0137754455,
0.012646718,
0.0324633531,
0.0196763556,
-0.0120495269,
0.0485947914,
0.0795699358,
-0.0554305092,
0.0004323973,
0.0113054141,
-0.0362286717,
0.0311578549,
0.0318445712,
0.0280922856,
0.0001875552,
-0.0474049449,
0.0373421982,
0.0356053524,
-0.0370381363,
0.0330940969,
-0.0546091013,
-0.0481537245,
0.0318534821,
-0.0233336929,
-0.0101573253,
-0.0091905361,
-0.0039452799,
-0.0012843863,
0.0166527461,
0.0030568652,
0.0113379788,
0.0822325721,
-0.0866015106,
0.0050071809,
0.0452940427,
-0.0227512773,
0.0946818069,
-0.0305215623,
0.0366212018,
-0.0113478703,
0.024747381,
-0.0010134589,
-0.0177626386,
-0.0491801426,
0.0276002679,
0.0476795025,
0.0173019972,
0.0598448738,
0.0064849942,
-0.0257013254,
-0.0039131553,
0.0065701362,
-0.0274867136,
0.0200152304,
0.0713369474,
-0.0650197268,
-0.0349532925,
0.0161745101,
0.0149675421,
0.0380972736,
0.0262246169,
-0.0032207067,
-0.083170034,
0.0628123954,
0.0157314651,
0.0622417778,
-0.0207257774,
0.0658753663,
0.0191372745,
0.0222274158,
0.0213349499,
-0.032174889,
0.0263954606,
0.014501377,
0.0151103307,
0.0062366636,
0.0199113116,
-0.040616408,
0.001900705,
0.0492945388,
-0.0099139372,
-0.0006960639,
0.0022874342,
-0.0010102679,
0.0192320663,
-0.0121660735,
-0.0688283518,
-0.0305634346,
-0.0541145653,
0.0327006616,
-0.0085568391,
0.0307414327,
-0.0007411292,
-0.0206051692,
-0.0158387385,
0.018667873,
-0.0217554122,
0.0190355405,
-0.061062336,
-0.0033934917,
-0.0162694622,
-0.0372329876,
-0.0092273764,
0.0280333478,
0.0383116119,
-0.0354105011,
-0.0607678331,
-0.0763777792,
-0.0136490101,
0.0388028324,
0.0380644687,
-0.0390861854,
-0.0351581126,
-0.0084250346,
0.010036747,
0.0393986329,
0.0146111799,
-0.0314075425,
-0.0037609669,
0.0433119871,
-0.0280669536,
-0.0516662486,
-0.0036631403,
0.0476370491,
-0.028150877,
-0.0564470068,
-0.0073242495,
-0.0014165391,
0.0514146946,
-0.011265819,
0.0225452352,
-0.0775130391,
-0.0797116384,
-0.0155039979,
-0.0357649177,
0.0274777655,
-0.0179698057,
-0.0289237052,
0.0519034378,
-0.0059432145,
-0.0180486329,
0.0146371564,
-0.0524279401,
-0.0455436781,
-0.0470720977,
-0.0197798591,
-0.0275228675,
-0.0172097217,
0.0137662403,
0.0214730203,
-0.0027699869,
-0.0328533463,
-0.0532565564,
0.003203372,
0.0003915593,
-0.023216363,
0.0306831729,
-0.049360767,
0.0181607381,
-0.010616892,
-0.06014264,
0.0017898291,
0.0289650112,
-0.0285792612,
0.023573447,
0.0578544177,
-0.0523533225,
-0.0190622415,
0.0486339666,
-0.0014600408,
0.0820919201,
0.0342982262,
0.0375921056,
0.0026797941,
0.0264187977,
0.020375181,
0.0049095498,
-0.007254547,
-0.0115869408,
0.0223190021,
-0.0214471761,
0.0270777177,
0.0158624966,
-0.0538285412,
0.0144035798,
0.0675995797,
0.0179295093,
-0.019290911,
-0.0038495993,
0.0393675491,
-0.0097807394,
0.0098781493,
0.0949599743,
0.0052528149,
-0.071900174,
-0.0128924055,
-0.0254906658,
0.0236313734,
0.0075778407,
0.0009566461,
-0.0862544328,
-0.0174363349,
0.0167323109,
0.0023620436,
0.0185970683,
0.0273441784,
-0.0201061182,
-0.0801028088,
-0.0008485848,
0.0235524699,
-0.0518202521,
-0.049098108,
-0.0231381673,
-0.0422940664,
-0.0438324697,
0.023530636,
-0.0051158532,
-0.0085211163,
-0.0512197353,
0.0575880148,
-0.0278745182,
-0.030521214,
-0.0057207919,
-0.0067073628,
0.0856191814,
0.0569937676,
-0.0176372472,
-0.0197563935,
-0.0025217189,
-0.0001887051,
-0.0290666036,
-0.0025763861,
-0.0232164077,
-0.0156926271,
-0.0075253989,
-0.0204720236,
0.0636925325,
-0.0033342182,
-0.0183218531,
-0.0160563737,
0.0179130211,
0.033894822,
-0.004503184,
-0.0137921823,
0.0323247798,
0.0128041385,
0.0212096628,
0.0263633542,
0.0432019569,
-0.0701399893,
0.0023737373,
-0.0019275257,
0.0240167622,
-0.0350266956,
0.0017725609,
-0.0195319653,
-0.0036999634,
-0.0512848236,
-0.0222862493,
0.0225358754,
0.0344435126,
0.0417606793,
0.0155157261,
0.0255979523,
0.0069931797,
0.0241525993,
-0.0188373104,
-0.0475037098,
-0.0131350076,
0.0113087269,
-0.086982742,
-0.036494527,
0.0429851264,
-0.0434974916,
-0.0001968522,
0.0064569185,
-0.0726923198,
-0.067074433,
0.0327609256,
-0.0034006359,
0.0125809275,
0.0497797951,
-0.0170856901,
-0.0607228652,
-0.0001393691,
-0.0204100478,
-0.0152036259,
0.0350060537,
0.0920132697,
-0.0000503177,
-0.0421325006,
0.0222104285,
-0.0311789345,
0.0096322885,
-0.0047644046,
0.0095002437,
-0.0876776427,
-0.0525021031,
-0.0238002092,
-0.0064610443,
0.0196706932,
-0.0500038415,
-0.0416627303,
-0.0286985263,
0.0652260259,
0.0284562483,
0.0446094126,
-0.0445640981,
-0.0325885005,
0.0200936422,
0.0127444956,
-0.0318113975,
0.0179766584,
-0.0036300067,
-0.0576147065,
0.0103087015,
0.0898129269,
0.0321496166,
0.0600997433,
0.0349779837,
0.0195869803,
-0.0019615777,
0.0358294137,
0.0501693487,
0.0059875431,
-0.0455466621,
0.028214924,
0.0056331535,
0.0027326997,
0.0471405797,
0.0503324755,
-0.0201151762,
-0.035575211,
0.0137990052,
0.0117361322,
0.0391832367,
-0.002637499,
0.080455415,
0.0146942232,
0.0170380063,
-0.0451895148,
0.0339952074,
-0.0008845693,
-0.0118254852,
0.0550402291,
0.0047182613,
-0.0134752989,
0.0431014448,
0.0487842374,
0.0059867469,
0.0262933075,
-0.0059019141,
0.0539949648,
-0.0000031336,
-0.0244387183,
0.015462175,
-0.0228799079,
-0.036473345,
0.0056177471,
0.0026022906,
-0.0953185335,
0.0358812138,
-0.0039799302,
0.0469485745,
-0.02130685,
-0.0119701587,
0.0390073918,
-0.0055441926,
0.0378218628,
-0.0262426119,
-0.0270415302,
0.0472982824,
-0.0304035116,
0.034860637,
-6.440626118e-33,
-0.0128168575,
0.0327865109,
-0.0069303098,
-0.0095205493,
0.011397942,
-0.0315029733,
-0.0373927169,
0.0078446921,
-0.0349534638,
-0.0514012575,
-0.0168314464,
0.0096331332,
0.0397630818,
-0.0036629927,
0.0110840965,
-0.0045090443,
0.0806705877,
-0.0011630326,
0.0137527967,
0.026402412,
0.0068210452,
0.0265199244,
0.0377172269,
-0.0365126766,
-0.0497190617,
0.0062255207,
-0.007022664,
-0.0485988371,
-0.0025427036,
0.0514641963,
0.015481892,
0.0356707051,
0.0022654808,
-0.0059589217,
-0.0091400677,
-0.0164056495,
-0.0924703851,
0.0152759627,
0.0119044213,
0.0825378373,
0.0080518303,
-0.0433959179,
-0.0019925386,
-0.0060244538,
-0.0135057569,
-0.0059580873,
0.0012933216,
-0.0097020734,
-0.0262108445,
-0.024351364,
-0.0540904999,
0.0525158308,
-0.0123007325,
0.015156161,
0.065067552,
0.0480236821,
-0.0316255614,
-0.0186800305,
-0.0777921975,
0.0294597652,
0.0277316123,
0.0468072332,
0.0334218517,
0.0461988114,
-0.0255694389,
-0.0134629002,
0.0697484985,
-0.0677520409,
0.0721975192,
-0.0047734277,
0.0652272105,
-0.0175456889,
0.009322756,
0.0360756516,
0.0286022518,
-0.0601785593,
-0.0550018027,
-0.0672235489,
0.0201171394,
0.0126709472,
0.0339095257,
0.035425391,
-0.0143245524,
-0.0143041965,
-0.0403179228,
-0.0429655872,
-0.0316491798,
-0.0449034534,
0.0404096842,
0.0105867973,
-0.0047228634,
0.0155807557,
0.0863242224,
-0.0125038028,
0.0061555947,
0.0210339911,
0.0211604629,
0.0091702258,
0.006522567,
0.0913347229,
-0.0885128751,
-0.0374777615,
0.0279126577,
-0.0033948144,
0.0245614462,
-0.022822706,
0.0216791444,
0.0818841234,
-0.0714861974,
-0.018346902,
0.0018752441,
0.0043696947,
0.0173811186,
0.0464829206,
0.0212523788,
0.0007091982,
0.0012595683,
0.0167500433,
-0.0401101597,
-0.0278232507,
-0.0246011894,
-0.0416431651,
0.01325393,
0.0603671782,
-0.0607631393,
-0.0151243331,
-0.0227126349,
-0.0023955407,
0.0330459699,
-0.0397421122,
-0.0294009093,
0.0286256578,
2.782e-7,
0.0088255247,
-0.0042007151,
-0.0033809759,
-0.0265687648,
-0.003082542,
-0.0286977198,
-0.0413816758,
-0.0233886056,
0.0297655873,
0.028273914,
-0.0046439455,
0.0189590417,
0.066786103,
0.013663251,
-0.0612549521,
-0.0229121111,
0.0017188856,
0.0242821854,
-0.0033243136,
-0.0145189762,
-0.0069558835,
0.1066406742,
-0.0503625385,
0.0093335798,
0.0299809948,
-0.002280372,
0.0162853654,
-0.0321275443,
0.0152791794,
-0.0307758823,
-0.0502712987,
-0.0081031416,
-0.0446938276,
0.0006163011,
-0.0256104302,
0.0183706488,
0.0242144112,
0.0634872243,
-0.021626465,
-0.0555377007,
0.0003618034,
0.0344933905,
-0.0636610165,
-0.0243493002,
0.0733300671,
0.0186470747,
-0.006280669,
-0.020019155,
-0.0260538198,
0.0198357459,
0.0045084204,
-0.0274453983,
-0.0159776006,
0.0308775809,
0.0292617735,
-0.0037619642,
-0.0125672305,
-0.0571330152,
0.0336715207,
0.0102258315,
-0.0130085014,
-0.0133224083,
-0.0446181968,
-0.0338722765,
0.0361424014,
0.0071363836,
0.022790635,
2.010186946e-34,
0.057422705,
-0.0190800931,
0.0260376912,
0.0089219147,
0.007661358,
-0.0521221869,
-0.0119385766,
0.0542322136,
-0.0125540486,
-0.0619687662,
-0.0548541322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07403v1 | DASpeech: Directed Acyclic Transformer for Fast and High-quality Speech-to-Speech Translation | 2023-10-11T11:39:36 | 2023-10-11T11:39:36 | Qingkai Fang, Yan Zhou, Yang Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7 | Direct speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) translates speech from one
language into another using a single model. However, due to the presence of
linguistic and acoustic diversity, the target speech follows a complex
multimodal distribution, posing challenges to achieving both high-quality
translations and fast decoding speeds for S2ST models. In this paper, we
propose DASpeech, a non-autoregressive direct S2ST model which realizes both
fast and high-quality S2ST. To better capture the complex distribution of the
target speech, DASpeech adopts the two-pass architecture to decompose the
generation process into two steps, where a linguistic decoder first generates
the target text, and an acoustic decoder then generates the target speech based
on the hidden states of the linguistic decoder. Specifically, we use the
decoder of DA-Transformer as the linguistic decoder, and use FastSpeech 2 as
the acoustic decoder. DA-Transformer models translations with a directed
acyclic graph (DAG). To consider all potential paths in the DAG during
training, we calculate the expected hidden states for each target token via
dynamic programming, and feed them into the acoustic decoder to predict the
target mel-spectrogram. During inference, we select the most probable path and
take hidden states on that path as input to the acoustic decoder. Experiments
on the CVSS Fr-En benchmark demonstrate that DASpeech can achieve comparable or
even better performance than the state-of-the-art S2ST model Translatotron 2,
while preserving up to 18.53x speedup compared to the autoregressive baseline.
Compared with the previous non-autoregressive S2ST model, DASpeech does not
rely on knowledge distillation and iterative decoding, achieving significant
improvements in both translation quality and decoding speed. Furthermore,
DASpeech shows the ability to preserve the speaker's voice of the source speech
during translation. | [
-0.0154436249,
0.0393822417,
-0.0004483565,
0.0024190361,
-0.0386409983,
-0.0510008521,
0.0575045682,
-0.0199351422,
-0.0664795041,
-0.0060541062,
-0.049835179,
-0.022345867,
0.0495370552,
0.0511259511,
0.0180519074,
-0.0275539644,
0.0319050401,
-0.0724030882,
-0.0228198506,
-0.0234820191,
-0.0202586874,
-0.0126365134,
-0.0339807719,
0.0241786838,
-0.0066902023,
0.0213189628,
-0.0082671558,
0.0319452845,
-0.005211039,
-0.0305715241,
-0.052466359,
-0.0126219019,
0.0337676667,
0.0590948723,
0.0000021217,
0.0042120009,
-0.0030381307,
0.0163767524,
-0.0129373632,
-0.0054749339,
0.0408809744,
-0.0197136663,
-0.0437335782,
0.0396591201,
0.000736434,
-0.0444659106,
0.0542228818,
-0.029854618,
0.017413307,
0.0690835193,
-0.0238343365,
-0.0599854328,
0.0120925093,
-0.0323769376,
-0.0648386925,
-0.021047255,
-0.0376312435,
-0.040511325,
-0.0438608155,
0.001005964,
-0.0554767661,
0.0795373246,
-0.0230152998,
-0.0235869326,
0.0528315157,
-0.0269506071,
-0.01661258,
-0.0610307753,
-0.0018822799,
0.0816063583,
-0.0193312336,
0.0038828424,
0.0015864238,
0.0253074095,
-0.0205719378,
-0.0168453474,
0.009489242,
0.0161141567,
0.0106899487,
-0.0210393351,
-0.0168827996,
0.0357564762,
0.0171242543,
-0.0460549071,
-0.0397896841,
0.0020040723,
0.023461489,
0.0017466868,
0.0033637711,
0.0055572689,
0.0274679884,
0.0175997447,
0.0848802552,
0.007010459,
-0.0159452669,
0.0075035277,
-0.0380761437,
-0.0639402345,
-0.0485416166,
-0.0002650451,
0.0604102835,
0.0731898695,
-0.0285921097,
-0.011141004,
-0.0402547345,
0.0214908756,
-0.021748675,
0.0233700518,
-0.0832559764,
-0.0220487881,
0.019410301,
0.0468941703,
-0.0842418894,
-0.0170933288,
-0.0312081743,
-0.0480088219,
-0.0087496182,
-0.0207998175,
0.0023610508,
-0.0051360219,
0.0200064071,
-0.0147061832,
-0.0943248793,
-0.0188498199,
0.0213487893,
0.0802801177,
0.0162110608,
-0.0045395368,
0.0061489777,
-0.0059023304,
-0.0191697869,
0.0371609703,
0.045815248,
0.00439347,
-0.0133700939,
0.0858560354,
-0.0324104428,
-0.0131364539,
-0.0212385003,
-0.005582354,
-0.0044633457,
-0.0202459097,
0.0065824026,
-0.0350793861,
0.0400657058,
0.0383325778,
-0.0191911049,
-0.0067104725,
0.0126957074,
0.0034218661,
0.0242631398,
0.03712935,
0.0185457096,
0.0099741006,
0.0623117611,
-0.0141075216,
-0.0380423628,
0.0399452001,
0.0535670854,
0.0297649223,
-0.0124643072,
-0.016215492,
-0.0237863734,
0.0655578151,
0.0280512143,
0.0447676666,
-0.0391176865,
-0.0349183008,
-0.0133053511,
0.0160023477,
0.0586734675,
0.0511845835,
-0.0276269931,
-0.0199780054,
0.04286642,
0.0304288045,
0.0415765159,
0.0345923416,
0.0692808703,
0.0069956165,
-0.016227426,
-0.0473550744,
0.033442162,
0.0436470695,
-0.013948638,
-0.014141662,
0.0123072611,
0.0487150736,
-0.0012905798,
0.0089025199,
0.0363952778,
-0.0199979004,
0.0529195443,
-0.01679557,
0.0331131406,
0.0338302478,
-0.0631058961,
0.0769833848,
-0.019133104,
-0.0511293896,
0.0133985328,
-0.0307368953,
-0.0883013979,
0.0163641479,
0.0244821049,
0.0257470198,
0.0032461653,
-0.0295799226,
-0.0629032627,
0.0565054677,
0.0196381547,
0.0166551713,
0.0327234119,
-0.0634021237,
-0.0215673931,
0.0523941033,
-0.0263301339,
0.0639327243,
-0.0243102107,
0.032293763,
0.0232595839,
0.0041980743,
0.0209007692,
-0.022141343,
0.012159612,
0.0343906544,
0.0470316,
0.0192455091,
0.038072776,
0.0105457501,
0.0096774194,
0.0358978324,
-0.0027177711,
-0.0526657961,
0.0253911279,
0.0240504276,
-0.0802068189,
-0.0406413451,
0.0401497521,
-0.0606293678,
0.0380879566,
0.0214292556,
0.0276327357,
-0.1077216342,
0.0708828121,
-0.0650526136,
-0.000345588,
0.0208480973,
0.0474902168,
0.0385268293,
0.050759647,
0.0241029467,
-0.0073217554,
0.0145238806,
-0.0553560331,
0.0394893214,
0.043890316,
0.00482322,
-0.0425712951,
0.0104562482,
0.0370231494,
0.0245252457,
-0.0058862241,
0.0138103571,
-0.0292446446,
0.0130530344,
-0.0140835745,
-0.0276879538,
-0.0106645729,
0.0023091617,
-0.0135736857,
0.0066293664,
0.0316905193,
0.0339234769,
0.0052740569,
-0.0324941576,
0.0472260565,
-0.0191588402,
-0.0244238209,
-0.0482064635,
0.009451244,
-0.0530927591,
-0.0044264095,
-0.0182661898,
0.0421697237,
0.0141147142,
-0.0309037082,
-0.0112434682,
-0.0584384724,
0.0258794725,
0.0319984369,
0.0427618809,
-0.0072772559,
-0.0630121306,
-0.0168054421,
0.014361958,
0.0528873764,
0.0130890347,
0.0112672811,
-0.0417060852,
-0.0044353688,
-0.0297684241,
-0.0261240732,
-0.0108985081,
0.0106259407,
0.0470269248,
-0.0192010161,
-0.02935124,
-0.0180607177,
0.0424810462,
0.0727357939,
0.0211531948,
-0.0626126155,
-0.097790651,
0.0138732456,
-0.012608083,
0.0030186612,
-0.0462840758,
-0.0053511099,
0.0013553998,
-0.0228916556,
-0.0121513177,
0.0186584629,
-0.0717415139,
-0.0318360366,
-0.0601457879,
-0.0264312383,
0.0052489745,
-0.004183183,
0.0099078575,
0.0361983664,
-0.0345882624,
-0.0328180268,
-0.0191088021,
0.0086481571,
0.0179339256,
-0.0704619735,
0.0626932308,
-0.0143962866,
0.0106204357,
-0.0252819266,
-0.019265376,
-0.0018594107,
0.0403727964,
-0.0012564884,
0.0237093866,
0.0317984968,
-0.060829483,
-0.029994661,
0.0523220524,
0.0258538835,
0.0806668177,
0.008969117,
0.0109151276,
-0.0196752772,
0.0361625664,
0.0078554461,
-0.0063593178,
-0.0057617691,
-0.0405511595,
0.0332265459,
0.013032197,
0.0667657182,
0.0158147756,
-0.0720008463,
-0.022734385,
0.0318909697,
0.0484412313,
-0.0628998578,
-0.0117799165,
0.0285494663,
-0.0239207037,
0.0091328034,
0.0615633167,
-0.0291746259,
-0.0456727594,
-0.0130230254,
0.0012981612,
0.0178222526,
0.0009957013,
-0.022107603,
-0.0786967874,
-0.0181279723,
0.0271036681,
0.0410417505,
0.0416402519,
0.0454655513,
-0.0214320049,
-0.0780335143,
0.010674512,
0.0745663345,
-0.0402486101,
-0.0215167254,
0.0275426712,
-0.0618833005,
-0.0016265133,
0.0243865289,
0.0288126674,
0.0058724987,
-0.0287076198,
0.0154707953,
-0.0328633115,
0.0257488806,
0.0026354333,
0.0034307479,
0.0589396544,
0.0372047201,
0.0219844095,
0.0022068836,
0.0020280345,
0.0358141363,
0.0052940762,
0.0210136585,
-0.0036583873,
-0.0233279318,
0.0172482505,
0.0061223228,
0.0249681994,
0.0197176021,
-0.0198731795,
0.0258814245,
-0.0274125338,
0.0598347224,
-0.0115595069,
0.0245077889,
0.0081493519,
0.0332876183,
-0.0238335077,
0.0416876338,
-0.0077254395,
-0.024015747,
-0.0172782596,
-0.0177187771,
0.0322196558,
-0.0483528785,
-0.0404495895,
0.0154085662,
0.0068634497,
-0.0788382292,
-0.0520458035,
0.0172119085,
-0.0179981906,
0.0640854165,
0.0051539154,
-0.0062891152,
0.0203514379,
0.0029081784,
-0.0270503704,
0.0029260789,
-0.0206899364,
0.0330155529,
-0.0653267279,
-0.0546463542,
0.0101383878,
-0.0551838726,
0.0031514498,
0.0421785824,
-0.0402852483,
-0.0552782193,
0.015455259,
-0.034456078,
0.0199033469,
0.0463451073,
-0.0297993049,
0.0010870736,
0.0443593934,
-0.037050128,
-0.0379056744,
0.0022148078,
0.0427833274,
-0.0064871404,
-0.0225701667,
0.0229807906,
-0.0115214624,
0.0291896109,
-0.0321073681,
0.0580016375,
-0.0043545822,
-0.0648320019,
0.0047158278,
0.0533369891,
0.0572075248,
-0.0246111341,
0.026743453,
0.0021227619,
0.0316902325,
-0.0108954087,
0.0464636311,
-0.0550169051,
0.0166510809,
0.0496570505,
-0.0097380988,
0.0164105669,
-0.0371125899,
0.0165060498,
-0.0363387503,
0.05139146,
0.0555052981,
0.0132931182,
0.0109304562,
0.0437448435,
-0.0013377153,
-0.0042987568,
0.0082242573,
0.0482668318,
0.0244278666,
-0.0427846126,
0.0338320881,
-0.0129138948,
0.0145191187,
-0.0041588494,
-0.0015074249,
-0.0006009975,
0.0130370995,
-0.0128375459,
0.0004394283,
0.0470148399,
0.0250524152,
0.0895585641,
-0.0162311587,
0.0317205414,
0.005133302,
0.0432016179,
-0.0168622583,
-0.0171427038,
-0.0089115165,
-0.0320155323,
0.0236102547,
0.0413298979,
0.0288394969,
-0.033656422,
0.0143012889,
-0.0506031513,
0.0357560292,
-0.03471056,
-0.0345361941,
-0.0367898308,
-0.0466909818,
-0.0157504808,
-0.01573468,
0.0002578611,
-0.0616585016,
0.0073458143,
-0.0291154366,
0.0271533541,
-0.0662843883,
0.0314839184,
0.0186701585,
-0.0325999148,
-0.0194368493,
-0.0184521955,
-0.0166065823,
0.0721812993,
-0.0086432146,
-0.0040892316,
-6.181882914e-33,
-0.0489635915,
0.0432211608,
0.0233025402,
-0.0096794292,
-0.0500001721,
-0.0091836751,
-0.0340061039,
0.001527351,
-0.0311418846,
-0.0163557511,
-0.008889514,
0.0142712668,
0.0263230819,
0.0156390071,
-0.0229474492,
0.0577503666,
0.0572556593,
-0.0386814624,
-0.0184899345,
0.0386958495,
0.0732502565,
0.0362690762,
0.0131942695,
-0.0291803125,
-0.0769184232,
0.0119024869,
-0.0122892177,
-0.0393116698,
0.0143784182,
-0.0368131399,
0.0116163753,
0.0438536592,
-0.0425328538,
-0.0176771767,
-0.0056305043,
-0.0041465536,
-0.0788883492,
0.0210862476,
-0.0157957021,
0.0568410233,
-0.0127585279,
-0.026517313,
0.031361986,
0.0083663473,
-0.0411334448,
-0.0348250903,
-0.0121062342,
-0.049956385,
-0.0333066322,
-0.0442387499,
-0.0286961589,
0.0435598753,
-0.0052363793,
0.0065974332,
0.0592980199,
0.0685166195,
-0.0337745957,
-0.0724486336,
-0.0583103411,
0.0508660637,
-0.0119153205,
0.0530505441,
0.0261581689,
0.0363955386,
0.005005965,
-0.0046611186,
0.0905660614,
-0.0650597662,
0.0812542289,
0.0177750941,
0.0346803516,
0.0401719734,
0.0354590192,
-0.0375459045,
-0.0052918014,
-0.068229638,
-0.0174755678,
-0.0018949516,
0.0209576264,
-0.007383679,
0.0317455418,
0.0408657081,
-0.0332536101,
0.0091079427,
-0.0438697599,
0.0117577575,
-0.0097788759,
-0.0299167205,
-0.0107703293,
0.0406672955,
-0.0125335138,
-0.0102910055,
0.0918131247,
0.0021262069,
0.0325073525,
0.0162651315,
-0.0274005309,
0.0301093888,
-0.0347889662,
0.0448983796,
-0.0095533533,
-0.0662395954,
0.0638380274,
0.010591846,
0.003349046,
-0.0010606149,
-0.0260279588,
0.0838801786,
-0.0525403358,
-0.0325967073,
-0.0364314392,
0.000508122,
-0.0146338111,
-0.0102207521,
0.025664188,
-0.0125865256,
-0.0181983877,
0.0367584005,
-0.0539712682,
0.0316201188,
-0.017895963,
0.0273989867,
0.0481078476,
0.0431985781,
-0.0602676831,
0.0467745215,
-0.0206088219,
-0.0456727594,
0.071050182,
-0.0519086085,
-0.0499149673,
0.004074913,
3.063e-7,
0.0144699737,
0.0367400087,
0.0303458385,
0.0001764294,
0.0099724559,
0.0178762823,
-0.0240907688,
-0.0126582263,
0.0211614668,
0.0252776053,
-0.0032095443,
0.003155252,
0.0727269128,
0.0361156277,
-0.0170436744,
-0.002161968,
-0.0279770177,
0.0109271109,
-0.0034882226,
0.007122112,
-0.0223297197,
0.0600087866,
-0.0794437826,
-0.0391718149,
0.0402046777,
-0.0081114965,
0.0392094702,
0.0306153689,
0.0094508817,
-0.039447926,
-0.0077027711,
-0.0294841733,
-0.0510898232,
0.0182705503,
-0.0494745634,
0.0254325122,
0.0108897882,
0.0453595519,
0.0006058618,
-0.0693486035,
0.0417788327,
0.0077539878,
-0.0536243692,
0.0379760414,
0.0180917233,
0.0138416616,
-0.0155471507,
0.0026099044,
-0.0632912889,
0.0479481518,
-0.0615539625,
-0.0169991944,
-0.0014351554,
0.013553801,
0.0326027274,
0.0081385635,
0.0044703279,
-0.0278088767,
-0.0330991335,
-0.0312875882,
-0.0533777997,
-0.0395930596,
-0.0357041471,
0.0294197071,
0.0066418359,
0.0179674774,
-0.0406388231,
2.852654334e-34,
0.0510731451,
-0.0469243675,
0.0133047514,
-0.0439088643,
0.0198381953,
-0.0483238772,
-0.013860045,
0.0301116016,
-0.008741512,
-0.0371855721,
-0.0997026786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07397v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07397v2 | Target-oriented Proactive Dialogue Systems with Personalization: Problem Formulation and Dataset Curation | 2023-10-11T11:32:57 | 2023-10-13T11:16:58 | Jian Wang, Yi Cheng, Dongding Lin, Chak Tou Leong, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Target-oriented dialogue systems, designed to proactively steer conversations
toward predefined targets or accomplish specific system-side goals, are an
exciting area in conversational AI. In this work, by formulating a <dialogue
act, topic> pair as the conversation target, we explore a novel problem of
personalized target-oriented dialogue by considering personalization during the
target accomplishment process. However, there remains an emergent need for
high-quality datasets, and building one from scratch requires tremendous human
effort. To address this, we propose an automatic dataset curation framework
using a role-playing approach. Based on this framework, we construct a
large-scale personalized target-oriented dialogue dataset, TopDial, which
comprises about 18K multi-turn dialogues. The experimental results show that
this dataset is of high quality and could contribute to exploring personalized
target-oriented dialogue. | [
0.0800916553,
0.0349345058,
-0.0403794646,
0.0119294999,
0.0001206041,
-0.0198747534,
0.0077460664,
-0.0482486002,
-0.0133574773,
-0.0073867813,
-0.0385174416,
-0.0112584764,
-0.0407722741,
0.0976722687,
-0.0076451404,
-0.0758928657,
0.0350766666,
-0.0237787981,
0.0388765261,
0.0215059072,
0.0203538723,
0.0221796948,
-0.0423483178,
0.0795761198,
-0.0123358192,
-0.0223733168,
-0.0333488248,
0.007441151,
0.0339079984,
-0.0031914061,
0.018218549,
0.030047616,
0.0126579488,
0.0054367161,
0.0000016706,
-0.0418207943,
0.0190998577,
-0.0628235117,
-0.0502560809,
-0.0594574362,
0.0336109176,
0.0370546579,
-0.0063233748,
0.0297856461,
-0.0325565599,
-0.0136162899,
0.0430253521,
0.0582003705,
0.0830512568,
0.0767800361,
-0.0041013262,
-0.0073563568,
0.0055508125,
-0.010416694,
0.027717026,
-0.05204219,
-0.0086682504,
0.0122596296,
0.0088750729,
-0.000961762,
0.0234214049,
-0.0074240668,
-0.0000341365,
-0.0431653708,
-0.0260235351,
0.004936079,
-0.0544183888,
-0.0006261992,
-0.0108234249,
0.1079403982,
0.0368482135,
0.010642278,
0.0250071511,
-0.0189847983,
0.0275706947,
-0.0123078674,
-0.014156295,
0.0073445849,
-0.0085285362,
-0.020896364,
-0.0094448384,
0.0507175252,
-0.0032813775,
-0.0099077821,
-0.0058260052,
0.0216435995,
-0.0388288833,
-0.0255926643,
-0.0242629871,
-0.0260948893,
0.0040931208,
-0.0778050348,
-0.0084957937,
0.0051944489,
-0.1158141196,
0.0303202998,
-0.0745686442,
0.0599062443,
-0.0146050043,
0.0258732475,
0.0459181778,
0.0262198858,
-0.0010595064,
0.0317336731,
0.0752031803,
0.0004873913,
0.0024880788,
-0.0349162146,
-0.0289532319,
-0.0178988576,
-0.0320173465,
0.0003040073,
-0.0805595145,
0.0247410033,
-0.020923676,
0.0038637163,
-0.0062746014,
0.0628201589,
-0.0408532545,
0.0570113808,
-0.0020961503,
0.0324077494,
-0.0590383373,
-0.0074568689,
-0.0354417935,
0.0194233619,
-0.0735072494,
0.0116161359,
0.0311185326,
-0.0225638282,
0.0027503138,
0.001486627,
0.0262949392,
-0.0180743169,
-0.0024812948,
0.0705594718,
-0.0276632179,
-0.0381873362,
0.0172095988,
-0.0474305525,
0.0129159242,
-0.064305447,
-0.019546425,
-0.0257878378,
0.0586880445,
-0.0337968543,
-0.018376708,
0.0046674493,
0.005368724,
0.0467110835,
0.0394770615,
0.0653173104,
0.0377930626,
-0.0056593199,
0.0254129265,
0.030489374,
-0.0399268568,
0.090569526,
0.0386948138,
0.0290110428,
0.0483787097,
0.0184503384,
0.0251668748,
0.0213067755,
0.0169476755,
-0.0149260741,
0.0351713672,
0.0578499138,
-0.0106707597,
0.0403161868,
-0.0171693694,
0.0005609217,
-0.0592908673,
-0.0352115631,
0.044868011,
0.0479059704,
-0.0345621333,
0.0157061499,
0.0174792446,
0.0559831634,
0.0046066321,
-0.0383456312,
-0.0002097718,
0.0300269127,
0.0032532823,
-0.0492248572,
-0.039312657,
0.0062916614,
-0.0439637154,
-0.0564689077,
0.0472892784,
-0.0133940196,
-0.0007799075,
0.0123154102,
0.0177739523,
0.012718305,
-0.0477644317,
0.0364120938,
-0.0274052899,
-0.0586088486,
-0.0387972184,
-0.015488985,
-0.0013705292,
0.0525961444,
0.0754999146,
-0.0704608038,
-0.0692072511,
-0.0322431773,
0.0112335226,
0.0097844871,
0.0171709228,
-0.0556749851,
0.0313384123,
-0.0401755497,
0.0031632725,
-0.0183145292,
-0.0443229266,
0.0161158945,
-0.0035858667,
-0.0262031592,
-0.0281255729,
0.0635861009,
0.0497575812,
-0.0093835089,
0.0241444875,
-0.0006871345,
0.036771819,
0.0275815353,
0.0592632778,
0.0389114767,
0.0106572164,
-0.0397632271,
0.0312665477,
0.0123626953,
-0.007766461,
0.0372240283,
-0.00501977,
-0.0191847328,
0.0101759154,
-0.0502306856,
-0.0519445352,
0.032324411,
-0.0253219567,
-0.045842059,
0.016131172,
-0.0286912136,
-0.0285103563,
0.0072196964,
0.0197577942,
0.0254691467,
0.0258528348,
0.004298368,
0.023123743,
0.0090060271,
-0.0227671266,
0.0389176719,
0.0245643072,
0.0071041472,
-0.0812058747,
0.011546256,
0.0241162553,
-0.0110454587,
-0.0319903009,
0.0223222803,
-0.0059482423,
-0.0514425226,
-0.0560975783,
-0.0637939051,
-0.0178588182,
0.0122536598,
-0.0494951718,
0.0027311086,
0.0279919598,
-0.0075857723,
-0.0275858063,
-0.0416915789,
-0.0193315279,
0.0384603627,
-0.0139860353,
0.0442471132,
0.029271923,
-0.0288408957,
-0.0246534199,
0.0168043971,
-0.0008644908,
0.0028046381,
-0.032622423,
0.038421955,
-0.032876201,
-0.0257681683,
-0.0263737515,
0.0449097715,
-0.0382019877,
-0.0367189683,
0.0518654063,
0.0095857326,
0.0135915847,
0.0551953204,
0.0001001846,
0.0566504449,
0.0097739743,
-0.0453596711,
-0.0145696783,
0.0567631796,
-0.0113058584,
0.0057104561,
-0.035165526,
-0.0188743621,
0.0394662432,
0.0232937317,
-0.0027760118,
0.0455015525,
-0.0475570299,
0.027506724,
0.0502086841,
-0.0390930288,
0.0065498645,
-0.0093160914,
-0.0233120583,
0.0318191685,
-0.0249793474,
0.0152515946,
0.0768785253,
0.0169923156,
-0.0398533009,
-0.0232641883,
0.0195073485,
-0.0126115978,
0.0622101538,
-0.0013844842,
-0.0035800864,
-0.0011287986,
-0.0301584862,
-0.0116857216,
-0.0224409681,
0.0228425637,
-0.0266529527,
0.043718379,
-0.0475388207,
-0.0268917102,
0.0126432208,
-0.0472561233,
-0.0626439974,
-0.0257722605,
-0.0157726761,
-0.022281358,
0.0217190124,
-0.0339134745,
-0.0709825903,
-0.0113585917,
-0.0004048056,
0.030123096,
0.0228318479,
-0.0126448004,
-0.0261993334,
-0.0185017362,
0.0415625311,
0.0230575968,
-0.0538933985,
0.0514170192,
0.0727091506,
0.0366128162,
0.0397125594,
-0.061163187,
0.0076775467,
-0.0022003094,
0.0441202745,
-0.0227738786,
0.0176328328,
-0.0010949071,
0.041700311,
-0.0232402291,
-0.0265370626,
0.0905533507,
0.0439988971,
-0.0253449436,
0.005404545,
-0.0009893,
0.0053193746,
0.0084267454,
0.0410201587,
-0.1066707224,
-0.0237838216,
-0.0160514265,
0.0091908285,
-0.0476103574,
-0.0553486571,
-0.0258788485,
-0.1123781428,
0.050146576,
-0.0139079858,
-0.0195794813,
0.0015973109,
0.0074629104,
0.0057508624,
-0.0260603707,
-0.0033783815,
-0.0164585449,
0.0359668061,
-0.03724356,
-0.0216424186,
-0.0150363538,
-0.0146380067,
0.0314407386,
-0.0237539783,
0.0863151029,
0.0756712034,
0.0905333012,
0.0429225415,
0.0327445678,
-0.0364669859,
0.040483661,
-0.0270505287,
0.0013609157,
0.0479402579,
-0.0343445688,
-0.0219464414,
0.0041669579,
0.0439181142,
-0.0206830371,
-0.0419679657,
0.0481598936,
0.0260351412,
-0.0554839708,
0.0367861539,
-0.0046291011,
0.0320242643,
0.0516167842,
0.0500984564,
-0.0143351387,
-0.0468264073,
0.0103905657,
-0.0239730719,
-0.0155153908,
-0.0631501451,
-0.0529974438,
-0.0127976891,
0.0239832755,
-0.0139878802,
-0.0582832582,
-0.0736699253,
0.0491268374,
0.0341163576,
-0.032719031,
-0.0233545732,
0.0056099012,
0.0530003086,
0.0062250206,
-0.0042177094,
-0.0308286734,
0.0027169515,
-0.0630536526,
-0.0859047249,
0.0229838938,
-0.0614032969,
0.0017988209,
0.0326359197,
-0.0280120466,
-0.0337634385,
-0.0217862539,
0.0492142737,
0.0238956399,
0.0619130954,
-0.0255298037,
-0.0553037412,
-0.0218570866,
0.0141671561,
-0.0155959381,
-0.0409529321,
0.0458542705,
0.0672530383,
-0.0027830168,
0.0380437486,
-0.0347387977,
0.0348884538,
-0.0332837813,
-0.0178333391,
-0.039242778,
-0.0391104296,
-0.0074747731,
-0.0166743975,
0.0556747206,
0.0122922184,
-0.0186457559,
-0.0081356037,
0.0586159565,
-0.0714269429,
-0.0359529331,
-0.0414412208,
0.016552886,
-0.0071689724,
-0.0226590317,
0.0202398747,
-0.0437290817,
-0.0804750323,
-0.008947094,
-0.0541729853,
0.0261224862,
0.0322529003,
0.0315488204,
0.0244504884,
0.0062191319,
0.0000933177,
0.031842161,
0.0216312259,
0.0206079334,
0.0357558839,
0.0365615822,
0.0472319461,
-0.0320488475,
-0.0136742545,
0.056963101,
-0.0520461313,
-0.014438861,
0.0156532153,
0.0249989629,
0.0105045093,
0.0153464563,
-0.0018551276,
-0.0371534713,
0.0296103973,
0.0184122548,
0.0219671074,
0.0245678369,
-0.0815674365,
0.0315515324,
0.0395047143,
-0.0140782073,
0.0040846774,
0.0544384755,
-0.0138966199,
0.0301208235,
-0.0116400141,
-0.0039687837,
-0.0543036647,
-0.0405123904,
-0.0147469556,
0.0341733173,
-0.0077587264,
-0.005165766,
-0.0385474898,
-0.0232218467,
-0.0112342844,
0.0286512561,
0.0007332481,
-0.0132819023,
0.0366361029,
0.019962538,
-0.0017228416,
-0.0249657892,
-0.0389090218,
0.0042086598,
-0.0213934109,
-0.0175342485,
-0.0206285268,
-4.829963391e-33,
-0.0226054844,
-0.0025974682,
0.043241661,
0.0630588531,
-0.0079456186,
-0.0237984825,
-0.0295031965,
-0.0081025716,
-0.0019565336,
0.0032503749,
-0.0341595337,
0.0300352015,
0.016372934,
0.0239618942,
-0.0185810402,
-0.0348565616,
0.0426091701,
-0.0197971538,
-0.0305550396,
0.060791485,
0.0411883332,
-0.0203048363,
0.011301606,
-0.107298106,
0.0219202582,
-0.0129081206,
-0.0385949388,
0.0451533422,
0.0069477013,
0.0717688203,
0.0279134475,
0.0441489406,
-0.0066934382,
-0.0400255173,
0.0140689593,
0.0413668305,
-0.0385514386,
-0.0414960422,
0.0158251729,
0.0211361106,
-0.0095253754,
-0.0304986518,
-0.0375422463,
-0.0064124288,
-0.0157553107,
0.0231584888,
0.012895409,
-0.0132424152,
-0.0056464355,
-0.0053573321,
-0.045855321,
-0.0096117621,
-0.0458858423,
-0.037671186,
0.0011092599,
0.0434178561,
0.0360982455,
-0.0261137076,
-0.0280257724,
0.0431316085,
-0.0104088392,
-0.002199023,
0.0088773854,
0.0553165153,
0.0312175099,
0.0373215191,
0.0654862225,
0.0454080924,
-0.0075879646,
0.0029647511,
-0.0405672342,
0.0717908815,
0.0265313238,
0.0628616661,
-0.0162147339,
-0.0044859652,
-0.0296721365,
0.0281007141,
0.0565399863,
0.0127208028,
0.0081769591,
0.0075168754,
-0.0537374727,
0.0056759375,
-0.0272423886,
0.0144817829,
-0.0019168033,
-0.0146970013,
0.0072514056,
0.0142745618,
-0.0220271163,
0.0317578055,
0.0141911404,
-0.0115779312,
-0.0087328469,
0.0357715711,
-0.0106220869,
0.0268395394,
-0.0203092583,
-0.0397314876,
-0.0444806293,
-0.0149864107,
0.0705487803,
-0.0170910433,
0.0390376225,
0.0277565829,
-0.007956163,
0.0266806614,
-0.029404901,
-0.0102224406,
-0.0220120437,
0.067303136,
-0.0570329428,
0.007930805,
0.0100693423,
0.0085862121,
-0.0414814316,
0.0713273212,
-0.010342964,
-0.0328145772,
-0.0362125598,
-0.0111409966,
-0.0027969796,
-0.0180654265,
-0.0317632295,
-0.0110135376,
-0.0370096453,
-0.0240389556,
0.0424120948,
-0.0194121674,
-0.0091036055,
-0.0404807441,
2.446e-7,
-0.0596068241,
0.0163460393,
0.0321940891,
0.0816064477,
0.0110838693,
0.0594087578,
-0.011641359,
0.0360231176,
0.0271733254,
-0.0087973662,
0.0756759122,
0.0230012666,
0.0246109124,
0.0249579754,
-0.1267320663,
-0.0360500142,
-0.0287715346,
-0.0213341154,
-0.037162751,
0.0078866445,
0.0398001708,
0.0623603389,
0.0535189509,
0.0159968957,
0.0158441719,
0.0280377008,
0.0202510357,
-0.0593569987,
-0.0146570299,
0.0299092662,
0.0461492427,
-0.0358479656,
-0.027948942,
0.0244296212,
-0.0195529684,
0.0259411428,
-0.0014635063,
0.0477009453,
0.000322245,
-0.0586867593,
-0.0201695003,
0.008092138,
-0.0010292714,
0.025400199,
0.0487260781,
-0.05608695,
-0.0413789004,
0.0245166328,
-0.006240732,
-0.0056992886,
-0.0159514137,
-0.0082630618,
-0.0363616347,
0.0162250437,
0.0015934922,
0.0165891536,
0.0335956179,
-0.113414295,
0.014128048,
-0.0297452919,
-0.0444622263,
-0.0276094265,
-0.0027239057,
-0.0381238721,
-0.0023658732,
-0.022926284,
0.0093614766,
1.900498055e-34,
0.0078436863,
0.0115794055,
-0.0026595588,
-0.0075563658,
0.0655810013,
-0.0136308521,
0.019904593,
0.0189330652,
0.0642066821,
-0.0595526621,
-0.0311739054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07387v1 | Linguistic laws in biology | 2023-10-11T11:08:20 | 2023-10-11T11:08:20 | Stuart Semple, Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho, Morgan L. Gustison | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.bio-ph | Linguistic laws, the common statistical patterns of human language, have been
investigated by quantitative linguists for nearly a century. Recently,
biologists from a range of disciplines have started to explore the prevalence
of these laws beyond language, finding patterns consistent with linguistic laws
across multiple levels of biological organisation, from molecular (genomes,
genes, and proteins) to organismal (animal behaviour) to ecological
(populations and ecosystems). We propose a new conceptual framework for the
study of linguistic laws in biology, comprising and integrating distinct levels
of analysis, from description to prediction to theory building. Adopting this
framework will provide critical new insights into the fundamental rules of
organisation underpinning natural systems, unifying linguistic laws and core
theory in biology. | [
0.0270727351,
0.0564259142,
-0.0414961018,
-0.0115401102,
-0.0376636051,
0.00251338,
-0.0145386476,
0.007997727,
-0.0382051691,
-0.0306574032,
0.0159954168,
-0.041487366,
0.0432690792,
-0.0241767839,
0.0384035818,
-0.0196448527,
-0.0011157907,
-0.0292472094,
0.0086304415,
0.0038498389,
0.0290965065,
0.0030436583,
0.0278969985,
0.0108361309,
0.0297472328,
0.0040380177,
0.0268469546,
-0.0435847789,
0.01668844,
0.0135609275,
-0.0382727273,
-0.0033351888,
-0.0268682856,
0.0351020694,
0.0000014129,
-0.0512406304,
0.0282604992,
0.0315367989,
0.0146435872,
-0.0211245492,
0.0262221415,
-0.0079444051,
-0.0246654991,
-0.0498913452,
0.0092295827,
0.043005202,
0.0718154162,
-0.0365546346,
-0.016092822,
0.0183495767,
-0.0118270349,
-0.0758436173,
0.0442542657,
-0.0157695003,
0.0348857455,
0.0648958385,
0.0474139899,
0.002030178,
0.0461379774,
-0.026048962,
-0.0461647622,
0.0318636335,
0.0240582544,
0.0499373972,
-0.0674051717,
0.014343068,
0.023449216,
-0.0521773808,
0.0645779371,
0.0374617875,
0.0135272741,
-0.0294933319,
0.0134109315,
0.0135981319,
-0.0094872294,
0.0379757509,
-0.0174982082,
0.0373205207,
-0.0004723343,
0.0298070703,
0.0465157293,
0.0137790209,
0.0199736394,
0.0059639895,
-0.0498808026,
0.0864907354,
0.0166485179,
-0.0524179339,
-0.0742553845,
-0.020905178,
-0.0076253694,
0.0057554916,
-0.0266915746,
-0.0009098138,
0.0120076761,
-0.0113179991,
0.066841878,
-0.0088014454,
0.0819311962,
-0.0368657932,
0.001438298,
-0.0026413503,
-0.0282775946,
0.0204918738,
0.028432766,
0.0130131589,
-0.0245234184,
-0.0006218696,
-0.0293663386,
0.0008375082,
-0.0777382106,
-0.0257267579,
0.036302682,
-0.021350123,
-0.0049507092,
0.0222443659,
-0.0472951904,
-0.0231580045,
0.0048481189,
-0.0598004274,
-0.0299666133,
-0.0324435383,
-0.0286886208,
0.0370410234,
0.016275879,
-0.0107945381,
-0.0170672908,
0.0304240417,
-0.0371504501,
-0.0717524141,
0.0082856594,
0.0144371577,
-0.0215817243,
0.0285244286,
-0.0388029628,
0.069571957,
0.0307871215,
-0.0060572769,
0.040759854,
-0.0003047463,
-0.0807162672,
0.0109258667,
-0.0104451794,
-0.0207788777,
0.0247635469,
0.0239380617,
-0.0121471072,
-0.0170599464,
-0.0121372053,
-0.0264595803,
-0.0524898134,
0.0237817504,
-0.0197819676,
0.0122509608,
-0.0063653323,
-0.0076128272,
0.0642103404,
0.0302304178,
0.0250425152,
-0.0475110225,
0.0466607437,
-0.0089334026,
0.0290170852,
-0.0012445098,
-0.012534813,
-0.0289547741,
-0.0127402069,
-0.0240994319,
0.0149080167,
-0.0119624343,
0.0253264755,
0.024226537,
-0.0099460771,
-0.048876483,
-0.0022002275,
0.0991021693,
0.0223986264,
0.0713962317,
0.0362393297,
-0.0029159139,
-0.0196927525,
0.0425726809,
0.0108682066,
-0.018324554,
-0.0371372364,
-0.0072648833,
-0.0024750014,
0.0250974428,
0.0623302236,
-0.0020920248,
-0.0155020803,
0.0273981374,
0.0138494214,
-0.0770754591,
0.0013676175,
-0.0083871223,
0.0457480364,
0.0177821126,
0.0146017959,
-0.0340639763,
0.0309892707,
-0.0045400565,
0.0147012481,
0.0133208986,
-0.0317942873,
-0.0102616446,
0.0286872778,
0.0411290936,
-0.0085404506,
0.0590959601,
-0.0365598202,
0.0064995233,
-0.008902452,
-0.0028805281,
0.0122135235,
0.0192426983,
-0.0105737681,
-0.0192678645,
-0.0840326026,
0.0507032014,
0.000117767,
0.0020578899,
-0.0510654971,
0.015082919,
-0.0126273967,
0.0137773203,
-0.0244754646,
-0.0241730604,
0.0333640501,
-0.0289928168,
-0.0588210002,
0.0629297048,
0.0015269135,
-0.0340828225,
-0.0178284477,
0.0366220959,
0.0249744803,
0.0193393845,
0.0319290459,
-0.0247843731,
0.0331365056,
-0.0598131977,
0.0224488974,
0.0002494707,
0.075843364,
-0.0820408612,
0.1002871096,
0.0035310925,
-0.0285334866,
-0.0393296033,
0.038286645,
-0.0239356812,
-0.0108591858,
0.0105655305,
0.0487429984,
-0.0321542248,
-0.0698269382,
0.0555301718,
-0.0395153239,
0.04428472,
0.0129296975,
0.0270039551,
-0.0292239692,
0.0575260408,
0.0015549515,
-0.0004775411,
-0.0064608352,
-0.0093849795,
-0.0826259255,
0.0101930406,
0.0781279728,
-0.0081220269,
-0.0223867763,
0.0071892086,
0.0276391897,
0.0074751466,
-0.0211286116,
0.0069100866,
0.0378008522,
0.0318172984,
-0.0395637378,
-0.0953673199,
-0.0242963452,
-0.0124517661,
-0.0638640895,
0.0412238687,
0.0089089153,
-0.0514938682,
-0.0191642866,
0.0140907755,
-0.0737473667,
-0.0229758453,
-0.0179897118,
-0.0693662688,
0.0261350833,
0.0231870394,
0.0488969535,
-0.03031932,
-0.0212431569,
-0.000997093,
0.0538824461,
-0.0048556291,
-0.0214949846,
-0.0541789681,
-0.0619572364,
0.0357323661,
-0.0289147776,
-0.0231605265,
-0.0192588698,
0.0617993027,
0.0283939447,
-0.0617726855,
-0.0264622979,
0.0461356565,
-0.0581623651,
0.0243231766,
-0.0120802727,
-0.0222290531,
-0.0187670849,
0.04157212,
-0.0383280776,
-0.0296622943,
0.0648188666,
0.013254242,
-0.0031297051,
-0.0452090316,
-0.0074410397,
-0.014864753,
0.047767818,
0.0197010227,
-0.0001196074,
0.0899365544,
-0.026365865,
-0.0332654156,
-0.0424358323,
0.0040181056,
-0.0126021421,
-0.0007731286,
-0.0955335796,
0.0115802595,
-0.0034340899,
-0.0061918884,
0.0191409364,
0.0232138149,
0.0070028859,
0.0569725372,
0.0357542299,
-0.0729600862,
0.0037352312,
0.0166757703,
0.0631127506,
-0.0515789464,
0.0048603523,
0.0104856864,
-0.0072284774,
0.0292941295,
0.0189649984,
0.0065983618,
0.0350515656,
-0.0182474647,
0.0132616265,
0.0324128121,
-0.0736028478,
0.0856781006,
0.03642717,
0.0365178362,
0.0276402496,
0.0183527563,
-0.0233683251,
-0.00709046,
-0.0042902911,
-0.0062810569,
0.0002598088,
0.0589498542,
0.01663642,
0.0483327284,
0.0618569776,
-0.0412340686,
-0.0280174185,
0.042411007,
0.0356448963,
-0.0545498319,
0.0435394719,
-0.0296155885,
-0.0596173704,
-0.002260003,
-0.045524314,
-0.0076850369,
-0.0259946529,
-0.011915342,
0.0389071405,
-0.0611012056,
-0.0189414956,
-0.0220937785,
-0.0146329524,
-0.0080511384,
-0.0038626534,
0.0179866087,
0.0050181355,
0.0236685574,
0.036919795,
-0.0453534946,
-0.007239609,
-0.0139603112,
-0.034020897,
0.003762387,
0.0620697141,
0.0341316462,
-0.0736307427,
-0.0420850664,
0.0048050778,
-0.0062443875,
-0.0242647231,
0.0276269354,
-0.0224853959,
0.0919510275,
-0.0127965994,
-0.0908480436,
-0.0191618372,
-0.0493182763,
-0.0415967107,
-0.0111202933,
0.1032047719,
0.0182149764,
-0.1012259573,
-0.0354235433,
0.0408690721,
-0.0349223539,
0.0406186879,
0.048626855,
0.0049500125,
-0.0181914978,
-0.0340986513,
-0.0140258167,
0.014666236,
-0.079580389,
0.0159477405,
0.0055509983,
-0.0796621516,
-0.0671223328,
0.0173295308,
0.0142085524,
-0.0028646037,
0.062601231,
-0.0258086454,
0.0323239937,
-0.0803721845,
0.0009095753,
0.0003447322,
0.0109050246,
-0.0161104929,
-0.0127863018,
-0.0266738646,
0.0756833032,
0.0361691229,
-0.0254180543,
-0.0028861682,
0.0386520438,
-0.0985753983,
0.0066193296,
0.015290834,
0.0152763976,
-0.0508315936,
0.0509257652,
-0.0806132928,
0.0318254381,
0.0647496879,
-0.0026543941,
0.0391051881,
0.0081762997,
-0.0226781834,
0.0259625595,
0.0405710675,
-0.0042918129,
0.0286881328,
-0.0139673529,
0.0414665602,
-0.0693619028,
-0.0135295689,
0.0444215946,
-0.0228918511,
0.0159677994,
-0.0369750783,
-0.0576473922,
0.0185664631,
-0.0261267908,
0.0197864585,
-0.0518920943,
0.0131103788,
-0.0183196049,
0.0133002829,
0.0513627119,
-0.0402488448,
0.0074764509,
-0.0301144142,
0.0145693626,
0.0346684232,
0.0229123421,
0.036042463,
-0.0050271135,
0.023999922,
0.0118067628,
0.0286026374,
0.075188145,
-0.1020624638,
0.0318966582,
-0.0031379634,
-0.0537969619,
0.0080791302,
-0.0072204098,
-0.0383180678,
-0.0114435349,
-0.0003773503,
0.0190719962,
0.0128236748,
-0.0454554185,
0.0285737962,
-0.0105995797,
0.0260187015,
-0.0294106789,
0.0040494166,
-0.0292562079,
-0.0055598812,
-0.0666286796,
0.0233486854,
-0.0132310782,
0.0263581704,
-0.0378111899,
-0.0415741876,
0.0386235043,
0.0391222835,
0.0190328564,
-0.0605642162,
-0.0251292586,
0.0276512317,
-0.0045903684,
-0.0092985267,
-0.0242069457,
0.0138031207,
0.0012496463,
-0.0728865564,
-0.0298132356,
0.001581841,
0.0235066321,
0.0284596365,
0.0214081965,
-0.0079908893,
0.0444857441,
0.0289533883,
-0.051052738,
-0.0249778051,
0.0179361515,
-0.0107798884,
-0.0170883201,
0.0001370369,
-4.648617674e-33,
0.0034617407,
-0.0417757407,
-0.0075237928,
0.0419359244,
0.0335993133,
-0.0175899528,
-0.0350441411,
0.0062106578,
0.0101126274,
0.0723280907,
0.0527222864,
0.0097180875,
-0.0107525252,
-0.0091754375,
0.0446932539,
0.0209704936,
-0.0210418757,
-0.0400227569,
0.0506579168,
-0.045001559,
0.0490473732,
0.0190311689,
0.0831548572,
-0.0128221847,
0.0493714884,
0.0549789444,
0.0141872177,
0.0020891242,
-0.0844292343,
-0.0096491622,
-0.0043318984,
0.0364225805,
0.0214505531,
-0.0168102272,
0.0133181354,
-0.0445633605,
0.0607989319,
-0.0421579778,
0.0303880926,
-0.0318393447,
-0.0038686341,
-0.023117274,
0.0408211723,
-0.0411476865,
-0.0669236779,
0.0142079201,
0.0376075022,
-0.0379363745,
-0.016038917,
-0.0333751701,
-0.03243481,
0.0050277379,
-0.0350823589,
0.042740766,
0.0452415161,
-0.0594677255,
-0.0007582576,
-0.0405042134,
-0.0015891196,
0.0813018382,
0.0044007483,
0.0517175384,
0.0466020294,
0.0021578164,
0.0013129709,
0.0381040014,
0.0530084223,
0.0123794535,
0.0110701406,
0.0373884328,
0.0188681129,
0.0458539538,
0.0034570498,
0.0031692248,
0.034767732,
0.0028436757,
-0.0692824274,
0.0301136933,
0.0162061788,
-0.0320095606,
-0.0482377298,
0.0301396772,
-0.0130671579,
-0.0187010206,
-0.0029632198,
-0.0214631502,
0.0062299934,
-0.0109688612,
-0.0513097718,
-0.0670868382,
-0.0018643356,
-0.0034381833,
0.0402580611,
-0.0419161431,
-0.0976125225,
-0.008561559,
-0.0136302691,
0.0095691672,
0.00186578,
0.0498606674,
-0.0433222502,
-0.0323460847,
-0.0204495601,
0.0373965725,
0.0452802517,
-0.0122896656,
0.0063645197,
0.0168775506,
-0.0137369838,
-0.0310441554,
0.0017913453,
-0.0873364434,
0.0347440019,
-0.0267034099,
-0.0187820569,
0.0392361954,
0.0267546382,
0.0014553111,
0.069025889,
0.0068972264,
0.0097040264,
0.0806055367,
-0.0291376114,
0.0152058881,
-0.0388636887,
-0.0324318483,
-0.0276615266,
0.0488398857,
0.0556330159,
-0.0087933689,
-0.0104709566,
-0.008337968,
2.459e-7,
0.0680089369,
0.0502069518,
0.0233743861,
-0.0026538689,
0.0430710241,
-0.0152726099,
-0.0195886157,
-0.0041497443,
-0.0689887926,
-0.0451005213,
0.0126518197,
-0.0049491711,
-0.008211337,
0.0444048494,
-0.022500718,
0.0009934758,
-0.0699120089,
-0.00696065,
0.0065054181,
-0.0115752369,
-0.0486185551,
0.0619363934,
-0.0073076007,
-0.010345961,
-0.0175579749,
-0.00564649,
0.0283178575,
-0.0161823668,
0.043102853,
0.0417688675,
-0.0371657945,
-0.0741504058,
0.0459235422,
0.0014856348,
0.0217828359,
0.0073500699,
-0.0061331401,
-0.0113243265,
-0.0006109064,
0.0311020575,
0.0450070165,
-0.0089375814,
-0.0079645449,
-0.0140977949,
-0.0082576089,
-0.0125979166,
-0.0469907001,
-0.0021116361,
0.0010721298,
0.0249093566,
0.0213622991,
0.0073826513,
-0.0021207121,
0.0251821484,
0.0172491875,
-0.0075710812,
-0.0222215839,
-0.0291265361,
-0.0375829041,
0.0296903644,
-0.0270258281,
-0.0393503234,
-0.0061642979,
0.0446352735,
0.0261769649,
-0.0080751684,
0.0049220449,
2.138151904e-34,
0.0225319695,
0.0020605584,
0.0137734208,
-0.0074639688,
0.0024381406,
-0.0178171266,
-0.0119940769,
0.0418928526,
0.0363944843,
-0.0421569422,
-0.0071570063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07347v1 | Fast-ELECTRA for Efficient Pre-training | 2023-10-11T09:55:46 | 2023-10-11T09:55:46 | Chengyu Dong, Liyuan Liu, Hao Cheng, Jingbo Shang, Jianfeng Gao, Xiaodong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | ELECTRA pre-trains language models by detecting tokens in a sequence that
have been replaced by an auxiliary model. Although ELECTRA offers a significant
boost in efficiency, its potential is constrained by the training cost brought
by the auxiliary model. Notably, this model, which is jointly trained with the
main model, only serves to assist the training of the main model and is
discarded post-training. This results in a substantial amount of training cost
being expended in vain. To mitigate this issue, we propose Fast-ELECTRA, which
leverages an existing language model as the auxiliary model. To construct a
learning curriculum for the main model, we smooth its output distribution via
temperature scaling following a descending schedule. Our approach rivals the
performance of state-of-the-art ELECTRA-style pre-training methods, while
significantly eliminating the computation and memory cost brought by the joint
training of the auxiliary model. Our method also reduces the sensitivity to
hyper-parameters and enhances the pre-training stability. | [
-0.0094219791,
0.0680363402,
-0.0015936673,
0.0294286869,
0.0000175884,
0.0476654656,
-0.0191246886,
0.0014276222,
-0.0171752647,
-0.0516260043,
-0.0485717319,
-0.0305426121,
-0.0203763489,
0.0399064273,
0.0149776833,
-0.0813119784,
0.0275080968,
-0.0337843373,
0.0136968344,
0.0122117763,
0.0091712838,
0.008126976,
0.0039406754,
0.0433947705,
-0.0042705624,
0.0079375468,
-0.0249097422,
0.021200873,
0.0215944499,
-0.0165075157,
0.0420730971,
0.0637525246,
0.0319688618,
0.0151182692,
0.0000022483,
-0.0333167166,
-0.0346243083,
-0.031628143,
-0.0252201743,
0.0129610095,
0.0857723281,
0.0158147607,
0.0110070491,
0.0552246496,
-0.0449174978,
-0.035619881,
0.0420824513,
0.013832923,
0.0170471985,
0.0585079789,
-0.0239918251,
-0.0197679885,
-0.0041611958,
-0.0229463857,
-0.0562667027,
-0.0241054855,
0.0002851031,
-0.0557534024,
-0.0323610492,
0.0083239535,
-0.0177754853,
0.0207827818,
0.0326042362,
0.0188108571,
0.0115300836,
0.031426318,
-0.0210339297,
-0.0437760465,
-0.0341537111,
0.0583187826,
-0.0820685402,
-0.06190449,
0.0230056476,
-0.0065897321,
-0.0294999778,
-0.0460456796,
-0.0204625316,
-0.0033257762,
0.0130086476,
0.0418745056,
0.0116093727,
-0.0233476683,
0.0159426089,
-0.0110224206,
-0.0306483787,
0.0589815378,
0.0422017537,
-0.0133441091,
0.0267632604,
-0.0021160606,
-0.0126628093,
-0.0773708075,
0.0223505627,
0.0423433818,
0.0015848499,
-0.0008548108,
-0.0757046193,
-0.0283341147,
0.0356400758,
-0.0193719286,
0.0407456346,
0.0268950593,
-0.0276291426,
0.0167430583,
-0.0418887846,
0.016738072,
0.0265436266,
0.046375528,
-0.0579665378,
0.0175162144,
0.0068795034,
-0.0090665938,
-0.0749750882,
0.0037094916,
-0.0146957617,
-0.0169299934,
-0.0614991784,
-0.0083577726,
0.0208443273,
-0.0180787928,
0.0195297599,
-0.0127083417,
-0.0300128739,
-0.00224866,
0.0279343668,
0.027972715,
-0.0390678085,
0.0523538999,
-0.0156253148,
-0.0406377167,
-0.0197000187,
0.0253941789,
0.0283004679,
-0.0029418739,
0.03522994,
0.0383713245,
-0.0173215624,
-0.0543413907,
-0.0561000146,
-0.0006177844,
0.0189539064,
-0.0690862834,
-0.0129916575,
-0.0597204939,
-0.0202023983,
-0.0021195274,
0.0192749295,
-0.0020912718,
-0.006038669,
-0.0039428906,
-0.0143821146,
0.083183147,
-0.0339677893,
-0.0238737967,
0.0306874868,
0.0087208562,
0.0253200103,
0.0881115198,
0.0262305755,
0.0106793856,
0.0256836005,
-0.0091403686,
0.0075035342,
0.0708395541,
0.0453910157,
0.0004209225,
-0.0371631235,
-0.0178662967,
0.0171859358,
0.0026708525,
0.0620650128,
0.032326106,
-0.020216329,
-0.0080234082,
0.0471076369,
0.0253190491,
-0.0166647695,
0.0037913362,
0.0753745735,
-0.0191426445,
-0.0132295666,
0.0339789465,
-0.038345322,
-0.0070243655,
-0.0387315154,
0.0186426695,
-0.0090912115,
0.0394435264,
-0.0612900369,
-0.0462846756,
-0.0087758703,
-0.0374592058,
0.0253226459,
-0.0022738897,
0.0355505235,
0.020297436,
-0.0667594224,
0.0568131097,
0.0636831671,
-0.0526654869,
0.0204268806,
-0.0591532253,
0.0038238105,
0.0583917648,
-0.0078235613,
-0.0286886971,
-0.0658257008,
0.008950037,
0.036809098,
0.0147980582,
0.0290365629,
-0.0033358899,
0.0249490887,
-0.0841160193,
-0.0220002569,
0.0144773973,
0.0290785749,
0.0451191515,
-0.0007966889,
0.0419157855,
0.0230948348,
-0.0200266503,
-0.0169213805,
0.0433789678,
-0.0536683016,
-0.0325871557,
-0.0187883787,
0.0246982463,
0.0274573658,
-0.0129575264,
-0.0081712864,
-0.0024693301,
0.065376617,
-0.0427303761,
0.011108038,
0.0338679366,
-0.0807804912,
-0.0511554554,
0.03256936,
0.0371599793,
0.0130264685,
0.065374963,
-0.0273751449,
-0.0378168561,
0.016874088,
0.034528587,
0.0859022811,
-0.0385219343,
0.0402092338,
0.0092279464,
0.0310402401,
-0.0160704516,
0.0203424599,
-0.0122782011,
0.0263078623,
0.0181378853,
0.0070591029,
-0.0003303961,
-0.046334736,
-0.0134565113,
0.0180640463,
0.013238648,
0.0117879426,
0.0097385161,
-0.0072825183,
-0.0486011356,
-0.0288900975,
-0.0959284455,
-0.0124389883,
-0.0577869788,
0.0181488525,
0.012846672,
0.004628621,
-0.0113335,
-0.0352915116,
-0.0160049498,
0.0188069362,
-0.0378679819,
0.0001848513,
0.0000676824,
0.0130264629,
-0.0395462587,
-0.0405740142,
-0.0158641264,
-0.0041719228,
0.0601960681,
0.0008927454,
0.0224363338,
-0.0186506324,
0.0164331254,
0.0028564874,
0.0524764322,
-0.0073394151,
-0.0620883144,
-0.007411757,
-0.0241066366,
0.0355935208,
0.0667061508,
0.0274466649,
0.0141319893,
0.0288538672,
-0.0072789891,
-0.0368168987,
-0.0018502754,
-0.031350404,
-0.0076301079,
-0.0342045613,
-0.0093935514,
-0.0270522553,
0.0901056007,
-0.0348633565,
0.0148554901,
-0.0404190458,
0.0071283644,
-0.0165846907,
-0.037708398,
-0.0345907733,
-0.0165721234,
-0.0172072165,
-0.0071864524,
-0.0265921559,
-0.0433668606,
0.0539998785,
-0.062730141,
-0.0169238113,
-0.0434058309,
-0.0294515174,
-0.0327360071,
0.0152014503,
0.0329068154,
0.0069493731,
-0.0008004615,
-0.0380130075,
-0.0160333999,
-0.0220134016,
0.0056545935,
-0.0032079646,
0.0104524391,
-0.0216848981,
0.0055757514,
0.0011521945,
-0.0137364063,
-0.0178298187,
-0.0329905264,
-0.0087258052,
0.0270032082,
0.0198489614,
-0.011912344,
-0.0208717398,
0.0294941254,
-0.0394305028,
0.1088771895,
-0.0095504019,
0.0252720341,
-0.024873361,
0.0509550646,
0.0599609427,
-0.0179329515,
-0.0233257003,
-0.0838580206,
0.0328012072,
0.0425282903,
0.0828243271,
-0.02474414,
-0.0523438491,
0.0470963344,
0.0406324901,
-0.0293088425,
-0.003570253,
0.0129767507,
0.0184460673,
-0.0396095105,
-0.0241526887,
0.130599916,
0.0155297257,
-0.0605131462,
-0.0016798769,
0.0195173807,
0.0940309241,
0.0235207491,
-0.0038758703,
-0.0445336141,
-0.0377372801,
0.0163538959,
0.0415558293,
-0.0037133044,
-0.0078896321,
-0.0053303633,
-0.0523979664,
-0.0028046267,
0.0124700656,
-0.0637337342,
0.0282657873,
-0.0390026234,
-0.000917463,
-0.0274396185,
0.0093823886,
-0.0109524028,
-0.0410027839,
-0.004061616,
0.0444460325,
-0.0129703283,
-0.0398065858,
0.0228296556,
-0.0563061908,
0.0119408937,
0.0383766666,
0.003400136,
-0.0135916239,
-0.0019207143,
0.0485852323,
-0.0016801941,
-0.0052408166,
-0.0323450342,
0.0270107575,
-0.0286176596,
-0.0212359149,
0.0353880003,
0.0242374055,
0.0025510413,
-0.0109089939,
-0.0054818913,
0.0532280877,
0.0110806171,
-0.0166803617,
0.0047533526,
-0.0200123191,
0.0511173941,
0.0610539503,
0.0359143205,
-0.0454792827,
-0.0132459281,
-0.002253877,
0.0037617623,
-0.0309550744,
-0.0300628152,
-0.0232070927,
-0.0023109026,
-0.0436349772,
-0.0585415289,
-0.0445399769,
0.0500575006,
0.0853156447,
-0.0040251687,
-0.0167408139,
-0.0061649303,
0.0234408751,
-0.0349592566,
0.0152363563,
-0.0183372498,
-0.0152913025,
-0.0858575553,
-0.051480066,
0.0419198386,
-0.002599987,
-0.0415267758,
0.0318472944,
-0.0689915046,
-0.0652443767,
0.0183563419,
0.0792061538,
0.0243024118,
0.0751573667,
0.0061581521,
-0.0410156958,
0.0359983929,
0.04267212,
-0.0144657586,
0.0374926217,
0.0471464582,
-0.0646277517,
-0.005914019,
0.0232942142,
-0.0132681141,
0.0573393591,
0.0218224563,
0.0222867168,
-0.0147946393,
-0.0562483557,
0.0305921771,
-0.002202648,
0.0377797335,
-0.0111376112,
-0.0018031555,
-0.0515059084,
0.0347003564,
0.0040026284,
0.0243663266,
-0.0570060872,
0.0089043882,
0.0085194604,
0.0204337593,
-0.0274888966,
-0.0319909267,
-0.0049073421,
0.0174357425,
-0.0461708382,
0.0182553902,
-0.0105164433,
0.0351368375,
0.0286948942,
0.0023088923,
-0.0101091517,
0.0343343914,
-0.0115392813,
0.0163394045,
-0.0574247502,
0.025378745,
-0.0029180006,
0.0395991355,
-0.0372547843,
0.0336074047,
-0.0345869213,
-0.0312179122,
-0.0734933615,
0.0484374166,
0.0712092146,
-0.0448824093,
0.0684453622,
-0.027422972,
-0.0070105861,
-0.0167755317,
0.0139156496,
0.0091078961,
-0.0527860932,
0.0190450381,
0.0183088612,
-0.0227810238,
0.0241684597,
0.0793310702,
0.028778119,
0.0697580352,
0.0381323732,
0.0057210918,
-0.0326776057,
0.0105967522,
0.0485911183,
-0.0248799566,
-0.0187754128,
0.0055284034,
0.01060763,
-0.0822945014,
-0.0008945918,
0.0032239628,
-0.0291304793,
0.0133898323,
0.0805256441,
0.0623578578,
-0.033445362,
-0.020834744,
-0.0148575809,
0.0075728241,
0.0584376194,
-0.0108104274,
0.0094558839,
-7.029349689e-33,
-0.02350807,
0.0216360148,
0.0096731652,
-0.0017390393,
0.0214453023,
0.0151438024,
-0.0089637553,
-0.0012636365,
-0.0074112574,
-0.0060935733,
-0.0107514923,
-0.0020901493,
0.0343424529,
0.0078596324,
-0.0128547903,
-0.0079250727,
0.0916881189,
-0.0127353324,
-0.0150205502,
0.0247463156,
0.0170823485,
0.0540597364,
0.0856893361,
-0.027793536,
-0.0566459186,
0.0034204563,
-0.0155673632,
0.008574944,
0.0265388135,
0.0488777533,
-0.0253117196,
0.0179154277,
-0.0120427189,
-0.0487560965,
-0.0398312323,
-0.0047462881,
-0.1012562737,
-0.0369170718,
-0.0045848815,
0.0255781617,
-0.0242058076,
-0.0259584598,
0.0455496125,
-0.0247649886,
-0.01472631,
0.0148448413,
0.0381401479,
0.0043684747,
-0.0244891047,
-0.0228792932,
-0.0669197887,
0.0291710645,
-0.0034737948,
-0.0109567838,
0.0474040881,
0.0033389227,
-0.0068756063,
0.0062307124,
-0.0510924943,
0.007924662,
0.0555976517,
0.0621784069,
0.0098318541,
0.0184573308,
-0.0168628916,
0.0412096195,
0.0179575086,
0.0044645718,
0.0079958448,
0.0057934527,
0.0843394771,
0.0173263196,
0.0262672994,
-0.0186216552,
0.0465475917,
-0.0299150255,
-0.0787734017,
0.0090537583,
0.0221083015,
0.0289353207,
0.0074148579,
-0.0070192642,
-0.0204554126,
-0.0228708107,
-0.0446470529,
-0.0313965976,
-0.0429099314,
-0.0272145644,
0.0558586568,
0.0605408847,
-0.0015811125,
-0.0080507072,
0.027354788,
0.0001706697,
0.0015193964,
0.0435492992,
0.0057149949,
-0.0029029581,
-0.0162615776,
0.0424468666,
-0.0645367056,
-0.0732634142,
0.0166303348,
-0.0119089102,
0.0120338183,
-0.0117755439,
0.0246678907,
0.0546429977,
-0.0550597683,
0.0041249786,
-0.010843575,
0.0144531531,
0.0423108414,
0.0172047764,
0.0518947318,
-0.0006507782,
0.0059825862,
0.0511294566,
-0.0006891702,
-0.0266206358,
-0.0415445045,
-0.0233690292,
0.0247601196,
0.0984712839,
-0.029285375,
-0.0186889265,
-0.0320653915,
-0.0420053564,
-0.000139101,
-0.0776829571,
-0.0043783425,
0.0161420479,
2.845e-7,
-0.0012012455,
0.0322192125,
0.0010263126,
-0.0370782875,
-0.0277785454,
0.0109453211,
-0.0396225303,
0.0350646041,
0.0175189897,
0.0162445139,
0.0158552695,
0.0157703776,
0.0187428072,
0.0212807152,
-0.0913734064,
-0.0476421565,
-0.0813172683,
0.0393659323,
-0.0327129886,
-0.0215095207,
0.0207585357,
0.1285855174,
0.0249831937,
-0.0084149325,
0.0019238215,
-0.0342625566,
0.0472078025,
-0.0102777444,
0.003851624,
0.0273715351,
0.0251684468,
0.0194894969,
-0.0322754867,
0.0049173185,
-0.0331012011,
0.0295930263,
-0.0004165019,
0.0541454367,
-0.0266576502,
-0.0180509519,
0.0594183467,
0.0302837398,
-0.036497429,
-0.0764238462,
0.0601953492,
-0.0364882201,
0.0126443561,
-0.0217574872,
-0.0331512876,
-0.0166350305,
0.0088619245,
-0.0340729468,
-0.0154684279,
0.0481817275,
0.0417769477,
-0.011761643,
-0.0113357008,
-0.1029513776,
-0.0055984394,
0.0282711815,
-0.0252053291,
-0.0319395252,
-0.064377442,
-0.0125495652,
0.0253473148,
-0.0517803729,
0.0235245079,
2.887790365e-34,
0.0575767048,
-0.0288286209,
0.0116500985,
0.0438938551,
-0.006261128,
-0.0110431639,
0.0236197282,
0.0056399801,
-0.0053907698,
-0.0994168893,
-0.0221069288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07345v1 | Investigating the Effect of Language Models in Sequence Discriminative Training for Neural Transducers | 2023-10-11T09:53:17 | 2023-10-11T09:53:17 | Zijian Yang, Wei Zhou, Ralf Schlüter, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this work, we investigate the effect of language models (LMs) with
different context lengths and label units (phoneme vs. word) used in sequence
discriminative training for phoneme-based neural transducers. Both lattice-free
and N-best-list approaches are examined. For lattice-free methods with
phoneme-level LMs, we propose a method to approximate the context history to
employ LMs with full-context dependency. This approximation can be extended to
arbitrary context length and enables the usage of word-level LMs in
lattice-free methods. Moreover, a systematic comparison is conducted across
lattice-free and N-best-list-based methods. Experimental results on Librispeech
show that using the word-level LM in training outperforms the phoneme-level LM.
Besides, we find that the context size of the LM used for probability
computation has a limited effect on performance. Moreover, our results reveal
the pivotal importance of the hypothesis space quality in sequence
discriminative training. | [
0.0010685332,
0.0580848418,
0.0033693174,
0.0267205685,
-0.0368663892,
0.0017052025,
0.0525398366,
-0.0304054953,
-0.0306566209,
-0.0269434024,
-0.0380638354,
-0.0865201727,
0.0672050118,
-0.0500764884,
0.0340590589,
-0.039909184,
0.0005074653,
-0.0586667843,
0.0039616502,
0.0073819729,
-0.0392024778,
-0.0377108455,
-0.0535383224,
0.05074808,
0.0059475098,
0.0322849303,
0.0227895044,
-0.0277361181,
0.018457856,
-0.0418497138,
-0.0375834666,
0.047636494,
0.0102795688,
0.0383331217,
0.0000017966,
-0.0331858024,
0.0086282222,
-0.0016471138,
-0.0100486549,
-0.0013834742,
0.0080796741,
-0.0293909386,
-0.0433341525,
0.0131159099,
0.0022265548,
-0.0334349275,
0.0835329518,
-0.0287801586,
-0.0301175378,
0.0754099935,
-0.0041134693,
-0.0300556123,
0.0488033295,
-0.0106507521,
0.0136409998,
-0.0643440709,
0.0057231612,
-0.0102168303,
0.0246643499,
-0.025132291,
-0.0259226896,
0.0566861518,
-0.0194500275,
0.0196897034,
0.0082985107,
0.0249265525,
0.00446461,
-0.0305471979,
-0.0009449872,
0.0389911011,
-0.0179840606,
-0.0437393188,
-0.0203408562,
0.033290647,
-0.0284515098,
-0.0073114387,
-0.0156835523,
0.0480221659,
-0.0239906069,
0.0272458661,
0.0203097016,
0.0019639879,
0.041093491,
-0.0176269896,
-0.039568767,
0.0754738003,
0.0221761465,
-0.0371824875,
-0.0176354311,
0.0030234642,
0.0321355462,
0.0114724813,
0.0605914444,
0.0254904609,
0.0257069264,
0.0246397369,
0.0173351914,
-0.0431651212,
-0.0137821585,
-0.0740752369,
0.0084280577,
0.0470750891,
-0.0349694788,
-0.0233862866,
-0.0475866273,
0.0681833923,
0.0110690985,
0.0112162,
-0.0495492555,
-0.0167064294,
-0.0158615988,
-0.0000997328,
-0.004406427,
-0.010700983,
0.001061082,
-0.0124658654,
-0.0632494763,
0.0048757056,
0.0526516214,
-0.0359529518,
-0.0158965401,
-0.0616648793,
-0.0477387831,
0.0169854984,
0.0168090351,
-0.0024284581,
0.0277263969,
0.0455327295,
-0.0225287024,
-0.1050442979,
-0.0397588685,
0.0006737155,
0.0175225213,
-0.0366236158,
0.0103909876,
0.0467326716,
0.0042357664,
-0.0829814225,
-0.0821043923,
0.0764605179,
-0.0462715998,
-0.0156846773,
0.005442787,
-0.0716872811,
0.0137527036,
-0.0156234838,
0.0154728973,
-0.0274598859,
0.0135256518,
-0.0209474694,
0.0218593925,
0.0898781642,
0.0165614542,
-0.0025086745,
0.0488152094,
-0.0054991557,
0.0547066368,
0.0503480248,
0.0727449134,
-0.018938832,
0.0151816206,
-0.0488453098,
0.0303594191,
0.0606549606,
0.0005472229,
-0.0135204848,
-0.0469807759,
-0.0334008373,
0.060674537,
0.0146773504,
0.0157479309,
0.0307354275,
-0.0375314578,
-0.0401276015,
0.0422128066,
0.0734115243,
0.0723392889,
-0.0073669069,
0.0307685044,
-0.0683953762,
0.0052783173,
0.0023977088,
0.0146746458,
-0.0196155943,
-0.0250150394,
0.0379547514,
0.0118899671,
0.0270290319,
-0.0278420001,
0.0191996004,
-0.0433162451,
-0.0282637365,
0.0032501004,
-0.019980995,
0.0608398616,
0.0029998301,
-0.0509898663,
0.0620491169,
0.0215436928,
-0.032104034,
0.0086765112,
-0.0073028565,
-0.0041717752,
0.038970314,
0.0176264737,
-0.0186796058,
-0.028873438,
-0.0140786115,
-0.0265220385,
0.0584589615,
0.0312217791,
-0.0026559844,
0.0257382914,
-0.0626440272,
0.0000744322,
0.0936066881,
0.0078598699,
0.044976484,
0.0180378482,
0.0441056378,
0.0230676401,
-0.0669868216,
-0.0187031981,
0.0215463713,
-0.019874325,
-0.0794507414,
-0.0015673416,
0.0155392578,
0.0717891231,
0.0117707206,
-0.0078484407,
0.0245007779,
0.036043752,
-0.0345108435,
0.0198742673,
-0.0052017681,
-0.0855685696,
-0.0489844084,
0.0583569892,
0.0055472343,
0.0389394537,
0.0027131373,
0.0414500237,
-0.0320650227,
0.0125160115,
-0.0450615957,
0.0549932495,
-0.0490970649,
0.0701710731,
0.0107577955,
0.0063595599,
-0.0201850086,
0.0026772697,
0.0008886926,
0.0194052495,
0.0153750535,
0.0154987518,
0.0184251536,
-0.0719953924,
-0.0004250827,
0.0672260523,
-0.019393025,
0.0044601914,
-0.0010580372,
-0.0065452899,
-0.0039197411,
-0.0122279823,
-0.0428830832,
-0.0550076142,
-0.0142032271,
0.0810666457,
-0.0524329767,
0.0082309619,
-0.0028803675,
-0.0068942732,
-0.0255906563,
-0.0002963412,
-0.0334498435,
0.0202978328,
0.0024313582,
0.0250314344,
-0.0362389907,
-0.0543668866,
-0.0357139409,
-0.0041872053,
0.0719590187,
-0.0044906726,
-0.0585286245,
-0.0292736702,
0.0216578729,
0.0086840363,
0.049859222,
-0.0053200754,
-0.0224548168,
0.017399855,
-0.0340132415,
0.021896014,
0.0134694949,
0.0003084298,
-0.0502497405,
0.0132802324,
-0.0406011306,
-0.0292602405,
-0.0017803761,
-0.0215834621,
0.0135414684,
-0.052786395,
-0.0318585522,
-0.0418560654,
0.0731404126,
-0.0028673692,
0.0144512597,
-0.065590173,
-0.0419046432,
-0.0105483178,
-0.0070213312,
0.0105306339,
-0.0171138328,
-0.0549077094,
0.0156642683,
-0.0024388956,
-0.0371581353,
0.0567447767,
-0.1058906913,
-0.0100243287,
-0.0641934052,
-0.0357495137,
-0.0422755331,
0.0490150154,
0.01946803,
-0.0077454797,
0.0146093471,
-0.052454561,
0.0050867484,
0.0224445704,
0.0081482483,
-0.0328017659,
0.0301176365,
-0.0627821237,
0.0258312523,
-0.0192447379,
-0.0154864704,
-0.0261603482,
0.030530598,
-0.0297760982,
0.0131061431,
0.0059725638,
-0.0147881377,
0.0009721724,
0.112390846,
0.0220311321,
0.0870434195,
0.035499502,
0.0407970622,
-0.0115984352,
0.0578846596,
0.0029619201,
-0.0286515821,
0.0044900863,
0.0193993766,
0.0166730173,
-0.0337416343,
0.0623528175,
0.0393031053,
-0.0208865795,
0.0115417261,
0.0588412769,
0.000871897,
-0.0266088415,
0.0375805795,
0.006529009,
-0.0389579907,
-0.0195251144,
0.0936951339,
0.0130601572,
0.0007865985,
0.0060493154,
0.0319031291,
-0.001328906,
-0.0269283522,
-0.030300688,
-0.0050146463,
-0.009701496,
0.0290114041,
0.0194866192,
0.0155863734,
0.0028651366,
-0.0166313816,
-0.0960410088,
-0.0205353815,
0.0543581434,
-0.0778299719,
-0.0380073898,
-0.0761459321,
0.0128684761,
-0.0167063233,
-0.0000803887,
0.0560164861,
-0.032486666,
-0.0185706206,
0.0530031174,
-0.0592479035,
-0.0895616785,
-0.0194954108,
-0.0402908139,
0.0418566391,
0.0887735039,
-0.0076488773,
-0.0281116869,
-0.03922287,
0.0511997752,
-0.022655176,
0.0025256905,
-0.0183784589,
-0.0005450798,
0.0080021154,
-0.0267689209,
0.0525265075,
0.0164167341,
-0.015200438,
-0.0080488008,
-0.0076323175,
0.0577920899,
0.0117263487,
0.0100163277,
0.0171598252,
0.0226916261,
0.0024792047,
0.0454430655,
0.0219946299,
-0.0465042815,
0.0008472002,
0.0070289415,
0.0220028386,
-0.0092895757,
0.012465613,
-0.0188059527,
-0.0062067844,
-0.0478698462,
-0.0588288084,
-0.061102964,
-0.0212577339,
0.0510160364,
0.034626428,
0.0264874659,
0.0135942306,
0.0228036046,
0.0106316218,
0.0106934374,
0.0077721397,
0.0499447584,
-0.0577335693,
0.0200706068,
0.0377490334,
-0.0316319987,
0.001784198,
0.0235098004,
-0.0714584365,
-0.0592621863,
-0.0170093346,
-0.0058939741,
0.025270775,
0.029620897,
0.0013042104,
-0.0194080546,
0.0371438339,
0.0223491285,
-0.0185457151,
0.0077454764,
0.0364369228,
-0.0300115459,
-0.0164151788,
-0.0075063966,
-0.0264205672,
0.0086086914,
0.0139031559,
0.0585671365,
-0.0336634107,
-0.087954618,
-0.0021117381,
-0.009572709,
0.0712303668,
0.0163645931,
0.0050183907,
-0.0311807636,
0.0493300445,
-0.0007462882,
0.0718127638,
0.0135491043,
-0.0127036422,
0.0446227044,
0.0355851427,
-0.0228056535,
-0.039528884,
0.0012145878,
0.0129036112,
0.0189620759,
0.06396503,
0.0220187716,
0.0208504237,
-0.0007319449,
-0.0263908133,
-0.0216836464,
0.0442281589,
-0.0078152614,
0.0406048894,
-0.0136552714,
0.0203447808,
-0.0072320024,
-0.0061075296,
0.0142794242,
-0.0168876573,
-0.0269016512,
0.0221212544,
-0.0491403192,
0.0142965158,
0.047719311,
-0.0230760407,
0.0302617829,
-0.0383886211,
-0.0070603583,
-0.0511525609,
-0.0229393747,
-0.0095719378,
0.042247802,
0.0246029086,
0.0193130039,
0.0004938391,
-0.0065182,
0.0747423247,
0.0552150533,
0.0442229174,
-0.0239342432,
-0.0067302315,
-0.0255438592,
-0.0436782092,
-0.038164828,
0.0175950248,
-0.0455681682,
0.0049885898,
-0.0563767701,
-0.0437110141,
0.0692412406,
-0.0271071009,
0.0487844646,
-0.0057912995,
0.0053552147,
0.0309347697,
-0.0196557287,
0.0378866754,
-0.0078517729,
-0.0297751725,
0.0294471644,
-0.029252287,
-0.0496803112,
-5.686883712e-33,
-0.0349987112,
-0.0007182776,
0.0324800462,
0.0005386753,
-0.0176485777,
-0.0000899204,
-0.0174624622,
0.0035414267,
-0.0121837184,
-0.0404890515,
0.0022104697,
-0.0187815428,
0.0349209495,
0.0296055209,
-0.0371565893,
0.0156112434,
0.0287173837,
0.0018924377,
0.0075194398,
-0.0471283868,
0.0046234033,
0.0603298731,
0.0581899472,
-0.0307035148,
0.0282395147,
0.0116242906,
0.0405500755,
-0.0211263485,
0.0032951336,
0.0463072024,
-0.0253052916,
0.0211497378,
-0.0079651941,
-0.0736786947,
0.0088716727,
0.0472499952,
-0.0941101834,
0.0127753522,
0.0334076546,
0.0473357737,
0.0420083702,
-0.0407720655,
0.0096476013,
-0.0322097018,
-0.0482813716,
0.0263885614,
0.0004631429,
-0.0899636373,
-0.046162717,
-0.0532776639,
-0.0275140423,
0.0626331642,
-0.0014913416,
-0.003483332,
0.0839482546,
0.0371763185,
-0.0371993147,
-0.0325656645,
-0.0570500121,
0.050330203,
0.0645586401,
0.063261874,
0.0192921236,
0.0630833581,
0.0036892213,
-0.0302198045,
0.0673144087,
-0.0708204955,
0.0349173434,
-0.0085714757,
0.0404451974,
-0.022533061,
0.0599689148,
0.0030792931,
0.0168364979,
-0.0066436292,
-0.0687260032,
-0.013165473,
0.0047835493,
-0.0313562863,
0.0257516485,
0.0121528003,
-0.0526043363,
-0.0135736689,
-0.0367541052,
-0.0398605615,
-0.0144723691,
-0.0015496474,
0.0253991224,
-0.0048259017,
0.0080477465,
-0.0057617142,
0.0626418442,
-0.0005881038,
-0.0262730438,
0.0087173488,
0.0176084433,
-0.0084201684,
-0.0158975329,
0.023038663,
-0.0849152356,
-0.0078638298,
0.0287248734,
0.0387979485,
0.0038412805,
-0.0164156742,
0.0429418683,
0.0338507034,
-0.0492880531,
-0.0100457501,
-0.05905452,
-0.0176721103,
0.0081093702,
0.0623047687,
0.0449322909,
-0.0360781699,
0.0267604012,
0.0443043299,
0.0131051112,
-0.0300618205,
0.0227598529,
0.0312695689,
-0.0118948584,
0.0371814258,
-0.0100308256,
-0.0048296852,
0.0146170892,
0.0504041649,
0.0166518968,
-0.0074787708,
0.0042414856,
0.0583161861,
2.633e-7,
0.0062705595,
-0.0168146249,
0.0596641153,
-0.017334545,
0.040134348,
-0.0026435668,
-0.0471052341,
-0.0076221949,
0.0294312518,
0.0199763365,
0.0378924794,
-0.0145499222,
0.0780449733,
0.0174707621,
-0.0628654361,
-0.0399941877,
-0.0629843846,
0.0450612605,
-0.0475754552,
0.0012307687,
-0.0131031005,
0.0762159079,
-0.019319497,
-0.0429443941,
-0.003737675,
-0.0562974885,
0.0454611257,
-0.0313703716,
0.0193805248,
0.0130146239,
0.0124788852,
0.0187291875,
-0.0057182317,
0.0082328562,
-0.0145617379,
0.029241398,
0.0365577117,
0.0229492895,
-0.0178018734,
-0.0581793748,
0.0317865424,
0.0051800213,
-0.0449810363,
-0.0240709316,
0.0255941786,
0.0205564871,
0.0054393667,
0.0124515044,
-0.0105671557,
0.0098950984,
0.0057101296,
-0.0275248773,
0.0243293233,
-0.0005525389,
0.0106891422,
0.0063831285,
-0.0403561033,
-0.0300411433,
-0.0165023021,
0.0111562526,
-0.0152452625,
-0.031204205,
-0.0385304764,
0.0032601147,
0.0139396675,
-0.0165393874,
-0.0036431698,
2.126117321e-34,
-0.0012144474,
-0.0388475806,
0.0119024366,
0.022644477,
0.0004174848,
-0.0247887578,
-0.0197793245,
0.0128333671,
0.0038061121,
-0.0642056912,
-0.0356608815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07343v1 | How Do Large Language Models Capture the Ever-changing World Knowledge? A Review of Recent Advances | 2023-10-11T09:46:32 | 2023-10-11T09:46:32 | Zihan Zhang, Meng Fang, Ling Chen, Mohammad-Reza Namazi-Rad, Jun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) are impressive in solving various
tasks, they can quickly be outdated after deployment. Maintaining their
up-to-date status is a pressing concern in the current era. This paper provides
a comprehensive review of recent advances in aligning LLMs with the
ever-changing world knowledge without re-training from scratch. We categorize
research works systemically and provide in-depth comparisons and discussion. We
also discuss existing challenges and highlight future directions to facilitate
research in this field. We release the paper list at
https://github.com/hyintell/awesome-refreshing-llms | [
0.0370901674,
0.0664763749,
-0.0429853648,
0.0193682779,
-0.0372739099,
-0.01858644,
-0.0420369245,
0.0267169327,
0.0147950081,
-0.0824285075,
-0.0281814542,
-0.041345913,
0.0198027268,
0.0338125527,
0.0417714342,
-0.0370807052,
0.0513773598,
-0.070955947,
-0.0386582091,
-0.0096285716,
-0.0094665373,
0.0349175669,
0.0196412075,
0.0386804231,
0.0277594328,
-0.0105437078,
-0.0125772571,
-0.0036694587,
0.0058534252,
-0.0082755964,
-0.020859547,
0.005139166,
0.0407701023,
0.0674803182,
0.0000018536,
-0.0536052175,
0.0001398421,
-0.008390517,
-0.0319270119,
0.034747798,
0.0330906399,
-0.0474056341,
-0.0283916593,
0.0210689791,
-0.0441316441,
-0.0180805959,
0.0257419012,
-0.0141391549,
0.0394576713,
0.058182776,
0.0152348317,
-0.006121573,
0.0428121835,
-0.0257179532,
-0.0206436031,
-0.0465002134,
0.0544009283,
0.0134764276,
0.028414011,
0.0165203083,
-0.001860645,
0.0437016487,
-0.0209086221,
-0.0394810811,
-0.0141615104,
0.0421151631,
-0.0233395677,
0.043089211,
-0.0163737684,
0.0335286744,
-0.0084406743,
-0.0390617885,
-0.0003287034,
0.0002555838,
-0.033491049,
-0.0114833843,
-0.0551342629,
0.0110728517,
0.0191480163,
0.0364075191,
0.023166921,
-0.0514779463,
0.0576968528,
0.0325956009,
-0.0305385347,
0.0754579529,
0.0316239484,
-0.0164536405,
-0.0337570272,
-0.0235292949,
-0.0097191539,
-0.0905926973,
-0.0077275271,
0.0743775219,
-0.0216079038,
0.0343270376,
-0.0288865119,
0.0022583713,
0.0223530605,
-0.0582771599,
0.0283029843,
0.0216145106,
-0.0104313027,
0.0682327747,
-0.019416932,
0.0633968264,
-0.0313994437,
-0.035516046,
-0.0269897524,
-0.0289466903,
-0.0636423677,
-0.0153993759,
-0.0230472181,
0.0353003778,
-0.0219649039,
-0.008551456,
0.0121795936,
0.0671713799,
0.0252547413,
0.0455285944,
-0.0019641581,
-0.0340127349,
-0.0267068502,
-0.017914189,
-0.0208743177,
0.0544779114,
0.0241102204,
-0.0115688378,
-0.0335213654,
-0.0343723744,
0.0391915105,
0.008967923,
-0.024993198,
0.0060594659,
-0.0105909482,
0.0876110122,
0.0262191631,
0.001994008,
-0.0559784994,
-0.0021812823,
-0.0273053609,
-0.0560184009,
-0.0342802294,
-0.0681239963,
-0.0014568329,
0.0158804227,
0.015746098,
-0.0582643226,
-0.0038276711,
-0.0244611502,
-0.0395199321,
0.0391613618,
-0.0387373678,
0.0234840121,
0.0335303508,
-0.0042610099,
0.0348114148,
0.1005760804,
0.0120452335,
-0.0096792653,
0.0455866829,
0.0006282697,
-0.0125636691,
0.0544828139,
-0.023272641,
0.0433851443,
-0.0446424298,
0.019085899,
0.034177959,
0.0290760454,
-0.0083693452,
0.049518086,
0.008057287,
0.006385969,
0.0669239238,
0.001801356,
0.0038043971,
0.0257016346,
0.0400028229,
0.0126671009,
0.0129123116,
-0.0035751867,
-0.0492536463,
0.0033816348,
-0.0403790511,
0.0077311229,
-0.0250048712,
0.0453650132,
-0.0430073179,
-0.0153246922,
-0.0327891372,
-0.0262209885,
-0.0314775184,
0.0063596717,
0.0733011812,
-0.0153061599,
0.0033623613,
0.0654565468,
0.0399633236,
-0.0208767168,
0.035046421,
-0.0466558672,
0.0173901394,
0.0786978826,
0.0648237616,
-0.0425999016,
-0.0490269996,
0.0097334227,
-0.005352736,
0.0060233851,
0.0344650783,
-0.0327884965,
0.0033477545,
-0.027393125,
-0.0279186126,
-0.0176390316,
-0.0006480473,
0.0137611199,
0.0348745696,
0.0153383361,
0.009310822,
-0.0588655584,
-0.034703847,
0.0315833427,
-0.0472202152,
0.0282809008,
-0.0078823892,
-0.0170232821,
0.0220931713,
0.0328634791,
-0.017281184,
-0.0136716543,
0.0358913317,
-0.0457852222,
-0.0044557657,
0.0210941974,
-0.0006714664,
-0.001573012,
0.0930006504,
0.0099935858,
-0.00097085,
0.0156347249,
-0.0461406708,
-0.0325745642,
0.0212965533,
-0.017754348,
0.0732469782,
-0.0298421197,
0.0445833653,
-0.0335004218,
-0.0102825137,
-0.0434049331,
0.0467178784,
0.0013553274,
-0.022786079,
0.0304245539,
-0.0176909715,
0.0232614446,
0.0046200352,
-0.0773036256,
0.0539122634,
0.019813858,
0.022147242,
0.0345260762,
0.0039042963,
-0.0188002028,
-0.0436250642,
-0.0821513683,
-0.0140485866,
-0.010381829,
0.0140441647,
0.0291094482,
0.0156145236,
-0.0169737451,
-0.0006277295,
-0.0221183505,
0.0144802621,
0.0030188102,
0.0256323833,
0.0256027505,
0.0138279563,
-0.0192022659,
-0.0473388769,
-0.0060467008,
0.0031175518,
0.0463476665,
-0.0320098028,
-0.0366399623,
-0.0970131755,
0.0176828373,
-0.0654910505,
0.0659486577,
-0.0379278809,
-0.0215955209,
-0.0149123054,
-0.0177303012,
0.0478190221,
0.0135687692,
-0.0044712699,
-0.0018160032,
0.0968413576,
-0.0107648484,
-0.0572780706,
-0.0200442038,
-0.0060943658,
-0.0599602945,
-0.0759590939,
-0.0160182267,
0.0062546399,
0.0351238474,
-0.0161788091,
-0.0350103155,
-0.0290832035,
-0.0191332288,
-0.0687736347,
-0.0274599679,
-0.0284362473,
-0.0212704577,
-0.0231582262,
0.0335621573,
-0.0079993075,
-0.0584668517,
0.0445995927,
-0.0392989069,
0.014588139,
-0.0442604311,
-0.0383867435,
-0.0531231128,
0.0659965277,
-0.0135799572,
0.0274408106,
0.0111693768,
-0.033598993,
-0.0536212511,
-0.0453155562,
-0.0156043647,
-0.0288991835,
0.0731458813,
-0.0781605244,
0.0500354283,
-0.0000344438,
-0.0423374064,
-0.0394731946,
-0.0159703605,
-0.049618721,
0.0239354502,
-0.009085536,
-0.0274920147,
-0.0215590857,
0.0349708833,
0.0333917923,
0.0193106402,
0.0080093369,
-0.0122325169,
-0.0358515494,
0.007709946,
0.0625304878,
-0.0004774247,
0.0021664526,
0.0052868123,
0.0110676652,
0.0569912232,
0.052965045,
-0.003963416,
-0.0508786291,
-0.0259136241,
0.0606389642,
-0.0594845526,
-0.0304787271,
0.0101044476,
0.0071246517,
-0.041741319,
0.0253691152,
0.1215237454,
0.0366566777,
-0.0334391631,
0.0218867157,
-0.0075544412,
0.0178874806,
0.0338553488,
0.0405287109,
-0.076122731,
-0.0057314625,
0.0144417016,
-0.0064009721,
0.0231515989,
-0.0257001668,
-0.0140160816,
-0.093218118,
0.0070490004,
0.0288067032,
-0.0152996229,
-0.025329411,
-0.0130219162,
0.0107779792,
0.015097647,
0.0084143681,
0.0080303987,
-0.021467261,
-0.0242803935,
0.0305126645,
-0.0694801435,
-0.0506607704,
0.0191270225,
-0.0367447361,
0.0675602555,
0.0655830577,
0.0412362516,
0.0024317529,
0.0007498138,
0.0192360114,
0.0120370062,
0.0323967226,
-0.013089858,
-0.0009432781,
-0.0108289514,
-0.0123344287,
0.0316063911,
-0.0235743951,
-0.041260954,
-0.0122517413,
0.0231879093,
0.0798501074,
-0.0332718231,
0.0120967338,
-0.0211164877,
-0.0282546133,
0.0012134599,
0.0624725558,
0.00254851,
-0.0247237682,
0.0061037946,
-0.0280827302,
-0.0115299597,
0.0115569122,
-0.0252055693,
0.0163628794,
-0.028432386,
-0.0085777128,
-0.0548962951,
0.0049633817,
0.0477345623,
0.0158829279,
0.042166736,
0.040072456,
0.0400837623,
-0.033864364,
-0.0347105637,
-0.0219540931,
-0.0645562038,
0.0264384504,
-0.0263855066,
-0.0235969052,
0.0523366667,
-0.0092684943,
0.005900146,
0.0230298806,
-0.1107874662,
-0.0814590082,
-0.0024742249,
0.016438989,
0.0243063346,
0.0287567005,
-0.0238991994,
-0.0471864752,
0.0481003858,
0.0202069115,
-0.0255259331,
0.0548800677,
0.0046125459,
0.0168075208,
0.0074992436,
0.0630277097,
-0.0674406588,
-0.0360647179,
0.0116942301,
0.0293851551,
-0.0228202324,
-0.0461016037,
0.0065124868,
0.010520177,
0.0059095966,
-0.0452490337,
-0.0253280979,
-0.0005904192,
0.012819767,
-0.0055994401,
-0.0313196294,
-0.0146696726,
0.0047780015,
0.0100736879,
0.0055200406,
0.0070035565,
0.0463078506,
0.0008339133,
0.0684475452,
-0.0342206657,
-0.0080724349,
-0.0041541136,
0.0180721451,
0.0733575821,
0.0248053893,
-0.0150085595,
0.0116841448,
-0.0150495693,
0.0104094949,
-0.017365912,
0.015035606,
0.0117352977,
-0.0376302525,
-0.0348979384,
0.0310868341,
-0.0508112758,
-0.0831473619,
0.0103627304,
0.0782218501,
0.1044429019,
0.0319881327,
0.0633014739,
-0.0338284783,
-0.01096527,
-0.0432227552,
0.0142811444,
0.0064272876,
-0.0296714716,
0.0197468791,
0.0100278025,
-0.0402480215,
0.0569961146,
0.080936268,
0.000661295,
0.0532957129,
0.0322929919,
-0.0049151569,
-0.0070119007,
-0.0084765572,
0.0319625214,
0.0220065378,
-0.0438352451,
0.002964197,
-0.0637665614,
-0.0455023497,
0.0315822251,
0.0147231985,
-0.0480808429,
-0.0193741657,
0.0139310351,
0.0689911991,
0.0197890066,
0.004692201,
-0.0530319959,
0.0104955351,
-0.0266783498,
-0.0113836909,
0.0143554974,
-5.962251345e-33,
-0.0245882981,
0.0140402839,
0.0363758169,
-0.0113983937,
-0.0451357178,
0.0257465839,
-0.0185759272,
-0.0061185891,
-0.0364101827,
-0.0089455061,
-0.0013722909,
0.0030963481,
0.0005335321,
0.004505937,
0.0294755045,
-0.0028755066,
0.0458740816,
0.0087678963,
-0.0049886052,
0.0472393148,
0.0573980212,
0.0171744749,
0.0929166004,
-0.0540335625,
0.0240930282,
0.0159014631,
0.0078662578,
0.0372677222,
0.0287374761,
0.0591490231,
-0.034599822,
0.0772419348,
0.0165302884,
-0.0192034859,
-0.0523066558,
-0.0533867441,
-0.0342602395,
-0.0101302378,
0.0493088327,
0.010170199,
0.0267794821,
-0.013544091,
0.0116876531,
-0.0036167789,
0.009365879,
0.026218513,
0.0291005652,
-0.0239008442,
-0.0347994752,
0.0130459517,
-0.0383364372,
0.0325601175,
-0.0019453742,
0.0124783712,
-0.0112599628,
-0.0175513271,
0.0286209024,
0.013956612,
-0.0760153607,
0.0386255458,
0.0571414232,
0.0759966224,
0.0880490616,
0.0043738093,
0.002443494,
0.0537170507,
-0.0117820296,
-0.0033368906,
-0.0014118287,
-0.0238305591,
0.0311474241,
0.0165584404,
-0.0002903432,
0.0307107419,
-0.0428662971,
-0.0125047062,
-0.043296501,
-0.0003689232,
0.0444785915,
0.0568170175,
0.029990362,
0.0412256569,
-0.0137240458,
-0.0286686346,
-0.0350191221,
0.0385083444,
-0.0170737542,
-0.018391598,
-0.0019047935,
-0.0096991817,
-0.006088817,
0.0189775135,
0.0352966227,
-0.0744017586,
-0.0646577477,
0.0101208258,
-0.0097390898,
0.0304343123,
0.005822367,
0.0589573793,
-0.0596537441,
-0.033759281,
-0.0106671108,
-0.0019678324,
-0.0232013818,
-0.0148883145,
-0.0251054149,
0.0510830097,
-0.0460290611,
0.0216214564,
-0.045619607,
-0.0036937918,
-0.0063507501,
-0.009398656,
0.0035297219,
0.0047877738,
0.0165576749,
0.0284981057,
0.0362725072,
-0.0398217291,
0.014711163,
0.0190657787,
0.0279874057,
0.0190747902,
-0.0056875735,
0.0087068407,
-0.0530701242,
0.0224781707,
0.0396143645,
-0.0122475382,
-0.005046194,
0.0131658241,
2.635e-7,
0.0541504323,
0.0406085625,
0.0244972669,
-0.0043899608,
0.043652311,
0.0189947393,
-0.0513179637,
0.0289109647,
-0.0028629776,
0.0144938156,
-0.010042863,
0.0334864333,
0.0236156601,
0.0229853652,
-0.0974261388,
0.0113613373,
-0.0621623211,
-0.034812402,
-0.0900552794,
-0.0063098352,
0.0019587204,
0.0882465988,
0.0278276596,
0.0047920449,
-0.0269091222,
-0.0675030872,
0.0509895571,
-0.0425673835,
-0.011503038,
0.0423079208,
0.0239322651,
0.0311489329,
0.0012688984,
-0.0027823541,
-0.029414326,
0.0153508065,
-0.0121223405,
0.0318609066,
-0.0079539279,
0.0046372185,
-0.0098733604,
-0.0217198357,
-0.0209697168,
-0.0809945911,
0.0825417265,
-0.0305639748,
-0.0300257728,
-0.0449916944,
-0.0012532556,
-0.0096450541,
-0.0375861377,
-0.0054604481,
-0.0274903551,
0.0170415267,
0.0154879494,
0.003995555,
-0.046455238,
-0.0965701044,
-0.0108556198,
-0.012042379,
-0.0304840356,
-0.0714096725,
-0.0322053581,
-0.012415546,
0.0198499449,
-0.0589377135,
0.0337710269,
2.314232692e-34,
0.0234793089,
0.0218380038,
-0.016086109,
0.0392210521,
0.0124409301,
-0.0010766102,
-0.0372845791,
0.0173919518,
-0.0072481097,
-0.0597828887,
-0.010701661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07328v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07328v2 | An Empirical Study of Instruction-tuning Large Language Models in Chinese | 2023-10-11T09:18:09 | 2023-10-20T08:02:09 | Qingyi Si, Tong Wang, Zheng Lin, Xu Zhang, Yanan Cao, Weiping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The success of ChatGPT validates the potential of large language models
(LLMs) in artificial general intelligence (AGI). Subsequently, the release of
LLMs has sparked the open-source community's interest in instruction-tuning,
which is deemed to accelerate ChatGPT's replication process. However, research
on instruction-tuning LLMs in Chinese, the world's most spoken language, is
still in its early stages. Therefore, this paper makes an in-depth empirical
study of instruction-tuning LLMs in Chinese, which can serve as a cookbook that
provides valuable findings for effectively customizing LLMs that can better
respond to Chinese instructions. Specifically, we systematically explore the
impact of LLM bases, parameter-efficient methods, instruction data types, which
are the three most important elements for instruction-tuning. Besides, we also
conduct experiment to study the impact of other factors, e.g., chain-of-thought
data and human-value alignment. We hope that this empirical study can make a
modest contribution to the open Chinese version of ChatGPT. This paper will
release a powerful Chinese LLMs that is comparable to ChatGLM. The code and
data are available at https://github.com/PhoebusSi/Alpaca-CoT. | [
0.045741301,
0.030768387,
-0.0173497833,
0.0400347747,
-0.0227393061,
0.017675411,
-0.0113765057,
-0.0146758594,
0.0233097468,
-0.0217017047,
-0.0754081607,
-0.0538947769,
0.0164009295,
-0.0100687416,
0.0033736208,
-0.0463564694,
0.0619883314,
-0.0231247358,
-0.0094608637,
-0.0090786647,
0.0114032347,
0.0058529717,
0.0080323713,
0.0380542204,
0.0272400826,
-0.0193156302,
-0.0257444307,
0.0350102112,
0.0235791616,
-0.0162656959,
0.0018021452,
0.0277027208,
0.005114798,
0.0047950931,
0.0000022088,
-0.0513131358,
-0.0040547196,
-0.0185156874,
-0.0186973307,
0.0864836574,
0.0344673507,
0.0035433581,
-0.0372119993,
0.0345602036,
-0.0260498747,
-0.0058061788,
0.0328236297,
0.0421217121,
0.051845707,
0.1045405343,
0.0190728512,
-0.0342903584,
0.0268495027,
-0.0110883089,
0.0012015648,
-0.0603209324,
0.0135982716,
0.0502861813,
0.0193824656,
0.0266912859,
-0.0454375744,
0.0068090204,
0.0095826099,
0.0317431726,
-0.0498932078,
0.0099243438,
-0.0330354534,
0.0057868273,
-0.0434407443,
0.0662486926,
-0.0092747537,
-0.0096602766,
-0.0231836047,
0.0040589622,
0.0200745407,
-0.0052329712,
-0.0379870981,
0.0417034775,
-0.0070522903,
0.0190922804,
0.0515913032,
-0.0423380919,
0.008456138,
0.0120688481,
-0.0304502808,
0.063352406,
-0.0024148042,
-0.0380297974,
-0.0103092389,
-0.0271005202,
-0.0387579054,
-0.0424093269,
-0.0217547119,
0.053481143,
-0.0368537493,
0.0266572814,
-0.0171621908,
0.0425914824,
0.0039521581,
-0.059107434,
0.0646283627,
0.0746431202,
-0.00359008,
0.0295623019,
-0.0008051043,
0.0913890302,
0.0062890979,
0.0101581831,
-0.0830071568,
-0.0007273795,
-0.0637648925,
-0.0044891457,
-0.0619989671,
0.0383113995,
-0.0019800945,
-0.0279417988,
-0.0516389906,
0.0423541367,
-0.0098555507,
0.0131499805,
0.0102333548,
-0.0439646915,
-0.0342800282,
-0.0007350282,
-0.0181795135,
0.0326462165,
-0.0385930873,
0.0130335223,
-0.0335436799,
-0.0462249629,
0.0210906435,
0.0095024938,
-0.0120866569,
-0.0001779223,
0.0372751504,
0.0798466951,
-0.0099036368,
-0.0032936165,
-0.0511691608,
0.0109969303,
0.0058810799,
-0.0635465011,
-0.0013350112,
-0.0382625088,
0.0007782627,
0.0038539229,
0.021778442,
0.0011311244,
-0.0046333512,
0.0096188933,
-0.0141187636,
0.0055761705,
0.0452056378,
0.0415299274,
-0.0008061187,
-0.0059631406,
-0.0258878246,
0.0922579989,
0.0496527143,
0.0150666172,
0.040905524,
-0.0524992868,
-0.0107970145,
0.0474774092,
-0.0217788443,
0.0143070668,
0.0039433511,
0.0058762524,
0.0174484756,
0.0082615018,
0.0245243236,
0.0553296506,
-0.016047556,
0.0186741557,
0.0606574044,
0.0217581522,
0.0138577064,
0.0166556984,
0.0645556673,
0.0315712728,
0.0188223142,
0.0232435204,
-0.0566362962,
0.0101883477,
-0.0640082955,
0.0305858366,
-0.0155712357,
0.0416889824,
-0.0476466604,
-0.0619733594,
-0.0312814228,
0.0060116961,
0.0270177331,
0.0101223541,
0.0235251803,
-0.0430908129,
-0.0323994085,
0.0029672438,
0.0361733437,
-0.0263868421,
-0.0158711188,
-0.0485027693,
0.003848454,
0.0890535191,
0.0112693096,
0.0061267642,
-0.0423084721,
0.032228753,
0.0220508389,
0.0320580453,
0.055635456,
-0.015965309,
-0.0508776046,
-0.0716335997,
-0.0158183184,
-0.0070629851,
0.0026736988,
0.0306008141,
0.03383426,
-0.0020275114,
-0.0147427507,
-0.0118276477,
-0.0669839904,
0.0117563223,
-0.0288493205,
-0.032079,
-0.0409088582,
0.0055776327,
0.0510341227,
0.0215371568,
-0.0156864505,
0.0100828074,
0.0034427503,
-0.0021628612,
-0.014310671,
0.0074459584,
-0.0534127951,
-0.0075863702,
0.0266821347,
-0.028174622,
-0.0144249788,
-0.0082980273,
-0.0708524585,
-0.0358998999,
0.0048708958,
-0.0098528676,
0.0460891984,
-0.034613423,
0.0671439767,
-0.02806128,
0.0060644131,
-0.0373333246,
0.0450684167,
-0.0131515833,
0.0044890596,
0.0272456817,
0.0493567958,
0.0159202497,
-0.0393437929,
-0.021186037,
0.0241404101,
0.0133204395,
0.039924819,
0.0286069773,
0.0628788471,
-0.0196800251,
-0.0531672202,
-0.1086121127,
0.0300264843,
-0.0306013953,
0.0220582616,
0.0324280225,
-0.0090135885,
-0.0285614301,
0.0258768611,
-0.0417809784,
0.0026233776,
-0.0306345616,
0.0013039934,
-0.0007656743,
-0.0121053597,
-0.0598652698,
-0.0209486019,
0.0073872502,
-0.0106650656,
-0.0258244015,
-0.0120454691,
-0.0178124327,
-0.0856808573,
0.0284673162,
-0.0115681849,
0.0289778262,
-0.0226172507,
-0.0846549571,
0.0062172511,
0.0177396331,
0.068963483,
0.0874409974,
-0.0071426001,
0.0307128672,
0.0335200429,
-0.0004199441,
-0.0535173416,
0.0281097405,
-0.0150321815,
-0.0734658465,
-0.0445602499,
-0.0495663695,
-0.0090157557,
0.1018043533,
0.0141298352,
-0.0035833549,
-0.0851473436,
-0.0301113874,
-0.0364130735,
0.0081270328,
-0.0078429459,
0.0224628281,
-0.0353588536,
-0.0336878784,
-0.0165941864,
-0.0486901887,
0.0605034195,
-0.0302352607,
-0.0132605787,
-0.0731100217,
-0.0176224206,
-0.0523406938,
0.0372073464,
0.006192334,
0.0271323677,
-0.0140419826,
-0.0192426853,
-0.068231076,
0.0586657673,
0.0154405069,
-0.0079366947,
0.0258434098,
-0.0529110953,
-0.0117264818,
-0.0281962268,
-0.019605102,
-0.0191398282,
0.0139629617,
-0.0225118045,
0.0379911289,
0.0641482696,
-0.0393867828,
-0.0180195309,
0.0109110251,
0.0275509804,
0.0060556922,
-0.014328694,
0.0285867397,
-0.0339632034,
-0.0712556988,
0.0397675,
-0.0022153193,
-0.0160906594,
-0.0254704542,
0.047180444,
0.0347050056,
0.0394381508,
0.0022195941,
0.0038417093,
0.0073628793,
0.0497216061,
-0.0427142307,
-0.0301988777,
0.0510213263,
0.0655738115,
-0.0458099209,
0.0164841563,
0.1179479733,
0.0219643395,
-0.0204155836,
0.0292821396,
-0.0035101885,
0.0297105927,
0.0082020145,
0.024867842,
-0.0847809911,
-0.0271909516,
-0.0111147631,
-0.0042944453,
-0.0209554471,
0.0285921227,
-0.0141114984,
-0.1421617568,
0.0358972326,
0.030850051,
-0.0502085537,
-0.0376383662,
-0.0183803756,
0.012163044,
-0.0060719461,
0.0441493094,
0.0116965557,
-0.0418323092,
-0.0242564362,
0.0202847533,
-0.0368817374,
-0.0581741706,
0.0381674021,
-0.0301933587,
0.0667714179,
0.0565545522,
-0.0022682271,
0.0131684197,
-0.0012545555,
0.0347872376,
0.0202239975,
0.0002735703,
-0.0218198355,
0.0069892365,
-0.0263972897,
0.0068311198,
0.0058955294,
0.0463893861,
-0.0107347313,
0.035402339,
0.0475369133,
0.0491000861,
-0.0305016357,
-0.0183620919,
-0.0030121098,
0.0006718869,
-0.0252878089,
0.107415013,
0.0186201651,
-0.0670198947,
-0.0150861694,
-0.042614799,
-0.0654161572,
-0.037939515,
-0.0306406803,
0.0646616966,
-0.0762834176,
0.0120427618,
-0.0619139858,
-0.0394119397,
0.024563171,
-0.0249463134,
0.0378023386,
-0.0012821829,
0.0388995819,
0.0028299401,
-0.0046908236,
0.0002376047,
-0.0140562132,
0.0040664151,
-0.105694063,
-0.0793589279,
0.0425145142,
-0.0265987888,
0.0200500712,
0.0245716777,
-0.0451317318,
-0.054311458,
0.0147177093,
0.0349388048,
0.0090008611,
0.0391954407,
0.0116914241,
-0.010390386,
0.0163934249,
-0.0103452625,
-0.0026205513,
0.0338536315,
0.0312111489,
0.029107241,
0.0021701283,
0.0137857636,
-0.0430116169,
0.0451668836,
0.0351162516,
0.0613540411,
-0.0347992443,
-0.0012401768,
0.019033242,
0.0422050841,
-0.0212725308,
-0.0274030194,
0.0043982281,
-0.0316212475,
0.0472043939,
-0.0398841202,
-0.0156410392,
-0.0378879756,
-0.0290042721,
0.0281536374,
-0.0171045251,
-0.0005534207,
-0.0075505353,
0.0062702978,
-0.0104742553,
-0.0184129514,
0.013573925,
-0.0251496155,
0.0491514169,
0.0166906919,
0.0097829457,
-0.03656682,
0.0113958074,
0.0114567177,
0.0235089473,
0.0122444946,
0.1112565175,
0.0196370482,
0.0096903061,
-0.0184989125,
0.0435326807,
-0.034182243,
-0.0626926422,
-0.0325472206,
0.0319545418,
0.0667766184,
0.0084942719,
0.0445321724,
-0.061725568,
0.0015530939,
-0.0332937986,
0.0342689529,
0.0134500815,
-0.0256293286,
-0.0041801459,
0.0311532374,
-0.03660281,
-0.0247605909,
0.0847305581,
0.0325727873,
0.0520478636,
-0.0036489652,
0.0021608043,
-0.0391188338,
-0.0200027525,
0.0186918415,
-0.0138064437,
-0.019464707,
0.0265823882,
-0.0684908628,
-0.0339052901,
-0.0587871186,
-0.0017905341,
0.0108496547,
-0.0119977333,
0.0335730165,
0.0406434685,
-0.0278305206,
-0.0221035536,
-0.0400174856,
-0.028430324,
-0.0378890075,
-0.0185511876,
-0.010888828,
-6.797924973e-33,
-0.049395889,
0.0004623855,
0.0446386486,
0.0110229645,
0.0010618914,
-0.0068089701,
0.0016256052,
0.0113209542,
-0.0345251895,
-0.0252214167,
0.0021588025,
-0.0154850082,
0.0088552227,
0.0132549414,
0.0128817894,
0.0092245564,
0.02416832,
0.0019439132,
-0.0201522037,
-0.0036250509,
0.0330504365,
0.0032931317,
0.0573490672,
-0.0335803218,
-0.0020659245,
-0.0135619426,
-0.0036006756,
0.0108548114,
-0.0226306953,
0.0775133893,
0.0039632949,
0.0319403373,
0.0264546443,
-0.0329002328,
-0.0180656202,
0.0010964073,
-0.0452043638,
-0.0594564527,
0.0492373258,
0.0355574526,
-0.0009085913,
-0.051999405,
-0.0155160278,
-0.025675755,
-0.0391311757,
0.002770887,
0.0211562235,
-0.0298150536,
0.0122296363,
0.0298557915,
-0.0761671513,
0.0156312063,
-0.0034635628,
-0.0126569821,
-0.0256994627,
0.0224555023,
-0.0232715923,
-0.0059329942,
-0.0082303733,
0.0301571991,
0.0576748773,
0.0546239354,
0.0810284913,
0.0242863819,
0.0288185049,
0.0177218076,
0.0157985985,
0.0146035198,
-0.0165639184,
-0.0083376169,
0.0252266992,
0.0477399863,
0.0008692397,
-0.0017939032,
0.0138391713,
0.0182855893,
-0.0674155205,
0.0108250482,
0.0502621904,
0.0431978591,
0.0271411017,
0.0261236764,
-0.0835360587,
-0.0275773928,
-0.0060054674,
0.0091060344,
-0.0153325368,
-0.0542623736,
0.0514611341,
0.0091702398,
-0.0158112179,
-0.0390234441,
0.0610527471,
-0.0407686383,
-0.0056580752,
0.0058950139,
-0.0378245078,
0.0222340859,
-0.015457361,
0.0201091953,
-0.0904316232,
-0.0847184807,
-0.0018065139,
-0.0170307271,
0.0216876864,
0.0238158107,
0.0212154873,
0.0205227993,
-0.034264978,
0.0131969731,
-0.0256275479,
-0.0248975642,
-0.0061731101,
-0.0328043737,
0.0065287421,
0.0037405114,
-0.0013692952,
0.0632668436,
0.0201159678,
-0.0052162558,
-0.0487603024,
-0.0414017327,
-0.0303300116,
0.0249619018,
-0.0243107397,
0.0509100221,
-0.0305818878,
-0.0131645873,
0.0112404078,
-0.0314545557,
-0.0325462893,
0.0154059213,
2.96e-7,
0.0132361325,
0.0449030735,
0.0186607763,
0.0689404234,
-0.0091492953,
0.0059441277,
-0.0290973596,
0.0090156728,
0.003621263,
0.0320063606,
0.0413522832,
0.0637059063,
0.0551321283,
-0.0077902297,
-0.0685239136,
-0.0008854977,
-0.0358898379,
0.0104221646,
-0.053988073,
0.0480896831,
-0.0026951393,
0.0786228254,
-0.0125150261,
0.0499491319,
0.0002700323,
-0.0104410984,
0.0342641734,
-0.0372816473,
-0.0187811553,
0.0856597498,
0.0124450317,
0.0338541046,
-0.0221481267,
0.0054047694,
0.0114428923,
0.0203808583,
-0.0050146589,
0.0987218618,
-0.0060209343,
-0.0279077776,
0.0144729447,
-0.0083119925,
-0.0147046158,
-0.0484359264,
0.0546329878,
-0.0334278382,
-0.0405496284,
-0.0013851824,
0.0282832664,
-0.0069358912,
-0.012523978,
-0.0169710144,
0.0008918425,
0.0235203449,
0.0192842372,
-0.0134836752,
-0.0121428184,
-0.038833607,
-0.0016853823,
0.0264257211,
-0.0238525178,
-0.1024351195,
-0.0073501188,
-0.0011391498,
0.0006936044,
-0.0277321003,
-0.0174223203,
2.749398864e-34,
0.0243348479,
-0.0465417989,
0.0412276834,
0.0505170599,
0.0461625941,
-0.0050119297,
-0.0432389788,
0.0293766391,
0.0147449328,
-0.0771669,
-0.0344085507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07321v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07321v2 | On the Impact of Cross-Domain Data on German Language Models | 2023-10-11T09:09:55 | 2023-10-13T14:24:31 | Amin Dada, Aokun Chen, Cheng Peng, Kaleb E Smith, Ahmad Idrissi-Yaghir, Constantin Marc Seibold, Jianning Li, Lars Heiliger, Xi Yang, Christoph M. Friedrich, Daniel Truhn, Jan Egger, Jiang Bian, Jens Kleesiek, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Traditionally, large language models have been either trained on general web
crawls or domain-specific data. However, recent successes of generative large
language models, have shed light on the benefits of cross-domain datasets. To
examine the significance of prioritizing data diversity over quality, we
present a German dataset comprising texts from five domains, along with another
dataset aimed at containing high-quality data. Through training a series of
models ranging between 122M and 750M parameters on both datasets, we conduct a
comprehensive benchmark on multiple downstream tasks. Our findings demonstrate
that the models trained on the cross-domain dataset outperform those trained on
quality data alone, leading to improvements up to $4.45\%$ over the previous
state-of-the-art. The models are available at
https://huggingface.co/ikim-uk-essen | [
0.0272262171,
0.0593095049,
0.013934697,
0.0494237766,
-0.0257391632,
0.0131018041,
0.0493689068,
-0.0189015456,
0.0121763637,
-0.0420703255,
-0.0627293661,
-0.1021003798,
0.0079660304,
0.0062449989,
0.0219087824,
-0.0373839065,
0.0047457884,
-0.0489067063,
-0.0310327429,
-0.0160381626,
-0.0005907242,
0.0116869295,
0.0461495854,
0.0351167247,
0.0205782577,
0.008804135,
0.025604032,
0.0216764044,
-0.0104534002,
-0.0014356744,
0.0343458466,
0.0203030556,
0.019748006,
0.0753448084,
0.0000015804,
-0.0322852843,
-0.0344493724,
0.0111969775,
0.0031862592,
0.0313648358,
0.0431756452,
-0.0594377704,
-0.0261994749,
0.0512099825,
-0.0226123109,
-0.0458943993,
0.0160024967,
0.0682230517,
0.0260390863,
0.0930718109,
0.001939197,
-0.0402689539,
0.0240727011,
-0.0783869475,
-0.0389809161,
-0.0458967686,
0.0155863659,
0.0181147866,
-0.0204541963,
0.0403922126,
-0.026187636,
0.0121298824,
0.0166378375,
0.0076964023,
-0.0363267958,
0.0120198103,
0.0077144466,
-0.0133548798,
0.0262637436,
0.0698933005,
-0.0496270806,
-0.0078102332,
-0.0048164772,
-0.0204390362,
0.0089927539,
0.0332023799,
-0.0372881182,
0.0453087017,
0.0178736523,
0.0285632573,
0.0000323126,
0.0011437597,
0.0363421217,
0.0282135066,
-0.021656096,
0.0281929392,
0.0256418735,
-0.0265537947,
0.0156039437,
0.0296888594,
-0.029971227,
-0.0223396663,
-0.0310914777,
-0.0102951545,
-0.0139523018,
0.0306597967,
-0.0550454706,
-0.0478406623,
0.0238880925,
-0.0071283015,
0.0168564785,
-0.0010644739,
-0.0248568375,
0.0446832292,
-0.0065816343,
0.0137365721,
-0.0157371257,
-0.0091303512,
-0.0447465554,
-0.0476698428,
-0.0252992474,
0.0147029078,
-0.007305413,
-0.0038368041,
-0.0344266631,
-0.004970042,
-0.0357427336,
-0.0004173089,
0.0281750206,
-0.0269584302,
0.0340900794,
-0.0108923269,
-0.0544701219,
-0.0056595416,
0.003896177,
0.0240015984,
-0.0149504319,
0.0360521376,
0.0106224148,
-0.0545704626,
0.0028088265,
0.0087759895,
0.0143689867,
-0.059868373,
0.0258361958,
0.0536313877,
-0.0007891242,
-0.0337158255,
-0.0429832675,
-0.0067439675,
-0.0278951153,
-0.0567452572,
-0.0156487096,
-0.0679167807,
0.0355250202,
0.020253947,
0.021951003,
-0.085878998,
0.0055902582,
0.0135608567,
-0.0436118767,
0.0476567186,
-0.0216036905,
0.0016009491,
-0.0141131962,
-0.0138362432,
-0.0102800131,
0.104016073,
-0.0164858121,
0.0085511468,
0.0440683328,
0.0153116342,
0.0034377479,
0.0358541794,
0.0350954458,
0.0346644968,
0.0228057113,
-0.0179349929,
0.0268456452,
0.011097081,
0.0464470387,
0.0332128741,
-0.0282152053,
-0.0033641374,
0.0610378385,
0.0027872578,
0.0645706207,
0.0063072504,
0.0286303554,
0.0001537146,
0.0097360946,
0.002330848,
-0.0187216159,
-0.0405894034,
0.0032565871,
0.0202697124,
0.0291191991,
0.0543883517,
-0.0387888514,
-0.014207379,
0.0128797926,
-0.0163409822,
0.032950107,
0.0167067666,
0.0915880799,
0.0090218382,
-0.0248324703,
0.0168799646,
0.0433283374,
-0.033550974,
0.0151206572,
-0.0079316823,
-0.0119809126,
0.0495049246,
0.033463221,
0.0158203486,
-0.0124422787,
-0.0189778041,
0.0402666703,
0.0481542796,
0.0621581711,
-0.0133331046,
0.0448771119,
-0.0693268776,
-0.0739487782,
-0.0061355294,
0.0126681048,
0.038672518,
0.0275197215,
0.0173541922,
0.0532169789,
-0.0591284148,
-0.0349254198,
0.0263523124,
-0.0805164054,
0.0257377699,
0.0241202544,
0.0004277808,
-0.0176642444,
0.022716403,
-0.0336573496,
-0.0049456162,
-0.005867986,
-0.0482337549,
-0.0114221694,
-0.0244351868,
-0.0003035178,
-0.0112684844,
0.0363579206,
-0.0591587909,
0.0077634146,
0.056240391,
-0.0359776914,
-0.0328309275,
0.0012503263,
-0.0324151106,
0.0237599574,
-0.0484586395,
0.0065312404,
-0.0181854852,
0.0438972153,
-0.0324880295,
0.0507633872,
0.0191378295,
0.0498044342,
-0.0059779915,
0.0134623498,
0.012540455,
-0.0102373604,
-0.0231242124,
-0.0028419818,
-0.0269720424,
0.0638773069,
0.0399858877,
0.0085134255,
-0.0250978526,
0.0199078266,
-0.0552017353,
0.0010680482,
-0.0618132316,
0.0048510283,
0.0016049305,
0.0326321535,
-0.0063771913,
-0.0107891764,
-0.0224449653,
-0.0210045371,
0.0232867841,
0.0347358137,
-0.0058776387,
0.0013647709,
0.0157315899,
-0.0203091763,
-0.0426805951,
0.0205791574,
0.0408254191,
-0.0127468985,
-0.0161140766,
-0.0652658716,
0.0596407726,
-0.0145801567,
0.0375828929,
-0.0321814604,
-0.0265027508,
-0.0310423579,
-0.0202353746,
0.0434826761,
0.0108948732,
-0.0020066903,
-0.0257703625,
0.028906351,
0.0149365133,
-0.0787779614,
-0.0286184065,
-0.0415807962,
0.0184653532,
-0.0639272481,
-0.0110055963,
0.0355589427,
0.0563469566,
-0.0145243406,
-0.0295622218,
-0.0355368257,
-0.0146964677,
-0.0448604375,
0.0053831437,
-0.028213568,
0.0082470151,
0.0054521151,
0.0478796363,
0.0015079228,
-0.0393429399,
0.0506186374,
-0.023735635,
0.0308767632,
-0.0402640738,
-0.0308445748,
-0.0453165285,
0.0382742099,
-0.0040715337,
0.037470445,
0.0505867079,
-0.0233441815,
-0.0411431454,
0.0292465053,
0.0492607728,
-0.00656523,
0.0667193383,
-0.0162974615,
0.0217986275,
-0.0175527036,
-0.0609514229,
-0.0480193757,
-0.0643052235,
-0.0043612407,
-0.0094015496,
0.0305441692,
-0.0104851369,
-0.0611729659,
0.0051725791,
0.0041776309,
0.0466349274,
-0.0171533171,
-0.0206941161,
0.0057188086,
0.0260477476,
0.068325974,
0.0034891714,
0.0290580541,
-0.0487927087,
-0.008322373,
0.0248520747,
0.0324871391,
-0.0074485205,
-0.0136328656,
-0.0180509537,
0.0527480096,
-0.0187648311,
-0.033946272,
-0.0188144147,
0.022806786,
-0.0026901818,
-0.0212209728,
0.0964864716,
-0.0054214732,
-0.0507056937,
-0.0249407534,
-0.0043055299,
0.0218627322,
0.0113004399,
0.0261030216,
-0.0515103415,
-0.0241195839,
0.004157844,
0.0323551558,
0.0202903282,
0.0051339022,
0.0075964043,
-0.1556449085,
0.0155943129,
-0.0007566207,
-0.0225147251,
-0.0599514581,
-0.0682098716,
-0.0035291729,
-0.0401097648,
0.0259177405,
-0.0207316354,
-0.0231747627,
-0.0153349284,
0.0339172892,
-0.0051046177,
-0.1162275225,
0.0033665176,
-0.0531134233,
0.0317420699,
0.0482763872,
0.0090016052,
-0.0051412559,
-0.0113016693,
0.0539408363,
-0.0403911918,
-0.0193018261,
-0.0153227635,
0.0591101684,
-0.0043831849,
-0.0213553719,
0.0113768652,
0.0240891576,
-0.0515136532,
0.000918932,
-0.0064241593,
0.0582267083,
-0.0105546759,
0.0038750679,
-0.0058551715,
-0.0486194268,
0.0119578186,
0.0701067448,
0.0203282852,
-0.0557663515,
-0.0045434223,
-0.0338588059,
-0.0240826514,
-0.0546970442,
-0.0351650268,
0.0455747321,
-0.0328453444,
-0.038840469,
-0.0497712567,
-0.0589685887,
0.0119878715,
0.043201793,
0.0166170672,
0.009612849,
-0.0088337166,
0.0094877593,
-0.0542227104,
0.0333619416,
-0.041901309,
0.0322465748,
-0.0556460246,
0.0018367243,
0.0593953617,
-0.0380598158,
-0.0333987549,
-0.0019722311,
-0.0600113235,
-0.0688541457,
-0.000723558,
-0.0038887428,
0.0180480238,
0.0777477846,
-0.0498204567,
-0.0546231307,
0.0542538278,
0.0081994999,
-0.0523075275,
-0.0338497646,
0.0314771682,
-0.0486407205,
-0.0014377121,
0.044943653,
-0.0774599463,
0.0328466631,
0.046617385,
0.0209176186,
-0.0002663241,
-0.0007999837,
0.0006789824,
0.0243020877,
0.0595454536,
-0.0378109515,
-0.0181193128,
-0.0513239615,
-0.0113284597,
0.0101792598,
-0.0137986401,
-0.0486223847,
0.0014839923,
0.0799587443,
-0.0202062968,
-0.0198106673,
0.0660429522,
-0.0035806992,
0.0260885339,
-0.0695169494,
0.0218748022,
0.0161976945,
0.0087870853,
0.0432369076,
0.0033194853,
0.0144650918,
0.0080785435,
0.0381425433,
0.018293567,
-0.020267887,
0.0082197478,
0.0114682,
0.0299040694,
-0.0018317867,
0.0188686214,
-0.0794647634,
-0.0166102834,
-0.0644300878,
-0.0334340036,
0.0634065121,
-0.0141689954,
0.0942531824,
-0.0192459039,
-0.0118482877,
-0.0387395732,
0.0196543895,
0.0159881581,
-0.0012455245,
0.0252573621,
-0.0038938329,
-0.0430440977,
0.0125321802,
0.1230734512,
0.0330438726,
0.0360465273,
-0.0023497012,
-0.0083034243,
-0.0351263434,
-0.0365935937,
0.0094251391,
-0.0241225008,
-0.0299433824,
-0.0113666924,
-0.0141378371,
-0.0656348243,
-0.0199647229,
-0.0267306305,
0.0081548216,
0.0151533429,
0.0438027643,
0.0846627206,
0.0016367523,
0.0703931525,
-0.0604045317,
0.0146234464,
0.0191977844,
-0.0584740117,
-0.0297463518,
-5.46784687e-33,
0.0400006622,
0.0157518759,
-0.0111080334,
-0.0419958606,
-0.0308878515,
0.014211583,
0.0014341711,
0.0055457768,
-0.0480002798,
0.0045276699,
-0.0009073458,
0.0303296875,
0.0291615166,
0.070267424,
0.0067438497,
-0.0084431805,
0.0630911589,
0.0011466776,
-0.0227865689,
0.0219191294,
0.0459085144,
0.044485487,
0.055093661,
-0.0254803561,
0.0246124882,
0.0004269718,
-0.0005960843,
-0.0153839467,
0.0728159025,
0.0763364956,
-0.0146286329,
0.057846766,
0.0199072342,
-0.0851627663,
-0.0273266304,
0.0062502297,
-0.0737700537,
0.0053812559,
-0.007887058,
0.0261169784,
0.0043410333,
-0.0343257263,
0.0251380652,
-0.0073745381,
0.0232288428,
-0.0217667371,
0.0408279821,
-0.0146052809,
-0.0418520793,
-0.0660396591,
-0.0427334979,
0.0450628288,
-0.0084828865,
-0.006635237,
0.0511516072,
0.0620667115,
0.012431304,
0.0414909311,
-0.0200632941,
0.0517279096,
-0.0112997042,
0.0367457867,
0.0500531718,
-0.0146811791,
-0.0059769917,
0.0368006714,
-0.0107694408,
0.0263369977,
0.0220601894,
-0.0339477286,
0.038307175,
0.0178448893,
0.0129790828,
0.0724360868,
0.0130752437,
-0.0323783606,
-0.0865862444,
0.0544895306,
-0.0009818333,
-0.0285254009,
0.0105769942,
-0.0034968567,
-0.0104882289,
-0.015799202,
-0.0285713226,
0.0106543051,
-0.0195740983,
-0.02190198,
0.0333511047,
0.0383911952,
-0.0333985649,
-0.0268292557,
0.0523234457,
-0.0787277296,
-0.0456398353,
0.0366759039,
-0.003212359,
0.0037316519,
0.0082788952,
0.0068082479,
-0.0287893843,
-0.0606462657,
-0.0176796503,
0.032051757,
-0.0057271048,
-0.0280483384,
0.0487995371,
0.0035291356,
-0.065075241,
0.011012868,
-0.0491509363,
0.0239636395,
-0.0064132637,
0.0530648753,
0.0407874882,
-0.0065619252,
-0.0210120939,
0.028269669,
0.044901941,
-0.0076558827,
-0.0042504515,
0.0044378885,
-0.0010281348,
0.0270642452,
-0.0305467211,
-0.027494818,
-0.0274198484,
-0.0135509344,
0.0572591238,
-0.0228174571,
-0.0248326398,
-0.0069349669,
2.24e-7,
0.0562318675,
0.0268012192,
-0.0070100282,
0.0536748134,
0.005595095,
0.0321360677,
-0.0099103572,
0.0295079928,
-0.0132253766,
0.0416966043,
-0.0102588441,
-0.0293216985,
0.0835460797,
0.029286962,
-0.0747772083,
0.0128916875,
-0.0144593874,
0.0046823574,
-0.0238363799,
-0.004419669,
0.0029345283,
0.1652611643,
-0.011638673,
-0.0220204163,
0.0057102703,
-0.0185194351,
0.0942341387,
-0.0387511775,
-0.0383642279,
0.0268443655,
0.0071292254,
0.0345094651,
-0.0010520713,
-0.0159887541,
-0.0449408032,
0.0182115454,
0.0495934673,
0.044476252,
0.0469391942,
-0.0059840493,
0.0066496655,
-0.0346910134,
0.0053582434,
-0.025559498,
0.0673252568,
-0.0324252509,
-0.0152566843,
-0.0151982401,
-0.025207568,
-0.0084563065,
0.0391849577,
-0.0454198904,
-0.0126504619,
0.0219220836,
0.0290208347,
-0.0208037756,
-0.0065493062,
-0.044957947,
-0.0210421514,
-0.0011274355,
-0.0384975486,
-0.0409636609,
-0.0099030649,
0.0028640302,
0.0301010665,
-0.031335488,
0.0209743492,
1.875743223e-34,
0.062717922,
-0.0114763873,
0.0009616401,
-0.0126750832,
-0.0087607317,
-0.015488605,
-0.004715418,
-0.0240495335,
-0.0263876058,
-0.06533245,
0.0002125387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07306v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07306v1 | SNOiC: Soft Labeling and Noisy Mixup based Open Intent Classification Model | 2023-10-11T08:40:06 | 2023-10-11T08:40:06 | Aditi Kanwar, Aditi Seetha, Satyendra Singh Chouhan, Rajdeep Niyogi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, ACM-class: F.2.2, I.2.7 | This paper presents a Soft Labeling and Noisy Mixup-based open intent
classification model (SNOiC). Most of the previous works have used
threshold-based methods to identify open intents, which are prone to
overfitting and may produce biased predictions. Additionally, the need for more
available data for an open intent class presents another limitation for these
existing models. SNOiC combines Soft Labeling and Noisy Mixup strategies to
reduce the biasing and generate pseudo-data for open intent class. The
experimental results on four benchmark datasets show that the SNOiC model
achieves a minimum and maximum performance of 68.72\% and 94.71\%,
respectively, in identifying open intents. Moreover, compared to
state-of-the-art models, the SNOiC model improves the performance of
identifying open intents by 0.93\% (minimum) and 12.76\% (maximum). The model's
efficacy is further established by analyzing various parameters used in the
proposed model. An ablation study is also conducted, which involves creating
three model variants to validate the effectiveness of the SNOiC model. | [
0.0383571498,
0.0100913122,
-0.0104820458,
-0.0067088208,
-0.0429580808,
-0.0254318453,
0.0563715026,
0.0036167246,
0.02455475,
-0.0863391757,
-0.0186875518,
0.0021464566,
-0.0196149107,
0.0647450536,
-0.0711481497,
0.0182524659,
0.0665203109,
-0.0203858335,
0.0542637222,
0.0212551039,
-0.0230349917,
0.0181011874,
0.0128873661,
0.0468403101,
0.0035964982,
-0.0147043653,
-0.0165165905,
0.0010807925,
0.0101419734,
-0.0412450284,
0.0209772717,
0.0472401232,
0.0093042962,
0.0485799015,
0.0000021545,
-0.1006810367,
-0.0516035482,
-0.0132690957,
-0.0579283834,
0.0135871852,
0.0282599889,
0.0341724493,
0.0244373828,
0.019172851,
0.0137650268,
-0.011097745,
0.0437260605,
0.0503897816,
0.0359144695,
0.0480328389,
-0.0145058744,
-0.0247945935,
0.0065101385,
0.0063009923,
0.0675788447,
-0.0670012087,
0.0602021068,
-0.0091800103,
-0.0454651527,
0.0159849413,
0.0232374817,
0.0121554239,
-0.0100713409,
0.0170649942,
-0.0019369797,
0.0320783854,
0.0557230599,
-0.0102143055,
-0.0324530005,
0.0445651971,
-0.03718739,
-0.0003900816,
0.0070566935,
-0.0767975003,
-0.0145896031,
-0.0187455751,
0.00170207,
0.014083392,
0.0189723615,
0.0277316626,
0.0534889959,
0.0451919287,
0.0065063764,
0.040091455,
-0.045484338,
0.0377739854,
-0.0448484346,
-0.0012329973,
0.046749115,
-0.0427738316,
0.0641414225,
-0.059478242,
0.0131994989,
0.0166025292,
-0.0101942709,
0.0086853802,
-0.0318828635,
-0.0326025449,
0.0640097186,
-0.0692974254,
-0.0430092551,
0.0105172871,
0.0023224233,
0.0570973232,
-0.0048236568,
-0.0646304116,
0.0474812724,
0.0479669161,
-0.0409274474,
0.0156966373,
-0.0535470359,
0.0043348907,
-0.028410444,
0.0386414416,
-0.0259334352,
-0.009349471,
-0.0390099734,
-0.0050682197,
-0.0368643589,
-0.0547943301,
0.0008698045,
-0.0026472446,
-0.0094777578,
0.0223028325,
-0.0337351337,
-0.0179505516,
0.0004585553,
0.048771061,
-0.0099955508,
-0.0116981063,
0.0166103933,
0.0358594209,
0.0093873926,
-0.0045312978,
0.0103723705,
-0.0238683037,
0.0017097605,
-0.0646499619,
-0.0438518412,
-0.0572301075,
-0.0155776246,
0.0084042279,
-0.0469632521,
-0.038080629,
-0.0313573144,
-0.0125363069,
0.0033188094,
-0.0100102974,
0.0031715427,
0.0087367473,
-0.0289871246,
0.0363287628,
-0.022196522,
-0.0109102745,
0.006648011,
-0.0058666035,
0.0015574013,
0.0455896221,
-0.0202262979,
0.0369400866,
0.0333292373,
0.01761912,
-0.0015189444,
0.0052577164,
0.0198403168,
-0.0237829797,
0.0839079618,
0.0277702622,
0.0311574228,
0.0136460373,
-0.0182765499,
0.0419903435,
-0.0072952514,
-0.0243453253,
0.0468084887,
-0.0187355299,
0.035976246,
0.0018432235,
-0.0030431326,
0.0592646673,
-0.0289498661,
-0.0646816045,
0.0333596021,
-0.0388995707,
-0.0755874664,
-0.0046834052,
-0.0023481452,
0.0071223965,
-0.0316194966,
-0.04602658,
-0.0291927326,
-0.0262059607,
0.0580639318,
-0.0192284025,
0.0809032619,
-0.0136555284,
-0.0326676778,
0.0401199535,
0.0102462778,
0.0362434238,
-0.0094663622,
-0.1040558517,
0.0482997447,
-0.0325904302,
0.0039563603,
-0.0703805909,
-0.0102569573,
-0.0719372705,
-0.09282846,
-0.0468995795,
0.046570491,
0.0058959802,
-0.0265215635,
-0.0270995125,
-0.0133985495,
-0.002679792,
0.0230632741,
-0.0093739564,
-0.0670956075,
0.0339538828,
0.0239317417,
-0.014140781,
0.0013985904,
0.017210301,
0.0524813645,
0.0164877065,
0.0570682511,
0.0105182333,
0.0461090021,
0.0565789193,
0.0529699251,
0.004012398,
0.0164637323,
0.0083644409,
-0.0118095512,
-0.0342437141,
0.0050829202,
-0.0126169901,
0.0202382505,
0.0537641197,
-0.0477053784,
-0.0068463138,
-0.0153899882,
0.0001711653,
-0.026311893,
-0.004164034,
0.0004483742,
-0.0896956027,
-0.0241942741,
-0.016421672,
-0.0195067246,
-0.0346862487,
0.0892088711,
0.0175928883,
-0.0015303141,
0.0323259346,
-0.043742355,
0.051357355,
-0.0046704565,
-0.0110697104,
-0.0299536996,
-0.0891164094,
0.0092846574,
-0.0390108414,
0.0444985405,
-0.0402642526,
-0.0143937916,
-0.0687268227,
-0.010390332,
-0.025403956,
-0.0468427129,
0.0176299401,
0.0217659287,
0.0245705154,
0.0379424356,
0.0210428964,
0.0476614125,
-0.0190387517,
0.0126723135,
-0.0063925213,
0.0328318067,
-0.0229194071,
0.037566755,
0.0123446519,
-0.0268323608,
0.0249849577,
0.0385900959,
-0.0254139453,
-0.0232130792,
0.0486309901,
-0.0040302877,
-0.0170363057,
-0.0045795641,
-0.0081858514,
-0.0299819224,
0.0129483929,
-0.0384196453,
0.0132091576,
-0.001159578,
0.0095291948,
0.0513891578,
0.0046361084,
-0.0407003649,
0.0136227272,
-0.0192998014,
0.0054189605,
-0.0277300403,
-0.0294728521,
0.0386217274,
0.0222488027,
0.0352078229,
-0.0168010369,
0.0152099095,
-0.0348864868,
-0.0281643141,
-0.036094673,
-0.0862087086,
0.0010816307,
-0.0364979729,
0.0470698588,
0.0145135401,
-0.0226812493,
0.0344820842,
0.0418312773,
0.0315596536,
-0.0697968975,
-0.0113178948,
-0.030709669,
0.022267729,
-0.0650906265,
0.0432867967,
0.0766775236,
-0.0348640159,
0.0244040191,
-0.0387056209,
-0.0424002893,
-0.0370121486,
0.0759881511,
0.0122148795,
0.0200477168,
0.0057661366,
0.0122767044,
-0.0325453393,
-0.0995169729,
0.0069869929,
0.0037386117,
0.0193111412,
0.0594781265,
-0.0111527313,
0.0519218184,
-0.0625724792,
0.0393653885,
-0.0008217376,
-0.0079400139,
-0.0050215404,
0.0037876603,
0.0001070374,
-0.0206109546,
-0.0129929055,
-0.0219873786,
-0.0150870439,
0.0008577525,
-0.0300702788,
-0.0003890206,
0.0068453583,
-0.0032429583,
0.0234229863,
0.0043529547,
0.0053240987,
0.0363120511,
0.0558645353,
0.0240699984,
-0.0016556914,
0.1087205485,
0.0430391915,
-0.0278781019,
-0.013888252,
-0.0414423272,
-0.0026099503,
-0.001055453,
-0.009985433,
-0.0258337837,
-0.0351943485,
-0.012550056,
0.0052070306,
-0.0399769656,
-0.0122397924,
0.0299495682,
-0.0902485922,
0.0347102433,
0.0118254479,
-0.0688239634,
-0.0150426375,
-0.0340180658,
-0.0103572793,
-0.0468593128,
-0.0280127991,
-0.0167763494,
0.0353077762,
-0.033373937,
0.00421819,
-0.0099818204,
-0.0521540046,
0.0479003489,
-0.0308994763,
0.0882013142,
-0.0069187819,
0.0105377184,
-0.0202719551,
-0.0274158642,
0.0357355177,
-0.041834332,
0.0242939927,
-0.0422133245,
0.0352456048,
-0.0080189146,
0.0402654782,
-0.0297121499,
0.0334424339,
-0.0185433533,
-0.0341101587,
-0.014268172,
0.0699421912,
-0.0060446667,
-0.0088914977,
-0.0133644538,
-0.0025834921,
0.0532578006,
0.0611815788,
-0.0187004693,
-0.0505515598,
0.0208562091,
-0.0122939562,
0.0080047287,
0.0400237553,
0.0331158228,
0.0304554291,
-0.0377971418,
-0.1211154535,
-0.0072766636,
-0.0024561256,
0.0182778593,
0.0196401551,
0.0333850496,
0.0442977473,
0.0210652445,
0.0239363723,
0.0089632096,
-0.0078493319,
0.0194853526,
0.0594040379,
-0.006074423,
-0.0201682132,
0.0239728596,
-0.0419010594,
-0.0420859791,
0.0034378374,
-0.0622109734,
-0.028092647,
0.0222853068,
0.0092789959,
0.018770298,
-0.0174754467,
-0.0343240798,
-0.0038472593,
0.0241231509,
0.050551068,
0.045598533,
-0.0068258396,
0.0672976077,
0.0226345174,
-0.00068658,
-0.0022304663,
-0.0365800522,
-0.0029549103,
0.023683615,
-0.042608127,
-0.0816804171,
-0.0427947119,
0.029739866,
0.0041289651,
0.0518053696,
0.0192027315,
-0.0223175883,
-0.0775003955,
-0.0078879707,
0.0463651232,
-0.0081776604,
-0.0049578696,
-0.0194708724,
0.0570863932,
-0.0093741212,
0.0140430387,
0.0074568144,
-0.020050738,
-0.0052314182,
-0.0185553487,
0.010409615,
0.0220279023,
0.0712643415,
-0.0289635062,
-0.0286956746,
-0.0525278151,
-0.0250562616,
-0.0027481185,
0.007590869,
0.0178816821,
0.078072235,
-0.015145042,
0.0051496518,
0.0114312777,
0.0183436293,
0.0152467918,
0.0401700176,
-0.0365367346,
-0.0031885505,
0.0052337749,
0.0121923899,
-0.0122131882,
-0.025887426,
0.030204894,
-0.0222094767,
0.0653410107,
-0.0135713965,
-0.0514470786,
-0.0082148165,
-0.0000662583,
-0.017731376,
0.0077083898,
0.014184556,
-0.0887678266,
0.017794298,
-0.0124217691,
-0.037018016,
-0.0257359222,
0.0736743882,
0.0446753241,
0.0752526671,
-0.0369745381,
0.0016311678,
-0.0501960702,
0.0085065328,
0.0284296349,
-0.020428611,
0.0486754589,
0.0456483923,
0.0345644765,
0.0451556034,
-0.0079320623,
-0.0156755354,
-0.0582381561,
-0.0389512219,
-0.0127675924,
0.0023767427,
-0.0387719162,
-6.145298224e-33,
0.014488331,
-0.0070445118,
-0.0381789654,
-0.0481399707,
-0.0174870547,
0.0355474129,
0.0047005797,
-0.0320027918,
-0.0077272118,
-0.0447639413,
0.0309198741,
-0.0155000677,
0.0125690801,
0.0035839987,
-0.0057875435,
-0.03380147,
0.0253682155,
-0.0079569174,
0.0195572581,
0.0056486777,
0.0441870727,
-0.0005778077,
0.0106361145,
-0.1260238141,
0.0129783591,
0.0302573163,
-0.0391357392,
-0.0262228828,
-0.0305268001,
0.0432902463,
-0.0026409947,
0.0479182974,
0.0375717618,
-0.0016515712,
-0.0034041463,
-0.0128765665,
-0.018078329,
-0.0362921022,
-0.0233780313,
-0.0123032983,
0.0286356434,
-0.0086117126,
0.0046369219,
0.0194232892,
-0.0348953195,
-0.0137479436,
0.0387449302,
0.009033733,
-0.0129900519,
0.0110547952,
-0.0488792248,
0.0274430253,
-0.0189502146,
-0.0067510591,
-0.0252085812,
0.0159540065,
-0.0006105702,
-0.0161008686,
-0.0804338157,
0.0287768599,
0.0275154896,
-0.0034753189,
-0.0035750812,
0.0201847591,
0.0122795841,
0.0634097606,
-0.0303006209,
0.0256537516,
0.0275915731,
0.0023809229,
-0.0075086686,
0.0695852563,
0.0179065038,
0.0288138259,
0.064029485,
-0.0386965051,
-0.0523810945,
0.0291551761,
0.0483209975,
-0.034278933,
0.0762479529,
0.029675493,
-0.0501213893,
0.0104397647,
-0.0000369816,
-0.0209370125,
-0.0297231935,
-0.0083970083,
0.0105868569,
0.028409211,
-0.060032621,
0.0047407113,
0.0312763713,
-0.0289864112,
0.0394221656,
-0.0463821441,
0.0499148965,
0.0488367863,
-0.0185821336,
-0.0205745045,
-0.0713135377,
-0.0784172863,
0.0420572795,
-0.0192784723,
0.0237050727,
0.0041501173,
-0.0337945372,
0.0185313448,
-0.0158617925,
-0.0102131264,
0.0285634063,
-0.0230829436,
-0.0025636707,
0.0146274343,
0.0126704732,
-0.0184801873,
-0.0115483757,
0.0870593488,
0.0260988474,
0.0089383312,
-0.0289581064,
-0.0923159793,
0.0065168589,
-0.0338031575,
0.0007014879,
-0.0049879202,
0.0281537622,
-0.0548124947,
0.0101649668,
-0.0148254987,
-0.0180949792,
0.0084770806,
2.875e-7,
0.0150524192,
0.0241479669,
-0.0532889031,
0.0789069384,
-0.0070414068,
0.0908031017,
0.0219332408,
0.0266437158,
0.019805517,
-0.043823082,
0.0498817712,
-0.0644158721,
-0.0471667945,
0.0294956118,
-0.0689876899,
0.0257089753,
0.0059198751,
0.0008834753,
-0.0655365214,
0.0469012186,
0.0870407671,
0.1009150892,
0.0395471826,
-0.0141798211,
0.0320088379,
-0.0099739991,
-0.01551197,
-0.0102576902,
0.0071980958,
0.0116912462,
0.0668694377,
-0.0428404473,
0.0120098684,
0.0556822568,
-0.0218669064,
0.0421088301,
-0.0089855567,
-0.0017517378,
-0.0076093217,
-0.0292027313,
0.0182838105,
-0.0355989002,
0.0199864991,
-0.0719345436,
0.0920102745,
0.011978101,
-0.0423402861,
0.0108837858,
0.0113253389,
0.0054368633,
0.0552967675,
-0.006764838,
0.0019737235,
-0.013728288,
-0.0249597337,
-0.0252754055,
0.0022724406,
-0.0658481568,
0.0330790803,
-0.0765635222,
-0.012980029,
-0.0406093597,
0.0275554694,
0.0334114879,
0.0542166494,
-0.0627062768,
0.0276391506,
2.545285979e-34,
0.0199933071,
-0.0182088483,
-0.0275440793,
0.0076703248,
0.0042209164,
0.0409151576,
-0.0125389015,
0.0242598876,
0.0140961315,
-0.0395974703,
-0.0046734912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07301v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07301v2 | Parrot: Enhancing Multi-Turn Instruction Following for Large Language Models | 2023-10-11T08:36:43 | 2024-05-23T09:32:52 | Yuchong Sun, Che Liu, Kun Zhou, Jinwen Huang, Ruihua Song, Wayne Xin Zhao, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans often interact with large language models (LLMs) in multi-turn
interaction to obtain desired answers or more information. However, most
existing studies overlook the multi-turn instruction following ability of LLMs,
in terms of training dataset, training method, and evaluation benchmark. In
this paper, we introduce Parrot, a solution aiming to enhance multi-turn
instruction following for LLMs. First, we introduce an efficient but effective
method for collecting multi-turn instructions that feature human-like queries,
such as anaphora and ellipsis. Second, we propose a context-aware preference
optimization strategy to further enhance LLMs for complex queries in multi-turn
interaction. Moreover, to quantitatively evaluate LLMs in multi-turn
instruction following, we manually build a multi-turn benchmark derived from
existing ones. Extensive experiments show that Parrot improves current LLMs by
up to 7.2% in multi-turn instruction following. Our dataset and codes will be
open-sourced to facilitate future research. | [
0.0565104187,
0.0399331339,
-0.0064901635,
0.0477528647,
-0.0346181653,
0.0077660838,
-0.030147789,
0.000867182,
0.0079022469,
-0.0390870124,
-0.0381882004,
-0.0110866353,
-0.0223972555,
-0.0485196933,
0.0174778849,
-0.0819077641,
0.0537453666,
-0.044575844,
-0.0298569519,
0.0013736186,
0.0112751629,
0.0230056308,
-0.0318590924,
0.0618838072,
0.0216773935,
-0.0181306675,
-0.0312340111,
0.0154170496,
-0.012254524,
-0.0320502445,
-0.0012447272,
0.062652722,
0.0210884921,
0.0269003138,
0.0000019624,
-0.0250014067,
-0.0057084155,
-0.0117900381,
-0.0482346155,
-0.0014598777,
0.0382356048,
0.0071211332,
0.0195138995,
0.0192174334,
-0.044276312,
0.0116302753,
0.0301328059,
0.0367917866,
0.0848485604,
0.0616784655,
0.0161954332,
-0.0124387871,
-0.0101731727,
-0.0079344334,
0.0399264432,
-0.068740651,
0.0033601292,
-0.027545115,
0.0527038127,
0.0439042784,
-0.0169673115,
0.0440573581,
0.0322754085,
-0.0207070038,
-0.046673499,
0.0201836396,
-0.0252391789,
-0.0097238338,
-0.0090688132,
0.1088905111,
-0.0289882142,
0.0185216758,
-0.008144577,
0.0023594291,
0.0380439945,
0.0057475548,
-0.0547622666,
-0.0295484476,
0.0000306366,
-0.0098935841,
-0.0163827688,
-0.0445164628,
-0.0106667755,
-0.0003894165,
-0.0546719022,
0.0942861512,
0.0064110905,
-0.0261047836,
0.0125037981,
-0.0104661435,
-0.0267826524,
-0.0646318793,
0.0325841755,
0.0386480093,
-0.0971404761,
0.0232504513,
-0.0570978075,
0.0232943445,
0.0148428883,
-0.0211011246,
0.0334057249,
0.0481053069,
0.0120434714,
0.0324923731,
-0.0006862057,
0.0417438261,
-0.0302266628,
0.03662844,
-0.0466133468,
-0.0046824357,
-0.0529812425,
0.0041923709,
-0.0405706242,
0.0539620444,
-0.0576741286,
-0.0360477678,
-0.0256102681,
0.060778331,
0.0265192874,
0.0323067084,
0.0246522631,
0.0167793389,
0.0070501012,
-0.0035578338,
-0.0252226777,
0.0252907332,
-0.0383087173,
0.0047601587,
0.0257443897,
-0.045575045,
0.0048407349,
-0.0017981866,
0.0170029793,
-0.0463386364,
-0.0018915945,
0.0889562592,
0.0043739369,
-0.0305204149,
-0.0008349281,
-0.0227715541,
-0.0016638398,
-0.0465766601,
-0.0249247234,
-0.0564661846,
0.0563457943,
0.0202959199,
-0.0086349864,
0.0124798557,
0.0252762716,
0.0688853711,
-0.024168795,
0.0692535862,
0.0269952137,
0.0191613361,
0.0060555972,
0.0025395947,
-0.0068156193,
0.065031141,
0.0459880345,
0.012231973,
0.053032577,
-0.021853881,
0.0065993671,
0.0596004538,
0.0000248227,
-0.0200888962,
0.0239336528,
0.034801349,
-0.0298270676,
0.0445263647,
0.0031137271,
0.0692670718,
-0.0414294116,
-0.0482077822,
0.0392044522,
0.0371838436,
0.0129953781,
-0.0379107557,
0.0472717695,
0.022904193,
-0.0106679471,
0.0353343859,
-0.070728384,
0.0348902568,
-0.0262672007,
0.0113614332,
0.0166168418,
0.023875827,
-0.0189205483,
-0.0320943333,
0.0247634742,
0.0009941858,
-0.0016578576,
0.0312873386,
0.0214693137,
-0.0162072629,
-0.0582089126,
0.0265888702,
0.0251712259,
-0.0363288298,
-0.0222991295,
-0.0452246331,
0.0226967074,
0.087420091,
0.0416128859,
-0.0063634836,
-0.0374863334,
-0.0078091975,
0.0035007389,
0.0394807644,
0.0286217667,
-0.0403467156,
0.033583004,
-0.0392993987,
-0.0155154411,
0.0284252558,
-0.0068763988,
0.0228793696,
0.0431648009,
-0.0107174031,
0.0090522282,
-0.011259973,
-0.0110937012,
0.0390485451,
-0.000336668,
-0.0341577642,
-0.0249935463,
0.0212382581,
0.0233118664,
0.0046895226,
0.00763111,
0.0196788032,
0.0566858016,
-0.0021066831,
0.0116953421,
-0.0061318455,
-0.0686083883,
-0.0776210129,
0.0250080973,
-0.0124237919,
-0.0538344346,
0.0159180686,
-0.0304161906,
-0.0298472326,
-0.0411349759,
-0.0192078147,
0.0891141444,
0.0091298409,
0.0472154915,
0.0400708318,
-0.0207723789,
-0.0537288561,
0.0299006756,
-0.0197966918,
0.0346691348,
0.0449632257,
0.0038261453,
-0.008426467,
-0.0410202183,
-0.0012997077,
0.013993144,
0.0023872603,
-0.0092920344,
0.0253740847,
0.0344426706,
-0.0641437992,
-0.0458495952,
-0.0744508356,
0.0089750933,
-0.023956785,
0.0037821766,
0.0169552248,
0.0230692159,
-0.012756601,
-0.0329076424,
-0.0185827352,
-0.0121725583,
-0.0111799389,
0.0428567082,
0.0151354074,
0.0373528637,
-0.0251288265,
-0.0624461994,
-0.0032464371,
-0.0170262959,
0.0025060175,
-0.0153095033,
0.0220525526,
-0.0498010814,
-0.0068435161,
-0.0032081443,
0.0390312448,
-0.005939025,
-0.0190719012,
0.0407452211,
-0.0358891003,
0.0455821157,
0.0886863992,
0.0195754413,
0.0155802732,
0.0206122808,
-0.0222860947,
-0.0981582105,
0.0198014546,
-0.03986964,
-0.0194326174,
-0.0395666175,
-0.0167556107,
0.0133929616,
0.0528629422,
-0.0080419676,
0.0142642679,
-0.0541087873,
-0.0337909237,
-0.0033601031,
-0.0258788429,
-0.0362103283,
0.0065980498,
-0.04562914,
0.0004012035,
-0.0243740194,
-0.0286443587,
0.0838023201,
-0.0305577684,
-0.0303357616,
-0.0331813172,
0.0022542789,
-0.0230053086,
0.0339989252,
0.0248186719,
0.0169579852,
-0.0365144238,
-0.0447023995,
-0.0605417714,
0.0177303459,
0.0085069798,
-0.0250357483,
0.077188544,
-0.0556279905,
0.0024037331,
0.0108587649,
-0.0264394246,
-0.0364684798,
-0.040489614,
-0.0131937498,
-0.006081691,
0.0612359717,
-0.0522914156,
-0.0200984497,
-0.0025381697,
0.0378159657,
0.0518251993,
-0.009782102,
-0.0275441539,
-0.0373692364,
-0.0027433955,
0.0790560469,
0.0032149199,
-0.020208519,
-0.0396506749,
0.0357490331,
0.0654025674,
0.0811181366,
-0.0393326022,
0.0262942277,
-0.0078358306,
0.0498034507,
-0.0547732599,
-0.0138127087,
0.0388424993,
0.0416733101,
-0.0279756486,
0.0094676875,
0.1422845572,
0.0481700599,
-0.0748924911,
0.0094332322,
-0.0244777407,
0.0490642786,
0.0345517844,
0.0379309319,
-0.0783186778,
-0.0373476967,
-0.011472417,
0.0243239682,
0.0284746401,
-0.0364627205,
-0.0013593864,
-0.1254764199,
-0.006556497,
-0.028058337,
-0.0463164523,
-0.0292189904,
-0.0180115104,
0.0291356947,
-0.0049579148,
0.0348442048,
0.0208437257,
-0.0197041593,
-0.0097788917,
0.0197658055,
-0.0137328543,
-0.0289735999,
0.0318227597,
-0.0393940061,
0.0147076268,
0.0488568246,
0.0219671912,
0.022024909,
-0.0156910475,
0.0064688474,
0.0043879882,
-0.0083702905,
-0.039540302,
0.0451803803,
-0.0405675359,
-0.0081738224,
-0.0342500098,
0.0371049978,
-0.020715965,
0.0009144885,
0.041367542,
0.049248334,
-0.0222908743,
0.0129951453,
-0.0071822447,
-0.0076353033,
0.0161066819,
0.0634547025,
0.0240873061,
-0.0619293563,
-0.0025122967,
-0.0454056934,
-0.0368832424,
-0.0687683746,
-0.0329604037,
-0.0210860614,
-0.0101459194,
0.0278728958,
-0.0684253052,
-0.0491293594,
0.0633543208,
0.0432279781,
-0.0099533899,
0.0221907441,
0.0469361246,
-0.01400482,
0.0227639619,
-0.0116756745,
-0.0165326223,
0.0354900882,
-0.0802939907,
-0.0295019764,
0.0170908906,
0.0066616507,
-0.0130661577,
-0.0137668625,
-0.0491424538,
-0.0744020641,
0.0196770784,
0.0660514235,
0.0192382224,
0.0543574989,
-0.0216482673,
-0.0074671404,
-0.0259773768,
0.0300982445,
-0.044300478,
-0.0053816517,
0.0175005142,
0.0240526907,
-0.0125300102,
0.0427236743,
-0.0233663712,
-0.0098806294,
-0.0301678423,
0.0394018479,
-0.0962978527,
-0.0836082846,
0.0476514362,
0.0124194445,
0.009548001,
-0.0030802176,
0.0156425778,
-0.0111819776,
0.0463940911,
-0.0440871343,
-0.0200801939,
-0.0485059656,
-0.0006191885,
0.0009261537,
-0.0460195951,
0.0127023123,
-0.0521578416,
-0.0168951396,
0.0007539784,
-0.0482053608,
0.0216274988,
0.0075055799,
-0.0017050657,
0.0452189632,
0.007444988,
0.0069729872,
-0.0063085896,
0.0207938496,
0.057855349,
-0.0128436275,
0.0834942907,
0.0296253469,
-0.0385478623,
-0.0088559454,
0.028948877,
-0.0498350896,
-0.0412358716,
-0.0162178334,
0.0137435207,
0.0471726619,
-0.0228574369,
0.0405505747,
-0.0022710899,
-0.0030498947,
0.0022868607,
0.0335142054,
0.002861789,
-0.0298031978,
0.0431191288,
0.048169598,
0.006981642,
-0.0062289792,
0.0772887766,
-0.0092871878,
0.0391055048,
0.0110343434,
0.0051221726,
-0.0486794785,
-0.0257619862,
0.017083304,
0.0301250108,
-0.0357846096,
0.0327683687,
-0.0320929699,
-0.052208297,
-0.0501242019,
0.0138496449,
-0.0201021079,
-0.0407128707,
0.0647945404,
0.0437513031,
0.0114106974,
-0.0353125632,
-0.0535828583,
0.0058744978,
-0.0215611905,
-0.0269498024,
-0.02389374,
-6.187602429e-33,
-0.0719513446,
-0.03517529,
0.039697282,
0.0091131246,
-0.0247708242,
-0.0499205813,
-0.0257766861,
0.0203149226,
-0.0449943058,
-0.0186733007,
-0.0253762361,
0.0172989424,
0.0160374362,
0.0095373588,
0.0391806364,
-0.0319335125,
0.0175642073,
0.0013718526,
-0.0153799579,
0.0076324265,
0.0185550861,
0.0039213342,
0.0276908558,
-0.0715119317,
0.0226522051,
-0.0145761976,
0.0092175845,
0.0273107719,
-0.0594490245,
0.0828770697,
0.0038883043,
0.0247264858,
0.0036647457,
-0.0268336404,
-0.0217335615,
0.0137341749,
-0.0378306769,
-0.0429371148,
0.0553273894,
0.0260236282,
-0.0564339943,
-0.0194330104,
0.0089791315,
-0.0272664968,
0.0230274666,
0.0206028242,
0.0180190578,
0.0037938769,
-0.0498869717,
0.059437152,
-0.0417997986,
0.005883777,
-0.003904219,
-0.0513384007,
0.0124692153,
0.0679529905,
0.0192196947,
0.0015192194,
-0.0388456583,
0.0147468578,
0.009667662,
0.045877248,
0.0354056694,
0.0216436982,
0.0275461525,
0.0322747603,
0.0016021942,
-0.0218302179,
0.0143839819,
-0.0011759608,
0.0015633461,
0.0805900469,
0.0078164442,
0.0109951403,
0.0038103079,
0.0160719808,
-0.0137388967,
0.0194453355,
0.0352209322,
0.0593776405,
0.0021320207,
-6.993e-7,
-0.0482219569,
-0.0120429713,
-0.0355868414,
0.0324192122,
-0.0293917861,
-0.0352000818,
0.0398840792,
0.0257577021,
-0.0045847073,
-0.0029031883,
0.0508837067,
0.0001939966,
-0.058800403,
0.0025764052,
-0.020268837,
0.0154613117,
-0.0009461082,
0.0172816459,
-0.0554284416,
-0.0180853251,
0.0079537192,
-0.0465462916,
0.0114287417,
0.0308741871,
0.0101106679,
0.009813969,
-0.0848594978,
-0.0125556318,
-0.02716773,
0.0034311342,
-0.037592724,
-0.0250592772,
0.0464452319,
-0.0068363245,
-0.0306450501,
0.08032877,
-0.0020133059,
-0.0215723608,
-0.0512089543,
-0.0564049482,
0.0088011241,
0.0162457526,
-0.0177377854,
-0.0000632365,
-0.0346063226,
0.0098315822,
-0.0085339928,
-0.0237280112,
-0.0194521323,
0.0139772296,
2.567e-7,
0.0410266295,
0.0533054993,
0.0155685991,
0.0737392008,
-0.0218212139,
0.0144564286,
-0.0191635583,
-0.0184977651,
0.0320460089,
-0.0049673342,
0.0090400111,
0.0261095501,
0.0153958658,
0.017446937,
-0.104519628,
-0.0291227493,
-0.0405175239,
0.0077483901,
-0.0426625386,
-0.0104545141,
0.0724880621,
0.10174606,
-0.0100366343,
0.03100181,
-0.0073270076,
0.0251665767,
0.0321684107,
-0.0425146967,
-0.0070290896,
0.0220438279,
-0.0013603925,
-0.0069483453,
0.0105246222,
0.0215279385,
-0.0106688552,
0.0084084608,
0.0061967103,
0.0915034562,
-0.0075572664,
-0.031924136,
0.0235616025,
-0.0223142505,
0.0046856334,
-0.0525505468,
0.0666663796,
-0.0363789462,
0.0258411709,
-0.0096222553,
-0.0031296024,
-0.0285395179,
-0.0103680473,
-0.0116323456,
-0.0165350623,
-0.0124571444,
0.0249465946,
-0.0217636954,
0.0028702889,
-0.0784099251,
-0.024037933,
-0.0037157049,
-0.0259284992,
-0.0340882465,
-0.0398709513,
-0.0126876757,
-0.0144174378,
-0.0151520697,
-0.0342902802,
2.339271411e-34,
0.0158797782,
-0.0100827739,
0.0603750423,
0.0816188008,
0.0391686708,
0.0053262045,
-0.0264212303,
0.0288041625,
0.0578620955,
-0.1057776585,
-0.0332639366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07299v1 | RobustGEC: Robust Grammatical Error Correction Against Subtle Context Perturbation | 2023-10-11T08:33:23 | 2023-10-11T08:33:23 | Yue Zhang, Leyang Cui, Enbo Zhao, Wei Bi, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) systems play a vital role in assisting
people with their daily writing tasks. However, users may sometimes come across
a GEC system that initially performs well but fails to correct errors when the
inputs are slightly modified. To ensure an ideal user experience, a reliable
GEC system should have the ability to provide consistent and accurate
suggestions when encountering irrelevant context perturbations, which we refer
to as context robustness. In this paper, we introduce RobustGEC, a benchmark
designed to evaluate the context robustness of GEC systems. RobustGEC comprises
5,000 GEC cases, each with one original error-correct sentence pair and five
variants carefully devised by human annotators. Utilizing RobustGEC, we reveal
that state-of-the-art GEC systems still lack sufficient robustness against
context perturbations. In addition, we propose a simple yet effective method
for remitting this issue. | [
0.0715646893,
0.0086834775,
-0.0008064046,
0.0209752694,
-0.0240355618,
0.0083486168,
-0.0196073521,
0.0017790622,
0.0055444394,
-0.0665528849,
0.0099110398,
-0.0347536504,
0.0451996736,
-0.0230959523,
0.0074961884,
-0.0544632189,
0.0620655343,
-0.0099915341,
-0.0462431498,
0.0141659044,
0.0305550266,
-0.0036292751,
-0.0352045186,
0.0608811155,
-0.050856173,
-0.0621570274,
0.0007430073,
0.0549977049,
0.0217466224,
-0.0281684883,
0.0705563575,
0.0468694307,
-0.0508611463,
0.0670484528,
0.0000017834,
-0.0348175168,
0.0013986195,
-0.0129948184,
-0.0027976003,
0.048347909,
0.0312927961,
-0.0127145331,
-0.0761861578,
0.0110420827,
-0.0098759132,
0.0433101915,
0.0589195378,
0.0327988118,
0.0309220087,
0.0604863539,
-0.0209232979,
0.0184341129,
0.0007689043,
0.0098894984,
-0.0278437007,
-0.0254469011,
0.0117333829,
-0.0265656915,
0.0072247917,
-0.0101593109,
-0.005205709,
0.0367582664,
0.0068047955,
-0.0745582879,
-0.0331783481,
-0.0007291553,
-0.0247015283,
0.0073388964,
-0.0160632525,
0.0211449917,
0.0496763773,
-0.0287218727,
-0.0203953572,
-0.0088234385,
0.0414263085,
0.0084950179,
-0.0073133237,
-0.0101506617,
-0.031988319,
-0.0078426301,
0.0300589837,
-0.0589649081,
-0.0138180731,
0.0140848653,
0.0636151135,
0.0717820302,
0.0190837253,
-0.05630631,
-0.0445805341,
0.0663342178,
-0.0465846956,
-0.0727585182,
0.0528424121,
-0.0049525909,
-0.0633834153,
-0.0281965174,
-0.0664346218,
-0.0833382905,
0.0016061018,
-0.0583924949,
0.0103994794,
0.0286590196,
-0.0352994427,
-0.0019395365,
-0.0172920581,
0.0522308163,
-0.0049168034,
-0.0076679098,
0.0115092192,
0.0149239954,
-0.0211463515,
-0.0021686857,
-0.0523578525,
0.020883251,
-0.0683232695,
0.0287147369,
-0.0828491896,
0.0268907044,
-0.0267816503,
0.0501437224,
0.0005539933,
0.0119791236,
-0.0348102227,
-0.0459334403,
0.0119734509,
-0.0159004293,
-0.0443236008,
0.0587698817,
0.0077015921,
-0.0376801863,
-0.0230316333,
0.0152687905,
0.0385970026,
-0.0166977216,
-0.0516414344,
-0.0052553085,
-0.0227385927,
-0.0165197682,
-0.0600777827,
-0.0189048108,
-0.055927325,
-0.0280732382,
-0.1022242755,
-0.0447524153,
-0.0420905836,
0.0006759488,
0.0163154434,
-0.0336154476,
-0.0031921533,
0.0196955055,
-0.0032173276,
0.0697458088,
-0.0408563986,
-0.0255628228,
0.0445605703,
-0.008879262,
-0.0093795676,
0.0196351446,
0.0221422538,
-0.0371118486,
0.0613086633,
0.0549798496,
0.0366371274,
0.0074588046,
-0.0706113428,
-0.0270411987,
0.0205549411,
-0.02573503,
0.0023462712,
0.0478018597,
0.0230921283,
0.0667225718,
-0.0064394581,
0.0314358398,
0.0956091508,
0.0419665426,
-0.0106901601,
0.0285965987,
0.0188250244,
-0.061480239,
-0.0057652784,
0.0450065285,
-0.0686159357,
-0.0182352792,
-0.0898306295,
-0.0033678776,
-0.0078668846,
-0.0095668258,
-0.0013470339,
-0.0481695868,
-0.0373663306,
0.0042214151,
0.0036491577,
-0.0568388775,
0.0156842917,
0.0239669643,
-0.0207603537,
0.0149835469,
-0.0147876022,
-0.0930541977,
-0.0135719785,
0.0059902789,
-0.0023054706,
0.071639441,
0.064102605,
-0.0316493995,
-0.0142868012,
-0.0355720632,
0.0039320346,
0.0295513719,
0.0508298166,
-0.0064619575,
0.0081224889,
-0.0300027318,
0.0169985835,
0.0262922794,
0.0282985363,
-0.0363491625,
0.0278110858,
0.0322655067,
-0.0025943327,
0.0257026292,
0.0034444614,
0.0319945626,
0.0218064766,
-0.0012252235,
-0.003704052,
-0.0105635514,
0.0111589916,
0.0243631005,
-0.0229692757,
-0.0074932282,
-0.0343723744,
-0.0046934146,
-0.0271587726,
0.0273231659,
-0.0483309031,
-0.0667649433,
0.0367372446,
-0.0194294211,
-0.0404705442,
0.0322233848,
-0.0006748951,
-0.0317071006,
-0.0288234912,
-0.0420615897,
0.0182787944,
-0.0595724732,
0.0583808161,
0.0004324868,
-0.013971271,
-0.0130179748,
0.0025465365,
0.0027299416,
-0.0016735152,
-0.0258430056,
0.028629411,
-0.0024862203,
-0.0553311855,
-0.0548169315,
-0.0120571582,
0.0107519506,
0.0215791482,
0.0196866002,
0.0243878327,
-0.0264182761,
-0.0142605854,
-0.1112974435,
-0.0099265547,
-0.045268435,
0.0043394882,
0.0369947515,
0.0058239913,
-0.0109218042,
-0.0336302482,
0.0255140979,
0.0430669524,
0.0083391517,
0.0129997944,
0.0548808016,
-0.0295961946,
-0.0000436072,
-0.0680950955,
0.0165997837,
-0.0250758976,
0.0010553952,
0.0351897031,
-0.0340368189,
-0.0715691969,
0.0547948107,
0.0018598913,
0.0241213832,
0.0599647984,
-0.0575810894,
-0.0005347622,
0.0227993242,
0.0751853809,
0.0430456512,
0.0019312063,
0.0252796691,
0.0019490091,
-0.0069456417,
0.0117790597,
-0.0022407526,
0.0332486629,
-0.014589238,
-0.0093920063,
-0.0026511142,
0.0032137157,
0.0551570468,
0.0265843999,
0.00497049,
-0.0208046511,
0.0021142971,
-0.0450229123,
-0.0242564436,
-0.0345162936,
-0.0185001027,
-0.0459873788,
0.0209704712,
-0.0313986875,
-0.0019109072,
0.0746421963,
0.0110605741,
-0.0129171172,
-0.0004177341,
-0.006614184,
0.0025140808,
-0.0107995989,
-0.0416878648,
0.0203826316,
-0.0191170815,
-0.0395765305,
-0.0543230325,
-0.0218022037,
0.0823240578,
-0.0064169564,
0.0640975237,
-0.0936708152,
0.0356734172,
0.0040576602,
-0.1024055034,
-0.0069983508,
-0.0279640872,
-0.0300821234,
-0.0069659594,
0.0266724192,
-0.0306434836,
-0.0166431982,
0.0076259738,
0.0001867818,
0.0952795967,
-0.0241333097,
-0.032520555,
-0.0158842411,
0.0333722532,
0.0047291094,
0.0244638287,
0.0232595596,
-0.0120726069,
0.0114965057,
0.0913047567,
-0.0104360515,
0.0189607553,
-0.0277295746,
0.0071226736,
0.0282976888,
-0.0368450955,
-0.037753325,
0.0024817735,
0.0961367264,
-0.0510403663,
-0.0645786673,
0.0762135312,
0.0117915077,
-0.0335593857,
-0.0059884898,
-0.0432212986,
0.0229668617,
0.0057276869,
0.0165126212,
-0.0545813106,
-0.0202045329,
0.0574146025,
0.0502537675,
-0.0027952462,
-0.0369207971,
0.0274168774,
-0.0841567516,
0.0599485114,
0.0216822959,
-0.0234101359,
-0.0536635853,
0.010862112,
0.0316486657,
0.0064019896,
0.0592584573,
0.0389703102,
0.0016816637,
-0.0269784909,
-0.0005419729,
-0.0568116866,
-0.0535882935,
-0.0455289707,
-0.048367057,
0.0510429814,
0.0456853248,
0.004667663,
0.0388483629,
-0.0126915295,
0.0702978149,
-0.0122803282,
0.0004656134,
-0.0020306497,
0.0099056521,
-0.0071132537,
0.0087007321,
-0.0429455154,
0.0442915894,
-0.0248806328,
-0.0408590473,
0.0076819449,
0.0436015688,
-0.0196039304,
0.0547613837,
0.0029558425,
-0.010808479,
0.0493830033,
0.0418621935,
0.0269381292,
-0.0704277828,
-0.0636894181,
-0.0784751251,
0.0003059154,
-0.0470753722,
0.0362254269,
0.0202568714,
-0.0003273709,
-0.0057399543,
-0.0768244639,
-0.0583230816,
-0.0121055609,
0.0192374475,
0.0090577481,
-0.015841864,
-0.0166001841,
0.0023672285,
0.014235314,
-0.036443267,
0.012975527,
0.0416612551,
-0.0880729631,
0.0407895483,
-0.0344056375,
0.0301573146,
0.0014191361,
0.0128695741,
-0.0500422157,
-0.0551392511,
0.0572989732,
0.0281663612,
0.0100543043,
0.0186956711,
-0.0247729663,
-0.1153922901,
-0.0186899956,
0.033161737,
0.0064344192,
0.0553588532,
0.0148520591,
0.0087311333,
0.0076138689,
0.0258113611,
-0.0138850976,
-0.0065141083,
0.0043781223,
0.074984327,
-0.0189828053,
-0.0309396684,
0.0298164859,
0.006726922,
0.0257656891,
-0.0281770248,
0.0001036557,
-0.0338582173,
0.0379278958,
-0.0525631271,
-0.0006799263,
-0.0017725236,
0.0306105763,
0.0055305921,
-0.0330424793,
-0.0285711475,
0.0112982588,
-0.0490828902,
0.0353040732,
-0.0572394207,
-0.0020809618,
0.0289804768,
0.0359124728,
0.0283790492,
0.0106057087,
-0.0128672756,
0.0324337631,
0.0070560169,
0.0399336219,
-0.0046741948,
0.0517309085,
0.0360988006,
-0.0073786331,
-0.0004799841,
0.022751078,
-0.070719704,
0.0748729929,
-0.0378814265,
0.0428078026,
0.1018228084,
0.0190628748,
0.0658666044,
-0.0249221753,
-0.036963664,
-0.0206876379,
0.0326092504,
0.0337099209,
-0.0035692332,
-0.0214720573,
0.0111722974,
0.0044564833,
0.0164959207,
0.0108151212,
-0.0559860319,
0.0085196216,
-0.0154961105,
-0.04298383,
-0.0324189775,
0.0033014864,
-0.0248253848,
0.0019086931,
-0.012427194,
-0.0163680147,
-0.0358342417,
-0.0407241322,
0.0281343125,
0.0508967191,
0.0147815561,
-0.0108491257,
-0.0011311767,
0.0291318949,
0.0038450139,
-0.0480840281,
-0.0220576245,
-0.0106993746,
0.0066874572,
-0.0160164516,
-0.0787837878,
-5.545244724e-33,
-0.0431305692,
-0.0235171802,
-0.0415034629,
-0.0204194412,
0.024237629,
-0.006853105,
-0.0363065489,
0.0419714637,
0.052601058,
0.053315267,
-0.0398031659,
0.0473167114,
0.0166621637,
0.0075596012,
0.033574488,
0.0180417914,
0.0760664046,
0.0074651074,
-0.0431663208,
-0.0413087457,
0.0439044163,
0.0246477053,
0.0530612879,
-0.073135972,
0.0518418401,
-0.0077103446,
-0.0325442255,
0.0136300819,
-0.0030294145,
0.0552125461,
0.0264906716,
0.0592441745,
0.0181659013,
0.053945832,
-0.0157779418,
0.0254786164,
-0.0628478304,
-0.0321933031,
-0.0184184406,
0.0298922397,
-0.0221584607,
-0.0380350165,
0.0443107076,
-0.0160968266,
-0.0507129915,
0.0260910988,
0.0125194583,
-0.0087305307,
0.016438799,
-0.0083922464,
-0.0281967986,
0.0115640825,
0.0070056985,
0.0225484259,
-0.0434322618,
0.0145790363,
-0.0029413898,
-0.0290840119,
-0.0653323978,
-0.0259976014,
0.0081853094,
0.020080911,
0.0206898674,
-0.0268405043,
-0.0680640116,
0.0162671916,
-0.0025746261,
0.0331026576,
-0.0317507312,
-0.0278156437,
-0.0021796834,
-0.0111907711,
0.0424662977,
0.101551339,
0.0369433612,
-0.0380224623,
0.0045287199,
0.0211374164,
-0.0036582642,
0.031300094,
-0.0006410403,
0.0080706785,
-0.056397669,
-0.0387670621,
-0.0092392294,
-0.0056686425,
-0.012224596,
0.0057516759,
0.0710069612,
-0.007745259,
0.0308510847,
-0.0045486782,
-0.0068404917,
0.0032852923,
-0.0088027259,
-0.0188374966,
0.0109348428,
0.037700057,
0.0015721309,
0.0314654149,
0.0104343854,
-0.0018789736,
0.0016186782,
0.0480580404,
0.0343985818,
-0.010458217,
0.0321830139,
0.0310418922,
-0.067815423,
0.0293900538,
0.0210522301,
0.0332427956,
-0.0136886481,
-0.0357929692,
0.0307821259,
-0.0227411855,
0.0209018644,
0.0303738303,
0.0274519026,
0.0209196452,
-0.032054428,
-0.034609437,
0.0032106058,
0.0257986188,
0.0074015111,
0.007612789,
0.0060925195,
0.0228939913,
0.0192901045,
-0.0334633105,
0.0089867385,
0.0006372485,
2.382e-7,
0.0270085838,
0.055534929,
0.03434854,
-0.0220520813,
0.0054409043,
0.0078184577,
0.0083997771,
0.0115160579,
-0.0251778997,
0.0564755388,
0.0295166839,
-0.0156234335,
0.042289611,
0.0171582308,
-0.0210860465,
-0.036184296,
-0.0619172156,
0.0615571253,
-0.0297977384,
-0.0019132819,
0.0803945884,
-0.0068156533,
0.0408459082,
-0.0032285126,
-0.0214122664,
-0.0627544075,
0.0362792276,
0.0020794291,
0.0182053596,
-0.007423257,
0.0532868207,
0.0144592542,
0.0207602661,
0.0200305581,
-0.0212095138,
-0.0309417825,
0.0161648467,
0.0477035232,
-0.0557898767,
0.0335995518,
0.0000709929,
0.0071756546,
-0.0094532687,
-0.0526139885,
0.0324310251,
-0.0067840884,
0.0562961102,
0.0054485495,
-0.0215761811,
-0.0211805347,
0.0087166876,
-0.00304308,
-0.0293806549,
-0.0144095067,
0.0492832512,
0.0530473515,
-0.0281916037,
-0.0428047962,
-0.028098058,
0.0554449297,
0.0252717268,
0.0012925311,
-0.0107445279,
0.0048630796,
0.0184279885,
-0.066544652,
-0.0188911054,
1.885721609e-34,
0.0454585962,
-0.009342527,
0.061500676,
0.0292981956,
0.0244466364,
0.0183185656,
0.0291445237,
0.0088433316,
0.0137361018,
-0.0099879233,
-0.0339599177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07289v1 | Beyond Factuality: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Large Language Models as Knowledge Generators | 2023-10-11T08:22:37 | 2023-10-11T08:22:37 | Liang Chen, Yang Deng, Yatao Bian, Zeyu Qin, Bingzhe Wu, Tat-Seng Chua, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) outperform information retrieval techniques for
downstream knowledge-intensive tasks when being prompted to generate world
knowledge. However, community concerns abound regarding the factuality and
potential implications of using this uncensored knowledge. In light of this, we
introduce CONNER, a COmpreheNsive kNowledge Evaluation fRamework, designed to
systematically and automatically evaluate generated knowledge from six
important perspectives -- Factuality, Relevance, Coherence, Informativeness,
Helpfulness and Validity. We conduct an extensive empirical analysis of the
generated knowledge from three different types of LLMs on two widely studied
knowledge-intensive tasks, i.e., open-domain question answering and
knowledge-grounded dialogue. Surprisingly, our study reveals that the
factuality of generated knowledge, even if lower, does not significantly hinder
downstream tasks. Instead, the relevance and coherence of the outputs are more
important than small factual mistakes. Further, we show how to use CONNER to
improve knowledge-intensive tasks by designing two strategies: Prompt
Engineering and Knowledge Selection. Our evaluation code and LLM-generated
knowledge with human annotations will be released to facilitate future
research. | [
0.0507357642,
0.0139329964,
-0.0014460891,
0.0498750024,
-0.0386826172,
-0.0119759385,
0.0022452702,
-0.0301007796,
0.0079952162,
-0.0718903244,
-0.0277065746,
-0.0126382764,
-0.0299302377,
0.0057413941,
0.0226674639,
-0.0050443215,
0.0503442213,
-0.0406375714,
0.0189804118,
-0.0046191323,
-0.0208163913,
0.0098423492,
-0.0195336491,
0.0340036824,
-0.0206751078,
-0.0028469192,
0.0059733042,
-0.0175746102,
0.0045874007,
-0.01752555,
0.0027853672,
0.0500764996,
0.020229727,
0.0110441521,
0.0000019882,
-0.0758852959,
0.0393963344,
-0.0124438042,
-0.05643747,
0.0131897889,
0.0084509328,
0.0503192358,
0.0150272613,
0.0040476364,
-0.0478117354,
0.0000319129,
0.0058113197,
0.0448037647,
0.0738588274,
0.0336514078,
0.0183972046,
-0.0164000355,
-0.0061893589,
-0.0060465666,
0.0265090186,
-0.0206108522,
0.0308262929,
0.0692675561,
0.0008238228,
0.0429476388,
0.0160838682,
0.0314733572,
0.000644105,
-0.0610372201,
0.0522957742,
0.0391715094,
-0.0340483412,
-0.0222251676,
0.0320792608,
0.0914785266,
0.063211605,
0.0067587798,
-0.0028240527,
0.0198336802,
0.0073607056,
0.0278159995,
-0.0544158071,
0.0551883616,
-0.0144497808,
0.006061011,
-0.0159139838,
0.0126303546,
0.0152641432,
0.0386474989,
0.0059983614,
0.0791070387,
-0.0029978384,
-0.0193942543,
0.0095796073,
-0.0082688536,
-0.0206403118,
-0.0724974126,
-0.0293468703,
0.0541895926,
-0.0170879271,
0.0317587107,
0.0214075949,
0.0279530361,
0.0503129661,
-0.0844680667,
-0.0076856581,
0.0173089355,
-0.0185949448,
0.086316891,
-0.0239996687,
0.0536194071,
0.0047444566,
0.0054975115,
-0.0251052994,
-0.0224022605,
-0.0530904904,
-0.0219736844,
-0.0120638283,
0.0299465843,
-0.03400857,
-0.0149320271,
0.015921358,
0.0204718132,
0.0031278899,
0.0156501569,
0.0137472171,
0.0224344637,
-0.0037170383,
0.0029995288,
-0.0985309705,
0.0389686488,
-0.0413266085,
0.0176938269,
0.0069061094,
-0.0509232171,
0.0123399245,
0.0319094285,
-0.0281628072,
-0.0082532633,
0.0000429904,
0.0070733759,
-0.0178477634,
0.0129579986,
-0.0548240431,
-0.042526871,
-0.0046885386,
-0.0702256858,
-0.0038007,
-0.0583066754,
0.022744121,
0.0124281133,
-0.0269892476,
-0.0388247557,
0.0376357175,
0.0371420346,
-0.0220240578,
0.0393095091,
-0.0262481738,
0.0325643681,
0.0714681,
0.0247761477,
-0.0015682596,
0.0530456305,
0.0270783752,
0.0214992296,
0.0579053536,
0.0077254972,
-0.0117192771,
-0.0067812349,
0.003510457,
-0.0118019814,
0.0074476702,
0.0717315152,
-0.0116996039,
0.0187623352,
0.0209945552,
0.0590584055,
-0.0177515019,
0.0210174918,
0.0699588358,
0.0350006409,
-0.0119217122,
0.0177000202,
0.0461336747,
0.013842864,
0.0342191048,
-0.0029624195,
-0.018795019,
0.0244722832,
-0.0485119447,
0.0121353688,
0.0182385594,
0.0452021696,
-0.0322960168,
-0.0559473187,
-0.006900691,
0.0125184534,
0.0106274439,
0.0420225635,
0.0422062427,
0.0096651791,
-0.0009663988,
0.0779932737,
0.0404201746,
-0.0507851318,
0.025525583,
-0.0492632166,
0.068650201,
0.0655400902,
0.0351654254,
-0.0123745557,
-0.0599600822,
0.0005834648,
0.0265918709,
0.0539623089,
0.0310236551,
-0.0264395401,
-0.0272655133,
-0.0277237706,
0.0007455799,
-0.0305406172,
0.0039129057,
-0.0338095836,
0.034867879,
0.012348026,
0.0317418054,
-0.0610063672,
-0.0277207661,
0.0180248301,
-0.0331768766,
-0.0256122928,
-0.0137419151,
0.0053029759,
-0.0123836994,
0.0358232781,
-0.0130709838,
0.0329501741,
0.0427925587,
-0.016497381,
-0.0445518084,
0.0131497122,
-0.0279163606,
-0.0158308018,
0.0470328145,
-0.0130806249,
-0.0217861012,
-0.0009850939,
-0.0138299214,
-0.0335860737,
0.0082514612,
-0.0286033805,
0.0043452694,
-0.06096825,
-0.0154419122,
-0.0012774873,
-0.0138967838,
-0.0585844032,
0.114811033,
0.0181519818,
0.0111079011,
0.0432914905,
-0.0044280104,
0.0077251978,
-0.0276362821,
-0.0139236115,
0.0275974441,
0.0240982734,
0.0036466813,
0.0424351431,
-0.0008861339,
-0.0606239066,
-0.0231631007,
-0.1167726517,
0.0349168852,
-0.0225644596,
0.0141676031,
0.0206921827,
-0.0175106749,
0.0014030257,
0.0014783067,
-0.0571153387,
-0.0108326022,
0.0152903534,
-0.0085137179,
0.0459546484,
0.0270428471,
0.0075563383,
-0.0065080994,
0.022189701,
0.0052237343,
0.0493296683,
0.0563926212,
0.0312375166,
-0.0466997698,
0.0551028624,
-0.0996637046,
0.0057008089,
-0.0080906237,
-0.0118434969,
0.0115735438,
0.0130125312,
0.0356036797,
0.0316350982,
0.0489937663,
0.0184822399,
0.0276737474,
-0.0170438699,
-0.0374818891,
0.0221100152,
-0.016346572,
-0.0295391437,
-0.0315851606,
-0.0213918909,
0.0107106334,
0.0136177624,
0.0203234367,
0.0081298472,
-0.0366593264,
0.0212569032,
-0.0370700918,
-0.0213244036,
-0.0779168308,
-0.0210961699,
-0.0000915016,
0.0618294887,
-0.0177294537,
-0.0134233665,
0.0491847843,
-0.0369349793,
0.0107606025,
-0.0286246538,
-0.0029688389,
-0.0463820249,
0.0526804738,
-0.0566103347,
0.0330719985,
-0.0016495553,
0.0121561242,
-0.0241968073,
-0.0129588805,
0.0205154512,
-0.065814659,
0.0673885122,
-0.0621584244,
0.0024692791,
0.0186632294,
-0.049633421,
-0.0596167892,
-0.0523267798,
-0.0237216242,
0.0250175744,
0.0240982454,
0.0078217043,
-0.0001578154,
-0.002176651,
0.0707730353,
-0.0108247483,
-0.0033088864,
-0.0104553122,
-0.0048078108,
0.0504588895,
0.0598455891,
0.0561725497,
0.032239683,
0.0102057951,
0.0532065593,
0.048631452,
-0.0065956423,
-0.0195394903,
-0.0057042115,
-0.0245019998,
0.0033975278,
-0.0360612273,
-0.0138126845,
0.0018045773,
0.047091566,
-0.0421284437,
-0.0175247304,
0.1518975496,
0.0289884042,
-0.0006226542,
-0.026441576,
-0.0636025518,
-0.0001128366,
0.0186283235,
0.0191192701,
-0.0645967349,
-0.0170070454,
-0.0069648866,
0.0135225886,
-0.0048120795,
-0.0433821157,
0.0035376847,
-0.1311426014,
0.0339092016,
-0.0304522682,
-0.0186700523,
-0.0593866035,
-0.0400768332,
0.0081043178,
0.0147677166,
-0.0122242309,
0.0453652926,
-0.0029101686,
0.0064491709,
0.0318106338,
-0.0167716555,
-0.0519794077,
0.0656589717,
-0.0298970975,
0.0485515818,
0.0508758985,
0.0382653028,
0.0016646403,
-0.0383666232,
-0.019771507,
-0.0262374319,
0.0275970027,
-0.0058487882,
0.0070542172,
0.0025980715,
-0.0171818901,
-0.0683548823,
0.0085225906,
-0.0175701044,
-0.0115064578,
0.0281880684,
0.0920937955,
-0.0357419327,
0.0047997306,
0.0032554362,
0.0189481955,
0.0184921939,
0.1226068512,
0.0192936659,
-0.0051036109,
0.0127036069,
-0.0199322775,
-0.011234194,
0.0038633966,
-0.0674307421,
0.0232377518,
0.0250334572,
0.0225918461,
-0.0907767639,
-0.0235581435,
0.0406950563,
0.0225442778,
-0.0125483666,
-0.0004909339,
0.0214168001,
0.0115849059,
-0.0228404272,
0.0309702437,
-0.0607953444,
-0.0036601205,
-0.0407460518,
-0.0164882019,
0.0420415178,
-0.053142067,
-0.0163080525,
0.0055343155,
-0.0447746478,
-0.0465716533,
-0.0144664813,
0.0244342778,
0.0243823323,
0.0042689503,
-0.0184686836,
-0.0215650648,
0.0235213842,
0.0202241801,
-0.0608352832,
0.0233154893,
-0.0101618422,
0.0237791743,
0.0038311572,
0.0400942042,
-0.0535835475,
-0.0096380562,
-0.013968911,
0.0543620363,
-0.0099492082,
-0.0943601355,
0.0235936251,
0.0428207591,
0.0242711455,
-0.0084587857,
-0.0110262372,
-0.0317776948,
-0.0116010066,
-0.0260152034,
-0.0491678007,
-0.0319624953,
0.0287717953,
-0.011511839,
-0.0180932712,
0.0120311016,
0.0259925779,
-0.0203635823,
0.052391734,
-0.0286354553,
-0.0179187804,
-0.0145638026,
-0.0027243511,
-0.0040717893,
-0.0007515023,
-0.0394792743,
0.0144162895,
-0.0196755789,
0.0360832699,
-0.0151696745,
0.063347429,
-0.0014027295,
-0.0212881826,
-0.0028206913,
0.0026810919,
-0.04978415,
-0.0713619068,
-0.0130790826,
0.0397495255,
0.0513122194,
0.0159353651,
0.0309247393,
-0.0578447022,
-0.023579469,
-0.0032772475,
-0.0075289072,
0.0336594805,
-0.0455032066,
0.0326079391,
0.0330131873,
-0.0249061789,
-0.0140952598,
0.0959403515,
-0.0182681922,
0.0336905345,
-0.0066814194,
-0.0379081927,
-0.0295154974,
-0.0395563133,
0.0142454682,
-0.0197786652,
-0.009021041,
0.0322257243,
-0.092168279,
-0.0449502692,
0.0136406422,
0.0044743773,
-0.0142476857,
-0.0110990973,
0.0683908537,
0.0736443773,
0.0144081144,
-0.0227705147,
-0.0862251893,
0.0588041395,
-0.0400788337,
0.0385040231,
-0.0156625491,
-6.904557004e-33,
-0.0479427986,
-0.0429001227,
0.0362526663,
-0.0146604124,
-0.039705541,
0.0188934766,
-0.033157222,
0.0127750253,
-0.0466480814,
0.0270244777,
0.0075551383,
-0.001332246,
-0.0048377407,
0.0097595006,
-0.0151228542,
-0.0513548218,
0.0238998886,
0.0054877847,
-0.0374533646,
0.0346492045,
0.0539574735,
-0.008719746,
0.0046811169,
-0.0368435159,
0.040332716,
-0.0254773404,
0.0131116044,
0.0522048511,
-0.0122151962,
0.0525285937,
-0.0144158266,
0.072744146,
0.024429949,
-0.082536988,
0.0087009259,
0.0093161566,
-0.0619894862,
-0.033983361,
0.0620696098,
-0.0307902787,
-0.0354329087,
-0.0270169377,
0.0163622573,
-0.0032918504,
0.0002037178,
-0.0011199219,
0.0308870506,
-0.0191792045,
0.0044206372,
-0.0266874414,
-0.0549982861,
0.0130134486,
-0.0108782696,
-0.0455144793,
-0.0465587825,
0.0162912887,
-0.0031496086,
-0.0098898262,
-0.0545894653,
0.0401649661,
0.0063828286,
0.0110721122,
0.0746504068,
-0.0048600696,
0.021151118,
0.0717639476,
-0.0310305152,
0.0275733694,
-0.0897823125,
-0.0191958789,
-0.0227690674,
0.0451478548,
0.030114973,
0.0696270764,
-0.0362264886,
-0.0010378058,
-0.0740437731,
0.0210175198,
-0.0052421517,
0.063845098,
0.013711011,
-0.0249621999,
-0.0176286306,
-0.0081050033,
-0.0823606402,
0.0580186732,
-0.0375620835,
-0.0186824854,
0.0259606969,
-0.0169037152,
-0.0380474627,
-0.0287046973,
0.007027796,
-0.0179548487,
0.0303777605,
0.0585369505,
-0.015176896,
0.020792637,
-0.0052021998,
0.0031755799,
-0.0437491015,
0.0221628975,
0.021224102,
0.0031531209,
-0.018936228,
0.0403483324,
-0.0243923403,
0.0069351816,
-0.0072869081,
0.0054361671,
-0.0393142551,
0.0179576091,
-0.0085985679,
-0.0544489026,
0.0000455666,
0.0258344878,
-0.0299453307,
0.0321798809,
0.0046283822,
-0.0020031268,
-0.0121716987,
-0.0428547896,
0.0296577588,
-0.0020338821,
-0.0407109633,
0.0374144465,
-0.018880846,
0.0180356801,
-0.0215485338,
-0.0376813374,
-0.00496137,
0.0201257505,
2.79e-7,
0.0375435874,
0.0388473347,
-0.0098461751,
0.0494256914,
0.0080547007,
0.0206401758,
-0.0126353055,
-0.0202014036,
0.0276752803,
-0.0674750507,
-0.0215748884,
0.0735201463,
0.0277119167,
0.0451847948,
-0.070232287,
-0.0203957446,
-0.0490239039,
-0.0547597185,
-0.0370660983,
-0.0098583186,
0.0710223839,
0.0309106596,
-0.0221084747,
-0.0026892947,
-0.0275842231,
-0.0791764259,
0.0499665104,
-0.0146991713,
-0.0375668518,
0.0157520398,
0.077116631,
0.0026428432,
0.0286555719,
0.0311590601,
-0.0053069349,
-0.0081949886,
0.0153347841,
0.0494744182,
0.0196554456,
-0.0210669357,
-0.0239729267,
-0.041433543,
0.0261360612,
-0.0805646926,
0.0864229649,
-0.0314876996,
-0.0095386244,
-0.0180890933,
-0.0176114235,
-0.0048247203,
0.001775715,
-0.0342995413,
-0.0289791152,
-0.0053910664,
0.006775687,
0.0203187931,
0.0141007435,
-0.0234017447,
-0.0279566254,
-0.0121363914,
-0.067483075,
-0.0830766484,
-0.0161327869,
-0.0356059372,
-0.0166096855,
-0.029618863,
0.0330465622,
2.292357707e-34,
0.0178265069,
0.0239635371,
0.0076092998,
0.0138183329,
0.0532476678,
0.0208922978,
-0.035981968,
-0.0190119408,
-0.0023073321,
-0.0741101205,
0.0055367299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07284v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07284v3 | Typing to Listen at the Cocktail Party: Text-Guided Target Speaker Extraction | 2023-10-11T08:17:54 | 2023-10-15T03:58:29 | Xiang Hao, Jibin Wu, Jianwei Yu, Chenglin Xu, Kay Chen Tan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Humans possess an extraordinary ability to selectively focus on the sound
source of interest amidst complex acoustic environments, commonly referred to
as cocktail party scenarios. In an attempt to replicate this remarkable
auditory attention capability in machines, target speaker extraction (TSE)
models have been developed. These models leverage the pre-registered cues of
the target speaker to extract the sound source of interest. However, the
effectiveness of these models is hindered in real-world scenarios due to the
unreliable or even absence of pre-registered cues. To address this limitation,
this study investigates the integration of natural language description to
enhance the feasibility, controllability, and performance of existing TSE
models. Specifically, we propose a model named LLM-TSE, wherein a large
language model (LLM) extracts useful semantic cues from the user's typed text
input. These cues can serve as independent extraction cues, task selectors to
control the TSE process or complement the pre-registered cues. Our experimental
results demonstrate competitive performance when only text-based cues are
presented, the effectiveness of using input text as a task selector, and a new
state-of-the-art when combining text-based cues with pre-registered cues. To
our knowledge, this is the first study to successfully incorporate LLMs to
guide target speaker extraction, which can be a cornerstone for cocktail party
problem research. | [
0.033291623,
-0.0231263135,
0.0035906376,
0.0170534588,
-0.039278727,
-0.0116649773,
0.0271391999,
-0.0301811881,
-0.00411868,
-0.029808538,
-0.083646737,
-0.0189342331,
-0.0123187611,
0.0198088232,
0.0254967306,
-0.0642280728,
0.0212816987,
-0.0713905916,
-0.0029704433,
0.0124923112,
-0.0015107102,
-0.0002372676,
-0.0201991796,
0.0261177961,
0.0027890077,
0.0061394768,
0.0114525575,
0.0145785678,
-0.0097931325,
0.0226874799,
-0.0010166718,
0.040882688,
0.0325890854,
0.0140826693,
0.0000017944,
-0.0310149733,
-0.0121648563,
-0.0286261886,
-0.0190173388,
-0.0480859093,
0.0082732495,
0.0566634275,
-0.0496816151,
-0.0007069515,
0.0323425643,
0.0236238223,
0.0217967499,
0.053078711,
0.0222231802,
0.0286557991,
-0.000391416,
-0.0210452918,
0.0051832623,
0.0119305728,
0.0758866668,
-0.091529645,
0.0300514512,
-0.0712568611,
0.0367815644,
0.028034294,
0.036350444,
0.0559137836,
-0.0231541619,
0.0097274194,
0.1146790013,
0.0470581241,
-0.0405715778,
-0.0206758585,
-0.0521478802,
0.0830753371,
0.0233741943,
-0.0009603378,
0.0331858657,
0.0122010764,
-0.0126553541,
-0.0255308077,
-0.0296089463,
-0.0288715865,
-0.0346114375,
-0.0111517226,
-0.0509723537,
0.0502872728,
0.026392011,
-0.0247077551,
0.0112588778,
0.047259964,
-0.0055701705,
-0.0768035948,
0.0405134559,
-0.0233874153,
0.0136730252,
-0.0410148315,
0.0872423947,
0.0088662487,
-0.059222687,
0.0094467867,
-0.0233318191,
-0.0498694554,
-0.0346382707,
-0.027673034,
-0.0022181012,
0.0135590471,
-0.045751214,
0.0767080784,
0.0183724761,
0.0069707795,
-0.0422433764,
-0.0419376865,
-0.0195226688,
-0.0317366086,
-0.036032591,
-0.0001294612,
-0.0340877399,
0.016015511,
-0.005715685,
-0.0549785793,
-0.005527731,
0.0216612462,
-0.0526976511,
-0.0252094585,
-0.0050016167,
0.020446524,
-0.0444790833,
-0.0104612289,
0.0243597012,
-0.0038034448,
-0.0200649649,
0.0266795717,
-0.0017086219,
-0.0363549963,
-0.0247785803,
0.0414562784,
0.0505092517,
-0.0377235934,
0.0097578829,
0.0840375721,
-0.0183856059,
-0.0543317422,
0.0080183707,
0.00003184,
-0.0443975031,
-0.024723649,
0.000231091,
-0.0415737964,
0.0579916984,
0.0004246881,
-0.0260522291,
-0.0465927944,
0.0092512444,
0.0336832106,
-0.0221534427,
0.0632042587,
0.0113904569,
0.0409462899,
0.0574882776,
0.0145056872,
-0.0544505566,
0.0280098375,
0.0514624119,
0.0390378349,
0.0193001237,
-0.0385704711,
0.0447708666,
0.0984462202,
-0.0161135029,
-0.0135448836,
-0.007257943,
0.0049634073,
-0.0150465788,
0.0176267959,
0.0298147481,
0.0045584175,
-0.006703109,
0.0177995339,
0.0855534971,
0.0597883277,
-0.0125833219,
0.0350756161,
0.0443133414,
0.0068071708,
-0.0343690924,
0.0249411743,
-0.0284120385,
0.0043540313,
-0.0626967177,
-0.0008952484,
0.0989407077,
-0.0215076338,
-0.0096284449,
0.0019990678,
-0.0014992018,
-0.0116281211,
-0.0078426795,
0.0540309027,
0.0374838114,
-0.0130915185,
-0.0475046448,
0.0395423733,
0.0280176327,
-0.0497779995,
-0.0021014183,
-0.0077820877,
0.0091916602,
0.0657233372,
0.0165624861,
-0.0618311688,
0.0163340904,
-0.0090744188,
0.0163176395,
0.0467268862,
0.0088088708,
0.0125313867,
0.0434277467,
0.0066067604,
-0.0316301547,
0.0399150364,
-0.0033072578,
0.032495901,
0.0236733425,
-0.0300192609,
0.0223067533,
-0.01048466,
0.0290179942,
-0.0012557413,
-0.0058189263,
-0.0855022892,
-0.0217274092,
0.021403173,
0.0626413301,
0.02150915,
-0.0300721116,
0.0041522011,
0.0149294594,
-0.0402021557,
0.0336226001,
-0.0092482455,
-0.03028672,
0.0314418972,
0.0139158415,
-0.012109871,
-0.0485903248,
0.0504672974,
0.0218011308,
-0.0255023316,
0.0471817292,
-0.0379425958,
-0.0084911268,
-0.006877739,
0.0219978094,
-0.0003450543,
-0.0059268912,
0.0052020676,
0.0558610708,
0.0337222293,
-0.0214537457,
0.0042210054,
-0.0046618101,
-0.0280138403,
-0.0892724097,
0.0016179653,
-0.011969666,
0.0200808048,
-0.000952778,
-0.0226374809,
-0.0024521402,
-0.0562050194,
-0.053249564,
-0.0499713719,
0.0241493266,
-0.0354494192,
-0.0074485824,
-0.0077169095,
0.0032048372,
-0.0092400117,
-0.0123941246,
-0.0237411708,
-0.0358689316,
-0.0631344914,
-0.0016430502,
-0.0399263017,
-0.0256724637,
-0.0405111052,
-0.0417378359,
0.0101064704,
-0.0022964766,
-0.0022675099,
0.0299802143,
-0.0780223161,
-0.0192793142,
0.0103710927,
-0.0067255651,
0.0181989875,
0.0119000161,
0.0386698656,
0.0031112928,
-0.0161949676,
0.0696565136,
0.0322003104,
0.0074936952,
0.0061472487,
-0.009728916,
-0.0269255564,
-0.0341911539,
0.0261954609,
0.0021065448,
0.0569604822,
-0.0181605779,
-0.0215894114,
0.0621917248,
0.0453446172,
0.022529861,
0.0235573519,
-0.019461412,
-0.001800671,
0.0070374613,
-0.0328478664,
-0.0587833226,
-0.0428255089,
-0.0941103548,
0.0050752056,
-0.0126660811,
-0.0126062296,
0.0711586922,
-0.0334456526,
-0.023845667,
-0.0276955292,
-0.0657954291,
-0.0076488275,
0.0003541067,
-0.0160234552,
0.004717418,
0.0323630236,
-0.065267764,
0.0050419159,
0.0203617513,
-0.0001025741,
-0.0448789448,
0.0463343076,
-0.0093644038,
0.0015372771,
0.0461033583,
-0.0175716504,
-0.0308850799,
-0.0582196899,
-0.0618617609,
0.004583166,
0.0041224435,
0.0236529317,
-0.0434927121,
0.0435555056,
0.0699903294,
0.0158211738,
0.0165617988,
0.0120886583,
-0.0391315557,
0.0145130893,
0.0083642891,
0.03048536,
-0.0540980138,
0.010541928,
-0.0207297932,
-0.0001949115,
0.0917926207,
-0.0246182885,
-0.0212581009,
-0.0007855893,
0.0573214218,
-0.0183684472,
-0.04180656,
0.0613025315,
0.0289101936,
-0.0392597765,
-0.0019371137,
0.0997447222,
0.0069583543,
-0.0613504313,
-0.0180184133,
0.0101825539,
0.0131928874,
0.0114435256,
0.014081426,
-0.0142309843,
-0.0432797298,
0.0541415922,
0.0508682877,
0.0281249266,
0.0233991481,
-0.0353219584,
-0.0824485794,
0.0302585103,
0.0226962082,
-0.0748315305,
-0.040658135,
-0.0319161974,
0.0540300868,
-0.0239783358,
0.0264992639,
0.0440504998,
-0.0082430132,
-0.0299680643,
0.0048394073,
-0.0623434298,
-0.0374723375,
0.0463456213,
-0.0374772921,
0.04954933,
0.0820540041,
0.0389722101,
-0.0103834746,
0.0016318663,
0.0294628721,
-0.0390056409,
0.0142352413,
-0.0018555697,
0.0305011887,
-0.0364250094,
0.0075361948,
-0.0072639473,
0.0590333715,
-0.0017235567,
-0.0030175769,
0.0541643798,
0.0582132451,
-0.024515219,
0.0062343115,
0.0116910106,
0.0699442849,
0.0493504964,
0.0919510946,
0.0703005418,
-0.050872568,
-0.0085380487,
-0.014789544,
-0.0247754045,
-0.0219803397,
-0.0478299558,
-0.0202830303,
-0.0425080955,
-0.0690267086,
-0.0240057223,
-0.0260483734,
0.0142703997,
0.0182796754,
0.0072873286,
0.0311832596,
-0.0119617693,
0.0214527473,
0.0505057238,
0.0511470325,
-0.0316213779,
0.0298401695,
-0.0451588668,
-0.0301353969,
0.0060478644,
-0.0883544683,
-0.0120504498,
0.0562390126,
-0.0431490578,
-0.042400118,
0.0087933689,
-0.0036511468,
0.025075227,
0.0638206899,
-0.0504042171,
-0.101721622,
0.0052296333,
-0.0202125534,
-0.038581118,
0.0376282446,
0.0355444551,
0.0186976343,
-0.0254910886,
0.010060288,
-0.0907369033,
0.0650154054,
0.0084482003,
-0.0123942522,
-0.0567648634,
-0.0186669901,
-0.0183026958,
0.0173885841,
0.0960931703,
-0.004138099,
-0.0022986801,
-0.026018396,
0.0073598069,
-0.0009613351,
-0.0239398796,
-0.0348425247,
-0.0300286692,
-0.0348968804,
0.0053805886,
-0.0308390558,
-0.0342922993,
-0.052859731,
0.0335685313,
-0.0750949383,
0.0028754084,
0.0283853207,
-0.0531000383,
0.0332225561,
-0.0169976093,
-0.0109310411,
0.0130401598,
0.0331250764,
0.0092052659,
0.0271329414,
0.0190388951,
-0.0068173613,
-0.0570355915,
-0.0071834475,
0.0247391984,
-0.0790906996,
0.0220736433,
0.0286223292,
0.0222199615,
0.0335811153,
-0.0085485233,
0.0425588377,
0.0247482937,
0.0116637824,
-0.014296772,
0.030531019,
-0.0300758127,
-0.0231081005,
-0.005616101,
0.017222628,
0.0034041221,
-0.0169506036,
0.0302880909,
-0.0138087273,
-0.0326757133,
-0.0040166355,
0.0192626044,
-0.0459318683,
-0.006302353,
-0.0224616304,
0.0260445364,
-0.0370726697,
-0.0364494249,
-0.0190051999,
-0.0228450447,
0.0629101917,
-0.0346503332,
0.0011890376,
-0.0399933942,
0.0611441806,
0.0383708142,
-0.0365795121,
-0.0127643682,
0.0070031141,
-0.024023287,
0.0042434698,
0.0016993931,
0.0035608537,
-5.963124517e-33,
-0.0518493466,
-0.0300054196,
0.0049061831,
0.0407429822,
-0.0607947335,
-0.0150343161,
-0.0545534417,
-0.011163556,
0.0375018418,
-0.0434100367,
-0.0066789459,
0.0053748242,
0.0215702038,
-0.0005615195,
0.0053842538,
-0.042557776,
0.0640464723,
-0.0116369436,
0.00538343,
0.0294181369,
0.0474366695,
0.0610679984,
0.010341092,
-0.0922598168,
0.0281150993,
-0.0123155294,
0.0165719725,
-0.0282415189,
0.0564746447,
0.0239255819,
0.0044087376,
0.0670648888,
-0.0231757071,
-0.0547690392,
-0.0096453689,
0.0783834904,
-0.0492597856,
-0.030198561,
-0.0222785175,
0.0236601103,
0.0189371873,
-0.0350942276,
0.0688080564,
-0.0051077707,
-0.0164560452,
-0.0242121518,
0.0691717938,
-0.0229824483,
-0.0434502065,
0.0003830472,
-0.040666461,
0.0245242994,
-0.0109873991,
-0.0348974094,
0.0493364707,
0.0889472738,
-0.0153182754,
0.0034819052,
-0.0591417141,
0.0499300845,
-0.0078496085,
-0.0171482433,
0.035653051,
0.0548184551,
0.0173017308,
0.0564157031,
0.0526339561,
-0.0359962955,
-0.0400535464,
-0.0400920436,
-0.0108526731,
0.0741351396,
0.0234161541,
-0.0185232926,
0.0187996272,
0.0230687857,
-0.0064866841,
0.0014241083,
0.0044679223,
-0.0402423218,
0.024536889,
0.0139896395,
-0.0666080713,
0.0060729696,
-0.0095738489,
0.0207004976,
-0.0449327938,
-0.0222688802,
0.0386074707,
-0.0143263452,
-0.0087448154,
0.0028260385,
0.0470521525,
-0.0081970012,
0.0250576288,
0.0078326194,
-0.0251543988,
0.023304943,
-0.0027629635,
0.007578976,
-0.0653638393,
-0.0103279771,
0.0557374805,
0.0148852877,
0.03727239,
0.0092416722,
-0.0328223221,
0.0399369076,
-0.0249832906,
-0.0215327013,
-0.0083831027,
0.0018619354,
0.0105900625,
0.0411199443,
0.0601258166,
0.0024267135,
-0.0263328888,
0.0151344314,
0.0387097746,
-0.0123718958,
-0.0040697902,
-0.0041040187,
-0.0394815728,
0.0173392426,
-0.0412465893,
0.0227408968,
0.0099726245,
-0.0230813362,
0.0294121429,
-0.0284903497,
-0.0143719157,
-0.0124150394,
2.687e-7,
-0.0228850432,
0.0222246535,
-0.0024247793,
0.0123333512,
0.0253227185,
0.0264572687,
-0.0086134057,
0.0322889239,
0.0449829251,
-0.0233834032,
0.018236611,
0.0003806476,
0.0825583711,
0.0285658929,
-0.1043915376,
-0.0129050268,
-0.0568220615,
0.0496220402,
-0.0238172747,
0.0189540833,
0.0271447022,
0.0384140871,
0.0296675637,
-0.0121970195,
-0.0001747711,
-0.0456736311,
0.0253179111,
-0.0563199408,
0.0150086703,
-0.0215996038,
0.0411949158,
-0.0119802356,
-0.0383896902,
0.0447387956,
-0.0328172036,
0.0505522527,
0.0526439622,
0.0659074187,
-0.0035534988,
-0.0523665324,
-0.0250119958,
0.0407606959,
-0.0001978238,
0.0126603087,
0.0868658945,
-0.037355721,
-0.0024985976,
0.030851623,
-0.030066235,
-0.0276682656,
-0.007765417,
-0.0050685727,
0.0064336853,
-0.020859519,
-0.0104116341,
0.0047263415,
-0.0252832025,
-0.0640682206,
-0.009051661,
0.0069956873,
-0.0719416812,
-0.0379304327,
-0.013618134,
-0.0239170995,
0.0178251173,
-0.0544754229,
-0.0133651178,
1.848112448e-34,
0.0135209346,
0.0027811569,
0.00519185,
0.0374414958,
-0.0127421012,
0.0125246001,
-0.0081675425,
0.0214865655,
0.0544862524,
-0.0288911927,
-0.0111256139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07282v2 | An Analysis on Large Language Models in Healthcare: A Case Study of BioBERT | 2023-10-11T08:16:35 | 2023-10-12T07:53:53 | Shyni Sharaf, V. S. Anoop | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper conducts a comprehensive investigation into applying large
language models, particularly on BioBERT, in healthcare. It begins with
thoroughly examining previous natural language processing (NLP) approaches in
healthcare, shedding light on the limitations and challenges these methods
face. Following that, this research explores the path that led to the
incorporation of BioBERT into healthcare applications, highlighting its
suitability for addressing the specific requirements of tasks related to
biomedical text mining. The analysis outlines a systematic methodology for
fine-tuning BioBERT to meet the unique needs of the healthcare domain. This
approach includes various components, including the gathering of data from a
wide range of healthcare sources, data annotation for tasks like identifying
medical entities and categorizing them, and the application of specialized
preprocessing techniques tailored to handle the complexities found in
biomedical texts. Additionally, the paper covers aspects related to model
evaluation, with a focus on healthcare benchmarks and functions like processing
of natural language in biomedical, question-answering, clinical document
classification, and medical entity recognition. It explores techniques to
improve the model's interpretability and validates its performance compared to
existing healthcare-focused language models. The paper thoroughly examines
ethical considerations, particularly patient privacy and data security. It
highlights the benefits of incorporating BioBERT into healthcare contexts,
including enhanced clinical decision support and more efficient information
retrieval. Nevertheless, it acknowledges the impediments and complexities of
this integration, encompassing concerns regarding data privacy, transparency,
resource-intensive requirements, and the necessity for model customization to
align with diverse healthcare domains. | [
0.0807488337,
0.0569409207,
-0.0009911241,
-0.0067788409,
-0.041872289,
0.0134638892,
-0.0008713237,
0.0159578435,
0.055473011,
-0.0419365689,
0.0016463801,
-0.0317124054,
0.0056543136,
0.0444499217,
-0.0090813776,
-0.0140111549,
0.030312296,
0.0345741436,
0.0503902845,
0.0301136076,
-0.0254730508,
0.0102662556,
0.0041698641,
0.0768568367,
0.0443532877,
0.010714123,
0.0349695273,
-0.0064560669,
0.0149178198,
-0.0723733529,
-0.0213035364,
0.0300944708,
-0.0306072216,
0.0182562899,
0.0000018236,
-0.0629350469,
-0.0474794619,
0.0754120946,
-0.028149737,
-0.0447854325,
0.0611640327,
-0.0370801054,
-0.0143103804,
0.007349499,
-0.0002179257,
-0.0149977738,
0.0265826453,
0.0365568772,
0.0485327728,
0.0407639705,
-0.0227356143,
-0.0231352821,
0.022150768,
0.0086634019,
-0.0188964065,
-0.0123364665,
0.0675528795,
-0.0312876292,
0.0671291277,
0.0173054971,
0.0364880748,
0.0432881489,
-0.0364552066,
0.0255175605,
0.0266874079,
0.0102885412,
-0.0101964399,
-0.0350972153,
0.0051070233,
0.0224766657,
0.0104249995,
-0.00205555,
0.0517189987,
0.0294592716,
-0.0066798008,
0.0086028008,
-0.0273967497,
0.0222732369,
-0.047283452,
-0.0070426883,
0.0128650023,
-0.0108168367,
0.0278354567,
0.0124276131,
-0.005266394,
-0.0001819501,
0.0141281476,
-0.0209683776,
0.0089477571,
-0.0348168872,
-0.0071099568,
-0.0429633036,
0.0628353134,
0.0230192039,
-0.012653945,
0.0286543053,
-0.0044594086,
-0.0036040435,
0.1157509759,
-0.0743688717,
-0.0102262404,
-0.0238006767,
0.0222258344,
0.0414181575,
0.0114791756,
-0.0270432364,
-0.0279251616,
0.0118815834,
-0.0196005683,
0.010238504,
-0.0615417957,
-0.0280670673,
-0.0234467089,
0.0522731654,
-0.0020384616,
0.0077663935,
-0.0855324641,
-0.0132316612,
0.0030651703,
0.0422971733,
0.0216788482,
0.0190499518,
-0.0165715478,
-0.0052463952,
-0.0199723169,
-0.032600522,
0.0270084031,
-0.0117975222,
-0.0361702852,
-0.0510612205,
0.0514304638,
-0.0243853685,
0.0075909533,
-0.0152862454,
0.0034827201,
0.0842766091,
0.0438260213,
-0.0373500101,
-0.0046222955,
-0.0608902983,
-0.0284085795,
-0.0080425553,
0.0094019789,
-0.0369186848,
0.0028420247,
0.0045353435,
-0.0217087958,
-0.0348978974,
0.0170170888,
0.0432035923,
-0.0728302598,
0.0488187373,
-0.0597422309,
-0.0072770887,
0.0157287791,
0.0434315167,
0.0296322964,
0.0035930036,
0.0276357438,
-0.0438676178,
0.0110804942,
-0.0121707218,
-0.0030976345,
0.0017854401,
-0.0018546473,
-0.0829093158,
-0.0079422835,
0.0600192808,
0.0030643225,
0.0449749157,
-0.0537838079,
0.0822205096,
0.0149612306,
-0.0131248701,
0.029473532,
0.1195751205,
0.0162466802,
0.0059857103,
-0.0230159275,
0.0008609559,
0.0058715865,
-0.0590475015,
0.0008567803,
-0.0357038714,
0.0015032215,
-0.0279574487,
-0.0438742004,
0.0162375309,
0.0135573857,
-0.0167242605,
-0.0579316914,
-0.0198102612,
-0.0050051063,
-0.0246079694,
0.010999552,
-0.0220732298,
-0.0200644936,
0.0670590401,
0.045104716,
-0.0437388197,
0.0003900071,
-0.0637502596,
-0.0251928922,
0.0949701518,
0.0626662076,
-0.0492994934,
-0.0110157551,
-0.0549679101,
-0.0336299017,
0.0080527803,
-0.0234323908,
-0.0191948488,
-0.002764815,
-0.0204756577,
-0.0092000049,
0.0541672595,
0.0199611373,
-0.0331900008,
-0.0307556223,
0.0382196866,
-0.0246690456,
-0.0043938765,
-0.0186473615,
0.0489861779,
-0.0412178151,
-0.0199630652,
-0.015119303,
-0.0115025863,
0.0275186319,
0.0480399691,
0.0077551594,
0.0501828901,
0.0248731636,
-0.026561249,
-0.0148224002,
-0.0210524909,
0.036814332,
0.0049423655,
-0.0004530141,
-0.0020765527,
0.0259029474,
-0.0093183629,
0.0085177459,
-0.0039334097,
-0.0587133244,
-0.0444593541,
0.0362479948,
-0.0079509877,
0.0231569968,
-0.0092433468,
-0.0144531494,
-0.0842216238,
0.0244580191,
-0.0323856957,
0.0187421665,
-0.0105427289,
-0.0641423464,
0.026010856,
-0.0106166778,
-0.0041247709,
0.0368179493,
-0.0078841792,
0.0162487645,
0.020843247,
-0.0084280977,
0.0036531258,
-0.0179669,
-0.0941053778,
0.0055804122,
0.0284019429,
0.0144148599,
0.0175415631,
0.0305334255,
-0.0003627655,
-0.0259209853,
-0.013887886,
-0.0257151052,
0.0128183197,
0.0226984713,
0.025434792,
0.0343741588,
-0.0402003042,
0.0055898395,
-0.0090310555,
-0.0426702648,
0.0549329296,
0.0116176791,
-0.0249890611,
0.0120704193,
-0.0189140514,
-0.0280195437,
-0.0248484872,
0.0064648166,
-0.0109673794,
-0.0086263232,
0.0022159822,
-0.0353117362,
0.0271139573,
-0.0039172522,
0.0364643224,
0.0197359063,
-0.001102033,
0.0224045515,
-0.0041034482,
-0.0261602737,
0.0159921087,
-0.0155531596,
-0.0463259555,
0.0544220433,
0.0384108908,
0.0076259226,
-0.0201946776,
-0.0120310374,
0.0067780269,
-0.0482638963,
0.0262990035,
-0.0292512216,
-0.0178262759,
-0.0331604034,
0.0351013988,
0.0133299259,
-0.0254487079,
0.0860368311,
-0.0167459901,
0.0463907234,
-0.108772248,
-0.0266778525,
-0.0508032851,
0.0156581663,
-0.0033921427,
0.0432695933,
0.0390436053,
-0.0379702672,
0.0476606376,
-0.0076716742,
0.0041057044,
-0.0817967877,
0.0397078022,
-0.0155036328,
0.0383593813,
-0.0055586239,
-0.0283222087,
-0.0307502039,
-0.0148932748,
-0.0445057638,
0.0270012002,
0.0368130282,
0.0107586654,
-0.0396742858,
0.0454093181,
-0.0146974726,
0.04441135,
0.0225736368,
-0.0203877445,
0.0131884217,
-0.0082137911,
-0.0095034121,
-0.0314793848,
0.0200292952,
0.0323761068,
0.0167645365,
0.067354396,
-0.0257911012,
0.0023640739,
0.0112968525,
-0.0029375346,
0.0033212134,
-0.0709421933,
-0.0132473828,
0.0232909471,
0.0487831682,
-0.0591788106,
0.0165843647,
0.0795681402,
0.0507882982,
-0.0411051288,
0.0333418921,
0.0174573697,
-0.0721855909,
-0.0320787057,
0.011762036,
-0.0343712717,
-0.0203829482,
0.010946353,
0.0184859298,
-0.0530725941,
-0.0521400571,
-0.0051865932,
0.0071487362,
0.0356088541,
-0.0120296869,
-0.0379646383,
-0.0151900528,
-0.0640431195,
-0.0021585159,
-0.0212581381,
-0.0290525593,
-0.0377199724,
-0.0319072902,
-0.0228215717,
0.0095990552,
-0.0857568309,
-0.1211074367,
0.0025696796,
-0.0082363328,
0.029170718,
0.0774075985,
0.0475856252,
-0.0204532519,
0.0157776587,
0.0130749084,
-0.0229562372,
-0.0125032524,
-0.0272603836,
0.0423499756,
0.0226492193,
-0.0054058624,
-0.0949262679,
0.022523649,
-0.016906146,
-0.0394907892,
-0.0050780894,
0.0644009635,
-0.0540829711,
0.0052866582,
-0.0677476153,
-0.0080481376,
0.020561697,
0.0565830097,
-0.0279572941,
-0.0034093079,
-0.0152007025,
0.0087297214,
0.0258135386,
0.0178806894,
-0.0363134481,
0.0263024848,
-0.0286859833,
-0.0240284912,
-0.0408298559,
-0.0159408785,
0.0170737561,
-0.0009670648,
0.0406916961,
0.04935617,
0.0810237974,
0.0108165406,
-0.0672035292,
0.0584564172,
0.038170971,
0.0207909774,
-0.0509067141,
-0.0416054875,
0.0606280304,
0.0280792341,
-0.0210108534,
0.0039873058,
0.0242660847,
-0.0188637432,
-0.0014286367,
0.0219902173,
0.0225841645,
-0.028539652,
0.0034342818,
-0.0509865917,
0.0441164412,
0.0396830589,
-0.0735711679,
-0.0532784313,
-0.0258010011,
0.0219901465,
-0.0218297802,
-0.0017605241,
0.001914836,
0.0242616385,
0.014053246,
0.0102830054,
-0.0094593111,
-0.0166373309,
0.0198027659,
0.0409675129,
-0.0030635789,
-0.013148143,
-0.0020112556,
-0.0317478813,
0.0115575586,
-0.0435287692,
0.0157873798,
-0.0326957591,
-0.0127610397,
0.0332788564,
-0.0046979589,
-0.0148230987,
0.0140380412,
-0.0517204925,
-0.0533438101,
-0.0331654213,
0.0847261548,
0.0179609731,
0.0189314857,
0.0355028026,
-0.0255693346,
-0.0023183755,
0.004265062,
-0.0200711358,
0.0102770729,
-0.0135187116,
0.038769573,
-0.0100868894,
0.0051094834,
-0.018026324,
0.0564936437,
-0.055610504,
-0.0239701401,
-0.0134361731,
0.0289139003,
-0.0002203021,
0.0090301633,
0.0073834537,
-0.0426600762,
-0.0041033402,
-0.0320068002,
0.0154896406,
-0.013688189,
0.0157738756,
0.0466099009,
0.0062045725,
-0.044698067,
-0.0585457534,
0.071810104,
0.0495712645,
0.0279306173,
-0.011148423,
-0.0732224062,
-0.03570522,
-0.0274701603,
0.0433178581,
0.0034608205,
-0.0887417197,
0.0076203365,
-0.0835175067,
-0.0168187506,
0.0399800315,
-0.029003337,
-0.0088349516,
-0.0146707892,
0.033523716,
0.0349061564,
0.0368287563,
-0.0594089441,
-0.0468724854,
0.0601611026,
-0.051533673,
-0.0059106988,
0.0478559546,
-5.173900549e-33,
-0.0007374539,
-0.046868138,
0.0140951863,
-0.0226048678,
0.0220097937,
0.0299093854,
-0.0193872713,
-0.0357488692,
0.0120297857,
0.0195200052,
-0.0148907164,
-0.0216355212,
0.0020166689,
0.0356447995,
0.0161707997,
-0.0281331446,
0.0445031747,
0.0330927521,
-0.0016788399,
0.0202465896,
-0.0181074198,
0.0749481842,
0.0249885786,
-0.0973955989,
0.0343748815,
0.0015766129,
0.0255311206,
0.0284497309,
-0.002238079,
0.0640173703,
-0.0510692559,
0.0054742889,
0.029833097,
-0.0164337028,
0.0097972723,
0.0365806781,
-0.0688865036,
0.0004956326,
0.0101355864,
0.0025323927,
-0.0105092507,
-0.0449245162,
0.0514636561,
-0.0210184902,
-0.0580774173,
0.0065742498,
0.0097583104,
-0.0463235304,
-0.0337118134,
-0.031607613,
-0.0258898605,
0.0489229448,
-0.0022063821,
0.0228635445,
0.0257822126,
-0.0216309372,
-0.0383419842,
0.0448149778,
0.0045841034,
-0.034686435,
0.0471513048,
-0.0104233343,
0.0107429177,
-0.0190689303,
-0.0016453494,
0.0642146692,
0.0114548281,
-0.0008061503,
-0.0170067679,
0.0184628181,
-0.0661974177,
0.0485030413,
0.0358049013,
0.0210075881,
-0.0036551247,
-0.0203793738,
-0.0958839506,
0.0377672724,
-0.0498974919,
0.03731931,
0.0620216243,
-0.0485651381,
-0.0423400216,
0.0039337054,
-0.0196360368,
0.0072537698,
-0.0082968362,
0.0048283804,
0.0150362877,
-0.0023066467,
0.0022503941,
0.0772595331,
0.000053746,
-0.037381947,
-0.0336772427,
-0.0077780625,
0.0749566481,
-0.0150217991,
-0.0340196788,
0.0122512747,
-0.0269637294,
-0.0113797225,
0.0118435593,
-0.033054281,
0.0484986901,
-0.007650977,
0.0085284524,
-0.040535558,
-0.0491662994,
-0.0029958803,
0.0421180539,
0.0155369416,
-0.0094656572,
0.0604636595,
0.0344136134,
0.0159992781,
0.0311917067,
0.052554179,
0.0092013255,
0.0223530382,
-0.0191830602,
0.006486949,
-0.002295784,
-0.00537429,
-0.0134327346,
-0.0149364797,
-0.0116652986,
0.0859080032,
0.0360768884,
-0.0429635197,
0.0157034472,
-0.0353183039,
2.612e-7,
0.1032899171,
0.0570573062,
-0.0258001909,
-0.0650502294,
0.0438467935,
0.0044254255,
0.006792706,
0.0040940885,
-0.0282802209,
-0.0133302948,
0.0192160252,
-0.0145180393,
0.0228744615,
0.0587849505,
-0.0483268946,
-0.0397680961,
-0.0616509169,
-0.0321621336,
-0.0616833232,
0.0042410917,
0.0522501729,
0.0578109175,
-0.0517731346,
-0.0319544896,
-0.0168442875,
-0.0069196532,
0.0096607069,
-0.050200291,
-0.0179195367,
0.0497523956,
0.0281104837,
0.0378608219,
0.0315886438,
0.0365444124,
-0.0177263618,
0.0240997188,
-0.0089950217,
0.096634075,
-0.0696691051,
0.0672490224,
0.0424614735,
-0.0504659787,
0.0245045424,
-0.0292998161,
0.056866616,
-0.0123140607,
-0.0744874775,
-0.0308047719,
0.0177611448,
-0.0547671393,
0.0720205456,
-0.0010896702,
-0.0133748027,
0.0369232073,
0.0192539729,
-0.002312677,
-0.0003050616,
-0.0764491111,
0.0068527875,
0.0363319218,
-0.0160872433,
-0.016587818,
0.0349126011,
0.0038855751,
0.0072265202,
-0.0825421587,
0.0665017813,
2.482340782e-34,
0.0073303264,
-0.0135909608,
-0.0228695069,
0.029451998,
0.0326522104,
0.0033129344,
0.0063099638,
0.0093223322,
-0.0103015183,
-0.0666347593,
0.0231375396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07279v1 | Enhancing expressivity transfer in textless speech-to-speech translation | 2023-10-11T08:07:22 | 2023-10-11T08:07:22 | Jarod Duret, Benjamin O'Brien, Yannick Estève, Titouan Parcollet | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Textless speech-to-speech translation systems are rapidly advancing, thanks
to the integration of self-supervised learning techniques. However, existing
state-of-the-art systems fall short when it comes to capturing and transferring
expressivity accurately across different languages. Expressivity plays a vital
role in conveying emotions, nuances, and cultural subtleties, thereby enhancing
communication across diverse languages. To address this issue this study
presents a novel method that operates at the discrete speech unit level and
leverages multilingual emotion embeddings to capture language-agnostic
information. Specifically, we demonstrate how these embeddings can be used to
effectively predict the pitch and duration of speech units in the target
language. Through objective and subjective experiments conducted on a
French-to-English translation task, our findings highlight the superior
expressivity transfer achieved by our approach compared to current
state-of-the-art systems. | [
-0.0594115146,
0.0611169264,
0.0095015746,
0.0184904709,
-0.0004337868,
-0.0334560238,
0.0560015254,
-0.0343874916,
-0.0234360229,
0.020481104,
-0.0975982025,
-0.0345116258,
0.0146794738,
0.0108084213,
0.0335617736,
-0.0505744293,
0.0139546348,
0.0126296207,
0.0190015119,
-0.0186409894,
0.0121955825,
0.0319732018,
-0.0357859284,
0.0449647456,
-0.0331166759,
0.0085111996,
-0.0553676933,
0.0607157648,
0.0280622877,
-0.0109234639,
-0.0413418338,
0.0250167251,
0.0560998768,
0.0491252765,
0.0000016707,
-0.0162021983,
-0.0224018898,
-0.0042707194,
-0.0132968035,
0.0108713154,
0.1015027016,
-0.0565335602,
-0.0323946215,
0.0107083954,
-0.0169000663,
-0.0459123105,
0.0819412768,
0.0277016442,
0.0193049293,
0.0798350275,
-0.0405109264,
0.007722246,
-0.0246088896,
-0.0453900658,
0.0106773451,
0.009410264,
-0.0223439187,
-0.0458084904,
-0.0379003212,
-0.0343813598,
-0.0683947429,
0.0538574867,
-0.0247730333,
-0.0084533384,
-0.0062044607,
-0.0160241406,
-0.0191466231,
-0.0357739627,
-0.0234285817,
0.0659005344,
-0.0319581181,
0.0235686358,
-0.0089184027,
0.0197138563,
-0.0034516875,
-0.0557642505,
-0.0145004336,
-0.0048403013,
0.0776829123,
0.0106462799,
-0.0156061947,
0.0954860598,
0.0154453805,
-0.054663118,
-0.0267925151,
0.0289137904,
-0.0009162572,
-0.037736766,
0.0505292788,
-0.0248490684,
-0.0067561273,
0.0042404206,
0.0526681654,
0.0010698612,
0.0583992228,
-0.0055620787,
-0.0203833356,
-0.0331987031,
-0.0383384861,
-0.0289615411,
0.0137430262,
0.0701895654,
-0.0184250753,
0.0097934697,
-0.0043555787,
0.0205651075,
0.0193895195,
-0.0370068997,
-0.0541122109,
-0.0120555377,
-0.0252058413,
0.0307006296,
-0.0136967143,
0.0003552865,
-0.0506851897,
-0.016523093,
-0.0275754202,
-0.034192495,
-0.0430829152,
0.0279278345,
0.0094580166,
0.0285028405,
-0.0675560832,
-0.0153139662,
-0.0023680038,
0.1128748655,
-0.0080515929,
-0.0013577638,
-0.0227374788,
-0.0497757867,
-0.0070756571,
0.0303947628,
0.0280314591,
0.0098201837,
0.0152052352,
0.0334957875,
-0.0212431569,
0.0110321641,
0.0003390267,
-0.0002492684,
-0.0314489305,
-0.0703368634,
0.0010834556,
-0.0542956106,
0.0599410459,
-0.0152603369,
0.0179287028,
-0.0599664263,
0.0024237353,
-0.0479651317,
0.0237692147,
0.0621529408,
0.023902731,
0.0198510792,
0.0087565407,
0.0122470856,
-0.0058913603,
0.0558835715,
0.0268606823,
0.0318138301,
0.0294804517,
-0.022888897,
0.0003416819,
0.0497972853,
0.0253249351,
0.0428445935,
-0.052977249,
-0.0682398379,
0.0183563735,
0.0423339084,
0.0648733824,
0.0140362531,
0.0132004293,
-0.0123079726,
0.0665396303,
0.0409771465,
0.0267100055,
0.050070826,
0.0661040246,
0.0380030163,
-0.0113478368,
-0.0019859273,
0.0031180743,
0.0305615738,
0.0196141098,
-0.0106733022,
0.0586267412,
0.045517683,
-0.0464993604,
-0.0397641994,
-0.000121977,
-0.049866952,
0.023623677,
-0.0161977299,
0.0207547154,
0.0047093099,
-0.0300314967,
0.011293429,
0.0157262776,
-0.0903180614,
0.0483856276,
0.0438246429,
-0.0087062744,
0.0387995131,
-0.016268054,
-0.0105807409,
0.0066938982,
-0.0362669565,
-0.0043555172,
0.0385649987,
0.0356561318,
-0.0009978388,
0.1162717491,
-0.0791082233,
0.0101855602,
0.0123912487,
-0.0019329808,
0.0384924039,
-0.0511875227,
0.0828635022,
0.0104821026,
-0.0414510034,
0.0331428945,
-0.0222537518,
-0.0356039517,
-0.0516360775,
0.0456193238,
0.0368238874,
0.0167606752,
0.0296064764,
-0.0068493322,
-0.0105813863,
0.0173542593,
-0.0364486203,
0.0021767588,
0.0325068869,
-0.0551751107,
-0.0419489779,
0.0147198066,
-0.0204662383,
0.0329967104,
0.0051582442,
-0.0228800718,
-0.0545802191,
0.0780363008,
0.0150104547,
0.0343462341,
-0.0011701781,
0.0002157706,
0.0157243926,
0.0495300926,
0.0502020754,
-0.0446077995,
0.035373468,
-0.039223507,
-0.0066938992,
-0.0210830029,
0.0209513344,
-0.020841945,
-0.0414467528,
0.0428126231,
0.0055223098,
0.0353275761,
0.0010087971,
-0.0334146209,
-0.0140102385,
-0.0228462927,
-0.1030975357,
0.0172611699,
0.0097886873,
0.0051631131,
-0.0063431314,
0.0492742993,
0.0017803457,
-0.0119233737,
-0.0808343738,
-0.0500167497,
-0.006121885,
-0.0158502944,
-0.0284065902,
-0.0130762933,
0.0106046535,
-0.0178288706,
0.0002023198,
-0.0034128737,
0.022510238,
-0.0337766036,
0.0145955887,
-0.0196960475,
0.0365468264,
-0.0530652441,
0.0140273971,
0.0088498443,
-0.0600747094,
-0.0154783698,
-0.0068046828,
0.057793282,
0.045285359,
-0.0160434712,
0.0105211111,
0.0496008061,
-0.0210589767,
-0.0589476451,
0.0178859308,
-0.0285931248,
0.0323012993,
-0.0038769313,
0.0057905554,
-0.0423530303,
0.0228451528,
0.0314266235,
-0.0081130927,
-0.0746513158,
-0.0129828779,
0.0186003074,
-0.0420033447,
-0.0062897489,
0.0342678726,
0.0196485352,
-0.0015875589,
0.0060113128,
-0.0548599586,
0.0317830928,
-0.0413135588,
-0.0657381415,
-0.0289590005,
-0.0035999736,
-0.0230023041,
0.0332632363,
-0.0867827833,
0.0234192424,
-0.0094710533,
-0.0163007788,
-0.0225365516,
-0.0177302156,
-0.0045912145,
-0.0496994779,
0.030895764,
-0.0165287517,
-0.0576012321,
0.0063190931,
-0.0295291152,
-0.0055281995,
-0.003214129,
-0.0088404287,
0.0118293362,
0.0225458294,
-0.0298271552,
-0.0174481999,
-0.0067773848,
0.0458101071,
-0.0189696811,
-0.0227446221,
0.0058844588,
0.0161192324,
-0.0032973986,
-0.0120124239,
0.01908057,
0.0101612462,
-0.0390106179,
0.024375746,
0.0030299237,
0.0320170522,
-0.0139466254,
-0.0459466986,
0.022772368,
0.0260212477,
0.0232676454,
-0.0111567779,
-0.020827584,
0.0384022035,
-0.0300895534,
0.060715422,
0.1090670004,
-0.0133344345,
-0.0429545827,
0.0120724458,
-0.0412684754,
0.0298284385,
0.023653388,
0.0332371294,
-0.0249360744,
-0.0254344624,
0.0078153806,
0.0313311741,
0.0449799225,
0.0103632696,
-0.017476365,
-0.1070990562,
0.0190176088,
0.0748510808,
-0.014535577,
-0.0423036069,
-0.0124685504,
-0.0202717241,
-0.0276176315,
-0.0098035419,
-0.0390181579,
0.0091716452,
-0.0246869195,
0.0215800516,
-0.0379773863,
-0.040812552,
0.003083729,
-0.0300391223,
0.0680316389,
0.0075266548,
0.0862632021,
-0.0194967259,
-0.0241809692,
-0.0308203213,
0.0198153481,
-0.0218277425,
-0.0105535164,
0.0381668657,
0.0014699848,
-0.0104366038,
0.0446778275,
0.0266820416,
-0.0118959518,
0.0509560816,
0.0135660283,
0.045654472,
0.0131869391,
-0.0029727109,
0.0130350934,
0.035063535,
0.0254279692,
0.0382859595,
-0.0006606056,
-0.0659240633,
-0.0096658533,
-0.0118386522,
0.0360888503,
-0.006016945,
-0.0565375313,
0.0031993431,
0.0001040722,
-0.0586553887,
-0.0522209704,
-0.0328159221,
0.0056884168,
0.0593933165,
0.0272281971,
-0.0036480359,
-0.0270701144,
0.0087085273,
-0.0080452738,
0.0153093813,
-0.0097157406,
0.0095239999,
-0.0310259536,
-0.0024481842,
-0.0047260257,
-0.0521121435,
0.0350012854,
-0.0281754658,
-0.0258824155,
-0.0506306775,
-0.0064531895,
0.0133287506,
0.0139177665,
0.059609551,
0.0046963217,
-0.004643769,
0.0687200949,
0.0091021499,
-0.0263379645,
0.0019073235,
0.1118188724,
0.0421050452,
-0.0025123216,
0.034193676,
0.0080900276,
0.0616679266,
-0.0318915397,
0.0452439412,
0.023518743,
-0.0855996162,
-0.0352150425,
-0.0037168704,
0.0123519851,
-0.0112331985,
0.0121124433,
-0.0291385464,
-0.0224504638,
-0.034234643,
0.0421368405,
-0.0657070726,
-0.0165022053,
0.0408155993,
0.0332907438,
0.0054862299,
-0.0460509844,
-0.0015002933,
-0.060240116,
0.0290886573,
0.0286155362,
0.0051030833,
-0.0017479749,
-0.0003272631,
0.063039951,
-0.0163583532,
0.0283880234,
0.0139982495,
0.0144799612,
-0.0412085652,
0.007939429,
-0.0034967777,
0.0212057699,
0.0092094168,
0.0232904255,
0.0366296694,
0.0578241274,
-0.00627696,
-0.0596934706,
0.0496006943,
-0.0082512293,
0.0945868939,
-0.0150320437,
0.0348070823,
-0.0275449567,
0.0210227221,
-0.0524432994,
-0.0112095093,
-0.0187239647,
-0.035213653,
-0.0092466874,
0.0575126223,
0.0080500422,
-0.043856401,
0.0130854929,
-0.0088130888,
0.0254506581,
-0.0194944032,
-0.0015729608,
0.0501814708,
-0.0682792142,
-0.0055396813,
-0.0147765409,
-0.043125663,
-0.0761840343,
0.0450133421,
-0.0193381757,
-0.0434104912,
-0.0439932272,
0.0237761922,
0.0227645282,
-0.065678671,
0.0459787622,
-0.023716405,
-0.0147165833,
-0.0427640043,
-0.0274327006,
0.0101970481,
-5.5042354e-33,
0.0122562498,
-0.004349858,
-0.0441543423,
0.0194118936,
-0.0404070765,
0.0219665095,
-0.0397405997,
0.0353915319,
-0.0051652957,
0.0401031412,
-0.0090110041,
-0.0162402466,
0.0099280952,
0.0165334195,
-0.0035701615,
-0.0028424715,
0.0604444258,
0.016057726,
-0.021745218,
0.0494060293,
0.04114566,
0.0349989869,
0.0568149425,
-0.0981979892,
0.0077054184,
0.024496723,
-0.0248243921,
-0.0045287693,
0.0534671694,
0.0410841703,
0.0216956157,
0.0441243239,
-0.039753858,
-0.0105712879,
-0.0120052453,
-0.0115840575,
-0.0436664373,
-0.0258388445,
-0.0179738458,
0.0069627687,
-0.0222840477,
-0.0211676061,
-0.0006416565,
-0.0067125168,
-0.0074082087,
-0.0460191444,
-0.0039075329,
-0.0252302252,
-0.0059015397,
-0.0784674361,
-0.0433734395,
0.013658219,
-0.0140586533,
-0.0339182504,
0.107417576,
0.072118327,
0.0117342276,
-0.0470311157,
-0.0477897264,
0.0305828713,
-0.0565354005,
0.0416285545,
0.0566166528,
-0.0313299485,
-0.0002210581,
0.0176373553,
0.037258476,
-0.0599878654,
0.017591618,
0.0329255015,
0.0723214522,
0.0003123986,
0.0380502194,
0.0243892614,
0.0169110019,
-0.0123846531,
0.001747322,
0.0129462238,
0.0514075235,
-0.0435381196,
0.0168122239,
0.0492859632,
-0.0160686839,
0.0042479965,
-0.050844904,
-0.0417974629,
0.000890213,
-0.0745544061,
0.0122198248,
-0.0120574515,
-0.008670303,
0.007690432,
0.078844592,
-0.0072953356,
0.0110250777,
-0.0043038041,
-0.0268543232,
0.0418978408,
-0.0007977444,
0.0208149906,
-0.0233140606,
-0.0081573939,
0.0447876155,
0.0357622504,
0.038580332,
-0.0159314815,
-0.0124366647,
0.0934991688,
-0.0469512939,
-0.0254016742,
-0.0245219246,
0.0196409207,
-0.028707331,
0.0067081358,
-0.001201322,
-0.0176359527,
-0.0080597661,
0.023388857,
-0.0088185128,
0.0219143722,
0.0004651877,
-0.0005648335,
0.0208356977,
0.0418132357,
-0.0800929889,
0.0198546872,
-0.0167985428,
-0.0451512747,
0.055773858,
-0.018340636,
-0.0156814903,
0.0162369069,
2.533e-7,
-0.0187561978,
0.0019490616,
0.0079867346,
-0.04455553,
0.0107828761,
0.0712272823,
-0.039688766,
0.0036763647,
0.0032220369,
0.0135244569,
0.0119627388,
0.0167214461,
0.107859537,
0.0153176133,
-0.0888055936,
-0.0359742381,
0.0073233475,
0.0381590761,
-0.0097323004,
0.0037481803,
0.0379902571,
0.0833886713,
0.011074922,
0.0099605471,
-0.0076842168,
0.0457659476,
0.0281119179,
-0.0255757887,
0.0004084661,
-0.0240850244,
-0.0133195287,
-0.0274610203,
-0.059515126,
-0.0271792915,
-0.045429647,
0.0191936623,
0.0467739999,
0.0705451444,
0.0162131079,
-0.0743714347,
0.0136233652,
0.03269035,
-0.0461799949,
0.0256507173,
0.0284992047,
-0.0389411822,
-0.0389940962,
0.0178075917,
0.0089870235,
0.0501138903,
0.036765337,
-0.0280282069,
-0.0439352393,
0.0155517021,
0.0405518301,
0.0035895812,
-0.0337623917,
-0.0299413167,
-0.0078218132,
-0.005626014,
-0.0219708364,
-0.0238136295,
0.0060558193,
0.0307601299,
-0.027080914,
-0.0238791816,
-0.0098852357,
1.864377547e-34,
0.0140859857,
-0.0466643907,
0.0258983728,
-0.0378496721,
0.0356290191,
-0.0429470651,
0.0229399279,
-0.0032221791,
0.043236658,
-0.0044177752,
-0.0511053056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07276v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07276v3 | BioT5: Enriching Cross-modal Integration in Biology with Chemical Knowledge and Natural Language Associations | 2023-10-11T07:57:08 | 2024-01-29T03:34:14 | Qizhi Pei, Wei Zhang, Jinhua Zhu, Kehan Wu, Kaiyuan Gao, Lijun Wu, Yingce Xia, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.BM | Recent advancements in biological research leverage the integration of
molecules, proteins, and natural language to enhance drug discovery. However,
current models exhibit several limitations, such as the generation of invalid
molecular SMILES, underutilization of contextual information, and equal
treatment of structured and unstructured knowledge. To address these issues, we
propose $\mathbf{BioT5}$, a comprehensive pre-training framework that enriches
cross-modal integration in biology with chemical knowledge and natural language
associations. $\mathbf{BioT5}$ utilizes SELFIES for $100%$ robust molecular
representations and extracts knowledge from the surrounding context of
bio-entities in unstructured biological literature. Furthermore,
$\mathbf{BioT5}$ distinguishes between structured and unstructured knowledge,
leading to more effective utilization of information. After fine-tuning, BioT5
shows superior performance across a wide range of tasks, demonstrating its
strong capability of capturing underlying relations and properties of
bio-entities. Our code is available at
$\href{https://github.com/QizhiPei/BioT5}{Github}$. | [
0.0290613454,
0.0641871616,
0.0147671644,
-0.0072275163,
0.0190116875,
-0.002035999,
0.0248104483,
-0.0084714042,
0.0617189258,
-0.0375660658,
-0.0351176932,
0.0192083865,
-0.0151351672,
0.0754613578,
0.0464081317,
-0.0048552994,
0.0417491309,
0.0409840904,
-0.0219076239,
-0.0147793442,
0.0151123554,
0.0181837343,
0.0264348201,
0.0012204082,
-0.0052183745,
-0.0373849571,
-0.0011919457,
0.0076834098,
0.0530526489,
-0.0363607444,
-0.0052931686,
0.0540799573,
0.0497962646,
0.0481667221,
0.0000016989,
-0.0317173339,
-0.0344346091,
0.0210783072,
-0.0165673867,
-0.009061004,
0.0705173761,
-0.046625264,
0.0046155117,
-0.0423307344,
-0.0213396698,
0.0034423086,
0.0613188222,
0.064430289,
0.0209349208,
0.0298676956,
0.0061093126,
-0.0188126937,
0.0639380217,
0.003904589,
0.0901559442,
0.0032122356,
0.0440262444,
-0.0169735532,
0.0417699628,
0.0185670685,
0.0125747379,
0.0343038663,
-0.0061024074,
-0.01665527,
0.0423584878,
0.0475159958,
0.0145815117,
-0.0115454961,
-0.0077708899,
0.092871964,
0.023702994,
-0.0107851615,
-0.0278028324,
0.009595193,
-0.0289740488,
0.0229289979,
-0.0375445634,
-0.028753439,
-0.0111097125,
0.0297394637,
-0.0235749129,
0.0070926966,
0.0226808675,
0.0136868106,
0.0338178538,
0.0234850962,
-0.0041270489,
-0.0113532459,
0.0140234297,
-0.0037701502,
0.0059120269,
-0.0039596879,
0.0328358933,
0.0186467078,
0.0383746624,
0.0012861083,
0.0089988355,
-0.0199954323,
0.0741211772,
-0.0141941598,
-0.019179659,
-0.0167921912,
-0.0654257238,
0.0439395234,
-0.0357076228,
-0.0206024796,
-0.0288557783,
0.0213165209,
0.0082667936,
0.0286364928,
-0.0935923457,
-0.0177605115,
-0.013465927,
0.0266230442,
0.0003813175,
-0.0078188227,
-0.0700223297,
-0.0021468524,
-0.0168317407,
-0.0260012913,
0.0076612826,
0.0574630648,
-0.0445059054,
0.0435192026,
-0.0299535617,
0.0360580459,
-0.0118650561,
-0.0324922577,
-0.0450471789,
-0.050997436,
-0.0338991806,
-0.0266069621,
0.0119548859,
-0.0565752536,
0.0300381687,
0.0774312392,
0.0081415828,
-0.0640460029,
0.0164098181,
-0.0473718829,
-0.0354359262,
-0.0658741817,
0.0131892217,
-0.039057523,
0.0618179068,
0.0009921101,
-0.0101521257,
-0.0279286522,
0.0141822444,
-0.0053898362,
-0.0337123126,
0.1179773882,
-0.0420115814,
-0.0744793043,
0.0080932258,
0.0117546543,
0.0111281071,
-0.0064153164,
-0.0089707561,
-0.0243006349,
-0.0152199641,
0.0030482367,
-0.032060042,
-0.0358586311,
0.0254596695,
-0.0580973402,
0.0269524418,
0.0112777995,
0.012392845,
0.0497637279,
-0.0019822032,
-0.0078481175,
-0.0086104833,
-0.0261508245,
0.0358359367,
0.0429560617,
0.0341872349,
0.0225744303,
0.0142228352,
0.0329733454,
0.012192362,
-0.0196219422,
-0.066539757,
0.0479798429,
-0.0568646155,
0.0381473936,
0.0008352496,
0.0702320263,
0.0120505542,
0.0068321391,
-0.0005778522,
0.0010872288,
0.0115767792,
-0.0520451777,
0.0158280507,
-0.0444253162,
-0.0389212221,
0.005131599,
0.0539723076,
-0.0470463932,
0.0241191685,
0.0091858394,
0.01930012,
0.0695816278,
0.0372360907,
-0.0651515946,
-0.0163706765,
-0.0260351598,
-0.0501791239,
0.0367862321,
0.0057472861,
-0.0395760387,
0.0080778059,
-0.0021590106,
-0.027577715,
-0.0409605131,
0.0002855342,
-0.0111582018,
-0.0383666977,
0.0343535654,
0.0012402651,
-0.0156092811,
0.0173383523,
0.0307102706,
0.007679889,
-0.0379648656,
-0.0355776064,
0.000715516,
0.0204155259,
0.0352990776,
0.0036829372,
0.0202597138,
0.0572842546,
-0.0360739417,
-0.0026511438,
-0.0082160421,
-0.0164253954,
-0.0592222847,
0.0453998633,
-0.034695603,
-0.0402190574,
-0.0061417446,
-0.0479778089,
-0.0355255529,
0.0429847799,
0.0091958744,
0.0099713868,
-0.0426687151,
-0.0223469529,
0.0375716947,
0.0492677651,
-0.0214093979,
0.0699497685,
0.0440215729,
-0.0261587556,
0.0014094204,
-0.0355018564,
0.0172983781,
-0.0236622933,
0.0357385799,
-0.0110648628,
0.0452805161,
0.008225224,
0.0181363951,
0.0027123729,
-0.0628538281,
0.0118816895,
-0.0805780515,
-0.0107046906,
0.0289549008,
0.0134714264,
-0.0194741879,
-0.0088869045,
0.0213041026,
-0.0160178803,
-0.054431472,
0.0024225912,
-0.0542635657,
0.0056794407,
0.0390110351,
0.024663385,
-0.0282195266,
-0.0502752401,
-0.0001477225,
-0.0787407607,
0.0527071357,
0.0146511067,
-0.0650612339,
0.0332944877,
-0.0262870863,
-0.0247910731,
0.0281257145,
0.0033382301,
0.0151824076,
0.0051859086,
0.0112694874,
-0.0008448625,
0.0218717754,
-0.0136231566,
0.0306748282,
0.0506800786,
0.0163618475,
-0.0283296797,
0.0401843302,
-0.0210976955,
0.0238639563,
0.0260706693,
0.0144667011,
-0.0255213622,
0.0400119051,
-0.0256566536,
-0.012800578,
-0.0472376794,
0.0353841335,
0.0303926971,
-0.0321702696,
-0.0302247591,
0.0218404438,
-0.0134544699,
-0.0019694834,
0.0090121776,
-0.0393865518,
0.102986373,
-0.0118845478,
-0.0064742225,
-0.0322955288,
0.0060298718,
-0.0008737572,
0.0245599449,
0.0324153341,
0.0259921495,
0.0587885864,
0.0029017921,
-0.0003920931,
0.0064747017,
0.0162977073,
-0.0171653293,
0.0126829967,
-0.0259626377,
0.0309759397,
0.0003544478,
-0.0342647582,
-0.0002734434,
0.016797211,
-0.0438832231,
0.0312746055,
-0.002981341,
-0.0578340665,
-0.0101529434,
0.0067514651,
0.0201281495,
-0.0119774071,
-0.0166940279,
-0.0174223073,
-0.0155742774,
0.0147266164,
0.0538356267,
-0.0385284498,
0.0374679938,
-0.026504619,
0.0187838897,
0.0557163171,
-0.0118546365,
0.0014668293,
0.0067744469,
0.055371739,
-0.0118902223,
-0.0184943024,
-0.0218100753,
0.0059750155,
0.0256980453,
-0.0351135954,
-0.0075488868,
0.0745646134,
0.018874608,
-0.0266000796,
0.0221159663,
-0.0207043234,
-0.0236556921,
-0.0140730552,
0.0556492694,
-0.1096598804,
-0.0530769154,
-0.0733703747,
-0.0069132624,
-0.0061947028,
-0.0625608563,
0.0033758476,
-0.0372455418,
0.054541029,
0.036517594,
-0.0560247377,
-0.0151623562,
-0.0641986355,
-0.0172760263,
-0.0374360643,
-0.0069387895,
-0.0167975668,
-0.0259171817,
-0.0052204719,
0.0023959789,
0.0275155343,
-0.067914851,
0.0366971493,
-0.0179208647,
0.0004712862,
0.0448073298,
0.0429529324,
0.0215028003,
-0.0219254754,
-0.0372536816,
-0.0065307524,
0.0284274053,
-0.0092958547,
0.1061622873,
-0.0454566777,
0.0022759903,
-0.0456907675,
0.0179279409,
-0.0520822853,
-0.0398960412,
-0.0726040751,
0.115991272,
0.0121599818,
-0.0162841268,
-0.0569058508,
0.0259810425,
-0.0149087412,
0.066842325,
0.0175393596,
0.010348781,
-0.0745866224,
-0.0090188831,
0.0563838258,
-0.0268096775,
-0.0371080078,
0.0321189612,
-0.0363736972,
-0.0340253524,
-0.0386495665,
-0.0647314563,
0.0808697641,
-0.0098426798,
-0.0181998517,
0.0133000501,
0.0045485059,
-0.0360858478,
-0.0807427689,
0.0718529001,
0.0214094166,
0.0179399513,
-0.0047828997,
-0.060242787,
0.0650501326,
-0.0094654849,
-0.001923295,
0.0536880568,
-0.0117565393,
-0.0843579024,
-0.030950848,
0.0171006974,
0.0263912398,
0.0203083418,
0.0058586248,
-0.038942609,
0.0704502612,
0.0859048143,
-0.0349116251,
-0.0557880029,
0.0069713695,
-0.0055224719,
-0.0232521743,
0.0138245281,
-0.0304273218,
-0.0156469066,
-0.0076665194,
0.0212699752,
-0.0001806922,
-0.0587312542,
0.0742838904,
-0.0004960847,
0.0460861027,
-0.0046187672,
0.0127629275,
-0.0295971781,
-0.0300834291,
-0.0171891041,
-0.0096335188,
-0.0025306353,
-0.0241349451,
0.016945973,
0.0032640633,
-0.0109360311,
0.019672567,
-0.0420115218,
0.0070560751,
-0.0249925088,
-0.0184175819,
0.0211689714,
-0.0176264364,
0.0520760529,
-0.0152506493,
-0.0048698946,
-0.0160123371,
-0.0174319725,
0.0080109229,
-0.0393721685,
0.0191890784,
-0.0061867433,
0.0295724925,
-0.0491294675,
0.0394357368,
-0.0458420813,
0.0193663239,
-0.0620683581,
0.0254070964,
0.0428279638,
-0.0200974196,
0.041712597,
-0.0126522724,
-0.0208218712,
-0.0187281948,
0.0183135867,
-0.0149670737,
-0.0046705143,
0.0915435627,
0.036377728,
-0.0289415475,
-0.0444120355,
0.0580786318,
-0.005077763,
0.0939796939,
0.0180619638,
-0.0298801865,
-0.0312391054,
0.0010942924,
0.024909202,
0.0104083372,
-0.0454644412,
0.002302147,
-0.0619613826,
-0.0661095977,
0.0813596621,
0.0067225364,
-0.0350253992,
0.0322414823,
0.0182208288,
0.0099305985,
0.0444747433,
-0.0950574651,
0.0042596641,
0.0574624464,
0.0262985304,
-0.0324011222,
-0.0115085589,
-5.657015135e-33,
-0.0152763389,
-0.0161272883,
-0.0084646428,
0.0015549007,
0.0098221553,
-0.0101943193,
-0.06875249,
-0.012418366,
0.0147789093,
0.0961272344,
-0.0035894746,
-0.0187430717,
-0.0053285793,
-0.0443660803,
-0.0122766728,
-0.0072659999,
0.0206465591,
0.0029896453,
0.0275334977,
0.0419191048,
0.0513697602,
0.0783271864,
0.0756262541,
-0.0681377575,
0.003454427,
0.0521134213,
0.0068616024,
-0.0037152115,
-0.0188965276,
0.0320524164,
-0.0552149639,
0.0443771258,
-0.0068748612,
0.0188769884,
-0.019176485,
-0.0051604016,
-0.0746441707,
-0.0087818988,
-0.0035326539,
-0.0056626354,
-0.0556067191,
-0.0234025083,
0.0261572674,
-0.0306532457,
-0.0049232617,
-0.0173108708,
0.065139547,
-0.0036436587,
-0.0276560169,
-0.0400893092,
-0.0792500526,
0.0191536006,
-0.0072187888,
0.0048170127,
0.0324843302,
-0.0184799246,
0.0373585559,
0.046830751,
-0.0197738819,
0.0199459568,
-0.0159855615,
-0.0102981506,
0.0586212501,
-0.0219724253,
0.0219426509,
0.0819494724,
0.0134722963,
-0.0369259976,
0.0033880339,
-0.0017057183,
0.013891737,
0.0422916301,
0.0230913516,
0.0490084067,
0.0043465518,
0.0445932858,
-0.0915303379,
0.0407412611,
-0.0302770231,
0.0267245416,
-0.0615384243,
0.0230495203,
0.001144089,
-0.0146088684,
0.0178099107,
0.0026442355,
-0.0182288475,
-0.0374378227,
-0.0451459438,
-0.0577315427,
-0.0581643991,
0.0345853008,
-0.0086609563,
-0.041578766,
-0.0561512671,
0.0283612646,
0.0168122631,
0.01052651,
-0.0117589356,
-0.0047372021,
-0.0381084904,
-0.028759608,
0.0401240215,
-0.01941045,
0.0354268812,
-0.0235455278,
0.0512929708,
0.0044115488,
-0.0187335592,
-0.0086430172,
-0.0393008143,
0.0127586499,
0.0308496654,
0.0183688365,
0.0260723364,
0.0329826884,
0.0005040494,
0.057617303,
0.0491555259,
-0.0007188748,
-0.0150369909,
0.0405548438,
0.0223885346,
0.0294588134,
-0.04589184,
-0.0219834615,
-0.0306393653,
-0.0013370336,
0.0450127944,
-0.0693937838,
-0.0332925878,
-0.0001283333,
2.576e-7,
0.081232734,
0.0427042171,
0.0604352877,
-0.014078957,
0.002003697,
0.0602505542,
-0.0124067133,
0.0491858087,
-0.0583798923,
-0.0595140792,
0.0121846041,
0.0075652166,
0.0020802713,
0.0101010008,
-0.010340319,
0.0083105937,
-0.0309708137,
-0.0369810499,
-0.046444267,
0.0187524538,
0.0287741739,
0.0676759928,
0.0012947441,
-0.0144436425,
0.0447773077,
-0.034715306,
0.0642310083,
-0.0011336806,
-0.0040445807,
0.0488142818,
-0.0335205272,
-0.0347393304,
-0.0107196644,
0.0336358137,
-0.0242835153,
-0.0326842628,
0.0184420515,
0.0262512267,
-0.0474425443,
-0.0123642599,
0.0248255804,
0.0082526067,
0.0241085403,
-0.0108280815,
0.0158324633,
-0.0554644056,
-0.0431431532,
-0.0129244849,
-0.0349572785,
-0.0150464987,
0.0370712839,
-0.0057428936,
-0.0122724203,
0.0608031228,
-0.0102005685,
0.008137065,
-0.0117735406,
-0.0945209935,
-0.0124924006,
0.0138714062,
-0.0240020193,
0.0349190049,
-0.0112782335,
0.0018247522,
0.0526704118,
-0.0656569079,
-0.0180549547,
2.28223996e-34,
0.0335656554,
-0.0115027493,
0.0352786593,
0.0032782275,
0.0394393317,
-0.0114141032,
-0.0308007002,
-0.0049260166,
0.0096246153,
-0.077034004,
-0.0398515724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07251v1 | Ethical Reasoning over Moral Alignment: A Case and Framework for In-Context Ethical Policies in LLMs | 2023-10-11T07:27:34 | 2023-10-11T07:27:34 | Abhinav Rao, Aditi Khandelwal, Kumar Tanmay, Utkarsh Agarwal, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this position paper, we argue that instead of morally aligning LLMs to
specific set of ethical principles, we should infuse generic ethical reasoning
capabilities into them so that they can handle value pluralism at a global
scale. When provided with an ethical policy, an LLM should be capable of making
decisions that are ethically consistent to the policy. We develop a framework
that integrates moral dilemmas with moral principles pertaining to different
foramlisms of normative ethics, and at different levels of abstractions.
Initial experiments with GPT-x models shows that while GPT-4 is a nearly
perfect ethical reasoner, the models still have bias towards the moral values
of Western and English speaking societies. | [
-0.0003168755,
0.0788906366,
0.0055838679,
0.0214435179,
-0.0827952847,
0.004874974,
0.0169489738,
0.0110191461,
-0.02231328,
0.0113625722,
0.0011435852,
0.0086003561,
-0.0281103011,
-0.0623418801,
-0.0086160703,
-0.0006455096,
0.0324195065,
0.0053343684,
0.0295944307,
-0.0396359451,
-0.0087071797,
0.0230195355,
0.0390203856,
-0.0266600065,
0.0293154698,
0.0116679417,
0.0027574936,
-0.0017961877,
0.0711498186,
-0.005907659,
-0.0205663927,
-0.0308256987,
0.0285695214,
-0.0361642838,
0.0000018959,
-0.0510519557,
-0.0193810724,
0.0065154945,
0.0280496776,
-0.0097199595,
0.0109487129,
0.015440559,
-0.00552226,
-0.0002540718,
-0.0336587913,
0.0921086371,
-0.0043748161,
0.034045741,
-0.0129780797,
0.0679449067,
0.0184928514,
-0.0338791758,
0.037604019,
0.0078207357,
0.0022493163,
-0.0436192751,
-0.005103474,
0.0230904426,
0.0067874696,
0.0309518557,
0.0008371971,
0.0279217567,
0.0282240752,
-0.0005502875,
-0.0375397727,
-0.0414450131,
0.0436315648,
-0.0170967728,
0.011097067,
0.0092192739,
0.0634767488,
0.0054438477,
0.0408203378,
0.0198754873,
0.0245525818,
-0.0078302203,
0.0227997638,
0.064919889,
-0.0368345194,
0.0429519564,
0.0898706689,
0.0053269221,
0.0337424353,
0.0541829728,
-0.0039310665,
0.0268865265,
-0.0244265161,
-0.0133182146,
-0.0058618579,
0.0141180316,
-0.0119983405,
-0.0010219823,
-0.0184714496,
0.0834696069,
-0.038088575,
0.0389910601,
0.025846405,
0.0874843672,
0.0448005833,
-0.0020317771,
-0.0119226696,
0.0347383134,
0.0354587249,
0.0014695362,
0.0093032047,
0.0088539664,
-0.0592252761,
0.079217501,
-0.021442011,
-0.0082446598,
0.0025264146,
-0.0015120526,
0.0318189114,
0.0338691957,
-0.0133364089,
0.082266219,
-0.0093033658,
0.0033790383,
-0.0672803298,
0.0578501485,
-0.0166091416,
0.0000579594,
0.0244998746,
-0.0452893749,
-0.0612062626,
-0.0005362782,
-0.0260721408,
0.014519061,
-0.0055164467,
-0.010911528,
0.0120477863,
-0.0428599864,
-0.0312311612,
0.0008420734,
0.023966765,
0.108427383,
0.0079534724,
0.0420698635,
-0.0588052683,
-0.0361860134,
-0.0071318815,
-0.0561790429,
-0.0063165822,
-0.035422381,
0.0153976725,
-0.0321359262,
-0.0032821072,
-0.0640467927,
0.0182600338,
0.0106142387,
0.0178251974,
0.0331665091,
-0.0150318434,
0.0117541011,
0.0017409464,
0.0542828813,
-0.0045015393,
0.0232157614,
0.0028788405,
-0.0068635158,
0.0206750277,
-0.0199614782,
0.024326263,
-0.0168248713,
-0.0339072496,
-0.0103721423,
-0.0303052645,
0.0180901233,
-0.0439293496,
0.0199419223,
0.0052369088,
0.0078814207,
-0.0196475852,
0.0216371994,
0.007039221,
0.0978654251,
0.0167210866,
0.0115782935,
0.0018643942,
-0.0641842037,
-0.0227359496,
0.0071669985,
-0.060298577,
0.0373036824,
0.0083311806,
0.0095192371,
-0.0943166912,
0.0452226475,
-0.0240563471,
-0.0710151717,
0.0331177749,
-0.0151293268,
-0.020529002,
0.0357874334,
-0.0296137463,
-0.0540223233,
0.0353888832,
-0.0220894329,
-0.0000635464,
-0.0705015808,
-0.0117900316,
-0.0255684648,
0.0897879303,
0.0528606772,
0.0166537575,
0.0003583668,
-0.0653514862,
-0.0347070731,
-0.0475841798,
0.0056382315,
0.0005669754,
-0.0144408718,
-0.0026562996,
-0.0653316304,
-0.0659163371,
-0.0307933204,
-0.0303319003,
0.0119657693,
-0.0335152894,
0.009783661,
0.005517113,
-0.0422691144,
0.0234794095,
0.0041843047,
-0.0188602339,
0.0220472049,
-0.0642201751,
0.0146405157,
0.0351161696,
0.0212130193,
0.0219673198,
0.0045594391,
-0.0000964145,
0.0065386482,
0.0177490618,
0.0005294336,
-0.0479400605,
0.049785912,
0.0227271635,
-0.1047083214,
-0.0178294834,
-0.0156919584,
-0.0361710936,
0.028069457,
-0.0696834251,
0.0182389468,
0.0092665991,
-0.0395377725,
-0.0099577336,
-0.0635396615,
-0.0443780087,
-0.0345258713,
0.0465708524,
-0.0058211219,
0.0026605395,
-0.0074317493,
0.0235461723,
0.0396690816,
-0.034203697,
0.0072372295,
0.0371340774,
0.000229913,
0.0344168022,
0.0336363092,
0.0469218418,
-0.0124175064,
-0.0226850566,
-0.0351979882,
0.0423678681,
0.0239043199,
0.0022181843,
-0.0304937884,
-0.0221569836,
-0.0082954634,
0.0329688117,
-0.0512181744,
-0.0098935599,
0.0178096406,
-0.004566153,
0.0456813686,
-0.055921644,
-0.0015131324,
0.0242198128,
0.0108074248,
-0.0114381099,
-0.0403008312,
-0.0126488395,
0.0159365796,
-0.0521878749,
0.0360761806,
-0.079829067,
-0.0257048216,
0.0228111148,
-0.0180851892,
-0.0067146104,
0.054511413,
-0.0346292518,
0.0376152657,
0.0363377072,
0.0103836926,
0.0145558119,
0.0517159216,
-0.0411011502,
-0.0109843807,
0.0130953444,
-0.0008411392,
-0.028338084,
-0.0149284536,
-0.0334775113,
-0.0026249299,
-0.0425406769,
0.0273511186,
-0.0231086444,
0.0382248908,
-0.005387736,
-0.0074075996,
0.0225536544,
-0.071384415,
-0.0094097489,
0.0752213225,
0.0014031461,
-0.04820152,
0.0239552725,
0.0535803065,
0.0349426121,
-0.0150081431,
-0.0207032878,
-0.055224672,
0.022287542,
-0.05920076,
0.0200537648,
-0.0074409214,
-0.0246703252,
-0.0322614871,
-0.0222535636,
0.0615119189,
-0.043344263,
0.1218034402,
-0.0200608019,
0.0122131566,
-0.0444449186,
-0.075831309,
-0.0348502584,
0.0030497722,
-0.0212327559,
-0.0121959019,
-0.0343576334,
0.0170469899,
0.0173558369,
-0.0208464935,
0.0534042679,
-0.0424060859,
0.0146741448,
-0.0014756243,
-0.0201553386,
-0.0708078817,
-0.0392392389,
0.0004919927,
0.0387093537,
0.0046776463,
0.0366676003,
0.0499876738,
-0.0166628715,
-0.0536871925,
0.013007883,
0.0486269221,
0.0264051147,
0.0118160835,
-0.0206818953,
-0.0003483967,
0.0690605864,
-0.0078726057,
0.022843359,
0.0954233781,
-0.0315163285,
-0.0424951687,
0.0022101549,
-0.0495585501,
-0.043228142,
-0.0082096308,
0.0112837246,
-0.0561051331,
0.0141307311,
-0.0030579311,
0.0156202745,
-0.0965839028,
-0.0321044922,
0.0174280833,
-0.0375825949,
0.0442387238,
0.0556502528,
0.0430399701,
-0.0072587128,
0.0484215952,
-0.016643187,
-0.0309216157,
0.0478366688,
0.012767368,
0.0061884285,
-0.030467188,
0.0347655527,
0.0393776037,
0.0479751192,
0.0255031679,
-0.0250459146,
0.0334004276,
0.0554925799,
0.0304376092,
-0.0183728226,
-0.1014641002,
0.0034304732,
0.0235842224,
0.0124540422,
0.0374870785,
-0.0675945878,
-0.014783239,
-0.0101857977,
-0.0728578046,
0.0022528721,
0.0075493008,
-0.0526251905,
0.0292274673,
0.0760691538,
-0.0599125847,
-0.0212422106,
-0.0080164075,
-0.0235639531,
-0.0798642188,
0.0401815623,
-0.0250684451,
0.0027249814,
-0.0146369459,
-0.0106818071,
-0.0702037588,
0.0198896024,
-0.0112965256,
-0.0201494154,
-0.021159349,
0.0243514497,
-0.0019540903,
-0.0323925912,
-0.0330097862,
0.0388980322,
0.0241345242,
-0.0652413741,
-0.0033321271,
-0.0047108531,
0.0025068065,
-0.00168744,
-0.026106704,
-0.0010036816,
0.004820914,
0.0601913333,
0.0213166773,
-0.0331779569,
0.0320895128,
-0.0422315486,
0.0774238333,
-0.0204728227,
-0.0148558691,
0.037094824,
0.0284638889,
0.0411665402,
0.0089117931,
0.0316075459,
0.0318307728,
0.0430392772,
-0.0253825188,
0.0264039375,
0.0355911367,
0.0393010043,
-0.0129535934,
-0.0001762939,
0.0001005415,
0.0007425096,
0.0300960485,
-0.0020399694,
-0.0543903261,
0.000777405,
0.0549808517,
0.0205746982,
-0.0413736291,
-0.0169270635,
0.0075997259,
-0.017449975,
-0.0317261517,
-0.0097122872,
-0.0267990921,
-0.0038204375,
-0.0045661074,
0.0371502899,
-0.0376864336,
0.007697043,
0.0015969357,
-0.0022957802,
-0.0286296401,
0.0102527933,
0.0491592176,
-0.0134259909,
0.0251095388,
-0.0272530932,
0.0093013691,
-0.0224943981,
0.024064444,
-0.0096548162,
0.0546930656,
-0.0106868818,
0.0940275863,
0.0269627813,
0.0463842638,
0.030334102,
0.028587345,
-0.0928251445,
-0.0842444822,
0.0236665756,
-0.0167252924,
-0.0069528394,
0.0186585691,
-0.0184152238,
-0.0007597338,
0.0271979459,
0.0274110027,
0.0255107917,
0.0105661713,
-0.0048059621,
0.0060451785,
0.0135006281,
-0.0105500193,
-0.057519123,
0.0052680736,
-0.072186254,
0.0139767379,
-0.0119763631,
0.017053552,
-0.0001837592,
-0.0575816855,
0.0204011276,
-0.0524949394,
0.0051612533,
-0.0531537011,
-0.0635072291,
-0.0326668806,
-0.0515055321,
0.0090251612,
-0.0497048572,
-0.0182011798,
-0.0299735498,
0.0247366745,
0.0145686939,
-0.0251611881,
-0.0046438631,
-0.0022164136,
-0.028799152,
0.0370800048,
-0.006553933,
-4.936807379e-33,
-0.008255465,
-0.032636974,
0.037677478,
-0.011913674,
-0.0475641824,
-0.0560941808,
0.0282781962,
0.0074210749,
-0.0814066678,
0.034759406,
-0.0345763937,
0.0129636638,
0.0028599256,
-0.0376762971,
0.0139118163,
-0.0798620284,
-0.0184775945,
0.0405407287,
0.0044382135,
-0.0045625512,
-0.0492600687,
-0.0383154042,
0.0615442619,
-0.0408317223,
0.0536123328,
0.0384978168,
-0.0260454547,
0.0151505172,
-0.0487718768,
0.0030759955,
0.0293075349,
0.0227033235,
0.004505998,
-0.0060456106,
0.0150697445,
0.0306647886,
0.0185542684,
-0.0156318769,
0.0620154478,
-0.0501345582,
-0.0170144606,
-0.0846689492,
0.004557556,
0.008754977,
-0.0463629775,
-0.0074738669,
0.015768962,
-0.0290834624,
0.0179587062,
-0.0116163669,
-0.0452923588,
0.0088689197,
-0.0573015362,
0.025094403,
-0.0251882952,
0.0052144281,
-0.0192236211,
0.0235395059,
0.0142174168,
0.0079960013,
0.0003189288,
-0.0927963257,
0.0631494224,
-0.0380784981,
-0.0099760434,
0.0546463653,
-0.0135630332,
0.0182109401,
-0.0632091835,
-0.016202366,
-0.0605795346,
0.0785546079,
0.0318827033,
0.0426092669,
-0.0560577735,
0.0023791906,
-0.0570025817,
0.0279165078,
0.0145436125,
0.0591124669,
0.0103744101,
0.0084554413,
-0.0205509923,
0.0051543275,
0.0049891411,
-0.05109464,
-0.0138049955,
-0.0206353664,
0.0116087655,
-0.0436185896,
-0.000534396,
0.012833287,
-0.0068126894,
-0.0374254473,
0.0446159355,
0.0223075468,
0.0468374938,
-0.0354207642,
0.0056114001,
0.0148947081,
-0.0095655965,
-0.0259612557,
-0.0288998485,
0.0034488742,
0.0521017015,
0.0158089977,
0.0056086392,
-0.0043157567,
-0.014005769,
-0.0106607126,
-0.0710617527,
0.0276838187,
-0.0131531851,
-0.03715951,
0.0189540777,
0.0146077722,
0.0190061815,
-0.0041783275,
-0.0277463961,
-0.0294066612,
-0.0250999909,
-0.0057736249,
-0.0191960651,
0.0249041058,
0.0167137962,
0.0040448043,
0.0240484588,
0.0696977079,
0.0418991484,
0.0080708163,
-0.0080505013,
0.0485637262,
2.629e-7,
0.0214367565,
-0.068267867,
0.0060496256,
-0.0060191955,
-0.0274688993,
0.0531070419,
0.0007804924,
0.0399695225,
0.0047367588,
-0.0604337752,
0.0534314178,
-0.0052891355,
0.0401751809,
-0.0062987558,
0.0203185715,
-0.0089348257,
0.0138422912,
-0.0591904186,
-0.0187064819,
0.0831469148,
0.0479937345,
-0.0026012769,
0.0059046606,
-0.0248900224,
0.022884015,
0.0427075475,
0.0356528834,
-0.0808367506,
-0.0111254724,
0.0129766362,
0.0144269885,
-0.0177077893,
0.0373352356,
0.0066569685,
0.0610843115,
-0.0101019666,
0.0077001411,
0.0920357332,
-0.0189330727,
-0.0621939562,
-0.0610992312,
-0.0653181747,
0.0037346641,
-0.053036768,
0.0587548949,
0.0712164864,
-0.0131952204,
-0.0105142258,
-0.0079495637,
-0.0315423161,
-0.0003396755,
0.0189345907,
0.0041079819,
0.007495854,
0.0095070517,
-0.0054462794,
0.0028780813,
-0.0475774184,
0.0069741537,
0.0006305885,
0.0246836096,
-0.0545440018,
0.0398401357,
0.0709584132,
0.0666254461,
-0.0589202307,
-0.0196308624,
1.904183528e-34,
-0.0383129306,
-0.052673649,
0.03872988,
0.0640971139,
0.0267261695,
0.0963429287,
-0.0329397507,
0.0094912415,
0.0218804963,
0.0174370576,
-0.0033471994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07225v2 | Exploring the landscape of large language models in medical question answering | 2023-10-11T06:26:19 | 2024-03-09T23:26:34 | Andrew M. Bean, Karolina Korgul, Felix Krones, Robert McCraith, Adam Mahdi | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid development of new large language models (LLMs), each claiming
to surpass previous models, an overall picture of medical LLM research can be
elusive. To address this challenge, we benchmark a range of top LLMs and
identify consistent patterns which appear across models. We test $8$ well-known
LLMs on $874$ newly collected questions from Polish medical licensing exams.
For each question, we score each model on the top-1 accuracy and the
distribution of probabilities assigned. We then compare with factors including
question difficulty for humans, question length, and the scores of the other
models. LLM accuracies were positively correlated pairwise ($0.29$ to $0.62$).
Model performance was also correlated with human performance ($0.07$ to
$0.16$), but negatively correlated to the difference between the question-level
accuracy of top-scoring and bottom-scoring humans ($-0.16$ to $-0.23$). The top
output probability and question length were positive and negative predictors of
accuracy respectively (p $< 0.05$). The top scoring LLM, GPT-4 Turbo, scored
$82\%$, followed by Med42, PaLM 2, Mixtral and GPT-3.5 around $63\%$. We found
evidence of similarities between models in which questions they answer
correctly, as well as similarities with human test takers. Larger models
typically performed better, but differences in training methods were also
highly impactful. Model accuracy was positively correlated with confidence, but
negatively correlated with question length. We expect that similar training
methods will lead these patterns to persist across future models. These
patterns can therefore aid medical experts in forming expectations about LLMs
as a category to support application research. | [
0.0603357367,
0.0095753549,
0.0058140075,
-0.0209574755,
-0.0149308024,
0.0153033063,
0.0131267617,
0.0389184132,
0.0014312969,
-0.0415670387,
-0.0143561438,
-0.0612631515,
-0.0173234269,
-0.0143687325,
0.0459164232,
-0.0459712595,
0.009073589,
-0.012550748,
0.003763292,
-0.0344053172,
-0.0219229013,
-0.0039638598,
-0.0302665103,
0.0456191748,
0.0486140177,
0.0051410422,
0.0338747688,
-0.0075163399,
0.0026075321,
-0.0546869859,
0.0086296629,
0.051621709,
-0.022961434,
0.0174510162,
0.0000017889,
-0.0758438483,
0.0209077932,
0.0199339278,
-0.0381754749,
0.0124399262,
0.0063113184,
-0.0114355711,
0.0089306831,
0.0396246612,
-0.046051383,
-0.032352481,
0.0076378491,
0.017885467,
0.0299377013,
0.0426333435,
0.0108233048,
-0.0143698202,
0.0625037998,
-0.0262386985,
0.0161125138,
-0.0520193353,
0.0361277387,
0.0369334929,
0.0284142122,
-0.0006272492,
-0.0153787648,
0.0224932581,
-0.0021750042,
0.0449972823,
-0.0007588764,
0.0318475962,
-0.0306075569,
-0.0103794932,
0.0055882437,
0.0388937816,
0.0160500724,
0.0040753633,
-0.0079925125,
0.0047457227,
0.0022911418,
0.0387917161,
-0.0815143064,
0.0385996252,
-0.0159772485,
-0.0117142405,
0.0184964929,
-0.0196219888,
0.0317012146,
0.0296646785,
-0.0143096736,
0.0224935357,
0.0306001138,
-0.0509307161,
0.0578381233,
0.0022637334,
-0.0125667285,
-0.0277713947,
0.0331349038,
0.0494018197,
-0.0306756161,
0.023325501,
0.003801611,
0.0030786523,
0.0943918973,
-0.0570261665,
0.009685115,
0.0208279323,
0.0047871387,
0.0401864052,
-0.0340381376,
0.0596360192,
-0.0255562402,
0.0232015271,
-0.0689878687,
-0.0041924161,
-0.0387814716,
-0.0310232099,
-0.0022161773,
0.0056315255,
0.0067181904,
0.0057244948,
-0.0901310295,
-0.0244865566,
0.0186926182,
-0.0049053491,
0.0127679612,
0.0438564494,
0.0010685964,
0.0167490691,
-0.0481156036,
0.0505634956,
-0.0285442341,
0.0133755198,
-0.0143333729,
-0.0557247214,
0.0407720022,
-0.0019693926,
0.0006237578,
-0.017602466,
0.0554808043,
0.0257733036,
-0.0099050179,
-0.0101687526,
0.0208013263,
-0.0292807389,
-0.016694488,
-0.0347550847,
0.0001403418,
-0.0632362142,
0.0066506998,
0.0471065901,
-0.0022071768,
-0.0269800518,
0.0213805772,
0.0434999391,
-0.0558325201,
0.0357913338,
-0.0067952485,
0.0528475791,
0.0410146751,
0.0282491092,
0.0013864266,
0.0072011552,
0.0169299878,
-0.0565096512,
0.0210301466,
-0.0633777976,
0.0256413501,
0.0218468942,
0.0013738179,
-0.0291336421,
0.0227144305,
0.0451981202,
0.0320642926,
0.0620622188,
-0.0107844556,
0.0689508989,
0.0005578405,
-0.0198482629,
0.0510056019,
0.0950828269,
0.0059426408,
0.0101890676,
0.0111567685,
-0.0352746919,
0.0460916795,
-0.0084256493,
-0.020815881,
-0.0314981118,
-0.013818454,
0.0304852277,
-0.0094833942,
0.0132478662,
-0.0288857482,
-0.0329196863,
-0.0592507236,
-0.0017639287,
-0.0197000541,
0.0136337476,
0.0520626269,
-0.0433723517,
-0.0285989866,
0.067719914,
0.0291176159,
-0.0189150777,
0.0031950807,
-0.0722044706,
0.0003877537,
0.0445392206,
0.0330141,
-0.0117611168,
-0.0309478119,
-0.0068648634,
0.0221637338,
0.0026723477,
0.0300730504,
-0.0159562547,
-0.0089656962,
-0.0324086845,
0.0152431438,
0.0339267403,
-0.0079909787,
-0.0478328243,
0.0336541384,
0.0436475165,
-0.0145105552,
-0.0331349932,
-0.0213677008,
0.0283719078,
-0.0755113214,
-0.0273246709,
-0.025661841,
-0.0207090732,
0.0120471567,
0.0084114512,
-0.005459521,
0.042269893,
0.0401180089,
-0.0129033597,
-0.0114164334,
-0.0424583517,
-0.026652135,
0.0090257283,
0.0446373075,
-0.0162538067,
0.0009890962,
0.0120113641,
-0.0111731598,
-0.033021789,
-0.0490440875,
-0.0589665286,
0.0154210078,
-0.0148169464,
0.0123076793,
0.0106290421,
-0.0142081426,
-0.0673959926,
0.0231558122,
-0.0200039856,
0.065434821,
0.026379155,
-0.0320967287,
-0.006527843,
-0.040457461,
-0.0243941303,
0.0311800744,
-0.0055550598,
0.0273664966,
-0.0056417068,
0.0012753471,
-0.0661818981,
-0.0322767086,
-0.1163575277,
-0.0001032045,
0.0123202819,
0.022054635,
0.0286229718,
-0.0121071702,
-0.0118436413,
-0.0104758497,
-0.0746663958,
-0.0483571626,
0.0593455583,
0.033942163,
0.0115722921,
0.0346124843,
-0.0073631904,
-0.0390486121,
-0.0372724757,
-0.0474610031,
0.0068004131,
0.0131861083,
0.0153608676,
-0.0168691836,
0.0251294598,
-0.0410893485,
-0.014362419,
-0.0049310587,
-0.0326357596,
0.0025695935,
-0.0047201193,
0.0011466276,
0.0661377907,
0.0093218973,
-0.0294528119,
0.0298150592,
0.0193209387,
-0.0276295841,
0.0097486498,
-0.0230299644,
-0.0604899675,
-0.0215185992,
-0.0696825013,
-0.0134177702,
0.064286679,
0.0238451455,
0.0104859928,
-0.0077874004,
-0.0083130728,
-0.0636936501,
0.0061107324,
-0.0432955585,
0.0197492801,
-0.038130004,
0.0617322065,
0.0203232989,
-0.0334821977,
0.0696347505,
-0.0146550732,
0.0244829692,
-0.0611065403,
-0.0148599967,
-0.0368361287,
0.0364953242,
-0.0025427337,
0.0198619142,
-0.0114655569,
-0.0155486017,
-0.0431221947,
-0.0067398469,
-0.0159506593,
-0.0753325596,
0.0441295654,
-0.0395609327,
0.0140971132,
-0.0083459131,
-0.0709323958,
-0.0328713469,
-0.056038402,
-0.0523370057,
0.0179428961,
-0.0137443785,
0.0032435937,
-0.019102741,
0.003480637,
0.0067245085,
0.0180634893,
-0.0155446446,
-0.0103556728,
-0.0002926572,
0.0585142374,
0.0612639748,
0.0453472473,
0.0257329848,
-0.0336626396,
0.0311551988,
0.0666674972,
0.0441543199,
0.0153177753,
0.0079872943,
-0.0104479995,
0.0357806608,
-0.0463253856,
-0.0194075983,
0.041746974,
0.0333731622,
-0.0716647059,
0.008095514,
0.123667188,
0.0277497154,
-0.0161286294,
0.0031309393,
-0.0269113537,
0.0001473065,
0.0149348089,
0.0378184207,
-0.0356648192,
-0.0350223519,
-0.0074346974,
0.066140987,
-0.0227287263,
-0.0088562053,
0.0363190658,
-0.0829252601,
0.0079152416,
-0.007186241,
-0.0449855216,
-0.0078152474,
-0.0490384996,
-0.0036382955,
0.0054626619,
0.0111111067,
0.0222500786,
-0.039090056,
0.0129245007,
0.0212869495,
-0.0730288774,
-0.0445577428,
0.0640411526,
-0.0256242007,
0.0567959212,
0.0693457425,
0.0024820454,
-0.0393404216,
-0.0361355245,
0.0244022869,
-0.0357950144,
0.023755582,
-0.010780558,
0.0559696592,
0.0137899928,
0.0203804635,
-0.0786994398,
0.036244981,
-0.0347981937,
0.0112403519,
0.0225850157,
0.0789394379,
0.0017886847,
-0.0383675545,
-0.0417363346,
0.028563004,
-0.0255583432,
0.0674135461,
0.0004040184,
-0.0428248122,
-0.0151227964,
0.0103244893,
0.0136829289,
0.0249723587,
-0.0321153104,
0.052154839,
-0.0038599998,
0.0226681773,
-0.0374667235,
-0.041569531,
0.0616558902,
-0.0055738878,
-0.0128023727,
0.059017282,
-0.0102348188,
0.0279244725,
-0.0387534648,
0.0517256968,
0.0019965831,
0.0151831023,
-0.0850065872,
-0.0120407697,
0.0757644847,
0.0027995072,
-0.0268346034,
-0.009552557,
-0.0524140559,
-0.0073697828,
0.0010567141,
0.0474054031,
0.0259426199,
-0.0261491574,
0.0121986726,
-0.0608827025,
0.0140451575,
0.0001515646,
-0.0491825715,
0.0238853786,
-0.0170104429,
-0.0031334551,
-0.0041969554,
0.0108946376,
-0.0309718475,
-0.0044799992,
0.0266360063,
0.0294642951,
-0.0249905195,
-0.0506710224,
0.0226317234,
0.0385562479,
0.0246964544,
0.0029817687,
-0.0042495406,
0.0161969997,
0.0257619023,
-0.0006112396,
0.0274460614,
0.0014276846,
-0.0127313007,
0.0481588319,
-0.0074762315,
-0.0181607828,
-0.0125384554,
-0.0337256789,
-0.0143813156,
-0.0876298472,
0.0393136553,
0.0159861948,
-0.0099527882,
0.0514665395,
-0.0230194479,
-0.0331815742,
0.0003859547,
0.0249031428,
0.0545397699,
0.0196767822,
0.0845402554,
-0.0326512195,
-0.0131063359,
0.0188548546,
0.0138213923,
-0.0833989903,
-0.0761293471,
-0.0028918956,
0.0340590402,
0.0404608585,
0.0164603908,
0.0165256821,
-0.00379853,
-0.0083306162,
-0.0264525879,
-0.0342921987,
-0.0143075455,
0.0242872145,
0.096224986,
0.0154298646,
-0.0064226454,
0.0068638814,
0.0990324393,
0.0382476225,
0.0396167561,
-0.0085839834,
-0.0480906144,
-0.0287175942,
-0.0079600597,
-0.0014067374,
0.0032040661,
-0.0493333936,
0.0222383793,
-0.0745553821,
-0.0447022282,
-0.0015406292,
-0.000246172,
-0.0167523939,
-0.0440348797,
0.0512933657,
0.0561042167,
0.0020364241,
-0.0347240344,
-0.0272384323,
0.0758816376,
-0.054444775,
-0.0154838003,
0.0033599702,
-5.84680678e-33,
0.0051221875,
-0.0140670985,
0.0252153706,
-0.040198002,
-0.0090787243,
0.0227998104,
-0.0165395178,
0.0228191689,
-0.0561888553,
0.0122136129,
-0.0445026979,
-0.0010558871,
0.0185679961,
0.0308070239,
0.0314193629,
-0.0543659143,
0.0000341119,
-0.0017953694,
-0.0059137321,
0.0157844257,
-0.0342191495,
0.0375942066,
0.031220099,
-0.0331347026,
0.0273375101,
-0.0231870878,
0.0407417044,
0.0109546343,
-0.0184626132,
0.0863226131,
-0.0081729125,
0.0450865999,
0.0594725274,
-0.0515123457,
0.0079368819,
0.0116740558,
-0.0624475218,
0.0123409834,
0.0241464097,
-0.0010888431,
-0.0295261834,
-0.0313032456,
0.0801497996,
-0.0095863678,
-0.055892501,
-0.0184795056,
0.0301371384,
-0.0286433268,
-0.0301664956,
-0.0419885777,
-0.0048079193,
0.0202052891,
0.0082438737,
0.0001684995,
-0.0543291457,
0.0408025198,
-0.0472824201,
0.049827233,
-0.0007034091,
-0.013932934,
0.0499039963,
0.0484542847,
0.0440931506,
-0.0127096716,
-0.00404556,
0.0423682779,
0.0468825474,
-0.0260838754,
-0.0072171851,
-0.0285919551,
-0.0271089915,
0.0059577418,
0.0823898092,
0.0365905166,
0.0312527791,
-0.0053908122,
-0.1149946973,
0.0355420411,
-0.0060998937,
0.0412453748,
0.0204914566,
-0.0314151198,
-0.0700870454,
-0.0249823648,
-0.0483165979,
0.0428065285,
-0.0203174409,
-0.0386381634,
0.058798708,
-0.0210965015,
0.0179420225,
0.0060300208,
0.0278040897,
-0.0392481945,
-0.014490461,
-0.0308334362,
0.0156705361,
0.0327580236,
-0.0356092416,
0.0367876738,
-0.0686800852,
0.033509206,
-0.0265472773,
-0.0219104923,
0.0326326713,
0.0190072712,
-0.0186250526,
-0.03781192,
-0.0677947178,
-0.0102853309,
0.0029779866,
-0.0192289986,
0.0179406088,
0.0257630274,
0.0523423031,
0.0269726142,
0.0222861953,
0.0392533578,
-0.0068600285,
-0.0229643006,
-0.0459426716,
-0.071546495,
0.0092674373,
-0.000610439,
-0.0325526185,
0.0254171807,
-0.0304919481,
0.0643421337,
-0.0070637893,
-0.0259479489,
-0.0068269572,
0.0099035576,
2.455e-7,
0.0959220231,
0.0653593168,
-0.0284289867,
-0.0180393271,
0.0225067195,
0.0127687845,
0.0012590304,
-0.0244795028,
0.0428675748,
-0.0013384133,
0.0026034846,
-0.0034658618,
0.0362949222,
0.0234024469,
-0.0712708086,
-0.0234265216,
-0.0873954594,
0.0026974389,
-0.0382206887,
0.0060558422,
0.0481279045,
0.0914791077,
-0.048046045,
-0.0446695313,
-0.0342476889,
-0.0581633188,
0.0468224846,
-0.0308403783,
-0.0247271042,
0.0264755469,
0.0268058274,
0.016736038,
0.0306848288,
0.0780340731,
-0.0201396644,
-0.0091345571,
0.0173378587,
0.0782106444,
-0.0334443189,
0.0027318317,
0.0362566188,
-0.028770335,
0.0258621983,
-0.0870389491,
0.080779776,
-0.0218547005,
-0.0396610498,
-0.0097209634,
-0.0123912916,
-0.053904701,
0.0654802248,
-0.0377319232,
-0.0209453404,
0.0117530385,
0.0149304811,
-0.0042924997,
-0.0106778704,
-0.027959412,
-0.0153229712,
0.019379111,
-0.0264583621,
-0.0775082707,
0.0025060913,
-0.0117681799,
-0.0231698733,
-0.0603537112,
-0.0306332614,
2.12497902e-34,
0.0214036889,
0.0213837996,
0.0485527441,
0.0481341667,
0.0082909986,
0.0095981415,
0.0192494243,
0.0260778349,
0.012680863,
-0.0854518935,
-0.0139796762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07188v1 | Adaptive Gating in Mixture-of-Experts based Language Models | 2023-10-11T04:30:18 | 2023-10-11T04:30:18 | Jiamin Li, Qiang Su, Yitao Yang, Yimin Jiang, Cong Wang, Hong Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models, such as OpenAI's ChatGPT, have demonstrated
exceptional language understanding capabilities in various NLP tasks. Sparsely
activated mixture-of-experts (MoE) has emerged as a promising solution for
scaling models while maintaining a constant number of computational operations.
Existing MoE model adopts a fixed gating network where each token is computed
by the same number of experts. However, this approach contradicts our intuition
that the tokens in each sequence vary in terms of their linguistic complexity
and, consequently, require different computational costs. Little is discussed
in prior research on the trade-off between computation per token and model
performance. This paper introduces adaptive gating in MoE, a flexible training
strategy that allows tokens to be processed by a variable number of experts
based on expert probability distribution. The proposed framework preserves
sparsity while improving training efficiency. Additionally, curriculum learning
is leveraged to further reduce training time. Extensive experiments on diverse
NLP tasks show that adaptive gating reduces at most 22.5% training time while
maintaining inference quality. Moreover, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of
the routing decisions and present our insights when adaptive gating is used. | [
0.0548336208,
0.0409406051,
-0.0044674808,
-0.0025635846,
-0.0570032597,
-0.015653478,
0.0255254693,
0.0123988958,
-0.0091944104,
-0.0346099585,
-0.0183451865,
-0.0249599423,
-0.0125453351,
0.0197315905,
0.0166658703,
-0.0505379364,
0.0322288945,
-0.0467685014,
0.0425973907,
-0.0191248748,
0.0110399779,
0.0156765953,
-0.0311184991,
0.0970641226,
-0.0275212228,
0.0109579256,
-0.01494799,
-0.0034832503,
0.0085110404,
0.0001604005,
0.0154043846,
0.0809666589,
0.0224639587,
0.0324537791,
0.0000021831,
0.0030600959,
-0.0113375103,
0.0073421928,
-0.0257320497,
0.003325284,
0.05546299,
0.0360448584,
0.0210199971,
0.0420973934,
-0.0041227634,
-0.0178676005,
0.0789651051,
0.050148055,
0.0161207449,
0.0833534375,
-0.0039572674,
-0.0029228174,
0.0516493917,
-0.0407514349,
0.0126346014,
-0.081524618,
0.0173957385,
0.0221339818,
-0.0177572221,
0.0244930498,
-0.0139989043,
0.0428937674,
0.0307801943,
0.0506491438,
0.0271338057,
0.0704767779,
-0.0270578023,
-0.0200636182,
-0.0457371548,
0.0400495641,
-0.0627234727,
-0.0276046749,
-0.0226231478,
-0.0216474999,
-0.0025616407,
0.0099233398,
-0.0424514115,
0.0034439138,
0.0059141973,
0.0364853367,
0.010042984,
0.0057651005,
0.0447375476,
0.0451113172,
-0.0571750589,
0.0444619879,
0.0060545672,
-0.0160696935,
-0.0190649219,
0.0128206601,
-0.0721982047,
-0.0547337234,
0.0100351144,
0.0224601477,
-0.0097460831,
0.0127709135,
-0.0220553614,
-0.0367389098,
-0.0095052067,
0.0147927748,
-0.0030914526,
0.0786190927,
-0.0278296396,
0.0586438477,
-0.0291243698,
0.0324724056,
-0.0061535663,
0.0182868391,
-0.029410176,
-0.0195511784,
-0.0704951212,
-0.0342014991,
-0.0528099537,
0.0378274694,
-0.0222723521,
-0.0506440997,
-0.0409576297,
-0.0108900787,
-0.0250818972,
-0.0126376236,
0.0333755538,
0.028941296,
-0.0519534312,
-0.0152303018,
-0.0324773043,
0.0586350039,
-0.0497501604,
0.0428994447,
0.0295311566,
-0.0550780967,
-0.0250115152,
0.0236053038,
0.0029033306,
-0.0133525506,
0.0037680336,
0.0655027702,
-0.0226534475,
-0.0445852615,
-0.0382527672,
0.0081342747,
-0.0185459945,
-0.051385954,
0.0058948412,
-0.0949016884,
0.0634787828,
-0.0099424962,
0.0096149193,
-0.0474995524,
-0.0073176078,
0.0109972665,
-0.0626387894,
0.0524091758,
-0.0255072769,
0.0070332191,
0.0131247183,
0.0204303972,
-0.0365987346,
0.0952385589,
0.019988317,
0.01960456,
0.0160094071,
0.0210885424,
0.0037930869,
0.0358155668,
0.023800794,
-0.0164283998,
-0.0022214851,
-0.0306935459,
0.0057863048,
0.0463903844,
0.0304490346,
0.0603368804,
-0.0751956254,
-0.014757866,
0.0510350242,
0.0599362962,
-0.0226910673,
0.0437576771,
0.0626727268,
0.0162992571,
-0.0031077808,
0.0381938107,
-0.026575258,
0.0155938137,
-0.0144276423,
-0.0108190924,
0.0531030968,
0.0362233706,
-0.0430574864,
-0.0275536906,
-0.0031402193,
-0.0066752718,
-0.0412203632,
0.0075817159,
0.0420332029,
-0.0163532514,
-0.0183989201,
0.0214090049,
0.0643994734,
-0.0204467233,
-0.0089098839,
-0.0709768161,
-0.0281324033,
0.0399878994,
0.0437289774,
-0.0238738619,
-0.0441476069,
0.0077786548,
-0.027475154,
-0.0010860831,
0.032127656,
0.0068050283,
0.0028188583,
-0.0894775465,
-0.0054619224,
-0.0102972323,
0.0286991056,
0.0488540195,
0.0472633019,
0.0242518112,
0.0249836966,
-0.0390118286,
-0.0172832124,
0.0100322142,
-0.0433941111,
-0.0212072488,
0.022466626,
0.0086319372,
0.0300404541,
-0.0057850094,
-0.0103979623,
0.012500965,
-0.008299497,
-0.0067019621,
-0.0204822719,
-0.0210410189,
-0.0702274144,
-0.0512373596,
0.0446619764,
0.0151377581,
-0.0055068429,
-0.0356022082,
-0.0344036072,
-0.0497812591,
0.0224868767,
-0.0040020985,
0.04396246,
-0.0475975573,
-0.0210166983,
0.0383502245,
0.0325498581,
-0.0367584415,
0.0804451257,
-0.0257585999,
-0.0019186724,
0.016799977,
0.0070052971,
0.0126411757,
-0.0192337818,
-0.0344687253,
-0.0231957678,
0.0239863507,
0.0162695032,
0.002200536,
-0.0082925092,
-0.0442943573,
-0.0897913948,
-0.1437072158,
0.0039824969,
-0.0201638956,
-0.001582838,
0.0142938029,
0.0234599058,
0.0003692471,
0.0154612958,
-0.0406614244,
0.021427488,
-0.0168042071,
0.0107938293,
-0.0154068293,
0.0103688417,
-0.0310675781,
-0.0323971361,
-0.0300265662,
-0.0229105521,
0.0394513309,
-0.0309942439,
-0.008605184,
-0.0165966712,
-0.0259098951,
-0.0543406829,
0.0453935117,
-0.0189919602,
-0.0056751147,
0.0129791936,
-0.044051487,
0.0835093036,
0.0413868912,
-0.0126488442,
0.0502855778,
0.031526465,
-0.0094183981,
-0.0455004461,
0.0486212596,
-0.0169785917,
-0.0274087731,
-0.008182588,
0.0062288367,
-0.0229599588,
0.0508456565,
-0.0090116365,
-0.0407606214,
-0.0893423185,
-0.0136354351,
-0.0025912477,
-0.0372623354,
-0.0143913087,
0.0307560824,
0.0031251856,
0.0162619725,
-0.0262787919,
-0.0127174407,
0.0512857288,
-0.0185105056,
0.0098068193,
-0.0458779633,
-0.0219725762,
-0.0250746496,
0.0347772576,
0.0274039656,
0.0144853136,
-0.0290445518,
-0.0197660569,
-0.0502066649,
0.0019319109,
-0.0108178901,
-0.0097474828,
0.0138904518,
-0.0431225598,
0.0255918,
0.0141050909,
-0.0283752214,
0.0059093866,
-0.0052906717,
-0.0215503555,
0.0583991371,
0.047264412,
-0.0107796201,
-0.0563057773,
0.0206085481,
-0.0120944735,
0.0628403947,
-0.0352148972,
0.0104033779,
-0.013883668,
0.0436002947,
0.0219920017,
0.0193009134,
-0.0147213014,
-0.0295391008,
-0.0120591223,
0.0506955832,
0.0595048703,
-0.0404128581,
-0.0408889242,
0.0058297096,
0.0091433264,
-0.0189747922,
-0.0151404208,
0.0296008307,
0.0420100912,
-0.0459260121,
-0.0132588465,
0.1055912599,
0.001976693,
-0.075306356,
0.0046823691,
0.0163494516,
0.0676348358,
-0.0071353437,
0.0129493782,
-0.0617455654,
-0.0346660502,
0.0167718548,
-0.0058717337,
-0.0045806537,
-0.0359434336,
-0.0121231982,
-0.0583047457,
0.0102531686,
-0.0064255744,
-0.0673603788,
-0.0084941713,
-0.0076676398,
0.0103630116,
-0.0141696986,
0.0394345187,
-0.0116643431,
0.0119441384,
0.0143228387,
0.0470142737,
0.011964865,
-0.0796269849,
0.0115078865,
-0.0190205686,
0.0942230299,
0.0051415595,
-0.0111308387,
0.0008380782,
-0.0101409908,
0.062587373,
0.0275915097,
0.0296274666,
-0.0040671905,
0.0365467072,
-0.043573726,
-0.0090043647,
0.0173271019,
-0.0079720663,
0.0260396209,
-0.0224524401,
-0.0008549879,
0.0804948136,
-0.0001015863,
-0.0225059818,
-0.0077608707,
-0.0243170932,
-0.007545935,
0.0636022463,
0.0190803967,
-0.0358802043,
-0.0283347536,
-0.0341098383,
-0.0210199356,
-0.0110421516,
-0.0196704306,
0.0078655705,
0.0483290814,
-0.08108861,
-0.0197372045,
-0.0218430031,
0.0726519376,
0.0600632615,
0.0046470556,
0.0151490988,
0.0128460946,
0.0333717205,
0.0040282276,
0.0352240093,
-0.0609522052,
-0.0293292105,
-0.0630392805,
-0.0221351348,
0.006663247,
-0.0272170193,
-0.0274002552,
-0.006016253,
-0.1088992283,
-0.0719691515,
-0.029644303,
0.0634917468,
0.0225926228,
0.0131749706,
0.0032567119,
-0.0664871186,
0.0352545939,
0.0750679523,
-0.0624744184,
0.0136589175,
0.0024027815,
-0.006614618,
0.0204293747,
0.0254716668,
0.0057289884,
0.0148974191,
0.0160075519,
0.0653873011,
-0.0074500632,
0.0114722839,
0.0214811992,
0.0076161087,
0.0242044218,
-0.0119290175,
0.031558957,
-0.0449691601,
-0.0100272689,
0.0161069781,
0.000730306,
-0.0342113264,
0.0072354972,
0.0307469666,
0.0238047466,
-0.0161413867,
-0.060093414,
0.0288108606,
0.0010927534,
-0.0086573409,
-0.037707366,
0.0051390622,
-0.0205941517,
0.0160272568,
-0.0262323115,
-0.0476242676,
-0.034085054,
-0.0207625683,
0.0016905343,
-0.0420282595,
0.0314378887,
0.0364769548,
0.001723511,
-0.0295618456,
0.0137666417,
-0.0574893057,
-0.065801613,
0.0003948745,
0.0931761712,
0.0725922361,
-0.0166117754,
0.0055592116,
-0.0478725582,
-0.0084341969,
-0.0267650001,
-0.0112216985,
0.0136124222,
-0.0119658438,
0.0180537179,
0.0248121135,
0.0135580068,
-0.0008349356,
0.096613057,
0.0256794803,
0.0179425403,
-0.0031151751,
0.0033206525,
-0.0272579063,
-0.0175349042,
-0.0054747635,
0.0721733868,
-0.0059139025,
0.0568224378,
-0.0132034142,
-0.0667471737,
-0.0668103397,
-0.0126603683,
0.0045024976,
0.0020592783,
0.0523748137,
0.071783714,
-0.0413815752,
-0.0092891511,
-0.0239328332,
-0.000050852,
0.0396219566,
0.0057818159,
-0.0172455683,
-7.227999418e-33,
-0.009996213,
-0.011635487,
0.0367609821,
-0.0165917873,
0.0058102398,
0.004228184,
-0.0222210158,
0.0204488654,
-0.024113955,
0.0079606948,
-0.032744918,
-0.0006057717,
0.0021765863,
0.0279898997,
-0.0013283864,
0.0031408265,
0.0378279649,
-0.0043882811,
0.0070492169,
0.0220137667,
0.0034251702,
0.0007913054,
0.0779863894,
-0.0825357735,
-0.0145711889,
0.0365063064,
-0.0091202548,
0.0048886905,
-0.0142395673,
0.0481085405,
-0.0159265567,
0.0510579497,
0.0376666337,
-0.0157803148,
0.010700942,
-0.0499913953,
-0.0670851693,
-0.0675705746,
0.0300108213,
-0.0306380838,
-0.0098230103,
-0.0253246594,
0.0481964424,
0.0057390118,
0.0031482119,
-0.0162869301,
0.0187467039,
-0.0018553437,
-0.0314788967,
0.0275128577,
-0.0261725876,
0.050664831,
0.0079569733,
0.0122222314,
0.0137410667,
-0.0134650832,
-0.0162983928,
-0.0093938438,
0.0011139963,
-0.018309582,
0.0305609833,
0.0802608654,
0.0096880523,
0.0188542344,
-0.0112442784,
0.0340889134,
0.0049555339,
0.0146404859,
-0.0799804553,
-0.0339226536,
0.0469350256,
0.0283502266,
0.0255268216,
-0.0345944129,
0.0565389395,
0.0017458911,
-0.0382051319,
-0.0018086436,
0.0471363515,
0.0653089583,
0.0626527593,
0.0120123522,
-0.0355230682,
-0.0115011251,
-0.0141496062,
-0.0211283434,
-0.0478644632,
-0.0305568594,
0.0245326478,
0.0352647267,
-0.009255263,
-0.0152804852,
0.032417018,
-0.0289007891,
-0.0146224871,
0.0201672595,
-0.0180507563,
0.0143831084,
-0.0079565076,
0.0487561226,
-0.0982685387,
-0.0528514124,
0.0198995024,
-0.0067078108,
-0.0084529556,
0.0118038617,
0.0211610403,
0.0032325883,
-0.0551221259,
-0.0183615796,
-0.0463976823,
0.0116794901,
0.0224147569,
0.0533746742,
0.054911796,
0.0243511293,
-0.0012713085,
-0.0024256173,
0.0129842591,
-0.0212489087,
-0.0189020056,
-0.0193194449,
0.001275248,
-0.0013666565,
-0.0551670194,
0.013021728,
-0.0358030498,
-0.0594770201,
-0.0149740065,
-0.0359731615,
-0.0343718901,
0.0376177505,
2.926e-7,
0.0355521552,
0.0437682904,
-0.0078933164,
-0.0082997689,
0.0015788123,
0.0032047683,
0.0007349228,
-0.0024804776,
0.0133866472,
-0.0255476292,
0.0495301038,
0.0794177949,
0.0001201348,
0.0008052508,
-0.1123765334,
-0.019599339,
-0.053498216,
0.0326843038,
-0.0388845429,
0.0011956925,
0.0424550772,
0.114428103,
0.0369028896,
0.0105157821,
0.0150133595,
-0.052393835,
0.0495507754,
0.0055707917,
0.0276519377,
0.0323575623,
0.0648907349,
0.060450878,
0.0078073898,
0.0496410653,
0.0244010855,
0.0371144973,
0.0259522684,
0.0750041828,
-0.0508421324,
0.0084478194,
0.0402707271,
-0.0112847872,
-0.0087397341,
-0.0746790692,
0.0679433569,
-0.0201281831,
-0.0042475346,
-0.0182071123,
0.0261221267,
-0.0082070045,
0.0189941507,
-0.0010240877,
-0.041653458,
0.0256541148,
0.0249352455,
-0.010427353,
-0.0159305055,
-0.1008989364,
0.0138511881,
0.0104023702,
-0.0644251928,
-0.0379584767,
-0.0352715254,
-0.000132622,
0.04216161,
-0.0242330935,
-0.005559762,
2.985746697e-34,
0.0681289136,
-0.0253214687,
0.0108652329,
0.0521981195,
0.0267617535,
-0.0101918327,
-0.0159566794,
-0.0055517717,
-0.004334589,
-0.0870064571,
-0.0635306686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07177v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07177v4 | Online Speculative Decoding | 2023-10-11T04:03:42 | 2024-06-10T01:36:31 | Xiaoxuan Liu, Lanxiang Hu, Peter Bailis, Alvin Cheung, Zhijie Deng, Ion Stoica, Hao Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Speculative decoding is a pivotal technique to accelerate the inference of
large language models (LLMs) by employing a smaller draft model to predict the
target model's outputs. However, its efficacy can be limited due to the low
predictive accuracy of the draft model, particularly when faced with diverse
text inputs and a significant capability gap between the draft and target
models. We introduce online speculative decoding to address this challenge. The
main idea is to continuously update the (multiple) draft model(s) on observed
user query data. Adapting to query distribution mitigates the shifts between
the training distribution of the draft model and the query distribution,
enabling the draft model to more accurately predict the target model's outputs.
We develop a prototype of online speculative decoding based on knowledge
distillation and evaluate it using both synthetic and real query data. The
results show a substantial increase in the token acceptance rate by 0.1 to
0.65, bringing 1.42x to 2.17x latency reduction. Our code is available at
https://github.com/LiuXiaoxuanPKU/OSD. | [
0.0309018698,
0.0835732669,
-0.0022396545,
-0.0038586208,
-0.0130572673,
0.0170433726,
-0.0268893186,
0.022619389,
-0.0341486298,
-0.0204276983,
-0.0029589131,
-0.0815570652,
0.0047582551,
0.0546124838,
-0.0020381901,
-0.0268335361,
0.0045259479,
-0.0496640652,
0.0167883225,
0.0007500932,
-0.0040431255,
0.0399894379,
0.0070585692,
0.0454466939,
0.0404412039,
-0.0040731542,
-0.0343424715,
0.0250656474,
-0.0563383773,
-0.0072484366,
0.0121141002,
0.0639813393,
0.0229102615,
0.0329527706,
0.0000018789,
-0.0123844864,
-0.0352438651,
0.0119774658,
-0.0598705821,
0.0178281311,
0.0559666753,
-0.0231403727,
0.0086842561,
0.0307518188,
-0.0392999761,
-0.0258045271,
0.0314990543,
0.0204960052,
-0.0085403668,
0.0463817455,
0.0040836409,
-0.0217088014,
0.0214432646,
-0.0009418192,
-0.0168835949,
-0.0326576419,
0.0199737307,
-0.0318783,
-0.0522988103,
-0.0014774476,
-0.0213721618,
0.0302733406,
0.0121753151,
0.0132235447,
-0.0012041336,
0.022034524,
-0.030267613,
-0.0321034156,
-0.0105123576,
0.0505272783,
-0.018596109,
-0.0361380093,
0.0234354064,
0.0192020237,
-0.0270043295,
0.0094894972,
-0.0468094498,
0.0025480133,
-0.0207948554,
0.0313568823,
0.0147787174,
-0.0016425119,
0.0354811698,
0.0296170916,
-0.0595917962,
0.0833340362,
0.010628053,
-0.0277485847,
-0.0204184614,
-0.0143666035,
-0.0205813665,
-0.0218996517,
0.0322165564,
-0.0123696439,
-0.0445114411,
0.0192965847,
-0.028995879,
-0.0684511587,
-0.0071891276,
-0.0479524545,
0.0230631232,
0.0585470349,
0.0230546463,
0.0198741648,
-0.0089375665,
0.0232884493,
0.0169817973,
0.0317227468,
-0.0478107706,
-0.0024581032,
-0.0564341545,
-0.007425067,
-0.0405820422,
0.0469623208,
-0.0364763625,
-0.0278527196,
-0.0104000922,
0.0309870634,
0.0330327414,
-0.0214418247,
0.0551638082,
-0.0007292801,
-0.0317465961,
-0.0128797526,
0.0089063542,
0.05640411,
0.0054530688,
-0.0115976706,
0.0044024666,
-0.0801898241,
-0.0019383887,
0.0051721786,
0.0035824212,
-0.0294448975,
-0.046658989,
0.0455070511,
-0.0184487589,
-0.0113089932,
-0.0090178335,
-0.0345912836,
0.0234970283,
-0.0271644741,
-0.0093448674,
-0.0527224056,
0.0524166636,
0.0137943923,
0.0159562714,
-0.0386623554,
-0.0204231236,
0.000426919,
-0.0365687273,
0.0511282124,
-0.0309708044,
0.0375828184,
0.0176155847,
-0.0101981834,
0.0060547045,
0.1210568175,
-0.0015240725,
0.0411591344,
0.0309293885,
-0.0146507584,
-0.0098026032,
0.0644817427,
0.0399132706,
0.0070710173,
-0.0106776794,
-0.0118207531,
-0.0021077415,
-0.0017029668,
0.0327955298,
0.033030428,
-0.0599655546,
0.0259889476,
0.0637549311,
0.0259840563,
0.0317200869,
-0.00555549,
0.007611759,
0.0663125366,
0.0021135276,
0.0032522476,
-0.0340048037,
-0.0079118162,
-0.018011177,
0.0201922487,
0.0333578587,
0.0325037129,
-0.0277864877,
-0.0151812816,
0.0163200386,
-0.0104196267,
0.0029262318,
0.0415309295,
0.0750670508,
0.0122101689,
-0.0416523442,
0.0678917766,
0.0243777819,
-0.0236725323,
0.0376816168,
-0.0478047729,
0.0071271546,
0.0934939533,
0.0705793053,
0.0210266933,
0.0213209242,
0.0093729692,
-0.0257794447,
0.0063434471,
0.0140798874,
-0.0416244902,
0.0221097544,
-0.0416565575,
-0.0410340764,
0.0733197853,
0.0222411677,
0.0114636011,
0.0489256084,
-0.0000046205,
0.0052600577,
-0.079890497,
-0.0169914961,
0.0216599256,
-0.0091821915,
-0.0069699176,
0.0098109832,
0.0153689692,
0.0271390062,
0.0095376391,
0.0016844865,
0.0048525203,
0.0259082615,
-0.0112785781,
-0.0210097712,
0.0101370541,
-0.0274621341,
-0.0340725183,
0.0277111121,
-0.0010353044,
0.0101646502,
0.0318285972,
-0.0476751812,
-0.0260189865,
0.023686178,
-0.004027992,
0.0767978653,
-0.0471349172,
0.0123067945,
-0.0084894402,
0.0040897168,
-0.0025154105,
0.0170560293,
-0.0401029959,
0.0016862109,
-0.0129976571,
-0.0421043113,
-0.0210115444,
-0.0116702951,
-0.0266222544,
0.017239945,
-0.0427501351,
0.010029518,
0.0132209323,
-0.0110040596,
-0.0097669829,
0.0026994448,
-0.0949702337,
-0.0224730466,
-0.0542270131,
0.0204534605,
0.0317100063,
0.0375146233,
-0.0173683427,
-0.0226687137,
0.0081453053,
-0.0332250446,
-0.026435338,
0.0316109397,
-0.0137962205,
0.0173969287,
-0.0138552329,
0.0012440522,
-0.0353944004,
0.0122252777,
0.0607802346,
-0.0590939187,
-0.0599547699,
-0.0502137765,
0.0093519818,
0.0226939004,
-0.0078923935,
-0.00996718,
-0.0360356458,
-0.0123565616,
-0.0457123183,
0.0081266761,
0.0043160454,
0.0160794314,
0.0039117485,
0.0364564732,
0.0031654683,
-0.083950907,
-0.0161895137,
-0.0232147407,
-0.0193138346,
-0.0753399134,
-0.0539269559,
0.0178136397,
0.0632060468,
0.0017541019,
0.0007866588,
-0.0855718926,
-0.0466741212,
-0.0382337384,
-0.0403347909,
-0.0826831758,
0.0168048795,
-0.0207220893,
0.0345105827,
-0.004181297,
-0.0531013608,
0.0954696611,
-0.0287885703,
-0.0038043996,
-0.0162688978,
-0.0029054102,
0.0080659557,
0.0381508768,
-0.0139331482,
0.0263464898,
-0.0055076163,
-0.055265408,
-0.0167718027,
0.0046698088,
0.0036701027,
-0.0421719179,
0.0460889265,
-0.0364544205,
0.0225361902,
0.0048989174,
-0.0187434331,
-0.0180531815,
-0.0547499023,
-0.0281180963,
-0.0150965936,
0.0532339588,
-0.0422331616,
-0.0004897352,
0.0311552305,
-0.0651030242,
0.0522312485,
-0.0240914654,
-0.0030584519,
-0.000041409,
-0.0032993734,
0.0715366378,
0.0014474184,
-0.0045068092,
-0.0382648259,
0.0356743187,
0.0749466047,
0.0732709318,
-0.0314940847,
-0.0179364122,
-0.0124386847,
0.0486195609,
-0.0146756647,
0.0092920978,
0.0647225082,
0.0274426527,
-0.0500473157,
-0.0106844613,
0.1239032447,
0.0264171474,
-0.0564937331,
-0.0087521672,
0.0039023778,
0.075278379,
-0.0109757651,
0.0360396765,
-0.0733787641,
-0.0301557221,
0.0399483107,
0.0826063529,
0.0117094871,
-0.035619583,
-0.0227125455,
-0.0936028436,
0.0325615034,
0.0100420462,
-0.0192421898,
-0.0009256558,
-0.0529608466,
-0.0398286171,
0.001459819,
0.0343486778,
0.0429611169,
0.0252224449,
0.020570131,
0.0273235906,
-0.0428196862,
-0.0514110848,
0.0005867485,
-0.0023356329,
0.0552963242,
0.0442104489,
0.0098294513,
0.0422420092,
0.0058584874,
-0.0031026704,
-0.0236842185,
-0.0119561395,
-0.0219501909,
0.045534309,
-0.029390255,
0.0259730499,
-0.004446289,
0.0181662962,
-0.0668787584,
-0.0097708208,
-0.0297541954,
0.0339380242,
-0.0098861847,
-0.0271781664,
-0.0079704272,
-0.0442112945,
0.025973564,
0.0736051351,
0.0295610074,
-0.0255707763,
-0.0476048402,
-0.0448008999,
-0.0108789206,
-0.0747937039,
0.0143035594,
0.0036526243,
0.0170524195,
-0.0206501987,
-0.0663041696,
0.0124294618,
0.0122182751,
0.0374095961,
-0.0039629033,
0.0591900013,
0.0391011201,
-0.010642251,
-0.0588823482,
0.0043658433,
-0.0288759675,
0.0127042569,
-0.0499757528,
-0.0045494447,
0.0165448505,
-0.0235900693,
-0.0260450318,
0.0100620333,
-0.1117143407,
-0.0681053251,
0.0226973351,
0.0257790033,
0.0264979862,
0.0282832552,
-0.0465438776,
-0.0658030435,
0.059943255,
0.0253200755,
-0.0723313987,
-0.013507124,
0.0210309532,
-0.0127942748,
-0.0040078452,
0.0432984009,
-0.0402494408,
-0.0281852651,
-0.0247838832,
0.0163633004,
-0.0295592137,
0.0089668576,
0.0195833817,
0.041652333,
0.045400884,
-0.0193532929,
-0.0257846899,
-0.0091767237,
0.0340576246,
0.0193868764,
-0.0003023618,
-0.0218769498,
0.0091767572,
0.0347841159,
-0.0341662653,
0.0070142387,
0.0494815856,
0.0170199703,
0.0216901358,
0.0023767829,
-0.0341145061,
0.0023186121,
0.0142215993,
0.0796014145,
-0.0177726503,
0.0041089249,
0.0252400711,
0.0100699933,
0.0433221236,
-0.048668731,
-0.0052193091,
0.0137287686,
0.0233081039,
0.0044708042,
0.0125797214,
-0.0739606917,
-0.0682227239,
-0.0383455865,
0.009769015,
0.0135935824,
0.0084013371,
0.0455853827,
-0.0131014111,
0.0241705161,
-0.0377132259,
0.0056879963,
-0.0220560711,
-0.0218102057,
0.0423498377,
0.0087921796,
-0.0244024042,
0.0033590223,
0.1140612736,
0.022801239,
0.0464982763,
0.001548118,
-0.0068079084,
-0.01757982,
-0.0183532722,
-0.0231885854,
0.0647987723,
-0.0551557802,
-0.0368831344,
0.0008445236,
-0.0444315523,
-0.0054239854,
-0.0421380438,
-0.0071270079,
-0.0134488158,
0.0360109024,
0.0666387603,
-0.0141397994,
-0.0243063346,
-0.0581428334,
-0.0087075336,
0.027939979,
-0.0233797953,
-0.0051370217,
-6.508896626e-33,
0.0198715348,
-0.0069683827,
-0.00326826,
-0.0613792464,
-0.027271077,
-0.0251358934,
-0.0258161053,
-0.0242145322,
0.0012101071,
-0.0072436393,
-0.0332116857,
0.0421581119,
0.0381556489,
0.0587192364,
0.0008260342,
-0.0162521787,
0.0696629286,
-0.0339869037,
-0.0077005005,
0.0142918704,
0.0460674427,
0.0644297749,
0.0091462368,
0.0044325539,
0.0146204764,
-0.0225437786,
-0.0122669814,
-0.0008273858,
0.0280277189,
0.0437563919,
-0.0184142571,
0.0436863899,
0.0198974796,
-0.0190313309,
-0.0587325282,
0.0085601201,
-0.0837973878,
0.0241294205,
0.0337013751,
0.046450384,
0.032539282,
-0.0020057529,
0.0072207735,
0.0027951514,
-0.003676489,
-0.0052368031,
-0.0161273461,
-0.0089081023,
-0.0401303768,
-0.0554743968,
0.005863443,
0.0188430063,
-0.0029491021,
0.0152113289,
0.0794306099,
0.0472968221,
0.0043002004,
0.006558246,
-0.0724258572,
0.05318591,
-0.0375550613,
0.0610490069,
0.0729595795,
0.0224130526,
-0.0118682459,
0.0334663764,
-0.0159028638,
-0.0211057067,
-0.0342172496,
-0.0045995452,
0.062656194,
0.022851767,
-0.0273324959,
0.028424859,
0.0743560791,
-0.0527166277,
-0.0187368765,
0.024433339,
0.0367728882,
0.0255525466,
0.0695754811,
0.0423167422,
-0.0358480662,
-0.0551946796,
-0.0607367642,
-0.0257912632,
-0.0370328799,
-0.0346864872,
0.0417593531,
0.0259631258,
-0.0419829115,
-0.0502076298,
0.0579858124,
-0.0721521676,
-0.0253949352,
0.0324081443,
0.0010825107,
0.0325770453,
-0.0189013705,
0.0359162614,
-0.0216706395,
-0.0466619991,
0.0366561376,
-0.0190523472,
-0.0346572623,
-0.0069647147,
-0.0031631358,
0.0129904272,
-0.053716857,
0.0077433991,
-0.0003520189,
0.0201281663,
0.0241187792,
0.0494704358,
0.0707612932,
-0.0006454734,
-0.0042775832,
0.0110735847,
-0.000234993,
0.043533463,
-0.0233208612,
-0.002165047,
0.0183540657,
0.0362156592,
0.0040880647,
0.0046499837,
-0.0366730168,
-0.0325573012,
0.0274677556,
-0.0200872924,
-0.0299238376,
0.0596107244,
2.583e-7,
0.050211221,
0.0533177182,
0.0219386071,
-0.0044482425,
0.011802108,
0.0093660951,
0.0004376175,
0.012065745,
0.0275861472,
-0.0369781256,
0.0028821414,
0.0198654179,
0.0728609338,
0.0299481079,
-0.1339254677,
-0.0513770171,
-0.0230878145,
0.0082620606,
-0.0458749384,
-0.0170371886,
0.003090502,
0.1092540473,
-0.0117141269,
-0.0213784892,
0.0350484289,
-0.0123351002,
0.0044651036,
0.0072457641,
-0.0184128787,
0.0291452501,
-0.0047271308,
0.0087269396,
0.0073095625,
0.0183662381,
-0.0414894037,
-0.0193731692,
-0.0085749207,
0.0593199916,
0.0103370817,
-0.0318230949,
-0.0110720871,
-0.0253883582,
0.0042173923,
-0.0553691573,
0.0581856743,
-0.0287702847,
-0.0118023828,
-0.0192570612,
-0.0074803461,
-0.0284193493,
-0.0340895802,
-0.0267160274,
0.0232853107,
0.0637223199,
0.0350093208,
-0.0113029005,
-0.0043100459,
-0.0809056684,
-0.0077624153,
-0.0296091959,
-0.0552707911,
-0.0617760308,
-0.0494583771,
-0.003905294,
0.0319060832,
-0.0536506027,
0.0398174971,
2.526824519e-34,
0.0691453516,
0.059795998,
0.0028034986,
0.0722553879,
0.0047182883,
-0.0261647087,
0.0286203735,
0.033418078,
0.013591514,
-0.0990562439,
-0.0212946087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07170v1 | PHALM: Building a Knowledge Graph from Scratch by Prompting Humans and a Language Model | 2023-10-11T03:39:46 | 2023-10-11T03:39:46 | Tatsuya Ide, Eiki Murata, Daisuke Kawahara, Takato Yamazaki, Shengzhe Li, Kenta Shinzato, Toshinori Sato | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the remarkable progress in natural language understanding with
pretrained Transformers, neural language models often do not handle commonsense
knowledge well. Toward commonsense-aware models, there have been attempts to
obtain knowledge, ranging from automatic acquisition to crowdsourcing. However,
it is difficult to obtain a high-quality knowledge base at a low cost,
especially from scratch. In this paper, we propose PHALM, a method of building
a knowledge graph from scratch, by prompting both crowdworkers and a large
language model (LLM). We used this method to build a Japanese event knowledge
graph and trained Japanese commonsense generation models. Experimental results
revealed the acceptability of the built graph and inferences generated by the
trained models. We also report the difference in prompting humans and an LLM.
Our code, data, and models are available at
github.com/nlp-waseda/comet-atomic-ja. | [
0.06601955,
0.0571430475,
-0.0034426767,
0.0648232847,
-0.022144625,
-0.0138555504,
-0.0561978072,
0.012965491,
0.0691867843,
-0.0170192625,
-0.0172507744,
0.0115480255,
0.0124952057,
0.018435847,
0.0118612899,
-0.0336022563,
0.0225131717,
0.0159311481,
-0.0139761856,
-0.0069412775,
0.0216390043,
0.0194905009,
-0.0058116061,
0.0401399024,
-0.0232794639,
0.0252367631,
-0.0049446789,
-0.0074638883,
0.0142136468,
-0.0124723911,
0.0050286022,
0.0517999344,
-0.0055007106,
0.0038947461,
0.0000017546,
-0.0147095202,
0.027417073,
-0.0323940925,
0.0001388645,
-0.0232189521,
0.0007440867,
-0.0129047437,
0.0257126093,
0.0068840319,
-0.0837832391,
-0.0131121064,
0.0091110319,
0.0200055614,
0.0709755272,
0.0570649989,
-0.0046549793,
-0.0216834694,
-0.0051825447,
-0.0217279326,
0.0068418533,
-0.0624725074,
0.0168121923,
-0.0172728114,
0.028152613,
-0.025826877,
-0.0162420366,
0.0160789602,
0.0229279604,
-0.0084252749,
0.0143813286,
0.0322368369,
-0.0240430534,
-0.0067173587,
-0.0343946405,
0.1353063434,
0.0237702522,
-0.0257093273,
0.0136026442,
0.0028786932,
0.0325720347,
0.0478721485,
-0.0359593257,
0.0237856321,
0.0115469312,
0.0264664423,
0.033989206,
-0.0125642987,
0.0209839791,
0.0394082591,
0.0353080072,
0.0683287978,
0.0140091237,
0.003177417,
-0.0317898132,
0.0251292624,
0.0032759896,
-0.0561808497,
0.0257832631,
0.0664560795,
-0.0413864926,
0.054268267,
-0.0550879426,
-0.012512452,
0.0245351363,
-0.0637914911,
-0.0012428809,
0.0045754942,
-0.0081473775,
0.0384581015,
-0.0134819206,
-0.014404919,
0.0078720795,
0.0396308936,
-0.0481413789,
-0.0047692708,
-0.052254118,
0.0228393935,
-0.066208154,
0.0079906965,
-0.0566100404,
0.0073228311,
-0.0281904917,
0.0012814597,
0.0062690992,
0.0115101561,
0.0492815748,
0.0286966935,
-0.0326069854,
-0.0083718821,
-0.022013573,
0.0407808982,
-0.0814199373,
0.0135962777,
0.0216505118,
-0.022772003,
-0.0099575724,
0.0015538341,
0.0510807596,
0.0147278262,
-0.0248873476,
0.0203623511,
-0.0133282077,
-0.0114528462,
-0.0818309709,
-0.0496725626,
-0.0084921084,
0.0042637573,
0.000390939,
-0.045441471,
0.0728603378,
-0.0043901238,
0.0051999982,
-0.0209044944,
0.0239682216,
0.0116097312,
-0.048420798,
0.0649194792,
-0.0480765253,
0.0136335585,
-0.0089163817,
0.0076729371,
-0.0037662666,
0.0361772031,
0.0470106639,
-0.0075891172,
0.0734336674,
0.0307029393,
0.0086259143,
0.0285822097,
0.0362517498,
0.0099431006,
0.046145469,
-0.0025153437,
-0.0490161851,
0.0460307412,
0.0482665673,
0.0382075906,
-0.0315154232,
0.0095570516,
0.0451354608,
0.0393300131,
-0.0555321462,
0.0318934955,
0.0182639081,
0.0205461513,
-0.0215929803,
-0.0014114174,
-0.0354023203,
0.010146915,
-0.0614193976,
0.0153072113,
-0.0165463146,
-0.0248032194,
-0.0171563774,
0.0000936609,
0.0092099914,
-0.0148867909,
0.0432427973,
-0.0039545125,
0.0340614878,
0.0537153669,
-0.0380207598,
0.0946019962,
0.0284907892,
-0.0810134187,
0.0534744859,
-0.009292976,
0.0280796383,
0.0487491153,
0.0441088341,
0.0331904404,
-0.0208552033,
0.0318334177,
-0.0157605186,
0.0554809719,
0.0405632518,
-0.055991862,
-0.030489061,
-0.0462649651,
-0.0152676115,
0.0302067921,
-0.0179433748,
-0.0051774895,
0.0641573966,
0.0092588533,
0.0417932719,
-0.0641265437,
-0.025427293,
0.0273929927,
-0.0301272124,
0.0019707093,
-0.0412838981,
-0.005130107,
0.0366848782,
0.0142277228,
0.0262626465,
0.0116839837,
0.0434451029,
-0.0403016396,
-0.0319120847,
0.0754340962,
-0.0378274657,
-0.0948537737,
0.0582110845,
-0.0353803597,
-0.0371427201,
0.0375273749,
-0.0494190454,
-0.0296350326,
0.0033676894,
0.0044736047,
0.0371917784,
-0.0800933465,
-0.023389725,
0.0219253749,
-0.0385423377,
0.0075332811,
0.0862953737,
-0.0231773201,
-0.0096772248,
-0.0019772358,
-0.008273623,
0.016221853,
-0.0337804444,
-0.0435179844,
-0.0080757355,
0.0148888826,
0.0089573096,
0.0107171927,
0.0233204197,
-0.0714338869,
0.0239968244,
-0.1065944135,
-0.0039706491,
-0.0099672284,
-0.0019403144,
-0.0004728189,
0.0005276006,
-0.0052202186,
-0.0148399286,
-0.0436052196,
0.0229789838,
0.012974415,
0.0101062721,
0.0354751088,
0.0063647572,
0.0215091612,
-0.0281689297,
0.0057831001,
0.0142997084,
0.0129050566,
0.0508303419,
0.0231990218,
-0.0419967137,
0.0296784826,
-0.0166122466,
0.0167193618,
0.003259907,
-0.073348023,
0.0071513774,
-0.0142961917,
0.0298363622,
0.0179131012,
-0.0034137266,
0.0315184891,
0.026265813,
-0.0255503859,
-0.0237433705,
-0.0029840602,
-0.0351617821,
-0.013193029,
-0.0168604255,
-0.0177943017,
0.012231892,
0.0474139713,
0.014515982,
-0.0100613572,
-0.077098988,
-0.0355369262,
-0.040222913,
-0.0070305183,
-0.0407495797,
-0.0228351373,
-0.0457620546,
0.0299755409,
-0.0297329575,
-0.0135185001,
0.0823522806,
-0.0178731661,
0.0144844567,
-0.0516505949,
0.045940917,
-0.0293837935,
0.0723945647,
-0.0124361003,
0.034119755,
-0.0244084448,
-0.0018096925,
-0.042079851,
0.0305274073,
0.0309691504,
-0.0491090715,
-0.011846452,
-0.0450506061,
0.0340427719,
0.0034912259,
-0.0249641314,
-0.0412687175,
-0.0429222137,
-0.0284503624,
-0.0198076554,
0.0407681875,
-0.0061969771,
0.0185620636,
0.0116152847,
-0.0179660097,
-0.003145749,
0.0202328898,
0.0009982121,
-0.010764298,
0.0792118683,
0.0587691776,
0.05205011,
-0.0186081138,
-0.0117420014,
-0.0285569075,
0.0546585657,
0.0759510472,
-0.0013278067,
-0.0128421104,
0.0352832489,
0.032379806,
-0.0391315259,
0.0029354903,
0.0256927088,
0.0703922585,
-0.0222481675,
-0.0020241037,
0.0849293917,
0.04454742,
-0.0331087038,
0.010355996,
-0.0093978057,
-0.0012095567,
-0.001611272,
0.0078080934,
-0.1007955596,
-0.0508003905,
0.0027381533,
0.0268470366,
-0.000334342,
-0.0832088366,
0.0250013061,
-0.1644074321,
0.0053864745,
0.0125572598,
-0.033404775,
-0.0221898779,
-0.0373796597,
0.011685349,
0.0013320752,
-0.0245501436,
0.0063932193,
0.0065669459,
0.0104043745,
-0.0038595411,
-0.0076783942,
-0.0819912925,
0.0230302475,
-0.0629498139,
0.0728200674,
0.0215720292,
0.0634383634,
0.0153028416,
-0.0646774769,
-0.0109373424,
-0.0322580524,
0.0196856912,
-0.0223552305,
0.0181895029,
0.0019594168,
-0.0226777904,
-0.0396378525,
0.0718414858,
-0.0689118356,
-0.0200786274,
0.0158703439,
0.0700736046,
0.0349030159,
-0.0343079381,
-0.0114554521,
-0.0001550999,
0.0306969304,
0.0980578437,
0.0435451344,
-0.0005956915,
0.0150955888,
-0.0094720498,
0.0025688035,
-0.0780479461,
-0.0164402891,
0.0466948561,
-0.0007712567,
-0.0123139806,
-0.1191389635,
-0.0308361836,
0.0437974557,
0.0068951193,
0.0144770062,
-0.0240393952,
0.0389713384,
0.0114367623,
-0.0454839617,
0.0719564557,
-0.0473424308,
-0.0213041231,
-0.0539397076,
-0.0415017605,
0.0087397899,
0.0080131227,
-0.0211997349,
0.0814938098,
-0.0490131415,
-0.0629300773,
-0.0113839814,
0.057438571,
0.0124095734,
0.0269775484,
-0.0229454152,
0.0042496929,
0.0143739153,
0.0436429009,
-0.0701240748,
0.009609987,
0.0012036414,
-0.0006915235,
-0.0054954831,
0.0590522587,
-0.0411409922,
-0.0216305237,
-0.0136615196,
0.0904886499,
-0.0499217473,
-0.0530430749,
0.0063821282,
0.0394219719,
0.0093086557,
-0.0485484749,
0.0137074562,
-0.0634240136,
-0.0393670611,
0.000658609,
-0.0363500006,
-0.0518420935,
-0.0116130691,
0.0140620777,
-0.0349629857,
-0.0197145939,
0.0079324897,
-0.0309277195,
0.0298604034,
0.0039800694,
-0.0140908072,
0.0633633956,
0.0289662648,
0.0400894731,
-0.0236865189,
-0.0208246205,
-0.0087382542,
-0.0351314209,
-0.003809704,
0.004677976,
0.0625274628,
0.0306391697,
-0.0295488704,
0.0107173463,
0.0018095569,
-0.0132282572,
-0.0122743873,
0.0103352144,
0.0568408556,
0.0604240596,
0.0140271131,
0.0409515165,
-0.0440129824,
-0.0237373356,
0.0296648741,
0.0547466315,
-0.0119228018,
-0.036705438,
0.050958015,
0.0076132058,
-0.0004071066,
-0.0022420613,
0.0978584662,
-0.0157180876,
0.032097578,
0.0022289888,
0.0109120989,
-0.0400435701,
-0.0147769665,
0.011487891,
0.0096690152,
-0.0055494248,
0.0205982514,
-0.068828918,
-0.0465062931,
-0.0120816994,
0.0311562773,
0.0149753224,
0.0181088895,
0.0428145155,
0.0480271205,
0.0089505306,
-0.0166141856,
-0.0299025662,
0.0532768033,
-0.0663175732,
0.0029320582,
-0.0280175004,
-6.295778031e-33,
-0.054911945,
-0.0834604949,
0.0136571182,
0.0130953602,
-0.0237210933,
-0.0287838094,
-0.0817250833,
-0.0056502097,
-0.0204277299,
0.0166187063,
-0.0123157697,
0.01949431,
-0.0055831783,
0.0179845951,
0.004556118,
-0.038732212,
0.0215463955,
0.0044944328,
-0.0024629615,
0.0224319398,
0.0580185726,
0.0093943365,
0.0241151564,
-0.0090052327,
0.0536274835,
-0.0484585576,
0.0057935677,
0.0274156202,
0.0122868959,
0.0319368914,
-0.0144694634,
0.069060415,
0.0156911686,
0.0072996584,
0.0209249146,
0.033138413,
-0.1042056456,
-0.0559528917,
0.0386011079,
0.0141975554,
-0.0401902422,
-0.0027115755,
0.0362248048,
0.0076131374,
0.0467746668,
0.0227397699,
0.039631974,
-0.0168669876,
-0.0251813289,
-0.0189679489,
-0.0112602282,
0.0125117712,
0.0143635636,
-0.0231567994,
-0.0449492186,
-0.0152456043,
-0.0091699632,
-0.0233222768,
-0.0663826168,
0.0262014829,
-0.0103875548,
-0.0303626414,
0.0240454897,
-0.0057187183,
0.0004551155,
0.0350197144,
-0.0553976037,
-0.0148863085,
-0.041379828,
0.0190864652,
0.0111378767,
0.0563641302,
0.0273259748,
0.0918586552,
0.0090263691,
-0.0299587511,
-0.0408657603,
0.0648976713,
0.0116273575,
0.0241108518,
-0.0114620589,
-0.0265488382,
-0.0162140951,
-0.0318762921,
-0.0204653535,
-0.0422177501,
-0.0233983491,
-0.0140408715,
-0.001207142,
-0.0066416953,
-0.0471070856,
-0.008148104,
-0.0062604467,
-0.027366275,
0.0126776788,
0.0706681535,
0.0118503692,
-0.0083617168,
-0.0256090425,
0.0241794195,
-0.0524560511,
-0.0122328913,
-0.0059049437,
-0.0198132414,
-0.0090825139,
0.0388756804,
0.0093017034,
-0.008887019,
0.0154048931,
0.0020561167,
-0.0243029129,
0.0061206175,
-0.0297901537,
-0.0300696306,
0.0454664566,
0.0435332656,
-0.0113144489,
-0.0108797811,
0.0263571627,
0.0418052822,
-0.0179779846,
0.0206610374,
0.0249375962,
0.0124923643,
-0.0198320877,
0.0048547168,
-0.0274448227,
0.0105128353,
0.0295404196,
-0.0327989236,
-0.0136746475,
0.0111409454,
2.515e-7,
0.0247433186,
-0.0044196802,
0.0336158313,
0.0526766516,
-0.0298718475,
0.0288308468,
-0.0086590014,
0.0266087409,
0.018484639,
-0.0157869551,
0.0208741296,
0.0651832148,
0.0312554017,
0.0392923057,
-0.1225192994,
-0.0017389371,
-0.0538231097,
0.0004685623,
-0.0250639953,
-0.0030069861,
0.0528396741,
-0.0064295223,
0.0379902534,
-0.0113303307,
0.0035601726,
-0.0530684628,
0.0614699274,
0.0015901153,
-0.0209393091,
-0.0059791291,
0.0235907771,
0.0234541949,
-0.0380937196,
0.0345616601,
-0.0288866647,
-0.0005441405,
-0.0054809633,
0.0101316758,
-0.0012102636,
-0.0208499469,
-0.0034449277,
-0.0473038927,
0.0094556427,
-0.0528520197,
0.0511300787,
-0.0840658322,
0.0053995037,
0.0199829023,
-0.0206208471,
-0.0071702921,
-0.0427180789,
-0.0305649694,
-0.0313416868,
0.0059017851,
0.0338202119,
-0.0258936305,
-0.0075678485,
-0.0474922955,
-0.01575578,
0.0030697514,
-0.0070941169,
-0.0725817978,
-0.0347352363,
-0.0603790134,
-0.0099673141,
-0.0680035725,
0.0229210462,
1.686019927e-34,
-0.0028880239,
0.0047798883,
-0.0209249556,
0.0010708015,
0.0415945835,
-0.0292984601,
-0.0170036033,
0.0110781342,
0.033930473,
-0.0349504948,
-0.0071586333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07161v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07161v2 | Psychoacoustic Challenges Of Speech Enhancement On VoIP Platforms | 2023-10-11T03:19:22 | 2023-11-21T07:54:34 | Joseph Konan, Ojas Bhargave, Shikhar Agnihotri, Shuo Han, Yunyang Zeng, Ankit Shah, Bhiksha Raj | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Within the ambit of VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) telecommunications,
the complexities introduced by acoustic transformations merit rigorous
analysis. This research, rooted in the exploration of proprietary sender-side
denoising effects, meticulously evaluates platforms such as Google Meets and
Zoom. The study draws upon the Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) 2020 dataset,
ensuring a structured examination tailored to various denoising settings and
receiver interfaces. A methodological novelty is introduced via the Oaxaca
decomposition, traditionally an econometric tool, repurposed herein to analyze
acoustic-phonetic perturbations within VoIP systems. To further ground the
implications of these transformations, psychoacoustic metrics, specifically
PESQ and STOI, were harnessed to furnish a comprehensive understanding of
speech alterations. Cumulatively, the insights garnered underscore the
intricate landscape of VoIP-influenced acoustic dynamics. In addition to the
primary findings, a multitude of metrics are reported, extending the research
purview. Moreover, out-of-domain benchmarking for both time and time-frequency
domain speech enhancement models is included, thereby enhancing the depth and
applicability of this inquiry. Repository:
github.com/deepology/VoIP-DNS-Challenge | [
-0.0329358093,
0.0675718635,
-0.0192594677,
-0.037377961,
-0.0280943271,
-0.0432179794,
0.0352697894,
0.0012291024,
-0.052991122,
0.0326271206,
-0.0497937687,
-0.027346015,
0.0510043129,
0.0174140222,
0.0149847651,
-0.0350330882,
-0.0171255786,
-0.0467600487,
0.0142097995,
0.0088400049,
0.0014578977,
-0.0143472059,
-0.0309650078,
0.0241363123,
0.0110853799,
-0.0251800474,
0.0074125747,
0.048022788,
-0.0423981398,
0.0175427366,
0.0040531163,
0.0047679213,
0.0051417756,
0.0230450127,
0.0000020147,
-0.0070100231,
-0.0084607368,
0.0286488924,
-0.0350659974,
0.0469219759,
0.0179425124,
0.0846459717,
-0.0520693213,
0.0102555742,
0.0051427921,
-0.007103418,
0.0325675271,
-0.0286717843,
0.0091471151,
0.0037145445,
-0.0157385767,
-0.007142711,
-0.0005388866,
0.0028153569,
-0.0192921329,
0.0247205701,
-0.0010270945,
-0.0559604242,
-0.0180110168,
-0.056606859,
0.0269179121,
0.0157448426,
-0.0006161464,
-0.0367875993,
0.0096986219,
-0.0343717001,
-0.0225841012,
-0.0647293031,
-0.0307604335,
0.0500586629,
0.0349037647,
-0.0036873401,
0.0171614531,
0.0436149277,
0.0010000238,
-0.0518612675,
-0.011788575,
-0.0565176979,
0.0462698974,
-0.051740326,
-0.0732871965,
0.0401903056,
0.0330646858,
-0.0322228745,
-0.0159841161,
-0.0044585406,
0.0192620531,
-0.0504362844,
0.0100181354,
-0.0250227563,
0.0027804514,
-0.0119952438,
0.0667379349,
0.0020120633,
-0.0278082583,
-0.023955429,
0.0356079899,
-0.0978405252,
-0.0468028709,
0.0061408868,
-0.0013164111,
0.0236932207,
-0.064590767,
-0.050105311,
0.016064262,
-0.0201981813,
0.0007008932,
-0.0350683481,
-0.01156752,
0.0194847975,
0.0361055508,
0.0101789637,
-0.0160366707,
0.0307993498,
-0.0427094661,
0.0194463674,
-0.038592197,
-0.0150328772,
-0.0520688035,
-0.0352719873,
-0.002343921,
0.0300363172,
-0.0325654596,
0.0074199964,
0.0403649695,
0.0316535272,
0.0075040623,
0.0519007295,
0.0003248747,
-0.0397811495,
0.0275130104,
0.0148607166,
0.0206852481,
0.000842927,
0.0128327385,
0.0675381646,
0.0170162152,
0.0411326103,
0.021175148,
-0.0387703069,
0.0214876793,
-0.0082443366,
-0.0291768238,
-0.0359197855,
0.0259582531,
-0.0259904992,
-0.0326623507,
-0.0060428823,
-0.0219176114,
-0.0314303711,
-0.0018721867,
0.0236642286,
-0.0352873653,
0.0069343275,
0.086867176,
0.0162898954,
0.0092203878,
0.0243658535,
0.0353852697,
-0.0800679028,
0.0552975051,
-0.100456208,
-0.0193870049,
0.0620290712,
0.0460061096,
0.0202698167,
-0.0492042713,
-0.039330069,
-0.0445147157,
0.0084555242,
0.0263763685,
0.0168668963,
-0.0261020418,
-0.0372352637,
0.0615567043,
0.0522284098,
0.0548635162,
0.0048680753,
-0.042218022,
0.0134120742,
-0.0276561733,
0.0268087871,
-0.0347078852,
-0.0339466482,
-0.0345929638,
0.0184066128,
0.0577243045,
0.0207131095,
-0.0150877004,
-0.0665371865,
0.0567872338,
-0.0152798127,
-0.0063080583,
0.0463560186,
0.0310236681,
0.0188667569,
0.0143015413,
0.018969534,
-0.0133858658,
-0.0677278489,
-0.0152623346,
-0.0328730494,
-0.0091886204,
-0.02372697,
-0.0238380283,
-0.0098425606,
-0.0078522963,
-0.0650507137,
-0.0463049188,
0.0174163524,
-0.0566409938,
0.012026608,
0.0579143167,
-0.022003198,
-0.0233569853,
0.0252532139,
-0.0062879599,
-0.0148179801,
-0.02743279,
-0.0169558153,
0.0278870985,
-0.0468749106,
0.0299412496,
-0.0306782629,
0.0080755204,
-0.0275949854,
0.033599887,
-0.0081431083,
0.0452551953,
0.0346386172,
-0.0225711912,
0.0071295695,
0.015215151,
-0.020900432,
0.0322357826,
0.0357013009,
-0.0043160524,
0.0702631101,
0.0354610085,
-0.0275090747,
0.0380545072,
0.0692966208,
0.0271829031,
-0.0268725287,
0.0803763792,
-0.0090898024,
0.0666441396,
-0.0243071094,
0.0176643897,
0.0102203749,
0.0439501107,
0.0496390611,
-0.0484080426,
0.0184150394,
-0.0262861662,
0.0511466116,
0.031211542,
-0.0153947305,
-0.0507975705,
0.0075333384,
0.0041843769,
-0.0553440601,
0.0047117881,
-0.0150450151,
-0.0214534774,
-0.0250955764,
0.0531182401,
-0.0535449199,
0.0156474765,
-0.0394396149,
-0.0258152075,
0.0617763363,
0.0309267286,
0.0210692137,
-0.0301379208,
0.0077628982,
-0.0441168956,
0.0047122915,
0.0219259709,
-0.0289797354,
-0.0393577404,
-0.0501606874,
-0.0344873443,
-0.0184312258,
-0.0045043402,
0.0369485021,
-0.0502934642,
-0.0434500165,
0.0006415269,
-0.018608138,
-0.0118304417,
0.0333736651,
0.0317433141,
-0.0472375527,
-0.0018992965,
0.0495471768,
0.0359302461,
0.0289957859,
0.0280068014,
0.0021362223,
-0.0050002327,
0.0199465193,
-0.0049993098,
0.0034431249,
-0.0120118214,
0.0345591269,
-0.035822954,
-0.0308234952,
0.0112958178,
0.0557390936,
0.005791557,
0.0183790755,
-0.0049287756,
-0.0162788481,
-0.049383454,
-0.0898034275,
-0.0245413426,
-0.0101383142,
-0.0517235659,
0.0545058809,
0.0125881005,
-0.0149106653,
-0.0242753401,
0.0010813744,
-0.0088342279,
-0.0396550782,
-0.091305986,
0.0300572794,
-0.0239433367,
-0.0464177877,
0.0158314575,
0.0220519044,
-0.0305057336,
-0.0205547623,
-0.0397257656,
-0.0101365382,
-0.0625579506,
-0.0136845456,
-0.0245930348,
-0.0349618904,
0.0234160349,
-0.0153733138,
0.0070961365,
-0.0026618156,
0.0220600348,
0.0068095354,
0.0310582109,
-0.0386247188,
0.0609721653,
0.0390410312,
0.0087517155,
0.0461574048,
0.0333468914,
0.010683476,
0.0035583097,
0.0382410102,
0.0237650145,
0.0688536614,
0.0194284674,
0.0195502751,
0.0410792902,
-0.0587244779,
0.0605684258,
0.0083035138,
-0.0120883994,
0.0082790162,
0.0155587066,
0.0128341606,
-0.0337781273,
0.0547023453,
0.0726733431,
-0.0342674814,
0.0385395922,
-0.0013764752,
-0.0269243959,
-0.0325356424,
0.0364396051,
-0.0110292425,
0.0368522368,
0.0017736094,
-0.0383022055,
-0.0330709331,
0.0403330922,
0.0537748635,
0.0181644298,
-0.0293008946,
0.0561207943,
-0.0191369001,
-0.0549804159,
0.0579250567,
0.0119814957,
0.0005296383,
0.0405912846,
-0.0608735383,
0.010237732,
0.0193381626,
0.0922385678,
0.0060066129,
0.0283888616,
-0.0374199897,
0.0668265373,
-0.1059985906,
0.0005136569,
-0.0637632832,
-0.0286998544,
0.0492638759,
0.0316013321,
-0.010636216,
-0.0437560193,
-0.0364374071,
0.0152148772,
0.0290383864,
-0.0210804641,
0.0174369328,
0.016253328,
0.0552672595,
0.0054362682,
-0.0034720011,
0.0590594783,
-0.0411299728,
0.0324534327,
0.009507196,
-0.0038787911,
-0.0006051073,
0.0004443082,
-0.0077006784,
0.0814021081,
-0.0056038424,
0.0289222188,
0.0349496901,
-0.0676199347,
-0.0040769619,
0.0021922491,
0.0242689215,
-0.0046849228,
-0.0259373598,
0.0047539687,
0.0402012244,
-0.1208372936,
0.0047369106,
0.009548177,
-0.0688809603,
0.0220149234,
0.025076909,
0.0375119746,
-0.0097822677,
0.0318185352,
0.0286528748,
-0.0347326957,
0.0378565304,
0.0417424887,
-0.0137411049,
0.0247453991,
-0.015346339,
-0.0149323298,
-0.0047552516,
0.0257551428,
-0.0572284572,
-0.0367722474,
0.0308316778,
-0.0442681238,
0.0264135282,
0.0452883057,
-0.0388084874,
-0.0448317528,
0.0274254624,
0.0147890784,
-0.0544491895,
0.0466841646,
0.0992877781,
-0.0068262313,
0.0143718692,
0.0331800841,
-0.0169098414,
0.0307117011,
-0.023790244,
-0.0075118728,
-0.0238183569,
-0.0647683963,
-0.0153687177,
0.002365377,
0.0717435703,
0.000989733,
-0.0227550585,
0.0268839821,
0.0483345948,
-0.0031025845,
0.0495555773,
-0.0065733469,
-0.051214125,
0.0005146146,
0.05835931,
0.0081510535,
0.0656753406,
-0.0150681511,
0.0064990553,
0.0029744648,
0.0477093421,
-0.0283328388,
-0.0271676257,
-0.0006841843,
0.0321279429,
0.0080175381,
0.0371702388,
0.0298579782,
0.0154910013,
0.0202208664,
-0.020925438,
0.0005035864,
-0.0165756531,
0.0231488105,
0.0308837984,
-0.0271048602,
-0.0414833166,
0.0249721389,
-0.0324988291,
-0.0195856746,
0.0064405832,
0.0162222516,
0.0439220853,
0.0162500143,
-0.0229579899,
0.0053262697,
-0.0212545954,
0.0662367567,
-0.0177383479,
-0.0244838465,
-0.0394856371,
0.0625168979,
0.0128424373,
0.0052581755,
0.049993977,
-0.0248085428,
0.0475279614,
0.0017996285,
-0.0448407792,
-0.0286974385,
0.0504957139,
-0.0349073932,
-0.0405724682,
-0.0076184557,
-0.0703607053,
-0.025409108,
-0.0551331118,
0.0544456467,
-0.0429704525,
0.0048796684,
0.0103859929,
-0.044480972,
0.0031601489,
0.021508351,
-0.0536465086,
0.0115451487,
-0.014144944,
0.0438949689,
-6.13078344e-33,
0.0230735745,
0.0194441769,
-0.0247430801,
0.0129499556,
-0.0279517118,
0.0048530959,
0.0108989803,
0.0185639318,
0.011689526,
-0.0089450628,
-0.0291274246,
0.0321265496,
0.0341509134,
0.0111292126,
-0.0532942861,
0.0222954303,
0.105737634,
-0.04708701,
0.0254910532,
0.0128240297,
0.0211438946,
0.0262834225,
0.0182487871,
-0.0834589973,
-0.0166406911,
0.0494663864,
-0.0195741709,
-0.0490205064,
0.0693345889,
0.0101454165,
0.0026951246,
0.0488551036,
-0.0383060835,
-0.0394065566,
0.0096024824,
0.0103276679,
-0.0455127694,
0.000719225,
0.002306133,
0.0251339637,
-0.0274207834,
-0.0057754503,
0.0804733112,
0.0531491488,
-0.0605017543,
-0.0348859578,
0.0242453571,
-0.0048000324,
-0.0155441705,
-0.0389071479,
0.0003736064,
-0.0109609207,
-0.0382031947,
-0.0453414842,
0.0602273308,
0.0603759885,
-0.0785727575,
-0.0388472565,
-0.0686160922,
0.0419517942,
0.0320213772,
0.0020600413,
0.0032581401,
0.0273275487,
0.0400223583,
-0.0130781569,
0.0716272295,
-0.0201278478,
-0.0018038157,
-0.0551893748,
0.0545638427,
0.0594304204,
-0.0004403355,
-0.0197118241,
0.0246777888,
-0.0449982062,
-0.0350521356,
0.0157389101,
0.0141741913,
-0.0447371975,
0.0077493074,
0.0466340296,
0.0125969518,
0.0082260501,
-0.0631772429,
-0.0232462958,
-0.0128142759,
-0.0147957643,
0.0062196571,
-0.060924951,
0.0200786274,
-0.0524018072,
0.0358972326,
-0.0473112129,
0.0400125943,
-0.0643193871,
-0.0308886096,
0.0251242295,
0.0248799995,
-0.0532518402,
-0.0046661892,
0.0106526483,
0.0451328568,
0.0795734748,
0.0191928744,
-0.0652811155,
-0.0260978788,
0.0087307077,
-0.0233463719,
-0.0071245371,
0.0102284672,
0.0223254617,
0.0732005388,
0.0284792762,
0.0225803852,
-0.0494470298,
-0.0157240741,
-0.0128114671,
-0.0136592425,
0.0795231164,
0.0252022389,
0.0312346071,
-0.0039439932,
0.0330113135,
-0.0915184245,
-0.0115875741,
-0.0033697842,
-0.0611379072,
0.058708515,
-0.0200997218,
-0.0337806866,
-0.0743650645,
2.881e-7,
-0.0697883815,
0.0068895933,
0.023107728,
0.0079554506,
0.0402051844,
0.0204498023,
0.0175894611,
-0.005582368,
0.0019021196,
-0.0744059235,
-0.0030894976,
-0.0380929038,
0.0464122258,
0.0083581097,
-0.0220996179,
-0.0331893861,
-0.0747986957,
-0.0091502406,
-0.0261771698,
0.0627249703,
-0.0191955548,
0.0369025581,
-0.0221524183,
-0.0661216304,
0.0311047249,
0.0619891547,
-0.0036289189,
-0.0610968247,
0.013629742,
-0.0027094269,
0.0826307386,
0.0170025881,
0.0185931399,
0.007615725,
-0.0327492133,
-0.0024438011,
0.0334065668,
0.0160138831,
-0.0159656052,
-0.0436038971,
-0.0178370848,
0.0229638014,
0.0117621077,
-0.0007243573,
0.0327026173,
0.0316851251,
-0.0433435217,
-0.0540970042,
-0.0765286013,
-0.0227033142,
0.0210515689,
-0.018605642,
0.0288756918,
-0.0265026931,
-0.0384776704,
0.0314653814,
-0.0100319879,
0.0115321195,
0.0106082372,
0.0629630536,
0.0027043847,
-0.0463477187,
-0.0388614945,
-0.03263833,
0.0259037334,
0.0410808809,
0.0150782885,
2.131669925e-34,
0.0065308772,
0.0037468614,
0.0162637495,
-0.0078304354,
0.0045110085,
-0.0536737591,
0.0438434668,
0.0170088746,
0.0064500603,
-0.0135583663,
-0.0162552539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07155v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07155v2 | "A Tale of Two Movements": Identifying and Comparing Perspectives in #BlackLivesMatter and #BlueLivesMatter Movements-related Tweets using Weakly Supervised Graph-based Structured Prediction | 2023-10-11T03:01:42 | 2023-10-21T16:28:07 | Shamik Roy, Dan Goldwasser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media has become a major driver of social change, by facilitating the
formation of online social movements. Automatically understanding the
perspectives driving the movement and the voices opposing it, is a challenging
task as annotated data is difficult to obtain. We propose a weakly supervised
graph-based approach that explicitly models perspectives in
#BackLivesMatter-related tweets. Our proposed approach utilizes a
social-linguistic representation of the data. We convert the text to a graph by
breaking it into structured elements and connect it with the social network of
authors, then structured prediction is done over the elements for identifying
perspectives. Our approach uses a small seed set of labeled examples. We
experiment with large language models for generating artificial training
examples, compare them to manual annotation, and find that it achieves
comparable performance. We perform quantitative and qualitative analyses using
a human-annotated test set. Our model outperforms multitask baselines by a
large margin, successfully characterizing the perspectives supporting and
opposing #BLM. | [
0.0187039003,
0.065115802,
0.027964389,
0.0183873847,
-0.0254966188,
0.0136611834,
-0.0076658246,
-0.0152742499,
0.0505921617,
-0.0601851121,
0.0431255028,
-0.0299985129,
-0.0337260365,
0.0490017533,
0.0213762894,
-0.024715675,
-0.004303324,
0.0389711373,
0.0652072728,
-0.0060077203,
0.050370425,
0.0498286225,
0.0175284743,
0.0406357571,
-0.0428398177,
0.0065751458,
0.0074227862,
0.0266130585,
0.0032907829,
-0.0129701737,
0.0386824869,
0.0203472916,
0.0130219618,
0.0807409734,
0.000001755,
-0.0218531601,
-0.0455785021,
-0.0266717114,
0.024626296,
-0.0686622038,
0.0169360973,
-0.0881363451,
0.0401775613,
0.026274411,
-0.0457879193,
-0.003539491,
0.0168590061,
0.0532545894,
0.0598296262,
0.070674248,
-0.0324593112,
-0.0110847801,
0.0091623981,
-0.0120695997,
-0.0146569256,
0.0060970299,
0.0552265756,
-0.0107505852,
-0.0252778977,
0.0437226184,
0.0049785296,
0.0215884093,
-0.0046452107,
-0.049317468,
0.0324851759,
-0.0183072705,
-0.031547267,
-0.0199613962,
0.0054637026,
0.0635967329,
0.0017154618,
-0.0467082299,
0.0556825362,
-0.0395294875,
-0.00281436,
0.0045839981,
-0.0348998383,
-0.0063195941,
-0.0388514884,
0.0483515374,
0.0003804884,
0.0043447413,
0.0447806269,
0.0317763835,
0.0544899106,
0.0638862103,
-0.0463487133,
-0.0323278084,
0.0136271827,
0.0347634107,
-0.0022138795,
-0.014523264,
0.0152245602,
-0.0211022142,
-0.0278488714,
0.0401688106,
-0.0176098738,
-0.0268494505,
-0.0200645085,
-0.0866943896,
0.0286991261,
-0.0201178305,
0.0354581885,
0.0253581163,
0.0136175361,
-0.0584464371,
-0.0357946977,
0.0039391671,
0.0212903954,
0.0078049107,
-0.070750095,
0.0039259889,
-0.0077870227,
-0.0229579695,
-0.0027490004,
-0.0058642435,
-0.0007219018,
-0.010402156,
-0.0157129206,
-0.011190474,
-0.0293534473,
0.0193387978,
0.0194345098,
0.0346020386,
-0.0001133121,
0.015754167,
-0.0047854357,
0.0104430579,
-0.0183084309,
-0.0039834715,
0.0185289532,
0.0296102203,
0.0406840742,
-0.0051648961,
-0.0160269886,
0.0338688679,
0.0260707736,
-0.0066547715,
-0.0453249514,
-0.0428602993,
-0.0123402979,
-0.025664866,
0.0315451026,
-0.084246859,
0.0331843346,
0.0441450365,
0.0027154358,
-0.0514247231,
0.0176064279,
0.0190813839,
-0.0240827315,
0.0538582504,
-0.0134527674,
-0.0003350383,
0.0446380451,
0.002215137,
0.0041692844,
0.0748964176,
0.0207839552,
0.0217875075,
0.0400236249,
-0.0127067938,
-0.0420262329,
0.012988925,
0.0035069096,
0.0142814601,
0.007563998,
0.0072763171,
-0.0467849523,
-0.021040285,
-0.0479612723,
0.0603136756,
0.0265412368,
-0.0220038854,
0.0103747891,
0.0654615015,
-0.0112848729,
-0.000347552,
0.0414902195,
0.0454713069,
-0.0115990704,
-0.0391877256,
-0.0062149721,
-0.0235812608,
-0.0178090818,
-0.0355827659,
0.0116355401,
-0.0268022995,
-0.0195934903,
-0.0085153105,
-0.0515941344,
0.0015874333,
0.0626065955,
-0.0358856469,
0.0224278998,
-0.0216539465,
-0.0203361567,
0.0214314554,
0.0329686552,
-0.051129777,
-0.0199269149,
-0.0153285759,
-0.0175269619,
0.0339869857,
-0.032272242,
-0.0045458768,
-0.0261144508,
-0.0510854721,
0.0745391399,
0.0549083166,
0.0461290292,
-0.0227631889,
-0.0494350567,
-0.0341224559,
-0.0470265523,
0.0098057967,
-0.0197812933,
0.014365796,
0.0222590305,
-0.0246206373,
0.0159005709,
-0.0181495268,
-0.0540520661,
0.0316587947,
0.0095149204,
-0.007000945,
0.0204503201,
-0.0029267124,
0.0244794413,
0.0849514827,
0.0043479041,
-0.0054298104,
0.0021698626,
-0.0102492133,
-0.0814863965,
-0.0029218476,
-0.0435132273,
0.00371531,
0.024684269,
-0.0340202712,
-0.0409628451,
0.0489989594,
-0.0271673165,
-0.0390230678,
0.0765887648,
-0.0176636819,
-0.0132177221,
-0.0080463262,
-0.0362956747,
-0.0454854108,
-0.0070209075,
-0.0287325997,
0.0616179928,
-0.0001986165,
-0.0094771162,
-0.0071573183,
-0.070333451,
0.0352461748,
-0.0035274155,
-0.0226082057,
0.0026436308,
0.0104935523,
0.0085287904,
0.0503799431,
-0.0193659794,
-0.066172041,
0.0147735383,
-0.0664670095,
-0.0083288215,
-0.0476864614,
-0.0200326107,
0.0010178857,
0.009572356,
0.0131346881,
-0.0249840021,
-0.0299823675,
0.0271866452,
0.0291614719,
-0.0017920285,
0.0087059969,
-0.0043443521,
0.0198397059,
-0.0590756536,
-0.0603309497,
-0.0775034651,
0.063007392,
0.0754980072,
-0.0979745314,
0.0060874321,
-0.0013798564,
-0.0259871799,
0.010268284,
0.0137515552,
0.0287283864,
0.0406261124,
-0.0206129607,
-0.0000051658,
-0.0017273529,
0.013853956,
0.0697131455,
0.0005750876,
0.0196443535,
-0.0339776352,
0.0074641029,
-0.0423697792,
0.0226900186,
-0.0451784134,
-0.0263859704,
-0.0146720093,
0.0631007925,
0.0325555503,
-0.0118392343,
-0.0923791677,
0.0222053435,
-0.0594326705,
-0.0433370396,
-0.0151608419,
-0.0382435769,
0.0085331313,
-0.0446597487,
-0.0473847836,
-0.0208570417,
0.0449438617,
0.0244743768,
0.0657436252,
0.0247010607,
-0.0558042265,
-0.0501536205,
0.0675145537,
0.0339667052,
0.0044791591,
-0.0196448732,
0.0062317937,
0.0187568069,
-0.0384391174,
-0.0013892585,
0.0017197322,
-0.0096750325,
-0.0004534382,
0.0471085049,
0.0197952315,
-0.0166045595,
-0.0201878343,
-0.0789537206,
-0.0535633229,
0.0092148948,
0.0059977518,
-0.0033958897,
0.0442807786,
0.0135024497,
-0.0146942148,
-0.0266733747,
0.0248297285,
-0.0195356999,
-0.0109324604,
-0.0148630757,
0.0033865282,
-0.0514257364,
-0.0035641789,
-0.0319956429,
0.0150203202,
0.0306649376,
0.0333419032,
0.0260508601,
-0.0448065996,
-0.0320980586,
0.003222602,
-0.0115720006,
-0.0088103814,
-0.0561494008,
0.0659647956,
-0.0162049364,
0.0199517086,
0.089334175,
0.0298303477,
-0.0187895484,
0.014476073,
0.0107976282,
0.027115183,
0.0325194076,
0.019102782,
-0.0761842802,
0.0104566021,
-0.0522849746,
0.0475860015,
-0.0146310683,
-0.0865802243,
0.0271855481,
-0.087814942,
-0.0189603902,
-0.0058144075,
0.0357347205,
0.0094529446,
-0.0574331544,
0.0331495889,
-0.0114882188,
-0.0239149574,
-0.0496167466,
0.0087585682,
0.0293311365,
0.0575747378,
-0.0677399933,
-0.0030375232,
0.0119568864,
-0.020838201,
-0.0212155525,
0.0270581786,
0.0496266037,
0.0135156522,
0.0142621361,
0.062105,
0.0026923155,
-0.0154362414,
-0.0014194101,
0.0587581135,
-0.0205698404,
-0.0108710974,
-0.003674258,
0.0755448937,
-0.0316612497,
-0.0451596566,
-0.0075920466,
0.0461368337,
-0.0012042915,
-0.0513751619,
-0.0175012238,
0.0235095564,
0.0123906769,
0.0233045667,
0.0515852496,
-0.0363042951,
-0.0040894626,
-0.075937815,
0.0516313575,
-0.060378246,
-0.0528326184,
-0.0174080618,
-0.0138825187,
0.0156432241,
-0.0131314648,
-0.0392650925,
0.0213606246,
0.0116104819,
-0.0104775317,
-0.0001192764,
0.0722919181,
-0.0369349346,
-0.0571960621,
0.0395217687,
-0.0100621711,
0.0451813713,
0.0448065847,
-0.0898978189,
-0.0065499255,
0.0415588319,
-0.0112998839,
0.0063901958,
-0.1010397077,
-0.0723470598,
0.0072312951,
-0.0027141701,
0.0157855228,
0.0352090262,
0.0046518599,
-0.0431761406,
0.0261921696,
0.0236282125,
0.0186875984,
-0.0053080753,
0.0073491954,
0.0136445696,
0.0084630558,
0.040581014,
-0.0305519011,
0.0123007456,
0.0309031494,
0.0292259455,
-0.0350774936,
0.0091064703,
-0.0231593475,
0.0005319015,
0.0737736672,
0.0089536831,
-0.0597091466,
-0.0296022333,
-0.070902884,
-0.0338431038,
-0.0494098477,
-0.0050187791,
0.0049900855,
0.0206456576,
-0.0070000836,
-0.0713409036,
0.0091684964,
-0.0269815195,
0.0688841417,
-0.0696407631,
0.0540818162,
0.0156515762,
-0.0023531062,
-0.0083871316,
-0.024459077,
0.0159482099,
0.0365053043,
0.0106907627,
-0.027271824,
0.0263497643,
0.005591061,
0.0091968076,
0.0315127298,
0.0082036229,
-0.0186544154,
-0.0385450274,
-0.0466273502,
-0.0280745588,
-0.0068267714,
-0.0141588254,
-0.0407460257,
0.0490230732,
0.0061320495,
-0.020228494,
0.0071140574,
0.0540897213,
0.0025209086,
-0.037438482,
0.0257537756,
0.0139643997,
-0.0334876925,
0.0404460914,
0.0169624705,
0.0159357507,
0.0224759318,
0.0545289814,
-0.0496644303,
-0.0280493628,
-0.0013651783,
0.0136134364,
0.0388486087,
0.0423876978,
0.0135882804,
-0.0165981818,
-0.0445690118,
0.0793737248,
-0.0292890836,
0.025829779,
0.0374163575,
0.0146886399,
0.0559447147,
0.0158078857,
0.0355933718,
-0.064353466,
-0.0048808195,
0.0006661395,
-0.0616618395,
0.0186338741,
-6.251431037e-33,
0.0277325306,
-0.0662659407,
-0.040710967,
0.0362714417,
-0.0138565116,
0.0162260067,
-0.0313100256,
0.0235938262,
0.0071080173,
0.030307008,
0.0052399822,
0.0406821966,
0.0108129187,
0.0495346785,
0.017245274,
-0.0124384062,
-0.0012811256,
-0.0029977444,
0.003005649,
0.0354793295,
0.0419703498,
0.0244258139,
0.0184031092,
-0.1218035296,
0.0678484142,
-0.0147350496,
0.0156336818,
-0.0121946046,
0.0361301191,
0.0176506676,
-0.0130075123,
0.0799550787,
0.0488963127,
0.0005569405,
0.019649826,
0.0919396579,
-0.0338143259,
-0.0092453929,
-0.0121225649,
-0.0157189015,
-0.064351663,
0.0107412534,
0.0094557162,
0.0013459362,
-0.0250971876,
0.0054990887,
0.0481012575,
0.019681992,
0.0550582632,
-0.03799548,
-0.0595404096,
0.0487460382,
-0.0556355529,
0.0230849534,
-0.004938859,
0.0090469019,
0.0340320803,
0.0171717871,
-0.019053679,
0.0019734534,
-0.0300486404,
-0.0139733665,
0.0087949811,
0.0298966039,
-0.0077536278,
0.0839165822,
-0.002308283,
0.0389588512,
-0.0200923253,
0.006597593,
-0.0068762535,
0.0107846353,
0.0281725898,
0.0763549879,
-0.0092993407,
-0.0189102422,
-0.0725373849,
0.0007547726,
0.0482949354,
-0.0119298454,
0.0085488865,
-0.0026852929,
-0.007947417,
-0.0439815931,
-0.0245915912,
-0.0806735456,
-0.0154777495,
-0.0234864727,
-0.0395696834,
-0.0046162121,
-0.045705203,
0.0498347841,
0.0164405257,
-0.03769508,
-0.0487369411,
0.0614311695,
-0.0341283791,
0.0228812471,
0.0099051641,
0.0216963477,
-0.0739659518,
-0.0002482886,
-0.0161875319,
0.0201646648,
0.0534441136,
-0.0172207765,
0.069090426,
0.0342402868,
-0.0473400317,
-0.0011250519,
-0.0238016453,
0.013394909,
-0.0554143488,
0.0037940443,
0.0353297368,
0.0689944401,
0.0089443419,
0.0414726399,
0.0439736545,
0.0148493377,
0.0430537462,
-0.0289839096,
-0.0256109405,
-0.0096239876,
-0.0405624472,
-0.0274493042,
0.011367457,
0.0355731919,
0.0183843598,
-0.0782580078,
0.0036995723,
-0.0225521494,
2.503e-7,
0.0896149948,
0.0531966761,
0.0249968544,
-0.0124529274,
0.0027458381,
0.0276016593,
0.0353328809,
0.0384604521,
-0.0618051477,
-0.0455383398,
-0.0307657756,
0.0514681526,
0.01260796,
0.0329371169,
-0.0678286105,
-0.003106503,
-0.0771534517,
0.0182625279,
-0.0656005144,
0.0366348177,
0.0371184833,
0.0581032261,
0.0496544577,
0.0076877731,
-0.0381543487,
-0.0193536002,
0.052586142,
-0.0330710225,
-0.0288661383,
-0.0061386456,
0.028062012,
-0.0463782996,
0.0070991116,
-0.0226448681,
-0.0379340351,
-0.0002403083,
0.0470119976,
0.021169981,
0.0204862934,
0.0071944669,
0.0003779315,
0.0252155047,
0.0275000017,
0.0375955589,
0.0365149789,
-0.0424274132,
-0.0657117739,
-0.0635841042,
-0.0229852963,
-0.0196865853,
0.0088669918,
0.0021704175,
-0.0120308483,
0.0105963713,
-0.0063260728,
-0.0148893511,
-0.0011555889,
-0.0745508224,
-0.0206004493,
-0.0120530492,
-0.0096381912,
0.0067066858,
0.0219621919,
0.033721175,
0.034085758,
0.0434264392,
0.0579004996,
1.934073916e-34,
0.0241738111,
0.0375591964,
-0.0206105262,
-0.0494064055,
0.0235021338,
0.0051970626,
-0.0700345635,
0.0139203789,
0.0259239115,
-0.0450611934,
-0.0103609283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07147v1 | QFT: Quantized Full-parameter Tuning of LLMs with Affordable Resources | 2023-10-11T02:47:40 | 2023-10-11T02:47:40 | Zhikai Li, Xiaoxuan Liu, Banghua Zhu, Zhen Dong, Qingyi Gu, Kurt Keutzer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable impacts across a wide
spectrum of natural language processing tasks. Fine-tuning these pre-trained
models on downstream datasets provides further significant performance gains,
but this process has been challenging due to its extraordinary resource
requirements. To this end, existing efforts focus on parameter-efficient
fine-tuning, which, unfortunately, fail to capitalize on the powerful potential
of full-parameter fine-tuning. In this work, we propose QFT, a novel Quantized
Full-parameter Tuning framework for LLMs that enables memory-efficient
fine-tuning without harming performance. Our framework incorporates two novel
ideas: (i) we adopt the efficient Lion optimizer, which only keeps track of the
momentum and has consistent update magnitudes for each parameter, an inherent
advantage for robust quantization; and (ii) we quantize all model states and
store them as integer values, and present a gradient flow and parameter update
scheme for the quantized weights. As a result, QFT reduces the model state
memory to 21% of the standard solution while achieving comparable performance,
e.g., tuning a LLaMA-7B model requires only <30GB of memory, satisfied by a
single A6000 GPU. | [
0.0136227878,
0.0972403288,
-0.0080120228,
0.0594480634,
-0.010116226,
0.0066017071,
-0.0350686349,
0.0227677077,
-0.0631015673,
-0.0402274318,
-0.0447808914,
-0.0586711764,
0.0012700522,
0.029682273,
0.0087830937,
-0.039265532,
0.0752976164,
-0.0299397837,
-0.0039234851,
-0.0172963496,
-0.0086023016,
-0.0010332614,
-0.008766734,
0.0076822806,
0.0139853656,
0.0032998049,
-0.0163125023,
0.040503595,
0.030247068,
0.0039035045,
0.0180775076,
0.0549213812,
0.0322539173,
0.0215226058,
0.0000020813,
-0.0339360833,
-0.0134351468,
-0.0190974753,
-0.0125384424,
0.0588296913,
0.0615308359,
-0.0143077001,
-0.0328458287,
0.0163794514,
-0.0085854828,
-0.0247299671,
0.03799849,
0.0063331039,
0.0711542815,
0.0878647119,
0.0067414544,
-0.0600761585,
0.0290599559,
-0.0288412254,
-0.0345255397,
-0.06702362,
0.0123579642,
-0.0232884325,
-0.003562459,
-0.0099499561,
-0.0509343334,
0.0313786007,
0.0084153302,
0.0105442563,
-0.0060210703,
-0.0132681066,
-0.0293126646,
-0.0208123345,
-0.0195046384,
0.0672462881,
-0.1081919223,
-0.0281744916,
0.0197872445,
-0.0166750848,
-0.0546909794,
-0.051478155,
0.002977377,
0.0255499426,
0.0331513397,
0.0214279611,
0.02941004,
-0.0596369021,
0.0457971208,
0.0209620669,
-0.0176503118,
0.0221342556,
0.0341923535,
0.0329946615,
-0.0352357514,
-0.0266797394,
-0.1035299674,
-0.0475497618,
-0.0023472279,
0.0255365055,
-0.0345294252,
-0.0008460075,
-0.0678882822,
-0.0072942949,
-0.0052367086,
-0.0153398449,
0.0472174808,
0.0707207918,
0.0007159864,
0.0280585885,
0.0012715484,
0.0196710844,
-0.0335422941,
0.0050180675,
-0.0445632115,
-0.0031085827,
-0.0055922298,
0.0098947911,
-0.0481735505,
0.0046854885,
-0.0610959679,
-0.0177318845,
-0.0545994975,
0.0071050776,
0.0364997052,
-0.0201725699,
0.0170245487,
0.0159429219,
-0.0130648315,
-0.0135953063,
0.0234100334,
0.0401286557,
-0.0293408372,
0.000937429,
-0.0067802961,
-0.0551536866,
-0.0147135314,
0.0180449821,
0.0177196544,
-0.0199156124,
0.0323516168,
0.0259877592,
0.0105350753,
-0.0633270144,
-0.0518547967,
0.0016830679,
0.0124952467,
-0.0696268007,
-0.0250855051,
-0.0235383604,
0.0160282273,
-0.0165699162,
0.0464426167,
-0.0423166379,
0.0272241086,
0.0098068118,
-0.0030229164,
0.0816523358,
-0.0255344901,
-0.0081472751,
0.0198605731,
0.0198098123,
0.0492473915,
0.0884076729,
0.0391227864,
0.0493080914,
0.0233038161,
0.0006835741,
-0.0223137233,
0.0356229097,
-0.0168811288,
0.0093165822,
-0.0670922846,
-0.0000619173,
-0.0042066188,
0.0471489169,
0.0571748763,
0.0415730029,
-0.0435552932,
-0.0373774506,
0.0573829971,
0.0384089574,
0.0464126654,
0.039811261,
-0.0203646645,
-0.0174768306,
0.0185455587,
-0.0453369357,
-0.0221610982,
0.0333835036,
-0.0158216283,
-0.0057238135,
0.0179298222,
0.0640319586,
-0.012872749,
-0.0263778996,
-0.0215662774,
-0.0051713013,
-0.0441492237,
0.0254207309,
0.0071358602,
-0.0049131429,
-0.0328909792,
0.0504481979,
0.0363638587,
-0.0313799866,
-0.0173722319,
-0.0582985319,
-0.0039023811,
0.0792677775,
0.0433437228,
-0.0090445224,
-0.0128378076,
-0.0030793578,
0.0151727656,
0.0244323406,
0.0231106691,
0.0106802508,
0.044508718,
-0.0757032335,
-0.0168247782,
-0.0137119684,
0.0047318209,
0.021102149,
0.0488558784,
0.0169791728,
-0.0017118597,
0.0068048863,
-0.0144406399,
0.0248637963,
0.014821779,
-0.0629329309,
0.0516118407,
-0.0232908707,
0.0455422886,
0.0008161447,
-0.0097963223,
-0.0183939505,
0.0376474224,
-0.0258938801,
0.012533877,
-0.0458008125,
-0.0096945763,
0.0083352644,
0.0482823551,
0.0530243218,
0.0440351479,
0.055346787,
-0.0663454458,
-0.0619295351,
0.0311095417,
-0.0163581688,
0.051614251,
-0.0294432081,
0.0151492571,
-0.0109008709,
0.0568426028,
-0.0373297222,
0.0072745699,
-0.0069850758,
-0.0053645568,
-0.0078180805,
0.0414164141,
-0.0339051299,
-0.0389002226,
-0.0371821709,
0.033055041,
0.0350730419,
0.0310884677,
-0.0237490237,
-0.0057584243,
-0.0051739826,
-0.0089214798,
-0.0794183388,
0.0393900648,
-0.0471081361,
-0.0002059989,
0.0349308737,
0.0382160395,
-0.0174522083,
0.0086849611,
-0.0011832153,
0.0159120858,
-0.0027067976,
0.0157536808,
0.0127620734,
-0.0054409108,
-0.0294449516,
-0.0509363823,
-0.0335896052,
0.033388041,
0.0130700041,
-0.0167305749,
-0.0278247055,
-0.0425889269,
-0.0154782152,
-0.0211706869,
0.0387993008,
-0.0070558037,
-0.0388389006,
-0.0392779075,
-0.011820389,
0.0087806908,
0.0738329738,
0.0234116763,
0.0162506737,
0.037099123,
0.0005729943,
-0.0244694743,
0.0368828103,
-0.0291214231,
-0.0572678447,
-0.0235202722,
0.0183073096,
-0.0064279949,
0.093448475,
-0.0401625149,
-0.0006845433,
-0.0217625797,
0.0180237684,
-0.0238655936,
-0.0192906931,
-0.0194956306,
0.0272826757,
-0.0223665237,
0.0223406795,
-0.0031174629,
-0.0588395596,
0.0306726638,
-0.0445953235,
-0.0021492953,
-0.0092295976,
-0.0341755673,
-0.0567424595,
0.0379987508,
0.0146474168,
0.0152364178,
-0.0508501194,
0.0195898507,
0.0067326091,
-0.0159163475,
0.0113856411,
-0.0146806967,
0.0208057538,
-0.033896286,
0.0399989262,
-0.0359343812,
-0.0282563381,
-0.0148199629,
0.0021771635,
-0.0350848995,
0.007061875,
0.0359885767,
-0.0783716515,
0.0125284605,
0.0381744392,
-0.0025609352,
0.0519599132,
-0.0249392148,
-0.0108975014,
-0.0453512222,
0.0248425175,
0.0698640198,
0.0050824401,
0.0520715676,
-0.0078385202,
-0.009955585,
0.0183538161,
0.0335973017,
0.0048174881,
-0.0463416316,
0.0249535926,
0.0464194976,
-0.04078345,
-0.0131347785,
0.0030633449,
0.0432204045,
-0.0622147173,
0.0091215437,
0.0855585635,
0.0318714716,
-0.0347076915,
0.0256818514,
0.0190044753,
0.0084816599,
0.018289635,
0.0320495926,
-0.0853640512,
-0.0620195977,
0.0237108711,
0.0381809361,
0.0295179114,
-0.0035983385,
-0.0230056923,
-0.0509151183,
0.0306245349,
0.0232717004,
0.0192010887,
-0.00595367,
-0.0309979152,
-0.0102689145,
-0.0541776717,
0.0308971349,
0.0425631888,
-0.0050753504,
-0.0056804363,
0.0084398575,
0.0297871009,
-0.0310259312,
0.0233897772,
-0.0192524269,
0.0251798034,
0.0079852277,
0.0128419651,
0.0213648267,
-0.0086630201,
0.0349645838,
-0.0443832651,
-0.0132094864,
-0.0467743725,
-0.0373244993,
-0.0248444062,
-0.030207675,
0.035198871,
0.0162385851,
-0.031398356,
-0.039264787,
-0.021328453,
0.0138907703,
-0.0248578768,
0.0214782488,
-0.0015127776,
-0.0373170599,
-0.0265956968,
0.0464480445,
-0.0037420427,
-0.0072047254,
-0.0292599201,
-0.0162109081,
-0.0376290716,
-0.0220338237,
-0.0438122451,
-0.0676181465,
0.003074728,
-0.0290103089,
-0.0313175172,
0.0385956801,
0.0056776847,
0.0190223437,
-0.0292665195,
-0.0023358241,
0.0051735402,
0.0155843915,
-0.0904283598,
0.043665234,
-0.0596087798,
0.0199772939,
-0.0709778368,
0.0010775813,
0.0723534301,
0.010742195,
-0.0113902129,
0.0468309373,
-0.0887884945,
-0.0757679641,
0.0296586361,
0.0318013877,
0.016536653,
0.04030215,
-0.0022322589,
-0.0695884153,
0.0164975692,
0.039246697,
-0.0037560503,
0.0638859197,
0.0058626714,
-0.0078995256,
-0.0048675244,
0.0371529944,
-0.010811151,
0.0258651022,
0.0243001767,
0.0450054072,
-0.0377388522,
-0.0779954866,
-0.0353699662,
0.0128553258,
0.0488406494,
-0.0128672244,
-0.0204999112,
-0.0012771364,
0.0431559719,
0.0090008276,
0.0346088,
-0.0391153097,
-0.0118828695,
0.0416802019,
-0.0088814646,
-0.0466232933,
0.0148546007,
0.0418755114,
-0.0102170147,
0.0142384022,
0.0410755388,
-0.0398914889,
-0.0092409011,
0.0159786046,
-0.0073877233,
0.0127918646,
0.0558358319,
0.0263800304,
0.0503009744,
-0.0222466439,
0.0295967255,
-0.0080733513,
0.0112160146,
-0.0825181678,
0.0241437089,
-0.0450469814,
-0.0843611136,
-0.0644762143,
0.0253504757,
0.0855870396,
0.0051581534,
0.0387478918,
0.0058781812,
-0.0388527364,
-0.009885882,
0.002791269,
0.0139356945,
0.0022492229,
0.0399492085,
0.0259346124,
-0.0493093841,
0.0247073341,
0.0350094028,
0.0367918462,
0.0703136846,
0.0115967998,
0.0158155058,
-0.0182313807,
-0.0481892228,
-0.0121496096,
0.0164038371,
-0.0075376611,
-0.0037430809,
-0.0018957346,
-0.0420545675,
0.0372114368,
-0.010955344,
0.0001332143,
-0.0369608589,
0.0435850993,
0.0045499834,
0.0099655129,
-0.026955409,
-0.0405506417,
-0.0348431952,
0.0080727953,
-0.0025524625,
0.0187443979,
-6.528110816e-33,
-0.027879104,
0.0407912843,
0.0151780359,
-0.0098146116,
-0.0044516646,
-0.0071124956,
-0.0075809387,
-0.0291885044,
-0.0158990361,
-0.0350210033,
-0.0325664058,
0.0156893581,
0.0248473566,
0.007396176,
-0.0221909769,
0.0016513604,
0.0609920435,
-0.020027874,
-0.0086068446,
0.0168522634,
0.0056562955,
0.0416465886,
0.0470379516,
0.0456291512,
-0.0627178326,
0.0132682798,
-0.0308465995,
0.0412736125,
-0.0226647314,
0.0064474922,
-0.0525359064,
0.0238685478,
-0.0137013523,
-0.0335581712,
-0.0188875198,
-0.0080796396,
-0.0681695491,
-0.0013536445,
0.0387161151,
0.0193188526,
-0.0039568041,
-0.0257274397,
0.0356298238,
0.0357164256,
-0.019000154,
0.0053556468,
-0.0357029513,
-0.0284492131,
-0.033985056,
-0.1028612778,
-0.0188247059,
0.0437233336,
0.0202601422,
0.0226282384,
0.0643740445,
-0.0468838252,
-0.0241827499,
-0.0112680821,
-0.0386879034,
-0.0338865481,
0.0518069901,
0.1017182991,
0.0462081768,
0.0420589969,
0.0151544521,
0.0279719848,
0.0483889244,
-0.0406525768,
-0.0022198558,
0.0744470805,
0.0483552665,
0.0159124807,
0.0235727821,
0.0142071191,
0.0531712472,
-0.0268024635,
-0.0768189728,
-0.0482852794,
0.0207202975,
0.0457927845,
-0.0117583126,
0.0561723411,
-0.0018787986,
-0.0166348126,
-0.0537877008,
-0.0200280771,
-0.0350429304,
0.0005541131,
0.0300390664,
0.0487091616,
-0.049737785,
-0.0044492441,
0.0143406941,
-0.0342175551,
0.0205088519,
-0.0256862585,
0.0106628034,
0.0200624056,
0.0212125666,
0.030759709,
-0.0284732841,
-0.0384175517,
-0.0011330913,
-0.0302239954,
0.0126905041,
-0.0315316468,
0.0157974251,
0.0579198077,
-0.0798241273,
0.0046607004,
-0.0294349287,
0.0375296809,
-0.0003343617,
0.0714716092,
0.0134889418,
-0.0047385017,
0.0219586901,
0.0522184707,
-0.0137754586,
0.0235713609,
-0.020271441,
-0.0022163484,
0.0103940526,
0.0707953647,
-0.0206963941,
-0.0057467748,
-0.0193936229,
0.0249160156,
0.0293551255,
-0.0948800966,
-0.0196939111,
0.0112237772,
2.804e-7,
0.0204879306,
0.0626848713,
-0.0040235179,
0.0028155094,
0.0102875931,
-0.0096140038,
0.0118067861,
0.0032676607,
0.0022194593,
0.0135568837,
0.0137768229,
0.0455343574,
0.0299765728,
0.0070546926,
-0.0748289227,
0.0154524883,
-0.0513121895,
0.0282484237,
-0.04432071,
-0.0502043739,
-0.0229380131,
0.1389190108,
0.0156709105,
-0.0133172935,
0.0351976976,
-0.0038725976,
0.0442832261,
-0.0235437062,
-0.0214744657,
0.0391008519,
0.035801921,
0.0424415506,
-0.0182737503,
-0.0536087267,
-0.025293095,
0.021511117,
-0.0375341624,
0.1320967227,
-0.0261394642,
-0.0329713933,
0.0049067722,
0.01702822,
-0.017337285,
-0.0012044816,
0.0799708664,
-0.0044983481,
0.0241074078,
-0.0907509103,
-0.0000515195,
-0.0153973112,
0.0410207137,
-0.0107664848,
0.0006603411,
0.0487755351,
0.026063662,
0.0068756528,
-0.0478334576,
-0.1011606008,
-0.0350311846,
0.0190006327,
-0.0304770488,
-0.0048997579,
-0.0776365101,
-0.0158077367,
0.0246626977,
-0.0606873482,
-0.0213698689,
2.73179354e-34,
0.0700223222,
-0.0303766578,
0.0163519029,
-0.0053729056,
0.0134956706,
0.0154970102,
-0.024877483,
0.0357604437,
-0.0137372762,
-0.0794257224,
-0.0274016894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07146v1 | Empowering Psychotherapy with Large Language Models: Cognitive Distortion Detection through Diagnosis of Thought Prompting | 2023-10-11T02:47:21 | 2023-10-11T02:47:21 | Zhiyu Chen, Yujie Lu, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mental illness remains one of the most critical public health issues of our
time, due to the severe scarcity and accessibility limit of professionals.
Psychotherapy requires high-level expertise to conduct deep, complex reasoning
and analysis on the cognition modeling of the patients. In the era of Large
Language Models, we believe it is the right time to develop AI assistance for
computational psychotherapy. We study the task of cognitive distortion
detection and propose the Diagnosis of Thought (DoT) prompting. DoT performs
diagnosis on the patient's speech via three stages: subjectivity assessment to
separate the facts and the thoughts; contrastive reasoning to elicit the
reasoning processes supporting and contradicting the thoughts; and schema
analysis to summarize the cognition schemas. The generated diagnosis rationales
through the three stages are essential for assisting the professionals.
Experiments demonstrate that DoT obtains significant improvements over ChatGPT
for cognitive distortion detection, while generating high-quality rationales
approved by human experts. | [
0.0493733101,
0.0215732139,
-0.0315069668,
0.0321592391,
-0.0605648831,
0.021914551,
-0.0069069085,
0.0180910397,
0.0744777918,
-0.0247636922,
0.0028346526,
-0.0372372866,
0.0193416942,
0.0351887345,
-0.01698252,
-0.0650475919,
0.0320499651,
0.0164457411,
0.0795210525,
0.0076938756,
0.0087150503,
0.0053191981,
-0.0547489859,
0.0306549966,
-0.0131250704,
-0.0320133828,
0.0283128526,
-0.0046959491,
0.014952004,
-0.0712620318,
-0.0441080369,
0.0120435869,
-0.0214281157,
0.020587584,
0.0000021324,
-0.0396430418,
-0.0149652706,
-0.0182453543,
-0.0253131986,
-0.0320704579,
0.0096659353,
0.0030904652,
0.0004159869,
0.0414680988,
-0.0356539637,
0.028302379,
0.0216499753,
0.1052169576,
0.0843461826,
0.0780700445,
-0.0299587362,
-0.0150761614,
0.0256441422,
0.0055689863,
-0.0144762583,
2.671e-7,
0.05275172,
0.0212871674,
0.0171905309,
-0.0110792667,
-0.0026747466,
0.0017685089,
-0.0434998982,
0.0143045848,
-0.0465626009,
0.004073618,
-0.0100382138,
-0.0309708659,
0.0037916668,
0.0669333935,
0.0347037427,
0.0069391858,
0.0350151584,
-0.0037745817,
-0.023705503,
-0.0277033877,
0.0067858282,
0.0124286618,
-0.029990023,
0.0240796749,
0.073658973,
-0.0049177776,
-0.0039273337,
-0.0070516369,
-0.0133499112,
0.0426975898,
-0.0035422321,
-0.0409137756,
0.0210749172,
-0.0257970449,
-0.0922823921,
-0.0800283104,
0.010036041,
0.0426888615,
-0.0795563832,
0.0077080284,
-0.0191695243,
-0.0726069212,
0.019729808,
-0.0364834517,
0.0353338309,
0.0593825504,
-0.0177317224,
0.0184552949,
0.0112055289,
0.0534122027,
-0.0403897725,
0.0343438834,
-0.0489047691,
0.0167643335,
-0.0771876127,
-0.0040656361,
-0.0295723788,
0.0167548079,
0.0082415799,
-0.0110857664,
-0.1076634973,
0.0004543375,
-0.0438998342,
-0.0043718889,
-0.0064934082,
0.0047519798,
0.0243496336,
0.0035431862,
-0.0258566234,
0.0170872528,
-0.0208176542,
0.010560289,
-0.0077914279,
-0.0390667319,
-0.0058007841,
0.033963304,
-0.0300129466,
-0.0347371325,
0.0176721253,
0.0054404535,
0.01568624,
0.0112364972,
-0.0366454311,
-0.0597662739,
-0.0621431358,
-0.0434500501,
0.0160104632,
-0.0248321053,
-0.0056646848,
-0.0045294613,
0.0056262943,
-0.0451412126,
0.0176835842,
-0.0147130825,
-0.0739914551,
0.089247331,
-0.057035502,
-0.0021502958,
0.0178098958,
0.0376586318,
-0.0411700532,
0.0188908651,
0.0108585712,
-0.0203231219,
0.0086069619,
-0.0200417023,
0.0209506806,
-0.0420679301,
0.0149021475,
-0.0486734807,
-0.0313032642,
-0.0066904207,
-0.0204741452,
0.042309165,
-0.0590125173,
0.0565591604,
0.0088207265,
0.0159785654,
0.0258465558,
0.0391266644,
0.0139631135,
0.0190937072,
0.0313377231,
-0.0104541974,
0.0024559004,
0.0100595886,
-0.0199204721,
0.0134647638,
-0.0662526935,
-0.0338992737,
-0.014449521,
-0.0008999433,
-0.0008679139,
-0.0508956574,
-0.0312384218,
-0.014632619,
-0.0069697695,
-0.0105512971,
-0.016496852,
-0.0306759812,
-0.0042227777,
0.0127300471,
0.0527846888,
0.0008221965,
-0.0654473901,
-0.1123807207,
0.0146732824,
0.089487128,
0.037489403,
-0.0715456456,
-0.025153596,
-0.0170801338,
0.0017876194,
0.0266253203,
0.0195532963,
-0.0053850845,
-0.0160082821,
-0.0072430288,
0.0071406425,
0.0292877443,
0.0192818418,
-0.0305664651,
-0.02528915,
0.0318759605,
-0.0201805253,
-0.0033829615,
0.0096701887,
0.0445025414,
0.0015372548,
-0.0292951223,
0.0002759487,
0.0153330769,
0.0566367432,
0.0352309234,
-0.0106082875,
0.0350424387,
0.0152679402,
-0.0434266515,
-0.0480205305,
0.0312511772,
-0.055546131,
-0.0271411184,
0.0243378058,
0.0046600653,
0.0070233857,
0.003688426,
-0.0106091136,
-0.0388917588,
0.0297752041,
-0.0549647138,
0.0200681351,
-0.0156354327,
0.0257147532,
0.0116657466,
0.0306965578,
-0.0190642923,
0.0690393969,
-0.0128999995,
0.0114106135,
0.0153420568,
-0.0490122624,
0.0128659206,
-0.0281852875,
-0.0270638093,
-0.0065576867,
0.0058443416,
0.0070393123,
-0.020090349,
-0.0284365006,
-0.0187848993,
0.0005109883,
-0.1196580976,
-0.0128797432,
0.0019254059,
0.0088522611,
0.0066851047,
-0.0171421114,
-0.0192313939,
0.0209708698,
-0.015291349,
0.0290341079,
0.0367491432,
0.0389840007,
0.0156789906,
0.0063253483,
-0.0210177973,
-0.0222483575,
0.0245871339,
-0.0851128474,
0.018092351,
-0.0184006896,
-0.0274857432,
-0.0519241951,
0.0086424137,
-0.0534038171,
0.018352516,
-0.0005111516,
-0.056716349,
0.0133034093,
-0.0038497893,
0.0326947011,
0.0628552958,
0.0169854574,
0.0322429128,
0.0421560779,
0.0019507984,
0.0017909701,
0.0068323454,
0.013423278,
0.0037669952,
-0.0220747944,
-0.0540184267,
-0.0032897401,
0.0855242237,
0.0541343391,
0.0009384891,
-0.0618480518,
0.0222417265,
-0.0084448531,
0.0231336318,
0.0257698875,
-0.0378679,
-0.0152635388,
0.0407908037,
-0.0023556915,
0.0017816868,
0.1073590145,
-0.0151508907,
0.0398226939,
-0.0755221918,
-0.0297767594,
-0.0096926596,
0.0095405811,
-0.0003828401,
0.04347587,
0.0422289036,
0.0287248045,
-0.0029054498,
-0.0570408218,
0.0158992931,
-0.0331173129,
0.0085681723,
-0.062722452,
0.0210519582,
0.0207206476,
-0.0061010653,
-0.053520564,
-0.0209864601,
-0.0232160017,
-0.0128226271,
0.0211964473,
0.0229833294,
-0.0214495454,
0.0089966878,
0.0228729323,
0.0347075276,
0.0166199766,
-0.0281709321,
-0.0038313896,
-0.00620068,
0.0011366876,
-0.0001268612,
0.0374152325,
0.002953653,
0.0535155386,
0.0578223765,
-0.0240729563,
0.0348239578,
-0.0250602495,
0.0149152996,
-0.049892962,
-0.005184216,
-0.0100954128,
0.0194606166,
0.0406143442,
-0.0000648565,
-0.0155203957,
0.1250891387,
0.0687171742,
-0.0441255011,
0.0287943967,
-0.0106158201,
-0.0542240702,
0.0060240789,
-0.0200844649,
-0.065680027,
-0.0321093313,
-0.0217012633,
0.0036465952,
-0.0631388724,
-0.0343920775,
-0.0110544004,
-0.036930833,
0.0412386172,
-0.0255063344,
0.0299317352,
-0.0183957182,
-0.0120881423,
0.0114690019,
0.0013796734,
-0.0275001321,
-0.0186440721,
0.0165445227,
-0.0194933787,
-0.0107456604,
-0.0399698652,
-0.0217023008,
0.0567235611,
-0.0046054483,
0.0855235755,
0.0171594825,
0.0630271435,
0.0140742585,
-0.0485414639,
-0.0410907157,
0.0371256173,
0.0312865227,
0.0002910301,
0.0490471497,
0.0504780784,
-0.0059431768,
-0.0436375067,
0.037552733,
-0.0479173698,
-0.0403036103,
0.0209540837,
0.1072156578,
-0.06816075,
-0.01327575,
-0.018840678,
0.0593351983,
0.0467623435,
0.0717371479,
0.0100213783,
-0.0218210034,
-0.0231314152,
0.0329903476,
-0.0011769081,
0.0306342132,
-0.0389916264,
0.0115807895,
0.0146224378,
-0.0008791662,
-0.1082214415,
0.006235315,
0.0081410082,
0.0033324412,
-0.0194964502,
-0.0375851952,
-0.0169580523,
0.0223773215,
-0.0730380863,
0.026297329,
0.015222461,
0.0332766585,
-0.0253620837,
0.00638142,
0.0196702518,
-0.025514951,
-0.0195002872,
0.0218511485,
-0.0288494471,
-0.0199799947,
0.0299245492,
-0.0054299072,
0.0262828469,
0.0120180612,
-0.0067393114,
0.0109080356,
-0.0035321289,
0.0011680243,
-0.0350597054,
0.0029725872,
0.0257453937,
0.0302127805,
0.0094998917,
0.0485142954,
0.0223669708,
0.0729686171,
0.0480351336,
0.0098862713,
-0.0401413068,
-0.0244266391,
0.0436698757,
0.0659506321,
0.027873354,
0.022704348,
0.0246603247,
0.005539516,
-0.0267257784,
-0.0331388935,
-0.014008252,
-0.0045642192,
-0.0228811577,
0.0034795837,
-0.0095348898,
-0.0160760321,
-0.0506933518,
-0.0978243873,
-0.0605660155,
-0.0009879853,
0.0121760052,
-0.0042796317,
-0.0085458364,
0.032002002,
-0.0157564264,
0.0079149455,
0.0174890012,
-0.0191092119,
0.0350668952,
-0.0077719265,
0.1051133871,
0.0364403613,
-0.0076290858,
-0.0272163972,
0.0299980436,
-0.0116799437,
-0.0921298116,
0.0156700034,
0.0086476961,
0.0305946227,
0.0181409493,
0.0211245399,
-0.0321561843,
0.0179528203,
0.0198271703,
0.0602448769,
0.0115443915,
-0.0041386196,
0.0203410313,
0.0170511603,
-0.0092401523,
-0.0228557419,
0.0536081754,
-0.0612942614,
0.0115435943,
0.0194426719,
-0.0567763448,
-0.059506461,
-0.0234112684,
-0.038008783,
0.0380123444,
-0.0262595639,
0.0510532223,
-0.0737759098,
-0.0530965254,
0.036550533,
-0.01524333,
-0.0104052462,
-0.0097511169,
0.0312467199,
0.0538340025,
0.0166776516,
-0.0376658551,
-0.0028240762,
0.0103554549,
-0.0286812652,
0.0111339083,
-0.0180608928,
-6.193501206e-33,
-0.0003122869,
-0.0290945191,
0.009814606,
0.0064057135,
-0.0235957876,
-0.0030188351,
-0.0357930437,
0.0277970638,
-0.0151363155,
0.0281672888,
-0.0005295646,
0.0784735456,
0.0033023218,
0.0128906984,
-0.0104950545,
0.0159575846,
0.0225769971,
-0.0074873045,
-0.022865802,
-0.0100442907,
0.011049171,
-0.0012369219,
0.0507598035,
-0.0841719583,
0.0107446676,
0.0524288937,
-0.014749066,
0.0495899506,
-0.0431497656,
0.0236141272,
-0.0457917564,
0.0637609065,
0.0481741726,
-0.022998115,
0.04404613,
-0.0026513417,
-0.0070010098,
-0.0369967557,
0.0476535149,
-0.0431447364,
-0.0460293256,
-0.0009870768,
-0.005521365,
0.002697756,
-0.0020387082,
0.0185890365,
0.0201854464,
-0.066992119,
0.0728631467,
0.0398306698,
-0.0444563776,
-0.0044760299,
-0.036950469,
-0.0200827029,
-0.0164402295,
-0.017262511,
-0.049452953,
0.0330799334,
-0.0553665012,
0.0015438834,
0.0358860418,
-0.013650436,
-0.0004422785,
-0.0453744158,
-0.0315063447,
0.0450090058,
0.0355871841,
0.009639767,
-0.0568882711,
0.0273096357,
-0.0400374793,
0.0530149899,
0.0830610842,
0.0237168409,
0.0206111092,
-0.0251636449,
-0.0708245337,
-0.0331304707,
0.0406529009,
0.0164894294,
0.0465841293,
-0.004762046,
-0.0542019829,
-0.0401763357,
-0.015823029,
0.0024548832,
-0.0652921349,
-0.0082480274,
0.0122933993,
-0.016310839,
-0.002423258,
-0.0188403782,
0.0048051579,
-0.0344114266,
0.056551598,
-0.0490800105,
-0.0002541604,
0.0015091574,
0.0012253807,
-0.0014757417,
-0.0389687568,
-0.0150800422,
0.0449957848,
-0.0000717527,
0.0611488484,
-0.0041192016,
0.0231338087,
-0.0354396738,
-0.0153830899,
-0.010608932,
-0.0129942009,
0.0335538276,
-0.0152808884,
0.0182177294,
-0.0061100656,
0.0369506553,
-0.0346924737,
0.0183290187,
0.0231589377,
0.0173231289,
-0.0656179339,
-0.0082449717,
-0.0047237137,
0.0136548262,
-0.0432686508,
-0.0385885909,
-0.0173488054,
-0.0112264669,
0.0127702253,
-0.0765392333,
-0.0342029408,
-0.0385115258,
3.037e-7,
0.0285527147,
0.0777247176,
-0.0000787128,
0.0166423358,
0.0484527424,
0.0547240153,
0.0060914848,
0.0217634924,
0.0132602602,
-0.0507387333,
0.0144954985,
0.0283274911,
0.0295559149,
0.0650968477,
0.0018294689,
0.0059012123,
-0.0233464986,
-0.0699226558,
-0.041287154,
0.0290082321,
0.1280148625,
0.036445681,
0.0222414993,
-0.0377853438,
0.0412216261,
0.0223387871,
0.0295640919,
0.0045641335,
0.0036917184,
0.0335516967,
0.0667498633,
-0.0231287237,
0.0324561112,
0.0691056177,
0.0278282203,
-0.0010360808,
-0.0187044181,
0.0157291349,
-0.0785298795,
-0.0049960054,
-0.0221176203,
-0.0011989599,
0.0083513279,
-0.019604113,
0.0636473373,
-0.0682756901,
-0.0798220783,
-0.0360784456,
-0.0414184555,
-0.0389598906,
0.0403338559,
-0.0069186562,
-0.021997733,
0.0431000739,
-0.0001871084,
0.0205157325,
0.012672211,
-0.0693255141,
-0.0004069963,
0.0409789607,
-0.0243464354,
0.0095685283,
0.0307333842,
0.0032572974,
0.0494726859,
-0.0869642049,
0.0461967662,
2.921643455e-34,
0.0369382687,
0.0430585891,
0.0450629145,
-0.0207828619,
0.0412798338,
0.0251774844,
-0.0050457348,
0.0072883563,
0.0079652322,
-0.0761710107,
-0.0048015271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07137v1 | AE-smnsMLC: Multi-Label Classification with Semantic Matching and Negative Label Sampling for Product Attribute Value Extraction | 2023-10-11T02:22:28 | 2023-10-11T02:22:28 | Zhongfen Deng, Wei-Te Chen, Lei Chen, Philip S. Yu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Product attribute value extraction plays an important role for many
real-world applications in e-Commerce such as product search and
recommendation. Previous methods treat it as a sequence labeling task that
needs more annotation for position of values in the product text. This limits
their application to real-world scenario in which only attribute values are
weakly-annotated for each product without their position. Moreover, these
methods only use product text (i.e., product title and description) and do not
consider the semantic connection between the multiple attribute values of a
given product and its text, which can help attribute value extraction. In this
paper, we reformulate this task as a multi-label classification task that can
be applied for real-world scenario in which only annotation of attribute values
is available to train models (i.e., annotation of positional information of
attribute values is not available). We propose a classification model with
semantic matching and negative label sampling for attribute value extraction.
Semantic matching aims to capture semantic interactions between attribute
values of a given product and its text. Negative label sampling aims to enhance
the model's ability of distinguishing similar values belonging to the same
attribute. Experimental results on three subsets of a large real-world
e-Commerce dataset demonstrate the effectiveness and superiority of our
proposed model. | [
0.0122295357,
-0.0276013147,
-0.0252578873,
0.0248075183,
-0.0464467667,
-0.0077974182,
-0.0118829198,
-0.0088023711,
-0.005716146,
-0.0907247588,
-0.0324655287,
0.0034944718,
-0.0182358902,
0.0106104035,
-0.0230245348,
0.0100203929,
0.0044266237,
0.0449337959,
0.0206708852,
0.0371237844,
0.057659626,
0.0371459797,
-0.0069723502,
-0.0127952239,
-0.0139603019,
-0.0099325199,
0.0015489234,
-0.0030389316,
0.0368096791,
-0.0317044631,
0.0326923281,
0.0022666657,
-0.0287897959,
-0.0476876423,
0.000001671,
-0.0668108165,
-0.0346902236,
0.0026722816,
-0.0072741667,
-0.0245037731,
0.0641052425,
0.044453077,
0.0595322326,
0.0268921666,
-0.0384471267,
0.0004990894,
0.0353080668,
0.0809291378,
0.0303976648,
0.0006611165,
-0.0380457379,
-0.0425161235,
-0.0153262615,
-0.0100436611,
0.0267059505,
-0.0490629114,
0.0397774689,
-0.0128748966,
0.044447843,
0.0634918287,
0.0222649891,
0.0234440714,
-0.0184500646,
0.0408730358,
0.0033349395,
0.0564190447,
-0.0001663745,
0.0061881165,
-0.0061260448,
0.1141036451,
-0.0243690424,
-0.0023514514,
0.0053387922,
-0.0231975317,
0.0324281156,
-0.0248391926,
0.0036015147,
-0.0100599881,
-0.0069191577,
-0.001426049,
-0.0147012435,
0.0281376969,
-0.0019303109,
0.0064220498,
0.0247851908,
0.0377323553,
-0.00668626,
-0.0546500869,
0.0084503014,
0.0088884607,
-0.0469923206,
-0.0214310065,
0.0487662368,
0.0000998457,
0.0404744074,
0.0249621104,
-0.0478646457,
-0.0317308269,
0.0140094822,
-0.0645757243,
-0.0202318132,
-0.0408786088,
-0.0379118212,
0.0556392856,
-0.0551741906,
-0.022158185,
0.0426715612,
0.0194338914,
-0.0356541574,
0.0017107857,
-0.061676655,
-0.0300012641,
-0.0195339788,
0.0678796992,
-0.006597599,
0.0098319072,
-0.0214445312,
-0.0452601463,
-0.0396629348,
0.0087929461,
-0.0286923852,
0.003302739,
0.0159089733,
0.0072687767,
0.002164277,
0.0277775191,
-0.0364415348,
0.0311434604,
-0.0226453748,
0.0098158289,
0.0327086337,
-0.0008643328,
0.0751006976,
-0.0549572855,
0.0221522413,
0.0377206691,
0.0108540636,
-0.0278293584,
-0.0540944934,
-0.064612031,
-0.0100775631,
-0.0100616282,
-0.0124135558,
-0.0016665916,
0.0464711599,
0.0021145693,
-0.0114509556,
-0.0366288237,
0.0255864803,
-0.0177861471,
-0.0099432869,
0.1132912785,
0.0204936098,
-0.0533947796,
0.0224406905,
-0.0121851414,
0.0220134594,
-0.0301209297,
-0.011308535,
0.0522555113,
0.0659650266,
0.0160329416,
0.0160395168,
0.0193627737,
0.0123765711,
-0.0379716493,
-0.0122353537,
0.0055869278,
0.0176191181,
0.0124759544,
0.0060940767,
0.0001846393,
-0.0425141267,
-0.0577000231,
0.079763867,
0.0010761427,
-0.0408145823,
-0.022393709,
-0.0165351424,
0.0512192659,
-0.017495323,
-0.0649246424,
0.0221272931,
0.0257013757,
-0.0309115164,
0.0278514829,
-0.0313925073,
-0.0246085655,
-0.020852726,
-0.0354762375,
-0.0010705728,
-0.0606979802,
0.0295142401,
0.0377659462,
0.0513756461,
-0.0110391844,
-0.0079706404,
0.023437677,
0.0081175538,
-0.0259646326,
-0.0231645461,
-0.0083138542,
0.0236437265,
0.0348496996,
-0.0055356221,
-0.0547659583,
-0.0585910678,
-0.0420955494,
-0.0002387353,
0.0161956381,
0.0298335459,
-0.0607654974,
-0.0055158315,
-0.0321729518,
-0.04011143,
-0.0045855246,
-0.020395888,
0.0231962949,
-0.0180605073,
0.0066159894,
0.0414946638,
0.0177316442,
-0.0085156988,
0.0370774455,
-0.0116249397,
-0.0030499587,
0.0259795878,
0.0296294708,
0.0260437895,
0.0219225958,
0.0069481595,
-0.0015445983,
0.0393567011,
-0.0574146509,
-0.0563821197,
-0.0051584821,
0.0155092627,
-0.0243021566,
0.0773318559,
-0.0118184686,
0.0217525735,
0.0309556518,
-0.0315578952,
-0.0320376642,
-0.0163491927,
-0.0000275335,
-0.0110170841,
-0.0125413937,
0.0152253062,
-0.0002031542,
0.019934753,
-0.0676482618,
0.029458601,
0.02989107,
-0.0027723333,
-0.0671684369,
-0.0104506109,
0.0101714665,
-0.010312791,
-0.0287845694,
-0.0031195118,
-0.0111030545,
0.0193882417,
0.0255007781,
-0.0006556897,
-0.0186904036,
0.0115445228,
-0.0118163656,
0.0197007824,
0.0312937647,
0.0333312526,
-0.0149584012,
-0.0001886966,
0.0269284844,
-0.0256372187,
-0.053523466,
-0.0040438748,
-0.0535916761,
0.0022802632,
0.045017682,
0.0324579813,
-0.0159428511,
0.0215504579,
-0.0003409719,
-0.0090241721,
0.0288621057,
0.0250724852,
-0.0102705611,
-0.0526826717,
-0.0384526774,
-0.0479860231,
-0.0098781791,
0.0220747292,
0.0260010231,
-0.0460681133,
-0.0082070362,
-0.0460436307,
0.0227890089,
0.0187870003,
-0.0182566941,
0.0150980568,
0.0307161305,
-0.0395757146,
0.0086555146,
-0.0219228901,
0.071719408,
-0.0009460092,
-0.0014884815,
0.0142936436,
0.082036376,
-0.0438469164,
-0.0138399778,
-0.0318887085,
-0.010581065,
-0.0000440498,
-0.0256752167,
-0.0379365869,
0.0457300693,
0.0062803579,
0.0227760803,
-0.0460637473,
-0.0106522152,
0.0648008585,
0.0033391933,
-0.0332786068,
-0.0120660122,
-0.002966898,
-0.0309542455,
0.0740725249,
-0.0124271493,
0.0411346331,
0.034432169,
-0.0104898931,
-0.0087556625,
-0.0058523077,
0.0550743751,
-0.0222130548,
0.004848572,
-0.0132165058,
0.0292934254,
-0.0583174601,
-0.046783518,
-0.0006455036,
-0.0556958504,
0.0200832952,
0.0005705319,
-0.0447788872,
0.0323053263,
-0.0777860731,
0.0284689534,
-0.028665252,
0.0267680194,
-0.0017061678,
-0.0198020842,
0.0077412082,
0.058062382,
0.0925168246,
-0.0568235293,
-0.041817531,
0.0078940336,
-0.0121165486,
0.0275874957,
-0.0197471678,
0.0108309472,
0.002757112,
-0.0219759401,
0.0582872927,
-0.0628666654,
0.0319090076,
0.030279113,
-0.0396888778,
0.010995782,
0.0107372124,
0.1059652343,
0.0416439697,
-0.0094254175,
-0.0090160584,
0.015396297,
0.01123532,
0.0306446571,
0.0014574949,
-0.069643721,
-0.0315270834,
-0.0258360244,
0.0138438735,
0.0217775162,
-0.0268863458,
0.0093632517,
-0.1133765355,
-0.0209676437,
-0.0318765715,
-0.0521759614,
-0.0258063693,
-0.034515433,
-0.0074766488,
-0.0444749705,
0.0329864211,
-0.0145810219,
-0.0010085752,
-0.0076746927,
0.031044038,
0.0308158193,
-0.0242485851,
0.0736136734,
-0.0235929135,
0.004193252,
0.025335839,
0.0468349084,
-0.0485550389,
-0.0109897675,
0.0067352285,
0.011394728,
-0.0385654941,
-0.0006950456,
0.0540627092,
-0.0417535529,
-0.0125649692,
0.0174037814,
0.0029251596,
-0.0484127291,
-0.008009728,
0.0226617083,
0.0211145096,
0.0150309363,
-0.0282973517,
-0.0178027507,
-0.0691917613,
-0.0162609424,
0.0404129475,
-0.0281966627,
-0.0911867768,
-0.0146241086,
0.0230622571,
0.0032247126,
0.002362085,
-0.0292484667,
0.0017486975,
-0.0394688509,
-0.0110793859,
-0.0677787513,
-0.0403142907,
0.044229351,
0.0422510616,
0.0103837941,
-0.0171852577,
0.031080151,
0.0226758495,
-0.0727190301,
-0.0077370689,
-0.0323400833,
0.060285978,
0.0353935584,
0.0318911895,
0.0909799114,
-0.0709244236,
-0.0563143678,
-0.0052531897,
-0.0006492022,
-0.0506951436,
-0.0285404734,
0.0156711675,
0.0106550734,
0.0658528283,
-0.0252733417,
-0.0503573865,
-0.0268744864,
0.0520210564,
-0.022758184,
-0.0541926585,
0.0253966283,
0.0056006396,
-0.0095682507,
0.017530961,
-0.0357181691,
0.0600586012,
0.0304725077,
0.0551614612,
-0.0026700336,
-0.056808576,
0.0484860614,
0.043195188,
0.048637487,
0.0024353699,
0.0284464695,
-0.0272316299,
0.0184641685,
0.0152861495,
-0.0630163699,
-0.0345548242,
-0.0087498957,
0.011548141,
-0.029151611,
-0.0160871297,
-0.0232602358,
0.0093910936,
0.043562226,
0.0070611075,
-0.0207176358,
-0.011738061,
0.0391989425,
-0.0261311252,
-0.0295891911,
0.0038669384,
-0.0195379127,
0.043539606,
0.0246766452,
-0.0391829833,
0.0028029208,
0.0314046629,
0.0057480265,
-0.0455757417,
0.0525536686,
0.0217137393,
0.0944833606,
-0.0621933378,
0.0112411892,
0.0125149991,
-0.0175921358,
0.040657863,
0.0093454337,
-0.0390979573,
-0.0179277863,
0.0463429168,
-0.0265538953,
-0.0009135877,
0.022863673,
0.0264066346,
-0.0357514806,
-0.0142201995,
0.0652856231,
0.0248597432,
0.0334788151,
-0.0329576991,
-0.0825658962,
-0.0483549498,
0.0045938515,
0.008108722,
0.0216821097,
-0.0316586904,
-0.0135609508,
-0.0301773995,
-0.0211870912,
0.0243075695,
-0.0352163278,
-0.0000104951,
0.0653030574,
0.0406064987,
0.0503613055,
0.0219401065,
-0.0262435414,
-0.0202881284,
-0.0141677856,
0.0051008388,
-0.0052102953,
-0.0250267554,
-4.895470386e-33,
0.0013645753,
-0.0487520769,
-0.0229750872,
0.0545289554,
-0.0066406513,
-0.0198369399,
0.0366365798,
-0.0236853324,
0.0150471479,
0.0312207416,
0.0269122999,
-0.0307287723,
0.0227220841,
0.0438400842,
0.0488400981,
-0.0414383188,
0.0278220735,
0.0337285995,
0.0095427753,
0.0380654,
0.0215462316,
0.0468417555,
0.0770015046,
-0.0925960019,
0.0437386446,
-0.0480834916,
-0.0097132884,
-0.0145627297,
0.0586867593,
0.0654117465,
0.0102226017,
0.0519158281,
0.045535177,
-0.0694278777,
0.0418989621,
-0.0228689127,
-0.1051582247,
-0.0102618961,
-0.0376612134,
0.0110981567,
-0.0114468476,
0.0190637242,
0.0303144585,
-0.0028218301,
0.0405932441,
0.0455960073,
0.0854297355,
-0.0508192442,
-0.040110752,
-0.0594478026,
-0.0455872938,
0.0329422876,
0.0020152398,
0.0047858008,
0.0595813803,
0.0465562083,
0.0055141128,
0.0494510494,
-0.0186681543,
0.0203698259,
-0.0485525802,
-0.0032784182,
-0.0025562216,
0.0520826839,
-0.0008220798,
0.0209066905,
0.0254969541,
-0.0020950097,
0.0603475645,
0.0352588668,
-0.0368258655,
0.0599774159,
-0.0071679377,
0.0819877908,
0.0284590684,
0.0076789251,
-0.0355136283,
0.055738613,
0.0228750203,
-0.0210565589,
-0.0309337974,
0.0155969709,
-0.0251601599,
-0.0003627653,
-0.0241831709,
0.0088844327,
-0.0533181913,
0.0113845868,
0.0311310701,
0.0361480191,
-0.0563396327,
0.1242860407,
0.0073080608,
-0.0243177637,
-0.0854940191,
-0.0391217433,
-0.0011658423,
0.0333717242,
-0.0200940091,
-0.0463963673,
-0.0237860512,
-0.0506509244,
-0.0084997313,
-0.041015923,
0.0041222451,
-0.0340627655,
0.0835115984,
-0.0262030624,
-0.0421547554,
0.0123690357,
0.0315072909,
-0.0572275259,
-0.0456649028,
-0.004619021,
0.0147527549,
0.0295197926,
-0.0283064581,
0.0667216256,
0.0564547628,
0.0048046876,
-0.0267852098,
-0.0592208765,
0.0262469891,
-0.0236908104,
-0.0199689399,
-0.0349909514,
-0.0146599086,
-0.0286406782,
0.0273612682,
-0.0643392652,
0.016493855,
-0.0053312457,
2.383e-7,
0.0040322533,
0.0081760697,
-0.0001246383,
-0.0204638522,
0.0294784606,
0.0844826251,
0.0117681213,
0.0473021865,
-0.0092300735,
0.0162300412,
0.0393724702,
-0.0371440426,
0.0066042016,
0.0251081977,
-0.0289894491,
-0.0090989992,
-0.0587872565,
-0.02350167,
-0.0431942604,
0.0087636793,
0.0806103572,
0.0662189573,
0.0620369129,
-0.0272157397,
-0.0252034292,
-0.0062815985,
0.0536263362,
0.0029457817,
0.036057733,
0.0194514412,
0.0044409344,
0.0148792425,
-0.0349719562,
0.0355072469,
-0.0170423761,
0.0157693736,
0.0760511085,
0.0678852051,
-0.0545418151,
-0.0072917496,
-0.0048715677,
-0.0286729205,
0.0066032382,
-0.0014419735,
0.0726115853,
-0.0697335675,
0.0010916272,
-0.047486227,
-0.0642945617,
0.0172608607,
-0.0130504668,
-0.0073495195,
0.0053985324,
0.0276873745,
0.0088066906,
0.0042547802,
-0.0420559086,
-0.0736068934,
-0.0050484054,
-0.0054527149,
0.0243875943,
0.0166137088,
0.0069742077,
0.0913432389,
0.0535604693,
-0.0657295287,
-0.015921751,
1.664290731e-34,
0.0030261071,
0.0068087867,
-0.0459845737,
0.0460159704,
-0.0301699452,
-0.0071404646,
-0.0230714325,
-0.0019398663,
-0.0159647875,
-0.0211890712,
0.0037471978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07135v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07135v2 | Comparing Styles across Languages | 2023-10-11T02:16:12 | 2023-12-05T02:18:40 | Shreya Havaldar, Matthew Pressimone, Eric Wong, Lyle Ungar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding how styles differ across languages is advantageous for training
both humans and computers to generate culturally appropriate text. We introduce
an explanation framework to extract stylistic differences from multilingual LMs
and compare styles across languages. Our framework (1) generates comprehensive
style lexica in any language and (2) consolidates feature importances from LMs
into comparable lexical categories. We apply this framework to compare
politeness, creating the first holistic multilingual politeness dataset and
exploring how politeness varies across four languages. Our approach enables an
effective evaluation of how distinct linguistic categories contribute to
stylistic variations and provides interpretable insights into how people
communicate differently around the world. | [
0.0470534153,
0.0461255126,
-0.0340554006,
0.0506641567,
-0.0103188362,
0.0403280146,
0.0346223228,
0.0163122509,
-0.0287163835,
-0.0046566627,
-0.050450135,
-0.0828028843,
0.039718248,
-0.0045270552,
0.0489422567,
-0.0512888916,
0.0000401912,
0.0012796018,
0.0351052992,
-0.0199899692,
0.0797685236,
0.0422837511,
0.0017521969,
0.0317000821,
-0.0044862991,
-0.0058555142,
-0.0531947464,
0.034259703,
0.0023473923,
0.025871383,
0.0383633375,
0.0514646322,
0.0090877516,
-0.0131240888,
0.0000016333,
-0.0236336477,
0.052536875,
-0.0550142601,
0.0426910706,
0.0162588898,
0.0795078874,
-0.0173844472,
-0.0114618987,
0.0038991889,
-0.0077327872,
-0.0440708697,
0.0833878294,
0.0483813956,
0.0576392896,
0.0833453387,
-0.0032850641,
-0.0635148361,
-0.0338636488,
-0.0274819639,
0.0026633034,
0.0052154395,
-0.0102566658,
-0.0545809083,
-0.0664989576,
0.0122557152,
0.0060310182,
0.0128888125,
-0.0350995585,
-0.0508405268,
-0.0052530812,
-0.0096395938,
-0.0309917275,
0.0030679966,
0.0021800094,
0.0277767722,
0.0669899508,
-0.0146002648,
0.0205533504,
0.0107275229,
0.0062675644,
-0.0142831728,
-0.0396032743,
0.0071744611,
-0.0072781686,
0.034950804,
0.023667179,
0.0054433676,
-0.0128801791,
0.0586326271,
0.020675065,
0.0383150503,
-0.0203850884,
0.0005128151,
-0.0650358424,
-0.000173701,
0.0372028872,
-0.0465617552,
0.0151157472,
0.0210181195,
-0.0005945101,
-0.0117508238,
0.0148073798,
-0.0099706072,
0.0543380454,
-0.0315193236,
0.0494550951,
-0.0270434767,
-0.0267623253,
-0.0095400661,
-0.015459232,
0.0566503257,
0.0056257066,
0.0143072736,
-0.0198883209,
-0.0360982195,
-0.065542087,
-0.0399100669,
0.0308472998,
-0.0332860537,
-0.0053596976,
0.0529826395,
-0.0193240754,
-0.0166456141,
-0.0227393154,
-0.0053340099,
0.017278228,
-0.0124250306,
-0.0293143913,
0.0063165994,
-0.0079487665,
-0.0112755811,
-0.0671855882,
0.0087488797,
0.0113103148,
-0.0260561742,
0.0231580492,
0.0297741815,
0.0107803531,
0.0054820413,
-0.002925525,
0.0283531286,
-0.0337370485,
0.0284555089,
-0.0150942514,
-0.0079606222,
-0.0110259159,
-0.0484386683,
0.011610317,
-0.067348443,
0.0186123345,
-0.010909915,
0.0059772814,
-0.0230903942,
-0.0093211522,
0.0135114407,
-0.0488752872,
0.025437057,
-0.0085404254,
0.0183071941,
0.061219316,
-0.0402950607,
0.0284664836,
0.0387885943,
0.0181860235,
0.0077640358,
0.0840894952,
-0.0177900251,
0.0002934843,
0.0050553535,
-0.0242758617,
0.0271052551,
-0.0295666214,
-0.0407124348,
-0.0067865099,
0.0305787344,
0.0559661537,
0.0305279847,
-0.0029492017,
-0.0012271818,
0.0676370114,
0.0146159763,
0.0379859097,
0.0409550741,
0.0398679376,
0.0511753596,
-0.0091866776,
0.0439150035,
-0.029536048,
0.0190093871,
-0.0215772949,
0.0281684026,
-0.0180705748,
0.0275358874,
-0.0498804003,
-0.051815331,
0.0008828553,
0.0015868185,
0.0199797191,
-0.0204490349,
-0.0021446135,
0.0146824587,
0.0044130837,
-0.0150490524,
0.0443229005,
-0.105477944,
-0.0238172263,
-0.0104760025,
0.0160703715,
0.1247968152,
0.0060393689,
0.0142445862,
0.018153023,
-0.0003499207,
0.0497041978,
0.0411406606,
0.0194390006,
-0.0137461275,
0.0878672749,
-0.0749897808,
0.0105373207,
-0.024350863,
0.0024440507,
0.00547801,
-0.0163528826,
0.0240013599,
0.0123603977,
-0.0178918261,
-0.0526702665,
0.0354936831,
0.0000844977,
-0.0289288685,
0.0263061225,
0.0139503693,
-0.0094682183,
0.0170700159,
-0.0333010964,
-0.0070795654,
-0.044734858,
-0.0620436706,
0.0340188518,
0.0429267101,
-0.0457762927,
-0.0402566381,
0.0056077461,
-0.0309431944,
-0.0144824116,
0.0049721156,
-0.0534197539,
-0.0374400504,
-0.0076040165,
-0.0329487137,
0.0254801773,
-0.08051157,
-0.0053116167,
-0.0270645637,
0.0056214426,
-0.0294737797,
0.0033631416,
0.0083003985,
-0.0048824423,
-0.0251663979,
-0.029739555,
0.0060762963,
0.0305263139,
-0.014072217,
0.0309031755,
-0.0054911589,
-0.0014520446,
0.0110440226,
0.0644459873,
-0.0112587912,
-0.0377830639,
-0.0973804444,
-0.0265588835,
-0.0162064172,
0.0130379284,
0.0288906302,
0.0011290865,
-0.011031785,
0.0000973314,
-0.0799604282,
-0.0083364611,
-0.0133236032,
0.0095071839,
0.091846928,
-0.03042854,
-0.0415767692,
-0.0442074612,
-0.0290052574,
0.0091847666,
0.0381788276,
-0.0224781614,
-0.0013774015,
-0.0353012308,
-0.0182745289,
-0.0503340177,
-0.0405462272,
0.0018163914,
-0.109419167,
0.0109804804,
-0.0025247997,
0.0055990741,
0.0470029935,
0.0836608559,
0.0090239551,
0.0341144167,
-0.0091936281,
-0.0232079104,
-0.0303936284,
0.001338992,
0.0349625014,
-0.0049790442,
-0.0897323862,
0.0049063787,
0.0347603522,
-0.0101378802,
0.0154312151,
-0.0434424467,
0.0148881469,
0.0663580745,
-0.0480946861,
-0.0111152157,
-0.00036023,
-0.0300731398,
0.0701739416,
-0.0125849536,
-0.0550232157,
0.0585236922,
-0.0468405485,
-0.0377154015,
0.0255143605,
-0.0060434211,
-0.0289667696,
0.0517527349,
-0.0507431999,
0.0453318581,
0.0153976651,
-0.0792893246,
-0.0033061865,
-0.0147974687,
0.1091684178,
0.002431063,
0.0211110618,
-0.0361572653,
-0.0307840221,
0.0226146709,
-0.0154739004,
0.0047107907,
-0.027329294,
-0.0032558851,
-0.0122555206,
0.0244894791,
-0.0354339145,
0.0339912735,
-0.0050486932,
-0.0031446971,
0.0119162844,
-0.0343849771,
0.0312336627,
0.0045151883,
0.0084577482,
-0.0060389014,
0.0264535639,
-0.0335070118,
-0.0547820032,
0.020369241,
-0.0124227861,
-0.0186775438,
-0.0115936277,
0.0179935768,
0.0050850268,
0.0358885564,
-0.0366349034,
-0.0576681755,
-0.0210201107,
0.0672535896,
-0.021563841,
0.0113774585,
0.0978335068,
0.0075892564,
-0.0585693307,
-0.0071899178,
-0.0251194779,
0.0530339219,
0.0154285785,
0.0473142117,
-0.0476775728,
-0.0124174608,
0.0076902648,
0.0229876116,
-0.0205542427,
0.0035326311,
-0.0119336573,
-0.0558051467,
0.0325778164,
0.0080064312,
-0.0686971694,
-0.0292138495,
0.0171966106,
-0.0211578198,
0.0202607848,
-0.0158988833,
0.0065498091,
-0.0031916841,
-0.035203442,
0.0127331354,
-0.0436963923,
-0.045656845,
-0.0172093492,
-0.030068025,
0.0198037513,
0.0376160629,
0.056779556,
-0.0172022004,
-0.0540459044,
-0.0320960842,
0.0122499717,
0.031566076,
-0.0222967565,
0.0691263452,
0.0327265821,
-0.0396262109,
-0.0652119443,
0.0285802819,
0.0155440886,
0.0189263877,
0.0296261292,
-0.0250048805,
-0.0214849394,
-0.0187516529,
-0.005009131,
0.0218703412,
0.0267117806,
0.0198385138,
0.0799975097,
-0.05614914,
-0.0371163711,
-0.0384337455,
-0.0082419533,
-0.0119129932,
-0.0182349365,
-0.0138892531,
-0.0221411325,
-0.0657666102,
-0.088267915,
-0.0506755374,
-0.0256121717,
0.0087876767,
0.0119250016,
-0.0452214107,
-0.0413268022,
0.0147456806,
-0.046488598,
-0.0231106523,
0.0227323975,
0.0288894717,
-0.0161585994,
-0.0413715169,
0.0136728911,
-0.0388632193,
0.0211403929,
-0.0228573121,
-0.0156665705,
-0.056057062,
0.0188035071,
0.0255631767,
0.0077688233,
0.0610517859,
0.0313544534,
-0.1014726162,
0.0126164574,
0.0299257506,
0.0291848704,
0.0341632441,
0.0729426444,
-0.0511668548,
0.0232954323,
0.0575405955,
0.0170117617,
0.0441227779,
-0.00343871,
0.0000942815,
0.0293191914,
-0.0242429208,
-0.0161528159,
0.0022180667,
-0.005305239,
-0.0345986821,
-0.0355657712,
-0.0484593362,
0.0101747708,
-0.0144604426,
-0.0289489068,
-0.0345620289,
-0.0066542928,
-0.0549595356,
-0.0050117583,
-0.0202725772,
-0.0235728174,
-0.0327282622,
0.0090582445,
-0.0254819747,
0.0553543232,
-0.0116766114,
0.0671660304,
-0.0415409058,
0.0527495183,
-0.0279252101,
0.0439886749,
-0.0047765505,
0.0415805764,
-0.0082229478,
0.0469995029,
0.0150636733,
0.0226772372,
-0.0010273539,
0.0341786519,
-0.024230307,
-0.0410590097,
-0.0040169293,
-0.0142549546,
0.0490033738,
-0.0501094572,
0.1043719947,
0.011136868,
0.0216842368,
-0.014627045,
0.0797118992,
0.0159192309,
-0.0488771051,
-0.0203584339,
0.0106841335,
-0.0210168567,
-0.0264431071,
0.0676017255,
-0.0386121273,
-0.0302924253,
0.0016865132,
-0.0236278791,
-0.0016071463,
-0.0128141018,
0.0731799453,
0.0354968645,
0.0368257202,
-0.0279220715,
-0.0158930849,
-0.0507446714,
0.0048993402,
-0.016391227,
0.0144016454,
-0.0192063041,
0.0293256715,
0.0554610454,
-0.0043150391,
0.0181791279,
-0.0874897987,
0.0203881599,
-0.0187284239,
0.0072596907,
-0.0201972574,
-5.50689165e-33,
-0.003334465,
-0.0118803019,
-0.0565977097,
0.0756046921,
-0.0231519584,
-0.0151033495,
-0.0569813736,
0.0037105444,
-0.0135779092,
0.0614489801,
-0.035881713,
-0.0080222394,
0.0054117362,
0.0233550873,
0.0830829516,
0.0197499506,
0.0198540203,
0.0305265859,
-0.0289529227,
0.050624758,
0.0604812615,
0.0095294639,
0.1281065345,
-0.0643104389,
0.0470635183,
-0.042398978,
-0.0396114439,
0.0238434542,
0.0362291448,
0.0292970072,
0.0222784504,
0.0531703532,
0.0186096933,
-0.0005486691,
-0.0224652104,
0.0191319995,
-0.0223028101,
-0.0536274388,
0.0198836252,
0.008406681,
0.03453888,
-0.0729902983,
0.0096403724,
-0.035910774,
-0.0080728866,
-0.0090188021,
0.0642619208,
0.0056701656,
0.0199985579,
-0.0382475667,
-0.0373980887,
0.0343676247,
-0.0455235019,
-0.0211141054,
0.0081272023,
0.022425767,
-0.0244359821,
-0.0080447486,
0.0061672418,
0.0530209765,
0.008867912,
0.0005001964,
0.0350239016,
0.0127236294,
-0.0080066593,
0.0679790378,
0.0398633443,
0.078716211,
0.005208917,
0.0183940232,
0.0466991141,
0.0235466324,
0.0009693758,
0.0947952718,
-0.0070857839,
-0.0056581302,
-0.0028749143,
0.0222114231,
0.0523942485,
0.0098095965,
-0.0098146815,
-0.0065826648,
-0.0107947895,
-0.0609456636,
-0.0149824331,
0.0018055621,
-0.0019313187,
-0.0155613888,
-0.0152051793,
-0.0583856925,
-0.001408873,
-0.0139881261,
0.0110010607,
-0.0311270822,
-0.0359110609,
0.0030618033,
-0.0340324715,
0.012580188,
0.0135014718,
-0.0264933221,
-0.0124823991,
-0.0357390083,
-0.0183055941,
0.0049848165,
0.0210816339,
0.0100663528,
0.0717558265,
0.026663132,
-0.0484211557,
0.0009507732,
-0.0063082967,
0.0227407683,
-0.0567841083,
0.004506907,
-0.0165084358,
-0.0186208449,
-0.0474182367,
0.0264360607,
0.0166645646,
-0.0117148496,
-0.040451277,
-0.08258719,
0.0000096944,
0.038207043,
-0.0476343222,
-0.001293676,
-0.0377720073,
-0.0770250112,
0.032465864,
0.0126159051,
0.0034722718,
-0.0207686424,
2.328e-7,
0.0116938129,
0.0182620529,
0.036401812,
0.0482278839,
0.0253791623,
0.0373342857,
0.0131298481,
0.0306789912,
-0.0143844867,
0.0384400114,
0.0264949817,
-0.0065992214,
0.0920476541,
0.0157493483,
-0.0944727808,
0.010584522,
-0.0647793487,
-0.0202280413,
-0.032325726,
-0.0119370203,
0.0317717008,
0.0221274868,
-0.0032242322,
-0.0261975806,
0.011109421,
0.0176956858,
0.0380423069,
-0.06931784,
0.0407890454,
-0.0028079897,
0.0263352897,
-0.0445993319,
0.0177475493,
0.0113157984,
-0.0127839455,
-0.014411944,
-0.0137009006,
0.0699853674,
-0.0011368841,
0.0253119841,
0.0433333591,
-0.0025340477,
-0.0200586151,
-0.0691469088,
0.0310853645,
0.0835111067,
-0.0227288399,
-0.064220801,
0.0083826678,
-0.0095005203,
0.0082622571,
-0.0268498901,
-0.0207379926,
0.070579119,
0.0023036941,
-0.0662982538,
0.0178902447,
-0.0306883585,
-0.046976991,
-0.0117584849,
0.0126448041,
-0.0052384925,
0.0115290778,
0.0022872554,
-0.0110106478,
0.0239099488,
0.0303252898,
1.548199873e-34,
0.0329816304,
0.0039346353,
0.0259897057,
0.0617524311,
0.0453256555,
0.0156508274,
0.0482081212,
0.0448230021,
0.0092290649,
-0.0158979874,
0.0052652382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07106v1 | The Temporal Structure of Language Processing in the Human Brain Corresponds to The Layered Hierarchy of Deep Language Models | 2023-10-11T01:03:42 | 2023-10-11T01:03:42 | Ariel Goldstein, Eric Ham, Mariano Schain, Samuel Nastase, Zaid Zada, Avigail Dabush, Bobbi Aubrey, Harshvardhan Gazula, Amir Feder, Werner K Doyle, Sasha Devore, Patricia Dugan, Daniel Friedman, Roi Reichart, Michael Brenner, Avinatan Hassidim, Orrin Devinsky, Adeen Flinker, Omer Levy, Uri Hasson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.NC | Deep Language Models (DLMs) provide a novel computational paradigm for
understanding the mechanisms of natural language processing in the human brain.
Unlike traditional psycholinguistic models, DLMs use layered sequences of
continuous numerical vectors to represent words and context, allowing a
plethora of emerging applications such as human-like text generation. In this
paper we show evidence that the layered hierarchy of DLMs may be used to model
the temporal dynamics of language comprehension in the brain by demonstrating a
strong correlation between DLM layer depth and the time at which layers are
most predictive of the human brain. Our ability to temporally resolve
individual layers benefits from our use of electrocorticography (ECoG) data,
which has a much higher temporal resolution than noninvasive methods like fMRI.
Using ECoG, we record neural activity from participants listening to a
30-minute narrative while also feeding the same narrative to a high-performing
DLM (GPT2-XL). We then extract contextual embeddings from the different layers
of the DLM and use linear encoding models to predict neural activity. We first
focus on the Inferior Frontal Gyrus (IFG, or Broca's area) and then extend our
model to track the increasing temporal receptive window along the linguistic
processing hierarchy from auditory to syntactic and semantic areas. Our results
reveal a connection between human language processing and DLMs, with the DLM's
layer-by-layer accumulation of contextual information mirroring the timing of
neural activity in high-order language areas. | [
0.0049898946,
0.0565719493,
-0.0415010788,
0.0181524828,
-0.0150269931,
0.0512155481,
0.0158324465,
0.0164853707,
-0.0018574457,
0.0026860069,
0.0171971601,
-0.0797050297,
0.054035753,
0.0720099509,
0.0202327538,
-0.0222619306,
-0.0007699674,
-0.0262839291,
0.0321307443,
0.0056112264,
-0.0407401659,
0.0028618569,
-0.0544090942,
0.0500391349,
0.0210158732,
-0.0052452772,
-0.022965936,
-0.0407223068,
0.0115075419,
-0.0316532142,
-0.019241821,
0.0392585285,
0.0248454493,
0.0299575496,
0.0000021322,
-0.0064685191,
0.0532685071,
-0.0115692411,
-0.0295488182,
0.0114953183,
0.0003169424,
0.0236893892,
0.0015279162,
-0.0260113031,
-0.0348163061,
-0.0061138845,
0.0117568364,
0.0576474555,
0.0016232912,
0.0300456993,
-0.016156476,
-0.035579253,
0.0584834106,
-0.0416187197,
0.0162556134,
0.0002288936,
0.0210531484,
-0.0067339456,
-0.0243455898,
0.0140832672,
-0.0271445457,
0.0072054882,
0.0307927001,
0.0359032378,
0.0035128749,
0.1003360376,
0.0111882491,
0.0107399495,
-0.0026574389,
0.0610044375,
0.0055946195,
-0.0331002399,
0.0199707709,
0.0311717317,
-0.0177810937,
-0.0283438563,
-0.0453343056,
0.036344599,
0.0124590574,
0.0386829227,
0.0591000132,
-0.0436957031,
0.012879679,
0.0008106795,
0.0127870236,
0.0896092057,
0.0145910401,
-0.0124590602,
0.0023713475,
-0.0056099547,
-0.0205798391,
-0.0741921738,
0.0181222279,
0.0258098338,
-0.0180050489,
-0.0013259422,
-0.0308916308,
0.0047980421,
0.004055074,
-0.0347832441,
0.0032389152,
0.042468451,
0.0020099273,
0.0208602026,
-0.0187780559,
0.0525821149,
-0.050003916,
0.0061114305,
-0.0204744749,
0.0228515603,
-0.0426202156,
-0.0487730689,
-0.0096508842,
0.0009953729,
-0.0413526595,
-0.0256780647,
-0.0750164539,
0.0035357107,
0.0053477455,
-0.0718777776,
-0.0550266802,
0.04614022,
-0.0159436259,
0.0437058695,
-0.0217179582,
-0.0113160834,
0.0051928419,
0.0526045002,
0.0126558607,
0.0045941402,
-0.0144768748,
0.0348365046,
-0.009307676,
-0.0171223711,
-0.0215992164,
0.0249705091,
-0.0078959391,
-0.0159120765,
-0.0499245934,
-0.0413604043,
-0.0214493182,
0.000340844,
0.0300005637,
-0.0569295846,
0.0203427617,
0.0061339671,
-0.0501808226,
-0.0107366685,
-0.0114568854,
0.0122831976,
-0.0254602544,
0.0401089564,
-0.0068614176,
0.0003112514,
0.0988580808,
0.0273366366,
0.0218206719,
-0.0088803358,
0.0761685222,
-0.0024688048,
-0.0478133485,
-0.0157981496,
-0.0146334842,
0.0207123589,
-0.0089533506,
-0.0282957479,
-0.0808589458,
-0.0695308298,
-0.064795509,
0.0485357903,
0.0555455573,
0.0069167218,
-0.0248808898,
-0.0334871188,
0.0705158785,
0.0712981373,
-0.0191259757,
0.0067457524,
0.0356136672,
-0.0029680484,
-0.0065827477,
0.0141621353,
-0.0311392397,
0.0498674177,
0.021071611,
-0.0080727125,
-0.0133390483,
-0.0272082277,
-0.002717851,
0.0080649694,
0.0130947409,
0.0063168164,
0.0201031063,
0.0127017042,
0.0077606835,
-0.0561682619,
-0.033923313,
0.0699817836,
0.0270743184,
0.0049160724,
0.0246364642,
-0.0196654201,
0.011012868,
0.0635139868,
-0.0020342749,
-0.0067390851,
-0.0131299021,
0.0062870472,
0.0406997837,
0.0614018962,
0.0075789415,
0.0142306425,
0.0569832511,
-0.0136016076,
0.0061720139,
-0.0059918161,
-0.0040001255,
0.0144855687,
-0.0341248922,
0.0054237377,
-0.0118309511,
-0.0028021063,
-0.0154908011,
0.04927269,
-0.0691639781,
-0.0031209898,
0.0018648005,
-0.006772757,
0.0226288307,
-0.0222562477,
-0.0354341343,
0.0140664168,
0.0236359034,
-0.0482243411,
-0.0324783921,
0.0262670275,
-0.054530073,
-0.0203235224,
0.0110047366,
-0.0127162002,
0.0006442696,
0.0009937222,
0.0080104833,
-0.0458451323,
0.0225043688,
-0.0567297898,
0.0459235348,
-0.0379308797,
-0.0146875838,
-0.0182065014,
0.0461972654,
-0.0478760563,
0.0479355752,
-0.0119887628,
-0.0015053123,
0.0373316817,
-0.0146719832,
0.0156464428,
-0.0421340428,
-0.0105712302,
0.0360069871,
-0.0120569505,
-0.0405249894,
-0.0111041879,
-0.0017572439,
-0.0649244115,
-0.0036234166,
-0.1071846038,
-0.0200380422,
0.0408958234,
-0.0019372936,
0.0172736496,
-0.0460796468,
0.0028606183,
0.0274845976,
-0.033155825,
0.0362983309,
0.027947709,
0.0268814284,
0.0178205259,
0.0066454024,
-0.0295712966,
-0.0397849306,
-0.0028393569,
-0.0479921736,
0.0682002008,
-0.0133737028,
-0.0264935978,
-0.0476213358,
-0.0067449203,
-0.0287484266,
0.0280449204,
-0.0020628052,
-0.0294020958,
0.0339587703,
0.0098918956,
0.0390738957,
0.0793463737,
0.0417629145,
0.0779688135,
0.05905338,
-0.0226168651,
-0.0006296589,
-0.0239745211,
-0.0343325362,
0.052918449,
-0.0328727476,
-0.0242037345,
-0.0016954277,
0.109765701,
0.0672324896,
0.0097002815,
-0.0252093822,
0.0266376249,
-0.0437624976,
-0.0485196896,
-0.0093484437,
-0.0313148648,
-0.07260672,
0.0752762556,
-0.0447237007,
-0.0225607324,
0.0751418471,
0.0099506732,
0.010276895,
0.0137613192,
-0.0190726779,
-0.0184548125,
0.0608205199,
0.0384955667,
0.0222866815,
-0.034437798,
-0.0564529262,
-0.0458176658,
0.0305771884,
-0.0401821695,
-0.0341010951,
0.0026570635,
-0.0558491014,
0.0053762053,
0.0361092016,
-0.0027815246,
-0.0446593761,
-0.021714557,
-0.0088263517,
0.0030802269,
-0.021680275,
0.0242813714,
-0.0527592227,
-0.0155470306,
0.0132974489,
0.044572778,
-0.0143898651,
-0.0238430183,
-0.0123936459,
0.0877944753,
0.0204234738,
0.0203782488,
0.0063997149,
-0.0282805096,
0.0232980344,
0.0118662566,
-0.0281331707,
0.1008029282,
-0.0534932725,
0.027672939,
-0.002272964,
-0.0125634456,
-0.0287606977,
0.0297413748,
-0.0206510779,
-0.0421445258,
-0.0199284498,
0.1298076063,
0.0179776829,
-0.0521380827,
0.0195673145,
-0.0055654086,
0.0249694474,
0.0221183617,
0.0098021636,
-0.048121199,
0.006651016,
0.0015869031,
-0.0017359544,
0.0097430311,
-0.0206177831,
-0.0197418835,
-0.0307096541,
0.0158837195,
-0.0021774517,
-0.058806926,
0.0143245067,
-0.0332756452,
0.0125726089,
0.0414044745,
0.0104146963,
0.0048454367,
0.0231750198,
0.0091505675,
0.0261322744,
0.0005013023,
-0.0231439117,
0.0427354798,
0.004011868,
0.0677588806,
0.0272904839,
0.0712553635,
-0.0255975164,
-0.0137378667,
0.0046421192,
0.0088164033,
-0.0028381296,
0.0044382256,
0.0174935255,
0.0434502363,
-0.0003344685,
-0.0304927193,
0.055781059,
-0.0290373061,
-0.0521900766,
-0.0281440523,
0.0793315992,
-0.0277966075,
-0.0327925049,
-0.0136993304,
0.0577822253,
-0.0046312413,
0.0563478358,
0.0666497424,
-0.0769506991,
-0.0098202359,
0.0046887938,
0.0505712926,
-0.0402806774,
-0.0329269022,
0.024529038,
0.051011268,
0.00350884,
-0.0453343764,
-0.0135292513,
-0.0154662887,
-0.0129517047,
0.0313226618,
0.0241369866,
0.0621928722,
-0.0639638528,
-0.0499588847,
0.0070591755,
0.0147053497,
-0.0086733522,
-0.0383198969,
-0.0076141902,
-0.0081438813,
-0.0448954478,
-0.0447819307,
0.0454094298,
-0.0906043649,
-0.0792303234,
0.0647654235,
-0.022504542,
0.0186007172,
-0.0005482644,
0.0428447984,
-0.0803634301,
0.067416288,
-0.0033014908,
-0.023141548,
0.0914658979,
-0.0782063827,
0.0274260882,
0.0066247401,
0.0188666545,
-0.0287175328,
0.0265895389,
-0.0168522,
-0.0053614001,
-0.0088857431,
-0.0191818476,
0.0136393709,
-0.0392065756,
0.0461123288,
-0.0350180604,
-0.0138640087,
-0.0299300309,
-0.0250432473,
0.0061363466,
0.0510506406,
-0.0081799952,
-0.0667045936,
0.0216000024,
0.0019103634,
-0.0168640688,
-0.0529880635,
0.0068314234,
0.0100301895,
0.0064984802,
-0.022903068,
-0.0629764944,
-0.0134006571,
0.008447241,
0.0456281751,
0.0046158186,
0.0293771271,
-0.0995423719,
0.010872459,
-0.0035739327,
0.0673094839,
0.0217039604,
0.0096168024,
-0.0223594904,
-0.0063640922,
-0.0587925315,
-0.0378444642,
0.047877524,
-0.0231641475,
0.0465802848,
-0.0169331674,
0.0470081642,
-0.0179284178,
0.0220361687,
-0.0244900398,
0.0231394041,
-0.0326379612,
-0.0265792608,
0.0454888158,
0.0156106902,
-0.0006666306,
-0.007076825,
0.0730052963,
0.056482099,
-0.0093430821,
0.0234265607,
0.0203430187,
-0.0044762013,
-0.0179975852,
0.0025639844,
0.0256893281,
-0.0399435125,
0.0249818265,
-0.0261316653,
-0.0453650765,
0.0321384333,
-0.0135920867,
0.0340732895,
-0.0508002602,
0.0094235288,
0.0390832722,
-0.0233412534,
-0.0202283375,
0.0042596376,
0.0347936116,
-0.0195845719,
-0.0622097254,
-0.0649012104,
-6.530259767e-33,
-0.0378780402,
-0.0772012994,
0.0060767089,
0.0556200631,
-0.0564431362,
0.047986757,
-0.0623644553,
0.040583916,
0.0421429574,
0.0109685836,
0.0009279535,
0.0254096612,
0.0012605839,
0.0401276089,
0.0167114753,
0.0073147411,
-0.0158756804,
-0.0430608243,
0.0212580692,
0.0247205254,
0.0592168942,
0.0488269515,
0.0780550614,
-0.0488117598,
-0.0018107004,
0.0339680351,
0.0301789343,
0.0295830183,
-0.0094029,
0.0308728963,
-0.0813494548,
0.0479902774,
0.0710788071,
-0.0281321332,
0.023225069,
0.0153104747,
-0.0410250798,
-0.0170414373,
0.0234995689,
-0.0029110645,
-0.0531164706,
-0.0175492652,
0.0767631456,
-0.0225666016,
0.0167718437,
-0.0118903304,
0.0404092781,
-0.020676,
-0.0349426046,
-0.0048092576,
-0.0667423531,
-0.0284900777,
-0.031429477,
0.0035417138,
0.0155296661,
0.0310892258,
-0.0483999699,
0.0249552634,
-0.0968792811,
0.0016326376,
-0.0279146712,
0.0327677988,
0.0120552443,
0.0223283526,
0.0304868687,
0.0824599937,
0.0744770542,
0.0131167332,
-0.0617676005,
0.0147112766,
0.0454761311,
0.0423044674,
-0.0150744868,
-0.0427191481,
0.0525156707,
-0.0277819112,
-0.0681784675,
-0.0136761842,
0.0064438186,
-0.0006461234,
0.040948391,
-0.0303667132,
0.0147726526,
-0.016778104,
-0.0519005917,
0.004535431,
-0.0386714227,
-0.0058078426,
0.0304113068,
-0.0344508961,
0.0156875364,
-0.0635223836,
0.0386391096,
-0.0109117627,
0.0135874255,
-0.0022566104,
-0.0443007126,
0.0096758455,
0.0369040333,
0.0480948351,
-0.0070611606,
-0.0292426776,
-0.0057901512,
-0.019386448,
0.0574278459,
-0.028770702,
-0.0184897482,
-0.0031258559,
0.003904697,
0.0029313103,
-0.018940907,
-0.0163005665,
0.0379012115,
0.0391914882,
0.0260450598,
-0.0171021279,
-0.0049208156,
-0.0122048547,
-0.0059768055,
0.0128700072,
-0.0118014878,
-0.0191343557,
-0.0094814152,
0.0699844286,
-0.0308097154,
-0.0174765736,
-0.0067568985,
-0.01463312,
0.0289070923,
-0.0632838085,
-0.0249589123,
-0.003725973,
2.98e-7,
0.0068931817,
0.0698806345,
0.0083479621,
0.0504089519,
0.0636931658,
0.0035311084,
0.0479382612,
0.0213492885,
0.0044027069,
-0.0288665686,
-0.0267176293,
0.0470508821,
0.0177002884,
-0.0127205029,
-0.0370864347,
-0.0449083634,
-0.0641679391,
0.0233159829,
-0.0490695685,
-0.0198315866,
0.0373660214,
0.0105537772,
0.0117521649,
-0.0505509786,
0.0198958647,
-0.0141362678,
0.0952896178,
-0.0159479827,
0.0223370325,
-0.0144436117,
-0.0085985158,
0.0111371204,
-0.0160641745,
0.0445556678,
0.0212201998,
0.0100126825,
-0.0249932855,
0.0228017718,
-0.0096818656,
-0.0190774892,
0.0173645616,
-0.0043154559,
-0.0250425674,
-0.046037171,
0.0279409606,
-0.0893983692,
-0.0743626803,
-0.0293157902,
-0.0215838384,
-0.0172774307,
0.0277672354,
-0.018271232,
0.002456438,
-0.0258927457,
0.0010484955,
-0.0167971887,
0.0168942809,
-0.0304006375,
-0.0294406433,
0.0527578965,
-0.0823340788,
0.0414852053,
-0.0536862426,
-0.0023487506,
0.0390788242,
-0.028538648,
0.0222078301,
2.409649314e-34,
-0.0275190715,
-0.0005225154,
0.0326450616,
0.0242323093,
-0.0002069527,
-0.0076543558,
0.0208907668,
-0.0192100536,
0.0003243165,
-0.087354742,
-0.0269734841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07096v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07096v1 | Sparse Universal Transformer | 2023-10-11T00:38:57 | 2023-10-11T00:38:57 | Shawn Tan, Yikang Shen, Zhenfang Chen, Aaron Courville, Chuang Gan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The Universal Transformer (UT) is a variant of the Transformer that shares
parameters across its layers. Empirical evidence shows that UTs have better
compositional generalization than Vanilla Transformers (VTs) in formal language
tasks. The parameter-sharing also affords it better parameter efficiency than
VTs. Despite its many advantages, scaling UT parameters is much more compute
and memory intensive than scaling up a VT. This paper proposes the Sparse
Universal Transformer (SUT), which leverages Sparse Mixture of Experts (SMoE)
and a new stick-breaking-based dynamic halting mechanism to reduce UT's
computation complexity while retaining its parameter efficiency and
generalization ability. Experiments show that SUT achieves the same performance
as strong baseline models while only using half computation and parameters on
WMT'14 and strong generalization results on formal language tasks (Logical
inference and CFQ). The new halting mechanism also enables around 50\%
reduction in computation during inference with very little performance decrease
on formal language tasks. | [
0.014048961,
0.0455906689,
0.016376866,
-0.009749881,
-0.0090559898,
0.0114227775,
0.0138426973,
-0.029193351,
-0.0309257898,
-0.0319645293,
0.0123523585,
-0.0076250099,
-0.0265225712,
0.0132077141,
0.0173873194,
-0.0671908483,
0.0307158176,
-0.0244750064,
-0.0245723557,
-0.0414605774,
-0.0188846681,
-0.011955292,
0.0131821139,
0.0459913611,
-0.0255493484,
0.0178059191,
-0.0468181595,
0.0039010153,
0.0221459512,
0.0261685234,
-0.0150195826,
0.0663386509,
0.0101175774,
0.0650581047,
0.0000023321,
-0.0038436286,
-0.0327673368,
0.0258158334,
-0.0185746178,
-0.0306326058,
0.0000790455,
-0.0045467401,
0.0120425466,
0.0441791005,
-0.0061633661,
-0.0347446501,
0.0955785364,
0.0682289973,
0.0675972253,
0.0796367005,
-0.0193729959,
-0.0246612206,
0.0322010405,
-0.0031151618,
-0.0212705377,
-0.0478630774,
-0.0069830506,
0.0038408907,
0.0188038871,
-0.0498920307,
-0.0111271665,
0.0259552468,
0.0394386239,
0.0212487634,
-0.0648985133,
0.0200055633,
-0.0645114407,
-0.051609233,
0.0002787545,
0.0343116224,
-0.0403648801,
-0.047456339,
-0.0059140706,
0.0432933047,
0.0123861469,
0.0286690872,
-0.0358764231,
0.0396257415,
-0.0292707849,
0.0015295175,
-0.0045753098,
0.0231240001,
0.0508930832,
-0.0079587232,
-0.084419027,
0.0877403393,
0.0334445611,
-0.0127343684,
0.0016965895,
-0.0136594102,
-0.0289036501,
-0.0152592175,
0.0013212966,
0.0341961235,
-0.0780756921,
-0.0239617787,
-0.0681432933,
-0.0132041434,
-0.0126808975,
-0.0224966388,
0.0490887091,
0.0630350262,
0.017337203,
0.0441004708,
-0.0139850155,
0.0218736194,
-0.0482904762,
0.0162211079,
0.004507408,
-0.0354237556,
-0.0301189534,
-0.020711286,
-0.0399312563,
0.0752914399,
0.0099753905,
-0.0231576618,
-0.0177783594,
0.0310274791,
-0.0112930704,
-0.0100106541,
0.0043266155,
-0.0023853197,
-0.0583853424,
-0.0162939858,
0.0221973192,
0.0414781682,
-0.037623819,
-0.0161043331,
0.008411211,
-0.0434819311,
-0.0148948189,
0.0028574236,
0.0132510029,
-0.0252701454,
0.03954399,
0.0781976208,
-0.0206706431,
-0.0431538224,
-0.0175126474,
0.0203039106,
0.0024978649,
-0.089301452,
-0.0158237852,
-0.077197805,
0.0235329717,
0.0115493611,
0.0079046609,
-0.024758162,
-0.0161614474,
0.0230055861,
-0.0287955515,
0.0425534323,
-0.0096852696,
-0.0339830741,
0.0010027071,
0.0141522801,
-0.0284278952,
0.0480716154,
-0.0324888825,
0.0249568317,
0.0018040142,
-0.0142872613,
0.0105583966,
0.0324955992,
-0.0167000722,
-0.03327436,
-0.043027997,
-0.0249569174,
-0.0196136162,
-0.0350273699,
-0.0203995258,
0.1015267745,
-0.0145788528,
-0.0190001484,
0.0182104465,
-0.0107787736,
0.0302997548,
0.0975193232,
0.0618159026,
0.0359630585,
-0.0159704108,
0.0437825434,
-0.0544395447,
0.0285272151,
-0.0927589834,
-0.0020392654,
0.0095921392,
0.0520409644,
-0.0473340787,
-0.0298123844,
0.0153544163,
-0.0111597069,
-0.0299546812,
0.0146745816,
0.0529787578,
0.019595122,
-0.0608133189,
0.1005003452,
0.0228945445,
-0.0492909253,
-0.0772145689,
-0.0324487053,
0.0301869195,
-0.0323859341,
0.0181274507,
-0.0494655371,
-0.0313468613,
-0.0049415347,
-0.0069287117,
0.0113402735,
-0.0087227579,
0.0224466659,
0.0120758004,
-0.0353970639,
-0.0312077161,
-0.0099994829,
0.0329607986,
0.0055204052,
0.0478215069,
0.0066410857,
0.0432424881,
-0.0543062203,
0.0095654121,
-0.0010976008,
0.0309531447,
0.0238667,
0.0225852262,
0.01559377,
0.0223213807,
-0.0069523663,
-0.0313823335,
0.0171510819,
0.0309401322,
-0.0273685958,
-0.0540537499,
0.0212406311,
-0.064605169,
0.0146118831,
0.038517341,
-0.0734236911,
-0.0031765744,
0.0586018302,
-0.0324345417,
-0.0626824573,
-0.0039886646,
-0.0668407679,
0.0183135942,
-0.0239584669,
0.0179271754,
-0.0291964784,
0.0126173124,
-0.0136011811,
0.065384239,
-0.0004378117,
-0.0067643984,
-0.0003375639,
-0.0388334431,
0.0024021184,
-0.0191284698,
-0.118923001,
-0.0154939191,
-0.0401187241,
0.0000519788,
0.039896246,
-0.0303111803,
0.0153849786,
-0.062343128,
-0.0883665755,
0.0170775093,
-0.0321585611,
0.0011933037,
-0.0075670998,
0.0699561164,
0.0236691739,
-0.0068555758,
-0.0058836853,
-0.0037880815,
0.0040342254,
0.0001622176,
-0.0102530317,
0.0092369281,
-0.062395405,
-0.0102018928,
-0.0487036519,
0.0016874227,
0.0668994561,
-0.0244517084,
-0.0192779806,
-0.03348241,
0.0438033119,
0.0130434278,
0.0367533267,
-0.03207637,
0.0082923798,
0.0308039356,
-0.0277818125,
0.056702204,
0.0657966286,
0.0115340305,
0.0231245738,
0.0495439991,
-0.0008488783,
-0.0178004131,
0.0449892581,
-0.0204396117,
0.0001346292,
-0.0317022353,
0.016141152,
0.0028075397,
0.0835876316,
-0.0326597616,
-0.0172035974,
-0.0577177666,
0.0049214615,
0.0333531648,
-0.0095354496,
0.0043554609,
0.0040382966,
0.0184627976,
-0.0001515055,
0.0007275408,
-0.0297432076,
0.0590676032,
-0.0286186505,
-0.0115368608,
0.0069781807,
-0.0119312909,
-0.0259444416,
0.0257887486,
0.0158609767,
-0.0004273501,
-0.0205994975,
-0.0048575145,
-0.0531628542,
0.0176774245,
0.0002071267,
0.0098687112,
0.0432896465,
-0.0334947072,
0.0149636297,
-0.0224792287,
-0.0505637452,
-0.0439829975,
0.0055103307,
-0.0290768985,
0.0157882385,
0.0225372072,
-0.0395079516,
-0.0999651253,
0.030935904,
0.0133595746,
0.0457989797,
0.0016817839,
0.0020401848,
-0.0066823605,
0.0052236738,
0.0070534684,
0.056255281,
0.0114185326,
0.0107968431,
0.0426914357,
0.0514159091,
0.0288769286,
-0.0143426163,
-0.0444375388,
-0.0173606519,
0.0254758727,
-0.0319674984,
-0.035595838,
0.0172121357,
0.0361105539,
-0.0440400392,
-0.0021936661,
0.1171872243,
0.0089153899,
-0.0093322387,
0.0014796428,
-0.0224407092,
0.0522441603,
0.0297068562,
0.0542903692,
-0.0967477113,
-0.0251988787,
0.0287976898,
-0.0071271914,
-0.0126751969,
-0.0348347314,
0.018682627,
-0.0829359069,
0.0037289115,
-0.002761404,
-0.0157871097,
0.0059088054,
-0.0425780006,
-0.0086235367,
-0.0182966888,
-0.0011815216,
-0.0163744017,
0.0021056633,
-0.0160876159,
-0.0051238062,
0.0064241923,
-0.0048258072,
0.0085570961,
-0.0182881895,
-0.010923096,
-0.0119507061,
0.0084325681,
-0.0344820619,
-0.0433570109,
0.0420588702,
0.0539137721,
-0.0082686171,
-0.0087637901,
-0.0060425927,
-0.0018695798,
-0.0147562232,
-0.0255837906,
0.035648033,
0.0155571997,
-0.0030857804,
-0.0041782199,
0.1053240076,
-0.0273955688,
-0.0610409603,
0.0047485032,
-0.0108332792,
-0.05223931,
0.0523279496,
-0.0018429288,
-0.0270855222,
-0.0472648442,
-0.0299588107,
-0.0238271318,
-0.0107607767,
-0.0444016419,
0.0237933472,
0.0272357222,
-0.0667408854,
0.0048904456,
0.0530997366,
0.0442734286,
0.072232306,
0.0016541391,
-0.0332012847,
0.0353039317,
0.0332344435,
-0.0626817122,
-0.0056960001,
-0.0244044159,
-0.0115632974,
-0.0814096779,
0.0124653587,
0.0086088609,
0.0038265164,
-0.019684637,
-0.0031859241,
-0.0846965164,
-0.0535840727,
0.029137738,
0.0771376714,
0.0203835294,
0.0029857415,
0.0065118931,
-0.0273704045,
0.0727696568,
0.0568792075,
-0.0393244326,
0.0011360238,
0.0622489639,
-0.0982935652,
0.0124348337,
0.0323211513,
0.0023422583,
0.0302434526,
0.0264403187,
0.0257162936,
-0.0333969221,
0.0021064966,
0.0437428355,
0.0257593635,
-0.0149321994,
0.001379411,
0.0611875318,
0.0267472509,
0.0343754329,
0.0165544469,
-0.0269452482,
-0.0596907809,
0.0303996317,
0.0128930416,
0.0229259524,
0.0191479251,
-0.0084318127,
0.0031591274,
0.013956639,
0.0080806417,
0.0408700854,
0.0335990228,
0.0135798519,
0.0319187604,
-0.0295715462,
-0.0222766008,
0.0020198785,
0.0385018177,
0.0295634922,
-0.0470287204,
0.0290537961,
0.0457255468,
0.0204113144,
-0.0479995869,
0.0126637118,
-0.0386016555,
-0.0814922526,
-0.0036851154,
0.0316143744,
0.0176043101,
0.0035135078,
-0.0096146651,
-0.0295778308,
0.0000986044,
-0.0100318091,
0.0457749479,
0.023861466,
-0.0316937901,
0.0319406129,
0.0331669226,
0.0106970584,
0.0112716062,
0.0662010238,
-0.0029291036,
0.0257025547,
0.0336318351,
-0.008494664,
-0.084454976,
-0.0409156084,
-0.0095261699,
0.0013386824,
-0.0021796452,
0.0052036112,
-0.0164485294,
-0.03754187,
0.0246040355,
-0.0458868966,
0.0170412883,
-0.007428695,
0.0071420115,
0.035687957,
0.0113288853,
-0.0026380236,
0.0185873564,
-0.0199091248,
0.0847876072,
0.0107504008,
0.0020348905,
-6.863560904e-33,
-0.032681521,
-0.013864669,
0.0056052934,
0.016138304,
0.0047498024,
-0.003986455,
-0.0089457314,
0.0301628634,
0.0023526652,
-0.0059265741,
-0.0392333195,
0.0252478737,
0.0137653081,
0.024618445,
-0.0255166702,
0.0093353326,
0.0644005761,
0.0564934686,
-0.0351475589,
0.0110838637,
0.0218005907,
0.0208263099,
0.0824017227,
-0.0367863476,
-0.036808461,
0.0298493728,
-0.0133182118,
0.0002776763,
-0.0075915912,
0.0061251922,
-0.0053205187,
0.0358420238,
0.0118844192,
-0.0256658383,
0.000008865,
0.0445614755,
-0.0741245002,
-0.0068070707,
0.0172638316,
0.0096939215,
0.0148411449,
-0.04904145,
0.0167617537,
-0.0048165992,
0.016989477,
-0.0582503937,
0.0132591156,
-0.0123521267,
0.0021086768,
-0.0495583452,
-0.0548518933,
0.0311598666,
-0.0132619105,
0.0190967191,
-0.0238451231,
0.0134096872,
-0.0256448984,
-0.0277920906,
-0.0350157879,
0.004767199,
0.0252215974,
0.0346125811,
0.0384709872,
-0.0242975932,
-0.026959043,
0.0083153183,
-0.0246232376,
0.0160523951,
-0.0475014485,
-0.0014367914,
0.0355243273,
0.0861017853,
0.0209448077,
0.0143794566,
0.0913902819,
0.0112091275,
-0.0463043787,
0.0169614349,
0.0037182195,
0.1189737841,
0.0696770325,
0.0053723706,
-0.0161743648,
-0.0189354308,
-0.0185611788,
0.0523762889,
-0.0355963744,
-0.0183819085,
0.0032061974,
0.0192048829,
-0.0549656004,
-0.0107524497,
0.0316579528,
-0.0643361881,
0.0461047553,
0.0092968009,
0.0095773013,
-0.0086718732,
-0.0095335273,
0.0072341454,
-0.0062856236,
-0.0624891557,
0.0272118151,
-0.0020507746,
0.0190454498,
-0.0043150946,
0.010434933,
0.0566672757,
-0.0567135625,
-0.0329399332,
-0.0416671,
0.0034973412,
-0.0109019419,
0.0568475239,
0.0294529311,
0.0302680675,
-0.0159762409,
-0.0492235012,
-0.0557331815,
-0.0061737192,
-0.0289531127,
0.0500721894,
0.0635930598,
0.0198198296,
-0.003906318,
-0.0474779941,
-0.0518826656,
-0.0206314158,
0.0219505467,
-0.0684166029,
-0.0201190971,
0.016851306,
3.176e-7,
0.0332943983,
-0.0048445174,
0.0453009047,
0.0140227797,
-0.0190648884,
-0.0017237061,
0.0282156244,
0.0139592588,
0.0034939519,
0.0291426871,
0.0266930778,
0.0155972755,
0.0230549928,
0.0366329439,
-0.1167219207,
-0.0771424845,
-0.0453927405,
-0.0118491333,
-0.0310086813,
-0.0164541528,
0.0097307684,
0.1177767217,
0.0278568715,
-0.0168944597,
0.0140144872,
-0.0507964715,
0.0247750841,
0.0081847999,
0.0327560119,
0.0098625766,
0.0445153117,
0.0052530365,
0.041349005,
0.0275542047,
0.0350949615,
0.0421657041,
0.0038799588,
0.0319175906,
0.0117144184,
0.0071929991,
0.0265625715,
-0.0301234163,
-0.0337180682,
-0.0296378676,
0.0597893186,
-0.0727445781,
-0.0587469861,
0.0128010847,
-0.0232975949,
-0.0248514749,
-0.0159307234,
-0.0188701544,
0.0378765091,
0.0298725702,
0.0379376635,
-0.0451002717,
0.027405791,
-0.0447121412,
-0.0191370212,
0.0132890651,
-0.0824396908,
-0.0345974937,
-0.0324302055,
-0.0686498284,
0.0475123525,
-0.0177490786,
0.0323053747,
3.468279552e-34,
0.0490711592,
0.0208265968,
0.0268713087,
0.05135113,
0.0415333174,
-0.0176718105,
-0.0125788935,
-0.0054270565,
-0.0095728179,
-0.078547731,
-0.0334161222
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.